id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10112v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10112v1
|
PRODIS -- a speech database and a phoneme-based language model for the study of predictability effects in Polish
| 2024-04-15T20:03:58 | 2024-04-15T20:03:58 |
Zofia Malisz, Jan Foremski, Małgorzata Kul
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We present a speech database and a phoneme-level language model of Polish.
The database and model are designed for the analysis of prosodic and discourse
factors and their impact on acoustic parameters in interaction with
predictability effects. The database is also the first large, publicly
available Polish speech corpus of excellent acoustic quality that can be used
for phonetic analysis and training of multi-speaker speech technology systems.
The speech in the database is processed in a pipeline that achieves a 90%
degree of automation. It incorporates state-of-the-art, freely available tools
enabling database expansion or adaptation to additional languages.
|
[
-0.4294376373,
-0.6982429028,
0.5985304117,
0.2033182085,
-0.2036718875,
-0.0824278742,
-0.1190685183,
-0.5647804737,
0.7026316524,
0.6216514707,
-0.8743447065,
-0.6234770417,
-0.2250168771,
0.1119221449,
-0.6142699122,
0.3390370309,
0.3658165336,
0.4992225766,
0.019113142,
0.2010421008,
-0.2044850737,
-0.7930686474,
-0.4025880396,
0.0422226675,
0.1874335408,
0.6410439014,
1.0571386814,
0.2673745155,
0.561717689,
0.3159412146,
0.1282560527,
-0.3901918232,
-0.1679754704,
0.4756708443,
-0.2961758077,
-0.4260280728,
-1.0000261068,
0.0596784465,
0.6471741199,
0.9234911799,
-0.2434807569,
0.022330422,
-0.2040185928,
0.4553003609,
-0.5613267422,
0.1501646489,
-0.1674615443,
-0.0815112814,
-0.8316815495,
-0.0153940385,
-0.3269183934,
-0.6331956387,
0.0064496715,
-0.9074396491,
0.1935841888,
-0.138378337,
0.4137400985,
-0.1177416891,
0.0522961989,
-0.6068495512,
-0.9645799994,
0.5578505993,
-0.7313117385,
0.9221981168,
0.7620828152,
0.267488271,
-0.3281018436,
-0.6900742054,
-0.5639490485,
-0.0569060445,
0.0426872671,
0.1162820756,
-0.0473143458,
0.1406898797,
-0.0944894701,
0.3546197712,
-0.6498018503,
0.013923117,
-0.482721895,
-0.3517169952,
0.6500239968,
0.208069846,
0.4063009918,
0.0101445979,
0.1473924965,
0.1289535165,
-0.8194078207,
-0.1118685752,
0.7512799501,
0.7877719998,
0.0827819556,
0.389863193,
-0.3845007122,
0.7571058273,
-0.2185455263,
-0.3210924268,
0.4527684748,
-0.5087236166,
0.0157597475,
0.3036997914,
0.9348085523,
-0.001293561,
0.3401409388,
-0.2010676563,
0.1092781648,
0.2112725377,
0.1075710207,
-0.635328114,
-0.4347744584,
0.3054356575,
-0.2985654771,
-0.3012237847,
0.0802127719,
-0.8011127114,
-0.2510405779,
-0.2830992043,
0.2205266654,
-0.733336091,
-0.7313478589,
0.3488965034,
0.3649170399,
-0.3193188608,
-0.1425597668,
-0.8807412386,
0.9367889166,
0.5214147568,
0.6987184882,
0.0013505284,
-0.0865390673,
-0.4515956044,
0.0052571497,
-0.6607477069,
0.814327836,
-0.7972481251,
-0.8439257741,
-0.0329016261,
0.2792284191,
-0.2242680639,
-0.7759400606,
0.9210454822,
-0.3125590086,
0.4220681489,
-0.2109392285,
-0.8136805296,
-0.1759521216,
-0.5065729022,
-0.8875846863,
0.57254529,
0.2516631186,
-0.6537946463,
0.2914193571,
-0.4741175771,
-0.483425051,
0.3653934002,
-0.0615693033,
-0.2735438049,
0.0483999588,
-0.219817549,
0.1614289731,
-0.1688839942,
0.3493844271,
-0.2764431834,
-0.351965487,
0.0296478942,
0.225668475,
1.0389499664,
0.295525521,
0.1484863162,
0.205323115,
-1.1759625673,
0.1173263788,
-0.184367761,
-0.2578503489,
-0.3938187063,
0.3580700457,
0.1497273892,
0.4145312011,
0.0621687137,
-0.9285142422,
-0.1760423332,
-0.7111133933,
0.4037362337,
0.095799759,
-0.0255975723,
0.4053756595,
0.1966337711,
0.7818029523,
-0.0929204151,
0.2636214495,
0.0926991552,
-0.6543315649,
-0.1735943854,
-0.1892821938,
0.6690996289,
0.9413072467,
-0.3908571899,
0.336904794,
0.0985677689,
-0.5212495327,
-0.5110315681,
-0.0386908166,
0.3114919364,
0.5076288581,
0.0060263476,
-0.474065125,
-1.0743021965,
-1.0267287493,
-0.1274590939,
-0.4405930936,
-0.0108359288,
0.0223299563,
0.21640715,
0.2961345911,
1.0129791498,
-0.0722332448,
-0.4722826183,
-0.3555335999,
-0.2867472172,
0.6546808481,
0.4467206895,
0.5525571704,
-0.594422102,
-0.3951630294,
-0.4255106747,
-0.7404779792,
-0.3007979989,
0.3910983503,
0.0929747894,
-0.0098160356,
0.3854117393,
-0.7043027282,
0.1507754475,
0.6367989182,
-0.6665263772,
0.8758105636,
-0.2088511288,
0.0792276114,
-0.8482156992,
-0.0184899028,
-0.1521441489,
-0.1822971106,
-1.0838462114,
-0.1908383518,
0.172510609,
-0.4264604151,
-0.8562728763,
0.3552404344,
-0.0975755975,
-0.5535470843,
0.0587857738,
0.1763987839,
-0.1742882282,
-0.0259790421,
0.1263822764,
1.1733350754,
0.9628155828,
-0.7443343401,
0.2705442309,
0.5341994762,
-0.8577448726,
0.7835345268,
-0.7142564654,
-0.0607378408,
0.1398055851,
-0.2093268931,
-0.7463826537,
-0.3290036917,
0.1815095395,
-0.5708409548,
0.0630596802,
0.2204956412,
-0.4398838282,
-0.3996973336,
-0.0698884577,
-0.1467832774,
0.3061179221,
-0.0360005647,
0.38770625,
0.6082646251,
-0.8287578821,
-0.3180655837,
-0.2905167639,
0.2061862946,
-0.0974124968,
-0.9409997463,
0.3817130029,
-0.1113978699,
-0.8040711284,
0.0658739656,
0.3375490308,
-0.3210971653,
0.1375860274,
0.4569947422,
0.142214492,
-0.2100099027,
0.1560020745,
-0.1317816228,
-0.3011599183,
0.0454571098,
-0.0785138533,
0.7080615163,
-0.1275526732,
0.0610207617,
-0.7456639409,
0.5976350307,
0.6130732298,
-0.1379633993,
0.803458035,
0.2116667777,
-0.3177300394,
0.2015942782,
-0.0613009483,
-0.1491069794,
-0.4509221613,
0.626976192,
-0.7574774027,
-0.4663386941,
0.7859092355,
0.0175161585,
-0.1644687355,
0.4498529732,
0.4975396693,
-0.4779556394,
1.1546462774,
0.6421218514,
0.0641477704,
0.4022028446,
0.0375833549,
0.0927330777,
-0.4146735072,
-0.2132369578,
-0.5444609523,
0.0121895773,
-0.4083089232,
-0.0325780176,
0.1617828459,
0.3338437378,
-0.2437163144,
0.4640801549,
0.0599469878,
0.2388731986,
0.541059792,
-0.0256281123,
0.3997519612,
-0.2308502197,
-0.1346345395,
-0.2665646672,
-0.6918817163,
-0.4806378782,
0.9030225873,
0.184295401,
0.4084799886,
0.1213811934,
0.5521656871,
0.2169446647,
-0.4118515849,
-0.4622994959,
0.7035506964,
-0.45801875,
-0.8311117291,
-0.4063169062,
-0.0608963072,
-0.8197210431,
0.0740635693,
-0.3927831054,
-0.7416728735,
0.7217316628,
0.1313975751,
-0.4521397352,
0.1850876659,
-0.6208996177,
0.7849391699,
0.0030747056,
-0.2336684614,
-0.3199326396,
-0.4386095703,
0.2460061461,
-0.2843640745,
0.7415078878,
-0.4482586384,
0.0326748937,
1.0129293203,
-0.5738120079,
0.6371434331,
-0.4198519886,
-0.1862177253,
0.2594824433,
0.5365440845,
0.2808794379,
-0.1406789273,
-0.5190573931,
0.246232748,
0.034094546,
-0.0766544864,
-0.1538951695,
0.6372896433,
-0.6617174149,
-0.3944183588,
0.1372439116,
-0.5376275778,
-0.6013128757,
0.4078205526,
0.2767310143,
0.7075561285,
-0.6278837323,
-0.0800798908,
0.577937305,
-0.4646652341,
0.3403008878,
0.7252455354,
-0.4820433855,
-0.3690257072,
0.8934183121,
0.4838337898,
0.1422036737,
-0.3268775046,
0.1092781872,
-0.2742350698,
-0.6439874172,
-0.1358061284,
0.3549848497,
-0.4418775141,
0.1041329727,
-0.4774200916,
-0.0791556761,
-0.5403385758,
0.2156978101,
-0.6152975559,
-0.8372453451,
-0.1274075359,
-0.2200694233,
0.2480750233,
0.9074527621,
-0.3551178873,
0.6652680635,
-0.5602404475,
0.2648845315,
0.0922630578,
0.8815315962,
-0.7568784356,
-0.3204638064,
-0.1530737281,
-0.1470156461,
0.0562494583,
-1.2854193449,
0.7244263291,
0.5601785779,
0.5119859576,
0.1437552422,
0.1412164569,
0.0800055563,
-0.6187275052,
0.8353618979,
0.1654699445,
-1.0289928913,
0.8315510154,
-0.5045162439,
0.0177328587,
0.5214160085,
0.3587670624,
-0.3484007418,
-0.5444421768,
-0.874964118,
-0.8107610941,
0.8899318576,
0.3053026199,
-0.1890845746,
-0.18444103,
0.1503145695,
0.3234993219,
0.1583926976,
0.102119185,
-0.0711426213,
-0.135042429,
-0.0357236043,
-0.189997986,
-0.7024294138,
0.0702978447,
-0.2319592088,
0.8148701787,
0.4314792454,
0.2010226697,
-0.0246011447,
-0.028550338,
-0.19734326,
0.391066283,
0.708793819,
1.0125410557,
-0.6823245883,
0.01903354,
0.0596175566,
-0.9273164272,
0.202841267,
-0.103819713,
-0.1499693245,
0.6128379107,
0.3249440193,
0.7087179422,
0.1311391294,
-0.5481889844,
0.3866899014,
0.0327332765,
-0.6297262311,
-0.6338034868,
-0.0428955182,
0.4454327226,
0.0957757086,
0.1333179027,
-0.0286963768,
0.4096802771,
-0.6770658493,
0.4316387475,
0.0683181211,
-0.4843223691,
-0.6670226455,
0.8326737881,
0.3115086555,
-0.6776901484,
0.7102415562,
0.0478207096,
-0.1921181381,
0.5251507163,
0.5445623398,
0.3981330991,
-0.9157186747,
0.3305582106,
0.4732910395,
-0.0845788866,
-0.041843202,
0.9874364734,
0.4260397255,
-0.9240677357,
-0.4524911344,
-0.4733052552,
-0.5203183293,
-0.0206470378,
-0.8036481738,
0.2660162151,
-0.2378745973,
-0.6184867024,
0.1862218529,
-0.0645623207,
-0.4008454084,
0.2735808492,
0.117501311,
1.0329247713,
-1.0680820942,
1.2614871264,
0.4400151372,
-0.1694587171,
-0.4211119115,
-0.5840059519,
-0.0242115129,
-0.6051936746,
0.8977190852,
-0.4123162627,
-0.2346075177,
-0.0040224059,
-0.0941904783,
-1.0884888172,
0.681240797,
0.7236059308,
-1.0850957632,
0.1460168213,
0.3113082945,
0.4850906134,
-0.3471432626,
0.0052726124,
1.0193582773,
0.4583744407,
-0.3411347568,
-1.3519173861,
-0.4541710615,
-0.2416822612,
-0.2182037532,
0.234212175,
-0.0095981332,
0.9637349844,
-0.0806615874,
-0.3534811437,
-0.054821793,
0.5345076919,
0.0819452107,
-0.0958323628,
0.5145269632,
0.3966366053,
1.0208262205,
-0.076776959,
1.1150034666,
-0.8105431199,
0.1744801551,
1.1846225262,
-0.3894124925,
1.0212265253,
0.1806713343,
-0.596807301,
0.5330883265,
0.6629316211,
0.5200783014,
0.826860249,
0.0093957493,
-0.3229079843,
-0.291577518,
-0.1110414043,
-0.4608258307,
0.485912323,
0.8022425771,
-0.2047032863,
0.037847057,
0.3448849916,
-0.1156288832,
0.2412442863,
-0.2965594232,
0.6242067218,
-0.2261373699,
-0.0242271721,
0.4375661016,
-0.293304652,
0.4487250447,
-0.4636497498,
0.2700889111,
-0.0736488402,
0.2293757945,
-0.4629237652,
-1.052520752,
0.6977907419,
-0.3336986005,
-0.2205618769,
0.0175838564,
0.8254801035,
-0.3970341682,
-0.737573266,
0.3832257688,
0.7394002676,
0.5512174368,
0.0430359244,
-0.5116153359,
0.1449483931,
-0.2704330087,
-0.2559914589,
0.2436439395,
0.0442341045,
-0.0613058396,
0.6531758308,
0.1848330647,
0.6227706075,
-0.0463364795,
0.4191888273,
0.5488798022,
-0.4140867293,
-0.7238566279,
-0.5496672392,
0.1850833148,
-0.0733842105,
-0.1186506003,
0.6183947921,
0.6851808429,
0.5361646414,
-0.1608806551,
0.7503599524,
-0.0252618603,
1.2925171852,
-0.2124502957,
0.6178665161,
0.0281331129,
0.1258275211,
-0.3992141187,
-0.9704441428,
-0.3013044894,
0.7413142323,
-0.3549681008,
-0.4018441439,
0.4409754574,
0.751110673,
0.2400018275,
0.4243310094,
0.5797799826,
0.3107132912,
0.0111312158,
0.2705700099,
0.5376760364,
-0.2543235421,
0.2203282565,
-0.570037663,
-0.1297305524,
0.0869305581,
-0.4023026228,
-0.3424960971,
-0.8553113937,
-0.3387748003,
-0.2532823086,
0.5026361346,
0.7061292529,
0.7646341324,
-1.2659870386,
-0.6281978488,
-0.0250914283,
-0.2248622775,
-0.2570225596,
-0.1770379245,
0.473787725,
-0.2563576698,
-0.6782153845,
0.8436045051,
0.0727963671,
-0.1065749079,
-0.2192518413,
-0.2142844498,
-0.1166879833,
0.0706703588,
0.5278050303,
0.2708534002,
-0.3944915533,
-0.0418956317,
0.1809145659,
0.2202025503,
0.0376815721,
0.7795625925,
-0.9405794144,
0.5644741654,
0.4455613792,
-0.263877362,
0.1975632161,
-0.2079989761,
1.0777146816,
-0.6484111547,
0.4289479256,
0.2151340991,
0.511236012,
0.187043339,
-0.36814183,
0.672972858,
0.2650713921,
-0.2264072895,
-0.622246623,
0.2902123034,
-0.718085289,
-0.4276309609,
0.8157785535,
-0.0752093866,
0.0197197925,
-0.5764952302,
-0.1134262979,
0.1438296288,
-0.3018399179,
0.3337052464,
0.9341772795,
-0.4008017182,
-0.2653487027,
-1.0733530521,
0.7534288168,
0.0712506771,
-0.5072293282,
0.2546227574,
0.4590980411,
0.3325150609,
0.1666775048,
0.9547752142,
-0.4581796229,
0.3350062966,
0.2066331059,
0.382918179,
-0.1291075051,
-0.5446279645,
-0.1306178272,
0.4097208977,
-0.002249626,
-0.1373570263
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10102v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10102v2
|
Chinchilla Scaling: A replication attempt
| 2024-04-15T19:19:56 | 2024-05-15T00:57:23 |
Tamay Besiroglu, Ege Erdil, Matthew Barnett, Josh You
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Hoffmann et al. (2022) propose three methods for estimating a compute-optimal
scaling law. We attempt to replicate their third estimation procedure, which
involves fitting a parametric loss function to a reconstruction of data from
their plots. We find that the reported estimates are inconsistent with their
first two estimation methods, fail at fitting the extracted data, and report
implausibly narrow confidence intervals--intervals this narrow would require
over 600,000 experiments, while they likely only ran fewer than 500. In
contrast, our rederivation of the scaling law using the third approach yields
results that are compatible with the findings from the first two estimation
procedures described by Hoffmann et al.
