id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14183v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14183v1
|
SemEval-2024 Task 8: Multidomain, Multimodel and Multilingual Machine-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-04-22T13:56:07 | 2024-04-22T13:56:07 |
Yuxia Wang, Jonibek Mansurov, Petar Ivanov, Jinyan Su, Artem Shelmanov, Akim Tsvigun, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Tarek Mahmoud, Giovanni Puccetti, Thomas Arnold, Chenxi Whitehouse, Alham Fikri Aji, Nizar Habash, Iryna Gurevych, Preslav Nakov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present the results and the main findings of SemEval-2024 Task 8:
Multigenerator, Multidomain, and Multilingual Machine-Generated Text Detection.
The task featured three subtasks. Subtask A is a binary classification task
determining whether a text is written by a human or generated by a machine.
This subtask has two tracks: a monolingual track focused solely on English
texts and a multilingual track. Subtask B is to detect the exact source of a
text, discerning whether it is written by a human or generated by a specific
LLM. Subtask C aims to identify the changing point within a text, at which the
authorship transitions from human to machine. The task attracted a large number
of participants: subtask A monolingual (126), subtask A multilingual (59),
subtask B (70), and subtask C (30). In this paper, we present the task, analyze
the results, and discuss the system submissions and the methods they used. For
all subtasks, the best systems used LLMs.
|
[
-0.4447826147,
-0.5190124512,
0.6340454817,
0.2186505795,
-0.3209745586,
0.1732686609,
0.0191557277,
-0.6189920902,
0.2604911029,
0.6591186523,
-0.9706746936,
-0.6007465124,
-0.6617639661,
0.665872097,
-0.2831099331,
1.1847393513,
-0.1891926378,
-0.2295678109,
-0.5907396674,
-0.002133423,
-0.4945921898,
-0.7063986659,
-0.6047626138,
-0.4016458392,
0.7103462815,
0.5623387694,
0.006100093,
0.2014264911,
0.5968319178,
0.3568042219,
0.1634627134,
0.207345888,
-0.3010867238,
0.393979609,
-0.3689032793,
-0.3754771352,
-0.5581864715,
-0.0234598387,
0.4215151668,
0.298903048,
0.2654187083,
0.4518415928,
0.1058041677,
0.5214365721,
-0.6074538827,
0.0686979145,
-0.4552726448,
0.0507880338,
-0.5787439346,
-0.4826928675,
-0.5430093408,
0.0457947738,
-0.2147779316,
-0.3537550271,
0.4478250444,
0.1596922129,
0.5366250277,
0.2815167308,
-0.7814566493,
-0.4747377634,
-0.3428204954,
0.9580990672,
-0.5412108898,
0.3663736284,
0.4101868868,
-0.0461682379,
-0.0873139054,
-0.570962429,
-0.424790293,
0.0519054122,
-0.0470353477,
0.293846786,
-0.1555075794,
-0.0656746849,
0.276227206,
0.0734680369,
-0.6577990651,
0.2219163775,
-0.5449960232,
-0.5903847814,
0.7962445617,
0.2335705161,
0.5083960295,
-0.2723818421,
-0.3234992623,
0.3245193362,
-0.6734184027,
0.0604716763,
0.7318983674,
0.1033344343,
-0.1138953865,
0.59212327,
-0.1439612508,
0.2120461762,
-0.1230468452,
-0.4924247861,
0.5070269108,
-0.8818656206,
0.1289598644,
0.2814657688,
0.8180886507,
0.0760467127,
0.0986061096,
0.2186153978,
-0.3119181395,
-0.0366197973,
0.3279806376,
-0.5325713158,
-0.1699091047,
0.1834456325,
-0.6507353783,
-0.3509956598,
-0.1832225323,
-0.4857119024,
-0.5555126071,
-0.3113205135,
0.42453596,
-0.2774576545,
-0.2733837366,
-0.3028363883,
0.0039293803,
0.0500811934,
0.6902521253,
-0.7903007269,
0.1001003906,
0.6168116331,
0.4984998703,
-0.5958767533,
-0.7192319632,
-0.4475820065,
-0.1106557921,
-0.2228996456,
1.0096343756,
-0.3007427156,
-0.1992219687,
-0.2032224387,
0.6129106283,
-0.2458229214,
-0.4060121477,
0.5807027817,
-0.4898528457,
0.2702197433,
-0.3408904076,
-0.406349957,
-0.4294912219,
0.2924143672,
-0.7445659041,
1.1673088074,
-0.0567618236,
-0.9672406912,
0.3307058513,
-0.6040558815,
-0.5504879355,
0.3556833565,
-0.140204832,
-0.537624836,
-0.1038779393,
0.1146622598,
0.6559595466,
-0.3051549494,
0.0596453175,
0.0934375748,
-0.3116782606,
0.0458054841,
-0.3079614043,
0.7743932009,
0.0902818292,
-0.6223201752,
0.1413982213,
-0.566963017,
-0.2048977762,
0.0350066274,
-0.6661877036,
-0.1988499314,
-0.1244422719,
0.1263945848,
0.1218845248,
0.754827559,
-0.8490440845,
0.0074781911,
0.0301855765,
0.1157712042,
0.7617164254,
0.2838870287,
0.3057923913,
-0.2410687059,
0.9620271325,
0.2822757959,
-0.133083418,
-0.5451833606,
-0.734444499,
-0.7389724851,
-0.3145346045,
0.5319424272,
0.820805192,
-0.8577315807,
0.146859929,
-0.0511959828,
-0.4792624414,
-0.2791361213,
0.1475010514,
0.4384484291,
-0.0100642536,
0.2945023775,
-0.1770920902,
-0.9386997819,
-1.0762424469,
-0.3036552966,
-0.1012823284,
0.3561045825,
0.0020580613,
1.1433084011,
-0.5281885862,
0.2743392289,
-0.2614122927,
-0.1511792839,
-0.4535725117,
0.3553317189,
0.0238581579,
0.5963577628,
0.5062586665,
-0.7618619204,
-0.5059615374,
0.0982803255,
-0.7929069996,
-0.3888061345,
0.0100363521,
-0.1542444974,
0.6106360555,
0.7491836548,
-0.1796723604,
0.525208354,
0.549980104,
-0.3205935657,
0.7868734598,
-0.097739011,
0.5887070298,
-1.2203361988,
0.0309039652,
-0.2939878404,
-0.4700990319,
-0.5043309331,
-0.0732832104,
0.2053979188,
0.1027155221,
-0.4494165778,
0.3468065858,
-0.4597731531,
-0.1718327403,
-0.3018631339,
-0.2531349063,
-0.1311673969,
0.4336436093,
-0.2319637239,
0.8006892204,
0.2699298263,
-0.486166209,
0.4929240942,
-0.030092949,
-0.2835491598,
0.5669503212,
-0.4036610425,
0.4322368801,
-0.3041292131,
0.0950822383,
-1.2685596943,
-0.2975869477,
0.0993093699,
-0.7362589836,
-0.0131245162,
-0.1692863703,
-0.5438653827,
-0.1910575628,
-0.2220119238,
0.415709734,
0.0575170331,
-0.1682419032,
0.673155129,
0.5902083516,
-0.5979986191,
-0.444368422,
-0.7999520302,
0.1665112674,
-0.1313907653,
-0.5701274276,
0.3201328814,
0.016346423,
-0.0102962693,
0.1385554075,
0.040779274,
-0.0181280971,
0.1190664023,
0.2847956717,
0.2220885009,
-0.091987133,
-0.2969940603,
0.2682237625,
-0.3871021271,
-0.0023915218,
-0.0880457088,
0.4230946004,
0.1245134622,
-0.4374315143,
-0.2967953682,
0.840996027,
0.7076222301,
-0.4089067578,
0.6430058479,
0.8854585886,
-0.5184528232,
-0.2738913298,
-0.3763315082,
0.1005147621,
-0.4017451704,
0.3329315782,
-0.6422934532,
-1.1930539608,
0.547608912,
0.0482228994,
0.2804319561,
0.7168874741,
0.9803822041,
-0.0644115731,
1.1737374067,
0.6791760325,
0.1919837892,
0.2900967896,
-0.0821475014,
0.2173519284,
-0.6744164824,
-0.4646826386,
-0.6353726983,
-0.4080949128,
-0.8169814348,
-0.3847933114,
0.5184147358,
-0.2990423143,
-0.0617800802,
0.6820641756,
-0.3700917959,
0.3283072412,
0.8829969764,
-0.1080259457,
0.2177149504,
-0.0838536173,
-0.4845826328,
-0.1580622047,
-0.4049804509,
-0.5670179129,
0.888348341,
0.229838416,
0.5558806658,
0.2538351119,
1.0726943016,
0.606112957,
0.0301564373,
-0.7142930627,
0.712677896,
-0.419937402,
-0.7554685473,
-0.2119550109,
-0.1853629351,
-0.9931544065,
0.2845349014,
-0.0037629667,
-0.5758695006,
0.2767714858,
-0.0385088176,
-0.0950338691,
0.0218159668,
-0.6534969211,
1.0714447498,
-0.139005363,
-0.051027149,
-0.1107817069,
-0.487169385,
0.2038066089,
-0.3810486495,
0.3927382827,
-0.2578412294,
-0.148230195,
1.0282056332,
-0.0236172322,
0.8449423313,
-0.1528863907,
-0.2104990035,
0.3960949481,
0.2472291738,
0.5501915812,
-0.1777330339,
-0.0268399268,
0.0610787347,
0.2564801574,
-0.2794781923,
-0.1018650383,
0.5769848824,
-0.6161408424,
-0.3088618517,
-0.6451283097,
-0.2021625936,
0.0569397025,
0.465079546,
0.6841949224,
0.3892341256,
-0.0749609172,
0.6277198792,
0.5014650822,
-0.4141350687,
0.4319275916,
0.593687892,
-0.0786639526,
-0.3590282202,
0.8865021467,
0.1783544719,
-0.1762471944,
0.5365210772,
0.057576444,
-0.3456122279,
-0.6230059266,
-0.453568399,
0.0035402584,
-0.7936202288,
-0.246940583,
-1.0254778862,
-0.3200072348,
-0.8015161157,
0.0055187228,
-0.296046257,
-0.2145415395,
-0.2397239655,
-0.006603302,
-0.011209459,
0.788615644,
-0.0515480153,
-0.0836850926,
-0.8826695681,
0.3243591487,
0.1153807342,
-0.3786763847,
-0.3423519433,
-0.6947978139,
-0.5267444253,
-0.2285146415,
-0.2517777085,
-0.7984128594,
0.3715640008,
0.0373531915,
0.7655299902,
-0.140835166,
-0.0582776219,
0.3158219457,
-0.7120460272,
0.9426782131,
0.0280341599,
-0.8219724894,
0.682671845,
-0.4830339551,
0.5434757471,
0.5576262474,
0.4551671147,
-0.6758195162,
-0.415135473,
-0.4565665722,
-0.778024435,
0.8832423091,
0.4032387435,
-0.0474858321,
0.2508912683,
0.1045438573,
0.3299073279,
0.3926073909,
-0.8073479533,
-0.0972054675,
0.0157535151,
-0.4167325795,
-0.1980347037,
-0.3836835623,
0.153734982,
0.0659450814,
0.8122706413,
-0.1829716265,
0.4603885412,
0.1925868541,
-0.2563930452,
-0.0441504344,
0.5237091184,
0.7894955277,
0.5100580454,
0.2517228425,
0.4923795462,
0.1968088597,
-0.6729437113,
0.2658819258,
-0.0494007394,
-0.3620293438,
-0.0472697392,
0.9383732677,
0.7664827108,
0.0540672131,
-0.47756809,
0.5172388554,
0.0358796902,
-0.5220115781,
-0.3070346117,
0.0275452174,
0.0920816958,
0.3188004792,
0.3451096117,
0.0963565782,
0.422911495,
-0.5041823983,
0.2260111719,
-0.0175748579,
-0.1658917367,
-0.5516354442,
0.5703353286,
0.2939805984,
-0.2440531552,
0.0423703156,
-0.4662046731,
-0.9930280447,
0.7987799644,
0.4855381846,
1.0901960135,
-0.2958773673,
0.2773234844,
0.3540347815,
0.6444800496,
0.0922830179,
0.5915210843,
0.0757573918,
-0.8894616365,
-0.4569856524,
-0.6899143457,
-0.4495344162,
0.3127589822,
-0.2694834173,
0.1953662187,
-0.0638795272,
-0.1025518104,
0.3517709076,
0.2074684501,
-0.6768034101,
0.1122424304,
0.1450188309,
0.4196261466,
-0.9328420758,
0.4855112135,
1.370036602,
-0.1322922856,
-0.6386629343,
-0.2536712885,
0.5125015378,
-0.5167424083,
0.8047282696,
0.216122061,
-0.2029099911,
0.0312959217,
-0.4659314156,
-0.8408842683,
0.9813629389,
0.2751200199,
-0.3151805699,
0.2524684668,
0.1813021302,
0.4540395439,
-0.3819878101,
-0.0882171541,
0.2673694193,
0.4362028241,
-0.1284168065,
-1.1685671806,
0.0570363104,
-0.4151491225,
-0.2500562668,
0.2918480039,
-0.539868474,
1.0446238518,
0.1532579213,
-0.0835618898,
0.0370682105,
0.4634955227,
0.4115106761,
0.4091587961,
0.684179306,
0.5274299979,
0.5756171346,
0.0401630178,
0.6736482978,
-0.1362785399,
0.3526365757,
0.916087091,
-0.2746554315,
0.5435125828,
0.2259799093,
-0.2369203418,
0.5827277303,
0.8664935827,
0.1705870181,
0.3414137363,
-0.0755286291,
-0.3908589184,
-0.5173556209,
-0.1554942131,
-0.2009261847,
0.7345528603,
0.1829496622,
-0.2092792839,
-0.2858913243,
0.4120298922,
-0.0343480706,
-0.2663787603,
-0.189930737,
0.7518729568,
0.0512386598,
-0.9898629189,
0.0489700176,
0.4813129306,
0.7506891489,
-0.4979354739,
-0.0935060158,
-0.1136327982,
0.3594972193,
-0.3777475059,
-0.7605261207,
0.2105675489,
0.1886840463,
-0.375782311,
-0.5262758136,
1.3181221485,
-0.5343316197,
-0.5877047181,
0.1552368999,
0.5379322171,
0.4498224556,
-0.1320502013,
-0.7884950638,
0.0763316974,
0.1591919661,
-0.2302158475,
0.1464865804,
0.7550743818,
-0.2913761437,
0.3848589659,
0.688615799,
-0.2685053945,
0.1562090963,
0.2433211803,
0.4943374097,
-0.6686609983,
-0.6708510518,
-0.7663859725,
0.2665604651,
0.1702549309,
-0.3467815816,
1.0622750521,
0.8544608951,
0.8886710405,
-0.1649290025,
0.99737221,
-0.2428290248,
0.8066850305,
-0.5216912627,
0.3950816095,
-0.7998051643,
0.0133418152,
-0.362904191,
-0.788782239,
0.0866174772,
0.4103712142,
-0.1404311359,
0.0782336071,
1.0674120188,
0.6389394403,
0.1856814623,
0.0297123939,
0.356731683,
-0.1899408549,
0.1956012696,
0.4782777429,
0.9580082893,
-0.5035485625,
0.4405083656,
-0.2529516816,
-0.103448756,
-0.2441741526,
-0.7793525457,
-0.963852942,
-0.7691426873,
-0.4061594903,
-0.1807425171,
-0.2324792445,
0.7263504267,
0.5326619148,
-1.1158344746,
-0.1544631869,
0.0956030115,
0.0816934705,
-0.0032962004,
-0.2187523395,
0.0810776949,
-0.3192199469,
-0.8736529946,
0.4321687818,
0.4694970846,
-0.0668906868,
-0.3642090857,
0.1043121591,
-0.5272610188,
-0.1154386103,
0.761171639,
-0.1439285278,
-0.4241831899,
-0.4050313234,
0.2241208255,
-0.1908473521,
-0.2231352478,
1.0567067862,
-0.3424401879,
0.2312284857,
1.0975351334,
0.5603218675,
0.5648085475,
-0.0441900045,
0.3391670585,
-0.7098723054,
-0.0028658286,
0.2594221532,
0.4283054471,
0.2279538065,
-0.5939151049,
0.6431244016,
0.7148184776,
-0.8287156224,
-0.7715724707,
0.1984532624,
-0.6928300261,
-0.3085110188,
1.1236094236,
-0.1371702105,
-0.2847833037,
-0.5930220485,
-0.2879109085,
0.0830182135,
-0.2675304115,
0.0383880772,
0.9515258074,
-0.3761132061,
-0.3464142084,
-0.759483397,
0.4246138632,
0.2752762735,
-1.0322178602,
-0.3952774704,
0.4670219719,
0.2675778866,
0.3598904312,
1.1291434765,
-0.0545094945,
0.3743451238,
0.0994508862,
0.2489893734,
0.1086806953,
-0.621581912,
0.0553083681,
0.2393317521,
-0.3739506006,
-0.274911046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14122v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14122v1
|
Fine-Tuning Large Language Models to Translate: Will a Touch of Noisy Data in Misaligned Languages Suffice?
| 2024-04-22T12:21:12 | 2024-04-22T12:21:12 |
Dawei Zhu, Pinzhen Chen, Miaoran Zhang, Barry Haddow, Xiaoyu Shen, Dietrich Klakow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Traditionally, success in multilingual machine translation can be attributed
to three key factors in training data: large volume, diverse translation
directions, and high quality. In the current practice of fine-tuning large
language models (LLMs) for translation, we revisit the importance of all these
factors. We find that LLMs display strong translation capability after being
fine-tuned on as few as 32 training instances, and that fine-tuning on a single
translation direction effectively enables LLMs to translate in multiple
directions. However, the choice of direction is critical: fine-tuning LLMs with
English on the target side can lead to task misinterpretation, which hinders
translations into non-English languages. A similar problem arises when noise is
introduced into the target side of parallel data, especially when the target
language is well-represented in the LLM's pre-training. In contrast, noise in
an under-represented language has a less pronounced effect. Our findings
suggest that attaining successful alignment hinges on teaching the model to
maintain a "superficial" focus, thereby avoiding the learning of erroneous
biases beyond translation.
|
[
-0.3370992839,
-0.492580533,
0.6119386554,
0.2369534671,
-0.4041436911,
-0.0666509792,
-0.5735796094,
-0.6195703149,
-0.1136828959,
0.6583507657,
-0.5176228881,
-0.3989495933,
-0.8962875009,
0.1317410022,
-0.587108314,
1.1387606859,
-0.2617808282,
0.4355363846,
-0.0104477918,
-0.3009450436,
-0.5908001661,
-0.3661860228,
-0.5592394471,
-0.5092700124,
0.6336931586,
0.5552018285,
0.9704554677,
1.0006394386,
0.6680876017,
0.3015478849,
0.0034318583,
0.4565360248,
-0.7528568506,
0.0983562544,
-0.1233521104,
-0.6597562432,
-0.3307451308,
0.0696838722,
0.7195453644,
0.9998741746,
0.0940402895,
-0.0237942804,
0.3423259258,
0.7491949201,
-0.1907473505,
-0.0072052302,
-0.6711534262,
-0.1041858047,
-0.404504627,
-0.0106489509,
-0.2580005825,
-0.1144455895,
-0.1870360374,
-0.5302380323,
0.180011645,
0.1921157241,
0.996974647,
0.4746591747,
-0.5989729166,
-0.1198742688,
-1.0036495924,
1.051245451,
-0.6427592039,
0.6403406858,
0.3876162767,
0.1681983322,
-0.2906367779,
-0.1480037123,
-0.1324968785,
0.1368760616,
0.1013643891,
-0.1218019947,
0.1708177924,
-0.0884239376,
0.2117567509,
0.2868523598,
-0.3324881494,
0.5785131454,
-0.4833586216,
-0.0512002483,
0.7569859028,
0.0922966227,
0.1499264836,
0.529635787,
-0.0936098844,
-0.0802885816,
-0.7663468122,
-0.2065085322,
0.4166406095,
0.7620850801,
-0.2223977298,
0.4341246784,
-0.1238316447,
0.8135731816,
0.3031591773,
-0.3061829805,
0.1341287196,
-0.575286746,
-0.013573573,
0.1853609681,
0.6759911776,
0.377635479,
0.5516291261,
-0.2870738506,
-0.3891735375,
-0.2393929958,
0.4148342907,
-0.7038464546,
0.0111584291,
0.0844937637,
-0.4160242975,
-0.1331447959,
-0.1427235156,
-0.2853205502,
-0.3857153654,
-0.8089003563,
0.2327586561,
-0.2830178142,
-0.0589970611,
0.3299508989,
0.4096657932,
0.185521394,
0.4520746171,
-0.9227421284,
0.1511699259,
0.8226232529,
0.7051724792,
-0.1488140523,
-0.6806334853,
-0.4629717767,
0.1529358923,
-0.7174973488,
0.5436319113,
-0.4485737681,
-0.0305744801,
0.1337381005,
0.1552875489,
-0.1316531897,
-0.5590209961,
0.5608727932,
-0.4148516655,
0.0924002305,
-0.4363106489,
-0.439868778,
-0.1787659526,
0.0102187563,
-0.4332742691,
0.5733861327,
-0.0901214704,
-0.3781542778,
0.3728360236,
-0.0281354766,
-0.8328811526,
-0.3757849336,
-0.0413385481,
-0.5550627112,
0.4546856284,
0.2555275559,
0.5768350363,
-0.2551780045,
0.287670821,
-0.3290555477,
-0.3572975993,
0.2596260011,
-0.4101764262,
0.4121973813,
0.3663109839,
-0.0387580208,
0.021686893,
-0.4287234545,
-0.2021985501,
-0.0748598576,
-0.4144820869,
-0.3054328859,
-0.0525384806,
0.093221128,
0.3191581368,
0.3934826851,
-0.2707815766,
0.1901606768,
-0.415856719,
0.3663729429,
0.5136839747,
-0.3963399231,
0.6953743696,
-0.3282247186,
0.3662652671,
0.196159184,
0.0632740334,
0.1019450426,
-0.4424109459,
-0.810000062,
-0.0383799151,
0.4509898424,
0.3102622628,
-0.4484181106,
0.1198907197,
-0.3417291343,
-0.4577588439,
-0.854778409,
0.6317251921,
0.3328386247,
0.3439011872,
0.3783070743,
-0.3466381133,
-0.3824416697,
-0.9157803655,
-0.3857771456,
0.185930118,
0.2501347661,
0.0601119436,
0.1541752219,
-0.2679284811,
0.1659177393,
-0.1186101213,
-0.5033576488,
-0.2905669808,
0.0962587148,
0.2715451121,
0.58578372,
0.4013111293,
-0.7616693377,
-0.5847113132,
0.4652212858,
-0.489158839,
-0.1903077811,
-0.2814009786,
-0.2241206169,
0.1368076801,
0.7839336991,
-0.6252619028,
-0.069976896,
0.738830328,
0.0988360941,
0.1923867613,
-0.3738377392,
0.167677477,
-1.0774049759,
-0.0744748041,
-0.0401941054,
-0.2603025138,
-0.649789691,
0.0913910866,
0.184680745,
0.1117285118,
-0.370734334,
0.3210677803,
-0.5219401717,
0.0959737673,
-0.5415765047,
0.0890429765,
-0.0325055495,
0.187188372,
-0.0912519172,
0.7162644267,
0.4083750248,
-0.7341573834,
-0.0018461627,
0.1862847954,
-0.3647429049,
0.6093794107,
-0.2972945869,
0.0456815027,
-0.1045224369,
-0.1518919617,
-0.7508143783,
-0.3764525056,
0.0386819765,
-0.2292377055,
0.9283064008,
-0.1167342439,
-0.3830932677,
-0.2468454987,
0.2685083747,
0.5303151011,
0.2036868185,
-0.4154573679,
0.2068344802,
0.3675474823,
-0.0647117645,
-0.5538739562,
-0.7816905379,
0.0902439281,
-0.3270255923,
-0.4318342805,
0.284032166,
0.1365264952,
-0.1905062944,
-0.3069612384,
-0.1850896478,
-0.1842622757,
0.1991478801,
0.0882436186,
-0.0614743568,
-0.193806529,
0.1595810354,
-0.0355215147,
-0.1502393037,
-0.1442096978,
-0.5282796621,
0.4968548119,
-0.0826454386,
-0.5055299997,
-0.3380047381,
0.356284529,
0.9265516996,
-0.3439011872,
0.7833011746,
0.6536903381,
-0.2938205898,
0.0620186143,
-0.5104329586,
-0.2212681174,
-0.3875416517,
0.6907248497,
-0.4690904617,
-0.6806871891,
0.4933916926,
-0.1368378997,
0.1303837895,
0.346801877,
0.5438051224,
-0.3203729987,
1.5589556694,
0.9191151261,
-0.4739611149,
0.460616976,
0.1207836717,
0.3869941235,
-0.6079612374,
-0.0725677088,
-0.7381352186,
-0.6921042204,
-0.7282500267,
-0.3343482018,
0.1655724347,
0.4008461535,
-0.2083723694,
0.4311395884,
-0.2500993013,
0.4698561728,
0.4689642787,
-0.0181183051,
0.3784665763,
0.1775496751,
0.1491500288,
-0.3270431161,
-0.789720118,
-0.4460948706,
0.9941470027,
0.4648366272,
0.9743618369,
0.0486483201,
0.7165670991,
-0.5780259967,
0.1260825396,
-0.7785509229,
0.1237085462,
-0.4510234892,
-0.4862160683,
-0.3304539323,
-0.3570829928,
-1.0444293022,
0.2772459388,
-0.1584006399,
-0.2971209586,
0.1165640727,
0.1649285406,
-0.2597934902,
0.3351995945,
-0.5381628871,
0.8353708386,
-0.6316120028,
-0.3829710186,
-0.3362096548,
-0.5836737752,
0.2716002762,
-0.4239033461,
0.4144574106,
-0.0937997028,
0.140382126,
0.4140842557,
-0.0834849998,
0.8328641057,
0.1283159554,
-0.3903504014,
-0.1660570651,
0.2190239578,
0.6289031506,
-0.2213063091,
0.0278046317,
0.360447675,
-0.1431700289,
-0.4596387446,
-0.3703278005,
0.6919850111,
-0.8935845494,
-0.6732029319,
-0.0231334958,
-1.0050804615,
-0.3086964488,
0.4044166207,
0.3360218704,
0.0211549215,
-0.0039973119,
0.2638274729,
0.7596898675,
0.0769524723,
0.0563488603,
0.6034175158,
-0.2774448991,
-0.0424366295,
1.184648037,
0.358237654,
0.4408460855,
0.330873996,
0.033627253,
-0.2394621968,
-0.9388495088,
-0.6432101727,
0.4239511788,
-0.4098704159,
-0.1807398796,
-0.4563271105,
-0.0672857985,
-0.295155108,
-0.1692376584,
-0.8713344932,
-0.2045118213,
-0.5317713022,
0.1642629504,
0.0879032537,
0.8075791597,
-0.0388221405,
0.3741826713,
-0.8246498108,
0.1502851397,
0.0172773134,
0.3675067425,
-0.3725245893,
-0.8537248969,
-0.7741501927,
0.2700257599,
-0.3354531527,
-0.5736125112,
0.4638111889,
0.1724501252,
0.4388712943,
0.4202670455,
-0.2790033519,
0.8992872834,
-0.6861204505,
0.3386337161,
0.098833859,
-0.5775634646,
0.2403461933,
-0.5117017031,
0.5037433505,
0.6415094733,
0.4369180202,
-0.6464523673,
-0.686304152,
-0.3323979378,
-0.6665152311,
0.6108933091,
-0.2340431958,
0.1817918271,
0.2550842464,
0.3619014025,
0.1355071813,
0.3598593771,
-0.632918179,
-0.0620778427,
0.0955415964,
-0.3137281537,
-0.4985312819,
-0.1083840728,
-0.299770236,
-0.254231751,
0.5760862231,
-0.1783195734,
-0.1064910516,
-0.1793297529,
-0.1052576452,
-0.6483991146,
0.1709119678,
0.7136042118,
0.5211026073,
0.1145207435,
0.1021953151,
0.1197414771,
-0.2803033292,
0.0605203211,
0.0822160617,
-0.3435225189,
-0.2186559588,
0.3742748201,
0.8547843099,
0.2433776259,
-0.0787835494,
0.3034129441,
0.2089022249,
-0.1805455089,
0.2225891054,
-0.0696749985,
0.1752220392,
0.3013275266,
-0.1175137088,
0.3475164771,
-0.1325837374,
-0.3546755612,
-0.1129133627,
0.6117144823,
-0.5500384569,
-0.2736639082,
0.7657397985,
0.2284757793,
-0.2025439441,
0.6122280955,
0.0603337251,
-0.4891704917,
0.4537796378,
0.6107577682,
0.6775480509,
-0.3523824513,
-0.1946040988,
0.286799401,
0.7035809755,
-0.5750048757,
0.0218068808,
0.2859504223,
-0.8003399968,
-0.6974083781,
-0.6717268825,
-0.2187013626,
0.1794000864,
-0.6589363813,
0.3826198876,
-0.0154232234,
-0.0248145722,
-0.1922469139,
-0.1217295527,
-0.8025243282,
0.0960864946,
0.3149031699,
0.6740037203,
-1.0225309134,
1.0173368454,
0.7462162971,
-0.2025852501,
-0.8448060751,
-0.1520165503,
-0.0504293889,
-0.7402155995,
0.5814721584,
0.1719592959,
-0.0919550583,
0.1117031127,
-0.6402413249,
-1.0361323357,
0.6205086112,
0.6344282031,
-1.0152543783,
0.2526526749,
0.494165957,
0.5413382649,
-0.3139878511,
-0.2266461402,
0.5757097602,
0.6089436412,
-0.1738988459,
-1.211032033,
-0.2008180022,
0.2313169092,
-0.0865492746,
0.431479305,
-0.8229760528,
0.7798025012,
-0.3515639901,
-0.168257013,
0.0940422863,
0.4717652798,
-0.1381518394,
-0.0027168381,
0.2102600187,
0.6166983843,
0.76524055,
-0.19863455,
1.0438872576,
-0.4381881654,
0.0861772299,
1.1311855316,
-0.2476220727,
0.7936641574,
0.8307110071,
0.1224604994,
-0.0986552462,
0.7340227365,
0.1130715609,
0.5409402251,
0.0002898067,
0.1171515435,
-0.6271725297,
-0.2046520412,
-0.4720463753,
0.486050874,
0.3961785436,
-0.3730901778,
-0.153179571,
0.0585288927,
-0.0415395349,
0.3357271254,
-0.3694117963,
0.6465089321,
0.3110103011,
-0.7874412537,
0.7106414437,
0.1050969586,
0.3985064626,
-0.4069577157,
0.1515927762,
-0.3067035079,
0.3875486255,
-0.1381693631,
-0.7466871142,
0.3744090199,
-0.3475870788,
-0.3367566466,
-0.5209020376,
0.4781832397,
-0.884403646,
-0.5624745488,
0.2521776259,
0.6649990082,
0.3121402264,
-0.1128135622,
-0.6480676532,
0.1882896721,
0.1391526759,
-0.0324046537,
0.5872471333,
0.630469799,
-0.0872671083,
0.6740080714,
0.5208182931,
0.4126265645,
-0.0341606587,
0.1754766256,
0.5802220106,
-0.4614961445,
-0.1530341357,
-0.7568634152,
0.2650340796,
0.2628737688,
-0.3090115786,
0.7804950476,
0.3803989589,
1.1609494686,
-0.036392279,
0.4117652476,
0.5821754932,
0.3854904473,
-0.6365766525,
0.7409172058,
-0.7188077569,
0.1272158623,
-0.057898961,
-1.0350203514,
-0.5683655739,
0.6384277344,
-0.3922864497,
-0.0250783022,
0.5478995442,
0.8949506283,
-0.2172035724,
-0.1442231238,
0.5574102998,
0.4085175693,
0.0456023812,
0.5745745897,
0.7205322981,
-0.6477572918,
0.7288495302,
-0.3121709824,
0.0598747022,
-0.2707943618,
-0.6798277497,
-0.7717111111,
-0.3115264475,
-0.3900704384,
-0.1719350964,
-0.0064967754,
0.680532217,
0.7836341262,
-0.965243876,
-0.4640773833,
-0.1526160091,
0.200326547,
-0.3112205863,
-0.0201398022,
-0.0679247901,
-0.7566674352,
-1.0527181625,
0.4298576415,
0.2145574987,
0.3261973262,
-0.1900325567,
-0.2969777584,
-0.0750594735,
-0.2634034753,
0.3493789136,
0.2655064166,
-0.722689271,
-0.1282716542,
-0.0777198672,
-0.5969694257,
0.0858862996,
0.5764940381,
-0.1968609691,
0.5092036724,
0.1984536052,
0.7825564742,
0.4405192137,
-0.043304719,
0.9234561324,
-0.6476207376,
0.2617586851,
-0.0727191791,
0.3097237945,
0.4497898221,
-0.414986968,
0.378862232,
-0.0614895374,
-0.7252901793,
-0.7779251337,
0.1871459633,
-0.5328457355,
-0.2403685153,
1.1940785646,
0.202272594,
-0.1280022711,
-0.1794373244,
-0.2777973413,
0.4473501146,
-0.0246292446,
0.6606562138,
0.9066026807,
0.0706944764,
-0.0564287119,
-0.8134022951,
0.5893645287,
0.8821308613,
-0.289387852,
0.2240844667,
0.3929181695,
0.075250119,
0.1543871015,
0.1570453942,
-0.1085587814,
-0.0306388717,
-0.2410859764,
-0.016777372,
0.1027230546,
-0.5218106508,
-0.6090292931,
-0.2266706824,
0.5581152439,
-0.1209540293
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14465v1
|
Benchmarking Advanced Text Anonymisation Methods: A Comparative Study on Novel and Traditional Approaches
| 2024-04-22T12:06:54 | 2024-04-22T12:06:54 |
Dimitris Asimopoulos, Ilias Siniosoglou, Vasileios Argyriou, Thomai Karamitsou, Eleftherios Fountoukidis, Sotirios K. Goudos, Ioannis D. Moscholios, Konstantinos E. Psannis, Panagiotis Sarigiannidis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
In the realm of data privacy, the ability to effectively anonymise text is
paramount. With the proliferation of deep learning and, in particular,
transformer architectures, there is a burgeoning interest in leveraging these
advanced models for text anonymisation tasks. This paper presents a
comprehensive benchmarking study comparing the performance of transformer-based
models and Large Language Models(LLM) against traditional architectures for
text anonymisation. Utilising the CoNLL-2003 dataset, known for its robustness
and diversity, we evaluate several models. Our results showcase the strengths
and weaknesses of each approach, offering a clear perspective on the efficacy
of modern versus traditional methods. Notably, while modern models exhibit
advanced capabilities in capturing con textual nuances, certain traditional
architectures still keep high performance. This work aims to guide researchers
in selecting the most suitable model for their anonymisation needs, while also
shedding light on potential paths for future advancements in the field.
|
[
-0.1050920859,
-0.8565657735,
0.2701541483,
0.006750728,
0.0288821589,
0.3520820141,
-0.2594188154,
-0.8194941878,
-0.2256340832,
0.6833840609,
-0.4603134394,
-0.5542516112,
-0.6743898988,
0.3356583118,
-0.879065454,
0.510022521,
-0.0109668858,
0.013056824,
-0.1804869324,
-0.3433108032,
-0.2592196763,
-0.6849839687,
-0.6905004978,
-0.3133936226,
0.2782639861,
-0.0033485761,
0.870218277,
1.0752481222,
0.8374257088,
0.3899240494,
-0.5655796528,
0.0969501957,
-0.4463613927,
0.3096165657,
-0.1670587659,
-0.308935672,
-0.1749220192,
0.0641012937,
0.6575935483,
0.5689890385,
0.0014071024,
0.2023648173,
-0.0155006247,
0.6140882969,
-0.9942482114,
-0.1402977407,
-0.4492841959,
0.1222206578,
-0.4264843166,
0.2091892064,
-0.4811167121,
-0.6562961936,
0.2716769576,
-0.4706404805,
0.4692988694,
0.2418311238,
0.9521027207,
0.3080082238,
-0.2350416034,
-0.6502630115,
-1.0923831463,
0.8991774917,
-0.7618516684,
0.6084377766,
0.1527396291,
0.5757834911,
0.3453665674,
-1.0533906221,
-0.3615190387,
-0.2142965645,
-0.5399957895,
-0.110582076,
-0.4857844412,
-0.1617133021,
0.2838543057,
0.6550594568,
-0.4704279304,
0.6085594893,
-0.2006186098,
-0.2084673941,
0.5499039888,
0.1310104132,
0.1648317128,
0.0806676969,
-0.6452823877,
0.0090963989,
-0.7203589082,
-0.0657882616,
0.7637653947,
-0.0457826219,
-0.1553249359,
0.3691522479,
-0.4374952018,
0.4397175312,
0.0049273712,
-0.1381151676,
0.1404845715,
-0.2609067261,
-0.2493641078,
-0.1396922022,
1.0295103788,
0.1504451483,
0.3875337243,
-0.6698630452,
-0.1946138144,
0.0344312415,
0.0518796854,
-0.9361587167,
-0.2735812068,
0.0067637661,
-0.6994364858,
-0.1830103099,
0.0057993205,
-1.028269887,
-0.7713424563,
-0.3056177497,
0.3119079769,
-0.3043179214,
-0.1247388721,
0.1022227854,
-0.1338560581,
0.1355744153,
0.2788110077,
-1.0628268719,
0.7722078562,
0.7649342418,
0.6408640742,
-0.5481458306,
-0.0625879541,
-0.0254897624,
0.0165047776,
-0.1004467383,
0.6249989271,
-0.8497024179,
-0.2421758473,
0.1002051011,
-0.0704089254,
-0.1041229665,
-0.7921375632,
0.6102015972,
-0.566498816,
0.3930286169,
0.0176563635,
-0.7496162653,
-0.4021743238,
0.2302994579,
-0.9798640609,
1.0724008083,
-0.2458169162,
-0.9281321764,
0.0404746309,
-0.4666159749,
-0.3240950406,
0.0284519978,
-0.2722028196,
-0.5355129838,
0.0179567058,
0.1235861406,
0.3243416846,
-0.6273482442,
0.447402209,
0.0214389469,
-0.4844397604,
0.4147631526,
-1.0053508282,
0.7548402548,
0.2859858572,
-0.4920296073,
-0.0728302747,
-1.0616489649,
-0.4460642934,
-0.0845636055,
-0.0186560899,
-0.240316987,
0.0587488525,
-0.0273593571,
-0.2984699011,
0.4046512246,
-0.6176669002,
-0.1630502194,
-0.4303201437,
0.4559858739,
0.3482805192,
-0.085770838,
0.633657515,
-0.2172323763,
0.5061473846,
-0.2081472576,
0.1412765384,
-0.2563896179,
-0.101560019,
-0.5885387659,
-0.3991569281,
0.661144197,
0.5558553934,
-0.319231391,
0.0537316538,
-0.3569033146,
-0.7709898949,
-0.7325438857,
-0.0782807171,
0.5998018384,
0.3813750148,
0.3220201135,
-0.0752150193,
-0.3922811747,
-1.0905588865,
-0.7254886031,
0.2291590869,
-0.2370144725,
0.416749388,
0.2545440793,
-0.0165755842,
0.8667884469,
-0.2601155341,
-0.1883453131,
-0.1173550338,
0.0941614285,
0.0359292515,
0.3923488259,
0.4852704704,
-1.158728838,
-0.4170868397,
-0.1331579536,
-0.8388535976,
0.0376641899,
0.0606198944,
0.2103073895,
0.0513702855,
0.5499890447,
-0.4539470375,
0.4437686205,
0.7495331168,
-0.091473572,
0.4308133125,
-0.2459615022,
0.2086921036,
-0.7980545759,
0.4493529201,
-0.0456454828,
-0.1572614163,
-0.9192994237,
0.1168963462,
0.2606392503,
-0.0598024428,
-0.6032431722,
0.7090654373,
-0.6811107397,
0.2876367271,
-0.1627246737,
-0.1639929712,
-0.0399670489,
0.1110836565,
0.1100661457,
0.659492135,
0.5524871945,
-0.4570438862,
0.069435522,
0.2135579735,
-0.2354514301,
0.193341881,
-0.4899234176,
0.2666003406,
-0.1218281984,
0.1049239859,
-1.1087377071,
-0.064688161,
0.1015809551,
-0.3783718348,
0.443783462,
-0.0120548448,
-0.6263386607,
-0.071673803,
-0.4216652811,
0.5700928569,
0.3693897128,
-0.6601293087,
0.7174847126,
0.3263395727,
-0.0367846601,
-0.8150709271,
-0.7143269181,
0.4737804532,
-0.3571254909,
-0.3143655956,
0.6164788604,
0.0003673859,
-0.387593478,
-0.0432627797,
-0.1061524674,
-0.474134177,
0.3942566514,
0.2356225997,
0.0891080573,
-0.2107934654,
-0.1640010029,
-0.3421167731,
-0.3548389077,
0.0691814199,
0.3087084293,
0.4135173559,
0.251486659,
0.0960452482,
-0.7731177807,
0.3511103392,
0.4672968984,
-0.492910713,
0.8864143491,
0.438351959,
-0.4218366444,
-0.0968073756,
-0.920425117,
-0.0421859585,
-0.5314099193,
0.17003645,
-0.0095575843,
-0.9138370752,
0.5026205182,
-0.4053959548,
0.204503119,
0.3706356287,
0.3148515821,
0.1968495101,
0.4879532456,
0.8343027234,
-0.2427119762,
0.3756819069,
0.0246827286,
0.3663290441,
-0.4153333902,
-0.2470541596,
-0.9222267866,
-0.3248251975,
-0.9413074851,
-0.0600224137,
-0.2531405687,
-0.1780054122,
-0.2246863246,
0.3777284622,
-0.524751544,
0.5830670595,
0.4730911851,
-0.0805260018,
0.6663864851,
-0.2480068952,
0.2716279626,
-0.0547012091,
-0.3303228617,
-0.8218533397,
0.9727768898,
0.3760283887,
0.7806286216,
0.0122138401,
0.5200676322,
0.2646369636,
0.5273519754,
-0.3895216882,
0.5364452004,
-0.5899922252,
-0.6377686262,
-0.2153360248,
-0.4739233255,
-0.9727406502,
0.2525305748,
-0.3911013305,
-0.9324579835,
0.1991489679,
0.0467897616,
-0.1175204068,
0.5050371289,
-0.5879755616,
0.6951663494,
0.1907934248,
-0.4442684352,
0.2423640788,
-0.7526616454,
0.2790987194,
-0.1069621369,
0.3919403255,
-0.0170613378,
-0.2163262367,
0.7134953141,
0.0659283102,
0.8769458532,
-0.0025608304,
-0.0542571284,
-0.0885573551,
-0.0133398939,
0.580811739,
-0.2366735786,
-0.5038785338,
0.4126574993,
-0.3028377593,
0.028331941,
-0.2617024183,
0.6557231545,
-0.5138349533,
-0.3072458804,
-0.0209037382,
-0.5767353773,
-0.0516948923,
0.4413464963,
0.5287789106,
0.7053137422,
-0.4271457195,
0.8595553637,
0.8458905816,
-0.207526952,
0.9895167947,
0.6477742195,
0.3651582301,
-0.4339103401,
0.2849430442,
0.2891927361,
-0.0149292732,
0.8730751872,
0.2732703388,
-0.4634857774,
-0.84742558,
-0.3350247145,
0.0388471149,
-0.5337081552,
-0.2430141568,
-0.9053748846,
-0.4422731102,
-0.1469187737,
-0.1521016955,
-0.5810464621,
-0.3998711705,
-0.0845701769,
-0.0295387451,
0.1373383701,
0.8318104744,
0.5492148399,
0.3546499312,
-0.3917408288,
0.506267488,
-0.0219694953,
0.444476217,
0.1386447698,
-0.316755414,
0.012006212,
-0.2431695312,
-0.3048515618,
-0.7373999357,
0.1022357345,
0.0938283354,
0.628056705,
0.1335327774,
0.2055051476,
0.2340271622,
-0.729967773,
0.7994462252,
0.0137994718,
-0.7941791415,
0.1022450551,
-0.0452460311,
0.2481888235,
0.6917231083,
0.33796224,
-0.3461405337,
-0.7587245703,
-0.6126750708,
-0.9693018198,
0.3129020631,
0.378937304,
0.2949706018,
0.2654165924,
0.4234695435,
0.5401371121,
0.3376299143,
-0.8618772626,
-0.6121757627,
0.2897776961,
-0.3168903589,
-0.1353725344,
-0.2345715761,
0.154636234,
0.1039542034,
0.3140509725,
0.340344578,
-0.140807122,
0.0837132931,
-0.2086106688,
0.2743481398,
0.3411775827,
0.4289158285,
0.6643366218,
0.0777065605,
0.3196794093,
0.361473918,
-0.6763667464,
0.2167851329,
0.2155040652,
-0.608062923,
0.2906069756,
0.4760288298,
0.6348866224,
0.2890643775,
-0.415071696,
0.5034732223,
-0.1363888532,
-0.3337988555,
0.0527228452,
0.1433131546,
0.1493677944,
0.1097436398,
0.3915256858,
0.173698917,
0.3926338255,
-0.2289465815,
0.0546179339,
0.3013288677,
-0.2096325457,
-0.322902441,
0.972658217,
-0.0264036506,
-0.763058126,
0.0704811141,
0.3256187439,
-0.1854776591,
0.5064979196,
0.3666769266,
1.0921858549,
-0.5201459527,
-0.1438422501,
0.3303288519,
0.2979038954,
-0.3516348004,
-0.295558542,
-0.1080108732,
-0.2659860849,
-0.0453268588,
-0.4169209599,
-0.8781294227,
0.1681309193,
-0.7943797708,
0.111196965,
-0.3871193826,
0.0032895245,
0.2762869895,
0.2331746966,
-0.8782095909,
0.3892283738,
0.2141748369,
0.9695175886,
-0.7774457335,
0.7093071342,
0.4295405746,
0.3182777762,
-0.4131558836,
0.1214342192,
0.0904191658,
-0.4106790721,
0.0267627202,
0.4431770146,
-0.3662877679,
0.0062303115,
-0.3291406631,
-0.7268388271,
1.16939044,
0.4574971795,
-0.7946599126,
0.077980198,
0.4730390906,
0.8165096045,
-0.1051723808,
0.3700245917,
0.6214570999,
0.3862434328,
-0.0985963866,
-0.772854507,
0.2008408457,
-0.0165998843,
0.0034514968,
0.20681867,
-0.9114480019,
0.7459248304,
0.2734975517,
-0.4289397299,
0.3709979951,
0.5232487917,
-0.1316832602,
0.3252611458,
0.2304612398,
0.2305863351,
0.9430033565,
0.0050398908,
0.8162450194,
-0.3948904574,
0.4677197635,
1.1926608086,
-0.2469070703,
0.9338490367,
0.236996606,
-0.03405549,
0.3707057536,
0.2414957732,
-0.248195067,
0.5873537064,
0.2419733256,
-0.1530665159,
0.3238383234,
-0.0986552387,
-0.2823405266,
0.4804649949,
-0.1294038296,
-0.585976541,
-0.4127044678,
-0.1541864872,
0.2967925966,
0.4138150513,
-0.0339260213,
1.0267268419,
-0.1855152249,
-0.5047262907,
0.236067757,
0.1078052148,
0.905135572,
-0.6352984905,
0.2473471463,
-0.4943817556,
0.378508836,
-0.0898165628,
-0.4990143776,
0.2403376251,
0.3771116138,
-0.2215860337,
-0.4951121807,
0.7377177477,
-0.3656233847,
-0.4244848788,
0.3400575221,
0.3539134562,
-0.0453238115,
0.188847512,
-0.4841886759,
0.1643887013,
-0.3111325502,
-0.2624031305,
0.1689043343,
0.5540930033,
0.0163339246,
0.6650996804,
0.2380097806,
-0.1166206598,
-0.0499292426,
0.1104698852,
0.6671231985,
-0.6834285259,
-0.4839388728,
-1.3620128632,
0.1295812279,
-0.3133313656,
-0.407618165,
1.110752821,
1.0542834997,
0.6778828502,
0.2402507812,
0.4926199615,
0.325699836,
0.7038763762,
-0.4528461397,
0.8693816066,
-0.1857715249,
0.5904775858,
-0.2180811763,
-0.9451333284,
-0.4702599347,
-0.0804046243,
-0.1014370471,
-0.2776823044,
0.5362501144,
0.8639351726,
-0.2021564841,
0.3644580245,
0.2152313143,
0.166183129,
0.3352457881,
0.2187845111,
0.7823130488,
-0.490542084,
0.5251495838,
-0.3627458215,
-0.1577020139,
0.0571576208,
-0.974253118,
-1.0181921721,
-0.0858608112,
-0.4262531698,
0.0745233446,
0.2753050625,
0.2173727751,
0.6099083424,
-0.8438777328,
-0.2289927602,
0.0656324625,
-0.061673332,
-0.282630533,
-0.114287287,
0.6654189229,
0.0652493089,
-0.8181404471,
0.3260543346,
0.2682304382,
0.111039646,
-0.1227463409,
0.2935013771,
0.0665881783,
0.2661689818,
0.1639566272,
-0.0093735745,
-0.6237905025,
-0.2416164875,
0.1958933175,
-0.2446285933,
0.2092536092,
0.7748183012,
-0.7667479515,
0.405921489,
0.3853411376,
0.8119142056,
0.4988840818,
0.2565521002,
0.4211370051,
-0.6809136868,
0.1031349003,
0.2600446045,
0.071606569,
0.4319899976,
-0.3576078117,
0.5595644712,
-0.0692319646,
-0.4352251887,
-0.9402494431,
-0.2698334157,
-0.5914897919,
-0.3604960442,
1.0858638287,
-0.2225243896,
-0.06249341,
-0.1424909532,
-0.1422031671,
0.0833756179,
0.008924121,
0.7912867069,
0.6442135572,
0.2973929048,
-0.0681170076,
-0.6737087369,
0.5882912278,
0.2171765119,
-0.6712762713,
0.3765825927,
0.0812479854,
0.3212859631,
-0.1390509754,
0.4471417069,
-0.1865225881,
0.0483721271,
0.0555719733,
-0.2076632231,
-0.1133207902,
-0.3477684855,
-0.4144954383,
0.6649081707,
-0.491446346,
-0.3292767406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14057v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14057v2
|
Bored to Death: Artificial Intelligence Research Reveals the Role of Boredom in Suicide Behavior
| 2024-04-22T10:16:02 | 2024-04-26T11:50:25 |
Shir Lissak, Yaakov Ophir, Refael Tikochinski, Anat Brunstein Klomek, Itay Sisso, Eyal Fruchter, Roi Reichart
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Background: Recent advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI) contributed
significantly to suicide assessment, however, our theoretical understanding of
this complex behavior is still limited. Objective: This study aimed to harness
AI methodologies to uncover hidden risk factors that trigger or aggravate
suicide behaviors. Method: The primary dataset included 228,052 Facebook
postings by 1,006 users who completed the gold-standard Columbia Suicide
Severity Rating Scale. This dataset was analyzed using a bottom-up research
pipeline without a-priory hypotheses and its findings were validated using a
top-down analysis of a new dataset. This secondary dataset included responses
by 1,062 participants to the same suicide scale as well as to well-validated
scales measuring depression and boredom. Results: An almost fully automated,
AI-guided research pipeline resulted in four Facebook topics that predicted the
risk of suicide, of which the strongest predictor was boredom. A comprehensive
literature review using APA PsycInfo revealed that boredom is rarely perceived
as a unique risk factor of suicide. A complementing top-down path analysis of
the secondary dataset uncovered an indirect relationship between boredom and
suicide, which was mediated by depression. An equivalent mediated relationship
was observed in the primary Facebook dataset as well. However, here, a direct
relationship between boredom and suicide risk was also observed. Conclusions:
Integrating AI methods allowed the discovery of an under-researched risk factor
of suicide. The study signals boredom as a maladaptive 'ingredient' that might
trigger suicide behaviors, regardless of depression. Further studies are
recommended to direct clinicians' attention to this burdening, and sometimes
existential experience.
|
[
-0.3527077734,
-1.0888712406,
1.0176342726,
0.1662530005,
-0.0857399181,
-0.0853748843,
0.1052732766,
-0.1062124297,
0.3972148895,
0.0977077186,
-0.968932569,
-0.2693298757,
-0.3810310066,
0.1700023562,
-0.385692209,
0.6874116659,
0.2578620017,
-0.0218661036,
-0.449482888,
0.2613057494,
-0.3014330268,
-0.2608071268,
-0.8558474183,
-0.2851812541,
0.9972332716,
0.1065052375,
0.9846755862,
0.2225206196,
0.5631682873,
0.3375769258,
0.1826670319,
-0.2146113515,
-0.750531733,
-0.0551684685,
0.1889593452,
-0.5242934823,
-0.0480943657,
0.2012779862,
-0.1942742914,
0.6761518717,
0.0105254687,
0.2477695495,
-0.1137885973,
0.865149498,
-0.5152389407,
-0.2192751914,
0.0122201731,
0.3285881877,
-0.3308226764,
-0.4098304808,
-0.2171521336,
-0.5115351081,
-0.067777805,
-0.644203186,
-0.0148043297,
-0.1165599972,
0.2700185478,
1.1466155052,
-0.4870230854,
-0.570293963,
-0.9358619452,
0.5185545683,
-0.4580830932,
-0.2949405611,
0.37338534,
-0.010949255,
-0.2959682643,
-0.103542991,
-0.6395621896,
-0.3553022444,
-0.0233412422,
0.258446902,
0.0575380251,
0.3072931767,
0.4461503029,
0.5561965704,
-0.6510845423,
0.071854569,
-0.6537713408,
0.0361250788,
1.1498051882,
0.4120574594,
0.7759928107,
-0.2699286938,
-0.0250538941,
0.1382301599,
-0.0639892295,
0.6437482238,
0.8569099307,
-0.3026648462,
-0.1013658419,
0.9151491523,
-0.1711246818,
0.4049917459,
-0.2076687217,
-0.0109458715,
0.3511869311,
0.1151309535,
0.1147213802,
0.2282527089,
0.9267064333,
0.6843078136,
0.2185728997,
-0.1832176,
0.2126419246,
-0.0838937983,
0.7462245226,
-0.3744342029,
-0.3728392124,
0.7643811703,
-0.6661754847,
-0.4035822749,
0.0598380044,
-0.6317055821,
-0.3954171836,
0.0660139918,
0.6901702285,
-0.5719970465,
-0.1091714725,
-0.0943201929,
-0.7184113264,
-0.3530178964,
0.3450007737,
0.0928559676,
-0.0513757393,
0.3968139887,
1.0208708048,
-0.5026067495,
-0.1957518756,
-0.2844751179,
-0.1821749955,
-0.4831027389,
0.7908020616,
-0.1575793028,
-0.2266935855,
0.0818475559,
0.0070206202,
0.1462932974,
-0.3219875395,
0.5907638073,
-0.2163531035,
0.2955187559,
-0.2383689582,
-0.3696788251,
-0.7362248302,
-0.0743545592,
-0.8089102507,
0.9412497282,
0.2650365829,
-0.3992460966,
0.1271269768,
-0.7641893029,
-0.5830942988,
0.337927103,
-0.0637770668,
-0.2201512009,
0.217738837,
-0.5701065063,
0.3637111187,
-0.097771287,
0.2234932631,
-0.6537691951,
-0.457416147,
0.5558176041,
-0.3353274167,
1.1004148722,
0.1900437474,
-0.1837502718,
-0.1667360961,
-0.5409622788,
-0.0396913029,
0.1099040806,
-0.2089004666,
-0.5548605323,
0.2762457728,
-0.2185863703,
0.7710667849,
0.1872192919,
-0.5880553126,
-0.2414572984,
-0.158986643,
0.119604595,
0.5646567345,
0.5753833652,
-0.2734697759,
-0.9883896112,
0.6453365088,
-0.1090943217,
0.4478779435,
0.2762494683,
-0.6963878274,
-0.3713194728,
-0.2386724502,
-0.438006103,
0.9102311134,
-0.4789246023,
0.412741363,
0.1440903991,
-0.676861465,
-0.3943059742,
-0.0506876968,
0.2455710322,
0.3501244485,
0.5526661277,
-0.2902217209,
-0.1234994307,
-0.7242144346,
-0.2117011398,
-0.0212543029,
-0.1211028323,
0.501083076,
0.2202547044,
-0.1502833068,
0.7216976285,
-0.5191344619,
-0.4430302083,
-0.0547506474,
0.2901725769,
0.2222745121,
0.4238757789,
0.5629894137,
-0.8882594109,
-0.4364739656,
-0.3668509722,
-1.1505585909,
-0.0269141234,
-0.642793715,
-0.0992442146,
-0.2103668004,
0.3914900422,
-0.8787384629,
1.1548784971,
-0.1923194975,
0.1238120347,
0.3718151152,
0.0699885786,
0.1135143489,
-0.3903466463,
0.2785438895,
-0.1533028185,
0.3034771681,
-0.810608089,
-0.2138869166,
-0.5894321799,
-0.4330917895,
-0.4616608024,
0.1878516525,
-0.1339552552,
0.0763721839,
-0.3192638159,
-0.0486601591,
-0.2742180824,
0.4290584624,
-0.5405059457,
0.5332024097,
0.4898619056,
-0.5679664612,
0.4999903142,
0.3576529324,
0.0843078345,
0.1326628923,
-0.5146516562,
-0.2903535068,
-0.546551466,
-0.0052705063,
-1.2795678377,
-0.5209087729,
0.5009785295,
-0.6268450022,
-0.2562341988,
0.5567459464,
-0.1869456172,
-0.6869930029,
-0.5610099435,
0.297713995,
0.5659757257,
0.6488422155,
0.7512417436,
0.1876710057,
-0.7562875152,
-0.2668745816,
-0.7119675279,
-0.111965172,
-0.3428794146,
-0.1942579746,
0.3626191914,
-0.5460669994,
-0.5118371844,
-0.0820371434,
-0.0993682221,
0.1464641243,
0.2775130868,
0.9611130357,
-0.0734237581,
0.1503939778,
0.1273752451,
0.1088870466,
-0.1082222462,
0.491029948,
0.478685379,
0.6919667721,
0.5610640049,
-0.5191130042,
-0.9553346038,
0.5274914503,
0.7039105296,
0.3972943425,
0.5302410722,
0.2354723215,
-0.2290843278,
0.0240284838,
-0.5074608922,
0.2089872807,
-0.4573677182,
0.0580149479,
0.2312887311,
-0.4241452515,
0.6520082355,
-0.2500669956,
-0.0697789937,
0.3611271679,
0.6225011945,
-0.4024836421,
0.8982964754,
0.7369012833,
-0.1689702868,
0.3686189651,
-0.0277406313,
0.559540391,
-0.2734940052,
-0.3085873127,
-0.057739716,
-0.5948380232,
-0.7277130485,
-0.2488247454,
0.6499337554,
0.0594605953,
-0.5708312392,
-0.2639545202,
-0.4005987644,
0.3709433377,
0.6963127851,
0.332282871,
0.1219857186,
-0.259170264,
0.2839835286,
0.3135662377,
-0.4170043468,
-0.1595430672,
0.9104142785,
-0.0171496086,
0.516579628,
0.0242791809,
1.1295354366,
0.8556262851,
0.1554678082,
-0.5740229487,
0.5364078879,
-0.1401672661,
-0.5892525315,
-0.652374506,
-0.3706316352,
-0.5164719224,
-0.8393309712,
0.1885240823,
-0.9127491117,
0.369235307,
-0.0160145704,
-1.0776288509,
-0.2880462408,
-0.5606190562,
0.5796211362,
-0.7146086693,
-0.3505561948,
-0.2799311876,
-1.0218034983,
0.7779098749,
-0.3414144814,
0.3738025129,
-0.3957912028,
0.3227029443,
0.5921519399,
-0.3005580604,
0.7709852457,
-0.0643403456,
0.26136446,
0.409789443,
0.2145982981,
0.372867763,
0.199011296,
-0.4713308513,
-0.0259062797,
-0.2384903133,
-0.4175561666,
-0.3437472582,
0.6537227631,
-1.0817532539,
-0.4461083114,
-0.4952396452,
-0.9463540912,
0.138227284,
0.1856764704,
0.4160960615,
-0.1791098714,
0.0287471153,
-0.0258298423,
0.3314441144,
-0.61153543,
0.707288444,
0.1150667146,
-0.1583117992,
-0.3238011599,
1.046807766,
0.1914480776,
0.3154368103,
0.0074207247,
-0.0508407541,
0.1806832254,
-0.1593913287,
0.0742005557,
0.2293257713,
-0.2908809781,
-0.185908407,
-0.9190719724,
-0.3719773591,
-0.4142845571,
-0.2277054489,
-0.2266838253,
-0.339530319,
-0.6313890219,
-0.0617691763,
0.4982544184,
0.9680634737,
-0.3302993178,
0.2596026957,
-0.5839580297,
0.6094660163,
0.3181952238,
-0.0237198863,
0.1261887699,
0.1538701653,
0.0151440855,
0.018284535,
-0.6171748042,
-1.0680549145,
0.3936965466,
0.362059027,
0.6108676195,
0.9040452838,
0.571144104,
0.8510336876,
-0.0470337383,
0.9994159341,
-0.0697495639,
-0.3490824997,
0.3629238605,
-0.4346590042,
-0.2341882139,
0.6907671094,
1.1657674313,
-0.5666249394,
-0.4480769634,
-0.7762104273,
-0.8733816147,
0.708701849,
0.2996187508,
-0.0142063582,
0.1493740529,
0.4910104871,
0.2668193877,
0.3707526326,
-0.8132506609,
-0.7592724562,
-0.3111412823,
-0.145760119,
0.0280504003,
-0.2782252729,
-0.2577937841,
-0.1183114126,
0.5422341824,
0.0847534165,
0.5377533436,
0.0951209888,
0.1467245668,
-0.9179873466,
-0.3723843098,
0.5273628831,
0.4588859677,
-0.4489652514,
-0.3542070091,
-0.1634767801,
-0.1760088205,
0.1405261159,
0.4936073422,
-0.5561574697,
-0.2145765722,
0.5439866185,
0.3509894013,
-0.3282203376,
-1.0831763744,
0.4678111672,
-0.050807938,
-0.1512080133,
-0.9459257126,
0.7011496425,
-0.095435746,
0.2485609353,
0.693423152,
0.2579529583,
0.3873718381,
-0.7000842094,
0.2777442932,
0.5072214007,
-0.3367068768,
-0.2852719426,
0.4654220045,
-0.1310728639,
-0.9278402925,
0.5127270222,
-0.420012027,
-0.34531039,
0.6847782731,
-0.141648218,
0.7813977003,
-0.1459405273,
0.720852077,
0.3101890981,
0.1961326748,
0.0663090348,
0.5416694283,
0.1216935813,
-0.0256916657,
-0.0717361495,
-0.7318242788,
-0.3179247081,
0.494802624,
-0.5958781838,
0.2200716883,
-0.3349467218,
0.0390898809,
-0.2515031993,
-0.1299215406,
-0.4488897622,
0.3657812476,
0.3604578078,
0.4989748299,
-0.9587107897,
-0.0313152224,
0.4622147083,
-0.79351753,
-0.5610758066,
0.7353739142,
0.2086775005,
-0.5009810328,
0.5126237869,
0.6000455022,
0.2501699328,
0.1533776671,
-0.6309736371,
-1.2864587307,
0.9925556183,
-0.0035943442,
0.0047751451,
-0.1642295569,
0.6608232856,
0.6312462091,
-0.1884773523,
0.3037400544,
0.2021394819,
0.5846841931,
-0.095181413,
-0.4536647201,
-0.0298989173,
-0.5405682325,
-0.2047794312,
0.0074795298,
-0.8468574882,
0.9720119834,
-0.4014994204,
-0.2962003648,
0.2322898954,
0.3530189395,
0.0131809702,
0.9195841551,
0.3016172349,
0.9101418257,
0.3895660043,
0.4180080593,
0.5579595566,
-0.3312734962,
0.0892545953,
0.5367805362,
-0.4393072426,
0.5038498044,
0.4891966879,
0.0004734667,
0.6602515578,
0.7396287322,
0.0389478803,
0.5687417984,
0.2068219334,
-0.237435326,
-0.5418196321,
-0.188301906,
-0.1905088872,
0.2726377845,
0.5224605203,
-0.3120509386,
-0.3796168566,
0.6289382577,
-0.2356907576,
-0.2822597027,
0.1126192734,
0.7866407633,
0.0396337658,
-0.8356478214,
0.2180580348,
-0.4683527052,
0.2108111233,
-0.404620558,
-0.0931760594,
-0.0600749776,
0.1097382233,
-0.0679424629,
-0.6780895591,
0.3923538029,
-0.2077029347,
-0.0956410244,
-0.0425711535,
0.5983788371,
-0.0639160126,
-0.5963004827,
0.2669382691,
0.628326416,
0.3281614184,
-0.3058178723,
-0.7482731938,
-0.2333647013,
0.1109038442,
-0.4643697739,
0.5220294595,
0.7521951795,
0.0385198854,
1.1222445965,
0.9303349853,
-0.030081084,
-0.0420465469,
-0.6081537604,
1.0744736195,
-1.013728857,
-0.2403617203,
-0.6887773275,
0.732049346,
0.0304782949,
-0.5444436073,
0.6051299572,
0.5679165721,
0.5039575696,
-0.2686363161,
0.9118451476,
-0.6734181643,
0.6466477513,
-0.2042987496,
1.0041267872,
-0.8179830909,
0.0753605589,
-0.1688837558,
-0.5187531114,
-0.195156917,
0.1842726171,
-0.5758690238,
0.0498226956,
0.8018454313,
0.7508760691,
0.3744981885,
-0.3540814817,
0.1806104332,
0.3324626386,
0.0874073729,
0.4917165935,
0.7523436546,
-0.2397913635,
0.4225405753,
-0.8744324446,
-0.2831297517,
-0.7169729471,
-0.520585835,
-1.1463376284,
-0.5228415728,
-0.3288097978,
-0.0182340443,
0.2250775695,
0.7918686271,
-0.2073209435,
-0.3842629492,
0.0417547151,
-0.2987693846,
0.1240916923,
-0.4084472656,
-0.2936618626,
0.3137277961,
-0.4518539011,
-0.1467600763,
0.1701058745,
0.4441272318,
-0.0482030474,
-0.2074901611,
0.123354353,
-0.4619389772,
-0.0799560323,
0.1922243387,
0.3769387901,
-0.7765965462,
-0.0487512872,
-0.0860918313,
-0.0799550414,
-0.2221964449,
0.594946444,
-0.7616891861,
-0.1046876311,
0.6758506894,
0.208394587,
-0.3703628182,
0.4989655614,
0.3222364485,
-0.4680002034,
-0.0538435727,
0.504229784,
-0.1549636722,
-0.0494812578,
-1.3061523438,
0.4019967914,
0.486389339,
-0.8817474246,
-0.9719624519,
-0.0405635498,
-1.0013084412,
-0.3109461069,
0.7107800245,
0.0183814075,
-0.3507939279,
-0.2986271977,
-0.2509362102,
0.3564759791,
-0.5233968496,
1.352098465,
0.6345150471,
-0.7004891634,
-0.1144763902,
-0.9679707885,
0.9314850569,
0.3862996399,
-0.6996857524,
0.0582395531,
0.4782164097,
-0.1133446544,
0.4760654271,
0.2961215675,
0.5725505948,
0.6648525596,
-0.1640910059,
-0.0843006968,
-0.114389956,
-0.244786337,
0.2463301718,
0.40054214,
-0.4319399893,
0.2729129493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14052v1
|
Differential contributions of machine learning and statistical analysis to language and cognitive sciences
| 2024-04-22T10:06:21 | 2024-04-22T10:06:21 |
Kun Sun, Rong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, stat.ME
|
Data-driven approaches have revolutionized scientific research. Machine
learning and statistical analysis are commonly utilized in this type of
research. Despite their widespread use, these methodologies differ
significantly in their techniques and objectives. Few studies have utilized a
consistent dataset to demonstrate these differences within the social sciences,
particularly in language and cognitive sciences. This study leverages the
Buckeye Speech Corpus to illustrate how both machine learning and statistical
analysis are applied in data-driven research to obtain distinct insights. This
study significantly enhances our understanding of the diverse approaches
employed in data-driven strategies.
|
[
-0.041933056,
-1.5140533447,
0.4529345036,
0.2409671098,
0.3922036886,
0.4180370271,
-0.2929518819,
-0.234565109,
0.2178454846,
0.4583776891,
-0.8593774438,
-0.3406841159,
-0.4472407997,
0.1800295115,
-0.4090996385,
0.7665564418,
0.2951073647,
0.6665681005,
-0.3690322638,
-0.1080505401,
-0.6614881754,
-0.5823577642,
-0.5925706029,
-0.2407973856,
0.3113301992,
0.5982103348,
0.6715692282,
0.6110465527,
0.771053791,
0.3023886383,
0.4008090794,
-0.3269779086,
-0.4681962132,
0.3025152683,
-0.151369065,
-0.6977876425,
-0.1802717894,
0.1637779474,
0.9215278625,
1.4295793772,
-0.047861442,
0.1043652147,
0.0383004099,
1.0352401733,
-0.5259714723,
0.7764088511,
-0.7331485748,
0.0749371424,
-0.62084198,
-0.3138769269,
-0.4426665008,
-0.5746105909,
0.2436179519,
-0.6187928319,
0.3942115009,
-0.1577969491,
0.4007101655,
0.2712544203,
-0.2797535956,
-0.5536550283,
-0.8911297321,
1.4255324602,
-0.2358284891,
0.3157028556,
0.4479984045,
0.2821539938,
-0.4407126904,
-0.3746816516,
-0.5074833632,
-0.1141651422,
0.154105112,
-0.0400306918,
-0.4599205256,
-0.3137304783,
0.1088524908,
0.1143371314,
-0.6416037083,
0.4475619197,
-0.6784071922,
-0.1916906536,
0.82897681,
0.6401259899,
0.2557864189,
0.0957940817,
0.3008442521,
-0.3777439296,
-0.3747630417,
0.272715807,
0.1983633637,
0.6510233879,
0.1126896366,
0.631495595,
-0.5455796719,
0.5992217064,
-0.3353285789,
-0.0521382689,
0.4150332212,
-0.2614217401,
-0.2174426019,
0.1870179772,
0.8739717007,
0.1805835366,
0.3742101789,
-0.1521316469,
0.1479288042,
0.6391826868,
0.0179384276,
-0.4827730358,
-0.3389706314,
0.1115306616,
-0.4033941627,
-0.59014678,
-0.0233004615,
-1.1336610317,
-0.2365182638,
-0.5169525146,
-0.0650923401,
-0.3360100389,
-0.1983458102,
0.0283770412,
-0.3557745814,
0.1714366227,
0.0255974717,
-0.9712977409,
0.6887694001,
0.7931426764,
0.69663167,
-0.486692369,
-0.1517143846,
-0.3866989017,
-0.0609022602,
-0.7967435122,
0.7867254019,
-1.0625874996,
-0.3918154538,
0.2147017717,
-0.0953938738,
-0.1146089137,
-0.6300138831,
0.1932447255,
-0.5162679553,
0.2247995436,
-0.4180327654,
-0.4714762866,
-0.5699819326,
-0.3956263065,
-0.7268306613,
0.9809008241,
0.021558512,
-0.5461935997,
1.0037264824,
-0.7748824358,
-0.7121009827,
0.1020049676,
-0.534460783,
-0.6479735374,
0.1984577179,
-0.0503770784,
0.6318916082,
-0.2386268377,
0.2880126834,
-0.69966501,
-0.1933026016,
0.6400613785,
-0.3955160081,
1.2487268448,
0.4127220809,
-0.438119024,
-0.135328725,
-1.0369648933,
0.0462865382,
0.3822383881,
-0.1241119206,
-0.3465329111,
0.3969228864,
0.0490399823,
-0.299310565,
-0.0716556609,
-0.5214393139,
0.1114317179,
-0.0607784614,
0.470195204,
0.5575065017,
-0.1390807331,
0.5114617944,
-0.2613134384,
0.3122260273,
-0.1060929298,
-0.0979380906,
0.2440349758,
-0.4362196326,
-0.3213461637,
-0.4584100544,
0.1699848771,
0.9270094633,
-0.5511668921,
0.1762838513,
-0.2087024152,
-0.5569932461,
-0.6282023191,
0.0282726493,
-0.126552999,
0.6762719154,
0.3123983145,
-0.295425415,
-0.6830079556,
-0.6608259082,
-0.2224425673,
-0.2974948287,
0.178263247,
0.2906866372,
0.3025681376,
-0.3541289568,
1.277592659,
-0.5967656374,
-0.1973853707,
-0.156059593,
0.2566944063,
0.1305090487,
0.4392070174,
0.5835499763,
-0.7219743729,
-0.2919593453,
-0.1269887537,
-1.1839385033,
-0.3246271014,
-0.0165067893,
0.0616925359,
0.3350434601,
0.175184384,
-0.0922850966,
0.7756773233,
0.3552431464,
-0.1774276495,
0.4911642373,
0.0216929186,
0.4898643792,
-0.6409091353,
-0.1442398131,
0.0421945155,
0.209559828,
-0.9401496053,
-0.527256906,
-0.1837048978,
0.0032319315,
0.0125857703,
-0.013030272,
-0.2500388622,
-0.236056447,
-0.2990555465,
-0.2604685426,
-0.3637899756,
-0.0738636851,
0.2403627485,
0.6058646441,
1.0213896036,
-0.8925440311,
0.5272958279,
0.20038791,
-0.3522142768,
0.2902758121,
-0.7059352398,
0.0750256777,
-0.1706688702,
0.0049573369,
-1.1587941647,
-0.2963693142,
0.2764847577,
-0.7186653614,
0.041400373,
0.2458417714,
-0.3873495758,
-0.1661585867,
-0.2577587664,
0.1049278602,
0.4214009643,
0.0446659774,
0.0913907588,
0.8144671917,
-0.635407865,
-0.3047486544,
-1.1399793625,
-0.1202634797,
-0.4970088303,
-0.619810462,
0.0769514889,
0.0077914856,
-0.9843271971,
-0.0567514449,
0.3846797049,
-0.4461399317,
0.3426077962,
0.1914577782,
0.6492472291,
-0.473315239,
0.4147320986,
0.0159960873,
-0.043277815,
0.2872377038,
-0.0918471441,
0.41733706,
0.1098387986,
-0.121405825,
-0.7045097351,
0.5872058868,
0.3882473707,
0.0137616415,
0.7411839962,
0.3407167792,
-0.0817826465,
0.0733389035,
-0.4091700912,
-0.4611723423,
-0.3614169657,
0.4325682223,
-0.1955366135,
-0.7240238786,
0.2384530008,
0.1851365268,
0.1417514086,
0.2983160615,
0.5918499827,
-0.2771410346,
0.9124557376,
0.6708260179,
-0.3573189378,
0.7135391831,
-0.048299972,
0.0775288343,
-0.282544136,
0.0747519732,
-0.9434384108,
0.046415057,
-0.9761266112,
-0.108426407,
0.0765213147,
-0.3789938688,
0.0939778984,
-0.0321398601,
-0.4620063901,
-0.1227672771,
0.4534318149,
-0.222810775,
0.1865774393,
0.3881453276,
0.1430820972,
-0.2673262656,
-0.7055448294,
-0.7294518948,
1.4851851463,
0.18747814,
0.7759069204,
-0.0729241967,
0.5612320304,
0.5184159279,
-0.1229521409,
-0.887840867,
0.4835985601,
0.033724688,
-0.7690632343,
-0.5631314516,
-0.7396785617,
-1.3405845165,
0.1781135499,
-0.4617398977,
-0.7712256908,
0.1992361844,
-0.0049943645,
0.160374105,
-0.1126604155,
-0.7692374587,
0.4099414945,
-0.0116908569,
-0.2818752527,
-0.3943740129,
-0.3863532245,
-0.0295766089,
-0.2152286768,
0.5645202398,
-0.0341012403,
0.2885059714,
1.2373819351,
0.0547254868,
0.7903395295,
-0.0668549836,
0.2141313404,
0.313334614,
0.0196728446,
0.0965924561,
0.0829623938,
-0.2316435277,
0.3801210225,
0.2909249365,
-0.6826407909,
-0.3456456363,
0.6882008314,
-0.5407344103,
-0.6191363335,
-0.559271574,
-0.8460176587,
-0.3535889387,
0.0041259695,
-0.0765117481,
0.3571550846,
-0.3848460913,
0.2793047726,
0.7549569011,
-0.0008727927,
0.6484334469,
0.7010493279,
-0.096452266,
-0.1332278997,
0.8735032082,
0.4243820906,
0.0716922283,
0.350910008,
0.3614238799,
-0.101297982,
-0.4000298381,
-0.010975603,
0.2067225873,
-0.4476921558,
0.4166092873,
-0.4787388742,
0.3378049433,
-1.016149044,
-0.1027706563,
-0.2308751196,
-0.4289525747,
-0.2689870894,
-0.102265805,
0.5243703127,
0.8314192295,
-0.193809405,
0.0407069959,
-0.2792004347,
0.2126424611,
0.1241739616,
-0.2237430811,
-0.1587491632,
0.1950178146,
0.0306479055,
0.2371823192,
-0.2252387553,
-1.0312519073,
0.316685915,
0.1418899447,
0.6988444924,
0.2370424569,
-0.1612232924,
0.6407635212,
-0.4672287107,
0.7961006165,
0.0130998529,
-0.6627240181,
0.8221491575,
-0.0905922204,
0.0145724341,
0.4592208564,
0.3905513585,
-0.2031797469,
-0.2414339483,
-0.5616480112,
-0.4929526746,
0.629909873,
0.2025776953,
-0.1643324494,
0.0962478369,
-0.11338301,
0.5037997365,
0.0367782898,
-0.0069186436,
-0.3903627098,
0.0618391559,
-0.281938076,
-0.3982082307,
0.3370233476,
-0.0857683644,
-0.3665974736,
0.6268846989,
-0.1970491111,
0.2328456193,
0.1272004247,
-0.0552257895,
0.1318900138,
0.3182677627,
0.3194162548,
0.9699400663,
0.0938341469,
-0.2023097873,
0.0085499082,
-0.8539820313,
-0.1224946752,
0.1714784056,
-0.2703773677,
0.174592182,
0.4370216727,
0.5745566487,
-0.0737582073,
-0.6958628893,
-0.0729582012,
-0.0897831768,
-0.3159435391,
-0.3548187912,
0.055122532,
-0.300870806,
0.1750256419,
0.669041276,
-0.0222301241,
0.3412587345,
-0.9541597366,
0.3143599033,
0.5636626482,
-0.5516059399,
-0.2212103456,
0.2526915371,
-0.2850415111,
-0.0201630071,
0.7818002701,
0.4736319184,
-0.048573453,
0.6180856228,
0.3655129075,
0.5260519981,
0.0053819865,
0.4524647593,
-0.1019411907,
-0.1213074401,
0.3414737582,
0.3476919532,
-0.2623290122,
-0.5758541822,
-0.2251529545,
-0.358017534,
-0.2494676113,
-0.0290100425,
-1.1178030968,
0.209803611,
-0.2130877078,
-0.3723831177,
0.6833496094,
0.3027723432,
-0.8522560596,
0.2148971558,
-0.1561829448,
0.3699998558,
-1.0460377932,
0.7790709138,
0.742053628,
-0.3340235353,
-0.469976306,
-0.2275716066,
0.4157889187,
-0.7908608913,
1.0845299959,
-0.231315136,
-0.1246833652,
-0.152120173,
-0.6815826297,
-0.5979611874,
0.8972150087,
-0.0307001173,
-0.3198835254,
0.479310751,
0.3546537161,
0.4390158057,
-0.511364162,
0.0665112287,
0.790487349,
0.3034285903,
-0.0815144926,
-0.8372237682,
-0.2394911349,
0.214258045,
0.0081137437,
0.0593215972,
-0.2169185877,
0.8114600778,
-0.2011356652,
-0.2843344808,
-0.2445278317,
0.8251630068,
0.3999281228,
0.7886801958,
0.0771942511,
0.2659845352,
1.1068525314,
-0.0799534619,
0.5798631907,
0.2836694121,
0.3900821805,
0.6913403273,
-0.5080062151,
0.8037947416,
0.7903898954,
-0.6392434835,
0.5116307735,
0.5463641882,
-0.1301762164,
0.5465066433,
0.275377661,
-0.1306366324,
0.174133569,
-0.0141439568,
-0.1731500328,
0.5858018398,
0.6656503081,
-0.2973089516,
0.1218963936,
0.1997687817,
0.1493900418,
0.1626319289,
-0.2826914191,
0.9811668396,
-0.1155998334,
-0.4074078202,
0.3015567064,
-0.5285462141,
0.4126730263,
-0.5553284883,
-0.1572582275,
0.073427245,
0.1982391179,
-0.2645808756,
-0.963775754,
0.5376013517,
0.0996650979,
-0.3742688894,
-0.0449818596,
0.4945789576,
0.0280111022,
-0.610845685,
0.0565778613,
0.411703676,
0.3589247763,
0.3244158924,
-0.5271433592,
0.3101830482,
0.0778095126,
0.0945777446,
0.1759552211,
0.4621845484,
-0.2705709338,
0.8344613314,
0.6956151724,
0.3734899163,
0.3239670992,
-0.0714764744,
0.5958111882,
-0.8219598532,
-0.3223938346,
-1.0129734278,
0.1831856072,
-0.1537017077,
-0.1551406384,
0.8850487471,
0.5379251242,
0.9297819138,
-0.1547757387,
1.131922245,
-0.3006347418,
0.7513386011,
-0.6116552949,
0.5090810657,
-0.0647510216,
0.0358677432,
-0.4880245626,
-0.6856597662,
-0.3240044713,
0.5447854996,
-0.6859748363,
-0.1724469364,
0.6871168613,
0.7326413393,
0.3785923123,
0.2294335663,
0.1647520363,
0.0334772691,
0.4553611875,
0.2469993383,
0.7167141438,
-0.3566484451,
0.1592977941,
-0.3264881372,
-0.7622844577,
-0.144971475,
-0.4380161464,
-0.7948752642,
-0.9717053771,
-0.5524175167,
0.0659160316,
0.1021032631,
0.4743152559,
0.7070074081,
-0.9711184502,
-0.5374395251,
-0.2180282474,
-0.0818466842,
-0.4117696881,
-0.4163102806,
0.148884207,
-0.6312003136,
-0.6565871239,
0.4246128201,
0.1508610845,
-0.1178451106,
-0.2726849318,
0.2014967054,
-0.0855969787,
0.1572093666,
0.4838950932,
0.3246507049,
-0.5487418175,
0.1162630767,
0.1828250885,
-0.0619189404,
0.0633635074,
0.8636816144,
-0.927701354,
0.4731065631,
0.7419476509,
0.6110010147,
0.1862038374,
-0.2448086888,
0.7326855063,
-0.0288449377,
0.0925868526,
0.3375346065,
0.150559485,
0.3387348652,
-0.441049546,
0.3985635638,
0.4010221958,
-0.8026632667,
-0.5606754422,
0.1099471152,
-0.904620409,
-0.4788393974,
0.9196490049,
0.2234274745,
-0.3513207436,
-0.3103632927,
-0.1391715705,
0.2745605707,
-0.661275208,
0.9237132668,
1.1030216217,
-0.6947365403,
0.0484505855,
-1.0083868504,
0.3499227166,
0.434550941,
-0.6824947596,
0.0114139467,
0.494748652,
0.3414969444,
0.106893532,
0.2191364467,
-0.2188147157,
0.1200958267,
0.0933161974,
-0.3616577387,
0.4496030211,
-0.1402682811,
-0.3618682623,
0.1705770791,
-0.2039136738,
-0.5509981513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14043v1
|
LLMs Know What They Need: Leveraging a Missing Information Guided Framework to Empower Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-22T09:56:59 | 2024-04-22T09:56:59 |
Keheng Wang, Feiyu Duan, Peiguang Li, Sirui Wang, Xunliang Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) demonstrates great value in alleviating
outdated knowledge or hallucination by supplying LLMs with updated and relevant
knowledge. However, there are still several difficulties for RAG in
understanding complex multi-hop query and retrieving relevant documents, which
require LLMs to perform reasoning and retrieve step by step. Inspired by
human's reasoning process in which they gradually search for the required
information, it is natural to ask whether the LLMs could notice the missing
information in each reasoning step. In this work, we first experimentally
verified the ability of LLMs to extract information as well as to know the
missing. Based on the above discovery, we propose a Missing Information Guided
Retrieve-Extraction-Solving paradigm (MIGRES), where we leverage the
identification of missing information to generate a targeted query that steers
the subsequent knowledge retrieval. Besides, we design a sentence-level
re-ranking filtering approach to filter the irrelevant content out from
document, along with the information extraction capability of LLMs to extract
useful information from cleaned-up documents, which in turn to bolster the
overall efficacy of RAG. Extensive experiments conducted on multiple public
datasets reveal the superiority of the proposed MIGRES method, and analytical
experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed modules.
|
[
-0.5422540307,
-0.5411818624,
0.8558470011,
-0.0467798896,
-0.1399045736,
0.2752918005,
0.1541872621,
-0.3716832399,
0.2804220319,
0.5689414144,
-0.5970926881,
-0.4321013391,
-0.7702614665,
0.2177034318,
-0.5192294717,
0.9308140278,
0.0681359693,
-0.1905763745,
-0.4058578908,
0.241830945,
-0.5480342507,
-0.0622214936,
-0.6346251965,
-0.4334629476,
0.9194142222,
0.4879153669,
0.1227909327,
0.6913643479,
0.3992102742,
0.1197810546,
-0.4875589311,
0.8270215392,
-0.5791848898,
0.1659439206,
-0.3075307906,
-0.4249879718,
-0.3458767235,
-0.1024021953,
0.3614997566,
0.5695214868,
-0.0590914153,
0.298122257,
0.3245804608,
0.962109983,
-0.8426480889,
-0.0786868036,
-0.8528673053,
0.1159117445,
-0.1956975162,
-0.8945229053,
-0.5096313357,
-0.2716170549,
-0.078016758,
-0.7636111379,
0.3084073067,
0.322422117,
0.9346315861,
0.3668227792,
-0.4886292517,
-0.5556886792,
-0.7635028362,
0.6173397303,
-0.3476313353,
0.4868589938,
0.5718591213,
0.1136135012,
-0.5917313099,
-0.6648833156,
-0.272007674,
0.0318078287,
-0.2159896195,
0.1976143867,
0.0620631538,
-0.1571319401,
0.2485401481,
0.4074583054,
-0.3195621967,
-0.3242796659,
-0.3421949744,
0.0310632959,
0.2738669813,
-0.0381256714,
-0.0286318865,
-0.4896180928,
-0.5595502257,
0.252761662,
-0.8184757829,
-0.2069744915,
0.2160641998,
0.2387695312,
0.2564142048,
0.6541470885,
-0.2137027383,
0.9297627211,
0.2330814898,
-0.310986042,
0.0529013649,
-0.1161681637,
-0.0877393708,
-0.1687627286,
0.1918960959,
-0.0699209645,
-0.106220223,
-0.4290808737,
-0.569565177,
-0.4641707242,
0.3430214822,
-0.4566357732,
0.0995961055,
-0.1117805019,
-0.3605902791,
-0.2639489472,
-0.11251349,
-1.0536689758,
-0.6266633272,
-0.4581084847,
0.6639322639,
-0.386546582,
-0.2708590329,
-0.0892718211,
-0.5603355765,
0.3550160825,
0.4046657383,
-0.6857017279,
0.1381617188,
0.7570982575,
0.7099068165,
-0.2293142676,
0.0632538497,
-0.6779996157,
0.5686761141,
-0.2853222787,
1.1515171528,
-0.4513490498,
-0.374193579,
-0.1744763255,
-0.1468002796,
-0.0845922455,
-0.5363063216,
0.6092135906,
-0.7674286962,
0.2642070055,
-0.4682624936,
-0.7152005434,
-0.2624013126,
0.6288904548,
-0.5975234509,
1.0473499298,
0.1031531841,
-0.9487202764,
0.3877814114,
-0.4426347613,
-0.2678641081,
0.1535283029,
-0.3267007172,
-0.1937309206,
0.1274939924,
0.2608272731,
0.268404305,
-0.6194233894,
0.1985982955,
0.0882577524,
-0.5577414036,
-0.1711891443,
-0.3116574287,
0.5916162729,
0.2095145881,
-0.2178846896,
-0.3645985126,
-0.8734021783,
-0.0662022755,
0.179391712,
-0.8326596022,
-0.424148351,
0.1876156628,
-0.4685051441,
0.0695258081,
0.2572308183,
-0.5073671341,
0.1702896953,
-0.3010564446,
-0.2113608718,
0.8551817536,
0.4565498233,
0.4457477629,
-0.7063720226,
0.4589653909,
-0.1478338242,
-0.033262413,
-0.153740868,
-0.4386273921,
-0.9680224061,
-0.3146201074,
0.2428902835,
0.582339406,
-0.8888278604,
0.1983080804,
-0.0807106122,
-0.4554233551,
-0.4953819215,
0.2489242554,
0.3904773891,
0.9163589478,
0.4804134369,
0.2811391652,
-0.788307786,
-0.6622613072,
-0.635817945,
0.0141973011,
-0.0408022292,
0.4544425607,
0.2277253717,
-0.2807311416,
1.0353831053,
-0.5079398155,
-0.4167373478,
-0.3217871785,
0.172646746,
0.2882629633,
0.043862246,
-0.1098586321,
-1.1149529219,
-0.0485600531,
0.0534354039,
-0.9369484782,
-0.3655941486,
-0.0650258511,
-0.269731164,
0.0925904959,
0.4694104195,
-0.3889420331,
0.5384610891,
0.1709809005,
-0.1846625507,
0.4418925643,
-0.177004993,
0.1693948358,
-0.9625297785,
0.3246686757,
-0.1473589689,
-0.1941157281,
-0.3413210511,
-0.2237317264,
0.0185507443,
0.0735987425,
-0.2109275907,
0.8001257181,
-0.863835156,
-0.253203094,
-0.4935877919,
0.4102822542,
0.3991138041,
0.5831981897,
-0.2799000442,
0.7668771148,
0.212600559,
-0.9554125071,
-0.0916590989,
0.2532174289,
-0.0037288126,
0.436624378,
-0.1233075336,
0.1457497925,
-0.6289049387,
-0.0482344329,
-0.6859613657,
-0.2367715687,
0.2453324646,
-0.5916764736,
0.4051130414,
-0.4658889174,
-0.6032078266,
-0.167329669,
-0.0829088464,
0.0050140526,
0.4050090015,
-0.6784848571,
1.1616578102,
0.5075865984,
-0.0220062304,
-0.7654106021,
-0.2472994626,
0.00408069,
-0.2196516246,
-0.3569196463,
0.3741348982,
0.097840406,
-0.235071525,
0.1238003895,
-0.3320517838,
0.0759382918,
0.1448460817,
0.2442502975,
0.2927230299,
0.1758832037,
0.3166713715,
-0.001080182,
-0.2132431418,
-0.015542713,
-0.083779037,
0.4289607406,
0.1868056804,
-0.4080066681,
0.0177498758,
0.3544905484,
0.3475448191,
-0.1889496893,
0.3406723142,
0.6368958354,
-0.5202084184,
-0.1340673417,
-0.8279043436,
-0.0000380942,
-0.4591176212,
0.105332315,
-0.3141075373,
-0.7509550452,
0.253901422,
-0.4806618392,
0.1110333949,
0.4429751039,
0.3590584099,
-0.173097074,
0.8966264129,
0.7570427656,
0.1645426303,
0.3727696538,
-0.2737959921,
0.0682012662,
-1.1869456768,
-0.7913141847,
-0.4671896398,
-0.1831329167,
-0.275488019,
-0.2759159505,
0.5791562796,
0.283141911,
-0.0189341772,
0.0928454623,
-0.6259698272,
0.3672455847,
0.5909006,
0.22364676,
0.5195087194,
0.1033838093,
-0.3971329331,
0.1563848108,
-0.7280924916,
-0.4545371532,
0.9287168384,
-0.1412816793,
0.7336067557,
-0.0135383485,
0.9942581058,
0.4828219414,
0.2890377641,
-0.7264080644,
0.6348384023,
0.1062047407,
-0.5782772899,
0.0933737606,
-0.5874002576,
-1.1359788179,
0.3026557267,
-0.2849034667,
-0.4881825745,
0.1495760828,
0.0524611324,
-0.0954911336,
0.3694191873,
-0.5825741887,
0.3002272546,
-0.2955049574,
-0.3737697899,
-0.0297583677,
-0.4514879882,
0.3518981338,
-0.3061293364,
0.4577968419,
-0.1951440275,
-0.180626303,
0.7975449562,
-0.0974007919,
0.4345904589,
-0.3334855139,
0.0461578295,
0.4339282215,
0.0854699686,
0.6255966425,
-0.1348327696,
-0.0776846185,
-0.2343588322,
-0.3818006814,
-0.1267777085,
-0.6723438501,
0.7078811526,
-0.3394310176,
-0.9820554256,
-0.4487075806,
-0.5253500938,
-0.2673885524,
0.3694285154,
0.1944096237,
0.0896949172,
0.1125021055,
0.0055031031,
0.8824881315,
-0.073686555,
0.3193791807,
0.7229668498,
-0.3021318614,
-0.3564322591,
0.9369972348,
0.1547403336,
-0.1134167388,
0.5822782516,
0.1963755041,
-0.1370288134,
-0.3767407238,
-0.4310763776,
0.345231086,
-0.6406105757,
-0.481524229,
-0.8047657609,
-0.3056104183,
-0.210044384,
0.0147376144,
-0.0131590962,
-0.1855244488,
-0.5817133188,
0.0051538078,
0.3317316473,
0.8396890759,
-0.3168486357,
-0.0377518199,
-0.9523937702,
0.6376484632,
0.1592830569,
0.189473331,
0.0935622826,
-0.5303407311,
-0.2696637213,
-0.1270771176,
-0.4015419185,
-0.9848420024,
0.3896950483,
-0.0534628555,
0.882784009,
0.0829782262,
-0.1072793007,
0.824174583,
-0.4287821949,
0.3468948901,
-0.2753418982,
-0.5249570012,
0.8125808835,
-0.3407133222,
-0.0936276019,
0.3630748987,
0.2836274803,
-0.3058731258,
-0.2330230027,
-0.6908957362,
-1.0313999653,
0.5496003032,
0.1461524516,
-0.3655607998,
-0.1170459837,
0.5831908584,
-0.0406653322,
0.1307885498,
-0.4350453615,
-0.2347869277,
0.3689484596,
-0.0620798469,
0.5122520328,
-0.3807751238,
-0.0660972074,
0.0884148553,
0.8411505818,
0.259239763,
0.3875079155,
0.4963861406,
-0.0885332972,
-0.1701291054,
0.2628464103,
0.2426510006,
0.6347627044,
-0.3440253735,
0.1212488115,
0.0195920318,
-0.2997567654,
0.2279426754,
0.1576878428,
-0.3641878664,
0.1361983567,
0.0496370383,
0.421659857,
0.0545598865,
-0.727399528,
0.5116397142,
-0.0682912767,
-0.0636591092,
-0.618961215,
0.2120230347,
0.06358888,
0.3004063964,
0.9392287731,
0.1902832836,
0.1791372895,
-0.1240831539,
0.5017858148,
0.4292163849,
-0.204889223,
0.1109373122,
0.5171573758,
-0.0146870716,
-0.4444281459,
0.3046558201,
-0.2756457925,
-0.2724872828,
0.453933537,
0.5472450256,
0.637042284,
0.2084523886,
-0.062219318,
0.2399386466,
0.331200093,
-0.2513557673,
0.2210882306,
-0.2560977936,
-0.4263710082,
-0.5590898991,
-0.6353130937,
-0.2361703515,
0.1183559746,
-0.7081121802,
0.3819850087,
-0.3078858554,
-0.0696078464,
-0.3067716956,
0.0187155809,
-0.5455883145,
0.1942365766,
-0.0463069491,
1.0632553101,
-0.464692384,
0.3712831736,
0.3345931768,
-0.3589264154,
-0.8786634803,
0.112839669,
0.0259251278,
-0.89700073,
0.825309813,
0.0558466129,
-0.369001925,
0.3131916523,
-0.4298025668,
-1.1310175657,
1.3941193819,
0.2764995694,
-0.3488675654,
-0.2465989441,
-0.4046351612,
0.1884573698,
-0.1994345635,
-0.0177084059,
0.4693272114,
0.6084396839,
0.5934420824,
-0.3929895759,
-0.2038163543,
-0.245360747,
-0.3000101745,
0.4607801437,
-0.2697257102,
0.7125264406,
-0.2326176316,
-0.301536411,
0.0226047933,
0.5547176003,
0.5357499719,
0.569827199,
0.3879471421,
0.7213259935,
0.8875076175,
0.223459661,
1.0299953222,
-0.0808683857,
0.1083505675,
1.1278246641,
-0.0964581445,
0.7356699705,
0.6115391254,
0.3138580918,
0.5000234842,
0.4627649188,
0.0800343081,
0.5225717425,
0.0329448842,
-0.574000597,
-0.1326555461,
-0.352312535,
-0.1503865123,
0.3761315346,
0.5535939336,
-0.5355530381,
-0.3897301257,
0.0278815851,
0.1300307959,
-0.0775082335,
-0.4826839566,
1.0077592134,
-0.0707839504,
-0.7910370231,
0.6818240881,
-0.0368012041,
0.5507009625,
-0.4559271336,
-0.3639950752,
-0.4504437745,
0.0140524115,
-0.2892125547,
-0.6396443844,
0.3225427568,
0.2072270066,
-0.4195839167,
-0.2112638205,
1.2402734756,
-0.2699630857,
-0.3674308062,
0.4334094226,
0.9151961803,
0.3262707293,
-0.122693263,
-0.4012083411,
-0.2050007433,
0.1930293888,
-0.2581886351,
0.3042100668,
0.7379142046,
0.131924808,
0.8544439673,
0.6475064754,
0.3989756107,
0.064581573,
-0.103727974,
1.0463302135,
-0.7529354095,
-0.0930208415,
-0.7909824848,
0.3076406121,
-0.2421747893,
0.071414493,
0.7369816303,
0.7464211583,
0.6261304617,
0.1214408875,
0.7742583752,
-0.2069116235,
1.1207336187,
-0.5190159082,
0.5658976436,
-0.8442040086,
0.4432770908,
-0.1359172165,
-0.7872958183,
-0.2517147064,
0.3502047956,
-0.0454222634,
-0.0072176917,
0.4919229448,
0.9840644598,
0.1087330356,
-0.2706794739,
0.2837997973,
-0.1002109125,
0.2881213427,
0.5064578652,
0.9252440333,
-0.4365791678,
0.8846780062,
0.1886219382,
-0.2002435625,
-0.1039498225,
-0.8272153735,
-0.6770804524,
-0.4195990562,
0.1507706195,
-0.2391638458,
0.2700163424,
0.7465956211,
0.400039345,
-0.1321559846,
0.1477974802,
-0.2678486109,
0.5323489308,
0.0820757374,
-0.2207133919,
0.2312811166,
-0.569660604,
-0.5336624384,
0.6430330276,
0.4782939851,
0.197852686,
-0.0284916107,
-0.0168277193,
-0.6183809638,
0.015397816,
0.3461229503,
0.2574392557,
-0.5886933208,
-0.1072182804,
0.119436264,
-0.1494833529,
0.1754664928,
0.9403628111,
-1.1143478155,
0.2520880103,
0.4230667949,
0.9302283525,
0.5421447754,
0.1477921903,
0.2956651151,
-0.937661171,
-0.015027252,
0.4018917382,
0.3092916906,
0.423463285,
-0.5650900602,
0.6708106995,
0.398304075,
-0.6891275048,
-0.6400620341,
0.1626850963,
-0.6746824384,
-0.2254258394,
1.3221099377,
-0.0008627871,
-0.3694741726,
-0.3003309071,
-0.353661716,
0.4352911115,
-0.2678076029,
0.9496876001,
0.5091786385,
-0.2598285377,
-0.2480442375,
-0.5156818032,
0.4321145117,
0.341204077,
-0.7833783031,
-0.0220728237,
0.5947136283,
0.219548583,
0.2531311214,
0.7683371305,
-0.2535614967,
0.0058700126,
-0.1653815806,
-0.0823412165,
-0.315983057,
-0.4763188064,
0.1321834922,
0.2585753798,
0.132539317,
-0.1212332994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14024v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14024v1
|
Exploring neural oscillations during speech perception via surrogate gradient spiking neural networks
| 2024-04-22T09:40:07 | 2024-04-22T09:40:07 |
Alexandre Bittar, Philip N. Garner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Understanding cognitive processes in the brain demands sophisticated models
capable of replicating neural dynamics at large scales. We present a
physiologically inspired speech recognition architecture, compatible and
scalable with deep learning frameworks, and demonstrate that end-to-end
gradient descent training leads to the emergence of neural oscillations in the
central spiking neural network. Significant cross-frequency couplings,
indicative of these oscillations, are measured within and across network layers
during speech processing, whereas no such interactions are observed when
handling background noise inputs. Furthermore, our findings highlight the
crucial inhibitory role of feedback mechanisms, such as spike frequency
adaptation and recurrent connections, in regulating and synchronising neural
activity to improve recognition performance. Overall, on top of developing our
understanding of synchronisation phenomena notably observed in the human
auditory pathway, our architecture exhibits dynamic and efficient information
processing, with relevance to neuromorphic technology.
|
[
-0.2834591269,
-0.6792616844,
0.190305993,
0.220309034,
-0.1731678843,
0.0924043208,
-0.2643527985,
-0.6371963024,
0.5842667222,
0.0441253185,
-0.8022096157,
0.0415900499,
-0.392991364,
-0.256649524,
-0.5066433549,
0.7436051369,
0.3478214443,
0.3253611922,
-0.0087489346,
-0.1173740327,
-0.3541837633,
-0.3414013982,
-0.8331082463,
-0.814440012,
0.4081106186,
-0.3314609826,
0.3294670582,
0.5213295817,
-0.0040902579,
0.1358982921,
-0.4668062925,
-0.1696449518,
-0.2136517167,
0.5781719685,
-0.1164593026,
-0.439157486,
-0.21376656,
-0.2472267747,
0.5905601978,
0.9768311381,
-0.548142612,
-0.0190792345,
0.1685016304,
0.5337834954,
-0.4017262161,
0.2347166836,
-0.556434989,
0.399759084,
-0.22649315,
-0.4523466825,
-0.1229893193,
-0.0165842772,
0.3903530836,
-0.3202715218,
0.2435651124,
-0.3279198706,
0.2875423133,
0.3489659131,
0.0853865296,
-0.4257257879,
-0.4930654466,
0.1828947812,
-0.0746445879,
0.914829433,
0.1282069534,
0.1944677234,
-0.2477673739,
-0.9052926302,
-0.2591693997,
-0.320364356,
0.4334847331,
0.3406352103,
-0.1743390113,
0.0368214063,
0.3119980693,
0.3292377293,
-0.4677186608,
-0.2043240219,
-0.3857243657,
-0.2703337073,
0.1997677386,
0.0013758142,
0.2265557498,
0.4801309109,
-0.1914282441,
0.2187175304,
-0.2590966821,
0.3101867139,
0.2688641846,
0.1638151258,
-0.0708132461,
-0.1108230054,
-0.0047708126,
0.3630946577,
0.2358496487,
0.471588254,
0.4893116653,
0.0808941349,
-0.0443314351,
0.6579164863,
0.535923481,
0.1671756655,
0.029912129,
-0.4110402167,
-0.134010613,
0.1922482699,
0.3078589737,
-0.7195752859,
-0.3198388517,
0.048678562,
-0.3523594439,
-0.0131964041,
-0.5671488047,
-0.5078101158,
-0.5738998652,
-0.3566710651,
0.410990119,
-0.6020799279,
-0.4576190412,
0.5439965725,
-0.5187902451,
-0.203262046,
0.2403623462,
-1.3272736073,
0.4307682812,
0.5964682698,
0.8250246644,
0.093916662,
-0.6077384353,
-0.2607605457,
-0.1384796947,
-0.4562943578,
0.3644474745,
-0.3591804802,
-0.35627985,
-0.2044590861,
-0.3180044889,
0.1559136361,
-0.4794980586,
0.3716614842,
-0.4902296066,
-0.5965149403,
-0.3057229817,
-0.0741047487,
0.1690845042,
-0.2016430795,
-0.3520226777,
0.8471134901,
-0.2709018588,
-0.4597953856,
0.2579646707,
-0.5793995261,
-0.5517577529,
0.1932292134,
-0.4721012712,
-0.2908791602,
0.5956801176,
-0.1480554789,
0.1493939012,
-0.0967962593,
0.2047251314,
-0.0706751719,
-0.272544831,
0.4965269268,
-0.6042801142,
0.7829826474,
0.2338446677,
-0.5856161714,
0.1437027752,
-1.100672245,
-0.2853916287,
-0.0627052933,
-0.1934697032,
-0.1224780232,
0.2029580474,
-0.2138059288,
-0.0415961668,
0.1039599851,
-0.5543035865,
-0.22086142,
-0.3556424379,
1.011958003,
0.4999621212,
0.0495541357,
0.2728310823,
-0.1906157732,
0.0168336388,
0.0933915824,
0.0704823583,
-0.4377432466,
-0.5210407376,
-0.4599665105,
-0.1411158144,
-0.1495895684,
0.0336932354,
-0.2262030691,
0.1771965921,
-0.1807169169,
-0.5706961751,
-0.2865861058,
-0.4066940546,
0.0502854213,
0.8523218632,
0.4877590537,
-0.4929712713,
-0.5875810385,
-0.5463169813,
-0.2741689384,
0.0683683977,
-0.0010037818,
0.2086600959,
0.2549997568,
-0.1596562713,
0.6998260021,
-0.0050718174,
0.0987910032,
0.1767472029,
0.4590170383,
0.2803537846,
0.6755737066,
0.5204719305,
-0.4881085753,
0.077438347,
0.1169496179,
-0.4327611327,
-0.1803197414,
0.005225359,
0.1551215351,
-0.2765231133,
0.6012016535,
-0.5768131614,
0.5151628256,
0.0742049813,
0.1943227202,
0.3902743161,
0.0627878755,
-0.0121936565,
-0.6569530368,
-0.030096326,
-0.170463413,
0.0813454241,
-0.679867506,
-0.1069075167,
0.1067448556,
-0.1703545153,
-0.1354471594,
-0.0237238724,
-0.4030010402,
-0.2642019391,
-0.2988753021,
-0.0639895946,
-0.23502101,
0.4330098331,
0.2264280319,
0.6451386809,
1.1009689569,
-0.5906820297,
0.3402802646,
0.0079942802,
-0.3287406266,
0.5288681388,
-0.5837343335,
0.0053169862,
-0.4184218645,
0.2423291057,
-0.7634971738,
-0.0011835889,
-0.1244208664,
-1.0446534157,
0.2710689902,
-0.1084491909,
-0.1368020177,
0.0906905755,
-0.0107510779,
0.5082510114,
0.5618041158,
-0.628757298,
0.7878988385,
0.5491070151,
0.1960146427,
-0.5132697225,
-1.0854738951,
-0.0716661587,
0.2199562788,
-0.2339472324,
0.2489714473,
0.0761164278,
0.2368816882,
-0.4248018563,
-0.5371884704,
0.154166624,
0.2356361449,
0.6361162663,
-0.0987240747,
-0.2520808876,
0.1308488101,
-0.1368323863,
0.0981224552,
0.3628202081,
-0.6442349553,
0.9994303584,
-0.0065351161,
-0.273471117,
-1.0252920389,
-0.0099904714,
0.8394499421,
-0.3789994419,
0.3138834834,
0.7003962994,
-0.6539793611,
-0.41980353,
-0.0000154763,
-0.4547279179,
-0.516697824,
0.6710987091,
-0.2978311181,
-0.4698809087,
0.7043449879,
-0.1604711711,
-0.2723885775,
-0.0253070928,
0.6492726207,
-0.0876045078,
0.8751737475,
-0.0127003761,
0.0024252858,
0.8437079191,
-0.1093965024,
-0.0129651166,
-0.9455118179,
-0.4048894346,
-0.4258443713,
-0.4873638749,
-0.3228778243,
-0.1720020622,
0.2712399065,
0.1653470248,
-0.3854199052,
0.1136479899,
-0.6089676023,
0.3052054942,
0.2040536702,
0.2397514135,
-0.3672140837,
0.3080514967,
-0.5448430181,
-0.1016845331,
-0.6494922042,
0.2352149189,
0.7425343394,
0.436817646,
0.6930009127,
-0.3582521677,
0.4444788396,
0.1286514699,
0.0394329131,
-0.6675905585,
0.4804463685,
-0.0289317295,
-0.3147876263,
0.0060913968,
-0.2640063465,
-0.8026551604,
0.0398383103,
-0.4526934326,
-1.0452917814,
0.4482168853,
0.1822092533,
-0.702034831,
0.3522539139,
-0.1156699955,
0.1449431777,
-0.0868360475,
-0.6288223863,
-0.2953330874,
-0.5955374241,
-0.0747282356,
0.3921343684,
0.0948683843,
0.1849431098,
0.1700470299,
0.3349583447,
0.1901575178,
0.9163730741,
-0.2378952801,
0.0044759866,
0.0299308319,
0.1081972048,
0.0597761497,
0.111269176,
-0.2322309911,
0.4381697774,
-0.288185209,
-0.1164237708,
-0.5237460732,
0.8319029212,
-0.7883620262,
-0.3065029681,
-0.4459145069,
-0.7677702904,
-0.2943010628,
0.1387135237,
0.1372520775,
0.4921846092,
-0.1559955031,
0.4752011299,
0.7292886972,
0.3236870766,
0.4574692845,
0.0967005864,
-0.2702998221,
-0.6180614829,
0.6451141834,
0.4605959356,
0.2150274366,
0.1020754129,
0.0936151296,
-0.1489493251,
-0.7012403607,
-0.4834895432,
-0.2122230381,
-0.4862229228,
0.2473172843,
-0.6095532775,
-0.4367589355,
-0.2196203619,
0.1316349059,
-0.5028910637,
-0.3277025223,
-0.3481783867,
-0.1167246476,
0.1202777028,
0.5086439848,
-0.2235492021,
0.5077075362,
-0.498223871,
0.2625384927,
0.499019146,
0.5103785992,
0.4257248342,
-0.4853649735,
-0.3769001365,
0.2229182571,
-0.1893225312,
-0.8642514348,
0.2483477145,
0.3378576636,
0.5478206277,
0.4475391805,
-0.4507108629,
0.8820128441,
-0.7392835617,
0.8916850686,
0.5370895863,
-1.187284708,
0.360843122,
-0.1789852232,
0.1610128433,
0.2057240903,
0.332205683,
-0.5518533587,
0.2390019,
-0.3388095796,
-0.6975589395,
0.7589184046,
0.2709003091,
0.2335872501,
0.064989239,
0.7374117374,
-0.026437398,
0.5173913836,
-0.28652367,
-0.427354753,
-0.25064224,
0.0832557008,
0.0047583682,
0.1993992627,
-0.3379701078,
-0.2125310451,
0.3240914345,
-0.0184999853,
0.1934726983,
0.4279049635,
0.2445441782,
-0.386513561,
-0.2534577847,
0.730931282,
0.2515089512,
-0.0733143985,
0.226858303,
0.2460200638,
-0.7484292984,
-0.1403540671,
0.0513281859,
-0.0355939865,
0.2164588422,
-0.0113948574,
1.1637084484,
0.1113718674,
-0.2795518339,
0.3265542388,
-0.2277717441,
-0.0702808276,
-0.2056233436,
0.2326841354,
0.3585473895,
0.6098968387,
0.5936183333,
0.7868077755,
0.1379890144,
-0.7569438815,
0.1927397549,
0.534045279,
-0.5227596164,
-0.5736431479,
0.7712635994,
-0.1070252582,
-0.8018302321,
0.3583795726,
0.3515328765,
-0.556052804,
0.7363391519,
0.7041221261,
0.8234546781,
-0.5441875458,
-0.4070144296,
0.1541132331,
0.1273114532,
-0.1303437203,
0.5572474599,
-0.8859736919,
-0.7045209408,
0.1306040138,
-0.7695987821,
-0.1411094815,
-0.0175850894,
-0.9910299182,
0.2301402092,
-0.8758607507,
-0.5215919614,
0.577513814,
-0.5190963149,
-0.2197326273,
0.3328049183,
0.3895729482,
1.0372523069,
-0.5168225765,
0.768039465,
0.5833358169,
-0.253657639,
-0.3461590707,
0.0906209499,
-0.167239219,
-0.9542933106,
0.6757831573,
0.1651052535,
-0.6874799132,
0.0493428968,
-0.599406004,
-0.6878285408,
0.9759883285,
0.5502076149,
-0.7449964285,
0.2803105414,
0.1283601969,
0.792470932,
-0.2683625519,
0.3056220412,
0.5138486624,
-0.2469905913,
0.2468776852,
-0.8859719038,
-0.3251492381,
-0.2698297799,
-0.1381728351,
0.1524367183,
-0.6355371475,
1.012988925,
0.1342431754,
-0.2003622353,
0.1258843839,
0.584474504,
0.4888724089,
0.5569210052,
0.42738235,
0.6802624464,
0.6155306101,
-0.1211851388,
0.3932816684,
-0.7451676726,
0.1622812003,
0.9678955674,
-0.3389207721,
0.8412073851,
0.8080661893,
-0.0796376094,
0.2799829245,
0.3948352337,
0.3721036613,
0.5106282234,
0.5100406408,
-0.389354825,
-0.2222736627,
-0.1970641166,
-0.7860613465,
0.1592624336,
0.8083873391,
-0.5788885355,
0.0318485573,
0.0777858049,
-0.4664508998,
0.014953292,
-0.6878085732,
0.4020331502,
0.2829552889,
-0.2929507494,
0.5860952735,
-0.7052268386,
0.6290282011,
-0.8247796893,
0.0235576443,
0.0465852171,
-0.0445431396,
-0.3251113594,
-0.5644090772,
0.3478417397,
-0.4026885331,
-0.2662611008,
-0.2733988166,
0.3762769699,
-0.139772132,
0.139699921,
0.6255525947,
-0.0617719181,
0.0991066545,
0.1338058114,
-0.3484406769,
0.2704983652,
-0.3561950624,
-0.0321704671,
0.3540863097,
0.3978061974,
0.2674568295,
0.5483224988,
0.9544671178,
0.3677299023,
0.4448179603,
0.1662534922,
0.7559272051,
-0.4881879985,
-0.9390462637,
-0.8068329692,
0.2103999108,
0.0023821227,
-0.331543386,
0.2550872266,
0.4478836358,
0.7653264403,
-0.0401421525,
0.4775975645,
0.289506048,
0.1712125838,
-0.2053662241,
1.0280529261,
-0.5020341277,
0.201077044,
0.2292772979,
-0.4260505438,
-0.4106582403,
0.5488929749,
-0.0592802092,
-0.1313724816,
0.3442572653,
0.8009856343,
-0.0136876162,
0.7189658284,
0.6425756216,
0.4004774988,
-0.1232048944,
0.308860302,
0.9362006187,
-0.3250442445,
0.0808833987,
-0.2053517401,
-0.121909298,
-0.0305983722,
-0.4700046778,
-0.6114592552,
-0.7053485513,
-0.2180039734,
-0.4863983393,
0.3686168492,
1.1126093864,
0.9642732739,
-0.7799765468,
-0.3551277816,
-0.8154457808,
-0.322943598,
-0.4592497945,
-0.1879948825,
0.0261603221,
-0.4203784466,
-0.5558702946,
0.7049716115,
0.6468410492,
-0.0102059878,
-0.1801586598,
0.0211505536,
0.0324239247,
0.1335565299,
0.228866905,
0.5331296921,
-0.425363183,
0.127320841,
0.0068415725,
0.0230872966,
0.1921363026,
0.7775880098,
-0.7634173632,
0.5609109998,
0.6758069396,
0.8604768515,
0.519317627,
-0.503752172,
0.2963749468,
-0.5263071656,
0.1829922795,
0.42674312,
0.5062322617,
0.0518792346,
-0.3551911116,
-0.0191618428,
0.3501439393,
-0.5982442498,
-1.0590113401,
0.3969338834,
-0.9134494066,
0.1169690117,
0.3947632611,
-0.1984744221,
-0.54936409,
0.0031676933,
-0.2295888066,
0.603061676,
-0.4529120922,
0.8120578527,
0.5195971727,
-0.6486067772,
-0.180491522,
-0.4394727647,
0.6501051188,
0.6143906713,
-0.1470033079,
0.0902298316,
0.2366092205,
0.3969780505,
0.5649063587,
0.147947818,
0.0582794659,
0.6585662365,
0.288289845,
-0.0227419063,
-0.0154342903,
-0.3183794618,
-0.8958954811,
0.4930755198,
-0.2202260345,
-0.735914886
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14464v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14464v1
|
Tree of Reviews: A Tree-based Dynamic Iterative Retrieval Framework for Multi-hop Question Answering
| 2024-04-22T09:25:05 | 2024-04-22T09:25:05 |
Li Jiapeng, Liu Runze, Li Yabo, Zhou Tong, Li Mingling, Chen Xiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Multi-hop question answering is a knowledge-intensive complex problem. Large
Language Models (LLMs) use their Chain of Thoughts (CoT) capability to reason
complex problems step by step, and retrieval-augmentation can effectively
alleviate factual errors caused by outdated and unknown knowledge in LLMs.
Recent works have introduced retrieval-augmentation in the CoT reasoning to
solve multi-hop question answering. However, these chain methods have the
following problems: 1) Retrieved irrelevant paragraphs may mislead the
reasoning; 2) An error in the chain structure may lead to a cascade of errors.
In this paper, we propose a dynamic retrieval framework called Tree of
Reviews (ToR), where the root node is the question, and the other nodes are
paragraphs from retrieval, extending different reasoning paths from the root
node to other nodes. Our framework dynamically decides to initiate a new
search, reject, or accept based on the paragraphs on the reasoning paths.
Compared to related work, we introduce a tree structure to handle each
retrieved paragraph separately, alleviating the misleading effect of irrelevant
paragraphs on the reasoning path; the diversity of reasoning path extension
reduces the impact of a single reasoning error on the whole. We conducted
experiments on three different multi-hop question answering datasets. The
results show that compared to the baseline methods, ToR achieves
state-of-the-art performance in both retrieval and response generation. In
addition, we propose two tree-based search optimization strategies, pruning and
effective expansion, to reduce time overhead and increase the diversity of path
extension. We will release our code.
|
[
-0.3336412609,
-1.2592380047,
0.7505599856,
0.2990740836,
-0.2993215621,
0.9614829421,
0.237828657,
-0.5438916683,
0.3675396442,
0.1444335878,
-0.7299922109,
-0.231266737,
-0.4349048138,
0.2114023566,
-0.4510315359,
0.7393619418,
-0.0567430109,
-0.2816199958,
0.2495224774,
-0.2206999809,
-0.2464637309,
-0.173603043,
-0.5761343241,
0.1514430493,
0.6718624234,
0.2231919914,
0.7238237262,
0.4186612964,
0.4861929715,
0.3397177458,
-0.5848165751,
0.4035769701,
-0.403545469,
0.5105835795,
-0.12182004,
-0.2918549478,
-0.4998441339,
-0.3542766571,
0.8718600869,
0.4424614608,
-0.032055296,
0.0204901006,
-0.0708859861,
0.645516932,
-0.7090523839,
-0.0752097815,
-0.9175664186,
0.0724264085,
0.0103900237,
-0.5419516563,
-0.4088988304,
-0.5942290425,
0.2573421597,
-0.4936701655,
-0.1318498403,
0.2763204873,
0.5641239882,
0.0871875361,
-0.6266115904,
-0.4191091657,
-0.7295094728,
0.5107203722,
-0.4925645292,
0.354881078,
0.0265276544,
0.4806613624,
-0.175854817,
-0.4745208025,
-0.6273064017,
-0.0523951761,
-0.0614837371,
0.2267753184,
-0.0977899656,
0.181405738,
0.1973952353,
0.6427512169,
-0.3330127001,
-0.4835111797,
-0.1379490346,
-0.0083674314,
0.4405822754,
0.1650963277,
0.1533848792,
-0.317017436,
-0.2694602907,
-0.3479850292,
-0.5618115664,
0.4226444662,
0.4333535135,
0.0642433688,
0.5390835404,
0.4387377799,
-0.3320180774,
0.7366425395,
0.1627750397,
-0.2624592483,
0.378280431,
-0.5613471866,
-0.0742292181,
-0.0399144292,
0.6050107479,
0.2092538476,
0.0028733562,
-0.1698096544,
-0.1411007345,
-0.2911942601,
0.2609171867,
-0.6084469557,
0.1191569939,
0.2763915956,
-0.3594729006,
-0.5120931268,
0.1214757636,
-0.958414495,
-0.2779956162,
0.2307503223,
0.2837456167,
-0.5953375101,
-0.4500600994,
0.2261171937,
-0.1607891768,
-0.0014756097,
0.5764268041,
0.0061073164,
0.40208745,
0.4391104281,
0.7025965452,
-0.0044147801,
-0.3572193682,
-0.7161419988,
-0.0169085432,
-0.3215584755,
0.5126209855,
-0.8085215092,
-0.1758366078,
-0.0899873301,
0.0017910717,
-0.0579839423,
-0.195614621,
0.4626047015,
-1.0142296553,
0.1140980646,
-0.194565922,
-0.2018968016,
-0.4564036131,
0.7893728018,
-0.7675176859,
0.9215643406,
0.1307123601,
-1.0373572111,
-0.1034877449,
-0.6065938473,
-0.3898753822,
-0.0846176818,
-0.0454286411,
-0.327713877,
-0.0668253228,
0.3527082801,
-0.2720750868,
-0.275072217,
0.4964693785,
-0.2069934756,
-0.4438802004,
0.0888337567,
-0.5293880105,
0.9614090323,
0.4520154595,
-0.228153944,
0.1961216182,
-0.5704063773,
0.3585368097,
0.0047425143,
-0.4256190956,
-0.3133034706,
0.1703051627,
-0.4238216877,
0.1965490431,
-0.3485009074,
-0.6548900008,
0.4520373642,
-0.3783246279,
0.3564119041,
0.519664824,
0.3245908916,
0.1267737299,
-0.3272636235,
0.7693074942,
0.1668697596,
0.2355741858,
-0.7101118565,
-0.4165439308,
-0.4865482152,
0.0024794999,
0.2665017545,
0.3416297734,
-0.89651829,
0.3474751711,
-0.2221008986,
-0.3941063583,
-0.7032589912,
-0.2838796675,
0.3484476805,
0.5127814412,
0.4710119963,
-0.117097944,
-0.4716545939,
-0.4538935423,
-0.2284489125,
-0.4871448576,
0.4443245232,
0.4137379527,
0.2721572816,
-0.2234948128,
0.9927158952,
-0.4913371801,
0.0369826294,
-0.1501839459,
0.1064835265,
0.2521690726,
0.1062912419,
0.2959545851,
-0.7689601779,
-0.4597009122,
-0.2221457213,
-0.2808019519,
0.1162823066,
-0.2900698483,
-0.0702779442,
-0.3264879286,
0.1685271263,
-0.5247057676,
0.1517959982,
0.3877944946,
-0.2606642842,
0.7064691782,
0.0899925381,
0.4433656633,
-0.9955570102,
0.1004233807,
-0.4725839794,
-0.3664827645,
-0.0869431794,
0.3809376955,
-0.0956899747,
0.0364439003,
-0.2116855532,
0.2809772491,
-0.4197838008,
0.1192791313,
-0.1748839915,
0.1646003127,
0.3781783879,
0.4455785453,
-0.0541531481,
0.6957405806,
0.5056754351,
-0.4980979264,
0.4389159679,
0.3233205378,
-0.2139143795,
0.1572746187,
-0.3599491417,
0.2202519327,
-0.393882215,
0.6349470019,
-1.0965812206,
0.2295140326,
0.1137956828,
-0.5419334769,
-0.1076948568,
-0.1592954993,
-0.5215007067,
-0.7529935837,
-0.7639471292,
0.5818250179,
0.0647476092,
-0.6610496044,
0.5350381732,
0.2587569058,
-0.0208750349,
-0.9958726764,
-0.2055600584,
-0.1114507169,
0.0776581466,
-0.5096893907,
0.4400860071,
-0.2324554771,
-0.1353013664,
0.3650164604,
-0.4110098481,
-0.0825535655,
0.0583819896,
-0.2656541169,
-0.0765308067,
-0.192907095,
0.3293190002,
0.2004477233,
0.1689786911,
0.0168497581,
-0.187208578,
0.615680635,
-0.4204418361,
-0.4738243818,
-0.1015586331,
0.3181973696,
0.8568447828,
-0.4622569382,
0.1331142634,
0.1647666246,
-0.1516217291,
-0.1531920582,
-0.5024772286,
-0.2780211568,
-0.4499325454,
0.5239603519,
-0.7035328746,
-0.8850951791,
0.3010499179,
-0.3966478407,
0.0624840111,
0.3491228819,
0.2664092183,
-0.3053441346,
1.0017515421,
0.418153286,
-0.0716515332,
0.3451501727,
-0.3990160823,
0.4560423195,
-1.081496954,
-0.2102185339,
-0.4963000119,
-0.4002141654,
-0.6320423484,
-0.4033219218,
0.4764397144,
0.3817578256,
-0.2191644907,
0.2084393203,
-0.6914925575,
0.4653426707,
0.4528303742,
0.0308964532,
0.7497738004,
-0.0245541744,
-0.482967943,
0.3189591169,
-0.830637753,
-0.2067476362,
0.7670551538,
0.4157580435,
0.8570309877,
0.1447746605,
0.3477898836,
0.0931744054,
0.0291355774,
-0.7321256399,
0.4202048779,
0.296074152,
-0.6028799415,
-0.3232459426,
-0.4820566475,
-0.9307066202,
0.4129794836,
-0.2212097049,
-0.6753944755,
0.0577093177,
0.1480791122,
-0.5542320013,
0.7523424029,
-0.2835481763,
0.3474769592,
-0.571875453,
-0.3733891249,
-0.3618310988,
-0.8419311643,
0.435772866,
-0.0186084826,
0.1042699292,
0.2601155937,
0.3364658356,
0.6404837966,
-0.3218831718,
0.4412046373,
-0.0754300058,
0.257283777,
0.7294281721,
0.5012301207,
0.8036424518,
0.1888065338,
-0.2287619114,
-0.4300325215,
0.3563733995,
0.1175003499,
-0.6595146656,
0.6007943153,
-0.6987426281,
-0.8101575971,
-0.7510339618,
-0.6059532762,
-0.5455501676,
0.3063876927,
-0.238125518,
0.1713456959,
0.0970833153,
0.4236138761,
0.376480639,
-0.2225397974,
0.4734271765,
0.4508859515,
-0.6069819331,
-0.5541101098,
0.4477903247,
0.0479109138,
0.1175089404,
0.4533843696,
0.4421530068,
-0.5183917284,
-0.5113143325,
-0.5822010636,
0.1477111876,
-0.490629673,
-0.3283722103,
-0.9942626953,
-0.4465714395,
-0.0857698619,
0.1749660075,
-0.2250940651,
-0.4090979695,
0.6124515533,
-0.329364419,
0.5938369036,
0.5842548013,
0.4308825731,
0.4392601252,
-0.8543570042,
0.1901349127,
0.0781951919,
0.6939186454,
0.3691142201,
-0.1255149394,
0.172507301,
-0.0444245785,
-0.7195709348,
-1.1413755417,
0.1150512397,
-0.1484124362,
0.441470176,
0.2514909804,
0.3071843088,
1.0661029816,
-0.4676369429,
0.3710583448,
0.1898807287,
-0.7705654502,
0.6163470149,
-0.195209235,
0.2695208192,
0.7845574021,
0.3766098917,
-0.7035637498,
-0.517162919,
-0.801692903,
-0.9506660104,
0.7097195983,
0.2361280769,
-0.0513794161,
0.0136313727,
0.2723523378,
0.094401516,
0.5544273853,
-0.7168185115,
0.0125676161,
0.0250013955,
0.0974826142,
0.4232832491,
-0.3296640515,
0.0332106315,
-0.3829873204,
0.5771604776,
-0.1980762482,
0.179764986,
0.411431253,
-0.0386441238,
-0.4053762555,
0.3482319713,
-0.0984029323,
0.7248826027,
-0.3973944783,
0.4134873748,
0.1177611277,
-0.2781023085,
0.2638717592,
-0.2535842955,
-0.4615284204,
0.0755934715,
0.3182987273,
0.6325103641,
-0.2746081948,
-0.5778701901,
0.4962738454,
0.128554076,
0.055402156,
-0.0394226573,
-0.05564408,
0.1002633497,
0.1610449404,
0.3447800577,
0.2931290865,
0.32482481,
-0.8664336205,
0.4819236696,
0.5667461753,
-0.3387560248,
-0.2540274858,
0.3085303903,
0.4021689892,
-0.5267319083,
0.8567337394,
-0.2873443365,
-0.8442146182,
0.4743788838,
0.5631610751,
0.7745323181,
-0.1151046976,
0.2714158297,
0.6156257987,
0.3699497581,
0.1821810305,
0.3249728978,
-0.2212278694,
-0.6318609118,
-0.6645668149,
-0.5865760446,
-0.4030360281,
0.2694604099,
-0.1357926428,
0.2023048848,
-0.4667026699,
-0.2084631175,
-0.433113724,
0.0888439417,
-0.1464746892,
0.2457188517,
-0.3191331923,
1.1239801645,
-0.5123741031,
0.822211504,
0.4057430923,
-0.4523689747,
-0.858641088,
0.508841753,
0.0646787137,
-0.3820059001,
0.2845363319,
0.1031088755,
-0.7446052432,
0.0407544635,
-0.0167758688,
-0.9398603439,
1.0240075588,
0.0175064187,
-0.7470229268,
-0.1771293133,
-0.085047245,
0.5639848113,
-0.38324821,
0.7606341243,
0.0540802442,
0.4723685384,
0.5529327393,
-0.7436019778,
0.0030505494,
-0.3358790874,
-0.2508075833,
0.0027465126,
-0.6697742343,
0.7438479066,
-0.2261098772,
-0.1390180439,
-0.1143917814,
0.0596724153,
0.5553902388,
0.194944337,
0.8364166617,
0.3577127159,
0.9233874083,
0.044902876,
0.9910255075,
-0.4686164856,
0.4418296516,
1.2097617388,
-0.2506414354,
0.7488752604,
0.5862780213,
-0.1736730784,
0.5696489811,
0.7584319115,
0.3365957439,
0.5168461204,
0.439665854,
-0.0818316191,
-0.0170716625,
0.0540264137,
-0.2477127761,
0.1643484533,
0.0249733869,
-0.2160703689,
-0.5008526444,
-0.3087631464,
-0.0770765319,
0.021766277,
-0.0746905655,
0.6343923807,
-0.2288490981,
-0.9448819757,
0.4425919056,
0.0610923767,
0.4401741028,
-0.6388137341,
-0.1551897824,
-0.0413465649,
0.1628605872,
-0.159523651,
-1.0159212351,
0.5898063779,
0.0626142323,
-0.0958946794,
-0.3756039739,
0.4806316197,
-0.266153723,
-0.5773607492,
0.6933572292,
0.8434201479,
-0.0597128868,
-0.1874240637,
-0.8952153921,
0.1271362156,
0.011779055,
-0.3841579854,
-0.2371737957,
0.5565567613,
-0.4070171118,
0.7557477951,
0.5353460312,
0.1314588636,
0.0639638007,
-0.0330302268,
1.1062030792,
-0.5632987618,
-0.6056163907,
-0.7319557071,
0.4366586506,
-0.2683725357,
-0.0235626027,
0.4559686482,
0.8195921183,
0.6882536411,
0.196422115,
0.6808826327,
-0.2808051109,
0.6297798753,
-0.2235472053,
0.4309025705,
-0.6366842389,
0.4053854048,
-0.414927423,
-1.1466578245,
-0.1963238418,
0.5617312193,
-0.1330976337,
0.0521935709,
1.316391468,
0.7058893442,
-0.1075218543,
0.1591660082,
0.0190945454,
0.458483398,
0.5084329844,
0.4808701873,
1.0187780857,
-0.4195105135,
0.7931278348,
-0.0166089423,
-0.2258175761,
-0.0163590685,
-0.7132745385,
-0.251380533,
-0.5279055834,
-0.2800700963,
-0.5123009682,
0.2732415199,
0.8537620902,
0.6206659079,
-0.6646496654,
-0.1816810817,
-0.3812515736,
0.5456117392,
-0.4498167634,
-0.2102465034,
0.5103164911,
-0.5074531436,
-0.6182634234,
0.42418015,
0.3947627842,
-0.4556177855,
-0.1634356081,
-0.0620656684,
-0.7307486534,
0.0630017444,
0.6245586872,
-0.0640842542,
-0.8325211406,
-0.3692533672,
0.5164599419,
0.1459679753,
0.4415437579,
0.9050152898,
-0.9657688737,
0.8670313358,
0.7759853005,
0.8478111625,
0.5623381734,
0.2216005474,
0.2592171431,
-0.6310481429,
-0.2763737142,
0.6063033938,
0.2631320655,
-0.0599567629,
-0.3134492338,
0.5479448438,
0.2697461843,
-0.2037144601,
-0.7399519086,
0.360372901,
-0.9700763822,
-0.3702846766,
1.0478737354,
-0.0704148561,
-0.3025546074,
-0.1224799901,
-0.5465758443,
0.0563630946,
-0.3246662617,
0.8443292975,
0.8119574189,
-0.3112558722,
-0.2998404205,
-0.0631336197,
0.4367346764,
0.2654193044,
-0.7059448361,
0.2524484098,
0.401753217,
0.2118627578,
0.4603666663,
0.9304905534,
-0.4426407516,
0.227966845,
-0.2311013937,
-0.4119343758,
-0.1205967218,
-0.6794334054,
-0.0429927707,
0.472781837,
0.2965339422,
-0.2325834632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14463v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14463v1
|
DAIC-WOZ: On the Validity of Using the Therapist's prompts in Automatic Depression Detection from Clinical Interviews
| 2024-04-22T09:07:50 | 2024-04-22T09:07:50 |
Sergio Burdisso, Ernesto Reyes-Ramírez, Esaú Villatoro-Tello, Fernando Sánchez-Vega, Pastor López-Monroy, Petr Motlicek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Automatic depression detection from conversational data has gained
significant interest in recent years. The DAIC-WOZ dataset, interviews
conducted by a human-controlled virtual agent, has been widely used for this
task. Recent studies have reported enhanced performance when incorporating
interviewer's prompts into the model. In this work, we hypothesize that this
improvement might be mainly due to a bias present in these prompts, rather than
the proposed architectures and methods. Through ablation experiments and
qualitative analysis, we discover that models using interviewer's prompts learn
to focus on a specific region of the interviews, where questions about past
experiences with mental health issues are asked, and use them as discriminative
shortcuts to detect depressed participants. In contrast, models using
participant responses gather evidence from across the entire interview.
Finally, to highlight the magnitude of this bias, we achieve a 0.90 F1 score by
intentionally exploiting it, the highest result reported to date on this
dataset using only textual information. Our findings underline the need for
caution when incorporating interviewers' prompts into models, as they may
inadvertently learn to exploit targeted prompts, rather than learning to
characterize the language and behavior that are genuinely indicative of the
patient's mental health condition.
|
[
-0.7198243737,
-1.0261925459,
1.0880304575,
-0.010898334,
-0.1043156013,
-0.3489047587,
-0.0472968072,
-0.1612777561,
0.0169662572,
0.0790414289,
-0.9238105416,
-0.5409834385,
-0.5239257216,
0.6509125233,
-0.2438340783,
0.7981541753,
0.2588132024,
0.0796699747,
-0.164009124,
0.1749768257,
-0.7642846107,
-0.1972971261,
-0.799916029,
-0.0344666913,
0.5289103389,
0.5009661317,
0.7968025804,
0.3862703741,
0.2700932622,
0.2789821029,
-0.0215977766,
0.1455869079,
-0.188027218,
0.1270506829,
0.1430247873,
-0.5997465849,
-0.2457149327,
0.2659512758,
-0.0686386302,
0.8997489214,
-0.1326701194,
-0.0588046126,
0.1597817093,
0.1717443764,
-0.6967163682,
0.0330720134,
-0.2015875131,
0.3568150997,
0.0849522427,
-0.0778768212,
-0.53070575,
-0.4849279225,
0.1436267793,
-0.2985559404,
0.415276289,
-0.3107144535,
0.7291300893,
0.6031814218,
-0.6669946313,
-0.3676370978,
-0.6780458689,
0.580360949,
-0.6607938409,
-0.0971872509,
0.9221530557,
0.4425387084,
0.0258733574,
-0.1632743478,
-0.3844147325,
-0.2199084461,
-0.1375189573,
0.2904011309,
-0.3857987225,
0.1803739667,
0.8015682697,
0.3076511323,
-0.5194687247,
0.3295362294,
-0.2367144376,
-0.2346880734,
0.5979636908,
0.6487468481,
0.2081730366,
-0.2725855708,
-0.2447507977,
-0.007071509,
-0.03857629,
0.3232123852,
0.1897486448,
0.2121598125,
-0.2721303701,
0.4737100005,
-0.0133113461,
0.8114043474,
0.4836533964,
-0.1555281579,
0.0337910987,
0.0655119494,
-0.0279367901,
-0.0153430384,
0.8632977009,
0.8227246404,
0.1045281067,
0.0724269226,
0.1516828835,
0.3713193238,
0.440138042,
-0.6411064267,
-0.4780705273,
0.5747056603,
-0.5449225903,
-0.2127532065,
-0.0361980163,
-0.8944411874,
-0.719774127,
-0.2702920735,
0.0692676827,
-0.3662240207,
-0.0454477519,
0.0499881841,
-0.3905267119,
0.046709165,
0.4622831345,
-0.4599704742,
0.1599329412,
0.2264146209,
0.7323966026,
-0.1352739185,
0.1465810686,
-0.7352800369,
-0.4586644769,
-0.4842328429,
0.9990412593,
-0.3272660375,
-0.7382115126,
0.2156923115,
0.1847598553,
0.0338002555,
-0.5034897327,
0.7933441997,
-0.0910192207,
0.5296078324,
-0.7009045482,
-0.4235561788,
0.1371433139,
0.1621994376,
-0.628716886,
0.8139420748,
0.3389067352,
-0.8058961034,
0.4088902175,
-0.4400478005,
-0.1296606362,
-0.1409766078,
-0.1135862544,
-0.2319149971,
0.0440336876,
0.3050611615,
0.3308037221,
-0.3514991105,
0.1792182177,
-0.4883897603,
-0.3079182506,
0.7358101606,
-0.4650000334,
1.0672826767,
0.2819106281,
-0.1597755551,
-0.4370465577,
-0.6915123463,
-0.2243614495,
-0.0712008849,
-0.0360170789,
-0.5003356934,
-0.4578775764,
-0.3270431757,
0.3822764754,
-0.2001773864,
-0.6420150399,
-0.1194870099,
-0.3051928282,
-0.254321754,
0.6554307342,
0.1975192875,
0.1176732928,
-0.4015410244,
0.9283851981,
0.2589054108,
0.2595422566,
-0.331943959,
-0.5152184963,
-0.2369385362,
-0.7418295145,
0.1381007284,
0.5593888164,
-0.4485150576,
0.8529174328,
0.4874267578,
-0.4889173508,
-0.5884484053,
-0.1836682856,
0.1648469269,
0.9904785156,
0.4100345075,
-0.4065268338,
-0.2894800305,
-0.7987084985,
-0.1895816177,
0.1241142228,
-0.3629459143,
0.3721021712,
0.0482517295,
-0.2070592046,
1.2401798964,
-0.8830480576,
-0.1054526865,
-0.2868473232,
0.2994543314,
0.3101670146,
0.1884614825,
0.4146064222,
-0.5906432867,
-0.73890692,
-0.511167109,
-0.9000990391,
-0.5660768747,
-0.1487908065,
-0.028171638,
-0.148009181,
0.2166782469,
-0.9074569345,
0.6817251444,
0.0944087878,
-0.7170325518,
0.7152966857,
-0.1521471143,
0.2765053511,
-0.7625012398,
-0.0042434195,
0.2492797673,
-0.1885949671,
-0.5317891836,
-0.7234079838,
-0.2463907897,
-0.1478892714,
-0.2109035999,
0.2554253936,
-0.2198829055,
0.2775452733,
-0.5973870754,
0.0994353369,
0.3291819394,
0.3954236507,
-0.2924111485,
0.6226888299,
0.707248807,
-0.8812413216,
0.4874900281,
0.7696512341,
-0.0832791701,
1.1791131496,
-0.5057206154,
0.2330027223,
-0.4245769083,
0.4151202738,
-1.1641455889,
-0.1675631702,
0.4324697256,
-0.3295840919,
-0.0429784991,
0.1215059385,
-0.0118048918,
-0.4740834832,
-0.2375255376,
0.3390577137,
0.5803114176,
-0.3484803736,
0.2807288766,
0.3620010316,
-0.2332217097,
-0.3681073785,
-0.565861702,
-0.0054496867,
-0.7388498783,
-0.2082370669,
0.280046463,
-0.3670602143,
-0.4976242781,
-0.3170415759,
-0.0351347998,
-0.1220993102,
0.2803391218,
0.2873425484,
0.407107085,
0.0094773509,
0.0016068502,
0.0911190137,
-0.4517139196,
0.5481421351,
0.2244217694,
0.4401045144,
0.3193226457,
-0.3157075047,
-1.0861070156,
0.5047147274,
0.2028784007,
0.0782621652,
0.7843469977,
0.4516210556,
-0.2876318395,
-0.0082223825,
-0.4611601233,
-0.3859546483,
-0.4159575403,
-0.1783317775,
-0.2561123669,
-0.6581733227,
0.6039002538,
-0.2934334874,
-0.2567483187,
0.1696929336,
0.6362515688,
-0.4959511161,
1.6779210567,
0.4847065508,
-0.0968530178,
0.4886616468,
-0.1352593154,
0.1839939952,
-0.5222350359,
0.0622568801,
-0.8262233734,
-0.0740719289,
-0.4303649664,
-0.0556700751,
0.5765661597,
-0.2266749293,
-0.0389311276,
0.0192502905,
-0.3458178937,
0.1536698937,
0.2607036829,
0.3862141967,
0.1627086401,
-0.440177232,
-0.1254564822,
-0.4260985851,
-0.4443046451,
-0.3822167814,
0.6849889755,
0.2448116988,
0.7420625687,
-0.3272331953,
0.3757860959,
0.7331596017,
0.0712336972,
-0.746515274,
0.3601965904,
0.3930235505,
-0.3439360261,
-0.2578940988,
-0.3810711801,
-1.1014826298,
0.2218109965,
0.216529429,
-0.6941081285,
0.6044538021,
0.1154441833,
-0.8157484531,
-0.3271805644,
-0.5826365948,
1.1202865839,
-0.0651940107,
-0.0202274062,
-0.0948899686,
-0.7669539452,
0.1343225688,
-0.0661459863,
0.4557737708,
-0.204467684,
0.2332649231,
0.464471966,
-0.5493975878,
0.9508327842,
-0.5270935893,
-0.4963797331,
0.4713056982,
0.0233974829,
0.4033210576,
0.0741586164,
-0.1314153671,
-0.1906181872,
0.1589757651,
-0.279070735,
-0.8588457704,
0.1069635227,
-0.5647888184,
-0.6387169361,
-0.290328294,
-0.5268384814,
-0.3804341555,
-0.0885465145,
0.2264094651,
0.6386160254,
-0.4749212861,
-0.2962913215,
0.5286584496,
-0.4573836327,
-0.0509827398,
0.4648576379,
0.1198816001,
-0.2324488461,
0.3096058667,
-0.141347751,
0.2493076921,
-0.0725657046,
0.3576686084,
-0.1062636226,
-0.0893562138,
0.0531705469,
0.4080325365,
-0.901714623,
-0.2966907322,
-0.719809413,
0.3200893402,
-0.4484979808,
-0.007522299,
-0.0650711134,
-0.3294824064,
-0.3135380149,
-0.5454955697,
0.2939687669,
0.2644594908,
-0.4039702117,
0.2629340887,
-0.7878511548,
0.6053393483,
0.224489525,
-0.1372139603,
-0.1789527982,
-0.4123489559,
-0.4239816964,
0.323669076,
-0.4080782831,
-1.2526369095,
0.4474554062,
-0.1044937447,
0.4539865851,
0.6908717752,
0.7148987651,
0.6994917989,
0.0036705488,
0.7878999114,
-0.0564412661,
-0.629472971,
0.740157783,
-0.3546545208,
0.3483429551,
0.8756868839,
0.8670262694,
-0.617377758,
-0.6770187616,
-0.7087078094,
-0.4278378189,
1.0260233879,
-0.1378492862,
0.0910770595,
-0.3888629973,
0.3202280998,
0.4735440612,
0.0552287512,
-0.3808008134,
-0.341086179,
-0.0578407198,
-0.6033304334,
0.026014274,
-0.4088841081,
-0.3878957033,
-0.2590198517,
0.4057240486,
-0.4234527349,
0.5777364373,
0.5079616904,
0.0624196678,
-0.2777303457,
0.1357062906,
-0.2135576755,
0.4190126956,
-0.0903618112,
0.1221384183,
0.2609421015,
-0.1669649482,
-0.0252596047,
0.204947412,
-0.1193316281,
0.2976107299,
0.1052867472,
0.7290508747,
-0.2271909118,
-0.9401412606,
0.6167426705,
-0.2577655613,
-0.0246896874,
-0.3244987726,
0.1921346486,
-0.4397732019,
0.458093524,
0.0719064102,
-0.0610052869,
0.6271324158,
-0.4976299703,
0.037168283,
0.5315674543,
-0.6326224804,
-0.4687328339,
0.6029547453,
-0.1343749315,
-0.334448725,
0.8894273043,
0.0411450677,
-0.4965360463,
0.640427053,
0.3225546479,
0.8096434474,
-0.3150791228,
0.5773884654,
0.4761016667,
-0.2199667096,
-0.0185914487,
0.3041418791,
-0.4134020507,
-0.6381284595,
0.1138190329,
-0.0913329124,
-0.4851506054,
-0.0670666993,
-0.9888120294,
0.4525936544,
-0.0838602707,
-0.6897532344,
-0.2071357816,
-0.265062809,
-0.7475059032,
0.432869792,
0.3225716054,
0.9188096523,
-1.0677057505,
0.2259891033,
0.4838943481,
-0.4966269732,
-0.5262949467,
0.2118152976,
0.2836780548,
-0.2980375886,
0.0659642518,
0.4095624685,
0.3494529724,
-0.0118228216,
-0.5176143646,
-0.5555351973,
1.0542640686,
0.4342283905,
0.1492561698,
-0.2442290485,
0.2729315162,
0.5932315588,
-0.2681945264,
0.7227155566,
0.6616236567,
0.3256291151,
-0.0170825515,
-0.9759523869,
0.1340868473,
-0.2339693159,
-0.2757626772,
-0.2528706789,
-0.5262845159,
0.8800724745,
-0.2511507273,
-0.3062761724,
-0.0139014618,
0.3835812211,
0.2239425927,
0.3691126108,
0.9296741486,
0.175147742,
1.1339054108,
0.1200820506,
1.2710413933,
-0.0986917838,
0.2086421102,
0.5558426976,
-0.4041143656,
0.0285560694,
0.2276088893,
-0.1872491539,
0.7708328962,
0.7050130367,
-0.1319432408,
0.7767340541,
-0.2210587859,
-0.3003982008,
-0.4590030909,
-0.5932851434,
-0.1159215793,
0.2230938226,
0.25572142,
-0.3349431753,
-0.3539661765,
0.4086880088,
0.1951965541,
-0.075118944,
0.166558966,
0.7969791889,
0.6064491272,
-0.7982577085,
0.6708203554,
-0.0326997936,
0.2793550789,
-0.3916581571,
0.1066290066,
-0.3430682421,
0.1516373307,
-0.126374498,
-0.2931106389,
0.1799498051,
0.381603986,
-0.0687175617,
-0.2734736204,
0.6071465015,
-0.1697939485,
-0.1248982623,
0.1103441119,
0.7408331037,
0.2817021608,
-0.1406131983,
-0.7283684611,
-0.2400807589,
-0.2826403677,
-0.2331887931,
0.3144319654,
0.7353103757,
0.1329272538,
0.4978908896,
0.3943601847,
-0.213000834,
-0.3494329453,
0.2480626851,
0.6477868557,
-0.7045981288,
-0.7791346312,
-0.857950747,
0.6612135768,
-0.066403605,
-0.2439256012,
0.9527304769,
0.302957803,
0.4216567278,
-0.0682257041,
0.8821790814,
-0.1157821566,
0.8470482826,
-0.3232694268,
0.2227062583,
-0.4223178327,
0.0462334417,
-0.4735745192,
-0.4265228808,
0.0640960187,
0.7630968094,
-0.4822782874,
0.1799917966,
0.8506913781,
0.7264491916,
0.2898567915,
0.2577651739,
0.2091580033,
0.2866172791,
0.3594003618,
0.3310329616,
1.152274251,
-0.1915706992,
0.1506502926,
-0.4043676257,
-0.355979085,
-0.0112122055,
-0.4418617487,
-0.9280763268,
-0.4583617747,
-0.650023222,
-0.394615382,
-0.2865304947,
1.0266317129,
0.0218791645,
-0.5645736456,
0.0412391163,
0.2019663602,
-0.0724138767,
-0.4977508783,
-0.2302859575,
0.2726535797,
-0.3540038764,
-0.7111698985,
0.547139585,
-0.1369042695,
-0.0463450402,
-0.1567687243,
0.0602191165,
0.1471240819,
-0.1339034438,
0.1373515129,
0.0383774526,
-0.2247055173,
-0.0743428841,
0.0703995749,
-0.3325176835,
0.3791512847,
0.7119944096,
-0.9100863934,
0.2951963246,
0.208141759,
0.3259600401,
0.0476785973,
0.5079185963,
0.7648234367,
-0.3003996313,
0.0216333997,
0.2187577933,
0.2690532207,
0.4532043636,
-0.6767516732,
0.1125515327,
0.3388496637,
-0.4828392565,
-0.8823933005,
0.0549830049,
-0.799063921,
-0.279892236,
1.0447229147,
-0.1925541759,
-0.2927170396,
-0.7130260468,
-0.7251155376,
0.309273392,
-0.3614743948,
1.3344982862,
0.6988065243,
-0.438138634,
-0.0768117011,
-0.4953904152,
0.619959414,
0.3848338425,
-0.692725718,
0.1206810623,
0.7894942164,
-0.0072978055,
-0.0712391511,
0.8976362944,
0.0556049496,
0.5071153641,
-0.2167684883,
-0.0920358002,
0.1386681795,
0.0168044753,
-0.5349283218,
-0.0045611048,
0.0180284306,
-0.1188846976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13985v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13985v2
|
Information Re-Organization Improves Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-22T08:47:27 | 2024-05-24T07:28:49 |
Xiaoxia Cheng, Zeqi Tan, Wei Xue, Weiming Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Improving the reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs) has
attracted considerable interest. Recent approaches primarily focus on improving
the reasoning process to yield a more precise final answer. However, in
scenarios involving contextually aware reasoning, these methods neglect the
importance of first identifying logical relationships from the context before
proceeding with the reasoning. This oversight could lead to a superficial
understanding and interaction with the context, potentially undermining the
quality and reliability of the reasoning outcomes. In this paper, we propose an
information re-organization (InfoRE) method before proceeding with the
reasoning to enhance the reasoning ability of LLMs. Our re-organization method
involves initially extracting logical relationships from the contextual
content, such as documents or paragraphs, and subsequently pruning redundant
content to minimize noise. Then, we utilize the re-organized information in the
reasoning process. This enables LLMs to deeply understand the contextual
content by clearly perceiving these logical relationships, while also ensuring
high-quality responses by eliminating potential noise. To demonstrate the
effectiveness of our approach in improving the reasoning ability, we conduct
experiments using Llama2-70B, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 on various contextually aware
multi-hop reasoning tasks. Using only a zero-shot setting, our method achieves
an average absolute improvement of 4% across all tasks, highlighting its
potential to improve the reasoning performance of LLMs. Our source code is
available at https://github.com/hustcxx/InfoRE.
|
[
-0.2945747077,
-0.956106782,
0.8557158709,
-0.1057811007,
-0.4433285296,
-0.1010849327,
-0.3818070292,
-0.4961063266,
0.1155671701,
0.4017900527,
-0.3980692029,
-0.4516029358,
-0.4628078938,
0.0043446841,
-0.3252654076,
0.7364048362,
-0.0076968409,
-0.2031654418,
-0.2669400573,
-0.1449397504,
-0.578792572,
-0.4807871878,
-0.6304838657,
-0.3386588991,
0.7283490896,
0.422735393,
0.5032998323,
0.8233919144,
0.5003094673,
0.3649383485,
-0.330348134,
0.431936264,
-0.5039883852,
0.4658164084,
-0.5081330538,
-0.4221312404,
-0.4504674077,
-0.3308579922,
0.617829442,
0.4803310335,
-0.2300990075,
0.1692216396,
-0.1884774417,
0.4743656218,
-0.7650285959,
0.333122015,
-0.8856442571,
-0.253867805,
-0.0701621771,
-0.6735756993,
-0.5782241821,
-0.0752118006,
0.0899777487,
-0.7864488363,
-0.0481424518,
0.0630623326,
0.7423814535,
0.3051728308,
-0.2008070946,
0.0988217965,
-0.7401480675,
0.806157887,
-0.6316472888,
0.7447481751,
0.1941768378,
0.2083925307,
-0.3811003268,
-0.6073058844,
-0.4968296885,
0.1452102661,
-0.1474777013,
-0.0230427645,
-0.259431988,
-0.1308532506,
0.361908704,
0.0191778839,
-0.422737211,
-0.1669001132,
-0.2072568238,
-0.1250882447,
0.3940854669,
-0.0299015343,
0.1789019406,
0.1110231131,
-0.2192739546,
-0.0086603342,
-0.6087770462,
-0.1048800573,
-0.2381276637,
0.0906831622,
0.3886716664,
0.5909143686,
-0.307924062,
0.8284195662,
0.2044282854,
-0.5762369633,
0.4353723526,
-0.6355740428,
-0.415784061,
0.1169171333,
0.3382949829,
0.2544172108,
0.1541951597,
-0.1101871729,
-0.2428968698,
-0.2896304727,
0.1952317059,
-0.6941740513,
0.0200143903,
0.2610390782,
-0.479827404,
-0.0320810489,
-0.0913350582,
-0.2513956428,
-0.2978507876,
-0.7184449434,
0.3847372532,
-0.7193177938,
-0.2740363479,
0.1922543943,
-0.0565491021,
0.3151821494,
0.8876417279,
-0.5788718462,
-0.0391862802,
0.7373639941,
0.5773631334,
0.2555010915,
-0.3747126758,
-0.6252678037,
0.6034682393,
-0.2422355413,
0.9792331457,
-0.5730003715,
0.1262015253,
-0.2813765109,
-0.0668566078,
-0.062970534,
-0.6031157374,
0.6466151476,
-0.7394445539,
0.0879442543,
-0.2358597517,
-0.4756076336,
-0.3117405772,
0.4480130672,
-0.4756136537,
0.6961480379,
-0.1170698404,
-0.9881391525,
0.3597303629,
-0.4209958613,
-0.4756959975,
-0.2168433219,
-0.2399006784,
-0.2254358232,
0.1790057868,
0.4683054984,
0.3383861184,
-0.3479842246,
0.3819589019,
-0.1952212155,
-0.5219776034,
0.3462801576,
-0.2601808608,
0.4750321507,
0.2196585834,
-0.1505468786,
0.2557654679,
-0.5588545799,
0.1566489488,
0.081231311,
-0.6060934067,
-0.4775549769,
-0.0352220759,
-0.4717303216,
0.1384772062,
0.2393697053,
-0.272521317,
0.2855929434,
-0.4134716094,
0.2994585633,
0.7189799547,
0.1286462545,
0.6579454541,
-0.2004351616,
0.1524453759,
0.1149665862,
0.2210368216,
-0.3058835864,
-0.2545931041,
-0.8792457581,
-0.2941578329,
-0.0150521472,
0.548858881,
-0.8607767224,
0.4409963489,
-0.3869293332,
-0.2277471572,
-0.2582022548,
0.2022564858,
0.4150256217,
0.7716869116,
0.4892551899,
0.1073032394,
-0.6237143278,
-0.9152911901,
-0.3751727939,
-0.2869580388,
0.1012920588,
0.1543847769,
0.2817173004,
-0.4300961494,
0.8876074553,
-0.4540115297,
0.030665148,
-0.2211452276,
0.0904520527,
0.3401196599,
0.2046486884,
0.0874343291,
-0.7525785565,
0.069001928,
0.0484319665,
-0.7245689631,
-0.246551469,
-0.1528447866,
-0.5469678044,
0.2137973756,
0.4032818675,
-0.7587760091,
0.5022873282,
0.0710961446,
-0.2479592562,
0.5539060831,
-0.2200480402,
0.3206631541,
-0.9122501612,
-0.013863246,
-0.0611996725,
-0.078261666,
-0.6963955164,
-0.1818403006,
0.0399545804,
0.1727494746,
-0.0770970881,
0.4511742592,
-0.6403203607,
-0.0962050557,
-0.281774193,
0.4365212023,
0.223150447,
0.424695015,
0.2171277106,
0.5889090896,
0.3911541104,
-0.5804976225,
0.0896998495,
0.227725029,
-0.6009560823,
0.6460624337,
-0.2859836519,
0.078362301,
-0.5248458982,
0.5729042888,
-0.934704423,
-0.2633796334,
0.2088641226,
-0.4031342566,
0.3752615452,
-0.109891817,
-0.5796055794,
0.1127203256,
-0.1014843732,
0.5559705496,
0.0667105913,
-0.6448391676,
0.6684768796,
0.2835690677,
-0.1490987539,
-0.7205055952,
-0.7082707286,
0.1252070367,
-0.2771123946,
-0.9967546463,
0.3603295386,
-0.0318097323,
-0.6527987123,
-0.1329004467,
-0.5098834038,
-0.3644875884,
-0.0072761653,
0.031282708,
0.1347742081,
-0.2082246244,
0.8399626613,
0.0429445095,
-0.2007728517,
-0.1982412785,
-0.4871421754,
0.3313636184,
-0.1160638556,
-0.2311429679,
-0.4646371901,
0.1700029373,
0.574441731,
-0.3956716955,
0.9573118091,
0.388697207,
-0.2709650397,
-0.0919387415,
-0.9727970362,
-0.2330117226,
-0.41508618,
0.3667161465,
-0.5713134408,
-0.9326725006,
0.1891189814,
-0.2093345821,
0.1244463325,
0.07560388,
0.2395087034,
-0.1613075286,
0.6974598169,
0.4633167386,
0.0216298867,
0.6352468729,
0.0308921691,
0.5468946695,
-0.9160684347,
-0.4870668054,
-0.2194170058,
-0.0332785323,
-0.004763837,
-0.7950130701,
0.2827048898,
0.4503905177,
-0.4113625586,
0.1725687683,
-0.4394488335,
0.5332807302,
0.1769530475,
0.2528486848,
0.60860461,
0.3058733046,
0.2709266245,
0.1136511117,
-0.8236295581,
-0.4635685086,
0.6697281599,
0.3298344016,
0.7804559469,
0.3700505495,
0.7329595089,
-0.1636008322,
0.465682894,
-0.8267694712,
0.6340770721,
0.1975487471,
-0.2277097255,
-0.4595671594,
-0.8138270378,
-0.9212215543,
0.520329833,
-0.0605680346,
-1.0337500572,
0.2726266086,
0.0538574383,
-0.2212076634,
0.2371749431,
-0.7542281151,
0.4232093394,
-0.4082655907,
-0.5157290697,
-0.2130224705,
-0.4691579938,
0.461653173,
-0.2533366978,
0.4466362894,
0.004450751,
-0.0623600371,
0.6591650248,
-0.5288492441,
0.4577142596,
0.0127784656,
-0.3925619721,
0.3348278403,
0.2783961892,
0.5951046944,
0.0031720356,
-0.301966995,
0.0957567841,
-0.1375512332,
-0.1509002745,
-1.0903704166,
0.7577764392,
-0.4366183281,
-0.9644771814,
-0.1147564799,
-0.761520803,
-0.0857710689,
0.2513235509,
0.0473827943,
0.4547542036,
0.2743957043,
0.3861981332,
0.6887536645,
-0.1574908495,
0.0934703499,
0.479554832,
-0.0476309247,
-0.3810293674,
0.3997752666,
0.2570310235,
0.2188971043,
0.781114459,
0.1582335979,
-0.4102683067,
-0.3688077927,
0.0395245664,
0.4619312882,
-0.9649383426,
-0.1522038579,
-0.6901756525,
0.1156717539,
-0.4760346413,
-0.0649684891,
-0.1929959804,
-0.3876540661,
0.0386953279,
-0.1221016794,
0.1695997566,
0.3891387582,
0.0544097833,
0.0866886824,
-0.6324855089,
0.1780506819,
0.1215497702,
0.2109843791,
0.0775661469,
-0.8022203445,
-0.1698822975,
-0.0797816366,
0.1758621037,
-0.7312194705,
0.0844219103,
-0.1189020053,
0.7252765894,
0.3488531709,
-0.099726975,
1.0176576376,
-0.3717851341,
0.1361050904,
0.190615356,
-0.8870126605,
0.7745747566,
-0.340064317,
0.4768534601,
0.4816627502,
-0.1087268814,
-0.2080094814,
-0.1179369092,
-0.518445611,
-0.9413076639,
0.7034591436,
0.3718295097,
-0.3171740174,
0.13132146,
0.6172245145,
-0.2855077982,
0.105393149,
-0.7117325068,
0.0284802951,
0.1056603938,
0.0673770607,
0.1210244671,
-0.5240389109,
-0.1503632814,
-0.3855528831,
0.7405905724,
0.020366881,
0.1837337911,
0.3505456448,
-0.1915791035,
0.0666014105,
0.509154439,
0.3997106552,
1.0451087952,
-0.2331002504,
0.4875812531,
0.1508049518,
-0.043059893,
0.2891592383,
-0.1245500296,
0.0181975812,
-0.1656739414,
0.6588411927,
0.5234431624,
0.2913590968,
-0.599151969,
0.4270641208,
-0.1684765965,
0.0414651856,
-0.23690328,
0.177602008,
0.2287506163,
0.5864005089,
0.072051093,
-0.1166837662,
-0.09807688,
-0.7013549805,
0.3182917833,
0.1758777648,
0.0686795339,
0.1277689189,
0.1175781712,
-0.0244747698,
-0.2603229582,
0.7434512377,
-0.0244133566,
-0.3074119687,
0.4182897508,
0.7689530253,
0.566570878,
-0.3108632863,
0.0621650927,
0.5524580479,
0.4530304968,
-0.2287934124,
0.1498947889,
-0.329364419,
-1.0727142096,
-0.7630617023,
-0.3597808182,
0.0033885259,
0.1553848833,
-0.3102963567,
0.1079756171,
-0.4293936193,
-0.1490493566,
-0.056206692,
-0.2914501131,
-0.3817851245,
0.2115749866,
-0.0206528008,
0.9353690147,
-0.4638907313,
0.8836578131,
0.6473461986,
-0.3959012628,
-0.8115133047,
0.3355801404,
-0.0415434167,
-0.4162696004,
0.9988561869,
0.3073147535,
-0.5532391071,
-0.207513243,
-0.5997568965,
-1.2195898294,
1.2719876766,
0.5108560324,
-0.7106992602,
0.4456268251,
-0.2707346082,
0.4792621136,
-0.438764751,
0.3253406286,
0.5367981195,
0.7165603638,
0.4160002768,
-0.6373668313,
0.260776937,
-0.3132237494,
-0.1063228846,
0.3208639622,
-0.4703544676,
0.6621125937,
-0.3997046351,
-0.516911149,
-0.0319744758,
0.3933971822,
0.5802416205,
0.2779720724,
0.713416934,
0.5447888374,
1.1536489725,
-0.0777829289,
0.9222393036,
-0.0859941244,
0.0559583977,
1.5698359013,
-0.3567737937,
0.6605142951,
0.695517242,
0.2625763416,
0.5552549362,
0.4371384978,
0.3189598918,
0.2813892365,
0.2677015662,
-0.3530763686,
-0.5738886595,
-0.2995788157,
-0.2124136984,
0.4636424482,
0.3033165038,
-0.4283267856,
-0.2051896602,
-0.3513768017,
0.1013421416,
-0.101850532,
-0.0647718832,
0.7729660869,
-0.0769542754,
-0.6648778319,
0.6882582307,
0.0638198406,
0.2191088945,
-0.4273099303,
-0.2143260539,
-0.2291335613,
0.2592540383,
-0.3623951077,
-0.7950436473,
0.2536406517,
0.0394145213,
-0.3892816901,
-0.148118183,
1.0367445946,
-0.4110682905,
-0.2191075981,
0.5496208668,
0.5276187062,
0.2553097308,
-0.225720048,
-0.4862798154,
0.1919827014,
0.0628637224,
-0.446960628,
0.1956093609,
0.7770109177,
-0.2454917878,
0.8020806313,
0.8110866547,
-0.1678043604,
-0.3339632154,
0.3611650169,
0.9822450876,
-0.6861669421,
-0.251234293,
-0.8861948848,
0.4480426311,
-0.3864804208,
0.0162429921,
0.62111485,
0.5402610898,
0.7296053171,
0.1539287567,
0.6603476405,
0.0306072533,
0.2238149643,
-0.5599039793,
0.2743022442,
-0.6187813878,
0.6960895658,
-0.2391169816,
-1.0669958591,
-0.5487915277,
0.7521492243,
-0.5101183057,
-0.0894611627,
0.6952583194,
0.9182283282,
-0.1507838964,
-0.064160876,
0.3049684465,
0.4547633231,
0.324523598,
0.5874822736,
0.9714815021,
-0.1253593415,
0.6833782196,
-0.1712745875,
-0.4545505643,
-0.0453624353,
-0.7802115679,
-0.6462057829,
-0.2680708766,
-0.3043265939,
-0.3187283278,
0.0960702598,
0.6988457441,
0.6120015383,
-0.3300411105,
-0.0724444985,
-0.0534394458,
0.4622394145,
-0.112580575,
-0.2431460321,
0.3510407209,
-0.3438704908,
-0.2912371755,
0.6166443825,
0.64403373,
-0.3555545807,
0.1500771344,
-0.0018649839,
-0.524467051,
0.1510149539,
0.7873461246,
-0.0302642137,
-0.8050835729,
-0.5383321047,
-0.2030201405,
0.0474429168,
0.1150859818,
0.8470478058,
-0.6614729762,
0.6452820897,
0.8147508502,
0.5763565302,
0.3900585771,
0.3509164453,
0.513045609,
-0.6277250051,
0.0910118073,
-0.1286708564,
0.6394761205,
0.1912675649,
-0.5237659216,
0.778624177,
0.123848103,
-0.4916517735,
-0.5380140543,
0.4166212678,
-0.876516521,
-0.598030448,
1.3712031841,
-0.1896089613,
-0.2955165505,
-0.1593943089,
-0.4021291733,
0.3743112683,
-0.4476115704,
0.770144999,
0.6285921335,
-0.4400607049,
-0.3743185103,
-0.3191081583,
-0.0129515138,
0.4247473776,
-1.050134778,
0.1678179055,
0.7180662155,
0.3892654479,
0.3576588631,
0.7984338999,
-0.1619652808,
0.0639555082,
-0.2710383534,
-0.0684056059,
-0.0660507083,
-0.4742144942,
-0.1550097018,
0.0617200546,
-0.1341553032,
0.1435294896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15154v1
|
Do not think pink elephant!
| 2024-04-22T08:28:13 | 2024-04-22T08:28:13 |
Kyomin Hwang, Suyoung Kim, JunHoo Lee, Nojun Kwak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Models (LMs) have heightened expectations for the potential of general
AI as they are akin to human intelligence. This paper shows that recent large
models such as Stable Diffusion and DALL-E3 also share the vulnerability of
human intelligence, namely the "white bear phenomenon". We investigate the
causes of the white bear phenomenon by analyzing their representation space.
Based on this analysis, we propose a simple prompt-based attack method, which
generates figures prohibited by the LM provider's policy. To counter these
attacks, we introduce prompt-based defense strategies inspired by cognitive
therapy techniques, successfully mitigating attacks by up to 48.22\%.
|
[
-0.7728583813,
-1.1535121202,
0.7135215402,
-0.0985870361,
-0.050228022,
-0.0867293328,
-0.0762939081,
-0.6125218272,
0.2586014271,
0.5101710558,
-0.7679072618,
-0.1898252219,
-0.6073910594,
-0.0838027373,
-0.1021489799,
0.9183064103,
0.2866191566,
-0.1704401225,
0.0393112637,
-0.3086012006,
-0.8225553036,
-0.5125106573,
-0.9181739688,
-0.0574036315,
0.5153053999,
-0.0405462869,
1.1575769186,
0.1905366033,
0.4796288013,
0.2588424981,
-0.2485590726,
-0.2631521225,
-0.4520794451,
0.1191755831,
-0.0031165667,
-0.5098851919,
-0.4034146667,
-0.0106192529,
0.4398729801,
0.3757438064,
-0.2570909858,
-0.1043979898,
-0.2048621923,
0.6898233891,
-0.7750377059,
-0.2344416529,
-0.7570733428,
0.1730937213,
-0.0703454539,
0.4138071537,
-0.6582973003,
0.0192023423,
-0.0002430856,
-0.6487221122,
0.1752111316,
0.1859206706,
0.5412724018,
0.31554842,
-0.577570796,
-0.2104026675,
-0.4428465962,
1.0091197491,
-0.4157915413,
-0.3011717796,
0.5409992933,
0.6222454906,
-0.4617764652,
-0.2343988717,
-0.5420052409,
-0.7151976228,
-0.2394593358,
-0.2040984631,
-0.3771082163,
-0.0242105071,
0.7268090844,
-0.2643018365,
-0.5551179051,
0.0740077868,
-0.2875785232,
-0.3139790297,
0.9477120638,
0.3343489766,
0.699113369,
0.1070900336,
-0.3208718002,
-0.0116602844,
-0.7968662977,
0.2038926333,
0.1256132126,
0.0603844225,
0.050489828,
0.4564396143,
0.048647292,
0.6294668913,
-0.0852639079,
0.1287191063,
-0.1305061877,
0.1913802624,
-0.2187463194,
0.3000690043,
0.6208372116,
0.3625299633,
0.1866363585,
-0.0236183237,
-0.4370427728,
0.1912128478,
0.4960127771,
-0.8919709325,
0.0222213194,
0.1924005449,
-0.5284392834,
-0.2438728362,
-0.0680363774,
-0.6583548188,
-0.7001641989,
0.0849777386,
0.6233026385,
-0.4853943884,
-0.5363473296,
-0.0953629166,
0.0965367556,
0.1499902457,
0.2929199338,
-0.7548638582,
0.5968191624,
0.7206637859,
0.7848513722,
-0.0850457251,
0.1239869222,
-0.4005812109,
0.3397537172,
-0.5838749409,
0.5257169604,
-0.3702805638,
-0.7623910904,
-0.0562654547,
0.0480020232,
0.3920485377,
-0.5976678133,
0.374039501,
-0.6902719736,
-0.0788275003,
-0.6064597368,
-0.2301158309,
-0.5587211847,
0.5531677008,
-0.745090127,
0.3576053977,
-0.2011953294,
-0.8071161509,
0.0333275646,
-1.2339087725,
-0.3561163843,
-0.0004256674,
-0.1656993628,
-0.2276650816,
0.0840330124,
0.2761608064,
0.4037040174,
-0.2277692556,
0.0212770775,
-0.7976444364,
-0.3738017678,
0.5861404538,
-0.1327008903,
1.0503416061,
0.4439401031,
-0.2046362758,
0.0885445848,
-0.4999948144,
-0.0875558555,
0.6296886802,
0.360642314,
-0.5475931168,
-0.0054993574,
-0.3435938954,
0.2055110335,
0.1072169244,
-0.4074694514,
0.2351040393,
0.0175249372,
0.5509568453,
0.8703398705,
0.3183070123,
0.4773239791,
-0.6190868616,
0.5556474924,
0.1516110152,
0.1983174682,
-0.213471055,
-0.6767666936,
-0.3629138768,
-0.592060864,
-0.1534851938,
0.4666719735,
-0.6306678653,
0.113140814,
0.2356344163,
-0.4754872024,
-0.3046314716,
-0.0662615746,
0.1409468055,
0.4488820136,
0.406306982,
0.1686136276,
0.1832597256,
-0.9365437031,
-0.172036916,
0.0611251406,
-0.0574025288,
-0.0369659849,
0.5089541674,
-0.4731750488,
0.8264914751,
-0.803984046,
-0.101666823,
0.0898679495,
0.352560699,
0.361403048,
0.7791019082,
0.9774618745,
-0.9739900827,
-0.2273754179,
-0.4401476085,
-0.6473688483,
0.3152686656,
-0.0847098902,
-0.1585703343,
0.4467971623,
0.6323536038,
-1.1345223188,
0.3091243505,
0.0867396966,
-0.4040023386,
0.2758205831,
-0.3037225008,
-0.0227279067,
-0.8957682252,
-0.036098104,
0.2476314008,
0.1153100953,
-0.6201797724,
0.1182515249,
0.0027374127,
-0.4638967216,
-0.3989219069,
0.6676730514,
-0.3238160908,
0.072541669,
-0.2549373507,
-0.0127401343,
-0.3328504264,
0.3592935801,
-0.1492230445,
0.4850795269,
0.6598868966,
-0.6970670819,
0.1830906421,
0.1801119596,
-0.2315676808,
0.620451808,
-0.6348149776,
0.399756819,
-0.3503390849,
0.2499643117,
-1.0746181011,
-0.0918494388,
0.4726439416,
-0.3425626755,
0.6336948872,
0.3341424763,
-0.3620031774,
-0.3740149438,
-0.5230519176,
0.5000079274,
0.9396187663,
-0.3469386399,
0.6238651872,
0.2170266062,
-0.4046494067,
-0.6588674188,
-0.6905516982,
0.1678047627,
-0.5560628772,
-0.876290977,
0.1390223354,
-0.4933675528,
-0.5697349906,
0.117489785,
0.1612508297,
0.0239887331,
0.5443512201,
0.1810781509,
0.2491531074,
-0.1978024393,
-0.0319608562,
-0.3303666711,
-0.1313337833,
0.4413291812,
0.1391696632,
0.119705312,
0.1621674299,
-0.6633576155,
-0.670435369,
0.4905996025,
0.7606315017,
-0.0654514953,
0.6658632755,
0.3807469308,
-0.6758264899,
-0.1463019699,
-0.4262142777,
-0.4857954979,
-0.4755186439,
0.6164853573,
-0.0466016792,
-0.512506485,
0.3982075155,
0.2825805247,
0.152537182,
0.3389233649,
0.4419328272,
-0.1573804319,
1.6190069914,
0.4456461668,
-0.2912293077,
0.3803355694,
-0.1773368269,
0.0520513654,
-0.7499705553,
-0.1598860323,
-0.2747274339,
-0.5890665054,
-0.4815368652,
-0.003475501,
0.2904163599,
-0.0670726821,
-0.782207787,
-0.1199432388,
-0.5226799846,
0.1816385835,
0.4450004101,
0.1500737071,
-0.2599247396,
-0.1139030084,
0.2231840044,
-0.0805839151,
-0.4361540973,
-0.3939883113,
0.903635323,
0.4501244724,
0.8923972249,
0.3588494956,
0.355134815,
0.7827215791,
0.5142306685,
-0.5713641047,
0.8576214314,
0.3196530342,
-0.8519287109,
-0.5190442204,
-0.3354519308,
-1.025198102,
0.4031166732,
-0.5093208551,
-0.8909005523,
-0.2158785909,
-0.0148180705,
-0.6181035638,
0.2160479575,
-0.7273022532,
0.5976212621,
-0.4362295568,
-0.1290809959,
-0.494530499,
-0.3680790365,
0.6205873489,
-0.3585000038,
0.423510164,
-0.1967033446,
-0.1986682713,
0.7769430876,
-0.2585103214,
0.7951689363,
-0.4682911336,
0.1077566966,
0.5193762183,
0.3990969956,
0.7832471728,
0.1803565472,
0.0659156665,
-0.0697598606,
-0.2037473619,
-0.9347669482,
-0.6033918262,
0.4257143438,
-0.8808833361,
-1.1612912416,
-0.5972200036,
-0.684150815,
-0.2247617543,
-0.1086527333,
0.1025889814,
-0.0569386147,
-0.3030401468,
0.008806617,
0.6846085787,
-0.3566002548,
0.7179263234,
0.5327137709,
-0.1119453907,
-0.5887492299,
0.730178535,
0.3200609684,
0.3605166972,
-0.0668237358,
0.0101382863,
-0.0684539899,
-0.5399218798,
0.0353363417,
0.4270940125,
-0.6534701586,
-0.1855921298,
-0.6584587097,
-0.0702487379,
-0.3162928522,
-0.5167054534,
0.0121343285,
-0.1552211046,
-0.2656188905,
-0.020644078,
0.387211591,
0.8526061177,
0.0076509458,
0.4673209488,
-0.7367013693,
0.2637602687,
0.7571804523,
-0.3465065062,
0.2553631663,
-0.3258290291,
-0.0892450362,
0.2810966372,
-0.7455518246,
-0.7837998271,
0.3077537119,
-0.5360186696,
0.7628003955,
0.8090506196,
0.358512491,
0.1796442568,
-0.2577392161,
0.8383684158,
0.6661641002,
-0.7576216459,
0.4049626589,
-0.3478861451,
0.1674970835,
-0.0738325194,
0.419023186,
-0.2049912661,
-0.2161628455,
-0.861166358,
-0.4069411755,
0.8679909706,
0.1599870324,
0.2910945415,
-0.0337243602,
0.35690853,
-0.3285347223,
0.0668501556,
-0.6683270335,
-0.0131891398,
-0.0718740597,
0.0839739963,
-0.0651553497,
-0.5366617441,
-0.479018718,
0.1066856608,
0.6980888844,
-0.0585833155,
0.120754756,
-0.0121435663,
-0.0791512281,
-0.1856487989,
0.025029907,
0.8594146371,
0.5497003794,
-0.1962920576,
-0.0688850209,
0.581848979,
-0.3559705913,
0.4024223983,
-0.1188931093,
-0.2775932848,
-0.2547315955,
0.5669336319,
0.5325058699,
0.015508309,
-0.6089821458,
0.5189023614,
0.008892253,
-0.0129729696,
-0.3634031713,
0.2640970051,
0.0693191141,
0.3593182564,
0.388495177,
0.0615471415,
-0.0876071677,
-0.6551795006,
-0.186233446,
0.8500768542,
-0.4564413726,
-0.4933726788,
0.6714304686,
0.1419473141,
-0.4585868418,
0.8055573106,
-0.2228177339,
-0.4483194053,
1.1721278429,
0.666256845,
0.776740849,
-0.492105335,
0.2626720667,
0.3255870938,
0.5827258229,
-0.139841482,
0.1394260973,
0.1140418053,
-0.5554119945,
-0.1264986843,
-0.0753532276,
-0.2289363891,
0.237611711,
-0.6387682557,
0.5498784184,
-0.802836597,
-0.3726255,
-0.1258912534,
-0.1293575019,
-0.2631467283,
0.079231061,
0.5179593563,
1.1050115824,
-0.6005060673,
0.5392220616,
0.7874556184,
-0.3567663431,
-0.3366348147,
0.1005930901,
0.0219765734,
-0.7932254076,
0.8601119518,
0.2820844352,
0.3404975235,
-0.4854183793,
-0.8705974817,
-0.7500635982,
1.1567596197,
0.6656547785,
-0.4369075298,
0.2147523016,
-0.275036782,
0.1400441825,
-0.4713620842,
0.1545951366,
0.3921931088,
0.7229418159,
0.1736106873,
-0.2744564712,
0.3991099298,
0.0467847474,
0.1682062149,
0.3194167912,
-0.7696955204,
0.9631872177,
-0.72245121,
-0.1177668571,
0.0461157225,
0.5108885765,
0.5786288381,
0.4497641921,
0.7828283906,
0.5102905035,
0.9643548131,
0.2265301496,
1.1431423426,
-0.0897871256,
0.163591221,
0.6271071434,
-0.4872610867,
0.5779498219,
0.1900489628,
-0.0619919635,
0.1148418263,
0.6797642112,
-0.1705482155,
0.7926772237,
0.4159854949,
-0.3641053736,
-0.1996677369,
0.1614263803,
-0.6161025167,
0.0110564129,
0.5895757675,
0.0092584016,
-0.1529577971,
0.1865395308,
0.3415198326,
-0.0167230275,
-0.6760284305,
0.8193432689,
0.2052592337,
-0.4835402966,
0.672748208,
-0.3661677241,
0.5468046069,
-0.6649189591,
-0.0358757414,
-0.0359671228,
-0.0597999021,
0.1003703922,
-0.4971454144,
0.1000899673,
-0.280374974,
-0.2653544247,
0.250823468,
0.500438273,
0.0181943234,
-0.4988275766,
0.4479080439,
0.0913615003,
-0.0428162776,
-0.1360655427,
-0.9316790104,
-0.0691302419,
-0.1260857731,
-0.410779804,
0.6035449505,
0.7717168331,
-0.4292025864,
0.8481667638,
0.5964624882,
-0.0549800955,
-0.2617287934,
-0.5584124923,
0.7639726996,
-0.9998700023,
-0.6626588106,
-1.0819306374,
0.3117979765,
-0.2884565592,
0.1904430389,
0.2239067703,
-0.0299417768,
0.3456277549,
-0.0280066431,
0.7572250962,
0.148761034,
0.2368453443,
-0.5807736516,
1.160828948,
-0.5287473798,
0.1893181056,
-0.1577294767,
-1.0550836325,
-0.1442091763,
0.2982752025,
-0.4196064472,
0.2255519331,
0.7194457054,
0.8568359017,
0.1438446045,
0.1679567546,
0.5910147429,
0.6891120672,
0.566989243,
0.64072299,
1.2054334879,
0.2493752688,
0.54711169,
0.1747894287,
-0.4652451575,
-0.5327373147,
-0.9200105071,
-1.1801691055,
-0.2967086732,
-0.4476093054,
-0.4668217301,
-0.0377401151,
0.788315475,
0.7481992245,
-0.8400752544,
0.1944735199,
0.2207285017,
0.2277649194,
-0.1037745252,
-0.1051738635,
0.5195712447,
-0.4465623796,
-0.303684622,
-0.0415308885,
0.1074143276,
0.4057388902,
-0.3894031346,
-0.180713132,
-0.0107463561,
0.2407397479,
0.5145510435,
0.3696907461,
-0.7949413657,
-0.3301683068,
-0.3123313189,
-0.2389327437,
-0.2449135631,
0.5330918431,
-0.6777967215,
0.21025002,
0.0811199769,
0.841140449,
0.0602942109,
-0.295866996,
0.4781149328,
-0.1051704586,
0.6505382657,
0.2909030914,
0.6726794839,
0.2910070419,
-0.7655351758,
0.4761293828,
0.188599363,
-0.4376740456,
-1.0106658936,
0.3118545115,
-0.7197739482,
-0.6681652665,
0.8808883429,
-0.2096944898,
-0.456140995,
0.2543152273,
-0.65212816,
-0.1649525762,
-0.6115564704,
1.2522625923,
0.7741539478,
-0.1260672957,
0.0575498715,
-0.940593183,
0.4744962454,
0.3946374059,
-0.6922332644,
-0.2395720929,
0.2995838821,
0.1630125046,
0.5442740917,
0.4493657649,
0.1262512803,
0.3545643389,
-0.1987242848,
-0.0694505423,
-0.1926037967,
-0.0571439415,
-0.3298733532,
0.4663556814,
0.0576406904,
-0.3845912814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13968v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13968v2
|
Protecting Your LLMs with Information Bottleneck
| 2024-04-22T08:16:07 | 2024-05-16T13:26:57 |
Zichuan Liu, Zefan Wang, Linjie Xu, Jinyu Wang, Lei Song, Tianchun Wang, Chunlin Chen, Wei Cheng, Jiang Bian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
The advent of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized the field of
natural language processing, yet they might be attacked to produce harmful
content. Despite efforts to ethically align LLMs, these are often fragile and
can be circumvented by jailbreaking attacks through optimized or manual
adversarial prompts. To address this, we introduce the Information Bottleneck
Protector (IBProtector), a defense mechanism grounded in the information
bottleneck principle, and we modify the objective to avoid trivial solutions.
The IBProtector selectively compresses and perturbs prompts, facilitated by a
lightweight and trainable extractor, preserving only essential information for
the target LLMs to respond with the expected answer. Moreover, we further
consider a situation where the gradient is not visible to be compatible with
any LLM. Our empirical evaluations show that IBProtector outperforms current
defense methods in mitigating jailbreak attempts, without overly affecting
response quality or inference speed. Its effectiveness and adaptability across
various attack methods and target LLMs underscore the potential of IBProtector
as a novel, transferable defense that bolsters the security of LLMs without
requiring modifications to the underlying models.
|
[
-0.7639402151,
-0.9636673331,
0.1537759602,
0.170463562,
0.0331713185,
0.2856816947,
-0.0493661277,
-0.5538965464,
-0.1009549424,
0.8196511865,
-0.4664158821,
-0.0930377319,
-0.6475719213,
0.0787195414,
-0.3194580078,
1.2566761971,
0.1148787439,
-0.2601329982,
-0.3616922498,
0.1103232875,
-0.555089891,
-0.4402185082,
-0.6928543448,
-0.2349724323,
0.3070126474,
0.343508333,
0.6345754266,
0.8870691657,
0.7808531523,
0.2596074641,
-0.2040506452,
-0.1080932543,
-0.4437289536,
0.565451622,
-0.2697191834,
-0.5294104815,
-0.2427143306,
-0.2615795732,
0.293273747,
0.3331403136,
-0.0973635986,
0.0680038333,
0.1340521127,
0.9287355542,
-0.9452944994,
-0.1533620656,
-1.0020030737,
0.0358247124,
-0.4894458055,
-0.0497392155,
-0.3986726403,
-0.2283204645,
-0.0639992058,
-0.2920298874,
0.162357986,
0.458399266,
0.8323280811,
0.2583642006,
0.0718339756,
-0.2902593613,
-0.5352050662,
0.4051572978,
-0.324655354,
-0.0694059357,
0.1904991716,
0.4554609358,
-0.290625602,
-0.5142221451,
-0.6189655066,
-0.2722224891,
0.1705815345,
-0.1308338642,
-0.80716151,
0.383572787,
0.55365628,
0.3409795463,
-0.7214385867,
0.3610485196,
-0.6114621758,
-0.4773141742,
0.3732152581,
0.1984878629,
0.3962037861,
-0.0419800766,
-0.7952346206,
0.05725912,
-1.0442384481,
0.3087176085,
0.4473675191,
0.0357876122,
0.2202085555,
0.5295912623,
-0.0434621461,
0.794354558,
0.0513001978,
-0.1899376959,
-0.1243955046,
0.0468100123,
-0.0261336137,
0.3240754008,
0.9905207753,
0.3504793644,
0.4454411566,
-0.2782675028,
-0.328790307,
-0.0432499498,
0.5585663915,
-1.0449761152,
-0.1550445259,
0.3602149487,
-0.1785899252,
-0.3643738329,
0.2194764465,
-0.8941452503,
-0.6294092536,
0.2421708256,
0.0984769762,
-0.4134652019,
-0.0965316817,
-0.0553287975,
-0.1073623374,
-0.0193212219,
-0.1287505031,
-0.8252034783,
0.4644427598,
0.8410536051,
1.0820889473,
-0.1938291639,
0.0603628643,
-0.7532119751,
0.2979705036,
-0.1833098978,
0.8849359751,
-0.3077752888,
-0.4225981832,
-0.180383116,
-0.3870297968,
0.1016257852,
-0.8352814317,
0.623483777,
-0.5766434669,
-0.4315512776,
-0.109413527,
-0.5145496726,
0.173555851,
0.3251109719,
-0.8991962075,
0.7744934559,
-0.0222300496,
-1.0625789165,
0.000866705,
-0.7034055591,
-0.5013684034,
0.143883124,
0.0208993554,
-0.489246726,
0.0785748959,
0.2615005374,
0.351585418,
-0.5161125064,
0.1535563618,
-0.4904780388,
-0.2911672294,
0.2772627175,
-0.351888448,
0.6720294356,
0.5327968597,
-0.008860142,
-0.1630163789,
-0.6646497846,
-0.0778770894,
0.1194828451,
-0.3774729669,
-0.3537608087,
-0.1293642223,
-0.3543993235,
0.0712912083,
0.2760723531,
-0.7186436057,
0.4427683353,
-0.2577935755,
0.4587342143,
0.9617339373,
0.0495278351,
0.266780436,
-0.4542480111,
0.6663554907,
-0.071834147,
0.2446657419,
-0.098621659,
-0.1550523341,
-0.5154870152,
-0.5643634796,
-0.017227862,
0.8738210797,
-0.8390383124,
0.3471476138,
-0.1740361452,
-0.4387010634,
-0.6943538189,
0.5156314969,
0.5650026202,
0.667884171,
0.2981369793,
-0.2721382976,
-0.5342197418,
-0.9579166174,
-0.6936485171,
-0.2794596255,
-0.0682631209,
0.0004753389,
0.1553620398,
-0.0234254915,
0.9587779045,
-0.5656737685,
-0.1922981888,
-0.6081408262,
0.2671246529,
0.3998325169,
0.5170169473,
0.5269946456,
-0.7048928142,
-0.3285312951,
-0.3792594075,
-0.7307161689,
-0.8047171235,
-0.1493285,
-0.0633407682,
-0.2998854518,
0.7038786411,
-0.9392088652,
0.2688676715,
0.2076601535,
-0.2864028811,
0.7011318207,
0.1305442452,
-0.4235841632,
-0.7765027881,
-0.0659273192,
-0.0435455143,
-0.2924379706,
-0.9380610585,
0.0690831244,
-0.1493316442,
-0.0100218179,
-0.3111073375,
0.6458793879,
-0.2512498796,
0.2548218369,
-0.5321250558,
0.1715645343,
0.0666095391,
0.0713811666,
-0.3142736852,
0.8362606764,
0.5968686342,
-0.7926892042,
0.4330406487,
0.2233439386,
-0.5287768245,
1.0311158895,
-0.7899391651,
0.1793491989,
-0.4042717814,
0.1174345091,
-0.4974374473,
0.0251947921,
0.3789812326,
-0.2846327126,
0.5791816115,
-0.2257513702,
-0.4206400216,
-0.5623969436,
-0.5868909955,
0.1049729362,
0.2821047306,
-0.6467788219,
0.6378669143,
0.3189328313,
-0.5017793179,
-0.96447891,
-0.7241601944,
0.2989997864,
-0.4039800167,
-0.6230791807,
0.3287223577,
-0.4056344628,
-0.4827875495,
-0.1424609721,
-0.2555406094,
-0.1667468548,
0.5292689204,
0.462172091,
0.47532776,
-0.051133316,
-0.0243981499,
-0.3118801415,
-0.1843298674,
0.1708350778,
-0.2210523635,
0.4636049271,
-0.0702893808,
-0.2450676411,
-0.2579012215,
0.324654758,
0.6353955865,
-0.0641657934,
0.6997233033,
0.4602241516,
-0.1257569045,
-0.1183268502,
-0.8008179069,
-0.065055646,
-0.543593049,
0.5104994178,
-0.4983106852,
-0.9731023908,
0.1918647438,
-0.0362264886,
0.0465589762,
0.1048996747,
0.342684567,
-0.0381703116,
0.6484901309,
0.5397277474,
-0.6283684969,
0.63897717,
0.1003170237,
0.3665849864,
-1.2216658592,
-0.0676920488,
-0.4101206362,
-0.1666145772,
-0.3867764175,
0.0886007547,
0.4432055652,
0.6564186811,
-0.4538308382,
0.445166707,
-0.5262741446,
0.7043564916,
0.5434711576,
-0.0780829042,
0.1197082475,
-0.202057153,
0.1202659383,
0.1895476878,
-0.74424541,
-0.6406198144,
0.9774267673,
0.474586606,
1.0668344498,
0.2662319243,
0.5238032341,
0.4246284962,
0.5129265785,
-0.4419352114,
0.6707853079,
-0.0043512932,
-0.856377244,
0.0295955706,
-0.6930912137,
-0.825638473,
0.4042813182,
-0.1346737891,
-1.3819483519,
0.0024701299,
0.4070321918,
-0.3525668681,
0.4624112844,
-0.4379146099,
0.6687777042,
-0.4209845364,
-0.6122307777,
0.271394968,
-0.6280963421,
0.5007152557,
-0.1530389488,
0.2654782534,
-0.3178979456,
0.114359431,
0.5186534524,
-0.5103269219,
0.7184917927,
-0.2632389367,
0.2620937228,
0.4765028954,
0.3774310052,
0.7481463552,
0.0601688363,
0.1188590154,
0.0790493041,
-0.2340964824,
-0.2355285436,
-0.4269686639,
0.4265686572,
-0.2729356289,
-1.214957118,
-0.281694591,
-0.6910372972,
0.0627489388,
0.2595083714,
0.5140221715,
-0.034580823,
-0.1518342942,
0.2516207397,
0.7283763289,
-0.1136260331,
0.4803152382,
0.7559500933,
0.1167625934,
-0.2843639255,
0.9622078538,
-0.0187977348,
0.5641212463,
0.4660934508,
0.3208943307,
-0.0176925622,
-0.6868633032,
-0.1900340617,
-0.2582414746,
-0.6774548292,
-0.6944667101,
-0.7537030578,
-0.3597815931,
-0.2071896791,
-0.119242169,
-0.4626688063,
-0.1964231431,
0.0107251247,
-0.1794839948,
0.401458323,
0.493944943,
-0.2038860321,
0.5134915709,
-0.6163749099,
0.3991582096,
0.0773099884,
-0.0412978455,
-0.2329260707,
-0.3015100062,
0.0233703423,
-0.3237174153,
-0.6167399883,
-0.5339195728,
0.3390510976,
0.1932130009,
0.4431158304,
0.7016640902,
0.4534273744,
0.3965874016,
-0.4950524271,
0.5121766925,
0.3789967,
-0.9759787321,
0.3405498266,
0.1406051815,
0.3178292513,
0.6887052059,
0.22142829,
-0.3829244971,
-0.664953649,
-0.161052689,
-1.1463230848,
0.307028234,
0.0791644827,
-0.1136536971,
-0.0171080939,
0.231744945,
-0.0569591448,
0.4140975177,
-0.9778910875,
0.0327849761,
-0.1053629071,
-0.2766773999,
0.5073006153,
-0.4012911916,
-0.226741448,
0.2902852893,
0.4840553105,
-0.0493626446,
0.1657236516,
0.2276316285,
-0.2248363495,
0.1472088993,
0.4658409655,
0.1625671983,
0.168422997,
-0.0811810195,
0.3883289397,
0.0894794092,
-0.7375952005,
0.2326918989,
0.1836624146,
-0.3920781314,
-0.3708126247,
0.6963235736,
0.8417798281,
-0.1961881369,
-0.8929337859,
0.6629114151,
-0.0005943422,
0.2365617901,
-0.1125501394,
0.3658492863,
-0.3169215918,
0.3719015419,
0.3057871759,
0.0420832075,
0.0983464867,
-0.3947923779,
0.1254817396,
0.7002683878,
-0.2983262241,
0.0045553902,
0.6592079997,
-0.1483155191,
-0.2364546955,
0.4553903043,
0.0396381728,
-0.8159434795,
0.578070581,
0.559320271,
0.8452377915,
-0.4451395869,
-0.2325739115,
-0.0755795315,
0.6230741143,
-0.2352348864,
0.1273477674,
-0.0894833282,
-0.8398792148,
-0.0100778323,
-0.526981473,
-0.3134807646,
0.1914444268,
-0.7018716931,
0.0045959996,
-0.7674419284,
-0.2316084653,
-0.0746194795,
-0.4019347727,
-0.4492804408,
-0.0453232378,
0.0754355788,
1.1220036745,
-0.2596127093,
0.5633627176,
0.014583772,
-0.2140411735,
-0.2458412796,
0.0793824196,
0.2580098808,
-0.779016614,
0.7476186752,
0.485367924,
-0.2497094423,
-0.4299184084,
-0.6012293696,
-0.7708697319,
0.8981539011,
0.6695502996,
-1.0470187664,
0.080488503,
0.1236811578,
0.2421096563,
-0.3881562948,
0.1161970869,
0.6309450865,
0.4012484252,
-0.0287099984,
-0.5171796679,
0.2052684873,
-0.2195880264,
-0.0923414901,
0.2105742991,
-0.5127274394,
0.8226358891,
-0.3814340532,
-0.3182144165,
0.2559305131,
0.315926373,
0.2375356555,
0.2020307183,
0.5589398742,
0.6819577813,
0.8315159082,
-0.2298810631,
1.3469187021,
-0.6062378883,
-0.13946338,
1.1421798468,
-0.3586778045,
0.5772782564,
0.5473795533,
0.0841701999,
0.1901492923,
0.3017910123,
-0.3127001524,
0.5406451225,
0.7327091098,
-0.561686635,
0.0935119018,
-0.3632707,
-0.1991285086,
0.3910524845,
0.3788839877,
-0.2863461971,
0.0886860862,
0.1741522104,
0.5431099534,
-0.0498976819,
-0.5063607693,
0.7803629041,
0.1613169611,
-0.6053807735,
0.6086505651,
-0.1491846591,
0.6016836166,
-0.7777184844,
0.3607855737,
-0.0646033809,
0.3092277646,
-0.140927732,
-0.73252666,
0.2716531456,
0.3726720214,
-0.1755047739,
-0.0626822934,
0.9567211866,
-0.2374424338,
-0.2092998475,
0.4537638426,
0.0276823901,
-0.0921240896,
-0.2013911009,
-0.5797194839,
0.3553571403,
-0.2776181698,
-0.4673575759,
0.3071926236,
0.2400804907,
0.0876324549,
1.1434580088,
0.5994418859,
0.4379228055,
-0.0574270487,
-0.2880069613,
1.198546648,
-0.5280861259,
-0.3688932359,
-1.3611342907,
0.2046991289,
-0.3805401623,
-0.1670233756,
0.5937337279,
0.5137556195,
0.7059819102,
0.2537356913,
1.1150904894,
0.0200246554,
0.4112657011,
-0.75465554,
0.6536191106,
0.0339327678,
0.7582859993,
-0.2662425935,
-0.8366295695,
-0.1024046019,
0.4732981324,
-0.2418375015,
-0.2855602801,
0.4617851377,
0.8636009693,
0.2748000324,
-0.1025266349,
0.0811716244,
0.4503960609,
0.5954170823,
0.8354889154,
0.7139892578,
0.1166020557,
0.7940481305,
-0.0598332621,
-0.3282475471,
-0.0411871038,
-0.9768227935,
-1.1638759375,
0.0534561388,
-0.1308139414,
-0.5026406646,
0.451294601,
0.8036811352,
0.6795531511,
-0.6675729156,
-0.2509136796,
-0.3697018027,
0.3692249954,
-0.0527575649,
-0.28077209,
-0.0915741771,
-0.2634380758,
-0.2374255657,
0.4968963265,
0.5413746834,
0.0260679144,
-0.2241403759,
0.1550070047,
0.1206632033,
0.2874216735,
0.2131329924,
0.6863886118,
-0.4647911191,
-0.1645256579,
-0.5355991125,
-0.1345809251,
0.0698714107,
0.9848110676,
-0.4836529791,
0.6631415486,
0.2339660376,
1.0267258883,
0.2521274984,
-0.0505943969,
0.7616533041,
-0.7672752738,
0.2459412217,
0.2417483032,
0.4843558967,
0.4796753228,
-0.6128058434,
0.4467457831,
0.2025432587,
-0.3400557935,
-1.0193215609,
0.5799411535,
-0.6136369109,
-0.3883177936,
0.8809321523,
-0.4002061188,
-0.3346024156,
-0.1422265917,
-0.1047365665,
-0.1657107919,
-0.4551029503,
0.9748683572,
0.6958556771,
-0.0851887912,
-0.2123291492,
-0.6883477569,
0.5126179457,
-0.0101623703,
-0.8282333612,
0.2386320233,
0.0013544949,
0.1784675568,
0.2919357717,
0.2123041749,
-0.0305204,
0.0134520847,
-0.1033150703,
0.129624486,
-0.3758339584,
-0.4000935256,
-0.1420461386,
0.4294233918,
-0.0125076612,
-0.1253512502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13957v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13957v1
|
How Well Can LLMs Echo Us? Evaluating AI Chatbots' Role-Play Ability with ECHO
| 2024-04-22T08:00:51 | 2024-04-22T08:00:51 |
Man Tik Ng, Hui Tung Tse, Jen-tse Huang, Jingjing Li, Wenxuan Wang, Michael R. Lyu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The role-play ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has emerged as a
popular research direction. However, existing studies focus on imitating
well-known public figures or fictional characters, overlooking the potential
for simulating ordinary individuals. Such an oversight limits the potential for
advancements in digital human clones and non-player characters in video games.
To bridge this gap, we introduce ECHO, an evaluative framework inspired by the
Turing test. This framework engages the acquaintances of the target individuals
to distinguish between human and machine-generated responses. Notably, our
framework focuses on emulating average individuals rather than historical or
fictional figures, presenting a unique advantage to apply the Turing Test. We
evaluated three role-playing LLMs using ECHO, with GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 serving as
foundational models, alongside the online application GPTs from OpenAI. Our
results demonstrate that GPT-4 more effectively deceives human evaluators, and
GPTs achieves a leading success rate of 48.3%. Furthermore, we investigated
whether LLMs could discern between human-generated and machine-generated texts.