|
[
-0.1961333603,
-0.3856000602,
0.7073563337,
0.5303105712,
0.0487512872,
-0.5681169033,
-0.0356213637,
-0.2952483594,
0.525411129,
0.3141433299,
-0.4166180193,
0.3861503899,
-0.2240686566,
0.0296635889,
-0.5526456833,
0.6475903988,
0.1858812273,
0.5409992337,
0.3736761808,
-0.1645644903,
-0.0130345738,
0.3114054203,
-0.5851889849,
-0.170337379,
0.3382176459,
0.5577458143,
1.2288534641,
1.0930570364,
0.4212975502,
0.1110650003,
-0.0819611624,
-0.1494040936,
-0.3002329767,
-0.4812756181,
0.2590759397,
-1.0913401842,
-0.283434689,
0.3313296735,
0.7646850944,
1.0744540691,
-0.4044457078,
0.2193210423,
0.0609218515,
0.7898032069,
-0.7413238287,
-0.3012146652,
-0.4699265063,
0.2395704538,
-0.2958316803,
-0.2249053419,
-0.6313447356,
-0.590467155,
-0.0995852277,
-0.7799440026,
0.512650907,
0.0966412798,
0.6356800795,
0.1606222838,
-0.129402101,
-0.2879646122,
-0.5306293368,
0.9841635823,
-0.9213767052,
-0.0960449502,
0.5937817693,
0.2397593856,
0.0307984818,
-1.0440263748,
-0.6154007316,
-0.4290907383,
0.1473855972,
-0.0441944785,
-0.4329590201,
-0.2945903838,
0.4934786558,
0.3340066671,
-0.364299804,
-0.0075792889,
-0.7132187486,
-0.3162922263,
0.7622483969,
0.2940605283,
0.2016767561,
-0.1783079803,
-0.3438479602,
-0.3283368945,
-0.6744382381,
0.0705609173,
0.461302489,
0.5275693536,
-0.0458852313,
0.5652136207,
-0.0135876266,
0.7045590878,
0.449223578,
-0.2375097573,
0.3447216749,
-0.2840622067,
-0.3253780007,
-0.0034531585,
0.7430747151,
0.9722021818,
0.1846928298,
0.2446630001,
0.2062258422,
-0.3540522456,
0.5497720838,
-0.683839798,
-0.1530676484,
0.0707706064,
-0.7405623794,
-0.4567773342,
0.093402274,
-0.9733906984,
-0.4108775556,
0.0541763455,
0.654931426,
-0.0770178512,
-0.2132259607,
-0.0911733657,
-0.2352081239,
0.4362523556,
0.4032335877,
-1.0283539295,
0.5794240832,
0.5344614983,
1.0956439972,
0.1430663168,
-0.4450725615,
-0.1117059365,
-0.2194545865,
-0.9305591583,
0.4121899307,
-0.2414277643,
-0.4538251162,
-0.1044831127,
0.1517843902,
0.1010448039,
-0.6159082055,
0.5033791661,
-0.2857295573,
-0.4362823069,
-0.3930743933,
-0.4499890506,
-0.1973736286,
-0.3101429939,
-0.8244285583,
0.6542795897,
0.5907265544,
-0.8736529946,
0.3124753833,
-0.1332899779,
-0.5248026848,
-0.1439362913,
0.2744417191,
-0.5654296875,
0.3643934727,
-0.002281843,
0.3727949262,
-0.6109150052,
-0.174730137,
-0.9065269828,
-0.4293341339,
0.0749095455,
-0.2674464881,
1.5319890976,
0.2727473378,
-0.5109809041,
-0.2593132257,
-0.7035187483,
0.2876106203,
0.1399235576,
0.1857220829,
-0.0915340483,
0.0327972993,
0.0922100991,
-0.5230678916,
-0.0636582151,
-0.6916238666,
0.1338185519,
-0.143091321,
0.6667599082,
0.6558802128,
0.2623702288,
0.4604816437,
-0.6436176896,
0.534810245,
-0.3852033615,
0.3988831043,
0.3154524267,
-0.4309103489,
-0.4018612802,
0.1110311598,
0.0083186738,
0.0734605715,
-0.164063558,
-0.3231733143,
0.0050121634,
-0.8594726324,
-0.2027503699,
-0.2343638241,
0.054319486,
0.6863771677,
0.5693870783,
-0.1000722498,
-0.5115530491,
-1.2266000509,
-0.4468944669,
-0.2320635021,
-0.2109096199,
0.0261804089,
0.5297102928,
0.068691507,
0.7947909832,
-0.6757323742,
-0.1576657593,
-0.0788868889,
0.1847763658,
0.2178557366,
0.725272119,
0.9395053387,
-0.7808725834,
-0.9614031315,
-0.1704773754,
-0.4030987024,
0.0271819327,
-0.0831444263,
0.2108422965,
-0.1793384403,
0.5491054058,
-0.2251632959,
0.4130090773,
0.4647552371,
0.6963835955,
0.9208996892,
-0.0869190469,
0.222949326,
-0.8335886598,
-0.0422589406,
0.3359222412,
-0.0305767655,
-0.9993641973,
0.0837828144,
0.6881660223,
0.1780365109,
-0.2607346475,
0.1549766809,
-0.4066295028,
0.0114645287,
-0.2296437472,
0.0470438674,
-0.2697072625,
0.4086234272,
-0.2330652177,
0.9617210627,
0.3886131048,
-0.4331213534,
0.2740581036,
-0.038013123,
-0.0499584824,
0.8841201067,
-0.9484562278,
-0.2412143648,
0.1713705957,
0.3658630252,
-0.9757473469,
-0.718108654,
0.2184657454,
-0.7093826532,
0.2025600374,
0.0359508283,
0.0134512773,
-0.456092298,
-1.0038846731,
0.2631184459,
0.6332233548,
-0.5532409549,
0.5508854389,
0.5824770927,
0.0544174835,
-0.5124426484,
-0.9450715184,
-0.2416048795,
-0.4862805605,
-0.5348981619,
0.1351665407,
-0.0226103831,
-0.3901929855,
-0.1398307681,
-0.4270188808,
-0.4585648775,
-0.0009408482,
0.1749854982,
0.1381064951,
-0.3981372118,
-0.3329200447,
-0.1808488816,
0.3641780317,
0.5387843251,
-0.0285294261,
0.1666412055,
-0.1818138361,
-0.182340607,
-0.910318315,
0.0423718616,
0.5280532241,
0.1685166955,
0.4125521481,
0.3053529263,
-0.5366226435,
0.0365588777,
-0.6605186462,
0.1452162564,
-0.4572608173,
0.1735721529,
-0.2397890091,
-0.2436942756,
0.6845930219,
0.138307333,
-0.084583424,
0.9557067752,
0.1963775307,
-0.3141540587,
1.1350477934,
0.6652106643,
0.0249335971,
0.1612745672,
-0.1845961213,
-0.041383028,
-1.3594046831,
-0.0194432121,
-0.9217217565,
-0.1090554371,
-0.6518243551,
-0.2975329161,
0.501722455,
0.1001075581,
-0.2175969929,
0.520121634,
0.0279144254,
0.3276830614,
0.6334528923,
0.5494722724,
0.0584719181,
0.0245738719,
0.2640897334,
-0.2159797698,
-0.5213481784,
-0.1392244548,
1.3531244993,
0.1316456944,
0.9007979631,
-0.0614084229,
0.6202744842,
0.0805904269,
0.8595388532,
-0.9269531369,
0.2667155862,
0.2334857285,
-0.7288792133,
-0.7498705387,
-0.5819032192,
-0.8936977983,
0.3698161244,
0.4260944128,
-0.8178573847,
0.2242105901,
0.395068109,
-0.5263014436,
0.307463944,
-0.3869449198,
0.4400300086,
0.238136813,
-0.4554874897,
-0.2320484519,
-0.8931912184,
0.6090299487,
-0.5276703835,
0.4253660142,
0.2140470743,
-0.337700218,
1.0085906982,
-0.9320178032,
0.7001279593,
-0.4235367477,
0.1195018142,
0.6336757541,
0.262360841,
0.5093481541,
0.1911360621,
-0.1003749892,
-0.3517975211,
0.302952379,
-0.7271040082,
-0.6194745302,
0.4889399111,
-0.6120081544,
-0.5197339058,
-0.4979201853,
-0.3126417994,
-0.2639760077,
0.2543221414,
0.4304684401,
0.5670397282,
-0.0118933236,
0.5668919086,
0.1524244249,
0.2981239557,
0.4828957319,
0.4241923988,
0.0261540916,
-0.5460044742,
0.6129549146,
0.4440867603,
0.5694352984,
-0.0047009699,
0.4524127841,
0.1319671124,
-0.6602899432,
-0.1144275963,
0.4273556769,
-0.4031680524,
-0.2146463394,
-0.417745024,
-0.0325729251,
-0.3856963515,
-0.4854344726,
-0.5899734497,
-0.3254281878,
-0.2269253433,
0.2622045577,
-0.0530444346,
0.5892729163,
-0.7195467353,
0.5319431424,
-0.426849097,
0.0411128551,
0.0856364295,
0.0196059197,
0.3622238934,
-0.7996432781,
-0.2206933945,
0.4936679304,
-0.1864899248,
-1.2036144733,
0.4394643009,
0.0754510835,
0.5563215613,
0.3922465444,
0.1784420907,
1.003664732,
-0.4786539078,
0.6562911272,
0.3749775887,
-0.9410535097,
0.5372325778,
-0.3070087433,
0.1552019417,
0.5264444351,
0.9279087186,
-0.3953480721,
-0.3646515012,
-0.9362280369,
-0.5744274259,
0.7045778632,
0.0029945932,
0.0852565765,
0.159459874,
0.6327906251,
-0.0657901838,
-0.1714703739,
-0.5650607347,
-0.2601649165,
-0.0475396514,
0.0410041213,
-0.1746643037,
-0.2535689771,
-0.2175917178,
-0.3071024418,
0.6154285669,
-0.4378966689,
-0.1181491688,
0.447910279,
-0.1894624084,
-0.3791970611,
-0.3555371463,
0.8500108123,
1.1787086725,
-0.4062469304,
-0.0727834851,
0.1322864592,
-0.918088913,
0.3063377142,
-0.1905959249,
-0.2725743949,
-0.2235788256,
0.7122100592,
0.1413858235,
0.2862192392,
-0.2651599348,
0.6718002558,
-0.0555804074,
-0.5633533001,
-0.5958241224,
-0.0180836711,
-0.0014639271,
0.2578312457,
0.6559675336,
0.3966529965,
0.2431900054,
-0.4136110544,
0.304150492,
0.334792763,
-0.4401469827,
-0.3092925549,
0.8397114277,
-0.195511505,
-0.2447086275,
0.649107635,
0.0747358277,
-0.3271187544,
0.9843649864,
0.3825075924,
0.562472403,
-0.4397166669,
0.4330549538,
0.9593821764,
0.55235219,
-0.669110477,
-0.0016482435,
0.097149007,
-0.455057025,
0.0820451677,
-0.2377568185,
-0.5086601973,
-0.0100140162,
-1.55621171,
-0.0095816543,
-0.4430963993,
-0.2235215604,
0.5741996169,
0.0568698943,
-0.2075161636,
0.0858575776,
-0.5391638279,
1.060344696,
-1.0116738081,
0.2266655266,
0.0660060346,
-0.5399093628,
-1.0656292439,
0.3335362673,
0.4403503835,
-1.0304619074,
0.2009766102,
0.0013171155,
-0.2280756682,
-0.1547937691,
-0.8483834267,
-1.0509396791,
1.1350290775,
0.2843993306,
-0.2974937856,
0.2503754199,
-0.2855215073,
0.5503299236,
-0.2777689993,
0.178554818,
0.6132817864,
0.3372353911,
-0.0089983316,
-1.0537086725,
0.1489067078,
0.1472547352,
0.2748737335,
0.1392913312,
-1.0483824015,
1.0879733562,
-0.8313875794,
-0.1253807992,
0.3667934537,
0.7399976254,
-0.2242594212,
0.0834244266,
0.6150562167,
0.1862957925,
0.7340129018,
0.2766551077,
1.2128702402,
-0.3185675144,
0.7679027915,
1.1047222614,
-0.3595452011,
0.9858118296,
0.5482545495,
-0.8794092536,
-0.0400725789,
0.993647635,
-0.2478620261,
0.3946148157,
0.2457229048,
0.183587864,
0.3597147167,
0.1035737917,
-0.4689839184,
0.2384817153,
-0.1067096889,
-0.2128865123,
-0.0287662875,
-0.2160362303,
0.5611397028,
-0.2562864125,
-0.3873253167,
0.0572330095,
-0.1981320679,
-0.5832511187,
0.7630958557,
-0.0815248042,
0.0949597731,
-0.3802153766,
0.1532089561,
-0.5523485541,
0.2972048223,
-0.2415913045,
-0.576261878,
0.2905639112,
-0.3107839227,
0.1464014053,
0.1260314733,
0.1511057615,
0.0628019795,
-0.3827373981,
0.009776582,
-0.126058355,
0.2487267256,
0.1154152155,
-0.3126658499,
0.0820841193,
0.3576853275,
-0.5936008692,
0.1581020504,
-0.0464256108,
0.3619740903,
0.6673340797,
0.0972792432,
0.1989410371,
0.2412676066,
-0.28666237,
0.5661613941,
-0.3638716638,
-0.1538256705,
-0.653482914,
0.0806428418,
-0.2730671465,
-0.4640060961,
0.9364950061,
0.6914785504,
0.8649401069,
0.0208006371,
0.6484610438,
-0.2688099444,
0.4382691085,
-0.4369239211,
0.186384201,
-0.8300070167,
-0.1850228757,
-0.1936421394,
-0.9361494184,
-0.2136160731,
0.6897867918,
0.2333728671,
0.2411375344,
1.174185276,
0.8146509528,
-0.0135638611,
0.4669406116,
-0.0946765095,
0.5014569759,
0.0291142557,
0.2048567384,
0.1191131845,
-0.4670696855,
0.2524849176,
-0.7563198805,
-0.7581723332,
-0.316454947,
-0.4054038823,
-0.2494988292,
-0.5914193988,
-0.1761710197,
-0.5097166896,
-0.2312743068,
0.5997193456,
0.7420874834,
-0.4719676971,
-0.5768710375,
0.0773060098,
-0.3511613011,
-0.7799152732,
-0.1703475267,
0.3913088143,
-0.2134094387,
-0.6281006932,
0.1849000454,
0.0824244171,
0.0449554734,
-0.5018667579,
0.1666208655,
-0.0899323523,
0.0649535507,
-0.0385724828,
0.64670223,
-0.7421649694,
-0.5398595929,
-0.2542181611,
-0.3113204837,
0.0578329824,
0.8420538306,
-0.0056068553,
0.3963630795,
0.3926235437,
0.4369460642,
0.7589223385,
-0.1160025522,
0.6452071667,
-0.0308618192,
-0.0383250192,
0.1540812254,
0.1715283096,
-0.0549606197,
-0.057448566,
0.8958396912,
0.0656127781,
-0.5424128771,
-1.159774065,
0.1291922629,
-0.8779225945,
-0.1609536111,
0.5311843157,
-0.2339500636,
-0.5896916986,
0.4485931396,
0.0469498709,
-0.0331642292,
0.0286644306,
0.5324619412,
0.7759071589,
-0.7811089754,
-0.0641847774,
-1.0785127878,
0.5105506182,
0.4146563411,
-0.5101145506,
0.0498401672,
0.3047094941,
0.5345799923,
0.4956407249,
0.6785776019,
-0.1027813628,
0.3818353713,
0.6993719339,
-0.5994203091,
0.5105221272,
-0.2099548131,
-0.4369505644,
0.3088600039,
0.0812130496,
0.1789387912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10054v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10054v1
|
AIGeN: An Adversarial Approach for Instruction Generation in VLN
| 2024-04-15T18:00:30 | 2024-04-15T18:00:30 |
Niyati Rawal, Roberto Bigazzi, Lorenzo Baraldi, Rita Cucchiara
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
In the last few years, the research interest in Vision-and-Language
Navigation (VLN) has grown significantly. VLN is a challenging task that
involves an agent following human instructions and navigating in a previously
unknown environment to reach a specified goal. Recent work in literature
focuses on different ways to augment the available datasets of instructions for
improving navigation performance by exploiting synthetic training data. In this
work, we propose AIGeN, a novel architecture inspired by Generative Adversarial
Networks (GANs) that produces meaningful and well-formed synthetic instructions
to improve navigation agents' performance. The model is composed of a
Transformer decoder (GPT-2) and a Transformer encoder (BERT). During the
training phase, the decoder generates sentences for a sequence of images
describing the agent's path to a particular point while the encoder
discriminates between real and fake instructions. Experimentally, we evaluate
the quality of the generated instructions and perform extensive ablation
studies. Additionally, we generate synthetic instructions for 217K trajectories
using AIGeN on Habitat-Matterport 3D Dataset (HM3D) and show an improvement in
the performance of an off-the-shelf VLN method. The validation analysis of our
proposal is conducted on REVERIE and R2R and highlights the promising aspects
of our proposal, achieving state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.3529920578,
-0.6897476315,
0.3244046271,
-0.1747593433,
-0.2539235353,
0.2388765663,
-0.0683794096,
-0.3435768187,
-0.013078182,
0.3497059047,
-0.6877499223,
-0.5693246126,
-0.2944343388,
-0.1787212342,
-0.4726279378,
0.5041591525,
0.1822769046,
0.2246561497,
-0.207142204,
0.0373892672,
-0.2504705489,
-0.2927838862,
-0.5876448154,
-0.2515808046,
0.0768442303,
0.19734402,
0.7269026041,
0.852250874,
0.3981984258,
0.3590880632,
0.0218670852,
0.6460700035,
-0.4147399366,
0.0859113261,
-0.2004298866,
-0.467290163,
-0.0850107223,
-0.20180659,
0.4991076589,
0.1479613632,
-0.0801027194,
-0.3334374428,
-0.0058171107,
0.7383694649,
-0.3749833703,
0.2730771899,
-0.2893007398,
0.2076572627,
-0.1147918701,
-0.508588016,
-0.4848099649,
-0.3864928782,
0.1405613124,
-0.9689447284,
0.55883044,
0.1115917936,
0.6976598501,
0.4352768362,
-0.3120683134,
-0.4710384309,
-0.8959746361,
0.4044969976,
-0.3781763315,
0.3380703628,
-0.2366988063,
0.6359048486,
-0.3249491155,
-0.769290626,
-0.4718923569,
-0.3048093915,
-0.153321296,
0.4831065536,
-0.1899424642,
0.2127860785,
-0.0165250525,
0.1253256351,
-0.8566468954,
-0.0106890565,
-0.6804454923,
-0.1687601507,
0.7502802014,
0.1534180194,
0.5278651714,
0.0487652831,
-0.7204999328,
-0.5969885588,
-0.9970721006,
-0.0988289937,
0.4385303557,
0.3152583539,
-0.0881560817,
0.5156367421,
-0.2202638835,
0.7635839581,
0.0131467059,
0.3348425329,
0.199881658,
-0.2948812544,
0.1931000948,
0.3031267822,
0.7174746394,
0.4202146232,
0.3042605221,
-0.3940373957,
-0.1669652313,
0.2060103416,
0.8539025187,
-0.6274440289,
-0.7159826159,
-0.1689388156,
-0.4217577875,
-0.3432974219,
0.0520637855,
-1.0056254864,
-0.4415253699,
-0.3088559508,
0.4664507508,
-0.7325230241,
-0.0882621035,
0.0138202999,
-0.105116643,
0.7315976024,
0.4866018891,
-0.6233788729,
-0.025325764,
0.5780069232,
0.7677435279,
-0.0665591955,
-0.1501610577,
-0.4900771677,
-0.0393961594,
-0.2225981206,
0.6502882242,
-0.4373934865,
-0.9964416027,
0.0184351243,
-0.1837622672,
-0.0869224146,
-0.4288339615,
0.1871575564,
-0.5832138062,
0.3581240773,
-0.15866144,
-0.3227544725,
-0.5780332685,
0.3146287501,
-0.5113809705,
0.5971894264,
0.1307621449,
-0.1265492886,
-0.007763017,
-0.7875186801,
-0.7844523787,
0.463431716,
-0.5356767178,
-0.2758300304,
0.1349837184,
0.3253146112,
-0.189037323,
-0.341160208,
-0.1252731234,
0.3299259245,
-0.6015570164,
-0.0686612055,
-0.8363213539,
0.9038176537,
0.105509609,
-0.7353497744,
0.123642154,
-0.7109531164,
0.1440674812,
0.2320937812,
-0.3967139721,
-0.19355084,
0.2129430324,
-0.277231276,
0.0462608375,
0.1074704602,
-0.433150351,
0.5355610847,
-0.6787059903,
-0.0195669979,
0.7683278918,
0.0834362432,
0.4119713306,
-0.1014788672,
0.6483066678,
-0.3292316794,
0.3496427536,
-0.0944070667,
-0.7645878792,
-0.9980165362,
0.1861437708,
-0.1048221588,
0.7089935541,
-1.4689602852,
0.1646948457,
-0.4010238647,
-0.397498399,
-0.7224394679,
-0.0099879568,
0.7280977964,
0.4305375218,
0.7201387286,
-0.0781389549,
-0.4198712409,
-0.6275954843,
0.1555179507,
-0.3878691196,
-0.0299170967,
0.3198495507,
0.2649889588,
-0.3577424586,
0.666036129,
-0.5089380145,
-0.1905272156,
-0.1683951616,
0.1531230658,
-0.4092316031,
0.4765814841,
0.5888331532,
-0.9201245308,
-0.3409157693,
0.1031100303,
-0.878484726,
0.2154583186,
-0.2536582053,
-0.4037552178,
-0.0567305908,
0.7190842032,
-0.5533161163,
0.527156055,
0.3211174309,
-0.2399666458,
0.2187003046,
-0.5487304926,
0.1655844599,
-0.874347508,
-0.0893094763,
-0.1042969599,
0.0698624253,
-0.6056732535,
0.4048615098,
-0.1062334999,
-0.102574423,
-0.6422876716,
0.5666451454,
-0.368868649,
0.1122417599,
-0.2824482024,
0.0577267334,
0.1047212854,
0.5629916191,
0.0338121094,
1.0967447758,
0.3261862695,
-0.7100173235,
0.9106596112,
0.5516841412,
-0.1670071781,
0.3877663314,
-0.4296337068,
0.2048819512,
-0.3571238816,
0.102507256,
-0.9066236615,
-0.1544960737,
0.4722464085,
-0.639729023,
0.5103669167,
-0.1958181262,
-0.2951857746,
-0.4324243069,
-0.0405738354,
0.2409852743,
0.8941813111,
-0.8901562095,
0.9775609374,
-0.1282858402,
0.2666561306,
-0.2697626352,
-0.6502887011,
0.3018518686,
-0.085809648,
-0.6478649974,
0.5494362712,
-0.0216799714,
-0.2216744125,
0.3269639611,
0.3464148045,
0.4211033285,
0.1090750173,
0.22021465,
0.4370901585,
-0.2475568652,
-0.1326682717,
-0.0848209187,
-0.2190733403,
0.263772577,
-0.476357013,
0.4993195832,
-0.2344253659,
-0.5266442299,
-0.2046959847,
0.1972599179,
0.5735805035,
-0.3442003131,
0.6556917429,
0.7852221131,
-0.0654476434,
-0.3798207939,
-0.0620928742,
-0.1452658325,
-0.5763387084,
0.2795074284,
-0.2887193859,
-0.1736336797,
0.1997764409,
-0.2705996037,
0.1913874,
0.4788939953,
0.3712399602,
-0.1361440569,
1.0872176886,
0.3995945156,
0.2291471511,
0.3677912354,
-0.7389966846,
0.2066664547,
-0.8622280955,
-0.6806951761,
-0.0193484332,
-0.4018332958,
-0.6339564323,
-0.773578167,
0.9110406637,
-0.5411558151,
-0.0120015088,
0.1838852912,
-0.5858420134,
0.3227808177,
1.0158225298,
0.176647827,
-0.1186453924,
0.0389730483,
-0.1986509413,
0.2128423899,
-1.0220352411,
-0.1335130781,
0.9731417298,
0.0049366788,
0.9864746928,
0.196599707,
0.6491789818,
0.5844424367,
0.141857639,
-0.6626095176,
0.8082941175,
-0.4359092116,
-0.3789964616,
-0.175454244,
-0.4241123199,
-0.817779243,
0.3263015151,
-0.1560058594,
-0.3256570995,
0.1201568916,
0.3154841065,
-0.5274137855,
0.2242167145,
-0.6610643268,
0.6224272847,
-0.7871564627,
-0.4704745412,
-0.0826179162,
-0.9103361368,
0.3037922382,
0.3191300929,
-0.1344392747,
0.5104128122,
0.2761713564,
0.375451237,
-0.3856858611,
0.6058177948,
-0.5951038003,
-0.0814542025,
0.5796030164,
-0.0343178697,
0.7141892314,
-0.2226234227,
-0.0036058528,
-0.1494209766,
-0.9126800895,
0.0624928586,
-0.6166374087,
0.7644456625,
-0.6983053088,
-0.6213254333,
-0.204784587,
-0.2822116911,
-0.1834679693,
0.0057377703,
0.6983876824,
0.637242794,
-0.2721953094,
0.242224589,
0.922494173,
-0.6646161079,
0.1682969332,
0.3584166467,
0.1749358177,
-0.3733102977,
1.2661480904,
-0.133935079,
0.2596563995,
0.3646448553,
0.0448488258,
-0.5589249134,
-0.5708683133,
-1.2248367071,
-0.0890627801,
-0.6461429596,
-0.1790799052,
-0.2750101388,
-0.6839945316,
-0.1838034838,
-0.4960089624,
-0.6275489926,
-0.0583278574,
-0.3821623623,
0.0727233812,
0.0863480791,
0.6692777872,
-0.0934912041,
0.3889935017,
-0.7077761292,
0.4659677446,
0.4044029415,
-0.0647249818,
0.0284526944,
-0.4045379162,
-0.2751114368,
0.3481011987,
-0.0777321011,
-0.4582808614,
0.427077949,
0.1645984054,
0.730664134,
0.2005538642,
0.0627261698,
0.4951890707,
-0.5702228546,
0.7683585286,
-0.0004488787,
-0.3471616507,
0.7824142575,
-0.1707945466,
0.524315238,
0.4316473603,
0.0367633589,
-0.0495649092,
-0.2824438512,
-0.5358447433,
-1.0328893661,
0.5779961944,
0.349159956,
0.0932007432,
0.2466649711,
0.3731438518,
-0.2697706819,
-0.0123443045,
-0.2852983475,
-0.372150898,
-0.2820258737,
-0.412717849,
-0.0309259668,
-0.0280745402,
-0.3358371258,
0.048472885,
0.862044692,
0.0052680084,
0.4696162343,
0.1380260438,
-0.0935840458,
-0.0479179733,
-0.2211201787,
0.6765615344,
0.0465903096,
-0.0175734889,
-0.0468144603,
-0.1566466093,
-0.533622086,
0.3937551975,
0.377022177,
-0.6283906698,
0.0061461418,
0.3618081212,
0.9145613313,
-0.3115623295,
-0.5071704984,
0.5085801482,
-0.3048857749,
-0.1582687497,
-0.3718566,
0.6124433279,
-0.3268846869,
0.4351877272,
0.285581708,
0.3195185363,
0.3424578905,
-0.3913041055,
0.247093603,
0.4485742748,
-0.4168720245,
-0.1747842878,
1.0082713366,
0.6554658413,
-0.2951435149,
0.947828114,
-0.563241899,
-0.7131410837,
0.637663424,
0.3239127696,
1.0141782761,
-0.4053955972,
0.2687470913,
0.3167076111,
0.5497854352,
0.0576091185,
0.1299053431,
-0.0271945316,
-0.4839877188,
-0.1193915159,
-0.5898910165,
-0.2702302039,
0.0748272538,
-0.5438559055,
0.0359367803,
-0.2189450562,
0.2075600177,
-0.5830463767,
-0.3305999339,
-0.7391981483,
0.5077903271,
0.5063076615,
0.6450929642,
-0.6021559834,
0.609023273,
0.690425396,
-0.0470375679,
-0.3323031366,
0.260152936,
0.4169285893,
-1.1105825901,
0.4496363699,
0.1231318265,
-0.5310807228,
0.1982296556,
-0.1264843494,
-0.6433833241,
1.1092031002,
-0.0144265611,
-0.5066515207,
-0.4268563986,
0.2038148642,
0.5604847074,
-0.1776183993,
-0.2740026712,
0.3106110096,
0.354742974,
0.3779278398,
-0.1842457354,
-0.0750551224,
-0.604786694,
0.1966494769,
-0.0298358444,
-0.8027487993,
0.5142911673,
-0.3918992877,
-0.3355253041,
0.255898416,
0.6026523113,
0.0058913091,
-0.0145850638,
0.4495609701,
0.42188555,
0.4290522039,
-0.2789858878,
1.1804671288,
-0.5185976028,
-0.1387668401,
1.0889679193,
0.0835889503,
0.2847215235,
0.1035067588,
0.1881713122,
0.5425636172,
0.2363702059,
-0.0837521702,
1.0253474712,
0.2983931899,
-0.4826485515,
0.0081553189,
0.0197765976,
-0.4955461323,
0.8094072938,
0.6574626565,
-0.4683608115,
-0.2627905905,
0.4539652467,
-0.2792438269,
0.0806248039,
-0.1722079962,
0.8541010618,
-0.295244962,
-0.6897313595,
0.3984535635,
0.0243030246,
0.309638381,
-0.66607517,
-0.3659387827,
-0.2681677938,
0.3228592575,
0.211333707,
-0.7951051593,
0.0504768789,
0.0559234321,
0.4030561447,
-0.3317110837,
0.709662199,
-0.5193029642,
-0.51348418,
0.1021116525,
0.3384600282,
-0.2483753413,
0.2594631612,
-0.468048811,
0.0615324602,
0.4057756662,
-0.3526316583,
-0.05696458,
0.3367144465,
0.3202129006,
0.7618965507,
0.4096187353,
0.0838115513,
0.1859679967,
0.0109091243,
0.8927420378,
-0.4676146209,
-0.4303292632,
-0.7182812691,
0.6814123988,
-0.0984113514,
-0.2569479346,
0.7371085882,
0.7673265934,
0.8597310781,
-0.0849920064,
1.0493452549,
-0.0189537592,
-0.0675183088,
-0.9326398969,
0.5196416974,
-0.5717076659,
0.4284563959,
0.4092258513,
-0.7404034734,
-0.0422356054,
0.7110481262,
-0.0711231381,
0.0186122041,
0.1443634331,
0.9238641858,
-0.1928414106,
-0.2531434596,
0.1207014099,
0.0834669098,
0.7471305728,
0.6267069578,
0.873020947,
-0.5042761564,
0.6449320912,
-0.2751756907,
-0.0313480198,
-0.5580080748,
-0.2110845894,
-0.6067963839,
-0.4192020595,
-0.2401939183,
-0.4811764657,
0.5089025497,
0.6098470688,
0.5230600238,
-0.3616845012,
0.0969686732,
-0.542448163,
-0.2960067987,
-0.0797155127,
-0.243090108,
0.267681092,
-0.2220464498,
-0.7208353281,
1.1140221357,
0.3080307543,
0.4997873902,
-0.6888600588,
-0.315570116,
0.052809488,
0.0434329249,
0.4206225276,
0.466293335,
-0.5340698361,
-0.3610195518,
0.0239294488,
-0.1292278767,
-0.014980332,
0.504263401,
-0.8935956359,
1.0826406479,
0.3803097308,
0.6794860959,
0.4596622288,
0.3036160767,
0.8616124392,
-0.756831944,
0.0213284139,
0.335069716,
0.1567598581,
0.4988537729,
-0.5478952527,
0.701577127,
0.1708991975,
-0.1844880581,
-0.2687189877,
0.2486303747,
-0.6694242358,
-0.2421527207,
1.2709344625,
-0.0610628426,
-0.4439052641,
0.2977311015,
-0.3883038461,
0.3076499701,
-0.1071840227,
0.9394052625,
0.1041106656,
-0.3056954443,
0.1804114133,
-0.4412952363,
0.5875630379,
0.0097131459,
-0.7978936434,
-0.1313279122,
0.7241892815,
-0.2885849178,
0.2982265353,
0.1665560007,
-0.0903248563,
0.4991154969,
0.4144581854,
-0.0596306026,
-0.4055663645,
-0.7801926136,
-0.0512216985,
0.1048164219,
-0.3345177174,
-0.7137736082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09992v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09992v1
|
MMInA: Benchmarking Multihop Multimodal Internet Agents
| 2024-04-15T17:59:50 | 2024-04-15T17:59:50 |
Ziniu Zhang, Shulin Tian, Liangyu Chen, Ziwei Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Autonomous embodied agents live on an Internet of multimedia websites. Can
they hop around multimodal websites to complete complex user tasks? Existing
benchmarks fail to assess them in a realistic, evolving environment for their
embodiment across websites. To answer this question, we present MMInA, a
multihop and multimodal benchmark to evaluate the embodied agents for
compositional Internet tasks, with several appealing properties: 1) Evolving
real-world multimodal websites. Our benchmark uniquely operates on evolving
real-world websites, ensuring a high degree of realism and applicability to
natural user tasks. Our data includes 1,050 human-written tasks covering
various domains such as shopping and travel, with each task requiring the agent
to autonomously extract multimodal information from web pages as observations;
2) Multihop web browsing. Our dataset features naturally compositional tasks
that require information from or actions on multiple websites to solve, to
assess long-range reasoning capabilities on web tasks; 3) Holistic evaluation.