While GPT-4 can identify differences, it could not determine which texts were
human-produced. Our code and results of reproducing the role-playing LLMs are
made publicly available via https://github.com/CUHK-ARISE/ECHO.
|
[
-0.5340402126,
-0.9607917666,
0.6718637943,
0.0229629222,
-0.2237832099,
0.4785067737,
-0.1223206446,
-0.6441465616,
0.2938465178,
0.4631916285,
-0.42350173,
-0.3214975297,
-0.59555161,
0.2929775119,
-0.5193030238,
0.7542638183,
0.1762970239,
0.0870264247,
-0.2213902622,
0.2521133125,
-0.1493469775,
-0.6758924723,
-0.8864679337,
-0.3530853093,
0.389508307,
0.1321183294,
0.6935730577,
0.4123542011,
0.4583085179,
0.3586439192,
0.2438042164,
0.3035388589,
-0.7082517743,
0.1876399368,
0.2694499493,
-0.5767392516,
-0.354622215,
0.2131522149,
0.4680212438,
0.2227078229,
-0.0197457839,
0.120631963,
0.3797469735,
0.2100771219,
-0.3214602768,
0.2366520315,
-0.637429893,
-0.0288896896,
0.0366880298,
-0.2808086574,
-0.3533558846,
-0.3893268108,
0.0298209731,
-0.7020110488,
0.2496524751,
0.1363997459,
0.6701437235,
0.3486673236,
-0.0305000488,
-0.5129420757,
-1.0096079111,
0.6300708055,
-0.7097215652,
0.2677277923,
0.5118733048,
0.1935086846,
-0.2851312459,
-0.566557169,
-0.6206489205,
-0.4679830968,
0.1151294932,
0.3414393663,
-0.4573982656,
0.2201205045,
0.3037933111,
0.2272116691,
-0.3237488866,
0.1710287631,
-0.2945513129,
-0.1576404124,
0.5509805679,
0.2111049443,
0.5496558547,
0.129002288,
-0.4359103143,
-0.2154596746,
-0.5842937827,
0.1297439188,
0.6512381434,
0.2073668391,
-0.0542731471,
0.4960006475,
0.4377692044,
0.1810425073,
0.1201431304,
-0.0050013564,
-0.0834329948,
0.1184801012,
-0.12446931,
-0.1162709817,
0.9877434373,
0.2837366164,
0.3240472674,
-0.0471087918,
-0.2872339189,
0.2832278907,
0.3925832808,
-0.5993654132,
0.0738706216,
0.2136022747,
-0.5971435905,
-0.2862051427,
0.0644089356,
-0.9214702249,
-0.8411774635,
0.037243709,
0.6590515971,
-0.2617512047,
-0.3725867271,
-0.1634618938,
-0.215977475,
0.1956823915,
0.2505141199,
-0.8669275641,
0.7635189891,
0.9526875019,
0.7102637291,
-0.2809979618,
-0.5767085552,
-0.4836485386,
-0.321891278,
-0.5343384147,
0.7136263251,
-0.6008712053,
-0.7374764681,
-0.0374130644,
-0.3282331228,
0.0016450358,
-0.6964252591,
0.3153779507,
-0.2762146294,
0.4560543299,
0.0395614244,
-0.7255082726,
0.0158238746,
0.2256605476,
-0.7873080969,
0.7795886397,
-0.0182832666,
-0.3531005681,
0.1000316292,
-0.8222153783,
-0.2382995933,
0.0517432913,
-0.4289128184,
-0.4886454642,
0.2344050407,
0.3036389649,
0.4709322453,
-0.5038912296,
-0.0940964073,
-0.3516308367,
-1.0374851227,
0.4572741389,
-0.9423126578,
0.4919027388,
0.0458562039,
-0.6616858244,
0.1062170118,
-0.0783731118,
0.0111342669,
-0.0141669558,
-0.1213305965,
0.0782546997,
0.2864687145,
-0.0591975898,
-0.0532420576,
-0.0345293209,
-0.4031756222,
0.0565479025,
-0.1060796827,
0.3264802396,
0.768279016,
0.0276107658,
0.16581361,
-0.6535144448,
1.0282201767,
-0.4836609662,
0.0639717951,
-0.2915552258,
-0.8198618293,
-0.4178064167,
-0.7053185105,
0.2209054679,
0.6079770327,
-0.577996254,
0.4836199284,
-0.2165208757,
-0.3988355994,
-1.0355718136,
0.018764561,
0.3509931266,
0.1101717353,
0.2043824345,
-0.2589409351,
-0.6182593703,
-0.7990294099,
-0.3115692735,
-0.6236618161,
-0.5024940968,
0.5545063615,
0.2887470424,
-0.2955852449,
0.7286424637,
-0.0331413709,
-0.2757003605,
-0.456378758,
0.1987838298,
0.0384714529,
0.0124749085,
0.2300725132,
-0.5693028569,
-0.3979105353,
-0.2312446833,
-0.71714288,
-0.2053188682,
-0.3856692314,
0.1419461221,
0.1063574255,
0.1920215935,
-0.6559512615,
0.4447125494,
0.8083052039,
-0.3150107861,
0.3254395425,
-0.3582234681,
0.6011560559,
-1.0670009851,
0.1501712799,
-0.3435155451,
-0.3182063997,
-0.3173369467,
-0.0224263351,
-0.4430933595,
-0.1615042537,
-0.2241509855,
0.5103356242,
-0.3838541508,
-0.3813614249,
-0.3024534285,
0.2187137157,
-0.2232462764,
0.3228287101,
-0.0929557756,
0.9651730657,
0.3863110244,
-0.3134633005,
0.312418282,
0.0088253561,
-0.3842230737,
0.4959920049,
-0.6702682376,
0.3819580376,
0.1835944653,
0.4132114947,
-1.117120862,
-0.1771154106,
0.3262189627,
-0.6034825444,
0.0332873836,
-0.2323432416,
-0.6121851206,
-0.3456997275,
-0.4240623713,
0.008235015,
1.2134883404,
-0.5813555121,
0.8258680701,
0.5284685493,
-0.0455507897,
-0.3538117409,
-0.373342216,
0.2744609714,
-0.4268524349,
-0.2820345461,
-0.0409320295,
-0.1751522124,
-0.3127275109,
-0.1892110854,
0.0767133981,
-0.1536576897,
0.3458818197,
0.4312776029,
0.2864467502,
-0.1923379004,
-0.1061354876,
-0.3135847449,
-0.0332193188,
0.069886826,
0.0861765742,
0.6574674249,
-0.2520046532,
-0.7947737575,
-0.7711991668,
0.2881555259,
0.5843815207,
0.0202794988,
0.0906817093,
0.5933925509,
-0.169738993,
-0.1294834763,
-0.548969388,
-0.3803226948,
-0.4800761044,
0.4075717032,
-0.1675526798,
-0.8100320697,
0.4979820251,
-0.1112364754,
0.1433428526,
0.1647398472,
0.4229592085,
-0.5040897131,
1.194204092,
0.1780970395,
-0.301889956,
0.351662904,
-0.0910601541,
0.0371470563,
-0.684599936,
0.255099088,
-0.2745012939,
-0.5862845182,
-0.8572379947,
-0.5875509977,
0.3476419747,
0.0425764397,
-0.095861569,
0.0719091445,
-0.3756829202,
0.6093614697,
0.5972912312,
0.1009915471,
0.2021141052,
0.0013751778,
0.3528732359,
-0.1207273379,
-0.3523533642,
-0.8023575544,
1.1323578358,
0.5250856876,
0.7453330159,
0.1026413962,
0.9974494576,
0.6085720062,
0.5809136033,
-0.652423799,
0.635402441,
-0.0277323648,
-0.6007413268,
-0.4340040982,
-0.3709471524,
-1.2138363123,
0.2505531013,
-0.2940838337,
-0.7689689994,
-0.4944044352,
0.2866508067,
-0.231451273,
0.5203139186,
-0.6856130958,
0.5530024767,
-0.2950551212,
-0.1900008172,
-0.2383910418,
-0.2329182029,
0.1157911941,
-0.0673363134,
0.2573641837,
-0.1080217361,
-0.212795198,
0.4181888402,
0.0613266714,
1.1603621244,
-0.1622468382,
-0.0495762192,
0.671816051,
0.4435729086,
0.3008113801,
-0.0556777306,
0.0294414554,
0.3955870271,
-0.129084751,
-0.2124746591,
-0.8205952644,
0.5040308833,
-0.7950889468,
-0.781752944,
-0.2787384689,
-0.2022187859,
-0.1718731076,
0.1428555846,
0.0073134047,
0.1705590189,
-0.6720418334,
0.2286125422,
0.2944765985,
-0.1352182627,
0.4143435061,
0.3030867577,
-0.4039355218,
-0.3631591797,
1.024242878,
-0.3961541057,
0.1834591329,
0.310010612,
0.3814057708,
-0.246263057,
-0.3075060546,
-0.5044568777,
0.0480716303,
-0.2716023028,
0.1153209358,
-0.251925379,
-0.1360091567,
-0.1510269791,
-0.0554309189,
-0.3184729815,
-0.0686279908,
-0.2315052599,
0.0481556766,
0.1333527118,
1.2130331993,
-0.0612444542,
0.1959256381,
-0.7009050846,
0.3964495957,
0.4578852355,
0.3876230121,
-0.1105482727,
-0.4070654809,
0.2512651384,
0.2681488097,
-0.3313059211,
-0.7639476657,
0.2225062251,
0.1732857972,
0.7206678391,
0.2760153413,
-0.1457072198,
0.7213615179,
-0.5957657695,
1.1564238071,
-0.0872168094,
-1.0046839714,
0.0769291222,
-0.4348528385,
0.0430040509,
0.3310013711,
0.2120910287,
-0.6410450935,
-0.5470520854,
-0.8221235871,
-0.4157952666,
0.5202456713,
0.5164089799,
0.3868317902,
-0.0799902231,
0.097078301,
0.146993801,
0.173064366,
-0.4016836584,
-0.1028780341,
0.0127494931,
-0.3689928949,
-0.3403925002,
0.019449275,
0.0041781678,
0.2700013518,
0.1883168966,
-0.0874288604,
0.6833069921,
0.1422554106,
0.132146135,
-0.0456001461,
0.0916191339,
0.578121841,
0.2885251045,
-0.0095215989,
0.2031874955,
0.1669370383,
-0.5831437111,
-0.0121050905,
-0.0159902833,
0.0640605837,
-0.1238348186,
0.8064399362,
0.5314418674,
0.3446362615,
-0.9119861126,
0.6149827242,
-0.2671225667,
-0.0982364789,
-0.3186994493,
0.2546170354,
0.3006749749,
0.440371871,
0.2716664374,
-0.0705601946,
0.1339382231,
-0.6628636718,
0.279493928,
0.4563608468,
-0.3509360552,
-0.4645409584,
0.6812711358,
0.3035207093,
-1.0043305159,
0.6448628902,
-0.01966382,
-0.6133261323,
0.7854888439,
0.6706559062,
1.0276612043,
-0.2355548441,
0.2058812976,
-0.0156682134,
0.1942370236,
-0.1836141497,
0.3610749543,
-0.0710893571,
-0.6417573094,
-0.0914087668,
-0.0745754689,
-0.788120091,
0.1161786541,
-0.4649450481,
0.1838087142,
-0.4421017468,
-0.2540922761,
-0.3532734215,
0.0152849667,
-0.7723938823,
-0.2206339389,
0.4280566573,
0.4286312163,
-0.5852771401,
0.4885858893,
0.3249701858,
-0.3534713089,
-0.5443193316,
0.2596320212,
0.0520465672,
-0.9948980808,
0.3232631385,
0.1507207453,
-0.3735587597,
0.098372221,
-0.5429065824,
-0.472918421,
1.1230908632,
0.3472283781,
-0.3054718971,
0.012509576,
0.2210724652,
0.9676162601,
-0.5597811341,
0.8531281352,
0.3854730427,
0.2332894951,
-0.1058894098,
-1.130753994,
-0.2754408121,
-0.0933523551,
-0.1240300462,
-0.1180861071,
-0.55245924,
0.5666177273,
-0.1921372861,
-0.2684810162,
0.2744002044,
0.3202680647,
0.4331104755,
0.2469263673,
0.7140294909,
-0.0044257487,
0.8444980383,
0.116762802,
1.1976047754,
-0.3041004241,
0.2137528211,
1.0667177439,
-0.3685208857,
1.163335681,
0.4648939073,
-0.2693140209,
0.4261208177,
0.5051388741,
-0.0998900235,
0.255242914,
0.3809214532,
-0.1400547773,
-0.2336538583,
0.1456567496,
-0.0571547449,
0.6760559082,
0.3879698217,
-0.3917973042,
0.0806383491,
-0.1667875051,
-0.0231362563,
0.181576401,
0.0993086547,
0.8542222977,
-0.0093317805,
-0.6378393769,
0.3951054811,
-0.4416789114,
0.6521177888,
-0.6044626832,
-0.5364297628,
-0.1775812805,
0.1672770083,
0.1719523668,
-0.7901230454,
-0.1016541272,
0.2070544809,
0.1946915388,
-0.3665100038,
0.3577532768,
-0.2404037118,
-0.3334501684,
0.4025205374,
0.623660624,
0.6447401643,
-0.0054881084,
-0.6452771425,
0.3630236387,
0.0272013973,
-0.1354339421,
0.108512111,
0.0539401472,
0.0299238637,
0.6004810929,
0.6283564568,
0.1368245482,
-0.232902199,
0.0378382169,
0.38918522,
-0.496029526,
-0.4256975055,
-0.9611200094,
0.3708956838,
-0.2013444006,
-0.469260931,
0.5875281692,
0.6693187356,
0.5620455146,
-0.0098428633,
0.9902585149,
0.2574496269,
0.6548674703,
-0.2584148347,
0.7636540532,
-0.2584311664,
0.4613051414,
-0.3330759406,
-0.9136208296,
-0.0465957336,
0.5301069617,
0.0820333511,
0.2306568325,
0.3978741765,
0.6748110652,
-0.1253083795,
0.204898119,
0.6922408342,
0.1199909672,
0.6286183,
0.5115623474,
1.3186479807,
-0.3204029202,
0.5157436132,
0.1176014394,
-0.3200813532,
-0.1615383178,
-0.6477379203,
-1.1017901897,
-0.492199868,
0.0807191283,
-0.2596286833,
0.1490452886,
1.2188782692,
0.6472097635,
-0.397595495,
-0.6020434499,
0.1318698674,
0.0149444388,
-0.3634260297,
-0.172402367,
0.2403914928,
-0.130779162,
-1.0724496841,
0.6231913567,
-0.081175901,
0.0358273871,
-0.5439459085,
-0.2211573571,
0.3538079262,
0.3579558134,
0.3394270837,
0.2483083904,
-1.0672410727,
-0.4357319772,
0.2346588075,
-0.2510554194,
0.0922356099,
0.8971648812,
-0.7795657516,
0.5732343197,
0.2874751389,
0.8649951816,
0.2064296454,
0.1903596669,
0.8352231979,
-0.3222784102,
-0.2005411386,
0.4638113081,
0.1586710811,
0.2505220473,
-0.3320553005,
0.4916417599,
0.0072902413,
-0.5863340497,
-0.6555631757,
0.0614804178,
-0.5888408422,
-0.0065805577,
1.2260769606,
-0.2285047472,
-0.1076435968,
-0.0141339414,
-0.4372294247,
0.0226368327,
-0.5278417468,
1.1514034271,
0.7144132257,
-0.4731474221,
-0.0775992647,
-0.4901331663,
0.5393217206,
0.1602463871,
-0.8802785277,
-0.0427929461,
0.3538249135,
0.129989177,
0.0812745467,
0.7953060865,
0.0683594644,
0.2666849494,
0.2397504002,
0.1885451078,
0.0408255234,
-0.0014832835,
-0.4937160611,
-0.0813596845,
0.1394010931,
-0.3272518814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13948v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13948v1
|
Typos that Broke the RAG's Back: Genetic Attack on RAG Pipeline by Simulating Documents in the Wild via Low-level Perturbations
| 2024-04-22T07:49:36 | 2024-04-22T07:49:36 |
Sukmin Cho, Soyeong Jeong, Jeongyeon Seo, Taeho Hwang, Jong C. Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The robustness of recent Large Language Models (LLMs) has become increasingly
crucial as their applicability expands across various domains and real-world
applications. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) is a promising solution for
addressing the limitations of LLMs, yet existing studies on the robustness of
RAG often overlook the interconnected relationships between RAG components or
the potential threats prevalent in real-world databases, such as minor textual
errors. In this work, we investigate two underexplored aspects when assessing
the robustness of RAG: 1) vulnerability to noisy documents through low-level
perturbations and 2) a holistic evaluation of RAG robustness. Furthermore, we
introduce a novel attack method, the Genetic Attack on RAG (\textit{GARAG}),
which targets these aspects. Specifically, GARAG is designed to reveal
vulnerabilities within each component and test the overall system functionality
against noisy documents. We validate RAG robustness by applying our
\textit{GARAG} to standard QA datasets, incorporating diverse retrievers and
LLMs. The experimental results show that GARAG consistently achieves high
attack success rates. Also, it significantly devastates the performance of each
component and their synergy, highlighting the substantial risk that minor
textual inaccuracies pose in disrupting RAG systems in the real world.
|
[
-0.370054841,
-1.0440579653,
0.3003680408,
-0.2118427753,
-0.0780452341,
0.6008918285,
0.140560165,
-0.6341372728,
0.2885769606,
0.5499005318,
-0.334685415,
-0.2633583546,
-0.6723207831,
0.1673979461,
-0.6020419002,
1.1261726618,
0.2300592661,
-0.2417734563,
-0.0165552925,
-0.233806625,
-0.2978411019,
-0.7870641351,
-0.6097386479,
0.0276793502,
0.5623534322,
0.2536272407,
0.8127115369,
0.3948043585,
0.5722621083,
0.1931285858,
-0.4320592582,
0.1019451693,
-0.7392619252,
0.7383657098,
-0.0272328276,
-0.5606409311,
-0.6157906055,
-0.1847714782,
0.5650171638,
0.2163295597,
-0.0028716454,
0.3880740404,
0.2661854625,
0.5973982811,
-0.798882246,
-0.5029858947,
-0.999845922,
0.0607521981,
-0.8560746908,
-0.3643141985,
-0.3356210887,
-0.0002718058,
-0.434843421,
-0.3678090274,
0.4895579219,
0.1701390594,
1.2704178095,
0.5279454589,
0.0327427275,
-0.4307884276,
-0.8427225351,
0.6463484168,
-0.5390386581,
0.1773125529,
0.4813445508,
0.40798226,
-0.6175785661,
-0.7526034713,
-0.6359974146,
-0.2860409617,
-0.0325844884,
-0.0163205452,
-0.2953101099,
-0.1342220753,
0.522731781,
0.599255681,
-0.7146095037,
0.1257562786,
-0.2909836471,
-0.0623680316,
0.3342793584,
0.1226105615,
0.6397954226,
-0.3950677216,
-0.2246514559,
-0.3192296624,
-0.7103096843,
-0.0122583201,
0.7787436843,
0.2564498186,
-0.0273828786,
0.7125745416,
0.0787421167,
0.5270290375,
0.307834357,
-0.146587953,
-0.0146624129,
-0.4581172764,
-0.2889130116,
-0.2785443068,
0.7933241129,
-0.231032595,
0.0437689126,
-0.3403623104,
-0.251965344,
0.1024548709,
0.6661680937,
-0.3856595755,
0.0658330545,
0.3582558036,
-0.1791418344,
-1.0017799139,
-0.0006619227,
-1.2883372307,
-0.7363864183,
0.6247825623,
0.3503126204,
-0.2873243988,
0.0827453882,
-0.0934548229,
-0.2175341249,
0.4552628398,
-0.1222287044,
-0.8068975806,
0.1780172288,
0.897177279,
0.6946802139,
0.0563967973,
-0.2173338532,
-0.8971819878,
0.2730941176,
-0.1768816113,
0.9383080602,
-0.5645654798,
-0.6671147943,
-0.3829259574,
-0.2706876695,
-0.1587278843,
-0.6001189947,
0.9650670886,
-0.5469699502,
0.1999202371,
-0.0287802964,
-0.1493357122,
0.2116298527,
0.3704270124,
-0.7804688215,
1.0966328382,
0.259629041,
-1.208607316,
0.3647560477,
-0.2749596834,
-0.4028434455,
-0.0916932747,
-0.2108323574,
-0.6903027296,
0.164140746,
0.1066232175,
0.1995465755,
-0.2103965133,
-0.1857133657,
-0.4831280708,
-0.3774268329,
0.2039626837,
-0.4257743359,
0.8323366046,
0.1037905142,
-0.3537874818,
-0.2116940171,
-0.7920656204,
0.0833256468,
0.3454183042,
-0.3309205472,
-0.6032986045,
-0.1127436906,
-0.3677949309,
0.0178525671,
0.0317500122,
-0.2854759097,
0.3745350242,
-0.5453330874,
-0.0122344708,
0.491671443,
0.2859559059,
0.4943153262,
-0.6412578821,
1.0115450621,
-0.3465323746,
0.1487578303,
0.0409251712,
-0.4757874608,
-0.5026122928,
-0.2957162261,
0.4983522892,
0.7325171828,
-0.7806582451,
-0.0305209309,
-0.2170556784,
-0.5673019886,
-0.4632551372,
0.1889799237,
0.4875932634,
0.5985857248,
0.3065499961,
-0.208029896,
-0.5590831637,
-0.5343538523,
-0.6177513003,
-0.1909543574,
-0.0474924855,
0.1665519178,
0.3229919672,
-0.5510371327,
0.6489446759,
-0.1743108779,
-0.1728625745,
-0.1368021369,
0.2848986983,
0.1764302999,
0.305280298,
0.7377374172,
-0.5969580412,
-0.3477522731,
0.0336540826,
-0.6539426446,
-0.279489845,
0.0371404551,
-0.0905158669,
0.4415738881,
0.3985394239,
-0.6379677653,
0.6342417002,
0.784938395,
-0.2403349876,
0.9060146809,
-0.1941270381,
0.0577643476,
-0.9588690996,
0.1324720234,
-0.2464393675,
0.0096695693,
-0.7001652718,
0.5773824453,
-0.20473212,
-0.023456715,
-0.0660906583,
0.5041509867,
-0.3655025363,
-0.1543796062,
-0.0821742788,
-0.2708524466,
0.0465790816,
0.0841847658,
-0.8053697348,
1.0262705088,
0.1892258674,
-0.3552942276,
0.0165832564,
0.2356344759,
0.182848528,
0.5910396576,
-0.679104805,
0.4176217616,
-0.0828725249,
0.3237161636,
-0.6148518324,
-0.5788443089,
0.4345951378,
-0.7272598743,
0.8351351619,
-0.4305245876,
-0.5615266562,
-0.1768618971,
-0.5529114008,
0.180149138,
0.4368445873,
-0.4067219198,
0.733215034,
0.5676750541,
-0.2992144227,
-0.7768641114,
-0.5756490231,
0.3960947692,
-0.5019564033,
-0.8658336401,
0.0766160563,
0.259115845,
-0.4613804519,
-0.0975841507,
-0.2968893647,
-0.1891276389,
0.4062448442,
0.2560364008,
0.2546660006,
-0.0828511193,
-0.2941869199,
-0.0484414883,
-0.1251207292,
-0.0523208641,
-0.0385495611,
0.5138875842,
-0.1196815968,
-0.3508155346,
0.1248974875,
0.29175964,
0.7918993235,
-0.2764780521,
0.4320033193,
0.5224189162,
-0.2996166945,
-0.5088113546,
-0.3659369946,
-0.070928432,
-0.4965578318,
0.2757505774,
-0.1979784667,
-0.6571674347,
0.443952322,
0.1457070708,
-0.026956426,
0.4605020881,
0.2649431825,
-0.4883779585,
0.7561422586,
0.5087532401,
0.057695806,
0.0535371639,
-0.2271824032,
0.1509679258,
-0.9240338206,
0.0300116688,
-0.9997552633,
-0.2522254288,
-0.8729972243,
-0.6621780396,
0.5019255877,
0.277450949,
-0.1894754022,
0.2284569591,
-0.3188378215,
0.3901894689,
0.4750642478,
-0.2045331299,
0.4013911486,
0.1434755474,
-0.3152819276,
-0.0799884647,
-0.8537397385,
-0.705742836,
1.0431226492,
0.3294560313,
1.0459192991,
0.104005456,
0.8288673759,
0.2353299558,
0.0924868509,
-0.5367242694,
0.282987237,
-0.5643252134,
-0.6429467201,
-0.2095475495,
-0.3814610839,
-1.1152575016,
0.027494058,
-0.5390041471,
-0.8045493364,
0.3233832121,
0.2552841008,
-0.3765591383,
0.5053688884,
-0.4856618345,
0.4428179562,
-0.3749319613,
-0.4241237342,
0.0581588484,
-0.6691274047,
0.5504505634,
-0.5623304248,
0.3893421292,
0.3377349973,
0.1605180949,
0.3039292991,
-0.4287593663,
0.682629168,
0.0965888202,
-0.1054519638,
0.0284057688,
0.3745924234,
0.7852339149,
-0.084861055,
-0.0073476229,
0.1055272073,
-0.1272243559,
-0.4355832338,
-0.5030729771,
0.4821323156,
-0.4268376529,
-0.5873427391,
-0.6859831214,
-0.3259645104,
-0.5779982209,
0.0358534679,
0.5368491411,
0.2103936374,
-0.0209097136,
0.0685321465,
0.7856135964,
-0.4954433739,
0.1075489223,
0.1052331179,
-0.1690729409,
-0.2848238945,
1.0503057241,
0.1897192448,
0.420314908,
0.0733159557,
0.1124373525,
0.0746950507,
-0.6414635777,
-0.4255329669,
0.1728029847,
-0.386217922,
-0.2001784742,
-0.6828736067,
-0.2045303434,
-0.1674239635,
-0.0659777895,
-0.136083588,
-0.2980912626,
-0.1538531631,
0.0280104838,
0.0980530605,
0.9230546951,
0.0267515555,
0.0609748773,
-0.9303482771,
0.5976330638,
0.4739433825,
0.2071800679,
-0.0778306797,
-0.5507743359,
-0.0476638526,
0.0745080933,
-0.4082104564,
-1.0416139364,
0.3566395938,
0.1103281602,
0.5043054819,
-0.0270315334,
-0.0111156479,
0.427280277,
-0.4918960333,
0.5769279003,
-0.341221571,
-0.576120019,
0.3513337076,
-0.7857108712,
0.1085179299,
0.5300679207,
-0.0311596971,
-0.1885703653,
-1.0383421183,
-1.0520048141,
-1.0264848471,
0.1552203596,
0.2166617513,
-0.0029605038,
0.2074771076,
0.3217875957,
0.0094334614,
-0.0622727945,
-0.261326611,
-0.1834383309,
-0.0042672735,
0.1371963322,
0.348428756,
-0.5142559409,
-0.0836858973,
0.1408180296,
0.6727529168,
0.0250266436,
0.0356010757,
0.1736880243,
-0.054158438,
-0.1654192358,
0.4187143147,
0.7439716458,
0.1677340865,
-0.1266831607,
-0.0727000162,
0.1183369383,
-0.9591057301,
0.1306829005,
0.0986177251,
-0.395748198,
0.1475635171,
0.378382206,
0.436930567,
0.1372772902,
-0.4027600288,
0.2027241886,
-0.2900990844,
0.1801986247,
-0.1175077558,
0.0906474441,
-0.183953613,
0.1509219557,
0.6351377368,
0.3091493845,
-0.0297406334,
-0.4291293919,
0.3016420901,
0.6631985307,
-0.0516735874,
-0.2299906462,
0.7985329628,
-0.1519075781,
-0.228982091,
0.0359123088,
-0.3074612916,
-0.6191205382,
0.6107976437,
0.3442831933,
0.9473547935,
-0.0799739659,
0.1710834205,
0.0775486156,
0.6461466551,
-0.0158563387,
0.1688800156,
0.3531140089,
-0.4386461973,
-0.4582761526,
-0.8606347442,
-0.6213281751,
0.1328398585,
-0.5967109203,
0.1493685842,
-0.5100205541,
-0.3266083896,
-0.2415819466,
-0.1227721423,
-0.2582190931,
0.0122307772,
0.0977565125,
0.6885854006,
-0.3810572028,
0.6138466001,
0.7456105947,
-0.2839983106,
-0.8921995163,
0.5833951831,
0.1721353978,
-0.6738917232,
0.5630174875,
-0.3700566888,
-0.184110716,
-0.2730915248,
-0.5362178683,
-0.7620553374,
0.9323830605,
0.6162908673,
-0.4134600163,
-0.2481720448,
-0.0044196388,
0.5695131421,
0.2624928057,
-0.2303947359,
0.5116198063,
0.4619573951,
0.030678805,
-0.9432985187,
-0.1191167086,
-0.1208126098,
-0.1283910722,
0.4066151381,
-0.453022629,
0.848767519,
-0.2744316757,
-0.4983266294,
0.2740200162,
0.3373544812,
0.6066080332,
0.2797324955,
0.3173239529,
0.9382174015,
1.0499516726,
-0.1735996753,
1.6163634062,
-0.2595801055,
0.257522434,
1.2193398476,
-0.2170792371,
0.7777266502,
0.5048756003,
-0.088751018,
0.3518575132,
0.1019838303,
0.0016687236,
0.1265041232,
0.2072176635,
-0.2223633081,
0.3049784005,
0.1582567096,
-0.385148257,
0.4899968803,
0.5275092721,
-0.1466649324,
-0.2862787843,
-0.134835884,
0.3828296959,
0.0726135895,
-0.1465463042,
0.6037727594,
0.0240316167,
-0.2931073606,
0.7055202723,
-0.1439676285,
0.8919030428,
-0.553987205,
0.0580556281,
-0.4336684048,
-0.0876089185,
-0.3245123625,
-0.4636206031,
0.6128561497,
0.4849601984,
-0.1885918975,
0.0588248074,
1.1861070395,
-0.0239227787,
-0.4159621596,
0.1710315645,
0.5287951827,
-0.1832173467,
0.136900261,
-0.3596987128,
0.3587982059,
-0.2652494609,
-0.1570235938,
0.5380205512,
0.4470040202,
-0.1130513176,
0.6055064797,
0.763857007,
0.5741783977,
0.3210629225,
-0.3169223368,
0.8597922325,
-0.4723528624,
-0.1973969787,
-0.6291353106,
0.3203791678,
-0.094490692,
-0.1903158277,
0.9164837003,
0.1936365664,
0.7095107436,
0.171423018,
0.9445123672,
-0.1619695425,
0.7605897188,
-0.4707235992,
1.1107305288,
-0.4228903949,
0.5731361508,
-0.4426099956,
-0.6402356029,
-0.2590449452,
0.2215860337,
-0.0519765429,
0.0117881261,
0.7498981357,
0.8045112491,
0.0754445195,
-0.2261270434,
0.239966616,
0.6309671402,
0.315476954,
0.2343492061,
0.7659502625,
-0.3933752179,
0.6670171618,
-0.188539803,
-0.0964483768,
0.0301471967,
-0.8750814199,
-0.5778084993,
-0.2590226531,
0.0440475643,
-0.8080221415,
0.5771979094,
0.1920895278,
0.1366126388,
-0.6390859485,
0.050544221,
0.1243093908,
0.1363393813,
0.1614562273,
-0.2508001328,
0.0812332928,
-0.4767056704,
-0.5050374269,
0.4829562902,
0.317532599,
0.2002287358,
-0.3617377579,
0.0889936686,
-0.0605378896,
0.0389110371,
0.1434798241,
0.8380624056,
-0.3084738255,
-0.233236447,
0.1382408589,
-0.4154081643,
-0.1257607937,
0.600353539,
-0.8090028167,
0.267721951,
0.6247591376,
0.9664446712,
0.0986469984,
0.155107528,
0.7033268213,
-0.857367456,
0.0865748525,
0.4895702004,
0.2589227259,
0.3188581169,
-0.5919886827,
0.6208273172,
0.2970704734,
-0.6850264668,
-1.2164633274,
0.1941300184,
-0.7782678008,
-0.1444645375,
1.2826435566,
0.1206885129,
-0.4019296169,
-0.1970412433,
-0.1054519936,
0.0602804385,
-0.057199683,
0.9961176515,
0.5615215302,
0.262206018,
0.2642937899,
-0.8976741433,
0.5513759255,
0.2970649898,
-0.7383188605,
-0.2197407633,
0.3346206248,
0.1631743312,
0.2989585698,
0.3157414794,
-0.3526051044,
0.371750623,
0.0721623227,
-0.3857106268,
0.0640936792,
-0.0568941459,
-0.5291383862,
0.4357321858,
0.1515842676,
0.0781116262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13940v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13940v2
|
A User-Centric Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models
| 2024-04-22T07:32:03 | 2024-04-23T01:58:24 |
Jiayin Wang, Fengran Mo, Weizhi Ma, Peijie Sun, Min Zhang, Jian-Yun Nie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are essential tools to collaborate with users on
different tasks. Evaluating their performance to serve users' needs in
real-world scenarios is important. While many benchmarks have been created,
they mainly focus on specific predefined model abilities. Few have covered the
intended utilization of LLMs by real users. To address this oversight, we
propose benchmarking LLMs from a user perspective in both dataset construction
and evaluation designs. We first collect 1846 real-world use cases with 15 LLMs
from a user study with 712 participants from 23 countries. These self-reported
cases form the User Reported Scenarios(URS) dataset with a categorization of 7
user intents. Secondly, on this authentic multi-cultural dataset, we benchmark
10 LLM services on their efficacy in satisfying user needs. Thirdly, we show
that our benchmark scores align well with user-reported experience in LLM
interactions across diverse intents, both of which emphasize the overlook of
subjective scenarios. In conclusion, our study proposes to benchmark LLMs from
a user-centric perspective, aiming to facilitate evaluations that better
reflect real user needs. The benchmark dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/Alice1998/URS.
|
[
-0.3765782118,
-0.4552319944,
0.6279985309,
0.4703298211,
-0.0983564928,
0.1239965186,
-0.6740874648,
-0.4920994341,
-0.0335737728,
0.6024526358,
-0.3679650128,
-0.7256115675,
-0.2469411641,
0.2114918232,
-0.3580266833,
0.4791764319,
-0.0164841544,
0.229836762,
-0.4716748893,
-0.2715771496,
-0.3200680315,
-0.6884708405,
-0.4656127989,
-0.4243722856,
0.6507920623,
0.4579113126,
0.5276778936,
0.4489922523,
0.4257135391,
0.2667634785,
0.0610870905,
0.1014176831,
-0.5989384651,
0.3561581075,
-0.1914232522,
-0.1972183436,
-0.2619356513,
0.0791341513,
0.6745125651,
0.6798466444,
-0.2846163213,
0.427131474,
0.0216300208,
0.3412775099,
-0.7408797741,
-0.0616256706,
-0.4703833461,
0.0819755793,
-0.2450628579,
0.0731372982,
-0.3665369749,
-0.4174301028,
0.0237491224,
-0.3007952273,
-0.3142214417,
0.2045833915,
0.5191450119,
-0.0373673514,
-0.5920252204,
-0.118589431,
-0.5978998542,
0.8251508474,
-0.9048852921,
0.6928396225,
0.207600832,
0.4768284857,
-0.3652609885,
-0.6029063463,
-0.3997498453,
-0.3795440793,
-0.0997312441,
-0.0561150275,
-0.0585835055,
-0.3202859461,
0.4036620259,
0.4213715792,
-0.5356584787,
0.4599039257,
0.0131424218,
-0.2468961775,
0.7674115896,
0.4083052278,
0.1921653003,
-0.1528232545,
-0.4167959988,
0.0504455492,
-0.7711077929,
0.0596071258,
0.5030986667,
0.3432484567,
-0.3639190793,
0.6016584039,
-0.3684091568,
0.575011313,
-0.4117772281,
-0.2236782014,
0.5669035912,
-0.134056583,
-0.120822005,
-0.3971606791,
1.0063718557,
0.5423026681,
0.564329803,
-0.3464431763,
-0.4515547752,
-0.3130447268,
0.2263929546,
-1.0164321661,
0.1502266526,
-0.0929623395,
-0.3611504138,
0.0917364806,
-0.1668008268,
-0.7016173005,
-0.5532439351,
-0.4232058823,
0.2305034697,
-0.0757824928,
-0.2461203933,
-0.041482009,
0.4062642753,
0.0293672178,
0.1282190084,
-0.7708724141,
0.5910657644,
0.9068514109,
0.7580804229,
-0.4199853837,
-0.4022728205,
-0.6171967983,
-0.158463791,
-0.1565266103,
0.7219022512,
-0.4723648727,
-0.4437740147,
0.2234244943,
-0.1634227484,
0.0746923685,
-0.7299303412,
0.8441272378,
-0.519448638,
0.0081021581,
-0.4889155328,
-0.6384456158,
-0.0536650121,
0.3954919875,
-0.4866488278,
1.1254858971,
0.1603168249,
-0.4879319966,
0.4336286783,
-0.3355941474,
-0.5733432174,
0.3462561369,
-0.3715303242,
-0.2242161483,
0.2800878882,
-0.0493383706,
0.584520638,
-0.7529537678,
0.3634448349,
-0.6031804085,
-0.4567498267,
0.3851052225,
-0.3770809174,
0.4806411862,
0.3921449482,
0.0732674748,
0.2198338658,
-0.745174408,
0.2427028716,
0.1597079188,
-0.3704461753,
-0.285267204,
0.0243701693,
0.4901447892,
0.3472290933,
0.3852945268,
-0.638332665,
0.103108272,
-0.1937181205,
0.3402175903,
0.6173042059,
-0.2733965218,
0.0337659977,
-0.0782276019,
0.5395302176,
-0.1825354695,
0.1564914435,
-0.0345049538,
-0.1029304489,
-0.5502430797,
-0.4280165136,
0.2319017351,
0.2407697886,
-0.2944189906,
0.4755999446,
-0.4376441538,
-0.5402841568,
-0.4340755343,
0.4821878076,
0.4572423697,
0.4573403001,
0.0924263075,
-0.5319814086,
-0.4496602118,
-1.1324979067,
-0.4480321407,
-0.1650774479,
-0.2856815755,
0.7468433976,
0.2568136156,
-0.2367054522,
0.867916584,
-0.3040119112,
-0.1976893842,
-0.2969675362,
-0.0207713135,
0.2849260569,
0.1174412742,
0.3387881815,
-0.5919132829,
-0.5499897003,
-0.0500800051,
-0.8484508395,
-0.4376588464,
0.2810018957,
0.0886381641,
0.3206878006,
0.3159622848,
-0.2313833982,
0.0608198978,
0.7905262113,
-0.2921321392,
0.463167578,
-0.32029441,
0.2994666696,
-0.9602479935,
0.2629061937,
0.1545943916,
-0.4128650725,
-0.3529208004,
-0.0257658232,
0.3240522742,
-0.0716359243,
-0.5028591156,
0.7142853737,
-0.4121468067,
-0.6937391758,
-0.0972652733,
0.1738624871,
-0.1557627469,
0.2367489338,
-0.0648715943,
0.9651879668,
0.3623690605,
-0.2203789502,
0.3236038089,
-0.0218171459,
-0.8942117691,
0.5560283065,
-0.7980718613,
0.2350507975,
0.300703615,
0.1604627669,
-0.8949049711,
-0.0355915017,
0.0181460064,
0.0724304616,
-0.0757909939,
-0.2367650419,
-1.0539340973,
-0.3775392473,
-0.1775296628,
0.3701470494,
0.3966017663,
-0.6064508557,
0.6176592112,
0.3857403696,
0.0406387933,
-0.2797161639,
-0.4328523874,
0.4061129689,
-0.5007781982,
-0.6577793956,
0.1748098433,
-0.22531645,
-0.2914830744,
-0.0736256838,
-0.0041717826,
0.2021291852,
0.3809813261,
0.477081418,
0.1152210385,
-0.2162301987,
-0.0273394603,
-0.4892172813,
-0.1462043971,
0.0942379683,
0.0899133533,
0.7401099205,
-0.24424918,
-0.5618733168,
-0.3293519318,
0.3069182932,
0.5843458772,
-0.3180070519,
0.590587914,
0.5177809596,
-0.2048404664,
-0.15615049,
-0.9848015904,
-0.0320076086,
-0.4533213079,
0.3808951378,
-0.6886323094,
-1.0025920868,
0.6476371288,
-0.1757404357,
0.1601143181,
0.06437172,
0.7966951728,
0.0407096446,
0.7791468501,
0.5455219746,
-0.3347407579,
0.2183273882,
0.1160191372,
0.2583816051,
-0.9723058343,
-0.2482084036,
-0.5139297247,
-0.1909836978,
-0.4575187564,
-0.2596944571,
0.3110690415,
0.0596762598,
-0.2946784198,
0.3753212392,
0.0806032643,
0.4780479372,
0.2781160772,
-0.3170557022,
0.4529060423,
0.0191286057,
-0.1639920473,
-0.2084409297,
-0.3907145262,
-0.7349258065,
1.2334089279,
0.453863591,
1.0372918844,
0.2094145566,
0.6373660564,
0.4006673098,
0.5629791021,
-0.7564986944,
0.6531432271,
-0.1571735144,
-0.4058354497,
-0.1918003857,
-0.6297485232,
-0.808735013,
0.5843481421,
-0.1945590526,
-0.9648425579,
-0.2965894341,
0.0121368384,
-0.1650974303,
0.0247219298,
-0.7375795841,
1.0305496454,
-0.6112232804,
-0.5628971457,
-0.34178859,
-0.1765172482,
0.2082379758,
-0.1189220697,
0.3398022354,
-0.4975115061,
-0.1734524071,
0.6255737543,
-0.0789231062,
0.612877667,
-0.0759921521,
-0.1996506006,
-0.1524460912,
0.0178007577,
0.2997781634,
0.1903697997,
-0.4479949474,
0.4080601037,
-0.1474272609,
-0.1606067121,
-0.4638076127,
1.2210136652,
-0.7256525159,
-0.6395486593,
-0.2738425732,
-0.4706017673,
-0.551435411,
0.2549731731,
-0.1746131331,
0.4930868447,
-0.4484346807,
0.3109455109,
0.320726335,
-0.1123488545,
0.3582067788,
1.0415861607,
-0.6197900772,
-0.1818574667,
0.5356580615,
0.0674437135,
0.1896296293,
0.104110308,
0.2318498343,
-0.457102716,
-0.6642631292,
-0.6008170843,
0.2830279768,
-0.7344884276,
-0.0408248976,
-0.6578869224,
-0.0078742858,
-0.2489559203,
0.1026838347,
-0.4952591062,
0.0836071074,
-0.0022278428,
0.1449609697,
0.1201491058,
0.6157121658,
0.2674563825,
0.1166504622,
-0.542308569,
0.2532092035,
0.1989831775,
0.7824258208,
0.2215869576,
-0.5645577312,
-0.3376594186,
-0.3058994412,
-0.0458718687,
-0.26473701,
0.1521575451,
-0.053695742,
0.8823359013,
0.3083532155,
-0.0552187227,
0.5781957507,
-0.5431320071,
0.5887743235,
0.0606299751,
-0.8589192033,
0.1131587401,
-0.1771226078,
0.2684090137,
0.8779780865,
0.4072516561,
-0.9032787681,
-0.0487489216,
-0.1577046812,
-0.9105576873,
0.5699663758,
-0.018065922,
0.253256321,
0.0934029147,
0.2374113351,
0.1618149132,
0.1142167449,
-0.7180590034,
-0.2583448589,
0.282636106,
-0.1195401028,
-0.3758478165,
-0.4182344079,
-0.0528414845,
0.1071362197,
0.4592964649,
-0.0474307872,
-0.38902843,
-0.1576177329,
-0.2104180008,
-0.0985190198,
0.3712390363,
0.3271565735,
1.0590319633,
-0.2667984962,
0.1170655414,
0.2367622107,
-0.0751004741,
0.0190283395,
0.1041836143,
-0.0461187735,
-0.3778752387,
0.3653505147,
0.5571613312,
0.4948267341,
-1.111700058,
0.544459343,
-0.4525564611,
0.2058961093,
-0.4238946736,
0.1789230108,
0.5272485614,
0.2474303097,
0.2438152283,
-0.4595004916,
0.1825079322,
-0.5153591037,
-0.0550985821,
0.4960650802,
-0.3401453197,
-0.2912535369,
0.3077599108,
0.3302651644,
-0.5797770023,
0.5137181282,
0.0504097119,
-0.2641513944,
0.1967283785,
0.5474648476,
0.8593654037,
-0.073266536,
-0.1304190606,
0.2955073714,
0.0609995499,
-0.0122841829,
0.2623019516,
-0.0844601914,
-0.6611406803,
-0.3820915818,
-0.6741712689,
-0.5012204647,
0.3507994413,
-0.6543230414,
0.323434025,
-0.3635151684,
-0.0873446837,
0.0494681075,
0.2277572155,
-0.7725963593,
0.0340910107,
0.3098378479,
0.9943829179,
-0.8202193379,
0.8162551522,
0.6894681454,
0.0366385877,
-0.3853476644,
-0.0869591162,
0.0975369588,
-0.8879711628,
0.5478340983,
0.2539728284,
-0.2214173228,
-0.4272125661,
-0.1178751662,
-0.6134154201,
0.9151519537,
0.3304981887,
-0.9464294314,
0.6116698384,
0.3356473744,
0.7433630228,
-0.6506868601,
0.3948907554,
0.6196401715,
0.4102016985,
-0.0769103467,
-0.9075781703,
0.0600739606,
-0.2092090547,
0.1955153942,
0.1223167256,
-0.7933724523,
0.5346477032,
-0.0078483,
-0.1875600368,
0.1455332339,
0.5524294972,
0.3673382699,
0.2948429585,
0.7944623828,
0.5281375051,
0.4178824723,
0.1832515746,
1.0829014778,
-0.3043968081,
0.1982585341,
1.2326509953,
-0.8336095214,
1.0050491095,
0.5116875768,
-0.2811490297,
0.1180037335,
0.4240567088,
-0.0377380177,
0.2771314681,
0.5861119628,
-0.201087594,
-0.4609985948,
-0.3659650981,
-0.3197907507,
0.437251389,
0.1553528905,
-0.1533188522,
-0.2107716352,
-0.2032626122,
0.0764345303,
0.4335977733,
0.0137268631,
0.8056938052,
0.18019934,
-0.629242897,
0.4587138593,
0.1109159067,
0.6518406272,
-0.6452602744,
0.3176020384,
-0.3859867752,
0.2215972394,
-0.1388142407,
-0.9400495291,
-0.0499212183,
0.3151357472,
-0.1056689993,
-0.226817742,
0.352966249,
-0.1818853319,
-0.5601226091,
0.6309756637,
0.429358989,
0.2118663788,
0.0718917325,
-0.4853672683,
0.6236947775,
-0.134397164,
-0.4751142263,
0.5653797984,
0.2763192952,
-0.1789426059,
0.8987375498,
0.4412309229,
0.1280683577,
-0.2893466949,
0.6696506143,
0.7782329321,
-0.6609604359,
-0.2432655394,
-0.8977692723,
0.1212278605,
-0.0956395045,
-0.5868290663,
1.0642092228,
1.010314703,
0.8779755831,
0.1615000367,
0.6836426258,
0.1083099842,
0.5864781141,
-0.276178956,
0.5803204775,
-0.6451160908,
0.4959784448,
-0.1164232939,
-1.0263661146,
-0.1362075508,
0.2158109099,
-0.4722268283,
0.1245756671,
0.1587519497,
0.6470220089,
-0.2407459766,
0.0236960556,
0.4885990024,
0.0645454004,
0.4574525058,
0.4146705568,
1.1037713289,
-0.0932475701,
0.1720470488,
-0.3103075922,
-0.1390362829,
-0.3187632263,
-1.0980488062,
-1.0568776131,
-0.4000439346,
-0.1734202802,
0.0018956882,
0.0382227972,
1.1242804527,
0.854547441,
-0.7263474464,
-0.7010105252,
0.4894142151,
-0.0443321727,
0.0640692413,
-0.1174447462,
0.2162436098,
-0.201789394,
-0.6160709262,
0.336841017,
0.3610285521,
-0.1681669801,
-0.6540349722,
-0.2238945812,
0.1057079732,
-0.177847147,
0.5906965733,
0.1547336876,
-0.809797585,
-0.2497178763,
-0.1153200567,
-0.2152667195,
-0.0668629408,
0.8935322762,
-0.6448239088,
0.3114773929,
0.238688305,
0.6655848026,
0.6156015396,
-0.0034106281,
0.5069574118,
-0.3937728107,
-0.0647801906,
0.0910734832,
0.4076496363,
0.6442888975,
-0.1150323153,
0.593001008,
-0.2415772527,
-0.542355001,
-0.9102970362,
0.0447087213,
-0.9788632989,
0.0354015231,
1.1847748756,
-0.5579320788,
0.061902564,
-0.0041329758,
0.0997889489,
-0.2632493079,
-0.4432304502,
0.7074220777,
0.7137422562,
0.1054528356,
0.0937382802,
-0.6249030232,
0.0618771836,
0.3835040927,
-0.8552955389,
0.4440463185,
0.4989797175,
0.5142663717,
-0.2871574461,
0.474707365,
-0.0644692108,
-0.0847653151,
-0.4653460979,
0.080845274,
-0.1068892851,
-0.3039737046,
-0.3465115726,
0.1384363919,
0.3922587037,
0.2802238464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16068v1
|
SemEval-2024 Task 9: BRAINTEASER: A Novel Task Defying Common Sense
| 2024-04-22T07:21:27 | 2024-04-22T07:21:27 |
Yifan Jiang, Filip Ilievski, Kaixin Ma
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While vertical thinking relies on logical and commonsense reasoning, lateral
thinking requires systems to defy commonsense associations and overwrite them
through unconventional thinking. Lateral thinking has been shown to be
challenging for current models but has received little attention. A recent
benchmark, BRAINTEASER, aims to evaluate current models' lateral thinking
ability in a zero-shot setting. In this paper, we split the original benchmark
to also support fine-tuning setting and present SemEval Task 9:
BRAIN-TEASER(S), the first task at this competition designed to test the
system's reasoning and lateral thinking ability. As a popular task,
BRAINTEASER(S)'s two subtasks receive 483 team submissions from 182
participants during the competition. This paper provides a fine-grained system
analysis of the competition results, together with a reflection on what this
means for the ability of the systems to reason laterally. We hope that the
BRAINTEASER(S) subtasks and findings in this paper can stimulate future work on
lateral thinking and robust reasoning by computational models.
|
[
-0.5383014679,
-0.819696486,
0.6191989779,
0.1888092011,
-0.3384249508,
-0.0861125439,
0.1181892157,
-0.4330324829,
0.1387166679,
0.3197489381,
-0.8842002749,
-0.3711717725,
-0.487343967,
0.1441214383,
0.0211432967,
0.8196265697,
0.0418535247,
-0.0794106647,
-0.1727830321,
-0.5720872283,
-1.1322578192,
-0.3248495162,
-0.6208466291,
-0.4764032662,
0.382634908,
0.4127464294,
0.4990528226,
0.2578310966,
0.432300508,
0.280354768,
-0.097259663,
-0.1150811985,
-0.4130731523,
0.3005809188,
-0.7953551412,
-0.3497981429,
-0.5863069892,
-0.1502409279,
0.3125820458,
0.6718075871,
0.0707750395,
0.2728085816,
-0.0010887205,
0.7062157393,
-0.7056577206,
-0.1893886924,
-0.788454175,
0.1739807129,
-0.245338127,
-0.2206371278,
-0.1917826384,
-0.0333714485,
-0.1195084974,
-0.3370622993,
0.073926568,
-0.1414201111,
0.7494506836,
0.6937816143,
-0.4993838072,
0.3531677127,
-0.2084485441,
0.7263066173,
-0.3702470064,
0.3933032453,
0.054740455,
0.7581652403,
0.1118889526,
-0.3479751945,
-0.2623860538,
0.0522379056,
0.7161417603,
0.2174297869,
-0.4139852524,
-0.3280630708,
0.4120238125,
-0.2082645446,
-0.4962392747,
0.153542906,
-0.6273704767,
-0.2728249431,
0.6864456534,
0.5628470182,
0.1907386333,
0.1092507988,
-0.5275197029,
0.1502063423,
-0.4837803543,
0.4119084179,
0.0085262069,
-0.0698313862,
0.1081805676,
0.5941218734,
-0.593983829,
0.4193609059,
0.2367768288,
0.4319389462,
0.3701144755,
-0.2892889082,
-0.3823746443,
0.0362194441,
0.2940485775,
0.6833732724,
0.0919976458,
-0.0344642065,
-0.3795354068,
0.5332348943,
0.2654391229,
-0.6492654085,
-0.2435833812,
0.302962929,
-0.2052284628,
-0.2964057326,
-0.6530807614,
-0.5749596953,
-0.4721387327,
-0.3306053877,
0.7480123043,
-0.741818428,
-0.0683184415,
0.3783636093,
-0.4567134082,
0.2754833996,
0.6469404697,
-0.4682992995,
0.2286396623,
0.821844101,
0.564204216,
-0.3320296705,
-0.594781518,
-0.6639671326,
-0.1664499938,
-0.2614454925,
1.1585501432,
-0.3891232908,
0.0231908988,
-0.6365761161,
0.0301100407,
0.0678287223,
-0.3842194378,
0.579615891,
-0.4629176557,
-0.2645638287,
-0.8930137753,
-0.3249344528,
-0.2761379778,
0.6902029514,
-0.4143268168,
0.6537029743,
-0.3369471729,
-0.6609315276,
0.6819687486,
-0.7133561969,
-0.3454647064,
0.4852408469,
-0.4482609928,
-0.0596081018,
0.0425363444,
0.3255026042,
0.3407520652,
-0.3314268887,
0.1011739895,
-0.5170973539,
-0.3314970136,
0.0688318685,
-0.1958756447,
1.2607040405,
0.0776054561,
-0.5127036572,
0.0854051188,
-0.5592467189,
0.1338953972,
0.255758971,
0.0994074643,
-0.2159975618,
-0.1935767382,
-0.4170640707,
0.3019171357,
0.3101739883,
-0.610987246,
0.1532994807,
-0.2844745219,
0.4184559286,
0.7532420754,
0.2349738777,
0.3928264081,
-0.2707386613,
0.5362907648,
0.2919448316,
0.1124168411,
0.0255928468,
-0.6688994169,
-0.4874567091,
-0.1318010539,
0.1412899047,
0.7039736509,
-0.629614234,
0.1254927963,
-0.0833516642,
-0.6492645741,
-0.1562963873,
-0.175292775,
0.1261889935,
0.7282669544,
0.43626073,
-0.3402858675,
-0.3617866635,
-1.2135272026,
-0.6968915462,
0.3242765963,
0.2455608696,
0.0001529435,
0.9150944948,
-0.1486379504,
0.445902288,
-0.4166940451,
-0.101819016,
-0.1777802855,
0.363229543,
0.2065003067,
0.495230794,
0.3038417101,
-0.3718611896,
-0.0369910523,
-0.2074938565,
-0.7220928073,
-0.2281952202,
0.0138244182,
-0.1738305688,
0.2319508195,
0.4847228229,
-0.4841445684,
0.7359253764,
0.0462301709,
-0.6907778382,
0.5045862794,
-0.0216410998,
0.098429516,
-0.3800299466,
0.1470330358,
-0.1229168922,
0.0890304819,
-0.5186207294,
0.1793242395,
0.0831754655,
-0.0926622078,
-0.3711795211,
0.4701526761,
-0.3895945847,
-0.0754826218,
-0.2692565918,
0.0287068188,
-0.029889822,
0.4994925261,
0.0011963794,
0.58107692,
0.4290294051,
-0.49973616,
0.0363602713,
0.0862352923,
-0.3967147768,
0.7488757372,
-0.7544710636,
0.3227487504,
-0.4296101928,
0.197458595,
-0.8585287929,
-0.0381661989,
-0.0567065142,
-0.5457997918,
-0.3165478408,
0.1684627831,
-0.140824452,
-0.3986952603,
-0.1163573414,
0.485982269,
0.438496083,
-0.1934632659,
0.5514591336,
0.7108969092,
-0.1149991378,
-0.6387394071,
-0.8643929362,
0.0824118406,
-0.4330509901,
-0.7679585218,
0.2445058823,
0.0075950553,
-0.1654393524,
-0.1832069904,
-0.3305646181,
-0.1667309105,
0.3591980636,
0.1045762375,
0.1972094923,
-0.0702709258,
-0.152763173,
0.2870642841,
-0.1604972631,
0.3828050792,
-0.0929629058,
0.246525988,
-0.6344025135,
-0.4779637158,
-0.0975368693,
0.2388052195,
0.4262500107,
-0.3054689765,
0.3367756605,
0.3366314471,
-0.4931502938,
-0.4848108888,
-0.7041983008,
-0.2106108218,
-0.4084780514,
0.2629774213,
-0.7714759707,
-0.9190514684,
0.6333500743,
0.1033904552,
-0.0187608469,
0.4819409549,
0.6978949904,
0.0652123392,
1.0915769339,
0.2669941187,
0.3322483003,
-0.322265625,
-0.1254234612,
0.1525952667,
-0.5732157826,
-0.3933838308,
-0.3423733413,
-0.8694623113,
-0.207510978,
-0.528150022,
0.4662718177,
0.0627457127,
-0.5422338843,
0.561866641,
-0.8670394421,
0.7509729862,
0.5110632181,
-0.0018884619,
0.0518885627,
-0.3008452058,
-0.6651310325,
-0.2808452547,
-0.4947988391,
-0.2043703347,
0.687725842,
0.2394180745,
0.2525601983,
0.1531249136,
0.6860878468,
-0.0129758446,
-0.0837381929,
-0.6323182583,
1.111748457,
0.2659604847,
-0.9305898547,
-0.4082400501,
-0.0781010687,
-0.9131192565,
0.4540439844,
0.1394088417,
-0.9893724918,
0.4748275876,
-0.1325342953,
-0.7469559908,
0.0376192182,
-0.3679800034,
1.0031956434,
-0.1916857362,
-0.7559745908,
-0.388238281,
-0.6075156331,
0.4392048717,
0.0109253544,
-0.0996234119,
-0.4497890472,
-0.3425889015,
0.5238856077,
-0.114124909,
0.4742214978,
-0.4214137197,
0.2621364892,
0.4405504167,
0.3864167035,
0.2450488359,
0.1248030961,
0.0059263152,
0.1792064458,
0.25259462,
-0.5087890029,
-0.5223173499,
0.4939185977,
-0.5095977187,
-0.887892127,
-0.608420074,
-0.4638472199,
-0.4393907189,
0.5156907439,
0.2370726615,
0.163666293,
-0.3073800504,
0.437127769,
0.5166115165,
-0.130635947,
0.2996645272,
0.4386322796,
0.0117667876,
-0.5078957677,
0.488260895,
0.4460225999,
-0.3075132966,
0.127272442,
0.1352858096,
-0.1657108516,
-0.6656888127,
-0.273124963,
-0.1829161644,
-0.7342312336,
-0.2243264467,
-0.5892804265,
-0.2140700966,
-0.1999618858,
-0.3055762649,
-0.3412331641,
-0.736672163,
0.263160646,
0.009390627,
-0.2968348563,
0.2602289915,
-0.3948494792,
-0.4738124907,
-0.551858902,
0.1063729748,
0.4288569689,
0.0002255057,
-0.0808416978,
-0.3611128628,
-0.0714546219,
-0.0744674429,
-0.5558080673,
-0.8707711697,
0.315505594,
-0.5843344927,
0.67904526,
0.2143560052,
-0.0105370302,
0.6166080236,
-0.4638321996,
0.7473896146,
0.3030197024,
-0.7755012512,
0.7713842988,
-0.6581791043,
0.872010529,
0.9291023612,
0.2193646133,
-0.1349503994,
-0.122797966,
-0.6421781182,
-0.372852385,
0.4614463747,
0.2713525891,
-0.3136484921,
0.0353403725,
-0.2088603973,
0.2016066462,
0.0189322345,
-0.4473120868,
0.2372069359,
-0.1988894194,
0.181213066,
0.1785289496,
0.2347667664,
-0.2037958205,
-0.6993547082,
0.4529577196,
-0.1918114126,
0.2348902971,
0.230703041,
-0.1170028076,
0.0395940766,
0.4560094178,
0.5291932225,
0.5889337063,
-0.1017333716,
0.0441901535,
0.7487497926,
-0.103881754,
0.1593520343,
0.1686324328,
-0.2591177523,
-0.385950923,
0.0107973935,
0.6829032302,
0.3145804703,
-0.6344459653,
0.6128022671,
0.1876022518,
-0.4677909911,
-0.1770364791,
0.2123963982,
0.2970664799,
0.4969438612,
0.2100724578,
0.6936318278,
0.5327054262,
-0.3999494612,
0.0860169604,
0.4536600709,
-0.3631515503,
-0.5946968794,
0.805670321,
0.2441622466,
-0.1669286042,
0.1417061239,
-0.4507961273,
-0.6193367243,
0.7887565494,
0.2087213248,
0.9862114191,
-0.0733738691,
0.0035913314,
0.400150001,
0.3799694479,
0.0976515934,
0.6647018194,
-0.2048635483,
-0.894398272,
-0.4511031508,
-0.0614137016,
-0.3335024118,
0.3989774287,
-0.3319947422,
0.5380245447,
-0.5595337152,
-0.4895272553,
0.4727097154,
0.1502742767,
-1.0400500298,
0.2087464035,
0.4127205014,
1.2871589661,
-0.4850913882,
0.6512723565,
1.0383687019,
-0.4774640203,
-0.6210624576,
-0.313082695,
0.3699696362,
-0.6763525009,
0.9333447814,
0.3453927636,
-0.3410399556,
-0.2730289102,
-0.5320216417,
-0.712970078,
1.0537478924,
0.2332083434,
-0.2540251315,
-0.1913382858,
-0.0184474476,
0.2851898968,
-0.2986994386,
0.2316182107,
0.5415841937,
0.4485977292,
0.0990442559,
-0.8381106257,
0.2321566492,
-0.4583703876,
-0.2315575778,
0.0990587026,
-0.9669061899,
0.8625067472,
-0.2524417341,
-0.2350852638,
-0.1512324661,
0.6466681361,
0.6822846532,
0.7211897373,
0.5725554824,
0.9015715122,
0.6173144579,
0.1563520283,
0.4336633682,
-0.1370263994,
-0.0857658833,
1.1868985891,
-0.7203239202,
0.9662606716,
0.4367789626,
0.1665678769,
0.5563237667,
0.087931186,
-0.0848962963,
0.5504626632,
0.0680091158,
0.0470619686,
-0.6404165626,
0.1363273561,
-0.3721432686,
0.8770175576,
0.2780251801,
0.1719533354,
-0.4949328005,
-0.0048065721,
-0.2800284922,
0.1109311581,
-0.3699211776,
0.3761843145,
0.1316624284,
-1.2269155979,
0.5342794657,
-0.0208510701,
0.4237870574,
-0.0358814485,
0.2572746575,
-0.1376096159,
0.597065866,
0.1297913492,
-0.9191047549,
0.4173206389,
-0.1094117239,
0.2363397181,
-0.2368498892,
1.2620484829,
0.2564909756,
-0.1958209723,
0.2137666643,
0.8351618648,
0.0485826172,
-0.0408767387,
-1.0132576227,
0.0912846774,
0.0083586536,
-0.1837575138,
0.2216397226,
0.8217803836,
-0.1520676762,
0.6609265804,
0.2589425445,
-0.2555093467,
-0.2116638571,
-0.0835547075,
0.6881434321,
-0.8938573599,
-0.7021232247,
-0.8814267516,
0.5280259848,
-0.3670005798,
-0.7097129822,
0.9459487796,
0.6991153955,
0.6344987154,
-0.1319824606,
0.5646001101,
0.164656505,
0.4811408222,
-0.0641892478,
0.6364302039,
-0.5444430113,
-0.0906365886,
-0.1234055534,
-0.6013657451,
-0.067848824,
0.4939874709,
-0.8301867247,
-0.1514776498,
0.9036749601,
0.6086795926,
-0.1351367384,
0.6686381102,
0.4519098997,
0.1105389297,
-0.2469651401,
1.0375950336,
1.0986666679,
-0.3254631758,
0.3975734115,
-0.1644193679,
-0.3204740584,
-0.1303623468,
-0.831509769,
-1.1992675066,
-0.5342534184,
-0.3584624827,
-0.243778497,
0.1593613327,
0.7501335144,
0.5391516089,
-0.7836390734,
-0.1436579823,
-0.4554596543,
-0.3070828021,
-0.4102832377,
-0.1920914948,
-0.2221739143,
-0.3498419523,
-0.3566231132,
0.5439442992,
0.5971505046,
-0.3182446361,
-0.0503310189,
0.1998590827,
-0.3243977427,
0.3761376739,
0.5820587277,
0.2527990341,
-0.6023155451,
-0.3665133119,
0.2191710621,
0.0089312941,
-0.0460572094,
0.5414720178,
-1.2471385002,
0.0248348955,
0.7887648344,
0.8651171327,
0.6755438447,
-0.1224075109,
0.4745825529,
0.0892579183,
0.0537871867,
0.6827166677,
0.3449586332,
0.0401305147,
-0.1881080121,
0.7084563971,
0.2867248952,
-0.7138132453,
-0.8403655887,
0.1398781091,
-0.8028973937,
-0.5175975561,
0.7737506628,
0.3037424982,
-0.5189076066,
-0.1293871552,
-0.0238800868,
-0.0012307008,
-0.3578466475,
0.5518603921,
0.8116133213,
-0.3210000992,
-0.1186618358,
-0.5630096197,
0.3078035116,
1.0414237976,
-0.5732983947,
-0.2707907856,
0.5104301572,
0.2926903069,
0.211806044,
0.7688477635,
-0.0065720459,
0.6531341672,
0.331769377,
-0.3909335136,
-0.1686390042,
-0.357005775,
-0.2318973541,
0.4913808703,
-0.4162612855,
-0.0626229942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13925v1
|
MARIO Eval: Evaluate Your Math LLM with your Math LLM--A mathematical dataset evaluation toolkit
| 2024-04-22T07:03:44 | 2024-04-22T07:03:44 |
Boning Zhang, Chengxi Li, Kai Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have been explored in a variety of reasoning
tasks including solving of mathematical problems. Each math dataset typically
includes its own specially designed evaluation script, which, while suitable
for its intended use, lacks generalizability across different datasets.
Consequently, updates and adaptations to these evaluation tools tend to occur
without being systematically reported, leading to inconsistencies and obstacles
to fair comparison across studies. To bridge this gap, we introduce a
comprehensive mathematical evaluation toolkit that not only utilizes a python
computer algebra system (CAS) for its numerical accuracy, but also integrates
an optional LLM, known for its considerable natural language processing
capabilities. To validate the effectiveness of our toolkit, we manually
annotated two distinct datasets. Our experiments demonstrate that the toolkit
yields more robust evaluation results compared to prior works, even without an
LLM. Furthermore, when an LLM is incorporated, there is a notable enhancement.
The code for our method will be made available at
\url{https://github.com/MARIO-Math-Reasoning/math_evaluation}.
|
[
-0.3881532252,
-0.9013698101,
0.704754293,
0.5142016411,
-0.1783976853,
0.3353787661,
-0.4996533692,
-0.1796777546,
0.1661684811,
0.4455564022,
-0.4612461627,
-0.569773674,
-0.5431923866,
0.2318386286,
-0.3028051555,
0.9329755306,
-0.2018181682,
0.4388917983,
-0.7327924371,
0.0495515913,
-0.2539204955,
-0.2757235765,
-0.5999829173,
-0.4228926301,
0.3564821482,
0.2054429054,
0.7239191532,
0.448176682,
1.0935444832,
0.3836020231,
0.139736563,
0.2408478111,
-0.4245926738,
0.2753084302,
-0.1109031439,
-0.3661441803,
-0.646682024,
-0.0987828225,
0.645993948,
0.7089548111,
-0.1916802526,
0.3346005976,
-0.0949698314,
0.5759874582,
-0.7488600016,
0.5022038817,
-0.4545114934,
0.0317074917,
-0.1233924404,
-0.0567988791,
-0.2864607275,
-0.7268932462,
-0.1495277733,
-0.6731772423,
-0.3318196237,
-0.2202024758,
0.3583772779,
0.3074539602,
-0.2333377004,
-0.5085252523,
-0.5027885437,
0.835688889,
-0.5634409189,
0.266050607,
0.3307875097,
0.6470400691,
-0.3349325061,
-0.5737181306,
-0.3653567433,
-0.5717920661,
0.1650263071,
0.2991240621,
-0.2584520578,
0.0450091399,
0.6599938869,
0.358643651,
-0.4843157828,
0.0152389929,
-0.3217511177,
-0.3064885139,
0.8068833351,
0.4427722991,
0.3647013009,
0.0241341367,
-0.098966077,
-0.0675306991,
-0.6666382551,
-0.1159605533,
0.6134748459,
0.2677475512,
-0.1889248937,
0.9671102762,
0.1036960036,
0.5516874194,
-0.3859099746,
-0.2889257073,
0.3006473184,
-0.1979428083,
-0.1815844178,
-0.0020101164,
0.9497722983,
0.2161968648,
0.4805813432,
0.015577984,
-0.390414834,
0.3446079195,
0.1354336441,
-0.7889729738,
-0.2488740385,
-0.1154433116,
0.0826321468,
-0.2448812127,
0.1805100143,
-0.7657334805,
-0.4355256855,
-0.3934186101,
0.4444688559,
-0.2345787883,
0.2120790929,
0.108277224,
0.0462148935,
-0.1949542165,
0.530566752,
-0.637989521,
0.6308313608,
1.1548659801,
0.8006251454,
-0.1019187495,
-0.1135850996,
-0.9566349983,
-0.2669789493,
-0.7662321925,
0.6638305783,
-0.8614187241,
-0.293736577,
-0.060999617,
-0.2155227661,
0.0714354813,
-0.5664944053,
0.6757860184,
-0.4009502232,
0.2429337651,
-0.1925544292,
-0.6237857342,
-0.0896262079,
0.0730581582,
-0.7512767911,
0.9574093223,
0.4194913805,
-0.4172936976,
0.1916345358,
-0.9321839809,
-0.2962217927,
0.1603041887,
0.0050987448,
-0.5652500987,
0.3405001462,
0.3294005394,
0.0823725313,
-0.502925992,
0.2919976711,
-0.8022007942,
-0.6472770572,
0.4524699152,
-0.6182934642,
0.9345861077,
0.2542450726,
0.091166757,
-0.0559824817,
-0.6266663074,
0.1599889994,
0.0121881245,
-0.3050075173,
-0.0843034163,
-0.1631840616,
-0.1596532464,
-0.0963269472,
0.5108999014,
-0.4431295395,
0.4816142619,
-0.4198359847,
0.1499946117,
0.767637074,
-0.1392557472,
0.2582283318,
-0.1937881559,
0.9073860049,
-0.2111302614,
-0.1396146268,
-0.2689651251,
-0.5938520432,
-0.6305350661,
-0.2650947273,
0.4083805084,
0.474778831,
-0.8421680331,
0.5304570198,
-0.2305941135,
-0.3434290588,
-0.5332026482,
0.4985938966,
0.30807513,
0.6226286888,
0.1380138844,
-0.2001819164,
-0.4551223516,
-0.9328545332,
-0.2285137028,
-0.1543385983,
-0.2873990834,
0.4020925462,
0.4444743693,
-0.15789029,
0.9766901135,
-0.3645948768,
-0.0050608409,
-0.5242631435,
0.0340223871,
0.4948088825,
0.2971731722,
0.4273833334,
-0.2516527474,
-0.4367106557,
-0.0490322039,
-0.6683924198,
-0.8018831611,
-0.1741283685,
-0.151031822,
-0.0227480754,
-0.0932544246,
-0.2805716693,
0.5253586173,
0.4185676277,
-0.22257559,
0.6424214244,
-0.2605588138,
0.1997563392,
-0.7482053041,
0.0440083221,
0.1553526968,
-0.35827443,
-0.322720021,
0.0408716276,
0.221247524,
-0.0500593372,
-0.381488055,
0.6087116003,
-0.1229675114,
-0.5387276411,
-0.0104817497,
0.314461261,
0.1004176661,
0.0630191043,
-0.2345010489,
1.0486973524,
0.7250906825,
-0.3892005682,
0.8688569665,
0.0813584551,
-0.6846131086,
0.4373218417,
-0.5742975473,
0.1440285891,
0.135004878,
0.159781903,
-0.6239203215,
-0.2082870603,
0.5164735317,
-0.309450686,
0.1001394838,
-0.0811908692,
-0.7613301277,
-0.4469885826,
-0.564594388,
0.2496499568,
0.3962949514,
-0.6496739984,
0.4238656461,
0.3299922049,
-0.2340754718,
-0.5110504031,
-0.6169407368,
0.2624235451,
-0.360527277,
-0.4883213341,
-0.2218035609,
-0.5163226724,
-0.6996046901,
-0.0864601433,
-0.0461913608,
-0.2967391908,
0.4172438085,
0.0870466009,
0.5933485627,
-0.3636045754,
0.1344667524,
0.2770697474,
-0.4799939692,
0.3716539741,
0.0900373086,
0.3864127994,
-0.3654383719,
-0.6964419484,
-0.4217036664,
-0.1964762509,
0.4404180646,
-0.0138346367,
0.2376847714,
0.2963681519,
-0.3934137821,
-0.1678257883,
-0.3930428922,
0.0738508999,
-0.4874390066,
0.4406001568,
-0.3825082779,
-0.6118075848,
0.3563249707,
0.0305125825,
0.0819428414,
0.3372125626,
0.6907221079,
0.0790754035,
1.1362097263,
0.1558493227,
-0.0672651306,
0.20365192,
-0.0721215084,
0.3473502398,
-1.0623264313,
-0.0492279492,
-0.4305217862,
-0.2965233922,
-0.3694621921,
-0.3952335119,
0.2443340272,
0.1302539557,
-0.2371328622,
0.3832085133,
-0.0948585346,
1.0092285872,
0.0915372744,
-0.0334366895,
0.4350684583,
0.036810644,
-0.1048114225,
-0.2609058022,
-0.3997883499,
-0.6875552535,
1.3775089979,
0.2264662832,
0.9345171452,
0.061057236,
0.6847611666,
0.2948012352,
0.7103101611,
-0.9909151793,
0.6507058144,
-0.1914949268,
-0.2738844752,
-0.1342654377,
-0.8731609583,
-0.8050839901,
0.1346907169,
-0.0679171979,
-0.9320222735,
-0.6337579489,
-0.1675099283,
-0.3440415263,
0.1121534705,
-0.6040011048,
0.7522845864,
-0.5980448723,
-0.5768794417,
-0.1450769156,
0.0189024974,
0.5287884474,
-0.5127736926,
0.1879049391,
-0.3071019053,
-0.3461029828,
0.5394817591,
-0.543609798,
0.3175792098,
0.1085285917,
-0.1187607348,
0.3280695081,
0.4974557161,
0.0566916578,
0.4951563776,
-0.3381405473,
0.191141516,
-0.0288927779,
-0.1426404864,
-1.0995351076,
0.9525644779,
-0.5495473742,
-0.5493335128,
-0.4228363335,
-0.8284125328,
-0.270855993,
0.0890692174,
-0.3971026838,
0.5615745187,
0.0565619394,
0.169296056,
0.137313962,
-0.308624953,
0.3953846395,
0.3400503695,
-0.67266047,
-0.6941293478,
0.8400657177,
-0.1311149448,
0.0933453888,
0.1724855602,
0.631249249,
-0.5135163069,
-0.0889499336,
-0.599766314,
0.1560100466,
-0.8592104316,
-0.3014794886,
0.0052654142,
-0.0955185443,
-0.2799780667,
-0.3006265461,
-0.270118475,
-0.6612327099,
-0.1077312157,
0.0554170199,
0.2577475309,
1.0509309769,
-0.0231845155,
0.2524733841,
-0.6247963905,
0.1796112657,
0.1460795403,
0.5400122404,
-0.2743167877,
-0.4271167815,
-0.1159968749,
0.2259649634,
-0.2607720494,
-0.6270582676,
0.4634105265,
0.1657380611,
0.6131716371,
0.5176332593,
-0.267886132,
1.0522760153,
-0.352930665,
0.5275427699,
0.2731558979,
-1.2461001873,
0.4885743558,
-0.0993561223,
0.1985316277,
0.693728745,
0.1753835827,
-0.2135575116,
-0.3380909264,
-0.585234344,
-0.296484679,
0.6642979383,
0.3875645995,
0.120771639,
0.1511016488,
0.272657007,
0.1674455553,
0.3631743193,
-0.6102899909,
0.0003745419,
0.2814378738,
-0.373812288,
-0.2666251361,
0.0109046791,
-0.029726848,
-0.3684389293,
0.5218268633,
-0.0690442026,
-0.028881222,
-0.3602248728,
-0.2326836586,
-0.1310027391,
-0.020601185,
0.4291201532,
1.1456829309,
0.0058390009,
0.1235143691,
0.4987995028,
-0.5852386355,
-0.0781676024,
0.0077113258,
0.1611680686,
0.0691003948,
0.5644019842,
0.4148274362,
0.4627114534,
-0.8586401939,
0.6337786913,
-0.1520219594,
0.0639274791,
-0.1321595609,
0.2587920129,
-0.0387994535,
0.0363341905,
-0.0103715807,
-0.108142823,
0.1778780371,
-0.3789872825,
0.2191287279,
0.3958079815,
-0.1489225179,
-0.2110966295,
0.3619969785,
-0.1000180617,
-0.5946601033,
0.738350153,
-0.2377242893,
-0.8004027605,
0.8538888097,
0.6200153828,
0.9529677629,
-0.0829604343,
0.0650081858,
0.391936034,
0.2673333287,
0.2039372772,
0.164029479,
-0.2456447035,
-0.3577279449,
-0.5949963331,
-0.7490733862,
-0.6903698444,
-0.0349255092,
-0.5675365925,
0.710827589,
-0.5610092878,
0.1006684452,
-0.241086036,
0.4587707818,
-0.6338226199,
-0.0828698725,
0.3643181324,
0.8617150784,
-0.8178433776,
0.6707122922,
0.6585523486,
-0.2113375962,
-0.4536963999,
-0.2386311293,
0.0546157509,
-1.0939286947,
0.6573066711,
0.2934974134,
-0.1605770439,
-0.3548626304,
-0.4381908774,
-0.7286936045,
0.8389987946,
0.6753394008,
-0.777561307,
0.620755434,
0.4440161586,
0.6568305492,
-0.5650703311,
0.8651382923,
0.6154135466,
0.6522887349,
0.2717898488,
-0.8577923179,
-0.3529665172,
-0.2768540382,
-0.010937172,
0.2078063041,
-0.2950409055,
0.5025320649,
-0.3251234889,
0.0163897518,
0.2662416697,
0.4062707424,
0.489425689,
0.6915201545,
0.2763897181,
0.724593699,
0.8309291005,
-0.2810010314,
1.097424984,
-0.4456983805,
0.6220319271,
1.1852762699,
-0.36328578,
0.6326162815,
0.2701003551,
-0.5708004832,
0.2706612945,
0.4950324595,
-0.2283084244,
0.0900718197,
0.5832400322,
-0.3407781422,
-0.5554212332,
0.1310030073,
-0.3398762941,
0.4258067906,
0.4760014713,
-0.147585541,
-0.5311766267,
-0.3065582216,
0.0342889875,
0.0430073664,
-0.3371214867,
0.5325351357,
0.2092406154,
-0.442638725,
0.1082651466,
-0.2151711285,
0.1655006856,
-0.7084258199,
-0.2288227528,
-0.2144965529,
0.1370494366,
-0.3172191679,
-0.9709203839,
0.341077894,
0.4169271588,
0.3961072564,
-0.0608723648,
0.4554515183,
-0.2789881527,
-1.1144815683,
0.0438933931,
0.5150515437,
0.5064672828,
0.3003930151,
-0.8973385692,
0.3919296861,
-0.2162289619,
-0.195487991,
0.1496470124,
0.3742506504,
0.0104041025,
0.8708817959,
0.97351861,
0.3719583154,
-0.2395007908,
0.5243039131,
0.9770962596,
-0.398024261,
-0.2853382528,
-1.1426309347,
0.2079600692,
-0.0991265997,
-0.3524034321,
1.0128393173,
1.1151008606,
0.5509192944,
0.157969445,
0.6670355201,
0.2214537561,
0.2245276868,
-0.4051631987,
0.5735641718,
-0.3925113678,
0.7087171078,
-0.4755401015,
-1.3705588579,
-0.6441063881,
0.971327126,
-0.689263463,
0.0415758491,
0.7303336263,
0.584253788,
-0.0613863133,
0.0723154992,
0.3775272369,
0.057974074,
0.4943296313,
0.7941169739,
1.1312283278,
-0.1962649226,
0.3382539451,
-0.5349174142,
-0.3146652579,
0.0301799253,
-1.1579717398,
-0.8804725409,
-0.0514207371,
-0.4708116651,
-0.3795939684,
0.0369804054,
1.1226490736,
0.1611007452,
-0.7480826974,
-0.5269076824,
-0.0013705275,
0.4377733469,
0.1054485291,
-0.2537240386,
0.1647105813,
-0.4739774764,
-1.0343445539,
0.4437480569,
0.508158803,
-0.2011451125,
-0.4215678871,
-0.1028766185,
0.4338952005,
-0.0399802327,
0.3807700872,
-0.1144940406,
-0.5158038735,
-0.1028493792,
-0.1731919646,
0.0195941683,
0.182309866,
0.7991393209,
-0.8886558414,
0.8935030699,
0.4890702367,
0.7523579597,
0.26171121,
0.0621935427,
0.4644414783,
-0.060958989,
-0.1885332018,
0.3920992613,
0.6582586169,
0.2549951971,
-0.1227423996,
0.5859132409,
0.1390867233,
-0.4052800536,
-0.9481927156,
-0.0745467022,
-0.9386174679,
0.1889062822,
1.001978159,
-0.3568266034,
-0.380966723,
0.2092678994,
-0.1649874002,
-0.1436216086,
-0.5347967744,
0.8221979737,
0.9653370976,
-0.2206424028,
0.1949187964,
-0.498658061,
0.0248059295,
0.2331426889,
-1.0929557085,
-0.0191575624,
0.5088725686,
0.2029338926,
0.0553063713,
-0.0008939264,
-0.1316393614,
0.4737835824,
-0.1035794839,
-0.3578666747,
-0.3812444508,
-0.4329997003,
-0.7864295244,
-0.0297955126,
-0.1970822215,
0.1859251261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13919v1
|
Navigating the Path of Writing: Outline-guided Text Generation with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-22T06:57:43 | 2024-04-22T06:57:43 |
Yukyung Lee, Soonwon Ka, Bokyung Son, Pilsung Kang, Jaewook Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly impacted the writing process,
enabling collaborative content creation and enhancing productivity. However,
generating high-quality, user-aligned text remains challenging. In this paper,
we propose Writing Path, a framework that uses explicit outlines to guide LLMs
in generating goal-oriented, high-quality pieces of writing. Our approach draws
inspiration from structured writing planning and reasoning paths, focusing on
capturing and reflecting user intentions throughout the writing process. We
construct a diverse dataset from unstructured blog posts to benchmark writing
performance and introduce a comprehensive evaluation framework assessing the
quality of outlines and generated texts. Our evaluations with GPT-3.5-turbo,
GPT-4, and HyperCLOVA X demonstrate that the Writing Path approach
significantly enhances text quality according to both LLMs and human
evaluations. This study highlights the potential of integrating
writing-specific techniques into LLMs to enhance their ability to meet the
diverse writing needs of users.
|
[
0.0277014803,
-0.5743533969,
1.0950601101,
0.0927121863,
-0.1775950342,
0.0606221594,
-0.3827207685,
-0.2938590944,
0.2726819813,
0.8919116855,
-0.813567102,
-0.9836043119,
-0.5318208933,
0.1544204056,
-0.4439457953,
1.2059781551,
-0.5019437671,
-0.4596399963,
-0.1337478757,
0.3235490024,
-0.3424256146,
-0.2135674357,
-0.4424029291,
-0.0924390554,
1.0233447552,
0.4198662937,
0.6227787733,
0.8654920459,
0.471429348,
0.0815307274,
0.3076847196,
0.2477023154,
-0.5883566141,
0.5937850475,
-0.0840440989,
0.0647560731,
-0.3853497803,
-0.1898505986,
0.6627945304,
0.792517662,
-0.1031975001,
0.1686736196,
0.2270580977,
0.4314027429,
-0.4727737308,
-0.3521842062,
-0.2169451714,
-0.1523557156,
-0.3348943591,
-0.3375947773,
-0.4244395494,
-0.6177806854,
-0.0101929773,
-0.7514023185,
-0.1312576979,
0.0938371718,
0.7288354039,
-0.1911724359,
-0.2451842725,
-0.9103836417,
-0.8144423366,
0.5996558666,
-0.6539871097,
0.2339393497,
0.1141259074,
0.3235990703,
-0.3380427957,
-0.9226654768,
-0.3521189392,
0.2739152312,
0.1433891207,
0.099239856,
0.1880596131,
0.1248349398,
0.1829146296,
0.1286744922,
-0.5999257565,
0.0246172566,
-0.1995310783,
-0.0323084071,
0.7488265634,
0.4274275899,
0.2838950753,
-0.0051391642,
-0.1904462129,
0.1270062178,
-0.9677818418,
0.1380797178,
0.7472276092,
0.3700593114,
0.1973057389,
0.7683104277,
-0.1273870915,
0.7814072967,
-0.2768273652,
-0.5038884878,
-0.3941862285,
-0.5396058559,
0.0531205572,
0.0563192666,
0.914588511,
0.7269770503,
0.2857687175,
-0.3424964845,
-0.5352687836,
-0.2382029891,
0.1779317856,
-0.881970942,
-0.0513509512,
-0.0675388798,
-0.2971248925,
-0.0981383547,
-0.0219499897,
-0.451207608,
-0.6535388827,
-0.5342648625,
0.1907827854,
-0.4446931481,
-0.2194891125,
0.2119619697,
-0.1219144836,
0.1542835385,
0.539142549,
-1.1794624329,
0.4564106762,
0.6296975613,
0.8213540912,
-0.1710104644,
-0.285910964,
-0.3696531057,
0.7089833021,
-0.4530603886,
0.8679504395,
-0.4269662499,
-0.3293148279,
0.229276821,
-0.6994274259,
0.1941365302,
-0.0991276726,
0.8100307584,
-0.0355129354,
0.0886344388,
-0.3326710463,
-0.6359261274,
0.0263259318,
0.0849952549,
-0.3458635509,
0.9493575692,
0.1047106385,
-0.389231205,
0.6161327362,
-0.3566373289,
-0.7496801615,
0.0193385612,
-0.1443046182,
-0.1386217177,
0.1239704639,
0.1341357082,
0.7508374453,
-0.3201512992,
0.3990164101,
0.2432192117,
-0.4461044669,
-0.0946309641,
-0.3146616518,
0.3136112094,
0.0223541968,
-0.1288797408,
0.475926429,
-0.8249168992,
0.1191809252,
-0.1242929474,
-0.7267062068,
-0.0938294679,
0.1224851459,
0.2175154537,
0.3340837359,
0.1278262138,
-0.3575215638,
0.3777308166,
0.0327618681,
0.2924720645,
0.863452971,
0.3275398314,
0.2964441478,
-0.4583310187,
0.5420786738,
-0.6032005548,
-0.0403849036,
-0.4575766027,
-0.4990215898,
-0.6810657382,
-0.0345482528,
-0.0746688098,
0.0106585324,
-0.0669122413,
0.6205176115,
-0.2387615144,
-0.6804556251,
-0.4289356172,
0.4149680138,
0.3572918773,
0.4182676375,
0.1270369291,
-0.0694403872,
-0.5095222592,
-0.4104588926,
-0.3229579031,
-0.129977718,
0.0246353652,
0.0114212455,
0.2700737417,
-0.1915600449,
0.808295548,
-0.6579064131,
-0.2275657058,
-0.6803330779,
0.2954396009,
0.1588424295,
0.2529996037,
0.089692153,
-0.3707491755,
-0.7802878022,
-0.2188214362,
-0.5409464836,
-0.3330745697,
-0.4550417066,
-0.6106837988,
0.044103954,
0.5590292811,
-0.5535293818,
0.2319330275,
0.4790201485,
-0.5093844533,
0.7564102411,
0.038694717,
0.1297529638,
-1.096503377,
0.1489498764,
0.0804446116,
-0.2179114521,
-0.5044622421,
-0.3224332631,
-0.4041029215,
-0.0542263016,
0.0183186047,
0.5064994097,
-0.5298032761,
-0.0600122139,
-0.1333233565,
0.1059501171,
0.3679681718,
0.3643364906,
0.2984620631,
0.4502287805,
0.3882490396,
-0.4050033092,
0.0019207699,
0.2350685894,
-0.4082659781,
0.4713079333,
-0.3969518542,
0.0049101263,
-0.0195023883,
0.1246042326,
-0.8732271194,
-0.2467615157,
0.0324484855,
-0.2387461066,
0.134967491,
0.0922995806,
-0.7090098262,
-0.0139221121,
-0.1379335821,
-0.095999293,
0.6323547363,
-0.1052624211,
0.5315030217,
-0.040300943,
-0.4110185504,
-0.1382320821,
-0.2674960196,
0.3636216521,
-0.0342270508,
-0.7293283939,
0.3879156113,
-0.2323013693,
-0.1910559684,
-0.1677258909,
0.0950553343,
0.1346052885,
0.0014909988,
0.4896756113,
-0.0790641755,
-0.2362970114,
-0.030490756,
0.2897967398,
0.109245941,
0.1519940943,
-0.2548817396,
0.5476621389,
0.3672893345,
-0.3152916729,
-0.3324103653,
0.7118581533,
0.4088109136,
-0.2245774269,
0.3801541328,
0.4632333219,
-0.4122734666,
-0.4751313031,
-0.3127767742,
-0.0801581219,
-0.3883116543,
0.0338201523,
-0.3273430169,
-0.6132311225,
0.3249289691,
-0.1138002723,
0.375082016,
0.3048171699,
0.4179136455,
-0.1293083876,
0.8095138073,
0.845399797,
0.4899213612,
0.1957714409,
-0.0345051512,
0.4335872233,
-0.9382145405,
-0.228400141,
-0.3258721232,
-0.0616078004,
-0.0379353017,
-0.2057031989,
0.1432251185,
0.377643168,
-0.203508988,
0.3695292771,
-0.5722080469,
0.3627187014,
0.467877686,
-0.2458102852,
0.5811483264,
-0.1351937503,
-0.3052979708,
-0.2877142131,
-0.6580207348,
-1.1692992449,
1.2507135868,
0.3138667643,
0.7327489853,
-0.032955233,
0.8976613879,
0.1234552339,
0.4514581859,
-0.449123919,
0.6411468387,
0.159441188,
-0.3730081916,
-0.4664852321,
-0.0452382639,
-0.5627214909,
0.0151209095,
-0.4554060698,
-0.8251646757,
-0.4446088076,
0.0828227997,
-0.424787432,
0.1293905675,
-0.4629802704,
0.9050219059,
-0.3196927011,
-0.7135639787,
0.2730543315,
-0.4912927747,
0.2638101578,
-0.0636010692,
-0.1026869938,
-0.2357269526,
0.0416151583,
0.8956856728,
-0.3874293864,
0.6539108157,
0.1002997458,
-0.2641300261,
0.6112561822,
0.1708844006,
0.4304583967,
-0.146420151,
-0.2677865028,
-0.1373591572,
-0.5137765408,
0.0937029272,
-0.5081959367,
0.6675853729,
-0.3046427965,
-0.4256055951,
-0.1678857207,
-0.474917233,
-0.2638088763,
0.6236259341,
0.4565446675,
0.5587246418,
-0.4543868303,
-0.3252566457,
0.4141451716,
-0.0566951521,
0.5166664124,
0.231986329,
-0.3440749049,
-0.2453267723,
0.7281311154,
-0.045937378,
0.3750752211,
0.3232724965,
0.0766878203,
-0.4970498085,
-1.1347256899,
-0.6621191502,
0.2965017855,
-0.8186523318,
0.0594740994,
-0.5048930049,
-0.2047535181,
-0.5591760278,
-0.9559788704,
-0.1348150969,
-0.1523883492,
-0.3037864864,
-0.0974453911,
0.0661533028,
1.186588645,
0.3274077773,
0.4342366755,
-0.5711011887,
0.0087851761,
-0.2522190809,
0.293002665,
0.0105985235,
-0.0809210464,
-0.1876439303,
-0.2589866221,
-0.4191045463,
-0.5518482924,
0.2785899937,
-0.1568538249,
0.4531992078,
0.3495001495,
-0.2010629326,
0.6008349061,
-0.6821144223,
0.7755748034,
0.5271757841,
-0.8350458741,
0.7427864075,
-0.8916079998,
0.2933731973,
0.7085337043,
0.5030050874,
-0.7434276342,
-0.5313991308,
-0.1842723042,
-0.9305405021,
0.2285716534,
0.4184086919,
-0.1330899745,
0.2165704817,
0.5370922089,
0.2524563074,
0.2456894666,
-0.7414160371,
0.1894324422,
-0.0297871176,
-0.5902938247,
-0.0886583626,
-0.1481657922,
-0.0013439667,
0.0293092001,
0.5521094203,
-0.1230327189,
-0.0766055062,
0.146395728,
0.0337481648,
-0.1452348232,
0.1609745324,
0.5597996116,
1.1410856247,
-0.0309077427,
-0.0742322505,
-0.599517107,
-0.4282295406,
0.1862992048,
-0.0604488589,
-0.3802698255,
0.030669678,
0.5525547266,
0.644538641,
-0.0626134649,
-0.6910936832,
0.5341998339,
0.0283178817,
-0.3397457302,
-0.1892087758,
0.3415315747,
0.2985316515,
-0.1567307115,
0.2459468693,
-0.1468385905,
0.2223166674,
-0.3386045992,
-0.0963297114,
0.1957131475,
-0.6494210958,
-0.1983483136,
0.5301858783,
0.5847243071,
-0.3368881345,
0.5584002733,
-0.0704169422,
-0.1112418249,
0.2182770669,
0.6733985543,
0.8361282945,
0.1202824116,
0.2444377095,
0.3951384723,
0.3016653359,
-0.1103896052,
0.2139545828,
-0.0040261932,
-0.3118924201,
-0.5009445548,
-0.9705794454,
-0.2469305545,
-0.1017490625,
-0.2696597576,
0.5710919499,
-0.5203509927,
0.046040263,
0.0552044101,
-0.1485812217,
-0.1711176485,
0.1942321211,
-0.0485522337,
0.8294301629,
-0.8021156192,
0.2624260783,
0.6311130524,
-0.4571626186,
-0.9813221693,
0.2755638957,
-0.0490451343,
-0.2240965068,
0.2897698283,
0.3088766336,
-0.4634725153,
0.1367793381,
-0.1817144305,
-0.6873291731,
1.2538510561,
0.1198810041,
-0.5413095951,
-0.2369336039,
0.3626762331,
0.5155382752,
-0.5698484778,
0.044421304,
0.1892037392,
0.4577204287,
0.1878399402,
-0.4589579105,
0.2538757026,
-0.0098248152,
0.0418481864,
0.3992846608,
-0.2440341264,
0.4508388042,
-0.3861072361,
-0.3827069402,
0.3349255919,
0.4608238041,
0.1603212357,
-0.030611245,
-0.000946962,
0.4076968133,
0.6719835997,
-0.0261142496,
0.8908326626,
-0.1497200131,
-0.2567867935,
0.8841228485,
-0.4876558185,
0.7435484529,
0.5009436607,
0.3476445973,
0.7891800404,
0.4450439513,
0.2443162799,
0.3492928445,
0.5254040956,
-0.356621176,
-0.1924363077,
-0.2518801987,
0.1605785936,
0.190104872,
0.2056767344,
-0.5972493887,
-0.2451474071,
-0.260712415,
0.4361968935,
0.7051182985,
-0.3796480298,
0.7469055057,
-0.1109336317,
-1.1792366505,
0.2053339332,
0.1164787039,
0.3840162158,
-0.7551484704,
-0.3671147823,
-0.0121146105,
-0.0708590075,
-0.298676312,
-1.2478501797,
0.2453561872,
0.2073728889,
-0.2478479147,
-0.8179653287,
0.7075818181,
-0.4363313317,
-0.4875679314,
-0.0792756379,
0.2669302225,
0.0064330189,
0.0478180833,
-0.2146888971,
0.1796558052,
-0.1476473659,
-0.4035161138,
0.0789806098,
0.5194958448,
-0.0908637047,
0.470225215,
0.7809311748,
0.1633009464,
-0.0698565617,
0.1628605872,
0.5541692972,
-0.6626115441,
-0.5303747058,
-0.7991392612,
0.6508522034,
-0.1146028042,
-0.839268446,
0.7414949536,
0.9673756957,
0.4831420481,
0.2424248308,
0.9785491824,
0.0875954628,
0.534424305,
-0.7755067945,
0.7843654752,
-0.1528865546,
0.013179726,
-0.5226362348,
-1.0655500889,
-0.4271621704,
0.4319115281,
-0.148215279,
-0.0082621248,
0.7802214622,
0.5814241767,
0.099413611,
-0.2266039699,
0.2300754935,
-0.2735395133,
0.5451385379,
0.7808145285,
0.75766927,
-0.2536005378,
0.587362349,
0.1161863655,
-0.2453297526,
0.1586356908,
-1.1328781843,
-1.0168077946,
-0.7398499846,
-0.1831241697,
-0.297668606,
0.3182118833,
0.4508287609,
0.638584435,
-0.0123045258,
-0.603064537,
-0.4772340953,
0.0939254314,
-0.0033527396,
-0.1375732273,
0.1806321591,
-0.2106092274,
-0.4808626473,
-0.0093701109,
0.5562896729,
0.095687218,
-0.5039721727,
-0.474981606,
-0.1978297681,
0.1422704458,
0.4353094101,
-0.0165696703,
-0.446523726,
0.0709411427,
0.0534624681,
-0.4781963229,
0.0151552754,
0.9646064043,
-0.0864847302,
0.112209864,
0.4369670749,
0.4340426326,
0.440702796,
-0.0130078653,
0.9107807875,
-0.5100295544,
-0.644710362,
0.4222011268,
0.1960828006,
0.5335300565,
-0.4186248481,
0.2781852186,
-0.1149825677,
-0.6320829391,
-0.4624988437,
0.2789503038,
-0.837992847,
-0.2667610347,
1.6659636497,
-0.2094365358,
-0.1356336325,
0.082546711,
-0.4481264353,
0.1027013585,
-0.3681225777,
0.3882759511,
0.8340334892,
-0.5230348706,
0.0209276751,
-0.3990892172,
0.7869884372,
-0.1987169534,
-0.9950849414,
0.3944074512,
0.8642578721,
0.1809762716,
0.0446889959,
1.0803849697,
0.04943984,
0.121100992,
-0.0446494818,
0.2198228389,
-0.0932894498,
-0.6291192174,
0.1578108668,
0.1140122712,
0.496113807,
0.3287521601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13906v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13906v2
|
Generating Attractive and Authentic Copywriting from Customer Reviews
| 2024-04-22T06:33:28 | 2024-05-14T08:05:00 |
Yu-Xiang Lin, Wei-Yun Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The goal of product copywriting is to capture the interest of potential
buyers by emphasizing the features of products through text descriptions. As
e-commerce platforms offer a wide range of services, it's becoming essential to
dynamically adjust the styles of these auto-generated descriptions. Typical
approaches to copywriting generation often rely solely on specified product
attributes, which may result in dull and repetitive content. To tackle this
issue, we propose to generate copywriting based on customer reviews, as they
provide firsthand practical experiences with products, offering a richer source
of information than just product attributes. We have developed a
sequence-to-sequence framework, enhanced with reinforcement learning, to
produce copywriting that is attractive, authentic, and rich in information. Our
framework outperforms all existing baseline and zero-shot large language
models, including LLaMA-2-chat-7B and GPT-3.5, in terms of both attractiveness
and faithfulness. Furthermore, this work features the use of LLMs for
aspect-based summaries collection and argument allure assessment. Experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of using LLMs for marketing domain corpus
construction. The code and the dataset is publicly available at:
https://github.com/YuXiangLin1234/Copywriting-Generation.
|
[
-0.1783351302,
-0.5599123836,
0.6340165138,
0.5315822363,
-0.3574521542,
0.0480064526,
-0.071973674,
-0.5520889163,
0.3876110613,
0.8379098177,
-0.6642302275,
-0.6661303043,
-0.0450368598,
0.3011258841,
-0.5817466974,
1.4258333445,
-0.1594479829,
-0.1064784005,
-0.3215745389,
-0.1126961187,
0.0834125057,
-0.5225378275,
-0.2811300755,
-0.0150102377,
0.5575377345,
0.4238623381,
0.4769929945,
0.391400218,
0.1629916877,
0.2586474121,
0.0415695608,
0.3601827025,
-0.5711067319,
0.6090065837,
-0.3271092176,
-0.2533449829,
-0.5340082049,
-0.1106109545,
0.4813924134,
0.310475409,
-0.1307028681,
0.2691697776,
0.2559859455,
0.7132219672,
-0.3768761158,
0.0998799652,
-0.7024392486,
0.1626304984,
0.1545608342,
-0.4502149522,
-0.4355460405,
-0.5675742626,
0.2144466639,
-0.8065888882,
0.2776968479,
0.2204593867,
0.8809189796,
-0.2564397752,
-0.0145770963,
-0.6705518365,
-0.7609126568,
0.761788249,
-0.7365697026,
-0.0155845145,
0.1199379563,
0.1350264996,
-0.2418920249,
-0.7072054148,
-0.7296190858,
-0.2853490114,
-0.0172038618,
0.3269484043,
-0.1549363434,
-0.3980527222,
0.1252270192,
0.6904542446,
-0.3386159241,
-0.0258139018,
-0.3890316784,
-0.0487356596,
0.8163015842,
0.2908658385,
-0.2155459076,
-0.371378094,
-0.6118452549,
-0.1198489368,
-0.615309298,
0.2189393789,
0.6781122684,
-0.0326715074,
0.1968600005,
0.6406396031,
-0.5535902381,
0.1694493741,
0.2789694369,
0.0150827114,
0.2142814994,
-0.3099032044,
-0.1545189768,
0.1216430813,
0.8075438142,
0.6269516945,
0.1253048629,
-0.0195630677,
-0.601185739,
-0.2363623977,
0.6084089875,
-0.818595767,
-0.0987255126,
0.2516750693,
-0.5910962224,
-0.8748831749,
0.3177631199,
-0.8343761563,
-0.3117088974,
-0.4214837551,
0.10425587,
-0.2979349196,
-0.0057183076,
-0.0296245776,
-0.0492141917,
0.3489029408,
0.1795340776,
-0.5806375146,
0.320325911,
0.6217999458,
0.4505025744,
-0.5438835621,
-0.3300685883,
-0.2673881054,
0.195859462,
-0.2887634933,
0.9407918453,
-0.1542257667,
-0.3822111189,
0.4212508798,
-0.082073912,
0.4736492634,
-0.643193543,
0.3229251206,
-0.6839547157,
0.19364582,
0.0569299869,
-0.5132017732,
-0.0072548958,
0.4602248669,
-0.6605350375,
0.8351267576,
0.1925432235,
-0.317291379,
0.3526719511,
-0.1982860863,
-0.9229445457,
-0.1305413544,
-0.0349413976,
-1.0990767479,
0.506126523,
0.4531099796,
0.4111860693,
0.0854715705,
-0.196327731,
-0.2423265725,
0.0461050719,
1.0285608768,
-0.2090392262,
0.100736104,
0.5575541258,
-0.4233985841,
0.2450814545,
-0.7025952339,
0.0743918195,
0.5082527995,
-0.4522544742,
0.2215474695,
-0.1958470792,
0.2488870025,
0.1349121481,
0.0872147679,
-0.1365887374,
0.257332474,
-0.5098451972,
0.2992485762,
0.7602822185,
0.5087370276,
0.4038059711,
-0.7374021411,
0.9235431552,
0.0370643064,
0.2673959732,
-0.6622920036,
-0.2576076388,
-0.8006106019,
0.1196295545,
0.0112258717,
0.2537490129,
-0.8594694138,
0.3904956877,
-0.2651778162,
-0.4001524448,
-0.4273122251,
0.512396276,
0.5652006865,
0.2228029817,
0.3741266131,
-0.693330884,
-0.4381498694,
-0.9009785652,
-0.3250924647,
-0.1909687072,
-0.0683949664,
0.4278033078,
0.0464453772,
0.0263387989,
0.8519355655,
-0.800681591,
-0.4500326514,
-0.8578472137,
0.0109946942,
-0.0325146057,
0.160963729,
0.4473163486,
-0.4100271165,
-0.4626557827,
-0.1474922895,
-0.4144871533,
-0.3030976653,
-0.6490159035,
-0.4469550848,
0.4850340486,
0.2789390087,
-0.5691491365,
0.3408782482,
0.2559356987,
-0.0160065927,
0.7019532919,
-0.1236177608,
0.172130242,
-1.3261965513,
-0.0190523341,
0.2766417563,
-0.3263970017,
-0.2136979401,
-0.0548985638,
-0.4364978075,
-0.192644462,
-0.6082314849,
0.3219564557,
-0.3837817609,
-0.173862651,
-0.2580093443,
0.0553211458,
0.6352780461,
0.6771942973,
0.0649119616,
0.4078897536,
-0.047660403,
-0.5999149084,
0.2495652884,
0.525598228,
-0.6278458834,
0.7670425177,
-0.5611541867,
0.1058968902,
-0.0126653435,
0.3620827198,
-0.6561980247,
-0.3141304851,
0.2674229443,
-0.4912407696,
0.0995072722,
0.0787519962,
-0.4263719618,
-0.0863363892,
-0.520355463,
-0.0668493584,
0.798950851,
-0.6094112396,
0.5181303024,
0.1210262105,
-0.4438754916,
-0.2418761849,
-0.4624834657,
0.1603605151,
-0.2056959122,
-0.3124594092,
0.4144127965,
-0.0187771954,
0.010698407,
-0.1567954868,
0.0322262533,
0.0774728805,
0.0299491212,
0.14197658,
0.1467591226,
-0.0547249988,
-0.0575622693,
-0.0203545485,
0.0604629591,
0.2309391946,
-0.6429173946,
0.4416419268,
-0.0471193157,
-0.188081488,
-0.3265604675,
0.3445628881,
0.4596070051,
-0.064305082,
-0.0142543642,
0.2605965734,
0.0963865891,
-1.0438120365,
-0.4630502164,
-0.1695651412,
-0.5041466355,
0.58530581,
-0.3137036264,
-0.5785689354,
0.1607331932,
0.120381467,
0.0431232378,
0.3199989498,
0.7777252197,
-0.3263198733,
0.6901896,
0.5665991902,
0.1601632237,
0.5977346897,
-0.0430261679,
0.2239146531,
-0.5813263059,
-0.3004001677,
-0.1695552021,
-0.4753194153,
-0.4010317326,
-0.1516298652,
0.0053594639,
0.196242854,
0.0833658502,
0.4157449901,
-0.5734117031,
0.5298948884,
0.6511734724,
0.2686454654,
0.3994181454,
0.5830218196,
0.041023165,
-0.0510833561,
-0.3116747737,
-0.629750967,
1.1430892944,
0.3231008351,
0.8359590173,
-0.001219746,
0.5737186074,
0.348975718,
0.4229671955,
-0.7949559093,
0.5444366932,
0.0066079469,
-0.182186529,
0.0383058675,
-0.3517934382,
-0.7467445731,
-0.1764050722,
-0.3157442808,
-0.0912347063,
-0.0586918592,
0.4211322069,
-0.361192137,
-0.0429269783,
-0.1430732161,
0.6401389837,
-0.7411976457,
-0.7043119073,
-0.1258447766,
-0.3326768875,
0.3467879593,
-0.1100090444,
-0.0432682745,
0.0275790822,
0.2279128879,
0.4514758289,
-0.460498631,
0.7848044634,
0.255223006,
-0.1629007608,
0.493216902,
0.3648694158,
0.3236866593,
0.1046017334,
0.1370068938,
-0.18406789,
-0.3716920912,
-0.2450763434,
-0.7359784245,
0.6326418519,
-0.4691044986,
-0.3997246921,
-0.2221252471,
-0.1873748899,
-0.2558266222,
0.1192900836,
0.19262743,
0.3044376969,
-0.5400264263,
-0.020923093,
0.4801283479,
-0.4668638408,
0.3269502819,
0.3499059379,
-0.5929200649,
-1.0083601475,
1.1329431534,
-0.4643957913,
0.5463906527,
0.2591086626,
0.093202889,
-0.2843976915,
-0.6158377528,
-0.5219037533,
0.0046686479,
-0.7917848229,
-0.2611279488,
-0.6992044449,
-0.1665114164,
-0.4337473214,
-0.3134934902,
-0.2666319013,
-0.6277721524,
-0.1248298287,
-0.2691398561,
0.3144857287,
1.0962253809,
0.3061380386,
0.3715884387,
-0.799941361,
0.2414835542,
0.2245365381,
0.3533493876,
0.2275172472,
-0.4079607427,
-0.3459143341,
-0.2477171272,
-0.9439187646,
-0.5221012235,
0.7103970647,
0.2252416462,
0.4049260318,
0.4938188493,
0.0845312476,
0.4248006344,
-0.4247549176,
0.9504956603,
0.2732439637,
-0.8425329924,
0.5537031889,
-0.1927747577,
0.1248012707,
0.6216518283,
0.3413592577,
-0.3842589557,
-0.5723528862,
-0.6993821263,
-1.0884610415,
0.4279335141,
0.3039231002,
0.3726100624,
-0.1139623821,
0.3322327733,
0.3742160201,
0.580008328,
-0.8731396198,
0.0327322744,
-0.5008883476,
-0.4178009629,
0.0520149954,
-0.3991786838,
0.0865714699,
0.1727764457,
0.8452278376,
-0.2239807844,
0.1203995571,
0.2497112602,
-0.3462038338,
0.0525771305,
0.4933232665,
0.7257299423,
0.4712752104,
0.1084645092,
-0.0719728842,
-0.096515879,
-0.3248855472,
-0.14630723,
-0.074939847,
-0.3576527834,
0.0590752698,
0.2176330239,
0.723508358,
0.3277484179,
-0.7168667912,
0.8118339777,
0.1083661243,
-0.3025025129,
-0.4475716949,
-0.160905093,
-0.0960850343,
0.0674387291,
0.0390776619,
-0.1170987561,
0.1929843128,
-0.5794048905,
0.4811105132,
0.200890705,
-0.4542170167,
-0.4389165044,
0.4728508592,
0.443223685,
-0.2031883895,
0.7258634567,
-0.3662806749,
-0.7205851078,
0.3634347916,
0.6196001172,
1.1837979555,
0.1843573302,
0.3057348132,
0.2014932334,
0.0605705976,
0.0155216772,
0.185649544,
-0.228375718,
-0.4028624296,
-0.2383504212,
-0.9286430478,
-0.7029372454,
-0.1035133377,
-0.5687642097,
0.4691587389,
-0.7315855026,
0.0783289149,
-0.1545591652,
-0.325686574,
-0.4527715743,
0.0625988916,
0.21929124,
0.3589326739,
-0.5781217217,
0.4475508332,
0.4277171493,
-0.8468461037,
-0.5288999677,
0.1579771191,
-0.1287905872,
-0.7508185506,
0.5352450013,
0.4467370212,
-0.0010938908,
-0.3227289319,
-0.5872302055,
-0.3675812483,
1.0014600754,
-0.1591346413,
-0.4533497393,
0.0571325943,
0.5165945292,
0.5520976782,
-0.7988322377,
0.0731892586,
0.3152472675,
0.0757323429,
0.353012383,
-0.4853054583,
0.005015986,
-0.3719036877,
0.0975528806,
-0.3054386973,
-0.3475419283,
0.4720804095,
-0.1042994335,
-0.0706121325,
0.4151055515,
0.7606493831,
0.5089676976,
0.2585468292,
0.3399374783,
0.6380755305,
0.2762190104,
0.2918376923,
1.1213409901,
-0.2888680696,
0.0240331404,
1.4213247299,
-0.4375520051,
1.0391495228,
0.3406563401,
-0.0343367718,
0.7348276973,
0.3679376543,
-0.3685843945,
0.5237087607,
0.5859835148,
-0.169029817,
-0.0823958367,
-0.1218046546,
-0.0340045765,
0.1147277802,
0.0349529013,
-0.9420438409,
0.0555810519,
-0.2094758004,
-0.0190785043,
0.3682107925,
-0.1549456269,
1.1895393133,
0.3526264727,
-0.8032127619,
0.2507787645,
-0.0425779074,
0.6413576603,
-0.5362270474,
-0.164344579,
-0.3264656067,
0.3806384802,
-0.3481314182,
-0.9374369383,
0.1786381006,
0.1188154519,
-0.283121556,
-0.7003836632,
0.4457698762,
-0.5101765394,
-0.6424848437,
-0.122665152,
0.2180520892,
0.0437506437,
0.0008070074,
-0.5533373356,
0.0315269642,
0.2297118902,
-0.5642370582,
0.2401494682,
0.3393800855,
0.0541422851,
0.2828961313,
0.8556898236,
0.2147053629,
-0.1736458242,
0.1471429765,
0.6615324616,
-0.6327937841,
-0.7193959355,
-0.6943891644,
0.6948838234,
-0.4921886325,
-0.4953835905,
0.7905904055,
0.8535113335,
0.8708304167,
-0.3794284463,
1.0235512257,
0.3785523772,
0.4450804293,
-0.5715636015,
0.8282473087,
-0.3323246241,
0.4902842045,
-0.2748043537,
-1.3567713499,
-0.1454075724,
0.4392701387,
-0.0349457338,
-0.0903712139,
0.7566921115,
0.7209455371,
0.1541764736,
-0.0505568683,
0.1106277779,
0.1109248176,
0.5450100899,
0.5507891178,
1.1150853634,
-0.2721572518,
0.8653011918,
-0.2597084641,
-0.0017831753,
-0.1724549532,
-1.1553360224,
-0.8708155155,
-0.2427220643,
-0.5333994627,
-0.9547107816,
-0.1784331948,
1.0339461565,
0.3614652753,
-0.7400471568,
-0.1903897971,
0.1295208484,
-0.2158283144,
-0.3255999684,
-0.2420795113,
0.0652171895,
-0.5315347314,
-0.6415907145,
0.2117803544,
0.3098515868,
0.225084424,
-0.4898810089,
-0.1110606194,
0.5302824974,
0.3318372667,
0.622643888,
0.2155022472,
-0.5171381831,
0.1592155099,
0.1533455253,
-0.1690351516,
0.2137723267,
0.985929966,
-0.5158452392,
0.2259583473,
0.3528765738,
0.630271554,
0.4725246429,
0.241178453,
0.9057861567,
-0.7206797004,
-0.2478464395,
0.3640087843,
0.2224326432,
0.5403884649,
-0.1962895244,
-0.0337996073,
0.0443232954,
-0.4728992581,
-0.4056578875,
0.5506577492,
-1.0935658216,
-0.196629867,
1.3481943607,
-0.1762036085,
-0.2851420939,
0.2754227221,
-0.2765190601,
-0.2553681731,
-0.47223562,
1.0869293213,
0.3853301108,
-0.03572217,
0.1499600857,
-0.0510829389,
0.6689522266,
0.3595915139,
-0.949583292,
0.0882284492,
0.6395714879,
0.3392679691,
-0.1635152251,
0.3785302341,
-0.2720118165,
0.2445150763,
-0.2568115294,
0.1896235794,
-0.2763788104,
-0.2238830179,
-0.3771100342,
0.2214750946,
0.4291230142,
0.1318975836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15155v1
|
Adaptive Collaboration Strategy for LLMs in Medical Decision Making
| 2024-04-22T06:30:05 | 2024-04-22T06:30:05 |
Yubin Kim, Chanwoo Park, Hyewon Jeong, Yik Siu Chan, Xuhai Xu, Daniel McDuff, Cynthia Breazeal, Hae Won Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Foundation models have become invaluable in advancing the medical field.
Despite their promise, the strategic deployment of LLMs for effective utility
in complex medical tasks remains an open question. Our novel framework, Medical
Decision-making Agents (MDAgents) aims to address this gap by automatically
assigning the effective collaboration structure for LLMs. Assigned solo or
group collaboration structure is tailored to the complexity of the medical task
at hand, emulating real-world medical decision making processes. We evaluate
our framework and baseline methods with state-of-the-art LLMs across a suite of
challenging medical benchmarks: MedQA, MedMCQA, PubMedQA, DDXPlus, PMC-VQA,
Path-VQA, and MedVidQA, achieving the best performance in 5 out of 7 benchmarks
that require an understanding of multi-modal medical reasoning. Ablation
studies reveal that MDAgents excels in adapting the number of collaborating
agents to optimize efficiency and accuracy, showcasing its robustness in
diverse scenarios. We also explore the dynamics of group consensus, offering
insights into how collaborative agents could behave in complex clinical team
dynamics. Our code can be found at https://github.com/mitmedialab/MDAgents.
|
[
-0.3042918444,
-0.5624890327,
0.875172317,
0.2580722868,
-0.1726659685,
0.5207823515,
-0.0389192998,
-0.1642324477,
0.2811513543,
0.4327229559,
-0.7515272498,
-0.2613483369,
-0.6244422197,
0.2860440314,
0.2508955002,
0.8483092785,
-0.3468957543,
0.3304474056,
-0.6033170223,
-0.6452339292,
-0.558796227,
-0.3392162621,
-0.6249118447,
-0.6422867775,
0.474227339,
0.4705127478,
0.8028158545,
0.7869061828,
0.8004642725,
0.4931919575,
0.1031862572,
0.3425117135,
-0.3529903889,
0.2952881753,
-0.4051369727,
-0.3743210435,
-0.7634885311,
-0.1314994246,
0.3202849925,
1.1485137939,
-0.6852042675,
-0.1728857756,
-0.1430607587,
0.8115253448,
-0.4735296369,
-0.090523079,
-0.518101275,
0.0597933307,
0.2699319422,
-0.4709081948,
-0.3601906002,
-0.2372347564,
0.3665048182,
-0.4998256266,
0.2050805837,
0.0727971271,
0.0549204536,
0.6877232194,
-0.3941379189,
-0.4380975962,
-0.5864349604,
0.3672260642,
-0.1250021607,
0.1508247405,
0.0512063988,
0.5470076203,
-0.4742790759,
-0.9481241107,
-0.0024219763,
-0.0951435417,
0.1976519972,
0.4585677385,
-0.0122545166,
0.3453777134,
-0.1612380296,
0.2289026529,
-0.3872930408,
0.2176773399,
-0.2266581655,
-0.0041818665,
0.508841455,
0.498675704,
0.107895799,
0.4276786745,
-0.6362938881,
0.2513886392,
-0.133326605,
-0.1541351229,
-0.6837132573,
0.0907638595,
-0.309610486,
0.4630516469,
-0.1619369239,
0.4725976586,
0.5405580401,
-0.2712762058,
0.4452908933,
-0.4093144238,
-0.5626931787,
0.1072117239,
0.5105905533,
0.6374821067,
-0.2005510926,
-0.1885087788,
-0.078530781,
0.1584815234,
0.2905478179,
-0.5035543442,
-0.38295874,
0.345653832,
-0.4545825124,
-0.4832371175,
-0.3486999571,
-0.454867065,
-0.8677346706,
-0.1657485962,
0.5462573767,
-0.2572186589,
-0.1392193139,
0.2828659713,
-0.0573364459,
-0.1575307995,
0.7301360965,
-0.4998101592,
0.5910578966,
0.3574074209,
0.9514501691,
-0.5432043672,
-0.4052894115,
-0.6290615797,
0.2032209188,
-0.47521469,
0.7876674533,
-0.1563920379,
-0.675457716,
-0.5159673691,
-0.1443402022,
-0.4753350019,
-0.8019914031,
0.3682613373,
-0.1778436601,
0.0541382842,
-0.3510174155,
-0.4508253634,
0.0641571209,
0.3755484819,
-0.7275699973,
0.2425682396,
0.1761868596,
-0.3808775246,
0.4564973712,
-0.9438380003,
-0.2759141922,
0.1871391535,
-0.4207085967,
-0.4513764083,
0.1326723695,
0.1490394175,
0.4743923545,
-0.4292062521,
0.1877221018,
-0.2044766843,
-0.1006097049,
0.531550467,
-0.1054743826,
0.598515451,
0.1822987348,
-0.2393862903,
0.6781973243,
-0.557054162,
-0.056062948,
0.0326061547,
-0.3452722132,
0.0446469858,
0.1362823993,
-0.4158298075,
0.2545596659,
-0.0864831209,
-0.0160529725,
0.2262299657,
-0.0348365195,
0.346155107,
0.9645786285,
0.3847576976,
0.4856693447,
-0.888974905,
0.6584705114,
-0.1995444894,
0.3879555762,
0.3417396843,
-0.2946522832,
-0.4324713349,
-0.7414128184,
0.1213397607,
0.4761132896,
-0.9145243764,
0.1527169049,
-0.1698969156,
-0.3541315794,
-0.4327861369,
-0.0437373333,
0.2037125677,
0.6812868714,
0.2766757905,
-0.4233618081,
-0.3403028846,
-0.8028721809,
0.1018676013,
-0.193323046,
0.2171275169,
0.243253231,
0.4165989459,
-0.5038279891,
0.7190888524,
-0.2286054492,
-0.2961962223,
-0.2351289839,
-0.160482049,
0.2150583863,
0.3718087077,
0.5299236774,
-1.070746541,
-0.414347887,
0.0760067776,
-0.7594023347,
-0.1926628351,
-0.0663076788,
-0.0819913298,
0.151723668,
0.4337345064,
-0.429181546,
0.1338935941,
0.7225055099,
-0.4218405783,
0.4582012296,
-0.4165200889,
0.4316109717,
-1.2936017513,
0.0303453244,
-0.2313988209,
-0.4130457044,
-0.7485342622,
-0.1533906758,
-0.1974698156,
0.2691610157,
-0.3631860614,
0.2881608009,
-0.5245721936,
-0.0013587342,
-0.3605778217,
0.0070867972,
-0.1733934134,
0.3078031838,
-0.1721860468,
0.6753093004,
0.4640669823,
-0.5613684654,
0.5549764633,
0.3080049157,
-0.0250514895,
1.0913223028,
-0.3804245293,
0.0304320958,
-0.0037424264,
0.3329345286,
-0.7332890034,
-0.3357684016,
0.3274898827,
-0.3854753375,
0.0694195777,
-0.204541415,
-0.279270947,
-0.1559733897,
-0.2480671853,
0.4830757976,
0.260648489,
-0.3130981624,
1.0295850039,
0.4972490072,
-0.303123951,
-0.3809981346,
-0.6942489147,
0.133325249,
-0.2022564411,
-0.5186766386,
0.448058337,
-0.4917432964,
-0.5995357037,
0.0500343516,
-0.2649036944,
-0.1330925375,
0.2293880731,
0.6139793992,
0.262467742,
-0.0003476028,
0.0220249798,
-0.0492303036,
-0.2273585647,
0.0724811181,
-0.0006726816,
0.1049338058,
-0.2550705969,
-0.5307248235,
-0.0041264156,
0.3429631591,
1.0807504654,
-0.2071142048,
0.7316211462,
0.2987155914,
-0.4956646264,
-0.2013148814,
-0.6356089711,
-0.0717050061,
-0.4783496559,
0.4607670009,
-0.3834045529,
-0.7566418052,
0.6929805875,
-0.5310950279,
-0.0028410463,
0.199995622,
1.1943291426,
-0.0137036229,
1.0130342245,
0.3868228793,
0.1012146994,
-0.093782343,
-0.0308352411,
-0.3711698651,
-0.5699319839,
-0.4015636146,
-0.2113027424,
-0.3086167276,
-0.3497115076,
-0.7300300598,
0.8468439579,
-0.2473546416,
0.0749876797,
-0.2988260388,
-0.5317299366,
0.4146243632,
0.1720633507,
0.3564150035,
0.3904980421,
-0.2291296422,
-0.6270290017,
0.2659873068,
-0.9222430587,
-0.0665562972,
0.8128590584,
0.1650470942,
0.5102301836,
0.3466465175,
0.7353058457,
0.4215191901,
0.4715794027,
-0.7130204439,
0.4912919402,
0.1400014907,
-0.414104104,
0.0557060279,
-0.434864819,
-1.0835551023,
0.4903500378,
-0.4260935783,
-0.3926323056,
0.1768126637,
-0.0377270654,
-0.4566417933,
0.290518254,
-0.5036005378,
0.607652247,
-0.318241179,
-0.492515713,
-0.3210269511,
-0.8563913107,
-0.147715196,
-0.3578800857,
0.3711861372,
-0.2269776613,
-0.590425849,
0.2967082858,
-0.4936145544,
0.6102517247,
-0.0521376058,
0.2447340786,
0.1247592047,
0.1595732421,
0.3882676065,
-0.0128802825,
-0.3488819599,
-0.2038224787,
-0.0800671354,
-0.3820934594,
-0.4628304243,
0.7517827153,
-0.6163734198,
-0.458747834,
-0.5689383149,
-0.7971720099,
-0.4115992486,
0.3185863793,
0.1662593186,
0.3156246543,
-0.3613500893,
0.1961170733,
0.3508399427,
0.3096606433,
0.3726484776,
0.7008708715,
0.0113458186,
-0.7941595912,
0.5358538628,
0.1258567572,
0.4587162435,
0.1821651161,
0.2156188041,
-0.050545916,
-1.1266624928,
-0.4313242733,
0.0692741945,
-0.7876780629,
-0.1379134208,
-0.2704798281,
0.0288429614,
0.0551751666,
-0.6146346927,
-0.3021117151,
-0.0949725583,
-0.0571753196,
-0.0423078164,
0.1409271508,
0.7484291792,
-0.045446638,
-0.0644128099,
-0.6014860272,
0.2312752455,
0.2227555811,
0.4332677722,
-0.4201601744,
-0.0067071998,
-0.2428629696,
-0.1422270834,
-0.1473078728,
-0.9015138745,
0.0194267388,
-0.1801796257,
1.0117180347,
-0.032524474,
0.1678328514,
0.4328179955,
-0.3685424626,
0.2684975564,
0.2825484276,
-0.5805755854,
0.3179157376,
-0.3716181219,
0.1543637514,
0.864959836,
0.1054046005,
-0.0846044272,
0.0810159594,
-0.5350235105,
-0.4582865834,
0.5205773115,
0.5235634446,
-0.6428582072,
0.3380099833,
0.466367811,
-0.0021915396,
0.2505129278,
-0.2960235775,
-0.3421904147,
0.3038503528,
-0.3935650587,
-0.0058468045,
0.2264236063,
-0.7179222703,
-0.0142514305,
0.2965409458,
-0.4435266852,
0.0924539268,
0.5734080672,
-0.0617391393,
-0.4198368788,
0.0591742396,
0.6828230023,
1.0033762455,
-0.1016090959,
-0.0767606646,
0.5732812285,
-0.3259842098,
0.3828777969,
0.3346824646,
0.3759715855,
-0.3341940939,
0.3878551722,
0.3576318026,
0.0003249849,
-0.6368674636,
0.3346009552,
-0.2389460504,
-0.5221997499,
0.1034406498,
0.1260965616,
0.1106853783,
0.6970505714,
0.2761000693,
0.6397871971,
0.1307835281,
-0.409059763,
0.3879093826,
0.250475049,
-0.4999628365,
-0.0767036825,
0.4405397177,
0.5040050745,
-0.3724746406,
-0.0309629403,
0.0884784311,
-0.3489553034,
0.8120821714,
0.2948136926,
0.7929585576,
-0.5258781314,
0.1081580371,
-0.3223208189,
0.3127225935,
-0.0741672739,
0.0599851236,
0.1532239169,
-0.7819539905,
-0.2793482244,
-0.0541889593,
-0.8862974644,
-0.2260142118,
-0.3824471831,
0.2254505306,
-0.659527123,
-0.2900274992,
0.07252682,
0.0852832422,
-0.5011467934,
0.2227500379,
-0.133498475,
0.6523472071,
-0.4672753513,
0.5900079012,
1.18430686,
-0.049362801,
-0.6022207141,
-0.2503294945,
0.5944104791,
-0.8464893103,
-0.3693768382,
-0.0930283591,
-0.3202134371,
-0.0844521523,
-0.1972049326,
-0.6061828136,
1.5449329615,
0.5263228416,
-0.3237690926,
0.1807394028,
-0.1346955597,
0.5709428191,
-0.6805179119,
-0.0350610167,
0.322878629,
0.22893323,
0.3572830856,
-1.2157161236,
0.2699267864,
-0.230565384,
-0.4472151995,
0.1178374961,
-0.7166226506,
0.7309284806,
-0.6404075027,
0.1209353209,
0.2367150784,
0.0626553819,
0.7321959734,
0.6573799253,
0.7441234589,
0.2511560619,
0.8721878529,
0.0738645196,
0.738083601,
-0.1239852607,
0.0573122688,
0.9115427136,
-0.5749147534,
0.274125576,
0.5178893209,
-0.2818299532,
0.2889714539,
0.5054431558,
-0.0778113157,
0.3128944039,
0.0596644878,
-0.4427777827,
-0.2790895998,
-0.1285247654,
-0.3451906145,
0.2732123733,
0.4728482068,
-0.4937420785,
0.0557885766,
0.1245914474,
-0.0693956912,
0.1052902639,
-0.3738526106,
1.0763781071,
0.0743318871,
-0.6813548207,
0.4442873299,
-0.2407391369,
0.1756426692,
-0.5748055577,
-0.0286269616,
0.0881437883,
0.5224974751,
-0.3145109415,
-0.5692964792,
-0.1491752863,
-0.4922057688,
-0.3688573837,
0.0263019856,
0.7100605369,
-0.2449373156,
-0.4151209891,
0.3572923839,
0.9162380099,
-0.2954074144,
0.2101890594,
-1.0136371851,
0.2125078738,
-0.0428569987,
0.0336564556,
0.2668598294,
0.3594908416,
0.0903728977,
0.9717411995,
0.5036321878,
0.1575411856,
-0.3223510385,
0.1386838406,
0.9230702519,
-0.4061404467,
-0.4211911559,
-0.8781253695,
0.3865694404,
0.0316984616,
0.0534173399,
0.4223632216,
0.4377845526,
0.2482738346,
0.274802506,
0.8385224342,
0.2298552096,
0.3151566684,
-0.4303057194,
0.691137135,
-0.5492559671,
0.3671632707,
-0.2673630416,
-0.6546844244,
-0.4769388735,
0.4616520107,
0.1754633933,
0.1776864976,
0.6346773505,
0.4890576899,
0.1613991112,
-0.0318598785,
0.1373620927,
0.3424017727,
0.5455808043,
0.7868697047,
0.5635507703,
0.0063151079,
0.4572175741,
-0.2592264116,
-0.7488070726,
-0.293731302,
-0.7912479639,
-0.8288315535,
-0.3984284997,
-0.4778446853,
-0.3780760467,
0.2753619254,
1.4829764366,
0.8414564133,
-0.4383868575,
-0.2877345085,
-0.1023041978,
0.1599887758,
-0.3689718246,
-0.0852504596,
0.2851414979,
0.0888504907,
-0.3265787661,
0.6932258606,
0.521410048,
0.1477821618,
0.029000923,
-0.5951048136,
-0.2753380835,
0.1434456557,
0.3854886293,
0.0201445371,
-0.5986195207,
-0.0781655163,
0.0518470667,
-0.2685112357,
0.1698289216,
0.7592763305,
-0.7327358127,
0.7501417994,
0.1854541451,
0.7380974293,
0.1453004926,
0.1007759795,
0.6888259053,
-0.2933877707,
-0.2041115165,
0.4516603053,
0.4546753764,
0.182050541,
-0.1254630685,
0.8414871693,
0.3964811862,
-0.8796110749,
-0.8156381845,
-0.0939324424,
-1.2637152672,
-0.2488420904,
0.8616169691,
0.0985365659,
0.0599011555,
-0.3229869902,
-0.4209152162,
0.130102396,
-0.2192251086,
0.6419724226,
0.3791610599,
-0.5983363986,
0.0316611119,
-0.2706413567,
0.4625469148,
0.5509976745,
-0.8157252073,
-0.3478539288,
0.5270953178,
0.3708987832,
0.174714148,
1.0766973495,
0.0034988692,
0.6103131771,
-0.2114133835,
-0.2830364406,
-0.2829324305,
-0.3342692554,
-0.3387016654,
0.236736089,
0.2127058208,
-0.3335371017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13899v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13899v1
|
Towards Better Text-to-Image Generation Alignment via Attention Modulation
| 2024-04-22T06:18:37 | 2024-04-22T06:18:37 |
Yihang Wu, Xiao Cao, Kaixin Li, Zitan Chen, Haonan Wang, Lei Meng, Zhiyong Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM
|
In text-to-image generation tasks, the advancements of diffusion models have
facilitated the fidelity of generated results. However, these models encounter
challenges when processing text prompts containing multiple entities and
attributes. The uneven distribution of attention results in the issues of
entity leakage and attribute misalignment. Training from scratch to address
this issue requires numerous labeled data and is resource-consuming. Motivated
by this, we propose an attribution-focusing mechanism, a training-free
phase-wise mechanism by modulation of attention for diffusion model. One of our
core ideas is to guide the model to concentrate on the corresponding syntactic
components of the prompt at distinct timesteps. To achieve this, we incorporate
a temperature control mechanism within the early phases of the self-attention
modules to mitigate entity leakage issues. An object-focused masking scheme and
a phase-wise dynamic weight control mechanism are integrated into the
cross-attention modules, enabling the model to discern the affiliation of
semantic information between entities more effectively. The experimental
results in various alignment scenarios demonstrate that our model attain better
image-text alignment with minimal additional computational cost.
|
[
-0.2456341684,
-0.6014924049,
0.7346718907,
0.3165174723,
-0.5781505108,
-0.2945446074,
0.0095347259,
-0.2447313517,
0.0069827018,
0.3977189362,
-0.7013839483,
-0.2522709072,
-0.8134022355,
0.0629154518,
-0.5068826675,
0.9137599468,
-0.3660119474,
-0.3710503578,
-0.3525700867,
0.1086048409,
-0.4347513914,
0.167737931,
-0.7596018314,
-0.5005590916,
0.8015494943,
0.2985593975,
0.5929345489,
1.0938571692,
0.4376887977,
0.3020646274,
0.2311653197,
0.0617128722,
-0.395860523,
0.2852113843,
-0.334756881,
-0.390668422,
-0.189610377,
-0.0750789195,
0.7031151652,
0.1381366998,
-0.0535183363,
0.0909226909,
0.2647254169,
0.6157548428,
-0.7526570559,
-0.1737722009,
-0.8620607853,
0.0129010668,
-0.1220242307,
-0.1738197953,
-0.5557024479,
-0.1853721142,
0.0565302521,
-0.7963448167,
0.5578522682,
-0.0236412846,
0.8966915607,
0.7340795398,
-0.4544221759,
-0.0576975457,
-0.6010404229,
0.7782553434,
-0.2477108985,
0.340074569,
0.1090757325,
-0.132733196,
0.2284598202,
-0.4210265279,
-0.6267416477,
0.5121144652,
-0.0513167493,
0.2330692559,
0.0079908958,
-0.2067510188,
-0.0480492823,
0.028831074,
-0.2877686024,
-0.2224477679,
-0.0210491437,
-0.0577908605,
0.3119493723,
0.053246405,
0.1157385483,
-0.2798763812,
-0.7529057264,
0.0001057928,
-0.515666008,
-0.2336845845,
0.3057992458,
0.1001761705,
-0.195218429,
0.6082472801,
0.115686886,
0.5027307868,
0.927236557,
0.0568653606,
0.076665923,
-0.3935886025,
-0.2429137379,
0.2446690649,
0.9110044241,
0.4958305061,
-0.0702118129,
-0.3396285474,
-0.1795310974,
-0.0007710181,
0.4469219148,
-0.9237784147,
-0.0971737355,
0.1129638553,
-0.4414868355,
-0.525485754,
-0.2282998413,
-0.7859965563,
-0.0787856653,
-0.1796468198,
0.4914634526,
-0.2604308128,
-0.221548304,
-0.0260249618,
-0.211116761,
0.1140756458,
0.2283737808,
-1.0978227854,
-0.1144000292,
0.3420735002,
0.9789875746,
-0.5129818916,
-0.0497758426,
-0.200281024,
1.0028254986,
-0.0286662709,
1.0111554861,
-0.6173397899,
-0.2304669172,
-0.0804578662,
0.0558845662,
-0.2029321492,
-0.2614719272,
0.0077331746,
-0.6278312206,
0.4293307662,
-0.1353757679,
-0.2867389917,
-0.0423183925,
0.1804953367,
-0.5999931097,
1.0111482143,
-0.0727154613,
-0.9324943423,
0.4381315112,
-0.6139332056,
-0.4298096001,
0.0749570802,
-0.125269264,
-0.670294404,
-0.0497753359,
0.305017978,
0.5110237598,
-0.3474910855,
0.2265552133,
-0.0039458955,
0.1451325119,
0.4033567607,
-0.3247250021,
0.4528616071,
0.0987698287,
-0.5730443001,
0.2207506001,
-0.7285370231,
-0.0183118731,
0.2795566022,
-0.1314648986,
-0.3065118194,
-0.0889279991,
-0.1969802827,
0.2575131059,
0.1780179888,
-0.315715909,
0.0718209743,
-0.2905117273,
0.3139294088,
0.5432898402,
0.3902693093,
1.182341218,
-0.1295256168,
0.5422590971,
0.3998792768,
0.1057614759,
-0.248068437,
-0.3810259998,
-0.7424770594,
-0.3874168694,
0.1350586563,
0.5966261625,
-0.9131294489,
0.2479221374,
0.0574448071,
-0.2667526305,
-0.6968580484,
0.2509156168,
0.4344423115,
0.866910696,
0.3550594747,
-0.4871765077,
0.1087609753,
-0.8692715168,
-0.0093741911,
0.3257645667,
-0.0132258097,
0.205764994,
0.2970975637,
-0.0109186647,
0.7160810828,
-0.4974570572,
-0.3931334913,
-0.0607909374,
0.2398308665,
-0.2220483869,
0.8367087841,
0.3288519382,
-0.6719343662,
-0.6590414643,
-0.1213127971,
-0.5309545994,
-0.0737062097,
-0.2610712945,
-0.7774537802,
0.1201476976,
0.5411016345,
-0.7959520221,
0.3469355106,
0.3256728649,
-0.3397441208,
0.0177122056,
0.0845583603,
0.2656457424,
-1.2304600477,
0.1381792724,
0.330532521,
-0.354845643,
-0.7022166848,
-0.0944300219,
0.4671598673,
-0.2272798717,
-0.7185765505,
0.4528006315,
-0.7826097012,
0.4662819803,
-0.4000206888,
0.1903693676,
0.4373230636,
0.4978869855,
0.0577374361,
0.4458407164,
0.7443116307,
-0.5707756281,
0.3139445782,
0.3650570512,
-0.1171243712,
0.9705762863,
-0.6244959831,
0.4451034069,
-0.3895449638,
0.2052154094,
-0.9582784176,
-0.1655946821,
0.8121221662,
-0.2043814212,
0.8293480873,
-0.0575992912,
-0.388302058,
0.0329673067,
-0.247363627,
0.9113903046,
0.2554721236,
-0.1873749346,
0.7375004292,
-0.0209893044,
-0.0391395055,
-0.4656152725,
-0.7380926609,
-0.1217129305,
-0.5248704553,
-0.7614148259,
0.639443934,
0.1021983102,
0.1585892439,
0.2741292715,
0.1090115756,
-0.0497763567,
-0.1574252248,
0.0499073677,
0.2527733743,
-0.0506843626,
0.1551753879,
0.2677344084,
-0.3191431165,
0.0255958661,
-0.4946447313,
0.3635053635,
0.8887038231,
-0.2458625138,
-0.8377736211,
0.7771193981,
0.2455564737,
-0.3040996492,
0.9119598269,
0.6211206913,
-0.3331795037,
-0.1697335392,
-0.4218097031,
-0.322590977,
-0.5294259191,
0.2126213908,
-0.1039446667,
-0.3607370853,
0.4647373855,
0.0847421139,
0.0891370624,
0.487080276,
0.6580795646,
-0.0954043344,
1.0720353127,
0.9766362906,
0.1695756763,
0.8621842861,
0.0706075057,
0.1066281125,
-0.8480838537,
-0.2919280827,
-0.3806975186,
-0.5592353344,
0.0302331038,
-0.7275409698,
0.2629156411,
-0.147013858,
-0.0544500425,
0.1400616616,
-0.9551466107,
0.7098103762,
0.2425076216,
0.325184226,
0.1037444025,
0.1322330534,
0.2113187015,
-0.1975286007,
-0.6265341043,
-0.2430076748,
0.8318631649,
0.3185437322,
0.9465857148,
-0.189814955,
0.6831083894,
-0.1097892076,
0.1842435747,
-0.4763072431,
0.418851018,
0.0233220067,
-0.6754180193,
-0.4187474549,
-0.2158362418,
-0.7471191883,
0.1553732008,
-0.0317808129,
-0.5496046543,
0.2466342449,
0.4459181428,
-0.2584050894,
0.0194015279,
-0.8866425753,
0.9407488108,
-0.0424994752,
-0.7672356963,
-0.0917992741,
-0.6651985049,
0.2571645081,
-0.2097811401,
-0.0815793797,
-0.2013284564,
-0.3567242026,
0.5308009982,
-0.2275703549,
0.9885400534,
-0.2031531185,
-0.5116373897,
0.2013627738,
-0.0058755185,
0.7448172569,
0.0052033132,
0.010202636,
-0.2632457912,
-0.5964746475,
-0.5280304551,
-0.4516982734,
0.4894278646,
-0.5334259272,
-0.6796524525,
-0.0854153931,
-0.6671714187,
-0.0140371835,
0.190777421,
0.862459898,
0.2448241711,
0.1152609661,
-0.2066215575,
1.1190727949,
0.1879906654,
0.4654307067,
0.1865753233,
0.0339426175,
-0.3634152412,
0.9471116066,
-0.3215104342,
0.8615840077,
0.4841994047,
-0.0229845606,
-0.2405878156,
-0.2805366516,
-0.5956332684,
0.3866086602,
-0.795111239,
-0.5313706398,
-0.8138177991,
0.0260235108,
-0.616825223,
-0.5152155161,
-0.4040898383,
-0.1693467647,
-0.8644106388,
0.2591768503,
0.317748189,
0.3936608434,
0.3217842877,
0.580514431,
-0.5056542754,
0.4724018574,
0.2393855751,
0.1512772739,
0.1686931103,
-0.5553144813,
-0.163718015,
-0.2144399583,
-0.7185005546,
-1.2164525986,
0.2490473241,
0.4076233804,
0.2333976775,
0.5448585749,
-0.1810561866,
0.6014284492,
-0.5039561987,
0.6092774868,
0.716614902,
-1.0427310467,
0.7296897769,
-0.2776875198,
0.7954146862,
0.3250305653,
0.3525253236,
-0.373891443,
-0.9792478085,
-0.506940484,
-0.9948404431,
0.8786409497,
0.1299113929,
0.1400267184,
0.1415501386,
0.5969665647,
0.217991814,
0.2415629029,
-0.8644791842,
-0.2582857609,
-0.3868428469,
-0.5508005619,
0.1119113341,
-0.1939051002,
-0.2160188705,
-0.1188708544,
0.8626270294,
-0.1658668965,
0.4249290824,
0.2851040363,
-0.1279587746,
-0.6570219994,
0.0427853465,
0.596234262,
0.2484076023,
0.3837256432,
0.2915633023,
-0.0164444484,
-0.4328429401,
0.3818438053,
0.004337844,
-0.6037723422,
-0.023056142,
-0.1113446578,
0.8603406549,
0.2062380165,
0.1533990353,
0.4332456887,
0.0054886993,
-0.4170309603,
0.4060511291,
0.1285670102,
0.248558864,
0.3913984895,
0.1966270059,
0.1151086167,
0.074825801,
-0.2201097757,
0.003490682,
0.5940542817,
-0.465883404,
-0.2362251133,
1.1207406521,
0.3767077923,
-0.0515184626,
0.4571655393,
0.0158778466,
-0.5142646432,
0.5555843115,
0.725925684,
0.931542635,
-0.3967787623,
0.3541641235,
0.2707872391,
0.2993322313,
-0.1216623709,
0.1227743626,
-0.2509812713,
-0.6429707408,
-0.2592154443,
-0.2550732195,
-0.0145203704,
-0.3018704355,
-0.3019168377,
0.330244571,
-0.3373188078,
-0.2741701603,
0.1222767904,
-0.5844506621,
-0.5510210395,
0.2644040883,
0.2298499495,
0.4434729815,
-0.8924332261,
0.7892378569,
0.4845628142,
-0.1642763317,
-0.7036021352,
0.1343954951,
-0.1825564057,
-0.7696028948,
0.4213257432,
0.3069978952,
-0.0172961485,
0.2488356084,
-0.7971072793,
-1.0179480314,
1.0599776506,
0.424433887,
-0.5517585874,
-0.1832005531,
0.1633670628,
0.1248886958,
-0.6154847145,
-0.1383882165,
0.2461609393,
0.4120821059,
0.2853830755,
-0.4708032906,
0.4467661977,
-0.1071825773,
0.0167076886,
0.5780739188,
-0.7830593586,
0.4158305526,
-0.1753278673,
-0.5662692785,
-0.2432872653,
0.9350857735,
-0.1095071286,
0.305280596,
0.7014411092,
0.6165012717,
0.4310982525,
-0.0662464723,
0.648209393,
-0.2065363824,
0.0937947184,
0.9223120213,
-0.2857685983,
0.3149924576,
0.9042556882,
0.2830162644,
0.389551729,
0.3954419196,
-0.1439448595,
0.9988854527,
-0.0168170873,
-0.3560578227,
-0.1860634238,
-0.3064827323,
-0.1826058924,
-0.2978329957,
0.1018468738,
-0.6324458122,
-0.1379928589,
0.2126679569,
-0.1290386766,
-0.0480997376,
-0.3271469474,
0.9954514503,
-0.043331895,
-0.8201022744,
0.3803901374,
-0.2519703805,
0.6949003339,
-0.4771578312,
0.3708626032,
0.1032043472,
0.0499324314,
-0.321074307,
-0.7043514848,
0.2336525768,
0.003305081,
-0.7009353638,
-0.6181513667,
0.7719823718,
-0.9171118736,
-0.4456365407,
-0.1436359435,
0.0610157587,
-0.0950952172,
-0.155413121,
-0.6967625618,
0.087181516,
0.1060135812,
-0.3585914969,
0.2466553301,
0.7397143245,
0.1054645479,
0.3494770229,
0.1733123511,
-0.132301867,
0.4895454347,
0.0108270943,
0.6721225977,
-0.4533858001,
-0.5315086842,
-0.8749835491,
0.633693099,
-0.0153735317,
-0.2131033391,
0.2876489758,
0.2944362462,
0.4591712654,
-0.0866865814,
0.5401363373,
0.0079806708,
0.0861473158,
-0.5780003071,
0.6842887402,
-0.6875963211,
-0.3393897116,
-0.1885330826,
-1.1638349295,
-0.1068747342,
0.231852755,
-0.0089042224,
-0.1920929253,
0.9377685785,
0.7029976249,
-0.0621740036,
-0.3377128243,
0.1661569923,
-0.2821732461,
0.2659247816,
0.5457328558,
0.5530418158,
-0.413000524,
0.6968490481,
-0.4743264019,
-0.1065670699,
0.0974343941,
-1.0850965977,
-0.778976202,
-0.774590373,
-0.844547689,
-0.2475266457,
-0.1739414781,
0.4749260545,
0.7824148536,
-0.3999377191,
0.3166613579,
-0.1527254283,
-0.1747595072,
-0.0578704812,
-0.2324092537,
0.2093413472,
-0.437964648,
-0.8295154572,
-0.1109250858,
0.5428440571,
0.5300152302,
-0.2313976884,
0.2309956849,
-0.1746658832,
0.1832084209,
0.2603480816,
-0.0352504477,
-0.5706958771,
0.0031335531,
-0.1969507337,
-0.4641454518,
0.2606538534,
0.9851778746,
-0.3153027594,
0.1845507026,
0.407643944,
0.3675346971,
0.4682137072,
0.2378084809,
0.6448808312,
-1.0187600851,
0.2860318422,
-0.0032105988,
0.0104682408,
0.578553319,
-0.9235566258,
0.0383657813,
0.1153398529,
-0.621543169,
-0.4492643774,
0.1854581237,
-1.1012804508,
-0.0840744302,
1.042140007,
0.1140345633,
-0.6305271387,
0.1620489657,
-0.2933498621,
0.6571395397,
-0.7205146551,
0.9570583701,
0.7156736851,
0.0783967972,
-0.4244248569,
-0.2329230458,
0.5003391504,
0.6860970855,
-0.8390401602,
0.0966361314,
0.4023670256,
0.2772619426,
0.2222347111,
0.4535256326,
-0.0879483148,
0.3104247451,
-0.3292588592,
0.2925826907,
0.2850670815,
-0.3048156202,
-0.2639536858,
0.2511762679,
-0.2162006646,
-0.4064135551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13885v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13885v1
|
Surveying Attitudinal Alignment Between Large Language Models Vs. Humans Towards 17 Sustainable Development Goals
| 2024-04-22T05:12:52 | 2024-04-22T05:12:52 |
Qingyang Wu, Ying Xu, Tingsong Xiao, Yunze Xiao, Yitong Li, Tianyang Wang, Yichi Zhang, Shanghai Zhong, Yuwei Zhang, Wei Lu, Yifan Yang
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as potent tools for advancing the
United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). However, the attitudinal
disparities between LLMs and humans towards these goals can pose significant
challenges. This study conducts a comprehensive review and analysis of the
existing literature on the attitudes of LLMs towards the 17 SDGs, emphasizing
the comparison between their attitudes and support for each goal and those of
humans. We examine the potential disparities, primarily focusing on aspects
such as understanding and emotions, cultural and regional differences, task
objective variations, and factors considered in the decision-making process.
These disparities arise from the underrepresentation and imbalance in LLM
training data, historical biases, quality issues, lack of contextual
understanding, and skewed ethical values reflected. The study also investigates
the risks and harms that may arise from neglecting the attitudes of LLMs
towards the SDGs, including the exacerbation of social inequalities, racial
discrimination, environmental destruction, and resource wastage. To address
these challenges, we propose strategies and recommendations to guide and
regulate the application of LLMs, ensuring their alignment with the principles
and goals of the SDGs, and therefore creating a more just, inclusive, and
sustainable future.
|
[
-0.4073131382,
-0.331438452,
0.6545372605,
-0.1228695512,
-0.2223769873,
0.7055512071,
-0.4257277548,
-0.4187553525,
0.0985450372,
0.3581677973,
-0.424470216,
-0.5527045131,
-1.0111535788,
0.0683257282,
0.0091911778,
0.7910693884,
0.003725328,
0.131091401,
-0.1812040508,
-0.128530398,
-0.3633738756,
-0.2554361522,
-0.4770396948,
-0.550585568,
0.5686879754,
0.3776155412,
0.7914963961,
0.5377551317,
0.6116493344,
0.2826763093,
-0.5863258839,
0.0552602708,
-0.476038456,
-0.2304987013,
-0.2359449118,
-0.2739763558,
-0.3535880744,
0.2215365171,
0.6978379488,
0.754868865,
-0.0669514015,
0.5116907954,
0.2778268158,
0.645478189,
-0.4140931666,
-0.1476552188,
-0.5460034609,
0.0679906309,
-0.2026501,
0.0488056652,
0.1662529111,
-0.3141822219,
-0.1618868113,
-0.3087698519,
-0.000817562,
0.0772596821,
0.7229287028,
0.5120864511,
-0.6928073764,
-0.4136960208,
-0.204284519,
1.1424751282,
-0.8454016447,
0.3884464204,
0.415884316,
-0.2120090872,
-0.3434835672,
-0.1994144171,
-0.6563107967,
0.1666912735,
0.3232775331,
0.2101286054,
0.0424718596,
0.078958869,
0.4168365002,
0.2008241564,
-0.3847398758,
0.4777852297,
-0.5338742137,
-0.1105038896,
0.9406650662,
0.0942073986,
0.173025921,
-0.5305701494,
-0.5388081074,
0.0472219698,
-1.0023747683,
0.1746721715,
0.7640627027,
0.4603275359,
-0.326711297,
0.645690918,
-0.0144678699,
0.5034630299,
0.0413985997,
-0.2705725431,
0.1807852536,
-0.5156068206,
0.1852090657,
0.1855811775,
0.7115151286,
0.7907431722,
0.4222522378,
0.064562209,
-0.289825052,
0.428057909,
0.4165946841,
-0.4487990141,
0.2333309501,
0.0708529577,
-0.5700026155,
-0.1180390716,
0.002737999,
-0.6518887877,
-0.6807860136,
-0.8475515246,
-0.2256609797,
-0.0103465831,
-0.1380627453,
0.0776395574,
0.2056847066,
0.5050782561,
0.4010030925,
-0.6835039258,
0.1406301409,
0.9001693726,
0.7696021199,
-0.211485073,
-0.0308037568,
-0.067864053,
0.0288179126,
-0.3026091754,
0.458234936,
-0.5002586842,
-0.7252950072,
-0.1265910864,
-0.18028225,
0.1238603145,
-0.4613381922,
0.784378469,
0.0311800577,
-0.0426939316,
-0.9485929608,
-0.3988266289,
0.0131090684,
0.2417310774,
-0.2422483712,
1.011459589,
-0.3304106593,
-0.4648250639,
0.5347271562,
-0.5654055476,
-0.2247505039,
-0.0316644721,
-0.3803526759,
-0.2195260525,
0.3694933951,
-0.0739608929,
0.4906789064,
-0.6109151244,
0.6595081091,
-0.3637344837,
-0.271397382,
0.130660817,
-0.4732197523,
1.0576303005,
0.35144943,
-0.1142381877,
0.3113868833,
-0.6557030678,
0.0457530431,
0.0455791131,
-0.5042153597,
-0.2103820592,
0.4954013824,
0.0310196467,
0.3761695325,
0.5274730921,
-0.6476507783,
0.1905925274,
0.1547855884,
0.8905969262,
1.1315894127,
-0.2475871295,
0.4493892193,
-0.4195697904,
0.4169346392,
-0.0947264582,
0.4648315907,
0.4446525872,
-0.3814354539,
-0.3756308854,
0.0058583771,
-0.0620795526,
0.3551929295,
-0.1520540714,
0.8132131696,
-0.4364275038,
-0.4432467818,
-0.6373195052,
0.4666870236,
0.1265284717,
0.358841747,
0.1788204759,
-0.2355787009,
-0.4442642927,
-0.6396017671,
-0.2398939133,
-0.5818943381,
-0.035560064,
0.0567527227,
0.6584689021,
-0.3269224465,
0.7157444954,
-0.1136767864,
-0.3148855567,
-0.0769837573,
-0.2909834087,
0.0105188508,
0.4848202467,
0.4369865954,
-1.138909936,
-0.2697771788,
-0.041345235,
-0.6836442947,
-0.1331222504,
0.2642739415,
0.176717788,
0.0583246462,
0.5013892055,
-0.5461653471,
0.1472913623,
0.6462805867,
-0.3143019974,
0.3689602911,
-0.0715499371,
0.328880161,
-0.9692421556,
-0.0967802107,
0.4784865677,
0.060253486,
-0.3569526672,
-0.169429183,
0.0777049586,
-0.0698322654,
-0.3156447709,
0.5181987286,
-0.5017958283,
-0.0830096751,
0.1258456558,
0.2261065543,
-0.1444797218,
-0.0887892321,
0.0299304016,
0.6709133387,
0.2587630451,
-0.4177580178,
0.4948484302,
0.391110003,
-0.5178588033,
0.8628907204,
-0.6790081859,
0.1327920705,
-0.3336178958,
0.3420471251,
-0.9006329179,
-0.0594847165,
0.2099856734,
-0.5890625119,
0.0801046491,
0.1026464626,
-0.4358464479,
-0.6167644262,
-0.5187115669,
0.3028318584,
0.510633409,
-0.0948813483,
0.3856625557,
0.579703927,
-0.304195255,
-0.6183763742,
-0.7502518892,
0.3714926541,
-0.8168340921,
-0.5896103382,
0.4038059711,
0.0571612045,
-0.6865398288,
-0.2240768522,
-0.3305702209,
0.4503596127,
0.0450185984,
0.3262261748,
0.1716751307,
0.0558494925,
-0.060908936,
-0.4661746323,
-0.1081447303,
0.1690021902,
-0.0827940926,
0.3676719666,
-0.0771915242,
-0.4234591722,
-0.0381403677,
0.2953979075,
0.7133571506,
-0.3572355807,
0.6667976379,
0.458412528,
-0.3661250472,
0.2856094539,
-0.6640310287,
-0.0911254138,
-0.4262363911,
0.3383207917,
-0.112040177,
-0.7554762959,
0.7477612495,
-0.0871625394,
0.1297838688,
0.0644642413,
0.4560415745,
-0.4264629781,
0.8536189795,
0.5209547877,
-0.3220308125,
0.5430768728,
-0.0894401968,
0.3273242712,
-1.1965450048,
-0.4229938686,
-0.564324975,
-0.5439283848,
-0.6359024048,
-0.4399594367,
0.2509482503,
0.2163225859,
-0.5133433938,
-0.0327887945,
-0.535772264,
0.3152543008,
0.2199727595,
-0.0985192582,
0.1657504141,
-0.0584047139,
0.1321033686,
-0.3111588359,
-0.5818095803,
-1.1389625072,
0.855804503,
0.4431232512,
1.0767627954,
0.288946718,
0.668348372,
0.6500178576,
0.0334312022,
-0.7121405602,
0.5333815217,
-0.195073083,
-0.5331568122,
-0.4277131855,
-0.2273431867,
-0.7390028238,
0.0685384348,
-0.1437847167,
-0.9185373187,
0.2050926089,
0.0244252253,
-0.2162481248,
0.3686361611,
-0.5220766068,
0.7413964868,
-0.5221580267,
-0.4368500412,
-0.3052176535,
-0.8768276572,
0.0180468541,
-0.1032424122,
0.5813899636,
-0.6281388998,
-0.236540243,
0.6895516515,
-0.1319552809,
1.1382358074,
-0.2372944057,
-0.7060496807,
0.3757691383,
-0.5078815818,
0.5463302135,
-0.1004027277,
-0.3121574521,
0.1338842362,
-0.1517347097,
-0.5438700318,
-0.0285698604,
0.778762877,
-1.0010451078,
-0.6952259541,
-0.5773832798,
-0.3417917192,
0.0097335903,
-0.0123017663,
0.1013546735,
0.0859227851,
-0.2690449059,
-0.0006067925,
0.8438744545,
-0.407235086,
0.3497295082,
0.2492683232,
-0.0260517113,
-0.1516591609,
0.8740748167,
0.3672442436,
0.7115424871,
0.0527196266,
0.2035382241,
-0.8025933504,
-0.6304775476,
-0.3302271664,
0.1896490455,
-0.7947608232,
-0.2578695714,
-0.1899629086,
0.0092456378,
-0.4604002833,
-0.5953863859,
-0.2560828328,
0.3879368901,
-0.3353001177,
-0.0684029907,
0.3614493906,
0.721595943,
-0.1463360786,
0.1157225519,
-0.5421933532,
0.2505459487,
-0.1725271195,
0.0456035025,
-0.1267586648,
-0.4757940471,
0.1440580785,
0.5559664369,
-0.412670821,
-0.5683080554,
-0.0521622971,
0.0000550304,
0.5465428233,
0.4804336727,
0.3356725574,
0.8600597978,
-0.3825010955,
0.8427581191,
0.4725520015,
-0.9252312779,
0.2485429198,
-0.614887774,
0.4489268064,
0.4385043681,
0.4112484455,
-0.8883212805,
-0.1049724221,
-0.3320913613,
-0.8959699869,
0.4721934497,
-0.0672183558,
0.1802387238,
0.1092196777,
0.0741348639,
-0.0359592922,
0.2216111422,
-0.7045658827,
-0.058121223,
0.0138832061,
-0.4149034023,
-0.2097732276,
-0.1064169407,
-0.125982672,
-0.0960276872,
0.5560286641,
-0.1022936627,
0.0203223303,
-0.2296875864,
0.0055542425,
-0.3418882191,
0.5678717494,
0.5262477994,
0.7879602313,
0.0208655372,
0.1360357553,
0.4913434982,
-0.5002841353,
0.6320714951,
-0.197170645,
-0.1812144667,
-0.6610715389,
0.2057249546,
0.5349122286,
0.1071402505,
-0.568338871,
0.0036342086,
0.0707562789,
-0.0104151005,
-0.2610037625,
-0.1988252848,
0.4732077122,
0.2942165136,
0.3776230216,
-0.0541375689,
-0.4326242208,
-0.7345535159,
-0.3513882458,
0.4884243011,
-0.3681900203,
-0.142546311,
0.542106986,
0.4329290688,
-0.3568105996,
0.5270977616,
0.0185979996,
-0.4768697023,
0.5060380101,
0.2656707764,
0.455430299,
-0.2343518734,
0.245218277,
0.1510748416,
0.5103725791,
-0.1467902511,
0.439917922,
0.0635105893,
-0.9610270262,
-0.5244295597,
-0.9067726731,
-0.0498157479,
-0.0011659304,
-0.7183648348,
0.2415644825,
-0.3368534446,
-0.4533248246,
0.1205321178,
0.3698171675,
-0.5875869393,
0.2473829091,
0.220862478,
0.4258493185,
-0.8044090271,
0.5363762975,
1.0655763149,
-0.3068094254,
-0.4452035129,
-0.0553895533,
0.4653634727,
-0.9531719089,
0.4281873107,
-0.0216544867,
-0.2108400911,
0.1136581451,
-0.3572910726,
-0.8704046607,
0.9287811518,
0.4743624926,
-0.8512960076,
-0.220761165,
0.4921526909,
0.3691704273,
-0.1670367122,
-0.263443917,
0.5292930007,
0.9571496844,
-0.1102038622,
-0.8682535887,
-0.0809443966,
0.203357175,
0.1794777513,
0.6034378409,
-0.9473520517,
0.5497155786,
-0.4178631604,
-0.1724610478,
-0.0453225598,
0.49001652,
0.3273772597,
0.039215114,
0.4296355546,
0.3710594475,
0.6649401188,
-0.3703027666,
0.8962107897,
-0.2786483467,
0.3657512367,
0.462659806,
-0.4794436693,
0.460201323,
0.7330069542,
-0.7388742566,
-0.3003765047,
1.0522555113,
0.0532668196,
0.2994201779,
0.7224369645,
-0.38376683,
-0.2110234797,
-0.5701345205,
-0.3239105344,
0.6189539433,
0.6612061262,
-0.0733332708,
-0.2775349319,
-0.1366641372,
-0.0290574394,
0.4782566428,
-0.630921483,
0.5639193058,
0.418723762,
-0.4358687103,
0.3480846584,
0.0635463148,
1.0398075581,
-0.6249781847,
0.2441830784,
0.0228863489,
0.2241627723,
-0.4249733686,
-0.9586009383,
0.3515976965,
0.2574645579,
-0.2509544492,
-0.4666820765,
0.5221981406,
-0.5066558123,
-0.4777090549,
0.1824447662,
0.4312427342,
0.0639483705,
0.2500588596,
-0.8527002335,
0.5141257048,
0.1971065402,
0.0946824104,
0.3043139875,
0.3962694705,
-0.392932564,
0.7510108352,
0.3150237203,
0.332852602,
0.1172084883,
-0.0261124857,
0.4286004305,
-0.5659671426,
-0.3280992508,
-1.1013286114,
0.4106907845,
-0.0417396016,
-0.5139745474,
0.888736546,
0.3934747577,
0.9151361585,
0.2041716427,
0.8121165633,
-0.3023271561,
0.0848898739,
-0.4000458419,
0.6476225257,
-0.5554929972,
0.1029409468,
-0.4046577513,
-1.3329572678,
0.1447827369,
0.8357738853,
-0.4267600179,
0.2477947623,
0.049187921,
0.5028024912,
0.1756634563,
-0.1294291019,
0.1057672575,
-0.1965374351,
0.3934644461,
0.3277385831,
0.9890010357,
0.0208828542,
-0.0952933058,
0.2144223452,
0.0823527873,
0.2043091655,
-0.9913014174,
-0.5969334841,
-0.5485154986,
-0.5597348213,
-0.0893600658,
0.107654199,
1.3229780197,
0.3370164335,
-0.6212289929,
-0.4902046025,
0.0082298927,
0.2607761025,
0.1690418273,
-0.1158601716,
0.2075443119,
0.1868171841,
-0.8718329668,
-0.2054209113,
0.1699924022,
0.2846612632,
-0.5853263736,
-0.3662897348,
-0.4504807293,
-0.1209823862,
0.5600512028,
0.3587062359,
-1.0760449171,
-0.5371486545,
-0.2097806633,
-0.1407137811,
-0.0493143238,
0.5100615025,
-0.3217180073,
-0.0600813739,
0.2222801149,
0.4517888725,
-0.07101015,
0.0083828289,
0.5590263605,
-0.4423212111,
0.104791142,
0.3232118189,
0.37484622,
0.7531639934,
-0.0651527271,
0.4562102854,
-0.0298284125,
-0.531046629,
-1.0124089718,
0.3462750316,
-0.58565557,
0.0047645271,
1.2734011412,
0.0796465129,
0.0710323304,
0.0075620618,
-0.1891649067,
0.3021258712,
-0.500880003,
0.8594920635,
0.9150705338,
0.0251678638,
-0.0552711077,
-0.4696044922,
0.6186731458,
0.3441657424,
-0.7096638083,
0.2258398235,
0.6869690418,
0.1717129946,
0.1804224998,
0.3206605613,
-0.0993036404,
-0.4220548868,
-0.2925750613,
0.2065837681,
0.4302771986,
-0.1288617551,
-0.1372160316,
-0.3809942305,
0.2324419022,
0.0743198842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14461v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14461v2
|
Competition Report: Finding Universal Jailbreak Backdoors in Aligned LLMs
| 2024-04-22T05:08:53 | 2024-06-06T12:45:52 |
Javier Rando, Francesco Croce, Kryštof Mitka, Stepan Shabalin, Maksym Andriushchenko, Nicolas Flammarion, Florian Tramèr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Large language models are aligned to be safe, preventing users from
generating harmful content like misinformation or instructions for illegal
activities. However, previous work has shown that the alignment process is
vulnerable to poisoning attacks. Adversaries can manipulate the safety training
data to inject backdoors that act like a universal sudo command: adding the
backdoor string to any prompt enables harmful responses from models that,
otherwise, behave safely. Our competition, co-located at IEEE SaTML 2024,
challenged participants to find universal backdoors in several large language
models. This report summarizes the key findings and promising ideas for future
research.
|
[
0.1189581752,
-0.3648438752,
0.8299684525,
0.0419125855,
0.0891062915,
0.1375439763,
0.101788871,
-0.6762509346,
-0.2940287888,
0.9752531052,
-0.4559615552,
-0.8762659431,
-0.4435514212,
0.0197263118,
-0.6153971553,
0.8780524731,
-0.1034362391,
0.1521805972,
-0.1592401564,
-0.1586254835,
-0.8175387383,
-0.8239009976,
-0.1899281442,
-0.067325145,
0.4622379839,
0.5400823951,
0.7081455588,
0.7577416897,
0.779384613,
0.331497103,
0.0016932536,
-0.2639971077,
-0.2214091867,
0.4410665333,
-0.4331253171,
-0.62845397,
-0.4701812267,
0.2915687859,
0.5276523829,
0.2485220283,
-0.3481047153,
0.0382895358,
-0.1900213063,
0.6643564105,
-0.6670565605,
-0.5617211461,
-0.9444169402,
-0.0514499284,
-0.3800517023,
0.1425925791,
-0.6413230896,
-0.4390787184,
-0.3210236728,
-0.2629823089,
0.0208663717,
0.3604119122,
0.8887209892,
0.342851758,
-0.178568244,
-0.3495275676,
-0.2976448834,
0.7476533055,
-0.8039761186,
0.5668411851,
-0.0686698556,
0.1510717571,
-0.4849619865,
-0.4831455648,
-0.3048037291,
-0.2564407587,
0.09397199,
-0.095638752,
-0.2963534296,
0.1155811697,
0.0336251929,
0.0524741486,
-0.6404607296,
0.8482534289,
-0.3152308464,
-0.2283803672,
0.9343112111,
0.5068868995,
0.816962719,
-0.0279475972,
-0.4968437552,
0.0140765551,
-1.23754251,
-0.1313334852,
0.6646909714,
0.2309965789,
-0.1730221361,
0.6498105526,
0.1364054233,
0.6440035105,
-0.2722469866,
0.0806939453,
-0.031115232,
-0.2211898267,
-0.0842572451,
0.2771131992,
0.8082536459,
0.427834481,
0.0919731557,
-0.4525363147,
-0.3514180183,
-0.0801533908,
0.4061066508,
-0.595739007,
0.0594168417,
0.3973787427,
-0.1769646853,
-0.5277862549,
0.289755702,
-0.7625576258,
-0.5463429689,
0.1713742465,
0.2880151868,
-0.220291853,
0.1392901093,
-0.0158023722,
-0.1568627208,
0.482034415,
0.1319594383,
-0.8003447652,
0.3909215629,
1.2037529945,
0.8133110404,
-0.2772653401,
-0.5403109193,
-0.5297129154,
0.3898470104,
-0.3703667521,
0.5255372524,
-0.5051932335,
-0.3517825902,
-0.1717581898,
-0.0297218785,
-0.0201902185,
-0.5967768431,
0.4807253182,
-0.8557057381,
0.1578519642,
-0.1266427189,
-0.5531618595,
0.0622126423,
0.0963705778,
-0.5469253063,
0.4712624252,
-0.3054198325,
-0.7001432776,
0.0527417548,
-0.3427698314,
-0.3481031358,
-0.0274635777,
-0.2431352288,
-0.5976387858,
0.1810890883,
0.0174534973,
0.303052485,
-0.2191727459,
0.2822111845,
-0.4351093471,
-0.3248708546,
0.4207313359,
-0.0857975036,
1.061958313,
0.3544940948,
-0.4488554895,
0.3175449371,
-0.3993712366,
-0.3463123739,
0.307962656,
-0.1738377064,
-0.4799388945,
-0.0949344933,
-0.3597854376,
0.2676475346,
0.2771376967,
-0.8228124976,
0.4184778035,
-0.409697026,
0.1918174028,
1.0763850212,
-0.0677825734,
0.4418642223,
-0.1040459573,
0.5875053406,
-0.0255055036,
0.2684268355,
-0.0014468752,
-0.4757603109,
-0.2902523577,
-0.3430747092,
0.3259337544,
0.8664315343,
-0.0541852303,
0.5921816826,
-0.0300451219,
-0.5053169131,
-0.6358936429,
0.3634940088,
0.6472883821,
0.3613213897,
-0.0778257549,
-0.192573458,
-0.5465304255,
-0.7965621352,
-0.489890486,
0.1129823476,
0.0848011523,
0.1871612072,
0.5880814195,
-0.4918481112,
0.571260035,
-0.5632967949,
-0.3152546883,
-0.0690483898,
-0.1775200367,
0.1892042309,
0.6827859879,
0.3800567091,
-0.6131517887,
-0.3035230339,
-0.1237379164,
-0.9816618562,
-0.2119220346,
0.0808760375,
0.0125731146,
0.3637492657,
0.89081949,
-0.5262892842,
0.3800090551,
0.8002810478,
-0.423307538,
0.6357087493,
0.0053423094,
0.0900036022,
-1.1531511545,
-0.0460190885,
-0.2703815997,
-0.0900585502,
-0.491030097,
0.728325069,
0.1750585586,
-0.386169225,
-0.4902024269,
0.5354100466,
-0.5264927149,
-0.1802706718,
0.0071194912,
0.370996803,
-0.3989831507,
-0.0566678196,
-0.3533970714,
0.9715460539,
0.5283552408,
-0.1961106807,
0.7387157083,
0.2746560872,
-0.3710890114,
0.2331917882,
-0.5680403709,
0.342376411,
0.1446999609,
0.2617242932,
-1.3602176905,
-0.4973489642,
0.1133261323,
-0.6508259177,
0.3977107704,
-0.0445633344,
-0.4897581935,
-0.3136644959,
-0.493601948,
0.2882310152,
0.4879308343,
-0.6592223048,
0.1674929708,
0.6449950933,
-0.0928774178,
-0.8002226949,
-0.6000117064,
0.304759264,
-0.4397607446,
-0.8442658782,
0.0557189733,
0.0311009437,
-0.4691244066,
-0.1193146035,
-0.0915969685,
0.1652449965,
0.5824586749,
0.5785554051,
0.4565812647,
-0.1089230031,
-0.3426952362,
-0.0718619972,
-0.1596160829,
0.2767885327,
-0.2479761541,
0.5123407841,
-0.2050198764,
-0.2671639025,
-0.7604441643,
0.45424667,
0.6717520952,
-0.2127105445,
0.8778059483,
-0.0459607504,
-0.1548673362,
-0.0484768189,
-0.6329660416,
-0.0884493887,
-0.5755839348,
0.2109717578,
-0.1336207688,
-1.0974977016,
0.6245380044,
-0.0695109144,
0.2451457083,
0.1094005853,
0.3833749592,
-0.0462879576,
1.3636900187,
0.7975206971,
-0.3468876183,
0.1565119177,
0.2362180203,
0.3388338387,
-0.7400048375,
-0.4054941237,
-0.7313630581,
-0.3012346327,
-0.6027092934,
0.2147968113,
0.2293597013,
0.1930986792,
-0.2089222968,
0.475186795,
-0.5318565965,
0.6841787696,
0.4530691206,
-0.1165401712,
0.337973386,
-0.2691981196,
-0.5511316657,
-0.1672136784,
-0.3389605582,
-0.3828333914,
1.1089485884,
0.4269680083,
1.0598291159,
0.3185524344,
1.3119233847,
0.1472902447,
0.5036885738,
-0.4507842362,
0.7060840726,
-0.116099678,
-0.891025722,
-0.1488077492,
-0.239031449,
-1.0328140259,
-0.0874396414,
0.2009034306,
-1.3075271845,
-0.2312295884,
-0.0302975103,
-0.4208396077,
0.5795862079,
-0.578720808,
0.8900609612,
-0.5102368593,
-0.1219535545,
-0.0065008262,
-1.0326815844,
0.8074838519,
-0.2049378604,
0.5015813112,
-0.1530602127,
-0.0654221699,
0.8396651745,
-0.4364586174,
0.6494035721,
0.0167587977,
-0.3700424135,
0.0317833126,
0.1997627467,
0.4177737534,
-0.0064978795,
0.0394721404,
0.1729739457,
-0.1657181084,
-0.1720052212,
-0.3318466544,
0.9961093068,
-0.768296957,
-1.0693267584,
-0.5321769714,
-0.5680832863,
-0.0524996258,
0.1802830994,
0.4896187186,
0.0751015842,
-0.0066453572,
0.1266304404,
0.7202838063,
-0.2349511981,
0.4802308083,
0.5217623115,
-0.327863276,
-0.5322037935,
0.7354184985,
-0.1251519471,
0.2327799797,
0.1274844408,
0.1106816381,
-0.1410126835,
-0.7648670077,
-0.3310593367,
0.3566806316,
-0.4292449057,
-0.5030069351,
-0.4505421519,
-0.3641888201,
-0.7478885055,
-0.437220335,
-0.5153514743,
-0.2644943297,
-0.1070571244,
-0.1482589394,
0.0616790242,
0.9348195195,
-0.4083308876,
0.4769689143,
-1.1392561197,
0.1012423486,
0.194381997,
0.344428122,
-0.0406807475,
-0.4925118387,
-0.2092451304,
-0.3323529363,
-0.4095304906,
-1.01722157,
0.3671400845,
-0.3560359776,
0.5628301501,
0.3873364925,
-0.0087251095,
0.3302124441,
-0.7437884212,
0.7782141566,
0.3968597353,
-1.0303018093,
0.6417358518,
-0.4579630792,
-0.1047592536,
0.5370678902,
0.4705634713,
-0.5911470056,
-0.627513051,
-0.5396813154,
-0.9233853221,
0.4628880918,
-0.0766134858,
0.1869862527,
0.2562671602,
0.3680984676,
0.1356650293,
0.1919546872,
-0.7246863246,
-0.1400270164,
0.5158393383,
-0.3188067079,
0.2285805047,
-0.3238411248,
-0.3735029995,
-0.1270603836,
0.4874895215,
0.4613142312,
0.0321415365,
-0.0638904944,
-0.0971874073,
-0.2136662453,
0.4576864243,
0.5654165745,
0.4201183617,
-0.1121653467,
0.0536033921,
-0.0177364349,
-0.4876261353,
0.4490871429,
-0.0160945859,
-0.191601187,
-0.3372519612,
0.3721406758,
0.1278986186,
0.2347400039,
-0.7863767147,
0.5914489031,
-0.1527629197,
-0.0792117715,
-0.3245918453,
0.3488047719,
-0.0722453818,
0.2678513527,
0.2461519241,
-0.1868595928,
0.0025879268,
-0.7494997978,
0.5178166032,
0.730953455,
-0.4484419823,
-0.3939863145,
0.8721361756,
0.2903948724,
-0.5568410158,
0.8033211827,
0.1423740238,
-0.8635547161,
0.3713694513,
0.7728381753,
1.0285019875,
-0.7466989756,
-0.2127593756,
-0.0232776087,
0.5308632851,
-0.0137104597,
0.2299298495,
0.2010589838,
-0.8324251175,
-0.1383194476,
-0.4384407401,
-0.4075186849,
0.2202933282,
-0.5850954056,
0.1132501513,
-0.6832384467,
0.13315624,
-0.1590221822,
-0.2711417377,
-0.0904199034,
-0.0399183296,
0.4135516584,
0.9398645759,
-0.8974432349,
0.7246376872,
0.4387791157,
-0.0665428713,
-0.7601443529,
0.0390242226,
0.5726792812,
-0.7566686869,
0.489754945,
0.3659266233,
-0.1971153915,
-0.1149545982,
-1.2886775732,
-0.8439831734,
0.7828127146,
0.2538466156,
-0.5195626616,
-0.4161438942,
-0.0423691273,
0.141909346,
-0.2943557203,
-0.5498162508,
0.9192044139,
0.4069428146,
-0.1633165628,
-0.7895045877,
0.3164790273,
-0.0727176741,
-0.2909196019,
0.5280722976,
-0.6373428106,
0.7360083461,
-0.4943895042,
-0.2818520367,
0.6703655124,
0.598093152,
0.6376374364,
0.469178915,
0.1514989585,
1.0912605524,
0.5616651773,
-0.2085972875,
0.8778703213,
-0.2179803103,
0.1106140912,
1.1994956732,
-0.6392540336,
0.7520473003,
0.5357694626,
0.1514900178,
0.6224558353,
0.3725055754,
-0.2830444574,
0.566514492,
0.3079224825,
-0.1061150506,
-0.1046745181,
0.0013462099,
-0.3549029231,
0.483251214,
0.4768402576,
-0.1157920584,
-0.1440618783,
-0.0769733265,
0.3580603898,
0.2213359773,
-0.2168297917,
0.8337954879,
0.2511288226,
-0.6823885441,
0.2842990458,
0.1487107575,
0.8028234243,
-0.5639993548,
0.147769317,
-0.1434184909,
0.290607214,
-0.3317728043,
-1.0158653259,
0.1709938049,
0.2066730112,
0.3579771519,
-0.0495311581,
0.5897326469,
-0.1337970644,
0.0063356506,
0.5216594338,
0.0398769863,
0.0018356175,
0.047025606,
-0.6482079625,
0.1589653343,
-0.0462785326,
-0.1083575487,
0.4021048248,
0.096160017,
-0.1277297437,
0.7792692184,
0.6614820957,
0.0478152223,
0.3140145838,
-0.2057182342,
0.9380014539,
-0.9596155882,
-0.4303907156,
-1.0523313284,
0.4072190821,
-0.2317169756,
-0.1965244412,
1.2896467447,
0.8285493255,
0.8536851406,
0.1919539124,
0.6391783953,
0.2473957986,
0.2932042181,
-0.5898881555,
0.9705656767,
-0.6352509856,
0.388333708,
-0.4639883041,
-0.5748221874,
-0.5289335847,
-0.0192655399,
-0.3895097971,
-0.4091442823,
0.6154943109,
0.7904109955,
0.1379359812,
0.0047250502,
0.2559948564,
0.2764371634,
0.344966054,
0.559230864,
1.1967715025,
-0.3265121579,
0.4477462769,
-0.0319745615,
-0.2746024728,
-0.2797877789,
-0.7058811784,
-0.767008841,
-0.3571089804,
0.0326033607,
-0.7318375111,
0.3283532858,
0.6355369687,
0.3207484782,
-1.0336780548,
-0.5057808161,
0.0130982501,
0.6225203872,
0.2885534465,
-0.1989935488,
-0.0057370607,
-0.2183552235,
-0.2701027691,
0.5657762289,
0.4230139554,
0.0705180764,
-0.0527759492,
-0.0474427231,
-0.1617646962,
0.0674664602,
-0.0214312989,
0.4818125665,
-0.7641097307,
-0.3712244034,
-0.070163846,
-0.4912682772,
-0.0885590017,
0.917342186,
-0.2788943648,
0.1850989759,
0.4457158446,
0.7057438493,
-0.0664789379,
0.2048125565,
0.8861086965,
-0.8542177081,
0.3435863554,
0.3086883724,
0.407602489,
0.2376765609,
-0.535961628,
0.4240036905,
0.1608845741,
-0.8848116398,
-1.1285881996,
0.4731043279,
-0.6977578998,
-0.6482018828,
1.0464446545,
-0.1630000472,
-0.5441634655,
0.0240290221,
0.1377754807,
0.0606745481,
-0.3272575736,
0.8698805571,
0.6758963466,
-0.0269883759,
0.1702145338,
-0.3991498053,
0.4540254772,
0.2924438417,
-0.7901880145,
0.097522594,
0.4525980055,
0.4658696651,
0.1906676143,
-0.016219981,
-0.4248606861,
0.4211023748,
-0.1519850343,
-0.1124333069,
-0.0097504118,
-0.6234391928,
-0.727368474,
-0.0600727797,
0.0214627218,
-0.0970531553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13874v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13874v2
|
VALOR-EVAL: Holistic Coverage and Faithfulness Evaluation of Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-04-22T04:49:22 | 2024-06-06T02:53:37 |
Haoyi Qiu, Wenbo Hu, Zi-Yi Dou, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) suffer from hallucination issues,
wherein the models generate plausible-sounding but factually incorrect outputs,
undermining their reliability. A comprehensive quantitative evaluation is
necessary to identify and understand the extent of hallucinations in these
models. However, existing benchmarks are often limited in scope, focusing
mainly on object hallucinations. Furthermore, current evaluation methods
struggle to effectively address the subtle semantic distinctions between model
outputs and reference data, as well as the balance between hallucination and
informativeness. To address these issues, we introduce a multi-dimensional
benchmark covering objects, attributes, and relations, with challenging images
selected based on associative biases. Moreover, we propose a large language
model (LLM)-based two-stage evaluation framework that generalizes the popular
CHAIR metric and incorporates both faithfulness and coverage into the
evaluation. Experiments on 10 established LVLMs demonstrate that our evaluation
metric is more comprehensive and better correlated with humans than existing
work when evaluating on our challenging human-annotated benchmark dataset. Our
work also highlights the critical balance between faithfulness and coverage of
model outputs, and encourages future works to address hallucinations in LVLMs
while keeping their outputs informative.
|
[
-0.2967501283,
-0.761770606,
0.6367024183,
0.3572387695,
-0.3001983762,
-0.0986301899,
-0.3256556988,
-0.5457730889,
0.0403680131,
0.7320846319,
-0.1962697357,
-0.650834322,
-0.4055459201,
-0.0103298509,
-0.5569621921,
0.5668240786,
-0.0988807976,
0.308508575,
-0.4422699213,
-0.4048527777,
-0.4363457263,
-0.5435438752,
-0.151257053,
-0.1969881654,
0.5383643508,
-0.0790945888,
0.9251483679,
0.4134504795,
0.8519327641,
0.2345659286,
0.0869441628,
0.3507926464,
-0.5153633952,
0.289127022,
-0.1378240734,
-0.1593475789,
-0.4302433431,
-0.2300766855,
0.7337546349,
0.7749167085,
-0.1821002513,
0.0638689101,
0.1354537606,
0.6036630869,
-0.8249828219,
0.2359943241,
-0.7561374307,
0.1140201017,
0.0930111185,
-0.1001278013,
-0.5433820486,
-0.3021099269,
-0.0782848522,
-0.5962017179,
0.069684647,
0.1070611402,
0.6576730013,
0.4309790134,
-0.220636636,
-0.0525142029,
-0.8072670102,
0.8524304032,
-0.4011318982,
0.7761788964,
0.6841733456,
0.5036109686,
0.0766302645,
-0.4877160788,
-0.4207732081,
-0.5415937901,
0.0567806475,
-0.0136288889,
-0.1322287172,
0.012143787,
0.1907826513,
0.1953091025,
-0.5529747605,
-0.1675876826,
-0.2994346321,
-0.4298940003,
0.8071414828,
0.351243645,
0.1097110882,
-0.031899713,
-0.3805786073,
-0.3944932222,
-0.4517661035,
-0.2590056062,
0.3641349077,
0.0777083859,
0.1919496804,
0.8535618186,
-0.1289876103,
0.6637257934,
-0.4522564113,
-0.0350298434,
0.3667041659,
-0.483568579,
-0.2895813584,
-0.2527671754,
0.6627781391,
0.6194512844,
0.3317409158,
-0.4917378724,
-0.4376664162,
0.3363946378,
0.6548380256,
-0.7085117102,
0.0807137564,
0.3714630008,
-0.5345719457,
-0.3024659753,
0.0394094661,
-0.8955090046,
-0.8568990231,
-0.6225913167,
0.6684557199,
-0.434805274,
-0.1276496351,
0.3731582463,
0.1483846605,
0.389131397,
0.375670284,
-0.4976489246,
0.3001977801,
0.7711457014,
0.7547957897,
-0.3751705885,
-0.5414077044,
-0.8065153956,
-0.2774812877,
-0.5880983472,
0.6510184407,
-0.5402331948,
-0.3413297236,
0.3972105384,
0.092346929,
0.0974887908,
-0.6057952642,
0.7005375028,
-0.3294177055,
-0.2236908525,
-0.3641676307,
-0.3948509097,
-0.1216895431,
0.4002963305,
-0.7413146496,
0.9456943274,
0.3426301777,
-0.6872715354,
0.5048565865,
0.0367753245,
-0.1810592264,
-0.0198822096,
-0.3551155329,
-0.6899167895,
0.3170666695,
0.04171497,
0.4796457589,
-0.2956737876,
0.3926158547,
-0.4144542217,
-0.5651994348,
0.2900371552,
-0.4474280477,
0.4975571036,
-0.1632152051,
-0.3279691637,
0.4644194543,
-0.9382392168,
-0.1908703893,
0.0059066401,
0.0538837053,
-0.5677990913,
-0.0092777638,
0.3973915875,
-0.0975721106,
0.1468333155,
-0.3243378103,
0.0957841799,
-0.3479574919,
-0.1874896884,
0.6300215721,
-0.2120355815,
0.3546017408,
-0.3416289389,
0.5166005492,
-0.1614740789,
0.5160101652,
-0.1706682444,
-0.1695764512,
-0.7543241382,
-0.2584031522,
-0.1900155097,
0.2203570902,
-0.8897032142,
0.3689337671,
-0.3409848511,
-0.5579483509,
-0.5687330365,
0.0554116815,
0.673592329,
0.2858627439,
0.5008350611,
-0.4650399089,
-0.5212743282,
-1.1255638599,
-0.3464099467,
-0.246260941,
0.0347463973,
0.4592576623,
0.7289991379,
-0.5643867254,
0.505589962,
-0.1152622849,
-0.627603054,
-0.0106464196,
0.0234003216,
-0.1811978966,
0.0665674284,
0.4941289425,
-0.6354689598,
-0.2818235755,
0.1242307201,
-0.8292106986,
0.0313155502,
-0.1100610942,
-0.1509824842,
0.3628522456,
0.1394140422,
-0.3604979515,
0.7090515494,
0.4626060724,
-0.5636267066,
0.8243052363,
-0.298314333,
0.3474936783,
-0.5864098668,
0.0293782763,
-0.1082303748,
-0.0938275456,
-0.436978519,
0.11882063,
0.0327343345,
0.2872492969,
-0.3124016821,
0.717818439,
-0.3489263952,
-0.5370516181,
-0.0417395532,
0.2796994746,
0.2951910198,
0.2696098089,
0.1422375888,
0.651574254,
0.6516544819,
-0.2963102758,
0.6131213903,
0.2337908596,
-0.6605763435,
0.6364101768,
-0.7369673252,
0.0492812395,
-0.1317990869,
0.0833156481,
-0.8036388159,
-0.2978244424,
0.133518517,
-0.132855013,
0.0400328748,
0.2490777224,
-0.5161970258,
-0.2449503839,
-0.4821699858,
0.5529060364,
0.5961663127,
-0.6250548363,
0.6991031766,
0.3841225207,
0.2612817883,
-0.55038625,
-0.4806367755,
0.1249169409,
-0.2706459165,
-0.5307179093,
0.2218802124,
-0.019930575,
-0.6910073161,
-0.1490724087,
-0.0233928505,
-0.0522851311,
-0.1382959038,
0.2726669312,
0.3410362899,
-0.1522939056,
-0.0216565374,
-0.491502732,
0.1730754375,
0.3285628259,
0.0814460665,
0.6266434789,
-0.4950964451,
-0.8260800242,
-0.2946016192,
0.0546398945,
0.7088696957,
-0.3294194639,
0.6321386099,
0.621797502,
-0.5050410032,
-0.1892903447,
-0.8196879625,
-0.3371112049,
-0.3151123226,
0.664056778,
-0.4000651538,
-0.3201361299,
0.7163727283,
0.4735575616,
0.0437913947,
0.3377299011,
0.6770337224,
0.221373558,
0.8123999238,
0.3463590443,
0.2248978317,
0.1122772619,
-0.2084017992,
-0.0748318732,
-1.1092182398,
-0.7099024653,
-0.3895893395,
0.0659459308,
-0.1536097676,
-0.9481270313,
0.1672013849,
-0.0884807929,
0.032199014,
0.2471824437,
-0.6252903342,
0.2733934224,
0.1696790457,
0.146258384,
0.3938222826,
0.2294810116,
0.1152659655,
-0.2443244755,
-0.1978885531,
-0.5905656219,
1.3054094315,
0.5015449524,
0.9357247353,
-0.0987070426,
0.3408320546,
0.3562202156,
0.3731708229,
-0.8735292554,
0.387853086,
0.0292748827,
-0.3870220184,
-0.5266552567,
-0.2416535467,
-0.9400633574,
0.7364658713,
-0.1481442004,
-0.7866852283,
0.3063468933,
-0.0024792496,
-0.2025290281,
0.2366078943,
-0.1742372364,
0.7039917707,
-0.5380117893,
-0.821359694,
-0.3395304382,
-0.4063455462,
0.5748184919,
-0.2747977376,
0.3493177891,
-0.0102916323,
0.0918710977,
0.6173932552,
-0.1420589685,
0.7145888805,
0.0363739058,
-0.3336021304,
0.2062389553,
0.3132551312,
0.4665550888,
-0.0121694347,
-0.0671509802,
0.3960664868,
0.1752322018,
-0.2178908288,
-0.7362741232,
0.3917980194,
-0.5267962217,
-0.3440309167,
-0.4242371917,
-0.5877882838,
-0.3362651169,
-0.1316547692,
0.039708022,
0.4949257374,
-0.577005446,
0.5845874548,
0.6588841677,
-0.5702797771,
-0.0349461883,
0.265078336,
-0.8643615842,
-0.4175430238,
0.8976587653,
-0.0879832506,
0.1881509125,
0.0339633413,
0.0748109221,
-0.4463612437,
-0.3691137731,
-0.3599226773,
0.231197387,
-0.8272913694,
0.0591641553,
-0.6584985256,
-0.291775912,
-0.1773130894,
-0.0010485025,
-0.6109417677,
0.0084500574,
-0.0171929002,
0.2143608779,
0.1048844457,
0.7721647024,
0.2485673279,
-0.0803611651,
-0.3258146048,
0.6230580807,
0.2023293674,
0.4734567404,
0.0312966816,
-0.7618502975,
-0.2121012509,
0.133565858,
-0.1137554497,
-0.7686498761,
0.4528043866,
-0.0351233035,
0.7137530446,
0.4709410071,
-0.0028417401,
0.5431507826,
-0.4551099539,
0.6974495053,
0.247783795,
-0.7241970301,
0.2856839299,
-0.2133906931,
-0.1191138104,
0.6354923844,
-0.1077087894,
-0.299288094,
-0.3935685158,
-0.5447784066,
-0.7336928248,
0.2868025601,
0.3325036168,
0.1636091024,
0.0767953694,
0.0471153557,
0.1838133186,
0.1317589432,
-0.7244182825,
0.0797258765,
-0.1940367222,
0.069908455,
-0.0569760427,
-0.421708554,
-0.3309772313,
-0.4168531001,
0.4837620556,
-0.0943344384,
-0.0042891321,
0.2861157358,
-0.1580133438,
-0.0441125147,
0.1473236382,
0.8450068831,
0.8713290095,
-0.2995174527,
0.3736265898,
0.2749210596,
-0.4786354005,
-0.0719077513,
-0.1787080914,
0.040151868,
0.2459133863,
0.823484838,
1.0742899179,
0.1861372441,
-0.8691872954,
0.9285395741,
-0.0981551409,
-0.1915410906,
-0.4815184176,
-0.0736595392,
-0.3282382488,
0.2951552272,
0.1291202605,
0.1193109676,
0.2781648934,
-0.6134003997,
0.2290029675,
0.7588937879,
-0.6932746768,
-0.3611874878,
0.7697715759,
-0.1270300001,
-0.3474692404,
0.5182334781,
-0.0449490622,
-0.5659325123,
0.8511931896,
0.3199177384,
0.959115684,
-0.1335280389,
0.273360759,
0.3619506061,
0.578234911,
-0.2745475471,
0.2475685328,
0.0697990656,
-0.5889415741,
-0.2088918686,
-0.9666848779,
-0.3604097962,
0.2152078003,
-0.9090850949,
0.3402333558,
0.0126379635,
-0.0111238286,
-0.4029166996,
-0.2120619565,
-0.7971003652,
0.1625744104,
0.0417789668,
0.6625421047,
-0.8923374414,
0.7164408565,
0.3264279366,
-0.5278872848,
-0.420996964,
0.066592373,
-0.3986567259,
-0.8974869251,
0.6138560176,
0.1556718349,
-0.1932092309,
-0.5240590572,
-0.2886488736,
-0.5075921416,
1.0483756065,
0.3829184473,
-0.7450250983,
0.142282635,
0.1749394834,
0.8499654531,
-0.4887711704,
0.2037470192,
0.706402719,
0.7369667888,
0.129800573,
-0.8744139671,
-0.036550872,
0.0045309151,
0.1760017276,
-0.3380922377,
-0.5553706884,
0.5163574219,
-0.3628701866,
0.0342535228,
0.1005362198,
0.4374547601,
0.5989316106,
0.4949279428,
0.5818378925,
0.3744683564,
0.6907125115,
0.0170828961,
1.4597123861,
-0.2348461598,
0.4367784858,
1.1374033689,
-0.4575085938,
0.9288828373,
0.618357718,
-0.2452867925,
0.0442054681,
0.3393100202,
-0.2775823176,
0.4924766421,
0.4687774479,
-0.0751383901,
-0.3345627487,
-0.326415509,
-0.4327910841,
0.4222058654,
0.1893718839,
-0.4703072608,
-0.0344986692,
0.2891812623,
-0.3417817354,
0.2069384754,
-0.096361652,
0.5258408189,
0.034617316,
-0.7350561619,
0.7616935372,
-0.2765263021,
0.2602260709,
-0.2604699731,
-0.2108752429,
-0.3382951319,
0.2044894099,
-0.1676014364,
-0.6704061031,
0.4454099238,
-0.0955428332,
0.0661830083,
-0.1509294361,
0.5491153002,
-0.4344692528,
-0.6314707994,
0.6533104181,
0.2545739412,
0.4279085696,
-0.268330127,
-0.3725377917,
0.7426520586,
-0.1520390064,
-0.4426497817,
0.0450492911,
0.2642495632,
-0.247946322,
0.6279684305,
0.3806739151,
0.3035201728,
0.0539179519,
0.5601449609,
0.7586728334,
-0.2514349818,
0.1083859354,
-1.0146893263,
0.5668016076,
-0.0826052353,
-0.3114026189,
0.6664401293,
0.857761085,
0.5099453926,
-0.1571011245,
0.5650759339,
0.3402635455,
0.0012749467,
-0.4977766573,
0.8340249062,
-0.877835393,
0.3863931,
-0.3420490324,
-1.3811788559,
-0.4391040802,
0.9568973184,
-0.234059751,
0.0667544007,
0.7093788981,
0.7618021369,
-0.136726141,
-0.4164194763,
0.9358408451,
0.3727721274,
0.1295326352,
0.4073542058,
1.0616713762,
-0.5076075196,
0.3192504048,
-0.2340202034,
-0.157264784,
-0.4178875089,
-0.692825973,
-1.1021672487,
-0.8318392634,
-0.2661595941,
-0.7413585782,
0.0965403244,
0.5229358077,
0.6381929517,
-0.7088390589,
-0.1073988378,
-0.0290033463,
0.0268842541,
-0.1257762015,
-0.1803821623,
0.7080898881,
-0.2680938542,
-0.6818755269,
0.2200118303,
0.5009433627,
-0.120148018,
-1.0526957512,
-0.3028281927,
0.4890120327,
0.2706004083,
0.7332519889,
-0.1891764253,
-1.3285572529,
-0.2895080745,
0.2460315675,
-0.3764026463,
-0.0110736853,
0.5356112123,
-0.7981880307,
0.7899258733,
0.3664117455,
0.7582998276,
0.3109226525,
0.0117865792,
0.2634084225,
-0.347465992,
0.1915106773,
0.3716593683,
0.527629137,
0.4606373608,
-0.2849313915,
0.752486527,
0.0859712586,
-0.4559088945,
-1.2120473385,
0.1298676878,
-1.1462380886,
-0.2038704455,
1.5951555967,
0.0428064167,
-0.3385332823,
-0.0450553894,
-0.4253125489,
0.0498300381,
0.1729751378,
1.2127293348,
0.8868019581,
0.1260642111,
-0.1003582478,
-0.7494755387,
0.4248001575,
0.403549403,
-0.8873289824,
0.3645758927,
0.6713475585,
-0.0231309105,
0.1648728848,
0.5065075755,
-0.274685055,
0.2110756636,
0.1167679131,
0.3169820309,
0.0565773807,
-0.6804225445,
-0.3580855727,
0.047655765,
0.0229144376,
0.0589412786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13865v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13865v1
|
Context-Enhanced Language Models for Generating Multi-Paper Citations
| 2024-04-22T04:30:36 | 2024-04-22T04:30:36 |
Avinash Anand, Kritarth Prasad, Ujjwal Goel, Mohit Gupta, Naman Lal, Astha Verma, Rajiv Ratn Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Citation text plays a pivotal role in elucidating the connection between
scientific documents, demanding an in-depth comprehension of the cited paper.
Constructing citations is often time-consuming, requiring researchers to delve
into extensive literature and grapple with articulating relevant content. To
address this challenge, the field of citation text generation (CTG) has
emerged. However, while earlier methods have primarily centered on creating
single-sentence citations, practical scenarios frequently necessitate citing
multiple papers within a single paragraph. To bridge this gap, we propose a
method that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate multi-citation
sentences. Our approach involves a single source paper and a collection of
target papers, culminating in a coherent paragraph containing multi-sentence
citation text. Furthermore, we introduce a curated dataset named MCG-S2ORC,
composed of English-language academic research papers in Computer Science,
showcasing multiple citation instances. In our experiments, we evaluate three
LLMs LLaMA, Alpaca, and Vicuna to ascertain the most effective model for this
endeavor. Additionally, we exhibit enhanced performance by integrating
knowledge graphs from target papers into the prompts for generating citation
text. This research underscores the potential of harnessing LLMs for citation
generation, opening a compelling avenue for exploring the intricate connections
between scientific documents.
|
[
-0.2408529818,
-0.7121818066,
0.9390684962,
0.2099796981,
-0.3356158733,
-0.0466700941,
-0.2090410739,
-0.4623453021,
0.1465756297,
0.3432436585,
-0.3102458417,
-0.3585961461,
-0.4691027403,
0.5534534454,
-0.2917772532,
1.028856039,
0.1259115785,
-0.0402883999,
-0.4721049368,
-0.0509219766,
-0.3262004554,
-0.4127680063,
-0.2939213812,
-0.2875792086,
0.9128174186,
0.3686242998,
0.2370292693,
0.4805659056,
0.3491206765,
0.1435007155,
-0.0511861853,
0.6131599545,
-0.1924999058,
0.4842423499,
-0.15340361,
-0.0307840109,
-0.2379514873,
-0.1154571623,
0.7512356639,
0.5818469524,
0.3080846667,
0.0996154249,
0.2705807686,
0.2509198785,
-0.5206711888,
0.1505464166,
-0.8856685162,
-0.338508904,
-0.3835943639,
-0.5893273354,
-0.6816908121,
-0.2159120888,
0.0175495557,
-0.4310470521,
-0.0450138003,
-0.0768947527,
0.5133240223,
-0.0298031177,
-0.7861686349,
-0.4027121067,
-0.3169837594,
0.6678074002,
-0.4347042739,
0.1650660932,
0.1228798106,
-0.0125396764,
-0.1841456592,
-1.0264697075,
-0.417430222,
-0.3708830476,
-0.1862953305,
0.0284789354,
0.0585042611,
-0.4505034983,
0.1079361886,
-0.1753838509,
-0.4901413023,
-0.3334792852,
-0.2812414169,
0.1039247215,
0.4353820384,
-0.1267059892,
-0.0063301688,
-0.4060878754,
-0.3248430192,
-0.1638576835,
-0.8677566648,
-0.3604619205,
0.1397278309,
0.8038630486,
0.2551926672,
0.593064189,
0.2193000615,
0.6278842688,
-0.3098210692,
-0.188663125,
0.0089474013,
-0.5586470366,
0.0949758664,
0.0772258639,
0.8431862593,
0.0508895963,
0.1859226525,
-0.4106949568,
0.2181058079,
-0.2162492275,
0.2104705721,
-0.9855859876,
0.0227594078,
0.1406454295,
-0.3810013533,
-0.2869785726,
0.0900244266,
-0.6925837994,
-0.4397962987,
-0.3565526605,
0.0224993173,
-0.3811861575,
-0.1219426095,
-0.2756674886,
-0.1555174142,
-0.1063980237,
0.1444941759,
-0.3402157426,
-0.2761587799,
0.3557745814,
1.1143189669,
-0.1140244305,
-0.5253377557,
-0.6391970515,
0.7351926565,
-0.030988289,
1.0832859278,
-0.8539279103,
-0.5568515062,
0.1564301252,
-0.1435558796,
-0.1878242791,
-0.178626135,
0.6795488,
-0.5109050274,
0.1008573771,
-0.5996476412,
-0.4259582162,
0.036402531,
0.1879690289,
-0.6469045877,
1.0865755081,
-0.1647284627,
-1.0355447531,
0.1719587594,
-0.9243665338,
-0.635529995,
0.1493182182,
-0.2675665915,
-0.3256936371,
0.0835111365,
0.2401167005,
0.5818373561,
-0.5310257077,
0.7700715661,
-0.5964391232,
0.1133943871,
0.3062643707,
-0.159453243,
0.726333499,
0.4667406976,
0.1312228888,
0.1189699993,
-0.8507325649,
0.0277056266,
0.1639964432,
-0.528891623,
-0.5705898404,
0.2234416604,
0.5178965926,
0.2873180509,
0.3867694736,
-0.4160653949,
0.3574990332,
0.3279420435,
0.5810819864,
0.4037927985,
0.0801209509,
0.1347624213,
-0.2280398458,
0.4264549315,
-0.2627492845,
-0.3840121329,
-0.698559761,
-0.2266117483,
-0.3906778395,
-0.3456354439,
0.0788901299,
0.2406684458,
-0.6062773466,
0.2659465075,
-0.4810111225,
-0.3161512315,
-0.1116804034,
0.1224530488,
0.1360783726,
0.5504568815,
0.4576722682,
0.3566476405,
-0.7480762005,
-0.6407727003,
-0.4991103411,
-0.1274449378,
0.0422886498,
0.490032196,
0.6804822087,
-0.2144649327,
1.0624732971,
-0.5633792877,
-0.1239536926,
-0.1481948495,
0.3600800037,
-0.1751210988,
0.3124880791,
0.6291251779,
-0.7578197122,
-0.5424711704,
0.0540261604,
-0.9024162889,
-0.3492348492,
-0.277159065,
-0.2463418245,
0.091301024,
0.7183127403,
-0.2953980267,
-0.0939185917,
0.4193539619,
-0.3626281917,
0.6416811347,
-0.1022019014,
0.1049423888,
-1.3520501852,
0.6708250642,
0.0400528572,
-0.1574485302,
-0.4534327686,
0.3430567086,
0.1687379926,
-0.1356516778,
-0.2224895358,
0.6075527668,
-0.5352977514,
0.1112781689,
-0.4848309755,
0.1388028115,
0.1823639125,
0.0905756131,
0.1945838183,
0.7124949694,
0.320781678,
-0.4383406639,
-0.2126522809,
0.1791390181,
-0.1225673258,
0.522600472,
-0.7118526101,
0.1908230186,
-0.0334277861,
0.5822950602,
-0.7540767193,
-0.2566939294,
-0.2944869399,
-0.1315550506,
0.1508356333,
-0.0937572792,
-0.8570744395,
-0.1941581666,
-0.1964738965,
0.5488974452,
-0.3018844724,
-0.7453989983,
0.5800689459,
0.3750604689,
-0.39547804,
-0.3819625974,
-0.6022415161,
0.4252499342,
-0.3965994418,
-0.7513768673,
0.4908310771,
-0.2425688356,
-0.1015482619,
-0.1734926254,
0.1073265076,
-0.0038888287,
0.0979274139,
0.0762348101,
0.2138411999,
-0.0409866273,
0.4850642979,
0.2584089339,
0.1826954484,
-0.1001668572,
-0.4831546247,
0.5683890581,
-0.1484056413,
-0.1749679148,
0.086394988,
0.928272903,
0.6483492851,
-0.3374102712,
0.7787781954,
0.5725604892,
-0.2168045193,
0.0759114847,
-0.4402679205,
-0.2210531235,
-0.3660405278,
0.2646063268,
-0.6368898749,
-0.9466704726,
0.5302878022,
-0.1927767545,
0.186387971,
0.3273999691,
0.4592461884,
0.0857439265,
0.7531554103,
0.4748241305,
0.1742108166,
0.5766344666,
0.180226922,
0.1433902681,
-0.7904736996,
-0.2854624093,
-1.0235044956,
0.1729354113,
-0.5596524477,
-0.3966931403,
0.5894593,
0.3457529545,
-0.2769322991,
0.2223951221,
-0.3983949721,
0.4484743178,
0.5662958026,
-0.0577466562,
0.4518903792,
0.4253054261,
-0.4444654286,
0.1962711513,
-0.7289996147,
-0.9169150591,
1.1239039898,
0.0362677015,
0.495377928,
0.1420770735,
0.847314477,
0.094505094,
0.3630155921,
-0.4451797009,
0.4718464017,
-0.0854120031,
-0.3772272468,
-0.0060305344,
-0.3194529116,
-1.1337760687,
0.5540629029,
-0.1281209141,
-0.6324281693,
-0.0217728466,
0.0115960268,
-0.0870642886,
0.0291573424,
-0.4269605577,
0.5981309414,
-0.2209889442,
-0.7258637547,
-0.0562389642,
-0.5288012624,
0.4499431252,
-0.2387704551,
0.3604092896,
0.173079595,
0.1675065309,
0.6478314996,
-0.2122836709,
0.5926080346,
0.033115495,
-0.0686870739,
0.535149157,
0.098036699,
0.6986475587,
0.3203463852,
-0.2370217294,
0.0526362993,
-0.0127088604,
-0.4173431695,
-0.0129152089,
0.955969274,
-0.4458623528,
-0.3777301908,
-0.4823313057,
-0.8965383172,
-0.2310238332,
0.371224612,
0.0217792764,
0.2214383036,
-0.2521493435,
0.3557937145,
0.374160409,
-0.1953174621,
0.697018981,
0.5137581229,
-0.0823683888,
-0.5278263092,
0.4927493334,
-0.0507654324,
-0.0672421679,
0.3577509224,
0.232383132,
-0.4981969893,
-0.3620525301,
-0.2330599427,
0.4490263164,
-0.625883162,
-0.3978696465,
-1.0049678087,
-0.0708550513,
-0.841684401,
-0.1678345054,
0.0034155042,
-0.4127987921,
-0.4885279834,
-0.0676155761,
0.3733552396,
0.5080241561,
-0.1255760342,
0.2182397544,
-0.8081105351,
0.0952647552,
0.1330753565,
0.0846247077,
0.035412401,
-0.2578199506,
-0.2394896597,
-0.2132115513,
-0.4079372883,
-1.0591901541,
0.4796850979,
0.269767493,
0.4959167242,
0.2345549762,
-0.1380303204,
0.8114573359,
-0.8058254123,
0.6937010288,
0.2910173833,
-0.7364587188,
0.6601673365,
-0.7115234733,
0.3332631588,
0.5300502181,
0.245531112,
-0.3268656731,
-0.3475137949,
-0.3670715094,
-1.2135887146,
0.5076929331,
0.0967745185,
-0.0285593718,
-0.3945595324,
0.2077493072,
0.1822133958,
0.1192769557,
-1.1571748257,
-0.0686107129,
-0.2016411275,
-0.0974573493,
-0.0053792391,
-0.3696537614,
-0.4339162409,
0.1523041725,
0.6300689578,
-0.6079890728,
0.1066574454,
0.1727184057,
-0.2234060466,
0.0798106194,
0.5089616776,
0.9332606196,
0.7347266674,
-0.1842209846,
0.4007177353,
-0.248971194,
-0.1052977145,
-0.1834678799,
0.3081366718,
-0.2337211967,
0.0186991151,
0.3441608548,
0.3665708005,
-0.0062223915,
-0.5894676447,
0.151566416,
0.043587856,
-0.2008944452,
-0.2119470686,
-0.4039070308,
0.2871039808,
0.2567794919,
0.7834687233,
-0.0677076057,
0.1316777915,
-0.5226586461,
0.1742801666,
0.5971496105,
0.1116537228,
-0.042543523,
0.7148841619,
0.2419359237,
0.1447899193,
0.1946683675,
-0.1086080149,
-0.304933399,
0.4206836224,
0.8665921092,
0.7931019664,
0.1321741194,
0.2434770018,
0.5813411474,
0.1864676028,
-0.2299358249,
0.1322529465,
-0.1413663179,
-0.4089185596,
-0.4616086781,
-0.7708467245,
-0.0518029295,
0.3456277251,
-0.5336367488,
0.1746406108,
0.0112989275,
-0.1163052693,
0.040536616,
0.0678528696,
-0.6245188117,
-0.1990923136,
0.1947162747,
0.7530583143,
-1.0059006214,
1.0500885248,
0.8326309919,
-0.4337382913,
-0.5591198802,
-0.0917068049,
-0.1459943652,
-0.3382895589,
0.5776574612,
0.1399346888,
-0.2164921165,
-0.124336645,
-0.6347737908,
-1.0358612537,
1.2525668144,
0.436078608,
-0.540075779,
0.1212102249,
-0.0304374024,
0.5075604916,
-0.7883611321,
0.4446874857,
0.3181121051,
0.6561430097,
0.1817777157,
-0.6438626647,
0.2067777067,
-0.3259252012,
0.1902131587,
-0.1271141768,
-0.68361485,
0.8499397039,
-0.2339911014,
-0.1061729565,
0.1157766804,
0.8133015633,
0.9653826952,
0.3758563101,
0.2502633333,
0.209341839,
1.0155090094,
0.2018006146,
1.0445705652,
-0.4982720315,
0.1719868183,
1.5778510571,
-0.4810311198,
0.8135528564,
0.8285987377,
0.0061903959,
0.6830986738,
0.4186205864,
0.0315656029,
0.4446719289,
0.016683124,
-0.243253991,
-0.3666478693,
-0.395650059,
-0.4408656359,
0.3797591925,
0.2472301722,
-0.7580904961,
-0.3243188262,
0.0209248587,
0.2606884241,
0.2340098619,
-0.0709056482,
0.4516838193,
-0.0009145105,
-0.9434708953,
0.2554677129,
0.0676865801,
0.4521561563,
-0.6097849607,
0.0895849392,
-0.189419046,
-0.1560468674,
-0.0105799651,
-0.5250304341,
0.0728714168,
0.4187978506,
-0.4910298884,
-0.3643915951,
0.7110702395,
-0.6172561049,
-0.6232863665,
0.2430479228,
0.6792962551,
0.1766889095,
0.0360703766,
-0.4497776628,
-0.1009528339,
0.0278473292,
-0.4012641907,
0.4030790925,
0.4571803212,
-0.0394472256,
0.515425086,
0.7366281152,
0.0306559484,
0.1068530008,
0.342290163,
0.834338665,
-0.5276266336,
-0.4404765368,
-0.8383447528,
0.4497642815,
-0.3305441439,
-0.1393173337,
0.7182874084,
0.6959581375,
0.4946499467,
-0.0092172874,
1.2220585346,
-0.2336627394,
0.4198267758,
-0.4021438062,
0.5043694377,
-0.6789779663,
0.4023800492,
-0.3839605153,
-0.7454983592,
-0.4527983665,
0.5888561606,
0.047673773,
0.1719604135,
0.9331020117,
0.6218398213,
0.0158379078,
-0.1078901216,
0.0198273044,
0.08633928,
0.6706553102,
0.4094695449,
0.6085739732,
-0.2299338579,
0.8793449402,
0.1550929397,
0.0774862245,
-0.238508299,
-1.3946176767,
-0.945538938,
-0.5946648717,
-0.4295898974,
-0.4786872864,
-0.1456822008,
0.7541636825,
0.5949780941,
-0.6254004836,
-0.1491991431,
-0.2630657852,
-0.067120485,
-0.008284987,
-0.278295666,
0.6260582209,
-0.537810564,
-0.8454212546,
0.6182066798,
0.2176434845,
-0.0271194857,
-0.0931844264,
-0.02057161,
-0.5337870717,
0.1584319025,
0.7481927276,
0.1212495565,
-0.6109600663,
-0.2684485018,
0.0495328344,
-0.3211368322,
-0.1208072975,
1.1997824907,
-0.7383941412,
0.2843064964,
0.4917322099,
0.4522357285,
0.5706889629,
-0.0192467738,
0.4366852045,
-0.8594487309,
-0.1456380188,
0.1227361187,
0.5955144763,
0.4557114542,
-0.1724934429,
0.5616836548,
0.0538264923,
-0.7563419938,
-1.0337495804,
0.2029474676,
-1.1228905916,
-0.7645029426,
1.4835321903,
-0.2372807711,
0.160807088,
0.0783553272,
-0.1047488898,
0.3156732619,
-0.4725360274,
0.9490785599,
0.7256584167,
-0.1173070222,
-0.1125045195,
-0.151979059,
0.1733138561,
0.3448019922,
-1.0148848295,
0.1881946176,
0.7113339901,
0.2056923658,
0.4271248281,
0.3292668462,
-0.0658290684,
0.1028046235,
0.0191111788,
-0.0795507282,
-0.3469769061,
-0.5181108117,
-0.0672060251,
0.6614583731,
0.0505346917,
0.3410485387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13855v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13855v1
|
Understanding the role of FFNs in driving multilingual behaviour in LLMs
| 2024-04-22T03:47:00 | 2024-04-22T03:47:00 |
Sunit Bhattacharya, Ondřej Bojar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingualism in Large Language Models (LLMs) is an yet under-explored
area. In this paper, we conduct an in-depth analysis of the multilingual
capabilities of a family of a Large Language Model, examining its architecture,
activation patterns, and processing mechanisms across languages. We introduce
novel metrics to probe the model's multilingual behaviour at different layers
and shed light on the impact of architectural choices on multilingual
processing.