We propose a novel protocol for evaluating an agent's progress in completing
multihop tasks. We experiment with both standalone (multimodal) language models
and heuristic-based web agents. Extensive experiments demonstrate that while
long-chain multihop web tasks are easy for humans, they remain challenging for
state-of-the-art web agents. We identify that agents are more likely to fail on
the early hops when solving tasks of more hops, which results in lower task
success rates. To address this issue, we propose a simple memory augmentation
approach replaying past action trajectories to reflect. Our method
significantly improved both the single-hop and multihop web browsing abilities
of agents. See our code and data at https://mmina.cliangyu.com
|
[
-0.4611546695,
-0.5797221661,
0.3946872056,
0.3066931367,
0.1566220373,
0.2593652606,
-0.0197457951,
-0.723816216,
0.3516157568,
0.1539266706,
-0.8793243766,
-0.0736131668,
-0.2644666731,
0.2558521926,
-0.1461425871,
0.3606680036,
0.0597766489,
-0.1330738366,
-0.597951293,
-0.3008491695,
-0.408651948,
-0.3159053326,
-0.5505104661,
-0.1381867081,
0.6430948973,
0.3240135908,
0.6561052203,
0.4207613468,
0.4213069975,
0.4903401434,
0.4927382469,
0.7817659378,
-0.243455112,
0.2713061571,
-0.1014811248,
-0.3928049207,
-0.8096984029,
0.1002223864,
0.3729729056,
0.4271685183,
0.0009482269,
0.0672641024,
-0.2527988553,
0.3978589475,
-1.1288256645,
-0.0651223734,
-0.2403288484,
-0.0104457019,
0.0235654246,
-0.2773862183,
-0.4248333573,
-0.0690980628,
-0.1670609117,
-0.8572890759,
-0.123273097,
-0.0255245846,
0.4628483355,
0.2500321269,
-0.76686728,
-0.2641218901,
-0.5368738174,
0.8589414358,
-0.3454657793,
0.7143496871,
0.4148440659,
0.6509525776,
-0.1059707329,
-0.7815101147,
-0.7964895964,
-0.4978508353,
0.1744439453,
0.2849262953,
-0.3773690164,
-0.2632863224,
0.2361647189,
0.0269500576,
-0.5128782392,
-0.2091636062,
-0.0717257112,
-0.3888659775,
0.3343009055,
0.2101497352,
0.5127548575,
0.0529054888,
-0.2994104922,
-0.5656682253,
-0.2072940916,
0.0854482427,
0.5640743375,
0.1244188398,
-0.0257786103,
0.5664854646,
-0.4180674851,
0.4898842573,
-0.1710173935,
-0.4615381956,
0.5780972242,
-0.2278840989,
-0.0246498492,
-0.4757350087,
0.4458589256,
0.6138160825,
0.1116826534,
-0.2780549824,
0.0171558876,
0.3029679358,
0.6997432113,
-0.7050305009,
-0.12618424,
0.381477803,
-0.341191709,
0.0552137643,
0.1056773812,
-0.8037505746,
-0.3035168648,
-0.4019220471,
0.6488795877,
-0.4614142776,
-0.2242376059,
-0.1463117003,
-0.4746404588,
0.1222249568,
0.5458514094,
-0.5385392904,
0.3637233078,
0.6368964314,
0.7691565752,
-0.0599199049,
-0.8585332632,
-0.6026520133,
0.1027998403,
-0.2407609969,
0.9517969489,
-0.5984352827,
0.0116057843,
0.0249072891,
0.1666094661,
-0.1397482455,
-0.4328713119,
0.5435020328,
-0.4948064983,
-0.165088281,
-0.1451173425,
-0.3280670345,
-0.1741723865,
0.7389836311,
-0.935369432,
0.7595002055,
-0.1320265383,
-0.2768407166,
0.518386364,
-0.7422847152,
-0.505248189,
-0.342964381,
0.256311208,
-0.0694015175,
0.036595773,
0.2346212566,
0.2559903264,
-0.0535949878,
-0.4370107651,
-0.5795471668,
-0.3149535954,
0.6025863886,
-0.7379286289,
0.5159359574,
0.0063601844,
-0.2833964229,
0.1127145365,
-1.0565365553,
0.2066904455,
-0.0930704549,
-0.475451082,
-0.2368019521,
-0.0242081545,
0.1388023347,
0.455688715,
0.2632177472,
-0.4118030667,
0.3752452731,
0.0797664002,
0.1362614632,
0.9527763724,
-0.2137928307,
0.2520889044,
-0.7043140531,
0.4374546707,
0.0747792944,
0.36105147,
-0.4521758258,
-0.3968527317,
-0.7805014253,
-0.5091146231,
-0.0516479649,
0.2375507653,
-0.8547559977,
-0.0012547936,
-0.5996378064,
-0.5540289283,
-0.5694819689,
0.0721220821,
0.3296392858,
0.02407589,
0.588213563,
-0.4460581839,
-0.1964493245,
-0.7888581157,
-0.1141211912,
0.1100965962,
-0.1811977029,
0.4963029921,
0.5440981984,
-0.5813882947,
0.5489968657,
-0.2123362571,
-0.104813762,
0.2603150308,
0.5752355456,
-0.286088407,
0.4896530211,
0.3423066735,
-0.8790705204,
-0.3987256587,
-0.0292257387,
-0.753708303,
-0.0053461655,
-0.2557625771,
-0.2444945723,
-0.0076929638,
0.2136192918,
-0.9645959139,
0.2038194388,
0.5785960555,
-0.2777584493,
0.7245163321,
-0.3852151632,
0.6969106793,
-0.8212361932,
0.2526378632,
-0.2777169049,
-0.423707962,
-0.5028621554,
0.3296419382,
0.2860247195,
0.0206517801,
-0.4740886092,
0.6944350004,
-0.7900114059,
-0.3982200325,
-0.4673016071,
0.0373777002,
0.1311879009,
0.8121914864,
-0.4085680544,
0.6885462403,
0.4969271123,
-0.8495755196,
0.5000715256,
0.0231273416,
0.0484607853,
0.9791145325,
-0.2797487378,
0.4646808505,
-0.072752133,
0.2481139749,
-1.0867154598,
-0.2285683304,
0.0977475718,
-0.4452796578,
-0.0466024652,
0.0231862795,
-0.6896189451,
-0.2296531051,
-0.6468209624,
0.5649989843,
0.1557036936,
-0.4541266561,
1.0347779989,
0.0401009656,
0.3870548308,
-0.6933335066,
-0.391067028,
0.2471978813,
-0.001417238,
-0.7129184008,
0.3210519254,
-0.5340613127,
-0.1737432629,
-0.1200707853,
-0.1427499503,
-0.1882358789,
0.1318078339,
0.2938137949,
-0.1363414824,
-0.1156737208,
-0.0451962948,
0.00908658,
-0.1507010907,
-0.0856422484,
-0.0884523615,
0.6115576625,
0.0663423762,
-0.8321730494,
-0.444981426,
0.3762698472,
0.9525384307,
-0.2393447757,
0.4507517517,
0.7582707405,
-0.3236113489,
-0.1461294442,
-0.6669579744,
-0.1714004129,
-0.4567801654,
-0.1530371904,
-0.6913600564,
-0.3071829081,
0.4931094646,
-0.310102284,
0.1760657728,
0.1319764256,
0.322016865,
-0.196101442,
0.9578183293,
0.4459242821,
0.131289959,
0.3719673455,
-0.2454450577,
-0.3991609812,
-0.907673955,
0.0070540812,
-0.3321824074,
-0.7135044336,
-0.5877516866,
-0.7320643067,
0.4172559381,
-0.2365449667,
0.0084903231,
0.2915287018,
0.1214836687,
0.3295545578,
0.7033571601,
0.4134733081,
0.3844532967,
-0.2052669376,
-0.1300356835,
0.1086639315,
-0.176184848,
-0.3278461993,
1.2990535498,
-0.089033179,
0.5970935225,
0.5913224816,
0.196998775,
0.8061621189,
0.3193624914,
-0.556745708,
0.5442202687,
0.0970891789,
-0.6169856787,
-0.1693682671,
-0.24524571,
-1.0919796228,
0.6446163058,
-0.2709883153,
-0.6804351807,
0.2219088674,
0.1769523025,
-0.0504585803,
-0.0513548627,
-0.4209465384,
1.0143245459,
-0.3956461847,
-0.8336574435,
-0.6024591923,
-0.6275249124,
0.125366509,
0.220711574,
0.2585447133,
-0.143409431,
-0.331059128,
0.3831165433,
-0.3267662227,
0.8049693704,
-0.1377374232,
0.3906188607,
0.0452078022,
0.1828105599,
0.3372634053,
-0.4512589276,
0.1592264622,
-0.0896674916,
-0.0474259444,
-0.6631697416,
-0.784390986,
0.5516734719,
-0.7142888308,
-0.0533580184,
-0.4187327623,
-0.2491392195,
-0.5858969092,
0.2132278234,
-0.3663157523,
0.6608854532,
-0.2375288606,
0.2141121477,
0.2663939297,
0.0350804254,
0.6261934638,
0.6263196468,
0.0042878259,
-0.4206250906,
0.8900948763,
-0.1219908148,
0.14352265,
0.5969024301,
0.1877662092,
-0.3658312261,
-0.2317027599,
-0.7487686872,
0.0605328456,
-0.9603685141,
-0.1553941071,
-0.7632775307,
0.3717095256,
-0.3488143086,
0.0173199531,
-0.3853063583,
-0.3024562299,
-0.0551395081,
0.0724229291,
-0.2134841233,
0.3044221699,
-0.2206305116,
0.211103484,
-0.8126577139,
0.5341051817,
0.6032768488,
0.0634349212,
0.3123037517,
-0.0698229223,
-0.163097173,
0.1904687881,
-0.5802337527,
-0.7671416998,
0.2017094046,
0.2287982255,
0.8008175492,
0.6144741774,
-0.1679984331,
1.1520748138,
-0.3982229531,
0.5680419207,
-0.0158853494,
-0.7993851304,
0.1943349838,
-0.3166827559,
0.4249398112,
0.5935611129,
0.5493729115,
-0.4524755478,
-0.0574798472,
-0.3371042907,
-0.6175985932,
0.3280558884,
0.1513650119,
0.3354789913,
-0.0092614805,
-0.078289412,
0.2025734931,
0.4438583553,
-0.70612818,
-0.077099219,
-0.221179381,
0.0845928863,
-0.0737614185,
-0.1006112024,
0.0185572058,
-0.0283650998,
0.5014644265,
-0.548576951,
0.3405558765,
0.0261087213,
-0.6054363251,
0.011010834,
0.1516602635,
0.8500608802,
0.9835631847,
-0.1122837141,
0.2344011217,
-0.1476169676,
-0.4084090889,
0.2092251182,
0.0838099346,
0.1374527365,
-0.2774598002,
0.6803676486,
0.4049378633,
0.4915987849,
-1.1050786972,
0.5692514181,
-0.2005768269,
0.1765521765,
-0.2776290178,
-0.0246952865,
-0.0355957933,
0.3463907242,
0.3908266425,
0.2265236378,
0.5127984285,
-1.0652530193,
0.288205862,
0.3329440355,
-0.0874334425,
-0.4795300663,
0.3981789649,
0.1689490676,
-0.3125423491,
0.6934494972,
-0.2580765188,
-0.2447258532,
0.432955265,
0.4518727362,
0.8575307727,
-0.2144270837,
0.1709606946,
0.1972301751,
0.2826377153,
0.0303120837,
0.1705801189,
-0.3908112347,
-0.6742219925,
-0.1409790367,
-0.5454800725,
-0.6189771891,
-0.2939629555,
-0.3249640763,
-0.0859113485,
-0.2127877027,
-0.2246211767,
0.0698728412,
-0.1245041266,
-0.7499514818,
0.28294909,
-0.1197795793,
0.6119477153,
-0.6408941746,
0.4963210821,
0.6630826592,
-0.5265907049,
-0.2369806767,
0.1309954226,
0.2225022167,
-0.6364669204,
0.3209728599,
0.4468380213,
-0.417211473,
-0.3798922002,
-0.1902136207,
-0.5823310018,
1.2570941448,
0.2006960511,
-0.122923784,
0.0512732454,
0.1859858036,
0.6403221488,
-0.150095582,
0.8375123739,
0.1026582867,
0.7035161257,
0.2075345963,
-0.9236407876,
-0.0739364102,
-0.6391218901,
-0.4190864861,
-0.0206376202,
-0.8292774558,
1.0925917625,
0.089006491,
-0.0856056437,
0.1616009772,
0.4772667289,
0.0862627104,
0.66719383,
0.5772134066,
0.7386841178,
0.7423948646,
0.2509175837,
0.9073038101,
-0.1616399139,
-0.1533284187,
1.0609508753,
-0.314142704,
1.0298596621,
0.3750803173,
-0.094398506,
0.5040940046,
0.2338118702,
0.2312647998,
0.4287151694,
-0.0290424395,
-0.1261921972,
-0.2881985903,
-0.015213564,
0.053424906,
0.8039240241,
-0.0518969186,
0.202029407,
-0.1847386211,
0.3281143308,
-0.0451245345,
-0.0190592185,
-0.1295129508,
0.8637092113,
-0.3546575904,
-0.8202914,
0.2522836328,
0.0771724507,
0.5964637399,
-0.7246739268,
-0.2687196434,
-0.3410260975,
0.289791137,
-0.0132011632,
-0.2149309814,
0.1354035437,
-0.162460342,
0.0753616393,
-0.1684794873,
0.6258624792,
0.0022728809,
-0.4644451141,
0.3777881265,
0.7888662815,
0.1827878952,
-0.3528648019,
-0.6333889961,
0.2423551083,
-0.4715541899,
-0.2309618592,
0.4127773643,
0.3977033198,
-0.1347118616,
1.0894318819,
0.893817842,
-0.3859627545,
0.3372681439,
0.0709480345,
0.7125399709,
-0.5791437626,
-0.5452703834,
-0.7895233035,
0.6356844902,
-0.2815472484,
-0.3124648333,
0.8321723342,
0.7442286611,
0.5508069992,
-0.1022086218,
0.4205489159,
-0.0181081574,
0.1745039523,
-0.501079917,
0.46707955,
-0.959369421,
-0.2330138534,
-0.3115324676,
-0.9452425241,
0.1985179484,
0.5471907854,
0.2289915234,
0.226552397,
0.6586928964,
0.6993159056,
-0.4874020815,
-0.187117219,
0.5694823861,
-0.0492768027,
0.37849015,
0.4840367436,
0.9628695846,
-0.4546062648,
0.4909977019,
-0.3625267744,
-0.2541050613,
-0.3122259378,
-0.8446438909,
-0.7504133582,
-0.6655976176,
-0.121384263,
0.0292673986,
0.1282977313,
0.9554697275,
1.0702066422,
-0.3493481874,
-0.2887204289,
0.3114109635,
-0.1005170941,
-0.8174288273,
-0.1770135015,
-0.0169169325,
-0.0653167367,
-0.8485072255,
0.6469931006,
0.41500175,
-0.0457350351,
-0.4358356595,
-0.0534715801,
-0.3973247707,
0.2681590617,
0.7560514808,
0.1159308478,
-0.560806334,
-0.3632015288,
0.0777216852,
0.0054310281,
0.2444608659,
0.8612228036,
-0.6578447223,
0.7039899826,
0.3081850111,
0.6588635445,
0.6331810951,
0.129927814,
0.2269532233,
-0.6139127612,
0.0281175617,
0.228601113,
0.3795707524,
0.2360779941,
0.0877563134,
0.4669860601,
0.1930606067,
-0.3423920572,
-0.5302164555,
0.0301242098,
-1.2883833647,
-0.4144045115,
0.6452553868,
-0.1836624742,
-0.272752583,
-0.085306339,
-0.0208086595,
-0.0761474445,
-0.3871521354,
0.790117383,
0.715431869,
-0.2555583119,
-0.2083190233,
-0.6438760161,
0.1768943369,
-0.0352939293,
-1.2070938349,
-0.0868081897,
0.9335234761,
0.1342971921,
0.4864524305,
0.8283165097,
0.3969949484,
0.5883216262,
0.4283785224,
-0.0413504541,
-0.2432536781,
-0.7661772966,
0.1584383398,
0.4252155125,
-0.1622914374,
-0.2739269137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09982v1
|
Memory Sharing for Large Language Model based Agents
| 2024-04-15T17:57:30 | 2024-04-15T17:57:30 |
Hang Gao, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the realm of artificial intelligence, the adaptation of Large Language
Model (LLM)-based agents to execute tasks via natural language prompts
represents a significant advancement, notably eliminating the need for explicit
retraining or fine tuning for fixed-answer tasks such as common sense questions
and yes/no queries. However, the application of In-context Learning to
open-ended challenges, such as poetry creation, reveals substantial limitations
due to the comprehensiveness of the provided examples and agent's ability to
understand the content expressed in the problem, leading to outputs that often
diverge significantly from expected results. Addressing this gap, our study
introduces the Memory-Sharing (MS) framework for LLM multi-agents, which
utilizes a real-time memory storage and retrieval system to enhance the
In-context Learning process. Each "memory" within this system captures both the
posed query and the corresponding real-time response from an LLM-based agent,
aggregating these memories from a broad spectrum of similar agents to enrich
the memory pool shared by all agents. This framework not only aids agents in
identifying the most relevant examples for specific tasks but also evaluates
the potential utility of their memories for future applications by other
agents. Empirical validation across three distinct domains involving
specialized functions of agents demonstrates that the MS framework
significantly improve the agent's performance regrading the open-ended
questions. Furthermore, we also discuss what type of memory pool and what
retrieval strategy in MS can better help agents, offering a future develop
direction of MS. The code and data are available at:
https://github.com/GHupppp/MemorySharingLLM
|
[
-0.3470338881,
-0.7497224808,
0.7542846203,
0.1409047842,
0.0393182002,
0.0651114359,
-0.4766431451,
-0.7245028019,
0.0815419108,
0.3500227034,
-0.3556523621,
-0.3228770792,
-0.3046675324,
-0.2640244663,
-0.2877802551,
0.64865762,
-0.2819492519,
-0.1977370977,
-0.5618395209,
-0.4126043618,
-0.7611527443,
-0.6490781903,
-0.8554916382,
-0.444586277,
0.5703803897,
0.3944516182,
0.6128546,
0.5620673299,
0.1637472808,
0.2657224536,
0.1492300928,
0.3819423914,
-0.4631432891,
0.4774489701,
-0.4121247232,
-0.3571035862,
-0.4899877906,
0.0027573407,
0.6799684763,
0.2507793903,
-0.1771320403,
0.0346211456,
-0.107257843,
0.506100297,
-0.7587874532,
0.1895724386,
-0.8210573196,
0.192589432,
-0.0010983947,
-0.3743785918,
-0.440749228,
-0.0899863765,
0.1929107457,
-0.5794519782,
0.0062909378,
0.0230452009,
0.6608166099,
0.2153987885,
-0.200236693,
-0.4129412472,
-0.6219103336,
0.8291315436,
-0.4158221781,
0.0306411125,
0.3199596703,
0.5083778501,
-0.132737875,
-0.6004409194,
-0.6152139902,
-0.2533093691,
0.1777223349,
0.0238493904,
-0.0316804163,
-0.0246285833,
0.0578749627,
0.0982554704,
-0.5358002186,
-0.0453840978,
-0.1034223214,
-0.0973316208,
0.4661084116,
0.3471437395,
0.5093919635,
0.3821146786,
-0.3799716234,
-0.0725331903,
-0.359608978,
-0.0121696051,
0.0788793117,
0.4085570872,
-0.0236880649,
0.4794770181,
-0.1656635255,
0.5862494111,
-0.3522467017,
0.2504089773,
0.2202400118,
-0.1948572397,
-0.0218564142,
-0.0385892056,
0.4382757246,
0.3345949352,
0.6135960221,
-0.3855305612,
-0.2755599916,
0.0591220744,
0.3227404952,
-0.8501713872,
0.1543650925,
0.0976616517,
-0.2795298398,
0.1063801721,
-0.0452222377,
-0.467651099,
-0.3216570318,
-0.1580524594,
0.5660670996,
-0.6240321994,
-0.187794596,
0.3428069353,
-0.2117051184,
0.2892869115,
0.4692584276,
-0.5517577529,
0.4393917322,
0.601026237,
0.886570394,
-0.3499306738,
-0.8120177388,
-0.7564689517,
0.4271213114,
-0.0564394556,
0.7726985812,
-0.6986237168,
-0.1438880116,
-0.0086942352,
-0.1046822891,
-0.4186284244,
-0.7938254476,
0.0177740138,
-0.6489859223,
0.0331998691,
-0.21237804,
-0.6211705804,
-0.0483289771,
0.4732735157,
-0.6921461225,
0.9505945444,
0.0822435617,
-0.2961831689,
-0.0382111669,
-0.7801119685,
-0.1087177619,
0.0628271028,
-0.3913687766,
-0.1439023465,
-0.0085270396,
-0.0434513651,
0.6172225475,
-0.2320071757,
0.0798538774,
-0.192541182,
-0.5762224197,
0.5572126508,
-0.4377919436,
0.1871933341,
0.2624654472,
-0.0541401356,
0.2070850581,
-0.3789606392,
0.1338327378,
0.2562844157,
-0.3551040292,
-0.2922031581,
-0.0357598923,
-0.0166100189,
0.2789174318,
0.4317444265,
-0.5124911666,
0.2554674447,
-0.0427612364,
0.4183196127,
0.7447085977,
0.0639493987,
0.491903007,
-0.7610535026,
0.4958055317,
0.207652986,
0.1596896499,
-0.3486191928,
-0.2833634615,
-0.4178826213,
-0.2074201256,
-0.1373434067,
0.537701726,
-0.5732596517,
-0.0176613666,
-0.1016754359,
-0.2343985587,
-0.4685892463,
0.1131436303,
0.4175234139,
0.3496225178,
0.3854417503,
-0.2700799406,
-0.2278289348,
-0.756788373,
-0.2065367848,
0.007818711,
0.2373266369,
0.7730851173,
0.315984726,
-0.2194027603,
0.9735094309,
-0.4555442631,
-0.1161481366,
-0.2501803041,
-0.2116632611,
-0.102772139,
0.3753838539,
0.5410306454,
-0.6361600161,
-0.5979200006,
-0.1018075049,
-0.8236023784,
0.059373606,
-0.1566488594,
-0.3665740788,
0.4477955997,
0.4628958702,
-0.9953798652,
0.3189463019,
0.3895503581,
-0.434789449,
0.5666714311,
-0.4249641597,
0.028278375,
-1.0483263731,
0.0451063849,
-0.4069081545,
-0.3076042235,
-0.408223033,
0.2304878384,
-0.023386592,
-0.1466038227,
-0.5821990371,
0.9910078645,
-0.6053151488,
-0.2478718013,
-0.5026457906,
0.3445588648,
-0.0587897636,
0.4494441152,
-0.1346258223,
0.9741272926,
0.6731391549,
-0.6355168223,
0.3352380395,
0.0164729711,
-0.0115569625,
0.4958330989,
-0.2714873254,
0.3257724047,
-0.1812874228,
0.3136321306,
-0.6324422359,
0.0526273251,
0.2561151385,
-0.4733579755,
0.1088373736,
0.079456903,
-0.7230176926,
0.0019865022,
-0.2155649066,
0.6747253537,
0.3346861601,
-0.6504879594,
0.5928055048,
0.1644637585,
0.0687455833,
-0.7543533444,
-0.4539911151,
0.1145878062,
-0.1678365171,
-0.5891496539,
0.3021449149,
-0.3761795461,
-0.3309037983,
0.4542801082,
-0.1194871217,
-0.1176839396,
0.1242972165,
0.2075023651,
0.1265889704,
-0.2403766215,
0.6440015435,
-0.2183980346,
-0.187657997,
-0.1485448927,
-0.4434950948,
0.8455714583,
-0.2719802558,
-0.4383388758,
-0.0932573304,
0.5979342461,
0.5505413413,
-0.4347147048,
1.0716043711,
0.3951928914,
-0.466827482,
-0.5890758634,
-0.4461706281,
-0.0812828615,
-0.444251895,
0.206182301,
-0.3192893267,
-1.1333209276,
0.6815305352,
0.0136022931,
-0.0548840687,
0.0327654406,
0.4437309504,
-0.1145022959,
0.4256984293,
0.5231594443,
-0.3899868727,
0.5074904561,
-0.3042271137,
-0.0749290511,
-0.6773224473,
-0.1097210497,
-0.1870903671,
-0.5281758904,
-0.0043409853,
-0.7972706556,
-0.0081603955,
0.0096018976,
-0.3544637263,
0.0402625166,
-0.4065646827,
0.8037608862,
0.4690475166,
-0.068518661,
0.2019099295,
0.0324424133,
-0.2139081806,
0.3565045297,
-0.434643507,
-0.5023198724,
1.0044394732,
0.1501031071,
0.53175807,
0.1758312583,
0.680911243,
0.4115822315,
0.014209386,
-0.7464826703,
0.8604685664,
0.1131758988,
-0.4525438249,
-0.4157886207,
-0.3954336345,
-1.1545914412,
0.472550422,
0.0608873703,
-0.9105778337,
-0.3453615606,
-0.0820366815,
-0.2266565114,
0.5261909366,
-0.5754198432,
0.7672340274,
-0.1478548646,
-0.3801184297,
-0.537978828,
-0.4323593974,
-0.0152731827,
0.0321502835,
-0.1980400085,
-0.1931849867,
-0.2960823476,
0.4585448802,
-0.2671957612,
0.6978833675,
-0.3914784193,
0.1506916583,
0.5906791091,
-0.0018927087,
0.4583011866,
-0.0662558377,
-0.3149631023,
-0.0893311948,
-0.0346529707,
-0.5311195254,
-0.6580260396,
0.8048064709,
-0.8202707767,
-0.4694023132,
-0.3336156905,
-1.0377565622,
-0.1669281423,
-0.0233383756,
-0.2257471234,
0.335904032,
-0.0650349855,
0.1305247694,
0.7516197562,
-0.5100409985,
0.7407927513,
0.7398564816,
-0.1471071839,
-0.1209110692,
0.8494553566,
0.2166023105,
0.2322757393,
0.4414450228,
0.1584254801,
-0.0819871947,
-0.5436294675,
-0.3006211519,
0.3701940179,
-0.7035726905,
-0.1317947656,
-0.6459951401,
-0.4124779403,
-0.1321198046,
-0.275808543,
-0.2292451262,
-0.1891455054,
-0.3342497051,
-0.1256016195,
0.6166986227,
0.4703113735,
0.1317540556,
0.3750357926,
-0.8800726533,
0.1469440758,
0.1330478191,
0.4843279719,
0.4532106221,
-0.2323879004,
-0.5586103201,
-0.2043391317,
-0.2421750575,
-0.9343876243,
0.2742253542,
0.139455229,
0.8472676873,
0.0524657778,
0.1107615978,
0.6891676784,
-0.4056218266,
0.622436583,
-0.1586629897,
-0.7319375873,
0.312625885,
-0.3966748416,
0.2461052835,
0.5382486582,
0.0496185981,
-0.7521749735,
-0.3224615157,
-0.4645854235,
-0.8887838125,
0.7249714136,
0.0627975985,
0.2266731262,
-0.1142948046,
0.7275514603,
-0.0115458509,
0.2513437271,
-0.5997812152,
-0.1964832842,
0.2041247189,
-0.2851551473,
-0.2184595913,
-0.0033367674,
-0.0058901547,
0.022850642,
0.4343549013,
-0.2389242053,
0.4918977916,
0.087020494,
-0.2902851403,
-0.1687717587,
0.3907909691,
0.6036141515,
0.5212174058,
-0.2186254263,
0.2842471898,
0.156984657,
-0.402795434,
0.1111394987,
0.0181385968,
-0.0714127049,
-0.3444041014,
0.1236433089,
0.5991899967,
-0.1429471821,
-1.2207869291,
0.4602398574,
-0.1601754278,
-0.0223630872,
-0.5206422806,
0.3017601073,
0.3368423283,
0.7804022431,
0.2656814754,
-0.1236499846,
-0.1704158187,
-0.7444438338,
0.4679560065,
0.6134343743,
-0.2691965401,
-0.2209643722,
0.2643414736,
-0.2366185486,
-0.4479782581,
0.6378944516,
-0.4052032232,
-0.3423885107,
0.7093418241,
0.7663383484,
0.9821596146,
-0.0934386775,
0.1313480288,
-0.0899330154,
0.0779637545,
-0.0654682368,
0.565567255,
-0.2146114111,
-0.9072036743,
-0.1616981626,
-0.4914760292,
-0.4212351143,
0.0905629918,
-0.3958923817,
-0.2407371104,
-0.4047635198,
-0.0103669446,
-0.7283780575,
0.259743154,
-0.4985664785,
-0.0814886317,
0.1501702815,
1.0146530867,
-0.5197373033,
1.1785240173,
0.8939643502,
-0.4469592869,
-0.7720561624,
0.2567653358,
-0.1722795516,
-0.8392654061,
0.4568526149,
0.3366090953,
-0.1473358124,
-0.1815648377,
-0.3965733945,
-0.7636989355,
1.5188406706,
0.43903476,
-0.1488565058,
0.0255419258,
0.0746008307,
0.6296237707,
-0.6862713099,
0.1700974107,
0.1499754488,
0.2514714599,
0.2059975713,
-0.770236969,
0.1925914735,
-0.3457419872,
-0.171697095,
0.1876517832,
-0.8524531126,
1.1745134592,
-0.1847344041,
-0.2048790455,
0.1267737299,
0.5732159019,
0.7614352107,
0.8033187389,
0.4672911763,
0.6156082749,
0.9181566238,
0.3976670504,
0.9077484012,
-0.3383567631,
-0.0053380667,
1.3799433708,
-0.5717645288,
1.0853536129,
0.4423635304,
0.2711288929,
0.3161736429,
0.257979244,
0.2465194017,
0.3231831491,
0.3766314983,
-0.5596199632,
-0.0759645477,
-0.2261836529,
-0.3025875092,
0.1508454829,