Our findings reveal different patterns of multilinugal processing in the
sublayers of Feed-Forward Networks of the models. Furthermore, we uncover the
phenomenon of "over-layerization" in certain model configurations, where
increasing layer depth without corresponding adjustments to other parameters
may degrade model performance. Through comparisons within and across languages,
we demonstrate the interplay between model architecture, layer depth, and
multilingual processing capabilities of LLMs trained on multiple languages.
|
[
-0.5252312422,
-0.5387414694,
0.2926360369,
0.5458938479,
0.0158216637,
0.1645115018,
-0.0702488497,
-0.6871602535,
0.0661640465,
0.5433973074,
-0.5832707882,
-0.0310048815,
-0.5014538765,
0.2320594341,
-0.2636937499,
0.6993798018,
-0.0440018289,
0.3404283524,
-0.1205037013,
-0.2511431277,
0.1252609789,
-0.758610785,
-0.8529295325,
-0.7434252501,
0.8799333572,
0.0140683679,
0.7565130591,
0.7489255667,
0.2667989433,
0.3553363979,
-0.39723894,
0.0697156712,
-0.4631664157,
0.3468766809,
-0.0811138526,
-0.3326115608,
-0.4499700665,
-0.2944755554,
1.0874984264,
0.8374340534,
0.0484756529,
0.1423729956,
0.3038486242,
0.5748708844,
-0.3005239367,
0.4203178585,
-0.2665803432,
0.2083580792,
-0.3272117078,
-0.2316176891,
-0.3904356956,
0.3323580325,
0.0307045523,
-0.1985125393,
-0.0655348003,
-0.2863087356,
0.3167230189,
-0.1014970616,
-0.6663425565,
-0.2433897853,
-0.61402601,
0.7590747476,
-0.6673521399,
0.8801478744,
0.113033019,
-0.1482856125,
-0.0220108442,
-0.2840696275,
-0.2505600154,
-0.0897741392,
-0.4158996046,
-0.2697674334,
-0.0296980906,
-0.0584509932,
0.2527348399,
0.2883671224,
-0.6856890321,
0.3886229694,
-0.4751569033,
-0.090895474,
0.4713334143,
0.0236243438,
0.1608865559,
-0.1341278851,
-0.4205093384,
0.1327464581,
-0.6625189185,
0.3867936134,
0.417263329,
0.6202967763,
-0.1211661845,
0.4345541596,
-0.0903848335,
0.571121037,
-0.3515551388,
-0.2451556772,
0.3432092965,
-0.2684687376,
-0.2409322411,
0.1307378113,
0.7563822269,
-0.1287855655,
0.4054815173,
-0.1781454235,
-0.4899758101,
-0.418983072,
-0.0355443433,
-0.7892770171,
0.184466511,
0.2195101082,
-0.3464714289,
-0.2367514819,
-0.1921137869,
-0.3837226033,
-0.3551288247,
-0.3567359447,
0.1131759807,
-0.3148688376,
-0.7131891251,
0.1906270534,
-0.0145582352,
0.4194770157,
-0.0829105377,
-0.8904254436,
0.3927644491,
0.8447294235,
0.8688295484,
-0.0987490118,
-0.9327691197,
-0.361259371,
0.1936059296,
-0.3963876963,
0.6009346247,
-0.652813077,
-0.2203460485,
0.0873293355,
0.2602035999,
-0.3439429998,
-0.4104993343,
0.1456345618,
-0.8916085958,
-0.0811692402,
-0.4364997149,
-0.2487781644,
-0.517383635,
0.3051717579,
-0.9138500094,
0.8962413073,
-0.0470971689,
-0.4035237432,
0.2674374282,
-0.4727511406,
-0.7559468746,
0.0336000063,
-0.0939618275,
-0.0821110532,
0.3316253126,
0.1252730936,
0.8839667439,
-0.2714441419,
0.2334144264,
-0.2437800467,
-0.3019348085,
0.3973352909,
-0.4769179225,
0.8343725204,
-0.0184374861,
-0.0860871151,
0.165306434,
-0.847014904,
-0.1782680005,
0.1974328607,
-0.5828202963,
-0.3713153303,
-0.0481214561,
-0.0364791155,
0.808132112,
0.0314271972,
-0.3459165096,
0.0072900658,
-0.4243724942,
0.6918893456,
0.5753564239,
-0.1639986336,
0.5375045538,
-0.1157782078,
0.6535668969,
0.3607967198,
0.1998495013,
-0.564339757,
-0.4397695661,
-0.5935889482,
-0.069092758,
-0.0052185585,
0.541416347,
-0.7148509026,
-0.3502397537,
-0.3178113699,
-0.1976741403,
-0.464590162,
0.5466143489,
0.659855485,
0.0072727511,
0.1261970252,
-0.171914041,
-0.2399582416,
-1.0694278479,
0.0883562714,
0.1341632456,
0.3245411515,
0.1763376743,
0.4685259759,
-0.2142264545,
0.2368830144,
0.0452349149,
-0.2266052365,
-0.3846007288,
-0.14882195,
0.2022415251,
0.2918526232,
0.7352952361,
-0.8943706751,
-0.2773726583,
0.4962953627,
-0.6050429344,
0.043267075,
-0.1555450857,
0.0822579339,
0.3836344481,
0.6647831202,
-0.5650547147,
-0.0779800117,
0.814493835,
-0.1574542671,
0.4269654751,
-0.1604104042,
0.1058013812,
-0.8329524994,
-0.197282359,
0.1455591321,
0.079235673,
-0.9219549894,
0.5529381037,
0.0192260891,
0.0492643639,
-0.784435451,
0.5600622296,
-0.6482607126,
-0.6999244094,
-0.0158688296,
0.0293536242,
0.3266226053,
0.6797937155,
0.133088842,
0.6867384911,
0.7050144672,
-0.6338235736,
0.5379300117,
-0.0526910387,
-0.467343092,
0.2809408605,
-0.5677568913,
-0.1515469402,
-0.1315663755,
-0.0770999715,
-1.2410289049,
-0.1363977045,
0.0147217652,
-0.2171895206,
0.4495862126,
-0.333229512,
-0.5865962505,
-0.3322870135,
-0.2740992606,
0.6096225977,
-0.2668372691,
-0.3774876297,
0.9667701125,
0.2641184628,
-0.1393736005,
-0.5388259888,
-1.0871441364,
0.0105824191,
-0.1992394626,
-1.0082517862,
0.2172905505,
0.1144712269,
-0.4035641551,
-0.3441471756,
0.1750070602,
-0.030427387,
0.2372319847,
0.0795167238,
-0.0576220043,
-0.8638422489,
0.0462004393,
0.1621513814,
0.0514898337,
0.2543623149,
-0.4241595864,
0.8682214618,
-0.3450007439,
-0.3365473151,
-0.208207503,
0.5225859284,
0.8781319857,
-0.6113979816,
1.1551661491,
0.5773563385,
-0.2295544744,
-0.3066412508,
-0.4303214848,
0.0502449833,
-0.5337273479,
0.5108876228,
-0.7263864875,
-0.9546203613,
1.161618948,
0.2322706133,
0.0182299968,
0.2854077816,
0.6576451063,
0.0674506649,
0.9374844432,
0.3443213701,
-0.0231276378,
0.3388488293,
-0.2517794669,
-0.0249173641,
-0.989810884,
-0.3602927327,
-0.3177985847,
-0.2456253469,
-0.5753372312,
-0.5173530579,
0.084196642,
0.0420189984,
-0.2222175598,
0.1855936199,
0.1111109331,
0.5192104578,
0.1486288458,
-0.2491698712,
0.1757541746,
0.1261599362,
-0.3486409783,
0.1965847909,
-0.8937940001,
-0.2638873756,
0.5633598566,
0.5994183421,
0.5780744553,
0.43481794,
0.3231787384,
-0.0000100202,
0.0344153717,
-0.740876615,
0.462204963,
-0.4455610514,
-0.5370746851,
-0.3981623948,
-0.3953335881,
-0.6951503754,
0.8145938516,
-0.0074435398,
-0.4966456294,
0.3254809678,
-0.1222512275,
-0.3605084419,
0.4157038629,
-0.5964942575,
0.7552480698,
-0.5371373296,
-0.559093833,
-0.020615356,
-0.4222945869,
0.5140739679,
-0.2523584962,
0.5879715085,
0.1343808919,
0.0265247989,
0.3640722036,
0.3418610394,
0.9335442185,
0.0547372438,
-0.8450027108,
-0.1307358295,
0.4274187684,
0.2629030645,
-0.0186119433,
-0.4052669108,
0.4366161525,
-0.0565055795,
-0.3060379326,
-0.36085096,
1.0734117031,
-0.757701695,
-0.5724314451,
-0.1384752989,
-0.4327403903,
-0.3784021735,
0.1740038991,
-0.095324412,
0.8240199089,
-0.0889190808,
0.2132363766,
0.7884507179,
-0.3322164416,
0.5564770103,
0.5748477578,
-0.7137457132,
-0.046246618,
0.9191533923,
0.2605490983,
0.57818681,
0.5925528407,
0.2268448621,
-0.3119225204,
-0.5843480229,
-0.6684313416,
0.2819674015,
-0.9104269743,
0.2177359164,
-0.68417418,
-0.3951097131,
-0.5933273435,
-0.1040614322,
-0.3372375071,
-0.312040031,
-0.2772728503,
-0.2637864053,
-0.0526514947,
0.9667395949,
0.1480845511,
0.4548175931,
-0.8745712638,
0.1100481302,
0.2917127013,
0.6011434793,
0.5748887062,
-0.5029133558,
-0.3943255246,
-0.016544681,
0.1382236332,
-0.4693315625,
0.309035778,
0.3980812132,
0.7911091447,
0.5483037233,
-0.6400635839,
0.5133328438,
-0.5598512888,
0.7747775316,
-0.220251143,
-0.8038793206,
-0.0507071093,
-0.5317736864,
0.5629901886,
-0.0920501277,
0.4060746133,
-0.7183403373,
-0.2744739354,
-0.0771040916,
-0.8940057158,
1.069183588,
0.0064095836,
0.3411581218,
0.1461091638,
0.3925709128,
0.0651867017,
0.1567295492,
-1.0624006987,
-0.0927871317,
-0.0590904132,
0.5806498528,
-0.2665072381,
-0.5507423282,
-0.0270604137,
-0.0513334945,
0.6015688181,
-0.2018167526,
-0.0612503476,
-0.2157167345,
-0.2963013947,
-0.2202750146,
0.2263583243,
1.0796095133,
0.6291360855,
0.1802041531,
0.1202975139,
0.0711441413,
-0.1400518864,
-0.0670429245,
-0.0552513041,
0.0362007245,
-0.3802981973,
0.8780360222,
1.1177227497,
0.6005166769,
-0.145340398,
0.114270784,
0.0807423368,
-0.2774676979,
-0.1710145772,
0.0623319745,
0.3721323311,
0.5326206088,
0.2812295556,
0.0108620804,
-0.0625097826,
-0.617208302,
0.1484324634,
0.3998295367,
-0.3271608651,
-0.5546513796,
0.2555027008,
0.0484055355,
-0.3188541532,
0.4528385699,
0.0266042277,
-0.7372179627,
0.5414223075,
0.4608913064,
0.7068368196,
-0.5422933698,
0.3191981316,
0.0391206853,
0.5761597753,
-0.0029071942,
0.2573693991,
-0.0263477694,
-1.0540866852,
-0.7011650205,
-0.9734053016,
0.2230104506,
0.1345403045,
-0.6260777116,
-0.0972896591,
-0.3447801173,
0.0855723247,
0.3020112216,
-0.387475431,
-0.4588207603,
0.0910092369,
0.7145537734,
0.9137131572,
-0.8059769273,
0.9562722445,
0.6523260474,
-0.0993088484,
-0.7118187547,
-0.1211784258,
0.1664623916,
-0.8585561514,
1.0022649765,
0.1961322874,
-0.6691087484,
-0.1089338362,
0.0882951468,
-1.0533311367,
0.7385514379,
0.3289069831,
-0.3881527781,
-0.1353237033,
0.7256520987,
0.6838729382,
-0.5332215428,
-0.0374561548,
0.5823242068,
0.4670893848,
0.1979859173,
-0.9465742707,
-0.1438761055,
-0.2338732332,
0.1850467771,
0.3810667396,
-0.8421674967,
1.0401470661,
-0.0692823231,
-0.0243930575,
-0.2198922038,
0.3735105395,
0.0260286685,
-0.1483241767,
0.3511498272,
0.1990186125,
0.3637713194,
0.0075939144,
1.1969745159,
-0.479052484,
0.03257275,
0.8624900579,
-0.5917419791,
0.8825028539,
0.5065612197,
-0.0471759439,
0.3248502016,
0.4373801649,
0.2157442123,
0.2698874772,
0.1913480163,
-0.0944090337,
-0.3344018757,
-0.0460970476,
-0.2312331796,
0.7233045697,
0.5776432157,
-0.5296969414,
-0.1957000941,
0.307371527,
-0.0783629641,
-0.1710496694,
-0.5099647045,
0.7125757933,
0.2547380924,
-0.5636136532,
0.4758013487,
0.1799457073,
0.56674546,
-0.7964271903,
0.324285835,
-0.2642975152,
0.2659361362,
-0.3400866687,
-1.0930265188,
0.4217402637,
-0.419053793,
-0.3433890641,
-0.6793333888,
0.5439611077,
-0.4942269027,
-0.6123799086,
1.1235945225,
0.7056020498,
-0.1615312397,
-0.0495142974,
-0.7514122725,
0.351136297,
-0.124907501,
-0.6567390561,
0.5233357549,
0.7784573436,
-0.2697693706,
0.7336595654,
0.7633069754,
0.0770828873,
0.2623993158,
0.4651612341,
0.7989657521,
-0.4842290878,
-0.450597465,
-1.0565757751,
0.3330124617,
0.3561098576,
-0.3275453448,
0.8339143395,
0.568814218,
1.1539690495,
-0.0192372557,
0.2395228148,
0.442184478,
0.0550096072,
-0.6766591668,
0.6964043379,
-0.784683764,
0.5265868902,
-0.2326631844,
-0.839621067,
-0.2908521295,
0.3737843633,
-0.1622529924,
0.1117336527,
0.3224437535,
0.8347704411,
-0.0933962464,
0.2907304168,
0.4913496673,
0.3871950507,
0.3475143909,
0.3300133944,
0.973534286,
-0.0524041504,
0.3514949977,
-0.3645558953,
0.0707563013,
0.1403365731,
-0.714564383,
-0.9859365225,
-0.7644996047,
-0.022127701,
-0.0783491209,
-0.218319878,
0.6859781146,
0.6066571474,
-0.8894358873,
-0.6949292421,
0.415310204,
0.1291751266,
-0.1612510234,
-0.2020776272,
0.0671168342,
-0.144547835,
-0.3660314977,
0.6872909069,
0.5074448586,
-0.0326081626,
-0.8191730976,
-0.044423569,
-0.5524063706,
0.0680098981,
0.9800265431,
0.0184459519,
-0.7136266232,
0.1679984182,
0.214319095,
-0.1483588517,
0.0447880588,
1.020575285,
-0.4813604057,
0.0377260223,
0.3731145561,
0.419092834,
0.2568387985,
-0.446744889,
0.6244177818,
-1.0061985254,
0.2857582867,
-0.0667605698,
0.5442866087,
0.4582709968,
-0.4487975538,
0.1393021494,
0.1053773463,
-0.212689653,
-0.7463226914,
0.2806663513,
-0.5286974907,
-0.471273452,
1.3456561565,
-0.0660852939,
-0.3003486693,
-0.0714496374,
0.1009468809,
-0.212782532,
-0.206923008,
0.249511525,
1.1488753557,
-0.1002404541,
-0.5381029248,
-0.6486011147,
0.429550916,
0.0353838243,
-0.2775092423,
0.2617536485,
0.2804845572,
0.1561776847,
0.3892315328,
0.3426821828,
-0.0228852704,
-0.00744155,
-0.330986619,
-0.4198156595,
-0.293464452,
-0.5947322249,
-0.6936385632,
0.3808329701,
-0.1088220552,
0.445130229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13847v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13847v1
|
EventLens: Leveraging Event-Aware Pretraining and Cross-modal Linking Enhances Visual Commonsense Reasoning
| 2024-04-22T03:05:32 | 2024-04-22T03:05:32 |
Mingjie Ma, Zhihuan Yu, Yichao Ma, Guohui Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Visual Commonsense Reasoning (VCR) is a cognitive task, challenging models to
answer visual questions requiring human commonsense, and to provide rationales
explaining why the answers are correct. With emergence of Large Language Models
(LLMs), it is natural and imperative to explore their applicability to VCR.
However, VCR task demands more external knowledge to tackle its challenging
questions, necessitating special designs to activate LLMs' commonsense
reasoning abilities. Also, most existing Multimodal LLMs adopted an abstraction
of entire input image, which makes it difficult to comprehend VCR's unique
co-reference tags between image regions and text, posing challenges for
fine-grained alignment. To address these issues, we propose EventLens that
leverages Event-Aware Pretraining and Cross-modal Linking and EnhanceS VCR.
First, by emulating the cognitive process of human reasoning, an Event-Aware
Pretraining auxiliary task is introduced to better activate LLM's global
comprehension of intricate scenarios. Second, during fine-tuning, we further
utilize reference tags to bridge RoI features with texts, while preserving both
modality semantics. Finally, we use instruct-style prompts to narrow the gap
between pretraining and fine-tuning, and task-specific adapters to better
integrate LLM's inherent knowledge with new commonsense. Experimental results
show the effectiveness of our proposed auxiliary task and fine-grained linking
strategy.
|
[
-0.5141793489,
-0.6819913983,
0.5555887818,
-0.2080161273,
-0.4733026624,
-0.2514391541,
-0.3804998994,
-0.5282815695,
-0.2352424115,
0.2315177023,
-0.5490199327,
-0.3472512662,
-0.2596702874,
0.1050757542,
0.0815870538,
0.8564246297,
-0.0938561559,
0.0291241743,
-0.4711123407,
0.0062471507,
-0.381911099,
-0.3484562635,
-0.6879760623,
-0.1727664918,
0.604356885,
0.5037450194,
0.4006268382,
0.5040769577,
0.534104228,
0.3237922788,
-0.0453341193,
0.6148706675,
-0.3829135299,
0.0606350116,
-0.5021534562,
-0.3920352161,
-0.2828358114,
-0.3158497214,
0.3692250848,
0.1839951575,
0.1253969371,
0.1421807408,
0.129777655,
0.2931207716,
-1.0346864462,
-0.0118457405,
-0.8417278528,
0.0923904181,
-0.2959632277,
-0.4894064963,
-0.2529812455,
0.1803278029,
0.0120453881,
-1.0414768457,
0.3671769798,
0.1055135354,
0.9132919312,
0.4447548985,
-0.3570030332,
0.0814639255,
-0.5546696782,
0.6648247838,
-0.431838423,
0.7770141363,
0.3831974566,
0.2988012731,
0.0916672945,
-0.7146726847,
-0.9336377978,
-0.2072449923,
-0.0106423292,
0.2731103301,
-0.1729470789,
0.1308030635,
0.3110242486,
-0.101481162,
-0.6337752342,
0.1504300088,
-0.3100612164,
-0.1277317405,
0.4629984796,
0.3307891488,
0.246645689,
-0.3137314916,
-0.6178354025,
-0.0093657011,
-0.497925669,
0.0927888304,
0.0029427111,
0.2312707901,
-0.1632135808,
0.4718757272,
-0.222086817,
0.8527046442,
0.2680255175,
0.006481573,
0.137344569,
-0.8408125043,
-0.3586600721,
0.1037153751,
0.5593307614,
0.4965816438,
0.2749848366,
0.0831199139,
-0.0450550802,
0.1181962714,
0.1608440727,
-0.6571327448,
-0.1221807748,
-0.0472946689,
-0.585354507,
-0.0559391007,
-0.0661512092,
-0.5558742285,
-0.2695058286,
-0.706764698,
0.5840910077,
-0.4650968611,
-0.1189856306,
0.0606413111,
-0.2181302607,
0.2963444293,
0.7069829106,
-0.8026083112,
-0.0918720588,
0.6210174561,
0.4519020021,
-0.1087264866,
-0.4138888419,
-0.8110477328,
0.5310863853,
0.0562362261,
0.8208063245,
-0.8479644656,
-0.1638885438,
-0.09663748,
0.1144848615,
-0.1747019589,
-0.4314433038,
0.4976835847,
-0.6080970168,
-0.0809540898,
-0.4801725745,
-0.3050244749,
0.2034272254,
0.6091197729,
-0.4575300217,
0.8375161886,
-0.4033694267,
-0.6638360023,
0.5962291956,
-0.5636872053,
-0.4219620228,
0.0727835521,
-0.3307778835,
-0.180734247,
0.0377753265,
0.5812498331,
0.5979748964,
-0.0477139466,
0.1858682185,
-0.312872678,
-0.118977569,
0.2576359212,
-0.6422403455,
0.2927171588,
0.2148618251,
-0.1694742143,
0.2791256011,
-0.7153046131,
-0.2623210847,
-0.1625342965,
-0.1645743698,
-0.5638726354,
-0.0777473673,
0.14675574,
0.3346020877,
0.2992501259,
-0.4025787413,
0.025896553,
-0.0190575235,
0.0942395031,
0.6776268482,
-0.05571872,
0.5815149546,
-0.2830665708,
0.2869228423,
0.2322566807,
0.4748542905,
-0.4146943092,
-0.3550688922,
-0.7882720828,
-0.179408282,
-0.2555469871,
0.6219956279,
-1.0961956978,
0.2049479187,
-0.1378535479,
-0.3037568927,
-0.2891147137,
0.296536386,
0.5996082425,
0.655105114,
0.5917066336,
-0.2474435568,
-0.6533358693,
-0.6199368238,
-0.1605705619,
-0.106984973,
0.1767392755,
0.2858151793,
0.4252231717,
-0.2089050561,
0.8470848799,
-0.2107729465,
-0.4395650029,
-0.1807812899,
0.2595123649,
-0.2783194184,
0.48828125,
0.2140570879,
-0.991482079,
-0.112339817,
0.2192968875,
-0.5790690184,
-0.1449469477,
-0.4238666594,
-0.1744883358,
0.2932879031,
0.8751456141,
-0.3225648999,
0.5340682268,
0.3573744893,
-0.5209174752,
0.5750436783,
-0.3070570827,
0.3205010593,
-0.9459794164,
-0.1482679844,
0.108771883,
-0.194699049,
-0.4201154113,
-0.1974262744,
-0.0714872777,
0.1445608884,
-0.632856667,
0.8269023895,
-0.5530406237,
0.0764249712,
-0.1361980438,
0.1805584878,
0.2481601685,
0.45307073,
0.3691346645,
0.5974727869,
0.3444208205,
-0.599501133,
0.4407303333,
0.3389478922,
-0.303255856,
0.8538079262,
-0.417396307,
-0.2671761513,
-0.213163808,
0.0370218381,
-0.7634336352,
-0.0845676064,
0.0664468482,
-0.3405273557,
0.2876635194,
-0.1747979671,
-0.3043785989,
-0.2080681622,
-0.0370142385,
0.6289564967,
0.2975682318,
-0.7950313687,
0.8564950824,
0.0495315865,
-0.0224841814,
-0.5591021776,
-0.716196239,
-0.0055927886,
-0.0818523467,
-0.6300438643,
0.2510865331,
-0.0055681258,
-0.2245353013,
0.205768317,
-0.0900851041,
-0.1764982492,
-0.2699967027,
0.0775458589,
0.4344835281,
-0.2658115029,
0.2953681052,
-0.0977017134,
-0.1732847244,
-0.2252862453,
-0.2169177532,
0.3038109839,
-0.2842692435,
-0.8742887378,
-0.5975171328,
0.1990019977,
0.4881564677,
-0.5459515452,
0.3625627756,
1.0427894592,
-0.1278447211,
-0.0314696655,
-0.8380967975,
-0.2031108588,
-0.4740552008,
0.5151213408,
-0.3274208903,
-1.1096458435,
0.3566718698,
0.0118518379,
-0.2994350791,
0.0747265667,
0.609572649,
-0.2709088326,
0.8259481192,
0.325561434,
0.3882706463,
0.9164894223,
-0.0438313596,
-0.0810212716,
-1.0531749725,
-0.5244096518,
-0.1797289997,
-0.2978743911,
-0.1973536015,
-1.0936954021,
0.3498294353,
0.1881275922,
-0.4789304733,
0.054341279,
-0.3899475932,
0.7464350462,
0.69116503,
0.2626355588,
0.4397409856,
-0.191257,
0.0912025645,
-0.1013170853,
-0.8178130388,
-0.3288812935,
0.6282793283,
-0.0756556839,
1.0163875818,
-0.1718755662,
0.5346668959,
-0.1508406103,
0.040295504,
-0.5338330865,
0.6275057793,
-0.133980602,
-0.5907806754,
-0.4013021588,
-0.2427915782,
-0.8473040462,
0.0980527401,
-0.4568370283,
-0.7845894694,
0.54390347,
0.4438222945,
-0.4161877632,
0.3819264174,
-0.6260174513,
1.1403722763,
-0.5726789236,
-0.7157694101,
-0.2157371342,
-0.7011235356,
0.244103387,
0.1670527309,
0.2350942791,
-0.0362887084,
-0.1609936506,
0.5365366936,
-0.3144303858,
1.161103487,
0.1182324886,
0.0405112728,
0.3860946596,
-0.0332226902,
0.5888525248,
0.20989573,
0.2486270964,
-0.1021950021,
-0.1755470932,
-0.1078808531,
-0.7280136347,
0.6077190638,
-0.6292465925,
-0.6138965487,
-0.088998884,
-0.5041100383,
-0.1291934401,
-0.0081635891,
0.2706378102,
0.7705494761,
-0.3509814739,
0.0611926094,
0.8874313235,
-0.1035808921,
0.5659428835,
0.4158422947,
0.0567284711,
-0.3915342689,
0.8551553488,
-0.2512823939,
0.401155144,
0.7843836546,
0.0490510352,
-0.2060669214,
-0.3853316307,
-0.4285266995,
-0.0493950546,
-0.7801345587,
-0.2882867754,
-0.652243793,
0.064266108,
-0.3717421889,
-0.7314114571,
-0.4050295949,
-0.3275814056,
-0.5089623928,
0.015827179,
0.4174390733,
0.2417948246,
-0.4566207826,
0.0627139583,
-1.04022789,
0.5664822459,
0.7502545118,
0.2538610995,
0.0501645319,
-0.4786753058,
-0.1425384432,
-0.1319858134,
-0.2100931704,
-0.65101403,
0.1477656364,
0.2171905488,
0.7057327032,
0.736358881,
0.140790984,
0.9780077934,
-0.6005988121,
0.6844129562,
0.5697690248,
-0.977756381,
0.8255500793,
-0.3213827014,
0.3300901055,
0.6046065092,
0.2395419776,
-0.4660476148,
-0.2904831767,
-0.5568284392,
-0.7692519426,
0.5357030034,
0.0462493934,
0.0221265964,
-0.107313931,
-0.1298932135,
-0.0409673899,
-0.1339750439,
-0.5544160604,
0.0799212828,
-0.3580517173,
-0.1246832237,
-0.0154418973,
-0.1045331955,
-0.2406495064,
-0.5559543967,
0.5271703601,
-0.1978746355,
0.0141500961,
0.4162153304,
-0.1971583515,
-0.1202351302,
0.4778019488,
0.5812657475,
0.6334217787,
0.0841186494,
0.3019111156,
0.554105401,
-0.4019643664,
-0.0120255034,
0.2831277847,
0.1222116724,
-0.1696622074,
0.5608232617,
1.1139672995,
0.5050751567,
-0.8226816058,
0.6942806244,
-0.104692027,
0.0504208989,
-0.0870367289,
0.1947475374,
0.0489323623,
0.7569565773,
0.1791772544,
0.1246265918,
-0.0398038812,
-0.4663205147,
0.3424346447,
0.5071924925,
-0.5252927542,
-0.2506353259,
0.7375807762,
0.47333318,
-0.1077734455,
0.3103710711,
-0.2951013446,
-0.630988121,
0.5979024172,
0.6096830368,
0.6184737086,
-0.1430229247,
0.1203744262,
0.356095612,
0.4643862844,
0.1382503957,
0.3752520978,
-0.4371083677,
-0.9440180063,
-0.6577361822,
-0.5471170545,
-0.3247673512,
-0.0736755878,
-0.5707709789,
0.4853661954,
-0.0702287406,
0.0832729936,
-0.221270889,
-0.3249477744,
-0.9764209986,
0.3437715173,
0.6228038669,
0.9807714224,
-0.8528629541,
0.6072323322,
0.9600893855,
-0.5551805496,
-0.7527471781,
-0.1657558978,
0.0151612284,
-0.8330065012,
1.0349514484,
-0.0773396417,
0.0496227257,
-0.060873162,
-0.4294663072,
-0.7815865874,
1.105512023,
0.0576993115,
-0.7920742035,
-0.0705457479,
-0.0118399281,
0.2133824527,
-0.2151541263,
0.2596484423,
0.2537232041,
0.6311036348,
0.5690826178,
-1.0731430054,
0.1586366296,
-0.2383992225,
0.0296132527,
0.2077505141,
-0.4387521744,
0.5697186589,
-0.5480827093,
0.0215914492,
-0.2063144147,
0.7253667712,
0.4567857683,
0.6969647408,
0.5159378052,
0.7700642347,
0.6960375905,
0.0176071879,
0.8188461065,
0.0650123954,
-0.0352574177,
1.4166376591,
-0.210198313,
0.8819125891,
0.6477846503,
0.2866114974,
0.3586673141,
0.2945219874,
-0.0554779768,
0.5456515551,
-0.0882883519,
-0.49421978,
-0.9740918875,
-0.369790405,
-0.4833674431,
0.6888225675,
0.3565369248,
-0.1941819489,
-0.3557675779,
0.4641762674,
-0.2937029898,
0.0089547615,
-0.6044450402,
0.8666805029,
0.0593799837,
-0.483725071,
0.2497227937,
-0.5310283303,
0.8022279739,
-0.5481184125,
-0.009200342,
0.1423778236,
0.2954917848,
-0.121978119,
-0.7850936651,
0.1817495078,
0.0106645543,
-0.1391654611,
-0.1416908205,
0.9997354746,
-0.6127718091,
-0.3586811423,
0.1250818521,
0.5967033505,
-0.1769130677,
0.0624888949,
-0.4996828139,
0.3122759461,
-0.273584187,
-0.2657408118,
0.2419537008,
0.9184597135,
-0.204225868,
0.4821127951,
0.723464489,
-0.0690876395,
0.0305119641,
0.2150276154,
1.0310214758,
-0.6330667734,
-0.5463397503,
-0.8156963587,
0.6967241168,
-0.1926128119,
-0.4336282313,
0.6020394564,
0.5085406303,
1.2105311155,
-0.065599598,
0.7611451745,
0.0755190626,
-0.1594731212,
-0.743127346,
0.5077018738,
-0.7763396502,
-0.0065103872,
-0.2862535417,
-0.5685237646,
-0.3102920949,
0.4882395267,
-0.4621440768,
-0.1210316867,
0.6008815765,
0.9213008881,
-0.2639089525,
0.0260475185,
0.4965158999,
-0.0016740207,
0.0851691291,
0.8353020549,
1.2712548971,
-0.0290945116,
0.7856087089,
-0.0510116443,
-0.1974013597,
-0.3703917861,
-1.2289165258,
-1.0971133709,
-0.7901721001,
-0.349793762,
-0.0593453422,
0.3253979087,
1.0784673691,
0.7163974643,
-0.5883563161,
0.1617783755,
-0.0481464751,
0.0320709459,
-0.0391975231,
-0.1674458534,
0.1597075462,
-0.5458984375,
-0.5420325398,
0.2477792501,
0.2892421782,
0.1364493966,
0.1499020159,
-0.1330703944,
-0.351890862,
-0.0443515703,
0.7028853893,
0.4069226384,
-0.6811000109,
-0.3907240033,
-0.137828812,
-0.1204634458,
-0.113982439,
0.96051085,
-0.9000793695,
0.6139925718,
0.7161749601,
0.6782721281,
0.554441154,
-0.0902728066,
0.4688690305,
-0.6719039083,
0.2260855734,
0.18340455,
0.4877305627,
0.3062908649,
-0.3054274917,
0.2394954711,
0.2498445958,
-0.4237783849,
-0.5673933625,
0.3700735867,
-1.224435091,
-0.3875052929,
1.2398847342,
0.2445858717,
-0.3016261756,
-0.3912695348,
-0.3409096599,
0.5431348681,
-0.178684026,
0.4749294817,
0.2883270383,
-0.2257023752,
-0.4044075012,
-0.3164322078,
0.6009098887,
0.327521503,
-0.9255496264,
0.1349096298,
0.5908053517,
-0.0948134735,
0.17613253,
0.6516727209,
0.1216866747,
0.5940055847,
-0.0304151271,
0.1718086302,
-0.5932437181,
-0.4269447327,
-0.0631330758,
-0.0636578426,
-0.3527145684,
-0.2402947843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13846v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13846v2
|
Filtered Direct Preference Optimization
| 2024-04-22T03:05:19 | 2024-04-23T11:56:45 |
Tetsuro Morimura, Mitsuki Sakamoto, Yuu Jinnai, Kenshi Abe, Kaito Ariu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) plays a crucial role in
aligning language models with human preferences. While the significance of
dataset quality is generally recognized, explicit investigations into its
impact within the RLHF framework, to our knowledge, have been limited. This
paper addresses the issue of text quality within the preference dataset by
focusing on Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), an increasingly adopted
reward-model-free RLHF method. We confirm that text quality significantly
influences the performance of models optimized with DPO more than those
optimized with reward-model-based RLHF. Building on this new insight, we
propose an extension of DPO, termed filtered direct preference optimization
(fDPO). fDPO uses a trained reward model to monitor the quality of texts within
the preference dataset during DPO training. Samples of lower quality are
discarded based on comparisons with texts generated by the model being
optimized, resulting in a more accurate dataset. Experimental results
demonstrate that fDPO enhances the final model performance. Our code is
available at https://github.com/CyberAgentAILab/filtered-dpo.
|
[
-0.2010910362,
-0.4407660365,
0.6796044111,
0.0262819882,
-0.5209813714,
0.005803566,
-0.2363568544,
-0.2938548625,
-0.0720082074,
0.7705239058,
-0.7134287953,
-0.453564167,
-0.650106132,
0.268876344,
-0.0347364247,
1.0063122511,
-0.2603424788,
-0.0564605929,
-0.3326277137,
0.0862020776,
-0.3426645994,
-0.4945582449,
-0.607034266,
-0.816342473,
0.5630529523,
0.5143660307,
0.8091723919,
0.9348866343,
0.31198138,
0.2297827154,
0.0207250528,
0.3477627337,
-0.7589771152,
0.2687931061,
-0.1872657835,
-0.3619943261,
-0.1888925731,
0.260253489,
0.5726903081,
0.3442478478,
-0.2354254127,
-0.2370698899,
0.2249696553,
1.1163071394,
-0.6255512834,
0.0883893222,
-0.3566188514,
0.1261591464,
0.3055538833,
-0.4642132223,
-0.5991828442,
-0.5476416945,
0.3067271411,
-0.9202260971,
-0.0259417929,
0.0707012787,
1.105411768,
0.6213456392,
-0.40976879,
-0.2686613798,
-0.6899648309,
1.0490566492,
-0.4143651128,
0.4240489602,
0.7607023716,
-0.109729521,
-0.2577362359,
-0.182384789,
-0.5293218493,
-0.394169569,
-0.2381681204,
0.1570119709,
-0.0072880005,
0.3160140514,
-0.2502951622,
0.5366686583,
-0.385676533,
0.2149208635,
-0.0003776394,
-0.0877991468,
0.6940814257,
-0.0053510778,
0.1533059031,
-0.2410722077,
-0.2758712769,
-0.5160559416,
-0.4733140767,
0.5237396359,
0.661183238,
0.3111559749,
0.228187412,
0.3030075729,
-0.3492130637,
0.9472175241,
0.1679610163,
-0.397297442,
0.101755701,
-0.1600508094,
-0.1768114567,
0.0039252252,
0.744223237,
0.3167539537,
0.2626360953,
-0.0274903122,
-0.5238803029,
-0.0776656643,
0.3981401622,
-0.9320998192,
-0.1799532175,
0.369894892,
-0.6694056988,
-0.8354939818,
-0.0016900869,
-0.6298124194,
-0.3745624125,
-0.6001915932,
0.2538895309,
-0.3164945245,
-0.3521927595,
0.2991433442,
-0.0120596718,
-0.3126070499,
0.3183774054,
-1.1182900667,
0.2356920391,
0.783111155,
0.4805319905,
-0.412771076,
-0.2472606152,
-0.8692233562,
-0.2412373126,
-0.4108430147,
0.7731825709,
-0.638663888,
-0.6034686565,
0.0524214134,
-0.2833436131,
0.1141257808,
-0.5929280519,
1.0401749611,
-0.6635819674,
0.3517436683,
-0.1040152013,
-0.5747668743,
-0.1772902161,
0.117346555,
-0.7769581676,
1.0601379871,
0.1204047576,
-0.5983654261,
0.666651845,
-0.2089265287,
-0.3181572556,
-0.2581829429,
-0.0705810115,
-0.4003992975,
0.1144297794,
0.3510650694,
0.2945288718,
-0.1476968378,
0.7321895361,
-0.2349487841,
-0.6460001469,
0.3380272985,
-0.3777380586,
0.2011617422,
0.2031241208,
-0.1097418442,
0.532376349,
-0.8824735284,
0.0083951894,
-0.0527449548,
-0.7458219528,
-0.6327100992,
0.2654644251,
-0.0989372805,
0.1829373091,
-0.0307993274,
-0.6524831653,
0.0252884608,
-0.6719766259,
0.2786652446,
1.0681706667,
-0.0902966708,
0.6087810397,
-0.3967313468,
0.4080356359,
-0.1318356991,
0.3112226129,
0.2919680178,
-0.2761279047,
-0.6073712707,
-0.3488368988,
0.4001608491,
0.4032008648,
-0.8741540909,
0.6285116076,
-0.2329896837,
-0.1789096892,
-0.5439208746,
0.111006178,
0.4321122766,
0.5416321158,
0.2321817875,
-0.16518116,
-0.1627237499,
-0.98104918,
-0.1711144298,
-0.2466934025,
-0.0564718917,
0.6162949204,
0.107306689,
-0.1389080584,
1.1517016888,
-0.6833541393,
-0.1627672315,
-0.1879721433,
-0.0665380359,
0.4051634371,
0.3458955586,
0.3790586293,
-0.8363076448,
-0.4001380205,
-0.2758522332,
-0.1711383164,
-0.1237569302,
0.0367873237,
-0.3043904901,
0.2460602969,
-0.1801102012,
-0.1226392016,
0.0857787579,
0.8145013452,
-0.5404153466,
0.3779864013,
-0.4986592531,
0.503924787,
-0.5618003607,
0.1530193835,
0.1468068957,
-0.2599140704,
-0.4309149981,
-0.3568251431,
0.1548878551,
-0.1493392587,
-0.3542478979,
0.8987891674,
0.0733520389,
0.1163123772,
-0.5373027921,
0.0826188475,
0.3941152394,
0.579843998,
0.3737817109,
0.8187203407,
0.0091375625,
-0.9034387469,
0.1847114563,
0.3386199772,
-0.3392668962,
0.3765258789,
-0.6295725703,
0.0924210697,
-0.2380346358,
0.1692253202,
-0.8865761161,
-0.0555031039,
0.3178943396,
-0.3991924226,
0.3208341002,
0.0125353141,
-0.365534395,
-0.1175303683,
-0.4457713664,
0.1563774496,
0.2550722361,
-0.8434311152,
-0.0233139563,
0.3726657927,
0.0913247466,
-0.8372853398,
-0.1849947423,
-0.3009844124,
0.0997414663,
-0.3080281317,
0.5818955302,
-0.0254050586,
-0.1291125417,
-0.0682906061,
-0.2493115813,
-0.1408998221,
0.1898969859,
0.1385117769,
0.4077928364,
0.411819309,
0.3296583593,
0.25647071,
-0.3178465664,
-0.1067408621,
-0.1890761852,
0.4763577878,
0.3659279943,
0.1545466036,
-0.6647522449,
0.1404320598,
0.1223651022,
-0.1406268924,
0.4980462193,
0.1757856458,
0.0841234103,
-0.5291606784,
-0.1266106069,
-0.5454524159,
-0.5582768321,
0.18649894,
-0.3954570293,
-0.998891294,
-0.1605605781,
0.2494224161,
-0.1072194725,
0.1615461707,
0.0250254162,
0.0659037977,
1.0765483379,
0.5099973679,
-0.1347928494,
0.8845824003,
0.0622142181,
-0.1056245863,
-0.4418174624,
-0.067207396,
-0.5915129781,
-0.2209184766,
-0.6559137106,
-0.2480390072,
-0.0667145774,
0.0423097126,
-0.3884139955,
-0.0178325828,
-0.8824218512,
0.3609453738,
0.8993742466,
0.6092344522,
0.5358301401,
0.2200651914,
-0.1794812977,
-0.2368129343,
-0.5768319368,
-0.5454951525,
1.0423827171,
0.4743285179,
0.8220883608,
-0.3291338086,
0.8244808912,
0.5517627597,
0.2501098812,
-0.8003532887,
0.3322511017,
-0.3650712669,
-0.2996090055,
-0.3561247885,
-0.7767850161,
-0.9457141161,
0.2282144576,
-0.1950561553,
-0.3645227253,
0.4578410089,
0.318256557,
-0.3012568057,
0.0469565019,
-0.4212020934,
0.6735785604,
-0.2866805196,
-0.5102919936,
-0.475804925,
-0.1538161039,
0.3309936523,
0.2792785764,
-0.0153969144,
-0.3399667144,
-0.0013111763,
0.8125607967,
-0.3004022837,
0.47974962,
-0.1854231209,
-0.2809253335,
0.1432697475,
0.1194454134,
0.5900895596,
0.2085648477,
-0.2920235395,
-0.0343322121,
-0.0094611999,
-0.2812603116,
-0.4205120504,
0.9096892476,
-1.2108448744,
-0.4621581435,
-0.5419932604,
-0.1290693134,
-0.3044879735,
0.1162505373,
0.013150516,
0.4201065004,
-0.0940582305,
-0.0082914121,
0.7555477619,
-0.563914001,
0.3097205758,
0.4757117629,
-0.2306307256,
-0.8815434575,
0.9932444096,
-0.3088259101,
0.2701947689,
0.799888134,
0.4398591518,
-0.5251280069,
-0.5385656953,
-0.5269141793,
0.3117962182,
-0.60124892,
-0.1090849042,
-0.3765922487,
0.1246616021,
-0.0976098254,
0.0644324943,
-0.4188682437,
-0.2386278957,
-0.5158172846,
-0.1464129537,
0.4626612961,
0.4641231894,
0.1146220937,
0.0974838659,
-0.7834199071,
0.3592014313,
0.4032752514,
0.8569620252,
-0.113120757,
-0.4368097782,
-0.0834534392,
0.2100848705,
-0.2056466341,
-0.6061998606,
0.56800735,
-0.0257293507,
0.557420373,
0.1815877259,
0.4391511083,
0.0893148854,
-0.1872340888,
0.4990117848,
0.0382810086,
-0.9149903059,
0.8432697654,
-0.465713799,
0.0720805824,
0.9244154096,
0.3568822443,
-0.5355712771,
0.0565955974,
-0.2897348702,
-0.6098192334,
1.0088768005,
0.0557648577,
0.0353469178,
0.0815060958,
0.6660037637,
0.2700301111,
0.4180920124,
-0.7019517422,
-0.29019171,
-0.3711679876,
-0.1252745986,
-0.1447650045,
-0.5867986679,
-0.009426997,
-0.0847960189,
0.8508355021,
-0.0721397772,
0.1547166705,
0.4006658792,
0.0867263228,
-0.2345805764,
0.256539166,
0.640284121,
0.5086477399,
-0.5460326076,
-0.2691101134,
-0.6045867801,
-0.5788936019,
0.5411653519,
-0.0666438118,
-0.4481339455,
-0.0177053027,
-0.0754082724,
1.1433682442,
0.1412168592,
-0.7357188463,
0.4425616264,
-0.2938364446,
-0.2281988561,
0.2143038511,
0.4204236269,
-0.4192595184,
-0.2188211977,
0.2834960222,
-0.0983993486,
0.1521324217,
-0.3014912009,
0.3405539393,
-0.0190537833,
-0.7948660254,
0.0069234297,
0.4283197522,
0.7052984238,
-0.4028730094,
0.6302469969,
-0.0245366246,
-0.3652957678,
0.4280318022,
0.2002298385,
0.684039712,
-0.0494090654,
0.6069629192,
0.592478931,
0.0622054823,
-0.204962045,
0.0213140938,
-0.2298553735,
-0.9235167503,
-0.6113488674,
-0.7714832425,
-0.7949523926,
0.0979066268,
-0.5626081228,
0.2096001059,
-0.461357832,
-0.0754136443,
-0.3124019206,
0.4848359823,
-0.3985249996,
0.5577820539,
-0.1348030716,
0.5497565269,
-0.4990553558,
1.0759482384,
0.4224561751,
-0.2291888893,
-0.6766100526,
0.0674341992,
-0.2390301079,
-0.6600759625,
0.8112418652,
0.0371527299,
-0.167283982,
0.0915040076,
-0.0142600862,
-0.8231919408,
0.846278131,
0.3649314642,
-0.5532295704,
0.2989719808,
0.0684695914,
0.4557730556,
-0.1396054029,
0.241098702,
0.6148169637,
0.5760471821,
-0.1605428457,
-0.8475604653,
-0.0001936602,
-0.0971042514,
0.1394326091,
0.2456114888,
-0.6574148536,
0.4063797295,
0.1097081527,
-0.1507314593,
-0.1585997194,
0.3373289704,
0.4207740128,
0.1057574898,
0.6083643436,
0.3812648356,
0.6201310158,
-0.1260496229,
1.3650776148,
-0.0802963227,
0.4541777372,
0.9946382046,
-0.3556367755,
0.8945869803,
0.5238412619,
-0.2620169222,
0.3314910233,
1.0327792168,
0.3439447284,
1.0462085009,
0.3565470278,
-0.1671406627,
-0.2005006075,
-0.2392513156,
-0.0968962759,
0.329792887,
-0.1488978118,
-0.4447888732,
0.0479996316,
0.0710496083,
-0.0346012972,
0.6014965177,
-0.1098238379,
0.8288490176,
-0.2523720264,
-1.1424722672,
0.7678893805,
0.0406407639,
0.9054952264,
-0.4696643651,
0.0963293388,
-0.4788029492,
0.4360991418,
-0.0249083955,
-0.7837740183,
0.1884857416,
-0.3480909467,
-0.5842381716,
-0.670306921,
0.6957034469,
-0.4272423983,
-0.1612715274,
0.5138959289,
0.1544579118,
-0.2320542186,
-0.3520572484,
-0.6164954305,
0.1983128339,
0.2586700022,
-0.519010663,
0.5031221509,
0.0617252216,
0.4044753313,
0.6657691598,
0.7314584255,
0.1168415919,
-0.6536694765,
0.0742783323,
0.6606827974,
-0.4658693671,
-0.657815218,
-0.795630753,
0.2864727974,
-0.2281897962,
-0.4953965545,
0.3105568588,
0.3961763084,
0.864339292,
-0.1551073194,
0.607216537,
0.4715285301,
0.6681844592,
-0.5115086436,
0.8845512867,
-0.6105057597,
0.1312087625,
-0.2765926123,
-0.8078988791,
-0.1277141869,
0.6305630803,
-0.4252268672,
-0.2710405886,
0.5833713412,
0.7182407975,
0.1755389571,
-0.0084898928,
0.4609063268,
-0.3805941045,
0.4103093445,
0.4570097923,
0.7324270606,
-0.3573834896,
0.6295520663,
-0.5365983248,
-0.2844304442,
-0.2532450259,
-0.9466989636,
-0.6350315213,
-0.6255541444,
-0.3329674602,
-0.3299320638,
0.198467344,
0.876991868,
0.808950305,
-0.6814716458,
-0.1718815118,
-0.2658872902,
0.5461683273,
-0.267023176,
-0.2611973286,
0.3685957789,
-0.3134909272,
-0.914594233,
0.3455881476,
0.1987454742,
-0.0453812219,
-0.04346136,
-0.4523254931,
-0.1015840098,
0.0687302947,
0.5430824161,
0.0197453331,
-0.5709734559,
-0.3842591047,
0.070893161,
-0.3402031064,
0.0618196912,
0.9994057417,
-0.871557951,
0.5092890859,
0.7030376792,
0.7131989598,
0.3857072592,
0.0742626265,
0.805511713,
-0.72988832,
0.1841741055,
0.3324818015,
0.075090833,
0.2401006371,
-0.6754767895,
0.4016979039,
0.187276274,
-0.7377818823,
-0.7558782697,
0.1375179738,
-0.6864546537,
-0.4846878946,
1.2985719442,
-0.0622987524,
-0.1618960798,
0.1036801338,
-0.4912427962,
0.0625075996,
-0.9294512868,
0.958722353,
0.854500711,
-0.1486698091,
-0.2524427176,
-0.4007135928,
1.0257751942,
0.504891932,
-0.8352552056,
0.0893574506,
0.6031195521,
0.1325219721,
-0.3682971895,
0.8203789592,
0.2059701234,
0.2800125778,
-0.2112965435,
0.001159949,
-0.2606751621,
-0.2698995173,
-0.3937393129,
0.0823357478,
0.2504751384,
-0.2592429221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15159v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15159v2
|
MixLoRA: Enhancing Large Language Models Fine-Tuning with LoRA-based Mixture of Experts
| 2024-04-22T02:15:52 | 2024-05-23T05:16:33 |
Dengchun Li, Yingzi Ma, Naizheng Wang, Zhengmao Ye, Zhiyuan Cheng, Yinghao Tang, Yan Zhang, Lei Duan, Jie Zuo, Cal Yang, Mingjie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs) is a common practice to adapt
pre-trained models for specific applications. While methods like LoRA have
effectively addressed GPU memory constraints during fine-tuning, their
performance often falls short, especially in multi-task scenarios. In contrast,
Mixture-of-Expert (MoE) models, such as Mixtral 8x7B, demonstrate remarkable
performance in multi-task learning scenarios while maintaining a reduced
parameter count. However, the resource requirements of these MoEs remain
challenging, particularly for consumer-grade GPUs with less than 24GB memory.
To tackle these challenges, we propose MixLoRA, an approach to construct a
resource-efficient sparse MoE model based on LoRA. MixLoRA inserts multiple
LoRA-based experts within the feed-forward network block of a frozen
pre-trained dense model and employs a commonly used top-k router. Unlike other
LoRA-based MoE methods, MixLoRA enhances model performance by utilizing
independent attention-layer LoRA adapters. Additionally, an auxiliary load
balance loss is employed to address the imbalance problem of the router. Our
evaluations show that MixLoRA improves about 9% accuracy compared to
state-of-the-art PEFT methods in multi-task learning scenarios. We also propose
a new high-throughput framework to alleviate the computation and memory
bottlenecks during the training and inference of MOE models. This framework
reduces GPU memory consumption by 40% and token computation latency by 30%
during both training and inference.
|
[
-0.7222848535,
-1.02026999,
0.256795913,
0.2843825221,
-0.2366863638,
-0.0039641177,
-0.5039722919,
-0.5503931642,
0.2579880357,
0.5717002153,
-0.2913759649,
-0.1295314282,
-0.4756650925,
-0.2973212302,
-0.0741846263,
0.7682243586,
0.0938607827,
-0.0077938065,
0.2703970075,
-0.3050771058,
-0.8889582753,
-0.2400502861,
-0.8322911263,
-0.5581279993,
0.8088884354,
0.4181502759,
0.7052235007,
0.3117303252,
0.0839141831,
0.3581213653,
-0.2141405493,
0.7159623504,
-0.8654814363,
0.0321213864,
-0.3397455513,
-0.3462233245,
-0.7786421776,
-0.2350990474,
0.4098497033,
0.5955138206,
-0.4482697845,
0.0197960436,
0.0923025906,
0.5688983202,
-0.9401761889,
-0.0038236817,
-1.0391311646,
-0.0678027719,
-0.2316530198,
-0.30026263,
-0.3144306242,
0.2229887098,
0.0216394272,
-0.7049538493,
0.1154373735,
0.1046097055,
0.5772994757,
0.5025977492,
-0.1824415773,
0.16017057,
-0.6801394224,
0.7971622944,
-1.027410984,
0.2667322755,
0.1434589624,
0.2933612466,
-0.3279963732,
-0.1305760592,
-0.6757116318,
0.3526285589,
0.2991196215,
0.0118254274,
-0.0530343354,
0.0680494234,
0.1273839474,
0.4411520064,
-0.3441468775,
0.3223229647,
-0.3009283841,
0.0673817322,
0.5685765743,
0.0973491371,
0.2380698174,
0.4325641096,
-0.1079953536,
0.0737918317,
-0.7700252533,
-0.4751681685,
0.2548684776,
0.5802308321,
0.0023589584,
0.4154463708,
-0.2029654831,
0.7930642366,
0.1926921755,
-0.3156146705,
0.2266385257,
-0.1234406903,
-0.4796014726,
0.1596023738,
0.5514591336,
0.0821530148,
0.1376149952,
-0.1407280713,
-0.207343623,
0.0879066586,
0.2100203484,
-0.7455474138,
-0.4430470467,
0.1293329895,
-0.1510761976,
-0.0592012219,
-0.3749723136,
-0.8823125362,
-0.4947765768,
-0.4308992326,
0.4609710574,
-0.3149849474,
-0.404166609,
0.2672412395,
0.1701801866,
0.0811185166,
0.7242647409,
-0.9244580865,
0.4328293502,
0.6587859392,
0.5591722131,
-0.3159868419,
-0.4777049422,
-0.7034194469,
0.2868175507,
-0.1038964093,
0.7985395193,
-0.4293006063,
-0.1585345417,
-0.2426783741,
-0.3952261508,
-0.382668972,
-0.8243913651,
0.1854616702,
-0.6382860541,
0.0585112944,
-0.1331836283,
-0.4207352698,
-0.359018147,
0.130678162,
-0.6948071718,
1.1546968222,
0.1333362609,
-0.720521152,
0.1654884368,
-0.5530415773,
-0.4687736928,
0.1048702747,
-0.0790561438,
-0.1396458447,
0.2445642799,
0.3493233919,
0.3511295021,
-0.4135825038,
0.2882654369,
-0.3746544123,
-0.3632644117,
0.0334184207,
-0.4620063901,
0.4974658191,
0.4372336864,
-0.2798367739,
0.454449743,
-0.7527642846,
0.0738310888,
-0.013698996,
-0.6090828776,
-0.2759120166,
-0.0066856528,
0.508767724,
0.2135715038,
0.3878428936,
-0.3150434792,
0.1566203684,
-0.1980688721,
0.4382866621,
0.7826377749,
-0.3073728979,
0.190840587,
-0.2749819458,
0.3010187745,
0.1550017893,
-0.0052948687,
-0.0655474067,
-0.6350123882,
-0.9684688449,
-0.3998420835,
0.1975331753,
0.5466967225,
-0.7900397182,
0.4875950217,
-0.2795803845,
-0.4489653111,
-0.6423053145,
0.7746468782,
0.2887085378,
0.4376831949,
0.5195093751,
-0.2598540485,
-0.3755148947,
-0.5973191261,
-0.0658915043,
0.2540500462,
0.2227960229,
0.451949805,
0.1610863805,
-0.2956083417,
0.8018994927,
-0.5451615453,
-0.376639694,
-0.4388115704,
-0.1571067423,
0.3274152875,
0.6079057455,
0.5779567957,
-0.6754230261,
-0.6218566895,
0.3513983488,
-0.4680294693,
-0.071931459,
0.0893495381,
-0.2706248164,
0.0534351282,
0.2674304545,
-0.6125739217,
0.1085037217,
0.7739555836,
-0.3662752807,
0.2554808259,
-0.5459441543,
-0.1220832691,
-1.0896975994,
0.0234302897,
-0.0039015356,
-0.3273879886,
-0.4629282355,
0.3051118851,
-0.1987175047,
-0.1741490066,
-0.4416505694,
0.6306792498,
-0.2551852465,
-0.0254598074,
-0.5967953801,
0.0277383067,
-0.0356202684,
0.741802156,
-0.1728459895,
0.9789907932,
0.5703133345,
-0.5954703093,
0.2503727376,
-0.0913058594,
-0.1179016083,
0.6035420299,
-0.5878368616,
0.2081853151,
0.1286582202,
0.1155780628,
-0.6669532061,
-0.2668836117,
0.2295975834,
0.1969773471,
0.3095749021,
-0.0306420047,
-0.6389400959,
0.0298702288,
-0.0505262874,
0.5814192295,
0.543651998,
-0.5926846266,
1.0646586418,
0.5230821967,
-0.112503998,
-0.4601479471,
-0.4955408871,
0.0967840031,
-0.238629058,
-0.6287309527,
0.3186048269,
-0.3696644306,
-0.1896071583,
-0.189672783,
-0.0409712158,
-0.327481091,
0.2314449549,
0.0646491349,
0.0592712238,
-0.4356780648,
-0.1835577488,
0.2427794337,
-0.0060761068,
-0.3540478349,
-0.1943903267,
0.7605726719,
-0.0960779563,
-0.4055580199,
-0.3463782668,
0.4037786722,
0.49653548,
-0.2237736732,
0.8297604918,
0.8199872971,
-0.3243990242,
-0.5251954198,
-0.8817011118,
0.0069340891,
-0.5020867586,
0.3785622418,
-0.2702257633,
-0.751834929,
0.6541119218,
-0.0683416948,
0.1740504503,
0.373903513,
0.643990159,
0.1407159716,
0.5992290378,
0.470279783,
-0.5169915557,
0.6960722804,
-0.1214662716,
0.0819375366,
-0.7772949338,
0.0489581898,
-0.2386597544,
-0.4764452577,
-0.1576977521,
-0.7104765177,
0.3554868698,
0.1246586367,
-0.2543908954,
-0.0023621332,
-0.2152162492,
0.7291163206,
0.5303967595,
0.4597064257,
0.3733760417,
0.1090862677,
0.1656355262,
0.3242135048,
-1.1157660484,
-0.1077494249,
1.0462397337,
0.2880077958,
0.8676657677,
0.0557994731,
0.5145063996,
0.1426481158,
0.2720716,
-0.4572829604,
0.6345334649,
-0.3221333623,
-0.5513846278,
-0.3062590957,
-0.4449479878,
-0.6911507845,
0.6740154028,
-0.2830350399,
-0.704354465,
0.0840270072,
0.4774735272,
-0.4872463346,
0.559392333,
-0.6538717747,
0.7504771948,
-0.1576568186,
-0.5536172986,
-0.5842263103,
-0.2054242194,
0.3069211245,
-0.2498009354,
0.1912788898,
-0.2252001911,
0.0848822221,
0.5300118923,
-0.5914683938,
1.0613923073,
-0.1178345606,
-0.5712456107,
0.2405735552,
-0.1150058657,
0.4610479474,
-0.1871159822,
-0.0638906434,
0.1858221292,
-0.3284344673,
-0.6067647934,
-0.5090745687,
1.1027261019,
-0.9864202142,
-0.3889820576,
0.0591697358,
-0.9118521214,
-0.3449677825,
0.2593784928,
0.0202994794,
0.3483898044,
0.1044239551,
0.0929955989,
0.9953085184,
-0.1541550756,
0.2095357627,
0.3730461597,
-0.1743188053,
-0.5130558014,
1.1384365559,
0.0849036574,
0.1451234072,
0.19523561,
0.1068883538,
0.2289228737,
-0.799955368,
-0.5208669305,
0.1624251008,
-0.7398506403,
-0.1904433072,
-0.4045384526,
-0.1055676788,
-0.0315914713,
-0.0914263353,
-0.7709986567,
-0.1219208315,
-0.5312586427,
0.3231962323,
0.2920565605,
0.5557070971,
0.3344048262,
0.8347392082,
-0.5739563107,
0.4034686983,
0.291528672,
0.5383482575,
0.3481904566,
-0.4899612665,
-0.3681673706,
-0.0769958273,
-0.2421929687,
-0.5101128817,
0.4341015816,
0.3057797253,
0.5605995059,
0.5970458984,
-0.1945676506,
1.0928838253,
-0.5398537517,
0.3464262187,
0.0158645995,
-0.8422170281,
0.2024728805,
-0.5643811822,
0.2526708245,
0.5757684708,
-0.0895057097,
0.0163228735,
-0.1557393819,
-0.3535966575,
-0.8569415808,
0.581110239,
0.0479955971,
0.0664037764,
0.3450762928,
0.2460786253,
0.2035868615,
0.2220205665,
-0.5753335357,
-0.3010923862,
0.0142576117,
-0.3989893794,
-0.4022510648,
-0.1810466945,
-0.2658078671,
-0.2516395748,
0.7057631016,
-0.328126967,
-0.1643523723,
-0.27767995,
-0.1631565094,
-0.2428791821,
0.2516364157,
0.5514097214,
0.932751894,
-0.1580254138,
0.0831739306,
0.5272932649,
-0.3556092083,
-0.1694370955,
0.1564757973,
-0.1978328824,
-0.1517512351,
0.1469779015,
0.8783851862,
0.7067130804,
-0.869192183,
0.0232578311,
0.1414359212,
0.0932139605,
-0.0197051596,
0.5528789759,
0.1913912147,
0.4040624499,
0.3551109135,
0.2723977268,
-0.1175724417,
-0.3580920696,
-0.2624970078,
0.3814706802,
0.0711813793,
-0.2852222025,
0.5433168411,
0.2995315194,
-0.0088658119,
0.4158410728,
0.0953700989,
-0.37293455,
0.4093690217,
0.5789913535,
0.583716929,
-0.261854589,
-0.2833958268,
-0.0884287283,
0.1116264462,
-0.2796416879,
0.5848449469,
0.0090813097,
-0.8439979553,
-0.4647460878,
-0.5535939932,
-0.3125375509,
0.1911265403,
-0.4529038668,
0.0613110028,
-0.5112280846,
-0.1430646926,
-0.1490233243,
-0.0523039363,
-0.7051928043,
0.071535103,
0.3132710159,
0.8633355498,
-0.8202121258,
1.0531795025,
0.5521652102,
-0.0344788395,
-0.7937244177,
-0.367146492,
-0.3617369831,
-0.6098704934,
0.468411386,
-0.0387736373,
-0.1893715113,
-0.0379745364,
-0.3505458534,
-0.7403742075,
1.0331579447,
0.6457601786,
-0.6206173897,
-0.0800011382,
-0.1135142446,
0.445042938,
-0.376991719,
0.1287755072,
0.2599433959,
0.3050563633,
0.1201808155,
-1.129253149,
-0.0499223731,
-0.2009102851,
-0.0709690005,
0.0237413868,
-0.6939211488,
1.2646257877,
-0.0367139503,
0.2168241292,
-0.1421087533,
0.8253325224,
0.5694628358,
0.3092182875,
0.5702492595,
0.7517011762,
0.8692299724,
0.2452129275,
0.8250340819,
-0.4680245817,
0.2065125406,
1.3632173538,
-0.4503694773,
1.162411809,
0.6024234891,
-0.1287009567,
0.3921006918,
0.4629323483,
0.2255702615,
0.3865340054,
-0.009468127,
-0.2513573468,
-0.5670438409,
0.0392125882,
-0.4666006565,
0.2229050547,
0.5071207285,
-0.2143616825,
-0.3031317294,
0.0178361852,
0.0590701997,
-0.2013424486,
-0.6887220144,
0.689306438,
0.1003900096,
-0.6769365668,
0.6906784177,
0.0801588967,
0.909494698,
-0.5393558145,
0.0178946927,
-0.2558754683,
0.5591745973,
-0.1693482995,
-0.269167304,
-0.1965346783,
-0.1468378603,
-0.1285455972,
0.1404324323,
0.6758902669,
-0.663369596,
-0.503462255,
0.2604129612,
0.6029507518,
-0.0008260261,
-0.2752380073,
-0.607676208,
0.3121547103,
-0.1959542781,
-0.1221117377,
0.7287557125,
0.4666977227,
0.1294876933,
0.9055284858,
0.6879246235,
0.3309980631,
0.4041447937,
0.0393092372,
1.2673350573,
-0.2672016323,
-0.6166439056,
-0.6866919398,
0.0428224429,
0.1327672452,
-0.220399633,
0.6917462945,
0.491260916,
0.7658362389,
-0.1658752412,
0.6484133601,
0.3131703734,
0.1498785913,
-0.6886181235,
0.7091274261,
-0.631277144,
0.3028042018,
-0.2359823883,
-0.9936363101,
-0.0391067713,
0.456066072,
-0.1689391285,
0.2064837068,
0.1976990253,
0.6032733917,
-0.6023439169,
-0.0676214844,
0.3557355702,
0.1802964807,
0.2194791883,
0.7726300955,
0.4068262875,
-0.250638932,
0.2260905057,
-0.2247595191,
-0.0155462148,
-0.4503572285,
-0.7419168353,
-1.0789049864,
-0.1018230841,
-0.3711301386,
-0.0375287496,
0.1178455651,
1.0611196756,
0.988907814,
-0.9110191464,
-0.3687427938,
0.0388168134,
0.0222095493,
-0.2061304301,
-0.1611181498,
0.3048897684,
-0.3729039133,
-0.6984719634,
0.6542981267,
0.0519195683,
-0.0245073512,
-0.5673246384,
-0.2742024958,
-0.1211669445,
0.1300115287,
0.6204452515,
0.2305442691,
-0.7536967397,
0.113841109,
-0.5061578751,
0.1216311976,
0.104512915,
0.679140985,
-0.7921033502,
0.3149106503,
0.4636477232,
0.8024888039,
0.3885861635,
0.0637662783,
0.6017893553,
-0.4911018908,
0.3398393691,
-0.0498953052,
0.7018622756,
0.1914465427,
-0.3113067746,
0.2315344959,
0.0819041133,
-0.3731389046,
-0.7546947598,
-0.0645670891,
-1.3260005713,
-0.3730820715,
0.9925895333,
-0.1975522339,
-0.219355166,
-0.1560761929,
-0.4098472595,
-0.0798259228,
-0.5715213418,
0.7022756338,
0.3884495199,
0.0175801143,
-0.2220300883,
-0.6717397571,
0.141289711,
0.5780530572,
-1.0019571781,
0.1144313514,
0.4939864576,
0.3808614612,
0.0015097889,
0.5906770825,
0.3608357012,
0.0576991364,
-0.1136427,
-0.0626452118,
-0.2779752314,
-0.4933026135,
-0.1245737895,
0.4231419861,
0.1499040574,
0.1482903808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13813v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13813v1
|
From LLM to NMT: Advancing Low-Resource Machine Translation with Claude
| 2024-04-22T01:22:23 | 2024-04-22T01:22:23 |
Maxim Enis, Mark Hopkins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We show that Claude 3 Opus, a large language model (LLM) released by
Anthropic in March 2024, exhibits stronger machine translation competence than
other LLMs. Though we find evidence of data contamination with Claude on
FLORES-200, we curate new benchmarks that corroborate the effectiveness of
Claude for low-resource machine translation into English. We find that Claude
has remarkable \textit{resource efficiency} -- the degree to which the quality
of the translation model depends on a language pair's resource level. Finally,
we show that advancements in LLM translation can be compressed into traditional
neural machine translation (NMT) models. Using Claude to generate synthetic
data, we demonstrate that knowledge distillation advances the state-of-the-art
in Yoruba-English translation, meeting or surpassing strong baselines like
NLLB-54B and Google Translate.
|
[
-0.3206828833,
-0.8405503035,
0.9877339602,
-0.0583918989,
-0.1658869982,
0.1501203924,
-0.4706317484,
-0.6458335519,
0.3196530342,
0.6836470962,
-0.5222184062,
-0.1822208464,
-1.0965943336,
0.4208362103,
-0.4722497761,
0.688442111,
-0.0198919419,
0.1821489036,
-0.2164890915,
-0.293482691,
-0.2667201757,
-0.3907272518,
-0.7003802061,
-0.6506636143,
0.9026908278,
0.2977297008,
0.5963542461,
0.9900839925,
0.4997987151,
0.3898673058,
-0.1947329938,
0.4504229724,
-0.4537232518,
0.2670025229,
-0.0793599486,
-0.4709443748,
-1.0349195004,
0.0859418139,
0.501224041,
0.7407470345,
0.1837393194,
0.0665260553,
0.1056926399,
1.0471957922,
-0.4002464116,
0.1134867221,
-0.7794196606,
-0.1611839384,
-0.2409518808,
-0.2644376755,
-0.4939603806,
-0.3251007497,
-0.0044021606,
-0.6671660542,
-0.262521714,
-0.0030283905,
0.7358878255,
0.6676079631,
-0.6647344828,
-0.1210648343,
-0.6144833565,
1.1260535717,
-0.5666621327,
0.3655969203,
0.6052085757,
0.3172948956,
-0.0918653384,
-1.0437691212,
-0.5146945715,
-0.0952052698,
0.2083170563,
0.0185178015,
-0.4211004376,
-0.2498110831,
0.2674451768,
0.4854862392,
-0.1148847044,
0.1426998228,
-0.7687861919,
-0.1126047671,
0.5564799309,
0.0295203552,
0.045084808,
-0.2264733016,
-0.3929594755,
-0.1744042933,
-0.6112989783,
-0.4697990716,
0.2382048815,
0.2297675908,
0.0257142819,
0.581455946,
-0.191534102,
0.8488847613,
-0.2710675597,
-0.0142301861,
0.1384151727,
-0.2100330293,
-0.2570050955,
0.0209871568,
1.0577600002,
0.3171426654,
0.1677850038,
-0.0891790688,
-0.1826986074,
-0.19184196,
0.3779149652,
-0.8933830857,
-0.24456352,
0.0610088669,
-0.3423597813,
-0.4456587434,
-0.2078263313,
-0.5127645135,
-0.6538197398,
-0.452085644,
0.2646984756,
-0.6034314036,
-0.1429093182,
-0.0399105661,
0.0655514523,
0.1146231741,
0.5717151761,
-0.7735651135,
0.1403018534,
0.5703599453,
0.9464339614,
-0.3150901794,
-0.2073227614,
-0.6190237403,
-0.2081029117,
-0.4301946759,
0.4399925768,
-0.0786492974,
-0.1772881299,
-0.2610738277,
0.1153474897,
0.2383604795,
-0.5345388651,
0.4986854196,
-0.8448737264,
0.145006299,
-0.5152564049,
-0.3384327292,
-0.6145123839,
0.4055829644,
-0.7492371202,
0.9605993629,
0.391712606,
-0.496973753,
0.1319258362,
-0.7611105442,
-0.3756402433,
-0.0753774866,
0.3547048569,
-0.3040349185,
0.2762551308,
0.2254478782,
0.4049308598,
-0.7112428546,
0.048654329,
-0.3935326338,
-0.0414523482,
0.468385756,
-0.6066441536,
1.1199516058,
0.6040093303,
0.0993605703,
-0.2891908586,
-0.7823112011,
0.0671677068,
0.1445659697,
-0.5704980493,
-0.254252106,
-0.1401932091,
-0.0814993307,
0.2309288979,
0.5239328146,
-0.3871833086,
0.4270826876,
-0.0226707552,
0.9725770354,
0.5780566335,
0.0603627637,
0.6119170189,
-0.2257078588,
0.4461840987,
-0.2171241641,
-0.0052710427,
-0.0831547379,
-0.6562173367,
-0.9299861789,
-0.1526589692,
0.5949255228,
0.6450921893,
-0.9501482248,
0.2483494729,
-0.4842809141,
-0.4530525506,
-0.8573018909,
0.3843846619,
0.1094470546,
0.6338639855,
0.7388401031,
-0.3317557573,
-0.5168520212,
-1.0468189716,
-0.0013650692,
-0.0201212782,
-0.102539219,
0.140117377,
0.2721497715,
-0.5086962581,
0.4679038227,
-0.450504601,
-0.0597597472,
-0.3923870027,
0.1103130281,
0.3666205704,
0.4163122177,
0.5749918222,
-0.5971999764,
-0.5216059089,
0.4064418077,
-0.893597126,
-0.1481254697,
0.4306295514,
-0.3589906693,
0.2955696285,
0.5191716552,
-0.1223936006,
-0.1475877613,
0.7065401673,
0.0007864273,
-0.0077435956,
-0.4118116498,
0.2946958542,
-1.4576917887,
-0.0166668501,
-0.2521564662,
-0.766310513,
-0.6117499471,
-0.0544817261,
0.2669064999,
-0.0559175089,
-0.6680200696,
0.1313630939,
-0.3672962487,
-0.0219974611,
-0.388816148,
0.3595456183,
0.0405509882,
0.205069527,
-0.1112450138,
0.6781592369,
0.369813472,
-0.6889603138,
0.699303925,
0.1160593927,
-0.1464770883,
0.6206434369,
-0.5103552341,
0.3309276104,
0.2481592298,
-0.0796377137,
-0.4575430453,
-0.2216463536,
0.0227421466,
-0.4944016039,
0.4629499912,
-0.2463917583,
-0.5362609029,
-0.254188031,
-0.1331847608,
0.120329462,
0.8681209683,
-0.3496792614,
0.3524375558,
0.4261409938,
-0.1538131237,
-0.4256253541,
-1.1365846395,
0.4019052386,
-0.3312468231,
-0.6684546471,
0.1118598804,
0.0123064611,
-0.34017995,
-0.0205037668,
0.0048434297,
-0.2854188979,
0.2232424617,
-0.4106163383,
0.2959263325,
-0.2902804911,
-0.1250469387,
-0.1000659615,
-0.2725837529,
0.1631786227,
-0.8992747068,
0.4746318758,
-0.2997563481,
0.1436515749,
-0.3231876791,
-0.1854045689,
0.7156217694,
-0.0238923263,
0.735799849,
0.6268969178,
-0.2654300928,
0.0057373629,
-0.4534020424,
-0.2731648088,
-0.4466197491,
0.3849735558,
-0.2411942184,
-0.6558523178,
0.331533879,
-0.4046370685,
-0.1202346757,
0.5796050429,
0.593434453,
-0.2959889472,
0.5763297081,
0.7502705455,
0.0723247454,
0.4542635381,
-0.7530388832,
-0.11538288,
-1.079577446,
-0.0015420601,
-0.2428238243,
-0.6413868666,
-0.9965256453,
-0.6951370835,
0.4576934576,
0.1589190662,
0.103299737,
1.0467562675,
-0.3789354861,
0.4955966473,
0.7527997494,
0.1637030691,
0.5801199675,
-0.0143811731,
0.0229935534,
-0.2948095202,
-0.7770401835,
-0.5521088243,
1.3170329332,
0.136991784,
0.3275277913,
0.1759514064,
0.7371049523,
0.4270582199,
0.3918451667,
-0.6652147174,
0.4767220914,
-0.1879921108,
-0.5971364975,
-0.3151298761,
-0.6941336989,
-0.8101328611,
0.2907234132,
-0.3773449957,
-0.446775198,
0.0811013281,
0.1071911827,
0.0058296816,
0.4184218943,
-0.576343596,
0.9751160145,
-0.4258959889,
-0.792658627,
-0.2818768919,
-0.611403048,
0.408880204,
-0.47669366,
0.2949983478,
-0.2006976157,
-0.3050822914,
0.360255897,
-0.5983868241,
0.3078889549,
-0.0423932709,
-0.2630819976,
0.2992618382,
0.3332147002,
0.5962045193,
0.0429839417,
-0.3913645744,
0.3144240379,
-0.3354094625,
-0.5778924823,
-0.5795776844,
0.7871044278,
-0.7114959359,
-0.3116796911,
-0.3001289368,
-0.6477093697,
-0.0765914619,
0.3817434907,
0.4993931949,
0.1476784199,
-0.0438740663,
0.4753732383,
0.8074364662,
-0.2220198959,
0.4350667596,
0.5914297104,
-0.1127335876,
-0.7231423259,
1.0410151482,
0.1957696825,
0.498565942,
0.5461006761,
0.2121040225,
-0.3621652126,
-0.4940932393,
-0.6879625916,
0.080580771,
-0.5278063416,
-0.4302991927,
-0.6778291464,
-0.0121784303,
-0.0808280855,
-0.2709488571,
-0.7346513271,
-0.8954720497,
0.029572973,
-0.0086131021,
0.5254799724,
0.9251324534,
-0.2426175922,
0.3393219709,
-0.7517963648,
0.177119568,
0.3584443927,
-0.1587643474,
-0.4000863433,
-0.7091676593,
-0.3679356575,
0.0789169148,
-0.6593661904,
-0.922295332,
0.5050436854,
-0.076883547,
0.1284832358,
0.2693972588,
0.0843038782,
0.4480650127,
-0.481238097,
0.63097471,
0.3164622784,
-0.9345271587,
0.5848484635,
-0.5774591565,
0.1208362356,
0.4790875912,
0.2752067745,
-0.4673790336,
-0.3713628948,
-0.574657917,
-0.9310837388,
0.8410981297,
0.3316696882,
-0.0841898099,
0.2204150707,
0.1573317796,
-0.0069712126,
0.3712404072,
-0.9599903822,
-0.1434280872,
-0.1179915518,
0.0230498314,
-0.1670916378,
-0.128783673,
0.0563723631,
-0.3414137959,
0.9642775059,
0.0402780697,
0.0049416032,
0.101917699,
-0.3398702741,
0.0585988313,
0.3940040767,
0.591024816,
0.4894070029,
-0.1567294598,
0.2680004239,
0.7067495584,
-0.2921544015,
0.3382996917,
0.1170882955,
-0.2796575427,
-0.2987028658,
0.5771969557,
0.6428407431,
0.1250678003,
-0.1132651269,
0.2520513535,
0.1734485626,
-0.3912380636,
-0.2058926225,
0.0775942579,
0.3294181526,
0.1944786161,
-0.0093530696,
0.2323013842,
0.0413737334,
-0.4976902902,
0.0317574777,
-0.0249491576,
-0.5603058934,
-0.3047204018,
1.1463732719,
0.4454862475,
-0.1277213842,
0.6916189194,
-0.4964534044,
-0.3471695781,
0.2851459682,
0.2323113233,
0.9154382348,
-0.1443257183,
-0.1884795427,
0.4363495708,
0.6584086418,
-0.1304282993,
0.173326239,
-0.183567971,
-0.531568706,
-0.661675036,
-0.7209935188,
-0.4349266887,
0.2159567177,
-0.6572062373,
0.3335968852,
-0.0814975798,
-0.3411405981,
-0.0400673226,
0.2569652498,
-0.5805187225,
-0.3304999769,
-0.0531882197,
0.7845872045,
-0.5718070269,
1.2522265911,
0.8089091182,
-0.4151526988,
-0.2948393524,
-0.1404108107,
0.1395072937,
-0.8519988656,
0.7860766053,
-0.1169461757,
-0.1181748882,
0.2731686234,
-0.3391177654,
-0.5604826212,
1.4028234482,
0.8558418751,
-0.6635273695,
0.3380413353,
0.1144590825,
0.5318334699,
-0.0670139492,
-0.1031515226,
0.6044549942,
0.8667938709,
-0.0608399771,
-0.7518373132,
-0.2449678332,
-0.1029435396,
0.14024055,
0.2410459369,
-0.575843811,
0.8287366033,
-0.2890051603,
-0.0129096713,
-0.0729813725,
0.6371333003,
-0.0649187714,
0.1579484493,
0.2756437361,
0.7041202188,
0.8255059719,
-0.4044730365,
1.3023239374,
-0.5025572181,
0.1918795109,
0.8490956426,
-0.0571375191,
0.7923628688,
0.5092720985,
-0.3594791889,
0.4210769832,
0.5014694929,
0.171683073,
0.397628963,
0.1252044886,
-0.2727669477,
-0.4297684133,
-0.0442642644,
-0.2756679952,
0.4443961382,
0.3067469597,
-0.3927159905,
0.0518565811,
-0.0526199788,
0.2369598448,
0.2903550565,
-0.1321600229,
0.8493978977,
0.4551958144,
-0.6453803182,
0.9355479479,
0.2271530479,
0.5339679122,
-0.5006159544,
0.0913962945,
-0.2833585739,
0.3406586349,
0.0674813464,
-0.5597076416,
0.3883924782,
0.1594154686,
-0.3634218276,
-0.7769357562,
0.5779137015,
-0.5810629129,
-0.4868027568,
0.5170899034,
0.8223555088,
0.3719051778,
-0.0061982786,
-0.4554777145,
0.1431795508,
-0.0266950689,
-0.1452198774,
0.071077764,
0.8951262832,
0.2321967632,
0.5343268514,
0.5849430561,
0.460491091,
-0.0780398324,
-0.3050948381,
0.7405279875,
-0.5371135473,
-0.2097594589,
-1.1016508341,
0.3348395526,
-0.2831351161,
0.000006129,
0.6721262336,
0.6903550625,
0.7517210841,
-0.1012395024,
0.7617393136,
-0.1434526592,
0.1767258048,
-0.6789826751,
0.8144776225,
-0.7561332583,
0.3655125797,
-0.020758884,
-1.172571063,
-0.0161872134,
0.5717933178,
-0.1843365133,
-0.2352986932,
0.9555945396,
0.4322449267,
-0.3097654879,
-0.2988094687,
0.4610750079,
0.4765547216,
0.1901540905,
0.7264790535,
0.7693563104,
-0.7054871321,
0.6938537359,
-0.2546747327,
-0.2069237381,
-0.1464416683,
-1.1384297609,
-0.7579555511,
-0.6053770185,
-0.2054699361,
-0.4659736753,
-0.0055308859,
0.9532217979,
0.7317246795,
-0.6706224084,
-0.1922513247,
-0.3141683042,
0.1977241933,
-0.3489731252,
-0.1493871659,
0.0112085994,
-0.381210953,
-1.1931407452,
0.8914894462,
0.3882353008,
0.2099370509,
-0.3393721879,
-0.3790744841,
0.0805019885,
-0.0938156173,
0.7913501859,
0.130344063,
-0.5336071253,
0.0639967099,
0.2110407799,
-0.2279647291,
0.098174125,
0.6797069907,
-0.679741919,
0.4964186251,
0.5658569932,
0.755756855,
0.8251951337,
-0.2219682336,
0.9253145456,
-0.8012924194,
0.3728696406,
0.1408839226,
0.516749084,
0.5841108561,
-0.0077306191,
0.8497938514,
0.5335425138,
-0.6072464585,
-0.7946940064,
0.3383144736,
-0.9708769917,
-0.0668589175,
1.0912483931,
0.0663016811,
-0.3286158741,
0.0478800721,
0.0088946549,
0.3407000899,
-0.318261981,
0.7315539718,
0.8264575005,
0.0259763841,
-0.0389958471,
-1.2215377092,
0.4764467776,
0.0599647388,
-0.83900249,
0.1358284205,
0.3933688104,
0.1119832769,
0.2942434251,
0.6159517765,
-0.3242546618,
0.0692480877,
-0.121103473,
0.0479081683,
-0.5069004893,
-0.1924495548,
-0.112536706,
-0.3176980913,
0.2397253662,
-0.1138230711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15157v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15157v1
|
FASTTRACK: Fast and Accurate Fact Tracing for LLMs
| 2024-04-22T00:07:55 | 2024-04-22T00:07:55 |
Si Chen, Feiyang Kang, Ning Yu, Ruoxi Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fact tracing seeks to identify specific training examples that serve as the
knowledge source for a given query. Existing approaches to fact tracing rely on
assessing the similarity between each training sample and the query along a
certain dimension, such as lexical similarity, gradient, or embedding space.
However, these methods fall short of effectively distinguishing between samples
that are merely relevant and those that actually provide supportive evidence
for the information sought by the query. This limitation often results in
suboptimal effectiveness. Moreover, these approaches necessitate the
examination of the similarity of individual training points for each query,
imposing significant computational demands and creating a substantial barrier
for practical applications. This paper introduces FASTTRACK, a novel approach
that harnesses the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to validate
supportive evidence for queries and at the same time clusters the training
database towards a reduced extent for LLMs to trace facts. Our experiments show
that FASTTRACK substantially outperforms existing methods in both accuracy and
efficiency, achieving more than 100\% improvement in F1 score over the
state-of-the-art methods while being X33 faster than \texttt{TracIn}.
|
[
-0.2576015592,
-0.783397615,
0.8057767749,
-0.0599649437,
-0.386851728,
0.4700099826,
-0.1474010497,
-0.3279783428,
0.3251024783,
0.4087239206,
-0.5513829589,
-0.8266381025,
-0.5979056358,
-0.2333279699,
-0.8319826126,
0.796705246,
-0.0437069722,
-0.1158758029,
-0.321221143,
-0.5427237153,
-0.1934326291,
-0.4515956342,
-0.665194571,
0.0027497513,
0.6748920679,
0.5328073502,
0.4570967555,
0.9320083261,
0.481446296,
0.2944635153,
0.1169151887,
0.2194422781,
-0.6090032458,
0.2999962568,
-0.1326523274,
-0.6895353198,
-0.238925159,
-0.0327058285,
0.6942524314,
0.3093179166,
-0.1962731779,
0.537715435,
-0.2068104744,
0.6148573756,
-0.8465263844,
0.1023775563,
-0.6640504003,
-0.1835677326,
-0.5930332541,
-0.3427641988,
-0.4484737217,
-0.813087821,
0.1383301169,
-0.5436463356,
0.6111938953,
0.1630347371,
0.6862747073,
0.1343755573,
-0.5745208859,
-0.5164991617,
-0.501921773,
0.5524195433,
-0.4608914554,
0.5359162092,
0.187185958,
0.5272001624,
0.0066434233,
-0.8504987359,
-0.4802978635,
-0.2851704061,
-0.241900593,
-0.3888193369,
0.2101394534,
-0.2623339891,
0.5117624998,
0.1670711786,
-0.4929740429,
0.1393325031,
-0.0309809372,
-0.6701922417,
0.518678546,
0.338860333,
0.0416370369,
0.1353577673,
-0.6344152093,
-0.1513760984,
-0.9392374158,
0.0853103399,
0.0664227977,
0.3799558282,
0.0342057571,
0.3097843826,
-0.4345522523,
0.7008455992,
-0.2486020178,
-0.5298086405,
0.1123817191,
-0.5116749406,
0.1255098432,
0.1257494986,
0.6991349459,
0.2532472014,
0.0577539951,
-0.0953301713,
0.0124736251,
-0.0303415731,
-0.2425322235,
-1.0295476913,
-0.0258546751,
-0.0039403583,
-0.1621529609,
-0.0039676442,
-0.1569662988,
-0.981857419,
-0.7988930345,
-0.1533098966,
0.2945749164,
-0.3327125609,
-0.1525970846,
-0.1043323204,
0.1186029837,
0.5199145079,
0.6048004031,
-0.6511309147,
0.0388689153,
0.8747965097,
1.1464022398,
-0.1646522284,
-0.1560650617,
-1.0325988531,
0.004191095,
-0.241408661,
0.9651858211,
-0.3679915667,
0.0822266862,
-0.0134775825,
-0.0844200179,
-0.0069043608,
-0.3991032541,
0.5596135855,
-0.6432294846,
-0.2113592327,
-0.4764386714,
-0.7840189338,
-0.293770045,
0.4015451968,
-0.8454381227,
0.9464886785,
-0.0047225072,
-0.7782139778,
0.388691783,
-0.3162049949,
-0.5879811645,
-0.0721864849,
-0.1582231969,
-0.379634738,
0.0212741215,
0.1057243049,
0.5568070412,
-0.4548249841,
0.1747330874,
-0.5113980174,
-0.5053483248,
0.2528656423,
0.0628095791,
0.8355849385,
0.0354291536,
-0.5776442885,
0.1646880507,
-1.16839993,
-0.0086204885,
0.0884954557,
-0.4278491735,
-0.783562839,
0.0036768089,
-0.327906549,
0.2848465145,
-0.1480465978,
-0.6553652287,
0.0747089908,
-0.0609833598,
0.2692729533,
0.7131565809,
-0.2248428762,
0.1914772391,
0.0057468857,
0.4952290952,
-0.2877011895,
-0.0727962479,
-0.2035332471,
-0.3034330904,
-0.9167135954,
-0.6665254831,
0.6758726835,
0.4582071006,
-0.718767643,
0.1327635497,
-0.4923523366,
-0.5918191671,
-0.5437195301,
0.0728274807,
0.2182630301,
0.7026760578,
0.1669148654,
-0.2909646034,
-0.550753653,
-0.6681989431,
-0.6489855647,
-0.0508624613,
-0.0392928608,
-0.1133959517,
0.484267205,
0.0532874353,
0.8592165709,
-0.5150387287,
-0.2518575788,
0.0039553749,
0.1310275197,
-0.1944845468,
0.1680236906,
0.551490128,
-0.3438078761,
-0.5291647315,
-0.2827593684,
-0.5367105603,
0.1777220219,
-0.0708655268,
-0.3352362514,
0.154704541,
0.6471687555,
-0.7882528901,
0.3583438396,
0.3409153223,
-0.6674394608,
0.2371722013,
0.2044562697,
0.2566172779,
-0.6249834299,
0.2810515463,
-0.0507146083,
-0.5636669993,
-0.3779390156,
0.1400203258,
0.1867624372,
0.0720312148,
-0.5170232654,
0.6353802085,
-0.2917821705,
-0.1362185627,
-0.0880900919,
0.2577193975,
-0.009709172,
0.3083033562,
-0.0736632869,
0.790245235,
0.5198039412,
-0.4713428915,
0.5941881537,
0.1664115489,
-0.9173543453,
0.4023706019,
-0.1314812452,
0.3024321496,
0.0514871068,
0.4544551373,
-1.1470295191,
0.1268533021,
-0.13427037,
-0.2184654474,
0.0611556098,
-0.1576998979,
-0.6336075664,
-0.0835477784,
-0.5384830236,
0.1563669294,
0.4889547229,
-0.661841929,
0.5657513142,
0.3562308848,
-0.0285136178,
-0.6835566759,
-0.4486109912,
-0.1782875359,
-0.2678123116,
-0.5329854488,
-0.019094497,
0.1891011596,
-0.2153006792,
-0.2504618764,
-0.3371424675,
-0.1883472353,
0.3592664599,
-0.0363294333,
0.0646949708,
-0.3903272152,
0.0934213102,
-0.4341846704,
-0.14347969,
0.2205633521,
0.060707286,
0.2558327615,
0.1645984501,
-0.3158172369,
-0.2478902936,
0.3599181473,
0.9001694322,
-0.4233286083,
0.8105102181,
0.7748996615,
-0.1742229909,
-0.5359310508,
-0.8000882864,
-0.4632954001,
-0.4509600699,
0.3042919338,
-0.2332343012,
-1.1023812294,
0.6045976877,
-0.1796170026,
0.1360913068,
0.3227052391,
0.5425118208,
0.00803544,
0.8642751575,
0.6233643293,
0.0358155407,
0.4318556488,
-0.1757590771,
0.2676424682,
-0.3654976487,
-0.4028027356,
-0.7649735808,
-0.2072062939,
-0.5574766994,
-0.5859270692,
0.1837810874,
-0.3703644574,
-0.0907969624,
0.0061219172,
-0.0019573523,
0.5312888622,
0.6803916693,
0.0171210133,
0.5310990214,
0.1476210207,
-0.2203909457,
-0.0163121261,
-0.8310425282,
-0.140993163,
1.2129098177,
0.2318836451,
0.7161702514,
-0.074423708,
0.5174363256,
0.2408078313,
0.5907894373,
-0.7994586229,
0.8367140293,
-0.0899252445,
-0.9148519635,
-0.2143822908,
-0.4784743786,
-0.3825917542,
0.4471285045,
-0.3510995507,
-0.3200486898,
0.0278163161,
0.2776646018,
-0.5405640006,
0.4155872166,
-0.6952050328,
0.7749763131,
-0.259517014,
-0.7411029935,
-0.2756716907,
-0.6506748796,
0.72028023,
-0.165429607,
0.2883875072,
-0.4962513447,
-0.010373787,
1.0442917347,
-0.5828467011,
0.7794074416,
-0.3684901297,
-0.0256138761,
0.6178136468,
0.2487478852,
0.7617666721,
-0.0687560514,
0.0536248907,
0.0483806804,
-0.0010017066,
-0.2425643653,
-0.7900320292,
0.8553386331,
-0.2581110597,
-0.4918285906,
-0.5917938352,
-0.4300311506,
-0.4363098145,
0.1377292275,
-0.1487198621,
0.4458350241,
-0.0792815909,
0.2683972716,
0.7958264947,
0.0340677015,
0.2529887855,
1.0675063133,
-0.0049634208,
-0.0538975596,
0.8887216449,
0.1557998657,
-0.0645623058,
0.4742756486,
0.1254490167,
-0.7037142515,
-0.6655836105,
-0.2653825581,
0.4824574292,
-0.9085980058,
-0.4376282096,
-0.5028990507,
0.1833618581,
-0.1545686275,
0.196931541,
-0.6075025201,
-0.6137609482,
0.1813882589,
-0.3026803732,
0.6288712025,
0.4238875806,
0.1889055222,
0.2252956629,
-0.8291874528,
0.221078217,
0.4959485829,
0.6616824865,
-0.0402896591,
-0.3362975419,
-0.5616739988,
-0.3249196708,
-0.1543379277,
-0.6610800624,
-0.0322677419,
0.0744004473,
0.5213344693,
0.2628874779,
0.21603778,
0.8272104263,
-0.5432755351,
0.5975433588,
0.0675353855,
-1.0699372292,
0.5450224876,
0.0479552709,
0.0734110549,
0.8402965069,
0.5776867867,
-0.184839204,
-0.3904981017,
-0.461319685,
-0.7726988792,
0.547908783,
-0.0104439752,
-0.6021700501,
0.322819829,
0.4618002474,
0.0919653624,
0.1318793297,
-0.2807569504,
-0.2472248971,
0.0566921346,
-0.3320029378,
-0.3040480912,
-0.3468801379,
-0.2671854198,
-0.3193854988,
0.5299070477,
-0.3720956147,
0.1830613762,
0.0800829455,
-0.3708779812,
0.1481580287,
0.1822695136,
0.7463002801,
0.9356686473,
-0.2394387871,
0.5125839114,
0.1473299563,
-0.4567629099,
0.397872448,
0.1043260098,
-0.171090126,
0.3357431889,
0.681392312,
0.5851028562,
0.132836476,
-0.8007547855,
0.6062426567,
-0.0908846036,
-0.066594772,
0.1866155416,
0.0776483491,
0.2550503612,
0.2002571374,
0.1320519,
-0.1460100114,
0.1937353611,
-0.4379264712,
0.3951110244,
0.4241957366,
-0.1456850618,
-0.4072447419,
0.3895987868,
0.4946855307,
-0.0233000852,
0.6156659126,
0.0922428444,
-0.438421905,
0.5978702307,
0.2375813127,
0.7338478565,
-0.3659871221,
0.0783649459,
0.5307973623,
0.2689225078,
-0.1918258369,
0.1600473374,
-0.1448730379,
-0.4017367661,
-0.764819324,
-0.5913590789,
-0.4462622702,
0.1004882082,
-0.5985888839,
0.20744811,
-0.5270367265,
-0.0204283129,
0.0215533953,
0.0862557143,
-0.8500527143,
0.1222753897,
0.2129924595,
1.233859539,
-0.9704477191,
1.1768687963,
0.5387898088,
0.0636253804,
-0.8472903967,
-0.1753133386,
0.2968155444,
-0.9896409512,
0.6166687012,
0.1264359504,
-0.386295855,
-0.0964177921,
-0.4444188476,
-0.9222243428,
1.2526509762,
0.7084085941,
-0.7814783454,
-0.0041464497,
0.0803346261,
0.3009042144,
-0.4037911594,
0.3272648752,
0.9658922553,
0.3598027229,
0.1595494002,
-0.6082298756,
0.5482103229,
0.223564446,
-0.3227814138,
0.1712649316,
-0.735386014,
0.7105576992,
-0.302361846,
-0.3342864215,
-0.2280316055,
0.6823941469,
0.2710478902,
0.39168033,
0.6830621958,
0.422642529,
0.9251775146,
-0.1392847449,
0.8861157894,
-0.1552259028,
0.4938726127,
1.1308819056,
-0.3602309525,
0.7961663604,
0.4681713581,
-0.0204126444,
0.6440137029,
0.4267833233,
0.2729418576,
0.5903198719,
0.1763636023,
-0.0872975886,
-0.4203962088,
0.0375865959,
-0.1949844062,
0.4742610455,
0.3854247928,
-0.1359687448,
-0.5245323777,
-0.1873958856,
0.1810605526,
-0.1433778256,
-0.2278757393,
0.5253863335,
-0.0901317075,
-0.7063533664,
0.8303972483,
-0.1187542602,
0.5105550289,
-0.9310784936,
-0.1352472156,
-0.5555565357,
0.3734047413,
-0.1532031447,
-0.5683303475,
0.2923227847,
0.1207085699,
0.1757638007,
-0.200951606,
0.6061332822,
-0.417450279,
-0.2102415711,
0.177580595,
0.5311219096,
-0.1418429166,
-0.0159350373,
-0.6003488898,
0.3653730452,
0.0549176857,
-0.2756146789,
0.3086876273,
0.4327685833,
-0.1224063188,
0.8178150654,
0.5048241615,
-0.0177254621,
0.3404721618,
-0.1618011892,
0.6951009631,
-0.9543846846,
-0.7472444773,
-1.010563612,
0.4774534404,
-0.0654810742,
-0.1804872453,
1.0486975908,
0.6837322712,
0.6755219102,
0.0003898862,
0.6251121759,
0.0483998097,
0.9632795453,
-0.7601847053,
0.6273292899,
-0.367834419,
0.2815362811,
0.1441774219,
-0.6561381817,
-0.3926932216,
0.4501209557,
0.0051147719,
-0.3941049576,
1.1278948784,
0.7954063416,
-0.1814093888,
0.0363750421,
0.0432895124,
0.3813381195,
0.451664269,
0.4992154539,
1.0930999517,
-0.253691107,
0.6899481416,
-0.2127749622,
-0.2505901158,
-0.5420928597,
-1.0072492361,
-0.9164277911,
-0.3991715014,
-0.6287176609,
-0.4029658437,
0.0403403938,
0.5941219926,
0.9086791277,
-0.8770901561,
-0.2462703735,
0.1649264842,
0.4424176514,
-0.1947982162,
-0.1889168024,
0.6087517142,
-0.1218395904,
-0.2491119653,
0.3692568839,
-0.0472348668,
-0.0415658839,
-0.3632311523,
0.2495485246,
-0.3807589412,
0.1019181982,
0.7185280323,
0.3515022993,
-0.5207704306,
-0.5006191134,
-0.0403483473,
-0.1725226343,
0.0315209702,
1.4954297543,
-1.0172857046,
0.2691961825,
0.7563832402,
0.7147395015,
0.8371952176,
-0.1462921202,
0.2443346381,
-0.7912677526,
0.3023747802,
0.1208927184,
0.1736377329,
0.5175939202,
-0.1508622319,
0.410405606,
0.4988225996,
-0.2288079858,
-0.9490147829,
0.1363045424,
-0.9024599195,
-0.0755267367,
0.99150002,
-0.3959403634,
-0.347797066,
0.0111256307,
0.1877398491,
0.1092301682,
-0.2074132711,
0.6112105846,
0.6249309778,
-0.0807524174,
0.0080817277,
-0.6661500931,
0.7316935062,
0.2303527743,
-0.7806065679,
0.3383677006,
0.4183977246,
0.8272144198,
0.061118681,
0.8355595469,
0.1665839255,
0.1302520335,
-0.0715517104,
-0.1336165518,
-0.1025409326,
-0.390389502,
-0.176572904,
0.6219652891,
0.0700327829,
-0.4340291917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13793v1
|
Lightweight Connective Detection Using Gradient Boosting
| 2024-04-21T23:14:02 | 2024-04-21T23:14:02 |
Mustafa Erolcan Er, Murathan Kurfalı, Deniz Zeyrek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
In this work, we introduce a lightweight discourse connective detection
system. Employing gradient boosting trained on straightforward, low-complexity
features, this proposed approach sidesteps the computational demands of the
current approaches that rely on deep neural networks. Considering its
simplicity, our approach achieves competitive results while offering
significant gains in terms of time even on CPU. Furthermore, the stable
performance across two unrelated languages suggests the robustness of our
system in the multilingual scenario. The model is designed to support the
annotation of discourse relations, particularly in scenarios with limited
resources, while minimizing performance loss.
|
[
-0.3963998258,
-0.6308969855,
0.2114075273,
0.3013505042,
-0.4390757978,
0.0652977154,
-0.2747979164,
-0.693696022,
0.5926419497,
0.0307070129,
-0.4069856405,
-0.051864583,
-0.4014686644,
-0.0912272036,
-0.1238785684,
1.0905543566,
0.3542326987,
0.1433079243,
-0.0796286464,
-0.6635654569,
-0.3249618411,
-0.0608540028,
-0.9700961113,
-0.5644305348,
0.5894640088,
0.4631300867,
0.5667186975,
0.6053051949,
0.3537436426,
0.3445253074,
-0.5054520369,
0.2071870714,
-0.4533294141,
0.304294765,
0.16428864,
-0.4478788376,
-0.4339824915,
-0.2869464755,
0.5536966324,
0.7083427906,
0.2729037404,
0.335124284,
0.3022306561,
0.6929707527,
-0.9494978189,
0.0496301763,
-0.6827402115,
0.0415906198,
-0.4268552363,
-0.1168706045,
-0.3233842254,
-0.1919451058,
-0.1249708831,
-0.3218284547,
0.0651600212,
0.0614252463,
0.6548599601,
0.2322575301,
-0.3918147087,
0.0784946159,
-0.3937293589,
0.5075197816,
-0.5916683674,
0.1012195498,
-0.000158997,
0.2403895706,
0.2250150442,
-0.7574799061,
-0.4466007352,
-0.0404331759,
-0.3773444891,
0.0505140387,
-0.0695746467,
0.1355404109,
0.3363099694,
0.513050437,
-0.3037606776,
0.260581851,
-0.1000945345,
-0.4610988796,
0.1164825484,
0.0722086951,
0.3455346823,
-0.4756291807,
-0.4599847496,
0.4593547881,
-0.7741715908,
0.4312848151,
0.3116878867,
0.6110194921,
-0.1704796106,
0.3162734509,
-0.0783302262,
0.4908049405,
0.1364765614,
-0.2968275547,
0.1840411425,
-0.3462823331,
-0.0671838075,
0.0728813633,
1.011549592,
0.2077792287,
0.1120981872,
0.0362743102,
-0.2649025023,
0.0432754979,
-0.4498715103,
-1.0447369814,
-0.3321218193,
-0.2140222937,
-0.7622628212,
-0.313675046,
-0.47148332,
-0.6427550316,
-0.7278737426,
-0.139325574,
-0.1552626342,
-0.5025832057,
-0.3465403318,
-0.1426618844,
-0.1325026602,
0.2256282717,
0.3205070496,
-0.9592933059,
0.5468125939,
0.5453640223,
1.1876565218,
-0.1378720701,
0.1733648032,
-1.0846550465,
-0.1174682826,
-0.1008338928,
0.8489641547,
-0.2860866785,
-0.0754129365,
0.099199675,
0.164519012,
0.0309835505,
-0.3029138446,
1.079177022,
-0.2538124621,
0.0516742431,
-0.2629637122,
-0.4767141938,
0.0587491058,
0.2447149903,
-0.7042192817,
1.2224919796,
-0.0948788226,
-1.4677824974,
0.3215767145,
-0.2919701934,
-0.6762857437,
0.5478628874,
-0.1622446775,
-0.4463427067,
-0.2313245237,
0.2356326282,
0.4609649777,
-0.3329029679,
0.1455129981,
-0.4887067974,
-0.7709339857,
-0.1909283847,
-0.2622786164,
1.0148910284,
-0.0126416143,
-0.3721926212,
0.0621508323,
-0.9554951191,
-0.2135602385,
-0.0921614841,
-0.4258389175,
-0.5309145451,
-0.0501310416,
0.3714617193,
0.2718992829,
0.2584898472,
-0.8272744417,
-0.0771863088,
-0.4376885891,
0.3694770038,
0.6450703144,
-0.3227488697,
0.5621575713,
-0.1721225977,
0.6700214744,
0.1662939489,
-0.4785901308,
-0.492656976,
-0.6967307925,
-1.1441396475,
-0.5997467041,
0.4589608908,
0.9275627136,
-1.2770133018,
0.4392941296,
-0.2977974713,
-0.2811922729,
-0.466640234,
0.2570470273,
0.5229015946,
0.9198656082,
0.2493117601,
-0.0200305711,
-0.6308752894,
-1.0680195093,
-0.3707149029,
-0.3038150072,
-0.184068203,
0.5427197814,
0.3341064453,
0.1583860368,
0.5541155934,
-0.4252699614,
-0.3520301878,
-0.1094942987,
0.2964475155,
0.0868697837,
0.6589915752,
0.8529940844,
-0.4234324396,
-0.5536535382,
0.2652293742,
-0.725635767,
-0.1775193065,
0.0305245146,
0.2507406771,
-0.0412230529,
0.809263289,
-0.3816370964,
0.1387483478,
0.2935456634,
-0.1001630723,
0.3441669345,
-0.0413714759,
-0.0444796905,
-0.9819908142,
0.3695940375,
0.5087391138,
-0.8467062712,
-0.5510499477,
-0.3454366326,
0.1101568118,
-0.2155250013,
-0.6239485741,
0.3816292584,
-0.4537861645,
0.1396866441,
-0.1143536866,
0.1995562166,
0.0452761054,
0.6009934545,
-0.0104080075,
0.9216039777,
0.5037464499,
-0.258153379,
0.1496077031,
0.0695830658,
-0.2342543304,
0.986548245,
-0.7035239339,
-0.0273981914,
-0.3061452508,
0.3138515651,
-1.3199850321,
0.037674509,
0.298920095,
-0.3053818941,
0.3501002192,
-0.5315358639,
-0.1616316885,
-0.3336085975,
-0.8039719462,
0.6842871308,
0.3876883686,
-0.7361503243,
0.4772072732,
0.5151885748,
-0.3523053527,
-0.7598059177,
-0.7722839117,
0.046914909,
-0.3139251769,
-0.7876967788,
0.3010894656,
0.2506324947,
0.1191950142,
-0.3777833879,
0.2104758024,
-0.3873399198,
0.1842600852,
0.2772040367,
0.2989363968,
-0.5247235298,
0.1923757046,
0.069497861,
-0.1100609377,
-0.0504439101,
-0.1516515762,
0.1080930308,
-0.2733870149,
0.0996739119,
-0.7029627562,
0.3806585968,
0.4515885711,
-0.0074568959,
0.5365800261,
0.9658172727,
-0.4455311298,
-0.2669604421,
-0.3453897536,
-0.2076330632,
-0.5726579428,
-0.0217197053,
-0.3085504472,
-1.2522665262,
0.8324477673,
-0.448106885,
-0.4714260101,
0.3044773638,
0.343056947,
-0.1477884501,
0.8233602047,
0.6187520623,
-0.2998482287,
0.6267666221,
0.1046689153,
0.2159388661,
-1.1056220531,
0.0355168469,
-0.7610769272,
-0.5216798186,
-0.7345572114,
-0.2991445959,
0.1534228623,
0.0629949942,
-0.042430643,
0.2007591277,
-0.7022465467,
0.6116087437,
0.2427955121,
0.1239856556,
0.2322557867,
-0.2776247859,
-0.3617124557,
-0.5320091248,
-0.7743034363,
-0.3778438568,
0.7040349245,
0.3879342377,
0.6631122231,
-0.0748468786,
0.2188743353,
0.255543828,
0.4919230938,
-1.0294282436,
0.6665432453,
-0.2069613039,
-0.1718787104,
0.1253679991,
-0.4870991707,
-0.8726704121,
0.4523123801,
-0.5849134326,
-0.9497116804,
0.4138499796,
0.2615176737,
-0.3010770082,
0.5833750963,
-0.4593123496,
0.6537050009,
0.2529605031,
-0.6867275238,
0.2794776559,
-0.841499567,
0.918738544,
0.5125338435,
0.0029469898,
-0.1252760291,
-0.0952171013,
0.8041129112,
-0.2138487548,
0.9780141711,
-0.1589737535,
-0.0329244398,
0.2792470455,
0.1294349134,
0.2762454748,
0.2276112437,
-0.0559594929,
-0.159363851,
-0.4031817019,
-0.3786230385,
-0.375854969,
0.8915199041,
-0.2087568045,
-0.2839500904,
-0.2531193793,
-0.3590817153,
-0.1067239046,
0.1914235502,
0.0941439494,
0.3227367699,
-0.5527545214,
0.2188753337,
0.5728051662,
0.2757327557,
0.9360489249,
0.1682235897,
-0.1558036655,
-0.4810062945,
1.1137266159,
-0.0346230865,
-0.1799077988,
0.1236284599,
0.0925729796,
-0.2473559529,
-0.4331648052,
-0.7439981699,
0.2784999013,
-0.814730525,
-0.3250824511,
-0.5934758186,
0.0660424381,
-0.0480221659,
-0.1373396367,
-0.4483663738,
-0.8483740687,
-0.4825288355,
0.0314889215,
0.0063056257,
0.4363444746,
0.1476262808,
0.3426718116,
-0.6168848872,
0.300907135,
0.5157752037,
0.2300985456,
0.0276906993,
-0.2439673394,
-0.1957110614,
-0.3948537111,
-0.4446911216,
-0.5002177954,
0.0062622786,
0.4210554659,
0.097709775,
0.7926826477,
0.0392511934,
0.4354472458,
-0.4904320538,
0.8445905447,
0.4655002952,
-1.2092514038,
0.4409468472,
-0.6708369255,
0.3057079315,
0.8938549161,
0.2782769203,
-0.3857733309,
-0.0928490907,
-0.2258370668,
-0.622790277,
0.4860354364,
0.0294680204,
-0.0015036232,
0.0765463114,
0.3781165183,
-0.1494073719,
0.1950811744,
-0.9384532571,
-0.3952912688,
0.0713650733,
-0.035340324,
0.3843812943,
-0.2341678441,
-0.244914636,
-0.5905987024,
0.4887329638,
-0.7637025118,
0.0034140931,
-0.0157194771,
-0.0858782157,
-0.1821094602,
0.1270035803,
0.6068504453,
0.275739193,
0.0040662037,
0.3369095325,
0.257873565,
-0.2599200308,
0.3932768404,
0.2096724361,
-0.3252120912,
0.2842443585,
0.4925912321,
0.7561032772,
0.4058682919,
-0.3761532903,
0.9600585699,
-0.2724245489,
0.0345910937,
0.2387951016,
-0.2456465214,
0.4112737179,
-0.1277317852,
0.1591942459,
0.5664044619,
0.3593757451,
-0.2272729874,
0.2218137234,
0.7374135256,
-0.6171177626,
-0.4133822024,
0.6418170333,
0.7037321925,
-0.4244858921,
0.1095883623,
-0.4698825777,
-0.6949537396,
0.4447111487,
0.5471391082,
0.695708096,
-0.2606287897,
0.3239070475,
0.3148649633,
0.2165181786,
0.0957930014,
0.3165612221,
-0.2428567857,
-0.6629648805,
-0.563236177,
-0.2326720953,
-0.2743493021,
0.0654826611,
-0.5640861988,
0.4067174494,
-0.6260681152,
-0.2038441449,
0.2890536189,
-0.1962401122,
-0.3552184701,
-0.0164439753,
0.2893479764,
0.7934269309,
-1.0794451237,
0.7572619319,
0.5429704785,
0.0094318977,
-0.3926868439,
-0.1703539789,
0.1735559106,
-0.4813998938,
0.8539091945,
0.557307601,
-0.7275156379,
-0.2999812067,
-0.1789965481,
-0.2816804051,
1.0188595057,
0.9380008578,
-0.3206832707,
0.1218711212,
-0.2843421102,
0.576454699,
-0.5445726514,
0.4498467445,
0.5078082085,
0.3090374768,
0.0860468745,
-0.8243017197,
0.3017728329,
-0.4868217707,
0.0206049643,
0.3055398464,
-0.8342471719,
1.1446142197,
0.2671961784,
-0.4846176803,
0.0442249514,
0.7422193885,
-0.1007580012,
0.2950224578,
0.6238946319,
0.7276514769,
1.0181349516,
-0.1179304272,
0.7796049714,
-0.4244199097,
0.3232801557,
1.0455409288,
-0.3122830987,
0.6682113409,
0.4787584543,
-0.0064917575,
0.6806584001,
0.3938546479,
0.3625156283,
0.1182638779,
0.2370972931,
-0.7443053126,
-0.3545410037,
-0.7618254423,
-0.3332751989,
0.398308605,
0.34719643,
-0.181661889,
-0.1945958287,
-0.1236220822,
0.1640486717,
0.1671369076,
-0.4441843629,
0.6862392426,
0.2199290395,
-0.6124408245,
0.742279768,
-0.247723937,
1.1598688364,
-0.2494256347,
-0.0233936571,
-0.0007647085,
0.2550604343,
-0.357770443,
-0.4510672688,
0.1001651138,
-0.2939959764,
0.1058471054,
0.040632505,
1.5368829966,
-0.4799119532,
-0.4776476324,
0.6705988646,
0.9049335122,
-0.3182854354,
0.4923897088,
-0.6807795167,
-0.0394034646,
-0.3292551339,
-0.1119994074,
0.3416287303,
0.5526196957,
0.2326919287,
0.7575314641,
0.5399286151,
0.0636175722,
-0.1959985644,
-0.0797161236,
1.2275004387,
-0.343080759,
-0.8111975193,
-0.8740739822,
0.5528770089,
-0.5427292585,
-0.3940758705,
0.7526441813,
0.5116959214,
0.1690258533,
0.1870851666,
0.5367324352,
0.2860008478,
0.3393958807,
-0.3663390279,
0.6379862428,
-0.3434995711,
0.2943860292,
-0.3700585961,
-0.6598948836,
-0.4030958116,
0.4907955229,
0.1655068398,
-0.2010425478,
0.8216998577,
0.5924540758,
-0.3296807706,
0.1971363425,
0.1818679273,
-0.3294590712,
0.1168643907,
0.5425783992,
0.701059401,
-0.381246388,
0.4712117314,
0.0013259563,
-0.2564715743,
-0.1658911407,
-1.2158149481,
-1.334048748,
-0.1688370854,
-0.3677057326,
-0.4379885495,
-0.3264095783,
0.6055107713,
0.9299711585,
-0.7302794456,
-0.1679714918,
-0.081305176,
0.3776153922,
-0.0254026912,
-0.2558008432,
0.2670257688,
-0.4573518634,
-0.3967448175,
0.550691545,
0.4783661962,
-0.1292541772,
-0.3679205477,
0.1431819201,
-0.5512757301,
-0.0334414504,
0.5062218308,
0.424705267,
-0.2453977913,
-0.3758740425,
-0.420860976,
-0.1405668259,
0.4607196748,
1.2916641235,
-0.9626798034,
0.3036811948,
0.7003062963,
0.9616616368,
0.5947861075,
-0.0068121441,
0.3255263269,
-1.1493164301,
0.9126981497,
0.3774540126,
0.8289994001,
0.7131115794,
-0.4110994935,
0.3397412598,
0.4562675655,
-0.6561511159,
-0.6978346109,
0.3906131387,
-1.0159287453,
-0.0479428433,
0.5645845532,
-0.5926860571,
-0.2157926559,
-0.3869664073,
-0.3763672113,
-0.0015613205,
-0.4834068418,
0.3427109718,
0.4938096404,
-0.1842353791,
-0.4251974523,
-0.1720537096,
0.8209631443,
0.539814949,
-0.7953424454,
-0.1407942772,
0.3596327007,
0.030501416,
0.5584229827,
0.9555197954,
0.4858720601,
0.3742926121,
-0.0198787116,
-0.3482284248,
0.1621999741,
-0.0756812915,
-0.6279098988,
0.6325787902,
-0.0402880907,
-0.2063243985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13792v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13792v1
|
Counterfactual Reasoning Using Predicted Latent Personality Dimensions for Optimizing Persuasion Outcome
| 2024-04-21T23:03:47 | 2024-04-21T23:03:47 |
Donghuo Zeng, Roberto S. Legaspi, Yuewen Sun, Xinshuai Dong, Kazushi Ikeda, Peter Spirtes, kun Zhang
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Customizing persuasive conversations related to the outcome of interest for
specific users achieves better persuasion results. However, existing persuasive
conversation systems rely on persuasive strategies and encounter challenges in
dynamically adjusting dialogues to suit the evolving states of individual users
during interactions. This limitation restricts the system's ability to deliver
flexible or dynamic conversations and achieve suboptimal persuasion outcomes.
In this paper, we present a novel approach that tracks a user's latent
personality dimensions (LPDs) during ongoing persuasion conversation and
generates tailored counterfactual utterances based on these LPDs to optimize
the overall persuasion outcome. In particular, our proposed method leverages a
Bi-directional Generative Adversarial Network (BiCoGAN) in tandem with a
Dialogue-based Personality Prediction Regression (DPPR) model to generate
counterfactual data. This enables the system to formulate alternative
persuasive utterances that are more suited to the user. Subsequently, we
utilize the D3QN model to learn policies for optimized selection of system
utterances on counterfactual data. Experimental results we obtained from using
the PersuasionForGood dataset demonstrate the superiority of our approach over
the existing method, BiCoGAN. The cumulative rewards and Q-values produced by
our method surpass ground truth benchmarks, showcasing the efficacy of
employing counterfactual reasoning and LPDs to optimize reinforcement learning
policy in online interactions.
|
[
-0.5792976022,
-1.1130516529,
0.7006250024,
0.149100408,
-0.2089770585,
0.2408939451,
-0.0247570369,
0.276994437,
0.2551695704,
0.5397618413,
-0.860588789,
-0.4797901809,
-0.155991599,
-0.3137178719,
0.1282023489,
1.1219191551,
0.2563960552,
0.154194206,
-0.3124225438,
-0.0164902136,
-0.5817991495,
-0.666023612,
-0.7069131732,
-0.688516438,
0.7086116076,
0.7109771967,
0.7377173901,
-0.0597297177,
-0.1216559559,
0.2152492106,
-0.024672078,
0.2241121083,
-0.7117484808,
0.143005982,
-0.5200522542,
-0.5265500546,
-0.3840690851,
0.1505428553,
0.1891026497,
0.494846642,
-0.3759257495,
-0.2540659606,
-0.0456423946,
0.3546362817,
-0.3602256179,
-0.0713907406,
-0.6974757314,
0.250517875,
-0.0389199816,
-0.2292319238,
-0.2467347831,
-0.4111766219,
0.3699572384,
-0.5618495941,
0.0502211601,
-0.1765346527,
0.4826249778,
0.0213648584,
-0.412745744,
-0.2069366425,
-0.9063097239,
0.5633603334,
-0.6832700968,
0.2081539929,
0.5257278681,
0.2099402696,
-0.2092828751,
-0.4470600784,
-0.9488790631,
-0.1762814224,
-0.0043163635,
0.374887079,
-0.4181016386,
-0.1625899076,
0.2762360871,
-0.040532425,
-0.7851733565,
0.2641162574,
0.1661244035,
-0.1190452427,
0.6403388381,
0.3327835798,
-0.1115688086,
-0.1318804473,
-0.2302688807,
-0.3445054889,
-0.7544407845,
0.1333699971,
0.7596219778,
0.1363940984,
-0.1249634549,
0.3827752471,
-0.3051629961,
0.2540378273,
0.7741167545,
0.0851051211,
-0.0789458305,
-0.5773133039,
-0.0830133632,
0.1669476479,
0.92329669,
0.3793270886,
0.1290580034,
0.0501806028,
0.0903518572,
0.0229324047,
0.3132880628,
-0.7653921843,
-0.6854203343,
0.3065873086,
-0.4741172791,
-0.4743870497,
-0.161087513,
-1.0594704151,
-0.4555188715,
-0.2286334187,
0.3592803478,
-0.4455269873,
-0.3723789752,
-0.2588173151,
0.0028856944,
-0.1320289373,
0.231880784,
-0.8665591478,
-0.1653445512,
0.4938516617,
0.8186364174,
0.0634483621,
0.1274333447,
-0.7882684469,
0.1798860729,
-0.5196319818,
0.6537340879,
-0.7349126339,
-0.6787868738,
-0.0691299215,
-0.0429739617,
0.0783022121,
-0.4307347536,
0.3817748129,
-0.4320776165,
0.4384527802,
-0.5227207541,
-0.330352962,
-0.0638487041,
0.5341259241,
-0.230279997,
0.3708905578,
-0.0660109296,
-0.5097390413,
0.3168914616,
-0.5758568048,
-0.4435974956,
0.1977218837,
-0.3769733608,
-0.7907086611,
-0.1194223985,
0.2068326026,
0.3907751739,
0.0073036938,
0.580561161,
-0.4940600693,
0.026540326,
0.6983778477,
-0.6831992269,
0.7851849794,
0.1055478156,
-0.5028776526,
0.4132575095,
-0.642279923,
-0.0964730829,
0.1835638732,
-0.1229205206,
-0.1903448105,
0.2586034834,
-0.3607545197,
0.0993351117,
0.1830386966,
-0.6880075932,
0.1300091594,
-0.4103274941,
0.2396377474,
0.7193495631,
0.2866950929,
0.2248992175,
-0.40214926,
0.419912219,
0.1350479275,
0.2782014608,
0.159531787,
-0.4704788327,
-0.4961437285,
-0.0957699493,
-0.179466188,
0.5906862617,
-1.1031140089,
0.4735450745,
-0.0396464653,
-0.5412612557,
0.1563277245,
-0.0765322521,
0.6381314993,
0.7423048615,
0.3405653238,
-0.0944457352,
-0.4092418849,
-0.7940893769,
-0.1634045094,
-0.6105009913,
-0.1246274784,
0.4289998412,
0.3953421414,
0.0527798273,
0.8707376719,
-0.5615471005,
-0.0499502346,
-0.2195369005,
0.728954792,
0.0873222798,
0.3027592003,
0.6135302782,
-0.982655108,
-0.571162343,
-0.1125807092,
-0.4750180542,
-0.2436477244,
-0.5969195366,
-0.0472559854,
0.1416449398,
0.2994070947,
-0.4561476707,
0.6932775378,
0.3696242273,
-0.5111399293,
0.7906623483,
-0.1309778243,
0.1137628555,
-0.6525238752,
-0.1054779366,
-0.0314807296,
-0.170598194,
-0.763426125,
-0.5724315643,
-0.3779518306,
-0.0960245878,
-0.2839092016,
0.2608551979,
0.0346007198,
0.0974927545,
-0.2610189617,
0.0927465335,
0.0778280124,
0.7289414406,
0.3086495996,
0.7371826172,
0.1947145313,
-0.5310020447,
0.7822053432,
0.5667753816,
-0.2631326914,
1.2704484463,
-0.7188794017,
0.2423154563,
-0.0795984119,
0.5070322156,
-1.0642256737,
0.1505035311,
0.4705198407,
-0.4424362779,
-0.0085566761,
-0.071555458,
-0.0934230387,
-0.079392828,
-0.1446493566,
-0.3141785264,
0.2070218325,
-0.6151447892,
0.588139236,
0.0015666963,
-0.3607071638,
-0.1718111634,
-0.4752840102,
0.3143061996,
-0.3294484019,
-0.3598219156,
0.5728530884,
-0.3958900869,
-0.2279390246,
-0.2252741307,
0.1096134484,
0.5339138508,
-0.1173943579,
0.1393779963,
0.3754210174,
0.029895585,
0.0334468409,
0.1207343042,
-0.0708995089,
0.2332008928,
-0.1974975616,
0.4924653769,
-0.0836845934,
-0.2905433476,
-0.4488740563,
0.539341867,
0.3022442162,
0.0593098775,
0.9064365625,
0.7700657845,
0.0005531259,
-0.0313494578,
-0.3777150214,
-0.3795370162,
-0.4371022582,
0.394205898,
-0.5123612881,
-0.4033219516,
0.4155701101,
-0.179021284,
0.0620173924,
-0.0813713223,
0.8465338945,
-0.1884893179,
1.4258881807,
0.0050039664,
0.5207989812,
0.6881809831,
-0.211199671,
0.3640958071,
-0.7118895054,
-0.7195120454,
-0.20679304,
-0.2662191689,
-0.3457271457,
-0.289752543,
0.4204188585,
-0.0578905791,
-0.5086304545,
0.2054070979,
-0.3440118432,
-0.0428219847,
0.5567362905,
0.2771459222,
-0.0477571525,
0.1284534782,
-0.4460653961,
-0.1904938966,
-0.5427479744,
-0.4391586781,
0.9169965982,
0.1326355487,
0.4662378132,
0.6713813543,
0.1046710461,
0.3748507202,
0.3739905059,
-0.6109596491,
0.6779888868,
-0.1781534404,
-0.501981616,
-0.4817664623,
-0.6065282822,
-0.7524713278,
0.2018219829,
-0.6645435095,
-0.9449703693,
0.5741338134,
0.2385555953,
-0.4029337764,
0.3040322661,
-0.5015601516,
0.8899971247,
-0.5130673647,
-0.8009349108,
-0.4845268726,
-0.5773545504,
-0.093818374,
-0.0236505158,
-0.2363626659,
0.0400985889,
0.3827558756,
0.6438370943,
-0.6239181161,
0.955426991,
-0.4247806668,
-0.0845280886,
0.1058257744,
0.1564397067,
0.7914279699,
0.2700323164,
-0.1309475005,
0.199193269,
0.0472232364,
-0.1508671343,
-0.8639928102,
0.7512441278,
-0.7978502512,
-0.7879295945,
-0.2753769755,
-0.2275775224,
-0.6149829626,
-0.0579279475,
0.208867237,
0.3692578971,
-0.9234980941,
0.3650187254,
0.7940945625,
-0.4988382161,
0.3951296508,
0.7987466455,
-0.0163952168,
-0.4320597947,
1.0920659304,
0.0306420196,
0.2508789301,
0.5091031194,
0.7303185463,
-0.6804118156,
-0.42939955,
-0.4860395491,
-0.1027666405,
-0.5486713052,
-0.0354871228,
-0.5606036186,
0.0322244503,
-0.5436171293,
-0.126695618,
-0.2155524045,
-0.0921926573,
-0.5180700421,
0.0297023356,
0.0584283136,
0.4309525788,
-0.2285048217,
0.4959620237,
-0.1798119694,
0.3239738345,
0.8440586925,
0.0145461727,
-0.0421079434,
-0.5740012527,
0.0557968244,
0.4208053052,
-0.7781507969,
-1.0393195152,
0.4825884402,
0.0098510562,
0.7537112832,
0.7292079329,
0.1981732398,
0.3864246309,
-0.0931846797,
0.7159986496,
0.6026186347,
-0.7801842093,
0.7424699664,
-0.42303285,
0.2534514666,
0.2816910446,
0.4991932511,
-0.487764895,
0.0559355654,
-0.5397279263,
-0.5124909878,
0.6109160185,
0.2381162494,
-0.0267927479,
0.0492810346,
0.0716452897,
0.1535090804,
0.2153020352,
-0.3742266893,
-0.2410721928,
-0.9367660284,
-0.1653423309,
-0.1593542695,
-0.1359875947,
-0.3739689291,
-0.123986423,
0.7926854491,
-0.3064025939,
-0.043041151,
0.1744793206,
0.3976247013,
0.0393730998,
0.3523419797,
0.7148646116,
0.6087556481,
-0.311529547,
-0.0477076434,
0.1287965924,
-0.2791264951,
0.1076291278,
0.1552520394,
-0.1915905327,
-0.2116029114,
-0.0086896429,
1.1396740675,
-0.2414759398,
-0.3570194542,
0.520853281,
-0.26175192,
-0.3990026712,
-0.477723062,
0.0247726273,
0.2404024601,
0.4199217856,
0.2462146282,
-0.0828773454,
-0.1009208858,
-0.7814090848,
0.0436373092,
0.4927406013,
-0.4421049058,
-0.4017373323,
0.6055642962,
0.4262922108,
-0.6094768643,
0.502881825,
-0.2616653442,
-0.5506113172,
0.455110997,
0.4910169244,
0.7320694923,
-0.3054332137,
0.7157165408,
0.2701141834,
-0.1383666098,
0.3011626005,
0.1184572205,
-0.1690021455,
-0.7970488071,
0.0319384634,
-0.2616217434,
-0.6309149861,
0.5402302146,
-0.3200770319,
0.0468173623,
-0.8007880449,
-0.3076266944,
0.3099071681,
0.1600301117,
-0.5024085641,
0.2958415747,
0.2424077988,
0.1027916968,
-0.8299071789,
0.4322905242,
0.6569933295,
-0.4300024211,
-0.4955815375,
0.271466136,
0.3872174323,
-0.4915028214,
0.5985561609,
-0.2715170681,
-0.401683569,
-0.3869206011,
-0.5064707994,
-0.4009569585,
0.8156306148,
0.2466192991,
-0.8310925961,
0.3338225484,
0.0762071237,
0.547719419,
-0.6445211768,
0.4512640536,
0.2509743273,
0.4560050368,
0.5233975649,
-0.4495356381,
0.138346985,
-0.0776809976,
0.0512715653,
-0.3306150138,
-0.7107431293,
0.5599168539,
-0.2361925244,
-0.0358193778,
-0.0846501216,
0.7440398932,
0.3626176715,
0.4451526403,
0.791562736,
0.2817512751,
0.6805636287,
0.0111885322,
0.6699359417,
0.0125351725,
-0.1384809315,
1.0860017538,
-0.3492500484,
0.571511507,
0.3422005177,
-0.1960812807,
0.9611554146,
0.4960699677,
-0.0130841248,
0.6435610056,
0.3280457258,
-0.4910236299,
-0.6639488339,
-0.3963150978,
0.0336967073,
0.6369401217,
0.6229271889,
0.0491522476,
0.1911960542,
0.2152436376,
0.1724582314,
0.532292068,
0.1308380216,
0.8205655217,
-0.2257112563,
-1.0092140436,
0.3366587162,
-0.0288505312,
0.4842199683,
-0.4240768552,
-0.2165543884,
-0.3106845021,
0.3108118773,
-0.1211974248,
-0.8996045589,
0.2093342692,
-0.1348777115,
-0.1411677897,
-0.519025445,
0.4259493351,
-0.5700616837,
-0.3045220077,
0.1270596087,
0.3076786697,
0.0493542291,
-0.0419185013,
-0.9042682648,
-0.1311034858,
0.0568083413,
-0.2180050462,
0.2033078372,
0.3695656359,
-0.0257333554,
0.6049496531,
0.9574012756,
0.118751429,
-0.75735569,
0.4328715503,
0.8730126023,
-0.3876007795,
-0.9311010838,
-0.6594511271,
0.1419086158,
-0.4443318248,
-0.3646067679,
0.6464974284,
0.4308103323,
0.7192536592,
0.2570110261,
0.7853293419,
0.1128706262,
0.6859244704,
-0.3918552101,
0.4899854064,
-0.4723505378,
0.3988793492,
-0.1444532871,
-0.6300287843,
0.3971389532,
0.7487737536,
-0.7665525675,
0.1236571521,
0.4009385407,
0.9270677567,
0.0547619872,
0.273940146,
0.4876557887,
0.2566310167,
0.7265072465,
0.7080154419,
0.7971460223,
0.1134826392,
0.7518059015,
-0.1111561432,
-0.2870443761,
-0.330521524,
-0.7725516558,
-1.1394056082,
-0.5077003837,
-0.5550422072,
-0.4605226517,
0.2655102611,
0.5427837968,
0.6364219189,
-0.6209747791,
0.1351146698,
-0.1503594667,
0.1109620556,
-0.1706025749,
-0.3141681254,
0.0964079127,
0.3443614542,
-0.514596343,
0.4921866953,
0.3155507445,
0.0411233045,
-0.6500517726,
-0.2893746495,
-0.5482352972,
0.4907242358,
0.4503817558,
0.3979528546,
-0.6607167721,
-0.33105582,
-0.1205116659,
0.0111969784,
0.0023751049,
0.8728349805,
-0.8359675407,
0.4754511416,
0.5114728212,
0.0995106101,
0.7909735441,
0.2646048665,
0.71805197,
-0.6280013323,
-0.2104653567,
0.3042099476,
-0.111376591,
0.5206720829,
-0.5882360935,
-0.0013663127,
0.3936773241,
-0.3085557222,
-0.4146113396,
0.6529993415,
-0.6206260324,
-0.664018631,
1.0291508436,
-0.4384303987,
0.1964194924,
-0.6291047335,
-0.0884018913,
0.286049962,
-0.4544132352,
0.723287344,
0.4866493642,
-0.4570059478,
-0.2840314209,
-0.0576813556,
0.4386181533,
0.8096315265,
-0.7392652035,
0.1145551652,
0.4999879897,
0.1777494103,
0.2572698891,
0.5852912068,
0.0973941609,
0.0648866817,
0.2841573358,
-0.3016405702,
-0.1894623339,
-0.2760893703,
0.0127383266,
0.0954820737,
-0.5840135813,
-0.0090250326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.16873v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.16873v1
|
AdvPrompter: Fast Adaptive Adversarial Prompting for LLMs
| 2024-04-21T22:18:13 | 2024-04-21T22:18:13 |
Anselm Paulus, Arman Zharmagambetov, Chuan Guo, Brandon Amos, Yuandong Tian
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While recently Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable
successes, they are vulnerable to certain jailbreaking attacks that lead to
generation of inappropriate or harmful content. Manual red-teaming requires
finding adversarial prompts that cause such jailbreaking, e.g. by appending a
suffix to a given instruction, which is inefficient and time-consuming. On the
other hand, automatic adversarial prompt generation often leads to semantically
meaningless attacks that can easily be detected by perplexity-based filters,
may require gradient information from the TargetLLM, or do not scale well due
to time-consuming discrete optimization processes over the token space. In this
paper, we present a novel method that uses another LLM, called the AdvPrompter,
to generate human-readable adversarial prompts in seconds, $\sim800\times$
faster than existing optimization-based approaches. We train the AdvPrompter
using a novel algorithm that does not require access to the gradients of the
TargetLLM. This process alternates between two steps: (1) generating
high-quality target adversarial suffixes by optimizing the AdvPrompter
predictions, and (2) low-rank fine-tuning of the AdvPrompter with the generated
adversarial suffixes. The trained AdvPrompter generates suffixes that veil the
input instruction without changing its meaning, such that the TargetLLM is
lured to give a harmful response. Experimental results on popular open source
TargetLLMs show state-of-the-art results on the AdvBench dataset, that also
transfer to closed-source black-box LLM APIs. Further, we demonstrate that by
fine-tuning on a synthetic dataset generated by AdvPrompter, LLMs can be made
more robust against jailbreaking attacks while maintaining performance, i.e.
high MMLU scores.
|
[
-0.5234124064,
-1.0407682657,
0.3201189041,
0.0796064585,
-0.1598897576,
0.0784422159,
-0.119276017,
-0.0638666749,
0.1105205119,
0.374162674,
-0.8714955449,
-0.3854210377,
-0.6257587671,
0.0193082895,
-0.1272128373,
1.0378295183,
0.0566077381,
-0.0056353295,
0.1699706167,
-0.0701376945,
-0.5944365263,
-0.4310766757,
-0.9701874852,
-0.0604922585,
0.5984936953,
0.3464659154,
0.7268908024,
0.6054059267,
0.4139406383,
0.2827455997,
-0.0739498511,
0.3075250983,
-0.4250174463,
0.3581368029,
-0.0280132703,
-0.3642373383,
-0.3971809745,
0.0436581895,
0.2316066474,
0.0222919043,
-0.0512546971,
0.0791834071,
-0.1771957129,
0.6266959906,
-0.7379665375,
-0.3728344738,
-0.9615702033,
-0.0042304373,
-0.1535877436,
-0.3589650393,
-0.431600064,
-0.3828211129,
-0.1959318072,
-0.5715139508,
0.3677163422,
0.0819436982,
0.6394008398,
0.5045386553,
-0.0619515888,
-0.3679435253,
-0.5394030213,
0.4965600073,
-0.4765780568,
0.0017843755,
-0.0427353829,
0.4644139111,
-0.6151886582,
-0.518026948,
-0.4934472442,
-0.3843584061,
0.2163534611,
0.1573349983,
-0.4974333048,
-0.0263640545,
0.3074886501,
-0.0211578012,
-0.6016530991,
0.3423104584,
-0.3182042539,
-0.3122221828,
0.5115554333,
0.3010949492,
0.3563971519,
0.0826638937,
-0.6173263192,
-0.1634891182,
-0.9011976719,
0.1184172258,
0.6594241261,
0.191600889,
0.2039469182,
0.3583521545,
0.0840611234,
0.8070383668,
0.130247429,
0.0424592271,
-0.1836381108,
-0.0578601174,
-0.006431052,
0.2605561316,
1.0319703817,
0.3509841263,
0.3871209025,
-0.012057852,
-0.2830808461,
0.3064329922,
0.4900519252,
-0.8581095934,
-0.5887299776,
0.243824333,
-0.0027539255,
-0.601900816,
0.0788683966,
-0.8187147975,
-0.7593635321,
0.0128622437,
0.3563336432,
-0.5610791445,
0.1259061098,
-0.145047605,
-0.2384720892,
0.076658003,
0.3244082332,
-0.7438723445,
0.1711242497,
0.6030915976,
0.8657799959,
-0.2677231431,
-0.25345397,
-1.1361638308,
-0.1467227936,
-0.3069931567,
0.7044739723,
-0.1902903318,
-0.3031033576,
-0.3343022466,
-0.0926238894,
-0.1252455562,
-0.652666688,
0.3507722914,
-0.7751511335,
0.1008893251,
0.0481735356,
-0.2968930304,
0.0957196876,
0.3367594481,
-0.6666638851,
0.7023935914,
-0.1152152643,
-0.6722591519,
0.3331105113,
-0.7142004967,
-0.4130515158,
0.2227725536,
0.1238359585,
-0.5407043099,
-0.0249012914,
0.6325070262,
0.4669184387,
-0.2347316593,
0.0361358523,
-0.2511042058,
-0.3443571031,
0.355545342,
-0.5937575698,
0.8332252502,
0.2233669013,
-0.3615609705,
0.4503598213,
-0.6394999623,
-0.2414709181,
0.4220782816,
-0.2743475437,
-0.2713206112,
-0.0384980887,
-0.2446082979,
0.1544786841,
0.1922532767,
-0.5097151399,
0.3243350983,
-0.5046355128,
0.4369859695,
1.0995316505,
0.1478462815,
0.2795831859,
-0.1890869886,
0.7837280631,
-0.094193466,
0.3353444934,
-0.2662954628,
-0.4367357492,
-0.5561327934,
-0.5785378814,
0.1794676036,
0.9320474863,
-0.8781794906,
0.4074194729,
0.0250305198,
-0.385235697,
-0.7694599628,
0.4021773934,
0.5222669244,
0.4666220844,
0.4281277061,
0.0141013134,
-0.4911783338,
-0.6144720912,
-0.3185960054,
-0.1901435107,
-0.0397198498,
0.3040634096,
0.3685248792,
-0.1590461135,
0.5582464337,
-0.6607204676,
-0.1953984052,
-0.2628892362,
0.132013604,
0.08245188,
0.1917202622,
0.5400163531,
-0.7831125855,
-0.3633452952,
-0.4270761013,
-0.4524773061,
-0.2847373486,
-0.1803534776,
-0.0237288047,
0.1039191484,
0.6320618391,
-0.3941648901,
0.0557643287,
0.4498649836,
-0.5522922277,
0.7620000839,
-0.2675103545,
-0.0214350596,
-1.1143630743,
-0.1222239211,
0.0322793722,
-0.3175985217,
-0.6284525394,
0.2195794135,
0.0679337308,
-0.1661365628,
-0.8625488877,
0.6588810682,
-0.3377455473,
0.3000642359,
-0.3603213429,
0.2728756666,
-0.1166792065,
0.3118422031,
-0.4773971736,
1.087247014,
0.5587174892,
-0.7131747007,
1.0154961348,
0.0752515569,
-0.0364817008,
0.5452424884,
-0.7095445991,
0.0698381066,
-0.0809925199,
0.1095856428,
-0.9059430957,
-0.158348754,
0.4480896294,
-0.5824232697,
0.3454183638,
-0.1790774763,
-0.3416969478,
-0.5078215599,
-0.6410626769,
0.1387007087,
0.5872269869,
-0.7917636037,
0.2146851271,
0.1277106106,
-0.0124333547,
-0.5640992522,
-0.3851638138,
0.2478102446,
-0.5043561459,
-0.5830977559,
0.201318562,
-0.1336842477,
-0.2742222548,
-0.0711809397,
0.1146194115,
0.2472033054,
0.5666689873,
0.3592644334,
0.5655221343,
-0.1642551273,
-0.2713948786,
-0.3166253567,
-0.2632357478,
0.2905923426,
-0.3930104375,
0.3028851449,
-0.0649705902,
-0.3286963105,
-0.357642889,
0.0876844525,
0.6953796148,
-0.1056366861,
0.8150040507,
0.7507945895,
-0.1465810835,
-0.5123254657,
-0.2855788767,
-0.2873231769,
-0.5411188006,
0.2723903954,
-0.3097217381,
-0.8127948642,
0.3570585847,
-0.1590834707,
-0.0144322589,
0.1509468704,
0.6294824481,
0.1761364341,
1.2405728102,
0.233270973,
-0.190992415,
0.5703824759,
-0.1365652978,
-0.0250874925,
-0.8613519073,
-0.1299479306,
-0.1080917045,
-0.303132683,
-0.350589633,
-0.2336353809,
0.5519701242,
0.0676088259,
-0.256249845,
0.3608188033,
-0.606074512,
0.5009868741,
0.7278217673,
0.0706705153,
-0.145281285,
-0.1817331761,
-0.2931857705,
-0.0305102523,
-0.6931113005,
-0.3079306185,
0.9355108738,
0.310306102,
0.8498847485,
0.149439767,
0.5593855977,
0.4672971666,
0.2373907566,
-1.0293076038,
0.6359892488,
-0.349001497,
-0.2900770307,
-0.0624422245,
-0.4113899767,
-0.9672917128,
0.1573643684,
-0.247839123,
-0.6492506266,
-0.1109105572,
0.3996168077,
-0.6610226631,
0.4021172523,
-0.6618168354,
0.812348783,
-0.2105388194,
-0.2569010258,
0.1171329767,
-0.5488553047,
0.4954468012,
-0.1256664097,
0.1253058463,
-0.1313182414,
-0.069854565,
0.7919400334,
-0.495811224,
0.6665747166,
-0.5681788921,
-0.0836192518,
0.274359107,
0.3587715328,
0.906316936,
0.1141227037,
-0.0369177051,
-0.4046806991,
-0.5626475215,
-0.3014858663,
-0.7417321205,
0.8455139399,
-0.6746327281,
-0.9645651579,
-0.2938282788,
-0.5838979483,
-0.0305010863,
0.0567050911,
0.314974606,
0.4053725004,
-0.2419680953,
-0.1029922217,
0.9187108874,
-0.3097710311,
0.3625964522,
0.6705741882,
0.3370711207,
-0.5168412328,
1.1782312393,
-0.1914045513,
0.2388874292,
0.2112184465,
0.2126366198,
-0.2286967039,
-0.7010347843,
-0.6649346948,
0.0342729092,
-0.5709849,
-0.4306340516,
-0.4163132012,
-0.222379446,
-0.2287846059,
-0.3675992787,
-0.2914482355,
-0.3162253201,
-0.4304853678,
0.1195462048,
0.6428463459,
0.6321269274,
0.0974144265,
0.3488163948,
-0.6855350733,
0.5308821201,
0.4946355224,
-0.1500607878,
-0.3289352953,
-0.6462774277,
-0.0044103838,
-0.0909638256,
-0.3761115074,
-0.8950837255,
0.3684691191,
0.0932084993,
0.3836741447,
0.3394271433,
0.4037386775,
0.5228925347,
-0.609159708,
0.8091093898,
0.1578321457,
-0.6546589732,
0.9337590933,
-0.2834733427,
0.213486135,
0.4030494988,
0.2189533859,
-0.2335178554,
-0.5446228981,
-0.4664178789,
-1.0102539062,
0.7885406613,
-0.0447073914,
0.0057203881,
-0.0690468997,
0.3832703233,
-0.2137635946,
-0.1681183428,
-0.3256274164,
-0.516728282,
-0.183688879,
-0.2688542306,
-0.026168773,
-0.2514760792,
-0.2989698946,
0.0159454066,
0.7978916168,
-0.1175809354,
0.0651546568,
0.0576198101,
-0.1685019881,
-0.0587485358,
0.4777380526,
0.6501612663,
0.2156303674,
-0.1454353631,
0.2137659043,
0.3689808846,
-0.5837159157,
0.5615193844,
0.2921395302,
-0.219642669,
-0.307364732,
0.3336900473,
1.0158914328,
-0.1676112115,
-0.7510721087,
0.7587562799,
-0.3636373281,
-0.2650304139,
-0.2170567513,
0.5152797699,
-0.2976168692,
0.349963367,
0.3308392465,
0.3200750947,
-0.0589325354,
-0.2538153231,
0.2476282865,
0.6134288907,
-0.5064057112,
-0.2541595697,
1.0953910351,
0.1666042954,
-0.4230747819,
0.4595526457,
-0.4052915573,
-0.7175514698,
0.5837196112,
0.6320319772,
0.9178677797,
-0.4377807677,
0.1180925444,
0.1022450402,
0.3550932407,
0.0078618061,
0.0202907603,
0.2233552188,
-0.5785030127,
-0.2642736435,
-0.5159695745,
-0.3516228497,
0.3770292699,
-0.5430262685,
0.3454264998,
-0.6119164824,
-0.0165785234,
0.1554652601,
-0.1457697004,
-0.2887497544,
0.1664714664,
0.1951567978,
0.9480965137,
-0.7841246724,
0.6233987212,
1.0032889843,
0.0709326789,
-0.4741901159,
0.1062055677,
0.4031228423,
-0.9940419793,
0.590156734,
0.1446326673,
-0.2082429677,
0.154979974,
-0.3085562885,
-0.4576051831,
0.9693148732,
0.5451549888,
-0.442112118,
0.1014987156,
-0.3229753375,
0.2897929251,
-0.2074092478,
-0.0270290226,
0.6652184725,
0.3562400639,
0.1364241391,
-0.4175415635,
0.555320859,
-0.4385051131,
-0.093906492,
0.3659890294,
-0.4943862855,
0.698805511,
-0.516683042,
-0.1818120629,
-0.0411528274,
0.4396055043,
0.4182377458,
0.0346247703,
0.6539600492,
0.4802685678,
0.5875806808,
-0.0708398893,
1.0885884762,
-0.3805428743,
-0.1841083616,
0.8641185164,
0.0196047556,
0.5699232817,
0.3378997445,
-0.1259269863,
0.2961167693,
0.499029994,
-0.2902089059,
0.636582911,
0.4791751504,
-0.5556898713,
-0.1333573461,
-0.068696253,
-0.0808598846,
0.1990387589,
0.499214232,
-0.2133217007,
-0.1173169762,
0.3358700871,
0.1515343338,
0.1684463173,
-0.3919436336,
1.0028657913,
-0.0548969544,
-0.7565700412,
0.911437273,
0.1343750954,
0.9173154235,
-0.6300885081,
0.137775436,
0.0704295561,
0.4293774068,
0.0271325223,
-0.6669900417,
0.1998118907,
0.2259653062,
-0.1506551653,
-0.1239983067,
0.8255771399,
-0.1615110785,
-0.2749353349,
0.3671893775,
0.1912129074,
-0.0317605585,
-0.2026635855,
-0.9599301219,
-0.0154216979,
-0.1236570999,
-0.449115485,
0.2705931067,
0.3131710887,
0.0149778118,
0.7662258148,
0.7637514472,
0.5305333138,
0.0908197463,
0.1700265408,
1.084643364,
-0.4827435017,
-0.4006302953,
-1.3124544621,
0.2604748011,
0.1266101599,
-0.1525827199,
0.8321378231,
0.3320246041,
0.5122017264,
0.12557666,
0.8918470144,
0.0420147106,
0.2726914883,
-0.5742815137,
0.6237806678,
-0.403382808,
0.5130037665,
0.0197575558,
-0.4874251187,
-0.3309872448,
0.1765780002,
-0.2399409115,
-0.3026298881,
0.3741821051,
1.0536222458,
-0.0165745597,
-0.3563797176,
0.1838690937,
0.1554344147,
0.4245479703,
0.7625813484,
0.837677598,
-0.3429644108,
0.7910410166,
-0.0219794586,
-0.3024430573,
-0.3430402279,
-0.6986918449,
-1.123742938,
-0.1554298997,
-0.2723086774,
-0.5607860684,
0.5416797996,
1.0104489326,
0.4765689075,
-0.9857238531,
0.3038391471,
-0.2990336418,
0.2038141042,
-0.1768902987,
-0.2876022756,
0.2748449743,
-0.4425109923,
-0.5536584258,
0.8434519172,
0.0261139963,
0.2464596331,
-0.345489651,
-0.1745108664,
0.0723030567,
0.1119553447,
0.326777935,
0.3027444184,
-0.663159132,
0.0160125978,
-0.0771906972,
-0.0510423705,
-0.1591929942,
0.7494161129,
-0.7646884322,
0.5394191146,
0.3746630847,
0.6088110209,
0.0659709871,
0.2391211838,
0.7434047461,
-1.0600998402,
0.277705431,
0.1546567082,
0.3055689931,
0.4510439038,
-0.6841901541,
0.1256997287,
0.3275279403,
-0.4272587597,
-0.8536168933,
0.3696309924,
-0.4638284147,
-0.5490992069,
1.1660788059,
-0.3360838294,
-0.4552790821,
-0.1959290951,
-0.3782138228,
0.2709810436,
-0.5581403375,
0.7164817452,
0.2877656519,
-0.0365831181,
-0.0661827549,
-0.4904941618,
0.7363693714,
0.2209253013,
-0.5990719199,
0.1582480371,
0.2338935733,
0.2754802704,
-0.0205002129,
0.2952727973,
0.1238064915,
0.5451322198,
0.0624400117,
-0.1846821159,
-0.7380360961,
-0.5006535053,
-0.5148199201,
0.2808481455,
0.0324461833,
-0.3671838045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13784v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13784v1
|
Iteratively Prompting Multimodal LLMs to Reproduce Natural and AI-Generated Images
| 2024-04-21T21:30:17 | 2024-04-21T21:30:17 |
Ali Naseh, Katherine Thai, Mohit Iyyer, Amir Houmansadr
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
With the digital imagery landscape rapidly evolving, image stocks and
AI-generated image marketplaces have become central to visual media.
Traditional stock images now exist alongside innovative platforms that trade in
prompts for AI-generated visuals, driven by sophisticated APIs like DALL-E 3
and Midjourney. This paper studies the possibility of employing multi-modal
models with enhanced visual understanding to mimic the outputs of these
platforms, introducing an original attack strategy. Our method leverages
fine-tuned CLIP models, a multi-label classifier, and the descriptive
capabilities of GPT-4V to create prompts that generate images similar to those
available in marketplaces and from premium stock image providers, yet at a
markedly lower expense. In presenting this strategy, we aim to spotlight a new
class of economic and security considerations within the realm of digital
imagery. Our findings, supported by both automated metrics and human
assessment, reveal that comparable visual content can be produced for a
fraction of the prevailing market prices ($0.23 - $0.27 per image), emphasizing
the need for awareness and strategic discussions about the integrity of digital
media in an increasingly AI-integrated landscape. Our work also contributes to
the field by assembling a dataset consisting of approximately 19 million
prompt-image pairs generated by the popular Midjourney platform, which we plan
to release publicly.
|
[
-0.5013115406,
-0.6463809013,
0.4809834659,
0.1550176889,
-0.4711723328,
0.1636861712,
0.1442472041,
-0.4390608966,
0.1369570643,
0.4900916219,
-0.8708151579,
-0.3450275064,
-0.5062429309,
0.2531566918,
-0.3511553109,
0.6671847105,
0.1058423072,
-0.2075589001,
-0.0518390983,
-0.1431442201,
-0.5805339217,
-0.6198006272,
-0.5920429826,
0.3169037402,
0.6380093694,
0.174390018,
0.7943871617,
0.4526999593,
0.6262677908,
0.3387638927,
0.4444640577,
0.3404762149,
-0.5525334477,
0.2344119251,
0.1950446516,
-0.2544897199,
-0.143519178,
0.3628096879,
0.3084540367,
-0.1562450081,
0.2025454044,
0.2645691037,
-0.0241365694,
0.4663674235,
-0.6160660982,
-0.0725721195,
-0.9648479223,
0.0183357596,
-0.3809657097,
-0.6660215855,
-0.5137598515,
0.0902435482,
-0.1421044171,
-0.8230078816,
-0.0711233169,
0.2392848283,
1.1044443846,
0.280217737,
-0.4147812724,
-0.4910470545,
-0.4964399338,
0.6522205472,
-0.2702699304,
0.0508081988,
0.0622576363,
0.6255218387,
-0.0977259725,
-0.9243857861,
-0.6792480946,
-0.2084215432,
0.2243750393,
0.3240657747,
-0.8010340929,
-0.2137534022,
0.2052178234,
0.0655669644,
-0.2831164002,
0.0743843168,
-0.5734954476,
-0.2602366209,
0.4995521009,
0.2856891453,
0.5291147232,
-0.342612952,
-0.9001775384,
-0.2688018978,
-0.8772495985,
0.1385787874,
0.6531246901,
0.0308299065,
-0.1715159267,
0.6755282879,
0.1396418065,
0.4776508808,
0.2819340229,
-0.2431124896,
0.0254765246,
-0.6948777437,
-0.1260234267,
-0.1986460686,
0.7745143771,
1.0327812433,
-0.1601525992,
0.1528899819,
-0.5703063011,
0.3473722339,
0.5502678156,
-0.7509088516,
-0.1961194724,
0.1054477096,
-0.5343854427,
-0.4799197912,
0.026232712,
-0.9647626281,
-0.3707006276,
-0.3120776117,
0.7233738303,
-0.3272314668,
0.0073821228,
-0.2233055085,
-0.3938091993,
0.5099700689,
0.6088971496,
-0.3096823394,
-0.2036565691,
0.284852922,
1.1094059944,
-0.0777911469,
-0.1796884686,
-0.52153337,
0.3051776886,
-0.4411829114,
0.8790410757,
-0.4373793006,
-0.6294717193,
-0.2227622718,
-0.1341852993,
0.3488873243,
-0.3565141261,
0.2102598548,
-1.0865991116,
0.1278547049,
-0.5299739838,
-0.0318555795,
-0.1793355346,
0.8592534661,
-0.9095338583,
0.649628818,
-0.2617086768,
-0.9163060784,
0.5435061455,
-0.8614917397,
0.1776999831,
0.1605020761,
-0.3979294598,
-0.2847435176,
-0.3672925234,
0.7117449045,
0.3244424462,
-0.159837693,
-0.2169231176,
-0.4797929823,
-0.1137589216,
0.6062404513,
-0.9436041713,
0.458261162,
0.3116244376,
-0.2670044005,
0.2076701969,
-0.5624418855,
-0.2803167403,
0.3578267097,
-0.0558695979,
-0.1983048618,
-0.3553694487,
0.0687923282,
0.1921400428,
0.2584553063,
-0.1764585227,
0.4089792967,
0.1262414902,
0.4862924814,
1.1856012344,
0.4655283093,
0.5164105892,
-0.4789054692,
0.7483083606,
0.1863294989,
0.4889575541,
-0.8318082094,
-0.4261527956,
-0.1571185291,
-0.91337502,
-0.0138203986,
0.4576660991,
-1.1465719938,
-0.4086124599,
-0.0924578235,
-0.3140393496,
-0.5093929768,
0.1038238183,
0.0093663326,
0.4831784368,
0.2683880031,
-0.3878230155,
-0.2451429963,
-0.9529339671,
-0.0695624426,
0.2902614772,
-0.1032020003,
0.4577506185,
0.3912606239,
-0.4934975505,
0.7255265117,
-0.2009831369,
-0.2588914335,
0.1567982733,
0.4845030308,
0.2885140181,
0.2026913464,
0.9135832191,
-0.8042587638,
-0.3438724875,
-0.3278426528,
-0.776473999,
-0.0361587368,
-0.7191281915,
-0.2103653252,
0.1864625365,
0.4011747241,
-0.6421999931,
0.5000517368,
0.2471161485,
-0.1253749579,
0.6243532896,
-0.2776391804,
0.50128299,
-0.9696496129,
-0.1465290636,
0.155692786,
-0.0775556564,
-0.3740801215,
0.329106003,
-0.1434777975,
-0.3207424283,
-0.5755568743,
0.3460059166,
-0.6674337387,
-0.2171179205,
-0.3054059148,
0.0962279961,
0.1567484438,
0.2285281122,
-0.3982730508,
1.0787382126,
0.8246695399,
-0.4582747817,
0.6342169642,
0.1070533767,
-0.0752820373,
1.0281597376,
-0.6686842442,
0.3537687361,
-0.3154985011,
0.3509481549,
-1.1451928616,
-0.3109727502,
0.6241996288,
-0.2740609348,
0.2827164233,
-0.2251279056,
-0.4768291116,
-0.3360450566,
-0.8041853309,
0.5318389535,
0.3412887454,
-0.7872751355,
0.7759450078,
0.1029116586,
-0.1561712176,
-0.6316677928,
-0.5966784954,
0.8202213645,
-0.6693493128,
-0.8489490151,
0.3092902601,
-0.1208770946,
-0.3109197617,
-0.0259016193,
0.2083309889,
0.2622879744,
-0.0099253142,
0.2409333289,
0.8635700941,
-0.1383531392,
-0.3301716745,
-0.3537715375,
-0.2180165499,
0.152371332,
-0.5040643811,
0.1997693777,
-0.1437019259,
-0.7469155192,
-0.8141393661,
0.5501566529,
0.8515292406,
-0.1691512913,
0.1983174533,
0.6416651011,
-0.1313237995,
-0.0262925159,
-0.461735338,
-0.3359368145,
-0.6303584576,
-0.0568071902,
-0.3727239072,
-0.3331744671,
0.3842029274,
-0.1020318344,
0.2065838575,
0.2306409329,
0.7949439883,
-0.171878919,
1.0524390936,
0.2675259113,
0.1125780642,
0.3488465846,
-0.3685023785,
0.2022415549,
-0.3078160584,
-0.3966510892,
0.0920000672,
-0.6469441652,
-0.5184207559,
-0.6770444512,
0.9332770705,
-0.1870164424,
-0.1600783616,
0.0141695431,
-0.4044633508,
0.4027232826,
1.0359847546,
0.2549501061,
0.2460482866,
0.2397468239,
-0.0252754595,
-0.1574091017,
-0.4116678536,
-0.6440784335,
1.2456905842,
0.2875507772,
1.0367387533,
0.1132881194,
0.5620453954,
0.8450306058,
0.1376082599,
-0.7699280977,
0.4489103258,
0.2467349917,
-0.2132960856,
0.1737369001,
-0.0104928389,
-0.8948634863,
0.0287369434,
-0.5390347838,
-0.4244962633,
0.297621578,
0.2607876956,
-0.4939404726,
0.141081661,
-0.6473738551,
0.6704792976,
-0.7167682648,
-0.5341998339,
-0.3314014077,
-0.5230472684,
0.4050366879,
-0.1536482126,
0.4008621871,
0.0663808286,
-0.3357464373,
0.3016234636,
-0.1838773638,
1.017594099,
-0.0885085538,
0.143060118,
0.4847644567,
0.2043805122,
0.5092463493,
0.0968292281,
0.4648284316,
0.0158619806,
-0.1019364446,
-0.5068567395,
-0.4942911267,
0.4621625841,
-0.7968323827,
-0.6540575624,
-0.2617585361,
-0.434433341,
0.2573060095,
0.0538578257,
0.3281036913,
0.5552583933,
0.0529480912,
-0.0605566204,
0.1940877885,
-0.318936497,
0.6208395958,
-0.0370191075,
-0.0183717292,
-0.7676065564,
0.9191997051,
0.043364007,
0.2734690011,
-0.1222313419,
-0.0494062938,
-0.5178152919,
-0.398414284,
-0.7102616429,
-0.1203220561,
-0.9486312866,
-0.513365984,
-0.4163395166,
0.1349595189,
-0.1371385455,
-0.5403517485,
-0.1839403212,
-0.0811626166,
-0.4718084931,
-0.0243507046,
0.4025339484,
0.785739243,
-0.2529030442,
0.3490414619,
-0.8556796312,
0.4938364029,
0.7053064704,
-0.1543865055,
0.0169132072,
-0.3208228946,
0.2304206491,
0.1017317921,
-0.7206104994,
-1.160405159,
0.4788298905,
0.0363923311,
0.5892575383,
0.6875649095,
0.1371622235,
0.7188424468,
-0.3855749071,
1.02693367,
0.5894248486,
-0.8688411713,
0.4909406602,
-0.3966872394,
0.0341724306,
0.1345797181,
0.5224210024,
-0.2058981508,
-0.1464015394,
-0.6501904726,
-0.9748503566,
0.37540254,
0.131592378,
0.3833923638,
0.0007478791,
0.0793637484,
0.0513436384,
0.2344471961,
-0.8184986115,
0.0244706105,
-0.6936151385,
0.0148039581,
0.644954443,
-0.1095781028,
-0.5451386571,
0.1575798839,
0.3142329752,
-0.3606189489,
0.3163325191,
0.2092877477,
-0.0774052665,
0.2933138013,
0.1105822474,
0.3991387486,
0.4021986425,
0.1525337249,
0.3048695326,
-0.1797662675,
-0.0901955962,
0.1085722446,
-0.1240909025,
-0.3295267224,
-0.2213982642,
0.1112368852,
0.7795056105,
-0.0255128704,
-0.733892262,
0.7740464211,
0.0810884982,
-0.410292238,
-0.3184813857,
-0.3308106065,
-0.1589608192,
0.7582777143,
0.5112562776,
0.3657814562,
0.2959291339,
-0.716376245,
0.4041528702,
0.6727343202,
0.0992043242,
-0.5709803104,
0.8664185405,
0.1135119349,
-0.0049240761,
0.7113726139,
-0.3470721841,
-0.5259253383,
0.6290102601,
0.4796382487,
0.5825197697,
0.3340791762,
0.2973692417,
0.2169241756,
0.5614871979,
-0.0775962695,
0.3348090053,
0.0300641153,
-0.6064510345,
-0.1562408358,
-0.0094492184,
-0.5317467451,
-0.033879783,
-0.3624488711,
0.626571238,
-0.7146232128,
-0.4430769384,
0.0096380226,
-0.6549206972,
-0.7951322794,
-0.1162266955,
0.7330526114,
0.5950677395,
-0.5447289944,
0.3428826034,
0.5265250802,
-0.7171196342,
-0.5624247789,
-0.0931439176,
0.343387723,
-1.1239138842,
0.6447620988,
0.4488555789,
-0.1066434383,
-0.1502173245,
-0.9661866426,
-0.6478478312,
1.1227471828,
0.2699742913,
-0.3240057528,
0.1073452607,
-0.1140024215,
0.0565876514,
-0.5547858477,
0.2181634009,
0.2879050672,
0.6246883869,
0.5401393175,
-0.2961999476,
0.0744687617,
-0.3471540809,
-0.1046893001,
-0.2041890025,
-0.4606362581,
0.8019883633,
-0.598911047,
-0.4816920161,
-0.1232420132,
0.4762513638,
0.3966444135,
0.6113575697,
0.7630853057,
0.3538588583,
0.7727915049,
0.1826880872,
0.9235928655,
-0.3544473648,
-0.0326280855,
0.6282648444,
-0.1964968294,
0.5885301232,
0.6665973663,
0.0505408198,
0.2360597402,
0.8363777995,
-0.7254981995,
0.8130468726,
-0.0962860808,
-0.3069301844,
-0.2383509278,
-0.2353544384,
-0.2025546432,
0.5166717172,
0.3345639706,
-0.1911426932,
-0.2380541712,
0.2621939778,
-0.2322388291,
-0.0873423442,
-0.3658028543,
0.7049047351,
-0.0222576484,
-0.1922706068,
0.4927420914,
-0.0394203104,
0.9211421609,
-0.4738660753,
0.0605779141,
-0.0209793597,
-0.2416487187,
0.0321573019,
-0.5639150739,
0.2133177668,
0.1510510147,
0.1021631286,
-0.511328578,
0.724824965,
-0.1468732357,
-0.5132333636,
0.0041789552,
0.4155329466,
-0.0836441889,
-0.1682825834,
-0.8928669095,
0.1253712475,
-0.1457978189,
-0.1670790166,
0.1995282173,
0.4592524469,
-0.0877749398,
0.5054006577,
0.9449804425,
-0.1561746448,
0.1927601993,
-0.1105223,
1.0573003292,
-0.5392488241,
-0.6580946445,
-0.9652403593,
0.4934645295,
-0.3621533215,
0.0703773201,
0.6147050858,
0.1325732917,
0.5617682934,
-0.1358314604,
0.890159905,
0.2782201469,
-0.2800325751,
-0.6489775777,
0.4350298643,
-0.6731101274,
0.4510588944,
-0.1174960434,
-0.459890455,
-0.0959069058,
0.2112137526,
-0.1590623856,
-0.2824695408,
0.3683301806,
1.0596290827,
-0.1238311902,
0.0490807332,
0.1788019985,
-0.0707905442,
0.467081368,
0.2390841097,
1.1580079794,
-0.1434393823,
0.7562651038,
-0.087278612,
-0.2793885469,
-0.061225649,
-1.2016326189,
-0.7391847968,
-0.3944944739,
-0.1988975257,
-0.3506278992,
-0.135934934,
0.9134099483,
0.5906939507,
-0.3296185732,
0.150499627,
0.4879962504,
-0.2183259875,
-0.1446482837,
-0.2283331454,
0.2180681825,
-0.2455941886,
-0.5876620412,
0.3077064753,
0.6869698167,
0.3326158226,
-0.3629306555,
0.1025884897,
0.1812628061,
0.3283433914,
0.5762441158,
0.0724604204,
-0.7713503838,
-0.1384363025,
0.281404376,
-0.0433847755,
0.2623056173,
0.8283172846,
-0.608504951,
0.4688232243,
0.2853876352,
0.9160671234,
0.2179264873,
0.1598197222,
0.5744011402,
-0.6639077067,
0.3024300933,
-0.0340114459,
0.3792836666,
0.5319678783,
-0.4462271929,
0.0816701502,
0.547332108,
-0.1990224272,
-0.6645287275,
0.1821036637,
-1.109731555,
-0.3386249244,
0.8499125838,
-0.1017380431,
-0.2999823391,
0.1487742364,
-0.4008869529,
-0.2366023064,
-0.6213722229,
0.9860576391,
0.3972985446,
0.1959056258,
-0.2512716055,
-0.5230868459,
-0.0065464657,
-0.0893978775,
-0.7028085589,
-0.3445373476,
0.9227944016,
0.0219696555,
0.2351742536,
0.5776353478,
-0.2182619572,
0.316506952,
0.2676473558,
-0.1771483719,
-0.2590577006,
-0.3878799975,
-0.1161463782,
0.4744395316,
0.0196628757,
-0.5498577952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13781v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13781v1
|
Evaluating Retrieval Quality in Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-21T21:22:28 | 2024-04-21T21:22:28 |
Alireza Salemi, Hamed Zamani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Evaluating retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) presents challenges,
particularly for retrieval models within these systems. Traditional end-to-end
evaluation methods are computationally expensive. Furthermore, evaluation of
the retrieval model's performance based on query-document relevance labels
shows a small correlation with the RAG system's downstream performance. We
propose a novel evaluation approach, eRAG, where each document in the retrieval
list is individually utilized by the large language model within the RAG
system. The output generated for each document is then evaluated based on the
downstream task ground truth labels. In this manner, the downstream performance
for each document serves as its relevance label. We employ various downstream
task metrics to obtain document-level annotations and aggregate them using
set-based or ranking metrics. Extensive experiments on a wide range of datasets
demonstrate that eRAG achieves a higher correlation with downstream RAG
performance compared to baseline methods, with improvements in Kendall's $\tau$
correlation ranging from 0.168 to 0.494. Additionally, eRAG offers significant
computational advantages, improving runtime and consuming up to 50 times less
GPU memory than end-to-end evaluation.
|
[
-0.5384223461,
-0.7405701876,
0.3638026714,
-0.177209422,
-0.3916276395,
0.2103992701,
-0.1809538454,
-0.3639762998,
0.1640186906,
0.4343928099,
-0.2128956616,
-0.3201883137,
-0.6090521812,
0.0227532201,
-0.4287396073,
0.8832395077,
0.2449690402,
-0.1703217775,
-0.2782997191,
-0.1890877187,
-0.4052973986,
-0.3730811477,
-0.609980464,
-0.4498797655,
0.3052255511,
0.1654087156,
0.5517961979,
0.7308923006,
0.6286504865,
0.2513533533,
-0.1900686026,
0.5325580239,
-0.7764347196,
0.4751879871,
-0.2696817219,
-0.0027244033,
-0.4531102777,
0.1992544234,
0.5874131918,
0.5629426241,
-0.0722136348,
0.6656028628,
0.199429065,
0.8071236014,
-1.0031663179,
-0.3031355441,
-0.6423517466,
-0.0695380792,
-0.3237211704,
-0.698135674,
-0.7336859107,
-0.206721887,
-0.0720808953,
-0.8201909661,
0.4547844529,
0.5143472552,
1.0896608829,
0.2464727759,
-0.2448906153,
-0.4032730758,
-0.6915748715,
0.6921730638,
-0.4810341299,
0.6047215462,
0.5428948402,
0.2943506539,
-0.2281110436,
-0.8452329636,
-0.2743159533,
-0.2767346203,
-0.0649043322,
0.5788250566,
0.0302438866,
-0.0809511095,
0.1851354986,
0.7297871113,
-0.5669847131,
-0.221933797,
-0.0454671308,
0.0917117,
0.5462132692,
-0.025872618,
0.1344864964,
-0.5032447577,
-0.4905852675,
-0.1285781562,
-0.5530198812,
-0.2484674305,
0.431420058,
0.5178142786,
0.5235232711,
0.5310821533,
-0.202088818,
0.8869595528,
0.344204694,
-0.0875489563,
0.2505135834,
-0.3974352777,
-0.1420681477,
-0.3152735829,
0.4923900664,
0.3573301435,
-0.3897476792,
-0.3821282387,
-0.496871829,
-0.4453720152,
0.6169127226,
-0.7838246226,
0.1686348468,
-0.0398403145,
-0.6691403985,
-0.0597583242,
-0.0107629225,
-0.9371007085,
-0.4628649354,
-0.4651978314,
0.9276515841,
-0.4916820824,
-0.0553389341,
-0.4738745391,
-0.425577879,
0.3153941035,
0.125281781,
-0.6154195666,
0.263761133,
0.7742368579,
0.7302336097,
-0.0495325476,
0.0558863506,
-1.028675437,
0.0356194116,
-0.502636373,
0.9731749296,
-0.7165108919,
-0.7365655303,
-0.1941561401,
-0.3448733985,
-0.1304220408,
-0.6852465868,
0.8230230808,
-0.9528301954,
0.0985126197,
-0.2395524234,
-0.7180421948,
-0.0131613929,
0.1834288239,
-0.5591034293,
1.5132614374,
0.472209394,
-0.6809278727,
0.7349134088,
-0.2241420746,
-0.4396978319,
0.5034579635,
-0.0865119249,
-0.1816569716,
0.3681923151,
0.2353907228,
0.0892100111,
-0.6894947886,
0.0559195392,
0.0109893708,
-0.5919235349,
-0.1891393214,
-0.2701901793,
0.4635231793,
0.5233994722,
-0.0770362318,
-0.2835680246,
-0.8331047297,
0.1965494901,
-0.1916846633,
-0.4809301496,
-0.7303363085,
-0.0646925047,
-0.2022441477,
-0.1180671751,
0.3636779785,
-0.6230471134,
0.0338818692,
-0.1758089215,
-0.3702802956,
0.5989536643,
0.2129767984,
0.4593208134,
-0.439424932,
0.56247437,
-0.6667467356,
0.2770691514,
-0.1585351527,
-0.3279468417,
-0.8980442882,
-0.1304318905,
0.6206341386,
0.2823422551,
-0.8849093318,
0.3202779889,
-0.4593261778,
-0.5476285815,
-0.6029461622,
0.1094702706,
0.6874134541,
0.7406766415,
0.4378686547,
-0.2967984974,
-0.3757729828,
-0.7150642276,
-0.3546189964,
-0.3513869941,
-0.0407392085,
0.7166012526,
0.2195066214,
0.0741054937,
0.8239747286,
-0.3219520748,
-0.1100605801,
0.1288294941,
0.52797544,
0.2474027425,
0.2532969117,
0.3144326508,
-0.8103295565,
-0.4337584972,
0.2157779783,
-0.610586822,
-0.4449827969,
-0.0159001164,
-0.4923452735,
0.3255693316,
0.432308495,
-0.0680618659,
0.4318298697,
0.3376012444,
-0.3717979789,
0.6494647264,
-0.38233006,
0.8049834967,
-0.7633699775,
0.3898258507,
-0.1925712973,
-0.0710384026,
-0.3069959581,
0.476667583,
0.031690374,
0.0210109018,
-0.0551888682,
0.6316464543,
-0.6156433821,
-0.4235506654,
-0.3878290653,
0.3366037905,
0.2541368008,
0.0515727773,
-0.3331879079,
1.1260091066,
-0.0339157544,
-0.6889673471,
0.0130186882,
0.0561707765,
-0.0931972489,
0.7188905478,
-0.3503623903,
0.3842850924,
-0.1992524266,
0.0920660645,
-0.8616299033,
-0.0700258017,
-0.2920270264,
-0.8867756724,
0.7065984011,
-0.4491055608,
-0.5570668578,
-0.1620758027,
-0.2895466983,
0.1439758986,
0.6998031139,
-0.8036966324,
0.9211892486,
0.3990474641,
-0.0633615032,
-0.629787147,
-0.2144894004,
0.1074755788,
-0.1883788258,
-0.5482837558,
0.4746705592,
0.2785303593,
-0.0793325827,
0.1451450437,
-0.2933010757,
0.2370590717,
-0.0609948374,
0.1454823464,
0.229355827,
-0.0137594081,
0.2657607794,
0.0646522045,
-0.1973514259,
-0.2451054007,
-0.2407979816,
0.4716332853,
0.1607238799,
-0.1890119016,
0.5403354764,
0.2945227921,
0.1048179045,
-0.4654000998,
0.5678196549,
0.7702821493,
-0.2852568626,
-0.3608183265,
-0.6730591059,
0.2171767205,
-0.4467765987,
0.1175894961,
-0.6041150689,
-0.622138083,
0.5475538969,
-0.1091627702,
0.2333799452,
0.7665902972,
0.3926711679,
-0.0746173784,
0.8511711955,
0.381598711,
0.4738351703,
0.4144161344,
-0.3560782373,
0.1433449984,
-1.4038375616,
-0.3177895546,
-0.7517472506,
-0.0544994511,
-0.5553455949,
-0.6440971494,
0.5972280502,
0.7150195837,
-0.3523759544,
0.2971962392,
-0.6865338087,
0.1646393985,
0.5826516151,
0.065832749,
0.4761020541,
0.0889015421,
-0.1596504003,
0.0694104359,
-0.7226908803,
-0.6862258315,
1.3510473967,
-0.0400712043,
0.6319925189,
0.2465818375,
0.919670701,
0.6856786609,
0.8132773638,
-0.4779206216,
0.5521792769,
-0.6921203136,
-0.5580269098,
-0.1784474254,
-0.5915203691,
-1.0734330416,
0.5660858154,
-0.1939743161,
-0.6839984655,
0.1094272658,
-0.0147248106,
-0.3384526968,
0.0694321319,
-0.6639074087,
0.2710215449,
-0.1294794381,
-0.5641846061,
-0.2061737031,
-0.3934875131,
0.2519616485,
-0.2529205084,
0.2998394668,
-0.0215010364,
-0.1767905205,
0.8851519823,
-0.4862308204,
-0.0426774323,
-0.1579149216,
0.1541734785,
0.5346129537,
0.1450588554,
0.2359908372,
-0.1165444553,
-0.4688785672,
-0.1974595785,
-0.1747655869,
-0.1383574754,
-0.6426485181,
0.8962122202,
-0.5899960995,
-0.589327395,
-0.444105804,
-0.4018671513,
-0.2451226264,
0.2106757909,
0.4316038489,
0.6187810898,
-0.0895466283,
0.0670679063,
0.4663306177,
-0.5282601118,
0.288569212,
0.4565932453,
-0.5677198172,
-0.6163517833,
1.0909883976,
0.4251918197,
0.3996350765,
0.322748214,
0.1932147443,
-0.5699703097,
-0.4422035217,
-0.7440069914,
0.0913386568,
-0.8262187243,
-0.4522953331,
-0.6486011147,
-0.199442178,
-0.4712218642,
0.0154819703,
-0.2643697858,
-0.3160904646,
-0.0802704692,
0.208625257,
0.3675252795,
0.6168506742,
-0.2237188965,
0.0868597329,
-0.8781806827,
0.5579737425,
0.2048530579,
0.6128980517,
0.1401027292,
-1.0158327818,
-0.3337601423,
-0.260502696,
-0.3684732318,
-0.7557682991,
0.3183575571,
0.3349211514,
0.718659699,
-0.0803658068,
0.1158369258,
0.9454096556,
-0.5188634396,
0.7346368432,
-0.2108609825,
-0.7687219977,
0.5355992913,
-0.3948944509,
0.0139579605,
0.7650178671,
0.0917732865,
-0.1856961697,
-0.2194904238,
-0.6727874875,
-1.4391108751,
0.5769246817,
0.2541599274,
-0.1213712245,
-0.2748733759,
0.5005412102,
0.0309531651,
-0.0585531853,
-0.0203287285,
-0.3526943624,
0.1023916453,
0.1646104157,
0.3054477274,
-0.2408771515,
0.0773854777,
0.0400745831,
0.9197242856,
0.0648719594,
0.2423250973,
0.3846566081,
-0.2492010742,
-0.2122554928,
0.2769548893,
-0.0720189065,
0.7136285305,
-0.6152402759,
-0.0345891863,
0.0926984251,
-0.4404816031,
0.1789251715,
0.3890375495,
-0.3835564256,
0.240953818,
0.3211342692,
0.5437790751,
-0.0512068756,
-0.4553090632,
0.2351550162,
0.0289436635,
0.1863631904,
-0.2131671011,
-0.1207597777,
-0.3203387558,
0.0137374513,
0.9146719575,
-0.282330364,
0.6160798669,
-0.4087011516,
0.3666965067,
0.2592125833,
-0.0653460249,
0.2301950008,
0.6722154021,
0.2243700773,
-0.311473161,
0.5950810313,
-0.5305674672,
-0.3959441483,
0.5321391225,
0.4606609046,
0.8931588531,
-0.1372786462,
-0.0169451367,
0.6177482009,
0.2009230405,
0.0635220036,
0.174167648,
-0.0877110213,
-0.3501701951,
-0.7331732512,
-1.1782982349,
-0.3256000578,
-0.0790712982,
-0.8852941394,
-0.0176408906,
-0.1001568064,
-0.6201614738,
-0.0326171927,
0.0244972296,
-0.6718617082,
0.3098310828,
-0.0579854399,
0.7800141573,
-0.4383613169,
0.1451032162,
0.7506892681,
-0.5739728808,
-0.6327769756,
-0.0861409456,
-0.329539746,
-0.51147753,
0.97285074,
0.0722239092,
-0.3430702388,
0.0863208622,
-0.0217142478,
-1.0177967548,
1.1541670561,
0.0403714478,
-0.3113146424,
0.230695039,
-0.3655742705,
0.5825954676,
-0.211671114,
0.7302732468,
0.6660436392,
0.3987863362,
0.0389716886,
-1.0352334976,
-0.1262314767,
-0.4117707908,
0.3198477924,
0.5748403668,
-0.6406313777,
0.6375541091,
0.0420836918,
-0.6558825374,
0.0411507562,
0.6524579525,
0.5262439251,
0.455004245,
0.5343934298,
0.9680270553,
0.5359553099,
-0.1985715032,
1.3786528111,
-0.4258265793,
0.5912391543,
1.1262636185,
-0.2350889444,
0.9612682462,
0.3229936063,
-0.271094203,
0.1576087475,
0.5253751278,
0.2709510028,
0.3673856258,
0.2677932978,
-0.3297666907,
-0.0877735019,
-0.4997897148,
-0.2332564741,
0.1431349814,
0.4083093703,
-0.4409647286,
-0.4691300392,
-0.1789176911,
-0.192903921,
0.2954615057,
-0.4244442284,
0.7978643179,
-0.1140654907,
-0.9584620595,
0.7256985307,
-0.0651587248,
0.5405957699,
-0.244342804,
-0.3139143586,
-0.3695066273,
0.0176566541,
-0.290584743,
-0.6111057997,
0.2620790601,
0.2574510276,
-0.1355501711,
-0.2080515921,
0.8242095113,
-0.1849124283,
-0.4187767208,
0.4014950693,
0.5346531868,
0.1609877646,
0.0948848352,
-0.4349157512,
0.1402526945,
-0.2214877009,
-0.4920979142,
0.3625255227,
0.3481478393,
-0.020046657,
0.4838050902,
0.6721330881,
0.1718971133,
0.2392590195,
0.4205174744,
0.8847747445,
-0.3724214137,
-0.1754057109,
-0.3638398945,
0.4285756648,
-0.1776785553,
-0.343514353,
0.8868886232,
0.8082821965,
0.6933217049,
0.3939136863,
0.7090767026,
-0.4768757224,
0.8443028331,
-0.4776884913,
0.6535563469,
-0.6831463575,
0.3880003095,
-0.1934969127,
-1.1380425692,
0.07949581,
0.4610460103,
-0.2433056533,
0.3507548571,
0.5208368301,
0.6259980798,
0.0704435036,
-0.2111772597,
0.3096314669,
-0.1326309592,
0.3379232883,
0.2009424716,
0.7040234208,
-0.6743998528,
0.4492266178,
-0.0944897458,
-0.498783797,
-0.1273253411,
-0.7568672299,
-0.3528191745,
-0.6128129959,
-0.0738919675,
-0.6228156686,
0.3769584,
0.6201767325,
0.6631780863,
-0.3291807473,
-0.0030409987,
0.261973083,
-0.3519104123,
-0.0261125192,
-0.2968387902,
0.5936844349,
-0.747330904,
-0.6444046497,
0.3887367547,
0.2899853587,
-0.416423887,
-0.1475328058,
-0.0417189673,
-0.3496732116,
0.000224819,
0.7357455492,
0.1252065152,
-0.5781443119,
-0.2920902967,
0.0508506559,
0.0072313137,
-0.1381146014,
0.6598464251,
-0.9563806057,
0.8095055819,
0.7376343608,
0.9790824056,
0.7626402378,
0.7361931801,
0.4454653859,
-0.8097804189,
-0.2528499067,
0.3945466578,
0.143463105,
0.3929968774,
-0.4214497209,
0.85714221,
0.0405675136,
-0.8956676722,
-0.7130099535,
-0.0458501168,
-0.7120717764,
-0.0937021598,
1.2735278606,
-0.2100920826,
-0.0743160844,
0.0058093029,
0.0246871561,
0.5005207658,
-0.4566528499,
0.6066300273,
0.5644629598,
-0.2798202336,
0.0077489624,
-0.8358163834,
0.1724773496,
0.3559045494,
-0.6463319659,
0.004878026,
0.7856345177,
-0.0177332889,
0.4164710343,
0.6305245757,
-0.4526306391,
0.2533719838,
0.1406852603,
0.158668831,
-0.1070946902,
-0.1477792263,
-0.2092858404,
0.1348501742,
0.2065184861,
-0.1656405926
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13779v1
|
Automated Text Mining of Experimental Methodologies from Biomedical Literature
| 2024-04-21T21:19:36 | 2024-04-21T21:19:36 |
Ziqing Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Biomedical literature is a rapidly expanding field of science and technology.