0.281065017,
-0.263731122,
-0.2662439644,
0.0409446359,
-0.0665352717,
0.2130765319,
-0.3219984174,
0.6062179208,
0.1196399033,
-0.6352940798,
0.2653045654,
-0.0660197362,
0.671303153,
-0.5822471976,
-0.0494535901,
-0.1836399287,
0.4440627992,
0.0820687562,
-0.8043193221,
0.3589370251,
-0.0002762214,
-0.3771915138,
-0.3307881355,
0.8771649599,
-0.5303487778,
0.1862188578,
0.8067147732,
0.7616768479,
0.3483702242,
-0.2935244441,
-0.7035202384,
0.069147028,
-0.3848338425,
-0.2233435661,
0.7119594216,
0.4955982268,
-0.180950284,
0.9478591084,
0.3793531954,
0.2141810954,
0.2013383955,
0.0074135577,
0.7671550512,
-0.7777357101,
-0.4111943245,
-0.874160707,
0.1865546256,
0.0355131291,
0.1508848071,
0.762339592,
0.7348930836,
0.8305866122,
-0.0388290063,
0.7177981734,
0.2613774836,
0.3558063805,
-0.4562321901,
0.885872066,
-0.6369838119,
0.1852964759,
-0.0612986125,
-0.7858859897,
-0.0091701252,
0.4863951802,
-0.0999200866,
0.0688814223,
0.6980346441,
0.835047543,
-0.0636037365,
-0.0891233161,
0.5530172586,
-0.024700623,
0.3115097284,
0.9421366453,
1.1249089241,
-0.1416070014,
0.6669318676,
0.1729984879,
0.016019199,
-0.0849510655,
-0.6457294822,
-0.7844053507,
-0.6651698351,
-0.0928883851,
-0.0426189527,
0.1867055446,
1.2147060633,
0.6092839837,
-0.3149380386,
-0.4806442261,
0.1237474605,
0.0144898323,
-0.2651589811,
-0.1944539547,
0.2542863488,
-0.4460040331,
-0.5155476928,
0.4797011018,
0.2913223505,
0.0605400205,
-0.1764925867,
-0.4698968828,
-0.2384704053,
0.4202518761,
0.6351783872,
0.370890826,
-0.5092742443,
-0.3186613321,
0.005733449,
-0.2729321122,
-0.0097591244,
0.7611083984,
-0.8986699581,
0.2074176371,
0.3912377059,
0.9815430045,
0.4844533801,
-0.0667526126,
0.2669138014,
-0.7438367009,
0.1016016081,
0.1667797565,
0.3970727324,
0.0771634951,
-0.370565176,
0.3865713179,
0.2459254563,
-0.5317976475,
-0.7094450593,
0.3107146025,
-1.209045887,
-0.5530266166,
1.0502948761,
-0.2238131613,
-0.2328583002,
-0.0515916087,
-0.1685121506,
0.3216617107,
-0.7562834024,
0.5493998528,
0.6881713271,
-0.3141750991,
-0.415189445,
-0.7651853561,
0.1140504628,
0.2999877632,
-0.852650106,
0.1985141784,
0.6504996419,
0.1924024224,
-0.0375683382,
1.0986881256,
0.0416474491,
0.1115755513,
-0.1327639967,
0.1874898672,
-0.40993312,
-0.6475805044,
-0.353723228,
0.4055470228,
0.1724102497,
-0.4230076075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09980v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09980v1
|
Context Does Matter: Implications for Crowdsourced Evaluation Labels in Task-Oriented Dialogue Systems
| 2024-04-15T17:56:39 | 2024-04-15T17:56:39 |
Clemencia Siro, Mohammad Aliannejadi, Maarten de Rijke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR
|
Crowdsourced labels play a crucial role in evaluating task-oriented dialogue
systems (TDSs). Obtaining high-quality and consistent ground-truth labels from
annotators presents challenges. When evaluating a TDS, annotators must fully
comprehend the dialogue before providing judgments. Previous studies suggest
using only a portion of the dialogue context in the annotation process.
However, the impact of this limitation on label quality remains unexplored.
This study investigates the influence of dialogue context on annotation
quality, considering the truncated context for relevance and usefulness
labeling. We further propose to use large language models (LLMs) to summarize
the dialogue context to provide a rich and short description of the dialogue
context and study the impact of doing so on the annotator's performance.
Reducing context leads to more positive ratings. Conversely, providing the
entire dialogue context yields higher-quality relevance ratings but introduces
ambiguity in usefulness ratings. Using the first user utterance as context
leads to consistent ratings, akin to those obtained using the entire dialogue,
with significantly reduced annotation effort. Our findings show how task
design, particularly the availability of dialogue context, affects the quality
and consistency of crowdsourced evaluation labels.
|
[
-0.4759796858,
-0.2003041953,
0.6886067986,
0.3164415658,
-0.5901901722,
-0.2625944316,
-0.2808954716,
-0.6819375157,
0.0476156063,
0.6051468849,
-0.2568975985,
-0.3897970021,
-0.8716004491,
0.2905561328,
-0.0369998924,
1.2370232344,
0.1392736137,
-0.2147226334,
-0.4764043987,
-0.4697259367,
-0.3849030137,
-0.7748922706,
-0.3567736745,
-0.302408427,
0.5145620704,
0.2188937068,
0.919808805,
0.5513550043,
0.1418430954,
0.3224769533,
-0.4095717072,
-0.0156630203,
-0.4313659072,
0.4849141836,
-0.2565034032,
-0.12207748,
-0.3268075585,
0.2787344456,
0.4677343071,
0.8062795997,
0.1518746763,
0.3422456682,
0.3704882264,
0.16696316,
-0.6701149344,
0.4682731628,
-0.2947437167,
-0.0525363944,
-0.056812942,
-0.2357453257,
-0.2736749053,
-0.0550458096,
0.5723810196,
-0.7892647982,
-0.003600219,
-0.0071735047,
0.5985587239,
0.4778170586,
-0.3890156448,
-0.2268942147,
-0.6886819005,
0.8012689352,
-0.6775251627,
0.2355692685,
0.5021964312,
0.100781709,
0.0220569223,
-0.426976651,
-0.3997701108,
-0.2352104932,
-0.396561712,
0.0003610166,
0.0226413626,
0.4632139504,
0.50731951,
0.1243266985,
0.2612457871,
0.0360870399,
-0.2565871775,
-0.5053656101,
0.4823884368,
0.2438528985,
0.0979090407,
-0.5627939701,
-0.2937685847,
0.0411220603,
-0.4038033485,
0.3384282589,
0.0409293845,
0.2897104025,
0.1078492254,
0.4767610729,
-0.4131035507,
1.049679637,
0.0101675587,
-0.5124130249,
-0.003645286,
-0.5340678692,
-0.1845026612,
0.0239476506,
0.6375259161,
0.7130990624,
-0.1056385934,
-0.1094914675,
-0.2460207045,
-0.3920434415,
0.2587603331,
-0.7623394132,
0.1390313655,
0.0590493456,
-0.3978364766,
-0.0502276309,
0.07397715,
-0.1611697674,
-0.4817798436,
-0.7515512705,
0.3228636682,
0.0129736215,
0.1169967204,
-0.3854771852,
-0.2399996817,
-0.290314883,
0.7407622933,
-0.5869973898,
0.0103107486,
0.6546019316,
0.697522223,
-0.1275836229,
0.0180093106,
-0.6848749518,
0.1782983094,
-0.0932454839,
0.5596215129,
-0.7135164142,
-0.6622446775,
-0.0666334778,
-0.0323830694,
0.0412081294,
-0.5470176935,
0.6187376976,
-0.4018599689,
0.2319678515,
-0.533448875,
-0.4096257091,
-0.1405011117,
-0.0032624267,
-0.6441743374,
0.7573533654,
0.2231026292,
-0.6382018924,
0.7503125668,
-0.6299173832,
-0.5347306132,
0.3665241599,
-0.048122976,
-0.0349849425,
0.2300515771,
0.2704996467,
0.5528311133,
-0.1454321444,
0.5695754886,
-0.1700093001,
-0.5640701652,
0.6065672636,
-0.3778703511,
0.5198222399,
0.2882482409,
-0.6187776327,
0.0295461863,
-0.4040245116,
0.0391772613,
-0.5460128784,
-0.3763200343,
-0.5290921926,
0.0254110917,
0.2141382843,
0.3636039495,
-0.0827249214,
-0.5566608906,
-0.0707311928,
-0.0624380447,
0.4365674555,
0.7215269804,
0.1874573827,
0.3300978243,
-0.1797243804,
0.4189741611,
-0.1439367384,
0.1676742285,
-0.3035276532,
-0.6485393643,
-0.6943070889,
-0.4152309597,
0.4153815508,
0.295946002,
-0.590272963,
0.3999431133,
-0.2454236299,
-0.358628124,
-0.4829753041,
-0.105661951,
0.5550411344,
0.5617913008,
0.0977332219,
-0.5311353207,
-0.3939360976,
-1.070864439,
-0.3402924836,
-0.3749984801,
-0.2186035216,
0.7286446691,
0.3377794325,
-0.2100472152,
1.4483759403,
-0.1926615089,
-0.3147265017,
-0.0706192479,
0.1310789883,
-0.069662407,
0.3656679094,
0.3195769489,
-0.60230124,
0.0354361422,
-0.2850535214,
-0.4926573038,
-0.5356541276,
-0.1429729313,
-0.0876508579,
0.1483189464,
0.0656685308,
-0.4464354217,
0.6280187368,
0.4720391929,
-0.2167502195,
0.4055104256,
0.029844746,
0.5330042243,
-0.8391544223,
0.1310908794,
0.1001735479,
-0.309972167,
-0.5168744922,
-0.3443862796,
-0.3369124532,
-0.3234378994,
-0.3654612303,
0.7390666604,
-0.0652172863,
-0.2577963769,
-0.2284063101,
0.4611359239,
0.3789416254,
0.3164497912,
0.2719041407,
1.0922043324,
0.0763635188,
-0.5683725476,
-0.0915385112,
0.3186457455,
-0.7578914165,
0.706155479,
-0.6711258888,
0.1015304849,
0.0584908053,
0.6001349688,
-0.9728468657,
-0.3447680771,
0.4021922946,
-0.2417915165,
0.0106455432,
-0.0819385722,
-0.5893664956,
-0.02417982,
0.2006107271,
0.3945693672,
0.0879026428,
-0.4166949093,
0.1636119336,
0.6716578603,
-0.2092381567,
-0.3842543662,
-0.5142078996,
0.1881669909,
-0.1576442719,
-0.4933552146,
0.2055792212,
0.1721266508,
-0.3133264482,
-0.223597914,
-0.4066005945,
-0.0290251654,
0.2660767734,
0.6938518882,
-0.1540645659,
0.1928175688,
0.4120156169,
0.0095294248,
-0.0889176056,
0.0858436003,
-0.2087366134,
-0.095867835,
0.0202276986,
-0.3448211253,
-0.7801691294,
0.3690808117,
0.5181607008,
0.0176883545,
0.6215058565,
0.4492154717,
-0.0826345906,
0.3057802618,
-0.7978374958,
-0.1177900806,
-0.4319582283,
0.3722159863,
-0.2800282538,
-1.386111021,
0.3992938101,
-0.075466834,
-0.0232443791,
0.3706787229,
0.2869294286,
-0.2353292853,
0.8024536967,
0.3135201037,
-0.0126458667,
0.6154692769,
0.0715598166,
0.2247217447,
-1.1595138311,
-0.2502970099,
-0.5572983027,
-0.2326959372,
-0.3097730279,
-0.5715988874,
0.5873504281,
0.0706519485,
-0.0639405772,
0.2198964655,
-0.6446166039,
0.3028372824,
0.4525381029,
0.150962919,
0.4009469748,
0.0469282679,
0.1756762862,
-0.2155371755,
-0.59263134,
-1.0269947052,
0.7657750249,
0.2789045274,
0.2367008328,
-0.0573459901,
0.6343272328,
0.5786476135,
0.6076661944,
-0.5091151595,
0.529900074,
0.4559415281,
-0.733328104,
-0.4470822215,
-0.2606892586,
-0.8680770993,
0.4981867969,
0.1311929822,
-1.1528817415,
0.2570832074,
-0.0091039622,
-0.445532918,
-0.0440937988,
-0.6676343083,
0.7598292232,
0.0920168161,
-0.2495399266,
0.0002253712,
-0.6341816187,
0.089409478,
0.0227577165,
0.3981980979,
-0.347173214,
-0.0788727105,
1.0930210352,
-0.6714912653,
1.1154624224,
-0.295512706,
-0.2461152822,
0.6691582203,
-0.078128837,
0.3032274246,
0.4385001361,
-0.2649265528,
0.3621511757,
-0.0069794618,
-0.2499141991,
-0.6566873789,
0.5102307796,
-0.8019273281,
-1.1773432493,
-0.2408454716,
-0.4462519288,
-0.22684668,
-0.0922084227,
0.1609811485,
0.655690074,
0.0833581313,
0.1572569609,
0.3763718009,
-0.0876311511,
0.1830886304,
0.1858520806,
0.1815833598,
-0.3282458782,
0.6214310527,
0.2158231586,
0.4801216125,
-0.0186987687,
-0.0446248613,
-0.1998448819,
-0.1765226126,
-0.5412201285,
-0.1532589197,
-0.9905340075,
-0.1767840087,
-0.6029381156,
0.1147907823,
-0.2423709482,
-0.031714309,
-0.11359182,
-0.5401545167,
-0.3714519143,
-0.172107473,
0.2763350308,
0.6464626193,
-0.0959283039,
0.3965869248,
-0.7055799365,
-0.0592214651,
0.4676978886,
0.3391662538,
-0.084285289,
-0.5751129985,
-0.4261880517,
0.280326128,
-0.1708143055,
-0.8242097497,
-0.1614564657,
-0.0450431779,
0.6355707049,
0.3367471695,
0.1385457516,
0.7070091963,
-0.079584308,
1.0618480444,
-0.0286960751,
-1.188035965,
0.4908319414,
-0.4813347459,
0.6718258858,
0.8218499422,
-0.1118798405,
-0.7445881367,
-0.6148671508,
-0.3208119571,
-0.8433506489,
1.0307115316,
0.5679955482,
0.214397639,
-0.0603109524,
0.3393557072,
0.2108905464,
0.3170656264,
-0.6119792461,
-0.2819641232,
-0.3140933514,
0.4042001367,
-0.1364592314,
-0.563046217,
-0.3845475316,
-0.2464235425,
0.3726170361,
0.0690799505,
0.2515822351,
0.4262195528,
-0.1693282574,
-0.0670254678,
0.5869407654,
0.7360242009,
0.9125730991,
0.0108316783,
-0.2285254598,
0.1817494482,
-0.0952795744,
0.1771559268,
0.1113834754,
-0.1586705297,
0.2587022185,
0.4419021904,
1.0952746868,
0.477704227,
-0.6472164989,
0.4142079949,
0.111574918,
0.1408307105,
-0.0048141596,
0.0509826094,
-0.2140704989,
0.2612723112,
0.6883180141,
0.0529114418,
0.423489213,
-0.3240613341,
0.0540761761,
0.3451868594,
-0.5960652828,
-0.085545145,
0.4539515674,
0.5987762809,
-0.39145872,
0.4039628506,
-0.1503112763,
-0.7021489143,
0.5741336942,
0.179386273,
0.703713119,
-0.1769352704,
0.3714580834,
0.2123954892,
0.2506979704,
0.222379148,
-0.3538673222,
-0.7968342304,
-0.3066540658,
-0.79612571,
-0.5516023636,
-0.7819873095,
-0.1419747472,
-0.6672884822,
-0.2465107739,
-0.1445316672,
-0.609375596,
-0.2490319014,
-0.2916944325,
-0.7872089744,
0.5131725669,
0.3836759329,
0.3933166862,
-0.6450031996,
0.349899292,
0.6134838462,
-0.000852741,
-0.7265579104,
0.0483461954,
-0.0400254391,
-0.250266999,
0.989867568,
0.5047104359,
-0.150128141,
-0.3446635306,
-0.3425583243,
-1.1365132332,
0.8874276876,
0.1649108082,
-0.395871073,
0.3175623417,
0.2340986878,
0.7261262536,
-0.4737432599,
0.5846441388,
0.460636735,
0.6588788033,
0.0578881316,
-1.393764019,
0.2636922002,
-0.1074346155,
0.3311715126,
0.0059572593,
-0.5305997133,
0.2343957722,
-0.1858792007,
-0.4283704758,
0.0191974249,
0.5169989467,
0.337038815,
0.3894358575,
0.5011864305,
0.2263948619,
0.4948444366,
-0.3922584355,
1.2289108038,
-0.1706165522,
0.3042173386,
1.0548480749,
-0.0983532444,
0.3389872611,
0.5987645984,
-0.1645915806,
0.4477870464,
0.7629947662,
0.3339655995,
0.3452289104,
0.4251849949,
-0.3602908552,
-0.4536044598,
-0.6231437325,
-0.3960067332,
0.4445364773,
0.4792439938,
-0.4315014482,
-0.1299172789,
0.1555462629,
-0.0188863315,
-0.124606885,
-0.1083224639,
0.8030629158,
-0.0739328563,
-0.8986497521,
0.4327390194,
-0.1011357903,
0.3039777279,
-0.0784528181,
0.0234890841,
-0.0522590317,
-0.4015522003,
-0.2706305087,
-0.7178019285,
0.1701722294,
-0.1111787558,
-0.1948169917,
-0.441912204,
0.4313347042,
-0.1675821543,
-0.2728323936,
0.0054920455,
0.3638873696,
0.2786269784,
-0.1414627284,
-0.2946431935,
0.4046660364,
-0.0825064331,
-0.5498023629,
0.2655137479,
0.4707629085,
-0.1375408024,
0.4792072177,
0.4853720069,
-0.4145472348,
-0.3685155809,
0.0563819185,
1.0087945461,
-0.5447368026,
-0.2480657548,
-0.5609089732,
0.6941512227,
-0.3059784174,
-0.4236938953,
0.6238179207,
0.4328258634,
0.7624207735,
0.1105637997,
0.9086824059,
-0.050516285,
0.2709220946,
-0.2177883387,
0.6142600775,
-0.3916974366,
0.3170601428,
-0.6646277308,
-1.0556455851,
-0.1760043502,
0.5276721716,
-0.5906165242,
0.273344785,
0.3968234658,
0.3025296628,
0.2526355982,
0.1353808641,
0.3629939556,
-0.1499870867,
0.25716272,
0.2492045015,
0.853499651,
-0.2515880167,
0.530695498,
-0.2679528594,
-0.201130107,
-0.3711375892,
-0.8405719399,
-0.9226813316,
-0.8297786117,
-0.5339801311,
-0.2607227266,
0.1316489279,
0.7653980255,
0.8871423006,
-0.5648123622,
-0.1153876185,
0.4776057303,
0.1979805827,
0.0293355919,
-0.3264436722,
0.2092041075,
-0.3851984441,
-0.7995354533,
0.1851169765,
0.4957995117,
-0.1681263149,
-0.0496940725,
-0.0693909973,
0.3081636131,
-0.1865638345,
0.7946357131,
0.0348185189,
-1.3187288046,
-0.6415196657,
-0.3113814592,
-0.3171510696,
0.0307802744,
0.9422956705,
-0.9827818871,
0.8715443611,
0.0752810687,
0.4618015885,
0.3026124239,
0.4094777405,
0.7164844871,
-0.6403208375,
0.1881138533,
0.2855932415,
0.1530946642,
0.4202190936,
-0.429166764,
0.3917111754,
0.0865483433,
-0.6393916011,
-0.6067415476,
0.1726101488,
-0.9195656776,
-0.046692688,
1.5046169758,
-0.3946701884,
-0.0156928785,
-0.4228744805,
-0.5867995024,
0.3034007847,
-0.7222912908,
0.7703403831,
0.9944527149,
-0.1284397393,
-0.0341886245,
-0.5062457323,
0.6075151563,
0.6018624902,
-0.4546713531,
0.1073555797,
0.7517110705,
0.1243856624,
0.3994086385,
0.5834336281,
0.2055490166,
0.2091670483,
-0.5104272366,
-0.1154454648,
-0.1044931486,
0.0917005464,
-0.1001903713,
0.1362133324,
0.104115881,
0.0223147701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09971v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09971v1
|
Constructing Benchmarks and Interventions for Combating Hallucinations in LLMs
| 2024-04-15T17:48:46 | 2024-04-15T17:48:46 |
Adi Simhi, Jonathan Herzig, Idan Szpektor, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) are susceptible to hallucination, which sparked
a widespread effort to detect and prevent them. Recent work attempts to
mitigate hallucinations by intervening in the model's computation during
generation, using different setups and heuristics. Those works lack separation
between different hallucination causes. In this work, we first introduce an
approach for constructing datasets based on the model knowledge for detection
and intervention methods in closed-book and open-book question-answering
settings. We then characterize the effect of different choices for
intervention, such as the intervened components (MLPs, attention block,
residual stream, and specific heads), and how often and how strongly to
intervene. We find that intervention success varies depending on the component,
with some components being detrimental to language modeling capabilities.
Finally, we find that interventions can benefit from pre-hallucination steering
direction instead of post-hallucination. The code is available at
https://github.com/technion-cs-nlp/hallucination-mitigation
|
[
-0.4682536423,
-1.0380132198,
0.6510474086,
0.0966000706,
-0.0877172947,
-0.1986893862,
-0.441101402,
-0.2845566571,
0.2428312004,
0.8443212509,
-0.5415711999,
-0.6113299727,
-0.5683239102,
0.1604807079,
-0.3176545203,
0.7278818488,
-0.0973370075,
0.1699831039,
-0.2192254961,
0.1115381271,
-0.7215287089,
-0.7083168626,
-0.5370265245,
-0.1583123058,
0.6943473816,
0.2653231323,
0.4724439979,
0.360044241,
0.5357819796,
0.2198849171,
-0.1142286807,
0.3307763934,
-0.76487571,
0.446600616,
0.0214614421,
-0.325853318,
-0.1685582846,
-0.167867735,
0.605707705,
0.8500649333,
-0.3735689521,
-0.1290969551,
0.3062928915,
0.4941821694,
-0.7814826965,
-0.0774625912,
-0.7681075931,
0.1771635264,
-0.1031545028,
-0.3535424173,
-0.501529038,
-0.3877003491,
-0.1989594847,
-0.1577781588,
0.1731155813,
0.0040794443,
0.5092754364,
0.5915285349,
-0.0783216804,
-0.5261822939,
-0.7601006031,
0.7425578237,
-0.7698611021,
0.4892601967,
0.5573948026,
0.1396765411,
-0.5069885254,
-0.4559398293,
-0.3039834201,
-0.2133136541,
-0.1112411618,
-0.2151007503,
-0.1176247522,
-0.0382767208,
0.5980665684,
0.1082112119,
-0.5679726005,
0.2527886629,
-0.337872386,
-0.3401796222,
0.410051316,
0.3109870553,
0.1052226871,
-0.1518140286,
-0.0189015195,
0.0105386404,
-0.909634769,
-0.1647951752,
0.4770012498,
0.3651956916,
0.3008013964,
0.8104169369,
-0.1749307513,
0.4611453414,
-0.1514652818,
0.0256247725,
0.1684388816,
-0.1823168844,
-0.2360641956,
0.0699154139,
0.5472569466,
0.3014089167,
0.3995871842,
-0.5538367629,
-0.5023947954,
0.0568584651,
0.5682605505,
-0.8052477837,
-0.1000227705,
0.50559479,
-0.3547715545,
-0.3154781759,
-0.1548192501,
-0.887883842,
-0.7881780267,
-0.4548536837,
0.4968380928,
-0.2696957886,
-0.3440502286,
0.3070870638,
0.0515571274,
0.3738547862,
-0.0636431202,
-0.7905086875,
0.4678267241,
0.7064176202,
0.7181881666,
-0.4274778068,
-0.2769509256,
-0.7349257469,
0.1459719837,
-0.4231592417,
0.8663595319,
-0.4854699671,
-0.4220472574,
0.4095815122,
0.0924226791,
-0.1181762815,
-0.9718391895,
0.5684019327,
-0.3045583665,
0.0474236496,
-0.4945038855,
-0.6620213389,
-0.0516971834,
0.1791172624,
-0.6641773582,
0.9391633272,
-0.1915501654,
-0.7730916142,
0.0765336454,
-0.3851807714,
-0.4380179048,
-0.0766149908,
-0.3355195224,
-0.3453106284,
0.5088765621,
0.3373716474,
0.6321948171,
-0.1414483637,
0.4321653843,
-0.0739494339,
-0.5890585184,
0.3077190816,
-0.225175336,
0.3572221398,
-0.141463235,
-0.4403832555,
0.481128931,
-0.7462334633,
-0.2159447521,
0.1524188817,
0.125519082,
-0.3755760491,
0.1640431881,
-0.0840557888,
-0.1701957583,
0.0532234274,
-0.1053771675,
0.0724416152,
-0.253251195,
-0.0174336284,
0.7337582111,
0.3425546587,
-0.0868772864,
-0.347270906,
0.5982507467,
0.1105239913,
0.0863175541,
0.0440449938,
-0.2584390938,
-0.7774111032,
-0.1850512922,
-0.023063248,
0.3014955223,
-0.8453432322,
0.5265296102,
0.006058454,
-0.2333283573,
-0.3208911717,
0.0502500571,
0.4580436349,
0.4341878593,
0.4631797075,
-0.1862063706,
-0.646959126,
-0.7986664176,
-0.072226584,
0.059209872,
-0.1315269172,
0.1446355283,
0.4615657628,
-0.2373197079,
0.5209671259,
-0.5448554754,
-0.3230622709,
-0.1456152052,
0.1202285588,
0.0491474569,
0.2412394881,
0.2641813457,
-0.4133979082,
-0.1050626412,
-0.3083173335,
-0.9338153005,
-0.3529874384,
-0.1524880677,
-0.1404675692,
0.3029457331,
0.91631037,
-0.4671232104,
0.4874074459,
0.2677655518,
-0.0604490787,
0.8015736938,
0.0134744467,
0.1449325383,
-0.8799844384,
0.0074726148,
-0.1728376597,
0.1122875437,
-0.9535387158,
0.0460804254,
-0.289200604,
0.214026466,
-0.2625419796,
0.2047339082,
-0.278087765,
-0.0940348953,
-0.3838029802,
0.389796108,
-0.4505027235,
0.5582834482,
0.3249645531,
0.8067037463,
0.3889268339,
-0.5600063205,
-0.030426722,
0.141265884,
-0.5096188188,
0.2384213358,
-0.6695374846,
0.3495082855,
-0.1062890366,
-0.2761593461,
-0.8890598416,
-0.1580376923,
0.5351884365,
-0.1382519752,
0.1292775422,
0.2432973385,
-0.5881137848,
-0.1751897633,
-0.4933517277,
0.2576311827,
0.1967998743,
-0.5404300094,
0.6318296194,
0.3293068111,
-0.1486393064,
-0.4852977395,
-0.3059062958,
0.1580461115,
-0.3540503681,
-0.3775268197,
0.1915471256,
-0.3715568483,
-0.3958305717,
-0.1955093145,
0.047745131,
0.3447939754,
0.1087627262,
0.2474407405,
0.1017700285,
-0.1340436786,
0.2844571471,
0.1190413982,
-0.1140959859,
0.2841499448,
0.0491531976,
0.9463287592,
0.1543763578,
-0.511554122,
-0.263360858,
0.3518272638,
0.3690814376,
-0.1492655724,
0.8535761237,
0.4520184398,
-0.5907706618,
-0.3849556744,
-0.8303315639,
-0.6090536714,
-0.432718277,
0.4703212976,
-0.5439233184,
-0.6912831068,
0.5602399707,
0.0375183038,
-0.0003942498,
-0.0810712129,
1.0673834085,
0.3146540225,
0.8506243229,
0.5235946178,
-0.0916447043,
0.2406630963,
0.030219825,
0.4384782314,
-0.9423473477,
-0.2678737342,
-0.4724890888,
-0.1048008129,
-0.455150485,
-0.5131607056,
0.2383915037,
0.2332988977,
0.032430727,
0.2370842546,
-0.6042968035,
0.3752734363,
0.2615869641,
0.1498448849,
0.2825930417,
0.0780762583,
-0.1507471651,
-0.2120798528,
-0.5092542171,
-0.6132478118,
1.1179425716,
0.3200572133,
0.6954858303,
0.015585348,
0.8644170761,
0.1463133991,
0.273488313,
-0.6466914415,
0.7866305113,
0.2795837224,
-0.2721942961,
-0.4361376464,
-0.3681318164,
-0.8737455606,
0.3539876938,
-0.1356494129,
-1.0504288673,
0.1469735354,
-0.1379612684,
-0.2042950988,
0.1198022068,
-0.5017132759,
0.7246108055,
-0.0883244053,
-0.430515945,
-0.2490068525,
-0.206590116,
0.4177185297,
-0.1997129768,
0.1146494374,
0.0601315238,
0.0739709288,
0.5569660664,
-0.0489919409,
0.9680956006,
-0.1281543821,
-0.4061406851,
0.0701609924,
0.1175832301,
0.6120591164,
-0.1180302277,
-0.0438445844,
0.1312467009,
-0.1075049043,
-0.1026781648,
-0.52098912,
0.6127226353,
-0.4861852527,
-0.8274808526,
-0.2006108761,
-0.8564392328,
-0.4249093235,
-0.1070729867,
0.125175029,
0.2093862742,
-0.2962935567,
0.287106663,
0.9735623598,
-0.3712053895,
0.3130696714,
0.4751078784,
-0.6225771308,
-0.3865552247,
0.8233502507,
0.0552926511,
0.1924340576,
-0.0031736223,
0.2291207612,