Classification of biomedical texts is an essential part of biomedicine
research, especially in the field of biology. This work proposes the fine-tuned
DistilBERT, a methodology-specific, pre-trained generative classification
language model for mining biomedicine texts. The model has proven its
effectiveness in linguistic understanding capabilities and has reduced the size
of BERT models by 40\% but by 60\% faster. The main objective of this project
is to improve the model and assess the performance of the model compared to the
non-fine-tuned model. We used DistilBert as a support model and pre-trained on
a corpus of 32,000 abstracts and complete text articles; our results were
impressive and surpassed those of traditional literature classification methods
by using RNN or LSTM. Our aim is to integrate this highly specialised and
specific model into different research industries.
|
[
0.0041188844,
-0.757024765,
0.5589216948,
0.1065877825,
-0.3706197441,
-0.0155940559,
-0.0889713541,
-0.6358902454,
0.1171967387,
0.3699802756,
-0.3178079128,
-0.7332136631,
-0.6473579407,
0.5827213526,
-0.6282365322,
1.2150037289,
0.1367333382,
0.4388876259,
-0.1285512149,
-0.1442976594,
0.1179272532,
-0.4652917683,
-0.3451461494,
-0.5404289961,
0.7598149776,
-0.0721543133,
0.4131671786,
0.5477077365,
0.7356262207,
0.4437766671,
-0.4864705205,
0.1240801513,
-0.496655196,
0.051983647,
-0.4241129756,
-0.5886112452,
-0.4592907727,
-0.036723353,
0.2671400607,
0.8679124117,
-0.1905804425,
0.2539066672,
0.2817978859,
0.5785770416,
-0.1085865498,
0.2611888349,
-0.4321220815,
0.0900760815,
-0.3084707856,
-0.3292885125,
-0.4920077026,
-0.4571754932,
0.2467161715,
-0.387227416,
0.5295019746,
-0.0101752365,
0.7168188095,
0.2907350361,
-0.1743354648,
-0.3545906842,
-0.4456116855,
0.7006283998,
-0.7640830874,
0.0088138049,
0.3529117107,
0.1411762536,
-0.4400939047,
-1.1039786339,
-0.1779198647,
-0.4716293812,
-0.4838464558,
-0.0920038372,
-0.1394935101,
0.4607248008,
0.1627617478,
0.5309300423,
-0.5758835077,
0.2374977469,
-0.7587054968,
-0.152192086,
0.5950955749,
0.1003677174,
0.1496805549,
-0.2298726588,
-0.0068044532,
0.0400771908,
-0.1433946788,
-0.2294018418,
0.0318406299,
0.1593069583,
0.3189581931,
0.4869678319,
-0.3483612239,
0.740811348,
-0.016798161,
0.0112065552,
0.4803893268,
-0.4254229367,
-0.3309303224,
0.2432603687,
0.8391968012,
0.0220826883,
-0.1207746565,
-0.0577773228,
-0.0918352827,
-0.0387816839,
0.4546071589,
-0.9789920449,
-0.5440348983,
0.153541714,
-0.7209472656,
-0.7503801584,
-0.3287974596,
-0.488966912,
-0.3214221597,
-0.260189712,
0.3036075234,
-0.8376409411,
-0.1932157725,
0.2766219974,
-0.105119437,
-0.1670358777,
0.3556942642,
-0.5756130815,
0.1113732904,
0.3954852819,
1.0886442661,
-0.0564720631,
-0.1166905463,
-0.177320376,
-0.0208179355,
-0.0922461674,
0.739031136,
-0.3664384782,
-0.4228074253,
-0.1479855627,
0.1791061312,
0.1939765066,
-0.4564832747,
0.8035829663,
-0.5512432456,
0.0069461209,
0.0303106569,
-0.8251059055,
-0.2577406466,
0.1840581894,
-0.7734305859,
0.698469162,
0.2645247579,
-1.0085952282,
0.4026062489,
-0.7888815403,
-0.5811730623,
0.37597242,
-0.0736958757,
-0.5021628141,
0.2065488398,
-0.1209489629,
0.6122102141,
-0.255173564,
0.5032442212,
-0.3643246293,
-0.3778399229,
0.2904560864,
-0.0614393987,
1.0491703749,
0.4519056678,
-0.0746072084,
0.0797048956,
-0.801413238,
0.080856882,
-0.2655410171,
-0.3997798264,
-0.8167111874,
-0.0445104949,
0.3907283545,
-0.2063179165,
0.1631440222,
-0.6963136792,
0.3363510966,
-0.6712163687,
0.7242335081,
0.3117605746,
-0.1705403179,
0.344204396,
-0.3140025437,
0.1738332957,
-0.1143878922,
0.1578270346,
0.0086706784,
-0.2500943244,
-0.3374634683,
-0.6243509054,
0.8486480713,
0.3521125019,
-0.5132553577,
0.7156108022,
0.0383482873,
-0.8043264747,
-0.8213266134,
-0.11176458,
0.2089319229,
0.5119042993,
0.5366784334,
-0.2407578081,
-0.5506004691,
-0.9574546814,
0.0457675681,
-0.1916844696,
-0.0412952341,
-0.1498948336,
0.470122993,
-0.7624575496,
0.9474123716,
-0.6133319139,
-0.2949612141,
-0.2583322227,
0.6446890235,
0.5005068779,
0.5298759937,
0.7921255827,
-0.8646866083,
-0.3220097423,
0.2087066621,
-0.8366763592,
-0.486305356,
0.2745118141,
-0.11741025,
-0.0947525278,
0.7446267605,
-0.3557252884,
0.3748311102,
0.3444063663,
-0.1040012389,
0.491476357,
-0.6008357406,
0.4656755328,
-1.0099178553,
0.3425014317,
0.1173802316,
-0.324151516,
-0.6591206193,
-0.0266419239,
0.0926743895,
0.2613149285,
-0.2583878934,
0.3590791821,
-0.3817841113,
0.5530471206,
-0.3884275556,
-0.5079479814,
0.0295732301,
0.0543775111,
0.146255061,
0.3617721498,
0.4264757931,
-0.7682984471,
0.393065244,
0.3633601069,
-0.476918757,
0.2470060438,
-0.8452570438,
-0.3306648135,
-0.3464806974,
0.2525401115,
-0.7147609591,
-0.1675468087,
-0.1878069788,
-0.3735705018,
0.4537368417,
0.0445006229,
-0.6524329782,
-0.4388766885,
-0.2161604911,
0.2872314751,
0.6183887124,
-0.2459295094,
0.3766182661,
0.3671636879,
-0.4845698774,
-0.3299748302,
-0.5961958766,
-0.2869822681,
-0.1652904451,
-0.1961431801,
0.734290421,
-0.0224169903,
-0.1227546707,
0.1138847768,
0.1814060658,
-0.4328400791,
0.0122082783,
0.0963405147,
0.2934899926,
0.0283628087,
0.4576786458,
0.5827508569,
0.130387038,
-0.0954268351,
-0.068464689,
0.2735534608,
0.1607257277,
-0.0436585695,
-0.2309391201,
0.1438313276,
0.619576931,
0.0209364872,
0.6824911237,
0.6438159943,
-0.2090158314,
-0.0445743166,
-0.3309261501,
-0.3462182879,
-0.4365571439,
0.783944428,
0.0732271671,
-0.7341551185,
0.3384554684,
-0.4474576116,
0.0383247212,
0.4911925495,
0.5303964019,
-0.3573606908,
0.7850534916,
0.832239449,
-0.1451588422,
0.2814323604,
-0.1606717706,
-0.1877476126,
-0.3976189196,
-0.2028769553,
-0.8417556286,
-0.3974433839,
-0.5497502685,
-0.3787482083,
0.5141495466,
0.1122124419,
0.049304232,
0.3744936585,
-0.7884135842,
0.3419890702,
0.3236652017,
0.3635112345,
0.5542644858,
0.0893317536,
-0.3507454991,
0.2207942903,
-0.7731289268,
-0.7180342674,
1.1301300526,
0.511231482,
0.8847966194,
-0.2267678082,
0.9085296392,
0.401032269,
0.7621986866,
-0.6248018742,
0.3113427758,
-0.3098091185,
-1.0695935488,
-0.3365351856,
-0.4153355658,
-1.0113288164,
-0.0415160321,
-0.311650008,
-0.3813197017,
0.0953497663,
0.2271303684,
-0.5024659634,
0.0142877614,
-0.4503824115,
0.6099674702,
-0.3033604324,
-0.2553089261,
-0.3527345657,
-0.6741046906,
0.2435497493,
-0.4407505095,
0.2536219656,
0.0214349516,
0.2625742853,
0.7220804691,
-0.4424144328,
0.841606617,
-0.0774659738,
0.1119242758,
0.1300880462,
-0.1329895109,
0.1098688915,
0.1712842733,
-0.3580578268,
0.4506135881,
0.5498438478,
-0.3000128865,
-0.0313618891,
0.457444191,
-0.6256762743,
-0.0909186527,
-0.621640563,
-0.3342241943,
0.00873488,
0.2249311954,
0.7354723215,
0.2187884599,
-0.5408711433,
0.2559271455,
0.7885038257,
-0.4301930368,
0.1541480422,
0.7104046941,
-0.1863840818,
-0.0278384574,
0.3201701343,
-0.0124196261,
-0.1563425064,
0.4843075871,
0.0791650712,
-0.4802374542,
-0.9704860449,
-0.2025499046,
0.1568949521,
-0.321762234,
-0.3925088346,
-0.9093279243,
-0.4011075497,
-0.3315995634,
-0.01486063,
-0.1008308083,
-0.1941527724,
-0.5864958763,
-0.1696168184,
0.7734284401,
0.6972705126,
-0.1113685817,
0.394227922,
-1.1199384928,
0.2429792881,
-0.1131882221,
0.4423257411,
-0.2480331808,
-0.4818634391,
-0.4218309522,
-0.1297034621,
-0.2917712331,
-1.003025651,
0.5904399753,
0.3973133266,
0.690272212,
0.1811089069,
0.117581889,
0.4887633324,
-0.7406747937,
0.2265945673,
0.2203502953,
-0.5487937927,
0.7606960535,
-0.2798641324,
0.0668274835,
1.0423997641,
0.6421352029,
-0.048968181,
-0.4718215168,
-0.4752549231,
-0.8299279809,
0.6138627529,
0.2683311403,
-0.1512488127,
0.0577045605,
0.452709496,
0.6148297787,
0.2788034081,
-0.6620343924,
-0.0559938364,
0.2194854468,
-0.6486850381,
-0.1117908955,
-0.1808147579,
-0.1357027888,
-0.6357406378,
0.6326852441,
0.0313664451,
-0.0446111001,
0.5424221158,
-0.4497385919,
0.1160620525,
0.16998218,
0.1645543724,
0.4813892543,
-0.4494441152,
-0.1555576771,
0.1172484979,
-0.7577252388,
0.238348648,
0.6798652411,
-0.1709934771,
0.3987525403,
0.4853118062,
0.1799418032,
0.0658601597,
-0.7763977647,
0.1516848356,
-0.1122119054,
-0.3725762665,
-0.0688941032,
0.1344778389,
-0.1524256468,
0.3186261058,
0.2967979014,
0.0724678114,
0.8676276207,
-0.3604291081,
0.3634470999,
0.1791139096,
-0.4277605116,
-0.1906467378,
0.4547828734,
0.3577387035,
-0.038626451,
0.398683548,
-0.2518848181,
-0.2338719219,
0.5707876086,
0.1843053102,
0.5938791037,
-0.3971059322,
0.3054369688,
0.3407319784,
0.0921125785,
-0.3297433555,
0.0186378974,
0.0499673784,
-0.4084946215,
-0.5634426475,
-1.3169227839,
-0.1407047063,
0.3979682326,
-0.5460026264,
0.6057416797,
-0.0959039703,
-0.4036708772,
0.5402986407,
-0.0936103836,
-0.4443104863,
0.1215845719,
-0.1535664648,
0.8996138573,
-0.8702989817,
1.1023222208,
0.9141173363,
-0.2410932779,
-0.4783420265,
-0.3531577289,
-0.2106370628,
-0.1950183064,
0.9484044313,
0.0367922746,
0.1503842324,
0.0146193244,
-0.4488757849,
-0.5034807324,
0.9870134592,
0.1935865283,
-1.0562374592,
-0.0507311411,
-0.1338834018,
1.0206121206,
-0.1382311583,
0.4368377328,
0.5698254704,
0.2759873569,
0.0667903572,
-1.2969349623,
-0.2505606115,
-0.4214841127,
-0.0500219539,
0.1261154115,
-0.1010895893,
0.7972601652,
0.1135649756,
0.1150572151,
0.3729481399,
0.3927700222,
0.2118128836,
0.5941006541,
0.3026585877,
0.4141334891,
0.7706193924,
0.0060221311,
0.6438044906,
-0.1846821308,
0.5086584687,
0.6627815366,
-0.3974829912,
0.343781054,
0.1719435155,
-0.3492967486,
0.5335605741,
0.8224382997,
-0.0316015296,
0.700522542,
0.5083546042,
-0.2405066192,
0.0255851801,
0.1229303181,
-0.6906212568,
0.3908090889,
0.4193898141,
-0.7839197516,
-0.084332414,
0.3635629714,
-0.1864223182,
0.2409215122,
-0.4481076896,
0.8163478374,
0.0479408614,
-0.3360210657,
0.5142797828,
0.0743545443,
0.8725810051,
-0.7155660391,
-0.0256315358,
-0.0724830329,
0.4270046055,
-0.2132697105,
-0.4366993308,
0.4166631699,
0.1351014227,
-0.2691763043,
0.1233162582,
0.8124683499,
-0.5626443624,
-0.9146286845,
0.3244473338,
0.333714366,
0.2338442951,
0.2518996596,
-0.7247280478,
-0.1255385876,
-0.0311559942,
-0.1355615407,
0.2381421924,
0.7730426192,
0.0290130898,
0.4017607272,
0.3908860385,
0.4243027568,
-0.4523520172,
-0.1145323813,
0.9693289995,
-0.6285262108,
-0.4876519144,
-1.129989624,
0.2934431136,
-0.4701526463,
-0.0094832536,
0.3412038386,
0.6164226532,
0.4844931662,
-0.3155271709,
0.8973203301,
-0.1026287824,
0.7697610259,
-0.3806436956,
1.1704343557,
-0.5021979809,
0.1006789878,
-0.5024786592,
-0.5909617543,
-0.3737047017,
0.8171685934,
0.0367950648,
-0.0791891217,
0.8144589663,
0.5659222007,
-0.1543194056,
0.1084757447,
0.0164942592,
0.4315822721,
0.1703031957,
0.2288878709,
0.5055938959,
-0.1184059381,
0.2680589259,
-0.1497578472,
-0.8011305928,
-0.4502725303,
-0.9982143641,
-0.8801492453,
-0.6332115531,
-0.4249469936,
-0.2043930739,
0.1614892781,
0.8596143126,
0.8181127906,
-0.7687693834,
-0.0373901427,
-0.2304700166,
-0.3052514195,
-0.1666928828,
-0.1475946158,
0.2777508199,
-0.5031064153,
-0.6795591712,
0.0923784524,
0.3973217309,
0.0811013058,
-0.1561659575,
0.1937418431,
-0.3708713949,
-0.050394915,
0.6568798423,
0.1661889106,
-0.188591212,
0.3567391336,
-0.0171317793,
-0.2138173133,
-0.36317873,
0.7336878777,
-0.8863346577,
0.3434196413,
0.4074617326,
0.4589027762,
0.4674237072,
-0.1240553483,
0.5772301555,
-0.6494621634,
0.4044411778,
0.6264448166,
0.242749989,
0.1463426948,
-0.5062406659,
0.6140884161,
0.0598729663,
-0.7826698422,
-0.8980247378,
-0.0619523041,
-0.8636997342,
-0.7271581292,
0.9868870974,
-0.0352137946,
-0.2614593506,
-0.3714831173,
-0.5854461789,
0.5398162603,
-0.1348841339,
0.9786219597,
0.5625302196,
-0.2402358502,
0.3869112432,
-0.4879955649,
0.8061539531,
0.229704693,
-0.7518010139,
-0.1774988174,
0.4843069017,
0.1751920283,
0.3033966422,
0.8011934757,
-0.2478910089,
0.0798418224,
-0.4918911755,
0.2215321809,
-0.0267715361,
-0.1279239208,
-0.1469822079,
0.1749943346,
0.2212280184,
0.0256943591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13764v1
|
Using Adaptive Empathetic Responses for Teaching English
| 2024-04-21T20:21:24 | 2024-04-21T20:21:24 |
Li Siyan, Teresa Shao, Zhou Yu, Julia Hirschberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing English-teaching chatbots rarely incorporate empathy explicitly in
their feedback, but empathetic feedback could help keep students engaged and
reduce learner anxiety. Toward this end, we propose the task of negative
emotion detection via audio, for recognizing empathetic feedback opportunities
in language learning. We then build the first spoken English-teaching chatbot
with adaptive, empathetic feedback. This feedback is synthesized through
automatic prompt optimization of ChatGPT and is evaluated with English
learners. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our system through a preliminary
user study.
|
[
-0.4698590338,
-0.9427404404,
0.3065374792,
0.1452605873,
0.0483416244,
0.1163331717,
-0.4899081886,
-0.203846544,
0.4187062681,
-0.271974057,
-0.5853155851,
-0.4156012833,
-0.5825482607,
0.1870413423,
-0.2016062438,
0.8975141644,
0.1092771664,
0.2963739038,
0.0911838636,
-0.1984337717,
-0.5842217207,
-0.3754641414,
-1.4228359461,
-0.3541405797,
0.4185493588,
0.9758726954,
0.3803712726,
-0.2078241557,
0.2217710167,
0.3380644917,
0.3594046533,
-0.0173714571,
-0.1905166507,
0.2427494079,
-0.1300216913,
-0.4644853175,
-0.5077434182,
-0.0650208965,
0.2500879169,
0.0241257809,
-0.3648270369,
-0.0305049531,
0.2217885256,
0.3446771204,
-0.4251531661,
-0.0340070948,
-0.2308430672,
0.4991941452,
0.3784835041,
-0.4630276263,
-0.6027522087,
-0.3910378814,
0.1891865581,
-0.606292069,
-0.1408091336,
0.0171760395,
0.4382426441,
0.3756931722,
-0.2466917336,
-0.6115301847,
-0.4995674789,
1.0115427971,
-0.6042926908,
0.5486842394,
0.5483880043,
0.4986742139,
0.2685569525,
-0.147046566,
-0.5498654842,
-0.3129777312,
0.2062611878,
0.8400992751,
-0.3394712806,
0.0837951973,
-0.1385110766,
0.1087416559,
-0.555840373,
0.3077906072,
-0.1697003394,
-0.0351833291,
0.4938386679,
0.1644903272,
0.7539172173,
-0.0809781104,
0.1953890175,
-0.0421223529,
-0.0472399183,
0.1190206036,
0.48562783,
0.2694727778,
-0.4243324399,
0.2317513078,
0.4880068302,
0.4234993458,
0.1408455521,
-0.1504316926,
0.1770334989,
0.420799911,
0.0045065177,
0.1900341362,
0.4933412373,
0.8554659486,
0.4760448039,
0.1241704822,
-0.0249167364,
0.4663975239,
0.1678819805,
-0.85159266,
-0.2104444057,
0.6229983568,
-0.1895897239,
-0.2395818084,
-0.6092748046,
-0.9978014231,
-0.4026351273,
-0.1057097912,
0.6338432431,
-0.6887441874,
-0.3091466129,
0.2196656168,
-0.392108947,
0.2095156461,
0.6510854959,
-0.8630611897,
0.5687984228,
0.3907217979,
0.9195203781,
0.1445474476,
-0.4433508515,
-0.4887205064,
-0.3567261994,
0.0520646311,
0.9062651396,
-0.6957754493,
-0.4387917519,
0.0237396639,
0.1917690635,
0.043969281,
-0.2429364324,
0.5604595542,
0.2243817449,
0.8313559294,
0.1984831542,
-0.8836985826,
-0.0940123349,
0.738547802,
-0.2792183757,
0.6841509342,
0.2517618537,
-0.6917425394,
0.0630824715,
-0.8648831844,
-0.3692319095,
-0.0938543156,
0.2544891536,
-0.2985500693,
-0.0740598962,
0.2255389541,
0.3314667344,
-0.1173768565,
-0.2550520897,
-0.1377298385,
-0.4818938375,
0.0574422739,
-0.3237505853,
0.5227942467,
0.1407524496,
-0.5343591571,
-0.0967170969,
-0.678206861,
-0.0960908309,
0.1628985703,
-0.1346535534,
-0.2685415149,
0.1936454624,
0.0628612041,
0.0099922447,
-0.2934997976,
-0.7286901474,
0.043595016,
-0.3243193924,
0.215703398,
0.8372954726,
0.1403848678,
0.2503535151,
-0.4260695577,
1.1520924568,
-0.1355236024,
0.0657432601,
-0.3263702691,
-0.2711659074,
-0.7970968485,
-0.0996375382,
-0.3222061992,
0.7839764953,
-0.3211442232,
0.3298587203,
0.2479421496,
-0.7176118493,
-1.0343585014,
-0.043253202,
0.2458459586,
0.5119590163,
0.3813885748,
-0.2802629471,
-0.5263318419,
-0.384486109,
-0.4910291433,
-0.1230490729,
-0.0353940725,
0.6063044071,
-0.0066656647,
-0.1683738828,
0.3583911359,
-0.4167331755,
-0.3063763678,
-0.0020519025,
-0.0146525064,
-0.0089659151,
0.3523289561,
0.5747942328,
-0.4325212836,
-0.9098248482,
0.094200857,
-0.3301017284,
-0.3119824231,
-0.1939333379,
-0.0553830825,
0.225973472,
0.2000809014,
-0.2754294276,
0.051892858,
0.7880946398,
-0.4820758402,
0.0822728276,
0.0350809991,
0.4840911329,
-1.1185560226,
-0.3173621595,
0.0668981299,
-0.3524300754,
-0.3780837059,
-0.4727104902,
-0.1374967694,
-0.2838775814,
-0.5082537532,
0.6398909688,
-0.1715070009,
0.2301239073,
-0.4562594593,
0.6085564494,
-0.0400996022,
0.4861635566,
0.1464977115,
0.454077661,
0.6318264604,
-0.4486917257,
0.577898562,
0.4211820066,
0.3143414855,
1.1793259382,
-0.4670296311,
0.3585681319,
-0.2834491134,
0.1309020519,
-1.0032185316,
-0.1001836509,
0.2453866154,
-0.9322163463,
0.3546923995,
-0.2786544859,
0.2414523214,
-0.4611666203,
-0.5666656494,
-0.0791002139,
0.8970584869,
-0.6214250922,
0.5738763809,
0.3217113614,
-0.3603053391,
-0.3556494415,
-0.6567780375,
-0.2426405102,
-0.1352364719,
-0.2972468734,
-0.3012241423,
-0.3787311018,
-0.2941685021,
0.0661314949,
0.0775246024,
-0.0062608691,
0.2088629156,
0.291258812,
-0.2077216357,
0.0619006045,
0.5697466135,
0.1741615236,
-0.184442699,
0.2437764108,
0.0083962465,
0.6285919547,
-0.1704326123,
-0.4084544778,
-0.667980969,
0.1348997951,
0.5149680376,
0.0796106607,
0.3409217596,
0.9031894207,
-0.2873921096,
-0.4420512915,
-0.2006062418,
-0.5385067463,
-0.476198107,
0.5028988719,
0.0553473942,
-0.9039156437,
0.3367961347,
0.1683093607,
0.0199130457,
-0.0619279034,
0.7265631557,
-0.2267896682,
1.1198982,
0.1996245086,
-0.0173775665,
0.7758180499,
0.1820684224,
0.3101395965,
-0.5075888038,
0.0541352257,
-0.5421828032,
-0.3595901728,
-0.61027807,
0.150870204,
0.0182678886,
-0.5737153888,
-0.3951480389,
0.0705927387,
-0.6353559494,
0.351236999,
0.3984864056,
0.2789113224,
-0.1933659613,
-0.4798436463,
0.4910052121,
-0.3125922978,
-0.3379118443,
-0.3543651402,
0.6860923171,
0.4587486982,
0.9556684494,
0.2708359063,
0.988945961,
0.272551775,
0.6169233322,
-1.1649323702,
0.2290274799,
-0.0127910562,
-0.3399705589,
-0.3654518723,
-0.1402906328,
-0.8662318587,
-0.0845297873,
-0.0255765803,
-0.5300143957,
-0.3359246552,
0.4165989757,
-0.2787199616,
0.244609803,
-1.3150873184,
0.6336580515,
-0.1758244038,
-0.4336360991,
-0.2083680481,
-0.324218452,
-0.2654826045,
-0.1127680317,
0.4123805165,
-0.1701718867,
0.1420884281,
0.6720616817,
-0.2960394025,
0.9835833311,
-0.779148519,
-0.2268831581,
0.4881532788,
0.5209189653,
0.2872531712,
0.0513861142,
-0.1036180109,
-0.6450738907,
-0.2089318782,
-0.4497997165,
-0.8787398338,
0.5437497497,
-0.8103747368,
-0.7222186327,
-0.0821567178,
-0.3140883446,
-0.2993493676,
-0.0543959625,
0.1697830707,
-0.0262459796,
-0.1955208927,
0.0524828136,
0.0733858272,
-0.5956944227,
0.476354003,
0.8577201366,
-0.2676348686,
-0.2234060764,
0.9446901083,
-0.0360545404,
0.0989772603,
0.3556364775,
0.5379654169,
0.0376486033,
0.0582445338,
-0.0955789536,
-0.1715897918,
-0.6521056294,
-0.3390307426,
-0.6369391084,
0.1869920045,
-0.2877469659,
-0.7594873309,
-0.6332640648,
-0.3327102363,
-0.1934520304,
-0.4961177409,
0.7864469886,
0.716863811,
-0.3415628672,
0.3797391057,
-0.8839856386,
-0.2330131531,
0.5516974926,
0.3826107979,
0.1115199104,
-0.7717123628,
-0.1793577969,
-0.0006704691,
-0.4868455231,
-0.9226258993,
0.787357688,
0.5303762555,
0.0849038288,
0.3332484961,
0.0555556901,
0.2561399937,
-0.3726250827,
0.9482399821,
0.1614686996,
-1.3037316799,
0.9025776386,
-0.2393443286,
0.1312874407,
0.226821512,
0.6807470918,
-0.8746882677,
-0.6907866597,
-0.5841795802,
-0.7296432853,
0.6750620604,
-0.1027862355,
0.7032107711,
-0.1911327988,
0.0047448664,
0.2502797842,
-0.2302108854,
-0.7573244572,
-0.0924726203,
-0.424162209,
-0.6530869603,
-0.0620645173,
-0.1078018323,
-0.0514871404,
-0.3164863288,
0.806035161,
-0.1020557359,
0.5821433067,
0.2339339405,
-0.1342189312,
-0.4146503508,
0.4952298999,
0.3711918294,
0.0399682485,
-0.4288927317,
0.1712749451,
0.5127079487,
-0.7567610741,
0.4444317818,
-0.2312782705,
0.44678846,
0.115052186,
0.4082109928,
0.6578097939,
0.3580123484,
-0.8129326105,
0.9221408367,
-0.330750972,
-0.0645669773,
-0.4292122424,
0.1436538696,
0.192796886,
0.3119213581,
-0.0661443919,
-0.1851701438,
0.2069221288,
-0.2783536315,
0.433896035,
-0.0680509806,
-0.6960670948,
-0.6616168022,
0.3520891964,
0.5871044993,
-0.8760133386,
0.5760192275,
-0.1877672821,
-0.9990524054,
0.5284103155,
0.971047163,
1.024721384,
-0.799115479,
0.3649295866,
0.4366627634,
0.1485138834,
0.5522415042,
0.8005340695,
-0.1175589487,
-0.8867733479,
-0.051008977,
-0.1400264353,
-1.1590029001,
-0.442522198,
-0.9446395636,
0.5007486939,
-0.5560997128,
-0.0278088991,
0.0269663706,
-0.1193822175,
-0.723200202,
0.3944945335,
0.1038882583,
0.6027126908,
-1.1723835468,
0.4908568561,
0.9416320324,
-0.3238296211,
-0.8524594903,
-0.1894982904,
0.2075047791,
-1.1544789076,
0.4984961748,
0.1584702432,
-0.3076809347,
0.2402921617,
-0.5598855019,
-0.0868702754,
0.8157538772,
0.3437927663,
-0.5379090905,
0.4233656824,
-0.4578329921,
0.8154020905,
-0.0986700952,
0.9207212329,
0.1873554885,
0.3850956261,
-0.3142479956,
-0.7081760168,
-0.2569372654,
-0.5235664248,
-0.6192671657,
0.1539998949,
-0.964104712,
0.5749233365,
-0.0786615908,
-0.1081514731,
-0.4588098526,
0.1400291473,
-0.1240914837,
0.4909265041,
0.5681459904,
0.4757378101,
0.7988578677,
0.0253324062,
0.926949501,
-0.4874213636,
0.4770520329,
0.9699133635,
-0.2879033089,
1.0342338085,
0.5948895216,
-0.3825357556,
0.553859055,
0.5991213918,
0.0849599466,
0.1008269638,
0.1677227914,
-0.4262560606,
0.0614057817,
-0.3810317814,
-0.0988089219,
0.4874691069,
0.3784540296,
-0.2081029564,
0.0187912825,
0.5494876504,
0.3482945561,
0.0311617572,
-0.3384485543,
0.650108397,
0.132134378,
-0.5548170209,
0.4255875647,
-0.4067302942,
0.8811374903,
-0.3041631281,
-0.1647002697,
-0.4653569758,
0.1648691893,
-0.4847042859,
-0.8843339682,
0.1309564859,
0.219199419,
0.1755041331,
-0.1747710407,
0.5999078751,
-0.710526228,
0.0199534595,
0.7556994557,
0.3032871783,
0.1526383013,
0.2928580344,
-0.3413628638,
-0.0484253541,
0.0208755936,
-0.4908777177,
0.030022433,
0.5343001485,
0.5496727228,
0.6390872002,
0.2129039913,
-0.0829721838,
-0.312874794,
0.3805669844,
0.626362443,
-0.7715792656,
-0.5298043489,
-0.7982187271,
0.5724095702,
0.1922052056,
-0.1368423849,
0.850338757,
0.0269428268,
0.7548487782,
-0.327077508,
0.9093567133,
-0.0512617901,
0.7354143858,
-0.2353680581,
0.467577219,
-0.7494100332,
-0.1112440601,
-0.6666954756,
-0.7467862964,
-0.3888867795,
0.8612892032,
-0.0601150654,
-0.0242228452,
0.798122108,
0.7586228848,
0.1600687504,
0.3750276268,
0.5841520429,
0.214698866,
0.3073741496,
0.7898548841,
1.0802106857,
-0.4536977708,
0.3409421146,
-0.2799003422,
-0.32920596,
-0.193867594,
-0.7790160775,
-0.8109756708,
-0.3959432542,
-0.4356879294,
-0.5089446902,
0.1403626651,
1.3951476812,
0.3366403282,
-0.8894879222,
-0.0979068503,
-0.1000994965,
0.038906049,
0.066985555,
-0.2988891602,
0.4122767746,
-0.5058998466,
-1.0638002157,
0.1312674284,
0.312220335,
0.366083771,
0.0774319991,
-0.5282056332,
0.1323098689,
0.2147406191,
0.6397806406,
0.3213892579,
-0.0693383887,
-0.782361567,
0.1482751667,
0.0669791698,
-0.002389733,
0.4158119261,
-0.0704515949,
0.6942910552,
0.2088239938,
0.881931603,
0.1000265554,
-0.2535886467,
0.624969244,
-0.5726640224,
0.486798197,
0.6062962413,
0.2812616229,
0.4221006632,
-0.4397252798,
0.5446419716,
0.0934560895,
-0.761502564,
-0.8176757693,
-0.1347074211,
-0.7967144847,
0.1544309705,
1.015930295,
-0.3523342311,
-0.1049534455,
0.125273034,
-0.7081112266,
0.2432163209,
-0.6759724617,
0.7783400416,
0.8777389526,
-0.3350699842,
-0.4956176579,
-0.1879056245,
0.3390849531,
0.8052231073,
-0.8262268305,
-0.2166966647,
0.2708352208,
0.0627694353,
-0.1325341165,
0.6394287348,
0.1754380912,
0.587415576,
0.1748313159,
0.5011637211,
0.322576493,
-0.0658750311,
-0.5838538408,
-0.1277750731,
0.4373228848,
-0.2599820495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13760v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13760v1
|
How to Encode Domain Information in Relation Classification
| 2024-04-21T20:16:35 | 2024-04-21T20:16:35 |
Elisa Bassignana, Viggo Unmack Gascou, Frida Nøhr Laustsen, Gustav Kristensen, Marie Haahr Petersen, Rob van der Goot, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current language models require a lot of training data to obtain high
performance. For Relation Classification (RC), many datasets are
domain-specific, so combining datasets to obtain better performance is
non-trivial. We explore a multi-domain training setup for RC, and attempt to
improve performance by encoding domain information. Our proposed models improve
> 2 Macro-F1 against the baseline setup, and our analysis reveals that not all
the labels benefit the same: The classes which occupy a similar space across
domains (i.e., their interpretation is close across them, for example
"physical") benefit the least, while domain-dependent relations (e.g.,
"part-of'') improve the most when encoding domain information.
|
[
-0.5138379335,
-0.1095970497,
0.1113435254,
-0.0154094445,
-0.0179278348,
0.063548103,
-0.2663730681,
-0.7934964895,
-0.0350179635,
0.3951364756,
-0.4703520834,
-0.3116200566,
-0.8451153636,
0.0750071928,
0.2234728336,
1.1572953463,
0.0663898066,
0.2128803134,
-0.6129463315,
-0.4085474908,
-0.2527124286,
-1.3135641813,
-0.3714155853,
-0.4601902962,
0.3850392103,
0.4082172513,
0.893666327,
0.7102612257,
0.6507080793,
0.1953204274,
-0.0500306189,
0.6952370405,
-0.486141026,
0.1130747721,
-0.1087904572,
-0.3411767483,
-0.6301116347,
-0.0156755969,
0.5026740432,
0.9979674816,
0.1741994917,
0.0073944749,
-0.0260530822,
0.5463680029,
-0.8791747093,
0.599509716,
-0.2694170773,
-0.0780240819,
-0.1357620209,
-0.4323430955,
-0.6875933409,
-0.0670928806,
0.2434127778,
-0.6782957911,
0.3972902596,
0.2991520762,
1.0493099689,
-0.0807195231,
-0.6680604219,
-0.0919405371,
-1.035826683,
0.7309333682,
-0.4452436864,
0.8053746223,
0.5848585367,
0.2392793894,
0.1023013517,
-0.483222574,
-0.249232918,
0.2683689594,
-0.4736388326,
-0.0286916513,
0.1095488295,
0.159123674,
0.3431313932,
0.334879756,
-0.456171751,
-0.1386374235,
-0.2173156291,
-0.0300578754,
0.5695584416,
0.2387384921,
0.2000695169,
0.0962765887,
-0.3031030297,
-0.2206788063,
-0.8384613395,
-0.0909694657,
0.1197855324,
0.5108711123,
0.1093303189,
0.3114718795,
-0.0167692546,
0.8513033986,
-0.0266548619,
-0.4018234313,
0.2520992458,
-0.190160796,
-0.2103027105,
-0.1999153495,
0.583884418,
0.2729534209,
0.6684345603,
-0.3652587235,
-0.1348589212,
0.2683460116,
0.1791188568,
-0.9420516491,
-0.3598798513,
-0.0409367532,
-0.2220635563,
0.052983243,
0.1750968695,
-0.4016826153,
0.0435354002,
-0.6543249488,
0.2134456933,
-0.502014339,
-0.2785097361,
0.0899577811,
-0.1330475509,
0.1127656177,
0.2329497635,
-1.2297309637,
0.7951309085,
0.5791662931,
0.4159218073,
0.0057478673,
-0.352140218,
-0.5460215211,
0.5592194796,
-0.0315555297,
0.8383027911,
-0.8410425186,
-0.2982982993,
0.2839158177,
-0.0809965655,
-0.3406529725,
-0.742887795,
0.0190000553,
-0.9845600128,
0.043981608,
-0.1339703351,
-0.8236902356,
0.0962283239,
0.0208600145,
-0.8795695305,
0.6607696414,
0.4186188579,
-1.0723488331,
0.5006132126,
-0.2751069367,
-0.6606516838,
0.0133392783,
-0.2599923909,
-0.4078094959,
-0.1129227653,
0.161662519,
0.5741147995,
-0.2186758667,
0.0600315854,
-0.2817694545,
-0.1201022342,
0.3878075182,
0.1043094844,
0.4551617801,
0.128273502,
0.2753272951,
-0.3345167041,
-0.7099496126,
0.0056957514,
-0.1075173691,
-0.3388406634,
-0.7284649611,
-0.2414323241,
-0.0479528978,
0.2136639953,
0.0824104846,
-0.2148117274,
0.4038010538,
-0.2341334075,
-0.0016177378,
0.3088357747,
0.2626798749,
0.84918648,
-0.3568447232,
0.5763757229,
0.408259362,
-0.0020616273,
0.2216499895,
-0.5875528455,
-0.6907762289,
-0.0788407251,
0.8812012672,
0.3905084431,
-0.8579161167,
0.1023295149,
-0.5403928161,
0.0606305525,
-0.2670665383,
0.1472495049,
0.5978190899,
0.1062263325,
0.4906042516,
-0.5003168583,
-0.5042824745,
-0.7551819682,
-0.0063225576,
0.0323100016,
0.209692806,
0.3616420329,
0.5239656568,
-0.3568693995,
0.9347046018,
-0.968388319,
-0.4195996523,
-0.2515347004,
0.0612013973,
-0.059045732,
0.3181488514,
0.6636900902,
-1.093172431,
-0.684307754,
0.1528010964,
-0.7122552991,
0.3683731556,
0.1540605277,
-0.2497976273,
-0.1307459921,
0.1603274941,
-0.4829412401,
0.3507449627,
0.1338696629,
0.0170414485,
0.386115402,
-0.1179888919,
0.0409964211,
-0.6559848189,
-0.2704975903,
0.2939009368,
-0.3146436214,
-1.1501301527,
0.051631622,
0.1174842194,
-0.0436798036,
-0.3027305603,
0.3372177184,
-0.7106264234,
0.1027168259,
-0.2327328473,
0.1025748923,
0.098868899,
0.8902266026,
0.5059719086,
0.6518417597,
0.5513225198,
-1.0476716757,
0.2087411284,
0.6455180049,
-0.1036183015,
0.5258740187,
0.0589553751,
0.2779129148,
-0.2030601948,
0.1720240116,
-0.5682125092,
-0.5232769251,
-0.0408627726,
-0.6236070395,
0.8602029085,
-0.3012126982,
-0.4773225188,
-0.0510817617,
-0.2267408669,
0.6565034389,
0.3387889564,
-0.8419185877,
0.4229184389,
0.6675676703,
0.2111317366,
-0.7319039702,
-0.5676336288,
-0.470667243,
-0.0755887553,
-0.5346588492,
0.6678141356,
0.1565252542,
-0.0716602281,
0.2882548273,
-0.2965556979,
-0.729504168,
-0.3451119065,
0.1866344661,
0.0683958456,
-0.1648501903,
0.4417823553,
-0.0953512043,
-0.0807043612,
0.027418483,
-0.1428955644,
0.1948190331,
0.1148035228,
0.1993781626,
-0.2837596238,
0.3793076873,
0.4989842474,
-0.238894105,
1.3162419796,
0.1061454341,
-0.7038120627,
-0.5846391916,
-0.0740457103,
-0.062284518,
-0.4303584099,
0.080634594,
-0.8891429305,
-0.8383011222,
0.3163448274,
-0.4531240463,
-0.1186700314,
0.352275461,
0.068946436,
0.0053010038,
0.9049117565,
1.0187786818,
-0.2126405984,
0.3089959323,
-0.6178302765,
0.3473882675,
-0.9498086572,
-0.5368373394,
-0.5121895075,
0.1803552657,
-0.3588046432,
-0.3510837257,
0.0906671658,
0.2500886321,
-0.2564782202,
0.8465890884,
-0.369959712,
0.3362832367,
0.2971858978,
0.2167417258,
0.4291397929,
0.1718678623,
0.1746094823,
-0.3689160347,
-1.2150988579,
-0.2694805861,
0.9898683429,
0.2499421835,
0.8864320517,
0.3044089675,
0.5835412741,
0.0043148906,
0.5876357555,
-0.7145854831,
0.1960935146,
-0.5363747478,
-0.5344896913,
-0.0440233909,
-0.8050226569,
-0.812538445,
0.1672510058,
-0.258980751,
-0.3809999228,
0.4970332086,
0.246412918,
-0.1499370933,
0.1510452479,
-0.5135663748,
0.816847086,
-0.1419478059,
-0.1874506474,
0.0449792892,
-0.6480029821,
0.4128564,
-0.1265744418,
0.4649204314,
0.1368495822,
0.2535101771,
0.8004686236,
-0.5888963342,
0.6917667389,
-0.1005791575,
0.0547992326,
0.211100027,
-0.1495254934,
0.2100207955,
-0.1555440277,
0.0559295006,
-0.1062202677,
0.0085819121,
-0.280826658,
-0.9504498839,
0.4486960769,
-0.9715970159,
-0.1809085906,
-0.3814807236,
-0.3508251011,
-0.81084162,
-0.2545212507,
0.3554604948,
0.7806044221,
-0.1746719182,
-0.0243154727,
0.8430456519,
-0.0222437717,
-0.1574707031,
0.317471385,
-0.0257888287,
-0.4597436488,
0.8989105225,
0.2203622311,
0.4689382911,
0.8963259459,
-0.2699654698,
-0.4800073206,
-0.0259235222,
-0.267360419,
0.5195736885,
-1.0425266027,
-0.7524285913,
-0.5439830422,
-0.5711116195,
-0.642216742,
0.197816968,
-0.1793481112,
-0.55353266,
-0.2257867008,
-0.0056012194,
0.4676995873,
0.8218952417,
0.0656300783,
0.7403557897,
-0.8015652895,
0.395654887,
0.4060505927,
0.5728248358,
0.0995808467,
-0.686425209,
-0.7728700042,
-0.1728345305,
-0.2322493643,
-0.8923424482,
0.3135659397,
0.680716455,
0.5570426583,
0.4380214214,
0.2523923516,
0.8537349701,
-0.7279177904,
0.2921005785,
0.2170100808,
-0.9108654857,
0.5360375643,
0.1945306063,
-0.044601351,
0.4209838808,
0.9107701778,
-0.4063554108,
-0.2634325325,
-0.7587875128,
-0.7152638435,
0.9946514964,
0.3735181093,
-0.0021108086,
0.0019944052,
0.5821826458,
-0.0970092416,
0.0917969942,
-0.8169724941,
-0.6009784937,
0.081315279,
-0.1489728689,
0.2234587967,
-0.3351909816,
-0.1669188887,
-0.4731522202,
0.6535467505,
0.0406327434,
0.5774202943,
-0.0095822793,
-0.2934453785,
-0.1905222237,
0.0188422203,
0.2398933172,
0.6958392262,
-0.2234603763,
0.4462740719,
0.2065487206,
-0.3072644174,
0.3757653236,
-0.2341081649,
0.5076734424,
0.1747447848,
0.7980139256,
0.8477134109,
0.174832046,
-0.1128910407,
0.677442193,
-0.0317287371,
-0.3288460374,
0.0270865206,
0.2507825792,
0.041772671,
-0.1762041897,
-0.0285238549,
0.1070648506,
0.076342456,
-0.710763514,
0.396769017,
0.1161762998,
0.0134288203,
-0.299549222,
0.5915160179,
0.1449920535,
-0.2552628815,
0.7233415246,
-0.1787655652,
-0.874479413,
0.5346372724,
0.6164019108,
0.5405442715,
-0.4949779809,
0.0649420694,
0.5081800818,
-0.0128901657,
-0.2045097649,
-0.104858093,
-0.1527671367,
-1.1488997936,
-0.5166168213,
-0.6031339169,
-0.8415931463,
0.1745559871,
-0.9775416851,
0.1287550032,
-0.3762308657,
-0.3882849514,
0.3428853154,
-0.1312158108,
-0.9221491814,
0.5180382729,
-0.076769568,
0.8288631439,
-1.0254018307,
1.2633720636,
0.7727357149,
-0.3908702135,
-0.735373795,
-0.0547876246,
-0.4721533656,
-0.2517746091,
1.2136127949,
0.2920798659,
-0.4269462824,
-0.3590579927,
-0.3858540952,
-0.6689039469,
0.5740207434,
0.1289791167,
-0.5350010395,
0.0631770492,
0.3982719481,
0.7652323246,
-0.8540370464,
-0.1676020473,
0.6622834802,
0.2707978785,
-0.0978278667,
-0.8524343371,
-0.1730129719,
-0.3320264816,
0.2012225688,
0.2816917896,
-0.4704126418,
0.4223233461,
-0.0247878153,
-0.3855518997,
-0.3461571634,
0.6465963125,
-0.1333608627,
0.2707052231,
0.3121186793,
0.359696269,
0.7662261128,
-0.1969132721,
1.0317031145,
-0.4807578623,
0.6193692088,
1.2245281935,
-0.2705433965,
0.7815470099,
0.0205484796,
-0.3664193451,
0.3334288895,
0.6599704623,
0.0925806165,
0.7505099177,
0.1283995509,
-0.4053226113,
-0.4322882295,
0.0654930398,
-0.4166458547,
0.1516093761,
0.5852776766,
-0.30479303,
0.145502314,
0.243528977,
-0.1568075418,
0.1347664744,
-0.0689988583,
0.8171043992,
0.3010131419,
-0.4464535117,
0.7155042291,
0.0539300591,
0.4430007339,
-0.3597109914,
-0.0332531594,
-0.2789280713,
0.3847092986,
-0.4287289381,
-0.5238206387,
0.3059924245,
-0.0300495923,
-0.5377389789,
-0.2457459271,
0.5839934349,
-0.7594351172,
-0.0636118799,
0.6067622304,
0.466229111,
0.2093982995,
0.1379692703,
-0.2778504789,
-0.0442913286,
-0.2443389595,
0.0081241615,
0.3842976987,
0.7079551816,
-0.0977768376,
0.4803850055,
0.2233994305,
0.1010610312,
-0.081247367,
0.3131900728,
1.1223207712,
-0.7128130198,
-0.1593024433,
-0.6157593727,
0.0308355428,
-0.0637776926,
-0.2744907737,
0.5643422604,
0.6525133252,
1.1078796387,
-0.3474671245,
0.6339601874,
0.1690990776,
0.3845775127,
-0.423499018,
0.2445723414,
-0.4220875502,
0.3269037008,
-0.1177994758,
-1.0463324785,
-0.7091763616,
0.7167607546,
-0.1812063456,
0.1184647903,
0.9218800068,
0.4534357786,
-0.3073564768,
-0.020193832,
0.4713031054,
-0.0724271387,
0.0509898327,
0.8470060825,
0.9775098562,
-0.5543915629,
0.4489104152,
-0.4495407939,
-0.3250590563,
-0.1313955337,
-0.367298007,
-1.1023044586,
-0.5958253145,
-0.5640979409,
-0.3435064256,
0.2376460135,
0.8191775084,
1.0610907078,
-0.877640903,
-0.3991149664,
0.3869118989,
-0.0371836275,
-0.2679178417,
-0.1458998471,
0.3330900967,
-0.4884375036,
-0.6922795773,
0.0889386982,
0.128959775,
0.0298947338,
0.2277476937,
-0.27378124,
-0.0477087833,
-0.0176409874,
0.7927893996,
0.1098820046,
-0.1509108841,
-0.3097958863,
-0.155194819,
-0.2790415585,
0.5113565922,
1.0733093023,
-0.5501272678,
0.1496161222,
0.2383834273,
0.6042941213,
0.7861462831,
0.1637515724,
0.6410306692,
-1.1492017508,
0.00243052,
0.0984829292,
0.3255525827,
0.3839519024,
-0.6460126042,
0.8527146578,
0.212594226,
-0.5922644138,
-0.5773251653,
0.3812749088,
-0.9141497016,
-0.3588836193,
1.1801319122,
-0.3622732162,
-0.1502239853,
-0.297780633,
0.1084933579,
0.3543215692,
-0.247362107,
0.2540826797,
0.8661009073,
-0.6578980684,
0.0385239646,
-0.3716580272,
0.8615604043,
0.0167287327,
-0.815418005,
0.2036061287,
0.393438518,
0.4178715348,
0.4195152521,
0.6163628101,
-0.0585783571,
0.1701550484,
0.0489677377,
0.0114340251,
0.1677623987,
-0.991982758,
-0.2864646018,
0.2072634697,
0.2682181895,
-0.18341811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13752v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13752v2
|
Towards General Conceptual Model Editing via Adversarial Representation Engineering
| 2024-04-21T19:24:15 | 2024-05-23T13:06:59 |
Yihao Zhang, Zeming Wei, Jun Sun, Meng Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, math.OC
|
Since the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has achieved remarkable
success, understanding and controlling their internal complex mechanisms has
become an urgent problem. Recent research has attempted to interpret their
behaviors through the lens of inner representation. However, developing
practical and efficient methods for applying these representations for general
and flexible model editing remains challenging. In this work, we explore how to
use representation engineering methods to guide the editing of LLMs by
deploying a representation sensor as an oracle. We first identify the
importance of a robust and reliable sensor during editing, then propose an
Adversarial Representation Engineering (ARE) framework to provide a unified and
interpretable approach for conceptual model editing without compromising
baseline performance. Experiments on multiple model editing paradigms
demonstrate the effectiveness of ARE in various settings. Code and data are
available at
https://github.com/Zhang-Yihao/Adversarial-Representation-Engineering.
|
[
-0.2696013153,
-0.7429196835,
0.7282317877,
-0.0494009815,
-0.1887203753,
0.0018755425,
-0.3267331719,
-0.6619904041,
0.3255162835,
0.5168821216,
-0.4255554676,
-0.494800806,
-0.5650683045,
-0.1276810914,
-0.4626227617,
0.5160309076,
-0.2097970992,
0.1699117273,
-0.0477625839,
-0.096313037,
-0.4107893407,
-0.4881744087,
-0.712262094,
-0.4333840907,
0.2906127274,
-0.4188252687,
1.0316864252,
0.7122870684,
0.1403984129,
0.4529532194,
-0.4895639122,
0.4706128836,
-0.101899296,
0.2000301778,
-0.3431045413,
-0.5837506652,
-0.5672194958,
-0.0553339086,
0.7876011729,
0.5874783397,
-0.1124628261,
-0.0050182305,
0.1183945686,
0.4119375944,
-0.9295405746,
0.3203801811,
-0.9533913136,
-0.1269004941,
-0.1426344365,
0.1453872174,
-0.6594080925,
0.020929236,
-0.4170936942,
-1.0232604742,
-0.0726128295,
-0.0987180769,
0.763130188,
0.6066377759,
-0.2835519314,
-0.3073668182,
-0.8694996834,
0.3131098151,
-0.5806561112,
0.1484326273,
0.1390952468,
0.1475006789,
-0.2547736466,
-0.6520036459,
-0.7013769746,
-0.1124099195,
-0.2541970313,
-0.0322006084,
-0.425314337,
0.3903117478,
0.0767860785,
-0.0737409592,
-0.3398382962,
0.3487872183,
0.1196614802,
-0.2176831365,
0.8003553152,
0.2671676576,
0.4651159048,
-0.1030674651,
-0.0464210026,
-0.0539082065,
-0.7024124265,
-0.3117642105,
0.2753525674,
0.2946203053,
0.2708519399,
0.7228142619,
0.2499686033,
0.7425507903,
0.1435734332,
0.513695538,
-0.2894319296,
0.0359740071,
-0.4137438238,
0.0817130506,
0.8247532845,
0.1702445,
0.1504141092,
-0.3148584962,
-0.3711201847,
0.4182700217,
0.8630847931,
-0.2137560695,
-0.1112403199,
0.2089112401,
-0.1262810081,
-0.4438497126,
0.0895424634,
-0.5243982077,
-0.8170361519,
-0.5966052413,
0.478161782,
-0.4202813804,
-0.2157953829,
0.2214616835,
0.0147584463,
-0.0741697997,
0.5034940839,
-1.0537704229,
0.1685405672,
0.7434379458,
0.7943823934,
0.2361489832,
-0.333622694,
-0.0793944448,
0.6361534595,
-0.7017683983,
0.5675768852,
-0.5757263899,
-0.5981836915,
-0.1413459331,
-0.2980723083,
-0.2538682818,
-0.5498834252,
0.4610056579,
-1.0503667593,
-0.1631065011,
-0.2471241504,
-0.6591543555,
-0.3802223206,
0.1562181115,
-0.7780045867,
0.8066381216,
-0.0690452382,
-0.6642047167,
0.0326859802,
-0.8465934992,
-0.0790313706,
-0.3138689697,
-0.153820321,
-0.2955945134,
0.2933148444,
0.598886013,
0.3881087899,
-0.05301423,
0.1847079843,
-0.4248124361,
-0.3809778094,
0.273437649,
-0.1678197533,
0.8227770925,
0.2227909118,
-0.2535188198,
0.4903386831,
-0.6851329803,
-0.1385659128,
0.3731716871,
0.0403363071,
-0.5816320181,
-0.0247428659,
-0.0830732286,
-0.2264637351,
0.129915297,
-0.5933045745,
0.4949557185,
-0.4187710881,
0.4643943906,
1.0623571873,
-0.0501815118,
0.6182553172,
0.1150206029,
0.5766226053,
-0.1882989109,
0.0743717104,
0.1165521219,
-0.2174243778,
-0.7350726128,
-0.2719566822,
0.4215490818,
0.6173806787,
-0.9292144775,
0.2800316513,
-0.2684268057,
-0.5458500385,
-0.6646087766,
0.222364217,
0.2828303277,
0.2705215514,
0.3290153444,
-0.0657730401,
-0.5662744045,
-0.7379516363,
-0.4966720343,
-0.544467628,
-0.140645951,
-0.1797576398,
0.5224867463,
-0.3041111827,
1.015568614,
-0.547370851,
-0.1005859599,
-0.0358500332,
0.0270723011,
-0.0549657233,
0.328320086,
0.8252084255,
-0.8331566453,
-0.0953611881,
0.0701184571,
-1.2494177818,
-0.1938944012,
-0.2620607316,
-0.2565758824,
0.0627802014,
0.6852777004,
-1.1514545679,
0.4795879126,
0.4275983572,
-0.1516389251,
0.7347346544,
-0.1593681276,
0.0402560122,
-0.8550197482,
-0.0023247171,
-0.0377404317,
-0.0032943916,
-0.6875680685,
0.8162014484,
0.2395370454,
-0.176671505,
-0.4469491839,
0.550694406,
-0.4122955203,
0.0646458566,
-0.3302207291,
-0.0773312077,
0.0982192978,
0.3156736195,
-0.0831931084,
0.7502608299,
0.4514569938,
-0.6031088233,
0.722668469,
0.1888440549,
-0.36484918,
0.5941615105,
-0.8532969952,
0.2905189991,
-0.2914422154,
0.2156456411,
-0.8127935529,
-0.1519491524,
0.5785571933,
-0.2764219046,
0.6410626173,
-0.1366573125,
-0.7789211869,
-0.1262278706,
-0.0942779034,
0.004976281,
-0.2303515226,
-0.8229949474,
1.0336967707,
0.5455915928,
-0.00232378,
-0.5145420432,
-0.9681688547,
0.3271647692,
-0.3535235524,
-0.9859545827,
0.6512525678,
0.2988584638,
-0.4405716658,
0.2828826606,
0.017269779,
0.080239661,
0.1870502681,
0.0922863409,
0.3171451986,
-0.2153176516,
0.268332243,
0.1517314464,
-0.3198460639,
0.2859304845,
-0.1769970953,
0.1043126509,
0.1291266084,
-0.7440035939,
-0.5014948845,
0.3259841502,
0.7345631123,
-0.3208192885,
0.7112053037,
0.2245323956,
-0.7057373524,
-0.22980313,
-0.285164237,
-0.0713175312,
-0.551856935,
0.652197063,
-0.5638421774,
-0.5928100348,
0.6874526739,
-0.1011442468,
0.0479501113,
0.2479871362,
0.3614440262,
-0.0859171301,
1.1014159918,
0.5749144554,
-0.2621907294,
0.2624732256,
-0.2771676481,
0.1773373485,
-1.0479940176,
0.0809009075,
-0.4282867312,
-0.3065274954,
-0.1459846497,
-0.5045001507,
0.6482715607,
0.2857670486,
-0.4682088494,
0.1651870012,
-0.5913675427,
0.5000885725,
0.2826703787,
0.1621054858,
0.3382589817,
-0.1429782659,
-0.1502201706,
-0.2543945014,
-0.4557793736,
-0.7661287189,
0.8203187585,
0.3433675766,
0.9701907635,
0.2001089901,
0.3441575766,
0.2607631385,
0.3469299376,
-0.4459468126,
0.64638412,
-0.3250502646,
-0.6926961541,
-0.2873614132,
-0.0537502989,
-0.5600304604,
0.739836216,
-0.0590579398,
-0.8422523737,
0.3344379365,
0.3891865015,
-0.1450994462,
0.8578080535,
-0.8339988589,
0.7879859209,
-0.1265849024,
-0.1059518531,
-0.2172054052,
-0.4187540114,
0.4798862934,
0.0083963089,
0.1977212727,
0.4199980795,
-0.1164067462,
0.1903148592,
-0.5756851435,
1.0687068701,
-0.3801833093,
-0.1270138323,
0.4347894192,
0.3050738871,
0.8678177595,
0.1763778329,
-0.4364335537,
-0.0424674936,
-0.3320451379,
-0.1740451008,
-1.1011784077,
0.5207612514,
-0.8039932251,
-0.5950567722,
-0.3691632748,
-0.2837803364,
-0.3341618478,
-0.1384842843,
0.2421997041,
-0.0888017267,
-0.445356667,
-0.2544887066,
0.4434766769,
-0.1962204725,
0.1870099902,
0.1822314858,
-0.3290223181,
-0.1144603565,
0.7865377665,
0.064990215,
0.1973426193,
0.4225966334,
-0.091129981,
-0.3323512375,
-0.6197577119,
-0.8350309134,
0.0302865487,
-0.96396029,
-0.1150246337,
-0.6259869337,
-0.3541525304,
-0.3068979979,
-0.241387248,
-0.597566545,
-0.4254950285,
-0.4630281925,
-0.199294582,
0.27319327,
0.9116753936,
-0.2154809982,
0.6307010055,
-0.2526639104,
0.4047197998,
0.4666427672,
0.1762723178,
0.2502234578,
-0.4198133945,
-0.2798180878,
0.3384470344,
-0.3054069877,
-0.9110981822,
0.215345338,
0.1314766705,
0.4723294079,
0.061831221,
-0.1419509798,
0.7947372198,
-0.2267828733,
0.7660294175,
-0.2135083079,
-1.4019943476,
0.5937045217,
-0.3034048378,
0.1901907325,
0.0677546561,
-0.0084888125,
-0.6414279342,
-0.4654030502,
-0.1961867511,
-0.7004595399,
0.746383965,
0.0312356725,
0.239878267,
0.441105932,
0.7177066207,
-0.3397344947,
0.0707992539,
-0.6599751115,
-0.3000286818,
-0.4888846576,
-0.0066672028,
0.0602873676,
-0.1504033953,
-0.0251398366,
0.0029906651,
0.8691432476,
-0.1259348541,
0.0666887164,
0.0397067554,
-0.3257563114,
-0.1194925904,
0.3207003772,
0.3733688593,
0.4871779382,
-0.0549585707,
0.064364545,
0.1172096282,
-0.3560169935,
0.1785388887,
0.1864754856,
-0.6249637008,
-0.0066687358,
0.5249053836,
0.9127681255,
0.0847505406,
-0.1757374257,
0.1280348152,
-0.0575556755,
-0.0009339881,
-0.0943964273,
0.1658040285,
0.387360692,
0.1672754288,
0.1304129213,
0.2242390215,
-0.1241100281,
-0.1900297701,
-0.1176725402,
0.2918376923,
-0.241524294,
-0.3355443478,
1.1391586065,
-0.0849634558,
0.0905228332,
0.6478569508,
-0.2174182087,
-0.3830217123,
0.4342819452,
0.417530328,
0.804425478,
-0.5147458911,
0.3375307322,
0.1101319864,
0.6393916607,
0.2974517643,
-0.1658822596,
0.4471744895,
-1.0406234264,
-0.7083058357,
-0.4719523489,
-0.4754011631,
0.1194729432,
-0.5121037364,
0.2303543985,
-0.5916768909,
-0.0600629076,
0.3089301586,
-0.4936380088,
-0.3468838632,
0.324583143,
0.2526531219,
0.6030231118,
-0.7684230208,
0.8492013812,
1.1341924667,
-0.2569170296,
-0.6597928405,
-0.3813293576,
0.5150441527,
-0.9350810051,
0.3611988723,
-0.220596537,
-0.1407126784,
-0.334867388,
-0.695918262,
-0.6481893659,
0.7958779931,
1.0001198053,
-0.4253214598,
-0.1838310659,
0.2753002048,
0.7555012703,
-0.3064499199,
0.1150152013,
0.3947188556,
0.6486312747,
-0.0907012522,
-0.6461901665,
0.1588012725,
-0.4840171933,
0.323720783,
0.0428680629,
-0.5032554865,
0.5741530061,
-0.0610777661,
-0.2456569225,
0.2494421899,
0.6803188324,
0.2310152799,
-0.0253274497,
0.6581689715,
0.7399404049,
0.7395524383,
-0.1053751558,
1.0817053318,
-0.0934038162,
0.037075907,
1.3469510078,
-0.2555238008,
0.4692427814,
0.3596490622,
-0.1907811761,
0.2154577076,
0.6963126659,
0.1567808241,
0.342358619,
0.3241165876,
-0.4361378551,
-0.2136492878,
0.008926156,
-0.3376885355,
0.7470027208,
0.8129798174,
-0.23828879,
-0.1739010364,
0.080580242,
0.0678872615,
0.5052063465,
-0.2152375281,
0.5885232091,
-0.0121574448,
-0.2017608285,
0.4661546648,
0.4986877143,
0.460672766,
-0.7613704205,
0.0609079823,
0.1517393887,
0.1477079242,
-0.0340361036,
-0.7729861736,
0.6927487254,
0.0567567982,
-0.2176188976,
-0.2115405649,
0.6689548492,
-0.1549839824,
-0.4773246348,
0.5243886709,
0.177532956,
-0.3685323298,
-0.6341637373,
-0.7851036191,
0.4387867749,
-0.0386904031,
-0.3756320477,
0.1302056164,
0.5067261457,
-0.1187625676,
0.6363394856,
0.5338400006,
0.4285930693,
0.0771518499,
-0.0081532206,
0.8824388981,
-0.6531317234,
-0.4440794289,
-0.8105139136,
0.6308864355,
0.0897468254,
-0.3426379263,
0.3557725549,
0.1172517017,
0.8351693749,
0.0096449237,
0.9146526456,
0.0419092476,
0.2722428143,
-0.7982270122,
0.8590791225,
-0.5057793856,
0.5508345962,
-0.4484480917,
-0.9627838135,
-0.6616199613,
0.5059623718,
-0.1380147487,
-0.1737155467,
0.2754245102,
1.0948034525,
-0.1976441443,
0.4149546027,
0.1251740605,
0.6816053987,
0.7119985819,
0.2670850754,
0.9116644263,
-0.4847751856,
0.2909325957,
-0.4500875175,
-0.0127305211,
0.2698895335,
-0.718485117,
-0.6065837741,
-0.4734494388,
-0.240435347,
-0.2216671407,
0.4010592997,
0.5184825659,
0.6342448592,
-0.6737733483,
-0.0157442149,
0.0085840859,
0.2277277112,
-0.1832101792,
-0.127599448,
0.7341858149,
-0.2027087659,
-0.8068621755,
0.5617642999,
0.239189893,
-0.0559512042,
-0.4426722825,
-0.0169058368,
-0.0027704858,
-0.2290824056,
0.4593576789,
0.1940386444,
-0.9121733904,
-0.3815740645,
-0.2535027266,
-0.0128184548,
-0.2484859526,
0.6760584116,
-0.5721713901,
0.9732874036,
0.1645706594,
0.8276084661,
0.2765983343,
-0.1548831463,
0.8327533603,
-0.7907805443,
0.2294111401,
0.1554513127,
0.5265911222,
0.5324864984,
-0.3979614973,
0.6025270224,
0.2048060745,
-0.4332578778,
-0.8107766509,
0.1888066083,
-0.6572522521,
-0.4034470618,
0.8056051731,
-0.2570921183,
-0.2007933408,
0.1128968224,
-0.3542021513,
0.2840827107,
-0.0660787597,
0.8623178005,
0.847708106,
-0.0412532762,
-0.1542452276,
-0.2799690366,
0.114916496,
0.4346179664,
-0.6157989502,
0.095394209,
0.4963650405,
-0.1720098555,
0.2999602258,
0.3106872439,
-0.2395244241,
0.2168077528,
0.1056337059,
0.2224766612,
-0.2228990942,
-0.0688153505,
-0.3821122646,
-0.0619803518,
0.093345277,
-0.128849864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13751v1
|
Embarrassingly Simple Unsupervised Aspect Based Sentiment Tuple Extraction
| 2024-04-21T19:20:42 | 2024-04-21T19:20:42 |
Kevin Scaria, Abyn Scaria, Ben Scaria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) tasks involve the extraction of
fine-grained sentiment tuples from sentences, aiming to discern the author's
opinions. Conventional methodologies predominantly rely on supervised
approaches; however, the efficacy of such methods diminishes in low-resource
domains lacking labeled datasets since they often lack the ability to
generalize across domains. To address this challenge, we propose a simple and
novel unsupervised approach to extract opinion terms and the corresponding
sentiment polarity for aspect terms in a sentence. Our experimental
evaluations, conducted on four benchmark datasets, demonstrate compelling
performance to extract the aspect oriented opinion words as well as assigning
sentiment polarity. Additionally, unsupervised approaches for opinion word
mining have not been explored and our work establishes a benchmark for the
same.
|
[
-0.6398043036,
-0.670712769,
0.4389933646,
0.1636748314,
-0.7894507647,
0.1732253134,
-0.0345758125,
-0.3019668758,
0.6065132618,
0.6567857265,
-0.38956514,
-0.5011355877,
-0.5402308702,
0.0118576111,
-0.1522388905,
1.2593688965,
0.2443306446,
0.0257322062,
-0.3332541585,
-0.5988946557,
-0.053568285,
-0.6933711767,
-0.2653292418,
-0.4563185871,
0.2126681209,
0.6347594857,
0.5656977892,
0.1171095073,
0.5067690611,
0.1688387692,
-0.3518711627,
0.2390594482,
0.0479133055,
0.0761666745,
-0.363384366,
-0.3106729388,
-0.4122543037,
0.335031718,
0.0894679427,
1.0348126888,
0.056181632,
0.0424271151,
0.2018422782,
1.288877964,
-0.512270391,
0.3714447021,
-0.5876749158,
-0.0576383621,
-0.2720551789,
0.0658674762,
-0.1236865371,
-0.2021537423,
0.1417741925,
-0.3585692346,
0.3695001602,
0.1094516814,
0.5315964818,
-0.1233605593,
-0.1936298311,
-0.2830189168,
-0.5543760657,
0.8644587398,
-0.6974569559,
0.1388272047,
0.031537015,
-0.2151944935,
0.0210773274,
-0.3834157884,
-0.6208184958,
0.461858362,
-0.0535252057,
0.2165055275,
-0.2922991514,
0.0578807592,
-0.1587915868,
0.8991631866,
0.0632202253,
-0.1267084181,
0.0075677927,
-0.0167347156,
0.6183676124,
-0.2959958613,
-0.1261080801,
-1.0094480515,
-0.2677719593,
0.0625073761,
-0.7301132083,
0.6268778443,
0.4336816072,
0.5710840821,
-0.1636053473,
1.0652030706,
-0.5987632275,
0.3432976007,
0.122643441,
0.2410592288,
0.4359653294,
0.0262150075,
-0.1738814861,
-0.234908998,
1.0429680347,
0.434818238,
-0.0806941465,
-0.2774333656,
-0.4226841331,
0.078047879,
0.3661719561,
-0.4456083179,
-0.3865218759,
0.5265138149,
-0.5659518838,
-0.5934172869,
0.3967893124,
-1.4783385992,
-0.769611001,
-0.0478514768,
0.3044059575,
-0.4935764074,
-0.202884689,
-0.1928078234,
-0.1617326438,
0.1824346334,
0.0123375487,
-0.4964266419,
-0.0777996331,
1.2340717316,
0.7475703359,
-0.4187136292,
0.1771696359,
-0.4069293141,
-0.5197782516,
-0.1537511945,
1.158603549,
-0.8599150181,
-0.4646163583,
0.0601252057,
0.0907875001,
0.3245269656,
-0.4121329188,
0.5788374543,
-0.3190608621,
0.410443902,
-0.2599672377,
-0.4417830408,
-0.6599753499,
0.1042534187,
-0.3881746829,
0.9510478377,
0.1703954637,
-0.8031478524,
0.1929528415,
-0.5414014459,
-0.6618127227,
-0.0555777103,
-0.2114040405,
-0.6841642261,
0.8821598291,
0.5895252228,
0.506036222,
-0.3259682357,
0.0070512793,
-0.4030616581,
0.228190884,
0.4819584489,
-0.1782768071,
0.7025007606,
0.144346118,
-0.345831424,
0.0307391249,
-0.5963187814,
-0.0088884262,
-0.0560461469,
0.0265169144,
-0.834416151,
0.12751472,
-0.0214898102,
-0.138673529,
0.3460701704,
-0.9105699658,
0.46159482,
-0.7192973495,
0.3302408457,
0.5450001955,
0.3416223526,
0.6547042727,
-0.0439678617,
0.4267531335,
0.2832943499,
0.2342498899,
0.2505086362,
-0.4317049384,
-0.9590550661,
-0.3691044748,
0.155972898,
0.2488742471,
-0.9729316235,
0.5858632326,
-0.071653977,
-0.627121985,
-0.671253562,
0.5070579052,
0.6204661727,
0.3480407,
0.2589067519,
-0.7660047412,
-0.3285319805,
-1.0533323288,
-0.5415952206,
-0.3009032011,
0.1357374936,
0.1800773591,
0.1239798367,
0.0512043163,
1.1726349592,
-0.6869632602,
-0.5309342146,
-0.6876429915,
0.8004661202,
0.3755604625,
0.2288428694,
0.4071417451,
-0.9411028028,
-0.0870824456,
0.0153184244,
-0.7023527026,
-0.1822550446,
0.1439913809,
-0.07511314,
0.2590592206,
0.141755715,
-0.4920413792,
0.3383681476,
0.2461379617,
-0.102517426,
0.2403558046,
0.1181033328,
0.0156346317,
-1.0759966373,
-0.1104376838,
0.322301358,
-0.2140651792,
-0.3795447946,
0.1961170733,
-0.1637039632,
-0.0071234345,
-0.4934265316,
0.026154751,
-0.7288473845,
-0.134637624,
-0.5122829676,
-0.0207540877,
0.1695502549,
0.8440674543,
0.2522711456,
0.383453548,
0.5239802003,
-0.3444088399,
0.2548856437,
0.1325841248,
-0.1868342161,
0.8039716482,
-0.4416370094,
0.4478609562,
-0.3620131612,
-0.3919388056,
-0.6478920579,
0.0568754189,
0.1404611468,
-0.2899228334,
0.2188832015,
-0.488660872,
-0.0163755082,
-0.1139606386,
-0.8117717505,
0.1617375612,
0.2817348242,
-0.4509395957,
0.8592161536,
0.9719379544,
-0.2769264579,
-0.5136243105,
-0.2065709829,
-0.0945777297,
-0.3955583572,
0.0921346992,
0.129905358,
0.3333484828,
-0.517505765,
-0.0177546963,
-0.128881216,
-0.0953820273,
-0.0860533044,
0.548425734,
0.2518230081,
-0.105858773,
-0.2639555037,
0.2093097121,
0.0032156943,
0.2571321428,
0.3326261044,
0.5487864614,
-0.5006287694,
-0.0593336374,
-0.2408053875,
0.6901391149,
0.5847465992,
-0.2158015221,
0.3329183161,
0.036579974,
-0.3596717119,
-0.2505047321,
-0.4055566192,
-0.0104841283,
-0.3772113025,
0.4138037562,
-0.196028173,
-0.2811148167,
0.3587587774,
-0.2204909027,
0.2563627362,
0.4169890583,
0.1667306721,
-0.3650803566,
0.7791177034,
0.8279453516,
-0.3843342662,
0.4258545935,
-0.3362202048,
0.4896888435,
-1.1327091455,
-0.2506226003,
-0.4795966148,
-0.1212317273,
-0.4210691452,
-0.0919285417,
0.3628852665,
0.4742522836,
0.2808694243,
0.166912064,
-0.7132099271,
0.2369085699,
0.5128772259,
0.256311655,
0.3839834034,
0.1155385226,
0.3844557405,
-0.1900794059,
-0.232620284,
-0.5034837723,
0.8969527483,
0.0748031661,
0.3213711679,
0.1092262566,
0.6155508161,
0.4864174724,
0.3715798855,
-1.1295007467,
0.569216013,
-0.6535553336,
-0.0959848315,
-0.0705902651,
-0.1653759331,
-0.6472457647,
0.279474467,
-0.5080876946,
-0.6318053603,
0.3814810812,
-0.1497681588,
-0.2211022377,
0.3168561757,
-0.6347466111,
0.6574031711,
-0.03182799,
-0.1445222497,
-0.0930604488,
-0.3898155391,
0.2837785482,
-0.1072633937,
0.5246884823,
-0.1544876248,
0.2739505172,
1.0521314144,
-0.6968843341,
0.8253583908,
-0.4420039654,
0.3972590566,
0.4034172297,
0.2050761282,
0.2480550408,
0.296592325,
0.0675498992,
0.6123153567,
-0.1539469957,
-0.1924859285,
-0.6111580729,
0.795846343,
-0.8443932533,
-0.6472590566,
-0.676687181,
-0.2954041064,
-0.6777562499,
0.0773996562,
0.28980878,
0.5088095665,
-0.2461155355,
0.1206603497,
0.3811455667,
-0.0148264877,
0.7880152464,
0.4180098474,
-0.2757210732,
-0.5152946115,
0.909309566,
-0.2540314794,
-0.3229506016,
0.3850087523,
0.3885495663,
-0.2010491937,
-0.6483594179,
-0.3663150966,
0.2934376299,
-0.3396957815,
-0.5451263189,
-0.7416199446,
-0.1126137823,
-0.5792309046,
-0.0939887688,
-0.8191405535,
-0.6444432139,
-0.1641517282,
0.0126672769,
0.6466307044,
0.8885620832,
0.0171111543,
0.5322396159,
-0.5039177537,
0.454267025,
0.173310101,
0.1023768112,
-0.2872368693,
-0.4364368916,
0.1257611811,
-0.0080338996,
-0.4948928058,
-0.8445749879,
0.6436837912,
0.2009114474,
0.2747857869,
0.7409285903,
0.3721834421,
0.2951384485,
0.0526978038,
0.9143225551,
0.2409682721,
-1.0316649675,
0.7160457373,
0.1452131718,
-0.0677723363,
0.7291067839,
0.2602329254,
-0.2416916043,
-0.4438365698,
-0.6663126349,
-1.1702498198,
0.501862824,
0.1189268157,
-0.0570669845,
0.059484195,
0.507994771,
0.6587031484,
0.498087883,
-0.6197474599,
-0.448513329,
-0.5304130316,
-0.2226154804,
-0.0801260322,
-0.4792422652,
-0.0874668434,
-0.0353285857,
0.7948265672,
-0.0909127891,
0.2018976063,
0.2535212934,
-0.0429679453,
0.3640094995,
0.6248092651,
-0.2513895929,
0.2040918469,
-0.3536568582,
0.3274589777,
-0.4150826335,
-0.4932600856,
-0.1779220551,
0.0958055854,
-0.3672231138,
0.0448836051,
0.3009632826,
0.357427299,
-0.1500762254,
-0.2251133919,
0.9167874455,
-0.0001810751,
0.375086993,
-0.3389098644,
-0.2638927698,
-0.2685193717,
0.0493767038,
0.3882231414,
0.2467342317,
0.2243595272,
-0.6745169759,
0.0903206095,
0.7347576022,
-0.8533079624,
-0.6293783784,
0.3317773938,
0.4684019983,
-0.2401110381,
0.3610646725,
-0.3549769521,
-0.6156803966,
0.1972917169,
0.051374916,
1.1573036909,
0.181796357,
0.49595052,
-0.1028339639,
0.1401934028,
-0.0185581185,
0.4425789714,
0.0960004777,
-0.7877264619,
-0.1356518418,
-0.6877339482,
-0.4746994376,
0.2845047116,
-1.1348757744,
0.0452379808,
-0.5105133653,
-0.0167983659,
0.2754929066,
0.0279707182,
-0.4011257589,
0.1397853643,
-0.18254821,
0.2994892299,
-1.0813497305,
0.6547520757,
1.1563833952,
-0.493068397,
-0.486543566,
-0.0961222798,
0.0964433104,
-0.570227325,
-0.180491522,
0.2856432199,
-0.1209840998,
-0.5546563268,
-0.506813705,
-0.1736150831,
0.371206522,
-0.1164045855,
-0.3214968443,
0.2887297869,
0.3680437505,
0.6086222529,
-0.5910373926,
-0.0636748746,
0.5533307791,
0.0943959281,
-0.1738951504,
-0.200178951,
-0.0866637081,
-0.3755628467,
-0.2517940998,
-0.0133329993,
-0.6497664452,
0.7681561708,
-0.0020058604,
-0.0197108313,
-0.1339838505,
1.2758563757,
-0.133541584,
0.5211406946,
0.8440660238,
0.3570511043,
0.4792935848,
-0.0945378691,
0.7809505463,
-0.3458637595,
0.40372926,
0.9241313338,
-0.085288018,
0.864336431,
0.7774856091,
0.0309984051,
0.5964341164,
0.4183845818,
0.439716965,
0.8606703281,
-0.3648980558,
-0.1747024506,
-0.3505353332,
-0.3454043567,
0.0536698736,
0.74024719,
0.2439335883,
-0.089681007,
0.058451049,
0.0672194958,
0.1920205057,
0.3616134524,
-0.6325824857,
0.8474621773,
0.325155139,
-0.7295497656,
-0.232651338,
0.0003516136,
0.9731155038,
-0.1362588853,
0.0383958854,
-0.7152843475,
0.2220434844,
-0.4308129549,
-1.1006543636,
0.5016276836,
0.3131248653,
-0.3372060061,
-0.066048339,
0.3693034649,
-0.0056728637,
-0.7817386389,
-0.0527173765,
0.6842195392,
0.1817604005,
-0.5263941884,
-0.4097300172,
-0.4711430371,
0.3800527155,
-0.4085263014,
0.2168161124,
0.8213069439,
-0.2116486728,
0.3126881123,
0.3924278021,
0.377245456,
-0.5491214991,
-0.0475743152,
0.9651257992,
-0.9183914065,
-0.4225639403,
-0.5664229989,
0.2300830185,
-0.271848768,
-0.6648970842,
0.7035757303,
0.7351421118,
0.3628357649,
0.0995529741,
0.8904286623,
-0.3382461369,
0.8612219095,
-0.4338033497,
0.5110328197,
-0.5560058355,
0.5699155331,
-0.3717843294,
-0.9581220746,
-0.0907181799,
0.4499664009,
-0.1981247067,
-0.4729682207,
0.8160997629,
0.7008225918,
-0.134139061,
0.41331622,
-0.2703817487,
0.2648581266,
0.3534936309,
0.2005872875,
0.5465089083,
-0.2143604308,
0.197294876,
-1.0284947157,
-0.5978724957,
0.0223895423,
-0.9707968235,
-1.0162609816,
-0.7091858387,
-0.66913414,
-0.4399798512,
-0.3042766452,
0.7621222138,
0.1422407776,
-1.1289693117,
0.2502557933,
-0.0248957425,
0.2382757962,
-0.5614774823,
-0.3292850852,
0.7139497995,
0.0608442202,
-0.7384179831,
0.3657781184,
0.2204676569,
-0.2226302475,
-0.2465958148,
0.6147208214,
0.1415989399,
0.119543694,
0.5045419335,
0.4692416489,
-0.4752624631,
-0.7307414412,
-0.3239547014,
0.1237276718,
0.3027881086,
1.0043867826,
-0.6067472696,
0.2922663093,
0.4441996217,
0.239093408,
0.2313634008,
0.5053243041,
0.3982565701,
-0.9170315862,
0.3834455609,
0.2608957887,
0.5784948468,
0.6651197672,
-0.4636766911,
0.3723027706,
0.3901126683,
-0.2685484588,
-0.5383477807,
0.1726800203,
-1.6961116791,
-0.3107405305,
1.2978266478,
-0.1340209842,
-0.4328706264,
-0.3439970016,
-0.1525961906,
-0.0386495367,
-0.6649877429,
1.1072838306,
0.2844983637,
-0.5755643249,
0.1443032324,
0.1785042882,
0.4353891611,
0.422572881,
-0.7242322564,
0.431129694,
0.4386861622,
0.2027920187,
0.2322046906,
0.3699577153,
-0.2860367894,
-0.1485741735,
-0.3223957419,
0.4772731066,
-0.3175466955,
-0.1725905091,
-0.396210283,
0.5389357805,
-0.0563381054,
-0.483551383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13721v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13721v1
|
The Framework of a Design Process Language
| 2024-04-21T17:20:19 | 2024-04-21T17:20:19 |
Arnulf Hagen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The thesis develops a view of design in a concept formation framework and
outlines a language to describe both the object of the design and the process
of designing. The unknown object at the outset of the design work may be seen
as an unknown concept that the designer is to define. Throughout the process,
she develops a description of this object by relating it to known concepts. The
search stops when the designer is satisfied that the design specification is
complete enough to satisfy the requirements from it once built. It is then a
collection of propositions that all contribute towards defining the design
object - a collection of sentences describing relationships between the object
and known concepts. Also, the design process itself may be described by
relating known concepts - by organizing known abilities into particular
patterns of activation, or mobilization. In view of the demands posed to a
language to use in this concept formation process, the framework of a Design
Process Language (DPL) is developed. The basis for the language are linguistic
categories that act as classes of relations used to combine concepts,
containing relations used for describing process and object within the same
general system, with some relations being process specific, others being object
specific, and with the bulk being used both for process and object description.
Another outcome is the distinction of modal relations, or relations describing
futurity, possibility, willingness, hypothetical events, and the like. The
design process almost always includes aspects such as these, and it is thus
necessary for a language facilitating design process description to support
such relationships to be constructed. The DPL is argued to be a foundation
whereupon to build a language that can be used for enabling computers to be
more useful - act more intelligently - in the design process.
|
[
-0.7135712504,
-0.7639915347,
0.5674277544,
0.2574105263,
-0.3544372618,
0.2329821885,
0.1228717044,
-0.5431955457,
0.0721107572,
0.3851079047,
-0.7384084463,
-0.1317013949,
-0.0684198067,
0.0155428415,
-0.2710441649,
0.3553931117,
-0.6687061787,
-0.1953020096,
-0.0034280827,
0.1813530475,
-0.5996510386,
-0.2856773436,
-0.4273774028,
-0.420622021,
0.208865121,
0.2028277367,
0.6196238995,
0.7393613458,
0.4312677383,
0.3326491714,
-0.2093888372,
-0.382347405,
-0.1812830567,
0.2763546407,
-0.2922053933,
-0.3947206736,
-0.5874687433,
0.0129907541,
0.3791548014,
1.1702737808,
0.1633541286,
0.1511494964,
0.2751208544,
0.9147863984,
-0.4902652502,
0.6800419092,
0.1110048667,
0.344574064,
-0.2722301185,
-0.2226719856,
-0.2214761823,
-0.1107922867,
0.1332969069,
-0.5387200713,
0.0670229644,
-0.0351586975,
0.5026403666,
-0.040336106,
0.0059172055,
-0.6794629693,
-0.8545556068,
0.602496326,
-0.4881583452,
0.3048060834,
0.3323161006,
0.2505603731,
-0.478628993,
-0.4421464503,
-0.6981750131,
-0.1412488371,
-0.2060206085,
-0.1298899651,
0.4607461691,
0.4080700576,
0.3100497425,
0.6711056232,
-0.4924996793,
-0.0789985731,
-0.4386456311,
-0.1949024647,
0.7517628074,
0.1075305119,
0.2288659811,
-0.1768843532,
-0.5411589146,
0.1308095902,
-0.4968423843,
-0.1101498306,
0.3069929779,
0.4953093529,
-0.0510689802,
0.5239272714,
-0.4476390183,
0.7279649973,
-0.0895510539,
-0.4627325833,
0.2682006955,
-0.0978158414,
-0.4283183813,
-0.0367191136,
0.5129044652,
0.1069963127,
0.1441875696,
-0.0082222912,
-0.4603095651,
0.3614528179,
0.3893829286,
-0.596511662,
-0.2059687823,
0.281450212,
-0.7557308078,
-0.4322853684,
0.2544715405,
-0.4579928517,
-0.0631682947,
-0.7079674602,
0.0772129446,
-0.0425217636,
-0.9792777896,
0.2453329265,
-0.3496048152,
0.2252458632,
0.2938190997,
-0.87588799,
0.4173055291,
0.6490182281,
0.5703792572,
-0.205407992,
-0.0988124311,
0.4575608075,
0.3644860685,
-0.7877580523,
0.7741577029,
-0.4880245328,
-0.8620485663,
0.2173491418,
-0.0569180883,
0.1823692918,
-0.3340158463,
0.5897189379,
-0.436730206,
0.262350291,
-0.1829679608,
-0.7721734643,
-0.3255352676,
-0.096743986,
-0.6986417174,
0.905041337,
0.3099193573,
-0.6493644714,
0.6184737086,
-1.1512241364,
-0.5642226934,
0.5202003717,
-0.6727639437,
-0.0750440359,
0.477113843,
-0.7511413097,
0.5803092122,
-0.2665739059,
0.1695798337,
-0.4198939204,
-0.2871427834,
0.2993531227,
0.1518804729,
0.7881595492,
0.6279022098,
-0.4038927555,
-0.0723897368,
-1.0821330547,
0.1703922749,
0.095723778,
-0.7847092152,
-0.4332154095,
0.2176653445,
0.07857804,
0.367154032,
0.1310204118,
-0.411310643,
0.1276591569,
-0.5316673517,
0.4173893034,
0.6698562503,
0.0244935229,
0.7636868954,
-0.2561977804,
0.5468276143,
-0.1318982095,
-0.1805996746,
-0.2549291253,
-0.3355308473,
-0.9405005574,
-0.0134389019,
-0.2858533263,
0.1736202687,
-0.5852690935,
0.4282721579,
0.3078293502,
-0.2172382325,
0.0432030521,
-0.0424344204,
0.3375684619,
0.3560486138,
-0.2131231576,
-0.3369819522,
-0.8055335283,
-0.9730892777,
0.4773180187,
-0.777954042,
-0.0384599455,
-0.0366915353,
0.4319578409,
-0.002592446,
1.0564227104,
-0.6165244579,
-0.0968927965,
-0.3691219687,
0.3382984698,
0.4586533904,
0.512357235,
0.792016089,
-0.9133265615,
-0.2620519698,
0.0191619769,
-0.8792400956,
-0.2183815092,
-0.004396582,
-0.3782476187,
0.269408077,
0.2002422959,
-0.4240537584,
0.6558625698,
-0.0316184089,
-0.3486170173,
0.5575117469,
-0.0600275695,
0.021824697,
-1.260133028,
0.2494914532,
-0.2027421892,
0.5452529788,
-0.7894948721,
0.2619526684,
0.0024868832,
-0.2559869289,
-0.6767662764,
0.523629427,
-0.6907891035,
0.047398366,
-0.7100829482,
-0.0818802565,
0.2527311146,
0.4932668805,
0.4403036535,
0.5058230758,
0.7628642321,
-1.178740263,
0.3532939255,
0.148373127,
-0.3294473588,
0.9936662316,
-0.586299479,
-0.102444686,
-0.1351433396,
-0.3834238946,
-1.1078243256,
-0.0981894955,
0.3039456606,
-0.0643156841,
0.4842649698,
0.0033960638,
-0.5635303259,
-0.761063695,
0.1221599057,
0.2598834634,
0.0898512825,
-0.0026425426,
0.2586942911,
0.6977308393,
-0.0875514671,
-0.2134067863,
-0.9321360588,
-0.1158092171,
-0.2194366902,
-0.936691165,
0.6281753182,
-0.2641856968,
-0.5994072556,
-0.1344358176,
-0.2941658795,
-0.4795596898,
0.3962483704,
0.3125371933,
0.1691993624,
-0.2555969954,
0.4759175479,
-0.1004759371,
-0.2400435805,
0.2824440897,
-0.176342085,
0.3951969147,
0.2586775422,
-0.3973740339,
-0.7611183524,
0.7817872763,
0.8297138214,
0.267260015,
0.3825361729,
0.088867344,
-0.6610552669,
-0.2544262707,
-0.1892779768,
0.0346713923,
-0.5074988604,
0.1230464801,
-1.1063603163,
-0.3960720003,
0.6269273162,
-0.070640929,
0.0766678602,
0.3726721704,
0.5687348843,
-0.1112572104,
0.7469149232,
1.356621027,
0.1834795773,
0.4547426105,
-0.2125429064,
0.2014814019,
-0.7934728861,
-0.2442182004,
-0.5137254,
-0.2382349968,
-0.5338025093,
-0.1206354722,
-0.2132432014,
0.3375889957,
-0.0499183647,
0.6769509315,
-0.6223952174,
0.0721027181,
0.1682505608,
-0.3644236326,
0.1812974066,
-0.1261046827,
-0.6015756726,
-0.1109295636,
-0.4642923772,
-1.039866209,
0.6428357959,
0.464507401,
1.2061158419,
0.1714016646,
0.7867970467,
0.3865065873,
0.0478192531,
-0.8329099417,
0.6814153194,
0.490914464,
-0.7220935225,
-0.0679557547,
0.0567486361,
-0.8313751817,
0.2629083693,
0.0951428339,
-0.6187304258,
0.3830669224,
-0.0308753718,
-0.0797733814,
0.0231704768,
-0.386778146,
0.6679063439,
-0.3127467036,
-0.5379766226,
-0.3496620655,
-0.2651034594,
0.346198976,
-0.0617442019,
0.3601202667,
-0.3201751411,
0.0160010755,
0.7685799003,
-0.2870566547,
0.8575646281,
0.0632109269,
-0.5225792527,
0.5506334901,
0.4077490568,
-0.063814275,
-0.0172798373,
-0.321600318,
-0.438241303,
0.1373912841,
-0.0910693482,
-0.3706725836,
0.3143140674,
-0.3579804599,
-0.7157570124,
-0.326669693,
-0.2322997451,
0.059259817,
0.4020172358,
-0.1641303897,
0.3838801384,
-0.7155393362,
-0.0120119983,
0.5788643956,
-0.0406181812,
0.6237267256,
0.5271965861,
-0.554394722,
0.0586336553,
0.416995585,
0.1537918597,
0.1510555148,
0.6391694546,
0.2423937619,
-0.3586331904,
-0.4668871164,
-0.4312906861,
-0.0692551285,
-0.7185767293,
0.0327386335,
-0.3501227498,
-0.2560008764,
-0.2582786977,
-0.2631859779,
-0.195951432,
-0.6412991285,
-0.2766210437,
-0.120248273,
-0.0022856833,
1.1087167263,
0.0182597917,
0.036617972,
-0.3993072808,
0.2826116681,
0.1075142547,
0.5503240824,
-0.0841406584,
-0.0879283398,
-0.2365584821,
0.0019935819,
-0.4403841794,
-1.1257047653,
0.1546222419,
-0.0256904606,
1.1716313362,
0.5400951505,
0.239941597,
0.4318351746,
-0.2981213927,
0.5497500896,
0.1911884546,
-0.7253594995,
0.9335090518,
-0.470173806,
0.0355091691,
0.1387194246,
0.182342574,
-0.5061510801,
-0.1493530869,
-0.7284476161,
-0.6717193127,
0.5272011161,
0.0433414914,
0.0468741432,
-0.219883576,
0.3875231445,
0.1753894985,
0.5497112274,
-0.5286785364,
-0.2644815147,
-0.0053921458,
0.0237095356,
0.5335785747,
-0.558799386,
-0.2989490032,
-0.0122513426,
0.3654873669,
-0.0804239064,
0.3263950646,
-0.1506612301,
0.0508278944,
-0.1931968033,
0.3799804747,
0.6823532581,
1.1899360418,
0.20593068,
0.2036403269,
-0.4243953824,
-0.1528436393,
0.3217728138,
-0.1402611285,
-0.0649028197,
-0.0960178226,
0.1584686637,
0.5154097676,
0.2315813601,
-0.2793195248,
0.0943284631,
0.092201367,
-0.3980568349,
-0.445908308,
0.1299338639,
0.0259319935,
0.126991719,
0.5508493185,
-0.1776410043,
0.162347272,
-0.8430649638,
0.4584981203,
0.1983413845,
-0.1051366106,
-0.3807263076,
0.6230089664,
0.5380613804,
-0.4957884848,
0.1979676634,
-0.3422478437,
-0.3074644208,
0.5014045835,
0.5851578712,
0.9820371866,
-0.1201585904,
0.5574213266,
0.2637556791,
-0.0718526393,
-0.0590470061,
0.7058210969,
-0.4166845381,
-0.7335782647,
-0.3366274834,
-1.061098814,
-0.2188394368,
-0.0439902879,
-0.4310828745,
0.4121682048,
-0.5955119133,
-0.2230757624,
-0.1759037524,
0.1176498607,
-0.4914416671,
0.2066179067,
0.1301065981,
0.6873924732,
-0.8037851453,
0.65329355,
0.9382039309,
-0.7407855988,
-0.5160371661,
-0.2492882013,
0.2322431654,
-0.5849766731,
1.1751365662,
-0.0134733813,
-0.1053234935,
-0.3411770761,
0.0797022656,
-1.1744421721,
0.7816464901,
0.1207475662,
-0.3469299972,
0.2446142137,
0.2767188251,
0.5977497101,
-0.7457525134,
-0.4126782715,
0.354544729,
0.5174507499,
0.399944216,
-0.9173378944,
0.2933373451,
-0.3341572285,
0.311852634,
0.2477383316,
-0.313491106,
0.7879503965,
-0.0583286993,
-0.8644292355,
0.3078970015,
0.5225009918,
0.1322842091,
0.0079752561,
0.156835705,
0.3671589494,
0.4911937416,
-0.1913384795,
0.5707337856,
-0.4471714199,
-0.025520768,
0.51290977,
-0.201460138,
0.7085401416,
0.620850563,
-0.4387499988,
0.5537275672,
0.7140703797,
0.4186087251,
0.3967755735,
0.6462042928,
-0.1657607108,
0.0515520349,
0.0426612608,
-0.4369331002,
0.4840307236,
0.6151781678,
-0.5628786087,
-0.1137029231,
0.0241483413,
-0.1204827204,
0.314771533,
-0.1592089683,
0.8224770427,
0.0961434543,
-0.5847966671,
0.4088642299,
-0.2306130677,
0.1395719051,
-0.3420737684,
-0.0177614465,
0.0607004091,
0.4312973619,
-0.1395370662,
-1.1526468992,
0.6323251724,
-0.567884922,
-0.5057670474,
-0.5290778279,
0.5111817718,
-0.1964860708,
-0.7108131647,
0.1883011013,
0.8334884644,
0.1258102506,
0.385519594,
-0.7386126518,
0.5693672299,
-0.2632580101,
-0.1852182597,
0.1242732704,
0.7202801704,
0.0420261063,
0.6404274702,
0.2616481781,
0.1203488186,
-0.2143544555,
0.2663874328,
0.7786194086,
-0.5005835891,
-0.6021335125,
-0.5514668226,
0.6373744011,
-0.1252388805,
-0.0744169727,
0.3607299626,
0.5093450546,
0.9436990023,
-0.0606309809,
1.1519240141,
-0.6306490302,
0.3928249478,
-0.4748284817,
0.5999658108,
-0.2470521927,
0.3466123641,
-0.6327915788,
-1.1546894312,
-0.3854014874,
1.2431515455,
0.0865768492,
0.1380312592,
0.8179104924,
0.6531450748,
0.1900094301,
0.0491718426,
0.3718886971,
-0.2716661692,
0.4990252256,
0.2473140955,
0.9203441143,
-0.1107267141,
0.2741524577,
-0.4208441675,
-0.6064270735,
-0.0348753966,
-0.9618340135,
-0.9584363103,
-1.0289324522,
-0.4599864483,
0.092646189,
-0.3184404075,
0.5743899941,
0.7370993495,
-0.6254871488,
-0.8343074322,
-0.3752899468,
0.1069604382,
-0.4583418667,
-0.2716527283,
0.0648212805,
-0.5491819978,
-0.6576939821,
0.2532147765,
0.6234128475,
0.371309489,
-0.8723651171,
-0.1595975906,
-0.1010453179,
-0.1556317508,
0.7826274037,
0.4332183897,
-0.6825249195,
-0.2859819829,
-0.0537702255,
0.0960156918,
-0.0422089621,
1.1855114698,
-0.4385848343,
0.6456071138,
0.8861666322,
0.2209187895,
0.1886992455,
-0.4318962991,
1.1063886881,
-0.4692500532,
0.2630442977,
-0.1363735348,
0.6589767337,
0.2347822785,
-0.1637226194,
0.6162148714,
0.4332937598,
-0.3351867497,
-0.4685934186,
0.9676781297,
-0.6270369291,
-0.5591694713,
0.8784153461,
0.2470792383,
-0.2046719491,
-0.5125542283,
-0.5657552481,
0.0877407938,
-0.2490313947,
0.9135437012,
0.8295717239,
-0.6963241696,
-0.0372118764,
-0.4064542055,
0.7022601962,
-0.207960099,
-0.3608164191,
0.2975207865,
0.3606822193,
0.0731683746,
0.5335025787,
0.7391552925,
-0.1300229281,
0.0788470432,
0.1271922141,
0.0401464291,
0.2089095116,
-0.1183081195,
0.4182898104,
0.5722285509,
0.3610135317,
-0.3069769442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13660v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13660v1
|
Trojan Detection in Large Language Models: Insights from The Trojan Detection Challenge
| 2024-04-21T13:31:16 | 2024-04-21T13:31:16 |
Narek Maloyan, Ekansh Verma, Bulat Nutfullin, Bislan Ashinov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
various domains, but their vulnerability to trojan or backdoor attacks poses
significant security risks. This paper explores the challenges and insights
gained from the Trojan Detection Competition 2023 (TDC2023), which focused on
identifying and evaluating trojan attacks on LLMs. We investigate the
difficulty of distinguishing between intended and unintended triggers, as well
as the feasibility of reverse engineering trojans in real-world scenarios. Our
comparative analysis of various trojan detection methods reveals that achieving
high Recall scores is significantly more challenging than obtaining high
Reverse-Engineering Attack Success Rate (REASR) scores. The top-performing
methods in the competition achieved Recall scores around 0.16, comparable to a
simple baseline of randomly sampling sentences from a distribution similar to
the given training prefixes. This finding raises questions about the
detectability and recoverability of trojans inserted into the model, given only
the harmful targets. Despite the inability to fully solve the problem, the
competition has led to interesting observations about the viability of trojan
detection and improved techniques for optimizing LLM input prompts. The
phenomenon of unintended triggers and the difficulty in distinguishing them
from intended triggers highlights the need for further research into the
robustness and interpretability of LLMs. The TDC2023 has provided valuable
insights into the challenges and opportunities associated with trojan detection
in LLMs, laying the groundwork for future research in this area to ensure their
safety and reliability in real-world applications.
|
[
-0.1710260212,
-0.6520400047,
0.7012519836,
0.025138123,
-0.2624877095,
0.2740107179,
-0.050454177,
-0.7853150368,
-0.0387273952,
0.5115085244,
-0.4209218919,
-0.5607323647,
-0.7278707027,
0.140392378,
-0.700981915,
0.7619858384,
0.028475957,
-0.283387363,
0.1700031161,
0.0472371131,
-0.7617478371,
-0.8558024168,
-0.807059288,
0.0110936183,
0.5582199097,
0.3101774752,
0.2194231153,
0.5608088374,
0.6118294001,
0.2350265533,
-0.3768233359,
-0.0296051316,
-0.4245653152,
0.3455946743,
-0.1040214002,
-0.6262931228,
-0.4751054645,
0.1319444031,
0.5419703126,
0.2719603479,
-0.068147175,
0.1995828152,
-0.0326625258,
0.5426421762,
-0.7316924334,
-0.0572977699,
-0.9878711104,
0.1172709912,
-0.738086164,
-0.4652231932,
-0.7890011072,
0.0410589576,
-0.0599896833,
-0.1430085897,
0.225245893,
0.4274170697,
0.6265767217,
-0.1707589179,
-0.5429206491,
-0.3036154807,
-0.8681177497,
0.8222067356,
-0.5441945791,
0.5051538944,
0.0887738988,
0.1768899411,
-0.7079713941,
-0.5967900157,
-0.4834695756,
-0.3262275159,
0.3426036239,
0.0035502007,
-0.7012878656,
-0.1117191389,
0.2140914947,
0.1911712289,
-0.6970103979,
0.637567699,
-0.5408435464,
-0.4005696476,
0.4802330732,
0.4421197176,
0.3291189075,
0.0491484664,
-0.2653794885,
0.1945861727,
-1.0072638988,
0.0208575875,
0.431707859,
0.2421771437,
-0.0176972225,
0.4923134148,
0.0987122729,
0.5759811401,
-0.1071518883,
-0.0617397316,
-0.0528101288,
-0.0882684216,
-0.0771086663,
0.192124173,
0.6862031221,
-0.0273304731,
0.2120161057,
-0.2212551087,
-0.4358338118,
-0.1506303251,
0.5311733484,
-0.2193658352,
0.0001990991,
0.3974339068,
-0.3274334073,
-0.4884037077,
0.0931538269,
-0.735234201,
-0.4985574782,
0.1182618514,
0.3547233641,
-0.0520798117,
0.0352489203,
0.282640934,
-0.0015028825,
0.5805557966,
0.4637364447,
-0.7634174228,
0.3029140532,
1.0560088158,
0.7822181582,
-0.6101399064,
-0.2034987211,
-0.8406728506,
0.1331553161,
-0.4056178331,
0.7107399106,
-0.2076559216,
-0.265686363,
-0.0064548496,
0.0232137199,
-0.14960289,
-0.7360776067,
0.5788013339,
-0.9906539917,
0.1781404763,
-0.0617611632,
-0.4266201556,
-0.0195481107,
0.4450103045,
-0.8129543662,
0.7963985801,
-0.3281342983,
-1.0541967154,
0.2207768261,
-0.2815227211,
-0.4599123299,
0.0794664845,
-0.0255502444,
-0.5643075705,
0.3033481836,
-0.0374747328,
0.4070723355,
-0.4767214358,
0.2279880643,
-0.4797576964,
-0.479660362,
0.3760789037,
-0.4166323245,
0.8675740361,
0.1368452311,
-0.5536962748,
0.1922375411,
-0.5740188956,
-0.589392066,
0.4019322395,
-0.3229423463,
-0.060326539,
-0.1194851249,
-0.3615416586,
0.1849609911,
0.0977291092,
-0.6897526979,
0.0855193064,
-0.2771611214,
0.3004075289,
0.879756093,
0.0174742937,
0.085162133,
-0.1303806007,
0.7894983292,
0.2999279201,
0.3838033974,
-0.0520683378,
-0.6880059838,
-0.6483548284,
-0.2845872343,
0.2591697276,
0.864628911,
-0.5712461472,
0.3520140946,
-0.0140875736,
-0.4512549043,
-0.2528220713,
0.0014834953,
0.2520455122,
0.5062892437,
0.2255684137,
-0.2833056152,
-0.4834909141,
-0.8670964241,
-0.4928616285,
-0.2776909471,
0.1057791486,
0.0014163087,
0.7944797873,
-0.0460156277,
0.7275269032,
-0.5140356421,
-0.3836378157,
-0.5857079029,
-0.0260175224,
0.2227016389,
0.4232675433,
0.3942959309,
-0.7548183203,
0.0032231803,
-0.1266596019,
-0.7668366432,
-0.026723735,
0.0648693591,
0.365885675,
0.380379796,
0.8336801529,
-0.6895726323,
0.5871818066,
0.4639891684,
-0.1741337478,
0.9803031683,
-0.2102464736,
0.1412883252,
-0.8700166941,
0.1016812623,
-0.1370599568,
-0.0180611741,
-0.8654539585,
0.1614809185,
0.128344208,
0.1000247747,
-0.7491492033,
0.5072983503,
-0.2301203907,
-0.1770450771,
-0.16041255,
0.3385739028,
-0.166806668,
0.0418341495,
-0.3072186708,
0.7454422116,
0.4337939322,
-0.5216072202,
0.7839384079,
-0.1260809451,
-0.5346376896,
0.2150348872,
-0.6727336049,
0.255083859,
0.057684131,
0.4155868888,
-1.125792861,
-0.1517067999,
0.3841573,
-0.6513400078,
0.4196219444,
-0.0212759934,
-0.6237812042,
-0.4968766272,
-0.5849460363,
0.4895894527,
0.3320411146,
-0.574297905,
0.5074563026,
0.4221524596,
0.0276340395,
-0.9206008911,
-0.6527121067,
0.3201263249,
-0.7143960595,
-0.5020458102,
0.0418451428,
0.330137521,
-0.3326441646,
-0.4111337364,
-0.1269947439,
0.269808352,
0.7267941236,
0.2290395945,
0.4571995735,
-0.1588500142,
0.0357693024,
-0.2371447831,
-0.3325340152,
0.3498694003,
-0.6328539252,
0.4208793342,
0.0372969322,
-0.5389348269,
-0.600628078,
0.1204221696,
0.5669845343,
-0.2983677983,
0.9155085683,
0.3739401698,
-0.4724861383,
-0.0583895966,
-0.688251853,
-0.2907868922,
-0.4612345397,
0.2623068094,
-0.2593382001,
-1.1563526392,
0.6806829572,
-0.0234717447,
-0.0316232219,
0.5222186446,
0.6194176078,
0.0168103352,
0.7937440872,
0.559445858,
-0.2910718024,
0.2599231303,
0.1830063611,
0.378477633,
-0.7314199209,
-0.5357277989,
-0.7858307958,
-0.1080844924,
-0.6353427768,
-0.1257957816,
0.3777246773,
-0.2755709887,
-0.14461115,
0.4374262094,
0.0115389507,
0.3743393123,
0.619949162,
-0.1262234747,
0.5820000172,
-0.1309375614,
-0.3614983857,
0.0069082677,
-0.5293979645,
-0.459101975,
0.924898088,
0.4424197674,
0.7321468592,
0.3591035008,
0.8393731713,
0.3374356031,
0.0335719101,
-0.5913643241,
0.6787083149,
-0.0668683052,
-0.8598346114,
-0.0721322596,
-0.3192044199,
-1.2919164896,
0.0120543232,
-0.394372344,
-1.4650470018,
-0.047665447,
0.1497921497,
-0.3457217813,
0.5937238932,
-0.2964837551,
0.8654444218,
-0.1761676371,
-0.3104121685,
-0.1093439162,
-0.6489890218,
0.7023772597,
-0.5938658118,
0.366876632,
-0.0410533845,
0.1715007275,
0.8092975616,
-0.0066011883,
0.7358494997,
0.1960905045,
-0.4423720837,
0.2659634948,
0.279524684,
0.6032672524,
0.0777697265,
0.089668639,
-0.0401425287,
-0.1131041348,
-0.2323579043,
-0.3916370273,
0.6331620812,
-0.5232434869,
-1.1268694401,
-0.6454865336,
-0.2602547109,
-0.1164473519,
0.1183628514,
0.2875937223,
0.2813447714,
-0.1079536229,
0.0856744051,
0.8421839476,
-0.6507482529,
0.2625779212,
0.5719389915,
-0.3321912885,
-0.1639475822,
0.9413073659,
-0.1279003322,
0.2012649775,
0.5049608946,
0.0474498905,
-0.0717601925,
-0.9578222036,
-0.3022063971,
0.3502983451,
-0.6376754045,
-0.1774696261,
-0.5389069319,
-0.1490941644,
-0.3643628061,
0.1273708344,
-0.4401259124,
-0.3351655006,
-0.5401957631,
-0.0717817321,
0.2134760469,
0.9103058577,
-0.0223042127,
0.1548912525,
-0.9915174842,
0.1454268545,
0.2160369158,
0.1657420993,
0.10263329,
-0.9399966598,
-0.1123479009,
-0.4015247226,
-0.3514608741,
-0.8891015053,
0.3879327476,
-0.4159121215,
0.4749455452,
0.2910000384,
0.0458450727,
0.284938246,
-0.3988944888,
0.8265120983,
-0.1036764458,
-0.9706726074,
0.491127193,
-0.286872685,
0.122622326,
0.1938206851,
0.4488670826,
-0.5290409923,
-0.4914261401,
-0.4958820641,
-0.8723993897,
0.6677061319,
0.1889790893,
-0.069434844,
0.0879905298,
0.5235819221,
-0.0802088827,
-0.0195970032,
-0.5403517485,
-0.1589586288,
0.6382098794,
-0.0068694996,
0.0448384769,
-0.3670540452,
0.0554051921,
0.0714907274,
0.5576398373,
0.3637515903,
0.1890539229,
-0.2328344584,
0.0088308835,
0.0617229342,
0.312811017,
0.7956314683,
0.2055951357,
-0.0934369862,
0.2748602033,
0.3757661581,
-0.7620012164,
0.2677065134,
-0.0247987788,
0.0336003974,
-0.37059021,
0.7810945511,
0.4040523469,
0.0089280913,
-0.8667862415,
0.5567218661,
-0.3300745785,
-0.0107139051,
-0.4755522311,
0.055817578,
-0.0185570475,
0.5485906005,
0.6500441432,
-0.3787273765,
0.1638879329,
-0.4592492282,
0.1402843148,
0.5970050097,
-0.4065276086,
-0.4543547034,
0.6808040142,
-0.0666701645,
-0.3051698208,
0.7844187617,
-0.0282740425,
-0.858930409,
0.7513469458,
0.6120547652,
0.8689501882,
-0.2687329054,
-0.2632893324,
-0.1547334939,
0.59184587,
-0.0702167451,
0.1372416914,
0.4708417058,
-0.7424051166,
-0.1938075125,
-0.2689042985,
-0.506970346,
0.4268135428,
-0.5919198394,
0.4811580777,
-0.3649002016,
-0.2156755924,
0.0914923847,
-0.2068068236,
-0.3249074221,
-0.0308771711,
0.384743154,
1.0019569397,
-0.7315083742,
0.684517622,
0.5207839012,
0.1805991828,
-0.6334599853,
-0.0370414816,
0.5451254249,
-0.6448246837,
0.8355290294,
0.2115240991,
-0.3186022639,
-0.1833434105,
-0.6170867085,
-0.6448740363,
1.0292129517,
0.4391001165,
-0.3132765293,
-0.0635158718,
0.2696703374,
0.4115606844,
-0.2852787077,
-0.1736992151,
0.8105029464,
0.2264322042,
0.1099902391,
-0.9464510679,
0.1523976922,
0.1124970615,
-0.2668880224,
0.282014966,
-0.3853593767,
0.8273236752,
-0.3258320391,
-0.315607965,
0.118948184,
0.6094766855,
0.6274216175,
0.5209069848,
0.1712047756,
0.4051966965,
0.4025479853,
-0.1669179946,
0.8785645962,
-0.0737541616,
0.2866512239,
0.9438869357,
-0.4032992125,
0.8945304751,
0.4323948026,
-0.1017811522,
0.2552590966,
0.55265975,
-0.0724379718,
0.1321270317,
0.4288783073,
-0.4372085929,
-0.3277374506,
-0.0481837727,
-0.1790075451,
0.7005954981,
0.5027266145,
-0.2875378728,
-0.0962559134,
0.1385835409,
0.0660728514,
-0.2452447861,
-0.1684180945,
0.531578064,
0.2144659609,
-0.3884957433,
0.322366029,
0.247509107,
0.4833961129,
-0.3824034631,
0.1454518139,
-0.2480348647,
0.4035459757,
0.0222817864,
-0.7656694651,
0.1737767607,
0.1217953414,
0.2881273925,
0.1996425837,
0.8285642862,
-0.0362374596,
0.0290661454,
0.4899187982,
0.4161151052,
0.1910906583,
-0.1777641624,
-0.3819875121,
0.5705420971,
-0.2597073317,
-0.3500669599,
0.4332256019,
0.4473761022,
-0.3100450635,
1.0288438797,
0.5004382133,
-0.0778802112,
0.0215383563,
-0.2831139266,
0.8372608423,
-0.7465586066,
-0.1305109859,
-1.1175370216,
0.0855101198,
0.1934041232,
-0.0275297556,
0.8248916864,
0.5848194957,
0.7742516994,
-0.2043375373,
0.4723080397,
0.4856643081,
0.2828517556,
-0.5389980078,
0.5884559751,
-0.4523294866,
0.6310858727,
-0.3038556278,
-0.6647179127,
-0.6947727203,
0.0578120872,
-0.4072445631,
0.007326114,
0.6739264727,
0.6027845144,
0.1325929165,
0.1497668922,
0.2839760184,
0.264369458,
0.5550647974,
0.7139607668,
1.1429949999,
-0.3254989982,
0.6115127802,
0.1827537864,
-0.1444569975,
-0.4512314796,
-0.9974601865,
-0.922901988,
-0.4689817131,
-0.1532373279,
-0.5475743413,
0.3852522671,
0.8223397732,
0.1451820284,
-1.1107379198,
-0.2047221363,
0.1611885279,
0.4254505634,
0.056366425,
-0.1746430248,
0.2312064618,
-0.0694618002,
-0.4272027314,
0.3892597258,
0.5589798689,
0.2866057754,
-0.1164990589,
0.2903751433,
-0.2341058552,
0.093960166,
0.5678867698,
0.5675702691,
-0.6868361235,
-0.4460173845,
0.0764868557,
-0.2097310871,
-0.2993434966,
0.8894128799,
-0.6704745889,
0.0538309142,
0.3998545706,
0.7378607392,
0.386063695,
-0.3136530519,
0.5520310402,
-0.3847076595,
0.069334358,
0.1359195411,
0.4386304021,
0.1493801773,
-0.1861710399,
0.2953775823,
0.4943968952,
-0.5171088576,
-1.0142509937,
0.398063153,
-1.0041488409,
-0.2102710158,
1.0431306362,
-0.3335817158,
-0.1798047274,
-0.4892007113,
-0.0190466288,
0.239452377,
-0.094989039,
1.0496807098,
0.6516321898,
-0.0157693997,
-0.0495898053,
-0.7305903435,
0.404358536,
0.2349354327,
-0.6860714555,
0.2134628594,
0.199835822,
0.1478533894,
0.0973576233,
0.1839962304,
-0.3172778785,
0.4364422858,
-0.3004206717,
-0.2982487381,
0.0616964698,
-0.5614766479,
-0.598333776,
0.2728089392,
0.3362060785,
-0.0144024258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13645v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13645v1
|
PEACH: Pretrained-embedding Explanation Across Contextual and Hierarchical Structure
| 2024-04-21T12:41:02 | 2024-04-21T12:41:02 |
Feiqi Cao, Caren Han, Hyunsuk Chung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we propose a novel tree-based explanation technique, PEACH
(Pretrained-embedding Explanation Across Contextual and Hierarchical
Structure), that can explain how text-based documents are classified by using
any pretrained contextual embeddings in a tree-based human-interpretable
manner. Note that PEACH can adopt any contextual embeddings of the PLMs as a
training input for the decision tree. Using the proposed PEACH, we perform a
comprehensive analysis of several contextual embeddings on nine different NLP
text classification benchmarks. This analysis demonstrates the flexibility of
the model by applying several PLM contextual embeddings, its attribute
selections, scaling, and clustering methods. Furthermore, we show the utility
of explanations by visualising the feature selection and important trend of
text classification via human-interpretable word-cloud-based trees, which
clearly identify model mistakes and assist in dataset debugging. Besides
interpretability, PEACH outperforms or is similar to those from pretrained
models.
|
[
-0.2743280232,
-0.9493396282,
0.6549482346,
0.2120199054,
-0.3230348527,
0.048784364,
-0.2406104803,
-0.1873116195,
0.1023306102,
0.2774160504,
-0.9053461552,
-0.4497499466,
-0.5159377456,
0.078666307,
-0.4430469573,
1.3052651882,
-0.2378339171,
-0.211513862,
-0.573718071,
0.0575778373,
-0.7176068425,
-0.5566452146,
-0.4105168879,
-0.1960143894,
0.3124313653,
0.3463631272,
0.6993482113,
0.7530655265,
0.2741807401,
0.2956848741,
-0.2149404734,
-0.2606746256,
-0.2400572896,
0.0019607304,
-0.1688581705,
-0.8066931367,
-0.4438738525,
0.1322054714,
0.7068466544,
0.757255435,
-0.1480102241,
-0.1168957949,
0.3957069516,
0.411120981,
-0.5047699213,
0.5018490553,
-0.6795327067,
0.4139978588,
-0.326969862,
-0.3967029154,
-0.6110453606,
-0.0964237452,
0.1576883793,
-0.837187469,
0.3610574007,
0.1673451066,
0.9296118021,
0.4504700899,
-0.3731229603,
-0.1041081175,
-0.2780729532,
0.8070560694,
-0.372148037,
0.2512723505,
0.3136096895,
0.5290130973,
0.0637040213,
-0.8736699224,
-0.3045104146,
0.2636089027,
-0.3698233366,
0.146208927,
0.217484206,
0.1684477925,
0.2969867885,
0.517254293,
-0.2564056516,
0.0159597266,
0.260332942,
-0.1908108592,
0.4675757885,
-0.0514322631,
0.4071363509,
-0.2481664568,
-0.3816440701,
0.1448845267,
-0.5234549046,
0.2442846,
-0.2328149825,
0.3459654152,
-0.150041014,
0.2163850814,
0.1144669577,
0.6806560755,
-0.0195561498,
-0.1192254499,
0.3584092557,
-0.3498280644,
-0.4312413037,
0.2432348728,
0.745679915,
0.2248173654,
0.0874560624,
-0.4209627807,
-0.0041365828,
0.0000483437,
0.2939626575,
-0.9634154439,
-0.1761498898,
0.0866650939,
-0.6983803511,
-0.4003551304,
0.1617965698,
-0.8639944196,
-0.384771049,
-0.0142260976,
0.1663195193,
-0.2821284831,
-0.2016248852,
-0.1118371636,
-0.2103429735,
0.04199389,
0.4034707248,
-1.2483997345,
0.4682139158,
0.8857315779,
0.8890188336,
0.0231775381,
-0.3523120582,
-0.4267854393,
0.0540011823,
-0.3660018146,
0.6517032981,
-0.6254656315,
-0.0665792525,
-0.2084817141,
0.2673887908,
-0.2438644767,
-0.0622491501,
0.8296768665,
-0.1695769131,
0.4782141149,
-0.5044891238,
-0.5592033267,
-0.612377882,
0.1784323454,
-0.4950035512,
0.7575929761,
0.2302284092,
-1.2259167433,
0.8405901194,
-0.8295941949,
-0.2533370256,
0.2494717985,
-0.3396213949,
-0.6082867384,
0.0736063346,
0.5737752914,
0.5325827599,
-0.2072137594,
0.6063420773,
-0.2487369776,
-0.3124698102,
-0.0519394949,
-0.3836268485,
0.8834891319,
0.3032473922,
-0.4267305732,
0.19169797,
-0.213081032,
0.0206680875,
0.3200618327,
-0.0404103585,
-0.3525055051,
0.4976749122,
-0.0920171589,
-0.1046400592,
0.15255557,
-0.4613503814,
0.1766367406,
-0.369212091,
0.7974104285,
0.3371528983,
-0.1266202778,
0.5490404367,
-0.2771743238,
0.7538737655,
0.1549282372,
0.1259258091,
-0.8597840667,
-0.6055346131,
-0.173844412,
-0.1105430126,
0.4859880507,
0.4340000153,
-0.4124136269,
0.3889521658,
-0.2761727571,
0.0421740115,
-0.2181868255,
-0.1444524974,
0.2285099477,
0.9019304514,
0.2782826424,
-0.4670451283,
-0.5098621845,
-0.7548919916,
-0.3748460412,
-0.0184372459,
0.0397144668,
0.4949990511,
0.4183985591,
-0.3124272823,
1.4235942364,
-0.2550409138,
-0.125334084,
-0.1711851358,
0.3371851146,
0.1914327145,
0.2987669706,
0.6269670725,
-1.0650646687,
-0.3155294955,
-0.0680121258,
-0.6837325692,
-0.2725319564,
-0.4482776225,
0.0128368987,
-0.0633622259,
0.4252685308,
-0.2879855335,
0.3319534361,
0.2652822435,
-0.6504876614,
0.6463900805,
-0.1235339418,
0.0700238571,
-0.9882334471,
-0.2048493624,
-0.0384356305,
-0.5690007806,
-0.2762559652,
0.1539606601,
0.2981077433,
-0.2498745918,
-0.1442684382,
0.2009687722,
-0.5251482129,
-0.4004622996,
0.1217778325,
0.1996240318,
0.2812410593,
0.4004872739,
0.1691534966,
0.7598160505,
0.6113295555,
-0.3335037529,
0.0236126166,
0.6068653464,
-0.3107030094,
0.4050768316,
-0.408667177,
-0.1508451849,
-0.2481308281,
0.4872251749,
-0.8292255998,
-0.2043904364,
0.1268658042,
-0.395624131,
0.1888927072,
-0.4058002234,
-0.2374943048,
-0.3692102432,
-0.3784323335,
0.1739345044,
0.2559043765,
-0.7640260458,
0.5581632853,
0.4013232887,
-0.3637356162,
-0.4257723987,
-0.868766427,
0.0805447251,
-0.5959944129,
-0.6242943406,
0.8592307568,
0.0438838191,
-0.0200266615,
0.0999173895,
-0.2008883804,
-0.3463267684,
0.646609962,
0.5886746645,
0.0981822833,
-0.4699519873,
0.3675599992,
0.1868118495,
-0.1004425436,
0.1904344708,
-0.2298058271,
0.0896480083,
-0.4956687987,
-0.1252360642,
-0.450116992,
0.2160205543,
0.378461957,
-0.3313745856,
0.8269272447,
0.4185395837,
-0.2502060235,
-0.3620310128,
0.001826955,
-0.0308942627,
-0.424983263,
0.2584698796,
-0.5234358907,
-0.7626866102,
0.3495929241,
-0.3761977553,
0.2462793738,
0.4724315703,
0.2325970531,
-0.1537290215,
1.2497798204,
0.7460775375,
-0.0905058756,
0.6065455675,
-0.194459945,
0.048885338,
-0.6821824908,
-0.3031066656,
-0.6082526445,
-0.2148129195,
-0.4230041504,
-0.3061995506,
-0.1000260115,
0.5944054723,
-0.4064732194,
0.1277941316,
-0.6803528666,
0.6652724743,
0.3301537335,
-0.1840494871,
0.2234357446,
-0.0410350859,
-0.2845557928,
-0.1876804084,
-0.8424419165,
-0.6711179018,
0.7507297397,
0.7315337062,
0.4566222727,
-0.206763953,
0.746180594,
0.0651567057,
0.492744118,
-1.0256052017,
0.1351623684,
-0.2346310467,
-0.4604566097,
-0.2045679986,
-0.5138896704,
-0.9938951731,
0.4296885431,
-0.4640415907,
-0.9932425022,
-0.137872681,
0.1781425029,
-0.4941768944,
0.1394249052,
-1.0464732647,
1.4936147928,
-0.6258032918,
-0.0787590966,
0.0451847054,
-0.3188556433,
0.3872963488,
-0.1632530242,
0.629065752,
0.1569783986,
-0.0860577822,
1.164026618,
-0.7298199534,
0.5216330886,
-0.3543660641,
0.2334309816,
0.1724271774,
0.0164967403,
0.3556172252,
-0.0080621941,
-0.0843516439,
0.1295101792,
0.1520284861,
-0.121345222,
-0.770811677,
0.4984030128,
-0.6274549365,
-0.614071548,
-0.3712893128,
-0.4694142342,
-0.2923123538,
0.2443355322,
0.1749263108,
0.6307413578,
0.0362799019,
0.5954153538,
0.2502604127,
-0.251409471,
0.4788002968,
0.2502269745,
-0.495301187,
0.1005893275,
0.6178911328,
-0.0504421107,
-0.4069449306,
0.395167917,
0.6345560551,
-0.5701546669,
-0.8028729558,
-0.3512466252,
0.0461150222,
-0.4378966093,
0.1532593817,
-0.5560464859,
0.0182306953,
-0.0981911346,
-0.3486821651,
-0.0542742684,
-0.4309197962,
-0.4944663644,
-0.1944111437,
0.1774961948,
0.8519440889,
0.4126060307,
0.7819253206,
-0.749774456,
0.3118335307,
0.1880459636,
0.6487932205,
-0.0953854918,
-0.4340577722,
-0.2372229248,
0.2327206731,
-0.4958898425,
-1.3470391035,
0.5661608577,
0.5374648571,
0.694167614,
0.5679479241,
-0.0781387165,
0.6513240933,
-0.4727320969,
0.8320584893,
0.2229013741,
-1.1249392033,
0.9159232974,
-0.3813631833,
0.0526328199,
0.6350369453,
0.4217343628,
-0.3502842188,
-0.0540789478,
-0.8396812081,
-0.7589610219,
1.1088854074,
-0.1232607588,
-0.2836802602,
0.1825013012,
0.445415318,
0.1609738022,
0.1708499342,
-0.9346891046,
-0.0029849843,
-0.4920223355,
-0.2516353726,
-0.2928718925,
-0.3339924812,
-0.0095088761,
-0.166177839,
0.5126848817,
-0.2496062368,
0.0629704967,
0.0320823379,
-0.4078795612,
-0.008455622,
0.3022516966,
-0.0898345783,
0.7832136154,
-0.260125339,
0.0677530542,
-0.0526124835,
-0.2954542935,
-0.1807368249,
0.1134502441,
-0.2122135907,
0.016154794,
0.499679625,
1.0114369392,
0.457064271,
-0.3703821898,
0.7456546426,
-0.3246964812,
-0.1573864222,
0.0136475237,
0.0545162149,
0.1029960886,
0.003429174,
0.2728319764,
-0.2021343559,
0.1477630883,
-0.790489912,
0.3739196658,
0.470605284,
-0.4179976881,
-0.1780647635,
0.8687803745,
0.384735316,
-0.3656489253,
0.5034204125,
-0.1228373423,
-0.8709275126,
0.6180424094,
0.5815334916,
0.816110909,
0.1161549315,
0.6425372362,
0.2043804824,
0.2689035833,
-0.0789160505,
-0.0244771279,
-0.6500849724,
-0.6276811361,
-0.5995205641,
-0.8089675307,
-0.4520174265,
-0.048905544,
-0.689340353,
0.0776518807,
-0.4029601812,
-0.055529736,
0.3675011992,
0.1468758285,
-0.5107587576,
0.3298693299,
0.1503913552,
0.9898386002,
-1.0757594109,
0.7228289843,
0.6970103383,
-0.3096981347,
-1.063903451,
0.1641523242,
0.1634637415,
-0.4258516431,
0.5338612199,
0.5689476132,
0.2904166579,
-0.1271555126,
-0.363981396,
-0.6331243515,
1.1410179138,
0.4997856021,
-0.7418583632,
-0.0614445657,
-0.2368971407,
0.4128814936,
-0.525433898,
0.6570097804,
0.6462238431,
0.4579373598,
-0.0518676266,
-0.9308148026,
0.0255925711,
-0.1758024693,
0.0201288685,
0.0853493065,
-0.0956657454,
0.9255375862,
-0.0218051206,
-0.5983513594,
-0.3423708677,
0.4227142334,
0.0250431225,
0.4278431833,
0.6022155285,
0.5979526639,
1.0046772957,
-0.4096895754,
1.4186635017,
-0.2006205916,
0.5445193648,
1.1855232716,
0.1795842797,
0.7281596065,
0.1954675168,
-0.4314715862,
0.9329131842,
1.0686912537,
0.2893295884,
0.4684924483,
-0.1108324453,
0.0302020982,
-0.1388421804,
0.046397239,
-0.4681940675,
0.4282489419,
0.5259830952,
-0.4917292595,
-0.44707793,
0.0231967997,
-0.1377858967,
0.0666953027,
-0.5349900723,
0.7595131397,
0.1135094613,
-0.7692610621,
0.4768932462,
0.0429601967,
0.8319931626,
-0.4682975113,
0.1149329618,
0.1124094352,
0.0879069939,
-0.5541433692,
-0.9373345375,
0.5317748189,
0.0091737527,
-0.1569849253,
-0.7623369694,
0.6981642842,
-0.3305955231,
-0.2174360752,
0.1013798118,
0.306820035,
0.2645345032,
-0.4082638323,
-1.0581842661,
-0.0948406085,
-0.0454701148,
-0.3127513528,
0.1702418327,
0.6484494209,
-0.2538269162,
0.576520443,
0.4648937285,
-0.0105425064,
-0.2477424294,
0.0937957168,
0.5260404944,
-0.6120733023,
-1.2081631422,
-0.8331608772,
0.3844921589,
-0.0140000526,
0.0053946716,
0.8436605334,
0.3775031269,
0.3692794144,
0.1909862608,
0.7759186029,
-0.0207633264,
0.527367413,
-0.4919795692,
0.7734514475,
-0.5849255323,
0.2712983787,
-0.4304895103,
-0.9322471619,
-0.1068616882,
0.9344618917,
-0.5200388432,
0.0238209385,
0.9903919697,
0.3204415739,
-0.1118777543,
0.592033565,
-0.0782437995,
0.4131304026,
0.1281841248,
0.6194555759,
0.6686447263,
-0.1043864861,
0.3554054201,
-0.1234251931,
-0.5068122149,
-0.1649393886,
-1.3056949377,
-0.585454464,
-0.6849248409,
-0.3713022768,
0.095017612,
-0.144554764,
0.4215177,
1.0117313862,
-0.7649110556,
0.1774530411,
-0.5087485909,
0.5043289065,
-0.2231884301,
-0.3023706675,
0.2737118006,
-0.4424394667,
-0.336879164,
0.4259032011,
0.1495176703,
-0.13267304,
-0.0184452273,
-0.1116121039,
0.0784172341,
-0.3271543384,
0.5916885734,
0.2128815949,
-0.654401958,
-0.1772219241,
-0.5447740555,
0.2744856179,
0.2180993408,
0.9073125124,
-1.1308326721,
0.6248376369,
0.5002995729,
0.8041283488,
0.6224645972,
0.4130475819,
0.6532943845,
-0.8618530631,
0.1479645371,
0.2245304435,
0.6277685761,
0.3329696357,
-0.4708451927,
0.3708931208,
0.1634680331,
-0.3324128389,
-0.7114816308,
-0.0357448198,
-0.9082763195,
-0.6076140404,
0.8083589673,
-0.4747080803,
-0.4539625943,
-0.2651421428,
-0.2760513127,
0.1049486697,
-0.1570490003,
0.5727551579,
0.7145058513,
-0.0432916582,
-0.448608458,
-0.4453163743,
0.7168291807,
0.4383916855,
-1.2307556868,
0.1599050164,
0.4693934321,
0.2369999737,
0.1357729435,
0.7195774913,
-0.196273312,
0.2843272686,
0.0518557355,
-0.3137402833,
-0.4256462157,
-0.5085473657,
-0.5511132479,
0.2901413739,
0.0026115931,
-0.169630304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13633v1
|
Incorporating Different Verbal Cues to Improve Text-Based Computer-Delivered Health Messaging
| 2024-04-21T12:15:44 | 2024-04-21T12:15:44 |
Samuel Rhys Cox
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
The ubiquity of smartphones has led to an increase in on demand healthcare
being supplied. For example, people can share their illness-related experiences
with others similar to themselves, and healthcare experts can offer advice for
better treatment and care for remediable, terminal and mental illnesses. As
well as this human-to-human communication, there has been an increased use of
human-to-computer digital health messaging, such as chatbots. These can prove
advantageous as they offer synchronous and anonymous feedback without the need
for a human conversational partner. However, there are many subtleties involved
in human conversation that a computer agent may not properly exhibit. For
example, there are various conversational styles, etiquettes, politeness
strategies or empathic responses that need to be chosen appropriately for the
conversation. Encouragingly, computers are social actors (CASA) posits that
people apply the same social norms to computers as they would do to people. On
from this, previous studies have focused on applying conversational strategies
to computer agents to make them embody more favourable human characteristics.
However, if a computer agent fails in this regard it can lead to negative
reactions from users. Therefore, in this dissertation we describe a series of
studies we carried out to lead to more effective human-to-computer digital
health messaging.
In our first study, we use the crowd [...]
Our second study investigates the effect of a health chatbot's conversational
style [...]
In our final study, we investigate the format used by a chatbot when [...]
In summary, we have researched how to create more effective digital health
interventions starting from generating health messages, to choosing an
appropriate formality of messaging, and finally to formatting messages which
reference a user's previous utterances.
|
[
0.0241725352,
-1.1144590378,
0.7632055283,
0.3032056391,
-0.3118554354,
0.0087348418,
-0.2290692776,
-0.7438947558,
0.72251302,
0.345674783,
-0.4518006444,
-0.4128195941,
-0.5849536657,
0.2783431709,
-0.2231699824,
0.9476553202,
0.3638434112,
0.2010952234,
-0.2138009965,
0.0522266887,
-0.6498852372,
-0.8346612453,
-0.9133121371,
-0.6062694192,
0.6264570355,
0.684525609,
1.120470047,
0.3763797879,
0.543576777,
0.2949699163,
0.0848776102,
0.3605673313,
-0.3746390641,
0.3621917069,
-0.0479816273,
-0.2454918772,
-0.4615639448,
-0.1638316512,
0.1426529586,
0.3830775619,
-0.1806556582,
0.0241210014,
0.2303877026,
0.5475666523,
-0.4030479491,
0.0711826608,
-0.2966741323,
0.1808941364,
-0.1371170282,
-0.4985774159,
-0.6028015018,
-0.1937732995,
0.119800128,
-0.739198029,
-0.2524194419,
-0.243402034,
0.8958469033,
0.3292337656,
-0.5773239136,
-0.5105431676,
-1.0366373062,
0.406014502,
-0.730134666,
0.1648785025,
0.6623075604,
0.2747278214,
-0.2217604667,
-0.6667239666,
-0.2078510225,
-0.1171330661,
-0.1077403277,
0.3365508616,
-0.2526498735,
0.3212063611,
-0.056857612,
0.0217899028,
-0.2435535789,
0.0669274703,
-0.3208381236,
-0.3794975877,
0.9092957377,
0.2781101167,
0.5984131694,
-0.2325680405,
0.0667078719,
-0.2243515998,
-0.2192791849,
-0.0576353334,
0.0461960398,
0.269577235,
-0.5822585225,
0.4624621868,
0.0052332594,
0.3253546059,
0.5673648119,
-0.349226743,
0.2231825143,
-0.3677040935,
-0.1529666632,
0.1451691687,
0.8173095584,
0.8186445832,
0.3623791039,
0.2288797349,
0.3704644144,
0.3136029243,
0.5921986699,
-0.7115855813,
-0.3432017267,
0.405375421,
-0.8532293439,
-0.3164935112,
0.0270327777,
-0.9412411451,
-0.6081137061,
-0.1423131377,
0.3365859091,
-0.4469322264,
-0.0910288095,
0.1231772304,
-0.1664808393,
0.2609342635,
0.2453645766,
-0.9199255109,
0.6225757003,
0.4066775143,
0.7167910933,
0.1880588233,
0.3425106406,
-0.4613712132,
-0.0403706096,
-0.1967077851,
0.7779490352,
-0.6851986647,
-0.6083951592,
0.1419037879,
-0.0669189766,
-0.1263733059,
-0.5062185526,
0.5872030854,
0.0087574776,
0.53272295,
-0.4281376898,
-0.2665925324,
0.3257086277,
0.2136053294,
-0.367880255,
0.8672869205,
-0.0677102506,
-0.8021021485,
-0.0047340333,
-0.8559134603,
-0.8474884629,
0.1179453433,
-0.3929902017,
-0.6707571745,
0.0892850682,
0.3889712691,
0.5346363187,
-0.1126846448,
-0.1359898001,
-0.20157592,
-0.4614181817,
0.6246746778,
-0.3171986341,
0.6293008924,
0.3036214113,
-0.5312642455,
0.3999346197,
-0.4165617824,
0.1902160496,
0.1713081449,
-0.0749473348,
-0.3118851781,
0.3166591525,
0.1401452273,
0.096300222,
-0.0647190362,
-0.183520034,
-0.1531981677,
-0.5359845757,
0.6542463899,
0.382034868,
0.3492499888,
0.3117207289,
-0.8423204422,
0.4394054711,
-0.1542874426,
0.8065062165,
-0.4001010656,
-0.8410887122,
-0.1382527798,
-0.2844395339,
-0.2177369744,
0.8793327212,
-0.8527654409,
0.2763512433,
-0.0048805065,
-0.3057869971,
-0.7059782743,
-0.2105375677,
0.45519346,
0.39537099,
0.2980467677,
-0.5845448375,
-0.3194042444,
-0.603774488,
-0.1323140264,
-0.643435061,
-0.0592159219,
0.7572354674,
-0.0945679918,
-0.4589684308,
0.5513731837,
-0.3876118362,
0.0462095104,
-0.2624614239,
0.005743735,
-0.4154038131,
0.1524312645,
0.2992820442,
-0.7773415446,
-0.5168620348,
0.0498059243,
-0.6763809919,
-0.2481131405,
-0.5348760486,
0.0611456335,
-0.1008511633,
0.3456956446,
-0.3080180287,
0.7227019072,
0.5362198949,
-0.36062181,
0.5009533763,
-0.4927374423,
0.6035056114,
-1.3447586298,
-0.2857508361,
0.275493443,
-0.2909380496,
-1.0149911642,
-0.2894042432,
-0.2491586208,
-0.2019696981,
-0.4965417683,
0.6237948537,
-0.5218386054,
0.0942092314,
-0.4536599219,
0.067949295,
0.0844124854,
0.1261001974,
-0.188859418,
0.5433773398,
0.4392486215,
-0.5727622509,
0.3337017894,
0.308796823,
0.3882236481,
1.3123283386,
-0.8365024924,
0.3947921097,
-0.2279517651,
0.3805683553,
-0.8664666414,
-0.5617725253,
0.6923551559,
-0.8784672618,
0.1337803304,
0.424970597,
-0.453376025,
-0.4095620811,
-0.4596772492,
0.3142178953,
0.5082632303,
-0.1105917394,
0.4856263697,
0.6400063038,
-0.2993853092,
-0.0175989103,
-0.9510582089,
0.5463674068,
-0.3522670567,
-0.6440235376,
0.5200996399,
-0.0894684643,
-0.6310420036,
-0.2429026216,
0.2169041038,
-0.3683095276,
0.1865628362,
0.6071703434,
0.3038128614,
0.2517249286,
0.5343991518,
0.1777222902,
0.0177933071,
0.1611264944,
-0.0948070288,
0.4185700715,
0.0569018424,
-0.4492083788,
-1.0986263752,
0.839695096,
0.3569132686,
-0.0303459838,
0.8315045834,
0.683719635,
-0.325725913,
0.2308219224,
-0.3935553133,
-0.8546416759,
-0.469686389,
0.111426495,
0.1003103852,
-0.6526576877,
0.2853403986,
-0.0779288709,
-0.1557497829,
-0.1134803295,
0.6663560867,
-0.4124952555,
1.0896850824,
0.4712764621,
-0.106892176,
0.610502243,
0.2881282866,
0.0152041866,
-0.3407530189,
-0.2585579157,
-0.6107135415,
-0.2066137493,
-0.7600407004,
-0.4204431772,
0.4895887375,
-0.5199490786,
-0.2458171844,
0.1887213737,
-0.9258800149,
-0.0669863224,
0.4442839324,
0.9574375749,
0.0483497754,
-0.0626813695,
-0.1530981362,
-0.0711476579,
-0.6506028771,
-0.5949791074,
0.7726204395,
0.3689085245,
0.8286169171,
-0.0526519679,
0.6423246264,
0.4092601538,
0.4250558913,
-0.5604363084,
0.4077756405,
0.1345495582,
-0.6830759645,
-0.1274586469,
-0.433229506,
-1.2819086313,
-0.1640871912,
-0.4409213066,
-0.9898400903,
-0.0492993854,
0.3075641692,
-0.5135154128,
-0.1333132982,
-0.897980988,
0.6794853806,
-0.2338528186,
-0.2927779853,
-0.2734917998,
-1.0904210806,
-0.3342978358,
0.2425149828,
0.3777155876,
-0.0428926051,
0.0721024424,
0.2908965945,
-0.553427577,
1.2844041586,
0.1419636011,
-0.0366198272,
0.468924135,
-0.3664909005,
0.3659845591,
-0.0549711101,
-0.038389612,
-0.0167194493,
0.2218057811,
-0.4708057046,
-0.5354593396,
0.3274484575,
-0.9085211158,
-0.4802726805,
-0.1719443351,
-0.255191803,
-0.2953285575,
-0.1733586341,
0.2562725842,
0.7087121606,
-0.3261705935,
-0.1635791659,
0.5636723638,
-0.7931122184,
0.1784340739,
0.2985426486,
0.1804279685,
-0.4828500748,
0.5985988975,
-0.3133735061,
0.3872243166,
0.4692568183,
0.5527671576,
-0.2072215676,
0.0624004826,
-0.1499624401,
0.4487836659,
-0.5602183342,
0.0568816848,
-0.4228224754,
-0.2897672951,
-0.7387911081,
-0.347898066,
0.0707492083,
0.0462930836,
-0.7382711172,
0.0412172526,
0.5516347885,
0.629974246,
-0.0102993716,
0.6388844252,
-0.9719978571,
0.1565943509,
0.4305152893,
0.0518579446,
0.0085885841,
-0.3097822964,
-0.0307433456,
0.2618370056,
-0.4683237076,
-1.6322592497,
0.1797958314,
0.1545806229,
0.4566040039,
0.4895694852,
0.2075438201,
0.6031392217,
-0.3011033833,
0.812877655,
0.4047417641,
-0.8585168719,
0.779312551,
-0.4053263068,
0.459725678,
0.5707986355,
0.2996837199,
-1.1885432005,
-0.3567634523,
-0.7044579387,
-0.452889353,
0.1945759207,
0.3284963369,
0.5291173458,
-0.4228554368,
0.4568375945,
-0.1998334676,
-0.0618355237,
-0.4385840893,
-0.4600000978,
-0.2237401754,
-0.6372845173,
0.4019710422,
-0.2119074017,
0.0110981548,
0.028540777,
0.3897762299,
-0.1764012724,
0.5574061275,
0.5670114756,
0.2664770186,
-0.0571594127,
0.6153897643,
0.5173537135,
0.1706366986,
0.1973555535,
0.1587943137,
0.0489139743,
-0.6708477139,
0.0336579196,
-0.0118020289,
0.013748128,
0.1188245863,
0.2720872462,
0.5442079902,
0.3677434027,
-0.7015407681,
0.4112541974,
-0.140502587,
-0.0475478023,
0.1171071231,
0.0513206981,
0.1252415776,
0.0950138643,
0.0587536991,
-0.2512646616,
0.3018861115,
-0.8405632377,
0.3249906003,
0.3702078164,
-0.8101782799,
-0.464569658,
0.7229102254,
0.7176526189,
-0.7196294665,
0.2565854788,
-0.0629556999,
-0.3220714927,
0.5090048313,
0.5584928393,
0.6706060767,
-0.6112128496,
0.7446014881,
0.1329673529,
0.1795642227,
-0.0756066665,
0.2796948254,
-0.1951581091,
-0.5597038865,
-0.4760766625,
0.3386023045,
-0.6490315795,
-0.2029708922,
-0.529687047,
0.0693975538,
-0.4200296402,
-0.8871842623,
0.3702431917,
0.1766114533,
-0.5160744786,
0.1784605682,
0.3278385401,
0.4282366931,
-0.8415575624,
0.5073586702,
0.9304461479,
-0.2648726702,
-0.9837340713,
0.2519803047,
0.5502981544,
-0.6314126253,
0.1033728942,
0.1949067712,
-0.1168725342,
-0.4944267869,
-0.4829494357,
-0.3785535991,
0.7385696769,
0.2894045115,
-0.4612798989,
0.0348338,
0.3622680008,
0.8395128846,
-0.1588165313,
0.6201214194,
0.1615433991,
0.4230024517,
0.1480110437,
-1.3567880392,
0.2356671691,
-0.3439545929,
-0.1266205162,
0.012582357,
-0.7785779834,
0.2851279974,
-0.3543061614,
-0.5844620466,
0.0713756531,
0.399426043,
-0.0263926573,
0.7000600696,
0.3246802092,
0.0489977598,
1.0488319397,
0.1597459316,
1.2178292274,
-0.1758225113,
-0.2209340632,
1.0820976496,
-0.4345127642,
0.639858067,
0.158500284,
-0.0374944769,
0.5258453488,
0.5884190202,
0.3937492073,
0.1517829597,
0.1477391869,
-0.5425899625,
0.101099506,
-0.5010973811,
-0.2406162769,
0.3531933725,
0.590182364,
-0.5322079659,
-0.0477010868,
0.3043275774,
0.4281310141,
0.6235457659,
-0.1980194151,
1.0403443575,
0.2002085447,
-0.4884477854,
0.2068790197,
-0.0110133355,
0.6241906881,
-0.2215376347,
-0.0378229916,
-0.0046812221,
-0.0095384223,
-0.3626960218,
-0.3602552414,
0.3695381582,
0.0460581034,
-0.0173255,
-0.3035667837,
1.2799496651,
-0.1729365885,
-0.4961567521,
0.2055810541,
0.551597774,
0.3931364715,
-0.1817210168,
-1.0717273951,
0.3793420494,
-0.2330458015,
0.2685837746,
0.0835925639,
0.3761582375,
-0.0816319138,
0.4485985041,
0.4584440887,
0.3075994253,
-0.3939282,
0.3610660434,
0.6571881771,
-0.6922335625,
-0.5264878869,
-0.9327946901,
0.317130357,
-0.3391591907,
-0.1541033089,
0.7695237398,
0.1091429442,
0.1155087352,
0.3395362794,
0.6872335076,
0.1286309958,
0.3939156234,
-0.0230124518,
0.5564219952,
-0.1343819797,
-0.0736590847,
-0.5292699337,
-0.1840053797,
-0.1634532511,
0.4704303443,
-0.1535381675,
0.1260646284,
0.5385013819,
0.6063904762,
0.664042592,
0.1519452184,
0.289422363,
-0.0553702302,
0.3523097038,
0.5870214105,
0.7456643581,
-0.2389097512,
0.3701553941,
0.0443359278,
-0.5138307214,
-0.4892113507,
-0.6443727016,
-0.9118793607,
-0.526322484,
-0.4905419946,
-0.5539889932,
0.4726734757,
1.136406064,
0.934761107,
-0.3294397593,
0.1049583331,
0.3667139709,
-0.0157244094,
-0.5164398551,
-0.221083954,
-0.0161909889,
-0.0578352809,
-0.360816747,
0.2163484693,
0.5219513774,
0.2307368666,
-0.0845123678,
0.0254116263,
0.1101016924,
0.5869880319,
0.663369,
0.4067384303,
-0.3091297746,
-0.3415410817,
0.2376137823,
-0.4781392217,
0.2987990677,
0.7614151835,
-0.621040225,
0.2730639875,
0.0875297338,
0.6106786728,
0.2556596994,
0.3077216148,
0.4849293232,
-0.6486876011,
0.0676505417,
0.333396405,
-0.1522585899,
0.7151958346,
-0.8218230009,
0.1114550903,
0.0641014501,
-0.4687010944,
-0.2939449251,
-0.0590669326,
-1.1052632332,
-0.4863409698,
1.3499416113,
0.2856017649,
-0.3992553353,
-0.4784518182,
-0.7253793478,
0.2896748185,
-0.7011116147,
1.079761982,
0.5580651164,
-0.2630538642,
-0.0077699739,
-0.4777319133,
0.4017991126,
0.2570474744,
-1.4950538874,
-0.2014934719,
0.5475245714,
0.0460419282,
0.073140502,
1.2450550795,
-0.1970417947,
0.387147218,
-0.0541824996,
-0.0728861839,
0.2166643441,
-0.0276079103,
-0.1135818288,
-0.133233726,
-0.1082977727,
-0.3566587865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13630v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13630v2
|
Utilizing Deep Learning to Optimize Software Development Processes
| 2024-04-21T12:06:05 | 2024-05-03T13:07:18 |
Keqin Li, Armando Zhu, Peng Zhao, Jintong Song, Jiabei Liu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study explores the application of deep learning technologies in software
development processes, particularly in automating code reviews, error
prediction, and test generation to enhance code quality and development
efficiency. Through a series of empirical studies, experimental groups using
deep learning tools and control groups using traditional methods were compared
in terms of code error rates and project completion times. The results
demonstrated significant improvements in the experimental group, validating the
effectiveness of deep learning technologies. The research also discusses
potential optimization points, methodologies, and technical challenges of deep
learning in software development, as well as how to integrate these
technologies into existing software development workflows.
|
[
-0.4413384795,
-0.4842060506,
0.2190835774,
0.2280581146,
-0.1770872176,
0.5703877807,
-0.3708543181,
-0.366491735,
-0.2654781044,
0.1590238512,
-0.4996207058,
-0.4095161259,
-0.1126835272,
-0.0476054214,
-0.3693602383,
0.6628208756,
-0.4717287421,
0.3536069095,
0.3257752061,
0.1553522348,
-0.5586435199,
-0.1784914881,
-0.7957904339,
-0.4051186144,
0.4624769092,
0.5765592456,
0.8300616145,
0.3496357799,
0.9150902033,
0.1472258419,
0.5669288039,
-0.0071865912,
-0.1756932884,
0.0889645144,
0.2961018384,
-0.4280619621,
-0.1519686282,
0.0739636198,
0.013999504,
0.6471996307,
-0.1058664918,
0.2586043179,
0.1751622856,
0.8621881008,
-0.6880145669,
0.066601634,
0.0461752899,
0.9484291077,
0.2967387736,
-0.2445030808,
-0.0701753721,
-0.920476675,
0.209415853,
-0.3918476105,
0.2950303555,
-0.2585652769,
0.4766169786,
0.479021281,
0.145286113,
-0.5261137486,
-1.0001550913,
0.5978955626,
-1.0848586559,
0.2616201937,
0.2389667332,
0.3175108433,
-0.1397278458,
-0.4776106179,
-0.3437342644,
-0.5261003971,
0.2640311718,
0.2563432455,
0.5373673439,
0.1208111718,
0.3714381456,
0.6392294168,
-0.8904288411,
0.573312223,
-0.6150121689,
-0.1397010535,
1.1051189899,
0.1191901192,
0.1533313692,
0.5037229061,
-0.0786507651,
-0.2155884206,
-0.3706563711,
0.3275997341,
0.2709400356,
0.1413544118,
0.1546443999,
0.4759957492,
-0.0875720531,
0.4029955864,
-0.2171614766,
0.2446666062,
0.6173949242,
-0.2039929777,
-0.8293280005,
-0.2527914643,
0.4571274221,
0.2849211991,
0.2612459362,
-0.0833647102,
-0.3382763863,
0.455860883,
0.632268548,
-0.7493495941,
-0.5372771025,
0.3012946546,
-0.5834726095,
-0.7363371253,
-0.0275472477,
-0.5028697252,
-0.8021072149,
-0.4890863895,
-0.0110313175,
-0.2998245656,
-0.5731143355,
0.2335211784,
-0.4091234505,
0.4861984849,
0.4011611044,
-0.5036117435,
-0.0196235497,
0.5956313014,
0.3946179152,
-0.2870309651,
-0.3585632145,
-0.2696262002,
-0.365993917,
-1.0937087536,
0.1698665172,
-0.4350682199,
-0.4523338675,
0.0412115268,
-0.467368573,
0.5724228621,
-0.6355825067,
0.1058683172,
-0.5012114644,
-0.118453756,
0.2464799881,
-0.6008847356,
-0.1201730818,
0.1377691776,
-0.5960270762,
1.0524659157,
0.4947840571,
-0.0119437985,
0.9264954329,
-0.8030653,
-0.643112123,
0.1921473593,
-0.2509629726,
-0.6314374804,
0.634583652,
-0.1293261051,
0.7360280156,
-0.08206743,
0.1784918904,
-0.2643756866,
-0.8397867084,
0.1463147998,
0.0790620372,
0.6590334773,
0.732347846,
-0.9541515708,
0.0674968064,
-0.538813591,
0.3971974254,
0.0611859262,
-0.7112464905,
0.0227164421,
0.029691048,
-0.4173455834,
0.1098414063,
-0.4122919738,
-0.1043151096,
0.4118609726,
-0.2002450675,
0.3007577956,
0.5118964911,
-0.0108009344,
0.6976574659,
0.1357780546,
0.5292087197,
0.0467826277,
0.6644112468,
-0.017205419,
-0.100252077,
-0.8818287253,
0.5744627714,
0.4106642902,
0.5387779474,
-0.574524343,
0.3258880377,
0.3958997428,
-0.5708155632,
-0.7252172232,
0.6671081185,
0.3527268171,
0.0358788297,
0.0909398198,
-0.7172593474,
-0.4396792352,
-0.5141450167,
0.0679467022,
-0.1176288351,
0.0968199521,
0.1948312521,
0.280862391,
-0.4418461621,
0.5197097063,
-0.4446570277,
-0.1290842593,
0.0460707843,
0.2498532534,
0.1602868587,
0.672919929,
0.3831020892,
-1.0937511921,
-0.4703205526,
0.0666520447,
-0.7542777061,
0.3485596478,
-0.2491320372,
0.0941987783,
0.440325588,
0.6730161905,
-0.0364816338,
0.7232483625,
0.3115605116,
-0.0766641125,
0.4789888561,
-0.2861066759,
0.2426554859,
-0.2367901802,
-0.1147689819,
0.0017735732,
0.2216575742,
-0.4166442454,
0.2914550006,
0.3798236251,
-0.3249541223,
-0.4435872436,
-0.3670618236,
-0.5963179469,
-0.212562412,
-0.4192382991,
-0.0640741438,
0.0442130379,
0.3777128756,
-0.1884838641,
1.0981024504,
0.5989003181,
-0.9518216252,
0.6265234947,
-0.4321604073,
-0.4487387538,
-0.1454216987,
-0.5590447187,
0.2452588677,
0.0415341631,
-0.3900457323,
-0.6197394133,
-0.1165355146,
0.019965047,
-0.7300513983,
0.43355757,
0.0696549118,
-0.5799813271,
-0.779563427,
-0.4970439672,
-0.1252025515,
0.931114614,
-0.0024481795,
0.1415098459,
0.2172739655,
0.3632609844,
-0.7096321583,
-1.2079380751,
-0.1146214008,
-0.1013498455,
-0.2771755755,
0.0627496988,
-0.167605415,
-0.2179403454,
-0.0348179191,
-0.1063911244,
-0.2393740863,
0.6113760471,
0.1627472937,
-0.030229168,
-0.4119867682,
0.5202848315,
-0.0331282206,
-0.0944131017,
0.1709875464,
-0.3745989799,
0.2749665976,
0.0546397604,
-0.2762376368,
-0.3941904008,
0.2274158001,
0.2685835361,
-0.2361262292,
0.3304729462,
0.8146235943,
-0.2498336583,
-0.6017457247,
-0.7030687332,
-0.0667008087,
-0.4552518725,
0.1875811368,
-0.1956913471,
-0.890637815,
0.3941389322,
-0.617290318,
0.2545956373,
0.2475994676,
0.2647204399,
-0.4087917507,
0.9658173919,
1.0418348312,
-0.1483004242,
0.4440041482,
-0.7106409669,
0.2619432807,
-0.5574232936,
-0.0277268738,
-0.3518070579,
-0.3020093739,
-0.3570883572,
-0.4592520297,
-0.1096614078,
0.5347613096,
-0.4656513929,
0.3556557,
-0.9678238034,
0.5259512067,
0.7571610212,
0.0568378419,
0.0543950573,
-0.213516295,
-0.1408159584,
-0.0337924734,
-0.5648629665,
-0.2787486315,
1.1345219612,
0.4078422785,
0.9099456072,
-0.2932651043,
0.8489935398,
0.7974339128,
0.2777622938,
-0.5368276834,
0.0137217809,
0.0834984332,
-0.4343449473,
-0.5155664682,
-0.2101536989,
-0.7602830529,
-0.3382052779,
-0.0060426495,
0.0929457694,
0.2264595628,
0.1000378355,
-0.6891399026,
0.1314581782,
-1.1441098452,
0.852953732,
-0.4984857142,
0.0433835387,
-0.360018611,
-0.555732429,
-0.1289403886,
-0.2263662964,
-0.0960070118,
-0.0582718439,
-0.0640121549,
0.5154338479,
-0.1957889497,
0.8749367595,
-0.3507244587,
-0.19132182,
0.5849939585,
0.0336995982,
0.3512227833,
0.1039815918,
-0.28417629,
-0.2750220895,
-0.6031959653,
-0.3636153638,
-0.7389191389,
0.7573816776,
-0.8473863602,
-0.1455122828,
-0.2112579644,
-0.3470516205,
0.0902733207,
0.2620690763,
-0.0470067672,
-0.0334491767,
0.008833766,
-0.0697098151,
0.8155212402,
-0.4244819283,
0.8194719553,
0.3444756866,
-0.3752967119,
-0.3856411278,
0.7038912773,
0.1737417728,
0.0728889406,
-0.1867852807,
0.0523578115,
0.4492194951,
-1.2273423672,
-0.4017182589,
-0.3930096626,
-0.4717152119,
-0.3304291368,
-0.1871614903,
-0.2203664333,
-0.5254303813,
-0.4338802099,
-0.3375557363,
-0.0346192494,
-0.2189161032,
-0.3511658907,
0.0700166523,
0.8523958325,
0.0974760726,
-0.0816845596,
-0.6442974806,
0.3048173785,
0.1841021031,
0.5994156599,
0.088989526,
0.3603192866,
-0.5454631448,
-0.0135985538,
-0.2916038632,
-0.5901042223,
0.2663582563,
-0.0571880974,
0.6096318364,
0.0165064801,
0.1078333333,
0.5574610233,
-0.0238100346,
0.7884463668,
0.1404211372,
-0.813526988,
1.0260095596,
0.0888077095,
0.293225944,
0.7778117657,
0.3363628387,
-0.0931145325,
-0.2137902081,
-0.3456532955,
-0.6875211596,
0.1679675579,
0.2472661734,
0.068269968,
0.5040909052,
0.6844432354,
0.2101032436,
0.3518100381,
-0.4409657121,
-0.1898389459,
0.0430856422,
0.0935436338,
-0.2214418054,
-0.1089213267,
0.0293818731,
-0.445110321,
0.4987486005,
-0.2081195265,
0.1415963173,
0.3854696751,
-0.2683867514,
-0.2015229315,
-0.0930510461,
0.7131431699,
1.1335189342,
0.1018886119,
-0.1912882179,
0.2191512883,
-0.5186326504,
0.155159831,
-0.0143130124,
0.0190878734,
-0.200733453,
0.1603269577,
0.6573242545,
-0.4294929802,
-0.5129864812,
0.2006331682,
-0.0737265274,
-0.2927615345,
-0.7855436206,
0.572563231,
-0.1605154723,
0.7344033718,
0.586419642,
0.255597204,
0.5332385302,
-0.4310249686,
0.2005699277,
0.1164287329,
-0.6501911283,
0.2678699791,
0.3210285604,
0.3568789065,
-0.5667847395,
0.92797786,
-0.2981769443,
-0.2782111168,
1.1641516685,
0.025834877,
1.1599384546,
-0.2129962891,
0.2802116871,
-0.0697548985,
0.3981661797,
0.3889267445,
0.7108963728,
-0.1778897941,
-0.2685101628,
-1.0216189623,
-0.3128668964,
-0.3785680532,
-0.0279441718,
-0.3557249606,
0.3450405896,
-0.6607121229,
-0.3462713063,
0.0319027714,
0.4598197043,
-0.7262467146,
0.422801882,
0.4447431564,
1.0389375687,
-0.590110898,
0.7743689418,
0.8226978779,
-0.5773165226,
-0.9062970877,
-0.1363955587,
-0.2361309081,
-0.5119336843,
0.7738676667,
0.1099725813,
-0.0264182761,
-0.2094201446,
-0.7004919648,
-0.5247002244,
1.0973027945,
0.0863510594,
-0.4108639956,
0.1743831038,
0.1362353563,
0.7692016959,
-0.3067729473,
0.0307557452,
0.4171498418,
0.4882466793,
-0.2581512928,
-0.7149669528,
-0.1866634488,
-0.4324441552,
0.2458104342,
0.5225972533,
-0.3561891317,
0.4176620841,
-0.5382021666,
0.0214545559,
-0.3254593313,
0.7379224896,
-0.0439785048,
0.4965220988,
0.1683684886,
0.3203886151,
0.6488739848,
-0.080197677,
0.8181711435,
-0.2043192238,
0.3390741348,
0.8458424211,
-0.2250015736,
0.394272536,
0.3650330007,
-0.2217402905,
0.2690933645,
0.8303700686,
-0.5471702218,
0.3747336268,
0.7296744585,
0.0243121032,
0.1992024034,
0.161150828,
-0.4330573678,
-0.1560432315,
0.174927175,
-0.6049700379,
0.3108014464,
0.5549740791,
0.0425069518,
-0.1001206413,
-0.4014706612,
0.7891050577,
0.0341510512,
-0.7050623298,
0.2552462816,
-0.2361528724,
0.7234535217,
-0.1837835163,
-0.2576872408,
-0.2948954105,
0.7337133288,
-0.3539859951,
-1.0152409077,
0.3334818482,
-0.2434818447,
0.0696379766,
-0.2182086706,
0.7429894805,
0.0242633037,
-0.3798891604,
0.5090541244,
0.300427109,
0.0251348559,
-0.0669859275,
-0.8694528341,
0.16659756,
0.0455728509,
-0.1500233263,
0.0205832813,
0.3781431019,
0.2475255132,
0.8007629514,
0.5273529887,
0.0949429572,
0.3506591618,
0.2603948414,
1.0278053284,
-0.9326903224,
-0.0551691875,
-0.950927496,
0.5161024928,
-0.3467042446,
-0.4367228746,
0.8005489111,
0.6963344812,
1.127146244,
-0.1745867431,
0.8252832294,
-0.1343060732,
0.1007651389,
-0.2882091403,
0.6989513636,
-0.1234564781,
0.0464597158,
-0.3835165799,
-0.8473160267,
-0.7992813587,
0.4216615856,
0.1848755777,
0.0985528603,
0.7019529939,
0.4142642617,
0.1944023818,
-0.0723932385,
0.2203685492,
-0.2798148394,
0.5019922256,
0.6921362281,
0.8397321105,
-0.6180292964,
0.2109609693,
-0.9514504075,
-0.166554898,
-0.1528098881,
-0.7607753873,
-0.8598180413,
-0.3638531566,
-0.7534410357,
-0.4706429243,
0.2093804628,
0.5939646959,
0.7599384785,
-0.8648804426,
-0.3906741142,
-0.5510985851,
-0.1224978641,
-0.5788596869,
-0.2340786755,
0.1262225062,
-0.9757890701,
-0.2735382318,
0.2139887214,
0.2199863791,
0.2965919971,
-0.689188242,
-0.4661570191,
0.0168425422,
-0.4510557652,
0.4181547463,
0.0714958608,
-0.1234256551,
0.1059654504,
0.3450053334,
-0.1784052998,
0.0064275274,
1.1827535629,
-0.7978201509,
0.2590509653,
0.5448153019,
0.7927746773,
0.4295364618,
-0.2394133508,
0.8665431738,
-0.2415912896,
-0.1230867207,
0.6391825676,
-0.0920145139,
0.0327462368,
-0.6458414793,
1.0968229771,
-0.3086397052,
-0.8923540115,
-0.6910849214,
-0.0867192745,
-0.4105285406,
-0.313102901,
0.6994986534,
-0.2497899979,
0.0483612493,
-0.2311947048,
-0.2897816896,
0.3173657358,
-0.2427428067,
0.6726034284,
0.5025251508,
-0.5172293782,
-0.253944397,
-0.8666772246,
0.833822906,
0.4209046662,
-0.8022446632,
-0.2475560308,
0.3827145994,
-0.0704780668,
0.2828164399,
0.1753379703,
0.0128913336,
0.5141351819,
-0.0721009299,
0.3837536573,
-0.1657110602,
-0.223955676,
-0.5944451094,
0.2213172764,
0.3272258043,
-0.1770407706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13628v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13628v1
|
Mixture of LoRA Experts
| 2024-04-21T11:59:53 | 2024-04-21T11:59:53 |
Xun Wu, Shaohan Huang, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
LoRA has gained widespread acceptance in the fine-tuning of large pre-trained
models to cater to a diverse array of downstream tasks, showcasing notable
effectiveness and efficiency, thereby solidifying its position as one of the
most prevalent fine-tuning techniques. Due to the modular nature of LoRA's
plug-and-play plugins, researchers have delved into the amalgamation of
multiple LoRAs to empower models to excel across various downstream tasks.
Nonetheless, extant approaches for LoRA fusion grapple with inherent
challenges. Direct arithmetic merging may result in the loss of the original
pre-trained model's generative capabilities or the distinct identity of LoRAs,
thereby yielding suboptimal outcomes. On the other hand, Reference tuning-based
fusion exhibits limitations concerning the requisite flexibility for the
effective combination of multiple LoRAs. In response to these challenges, this
paper introduces the Mixture of LoRA Experts (MoLE) approach, which harnesses
hierarchical control and unfettered branch selection. The MoLE approach not
only achieves superior LoRA fusion performance in comparison to direct
arithmetic merging but also retains the crucial flexibility for combining LoRAs
effectively. Extensive experimental evaluations conducted in both the Natural
Language Processing (NLP) and Vision & Language (V&L) domains substantiate the
efficacy of MoLE.
|
[
-0.7888578176,
-0.7055432796,
0.4006438553,
-0.0926240981,
-0.4173256159,
0.6728369594,
-0.0292127933,
-0.7185915112,
0.4376014769,
0.6602796912,
-0.6128976941,
-0.3130989075,
-0.6108425856,
-0.1074950844,
-0.5037938356,
0.8191886544,
0.1408334523,
-0.2523932457,
-0.0474405289,
-0.3406990469,
-0.5291608572,
-0.2449101955,
-0.4019995332,
-0.6081703901,
0.8287054896,
0.1550885737,
0.7245315313,
0.6618753076,
0.6235820651,
0.4187186658,
-0.4154672623,
0.9162427187,
-0.5661938787,
-0.1949726045,
-0.5313155055,
-0.1839118302,
-0.6356520653,
-0.0317408927,
0.2516998947,
0.7914050221,
-0.4259119928,
-0.0848878175,
-0.0281067062,
0.8813209534,
-0.9959933758,
-0.455501169,
-1.1676715612,
0.0129688689,
-0.1544945389,
-0.0874709338,
-0.1915052086,
-0.4456910193,
-0.1187862828,
-0.5353472829,
-0.1313729286,
-0.1434324682,
0.7958323956,
0.8272802234,
-0.648968339,
0.1328413934,
-0.7797597647,
0.647580862,
-0.8418599367,
-0.1304360777,
0.2190881371,
0.5733069777,
-0.1010539383,
-0.2248280197,
-0.340914011,
0.4144424498,
0.1613179892,
0.1638448536,
-0.3412421346,
0.0159290843,
-0.1604366452,
0.482426405,
0.031596534,
0.6312407255,
-0.3186449111,
-0.0745669976,
0.4913830459,
0.1754884124,
-0.1854569912,
-0.039751485,
-0.3963802457,
0.0482237153,
-0.666380465,
-0.2538408041,
0.4943802357,
0.4300337136,
0.3181021512,
0.7308474183,
-0.4591789246,
1.0606036186,
0.2951818407,
-0.2714547515,
0.1127460375,
-0.4704946578,
-0.5095593333,
-0.2592866421,
0.9174897671,
-0.0525261275,
0.107076399,
-0.1455879062,
-0.2211241871,
0.2344660312,
0.2233611792,
-0.3249691129,
-0.0076573081,
0.2490902543,
-0.0346855782,
-0.5551114678,
0.028674189,
-0.889484942,
-0.535430491,
-0.5092788935,
0.7639544606,
-0.5535219312,
-0.0985862836,
0.1120541766,
-0.0779017732,
-0.1115435511,
0.3202351928,
-1.045881629,
0.3854228258,
0.843916297,
0.5288851857,
-0.2284145653,
-0.2345638871,
-0.7167792916,
0.2395535111,
-0.1235646531,
0.9631696939,
-0.3365561366,
-0.5213388205,
-0.2822953761,
-0.6730739474,
-0.2865587771,
-0.8301776052,
0.179796502,
-0.5545296073,
0.0680066347,
-0.0696925148,
-0.1430102885,
-0.1853413582,
0.1347886771,
-0.5987363458,
0.8020048738,
0.4123110771,
-0.6141406298,
0.2933402359,
-0.4838006794,
-0.4980237186,
-0.1550970525,
-0.3062369823,
-0.3569578528,
0.1371828169,
0.4661220014,
0.116853863,
-0.2601828277,
0.1769402474,
-0.0315328613,
-0.1309367269,
0.1386535317,
-0.0232122708,
0.6563684344,
0.0492791012,
-0.1281477511,
0.6569562554,
-0.8192612529,
0.1605153084,
-0.3844199479,
-0.231845215,
-0.3316371441,
-0.0470944941,
-0.3553243279,
0.2449462265,
0.3773943186,
-0.1695459336,
0.2520717382,
-0.3808832467,
0.4184147418,
0.8656163812,
0.0985384062,
0.5393149257,
-0.3756025136,
0.3031589985,
0.0688162372,
0.1629769504,
0.1369224787,
-0.5302433372,
-0.9517692924,
-0.3629393578,
0.6084300876,
0.4878400564,
-0.952632606,
0.9621206522,
-0.0361160301,
-0.7911126018,
-0.6288117766,
0.7030927539,
0.4421365261,
0.8343945742,
0.3595086932,
-0.2114404142,
-0.5981234908,
-0.9840893149,
0.0139996465,
0.0381465554,
0.1322044432,
0.1529323757,
0.4948128164,
-0.4696586728,
1.2463784218,
-0.5415536165,
-0.5558874011,
-0.0119585656,
0.222704038,
0.3887314498,
0.3539642096,
0.3713939786,
-0.8300631642,
-0.3384137154,
0.6058501601,
-0.5721400976,
0.0066561811,
0.2575829625,
-0.2981261611,
0.0936316028,
0.2579661012,
-0.6190569997,
0.3839104772,
0.7751007676,
-0.1533192843,
0.3522068262,
-0.3618562222,
0.0577452779,
-1.2462123632,
0.0488600805,
-0.2266192287,
-0.1458452642,
-0.4140091538,
0.1798701137,
0.032657221,
0.1695394665,
-0.577467382,
0.2123098224,
-0.2035575509,
-0.1065797061,
-0.2974366844,
0.1310825497,
-0.0938429609,
0.4774987996,
-0.2943265438,
0.5222807527,
0.4750330448,
-0.8194997311,
0.4207848907,
0.2798831165,
-0.457311511,
0.3571939468,
-0.6063455939,
0.0624192245,
0.1518813819,
-0.0164906736,
-0.6203157902,
-0.3557954729,
-0.0236190315,
-0.1239059791,
0.0067520002,
0.0747976005,
-0.4089111984,
-0.2683716416,
-0.1357776225,
0.1712485701,
0.9407823086,
-0.3814249933,
1.2616690397,
0.3783038259,
0.1827521026,
-0.7925760746,
-0.5090768337,
-0.2750181854,
-0.3276268542,
-0.7766993642,
0.5172637701,
0.1529985219,
-0.443551451,
0.0615704395,
-0.1421069652,
-0.1469303221,
-0.0139556993,
0.3996653557,
0.4081026912,
-0.0965361446,
-0.3887385726,
0.1544249654,
-0.2723324895,
-0.3909142911,
0.1191688478,
0.6040896773,
0.1471012384,
-0.6811298132,
-0.1769299954,
0.2569632828,
0.8243183494,
-0.4863496721,
0.7989294529,
0.4317148626,
-0.0894685909,
-0.1981805265,
-0.7913210392,
0.0119663393,
-0.5381246209,
0.2303407788,
-0.21363464,
-0.6767990589,
0.8539775014,
-0.243478477,
0.157710284,
0.586438179,
0.4390535355,
-0.0617446415,
0.8325299025,
0.858743012,
-0.2211759537,
0.4296585023,
-0.3077633083,
0.2307563722,
-0.9331594706,
-0.4773411453,
-0.5397154689,
-0.4850836098,
-0.2699890435,
-0.5361533761,
0.4981129467,
-0.020804638,
-0.1034013107,
0.3973400891,
-0.4299587607,
0.6258803606,
0.5286007524,
0.2674642801,
0.6032893658,
0.0372334346,
0.0592623726,
0.2845478058,
-0.8636753559,
0.0409113057,
0.5499958396,
0.1098371893,
0.9453225732,
0.1530070603,
0.6896716356,
-0.0967283547,
-0.0282301996,
-0.8724360466,
0.7018060684,
-0.5142046213,
-0.3510018289,
-0.3477983177,
-0.4753920436,
-0.8438444734,
0.4761427343,
-0.4412890375,
-0.6809618473,
0.3771453202,
0.17938371,
-0.7885531783,
0.4961179197,
-0.5652889013,
0.459471643,
-0.1231050342,
-0.1575938016,
-0.3391945362,
-0.6444981098,
0.7468142509,
-0.630348742,
0.3188603818,
-0.1356752217,
-0.0767832622,
0.6674807668,
-0.7503588796,
0.757820189,
0.2444072813,
-0.2849681079,
0.2026552856,
0.0051224646,
0.4111473262,
-0.2658841014,
-0.0744409934,
0.0364379957,
-0.5110882521,
-0.288629204,
-0.650686264,
0.7520205975,
-1.0971262455,
-0.5713613033,
-0.1622147262,
-0.6275935173,
-0.7148378491,
0.1284671724,
0.4674935937,
0.2376472354,
-0.016643595,
0.2399392426,
0.7278777957,
0.1870734841,
0.5163350701,
0.4284475744,
-0.6593293548,
-0.6282342672,
0.8592303395,
-0.0389307737,
0.5716564059,
0.2743724287,
0.0937483981,
0.0996669531,
-0.5505156517,
-0.2227182239,
0.092768997,
-0.5990532637,
-0.4478487968,
-0.4041575193,
-0.5374181867,
-0.0666094571,
-0.2775492668,
-0.6041867733,
-0.2461729348,
-0.3547246158,
0.2147026509,
0.3978773952,
0.8190939426,
0.1048275307,
0.5661372542,
-0.7445445657,
0.7225522399,
0.804223001,
0.0818643421,
-0.2097492665,
-0.4061359465,
-0.071888499,
0.1377707273,
-0.0517120995,
-0.6864195466,
0.3880719543,
0.17198807,
0.5181667209,
0.489533931,
-0.2464450449,
0.8757967353,
-0.26746279,
0.3690229654,
0.3591945469,
-0.9401154518,
0.7063955069,
-0.5925733447,
0.2428143024,
0.7935861349,
0.0484941676,
0.1477662921,
-0.2067055255,
-0.3782454133,
-1.0003629923,
0.3665419817,
0.2709218264,
-0.2739097178,
0.5741947889,
-0.2655041814,
0.3311759531,
0.2960107028,
-0.2283846438,
-0.0137782134,
0.0227429681,
-0.09193483,
-0.1156556681,
0.1250094622,
-0.5667027831,
-0.4198727012,
0.4928632081,
-0.090195477,
-0.3110310137,
-0.273761481,
0.1836204678,
-0.3088241816,
0.1381377578,
0.3507267833,
0.9119510055,
-0.4218568504,
-0.0581999086,
0.155097872,
-0.1637768149,
0.0037438949,
-0.1521237791,
-0.1197335646,
-0.0553554781,
0.3071830869,
0.705938518,
0.3612682223,
-0.5574239492,
0.0528781414,
0.310623318,
-0.6104534864,
0.2091398537,
0.4848198295,
0.14111045,
-0.0605098121,
0.4878385663,
0.8193610311,
-0.3230419755,
-0.7221708894,
-0.1531232744,
0.5929723978,
-0.1514986157,
0.0952808782,
0.2063811719,
0.5988760591,
-0.22550717,
0.413009584,
0.205137372,
-0.4890255928,
0.6968584657,
0.3833066225,
0.5241692662,
-0.1101601198,
0.1279730499,
-0.1168473512,
0.1507015675,
-0.0563737042,
0.060254775,
0.1404476762,
-0.8708728552,
-0.8062854409,
-0.6338037252,
-0.63514781,
-0.0762657374,
-0.6278390884,
0.1798260212,
-0.4450403452,
-0.1594053358,
0.1637444794,
-0.1438372284,
-0.295751363,
0.1542738676,
-0.0852281377,
1.0847655535,
-0.9103655219,
0.868807435,
0.6661037803,
-0.2229748666,
-0.8228363991,
-0.3887054622,
-0.0098539228,
-0.7534844279,
0.4565620124,
-0.2820749879,
-0.4710215032,
0.0088094072,
-0.2065934539,
-0.8133656383,
1.1668976545,
0.3332352042,
-0.6241748929,
-0.1585758328,
-0.1364780515,
0.4957765341,
-0.3521202803,
-0.1838891506,
0.7823539376,
0.4609822035,
0.7714155316,
-1.1869958639,
-0.41444543,
-0.168717429,
-0.2587486804,
0.5642241836,
-0.6626909971,
1.1634637117,
-0.1067925245,
0.1451456249,
0.1474432647,
0.6396341324,
0.4412967265,
0.1133413091,
0.6998056769,
0.6559879184,
0.9873144627,
-0.0941569805,
0.8029213548,
-0.1103356481,
0.0580167584,
1.0604820251,
-0.3315473795,
1.0198582411,
0.6544172168,
-0.3044076562,
0.6633303165,
0.5374621749,
0.2223415673,
0.752004087,
-0.3513360023,
-0.3884220123,
-0.2872608304,
-0.2071561813,
-0.6310682297,
0.5909041762,
0.278205812,
-0.049605567,
-0.2359679788,
-0.2233186364,
-0.4590214789,
0.1660346091,
-0.6747822762,
0.8568875194,
0.0015926259,
-0.8003242612,
0.3508276939,
-0.2690623701,
0.9728375673,
-0.9383362532,
0.2591519952,
-0.0914828926,
0.2442046702,
-0.5637545586,
-0.6434570551,
0.300263226,
-0.1611097753,
-0.1180827841,
0.0597057715,
0.8918163776,
-0.311534375,
-0.3732151687,
0.2051707506,
0.8358492255,
-0.2824757099,
-0.2107445598,
-0.2494456917,
0.0317088626,
0.1318291575,
0.1866057515,
0.4557836652,
0.254193455,
0.2144562602,
0.7317469716,
0.7092961073,
0.2252122015,
-0.1180675775,
0.0957739726,
1.339725256,
-0.6348463893,
-0.4226591587,
-0.9684043527,
0.6022125483,
-0.1209778339,
-0.4198765457,
0.740897119,
0.3569776714,
0.3492249846,
-0.0831711814,
0.6407307982,
-0.0512286909,
0.347065419,
-0.8609883785,
0.5645401478,
-0.4497804344,
0.0563975796,
-0.1853724718,
-1.1527996063,
0.0058120708,
0.288576901,
-0.1185323,
0.159876287,
0.7732470036,
0.4660248458,
-0.2188940942,
-0.2273170799,
0.4426491857,
0.0848304555,
0.0010530754,
0.7861450315,
0.8273223639,
-0.1498787999,
0.487947315,
-0.2925465405,
-0.0938537344,
-0.4726894796,
-0.9233957529,
-0.9130648971,
-0.3294741213,
-0.1603565216,
-0.0541726537,
-0.3061733842,
0.6600310206,
0.9680041671,
-0.5989782214,
0.0458452888,
-0.0868706703,
0.3054836988,
-0.0912144035,
-0.0705018416,
0.0529449843,
-0.0623189583,
-0.5660617352,
0.6405572891,
0.4927155972,
0.1311931163,
-0.4898437262,
-0.0303246062,
-0.1574333608,
0.193551302,
0.4521891177,
0.4003790319,
-0.8483131528,
0.2159395367,
-0.1150596365,
-0.1976367384,
0.0405855626,
0.654751718,
-1.2526377439,
0.2286086828,
0.5340133905,
0.596457839,
0.3028990328,
0.5024314523,
0.6713168621,
-0.6112264991,
0.1737596542,
0.2064281255,
0.4327006936,
0.1837092042,
-0.166489467,
0.7966995835,
-0.0503812656,
-0.4514457285,
-0.7244369984,
0.2814328671,
-1.5734103918,
-0.3175775409,
1.032528162,
0.3116931021,
-0.3193612099,
0.0192983504,
-0.5254745483,
0.0957875177,
-0.2460944355,
0.7203646302,
0.445315212,
-0.2763827443,
0.1952428073,
0.0002752534,
0.1984557956,
0.5193523765,
-1.180532217,
-0.3008622825,
0.261772126,
-0.0316736028,
0.5668356419,
0.335373491,
0.191256687,
0.1183311641,
-0.0420723744,
-0.1438951492,
-0.3226647377,
-0.2856229842,
-0.2934368551,
0.301433593,
0.0229195841,
0.1366148591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13627v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13627v1
|
NegotiationToM: A Benchmark for Stress-testing Machine Theory of Mind on Negotiation Surrounding
| 2024-04-21T11:51:13 | 2024-04-21T11:51:13 |
Chunkit Chan, Cheng Jiayang, Yauwai Yim, Zheye Deng, Wei Fan, Haoran Li, Xin Liu, Hongming Zhang, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have sparked substantial interest and debate
concerning their potential emergence of Theory of Mind (ToM) ability. Theory of
mind evaluations currently focuses on testing models using machine-generated
data or game settings prone to shortcuts and spurious correlations, which lacks
evaluation of machine ToM ability in real-world human interaction scenarios.
This poses a pressing demand to develop new real-world scenario benchmarks. We
introduce NegotiationToM, a new benchmark designed to stress-test machine ToM
in real-world negotiation surrounding covered multi-dimensional mental states
(i.e., desires, beliefs, and intentions). Our benchmark builds upon the
Belief-Desire-Intention (BDI) agent modeling theory and conducts the necessary
empirical experiments to evaluate large language models. Our findings
demonstrate that NegotiationToM is challenging for state-of-the-art LLMs, as
they consistently perform significantly worse than humans, even when employing
the chain-of-thought (CoT) method.
|
[
-0.8669568896,
-0.7454651594,
0.8612691164,
0.0115286903,
-0.3860145509,
-0.012992451,
-0.5270323157,
-0.7239930034,
0.0092611192,
0.3080827594,
-0.6462884545,
-0.1004630998,
-0.5996326208,
0.1023319215,
-0.0984889865,
0.4668265581,
-0.1066063717,
0.0373347215,
-0.3414473236,
-0.1628699452,
-0.3705114722,
-0.5775240064,
-0.9090192914,
-0.6986654401,
0.395724982,
-0.0758190006,
0.8155645728,
0.187438786,
0.7467874289,
0.2868458927,
-0.0662743822,
0.08995758,
-0.1567225307,
0.476325959,
-0.5728713274,
-0.5662921071,
-0.419125706,
0.5371152163,
0.2442846745,
0.4488535225,
-0.1411992013,
0.1184637547,
-0.1185893118,
0.315230757,
-0.6669127345,
-0.0524593256,
-1.0723944902,
0.1465952396,
0.0735910237,
-0.2967193425,
-0.5722570419,
-0.379873693,
0.4101329744,
-0.4196760356,
-0.0126064168,
0.1994918734,
1.1331003904,
0.358723402,
-0.6527065635,
-0.3208241165,
-0.6562994719,
0.5944221616,
-0.4310148656,
0.5326398015,
0.3078838885,
0.6842420697,
-0.3243626952,
-0.5449885726,
-0.7252833843,
-0.5266709924,
0.0710101947,
0.2797124088,
-0.1070099026,
0.1614622027,
0.357937336,
0.3276666105,
-0.5392825603,
-0.0596277975,
-0.0964671299,
-0.0493963957,
0.7128708363,
0.2762465477,
-0.0013274536,
0.0644249991,
-0.6951659322,
-0.3236870468,
-0.3956535161,
-0.1700589657,
0.0605865195,
0.2703659832,
0.0838353261,
0.4598557949,
0.0749517754,
0.6858487129,
-0.1230390966,
0.1111615598,
-0.0512168519,
0.0807681084,
-0.6578966975,
-0.289788574,
0.7044764757,
0.6494511366,
0.3687676191,
-0.0241547283,
-0.2495785356,
0.4453068674,
0.6424641609,
-0.6997824311,
0.0196892153,
0.4245464504,
-0.4726296961,
-0.2982896864,
-0.2063159347,
-1.3503832817,
-0.5666870475,
-0.0956222937,
0.4361986816,
-0.5300273895,
-0.3934381604,
0.1917876899,
-0.1269296855,
0.6510698795,
0.2104567438,
-0.2778284848,
0.6237220168,
0.6269527078,
0.7691607475,
-0.2398783714,
-0.5622584224,
-0.1444977075,
0.0092507061,
-0.6004490256,
0.9133193493,
-0.7694578171,
-0.6099741459,
-0.0959277824,
-0.4660865366,
-0.1704649329,
-0.7471104264,
0.5821611881,
-0.3863885701,
0.0394792631,
-0.2550636232,
-0.7622199655,
0.106149964,
0.829670012,
-0.5164480805,
0.7972822785,
0.085088782,
-0.1757280231,
0.4225969315,
-0.8234094977,
-0.3319172561,
-0.0202659406,
-0.3782849014,
-0.2416828424,
0.1220530123,
-0.3224869967,
0.4783035219,
-1.1191509962,
0.3211478293,
-0.5279450417,
-0.2469487637,
0.9392461777,
-0.3939805329,
0.4476926029,
0.43901667,
-0.3414850235,
-0.1346292198,
-0.3934159875,
0.2021710128,
0.5052193403,
-0.0927000716,
-0.3835991025,
-0.0335537829,
-0.1710503846,
0.5983432531,
0.280017823,
-0.2513821125,
0.3310394287,
-0.0714557469,
0.1923355311,
0.7681882381,
-0.0852227136,
-0.069077149,
-0.5341553092,
0.7382592559,
-0.0248938687,
0.0993645489,
0.3340421915,
-0.370919317,
-0.7703885436,
-0.100459516,
0.0914043114,
0.2151338458,
-0.5999876261,
0.2296161801,
-0.1972306818,
-0.825971067,
-0.6965390444,
-0.189928174,
0.7067347765,
0.1525460482,
0.2284696251,
-0.2113390714,
-0.5194140673,
-0.9225182533,
-0.5659444332,
-0.1071591452,
0.0948071554,
0.3354484737,
0.4161265492,
-0.1627880931,
0.7187680006,
-0.7006678581,
-0.1572723389,
-0.1319880933,
0.369200021,
-0.0848765448,
0.3410094678,
0.6271642447,
-0.793851316,
0.0019853998,
-0.04838752,
-0.4935403168,
0.2629897594,
-0.0472877249,
-0.3462177813,
0.3507590592,
0.2974008322,
-0.9929575324,
0.3854277432,
0.5349346399,
-0.3241680562,
0.6293723583,
-0.2624437213,
0.2755524516,
-1.0687838793,
0.0948428139,
0.1569610387,
0.0526103191,
-0.3831321895,
0.5359589458,
0.1144928411,
-0.2641094327,
-0.4692622423,
0.5055081844,
-0.3455814421,
-0.3381668925,
-0.2164625525,
0.5050895214,
-0.2302547246,
0.5327534676,
0.1325804293,
0.8464138508,
0.2738152146,
-0.9497273564,
0.3432764411,
0.0844283029,
-0.4150343835,
1.0921119452,
-0.3620773256,
0.3570907712,
0.3103660345,
0.1992362887,
-0.9246887565,
-0.04741548,
0.0252016317,
-0.2927941084,
-0.0175308939,
-0.0931608677,
-0.3583633304,
-0.4130690396,
-0.0411628075,
0.4193434417,
0.6633241773,
-0.3514865339,
0.583722949,
0.3545308709,
0.3694761693,
0.0279465765,
-0.6056341529,
0.2018993497,
-0.5174406171,
-0.1665789485,
0.4162498415,
-0.3498094082,
-0.4955865145,
-0.3154757917,
-0.1108821556,
-0.2149336189,
0.2990802228,
-0.0323665515,
0.1077948362,
0.1670941859,
0.2053013593,
-0.1418650299,
-0.2699742913,
0.4125795364,
-0.0843841508,
0.8704594374,
-0.0892214477,
-0.3201242983,
-0.2251870185,
-0.1478267312,
0.9210382104,
-0.3967667818,
0.4030221105,
0.0934773088,
-0.6698984504,
-0.1626235247,
-0.4740923047,
-0.0758185163,
-0.4522340894,
0.265111506,
-0.9857841134,
-0.5053524375,
0.3208873868,
-0.7467321157,
-0.0542401336,
0.296431601,
0.6178452373,
0.1299933642,
0.9467491508,
0.1380885094,
0.0111100487,
0.0246452522,
-0.2153767943,
0.1552405208,
-1.0749076605,
-0.0822058693,
-0.5832248926,
-0.4951094985,
-0.464854449,
-0.5870332122,
0.2333330065,
-0.3226879537,
-0.2008440495,
0.4146364927,
-0.4471673965,
0.4417692423,
0.2054641545,
0.1409939826,
0.1431369483,
-0.5005603433,
-0.3349384964,
-0.2139974385,
-0.143789649,
-0.6376714706,
1.0026644468,
0.0877095833,
0.3395296931,
0.2902591825,
0.3498312533,
0.1975889504,
0.2367839366,
-0.8850651979,
0.9620956182,
0.25393489,
-0.7845036983,
-0.2116530985,
-0.4517209828,
-1.3069578409,
0.6890295148,
-0.2227992117,
-0.8228622079,
-0.0675708577,
0.1145512164,
-0.1358383596,
0.4490601718,
-0.3714181185,
0.6795278788,
-0.4712587893,
-0.4458763003,
-0.6937791705,
-0.2743218541,
0.4511068463,
-0.035015393,
0.1272435188,
-0.3828446567,
-0.2743271887,
0.5899663568,
-0.0648078248,
0.4416699111,
-0.1587144136,
-0.3830595016,
-0.0778610334,
0.7983654737,
0.4812140763,
-0.28336218,
-0.4219241142,
-0.2807698846,
0.0031097012,
-0.406098038,
-0.7627362609,
0.4915979803,
-0.7012193799,
-0.5966528058,
-0.5406229496,
-0.5957551003,
-0.7153662443,
0.0766477436,
0.2082689703,
0.1636974514,
-0.5295481682,
-0.1544457823,
0.5715176463,
-0.0270993225,
-0.0097159324,
0.4631483555,
-0.4380742311,
-0.2615987957,
0.8924841285,
0.036905162,
0.2320936918,
0.130443275,
0.2609091699,
-0.0766535699,
-0.4644518197,
0.1060744673,
0.0621703975,
-0.5267838836,
-0.3131884336,
-0.1254896373,
-0.2341135442,
-0.0654231012,
-0.21653229,
-0.6262761354,
-0.0433079712,
0.3071612418,
-0.2016556561,
0.2326561213,
0.6365934014,
0.3118607402,
0.0475003831,
-0.312980324,
0.2763862908,
0.3631286621,
0.6031381488,
0.0977880508,
-0.2896272242,
-0.1696262509,
0.1854303777,
-0.4293342531,
-0.8569474816,
0.1960296482,
-0.2404201925,
0.5763736367,
0.4209983647,
0.3201899529,
0.9619727135,
-0.0748521611,
0.7266283631,
-0.0429441109,
-1.0977609158,
0.6644157767,
-0.2363306731,
0.0561523587,
0.3659879565,
0.4165469706,
-0.5768390298,
-0.3680813015,
-0.8391517997,
-0.5352200866,
0.443811506,
0.1267435253,
-0.1401376873,
-0.0494162142,
0.396966815,
0.1523801237,
0.365026921,
-0.481968075,
-0.0000042706,
0.3972281814,
-0.0199428797,
-0.2071934938,
-0.0728619397,
-0.3045063317,
-0.2980371118,
0.6179674864,
-0.0383708104,
0.4974046946,
0.2327637374,
-0.2799289823,
-0.1377491057,
0.2160700411,
0.8061572313,
0.7166839838,
-0.3488861024,
0.3713275194,
0.334867537,
-0.0075577246,
0.4485905468,
-0.0259196777,
0.3254512846,
-0.377143383,
0.1792052686,
0.6663336158,
0.4108275771,
-0.9601296186,
0.2642789483,
-0.1318234205,
-0.5866765976,
-0.3859644532,
0.2052705288,
-0.0967250392,
0.4827558398,
0.1713220477,
-0.1708136052,
-0.021194784,
-0.5945938826,
0.1947909594,
0.4172691107,
-0.4478563666,
-0.3033581376,
0.5026233792,
0.3496801555,
-0.613743186,
0.5293393135,
-0.4083705544,
-0.6336724162,
0.6143898964,
0.5416677594,
0.976213038,
-0.2468551248,
0.1127068475,
0.0626578405,
0.4417382479,
0.186737299,
0.3827124536,
-0.0243331473,
-0.9434588552,
0.1372448355,
-0.106036514,
-0.9081398845,
0.3513707519,
-0.9806389213,
0.0413129926,
-0.5852177739,
-0.4953426123,
-0.3338220716,
0.5341121554,
-0.8841409087,
0.3677118123,
0.0613652654,
1.06450665,
-0.5058380365,
0.8618561029,
0.8787206411,
-0.1839876175,
-0.3402752578,
0.3899691105,
-0.007390005,
-0.8910147548,
0.1272462904,
0.1344298422,
-0.3535274565,
-0.1139776483,
-0.5429919362,
-0.6073867679,
1.2165518999,
0.7307305932,
-0.428173393,
0.2349531204,
0.0494748093,
0.5984892845,
-0.3652235866,
0.3133017421,
0.9360194802,
0.7751014829,
-0.0773134306,
-0.6756731272,
0.3432320356,
-0.3109919131,
0.1557666957,
0.3165365756,
-1.2175238132,
0.7450348735,
0.2048548013,
0.0042368216,
0.1942595541,
0.5110939741,
0.582967639,
0.388335973,
0.8469029069,
0.7080717683,
0.9901454449,
-0.1602303088,
1.1114299297,
-0.3727140129,
0.4057669342,
0.988658309,
-0.9720648527,
0.9313828349,
0.4702436328,
-0.339376092,
0.3775419891,
0.7384061217,
0.1097927764,
0.2868075669,
0.6459644437,
0.0491355471,
-0.5118492246,
-0.001834502,
-0.1643038243,
0.6507324576,
0.4981441498,
0.0108669745,
0.0469775386,
-0.0103216479,
0.1693466455,
0.2303594649,
0.0018672616,
0.6501448154,
-0.031366609,
-0.8557191491,
0.4624751508,
-0.123175025,
0.5122070909,
-0.529830277,
0.2278157473,
-0.1142529473,
0.2994718552,
0.4219819605,
-0.7209247351,
0.1796348542,
-0.1380512565,
0.2900681794,
-0.1331295967,
0.5436847806,
-0.3192827702,
-0.1848478615,
0.8002002835,
0.4340506196,
0.38423419,
-0.0529147126,
-0.8081855774,
0.4245896637,
-0.4416713417,
-0.5288984179,
0.5241288543,
0.5381327868,
0.2873066962,
0.9083537459,
0.3360053599,
0.0519519001,
-0.3670706451,
-0.2793893814,
0.6447066665,
-1.0171700716,
-0.1945507824,
-0.8246042132,
0.1398236454,
-0.1600970477,
-0.6341232061,
0.3245166838,
0.4797023833,
0.8295076489,
0.321750313,
0.736704886,
0.0293043666,
0.1973560005,
-0.7319794297,
0.7505185008,
-0.7695964575,
-0.0331368409,
-0.4583683312,
-0.7406443357,
0.0627287403,
0.6244412065,
-0.1901217997,
0.2697808146,
1.1206607819,
0.4644649625,
-0.0088735512,
0.1332383156,
0.7436540723,
0.402913481,
0.3175624907,
0.8372867107,
1.0021829605,
-0.3030872643,
0.6566203833,
-0.2732774317,
-0.0427559577,
-0.2252919823,
-0.7519333959,
-1.0653381348,
-0.9390417933,
-0.2711052001,
-0.2588500679,
0.0953090265,
1.3321429491,
0.5625246167,
-0.2094641924,
-0.7667431831,
0.0697172433,
0.1409738213,
-0.573317945,
-0.206529811,
0.1024869457,
-0.3378501534,
-0.7525317073,
0.3413158655,
0.1091957688,
0.2460248023,
-0.4014300406,
-0.2804744542,
-0.3260211349,
0.5186013579,
0.5421789885,
-0.066975072,
-0.7612969279,
-0.4999869764,
-0.3714933693,
-0.1598230004,
0.0181022603,
1.2081744671,
-0.8459917903,
0.3006511033,
-0.0966818705,
0.6631553173,
0.421628058,
-0.3120162785,
0.8885521889,
-0.3086931705,
0.3152977228,
0.178850919,
0.4555770755,
-0.0587476492,
-0.1823364645,
0.7122574449,
0.0521030873,
-0.2998690009,
-0.9566424489,
0.4608211517,
-0.7931468487,
-0.5114198923,
0.6383500695,
-0.0685670227,
-0.2309273481,
0.1807928234,
-0.1875174642,
0.2801096439,
-0.2185841054,
1.0471395254,
0.9484008551,
-0.0897590518,
-0.2920253575,
-0.3139679134,
0.4697002172,
0.6541770101,
-0.9492124319,
0.3324823678,
0.1704975516,
-0.3301668465,
0.0912880078,
0.5644689202,
0.1247836798,
0.3145546317,
-0.1298092753,
0.249607712,
0.1417147517,
-0.2758942246,
-0.250346154,
0.0506710596,
0.2864233553,
-0.1153268963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13613v1
|
The Branch Not Taken: Predicting Branching in Online Conversations
| 2024-04-21T10:49:41 | 2024-04-21T10:49:41 |
Shai Meital, Lior Rokach, Roman Vainshtein, Nir Grinberg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Multi-participant discussions tend to unfold in a tree structure rather than
a chain structure. Branching may occur for multiple reasons -- from the
asynchronous nature of online platforms to a conscious decision by an
interlocutor to disengage with part of the conversation. Predicting branching
and understanding the reasons for creating new branches is important for many
downstream tasks such as summarization and thread disentanglement and may help
develop online spaces that encourage users to engage in online discussions in
more meaningful ways. In this work, we define the novel task of branch
prediction and propose GLOBS (Global Branching Score) -- a deep neural network
model for predicting branching. GLOBS is evaluated on three large discussion
forums from Reddit, achieving significant improvements over an array of
competitive baselines and demonstrating better transferability. We affirm that
structural, temporal, and linguistic features contribute to GLOBS success and
find that branching is associated with a greater number of conversation
participants and tends to occur in earlier levels of the conversation tree. We
publicly release GLOBS and our implementation of all baseline models to allow
reproducibility and promote further research on this important task.
|
[
-0.7476328015,
-1.206739068,
0.7324322462,
0.0885687694,
-0.3955637813,
0.5694180727,
-0.0045786304,
-0.9797142148,
0.7501863241,
0.1561148614,
-1.0633423328,
-0.2996535599,
-0.8001986742,
-0.3587836623,
-0.7428888083,
1.1186910868,
0.2068271786,
-0.0548888557,
-0.2708040774,
0.2193611115,
-0.4069002867,
-0.3610007763,
-0.6599218845,
-0.2892870605,
0.7903013229,
0.3061449528,
0.5038917065,
0.4254466295,
0.6031739712,
0.2975237966,
-0.6813739538,
-0.1499374956,
-0.4912534356,
0.1686037332,
0.1736888885,
-0.3623707891,
-0.4234350622,
-0.4435875714,
0.3266644776,
0.7999154329,
-0.0544421934,
0.1959180385,
0.0666857883,
0.6119792461,
-0.1654835641,
0.1782604307,
-0.9215289354,
-0.0331723616,
0.0763116777,
-0.0555776283,
-0.1315716058,
-0.8006613255,
0.457228452,
-0.0447487943,
0.1627210677,
-0.3858803809,
0.6927176714,
-0.1162323058,
-0.4622027576,
-0.5410218239,
-0.6013947725,
0.119869113,
-0.718801558,
0.1152108163,
0.4663723111,
0.4613671303,
-0.0111558987,
-0.6335340142,
0.0410971791,
-0.1006542891,
-0.0876437873,
-0.1185761094,
-0.3059083223,
0.1260501593,
-0.0829693004,
0.3332667053,
-0.1985851377,
-0.0227002222,
-0.8803163767,
-0.0965333581,
0.3800638318,
0.2510196865,
0.1503925771,
-0.2162664086,
-0.1012286693,
0.343180716,
-0.3851927519,
0.2419389635,
0.4156564772,
0.3311613202,
0.0200771354,
0.403393805,
-0.1221224219,
0.3623490632,
0.257358849,
0.0502861738,
0.0518450774,
-0.7765034437,
-0.0623946674,
-0.0858700722,
0.5796868801,
0.4341956079,
0.2340320945,
0.0082179876,
0.2382121235,
-0.0400992297,
0.3442289233,
-0.9191640615,
-0.3124550581,
0.2584368885,
-0.5556481481,
-0.2498850971,
0.2430773824,
-0.8206880093,
-0.3638083935,
-0.1333501339,
-0.1579790413,
-0.272002846,
-0.3242250383,
-0.6202148795,
-0.1651892364,
-0.3331100941,
0.7919258475,
-0.6810628772,
0.5028037429,
0.7865175605,
1.220795393,
-0.0567558818,
-0.223591581,
-0.1732982546,
-0.3681855798,
-0.6411044598,
0.6414034367,
-0.5397273898,
-0.3787642419,
-0.2300114483,
0.0291178096,
0.3766615093,
-0.0432179868,
0.3080535233,
-0.4658617973,
0.2348853201,
-0.0670180693,
-0.6327459812,
-0.5756751895,
0.3736073077,
-0.5718180537,
0.0803069621,
-0.0861715749,
-0.7745392919,
0.3559752703,
-0.6437667608,
-0.2369973511,
0.1434780508,
-0.0135492729,
-0.4259824157,
0.2232290655,
0.2076232582,
0.2749825716,
0.0554719865,
0.573995471,
-0.6324723959,
-0.2766672373,
0.3372657597,
-0.3568504751,
0.7074935436,
-0.0744606704,
-0.1661814898,
0.5286809206,
0.1759043038,
0.3802794814,
-0.3301509321,
-0.0507575683,
0.0053179157,
0.289576143,
-0.3023331761,
0.111519143,
-0.031882599,
-0.446503371,
0.435785532,
-0.4575116634,
0.6624837518,
0.7424885035,
0.5622499585,
0.302156806,
-0.090277724,
0.3949088752,
-0.076366663,
0.5127946734,
-0.2679827213,
-1.0230662823,
-0.430113852,
0.0154613517,
0.3310984373,
0.2077120692,
-0.2113978863,
0.3823632896,
-0.1906045228,
-0.9289684296,
-0.0857340023,
0.1070091352,
0.2567805052,
-0.1006360203,
0.2792844176,
-0.5918425322,
-0.6279315352,
-0.6396303773,
-0.0026901031,
-0.4680356681,
-0.0157885961,
0.4485705197,
0.4389744401,
-0.6230905652,
1.0643186569,
-0.4637149572,
-0.506981194,
-0.3769294024,
0.577588141,
0.2654125094,
0.0859896243,
0.0487595983,
-0.7290519476,
-0.5639311671,
0.1415956318,
-0.4857428968,
0.3813206255,
-0.128342405,
0.0847043172,
0.0357408263,
0.7241985798,
-0.686278224,
0.4891477823,
0.932251215,
-0.5339625478,
0.3634177148,
-0.1311490387,
-0.0732418224,
-0.963997364,
-0.1570406854,
-0.3211593926,
-0.2519263029,
-0.5755808949,
-0.3517207801,
0.0517843701,
-0.0132906549,
-0.4462057948,
0.2725197971,
-0.5659618974,
-0.2243731469,
-0.2260970473,
-0.0636983886,
-0.2172195464,
0.57178092,
-0.2592248023,
0.3570679724,
0.5956124067,
-0.6178193092,
0.1936472207,
0.285550952,
-0.4886644781,
-0.2714066207,
-0.6051780581,
0.096038945,
-0.0382409319,
0.4891462624,
-1.0082228184,
-0.3663812876,
0.2581282854,
-0.8474936485,
0.1062716693,
-0.2662782967,
-0.0218755063,
-0.592962265,
-0.3240532279,
0.3708193302,
0.3705821931,
-0.0914103761,
0.364467293,
0.7294035554,
-0.4324168563,
-0.2597830892,
-0.7042403817,
0.1196695864,
-0.2349235564,
-0.5754989982,
0.2521268129,
-0.1236940995,
-0.0844454989,
0.3122129738,
-0.0137331318,
-0.3432798982,
0.3414583206,
0.615228653,
0.2006272823,
-0.1367801279,
0.2947151661,
-0.1723796278,
0.1465304047,
0.3831676841,
-0.0719013661,
0.4132042527,
-0.3846117854,
-0.6632210612,
-0.3002710938,
0.2105693817,
0.7841825485,
0.0602992624,
0.5715058446,
0.3087860942,
-0.3454009891,
0.0533850789,
-0.5052954555,
-0.4732954502,
-0.38939026,
0.5639079809,
0.2261851132,
-1.1434452534,
0.6012488008,
-0.0762864649,
0.1010228992,
0.1361597627,
0.6351875067,
-0.1405443847,
0.94621104,
0.7770169973,
0.0773340315,
0.7109883428,
-0.0302104447,
0.4093544185,
-0.7096247673,
-0.1680344492,
-0.1144030392,
-0.6232796907,
-0.7141540051,
-0.7080854774,
0.0023620687,
0.4542537332,
0.3816284239,
0.3810710013,
-0.3573714495,
0.7170797586,
0.3533270657,
-0.2289071381,
0.2627037764,
0.0220014676,
0.0680433065,
0.0077322642,
-0.2909443378,
-0.0773574859,
1.0086671114,
0.628973186,
0.4842827022,
0.0465865657,
0.6136523485,
0.368141979,
0.531873405,
-0.9522938132,
0.4316491783,
0.1894906312,
-1.0121250153,
-0.5931308866,
-0.6141067743,
-1.1128354073,
0.1613372415,
0.0006773687,
-1.3333433867,
-0.0847696736,
0.0599997081,
-0.4078459442,
0.4464933872,
-0.6709135175,
0.8495955467,
-0.5249978304,
-0.0429557636,
-0.3579951227,
-0.7051397562,
0.6122556329,
-0.1876201183,
0.3788909912,
-0.410143435,
0.2931128442,
0.5780370831,
-0.092511259,
0.9791818261,
-0.0604991838,
0.5138778687,
0.7504580021,
0.3218480051,
0.2466182411,
0.2200614065,
0.4324477613,
0.4300566912,
-0.1848336607,
0.1618335247,
-0.3902596235,
0.5093729496,
-0.789028883,
-0.4601767659,
-0.2526160479,
-0.1163850427,
-0.2072091997,
0.1128436327,
0.1895435601,
0.1121860445,
-0.5026714802,
0.6067414284,
0.0294665992,
0.1873395592,
0.7008697987,
-0.0506077334,
-0.957136929,
-0.5658959746,
0.8904425502,
0.315651983,
0.3674396873,
-0.0492854267,
0.4117494524,
-0.4309631288,
-0.5252864957,
-0.2780433297,
0.1374523789,
-0.8161187768,
-0.3270772099,
-0.6265904903,
-0.5704194903,
-0.0678104088,
-0.0167066697,
-0.2871222496,
-0.4309071302,
-0.2254311889,
-0.4671112895,
0.3469525278,
1.1928999424,
0.0618474819,
0.0584521852,
-1.0651526451,
0.02605002,
0.473852545,
0.3692850471,
0.2680698633,
-0.4187048972,
-0.2257862389,
0.1966557652,
-0.5899112225,
-0.9303647876,
0.5857958198,
0.3207019567,
0.52402246,
0.4248595536,
-0.303437233,
0.8007057905,
-0.1875355095,
0.5638977289,
0.491114378,
-1.0317033529,
0.5951451063,
-0.2840284705,
0.3520126343,
0.5151538849,
0.6191501617,
-0.745089829,
-0.6919643283,
-0.9607357383,
-1.067032218,
0.7099295855,
0.3587625027,
0.3805893362,
0.1359397322,
-0.2138275802,
0.2682421803,
0.4358333945,
-0.8257462382,
0.1091002896,
0.040623188,
0.4571996331,
0.0313921906,
-0.2823174298,
0.0108229704,
-0.377781868,
0.3189040422,
-0.338594228,
0.3816630542,
0.0587565415,
0.1902050972,
-0.6023022532,
0.233744055,
0.5379076004,
1.1154506207,
-0.4182341993,
-0.1269091368,
0.3110581636,
-0.1084010825,
-0.0730444565,
-0.4435162842,
-0.1094163209,
0.1733070016,
0.4481071234,
1.0283645391,
0.1934743524,
-0.3340956569,
0.3404792547,
-0.4474771023,
-0.4448229671,
-0.2745445073,
-0.2094314247,
0.7748678923,
0.2806591988,
0.2416132987,
0.3254444301,
0.1210992858,
-0.8060241342,
0.4495737255,
0.4356251359,
-0.7961243987,
-0.3321038187,
0.1107225791,
0.2544911206,
-0.6524630785,
0.7785752416,
-0.2552143633,
-0.6053177714,
0.7644828558,
0.1470358968,
1.1217362881,
0.110542953,
0.5280633569,
0.5834564567,
0.1063171551,
0.147432074,
-0.4017715752,
0.022316277,
-0.4650550485,
-0.4852935076,
-0.7075542808,
-0.7730518579,
-0.0499898195,
-0.3540211916,
0.2177839428,
-0.5356721282,
-0.5616549253,
-0.0736087337,
-0.1350698918,
-0.1533132941,
-0.0692352727,
0.6581618786,
0.6620893478,
-0.6793009639,
0.7928483486,
0.1921257079,
-0.2844959795,
-0.6800820231,
0.2887873054,
0.1141397282,
-0.2576433122,
0.525616467,
0.743976891,
0.1812828779,
-0.3513364196,
-0.0632197782,
-1.2343341112,
0.926410377,
0.260376513,
-0.5097108483,
-0.4476695955,
-0.105994001,
0.7332760096,
-0.3293451667,
0.895631671,
-0.0696844906,
0.2713448703,
0.6143606901,
-0.9138950109,
-0.1770456284,
-0.0388437137,
-0.234018296,
0.3351473808,
-0.2829370797,
1.2071689367,
-0.3339141905,
-0.4887066782,
-0.1997618824,
0.5717156529,
-0.0706872717,
0.0784628466,
0.5229741335,
0.1435397565,
0.8348152041,
-0.203785032,
0.8414153457,
-0.2162490785,
0.5462934375,
0.9877268672,
0.1428731978,
0.9498950839,
0.5216799974,
-0.0084973853,
0.6714470387,
0.7760301232,
0.0516871326,
0.4724619091,
0.232782647,
0.2565308213,
-0.0768011361,
-0.0563344583,
-0.6255871654,
0.4371314049,
0.5319401622,
-0.4382913709,
-0.3731423318,
-0.3811548948,
-0.1880295724,
-0.4679005146,
-0.3665502965,
1.1666873693,
0.0921959355,
-1.1239025593,
0.3424012959,
-0.2682467103,
0.4295471311,
-0.8410773277,
0.0277779773,
-0.2141576558,
0.557074368,
-0.3093149364,
-1.1316074133,
0.8405448198,
-0.2049062252,
0.1410835534,
-0.4858681262,
0.6366137266,
-0.253502667,
-0.7286031842,
1.1396400928,
0.8964149356,
0.1237011403,
-0.2697770894,
-0.7969948649,
0.0419098698,
0.1479432136,
-0.4296455979,
0.5222734213,
0.5503249764,
-0.1768217385,
0.6754284501,
0.7897314429,
-0.0205298457,
0.0916849524,
-0.1490925252,
0.98700279,
-0.6234198213,
-0.5775033236,
-1.100615263,
0.6346688271,
-0.1153189912,
-0.3995108008,
0.5711234212,
0.2791761458,
0.7208384871,
0.0074042208,
0.53993994,
-0.1128554568,
0.3979377747,
-0.2745647728,
0.7112694383,
-0.4194745421,
-0.0772798732,
-0.3012602031,
-0.9554185867,
0.0179600231,
0.4187097251,
-0.2992360294,
-0.2591785491,
0.9511091709,
0.4560970664,
0.086541824,
0.275437206,
0.2065652758,
0.0595474616,
0.5559107661,
0.483384937,
0.8885025382,
-0.0427008569,
0.9200380445,
-0.2558445036,
-0.0349093601,
-0.503523469,
-0.7184098959,
-0.9594772458,
-0.476922363,
-0.1958756149,
-0.1168551072,
-0.0746624544,
0.7434382439,
0.8003427982,
-0.9713276029,
-0.6168925166,
-0.8059957623,
0.3851972222,
-0.0997806862,
-0.174465239,
-0.2422954142,
-0.3431014419,
-0.2890944779,
0.3619741797,
0.2076466382,
-0.0727935508,
-0.3403213918,
-0.1014891788,
-0.4977603555,
-0.1714415103,
0.2893156707,
0.3115609884,
-1.0807570219,
-0.2123890817,
0.111318633,
-0.1645603329,
0.3828542531,
0.7620258927,
-0.5457790494,
0.512129724,
0.6968970299,
0.7095265985,
0.7834912539,
0.3423923254,
0.5345416665,
-0.631290257,
-0.2861155868,
0.6045811772,
0.1707660407,
0.2491444647,
-0.2876466811,
0.4846725166,
0.1006157547,
-0.6016581655,
-0.5803341269,
0.1185691506,
-0.5829741955,
-0.6875028014,
0.7940829992,
-0.2000567913,
-0.1785817593,
-0.067858994,
-0.3835396767,
0.1382385641,
-0.5875839591,
0.8247750401,
1.0264780521,
-0.3094454706,
-0.2276081592,
-0.3214780688,
0.3395107687,
0.1249565631,
-1.0910122395,
0.3515846431,
0.4622662365,
-0.1487123519,
0.8029273748,
0.6849332452,
0.2962338924,
0.095353514,
0.0718522593,
-0.2715353966,
-0.0243857987,
-0.7034938931,
-0.0931177959,
0.6856254935,
0.1737470031,
0.0858427659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13611v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13611v2
|
Video sentence grounding with temporally global textual knowledge
| 2024-04-21T10:41:04 | 2024-06-01T06:56:16 |
Cai Chen, Runzhong Zhang, Jianjun Gao, Kejun Wu, Kim-Hui Yap, Yi Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Temporal sentence grounding involves the retrieval of a video moment with a
natural language query. Many existing works directly incorporate the given
video and temporally localized query for temporal grounding, overlooking the
inherent domain gap between different modalities. In this paper, we utilize
pseudo-query features containing extensive temporally global textual knowledge
sourced from the same video-query pair, to enhance the bridging of domain gaps
and attain a heightened level of similarity between multi-modal features.
Specifically, we propose a Pseudo-query Intermediary Network (PIN) to achieve
an improved alignment of visual and comprehensive pseudo-query features within
the feature space through contrastive learning. Subsequently, we utilize
learnable prompts to encapsulate the knowledge of pseudo-queries, propagating
them into the textual encoder and multi-modal fusion module, further enhancing
the feature alignment between visual and language for better temporal
grounding. Extensive experiments conducted on the Charades-STA and
ActivityNet-Captions datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.2130686492,
-1.0025116205,
0.6817406416,
0.1946808547,
-0.5802131891,
0.0457523614,
-0.0631920621,
-0.1595120132,
0.4898914695,
0.2288442701,
-0.7616429329,
-0.4741490483,
-0.2913493514,
-0.2368458509,
-0.2666604519,
0.8038992882,
0.000279558,
0.0150003349,
-0.2374955565,
-0.4922367036,
-0.5927919745,
-0.5810442567,
-0.1852065027,
-0.0576550886,
0.0724702477,
0.312146306,
0.612865448,
0.3850420117,
0.4189764857,
0.3452710509,
0.2111763954,
0.4854734838,
-0.4280320108,
0.0587973781,
-0.445558697,
-0.5228734016,
0.0630185306,
-0.186860323,
0.6543166041,
0.5147999525,
0.229951784,
-0.081817992,
-0.1311863214,
0.55862391,
-0.550866425,
0.1978683472,
-0.9036957622,
0.2818832397,
-0.1377272755,
-0.7360388637,
-0.1090301648,
-0.2994889915,
0.1820217967,
-0.6626551747,
0.4212526083,
0.2682309747,
1.3333165646,
0.4019246697,
-0.3341191411,
0.072204344,
-0.3866734505,
0.4830416441,
-0.3430855274,
0.4015690386,
0.6559360027,
0.4717769623,
0.1665128917,
-0.7286893725,
-0.8397914171,
-0.2433113456,
-0.2282339185,
0.2115188241,
0.0358736478,
0.0624049678,
0.2327325791,
0.2938271761,
-0.7945769429,
-0.2914360464,
-0.0945547745,
-0.1622355878,
0.0409593247,
0.1019843817,
0.6061499119,
-0.503892839,
-0.3094668686,
-0.0436207913,
-0.5305600166,
0.1826935261,
0.2475711703,
0.1165872142,
-0.2281480432,
0.8189117908,
-0.3727047145,
0.6238489151,
0.3686328828,
0.0222924203,
0.2951216996,
-0.6098026633,
-0.3547397852,
0.1226106435,
0.6217126846,
0.8600670099,
0.0073642177,
-0.2817094028,
0.2304525077,
0.3308928013,
0.1959586591,
-0.6799248457,
-0.3815169334,
-0.071937792,
-0.5488946438,
0.1027092561,
0.4759396613,
-0.591611743,
-0.0067937467,
-0.5228506923,
0.461250484,
-0.5008043647,
0.0653604642,
-0.1476289481,
-0.0539829507,
0.3411765397,
0.0044926708,
-0.6995991468,
0.1300833076,
0.1738520861,
1.1097379923,
0.3111887872,
-0.2792806625,
-0.8324705958,
0.3483893573,
-0.2454577833,
0.732714057,
-0.5700595975,
-0.0548845008,
0.1562764794,
0.4274191558,
-0.1381443143,
-0.4494901597,
0.2562762201,
-0.8703913689,
0.4894670248,
-0.3359666169,
-0.2373912483,
-0.1092372462,
0.5441732407,
-0.5246937275,
1.0047504902,
-0.1892208904,
-0.8707766533,
0.4719149172,
-0.2775954306,
-0.4786387086,
-0.272246778,
-0.4973778725,
-0.4771703482,
-0.1286226362,
0.6841288209,
0.3161580861,
-0.0508316942,
0.7158089876,
-0.2383976281,
-0.484900862,
-0.0211552139,
-0.3142083883,
0.2743924558,
0.1182410792,
-0.6356557608,
0.1747340858,
-0.5624182224,
-0.0303017534,
-0.0463451371,
0.1480938494,
-0.3936065435,
0.0408437103,
-0.1645459384,
0.4733440578,
-0.0141761824,
-0.1612808853,
0.0801019743,
-0.4749154449,
0.5965586305,
0.4479768872,
0.3571982384,
0.6237695217,
-0.1793218255,
0.2527410984,
0.1633720845,
0.0138647454,
-0.5942229629,
-0.1720587164,
-0.6575357914,
-0.0334261693,
-0.1773398519,
0.7612771988,
-1.2341316938,
0.6194999218,
-0.4514128864,
-0.1862714738,
-0.2927982807,
0.1396733671,
0.5017047524,
0.8343635201,
0.6944422126,
0.005073152,
-0.5699235201,
-0.9326763153,
0.0015821224,
-0.3697213531,
-0.064464055,
0.5751391053,
0.3599060774,
0.0536369495,
1.0127190351,
-0.519949317,
-0.5604777932,
0.1099429131,
0.3996725678,
0.2426281422,
0.3586223125,
0.6610382199,
-1.192640543,
-0.4382660687,
-0.1951125115,
-1.0994046926,
-0.2196705192,
-0.3834679425,
-0.310292989,
-0.2245765924,
0.955663085,
-0.6082075238,
0.284379065,
0.2358637452,
-0.3448213041,
0.3285135627,
-0.2704657614,
0.881095171,
-0.9898219109,
-0.0588046163,
-0.0749436244,
-0.2588923573,
-0.0318129957,
-0.2079864442,
0.0765902698,
-0.317093581,
-0.5330118537,
0.3483891189,
-0.5570237637,
-0.121749185,
-0.1097323447,
0.4021691978,
0.1130587459,
0.5523293018,
0.2683146298,
1.0703591108,
0.7331838608,
-0.6501341462,
0.4082299769,
0.4437155724,
-0.2810808718,
0.8011613488,
-0.6460481882,
-0.060070537,
-0.3682765961,
0.2361994386,
-1.189088583,
-0.1420602947,
0.0954115093,
-0.4950760305,
0.0348096639,
-0.42525509,
-0.4406794906,
-0.0435173698,
-0.3149502873,
0.5828129649,
0.3146704137,
-0.6852036119,
0.41890347,
0.1484706551,
-0.0572693795,
-0.4932588041,
-0.693005383,
0.4395129681,
-0.3700200617,
-0.8320671916,
0.8549648523,
0.0639506876,
-0.1970511824,
0.1747983396,
-0.1884756088,
-0.1254557818,
-0.3723686934,
0.2011107951,
0.1439685524,
-0.383430481,
0.246383369,
0.1859057546,
-0.0929745138,
-0.2155014724,
-0.5817659497,
0.4185126424,
-0.0686836466,
-0.5295206904,
-0.3418743312,
0.4632315338,
0.2035720795,
-0.3292295039,
0.7412954569,
0.4838843048,
-0.4031216502,
0.0465414822,
-0.6349956393,
-0.278151989,
-0.4589491189,
0.1614274085,
-0.4595561326,
-0.9093401432,
0.3688888252,
-0.2258034647,
-0.473793745,
0.1568417996,
0.2830396891,
-0.4440431595,
0.5792812705,
0.5508905053,
0.0247536376,
0.8306168914,
-0.4497524798,
0.0881788954,
-0.40066576,
-0.4136219025,
-0.2188165635,
-0.2520380616,
-0.1414462179,
-0.6453142762,
0.3794562817,
0.5051927567,
-0.1332181096,
0.1998702288,
-0.0056319288,
0.6581343412,
0.3679170012,
0.3453026116,
-0.0608017519,
0.1551349163,
-0.4401889443,
-0.6593050361,
-0.5820411444,
-0.3302547932,
0.4411689043,
-0.2959195673,
0.3650713563,
0.2854958177,
0.1258143932,
0.5389385819,
-0.4676306844,
-0.3908590972,
0.4577919245,
-0.1574543417,
-0.2522553802,
-0.1107347086,
-0.2266884297,
-0.5512332916,
0.1870095283,
-0.4331575632,
-0.5344581008,
0.0152190905,
0.0848449394,
-0.1387024671,
0.2971860766,
-0.7231042385,
0.986361742,
-0.3572843969,
-0.7316401005,
-0.0865636468,
-1.2361294031,
0.0559592173,
0.3447275758,
0.1792456061,
0.190617457,
0.1094291508,
0.3960712254,
-0.616348207,
0.7839571238,
-0.2009721249,
0.4919962287,
0.3615008593,
0.0195141751,
0.3000047803,
0.2994467616,
0.2727327049,
-0.0896964073,
-0.5038261414,
-0.4130510092,
-0.7618029714,
0.6991878152,
-0.5431342721,
-0.5098151565,
-0.2677440345,
-0.0963336676,
-0.330704689,
0.2320189774,
0.2826160789,
0.7189353704,
-0.3122726679,
0.3407502472,
0.9597321153,
-0.106591925,
0.7505520582,
0.3023467064,
0.2172513008,
-0.6120390892,
0.7749086022,
-0.1835636795,
0.0196000896,
1.0758206844,
-0.1720214635,
-0.5652455091,
-0.5374540091,
-0.4361236095,
0.2352151871,
-0.7566292882,
-0.3618532419,
-0.8340580463,
0.004255278,
-0.5290185213,
-0.5047966242,
-0.0184742678,
-0.1015942246,
-0.3609446883,
-0.6623135209,
0.4418499172,
-0.1704973578,
0.1040676013,
0.6440306306,
-0.9851686358,
0.9646187425,
0.3603378534,
0.2403415591,
-0.4804347157,
-0.5997356772,
-0.1206185296,
-0.417362541,
-0.0573712029,
-0.8609411716,
0.2003630698,
0.5606149435,
0.6959614158,
0.5174396634,
0.0295409914,
1.1193058491,
-0.8483434916,
1.1644821167,
0.3294748366,
-1.0019756556,
0.9046400189,
-0.4177904129,
0.3326087296,
0.7268018126,
0.5194960237,
-0.3894906938,
-0.1634497195,
-0.4155313373,
-1.0529060364,
0.5411113501,
0.4104796052,
0.2088883519,
-0.2550541461,
0.3650116622,
-0.0517576486,
0.1298506707,
-0.7570014,
-0.1739902049,
-0.7673345208,
-0.0541988984,
0.0025607513,
-0.1784938276,
-0.0330044553,
0.0122811394,
0.4007356167,
-0.3125944138,
0.0509133227,
0.4294408262,
-0.7050518394,
0.0478597842,
0.2166713178,
0.3453576565,
0.6917725801,
-0.309538126,
0.3961398602,
0.125240609,
-0.2120895833,
0.2923885882,
0.142716527,
-0.0689074397,
0.0546930172,
0.5996232033,
0.8265789151,
0.4196305275,
-0.5372418165,
0.572085917,
-0.0339900218,
-0.1141190082,
-0.0952793881,
-0.3210166097,
-0.1804724485,
0.4607614577,
0.34202075,
-0.0476338603,
0.1275856346,
-0.678285718,
0.6900660396,
0.2022421211,
-0.4297396839,
-0.3061284423,
0.8981004953,
0.149654001,
-0.0654457435,
0.4830989242,
-0.1388774663,
-0.5471716523,
0.3868781924,
0.5441888571,
0.5611985326,
0.0686924681,
0.3712260723,
0.4093462825,
0.3205227554,
-0.0695463493,
0.32988289,
-0.3430868387,
-0.3685804904,
-0.5072789788,
-0.1640644968,
-0.0089559788,
-0.1101115793,
-0.3801914752,
0.4825283587,
-0.4813660979,
-0.1296382695,
-0.5407460928,
-0.0257716663,
-0.5084863901,
0.6140096188,
0.0958653688,
0.5104093552,
-1.1131757498,
0.6876136661,
0.9925024509,
-0.9322336316,
-0.4301428199,
0.1561721265,
-0.0723179653,
-0.5486152768,
0.8880126476,
0.2805268466,
-0.4251192212,
-0.3590483963,
-0.3286589682,
-0.4929651618,
1.2525510788,
0.3797547817,
-0.395862788,
-0.3582967818,
0.0039996379,
0.4812291563,
-0.2918000817,
0.3921897411,
0.0873644501,
0.20273678,
0.2154179662,
-0.7042511702,
0.0390557051,
-0.4784666002,
-0.1754866987,
0.13288939,
-0.5654808283,
0.5723522902,
0.1179161891,
-0.2533430755,
-0.2518314719,
1.0043623447,
0.1838442981,
0.5204348564,
0.5628974438,
0.6105357409,
0.6111441851,
-0.0422315486,
0.67698282,
-0.0837733224,
-0.0230324697,
1.2836529016,
-0.110689275,
0.4955722094,
0.6661047935,
0.0951532349,
0.5370054245,
0.4906728864,
0.1666984707,
1.0143409967,
-0.0198812075,
-0.0344511233,
-0.5851487517,
-0.3287169337,
-0.5049993992,
0.1941303909,
0.2082656175,
-0.2257869989,
-0.3283920884,
0.1679229736,
-0.2313794941,
0.5815821886,
-0.3191865385,
0.7760437131,
0.0247282274,
-0.4380273521,
0.2219390869,
-0.1460604519,
0.6927958727,
-0.8580492735,
-0.2906744182,
-0.3796492517,
-0.2177213132,
-0.2155548036,
-0.6623518467,
0.3801112473,
0.0399509966,
-0.394317925,
-0.2154269516,
0.7151898742,
-0.5262556672,
-0.0549944043,
0.3237630129,
0.4452126026,
-0.0377468802,
-0.1830954999,
-0.7230601907,
-0.1076916978,
-0.3360452652,
0.1831328273,
0.1589690298,
0.8763589263,
-0.2742753327,
0.4151365161,
0.6148471236,
-0.1179353446,
0.0217731185,
0.4313390553,
1.0569272041,
-0.9875404835,
-1.0781371593,
-0.8119397759,
0.5582044125,
-0.1856394112,
-0.075337097,
0.6878367662,
0.579898417,
0.7318835855,
0.0884616822,
0.5079503655,
-0.0492456295,
-0.0287395604,
-1.2838851213,
0.3799190819,
-0.551240623,
0.167260468,
-0.3589685857,
-1.0880526304,
-0.3450170159,
0.4195259511,
-0.2992612123,
-0.1780683994,
1.0403763056,
0.7018930912,
-0.4672573507,
-0.2049337029,
0.322580725,
0.0245951973,
0.4860802591,
0.4094002843,
0.9514152408,
-0.380277276,
0.8285785317,
-0.1086646914,
-0.1444218308,
-0.1360085756,
-1.1897821426,
-1.1538887024,
-0.7334462404,
-0.2585255504,
-0.146805957,
0.3527281284,
0.8860706091,
0.8375863433,
-0.7144913077,
0.099806942,
0.0473087244,
-0.0810844451,
-0.1026094928,
-0.2470286787,
0.7443934679,
-0.359686017,
-0.3765586615,
0.6930023432,
0.3597874045,
-0.0736260116,
0.230916515,
0.2063014656,
-0.5629366636,
-0.1687993407,
0.5870911479,
0.1667417884,
-0.5299017429,
-0.3879514337,
0.3029417694,
0.1515599936,
0.2286475748,
1.3076677322,
-0.9603792429,
0.5155783892,
0.5668147206,
0.712264359,
0.6779190898,
0.2650991082,
0.5077887774,
-1.1830625534,
0.5898917913,
0.0857213363,
0.5576959848,
0.5325242877,
-0.4017073512,
0.3180040121,
0.53486377,
-0.2160442024,
-0.3681823611,
0.1533047855,
-1.0508586168,
-0.232367754,
0.8623149395,
-0.1357321292,
0.0165261943,
-0.3359125555,
-0.4114094973,
0.406647712,
-0.3243449628,
0.8063541055,
0.6796154976,
-0.043908,
-0.2408165932,
-0.2989493012,
0.3877133429,
0.4913759232,
-0.8234637976,
-0.2693965733,
0.7839875817,
0.0409537368,
0.0323409364,
0.8160232902,
-0.1629853845,
0.2431548387,
0.0246499982,
-0.50542593,
-0.2065849155,
-0.671150744,
-0.1775640249,
0.3092955947,
-0.4387388229,
-0.3219715059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13599v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13599v2
|
"A good pun is its own reword": Can Large Language Models Understand Puns?
| 2024-04-21T09:42:05 | 2024-06-16T11:31:18 |
Zhijun Xu, Siyu Yuan, Lingjie Chen, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Puns play a vital role in academic research due to their distinct structure
and clear definition, which aid in the comprehensive analysis of linguistic
humor. However, the understanding of puns in large language models (LLMs) has
not been thoroughly examined, limiting their use in creative writing and humor
creation. In this paper, we leverage three popular tasks, i.e., pun
recognition, explanation and generation to systematically evaluate the
capabilities of LLMs in pun understanding. In addition to adopting the
automated evaluation metrics from prior research, we introduce new evaluation
methods and metrics that are better suited to the in-context learning paradigm
of LLMs. These new metrics offer a more rigorous assessment of an LLM's ability
to understand puns and align more closely with human cognition than previous
metrics. Our findings reveal the "lazy pun generation" pattern and identify the
primary challenges LLMs encounter in understanding puns.
|
[
-0.2515228689,
-0.7549512982,
0.8567461967,
0.6313397884,
-0.6028472185,
0.1832194328,
-0.517999649,
-0.4494579434,
0.227880165,
0.3403538465,
-0.4101801515,
-0.1825100929,
-0.6692774892,
0.7515608072,
-0.2716098428,
0.9422296286,
-0.0017583335,
0.1390903443,
-0.8100454211,
0.009612211,
-0.6584945321,
-0.2515270114,
-0.6763344407,
-0.2318645567,
0.7037559152,
0.3915243745,
0.4595171213,
0.5828789473,
0.7287839055,
0.4399724901,
-0.2794324458,
0.1236224324,
-0.4369958639,
-0.0348685905,
-0.2645747364,
-0.6207429171,
0.0047363234,
0.0750340968,
0.8987175226,
1.2112395763,
0.2131320685,
0.2128441483,
0.0522479229,
0.3765240312,
-0.5124784708,
0.0468017906,
-0.5344083309,
0.1069902182,
-0.3712230325,
-0.0974412039,
-0.506167531,
-0.439181,
0.0354861021,
-0.7261876464,
0.0839688927,
0.3828159869,
0.5911290646,
0.2932246625,
-0.2150854766,
-0.6051228642,
-0.2703043818,
0.8455639482,
-0.55588907,
0.3889806867,
0.0604500882,
0.1600549519,
-0.3947132528,
-0.7348412275,
-0.601398468,
-0.1596486866,
-0.0880045667,
-0.1337398589,
-0.2298881114,
-0.493190676,
0.1265270561,
0.577647686,
-0.2980913222,
0.4055847228,
-0.3955049217,
-0.1070721522,
0.4527007937,
0.425952822,
0.2089585215,
-0.5458304882,
-0.6121758223,
0.3895435929,
-0.4883175492,
0.126017496,
0.4511063695,
0.0424857624,
-0.1884876937,
0.3943181932,
0.2833977938,
0.6895769238,
-0.3248163462,
-0.2617280781,
0.2936376929,
-0.3982809782,
-0.2306679636,
-0.3890434504,
1.0181692839,
0.0152790798,
0.6336182952,
-0.4616096318,
-0.2785767019,
-0.1421372592,
0.1353777796,
-0.2797191739,
-0.0589394346,
-0.1534262598,
-0.249917075,
-0.350279659,
-0.096495375,
-0.584310472,
-0.5565371513,
-0.2275585681,
0.1833766103,
-0.403072685,
-0.040741697,
0.4249571264,
-0.5843836069,
0.1207009256,
0.2092607617,
-0.4248464406,
0.3222773373,
0.8589406013,
0.8243198395,
-0.40035671,
-0.6404661536,
-0.4406057894,
-0.0217092,
-0.3391006887,
1.0973848104,
-0.5969656706,
-0.312499851,
-0.3328975439,
0.0566076562,
-0.358877033,
-0.6794164181,
0.7881377339,
-0.2427893281,
0.4601801932,
-0.3898740113,
-0.7017538548,
-0.1851622909,
0.2681509852,
-0.493052572,
0.4111060798,
0.1081126481,
-1.0627007484,
0.3537436128,
-0.4818396568,
-0.5982351899,
0.1885459721,
0.0046869493,
-0.3347453177,
0.7812340856,
0.2454552799,
0.3280047476,
-0.6239324808,
0.2477951646,
-0.1558561027,
-0.5723870397,
0.7441272736,
-0.1546165347,
0.939117372,
0.2013878375,
-0.0543247908,
-0.1069903299,
-0.5108013749,
-0.1285829991,
0.5067489147,
-0.5741958618,
-0.4167141914,
-0.0471164472,
-0.3778557479,
-0.091021657,
0.2364599258,
-0.5068054795,
0.0947227851,
-0.5497591496,
0.6334703565,
0.6688324809,
-0.177021265,
0.1242597252,
-0.1408801079,
0.5381994247,
-0.152337566,
0.1268857569,
-0.3596433997,
-0.2677485049,
-0.8889551163,
-0.5178974271,
0.2920439243,
0.296312809,
-0.4795702398,
0.4195719659,
-0.2682201862,
-0.3815469146,
-0.4694144726,
0.586017549,
0.4531581104,
0.3828426003,
0.1025192663,
-0.6928912401,
-0.3933386207,
-0.7603033781,
-0.7411432266,
-0.0505796298,
0.1014131159,
0.5507236123,
0.4952522516,
0.0002088875,
0.7366247177,
-0.2242040485,
0.0289783403,
-0.536768198,
0.1664337665,
0.2741021812,
0.0890933871,
0.4924470782,
-0.2509174049,
-0.1792465001,
-0.4133549631,
-0.8643407226,
-0.4482461214,
0.0482191406,
0.1495446563,
-0.382121861,
0.5652881265,
-0.5390811563,
0.0670145154,
0.2993993461,
-0.6400472522,
0.9272736907,
0.1850074232,
-0.1359942853,
-0.5181698799,
0.0468891487,
-0.0361165404,
-0.2577053905,
-0.2745076716,
0.3455761671,
-0.1158856377,
-0.1046676934,
-0.6057403684,
0.6829028726,
-0.661007762,
-0.4423817098,
-0.3372747302,
0.2741317153,
0.3190015852,
0.1029961184,
-0.2319030166,
0.7391605973,
0.5627108216,
-0.4714970887,
0.4163668752,
0.0585292988,
-0.726015389,
0.4963589311,
-0.7852053642,
0.241915673,
-0.1524156332,
0.2885451019,
-0.9924421906,
-0.1036668718,
0.1782068461,
-0.2848577499,
0.0573567748,
0.072394602,
-0.8215545416,
-0.678173244,
-0.0293243732,
0.6220414042,
0.3579333723,
-0.5211404562,
0.2293523997,
0.1233641654,
-0.1432291716,
-0.5229154825,
-0.4418224394,
0.2487736791,
-0.6003037691,
-0.6982989311,
-0.1276200861,
0.041936934,
-0.6177043915,
-0.228299886,
0.2703700364,
0.154726997,
0.3365889788,
0.0254615024,
-0.1185438409,
-0.2335297316,
0.2424984872,
-0.4517616332,
-0.0551811494,
0.3889471889,
-0.0894571692,
0.5819157362,
0.0813614056,
-0.1817861795,
-0.5282017589,
0.139645949,
0.6979088783,
-0.3186499178,
0.3778803349,
0.4745666087,
0.0007172619,
-0.2493519634,
-0.602154851,
0.0158274099,
-0.4676457942,
0.1656233966,
-0.2917390168,
-0.6981064081,
0.3725140691,
-0.1861550808,
-0.0821567103,
0.4695227146,
0.4308376908,
-0.1807221621,
0.4563797414,
0.7546502948,
0.0766494721,
0.3027949333,
0.0987551138,
0.2731230259,
-0.878783226,
-0.2234170139,
-0.5150831938,
-0.3095895052,
0.0594746284,
-0.5823610425,
0.222928673,
0.1452995539,
-0.2316660583,
0.0558653027,
-0.1593509614,
0.6966286302,
0.2943351567,
-0.2579742074,
0.3614919484,
0.1320633143,
-0.3792154789,
-0.0880435109,
-0.5102397203,
-0.451603502,
0.6830126643,
0.6720561981,
0.8309003115,
0.0505780056,
0.6609480977,
0.0602916516,
0.2005865723,
-0.9427710772,
0.6449579597,
-0.4259874225,
-0.2933514714,
-0.0018477195,
-0.519832015,
-0.9033896327,
0.0597776733,
-0.047670003,
-0.8307810426,
-0.1236412972,
-0.0653833747,
-0.3340214491,
0.2588209808,
-0.7659910917,
0.8411050439,
-0.4862853289,
-0.3442484736,
-0.2228556871,
-0.3610618711,
0.6051235199,
-0.0940022543,
0.5625416636,
-0.1399386078,
-0.118486926,
0.9882997274,
-0.0709888265,
0.7796611786,
0.0689576566,
-0.1016625464,
0.5194900632,
0.3217600882,
0.304086715,
0.0604991205,
-0.249479413,
0.1655377448,
-0.348639816,
-0.2696864009,
-0.5112000108,
0.6064412594,
-0.6152261496,
-0.7123481631,
-0.2544113398,
-0.7642173767,
-0.071979329,
-0.0565965064,
0.1608530581,
0.0477032959,
-0.2938255668,
0.1090829521,
0.1701633334,
-0.690531373,
0.4115560353,
0.5220208764,
-0.1434887499,
-0.2886631489,
0.8662180901,
-0.3134146333,
0.0979742482,
-0.02597991,
0.561655283,
-0.3022709489,
-0.4980621338,
-0.2664919496,
0.6374729872,
-0.9584792852,
-0.0375474393,
-0.7457542419,
0.070000343,
-0.2906646132,
-0.1712407321,
-0.2115482539,
-0.1860776246,
-0.405035913,
0.1376608312,
0.1478306353,
1.0971441269,
-0.0746621042,
0.5663537383,
-0.3979851007,
0.0134347826,
0.1694124192,
0.4166354239,
0.0685710758,
-0.761711657,
-0.1273625642,
-0.5716286898,
-0.3748577237,
-0.7644602656,
0.162920326,
0.2436614782,
0.3803286552,
0.5371982455,
-0.4401116669,
0.4627414644,
-0.6629354954,
0.8983801603,
0.4290151,
-1.0342160463,
0.3316298425,
-0.0566755235,
0.1261626035,
0.2726092637,
0.3664895296,
-0.3832008541,
-0.4173307121,
-0.5501449108,
-0.5444866419,
0.2925298512,
0.104716368,
0.427636385,
-0.3660218418,
0.4162730873,
0.4418620169,
0.1932602227,
-0.9809924364,
0.160501048,
-0.0049567232,
0.0848933682,
-0.3567292094,
-0.364902854,
-0.0728417858,
-0.346632272,
0.0939077511,
0.1227477714,
0.1922290772,
-0.1001125798,
-0.2355316877,
-0.269218713,
0.3364280164,
0.2721275091,
0.852940917,
0.1395415664,
0.2963838577,
0.1632996202,
-0.2033489496,
-0.1834838241,
-0.151762262,
0.382953465,
0.1622146666,
0.6969990134,
0.6345130205,
0.3786815107,
-0.7582380176,
0.7622135878,
-0.0440600514,
-0.0154622486,
-0.294762969,
0.2279817909,
0.2973653376,
0.1463790089,
0.1271558106,
-0.2932676971,
-0.0275845304,
-0.7798321843,
0.1245606318,
0.4705808461,
-0.1772298366,
-0.4343417883,
0.3627788126,
0.3946402073,
-0.4417668879,
0.6714126468,
-0.3362048268,
-0.7036423683,
0.7591663003,
0.9013798237,
0.6697633266,
0.1490985751,
-0.0026388261,
0.340141654,
0.2565696537,
0.1195515916,
0.2675204575,
0.1925095767,
-0.6501570344,
-0.591999054,
-0.9784799218,
-0.1766742766,
0.2429599166,
-0.2233861983,
0.4997093379,
-0.5466823578,
-0.0386385247,
0.3162309825,
-0.1240716502,
-1.0774549246,
0.1823356748,
0.11868985,
0.9728232622,
-0.893016696,
0.2247674316,
0.7436317801,
-0.2422098666,
-0.4841444194,
0.0602640398,
-0.2143970728,
-1.0246876478,
0.7420351505,
0.3491366804,
0.0796816722,
-0.0120671866,
-0.6985060573,
-0.608930409,
0.5750878453,
0.4593370259,
-0.6639800072,
-0.0866713747,
0.0324066356,
0.414141804,
-0.5400413871,
0.291066736,
0.6183872223,
0.5516512394,
-0.2017973065,
-0.9410066009,
0.0187467206,
0.0303100869,
-0.5286611319,
0.108307831,
-0.6682963371,
0.919686079,
-0.5866545439,
-0.2664694488,
0.222068131,
0.5394334197,
0.2581706941,
0.5567124486,
0.789960444,
0.8134406209,
0.576810658,
0.0441458523,
1.1723086834,
-0.1068129763,
0.188948825,
0.8987023234,
0.0324520357,
0.4636695981,
0.5914453268,
-0.1140651628,
0.7136258483,
0.5995089412,
-0.2015787959,
0.1574230641,
0.8189619184,
-0.0427172072,
-0.6201910377,
-0.3529868424,
-0.0678152516,
0.7778808475,
0.4693719745,
-0.6908218265,
-0.1671745479,
-0.0168779232,
0.0192964785,
0.2149037272,
-0.2966594696,
0.7147536874,
0.4662012756,
-0.6179421544,
0.3648261428,
-0.0689934641,
0.6747950315,
-0.2589533627,
0.2403715253,
-0.1715608537,
-0.1427348405,
-0.1270668209,
-0.9424597621,
0.19989416,
0.27545169,
0.053199444,
0.4028876722,
0.5064684153,
0.1846366525,
-0.6761052012,
0.3583908677,
0.9825131893,
0.710901916,
0.2124371082,
-0.5651113391,
0.2775712907,
-0.2860129476,
-0.0581361428,
-0.1064368859,
0.9005734921,
0.0185269099,
0.7220184803,
0.4271533787,
0.2551744878,
0.030362064,
0.2509173751,
0.7879949212,
-0.8302590251,
-0.4798871577,
-0.8985289335,
0.2304535657,
0.0463583767,
-0.5981510878,
0.6837152243,
0.3488563597,
0.6301653385,
-0.0355034471,
0.7518765926,
0.0569072999,
0.3384407163,
-0.2825614512,
0.2850269079,
-0.8635445833,
0.2354842722,
-0.3342519701,
-0.943466723,
-0.2086096853,
0.519225955,
-0.6139800549,
-0.0113829542,
0.8493553996,
0.2062475383,
-0.4001512527,
-0.0509234667,
0.2114562392,
0.2209738195,
0.0495212823,
0.578746736,
1.2500504255,
0.0197550282,
0.528585732,
-0.079168804,
-0.0105807371,
-0.0859644637,
-1.0334037542,
-1.0511347055,
-0.182161659,
-0.2130433768,
0.0278246347,
0.1392475814,
0.6294702888,
0.228426218,
-0.4351344407,
-0.1952900887,
0.0613167547,
0.3826556802,
-0.0402111039,
-0.2398560941,
0.3596547246,
-0.8554992676,
-0.741783917,
0.4504282475,
0.2845699787,
-0.174580127,
-0.4601739347,
0.0468159057,
0.1206382662,
0.245995298,
0.4715630114,
0.2043817788,
-0.8743780255,
-0.3954940438,
-0.1344947666,
0.0659241751,
-0.0447416529,
1.1787222624,
-0.6247954369,
0.4380680025,
0.501952827,
0.6225164533,
-0.2361760587,
-0.0960041732,
0.5492179394,
-0.7136566639,
0.1162867472,
0.1734405905,
0.713342309,
0.7545378208,
-0.2417889535,
0.4692392051,
0.5749428868,
-0.5218152404,
-0.9830582142,
0.2967095971,
-0.6717236042,
-0.5250657201,
1.2569967508,
-0.2936918437,
-0.3763716221,
-0.1871830225,
0.1643146724,
0.2720166147,
0.084400937,
0.8175646067,
0.6506566405,
0.0115405247,
-0.161198929,
-0.5525613427,
0.2190207094,
0.6642413139,
-0.3839095831,
0.1072419509,
0.2513065338,
0.7087392211,
0.2179729491,
0.3920487463,
-0.1650973856,
0.3214720488,
-0.3017803729,
0.0243854057,
-0.1219252273,
-0.4728946686,
-0.1063854694,
0.0067491382,
0.2698008716,
0.0457341187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14454v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14454v2
|
Reinforcement of Explainability of ChatGPT Prompts by Embedding Breast Cancer Self-Screening Rules into AI Responses
| 2024-04-21T09:20:16 | 2024-06-02T22:42:00 |
Yousef Khan, Ahmed Abdeen Hamed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2; I.2.1
|
Addressing the global challenge of breast cancer, this research explores the
fusion of generative AI, focusing on ChatGPT 3.5 turbo model, and the
intricacies of breast cancer risk assessment. The research aims to evaluate
ChatGPT's reasoning capabilities, emphasizing its potential to process rules
and provide explanations for screening recommendations. The study seeks to
bridge the technology gap between intelligent machines and clinicians by
demonstrating ChatGPT's unique proficiency in natural language reasoning. The
methodology employs a supervised prompt-engineering approach to enforce
detailed explanations for ChatGPT's recommendations. Synthetic use cases,
generated algorithmically, serve as the testing ground for the encoded rules,
evaluating the model's processing prowess. Findings highlight ChatGPT's
promising capacity in processing rules comparable to Expert System Shells, with
a focus on natural language reasoning. The research introduces the concept of
reinforcement explainability, showcasing its potential in elucidating outcomes
and facilitating user-friendly interfaces for breast cancer risk assessment.
|
[
-0.3743228614,
-0.9129810333,
0.7793566585,
0.2532814145,
-0.1378300041,
-0.0144981677,
0.2974242568,
-0.2456653118,
-0.1297715604,
0.4726911485,
-1.0471075773,
-0.3758963048,
-0.5511736274,
0.2080638558,
-0.4576085508,
1.1533933878,
-0.0523543879,
0.0471264459,
-0.1489298642,
0.3642657101,
-0.6443457603,
-0.1138092652,
-1.094132781,
-0.283421576,
0.6196651459,
0.4035987556,
0.7832565308,
0.6808909178,
0.3156798482,
0.2532098591,
0.1409875005,
0.1481312662,
-0.2443911731,
0.2171672732,
-0.0752520934,
-0.3158136904,
-0.1157691628,
-0.0006284458,
0.1929199845,
0.4832067192,
-0.1563214362,
-0.2003413886,
0.1766494364,
0.6553980112,
-0.2852248251,
0.4285447001,
-0.3256836534,
0.018323103,
0.2761817276,
-0.4580693841,
-0.3296501637,
-0.704590261,
0.1265199035,
-0.6359863281,
0.3072879314,
0.0682536736,
0.5949364901,
0.394318372,
-0.4608179927,
-0.3965576291,
-0.6839665771,
0.1030058712,
-0.5731250048,
-0.1839439124,
0.4563961923,
0.7436253428,
-0.4968091846,
-0.5356388688,
-0.3788490295,
-0.2822415233,
-0.1259486973,
0.1895057261,
-0.4524502754,
0.3865609765,
0.1739553064,
0.3706512451,
-0.9804961085,
0.1758805811,
-0.3936598599,
-0.5302986503,
0.5545770526,
0.1048619747,
0.6145278215,
-0.0859588236,
-0.1807938963,
0.1776884645,
-0.744730413,
0.2677530646,
0.2378601283,
0.2604032755,
-0.0070341858,
0.5595071316,
-0.4045965672,
0.6064566374,
-0.1255366057,
0.4792742133,
-0.2494432181,
-0.4430086017,
-0.1451717615,
0.3792975247,
0.8381640315,
0.416973412,
0.1528764516,
0.020031631,
0.4510326087,
0.0799940675,
0.4221795499,
-0.9277589917,
-0.3084101081,
0.4419735074,
-0.4263541102,
-0.1701285094,
-0.1593267918,
-0.6613100767,
-0.519656539,
0.1052959636,
0.8037595153,
-0.635597229,
-0.1689930707,
0.4411640465,
-0.2561632693,
0.1194574982,
0.211718291,
-0.8220402598,
0.1767711639,
0.7590278983,
0.7470522523,
0.1966492087,
-0.0327676833,
-0.368083179,
-0.0064346832,
-0.0524705388,
1.1003708839,
-0.4606330693,
-0.654306531,
-0.1618607193,
0.0653104112,
-0.3298429847,
-0.1078549102,
0.6694809198,
-0.1005222425,
0.492483139,
-0.2137567699,
-0.4885706306,
-0.4633972943,
0.24566257,
-0.3764438033,
0.6546429396,
0.0928530321,
-0.6825277209,
0.4589090943,
-0.9288887382,
-0.3887486756,
0.1639205217,
-0.0313480906,
-0.4314897358,
-0.3190056384,
0.5795365572,
0.4838139415,
-0.1076707318,
0.1050018892,
-0.4911665916,
-0.4749155045,
0.4189748466,
-0.6662866473,
0.7404686213,
0.3732042909,
-0.4239907563,
0.3455180824,
-0.4247106016,
-0.0886628702,
0.1656867415,
0.0997178555,
0.034109816,
0.1981759816,
-0.5657583475,
0.1796577275,
0.0017739428,
-0.4334415793,
0.3159318864,
-0.5646351576,
0.8401150703,
0.6103059053,
0.3007129133,
-0.0256208368,
-0.6001881361,
0.6556891203,
-0.2221673429,
0.4185425937,
-0.3992658257,
-0.8917477727,
-0.5056840777,
-0.3306882977,
-0.0219442956,
0.4447950423,
-0.6489847898,
0.0678681731,
0.129455328,
-0.4751626849,
-0.6335421801,
-0.2049087286,
0.4207292199,
0.6481574178,
0.3885252178,
-0.2232633531,
-0.5467076302,
-1.1803189516,
-0.2040017992,
-0.3825786412,
0.0895918384,
0.2208240777,
0.2204403132,
-0.1100457907,
1.0440386534,
-0.4208862484,
0.2482847869,
-0.3043717742,
0.4744205475,
0.2781303525,
0.4455648065,
0.1721009165,
-0.7445010543,
-0.1170786098,
-0.0535417311,
-0.5196400881,
-0.319444418,
-0.1383090317,
-0.2033386528,
-0.2815124393,
0.3604926467,
-0.6568635106,
0.7545138597,
0.3750286996,
-0.5108020902,
0.6193413734,
-0.5120084882,
0.3803004622,
-0.8397716284,
-0.3909894526,
0.1920304596,
-0.3423326015,
-0.4346833229,
-0.3423673213,
-0.4080170989,
-0.3165023625,
-0.0748248622,
0.5213127136,
-0.0081561403,
-0.1488397419,
-0.4267755449,
-0.1493466645,
0.0170272999,
0.2831399739,
-0.1363929361,
0.9141569734,
0.3986137509,
-0.9163498282,
0.2024894804,
0.1450912952,
-0.1827930063,
0.4910640419,
-0.8696065545,
-0.4207645059,
-0.0846313909,
0.5202720761,
-1.430388689,
-0.2217960656,
0.4510258138,
-0.6499618292,
-0.1207938194,
-0.311494112,
-0.1837087125,
-0.6490172744,
0.0499802008,
0.1127931699,
0.7389109731,
-0.3600228727,
0.3523856699,
0.2523521781,
-0.547074914,
-0.2685599625,
-0.4373117387,
-0.0875253305,
-0.3984094262,
-0.7008229494,
0.2599596381,
-0.3778989017,
-0.0179444384,
-0.0360024646,
0.0855501369,
-0.2320854515,
0.3584213853,
0.5848088861,
0.1344717592,
-0.0493922904,
0.2403734773,
0.1406683922,
-0.3690479696,
0.3326518834,
-0.2387105078,
0.349009186,
-0.210482493,
-0.7115559578,
-0.5412806869,
0.3317195475,
0.4426838756,
-0.0032051804,
0.4583358169,
0.855796814,
-0.1936045736,
-0.0087257847,
-0.3756048679,
-0.2758696675,
-0.4348737895,
0.0417282619,
-0.3143355548,
-1.1323919296,
0.4919638634,
0.1211608797,
-0.0903000981,
0.7250531912,
1.0209742785,
-0.1873955578,
1.631327033,
0.3484542072,
0.1689193547,
0.2636786103,
0.0828598067,
0.2318496704,
-0.3506968617,
-0.2888188362,
-0.4949823916,
0.0696021691,
-0.7910262942,
-0.2099467665,
0.6365793943,
-0.298171103,
-0.5911749601,
0.2837487459,
-0.8709154725,
0.1786894947,
0.7325485945,
0.4090841115,
0.2040887624,
-0.3746272922,
-0.2859348655,
0.2585857511,
-1.0322556496,
-0.3757936656,
0.7742949724,
0.4101379812,
0.475410521,
0.1018393189,
0.4132494032,
0.4611600339,
0.1574151218,
-0.5682619214,
0.4090550244,
0.1669539958,
-0.6869195104,
-0.2617169917,
-0.4572927952,
-1.1220639944,
0.0685950369,
-0.0733607337,
-0.832095027,
-0.1875619888,
0.2536518276,
-0.7642143369,
-0.0496715531,
-0.8957824111,
1.0834338665,
-0.1086839959,
-0.3374020159,
-0.2090302259,
-0.5439881086,
0.4958468378,
0.1928784102,
0.357524693,
-0.4432875216,
0.3531188369,
0.477660805,
-0.7552319765,
0.9480322003,
0.0069802892,
0.1172969937,
0.3984698653,
0.2461940497,
0.1708421707,
0.1813289225,
-0.0470845997,
-0.2381351292,
0.2734177411,
-0.5449739695,
-0.6538465619,
0.5409523845,
-0.4921713173,
-0.6129407883,
-0.290188849,
-0.4590604305,
-0.2104539573,
-0.0802981853,
0.1709048748,
0.1966544539,
-0.3103876114,
-0.1170560867,
0.5775083899,
-0.3765881956,
0.2274490893,
0.4840435088,
-0.1295524985,
0.139398545,
1.0002403259,
-0.1562836319,
0.0269305874,
0.3467139602,
0.5531369448,
-0.3960604072,
-0.482206136,
-0.4921904504,
-0.2046768367,
-0.4121618867,
0.1447850615,
-0.6706632972,
-0.3659625351,
-0.4306461215,
-0.164100036,
-0.1598946005,
-0.4689543545,
-0.0534534454,
-0.1462689489,
0.6901568174,
0.7197088599,
-0.2480903566,
0.3688919544,
-0.6643281579,
0.0982413962,
0.7253856659,
0.2110356838,
-0.3432719111,
-0.4710027277,
-0.0131644635,
0.077431269,
-0.1548899412,
-1.0139191151,
0.3887599111,
-0.0990017578,
0.7619083524,
0.4379214644,
-0.0193687025,
0.2792346776,
-0.2715747356,
0.7565315962,
-0.0094486577,
-0.7026965022,
0.8231873512,
-0.8436877131,
0.2610844672,
0.3292309344,
0.5453110337,
-0.5415010452,
-0.2566157281,
-0.8423802257,
-0.6115350723,
0.4737503529,
0.4606439769,
-0.1715949327,
-0.086992085,
0.3873979151,
0.3572354913,
-0.0095929932,
-0.4724080563,
0.1108826548,
-0.4410010874,
-0.3422248065,
0.0293442514,
-0.4425604045,
-0.3178212345,
0.0148882484,
0.8575691581,
-0.2002981454,
0.5713273883,
0.1618209183,
0.1247481927,
0.4433259964,
0.4664217532,
0.6654783487,
0.3632320464,
-0.3736189306,
0.112028636,
0.0376958773,
-0.1925025284,
0.0228519328,
0.5317069888,
0.0169338677,
-0.3102367222,
0.315585047,
0.6373749375,
0.2992059886,
-0.639049232,
0.3960452974,
-0.3190032542,
-0.3134958446,
-0.0248753689,
0.3351104558,
-0.0496499017,
0.1499034017,
0.0741778091,
-0.1920494884,
0.4942883849,
-0.433388561,
0.3119318783,
0.2999589443,
-0.8592502475,
0.0184963252,
0.6431614161,
0.1009410396,
-0.0466045812,
0.4612787068,
-0.2431804836,
-0.4487639964,
0.9207953215,
0.4403449893,
0.665630877,
-0.1731708199,
0.6165105104,
0.5072012544,
0.4043032527,
-0.0728720948,
0.1097698063,
0.0404540487,
-0.7332314253,
-0.5035582781,
-0.1206459254,
-0.809504509,
-0.2366572767,
-0.3140954375,
0.0212672818,
-0.48924613,
-0.0348481685,
0.3385939598,
-0.2443594187,
-0.3755934536,
0.253236115,
0.0252604466,
0.6127701402,
-0.7748557925,
0.2503555119,
0.3304112852,
-0.8455958962,
-0.9075821638,
-0.3088946342,
0.3450500667,
-1.3390653133,
0.4241259992,
0.4474761188,
0.097746335,
-0.1725188941,
-0.4753506482,
-0.6282648444,
0.906134963,
0.2943135798,
0.0025119323,
0.0116517758,
-0.0938954353,
0.3821677268,
-0.372878015,
0.9970383048,
0.595443368,
0.5702357292,
0.4116412699,
-0.7850131989,
0.0649105385,
-0.3228611648,
-0.1233346015,
-0.1666062027,
-0.3264265656,
0.6085634232,
-0.3261334598,
-0.1763501018,
0.0730257183,
0.4020255506,
0.3062276244,
0.4646478295,
0.3292448521,
0.3551009595,
0.6263937354,
-0.2859230638,
1.4212943316,
-0.1744091809,
0.0190554,
0.8524959683,
0.1049182937,
0.2813254297,
0.0499886908,
-0.2816648483,
0.8409189582,
1.2241401672,
0.1814596653,
0.2972186208,
0.2778981626,
-0.4074271023,
-0.4186588824,
-0.3035008609,
-0.3359929919,
0.3808248341,
0.5765455961,
-0.2810528874,
-0.4261636734,
0.199205488,
-0.0105290543,
-0.0767583176,
-0.4926270545,
0.7135222554,
-0.0911491662,
-0.6903451085,
0.1381031573,
-0.1296188682,
0.186945945,
-0.6658394933,
-0.221807465,
-0.0723878965,
0.0367250033,
-0.2434699833,
-0.8940445781,
0.2296872586,
-0.1342335045,
-0.1654997319,
-0.2391249388,
0.8463618159,
-0.1873384267,
-0.4868811667,
-0.1199560314,
0.4297499061,
0.4963966012,
-0.1704278737,
-1.0287492275,
-0.2139086276,
0.0057858634,
-0.0566824749,
0.2506284416,
0.413554132,
-0.0362475738,
1.1942155361,
0.7180487514,
-0.1584693044,
-0.2383693159,
-0.0850729123,
0.7412993312,
-0.5351296663,
-0.574834168,
-0.9611853361,
0.4188790321,
-0.0442964509,
-0.1659110039,
0.7653779984,
0.3392534852,
0.2136934847,
0.2872643769,
0.8892963529,
0.1428152472,
0.6504405141,
-0.7416573763,
0.6609202623,
-0.2156336606,
0.172355026,
-0.029241126,
-0.3461286724,
-0.1576246023,
0.7073684335,
-0.6630883813,
0.3721399307,
0.6633301973,
0.9659484029,
0.2788130343,
0.4003088772,
0.125922367,
0.3351533115,
0.4098575115,
0.7774943113,
0.7595816255,
-0.128822282,
0.7672259212,
0.0671859533,
-0.3866125643,
-0.5320802927,
-1.0382677317,
-0.6335496306,
-0.6140531898,
-0.4072037637,
-0.5807878375,
0.3878566921,
0.8224428892,
0.861201942,
-0.3916577995,
0.202150926,
-0.3370587528,
0.5163038969,
-0.3962183893,
-0.2692539096,
0.2696952522,
-0.2208091915,
-0.3328287601,
0.7525709867,
0.4196648598,
0.0506071076,
-0.4087766707,
-0.0591950081,
0.0277570579,
0.1118869111,
0.2924659848,
0.7666090727,
-0.4537840486,
-0.2329819202,
-0.3866974413,
-0.1063506752,
-0.0640495643,
0.7129426599,
-0.9581971169,
0.696786046,
0.3214630485,
0.701248765,
0.5183916092,
-0.1027978137,
1.006504178,
-0.07242167,
-0.2603209019,
0.134854883,
0.3214401603,
0.1998374164,
-0.6744406819,
0.5387422442,
0.1930538118,
-0.6638424993,
-0.3183236122,
0.3532452583,
-1.2090902328,
-0.3407774568,
1.1487907171,
-0.1239404231,
-0.2148227394,
-0.5206612945,
-0.530793488,
0.3582785726,
-0.5481464267,
0.8758339286,
0.6414493918,
-0.6133047342,
-0.48689273,
-0.7259085774,
0.7480702996,
0.3898694217,
-0.8774773479,
-0.0396083929,
0.3652074039,
0.2238568068,
-0.4156584144,
0.9662299752,
-0.1877033412,
0.5379753113,
-0.0710005611,
0.0432974957,
-0.388822794,
0.1897585839,
-0.2649323046,
0.0660992339,
-0.0399236977,
-0.0564237311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.15190v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.15190v1
|
Socratic Planner: Inquiry-Based Zero-Shot Planning for Embodied Instruction Following
| 2024-04-21T08:10:20 | 2024-04-21T08:10:20 |
Suyeon Shin, Sujin jeon, Junghyun Kim, Gi-Cheon Kang, Byoung-Tak Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.RO, 68T01 (Primary) 68T40, 68T50, 68T45 (Secondary)
|
Embodied Instruction Following (EIF) is the task of executing natural
language instructions by navigating and interacting with objects in 3D
environments. One of the primary challenges in EIF is compositional task
planning, which is often addressed with supervised or in-context learning with
labeled data. To this end, we introduce the Socratic Planner, the first
zero-shot planning method that infers without the need for any training data.
Socratic Planner first decomposes the instructions into substructural
information of the task through self-questioning and answering, translating it
into a high-level plan, i.e., a sequence of subgoals. Subgoals are executed
sequentially, with our visually grounded re-planning mechanism adjusting plans
dynamically through a dense visual feedback. We also introduce an evaluation
metric of high-level plans, RelaxedHLP, for a more comprehensive evaluation.
Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the Socratic Planner, achieving
competitive performance on both zero-shot and few-shot task planning in the
ALFRED benchmark, particularly excelling in tasks requiring higher-dimensional
inference. Additionally, a precise adjustments in the plan were achieved by
incorporating environmental visual information.
|
[
-0.2187736183,
-0.7660890818,
0.6237235069,
0.3295795023,
-0.1388220638,
-0.0669339523,
0.2784220874,
-0.4261694252,
0.4750367701,
0.4369011819,
-0.9069325328,
-0.8936614394,
-0.2816923857,
-0.1942670047,
-0.0863656253,
0.5739166737,
-0.1984477043,
-0.2965718508,
-0.1712259054,
0.1692820638,
-0.4754339457,
-0.2439413667,
-0.455645889,
-0.3127911091,
0.3977729976,
0.8457425237,
0.3360103965,
0.3956276178,
-0.0722925216,
0.1635301113,
0.1442737132,
0.207011655,
-0.7820363045,
0.3431625962,
0.0972429737,
-0.4567323923,
-0.3386547565,
-0.2307681441,
0.4276690185,
0.5986328125,
-0.0997383446,
0.2572066784,
-0.2123430073,
0.5554139614,
-1.2533131838,
0.4441987872,
-0.0627048016,
0.6060121059,
0.4188592732,
-0.3239810169,
-0.4126832187,
-0.1135126874,
0.0579659194,
-0.5939481854,
0.2766096592,
-0.1774642617,
0.134846881,
0.3693476617,
-0.2092218101,
0.1230086684,
-1.0116285086,
0.599597156,
-0.303381741,
0.341685921,
0.4861880243,
0.254460752,
-0.2825316489,
-0.315302819,
-0.4105639756,
0.0366655029,
0.0375464037,
0.4869228601,
0.0430698097,
0.4726462066,
0.4057842195,
-0.1351536512,
-0.840839684,
-0.1402069926,
-0.4824986458,
0.0163362008,
0.7986367941,
0.3539562821,
0.1248122454,
-0.0184471626,
-0.4428004324,
-0.0255139694,
-0.8313202262,
0.1876206994,
-0.0940372869,
-0.1203740016,
-0.3446953893,
0.7474714518,
-0.7492260337,
0.7241147757,
0.0108902995,
-0.1039068252,
-0.3069132268,
-0.2092126012,
-0.3291462064,
0.3332777917,
0.3270242214,
0.5378884673,
-0.0165588614,
-0.3516362309,
-0.237888813,
-0.1475769728,
0.3098053634,
-0.9257158041,
-0.2128262669,
0.2785106003,
0.0858475715,
-0.1073989272,
-0.4815723896,
-0.7487644553,
-0.0499670878,
-0.3666621447,
0.5936220884,
-0.4525651038,
0.1488773376,
0.252356261,
-0.082090877,
0.648658812,
0.7501687407,
-0.9454457164,
0.2860999703,
0.6548880935,
0.8896455765,
0.562961936,
-0.3669052422,
-0.501778543,
0.7541737556,
-0.5030475855,
1.168751955,
-0.4183671474,
-0.8409448862,
0.0741715282,
-0.2265696675,
0.0417167731,
-0.0554816239,
0.2579674125,
-0.0027710896,
0.0428800844,
-0.454321295,
-0.3174453378,
-0.2352052629,
0.4598107934,
-0.2430857867,
1.0466892719,
0.1993451118,
-0.4496099949,
0.5457107425,
-0.5612456799,
-0.5573554635,
0.2867895961,
-0.7723733187,
0.0645264089,
-0.0373102017,
0.222659409,
0.4455675185,
-0.017056888,
-0.165745765,
-0.1738482565,
-0.7901830077,
-0.5711138844,
0.0842933133,
0.6934709549,
-0.3514860272,
-0.8124964237,
0.240259707,
-0.6495192647,
0.2274492681,
0.1264506578,
-0.0610952936,
0.0502278283,
0.1400401443,
-0.3681076467,
0.1188351512,
0.0343033336,
-0.7905170321,
0.3123803139,
-0.4187155962,
0.01954633,
0.8922694921,
0.2715677917,
0.6940031648,
-0.5308870077,
0.8288425803,
-0.5824015737,
0.4549311697,
-0.2427176982,
-0.523684442,
-0.7287192345,
-0.1753266901,
-0.520067513,
0.455029577,
-0.9121163487,
0.0219783001,
-0.0219471622,
-0.826307714,
-0.0239152368,
-0.3432660401,
0.5725281835,
0.4279190302,
0.2545946836,
-0.1269710213,
-0.1820674837,
-0.7644971013,
0.2594466805,
-0.3942748308,
0.1652023643,
0.1778686494,
0.5056699514,
0.1683062017,
0.7100816965,
-0.9804762602,
-0.1570248753,
-0.1989265084,
0.6631922126,
-0.1936985552,
0.3739614487,
0.7772826552,
-0.3633574545,
-0.6427375078,
-0.2307841927,
-0.5853872895,
-0.1178273037,
-0.314299643,
-0.6159097552,
-0.1473103166,
0.2801026106,
-0.6195809841,
0.9492141008,
0.1245267391,
-0.1684167236,
0.8081794977,
-0.0632736012,
0.0408221856,
-0.7151799202,
0.0136544211,
-0.1111914366,
-0.0842302367,
-0.7547030449,
0.3723191917,
-0.1565483361,
-0.3080687225,
-0.4779538512,
0.5461540818,
-0.6851417422,
-0.2534411252,
-0.3390755355,
-0.0867753848,
0.0196203496,
0.9552006721,
0.3024627268,
0.6072663665,
0.5062775016,
-0.6852716208,
0.3307659328,
0.4612380862,
-0.1213703379,
0.6765576005,
-0.813993752,
0.4925753474,
-0.5656805038,
0.375454843,
-0.8853294253,
-0.0446914472,
0.5434360504,
-0.3891341984,
0.3497534096,
-0.2252653092,
-0.1059631109,
-0.0467027761,
-0.5505122542,
0.2612128854,
0.0523044653,
-0.1243320107,
0.8004270792,
0.2107622325,
-0.0823870525,
-0.7566993833,
-0.4948094785,
-0.2117728293,
0.4451885223,
-0.5141096711,
0.5003994703,
-0.1753078401,
0.01377906,
-0.1334780604,
-0.4149596691,
-0.0255327411,
-0.142664358,
0.661451757,
0.2518687248,
-0.0418694094,
-0.2517214417,
0.1860724539,
-0.1887443364,
0.27063936,
0.1637317091,
0.4852063358,
0.2443748862,
-0.4895584285,
-0.5494561791,
0.6256763935,
0.4513533115,
-0.1901583374,
0.5964591503,
0.2976037264,
-0.622081697,
-0.3130815923,
-0.20176588,
-0.1277893037,
-0.3711667061,
0.0163712818,
-0.3943945765,
-0.5666536093,
0.0874028504,
0.0117773991,
0.5871590972,
-0.1544178128,
0.1796751916,
0.0209810864,
1.0053058863,
0.9913900495,
0.4031452239,
0.4693136513,
-0.8003624082,
0.2106036842,
-0.8663853407,
-0.6508706808,
-0.5044241548,
-0.694571197,
-0.0405763872,
-0.6700628996,
0.4116517007,
-0.0617395043,
-0.3866104186,
0.4732044339,
-0.4675129652,
0.4101356268,
0.6440755129,
0.2194630206,
0.011570693,
-0.2837819159,
-0.158634603,
0.214644596,
-0.6631274819,
-0.337105006,
0.8900844455,
-0.2747248709,
0.7763330936,
0.0390033387,
1.1764963865,
-0.0732908174,
0.2910164595,
-1.0432727337,
0.9101564884,
0.4682824612,
-0.5521455407,
-0.5486454964,
-0.0233618002,
-0.5231123567,
0.3009046316,
-0.5391017795,
-1.0118401051,
0.7785114646,
0.0752490759,
-0.7189970016,
-0.0121026635,
-0.8584678769,
0.73738271,
-0.4272724688,
-0.6634976268,
-0.2241176367,
-0.5906363726,
0.0660573319,
0.2383324951,
-0.3229837418,
-0.2418903261,
-0.0973862112,
0.4720309079,
-0.1510826349,
0.8895111084,
-0.4365814626,
0.3279921412,
0.2831352055,
0.4017654061,
0.4391341507,
-0.0396143571,
0.0165857822,
-0.271677047,
0.3698973954,
-0.7105230689,
-0.6710801125,
0.4496938586,
-0.648732245,
-0.6370109916,
-0.5828588009,
-0.3751187623,
-0.2577767074,
0.2708973289,
0.2132613063,
0.4767744243,
-0.7071224451,
0.1381020993,
0.3880268633,
-0.2887084782,
0.3464365602,
0.7609876394,
-0.1905278563,
-0.1049122065,
0.4303657413,
0.2874740958,
0.2577470541,
0.7771267891,
-0.0272205826,
-0.1070111841,
-0.4724182189,
-0.53504318,
0.0418456942,
-0.549525857,
-0.2160439342,
-0.6766000986,
-0.1522213817,
-0.5546293259,
-0.6683415174,
-0.2377156019,
-0.2670513391,
-0.0741504431,
-0.2046367526,
-0.2655262053,
0.7646073699,
-0.169814229,
0.288056314,
-0.5516422987,
0.3230281472,
0.4426043928,
-0.0116074951,
-0.0726860464,
0.121635966,
-0.1509549469,
0.2251201719,
-0.4027048945,
-1.2213153839,
0.3409705162,
0.2224722207,
0.6632236242,
0.6241767406,
0.4317348599,
0.9843465686,
-0.3667596579,
0.5899047256,
0.1200038269,
-0.4977916777,
0.8192365766,
-0.1493659616,
0.6196693778,
0.5555528998,
0.7252480984,
-0.4707714915,
-0.2060223967,
-0.5062589049,
-0.6931616664,
0.8744657636,
0.0954331681,
0.0628034696,
-0.0525839403,
0.4748319685,
-0.0402727388,
0.1864152104,
-0.3696886599,
-0.006140362,
-0.1499240994,
0.3261860311,
0.0290828981,
-0.2490350604,
-0.2506754994,
-0.4030324817,
0.5420439839,
-0.3801005483,
0.5792350173,
0.4939977527,
0.0127220806,
-0.3733071089,
0.1857946068,
0.7714370489,
0.7760127187,
-0.4013035893,
0.1026026234,
0.1286470294,
-0.4489837587,
0.1079196259,
-0.1278736293,
-0.5076698065,
-0.2024911791,
0.2982992232,
0.5546788573,
0.6807528734,
-0.6461556554,
0.4107936621,
-0.0541506782,
-0.4400934577,
-0.4286939204,
0.3179672062,
-0.1717573255,
0.2958043218,
0.1972729117,
-0.2330167592,
0.3467117846,
-0.8131315112,
-0.066892013,
0.2526398003,
-0.5669074655,
-0.4190476239,
0.467853874,
0.1069647372,
-0.2692303956,
0.4318271875,
-0.2224119604,
-0.4656386971,
0.6513010263,
0.6799833775,
0.9454440475,
-0.275780648,
0.9832987189,
0.5816068649,
0.5586403012,
0.2343925387,
0.8081328273,
-0.5786544681,
-0.5877150893,
-0.4060405493,
-0.4154308438,
-0.6116791964,
-0.2662056088,
-0.4933906794,
0.3029935062,
-1.0307574272,
0.2491308302,
-0.0590695962,
-0.0009632924,
-0.599840343,
0.15803729,
0.104819037,
0.7491919398,
-0.7355723381,
0.2610208988,
0.9107448459,
-0.5144319534,
-0.7951393723,
0.0991791785,
0.2863874435,
-0.9568475485,
0.4915710688,
0.2113099396,
-0.7470902801,
-0.0386666916,
-0.8493224978,
-0.6495373845,
1.3201750517,
0.509023726,
-0.2877411842,
-0.3766056597,
0.013023315,
0.3869197369,
-0.2259355783,
0.2504608333,
0.1240136772,
0.2818908691,
0.7846669555,
-0.4070762992,
0.0408063941,
-0.2221733779,
-0.307233125,
0.4697445333,
-0.754381299,
0.4022992551,
-0.4635239244,
-0.5958005786,
0.0465566739,
0.5887905955,
0.0141869821,
0.5507571697,
0.2315364927,
0.68751508,
0.3911366761,
0.1154389828,
0.7251072526,
-0.3118496835,
0.0011118824,
1.4256899357,
-0.4997614026,
0.9996632338,
0.1937903017,
0.1551488936,
0.4409765899,
0.4675281346,
0.4014891386,
0.6116213202,
-0.1083667353,
-0.6181831956,
-0.2100160122,
-0.1930718869,
-0.2046217173,
0.7868551612,
0.231473282,
0.1681011766,
-0.4050478935,
-0.2495179623,
-0.1801945567,
-0.1527582854,
-0.2535292804,
0.757760942,
-0.123291716,
-0.7219272852,
0.3786390126,
-0.0335375927,
0.0139981816,
-0.3617889881,
-0.5068628192,
-0.2628650069,
-0.2412441671,
-0.3242055774,
-0.8213924766,
0.3026722074,
-0.21506235,
0.3583695292,
-0.397006005,
0.8062824607,
-0.104703702,
-0.0685831979,
0.147230953,
0.4764837921,
0.1077199876,
-0.1381580085,
-0.5994469523,
-0.4333040714,
-0.1465800256,
0.0032034277,
0.117047824,
0.3644710779,
0.1103323549,
0.5474935174,
0.4839780927,
-0.2350212187,
0.0298146904,
-0.220590502,
0.9054321051,
-0.7450186014,
-0.6070089936,
-0.3210693896,
0.4039772153,
-0.0642667189,
-0.2860899568,
0.2889851928,
0.7277257442,
0.9292650223,
0.0655579939,
0.3196264505,
-0.0849929973,
-0.065033339,
-0.3752431273,
0.3403218389,
-0.3768430352,
-0.0632980615,
-0.1288823187,
-1.1369098425,
-0.0831375271,
0.8514569402,
-0.6342080235,
-0.1254147738,
0.5397162437,
0.88717556,
0.1664592922,
0.2072360218,
0.5239602327,
-0.1374192536,
0.256201148,
0.7712878585,
0.6866534352,
0.0097341277,
0.143392846,
-0.6919701695,
-0.516793251,
-0.2765034437,
-0.4961182475,
-0.8213456273,
-0.3681094348,
-0.1554245055,
0.1784754992,
0.3236403465,
1.0526161194,
0.9057732224,
-0.1982461363,
-0.3087719083,
-0.1703416407,
-0.0105273193,
-0.243386656,
-0.194138974,
0.0275648683,
0.1411838979,
-0.5120285749,
0.5694292784,
0.8284289837,
0.0848769471,
-0.4013793766,
-0.12638475,
-0.3925782442,
0.070886828,
0.8430042267,
0.6884282231,
-0.2615038753,
-0.5157874227,
0.3279901743,
0.0152793257,
-0.1895920038,
0.7556801438,
-0.7343456745,
0.8724897504,
0.6016668677,
0.2629353106,
1.1515886784,
-0.1466293335,
0.7455258965,
-0.6493511796,
0.2972774804,
0.5575678945,
0.0337767825,
-0.1417661756,
-0.5133895278,
0.694966197,
-0.084559679,
-0.5388367772,
-0.4158536792,
0.305400759,
-1.0840876102,
-0.0781930238,
0.770413518,
-0.1958227754,
-0.4296029508,
-0.0606197901,
-0.5428228974,
0.2069437951,
-0.1719667763,
0.8611880541,
0.4494692087,
-0.6874631643,
-0.5491019487,
-0.6040523052,
0.1940183043,
0.2167443335,
-0.8013817668,
-0.3269912899,
0.9546301961,
-0.1998679489,
0.0447617024,
1.1734149456,
0.1337691694,
0.5609090924,
0.3098242283,
0.1992581189,
0.0466208123,
-0.6380763054,
0.3311594427,
0.1072835624,
-0.0372792743,
-0.2648422122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13565v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13565v2
|
Exploring Diverse Methods in Visual Question Answering
| 2024-04-21T07:34:44 | 2024-05-21T02:38:35 |
Panfeng Li, Qikai Yang, Xieming Geng, Wenjing Zhou, Zhicheng Ding, Yi Nian
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This study explores innovative methods for improving Visual Question
Answering (VQA) using Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), autoencoders, and
attention mechanisms. Leveraging a balanced VQA dataset, we investigate three
distinct strategies. Firstly, GAN-based approaches aim to generate answer
embeddings conditioned on image and question inputs, showing potential but
struggling with more complex tasks. Secondly, autoencoder-based techniques
focus on learning optimal embeddings for questions and images, achieving
comparable results with GAN due to better ability on complex questions. Lastly,
attention mechanisms, incorporating Multimodal Compact Bilinear pooling (MCB),
address language priors and attention modeling, albeit with a
complexity-performance trade-off. This study underscores the challenges and
opportunities in VQA and suggests avenues for future research, including
alternative GAN formulations and attentional mechanisms.
|
[
-0.8169158101,
-1.223107338,
0.3696410954,
-0.0825446099,
-0.1807174087,
0.2332970351,
0.1935967207,
-0.216180414,
-0.0345836394,
0.3898638487,
-0.6406111121,
0.0348454006,
-0.4077520072,
-0.0055733062,
-0.1611716151,
0.5397645235,
-0.1578456163,
0.4214556217,
-0.5816777945,
-0.4618106186,
-0.6068459749,
-0.3398588598,
-0.7474324703,
0.2098082751,
0.7609248161,
0.2051562369,
0.7923959494,
0.4360960424,
0.6245364547,
0.3072823882,
-0.0842629448,
0.206048578,
-0.4517937303,
-0.0007146263,
-0.0255274065,
-0.772156775,
0.0255910773,
-0.288128525,
0.1314380765,
0.4929464161,
-0.1672336459,
0.3767726719,
-0.1553554088,
0.4627653658,
-0.9223489165,
-0.1991508305,
-0.4287809134,
0.2447057515,
0.0092656119,
-0.3856260478,
0.1650939733,
-0.1529857665,
0.3421783447,
-0.6155828238,
0.4279833734,
-0.0046797255,
0.8817180395,
0.6879911423,
-0.3280367255,
-0.1299103051,
-0.4586675465,
0.3761848211,
-0.2731271386,
0.0929013416,
-0.0239032488,
0.8118953705,
0.3283905685,
-0.8853476644,
-0.6489021182,
0.3981557786,
0.1179974005,
0.5768144131,
-0.3129795492,
0.0435124524,
0.3871606886,
0.711630404,
-0.8725234866,
-0.352394253,
-0.5156743526,
0.1387288123,
0.3908147514,
0.263159126,
0.5656557083,
-0.261030525,
-0.5455164909,
-0.3815710843,
-0.4817588627,
0.6088598371,
0.0641811118,
-0.343667984,
0.0912692547,
0.9180423021,
-0.4706200659,
0.7764322758,
0.0696818233,
0.6938390136,
-0.1258360893,
-0.5385870337,
-0.4787507653,
-0.5036931038,
0.5497707129,
0.6624304652,
0.3077227771,
-0.0553986542,
0.0815082043,
-0.0369803309,
0.4644954205,
-0.466671735,
-0.5019688606,
0.0875393674,
-0.262557596,
-0.1114111394,
0.02549126,
-0.9401223063,
-0.1213148758,
-0.2960580885,
0.9139666557,
-0.2477867603,
0.0789644197,
0.0647916421,
-0.5332015157,
1.0811953545,
0.5540687442,
-0.7301219702,
0.1116021127,
0.0991972089,
0.4231871665,
0.1643225998,
-0.0392391682,
-0.7941763401,
-0.0783975199,
-0.4245004654,
0.6065753102,
-0.2056113482,
0.0635591745,
0.0101174535,
0.0602283739,
-0.1905687898,
-0.5537812114,
0.0613443442,
-0.9587709308,
0.4615399539,
-0.8290885091,
-0.1358543187,
-0.4561062455,
0.4574333429,
-0.8348401189,
0.7543199062,
0.166241765,
-0.7166690826,
0.1002237722,
-0.5007380247,
-0.1533160955,
0.1883628964,
-0.4186773002,
-0.2452031821,
0.1873640716,
0.9516634941,
0.2832084,
-0.3134357929,
-0.159373492,
-0.283520788,
-0.3031954467,
0.3492195606,
-0.4776369333,
0.7881786823,
0.2595853209,
-0.501244545,
0.2285056263,
-0.3384976685,
0.303894788,
0.4800359011,
0.1085777059,
-0.1015794575,
-0.3791021705,
-0.1308184862,
0.2430134565,
0.0705390275,
-0.3892958164,
0.0301130079,
-0.1145438924,
0.4176166058,
0.4988456368,
0.305764854,
0.2048753947,
-0.2258188277,
1.0536785126,
0.0520050414,
0.4418568909,
-0.0743912011,
-0.5007798076,
-1.0478346348,
0.0298527181,
0.1756280363,
0.8364697099,
-1.4912384748,
-0.4848607779,
0.0328120068,
-0.002647826,
-0.8515044451,
0.2392091453,
0.5867712498,
0.3994222879,
0.5424889922,
-0.5156942606,
-0.2916451991,
-0.9177655578,
-0.0432453565,
-0.1379869878,
0.1852058917,
0.4403473139,
0.4083838165,
0.2653314769,
0.7468804121,
-0.8151816726,
0.2148149312,
-0.169847697,
0.2092312425,
-0.3805282712,
0.0012401731,
0.852686286,
-1.2474076748,
-0.3820186555,
-0.326312989,
-1.018553257,
0.389831543,
-0.1999919713,
-0.1498569995,
-0.2433793098,
0.7469664216,
-0.4182914495,
0.6897289753,
0.1427875459,
0.0138916783,
0.143391028,
-0.0141619844,
0.4923322201,
-0.6867559552,
-0.1479581743,
-0.0578630641,
-0.2315144837,
-0.5698161125,
0.373960197,
0.0210132673,
-0.2493979931,
-0.6975931525,
0.4873785377,
-0.6924418211,
-0.0985008925,
-0.0208425168,
0.0531595908,
0.1695492566,
0.7969532013,
-0.0778645352,
0.9030798674,
0.6890004873,
-0.3562047184,
0.9498896599,
0.5208575726,
-0.1476281881,
0.567499578,
-1.1381146908,
0.1987244636,
-0.8706236482,
-0.3406794667,
-1.7326748371,
-0.269454807,
0.4693187773,
-0.5993747711,
0.4055816233,
-0.1319854259,
-0.2049544007,
-0.6578451395,
-0.3867483139,
0.6377372146,
0.3502399623,
-0.5504297614,
0.5853508115,
0.008611748,
-0.4173972607,
-0.7077813148,
-0.8753393888,
0.2582401931,
-0.2327468097,
-0.7047189474,
0.0222647674,
-0.2809248269,
-0.1072710976,
0.2678759992,
0.0879644677,
-0.1352619976,
0.0832046345,
-0.1673916429,
0.30503878,
-0.3704748452,
-0.1350373626,
-0.2058778703,
0.2764514387,
0.0942512751,
0.0302906781,
0.2310911566,
-0.2692498267,
-0.3505992889,
-0.0287939701,
0.8534812331,
0.7265176177,
-0.8480502963,
0.4538465142,
0.8238924742,
-0.1565041095,
-0.0401194394,
-0.5449187756,
-0.0384360366,
-0.3955171704,
0.4260234237,
-0.4279802442,
-0.8243187666,
0.4953218102,
0.4267267287,
-0.0397080854,
0.0601232946,
0.6846202612,
-0.4747719169,
0.91526407,
0.5548018813,
0.3227631748,
0.5139882565,
-0.3128139377,
0.1283729821,
-0.9842279553,
-0.281165868,
0.1022204235,
-0.302059114,
-0.3557596803,
-0.6732928753,
0.5712072849,
0.2525754869,
-0.0274844747,
0.0688886791,
-0.4446782768,
0.3495632708,
0.7632123828,
0.2496675253,
-0.1000712514,
0.0562767051,
0.1480719,
0.0755770877,
-1.1318035126,
-0.0190994348,
1.0097335577,
0.1040601358,
0.7448311448,
0.2226736844,
0.2153716087,
-0.133920297,
0.2299859971,
-0.47511217,
0.4045322835,
-0.0163073093,
-0.7496033311,
-0.5489879251,
-0.2598737776,
-0.7447475791,
0.4134970605,
-0.2242786288,
-0.2604714036,
0.4001692533,
0.1895359457,
-0.7143668532,
0.0358774811,
-0.7572411895,
1.1369155645,
-0.4774912,
-0.6335962415,
0.3680091798,
-0.9637019634,
0.3440285623,
0.7392498255,
-0.2618521154,
0.4915924072,
0.0438556783,
0.2804032266,
-0.1287942231,
0.5783568025,
-0.027717106,
0.1222352758,
0.6258077621,
-0.3923894763,
0.1520303488,
0.2133806646,
0.5685175061,
-0.3353167772,
-0.1235593557,
-0.8039482832,
-1.0079878569,
0.3720084131,
-0.7111734748,
-0.7244386673,
-0.2291629016,
-0.3901070058,
-0.4689048827,
-0.1900797486,
0.558455646,
0.6098372936,
-0.1045994535,
0.3341094553,
1.2236346006,
-0.3184957504,
0.6793510318,
-0.0501984321,
0.0542702787,
-0.8995336294,
0.5954607129,
0.0497806445,
0.4843938053,
0.4607434869,
-0.230607301,
-0.4708999991,
-0.4775811732,
-1.1180435419,
0.1252408773,
-0.9162399173,
-0.0851179361,
-0.668218255,
-0.3269061446,
-0.367467016,
0.0452541001,
-0.0273560248,
-0.2058987021,
-0.2152498066,
-0.2106606215,
0.3397639394,
0.1574842036,
0.2690832615,
0.0268045813,
-0.4921755493,
1.0355005264,
1.3306322098,
0.0845129564,
-0.0460546538,
-0.1623641998,
0.0687040836,
0.1286800802,
-0.1930812001,
-1.101393342,
0.0436093919,
0.083133094,
0.7289598584,
-0.0932760164,
0.0384058617,
0.9569358826,
-0.2714824677,
0.8245544434,
0.2576742172,
-0.5463830233,
0.4812936783,
-0.3914529979,
0.4767061174,
0.6033643484,
0.4145961106,
-0.3856674731,
-0.0768327266,
-0.3680720031,
-0.8327370882,
0.2089229673,
0.5131220222,
0.1964490265,
0.0744900852,
0.3349017203,
-0.3444800377,
0.6087985635,
-0.573892355,
-0.4844692349,
-0.6274753809,
-0.2435796857,
-0.0444091298,
0.0377401449,
-0.3938674629,
-0.2212990522,
0.2157660425,
-0.2710905373,
0.2371734679,
0.6674852967,
-0.211976856,
-0.0756217614,
0.1196798384,
0.4338335395,
0.6463729143,
0.0831594542,
0.0248433445,
0.2558816969,
-0.1564798653,
0.0418277495,
0.1332470477,
-0.44142735,
-0.1560981721,
0.1914952099,
1.0198298693,
-0.3092059195,
-0.6553035975,
0.6737751365,
-0.5515030622,
-0.301587522,
-0.2215950191,
0.1686196923,
0.2292035371,
0.3524656296,
0.2223986536,
-0.0394199342,
0.328512758,
-0.7970556021,
0.1770954877,
0.5054342747,
-0.7417507768,
0.1324568391,
0.8906981945,
-0.0224475637,
0.0689016357,
0.429472208,
0.1075528115,
-0.4849623144,
0.8535954952,
-0.0470298901,
0.701879859,
-0.1439662576,
0.4874841869,
0.2076360732,
0.4580380917,
0.3759106696,
0.7788392901,
-0.1525052786,
-0.2949672043,
-0.3936846554,
-0.1169397533,
-0.3054978251,
0.188997373,
-0.8921717405,
-0.1671856493,
-0.2519508004,
0.0738450065,
0.0521093421,
-0.2014142573,
-0.9124106169,
0.6565101743,
0.3926402628,
0.4534781575,
-0.7322220206,
0.1064208001,
1.1430902481,
-0.7280091643,
-0.598870337,
-0.025488507,
-0.0797575191,
-0.6264109015,
0.39869681,
-0.1288392842,
-0.1869600564,
0.1636486948,
-0.9305707812,
-0.911730051,
0.9820033312,
0.1714304835,
-0.1095790789,
-0.0837370306,
-0.0432031564,
0.4561913311,
-0.0868900344,
0.3526203036,
0.0243574418,
0.2318479568,
0.4785978496,
-0.3165802956,
-0.1449914575,
-0.7442914844,
0.3523204625,
-0.1118615717,
-0.8424052,
0.7049258351,
-0.3927450478,
-0.2772522867,
0.2858877182,
0.853456974,
-0.0377357267,
0.266030848,
0.4081241786,
0.6053414345,
0.5128506422,
-0.0974615589,
1.0366146564,
0.2318495512,
0.0664730743,
0.9638989568,
0.0557892546,
0.4675340652,
0.6237261295,
-0.0786060691,
0.1743500829,
0.7153216004,
-0.1197437122,
0.6772347093,
0.4620948732,
-0.1217331737,
-0.5215697885,
0.0666777268,
-0.3536666632,
0.2587397397,
0.0041404832,
0.0187103953,
-0.2762730122,
0.439273864,
-0.5529351234,
0.0780762881,
-0.2963998318,
0.9219303131,
-0.0717264265,
-0.8171728253,
0.6418094635,
-0.3981954157,
0.1499683559,
-0.3263105154,
-0.1700288504,
-0.3011165857,
-0.1801026464,
0.2504314482,
-0.9452731013,
0.0556806438,
-0.0358878896,
-0.2982124984,
-0.0431391895,
0.3496716022,
-0.6187847853,
-0.4634363949,
-0.0923341364,
0.7254720926,
-0.3409702778,
-0.0564274453,
-0.7602006793,
-0.3713779747,
-0.0566226207,
-0.3225306273,
-0.012224189,
0.7745465636,
-0.0392984711,
0.6990466118,
0.4279617071,
-0.3646790981,
0.6218888164,
0.0307846367,
0.9256381989,
-0.5821697116,
-0.3569775522,
-0.3828252256,
0.8510875106,
-0.3287168443,
-0.5618456602,
0.7777634263,
0.2014720738,
0.7583931088,
-0.3516676426,
0.6865938306,
0.0503019914,
0.0545142032,
-0.6222919822,
0.3625388741,
-0.9467182159,
-0.0310075711,
-0.2923911214,
-0.6926143169,
-0.2433891743,
0.3532964587,
-0.153653577,
-0.0348203629,
0.5869107246,
0.6703725457,
0.0782384351,
-0.1238596514,
0.2717059851,
-0.1938312948,
0.1513721347,
0.8214153051,
1.1686652899,
-0.6916653514,
0.7071564198,
-0.3302036226,
-0.1394220591,
-0.2093474418,
-0.2254901528,
-0.9465739131,
-0.481494993,
-0.4986694157,
0.0019286454,
0.1909065098,
0.0441428646,
0.6257778406,
-0.5191486478,
0.2676901221,
-0.1342144161,
-0.0877118856,
-0.356964618,
-0.1847674847,
0.3071843684,
-0.2109563202,
-0.5969364643,
-0.08371187,
0.3441641927,
0.3234317303,
-0.2511657178,
0.3899072707,
-0.2852763236,
0.1173666343,
0.5733293891,
0.453312993,
-0.669267714,
-0.2267698795,
0.6567391753,
-0.222199291,
0.1416253895,
0.5141913295,
-0.5712576509,
0.719699204,
0.9385265112,
1.0060319901,
0.6804147959,
0.556445241,
0.6902586222,
-0.384559989,
-0.3348899484,
0.3269609809,
0.2163353562,
0.5312457085,
-0.3208689392,
0.4141572118,
0.0474480055,
-0.1210349351,
-0.3480780423,
0.4147540927,
-1.1772398949,
-0.4107185006,
0.7516252398,
-0.0814421102,
-0.4816069901,
-0.2069163769,
-0.480687499,
0.0618023016,
0.3826948106,
0.3135960996,
0.7209061384,
-0.2257829607,
-0.8396623135,
-0.777964592,
0.4343181849,
0.7764024734,
-0.8563065529,
-0.1701702029,
0.4906760156,
0.1978493333,
-0.0405638143,
0.4047991633,
-0.2121737003,
0.8629745841,
-0.1524627507,
-0.0245138425,
-0.0950579271,
-0.4603565633,
-0.4134246409,
0.4519105852,
-0.3009333909,
-0.5396879315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13556v1
|
ChatRetriever: Adapting Large Language Models for Generalized and Robust Conversational Dense Retrieval
| 2024-04-21T07:03:55 | 2024-04-21T07:03:55 |
Kelong Mao, Chenlong Deng, Haonan Chen, Fengran Mo, Zheng Liu, Tetsuya Sakai, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Conversational search requires accurate interpretation of user intent from
complex multi-turn contexts. This paper presents ChatRetriever, which inherits
the strong generalization capability of large language models to robustly
represent complex conversational sessions for dense retrieval. To achieve this,
we propose a simple and effective dual-learning approach that adapts LLM for
retrieval via contrastive learning while enhancing the complex session
understanding through masked instruction tuning on high-quality conversational
instruction tuning data. Extensive experiments on five conversational search
benchmarks demonstrate that ChatRetriever substantially outperforms existing
conversational dense retrievers, achieving state-of-the-art performance on par
with LLM-based rewriting approaches. Furthermore, ChatRetriever exhibits
superior robustness in handling diverse conversational contexts. Our work
highlights the potential of adapting LLMs for retrieval with complex inputs
like conversational search sessions and proposes an effective approach to
advance this research direction.
|
[
-0.0610129349,
-0.9916610718,
0.3881020546,
0.1493344009,
-0.1411215365,
0.4983492792,
-0.6758181453,
-0.2446466833,
0.1120819077,
0.4967934787,
-0.4492355287,
-0.5482767224,
-0.3828576505,
-0.3247588873,
-0.2192816883,
0.7398370504,
0.3180174232,
0.2589887381,
-0.0902527645,
-0.1275820285,
-0.6462835073,
-0.6110291481,
-0.851377964,
-0.3408943713,
0.3937099278,
0.7178428173,
0.8738821149,
-0.1159959882,
0.5433913469,
0.3917949498,
0.0610105842,
0.4555141032,
-1.2811460495,
0.7529871464,
-0.3640222549,
-0.5033630729,
-0.2086697221,
-0.4657626152,
0.7147741318,
0.5983529091,
-0.6108826399,
-0.3658912778,
0.1740934253,
0.4943036437,
-0.6472982168,
0.1046763584,
-1.0438395739,
-0.0451147854,
0.2155069262,
-0.4237147272,
-0.7216693163,
-0.1795548052,
0.2807201147,
-0.4946096838,
0.6731582284,
0.2331046015,
0.6089941263,
0.0626261011,
-0.5419957042,
-0.4070015252,
-0.9347625375,
1.0737119913,
-0.3595895171,
0.5378473997,
0.2172614932,
0.8199433088,
-0.4494819641,
-0.9425451756,
-0.1063738689,
-0.133886978,
-0.2465164214,
0.1576470137,
-0.3282906115,
0.3669866621,
-0.1081756204,
0.5835955143,
-0.6559904814,
0.0633652732,
-0.1542773247,
-0.2366312295,
0.5787459612,
0.3493382037,
0.4197434485,
0.3051744401,
-0.2809044123,
-0.2182772011,
-0.3825547993,
-0.093178533,
0.0521961525,
0.3765230775,
-0.1375770271,
0.278804332,
-0.2385843843,
0.5028985143,
0.136632815,
-0.0434297808,
0.0752201676,
-0.4313489199,
-0.1995483339,
-0.0470255502,
0.5969027281,
0.2803986073,
0.1212996617,
-0.410548389,
-0.2351384014,
-0.4658147693,
0.3484707773,
-1.0752931833,
-0.3286817372,
0.0197747815,
-0.2901520133,
-0.1388632357,
0.0763139278,
-0.9973593354,
-0.2400180697,
-0.2050167769,
0.3236964345,
-0.4223558307,
-0.1352615654,
0.5020381808,
0.040633399,
0.4845152795,
0.604358077,
-1.1078641415,
0.6093735695,
0.6988720298,
0.8300516009,
-0.1117343009,
0.10229633,
-0.8510579467,
0.1725477129,
-0.0699960664,
0.6227984428,
-0.9993318915,
-0.6940327883,
0.2392363846,
0.0498768762,
-0.3170422614,
-0.6186524034,
0.6790745854,
-0.9221853614,
0.3758417666,
-0.138696298,
-0.316019088,
-0.3071362674,
0.270388782,
-0.427742362,
0.9810222983,
0.108363539,
-0.4261741936,
-0.0639475137,
-0.3499124646,
-0.4875501096,
0.2620636225,
-0.1848604679,
-0.3658050299,
0.2713122666,
0.1308952868,
0.3990647495,
-0.1650419533,
0.3681564331,
-0.3752584755,
-0.6672237515,
0.2121548206,
-0.4532711506,
0.3331947625,
0.1211809963,
-0.0746006295,
0.2518083155,
-0.4049033523,
0.0115957977,
0.1850438565,
-0.560064733,
-0.254165858,
0.1546549201,
0.2871198952,
-0.1393324882,
0.1703006476,
-0.380872786,
0.1767501831,
-0.262927264,
0.5158513188,
0.5000787377,
-0.1265235394,
0.5897493958,
-0.2832056582,
0.4841881096,
-0.2001435012,
-0.041064661,
-0.1912849993,
-0.1741664857,
-1.016567111,
-0.2943784297,
0.0930102468,
0.5634467006,
-0.6966041923,
0.28237468,
-0.424633801,
-0.2467285842,
-0.403160274,
0.2352500707,
0.5503845215,
0.4122277498,
0.4538550973,
-0.4111613035,
-0.5642563105,
-0.8369377851,
-0.2748396695,
-0.0240489487,
-0.1270513088,
0.9532696009,
0.1203466058,
-0.6378293037,
0.4618784487,
-0.6854144931,
-0.3141222894,
-0.272585541,
-0.0330897458,
0.1282157749,
0.3982534409,
0.2697970271,
-1.084685564,
-0.5477217436,
0.1438938826,
-0.6380498409,
0.188566193,
-0.0172676072,
-0.4561119378,
-0.202016592,
0.7279492617,
-0.3329150379,
0.0319923684,
0.4214535356,
-0.3574234247,
0.3578596413,
-0.3499389589,
0.1646439135,
-1.010741353,
-0.0963745266,
-0.2697399259,
-0.5887659788,
-0.7613708377,
0.2668556571,
0.0175276492,
-0.1721091419,
-0.2967764139,
0.5767188668,
-0.4618671834,
0.0044287425,
-0.1794172078,
0.2366807461,
0.1139660254,
0.4301085174,
-0.0397248603,
0.936953485,
0.4364006519,
-0.5036608577,
0.4142693579,
0.2955830395,
-0.2463034987,
0.5094103217,
-0.778686583,
0.3025766015,
-0.3149197698,
0.3170487881,
-1.2116756439,
-0.4088708758,
0.0344623215,
-0.1279770434,
0.6161723733,
-0.3692994416,
-0.2403785735,
0.081016615,
-0.2869218886,
0.4010360241,
0.4657540619,
-0.7120574117,
0.9741382599,
0.1501298398,
-0.2732285559,
-0.5449283719,
-0.56120193,
0.3120464683,
-0.1073448583,
-0.6995773911,
0.4461647272,
-0.3925558329,
-0.1991963983,
-0.4665157497,
-0.0482628085,
-0.1026405245,
0.1757286042,
0.1237244457,
0.155349955,
-0.4676703811,
0.2669411004,
-0.0701389089,
-0.0217192154,
-0.2154906392,
0.1054202169,
0.7390279174,
-0.2975125611,
-0.3474161923,
0.0099914772,
0.4240972698,
0.3871618211,
0.0242664143,
0.5931886435,
0.7948198318,
0.0667651892,
-0.4176107645,
-0.9625335932,
-0.4739874601,
-0.5734611154,
0.6072193384,
-0.4828842282,
-1.4381526709,
0.3836675882,
-0.0551340245,
-0.0601714663,
-0.0819138661,
0.6499217749,
-0.0547499619,
0.9394654036,
0.5722893476,
0.0331247635,
0.6964663267,
0.0303923134,
0.1768717319,
-0.7501880527,
-0.4352717102,
-0.4287498295,
-0.4457073808,
-0.4885783494,
-0.4522164762,
0.2364267111,
0.0932464227,
-0.0429416038,
-0.0962072611,
-0.4745972157,
0.6093360186,
0.5713764429,
0.5483246446,
0.3958708346,
0.2657749355,
0.0173857249,
-0.1580393314,
-0.5797014832,
-0.2961420417,
0.8978760839,
0.0488099158,
1.0265895128,
0.567800045,
0.4162224829,
0.2079319954,
-0.0672670081,
-0.8669308424,
0.4225886166,
-0.2934916914,
-0.5238861442,
-0.1279662102,
-0.5485345125,
-1.1214441061,
0.7538369298,
-0.1637955457,
-0.5922345519,
0.1438931674,
0.0693206117,
-0.1461419016,
0.0084105954,
-0.8893090487,
0.7848085761,
-0.4044223428,
-0.4909359217,
-0.5565004349,
-0.4603320062,
0.4512088597,
0.1925440729,
0.0266606417,
-0.09808065,
-0.1609651148,
0.4268583655,
0.1188007817,
0.8748511076,
-0.0201501269,
0.2356337905,
-0.0769428238,
0.4136731029,
0.5107765794,
0.3296325803,
-0.1823831201,
-0.1618454158,
-0.0892407298,
-0.5981960893,
-0.7325869203,
1.0004239082,
-0.846354425,
-0.9555032253,
-0.2587969005,
-0.6253764033,
-0.2497654557,
0.3115023971,
-0.0815803632,
0.3330385983,
-0.6556960344,
0.6288738251,
1.1197773218,
-0.2273835987,
0.1630764604,
0.7658210397,
-0.2261729538,
-0.2312579602,
0.8374463916,
-0.521507144,
0.2476773262,
0.7374740243,
0.2165419161,
-0.1151307821,
-0.6773219705,
-0.0944314972,
0.1956114024,
-0.7231670022,
-0.1210724115,
-0.7611679435,
-0.2497522682,
-0.1007543951,
-0.2865300179,
-0.1911889911,
-0.0612629876,
-0.6008808613,
0.1704353392,
0.3055669963,
0.2404212207,
0.3084301651,
0.378839612,
-0.571588397,
0.3109280467,
0.7367179394,
0.3146591187,
-0.0866945535,
-0.7736387253,
-0.0758992136,
0.0582027994,
-0.2394623309,
-0.2467553616,
0.2997164726,
0.7238984108,
0.5525189042,
0.4418056011,
0.0892575979,
0.8030288815,
-0.436018616,
0.4843178988,
0.1842410415,
-0.5562356114,
0.4703584313,
-0.2475983202,
0.3916737437,
0.936688602,
0.2410171479,
-0.6090692282,
-0.0324349292,
-0.2935613096,
-0.776913166,
0.7029951811,
0.0808077902,
0.5789141059,
0.264301151,
0.3224479258,
0.0825220421,
0.0203031134,
-0.3654426634,
-0.0293584429,
-0.2218287736,
-0.2371994257,
-0.2306534052,
-0.6556420922,
-0.1761090755,
0.0381353311,
0.5144312382,
-0.2661195397,
0.207834959,
0.0744095296,
-0.2687167823,
0.0440215692,
0.5113579631,
0.4778055251,
0.4214922786,
-0.4430991709,
0.415727973,
0.1747924685,
-0.6490954757,
0.0274870787,
0.0882456079,
0.0482319817,
0.0037310957,
0.3024627268,
0.6723189354,
0.9740658402,
-0.9337309599,
0.6804656982,
-0.533534646,
-0.0126471408,
-0.2731580734,
0.5944589376,
0.1684135199,
0.3081335723,
0.3179119825,
-0.085765563,
0.2924325168,
-0.498118788,
0.1261005402,
0.8000305295,
-0.621058166,
-0.3460860252,
0.473767221,
0.3353810608,
-0.3379695714,
0.7875586152,
-0.0264775027,
-0.3045057654,
0.1039334461,
0.6144179702,
0.8216861486,
-0.4490203261,
0.0322527736,
0.2840808034,
-0.0705752224,
-0.1395190656,
0.1262723058,
-0.2550549507,
-0.8513028026,
-0.1662367284,
-0.5104916692,
-0.3886076808,
-0.001851877,
-0.7224590778,
0.1916103214,
-0.4174082577,
0.0783239007,
-0.0640962496,
0.0228308104,
-0.7454934716,
-0.2092825323,
0.0102945725,
0.6229764819,
-0.341001153,
0.8264417648,
0.5004222989,
-0.2299601585,
-0.2356556952,
-0.3092456758,
0.075813219,
-1.2555341721,
0.4615272582,
-0.0783280954,
-0.3878982961,
0.0465300009,
-0.4846027195,
-0.7972573042,
1.1513836384,
0.5302263498,
-0.9697324634,
-0.2052507997,
-0.1892264336,
0.4430722594,
-0.3350585401,
0.6265585423,
0.4895396531,
0.0647887364,
0.6642016172,
-0.6000540853,
0.0005660948,
-0.044404678,
0.2249854058,
0.0848939419,
-0.8542042971,
0.3807203472,
0.0068208915,
-0.3542483449,
0.0579465739,
0.3782319725,
0.2411747128,
0.2315545827,
0.2275421768,
0.2371108979,
0.647256732,
-0.071335949,
0.8124462366,
-0.0976049006,
0.3435527086,
1.3175660372,
-0.2919070721,
0.9738292694,
0.3419043124,
-0.1216805503,
0.6286026835,
0.2464476824,
0.0688347295,
0.5875478983,
0.0306258891,
-0.626254499,
-0.6268829107,
-0.0937175378,
-0.1200120077,
0.379865557,
0.6685693264,
-0.3383874297,
-0.3303704262,
-0.1832655817,
0.0964038819,
0.2890047133,
-0.037331339,
1.0194300413,
0.1548671573,
-0.6030097008,
0.7414221764,
0.0419221707,
0.7766065598,
-0.6334015131,
-0.1481666416,
-0.4026635289,
0.4314177334,
-0.3092319369,
-0.5414127111,
-0.0909371153,
-0.4986622632,
-0.1654372662,
-0.0983622819,
0.9720045924,
-0.6367040873,
-0.514662385,
0.4674332142,
0.3942344487,
-0.0604566932,
0.0579715371,
-0.9408176541,
0.3436568081,
0.2329404205,
-0.1204157546,
0.5426855683,
0.3473791182,
0.2884331644,
0.7430594563,
0.5656528473,
-0.3563761711,
-0.0106452331,
0.3253295422,
0.9120520353,
-0.5960528851,
-0.2569345236,
-0.6992413998,
0.2405057251,
-0.0790861249,
0.0644543692,
0.7451640964,
0.694775641,
0.6845202446,
0.1219771653,
0.5851786733,
0.384165436,
0.3930256367,
-0.6341409683,
0.376917541,
-0.2066184878,
0.4706356525,
0.0966718197,
-1.0039567947,
-0.4658703804,
0.5261737704,
-0.3783569336,
0.1356423795,
0.3801211715,
1.1922416687,
-0.7456646562,
0.0613333769,
0.5046026111,
0.2588817179,
0.5270270705,
0.8415504098,
0.8515839577,
-0.4674956203,
0.7640981078,
0.1762436777,
-0.3042173982,
-0.8307318091,
-0.4353623986,
-1.086384058,
-0.2791438103,
-0.2444509864,
-0.2304839045,
0.2448471785,
0.6470723748,
0.9521398544,
-0.8291277289,
-0.3942950964,
-0.0533503294,
0.0511535406,
0.1331458837,
-0.2786992192,
0.2477378845,
-0.7714071274,
-0.6585733891,
0.7053405046,
0.3328055143,
-0.1072317809,
-0.1715550125,
-0.3647589684,
-0.2111142576,
-0.0645797774,
0.7865499854,
0.2496698946,
-0.6970137954,
-0.287546128,
-0.007064268,
-0.3218183815,
0.2810136974,
1.0132739544,
-0.7091405392,
0.8491058946,
0.200485602,
0.7805652618,
1.1005926132,
0.0198210329,
0.5664092302,
-0.6653795242,
0.1865832359,
0.4814240932,
0.26163131,
0.4705888331,
-0.4152542353,
0.4264402986,
-0.1296344399,
-0.7302555442,
-0.6586812139,
0.3259445429,
-1.0527266264,
-0.3650349379,
1.2219736576,
-0.0140214385,
0.1378986984,
-0.3601292372,
-0.4128753245,
-0.0585959964,
-0.7319488525,
0.7264089584,
0.5072526932,
-0.0529212356,
-0.3660783768,
-0.430536896,
0.2390245199,
0.484793812,
-0.2991064191,
0.1088070348,
0.5327634215,
0.3032310605,
-0.1760290563,
0.4689924121,
-0.0211622212,
0.2721201181,
-0.2326684296,
-0.167932719,
0.1133785769,
0.0290419422,
-0.3969019055,
0.2040545642,
0.3791262507,
0.1492476165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13547v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13547v1
|
E-QGen: Educational Lecture Abstract-based Question Generation System
| 2024-04-21T06:03:43 | 2024-04-21T06:03:43 |
Mao-Siang Chen, An-Zi Yen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To optimize the preparation process for educators in academic lectures and
associated question-and-answer sessions, this paper presents E-QGen, a lecture
abstract-based question generation system. Given a lecture abstract, E-QGen
generates potential student inquiries. The questions suggested by our system
are expected to not only facilitate teachers in preparing answers in advance
but also enable them to supply additional resources when necessary.
|
[
-0.7020589113,
-0.8339310288,
0.5801382065,
-0.3454300761,
-0.1920136958,
0.1616014242,
0.2275368273,
-0.3346494734,
0.2384400964,
0.0816156641,
-0.7140229344,
-0.1982869804,
-0.1336533427,
0.4029815197,
-0.6647629738,
0.7600417733,
0.1285991669,
0.2583938241,
-0.6769636273,
0.2984245121,
0.0744345263,
-0.3628460467,
-1.0447790623,
-0.2808983922,
0.3266030252,
0.8603972793,
0.1324395984,
0.3022246957,
0.2439091653,
0.2744376957,
0.3575139046,
0.0068335263,
-0.2555460334,
0.3674278557,
-0.1805850416,
-0.6135398746,
-0.2675769031,
-0.4014784694,
0.5860188007,
0.5988695621,
-0.2993197441,
0.3258266449,
-0.0873677433,
0.3559473455,
-0.7146776319,
-0.5368034244,
-0.1006947905,
0.3258800209,
0.1127950549,
-0.6862330437,
-0.4416544139,
-0.9740986228,
0.1860001683,
-0.7090294361,
0.3236318827,
0.0305988342,
0.5233168006,
0.0217816588,
-0.3582469523,
-0.1651613712,
-0.6741632819,
0.6700046062,
-0.2058970481,
0.3706136942,
0.1934232414,
0.4901189506,
-0.193573907,
-1.0724539757,
-0.5348798037,
0.3834859729,
0.012630404,
0.1502947211,
0.355645746,
0.4724234641,
0.3323299885,
0.4252508879,
-0.8135429621,
-0.3433268368,
-0.6389449835,
-0.1775071472,
0.6637854576,
0.35216555,
0.5745057464,
-0.0178693552,
-0.310410738,
-0.3243893683,
-0.8275016546,
-0.110900037,
0.4599259794,
-0.2898975909,
0.2927288413,
0.283318162,
-0.3507515788,
0.9512448907,
0.111416325,
-0.1087366864,
-0.1071056277,
-0.1812383682,
0.0616332591,
0.6465656161,
0.3591851592,
0.5108692646,
-0.0358706675,
0.1962211132,
-0.104950361,
0.0924496725,
-0.1494941562,
-1.2022577524,
-0.5108734369,
0.7520885468,
-0.364833802,
-0.4150476456,
-0.0429531261,
-1.2168115377,
0.3008972406,
-0.1930434108,
0.6205425262,
-0.2783523798,
-0.380792588,
0.0486774556,
-0.6339898705,
0.2499610633,
0.479708612,
-0.9787564874,
0.3330160379,
0.0375985131,
0.3207382262,
0.1555102468,
0.1299464554,
-0.4450425506,
0.3606622517,
-0.0855380669,
1.0164012909,
-0.7840650678,
-0.9783374071,
0.3212173283,
-0.0740189627,
0.1469057798,
-0.4639431536,
0.422757417,
-0.5963843465,
0.6840721369,
-0.16416125,
-1.0603834391,
0.0741499364,
0.2811418772,
-0.1228420809,
0.9702234864,
0.1205763295,
-0.6708373427,
0.2399341017,
-0.6651220918,
0.00983309,
0.5992838144,
-0.6216606498,
0.0879403278,
-0.3569360673,
0.0454717316,
0.0682668537,
-0.2403398305,
-0.0984376222,
0.2853613794,
-0.3059809208,
-0.0770739987,
0.1296348423,
0.5855403543,
0.5350109935,
-0.418882221,
0.0517371371,
-1.1581772566,
0.8810833693,
0.3436395824,
-0.6125993133,
-0.5136602521,
0.1845442206,
-0.1989227384,
0.2005675584,
0.2769785523,
-0.8442307115,
0.1410685629,
-0.2914034128,
0.2132179737,
0.7329738736,
0.4180357754,
0.1123020053,
-0.2501930296,
0.9854927659,
-0.1100473478,
0.0129858153,
-0.5422564745,
-0.3733159602,
-0.6717399359,
0.3590054214,
0.2981544137,
0.6059641838,
-1.005056262,
-0.0439992994,
0.3031130433,
-0.3309277296,
-0.3602266908,
-0.140152514,
0.4111129642,
0.5178351402,
0.157424733,
-0.0652519092,
-0.7165096402,
-0.7323657274,
0.249381274,
-0.3152704835,
-0.179084897,
0.1378468424,
0.3855051994,
0.302811563,
0.8070917726,
-0.96219486,
0.6921488047,
-0.1535997838,
0.2133146822,
-0.4459651709,
0.5365443826,
0.6096374393,
-0.9500601292,
-0.5778415799,
-0.4162186384,
-0.5324918628,
-0.3576675057,
-0.0942765549,
-0.4033515453,
-0.1789805293,
0.7219117284,
-0.3310140371,
0.0454903916,
0.1382702142,
-0.3995095789,
0.651432693,
-0.1897773296,
0.1960606575,
-0.9349534512,
-0.0336132348,
-0.295098424,
-0.214138031,
-0.5672618151,
0.1666238159,
-0.0497382358,
-0.3994128704,
-0.5884160399,
0.4833174348,
-0.0010235457,
0.0644059777,
-0.4718994796,
0.7013706565,
0.3500547111,
0.1875366569,
-0.0055088457,
0.9236192107,
0.4399617016,
-1.1649590731,
0.512152195,
0.5718207359,
-0.1558416039,
0.9411732554,
-0.7507641912,
0.3436102271,
-0.2433516532,
0.1636940539,
-1.0263371468,
-0.5612319708,
0.2159852237,
-0.43331182,
0.3698975444,
0.2517378628,
-0.2562664151,
-0.4385294914,
-0.2602408528,
0.6195219755,
0.4430253208,
-0.7019265294,
0.076709494,
0.1194279045,
-0.8015306592,
-0.3788696826,
-0.0693259612,
-0.124771148,
0.2125823945,
-0.8314327002,
0.5816498399,
-0.2550775707,
-0.4165767133,
0.2184502929,
0.1403012574,
0.1602756232,
-0.1535720676,
-0.20383434,
0.1944057792,
-0.2582356632,
0.5071302056,
0.5557563901,
0.1857863516,
0.3799621761,
-0.3577927947,
0.60460186,
0.2462965548,
-0.3578668833,
-0.1760114431,
0.986740768,
0.3658562005,
-0.0875399485,
0.3480496705,
0.1756119132,
-0.2830372751,
-0.378235817,
-0.2581818104,
-0.5792033076,
-0.5363129973,
0.3798907101,
-0.1009589732,
-0.7638112307,
0.175076589,
-0.3287384212,
0.3998592496,
0.4479881823,
0.5607479811,
0.0699540749,
1.5590913296,
0.5500345826,
0.6495149136,
0.409907639,
-0.1804726124,
0.1229731068,
-0.603630662,
-0.575214088,
-0.7034447789,
-0.2267341614,
-0.3767077923,
0.0502351783,
0.3393411636,
-0.0826729089,
-0.3160343468,
-0.1377408952,
-0.948887527,
0.3266754746,
0.8209199309,
-0.1220206022,
0.0276519358,
-0.3469358683,
-0.1893212199,
0.1798341125,
-0.8695732951,
-0.7949234247,
1.1447197199,
0.068971552,
0.5067383051,
0.1236791536,
1.2128350735,
0.0115822237,
0.005553484,
-0.4039103687,
0.964725554,
0.5351852179,
-0.9040163755,
-0.5859138966,
-0.1538979262,
-0.7521259785,
0.3442032039,
-0.1267345101,
-0.4199011922,
0.2478187829,
0.108219333,
-0.8320249319,
0.3558296561,
-0.7165212631,
0.4565440714,
-0.3408596516,
-0.437541008,
-0.2461251765,
-0.6495919228,
0.2140782773,
-0.0476746559,
0.0186475907,
0.2180707455,
0.1950873137,
1.0617177486,
-0.5294504166,
0.3722813427,
-0.4276008904,
0.0799562484,
0.9643936157,
-0.1146498844,
0.2682152689,
0.0308580715,
0.1770942658,
-0.9465456009,
0.3584211767,
-0.4653319418,
-0.4205097854,
0.4445910156,
-0.8365212679,
-0.9593070149,
-0.2831123471,
-0.1510994285,
-0.1818073094,
0.2497186512,
0.6175745726,
0.6598987579,
-0.2127826661,
-0.1212821975,
1.166139245,
-0.739418447,
0.4609228671,
0.2617258728,
-0.4273486435,
-0.3324143291,
1.056641221,
0.0359298922,
0.4610296488,
0.3373344243,
0.1170333773,
-0.4055332839,
-0.3932912648,
-0.6974511147,
-0.161765337,
-0.8956185579,
-0.1371705979,
-0.813182056,
-0.3221287727,
-0.5041683912,
-0.2336433828,
0.248467207,
-0.8700197935,
-0.1872769743,
-0.6532258391,
0.321936816,
0.4949424863,
-0.2371258289,
0.2071390003,
-1.0342472792,
0.0742457956,
1.1588637829,
0.0504169613,
-0.2531512082,
-0.1885959804,
-0.0745920911,
0.0167771634,
-1.0801947117,
-1.0178283453,
0.1592677683,
0.6423905492,
0.6511368155,
0.6509744525,
0.3117343783,
0.014979274,
-0.4018960595,
1.0989103317,
0.3929560184,
-0.484798938,
1.0517631769,
-0.3458200395,
0.1106156185,
0.3724669218,
0.452080965,
-0.2693952918,
-0.6126010418,
-0.8972046971,
-1.1887294054,
0.6140895486,
-0.006754376,
0.0979610309,
-0.2144036889,
0.2458317876,
0.1634291857,
0.4485814869,
-0.2900333107,
-0.5493047833,
-0.5235382318,
-0.0504289791,
0.1962717175,
-0.3595615625,
-0.3464468718,
-0.25705567,
0.6847681403,
0.2055369467,
0.4684203267,
0.5689362884,
0.2286391109,
-0.5705599189,
0.7060259581,
1.1332207918,
0.5953672528,
-0.4611067772,
0.0155079989,
0.0087159993,
-0.5869631171,
0.6088886857,
-0.1810385734,
-0.0790025517,
0.4175952673,
-0.4228638411,
0.2583896518,
0.0378717072,
-0.8282459974,
0.2364659309,
-0.1655855477,
-0.7664273977,
-0.5960678458,
0.4909835756,
-0.1220411882,
-0.0695207044,
0.6702851057,
-0.5327683091,
0.2574252784,
-0.5682039261,
0.5602776408,
-0.1008992642,
-0.0398787074,
-0.0348012447,
1.0458847284,
0.7083400488,
-0.4838655889,
0.6803507805,
-0.2305847853,
-0.690980196,
0.7193770409,
0.7184512615,
0.671664238,
-0.5927151442,
0.6099885106,
0.8372132778,
-0.2773424387,
0.1238017306,
0.9165597558,
0.0059986729,
-0.5858843923,
-0.295953542,
-0.4628130794,
-0.9743146896,
-0.0364599526,
-0.7587700486,
0.2353152782,
-0.6967936754,
-0.2506496012,
-0.0248026326,
-0.1976785809,
-0.2984058857,
0.6820610166,
0.1184298322,
1.0351015329,
-0.780399859,
0.5090410709,
1.0680991411,
-0.1783594191,
-0.6954858303,
-0.4802956283,
-0.1958054602,
-0.2700903714,
0.9182482958,
-0.2398411483,
-0.0419231355,
0.4232274592,
-0.5435630679,
-0.7113503814,
1.0186225176,
-0.095616959,
-0.5854753852,
-0.0402946584,
0.0732062235,
0.3191164434,
-0.3243893087,
0.1645456851,
0.3213408887,
0.5130909681,
0.1883668005,
-0.2020584345,
-0.0832863823,
-0.6225761175,
-0.3995755315,
0.7710917592,
-0.5195139647,
0.8220249414,
-0.1978420913,
-0.1243410781,
-0.1429863125,
0.5186473131,
0.3468573689,
0.5480562449,
0.3239913583,
0.5940412283,
0.8163427114,
-0.2415095121,
0.9848681688,
-0.6101595163,
0.0140223354,
0.6119869351,
0.0493011922,
0.5668324828,
0.669392705,
-0.2909998894,
0.5999560952,
1.0200878382,
-0.0025742496,
0.733628571,
0.3816072941,
-0.8843051195,
-0.4597266316,
-0.1620497555,
-0.9283705354,
-0.0027654674,
0.5928041339,
-0.0480123609,
-0.2186273336,
0.0911310539,
-0.3743516505,
-0.0494705178,
-0.515135169,
0.5045693517,
0.1811855286,
-0.8091127276,
0.1845817119,
0.0910955518,
0.2451443672,
-0.3281975091,
-0.2665442824,
0.0483312905,
-0.1739723384,
-0.4410119057,
-0.4393549562,
-0.0807216614,
-0.1303843707,
0.0190434474,
-0.0648214966,
0.8608791828,
-0.4930559099,
-0.2192485631,
-0.4617536962,
0.6174933314,
0.1535267383,
0.5539065599,
-0.4590683281,
-0.5540046096,
0.0082980869,
-0.2559840083,
0.5616893172,
0.300151825,
0.2918094397,
0.5435751677,
0.357676506,
0.0107568437,
0.3926760554,
-0.2162112147,
0.7545220852,
-0.4399358332,
-0.7115000486,
-0.316791445,
0.5869389772,
-0.2248349488,
-0.3947219551,
0.5313655734,
0.4833444953,
1.0417333841,
-0.045008339,
1.3763340712,
-0.2054271251,
0.7588751316,
-0.3146535456,
0.3491401672,
-0.6186660528,
-0.092003122,
-0.379868418,
-0.9088469148,
0.3456493318,
0.7285872102,
-0.1638987958,
0.0528324619,
0.8526700735,
0.4499980509,
0.4577344656,
0.515733242,
0.4040316641,
-0.4708547592,
0.3184259534,
0.6077262759,
1.2645014524,
-0.5095540285,
0.5440008044,
-0.38563025,
0.0070142769,
-0.5237669945,
-0.3758150339,
-0.7348741293,
-0.5444170237,
-0.7481111288,
-0.097544387,
0.0081955874,
1.2142978907,
0.1914212704,
-0.8049917221,
-0.0591469072,
-0.2162127942,
-0.0366405845,
0.2033431828,
-0.2486713827,
0.4129493237,
-0.3345501423,
-0.7508330345,
-0.0097436849,
-0.0944827795,
0.5094540119,
-0.2156300098,
0.0442648977,
-0.0440163165,
0.3405832648,
0.6220671535,
0.5312475562,
0.0479794629,
-0.4621162713,
0.1763609201,
-0.123067908,
-0.08801011,
0.8558056951,
-0.4256817102,
0.4841007292,
0.6164031029,
0.5134403706,
0.1459415704,
0.0326566361,
0.8584526181,
-0.7043673992,
0.0961582735,
0.5576518774,
0.1703962386,
0.0273268428,
-0.4669419825,
0.2584138513,
0.0298564583,
-0.9008598924,
-0.864679873,
0.2295657545,
-0.4018271565,
-0.4082262814,
0.9395673275,
-0.1124412864,
0.0843679309,
-0.4771882296,
-0.4595268369,
0.196011126,
-0.0739201903,
0.9346867204,
0.6328977346,
-0.4270531535,
-0.3116876185,
-0.7723391652,
0.594168365,
0.5098640323,
-0.8426425457,
-0.6758918166,
0.2635771036,
0.0642541498,
0.1649656147,
0.6214209795,
-0.1809537411,
0.829831481,
0.296779424,
0.4005128443,
0.0789913014,
-0.3193463385,
0.3884780407,
0.5748431087,
0.1474565119,
-0.5378824472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13530v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13530v1
|
Listen Then See: Video Alignment with Speaker Attention
| 2024-04-21T04:55:13 | 2024-04-21T04:55:13 |
Aviral Agrawal, Carlos Mateo Samudio Lezcano, Iqui Balam Heredia-Marin, Prabhdeep Singh Sethi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Video-based Question Answering (Video QA) is a challenging task and becomes
even more intricate when addressing Socially Intelligent Question Answering
(SIQA). SIQA requires context understanding, temporal reasoning, and the
integration of multimodal information, but in addition, it requires processing
nuanced human behavior. Furthermore, the complexities involved are exacerbated
by the dominance of the primary modality (text) over the others. Thus, there is
a need to help the task's secondary modalities to work in tandem with the
primary modality. In this work, we introduce a cross-modal alignment and
subsequent representation fusion approach that achieves state-of-the-art
results (82.06\% accuracy) on the Social IQ 2.0 dataset for SIQA. Our approach
exhibits an improved ability to leverage the video modality by using the audio
modality as a bridge with the language modality. This leads to enhanced
performance by reducing the prevalent issue of language overfitting and
resultant video modality bypassing encountered by current existing techniques.
Our code and models are publicly available at
https://github.com/sts-vlcc/sts-vlcc
|
[
-0.4104498625,
-0.6583564281,
0.5329363942,
-0.0018775833,
-0.3215082288,
0.28158167,
-0.1003395915,
-0.2003679127,
0.3672266603,
0.2908560038,
-0.6718557477,
-0.2615363598,
-0.6540434361,
-0.4351404011,
-0.3109669387,
0.6173616052,
0.1559592187,
0.4304049611,
-0.3728695214,
-0.3408611715,
-0.7569426298,
-0.0111072566,
-0.3889368474,
-0.0750335008,
0.2942493558,
0.6424408555,
0.8594605923,
0.5301894546,
0.2832853198,
0.293523401,
0.1281355321,
0.2129388005,
-0.4672856927,
-0.0686438531,
-0.4115309119,
0.0378647745,
-0.3268017471,
-0.2698179185,
0.8597402573,
0.4548531473,
0.1562983096,
0.5146007538,
-0.0749950483,
0.4983353019,
-0.5422129035,
-0.0758274868,
-0.8183760047,
-0.1584997773,
0.0940783322,
-0.4498086572,
-0.3238764703,
-0.0655727014,
0.1309984028,
-0.5679450035,
-0.2153539658,
-0.0479456522,
0.7388808727,
0.8732209802,
-0.7007504106,
0.31943205,
-1.0163679123,
0.5799998641,
-0.4790431261,
0.9279257655,
0.2906164825,
0.6692944765,
0.1579884738,
-0.2852979004,
-0.8005188107,
0.333375752,
0.172020629,
0.1271397322,
0.0171513632,
-0.0042900848,
0.2945524752,
0.2416267097,
-0.851754725,
-0.1563285738,
-0.5221986175,
-0.2992878854,
0.7321743965,
0.0114603564,
0.5549069047,
-0.26212883,
-0.5561339259,
-0.1982601732,
-0.3194560111,
0.273788631,
0.1208994836,
0.0009496489,
-0.0180961732,
0.8021064401,
-0.2908555865,
0.3722888231,
0.2798448205,
-0.0957072154,
0.3927429318,
-0.7913526893,
-0.3479799628,
0.2749302387,
0.6205368638,
0.5696790814,
0.0459583998,
0.0589313395,
0.3029294908,
0.1579103023,
0.2656698823,
-0.3885769546,
-0.0639785081,
0.2257720679,
-0.3152946234,
0.2639376521,
0.0299865548,
-0.6090328097,
-0.243599534,
-0.407415092,
0.8835161924,
-0.4260065556,
-0.4403668046,
0.0085246805,
-0.0204608571,
0.7287712693,
0.3405472636,
-0.8005191088,
0.2747161984,
0.6726487875,
0.4313738346,
0.1598043889,
-0.0344434604,
-1.0053443909,
0.5967199206,
-0.0567978732,
0.6304680109,
-0.6119487882,
-0.0274978355,
-0.1036842987,
0.1531344801,
-0.2566654086,
-0.1835082471,
0.341806978,
-0.6105923653,
0.5068646669,
-0.4696526229,
-0.3233787119,
-0.1961823851,
0.0951568484,
-0.6034934521,
1.1460702419,
0.0221012793,
-0.6214077473,
0.2466538697,
-0.2360078543,
-0.2371667624,
0.016342923,
-0.5894517303,
-0.254376173,
-0.3454056084,
0.4539284706,
0.1293530166,
-0.2417714447,
0.2432150394,
-0.0709843859,
-0.4989339411,
0.1428959519,
-0.2133313864,
0.4155577719,
-0.1403865516,
-0.7610605955,
0.2751351297,
-0.5122436881,
0.1188159809,
-0.2001721561,
0.2310554981,
-0.3257096112,
0.0428105108,
0.0767741874,
0.5292356014,
0.1544219553,
-0.6145603061,
-0.3854474127,
-0.3879712224,
0.2941958308,
0.7851520181,
-0.2074815333,
0.5518990159,
-0.1502300054,
0.5317277908,
-0.0938997641,
0.113045454,
0.07920219,
-0.4657121301,
-0.2697282434,
-0.2043347955,
0.1373299658,
0.8135875463,
-1.0593417883,
0.1033855975,
-0.4864550829,
-0.493801713,
-0.9381837845,
0.3883312047,
0.6495209932,
0.384446919,
0.4522180855,
-0.3691270947,
-0.5669848323,
-1.0665177107,
-0.1408337504,
-0.5552217364,
-0.0985624343,
0.5886000991,
-0.1022181287,
-0.1533032805,
0.7803797126,
-0.3188517392,
-0.219892785,
-0.1100845784,
-0.0538271591,
-0.1366215497,
0.5195551515,
0.2576777637,
-1.3501580954,
-0.4478805065,
0.1902921051,
-0.5203607678,
-0.038084954,
-0.2807185352,
-0.4251270294,
0.0438808911,
0.7043173313,
-0.5177767277,
0.3319415152,
0.4163024724,
-0.3971871138,
0.0202618465,
0.31234622,
0.6086091399,
-1.1547465324,
-0.0670278966,
-0.0244176295,
-0.2652366757,
-0.48304075,
-0.4240587354,
-0.1047957987,
-0.2476730645,
-0.7148692012,
0.3878182769,
-0.3151603043,
-0.5279934406,
-0.0378622301,
0.5077176094,
0.0542977415,
0.6945508718,
0.0227578711,
0.8725301027,
0.442724824,
-0.1724882424,
0.5207657218,
0.4984336793,
-0.1165608987,
0.6168278456,
-0.8256958723,
0.1486783177,
-0.3110776246,
0.0311800092,
-1.4553006887,
-0.3886170983,
0.4166221023,
-0.8769524097,
0.3546175659,
0.1294340193,
-0.0925191119,
-0.0179064367,
-0.408136636,
0.9524996877,
0.4189087152,
-0.3214235008,
0.90368402,
0.7279349566,
-0.4429018795,
-0.5552742481,
-0.5073052645,
-0.0719893649,
-0.0765450969,
-1.0391232967,
0.576756537,
-0.2682134807,
-0.1922213584,
-0.019811172,
-0.306101948,
-0.0154135851,
-0.3171720207,
0.2666809261,
0.2420069128,
-0.4371604621,
0.2852936983,
0.2521124482,
-0.1051809192,
-0.0390365608,
0.0574781559,
0.4308675826,
-0.0509425029,
-0.4769256413,
-0.7515033484,
0.9238148928,
0.76384902,
-0.4442473948,
0.5403456688,
0.840980649,
-0.4808840454,
0.3603975773,
-0.7807106376,
-0.1248997226,
-0.4483164549,
0.576860249,
-0.1726050824,
-1.0032367706,
0.3069376945,
0.2651535571,
-0.078116551,
0.0956909284,
0.5580569506,
-0.1171884611,
1.4875093699,
0.5780177116,
0.1151053682,
0.7284706831,
0.184431091,
0.4890636504,
-0.7255120277,
-0.5774080753,
-0.2300219238,
-0.3075120151,
-0.3537993729,
-0.6350775361,
0.5264115334,
-0.2439141273,
-0.2065055668,
0.3906105757,
-0.3395775557,
0.4009640217,
0.4413752258,
0.2359364182,
0.0464959554,
-0.00923716,
0.6161444783,
-0.4179010689,
-0.6427680254,
-0.3230849206,
0.5257982016,
0.4248988628,
0.6622946262,
0.4642604589,
0.3643681705,
0.3852036893,
-0.3195997179,
-0.6594721079,
0.8509101272,
0.0234995726,
-0.3738385141,
-0.5776255727,
-0.1659703255,
-0.4884704649,
0.1897713244,
-0.1583214402,
-0.7507247329,
0.2773593962,
0.2041594684,
-0.6082978845,
0.0065546175,
-0.869050324,
1.147354722,
-0.1622413248,
-0.4698163867,
-0.4405127466,
-1.0519269705,
0.2316151112,
0.3297922909,
0.3230811954,
0.0430025421,
0.0389598906,
0.637907505,
-0.1144354939,
0.6309075952,
-0.0263897683,
0.0957085118,
0.2803893387,
-0.2170776874,
0.2478217185,
0.245508343,
0.2643089294,
-0.4036916792,
0.2243083119,
-0.6105625033,
-0.9034050107,
0.5882873535,
-0.8539640307,
-0.9025284052,
-0.2057762742,
-0.5352652669,
-0.4942993522,
-0.0805508196,
-0.1362651139,
0.456818521,
-0.0114145391,
0.3673581481,
1.0461676121,
-0.0935632959,
0.178744331,
0.2319155782,
0.0759236366,
-0.6135671735,
1.0717507601,
0.0922252014,
0.530661881,
0.3840074837,
-0.2313634902,
-0.2197863311,
-0.3143621087,
-0.6854072809,
0.2585735321,
-0.6559225917,
-0.0650511608,
-0.8720201254,
-0.3238224983,
-1.0334224701,
-0.0948873684,
-0.2494704127,
-0.3678531647,
-0.11812713,
-0.376588285,
0.2452583611,
0.1515387893,
-0.0532397218,
0.3022356927,
-0.9366218448,
0.5595623851,
0.8264988065,
0.0184523873,
-0.3796181977,
-0.5434678197,
-0.2990953028,
0.0870588347,
-0.1285749376,
-1.1770149469,
-0.0022065931,
0.4041157365,
0.7062693834,
0.0967753455,
0.0188771877,
0.7795091271,
-0.3342568576,
0.9680080414,
0.1120550632,
-1.0306564569,
0.7679746151,
-0.2808568776,
0.4944200218,
0.8103755116,
0.4606871605,
-0.6559401155,
-0.249442786,
-0.5783943534,
-1.0432448387,
0.5678705573,
0.0747430846,
0.0880296379,
0.1713546962,
-0.1162177101,
0.0354482532,
0.115279749,
-0.5684837103,
0.0985068232,
-0.3803806603,
-0.3471962512,
0.1801033169,
-0.2133479416,
-0.2191145718,
-0.2834075093,
1.0594097376,
-0.4321983457,
0.1045629233,
0.3971496224,
-0.2508563399,
-0.3999164701,
0.2236943543,
0.494133234,
0.5949385166,
0.0038955356,
0.0221380517,
0.2218303382,
-0.2509772778,
-0.0254999325,
0.1392504573,
-0.0897677839,
0.0526587963,
0.1924021691,
0.7071820498,
0.357147187,
-1.0255019665,
0.6533434391,
-0.1002337709,
0.0515183136,
-0.3501179516,
0.0154559352,
-0.0292002317,
0.7446706891,
0.3374429047,
-0.019264102,
0.3274562061,
-0.7250415683,
0.4352759123,
0.5636275411,
-0.7076919675,
-0.2018609792,
0.7026669979,
0.2040296793,
-0.4907380939,
0.2229057103,
0.2196169794,
-0.6533548236,
0.4855809212,
0.1898150146,
0.781560123,
-0.292524457,
0.5644751191,
0.2573131025,
0.1871725172,
0.3267769814,
0.6566744447,
-0.4759432077,
-0.5130339265,
-0.7210752368,
-0.1330432743,
-0.3259070814,
-0.2165888399,
-0.7155038714,
0.2597593367,
-0.3809646964,
-0.068199642,
0.104557611,
-0.2009222955,
-0.3674467206,
0.3556573391,
0.6131830812,
0.5666621327,
-1.1139886379,
0.7559956312,
0.8432977796,
-0.3598504961,
-1.0529649258,
-0.0085975183,
0.1775151789,
-0.5845026374,
0.3680466712,
0.1243939102,
-0.3266111314,
-0.1650759131,
-0.5625419617,
-1.1115261316,
1.2744641304,
0.4152163565,
-0.3471276462,
-0.0707138255,
0.1543153524,
0.4317871928,
-0.3786203563,
0.2681261897,
0.4070163071,
0.3028376698,
0.4553142786,
-1.0418795347,
0.0361690968,
-0.6223697066,
-0.0391902849,
0.2142236978,
-0.8340011835,
0.2091531456,
-0.0804681405,
-0.2925559878,
-0.2108380049,
1.0072345734,
0.1949021071,
0.6918802261,
0.7224518657,
0.2854917943,
0.3471424878,
0.0626765639,
0.4718635082,
-0.0253277756,
-0.1244827211,
1.3318197727,
-0.3361158669,
0.7587827444,
1.0179234743,
-0.0328198858,
0.3730804324,
0.6420509815,
0.3833709955,
0.5537433028,
-0.3130483627,
-0.1994718611,
-0.9208359718,
-0.6724433899,
-0.5433298945,
0.5292238593,
0.0814448297,
-0.1755719632,
0.0701837167,
0.1955040544,
-0.3820123672,
0.5205098391,
-0.3826678097,
0.8735402226,
-0.1071557105,
-0.6918981075,
0.2449933439,
-0.6035764217,
0.3222998083,
-0.4403282404,
-0.2375134528,
0.139575392,
-0.1575469375,
-0.3284418881,
-0.7377851605,
0.435172081,
-0.1991719157,
-0.454430759,
-0.1799889207,
0.6082751155,
-0.9208897948,
-0.2861427367,
0.4097653627,
0.3407279849,
-0.0710662827,
0.2110173106,
-0.4050099552,
0.2095530778,
0.1566363722,
0.0707375854,
0.1104194522,
0.4264287353,
-0.2332135141,
0.3579357862,
0.3386106789,
-0.4289287925,
0.0916539431,
0.1322401464,
1.0465611219,
-0.5804817677,
-0.4700104892,
-0.5426409841,
0.7892676592,
-0.244889304,
-0.298538208,
0.601716578,
0.4553024173,
1.0825921297,
0.2076242417,
0.4645591676,
-0.0913720354,
0.5219461322,
-0.5146801472,
0.1963409334,
-0.7776765823,
0.1815864295,
-0.6157112122,
-0.860127151,
-0.0944403112,
0.2036101669,
-0.4132911563,
-0.3559408784,
0.4542776942,
0.9602673054,
0.0040159523,
0.1797229499,
0.3420700431,
0.0246250816,
0.1802979857,
0.7077590823,
0.8130813241,
-0.8126189709,
0.8847258091,
-0.1589476764,
-0.2617355287,
-0.150448963,
-0.4978731871,
-0.6005538702,
-0.7604651451,
-0.638525188,
-0.4614152312,
0.1852495968,
1.1365510225,
0.6039116383,
-0.6017599106,
0.0658875555,
0.5990751386,
0.1540762782,
-0.3143179715,
-0.2055829316,
0.2957644165,
0.2982524335,
-0.6428417563,
0.5340356231,
0.4968171716,
-0.1826971173,
-0.2579187453,
-0.233876273,
-0.5624483228,
0.1628062129,
0.5065957904,
0.4905052483,
-0.6284204721,
-0.821126163,
0.3914761543,
-0.1286872327,
0.0959614292,
0.7091504335,
-0.7787433267,
0.5074784756,
1.0106759071,
1.0836664438,
0.4831683934,
0.2601444423,
0.8270449638,
-0.4496397972,
-0.0145637887,
0.3489292264,
0.2398739457,
0.5422161222,
-0.5195765495,
0.3171585798,
0.2040250599,
-0.503231287,
-0.8822781444,
0.3256072998,
-1.5704959631,
0.0618492179,
1.1483889818,
0.2453739345,
-0.4443904757,
-0.192599088,
-0.6373897791,
0.4891711175,
-0.3560172915,
0.5331987739,
0.521502018,
0.1039583236,
-0.5822064281,
-0.3570096493,
0.2412374169,
1.227594018,
-0.4891914725,
-0.2685821056,
0.5119467974,
0.0341091827,
0.2028631717,
0.7566380501,
-0.1936311424,
0.9821990728,
-0.32649225,
-0.1746885628,
0.2001387775,
-0.3589318693,
-0.2681336999,
0.1010396928,
-0.3235394359,
-0.4659118652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14453v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14453v1
|
EPI-SQL: Enhancing Text-to-SQL Translation with Error-Prevention Instructions
| 2024-04-21T03:52:46 | 2024-04-21T03:52:46 |
Xiping Liu, Zhao Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
The conversion of natural language queries into SQL queries, known as
Text-to-SQL, is a critical yet challenging task. This paper introduces EPI-SQL,
a novel methodological framework leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs) to
enhance the performance of Text-to-SQL tasks. EPI-SQL operates through a
four-step process. Initially, the method involves gathering instances from the
Spider dataset on which LLMs are prone to failure. These instances are then
utilized to generate general error-prevention instructions (EPIs).
Subsequently, LLMs craft contextualized EPIs tailored to the specific context
of the current task. Finally, these context-specific EPIs are incorporated into
the prompt used for SQL generation. EPI-SQL is distinguished in that it
provides task-specific guidance, enabling the model to circumvent potential
errors for the task at hand. Notably, the methodology rivals the performance of
advanced few-shot methods despite being a zero-shot approach. An empirical
assessment using the Spider benchmark reveals that EPI-SQL achieves an
execution accuracy of 85.1\%, underscoring its effectiveness in generating
accurate SQL queries through LLMs. The findings indicate a promising direction
for future research, i.e. enhancing instructions with task-specific and
contextualized rules, for boosting LLMs' performance in NLP tasks.
|
[
0.0175608005,
-0.9040602446,
0.656832397,
0.3175012469,
-0.2766286731,
-0.2182603478,
-0.2531695962,
-0.1388897747,
0.2560322881,
0.7253457904,
-0.5426565409,
-0.7562342882,
-0.2860413492,
0.4984607399,
-0.4757792056,
0.9673295021,
0.0955404639,
0.1547399908,
-0.2670720518,
0.131563589,
-0.2864669859,
-0.7233106494,
-0.5284332037,
0.1800975353,
0.3511624038,
0.4444709122,
0.2884112597,
0.6197557449,
0.4964480698,
0.1564586014,
-0.0727148503,
0.5325017571,
-0.5008130074,
0.1293592304,
-0.3339067101,
-1.1054093838,
-0.528840363,
-0.5079752803,
0.5167399049,
0.762221396,
-0.5251480341,
-0.1418383271,
0.0215219911,
0.8207170367,
-0.6839942932,
-0.0670505688,
-0.746145606,
0.0835679024,
-0.3031014204,
-0.6249006391,
-0.8001639843,
-0.1755464673,
-0.1763956398,
-0.4528766274,
0.102669999,
0.312105,
0.7086380124,
0.1836301088,
-0.4367304444,
-0.1891852617,
-0.7269454598,
0.8721628785,
-0.8331575394,
0.1160115823,
0.4195769727,
0.2545026541,
-0.5794988275,
-0.4429245591,
-0.5115049481,
-0.0361929908,
-0.1432546675,
0.0061856895,
0.0452157706,
0.1527875811,
0.2406669408,
-0.0128993159,
-0.4767082632,
0.0628711432,
-0.0237524156,
0.2339031994,
0.5146614313,
0.3579950035,
0.3932088614,
0.0066340002,
-0.1829658747,
0.2804753482,
-1.1018035412,
-0.3773360252,
0.1029839665,
0.60723418,
0.0183164794,
0.9178256989,
-0.4556308985,
1.0397388935,
-0.040660914,
0.039486289,
-0.0646990016,
-0.5275607109,
-0.1513991058,
0.112138547,
0.5917576551,
0.5042172074,
0.0439428091,
-0.4793912768,
-0.255836904,
-0.0365256071,
0.263297379,
-0.774109304,
0.1400570869,
0.478512466,
-0.3179267049,
-0.2437103838,
-0.1841857433,
-0.87684834,
-0.3489498794,
-0.2554622889,
0.2655925453,
-0.4714133143,
-0.17816782,
-0.1476807743,
0.0811884925,
0.5116131306,
0.3830423951,
-0.5789862275,
0.5481027961,
0.781001687,
0.8901587725,
-0.4455780983,
-0.1234261319,
-0.5171841383,
0.8243817687,
-0.5175093412,
0.821798861,
-0.5534060597,
-0.336304307,
0.0901058465,
0.0915795043,
-0.136767298,
-0.416092813,
0.6786429286,
-0.2898858786,
0.2457557619,
-0.1304384768,
-0.7945697308,
-0.0074682576,
0.2329891473,
-0.3868536949,
0.8753548265,
-0.1550899744,
-0.5175282359,
0.3780548573,
-0.9836066961,
-0.6136081219,
0.0506540053,
-0.1248470694,
-0.3263656497,
0.4152247608,
0.2062007934,
0.463385731,
-0.686863482,
-0.0353636593,
-0.0984346867,
-0.4121577442,
0.0767282769,
-0.0742897689,
0.6141182184,
0.0734758601,
-0.3887663186,
-0.0506199263,
-0.7509845495,
0.2260297686,
0.2381385267,
-0.2684022486,
-0.419703871,
0.3763151467,
-0.1073432937,
0.0392661914,
0.0458543412,
-0.5634752512,
-0.1558764428,
-0.7389203906,
0.4111192226,
0.315143019,
-0.0568762831,
0.4550683498,
-0.1418069303,
0.1825562865,
0.044146277,
0.072015062,
-0.4545789063,
-0.4902133048,
-0.8277921081,
-0.0794568509,
0.1141642481,
1.0888968706,
-0.7009651065,
0.7261607647,
-0.2815109193,
-0.4261796176,
-0.2078119218,
-0.0229532253,
0.3406440616,
0.155446589,
0.4373663366,
-0.108296074,
-0.5163035393,
-0.7598086596,
-0.6189896464,
-0.1925532222,
-0.1784630567,
0.3867013156,
0.4030794203,
0.0901478678,
0.7851551175,
-0.4595028758,
-0.4415535927,
-0.203833133,
0.0499163233,
0.3412728012,
0.5310209394,
0.2681257725,
-0.6585319638,
-0.602072835,
0.1752295494,
-0.7476864457,
-0.0838531852,
-0.257748574,
-0.2878845334,
0.6681518555,
0.2982541323,
-0.5691950321,
0.4925047755,
0.2144025713,
-0.5075992942,
0.4306666553,
-0.31303671,
0.4215595126,
-1.229573369,
0.0080935322,
0.2603323162,
-0.2176831812,
-0.8357734084,
0.1808459163,
-0.0303530376,
-0.1264405996,
-0.4063011706,
-0.0295139384,
-0.5651763082,
0.0916315988,
-0.0985629931,
-0.0758923367,
-0.098815158,
0.3696752787,
0.0687187389,
0.8654860258,
0.3745279312,
-0.7780537009,
0.2241728008,
0.2445641905,
-0.0087138396,
0.975179553,
-0.7125232816,
0.3901146352,
-0.0479742736,
-0.0322668999,
-0.954937458,
-0.2962352931,
0.0319727995,
-0.4678998888,
0.4647938013,
-0.291167438,
-0.591609776,
0.0583067574,
-0.2056239694,
-0.1813189238,
0.3608807921,
-0.4320403934,
0.8420848846,
0.4064374864,
-0.2354527861,
-0.382050693,
-1.0721117258,
0.6233551502,
-0.1953900754,
-0.5667760968,
0.6545841694,
0.2717609107,
-0.2161807567,
-0.0844990313,
0.1752990037,
-0.4488309622,
-0.0529213957,
-0.0325564109,
0.3290842772,
0.0320370942,
-0.0304850712,
0.2344067693,
0.1391322911,
-0.0172596499,
-0.2155658007,
0.2947300375,
0.1803788245,
-0.3726323247,
-0.766277492,
0.7686719894,
0.3771684766,
-0.0986143202,
1.2380795479,
0.0922276452,
-0.370876044,
-0.366707325,
-0.6317594647,
-0.3995907009,
-0.3553209305,
0.5498391986,
-0.5466687083,
-0.4084990323,
0.1141690984,
-0.4048551917,
0.0738824457,
0.1912525445,
0.2749867737,
-0.234341234,
1.3594971895,
0.8150134087,
0.3017739058,
0.3445974886,
0.0513036475,
0.3438468874,
-0.5180476904,
-0.2189631611,
-0.8964931369,
0.1891927272,
-0.3535135388,
-0.5553552508,
0.3955255747,
0.1373800188,
-0.1246968061,
0.4462502003,
-0.5975515842,
0.6120946407,
0.0008491465,
0.1220223755,
0.2385317534,
0.5653212667,
0.0528024398,
-0.300319463,
-0.7201905847,
-0.6467003822,
1.204518795,
0.0618139207,
0.5129669309,
0.3960511386,
0.828192234,
0.2641659975,
0.0516492575,
-0.5598617792,
0.7604588866,
-0.1832013726,
-0.4853886366,
-0.2843056023,
-0.5337480903,
-0.5135610104,
0.2230370641,
-0.3493862152,
-0.7352426648,
0.0828869864,
0.1232496127,
-0.0307908114,
0.3448512852,
-1.0441945791,
0.6875347495,
-0.351911217,
-0.7967446446,
-0.3287561834,
-0.4704632461,
0.0772840232,
-0.0707947761,
0.1382437646,
0.1282051206,
-0.7023534179,
0.5345873237,
-0.510148108,
0.8996394873,
-0.3612249792,
0.1374950856,
0.1967520565,
0.1650348455,
1.0101225376,
-0.3956426382,
-0.374777019,
0.1646213979,
0.1766130626,
-0.4485635459,
-0.6184185743,
0.5534581542,
-0.3004032969,
-0.5405967236,
-0.2590534985,
-0.2299478203,
-0.210718438,
-0.0343279652,
-0.0213506389,
0.2717164755,
-0.1966935992,
0.1243206039,
0.6738365889,
-0.4017057121,
0.272955209,
0.6916885376,
0.0141349025,
-0.2197954506,
0.9138334394,
0.1008224934,
0.2342026085,
0.7181400657,
-0.1268292964,
-0.5167452097,
-0.9683520794,
-0.566075623,
0.3220863342,
-0.5512124896,
-0.1546891183,
-0.6544615626,
0.3190740347,
-0.269333154,
0.0908394083,
-0.2774099708,
-0.5423415899,
-0.1571457684,
0.0864249021,
0.3942037821,
0.4707888663,
0.4295648336,
0.2148282081,
-0.8460173607,
-0.1938771755,
-0.2407733947,
0.3118150234,
-0.3328778446,
-0.456461072,
-0.129652217,
-0.2189045995,
0.0530629233,
-1.2956347466,
0.6006377935,
0.5892406106,
0.5081760883,
-0.1068147793,
0.203957364,
0.7442497015,
-0.7657279372,
0.7890696526,
0.3147233129,
-0.8759834766,
0.9616780877,
-0.3444913626,
-0.0235040523,
0.5216198564,
0.4196439087,
-0.2704081833,
-0.2745287716,
-0.1912891418,
-1.1156451702,
0.8354572058,
0.3134860694,
-0.0222714543,
-0.1535767764,
0.6294962764,
-0.1827213615,
0.2309888005,
-0.4484731555,
-0.1966425478,
0.1983203441,
-0.3332831562,
0.1757796109,
-0.4160840511,
-0.2466486543,
-0.1441383511,
0.6461367011,
-0.4121881723,
0.4559744895,
0.3577627242,
-0.2764634788,
-0.02812865,
0.5125982761,
0.4392377734,
0.8129152656,
-0.0923729613,
-0.2610383034,
0.5303029418,
-0.2291755676,
-0.0927288011,
-0.1248970404,
-0.2609190643,
0.0135634579,
0.0184041932,
0.5341761112,
-0.1294988245,
-0.718830049,
0.5088835359,
-0.0826744586,
0.2480686456,
-0.4741966128,
-0.2170804143,
0.0077036228,
-0.3471718729,
0.4681713879,
-0.0830936208,
0.3320445716,
-0.5047956109,
0.1515649706,
0.2766834497,
-0.3590633273,
-0.240912497,
0.5097083449,
0.5170701146,
-0.4964598715,
0.265204519,
-0.3023503721,
-0.2315640301,
0.4058966637,
0.9235790968,
0.7627909184,
-0.2518551648,
0.0350198112,
0.5045847297,
0.3604443967,
-0.096108593,
0.5954050422,
0.0962552503,
-0.4186053872,
-0.8227691054,
-0.6117862463,
-0.3834977746,
-0.3575032651,
-0.4368469715,
0.4576832056,
-0.4025865197,
-0.0146816,
-0.1875982583,
-0.392010957,
-0.2896988094,
0.0210830681,
-0.2090057135,
0.8375013471,
-0.6626756787,
0.7533915043,
0.8974066377,
-0.3428548276,
-0.5914667249,
-0.0865317658,
0.066773355,
-0.2217807472,
0.421600014,
-0.0155028058,
0.044223927,
0.0992485136,
-0.4266435504,
-0.4297994077,
0.8490210176,
0.3886107504,
-0.8345682621,
-0.097163409,
0.4660033584,
0.4760388136,
-0.7129622102,
0.4929828942,
0.8959991336,
0.3294040859,
-0.031788528,
-0.797944963,
0.2128198892,
-0.1254365742,
0.2937364578,
0.4871284366,
-0.1036629751,
0.5601513386,
-0.2337043285,
-0.3099655509,
0.0892541334,
0.5303746462,
0.2403521985,
0.1688792855,
0.5349953771,
0.4784270823,
0.5930845141,
-0.3567121625,
1.4019962549,
-0.4352529943,
-0.0766219944,
0.991677165,
-0.628247261,
1.2240885496,
0.7943750024,
-0.4570714831,
0.5168185234,
0.1990657747,
0.2129795253,
0.3295575678,
0.0063074515,
-0.4104382396,
-0.2807690501,
-0.3191012442,
-0.0472987033,
0.325702101,
0.603741765,
-0.3609053493,
-0.0862457529,
-0.3366270065,
0.0227019824,
0.5676543713,
-0.2564978302,
1.0031089783,
-0.0788403153,
-0.6227914095,
0.5244945288,
0.1692357808,
0.8147286773,
-0.6286451817,
-0.4216989577,
0.0701674521,
0.3009044528,
-0.459703058,
-0.5666571259,
0.6770189404,
0.2018373162,
-0.1273184419,
0.2231265455,
0.7470937371,
-0.4102385938,
-0.3944198191,
0.2719139159,
0.4468436539,
0.4115970731,
-0.1570575386,
-0.7641503811,
-0.0693991631,
0.1901082397,
0.0152417822,
0.291046679,
0.3876224458,
0.0513198562,
0.4200743437,
0.6316359639,
0.4053957462,
0.0996864289,
0.0238547679,
0.4653162658,
-0.7741872072,
-0.5136399269,
-0.7851667404,
0.5195477605,
-0.6073208451,
0.0541014858,
0.7179629207,
0.6649317145,
0.5295007229,
-0.105857797,
0.654946804,
-0.1467894167,
0.7702145576,
-0.5565175414,
0.6661784649,
-0.4606650174,
0.5380493402,
-0.0114783682,
-0.98800385,
-0.4645302892,
0.2854732275,
-0.3068137765,
-0.1821423322,
0.8188388348,
1.2937870026,
0.4760237634,
0.1054023802,
0.3843371272,
0.1191430762,
0.2473935485,
0.4944103062,
0.6341255903,
-0.4661642909,
0.6986682415,
-0.1019947529,
-0.307240665,
-0.0377897881,
-0.8411681056,
-0.7052636743,
-0.2859393358,
-0.3913663328,
-0.415968895,
0.5141208172,
0.9751985669,
0.732499361,
-1.0760588646,
-0.4498655796,
-0.5388865471,
-0.1188362986,
-0.3511143625,
-0.2025662959,
0.2242892683,
-0.6422815919,
-0.8718116283,
0.6165600419,
0.4094223678,
-0.1445104331,
-0.0787758157,
-0.0248205494,
-0.4842574,
0.3033640981,
0.6970337629,
0.0797649622,
-0.5855723023,
0.1044429615,
-0.213908419,
-0.0643039197,
0.0008792289,
0.7728559375,
-0.5374962091,
0.3012244701,
0.5961843133,
0.7102743387,
0.4547886252,
-0.2399568111,
0.9738478661,
-0.8715506196,
0.1098671183,
0.2720195055,
0.2830457687,
0.4922308326,
-0.6609418392,
0.8024674654,
0.2894634902,
-0.4112260342,
-1.1347999573,
0.1376497895,
-0.7107467651,
-0.273514241,
1.0716817379,
-0.242363587,
-0.7611318827,
-0.3471018374,
-0.116167143,
0.0539361201,
-0.2945635319,
0.4510903955,
0.3346230686,
-0.0807073191,
-0.1381377727,
-0.5357302427,
0.5454737544,
0.7221246362,
-1.1231353283,
0.0983295068,
0.4651850462,
0.2452324629,
0.2273739129,
0.3175997436,
-0.4511612058,
0.2862364948,
0.0275325291,
0.1748738587,
0.0377755463,
-0.2293905914,
-0.3364183605,
0.3451409042,
0.110871464,
-0.0255218185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13506v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13506v2
|
Parameter Efficient Fine Tuning: A Comprehensive Analysis Across Applications
| 2024-04-21T02:26:15 | 2024-04-23T21:28:26 |
Charith Chandra Sai Balne, Sreyoshi Bhaduri, Tamoghna Roy, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The rise of deep learning has marked significant progress in fields such as
computer vision, natural language processing, and medical imaging, primarily
through the adaptation of pre-trained models for specific tasks. Traditional
fine-tuning methods, involving adjustments to all parameters, face challenges
due to high computational and memory demands. This has led to the development
of Parameter Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques, which selectively update
parameters to balance computational efficiency with performance. This review
examines PEFT approaches, offering a detailed comparison of various strategies
highlighting applications across different domains, including text generation,
medical imaging, protein modeling, and speech synthesis. By assessing the
effectiveness of PEFT methods in reducing computational load, speeding up
training, and lowering memory usage, this paper contributes to making deep
learning more accessible and adaptable, facilitating its wider application and
encouraging innovation in model optimization. Ultimately, the paper aims to
contribute towards insights into PEFT's evolving landscape, guiding researchers
and practitioners in overcoming the limitations of conventional fine-tuning
approaches.
|
[
-0.5722723007,
-0.9786809683,
0.6142803431,
-0.0325896107,
-0.3586986959,
0.0312471762,
-0.5463058352,
-0.3387274444,
-0.4820657074,
0.3663780689,
-0.3872526884,
-0.271335423,
-0.5411128998,
0.0462796837,
-0.161517024,
0.8025103211,
-0.1207429394,
0.1285854727,
-0.150151819,
-0.2132468522,
-0.2481314987,
-0.3884879947,
-1.1518516541,
-0.4782192409,
0.3327471912,
0.231551975,
0.6342570782,
0.5915346742,
0.8600437045,
0.2633314431,
-0.0610073544,
0.5087763667,
-0.6023175716,
0.1430092305,
-0.2485755086,
-0.0643306747,
-0.489851743,
-0.1557802558,
0.920333147,
1.1073958874,
0.0723188445,
0.1547087729,
0.2992337644,
1.0322535038,
-0.9061462283,
-0.1491336524,
-0.7566753626,
0.0004883481,
-0.0451243035,
-0.4072065949,
-0.1212259457,
-0.1692301631,
0.2673809826,
-0.7123887539,
0.4111948311,
-0.3731660545,
0.8484914899,
0.6031057835,
-0.1433122903,
0.033428777,
-0.8714133501,
0.8877869248,
-0.6276278496,
0.7282206416,
0.2674650848,
0.31476897,
-0.20589073,
-0.9990472794,
-0.025408702,
-0.1645716429,
0.3130307496,
-0.0083635524,
-0.1043879464,
0.3640496433,
0.1579002887,
0.3938250542,
-0.2448241264,
0.1465365142,
-0.3034344614,
-0.1188486367,
0.5611670017,
0.0356594548,
0.0103500895,
0.5029043555,
-0.0220882297,
-0.196491003,
-0.584833324,
0.0593853258,
0.3693118095,
0.385119617,
0.2614609599,
0.1105669886,
-0.4225147963,
1.014580965,
0.5071717501,
-0.0418091938,
0.0223348867,
-0.3769110441,
-0.531768024,
-0.1267736256,
0.5033357739,
0.4522491992,
0.1759416759,
-0.0230210721,
-0.1094017401,
-0.3713370264,
0.3891132474,
-0.8869910836,
-0.3068885207,
0.0489619486,
-0.6451230645,
-0.2393795401,
-0.3777853847,
-0.7491915822,
-0.4157966673,
-0.5323320031,
0.3879673183,
-0.5048767328,
-0.0406723544,
0.3006872237,
-0.025740115,
0.2474763095,
0.5179950595,
-0.9769576788,
0.2525503635,
0.6449046135,
0.6803399324,
-0.119037576,
-0.1590810418,
-0.5307804942,
0.0384422466,
-0.5000563264,
0.767173171,
-0.7101119757,
-0.2408311963,
-0.3611834645,
-0.1009531841,
-0.1838226169,
-0.6590717435,
0.7224759459,
-0.2704542875,
-0.2944705188,
-0.2208013088,
-0.5011450648,
-0.3538897634,
0.094206959,
-0.5170992613,
0.8520262241,
0.0466482937,
-0.3279584646,
0.6466983557,
-0.6186606884,
-0.4377826154,
-0.1243135333,
0.0499432795,
-0.6772590876,
0.6321522593,
0.4511740208,
0.729363203,
-0.3201987445,
0.2814789116,
-0.3809267282,
-0.5291904807,
-0.0541517027,
-0.5082165003,
0.3078891635,
0.5821526051,
-0.3180012107,
0.0435299017,
-0.973315239,
0.1886921823,
0.0194778871,
-0.52495116,
-0.2359215766,
0.210784018,
-0.0608473457,
-0.3433649242,
0.0965790823,
-0.1731707156,
0.1174053997,
-0.6224400997,
0.7970861793,
0.4848736823,
0.0996060446,
0.5023989081,
-0.1669484973,
0.1167230979,
-0.3244323134,
0.4238970876,
-0.2390519828,
-0.086439684,
-0.5532721281,
-0.2298011184,
0.6402548552,
0.2506233752,
-0.186526686,
0.1575387418,
0.2539227307,
-0.662203908,
-0.5074915886,
0.226723969,
0.2292205542,
0.6401886344,
0.3720445037,
-0.1021567881,
-0.362170279,
-1.0263853073,
-0.6847633719,
0.0591334924,
0.0550866053,
0.4899371266,
0.0098840306,
-0.1072361544,
0.2669085562,
-0.2862790525,
0.0125058098,
0.0370871052,
0.0236145202,
0.235511601,
0.7303597927,
0.7966302633,
-0.8706589341,
-0.742915988,
0.2481952906,
-0.2788948119,
0.0939385071,
-0.5185168982,
0.0055615385,
-0.0541370623,
0.6689398885,
-0.1042756587,
0.1237311661,
0.1878236085,
-0.1327990741,
0.2745371163,
-0.570766449,
0.4716873765,
-0.4398599863,
0.1535184979,
0.1226305813,
-0.3102004826,
-0.7093893886,
0.3123691976,
0.2439247519,
-0.0782774091,
-0.4541401863,
0.2984590232,
-0.4883683026,
0.337465018,
-0.3438404202,
-0.4353631139,
0.0541370474,
0.2455312759,
-0.1112806574,
0.7775714993,
0.9135542512,
-0.7124046683,
0.0356515199,
-0.1744775176,
-0.0514138341,
0.4840188324,
-0.6615350842,
0.3179152608,
-0.1636399031,
-0.3413783014,
-0.8151655197,
-0.2002110183,
0.2136970609,
-0.1596092135,
0.6473717093,
-0.0737292171,
-0.5077335238,
-0.0386776328,
-0.3650004268,
0.4462676346,
0.6262017488,
-0.5352743864,
0.6605941653,
0.2362562567,
0.0337566696,
-0.1350909173,
-0.3633046448,
-0.1122469157,
-0.4061116278,
-0.2896047533,
0.8266429901,
-0.0881649926,
-0.0867967904,
-0.2921012342,
-0.278363049,
-0.3070517182,
0.3817001283,
-0.1328466386,
-0.2483715415,
-0.2534969449,
0.0502247959,
0.5683372617,
-0.0317493603,
-0.3022271693,
-0.3325659931,
0.2926853299,
-0.2158499062,
-0.0996571481,
-0.5073641539,
0.4465548694,
0.5162466764,
-0.2631451488,
0.4719178975,
0.7527748942,
-0.4715583622,
-0.0976949111,
-0.5852691531,
-0.1246020421,
-0.5603787303,
0.6309182048,
-0.3768086433,
-0.6385534406,
0.2470334321,
-0.8925120234,
0.0095547773,
0.4999481738,
0.615383625,
-0.245663479,
1.2394002676,
0.8491356373,
0.3707524538,
0.6347777247,
-0.1278100908,
0.1132463738,
-0.6638180614,
-0.0677094087,
-0.546779573,
-0.5572968125,
-0.4609421492,
-0.1415646076,
0.328424871,
0.4933321476,
-0.3961543143,
0.0319449529,
-0.981528163,
0.7144368887,
0.5767301321,
0.2494500726,
0.0767286271,
0.1767381877,
-0.0403697118,
0.0054633594,
-0.6199182272,
-0.3252110481,
1.2459545135,
0.3042444289,
0.6031327248,
-0.4787770212,
0.4702154994,
0.0516542904,
-0.3497621119,
-0.6448135972,
0.3571749628,
-0.6607011557,
-0.268871516,
-0.3472799063,
-0.1255462021,
-0.7415697575,
-0.1067637801,
-0.3517703414,
-0.4806340933,
0.4514717162,
0.5008630753,
-0.7438246012,
0.4048825204,
-0.8645790815,
0.6932920814,
-0.3641727567,
-0.4307705164,
-0.409437269,
-0.4474057853,
-0.2358162999,
-0.5446445346,
-0.3682327271,
-0.2733838856,
-0.3135226965,
0.6460344791,
-0.096952334,
0.6397675872,
-0.3899563551,
0.2181333005,
0.1679373533,
-0.1258257926,
0.2907676101,
0.0617447272,
-0.4076312184,
0.3148736358,
0.2649986446,
-0.4562960565,
-0.5575129986,
0.6734805703,
-0.7123243213,
-0.3374648094,
0.1302381903,
-0.560313642,
-0.5578441024,
0.353164196,
0.3259415329,
0.2363208383,
-0.1176574901,
0.4961686134,
0.7669818997,
-0.3636360765,
0.4573487043,
0.1768866926,
0.4077412188,
-0.3815495372,
0.9048935175,
0.3088659942,
0.0915482268,
0.3990974724,
0.3034314215,
-0.1131212786,
-1.3606722355,
-0.1802040637,
0.1080893725,
-0.4795783162,
-0.2270984054,
-0.3482355773,
-0.0604908951,
-0.2226258218,
-0.4680759609,
-0.7050109506,
-0.3067385852,
-0.5712826252,
0.1669180691,
0.4278081059,
0.1104013175,
-0.0235433262,
0.4851986468,
-0.5732175708,
0.504365921,
0.3087761104,
0.7550088763,
-0.1699878275,
-0.2515868843,
-0.2445192784,
-0.1218925342,
-0.5520374179,
-0.6312640309,
0.1029043719,
0.9920199513,
0.8381685615,
0.3437990546,
0.0459194593,
0.8235986829,
-0.4703525305,
0.6721998453,
0.220783025,
-0.8830045462,
0.8736872673,
-0.2815511823,
0.2295014858,
0.9731732011,
0.4205902219,
0.0786695033,
-0.0322216973,
-0.3762838542,
-1.0041342974,
0.2605015039,
-0.0251098126,
0.352727741,
0.4764377177,
1.0799460411,
0.5314030051,
0.104411535,
-0.0535007864,
-0.1199136004,
-0.1004426926,
-0.3500796258,
-0.0000696171,
-0.0648418888,
0.0081250537,
-0.8855912685,
0.5488475561,
-0.4934013486,
0.2435732633,
0.2604828775,
0.0132346032,
-0.1251559705,
-0.0130732525,
0.568669498,
0.7703187466,
-0.1676866412,
-0.0124881957,
0.3183534443,
-0.5375916958,
-0.0300862901,
0.201985836,
-0.2443984151,
-0.2176190466,
0.059816774,
0.9951034188,
0.0691315308,
-0.6813652515,
0.1374942809,
-0.018210426,
-0.6750835776,
0.1927262098,
0.5370828509,
-0.2073813528,
0.483122468,
0.4035672247,
0.4468365014,
0.4859093428,
-0.2311245054,
0.1773245931,
0.4800885916,
-0.4393947423,
-0.2260848433,
0.7888976336,
0.0882261693,
-0.2885224819,
0.3723711371,
0.3064775467,
0.0818911418,
0.3971703649,
0.2965807617,
0.8748651147,
-0.0299668536,
-0.0454305001,
0.2567856908,
0.1320513636,
0.0077032996,
0.3001869023,
-0.2271101475,
-0.4546719193,
-0.4859963655,
-0.780672133,
-0.3648802936,
0.268967092,
-0.4914862514,
0.2089230567,
-0.7983027697,
-0.4828002155,
0.4659183621,
0.287776351,
-0.8104895353,
0.2866159678,
0.1735677421,
0.9539911747,
-0.5374474525,
0.764837265,
0.9231523871,
0.0298481937,
-0.6811617613,
0.0029885089,
-0.2914651632,
-0.6292975545,
0.238249287,
-0.2130653113,
-0.0341370739,
0.1865001917,
-0.6030259132,
-0.6419289708,
0.7121436596,
0.9493361712,
-0.7174802423,
0.073002696,
0.0694388375,
0.5586532354,
-0.1371224374,
-0.1165230796,
0.9397476315,
0.5485458374,
-0.1213226169,
-0.8873296976,
-0.0392818414,
-0.1670698673,
0.0528647564,
0.2514255941,
-0.7149114609,
0.6236222982,
-0.0094883051,
0.0594781786,
0.119605802,
0.4093016088,
0.1172743812,
0.4092389643,
0.4093180001,
0.2496582568,
0.8893560767,
-0.1684198081,
0.7228248715,
-0.3791843057,
0.4151309729,
0.7184785008,
0.0413248017,
0.5885278583,
0.6899062991,
-0.320160985,
-0.1555382162,
0.9761482477,
-0.394850105,
0.8678690791,
-0.0099554863,
-0.0416053794,
-0.4653688669,
0.0845915303,
-0.3795486391,
0.4622518122,
0.3136012256,
-0.6317830086,
-0.2539585531,
0.261351943,
-0.3786724508,
0.0999770835,
-0.6860089898,
0.8957254291,
0.0391421765,
-0.5244590044,
0.8125206828,
-0.0287411772,
0.5319364071,
-0.3744049072,
-0.1269476861,
0.0570196509,
0.3718574643,
-0.1428693831,
-0.4927940667,
0.4671696424,
-0.2055702955,
-0.2446726561,
-0.2700617313,
1.0317374468,
0.0020641801,
-0.5961862206,
0.1112572476,
0.3545929492,
-0.0128924148,
-0.3946331143,
-1.1346433163,
0.1574744135,
0.0017626798,
-0.2014383376,
0.3726905286,
0.1900908798,
0.2310578674,
0.3150576353,
0.668073833,
0.2556368113,
-0.0192476436,
-0.0541774742,
0.8346431851,
-0.5591756701,
-0.3001890779,
-0.9084679484,
0.3222682774,
0.0127761969,
-0.3386889994,
0.3858486116,
0.3526510894,
0.8581174612,
-0.0429944992,
0.5914138556,
0.3137184083,
0.4359245598,
-0.5564826727,
0.8476638794,
-0.8353838325,
0.0018107903,
-0.3664249778,
-0.8205628991,
-0.7271184325,
0.5865130424,
-0.2619099319,
0.1448523104,
0.4775492847,
0.4838004112,
-0.2868718207,
-0.012854211,
0.3677265346,
-0.0616352148,
0.1090282202,
0.4743173122,
0.4522530437,
-0.4912451506,
0.3513385653,
-0.4341207743,
-0.1609457433,
-0.1876333058,
-1.006196022,
-0.6939210892,
-0.5376474261,
-0.7260191441,
0.1513796449,
0.2599629164,
0.5333174467,
1.2285753489,
-0.920214653,
0.2590526342,
-0.310200721,
-0.2681533992,
-0.6970996261,
-0.0815372914,
0.5888890624,
-0.4295001924,
-0.8453551531,
0.4863080084,
0.4211857021,
-0.0182301067,
0.1090045571,
-0.0826585889,
0.109365955,
0.2344043404,
0.5797093511,
0.4108252227,
-0.5804229379,
-0.1919710189,
0.1001450047,
0.3032936752,
0.2330897152,
0.8087306619,
-0.8443714976,
0.5003678799,
0.6068778634,
1.0062088966,
0.5680977106,
-0.2451793849,
0.6865177751,
-0.5007091165,
-0.0258277133,
0.2997020781,
0.1586481929,
0.2462730408,
-0.6326212883,
0.4929027259,
0.059311904,
-0.6579210758,
-1.0267025232,
-0.0681175366,
-1.045784831,
-0.6529994011,
0.5771493316,
0.1243280321,
-0.1520211697,
0.0771992058,
-0.3051336408,
0.3896009028,
-0.1804201007,
0.5973884463,
0.2572708428,
-0.65020895,
-0.2749510109,
-0.5550090075,
0.6477704048,
0.4866531193,
-0.5878586769,
-0.0875776038,
0.1641352624,
0.2427932471,
-0.1836436987,
0.4355199337,
-0.0656142831,
0.388338536,
-0.2136692554,
-0.50629282,
-0.2825449109,
-0.4163271487,
-0.5061301589,
0.5538340211,
0.2108714432,
-0.1250069588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13504v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13504v1
|
IMO: Greedy Layer-Wise Sparse Representation Learning for Out-of-Distribution Text Classification with Pre-trained Models
| 2024-04-21T02:15:59 | 2024-04-21T02:15:59 |
Tao Feng, Lizhen Qu, Zhuang Li, Haolan Zhan, Yuncheng Hua, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine learning models have made incredible progress, but they still
struggle when applied to examples from unseen domains. This study focuses on a
specific problem of domain generalization, where a model is trained on one
source domain and tested on multiple target domains that are unseen during
training. We propose IMO: Invariant features Masks for Out-of-Distribution text
classification, to achieve OOD generalization by learning invariant features.
During training, IMO would learn sparse mask layers to remove irrelevant
features for prediction, where the remaining features keep invariant.
Additionally, IMO has an attention module at the token level to focus on tokens
that are useful for prediction. Our comprehensive experiments show that IMO
substantially outperforms strong baselines in terms of various evaluation
metrics and settings.
|
[
-0.3467908204,
-0.5666771531,
0.4423245192,
0.0974784568,
-0.3637398183,
0.0570358783,
-0.0589416921,
-0.6347903013,
0.3515661955,
0.760977149,
-0.5526188016,
-0.2570745051,
-1.0845170021,
-0.0465279073,
-0.3861961067,
1.032733798,
-0.0473421067,
-0.1053866893,
-0.4033138752,
-0.4441594183,
-0.3604286611,
-0.7531537414,
-0.2758997083,
-0.3303036988,
0.1239755303,
0.4880157709,
0.5009194613,
0.5541777611,
0.2874889374,
0.3423464894,
0.3725068271,
0.2893798351,
-0.4377939999,
0.0541585796,
-0.1816344261,
-0.3855645657,
-0.330454886,
0.2228740305,
0.813190937,
0.5774772763,
-0.0770901442,
-0.0261249226,
0.453589201,
0.5000236034,
-0.9294263124,
0.0614223033,
-0.9338108301,
0.184598133,
0.0094392486,
-0.2282585353,
-0.6586031914,
0.1687919945,
0.3432605267,
-1.0228812695,
0.223121509,
0.3591240942,
0.9150949717,
0.2411479354,
-0.3446307778,
-0.2600317597,
-0.5838589668,
1.1107494831,
-0.2686400115,
0.2197440118,
0.7072110772,
0.2040468305,
0.086244069,
-0.7454192638,
-0.380851835,
-0.0904987007,
-0.0250919219,
0.2154630572,
-0.1580106616,
0.0501776487,
-0.0648094639,
0.2687069178,
-0.3833548427,
0.1107247993,
-0.1435308605,
-0.0219352674,
0.4489248991,
-0.2740924656,
0.1433213502,
0.2054524869,
-0.6765291095,
0.0719489381,
-0.4636590481,
-0.2951138318,
0.3957442939,
0.2712332904,
-0.0665178597,
0.4817561507,
-0.0968824476,
0.7224373817,
0.0963765383,
-0.0037559874,
0.1682397276,
0.0267684087,
-0.3225325644,
0.0116879502,
0.5521132946,
-0.2803120017,
0.14401564,
-0.3335593939,
-0.205729112,
-0.2842247784,
0.5008359551,
-0.9188469052,
0.0863172412,
0.1150344759,
-0.567276895,
-0.2510839403,
0.3439134061,
-0.6221590638,
-0.4028201699,
-0.3653230965,
0.7377719879,
-0.1502033025,
-0.111750342,
0.142107591,
-0.1384024024,
-0.3839494586,
0.392788887,
-0.945343554,
0.3328113258,
0.3428577781,
0.942489028,
-0.1188112944,
-0.5299558043,
-0.6543506384,
0.2796750069,
0.0643586442,
0.7923921943,
-0.6514024734,
0.2220510691,
0.0099362358,
-0.0695850924,
-0.3177669942,
-0.782662034,
0.3028482497,
-0.6012063026,
0.2443831563,
0.4078136086,
-0.579179287,
-0.2632775307,
0.4732500911,
-0.6781805754,
0.7782766223,
0.6608864665,
-0.7532544136,
0.5138941407,
-0.4696151614,
-0.1063724235,
0.0823101923,
0.0426038019,
-0.8398686051,
0.088173151,
0.2291718572,
0.672480464,
-0.2236079276,
0.0584602356,
-0.5875518918,
-0.4499858022,
0.3217550218,
-0.2261664569,
0.5156615376,
0.3093224466,
-0.3295979798,
-0.0852348134,
-0.8683101535,
0.1137323081,
0.1614444107,
-0.2707045376,
-0.6680976152,
-0.1214582473,
-0.0149094937,
-0.0346281379,
-0.0165663604,
-0.4086481929,
0.2981214523,
-0.3707009554,
0.7804798484,
0.8096193671,
0.070956938,
0.8301149011,
-0.2461996228,
0.5677632093,
0.4079966545,
0.2502131164,
-0.0434144363,
-0.6255143881,
-0.4975503981,
-0.6601269841,
0.55559659,
0.5215308666,
-0.8688061237,
0.6395443678,
-0.0483511314,
-0.0709867701,
-0.1192943156,
0.3977792859,
0.3818795681,
0.3041352928,
0.2081638873,
-0.4359699488,
-0.244669795,
-0.4601330757,
-0.2113260031,
-0.1830079406,
0.1991830468,
0.2250730991,
0.4176809788,
-0.6515416503,
0.9028574228,
-0.427252233,
-0.8279331326,
-0.3025763035,
0.2034104764,
-0.1473813206,
0.4989108741,
0.6309944987,
-1.0145841837,
-0.5374516845,
0.3057667911,
-0.6266043186,
0.1515413374,
-0.0577899739,
-0.298377037,
-0.0035259663,
0.503180325,
-0.4212547541,
0.1840660423,
0.5658618808,
-0.0093136868,
-0.0856056437,
-0.3164246678,
-0.0344710127,
-0.9882176518,
-0.2273128778,
0.1507973373,
-0.3890042603,
-0.4362958074,
0.0662795007,
0.2209376246,
-0.4301664829,
-0.293464154,
0.7439438105,
-0.4890079796,
0.1046335772,
-0.2837401628,
0.0538363121,
0.2107816488,
0.6370007992,
-0.1158442795,
0.6095013618,
0.5466660261,
-0.7945452332,
-0.1217959896,
0.0699280873,
-0.443194747,
0.5235204697,
-0.2588798404,
0.2094167173,
-0.2899552286,
0.1003979221,
-0.7810240388,
-0.4162313938,
0.4770525098,
-0.3779166043,
0.4977219105,
-0.3477363288,
-0.4232250452,
-0.0601737425,
-0.2601230443,
0.7546750307,
0.4236795604,
-0.7216239572,
0.5882299542,
0.7877812982,
0.2514372766,
-0.9418569803,
-0.5892530084,
-0.2018263787,
-0.5304042697,
-0.182094574,
0.447299242,
-0.0486341044,
0.0192713458,
0.185528487,
0.0868938044,
-0.6486147046,
0.2112012357,
0.166570574,
-0.1656427532,
-0.0242829751,
0.3340539634,
0.2591620982,
-0.0126265865,
-0.2538040578,
-0.7395412326,
0.3298838735,
0.1952158511,
-0.1058624759,
-0.065211162,
0.4713458717,
0.3922801614,
-0.2105571032,
0.7352930903,
0.2617579997,
-0.711509347,
-0.9304639697,
-0.1381135434,
0.0855143145,
-0.43630597,
0.4651488364,
-0.2922245264,
-0.8191713691,
0.460301429,
-0.3238997161,
-0.3354578614,
0.4127555192,
0.1240969896,
-0.0720308796,
1.2634476423,
1.299978137,
-0.0458683074,
0.7492571473,
-0.5571895242,
0.121277079,
-0.5082271695,
-0.0276598558,
-0.4292823374,
-0.1587969065,
-0.1698136479,
-0.2284527868,
0.3403909206,
0.4416989088,
-0.0271085668,
0.2590747476,
-0.6357282996,
0.7711797357,
0.4330344796,
0.4885352552,
0.1081121936,
0.257322371,
0.2371765524,
0.0861870646,
-0.7351676822,
-0.2692645788,
1.1107707024,
0.3090600967,
0.5980754495,
-0.1107331365,
0.7496498227,
0.7896084785,
0.6709027886,
-0.9241588712,
0.1801016778,
-0.4183318615,
-0.477529496,
-0.206004709,
-0.4723819494,
-0.8436272144,
0.321274817,
-0.2613047361,
-0.3894590735,
0.545219183,
0.2973103821,
-0.0843139291,
0.2705556452,
-1.0281660557,
0.8795838356,
0.050080616,
-0.0170384832,
-0.0631653965,
-0.4894100428,
0.3402063251,
-0.3655859232,
0.1896121055,
0.0394652337,
-0.1820722818,
0.5002052188,
-0.5644442439,
0.9414337873,
-0.1463185549,
0.1663327664,
0.5509886742,
-0.3702072501,
0.4951005578,
0.126236856,
-0.087579146,
0.3429730833,
-0.3435052931,
-0.4728429914,
-0.6219078898,
0.4906930029,
-0.9935817122,
-0.085629724,
-0.5886071324,
-0.3696223497,
-0.3543674052,
0.4009215236,
0.673745513,
0.4371758401,
-0.1360135525,
-0.0374989547,
0.9079264998,
0.0700478852,
0.244566977,
0.1573032588,
0.1131103411,
-0.6371846795,
1.0463271141,
0.386110425,
0.2925443649,
0.7622758746,
0.192494303,
-0.2109899223,
-0.6911847591,
-0.6680496931,
0.1406766027,
-1.0279588699,
-0.5539308786,
-0.7638144493,
-0.3630229533,
-0.2638544738,
-0.1942426115,
-0.0988770425,
-0.3310142457,
-0.7204915881,
0.0782418102,
-0.0032999543,
1.0171635151,
0.1713724732,
0.7078956962,
-0.6192101836,
0.2315042466,
0.2203468829,
0.3956749737,
-0.067844823,
-0.6435495615,
-0.6964378953,
-0.1763602942,
-0.5637117624,
-0.5302097201,
0.5681983829,
0.5416610241,
0.5176736116,
0.6276347637,
0.2421993315,
0.6174120307,
-0.3781987727,
0.1902271062,
0.2128714472,
-1.0775369406,
0.4588258862,
-0.0375865065,
-0.0263611712,
0.4647892714,
0.5324645042,
0.1055539623,
-0.6024662852,
-0.6305092573,
-0.5809977055,
1.0232179165,
-0.0871642902,
0.3338095844,
0.1820911169,
0.621240437,
0.5787999034,
0.3047141135,
-1.0403838158,
-0.0418940559,
-0.3394203484,
-0.2353003025,
-0.1486689597,
-0.3329472244,
0.0726038888,
0.0103380587,
0.6553857327,
-0.4228957891,
0.2754932046,
0.1851910204,
-0.5027897954,
-0.3098328412,
0.0830717087,
0.482652396,
0.7240582705,
-0.2643240094,
0.2970276773,
-0.214261964,
-0.8124959469,
0.2914454043,
0.0635207966,
-0.2381269485,
-0.1783402413,
0.1793186963,
0.6024774313,
-0.0220384095,
-0.6037102938,
0.8114289045,
-0.1058835462,
-0.341057688,
-0.1215464771,
-0.0199498199,
-0.5634482503,
0.1088184863,
0.18565768,
0.5624779463,
0.3840082884,
-0.5661469102,
0.2070043385,
0.4037157893,
-0.6633294821,
-0.2075867355,
0.731115818,
-0.1271774173,
0.1714206785,
0.393917799,
-0.3233848214,
-0.44327268,
0.7273807526,
0.7533792257,
1.0625816584,
0.0009098414,
0.3224312067,
0.1491531134,
0.4237169027,
-0.1636341214,
-0.0410688557,
-0.3164973259,
-0.7908380628,
-0.2443130314,
-0.3242696226,
-0.6220139265,
0.0144435586,
-0.3773980439,
0.4456215799,
-0.6816228032,
-0.1184113994,
-0.1813358068,
-0.2086890638,
-0.3647217155,
0.3034408092,
-0.1219156682,
0.5083011389,
-0.8939477205,
1.0177875757,
0.8742693067,
-0.2694351077,
-0.2804529965,
0.2689932585,
-0.6116418242,
-0.8711082935,
0.5673215985,
0.4598065615,
-0.0276090112,
-0.0161598995,
-0.8611096144,
-0.9213328958,
0.8285880685,
0.7664711475,
-0.1600605398,
0.4143936634,
0.1944907606,
0.2129645646,
-0.5682522058,
0.1101160124,
-0.2009746432,
0.0049539087,
-0.0496642515,
-0.5208699703,
-0.2599944472,
-0.2712800205,
-0.0841122568,
0.2927353382,
-0.8746907115,
0.9966436028,
-0.1361030042,
-0.1967137307,
0.1067415848,
0.6914643049,
0.0536282286,
0.6733465195,
0.530590117,
0.6966953874,
0.7233687043,
-0.0073852157,
1.0904779434,
0.1637534648,
0.4987095892,
0.785564959,
-0.256444335,
0.5649718046,
0.0807599127,
0.0838777274,
0.3610338271,
0.5770546794,
0.4699886143,
1.0008864403,
0.1370386481,
-0.3524080217,
-0.2127212286,
-0.0846211165,
-0.3395803571,
0.3058496416,
0.4125415385,
-0.2856226265,
-0.0730808526,
0.4780964255,
-0.2010096461,
0.0400199108,
-0.5698751211,
0.7384235263,
0.1212537438,
-0.4569808841,
0.53756845,
0.1909253001,
0.6191864014,
-0.8806189299,
-0.22670874,
-0.1579632908,
0.6876943111,
-0.1177534908,
-0.3632698357,
0.1819040924,
-0.3051898479,
-0.5633344054,
-0.4019086659,
0.9509705305,
-0.3662472963,
-0.3273488283,
0.377315551,
0.2020510584,
0.0087541137,
-0.5322046876,
-0.7210285068,
-0.1241350397,
-0.2600314021,
-0.0808002725,
0.7826762795,
1.0111716986,
-0.3484985232,
0.6111249328,
0.2580734789,
-0.1670600176,
0.4048844278,
-0.073194325,
0.8294532895,
-0.3809192181,
-0.7875978351,
-0.5775360465,
0.3275557756,
-0.0029993204,
-0.4895379543,
0.6202201247,
0.4237157404,
1.0065284967,
-0.3093602061,
0.7963629961,
0.2056226432,
0.4391099215,
-0.6719893813,
0.6432772279,
-0.790876925,
0.0809157342,
-0.1237110943,
-1.1813701391,
-0.5526467562,
0.4920824468,
0.1913723052,
0.0927428752,
0.6908957958,
0.2327214628,
-0.4862789214,
-0.1649172157,
0.5372443199,
-0.0367992036,
0.0455136076,
0.4835672379,
1.0697185993,
-0.7116737366,
0.3281438351,
-0.4855648279,
-0.4612945318,
-0.1836525947,
-0.8726542592,
-0.9480724335,
-0.7842976451,
-0.4611350596,
-0.2787804902,
-0.0064017647,
0.6636964679,
1.0971112251,
-0.8368301988,
-0.0315047801,
-0.1513502896,
0.2812487185,
-0.37658301,
-0.223703146,
0.2550008297,
-0.5726520419,
-0.834697783,
0.0521166734,
0.4904352129,
0.1937683225,
-0.0911241919,
-0.0716538057,
0.1661662757,
0.0802253038,
0.7943874598,
0.3549017608,
-0.2525169551,
-0.1141712964,
-0.2963652015,
0.0253190026,
0.103485018,
1.0451586246,
-0.7835077047,
0.4218792915,
0.3660776317,
0.7881891727,
0.3016974926,
0.1149462759,
0.1831765771,
-1.1022037268,
0.5640556216,
0.2950110137,
0.4500783086,
0.0212461092,
-0.6248347163,
0.3973308206,
0.3541620374,
-0.594176352,
-0.9686337709,
0.0119618326,
-1.1244086027,
-0.4185291231,
0.8084233403,
-0.3263930976,
-0.1723483056,
-0.2922587693,
-0.0960484073,
-0.1903641522,
-0.2321596444,
0.7546764612,
0.5633436441,
-0.0109704575,
-0.1945824325,
-0.4794384241,
0.2648491561,
0.2548963428,
-0.9537608027,
-0.1344577819,
0.2081815302,
-0.0753545091,
0.1064591482,
0.8849532008,
-0.163465336,
-0.0685377717,
-0.1646152288,
-0.1870645732,
0.1561683416,
-0.8241664767,
-0.3766686618,
0.2021201104,
0.1798819602,
-0.3914962113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13465v1
|
Do "English" Named Entity Recognizers Work Well on Global Englishes?
| 2024-04-20T20:48:42 | 2024-04-20T20:48:42 |
Alexander Shan, John Bauer, Riley Carlson, Christopher Manning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The vast majority of the popular English named entity recognition (NER)
datasets contain American or British English data, despite the existence of
many global varieties of English. As such, it is unclear whether they
generalize for analyzing use of English globally. To test this, we build a
newswire dataset, the Worldwide English NER Dataset, to analyze NER model
performance on low-resource English variants from around the world. We test
widely used NER toolkits and transformer models, including models using the
pre-trained contextual models RoBERTa and ELECTRA, on three datasets: a
commonly used British English newswire dataset, CoNLL 2003, a more American
focused dataset OntoNotes, and our global dataset. All models trained on the
CoNLL or OntoNotes datasets experienced significant performance drops-over 10
F1 in some cases-when tested on the Worldwide English dataset. Upon examination
of region-specific errors, we observe the greatest performance drops for
Oceania and Africa, while Asia and the Middle East had comparatively strong
performance. Lastly, we find that a combined model trained on the Worldwide
dataset and either CoNLL or OntoNotes lost only 1-2 F1 on both test sets.
|
[
-0.4060908556,
-0.3774520755,
0.3539201319,
0.1425384432,
-0.1379980892,
-0.0872292593,
-0.33476457,
-1.0384411812,
0.3155350387,
0.1897140443,
-0.1956233829,
-0.2153383344,
-0.7285020947,
0.8744133115,
-0.5520442724,
0.7618350387,
-0.0941518024,
0.2660872936,
-0.032204397,
-0.3794651031,
-0.5307064652,
-0.618257165,
-1.1546214819,
-0.2585113645,
0.7048895359,
0.432515949,
0.4993853569,
0.1432205588,
0.8349211216,
0.2712864578,
-0.2983526289,
0.2266948074,
-0.3036160767,
-0.0410720222,
-0.3960062265,
-0.3572395742,
-0.2203571647,
-0.0652343184,
0.5710395575,
0.4847732782,
-0.0380433016,
0.0135073159,
-0.0499562435,
-0.0078473687,
-0.4415299892,
-0.1412923932,
-0.9398666024,
0.0870283023,
-0.2905980349,
0.1371130794,
-0.4105886817,
-0.0741567537,
0.4811833799,
-0.6648942828,
0.5210322738,
0.2659054995,
1.2605547905,
-0.0301377438,
-0.8849424124,
-0.3814215064,
-1.1043077707,
0.7119519114,
-0.3209425211,
0.7405383587,
0.1624180824,
0.432266593,
-0.1331817508,
-0.5775745511,
-0.449526161,
-0.0783184171,
-0.388374567,
0.0291110799,
-0.5624083877,
-0.1660986394,
0.3010240197,
0.4356117547,
-0.4771822691,
0.2521889508,
-0.4918293059,
-0.318642199,
0.5301657915,
-0.1238104999,
0.3770152032,
-0.2838562429,
-0.3062053621,
0.4637703598,
-0.9613226652,
0.1576040238,
0.0116059696,
0.6105041504,
-0.1481975764,
0.2190214694,
0.0876978263,
0.5080124736,
-0.0056721177,
-0.3095360398,
0.0878229439,
-0.0130993947,
-0.2673366368,
0.132354632,
0.4493023455,
0.3971584737,
0.5557373166,
-0.6703726649,
-0.3516682684,
-0.0291241594,
-0.0812897608,
-0.8294795752,
-0.4196445048,
-0.1766611785,
-0.1991959065,
0.2668332458,
0.1951094717,
-0.159138009,
-0.3457866609,
-0.2687488794,
0.5386574268,
-0.1838323623,
-0.3863300383,
0.0253709126,
-0.250323534,
0.3059277534,
0.1226422563,
-0.5694667101,
0.3973215222,
0.4317219555,
0.7189372778,
-0.3503092825,
-0.2462361604,
-0.3808698058,
0.0430409573,
-0.0882837102,
0.9834135771,
-0.4987150431,
-0.2169912606,
-0.1948005706,
0.534196794,
-0.2040710449,
-0.7090138197,
0.3580804169,
-0.6363914609,
0.219747901,
-0.5350852609,
-0.5253460407,
-0.1077044085,
0.3545641303,
-1.159389019,
0.5914383531,
-0.2021708935,
-0.9896851778,
0.781834662,
-0.2858501375,
-0.7446861267,
-0.0825834945,
-0.1180763543,
-0.2468039691,
0.2922135592,
0.421522826,
0.4650490582,
-0.4259966016,
0.3753854334,
0.2110779136,
-0.6402556896,
0.1558064371,
-0.7378741503,
0.4700443447,
-0.1427881569,
-0.2081238925,
-0.8188719153,
-0.9281073809,
-0.2755346596,
0.3074453175,
-0.323653549,
-0.7993401289,
0.0733230859,
0.2319058627,
0.1252159774,
-0.3651716411,
-0.8259658813,
0.1183846295,
-0.2300926894,
0.463119626,
0.2703394294,
0.2498736829,
0.3066312969,
-0.0860602781,
0.6164176464,
0.1641552299,
-0.306607753,
0.0087660002,
-0.3777708411,
-0.8680482507,
-0.206025809,
0.7836933732,
0.666187048,
-0.5636798739,
-0.1152743325,
-0.5056292415,
-0.4911862612,
-0.4689467251,
-0.3358056843,
0.3401745558,
0.425111711,
0.4225645065,
0.0779447109,
-0.801609993,
-1.1679400206,
-0.4015000463,
0.1562967449,
-0.16149652,
0.4875915051,
0.4695537388,
-0.0293842517,
0.9110352397,
0.0395588614,
-0.2517331243,
-0.4076876938,
-0.0218404531,
0.142025888,
0.0221961923,
0.394543618,
-0.9948781133,
-0.3326675892,
-0.035790395,
-0.5897656679,
0.038759727,
-0.2293285578,
0.0996958837,
0.3834195435,
0.1852394342,
-0.3764057755,
0.4044355154,
0.7021794319,
-0.3815259337,
0.2515210509,
-0.0331790186,
0.279270649,
-1.2145608664,
0.0619966984,
0.1053600609,
-0.2124248892,
-0.481249541,
-0.3136883974,
0.3610080183,
0.0092123635,
-0.6400918961,
0.93598634,
-0.8315052986,
0.0061853542,
0.1601954997,
0.0871140733,
0.2150525153,
-0.0594462305,
0.2245813012,
1.0459884405,
0.4716499746,
-0.7700558901,
0.0403578915,
0.2103479207,
-0.4644265473,
0.696302712,
-0.7105459571,
0.0466264039,
-0.2264543176,
0.1062418446,
-0.6089360714,
-0.2407040745,
-0.2021126449,
-0.0774472058,
0.2729656398,
-0.3504966199,
-0.1599422246,
-0.438683182,
0.2221165895,
0.1835467517,
0.1398251653,
-0.9736967087,
0.4891396463,
0.5441762805,
-0.0331227034,
-0.572034955,
-1.0401008129,
0.2853583395,
-0.371686548,
-0.5462138653,
0.6974679232,
0.3260137439,
-0.3078701794,
0.0093833152,
-0.389610827,
-0.3000662923,
0.1195514724,
0.1372144073,
0.106716387,
-0.3261348307,
0.2281267047,
-0.1793424487,
-0.0804559514,
0.0713823363,
0.0589641184,
0.0189144872,
0.0266703889,
-0.0812955573,
-0.2355403602,
0.2551251948,
0.3375979364,
-0.4710155427,
0.8111726046,
0.2076520622,
-0.6426159143,
-0.2899945676,
-0.6259482503,
-0.0614933297,
-0.4137378633,
0.4102595747,
-0.6502732635,
-0.7549307942,
0.8223283887,
0.2404278219,
-0.0881170928,
0.4276230335,
-0.1309158355,
0.0689063445,
0.8032768369,
0.6902116537,
-0.2140738815,
0.1912683994,
-0.5377486348,
0.6616615653,
-0.6804189682,
-0.1608854234,
-0.5131981373,
-0.5450946689,
-0.8134068251,
0.0342509933,
0.08887849,
0.1215351969,
0.0332049094,
0.5512856841,
-0.3929920197,
1.0501867533,
0.2730634809,
-0.3535783887,
0.4898098111,
0.0975714996,
-0.0198134445,
-0.4380759597,
-0.5880640745,
-0.5112079382,
0.909208715,
0.016750114,
0.7441741824,
0.1279851943,
0.7564134598,
0.0725161955,
0.3614285588,
-0.6439983249,
0.4398127198,
-0.3731185794,
-0.4544975162,
0.050658673,
-0.3952968717,
-1.3621171713,
0.1533228904,
-0.0778173208,
-0.4957675934,
0.1929103285,
0.1193687171,
-0.2968461514,
0.6149222851,
-0.5663895607,
0.757743597,
-0.2844501436,
0.2286039293,
0.2913814783,
-0.145912081,
0.1992443949,
-0.1066905707,
0.3966966569,
-0.1902962327,
0.0301508512,
0.7072931528,
0.1214744151,
0.1968162656,
-0.3020805418,
-0.0093400357,
0.1020986959,
0.0213936642,
0.5264122486,
0.3632870615,
-0.0809963197,
0.7242320776,
-0.3339146972,
-0.0399733894,
-0.4790202975,
0.6584931612,
-0.6548794508,
-0.3247709274,
-0.4094793797,
-0.200568065,
-0.0565303154,
0.1898133904,
0.6832790375,
0.8083531857,
-0.4123272002,
0.296141088,
0.3999738097,
0.0960337445,
0.4475124478,
0.8932502866,
-0.110759981,
-0.3435629308,
0.6922898889,
0.6350533366,
-0.0574289076,
0.4272354245,
-0.1492457241,
-0.0597934723,
-0.6496802568,
-0.3090729117,
0.207104072,
-0.4246811271,
-0.4252638221,
-0.6717613339,
-0.3758244216,
0.0382022038,
-0.1672888249,
-0.0799533576,
-0.3555183113,
0.047431916,
-0.2310287654,
0.3281077147,
0.7959373593,
0.1547612548,
0.0594899654,
-0.7919389009,
0.2462394238,
0.2271236777,
0.2562481463,
-0.3636707962,
-0.6022822857,
-0.3281769753,
-0.0936789587,
0.1482975781,
-1.0130004883,
0.2906310558,
0.427664578,
0.5617786646,
0.128801167,
-0.004008607,
0.729036808,
-0.8416490555,
0.724958241,
-0.4327640235,
-0.6541067362,
0.4680681229,
-0.0870171189,
0.1429878622,
0.6347058415,
0.5899785757,
-0.9007909298,
-0.6987431049,
-0.6072238684,
-0.9605823159,
0.4868172109,
0.0765574872,
0.3263137937,
-0.4778120518,
0.3185190558,
0.1074525565,
-0.0105744954,
-0.8973135352,
-0.3379768431,
0.5365567803,
0.0303925425,
-0.0364561826,
0.0642176718,
0.4605890512,
-0.1237634048,
0.8804064393,
0.1322227269,
0.1639039814,
0.538038969,
-0.5115907192,
0.0791355371,
0.4444982708,
-0.0619573519,
0.6695474982,
-0.0792813823,
0.0446055569,
0.3438620269,
-0.5170137882,
0.3236472011,
0.4014475644,
-0.6872856021,
0.4038195908,
0.2497790009,
0.6487112641,
0.6082135439,
-0.5056475997,
0.4100497365,
-0.6006088257,
0.0478921458,
-0.5594521761,
-0.0155609995,
0.0780701041,
0.0936300829,
0.538312614,
0.2230380625,
0.1996745765,
-0.1251272857,
0.0330529064,
0.5576611161,
-0.0250306875,
-0.3846681118,
0.7197031379,
0.3523471355,
-0.6180744767,
0.7855184078,
-0.6199499369,
-0.5792961717,
0.8966022134,
0.8547661304,
0.7329009175,
-0.176104337,
-0.0217496473,
0.4213781655,
0.5567392707,
-0.1036677435,
0.3454628289,
0.2649730742,
-0.9889010191,
-0.3612885773,
-0.4179517329,
-0.5625404716,
0.4530252218,
-0.784783721,
0.4694753885,
-0.0156683605,
-0.202266857,
0.2221297771,
0.0085597802,
-1.3411509991,
0.3974070251,
0.3789666891,
1.0612919331,
-1.0746510029,
0.5958081484,
1.1705440283,
-0.2617185712,
-1.2077667713,
0.2193561047,
0.004461329,
-0.3388802111,
0.6350001693,
0.7710013986,
0.0689926594,
0.0655190498,
-0.051201947,
-1.4473019838,
1.1544511318,
0.3182523847,
-0.6730205417,
-0.0819903612,
0.1349906921,
0.3655148149,
-0.3063214123,
0.4964593947,
0.612691462,
0.2993174493,
-0.1816478521,
-1.2169539928,
-0.2351648211,
-0.2972149551,
-0.0334395207,
0.5662943125,
-0.6606160402,
0.8123651147,
-0.1958145797,
-0.5420432687,
-0.2672570348,
0.5226708651,
0.0406849347,
0.2605956495,
0.527883172,
0.685429275,
1.1741456985,
-0.2704187632,
0.9140411615,
-0.3116692603,
0.2943617105,
1.0892478228,
-0.5763146877,
1.1045987606,
0.1608388871,
-0.2891206443,
0.5204613209,
0.4446277022,
-0.1870023161,
0.434437871,
0.0366767161,
-0.045723781,
-0.1626677215,
-0.1338209957,
-0.201928556,
0.6800886989,
0.0187273249,
-0.143710807,
-0.2204678059,
0.3577452004,
0.2957787812,
-0.2321433127,
-0.4448533952,
0.6311047673,
-0.0230249204,
-0.6967239976,
0.4667244256,
0.0863255188,
1.019765377,
-0.4610868692,
0.1577189416,
-0.6405361295,
0.183593601,
-0.0837146491,
-0.3537505567,
0.3548262119,
0.3184711337,
-0.332025975,
0.1263370961,
0.8823647499,
-0.4993137121,
-0.7332807779,
0.5849670768,
0.4706713557,
0.3253882527,
-0.0986712128,
-0.2683095634,
-0.223411262,
-0.1862412393,
-0.2572494149,
0.1277037263,
0.5012780428,
-0.1140398607,
0.4260438979,
0.2728399336,
0.3530454636,
-0.0470291711,
0.2214268595,
0.303491354,
-0.6675896049,
-0.3452704251,
-0.6628637314,
0.4951366782,
-0.2926549613,
-0.2921212018,
0.8872776031,
0.8191661835,
1.2854088545,
0.3149742186,
0.7485561967,
-0.0842268541,
0.7836948037,
-0.5211588144,
0.6543384194,
-0.6046053171,
0.1181694418,
-0.0161830541,
-1.072481513,
-0.3660367727,
0.5775877237,
-0.2777817249,
-0.1303054392,
0.7288075686,
0.6755611897,
-0.4737360775,
0.1564911604,
0.2741952538,
0.227978155,
0.2246199548,
0.5318402648,
0.7906280756,
-0.6913228631,
0.6415005922,
-0.2770565748,
0.340064615,
0.116931729,
-1.0280264616,
-0.8313366175,
-0.194039017,
-0.358938545,
-0.2230729759,
0.2802380323,
0.9686718583,
0.6865829229,
-1.106626153,
0.3092086315,
0.0940320045,
0.0106556769,
0.023659138,
-0.2363003343,
0.2793144584,
0.0365635492,
-0.7906402946,
0.5790977478,
-0.1194942221,
0.10373009,
0.0267596524,
0.107705079,
0.1397088468,
0.1085558683,
0.3111563623,
0.1765542924,
-0.843808949,
-0.5395463109,
0.300235033,
-0.2065995634,
0.0211091973,
0.7149142623,
-0.9804908633,
0.0752219707,
0.0802114382,
0.5557233095,
0.0030677211,
-0.0452154279,
0.3732336164,
-0.9798303843,
0.1029362231,
0.1607419997,
0.7842881083,
0.7374773622,
-0.5029978156,
0.560264945,
0.1329442859,
-0.7897789478,
-0.6862618327,
-0.2643735409,
-0.3416306973,
0.172406435,
1.2344994545,
-0.169918716,
0.1066697985,
-0.218655467,
0.1153566167,
-0.1315633953,
-0.362334609,
0.4727598727,
0.8038677573,
0.0533671975,
0.1113003865,
-0.6774950624,
0.3424135447,
0.1871211678,
-0.715159297,
-0.193910107,
0.592810452,
0.6061584949,
0.1805891097,
0.6419904828,
0.3141241968,
0.2431649268,
-0.2612515688,
0.0066911313,
0.0745471567,
-0.7534518242,
-0.4803328514,
-0.1139757484,
0.0070810462,
-0.0602129176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13439v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13439v1
|
Fine-Grained Named Entities for Corona News
| 2024-04-20T18:22:49 | 2024-04-20T18:22:49 |
Sefika Efeoglu, Adrian Paschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Information resources such as newspapers have produced unstructured text data
in various languages related to the corona outbreak since December 2019.
Analyzing these unstructured texts is time-consuming without representing them
in a structured format; therefore, representing them in a structured format is
crucial. An information extraction pipeline with essential tasks -- named
entity tagging and relation extraction -- to accomplish this goal might be
applied to these texts. This study proposes a data annotation pipeline to
generate training data from corona news articles, including generic and
domain-specific entities. Named entity recognition models are trained on this
annotated corpus and then evaluated on test sentences manually annotated by
domain experts evaluating the performance of a trained model. The code base and
demonstration are available at https://github.com/sefeoglu/coronanews-ner.git.
|
[
-0.2903666198,
-0.8595825434,
0.6498228312,
0.3966507316,
-0.2408661991,
0.2276371419,
-0.3185437024,
-0.7588866949,
0.3210045099,
0.6844131947,
-0.2735044062,
-0.6528476477,
-0.4315465689,
-0.0169118941,
-0.8179242611,
1.5258278847,
-0.1016706824,
-0.1118263602,
-0.0742949843,
0.3395400941,
-0.1783436984,
-0.1845382005,
-0.8784183264,
-0.172707811,
0.718693614,
0.489821732,
0.3790898621,
0.6207318306,
0.7061918378,
0.092708759,
0.2196641564,
0.2259390503,
-0.2976602614,
-0.0257526375,
-0.2900028229,
-0.2022629231,
-0.3548999131,
0.1701384932,
0.3066286743,
0.4445918798,
0.2356795073,
0.262009114,
-0.0440303013,
0.4465165436,
-0.6008991003,
0.2428501844,
-0.9207985401,
-0.1248434335,
-0.4839462638,
-0.3444540799,
-0.429974556,
-0.1045931876,
0.2464369535,
-0.6854140759,
0.3003608882,
0.1715247035,
1.3573818207,
0.0980393291,
-0.2375903428,
-0.4165134728,
-0.9623866081,
0.608024478,
-0.172600463,
0.2417722344,
0.4173217416,
0.1422279328,
-0.1450956166,
-0.9139265418,
-0.236823231,
-0.0090159103,
0.0961376727,
0.1708185971,
-0.3043467104,
-0.0180856157,
-0.1772266477,
0.570301652,
-0.2980508804,
0.3425825238,
-0.5203174949,
-0.0850510746,
0.6943213344,
-0.0529697426,
0.1437683254,
-0.5559535623,
-0.6761376262,
0.4758923054,
-0.5164945722,
0.0421542749,
0.3128970265,
0.4302082658,
-0.0774703696,
0.6517154574,
-0.1550734937,
0.5753377676,
0.1293268502,
-0.3341627717,
0.0976593047,
0.1453537494,
-0.5880627632,
0.3139300048,
0.6017318368,
0.3950786293,
0.2641818523,
-0.7054549456,
-0.1498206109,
0.1316408813,
0.4701085389,
-0.6839881539,
-0.6342382431,
0.2746111751,
-0.2933048904,
-0.5991322398,
0.3037467003,
-0.8348097205,
-0.3160840571,
-0.4330033064,
0.1084869951,
-0.4049267471,
0.09378355,
-0.1021823436,
-0.516661346,
0.1689424962,
0.5006169677,
-0.5900402069,
0.1256052405,
0.5534353852,
0.4831877947,
-0.2610824704,
-0.0150102777,
-0.7276291251,
0.3508140743,
0.0706127733,
1.1736198664,
-0.7668422461,
-0.0946039259,
-0.1830578297,
0.1352382004,
-0.0403418094,
-0.3769443929,
0.6286113858,
-0.6744550467,
-0.0531364828,
0.0543451719,
-0.777262032,
0.1342526823,
0.0575881265,
-0.630939126,
1.0056761503,
0.3360513151,
-1.1809465885,
0.345184505,
-0.2567066848,
-0.5024049282,
0.1968026906,
-0.0997897089,
-0.5305489302,
0.0629710853,
0.3632136583,
0.5549030304,
-0.25129354,
0.3609673679,
-0.1714533269,
0.1436398774,
0.0084619848,
-0.0098682754,
0.5357684493,
0.2345638424,
-0.1012654379,
-0.1306519806,
-1.2116308212,
-0.2764910758,
0.0110744657,
-0.4780736864,
-0.7982755899,
-0.0708132908,
0.4929069579,
-0.0486480035,
0.0523015559,
-0.6122837663,
0.4204651117,
-0.0878735036,
0.3623453081,
0.3848552406,
0.5610074401,
0.5468882322,
-0.0151747474,
0.4522946179,
0.2154966742,
0.0676358715,
-0.1356165856,
-0.3781366944,
-0.9483675957,
-0.4587970972,
0.6155029535,
0.6402010918,
-1.1231666803,
0.3112116456,
-0.1529711187,
-0.8186376691,
-0.3625736833,
-0.0619271807,
0.2433701754,
0.8111465573,
0.3793936372,
-0.1491397917,
-1.0215380192,
-0.8856561184,
-0.2729652226,
0.0993685275,
0.0150276329,
0.2225379497,
0.6073927879,
-0.3599340916,
1.3201116323,
-0.6566932201,
-0.3723032475,
-0.0222683419,
0.6284444332,
-0.2683641613,
0.3689197004,
0.3310814798,
-0.9601762891,
-0.1370953023,
0.0634737015,
-0.5957807899,
-0.0765752643,
-0.3094548881,
-0.0459658802,
-0.1468367279,
0.4939251542,
-0.3965575397,
0.4914197326,
0.3989052773,
-0.0383824669,
0.6837720275,
0.1353116632,
-0.0330223776,
-1.1300202608,
0.0354181714,
0.3464853466,
-0.57657969,
-0.597201407,
-0.1085914373,
0.1057964563,
-0.1707661003,
-0.7311133742,
0.6962367296,
-0.4831857085,
-0.2425433099,
-0.3465093374,
0.4001098275,
0.2694769502,
0.0878269672,
0.5073937178,
0.5126864314,
0.6919505596,
-0.8661082387,
0.5484167933,
0.0332100578,
-0.2826541066,
0.611877799,
-0.3456472456,
-0.1765124053,
-0.3742347658,
0.1819706559,
-0.2742891312,
-0.3746356666,
0.046216473,
-0.2852166593,
0.178009212,
-0.2820026577,
-0.4403409362,
-0.4494642317,
-0.1605796367,
0.0164631046,
-0.0109549956,
-0.4198210835,
0.1773503423,
0.7648018599,
-0.0742169693,
-0.2859823406,
-0.6309175491,
0.1313412338,
-0.4238061309,
-0.3003443182,
0.6781185269,
0.3882192075,
-0.2402775288,
0.2623742819,
-0.0751766115,
-0.7349485755,
0.3440039158,
0.2807906568,
0.3510131836,
-0.1939762831,
0.4463860393,
0.0862010494,
-0.0459789671,
-0.2742520571,
-0.1828541309,
0.4048739076,
-0.0536849573,
0.3499508202,
-0.4369696379,
0.2057913542,
0.2127676457,
-0.6178209186,
0.6807265282,
0.7502051592,
-0.7591192722,
-0.0933572724,
-0.2178606391,
0.1736138612,
-0.2944386899,
0.0206351206,
-0.2768547237,
-0.7912966013,
0.6728013754,
-0.2498179972,
-0.0931960493,
0.8379719853,
0.1774368882,
-0.0567436218,
0.2861443162,
0.7478646636,
-0.2021729201,
0.3878384531,
-0.3048619926,
0.1061230153,
-0.9395141006,
-0.3825176656,
-0.5821649432,
-0.0033650899,
-0.3133840263,
-0.4026530981,
-0.0523622781,
0.5057863593,
0.1080201566,
0.8675695658,
-0.482370019,
0.3131694198,
0.3907854557,
-0.1759383678,
0.5431206226,
-0.1535825133,
0.2546078861,
0.023025712,
-0.1507214308,
-0.7104759812,
0.7513586879,
0.546531558,
1.0140725374,
-0.4404088557,
0.8499243855,
0.3483554125,
0.4770963192,
-0.8369543552,
0.0110182632,
-0.2400040627,
-0.3840437829,
0.0061508622,
-0.2613007128,
-1.2147034407,
-0.4308735728,
-0.1079358533,
-0.9705873132,
0.42521137,
-0.2425902635,
-0.6406747699,
0.1122798175,
-0.506650269,
0.5680700541,
-0.0618887618,
0.3050078154,
0.2174757123,
-0.2872177958,
0.4724782407,
-0.3726677001,
0.2814626694,
-0.3293789029,
0.1073934734,
0.8142244816,
-0.1915454865,
0.5080459714,
0.0762468502,
-0.0974880457,
0.5023956895,
-0.3245546222,
0.4763947427,
0.5908449888,
0.1703237891,
0.0896844938,
-0.3342397213,
-0.1777885258,
-0.1827057898,
0.7439273596,
-0.4522867203,
-0.0317598209,
-0.3220892251,
-0.2575754225,
-0.0010152677,
0.2589229643,
0.4886267185,
0.5333606005,
-0.3690379858,
0.0268997122,
0.5294148326,
0.0034686057,
0.5568023324,
0.5093889236,
-0.4462203979,
-0.4041183591,
0.8425506353,
0.114974685,
-0.2566913366,
0.6770584583,
-0.3038359284,
0.2469453663,
-0.4399209917,
-0.4048656225,
-0.0921177641,
-0.2087520063,
-0.7274742723,
-0.7921904922,
-0.610019207,
-0.3614625037,
-0.2584620118,
-0.6845964789,
-0.4593735933,
-0.8459975719,
-0.1176914573,
0.3455079496,
0.7365643978,
0.4444909394,
0.5872944593,
-0.9211777449,
0.4226875007,
0.2073080391,
0.1491407901,
-0.3500426114,
-0.0102326693,
-0.486689657,
-0.1003272757,
-0.4944420159,
-0.8496807218,
0.4257822335,
0.2279468179,
0.1868793666,
0.60467273,
0.2479690164,
0.9493749738,
-0.5678558946,
0.6941621304,
-0.0400873013,
-0.8952778578,
1.0904092789,
-0.4006384611,
-0.1695622206,
0.5396983624,
0.4283795059,
-0.4008122087,
-0.8117684126,
-0.9008620977,
-0.7519355416,
0.5398404598,
0.4278211594,
-0.2495954335,
-0.4696791768,
0.4917493761,
0.1322039664,
0.30148983,
-0.5657933354,
-0.3966482282,
0.1506625712,
-0.0331373475,
0.3034802973,
-0.1831338257,
0.1758662462,
-0.0630853102,
0.7221079469,
0.1610102057,
0.2851736844,
0.5534662008,
-0.3767135739,
-0.0795158148,
0.2329569608,
0.3426088989,
0.4141256809,
-0.1114823967,
0.2755106986,
-0.3964436352,
-0.3964223266,
-0.2379164398,
0.5046948791,
-0.1081243306,
0.2468561381,
0.3279283941,
0.8405177593,
0.588126421,
-0.5657066107,
0.5357797146,
-0.1155438498,
0.2137971967,
-0.7005730271,
0.0665604696,
-0.174240455,
0.4028014839,
0.5239838362,
0.2810764611,
0.3399251401,
-0.6478930712,
0.4467496276,
0.2814906538,
-0.3726920784,
-0.3968711793,
0.8037279248,
0.2701385915,
-0.0657424331,
0.5225765705,
-0.3932238221,
-0.3224152625,
0.5869589448,
0.423274368,
0.685836792,
-0.1558271199,
0.4774169028,
0.0986790881,
0.1448512822,
-0.1259562522,
-0.0079209795,
0.2083508819,
-0.5972067118,
-0.2174407542,
-0.8567864299,
-0.0280016009,
0.4876316786,
-0.8630338907,
0.692435801,
-0.3122756481,
-0.2730640769,
0.7201507092,
0.2774642706,
-0.8618356586,
0.4087882936,
0.5382621288,
1.1910318136,
-0.95211941,
0.9737743139,
0.7589489222,
-0.5521416664,
-0.7489905953,
0.0524682179,
-0.4450664818,
-0.6040481925,
0.6363130212,
0.3008274436,
0.5042794943,
0.1928049922,
-0.3717618585,
-0.9506960511,
1.0985589027,
0.3743781745,
-0.5411706567,
-0.4259162843,
-0.1101888195,
0.4290986359,
-0.8757513165,
-0.0354880318,
0.5705567002,
0.5116422772,
-0.1847566217,
-1.0141450167,
-0.4783722758,
0.0146991005,
0.1137335375,
0.250623405,
-0.5548947453,
0.7000842094,
-0.0573725253,
-0.3485527337,
0.0332561582,
0.9714109302,
-0.137000367,
0.673402667,
0.1363079697,
0.9376655221,
1.1505293846,
-0.1221930385,
1.042812705,
0.0269615129,
0.7379490733,
1.3724440336,
0.0034111866,
0.7244458199,
0.3681669235,
-0.0263144355,
0.7957419753,
0.8559646606,
-0.3142029643,
0.6623865962,
0.0374355093,
-0.1672865748,
-0.0457453951,
-0.4502004087,
0.0504131578,
0.7358154058,
0.3635169268,
-0.8426581025,
-0.5291064978,
0.5332419872,
0.3585264981,
-0.1642132699,
-0.8277690411,
0.6710372567,
0.1249882802,
-0.4891048074,
0.0036382817,
0.4239390492,
0.3138861358,
-0.0567163341,
0.2210922241,
0.1524683833,
-0.0691341087,
-0.5176843405,
-0.7215214968,
0.4231831431,
0.4020673335,
-0.5376498103,
0.1251076311,
0.9098057747,
-0.6698130369,
-0.5659288168,
0.0632085875,
0.29721573,
0.3189199865,
-0.4000971913,
-0.4226003587,
-0.1290386617,
-0.1883820593,
-0.3122140765,
0.0806180909,
0.3497869074,
-0.2625527382,
0.2729197741,
0.3579799831,
0.2255863845,
0.1424147338,
0.1312009692,
0.9789378047,
-0.5994790792,
-0.2989948094,
-0.7223035097,
0.5528175831,
-0.2936348319,
-0.4107053876,
0.726590395,
1.0114971399,
0.6616564393,
-0.1422995329,
0.6453396082,
-0.1736815721,
0.3844093084,
-0.5072283149,
0.4775538743,
-0.1415466815,
0.1003895551,
-0.3105794489,
-1.0129885674,
-0.3462523222,
0.310282588,
-0.2834836841,
-0.4945496619,
0.7346984744,
0.129292354,
-0.0471689254,
0.0751195997,
-0.149506852,
0.0110474816,
0.3571248651,
0.4084249437,
0.4974176586,
-0.5353670716,
0.2243861556,
-0.4885249734,
-0.0356451347,
-0.2887943685,
-0.9340962768,
-0.9344386458,
-0.6512764692,
-0.6708687544,
-0.0940130875,
-0.0515374504,
0.6649596691,
0.6925836205,
-0.6079514623,
0.5878800154,
-0.4358179271,
0.1327839047,
0.1847484708,
-0.3955209255,
0.5320029259,
-0.4917375445,
-0.8290842772,
0.2659704983,
0.4137408435,
0.1137880608,
-0.191215232,
0.4333792329,
-0.0296235904,
-0.0502443872,
0.4480856657,
0.302477926,
-0.5334767699,
-0.5092225671,
-0.2781928778,
-0.3021935523,
0.0331773907,
0.8150666952,
-1.0064325333,
0.1757040918,
0.135166198,
0.662666738,
0.4090521336,
0.3107637465,
0.1476411968,
-1.2679573298,
0.1432757676,
0.2228282392,
0.284837842,
0.3766207099,
-0.7592383027,
0.3348344862,
0.2477677464,
-0.6171717644,
-0.700068891,
0.0314512551,
-1.1820396185,
-0.1045564339,
1.2573771477,
-0.2915224731,
-0.4785675406,
-0.1810679734,
-0.0917618871,
0.3493524492,
-0.6142024994,
0.702500701,
0.6100847125,
-0.1844548732,
-0.201509729,
-0.4001949728,
0.5809620619,
-0.5638899207,
-1.1597013474,
-0.0522743352,
0.2203701437,
0.2869128883,
0.2758939266,
0.589238584,
-0.0546499118,
0.1027080789,
-0.244645074,
0.1591675133,
0.1239547133,
-0.7658292651,
-0.0112753669,
0.0998498872,
-0.1310439706,
-0.1680573225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14449v1
|
Predicting Question Quality on StackOverflow with Neural Networks
| 2024-04-20T16:48:18 | 2024-04-20T16:48:18 |
Mohammad Al-Ramahi, Izzat Alsmadi, Abdullah Wahbeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The wealth of information available through the Internet and social media is
unprecedented. Within computing fields, websites such as Stack Overflow are
considered important sources for users seeking solutions to their computing and
programming issues. However, like other social media platforms, Stack Overflow
contains a mixture of relevant and irrelevant information. In this paper, we
evaluated neural network models to predict the quality of questions on Stack
Overflow, as an example of Question Answering (QA) communities. Our results
demonstrate the effectiveness of neural network models compared to baseline
machine learning models, achieving an accuracy of 80%. Furthermore, our
findings indicate that the number of layers in the neural network model can
significantly impact its performance.
|
[
-0.4844945073,
-0.863032937,
0.551379621,
0.1444808096,
-0.0019953875,
0.2096175551,
0.3322014809,
-0.5332278013,
0.4274523258,
0.3560136259,
-0.31876719,
-0.2508452535,
-0.4089696705,
-0.3503088653,
-0.7436702251,
0.906706512,
0.2451567799,
0.3664459586,
-0.7130579352,
0.1388082802,
-0.3300664723,
-0.4632798135,
-1.0513484478,
-0.2304185927,
0.8137532473,
-0.1564498395,
0.7704442143,
0.4288665354,
0.4532134533,
0.2873570621,
-0.4535009563,
0.1921600252,
-0.4166715443,
0.0622363091,
-0.1445697546,
-0.4468008578,
-0.1009812504,
-0.2947890162,
0.3240039349,
0.7057503462,
-0.0837301463,
0.5494683981,
0.1490750164,
0.4177671969,
-0.5853621364,
-0.1080692485,
-0.5950388908,
-0.0843152255,
0.4249752164,
-0.3086903691,
0.0921211541,
-0.916508019,
0.0302408766,
-0.3415190578,
-0.1341063529,
-0.0899996459,
0.6378353238,
0.2504874468,
-0.1763328016,
-0.1786028743,
-0.6981002688,
0.6157090664,
-0.9199474454,
0.1498150378,
0.5457499027,
0.4029234946,
-0.2104802728,
-0.5668362975,
-0.5114061236,
-0.0332815126,
0.0093828104,
0.2605898082,
-0.3917604983,
-0.2223809659,
0.0804499984,
0.1523530483,
-0.6866929531,
0.2002535462,
-0.7882151008,
0.0495500639,
0.4959149361,
0.1962601095,
0.5010122061,
-0.4102554321,
-0.3175411522,
0.3761910796,
-0.1825821847,
0.3416094482,
0.3865956664,
0.0802856684,
0.4967005849,
0.4004336298,
-0.0991981998,
0.6887998581,
-0.0133573506,
0.1633615047,
-0.0313947536,
-0.3736392558,
-0.0612383485,
-0.2460960746,
0.5832496285,
0.4560211897,
0.2653341889,
-0.2053922713,
-0.1008375287,
-0.1684780866,
0.7519541383,
-0.7786064148,
-0.0547928996,
0.7238543034,
-0.5642571449,
-0.4125337303,
0.0456199199,
-0.3205025196,
-0.5163547993,
-0.1217009574,
0.2865953743,
-0.22669442,
-0.4987023473,
-0.0640776008,
-0.341424197,
-0.1412035674,
0.3357361555,
-0.340439707,
0.1971832067,
0.8708688617,
0.9701203108,
-0.1269951314,
-0.1954562962,
-0.3527666926,
-0.5979034901,
-0.3442103863,
0.7434222102,
-0.3212992549,
0.0955436528,
0.1373794675,
-0.3666418493,
-0.100321129,
-0.3878196478,
0.3157832623,
-1.2252527475,
0.1080962121,
-0.154437393,
-0.9300421476,
-0.214214161,
0.6920089722,
-0.9009155035,
0.680842638,
0.0452738963,
-0.5526008606,
0.0710677877,
-0.6611021757,
-0.2853650153,
0.0884164423,
0.23467502,
-0.2300991416,
0.112655662,
0.2455540448,
0.478867054,
-0.0764245316,
0.0283279959,
-0.2870539427,
-0.3385109305,
0.7876184583,
-0.1431305707,
1.0447334051,
0.3532852232,
0.1620810777,
0.006449569,
-0.5685942173,
0.5262205601,
-0.2556245625,
-0.3564184904,
-0.2938995063,
-0.0767083317,
-0.0081822602,
0.637347877,
0.1904390603,
-0.7522608638,
-0.28025195,
-0.4956351519,
0.7410058975,
0.4732640386,
0.3242823482,
0.019866677,
-0.4853820205,
0.8570966721,
0.1749163717,
0.2448998541,
0.2906752527,
-0.9091021419,
-0.2887328267,
0.4863279164,
0.5412228703,
0.5693653822,
-0.7830376029,
0.3945747912,
-0.115455173,
-0.6463941336,
-0.5031469464,
0.2162319124,
0.3858996928,
0.4194394052,
0.4853788316,
-0.1614945233,
-0.363732785,
-0.3673739135,
-0.0604761727,
-0.4741464555,
-0.2411602587,
0.4223274291,
0.5102190375,
-0.0044318037,
0.95758003,
-0.3219793141,
-0.065946281,
-0.1597045213,
0.3121951222,
0.3340518475,
0.3981812596,
0.2884774804,
-1.0464645624,
-0.3012913167,
-0.1254226118,
-0.5051965714,
0.1400875896,
-0.0148320198,
-0.0744777545,
0.0099236546,
0.4230980873,
-0.4504233599,
0.1156359911,
0.7407294512,
-0.2242553085,
0.3281102479,
0.1081144363,
0.1487671584,
-1.4301580191,
0.1469073743,
0.3268517554,
-0.1196518317,
-0.7109928727,
0.0634963512,
0.2131362408,
-0.2790133953,
-0.6935722828,
0.4223311841,
-0.1067894995,
-0.2628638148,
-0.3484110236,
-0.0018103928,
0.459648639,
0.4606617689,
-0.2350751758,
0.5628327131,
0.2623066306,
-0.4569957852,
0.6631768346,
0.0775150657,
-0.7808850408,
0.2556971014,
-1.1862385273,
0.0019002259,
-0.1862079054,
0.2853550911,
-1.3209514618,
-0.0175905488,
-0.0860305578,
-1.0425145626,
-0.2487238795,
-0.3043915629,
-0.4189912677,
-0.7709735036,
-0.1329943985,
0.6053781509,
0.6042500138,
-0.2809824347,
0.3919938803,
0.4035981894,
0.0004233025,
-0.6984132528,
-0.8235686421,
-0.1935561597,
0.2744725645,
-0.8591704369,
0.1685774326,
-0.0509701818,
0.0498667993,
0.3178215325,
0.2105099708,
-0.7454875708,
0.4059967399,
0.4235188961,
0.0222936478,
-0.5684110522,
0.2203500569,
-0.3027392328,
0.1625184864,
0.4602315724,
-0.5339539051,
0.6388682723,
-0.0663799196,
-0.532300055,
-0.5573240519,
0.1774270833,
0.7851541638,
-0.4688708186,
0.9898079634,
0.4830353856,
-0.6593885422,
-0.1399399489,
-0.6410703659,
-0.4129734039,
-0.391848892,
0.4300091267,
0.2612783313,
-0.7225164771,
1.0214008093,
0.2460267842,
-0.1413182616,
0.4002163708,
0.135964781,
-0.5418770313,
1.4075951576,
0.3118071854,
-0.1909958273,
0.6248355508,
-0.2570845485,
0.0538728423,
-0.6557768583,
-0.2501313984,
-0.5445742607,
-0.6270383,
-0.2802747786,
-0.2567951977,
0.2203762978,
0.1527018994,
-0.0465336069,
0.3323229849,
-0.4171989262,
0.7157187462,
0.6742895246,
0.307084471,
-0.0632059351,
0.0159364697,
0.3460032046,
0.4384123385,
-0.8353281021,
-0.2409566641,
0.8130375743,
0.6645157933,
0.5923361778,
-0.1287433058,
0.3095205426,
0.2924570739,
0.0737494156,
-0.5186048746,
0.216912806,
-0.2577886879,
-0.8045387864,
-0.490883857,
-0.8801111579,
-0.8098224998,
-0.2137014568,
-0.2550350428,
-0.3311396539,
0.2712614238,
0.0889686272,
-1.2203111649,
0.6150405407,
-0.3821514845,
0.8615810275,
-0.3572411239,
-0.0075584007,
-0.0525038503,
-0.5067461133,
0.0198535882,
0.0349035002,
-0.1870253533,
0.0730659738,
0.144174099,
0.7607086301,
-0.3190311491,
0.8614909053,
0.0317966864,
0.2540468276,
0.6498644948,
-0.0625762939,
0.223288998,
0.1290486604,
-0.5735462904,
0.4062210917,
0.1588793844,
-0.5584157705,
-0.8910690546,
0.7726899385,
-1.1333822012,
-0.0096872756,
-0.0647616163,
-0.2073184699,
-0.1438413262,
0.2011907101,
0.3249049187,
0.6980500221,
-0.0357649848,
0.3772619665,
0.7005015016,
-0.2233346999,
0.2603317201,
0.0647067353,
-0.2243655622,
-0.4187543392,
0.8864442706,
0.6520867348,
0.2989039719,
0.1599590629,
0.1584911793,
-0.5517624617,
-0.8208959103,
-0.7326906323,
-0.2663317621,
-0.63926965,
-0.4926484525,
-0.7775696516,
-0.8948961496,
-0.3958641887,
0.0535271168,
-0.3061996698,
-0.4323718548,
-0.5388607979,
-0.0614860244,
0.3479110003,
0.6533249617,
0.4025683999,
0.1041730642,
-0.878926754,
0.0836848989,
0.4813140631,
0.6063434482,
0.1658108979,
-0.7186487317,
-0.2867751122,
0.3779035807,
-0.1670636684,
-0.7139154673,
0.2551542222,
0.0884805322,
0.5226122737,
0.28073138,
0.1436124742,
0.2814810872,
0.0298563298,
0.7686021328,
0.2165643275,
-0.5371029973,
0.4997288585,
-0.2634755373,
0.4644895494,
0.5801636577,
0.9141514897,
-0.7855716348,
-0.4859333038,
-0.6515191793,
-0.5717016459,
0.1710990369,
0.181131646,
0.6890046,
-0.1294995993,
0.4197743535,
-0.1537098289,
0.336597085,
-0.4969056547,
-0.0287774839,
-0.4697684646,
-0.01861603,
0.3944508433,
-0.2371745557,
0.3450086415,
-0.1289131641,
0.4472579956,
0.0730698705,
0.1026262119,
-0.139580965,
0.1576479822,
-0.3843451738,
-0.0482147075,
0.4709767401,
1.3360148668,
-0.1788256317,
0.0639569536,
0.4081678092,
-0.1571961939,
-0.2401942164,
-0.2327293754,
-0.3547768891,
0.0391032025,
0.1951536238,
0.6586508751,
-0.1233442277,
-0.4076656699,
0.6875654459,
-0.0208806451,
-0.1241378114,
-0.5191726685,
0.2984500527,
0.1972157061,
0.3216681778,
0.3408221602,
0.3435415328,
0.1097127646,
-0.6076754928,
0.3660042286,
0.2982569635,
-0.6980637312,
-0.0380069539,
0.3965886533,
0.2122424394,
-0.5565364361,
0.9377095103,
0.0356893428,
-0.8988711238,
1.2195202112,
0.2696130872,
0.5765044689,
-0.1408123076,
0.4849602878,
0.6123408675,
0.0015353883,
-0.0705814883,
0.3662326634,
0.5204931498,
-0.8453663588,
-0.726513207,
-0.7085760236,
-0.5824556947,
0.2272258997,
-0.4665655792,
-0.1534341127,
-0.8079473972,
-0.4351988733,
0.1764382273,
-0.0802888051,
-0.2971596122,
0.6262652874,
0.1217938736,
0.780756712,
-0.7380056381,
0.5197097063,
0.6815004349,
-0.7496355772,
-0.6852887869,
-0.1766368002,
-0.4104235172,
-0.6759369969,
0.5536135435,
0.0575295724,
0.0968603417,
0.0415244326,
-0.4146097898,
-0.9379181862,
0.8543459773,
0.0977521166,
0.0204362459,
0.1928667426,
0.2493292093,
0.9557814598,
-0.2023835629,
0.697758615,
-0.2163067311,
0.0871770009,
0.2971959412,
-0.553714931,
-0.2243211269,
-0.7281015515,
0.2066586465,
0.0776799023,
-0.2955219448,
1.0433317423,
0.0248142388,
-0.0012266773,
-0.0319751017,
0.9359416366,
-0.0967506617,
0.3568699956,
0.561116159,
0.2644941509,
0.7631153464,
0.0932712555,
1.0234339237,
-0.5258843899,
0.2541305423,
0.6899065375,
0.1482015997,
1.3428019285,
0.1793022901,
0.1433879733,
0.5818327665,
0.7126433253,
-0.1730031967,
0.1695031375,
0.5093138218,
0.1222407594,
-0.3014217615,
-0.3579823971,
-0.5082529187,
0.2297892123,
0.1404101849,
-0.6118542552,
0.0463158414,
0.038173724,
-0.4465197921,
0.0986401215,
-0.7423242927,
0.737819016,
-0.1484798938,
-0.8424280882,
0.6380364895,
-0.0563158803,
0.5820637345,
-0.0986505374,
0.0374368541,
-0.6095941663,
0.0826951861,
-0.5400803089,
-1.3185322285,
0.5140375495,
-0.1930073947,
-0.448248744,
-0.2679104507,
0.8890115023,
-0.4258068502,
-0.8665364981,
0.3069203794,
0.6558410525,
0.2480001897,
-0.5454097986,
-0.9221754074,
-0.5244889259,
-0.3566495478,
-0.136094138,
0.1472382396,
0.1735275835,
0.1011351123,
0.8720749617,
0.7793715,
0.1094992608,
0.2724516094,
-0.0174099617,
0.8221975565,
-0.2836371362,
-0.5796301365,
-0.6727917194,
0.659635365,
-0.3850074708,
-0.6374673843,
0.600741744,
0.2634696662,
0.8614923358,
0.169488132,
0.519438386,
0.2527911663,
0.6002427936,
-0.3242872357,
1.2282921076,
-0.7491608858,
0.0638265312,
-0.0807557851,
-0.9175027609,
-0.2415370196,
0.3175510168,
-0.4644387364,
0.3139666617,
0.2904487848,
0.7668340802,
-0.2950621843,
0.2688626051,
0.3527722955,
-0.0856097117,
-0.0376659483,
0.571631372,
1.1575074196,
-0.3704858422,
0.8444692492,
-0.4591712058,
0.1264532655,
-0.5402060747,
-0.6068050861,
-0.8766347766,
-0.5803509355,
-0.3061048388,
-0.6825313568,
0.1016257405,
0.7571027279,
0.8816980124,
-1.1430065632,
0.0687547475,
-0.1932692975,
0.4163703918,
-0.2859214246,
-0.1239783838,
0.2642052174,
-0.1736507416,
-0.1296049654,
0.059721496,
-0.0923399925,
-0.233235389,
-0.560631156,
0.1787029207,
-0.2632735968,
0.1728073806,
0.457218796,
0.4437909126,
-0.3718014657,
-0.2418524027,
0.4683532715,
-0.5294991732,
-0.011445703,
0.3343054056,
-0.3861008286,
0.1207874566,
1.1611200571,
1.1963014603,
0.1433666646,
0.51011163,
0.4655697346,
-0.7006530166,
-0.7457431555,
0.6160483956,
0.2652122378,
0.0649426579,
-0.5062752962,
0.2165217996,
-0.2338286787,
-0.7409082651,
-0.4649822116,
-0.0630370602,
-0.5421435237,
-0.5283632278,
1.2585248947,
-0.2759898007,
-0.3792803288,
-0.3445011377,
0.0360965915,
0.140265137,
-0.2651257813,
1.1108173132,
0.4958779514,
0.0928515568,
-0.2249379009,
-0.8018000126,
0.2143926322,
0.7354935408,
-0.9952662587,
-0.4844154716,
0.4415188432,
0.1986194253,
0.5565263033,
0.2221342027,
0.3096980453,
0.6618228555,
-0.3558692038,
-0.2008529603,
-0.2779010534,
-0.3495388329,
-0.2592785358,
0.7284654975,
-0.0475221649,
-0.32510975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13402v1
|
Intrusion Detection at Scale with the Assistance of a Command-line Language Model
| 2024-04-20T15:04:25 | 2024-04-20T15:04:25 |
Jiongliang Lin, Yiwen Guo, Hao Chen
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Intrusion detection is a long standing and crucial problem in security. A
system capable of detecting intrusions automatically is on great demand in
enterprise security solutions. Existing solutions rely heavily on hand-crafted
rules designed by security operators, which suffer from high false negative
rates and poor generalization ability to new, zero-day attacks at scale. AI and
machine learning offer promising solutions to address the issues, by inspecting
abnormal user behaviors intelligently and automatically from data. However,
existing learning-based intrusion detection systems in the literature are
mostly designed for small data, and they lack the ability to leverage the power
of big data in cloud environments. In this paper, we target at this problem and
introduce an intrusion detection system which incorporates large-scale
pre-training, so as to train a large language model based on tens of millions
of command lines for AI-based intrusion detection. Experiments performed on 30
million training samples and 10 million test samples verify the effectiveness
of our solution.
|
[
-0.7441754341,
-1.1284006834,
0.5040554404,
-0.1207869723,
-0.0589869507,
-0.1369625181,
-0.0942720398,
-0.3930417001,
0.1780579835,
0.7459828854,
-0.5895736217,
-0.4532774687,
-0.7156175971,
-0.0012109498,
-0.4130843282,
0.9390303493,
0.2316601872,
-0.1210475788,
-0.0928710103,
0.1673669666,
-0.610088408,
-0.7589054704,
-0.7095862627,
-0.1025744081,
0.0554047078,
0.7019425631,
0.3035680056,
0.5812224746,
0.725302279,
0.3620601892,
0.2861388326,
0.2935791016,
-0.2378042638,
-0.019649256,
-0.0369733237,
-0.6079027057,
-0.392277211,
-0.1560196877,
0.6313109398,
0.5089511871,
-0.0857227594,
0.0229852051,
-0.1944271922,
0.4158115983,
-0.360098213,
0.0624349117,
-0.7010947466,
-0.0963570252,
-0.206777066,
0.2256956846,
-0.5373849869,
0.1887183934,
0.1760941297,
-0.4194716811,
-0.0132924858,
0.3641152978,
0.5852723122,
0.279310286,
-0.2637428343,
-0.2888806164,
-0.6924450397,
0.8023361564,
-0.6308101416,
0.311355263,
0.4192018509,
0.3753065765,
-0.3821735978,
-0.6762724519,
-0.531260252,
-0.4122022986,
-0.0068731401,
-0.4149957895,
-0.3762860894,
-0.0590577237,
0.5057831407,
0.0150145274,
-0.7696870565,
0.5891135931,
-0.1278863549,
0.0491468869,
0.5597958565,
0.3232809603,
0.3380944729,
0.2178739458,
-0.3015433848,
-0.0240339935,
-0.2782519162,
0.1145217791,
0.2805238068,
0.5051353574,
-0.0609544963,
0.0049378625,
-0.3606756926,
0.7019085884,
0.1358230859,
0.03480497,
-0.0424945541,
-0.0888258442,
-0.3246042132,
-0.0314721577,
0.9258257747,
-0.057755623,
0.3050051033,
-0.2126043588,
-0.2586989105,
-0.0372876748,
0.5555477142,
-1.2624646425,
-0.5259861946,
0.1923641264,
-0.6183279157,
-0.3610872626,
0.2454074025,
-0.8211267591,
-0.7386671305,
-0.4429251254,
0.2512277663,
-0.5974364281,
-0.3647575676,
-0.0435479805,
0.2720327973,
0.284825176,
0.3707695901,
-0.6079566479,
0.4610586762,
0.7125625014,
0.7642087936,
-0.2960681021,
-0.3508837521,
-1.0569968224,
-0.2571370304,
-0.3851865232,
0.5366367698,
-0.4523115754,
-0.2935806513,
-0.303812474,
0.047646828,
-0.0546800718,
-0.6726004481,
0.3604266047,
-0.6492138505,
-0.0943407416,
0.1564278007,
-0.6819424033,
0.0434052758,
0.4145183563,
-0.5678542256,
0.5336648822,
-0.1066785604,
-0.4848764539,
0.3699169457,
-1.0345973969,
-0.4805846214,
0.5801107287,
-0.0808031559,
-0.576543808,
-0.1249391884,
0.4082814157,
0.5872520804,
-0.391009897,
0.2534838915,
-0.4467627704,
-0.1018947139,
0.0850149766,
-0.208092764,
0.6554145813,
0.3293029368,
-0.3843373358,
-0.1907557994,
-0.6075496078,
0.1741100699,
0.2079082429,
-0.1671563834,
-0.3694922328,
0.1059716642,
-0.1552621722,
-0.157901302,
0.4138301909,
-0.6271443367,
0.2329743207,
-0.0515208207,
0.1473015994,
0.5446712971,
0.0865076929,
0.3342135251,
0.1479333192,
0.5187478662,
0.5070362091,
0.2831248939,
-0.3068534732,
-0.2936201692,
-0.491786629,
-0.6311838627,
0.130599767,
0.8617966771,
-0.4918909371,
0.9549928308,
-0.2615425885,
-0.5475413799,
0.0415351689,
0.2641736567,
-0.1135595813,
0.3843997419,
0.4050009847,
-0.0144793028,
-0.4797631204,
-0.8282873034,
-0.2607982457,
-0.002589667,
-0.3325761557,
0.289770782,
0.7519518137,
-0.5636621714,
0.9493072033,
-0.8826445937,
-0.4423744977,
-0.1491918117,
0.3578651845,
0.2531707287,
0.6075572968,
0.4769929051,
-0.8184428215,
-0.380605638,
0.1684033275,
-0.8692764044,
-0.0906660855,
-0.1059267744,
0.1735558212,
-0.1434535831,
0.9823082089,
-0.197560057,
0.2950134575,
0.2385321707,
-0.272703886,
0.3442111611,
-0.3218200505,
-0.0464405753,
-1.1199270487,
0.0432457812,
0.0824205875,
-0.1913206726,
-1.1548837423,
0.1182319,
0.2503118515,
-0.578969419,
-0.1469560266,
0.1614439189,
-0.2884001434,
0.3120636046,
-0.3203388155,
-0.3982251585,
-0.3185068369,
0.3364078701,
0.069529146,
0.677980423,
0.7167887688,
-0.8209730983,
0.7997678518,
-0.0145305134,
-0.3035758734,
1.0217918158,
-0.5427247286,
0.195085898,
0.0393107124,
0.3407444656,
-0.8577961922,
-0.3201804757,
0.0718301609,
-0.2488317788,
0.1616423279,
-0.3782895207,
-0.4416200221,
-0.4563305378,
-0.1420321614,
0.351714164,
0.4620597959,
-0.7583853602,
0.7733269334,
0.3393671513,
0.1376248449,
-0.439242363,
-0.4860605299,
0.4335647821,
-0.4694101214,
-0.6021920443,
-0.2243835926,
0.0396814682,
-0.2435472608,
-0.3011225164,
0.1595357955,
-0.5608379245,
0.5484273434,
0.4218238294,
0.2369441539,
-0.3352158368,
0.0196990855,
-0.4542078674,
0.2380591482,
0.2902310193,
-0.7702156305,
0.7358909249,
-0.3037557602,
-0.3713485301,
-0.8665933609,
0.4953513145,
1.1781879663,
-0.4733603597,
0.9708735347,
0.4868608415,
-0.4651285708,
-0.491576463,
-0.2767981589,
-0.3263679147,
-0.5197398067,
0.4793117642,
-0.3650715649,
-0.4992100894,
0.2973846793,
-0.4706541896,
-0.1142431051,
0.2613735795,
0.0250925589,
-0.1315927953,
0.9593714476,
0.7787007689,
-0.7290390134,
0.7760255337,
-0.4279986322,
0.7154126763,
-0.455514431,
0.2363314033,
-0.4367390573,
-0.1617012173,
-0.6464965343,
-0.0026112352,
0.558367312,
0.0328687541,
-0.4314323068,
0.3798902631,
-0.270963937,
0.4324433804,
0.5254679322,
0.3211421371,
-0.0826726928,
-0.2573222518,
0.1741779894,
0.2938018739,
-0.3358462453,
-0.2478008568,
1.251123786,
0.4465556741,
0.7559771538,
0.1233739406,
0.7024127841,
0.8312866688,
0.0072082849,
-0.8814866543,
0.6150860786,
-0.2462943196,
-0.2565213442,
-0.7573419809,
-0.5420377254,
-0.9996542931,
-0.2624954581,
-0.1786714941,
-0.7429882288,
0.0620972328,
0.0758812055,
-0.2497862428,
0.5263233185,
-0.8138684034,
0.8066011667,
-0.3333896101,
0.2197603434,
-0.2362055033,
-0.4381979108,
0.410482794,
-0.4604806602,
0.0362690836,
0.2510837018,
0.2180173546,
0.7754802704,
-0.6753666997,
0.7461700439,
-0.648262918,
-0.0690078065,
0.2069533765,
0.0520567149,
0.9441018105,
0.0335276984,
0.2925503552,
0.2668239772,
-0.3664879799,
-0.3454790413,
-0.4389919341,
0.3636951447,
-0.6213569641,
-0.4068990052,
-0.186256513,
-0.5631474853,
0.0486714765,
0.3103569448,
0.1998091787,
0.4471778274,
-0.3336852491,
0.4853414595,
1.0616440773,
-0.2882961929,
0.2677613497,
0.5553202033,
-0.1033234447,
-0.0346450917,
0.8720718026,
0.0812616646,
0.2570288181,
0.3755723536,
0.1526940167,
-0.0896086767,
-0.5312307477,
-0.6118787527,
0.0316461064,
-0.2033255398,
-0.3571142554,
-0.7084497809,
-0.4677408636,
-0.4332259297,
-0.0811482221,
-0.1471847892,
0.165125221,
-0.2320931852,
0.3663191497,
0.5565709472,
0.5474046469,
0.1316329092,
0.7427995205,
-0.4835194051,
0.4709227979,
0.5575733781,
0.25881356,
0.0011417227,
-0.4924956262,
-0.4903698862,
-0.0532905757,
-0.0786935538,
-0.4327382147,
0.4065312147,
0.2166820467,
0.3043601513,
0.9028903842,
0.173953101,
0.1455177069,
-0.4793783128,
0.638931334,
-0.06276723,
-0.8577114344,
0.6905835867,
-0.3560129106,
0.2420428693,
0.4342619777,
0.3369982541,
-0.6741691828,
-0.2316239029,
-0.4803786576,
-0.538495183,
0.8810380697,
-0.3156155348,
-0.0237699226,
0.285648793,
0.042561356,
-0.2292383015,
0.1964705288,
-0.3414143622,
-0.1728320271,
-0.0084645934,
0.0096084205,
0.0078365495,
0.2180233598,
0.0044731349,
0.0636033937,
0.432461679,
-0.1188266203,
0.1790345013,
-0.4387470484,
-0.232475251,
0.2434668541,
0.1261120588,
0.4038873911,
0.3526661396,
-0.0222990941,
-0.0508183725,
0.5646907091,
-0.9047444463,
0.1550796479,
0.0986968055,
-0.0928160548,
-0.170216769,
0.2628180385,
0.4913317561,
-0.6033170223,
-0.5773470998,
0.7709602118,
-0.1360092014,
-0.1920812726,
-0.6186118126,
0.3555976152,
-0.1271947175,
0.1274487227,
0.4286460578,
-0.0734025091,
0.0900454521,
-0.3981055021,
0.3951661587,
0.7400975823,
-0.1662299782,
0.0314605944,
0.294718504,
0.1866037548,
-0.4631438255,
0.9380769134,
-0.2291388363,
-0.8130530119,
0.9760738015,
0.3346497118,
0.7720798254,
-0.645403862,
-0.1781218201,
0.0698831975,
0.5048407912,
-0.0370101668,
0.0273788646,
-0.0636346117,
-0.7620217204,
0.003350772,
-0.4231321216,
-0.5383026004,
0.8705527186,
-0.446695596,
0.5011921525,
-1.0061644316,
0.2044566423,
0.0607760139,
-0.0891257003,
-0.7902597785,
0.3655747175,
0.3870609701,
0.9265316725,
-1.1996901035,
0.8437260985,
0.5009367466,
-0.1138728857,
-0.5325667262,
0.0429201163,
-0.0571393408,
-0.6512915492,
0.7492827773,
0.4399698973,
-0.1001722366,
-0.1482448131,
-0.7501932979,
-0.6050083637,
0.6677285433,
0.0306798313,
-0.4233082533,
0.3123546243,
0.3622581065,
0.5736666918,
-0.5496022105,
0.025222009,
0.8678507209,
0.5041565895,
-0.5771574378,
-0.6030132771,
-0.2557720244,
-0.0728762522,
-0.2881381512,
0.5982825756,
-0.3145932853,
1.0311081409,
0.2680363953,
0.1398554593,
-0.4396147132,
0.6642982364,
-0.2308703065,
0.2278811336,
0.895211339,
0.6625037193,
0.8509801626,
0.2103811502,
0.61051476,
-0.2806966007,
0.0053787553,
1.0675122738,
-0.360511452,
0.6999714375,
-0.0740919039,
-0.2103951275,
0.5307314396,
0.4154367447,
-0.1403585374,
0.3028805852,
0.372993052,
-0.5923775434,
-0.2660188675,
-0.2469802499,
-0.1192245632,
0.6101845503,
0.751126945,
-0.3402510881,
-0.0124337543,
0.1891466975,
0.1511660516,
-0.1807344705,
-0.6241856813,
0.7779608369,
-0.1714054495,
-0.3893354237,
0.6177107096,
0.0930944085,
0.8143883348,
-0.7622324824,
0.1313039958,
-0.0378647186,
0.3534463644,
-0.1892400235,
-0.5646250248,
-0.0051249075,
0.4054622054,
-0.256334126,
-0.0156954676,
0.5564329028,
-0.18008928,
-0.2721110582,
0.3264577389,
0.2158727646,
0.3859245181,
-0.4498742521,
-0.322488308,
-0.3560865521,
-0.093718946,
-0.0306672473,
0.2694751918,
0.6270389557,
-0.2957606018,
0.7698427439,
0.7916322947,
0.1677849591,
-0.0713090971,
-0.1613910347,
0.7265997529,
-0.2049742788,
-0.9093754888,
-0.9957609773,
0.0292016082,
-0.5813872218,
-0.0942405239,
0.3911934495,
0.4993683696,
0.5964891315,
-0.0902783945,
0.9626448154,
-0.0894395038,
0.5280614495,
-0.2003728598,
0.6846284866,
-0.2986940444,
0.2070294619,
-0.0056521236,
-0.6679759026,
-0.1991784126,
0.2601213455,
-0.4908134639,
-0.0006596582,
0.7675029635,
0.9941240549,
-0.4527749419,
-0.0463351645,
0.3928627372,
0.1725632101,
0.586817503,
0.3470383883,
0.6354632378,
-0.1161650941,
0.3722242415,
0.2074338794,
-0.5339402556,
-0.497392118,
-0.9010075927,
-1.0399384499,
-0.4429108202,
0.075060688,
0.0137222065,
-0.2333508581,
0.9779610038,
0.8743787408,
-1.0818798542,
-0.1193071827,
-0.2214908004,
-0.2041022629,
-0.1299395114,
-0.1890665144,
0.3161323369,
-0.4825487435,
-0.4114015102,
0.4831961989,
-0.0260049086,
-0.0500001758,
-0.294657141,
0.1756183058,
-0.1593243331,
0.0681144446,
0.2735143006,
0.3930383325,
-0.1553413421,
-0.2097713798,
-0.2043533325,
-0.148651436,
-0.2113075405,
0.6916335821,
-0.6570020914,
0.1731802672,
0.3523968756,
1.1656122208,
0.1620238423,
0.134232834,
0.5161454082,
-0.5950594544,
0.0832886994,
0.0879292116,
0.3369976878,
0.1476744264,
-0.7974108458,
0.2278901637,
0.1526497155,
-0.7383800149,
-0.7132813334,
0.4122571349,
-0.517188251,
-0.3826191425,
0.5576152802,
-0.3560633659,
-0.0541965328,
-0.2315639108,
-0.0640076846,
-0.0288977604,
-0.448205322,
0.7514847517,
0.6239554286,
-0.2037174702,
0.3470412791,
-0.4614276588,
0.4235462546,
0.4098824859,
-1.2282489538,
0.377490133,
0.3696796894,
0.0315893143,
0.1754988581,
0.0991417244,
0.49694103,
0.3324806094,
-0.1024771333,
0.1251052171,
0.0715489537,
-0.696665585,
-0.6057918072,
-0.0510361902,
0.0151439533,
-0.6860871315
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13397v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13397v1
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation-based Relation Extraction
| 2024-04-20T14:42:43 | 2024-04-20T14:42:43 |
Sefika Efeoglu, Adrian Paschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Information Extraction (IE) is a transformative process that converts
unstructured text data into a structured format by employing entity and
relation extraction (RE) methodologies. The identification of the relation
between a pair of entities plays a crucial role within this framework. Despite
the existence of various techniques for relation extraction, their efficacy
heavily relies on access to labeled data and substantial computational
resources. In addressing these challenges, Large Language Models (LLMs) emerge
as promising solutions; however, they might return hallucinating responses due
to their own training data. To overcome these limitations, Retrieved-Augmented
Generation-based Relation Extraction (RAG4RE) in this work is proposed,
offering a pathway to enhance the performance of relation extraction tasks.
This work evaluated the effectiveness of our RAG4RE approach utilizing
different LLMs. Through the utilization of established benchmarks, such as
TACRED, TACREV, Re-TACRED, and SemEval RE datasets, our aim is to
comprehensively evaluate the efficacy of our RAG4RE approach. In particularly,
we leverage prominent LLMs including Flan T5, Llama2, and Mistral in our
investigation. The results of our study demonstrate that our RAG4RE approach
surpasses performance of traditional RE approaches based solely on LLMs,
particularly evident in the TACRED dataset and its variations. Furthermore, our
approach exhibits remarkable performance compared to previous RE methodologies
across both TACRED and TACREV datasets, underscoring its efficacy and potential
for advancing RE tasks in natural language processing.
|
[
-0.4241069853,
-0.6180980802,
0.4795611799,
0.1470023543,
-0.2349009067,
0.242533356,
-0.2737795115,
-0.7800332904,
0.1522419006,
0.6222099662,
-0.1963428855,
-0.1970745623,
-0.5489996672,
0.5285249352,
-0.2409018576,
0.9454747438,
-0.0741475746,
-0.2620453537,
-0.1712601781,
-0.2020296007,
-0.5467615128,
-0.3800385892,
-0.5808832049,
-0.398121655,
0.5691754222,
0.3202895522,
0.0981630981,
0.5864611268,
0.7305175662,
0.3034415543,
-0.0771385878,
0.434384495,
-0.5496892929,
0.4971399605,
-0.4336816967,
-0.1933746785,
-0.3620177805,
0.136477679,
0.6028979421,
0.2624097466,
-0.2159340978,
0.5448964834,
0.0976221189,
0.5881993175,
-0.7622734308,
0.2276714295,
-0.8822338581,
-0.108335048,
-0.4390434921,
-0.6127258539,
-0.4860031009,
-0.2421187013,
0.091253303,
-0.6876591444,
0.2920223773,
0.2187604308,
1.3263566494,
-0.0305951219,
-0.2072786838,
-0.4176271558,
-0.8572406173,
0.8086029291,
-0.5069566965,
0.9192017317,
0.3072682619,
0.2882301807,
-0.27731511,
-1.0575973988,
-0.321901381,
-0.0438947193,
-0.1294516623,
0.1534068584,
-0.0402281955,
-0.2598178685,
0.4106097221,
0.7006191611,
-0.0925431624,
-0.0686999261,
-0.1144586205,
-0.0631512403,
0.2819866836,
-0.0110458359,
0.1635904163,
-0.5621511936,
-0.6558773518,
0.0329281725,
-0.6892191172,
-0.1358394772,
0.0194793008,
0.3902646899,
0.1923687756,
0.5828378797,
0.0931959301,
0.5243685246,
0.2367166132,
-0.467869401,
0.3474748731,
-0.4002258778,
-0.0957084,
-0.4736434519,
0.8814035654,
0.0536897816,
0.331641674,
-0.5860407948,
-0.4138675034,
-0.2917264104,
0.1862907708,
-0.7837156653,
-0.0141772665,
-0.093637228,
-0.5049730539,
-0.3571533859,
-0.0467413925,
-1.3012766838,
-0.2740661204,
-0.2796996832,
0.2277922183,
-0.5977971554,
-0.570995748,
-0.4143140316,
-0.2882695794,
0.5992610455,
0.1721111387,
-0.7914237976,
0.3799962699,
0.8188410997,
0.6794454455,
-0.457769841,
0.1740080714,
-0.7070587277,
0.3505597711,
-0.1435417086,
0.7459598184,
-0.6648447514,
-0.4305327237,
-0.1792836785,
-0.1392376423,
-0.1016752422,
-0.9407852292,
0.7152180672,
-1.0537774563,
0.2548365593,
-0.1529466361,
-0.4066888094,
-0.000376245,
0.4247552156,
-1.0572361946,
1.2353843451,
0.3104869127,
-0.9722083807,
0.1688450873,
-0.2237217873,
-0.3073796034,
0.1742930561,
-0.4633575082,
-0.4888563156,
-0.1427320093,
0.3207741976,
0.3922112882,
-0.8688818812,
0.0967614874,
-0.0983369946,
-0.0204405729,
0.0733974054,
-0.2275174856,
0.5207485557,
0.2642056346,
-0.1707482636,
-0.3698968589,
-0.8316317201,
-0.0221887715,
0.1910431087,
-0.4353998899,
-0.6078990698,
-0.2803922296,
-0.1520611495,
0.3852887154,
0.1644790322,
-0.683652997,
0.0453743897,
-0.6544237137,
0.0468675457,
0.532549262,
0.6283951402,
0.4853438437,
-0.0303137694,
0.7617013454,
-0.1814617515,
-0.4627493322,
-0.0783150941,
-0.269035399,
-0.5181283951,
-0.3204144537,
0.7312435508,
0.5308036804,
-1.1906527281,
0.0791746601,
-0.4918493629,
-0.1948418915,
-0.4307934344,
0.2441719919,
0.6872397661,
0.944758594,
0.4067658484,
-0.0399359651,
-0.7921649218,
-0.7309665084,
-0.46393767,
-0.0917309821,
0.064584218,
0.4009109139,
0.1478915066,
-0.0984176919,
0.9217532873,
-0.4486787617,
-0.3514820635,
-0.3805166483,
0.0991219506,
0.1591659337,
0.0605851784,
0.342651099,
-1.0034147501,
-0.3454283476,
0.3106375039,
-0.9147418141,
-0.1534712911,
0.0783019587,
-0.2795958817,
0.1888664961,
0.228219673,
-0.5310498476,
0.4719567001,
0.3151600957,
0.0738241598,
0.5557831526,
0.0996117592,
0.2534043491,
-1.1641708612,
0.3567938805,
0.142642647,
-0.4689362943,
-0.5189654827,
0.0853909701,
0.1381782293,
0.093305409,
-0.1103983447,
0.5365185142,
-0.8223471642,
-0.3617650568,
0.0449720286,
0.2687020004,
0.1841202527,
0.3400640786,
-0.05460288,
0.996773541,
-0.1220381185,
-0.4593931735,
0.1117089018,
0.5287802219,
0.0043630283,
0.2932323515,
-0.2813640535,
0.1850395203,
-0.043856889,
-0.0252034571,
-0.5763208866,
-0.093597047,
0.1681108326,
-0.5509848595,
0.6807672381,
-0.116512835,
-0.3973501921,
-0.0567615367,
-0.3393690884,
0.1543822289,
0.2464215755,
-0.7676813006,
1.0620480776,
0.5543678403,
-0.2790340781,
-0.7802706957,
-0.2095072269,
0.1315696836,
-0.461322248,
-0.3452210128,
0.5458217859,
0.394729346,
-0.3827466071,
0.0959443748,
-0.247397095,
-0.1316600591,
-0.1934699118,
0.1913707256,
0.4128504694,
-0.0448126607,
0.1559870839,
-0.4197564721,
-0.1212900281,
0.0240001231,
0.5473110676,
0.494654566,
0.1527940929,
0.2619774342,
-0.2314510494,
0.2201388776,
0.3398618996,
-0.6358609796,
0.5910564065,
0.5215747356,
-0.3350829482,
-0.1028864086,
-0.9388238788,
-0.0715983957,
-0.4270461798,
0.275182128,
-0.7777730227,
-0.8187764883,
0.4348297715,
-0.5309259892,
0.0860099122,
0.4520842731,
0.2794557214,
-0.0226943325,
0.4538342059,
0.5480771661,
-0.1219255775,
0.5229051113,
-0.3970608413,
0.157063216,
-1.4370812178,
-0.4806714058,
-0.6447682381,
0.1912130862,
-0.656011939,
-0.2324999422,
0.118078433,
0.1597575992,
0.0756068975,
0.455519408,
-0.2165415734,
0.1166622788,
0.0324283913,
-0.0204054154,
0.5660645366,
0.2413711101,
0.0360223167,
-0.4113996029,
-0.483250618,
-0.4396628141,
1.0290821791,
0.3095359802,
0.5049470663,
0.2428788245,
0.9660741091,
0.0694397166,
0.6837744713,
-0.6766554117,
0.5856735706,
-0.0387921371,
-0.4047066569,
-0.0883537233,
-0.837303102,
-1.4611754417,
0.2642042339,
-0.458414942,
-0.7384718657,
0.1947271526,
-0.1008273512,
0.0561101697,
0.2845781744,
-0.6206951141,
0.3367033303,
-0.0917711556,
-0.5823382735,
0.144953832,
-0.4857091606,
0.6226689816,
-0.4578629136,
0.3741925359,
0.0130548375,
-0.1643291116,
0.8062107563,
-0.1074437574,
0.0038942471,
-0.0568382703,
-0.0821075812,
0.1378653646,
0.0272858888,
0.6178492308,
-0.0367441513,
-0.4629603624,
0.0438121371,
-0.0998986587,
0.2100231647,
-0.8451746106,
0.871040225,
-0.5111699104,
-0.4813060164,
-0.456342876,
-0.335108459,
-0.4428354204,
0.282142669,
0.0578017198,
0.5601916313,
-0.1251567751,
0.261929363,
0.4192537069,
-0.2560482919,
0.4867690802,
0.37166816,
-0.5203250051,
-0.7911044359,
0.8260558248,
0.0014383296,
0.1649224758,
0.463249445,
-0.113843672,
-0.4957015216,
-0.1937610358,
-0.2111198604,
0.4925259948,
-0.3485355973,
-0.6806476712,
-0.673772037,
-0.2688992321,
-0.4022861421,
0.5482763052,
-0.2425125986,
-0.3014027774,
-0.2361451834,
0.0487730652,
0.2834558189,
0.6706010103,
0.0985772163,
-0.195614174,
-0.9278180003,
0.8012253642,
-0.0463618487,
0.2203274518,
0.1366099566,
-0.4745521843,
-0.0139169237,
-0.4630686641,
-0.2829709053,
-1.079891324,
0.6333914399,
0.233979255,
0.5503575802,
0.0809371099,
-0.127413854,
0.9863660336,
-0.6537973285,
0.3702738881,
0.0772470906,
-0.3935496211,
0.4213855863,
-0.2174535692,
-0.2270019203,
0.596726656,
0.2787783742,
-0.0083871707,
-0.0448290855,
-0.9547130466,
-0.9725345373,
0.557924509,
0.5491064191,
-0.3428969979,
0.0112069668,
0.8157783151,
-0.079068087,
0.189819932,
-0.4695105851,
-0.2753824294,
0.377597034,
-0.0167469941,
0.2098393887,
-0.4557788074,
0.2256696224,
-0.0451894999,
0.6616482139,
0.551122427,
0.2667033076,
0.2970830798,
-0.0374157205,
-0.107922256,
0.3356498182,
-0.0494007878,
0.7953092456,
-0.3908668458,
0.1361571997,
0.2144654095,
-0.5285910368,
0.0441485718,
0.4349074066,
-0.00061555,
0.1106195599,
0.4882468879,
0.2820171118,
0.2019656599,
-0.432094276,
0.5062639713,
-0.2019533962,
0.1259907931,
-0.482033819,
-0.1659410298,
-0.0004982817,
0.1678414345,
0.4716032147,
-0.2252108604,
0.2328174859,
-0.4425299764,
0.5377983451,
0.4641832709,
-0.0078798467,
-0.2207576483,
0.4548273385,
0.0219433606,
-0.5241078734,
0.5897823572,
-0.0944894552,
-0.3246824443,
0.2073463947,
0.7996383309,
0.634824872,
-0.3382348418,
-0.1174765527,
0.6841632724,
0.1033958495,
0.0479549468,
0.1055666208,
-0.0298525747,
-0.8292090297,
-0.8534399867,
-0.7865008116,
-0.1426401436,
0.4488314688,
-1.0574717522,
0.2185059488,
-0.1693255007,
-0.2789956331,
0.0186507367,
0.2376009226,
-0.659165442,
0.1443158239,
-0.2016705275,
0.8321759701,
-0.3687000275,
0.7150578499,
0.5052285194,
-0.5538078547,
-1.2798464298,
0.0440530181,
-0.2576699257,
-0.4605860412,
0.8365589976,
0.0484722406,
-0.2590012848,
0.1814543009,
-0.2228952944,
-0.8714356422,
1.2008978128,
0.3498356044,
-0.5688567758,
-0.1182578728,
-0.1148163974,
0.4784887731,
-0.4289092422,
0.2285721004,
0.897366941,
0.2223144323,
0.3128018677,
-0.819775939,
0.097423628,
-0.2482333481,
0.1533508599,
0.6785019636,
-0.2654220164,
0.3834713101,
0.1062477827,
-0.4639301896,
0.1145017669,
0.7652754188,
0.6543009877,
0.2688565254,
0.471365422,
0.7369439006,
0.5316544175,
0.0479146093,
1.1013724804,
-0.0921749473,
0.2644298077,
1.3470487595,
-0.4317954481,
1.0942769051,
0.7365216017,
-0.1431383193,
0.7286453247,
0.2490702868,
0.2702400684,
0.4577551484,
-0.2128719538,
-0.2659652233,
0.0264723133,
-0.1970952451,
-0.2634563744,
0.4048675895,
0.5345340967,
-0.5051156282,
-0.3587349951,
-0.1545356661,
0.1651030928,
0.2413047999,
-0.0628242418,
1.0919818878,
0.1953606009,
-0.6687069535,
0.487103641,
-0.1774674207,
0.4174199402,
-0.4326292574,
-0.7008450627,
-0.1417447627,
0.028183097,
-0.2036135644,
-0.5001932979,
0.0865938142,
0.2962145805,
-0.1867086738,
-0.054606732,
1.1636914015,
-0.330519706,
-0.2330781966,
0.4588403404,
0.7270852327,
0.1186835989,
0.1309926063,
-0.4742119014,
0.1195868403,
0.2480730116,
-0.3827431798,
0.3397540152,
0.6663657427,
-0.0956698209,
0.5105191469,
0.7084465623,
0.5336746573,
-0.2317246497,
-0.0691280887,
1.0828108788,
-0.7808412313,
0.0358711034,
-0.6931983829,
0.2540081143,
-0.4953175187,
-0.112787351,
0.8907283545,
0.7431859374,
0.3525808752,
0.298304528,
0.6116242409,
-0.1705883443,
1.190772295,
-0.3485503793,
0.2081665546,
-0.2621103227,
0.5759655833,
-0.4728535712,
-1.2243626118,
-0.2205539793,
0.4163228571,
-0.3837693036,
0.0275091883,
0.6521804929,
0.8314625621,
-0.0273865666,
-0.1238479465,
0.0315767154,
0.1113070175,
0.6091930866,
0.3136461079,
0.880567193,
-0.4719238281,
0.7291321754,
-0.165738821,
-0.2333297282,
0.2607192695,
-0.8161814809,
-0.7277445793,
-0.4959189296,
0.0469348952,
-0.4150437415,
0.1400414854,
0.7386532426,
0.1653546989,
-0.3896279633,
0.015189345,
0.0626912042,
-0.1513808817,
0.1979645789,
-0.3159137368,
0.512475431,
-0.3077045679,
-0.5080543756,
0.418322593,
0.2290787995,
-0.1595066488,
0.0475057475,
-0.0691438019,
-0.6021705866,
-0.3474721014,
0.5990463495,
0.3828993738,
-0.5375149846,
-0.2316640913,
-0.135077104,
-0.0717848316,
0.1751021892,
0.577940762,
-0.9553037286,
0.4607202709,
0.4154004157,
0.9424880147,
0.7593634129,
0.6042948961,
0.6651453972,
-0.8521794081,
-0.0319185108,
0.3110907078,
0.0800305009,
0.5257210732,
-0.3992810249,
0.9690630436,
0.0268001966,
-0.7134979963,
-0.7296287417,
0.0441847444,
-0.8844323754,
0.1495480388,
1.4418230057,
-0.1741811931,
-0.1289681792,
-0.1935162842,
-0.2092378587,
0.3969618976,
-0.399843514,
0.4486279488,
0.3474025428,
-0.3565553427,
-0.439755857,
-0.8079959154,
0.4751468897,
0.0676319227,
-0.880415082,
-0.0773769245,
0.4120445549,
0.3817176521,
0.2746480405,
0.6097823381,
-0.4859099984,
-0.1232351959,
-0.4978883862,
0.1302939355,
-0.0152718788,
-0.1445764899,
-0.2044757754,
0.2984396219,
0.11643783,
-0.1777988225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13390v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13390v1
|
Explanation based Bias Decoupling Regularization for Natural Language Inference
| 2024-04-20T14:20:24 | 2024-04-20T14:20:24 |
Jianxiang Zang, Hui Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The robustness of Transformer-based Natural Language Inference encoders is
frequently compromised as they tend to rely more on dataset biases than on the
intended task-relevant features. Recent studies have attempted to mitigate this
by reducing the weight of biased samples during the training process. However,
these debiasing methods primarily focus on identifying which samples are biased
without explicitly determining the biased components within each case. This
limitation restricts those methods' capability in out-of-distribution
inference. To address this issue, we aim to train models to adopt the logic
humans use in explaining causality. We propose a simple, comprehensive, and
interpretable method: Explanation based Bias Decoupling Regularization
(EBD-Reg). EBD-Reg employs human explanations as criteria, guiding the encoder
to establish a tripartite parallel supervision of Distinguishing, Decoupling
and Aligning. This method enables encoders to identify and focus on keywords
that represent the task-relevant features during inference, while discarding
the residual elements acting as biases. Empirical evidence underscores that
EBD-Reg effectively guides various Transformer-based encoders to decouple
biases through a human-centric lens, significantly surpassing other methods in
terms of out-of-distribution inference capabilities.
|
[
-0.6068065166,
-0.9662595391,
0.4215564132,
0.2250164747,
-0.3749433756,
-0.339720875,
-0.4360356927,
-0.3144269586,
0.0475239903,
0.3909957409,
-0.7346391082,
-0.216637373,
-0.601391077,
0.3587828279,
-0.1493070275,
1.1115338802,
0.0167987347,
0.0903939232,
-0.3004498482,
-0.0260905959,
-0.7033185363,
-0.139017567,
-0.6040803194,
-0.4457232356,
0.2012986094,
0.2354111522,
0.5822799206,
0.8068231344,
0.223536849,
0.1746225953,
-0.12483529,
0.1298019886,
-0.4418908656,
-0.0673045442,
-0.26158306,
-0.4428262413,
-0.1021771878,
0.034308292,
0.3939123452,
1.1139822006,
-0.2750972211,
0.0138812726,
0.2007623464,
0.6718651652,
-0.7637847662,
0.1687311977,
-0.3721455634,
-0.0828053579,
0.0199317001,
-0.218447417,
-0.5555734038,
-0.4651295245,
0.2477893233,
-0.6087481976,
0.7936167121,
0.0992350727,
1.0019253492,
0.6061742306,
-0.5646876693,
-0.0131607503,
-0.9063824415,
0.8476962447,
-0.6650928855,
0.6170855761,
0.492897898,
0.2807606757,
-0.1642088145,
-0.3376286626,
-0.6040690541,
0.1953474432,
-0.4456883669,
0.279884845,
-0.1877124459,
0.3572259843,
0.419300884,
0.2379857451,
-0.5247035027,
0.0064053722,
-0.042712152,
-0.2126776129,
0.3291716874,
-0.1420333534,
0.2316102237,
-0.0950683206,
-0.4521323144,
0.0691729113,
-0.5121813416,
0.0814312547,
0.3567945361,
0.0136401718,
-0.1097774208,
0.2514040172,
-0.2718327343,
0.9136840701,
0.4428012967,
-0.0529096127,
0.0775368363,
-0.2088321447,
-0.5158497691,
0.226939708,
0.4811599851,
0.4768079519,
0.1308801174,
-0.5345172286,
-0.0327088535,
0.3278661966,
0.0970046148,
-0.7980558276,
-0.1467505246,
0.2575539649,
-0.7758527398,
-0.165582791,
0.1397010088,
-1.3551917076,
-0.4907894731,
-0.3977147639,
0.2295547426,
-0.0953026116,
-0.2505176365,
0.3990730345,
-0.5386819839,
0.3490473032,
0.0126395319,
-0.9583978653,
0.4797255993,
0.3774006367,
0.489212513,
-0.090157263,
0.0049785911,
-0.5502586961,
0.3180229366,
-0.0698379949,
0.7595492005,
-0.4915926158,
0.1388342381,
-0.0635957494,
0.0465577468,
-0.1179173067,
-0.573135078,
0.9415184855,
-0.5229902864,
0.3857481182,
-0.3434352279,
-0.6026782393,
-0.428599447,
0.1089198068,
-0.7841316462,
0.9444538951,
-0.0695476532,
-1.0853674412,
0.8620602489,
-0.6022106409,
-0.4147156179,
-0.3202736974,
-0.0672087967,
-0.4274871945,
0.1404991448,
0.7311911583,
0.2011227459,
-0.6895526052,
0.6491963267,
-0.3872676194,
-0.2898867428,
0.0502116866,
-0.805899024,
1.0049824715,
0.1780363023,
-0.5688981414,
0.0472439267,
-0.8052740693,
-0.4638208747,
0.0380103663,
-0.2328907847,
-0.5398997664,
0.075996764,
-0.1671506166,
0.1589312404,
-0.1269882768,
-0.6554372311,
-0.2301467359,
-0.5718277097,
0.3604625463,
0.6260817051,
0.2051248997,
0.7277238965,
-0.1394563019,
0.499484241,
0.2037423253,
0.1262694746,
-0.1501367241,
-0.6011016369,
-0.5382502675,
-0.7560289502,
0.2896891236,
0.5073105097,
-0.4126985967,
0.8331795931,
-0.2678603232,
0.045398552,
-0.6747643352,
0.0467554927,
0.441819936,
1.0068507195,
0.5959116817,
-0.1463116556,
-0.6242595315,
-1.0748962164,
-0.6268055439,
0.1760418415,
-0.2606767416,
-0.0688899979,
0.2605747879,
-0.2398027182,
1.4553815126,
-0.4395267367,
-0.2138880342,
-0.3843379915,
0.290302068,
0.1351752132,
0.2617071867,
0.3092739582,
-0.7627165914,
-0.130660072,
-0.2604182065,
-0.5949825048,
-0.4731189311,
-0.5649591684,
-0.4080888927,
0.1086142436,
0.4628757536,
-0.7220706344,
0.585708499,
0.2325965613,
-0.3861237764,
0.337333709,
-0.2190036327,
-0.1726752073,
-0.9055936337,
-0.0220079124,
0.2647126913,
-0.2134128958,
-0.7009256482,
-0.1997185349,
0.0549926832,
0.1820495278,
0.1158600524,
0.4125460982,
-0.6415384412,
0.1108121499,
-0.102660656,
0.2075252235,
0.5166657567,
0.4871640205,
0.0531915911,
0.1694104373,
0.495842129,
-0.5207059383,
0.1689045876,
0.2348645329,
-0.0065750931,
0.5347335935,
-0.5073971152,
-0.0848045573,
-0.6087848544,
0.6324415207,
-1.0850384235,
-0.3181018233,
0.4196687341,
-0.2304634154,
0.2712640464,
-0.305544436,
-0.3264087737,
-0.3236448467,
-0.3138213158,
0.4123218954,
0.5164855123,
-0.906547308,
0.8656646013,
0.2650513053,
0.1683695763,
-0.566280961,
-0.8524897695,
-0.0961875618,
-0.5747425556,
-0.6113682389,
0.5042616129,
0.1491817236,
-0.397159934,
0.0610690527,
-0.3423255384,
-0.2964071929,
0.0570385493,
0.1083688289,
0.18107149,
-0.013688569,
0.1140001193,
0.4671812356,
-0.1781758219,
0.3682101965,
-0.1291214824,
0.1581715643,
0.2384239137,
-0.309433043,
-0.7716121078,
0.4631060958,
0.3285937309,
-0.2859430611,
0.8722486496,
0.6467109919,
-0.556728065,
-0.3031848669,
-0.8162595034,
-0.5976068377,
-0.3569050133,
0.1612542272,
-0.1084166393,
-0.4512735605,
0.5177559853,
-0.1005514562,
-0.0018528138,
0.1438365728,
0.4043343067,
0.1066653281,
1.1229121685,
0.5759010315,
-0.1626820415,
0.3293273449,
0.0169035364,
0.4995969534,
-0.6562489271,
-0.1084768325,
-0.4438065588,
-0.1872124374,
-0.2919619381,
-0.2119755596,
-0.1793352365,
0.3640427589,
-0.0915353149,
0.0187419355,
-0.4602919519,
0.5009998679,
0.5867415667,
0.2778845131,
0.4102772176,
0.0329737477,
0.0938951597,
-0.0108800074,
-0.5485997796,
-0.3139052689,
0.8122161031,
0.3658512235,
0.7938601971,
-0.0164063741,
0.8149293065,
0.0991467685,
0.3710571229,
-0.6985622048,
0.1459574997,
0.2650258243,
-0.727617979,
-0.2305188328,
-0.4685354531,
-0.7761850357,
0.4117961824,
-0.0846088305,
-0.5335472822,
0.6011818051,
0.3920874894,
-0.2300167382,
0.0339559577,
-1.0621058941,
1.0474528074,
0.1566300094,
-0.1821901053,
-0.0755617991,
-0.8764945865,
0.5007740855,
0.1361912042,
0.4194245338,
0.2619949877,
0.2948463559,
0.7613880038,
-0.2338530123,
1.0194702148,
-0.4727747738,
-0.0257207453,
0.1966222525,
-0.0906129032,
0.6764453053,
0.1396332085,
0.0718241185,
0.1400264949,
-0.334905535,
-0.3285287619,
-0.9178606272,
0.2899889052,
-0.4122196436,
-0.5756329298,
-0.0169567,
-0.6651736498,
-0.2698960006,
0.2287490517,
0.3713999689,
0.5915166736,
-0.0130504631,
0.0385168679,
0.7830608487,
-0.2894574702,
0.3603841364,
0.3091823161,
0.1449370831,
-0.3229428828,
0.7321900725,
-0.2488815635,
0.2193347961,
0.4907502234,
0.3801790774,
-0.4879018068,
-0.3909274042,
-0.3302143514,
0.2027338892,
-0.7629138827,
-0.0350423753,
-0.6048575044,
0.3482569158,
-0.2786849439,
-0.1958096325,
-0.064330861,
-0.154071331,
-0.1593542844,
-0.4158751369,
0.0423890688,
0.4842030108,
-0.0017776174,
0.1569923013,
-0.6193124056,
0.7973133922,
0.1390794665,
0.2218121141,
-0.089740634,
-0.6372452974,
-0.153940782,
0.1467989683,
-0.0829602182,
-1.2449624538,
0.3930370212,
0.1334476769,
0.731102705,
0.9013929367,
0.306973964,
0.7196830511,
-0.2411670685,
0.4500715137,
0.1407470107,
-0.9328851104,
0.5158119798,
-0.2086942643,
-0.1140241846,
0.3136320412,
0.1984119713,
-0.30372563,
-0.4789519608,
-0.426944077,
-0.8393269181,
0.7211310267,
0.1579575837,
-0.3035879731,
-0.3146970868,
0.3378913403,
0.2553395033,
-0.0326510854,
-0.6738122106,
-0.3851177394,
-0.2844111323,
-0.412304461,
0.1598119438,
-0.3110990524,
-0.4085565209,
-0.314098835,
0.4432874024,
-0.1780555993,
0.2363982648,
0.3879366219,
-0.4785386324,
-0.0179659259,
0.4523287714,
0.5015912652,
0.6465400457,
-0.4104822874,
0.2620609999,
0.0698612481,
-0.397000283,
-0.056958396,
0.373930186,
-0.2841235697,
0.1071238667,
0.3616274297,
0.7758771777,
-0.0328492038,
-0.5635212064,
0.597424984,
-0.1025424227,
-0.0236783586,
0.141405344,
-0.4633951485,
-0.0003172457,
0.1394901723,
0.3355402946,
0.3171799183,
0.3327590823,
-0.2249106914,
0.1560907364,
0.4891285002,
-0.4575811028,
-0.400923878,
0.7996606231,
0.3637397885,
0.2152896076,
0.4457571208,
-0.3005375564,
-0.3945226371,
0.6853398085,
0.7238682508,
1.1675440073,
0.1517406702,
0.1517540663,
0.2958368659,
0.542222023,
-0.2845705748,
0.1209371537,
-0.1325799078,
-0.9597845078,
-0.8007688522,
-0.5351856351,
-0.0740621984,
-0.1311386675,
-1.1309643984,
0.0712321177,
-0.0144516183,
0.0513287485,
-0.2277085334,
-0.5647896528,
-0.6800527573,
0.1688230187,
0.0268484131,
0.8253044486,
-1.3331613541,
0.5787279606,
0.5002299547,
-0.4829592109,
-0.6183257103,
0.4610516131,
0.0541845597,
-0.3527174592,
0.7396350503,
0.2774068415,
-0.0235692803,
0.1276557893,
-0.3096317947,
-0.4470265806,
0.9661058784,
0.7814929485,
-0.3405755758,
-0.0136118177,
-0.1045784801,
0.3791922033,
-0.1906360239,
0.3417771459,
0.9883614779,
0.6399880052,
-0.4309088588,
-0.6049434543,
0.4536221027,
0.1382100284,
-0.0129190506,
0.2601329386,
-0.1016775668,
0.4618194103,
-0.2638567686,
-0.335025996,
-0.4709113538,
0.5694060326,
0.078848429,
0.1928773075,
0.6380854845,
0.8617063761,
0.7682127953,
-0.1003542095,
1.1238743067,
-0.1576093882,
0.4797969162,
1.0400953293,
-0.0479047447,
0.2565660775,
0.8109987378,
-0.001237739,
0.5682028532,
0.6716267467,
0.2396862358,
0.6786795259,
-0.0801026747,
-0.2625172138,
-0.3872485459,
-0.1443254501,
-0.0484448969,
0.2075225264,
0.2064948827,
-0.4259893,
-0.5508850217,
-0.0036603741,
-0.0568712354,
0.0098976241,
-0.157842204,
0.7050634027,
-0.1595396101,
-0.7003943324,
0.3551200032,
-0.0681742132,
0.6602417827,
-0.2053687871,
-0.2918642461,
-0.3770292103,
0.2577728331,
-0.3840891719,
-0.4063474238,
0.4079127312,
-0.2182064354,
-0.526191473,
-0.3659997284,
0.6484956741,
-0.4749407172,
-0.149349317,
0.4057356715,
0.3120444715,
-0.1509005725,
-0.2123969048,
-0.3544061482,
-0.2126410306,
0.0140178353,
-0.3296482861,
0.1864373386,
0.5510390401,
-0.2013318986,
0.5322465301,
0.661853075,
0.0838963613,
0.1737122089,
0.4650417864,
0.7593165636,
-0.6307300329,
-0.5451025963,
-1.0492269993,
0.5682741404,
-0.1230858266,
-0.1161481962,
0.7547367811,
0.3199779391,
0.6747380495,
-0.2257503569,
0.8812729716,
-0.0663903579,
0.4793092906,
-0.5586378574,
0.4851155877,
-0.2660638988,
0.29937765,
-0.1630514413,
-0.9456109405,
-0.4974260032,
0.5652766824,
-0.2764813006,
0.0361640602,
0.9076783061,
0.8431405425,
-0.1953456849,
0.1000167057,
0.0040151696,
0.2802446485,
0.4354133606,
0.1837548614,
0.5294530392,
-0.1083170548,
0.7101799846,
-0.3663149774,
-0.516669929,
-0.1746554226,
-1.0084272623,
-1.0369712114,
-0.2047353387,
-0.3124566674,
-0.2040949613,
-0.0974879116,
0.8697989583,
0.4894903004,
-0.866633296,
0.2289927304,
-0.6865863204,
0.323040992,
-0.578573823,
-0.3564640284,
0.4031110406,
-0.3651322126,
-0.6489807963,
0.2928165495,
0.263240546,
-0.4321250916,
-0.125098452,
0.0382069983,
-0.0377770364,
0.0856361762,
0.4259602129,
0.1926216334,
-0.9148136973,
-0.3098143935,
-0.2951903641,
0.210285902,
-0.0195650812,
0.8385329843,
-0.838170588,
0.7374287844,
0.7451550364,
0.8306382895,
0.1570632905,
0.3910557032,
0.8005252481,
-0.7870240211,
0.2236481756,
-0.1180612296,
0.4853993952,
0.2838103175,
-0.2675250769,
0.3031242192,
0.3669543862,
-0.4116309583,
-0.8890593648,
0.3283911645,
-0.892337501,
-0.0410011709,
1.1147493124,
-0.1540767401,
-0.2010357529,
-0.6921464801,
-0.3035515845,
0.5505903363,
-0.3787617683,
0.8973459005,
0.5570497513,
-0.1736739725,
-0.1340351254,
-0.4322040677,
0.5878053904,
0.4064555168,
-0.8356661201,
0.4292174876,
0.5058742166,
0.3238835633,
-0.0857835561,
0.3485458195,
0.0444458127,
0.157472074,
-0.0822045729,
0.2289133817,
0.0723654851,
-0.1822330505,
-0.610655427,
-0.2064559311,
-0.2383572161,
-0.2724768817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13370v1
|
Movie101v2: Improved Movie Narration Benchmark
| 2024-04-20T13:15:27 | 2024-04-20T13:15:27 |
Zihao Yue, Yepeng Zhang, Ziheng Wang, Qin Jin
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Automatic movie narration targets at creating video-aligned plot descriptions
to assist visually impaired audiences. It differs from standard video
captioning in that it requires not only describing key visual details but also
inferring the plots developed across multiple movie shots, thus posing unique
and ongoing challenges. To advance the development of automatic movie narrating
systems, we first revisit the limitations of existing datasets and develop a
large-scale, bilingual movie narration dataset, Movie101v2. Second, taking into
account the essential difficulties in achieving applicable movie narration, we
break the long-term goal into three progressive stages and tentatively focus on
the initial stages featuring understanding within individual clips. We also
introduce a new narration assessment to align with our staged task goals.
Third, using our new dataset, we baseline several leading large vision-language
models, including GPT-4V, and conduct in-depth investigations into the
challenges current models face for movie narration generation. Our findings
reveal that achieving applicable movie narration generation is a fascinating
goal that requires thorough research.
|
[
-0.1078402027,
-0.4470126331,
0.481380403,
0.38242504,
-0.19423379,
0.0533348434,
0.2158083469,
-0.3635324538,
-0.1543317288,
0.357096225,
-0.5987171531,
-0.0055320296,
-0.6645684242,
0.2824146748,
-0.4950310588,
0.9740536809,
-0.4002248347,
0.1254189909,
-0.303424418,
-0.0717784762,
-0.7436474562,
-0.2432333678,
-0.4298412502,
-0.0729755834,
0.3378977478,
0.467694521,
0.7195514441,
1.012237072,
0.616790235,
0.1657814384,
0.2686216235,
0.1923011243,
-0.2185644209,
0.2147770524,
0.1061581001,
-0.1307735145,
-0.4073950052,
0.0641804859,
0.8770189285,
0.8097680211,
-0.0651325136,
0.4168688357,
0.0849023014,
0.6466856003,
-0.6388348341,
0.4376708567,
-0.0944439024,
0.2022039741,
-0.114406839,
0.1164872423,
-0.1695545316,
-0.3379158676,
0.2201248854,
-0.6611241102,
0.286514461,
0.0933635086,
0.9151309133,
0.4179801643,
-0.4394799769,
-0.0480860919,
-0.9253997803,
0.4534842968,
-0.3183318675,
0.1544219702,
0.489035964,
0.5885868073,
0.391782105,
-0.9349896908,
-0.3621766567,
-0.145752117,
0.1101224124,
0.0508473963,
-0.4166107774,
-0.1639084518,
0.4370501637,
0.4218834043,
-0.5991894603,
0.1364446878,
-0.6780186892,
-0.3980287611,
0.3894036412,
0.5361123085,
-0.1074686348,
-0.4460294545,
-0.5133250356,
-0.2252009213,
-0.4166526198,
0.2772952318,
0.3924830258,
-0.0609053001,
-0.1266949326,
0.4851844311,
-0.5880216956,
0.3665681183,
-0.064171873,
-0.0738277659,
0.3870785832,
-0.6113259792,
-0.2559810281,
0.1760746241,
0.3206105828,
0.9742270112,
0.5065507293,
0.1082396135,
-0.0720513314,
0.0162102394,
0.3908411562,
-0.7262351513,
-0.296721518,
0.0416331217,
-0.3479117155,
-0.204800114,
0.0466497391,
-0.8695796728,
-0.7806782126,
-0.4161812365,
0.6466950178,
-0.4007921815,
-0.0487832651,
-0.1552404612,
-0.4819925725,
0.623024404,
0.6125703454,
-0.8826314807,
0.5073148608,
0.3960903585,
0.7472441792,
-0.3810931742,
-0.3504394889,
-0.9342110157,
0.3315215409,
-0.5383902192,
0.6663247347,
-0.3552857339,
0.0360409394,
0.0305076391,
-0.0845012516,
0.1553366482,
-0.415597707,
0.3740658164,
-0.0115099102,
0.4311705828,
-0.2467024922,
-0.2545473874,
-0.1095107347,
0.3836206198,
-0.5306913257,
0.7061359882,
0.3853535354,
-0.2883507609,
0.4452795982,
-0.3490277529,
-0.2166792154,
0.068491675,
-0.3766630292,
-0.3611249924,
0.2607563734,
0.4659241438,
0.1041012406,
-0.5122728348,
0.4209062457,
0.3326197565,
-0.3958024681,
-0.1761300266,
-0.6372682452,
0.4177385867,
0.2648013532,
-0.2944564223,
-0.0215036981,
-0.6832429767,
0.0521590151,
0.0977217108,
0.1078497544,
0.2544897497,
0.0211676285,
-0.0781537443,
-0.1009640321,
0.1067211777,
-0.1443341076,
0.0828739926,
-0.2304972261,
0.2096603364,
0.6213744879,
0.1034973115,
0.3451201022,
-0.1710136533,
0.839923501,
-0.1635450423,
0.486076802,
-0.8448174596,
-0.4590634704,
-0.6990794539,
0.0489375554,
0.0647668466,
0.7323318124,
-0.7328287363,
-0.0470157191,
-0.2164028287,
-0.1390773654,
-0.2003688067,
0.0366779678,
0.5426421165,
0.5531696677,
0.5584284663,
-0.6279141307,
-0.720554471,
-1.0819711685,
0.1918471903,
-0.3497752249,
-0.2602923214,
0.0817966461,
0.2542414069,
0.2299060076,
0.5964733362,
-0.2818005681,
-0.54505831,
-0.3797457516,
0.0445454232,
0.1213764027,
0.397543937,
0.1459684074,
-0.7216778994,
-0.5475959182,
-0.1830744594,
-0.9950354695,
-0.0017503219,
-0.2348239869,
0.4984073341,
-0.1284147501,
0.7017205358,
-0.1981469691,
0.6125295162,
0.3453751504,
-0.4113166332,
0.6264172196,
-0.5749477744,
0.4245615005,
-0.5189875364,
-0.2595938444,
-0.0202771556,
-0.0080476897,
-0.7004871964,
-0.3247624338,
-0.0254789721,
-0.1461487263,
-0.4245329201,
0.2902933359,
-0.4946324229,
-0.2890039682,
-0.2236260027,
0.1105774269,
0.179913938,
0.3637879789,
-0.0126298117,
0.5350123048,
0.6641889215,
-0.4454258978,
0.7081948519,
0.4991576374,
-0.7093955874,
0.5051844716,
-0.627335906,
-0.2062850595,
-0.2571931481,
0.2634220421,
-1.1232864857,
-0.634005785,
0.1348666847,
-0.2815317512,
0.2384288758,
-0.1469503492,
-0.3688812256,
-0.2596944571,
-0.1477104425,
0.2702351511,
0.8016062379,
-0.1447152942,
0.4677307904,
0.1516174972,
-0.4587682784,
-0.2489171028,
-0.4269258976,
0.4354521632,
-0.6081950068,
-0.6334670782,
0.4222522378,
0.2501530647,
-0.3500267863,
-0.5687714219,
-0.3133168221,
-0.18342489,
-0.1931524277,
0.2372974753,
0.3175246119,
-0.1254404634,
0.1443796903,
-0.0606964082,
-0.4035960436,
0.1540814191,
0.0390885286,
0.1711402386,
0.1253011376,
0.0963778943,
-0.5834143162,
0.5103672743,
0.4340204298,
-0.4103599787,
0.0121570509,
0.8105245829,
-0.1587022543,
0.102931872,
-0.6710543036,
0.0250502378,
-0.4166479409,
0.5954937935,
-0.5705803633,
-0.4165765345,
0.2533416748,
-0.1441531926,
-0.254907757,
0.3704584539,
0.2763472199,
-0.1062681228,
1.1612871885,
0.7793850303,
0.3955807686,
0.4062738717,
0.0009579587,
-0.0922700912,
-0.6795625687,
-0.4255990386,
-0.3103630841,
-0.1387065351,
-0.2863762677,
-0.5455565453,
0.4876094162,
0.3700959682,
-0.4418826401,
0.3542928398,
-0.4354299605,
0.6828907728,
0.4213427007,
-0.2573067844,
0.3774374127,
0.2056830674,
-0.0469919667,
-0.3252580464,
-0.5915783644,
-0.6395779848,
0.7098535895,
0.5755230784,
0.6602955461,
0.2118680328,
0.2233338654,
0.4687671661,
-0.1306911856,
-0.2968186438,
0.4632209539,
-0.3340698183,
-0.5434157848,
-0.430398941,
0.111503467,
-0.6562317014,
-0.0680090487,
0.0811598152,
-1.0991866589,
0.3609427214,
0.2198262513,
-0.515037179,
-0.1783391982,
-0.8742503524,
1.1819924116,
-0.3211834729,
-0.5925449133,
-0.035937544,
-1.0988745689,
0.0840032101,
0.0804820061,
0.1151916683,
-0.2191608399,
-0.1100080386,
0.7089002132,
-0.2187990695,
0.6294935942,
-0.3607993126,
0.1510419101,
0.4474991858,
0.2020750046,
0.6679885387,
-0.1323212236,
-0.0283257905,
-0.2057785541,
0.058605779,
-0.2615192831,
-0.455147326,
0.3184788823,
-0.3749173284,
-0.6963418722,
-0.4723230302,
-0.3953133821,
-0.4095734358,
-0.1444996744,
0.1967886537,
0.5652894378,
-0.2065061033,
0.2361894846,
0.4826948345,
-0.4577080607,
0.6451554894,
0.3236577809,
-0.4161168337,
-0.6602708101,
0.8486210108,
-0.0196882691,
0.4380086064,
0.0807979479,
0.0096108122,
-0.1777883917,
-0.7902082205,
-0.7031915784,
-0.152119562,
-0.7279994488,
-0.0825209692,
-0.3617425859,
-0.1162915006,
-0.2953706086,
-0.0448880866,
-0.4405433536,
-0.3325619102,
0.1044139788,
-0.4684065878,
0.1985830218,
0.7828407884,
-0.1640308797,
0.1552403867,
-0.6197996736,
0.5473054051,
0.4136642218,
0.362788856,
-0.300039798,
-0.8493700027,
-0.3606348336,
-0.406318754,
-0.3331958652,
-0.5836901665,
0.4074948132,
0.2135400921,
0.4513075352,
0.1624620259,
-0.1498527229,
0.8798651099,
-0.7120438814,
0.9964296222,
0.4329708517,
-0.7885366678,
0.814132154,
-0.3074206412,
0.4885570705,
0.4870867133,
0.3247264624,
-0.3383898735,
-0.009343775,
-0.4443761408,
-0.7901208401,
0.7882675529,
0.7140614986,
0.2478365451,
0.2496331632,
0.0989484936,
0.4851277769,
0.0838769227,
-0.5190326571,
-0.242812857,
-0.4978497922,
0.0762530044,
-0.4277451932,
-0.3133152723,
-0.0602390207,
-0.4752835035,
0.1883427203,
-0.1311273724,
0.1095942706,
0.3514212072,
0.1003846079,
-0.2141906917,
0.0573259145,
0.432263732,
0.755197227,
-0.3638774753,
0.025064351,
0.2183519453,
-0.3302009106,
0.2423358262,
0.3411956728,
-0.0948484838,
0.0794664696,
0.5955893397,
1.1941072941,
-0.1226749942,
-0.7587275505,
0.4871659279,
0.2155573964,
-0.4935527146,
-0.4464337826,
0.0273573045,
-0.3098700047,
0.2904466093,
0.8069208264,
-0.2020546794,
0.2262074947,
-0.7382865548,
0.3302464187,
-0.0861349851,
-0.5715169311,
-0.0745210275,
0.945289731,
0.2926176488,
-0.4022533596,
0.7516277432,
-0.1056764275,
-0.1244767457,
0.8133373857,
0.2867589593,
0.7652680278,
-0.1709291637,
0.5020407438,
0.6398627162,
0.311252296,
-0.2136538178,
-0.0907498077,
-0.2220458984,
-0.4408795834,
-0.3634478748,
-0.5267916918,
-0.522577107,
-0.0084620267,
-0.7434375882,
0.2633821368,
-0.170034349,
0.1597572118,
0.3049026132,
-0.1192260906,
-0.3858053982,
0.458334744,
0.5724074841,
0.5893560052,
-0.6513857841,
0.8766108751,
0.2652521133,
-0.7028082013,
-0.5861003399,
-0.2574548125,
0.068049252,
-0.5970076323,
0.8143837452,
0.4949697256,
0.2514315248,
0.0970957428,
-0.492842555,
-0.8291969299,
1.3413625956,
0.2698124647,
-0.4710046947,
-0.6062387228,
0.2521318793,
0.5962432027,
-0.6927482486,
0.1456563622,
0.6592939496,
0.6409085989,
0.1213575751,
-1.2607392073,
-0.2375453413,
-0.2348567694,
-0.1387910992,
0.019080488,
-0.4689193368,
0.6372339129,
-0.3958717883,
-0.0591196679,
0.2717565,
0.4476980269,
-0.0418199077,
0.6117719412,
0.4898636341,
0.015738707,
0.3784928322,
-0.2652687132,
1.2769385576,
0.3277873397,
-0.1022794917,
1.4799138308,
-0.3303690553,
0.4555446506,
0.5158402324,
-0.4074340761,
0.447163254,
0.3581804037,
-0.4331080914,
0.4972029328,
0.1768183857,
0.0046003996,
-0.5221236944,
-0.1789358854,
-0.2401587367,
0.7407242656,
0.1857460588,
-0.5495694876,
-0.2445936203,
0.3646329045,
-0.5826817751,
0.2794916034,
-0.2415614873,
0.9668662548,
-0.1768025309,
-0.8402338028,
0.423607111,
-0.3004371524,
0.0051185186,
-0.7205964923,
-0.2195095271,
-0.4858005643,
0.056026306,
0.1937714964,
-0.6001774073,
0.1120766401,
0.389801234,
-0.2449149787,
-0.5521218777,
0.1346702874,
-0.3689349294,
-0.3437686563,
-0.0884497836,
0.4890820384,
0.5029765964,
-0.1405934244,
-0.4706485271,
0.3155854642,
0.3880643845,
-0.028130481,
0.2030369043,
0.269136101,
-0.2519574463,
0.630720675,
-0.1331235915,
-0.2195628881,
0.0254824962,
0.200166598,
0.3712543845,
-0.8743961453,
-0.3185353577,
-0.6185362935,
0.9058238268,
-0.2355749905,
-0.4797578156,
0.7301268578,
0.6684219837,
0.6173602939,
-0.1948911548,
0.602150321,
-0.1534250528,
0.3712624907,
-0.591163516,
0.1000596136,
-0.2898055911,
0.3464341164,
-0.1807061434,
-1.2670993805,
-0.2111299634,
0.3447223604,
-0.1442307532,
-0.0394144468,
1.0127452612,
0.6795555949,
0.1649962366,
-0.230938822,
0.4179842174,
-0.0038728751,
0.3191233873,
0.4881172776,
0.8562726378,
-0.7993091345,
1.0288221836,
-0.3844305873,
-0.0651762187,
0.0206911005,
-0.797917068,
-0.4297502339,
-0.6432749033,
-0.8121196628,
-0.1962107271,
0.3692636192,
0.5117801428,
0.5917448997,
-0.6732754111,
-0.3589610159,
-0.1795256734,
-0.2670986056,
-0.4558927715,
-0.2378235012,
0.3208045661,
-0.1203561574,
-0.8953437209,
0.6496035457,
0.5264890194,
0.1478801668,
-0.3032746017,
-0.3411659002,
-0.0344774574,
0.0976345316,
0.4224712551,
0.2652079463,
-0.6832040548,
-0.2689240277,
-0.3506395817,
0.0514859259,
0.2176377028,
0.7176538706,
-0.8438648582,
0.8764426112,
0.1846585572,
0.1731007248,
0.7901608348,
0.2550012469,
1.0079885721,
-0.5464458466,
-0.0328450277,
0.0774010941,
0.1680356562,
0.4894842207,
0.0130173611,
0.8092272878,
0.0499663129,
-0.4123997092,
-0.9209027886,
0.1989611983,
-1.2161587477,
-0.1052155197,
1.0270398855,
0.0045335377,
0.2771824598,
-0.2388956845,
-0.4943916798,
-0.0063411728,
-0.1472740024,
0.4788754582,
0.7495432496,
-0.3549930155,
-0.4391337633,
-0.635618329,
0.7980223298,
0.2301501334,
-0.6361843348,
0.4017784894,
0.8709811568,
-0.016080711,
-0.0053383424,
0.4434130192,
-0.1828659028,
0.6449198127,
0.5629402995,
-0.1469467729,
-0.4259737134,
-0.5152485967,
-0.3975241482,
0.5063501596,
-0.1761717498,
-0.1142440662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13364v1
|
MahaSQuAD: Bridging Linguistic Divides in Marathi Question-Answering
| 2024-04-20T12:16:35 | 2024-04-20T12:16:35 |
Ruturaj Ghatage, Aditya Kulkarni, Rajlaxmi Patil, Sharvi Endait, Raviraj Joshi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Question-answering systems have revolutionized information retrieval, but
linguistic and cultural boundaries limit their widespread accessibility. This
research endeavors to bridge the gap of the absence of efficient QnA datasets
in low-resource languages by translating the English Question Answering Dataset
(SQuAD) using a robust data curation approach. We introduce MahaSQuAD, the
first-ever full SQuAD dataset for the Indic language Marathi, consisting of
118,516 training, 11,873 validation, and 11,803 test samples. We also present a
gold test set of manually verified 500 examples. Challenges in maintaining
context and handling linguistic nuances are addressed, ensuring accurate
translations. Moreover, as a QnA dataset cannot be simply converted into any
low-resource language using translation, we need a robust method to map the
answer translation to its span in the translated passage. Hence, to address
this challenge, we also present a generic approach for translating SQuAD into
any low-resource language. Thus, we offer a scalable approach to bridge
linguistic and cultural gaps present in low-resource languages, in the realm of
question-answering systems. The datasets and models are shared publicly at
https://github.com/l3cube-pune/MarathiNLP .
|
[
-0.4417814016,
-0.8068484068,
0.2003168464,
0.1836172789,
-0.3943529129,
0.4951130748,
-0.1066099405,
-0.2233482152,
0.3309054971,
0.4773675501,
-0.9241347909,
-0.233264938,
-0.4293355644,
0.30617401,
-0.2341509163,
1.0313301086,
-0.0809392482,
0.0292439405,
-0.3165097237,
-0.7278422117,
-0.4867088199,
-0.4821845591,
-0.4455750287,
0.07444904,
0.0949063152,
0.6723912358,
0.6675516367,
0.318967253,
0.5346892476,
0.2117406577,
-0.0380004495,
0.5802260041,
-0.4773293138,
0.6072651744,
-0.197404623,
-0.4580257535,
-0.0492587276,
-0.3242304325,
0.4711681008,
0.5914254785,
-0.3646828532,
0.3619583547,
0.0618309081,
0.7119222283,
-0.6690070033,
0.2254508585,
-0.6358628273,
-0.0441077761,
-0.5198184252,
0.0147357909,
-0.2279103994,
-0.596121788,
-0.3148991764,
-0.5958760381,
0.0880014747,
-0.089360334,
0.834747076,
0.3443902731,
-0.3796588778,
-0.2100893259,
-0.6915562749,
0.7681312561,
-0.4925753474,
-0.1675643027,
0.5493989587,
0.7411282063,
0.1965733767,
-0.1770564616,
-0.47258389,
0.5419206023,
0.1718045622,
0.2127782404,
-0.1163914353,
-0.2959522605,
0.005995871,
0.6191940308,
-0.7337261438,
-0.2806223929,
-0.6499730349,
-0.0487880707,
0.8692317605,
0.3957075775,
0.6963887215,
-0.3015944064,
-0.1763721257,
0.0855631083,
-0.5618818998,
0.1244501024,
0.1688175648,
0.5201476216,
-0.21842435,
0.8175984621,
-0.6862469912,
0.5486604571,
-0.1602612883,
0.2005436569,
0.1487122625,
-0.5309419632,
0.0076062125,
0.0206984505,
0.8807480931,
0.2113618404,
0.3473598659,
-0.1248932555,
-0.0018135495,
0.2782982886,
0.0709374472,
-0.6411268115,
-0.2676210105,
0.1349970102,
0.0105894366,
-0.3340192437,
-0.2509687245,
-0.8117714524,
-0.2529533207,
0.2497989237,
0.1685529053,
-0.4962979853,
-0.3413925469,
0.0777038112,
0.2338154465,
0.8007264137,
0.0356705263,
-0.8225463033,
0.3235342801,
0.4259728491,
0.8094920516,
-0.2591166794,
0.1569891125,
-0.4484170675,
0.1115599647,
-0.5294956565,
0.7429475784,
-0.5347318053,
-0.5077819824,
0.0897177309,
-0.1106321141,
-0.0990977213,
-0.4801979065,
0.4949062169,
-0.8277291059,
0.1484212875,
-0.3518933058,
-0.3556845784,
-0.0775024742,
0.3818636537,
-0.5081797242,
1.1623237133,
0.3607368469,
-0.7101701498,
-0.0135093965,
-0.5163285732,
-0.553780973,
0.5185152888,
-0.1231866851,
-0.1463485658,
-0.0325893089,
0.6533576846,
0.1136584431,
-0.4414809048,
0.2111578584,
-0.071475789,
-0.0018136856,
0.2157679796,
-0.1553168893,
1.1909304857,
0.6083552837,
0.1159490943,
-0.1786090434,
-0.395914495,
0.3113899231,
0.137359038,
-0.1028593406,
-0.3221593797,
-0.034570016,
-0.02539552,
0.4779402316,
0.1843416244,
-0.8385696411,
0.2273832113,
-0.3889324963,
0.5820248127,
0.3965361416,
0.1765537709,
0.5742583275,
-0.3595502377,
1.1033138037,
0.2800641954,
0.2992543578,
0.0257233307,
-0.8465336561,
-0.5519124866,
-0.1887122393,
0.1051206142,
0.8942621946,
-1.3486421108,
0.0708647743,
-0.3637968004,
-0.4851062596,
-1.0532841682,
0.3599006832,
0.3757359087,
0.4348262846,
0.5574163198,
-0.2298769057,
-0.4573028386,
-1.0433946848,
-0.1061346829,
-0.1790355593,
0.0766855851,
0.0808643624,
0.2112709433,
-0.148369357,
0.9681574106,
-0.5040596724,
-0.1861612797,
-0.5511683822,
-0.2925578654,
0.002835253,
0.4056443274,
0.0372914337,
-0.806398809,
-0.4389773607,
-0.1743675023,
-0.8381417394,
-0.2126430869,
0.307957679,
-0.6776806116,
0.0482862517,
0.452585578,
-0.6623129845,
0.305282414,
0.7556626797,
-0.0435194261,
0.3530263901,
0.1862631738,
0.3827240467,
-1.5763889551,
-0.2374220639,
-0.3021675944,
-0.1688683182,
-0.5373817086,
0.5156500936,
0.0768186972,
-0.4600491226,
-0.3782420754,
0.3611158133,
-0.2112333775,
0.1925421059,
0.2364663929,
0.3555143476,
0.0467032269,
0.3480066657,
-0.3231900632,
1.2015278339,
0.4228712022,
-0.4369267821,
0.4435107112,
0.8685268164,
-0.4068775475,
0.7212029696,
-0.6136351228,
0.1259089261,
-0.1306541115,
0.039961312,
-1.2870721817,
-0.2616052926,
0.3695411384,
-0.547565937,
-0.0245714784,
-0.3831053078,
-0.518918097,
-0.1186232716,
-0.0884260014,
0.977930367,
0.5413131714,
-0.1084074527,
0.2130726427,
0.7717241645,
-0.589412868,
-0.29570508,
-1.0395425558,
0.0885796845,
-0.0218967814,
-0.7239043117,
-0.1771788448,
-0.2104552388,
-0.3141170442,
-0.105678156,
-0.1101493537,
-0.6629809141,
-0.1035343111,
0.1856923103,
0.4231179953,
-0.4151443839,
0.1952137947,
0.1715744734,
0.0679806471,
-0.0283293128,
-0.0846515298,
0.3624146581,
-0.2381438166,
-0.1983860433,
-0.0517247207,
0.7258056402,
0.653087616,
-0.8315809369,
0.6758487225,
0.211202845,
-0.1629581451,
-0.1769222766,
-0.3410772383,
0.1329329163,
-0.4038007557,
0.1096112356,
-0.511842072,
-0.7557117939,
0.4842296243,
0.2429866195,
0.1392125636,
0.5515890718,
0.3548636436,
-0.2459736466,
1.0056914091,
0.5102052689,
-0.2992143333,
-0.0395935252,
-0.1363864094,
0.3351708949,
-0.8370120525,
-0.1502450258,
-0.5274339914,
-0.1293970197,
-0.7445049882,
-0.6168115139,
0.4363495708,
-0.2310364991,
-0.0122653758,
0.3062150478,
-0.5738706589,
0.3631546795,
0.1927554905,
0.2066213787,
0.3959183693,
-0.095238179,
0.1552146822,
-0.1951587945,
-0.9664598703,
-0.4310037196,
0.9141204357,
-0.3083629906,
0.6184752584,
0.4503724277,
0.5511684418,
0.2026855052,
0.1603456438,
-0.6914644837,
0.651311934,
0.0399289988,
-0.92622751,
-0.4106515646,
-0.508030653,
-0.7888464928,
0.261362642,
-0.237634778,
-0.1215699911,
-0.0156439561,
-0.2291873097,
-0.2884759307,
0.3381957412,
-0.5594687462,
0.6768714786,
-0.0314751938,
-0.2747223377,
-0.0224370304,
-0.7048586011,
0.649905622,
-0.0213593934,
0.4015908539,
-0.2390234321,
-0.0637951419,
0.7127318382,
-0.5190558434,
0.2936846912,
0.0878010392,
-0.007901323,
0.4211569428,
0.3457062244,
0.0786952898,
-0.0058086514,
-0.2483680248,
-0.1252243072,
0.4170381725,
-1.1188714504,
-0.4839512408,
0.4675331116,
-0.6740516424,
-0.3299285769,
-0.3843014836,
-0.8979561925,
-0.6569167972,
-0.0575705394,
0.3214751482,
0.5904569626,
-0.0576637052,
0.1645806581,
0.8970626593,
-0.0854171813,
0.2237324119,
0.3780370951,
-0.2139388025,
-0.1076678187,
0.7229188681,
0.1212743595,
0.3136279285,
0.237916708,
-0.2273790091,
-0.444647342,
-0.2812281847,
-0.9388058186,
0.0971395969,
-0.5443799496,
-0.2927036881,
-0.3708846271,
-0.407363236,
-0.2503921092,
-0.0592876449,
-0.3612062931,
-0.5281096697,
0.311594069,
-0.0620307662,
0.5280438662,
0.6427446008,
0.4259907305,
0.0460372046,
-0.6724486947,
0.4508209825,
0.3783891797,
0.2258560508,
-0.4894132316,
-0.6074909568,
-0.1959206462,
0.207754463,
-0.0165420249,
-1.0833026171,
0.3093706965,
0.2378768027,
0.2135028094,
0.0473956838,
0.49741745,
0.7769405842,
-0.3065252602,
0.766782999,
-0.1506890059,
-0.5952246189,
0.8474546075,
-0.426836431,
0.7080579996,
1.1481552124,
0.4318482578,
-0.551199317,
-0.6829428673,
-0.5532883406,
-0.8223447204,
0.3625673652,
0.2788585424,
0.1643595845,
-0.1999283433,
0.2743683457,
-0.0978200212,
0.2487352937,
-0.0978989899,
-0.1720187068,
0.0144111756,
-0.3979355693,
-0.266413033,
0.0257476754,
-0.004741346,
-0.3663026989,
0.6555113792,
0.0244408138,
-0.2179751992,
0.1179213077,
-0.5836805701,
0.0893381536,
0.3738236725,
0.2363806665,
0.4994806051,
0.0832715034,
-0.1102918908,
0.3777439594,
-0.5848714709,
0.4156303406,
-0.1277984083,
-0.399079144,
0.1468967944,
-0.0300609805,
0.165630877,
0.1679765433,
-0.7676189542,
0.5613766313,
-0.0873728395,
0.0958681852,
-0.1017907858,
-0.093185164,
-0.0247809533,
-0.1224660724,
0.2669970691,
0.0073764282,
0.0395885818,
-0.5462288857,
0.1931831986,
0.3284748793,
-0.6200528145,
-0.033134222,
0.6684791446,
0.2839861512,
-0.1390163004,
0.8805969357,
-0.3341244161,
-0.3808898926,
0.3956196308,
0.0751094222,
0.659511745,
-0.5220298171,
0.396964699,
0.3756543398,
0.5066158175,
0.1184614152,
0.4267037511,
-0.2969463468,
-0.5198457837,
-0.5074022412,
-0.5886844993,
-0.5587731004,
-0.2589481473,
-1.0228295326,
0.0218151435,
-0.3005916774,
0.072959654,
-0.3431273997,
0.1468098462,
-0.597582221,
0.0558294766,
0.0046152314,
0.9599740505,
-1.1231354475,
0.8394096494,
0.8458502293,
-0.7410373688,
-0.6802916527,
-0.2019685954,
-0.089936994,
-0.7801268101,
0.191487655,
-0.1910621077,
-0.2132222652,
0.1275222301,
-0.5494132638,
-0.4663308561,
0.751642704,
0.0722189322,
-0.2274633199,
0.1134667397,
0.2844339311,
0.4005697966,
-0.2078161538,
0.0709478185,
0.6191310287,
0.1278028786,
-0.0432265326,
-0.5482022166,
0.0689992085,
-0.6458390951,
0.0783110484,
0.3037946224,
-0.5290808082,
0.5965412259,
-0.1079201847,
-0.3200629652,
0.212741375,
0.5862064362,
0.2818253338,
-0.1001865938,
0.2871176898,
0.5573713183,
0.7233813405,
-0.1719434261,
0.9886382222,
-0.3020625412,
0.1135668233,
0.8558850884,
-0.2460360974,
0.9959614873,
0.5230890512,
-0.3405030668,
0.5549991131,
0.4861253798,
0.4303860068,
0.4378521144,
0.1716421396,
-0.5276873708,
-0.404424727,
-0.123817414,
-0.2649919689,
0.4162788093,
0.292922765,
0.4132833481,
-0.495334357,
0.0585749485,
-0.1155919284,
0.4389674962,
-0.180912897,
0.7664197683,
-0.0727164149,
-0.6509266496,
0.6307301521,
-0.1994619966,
0.6099406481,
-0.7487290502,
0.1159207299,
-0.7235408425,
-0.2501285076,
-0.2251971513,
-1.0010714531,
0.5586752892,
0.2271499336,
-0.1855132431,
-0.1476524323,
0.4218884706,
-0.7356736064,
-0.5150896907,
-0.1915962547,
0.7922548652,
0.3351652324,
-0.1216877997,
-0.5734964013,
0.0278462395,
-0.1650677025,
0.3219618499,
0.1893778741,
0.5351191759,
-0.2784619033,
0.8837323785,
0.4212097228,
0.0854853466,
0.3073460162,
-0.2986139059,
0.5924236774,
-0.3690136969,
-0.7093743682,
-0.5216776133,
0.4464546144,
-0.0795712173,
-0.4516909719,
0.8133388162,
0.7978805304,
0.6571341157,
0.0325583145,
0.964347899,
-0.1033157259,
0.5032873154,
-0.2160427123,
0.9530099034,
-0.373254329,
0.0547738932,
-0.0266369358,
-0.5728085041,
-0.0170893539,
0.3493358493,
-0.2603930831,
-0.318117559,
0.4631693065,
0.9951902032,
-0.1283113509,
0.1946747154,
0.310487777,
0.0432593897,
0.058725059,
0.8493867517,
0.8487063646,
-0.8206348419,
1.0463731289,
-0.2583301663,
-0.1389673948,
-0.0875826851,
-0.2101314962,
-0.452553153,
-0.9984563589,
-0.3741147518,
-0.4536454678,
0.1521386206,
0.6461672187,
0.7468782067,
-1.0054081678,
-0.2646107674,
0.1964412332,
0.0901875272,
-0.1584807187,
-0.1998498291,
0.0776438043,
-0.4890654981,
-0.5073120594,
0.2396146506,
0.2830911577,
-0.3461077213,
-0.2077754289,
0.0634049848,
-0.4653559625,
0.2588690817,
0.7561015487,
0.5947175622,
-0.3202573061,
0.0940098837,
0.131937176,
-0.5209348202,
0.1802922487,
0.460636884,
-0.7120386958,
0.638920784,
0.4106296599,
1.1853233576,
0.4459916353,
0.1455690712,
0.4830226898,
-0.6779606938,
0.1835408062,
0.3629261255,
0.0421958566,
0.5440669656,
-0.0512651131,
0.5708358288,
0.1023359522,
-0.3360075057,
-0.7081612349,
0.4343704581,
-1.031735301,
0.0127234031,
1.136903882,
0.112822406,
-0.2837879956,
-0.5638144612,
-0.3026934862,
0.2874577641,
-0.0567591898,
0.7748835683,
0.8263711333,
0.1324313283,
-0.2193040401,
-1.0424830914,
0.4525680542,
0.5638936758,
-0.9443135262,
-0.0526062958,
0.3202152848,
0.2630746365,
-0.2068377435,
0.8437073827,
-0.4270489216,
0.363973707,
-0.2570443451,
-0.0154606681,
0.1676176041,
0.1156206205,
-0.4188893735,
0.0072062709,
-0.0430548973,
-0.651252985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13362v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13362v1
|
Semantically Corrected Amharic Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-04-20T12:08:00 | 2024-04-20T12:08:00 |
Samuael Adnew, Paul Pu Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) can play a crucial role in enhancing the
accessibility of spoken languages worldwide. In this paper, we build a set of
ASR tools for Amharic, a language spoken by more than 50 million people
primarily in eastern Africa. Amharic is written in the Ge'ez script, a sequence
of graphemes with spacings denoting word boundaries. This makes computational
processing of Amharic challenging since the location of spacings can
significantly impact the meaning of formed sentences. We find that existing
benchmarks for Amharic ASR do not account for these spacings and only measure
individual grapheme error rates, leading to significantly inflated measurements
of in-the-wild performance. In this paper, we first release corrected
transcriptions of existing Amharic ASR test datasets, enabling the community to
accurately evaluate progress. Furthermore, we introduce a post-processing
approach using a transformer encoder-decoder architecture to organize raw ASR
outputs into a grammatically complete and semantically meaningful Amharic
sentence. Through experiments on the corrected test dataset, our model enhances
the semantic correctness of Amharic speech recognition systems, achieving a
Character Error Rate (CER) of 5.5\% and a Word Error Rate (WER) of 23.3\%.
|
[
-0.1172218472,
-0.7412111759,
-0.1450422704,
0.2085966915,
-0.0582481585,
0.37778005,
-0.521329999,
-0.8086076975,
0.5351413488,
0.2926277518,
-0.3059887886,
-0.5940926671,
-0.6756138802,
0.3855716884,
-0.5512623787,
0.5426691175,
-0.253282398,
0.1130042374,
0.2830137312,
-0.4702152312,
-0.2927043736,
-0.6462267041,
-0.6224401593,
-0.0916809812,
0.4420356154,
0.4958942533,
0.8732717037,
0.6010406017,
0.0800061673,
0.3399968743,
-0.2493156493,
0.2670572996,
-0.143805176,
-0.0653245524,
0.4714097381,
0.0307509843,
-0.4067200124,
-0.3419101536,
0.6388280988,
0.8017367125,
-0.5593482256,
-0.0262266733,
0.1276254207,
0.442723155,
-0.5731562972,
0.0947819799,
-0.6463231444,
-0.1157515794,
-0.4978337884,
0.0554426424,
-0.1673499495,
-0.3209564984,
-0.1539327055,
-0.612960577,
0.4108349085,
-0.050805293,
0.8328014612,
0.3135682046,
-0.1396796852,
-0.7957966328,
-0.7012880445,
0.3802030385,
-0.7047514319,
0.4261333346,
0.3545844257,
0.5941793323,
-0.1966539919,
-0.5644710064,
-0.8396815062,
-0.0597241186,
-0.1017742082,
0.0678597093,
-0.2940272093,
0.0744615495,
0.4504927695,
0.3415117562,
-0.4054251015,
0.0165585726,
-0.4949953854,
-0.6733649969,
0.5294871926,
-0.0008204686,
0.4913098216,
-0.1659343541,
0.0535577871,
-0.2390263379,
-0.5771408081,
0.3361821771,
0.7467874289,
0.4596552849,
-0.0936691388,
0.8590978384,
-0.1705915779,
0.882576406,
-0.3121721148,
0.1952906251,
0.4631172717,
-0.3077380359,
0.0120370127,
0.6014567018,
0.6233894229,
0.2217993885,
0.4363225102,
-0.2186346799,
-0.349989444,
0.4365203083,
0.5835129619,
-0.4851844013,
-0.2798601687,
-0.0638252422,
-0.0237767603,
0.1658228487,
-0.0456508249,
-0.4291145205,
-0.0552581474,
-0.2131495625,
0.4706661701,
-0.4735078514,
0.3867427111,
0.1207587495,
0.1053436548,
0.2325309813,
0.5779084563,
-0.798270762,
0.5130659938,
0.162830472,
0.7826260924,
0.3257018626,
-0.2104937285,
-0.5689359903,
0.1255137622,
-0.09365841,
0.7705193162,
-0.4895377755,
-0.668222785,
-0.0595413335,
0.0288747344,
-0.1274403632,
-0.6169358492,
0.7612546682,
-0.538470149,
-0.3457596302,
-0.2118430138,
-0.3768521547,
-0.2622526288,
-0.0637956485,
-0.5655124784,
0.5439196229,
-0.0640391856,
-0.6198714972,
0.4232058227,
-0.7618897557,
-0.7789210081,
-0.0251887832,
-0.1175488234,
-0.3667868674,
-0.2460588217,
0.3898251057,
-0.0773513317,
0.1354691386,
-0.0583765134,
-0.01648519,
-0.3941974938,
0.3779854774,
-0.4048763812,
0.6410172582,
0.1794483364,
-0.2673240304,
0.1653635055,
-0.9129984379,
0.2753014266,
-0.319442153,
-0.5505310297,
-0.0847477987,
0.0807549059,
0.326197803,
0.1335426271,
0.0405102819,
-1.0404307842,
-0.1778329462,
-0.7286458611,
0.6451319456,
0.4610207081,
-0.3890212774,
0.2560192347,
-0.1709481478,
0.1829584986,
0.0158626866,
-0.1537673622,
0.0332808085,
-0.4780266583,
-1.0102796555,
-0.1581636667,
0.719319284,
0.634349823,
-0.4905560315,
0.5894756913,
-0.3974708021,
-0.3989281952,
-0.939273417,
-0.0666444674,
0.3565756679,
0.6679617763,
0.6262004375,
-0.3152544498,
-0.661717236,
-0.7696599364,
-0.4077427983,
-0.2352705598,
-0.3070233762,
0.5382436514,
0.3085774779,
-0.4625458717,
0.6783662438,
-0.4216243923,
-0.4783067107,
0.0935694426,
0.2006833255,
0.070689328,
0.3741047084,
-0.0992404595,
-0.5707401633,
-0.3869371116,
0.0296674296,
-0.356281966,
-0.3812183142,
0.4483148754,
0.183364585,
0.46667099,
0.5700030327,
-0.3789177537,
0.7717320323,
0.4393440187,
-0.3205369115,
0.4305869639,
-0.457310468,
0.3767260611,
-0.6890097857,
0.2074918896,
-0.4237375259,
-0.052008003,
-0.4745396674,
-0.3844495714,
0.2142216712,
-0.1846238673,
-0.1441510171,
0.4858757257,
-0.3595503271,
-0.2543111444,
-0.268528074,
0.1612405032,
-0.3014266193,
0.1935722679,
-0.2468700707,
0.9837306142,
0.3118551075,
-0.7511717677,
0.3027233481,
0.7261795402,
-0.2702240646,
0.11619813,
-0.8306390643,
0.0452007204,
0.0315263756,
0.2121083587,
-0.9761746526,
-0.5176330805,
0.2545830607,
-0.8424681425,
0.4234425426,
0.1460592747,
-0.4899976254,
-0.3312236667,
0.0884877369,
0.3268434107,
0.3903415203,
-0.4886274934,
0.5789815784,
0.5863104463,
-0.1491678655,
-0.6698251963,
-0.7091377378,
0.3437111974,
0.129338488,
-1.0598340034,
0.4673776329,
0.3105328977,
-0.1350120604,
0.0087170545,
-0.0837906376,
0.1726986021,
0.0136946682,
0.4008894563,
-0.1706924438,
-0.1037430987,
-0.01299359,
-0.1083027199,
-0.3166514933,
-0.2254091799,
-0.0951405168,
0.4063049853,
-0.0675806254,
-0.4018380046,
-0.0194663536,
0.1772875339,
0.2350556999,
-0.1802399755,
0.6055879593,
0.3674643934,
-0.6466162801,
0.0312343501,
-0.4537644684,
0.1053635925,
-0.391010046,
-0.0006024428,
-0.3677202463,
-0.8020237684,
0.9097365141,
0.2318919152,
-0.0787524357,
0.2944487035,
0.286806345,
-0.0633469969,
0.7739126086,
0.364919126,
0.0296046082,
0.1202379465,
-0.0160819162,
0.4428372085,
-0.9133118987,
-0.1814350784,
-0.7579289079,
-0.3895943761,
-0.6347774267,
-0.5263790488,
0.6125212908,
-0.0765918568,
0.0483087748,
0.5561407208,
-0.1463437676,
0.2742188573,
0.4343370795,
0.2739485502,
0.2935084701,
0.1180623621,
-0.2415490896,
-0.0454404466,
-0.359960109,
-0.7152813673,
0.6010438204,
-0.05755255,
0.8404060602,
0.2706702352,
0.3426445127,
0.3636671007,
-0.0057858904,
-0.869720757,
0.2625378072,
-0.587651968,
-0.1796027124,
-0.5410146713,
-0.2089675963,
-0.8969944715,
0.0382990241,
0.0191254821,
-0.5510835052,
0.0866007209,
0.4352081716,
-0.4216305315,
0.0951339975,
-0.8713746071,
0.9206440449,
0.0643066987,
0.1319379508,
-0.2544698119,
-1.0489797592,
-0.1403040141,
-0.0901411325,
0.2122823894,
-0.0817581415,
-0.0007798985,
0.6812127233,
-0.9341808558,
0.531064868,
-0.2824014425,
0.0959317684,
0.2389165461,
-0.1726244241,
0.4016848505,
-0.2798611224,
-0.1546106488,
0.323551327,
-0.3233680129,
-0.4294158816,
-0.5763434172,
0.419608742,
-0.8178679943,
-0.1740710735,
-0.22773844,
-0.1790837497,
-0.2914030552,
-0.1464205831,
0.3955562115,
0.7755119205,
-0.464538455,
-0.0832627937,
0.2411642522,
-0.4075111747,
0.3128265738,
0.5411700606,
0.188147068,
-0.5438644886,
0.6408916712,
0.4956400096,
0.1149817184,
0.1760282516,
-0.1080026254,
-0.5686430335,
-0.5296328068,
-0.8808924556,
0.1275975555,
-0.8356733322,
-0.3191331923,
-1.1354045868,
-0.3919236958,
-0.413579464,
-0.376919955,
-0.1113861948,
-0.5517187119,
-0.1932501942,
0.022794405,
0.5440055728,
0.4229296148,
-0.1600105464,
0.6498456001,
-0.8502550721,
0.2400934547,
-0.0035586241,
0.1073951274,
-0.128367126,
-0.7325084805,
-0.0505758189,
0.4034398794,
-0.0932754949,
-0.5094743967,
0.5402386785,
0.5578321815,
0.1856412888,
-0.1245628595,
-0.0369553454,
1.1495659351,
-0.9322308302,
0.5948168039,
-0.0250370428,
-1.2100886106,
0.6838670373,
0.0129809342,
0.4260793924,
0.4802082181,
-0.0421255417,
-0.8428652287,
-0.5231260061,
-0.5649104118,
-1.0753356218,
0.7326956987,
0.3980056345,
0.0723933727,
-0.051542595,
0.2172876596,
-0.0823372602,
0.0359790325,
-0.1388215423,
-0.2180796266,
-0.3628289402,
-0.4194355011,
-0.3101639748,
-0.2375981957,
0.1818381399,
-0.0382588319,
0.7763863802,
-0.0555750243,
0.1545198858,
0.3485097885,
-0.5374703407,
-0.2277643085,
0.4157918096,
0.4580715895,
0.4131110609,
-0.0526119582,
0.1359918714,
0.3161032498,
-0.8274985552,
0.2484971434,
0.4910633862,
-0.2522566319,
0.1152123734,
0.0905447677,
0.6770311594,
0.4327380657,
-0.7592008114,
0.4713378847,
-0.2274572551,
0.1897572726,
-0.579888463,
0.0891487077,
-0.0983768255,
-0.0804023072,
0.1655447781,
0.5325859189,
0.5142742991,
-0.1799262017,
0.3915193677,
0.2467980087,
-0.4123538435,
-0.3215681016,
0.648165822,
0.268309474,
-0.347294867,
0.8560466766,
-0.0061732135,
-0.6863602996,
0.5687849522,
0.5230949521,
0.6104066372,
-0.467241466,
-0.0333878882,
0.6629137397,
0.3341788948,
0.1369077712,
0.2941249907,
-0.0663264245,
-0.9844973683,
-0.3698814511,
-0.9489352107,
-0.4362849593,
-0.4470110536,
-0.5138875246,
0.5988206863,
-0.1984263361,
-0.1807395369,
0.3852739632,
-0.2091271877,
-0.3163615465,
0.2953772247,
0.1352589577,
0.7787599564,
-0.5823014975,
0.7262867689,
0.6499462128,
-0.0421148203,
-1.0638518333,
-0.0213175546,
-0.1034575328,
-0.9559839964,
0.4651236534,
0.4461631477,
-0.5282335877,
0.1834769249,
-0.2410959899,
-0.7043282986,
0.7962911129,
0.2830071449,
-0.4427840412,
0.1144946441,
0.0478945337,
0.6709722281,
-0.1255886108,
0.0125500439,
0.3761048317,
0.338839978,
0.5331653357,
-1.2239952087,
-0.0794588998,
-0.412840724,
-0.0332335941,
0.5807678103,
-0.2788400054,
0.42613253,
-0.5134164095,
-0.5956118703,
0.1566461921,
0.6049866676,
-0.0298344921,
0.11902605,
0.5835751295,
0.5790019631,
0.9040060639,
-0.1270252615,
0.974434495,
-0.0793408528,
-0.1290497333,
0.9325396419,
-0.3681148887,
0.8827146888,
0.2740771174,
-0.2140128762,
0.355994612,
0.4324922562,
0.2767151892,
0.2873180807,
0.4340515733,
-0.6011263728,
-0.0050015543,
-0.2471480221,
-0.0949160233,
0.7183747888,
0.5982624292,
-0.1620496511,
-0.2336756587,
0.0747433975,
0.0239133704,
0.2175011784,
-0.3210671246,
0.7491099238,
-0.005858364,
-0.2680161297,
0.6473861337,
0.2135427743,
0.6298012137,
-0.6793836355,
-0.0188331027,
0.174029246,
0.344891578,
-0.3426338136,
-0.6028423905,
0.7800894976,
0.3299553096,
-0.1139483303,
0.1212651581,
0.8144812584,
-0.6318484545,
-0.3592223823,
0.2962522805,
0.2383490354,
0.3285854459,
-0.0362733826,
-0.2750889957,
0.1155823842,
-0.0534480587,
0.5091235638,
-0.090932183,
0.3533881307,
-0.1033031344,
0.5753766894,
0.5294690728,
0.2157672793,
0.3517941535,
0.2722073793,
0.7845444083,
-0.63150388,
-0.5675221086,
-0.8154095411,
0.3915369809,
0.0242679063,
-0.1413855851,
0.8114063144,
0.5176780224,
0.9361405373,
-0.0112103093,
0.6463114023,
-0.317242384,
0.6961736083,
-0.6524222493,
0.6278455257,
-0.1912920475,
0.235159725,
-0.2009186894,
-0.5476417542,
-0.5232951045,
0.8496428132,
-0.124134481,
-0.11491023,
0.4103019238,
1.0648574829,
0.0734600797,
0.3670855463,
0.3178522587,
0.3917472959,
0.1915154457,
0.2333106399,
0.9442040324,
-0.7307350636,
0.45924142,
-0.040391922,
-0.1119762585,
0.0066354042,
-0.4640692472,
-0.3274214268,
-0.4242874384,
-0.3122728169,
-0.5622161627,
0.2511329651,
0.971111536,
0.1854750961,
-1.1431484222,
-0.2645874918,
0.0116920453,
-0.117369093,
0.0485013351,
-0.1143908352,
0.2464684248,
-0.3523432612,
-0.46065256,
0.2026226968,
0.2119568288,
0.3309413493,
0.3505079746,
-0.1436963379,
0.0864651799,
-0.253683567,
0.4912936091,
0.2200981826,
-0.7522107959,
-0.5380201936,
0.1154521629,
0.0032397446,
0.1772716045,
0.7954065204,
-0.6523198485,
0.6104861498,
0.1457482427,
0.5687958002,
0.3191083074,
0.1540912241,
0.6537861228,
-0.8042097092,
-0.0634453744,
0.3797622025,
0.4727793932,
0.7649152875,
-0.2161234468,
0.5430648923,
0.1163152307,
-0.588046968,
-0.5562264919,
-0.0272298157,
-0.9185992479,
0.2543618679,
0.9662089944,
-0.1619771123,
-0.3459222615,
-0.4776275754,
-0.3931582272,
0.5353764892,
-0.5394868255,
0.6355618834,
0.8029334545,
-0.0912572816,
0.3509738743,
-0.4393421412,
0.4075463414,
0.0188695733,
-0.5526207685,
0.356022507,
0.7511556745,
0.1701244712,
0.2861757874,
0.6873447299,
-0.2949973643,
0.2483864725,
0.0653265268,
0.1406918764,
0.3128754497,
-0.2399109155,
-0.5649561882,
-0.2496251166,
0.1337798238,
-0.1637488455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13350v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13350v1
|
Swa Bhasha: Message-Based Singlish to Sinhala Transliteration
| 2024-04-20T11:10:37 | 2024-04-20T11:10:37 |
Maneesha U. Athukorala, Deshan K. Sumanathilaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine Transliteration provides the ability to transliterate a basic
language into different languages in a computational way. Transliteration is an
important technical process that has caught the attention most recently. The
Sinhala transliteration has many constraints because of the insufficiency of
resources in the Sinhala language. Due to these limitations, Sinhala
Transliteration is highly complex and time-consuming. Therefore, the majority
of the Sri Lankans uses non-formal texting language named 'Singlish' to make
that process simple. This study has focused on the transliteration of the
Singlish language at the word level by reducing the complication in the
transliteration. A new approach of coding system has invented with the
rule-based approach that can map the matching Sinhala words even without the
vowels. Various typing patterns were collected by different communities for
this. The collected data have analyzed with every Sinhala character and unique
Singlish patterns related to them were generated. The system has introduced a
newly initiated numeric coding system to use with the Singlish letters by
matching with the recognized typing patterns. For the mapping process, fuzzy
logic-based implementation has used. A codified dictionary has also implemented
including unique numeric values. In this system, Each Romanized English letter
was assigned with a unique numeric code that can construct a unique pattern for
each word. The system can identify the most relevant Sinhala word that matches
with the pattern of the Singlish word or it gives the most related word
suggestions. For example, the word 'kiyanna,kianna, kynna, kynn, kiynna' have
mapped with the accurate Sinhala word "kiyanna". These results revealed that
the 'Swa Bhasha' transliteration system has the ability to enhance the Sinhala
users' experience while conducting the texting in Singlish to Sinhala.
|
[
0.3498322666,
-0.4627122283,
0.0691005513,
0.6828821898,
-0.3521746099,
0.3139387667,
-0.4004162848,
-0.5424684286,
0.5490987301,
0.6122514606,
-0.3640423119,
-0.1709005535,
-0.4138555825,
0.3369576037,
-0.3156920373,
0.4203594625,
-0.0275872499,
0.2047309577,
0.3943660259,
-0.0982773975,
-1.0147584677,
-0.5707730055,
-0.408741504,
-0.078536801,
0.3747843504,
0.5250660181,
0.475694567,
0.1175855994,
0.7501633167,
0.3402047753,
-0.3999315798,
0.2778477669,
-0.6867524385,
0.5861642957,
-0.1762966812,
-0.7995889187,
-0.02312156,
-0.42630288,
0.4583638906,
0.3161121607,
-0.3355721533,
0.3646471798,
-0.3253899813,
0.9264370799,
-0.468773365,
0.1113728806,
-0.849386096,
0.0526172407,
-0.3683378696,
-0.7016927004,
-0.6819280982,
-0.6825666428,
-0.3219606578,
-0.512832284,
-0.0422851294,
0.509759903,
0.7596102953,
0.1736654192,
-0.2663167715,
-0.8207185864,
-0.7876514792,
0.7534179091,
-0.8517421484,
0.3294874132,
0.1797262877,
0.704495132,
-0.1568765938,
-0.1875165999,
-0.5339564085,
-0.0299351066,
-0.0948408246,
-0.1000925973,
0.1791840941,
0.1021084934,
0.1692604572,
0.3924133778,
-0.6738714576,
-0.1980481148,
-0.7058683038,
-0.0897340178,
0.7743724585,
-0.0244616847,
0.8994960189,
-0.6340289116,
-0.592848897,
0.0710965395,
-0.835421443,
-0.2447672486,
0.1484267563,
0.8668476343,
-0.1195229739,
0.7367524505,
-0.2591025829,
0.5784207582,
0.2000735551,
-0.517645061,
0.4262519479,
-0.2886099517,
-0.4909060895,
0.5411241055,
0.3441344202,
0.2267021835,
0.495465368,
-0.0861499831,
-0.1357908845,
-0.0181596167,
0.3024128079,
-0.6777665615,
0.3845149279,
0.0813807249,
-0.8880354166,
-0.5572411418,
-0.2147038728,
-0.7056473494,
-0.49690485,
-0.3486907482,
0.7040675282,
-0.4757834673,
-0.5316462517,
-0.1684281826,
-0.223952502,
0.3574834168,
0.453699857,
-0.7688131332,
0.0922726691,
0.5028030872,
0.756757021,
-0.0818258375,
-0.2551826239,
-0.0181526002,
0.1509316415,
-0.5455673337,
0.5497438312,
-0.3481456935,
-0.1888929754,
0.1295658648,
-0.1722776443,
-0.4369312525,
-0.7649410367,
0.2189988047,
-0.8497132659,
0.1013205275,
-0.2516589761,
-0.6114829779,
-0.6677344441,
-0.0298933703,
-0.5364829898,
0.7682785392,
0.2987025678,
-0.7064787745,
0.3510497808,
-0.519454658,
-0.8125804067,
0.6939287186,
-0.011508639,
0.0180607233,
0.3538080454,
-0.1941430718,
0.178992644,
-0.2869586647,
0.3262161314,
0.1787755042,
-0.8557344079,
0.2171822339,
-0.1547371447,
1.062437892,
0.4886541963,
-0.6768916249,
0.1041582897,
-0.5752775073,
0.3671855032,
-0.0765490085,
-0.2675883472,
-0.1692551225,
-0.1464303285,
0.4289940596,
0.3217128515,
0.3254971802,
-0.5153681636,
0.011463562,
-0.5953297615,
0.0054648579,
0.6453198791,
0.2338535339,
0.3037652075,
-0.3150164187,
0.6817100048,
-0.0312907286,
0.0687172785,
0.0207615141,
-0.4240247309,
-0.5491156578,
-0.1926218867,
0.4291219115,
0.8377887011,
-0.5762323141,
0.0395848602,
-0.1528709829,
-0.5120826364,
-0.8602847457,
0.2143923342,
0.2459501028,
0.1671792567,
0.4458969235,
-0.2029608786,
-0.9865281582,
-0.5900921822,
-0.1346918046,
-0.3760380745,
0.449655503,
0.1791593283,
0.046313718,
-0.0888827965,
0.328437686,
-0.4708837271,
-0.463647455,
-0.6208732724,
-0.1553135216,
0.4134486914,
0.0982164443,
0.3151427805,
-0.9453767538,
-0.7525647879,
0.18948856,
-0.7104451656,
-0.2383092642,
-0.2431111038,
-0.090726845,
0.5544037223,
0.4819068313,
-0.3827212751,
0.6898831725,
0.4625408053,
-0.3512143195,
0.6773656607,
-0.1450219303,
0.6093494296,
-1.0773912668,
0.3880598843,
-0.7857397795,
-0.0955399275,
-0.7592930198,
0.5083746314,
-0.0870767087,
-0.2147747576,
-0.2332636565,
0.4391559958,
-0.5142664313,
0.0563744679,
-0.3886740208,
-0.1226353645,
-0.5208550096,
0.4695923626,
0.022133192,
0.6461343765,
0.3413039744,
-0.3742299974,
0.2178501636,
0.293438077,
-0.0576703772,
0.6936776638,
-0.3541909456,
-0.1875753403,
-0.136291638,
0.0425213613,
-0.9055017233,
0.0302062742,
0.1333059818,
-0.5549467802,
0.3014054894,
-0.1016712561,
-0.4827901125,
-0.0476066731,
-0.0607813597,
0.4172992706,
0.7778712511,
-0.3879301846,
0.3033328354,
0.2007190287,
-0.3004166186,
-0.4422359467,
-0.6492063403,
0.3171759546,
-0.2250154912,
-0.3668976724,
0.0393294133,
-0.1388020068,
-0.0919435769,
-0.3009976447,
0.0192261562,
-0.193630293,
-0.1657154858,
0.5511068106,
0.1982922256,
-0.3120510578,
-0.1227709055,
0.0508188903,
0.0876900628,
-0.2977385223,
0.0237335954,
0.746933341,
0.3068616092,
-0.2034182549,
-0.5261633992,
0.8037070036,
0.7036006451,
-0.1033028811,
0.6944060922,
0.4764810801,
-0.4534147978,
-0.5712207556,
-0.5274147987,
0.2349322736,
-0.4653374851,
-0.0541035756,
-0.2256895751,
-0.6225950122,
0.2239985168,
-0.1438319087,
-0.3642426729,
0.3499962986,
0.8009466529,
-0.2510500252,
0.4672002792,
0.6765384078,
-0.0765933469,
0.2908393443,
0.1671982408,
0.6278449893,
-0.5656208992,
-0.3266245127,
-0.512889266,
-0.3871411383,
-0.6565438509,
-0.5904412866,
0.0752636939,
0.0298673455,
0.0774729922,
0.5031175017,
-0.6483604908,
0.0430023223,
0.3251313269,
-0.1587420106,
0.2262676358,
0.1446115971,
-0.3030828536,
-0.1563676447,
-0.4830894172,
-0.1036965623,
0.8836811781,
0.0724167302,
0.8449602723,
0.121966511,
1.1080226898,
0.5479401946,
0.2196539938,
-0.6112877131,
0.7185283899,
-0.1836745292,
-0.6351876855,
-0.1073346138,
-0.5009933114,
-0.7785980105,
0.0451228879,
0.0190416053,
-0.4698719084,
0.0181347169,
-0.0671556368,
0.1577728838,
0.2536096871,
-0.7629410028,
0.2344421148,
-0.1777945608,
0.2728175521,
-0.3956720829,
-0.7619842291,
0.2801738083,
-0.0316635892,
0.3410530686,
0.0937679857,
0.4068042934,
0.604634285,
-0.6245176196,
0.810533464,
-0.4117302299,
-0.2011567354,
0.3156278431,
0.2688678801,
0.0063899672,
-0.4366900027,
-0.2443746775,
-0.0636597201,
0.2819952369,
-0.3497113883,
-0.5171696544,
0.4868022799,
-0.3680109978,
-0.0045481138,
-0.5010778308,
-0.4119704366,
-0.0001747259,
0.552154839,
0.1063671932,
0.4496352077,
-0.0118069928,
-0.2695663273,
0.3901048303,
-0.2184592634,
0.3645297885,
0.4910618067,
-0.4686579406,
-0.5541172028,
1.210986495,
0.2268052995,
0.0486922562,
0.8789994717,
0.0615527034,
-0.3267132342,
-0.4556206465,
-0.5861176252,
0.4298109412,
-0.6213898659,
-0.6010815501,
-0.0431682132,
-0.5386187434,
-0.3803977668,
-0.3964696527,
0.1270259321,
-0.501432538,
0.0687690675,
0.2075785995,
0.2394955456,
1.1935616732,
0.1611890495,
0.1598274857,
-0.4308474362,
0.4482474327,
-0.0139272492,
0.3303317726,
0.2699553668,
-0.3885388076,
-0.1132078618,
-0.0426742099,
0.1448995769,
-1.4603937864,
0.3773375452,
0.0584350862,
0.3265678287,
0.0073134573,
-0.210624516,
0.8923659921,
-0.4619414508,
0.646317184,
0.015482367,
-0.9417272806,
0.6014618278,
-0.0439931639,
0.1265083402,
0.8072125912,
-0.0049437424,
-1.0761419535,
-0.3581362665,
-0.6323022246,
-0.7422383428,
0.3644919991,
0.1670252085,
-0.0614906922,
0.1381996721,
0.27097857,
0.134370625,
0.5850313902,
-0.245542407,
-0.1918617338,
0.0206858385,
-0.5941137671,
0.0764491558,
-0.2276326716,
0.4482839108,
-0.0504099578,
0.6401903629,
0.1534460336,
0.3701266944,
0.1490234137,
-0.674875617,
-0.2960005105,
0.3316019773,
0.8862991333,
0.3132839203,
-0.039434094,
0.0858649686,
0.1640600413,
-0.7364143133,
0.277562499,
-0.3503079116,
-0.6711288691,
0.280272752,
0.5254704356,
0.5678185821,
0.4187639058,
-0.7197821736,
0.4437471628,
0.1903983057,
-0.1133013889,
-0.0318663269,
-0.1623284072,
0.0971678868,
-0.0781306028,
0.5121256113,
0.2326763272,
0.1460747868,
-0.4373821318,
0.2107678503,
0.262287885,
-0.2991511524,
-0.1877168715,
0.2862140238,
0.1998897791,
-0.707116127,
0.3824730515,
-0.3493722975,
-0.9182053804,
0.4148276448,
1.0325770378,
0.6295704842,
-0.6898719668,
0.5248061419,
0.5614328384,
0.5865004659,
0.0206326898,
0.9628227353,
-0.1667261422,
-0.1526150703,
-0.2702102065,
-0.9235343933,
-0.339040339,
-0.3176620007,
-0.4214023948,
0.2520775795,
-0.4843115211,
0.3944726586,
-0.4634598792,
0.3773228526,
-0.3967812359,
0.5932433009,
0.1988197118,
1.0565131903,
-0.8981591463,
0.32645154,
0.5187954307,
-0.1933924407,
-1.3892831802,
-0.0567561053,
-0.0573305748,
-1.0033382177,
0.6558095813,
0.247249499,
-0.1239999831,
-0.2745537758,
-0.2599650919,
-1.015640378,
0.9798321128,
-0.0385884717,
-0.3446761966,
-0.1140567735,
0.1326399595,
0.8793833852,
-0.2038873285,
0.2589073777,
0.0850509033,
0.5775822997,
0.2774812281,
-0.9534679651,
0.5395900607,
-0.4749106765,
0.1455382705,
0.2715390623,
-0.5730414391,
0.3007996082,
-0.1684675664,
-0.384056747,
0.0977861881,
0.6666043401,
0.1282652467,
0.109869726,
0.3684284389,
0.3098687828,
0.8262758851,
0.3566078246,
0.5088151097,
-0.1602192968,
0.2244759649,
0.7266915441,
-0.3981648088,
1.1906423569,
0.6148732901,
-0.2417773902,
0.7071051598,
0.1581518203,
0.0202062782,
0.3151417971,
0.5842018723,
0.0365219153,
0.3143850267,
-0.0782440156,
-0.2571712732,
0.5278150439,
0.2211241275,
-0.2391408384,
-0.3245199025,
-0.1011657044,
0.04015214,
0.0992663577,
-0.1659208983,
0.7419587374,
-0.0611025169,
-0.7803233266,
0.8672135472,
0.0603085682,
1.0595467091,
-0.7039653659,
-0.1891295165,
-0.2036706358,
-0.1625627875,
-0.4859527349,
-0.3257380128,
0.398337245,
-0.1458528936,
0.0343248844,
-0.3913199604,
1.1239299774,
-0.8543925285,
-0.5690817833,
0.2237896919,
0.2679720819,
0.2537626326,
0.2507415116,
-0.4779037833,
0.3183039725,
0.1460318118,
0.267988652,
0.0564576462,
0.0205670465,
-0.0656179339,
0.4852528274,
0.4579662085,
0.7122460604,
0.3527032733,
0.2506799698,
0.2899900675,
-0.7914297581,
-0.6658827066,
-0.3256104589,
0.0581809245,
0.0049360218,
-0.2749971747,
0.7239838243,
0.4851436615,
0.097982198,
-0.2168650925,
0.7132310867,
-0.3261366487,
0.7396285534,
-0.3269219995,
1.0091515779,
-0.5912510753,
-0.1106413603,
-0.4654963017,
-0.674654901,
-0.2261165679,
0.4219113886,
0.1780611575,
-0.044255197,
0.8298168182,
0.7903645635,
0.0440897122,
0.1896791011,
0.2744525671,
0.0935987458,
-0.0284567121,
0.4824312925,
0.5189100504,
-0.5101631284,
0.3588039577,
-0.0817148238,
-0.2659058273,
-0.6729016304,
-0.4179627001,
-0.599660933,
-0.8841711283,
-0.0622560941,
-0.2548291683,
-0.0059681931,
0.701979816,
0.6073593497,
-0.7276758552,
-0.5407093167,
0.2434220314,
0.4985226095,
-0.6123843193,
-0.2985319197,
0.3433924317,
-0.4730675817,
-0.2281258851,
0.4497745633,
0.5428906679,
-0.1679427475,
-0.2087172121,
0.1839949489,
-0.4393789172,
0.4023761451,
0.5504612327,
0.258548677,
-0.3731285036,
-0.0703979656,
0.1446803361,
-0.4206304848,
0.0888175294,
0.9345651865,
-0.3664261997,
0.2175930738,
0.8038132191,
0.4145688713,
0.2387618423,
0.033859089,
0.4387091696,
-0.5928364992,
-0.0052306522,
0.1965545416,
-0.2147704512,
0.5993453264,
-0.7802679539,
0.3073093295,
0.1766802967,
-0.3944427669,
-0.9929537177,
0.2196009457,
-1.1725231409,
-0.1178196594,
1.2327650785,
0.1754223704,
-0.5420723557,
-0.0642751753,
-0.7121473551,
0.1377097815,
-0.0319859609,
0.5567557812,
0.4946163297,
0.1304564476,
0.1250232458,
-0.1939668953,
0.6492143273,
0.7941842079,
-0.7668328285,
-0.014605606,
-0.0038901491,
0.6353307962,
0.3273219764,
1.019446373,
-0.2435797006,
0.4140084386,
0.0499475673,
-0.034631405,
0.3237552643,
-0.3368907869,
-0.3907376826,
0.4737795591,
0.1326155066,
-0.1481902748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13343v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13343v1
|
UnibucLLM: Harnessing LLMs for Automated Prediction of Item Difficulty and Response Time for Multiple-Choice Questions
| 2024-04-20T10:41:02 | 2024-04-20T10:41:02 |
Ana-Cristina Rogoz, Radu Tudor Ionescu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This work explores a novel data augmentation method based on Large Language
Models (LLMs) for predicting item difficulty and response time of retired USMLE
Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs) in the BEA 2024 Shared Task. Our approach is
based on augmenting the dataset with answers from zero-shot LLMs (Falcon,
Meditron, Mistral) and employing transformer-based models based on six
alternative feature combinations. The results suggest that predicting the
difficulty of questions is more challenging. Notably, our top performing
methods consistently include the question text, and benefit from the
variability of LLM answers, highlighting the potential of LLMs for improving
automated assessment in medical licensing exams. We make our code available
https://github.com/ana-rogoz/BEA-2024.
|
[
-0.4402399659,
-0.7310701609,
0.6693851948,
0.0597609878,
-0.2275436223,
0.4361391366,
-0.1080943942,
-0.5448749065,
-0.0126246791,
0.7289810777,
-0.8489615917,
-0.2870551348,
-0.3587603271,
0.5058478117,
0.0758851618,
0.8142889142,
-0.1971753687,
0.3752591908,
-0.4418779314,
-0.0747632012,
-0.6213332415,
-0.4342414737,
-0.2589737475,
-0.4925694466,
0.4666978121,
0.3815289438,
0.4377948344,
0.2260790169,
0.9328337908,
0.2663102746,
-0.0856042355,
0.2622708082,
-0.1841756254,
0.0298236329,
-0.1883002967,
-0.2969725728,
-0.6950807571,
0.0578942187,
0.2033037394,
0.9927862287,
-0.1708893925,
0.1881871819,
-0.0270335209,
0.4089310169,
-0.365437746,
-0.0659105033,
-0.7574527264,
0.0127511248,
-0.0788331255,
-0.4164494872,
-0.4007181525,
-0.1746336967,
0.0770028904,
-0.2832665443,
0.1439875662,
0.0891446993,
0.4312635064,
0.5770644546,
-0.731731534,
-0.3599719703,
-0.5134111643,
0.9127438664,
-0.6332098246,
0.3043628931,
0.0939317867,
0.2944638133,
-0.3808405697,
-0.8267723322,
-0.3329927921,
-0.3471272588,
0.0167439431,
0.2082256228,
0.088504985,
0.1305985004,
0.1058963612,
0.407662034,
-0.5986744165,
0.1371442527,
-0.6599991918,
-0.1213868037,
0.8450120687,
0.5590690374,
0.1154295951,
-0.1215054095,
-0.4521239698,
0.2774187028,
-0.6102384329,
0.0919729471,
-0.0115839513,
0.0391858518,
0.3139592707,
0.8934582472,
-0.2723858356,
0.8616625071,
0.0319515169,
0.0014753293,
0.5405274034,
-0.4449334741,
-0.2422496378,
-0.1414239556,
0.7369279861,
0.2721280456,
-0.1026956216,
-0.0742053986,
-0.0304757338,
-0.1736496985,
0.1741461605,
-0.6525313258,
-0.1320929527,
0.5237035751,
-0.2687033117,
-0.2165373564,
-0.0204532817,
-0.7844447494,
-0.3929463029,
-0.3084654808,
0.4259671569,
-0.1953663379,
0.334559083,
0.2593319416,
0.319018364,
-0.014417951,
0.3750194013,
-0.3402406275,
0.2372104973,
0.343926549,
0.5504823327,
-0.5773816705,
-0.146028921,
-0.6532533765,
0.0613482334,
-0.1278290451,
0.932209909,
-0.6360587478,
-0.5515392423,
-0.5679080486,
0.2897442579,
-0.0192132518,
-0.4712896943,
0.5579651594,
-0.5714114308,
0.2955674529,
-0.0943229347,
-0.5607472658,
-0.2267881781,
0.2495732307,
-0.7216049433,
0.8797585964,
0.2797033787,
-0.57241714,
0.1321068406,
-0.9507827163,
-0.2925204337,
0.2049871683,
-0.0622045882,
-0.4330334961,
0.010370886,
0.3789845407,
0.6271240115,
-0.3618506193,
0.2218803316,
-0.3774673939,
-0.5277315378,
0.5111039877,
-0.6460338831,
0.9129869938,
0.1486689597,
-0.0710227489,
0.0247851573,
-0.8255911469,
0.1745907366,
-0.0646543577,
-0.7276000977,
0.233409375,
-0.2924182415,
-0.1530755758,
0.1908963621,
0.401447773,
-0.6787894368,
0.411608994,
-0.2738730311,
-0.0056989756,
0.7416399121,
0.1341652572,
0.4160625041,
-0.4082549214,
0.788657248,
-0.0789681002,
0.317566067,
-0.0042775292,
-0.7312273383,
-0.3226558268,
-0.1443305612,
0.5292150974,
0.8591454625,
-0.5781490803,
0.2229751945,
-0.004199299,
-0.5186991096,
-0.8033093214,
0.4783646166,
0.1574190706,
0.4547980428,
0.5798417926,
-0.3712070882,
-0.6658650637,
-0.3927277625,
0.2865792215,
-0.1648778617,
-0.2359540612,
0.5471140742,
0.371327877,
-0.6097983122,
0.484493494,
-0.6181337237,
-0.329264015,
-0.202373147,
0.3140825927,
0.3951507211,
0.2206137031,
0.0088428026,
-0.6473879814,
-0.4084563553,
-0.063812986,
-0.5641650558,
-0.3621698618,
-0.1117263064,
0.2287352085,
0.4012886584,
0.4067393839,
-0.2544265389,
0.38654688,
0.5349076986,
-0.1866263747,
0.6009296179,
-0.3720736206,
0.4526515007,
-1.0566002131,
-0.2303171456,
-0.3080670536,
0.0591296218,
-0.3809259236,
-0.0779978931,
0.2265770733,
0.1951561421,
-0.6569386721,
0.5589398146,
-0.5832059979,
-0.0994980782,
-0.2480064034,
0.0299706664,
0.0634342954,
0.2974383831,
-0.0723654479,
0.9086065888,
0.431255132,
-0.5279707313,
0.7846004963,
0.1598862559,
-0.14656955,
0.5450912118,
-0.6903400421,
0.1368261278,
-0.1035959497,
0.1991972178,
-1.0207077265,
-0.2921785712,
-0.2198108584,
-0.4505046606,
0.2408657223,
0.1739147156,
-0.1900591552,
-0.832680285,
-0.3763266802,
0.4745364487,
0.3138827384,
-0.408447504,
0.7910075188,
0.1117907092,
-0.3208123744,
-0.7721838355,
-0.774930656,
0.0703312308,
-0.1271758229,
-0.5906328559,
0.4082927406,
-0.7904626727,
-0.1774853319,
-0.1279475987,
0.1847487986,
-0.1592853814,
0.2821829319,
0.4026313424,
0.7406984568,
0.0709841996,
0.103260532,
0.0549037084,
0.0012341001,
-0.0301087536,
0.2814056575,
0.4819204509,
-0.0400699638,
-0.629927516,
-0.2510264814,
0.3235608041,
0.4419655502,
-0.1139864475,
0.2018250525,
0.54996562,
-0.1178414226,
0.146073252,
-0.6740202904,
-0.2117519528,
-0.47281757,
0.3647437692,
-0.2826013267,
-0.8194988966,
0.6041975021,
-0.0111276535,
0.0718571991,
0.2247529328,
0.7930861115,
-0.301287353,
1.1348251104,
0.3122733235,
0.1084939167,
-0.0280096401,
-0.1855829209,
-0.1255279183,
-1.1441448927,
-0.6674433947,
-0.2053675652,
-0.3303034008,
-0.4252371192,
-0.7804820538,
0.4192792475,
-0.1770467311,
-0.0544633977,
0.0967334062,
-0.4801287353,
0.4141101241,
0.4513958097,
0.1682237089,
0.5685714483,
-0.2886690497,
-0.3421993554,
0.0577783734,
-0.4314051867,
-0.3157619536,
1.7776312828,
0.1893928796,
1.0794248581,
0.0451059937,
0.604375124,
0.0796425045,
0.3491143584,
-0.8000339866,
0.535533607,
-0.0482160151,
-0.7046824694,
-0.267603606,
-0.4320905507,
-1.0106608868,
-0.0747635365,
-0.1701329201,
-0.5614138842,
-0.0054543638,
-0.2164706588,
-0.6271015406,
0.1612263769,
-0.3624499142,
0.2081891149,
-0.5009529591,
-0.2068697214,
0.2616238892,
-0.7393764853,
0.3652087748,
-0.5074366927,
0.2499515861,
-0.1513814181,
-0.3296734393,
0.7458175421,
-0.1893509924,
0.4787842333,
0.2668300867,
0.0153100519,
0.2115718275,
-0.0655665025,
0.2464892268,
0.3152111769,
-0.3531593978,
-0.0192740951,
0.0309843086,
-0.384495616,
-0.5245208144,
0.679915309,
-0.4205835164,
-0.5521842837,
-0.5466247797,
-1.1456137896,
-0.4886540174,
-0.0256426055,
0.1786209941,
0.510837853,
0.0032818734,
0.2261155099,
0.5919024944,
-0.066631645,
0.6382184625,
0.7433899641,
-0.0868229195,
-0.5636040568,
0.432025075,
0.2965603769,
0.128577441,
0.1256581545,
-0.0288138948,
-0.6417203546,
-0.8497336507,
-0.4710830152,
0.2578561604,
-0.5738684535,
-0.472577244,
-0.6419460773,
-0.287425667,
-0.3453023434,
-0.1996693611,
-0.0848933905,
-0.4289644361,
-0.7320586443,
-0.2872163355,
0.4913416505,
0.9302065969,
-0.1188674048,
0.3348410726,
-0.8711165786,
0.2160697281,
0.5177907348,
0.4115363061,
-0.4252311587,
-0.8512518406,
0.1278555691,
0.0501071736,
-0.6244598031,
-0.7605106235,
0.3880643547,
-0.0062855692,
0.6905629039,
0.1999649405,
0.1158560142,
0.6960673928,
-0.5577337146,
0.9182333946,
0.2324727476,
-0.5748389363,
0.4304763973,
0.0880366713,
0.127951622,
0.6540625095,
0.369430691,
-0.0508056767,
-0.3326121867,
-0.5274100304,
-0.6990098953,
0.5361213088,
-0.0127407229,
0.1745503247,
0.0418626592,
0.3610993922,
0.1931856871,
0.0984598324,
-0.6581594944,
-0.3723934293,
0.1864762902,
-0.4114297628,
-0.1535402983,
-0.3173514605,
0.0790479183,
-0.5358384252,
0.6032370925,
-0.2036928385,
0.2407738268,
0.1077784672,
-0.0621374398,
-0.3145188689,
0.5505998135,
0.4568319023,
0.8633100986,
-0.7482987046,
-0.053503003,
0.6421833634,
-0.4264235795,
0.3302323222,
0.3835300505,
0.1478658319,
-0.0159497466,
0.1571220607,
0.6061499119,
0.0403358079,
-0.813647449,
0.3414224088,
-0.205497697,
-0.4424891472,
-0.2819606662,
-0.0724541247,
0.0146490298,
0.3487180769,
0.5917822719,
-0.1815969795,
0.3914324641,
-0.583558023,
0.5599333644,
0.5285827518,
-0.6076672077,
-0.0708103105,
0.6523447037,
0.0427636318,
-0.2076820433,
0.1628239304,
-0.2558091283,
-0.4038042724,
0.5424463153,
0.697391808,
0.2520445883,
-0.6512954831,
0.277775526,
0.1248029172,
0.0968845934,
-0.0289619714,
0.7064039707,
0.4561110735,
-0.2858189344,
-0.6364876628,
-0.5524335504,
-0.6413491368,
0.1943886578,
-0.552916944,
0.3563593328,
-0.2909940183,
-0.1640310138,
-0.3277463615,
0.4526407421,
-0.6302133203,
0.5644029975,
-0.045337256,
0.8560458422,
-0.5339565873,
0.5900415778,
0.8093153238,
-0.4006388187,
-0.8082979918,
-0.3052656054,
-0.0237533301,
-0.6819283366,
0.3449706733,
-0.0250335149,
0.205959186,
0.0276767462,
-0.1999721676,
-0.7189279795,
1.5528354645,
0.2791895568,
-0.5612000227,
-0.1488174498,
0.2799426019,
0.3486506641,
-0.4798995852,
0.7085822225,
0.7202766538,
0.2801226974,
0.4637524188,
-1.0060539246,
0.0018830054,
-0.0974930152,
-0.3133892417,
0.0934131294,
-0.1829369515,
0.9671292901,
-0.5300647616,
0.2317756414,
0.1431015879,
0.4894998372,
0.5256767273,
0.6727715135,
0.2557368577,
0.4840121567,
1.102212429,
-0.0030598615,
0.7605085969,
-0.0562472455,
0.3929074407,
1.2257459164,
-0.3900676668,
0.8484355211,
0.726113081,
-0.4889729023,
0.6860235333,
0.7933129668,
-0.073413454,
0.2619908452,
0.1728229672,
-0.3689708114,
-0.2183400244,
-0.1325912178,
-0.4146682918,
0.5236949325,
0.3486768305,
-0.243406713,
-0.1349533647,
0.280965656,
-0.3725031018,
-0.089473173,
-0.4115809798,
0.826171875,
0.0533338673,
-0.4098130167,
0.5366309285,
-0.2495123893,
0.7163953781,
-0.146183446,
0.0133055057,
-0.2802616954,
-0.0437659919,
-0.0877785459,
-1.0981534719,
0.2472618669,
-0.1342669427,
-0.1008227468,
0.2720530927,
0.5549048185,
-0.4241835177,
-0.994099021,
0.3950619996,
0.6258358359,
0.2222207636,
0.0737013444,
-0.973179996,
-0.0570677519,
0.0746009797,
-0.1955235302,
0.1618929058,
0.2467042953,
0.0528836735,
0.9995598793,
0.487220794,
0.2647135556,
0.258526504,
-0.0470913723,
0.7868996859,
-0.455535233,
0.0097219497,
-0.7490143776,
0.7119959593,
-0.0234794673,
0.1515848935,
0.380097419,
0.4278353751,
0.594379425,
-0.0145794377,
0.7553147078,
0.2345032245,
0.8341128826,
-0.4892009497,
0.4370978177,
-0.7180672288,
0.7183943391,
-0.2255336791,
-0.823957324,
-0.4493580461,
0.1371105164,
-0.1933447719,
0.0519862324,
0.8236902952,
1.0189566612,
-0.0704130679,
-0.2505155206,
0.4289993644,
-0.1642444432,
0.085589163,
0.9697543383,
0.6058131456,
-0.5323123336,
0.9687969685,
-0.625872612,
-0.1806666851,
-0.3749673963,
-0.805426538,
-0.9384192824,
-0.5482000113,
-0.3614104092,
-0.2954966128,
-0.2981313765,
1.1314953566,
0.4185078442,
-0.9884009361,
-0.1255557984,
0.1086537167,
0.1285776198,
0.1901158243,
-0.1624313146,
0.3485753834,
-0.2721008956,
-0.7632188797,
0.460049659,
0.1543318331,
0.3406725228,
-0.0808114782,
-0.2157470882,
-0.3156348169,
0.4756732285,
0.3413495719,
-0.1241009682,
-0.7474874854,
-0.1033952385,
0.3585580289,
-0.0123319328,
0.1486900896,
0.5120456219,
-0.8734769821,
0.5921304226,
0.3329178393,
0.6209946871,
0.1036516875,
0.3005075455,
0.4274847209,
-0.5763553381,
-0.2302050292,
0.3969491422,
0.5569301248,
0.3536732495,
-0.5451863408,
0.651350379,
0.2287341207,
-0.7571669817,
-0.9109531641,
0.039231021,
-1.1607946157,
-0.4091613293,
1.1111047268,
-0.1311223209,
-0.2065903246,
-0.5313641429,
-0.46262604,
0.2408527136,
-0.2308757007,
0.8250279427,
0.4763499498,
-0.3887688816,
-0.3413858414,
-0.553498745,
0.3134126663,
0.4704940617,
-1.0021990538,
-0.1657381803,
0.4341412187,
0.4009640813,
0.1774203926,
0.626562655,
-0.1640117168,
0.5046212077,
-0.6103465557,
-0.0380444415,
-0.3617277741,
-0.2978369594,
-0.4710919857,
0.2255138159,
0.0042591244,
-0.06637986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14445v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14445v1
|
A Multi-Faceted Evaluation Framework for Assessing Synthetic Data Generated by Large Language Models
| 2024-04-20T08:08:28 | 2024-04-20T08:08:28 |
Yefeng Yuan, Yuhong Liu, Liang Cheng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The rapid advancements in generative AI and large language models (LLMs) have
opened up new avenues for producing synthetic data, particularly in the realm
of structured tabular formats, such as product reviews. Despite the potential
benefits, concerns regarding privacy leakage have surfaced, especially when
personal information is utilized in the training datasets. In addition, there
is an absence of a comprehensive evaluation framework capable of quantitatively
measuring the quality of the generated synthetic data and their utility for
downstream tasks. In response to this gap, we introduce SynEval, an open-source
evaluation framework designed to assess the fidelity, utility, and privacy
preservation of synthetically generated tabular data via a suite of diverse
evaluation metrics. We validate the efficacy of our proposed framework -
SynEval - by applying it to synthetic product review data generated by three
state-of-the-art LLMs: ChatGPT, Claude, and Llama. Our experimental findings
illuminate the trade-offs between various evaluation metrics in the context of
synthetic data generation. Furthermore, SynEval stands as a critical instrument
for researchers and practitioners engaged with synthetic tabular data,,
empowering them to judiciously determine the suitability of the generated data
for their specific applications, with an emphasis on upholding user privacy.
|
[
-0.2320875973,
-0.8871625066,
0.3444517851,
0.4101111293,
0.1922610998,
0.3753263652,
-0.4681712389,
-0.4023010135,
0.0425308645,
0.2325610518,
-0.3056423962,
-0.9202702641,
-0.1355869621,
0.0454620458,
-0.746594727,
1.3225013018,
-0.0888519436,
0.0378157794,
-0.3869640827,
-0.0944423676,
-0.1416405141,
-0.5808145404,
-0.3271754384,
0.1096763089,
0.435080409,
0.0838670433,
0.770085156,
0.3290395439,
0.5620151162,
0.3860376775,
0.0989087746,
0.1826285869,
-0.5464931726,
0.55259341,
-0.3018397987,
-0.3184219897,
-0.6051892042,
-0.0240872931,
0.8133822083,
0.4422248304,
-0.3965915143,
0.7611979246,
0.2180679142,
0.721475184,
-0.7077630162,
0.3371600509,
-0.6971166134,
0.2480558902,
-0.3345738351,
0.1055962294,
-0.298137635,
-0.774195075,
0.0749109313,
-0.4638572931,
0.2713465393,
0.2554225624,
0.5012980103,
0.0611009821,
0.037974786,
-0.1321647465,
-0.968482852,
0.6268109679,
-0.7935006022,
0.6531879306,
0.1139642596,
0.6992678642,
-0.2680829465,
-0.9094483256,
-1.0394678116,
-0.4955587685,
-0.0158292837,
0.2000100017,
0.0046110144,
-0.0313668437,
0.0763008669,
0.7132876515,
-0.7756153345,
-0.2021291852,
-0.4090244472,
-0.3549472094,
0.8921280503,
0.2075358033,
0.4168034494,
-0.2075168639,
-0.5643222332,
-0.280685097,
-0.7774527669,
0.0347545817,
0.6179966927,
0.2577515244,
-0.1947201788,
0.7317450643,
-0.1723103672,
0.3998689055,
-0.2875454724,
-0.0243013389,
0.519973278,
-0.6801757812,
-0.3291115463,
-0.1054488048,
1.0918058157,
0.3211417198,
0.1126972437,
-0.2784757912,
-0.3209381402,
0.3450340331,
0.4276644588,
-0.7361791134,
-0.1069530845,
0.4823766947,
-0.4221795499,
-0.4489987195,
0.1756650954,
-0.9581088424,
-0.4907432795,
-0.3918915987,
0.3076117039,
0.0230788067,
-0.0581548847,
-0.0920596421,
0.0078271953,
0.0011941899,
0.0801420435,
-0.7203565836,
0.4906556606,
0.780192554,
0.6858328581,
-0.4789764881,
-0.2431301028,
-0.4368977249,
0.0129052876,
-0.3878134191,
0.7043308616,
-0.3691859543,
-0.4277909994,
0.0312757082,
0.0060424623,
0.0640333071,
-0.6797292829,
0.4626253545,
-0.4508827329,
0.1741767079,
-0.0623618551,
-0.2496840656,
0.1921298355,
0.6171811819,
-0.7483727932,
0.9199353456,
0.2519418299,
-0.5893377066,
0.5779341459,
-0.5473572016,
-0.3644148111,
0.2428574711,
-0.4413115382,
-0.6980523467,
0.0274761673,
0.0598215796,
0.0549843796,
-0.5485697389,
0.4377611279,
-0.4684813023,
0.0312569626,
0.5541689396,
-0.4033689797,
0.4352761507,
0.2014454156,
-0.3055809736,
0.4467243552,
-0.7625694275,
0.2951533794,
-0.200057745,
-0.42943874,
0.0523956083,
-0.025598947,
0.287643373,
0.0809442624,
0.2190579921,
-0.9125549793,
-0.2591413558,
-0.4936867058,
0.2937997282,
0.7581246495,
0.147558406,
0.2488251776,
-0.2735191882,
0.7935208082,
-0.1361909956,
0.378279835,
0.1041533649,
-0.2129022926,
-0.5782260895,
0.0283838008,
0.5204385519,
0.3101444542,
-0.3903979659,
0.3522179425,
-0.256013155,
-0.6507492065,
-0.5802288651,
0.2409280241,
0.480594188,
0.2842173874,
0.2137724757,
-0.3051742613,
-0.4855823517,
-1.3081026077,
-0.4663476944,
-0.3510639369,
-0.1028684676,
0.3975093067,
0.3520544171,
-0.2514983714,
0.9132381082,
-0.0227897689,
-0.3130275011,
-0.3163696527,
0.0375838093,
0.0045801438,
0.4391159415,
0.2819721997,
-0.4827952087,
-0.5262023211,
0.1431398243,
-0.7256801128,
-0.0508398339,
-0.235105738,
-0.2266156375,
0.0430803597,
-0.0039559328,
-0.6804006696,
0.3655394018,
0.7373191118,
-0.0140002081,
0.6757538319,
-0.1111106426,
0.1842886806,
-0.9623532295,
0.22701253,
-0.1461392641,
-0.1458985806,
-0.4676636457,
0.1186077595,
0.0328289978,
-0.3038472235,
-0.4452819824,
0.5677254796,
-0.3567150831,
-0.3348710239,
0.2559684217,
0.2213787138,
0.2057683617,
0.1050177217,
-0.1287256032,
0.8964298368,
0.2168504298,
-0.103958115,
0.2592721879,
0.4737373292,
-0.5753727555,
0.4990555942,
-0.8598412275,
0.1820529848,
-0.0447013974,
0.3180032372,
-0.8592650294,
-0.3271983564,
0.1131457463,
-0.4429606795,
0.231323272,
0.1483924538,
-0.6154334545,
-0.2531683445,
-0.4922477603,
0.3431152701,
0.4039877653,
-0.5129554272,
0.4556414485,
0.7133026719,
-0.3093815744,
-0.4527370632,
-0.6711161137,
0.1425779909,
-0.1730932891,
-0.8490178585,
0.4793499708,
-0.0674402937,
-0.3718655407,
-0.0563572496,
-0.2938217521,
0.2160279155,
-0.1630232781,
0.3206917048,
0.238852635,
-0.1770841181,
0.02052732,
0.1292181611,
-0.0175103378,
0.3090902269,
-0.1016450822,
0.4218341708,
-0.4211789072,
-0.2705175877,
-0.3219251931,
0.0678102225,
0.4932087958,
-0.3548814058,
0.6471396685,
0.4595465064,
-0.2744315267,
-0.890219152,
-0.4456428289,
-0.0154368822,
-0.4873702824,
0.27671808,
-0.0150544615,
-0.4142456651,
0.5541779399,
0.1518687159,
0.1236677319,
0.2789873481,
0.8689261079,
0.1015363261,
0.7599480748,
0.2757899463,
0.281364888,
0.1315864027,
-0.2841203511,
0.5355936885,
-0.7667747736,
-0.661131382,
-0.3946395814,
-0.4785208404,
-0.7211861014,
-0.250344336,
0.7600833774,
-0.1500256658,
-0.085493274,
0.2957508564,
-0.3908916116,
0.5177953243,
0.251907438,
-0.0431155562,
0.3919972181,
0.0541652739,
0.0665899813,
0.0393877737,
-0.3052373528,
-0.6937309504,
1.2489345074,
0.3846918046,
0.8190052509,
0.0137683265,
0.699888289,
0.4794542789,
0.5653399825,
-0.514537394,
0.5631014705,
-0.0921865329,
-0.6585819125,
-0.2757905722,
-0.4489162266,
-0.861800313,
0.3102734387,
-0.2650887668,
-0.7278152704,
0.1480389088,
0.237937957,
-0.4044216573,
0.0166825168,
-0.6072119474,
1.0851408243,
-0.4497586489,
-0.815885365,
-0.2120889872,
-0.5133745074,
0.5139065385,
-0.3167499304,
0.1515231282,
-0.1562385261,
0.1162858456,
0.6891854405,
-0.5651692748,
0.5358720422,
-0.2288551182,
-0.0022697453,
0.2899935246,
0.4525797963,
0.3011155725,
0.383267045,
-0.1193974614,
0.2539316118,
0.2107557505,
0.137406677,
-0.7915836573,
0.929733634,
-0.5699688792,
-0.4710604846,
-0.3178499937,
-0.6126669645,
-0.5747942328,
0.0583709963,
-0.0936961919,
0.2220991403,
-0.4469895065,
0.4293180406,
0.0232830383,
-0.6382181644,
0.0406462178,
0.3196745217,
-0.3319255412,
-0.5275509357,
0.9798938036,
0.0066209002,
0.2805895209,
0.0051231529,
0.3572705388,
-0.655954361,
-0.6051055789,
-0.6275015473,
-0.0221746583,
-0.4116300046,
-0.3295466006,
-0.4172448516,
-0.4384762347,
-0.1997940838,
0.2622949481,
-0.5189824104,
-0.5986059308,
0.2716700137,
-0.2499981523,
0.021935802,
0.7265980244,
0.11857263,
-0.0208950993,
-0.6838837266,
0.4018875659,
-0.0553540029,
0.3338572681,
-0.0252866391,
-0.0229895245,
-0.0355387703,
0.192025885,
-0.4517076015,
-0.6649628282,
0.562281251,
0.253179431,
0.6757355332,
-0.0208621453,
0.1501063406,
0.4547857046,
-0.3980517685,
0.9228793383,
-0.0233557802,
-0.8838425875,
0.3286608458,
-0.32917732,
-0.0744755268,
0.7221650481,
0.1489547491,
-0.348700732,
-0.4942978919,
-0.505723536,
-0.9269769788,
0.3551061749,
0.4159526229,
0.1299456209,
0.0795400217,
-0.1561960727,
0.3421568274,
0.6598507762,
-0.7677682638,
0.1374362707,
-0.1372067332,
-0.3339546621,
0.2891287506,
0.1205891818,
-0.1001749113,
0.0499822907,
0.4378623366,
0.120953761,
-0.0700873956,
0.0429456159,
-0.1826241314,
0.1818042994,
0.5499249101,
0.1375668794,
0.6942617297,
-0.1056534946,
0.0469637848,
-0.0428602807,
-0.4151082039,
0.0399692245,
0.0759177804,
-0.3147257864,
-0.1961644888,
0.1028272137,
0.3931434751,
-0.1624775976,
-0.7387643456,
0.6163789034,
-0.0083298208,
-0.0226136986,
-0.325230509,
-0.0607438274,
-0.1389406174,
0.116118446,
-0.1049863994,
0.0893366039,
0.4314491749,
-0.7172417641,
0.2330024689,
0.5500584841,
0.0957928374,
-0.5867086053,
0.6234792471,
0.1224321797,
-0.2858180702,
0.6107649207,
-0.046875935,
-0.2919255495,
0.3722617924,
0.5476740003,
1.0289952755,
-0.2271579504,
0.4623491764,
0.2608692944,
0.2762344182,
0.2834021449,
0.3496615589,
-0.3482551575,
-0.5458188057,
-0.0345100164,
-1.1495683193,
-0.2733846307,
0.1876332313,
-0.5765269995,
-0.0763932094,
-0.6021026969,
-0.3873002529,
0.0402090214,
-0.2223719209,
-0.7938309312,
-0.0343587995,
0.0251901504,
0.6390321851,
-0.6416346431,
0.5089108944,
0.1522478461,
-0.4488895237,
-0.5962116122,
0.000047587,
0.0642958805,
-0.683564961,
0.6491123438,
0.0998568013,
-0.1329509467,
-0.6200737357,
-0.0600514933,
-0.6415287852,
0.8798913956,
0.3740734458,
-0.8087417483,
-0.0399917588,
0.723941505,
1.0523145199,
-0.2815509737,
0.0349969268,
0.8173051476,
0.5562515259,
-0.1540970951,
-0.9093077183,
0.0680727586,
-0.5480449796,
0.1337217391,
0.084070161,
-0.4415369332,
0.6169992089,
-0.1930107027,
-0.6779404879,
0.2072745413,
0.2558045983,
0.3485142589,
0.3012174964,
0.2853843868,
0.3902558684,
0.6243491173,
-0.0372048654,
1.2448198795,
-0.5032278895,
0.1707983017,
1.2512296438,
-0.6612786651,
1.0802794695,
0.3452725708,
-0.3306130469,
0.4753519595,
0.3202295303,
-0.2234007269,
0.3610597253,
0.6459141374,
-0.1672286838,
0.1227337569,
-0.2386689633,
-0.3051402569,
0.3199451566,
0.4120304286,
-0.5178759098,
-0.2545298934,
-0.2917938828,
-0.4120986164,
0.1447932273,
0.1840281934,
0.8070321679,
0.0889858752,
-0.553515017,
0.4607946873,
-0.0563763343,
0.0226576328,
-0.4267135262,
-0.0344385207,
-0.2421717793,
0.3337697089,
-0.4773561656,
-0.8563527465,
0.4733799398,
0.1912574023,
0.1088824198,
-0.1875552386,
0.3851104677,
-0.5092715025,
-0.581825614,
0.1827778965,
0.6266050935,
0.0497732051,
0.2279214263,
-0.6127611995,
0.2825181186,
-0.3414282799,
-0.3395618796,
0.1874230206,
-0.0092250993,
-0.2373333573,
0.4383129478,
1.0155619383,
0.480871439,
0.04161245,
0.3794292808,
0.8276383281,
-0.3415437341,
-0.484983772,
-0.8083436489,
0.6486275792,
-0.1689744741,
-0.3876081705,
1.1612248421,
0.9277267456,
0.8084621429,
0.0119624622,
0.8259223104,
0.0976471305,
0.4350275695,
-0.4499742091,
1.0069227219,
-0.1468347013,
0.5411866307,
-0.2600320578,
-1.3815835714,
-0.2147217095,
0.4532569647,
-0.38616997,
0.0414193794,
0.6289852858,
1.108622551,
-0.0829712674,
0.2196831554,
0.0855541229,
0.3157491088,
0.3573392034,
0.2445100695,
1.235756278,
-0.3238382339,
0.2387106419,
-0.0798816904,
-0.0294118766,
0.4177252054,
-0.7031582594,
-0.7704461217,
-0.3990989625,
-0.1536021978,
-0.4410456419,
0.185019061,
0.7563868165,
0.7967467308,
-0.9304021001,
-0.4011741579,
-0.1761408299,
-0.26366207,
0.1807998717,
-0.2539870441,
0.4496993721,
-0.3320816755,
-0.5326040387,
0.5974105597,
0.3691504002,
-0.0815823674,
-0.769562006,
0.0460383669,
0.5787702203,
0.1117820963,
0.6524400711,
0.1035524383,
-0.7396972179,
-0.0310023911,
0.0174934175,
0.1912125796,
0.0007589046,
0.8243054152,
-0.8231061101,
0.716758132,
0.7390304804,
0.7123131752,
0.6441991329,
0.2611103952,
0.8624367714,
-0.7803090215,
-0.1894723326,
0.3334755003,
0.2472520024,
0.508064568,
-0.1748766303,
0.3328694105,
-0.3459066451,
-0.650862813,
-1.1007727385,
0.016094584,
-0.8883920908,
0.202874437,
1.0705913305,
-0.1487834752,
-0.3510994613,
0.255092293,
-0.0368301235,
-0.220054701,
-0.4459836781,
0.9821308255,
0.3191516399,
0.0060698465,
0.2896915674,
-0.547612071,
0.7394694686,
0.0612020195,
-1.3034619093,
0.3820856512,
0.6895156503,
0.2387412339,
0.1423199028,
0.1029440016,
-0.6003315449,
0.129604429,
0.0744055361,
-0.2338001132,
-0.1090587676,
-0.7042352557,
-0.178819567,
0.2724613249,
-0.0076851905,
-0.0737081766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13307v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13307v1
|
Beyond Accuracy: Investigating Error Types in GPT-4 Responses to USMLE Questions
| 2024-04-20T07:29:06 | 2024-04-20T07:29:06 |
Soumyadeep Roy, Aparup Khatua, Fatemeh Ghoochani, Uwe Hadler, Wolfgang Nejdl, Niloy Ganguly
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
GPT-4 demonstrates high accuracy in medical QA tasks, leading with an
accuracy of 86.70%, followed by Med-PaLM 2 at 86.50%. However, around 14% of
errors remain. Additionally, current works use GPT-4 to only predict the
correct option without providing any explanation and thus do not provide any
insight into the thinking process and reasoning used by GPT-4 or other LLMs.
Therefore, we introduce a new domain-specific error taxonomy derived from
collaboration with medical students. Our GPT-4 USMLE Error (G4UE) dataset
comprises 4153 GPT-4 correct responses and 919 incorrect responses to the
United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) respectively. These
responses are quite long (258 words on average), containing detailed
explanations from GPT-4 justifying the selected option. We then launch a
large-scale annotation study using the Potato annotation platform and recruit
44 medical experts through Prolific, a well-known crowdsourcing platform. We
annotated 300 out of these 919 incorrect data points at a granular level for
different classes and created a multi-label span to identify the reasons behind
the error. In our annotated dataset, a substantial portion of GPT-4's incorrect
responses is categorized as a "Reasonable response by GPT-4," by annotators.
This sheds light on the challenge of discerning explanations that may lead to
incorrect options, even among trained medical professionals. We also provide
medical concepts and medical semantic predications extracted using the SemRep
tool for every data point. We believe that it will aid in evaluating the
ability of LLMs to answer complex medical questions. We make the resources
available at https://github.com/roysoumya/usmle-gpt4-error-taxonomy .
|
[
-0.1061819792,
-0.6733729839,
0.8728392124,
0.0145948036,
-0.0130337635,
0.2774307728,
0.1663657427,
-0.5681706667,
0.0216634348,
0.1615060866,
-0.3335953057,
-0.4222201407,
-0.7791206837,
0.4207696915,
0.0483493581,
0.9310373664,
-0.3516146541,
0.2819381952,
-0.2002332956,
-0.3008697033,
-0.5517167449,
-0.7126510143,
-0.5641095042,
-0.0780225098,
0.715413034,
0.4097331464,
0.6448256969,
0.2917595804,
0.7629529238,
0.214945972,
0.3664395511,
0.1206861436,
-0.1970112324,
-0.2687115371,
-0.2025602013,
-0.4477913678,
-0.8544077873,
0.4119144082,
0.2219644785,
0.5141125321,
-0.0898593366,
0.0806031004,
-0.2559678555,
0.5502024293,
-0.3772241771,
0.1938023567,
-0.3772574663,
0.0717903376,
-0.4430945814,
-0.4085042179,
-0.2053790689,
-0.5316640735,
0.286544472,
-0.761433363,
0.4008031785,
-0.1692698896,
0.9172779322,
0.4311400652,
-0.3133503199,
-0.2995341718,
-0.420755595,
0.3053644896,
-0.8216415644,
0.1955180168,
0.4299361706,
0.3448967934,
-0.0513665192,
-0.9191282392,
-0.5565880537,
0.0484043844,
0.0424840339,
0.3616020679,
0.0152442884,
0.334395498,
0.3676235378,
0.3110692799,
-0.5606654286,
-0.0331219956,
-0.4261340797,
-0.3601175249,
0.5021213889,
0.0104631949,
0.3898830414,
0.1856117547,
-0.219159767,
0.1978849024,
-0.7061390281,
-0.0966018215,
0.0662718192,
-0.1838276088,
0.1958067268,
0.5744159818,
0.1377381682,
0.6937951446,
0.1116672456,
-0.0090767639,
0.6378849149,
-0.5415034294,
-0.2069393545,
-0.1594450027,
0.6362264752,
0.7120720744,
0.1336040497,
-0.0014741798,
-0.2172744572,
0.2182536125,
0.4718659222,
-0.5158113241,
-0.3422500789,
0.4781830609,
-0.0790162832,
-0.1155772656,
-0.1429222524,
-0.6186615825,
-0.3301500976,
-0.116180338,
0.6525634527,
-0.4168363512,
-0.0660323799,
0.2020170242,
-0.0403047726,
0.1540149003,
0.5012679696,
-0.6758534908,
0.3690771163,
0.4374025762,
0.7156024575,
-0.2596976459,
-0.3035120964,
-0.299772501,
-0.0602231808,
-0.5217235684,
0.8312642574,
-0.3123683333,
-0.4310910702,
-0.1304739863,
0.0334174633,
-0.1930019408,
-0.5682567954,
0.6952876449,
-0.4696636498,
0.2563597262,
-0.5641932487,
-0.8039213419,
-0.4065376818,
0.3648615479,
-0.5024093986,
0.7719182372,
0.3963816762,
-0.7743356824,
0.5561349988,
-0.9953442812,
0.0380847119,
0.1986030042,
-0.4436346292,
-0.4445230067,
-0.0695812926,
0.120243147,
0.4553082883,
-0.1767613143,
0.5159107447,
-0.1051479578,
-0.2879574001,
0.3527332544,
-0.2013646662,
0.6068868041,
-0.0965522751,
-0.5030099154,
0.0648609772,
-0.6044394374,
0.0343019776,
0.2069994211,
-0.1682483554,
-0.0458533354,
-0.3257115483,
-0.3114846945,
0.2564521432,
0.1892114729,
-0.6225768924,
0.2712134719,
-0.0142020751,
0.3501730859,
0.6407505274,
0.1784673482,
0.1658091992,
-0.3973605931,
0.8233588338,
-0.015689861,
0.5755763054,
0.1830578297,
-0.9920976758,
-0.1774486452,
-0.0023962874,
0.4068765938,
0.641582787,
-0.7714568973,
0.1577863842,
-0.229178682,
-0.4117469192,
-0.5483505726,
-0.1190810651,
0.3939566612,
0.982380867,
0.6202447414,
-0.390796423,
-0.5231040716,
-0.7698810101,
-0.1902540475,
-0.2423620522,
0.0724683776,
0.3324446678,
0.5416868925,
-0.6180728674,
0.7878029943,
-0.4321248233,
-0.2286522686,
0.1261066496,
0.0947872177,
0.1406048685,
0.2793276608,
0.4347623885,
-0.7760512829,
-0.2951423228,
-0.153633669,
-0.5932974815,
-0.2965810001,
-0.1267441511,
0.0102084316,
0.3779411912,
-0.0450939648,
-0.5005803704,
0.3307143748,
0.5668805242,
-0.3928149045,
0.5715432763,
-0.3513726592,
0.3754909039,
-0.7187342048,
-0.1219928116,
0.0626996234,
0.0491069257,
-0.5185756087,
-0.0783931091,
0.2308063954,
0.5307886004,
-0.1491602063,
0.3195228875,
-0.3639307618,
-0.2298248261,
0.0938369185,
0.0701269582,
0.1143025234,
0.137892127,
-0.1301983744,
0.8769466281,
0.4609938562,
-0.0866410136,
0.4328620732,
0.294472605,
0.3106779456,
0.6615696549,
-0.4031173289,
0.0818995833,
0.2056588978,
0.380118221,
-0.9937052131,
-0.6735209823,
0.4428498447,
-0.6307290792,
0.4762441814,
-0.1154139638,
-0.3104353547,
-0.684425354,
-0.4204839766,
0.4019258618,
0.3712738454,
-0.2815037072,
0.4312549829,
0.4597135484,
-0.1774353385,
-0.7268151045,
-0.5954419971,
0.1734676361,
-0.1049347743,
-0.5091304183,
0.080345273,
-0.3075216413,
-0.0923179537,
-0.1600189954,
-0.3209243715,
-0.4560699165,
-0.0346078426,
0.2065109611,
0.4986376762,
-0.2618374527,
0.223913312,
-0.240048334,
-0.0528336838,
0.3354846239,
0.0206963271,
0.154317081,
-0.2740289867,
-0.4198518097,
-0.4882212579,
0.0520770214,
0.4073975384,
0.0696702003,
0.062003646,
0.4547156096,
-0.3425870538,
0.4418073595,
-0.6764990687,
-0.2400717288,
-0.3812133372,
0.3420940638,
-0.4044083655,
-0.7848687172,
0.5465700626,
0.2921229899,
0.2144414634,
0.5980407,
0.3017710745,
-0.2117342651,
0.6843913794,
0.1265355945,
0.3945793211,
-0.2774344683,
-0.1977730691,
0.0623109825,
-0.6782056093,
-0.3306181729,
-0.2329891473,
-0.0942580402,
-0.525500536,
-0.8693560362,
0.3592633009,
-0.2658315897,
-0.3152510226,
-0.1769101769,
-0.6448600888,
0.3210993707,
0.4615574181,
0.0871788934,
0.2590681612,
-0.2306882888,
0.1128293946,
-0.2229888141,
-0.6376017332,
-0.4966617227,
1.4251718521,
0.547434032,
0.3909096122,
0.1030863896,
0.7099865675,
0.0882169083,
0.7726173401,
-0.8740651011,
0.2146892101,
0.0269700103,
-0.8311095238,
-0.3001475334,
-0.3793306351,
-0.7158958316,
-0.0447916873,
-0.1427790076,
-0.3469325602,
-0.0864274278,
0.3467614055,
-0.5315726399,
0.3021004498,
-0.8008052111,
0.9614263177,
-0.393192023,
-0.045197133,
0.3280313313,
-1.1815253496,
0.3815766275,
-0.6308567524,
0.3456360996,
-0.0553379767,
-0.4723500311,
0.6127398014,
-0.4144541025,
0.7945133448,
-0.2825301886,
-0.1976212263,
0.290211767,
-0.207843557,
0.3496643901,
0.0584104285,
0.1693310142,
0.4641233087,
0.1525890976,
-0.5137756467,
-0.5793949962,
0.307403475,
-0.7522030473,
-0.49216187,
-0.6738544106,
-0.2922823727,
-0.5120188594,
0.082509324,
0.5373135805,
0.5300579071,
0.1613873839,
-0.4381532371,
0.5490531325,
-0.0977785811,
0.0751567483,
0.487593323,
-0.0545897968,
-0.3440622687,
0.6830646396,
0.4920092821,
0.1432606578,
0.0744273737,
0.1612550169,
-0.6703966856,
-0.9729595184,
-0.7199598551,
0.4401829839,
-0.7360116243,
-0.225686416,
-0.7040696144,
-0.1021903828,
-0.1910851896,
-0.0388151556,
-0.1911752522,
-0.3330055773,
-0.2963917255,
-0.487801224,
0.4513539672,
0.9337874651,
-0.0394620411,
0.1588373035,
-1.0642377138,
0.0981870517,
0.1757570207,
0.4322801828,
-0.6460965872,
-0.5889518857,
0.08776512,
-0.0642234385,
-0.2578767836,
-1.0911529064,
0.0024565121,
0.1188727394,
0.5038862228,
0.1662071943,
-0.2212535292,
0.6505606174,
-0.6226266623,
1.0548094511,
0.2396249324,
-0.774695456,
0.3737246692,
-0.4169305563,
-0.1875117719,
0.4912660718,
0.5720068812,
-0.3166289628,
-0.3933850825,
-1.0201570988,
-0.822602272,
0.2826786339,
0.0786107257,
-0.1234848574,
-0.1936056614,
0.755854547,
0.3116512597,
-0.0269149691,
-0.5932801962,
-0.3297000229,
-0.2120284587,
-0.2336948663,
-0.2245900333,
-0.3738537431,
-0.3350402117,
-0.1648093164,
0.6662024856,
-0.3211816847,
0.1742008179,
0.5343320966,
0.0982449725,
-0.0738790631,
0.2768068314,
0.8855464458,
1.203797698,
-0.3543331325,
0.3087358177,
0.2033617496,
-0.9495739341,
0.3229351938,
0.3263171613,
0.295833081,
0.1003648713,
0.3206090033,
0.136735335,
-0.0675867945,
-0.5889014602,
0.8745310307,
-0.273000598,
-0.3404445648,
-0.4161696136,
-0.2186336964,
0.0200678222,
-0.0354155116,
0.3385554552,
0.2217264771,
0.4483595192,
-0.1339806318,
0.4774423242,
0.0616750084,
-0.342811048,
-0.5492967963,
0.6919599175,
0.2845900953,
0.1773931682,
0.2475292832,
-0.2450045198,
-0.3471653461,
0.4997908175,
0.3921664655,
0.5225641131,
-0.3020898402,
0.4436199069,
0.3227422535,
0.1074337438,
-0.3090418577,
0.5533229113,
0.5449659824,
-0.7737188935,
-0.8415775299,
-0.12540254,
-0.601053834,
0.144183293,
-0.5052821636,
-0.2073345184,
-0.5592003465,
-0.4879344106,
-0.0296149105,
-0.0540566258,
-0.3254347742,
0.518140614,
-0.0096004717,
0.8010699153,
-0.8162593246,
0.5318753719,
1.1107372046,
-0.5123960972,
-1.1984534264,
-0.1288713962,
0.221993506,
-0.9080643058,
0.6196603179,
0.0176363271,
0.0465194322,
-0.1058346704,
-0.516987741,
-0.6026453972,
1.0312638283,
0.038137868,
-0.5083370209,
-0.0751663446,
0.0155471647,
0.5358057618,
-0.1679892093,
0.3530184627,
0.8013365865,
0.3786741793,
0.1666014493,
-1.1003319025,
0.2551817894,
0.0595397279,
-0.1560144126,
0.1930576265,
-0.2817160189,
0.6836764812,
-0.5314347148,
0.2010411322,
-0.0957414582,
-0.064317368,
0.3233194351,
0.6024621129,
0.2642923295,
0.6253950596,
1.0540190935,
-0.3203236461,
1.0775934458,
0.0804713219,
0.3815680742,
0.9833634496,
-0.1867601424,
0.6047055721,
0.5262106657,
-0.4604897499,
0.2112164944,
1.0358070135,
0.1030215248,
0.0994699821,
0.1578901112,
-0.3906878531,
-0.0135275079,
0.2888412476,
-0.4473826587,
0.1536539644,
0.6013820171,
-0.2723217607,
0.028372949,
-0.2372512668,
0.0789865255,
-0.1763579249,
-0.3319931328,
0.5509925485,
-0.0268544704,
-0.4219133556,
0.6278886795,
-0.4671187401,
0.556782186,
-0.252071172,
-0.2985355854,
-0.226110056,
-0.0230587237,
-0.5032198429,
-1.0472034216,
0.1847676933,
-0.12258441,
0.0251194853,
0.04658591,
0.4240543246,
-0.1078673974,
-0.1189656183,
-0.0378548652,
0.5035968423,
0.5126769543,
-0.04413509,
-0.9240225554,
-0.0818566233,
0.1643276662,
-0.0182411931,
-0.0606649853,
0.5403763652,
-0.1127337888,
0.4715353251,
0.3881061971,
0.2641458809,
0.2266285866,
0.0429103151,
0.6107795835,
-0.4649738073,
-0.1637353003,
-0.6564728618,
0.6282431483,
-0.084939003,
-0.3410860002,
0.4439173639,
0.42072317,
0.621991992,
-0.11048612,
0.90857476,
0.1639479697,
0.7625142932,
-0.4101527929,
0.282803297,
-0.4338526726,
0.3402171135,
-0.3134495616,
-0.6868191957,
-0.6588602066,
0.499253273,
-0.3605702221,
0.2413181812,
0.8083203435,
0.4662178457,
0.1687642783,
0.1559356004,
0.4535338283,
0.5036230683,
0.3790228069,
0.5369070768,
0.7235885262,
-0.3790380657,
0.3142373264,
-0.1048026383,
-0.5031915307,
-0.3299085498,
-0.6244329214,
-0.5746299028,
-0.3320145309,
-0.5429167747,
-0.7106449008,
0.060527537,
0.807493329,
0.3387356102,
-0.6943547726,
0.340294987,
-0.0539313294,
-0.2106897086,
0.1493768692,
-0.1967228949,
0.5340335965,
-0.4233369827,
-0.4123561382,
-0.0140856747,
0.3392705321,
0.3814674616,
0.2092404962,
-0.0646428019,
0.0664431378,
-0.1467922926,
0.3886075318,
0.3063373268,
-0.7328568101,
-0.5948286057,
0.0014590805,
-0.2392414659,
0.4943463504,
0.5435419679,
-0.2616758049,
0.6302438378,
0.0229013935,
0.8155810237,
0.0742323026,
0.2478840202,
0.5341019034,
-0.4537366331,
-0.4443952441,
0.5454858541,
0.4192572832,
0.5104871392,
-0.4389758408,
0.858853817,
0.594630301,
-0.8408534527,
-0.4536559284,
0.0655251741,
-1.0745239258,
-0.1732146889,
1.2012238503,
-0.4157760739,
-0.0171061829,
-0.5005193949,
-0.4864212871,
0.0860684142,
-0.3295772672,
0.6385523677,
0.6247371435,
-0.6669560075,
-0.0299481899,
-1.1054625511,
0.8487260938,
0.2754140794,
-0.9959465861,
-0.183191523,
0.8429020643,
0.7484455705,
0.3577592373,
1.1710547209,
-0.2552628219,
0.6377270818,
-0.1910524517,
0.1350750178,
0.1838460118,
0.076902844,
-0.3624030948,
-0.1360971183,
0.4159734249,
-0.3475968838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13292v1
|
Evaluating Subword Tokenization: Alien Subword Composition and OOV Generalization Challenge
| 2024-04-20T06:49:15 | 2024-04-20T06:49:15 |
Khuyagbaatar Batsuren, Ekaterina Vylomova, Verna Dankers, Tsetsuukhei Delgerbaatar, Omri Uzan, Yuval Pinter, Gábor Bella
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The popular subword tokenizers of current language models, such as Byte-Pair
Encoding (BPE), are known not to respect morpheme boundaries, which affects the
downstream performance of the models. While many improved tokenization
algorithms have been proposed, their evaluation and cross-comparison is still
an open problem. As a solution, we propose a combined intrinsic-extrinsic
evaluation framework for subword tokenization. Intrinsic evaluation is based on
our new UniMorph Labeller tool that classifies subword tokenization as either
morphological or alien. Extrinsic evaluation, in turn, is performed via the
Out-of-Vocabulary Generalization Challenge 1.0 benchmark, which consists of
three newly specified downstream text classification tasks. Our empirical
findings show that the accuracy of UniMorph Labeller is 98%, and that, in all
language models studied (including ALBERT, BERT, RoBERTa, and DeBERTa), alien
tokenization leads to poorer generalizations compared to morphological
tokenization for semantic compositionality of word meanings.
|
[
-0.2091559172,
-0.6595756412,
0.2016555369,
-0.122164391,
-0.7563391924,
0.3040715754,
-0.2735692561,
-0.5863140225,
0.1388414949,
0.1559539735,
-0.2942455411,
-0.5576846004,
-0.7849071026,
0.0680102259,
-0.3587104082,
1.0038251877,
-0.0762921646,
0.1000659838,
-0.3092080355,
-0.3154232204,
-0.4801462591,
-0.6550135016,
-0.358299762,
-0.3719193339,
0.1227890775,
-0.1285110414,
0.5220479965,
0.5483262539,
0.7990728021,
0.3426009119,
-0.4022029936,
-0.0723242462,
-0.3231640756,
0.0319544636,
-0.7173885107,
-0.262691915,
-0.1233017966,
-0.1443293244,
0.5963286757,
0.8995164037,
-0.0439960361,
0.211838752,
-0.4261702895,
0.5923579335,
-0.6035253406,
0.0217508357,
-0.8194582462,
0.1550501734,
-0.1294414252,
0.0330711417,
-0.3413326442,
0.0417116918,
0.1647564173,
-0.243304953,
0.1288705021,
0.2688954175,
0.4422417283,
0.1831437051,
-0.1792335361,
-0.4902995825,
-0.4695175588,
0.6438579559,
-0.6095417142,
0.5568631887,
-0.2289490104,
-0.1356325448,
-0.119067356,
-0.6601786017,
-0.5714392066,
-0.353366375,
-0.0309728272,
0.2782660127,
-0.6355470419,
0.0893384218,
-0.3282120526,
0.7698206902,
-0.4390998483,
0.2425465435,
-0.6010637879,
-0.2034027427,
0.3416950107,
0.0771872848,
0.4832039475,
-0.134917751,
-0.5638121367,
0.0827159211,
-0.5078850389,
0.142982915,
0.4288157225,
0.2602385879,
0.0376208425,
1.0006942749,
-0.0182632171,
0.377184242,
0.1062503234,
0.2665694356,
0.3227002025,
-0.601223588,
0.0010100253,
0.0320555046,
0.6929119825,
0.4254273176,
-0.1371588558,
-0.4798509479,
-0.2731769383,
0.3148246109,
0.196110636,
-0.6344144344,
0.123904556,
0.4660057425,
-0.6281715631,
-0.0716548637,
0.3745221496,
-0.458979547,
-0.3233059347,
-0.2069059461,
0.4183413982,
-0.5464560986,
-0.1910946816,
0.151848048,
-0.5361670852,
0.0537034683,
-0.0897046477,
-0.964494586,
0.337263912,
1.0040353537,
0.9021974802,
-0.4950605333,
-0.2750953436,
-0.535787642,
-0.1215826944,
-0.3776652813,
0.8757175207,
-0.9296776056,
-0.7562448978,
-0.1995599866,
-0.1663739681,
-0.1422507614,
-0.7117418051,
0.4581821859,
-0.3027575016,
0.0733290985,
0.191947937,
-0.7247158289,
-0.104231596,
0.1114357859,
-0.2601429522,
1.1152986288,
0.5804154277,
-0.6035260558,
0.466532588,
-0.8273959756,
-0.2997426689,
0.3685248792,
-0.1201491877,
0.0149504608,
0.8040459752,
-0.0406828634,
0.0680519938,
-0.2513672113,
-0.0554029122,
0.1459510475,
-0.594088316,
0.2472227514,
-0.0781124607,
0.4592081308,
-0.1813275218,
-0.6266764402,
0.3808087111,
-0.6897912025,
0.0336460024,
-0.2267115563,
-0.5182974935,
-0.5996351242,
-0.043958351,
-0.086844258,
-0.1674958915,
0.3650872111,
-1.1003806591,
0.1986428201,
-0.5642186403,
0.4779187739,
0.7352035046,
-0.2237706184,
0.4586756229,
0.1517736614,
0.4590573609,
0.3221011758,
0.2535627186,
-0.1439189464,
-0.5101945996,
-0.7498142719,
-0.3559391201,
0.3940344453,
0.5348643661,
-0.556196332,
0.7244829535,
-0.576333046,
-0.8032835722,
-0.4655483663,
0.0301050451,
0.8192248344,
0.2767935991,
0.5983663201,
-0.6166065931,
-0.4074252248,
-0.7417011857,
-0.3743833601,
-0.5110230446,
-0.0090419995,
0.2017316073,
0.7239969969,
-0.5890904665,
0.817683816,
-0.1529563516,
-0.5013943315,
-0.3201794922,
0.6025545597,
0.3109476864,
0.7416448593,
0.415112704,
-0.5558309555,
-0.4781504273,
0.5583415627,
-0.2696917951,
-0.0131523861,
0.3273763657,
0.10611137,
0.3803215623,
0.5749941468,
-0.4545322061,
0.422855705,
0.5748197436,
-0.4460107088,
0.272110343,
-0.3555372953,
-0.066153422,
-0.6271964908,
0.1488080919,
-0.3616415262,
0.1861663163,
-0.5044278502,
0.4516452551,
-0.144258514,
0.0267939512,
-0.6232249737,
0.6017544866,
-0.5337657332,
0.0702328756,
-0.228480503,
0.0619406477,
-0.3643427491,
0.4223171473,
0.2583627105,
0.5453100801,
0.5667454004,
-0.4646410048,
0.6977191567,
0.1083621234,
-0.4516471326,
0.6297967434,
-0.9987939596,
0.5302973986,
-0.5255064368,
0.1643353105,
-0.9627941847,
0.2005241364,
0.4667317867,
-0.5751493573,
0.2945366204,
-0.1168659031,
-0.1700435281,
-0.1672752649,
-0.5417739749,
0.6176700592,
0.5366666913,
-0.3821835816,
0.9616801739,
0.2293423116,
-0.0430066362,
-0.5237503052,
-0.688180685,
0.0913413465,
0.0172620546,
-0.3506597579,
0.6062833667,
-0.0311144013,
-0.2421557307,
0.5160911083,
-0.2130143195,
0.2225452662,
-0.1682022512,
0.1697862893,
0.2005547136,
-0.198980093,
-0.2003964782,
0.1898882985,
-0.2311173081,
-0.0369528271,
-0.5831059813,
0.6706116199,
-0.2114308625,
-0.4769887626,
-0.0449978374,
0.6090236902,
0.4199700356,
-0.3302583992,
0.7509000897,
0.6803434491,
-0.3407725096,
0.0974953175,
-0.4288249612,
0.1599882692,
-0.3731696606,
0.692730248,
-0.5026079416,
-0.9363731146,
0.5217939019,
0.2112712115,
0.2099423707,
0.5579075813,
0.4984293878,
0.3526714146,
0.8534902334,
0.528876245,
0.1652784944,
0.2610548735,
-0.1490054727,
0.3607378602,
-1.21301651,
-0.6351289153,
-0.4990054667,
-0.2910488248,
-0.5996562839,
-0.5091583729,
0.3046736419,
-0.0485076234,
0.3524403572,
0.6897551417,
-0.5663311481,
0.4774889946,
0.623067379,
-0.2128448188,
0.121165745,
0.0850201696,
-0.3878505528,
0.0443014652,
-0.3725681305,
-0.3990722001,
0.8403040767,
0.3401848674,
0.6981850863,
0.2368068546,
0.4346590936,
0.3958743811,
0.5519676805,
-0.9803599119,
0.4126650393,
-0.6567220092,
-0.7245798111,
-0.2602036595,
-0.4394322634,
-0.8274071217,
0.5695382357,
-0.093652606,
-1.0632573366,
0.475450784,
-0.1133507565,
-0.302285403,
0.2549265325,
-0.7083861828,
0.7816477418,
-0.1531686634,
0.0016600074,
-0.1270555109,
-0.6307338476,
-0.0156782698,
-0.2235881984,
0.2065666467,
-0.0588191226,
-0.4221134782,
0.7939488888,
-0.4467363954,
0.5896447301,
-0.1223846897,
-0.1164752617,
0.3971321285,
-0.098053053,
0.2070117593,
-0.0513335206,
-0.1098867953,
0.5323262811,
0.3134396076,
-0.2104036957,
-0.6648418903,
0.2950460911,
-0.6196199059,
-0.4224557579,
-0.4255505502,
-0.1683531255,
-0.0892786458,
0.3025792241,
0.7260326743,
0.5768566132,
-0.3665851355,
0.4766616821,
0.2655668855,
-0.2747555971,
0.2428061068,
0.5731499791,
-0.2176750004,
-0.6678321362,
1.1214638948,
-0.0400727317,
0.0789007023,
0.8285335898,
0.5156763792,
-0.7736222744,
-0.7899424434,
-0.441799432,
0.0452710949,
-0.8468330503,
-0.0075790971,
-0.5989075303,
-0.0606189892,
-0.5360108018,
0.0485126153,
-0.3916626573,
-0.2038074881,
-0.1456387043,
0.0083187316,
-0.1849538833,
0.9313340187,
-0.1967925727,
0.3144657314,
-1.0279245377,
0.1012974232,
0.1285610199,
0.1388935894,
-0.2843990624,
-0.8005225658,
-0.1031694189,
0.0134484833,
0.1050408632,
-0.5477306247,
-0.1331060976,
0.3367232382,
0.702387929,
0.5220583677,
-0.0204590801,
0.5819116831,
-0.4734185934,
0.8885228634,
0.4492883682,
-1.5348703861,
0.2534964383,
0.0455481261,
0.112049453,
0.7282530069,
0.1467849612,
-0.8020866513,
-0.3118581772,
-0.2823621035,
-1.0991848707,
0.4948720336,
0.2286439538,
0.6047264934,
-0.3154701591,
0.2977809906,
0.3844274282,
0.2987383604,
-0.602627337,
-0.2307730019,
-0.2311976105,
-0.1272397339,
0.011621925,
-0.4349136055,
0.2716743946,
-0.2740218043,
0.5557246804,
-0.094999902,
0.3559228778,
0.2594200671,
-0.1608835906,
0.0277737211,
0.3169451952,
0.6439911723,
0.5965925455,
-0.2367925644,
0.3403860033,
0.1780991107,
-0.5993968248,
0.2742095292,
-0.110475637,
-0.1700852811,
0.3070178628,
0.613303721,
0.749882102,
0.1157006621,
-0.9154634476,
0.6042283773,
-0.1541969329,
-0.083331272,
-0.1062902883,
-0.0933778882,
-0.1789978445,
-0.1164642796,
0.3609510362,
0.0579167902,
0.1464679986,
-0.8191226721,
-0.1903609186,
0.6530138254,
-0.7316396236,
-0.5576961637,
0.4393385947,
0.2748520374,
-0.2137766033,
0.5748375654,
-0.2558145821,
-0.8740930557,
0.4099396467,
0.5246533751,
0.9271966815,
-0.1901565194,
-0.053113617,
0.1120646894,
0.6102855206,
0.366766721,
0.40425089,
-0.180497542,
-0.6585290432,
-0.268601954,
-0.6432458162,
-0.51676476,
-0.0777234435,
-0.5635156631,
0.0589739121,
-0.3669058383,
-0.0875590444,
-0.0229100455,
-0.3789969981,
-0.2680939734,
0.3146679699,
-0.0756472126,
0.8533397913,
-0.5522419214,
0.2142463028,
1.3190698624,
-0.2408992499,
-0.2192108333,
-0.3269141912,
-0.4448279738,
-0.7357184291,
0.8839859366,
0.3207390904,
-0.3031992316,
-0.1400863528,
-0.1116077229,
-0.8033843637,
0.6052735448,
0.2150883228,
-0.3668424189,
0.1219003052,
0.3860426545,
0.6891735792,
-0.3846016824,
0.4659853578,
0.4820857942,
0.4519116282,
0.1644352525,
-0.84122926,
0.0007871292,
-0.611150682,
0.3425586522,
0.275683105,
-0.4763070047,
0.8209609389,
-0.0043602269,
-0.5302758813,
0.2547745705,
0.8277440071,
-0.2167642415,
0.0518341884,
0.6170927882,
0.6495899558,
0.3846305311,
-0.0737983659,
0.847014606,
-0.3903405964,
0.3080814183,
0.9707269073,
-0.1224381477,
0.8357226253,
0.6369001865,
-0.331078738,
0.4995872676,
0.4398853183,
-0.0269630309,
0.4215631485,
0.4801816642,
-0.2634358406,
0.0492904447,
-0.5155112743,
-0.5078060031,
0.7780200839,
0.1237099394,
-0.2719808519,
-0.1559936255,
-0.0852003247,
-0.185136348,
-0.082258001,
-0.3165774047,
0.7811591029,
-0.0318099074,
-0.7911229134,
0.2505927384,
0.5009637475,
0.8866881132,
-0.5639546514,
0.1708801091,
-0.3825419843,
0.3961647451,
-0.2603966594,
-0.4243456125,
0.5390799046,
0.0768153518,
0.0991032645,
0.0903368592,
0.4079940021,
-0.3186805248,
-0.5247892141,
0.310336858,
0.2549871504,
0.260040015,
-0.1620016247,
-0.3457529843,
0.2209251225,
-0.3132033348,
-0.0256835688,
0.0212313905,
0.3084874153,
-0.0112116486,
0.3971905708,
0.7709651589,
0.0584522337,
0.3482121825,
0.0525412038,
0.8686357737,
-0.553335309,
-0.4443430603,
-1.1351314783,
0.420989573,
0.1245289147,
-0.6834711432,
0.6455400586,
0.7993169427,
0.960283339,
-0.2695067823,
0.6514542103,
-0.327593416,
0.2932989597,
-0.4726743698,
0.270513624,
-0.6078176498,
-0.0557783283,
-0.2894854844,
-1.1616330147,
-0.107306391,
0.443690747,
0.0336333886,
-0.0449690484,
1.0398881435,
0.4763375223,
0.032111235,
-0.2062013745,
0.3292969465,
-0.1951229274,
0.1575894207,
0.3971076608,
1.2031407356,
-0.3972878754,
0.4029873908,
-0.3312969208,
-0.4498578906,
-0.0052886019,
-0.9496741295,
-1.1385920048,
-0.5649522543,
-0.4552744031,
-0.1003201753,
-0.0744703561,
1.0807931423,
0.5331099033,
-0.945522666,
-0.0123656271,
-0.3483439088,
0.009820764,
-0.3176984191,
-0.1950675398,
0.300108552,
-0.141261965,
-1.0269825459,
0.3918055892,
0.7540799975,
0.1384370327,
-0.4167535305,
0.1687105149,
0.2131579965,
0.3260074854,
0.6386298537,
-0.0438589714,
-0.7861844301,
-0.3127085268,
0.1302673519,
0.1490508765,
-0.0991899595,
1.0543382168,
-0.4356399477,
0.4024291337,
0.8288490772,
0.5758494139,
0.0491968878,
0.3224422336,
0.2686904371,
-0.5489981771,
0.1102178246,
0.1960700601,
0.4522894025,
0.2960989773,
-0.2874300182,
0.5920293927,
0.5431568027,
0.0569308959,
-0.8438201547,
0.2687981129,
-0.7838259339,
-0.381696701,
1.0931367874,
-0.358636409,
-0.5162556767,
-0.2757194936,
-0.3407433033,
0.0083279619,
-0.3104816079,
0.5175819993,
0.6456278563,
-0.1779818386,
0.095476985,
0.5220065713,
-0.1416372359,
0.6074286699,
-0.708022058,
-0.1542475522,
0.1645174772,
0.131225273,
0.6693648696,
0.5543261766,
-0.2908518612,
0.1166858897,
0.1544601172,
0.0401568115,
-0.2508388758,
-0.0907465592,
-0.3223534226,
0.0114207501,
-0.1194869056,
-0.3632824719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13289v1
|
Double Mixture: Towards Continual Event Detection from Speech
| 2024-04-20T06:32:00 | 2024-04-20T06:32:00 |
Jingqi Kang, Tongtong Wu, Jinming Zhao, Guitao Wang, Yinwei Wei, Hao Yang, Guilin Qi, Yuan-Fang Li, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech event detection is crucial for multimedia retrieval, involving the
tagging of both semantic and acoustic events. Traditional ASR systems often
overlook the interplay between these events, focusing solely on content, even
though the interpretation of dialogue can vary with environmental context. This
paper tackles two primary challenges in speech event detection: the continual
integration of new events without forgetting previous ones, and the
disentanglement of semantic from acoustic events. We introduce a new task,
continual event detection from speech, for which we also provide two benchmark
datasets. To address the challenges of catastrophic forgetting and effective
disentanglement, we propose a novel method, 'Double Mixture.' This method
merges speech expertise with robust memory mechanisms to enhance adaptability
and prevent forgetting. Our comprehensive experiments show that this task
presents significant challenges that are not effectively addressed by current
state-of-the-art methods in either computer vision or natural language
processing. Our approach achieves the lowest rates of forgetting and the
highest levels of generalization, proving robust across various continual
learning sequences. Our code and data are available at
https://anonymous.4open.science/status/Continual-SpeechED-6461.
|
[
-0.1595978886,
-0.6513439417,
0.2691956162,
0.2357996255,
-0.3991187215,
0.4002934694,
-0.3121144474,
-0.4466633499,
0.0995803475,
0.3769553304,
-0.5163826942,
-0.1079734564,
-0.6954498887,
-0.5255560279,
-0.6001566052,
0.7308868766,
-0.0061341338,
-0.1086404994,
-0.2594438493,
-0.5550438762,
-0.7938476801,
-0.4860545695,
-1.1655887365,
-0.7743322253,
0.3452656567,
0.3002096117,
0.2026957721,
0.3785534501,
0.1815443039,
0.2360357046,
-0.2966344655,
0.2352063358,
-0.4370859265,
0.5081490278,
-0.3728026152,
-0.3712129891,
0.1678037643,
-0.1437969953,
1.185739994,
0.63601017,
-0.4067413211,
-0.0161024015,
0.2666833401,
0.6971564293,
-0.6339155436,
-0.0103825163,
-0.9350960851,
0.2587255239,
-0.4749273658,
-0.1564391553,
-0.1780084223,
0.3491044343,
-0.0236330684,
-0.2332749367,
0.2318862677,
-0.2348635197,
0.5961384773,
0.6335656047,
-0.3727453947,
-0.4463016987,
-1.0201705694,
0.9057066441,
-0.1969398111,
0.4886490703,
0.4426395297,
0.2047439814,
-0.2835340202,
-0.770901978,
-1.0425232649,
-0.0939822271,
0.475748539,
0.261472851,
-0.4696119726,
-0.2140147835,
-0.1645147353,
0.3015043736,
-0.7375339866,
0.2595449388,
-0.0676306635,
-0.49377653,
0.5128627419,
0.0956421867,
0.5992873311,
0.2021069229,
-0.1797284037,
-0.0133406352,
-0.2899576426,
-0.1695625782,
0.1704220772,
-0.0880853981,
-0.1389569789,
0.2713871896,
0.2173805982,
0.3455533087,
-0.0390592106,
-0.170303762,
0.2271519899,
-0.5204470754,
0.2716599107,
0.3726232648,
0.7326253057,
0.0123200798,
0.0037983377,
-0.2343844771,
-0.0769517571,
0.4757117033,
0.0163325984,
-0.119918339,
-0.5563036799,
0.306012094,
-0.2136826515,
0.1716753244,
-0.1341240853,
-0.546007514,
-0.3245720863,
-0.4215244055,
0.6061582565,
-0.5539960265,
-0.5606709123,
0.1353346258,
-0.6161959767,
0.0583742596,
0.0503807701,
-0.6172465682,
0.3448281884,
0.7918413281,
0.8875319958,
-0.3636402488,
-0.2552668452,
-0.9842405319,
0.4367879629,
-0.0382159539,
1.0642809868,
-0.6110204458,
-0.4724933505,
-0.3357951939,
-0.2927286327,
-0.0331626423,
-1.0423977375,
0.4924657941,
-0.3307862878,
0.0430994146,
-0.0757604465,
-0.5673679709,
0.0347806774,
-0.1652657837,
-0.3888656199,
1.3187162876,
-0.3266116679,
-0.5650098324,
0.715520978,
-0.2415578812,
-0.4951389432,
0.1572936177,
-0.3920312822,
-0.518014729,
0.1247293353,
-0.0468557812,
-0.2581254542,
0.1338678747,
0.6458577514,
-0.2722292542,
-0.2744938433,
0.2307620645,
-0.5218929648,
0.4419834614,
0.0202325583,
-0.4267623127,
-0.0660326928,
-0.9021747708,
-0.4105900526,
-0.0030777112,
-0.3521898091,
-0.2125032246,
0.6552318931,
0.136351198,
0.3414562643,
0.1627143323,
-0.6669688225,
-0.2691588104,
-0.1707427204,
0.373165369,
0.588106811,
0.2250003517,
0.2997300625,
-0.444976747,
0.1282467842,
0.6103306413,
-0.4341056049,
-0.199190706,
-0.5727533698,
-0.8009619117,
-0.2689573467,
-0.0949911252,
0.8091897964,
-0.8284169436,
0.7449553609,
-0.0088422364,
-0.0849842429,
-0.3432475626,
0.3327133954,
0.3542451859,
0.5601005554,
0.3854267895,
-0.5137856603,
-0.9717376232,
-0.4509181082,
-0.2375246286,
-0.3373831511,
-0.2736428082,
0.018815916,
0.4034129381,
-0.3465562463,
1.1451739073,
-0.3654203415,
-0.4357873201,
-0.1526192129,
0.4130223393,
-0.1523481309,
0.649736166,
0.2916317284,
-1.0544612408,
-0.3207576871,
-0.1027704626,
-0.8478253484,
-0.1043324545,
-0.3391425014,
0.1761683375,
0.2475226671,
0.4311655462,
-0.1255681664,
0.478813976,
0.2715620995,
-0.1867518574,
0.3219330311,
-0.2219592631,
-0.2822770476,
-0.7156322002,
-0.0966123641,
0.0008825249,
-0.236083582,
-0.7394538522,
-0.3702229857,
-0.2545588315,
-0.1251878887,
-0.1831911504,
0.569917202,
-0.3142045438,
-0.0451121852,
-0.6750133634,
0.204195857,
-0.0672676638,
0.1922384351,
0.2333423495,
0.5488750935,
0.8026201725,
-0.7701981664,
0.5942299962,
0.2894993424,
-0.2036971897,
0.8133004904,
-0.5012013316,
0.3164950609,
-0.5033716559,
0.4609336555,
-1.1061083078,
-0.0973269716,
0.2876126468,
-0.5338259339,
0.5668984652,
-0.1361731291,
-0.7147724628,
-0.3074686229,
-0.0806450844,
0.2168591022,
0.6308056712,
-0.5055629611,
0.6409421563,
0.9366489649,
-0.4517678916,
-0.2513531744,
-0.9686251283,
0.4655086398,
-0.2810168564,
-0.7342982888,
0.4101700783,
-0.076633513,
-0.0383476838,
0.0835066587,
-0.6602964401,
-0.4060139656,
-0.1948514283,
0.2347225547,
-0.0555078685,
-0.1258948892,
0.1104963422,
0.0018773478,
-0.3341630399,
-0.1768229604,
-0.7256065011,
0.5174812675,
0.2291641086,
-0.4315356314,
-0.9413354993,
0.8728641868,
0.3563100994,
-0.138376832,
0.6487213969,
1.2118062973,
-0.5235600471,
0.0716491267,
-0.9010750651,
0.0174666196,
-0.4905294478,
0.2973957956,
-0.1192894205,
-1.0947437286,
0.6644183397,
0.1600960195,
-0.058957573,
0.2588944137,
0.397377044,
-0.5347399116,
0.665424943,
0.3508728147,
-0.3218213618,
0.6536245942,
0.0739091635,
0.0764061511,
-0.7519906759,
-0.4131861925,
-0.2885211408,
-0.3769501746,
-0.0962551907,
-0.3767022491,
0.4669629335,
0.1185590699,
0.1104381159,
-0.0939664021,
-0.3085993826,
0.413302362,
0.6103414297,
0.1764174402,
0.2861168385,
0.1336420327,
0.2636011839,
-0.1801075786,
-0.5837951303,
-0.1057134494,
0.5957340598,
0.1099606827,
0.4599079192,
0.2764587402,
0.8657438159,
0.3029535413,
-0.3194058537,
-0.5754420161,
0.5131669641,
-0.2944460809,
-0.3746405244,
-0.1521424055,
-0.614906013,
-0.9487760663,
0.2285569161,
0.0041466141,
-1.0309016705,
0.2104654461,
0.3689541817,
-0.3870148361,
0.2326189727,
-0.3163187206,
0.4290811121,
0.0956218019,
-0.3467468023,
-0.5053833723,
-0.7334093451,
0.0875488892,
-0.2320461869,
0.2732059658,
-0.2300903499,
-0.1213662624,
0.9171605706,
-0.0066783992,
0.7555629015,
-0.2753518522,
0.2350163609,
0.7111686468,
-0.2447634339,
0.2379969209,
0.0884833187,
0.2339000106,
-0.0195929687,
0.0848910362,
-0.4699576795,
-0.3737666607,
0.6551290154,
-0.5290791392,
-0.2254731953,
-0.4659667015,
-0.3744838238,
-0.1782962084,
-0.1165343821,
0.1380803734,
0.6265739202,
-0.1265689135,
0.1219605356,
1.0061658621,
-0.17197375,
0.6397898793,
0.5960708261,
0.0720853433,
-0.3723730445,
1.2982399464,
0.2034399062,
0.0134132123,
0.1837040931,
0.2599953115,
-0.283965528,
-0.8039517403,
-0.2686400115,
0.1160208732,
-0.4583226442,
0.111255005,
-1.0985165834,
-0.2344135791,
-0.4415068626,
0.1624433696,
-0.3902263045,
-0.3695549369,
-0.6514654756,
0.1611772031,
0.1129624471,
0.3126370907,
-0.7279322743,
0.1031322405,
-1.0655508041,
0.8195275068,
0.5308429599,
0.1144469231,
-0.0905085132,
-0.7802346945,
0.1292701811,
0.0493528433,
-0.2915082872,
-0.6218445897,
0.1729065776,
0.890408814,
0.8481544852,
0.3634904325,
-0.1996919811,
0.6694919467,
-0.4814668298,
0.882689178,
0.2105706483,
-0.8323229551,
0.8206660748,
-0.1861457974,
0.5712377429,
0.777706027,
0.0786417872,
-0.8908134699,
-0.3681396544,
-0.5727573633,
-0.9857113957,
0.6849458814,
0.3212016821,
0.0373415016,
-0.0357054137,
0.0867122561,
-0.1644378006,
0.1376797557,
-0.304672718,
-0.2391409874,
0.091560863,
-0.1312215477,
-0.0130224954,
-0.4893870652,
-0.028625695,
-0.2119912952,
0.5899247527,
0.3357098401,
0.1158579215,
-0.0398818627,
-0.3287121356,
0.1164023429,
0.1115678251,
0.4971478283,
0.2926203609,
-0.212403059,
0.2064176649,
0.1582088917,
-0.784106791,
0.2231874168,
0.1873028874,
0.257833302,
0.3166440427,
0.3813869953,
0.5276607275,
0.5194464326,
-0.9157230258,
0.279649049,
0.1193302572,
0.0177913904,
-0.7477856874,
0.137621507,
0.2156077176,
0.1666132361,
0.6075562239,
0.0834425986,
0.2846874893,
-0.9206864834,
0.9179101586,
0.1263942569,
-0.6345273256,
-0.2998355329,
0.5302189589,
0.1230557039,
-0.2655110061,
0.6489916444,
-0.582021296,
-0.3908154666,
0.6177547574,
0.6047327518,
0.6862800717,
-0.4206058979,
-0.0659260303,
0.0606323183,
-0.0363787934,
-0.218518585,
0.5620775819,
-0.2893147171,
-0.9898568392,
-0.3464854658,
-0.6284110546,
-0.340498358,
0.0856108516,
-0.8957151175,
-0.1387988478,
-0.2343053371,
-0.0790318623,
0.3404206336,
-0.2157182992,
-0.1946796775,
-0.1320525855,
0.61925596,
0.5967246294,
-0.8713745475,
0.8817099929,
0.5837301016,
-0.0583393499,
-0.162048623,
-0.1218667701,
0.7006733418,
-0.4388103783,
0.3365284503,
0.1263797134,
-0.3208428621,
-0.0774900615,
-0.1289185584,
-0.7152831554,
0.6917921901,
0.1504522264,
-0.5135425925,
0.0117928199,
-0.1497140527,
0.3226759136,
0.1131217852,
-0.2873517275,
1.0407031775,
0.3138830364,
0.9016640186,
-0.9289753437,
-0.7132741809,
-0.0332901552,
-0.088949047,
0.4635995328,
-0.3646873832,
0.2767066061,
0.1899438053,
-0.5113906264,
-0.0797653645,
0.9247598052,
0.4933755994,
1.0977369547,
0.5447945595,
0.7636637092,
0.9097216129,
-0.124374643,
0.4689076245,
0.1960054487,
0.2257144302,
1.5799584389,
-0.5055891275,
0.8099761009,
0.4090373814,
-0.4554836452,
0.2627713084,
0.2594996691,
0.1377240866,
0.6716247797,
-0.0085739484,
-0.9999144673,
-0.2979091406,
-0.2321644872,
-0.3154133856,
0.720731318,
0.7875295877,
0.3615091145,
-0.3166106343,
0.4620063007,
-0.0331157893,
0.2633455098,
-0.3016163111,
1.0556862354,
0.2908324003,
-0.3744775057,
0.1711474359,
-0.3870379627,
0.9524595737,
-0.5453437567,
-0.0059805545,
-0.0513506532,
0.1402435899,
-0.0897483379,
-0.7522135377,
0.8530081511,
-0.0859099478,
-0.2563205957,
-0.0008832914,
0.7719060183,
-0.8214068413,
-0.3916006386,
0.2458773553,
0.0699520037,
0.2149964571,
-0.3135288358,
-0.5290224552,
0.4382090271,
0.0553780645,
0.3428131342,
0.4427089095,
0.2830324471,
0.165877685,
0.6682781577,
0.5024693608,
-0.0278038513,
0.176258564,
0.0433805548,
0.7795918584,
-0.5043203235,
-0.6553399563,
-0.848715961,
0.4841630459,
-0.2903681993,
-0.0117960721,
0.2450337708,
0.6934369206,
0.664370954,
0.2772553563,
0.8132465482,
0.1029680744,
0.3967154324,
-0.5039386749,
0.528719008,
-0.370438844,
0.0110921534,
-0.0838259161,
-0.4996117055,
-0.3228727877,
0.4514965713,
0.1580215991,
-0.3359532058,
0.5537407994,
0.568523705,
-0.2291643173,
0.150368169,
0.2061088532,
-0.0369612388,
0.400000006,
0.6506304145,
0.9756170511,
-0.1461354941,
0.5209001303,
0.0242719464,
-0.3427665532,
-0.0247723721,
-0.6419537663,
-0.5087960362,
-0.9486335516,
-0.8096889853,
-0.2101515532,
0.0962785184,
0.6926307082,
0.6953537464,
-1.0089678764,
-0.0373948552,
-0.005665415,
0.0057090227,
-0.2625364363,
-0.1942396164,
0.0192012824,
-0.3086182773,
-0.4557135701,
0.8997072577,
0.8548160791,
0.0855811164,
0.1130849645,
0.2716854811,
-0.4037892818,
-0.024137849,
0.4794356227,
0.6060586572,
-0.5717557073,
-0.5332953334,
-0.7753095031,
0.2622068524,
0.0925580785,
0.8042680621,
-0.7824699283,
0.6574223638,
0.2582897246,
0.6932590604,
0.8771268129,
-0.327725172,
0.3579189181,
-0.887735188,
0.6515461802,
0.6135392785,
0.2441311479,
0.3936276436,
-0.1873187721,
0.158777833,
0.5468000174,
-0.5684752464,
-0.900698185,
0.4636341035,
-1.3016785383,
0.0097354474,
0.8602197766,
-0.0362108909,
0.1891109943,
-0.6572324038,
0.0081662368,
0.3407807052,
-0.1736587286,
0.6288968921,
0.6433104873,
-0.3836585581,
-0.3183376193,
-0.3761400878,
0.0692142323,
0.3351831436,
-0.3153441548,
-0.1902157366,
0.6530585289,
0.4651885033,
0.14807868,
0.8553512096,
0.1296518892,
0.4023795128,
0.324796319,
-0.214448899,
0.1118179709,
-0.4899070561,
-0.6257186532,
0.0873253196,
-0.2077593803,
-0.4051621258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14443v1
|
Evaluation of Machine Translation Based on Semantic Dependencies and Keywords
| 2024-04-20T04:14:28 | 2024-04-20T04:14:28 |
Kewei Yuan, Qiurong Zhao, Yang Xu, Xiao Zhang, Huansheng Ning
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In view of the fact that most of the existing machine translation evaluation
algorithms only consider the lexical and syntactic information, but ignore the
deep semantic information contained in the sentence, this paper proposes a
computational method for evaluating the semantic correctness of machine
translations based on reference translations and incorporating semantic
dependencies and sentence keyword information. Use the language technology
platform developed by the Social Computing and Information Retrieval Research
Center of Harbin Institute of Technology to conduct semantic dependency
analysis and keyword analysis on sentences, and obtain semantic dependency
graphs, keywords, and weight information corresponding to keywords. It includes
all word information with semantic dependencies in the sentence and keyword
information that affects semantic information. Construct semantic association
pairs including word and dependency multi-features. The key semantics of the
sentence cannot be highlighted in the semantic information extracted through
semantic dependence, resulting in vague semantics analysis. Therefore, the
sentence keyword information is also included in the scope of machine
translation semantic evaluation. To achieve a comprehensive and in-depth
evaluation of the semantic correctness of sentences, the experimental results
show that the accuracy of the evaluation algorithm has been improved compared
with similar methods, and it can more accurately measure the semantic
correctness of machine translation.
|
[
-0.1739014834,
-0.6816859245,
0.6476379633,
0.2344495356,
-0.3966838717,
-0.104551442,
-0.2939070463,
-0.3655605912,
0.2483431399,
0.7839332819,
-0.425444901,
-0.5059941411,
-0.8001657724,
0.3469601572,
-0.1619531065,
0.8620917201,
-0.4088257849,
0.243390426,
-0.4764624536,
-0.3231633902,
-0.8277712464,
-0.2487885058,
0.1475606114,
-0.0361660905,
0.1028757095,
0.3275878429,
0.9071029425,
0.721044898,
1.0129864216,
0.5451949835,
-0.0433841795,
0.161634922,
-0.2383105457,
0.1370212287,
-0.4225413501,
-0.2807226479,
-0.443569839,
-0.2079568058,
0.7543775439,
0.5022196174,
0.4710939229,
0.1558897942,
0.0994778052,
0.7379413247,
-0.6302346587,
0.5048545599,
-0.8803298473,
-0.0647277385,
-0.1436473131,
-0.2901903987,
-0.1774407923,
-0.2628585398,
0.138946712,
-0.3979764581,
0.116399087,
-0.0477139279,
0.8162918091,
0.4451863468,
-0.3627661169,
-0.4529266357,
-0.533477664,
0.7489565015,
-0.7562954426,
0.3811888099,
0.3266643286,
0.3656761646,
-0.2881564796,
-0.4597488046,
-0.5122739077,
-0.5717679262,
-0.2125086784,
0.1053235382,
0.1800800115,
0.1412854344,
0.0056811566,
0.2920897305,
-0.5219250917,
-0.3610429168,
-0.4571333528,
-0.2290348411,
0.5145737529,
0.2400110215,
0.4994661212,
-0.5516149998,
-0.3364892304,
-0.1997462809,
-0.2348331958,
-0.4068022966,
-0.1676638126,
0.3741796613,
-0.0586890802,
0.9155809283,
-0.4200359881,
0.6836773753,
-0.0402951948,
-0.1132728457,
0.6745285988,
-0.8183205724,
-0.1880365014,
0.1242783964,
0.8944709897,
0.5045212507,
0.2219929695,
-0.5755506158,
-0.1050701961,
0.2667950094,
0.3660841882,
-0.626799643,
0.380069077,
0.2150212079,
-0.4777462184,
-0.2005292624,
0.20542638,
-0.4994415343,
-0.0740849823,
-0.1745893955,
0.5954344273,
-0.5787281394,
0.0799666792,
-0.0338053852,
0.0054632491,
0.1507528871,
0.0954978615,
-0.3672224581,
0.3125000298,
0.6844935417,
0.7568892241,
-0.1612633318,
-0.484464705,
-0.5731756687,
0.2912513912,
-0.0328423828,
0.5338127613,
-0.3947837651,
-0.209793359,
0.0227965862,
0.200485304,
-0.3655051291,
-0.5707539916,
0.8574618697,
-0.6816943884,
-0.0175438169,
0.0368571244,
-0.9491847157,
-0.5434461832,
0.2631186545,
-0.6894520521,
0.5759302974,
0.1960061789,
-0.8399919271,
0.2299176306,
-0.5537037253,
-0.6031404138,
0.2485622019,
-0.0117792403,
-0.3777534664,
0.0040438678,
0.0414612144,
0.3894785643,
-0.2083886266,
0.4079141617,
-0.320977807,
-0.4145963788,
0.2763804793,
0.0690398589,
0.6426874995,
0.2574454248,
-0.4553783238,
0.2238614708,
-0.7632523775,
0.1186482906,
-0.078889899,
-0.18160972,
-0.2832708061,
0.0339171998,
0.0828030184,
0.306391567,
0.4635500014,
-0.5262209177,
-0.0581051372,
-0.7678944468,
0.3197552264,
0.2786141336,
0.084688656,
0.3823307753,
0.0565686412,
0.3901332617,
-0.0705782101,
0.038563095,
0.0308659263,
-0.5943437815,
-0.7487377524,
0.1448949277,
0.466914475,
0.8523792028,
-0.7021822333,
0.8514430523,
-0.4967675507,
-0.1959069371,
-0.5519485474,
0.3479040861,
0.5781390071,
0.2680295408,
0.3882034123,
-0.2886639237,
-0.6950276494,
-0.6912449002,
-0.2956824899,
-0.2855167687,
0.16660285,
-0.1148245037,
0.7291404605,
-0.3303433657,
0.67956388,
-0.371722281,
-0.334497124,
-0.142148301,
0.1608199775,
0.1598462015,
0.4951836765,
0.1935710907,
-0.7059201598,
-0.3291392028,
0.1511020809,
-0.6830342412,
-0.1061987653,
0.2104363292,
-0.1241133437,
-0.0153363962,
0.2712689638,
-0.7488276362,
0.4503155053,
0.3833375275,
-0.2639833391,
0.1388941854,
-0.3431819975,
0.3993670344,
-1.0321128368,
0.3264740705,
-0.4164329767,
-0.1592389345,
-0.3177891672,
0.3844940662,
0.1779716611,
0.0006964949,
-0.4783850312,
0.2981041074,
-0.2548446953,
-0.1040787101,
-0.3131141365,
0.6364457011,
0.0728113428,
0.2004170418,
-0.1055064946,
0.4324559271,
0.0457935892,
-0.5201695561,
0.6350187063,
0.3100717664,
-0.3397064507,
0.3454196751,
-0.5706734657,
0.3018294275,
-0.0101578357,
-0.0123737641,
-0.9047668576,
-0.0669295862,
0.6458277702,
-0.5364796519,
0.0075582024,
0.2220654041,
-0.7822105289,
-0.2473423779,
-0.0472269319,
0.0628423765,
0.1743779182,
0.0679224432,
0.3253051639,
0.2888757586,
-0.0097237974,
-0.2940830588,
-0.429589957,
0.3110619485,
-0.028341094,
-0.9181507826,
0.3635593355,
0.1116013229,
-0.2802940309,
0.2707673311,
0.0873146728,
-0.2464300394,
0.0983916968,
0.1720359623,
0.3155310452,
0.0796407834,
0.213511616,
-0.1223614737,
-0.4067989588,
-0.1513597965,
-0.3592439592,
0.2911527753,
-0.3731205761,
-0.1987947971,
-0.4107043743,
0.1866355389,
0.5072386265,
-0.3060737252,
0.4320093393,
0.7323494554,
-0.3423719108,
0.3070785701,
-0.4342511892,
0.0982605591,
-0.3430034518,
0.562522471,
-0.5943757296,
-0.6870411634,
0.3378633261,
0.0468227901,
-0.2356579006,
0.8556244373,
0.5534208417,
0.1357751489,
0.9196434021,
0.5371043682,
-0.0669910684,
0.0714493543,
0.0572758876,
0.0731800273,
-0.5136163831,
-0.0824289396,
-0.8986391425,
0.0442411304,
-0.7873782516,
-0.4749086201,
0.2812152803,
0.1195080802,
0.0749436393,
0.8030045629,
-0.4604676962,
0.0474242494,
0.2633273602,
-0.0081160003,
0.3583163917,
-0.1631950587,
-0.3582725227,
-0.1414916962,
-0.1868938059,
-0.6361427903,
0.9150161743,
0.1385162026,
0.2729594409,
-0.1055157706,
0.4312922359,
0.4191322327,
-0.0797240138,
-0.7970882654,
0.6045937538,
-0.3321836591,
-0.3406401575,
-0.0568624623,
-0.6379391551,
-0.8061672449,
0.2190638483,
-0.2096809894,
-0.521704495,
-0.3552491367,
-0.2193223387,
0.139874652,
-0.3226761222,
-0.626163125,
1.139038682,
-0.4046857655,
-0.0346137024,
-0.5452157259,
-0.977578342,
0.0578495264,
-0.1181083396,
0.1597241312,
0.1062479839,
-0.078264311,
0.7421109676,
-0.7760816216,
0.621093154,
0.1362431198,
0.0809163824,
0.3480240107,
-0.094282575,
0.4708666503,
-0.3478231728,
-0.2061868757,
0.1604894549,
0.2563661337,
-0.2931255102,
-0.7613825202,
0.561573267,
-0.6875766516,
-0.2447258085,
-0.0826475173,
-0.564166069,
-0.2311689258,
0.5642554164,
0.2282510698,
-0.1815360039,
-0.2641099393,
-0.0966380239,
0.2048185319,
-0.1196697727,
0.0323980562,
0.4287237525,
-0.3030537665,
-0.6330766082,
0.8568081856,
0.1832692474,
0.2445665598,
0.7178835869,
0.2718709707,
-0.2168237418,
-0.349072963,
-0.8589404821,
0.1706293672,
-0.6137986183,
-0.0582937002,
-0.7297981977,
-0.1933291107,
-0.5248669386,
0.0056703635,
-0.2108093053,
-0.4938569367,
0.1879258454,
0.2333690524,
0.2937244475,
0.6877387762,
0.4014756083,
0.3459719121,
-1.2106938362,
0.2235922664,
-0.1958485097,
0.193054378,
-0.2608931363,
-0.350738883,
-0.5233585238,
-0.1164975762,
-0.4114507139,
-0.906691134,
-0.0193311442,
-0.0310104378,
0.4871480763,
0.2852405012,
-0.1627997309,
0.5805872679,
-0.6006952524,
0.6496803164,
0.1255266219,
-1.2827945948,
0.6264097691,
0.0357228518,
0.4709951282,
0.7955440879,
-0.0388477705,
-0.3647838235,
-0.6848809719,
-0.6528962851,
-0.7284727097,
0.4480537176,
0.4522071183,
-0.0212050267,
0.0856119543,
0.4785325527,
-0.0967111439,
0.2602588236,
-0.2466813326,
-0.0208272301,
-0.0205580778,
-0.2877760231,
-0.0371822752,
-0.0447513163,
0.3068726659,
0.051317893,
0.7027977109,
0.1532565504,
0.0874383226,
-0.0001855732,
-0.3256505728,
-0.0734461173,
0.2981509268,
0.3532503843,
0.5045195818,
-0.4954248667,
0.0879380926,
0.2931891978,
-0.5363789797,
-0.0002290525,
-0.0168505441,
-0.4330616295,
0.6135748029,
0.4745976925,
0.6941539049,
0.2368584424,
-0.5625745058,
0.6511528492,
0.2550279796,
0.2449302673,
-0.1482664496,
-0.1129397005,
0.1434990466,
-0.0745375231,
-0.3758800924,
0.3007516861,
0.4125185013,
-0.3593075573,
0.3909088671,
0.3096899688,
-0.7418150902,
-0.072959736,
0.2584103942,
0.0911924914,
-0.2544594109,
0.5502725244,
-0.1017013565,
-0.7612836957,
0.6026051044,
0.3643433452,
1.1270092726,
-0.2865802944,
0.0402730331,
0.279474467,
0.4493892491,
0.1057847664,
0.2050888985,
-0.0843456909,
-0.6312410235,
-0.7684924006,
-0.4461572468,
-0.4597032666,
-0.2426641434,
-0.3819978535,
0.5825126171,
-0.1270542294,
-0.2692441344,
0.0119343437,
0.0773366317,
-0.6205058694,
0.3610135019,
-0.2429274619,
0.5599712729,
-0.568015635,
0.8435481191,
0.9728754759,
-0.674677074,
-0.4735396504,
0.0323502719,
-0.2732013464,
-0.7086312771,
0.9742430449,
0.1361899674,
-0.3691575229,
-0.3867381513,
-0.1791576594,
-0.7637976408,
0.6890022755,
0.3551940322,
-0.4742980897,
0.2880239785,
0.490095526,
0.5962120295,
-0.2722465396,
0.2276992053,
0.1839442104,
0.6828514338,
0.2842720449,
-1.1254751682,
0.3587491214,
-0.4007484317,
0.4083935916,
0.1862488985,
-0.280610621,
0.3100540936,
0.0532039106,
-0.2272944897,
0.2229803354,
0.6159026623,
-0.1686988622,
0.1214394942,
0.5259916186,
0.4812741876,
0.3055890799,
0.3026188314,
0.8693688512,
-0.625977397,
0.6807746291,
1.1839293242,
-0.1931257248,
0.909389317,
0.482289046,
-0.2538175583,
0.1811280102,
0.3004021645,
-0.2089697719,
0.4055235386,
0.6034476757,
-0.0935998037,
0.0963566527,
-0.1224594861,
-0.3017682731,
0.4811192751,
0.1704436243,
-0.6155172586,
-0.4748035967,
0.0166585166,
0.155271396,
0.1505216211,
0.0637392178,
0.6779686809,
0.142974779,
-0.6009138823,
0.6667742729,
0.5115484595,
0.2445755601,
-0.3912988305,
-0.1772053689,
0.2736395895,
0.3718036711,
-0.2946722209,
-0.4993691146,
0.6892596483,
0.013678208,
-0.2197945416,
-0.0013807201,
0.9606935382,
-0.1749784946,
-0.7046158314,
0.5023854971,
0.4304326177,
0.4502251744,
-0.0848468691,
-0.7214994431,
0.2561601698,
-0.2353455126,
0.3065089285,
0.0818840638,
0.4785133004,
-0.0025610488,
0.352424413,
0.1672803611,
0.1471261084,
-0.1152641848,
0.028069308,
0.5783002973,
-0.729372859,
-0.3088476956,
-0.9099113345,
0.3194799125,
-0.0251378417,
-0.3956004083,
0.8405996561,
0.4626985788,
0.8135346174,
-0.1063217446,
0.924259305,
-0.2770122588,
0.3476783931,
-0.4793951213,
0.5387629867,
-0.2654732764,
0.1066293791,
-0.6802809834,
-1.0663385391,
-0.4846090972,
0.609070003,
-0.4982378185,
-0.0396172255,
0.9692170024,
0.6987170577,
0.1018791199,
0.2049130946,
0.2709286511,
0.3596641123,
-0.2070709914,
0.3480713964,
0.6244049072,
-0.8296474218,
0.5659100413,
-0.1846446544,
-0.4112618864,
-0.3843145669,
-0.8368548751,
-0.5111498237,
-0.6176064014,
-0.5080414414,
-0.7752425671,
0.147543624,
0.6898731589,
0.276683569,
-0.9284424782,
-0.3874717057,
-0.1826384962,
0.4100105166,
-0.3756850958,
-0.2371928841,
0.6534563899,
-0.8397898674,
-0.6220060587,
0.2294314504,
0.4798536003,
-0.4166436791,
-0.207388103,
-0.1269956827,
-0.2240378857,
-0.2734346092,
0.5324040055,
-0.3633263707,
-0.7818050981,
-0.3549069166,
0.0378755666,
-0.3395617604,
0.0642462522,
0.5589831471,
-0.4730938077,
0.6634996533,
0.8438609242,
0.8832993507,
0.4214612842,
-0.2461003363,
0.5619504452,
0.0944980979,
-0.101622805,
-0.0401055887,
0.2209384441,
0.3705666363,
-0.333155483,
0.5781238079,
0.4686853588,
-0.4627297819,
-0.0975479931,
0.1682468206,
-0.9904285669,
-0.0965703875,
0.9304797649,
-0.540117681,
-0.5053911805,
-0.2016277164,
-0.2383911014,
0.6804824471,
0.0055185207,
0.7334248424,
0.828623116,
0.127615422,
0.1046512946,
-0.7050943971,
-0.0486090705,
0.6789645553,
-0.5585335493,
-0.4635614753,
0.4915091991,
0.1521132886,
0.4259645343,
0.3726718724,
-0.4660939872,
0.04069224,
-0.1639222354,
0.1508839428,
0.4289599359,
0.0994397402,
-0.0752312168,
0.0320572406,
-0.0544201918,
-0.5087000132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13246v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13246v1
|
ISQA: Informative Factuality Feedback for Scientific Summarization
| 2024-04-20T03:16:13 | 2024-04-20T03:16:13 |
Zekai Li, Yanxia Qin, Qian Liu, Min-Yen Kan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose Iterative Facuality Refining on Informative Scientific
Question-Answering (ISQA) feedback\footnote{Code is available at
\url{https://github.com/lizekai-richard/isqa}}, a method following human
learning theories that employs model-generated feedback consisting of both
positive and negative information. Through iterative refining of summaries, it
probes for the underlying rationale of statements to enhance the factuality of
scientific summarization. ISQA does this in a fine-grained manner by asking a
summarization agent to reinforce validated statements in positive feedback and
fix incorrect ones in negative feedback. Our findings demonstrate that the ISQA
feedback mechanism significantly improves the factuality of various open-source
LLMs on the summarization task, as evaluated across multiple scientific
datasets.
|
[
-0.3280254602,
-0.6221740842,
0.617406249,
0.3799734712,
-0.4150680602,
0.1956253797,
-0.2288976759,
-0.1847913712,
0.6984338164,
0.3258985877,
-0.50352633,
-0.4391028285,
-0.3097015321,
0.2501051426,
-0.5212323666,
1.5716737509,
0.1711424589,
0.3939872384,
-0.7489584088,
-0.1207513288,
0.1124415547,
-0.3339150548,
-0.3769702315,
-0.303715378,
0.6653862596,
0.6142263412,
0.4107140899,
0.5229511261,
0.4697979689,
0.2870501578,
-0.0628873557,
0.3278429508,
-0.6079494953,
0.0412258506,
-0.3451780975,
-0.6243781447,
-0.264077872,
0.0164263751,
0.6792546511,
0.6101108193,
-0.1842450649,
0.5741496682,
0.1672329307,
0.7918701768,
-0.6497228742,
0.32974419,
-0.3395493031,
-0.0752660558,
0.0834629685,
-0.6186704636,
-0.3481220305,
-0.7462692857,
-0.0079648616,
-0.6758046746,
0.3173108697,
0.0983734429,
0.9458873272,
0.6586995125,
-0.4487376213,
-0.2722450197,
-0.6311148405,
0.54166466,
-0.8981592059,
0.1167175099,
0.2315832973,
0.2714297771,
0.1698989868,
-0.7146507502,
-0.5809737444,
-0.5693660378,
-0.075524725,
0.4722694755,
-0.0904565677,
0.1277688444,
0.3199192286,
0.5202980638,
-0.2758679092,
-0.3568428457,
-0.8213697672,
-0.3788828254,
0.6380987763,
-0.0733128414,
0.0806815028,
0.0138327451,
-0.3596460819,
0.301921308,
-0.8204669356,
0.2692957819,
0.1338077635,
0.0778181851,
0.0831197128,
0.8940660954,
-0.6822959781,
0.260428071,
0.2954463065,
-0.1487866789,
0.0570802242,
-0.6889757514,
0.2257170826,
0.2918727398,
0.3217272758,
0.783698976,
-0.2106774449,
-0.4068297148,
-0.132727325,
0.0796144009,
0.3477321863,
-0.9285458922,
-0.3397794664,
0.3759807348,
-0.3095752597,
-0.3515784144,
0.2159653455,
-0.4752668738,
-0.4570238292,
-0.4430340528,
0.5670157075,
-0.2993756235,
-0.0399781466,
-0.0824605376,
-0.3627869487,
0.0832904279,
0.7305124402,
-0.6221140623,
0.3374764621,
0.4006502628,
0.9208863378,
-0.0273641609,
-0.3037475944,
-0.7434787154,
-0.0691536516,
-0.0713896304,
1.1096125841,
-0.1144467518,
-0.2985160351,
-0.5685819387,
-0.0257269423,
0.1697969586,
-0.5544368029,
0.2981833816,
-0.5590596199,
0.2114428282,
-0.819942832,
-0.5071486831,
-0.6132622957,
0.4873153269,
-0.6631617546,
0.9384205341,
-0.124300532,
-0.8988420963,
0.3135657907,
-0.8704189658,
-0.1095740199,
-0.0198177081,
-0.0189986043,
-0.4053699672,
0.0032503535,
0.1594882905,
0.0851201043,
-0.3485514224,
0.394569397,
-0.3067239821,
-0.2626348436,
0.5031951666,
-0.079848811,
0.5149926543,
0.2945531309,
-0.4927612841,
0.510256052,
-0.9232515097,
0.0686021671,
-0.3221710622,
-0.5142026544,
0.039291285,
-0.0300939064,
-0.4125143886,
0.090235278,
0.1344495863,
-0.777540803,
0.2189782411,
-0.2189746797,
0.3193971813,
0.4818368256,
0.4540900886,
0.362770468,
-0.8789129853,
0.3846413791,
-0.0592831075,
-0.0141152041,
-0.1466164887,
-0.4110918641,
-1.0170681477,
-0.4025550187,
0.5328983068,
0.5000901818,
-0.9296875,
0.1479368061,
-0.1712519974,
-0.5440192223,
-0.4650821984,
0.0850340798,
0.3819862008,
0.8976686001,
0.4878533185,
-0.3356318474,
-0.60880512,
-0.6572563648,
-0.250266552,
-0.5080046058,
-0.0648690313,
-0.2704357207,
0.7138473392,
-0.0054468205,
0.9910680056,
-0.2909437716,
0.1535941511,
0.1141609997,
0.3249806762,
0.2321705073,
0.2066259086,
0.3510486782,
-0.5911668539,
-0.0549784563,
-0.4448484778,
-0.8072731495,
-0.295781374,
-0.0282258857,
0.0269791596,
0.004093484,
0.3796568513,
-0.546264708,
0.594362855,
0.1462257951,
-0.4389030337,
0.8568240404,
0.0297123212,
0.6097483039,
-0.7527912259,
0.4013302922,
-0.1997999549,
-0.2475542724,
-0.4007541835,
0.140640825,
0.082294181,
0.2992354035,
-0.210763827,
0.2491879463,
-0.2684339881,
0.0445584692,
-0.3948234022,
0.2319444567,
0.0992217436,
0.4240852892,
-0.0348948054,
0.8027769327,
0.134938851,
-0.9887475371,
0.347135514,
0.2090707123,
-0.2928478718,
0.4964671433,
-0.8505750299,
-0.1858396679,
-0.4672420621,
0.3959715068,
-1.1675573587,
-0.4591896534,
0.1865893453,
-0.6386870742,
-0.2591759264,
0.10998559,
-0.3886938095,
-0.221884951,
-0.7555299401,
0.1067381725,
0.0502200611,
-0.6806246042,
0.5349692106,
0.1660434455,
-0.5087797642,
-0.8258408308,
-0.4191075265,
0.0339381732,
0.0365120545,
-0.6842800975,
0.1435517222,
-0.5816100836,
-0.6037663221,
0.1343734711,
-0.2315409034,
0.1677895039,
0.2869515121,
0.2869778574,
0.5453733206,
-0.1478551626,
0.2849904597,
0.2706494927,
-0.0462666862,
0.3782532513,
-0.1287786216,
0.1083321944,
-0.3037429452,
-0.2188608646,
-0.217139408,
0.1784902513,
0.5475363135,
-0.0496629663,
0.3480409384,
0.217395857,
-0.2786652744,
0.0461551324,
-0.4651242197,
-0.6785323024,
-0.4168157578,
0.209112227,
0.007110381,
-0.9675474763,
0.4772036076,
-0.0513992757,
0.3138540387,
0.4637637138,
0.7363135815,
-0.2789155543,
0.6579990387,
0.413212657,
0.2942233384,
-0.1111444309,
-0.2895676494,
-0.0032340614,
-0.5193698406,
-0.4231857359,
-0.4981088042,
-0.0348016024,
0.0110801579,
-0.3156751394,
0.6346068382,
0.1074438915,
-0.0502838232,
-0.3221246302,
-0.2866297364,
0.6976605058,
0.7347127795,
0.2612002194,
0.6668815017,
-0.2308082581,
-0.0402074456,
0.1487833411,
-0.566274941,
-0.5390487909,
0.8823702335,
0.2738841474,
0.7006033063,
0.394600302,
0.5638713837,
0.4242049754,
0.6910837293,
-1.0424717665,
0.4463685751,
0.3630740643,
-0.602001965,
-0.2242781818,
-0.3729883432,
-0.3323442936,
0.1743198335,
-0.4978036582,
-0.3902126253,
-0.050315246,
0.6191552281,
-0.5926452875,
0.1350214332,
-0.4724923372,
0.1284965277,
-0.023761468,
-0.2758481503,
-0.1971599758,
-0.9027196765,
0.5845618248,
0.1449433416,
0.1467156261,
0.209313482,
0.0532161705,
0.7187519073,
-0.9101951718,
0.9404571652,
-0.2703831196,
-0.1125169024,
0.3598881662,
-0.1575655341,
0.4168202579,
0.4579304755,
0.0428671874,
-0.1613676548,
0.2579210103,
-0.5676427484,
-0.8281676173,
0.3472187221,
-0.6436790228,
-0.7158595324,
-0.5305138826,
-0.4794851542,
-0.2954995036,
0.1028589755,
0.6432153583,
0.266038239,
-0.0667319745,
0.1080115288,
0.876432538,
0.1544478834,
0.0544484928,
0.8278383017,
-0.4576866627,
-0.6603682637,
0.7200524807,
0.2827504277,
0.1468063593,
0.3136736155,
0.1363372952,
-0.3821106255,
-0.6854007244,
-0.4291658998,
0.5203318,
-0.9485613108,
-0.4224251509,
-0.7278141975,
-0.3344252408,
-0.4006986022,
0.1250289679,
-0.0949959978,
-1.1421056986,
-0.2859747708,
-0.5568552017,
0.4778701067,
0.9185872674,
-0.2462382615,
0.1216436699,
-0.8255249858,
0.3699071705,
0.389991641,
0.1068906263,
-0.0327823348,
-0.6602279544,
-0.453797847,
0.1397403479,
-0.4182171822,
-0.7142078876,
-0.0272951778,
0.236988306,
0.3541088998,
0.3505777121,
0.2065407932,
0.4195359051,
-0.1113947853,
1.0793873072,
0.1159432679,
-0.9879211187,
0.4401783049,
-0.142509535,
0.5223330259,
0.8148903847,
0.5535126925,
-0.3410331309,
-0.604481101,
-0.3911437094,
-0.7794858217,
0.428979665,
0.0112475911,
-0.461897403,
0.2419772297,
0.6006801724,
0.3756611943,
0.5692246556,
-0.63869977,
-0.3290989399,
-0.6402642727,
-0.0842918381,
0.2148689628,
-0.3746560812,
-0.5430479646,
-0.1267718524,
1.1703033447,
-0.4196200669,
0.0962694958,
0.455991447,
-0.1923458874,
-0.1152134016,
0.3831660151,
0.7974721789,
0.8156389594,
-0.3587993085,
0.3484191895,
0.059039589,
-0.5848620534,
0.0459915251,
0.0547971725,
-0.5251739025,
0.0028050994,
0.3414464593,
0.4893065989,
-0.0930659845,
-0.5549923182,
0.4748631418,
-0.256136924,
-0.5478745103,
-0.1904998422,
0.24297373,
-0.1101417914,
0.3711505234,
0.5859095454,
0.3797261715,
0.7159968615,
-0.4887764752,
0.3124294579,
0.1052420363,
-0.2592211962,
-0.5455394387,
0.7986406684,
0.2099314779,
0.2206902504,
0.4300695062,
-0.1271041036,
-0.5832518935,
0.5187797546,
0.5113472342,
0.541310966,
0.0793817341,
0.6878558397,
0.7712010145,
0.2805734277,
-0.0610973909,
0.7995795608,
-0.5153957009,
-0.4010702968,
-0.6927324533,
-0.2367133051,
-0.9399282932,
-0.2336307764,
-0.7207859159,
0.2268996388,
-0.5802987218,
-0.2118782401,
0.0262836665,
-0.1026398689,
0.0264888667,
0.2441541553,
-0.1522818804,
0.9946787953,
-0.6032620668,
0.4095655382,
0.6595673561,
-0.6939300299,
-0.7059626579,
-0.0815023556,
0.3003925979,
-0.4716232717,
0.6840575337,
0.0217150692,
-0.5318368077,
-0.119892776,
-1.1773189306,
-1.1413089037,
1.2809277773,
0.4055087566,
-0.2354161441,
-0.0100320429,
-0.2050716579,
0.5413586497,
-0.06373059,
0.4093418717,
0.1312701851,
0.6576192975,
0.1796495318,
-0.5808465481,
0.3162494898,
-0.8580560088,
-0.3803237081,
0.0102391522,
-0.8828346729,
0.5279689431,
-0.7463409305,
-0.3528160453,
0.4165969789,
0.9851729274,
0.5811451674,
0.7455296516,
0.498981148,
0.5205930471,
1.2175371647,
-0.1743477881,
0.9182796478,
-0.3193942308,
0.2416339666,
1.2571921349,
0.0352711715,
0.3267045915,
0.6541272998,
-0.1722836941,
0.5097469687,
0.594114542,
0.0091266492,
0.5662152767,
0.289311409,
-0.2950908542,
0.03748345,
-0.1745179892,
-0.3204502463,
0.3036709726,
0.298607707,
-0.0581335463,
-0.2865829468,
-0.0257002395,
0.3010656834,
0.0166955721,
-0.374979198,
0.661806345,
-0.1415715814,
-0.9336414337,
0.717276454,
-0.229707703,
0.5173358917,
-0.645539999,
-0.3284690082,
-0.196617052,
-0.3830626607,
-0.6817789078,
-0.3636131585,
0.2041320056,
0.0756698623,
-0.5395889282,
0.3691464067,
0.2668405175,
-0.5155467987,
0.0548979416,
-0.3335550129,
0.208626017,
0.0609347001,
0.094173111,
-0.4329101443,
-0.2714644074,
0.1900093108,
-0.0779225901,
-0.1239733174,
0.320445627,
0.0766436458,
0.7131835818,
0.6465451121,
0.19767268,
0.0698449314,
-0.0236319974,
1.0516525507,
-0.7532098293,
-0.5560102463,
-0.5441714525,
0.6567489505,
-0.2805787027,
-0.2669632435,
1.1148825884,
0.6057700515,
0.5065729022,
-0.2368612587,
1.0641063452,
0.0471552536,
0.6879454255,
-0.7880801558,
0.6423472762,
-0.2414174527,
0.574397862,
0.014584302,
-0.831305027,
-0.3692475557,
0.2206345797,
-0.1238291413,
-0.1726700664,
0.8515815139,
0.8563326597,
0.2565307915,
0.4366629422,
0.0125414245,
0.5774224401,
0.2582350075,
-0.2029480934,
1.2140696049,
-0.1701819152,
0.1841899604,
-0.416353941,
-0.5759184361,
-0.3131064475,
-0.8292069435,
-0.6743603349,
-0.5435011983,
-0.5862998962,
-0.7297962904,
0.0639414713,
1.1579290628,
0.2713680565,
-0.9631055593,
-0.0538022146,
0.084131062,
0.0382620245,
-0.0972971842,
-0.2997281849,
0.1629325449,
-0.4316562712,
-0.3569089472,
0.3618894815,
0.5341181159,
-0.0671651736,
-0.1802505851,
0.0359813049,
-0.1713008434,
0.4061798155,
0.5116960406,
0.5394682288,
-0.4324117601,
-0.1784849912,
0.1207899377,
0.2255390733,
0.1320557296,
0.8711650372,
-0.6288087964,
0.5723754764,
0.4411624968,
0.6150214076,
0.4274373949,
0.1998317689,
0.4414177835,
-0.6462579966,
-0.3172121048,
0.2210899293,
0.2854262888,
0.3301598132,
-0.5739027858,
0.7224583626,
0.1537612677,
-0.759968996,
-0.7699615359,
0.0648002252,
-1.1192866564,
-0.0632908121,
1.02095294,
-0.1065169275,
-0.3381823897,
-0.1303118765,
-0.5271164179,
0.1940757483,
-0.5409122109,
1.2797210217,
0.7501607537,
-0.3350560963,
0.0758883059,
-0.0003602643,
0.4603088498,
0.4450600743,
-0.9918522835,
-0.1749710143,
0.7170962691,
0.326990068,
0.469586432,
0.8382512331,
-0.204095304,
0.8369453549,
-0.179944858,
0.0670804381,
-0.1548617184,
-0.3097659051,
-0.2981538475,
0.0179389585,
0.2902867198,
0.2249640375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13238v1
|
Personalized Wireless Federated Learning for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-20T02:30:21 | 2024-04-20T02:30:21 |
Feibo Jiang, Li Dong, Siwei Tu, Yubo Peng, Kezhi Wang, Kun Yang, Cunhua Pan, Dusit Niyato
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
tasks. However, their deployment in wireless networks still face challenges,
i.e., a lack of privacy and security protection mechanisms. Federated Learning
(FL) has emerged as a promising approach to address these challenges. Yet, it
suffers from issues including inefficient handling with big and heterogeneous
data, resource-intensive training, and high communication overhead. To tackle
these issues, we first compare different learning stages and their features of
LLMs in wireless networks. Next, we introduce two personalized wireless
federated fine-tuning methods with low communication overhead, i.e., (1)
Personalized Federated Instruction Tuning (PFIT), which employs reinforcement
learning to fine-tune local LLMs with diverse reward models to achieve
personalization; (2) Personalized Federated Task Tuning (PFTT), which can
leverage global adapters and local Low-Rank Adaptations (LoRA) to
collaboratively fine-tune local LLMs, where the local LoRAs can be applied to
achieve personalization without aggregation. Finally, we perform simulations to
demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed two methods and comprehensively
discuss open issues.
|
[
-0.1951126754,
-0.7204096317,
0.3609315157,
0.3199840784,
0.1516275853,
0.2489803135,
-0.6257543564,
-0.5533613563,
0.149875924,
0.4928351641,
-0.7352625132,
-0.5363339186,
-0.4742336571,
0.1928717047,
0.1190458834,
1.1906405687,
-0.0506893359,
-0.2813231051,
-0.0898027346,
-0.2458738685,
-0.3163849413,
-0.2567523718,
-0.7075746655,
-0.5305172205,
0.774523735,
0.6646404862,
0.5973561406,
0.4980416894,
0.4691695273,
0.4794102907,
0.0522900522,
0.3237577677,
-0.7072169185,
0.2445624471,
-0.4240281284,
-0.2643044889,
-0.1227583438,
-0.1121008545,
0.5190650821,
0.8753730655,
-0.12762402,
0.2737001479,
-0.1861651838,
0.7690078616,
-0.6603303552,
0.3763963282,
-0.6995898485,
0.1001506522,
-0.1901324093,
-0.1960624754,
-0.4329501688,
-0.3557601571,
0.3369647264,
-0.6578195095,
0.154234603,
0.1862100363,
0.6580637693,
0.0579913445,
-0.4722773135,
-0.2721002102,
-0.9055669308,
0.8972942829,
-0.6854373217,
0.179434225,
0.4145238101,
0.299803406,
-0.4916405082,
-0.6690582037,
-0.2966247797,
-0.1684852839,
-0.212391749,
-0.146589756,
-0.2795847654,
0.3067272305,
0.0963785499,
0.5181561708,
-0.5103591681,
0.5766938329,
0.0765227303,
-0.1976004988,
0.7284530997,
0.1701810807,
0.0666160733,
0.3906607032,
-0.3542685509,
0.0952829793,
-0.3684715331,
0.1637501121,
0.334541589,
0.609918654,
-0.2665331364,
0.3738648891,
-1.1026594639,
0.7557265759,
0.2902396321,
-0.392337501,
0.4856797755,
0.0956994742,
-0.3312192857,
-0.0462572314,
0.8793378472,
-0.1923163831,
0.073638387,
-0.5933480859,
-0.345292002,
-0.449487865,
-0.1395065784,
-0.6710147262,
-0.2159205526,
0.1483230144,
-0.472507,
-0.4772500694,
-0.1213329583,
-0.3827905357,
-0.248319,
-0.289663583,
0.5844987035,
-0.1475741565,
-0.0393075235,
0.1973787993,
0.2764082253,
-0.1865307242,
0.2381372601,
-1.5287183523,
0.2239251435,
0.7897984385,
0.822062552,
0.0930879042,
-0.4247239232,
-0.7104088068,
0.1381076127,
0.1959278882,
0.6393190026,
-0.3838188648,
-0.0478643477,
0.1582327932,
0.0158269498,
-0.282104373,
-0.1573465168,
0.3966819048,
-0.7346220613,
0.3465693295,
-0.2759373486,
-0.5945578218,
-0.1010641977,
0.1864885241,
-0.2796731591,
0.4394236207,
0.2054907233,
-1.0024493933,
-0.0755565912,
-0.5489643216,
-0.6891000867,
0.2222239971,
-0.0487215184,
-0.5193668008,
0.3081387877,
0.1899114847,
0.7751817703,
-0.1175787672,
0.1299458444,
-0.4282997847,
-0.4550180435,
-0.0389587469,
-0.2011071444,
0.5896780491,
0.2806800306,
-0.4242619574,
0.3174527586,
-0.7951493859,
0.1930899024,
0.1745811403,
-0.6213323474,
-0.3701927662,
0.1974021941,
-0.1378582269,
0.0570738651,
0.3653768301,
-0.8528638482,
0.1822384,
-0.7713215947,
0.5110824704,
0.7758170366,
-0.0567390993,
0.5615491271,
-0.510856092,
0.1014029384,
-0.187895909,
-0.0132367145,
-0.1001293808,
-0.1048715115,
-0.5694797039,
-0.2510028183,
0.0914685279,
0.3573264182,
-0.7979802489,
0.4849826992,
-0.4268215597,
-0.4142804742,
-0.153197363,
0.2510034442,
0.4396395087,
0.5481434464,
0.1567924768,
0.0681880116,
-0.1787361205,
-0.7810465097,
-0.2145476639,
0.0751084313,
-0.1496347189,
0.4239268899,
0.369551599,
-0.4779353738,
0.8325691223,
-0.5290818214,
-0.508675456,
-0.1350201368,
0.1882889122,
0.1119506583,
0.3298524916,
0.2996269464,
-0.595079422,
-0.4596354365,
0.4626054168,
-0.4594968557,
-0.0863141567,
-0.0316608474,
0.1453758925,
0.1486717165,
0.0612691417,
-0.3904907405,
-0.0457536429,
0.8899510503,
-0.4307038784,
0.3066570163,
-0.4011624753,
0.0835810602,
-0.9799389839,
-0.1849617809,
-0.0388528518,
-0.3938757181,
-0.59150666,
0.0356970541,
-0.1771176606,
-0.0830656812,
-0.0276895054,
0.4310285449,
-0.2456289083,
-0.1014365256,
-0.4156525135,
-0.0914139897,
-0.2084234506,
0.5237846971,
-0.0551626571,
0.5682535768,
0.2286493629,
-0.3958910406,
0.3804954588,
0.3683552146,
-0.3353657424,
0.0853615552,
-0.4906398952,
0.1692945361,
-0.0383409113,
0.5190035105,
-0.6561126113,
-0.5090563297,
0.0077824444,
-0.1471519619,
-0.0136829214,
0.2348911166,
-0.3177280724,
-0.0730798542,
-0.2428597957,
0.0516287759,
0.1647891104,
-1.0112144947,
0.3826483488,
0.1580918133,
-0.0098656854,
-0.5716128349,
-0.4399212897,
-0.292191267,
-0.022472823,
-0.7889765501,
0.5302385688,
0.0670184642,
-0.0860010684,
-0.2012284845,
-0.1541283429,
0.1212863922,
0.3580940366,
0.4542725384,
-0.3181682527,
-0.2890315652,
0.3062407076,
0.2997042239,
-0.1247725338,
-0.1188623756,
-0.3718096614,
0.3543685973,
-0.2161279172,
-0.1047879755,
-0.4932164252,
0.3511634767,
0.3267309964,
-0.4925907552,
0.9531539679,
0.8905223608,
-0.2415535748,
-0.4715372622,
-0.6897939444,
-0.2435294688,
-0.5651939511,
0.2683752477,
-0.2444583476,
-1.704521656,
0.2840171158,
-0.4237025976,
0.3511442244,
-0.0651329979,
0.6346828341,
-0.3863135278,
0.8207874894,
0.9035465121,
-0.4099977314,
0.7605037093,
0.0840867981,
0.3907386363,
-0.5600979328,
-0.2746178508,
-0.5112248063,
-0.4431022704,
-0.7317707539,
-0.0029389958,
0.1726329625,
-0.0574783757,
-0.5624457002,
0.0586765036,
-0.3026660979,
0.557087779,
0.4369072318,
0.2600618303,
0.3723370135,
0.361207664,
0.0470784158,
0.1843825579,
-0.6623965502,
-0.2067434043,
0.7126253247,
0.4961435795,
0.6884034276,
0.1410953999,
0.9387396574,
0.0179167092,
0.3438920975,
-0.5236561894,
0.3086853623,
-0.3375443816,
-0.257478863,
-0.3967640102,
-0.8576940298,
-0.8932980895,
0.281224072,
-0.5666258931,
-1.0670534372,
0.0002761863,
0.2051874101,
-0.3935127258,
0.3076163232,
-0.7242494226,
0.6050038934,
-0.1014981344,
-0.4568081498,
-0.2793884277,
-0.5444316864,
0.4250833094,
0.0020270071,
0.2349237949,
-0.2473507971,
0.1422951967,
0.6137871146,
-0.3604618609,
0.8289979696,
-0.2187507451,
0.1308167726,
-0.2994242311,
-0.1514615119,
0.8281216025,
0.3399733603,
-0.0962872058,
0.1405928135,
-0.2021350712,
-0.3492997885,
-0.381793648,
1.2110815048,
-0.9241048098,
-0.4709317088,
-0.2417022586,
-0.6115528941,
-0.6091145873,
0.2177441865,
0.3540810049,
0.3479377925,
-0.1009851098,
0.4000552595,
0.7792069316,
-0.444336623,
0.5565078259,
0.8006568551,
0.045735348,
-0.4354065061,
0.9679628015,
-0.2611834407,
0.1805310398,
0.7591224909,
0.5110551119,
0.008212341,
-0.7800659537,
-0.0082203103,
0.2534732223,
-0.4276246727,
-0.4015144706,
-0.5681303144,
-0.0016258828,
-0.2473326027,
-0.38921538,
-0.4438350499,
0.0215786025,
-0.3742411137,
0.088082701,
0.5246329904,
0.3500523567,
0.2178079933,
0.7003097534,
-0.794167757,
0.1359530389,
0.3152871728,
0.686424017,
-0.0600394011,
-0.2988529801,
-0.5310472846,
0.1243306026,
-0.1189718395,
-0.2898499668,
0.192033574,
0.3368483782,
0.339446336,
0.3299931288,
0.305806756,
0.5342417955,
-0.5020661354,
0.3464921415,
0.1717680842,
-0.8145538568,
0.2310474664,
-0.5698207021,
0.3413783014,
0.7906493545,
0.2246469408,
-0.5405808091,
-0.222026661,
-0.219642058,
-0.6541212797,
0.6900541782,
0.015112116,
0.3923655152,
0.0377299935,
0.4200040698,
0.0752665401,
0.0132560749,
-0.6209577918,
-0.0781218931,
0.0456180461,
-0.3146196008,
-0.1246006638,
-0.0257374588,
-0.0867672339,
-0.3369822502,
0.6296204925,
-0.2532550693,
0.1289073974,
0.0553839728,
-0.0679501668,
-0.2441894561,
0.1904347539,
0.5797662139,
0.4636505544,
-0.1723333746,
-0.2517351508,
0.173843503,
-0.225202322,
0.0811032504,
0.1609595418,
-0.1341814995,
-0.070791252,
0.5549662709,
1.2359621525,
0.6868157387,
-0.426145643,
0.5088053346,
-0.2784040868,
-0.3716413975,
-0.2579679191,
0.2304813862,
0.3029194772,
0.4562165439,
0.1415216476,
-0.010860255,
-0.1376248002,
-0.2592208982,
-0.1341791302,
0.6516671777,
-0.010652056,
-0.2647547722,
0.438963294,
0.5125041008,
-0.3503251374,
0.4471795261,
-0.0613426492,
-0.2300238907,
0.2419571728,
0.5946456194,
0.6870583296,
-0.2973717153,
0.4210526645,
0.1074969172,
0.1831675768,
-0.255833447,
-0.1030537412,
-0.4011105001,
-0.7628367543,
-0.3537115157,
-0.745685935,
-0.3773083389,
0.2742838562,
-0.4887021482,
0.0349267051,
-0.6069368124,
0.2291973531,
0.0784014687,
0.4591126442,
-0.5627608299,
0.179870069,
0.1558107287,
0.8695818782,
-0.7095742226,
1.1412725449,
0.4680151045,
0.0352048129,
-0.9714571834,
0.0138339764,
-0.1571725607,
-0.2135248929,
0.4740359187,
0.0827200413,
-0.1347270906,
0.1884998083,
-0.2079622149,
-0.8435745239,
1.3457865715,
0.3860441148,
-0.9225671291,
-0.1146497279,
-0.0571689159,
0.52150172,
-0.3754431605,
0.1024666131,
0.4182618558,
0.1709152907,
-0.0008129176,
-0.8661335111,
-0.1330085993,
0.2842553556,
0.1218940541,
0.062998645,
-0.9308930635,
0.7762553692,
-0.2062640935,
-0.1350089461,
-0.0729186907,
0.758367002,
-0.0086061554,
0.4185643196,
0.4667757452,
0.2446081191,
0.8687775731,
0.035204947,
0.8843013644,
-0.045528315,
0.6819671392,
1.1546088457,
-0.4169537723,
0.7979840636,
0.241816327,
0.0405254103,
0.2650624812,
0.4465075731,
0.2469571978,
0.7454252839,
0.1003618166,
-0.7048864365,
-0.0807806477,
0.2173580527,
-0.2341093272,
0.6573563218,
0.2249264121,
-0.4679365754,
-0.4467558563,
0.3832006156,
-0.0253720637,
0.3240667582,
-0.3914118707,
0.9693935513,
-0.0468596444,
-0.250438571,
0.4514458776,
0.547331214,
1.0674167871,
-0.7955200672,
0.3049450815,
-0.4179384708,
0.3154375255,
-0.4801146686,
-0.0980271921,
0.3075367212,
-0.0956080556,
-0.2468812764,
-0.3962180912,
0.8549748063,
-0.3552483618,
-0.1766026467,
0.2843583822,
0.1005728915,
-0.4150553942,
0.0865154192,
-0.4721520543,
0.2549881041,
0.0583098941,
-0.6854644418,
0.8978185058,
0.1440556943,
-0.0445588306,
0.816383481,
0.6963707805,
0.0557944439,
-0.1374546438,
-0.1001388133,
0.8921355605,
-0.2966960073,
-0.5215672255,
-0.714193821,
0.0185445119,
0.0042545577,
-0.3832710981,
0.6918639541,
0.2263843417,
1.0778039694,
-0.1759155393,
0.7116529346,
0.0221953411,
0.4010573626,
-0.5498377681,
0.9159600139,
-0.2170006633,
0.2650190592,
-0.0698645189,
-0.5954269171,
-0.1765755564,
0.6846606135,
-0.5485681891,
-0.1828450412,
0.3398040533,
0.5902988911,
-0.2007567286,
0.447129935,
0.2792927921,
0.0191189591,
0.3228851557,
0.7775836587,
0.3569278121,
-0.1018526703,
0.1435156614,
-0.7527968287,
-0.253685087,
-0.4113180935,
-0.7567051649,
-1.024081111,
-0.5836941004,
-0.4128662348,
0.0256573334,
0.1968904287,
1.3135031462,
0.8575513363,
-0.772762239,
-0.0415556058,
-0.1919603348,
0.3387643099,
-0.2183116078,
-0.129223153,
0.1467143744,
-0.4473345578,
-0.48272717,
0.573287189,
0.2585372627,
-0.2474624217,
-0.0641451851,
-0.0806491524,
-0.092994839,
-0.0949826762,
0.7011684775,
0.5393621922,
-0.5379170775,
-0.5657216311,
-0.4308782816,
-0.2678579688,
-0.2782502174,
0.8729947805,
-0.8676399589,
0.2468430549,
0.5518526435,
0.9373294115,
0.3912293017,
0.0999628827,
0.380427599,
-1.0352526903,
0.3135636449,
0.2036327571,
0.0394842029,
0.2166659087,
-0.6542912126,
0.0645433217,
-0.0102403928,
-0.8257033825,
-0.8338617682,
0.2226506621,
-0.8196492791,
-0.1197374687,
0.9670698643,
-0.5633576512,
-0.0090645924,
-0.0403134786,
0.1180048138,
0.0860363543,
-0.2202505618,
0.8049897552,
0.4883454144,
-0.1860901266,
-0.077056475,
-0.5624192357,
0.5173789859,
0.2745957077,
-0.8237657547,
0.1483237892,
0.3015410304,
0.5474250913,
-0.1879944354,
0.6319699287,
0.3767619133,
-0.0548028089,
-0.4388563633,
-0.2021835297,
-0.6236908436,
-0.0813091695,
-0.5978581309,
0.3087774813,
0.0639412776,
-0.2558738291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13208v1
|
The Instruction Hierarchy: Training LLMs to Prioritize Privileged Instructions
| 2024-04-19T22:55:23 | 2024-04-19T22:55:23 |
Eric Wallace, Kai Xiao, Reimar Leike, Lilian Weng, Johannes Heidecke, Alex Beutel
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Today's LLMs are susceptible to prompt injections, jailbreaks, and other
attacks that allow adversaries to overwrite a model's original instructions
with their own malicious prompts. In this work, we argue that one of the
primary vulnerabilities underlying these attacks is that LLMs often consider
system prompts (e.g., text from an application developer) to be the same
priority as text from untrusted users and third parties. To address this, we
propose an instruction hierarchy that explicitly defines how models should
behave when instructions of different priorities conflict. We then propose a
data generation method to demonstrate this hierarchical instruction following
behavior, which teaches LLMs to selectively ignore lower-privileged
instructions. We apply this method to GPT-3.5, showing that it drastically
increases robustness -- even for attack types not seen during training -- while
imposing minimal degradations on standard capabilities.
|
[
-0.0683646053,
-0.6016462445,
0.5513714552,
-0.1168408468,
0.0150247328,
0.1237590536,
0.2999513149,
-0.270288378,
-0.2497083098,
0.5760673881,
-0.626175046,
-0.6354536414,
-0.7986684442,
-0.1761771441,
-0.2004428506,
1.16152215,
0.0709943697,
-0.1237624884,
-0.3263941705,
0.3214177787,
-0.5500712991,
-0.9681509733,
-0.5831087232,
-0.088597551,
0.404843837,
0.7130737305,
0.8627499342,
0.8155389428,
0.6253871322,
0.3302202523,
0.0277131014,
-0.1180822924,
-0.4461114705,
0.4333003163,
0.0398768783,
-0.392922163,
-0.8461209536,
-0.0600062832,
0.4021445215,
0.4394144118,
0.0402858667,
-0.0092639606,
0.2781325579,
0.5701006055,
-0.6850435734,
-0.1649283022,
-0.8478114009,
0.1435839683,
-0.18437922,
-0.5717419386,
-0.5631735921,
-0.2651900947,
0.057715863,
-0.3362771273,
0.2649777532,
0.0222819652,
0.6161655188,
0.2818545401,
-0.3797691166,
-0.0908764824,
-0.3499925733,
0.6613212228,
-0.232942149,
-0.0564537868,
0.4748578072,
0.1080269217,
-0.3186433911,
-0.3772160113,
0.1269730926,
-0.4148182571,
-0.0081317984,
0.0750452727,
-0.2769854665,
0.4020953178,
0.4542723596,
0.2230658531,
-0.5734446049,
0.4520003796,
-0.3365291953,
-0.1323060542,
0.3739064932,
0.4697874188,
0.3129054606,
-0.0573249757,
-0.7920873761,
0.1056162566,
-1.2072827816,
0.0759158209,
0.5131230354,
0.2557415068,
-0.0295016076,
0.4814678729,
-0.0895302072,
0.7026950121,
0.2596698701,
0.0108699827,
-0.0381585769,
0.067314133,
-0.5022545457,
0.2154304981,
0.5041596293,
0.4085273445,
-0.0953778774,
-0.2275952995,
-0.3550516367,
-0.144921124,
0.4402846396,
-0.7140559554,
-0.0897638649,
0.3294735849,
-0.2258989662,
-0.6738649607,
-0.0456095599,
-0.6344001889,
-0.6210616231,
-0.0173039269,
0.3184954822,
-0.289791584,
0.2910127342,
-0.0158833154,
0.0759654045,
0.2509498298,
0.2249774784,
-1.4382019043,
0.3912270069,
0.9199128151,
0.5087218285,
-0.2367368042,
-0.3341120481,
-0.7678453922,
0.5969583392,
-0.2153876275,
0.4961204827,
-0.5286076665,
-0.6245297194,
-0.0864078775,
-0.1549703479,
-0.0951252654,
-0.6686933041,
0.3783736229,
-0.6490659714,
-0.0254558753,
-0.3202228844,
-0.5379991531,
0.4180124998,
0.1610819399,
-0.2647460997,
0.8560500145,
0.0516600832,
-0.8190739751,
0.2343498021,
-0.5094571114,
-0.4293916225,
0.1146550104,
-0.2747429311,
-0.337539196,
-0.0722645819,
0.3072429299,
0.5993013382,
-0.1161717921,
-0.0192267243,
-0.1537680626,
-0.4228660762,
-0.0943599939,
-0.3906612098,
0.6969480515,
0.1112057492,
-0.4607530236,
0.294336766,
-0.5851575732,
0.0610326007,
0.0816567987,
-0.3998244405,
-0.3362199664,
0.0165350214,
-0.7487161756,
-0.1268540025,
0.5018948913,
-0.0718799382,
0.600943327,
-0.263728559,
0.3476701081,
1.2607917786,
0.22610493,
0.5383812785,
-0.4673710763,
0.5043982863,
0.1555058062,
0.661817193,
-0.0220997445,
-0.6012391448,
-0.6534584761,
-0.1336070001,
-0.2363592833,
0.9321393967,
-0.6358767152,
0.4280550778,
-0.1488823742,
-0.2831381261,
-0.19538109,
0.2722609043,
0.6099004745,
0.5177442431,
0.4295760095,
-0.0488301553,
-0.4402002692,
-0.9440718293,
-0.1270702034,
-0.4141470194,
-0.1498338878,
-0.0048176581,
0.2227302939,
-0.2136129588,
0.4881640077,
-0.4257136881,
0.173861742,
-0.1357146949,
0.0405167267,
-0.0624312051,
0.7710550427,
0.3632841706,
-0.4476609826,
-0.065614678,
-0.2131330967,
-0.7342557907,
-0.3509408832,
0.0495658144,
-0.291800797,
-0.0226245634,
0.7842721343,
-0.4565636516,
0.3320274353,
0.2287411392,
0.0364899337,
0.3499171436,
-0.2265551686,
0.1537506282,
-1.0800147057,
-0.4158235192,
-0.1961464137,
0.0382806696,
-0.7947080731,
0.2192221731,
-0.0086463727,
-0.2233232409,
-0.4851878583,
0.2781544626,
-0.3847401738,
-0.2676805854,
0.0127275158,
-0.1440008432,
-0.1435629576,
0.3188715279,
-0.1225614101,
1.0126799345,
0.6947388649,
-0.7669295669,
0.1860115081,
-0.0188321993,
0.0324301273,
0.5824252367,
-0.620722115,
0.3326700926,
0.0123949833,
-0.1857216209,
-0.8393352032,
-0.2603635192,
0.4543224275,
-0.2004365772,
0.6251295805,
-0.4315982759,
-0.3804130852,
-0.2774570882,
-0.4469347596,
-0.0069236336,
0.6448412538,
-0.5406743884,
0.1587984115,
0.3594932556,
-0.1254339069,
-0.9469023347,
-0.4998929501,
-0.040059533,
-0.3994782269,
-0.4611382484,
0.3692355156,
-0.1004973873,
-0.1778855026,
-0.2697345614,
-0.2549924254,
-0.1475955695,
0.5354585052,
0.5015307665,
0.5779180527,
-0.1249463782,
-0.1785416603,
0.0357661992,
-0.1316279173,
0.1701702029,
-0.3101371527,
0.2271599174,
-0.0799280033,
-0.737411499,
-0.5314326882,
0.3945955336,
0.4637874961,
0.0907314867,
0.4154891074,
0.065839909,
-0.1257337481,
-0.0002868134,
-0.1538396031,
-0.2060861737,
-0.593316853,
0.3671646416,
-0.2511073947,
-0.7762959003,
0.2558325827,
0.0548033305,
0.3594691157,
0.0217482038,
0.3706198931,
-0.092680119,
1.2199549675,
0.7118803859,
-0.3222164214,
0.6522208452,
-0.0769442394,
-0.018845195,
-0.6146316528,
-0.1256808639,
-0.4158325493,
-0.2233512104,
-0.6836620569,
-0.2431955189,
0.3914902508,
0.1279792786,
-0.650092423,
0.2868901491,
-0.7199994326,
0.8196914792,
0.6634312272,
0.1726549417,
0.1216556653,
0.1759290248,
-0.1934337467,
0.172202453,
-0.7670505047,
-0.8172383904,
1.0101333857,
0.4257653058,
0.9725771546,
0.1209956408,
1.2253440619,
0.2563687563,
0.4685572982,
-0.5877340436,
0.8642766476,
-0.2040299773,
-0.4417125583,
0.0060524535,
-0.4860015213,
-1.0161783695,
0.0860911459,
0.1955016702,
-0.8173754811,
-0.0464598984,
0.3093463778,
-0.6436123848,
0.3665009439,
-1.1063739061,
0.6939710975,
-0.2150916159,
-0.4923076034,
0.2601470649,
-0.7413476706,
0.4018906057,
0.304251641,
-0.1302088797,
0.0800718963,
-0.23199597,
0.4832184315,
-0.4882900119,
1.1741709709,
-0.2941430211,
-0.254727006,
0.0651776642,
0.0944965035,
0.4767338336,
0.0802525878,
0.113589935,
-0.2645566165,
-0.4167435765,
-0.6042253375,
-0.4068186283,
0.7332676053,
-0.9378774166,
-1.3476647139,
-0.31678316,
-0.5348528028,
-0.421328783,
-0.0463276654,
0.488428086,
0.3230768442,
-0.0107482597,
-0.0951485932,
0.9396622181,
-0.0886525884,
0.321272552,
0.3169695437,
0.2855321169,
-0.1917486638,
0.7670245767,
0.0754074752,
0.7279629111,
0.4312588573,
-0.066851601,
0.1369875968,
-0.7658295631,
-0.5885639787,
-0.4438639581,
-0.8667126894,
-0.3945052028,
-0.4073035121,
-0.4584414065,
-0.3370536864,
-0.5592653751,
-0.0043229358,
-0.2787288725,
-0.3771516085,
-0.3299642503,
0.2867240608,
0.7743620872,
0.1658069938,
0.5675247312,
-0.8091371655,
0.2260965407,
0.7420634031,
0.0355037376,
-0.1123558059,
-0.4542902112,
0.0285843462,
-0.1557234824,
-0.7891769409,
-0.8448365927,
-0.0099600116,
-0.2081978917,
0.8127222061,
0.301196605,
-0.0111591695,
0.4926124513,
-0.5353569388,
0.8326336145,
0.0543708131,
-0.9008997083,
0.9172142148,
-0.3573678136,
0.1292823702,
0.4418637753,
0.5311716199,
-0.0121050095,
-0.7396278977,
-0.7728896737,
-0.9941810966,
0.6798356771,
0.1150898859,
0.2457224429,
-0.1425794661,
0.3352597058,
-0.1231308207,
0.1301915944,
-0.6577486992,
-0.3628875315,
-0.0909483135,
-0.1076662168,
0.4106561542,
-0.3863245845,
-0.3485155106,
0.0089477031,
0.3672991693,
0.2023293376,
0.2810326219,
-0.0197858308,
0.0366205573,
-0.0355022885,
0.572691977,
0.5332139134,
0.2884882689,
-0.2128537744,
0.4626857638,
0.2024974078,
-0.7774435878,
0.4593094885,
-0.0595504828,
-0.306953609,
-0.5656260252,
0.53584975,
0.7316951156,
0.343311578,
-0.204559058,
0.4282427132,
0.0583641753,
-0.1797713041,
0.2375713736,
0.6682138443,
-0.184178412,
0.1661150753,
0.3180254698,
0.2950802743,
0.021838339,
-0.5061221123,
0.3397787809,
0.3062490225,
-0.2007159591,
-0.22294195,
0.5535035133,
0.2110613137,
-0.0341028497,
0.2680856586,
-0.1171780601,
-0.6048509479,
0.7828717232,
0.524785161,
0.8890911937,
-0.669374764,
0.1351671368,
-0.0128787085,
0.6421629786,
0.0259299371,
0.3313966393,
0.1128219962,
-0.5297761559,
0.1362212151,
-0.1535596251,
-0.6951703429,
0.2577630281,
-0.6529883742,
0.2045123279,
-0.9246590734,
-0.1417703778,
-0.072942175,
-0.1631820649,
-0.2975873053,
-0.017959509,
0.2555360794,
0.5941722393,
-0.7039700747,
0.7326564789,
0.5003662705,
-0.1960952282,
-0.6000807881,
0.3768809736,
0.2253953665,
-1.0904735327,
0.854264617,
0.22571069,
-0.1721887439,
0.0165814534,
-0.687256217,
-0.5967430472,
1.0673066378,
0.575953424,
-0.3183084726,
0.0326463543,
0.0654315278,
0.223231405,
-0.3898730874,
-0.0386077464,
0.3656844199,
0.26170367,
0.1628914773,
-0.4197278917,
0.0956072211,
-0.1152880266,
-0.0973211974,
0.1445634514,
-0.4172346294,
0.9728063941,
-0.4968260527,
-0.2862060964,
0.1034835652,
0.4115142822,
0.4258412421,
0.1519569159,
0.3292381465,
0.4713463783,
0.7977955341,
-0.0319320075,
1.0934135914,
-0.1926737875,
-0.2253950536,
1.1814497709,
-0.4981316328,
0.6987493038,
0.3805859685,
0.0306448862,
0.1932592541,
0.8114019632,
0.0623048656,
0.6571578383,
0.2695415914,
-0.3799973428,
-0.135961026,
0.132447958,
-0.5988764763,
0.0297161993,
0.3066238463,
-0.4017938673,
-0.3327506185,
-0.1051895618,
0.2327216864,
-0.1910628676,
-0.5718590617,
0.8182727098,
-0.1169344634,
-0.5419570804,
1.0415666103,
-0.0890590996,
0.4857174754,
-0.5693955421,
0.141334638,
-0.1623476595,
0.0108522894,
-0.2835983038,
-0.8813023567,
0.0255426187,
0.311416924,
-0.3661031723,
-0.3898128867,
0.6474662423,
-0.0686174333,
-0.1192683205,
0.235842526,
0.30856511,
-0.0525604114,
0.3104842603,
-0.8470506072,
-0.0376097225,
-0.1006338298,
-0.3333782256,
0.6255850196,
0.4477711916,
-0.3276432157,
0.7160624862,
0.4875613153,
-0.0305838156,
0.2290391475,
0.2677186131,
1.1726170778,
-0.3272209167,
-0.3205688,
-1.0821644068,
0.3290016651,
-0.1717485487,
-0.0766250119,
0.7408139706,
0.4161089063,
0.7716050148,
0.0808460116,
0.9063356519,
0.1535424143,
0.0843510106,
-0.7813170552,
0.4106167853,
-0.1787370741,
0.9224873781,
-0.2076899111,
-0.465100497,
-0.2458601147,
0.3339851201,
-0.6798784733,
0.2257826924,
0.5888372064,
0.9090158939,
-0.0616013221,
0.06414105,
0.3003711998,
0.0889210626,
0.2596890926,
0.888741076,
1.1438326836,
-0.3124456108,
0.3907491863,
-0.1044611484,
-0.4607322514,
-0.1925178766,
-0.9012448788,
-1.0326833725,
-0.2016480267,
-0.1170071959,
-0.2277945876,
0.4019515514,
0.8681086898,
0.6514336467,
-0.621322453,
-0.1832733899,
-0.1199217066,
0.4110231996,
-0.0994282514,
-0.1274750531,
0.1935549378,
-0.5546015501,
-0.2888971567,
0.5693204403,
0.284705162,
0.5323269367,
-0.1036558077,
0.0251823366,
0.2634414434,
-0.0344231874,
0.4408867657,
0.1051234379,
-0.3989613354,
-0.4589993656,
0.032153111,
-0.4905714989,
0.1134529114,
0.8992471099,
-0.3957144916,
0.0284710173,
0.3197292984,
0.6343242526,
-0.2062447965,
-0.0628489926,
0.579392612,
-1.1378645897,
0.0834694654,
0.2078195512,
0.2495370358,
0.2535649538,
-0.9000380039,
0.2508365512,
0.1614181995,
-0.5784823298,
-0.821387887,
0.4441862702,
-0.62914294,
-0.145171538,
1.019777298,
-0.3142993748,
-0.2998103499,
-0.2042493969,
-0.248594895,
-0.1155413836,
-0.4122135341,
0.7566098571,
0.4673093259,
-0.1099026874,
-0.0179191176,
-0.8994891644,
0.7600790858,
0.3545842767,
-0.9671804309,
0.4749549031,
0.3578944206,
0.115545705,
-0.1262594163,
0.6108054519,
-0.2029413879,
0.2521027029,
-0.1482698619,
-0.2817507088,
-0.0457099117,
-0.5630568862,
-0.3368153274,
0.3285175264,
0.1842937022,
-0.3327037692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13192v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13192v1
|
Heterogeneous Subgraph Transformer for Fake News Detection
| 2024-04-19T21:39:37 | 2024-04-19T21:39:37 |
Yuchen Zhang, Xiaoxiao Ma, Jia Wu, Jian Yang, Hao Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fake news is pervasive on social media, inflicting substantial harm on public
discourse and societal well-being. We investigate the explicit structural
information and textual features of news pieces by constructing a heterogeneous
graph concerning the relations among news topics, entities, and content.
Through our study, we reveal that fake news can be effectively detected in
terms of the atypical heterogeneous subgraphs centered on them, which
encapsulate the essential semantics and intricate relations between news
elements. However, suffering from the heterogeneity, exploring such
heterogeneous subgraphs remains an open problem. To bridge the gap, this work
proposes a heterogeneous subgraph transformer (HeteroSGT) to exploit subgraphs
in our constructed heterogeneous graph. In HeteroSGT, we first employ a
pre-trained language model to derive both word-level and sentence-level
semantics. Then the random walk with restart (RWR) is applied to extract
subgraphs centered on each news, which are further fed to our proposed subgraph
Transformer to quantify the authenticity. Extensive experiments on five
real-world datasets demonstrate the superior performance of HeteroSGT over five
baselines. Further case and ablation studies validate our motivation and
demonstrate that performance improvement stems from our specially designed
components.
|
[
-0.3694722652,
-1.3386862278,
0.5623468757,
0.2486400902,
-0.4737757146,
0.3336044848,
0.1570038199,
-0.4729486406,
0.6723750234,
0.347266078,
-0.535974741,
-0.492982775,
-0.5910230875,
-0.1034345478,
-0.6380809546,
0.9030305147,
0.0108775795,
-0.2123078555,
-0.0364682488,
-0.1165804267,
-0.1217069328,
-0.0901309326,
-0.1811833084,
-0.5407865047,
0.4256789982,
0.1605550796,
0.9160260558,
0.6084527373,
0.0138355326,
0.2711224854,
0.1823398471,
0.1724870503,
-0.5772814155,
-0.3230307698,
-0.2081014216,
-0.177586779,
-0.2274236232,
0.3230730593,
0.7006801367,
0.4256319404,
-0.0176309943,
0.1818749905,
-0.408310771,
0.2082401365,
-0.3262339234,
-0.0484588072,
-0.6701517701,
0.2720050514,
-0.4999539554,
-0.4499531686,
-0.3907001913,
-0.5282791853,
-0.1773573309,
-0.7138282657,
0.4802895188,
0.3223494291,
1.4609280825,
0.1326642036,
-0.3237411976,
0.0856455117,
-0.7390190363,
0.327411294,
-0.4582200944,
0.6218723655,
0.0248944778,
0.608972013,
-0.0368780755,
-1.0532312393,
-0.8870069385,
-0.1243314594,
-0.3745777309,
0.2259967625,
-0.6359772682,
-0.3773961067,
0.1804921925,
0.4151762724,
-0.6067413688,
0.1898944825,
-0.2309216708,
-0.6966784596,
0.2252192646,
-0.0626279637,
0.6108602285,
-0.3984675109,
-0.5062538385,
0.1131490916,
-0.4563684165,
-0.3088187575,
0.8874338865,
0.368730396,
-0.0234760698,
0.5424202681,
-0.2555327415,
0.404450953,
0.2025960535,
-0.3093764782,
0.6797520518,
-0.2221067548,
-0.0710667223,
0.2822219431,
0.632774055,
0.0995532498,
0.2516595125,
-0.2665706575,
-0.2138390839,
0.3658535779,
0.3898094594,
-0.6324974298,
-0.3166011274,
0.0066566211,
-0.7657375932,
-0.4415397644,
0.2262057662,
-0.7649671435,
-0.3270064294,
-0.1093278229,
0.3115513623,
-0.5047323704,
-0.4295791984,
0.008045774,
-0.4665391445,
-0.0184902549,
0.3222721219,
-0.1265169531,
0.1019255891,
0.3826010227,
0.6652548313,
0.0614846125,
-0.3704195321,
-0.7592691183,
-0.0309239514,
-0.2884575129,
1.071547389,
-0.4318368137,
0.0068819951,
0.0570302941,
0.1777806133,
0.1311696917,
-0.3173062503,
0.6192574501,
-0.6709768176,
0.4205608666,
-0.079972215,
-0.536850214,
0.1791901588,
0.5594810247,
-0.8637737632,
0.9954349399,
0.3823251724,
-1.102101326,
0.3710643053,
-0.4551517963,
-0.8160428405,
0.2676351666,
-0.2005018145,
-0.6894705892,
-0.056457568,
0.3125159442,
0.189003557,
0.0857542977,
-0.0285516717,
-0.1017174795,
-0.3757961392,
-0.0253730286,
-0.6815415025,
0.7604186535,
0.1131101251,
-0.2706304789,
0.0573017076,
-0.7088218927,
-0.1802521795,
0.227007553,
-0.286832124,
-0.4096009731,
-0.1772852391,
0.1448813379,
0.1521297097,
0.0065027769,
-0.9091313481,
-0.0230046287,
-0.0514518432,
0.0702871233,
0.6093643904,
0.1601718515,
0.4109123647,
-0.2904573083,
0.3619839251,
0.1488886625,
0.1963237226,
-0.1337168068,
-0.5395201445,
-0.3601950705,
-0.2839818001,
0.4154184759,
0.6169932485,
-0.9290295243,
0.3163560629,
-0.505124867,
-0.5342150331,
-0.5407581925,
-0.272685051,
0.2133344412,
0.6903035045,
0.5997874141,
0.0456852093,
-0.5621377826,
-0.9667977095,
-0.7393398881,
0.0434799381,
0.1172430813,
-0.0075771422,
0.3790903091,
-0.426520735,
1.1938867569,
-0.4121560752,
-0.3520239294,
-0.1380764395,
0.3416288793,
-0.0081340345,
0.2522565424,
0.6605153084,
-1.1793547869,
-0.4779187143,
0.0382699892,
-0.5556476712,
-0.1611471921,
-0.1205326691,
0.1099956408,
0.3235774636,
0.7734943628,
-0.5219498277,
0.6646655202,
0.5764752626,
-0.350708127,
0.7027736306,
0.051591821,
0.2582275271,
-0.7792379856,
-0.2346329987,
0.1549252719,
-0.6583281755,
-0.593345046,
-0.4230852127,
0.0066631655,
-0.0642224774,
-0.4601871371,
0.3142044842,
-0.3298844397,
-0.1945719421,
-0.3028066456,
0.030950129,
-0.0072474312,
0.1566340327,
-0.1290110499,
0.2398593277,
0.1695710868,
-0.0757464468,
0.5127164125,
-0.0174903441,
-0.4755949676,
0.5487194061,
-0.5701852441,
0.0176629592,
-0.406234771,
0.8429324031,
-1.0402423143,
-0.4548916817,
0.4097694755,
-0.6310935616,
-0.0442946702,
-0.1952641159,
-0.6852132082,
-0.5761318207,
-0.0693062097,
0.0663369894,
0.4924371243,
-0.6612132788,
1.0298433304,
0.2390815318,
0.4871747792,
-0.3810441494,
-0.7827624679,
-0.0342621394,
0.0166336987,
-0.6888138652,
0.5768746138,
0.4332495034,
-0.1631140709,
0.6817913055,
-0.3805041313,
0.1050220355,
-0.1784178913,
0.330058217,
0.0827872679,
-0.375739783,
0.1096462831,
0.1747297347,
-0.2699852586,
-0.2107572258,
-0.3314144909,
0.752864778,
-0.0922192484,
-0.4610472023,
-0.6057302952,
0.2569380701,
0.6741507649,
-0.1749500483,
0.9111061692,
0.9703332782,
-0.604855299,
-0.3198572099,
-0.484985888,
-0.1064591035,
-0.4347929657,
0.3892988861,
-0.3299610615,
-0.680210948,
0.3891363442,
-0.1695833951,
-0.2514870465,
0.4300032556,
0.3421722949,
0.1178921983,
0.9113094807,
0.6990754008,
-0.3308497369,
0.5573587418,
0.1545758247,
0.494913131,
-0.0806133002,
-0.2399802208,
-0.3632243276,
-0.2826092839,
-0.5792401433,
-0.374409914,
0.3393077552,
-0.3230428994,
-0.1322116107,
0.3689471483,
-0.2873770893,
0.5874325633,
0.3610325754,
0.1902723759,
0.5451955199,
0.3449611962,
0.1360378861,
0.0059685134,
-0.7560269833,
-0.4502039552,
0.4408404827,
0.6510050893,
0.9184625149,
-0.1179283559,
0.4353073537,
0.5154253244,
0.6499819756,
-0.5550829172,
0.2578475177,
-0.1912148744,
-0.4218172133,
-0.4077376723,
-0.5051699877,
-0.6961472034,
0.3127985597,
-0.3655482531,
-0.5164691806,
0.1020280272,
0.2679299414,
-0.0186543707,
0.5561432242,
-0.631519258,
0.6593356133,
0.0990754068,
0.0975474492,
-0.0531117991,
-0.5992647409,
0.3803712428,
-0.0275749415,
0.436921984,
-0.0121114571,
0.4831714928,
0.3945731521,
-0.188752681,
0.8208912611,
-0.1773314178,
-0.0778071582,
0.1252449155,
-0.0024839144,
0.6741627455,
0.1973347515,
0.1713706255,
0.230883047,
-0.5044249296,
-0.4597848058,
-0.4222148061,
0.5972020626,
-0.6434428096,
-0.3018543124,
-0.3285394907,
-0.5848883986,
-0.2149940878,
0.494117856,
0.7055741549,
0.3647450805,
-0.4286384583,
0.0391909145,
0.6953607202,
-0.134422034,
0.1283517927,
0.3420521915,
-0.327595681,
0.0165713616,
1.1078227758,
0.2628545761,
0.105219692,
0.3040306568,
0.2707716525,
-0.1972740293,
-0.2928577065,
-0.3297250271,
0.2082543224,
-0.6014202833,
-0.10768345,
-0.8858447075,
-0.3523706794,
-0.7581338286,
-0.1101481095,
-0.63802737,
-0.1743221134,
-0.0387931056,
-0.2598002851,
0.0132810557,
0.4081171751,
-0.0672392398,
0.1684582978,
-0.6107469201,
0.822644949,
0.3741235733,
0.2343550175,
-0.2760861218,
-0.3780786097,
-0.1233067885,
0.1396772414,
0.0647929385,
-0.7621969581,
0.1840958744,
-0.2776069641,
0.6700894237,
0.2911550403,
0.2302801162,
0.4764826596,
-0.5471996069,
0.6075047255,
0.1525002122,
-0.8805772662,
0.3538532257,
-0.4679943025,
-0.043942634,
0.130981341,
0.5477722883,
-0.5146811604,
-0.4484353065,
-0.8486025333,
-0.6784857512,
0.4955299795,
0.2261361182,
0.1755896807,
0.0768670961,
0.104750216,
0.0100954454,
0.2085231692,
-0.9714866877,
-0.30655846,
-0.947432518,
-0.0457759388,
0.1931134909,
0.013791983,
-0.3432548344,
-0.0474062786,
0.6647598743,
-0.2075948119,
0.3645062745,
0.1881034821,
-0.1090074331,
-0.2611352503,
0.0297385398,
0.3539319038,
0.389916867,
-0.0266813729,
0.3698996007,
-0.0629588664,
-0.5848711729,
-0.1582238823,
0.3386995494,
-0.2112368792,
0.3588039875,
0.7335222363,
0.7547119856,
-0.2364990413,
-0.3098396659,
0.6727949977,
-0.0493180789,
-0.3256669641,
-0.1737399846,
-0.2600483298,
0.0294184424,
0.3398801386,
0.6307207346,
0.0653334334,
-0.021039322,
-0.9496789575,
0.334787637,
0.2197927535,
-0.5091845989,
-0.2312415242,
0.3912951648,
-0.0303822774,
-0.3874357641,
0.5724582672,
-0.2153682262,
-0.8939729929,
0.5705345869,
0.9457135201,
0.3869305551,
-0.05548729,
0.6581876874,
-0.1429758221,
0.6968307495,
-0.0516309887,
-0.2136366367,
0.4313346148,
-1.1423281431,
-0.1853397936,
-0.5109998584,
-0.1201064438,
0.276682198,
-0.2799445391,
0.1331607401,
-0.298286289,
0.2522635758,
0.1237573251,
-0.1338136196,
-0.2320368588,
0.4795724452,
0.1333954036,
0.9525622725,
-1.264786005,
0.7973557711,
0.5018495917,
-0.2745502591,
-0.8372092247,
0.4845567048,
0.0129284477,
-0.7229204774,
0.2886309028,
0.0709457546,
-0.0596327297,
0.1545102596,
-0.6469942331,
-0.36726439,
0.9508701563,
0.5550575852,
-0.3003135622,
0.0379947461,
0.2894379199,
0.5347878933,
-0.368394196,
-0.1613218337,
0.3639603257,
0.7446103692,
0.0569296367,
-0.5486701131,
0.222272262,
-0.1645801663,
-0.1186407506,
0.2982383966,
-0.640451014,
1.1134234667,
0.3091540337,
-0.3957969844,
-0.3786281943,
0.8274312615,
0.041939076,
0.5867922902,
0.8071827888,
0.6334959269,
0.773283124,
-0.1367808282,
1.1653734446,
0.1243625805,
0.4220922887,
0.9833821058,
-0.1290696859,
0.0279366355,
0.3901899159,
0.3162140846,
0.9475983381,
0.3081374764,
-0.0759609267,
0.4866299629,
0.2600971758,
-0.0640032068,
-0.3486924469,
-0.1504236907,
-0.3560898602,
0.2404039949,
0.2240972817,
-0.2906716466,
-0.641125083,
0.3726300001,
0.195329681,
0.4724300504,
-0.1555302292,
-0.0262969732,
-0.3200205266,
-0.3277338147,
-0.022604106,
0.2972331047,
0.654253006,
-0.5158450603,
-0.050865151,
-0.2629515529,
0.0162273161,
-0.4973444939,
-0.5946311355,
0.4792109728,
-0.3152202964,
-0.2776010036,
-0.392930001,
1.3360301256,
-0.2366910577,
-0.1561295688,
0.2382990271,
0.5201280713,
-0.158953771,
-0.2040516436,
-0.3262171745,
0.2575406134,
-0.125484392,
-0.4996918142,
0.1555298418,
0.6982639432,
-0.2877882421,
0.3757641315,
0.8517248034,
-0.1156038493,
0.136522904,
0.2208773047,
0.9773689508,
-0.340775907,
-0.680618763,
-0.5940034986,
0.282582134,
-0.375703007,
-0.3180671036,
1.1357250214,
0.637106359,
0.8072907329,
0.0621744357,
0.8806297779,
-0.284661144,
0.5714675188,
-0.4746105969,
0.7729479671,
-0.4209830165,
0.1513368934,
-0.3277482986,
-0.6464202404,
-0.2540310025,
0.5091798902,
-0.2630057931,
-0.2427861989,
0.655138731,
0.6094022989,
-0.5508009195,
0.1119893566,
0.1305213124,
0.4041020572,
0.4705850184,
-0.0622215271,
0.7983990312,
-0.4835137427,
0.5258458257,
-0.0969029143,
-0.176421389,
-0.257093668,
-0.8859398961,
-0.8379998803,
-0.4007582366,
-0.4406192601,
-0.8303218484,
0.0358175598,
0.4344645739,
0.6588870883,
-0.3400127888,
0.4208312929,
-0.3725869656,
0.4036319554,
-0.1367461532,
-0.3488332331,
0.3460711837,
0.0288863722,
-0.6255003214,
0.3624677956,
0.133880347,
0.0579058267,
-0.2278407961,
0.1073102653,
-0.293872714,
0.2897494137,
0.3288531899,
0.3008751571,
-0.2542478144,
-0.7149472833,
-0.0791325122,
-0.2507030666,
-0.0447735339,
0.9104958177,
-1.07320261,
-0.0661965385,
0.5427569747,
0.5111239552,
0.6800453067,
0.2698366344,
0.1091230586,
-1.0554051399,
0.3335338533,
0.2003373653,
0.1851491779,
0.1787204593,
-0.5811378956,
0.318151027,
0.8797985911,
-0.1143766865,
-0.9985792041,
0.4217894077,
-0.972027123,
-0.5936760902,
1.1024490595,
0.1194953918,
-0.4766192436,
-0.3999883235,
-0.1489747018,
0.5002647042,
-0.2665578425,
0.5804896951,
0.3817578852,
-0.044057928,
0.0629750118,
-0.29163903,
0.1990828365,
-0.0861425847,
-0.9067025781,
-0.4619689584,
0.4946642518,
0.4992170632,
0.6083373427,
0.91707021,
-0.206528604,
0.1973879933,
0.3395385444,
-0.2771313488,
-0.2325601429,
-0.4249926209,
0.2323272377,
0.5085588694,
-0.9057872891,
-0.2270245105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13163v1
|
A national longitudinal dataset of skills taught in U.S. higher education curricula
| 2024-04-19T20:14:15 | 2024-04-19T20:14:15 |
Alireza Javadian Sabet, Sarah H. Bana, Renzhe Yu, Morgan R. Frank
|
econ.GN
|
econ.GN, cs.CL, q-fin.EC
|
Higher education plays a critical role in driving an innovative economy by
equipping students with knowledge and skills demanded by the workforce. While
researchers and practitioners have developed data systems to track detailed
occupational skills, such as those established by the U.S. Department of Labor
(DOL), much less effort has been made to document skill development in higher
education at a similar granularity. Here, we fill this gap by presenting a
longitudinal dataset of skills inferred from over three million course syllabi
taught at nearly three thousand U.S. higher education institutions. To
construct this dataset, we apply natural language processing to extract from
course descriptions detailed workplace activities (DWAs) used by the DOL to
describe occupations. We then aggregate these DWAs to create skill profiles for
institutions and academic majors. Our dataset offers a large-scale
representation of college-educated workers and their role in the economy. To
showcase the utility of this dataset, we use it to 1) compare the similarity of
skills taught and skills in the workforce according to the US Bureau of Labor
Statistics, 2) estimate gender differences in acquired skills based on
enrollment data, 3) depict temporal trends in the skills taught in social
science curricula, and 4) connect college majors' skill distinctiveness to
salary differences of graduates. Overall, this dataset can enable new research
on the source of skills in the context of workforce development and provide
actionable insights for shaping the future of higher education to meet evolving
labor demands especially in the face of new technologies.
|
[
0.0252991412,
-0.9922555685,
0.3363732398,
-0.089624621,
0.2602702975,
0.4294995964,
0.0029169726,
-0.2961595953,
0.1420816183,
0.5238208175,
-0.5490133762,
-0.5261006951,
-0.2997440398,
-0.0613028109,
-0.302513361,
0.9941862226,
0.4788187742,
-0.1502887309,
-0.4163600206,
-0.0646196455,
-0.7692273855,
-0.3027856052,
-0.5151974559,
-0.4960535169,
0.5237434506,
0.5057941079,
0.7458006144,
0.5537648797,
0.4555899501,
0.1845958978,
0.0725434497,
-0.1060057059,
-0.5434987545,
-0.1969578415,
0.074114427,
-0.3817406297,
-0.6925082803,
0.2346934676,
0.8513688445,
1.3509676456,
-0.072700873,
0.5163214207,
0.159069702,
0.7671692967,
-0.417624563,
0.5567439198,
-0.2604136467,
-0.1422954053,
-0.5823553205,
-0.0785958692,
-0.3867525756,
-0.7092424631,
0.2288206667,
-0.6182468534,
0.3438590169,
-0.4402966201,
0.4702786505,
-0.0841338709,
-0.6449161172,
0.1677057594,
-0.4583082795,
0.8587855697,
-0.459554404,
0.5641921759,
0.2026969641,
0.0479664356,
-0.1666062027,
-0.6230624914,
-0.1489504725,
0.0907072797,
-0.1482259631,
0.1168018654,
0.3055130839,
-0.2224051803,
0.173702836,
0.4998338223,
-0.6930458546,
0.3597402573,
-0.9576551318,
-0.0058700382,
0.831182003,
0.7360979915,
0.0762472674,
0.3581284285,
-0.045409251,
-0.4524092376,
-0.7565637231,
0.4597800076,
0.509203434,
0.3359479904,
0.0257604793,
0.3904625177,
-0.3282672763,
0.6872135401,
-0.3722268343,
-0.3158259094,
0.2262736857,
-0.0069996999,
0.0799705833,
-0.1055299714,
0.3487751484,
0.1152106002,
0.0776230991,
-0.3263647854,
0.1571921706,
0.1359705329,
0.2696836889,
-0.2868417501,
-0.1394657046,
-0.2895150781,
-0.3339887559,
-0.2407159507,
0.029329231,
-0.8172349334,
-0.4743407369,
-0.4898845851,
0.0512252674,
0.0002396735,
0.0066826819,
-0.0783664733,
-0.2567184269,
0.2305787951,
-0.0334719531,
-0.9710012078,
0.3576237261,
0.7982645631,
0.8091695309,
-0.3469762504,
-0.4609052241,
-0.2959426343,
0.0478379466,
-0.201474458,
0.3010779619,
-0.6561513543,
-0.2654951513,
0.4883343279,
0.1389998049,
-0.0604062527,
-0.4040739238,
0.1691925675,
-0.6345797777,
0.1350035965,
-0.3334191442,
-0.6223814487,
-0.3032121956,
0.0355531126,
-0.751357913,
1.224588871,
0.5955483913,
-0.5356637836,
0.7335077524,
-0.8129200339,
-0.4300840497,
0.2339994907,
-0.4773800373,
-0.408212781,
-0.1681366712,
-0.226962924,
0.5919536352,
0.0000737555,
0.7505933642,
-0.228301242,
-0.4965913296,
0.177365914,
-0.4339585304,
1.2764714956,
-0.1732847244,
-0.2292649001,
-0.2811426818,
-0.6246527433,
-0.329880029,
-0.0398665629,
-0.4835960567,
-0.125516355,
-0.1794350296,
-0.1502680629,
-0.0317322835,
0.3629435897,
-0.3478835821,
0.2441981882,
-0.1923893392,
0.1667291373,
0.7239176631,
-0.119562678,
0.4945703745,
-0.2670786977,
0.360611856,
-0.3525079787,
0.1442846507,
-0.0452587977,
-0.5499569774,
-0.3828216195,
0.0462222919,
-0.3277134299,
0.3712152541,
-0.1414241195,
0.2053473741,
-0.0031763481,
-0.7136532068,
-0.4259474874,
0.1113368645,
0.2919533551,
0.6987057924,
0.5743329525,
-0.2284599543,
-0.4239391088,
-0.6436051726,
-0.4546580911,
-0.0295512509,
-0.1128868312,
-0.0284046251,
0.3979334831,
0.0512684509,
0.8587888479,
-0.9108252525,
-0.4324450791,
0.0261813048,
0.4454912245,
0.3690030277,
0.32781896,
0.3349448442,
-0.318198055,
-0.1400306523,
0.0104425838,
-1.106402874,
-0.079168953,
-0.193662852,
-0.3425602913,
-0.1580763608,
0.3767288327,
-0.0245427769,
0.5371556878,
0.0425504819,
-0.8232238889,
0.6039736867,
-0.0947343335,
0.065912284,
-0.424877733,
0.341199398,
-0.0212934241,
0.3098778725,
-0.5622755289,
-0.2548318207,
-0.0388359725,
-0.1543323845,
-0.0470068604,
0.7895893455,
-0.4330796301,
-0.3725423515,
0.0467397273,
-0.0059504495,
0.0448267348,
0.2887977958,
0.0520861708,
0.7305685878,
0.6139888167,
-0.4372343123,
0.1173224822,
0.623010695,
-0.3450709581,
0.7361855507,
-0.3482481539,
-0.0035773949,
-0.08742778,
0.1226147264,
-0.0780503228,
-0.2125988156,
-0.4330774844,
0.0246852469,
0.060593605,
0.1343367994,
0.1443377137,
-0.530198276,
-0.1215360686,
-0.0838065669,
0.4823370874,
-0.1334688812,
0.3010773659,
0.4602819383,
-0.4646535814,
-0.929092288,
-0.4671742618,
-0.1025806069,
-0.20074898,
-0.4719511867,
0.5682736635,
0.3152902424,
-0.2512924969,
-0.0439719521,
-0.0743932351,
-0.5944417119,
0.4390221834,
0.339088589,
0.7527365685,
-0.2953799069,
0.0316948928,
-0.0107013481,
-0.1173183098,
0.3294306099,
-0.2738871276,
0.1498591453,
0.0519661531,
-0.3620265722,
-0.293004632,
0.2807063758,
0.6040326953,
-0.0852715522,
0.7332684994,
0.8090181351,
-0.1291781366,
0.0324715339,
-0.514942348,
-0.6199592352,
-0.4919151664,
0.4430038929,
0.21904324,
-0.9323500991,
0.1960653067,
0.4594234526,
0.8180897236,
0.119635649,
0.1069908366,
-0.055338189,
0.2392509729,
0.7045381665,
-0.2260987461,
0.5498632193,
-0.6318831444,
0.3361568451,
-0.7480723858,
-0.8508354425,
-0.2817937732,
-0.4259833992,
-0.1982584596,
-0.3137625158,
0.3055060506,
-0.1932213902,
-0.458058387,
0.2208754867,
-0.1366009265,
0.4067656398,
0.7427383065,
0.1626718342,
0.3861163855,
0.0304138903,
0.4088234603,
-0.020371642,
-0.2571953237,
-0.7645363808,
1.2605013847,
0.3607814312,
0.4950785637,
-0.0545299351,
0.477113843,
0.6086040139,
0.3302239478,
-0.3652469218,
0.5319252014,
-0.4787474573,
-0.5564746261,
-0.7210416794,
-0.340274483,
-0.8852584362,
-0.2765419781,
-0.3747870922,
-0.411929965,
0.0402147248,
0.1803237796,
-0.2809433043,
0.3490619957,
-0.2231182158,
0.997399509,
-0.1851346344,
-0.6101201773,
-0.3300511241,
-0.5529474616,
-0.0359279327,
-0.0138547709,
0.2837783396,
-0.3833456337,
0.2774742544,
1.153406024,
-0.0969392732,
0.872305274,
-0.3099017441,
0.0474135987,
0.2624509931,
-0.0560606346,
0.2359413356,
0.0196922645,
-0.4035943151,
0.1279674768,
-0.1605762094,
-0.4517506063,
-0.1888318509,
0.6117519736,
-0.5828357339,
-0.4100715816,
-0.1086522639,
-0.7378563285,
-0.2117944956,
0.1299601644,
0.0833833814,
0.6437669396,
-0.6151955128,
0.2767233551,
0.5500609279,
0.190336287,
0.4382312596,
0.2587100267,
0.2926155925,
0.0572646447,
0.8931831121,
0.7186638117,
0.0087208347,
0.2173819393,
0.0108441412,
-0.4129451811,
-0.0059206542,
-0.0467076451,
0.2181562036,
-0.6762971878,
-0.1622784287,
-0.6477788687,
-0.1976963431,
-0.5540947318,
-0.8436534405,
0.1822734475,
-0.0598682389,
-0.4543972909,
-0.3348064125,
0.4920400977,
0.9936587214,
0.0088654049,
0.1236563399,
-0.5599374771,
0.1427885443,
0.878015697,
0.4453167617,
0.1692586541,
-0.3860340118,
-0.3541055322,
0.0618636496,
-0.5166375637,
-0.7622019649,
0.3650391102,
0.4077523947,
0.7235869169,
0.5217012167,
-0.0328299999,
0.4970425665,
-0.1907550395,
0.7625008225,
0.139280051,
-0.6601158381,
0.2873936594,
-0.4483057261,
0.0741705149,
0.5504136682,
0.6529197693,
-0.4992772937,
-0.4538525343,
-0.687402606,
-1.0198994875,
0.5822515488,
0.0385950729,
0.3965607584,
0.0316375382,
0.091137208,
0.550273478,
0.0954737514,
-0.436116159,
-0.3514688611,
-0.0619517602,
-0.3342292607,
-0.0995614454,
-0.0885538831,
0.0411206633,
-0.3458495736,
0.5068540573,
0.0426792018,
-0.1710940897,
-0.3095813394,
-0.1483617574,
0.1219843999,
0.4185011089,
0.1362402737,
1.0629835129,
-0.2399780452,
0.1209351271,
0.3727164865,
-0.7739314437,
0.1023279279,
-0.3238558173,
-0.011569866,
-0.0516838022,
0.2266236693,
0.5153658986,
0.2997011244,
-0.7105128169,
0.3981364369,
0.5105471611,
-0.2777408063,
-0.5463699102,
0.3774221838,
-0.0446110368,
0.2464241982,
0.7868672609,
-0.1891671419,
0.2847318947,
-0.4857461751,
0.3354914188,
0.1415787935,
-0.4546560645,
-0.376516223,
0.6742141247,
0.242242679,
-0.0227827709,
0.8121700287,
0.2198726535,
0.216099456,
0.7227381468,
0.5995067954,
0.531376183,
-0.018557895,
0.2992222309,
0.5255715251,
-0.1913537979,
-0.3573459387,
0.2134151161,
0.1593037397,
-0.3268387914,
-0.1008034423,
-0.6722527742,
-0.3139404356,
0.2564812601,
-0.9413217306,
0.351359874,
-0.2637803853,
-0.2072485238,
0.0493635684,
-0.2314757407,
-1.2510020733,
0.4993847609,
-0.0176916327,
0.5416453481,
-1.5023157597,
0.5371388793,
0.650287807,
-0.363132,
-0.4384193122,
-0.4892388582,
0.0922370479,
-0.5696079731,
0.8825892806,
0.1531008184,
0.1013659164,
0.1172363833,
-0.0214717221,
-0.5532819629,
1.4182755947,
0.238782391,
-0.4995892942,
-0.432749331,
0.2226290107,
0.1052244604,
-0.4087849855,
0.2152219862,
0.8969012499,
0.3617641032,
-0.4715081453,
-0.6858463883,
-0.1917663813,
-0.0193905924,
-0.3174038827,
0.0737504959,
-0.2311757803,
0.8907846212,
-0.2983474135,
-0.1373442262,
-0.6122764349,
0.5580453873,
0.1583769619,
0.6971535087,
-0.0020300499,
0.3920944631,
1.1079953909,
-0.125804469,
0.1769187301,
0.0917150229,
0.1520675123,
1.0323660374,
0.020767903,
0.8232020736,
0.3702276349,
-0.4021710157,
0.9234295487,
0.2443065047,
-0.2347824574,
0.0852355212,
-0.0048097135,
-0.3275433779,
-0.0786171183,
-0.1868198216,
-0.6136681437,
0.5842801929,
0.3475190401,
-0.2677063048,
-0.0103399865,
0.1515243351,
0.0850836933,
0.1994586885,
-0.374686718,
0.6315606236,
-0.0849623606,
-0.3665168881,
0.0724664852,
-0.6327806711,
0.5587078929,
-0.2887490392,
-0.3069061637,
-0.4092175961,
-0.2590703666,
-0.5434435606,
-1.2507296801,
0.5231889486,
0.2218348384,
-0.2828327417,
-0.2446843535,
0.3496489227,
-0.3317387104,
-0.3302201331,
-0.0052067209,
0.3859721422,
0.1909779012,
0.5251497626,
0.1718769372,
-0.2528571784,
-0.1989950538,
0.1273989826,
0.1547296941,
0.2946110666,
-0.2569170892,
0.7193737626,
0.4682135284,
0.103905715,
0.274369061,
0.0567613877,
0.5130774975,
-0.857843101,
-0.5407982469,
-0.530960083,
0.8787310123,
-0.4825071394,
-0.7044101954,
0.3262785971,
0.5027454495,
1.1247004271,
-0.1444140971,
0.8317872882,
-0.3141244054,
0.0963958427,
-0.2268752158,
0.5761858225,
-0.17564933,
0.2413410544,
-0.1175050214,
-0.7022941113,
-0.1046951637,
0.509405911,
-0.4366371036,
0.079126358,
0.2521778345,
0.4259934425,
0.1133877262,
-0.1541211158,
0.4137150049,
-0.3350970447,
0.0313829035,
0.1101874635,
0.3629727364,
-0.2375832051,
0.2473868132,
-0.5273875594,
-0.1465215087,
-0.4887750745,
-0.5886419415,
-0.8577311039,
-0.6396827698,
-0.7813526392,
0.0590656698,
0.132779479,
0.4651511312,
0.4407631755,
-0.468788147,
-0.7311909795,
0.04453912,
-0.0804268569,
-0.5953509808,
-0.3598376513,
0.2746224105,
-0.2649984658,
-0.1444991082,
0.4719351232,
0.241135478,
-0.0630752891,
-0.2311374545,
0.1641584635,
0.000202279,
-0.365180403,
0.4375550747,
0.4973252714,
-0.600810051,
-0.1829262823,
0.385895282,
0.089780584,
-0.2454925328,
0.9246221185,
-0.6543852687,
0.2556318045,
0.4710027874,
0.3937169015,
0.0742015392,
-0.3702918887,
0.4353507161,
-0.8615678549,
0.0837353542,
0.279120028,
0.2044177949,
0.2010039836,
-0.588553071,
0.5138039589,
0.0872716531,
-0.5419957638,
-0.6890964508,
-0.0778373852,
-0.5868619084,
-0.2795310616,
0.3168608546,
-0.2257980406,
0.3350319266,
-0.8270489573,
0.1820931882,
0.5025093555,
-0.3827540576,
1.1632341146,
0.1424478889,
-0.1936478764,
-0.0064996793,
-0.7450562716,
0.4615267813,
-0.1005187556,
-0.7110283375,
0.3303879201,
0.5331804156,
0.1872484684,
-0.1123056784,
0.6402551532,
-0.0824745595,
0.4935064018,
0.1928959936,
0.143682614,
-0.1135302484,
-0.6326923966,
0.2070432454,
0.3119890094,
0.1605021507,
0.1328940839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13149v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13149v1
|
Beyond Self-Consistency: Ensemble Reasoning Boosts Consistency and Accuracy of LLMs in Cancer Staging
| 2024-04-19T19:34:35 | 2024-04-19T19:34:35 |
Chia-Hsuan Chang, Mary M. Lucas, Yeawon Lee, Christopher C. Yang, Grace Lu-Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Advances in large language models (LLMs) have encouraged their adoption in
the healthcare domain where vital clinical information is often contained in
unstructured notes. Cancer staging status is available in clinical reports, but
it requires natural language processing to extract the status from the
unstructured text. With the advance in clinical-oriented LLMs, it is promising
to extract such status without extensive efforts in training the algorithms.
Prompting approaches of the pre-trained LLMs that elicit a model's reasoning
process, such as chain-of-thought, may help to improve the trustworthiness of
the generated responses. Using self-consistency further improves model
performance, but often results in inconsistent generations across the multiple
reasoning paths. In this study, we propose an ensemble reasoning approach with
the aim of improving the consistency of the model generations. Using an open
access clinical large language model to determine the pathologic cancer stage
from real-world pathology reports, we show that the ensemble reasoning approach
is able to improve both the consistency and performance of the LLM in
determining cancer stage, thereby demonstrating the potential to use these
models in clinical or other domains where reliability and trustworthiness are
critical.
|
[
0.0552241281,
-0.2147663087,
1.0535166264,
0.2289639413,
-0.0828074142,
0.1405244321,
-0.1268519461,
-0.553904295,
0.2357037961,
0.7702242732,
-0.343467921,
-0.704513073,
-0.5346918106,
0.1795597225,
-0.453692019,
0.7535673976,
-0.0221166275,
0.2328459471,
-0.4780133367,
-0.2190466225,
-0.0069727879,
-0.1451841742,
-0.9102057219,
-0.4609564543,
0.5257914066,
0.399415493,
0.5428279042,
1.0151706934,
0.5616527796,
0.3288748264,
0.2684114575,
0.3302895725,
-0.1301020533,
0.5802326202,
-0.2891438305,
-0.3743264079,
-0.4040202498,
-0.0431908369,
0.4708685875,
0.4831675887,
-0.4321680367,
-0.4961579442,
0.1131865382,
0.4286268055,
-0.5673558712,
0.0931180641,
-0.6577498913,
-0.1082598194,
-0.0262083672,
-0.3217642903,
-0.3902347088,
-0.4611183703,
-0.0735567957,
-0.6825006604,
-0.0462343171,
-0.2123027444,
0.4223436415,
0.1809063852,
-0.2852129042,
-0.3264394701,
-0.7598057389,
0.5574973822,
-0.8988672495,
0.2703405917,
0.4242421985,
0.2598616779,
-0.3142922819,
-0.8600641489,
-0.3510687947,
-0.2203274965,
-0.068144165,
0.3061087132,
0.0130203823,
0.3558347523,
-0.0324548371,
0.4566396475,
-0.5386424661,
0.3823325634,
0.022342423,
-0.5055446029,
0.8572371006,
0.090637736,
0.1948741376,
-0.0459184945,
-0.4174857736,
-0.0004550373,
-0.6726278067,
-0.2875141501,
-0.0908015892,
0.2657102644,
0.3200744689,
0.3040956855,
-0.4309654832,
0.5497652888,
0.2321764529,
-0.3765715957,
-0.111414291,
-0.2028187662,
-0.2883072793,
0.4275502264,
0.893383801,
0.1084355116,
-0.0130449999,
-0.0502137467,
0.0181979779,
0.1570196599,
0.2386325896,
-0.3932436109,
-0.2894586325,
0.5771853924,
-0.5487632751,
-0.2931317985,
-0.3028711677,
-0.7532413006,
-0.5886358023,
-0.118723169,
0.6921521425,
-0.5412560105,
0.0029799487,
0.0874767676,
0.2251254171,
-0.311124742,
0.7476972938,
-0.6812498569,
0.1575721055,
0.7057060599,
0.5673903227,
0.0272016581,
-0.0649831071,
-0.5404778123,
0.4123813212,
-0.3231891096,
1.0608261824,
-0.7182071209,
-0.3890204132,
-0.1641481817,
-0.0267016236,
-0.3342228234,
-0.4151833057,
0.7626437545,
-0.1751760393,
0.4898107052,
0.022220321,
-0.8439819217,
0.2088504881,
0.4306389391,
-0.325447768,
0.8209441304,
-0.2662573755,
-0.2984363139,
0.5306542516,
-0.2592869103,
-0.3124050498,
0.156059891,
-0.4268075526,
-0.2731348872,
-0.1507848948,
0.3152538836,
0.52314502,
-0.0098539339,
0.0697192624,
-0.4050147533,
-0.1426885277,
-0.1534201205,
-0.153564319,
0.3241515458,
0.5090752244,
-0.1807773411,
-0.0777160972,
-0.8127163649,
0.3423124254,
-0.1975206286,
-0.2045759261,
-0.3832372129,
0.3001001775,
-0.7183546424,
0.2815010846,
0.2322978079,
-0.6326576471,
0.3891909122,
-0.423910141,
0.2617013156,
0.5839847326,
-0.0096342154,
0.2314233631,
-0.3804205656,
0.3364756107,
0.1405147463,
-0.0322556421,
-0.3943484724,
-0.6495315433,
-0.2954235971,
-0.1802247465,
0.3333326578,
0.4601641893,
-0.4751722515,
0.4283205569,
-0.1398965865,
-0.5545207858,
-0.5193463564,
-0.0605661906,
0.3857242465,
0.7906304002,
0.4442631304,
-0.3425049186,
-0.6428854465,
-0.6815782785,
-0.3211225271,
-0.4062874913,
0.0516143441,
0.1360691935,
0.1436393559,
-0.0826698989,
0.635012567,
-0.2191708088,
-0.2446581572,
-0.1193450913,
0.1164240316,
0.2440605015,
0.7259363532,
-0.1716513336,
-0.3169677854,
-0.1587356329,
0.2682489157,
-0.8454903364,
-0.1477031559,
-0.1676225215,
-0.2569316328,
0.1972524971,
0.5318564177,
-0.5593399405,
0.507084012,
0.6343260407,
-0.1911118627,
0.3709320724,
-0.6796666384,
0.4994317889,
-0.927054584,
-0.1050528586,
0.1118224114,
-0.3923942447,
-0.3068717718,
-0.2383473217,
-0.1201347038,
0.2975361645,
0.0621605553,
0.4803758264,
-0.3311296105,
-0.1663746238,
-0.2912419438,
0.1355735064,
0.2050293237,
-0.0385435522,
0.3537965119,
0.5127280354,
0.4183261693,
-0.6254149675,
0.105876185,
0.0984224081,
-0.308108747,
0.7057229877,
-0.3322777748,
0.0932581201,
0.0292680543,
0.5822074413,
-1.0117448568,
-0.3954118192,
0.1037084013,
-0.2348205596,
0.3489363492,
-0.3095662892,
-0.3722119629,
-0.4836419225,
0.1412100196,
0.168683663,
0.5457206368,
-0.3855164349,
0.6454322934,
0.1077501252,
0.0363580957,
-0.4058896899,
-0.6506296396,
-0.0894465297,
-0.1894317269,
-0.8288538456,
0.4165132344,
0.0551207289,
-0.3913447261,
-0.354949683,
-0.2637753189,
-0.1274488866,
-0.0907783732,
-0.0741978511,
0.0029848844,
-0.2685186863,
0.5223270655,
0.076012738,
-0.0147403702,
-0.0775745437,
-0.5645555854,
0.3456350863,
0.2746174335,
-0.542501688,
-0.5012357235,
0.0498287417,
0.5485771894,
-0.0348367579,
0.5804371834,
0.1331345737,
-0.4495953321,
-0.101297833,
-0.6503025293,
-0.2500887513,
-0.367243439,
-0.138032034,
-0.0890672356,
-0.8727191687,
0.716789484,
-0.3206782937,
-0.0229421761,
0.7433770299,
0.6850482821,
-0.3635710776,
1.1833802462,
-0.0090215839,
0.1602624059,
-0.0607743487,
0.2924798727,
-0.107779704,
-0.7172191739,
-0.3670500815,
-0.5559138656,
-0.1289804876,
-0.5465427637,
-0.5463463664,
0.7404222488,
-0.0476951115,
-0.2688808143,
0.0497476608,
-0.7283115983,
0.3195468783,
0.2960704863,
0.4861662686,
0.6951999664,
-0.0555878989,
-0.1769386381,
0.2205921859,
-0.7953076363,
-0.7583088875,
1.1224850416,
0.3189067245,
0.67356354,
-0.0774556696,
0.970272541,
0.1452222317,
0.1380303353,
-0.3584837019,
0.3546332121,
-0.3134903014,
-0.6441438198,
-0.581905961,
-0.4524192512,
-1.1444926262,
0.2668156028,
-0.1739451289,
-1.0732666254,
0.2512276471,
0.4285794199,
-0.7145096064,
0.2816410959,
-0.2244569659,
0.704390645,
-0.3039720654,
-0.597617209,
-0.2143338323,
-0.7758399844,
0.386484772,
0.0104561448,
0.411147058,
-0.0455650799,
0.2027251869,
0.5710114241,
-0.5585626364,
0.6751596332,
0.1279576868,
-0.319581449,
0.4216392934,
0.3351828754,
0.7898510695,
0.0917828456,
-0.3477851152,
0.0079801874,
0.2058338821,
-0.3338345289,
-0.5965071321,
0.8787312508,
-0.4601435065,
-0.6099879742,
-0.3478418589,
-0.4453305006,
-0.6019303799,
0.16307877,
0.3769780099,
0.432426244,
-0.1264432073,
0.0463115424,
0.8909692168,
0.0648360848,
0.2488297969,
0.234318167,
-0.2357548475,
-0.1605560631,
0.4835630953,
0.0085334592,
0.461572051,
0.4854299724,
0.3368245065,
-0.3485833406,
-0.6591226459,
-0.3500156701,
-0.0177009758,
-0.6303536296,
-0.1356510222,
-0.8628861904,
-0.197923243,
-0.5692296028,
0.0287087858,
-0.4245832264,
-0.5411503911,
-0.0982649773,
0.0008871995,
0.3133902848,
0.6329391599,
-0.4067394733,
0.0781859532,
-0.9126500487,
-0.2394613773,
0.3693665862,
0.4117653668,
-0.0758631453,
-0.476026535,
-0.1764245927,
0.2173588276,
-0.2863238156,
-0.6583614349,
0.2721481323,
0.1705480218,
0.8509277105,
0.4020097554,
-0.1643514037,
0.5571857691,
-0.1577035338,
0.729029417,
0.153342694,
-0.7717860341,
0.7797320485,
-0.7552320957,
0.1413908303,
0.668941021,
0.3130626678,
-0.3434734046,
-0.5025759339,
-0.9318017364,
-0.3398087323,
0.5776982903,
0.3859132528,
-0.4945680797,
-0.1754785627,
0.2987798452,
0.1998507977,
0.1160665154,
-0.4461240172,
0.2110231519,
-0.3179614246,
-0.5339146256,
-0.1843002886,
-0.0667715818,
-0.5202320814,
-0.2726446986,
0.577419281,
-0.3461161256,
0.2549368441,
0.6319171786,
0.3303068876,
-0.3192925453,
0.2834375203,
0.6621540189,
0.5403171778,
-0.0956896171,
0.2891575694,
0.1771972477,
-0.2739309967,
0.0655493811,
-0.1540084332,
0.2978254557,
-0.3548505604,
0.7401341796,
0.2576339543,
0.2671535015,
-0.6568584442,
0.3307071924,
0.2837758958,
-0.2681154609,
-0.0839758217,
0.1912539005,
0.0981859416,
0.2593353093,
0.1743245274,
0.2240140289,
0.2538874745,
-0.7501639724,
0.4028301835,
0.3129955828,
-0.3947435915,
0.0647966638,
0.6225697398,
-0.0154654933,
-0.0348099619,
0.5314234495,
0.1536356211,
-0.2820993662,
0.7523126006,
0.6214510798,
0.5058840513,
-0.5177640915,
0.2976626456,
0.3175368309,
0.1418799013,
-0.6461988091,
0.1252445877,
0.2433314323,
-0.884978652,
-0.50239259,
-0.5203405023,
-0.4325283766,
-0.1315674484,
-0.3352191448,
0.0599780157,
-0.5734629035,
0.1816093922,
-0.2220963687,
-0.2128274292,
-0.1526720375,
0.7349005938,
0.3843765557,
0.8141508698,
-0.415127337,
0.840049088,
0.4669776857,
-0.1062092781,
-1.1980564594,
0.005297611,
0.0980477408,
-1.0557461977,
0.2901208699,
-0.061964985,
0.1367502809,
-0.0651108846,
-0.5268387794,
-1.2273586988,
1.2360310555,
0.0838916972,
-0.8673447967,
0.0093835061,
-0.2063230872,
0.8560587764,
-0.8043958545,
0.5773517489,
0.3671344817,
0.5774063468,
0.8603064418,
-1.1222436428,
0.0757981837,
0.1923814714,
-0.3961660862,
0.2255969197,
-0.4950184524,
0.7869715095,
-0.1465636641,
-0.059400104,
0.290889591,
0.4725734293,
0.6723310947,
0.7420212626,
0.3860569894,
0.8334860802,
1.1554057598,
-0.1312758029,
1.3064137697,
-0.4381552339,
0.2590209246,
0.8147519827,
-0.5565702319,
0.5953674912,
0.0747082531,
-0.181357637,
1.0502822399,
0.5805803537,
0.2703382969,
0.4029777348,
-0.0577722713,
-0.2974771857,
-0.9391132593,
0.1492370069,
-0.4233824015,
0.5847349167,
0.474612385,
-0.741952002,
-0.278997153,
-0.1985200197,
0.1321879774,
0.2728276849,
-0.6479001641,
0.6703787446,
0.1456007957,
-1.0280098915,
0.2035235763,
-0.4081716239,
0.247198686,
-0.562513411,
-0.066792883,
-0.0362770669,
0.223262623,
-0.5305263996,
-0.8267877698,
0.2822146416,
-0.4827913642,
-0.03104591,
-0.0260643642,
1.0066258907,
-0.4639481008,
-0.6921902895,
0.0513478592,
0.5821458101,
0.2494920343,
0.0138954837,
-0.4882001877,
-0.0259318072,
-0.1177996546,
0.0964251757,
0.4881534576,
0.4757139981,
-0.0463296063,
0.736353457,
0.5267521739,
0.1176484004,
-0.2907549143,
-0.1319587529,
0.5952199697,
-0.4959225655,
-0.4612877369,
-0.7885335684,
0.3557736278,
-0.3232836127,
-0.2747822404,
0.6942405701,
0.3161453307,
0.3957773149,
0.4479581416,
0.6751908064,
0.2070722729,
0.7799978852,
-0.7894533873,
0.6338412762,
-0.5368229747,
0.5895229578,
-0.3174010515,
-0.501904726,
-0.3225509822,
0.5933169127,
-0.5131363273,
0.3601294458,
0.8110816479,
0.5619887114,
0.1670291126,
0.3702439964,
0.3461279273,
0.5105873346,
0.2074095756,
0.65600878,
0.6423977613,
-0.2465214282,
0.2752190828,
-0.1491557509,
-0.3473639488,
0.0076909969,
-0.8986512423,
-0.4913276434,
-0.2719860971,
-0.4835966527,
-0.64289397,
0.3814131021,
1.0636384487,
0.7436403632,
-0.6567126513,
-0.0783141628,
-0.3228772879,
0.1704130024,
-0.3523151875,
-0.1638989002,
0.2195417583,
-0.2839315832,
-0.4129721522,
0.7608391643,
0.5334082842,
-0.2025244832,
-0.2489153147,
-0.0265487563,
-0.3413281441,
0.2563396394,
0.311195612,
0.3895618618,
-0.6051754355,
-0.4613111019,
-0.3036932051,
-0.2595671713,
0.3175728917,
0.5234732628,
-1.1175310612,
0.5598070621,
0.2250158042,
0.1851225197,
0.294053793,
0.0901895538,
0.7228088975,
-0.3405758142,
-0.3852645457,
0.5109279156,
0.384227246,
0.0864588991,
-0.7652236223,
0.5913535357,
0.3777700365,
-0.9353757501,
-0.5426063538,
0.2320268303,
-1.0580221415,
-0.2616419494,
1.1754841805,
-0.248021096,
-0.075772509,
-0.1840926707,
0.0503750443,
0.0959701017,
-0.3933207095,
0.9950113297,
0.5356149673,
-0.7309333086,
-0.3965196013,
0.168121323,
0.5597028136,
0.414572984,
-0.9030011296,
-0.3304615617,
0.3711127043,
0.2574409544,
0.2469585538,
0.8863261938,
-0.3806345761,
0.2949359715,
-0.1198305115,
-0.1073162779,
0.2743929625,
-0.1786965579,
-0.0601130612,
0.3756296933,
-0.1095929593,
0.210267663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13043v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13043v1
|
Data Alignment for Zero-Shot Concept Generation in Dermatology AI
| 2024-04-19T17:57:29 | 2024-04-19T17:57:29 |
Soham Gadgil, Mahtab Bigverdi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
AI in dermatology is evolving at a rapid pace but the major limitation to
training trustworthy classifiers is the scarcity of data with ground-truth
concept level labels, which are meta-labels semantically meaningful to humans.
Foundation models like CLIP providing zero-shot capabilities can help alleviate
this challenge by leveraging vast amounts of image-caption pairs available on
the internet. CLIP can be fine-tuned using domain specific image-caption pairs
to improve classification performance. However, CLIP's pre-training data is not
well-aligned with the medical jargon that clinicians use to perform diagnoses.
The development of large language models (LLMs) in recent years has led to the
possibility of leveraging the expressive nature of these models to generate
rich text. Our goal is to use these models to generate caption text that aligns
well with both the clinical lexicon and with the natural human language used in
CLIP's pre-training data. Starting with captions used for images in PubMed
articles, we extend them by passing the raw captions through an LLM fine-tuned
on the field's several textbooks. We find that using captions generated by an
expressive fine-tuned LLM like GPT-3.5 improves downstream zero-shot concept
classification performance.
|
[
-0.1448916346,
-0.5304228663,
0.859239161,
-0.3818093538,
-0.5558512807,
0.2359120548,
-0.0584959574,
-0.6143308282,
0.2268828154,
0.6646311283,
-0.4326478839,
-0.8029099703,
-0.5406498313,
0.1689402461,
-0.407923907,
1.260434866,
-0.1755263656,
0.0940472037,
-0.4676781893,
-0.2900232673,
-0.4235193133,
-0.2270236462,
-0.3293400407,
-0.2955001295,
0.2998977304,
0.6989426017,
0.7963410616,
1.1140903234,
0.8542356491,
0.1499388963,
0.2680586874,
-0.0818574801,
-0.2404814065,
0.2268815041,
-0.1653721482,
-0.3284628689,
-0.5754594207,
0.0675339922,
0.4124165475,
0.6261867881,
-0.113640964,
-0.124117896,
-0.5068951845,
0.5669462085,
-0.4218664765,
-0.1197396293,
-0.570553422,
0.1246056259,
-0.1109518856,
-0.1912937909,
-0.0503069237,
-0.1666395813,
0.4190937579,
-0.5996921062,
0.7152166963,
-0.2430209517,
1.2348605394,
0.4649654925,
-0.0999343097,
0.044346679,
-0.6676273346,
0.4342300594,
-0.8481513858,
-0.0650903136,
0.0705306306,
0.5460751653,
0.3545610011,
-0.5557793379,
-0.5287426114,
-0.0772768855,
0.0518939421,
0.2068562657,
-0.0166930892,
0.12912108,
0.2056293935,
0.38500157,
-0.4757855237,
0.2464351654,
-0.3710204959,
-0.1066721529,
0.8818802238,
0.339897573,
0.3509793878,
0.0870046914,
-0.5987013578,
-0.0982081518,
-0.9601822495,
-0.4881516993,
-0.1530584097,
0.2985673547,
-0.0728262737,
0.7380221486,
-0.2672644556,
0.8859649301,
0.0881041735,
-0.279284656,
0.1762536317,
-0.4576207995,
-0.2180010229,
0.4002865851,
0.8661907911,
0.6643843055,
0.2851176858,
-0.1480377465,
0.0158021227,
0.0934639871,
0.5372175574,
-1.0788171291,
-0.1253417283,
0.4488765597,
-0.0388873369,
-0.7947906852,
0.0777355283,
-0.6921623945,
-0.4109587967,
-0.2411499619,
0.4775016606,
-0.4093420506,
0.014647346,
0.2218735963,
-0.0335965008,
0.2025125325,
0.4876950681,
-0.7148342133,
0.2042968124,
0.2724303603,
1.0504754782,
-0.1818662584,
-0.0787601247,
-0.3541812897,
0.5310152173,
-0.4673146307,
0.7947793007,
-0.4370781779,
-0.18542476,
0.0407437682,
-0.1461097896,
-0.1262590736,
-0.3916874826,
0.4187658429,
-0.1627478153,
0.2856963873,
0.0590375438,
-0.8144683838,
-0.0416187532,
0.302477777,
-0.35536322,
0.4888112843,
0.4595779181,
-0.5915727615,
0.4146293998,
-0.7398738861,
-0.3743767738,
0.3101253211,
-0.2673213184,
-0.783949852,
0.0607760251,
0.3185178041,
0.6195327044,
-0.18910335,
0.309905827,
-0.2350422889,
-0.3252490461,
0.347743392,
0.0551636294,
0.2880710065,
0.013872331,
-0.4971041977,
0.2757820487,
-0.671749711,
-0.2487925142,
0.3835215271,
0.3505563736,
-0.2444907576,
-0.0373517796,
-0.2483080924,
0.1398910135,
0.0133059332,
-0.8183627725,
0.3797356784,
-0.4518906474,
0.487619549,
0.4016197026,
0.2184418291,
0.3370199502,
-0.572953105,
0.4483793378,
0.2628295124,
0.1308735907,
-0.3427377343,
-0.4368465841,
-0.5570688844,
-0.3982586861,
0.4189568162,
0.4830203354,
-0.4479412735,
0.4133980572,
-0.4571457505,
-0.5401180983,
-0.5648470521,
0.0204438828,
0.3370584548,
0.8833904862,
0.3898042738,
-0.6362629533,
-0.2051355839,
-0.9250076413,
0.2344008833,
0.1720453501,
0.0539665818,
0.5968304276,
0.192138508,
-0.336761266,
0.9829544425,
-0.8449198008,
-0.7365125418,
-0.1789162606,
0.0236127358,
0.070447281,
0.3882787824,
0.6235803366,
-0.5402877331,
-0.6684402823,
0.2349461615,
-0.5925648212,
-0.3089224398,
-0.1629981846,
-0.0722788721,
0.1951816976,
0.4703019857,
-0.80557096,
0.4533429742,
0.2777472734,
-0.2700464725,
0.361851275,
-0.0377806835,
0.1110591292,
-1.1333500147,
0.2152001709,
0.0852096677,
-0.4481305182,
-0.6181105375,
0.0210686941,
-0.0696043596,
-0.3104861081,
-0.4691362083,
0.5875957012,
-0.1775362492,
0.0921204761,
-0.2139222175,
0.3014243841,
0.2535616159,
0.085540235,
0.3403608501,
0.8527089357,
0.6241947412,
-0.3439579606,
0.2822289169,
0.6472120881,
-0.0579564013,
0.77064991,
-0.6394640207,
0.0161360465,
0.0283536352,
0.1291617155,
-0.8175504804,
-0.609718442,
0.3785353005,
-0.3636685014,
0.6522844434,
-0.1256653816,
-0.2389679551,
-0.2955777943,
-0.3608982265,
0.4806591868,
0.3967472017,
-0.234922722,
-0.0070482059,
0.2601191401,
-0.2598802149,
-0.4606280923,
-0.4504708648,
0.1572568417,
-0.276796639,
-0.2367044687,
0.6263815761,
-0.0022264922,
-0.0062974077,
0.0766846016,
-0.1814688146,
-0.1761172861,
-0.0582425147,
0.2748272717,
0.5722643733,
-0.371111244,
0.0665838271,
-0.1292907298,
0.0906622112,
-0.2134175301,
-0.1699868739,
0.2959746718,
0.0428360179,
-0.567571044,
-0.5232970119,
0.1107481942,
0.7004610896,
-0.120915778,
0.5057065487,
0.3572535217,
-0.2136393487,
-0.049320247,
-0.3988373578,
-0.1306556165,
-0.3127410412,
0.1728220135,
-0.0407691561,
-0.8767197728,
0.3437156379,
0.1536144912,
-0.0387855358,
0.6256055832,
0.5174736977,
-0.2057572007,
0.790872395,
0.682564497,
0.0523596033,
0.2873855829,
-0.2312609404,
0.148230657,
-0.6769585609,
-0.2028700411,
-0.248831898,
-0.2200386971,
-0.2540944219,
-0.4297843874,
0.2195190489,
0.1998942941,
-0.2067321241,
0.4369085431,
-0.9266563654,
0.5516789556,
0.4421416223,
0.1980649829,
0.1567952335,
0.0693065077,
0.1188796684,
-0.0343602262,
-0.6286773086,
-0.4230265915,
1.5102778673,
0.3613697886,
0.5301863551,
0.0097098025,
0.8144159913,
0.2555164993,
0.5639606118,
-0.9958553314,
0.1987768412,
-0.3022747338,
-0.6061679721,
-0.1660645753,
-0.231820941,
-0.8227995634,
-0.1578817219,
-0.2941997945,
-0.5344710946,
0.0799187273,
-0.0726938397,
-0.7780047655,
0.2047716081,
-0.4349130988,
0.9685140252,
-0.2840385437,
-0.2657385468,
0.0771963745,
-0.8350364566,
0.4476917982,
-0.3041965067,
-0.146952495,
-0.3397822678,
-0.1171966717,
0.4733227789,
-0.5666577816,
0.8573191166,
-0.0831844136,
-0.1064020246,
0.259011209,
0.0508423187,
-0.0640639216,
-0.0784607455,
0.4986599684,
0.3292483687,
0.1955892742,
-0.3874790668,
-0.3160182238,
0.4826157093,
-0.756357491,
-0.5133433342,
-0.541803658,
-0.6393448114,
-0.409334749,
0.2215583622,
0.3543242812,
0.3240587711,
-0.2725488544,
0.0366829485,
0.6418175697,
-0.1311768889,
0.2275235355,
0.6281960607,
-0.0235957932,
-0.6733970046,
0.8827520013,
-0.0730676204,
0.3265266716,
0.3719864786,
0.0778865889,
-0.1649305671,
-0.8091165423,
-0.7842181325,
0.2396106422,
-0.3303209543,
-0.8750406504,
-0.4130898118,
-0.6512226462,
-0.4263903201,
-0.3944318891,
-0.1390576065,
-0.4936238229,
-0.3572311103,
-0.0821292326,
0.6182066798,
0.8488537073,
-0.0740053207,
0.6855964661,
-1.1307783127,
0.3646429479,
0.0129912756,
0.5000855923,
-0.4942365885,
-0.38850981,
-0.2783688903,
0.0035088782,
-0.4695456624,
-0.9265692234,
0.4950943887,
0.4797276855,
0.2825875878,
0.7620854378,
0.0074052778,
0.4408090115,
-0.7019467354,
0.6285536289,
0.450787425,
-0.7145600915,
0.8164584637,
-0.5732456446,
0.0558342636,
0.6796603799,
0.334156245,
-0.2890542746,
-0.4534914792,
-0.8826886415,
-0.6740171909,
0.8413184881,
0.0910092965,
0.0582385287,
-0.1291650236,
0.4062147141,
0.2217038721,
0.2678560913,
-0.3726997375,
0.0228134021,
-0.3069391847,
-0.599026382,
-0.1155119836,
-0.3167940676,
-0.7090258002,
-0.2901117802,
0.4406943321,
-0.4690290689,
0.2466183901,
0.491754204,
-0.044760786,
-0.4676210582,
0.0684444681,
0.9407300353,
0.5865020156,
-0.4781403244,
-0.0394873619,
-0.1517744362,
-0.5362445116,
0.2418881357,
0.2260392606,
-0.3533734381,
0.292689383,
0.3438920975,
0.694650948,
0.2389244288,
-0.726456821,
0.9848608375,
0.1662396342,
-0.7401558161,
0.0895852596,
0.1978962272,
-0.1408585906,
0.0431748107,
0.1820141375,
0.2590537965,
-0.1020239741,
-0.1094909832,
0.5812477469,
0.5640796423,
-0.5835051537,
-0.2308534831,
0.7022968531,
0.2446913123,
-0.0999634117,
0.5921117663,
0.1852122247,
-0.4885143638,
0.6105011106,
0.5193995833,
0.7833280563,
0.0195907075,
0.5696585774,
0.4029648006,
-0.06584353,
0.0187235605,
-0.1259788275,
-0.0376025438,
-0.7227775455,
-0.5652683973,
-0.6884765625,
-0.6041159034,
0.0914833173,
-0.6067658067,
0.2997674048,
-0.7398297191,
-0.11851836,
0.1657870114,
0.0642605275,
-0.4978126585,
0.3549239933,
0.286778748,
0.8431571126,
-0.954904139,
0.8050644398,
0.5556215644,
-0.7271038294,
-0.6748414636,
-0.0519299954,
-0.0777885467,
-0.9135432839,
0.3908208311,
0.3279520273,
0.2250737697,
-0.007440859,
-0.8443854451,
-0.795329988,
1.1554400921,
0.4012086987,
-0.5797861814,
0.0770899653,
0.2464120984,
0.6784328818,
-0.6939768791,
0.0063715884,
0.5331491232,
0.1597060561,
0.5170016885,
-0.9157289863,
0.0125775347,
0.0880165026,
-0.2438061386,
0.2216406912,
-0.2369540632,
0.5614760518,
-0.5388383269,
-0.3575051725,
0.2099969238,
0.1843070537,
0.0997536033,
0.2968450785,
0.0464868508,
1.0940608978,
0.3332530558,
-0.22512649,
1.1308400631,
-0.4087249041,
0.2163390815,
1.038746357,
-0.4379198253,
0.769069612,
0.2805115879,
-0.235568434,
0.5066570044,
0.6564614773,
-0.3987800181,
0.4423803985,
-0.1186027005,
-0.2740447223,
-0.1363782883,
-0.3801629841,
-0.456479013,
0.5091679096,
0.2397208363,
-0.4419229031,
-0.3523926437,
-0.2658195496,
-0.197168842,
0.0218231734,
-0.2652012706,
1.2052253485,
-0.0687070638,
-0.295732826,
0.5973557234,
-0.2020633519,
0.3565769196,
-0.4586185813,
-0.1315950453,
-0.2515338659,
0.0640557185,
-0.3255041242,
-0.9699448943,
0.3964320719,
0.0316875391,
-0.0728287771,
0.0585613325,
0.5264431834,
-0.5867556334,
-0.4925183356,
-0.1783387661,
0.6856216788,
0.2836779058,
-0.0105504403,
-0.6478379369,
-0.1627796292,
-0.0818317831,
0.2475855649,
0.3296994567,
0.3381437957,
-0.1049304008,
0.3593110442,
0.6899431348,
0.4601031244,
-0.2957321703,
0.234625414,
0.7563580275,
-0.5859411955,
0.0353507958,
-0.8946983218,
0.2878184319,
-0.221364975,
-0.1633159369,
0.3491977751,
0.532276988,
0.7015885711,
-0.1403766423,
0.6261056662,
0.0714641809,
0.4944164455,
-0.245322004,
0.7925287485,
-0.6040025353,
-0.0159307327,
-0.3142364621,
-0.9690358043,
-0.8076408505,
0.4974962473,
-0.0921386033,
-0.2584524453,
0.6028208137,
0.5232626796,
-0.0297410116,
-0.292858243,
0.3767362833,
-0.0019730171,
0.2025281936,
0.5439115763,
0.4903616309,
-0.4525986016,
0.3507263064,
-0.4002781808,
-0.184101671,
-0.3557782173,
-0.8406996727,
-0.7135343552,
-0.2561957836,
-0.6282938123,
-0.2428976446,
-0.0623531565,
0.6878667474,
0.8714653254,
-1.0248119831,
0.106200479,
-0.2763866186,
-0.1024630144,
0.0031107841,
-0.2472494245,
0.4278617203,
-0.3848184049,
-0.5994561911,
0.1515629888,
0.5768162012,
0.5557284951,
-0.0541594326,
0.0381783769,
-0.0049521229,
0.0079907039,
0.3909595311,
0.3836212158,
-0.6120192409,
-0.3153477609,
-0.0026872766,
-0.2934202552,
0.4393197,
0.7264444232,
-0.7680538297,
0.4932993054,
0.0245656557,
0.8167302012,
0.1668112278,
0.3462645113,
0.7535678148,
-0.7558177114,
-0.1143369004,
0.4890935421,
0.1421050727,
0.5900012851,
-0.3438503146,
0.6542260051,
0.4105330706,
-0.3473135829,
-0.88966012,
0.1149536818,
-1.1479575634,
-0.3370454013,
0.983150661,
-0.072565414,
-0.2467450351,
0.0866299272,
-0.3139002323,
0.1698563993,
-0.1202571765,
0.7626288533,
0.4547713101,
-0.3232034147,
-0.3772218525,
-0.286123544,
0.7263878584,
0.3106909394,
-0.8329977989,
-0.0991565436,
0.6701106429,
0.4034298062,
0.3246332109,
0.7209512591,
-0.2226712406,
0.2763626575,
-0.1293604523,
0.3027175069,
-0.2601540387,
-0.3250193,
-0.3065382242,
-0.046955239,
0.1111100614,
-0.3164803684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13039v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13039v1
|
LaPA: Latent Prompt Assist Model For Medical Visual Question Answering
| 2024-04-19T17:51:52 | 2024-04-19T17:51:52 |
Tiancheng Gu, Kaicheng Yang, Dongnan Liu, Weidong Cai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Medical visual question answering (Med-VQA) aims to automate the prediction
of correct answers for medical images and questions, thereby assisting
physicians in reducing repetitive tasks and alleviating their workload.
Existing approaches primarily focus on pre-training models using additional and
comprehensive datasets, followed by fine-tuning to enhance performance in
downstream tasks. However, there is also significant value in exploring
existing models to extract clinically relevant information. In this paper, we
propose the Latent Prompt Assist model (LaPA) for medical visual question
answering. Firstly, we design a latent prompt generation module to generate the
latent prompt with the constraint of the target answer. Subsequently, we
propose a multi-modal fusion block with latent prompt fusion module that
utilizes the latent prompt to extract clinical-relevant information from
uni-modal and multi-modal features. Additionally, we introduce a prior
knowledge fusion module to integrate the relationship between diseases and
organs with the clinical-relevant information. Finally, we combine the final
integrated information with image-language cross-modal information to predict
the final answers. Experimental results on three publicly available Med-VQA
datasets demonstrate that LaPA outperforms the state-of-the-art model ARL,
achieving improvements of 1.83%, 0.63%, and 1.80% on VQA-RAD, SLAKE, and
VQA-2019, respectively. The code is publicly available at
https://github.com/GaryGuTC/LaPA_model.
|
[
-0.3801098168,
-1.2023427486,
0.9679661393,
-0.0867596567,
-0.5596988201,
-0.0798751265,
0.3889549673,
-0.4633817971,
0.2586199343,
0.4588980675,
-0.6758655906,
-0.2503840625,
-0.3011827469,
-0.0127961943,
0.2550328672,
0.5958307385,
-0.1197394505,
0.6916594505,
-0.6181896925,
-0.0713325217,
-0.9138646722,
-0.2319090068,
-0.4536973238,
0.245860815,
0.7434590459,
0.2962785363,
0.5359126329,
0.2737990022,
0.7141686678,
0.2308275849,
0.0430916399,
0.1245127767,
0.0431511961,
0.2469465137,
0.1063116267,
-0.4984909892,
-0.5839769244,
-0.030947065,
0.3136529028,
0.4535447657,
-0.0507741868,
0.1613602489,
-0.4698212445,
0.4368167222,
-0.3978615701,
-0.0436669774,
-0.5894035697,
-0.0534998253,
0.0751309618,
-0.5053222775,
-0.0789810717,
-0.3226703703,
0.208902359,
-0.7205123901,
-0.0104289763,
0.0747744143,
0.7498918772,
0.6976451278,
-0.2306976765,
0.1200229377,
-0.2922506928,
0.3700697422,
-0.5239716768,
0.189709723,
0.3990967274,
0.7382807136,
0.0365638696,
-0.6225517988,
-0.7102180123,
-0.1823744476,
0.0714231208,
0.4638622105,
-0.1340345442,
0.0369997732,
0.0781474859,
0.3665192723,
-0.8837199211,
-0.1228742823,
-0.5425322652,
0.0009544272,
0.3285954297,
0.4123346508,
0.6646190882,
-0.4160120189,
-0.605931282,
0.1457652748,
-0.6200087667,
0.4163455963,
-0.4837973416,
-0.0149729205,
-0.2479348481,
0.7769743204,
-0.1019405127,
0.8996017575,
-0.0829689428,
-0.0521525815,
0.2145798802,
-0.556152761,
-0.2945657074,
-0.3700060546,
0.5573708415,
0.4890238941,
-0.2433231473,
0.1666354984,
-0.0891460702,
0.1796056479,
0.289804846,
-0.5702776313,
-0.2758918703,
0.3479845524,
-0.7553165555,
-0.3338390589,
-0.3058570027,
-0.7464495301,
-0.475915879,
-0.2989050746,
0.7838878036,
-0.2725868821,
0.061889831,
-0.0955997482,
-0.0129769277,
0.3694595993,
0.9144623876,
-0.2780804038,
-0.1002860144,
0.1266916543,
0.6524890661,
-0.1709088534,
0.0838841423,
-0.9882234335,
-0.2348725051,
-0.1644634008,
0.8767904639,
-0.7037346959,
-0.3321228921,
-0.2548111379,
0.2750187814,
-0.3242228627,
-0.3991440237,
0.2208552063,
-0.799728334,
0.4330918193,
-0.5690992475,
-0.3063084781,
-0.2751777768,
0.1984795332,
-0.6851662993,
0.5375804305,
0.2306675911,
-0.6892240644,
0.1095673814,
-0.5450117588,
0.0001867775,
0.4459553063,
-0.7261229753,
-0.3135424852,
0.0633183718,
0.6653417349,
0.4775131643,
-0.6812137365,
0.2831940651,
-0.2601639926,
-0.0718921572,
0.4646146297,
-0.3309149146,
0.4092248082,
0.1541734189,
-0.005692923,
0.4871566296,
-0.6595668793,
-0.1169430614,
0.2911861539,
0.1047130972,
-0.2133671343,
-0.3843023777,
-0.0217101779,
0.5453341603,
0.3316843808,
-0.5409078598,
0.1682846248,
0.0213804096,
-0.0434744842,
0.6284632087,
0.4798067808,
0.1039738283,
-0.4420408607,
1.1010557413,
0.0132298889,
0.4474474788,
-0.2632672787,
-1.0037784576,
-0.2600432932,
-0.4725454748,
0.3260386586,
0.8533446789,
-1.2802191973,
-0.0567092486,
0.2246846706,
-0.3408863842,
-0.68142277,
-0.1671739966,
0.4320428967,
1.0373500586,
0.5509624481,
-0.3899330497,
-0.3072479665,
-0.8865147233,
0.2829518914,
-0.190571323,
0.0081922105,
0.6375936866,
0.2133978009,
0.0062786825,
0.5875415802,
-0.6089330316,
-0.2740959227,
-0.0643497854,
0.0779456869,
0.1654055119,
0.4005840123,
0.5195711851,
-1.0752441883,
-0.2809886038,
-0.0998291075,
-0.9267343879,
-0.0323731564,
-0.1487757564,
0.0956411436,
-0.0731052831,
0.3842839301,
-0.3718427122,
0.7663537264,
0.3372206986,
-0.3939486444,
0.4862089455,
-0.384202987,
0.5481628776,
-1.3005791903,
0.3475178182,
-0.0975689963,
-0.21831128,
-0.4722107947,
0.051742278,
0.1218477264,
-0.4125469327,
-0.4325163662,
0.6330105662,
-0.1868884563,
0.141885981,
-0.1200910509,
-0.1202876419,
-0.128736034,
0.4736985564,
0.2408417761,
1.0745879412,
0.6191071868,
-0.3944969177,
0.3700348437,
0.3112757504,
-0.2255283147,
0.6350523829,
-1.0168638229,
-0.0887856707,
-0.4104527533,
-0.0252737291,
-1.2443348169,
-0.2618462443,
0.3573854268,
-0.5872476697,
0.3031433523,
-0.2046260089,
-0.0163290873,
-0.4508408904,
0.010163025,
0.5786274076,
0.5101943016,
-0.3152527809,
0.7853771448,
0.3682747185,
-0.6515545845,
-0.7082741857,
-0.2960108221,
-0.0752442107,
0.0700983778,
-0.6541291475,
0.2192015648,
-0.3952565193,
-0.0651203394,
0.0227185711,
0.0576338172,
-0.2657143176,
-0.1257787049,
0.3456763327,
0.9556823969,
-0.2811365426,
0.1763538271,
0.0436268933,
-0.0344142355,
-0.1272317916,
0.1428231001,
0.3868010044,
-0.1276330352,
-0.4701372981,
-0.554225564,
0.6973778605,
0.7131910324,
-0.5458043218,
0.5612739921,
0.5320167542,
-0.4711275995,
0.5853254199,
-0.5871776342,
-0.2294029444,
-0.3735970557,
0.3208044171,
-0.3845033646,
-0.5820927024,
0.5728334785,
0.2222603112,
-0.1001656428,
0.2671517134,
0.6845045686,
-0.3567129076,
1.150218606,
0.6097921133,
0.4596849084,
0.3525570929,
-0.0988927856,
-0.2316370904,
-0.7623353004,
-0.5814062357,
-0.3111392856,
0.1644251794,
-0.0186399166,
-0.8983825445,
0.9648525715,
0.0481825173,
0.2101214826,
-0.1878359765,
-0.4747579992,
0.2017827332,
0.4708449841,
0.4490630627,
0.0379483774,
-0.0982529894,
-0.2134065479,
-0.0730708838,
-0.8660017252,
-0.2294448912,
0.9578121901,
0.2535128295,
0.8523027301,
-0.0400072671,
0.2529490888,
0.1879603118,
0.0125885755,
-0.5205425024,
0.4174818397,
-0.0189395621,
-0.3627208173,
-0.2452007234,
-0.1544404626,
-0.6492236853,
0.0371490791,
-0.5965508819,
-0.4732420444,
0.3469693661,
0.3314425349,
-0.6743825674,
0.0817449987,
-0.4565977454,
0.954962492,
-0.2334506661,
-0.4238227904,
0.0075195865,
-1.0011291504,
0.2915287912,
-0.0611391217,
0.1249392182,
0.1534917504,
-0.1369738579,
0.6285094023,
-0.5058243871,
0.7138587832,
-0.3447462916,
-0.0107193096,
0.2007781863,
-0.2544033825,
0.3726756275,
0.3227947056,
0.4548917413,
-0.1998214722,
0.2782030404,
-0.539450407,
-0.6298778057,
0.5383598804,
-0.5226148367,
-0.4719415903,
-0.2005975991,
-0.5035934448,
-0.242358759,
-0.0381541885,
0.298019141,
0.7747522593,
0.0608962588,
0.0162137058,
0.9721969366,
-0.5207098126,
0.3195126951,
0.3826507926,
-0.0736235604,
-0.5310744643,
0.7942290902,
-0.1818984747,
0.1346620768,
0.5361579657,
0.0632465407,
-0.5808976889,
-0.4868268371,
-1.0540089607,
0.337983489,
-0.7393948436,
-0.2668967843,
-0.7835632563,
-0.0462168902,
-0.2353440523,
-0.1227307543,
-0.0454646125,
-0.447132498,
-0.3196821213,
0.462502569,
0.4647927582,
0.491933316,
0.1599137485,
-0.0301533472,
-0.9473711252,
0.8537334204,
0.8575811982,
0.239531219,
-0.2470247149,
-0.4335148633,
0.2599171996,
-0.215570733,
0.0765333697,
-1.238846302,
0.1238239333,
-0.2313049436,
0.6188479066,
0.0113041038,
-0.0321807265,
0.5639243722,
-0.4877947271,
1.0467211008,
0.5679100752,
-0.3283272386,
0.6887487173,
-0.2733647227,
0.3065259457,
0.4787341356,
0.4425814152,
-0.3447186053,
-0.0228407122,
-0.4155191481,
-0.4951566458,
0.1749177277,
-0.0970736071,
-0.2647809386,
0.2063614577,
0.3393839598,
0.1945153028,
0.2524520159,
-0.4048391879,
-0.2518841028,
-0.1373488158,
-0.1727414131,
0.0644959956,
-0.1933924705,
-0.2018000633,
-0.325252533,
0.5522807837,
-0.2908273935,
0.326931119,
0.5377544165,
-0.1756305695,
-0.1738308221,
0.277979672,
0.6594389677,
0.7303967476,
-0.0488087535,
-0.090036951,
0.0717987046,
-0.5200994015,
-0.0091485018,
0.390065074,
-0.1238608658,
-0.0458360873,
0.1064953282,
0.7827942967,
-0.362949878,
-0.8586742878,
0.8039136529,
-0.569703877,
0.0249569155,
-0.1657593399,
-0.065509297,
-0.0887192041,
0.383735925,
0.4097516835,
0.2522930205,
0.206112951,
-0.2291817963,
0.3234239221,
0.4913823307,
-0.6426973343,
-0.1092533916,
0.9676857591,
0.0429699756,
-0.0419170111,
0.2938110828,
0.3420302868,
-0.4026388824,
0.6153223515,
0.1851946115,
0.4125141203,
-0.3233541548,
0.3089390695,
0.2237626761,
0.0824499354,
0.5874660611,
0.9880002141,
0.0006567787,
-0.1023087054,
-0.5685409307,
-0.4500529468,
-0.2429844886,
0.2672728896,
-0.4826879501,
0.1565329731,
-0.2957949042,
-0.1108072773,
0.2392243445,
-0.0926791206,
-0.7712851167,
0.5359044671,
0.2445138246,
0.79229182,
-0.8616206646,
0.6029418707,
0.9938059449,
-0.9021224976,
-0.8285773396,
-0.2632890344,
-0.1313711256,
-0.8803437352,
0.3050869107,
-0.1822151542,
0.1411580145,
-0.2704641223,
-0.6281980276,
-0.6197904348,
0.9382202625,
0.0836276114,
-0.3202732503,
-0.0473664738,
-0.2341261506,
0.3584789336,
-0.4175117314,
0.3022656739,
-0.0860074684,
0.1910371035,
0.468483001,
-0.925355494,
0.2989419997,
-0.5782808065,
0.0098429006,
-0.1865707189,
-0.1838223487,
0.8661008477,
-0.7105181813,
0.2022078186,
0.427000016,
0.4232541323,
0.4118309319,
0.3532444835,
0.4736308753,
0.1839892417,
0.780639112,
0.0361244343,
1.1408656836,
-0.2230204493,
-0.1887382716,
0.8991667628,
0.1504151523,
0.7250971198,
0.7191649079,
-0.0346443281,
0.3936127722,
0.7818375826,
0.1989417225,
0.5615377426,
-0.142645061,
-0.4293154776,
-0.5951337814,
-0.2911334634,
-0.9062252045,
0.2610926926,
0.2806891203,
-0.3854148388,
0.0367099419,
0.2540798485,
-0.5476493835,
-0.169678703,
-0.3009797037,
0.8785901666,
-0.0574755594,
-0.6536201239,
0.7814570069,
-0.3923057318,
0.2612937689,
-0.4605796933,
-0.4510779381,
-0.1298235357,
-0.3382210732,
0.0726409182,
-0.5903215408,
-0.1861386448,
-0.2662221193,
-0.4288040996,
0.4404733777,
0.7316531539,
-0.5390788317,
-0.4032745957,
-0.3297399879,
0.8727248907,
0.1338197291,
0.07028348,
-0.9198863506,
-0.1233779788,
-0.1102979705,
0.1638130546,
0.2261388451,
0.0348641761,
-0.2373314202,
0.6524341702,
0.6707439423,
-0.0133608244,
0.1194222867,
-0.0054888004,
1.0268975496,
-0.4135544002,
-0.5971674919,
-0.0954231173,
0.6168787479,
-0.0969874933,
-0.1813707054,
0.2750715613,
0.0688988641,
0.079352878,
-0.3978213072,
0.65994519,
0.025704788,
0.5289050937,
-0.7940717936,
0.7983907461,
-1.13804245,
0.1199302524,
-0.3455194831,
-0.5244371295,
-0.3499349654,
0.4325864315,
-0.2380166352,
-0.0383001827,
0.6205459833,
0.8519782424,
-0.0754404441,
0.0066316961,
0.4497209489,
-0.0789443329,
0.1539730579,
0.6286241412,
0.8912448287,
-0.3354622126,
0.2408325076,
-0.260386616,
-0.5267843604,
-0.2566203177,
-0.5567025542,
-0.8760384321,
-0.8948021531,
-0.4221153557,
-0.418192327,
0.0168892965,
0.7554284334,
0.7738947868,
-0.5305334926,
0.4668971896,
0.206390515,
0.0142783727,
-0.1191677302,
-0.1317788959,
0.6350953579,
-0.2097320557,
-0.3361649513,
0.5528501868,
0.2299047709,
0.3553108573,
-0.0741228312,
0.0853124335,
-0.259927839,
-0.0315501541,
0.3831486106,
0.4650242329,
-0.7643795013,
0.0280792341,
0.3408561945,
-0.1244806722,
0.1981816143,
0.7336345315,
-1.0489877462,
0.8272200823,
0.6118189096,
0.7904028893,
0.2344086468,
0.1385899335,
0.6239677668,
-0.4127365947,
-0.0131606795,
0.2508095503,
0.3630345166,
0.2726589739,
-0.4708915651,
0.1027342603,
0.3464818299,
-0.3804320693,
-0.5996054411,
0.2204765975,
-1.3144165277,
-0.4233407974,
0.8535189629,
-0.0702046305,
-0.4742017984,
-0.2396326661,
-0.6333813071,
0.1766202003,
-0.1745488048,
0.456284672,
0.0571085885,
-0.2116408795,
-0.6488947868,
-0.4813988507,
0.621055007,
0.6717839837,
-1.1144709587,
-0.3678247333,
0.7629902959,
0.3124679029,
-0.0347283818,
0.8246807456,
-0.3475903571,
1.1385236979,
-0.2619943023,
-0.1382011771,
-0.2304061502,
-0.5455530882,
-0.5970056057,
0.2854653299,
-0.0758442879,
-0.5412504673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13033v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13033v1
|
Sample Design Engineering: An Empirical Study of What Makes Good Downstream Fine-Tuning Samples for LLMs
| 2024-04-19T17:47:02 | 2024-04-19T17:47:02 |
Biyang Guo, He Wang, Wenyilin Xiao, Hong Chen, Zhuxin Lee, Songqiao Han, Hailiang Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the burgeoning field of Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT and
LLaMA, Prompt Engineering (PE) is renowned for boosting zero-shot or in-context
learning (ICL) through prompt modifications. Yet, the realm of the sample
design for downstream fine-tuning, crucial for task-specific LLM adaptation, is
largely unexplored. This paper introduces Sample Design Engineering (SDE), a
methodical approach to enhancing LLMs' post-tuning performance by refining
input, output, and reasoning designs. We conduct a series of in-domain (ID) and
out-of-domain (OOD) experiments to assess the impact of various design options
on LLMs' downstream performance, revealing several intriguing patterns that
hold consistently across different LLMs. Based on these insights, we propose an
integrated SDE strategy, combining the most effective options, and validate its
consistent superiority over heuristic sample designs in complex downstream
tasks like multi-aspect sentiment analysis, event extraction, and nested entity
recognition. Additionally, analyses of LLMs' inherent prompt/output perplexity,
zero-shot, and ICL abilities illustrate that good PE strategies may not always
translate to good SDE strategies. Code available at
https://github.com/beyondguo/LLM-Tuning.
|
[
-0.7688792944,
-0.4763632119,
0.671441853,
0.0913494751,
-0.4616018236,
0.3891678452,
-0.3394032121,
-0.276614964,
-0.0459568389,
0.4202404618,
-0.8727465868,
-0.5972144008,
-0.3763179481,
0.0032580988,
0.03565244,
0.9449508786,
-0.2993280888,
-0.0296442974,
0.1120012105,
0.1917888671,
-0.807254374,
-0.2222644538,
-0.9921674728,
-0.0547071584,
0.5722617507,
0.7046149373,
-0.0028366053,
0.4483719468,
0.2384924889,
0.1263948083,
-0.2388891578,
0.2401132435,
-0.769235909,
0.2506385744,
-0.4322197735,
-0.4922903776,
-0.3016086221,
0.1018521562,
0.2693781555,
0.5373812318,
0.1842499226,
0.5079439282,
0.5665949583,
0.3979816437,
-0.8685263395,
0.1928171068,
-0.6642811894,
-0.3559390903,
-0.2630500793,
-0.3851658106,
-0.5009010434,
-0.2678227425,
-0.2452074885,
-0.3323351741,
0.1897279173,
0.2287161201,
0.7717601657,
0.4952297509,
-0.14309223,
-0.346718967,
-0.5919938087,
0.9726628661,
-0.9551478028,
0.2894542515,
0.0413969457,
0.2615215778,
-0.5772506595,
-0.3234755695,
-0.3164758384,
-0.1142526492,
0.1186987162,
0.1779858619,
0.262029171,
0.1708638817,
0.1032101586,
0.3960462809,
-0.3494294584,
0.6140779853,
-0.328520745,
-0.088920258,
0.7474068403,
-0.1625953019,
0.2895442545,
0.2108990103,
-0.3284623921,
-0.0447793938,
-1.0039412975,
0.4276839793,
0.338678807,
0.5294902325,
-0.0355029665,
0.4328609109,
-0.42664814,
0.527350843,
0.2146195173,
-0.079708524,
0.0044888523,
-0.2673526108,
-0.1334413439,
0.0093353605,
0.5621419549,
0.326220721,
0.1437170208,
-0.1735033244,
-0.4875581264,
-0.1251872629,
0.2813535929,
-0.8471542597,
-0.1547083706,
0.4977172017,
-0.4060790539,
-0.3085387349,
-0.1537616253,
-0.5852506757,
-0.3840343356,
-0.8053998947,
0.2818187475,
-0.3970700204,
-0.2004861683,
0.0240559224,
-0.3670275509,
0.3520457447,
0.2347349524,
-0.7935809493,
0.0659933612,
0.8607100248,
0.6848698854,
-0.4785651863,
-0.2165779471,
-0.7457106113,
-0.1514150649,
-0.4900766015,
1.3034082651,
-0.3814852536,
-0.6691067815,
-0.1346130669,
-0.1805778742,
0.0383815169,
-0.6806972623,
0.9091004729,
-0.6861971021,
-0.1134394854,
-0.399553299,
-0.7329508662,
-0.0217669364,
-0.0552095734,
-0.4225444198,
0.7921068668,
-0.0541000292,
-0.2921362221,
0.7404646873,
-0.6114072204,
-0.17867966,
0.1064995229,
-0.309289366,
-0.1614264995,
0.5610662699,
0.3277554512,
0.4294750094,
-0.1012214497,
-0.1711745113,
-0.5732399225,
-0.6100112796,
-0.0359547473,
-0.1310059428,
0.6445729733,
0.4547436833,
-0.029012097,
0.281416744,
-0.8976995945,
0.2465871125,
-0.1000569016,
-0.4649088979,
-0.3937918246,
0.2641722262,
0.0288770348,
0.1161962524,
-0.0250056349,
-0.6099523902,
0.2234141082,
-0.4231607914,
0.4440456033,
0.9041384459,
0.2358211875,
0.7337788939,
-0.4121648967,
0.4956193864,
-0.2369258702,
-0.0265615042,
-0.4094475508,
-0.2305071503,
-0.6065529585,
-0.5777059793,
0.3446157575,
0.5181174874,
-0.6523507833,
0.4544371068,
0.0287585165,
-0.1792576313,
-0.4755326807,
0.3887280226,
-0.0423895195,
0.2904378772,
0.1692757457,
-0.2027139217,
-0.5804646015,
-0.7133180499,
-0.2499162257,
-0.0320028588,
-0.4898307025,
0.1628056467,
0.1568888724,
0.0822958946,
1.2281953096,
-0.4921991229,
-0.0308133233,
-0.4033363461,
0.0368355215,
0.5019789338,
0.1960679591,
0.7355188131,
-0.2207335681,
-0.2341914773,
-0.2150798738,
-0.412504077,
-0.6471984982,
-0.2640073001,
-0.325384587,
-0.1918048263,
0.5589061975,
-0.3383690417,
0.1920041293,
0.3170892596,
-0.0253327843,
0.4505850971,
-0.0954700038,
0.0508212075,
-1.0200463533,
-0.4077810645,
0.134996891,
0.1469349712,
-0.3446491659,
0.3827549219,
0.1791204661,
-0.1282927394,
-0.491656661,
0.61689955,
-0.5784154534,
0.2907996178,
-0.7266424298,
-0.0424725302,
-0.0227804556,
0.4577271342,
-0.1900238991,
1.0459229946,
0.3908980787,
-0.8094763756,
-0.0126357628,
-0.1872780174,
-0.4918859601,
0.6741322875,
-0.6393051147,
0.2866710424,
-0.3172625601,
0.1079144999,
-1.3293830156,
-0.0185965262,
0.0048330105,
-0.1825445592,
0.5038256049,
-0.2977476716,
-0.3700796068,
-0.1564519405,
-0.4911684692,
0.1577576399,
0.6376867294,
-0.722789824,
0.2633273005,
0.211013034,
-0.5366953015,
-0.0183640961,
-0.2927869558,
0.0331995375,
-0.3173335195,
-0.489143312,
0.4848340154,
-0.162592411,
-0.3399101198,
-0.3442079425,
-0.322462678,
0.0029442643,
0.2646908462,
-0.0967625603,
0.2810793519,
-0.3880641162,
0.0172339436,
0.5075110793,
-0.0964777023,
0.0819083527,
-0.272344768,
0.4379286468,
0.3569957912,
-0.3957901597,
-0.3484646976,
0.3740617931,
0.3023277223,
-0.0131023498,
0.1463487893,
0.1832187921,
-0.1321150064,
-0.9222632051,
-0.4129044116,
-0.4129378796,
-0.5119843483,
0.2335759848,
-0.5873607993,
-0.7739858031,
0.3442825973,
-0.5637959838,
0.5292978287,
0.0003086856,
0.4517501891,
-0.5818317533,
0.5736116171,
0.7795892954,
-0.0632041767,
0.6774550676,
-0.1499889046,
0.3408228755,
-0.8887329102,
0.4669097066,
-0.4893299937,
-0.4910815358,
-0.4884584248,
-0.2539309263,
0.1273118109,
0.5684195757,
-0.1485492587,
0.1766043752,
-0.2482162565,
0.7373809814,
0.6379551291,
0.0195304491,
0.2202195674,
-0.0582425259,
-0.0598115027,
-0.0118191903,
-0.3977049887,
-0.9237723947,
0.8831162453,
0.3162039816,
0.9739531279,
-0.0811402574,
0.9073536992,
0.1766058803,
0.3075634241,
-0.9805219769,
0.4269741178,
-0.1505202204,
-0.2586069405,
-0.1124605983,
0.0475350693,
-0.632992506,
0.2888845801,
0.0789204165,
-0.7226698399,
0.3897919357,
0.2195104957,
-0.518478632,
0.0814896077,
-0.9611494541,
0.4103687704,
-0.1435473561,
-0.1944954693,
-0.1238971651,
-0.1762780398,
0.3616853058,
-0.1523241848,
0.1730514914,
-0.1650015265,
-0.049317047,
0.2371504158,
-0.3125069141,
1.0225743055,
-0.0286436025,
-0.4884917736,
0.2980821431,
-0.1235346124,
0.5324229598,
0.2060158849,
-0.1333947182,
0.1145835146,
-0.0149826892,
-0.485680759,
-0.6790270209,
0.7320281863,
-0.6398130655,
-0.6813949943,
0.1204465479,
-0.3619633913,
-0.5176742077,
0.0060187108,
0.3412886858,
0.1448860168,
-0.0296415407,
0.0716045499,
0.8466387391,
-0.3492954075,
0.5675637722,
0.5095970035,
0.0581887551,
-0.203168124,
0.9634476304,
0.1022441089,
0.3464074135,
0.4691519737,
0.1012837589,
-0.2323147804,
-0.8516820669,
-0.7322024107,
0.0567596219,
-0.5957869887,
0.0156806763,
-0.1760574132,
-0.3163194656,
-0.3750256002,
-0.2949624062,
-0.3432559073,
-0.0691844746,
-0.4201572239,
-0.0466068164,
0.1893165559,
0.5636185408,
0.2378125936,
0.3720443547,
-0.6214054823,
0.1806816012,
0.1472174823,
0.4625531733,
-0.082938984,
-0.6288815737,
0.0682520866,
0.1662323922,
-0.5420209765,
-0.6440111995,
-0.0771216229,
0.075109534,
0.8863438964,
0.2890548408,
0.1833048612,
0.4833112359,
-0.6363328099,
0.7119565606,
-0.2698000669,
-0.6667523384,
0.7107229233,
-0.2442917377,
0.2104170769,
0.5986230373,
0.1701916754,
-0.3259222209,
-0.3472352326,
-0.1850071549,
-0.8405623436,
0.4329826534,
0.0458203256,
0.0775916204,
0.2721343935,
0.5759341717,
0.3523264229,
0.1514143795,
-0.136068061,
-0.0663398728,
0.0175737292,
-0.3737365901,
0.0143903289,
-0.2592230737,
0.1180542931,
0.0965031311,
0.6144753098,
-0.2776583433,
-0.1439967602,
-0.1019321829,
-0.133528769,
0.3063397706,
0.5313022733,
0.6990315914,
0.6317023039,
-0.1998511255,
-0.013643858,
0.2769643962,
-0.3564738035,
0.1525071412,
0.0133247487,
-0.4081398547,
-0.2089340836,
0.3197069168,
0.7320258617,
0.1096849665,
-0.5335956216,
0.1028942615,
-0.0454844572,
-0.1371172369,
0.1297937334,
0.4232166409,
-0.0468306504,
0.2777244747,
0.4113577902,
-0.0846623033,
0.2404484451,
-0.4489867091,
0.0657707378,
0.3395426273,
-0.1394901425,
-0.4095316827,
0.6205598116,
0.3131335974,
-0.3122597933,
0.2892057598,
-0.2017284334,
0.0789922625,
0.5825694799,
0.3610114455,
0.9520527124,
0.0135034928,
0.0004857576,
0.1263644397,
0.2120890766,
0.2268888503,
0.3958857656,
-0.1962870061,
-0.6712479591,
-0.9863744974,
-0.7508162856,
-0.4967106283,
0.4195475578,
-0.4273527861,
0.7328838706,
-0.3728670776,
0.0449448004,
-0.1860459745,
-0.1181035712,
-0.5301013589,
0.0845749676,
0.2817344964,
1.0703502893,
-0.6525629759,
0.627541244,
0.7673467398,
-0.3178318441,
-0.6308700442,
0.1339087486,
0.1252151877,
-0.8168500066,
0.7200607657,
-0.1404217631,
-0.0439911857,
0.032375861,
-0.6348183751,
-0.9590913057,
0.8522444367,
0.3314570189,
-0.7955921888,
0.1285275966,
0.005176262,
0.4041876495,
-0.2228464633,
0.2932868004,
0.570377171,
-0.008728832,
0.2625059187,
-0.7542011738,
-0.0223665293,
-0.2245411724,
0.3504181802,
0.1122271121,
-0.6916067004,
0.5163300633,
-0.2942606211,
-0.3910783529,
-0.0179331917,
0.6898809075,
0.7616124749,
0.2182386965,
0.5387182236,
0.3323625326,
0.6383146048,
0.008971367,
0.8341670632,
-0.3667368591,
0.0693981946,
1.4764339924,
-0.4632112086,
0.9431551695,
0.7340070009,
-0.0959631726,
0.1147463918,
1.0892516375,
0.2326135486,
0.7891381979,
0.557435751,
-0.2152643949,
-0.0078117214,
-0.0871306583,
-0.2290482223,
0.196549058,
0.3387829661,
-0.2176760435,
-0.5036414266,
0.0282356553,
-0.1878031045,
-0.0995458439,
-0.2311665863,
0.8343417645,
0.3278958499,
-0.5227015615,
0.4372142255,
-0.2021917403,
0.835105598,
-0.2519507706,
-0.0914238244,
-0.5028170943,
0.2764509618,
0.0020740114,
-0.8509780169,
0.2389277965,
-0.1111712307,
-0.2852752507,
-0.5444141626,
0.5670102239,
0.0094145723,
-0.3122791052,
0.0619673505,
0.4106128812,
-0.0064643868,
-0.1441883743,
-0.2400793433,
0.1926945597,
-0.0968757197,
-0.2706844807,
0.4115260243,
0.5858553648,
-0.1113378555,
0.4236667752,
0.7441295981,
0.3690317869,
-0.0286443681,
0.395930022,
0.9159657955,
-0.5358378887,
-0.3876964152,
-0.8720484376,
0.5111184716,
-0.163959235,
-0.5616230965,
0.6236391068,
0.5703940392,
1.2147804499,
-0.1110660508,
1.123669982,
0.2089390606,
0.5911949873,
-0.7708265781,
0.4824273884,
-0.3743368089,
0.5337813497,
-0.0597275384,
-0.8085465431,
0.0305057392,
0.2840721607,
-0.2980231345,
-0.1317074895,
0.5190903544,
0.7872638106,
-0.1293315291,
0.2685817778,
0.2217529267,
0.0226590354,
0.7619726658,
0.5270575881,
1.0320390463,
-0.1886502802,
0.3773384988,
-0.2158585638,
-0.5078278184,
-0.0673372,
-0.9082508683,
-0.9016404152,
-0.297768563,
-0.2772960365,
0.0927056745,
-0.1188580766,
0.9487021565,
0.7819489241,
-0.9820907712,
-0.2894745767,
-0.1257354766,
0.0368698426,
-0.2185676694,
-0.2106478065,
0.018830942,
-1.0057915449,
-0.9187024236,
0.5396215916,
0.3782581091,
-0.0282180458,
-0.1816346347,
0.2711597383,
0.3177900314,
0.0583447702,
0.8388207555,
0.0416288748,
-0.7271745205,
-0.1541010588,
0.1775586456,
0.0391773283,
0.0215032157,
1.0221883059,
-0.5872893929,
0.0831609815,
0.7181192636,
0.9045968652,
0.2061701864,
-0.0136243012,
0.7369244099,
-0.7777842283,
-0.0901862308,
0.0422172584,
0.4565368891,
-0.0264598243,
-0.4430440366,
0.3450880051,
0.0176611077,
-0.6610181928,
-0.6927868724,
0.3036593199,
-0.8410305977,
-0.5659769773,
1.2491410971,
0.0815903246,
-0.1617504507,
-0.2163354307,
-0.7517516613,
-0.0440934449,
-0.5008225441,
0.8821784854,
1.0068315268,
-0.318135798,
-0.3101965487,
-0.7764686346,
0.3278499544,
0.0983099267,
-0.8331457376,
-0.1015691981,
0.2181183696,
0.5027740598,
-0.0684040189,
0.403522402,
0.2943089902,
0.0223221742,
-0.3126773834,
0.0175848827,
0.1823289841,
0.0557958633,
-0.17412889,
0.1594669074,
0.3995101452,
-0.4818020761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13020v1
|
Stronger Random Baselines for In-Context Learning
| 2024-04-19T17:30:10 | 2024-04-19T17:30:10 |
Gregory Yauney, David Mimno
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Evaluating the in-context learning classification performance of language
models poses challenges due to small dataset sizes, extensive prompt-selection
using the validation set, and intentionally difficult tasks that lead to
near-random performance. The standard random baseline -- the expected accuracy
of guessing labels uniformly at random -- is stable when the evaluation set is
used only once or when the dataset is large. We account for the common practice
of validation set reuse and existing small datasets with a stronger random
baseline: the expected maximum accuracy across multiple random classifiers.
When choosing the best prompt demonstrations across six quantized language
models applied to 16 BIG-bench Lite tasks, more than 20\% of the few-shot
results that exceed the standard baseline do not exceed this stronger random
baseline. When held-out test sets are available, this stronger baseline is also
a better predictor of held-out performance than the standard baseline, avoiding
unnecessary test set evaluations. This maximum random baseline provides an
easily calculated drop-in replacement for the standard baseline.
|
[
-0.317091167,
-0.5341157317,
0.2781355381,
0.1180029213,
-0.0619056113,
-0.2710929215,
-0.540995419,
-0.340634495,
-0.6631089449,
0.1747745574,
-0.2170744985,
-0.3996416926,
-0.5692045093,
0.1405219883,
-0.5505017042,
1.0780054331,
0.0140323881,
0.1448153555,
-0.5732501745,
-0.6439657807,
-0.6096441746,
-0.3978494704,
-0.5542333722,
-0.4973460734,
0.411670357,
0.6136874557,
0.5699154735,
0.4562536478,
0.4862083793,
0.2418996096,
-0.1115462258,
-0.2248886973,
-0.5185573101,
0.1223264709,
-0.0439184792,
-0.4408739805,
0.0837753341,
0.061356321,
1.0046652555,
1.0557409525,
-0.2995738685,
0.2871642411,
0.2398141026,
0.3232973814,
-0.7856433988,
-0.010748039,
-0.4380365014,
0.1220483333,
-0.1356568336,
-0.0516246408,
-0.6690149307,
-0.4153632224,
0.3720383644,
-0.4409328997,
0.0425501689,
0.0626155883,
1.0234416723,
0.1918973178,
-0.516163528,
-0.0266985297,
-0.6000086069,
0.9874295592,
-0.3561446071,
0.4727925658,
0.4201562405,
0.6738460064,
-0.1379724592,
-0.8626124859,
-0.3361311853,
-0.4886685312,
0.134101361,
0.0292215347,
-0.0115187773,
-0.0002634928,
0.5698176622,
0.4098121822,
-0.3544743359,
0.4159696102,
-0.2398753762,
-0.1122997329,
0.2303393781,
0.0978766829,
0.1359922439,
0.0771067441,
-0.3687463403,
-0.3113446534,
-0.8702012897,
0.3138144016,
-0.1230914518,
0.3913490176,
0.0028991459,
0.3550186753,
-0.461728096,
0.9565158486,
0.0982178822,
-0.3451890349,
0.4024795592,
-0.3375029862,
-0.4470730424,
-0.2625161409,
0.5583788157,
0.2463043779,
0.3175468743,
-0.0327727906,
-0.4427436292,
-0.2807718515,
-0.0150169991,
-0.6605069637,
-0.2049361467,
0.0552820452,
-0.4238010347,
-0.2023884356,
-0.0430575646,
-0.2241423726,
-0.2977510989,
-0.5359755158,
0.5370688438,
-0.4435506463,
0.3017015755,
-0.071485348,
-0.3733580112,
0.0608231537,
0.5052259564,
-0.5869585276,
0.3104388416,
0.3924554884,
0.49271366,
-0.1201665178,
-0.5117635727,
-0.5682292581,
-0.1227253973,
-0.4095326662,
0.6701855063,
-0.4208551049,
-0.2142958343,
0.1012824923,
-0.226347208,
0.0118040778,
-0.6520749331,
0.4277626872,
-0.3978672028,
0.5402641296,
-0.6337433457,
-0.8225593567,
0.2135716826,
0.1145724878,
-0.4452104867,
1.2577160597,
0.5193901658,
-0.6637012959,
1.2018820047,
0.0006126541,
-0.3275250196,
0.272742182,
-0.2772052884,
-0.3619405031,
0.1661705971,
0.1159009188,
0.5328933597,
-0.2174579799,
0.2396194786,
-0.4095272124,
-0.6414810419,
0.2334258854,
-0.4682435989,
0.9525692463,
0.2284401953,
-0.3376421034,
-0.0766560957,
-0.9711534977,
0.1663574427,
-0.1443645507,
-0.3809339404,
-0.5420444608,
-0.0506815016,
-0.0042582192,
0.2743120492,
0.0507405326,
-0.3725311458,
-0.1253408492,
-0.138619855,
0.0010728213,
0.8183515668,
0.0950194597,
0.5507814884,
-0.4609815478,
0.3006894588,
-0.049775634,
0.0646612421,
-0.0979431421,
-0.4078838825,
-0.4562466741,
-0.4960576594,
0.5524504185,
0.3608427346,
-0.5266984701,
0.427410394,
-0.4855235815,
-0.3753812015,
-0.2201651335,
0.3290702701,
0.7066688538,
0.7349857688,
0.2182626277,
-0.1739972234,
-0.3779944181,
-0.9658682346,
-0.0475242175,
-0.052559603,
-0.2617812455,
0.1830714792,
0.5337684155,
-0.0410643741,
1.2101413012,
-0.0529177561,
0.0190095473,
-0.3319730163,
0.1973116398,
-0.0290588066,
0.5192771554,
0.6048285961,
-0.691205442,
-0.571909368,
-0.0552959442,
-0.8784193397,
-0.1129338145,
-0.0532461815,
0.1629828811,
0.1100307629,
0.4040122628,
-0.2193895131,
0.2266888618,
0.3712749779,
0.0052363328,
0.5513723493,
0.0532594584,
0.0723995566,
-0.9579691887,
-0.0274059307,
0.1258377284,
-0.1912472397,
-0.4980930388,
0.1256957352,
0.3614598215,
-0.1283410192,
-0.5335512757,
0.8196011186,
-0.183291018,
-0.0393623821,
-0.0259611048,
0.10707964,
-0.1438346356,
0.1353068352,
-0.0079572406,
0.9119441509,
0.5119996667,
-0.7280278802,
0.0127076497,
0.0706294253,
-0.8197759986,
0.8170144558,
-0.4832673371,
-0.1641867757,
0.000070196,
0.664496243,
-0.8704079986,
-0.5187746286,
-0.2916482091,
-0.2589656115,
0.383477211,
0.1022033021,
-0.5350952744,
-0.2390643805,
-0.211695075,
0.3370218575,
0.5831503272,
-1.0413267612,
0.0140805496,
0.323475033,
0.1899246722,
-0.885103941,
-0.6070028543,
-0.1201196313,
-0.3383350074,
-0.3626039326,
0.1089723483,
-0.0314334482,
-0.3831672966,
-0.260340184,
-0.3317472637,
-0.1046500355,
0.322243005,
0.2803345323,
-0.0600343235,
-0.1198969483,
0.3623264134,
-0.1148891002,
-0.0176869128,
-0.0976025015,
-0.092719309,
0.1222945228,
-0.2795119286,
-0.1608061194,
-0.4427600205,
0.0666597784,
0.3032648861,
0.2853650749,
0.9063469768,
0.3572209775,
-0.62511307,
-0.5964912176,
-0.4498079121,
-0.2273348123,
-0.4305316508,
0.4211381972,
-0.712738812,
-0.9587669373,
0.5621541142,
0.1865864992,
0.1134401932,
0.3421062529,
0.459854275,
-0.4750267863,
0.9696289897,
0.5167654157,
-0.021104373,
0.6169965863,
-0.0273195598,
-0.1214922294,
-0.5944173932,
-0.0521122403,
-0.6080387831,
-0.1345273256,
-0.3615063429,
-0.1493044794,
0.0299798753,
0.2858706117,
-0.4282498956,
0.3344675004,
-0.333990097,
0.6687526107,
0.678157866,
0.1021468714,
0.0454409905,
0.0932815224,
-0.3947407007,
-0.003958418,
-0.7910400033,
-0.5489536524,
1.1420121193,
0.3154353201,
0.5382823944,
-0.2720900476,
0.8038576841,
0.0507166497,
0.7714813948,
-0.4818359911,
0.5292847753,
0.0224946886,
-0.7254075408,
-0.4381977618,
-0.6189409494,
-0.8743344545,
0.2061819136,
-0.0463486165,
-0.8010872602,
0.1237636134,
0.1663814932,
-0.4925605357,
0.0946735889,
-0.7791718841,
0.898312211,
0.2261212021,
-0.1236964613,
0.1105274558,
-0.7176125646,
0.4065380692,
-0.0259827431,
0.129425168,
0.0545511916,
0.0973189548,
0.6933948398,
-0.3756444156,
0.75683254,
-0.1763333678,
0.0778026655,
0.4267135561,
-0.1788032353,
0.4136725664,
0.0584283546,
-0.0273209903,
0.0092792111,
-0.0469052345,
-0.6629119515,
-0.7153782845,
0.4397385418,
-0.7878293991,
-0.1855876744,
-0.5232713223,
-0.2672030032,
-0.4309032261,
-0.0705921426,
0.6897305846,
0.6864579916,
-0.4156384468,
0.7874352932,
0.8449926972,
-0.0064327684,
0.2462432534,
0.2912578285,
0.0779219493,
-0.4692753553,
0.8628424406,
0.360130161,
0.5054606795,
0.4960358441,
0.2704417706,
-0.1527623534,
-0.7675700188,
-0.2253157347,
-0.2741441131,
-1.1379364729,
-0.2705589235,
-0.3819997013,
-0.1277594119,
-0.2219045907,
-0.4893345237,
-0.2047117501,
-0.5728305578,
0.0149463341,
-0.3130244017,
-0.0382583402,
0.3447850049,
-0.0277497936,
0.4199958146,
-0.4466430247,
0.0240918528,
0.5704826713,
0.3896439672,
-0.1072044224,
-0.7827184796,
-0.453014642,
-0.1619884372,
-0.0225293227,
-0.591719687,
-0.0175585505,
0.2332054526,
0.6851292849,
0.396930784,
-0.1248808056,
0.6513799429,
-0.390933603,
0.7323876023,
0.1277405024,
-0.6510398388,
0.4004478753,
-0.4021663368,
0.5413654447,
1.1161484718,
0.3498326242,
-0.3839474916,
-0.5660030246,
-0.8362814188,
-0.8326179385,
0.6264203787,
0.1859763563,
-0.0846686065,
-0.2475943416,
0.3063479066,
0.1560176313,
0.226552397,
-0.8767938018,
-0.2670251429,
0.115820393,
-0.3384187818,
-0.1989781857,
-0.183131218,
-0.2946135998,
-0.3486713171,
0.4912793636,
-0.1636039019,
0.1443965286,
-0.2807195783,
-0.5309906602,
-0.0524678528,
0.229737252,
0.5090091228,
0.8478244543,
-0.4541389644,
0.116160281,
0.6738992333,
-0.3334597349,
0.0721259788,
-0.0907281488,
-0.2597378194,
-0.1444806904,
0.5175006986,
0.749348104,
0.9317480922,
-0.8134797215,
0.4934392869,
-0.1063810736,
-0.0705011934,
-0.3782588542,
0.0601738878,
-0.3154147863,
-0.153753683,
0.5110741258,
0.1291950494,
0.0483723283,
-0.4252508283,
0.5725863576,
0.2351157069,
-0.3797900379,
-0.0615510345,
0.3440826833,
-0.0100729102,
-0.0583171844,
0.7677772641,
-0.2459830344,
-0.2110122293,
0.8116821051,
0.5653666854,
0.7052848935,
-0.1278764904,
0.1792397648,
0.5405342579,
0.0921967924,
-0.5547876954,
0.0021858509,
-0.2806898057,
-0.7592353821,
-0.164157331,
-0.5941291451,
-0.632930398,
0.0734109804,
-0.8494861722,
0.3138627708,
-0.5964018106,
-0.1293913573,
-0.2293610871,
0.0762389526,
-0.7325575948,
0.6679148674,
0.1520183235,
0.8898719549,
-0.9527332783,
0.7938497066,
0.5919148326,
-0.4376647174,
-0.7232496738,
-0.1758105159,
0.161786139,
-0.5721906424,
0.7015068531,
0.3315897286,
0.3999345005,
-0.1698904634,
-0.5541729927,
-1.008058548,
0.99650985,
0.1845416874,
-0.4314718843,
0.1338244826,
-0.2110747993,
0.6664093137,
-0.4594378471,
0.5477556586,
0.545655489,
0.2306388915,
0.0427171402,
-0.8497004509,
-0.0379613154,
-0.011737939,
0.0798680708,
0.0235687625,
-0.6161492467,
0.7101578116,
0.069272548,
-0.1917034537,
0.0724826306,
0.7777693272,
0.8081580997,
0.4416940212,
0.4829782248,
0.7065081596,
1.0234487057,
-0.3037522435,
1.4350786209,
0.0889348537,
0.2658479214,
1.397334218,
-0.2578018904,
1.1716855764,
0.2302449197,
-0.2128598243,
0.3367204368,
0.8869473934,
-0.003330061,
0.4715909362,
0.1725504249,
-0.1337211877,
-0.21432437,
0.1727679223,
-0.2961765528,
0.2522553504,
0.2398782372,
-0.1368723214,
-0.3105349541,
0.3270488083,
-0.0581553169,
0.0792534798,
-0.1714665294,
0.4725500047,
0.1691410244,
-0.7035552859,
0.6712898612,
-0.2856543958,
0.4488216639,
-0.3551944792,
0.268274188,
-0.2032402456,
0.2642684281,
-0.0524743125,
-0.7151087523,
-0.1559200585,
-0.0282762162,
-0.2828683555,
-0.5377646089,
0.4648348987,
-0.2945193648,
-0.2586289644,
0.0698147342,
0.2008280158,
0.0420419425,
0.2421471775,
-0.6591911316,
-0.0996755064,
-0.1809956133,
-0.5198721886,
0.912019074,
0.5545698404,
-0.2703411579,
0.7695237398,
0.3970938325,
-0.2327441424,
0.2398531139,
0.3433704674,
0.6024253964,
-0.4031727612,
-0.3331119716,
-0.442465961,
0.5051248074,
-0.2529944777,
-0.7851797938,
1.0778837204,
0.4899976254,
1.1085751057,
0.1251469553,
0.7213122845,
0.0026668347,
0.4309871197,
-0.3958187699,
0.4807060063,
-0.5523377657,
0.1526645571,
-0.2696662247,
-0.9254698157,
-0.3317365348,
0.7383999825,
-0.2653424144,
0.3319959044,
0.9356211424,
0.3209441602,
0.0881200582,
0.0449445248,
0.4969841242,
-0.1033145636,
0.2142553329,
0.5571855307,
0.8954778314,
-0.5014879704,
0.3511988819,
-0.620126307,
-0.3624165058,
-0.2111710459,
-0.8225741386,
-0.9551748633,
-0.6172298789,
-0.5341467261,
-0.4451384544,
0.0867633447,
0.9965128899,
0.732504487,
-1.024433136,
-0.2473130822,
-0.1322937012,
-0.0003672027,
-0.5478044152,
-0.2650096714,
0.266836822,
-0.8057809472,
-0.6876828671,
0.4327169061,
-0.0195842125,
0.0130712604,
0.1108117998,
-0.035646569,
-0.00055917,
-0.0983592197,
0.4825672805,
0.6636429429,
-0.4928442836,
-0.4300568402,
-0.2950719595,
-0.5669843554,
-0.0501608029,
0.4718373716,
-0.9357898235,
0.473785758,
0.5696443319,
0.6755260825,
0.3265995681,
0.0997518376,
0.7003801465,
-1.0857589245,
0.2471487522,
0.3736831248,
0.4512468576,
0.2226010263,
-0.0306615755,
0.4554840624,
0.1762624532,
-0.5773091912,
-1.3798199892,
-0.1094493419,
-0.8228694201,
-0.1720599234,
1.1480326653,
-0.1268801093,
-0.178404808,
-0.085926041,
0.2428444922,
0.0008690738,
-0.2729364634,
0.6862133145,
1.0139489174,
0.1694154739,
-0.124856174,
-0.6956109405,
0.7099782228,
0.5083631873,
-0.5099388957,
0.0117052039,
0.4747820199,
0.426540345,
0.1446532309,
0.5254666805,
0.0116541442,
0.4898100495,
0.1234736964,
-0.1329881102,
0.1995394677,
-0.599817276,
-0.6399160028,
0.5040138364,
0.0763313621,
0.0776851401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13013v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13013v1
|
Groma: Localized Visual Tokenization for Grounding Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-04-19T17:22:51 | 2024-04-19T17:22:51 |
Chuofan Ma, Yi Jiang, Jiannan Wu, Zehuan Yuan, Xiaojuan Qi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We introduce Groma, a Multimodal Large Language Model (MLLM) with grounded
and fine-grained visual perception ability. Beyond holistic image
understanding, Groma is adept at region-level tasks such as region captioning
and visual grounding. Such capabilities are built upon a localized visual
tokenization mechanism, where an image input is decomposed into regions of
interest and subsequently encoded into region tokens. By integrating region
tokens into user instructions and model responses, we seamlessly enable Groma
to understand user-specified region inputs and ground its textual output to
images. Besides, to enhance the grounded chat ability of Groma, we curate a
visually grounded instruction dataset by leveraging the powerful GPT-4V and
visual prompting techniques. Compared with MLLMs that rely on the language
model or external module for localization, Groma consistently demonstrates
superior performances in standard referring and grounding benchmarks,
highlighting the advantages of embedding localization into image tokenization.
Project page: https://groma-mllm.github.io/.
|
[
-0.2565455139,
-0.9803994298,
0.6626018286,
0.2420293093,
-0.3998779058,
-0.1213965341,
-0.3396049738,
-0.1112252846,
0.0129254889,
0.6940334439,
-0.0408720076,
-1.0180119276,
-0.5891181231,
-0.3718517125,
-0.3323680162,
0.902079463,
0.071325101,
0.1560283601,
-0.7053284049,
-0.2059696764,
-0.7799502611,
-0.6745504737,
-0.7551315427,
-0.3036424816,
0.3744780719,
0.3599872589,
0.759408474,
0.6807290912,
0.5300626159,
0.3428965211,
-0.1730954498,
0.1044627205,
-0.3948883414,
-0.0222706106,
-0.100122951,
-0.5463830233,
-0.3697573841,
-0.3261598349,
0.7712212205,
0.5932791829,
-0.0712287799,
0.0598330945,
-0.2882058322,
0.5598550439,
-0.5267213583,
0.3039448559,
-0.7261199355,
-0.0482724719,
-0.1843235791,
-0.2862027884,
-0.3938875198,
-0.0502033271,
-0.052661784,
-0.5923954844,
0.3731882274,
-0.1123875007,
0.9430484772,
0.2885667086,
-0.6518650651,
-0.1137260422,
-0.4487376809,
0.6907004118,
-0.529319942,
0.3952602744,
0.4787522256,
0.6245908141,
-0.1507389843,
-0.9963869452,
-0.3523471057,
-0.3547149301,
-0.2185518891,
0.0687929019,
-0.1486511379,
0.2262351811,
0.2053584009,
0.4455123246,
-0.466579169,
-0.1392379254,
-0.2268453091,
-0.22828345,
-0.0041145338,
-0.0068522864,
0.5441311002,
0.0806099325,
-0.2836897969,
-0.0088268407,
-0.6659867764,
-0.0439116172,
0.0935410932,
0.4208102822,
-0.3618971407,
0.4978084862,
-0.2584787011,
0.8751203418,
-0.0493559428,
-0.3347504437,
0.3798388243,
-0.1183461696,
-0.4100640714,
-0.2063715309,
0.668063581,
0.5102314353,
-0.144036755,
-0.0261393469,
-0.3421621621,
0.0766727626,
-0.0490393192,
-0.7136931419,
-0.1323361546,
0.122270368,
-0.5784544945,
-0.224180758,
0.0398423001,
-0.9189586639,
-0.7595011592,
-0.3290904462,
0.3310977221,
-0.0981655568,
-0.086133495,
0.0419077352,
-0.2663115263,
-0.0553792939,
0.4649752676,
-0.9451288581,
0.1309712976,
0.5165452361,
1.0602942705,
0.2064662278,
-0.4567998052,
-0.8649326563,
0.3736656308,
-0.1689296067,
0.648753643,
-0.8768277168,
-0.2159886658,
0.0525792614,
0.1376666874,
0.0205747169,
-0.4126576781,
0.4103585482,
-0.3553550243,
0.4394996166,
-0.2381548733,
-0.1467840374,
-0.3509116173,
0.4059958756,
-0.4661769867,
0.753706336,
-0.0279348828,
-0.6581448913,
0.3378431201,
-0.7684975863,
-0.3265494406,
0.0736138076,
-0.4731486142,
-0.063954629,
0.0383367054,
0.7074398398,
0.6214504838,
-0.2617873549,
0.5656637549,
-0.1316692829,
-0.4244780838,
-0.2513686121,
-0.5791035891,
0.1963141859,
0.1302611828,
-0.4896182716,
0.5684612989,
-0.7111377716,
-0.1264968067,
0.2019503713,
-0.1378482878,
-0.3621793687,
0.0625861958,
0.0764118135,
0.1394677907,
0.3910702169,
-0.0239821821,
0.186869055,
-0.0388882644,
0.5758883953,
0.606664896,
-0.0796683878,
0.6468689442,
0.2304509431,
0.5213828683,
0.083984457,
0.1803175211,
-0.9743012786,
-0.6513870358,
-0.7773077488,
-0.6953654885,
0.0577243716,
0.4278255403,
-0.8935577869,
0.1255739182,
-0.3777078986,
-0.462018013,
-0.3259057701,
0.0347455889,
0.4370545447,
0.7310188413,
0.405068785,
-0.0130593674,
-0.2956569791,
-0.9243315458,
0.2281199843,
-0.0311970543,
0.0371938571,
0.4027031362,
0.3913917243,
-0.5750607252,
0.8361721635,
-0.357713908,
-0.4712728262,
-0.1010058075,
0.2964867353,
0.3156996667,
0.4407977462,
1.0114670992,
-0.9067729115,
-0.3717188537,
0.8253790736,
-1.0096589327,
-0.1068880707,
-0.1989438087,
-0.1636957526,
-0.0072738854,
0.5694968104,
-0.6064694524,
0.4439131618,
0.8711535335,
-0.6102476716,
0.1555634439,
-0.3286818564,
0.4781221449,
-1.0995417833,
0.2386617661,
-0.1734306216,
-0.4456346333,
-0.5992960334,
0.3494842947,
0.0610388964,
-0.5175953507,
-0.2990371585,
0.7469888926,
-0.5976439714,
-0.2660508752,
-0.2687719762,
0.0731135234,
0.0924374908,
0.4505009651,
0.0809591934,
1.063546896,
1.0312033892,
-0.3499743342,
0.4177621007,
0.1154653206,
-0.1088160053,
0.4635863602,
-0.8645216227,
0.1751143932,
-0.3066491187,
0.3589292467,
-0.8702106476,
-0.5274580121,
0.2398883998,
-0.3440290689,
0.1554057896,
-0.8152061105,
-0.2159703523,
-0.1029396504,
0.0043955897,
0.4226177931,
0.4794935584,
-0.7824268341,
0.8220323324,
0.3766804338,
-0.0075738621,
-0.5785667896,
-0.5730830431,
0.4206978977,
-0.3917323649,
-0.5415552258,
-0.0657594055,
0.3005429804,
-0.13487041,
-0.0919478834,
0.1845842898,
-0.0733984932,
0.0985188186,
0.5715436339,
-0.0069028451,
-0.2005541474,
0.2542838454,
0.0753562674,
-0.1798371524,
-0.1264935136,
-0.5521422625,
0.7597153783,
-0.5028706789,
-0.6100499034,
-0.5254539847,
0.382638514,
0.9837955236,
-0.45381549,
0.7878269553,
0.7266504765,
-0.522751987,
0.3356508315,
-0.4812578559,
0.1152286679,
-0.4955289662,
0.4263139069,
-0.4268002808,
-0.9690727592,
0.7791753411,
0.01055835,
-0.2282526791,
0.2531227171,
0.6546929479,
0.1849962175,
1.1904176474,
0.5397614241,
-0.180935815,
0.6587531567,
-0.1742165685,
0.0203271043,
-0.4859282672,
-0.3019986451,
-0.4176544249,
-0.0223561693,
-0.0633954555,
-0.7417192459,
0.2426990569,
0.355445534,
-0.1685264409,
-0.156887576,
-0.3402770758,
0.8686510921,
0.749647975,
-0.0551616624,
0.0074342694,
0.237448588,
-0.2385294884,
-0.1313636154,
-0.6542993784,
-0.7850309014,
0.7550540566,
0.668217361,
0.8515272737,
-0.1442970335,
0.4568946958,
0.4183165133,
0.3611314297,
-0.7721115947,
0.4661841393,
0.0244515408,
-0.2319397479,
-0.1833811849,
-0.4290805757,
-0.7285955548,
0.4496355355,
-0.117133379,
-0.7082285881,
0.045136638,
0.3737978041,
0.0361554548,
0.3480900228,
-1.0065815449,
1.12406075,
-0.1718440652,
-0.1668219715,
0.0620222837,
-0.5052388906,
0.2453048825,
0.190210104,
0.2155962437,
0.0896538347,
0.1587892622,
0.4933118224,
-0.1149028242,
1.0723786354,
-0.6036933064,
-0.3122455776,
0.185818851,
-0.0413065888,
0.5191942453,
0.2875227332,
0.3310900927,
0.4964172542,
-0.3028760552,
-0.5161153674,
-0.8275405169,
0.8653202057,
-0.7031193972,
-0.4584894776,
-0.2083473653,
-0.4369873405,
-0.1598633379,
0.5023575425,
0.0366201364,
0.826399684,
0.0045466777,
0.4088900983,
0.4165503979,
-0.2974301279,
0.1384795904,
0.0353919044,
-0.662989676,
-0.940482676,
1.1689217091,
-0.3350633681,
0.1195858717,
0.4932934344,
0.0342188403,
-0.2130072415,
-0.6371564865,
-0.4923232198,
0.2498227954,
-1.1331640482,
-0.1194334328,
-0.5259920359,
0.3242792189,
-0.3342456222,
-0.4409991801,
-0.3755945563,
-0.0653108954,
-0.337302506,
-0.1119303331,
0.0163634401,
0.6971791387,
0.2577835321,
0.7026742697,
-0.949575901,
0.3607937992,
0.4792321622,
0.2594244182,
-0.1638015956,
-0.4970079958,
-0.3773986399,
0.2317978144,
0.1409673691,
-0.5687829852,
0.3103711009,
0.0352875367,
0.5714862943,
0.8212128878,
-0.5648600459,
1.2054088116,
-0.6989538074,
0.9983331561,
0.3649353683,
-1.1179182529,
0.8316651583,
-0.7039132118,
0.3235467374,
0.3054128289,
-0.0229717307,
-0.7546816468,
-0.3858229518,
-0.1972627789,
-0.8608423471,
0.3466810584,
0.1064175814,
0.4949620068,
-0.2906630039,
0.2343123555,
0.084024176,
0.2512043118,
-0.7417479753,
-0.1229343712,
-0.358196497,
-0.1198329851,
-0.1737485081,
-0.5007945299,
-0.6315864325,
-0.1285909712,
0.2872031629,
-0.5662479997,
0.5521940589,
0.0231931601,
-0.2473629713,
0.0840848312,
0.0366575904,
1.1097369194,
0.9331768751,
-0.1229884252,
0.3603191972,
-0.0051615257,
-0.4013145864,
-0.0913780406,
-0.1212303191,
-0.1558757722,
0.186703369,
0.65572083,
1.2768845558,
0.0636791289,
-0.6508660913,
0.579798758,
-0.1856865734,
-0.0812959746,
-0.0204851124,
-0.1571271271,
-0.1331387013,
0.3194548786,
0.44142133,
0.1266935468,
-0.0682334676,
-0.4685888588,
0.0272801127,
0.4682469964,
-0.4725825489,
-0.4009572566,
0.8338994384,
0.458923161,
0.0037844493,
0.2625451386,
0.0166421365,
-0.5749584436,
0.547254622,
0.8955100179,
0.7118057609,
0.1515455991,
0.4003742039,
0.2512942851,
0.4583930373,
-0.0908990949,
0.063496612,
-0.0632070899,
-0.5452976823,
-0.3156453967,
-0.1854764521,
-0.382599622,
0.0262010731,
-0.6054064631,
0.2352487445,
-0.5654682517,
-0.1636273861,
-0.635032475,
-0.5274454951,
-0.4928233922,
0.3583379388,
0.5240623951,
0.6745204926,
-1.0652115345,
0.516595602,
1.2088419199,
-0.1022423133,
-0.3077528477,
-0.1305674464,
-0.2161324173,
-0.7520352006,
0.7511942983,
0.5215926766,
-0.1749106944,
-0.0094303293,
-0.8015298843,
-0.7430197597,
1.3059386015,
0.6050103903,
-0.2868098915,
0.2879471481,
-0.0931557566,
0.4752359986,
-0.4584924281,
0.3701871336,
0.2672421634,
0.4255279303,
0.1019419134,
-0.7983611822,
-0.1401769817,
-0.2742272615,
0.10525278,
0.2446689457,
-0.5672581792,
0.7748703957,
-0.0881237835,
-0.3262250721,
-0.0697295219,
0.8422271609,
0.1800327748,
0.6338387132,
0.3720183372,
0.6742044687,
1.1041680574,
-0.2788213491,
1.0939415693,
-0.1144313589,
0.3701729178,
1.1665785313,
-0.2324534506,
0.585959971,
0.6582235694,
0.240038082,
0.3556863964,
0.3737385869,
0.2421069145,
0.6551532745,
-0.2898187339,
-0.3330560923,
-0.3394042552,
-0.3846843243,
-0.7057664394,
0.434871316,
0.3197906911,
-0.3349255025,
-0.3013208508,
0.2436160296,
-0.0134735191,
0.1814644188,
-0.4903089702,
0.5045590997,
-0.2567258179,
-0.1763858497,
0.5264031887,
0.0595146008,
0.4366763234,
-0.7421973348,
-0.3785102665,
-0.6028654575,
-0.0370665863,
-0.1360616386,
-0.5659668446,
-0.017288778,
0.152958855,
-0.2160894424,
-0.2707071304,
0.7687753439,
-0.5046935081,
-0.2953196168,
0.1215213463,
0.2989712059,
0.158433795,
-0.2241482586,
-0.5259115696,
0.1665942669,
-0.0366231017,
-0.1765288413,
0.2694742978,
0.7774890065,
-0.4191383421,
0.9817442298,
0.9719967246,
-0.2008073926,
0.0572853722,
0.5532271266,
1.0325852633,
-0.7495758533,
-0.5466353893,
-0.7423180342,
0.6927824616,
-0.1682560742,
-0.2980687022,
0.8812420964,
0.3598820567,
0.5810070634,
-0.4231740534,
0.7246335149,
-0.0377003253,
-0.1997950673,
-0.8831232786,
0.6628183126,
-0.5739482641,
-0.0411286838,
-0.2172712088,
-0.9467309713,
-0.7284440398,
0.671241641,
-0.3220347762,
-0.1003853902,
0.6446642876,
0.7614706755,
-0.121485658,
-0.5925644636,
0.7580266595,
-0.0413112789,
0.5821041465,
0.1700670123,
1.0018700361,
-0.276160568,
0.2702048719,
0.0954151601,
-0.2431042194,
-0.0935758278,
-1.0158421993,
-1.4562903643,
-0.4176954329,
-0.0817954093,
0.0223575588,
-0.1061264873,
0.8075203896,
0.6771964431,
-0.8206406832,
-0.035772115,
-0.1548812091,
0.1809835881,
0.0068869935,
-0.242972225,
0.1819022298,
-0.3252702057,
-0.8863873482,
0.570941627,
0.5218390226,
0.1970250905,
-0.1232366189,
-0.2024650425,
0.0685232282,
-0.4479858577,
0.6924069524,
0.1877385825,
-0.850199163,
-0.415741384,
-0.1621778607,
-0.1731813699,
-0.1004975438,
0.7466940284,
-0.7846519947,
0.6945282221,
0.376801312,
0.772554636,
0.0847182274,
0.2943796217,
0.6657280922,
-0.8780641556,
0.802637279,
-0.0941798612,
0.5787186027,
0.4850594103,
-0.3402141035,
0.515860498,
0.3615248203,
-0.4923519492,
-0.9343361259,
-0.0371911451,
-0.8883368373,
0.1834791005,
1.2067222595,
-0.2955347896,
-0.1425713897,
0.2306492627,
-0.8325967789,
-0.0911441818,
-0.3454932868,
0.410751462,
0.6592478156,
0.6680594087,
-0.3490102291,
-0.6164051294,
0.049658969,
0.3523055315,
-0.948884964,
-0.0399242491,
0.8407411575,
-0.0880754441,
0.2896559238,
0.6285203099,
0.0882870629,
0.3110135794,
0.0545704253,
0.3134589791,
-0.3286038339,
-0.7046957016,
-0.6501321793,
0.1316043437,
-0.0097865043,
-0.448161006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12994v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12994v2
|
Rethinking the Evaluation of Dialogue Systems: Effects of User Feedback on Crowdworkers and LLMs
| 2024-04-19T16:45:50 | 2024-04-29T19:00:34 |
Clemencia Siro, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Maarten de Rijke
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
In ad-hoc retrieval, evaluation relies heavily on user actions, including
implicit feedback. In a conversational setting such signals are usually
unavailable due to the nature of the interactions, and, instead, the evaluation
often relies on crowdsourced evaluation labels. The role of user feedback in
annotators' assessment of turns in a conversational perception has been little
studied. We focus on how the evaluation of task-oriented dialogue systems
(TDSs), is affected by considering user feedback, explicit or implicit, as
provided through the follow-up utterance of a turn being evaluated. We explore
and compare two methodologies for assessing TDSs: one includes the user's
follow-up utterance and one without. We use both crowdworkers and large
language models (LLMs) as annotators to assess system responses across four
aspects: relevance, usefulness, interestingness, and explanation quality. Our
findings indicate that there is a distinct difference in ratings assigned by
both annotator groups in the two setups, indicating user feedback does
influence system evaluation. Workers are more susceptible to user feedback on
usefulness and interestingness compared to LLMs on interestingness and
relevance. User feedback leads to a more personalized assessment of usefulness
by workers, aligning closely with the user's explicit feedback. Additionally,
in cases of ambiguous or complex user requests, user feedback improves
agreement among crowdworkers. These findings emphasize the significance of user
feedback in refining system evaluations and suggest the potential for automated
feedback integration in future research. We publicly release the annotated data
to foster research in this area.
|
[
-0.4323955774,
-0.3252126575,
0.6753360629,
0.3617291749,
-0.2198824286,
0.1188516691,
-0.2343497276,
-0.6681626439,
0.2461788356,
0.5971416235,
-0.5372327566,
-0.051071927,
-0.542968452,
0.3527450264,
-0.5124550462,
1.1206671,
0.1369779557,
0.1024535745,
-0.2329263836,
-0.0235545728,
-0.5702464581,
-0.7562531233,
-0.5980359912,
-0.4316597581,
0.7787874937,
0.297721684,
0.9844713211,
0.1257771552,
0.2763646841,
0.4730025232,
-0.084941633,
-0.0280757863,
-0.4938718379,
0.3586762846,
-0.1011949852,
-0.2496451288,
-0.0826242268,
0.083999604,
0.2938704789,
0.8475791812,
-0.0807157233,
0.21321024,
0.3176470101,
0.4962435067,
-0.6317180991,
0.2890947163,
-0.3135108054,
0.0294807963,
-0.0989390388,
-0.219038859,
-0.4160526693,
-0.5196243525,
0.5195294619,
-0.5256096721,
0.085873574,
-0.0276770778,
0.4053841233,
0.140745908,
-0.2033335119,
-0.4539808929,
-0.851013124,
0.6668473482,
-0.6253815293,
0.2243971378,
0.2200691104,
0.1227721721,
-0.2530598342,
-0.3370575309,
-0.5874940753,
-0.4678017199,
-0.3016347587,
0.2421052158,
-0.1422298998,
0.2606741488,
0.4078148603,
0.2359556109,
0.0399371535,
0.0165018905,
-0.4628477693,
-0.1865286231,
0.9368725419,
0.2611789703,
0.1439175755,
-0.423589021,
-0.4011002779,
-0.0121399472,
-0.2951746285,
0.212839067,
0.4872270226,
0.1944879293,
0.3558466733,
0.6564122438,
-0.6251966953,
0.7049772143,
0.1258786768,
0.0433254726,
0.2882910371,
-0.3002967536,
-0.0977192447,
-0.3116890192,
0.9151772857,
0.5664479136,
0.3112321794,
-0.2934402227,
-0.5714185834,
-0.0764083713,
0.2730977833,
-0.4652170241,
-0.0980185941,
-0.0370568596,
-0.4402215183,
-0.2994858027,
0.3511002362,
-0.5124304295,
-0.7876925468,
-0.6682718992,
0.4150856435,
0.0126832891,
-0.2465297282,
-0.2834834754,
-0.3430920839,
-0.1718305498,
0.8852050304,
-0.5873940587,
0.3636987805,
0.8202350736,
0.6675109863,
-0.2228646725,
-0.3062009811,
-0.7046065331,
-0.2184286416,
-0.0513500646,
0.8156654239,
-0.7666656971,
-0.7302723527,
0.2562091649,
0.0911363363,
-0.1836651713,
-0.7129161358,
0.3551972806,
-0.5540049672,
0.3112584949,
-0.5894152522,
-0.1645630002,
-0.1604870409,
-0.0814742818,
-0.5772713423,
0.9690116644,
-0.0542335548,
-0.7076835036,
0.535558641,
-0.8492624164,
-0.3600084782,
0.3681021631,
-0.0148376524,
0.1396522671,
0.4084640145,
0.0139441686,
0.2314056158,
0.0159338973,
0.1481407285,
-0.4392986894,
-0.6826716661,
0.8132849932,
-0.3899361789,
0.4353758395,
0.1614495367,
-0.4760637581,
0.3159963191,
-0.3096805811,
0.0607224293,
-0.3545214832,
-0.412488848,
-0.2155285031,
0.0594696738,
0.1285583973,
0.1346169412,
-0.0433271527,
-0.5824273825,
-0.01983032,
-0.2091625035,
0.479919076,
0.7847792506,
0.1200357527,
0.1253570765,
-0.3055455685,
0.4802870154,
-0.2064914852,
0.2538588345,
-0.3244789541,
-0.5623254776,
-0.8550878763,
-0.0228059273,
0.1981935948,
0.416710645,
-0.7511889338,
-0.0108832242,
-0.1818039268,
-0.3594566882,
-0.6250748038,
0.1982474327,
0.633777678,
0.0361347571,
0.0905260444,
-0.912489593,
-0.346891135,
-0.7157025933,
-0.4089203775,
-0.69305861,
-0.3723521531,
0.4260324538,
0.2823664844,
-0.0822415873,
1.0218129158,
-0.1934730262,
0.0940309316,
-0.1859117448,
0.4046715498,
-0.2895554304,
0.1184498146,
-0.0704243258,
-0.4473420978,
-0.0148482546,
-0.2104824632,
-0.3939165771,
-0.4970000684,
-0.0430524684,
0.1357111037,
0.3169272244,
0.1639154851,
-0.5476463437,
0.7079383135,
0.2834317088,
-0.3667190671,
0.726670444,
0.1500479877,
0.4337264597,
-0.2485560179,
0.1080255359,
-0.1816582084,
-0.2443329543,
-0.5570544004,
-0.3590303361,
-0.5072277784,
-0.28737849,
-0.2172268927,
0.474525243,
-0.4698730707,
-0.6553968191,
-0.3991839886,
0.5780464411,
0.0199999381,
0.534506321,
0.0762958229,
0.8149306178,
-0.123536855,
-0.4562874138,
0.4179378748,
0.2043421268,
-0.4403503835,
0.6613197327,
-0.7288681865,
0.6605408788,
0.1041984782,
0.4706345797,
-1.315295577,
-0.1091741025,
0.3801590502,
-0.5478711128,
-0.1844378114,
-0.10834492,
-0.555251956,
-0.6192600131,
-0.3219254911,
-0.1043800712,
0.1451598853,
-0.3449252844,
0.2179605067,
0.3925363123,
-0.4061206579,
-0.251801461,
-0.339923799,
0.2735732794,
0.0050124917,
-0.6781546474,
-0.2309202999,
0.0955080688,
-0.6348585486,
-0.2962728143,
-0.2226868272,
-0.0089254631,
0.1778956354,
0.6501696706,
0.2197350264,
0.3429570198,
0.1930193603,
-0.3058735728,
-0.2361595929,
0.2927336395,
0.0471786447,
0.3569853008,
-0.1849553287,
-0.6812799573,
-0.5782175064,
0.3577333391,
0.485081315,
-0.0149786128,
0.2346975356,
0.7107508779,
0.0785612836,
0.4222614169,
-1.0215779543,
-0.343147248,
-0.4555815756,
0.275578022,
-0.2622148693,
-1.0337219238,
0.4186005294,
-0.0678548887,
0.2608881593,
0.3853077888,
0.6632383466,
-0.2398331314,
1.0643912554,
0.3553284109,
0.1645296514,
0.7420777082,
0.1097480059,
0.0254444405,
-0.9626356959,
-0.4804986119,
-0.7241871953,
-0.3134796619,
-0.3759112954,
-0.3393149078,
0.1269096136,
-0.0302234516,
0.1110197753,
0.2147592604,
-0.2693818808,
0.0645517558,
0.4809586108,
0.1493862122,
0.5834490061,
-0.2462110072,
0.1729923338,
0.0036054719,
-0.5208653212,
-0.7366402745,
0.7416608334,
0.2991729677,
0.5656690001,
-0.1818485409,
0.621250093,
0.6453018785,
0.7359025478,
-0.8216841817,
0.6805219054,
0.4019382,
-0.4609158039,
-0.6005598307,
-0.2110490799,
-0.8429830074,
0.58921808,
-0.0802577287,
-1.0606187582,
0.2353485227,
-0.0403733328,
-0.3788951039,
-0.0765255615,
-1.0352296829,
0.4604543746,
-0.0714663491,
-0.3412947953,
-0.3696791232,
-0.5365089774,
0.03601899,
0.1361107081,
0.3573521078,
-0.0985287279,
0.1255844384,
1.1251052618,
-0.8853986263,
1.0637472868,
-0.5789405704,
-0.0612538457,
0.4636009634,
0.0660231486,
0.3686725199,
0.1098707095,
-0.1851032823,
0.1762068868,
0.0484049022,
-0.0995669067,
-0.8636356592,
0.6936736107,
-0.7984988093,
-1.2005867958,
-0.1713291705,
-0.4015805423,
-0.3156190813,
-0.0572460368,
-0.2109987587,
0.474350065,
-0.0924404114,
-0.0768950656,
0.1601575464,
0.0509595163,
0.430719465,
0.6805282831,
-0.3642982841,
-0.3631767035,
0.4388773441,
0.1056606174,
0.2922548652,
-0.10384617,
-0.0818983093,
-0.2543593049,
-0.291816771,
-0.7891516685,
0.1035447568,
-0.6335099339,
-0.0397862457,
-0.5167019963,
0.2191575319,
-0.062539883,
0.0705228895,
-0.1268668026,
-0.5208258629,
-0.2107851058,
-0.2421615422,
0.2957025468,
1.2593744993,
-0.0155454651,
0.256714493,
-0.5460835695,
-0.2620077431,
0.4974242747,
0.4456891119,
0.3053879142,
-0.4756153822,
-0.2954361737,
0.0680158287,
-0.335498929,
-0.9798122048,
-0.0558298677,
-0.3075637519,
0.4872747958,
0.4369686842,
-0.0778038949,
0.721924901,
-0.2017583251,
0.9418250322,
0.2546871305,
-1.0997620821,
0.2699621916,
-0.1639556736,
0.4441763759,
0.7455696464,
0.0395216793,
-0.8639901876,
-0.4754408598,
-0.3502939343,
-0.7472657561,
0.9254924059,
0.3476051688,
0.0968963429,
-0.0021656682,
0.2591124475,
0.2046943605,
0.3732393384,
-0.3749792874,
0.0358273983,
-0.2426256388,
0.420670867,
0.0281383321,
-0.5199542642,
-0.2737084627,
0.0853020251,
0.2450253218,
0.0861611143,
0.3503739536,
0.3750454783,
-0.1130270883,
-0.386451602,
0.6364299059,
0.3617862761,
0.8390870094,
-0.006690538,
-0.1936547607,
0.376876533,
-0.1846476793,
-0.0784120411,
0.108393997,
-0.0741397664,
0.3457893431,
0.3395887315,
0.9854997993,
0.3569853604,
-0.5784204006,
0.4802910984,
0.022655759,
-0.0235893931,
-0.2738941908,
0.029504912,
-0.1747139692,
0.3413393795,
0.7179566026,
0.171136409,
0.5080803037,
-0.609683156,
-0.0685230792,
0.4752391875,
-0.8960507512,
-0.6449794173,
0.1231615394,
0.6365255713,
-0.7464545965,
0.332546562,
0.0730742589,
-0.6573427916,
0.2389076054,
0.0602566935,
1.1056872606,
-0.2551846504,
0.2826201618,
-0.0501652211,
0.3073614836,
0.1735585332,
0.1316392422,
-0.4736993611,
-0.258870095,
-0.6356088519,
-0.4103277922,
-0.7813230157,
-0.0874203891,
-0.8230566978,
0.0291510131,
-0.2151639163,
-0.5681705475,
-0.0429397225,
0.0733837634,
-0.8284479976,
0.0884882063,
0.2732170522,
0.5083150268,
-0.7124847174,
0.2258428931,
0.7801049948,
-0.2966740727,
-0.5697253346,
0.1186772138,
0.0860686973,
-0.7188003659,
0.7578323483,
0.2725023925,
-0.3608209193,
-0.4716475308,
-0.3939241767,
-0.8180619478,
0.9392701983,
-0.029500043,
-0.5831689835,
0.2560892701,
0.065640077,
0.8664647937,
-0.2733379304,
1.1408931017,
0.5797887444,
0.6141445637,
0.1920731813,
-1.5420627594,
0.1734906286,
-0.2988975346,
0.3871576488,
0.0707527846,
-0.8003863096,
0.2780162394,
-0.4269634485,
-0.4056610763,
0.152092427,
0.5683460236,
0.1690202653,
0.5334987044,
0.9199662209,
0.1421756595,
0.5380487442,
-0.2369230837,
1.1691465378,
0.1349430829,
0.1160667613,
0.8184858561,
-0.3030441105,
0.8114158511,
0.7211139798,
-0.4111617506,
0.6908354759,
0.3846823573,
0.3045438826,
0.1989182085,
0.6778203845,
-0.0775635317,
-0.2560281157,
-0.4050318599,
-0.2616578043,
0.3479661644,
0.2623876631,
-0.2503600121,
0.0149686821,
0.0511592142,
0.1188261211,
-0.2570046782,
-0.1870727986,
1.1168233156,
0.0180208236,
-0.9730123281,
0.3057834804,
-0.1650259048,
0.4110013843,
-0.1398770958,
-0.0319137871,
-0.2652595043,
-0.1829533875,
-0.6095193028,
-0.7969226241,
0.2386618406,
0.1577801108,
-0.1223848462,
-0.3083895147,
0.5908997655,
-0.0252773371,
-0.1673446596,
0.3315550983,
0.4629772007,
0.2864636779,
-0.080907084,
-0.534502089,
0.4760875404,
0.1868592203,
-0.6096153259,
0.1026464477,
0.4105095863,
-0.2052022219,
0.7300410867,
0.7491543889,
-0.2206654698,
-0.195901677,
0.468781054,
1.1214517355,
-0.5957312584,
-0.187785551,
-0.5271093249,
0.4639959633,
-0.099219285,
-0.283414185,
0.7899030447,
0.3112054169,
0.8629247546,
0.0534579828,
0.9940226078,
-0.0009374925,
0.7040987611,
-0.1521210819,
0.2480953485,
-0.1380422115,
0.455095619,
-0.6464474201,
-0.8988878727,
0.2448111475,
0.1805233806,
-0.8472801447,
0.2903165519,
0.4591271579,
0.4526561201,
0.3568375409,
0.4542546868,
0.1148785949,
0.1901702285,
0.2400833815,
0.0589373447,
1.4325778484,
-0.1305578947,
0.7805565,
0.023062354,
-0.3731065094,
-0.498577714,
-0.3433628678,
-0.8386686444,
-0.5110146999,
-0.3229998648,
-0.2632992864,
0.2950073481,
0.650919497,
0.5515347123,
-0.8312976956,
-0.5549951196,
0.4702341557,
0.0468973443,
-0.0397655107,
-0.3220333159,
-0.0037471338,
-0.3473915756,
-0.7459903955,
0.2943035066,
0.470549643,
-0.406942457,
-0.59109658,
-0.0512155183,
0.2344144285,
-0.0330512971,
0.6760960221,
0.2026911229,
-1.1869350672,
-0.5581088066,
0.0889503658,
-0.0023852428,
-0.1904038042,
0.9409123063,
-0.9683084488,
0.6667238474,
0.4483830929,
0.1298828125,
0.5905864835,
0.3790737092,
0.842435956,
-0.1525857449,
-0.0870548561,
0.1158212125,
0.2054914534,
0.5926938653,
-0.1722291559,
0.3863086104,
0.2791136503,
-0.5870668888,
-0.5745337009,
0.0700503215,
-0.8403355479,
0.2286132127,
1.3329259157,
-0.3825216889,
0.1178838462,
-0.4489286542,
-0.4932335615,
0.0166372079,
-0.900372982,
0.9800486565,
0.8444414735,
-0.2343642414,
0.0804534554,
-0.335172832,
0.3406411409,
0.6061449647,
-0.4446150362,
0.0777915493,
0.68988204,
0.0297600273,
0.4882742465,
0.7706187963,
-0.00320089,
0.1540313661,
-0.3780338466,
-0.0966848806,
-0.0908618718,
-0.1138205677,
-0.3808060884,
0.1288515031,
0.2344756573,
-0.0680498853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12957v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12957v1
|
Towards Reliable Latent Knowledge Estimation in LLMs: In-Context Learning vs. Prompting Based Factual Knowledge Extraction
| 2024-04-19T15:40:39 | 2024-04-19T15:40:39 |
Qinyuan Wu, Mohammad Aflah Khan, Soumi Das, Vedant Nanda, Bishwamittra Ghosh, Camila Kolling, Till Speicher, Laurent Bindschaedler, Krishna P. Gummadi, Evimaria Terzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We propose an approach for estimating the latent knowledge embedded inside
large language models (LLMs). We leverage the in-context learning (ICL)
abilities of LLMs to estimate the extent to which an LLM knows the facts stored
in a knowledge base. Our knowledge estimator avoids reliability concerns with
previous prompting-based methods, is both conceptually simpler and easier to
apply, and we demonstrate that it can surface more of the latent knowledge
embedded in LLMs. We also investigate how different design choices affect the
performance of ICL-based knowledge estimation. Using the proposed estimator, we
perform a large-scale evaluation of the factual knowledge of a variety of open
source LLMs, like OPT, Pythia, Llama(2), Mistral, Gemma, etc. over a large set
of relations and facts from the Wikidata knowledge base. We observe differences
in the factual knowledge between different model families and models of
different sizes, that some relations are consistently better known than others
but that models differ in the precise facts they know, and differences in the
knowledge of base models and their finetuned counterparts.
|
[
-0.0932810307,
-0.8197023273,
0.9969707131,
0.0483836271,
-0.1774237007,
0.153401494,
-0.4030846357,
-0.4125835896,
-0.273183614,
0.2031104565,
-0.2471694946,
-0.3508437872,
-0.4491965473,
-0.165838778,
-0.1571344137,
0.7092880011,
0.0688155219,
0.2697122693,
-0.7725204825,
0.1534591317,
-0.3719856739,
-0.3022612333,
-0.3656726182,
-0.3900960982,
0.5202934742,
0.5912746191,
0.4146079719,
0.1760344803,
0.1235135421,
0.1598852128,
-0.4693983495,
0.4555191994,
-0.521909833,
0.207676366,
-0.3042951226,
-0.611153543,
-0.2495252639,
0.0179130398,
0.5833285451,
0.7798571587,
-0.0508370884,
0.1819184721,
0.2103663683,
0.4010297358,
-0.822288096,
0.2669811845,
-0.8772898912,
0.0381073691,
-0.0447179154,
-0.1158095896,
-0.5401530266,
-0.4069352746,
0.4243199825,
-0.4336416125,
-0.215059191,
0.0714240596,
0.6465717554,
0.3957701921,
-0.4509802759,
-0.5382291675,
-0.687587142,
0.95827806,
-0.8768433928,
0.7632197738,
0.5515270829,
0.1744379401,
-0.3113895655,
-0.7195415497,
-0.6773272157,
-0.5937313437,
-0.166418016,
0.0837213248,
0.0260419454,
-0.2450403124,
0.3618586063,
0.3535794318,
-0.3184456527,
0.2457090467,
0.0035005528,
-0.1884065866,
0.2859487534,
-0.0158920567,
0.201192975,
-0.278264612,
-0.4162028134,
0.4348970354,
-1.2242827415,
0.0415156521,
0.1750090569,
-0.0201597251,
-0.1961734593,
0.5805486441,
0.0368582234,
0.7410181761,
0.2528713942,
-0.7563751936,
0.0419788808,
-0.2943614721,
-0.013384277,
-0.0604995117,
0.7677371502,
0.1123464033,
0.1290513575,
-0.4794552028,
-0.3274824917,
-0.347382009,
-0.1081395298,
-0.5131866932,
-0.1511676013,
0.0469242632,
-0.3186115921,
-0.1006580293,
0.0259151943,
-0.6997647285,
-0.3867426515,
-0.3855657876,
0.4490933418,
-0.3976239562,
-0.2763249278,
-0.5162757039,
0.0543255098,
0.4103337824,
0.4391873479,
-0.8826838732,
-0.0132208746,
0.5683358908,
0.8895888329,
-0.3001734018,
0.0466649979,
-0.4994843602,
0.2389353067,
-0.3629919887,
0.7686214447,
-0.2535588145,
-0.2680152357,
-0.1436281055,
-0.1243106201,
0.0411943309,
-0.546156466,
0.2448674142,
-1.0335197449,
0.2761976421,
-0.4825570285,
-0.9562855363,
-0.0661185607,
0.4243745506,
-0.6647544503,
1.059420228,
0.0992977172,
-0.9579603672,
0.6030920148,
-0.4183187485,
-0.1932009757,
0.0892303735,
-0.248035565,
-0.2272263169,
0.1171758994,
0.2243216485,
0.6556941867,
-0.3329746723,
0.4507002234,
-0.4596803784,
-0.2020717263,
0.5830742717,
-0.7563464642,
0.9262644053,
0.2765411735,
-0.2985157669,
-0.1632449627,
-0.6198993921,
-0.2543278635,
-0.0595312268,
-0.6285927892,
-0.4182496965,
0.3295818865,
-0.3512978852,
0.1552290171,
0.5602715015,
-0.5899323225,
0.0902999341,
-0.5493401289,
-0.0125100389,
0.7425895929,
0.3000813127,
0.4851585031,
-0.1659513712,
0.3273423612,
-0.0826167092,
0.0951093212,
0.1144512519,
-0.3226496577,
-0.5884473324,
-0.1993762553,
0.4251009524,
0.4478979409,
-0.7969414592,
0.3808604181,
-0.2767162025,
-0.4613106251,
0.1046594754,
0.2767991126,
0.4289917052,
0.8549239039,
0.2018776685,
0.1630173326,
-0.4068956375,
-0.3812435269,
-0.0596453957,
-0.5080651641,
0.0127784284,
0.3347091973,
0.4702513814,
0.0164375845,
1.2271738052,
-0.466552496,
0.267680347,
-0.1727367938,
-0.2291675061,
0.1577686816,
0.2078833431,
0.5351231098,
-0.8027819991,
-0.6937407851,
0.1444526762,
-1.1441066265,
-0.0821861848,
0.210848853,
0.178081587,
0.3729365468,
0.7272774577,
-0.6224777102,
0.2008027583,
0.5664712191,
-0.1864486337,
0.7498030066,
-0.034517318,
-0.1231309697,
-1.2023348808,
0.0590342358,
-0.0827040002,
-0.2929783463,
-0.4729097784,
-0.1008185744,
0.2134552002,
0.3862542808,
-0.5507526398,
0.907859683,
-0.5727844238,
-0.1920152903,
-0.1353388578,
0.2816343307,
-0.1649761051,
0.2569582462,
0.0314052589,
1.1171512604,
0.3461019695,
-0.7413694859,
0.2849000692,
0.1490056217,
-0.7924910188,
0.4585849643,
-0.4501316845,
0.1288575977,
0.1199673042,
0.1492293775,
-0.9208832979,
-0.2345496863,
0.342363894,
-0.5284709334,
0.4015192389,
-0.4608457983,
-0.589676559,
-0.0206519701,
0.086811766,
0.0453403145,
0.4244391918,
-0.9010995626,
0.4909093976,
0.5533454418,
-0.2513746321,
-0.7857751846,
-0.3431228995,
0.0466389209,
-0.3954325318,
-0.5029324293,
0.1823617518,
-0.2497107983,
-0.697863102,
0.1699223518,
-0.1478534788,
-0.3095313609,
0.2070413083,
0.1686513573,
0.3269007802,
-0.4126807153,
0.5056246519,
0.1705015302,
0.0378532298,
0.194462046,
-0.4154381752,
0.2691149414,
0.015810933,
-0.5396314859,
-0.1115100384,
-0.0559831522,
0.4905349314,
-0.0590041094,
1.0320382118,
0.3731676042,
-0.491885215,
-0.1923897564,
-0.7676294446,
-0.0383699462,
-0.3921104372,
0.1443190277,
-0.2813551426,
-0.8521036506,
0.6307073832,
-0.1665713638,
0.0342904106,
0.4949820936,
0.5700545907,
-0.2976206541,
0.6722595096,
0.7163723707,
-0.0729281157,
0.590899229,
-0.1684604883,
-0.1275003254,
-0.8740987182,
-0.3665823638,
-0.3593453169,
0.3085120618,
-0.1881306618,
-0.3100508153,
0.580722332,
0.235352844,
-0.0975972041,
-0.133303538,
0.2289890349,
0.4407216907,
0.3687991798,
0.2226834446,
0.4681785107,
0.0723585263,
-0.1967839748,
-0.0350152105,
-0.8597803712,
-0.6710806489,
1.2437008619,
0.2640376389,
0.7706653476,
0.3892995715,
0.3589121103,
0.1445578933,
0.5712043047,
-0.9818271995,
0.2262313068,
0.1772986054,
-0.5933383703,
-0.2907011807,
-0.5598427057,
-0.555806458,
-0.0148034729,
-0.270961374,
-0.7651442289,
0.0913125426,
0.1628580689,
-0.3195619285,
0.4432407022,
-0.6018012762,
0.4403797686,
-0.4146221578,
-0.3877622187,
-0.1575025767,
-0.4846274555,
0.3742269576,
-0.281232655,
0.1006343737,
0.0497468747,
-0.0374182686,
0.8109446764,
-0.5544537902,
0.987898767,
-0.4050324559,
-0.2468774617,
0.4178466797,
-0.1930150688,
0.594555378,
0.180886969,
-0.2233144492,
0.1387622207,
-0.0005020773,
-0.1722489297,
-0.778306663,
0.6739826202,
-0.756677866,
-0.5829028487,
-0.1873401254,
-0.3835931718,
-0.5896689296,
0.0337017141,
0.3986890912,
0.5071849227,
-0.3331263661,
0.3857059777,
1.0721658468,
-0.2962248027,
0.4502171874,
0.6392350793,
0.0764958635,
-0.3304490149,
0.760304153,
0.4037491083,
0.3618284166,
0.7068701982,
0.4172730744,
-0.5066844225,
-0.6252143383,
-0.4398469925,
0.3174321949,
-0.9941158295,
-0.2299888432,
-0.6472331882,
-0.2504425943,
-0.1853204817,
0.0785111934,
-0.1499682218,
-0.1717435271,
-0.5015146732,
-0.158826977,
0.4596230388,
0.9415211678,
0.0904109702,
0.2936585844,
-0.6829990149,
-0.1657821536,
0.4480758607,
0.2641118169,
0.1899368614,
-0.7649334073,
-0.5494372845,
-0.0879333839,
0.0048623462,
-1.004119873,
0.0915562809,
-0.0579443537,
1.0912207365,
0.504453063,
0.0198355764,
0.5531508327,
-0.3197783828,
0.889353931,
0.063633129,
-0.7024416327,
0.3509145677,
-0.2248202413,
0.1429017186,
0.4996405542,
0.465030998,
-0.3635050952,
-0.1576571018,
-0.6147918701,
-0.5651941299,
0.4373849332,
-0.209907636,
0.0075680413,
-0.0259346254,
0.5134697556,
0.2299044728,
0.2388839424,
-0.7437329292,
-0.2204866707,
0.1538227051,
-0.3273223937,
0.1577130854,
-0.6468626857,
0.0725075826,
-0.1112509891,
0.8955934048,
-0.292743206,
0.1108273789,
0.0176276155,
-0.6712364554,
-0.07590615,
0.1292373985,
0.4015620053,
1.2377027273,
-0.1835724264,
0.1599280834,
0.6189424396,
-0.3374135196,
-0.0756721497,
-0.0398468748,
-0.3306459785,
-0.0051361299,
0.6124098897,
0.7037456036,
0.5452150702,
-0.6204391122,
0.6607124209,
-0.0182653964,
0.1350400448,
-0.6468570828,
-0.0768124238,
0.1957357377,
0.3934666514,
0.4113427997,
-0.2113189399,
-0.1346253902,
-0.2747368813,
0.2749011815,
0.5553120971,
-0.5585041046,
-0.3359233439,
0.3167662323,
0.0395287424,
0.0195924714,
0.4011218548,
-0.1128711328,
-0.3733821511,
0.4091887772,
0.5697671175,
0.5305432081,
-0.2356935889,
0.0095065963,
0.360070616,
0.0616649911,
-0.0021144268,
-0.0549060814,
-0.2751090229,
-0.937093854,
-0.7226292491,
-0.5745606422,
-0.5923920274,
0.323849082,
-0.2431923449,
0.1271482557,
-0.3242223859,
0.0681486055,
-0.3017342985,
0.2926127017,
-0.554831028,
0.085767135,
0.0874493346,
1.0216858387,
-0.6719543338,
0.8755625486,
0.5854232311,
-0.4324635565,
-1.0365035534,
0.3420611322,
0.0385610461,
-0.569088459,
0.802703619,
-0.2222332209,
-0.1884049028,
-0.0590067059,
-0.8203931451,
-1.1184084415,
1.3111923933,
0.603493154,
-0.3819323778,
0.0008698557,
-0.4331943393,
0.2340089977,
-0.3013384044,
0.3171547949,
0.2749824822,
0.4091974497,
0.2499335408,
-0.8325713277,
-0.1211853847,
0.0557492487,
-0.3686313331,
-0.1115427688,
-0.3830744028,
0.6184614897,
-0.2189267278,
-0.2540344298,
0.0551830269,
0.9610625505,
0.532820344,
0.3406957984,
0.6089861393,
0.1006055027,
1.1491806507,
0.1365304887,
0.9689785838,
-0.3554381132,
0.3198892772,
1.1535894871,
-0.0176888891,
0.8002445102,
0.6197716594,
-0.1896978617,
0.5853152871,
0.7524450421,
0.3286927342,
0.3679616153,
-0.2863172293,
-0.4377906024,
-0.1934078783,
-0.0905461982,
-0.2632183135,
0.4037240148,
0.6271901727,
-0.322822243,
-0.0505673513,
-0.3150034547,
0.3956316113,
-0.2209259421,
-0.2044454813,
1.0351480246,
0.2901198268,
-0.7748017907,
0.2662116587,
-0.1702204943,
0.5067209005,
-0.6072645187,
-0.1024456993,
-0.2292107046,
-0.0675487071,
-0.220966503,
-0.8227235079,
0.1193957254,
0.1012764946,
-0.3432707191,
0.138588205,
0.9700664878,
-0.4983506501,
-0.3284974992,
0.2153594196,
0.9801738858,
0.0843605176,
-0.0196042247,
-0.4332203567,
-0.1745975912,
-0.1022075489,
-0.420681417,
0.2546230257,
0.5042774677,
-0.1686274558,
0.6131358147,
0.6781131029,
0.1851660311,
-0.0221765488,
-0.1899754405,
0.8440078497,
-0.2858041823,
-0.3553251028,
-0.8881322145,
0.548869431,
-0.182305485,
-0.0802077502,
0.9565417767,
0.3446319401,
0.6503471732,
0.0326732621,
0.9228602648,
-0.1692611426,
0.4594932199,
-0.91099298,
0.7949619293,
-0.4816545546,
0.4653885961,
-0.2387506366,
-1.083583951,
-0.1039862335,
0.5416020155,
-0.6415959001,
-0.0235115923,
0.4536725879,
0.7657632232,
-0.2535368204,
-0.0626991615,
0.4484958649,
0.312807411,
0.2880743146,
0.0910316557,
1.1760591269,
0.0429730266,
0.2602007687,
-0.1355641037,
-0.3489263952,
-0.1785106808,
-1.026506424,
-0.7882809639,
-0.6849737167,
-0.0068376916,
-0.1721200645,
-0.0025125635,
1.0589438677,
0.742105186,
-0.7241722345,
-0.2089182436,
0.2155089378,
0.6525982022,
0.0148154804,
-0.245079726,
0.5094588995,
-0.3832058012,
-0.4689486623,
0.7156307697,
0.1499056667,
-0.1337433904,
-0.4425100386,
-0.287868619,
-0.2980736494,
-0.1123652905,
0.8050010204,
0.2660216689,
-0.736825645,
-0.4951978028,
-0.0889998525,
-0.0886941701,
-0.0376798548,
0.5284583569,
-0.8892523646,
0.3399938345,
0.4842168987,
0.5935682058,
0.385667026,
-0.101407662,
0.5289471745,
-0.8170745373,
-0.0607874319,
0.0084530208,
0.5097510219,
0.6026336551,
-0.4727221727,
0.4540995359,
0.3446163833,
-0.5400089025,
-0.6727842689,
0.2768664956,
-0.6472425461,
-0.2750519514,
1.3969899416,
-0.4548539817,
-0.2323969603,
-0.3502767384,
0.1384153217,
0.2648679018,
-0.2765523791,
0.5211828351,
0.6149454713,
-0.0271088611,
-0.1675337255,
-0.6846707463,
0.5785987377,
-0.0082828011,
-0.7442242503,
-0.1284640282,
0.593398869,
0.6812970042,
0.1606373638,
0.5437411666,
-0.1135353073,
0.0929126963,
-0.1920428574,
-0.1730726659,
0.0630463362,
-0.4715800285,
-0.2273747474,
0.1761484444,
0.4949815869,
0.3110481501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12938v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12938v2
|
MAiDE-up: Multilingual Deception Detection of GPT-generated Hotel Reviews
| 2024-04-19T15:08:06 | 2024-06-19T03:34:42 |
Oana Ignat, Xiaomeng Xu, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Deceptive reviews are becoming increasingly common, especially given the
increase in performance and the prevalence of LLMs. While work to date has
addressed the development of models to differentiate between truthful and
deceptive human reviews, much less is known about the distinction between real
reviews and AI-authored fake reviews. Moreover, most of the research so far has
focused primarily on English, with very little work dedicated to other
languages. In this paper, we compile and make publicly available the MAiDE-up
dataset, consisting of 10,000 real and 10,000 AI-generated fake hotel reviews,
balanced across ten languages. Using this dataset, we conduct extensive
linguistic analyses to (1) compare the AI fake hotel reviews to real hotel
reviews, and (2) identify the factors that influence the deception detection
model performance. We explore the effectiveness of several models for deception
detection in hotel reviews across three main dimensions: sentiment, location,
and language. We find that these dimensions influence how well we can detect
AI-generated fake reviews.
|
[
-0.342530489,
-0.5963210464,
0.7630198002,
0.3747434616,
-0.2986282706,
0.1063938737,
0.1862102747,
-0.6966379881,
0.3387040794,
0.6654257774,
-0.4363134205,
-0.4239399433,
-0.5160406232,
0.5306247473,
-0.1265354156,
0.9246862531,
-0.0945397392,
0.7188783884,
-0.1940534115,
0.0067972839,
-0.3879587352,
-0.7226843238,
-0.6053152084,
-0.3629600108,
0.1499408931,
-0.0811413378,
0.6994341612,
-0.1412521005,
0.2902019024,
0.2087171078,
0.4498961866,
0.6780682206,
-0.1417299509,
-0.1185363904,
0.1480683684,
-0.381700635,
-0.1991427243,
0.2416342199,
0.4696153104,
-0.0031288147,
-0.1915979385,
0.3701519072,
-0.2011115998,
0.7840002179,
-0.4870530665,
0.3782084882,
-0.5431010723,
-0.1123744175,
0.0771319568,
0.2709700465,
-0.4269350767,
-0.4417648613,
-0.257439822,
-0.3344403505,
0.3831034303,
-0.0570772812,
1.0810412169,
0.2131009698,
-0.5436993241,
-0.4341315031,
-0.9398462176,
0.5733772516,
-0.6289973855,
0.4727377892,
0.5851892233,
0.3896021247,
0.0914964601,
-0.1727406532,
-0.9301661253,
-0.6900908947,
-0.303543359,
0.2482010871,
-0.1466442049,
-0.3204879463,
0.0990689993,
0.2587804794,
-0.4537683725,
-0.2235513031,
-0.0031502056,
-0.380171001,
0.7617971301,
-0.0604590662,
0.6561310291,
-0.0900867358,
-0.2628890872,
0.0105963061,
-0.7560857534,
-0.2294685245,
0.6577708721,
-0.0686238855,
-0.0366759151,
0.2042660713,
0.0039322758,
0.4578372538,
-0.131486237,
-0.0984581783,
0.1083431691,
-0.5223080516,
-0.3938606083,
0.1964280307,
0.7806850076,
0.6004009843,
0.5213854909,
-0.0303188507,
-0.5595302582,
0.5434624553,
0.4360162616,
-0.7191560864,
-0.1637650877,
0.1059779897,
-0.5662025213,
-0.7448862195,
0.3598775268,
-0.4481662214,
-0.6525834203,
-0.3326276541,
0.2842797041,
-0.1376065612,
-0.429879725,
0.1316437274,
-0.1955059767,
0.2538553774,
0.3127660751,
-0.1329361796,
0.2872890234,
0.4120037854,
0.6179848313,
-0.1801594496,
-0.382445991,
-0.4515287876,
-0.1612323374,
-0.404753983,
0.7130274773,
-0.4137777984,
-0.4417116344,
0.1586510837,
0.0115303164,
-0.2031182498,
-0.5918645859,
0.8574101925,
-0.6334298849,
0.6335009336,
-0.3412560225,
-0.2075520903,
-0.3927783668,
0.475474894,
-0.8393421769,
0.9874669313,
0.0472711623,
-0.6046446562,
0.3445875049,
-0.6419640183,
-0.4373078942,
-0.1398764253,
-0.21331954,
-0.7687577605,
0.4955839813,
0.8327184916,
0.30740574,
-0.0361953825,
0.2751105726,
0.1305371821,
-0.4181082845,
0.6389758587,
-0.850300312,
0.9321933985,
0.3295708597,
-0.4264714122,
-0.1103291661,
-0.6886470318,
-0.3634358943,
0.4078111053,
-0.1886093169,
-0.2610088587,
-0.1662308723,
-0.0345351771,
0.1353652924,
0.082115218,
-0.5852567554,
0.1019782275,
-0.3157899976,
0.1240647361,
0.212325722,
0.3737373054,
0.2356374711,
-0.5590550303,
0.8067674041,
0.1545412838,
0.2598499954,
-0.0992975533,
-0.4615263939,
-0.6391267776,
-0.404840976,
0.2849342525,
0.5719348192,
-0.9298918843,
0.1966265738,
-0.2913478315,
-0.3598078787,
-0.8756849766,
-0.2670179605,
0.6510388255,
0.2579023242,
0.2862800658,
0.181867063,
-0.1479983628,
-0.8839355707,
-0.5948325396,
-0.3632023931,
-0.1852021813,
-0.0209138952,
0.4975396693,
-0.3026010096,
0.4004312754,
-0.2933526039,
-0.5953705907,
-0.0573336519,
-0.1285136789,
0.0788902938,
0.0667517781,
0.8656285405,
-0.8181191087,
-0.6477575302,
-0.2354064137,
-0.5967520475,
-0.055502411,
-0.3707951903,
0.1658283174,
0.555110395,
0.1019219831,
-0.5907335877,
0.3755636811,
0.5891526937,
-0.1381585747,
1.0352525711,
-0.1296323985,
0.5862073898,
-1.0721031427,
-0.378929168,
0.0109318057,
-0.2287357301,
-0.5627849698,
0.2045025676,
0.018667534,
-0.1589963138,
-0.3124557137,
0.5670568347,
-0.6597934961,
0.2522341907,
-0.1993025243,
-0.1202610359,
0.234149918,
0.4377676845,
0.1130590811,
0.8402574062,
0.566010654,
-0.4103903174,
0.3211212158,
0.1785831749,
-0.6705730557,
0.5880063772,
-0.4462456703,
0.250926137,
0.0696004704,
0.3847415447,
-1.2694202662,
-0.3856087923,
0.3500585556,
-0.7690779567,
0.2257677615,
-0.3080284894,
-0.6947517395,
-0.3148151338,
-0.4776453376,
0.0736274868,
0.3585498929,
-0.8138849735,
1.0668567419,
0.3989895582,
0.131033659,
-0.6263559461,
-0.6774969101,
0.3489856422,
-0.1133995205,
-0.5245407224,
-0.0141828852,
0.3541774452,
-0.6335958242,
-0.1599905938,
-0.3311834931,
0.0510714315,
-0.1842073202,
0.1923042834,
0.3100146949,
0.0562018156,
-0.1022611484,
-0.2071085274,
0.0857954249,
0.3565855622,
-0.2332053185,
0.5573230386,
-0.3478883207,
-0.432448566,
-0.6655774117,
0.2541181743,
0.8197425604,
-0.2134970427,
0.6952913404,
0.8281522393,
-0.303185761,
-0.3077143729,
-0.7672759295,
-0.2482822984,
-0.380197078,
0.1310139149,
-0.6365417242,
-0.4890761971,
0.7106013894,
0.2896317244,
-0.0236874986,
0.3064750135,
0.6760885715,
-0.2198749781,
1.4129348993,
0.5301495194,
-0.2804995477,
0.1822695881,
-0.0358733386,
0.5499925017,
-0.4243646264,
-0.2861582339,
-0.6524195671,
-0.0274301562,
-0.9657773376,
-0.3098452389,
0.5169112086,
-0.0551735684,
0.0581948124,
0.1180415526,
-0.6456942558,
0.7843919396,
0.546964705,
-0.0379813462,
0.6111031175,
0.3240486085,
-0.1162729934,
0.1299466044,
-0.3367115557,
-0.7893307805,
0.7535077333,
0.257915616,
0.5683903098,
0.1714443266,
0.4583229721,
0.6073439121,
0.3977565169,
-0.5918238759,
0.5263916254,
-0.0238933656,
-0.5701513886,
-0.1635835171,
-0.2418840826,
-0.5070340037,
0.4949819744,
0.0002629201,
-0.1216889098,
0.094094798,
-0.0667756572,
-0.09964028,
0.4091934562,
-0.8209296465,
0.1877571642,
-0.5839434266,
0.0899806693,
-0.2878929377,
-0.479824543,
0.5987596512,
-0.3283002377,
0.4935976863,
-0.2768033445,
0.1714567095,
0.505012691,
-0.3100591302,
0.787717402,
-0.3470194638,
-0.4236498475,
0.1003043801,
0.647578299,
0.6334548593,
0.4646136165,
0.0887376368,
0.7220598459,
-0.0600605235,
-0.2838851511,
-0.4718487561,
0.7666774392,
-0.9018713832,
-0.5433104634,
-0.6430586576,
-0.1370414197,
-0.4334460497,
0.185443759,
0.3539892137,
0.3383238614,
-0.3227060139,
-0.521291554,
0.3742186129,
-0.2438486665,
0.289798528,
0.8183249235,
-0.5271112919,
-0.479637742,
0.9012197256,
-0.194405809,
-0.1383165717,
0.2742102742,
0.3376407921,
-0.669496417,
-0.4703162909,
-0.7447652221,
0.4696862698,
-0.524456501,
-0.0469227731,
-0.4786633253,
-0.0666231886,
-0.4315324426,
0.0008938217,
-0.3861516118,
-0.4477276504,
0.1297449768,
-0.0497543551,
-0.0117915766,
0.904341042,
0.086278446,
0.3614737391,
-0.7532094717,
0.6561667323,
0.1080607101,
0.3110156655,
-0.2927428484,
-0.4842447937,
-0.1649732292,
0.3448049724,
0.0317283422,
-0.896795392,
0.3934494257,
-0.1448903233,
0.5606136918,
0.5567289591,
0.033521492,
0.1736902595,
-0.3093138933,
1.2037945986,
0.1291290969,
-0.7059556842,
0.2898470163,
-0.2800597847,
0.1209945828,
0.4759550095,
0.6890344024,
-0.4170306325,
-0.4834233522,
-0.6392461061,
-0.1684955209,
0.2469002753,
0.2430748791,
0.4303937554,
0.1089452431,
0.0908262804,
0.2473705262,
0.5781496763,
-1.2113072872,
-0.195763275,
-0.1591117084,
0.3439630866,
-0.0176302865,
-0.3077623844,
-0.3362200558,
-0.1163751036,
0.8795309067,
0.0642019138,
0.5442726612,
-0.0276292823,
-0.2937635183,
-0.1101251543,
0.0644281581,
0.9031668901,
0.7332559824,
-0.1072281972,
0.2098939419,
-0.0568843335,
-0.6159163117,
0.1489243507,
-0.1083968431,
-0.4955059588,
0.4137821496,
0.5341416001,
0.7407389283,
-0.5972630382,
-0.2474539131,
0.6658976674,
-0.2886500657,
-0.2502720058,
-0.5971871018,
-0.1498898715,
-0.2530550957,
-0.1097205207,
0.1741493791,
0.4384979308,
0.114131704,
-0.5388059616,
0.0572352894,
0.6324035525,
-0.2889682949,
-0.3561353683,
0.7006765008,
0.5182829499,
-0.3675400913,
0.8155727983,
-0.4710208476,
-0.9406254888,
0.3009022474,
0.1649408787,
1.2107012272,
-0.3391297162,
0.6634178162,
0.2980809808,
0.7317925096,
0.0333512798,
0.3374091387,
-0.1533093303,
-1.1238501072,
-0.6029051542,
-0.8376601934,
-0.2728338838,
0.4840979576,
-0.4682789445,
0.2637076676,
-0.0263209697,
0.0262127779,
-0.2258399576,
0.0208603758,
-0.5838244557,
0.1420864314,
0.3716983497,
0.5624164939,
-1.0506401062,
0.7709094286,
0.5830488801,
-0.5730257034,
-0.6866434813,
0.4565334022,
0.1173751131,
-1.1692713499,
0.3129113019,
0.2052963972,
-0.8274254799,
-0.2112017721,
-0.5987121463,
-0.1663785577,
0.3437354565,
0.1401055455,
-0.5899012685,
-0.0497859791,
0.4327383041,
0.7645122409,
-0.3901101351,
0.2335290462,
0.7248248458,
0.5214754343,
-0.2726997137,
-0.9052137733,
-0.0930838585,
0.04253098,
-0.065219216,
0.0065835151,
-0.576390624,
0.2795319259,
-0.2317207605,
-0.2971622348,
-0.3210919797,
0.1340455413,
0.2245762497,
0.4279609621,
0.5143505335,
0.561008513,
0.7055395246,
-0.311714679,
1.2858986855,
-0.339250356,
0.1325373948,
1.0279114246,
-0.4963900149,
0.6113448739,
0.1360293329,
-0.1985869408,
0.7590574026,
0.5920333266,
-0.4552786052,
0.5643277168,
0.2845265567,
-0.2791677713,
-0.155622527,
0.0028744047,
-0.1552954167,
0.4967884421,
0.2623105049,
-0.2346127331,
-0.1736336201,
0.3545956612,
0.237141937,
-0.0417077579,
-0.3332464993,
0.8951785564,
-0.056352701,
-0.8207392097,
0.6923061609,
0.1127354801,
0.5793421268,
-0.3947294652,
-0.1697450727,
-0.5529413819,
-0.0607894287,
-0.1864009947,
-0.6258044243,
0.0735514387,
-0.0576055236,
-0.1608502269,
-0.3905354738,
0.8965523243,
-0.4358205795,
-0.6886299253,
0.0661526173,
0.8704692721,
0.3258216679,
-0.5507257581,
-0.8390488625,
-0.0501890816,
0.1475998312,
-0.1248337999,
0.1391859055,
0.1880699694,
-0.2236011028,
0.6311351061,
0.770006299,
0.2769480646,
0.0640483573,
0.4785636067,
0.3358971775,
-0.30736655,
-0.7040016055,
-0.9112365246,
0.2034626901,
-0.196383968,
0.0328416862,
1.0558182001,
0.7885830998,
1.0930033922,
-0.590434134,
0.835080862,
0.5040179491,
0.5246239305,
-0.519872427,
0.8326095939,
-0.3602048755,
0.4449804127,
-0.0526660159,
-1.0700399876,
-0.2506997883,
0.5781584382,
-0.2629460096,
0.1293812692,
0.7433254719,
0.9534128308,
0.1243497282,
0.0108143361,
0.4498119354,
0.2243884504,
0.4603418708,
-0.0196751785,
1.4326549768,
-0.486634016,
0.325417608,
-0.0317136385,
0.1934527457,
-0.1832279861,
-0.8921155334,
-0.9522443414,
-0.4379858077,
-0.6017854214,
-0.6573032141,
-0.2266608477,
0.4970709085,
0.479688406,
-1.0631227493,
-0.0126093868,
0.0249441881,
0.1311693341,
-0.489166677,
-0.2507528365,
0.6267660856,
-0.0275648218,
-0.9285110235,
0.5199157,
0.0663579777,
0.0525798723,
-0.584675312,
0.0575019568,
0.1976126283,
0.4615640044,
0.5004953146,
-0.3682514727,
-0.8798118234,
-0.0244762376,
-0.0879907683,
-0.1535058022,
-0.0713022351,
1.0456340313,
-0.5501524806,
0.4118112326,
0.3920363784,
0.3008804619,
0.3763405979,
0.0051249312,
0.3934698105,
-0.9198127389,
-0.225468412,
0.2599101663,
0.3271394074,
0.2837334275,
-0.5575857162,
0.5251791477,
0.3836474717,
-0.6342167854,
-0.9706602693,
0.1962927133,
-0.7822193503,
-0.3337063193,
1.2053518295,
0.2371101826,
0.0609560236,
-0.3069499731,
-0.3479343653,
-0.1609084755,
-0.2569357455,
1.1195671558,
1.1003959179,
-0.2695164979,
0.2438981533,
-0.7090625167,
1.0526041985,
0.1065385938,
-0.7603750229,
0.0182064231,
0.7896225452,
0.4923972487,
0.3820163012,
0.6930212379,
-0.3325727284,
0.4084047377,
-0.1750077605,
-0.0232320186,
-0.4126772881,
-0.4973662794,
-0.5790312886,
0.0835613161,
-0.1349127889,
-0.3663696647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12933v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12933v2
|
Cross-cultural Inspiration Detection and Analysis in Real and LLM-generated Social Media Data
| 2024-04-19T15:04:30 | 2024-06-19T03:27:43 |
Oana Ignat, Gayathri Ganesh Lakshmy, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Inspiration is linked to various positive outcomes, such as increased
creativity, productivity, and happiness. Although inspiration has great
potential, there has been limited effort toward identifying content that is
inspiring, as opposed to just engaging or positive. Additionally, most research
has concentrated on Western data, with little attention paid to other cultures.
This work is the first to study cross-cultural inspiration through machine
learning methods. We aim to identify and analyze real and AI-generated
cross-cultural inspiring posts. To this end, we compile and make publicly
available the InspAIred dataset, which consists of 2,000 real inspiring posts,
2,000 real non-inspiring posts, and 2,000 generated inspiring posts evenly
distributed across India and the UK. The real posts are sourced from Reddit,
while the generated posts are created using the GPT-4 model. Using this
dataset, we conduct extensive computational linguistic analyses to (1) compare
inspiring content across cultures, (2) compare AI-generated inspiring posts to
real inspiring posts, and (3) determine if detection models can accurately
distinguish between inspiring content across cultures and data sources.
|
[
-0.351135999,
-0.6721352339,
0.4137689471,
0.573644042,
-0.5699074864,
0.3574454784,
-0.2862669528,
-0.704724133,
0.3437612057,
0.098644197,
-0.9807800651,
-0.547375381,
-0.7553268671,
0.4510300756,
-0.3699972928,
0.9052452445,
-0.3624941111,
0.1595001519,
-0.3052634597,
-0.126339227,
-0.6160897613,
-0.1593976319,
-0.351918608,
-0.08644104,
0.4702768028,
0.4885973334,
0.0432398021,
0.1352501214,
0.4931416512,
0.147061497,
0.31875512,
0.3539895117,
-0.8873215318,
-0.1622645408,
-0.3583586812,
-0.3106697798,
0.3673838675,
0.2200337648,
0.581513226,
0.0232463814,
0.0789717808,
0.542927444,
0.2781823575,
0.6980826259,
-0.3484309614,
0.2042678893,
-0.7820827961,
0.4238354564,
-0.1117780879,
-0.3720865846,
-0.0254361574,
-0.948875308,
-0.3130631745,
-0.4276219606,
0.2986627817,
-0.2119144201,
0.8975760341,
0.1170400605,
-0.3016307056,
-0.7158437967,
-0.6767824292,
0.8299642205,
-0.0972752348,
0.3587924838,
0.1445757002,
0.2735341489,
-0.0619488396,
-0.4452119172,
-0.8149136305,
0.1453216672,
-0.0764623731,
0.2926846147,
-0.6025304794,
-0.8448991776,
0.1630493701,
0.39714697,
-0.7553730607,
-0.0811597407,
-0.3368887901,
0.032448817,
0.8290558457,
0.103518568,
0.8416098952,
-0.0655735061,
-0.3476589322,
-0.1223270521,
-0.7375727296,
0.1424234211,
0.4008927345,
-0.014993716,
-0.5879632235,
0.483122021,
-0.5720330477,
0.4244650006,
-0.1932068169,
-0.0498638339,
0.2195410132,
-0.5147674084,
0.2284573317,
0.0243031997,
0.8466007113,
0.3921847343,
0.4720826447,
-0.221597895,
-0.2198671997,
0.2562478781,
0.0730123743,
-0.9395890832,
0.0029254581,
-0.2843134105,
-0.8271915317,
-0.3935678005,
0.4107927084,
-0.5040590167,
-0.6064934134,
-0.359824419,
0.280433625,
-0.3043059111,
-0.3982004821,
-0.2979682684,
-0.2883333564,
0.4670240581,
0.115795657,
-0.9037442207,
-0.1424595118,
0.9270730019,
0.9553080797,
-0.1127310544,
-0.1991838366,
-0.0084977057,
-0.3335028291,
-0.6161623597,
0.7478603721,
-0.5269895196,
-0.172468096,
0.0100281695,
0.2006019056,
0.2926613986,
-0.3922916055,
0.9486059546,
-0.4032350481,
0.2667303681,
-0.6088383794,
-0.370301038,
-0.4312477708,
0.3200804293,
-0.594709754,
0.6882269382,
0.2048157156,
-0.6519232392,
0.7953577042,
-0.7094503641,
-0.4279648662,
0.1937945932,
-0.3821091652,
-0.331631422,
0.4615871012,
0.4797977507,
0.4302074015,
-0.8211566806,
0.1271294653,
-0.1997828484,
-0.3816285729,
0.2097298205,
-0.4588451684,
1.1164040565,
0.5172746181,
-0.401463151,
0.1054817811,
-0.7740219235,
-0.0794524178,
0.5957584977,
-0.1550335288,
-0.3709078133,
-0.5016530752,
-0.1552186012,
0.5802532434,
0.067900911,
-0.9354798794,
0.0939356908,
0.0488016047,
0.2722215354,
0.7331035137,
0.4522271752,
0.0148696285,
-0.3548396528,
0.978081882,
-0.0919484496,
0.0118386466,
0.0137722595,
-0.6661320329,
-0.0101903193,
-0.2361498028,
0.1884943098,
0.5477086902,
-0.7424392104,
0.228865698,
-0.3995779157,
-1.0453381538,
-0.8475771546,
0.3625600338,
0.0597205721,
0.6533543468,
0.1249323711,
-0.3400352895,
-0.6807277203,
-0.7676357627,
-0.6273646355,
0.1316806078,
-0.0120654879,
0.1006323248,
0.5204492807,
-0.3359371722,
0.643620193,
-0.17427966,
-0.1673375964,
-0.2234461606,
0.3418836892,
0.4596255124,
0.3833903968,
0.7311131358,
-0.9126657844,
-1.1915123463,
0.1058133841,
-1.269161582,
-0.4969521463,
-0.292685926,
-0.4316795468,
-0.0733743608,
0.1341644078,
-0.5171580911,
0.582868278,
0.6637657881,
-0.113823697,
0.514998138,
0.2394745797,
0.5260800719,
-1.0942054987,
-0.206423074,
0.1267746836,
0.2590705752,
-0.2589755654,
-0.4007160366,
0.2065916061,
-0.4971130192,
-0.42053473,
0.6746426225,
-0.2667915821,
-0.0533831045,
-0.2406954914,
-0.3164587915,
-0.0570633374,
0.3343973458,
0.2762630582,
0.4555414617,
0.7652808428,
-0.0282247271,
0.5122396946,
0.1015813276,
-0.7236084342,
0.7066117525,
-0.4814705253,
0.1568689495,
-0.2664588988,
0.2379248589,
-1.077298522,
-0.378739357,
0.3919773102,
-0.713773787,
-0.2343216538,
-0.0692190081,
-0.6382243633,
-0.5425339341,
-0.1839445531,
0.2793767154,
0.6577826142,
-0.8905548453,
0.3976559639,
0.1120684072,
-0.202160731,
-0.3316988051,
-0.5661997199,
0.0553727262,
-0.6480835676,
-0.6244622469,
0.2915456295,
-0.0458367877,
-0.2366109043,
0.1295383126,
0.2782472372,
0.4816243649,
0.0262266807,
0.4450861812,
-0.0246071387,
-0.1320268661,
-0.2563066483,
-0.1585108936,
0.1563289762,
0.2753764987,
-0.2488466948,
0.678355217,
-0.078700833,
-0.4944598079,
-1.1443077326,
0.547724247,
0.3768329918,
-0.2483704835,
0.6615352631,
1.0667140484,
-0.4900717735,
-0.2378527522,
-0.3680377305,
-0.1157671809,
-0.4603364468,
0.1336972862,
-0.2587631345,
-0.5141755939,
0.4733696282,
0.2353251725,
0.0376092233,
0.4845612943,
0.8106847405,
-0.2570161819,
0.9162706137,
0.7811615467,
-0.1602214277,
0.7735273242,
-0.2031390667,
0.1760938317,
-0.2652806938,
-0.1349450201,
-0.3258518279,
-0.6257373691,
-0.9033486843,
-0.109100543,
0.235550642,
-0.1819265932,
0.0469477251,
0.14928931,
-0.6442506313,
0.5592719316,
0.7542994618,
-0.0742276311,
-0.0766355619,
0.334861666,
0.0123298764,
-0.1624420881,
-0.6393171549,
-0.3053409159,
1.1181439161,
0.1245881841,
0.9030278921,
0.1183618978,
0.9159498215,
0.705021441,
0.7312492728,
-0.6719018817,
0.4012134373,
-0.0273170918,
-0.2045488358,
0.1389785409,
-0.5072402358,
-0.898481369,
-0.2166286856,
-0.3824251592,
-0.3678107262,
0.2023125738,
-0.0948226899,
0.0018916188,
0.2611526847,
-0.6120404005,
0.8039541841,
-0.637567997,
-0.2478467673,
-0.2566102445,
-0.3938307166,
0.4637352228,
-0.2413541973,
0.2051125616,
0.0275377426,
0.5563967228,
0.832864821,
0.0721315369,
0.7499347329,
-0.2339103371,
-0.0226094425,
0.5896872878,
-0.0099559529,
0.5575813055,
-0.0880913213,
-0.1247367263,
0.4270130992,
-0.4668188691,
-0.4259035289,
-0.590213716,
0.751975894,
-0.8497740626,
-0.2483572662,
0.0144420769,
-0.4515912235,
-0.0354447141,
0.1321674883,
0.4288545251,
0.1070346609,
-0.0630649626,
0.459718138,
0.0125692207,
-0.2956125736,
0.3934282064,
0.283465296,
-0.0076880795,
-0.5359948874,
1.10985744,
0.112352185,
0.0856681913,
0.2578203976,
0.3502393067,
-0.4487843513,
-0.2404200584,
-0.6356143951,
0.2310377657,
-0.9190188646,
0.0411696546,
-0.3986998796,
-0.0182356648,
-0.6029635072,
-0.2481644899,
-0.1624435186,
-0.3646844327,
-0.256167233,
-0.2188178301,
0.2905200124,
0.8638442755,
-0.5136205554,
0.088288568,
-0.6799761653,
0.3223310113,
0.3289853334,
0.1330424547,
0.123279117,
-0.3266623318,
-0.4927508831,
0.0628752112,
-0.4288041294,
-0.8105130196,
0.5442152619,
0.0815645605,
0.714695096,
0.6671566367,
-0.1288114339,
0.6472082734,
-0.0924774632,
0.711062789,
0.2111221999,
-0.3733975887,
0.683657825,
-0.1884039789,
0.203290984,
0.3704359531,
0.9052095413,
-0.7406486869,
-0.1895590574,
-0.6220251918,
-0.5489214063,
0.3665216267,
0.0131149786,
0.2907515168,
0.1353798062,
0.2195619494,
0.462002337,
0.089135088,
-0.9898881912,
0.1427444518,
-0.4186311364,
-0.2613473833,
0.2571967542,
0.0705045089,
-0.1365901679,
-0.2839249074,
0.7957255244,
-0.0688762814,
0.3269367516,
0.0678977296,
-0.1059381738,
-0.4193567336,
-0.1884195954,
0.3889289796,
0.7297406197,
0.2009274811,
-0.0736005008,
0.199904561,
-0.2716456652,
0.1461949497,
0.0151295252,
-0.2659057081,
-0.0848056525,
0.4917602241,
0.8641005754,
-0.5479381084,
-0.5220035315,
0.1220862493,
-0.6331747174,
-0.0079238582,
-0.5160021782,
0.1629258394,
0.0101832096,
0.334631294,
0.6163352728,
-0.1056180075,
-0.1965796947,
-0.8561497331,
0.2123764902,
0.7120483518,
-0.6223394275,
-0.516503036,
0.6955605745,
-0.0615400597,
-0.583709836,
0.6849576235,
-0.4392448366,
-0.590495944,
0.6933627129,
0.7034346461,
1.0089894533,
0.2309116721,
0.122005485,
0.4251979887,
0.1543023288,
0.2728452682,
0.516310215,
-0.3545868993,
-0.8771064878,
-0.2816203237,
-0.8043369651,
-0.3530040681,
0.1211869568,
-0.552857101,
0.5699071884,
-0.1237482429,
0.2270891219,
-0.0411157906,
-0.0169999041,
-0.9789531231,
0.4525075555,
0.516492784,
0.6353205442,
-1.4638229609,
0.7409311533,
0.5490056872,
-0.4660131037,
-0.7880042195,
0.2357919216,
0.1479386687,
-0.9360740781,
0.8444100618,
0.3477317393,
-0.122117348,
0.1111474931,
-0.6301655173,
-0.6299561858,
0.9863381982,
0.0291414931,
-0.149359107,
0.3828605413,
0.4455003738,
0.7017685175,
-0.7029402852,
0.0443508551,
0.1014355719,
0.2985827327,
0.0256451666,
-0.4417367876,
-0.1233180091,
-0.4974978864,
-0.1979714334,
-0.1759095639,
-0.6937195659,
0.6658571959,
-0.0815547556,
-0.2891510725,
-0.1362623572,
0.7843637466,
0.5232063532,
0.2035689354,
0.5275450349,
0.6207568049,
0.6653687954,
0.0219700541,
1.1534142494,
-0.5153126121,
0.2835904062,
0.6762405634,
-0.1488237977,
0.4699377418,
0.3052403629,
0.0769289881,
0.8078033924,
0.9255160689,
-0.2920645475,
0.6805841923,
-0.0610870682,
-0.2931893766,
0.0565844476,
-0.3941583633,
-0.4294839799,
0.6666445136,
0.2786930799,
-0.7370006442,
-0.2209526151,
0.2003878504,
-0.1682830155,
0.0113590825,
-0.3679737449,
0.6922973394,
-0.0465476625,
-0.9054490924,
0.7715661526,
-0.2592503726,
0.5798329711,
-0.5983711481,
-0.2843997777,
-0.2709558308,
-0.060121458,
-0.2179553658,
-0.8472715616,
0.5862234831,
0.323571384,
-0.0132342242,
-0.6410033703,
1.1166330576,
-0.1741594076,
-0.7825192809,
0.3822803199,
0.4727887213,
0.2559339106,
-0.1251977533,
-0.8349236846,
-0.0268899649,
0.2223724723,
-0.246792838,
0.201604858,
0.8812983036,
-0.3400970995,
0.4353984892,
1.0621416569,
0.1536939293,
-0.2084365934,
-0.0175936017,
0.6392948031,
-0.8291999102,
-0.8131566644,
-1.2260347605,
0.2947995365,
-0.1557416618,
-0.1426484436,
1.0002975464,
0.6453944445,
0.8831431866,
-0.3382911384,
1.084431529,
-0.4313869178,
0.4600393474,
-0.1044766009,
0.9468421936,
-0.746455729,
-0.145277068,
-0.3551350534,
-0.8305956721,
-0.198372826,
0.3128480315,
-0.5003045201,
-0.3297921419,
0.1667507887,
0.8876883388,
-0.0609791204,
0.4288373888,
0.0681439713,
-0.0465379953,
0.3180927634,
0.2312995493,
1.4178168774,
0.2162808329,
0.4300585687,
-0.6101804376,
-0.382725805,
-0.0957134962,
-0.970451951,
-0.6465163827,
-0.5742121339,
-0.0983807147,
-0.2488591373,
-0.2548854649,
0.9822659492,
0.5622964501,
-0.6906352639,
-0.0977601781,
-0.1362227798,
0.2381036431,
-0.3620080054,
-0.265565604,
0.3930432796,
-0.0687295124,
-0.5631073117,
0.3751988709,
0.136381194,
-0.0804252028,
-0.3457723856,
0.047571905,
0.024469424,
0.0045162211,
0.7065017223,
0.3145669103,
-0.3845823109,
-0.3978356421,
-0.1006866768,
0.101685442,
0.1817863733,
0.7605794072,
-0.6917510629,
0.2925091088,
0.895981133,
0.7912444472,
0.3736054003,
0.4280374646,
0.3329901099,
-0.6812096238,
0.0359114148,
0.1511204541,
0.4934528768,
0.501149416,
-0.3629054427,
0.8545607328,
0.6021415591,
-0.7089522481,
-0.6205919981,
0.1631723344,
-0.5383296013,
0.0136257811,
0.994170785,
-0.2502502501,
-0.4185219407,
0.1725117862,
-0.2605916858,
0.3442794979,
-0.1716338545,
1.1736397743,
0.8796801567,
-0.6217733026,
-0.044627104,
-0.514125824,
0.3793022931,
0.2998319268,
-0.9239429832,
-0.130573228,
0.4537009001,
0.37908867,
0.1627143174,
0.4165702164,
-0.0973216146,
0.4038001895,
-0.1902582347,
0.0835990757,
0.3502926528,
-0.1110783666,
-0.3023087978,
0.2966738939,
-0.1882733554,
-0.2926638126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12897v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12897v2
|
Enabling Natural Zero-Shot Prompting on Encoder Models via Statement-Tuning
| 2024-04-19T14:05:03 | 2024-04-22T10:17:07 |
Ahmed Elshabrawy, Yongxin Huang, Iryna Gurevych, Alham Fikri Aji
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable capabilities in
zero-shot and few-shot scenarios, they often require computationally
prohibitive sizes. Conversely, smaller Masked Language Models (MLMs) like BERT
and RoBERTa achieve state-of-the-art results through fine-tuning but struggle
with extending to few-shot and zero-shot settings due to their architectural
constraints. Hence, we propose Statement-Tuning, a technique that models
discriminative tasks as a set of finite statements and trains an Encoder model
to discriminate between the potential statements to determine the label. We do
Statement-Tuning on multiple tasks to enable cross-task generalization.
Experimental results demonstrate that Statement Tuning achieves competitive
performance compared to state-of-the-art LLMs with significantly fewer
parameters. Moreover, the study investigates the impact of several design
choices on few-shot and zero-shot generalization, revealing that Statement
Tuning can achieve sufficient performance with modest training data and
benefits from task and statement diversity for unseen task generalizability.
|
[
-0.3703459799,
-0.9602867365,
0.3987131119,
0.0560821854,
-0.2574877739,
0.0244049877,
-0.6145045757,
-0.4698865414,
-0.0324755199,
0.5398000479,
-0.7770892978,
-0.687713325,
-0.631144762,
0.3714713454,
-0.0673896596,
1.0763617754,
0.091548346,
-0.0745470673,
-0.0620561689,
-0.0403105058,
-0.9492444992,
-0.0594605468,
-0.6171515584,
-0.3273455203,
0.45511657,
0.3925049305,
0.5385301709,
0.624786973,
0.2681697607,
0.1561653018,
0.2187404484,
0.4484169781,
-0.5376645923,
0.2485665083,
-0.0577856302,
-0.8340395689,
-0.1122446358,
-0.0736485943,
0.49903512,
0.6649054289,
0.0911707357,
0.2292253226,
0.1277678758,
0.5240801573,
-1.0185567141,
0.0852212831,
-0.9751454592,
0.2706752419,
-0.0897436738,
-0.3240449131,
-0.5126402378,
-0.2871180773,
-0.1387601048,
-0.6044785976,
0.6253946424,
0.0699801892,
0.9804115295,
0.5431169868,
-0.2026891857,
-0.2131468207,
-0.8462765813,
0.8061128855,
-0.5972205997,
0.2384634465,
0.439186722,
0.2223512232,
0.0403994918,
-0.0555378422,
-0.5144134164,
-0.1910653859,
-0.0460177101,
0.08999639,
-0.4014982879,
0.4444041848,
0.4846023023,
0.233558923,
-0.6842036843,
0.3946935833,
-0.1227978244,
-0.0535800084,
0.3256663978,
0.1933239996,
-0.0766424909,
0.2007015944,
0.0349531882,
0.1938598156,
-0.9135783315,
-0.0893970579,
0.2526229918,
0.7945091724,
-0.1498586535,
0.5890051723,
-0.6493865848,
1.5069708824,
0.4888220727,
0.1318178773,
-0.1320975721,
-0.2735454142,
-0.5240258574,
0.1818190515,
0.5079783201,
0.3656944335,
0.3750565648,
-0.3814353645,
-0.1346758604,
0.4814021289,
0.3705601096,
-0.9094102383,
-0.0635998026,
0.1463369727,
-0.2704656422,
-0.1781526506,
-0.1442355514,
-0.6533771157,
-0.3496170044,
-0.4353682101,
0.5853017569,
-0.2953644097,
0.1082023084,
0.437677592,
-0.3744295835,
0.5376036763,
0.0880543739,
-1.0811822414,
0.0705151111,
0.6269493699,
0.8422891498,
-0.0296644866,
0.1633559614,
-0.7467320561,
0.2946022451,
-0.5791078806,
0.5936978459,
-0.9849986434,
-0.4359076619,
0.2374115735,
-0.1898047179,
-0.2504566908,
-0.6893061996,
0.3768187463,
-0.3126501143,
-0.0341038145,
-0.3166389763,
-0.5388153195,
0.1695638001,
0.4041202366,
-0.2274236083,
0.8242759109,
-0.0613035262,
-0.2763014436,
0.7629303336,
-0.7874847054,
-0.666369915,
0.2546315789,
-0.4503186643,
-0.4382864535,
0.5908834934,
0.5020193458,
0.4639451206,
-0.2397716045,
0.10309764,
-0.2038045079,
-0.5737842321,
0.0334096886,
-0.2969373167,
0.468718946,
0.2010241598,
-0.2895241082,
-0.0803928822,
-0.7143277526,
0.1597502828,
-0.0692223683,
-0.4084105492,
-0.0932088941,
-0.1305615902,
-0.5930301547,
0.0848505646,
0.3003042638,
-0.8720426559,
0.264539808,
-0.5303174853,
0.0768710077,
0.4823990762,
-0.0757017061,
0.4247487485,
-0.4475785196,
0.7470529675,
-0.1086313799,
0.0492318533,
-0.4297029376,
-0.5619788766,
-1.0756348372,
-0.2504600286,
0.3617898524,
0.6504582763,
-0.8871302605,
0.5882745981,
-0.049461484,
-0.1432187259,
-0.9095862508,
0.1856037378,
0.5212996602,
0.6210434437,
0.3976466656,
0.0190355163,
-0.6888301373,
-0.9883112907,
-0.4956167042,
0.1425179988,
-0.2674404085,
0.414981395,
0.3074809313,
0.2444043756,
1.2248806953,
-0.6836470366,
-0.479511112,
-0.244690448,
0.3416344821,
0.4315235317,
0.3342310786,
0.5124505758,
-0.4718871117,
-0.724378407,
0.0646806285,
-0.7961516976,
-0.1602175981,
-0.280952692,
-0.0761969611,
0.2885685861,
0.2851801813,
-0.6878256202,
0.4914051294,
0.4109147489,
-0.0771781504,
0.3791983724,
-0.2922579944,
0.0256792009,
-0.612862587,
-0.2572247386,
0.2411039025,
-0.1430393159,
-0.7772632241,
0.1628015488,
0.0182598345,
-0.2327362299,
-0.2209913284,
0.1878516227,
-0.5393599868,
0.1965556443,
-0.3935777247,
-0.1061671674,
0.0402987488,
0.4848450124,
0.2689410448,
0.6380910873,
1.0813480616,
-0.9289908409,
-0.0219384078,
0.2049117237,
-0.2421072572,
0.8406761885,
-0.8456988335,
0.224193722,
-0.3604361117,
0.0602386929,
-0.8190259933,
-0.1166809872,
0.2200303823,
-0.4579801261,
0.4728117585,
-0.3101468384,
-0.4086313844,
-0.4091173708,
-0.1455613822,
0.017993262,
0.5889081955,
-0.5495501161,
0.4540317357,
-0.0111597059,
0.1770146191,
-0.2799375355,
-0.7535158396,
0.178171128,
-0.1408939213,
-0.410176754,
0.4840694964,
-0.1194961295,
0.1443480104,
-0.3183932602,
-0.2260942906,
0.0831951052,
-0.1414132118,
0.2085017711,
0.3609457612,
-0.273917824,
0.2465891689,
0.1661983281,
0.0401655175,
-0.2405231446,
-0.5035704374,
0.295828402,
0.0089993915,
-0.3441033661,
-0.1206497326,
0.3890971839,
-0.1354005784,
-0.3444650471,
0.7600322366,
0.5254283547,
-0.2665725946,
-0.5103592873,
-0.4741716683,
-0.2536047101,
-0.527728796,
0.1882291585,
-0.4781290591,
-1.4015474319,
0.0614315867,
-0.1339496523,
0.1556974053,
0.0594434626,
0.7325053811,
-0.1155764684,
1.1985116005,
0.8534852266,
0.1280139089,
0.4082552493,
0.0039999983,
0.3059774935,
-0.5407295227,
0.0087962318,
-0.688754499,
-0.5869959593,
-0.6070362926,
-0.4604654908,
0.5858174562,
0.0722427741,
-0.1671350747,
0.3549991846,
-0.8638219237,
0.9061869979,
0.5381780863,
0.173579365,
0.1279889047,
-0.0456527956,
-0.0067015472,
0.0285172742,
-0.7649724483,
-0.2604625821,
1.1024795771,
-0.0393084884,
0.8034915924,
-0.0424594954,
0.9215882421,
0.1371062547,
-0.1287635118,
-0.7520051003,
0.4969522059,
-0.4702957869,
-0.8586736321,
-0.3294594288,
-0.3194125891,
-1.0840409994,
0.2088076174,
-0.3245587647,
-0.8204735518,
0.4180779755,
0.3942938447,
-0.8818208575,
0.0281918086,
-0.5249614716,
0.7296347022,
-0.058190871,
-0.182289049,
-0.1694535315,
-0.5663952231,
0.3603655398,
0.044491116,
-0.1705898046,
-0.2512712777,
-0.0608625188,
0.3631413579,
-0.0705515891,
1.2976372242,
-0.4759291708,
-0.1614096612,
0.168666482,
0.120653443,
0.5957104564,
-0.1578342319,
-0.102595374,
0.0467735901,
-0.3447191119,
-0.3378950655,
-0.6518232822,
0.6444818974,
-0.4874123335,
-0.7287470102,
-0.0743438974,
-0.5083543658,
-0.5719816089,
0.0866548866,
0.4480449855,
0.284250468,
-0.2399971187,
0.3025251627,
0.9866713881,
-0.307574302,
0.5019932985,
0.9198998213,
0.0256293248,
0.070008412,
1.07853508,
-0.0242733266,
0.3918605447,
0.61876297,
-0.004795067,
-0.1306216419,
-0.5691126585,
-0.3587864041,
0.0622548312,
-0.3658212125,
-0.4998544157,
-0.3865000308,
-0.0371223576,
-0.3732568622,
-0.3307035267,
-0.2504439056,
-0.3783941865,
-0.4329032004,
-0.1300780177,
0.3370908499,
0.4624188542,
-0.072213687,
0.4517865181,
-0.5748205185,
0.724021852,
0.3631972671,
0.5305943489,
-0.37579602,
-0.622426331,
-0.4220039546,
0.2065047175,
-0.425431639,
-0.6204531789,
0.3071263134,
0.7543541193,
0.521333158,
0.4207504094,
0.2211596072,
0.7572306395,
-0.525837481,
0.645180881,
0.1879869401,
-0.7793426514,
1.01919806,
-0.4393795431,
0.6902569532,
0.5709488392,
0.3289288282,
-0.4132630527,
-0.5516682863,
0.0055533638,
-0.4140866995,
0.8167536855,
0.1594735086,
0.3208025992,
-0.2989007831,
0.1773830205,
0.2705323398,
0.3598457277,
-0.4324648082,
-0.3121321499,
-0.3003824353,
-0.0488547683,
0.0990240425,
0.1821322739,
-0.3128582835,
-0.3230389059,
0.4559890032,
-0.5823273659,
0.3805074692,
-0.0542347282,
-0.1480947435,
-0.2017204911,
0.5300036669,
0.6074504256,
0.3682377338,
-0.2054545581,
-0.088708289,
0.1928438395,
0.1251488775,
0.0313602723,
0.0746341124,
-0.5734182596,
0.1212359592,
0.0121255498,
1.4662994146,
0.2515902221,
-0.3689491153,
0.149368763,
0.0333201364,
-0.4167498648,
0.1672996879,
0.477221936,
-0.1635561734,
0.1025966629,
0.276348561,
0.1000908241,
-0.0409430377,
-0.421756506,
-0.031037746,
0.8228378892,
-0.4620573819,
-0.147081688,
0.7483387589,
0.2521369159,
-0.3321634829,
0.5175555348,
-0.2849781811,
-0.0060439841,
0.6288137436,
0.7157201767,
1.0228432417,
0.0582880042,
0.6202904582,
0.3875017166,
0.3904265761,
0.0943652391,
0.3042246997,
-0.4188377559,
-0.983135283,
-0.5130248666,
-0.8419213891,
-0.3488046229,
-0.0806270689,
-0.8690993786,
0.2180103958,
-0.5132350922,
-0.3041520417,
0.0763120875,
-0.275701493,
-0.9052157402,
0.2117607296,
0.4516601861,
0.8112156987,
-0.6005302668,
0.8384920955,
0.3746266961,
-0.3228753507,
-0.3955715001,
-0.0866188183,
-0.0454731844,
-1.0396038294,
0.5024200082,
0.22466892,
-0.0538380407,
0.1133451611,
-0.7697174549,
-0.4157910645,
0.9080263376,
0.6693280339,
-0.9353955388,
-0.1906465888,
0.5261747837,
0.5098626018,
-0.6064731479,
-0.0911711082,
0.8833134174,
0.4378691018,
0.2426667362,
-0.946223855,
0.005681016,
0.1376340389,
0.1437529773,
0.2759550214,
-0.5681484342,
0.6889691353,
-0.2364363819,
-0.2689382434,
0.0254068989,
0.5015774369,
0.4103858173,
0.0452134162,
0.2684708238,
0.516253233,
0.7267062664,
-0.2623640299,
1.0370731354,
-0.5247664452,
0.0580613054,
1.2811412811,
-0.4439822733,
0.6109192967,
0.2478077263,
-0.1910910904,
0.2960189879,
0.3305543661,
-0.2544367611,
0.6469811201,
0.1965557188,
-0.5406628847,
-0.6202017665,
-0.4064138234,
-0.2221707255,
0.6246964931,
0.5004472136,
-0.2486206889,
-0.4599265456,
0.0424870215,
-0.319255203,
-0.0832566395,
-0.4907236695,
0.8794344068,
0.0770270079,
-0.8677756786,
0.8180410266,
0.0567113608,
1.0649276972,
-0.7691756487,
-0.1782006472,
-0.1619298309,
-0.0540448129,
-0.1126585156,
-0.5295348763,
0.3533559144,
0.0775988773,
-0.3152205646,
-0.4021568,
0.803059876,
-0.5786307454,
-0.5700007081,
-0.0130582126,
0.3382609487,
-0.1986259669,
-0.1628524363,
-0.5522425175,
0.0556424372,
-0.0047086007,
0.2393207252,
0.5333584547,
0.330352366,
0.2343084663,
0.5062478185,
0.515565753,
0.2014493793,
0.1960736811,
0.3218875229,
0.7095817924,
-0.6530994773,
-0.4790840745,
-0.8717309833,
0.287004739,
-0.0092965206,
-0.2625540793,
0.7156792283,
0.4518771172,
0.8291066885,
-0.2385623306,
1.0065765381,
-0.0449509397,
0.4815924764,
-0.6004658937,
0.4200825393,
-0.3044904172,
0.0658013225,
0.1400352269,
-0.6490261555,
-0.3539210856,
0.5618364215,
-0.1899947077,
0.0534857623,
0.287630111,
1.1919878721,
0.2050374746,
0.0236289073,
0.7642709613,
0.0618998446,
0.057853803,
0.743960619,
0.5015826821,
-0.0635388047,
0.551994741,
0.076998435,
-0.1217276976,
-0.041967988,
-0.8758791089,
-1.128305316,
-0.1503967196,
-0.5923600197,
0.0466952175,
0.2921713293,
0.6918655038,
0.8359676003,
-1.0264173746,
-0.1339008212,
-0.1757919192,
-0.0652434751,
-0.2648863196,
-0.2353157997,
-0.2522917092,
-0.6435823441,
-0.7191326022,
0.7456344962,
0.5042625666,
-0.0620025247,
-0.166473493,
-0.2100459635,
-0.1109961793,
0.3953553736,
0.5662298799,
0.5551150441,
-0.7187235951,
-0.2677318752,
-0.0104703624,
0.2215431482,
0.1365210116,
0.9583877921,
-1.093193531,
0.6994841695,
0.1154237986,
0.6248521209,
0.6811408401,
-0.0741920993,
0.8001279235,
-1.4871524572,
-0.0140370345,
0.1181377992,
0.0227275975,
0.2223771214,
-0.3719474673,
0.3348034024,
-0.0731933713,
-0.3412853479,
-0.7193974853,
0.4372681379,
-0.5159587264,
-0.2750434577,
0.8465669155,
-0.0109885996,
0.1020899788,
-0.2049956471,
-0.0243831854,
0.1589043885,
-0.4531782269,
0.683694303,
0.6958529949,
-0.4417819381,
-0.2930011451,
-0.4956404269,
0.5625609756,
0.4778602421,
-0.6285238862,
0.0562240854,
0.5379373431,
0.045622468,
-0.0611370131,
0.6288664341,
0.2763228118,
0.2453890294,
-0.0368990824,
-0.0858982578,
-0.2183014452,
-0.3293845654,
-0.5909762383,
0.1324231029,
0.0485082082,
-0.5360337496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12879v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12879v1
|
Unlocking Multi-View Insights in Knowledge-Dense Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-04-19T13:27:38 | 2024-04-19T13:27:38 |
Guanhua Chen, Wenhan Yu, Lei Sha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) plays a crucial role in the
application of Large Language Models (LLMs), existing retrieval methods in
knowledge-dense domains like law and medicine still suffer from a lack of
multi-perspective views, which are essential for improving interpretability and
reliability. Previous research on multi-view retrieval often focused solely on
different semantic forms of queries, neglecting the expression of specific
domain knowledge perspectives. This paper introduces a novel multi-view RAG
framework, MVRAG, tailored for knowledge-dense domains that utilizes
intention-aware query rewriting from multiple domain viewpoints to enhance
retrieval precision, thereby improving the effectiveness of the final
inference. Experiments conducted on legal and medical case retrieval
demonstrate significant improvements in recall and precision rates with our
framework. Our multi-perspective retrieval approach unleashes the potential of
multi-view information enhancing RAG tasks, accelerating the further
application of LLMs in knowledge-intensive fields.
|
[
-0.2630325854,
-0.4933660328,
0.9129065871,
-0.0538905486,
-0.1956605166,
0.0232185256,
0.0318443403,
-0.150553003,
0.5166469812,
0.829464972,
-0.2083564401,
-0.3550694287,
-0.7451056242,
-0.253446281,
-0.1842734814,
0.9307332039,
0.009063852,
0.0877026916,
-0.359970808,
-0.4310257137,
-0.3146911263,
-0.6859922409,
-0.449390322,
-0.1928382516,
0.8793399334,
0.4147782326,
0.2919393182,
0.4081593156,
0.4472018182,
0.263725549,
0.0034583323,
0.6523609161,
-0.547873795,
0.3475868702,
-0.1396160573,
-0.4840748906,
-0.5677746534,
-0.0567912906,
0.8132120371,
0.7835719585,
-0.4680558443,
0.0039893347,
0.1325960904,
1.0531468391,
-1.2159512043,
-0.1067529768,
-0.7728644013,
-0.1075752079,
-0.1700178683,
-0.5990754366,
-0.6367539763,
-0.1398439109,
0.0161445551,
-0.8339377642,
0.2477967441,
0.2818318307,
0.6211771965,
0.4475892186,
-0.6854031682,
0.1401813477,
-0.5348885655,
0.9456511736,
-0.3583866656,
0.6654582024,
0.1636198014,
0.5467768908,
-0.2480766475,
-0.7276130319,
-0.5061886311,
0.3144495785,
-0.1286400557,
0.2236970067,
0.1266112924,
0.1070301607,
0.0559910238,
0.2788110971,
-0.2904271781,
-0.3973607421,
-0.3866965771,
-0.0488512404,
0.5638892055,
0.0623657815,
-0.1397070885,
-0.4311573803,
-0.3065174222,
0.0545787029,
-0.7832414508,
-0.2775519192,
0.1003511921,
0.0615198202,
0.1528194398,
0.6875495911,
-0.3466404378,
0.895631671,
0.0493367985,
-0.4553596377,
0.2730366886,
-0.2669528127,
-0.3280661106,
-0.0718823001,
0.4241336882,
0.4252745509,
-0.1648720801,
0.138255015,
0.0663160905,
-0.3851400912,
0.6752566695,
-0.7697682381,
-0.0547772385,
0.2200032175,
-0.5518887639,
-0.3387130201,
-0.1090668961,
-0.8808046579,
-0.904404521,
-0.3380599618,
0.3155049384,
-0.4609332383,
-0.3833740354,
0.3682842851,
-0.321384877,
0.3535939753,
0.6136396527,
-0.4559985101,
-0.0625238568,
0.77544415,
0.3540794253,
-0.0294296611,
-0.3890144229,
-0.8053199649,
0.7032505274,
-0.4130491912,
0.8102846742,
-0.8152400255,
-0.2382187843,
-0.1310434937,
-0.3890788257,
-0.1515463293,
-0.5156273842,
0.6324267983,
-0.7748777866,
0.2355058193,
-0.2824580073,
-0.4247600734,
-0.5417034626,
0.5730952621,
-0.5408238769,
0.7327542901,
-0.124318257,
-0.8213402629,
0.8261346221,
-0.4228115082,
-0.4484786689,
-0.1177812964,
-0.5140711665,
-0.3469270468,
0.4334863424,
0.3295387328,
0.5009264946,
-0.30125615,
0.4545306265,
-0.1600703895,
0.0906385481,
-0.1603532284,
-0.5311253071,
0.2871046066,
0.0891921148,
0.2211260498,
0.1414360404,
-0.7604832649,
0.1821374446,
0.0752066001,
-0.6894834042,
-0.6960639954,
0.1876719743,
-0.3112939596,
0.2562074363,
0.1343507469,
-0.3694737554,
0.2130963504,
-0.2469793856,
-0.0909789875,
0.398330003,
0.2567706108,
0.5509986877,
-0.2877907455,
0.4796093404,
0.3257761598,
0.147031486,
-0.3502606153,
-0.4576223493,
-0.6060451269,
-0.4057099521,
0.2354829907,
0.2587950528,
-0.9819074869,
-0.1715234071,
-0.3780870736,
-0.3715749383,
-0.8373901844,
0.0447318405,
0.6522367597,
0.7160546184,
0.483084023,
-0.2692679763,
-0.5788635612,
-1.0638985634,
-0.810382545,
0.1004409194,
0.2172286659,
0.743010819,
0.3007666767,
-0.1047161147,
0.5546324849,
-0.6170503497,
-0.3131133914,
-0.4781895876,
-0.0401623175,
0.2419383675,
0.2806333601,
0.4765230715,
-1.453877449,
-0.4995734692,
0.1279146969,
-0.6822222471,
0.1763069779,
0.0756905079,
-0.4337620437,
0.1998306215,
0.2746754885,
-0.4767659903,
0.4877394438,
0.4420969486,
-0.1555915624,
0.5401744843,
-0.260161221,
0.5642156005,
-1.2862993479,
0.0955646783,
-0.136257112,
-0.2204499692,
-0.6073645949,
0.1408439428,
0.3208298981,
0.3071550727,
-0.618452251,
0.6021700501,
-0.5940231085,
-0.2025213689,
-0.1837336123,
0.1914694607,
0.6638950109,
0.4036145806,
-0.0365066938,
0.7555376887,
0.278083384,
-0.6894056201,
-0.1698272377,
0.1739899814,
-0.3450400829,
0.7914914489,
-0.3205609918,
-0.1268552244,
-0.5374324918,
0.2820410132,
-0.4851044118,
-0.7170134783,
-0.0602237917,
-0.4154943526,
0.5666003227,
-0.5212281346,
-0.4170295,
0.0167942662,
-0.3721319139,
0.6188862324,
0.0927901417,
-0.5607110262,
0.9962826967,
0.6893247366,
0.0629749745,
-1.2227876186,
-0.3174933493,
0.0172126386,
-0.2975167036,
-0.4512425363,
0.4539892673,
0.2246721387,
-0.3941115141,
-0.2014978677,
-0.1662539989,
-0.1931451708,
-0.162030682,
-0.1219021082,
0.155553624,
-0.1612757742,
0.0780849382,
0.4053620994,
0.0570570752,
-0.0876154006,
-0.3070223331,
0.5432405472,
0.2323465645,
-0.5675004721,
-0.0120352739,
0.5912060142,
0.6286507249,
-0.5841687322,
0.8362414837,
0.2283384949,
-0.3476266265,
-0.2141978294,
-0.8721733689,
0.037565589,
-0.4256024361,
0.4628558159,
-0.5912362337,
-0.9066334367,
0.1442391872,
-0.2982173264,
0.1332175732,
0.3797909617,
0.5794909,
0.0826196373,
0.8961507678,
0.7460072041,
0.0409264341,
0.2538621128,
-0.1227802038,
0.236868903,
-1.3870216608,
-0.4640617967,
-0.3846244514,
-0.211286813,
-0.2123528421,
-0.7551582456,
0.8507731557,
0.2946039736,
-0.1690424681,
-0.1364950687,
-0.5312244296,
0.6036139131,
0.4208274186,
0.0627441853,
0.6326857209,
-0.0119661773,
-0.2547278106,
-0.2176504582,
-0.8399422765,
-0.1885058284,
1.2290186882,
-0.1728933603,
0.5737857819,
0.3653175533,
0.7637243867,
-0.1769856066,
0.2152876109,
-0.7345669866,
0.2514283955,
-0.1966691613,
-0.7587125301,
0.0105566438,
-0.4366318882,
-0.8318961263,
0.9383865595,
-0.1944048107,
-0.3986079395,
0.2430575937,
0.2136794627,
-0.4028802216,
0.3699019849,
-0.7280420065,
0.6513977051,
-0.1742797643,
-0.6348890662,
-0.327652663,
-0.5767701864,
0.5762816072,
-0.2550733685,
0.3900822103,
0.041501645,
-0.1600424051,
0.3482275605,
-0.2946267426,
0.5341268778,
-0.4080727398,
-0.1085308269,
0.2453893423,
0.0860344842,
0.2864956558,
0.2040066272,
-0.2751986086,
-0.182179451,
-0.3111629486,
-0.166190818,
-0.6649677157,
0.6874996424,
-0.2608406246,
-0.7436879873,
-0.2985494435,
-0.825915277,
-0.4033518434,
0.5136314631,
0.0803694725,
0.4343429208,
0.0359680206,
0.314643532,
0.8613497615,
-0.4935659468,
-0.0951317474,
0.6126873493,
-0.4645971954,
-0.242824927,
0.718546927,
0.0184960533,
0.2377520055,
0.7206308246,
0.0698199496,
-0.2115971297,
-0.5760480165,
-0.7288550735,
0.1871297359,
-0.5857309699,
-0.3730983734,
-1.0718327761,
-0.1117670611,
-0.4918298721,
-0.1719226241,
-0.4701153338,
-0.455951333,
0.2678055167,
0.0922886506,
0.4177301824,
0.581146121,
0.0041703219,
0.0162502229,
-0.7676251531,
0.6716069579,
0.1139596999,
0.4287665486,
-0.0749233961,
-0.476531595,
-0.1667369008,
-0.1119920537,
-0.3005031049,
-0.5203695893,
0.5565211177,
0.2640388012,
0.640253067,
0.1862989664,
0.0196034536,
0.9547495246,
-0.9149058461,
0.4069847465,
0.0397862606,
-0.3747759759,
0.7117210627,
-0.3242186606,
0.0253744312,
0.6314740777,
0.2751709223,
-0.3932947516,
-0.1681373864,
-0.5398043394,
-0.9550180435,
0.508991003,
-0.162295863,
-0.0191151649,
0.2622115016,
0.6047946811,
0.2460790575,
0.5237264037,
-0.1512128115,
-0.2554165423,
0.0762354061,
-0.0503020734,
0.0882497132,
-0.3317832649,
-0.2397992611,
-0.3221473098,
0.4953067303,
-0.2548270822,
0.1043860614,
0.3136007786,
0.0287110209,
0.205586493,
0.4514009953,
0.442712456,
0.587253809,
0.0963137001,
0.0733697936,
0.0174011346,
-0.5672049522,
-0.1424634159,
0.0356612876,
-0.0560465939,
-0.0616029538,
0.0442242175,
0.524415791,
0.2618341148,
-0.503677547,
0.6396784782,
-0.1053126082,
-0.272115469,
-0.4386821389,
0.1484020948,
0.0390935726,
0.3477682769,
0.3440379202,
0.3498906493,
0.5904424787,
-0.2544199526,
0.2679591477,
0.5299277306,
-0.1840128601,
0.0802329853,
1.0019779205,
-0.1328299642,
0.2058611661,
0.2575848401,
0.0993832946,
-0.3483422101,
0.2482516617,
0.2546703517,
0.5435207486,
-0.1110490113,
-0.0547272488,
0.2959430516,
0.0082932971,
-0.1901479065,
0.4912286103,
-0.1590405107,
-0.7545397282,
-0.8020322919,
-0.8858249187,
-0.3879244924,
-0.0451676771,
-0.8296883106,
0.1428435892,
-0.095179528,
0.1555209756,
0.0613419116,
-0.1628249586,
-0.4301539063,
0.2259373367,
-0.2596945167,
0.7132041454,
-0.1002075523,
1.0943293571,
0.7389088869,
-0.1712291688,
-0.7893109918,
0.0016487679,
0.2516522408,
-0.7829676867,
0.4051595926,
0.0640631542,
-0.5770486593,
-0.1366120428,
-0.4669952393,
-0.809437871,
1.0620548725,
0.3221514523,
-0.2930343151,
0.0485410653,
-0.1019137353,
0.3795460761,
-0.3571805954,
-0.1845409423,
0.5298367739,
0.4595414996,
0.1502401382,
-0.8103631139,
-0.357077986,
-0.3128878474,
-0.1766732931,
0.5968159437,
-0.6077591181,
0.7566543221,
-0.4351072907,
0.1701933593,
-0.2409326881,
0.5564831495,
0.7651159167,
0.4067330062,
0.2035233825,
0.6899002194,
0.7217457294,
0.2080535144,
1.4685180187,
-0.3113270402,
0.0539735816,
1.2829611301,
-0.3717684448,
0.9705615044,
0.7211773992,
0.1687544584,
0.3611359298,
-0.0736739859,
0.5075882673,
0.5546424985,
-0.1040052399,
-0.4254644513,
-0.3682208061,
-0.2069615722,
-0.2863523066,
0.5163778067,
0.7017980218,
-0.4795019925,
0.0022009441,
-0.0362222902,
0.299728334,
0.1903090328,
-0.4080863893,
0.8281468749,
0.1266334802,
-0.7632827163,
0.4324138761,
0.0295709092,
0.6859427094,
-0.3834507465,
-0.3034444749,
0.0174593627,
0.3720470071,
-0.2255892009,
-0.8229508996,
0.4465705752,
-0.0063453875,
-0.5253172517,
-0.3681545258,
1.0344142914,
-0.2702326477,
-0.5298999548,
0.3117363453,
0.9238108397,
0.1661599129,
-0.3941679001,
-0.429602325,
-0.142565161,
0.0121243671,
-0.4281476438,
0.4468198419,
0.9416699409,
-0.0379467905,
0.6211540103,
0.4110376835,
0.0640525594,
0.2865070403,
0.2095680833,
1.0045113564,
-0.5869925618,
-0.0219218861,
-0.4826591611,
0.5904626846,
-0.2950020432,
-0.2192001939,
0.7403081656,
0.8793041706,
0.7931549549,
0.0217955131,
0.9338197112,
-0.2184334695,
1.0400737524,
-0.4981599152,
1.0627958775,
-1.0902457237,
0.1100982726,
-0.182477355,
-0.6648048162,
-0.5853583813,
0.4526256025,
-0.2823406756,
0.1330682486,
0.4805557132,
0.7548111081,
-0.1670678407,
-0.3618236482,
0.52536726,
0.1842907518,
0.2255381346,
0.4065963626,
0.583055675,
-0.5173586607,
0.5853765607,
-0.2267538309,
-0.0881650597,
-0.1671318114,
-0.6381579041,
-0.5242568254,
-0.5379958153,
0.1220580265,
-0.142294541,
-0.0172323659,
0.4287931621,
0.5889558792,
-0.355001241,
0.1470380574,
0.2803564072,
0.1191777289,
-0.0496074408,
-0.2100943029,
0.2651871741,
-0.4320584238,
-0.74237293,
0.5760295391,
0.4469383061,
-0.5522953272,
-0.0984992236,
-0.0044933683,
-0.2611241043,
-0.0298954211,
0.9973481297,
0.0181623064,
-0.6326053143,
-0.1779374778,
0.0123511609,
-0.0468454584,
0.3664794266,
0.8956649303,
-0.9979888201,
0.4181407392,
0.389241457,
0.7021639347,
0.4746893644,
0.1617141664,
0.6157822013,
-0.8850613236,
0.1938193142,
0.3054301739,
0.5654578209,
0.2708896101,
-0.3768520951,
0.4633668661,
0.0150070945,
-0.6422483921,
-0.5890745521,
0.456866771,
-0.8408721089,
-0.3042887747,
1.1993368864,
0.1836432815,
-0.2034833133,
-0.3034390807,
-0.3389925361,
0.0384376571,
-0.3332106769,
0.580245018,
0.4028707147,
-0.3040538728,
-0.2279410213,
-1.0670794249,
0.5184761286,
0.4569231868,
-0.8018122315,
0.1073274389,
0.8581641912,
0.123856917,
0.2141222507,
0.8118159771,
-0.5775478482,
0.1781167984,
-0.0871614516,
0.0324620791,
0.1690835804,
-0.7550471425,
-0.0001616261,
0.4363622367,
-0.033976268,
0.0792762786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12872v1
|
LLM-R2: A Large Language Model Enhanced Rule-based Rewrite System for Boosting Query Efficiency
| 2024-04-19T13:17:07 | 2024-04-19T13:17:07 |
Zhaodonghui Li, Haitao Yuan, Huiming Wang, Gao Cong, Lidong Bing
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
Query rewrite, which aims to generate more efficient queries by altering a
SQL query's structure without changing the query result, has been an important
research problem. In order to maintain equivalence between the rewritten query
and the original one during rewriting, traditional query rewrite methods always
rewrite the queries following certain rewrite rules. However, some problems
still remain. Firstly, existing methods of finding the optimal choice or
sequence of rewrite rules are still limited and the process always costs a lot
of resources. Methods involving discovering new rewrite rules typically require
complicated proofs of structural logic or extensive user interactions.
Secondly, current query rewrite methods usually rely highly on DBMS cost
estimators which are often not accurate. In this paper, we address these
problems by proposing a novel method of query rewrite named LLM-R2, adopting a
large language model (LLM) to propose possible rewrite rules for a database
rewrite system. To further improve the inference ability of LLM in recommending
rewrite rules, we train a contrastive model by curriculum to learn query
representations and select effective query demonstrations for the LLM.
Experimental results have shown that our method can significantly improve the
query execution efficiency and outperform the baseline methods. In addition,
our method enjoys high robustness across different datasets.
|
[
-0.0955833197,
-1.1290516853,
0.2887870967,
0.0263518021,
-0.5074734092,
-0.1912671775,
-0.1959297508,
-0.2858163118,
0.4637075067,
0.9104712605,
-0.8359521031,
-0.4378201067,
-0.2161495537,
0.0290317368,
-0.1463356465,
0.5350927114,
0.1747347414,
0.2043465972,
-0.1459862441,
0.0500112809,
-0.4792239964,
-0.3538733125,
-0.8230347037,
-0.3236722052,
0.5886774659,
0.5816961527,
0.4998812675,
0.6670562625,
0.5914414525,
0.2000060081,
-0.1047916785,
0.4901825488,
-0.790499866,
0.4891003072,
-0.4024572968,
-0.9511331916,
-0.6146187782,
-0.4228840172,
0.4410494864,
0.5117333531,
-0.47363469,
-0.0131023908,
-0.0082405219,
0.9815698862,
-0.4703909457,
0.0601462871,
-1.1619954109,
-0.1362841427,
0.0254001953,
-0.4504759312,
-0.5362749696,
-0.6693929434,
-0.2474966645,
-0.5038815141,
0.2422447205,
0.3602895737,
0.6077185869,
0.1845162511,
-0.3868600428,
-0.1876168698,
-0.2601294219,
0.7340618968,
-0.7232553959,
0.4815815389,
0.1941691041,
0.6026452184,
-0.356477201,
-0.6515740156,
-0.4216276705,
-0.1621395797,
-0.0569431484,
-0.1269446909,
-0.0550429411,
-0.2020812631,
0.1986670792,
0.0748867989,
-0.4322946668,
0.2331249863,
-0.1814428419,
-0.0883612335,
0.6505163312,
0.2843827009,
-0.0243065171,
-0.1092277393,
-0.379404068,
0.0691110268,
-1.1541488171,
-0.4487377703,
0.3646663129,
0.3833996356,
0.2746503055,
0.663869679,
-0.3533756733,
0.5837862492,
-0.0695553124,
-0.1625774801,
0.0258150138,
-0.3485987782,
-0.0690903589,
-0.2254361212,
0.2375077307,
0.9399034977,
0.39745152,
-0.1546901613,
-0.2453491837,
-0.20646213,
0.1406838894,
-1.2035266161,
0.08654093,
0.0617529936,
-0.5187091827,
-0.0972729474,
-0.1709580272,
-0.9503411055,
-0.3200595677,
-0.3299051523,
0.3263777494,
-0.3477350473,
-0.39284724,
0.0576657653,
0.1561379135,
0.5951752067,
0.5063543916,
-0.8360464573,
0.3075583577,
0.9873424172,
0.6543286443,
-0.1067694947,
0.0058631911,
-0.3403310478,
0.240504384,
-0.347579211,
0.9519684911,
-0.667129755,
-0.5314413905,
0.0397222266,
0.120488964,
0.0919591263,
-0.7553323507,
0.6587210894,
-1.0263944864,
0.0147787742,
-0.2905071676,
-0.7782223821,
-0.1513067782,
0.0392806679,
-0.4925233424,
0.8730280399,
-0.0107344994,
-0.4378913939,
0.4035689235,
-0.26942119,
-0.6157397032,
-0.0034930706,
0.0286109932,
-0.6895314455,
0.1118428111,
0.1929647923,
0.0305312853,
-0.5317238569,
0.2619079351,
-0.1837147921,
-0.6190891862,
-0.0358916186,
-0.2488067895,
0.5364679098,
0.0521127097,
-0.2312437296,
0.0810045078,
-0.4579240382,
0.3368445337,
0.2893860936,
-0.5839816332,
-0.3121489286,
0.0799317285,
-0.1622870415,
-0.096437797,
0.1051524282,
-0.2658556998,
0.5450206399,
-0.5825132728,
0.2994797528,
0.5101807714,
0.152055636,
0.3985257745,
-0.2546732128,
0.5532307029,
-0.4029456973,
-0.0523978248,
-0.1352989078,
-0.3472127318,
-0.9215942621,
-0.1695925146,
0.189448759,
0.5755189061,
-0.519644618,
0.2774330676,
-0.2292545289,
-0.3808620274,
-0.6519950032,
0.1997268647,
0.4978769422,
0.5175884962,
0.4631980956,
0.1382536441,
-0.782045424,
-0.9998189807,
-0.6412346959,
0.0480369143,
0.150115028,
0.7054921389,
0.4524586201,
-0.1713984758,
0.4094768167,
-0.9219822288,
-0.2078116387,
-0.3578710258,
-0.3707006276,
0.2539806068,
0.4243568182,
0.2203468978,
-0.5148490071,
-0.4924683273,
-0.3524844348,
-0.4284212291,
-0.254557848,
0.1557003856,
-0.5516005158,
0.4170871377,
0.7739849091,
-0.2457624227,
0.160808295,
-0.1584121436,
-0.2903545499,
0.4920651019,
-0.4194495976,
0.24582991,
-0.9478530884,
-0.3303183317,
-0.1100462526,
-0.1533474326,
-0.2435571104,
0.3360390961,
0.2585245073,
0.0830530822,
-0.2142297477,
0.3621657789,
-0.5978931189,
-0.1021404788,
-0.5231398344,
0.2193771303,
0.1220600307,
0.4756071568,
-0.0177068897,
0.8795264363,
0.4065956175,
-0.4900859594,
0.3231551349,
0.2348276973,
-0.5045181513,
0.7307328582,
-0.6789309382,
0.3197903633,
-0.1777505428,
0.4929679036,
-0.9692950249,
-0.0536018647,
0.0899135023,
-0.2433300763,
0.424757123,
-0.4192715585,
-0.5564896464,
-0.0499976836,
-0.3229568601,
0.1496936828,
0.5967519879,
-0.6743391752,
0.4110156298,
0.2500403821,
-0.1449514627,
-0.4974850118,
-0.7849519253,
0.2801224589,
-0.3709269762,
-0.695970118,
0.4544122219,
0.2501832247,
-0.1023299173,
-0.2399141043,
0.0061101378,
-0.0411454737,
-0.0158610083,
-0.0384392925,
0.2301852554,
-0.4464683533,
0.0981892496,
0.25461483,
-0.0426402763,
0.0921972319,
-0.0481923297,
0.5419332981,
0.395588249,
-0.3261658847,
-0.8021982312,
0.4718170762,
0.4031735361,
-0.316599071,
0.7079848051,
0.2262803167,
-0.1198303923,
-0.529317975,
-0.7226703167,
-0.5656141639,
-0.4494895935,
0.817699194,
-0.6236251593,
-0.8165602088,
0.116559431,
-0.3741392791,
-0.004383706,
0.2978395522,
0.5705857873,
0.1322779208,
0.7355760336,
0.4044398069,
0.3209958971,
0.4641515613,
-0.1884123832,
0.0655587241,
-0.8499384522,
-0.4759839177,
-0.7097658515,
-0.137928918,
-0.5113354325,
-0.7861692905,
0.0967527255,
0.2633710206,
-0.3910913765,
0.2881644368,
-0.3764774501,
0.661454618,
0.4243836999,
0.4328736067,
0.4131846428,
0.3576090336,
-0.1071704477,
-0.2288893014,
-0.5855578184,
-0.3851848245,
1.2428013086,
-0.0172141418,
0.9778961539,
0.6153557897,
0.4940800071,
0.2975089848,
0.292888552,
-0.7633744478,
0.6574319601,
-0.0426149517,
-0.5889107585,
-0.3026177287,
-0.3572807014,
-0.7111845016,
0.6324332952,
-0.3185645938,
-0.3784076869,
-0.0036332477,
0.1821333617,
0.0935430527,
0.3588356972,
-0.7728057504,
0.4542312622,
-0.0595941395,
-0.857699573,
-0.6391077042,
-0.3685992956,
0.3875499368,
-0.0383616798,
0.1218961403,
-0.0021516236,
-0.3253542185,
0.5273617506,
-0.6284005046,
0.6786040068,
-0.3664810956,
-0.1513897032,
0.3597183228,
0.4082102478,
0.9791205525,
0.1281049252,
-0.6151499748,
-0.3693493903,
-0.3042379022,
-0.1394413263,
-0.7665610909,
0.8303992748,
-0.243682757,
-0.9719828963,
0.0212073028,
-0.383792758,
-0.0353713632,
0.1867893934,
-0.214986071,
0.3646000922,
-0.1354576349,
0.4215187728,
0.4936291277,
-0.3239211738,
-0.1567433774,
0.9854546189,
-0.2905685604,
-0.3593654335,
0.6147494912,
-0.0808166638,
0.2933364809,
0.6687158942,
0.0358384214,
-0.7326259017,
-0.5910832882,
-0.3113676012,
0.4896543324,
-0.6439680457,
-0.2818403244,
-0.6486752629,
0.2917591333,
-0.5289071202,
-0.1457401365,
-0.0842461288,
-0.4666830599,
0.0040311501,
0.067957744,
0.3943540454,
0.2778613865,
0.2173890918,
0.1370200515,
-0.0642163306,
0.3238641024,
0.2094566673,
0.5711547732,
0.201198101,
-0.8097846508,
0.0777167603,
-0.3691785038,
-0.1588079929,
-0.6791346073,
0.2264819741,
0.3024293184,
0.5094251037,
0.3160223365,
0.0641522259,
0.684268415,
-0.7942294478,
0.2193954885,
-0.0751288682,
-0.4361537397,
0.6217552423,
-0.1481500119,
-0.1310111582,
0.501062572,
0.0171480216,
-0.1458643824,
-0.0403891392,
-0.2047526538,
-0.8794631958,
0.4512943625,
-0.0165752787,
0.1680332571,
0.0984529778,
0.7836329937,
0.0489048846,
0.0077734906,
-0.2553580105,
-0.3452642262,
-0.0008521692,
0.2095888257,
0.0267893113,
-0.8337566853,
0.1680329293,
-0.165408805,
0.8208011389,
0.0810340717,
0.1129067317,
-0.0220132265,
0.0292395372,
-0.1059170663,
0.5094810724,
0.4451325834,
0.5011121035,
-0.4790474474,
-0.119696632,
0.3437722623,
-0.0507235974,
0.1316979229,
-0.1026898995,
-0.2458836734,
-0.2104805261,
0.1332600415,
0.4855616987,
0.319717586,
-0.6342265606,
0.2949990928,
0.0348473005,
-0.3665184081,
-0.0830512866,
0.349181354,
0.6400026083,
0.2665097415,
0.0663406849,
-0.5426411629,
0.1632801145,
-0.4038030803,
0.2703157365,
0.6493247747,
-0.0465588123,
0.2055513114,
0.7237658501,
0.3450536132,
-0.559499681,
0.521250248,
0.1890886128,
-0.2776898742,
0.4809346795,
0.9008897543,
0.3966217041,
-0.267689079,
-0.1124029458,
0.6612645984,
0.3307222426,
-0.1443765908,
0.5226399899,
0.0131942518,
-0.4514785707,
-0.2488743514,
-0.597427547,
-0.4572332799,
-0.119885616,
-0.635972023,
0.4413955808,
-0.2151241004,
0.1532705128,
0.0785855874,
0.125859648,
-0.2422425747,
0.2026223987,
-0.5431216359,
1.1707173586,
-0.3991826773,
0.7993242741,
0.5490345955,
-0.318985045,
-0.6343671083,
-0.2647933066,
0.0232106447,
-0.9203749299,
0.5927114487,
-0.0130954999,
-0.4815245867,
0.0240256228,
-0.3474927843,
-0.6725758314,
1.1583766937,
0.5087990761,
-0.9131709933,
0.0338024721,
-0.1080360189,
0.4344869554,
-0.5418455601,
0.3326766193,
0.4835456312,
0.4387392104,
0.3846913278,
-0.3680888712,
0.3271990418,
0.0283052102,
0.0885284469,
0.2841631174,
-0.7053821683,
0.4953874648,
-0.6784379482,
-0.0449051,
0.3934114575,
0.5926611423,
0.3530874252,
0.2177669257,
0.3713619411,
0.4245244265,
0.5729441047,
-0.0138893714,
1.001085043,
-0.2510572076,
0.3756691515,
1.4352668524,
-0.6760518551,
1.141646862,
0.4279468954,
-0.4304032922,
0.5025935173,
0.2120084912,
-0.224370569,
0.4328452349,
0.6902714372,
-0.1191744506,
-0.5059167743,
-0.0586563535,
-0.4626559317,
0.4094704986,
0.1176558211,
-0.5558227897,
-0.3003405333,
-0.6286393404,
0.2892806828,
0.2941053808,
-0.060904488,
0.8044614792,
0.0170080196,
-0.8198182583,
0.7699231505,
0.2843286097,
0.7281771898,
-0.4680248499,
-0.1723784655,
-0.5535438061,
0.3635252714,
-0.2306009531,
-0.5049262047,
0.2159876823,
-0.0115093943,
-0.2429587543,
0.1174449027,
0.6846539378,
-0.3842481375,
-0.5265978575,
0.2773856521,
0.510676384,
0.3527839482,
-0.0801884383,
-0.6726459861,
-0.0958964229,
0.2791568339,
-0.2529010177,
0.3485203683,
0.4286256135,
0.0672991127,
0.8340517879,
0.5756366849,
0.1182176247,
-0.3293576241,
0.315004915,
0.8617273569,
-0.7831168175,
-0.5604891181,
-0.7813756466,
0.0876874104,
-0.1273419708,
0.1830507964,
0.6561650038,
0.9085832238,
0.4622241557,
0.0648031235,
0.5229463577,
0.4128622413,
0.8713496327,
-0.6496717334,
0.6318976283,
-0.8265389204,
0.6441463828,
-0.1513739973,
-0.9982169271,
-0.4545411468,
0.3124733567,
-0.2103849053,
0.1793848276,
0.4193788171,
1.6068620682,
0.0750201792,
0.0035932856,
0.2814639211,
0.2342895567,
0.2572615445,
0.4801876545,
0.3748915195,
-0.1450865716,
0.6525555849,
0.1559798867,
-0.1394210458,
-0.6936761737,
-0.6852281094,
-0.7554368973,
-0.0811283067,
-0.3554652333,
-0.6132321358,
0.4718790352,
0.8152039647,
0.5111197829,
-0.6679075956,
-0.1784124821,
-0.0575904585,
0.241706118,
-0.0624236651,
-0.2417849153,
0.8184213638,
-0.1427467465,
-0.5470381379,
0.523352623,
0.1696373671,
-0.2081656456,
-0.0470732935,
-0.0593213066,
-0.3773046434,
0.2082547396,
0.5781184435,
-0.028503783,
-0.7720936537,
0.0359997414,
-0.164901495,
-0.0932964832,
0.1176495478,
0.7826672792,
-0.6641449332,
0.2637874782,
0.2834004462,
0.5722544193,
0.4598953426,
0.1699895561,
0.364097178,
-0.2398126423,
-0.0927113742,
-0.0639661923,
0.3506142497,
0.245330289,
-0.4390502274,
0.5645016432,
0.1570352912,
-0.5125679374,
-0.7146270871,
0.4515657723,
-0.7512390018,
-0.4330851436,
1.4786144495,
0.0458550788,
-0.0851687491,
0.0569505841,
-0.4811379313,
0.1896630973,
-0.5130004883,
0.5656383038,
0.0559123382,
-0.1352215707,
-0.2521879375,
-0.4057081938,
0.3310760856,
0.4585517049,
-0.6545476913,
0.3529879451,
0.6130233407,
0.6625581384,
-0.5740152597,
0.4870812893,
-0.3486341238,
0.0821914151,
0.0473799184,
-0.1787450016,
-0.1423692852,
-0.0009959169,
-0.0854119435,
0.3901284635,
0.1098695025,
0.1165467352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12866v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12866v1
|
How Does the Textual Information Affect the Retrieval of Multimodal In-Context Learning?
| 2024-04-19T13:05:37 | 2024-04-19T13:05:37 |
Yang Luo, Zangwei Zheng, Zirui Zhu, Yang You
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
The increase in parameter size of multimodal large language models (MLLMs)
introduces significant capabilities, particularly in-context learning, where
MLLMs enhance task performance without updating pre-trained parameters. This
effectiveness, however, hinges on the appropriate selection of in-context
examples, a process that is currently biased towards visual data, overlooking
textual information. Furthermore, the area of supervised retrievers for MLLMs,
crucial for optimal in-context example selection, continues to be
uninvestigated. Our study offers an in-depth evaluation of the impact of
textual information on the unsupervised selection of in-context examples in
multimodal contexts, uncovering a notable sensitivity of retriever performance
to the employed modalities. Responding to this, we introduce a novel supervised
MLLM-retriever MSIER that employs a neural network to select examples that
enhance multimodal in-context learning efficiency. This approach is validated
through extensive testing across three distinct tasks, demonstrating the
method's effectiveness. Additionally, we investigate the influence of
modalities on our supervised retrieval method's training and pinpoint factors
contributing to our model's success. This exploration paves the way for future
advancements, highlighting the potential for refined in-context learning in
MLLMs through the strategic use of multimodal data.
|
[
-0.1468491405,
-0.7174392939,
0.6104140282,
0.0764938444,
-0.3593167365,
-0.3807505667,
-0.4410078824,
-0.2965391576,
-0.1301493645,
0.3138251007,
-0.267049253,
-0.223088637,
-0.7094089985,
0.1687654406,
-0.3704989851,
0.9926088452,
0.2510541677,
0.1620145291,
-0.5401513577,
-0.1901474148,
-0.3533784151,
-0.8440241218,
-0.4225285053,
-0.2693605721,
0.8071779013,
0.2270730138,
0.3832437694,
0.438782841,
0.4543858171,
0.3617502451,
-0.1720279455,
0.3239559233,
-0.455000937,
0.4665967822,
0.044973325,
-0.3543250561,
0.1221210212,
-0.0195241477,
0.8881313801,
0.5601320863,
0.1314179748,
0.076344274,
0.2483065128,
0.4694142044,
-1.0323507786,
0.2345835865,
-0.7301164865,
0.0287651829,
-0.1988109201,
-0.5326449275,
-0.9370358586,
0.106609866,
0.4003454745,
-0.6145553589,
0.1090328321,
-0.004830162,
0.5381925106,
0.0956378654,
-1.0440987349,
-0.4470827878,
-0.3981376588,
1.0203611851,
-0.4697677195,
0.5117407441,
0.7158127427,
0.1581901014,
-0.0725515932,
-0.804394424,
-0.2411213219,
-0.3737787902,
-0.4960765541,
0.1495609581,
0.1699181795,
-0.095005177,
0.3998206556,
-0.0635388717,
-0.4890569746,
-0.1614914685,
-0.2538680434,
-0.1788036227,
0.2985151112,
0.0000883597,
0.1509527713,
-0.4656180143,
-0.4789265096,
-0.2623743415,
-0.4085505605,
0.1142645776,
0.1056978405,
0.3812860548,
0.1851802468,
0.6782505512,
-0.076276131,
0.6951048374,
-0.2841431499,
-0.2396823615,
0.5072963834,
-0.6269173026,
-0.1874453127,
-0.1536278725,
0.6205332875,
0.3307839632,
-0.0791816488,
-0.2051866204,
-0.3609555066,
-0.2977949083,
0.2710814476,
-1.0010861158,
-0.0928294286,
-0.2575087845,
-0.7719537616,
-0.0584532171,
0.2317695767,
-0.7867732644,
-0.2688119411,
-0.4203449786,
0.5055909753,
-0.6284464002,
-0.1664619148,
-0.2017901242,
-0.5403283238,
0.0071102506,
0.3797756732,
-0.7444853783,
-0.1268263906,
0.3892192841,
0.5699310303,
-0.0887651369,
-0.2759515047,
-0.8394132853,
0.242056936,
-0.1099890992,
0.3602076471,
-0.9356915951,
-0.2577605844,
0.0111014824,
0.0838491693,
-0.4427801669,
-0.4692754149,
0.5398434997,
-0.6228590608,
0.3609566092,
-0.3633654416,
-0.4252489507,
-0.3392761946,
0.1067796573,
-0.7966833711,
0.9582142234,
-0.2454665899,
-0.8370079994,
0.6535801291,
-0.557608664,
-0.449041456,
-0.1430171579,
-0.2450842857,
-0.3453790247,
0.2344830632,
0.221462816,
0.7221133709,
0.0704023093,
0.192232579,
-0.2193062603,
-0.5615113378,
0.5745469928,
-0.9238134623,
0.7240678072,
0.202947557,
-0.1909422427,
0.0999509022,
-0.6193552613,
0.0339246877,
-0.0409158655,
-0.6679965854,
-0.838273406,
-0.0301649608,
0.5560566187,
0.5008068681,
0.0892079696,
-0.5504425168,
-0.1403626055,
-0.1031568348,
0.2708210349,
0.6510868669,
-0.0600516871,
0.6084569097,
-0.0135525363,
0.1454928368,
0.0636783987,
0.0962271467,
-0.6186516285,
-0.2237844616,
-0.428060025,
-0.5940418243,
0.3294571936,
0.1441577226,
-1.1880407333,
-0.001229269,
-0.0626120046,
-0.1692535877,
-0.3227854371,
0.3712180555,
0.7056205869,
0.450884521,
0.4034990072,
0.0111190351,
-0.4513908327,
-1.0287293196,
-0.2737397254,
0.2665232718,
-0.083460398,
0.4484700859,
0.5504008532,
-0.2448134869,
0.8919776082,
-0.1301899254,
-0.2319350839,
-0.2186369747,
0.1632297933,
-0.0640304312,
0.392531693,
0.6349083781,
-1.3302589655,
-0.3385619223,
0.0116546322,
-1.0306960344,
0.2585526407,
-0.0624217652,
-0.1457160413,
0.1771431118,
0.5765240192,
-0.6340606809,
0.4855382442,
0.332195282,
-0.3994163275,
0.1687730104,
-0.5458802581,
0.1318846047,
-1.0361264944,
0.1273009777,
0.1894606948,
-0.1748432219,
-0.4731121361,
0.1080918908,
0.7478992939,
0.1830240339,
-0.4890319705,
0.5257108212,
-0.6481199861,
0.0790171176,
-0.0879509822,
0.1587435752,
0.1447822005,
0.5828208923,
-0.1391727626,
0.7617470622,
0.2321463972,
-0.6316124797,
0.0470808558,
0.1179752573,
-0.3136367798,
0.5998132229,
-0.2775566876,
0.0163743496,
-0.6291471124,
0.341014117,
-0.9237794876,
-0.236982286,
-0.1399682015,
-0.2126093358,
0.6181740165,
-0.024720192,
-0.7624272704,
0.0088235,
-0.3516710699,
0.5528858304,
-0.0466607623,
-0.7215579152,
0.7722053528,
0.2046600729,
0.0332592912,
-0.8272852898,
-0.5738517046,
0.0730781034,
-0.2673532665,
-0.145864442,
0.0909916088,
-0.2289375961,
-0.1710434556,
-0.2452664673,
-0.0558026619,
0.0232871566,
0.2017140687,
0.2029015571,
0.1965995878,
0.017640736,
0.6123170853,
0.0669372901,
0.0343954936,
0.0171303041,
-0.0472798347,
0.305090636,
-0.1263641119,
-0.3692510128,
-0.3382635415,
0.3858471215,
0.3927163482,
-0.5230569243,
0.8836128712,
0.7096687555,
-0.178671971,
-0.1001081914,
-0.4628249705,
-0.3343553245,
-0.4327892959,
0.6650221348,
-0.4273586869,
-0.7790944576,
0.0227904897,
0.0956278294,
-0.18299523,
0.2207192034,
0.3589669764,
-0.1918055713,
1.0624734163,
0.462567091,
0.096901834,
0.8554354906,
-0.2472988814,
-0.2007374913,
-0.9742189646,
-0.5372164249,
-0.4116828144,
-0.3063476086,
-0.3692650497,
-0.3096979856,
0.3959774077,
-0.0469489992,
-0.0771667361,
0.1794253141,
-0.1766884625,
0.462592572,
0.6047052741,
0.5205967426,
0.4400910437,
0.0081083737,
-0.3605592549,
-0.2150158882,
-0.6918412447,
-0.4017695189,
1.1615283489,
0.104186736,
0.5385149717,
0.3458494246,
0.128972128,
0.1184179559,
0.403424859,
-0.5318182707,
0.3719413877,
-0.1577907205,
-0.708781004,
-0.2074556053,
-0.5232759714,
-1.0792928934,
0.8699679375,
-0.3923622072,
-0.5950168967,
0.1350358278,
-0.149145022,
0.0384396426,
0.0228201505,
-0.83784163,
0.8363294005,
-0.2576772571,
-0.4466623068,
-0.1579397917,
-0.885623455,
0.0572049245,
-0.232632488,
0.1525015384,
0.2209274173,
-0.2065901011,
0.4264001846,
0.137145713,
0.8123468757,
-0.219901979,
-0.0111083016,
-0.1451097429,
-0.006096981,
0.3069282472,
0.0556568019,
-0.3727486134,
-0.0898845941,
-0.1974595785,
-0.3059158325,
-0.7610641122,
0.7020147443,
-0.456548959,
-0.1792844236,
-0.1473679245,
-0.7958552241,
-0.1262655109,
0.0965489298,
0.3012069762,
0.9851948023,
-0.0365470611,
0.9642565846,
0.6878291965,
-0.2189054489,
0.9381389618,
0.3484252691,
-0.1596284062,
-0.2278462052,
0.8466809392,
0.1264594048,
0.27855739,
0.7637146711,
0.0208392199,
-0.5416846871,
-0.2528012991,
-0.5021826625,
0.1010586098,
-1.0238463879,
-0.2230095416,
-0.817338109,
0.0291175768,
0.0422616266,
0.2139308155,
0.0070225461,
-0.1779320836,
-0.5421429873,
-0.108603172,
0.1023755819,
0.5599526167,
0.4892967343,
0.2321533561,
-0.565423131,
-0.0101613477,
0.1633707881,
0.2142623216,
0.0967390314,
-0.5183644295,
-0.3549685776,
0.1115374118,
-0.1734587997,
-0.6585537195,
0.3089097738,
0.3923936486,
0.8843044043,
0.3731637895,
-0.0678521022,
0.4701161087,
-0.3724006116,
0.4990788996,
0.0599700548,
-0.6356356144,
0.4274824858,
-0.2642096579,
0.3692660034,
0.5088776946,
0.4515776336,
-0.1644148976,
-0.2161878496,
-0.2618902624,
-0.7279336452,
0.5884703398,
0.2748854458,
0.4010517597,
-0.1767170578,
0.1487666517,
0.109026581,
0.4270381033,
-0.8058397174,
-0.0907325298,
-0.105708532,
-0.2259539366,
-0.3706264496,
-0.3586662114,
0.0481223762,
-0.2072830498,
0.3589070439,
-0.337146312,
-0.0025334563,
0.1672802418,
-0.658881247,
0.2620392442,
0.3693715632,
0.7055282593,
0.7493491769,
-0.220532611,
0.2951660454,
0.1336200237,
-0.3605323136,
-0.1809108704,
0.0804878995,
-0.1078459248,
0.2440180779,
0.4431767464,
0.8302483559,
0.6360079646,
-0.8410056233,
0.8749397397,
-0.1866459697,
-0.0233269259,
-0.2380587161,
-0.282569319,
-0.2018454969,
0.485198617,
0.7186791897,
0.2384886295,
0.345369637,
-0.5571442246,
0.3270275593,
0.7851217985,
-0.4891490638,
-0.0531549975,
0.6121299267,
-0.1020320654,
-0.1203236505,
0.6316906214,
0.0747179389,
-0.2338016629,
0.4130685925,
0.7482520342,
0.4169288874,
-0.0406658761,
0.0190344192,
0.1030493677,
0.2009172142,
-0.0269030742,
-0.0694568157,
-0.3106815517,
-0.5218889117,
-0.4532371461,
-0.4881474376,
0.1265362054,
-0.1861976832,
-0.730437398,
0.0555625334,
-0.070520401,
-0.4046030343,
-0.2249867618,
-0.2878882289,
-0.6498012543,
0.2296304852,
0.1411004066,
0.7297904491,
-0.4188700914,
0.9001190066,
0.6410053968,
-0.4721295834,
-0.4678995013,
0.017965883,
-0.0407916903,
-0.3471807241,
0.9862901568,
0.4216196835,
-0.2348370403,
-0.1949776411,
-0.3347480893,
-0.8237358332,
1.2415087223,
0.438716799,
-0.1306042075,
-0.006436978,
-0.2700629532,
0.5843313932,
-0.4104242325,
0.7559553981,
0.1024214104,
0.3177735507,
0.0421040542,
-0.8950493336,
-0.0477200784,
-0.4933295548,
0.3467401862,
0.1865080595,
-0.4609476626,
0.8846127391,
-0.1508917361,
-0.0520926677,
0.0277121365,
0.4275444746,
0.1632371396,
0.4226261675,
0.4021931291,
0.1995746642,
0.6328408122,
0.0970585346,
1.4262906313,
0.1314370632,
0.2685857713,
1.0284631252,
-0.0865160897,
1.1209123135,
0.7610734701,
0.4269567728,
0.4703294039,
0.3217303157,
0.2343768924,
0.6674826741,
-0.0829990134,
-0.2189702541,
-0.1835174263,
-0.2801592946,
-0.2395882159,
0.6902123094,
0.300678581,
-0.8311466575,
-0.1770181954,
0.547509253,
-0.0553939156,
0.1817507148,
-0.2191171497,
0.8052176237,
-0.0631706268,
-0.410210371,
0.4002240598,
-0.1298437417,
0.8876276612,
-0.6107197404,
-0.1709520072,
0.0010944429,
0.2411057502,
-0.1156968027,
-0.4733367562,
-0.0933583975,
-0.3891763389,
-0.3192738593,
-0.4378351569,
0.6555582881,
-0.6160053611,
-0.4229437411,
0.6259168983,
0.5738604665,
-0.1251676083,
-0.3941664696,
-0.3523127139,
0.0458944812,
-0.140006423,
-0.4194938838,
0.5873731971,
0.6299497485,
-0.0603509098,
0.6923831105,
0.6864125133,
-0.4285309911,
0.0536784865,
0.1509381533,
0.9358530045,
-0.494735986,
-0.1589447558,
-1.0300234556,
0.6297083497,
-0.2914362252,
-0.2539813519,
1.1026406288,
0.8147810698,
1.0341359377,
-0.1614978909,
0.5166913271,
0.2305452526,
0.3237346113,
-0.6489782929,
0.812492013,
-0.887473166,
0.2280461639,
-0.51230371,
-0.7096212506,
-0.231209144,
0.5748355985,
-0.2819539309,
0.2459918708,
0.8079227805,
0.7628719211,
-0.1405898482,
0.1045681983,
0.547873199,
-0.0359777138,
0.105552882,
0.2522496879,
0.9854193926,
-0.4096408486,
0.658929646,
-0.2174147964,
-0.1288413256,
-0.2498233169,
-0.8172802329,
-1.0350441933,
-0.9080410004,
0.2743963897,
-0.122100018,
-0.0540675968,
1.0466197729,
0.7263734341,
-0.365450561,
-0.1366824955,
0.6103157997,
-0.1123917177,
-0.0724219084,
-0.2135765404,
0.2231126577,
-0.4410852492,
-0.6929644942,
0.5780201554,
0.2635551095,
-0.1957633793,
0.1825668514,
-0.010862682,
-0.5881514549,
-0.3492188454,
1.1807786226,
-0.3238619268,
-0.7494821548,
-0.0985401049,
0.1404049993,
-0.4066097736,
-0.0835370198,
0.9369564652,
-0.8134387136,
0.6111153364,
0.2348830551,
0.8862455487,
0.6749424934,
-0.0317911059,
0.397148639,
-0.9925532937,
0.3754397333,
0.0702708364,
0.5751577616,
0.3157895505,
-0.3975814879,
0.3162415624,
0.1497466564,
-0.4045484364,
-0.6129270196,
-0.0108851921,
-0.7352701426,
-0.6029165983,
1.2047024965,
0.1016822383,
-0.000679402,
-0.1929409057,
-0.4744371772,
0.103575632,
-0.5237511992,
0.4857364297,
0.5986132026,
0.1689368486,
-0.4446290433,
-0.8891615272,
0.3545686901,
0.5444639325,
-0.4486605823,
-0.0545251146,
0.6388329864,
0.1226435527,
0.0404730737,
0.3595286906,
0.020440748,
0.0136207193,
-0.2759863436,
-0.2354788184,
-0.1331434995,
-0.4604838192,
-0.3688173592,
0.3378359079,
-0.2633974254,
0.0402812548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13104v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13104v1
|
Multi Class Depression Detection Through Tweets using Artificial Intelligence
| 2024-04-19T12:47:56 | 2024-04-19T12:47:56 |
Muhammad Osama Nusrat, Waseem Shahzad, Saad Ahmed Jamal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Depression is a significant issue nowadays. As per the World Health
Organization (WHO), in 2023, over 280 million individuals are grappling with
depression. This is a huge number; if not taken seriously, these numbers will
increase rapidly. About 4.89 billion individuals are social media users. People
express their feelings and emotions on platforms like Twitter, Facebook,
Reddit, Instagram, etc. These platforms contain valuable information which can
be used for research purposes. Considerable research has been conducted across
various social media platforms. However, certain limitations persist in these
endeavors. Particularly, previous studies were only focused on detecting
depression and the intensity of depression in tweets. Also, there existed
inaccuracies in dataset labeling. In this research work, five types of
depression (Bipolar, major, psychotic, atypical, and postpartum) were predicted
using tweets from the Twitter database based on lexicon labeling. Explainable
AI was used to provide reasoning by highlighting the parts of tweets that
represent type of depression. Bidirectional Encoder Representations from
Transformers (BERT) was used for feature extraction and training. Machine
learning and deep learning methodologies were used to train the model. The BERT
model presented the most promising results, achieving an overall accuracy of
0.96.
|
[
-0.3681458831,
-0.7949494123,
0.6996669173,
0.7791875601,
-0.1753813028,
0.4769955873,
-0.2822921276,
-0.4378328919,
0.4035014808,
-0.1289320588,
-0.6236606836,
-0.710767746,
-0.9067219496,
0.2829354107,
-0.5575778484,
0.6371436119,
-0.1136801019,
0.1086813807,
0.2322030813,
-0.0454197265,
-0.3673176169,
-0.3973380625,
-0.8553158045,
-0.0846390277,
0.5082658529,
0.4687993526,
0.4943595231,
-0.3070462644,
0.6853455901,
0.4378300309,
-0.0110795638,
0.0874976963,
-0.1523588002,
0.0064048395,
0.0364239328,
-0.0539970174,
-0.3187197447,
-0.3217927814,
0.2738714516,
0.1214525104,
0.081470795,
0.1428956985,
0.1512596309,
0.5374283195,
-0.4766395688,
0.1515433192,
-0.443990618,
0.3132704198,
0.0341039784,
0.0537052006,
-0.0942651182,
-0.6622830033,
-0.0049246871,
-0.1274505854,
0.3866313696,
-0.4869056344,
0.7922858596,
0.4102227986,
-0.4791050851,
-0.342854023,
-0.5959042907,
0.7753110528,
-0.667357862,
0.1590289772,
0.3262712359,
0.4396582246,
0.0697737336,
-0.3672636449,
-0.4726985097,
0.2651199102,
-0.0776102617,
0.1260811538,
0.0858985111,
-0.0131297847,
0.0384920686,
0.3210642636,
-0.5488492846,
0.0904150307,
-0.0680879056,
-0.038976375,
0.5999737978,
0.0188764855,
0.5337933898,
-0.3964741826,
-0.1919164956,
0.1782275885,
0.4864369631,
0.0111841401,
0.0699841157,
0.2286484689,
-0.3661755621,
0.5539735556,
0.0863863677,
0.4210937321,
-0.0126517713,
-0.1953947544,
0.4105048478,
-0.0116224941,
-0.2901203632,
0.1392859668,
0.8806141615,
0.4856193364,
0.5334740877,
0.0666168109,
-0.1329383403,
0.4104366601,
0.3048137128,
-0.6073336005,
-0.180745706,
0.4270159602,
-0.7636730075,
-0.3650020361,
-0.2718770802,
-1.0550639629,
-0.8529773355,
-0.1569185108,
0.3394362032,
-0.8440756798,
-0.4618862569,
0.0633911416,
-0.3286947608,
-0.1224330962,
0.4050638974,
-0.7337025404,
-0.2005223334,
0.4606267214,
1.2111349106,
0.103668645,
0.1333001256,
0.2188012898,
0.0710263997,
-0.0739356056,
1.0341430902,
-0.3982252181,
-0.0485102385,
0.266744256,
-0.0567286052,
-0.3138343394,
-0.0890070498,
0.8879514337,
-0.1766655892,
-0.0018895008,
-0.0044222376,
-0.6252850294,
-0.1895035803,
0.354885906,
-0.7302915454,
0.5693755746,
0.345468998,
-0.9955559969,
0.3028693497,
-0.85457021,
-0.5831753016,
0.1564435512,
0.0417398885,
-0.8033533096,
0.119383581,
0.5645388961,
0.8587537408,
-0.0706013218,
0.4537911117,
-0.7203551531,
-0.298712343,
0.1499309391,
-0.1693025678,
0.646455884,
0.1084803864,
-0.4187698662,
0.2274185866,
-0.581384182,
-0.0909852162,
0.0374569893,
-0.2071321905,
-0.2780700326,
0.0454077125,
0.1974762976,
0.2977105379,
-0.0387587771,
-0.7663830519,
-0.017592527,
0.0549123101,
0.7111330628,
0.6823071837,
0.2462262064,
-0.0578188002,
-0.1706151366,
0.3696033955,
0.2109625936,
0.5635082126,
0.2445398271,
-0.6168499589,
-0.4000789523,
-0.6607983112,
0.2213190049,
0.5361922383,
-0.5685871243,
0.681753695,
-0.0152566135,
-0.4629970491,
-0.8791253567,
-0.3459938765,
-0.1182967648,
0.4118120968,
0.6826176047,
0.233192414,
-0.6784017086,
-0.8798655868,
-0.3380775452,
0.0641790479,
-0.0318927355,
-0.0477927513,
0.2322253883,
-0.6339113712,
0.6941972375,
-0.495230943,
-0.4607836306,
-0.4796596467,
0.372397691,
0.1013927236,
0.3386306763,
0.5155242682,
-0.909717083,
-0.7515468001,
-0.2329381704,
-0.9250733852,
0.1616909206,
-0.3429737985,
-0.0403407663,
0.3336874545,
0.0490956418,
-0.535042882,
0.6786683202,
0.3929087222,
-0.1843343526,
0.1150440425,
0.23154293,
0.2086913586,
-1.1518689394,
-0.2099176645,
0.5917085409,
-0.1196130142,
-0.5221962333,
-0.7821480036,
0.2790038586,
-0.1177730635,
-0.0571358204,
0.1422978491,
-0.1413128227,
0.1611579359,
-0.11749053,
-0.1303257197,
-0.1610155255,
0.1947397739,
-0.2352708131,
0.250624299,
0.8485711217,
-0.2895475924,
0.3148488104,
0.3007970452,
-0.2343697995,
0.3546334803,
-0.2837040722,
-0.2883343399,
-0.3410046995,
0.347517997,
-1.1208268404,
-0.2863072753,
0.3953719735,
-0.7181286216,
0.1191441491,
0.273444593,
-0.7078949213,
-0.8113248944,
-0.5231442451,
0.2199549079,
0.1624275297,
-0.4073399603,
0.6477660537,
0.2889994681,
0.0554115511,
-0.36529845,
-0.6591131091,
0.2262613177,
-0.4349249005,
-0.6473549008,
0.3885083199,
0.0073755649,
-0.0404087715,
0.1233793721,
0.0443298481,
-0.2188889682,
0.1352728158,
0.2022239119,
0.0498354882,
0.1482121944,
0.5732377768,
0.0131813455,
0.1049047559,
-0.0026330294,
0.3524652719,
0.8080480695,
-0.2077476084,
-0.0151830288,
-1.037274003,
0.5411121249,
0.5984297395,
0.0556522086,
1.0054285526,
1.0808809996,
-0.7060792446,
-0.074677147,
-0.5557726622,
-0.1331149787,
-0.4696546197,
0.1079633757,
-0.1343065053,
-0.4998984337,
0.5137478113,
-0.1690011024,
-0.203845486,
0.3903369606,
0.4554730654,
-0.1404052973,
1.377690196,
0.7124782801,
-0.2535890043,
0.5503754616,
-0.327483505,
0.7537730336,
-0.3467059135,
-0.1816579103,
-0.33172068,
-0.5519183278,
-0.7900344133,
0.1569007039,
0.2799068391,
-0.0173749849,
-0.3363735378,
0.2826434672,
-0.8615711927,
0.1194091439,
0.5145859718,
0.6019608974,
0.0092741847,
-0.0902677923,
0.3140812814,
0.008146178,
-0.1975158453,
-0.4986319542,
0.8165413141,
0.4087287486,
0.5537099838,
0.082888186,
0.7810463905,
0.7305624485,
0.5720226169,
-0.838019073,
0.3903878629,
-0.366571188,
-0.5092567205,
-0.3611643314,
-0.3983270526,
-0.6981247663,
-0.1412733048,
-0.2130064368,
-0.5378978848,
0.1881907284,
-0.2146484703,
-0.4424123168,
0.4561855793,
-1.0164244175,
0.7848258018,
-0.33703807,
0.2124824971,
-0.2993841767,
-0.8526514769,
0.423135519,
-0.3648344576,
0.2891477644,
-0.4626136422,
0.2422244698,
0.6517374516,
-0.0534725748,
0.9384942055,
-0.1819125563,
0.0251293052,
0.121849075,
-0.3956947625,
-0.0693289936,
0.1353099048,
-0.2138183564,
0.1040785313,
-0.1331432611,
-0.5978046656,
-0.1750556529,
0.4932428896,
-1.0393989086,
-0.1459308565,
-0.261839658,
-0.4011192024,
-0.3643586636,
0.1058509201,
0.2383696586,
0.303571105,
0.0922705606,
-0.1025265008,
0.1887289733,
-0.4764809608,
0.8869484663,
-0.0317376293,
0.1364628226,
-0.4980894029,
0.8666661382,
0.0287195742,
-0.2283937186,
0.3605723381,
0.3797437847,
-0.2720263004,
-0.1430349499,
-0.1289773732,
0.3709770441,
-0.5306910872,
-0.6060963869,
-0.8879888654,
-0.1757122725,
-0.9084258676,
-0.2770728469,
-0.2246539146,
-0.3293789625,
-0.7151549459,
-0.2203009576,
0.5299993753,
0.649512291,
-0.2907058299,
0.3603681326,
-1.0037509203,
0.8174871802,
0.2411372066,
0.4692788124,
0.2384159416,
0.102120854,
-0.087007232,
0.0129877701,
-0.5875934958,
-1.0092053413,
0.6420069933,
0.2450108677,
0.2355189174,
0.9242275953,
0.350102663,
0.7172138691,
-0.0027450526,
0.458143115,
0.4828914702,
-0.9640678167,
0.7829560041,
-0.1665991247,
-0.0401688479,
0.4679756463,
0.8707075715,
-0.7442128062,
-0.4969545305,
-0.6247220039,
-0.7439549565,
0.7158255577,
0.1281825304,
-0.0151122259,
-0.136301592,
0.2066277266,
0.2134340852,
0.1871513873,
-0.6337681413,
-0.167945236,
-0.4549129009,
-0.6871931553,
-0.0093016,
-0.2924166322,
0.1630385965,
-0.3340201676,
0.4004829526,
0.2147988528,
0.5901276469,
0.1435217261,
0.1490393132,
-0.2926721573,
0.1270029992,
0.3744089603,
0.5073232055,
-0.5928010941,
0.1999095082,
-0.352225244,
-0.1689916104,
-0.0334849432,
0.337344408,
0.0741771162,
0.3202824891,
0.5150449872,
0.5629247427,
-0.2617247105,
-0.5342350602,
0.4377448261,
-0.3897915483,
-0.199816823,
-0.7938681841,
-0.2255170047,
0.2922792137,
0.5011008382,
0.3338832855,
0.2169326842,
0.2618802488,
-0.6342489719,
0.0887498856,
0.1901788861,
-0.3264743984,
-0.4017867148,
0.31191504,
0.188001141,
-0.6375868917,
0.6181650162,
-0.1295893192,
-0.8240082264,
0.6956182718,
0.2624440789,
1.0475373268,
-0.5221111178,
0.7016622424,
0.3484495282,
0.121865198,
-0.2153012305,
0.5594560504,
0.1943245083,
-0.8311662674,
-0.1478268802,
-0.5825778246,
-0.2696176171,
0.2862049341,
-0.4542273283,
0.4733471274,
-0.4326006472,
-0.5566686392,
0.2080896497,
-0.228337571,
-0.5196439624,
0.2924201488,
0.4563281238,
0.5911186337,
-1.1292194128,
0.48960343,
0.7067830563,
-0.374930501,
-0.5721980929,
0.5150523782,
-0.0877111852,
-0.7073222399,
0.3357255757,
0.8003285527,
0.1427749693,
0.0485585891,
-0.5787466764,
-0.547835052,
0.6773215532,
0.0006248374,
-0.2295913398,
0.1517249942,
0.2501152456,
0.7357233167,
-0.2389758825,
0.3003186285,
0.4042859674,
0.7300271392,
-0.0510034375,
-0.7558178306,
-0.1776020974,
-0.1016501561,
-0.076172635,
0.2578920126,
-0.6623017788,
0.836019218,
-0.0980330408,
-0.4142444432,
-0.419459641,
0.2108220905,
0.1322345138,
0.4781768322,
0.633646667,
0.7438868284,
0.5822982192,
0.152299732,
0.7657945752,
-0.1423345655,
0.6437868476,
0.4476224482,
-0.1063978449,
0.5437199473,
0.1195894927,
-0.0104247285,
0.3990633786,
0.9773963094,
-0.0903459266,
0.6952313185,
0.0676637366,
-0.5217587948,
-0.4216236174,
-0.2119666338,
-0.3417094648,
0.0690983236,
0.6697561741,
-0.4679891467,
-0.4290350676,
0.4092770815,
-0.0571362376,
-0.1167155951,
-0.3187129498,
0.712636888,
0.0277555864,
-0.3677436709,
0.6846513152,
0.0767832696,
0.7739449739,
-0.0218888279,
0.0482903197,
-0.095369786,
0.5822923779,
-0.2843405902,
-0.8390467167,
0.4260263145,
-0.005857205,
0.0041295993,
-0.4085535705,
1.0173774958,
-0.1977748424,
-0.9177002907,
0.7980771065,
0.5377963781,
0.0184471104,
-0.4509427845,
-0.9327287674,
-0.0744620711,
0.0106018856,
-0.0941320062,
-0.0440603904,
0.8407461643,
0.1137200519,
0.7784726024,
0.0806622654,
-0.136525318,
0.070523724,
0.477596581,
0.9109791517,
-0.7692192197,
-0.3624925911,
-0.9944929481,
0.3111145496,
-0.3118658662,
-0.1114425138,
0.4953472316,
0.283788383,
0.4081608057,
-0.1499335468,
0.9305262566,
-0.2992767394,
1.0884662867,
0.1614854932,
0.4722686708,
-0.6267059445,
-0.1535931975,
-0.4595270753,
-0.3859052956,
-0.6509984732,
0.5978751779,
-0.3041249216,
-0.020354826,
0.732876122,
0.3160227835,
-0.0016848955,
0.3499228656,
-0.0190717913,
0.2290752679,
0.500788033,
0.4125573337,
0.8770433664,
-0.1633511633,
0.4538157284,
-0.5524073839,
-0.3146783113,
-0.5353441834,
-0.3999015093,
-1.170971036,
-0.41468817,
-0.4163558781,
-0.1636597216,
-0.0882475972,
0.6874569058,
0.3465815783,
-0.8569393158,
0.1572431326,
-0.2387027144,
0.3843470812,
-0.1895698309,
-0.3023831546,
0.7405415177,
-0.476226151,
-0.3771491647,
-0.2088135332,
0.078195259,
-0.0078830468,
0.0421733446,
0.4852129519,
-0.6301356554,
-0.2506993115,
0.7260086536,
-0.2879063487,
-0.4158060253,
-0.2893725932,
-0.2877269685,
-0.1647336185,
0.266159445,
0.5985336304,
-0.5301324725,
-0.0584589057,
0.5190258622,
0.4418615997,
0.1854838878,
0.3527211845,
0.0240176059,
-0.4398926497,
-0.283773005,
0.5552474856,
0.2811391056,
0.5771306753,
-0.5791919231,
0.4658724368,
0.3458695412,
-0.6769385338,
-0.556877315,
-0.0547752827,
-1.0072042942,
-0.7190073729,
0.8119345903,
0.1245241836,
-0.0493726917,
-0.4686285853,
-0.1372471452,
0.7551367879,
-0.8827431202,
1.5738140345,
0.4764227569,
-0.5743291378,
-0.2580542266,
-0.5513456464,
0.2877457738,
0.1288294345,
-0.8354706764,
-0.2919724584,
0.1806485504,
-0.0583701618,
0.0909479707,
0.5910025239,
0.1974274069,
-0.2310809493,
-0.5459496379,
0.3551145494,
0.4750317633,
-0.0328907669,
-0.0685848966,
0.3435032368,
-0.6316943765,
-0.6220257282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12845v1
|
TartuNLP @ SIGTYP 2024 Shared Task: Adapting XLM-RoBERTa for Ancient and Historical Languages
| 2024-04-19T12:26:28 | 2024-04-19T12:26:28 |
Aleksei Dorkin, Kairit Sirts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present our submission to the unconstrained subtask of the SIGTYP 2024
Shared Task on Word Embedding Evaluation for Ancient and Historical Languages
for morphological annotation, POS-tagging, lemmatization, character- and
word-level gap-filling. We developed a simple, uniform, and computationally
lightweight approach based on the adapters framework using parameter-efficient
fine-tuning. We applied the same adapter-based approach uniformly to all tasks
and 16 languages by fine-tuning stacked language- and task-specific adapters.
Our submission obtained an overall second place out of three submissions, with
the first place in word-level gap-filling. Our results show the feasibility of
adapting language models pre-trained on modern languages to historical and
ancient languages via adapter training.
|
[
-0.3964652717,
-0.4211379588,
0.6639861465,
0.0815077052,
-0.4637604654,
-0.2963506281,
-0.5071556568,
-0.5323342681,
0.1622147858,
0.4091236889,
-0.1999108344,
-0.4764201045,
-0.691476047,
0.1466125697,
0.2233389467,
0.8025134206,
-0.6013216972,
0.16890876,
-0.178323552,
-0.5064706206,
-0.5871042013,
-0.496242553,
-0.4536480308,
-0.1345799267,
0.1731548607,
0.1764555573,
0.4119417965,
0.6812007427,
0.2912232578,
0.3049661815,
-0.0595576316,
0.25125736,
-0.1871702522,
0.1028243676,
-0.4287550449,
-0.318015039,
-0.810303688,
-0.1594381928,
0.7150800824,
0.5828970075,
-0.0229688268,
0.2006741017,
0.2021390498,
0.367756784,
-0.6939919591,
0.2922887206,
-0.8449825048,
0.1091356352,
-0.398142457,
-0.6688951254,
-0.3457909226,
-0.2608086467,
0.0888919309,
-0.7753209472,
-0.0943800732,
-0.0089295432,
0.3811348975,
0.4562698007,
0.1091365516,
-0.4759896994,
-0.5081982613,
0.7431345582,
-0.8068192601,
0.2617880404,
0.2515209615,
-0.0938664377,
-0.1027743444,
-0.6284680367,
-0.2689648271,
-0.1555401832,
0.1550845951,
0.1333204806,
-0.3639635742,
0.0816130787,
0.0607814901,
0.3264681101,
-0.549213171,
0.2249679565,
-0.2968171537,
-0.2014602274,
0.2927772105,
0.1307254434,
0.5004661083,
0.3544702232,
-0.1713805646,
0.1730979979,
-0.6005117893,
-0.3981787264,
0.3143767416,
0.39363572,
-0.202022329,
0.4985759854,
0.0907336697,
0.8378043175,
0.0704133064,
0.1951726079,
0.172960192,
-0.3924758732,
-0.008451649,
-0.0148808816,
0.4052375555,
0.1505903155,
0.2854834795,
-0.1014281288,
-0.0282380078,
-0.0114066424,
0.0720891207,
-0.6344076991,
-0.2825339437,
-0.3086691797,
-0.1620104462,
0.0993909016,
-0.0039472436,
-0.6999275088,
-0.3598812521,
0.0241187587,
0.6265454888,
-0.5050542355,
0.0144372685,
0.252366364,
-0.0866182074,
-0.0729917213,
0.7465724349,
-1.006526947,
0.4304360449,
0.6665905118,
0.8440564275,
0.0838520303,
-0.4224101007,
-0.5834771395,
0.3184637427,
-0.1527554542,
0.8400901556,
-0.7299215794,
-0.2758052051,
-0.0612606518,
0.2623889744,
-0.3214176595,
-0.4376213849,
0.9442101717,
-0.2159749717,
0.2464014441,
0.1056615412,
-0.6717630625,
-0.1294009984,
0.1689580977,
-0.4979255199,
1.0054565668,
0.3670378327,
-0.6718035936,
0.2299837023,
-0.7514070272,
-0.0663124174,
0.5663204789,
-0.1799290627,
-0.3429085612,
0.202069506,
0.318544358,
0.199544251,
-0.0205824543,
-0.0095526474,
-0.2298693806,
-0.3926559687,
-0.1478484124,
-0.2108696401,
0.4013252556,
0.0017583907,
-0.5188858509,
0.2567150593,
-0.3644107282,
0.0156852901,
-0.103287898,
-0.4897303283,
-0.550344944,
-0.1854887903,
0.2002510726,
-0.084621489,
0.5645262003,
-0.5881428719,
0.595415771,
-0.3520551324,
0.5065207481,
0.7592345476,
-0.3287906647,
0.4890395701,
-0.2412125319,
0.5999660492,
-0.1783854365,
-0.1364662349,
-0.1305862218,
-0.4693562686,
-0.6103693843,
-0.1593907475,
0.8172309995,
0.5137126446,
-0.5574146509,
0.3390193284,
-0.335870713,
-0.5565188527,
-0.4767971337,
-0.0509785749,
0.2293452471,
-0.0566628873,
0.3288271725,
-0.6429305673,
-0.7881422639,
-0.5223055482,
-0.1779652983,
-0.116589278,
0.0035218569,
0.3231383264,
0.4874674082,
-0.2982392013,
0.2698173821,
-0.177910924,
-0.5108271837,
-0.1800765246,
0.1840430647,
0.0016015887,
0.7166419029,
0.847781837,
-0.5024449229,
-0.493850708,
0.1522739679,
-0.3639580011,
-0.0942149758,
0.303332448,
0.1217486411,
0.4672902226,
0.5274724364,
-0.084690176,
0.4520490468,
0.9632493258,
-0.381556958,
0.1574017704,
-0.7032040358,
0.227208361,
-1.215429306,
-0.0698364526,
-0.2342163175,
-0.3463534713,
-0.4032667875,
-0.0065141586,
0.144019261,
-0.1823106408,
-0.3906491995,
0.7498071194,
-0.679249227,
0.0565226674,
-0.2842362225,
0.1930492818,
-0.6359243989,
0.2669944465,
0.0299168807,
0.690535605,
0.6708476543,
-0.4147839248,
-0.0491761714,
0.1632400304,
-0.1349734813,
0.4492984414,
-0.4666466713,
0.3455675542,
0.0176826566,
0.2421761602,
-0.7738386989,
-0.0359576121,
0.3691707551,
-0.3914526403,
0.309029758,
-0.4781935811,
-0.3768849671,
0.0128241032,
-0.4465411007,
0.8791636229,
0.3821093142,
-0.204360202,
0.7905083299,
0.5695218444,
-0.3143981695,
-0.2624614835,
-0.5706427097,
0.1739837527,
-0.3803420663,
-0.515080452,
0.6412346959,
-0.2202538699,
-0.0352945141,
0.3149102032,
-0.1113339439,
0.0150798364,
0.1498903185,
0.3109487891,
0.0919084176,
-0.4898334146,
-0.3805266917,
-0.1260210276,
-0.3036717176,
-0.5284400582,
-0.6365624666,
0.8027308583,
-0.2483334988,
-0.3703328371,
-0.4461200535,
0.1277641207,
0.4818803072,
-0.1689388007,
0.5732527971,
0.6735863686,
-0.6719473004,
-0.0422263332,
-0.4364890158,
0.2138824612,
-0.3928344846,
0.4108656645,
-0.3814515769,
-1.2929362059,
0.311047107,
-0.375605911,
0.0894675627,
0.6274671555,
0.726169467,
0.1097714677,
0.7434088588,
0.9618680477,
-0.137089327,
0.6737754941,
0.0591617338,
-0.0533278883,
-1.0125578642,
0.1681150198,
-0.7018319368,
-0.1550782025,
-1.0020942688,
-0.654673636,
0.1803383529,
0.1953156888,
0.3208069801,
0.5334814787,
-0.2336584777,
0.0823056549,
0.2973500788,
-0.1621323079,
0.0705793649,
-0.1478271931,
-0.033578299,
-0.2425756454,
-0.6330345273,
-0.6428790092,
0.9792097211,
0.1633677185,
0.8034467697,
0.0604736432,
0.8019549847,
0.3210152984,
-0.0259830616,
-0.5912956595,
0.3870387971,
-0.7091911435,
-0.1396295726,
-0.3234735727,
-0.0700722709,
-0.9327428341,
0.1613135189,
-0.0172838625,
-1.039855957,
0.1011757553,
0.2677167654,
-0.2915394008,
0.3711072505,
-0.3037462831,
0.8910714388,
0.0199984945,
-0.0375495777,
-0.3741362691,
-0.3539398313,
-0.2590174973,
-0.0659624189,
0.3664151728,
-0.0958943665,
-0.1452956051,
0.8832848072,
-0.1689061224,
0.6930965185,
-0.2124915421,
-0.0775816739,
0.0899920538,
0.0964415967,
0.4381586015,
0.1086711362,
-0.1313712448,
-0.0559221432,
0.3646292984,
-0.4570590854,
-0.3757278621,
0.7549006939,
-0.5985665321,
-0.5331322551,
-0.703256309,
-0.8835813403,
-0.0663575307,
0.1244031563,
-0.005319865,
0.5867447853,
-0.3766798377,
0.1942426264,
0.5305282474,
-0.0834262446,
0.3656668961,
0.3933118284,
0.0121545466,
-0.4713257849,
0.7003364563,
0.1818340719,
-0.1018024832,
0.4653594792,
0.2824006677,
-0.0375550948,
-0.9904480577,
-0.8547891974,
0.1933959275,
-0.4223814309,
0.1015322655,
-0.4122798443,
-0.149532631,
-0.4868583977,
-0.2524725497,
-0.2735711932,
-0.7313631773,
-0.3894444108,
0.3015872538,
0.2820875943,
0.9408322573,
-0.2484648377,
0.1160942316,
-0.7191816568,
0.0673829094,
-0.0156660825,
0.1217175648,
-0.3581181467,
-0.6800209284,
-0.2865884304,
-0.0659650564,
-0.2072988451,
-0.5092046261,
0.0818900689,
0.4499751925,
0.800388515,
-0.0707596093,
-0.0948315561,
0.9078221917,
-0.8203780055,
0.7628927231,
-0.2030628473,
-0.9893143177,
0.6199657917,
-0.2918098867,
0.4498299062,
0.5863347054,
0.280641973,
-0.6204593778,
-0.4497042298,
-0.4008256197,
-1.0562757254,
0.7252753377,
0.1323369443,
0.2565945387,
0.272334069,
0.4045917988,
0.2399691045,
-0.1224783286,
-0.5409841537,
-0.0581332408,
0.0557178892,
-0.33436656,
0.0753159225,
-0.3193459511,
0.0957167447,
-0.1878889948,
0.7367248535,
-0.2409649193,
0.2310634851,
0.0673593879,
-0.4814035296,
-0.2435842752,
0.7221857905,
0.8845074773,
0.9588162303,
-0.1294456124,
0.3297932148,
0.55796206,
-0.4962511361,
-0.2533704042,
0.3996998966,
-0.2094309777,
0.1113146245,
0.3846236765,
0.8788821101,
0.3544704616,
-0.4307604432,
0.1460579932,
-0.2844308913,
-0.0326897874,
-0.4565113187,
-0.0036153295,
0.05319364,
0.3501419127,
0.2661719024,
0.1515679955,
-0.0952061787,
-0.7836328745,
0.0879729092,
0.424780488,
-0.6300643086,
-0.6116378307,
0.6444152594,
0.0200791825,
-0.3608991206,
-0.0652355552,
-0.203789115,
-0.7079535127,
0.2314918935,
0.7509655356,
0.6023206711,
-0.4712685645,
-0.2126643956,
0.5008351803,
0.2540795505,
-0.0299711674,
0.5607177019,
0.0389291942,
-0.2844417691,
-0.1865903437,
-0.7345852852,
-0.3386820853,
0.0355517305,
-0.587092638,
0.4075178504,
-0.2101740539,
-0.049763523,
-0.0796610415,
0.0231574252,
-0.7238375545,
0.0008650026,
0.1701154858,
0.9687054157,
-0.6320208311,
0.8473035693,
1.0315041542,
-0.1074954122,
-0.5323806405,
0.0505139977,
0.009405015,
-0.9069575667,
0.2815288901,
-0.1306134015,
-0.1219528094,
0.1650576293,
-0.1012684703,
-0.7511168718,
1.0453352928,
0.4348657131,
-0.4992671907,
-0.1533893198,
0.1096499488,
0.5155043006,
-0.3453736305,
0.2127229422,
0.2249526978,
0.5763428807,
-0.1643851548,
-1.2482843399,
0.2349870652,
-0.2946986258,
0.1801210195,
0.3620358706,
-0.2948296368,
0.7381061912,
0.1355070323,
-0.1742859483,
0.9482594728,
0.7099208236,
0.2301724851,
0.0696614459,
0.5940808058,
0.8318166733,
0.5148233771,
-0.2906134427,
0.8019182086,
-0.4265012145,
0.2701500058,
1.1316058636,
0.0231523234,
0.7713097334,
0.4755242169,
-0.1365062147,
0.4056912065,
0.5427032113,
0.029224731,
0.495603621,
0.354783535,
-0.2270076424,
-0.0381839536,
-0.3760068119,
-0.7494243383,
0.3064225018,
0.4052188694,
-0.2459243238,
-0.3720260561,
-0.0803306177,
0.2940799296,
0.0002005625,
-0.4741691947,
0.7648435235,
0.0865533873,
-0.5309204459,
0.3240643144,
0.1446701884,
0.9097005725,
-0.6691486835,
-0.1783664525,
0.0062874127,
0.3373454511,
-0.1234047562,
-0.7807599902,
0.25055632,
0.0158853214,
0.2171503901,
-0.139723897,
0.5213608742,
-0.6202096343,
-0.4497361183,
0.2930206954,
0.4260926545,
0.2268976718,
0.1324171126,
-0.4811157584,
0.2411487401,
-0.1417532265,
0.0667962655,
0.326684922,
0.7976440191,
-0.3838628829,
0.1091504693,
0.2543084025,
0.3846391737,
0.1162492707,
0.3410644531,
0.6970922947,
-0.5154336691,
-0.4274470508,
-0.9268779755,
0.3384205997,
0.4962897897,
-0.3242847323,
0.7647120357,
0.7331672311,
1.063565731,
-0.1126113236,
0.771373868,
-0.2054831982,
0.1243480071,
-0.5745646358,
0.67235744,
-0.5885826349,
-0.1375416815,
-0.5041906834,
-0.8604003787,
-0.2778815329,
0.4217355549,
-0.2682126462,
-0.1132507101,
0.7560576797,
0.4057486653,
-0.1746609211,
-0.1844841093,
0.3673581779,
0.0209982898,
-0.0109242834,
0.6309185624,
0.8194807768,
-0.3536759615,
0.4988929033,
-0.1496465355,
-0.2648772895,
-0.2312162966,
-0.9618145227,
-0.7000035644,
-0.9707942009,
-0.3493051529,
-0.1534075737,
0.3570022285,
0.9292077422,
0.4715155661,
-0.985454917,
-0.1738169938,
0.0458245352,
-0.2400606424,
-0.0674859285,
-0.1054568961,
0.4618447125,
-0.1266560555,
-1.0300334692,
0.4017959833,
0.5393857956,
0.1264301687,
0.0659694672,
-0.1296945512,
-0.1235013455,
-0.1656582206,
0.279117018,
0.2373980433,
-0.8771469593,
-0.6382980943,
-0.1742202342,
0.1553957164,
0.325654,
1.0474467278,
-0.5340129733,
0.4191736281,
0.533151865,
0.6290875077,
0.6075857282,
-0.2057905197,
0.6469843984,
-0.4147095084,
0.3830518425,
0.2991095483,
0.9333892465,
0.4183473289,
-0.1238599122,
0.6178365946,
0.1576351672,
-0.5219752789,
-0.7679618597,
0.1544296592,
-1.1690783501,
-0.1539836526,
0.7510066628,
-0.4651866257,
-0.2966455519,
-0.2209791392,
-0.4187178016,
0.5955888629,
-0.1771312207,
0.6856400371,
0.7117351294,
-0.0570752807,
-0.3003426194,
-0.4689272642,
0.364779681,
0.3571633995,
-0.9366837144,
-0.1674010754,
0.1947492957,
0.3631285727,
0.3516293764,
0.5964838266,
-0.3804999888,
0.4592803717,
-0.1448749155,
-0.0041795699,
-0.1069925353,
-0.074541904,
-0.5059034228,
-0.0774862319,
0.4493104517,
-0.1212443039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12843v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12843v1
|
Towards Logically Consistent Language Models via Probabilistic Reasoning
| 2024-04-19T12:23:57 | 2024-04-19T12:23:57 |
Diego Calanzone, Stefano Teso, Antonio Vergari
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are a promising venue for natural language
understanding and generation tasks. However, current LLMs are far from
reliable: they are prone to generate non-factual information and, more
crucially, to contradict themselves when prompted to reason about beliefs of
the world. These problems are currently addressed with large scale fine-tuning
or by delegating consistent reasoning to external tools. In this work, we
strive for a middle ground and introduce a training objective based on
principled probabilistic reasoning that teaches a LLM to be consistent with
external knowledge in the form of a set of facts and rules. Fine-tuning with
our loss on a limited set of facts enables our LLMs to be more logically
consistent than previous baselines and allows them to extrapolate to unseen but
semantically similar factual knowledge more systematically.
|
[
-0.0191786718,
-0.9086683393,
0.9862468243,
-0.081261158,
-0.1273141652,
-0.2809342742,
-0.5840460062,
-0.0800246894,
-0.3074010611,
0.7391794324,
-0.6474545598,
-0.4166203141,
-0.4679300785,
-0.1375743747,
-0.2657060325,
0.8798939586,
-0.0079918709,
-0.1274300218,
0.0595678911,
-0.0726004764,
-0.357409209,
-0.3249195516,
-0.7367163301,
-0.4842068255,
0.3967526853,
0.502969563,
0.9733138084,
0.541654408,
0.3578636348,
0.2240483463,
0.1978270262,
0.6112326384,
-0.545779407,
0.0206082817,
-0.750946641,
-0.6177774072,
0.2300653607,
0.0533203222,
0.6829374433,
0.8315468431,
-0.4004331827,
0.0274815429,
0.1634998173,
0.5076003671,
-0.5898093581,
0.4722459912,
-1.1175136566,
-0.0973054841,
-0.0685002357,
-0.2411619276,
-0.6083724499,
-0.5740144253,
-0.11152789,
-0.7254117131,
0.190294385,
0.1524136961,
0.8090738058,
0.2847945094,
-0.3971656263,
-0.257186234,
-0.734147191,
0.822193563,
-0.7043068409,
0.5734395385,
0.5392227769,
0.1852861941,
-0.7445853353,
-0.3490331769,
-0.8848270178,
-0.3957705796,
0.1376015544,
-0.0838735029,
0.1666109711,
-0.0207085181,
0.1749935597,
-0.0367330052,
-0.3826159835,
0.0875106305,
0.2294846773,
-0.0996803567,
0.6944101453,
0.031609647,
-0.0155114029,
0.2176827937,
-0.1203808933,
0.0370022207,
-0.9894881845,
-0.0825128704,
0.5511969924,
0.4379328489,
0.0083692772,
0.693991363,
-0.2901005149,
0.8484377265,
0.1703601778,
-0.5331120491,
0.0134668089,
-0.1918540895,
-0.245073095,
0.0588479117,
0.6523603797,
0.4071233273,
0.7238683105,
-0.1014583707,
-0.1893269271,
0.2819158733,
0.0205227714,
-0.4134280682,
-0.4157257378,
-0.0452768318,
-0.1542697996,
-0.3156368732,
-0.0873698667,
-0.1116050929,
-0.2741333842,
-0.8114996552,
0.6017349362,
-0.7378226519,
-0.1499913186,
0.3894886672,
0.1671604067,
0.0736820623,
0.5636322498,
-1.0949798822,
0.0924523622,
0.9745079875,
0.4293198884,
0.3632573783,
-0.1754900068,
-0.7681491375,
0.5627607107,
-0.7284326553,
0.6023161411,
-0.6737892628,
0.0599821247,
0.1622010618,
-0.0294434242,
0.0754256546,
-0.5333350301,
0.7582194805,
-0.4129748344,
0.0689193383,
-0.3483344018,
-0.8056870699,
-0.123379454,
0.4693235755,
-0.0912848935,
0.6974121928,
-0.0673587173,
-0.7863792777,
0.5952448845,
0.1129801795,
-0.2729022801,
-0.1212204397,
-0.4315775335,
-0.3655467331,
0.1841287911,
-0.0086417831,
0.4728075266,
-0.3717289269,
0.7669054866,
-0.4527308345,
-0.1739554107,
0.2594234049,
-0.5673676729,
0.5474036932,
0.2494587451,
-0.279343009,
-0.010741028,
-0.809615016,
0.0158376656,
0.0257458799,
-0.5048822761,
-0.2151660025,
0.4561009109,
-0.2389838994,
0.2778044343,
0.1148093939,
-0.6270759106,
0.1509563476,
-0.3161116838,
0.2584655285,
0.8583855629,
-0.0259277597,
0.2033752501,
-0.6335722208,
-0.1721334159,
0.1670443416,
-0.0163990464,
-0.0718277097,
-0.4243804812,
-0.6869863272,
-0.3440324664,
0.0892729908,
0.4775756299,
-0.6100568771,
0.815402627,
-0.0824573487,
-0.3819357753,
-0.3455489278,
0.4064810276,
0.1894892305,
0.754945755,
0.2102979571,
0.0202512927,
-0.6749787927,
-0.8899460435,
-0.3797604442,
-0.2743229568,
-0.0769827366,
-0.0544197857,
0.3064580262,
-0.2267234027,
0.9748977423,
-0.2182420939,
-0.2699801326,
-0.5024337173,
0.0602775849,
0.4227916896,
0.6501767635,
0.0550707132,
-0.5902833939,
-0.3791758716,
-0.0633774921,
-0.8448501229,
-0.0540275872,
-0.4236916304,
-0.0431470573,
0.2965400219,
0.6839563251,
-0.881057322,
0.106750384,
0.5156508088,
-0.1240272075,
0.5491660833,
-0.4492599964,
-0.128066957,
-0.9255400896,
-0.1743583828,
0.2119843215,
-0.3869719207,
-0.3156400323,
-0.0680426136,
-0.174406454,
0.1381079406,
-0.2371099144,
0.570258975,
-0.1816805601,
0.2632769942,
-0.2318784595,
0.1981327981,
0.017149074,
0.1832491904,
0.36284253,
0.527643621,
0.5272220373,
-0.5854718089,
0.3776521385,
0.1491351575,
-0.6362391114,
0.6360536814,
-0.4495697021,
-0.2928749025,
-0.2495141476,
0.3963529468,
-0.6313043237,
-0.2226760089,
0.1471122503,
-0.1794682294,
0.3276672363,
-0.1192737296,
-0.8403201699,
-0.0392176434,
0.0479335487,
-0.0590054989,
0.7851632833,
-0.7029961944,
0.4805673659,
0.2838405371,
0.0727043077,
-0.451838851,
-0.4610459507,
-0.1135325357,
-0.0263304636,
-0.6450174451,
0.0511254892,
0.0908400267,
-0.5495269895,
-0.0606606752,
-0.2196398377,
0.1823156476,
0.1201947629,
0.0931838974,
0.01014682,
-0.2264181226,
0.272478193,
-0.2410723716,
-0.1782658994,
0.1229516715,
-0.7126013637,
0.3163874745,
-0.1347616315,
-0.6993255615,
-0.6645684838,
0.124066554,
0.1117924973,
-0.0638925731,
1.0876361132,
0.4164721072,
-0.5042924881,
-0.518253684,
-0.687871933,
-0.1525355577,
-0.4437504411,
0.2442283034,
-0.5716858506,
-0.805311203,
0.3391360343,
-0.1811392307,
0.1691247672,
0.4417765737,
0.6458572745,
-0.2438532859,
0.9747253656,
0.652754724,
0.2847562432,
0.1611722112,
0.1163680032,
0.2950926125,
-0.418204695,
-0.3010740876,
-0.3204342127,
0.1178734004,
-0.7119371295,
-0.4438758194,
0.0163378697,
0.5393104553,
-0.6245847344,
0.1185282841,
-0.1102217585,
0.6573765278,
0.8492042422,
0.1687511653,
0.1384663135,
-0.1690240353,
-0.3223978579,
0.0354506113,
-0.7741710544,
-0.8841885924,
0.9397184849,
0.3180428147,
1.0820288658,
0.021885585,
0.7008937597,
-0.0497296192,
0.2631165087,
-0.4495683014,
0.5670763254,
-0.0927117318,
-0.5706319213,
-0.3197318017,
-0.5253129601,
-0.6668163538,
0.0472105704,
-0.3110691607,
-0.8906208873,
-0.1058875248,
0.3804383874,
-0.0792250335,
0.5685865283,
-0.4585531652,
0.9565755725,
-0.1476459652,
-0.5197627544,
-0.3363503814,
-0.7218312025,
0.3967669606,
-0.1768838018,
0.4271714389,
-0.4636512101,
0.3459923863,
0.2723259628,
-0.4253360629,
1.021214366,
-0.1513064504,
-0.2968089581,
0.5418581963,
0.2869457901,
0.7725591063,
0.3533964455,
-0.0928387344,
0.02911097,
-0.1549102217,
-0.3578484654,
-0.4860376418,
0.5457293391,
-0.7411820889,
-0.8060173988,
-0.3001382649,
-0.7717456818,
-0.4843535125,
0.0302599743,
0.0687274337,
0.3724181354,
-0.0228993334,
0.1795128286,
1.1225941181,
-0.2882804573,
-0.0473183617,
0.5139861703,
-0.0056186984,
-0.0417323969,
0.9049994946,
0.0239711925,
0.3154813051,
0.8068675995,
0.3232543468,
-0.4807421565,
-0.5154801607,
-0.1993559599,
0.1622716784,
-0.8022993803,
-0.1684642434,
-0.4352457821,
-0.1629307568,
-0.2870908082,
-0.2479570955,
-0.3369478583,
-0.2536861897,
-0.2246693373,
-0.0562271327,
0.251347363,
0.4030032456,
-0.2772126794,
0.2826958299,
-0.8341462612,
0.3237474561,
0.3900377452,
0.2996749878,
-0.4934593439,
-0.8490405679,
-0.0739148781,
0.2078671157,
-0.3266828656,
-0.5483672023,
0.0390460007,
0.3843210638,
0.760176897,
0.5083143711,
0.0946415067,
0.4155822396,
-0.9082271457,
0.4607640505,
0.3114131987,
-0.9186193347,
0.7779237628,
-0.6665443778,
0.1055767387,
0.5936163068,
0.4183900654,
-0.5875730515,
-0.6817762852,
-0.8378325701,
-0.5476375818,
0.4981012344,
-0.0422211662,
0.0623806417,
-0.3635343015,
0.3668555915,
0.2049823105,
0.2561791539,
-0.5073224902,
0.2298647314,
-0.0169628989,
-0.8392983079,
-0.2971476018,
-0.159169212,
-0.3560041189,
0.0043083937,
1.0433369875,
-0.3984392881,
-0.2258168459,
-0.0487280264,
-0.0664738715,
-0.1147734374,
0.3580060899,
0.6247192621,
0.9038245082,
-0.177139014,
0.6131802797,
0.1082465425,
0.0209511332,
0.1829242259,
-0.0270709004,
-0.2812356949,
-0.0583885983,
0.501758635,
0.6210144758,
0.2745335698,
-0.9026278257,
0.485281378,
0.2156145722,
-0.2859760523,
-0.4076459706,
0.3296078146,
0.407079339,
0.3970431685,
0.065753825,
0.1946389824,
-0.3299947083,
-0.8107869029,
0.3928448558,
0.5163585544,
-0.1432148963,
-0.2930477262,
0.7518712878,
-0.0347339362,
-0.1469448805,
0.6722702384,
-0.3262567222,
-0.3104888201,
0.3168407083,
0.6775082946,
0.5027040839,
-0.0382162146,
0.1571934074,
0.2603881955,
0.4468632936,
-0.7023819089,
0.420958519,
0.222076416,
-1.1337368488,
-0.6398135424,
-0.8930357099,
-0.5288934708,
0.1442428529,
-0.1872046739,
0.3191334009,
-0.6012263298,
0.1090521142,
-0.1390878856,
-0.1220891774,
-0.5750770569,
0.4632949829,
0.2597107291,
1.0888427496,
-0.8869100809,
1.1070742607,
0.5098952055,
-0.3667267263,
-1.1036932468,
-0.0653491989,
0.0333703235,
-0.7319621444,
0.8029600382,
0.1787525117,
-0.0555278249,
-0.1682741344,
-0.6001086235,
-0.7966428399,
0.5255127549,
0.8631466627,
-1.0521088839,
0.1987062395,
0.1620227993,
0.3885833025,
-0.355281204,
-0.1272470653,
0.5393824577,
0.383664012,
0.1540718675,
-0.8568539023,
0.0414156206,
0.2730905712,
-0.0958766043,
0.1270547956,
-0.5735619068,
0.7067787051,
-0.5630247593,
0.0467694551,
-0.1151650846,
0.7177783847,
0.6147039533,
0.0495264828,
0.4190694094,
0.930649817,
0.9719086289,
-0.2555565536,
0.959723711,
-0.4427018166,
0.3019914031,
1.4854929447,
-0.5019370317,
0.9238624573,
0.3947688341,
0.0199528299,
0.3632629514,
0.568651557,
0.1013113931,
0.6027809978,
0.3702658713,
-0.4711760283,
-0.8481612206,
-0.1138050631,
-0.0879253075,
0.4456533194,
0.250870198,
-0.2145407647,
-0.1963974983,
-0.2955528796,
-0.017128529,
0.5076607466,
-0.298836261,
0.6534160972,
0.1346363574,
-0.6769670844,
0.5379505754,
0.1851815283,
0.4214295149,
-0.6569895148,
0.0220596269,
-0.0085993698,
0.6427763104,
-0.133775562,
-0.916714251,
0.4380519092,
-0.1844287366,
-0.1990114748,
-0.2109549195,
0.5348899364,
-0.6267420053,
-0.5757886767,
-0.1043451577,
0.3585527539,
-0.0145137953,
0.0922393575,
-0.4733783603,
0.0033761063,
-0.0540814176,
-0.1646824479,
0.3217348754,
1.030195117,
-0.0787096247,
0.8315068483,
0.6335378289,
0.1852470636,
-0.0725641027,
0.234027341,
0.5219790936,
-0.4739891291,
-0.495419234,
-0.9928087592,
0.2165822685,
0.1616348773,
-0.2268140167,
0.7473007441,
0.4597370028,
1.0851328373,
0.0654074773,
0.8241308928,
0.1922656298,
0.5027476549,
-0.7952158451,
0.3435716331,
-0.2494996786,
0.1657558531,
0.0127563216,
-0.969203651,
-0.2948749959,
0.9786387086,
-0.2476979792,
-0.181308642,
0.487688005,
0.6826991439,
-0.1143616512,
0.0209837481,
0.3669476807,
0.2290590405,
0.3568463326,
0.5698727369,
0.9599533677,
-0.0857226625,
0.2699514925,
0.0583893247,
-0.1673958898,
-0.0087467041,
-1.0291697979,
-0.780831635,
-0.2973245084,
-0.4396167994,
-0.2068263292,
0.3550357223,
1.177287221,
0.7068371773,
-0.8972533941,
-0.0947890133,
-0.598126173,
0.1236035973,
-0.1357830465,
-0.1539686918,
0.1394294351,
-0.8342087269,
-0.3892038167,
0.3024139404,
0.3185346127,
-0.2137591392,
-0.0841992572,
-0.1731283665,
-0.3295074999,
0.3469547629,
0.522321701,
0.2073723525,
-0.7930245996,
-0.8445078135,
-0.5094410777,
-0.1267820895,
-0.151211679,
0.4851084054,
-0.6601204872,
0.1199431419,
0.3968063891,
0.7426550984,
0.156744197,
-0.0889650881,
0.5945217013,
-0.8582071066,
0.1874401122,
0.0898945481,
0.5357624292,
0.5347416997,
-0.0191854741,
0.4305746555,
0.3618116975,
-0.6800259948,
-0.7335931063,
0.4543965161,
-0.7223075032,
-0.2886639237,
1.2580592632,
-0.3629977107,
-0.0280504543,
-0.115041472,
-0.0909871683,
0.3611202836,
-0.1370640993,
0.6665210724,
0.5912759304,
-0.0622775108,
-0.1183960587,
-0.5746811628,
0.5316252708,
0.369242996,
-0.7887124419,
0.274903059,
0.5235915184,
0.5745738745,
0.0308394823,
0.6146715879,
0.2283107787,
-0.0135848084,
0.1235938072,
-0.0914461315,
0.2261116654,
-0.5339661241,
0.0275145657,
0.1494545639,
0.3762072623,
0.1399004161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12829v1
|
LiMe: a Latin Corpus of Late Medieval Criminal Sentences
| 2024-04-19T12:06:28 | 2024-04-19T12:06:28 |
Alessandra Bassani, Beatrice Del Bo, Alfio Ferrara, Marta Mangini, Sergio Picascia, Ambra Stefanello
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Latin language has received attention from the computational linguistics
research community, which has built, over the years, several valuable
resources, ranging from detailed annotated corpora to sophisticated tools for
linguistic analysis. With the recent advent of large language models,
researchers have also started developing models capable of generating vector
representations of Latin texts. The performances of such models remain behind
the ones for modern languages, given the disparity in available data. In this
paper, we present the LiMe dataset, a corpus of 325 documents extracted from a
series of medieval manuscripts called Libri sententiarum potestatis Mediolani,
and thoroughly annotated by experts, in order to be employed for masked
language model, as well as supervised natural language processing tasks.
|
[
0.2463515848,
-0.7088857293,
0.4916533828,
0.1238353103,
-0.2161538154,
0.2701962292,
-0.1984108239,
-0.5432989597,
0.4666062295,
0.9648917317,
-0.0454692543,
-0.5121823549,
-0.1569843441,
0.1532332897,
-0.5439708233,
1.0640963316,
-0.0172955152,
0.3532659113,
0.4982820749,
0.047501307,
-0.7963485718,
-0.5651805997,
-0.1850208938,
-0.0607991628,
0.3626489341,
0.0118242251,
0.7772885561,
0.4124664068,
0.5326081514,
0.3720023632,
0.0573684759,
0.5181053877,
-0.7441804409,
0.2138361186,
-0.4721125066,
-0.5068297982,
-0.3362185359,
0.1776605397,
0.324190706,
0.3825832307,
0.2349381298,
-0.2564221919,
-0.3738926351,
0.547323823,
-0.5841089487,
0.121235013,
-0.683688581,
-0.0846806467,
-0.5675354004,
-0.5165265799,
-0.9766497612,
-0.7711728215,
-0.0597752929,
-0.879822731,
0.2294545025,
0.0297092721,
0.4914583862,
-0.0572004318,
-0.2032592148,
-0.6416774988,
-0.9473558664,
0.6812663674,
-0.0674879327,
-0.3430153728,
0.4297604561,
0.4590684772,
-0.6772887707,
-0.9594789147,
-0.3294292688,
-0.0884838924,
-0.2571689487,
0.0195790026,
-0.2901167572,
0.1070300564,
-0.1516226083,
0.2565444708,
-0.5922771096,
-0.2427849472,
-0.8423833251,
-0.5381272435,
0.5517523885,
0.1949750483,
-0.0470795818,
0.0204364788,
-0.1428362727,
-0.1132200137,
-0.9988533854,
-0.0619964488,
0.7818943858,
0.3189355433,
-0.0522100702,
0.5199241042,
0.0901653022,
0.689884305,
-0.0585950166,
-0.3587095737,
0.2568178773,
-0.1601613015,
-0.0970509127,
0.236199677,
0.4235807359,
0.4140580297,
0.7927727103,
-0.174865678,
-0.1814187765,
0.4432800114,
0.5185835361,
-0.89515239,
-0.5700470805,
0.2621441483,
-0.3866044581,
-0.4143660069,
0.0166331157,
-0.3791943491,
-0.6832216978,
-0.1275354773,
-0.1538737416,
-0.5560988188,
-0.0273177102,
0.0741587952,
-0.3934078813,
-0.00890119,
0.8204939365,
-0.3944032192,
0.3728047907,
0.5478408337,
0.7513119578,
-0.2717699409,
0.3029354513,
-0.7679441571,
0.2832151651,
-0.5420084,
0.5677067041,
-0.713549912,
-0.416595459,
0.2508562505,
0.4652229846,
0.2483076751,
-0.5250272155,
0.8411791921,
-0.8319526315,
-0.0939016864,
0.2541882098,
-0.5933209062,
-0.1867750734,
-0.093130134,
-0.6436724663,
0.8007477522,
0.2408391386,
-0.9484288096,
0.062293373,
-0.1347054541,
-0.3334896564,
0.6852084994,
-0.6094522476,
0.1349675953,
0.2215141952,
-0.2705672979,
0.3120650351,
-0.1347177029,
0.5610283613,
-0.1948716044,
-0.5669676661,
0.6792238355,
-0.3370583355,
1.1225960255,
0.549883306,
-0.1013897434,
-0.0005196042,
-0.6545342803,
-0.3740557134,
-0.1641212106,
-0.1442108601,
-0.5400598049,
-0.0587291643,
0.8670233488,
0.0508984476,
0.3782383502,
-0.9053800702,
0.2315817177,
-0.4035929143,
0.4283252954,
0.7758703232,
-0.1274857223,
0.1187082157,
-0.2781770825,
0.6879507303,
-0.1002962738,
-0.1286254376,
-0.1803448349,
-0.3783274889,
-0.344810009,
-0.6401795149,
0.6384011507,
0.9657292962,
-0.8079562187,
0.2299779505,
-0.1319927871,
-0.531014204,
-0.708119452,
-0.2328093201,
0.289300561,
0.0862065256,
0.124968946,
-0.2529004812,
-0.4780129194,
-1.0557112694,
-0.0895640552,
-0.2037889957,
0.144646436,
0.3695801497,
0.8789002299,
-0.0222061053,
1.215159893,
-0.6517015696,
-0.4519633651,
-0.1067181304,
0.1664737314,
0.515943408,
0.4817853868,
0.7195566893,
-0.8235270977,
-0.302862227,
0.1155812591,
-0.6716843843,
-0.2742957175,
-0.1398622543,
-0.0485971384,
0.1179430634,
0.6883835196,
-0.165051952,
0.8722136021,
0.1076229364,
-0.5078990459,
0.7698071003,
-0.3340429366,
0.2313039303,
-0.8439669609,
0.0335865021,
-0.5329921246,
-0.8696870804,
-0.7591213584,
0.0241836775,
0.263461709,
0.0163980853,
-0.7156347036,
0.6184209585,
-0.3800460994,
0.2409558147,
-0.4413079023,
0.1300570518,
-0.3500531912,
0.3154723346,
0.4118599892,
0.6872275472,
0.4450240135,
-0.0599324778,
0.4679801762,
-0.0052996944,
-0.2410310954,
0.5480356216,
-0.6345883012,
0.0288327765,
-0.1234904975,
0.0825688466,
-0.7005126476,
-0.2312778831,
-0.1471960992,
-0.3586466312,
0.3854997754,
-0.5346867442,
-0.6978485584,
-0.1388475597,
-0.3590042889,
0.6848893762,
0.1002252847,
0.0341997594,
0.2136969715,
0.6819728613,
-0.2852329612,
-0.6946278811,
-0.6025853753,
0.1694971174,
-0.26059407,
-0.6722692847,
0.6490347981,
-0.1622556448,
-0.7480971813,
-0.1328224391,
0.415971607,
-0.287343204,
0.1252516061,
0.6001746058,
0.386688143,
-0.1449985951,
0.1938292086,
-0.0710463449,
0.1975159943,
-0.1819285899,
-0.1131164506,
0.724265337,
-0.0582281202,
0.1314031333,
-0.0535333082,
0.4798125327,
0.3406168222,
-0.148107186,
0.6738042831,
0.0016181498,
-0.4153295755,
-0.0944332629,
-0.2876985669,
0.0073679411,
-0.4516359568,
-0.0451029874,
-0.3607763946,
-1.0700486898,
0.5835722089,
0.0779994279,
0.0816506967,
0.3132049739,
0.723490715,
0.1289579123,
0.2083472311,
0.5253850222,
-0.2837719023,
0.2592894733,
0.0010291251,
-0.0206530578,
-0.1284229755,
0.2109399885,
-0.4610374272,
0.0632819533,
-1.0283988714,
-0.6486135125,
0.4667726457,
-0.0540726259,
0.0377358571,
0.3431780338,
-0.2913958728,
0.604812026,
0.3635427058,
-0.0331082158,
0.3062355816,
0.0686829165,
-0.1678513288,
0.0383515432,
-0.1955314726,
-0.8486697674,
1.2124521732,
0.2598026395,
0.7714035511,
0.3728852272,
0.6200073957,
0.9746720791,
0.0636673719,
-0.2728767991,
0.2285908312,
-0.2624176741,
-1.1539508104,
0.2219840288,
-0.1451439559,
-1.3510804176,
0.2448525727,
-0.0343243703,
-0.7189528346,
0.6080530882,
-0.2478670925,
-0.5769987702,
-0.2761492729,
-0.3797450364,
0.6926813126,
0.0316224471,
-0.6154519916,
-0.2988205552,
-0.6740524769,
0.4614538848,
-0.1575345993,
0.437333554,
0.1175202727,
0.2592263222,
0.8373053074,
-0.7413666844,
0.8471556902,
-0.007389829,
-0.0387648195,
0.557547152,
0.4535609782,
0.5364631414,
0.1512365043,
0.2277458906,
-0.3778107464,
0.3169002533,
-0.5280271769,
-0.0040800492,
0.6160624623,
-0.4718239605,
-0.0799322277,
-0.9470260143,
-0.7661425471,
0.4408966601,
0.1777366996,
0.2131876647,
0.7318034172,
-0.4308412075,
0.2869196534,
0.7593790293,
-0.235214889,
0.5692698359,
0.7129608989,
-0.3438487649,
-0.4189596474,
0.521792829,
0.0926581323,
-0.0227366462,
0.363450408,
-0.3950441778,
0.2336787283,
-0.720952034,
-0.3438251913,
0.3089367151,
-0.4941064417,
-0.185607329,
-0.5701338053,
-0.2227557302,
-0.5814320445,
-0.4772248566,
-0.2471426129,
-0.6107692719,
-0.3903001547,
0.0461006984,
0.5320785046,
0.8888233304,
0.2102496475,
0.6500731707,
-0.4475355446,
0.3078862727,
-0.1466779858,
-0.2769528031,
-0.5877596736,
-0.5382338762,
-0.3674290478,
-0.2598867118,
-0.1595923603,
-1.4014767408,
0.9530442357,
-0.1803446263,
0.0640322417,
0.4022626281,
0.2179249823,
0.4040683508,
-0.6794133782,
0.5710412264,
-0.3133793771,
-0.4084360003,
0.4850508571,
-0.6673953533,
-0.1200193316,
0.5650333166,
0.196972385,
-0.4139305651,
-0.6288046241,
-0.6242219806,
-0.8028467894,
0.5836930871,
0.8412127495,
-0.1531903744,
-0.1421026289,
0.1994483322,
0.3357999325,
0.2698157132,
-0.9001287818,
-0.310791105,
0.1100975573,
-0.28549245,
0.0357126817,
-0.1300403774,
0.0719127804,
0.0703360885,
0.6332213879,
-0.0373843275,
0.1608000547,
0.1528283656,
-0.8222727776,
0.2310189754,
0.1419531256,
0.7746642828,
0.8342733383,
-0.5903460979,
0.1659120619,
-0.2809517682,
-0.9774568081,
-0.0242783334,
0.2858050168,
-0.4656812549,
0.1488605291,
0.6339529753,
0.3558157086,
-0.3909730315,
-1.0099750757,
0.7171370983,
-0.1363931447,
0.3076540232,
-1.2357243299,
-0.0179739688,
-0.3578122258,
0.4941723049,
0.4428688586,
-0.1338521391,
0.3471867144,
-0.8384916782,
0.163501367,
0.2543515861,
-0.3544838727,
-0.173102513,
0.3405916095,
-0.0333450362,
-0.1175129339,
0.2460685074,
-0.4329828918,
-0.5300005674,
0.2930935323,
0.3165479004,
0.5655099154,
-0.1661742479,
0.3118387461,
0.0353153609,
0.6289474964,
0.1272949278,
0.4950481653,
0.1697649807,
-0.5021477342,
-0.3805457354,
-0.8084471226,
0.1019080356,
0.1483219564,
-0.2720208168,
0.1675077081,
-0.3844651878,
-0.0790618956,
0.1743369699,
-0.0090354942,
-0.432718873,
0.0607257523,
-0.0776315033,
0.8650458455,
-0.9381907582,
1.1177111864,
0.1204564199,
-0.3506717086,
-0.0840885937,
-0.7988808751,
0.0205832887,
-0.6476100683,
0.9291629195,
0.0642628148,
-0.1600886583,
-0.5539397001,
-0.6423422694,
-0.3726275861,
0.7200478911,
0.2506794333,
-0.6077330709,
-0.0046696784,
0.1417974979,
0.8337091804,
-0.9075111747,
0.2956009209,
0.6628301144,
0.1892244816,
-0.1351334006,
-0.6581523418,
-0.2373145074,
-0.5873765945,
-0.287587136,
0.21005252,
-0.153357476,
1.1023738384,
0.4455609322,
-0.0750350952,
0.3425794542,
0.7879148126,
0.1517872661,
0.063805826,
0.1352510899,
0.4367342591,
0.9001680613,
-0.1534482837,
0.9587165117,
-0.0490283743,
-0.1534339786,
1.2853832245,
-0.281242609,
0.6421899796,
0.3228739798,
-0.0782959685,
0.6167696714,
0.8288078308,
-0.0231444836,
0.6533511877,
0.7215028405,
-0.2672583461,
-0.1031902581,
-0.3565866053,
-0.0614018738,
0.3637680411,
0.5848763585,
-0.6923844814,
0.161778897,
-0.0547784604,
0.2907826304,
0.1399961561,
-0.5577825904,
0.6352050304,
-0.1893979162,
-0.5688551068,
0.4536470175,
0.2107328624,
0.3247716427,
-0.2271695435,
-0.2468665987,
-0.2837026417,
0.3593279123,
-0.0626038834,
-0.6511579156,
0.04820076,
0.3982360661,
-0.3462949097,
-0.3303480446,
0.8182553649,
-0.4487490654,
-0.6837052703,
0.1334158182,
0.1470584124,
0.964122653,
-0.1899822354,
-0.0948864594,
-0.364045471,
-0.0021035692,
0.226197198,
-0.1009084433,
0.6013320684,
-0.5896130204,
0.1186922565,
0.4280541539,
0.4278827906,
0.414961189,
-0.0745625645,
0.8283341527,
-0.8312923312,
-0.6028059721,
-0.720529139,
0.4135708213,
-0.3494547307,
-0.4586291015,
0.5540421009,
0.9593872428,
0.6049393415,
-0.0563784353,
0.704467237,
-0.06146577,
0.7783958912,
-0.5272921324,
0.682456255,
-0.0867497995,
0.0779981986,
-0.3977583945,
-0.6606849432,
0.1523712277,
0.5881267786,
-0.0307645388,
-0.291780591,
0.7779961824,
0.9183347821,
-0.0329150073,
0.0748590603,
0.236546725,
0.3725712001,
0.1045220792,
0.5799453259,
0.7070545554,
-0.1280312389,
0.2315892726,
0.0365248583,
-0.2181593478,
-0.5317953229,
-0.7082635164,
-1.1743147373,
-0.5355420709,
-0.032543242,
-0.4103448093,
0.2004983723,
0.7942106724,
0.4335405231,
-1.2160285711,
-0.4895737767,
-0.000031432,
-0.1628046781,
0.2244295776,
-0.1443594545,
0.5797837973,
-0.0541567355,
-0.5266870856,
0.6645824313,
0.1714719981,
0.1352337003,
-0.2736403644,
0.026220249,
-0.3824161291,
0.2673959136,
0.4078264832,
-0.1634057611,
-0.6302773356,
-0.0789532512,
-0.0451590493,
-0.2349634916,
0.0085276626,
1.0956121683,
-0.8748930097,
0.6430674195,
0.4744727015,
0.5064859986,
0.9485446811,
-0.3722798228,
0.6988447905,
-0.8062301278,
0.6289461255,
0.4963605106,
0.6639643908,
0.3177971244,
-0.2890177965,
0.7728944421,
0.4160376787,
-0.428891331,
-0.8742815256,
0.2781891823,
-0.9864727259,
-0.7934177518,
0.851485908,
-0.4716820121,
-0.505726397,
-0.5582073927,
-0.3920125663,
0.263259232,
-0.6095212698,
0.3573807776,
0.9337930679,
0.4254083037,
0.2422848493,
-0.8557543159,
0.6605744958,
0.0590599515,
-0.5680855513,
0.176965937,
1.0857203007,
-0.1196926534,
0.5376357436,
0.4804901481,
-0.3051145077,
0.4659976065,
-0.2149286568,
0.0686760992,
0.3152057827,
-0.6267121434,
-0.3364767432,
0.5847824812,
-0.2316741049,
0.1443579197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.12827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.12827v1
|
CT-ADE: An Evaluation Benchmark for Adverse Drug Event Prediction from Clinical Trial Results
| 2024-04-19T12:04:32 | 2024-04-19T12:04:32 |
Anthony Yazdani, Alban Bornet, Boya Zhang, Philipp Khlebnikov, Poorya Amini, Douglas Teodoro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Adverse drug events (ADEs) significantly impact clinical research and public
health, contributing to failures in clinical trials and leading to increased
healthcare costs. The accurate prediction and management of ADEs are crucial
for improving the development of safer, more effective medications, and
enhancing patient outcomes. To support this effort, we introduce CT-ADE, a
novel dataset compiled to enhance the predictive modeling of ADEs. Encompassing
over 12,000 instances extracted from clinical trial results, the CT-ADE dataset
integrates drug, patient population, and contextual information for multilabel
ADE classification tasks in monopharmacy treatments, providing a comprehensive
resource for developing advanced predictive models. To mirror the complex
nature of ADEs, annotations are standardized at the system organ class level of
the Medical Dictionary for Regulatory Activities (MedDRA) ontology. Preliminary
analyses using baseline models have demonstrated promising results, achieving
73.33% F1 score and 81.54% balanced accuracy, highlighting CT-ADE's potential
to advance ADE prediction. CT-ADE provides an essential tool for researchers
aiming to leverage the power of artificial intelligence and machine learning to
enhance patient safety and minimize the impact of ADEs on pharmaceutical
research and development. Researchers interested in using the CT-ADE dataset
can find all necessary resources at https://github.com/xxxx/xxxx.
|
[
-0.1707824618,
-0.44324857,
0.6086471081,
-0.2820608914,
-0.0320823304,
-0.3103852868,
0.0077895448,
-0.5221598148,
0.1315909624,
0.6600274444,
-0.34763062,
-0.8440005183,
-0.8376073241,
-0.1369102448,
-0.2741807997,
0.9714425206,
0.0912113562,
0.3575140834,
0.3985271156,
-0.2866054773,
-0.7062756419,
-0.4195685983,
-0.9003868103,
0.094551526,
0.9071842432,
0.0565540567,
0.4107671678,
0.5489812493,
0.7933167815,
0.2244845778,
0.1187602654,
-0.0511559807,
-0.2823133171,
-0.0969828367,
-0.0291272085,
-0.4672242701,
-0.830157578,
0.3277964294,
0.0814715177,
0.5484901071,
-0.2719642818,
-0.1227305606,
-0.1777121127,
0.4265180528,
-0.8551257849,
-0.0269086789,
-0.3876444697,
0.0201609284,
-0.0194412638,
-0.023916278,
-0.48119995,
-0.7001518607,
0.6155736446,
-0.9177390337,
0.0590623505,
-0.15840891,
0.4060249627,
0.2569034398,
-0.8733264804,
-0.3134299219,
-0.2036515772,
0.5728533268,
-0.5190684199,
0.1037579998,
-0.104171373,
0.6017979383,
-0.4946681261,
-0.8371423483,
-0.2639378905,
-0.1347706467,
-0.1659613848,
0.0932412595,
0.2021733671,
0.5173537135,
-0.0265828818,
0.2370581776,
-0.6940502524,
0.1967643946,
-0.4392921925,
-0.2285922915,
0.5167256594,
0.4366733432,
0.2765232325,
0.0460756645,
-0.8141684532,
-0.1741147488,
-0.6205402017,
-0.1679345816,
-0.3506687284,
0.4804977477,
0.0252224654,
0.3278075159,
0.1709756702,
0.4241939783,
-0.0721364841,
0.4342320859,
0.2301301509,
-0.5093508363,
-0.2874735594,
0.3412309289,
0.8350045681,
0.5154669285,
-0.0694872141,
0.0511347391,
0.1309282482,
0.3493040502,
0.242064774,
-0.989911437,
-0.4710047245,
0.6268411875,
-0.2887113094,
-0.7090523839,
0.3356070817,
-1.0854412317,
-0.9567614198,
-0.1741043031,
0.5531702042,
-0.5624764562,
-0.110067077,
0.3147561252,
-0.2993140221,
-0.2422491461,
0.470739305,
-0.0718851686,
0.4750884473,
0.3878448308,
0.5876989961,
-0.6631940603,
-0.3027519286,
-0.4408256114,
-0.0335342474,
-0.5080806613,
1.1169300079,
-0.2690330148,
-0.5168456435,
0.144829452,
0.0370335057,
-0.4369511008,
-0.6145989895,
0.9673317671,
-0.3119998872,
0.1682378799,
-0.0458289646,
-0.645929575,
-0.3996849954,
0.0143303005,
-0.8424418569,
0.1177607179,
-0.2293827981,
-0.5629566908,
0.7677307129,
-1.1892235279,
-0.1121511161,
0.0196742471,
-0.0906143337,
-0.5510956049,
0.3419150412,
0.1294683069,
0.0124183455,
-0.344756335,
0.435554266,
-0.4726475477,
-0.298974812,
0.0227356385,
-0.2808507979,
0.7821897268,
0.4488390088,
0.0048293634,
0.1768549979,
-0.8169909716,
0.0939974114,
0.0667817071,
-0.3505673707,
-0.2467381805,
-0.3427824378,
0.50492239,
0.5040784478,
0.2028246224,
-0.6455210447,
0.2169632018,
-0.2838115692,
-0.010022454,
0.8211293817,
0.3551750481,
-0.040833991,
-0.2278708965,
0.3802303076,
0.4055958688,
0.5122368932,
-0.3095312417,
-0.2671400607,
-0.143967554,
-0.2348973602,
0.6483029723,
0.6585249901,
-0.2761303782,
0.5229957104,
-0.1718091071,
-0.3456397653,
-0.2316249311,
-0.3920726776,
0.3287339807,
0.164903298,
0.3476581275,
-0.229572013,
-0.6639808416,
-0.800596714,
-0.2254666984,
0.0358230509,
-0.0384440534,
0.1012867615,
0.462929517,
-0.2877557576,
0.4544837475,
-0.8163508177,
-0.6321749687,
0.0286218226,
0.2894188464,
0.0374600291,
0.5925567746,
0.5047585964,
-0.6633584499,
-0.2988412976,
-0.0782926157,
-0.7423084378,
-0.0688173398,
0.0143981939,
-0.1914395839,
-0.1294876188,
0.1829795241,
-0.2205706984,
0.5903801918,
0.5151313543,
-0.6498554349,
0.3140451908,
-0.2516925037,
0.6487505436,
-0.9776787162,
0.1405266225,
0.307302624,
0.279065311,
-0.8203126788,
-0.3769600987,
0.0291465707,
-0.2539871335,
-0.5374991298,
0.4515483975,
0.0531116948,
0.4477821887,
-0.186929822,
-0.0331830718,
0.1885314137,
0.1234186664,
0.0208860543,
0.6437195539,
0.4809412658,
-0.4191399813,
0.0473868959,
0.3013329804,
-0.29917714,
0.4627503753,
-0.460770756,
-0.0972365737,
0.2253278494,
0.1873473376,
-0.6396151185,
-0.1631674767,
-0.1890550256,
-0.425124824,
0.4936089814,
-0.1943026632,
-0.3695135713,
-0.4862965941,
-0.4901495278,
0.4657296836,
0.0319117233,
-0.3370097578,
0.5198877454,
0.7765458226,
-0.1327968836,
-0.5158195496,
-0.411190331,
0.2705274224,
-0.3287687898,
-0.3432464004,
0.0950366929,
-0.0878774524,
-0.0734743178,
-0.1347218901,
0.0916905701,
-0.6051843166,
-0.0693343356,
0.2536165416,
0.5631787777,
-0.248246178,
0.1836920381,
-0.0531249978,
-0.3220938146,
0.1906638443,
-0.2480952591,
0.1292672008,
0.0382787436,
-0.0616730452,
-0.7733314037,
0.4493432939,
0.8202058673,
0.0550107248,
0.3750734627,
0.1184492335,
-0.7786040902,
0.2617343366,
-0.2572796047,
-0.39405334,
-0.3525280356,
0.6183601022,
-0.2049177885,
0.0701025501,
0.5459275246,
-0.1388068497,
0.1443924606,
0.4988730252,
0.1954682171,
0.1739416867,
1.1936582327,
0.3688104749,
0.3346560001,
0.3967386782,
-0.2482974827,
-0.0329564065,
-0.6449410915,
-0.1393830776,
-0.2587952316,
-0.2024796307,
-0.7109892368,
-0.3554826081,
0.9016254544,
-0.3929203451,
-0.4901587963,
0.3330118954,
-0.4731456041,
0.1555692852,
0.2584346235,
0.2639758289,
0.4038780034,
-0.333624959,
0.0734137967,
-0.0037028892,
-0.5944246054,
-0.4651728272,
1.6127389669,
0.1909915358,
0.4378013313,
-0.2469691783,
0.4745946229,
0.5217564106,
0.4645694494,
-0.5760455132,
0.2968333066,
-0.6419513226,
-0.906978786,
0.1306879371,
-0.1508067548,
-0.9558703899,
0.0947483033,
-0.3750356436,
-0.6848420501,
0.5298947692,
0.0723490342,
-0.8154987097,
0.1075814739,
-1.0157626867,
1.2365652323,
-0.2479643375,
-0.0740545914,
-0.3914803565,
-0.5907480717,
0.2253976017,
-0.3770063519,
0.3174527287,
-0.088736251,
-0.1540631354,
0.7604532838,
-0.4686415792,
0.6658244729,
-0.2324849814,
0.0463213325,
0.374078095,
0.0046131779,
0.4045954943,
0.0996090695,
-0.2151536942,
0.3713366091,
0.1889701188,
-0.5020320415,
-0.5102258325,
0.9602835178,
-0.6234673858,
-0.1575560719,
-0.5574402809,
-0.4540393651,
0.0304558221,
0.3052902818,
0.2429270148,
0.7926963568,
-0.366006732,
-0.3188551068,
0.4114844799,
-0.4375906289,
-0.027209986,
0.7734697461,
0.2053563446,
-0.7389149666,
0.5787320137,
0.3188913763,
0.0461287908,
0.2166002244,
0.2289895564,
-0.4081262648,
-0.8589214683,
-0.1696388423,
-0.1898541301,
-0.8131300211,
-0.1859302223,
-0.5326488018,
0.0505288094,
-0.3934415281,
-0.18174389,
-0.7584534883,
-0.393116504,
0.1898173988,
-0.2085819095,
0.1805084199,
1.0370320082,
0.0918308124,
0.2650763988,
-0.8292489052,
-0.0802260265,
-0.1874170601,
0.5227581263,
-0.5219795108,
-0.2272848636,
-0.229208529,
0.0086668301,
-0.6222169995,
-0.6871959567,
-0.0452466831,
0.0144907404,
0.6002326012,
0.4113106728,
0.2856686711,
0.4720084071,
-0.169820413,
0.5643878579,
0.4061757922,
-0.4737485647,
1.0950585604,
-0.3948421478,
-0.0553084984,
0.7993975282,
0.0380449556,
-0.1825311333,
-0.1348504126,
-0.6295912862,
-0.9718168974,
0.7835361958,
0.3608978689,
-0.6281557679,
-0.1622094363,
0.337087363,
0.412332654,
0.0674624816,
-0.3592356443,
-0.4433498383,
0.0970958546,
-0.3069112897,
-0.0335402302,
-0.0149045018,
-0.1206932589,
0.140594855,
0.6476625204,
-0.0110792881,
0.0985975042,
0.1896469146,
0.1682525873,
-0.1174933463,
0.2061607689,
0.4197694957,
0.5264481306,
-0.6443601847,
0.0659584999,
0.1994784325,
-0.9471567869,
-0.0911022872,
0.6257047057,
0.3556288779,
-0.3604013324,
0.131212756,
0.2085428089,
-0.2207195014,
-0.9014536142,
0.4702933729,
-0.3236987293,
0.084640272,
-0.5040172935,
-0.0684829205,
-0.8435329199,
-0.0466020703,
0.4152434766,
0.4157974422,
0.72346735,
-0.2446310073,
0.6529121995,
-0.0533463359,
-0.909057796,
-0.2905876637,
0.8397494555,
0.4957670569,
0.2789950669,
0.3052394986,
0.3253149986,
0.0063356366,
1.0980429649,
0.0757459849,
0.977987051,
-0.2720315456,
-0.1854929328,
0.6852021813,
-0.0095702512,
0.3589050472,
0.1620767117,
0.8632465005,
-0.3000062108,
-0.1867647171,
-0.1572620124,
-0.1055388972,
0.3505913019,
-0.5060735941,
1.0334163904,
-0.3162640631,
-0.3818123341,
0.398781538,
0.2642086148,
-0.3415200114,
0.3441577554,
0.2102844417,
0.9741051197,
-0.9753801823,
0.7277541757,
0.9925401807,
-0.27352494,
-0.2258143425,
-0.1468936354,
0.3427990973,
-0.4966272116,
0.3074778914,
0.4138703644,
0.0815135464,
-0.2515124679,
-0.1191834733,
-0.4502221942,
1.116600275,
-0.0895375982,
-0.3863160014,
0.1256446391,
0.126104787,
0.5789707899,
-0.6539882421,
0.4359810054,
0.7214257717,
0.4243649244,
0.1709886193,
-0.8610255718,
0.1775471568,
-0.2405080795,
-0.0914585218,
0.363943696,
-0.1923212707,
0.5369877815,
-0.6665434837,
-0.094215408,
0.0511288755,
0.0230289586,
0.2312372923,
0.7687787414,
0.4466513395,
0.5248609781,
0.4990989268,
-0.2959183156,
1.0037564039,
-0.4172127843,
0.3300179541,
0.9896513224,
-0.2588306367,
0.5893609524,
0.1198573112,
-0.1939336956,
0.0903569832,
0.6260423064,
0.0688830093,
0.7411878705,
-0.0953189954,
-0.230781883,
-0.2223195434,
-0.2880502343,
-0.3805099428,
0.3298625946,
0.6971267462,
-0.4773353934,
-0.3014799654,
0.2130672932,
-0.2943611145,
0.0401104279,
-0.1669137329,
0.8759736419,
-0.1574946642,
-0.4744613469,
0.5310806632,
-0.5377780199,
0.2255985141,
-0.4511588514,
-0.1827023923,
0.0748678669,
0.7982292175,
-0.0706812814,
-0.8004696965,
0.2323435545,
-0.3680992126,
-0.0634144768,
0.6228002906,
0.2218559682,
-0.1034891531,
-0.3464654684,
0.5059664845,
0.1863380522,
-0.1743797809,
-0.0416068658,
-0.7914102077,
-0.0472106934,
-0.2034211606,
-0.2260786593,
0.3997942209,
0.4440805316,
-0.0134309176,
0.4521407485,
0.3301070333,
0.0925142616,
-0.161002636,
-0.0296958424,
0.8145531416,
-0.5997037292,
-0.3531620502,
-0.4545116723,
0.7248212695,
-0.1637333333,
-0.5048418641,
0.1238528714,
0.9801173806,
0.1220246479,
0.0470075868,
0.9262698293,
0.0500196554,
0.5402968526,
-0.1435247213,
0.5755252838,
-0.4789316952,
0.4300770462,
0.1887494475,
-0.3393440545,
-0.493609488,
0.0426731035,
-0.3344554901,
0.0136461444,
0.8653949499,
0.4791000187,
0.1941642463,
0.308442533,
0.1816388667,
0.5158311725,
0.54976511,
0.8695415854,
0.4633652568,
-1.1020066738,
0.6728229523,
-0.2421813309,
-0.5306372046,
-0.2091699094,
-0.5551906228,
-0.8045145273,
-0.4240464866,
-0.6101100445,
-0.4735486805,
0.5015965104,
1.2421709299,
0.7019110918,
-1.4747991562,
0.0304131545,
-0.2205478549,
-0.0353651606,
-0.3223605752,
-0.1972464323,
0.7051290274,
-0.3729537427,
-0.9335957766,
0.1914824992,
0.4097626507,
0.2547967136,
0.436024338,
0.168300584,
-0.2913955748,
0.0156139415,
0.43901667,
0.0187650155,
-0.4623631835,
0.0416916087,
-0.2709014416,
-0.3231292069,
0.0974042416,
0.8789100647,
-0.5341098905,
0.7893018126,
0.4090192318,
0.1195504293,
-0.041683577,
-0.1565844119,
0.9228230715,
-0.0747589096,
0.0506645925,
0.4215980172,
0.5595793128,
-0.3004827201,
-0.4881698787,
0.4533724189,
0.1072157919,
-0.6362140775,
-0.7048027515,
0.0818322822,
-0.9609081149,
-0.4323275685,
0.7552039623,
-0.2600489855,
-0.0992147923,
-0.5216240287,
-0.3092973828,
0.1999684572,
-0.634090662,
1.0876170397,
0.0929495692,
-0.2556898892,
0.1195311397,
-0.959239006,
0.5112378001,
0.0926370919,
-0.8256056905,
0.5694923401,
0.6697288156,
-0.0020868194,
0.1783426255,
0.3656797111,
-0.4710307717,
0.5458021164,
0.060550537,
0.2779402435,
-0.0245952662,
-0.3093383908,
-0.2361486107,
0.2582384944,
-0.2087398618,
-0.5220005512
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.