-0.1338008046,
-0.8952738643,
0.1611621529,
0.4493320286,
-0.8334418535,
-0.0527789295,
-0.6260824203,
-0.4622936547,
-0.6541512012,
0.1911689639,
-0.0500660129,
0.034512125,
-0.3441978693,
-0.0984851196,
0.197361663,
0.6674446464,
-0.0676653907,
0.1494825929,
-0.3417600989,
0.4546990693,
0.0141190272,
0.3155902624,
0.280018419,
-0.5706125498,
-0.3176380694,
-0.2430244386,
-0.1072272286,
-0.8225345016,
0.4094566107,
-0.2557163537,
0.6993576884,
0.5459307432,
0.1307741851,
0.5995687246,
-0.5585224628,
0.5430037975,
0.0128124095,
-0.7909607887,
0.3399870098,
-0.1359017789,
0.1807892919,
0.4350161254,
0.4938973784,
-0.596314013,
-0.761210382,
-0.1508317739,
-0.688120544,
0.4376143515,
0.3996447921,
-0.1000364572,
-0.0392338559,
0.4073889256,
0.114942126,
0.4205287099,
-0.7577276826,
0.0621405169,
0.1314702183,
-0.1689423621,
-0.0499181598,
-0.4595614672,
-0.3797297478,
-0.1755529791,
0.7532659173,
-0.0783409998,
-0.0199460052,
-0.0108310478,
-0.1917581856,
-0.127481088,
-0.0279957224,
0.8083136678,
0.5737782121,
-0.2432863265,
0.1219509467,
-0.0193343218,
-0.4443390369,
-0.2689942122,
0.104537189,
-0.2687118351,
-0.1629536003,
0.5503991246,
0.7755904794,
0.1184782609,
-0.9030029178,
0.1248227581,
-0.1242888719,
-0.2391767204,
-0.2424197346,
0.1540173888,
0.142787084,
0.4661882818,
0.090909414,
-0.5978724957,
0.0693149492,
-0.3865099251,
0.1642180085,
0.5983628631,
-0.3381353319,
-0.1594489068,
0.4571421742,
-0.1643918008,
-0.6273918152,
0.5463525057,
0.0091344137,
-0.5489788651,
0.4943237305,
0.5260456204,
1.1245341301,
-0.3336943388,
0.0745377019,
0.2680129111,
0.5338546634,
0.0668914616,
0.5110056996,
-0.0309628155,
-0.8727560043,
-0.1605082154,
-0.5772296786,
-0.3125606179,
0.5524839759,
-0.6845555305,
0.3647414148,
-0.214626953,
-0.0031015601,
-0.0140196756,
-0.1841023862,
-0.46848616,
-0.2257300615,
0.2741016746,
0.6313889623,
-0.859018147,
0.7791468501,
0.2242869586,
-0.56010741,
-0.4456562698,
0.5334854722,
-0.1547059268,
-0.5990806222,
0.3749922216,
0.2898636758,
-0.2408167571,
-0.036292132,
-0.5775026679,
-0.5363265276,
0.730302155,
0.0153593691,
-0.6971212626,
0.100956507,
0.4609566331,
0.6555743814,
-0.4070816934,
-0.0586114116,
0.9091802239,
0.507796526,
-0.0323179513,
-0.5103110075,
0.2087240815,
-0.0122840796,
-0.0247640107,
0.1515131444,
-0.0907809585,
0.4181195498,
-0.0612990335,
-0.0406026766,
0.2652934194,
0.4790843129,
0.5350023508,
0.1692909896,
0.586797297,
0.4079397321,
0.9062489867,
-0.0303560365,
0.7724568248,
-0.4761004448,
-0.0299327094,
1.1701698303,
-0.5899586082,
0.9451188445,
0.8969130516,
0.0795566216,
0.1411570013,
0.5685765743,
-0.1515040994,
0.6157889962,
0.5667311549,
-0.2407115251,
-0.2786503136,
-0.3692803681,
-0.4147664607,
0.1204379946,
0.4596737325,
-0.1384146959,
0.0493481308,
0.4171093404,
-0.1271915734,
0.187339291,
0.0840313882,
0.8237885237,
0.1123430282,
-0.7017558813,
0.7182039022,
-0.2405730337,
0.2785661519,
-0.443313539,
-0.1454139203,
-0.4000560045,
0.1449364871,
-0.0342570692,
-0.4144725502,
0.3185593188,
-0.0464152321,
-0.2084355354,
0.0713931024,
0.5845609307,
-0.6455770135,
-0.4438268542,
0.498860985,
0.5158420801,
0.3415349722,
-0.1583113074,
-0.2859684825,
0.5331597924,
-0.0998791382,
-0.4532610774,
0.2928075492,
0.400226444,
-0.1811244935,
0.4926407337,
0.5190074444,
0.2016842663,
0.0162062664,
0.6793757677,
1.0118129253,
-0.6575398445,
-0.0993583277,
-0.720985651,
0.2363360673,
-0.1034428552,
-0.1530954242,
0.739282608,
0.5543161631,
0.6225660443,
-0.1172106117,
0.4310836494,
0.2382501215,
0.4848909974,
-0.7298962474,
0.5957127213,
-0.6589638591,
0.6323247552,
-0.2023002505,
-1.0260646343,
-0.4855730534,
0.4370939434,
-0.3498668373,
-0.0527398027,
0.8483790159,
1.3944218159,
0.271713227,
0.0367463417,
0.5722200274,
0.3956404328,
0.3619659543,
0.3478309512,
1.0376788378,
-0.1251822859,
0.3895174265,
-0.2574922144,
-0.1376300752,
-0.1703266501,
-0.7431662679,
-1.314404726,
-0.5007331371,
-0.2190142572,
-0.3569581807,
0.3095130622,
0.8018403649,
0.2556243837,
-0.9746101499,
-0.522821188,
-0.1780145317,
0.2608591616,
-0.2470707595,
-0.1696676612,
0.567935884,
-0.6624225974,
-0.6599727869,
0.4080818295,
0.2251257598,
-0.2284681499,
-0.682654202,
-0.0694115907,
-0.1157788411,
0.3012179136,
0.632976532,
-0.0844726562,
-0.9010038376,
-0.2279169858,
0.2081621885,
-0.0512274727,
0.0340252556,
1.0979385376,
-0.6608623266,
0.3263821304,
0.2979832888,
0.7169818878,
0.2544796765,
-0.2473885715,
0.5112324357,
-0.5728468895,
0.1905148029,
0.2742789984,
0.3196454346,
0.3009285629,
-0.3544919491,
0.7079819441,
0.0897256956,
-0.5119011998,
-1.3145074844,
0.0474092662,
-0.5637209415,
-0.4760417044,
1.1887464523,
0.1814351976,
-0.0593312941,
-0.1311453879,
-0.2269318998,
0.166400671,
0.0375634693,
1.2703002691,
1.014985919,
-0.0054364437,
-0.1565002352,
-0.6300650239,
0.5440604091,
0.4811107814,
-1.088944912,
0.4422995448,
0.5044060349,
-0.2258358151,
0.1393454522,
0.3906220198,
-0.0552858673,
-0.0207180474,
-0.0871400386,
0.3423877358,
0.154592976,
-0.6594605446,
-0.5668668747,
0.1486410499,
-0.0881083906,
-0.0019590945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09956v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09956v2
|
Tango 2: Aligning Diffusion-based Text-to-Audio Generations through Direct Preference Optimization
| 2024-04-15T17:31:22 | 2024-04-16T12:12:39 |
Navonil Majumder, Chia-Yu Hung, Deepanway Ghosal, Wei-Ning Hsu, Rada Mihalcea, Soujanya Poria
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Generative multimodal content is increasingly prevalent in much of the
content creation arena, as it has the potential to allow artists and media
personnel to create pre-production mockups by quickly bringing their ideas to
life. The generation of audio from text prompts is an important aspect of such
processes in the music and film industry. Many of the recent diffusion-based
text-to-audio models focus on training increasingly sophisticated diffusion
models on a large set of datasets of prompt-audio pairs. These models do not
explicitly focus on the presence of concepts or events and their temporal
ordering in the output audio with respect to the input prompt. Our hypothesis
is focusing on how these aspects of audio generation could improve audio
generation performance in the presence of limited data. As such, in this work,
using an existing text-to-audio model Tango, we synthetically create a
preference dataset where each prompt has a winner audio output and some loser
audio outputs for the diffusion model to learn from. The loser outputs, in
theory, have some concepts from the prompt missing or in an incorrect order. We
fine-tune the publicly available Tango text-to-audio model using diffusion-DPO
(direct preference optimization) loss on our preference dataset and show that
it leads to improved audio output over Tango and AudioLDM2, in terms of both
automatic- and manual-evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.4417952001,
-0.4980733395,
0.7126401067,
0.3682257831,
-0.2480002791,
-0.0795231536,
-0.1579866111,
-0.0446043722,
0.1051199362,
0.3290786147,
-0.8894196749,
-0.3023836911,
-0.6165734529,
-0.0492319576,
-0.2059605122,
0.9923856854,
0.2823302746,
0.0613557696,
-0.423551023,
0.0123738972,
-0.9367243648,
0.148566097,
-0.8677191734,
-0.3904957175,
0.3836510777,
0.6133170128,
0.5242262483,
0.5740271211,
0.0606226698,
0.1107685193,
-0.1420334876,
0.2694586515,
-0.5229876041,
0.3516700268,
0.0632009134,
-0.0612540394,
-0.5042189956,
0.1373349577,
0.545820415,
0.2858571112,
-0.1411919296,
0.2588844001,
0.1391387433,
0.9969857335,
-0.3155204356,
-0.3474932313,
-0.6131356359,
0.4253739119,
-0.0482494384,
-0.5528810024,
-0.609773159,
-0.4869819582,
0.0372744836,
-0.8436120749,
0.2273775935,
0.0265659429,
0.5477671027,
0.3775734007,
-0.4867860973,
-0.4801145792,
-1.0593214035,
0.6305150986,
-0.3185783327,
0.2483879924,
0.3072243631,
0.2713273466,
-0.1702999473,
-0.4054597318,
-0.5995827317,
0.0446373671,
0.3691875935,
0.4388646781,
-0.2046156824,
-0.0329497159,
-0.0615273304,
0.3853190243,
-0.5875874758,
0.108420521,
0.030926222,
-0.1466789991,
0.601839304,
0.0798938647,
0.2106388062,
-0.093951039,
-0.3288355172,
-0.1552234888,
-0.6075356603,
0.0958610475,
0.808408618,
0.1966727823,
-0.116486378,
0.667332828,
0.1608542949,
0.6534785032,
0.4404426515,
-0.2950505614,
0.4515939355,
-0.5784828067,
0.1068976298,
0.1928958744,
1.0620903969,
0.5294972658,
-0.1342304945,
0.0496899784,
-0.3122628927,
0.0071019814,
0.0615292303,
-0.5689595938,
-0.0266246721,
0.3609421849,
-0.1093486845,
-0.3972673416,
-0.2234965563,
-0.9880868793,
-0.5907130837,
-0.4070737958,
0.6191431284,
-0.3008478284,
-0.3083762228,
0.1453278512,
-0.4581669569,
-0.2186906487,
0.369214505,
-0.9198645353,
0.1142913476,
0.5638846159,
0.9773729444,
-0.4133461714,
0.2798594236,
-0.8247959614,
0.2084310651,
-0.4358606935,
0.6206942201,
-0.4769122601,
-0.6960440278,
-0.0550300293,
-0.5745198727,
0.1363059729,
-0.5325779915,
0.7720165849,
-0.2599785626,
0.5921350718,
-0.0308029987,
-0.4723140001,
0.3433552086,
-0.2706031799,
-0.5194346905,
1.295992732,
-0.1153948754,
-0.5794022083,
0.4834442139,
-0.6790500283,
-0.5343053937,
-0.3746145368,
-0.2130768746,
-0.6462246776,
-0.0132286437,
0.1130380556,
0.2995284796,
-0.5551874638,
0.5116484761,
-0.0847110599,
-0.1783623397,
0.2602015436,
-0.3776060641,
0.2935319543,
0.4124539793,
-0.5203983188,
0.0659834296,
-0.8706861734,
-0.3246615827,
0.1220611855,
-0.3903798163,
-0.2730431855,
0.3326485157,
0.1134374514,
0.2091994733,
-0.0644343495,
-0.4080826044,
0.1111251488,
-0.3824205995,
0.2863524854,
0.8107111454,
0.0484934002,
0.9258435369,
-0.3125143945,
0.6431003809,
0.075975582,
0.1507508904,
-0.2048920095,
-0.6793737411,
-0.3908025622,
-0.0792701691,
0.002723759,
0.3957144618,
-0.3850904107,
0.3514577746,
-0.1024106815,
-0.3399890661,
-0.5919601917,
0.2409974635,
0.1769874096,
0.8455886841,
0.2293876559,
-0.1622751504,
-0.509411633,
-0.8208043575,
0.2809460461,
-0.0322946496,
-0.1070761457,
0.7153452635,
-0.2689323425,
-0.2240560949,
1.1813317537,
-0.6934449673,
-0.2684222162,
-0.1693944931,
0.126989305,
0.3084978759,
0.61059618,
0.6728343368,
-0.8593000174,
-0.2852080166,
-0.1230633482,
-0.3284467459,
-0.3121493459,
-0.1374117285,
-0.4735275805,
-0.0184123162,
0.1785877645,
-0.4045664966,
-0.2347613275,
0.7347186804,
-0.3470928967,
0.5270292759,
-0.1100520045,
0.1082224473,
-1.2481460571,
-0.1078345925,
0.0654273927,
-0.0678414106,
-0.617426455,
-0.7037925124,
-0.2676179707,
-0.4670714736,
-0.2803759873,
0.5582860112,
-0.3124219775,
-0.2383436114,
-0.2078424245,
0.5487107635,
0.400413245,
0.227659747,
0.1653145105,
0.855958879,
0.6613359451,
-0.8666397333,
0.1718326509,
0.385815382,
-0.300770402,
0.3970119357,
-0.5637819171,
0.5177713633,
-0.1997764111,
0.1732946336,
-1.4732112885,
-0.0313146561,
0.2780511975,
-0.5954951048,
0.3745395243,
-0.1701956689,
-0.1869804859,
-0.1910887361,
-0.2178028822,
0.7431384921,
0.832922399,
-0.4850915372,
0.55030334,
0.340493679,
-0.3482782245,
-0.6307070851,
-0.3744620085,
-0.1921736002,
-0.4069613218,
-0.7575671077,
0.4347620308,
-0.2866550982,
-0.0897564664,
-0.1360011548,
-0.086955823,
0.0624105074,
-0.1296257973,
0.3264107108,
0.1649395227,
-0.2956495285,
0.3431335688,
0.4772638381,
-0.1239446104,
-0.1586644948,
-0.5104212165,
0.5978369713,
0.5829476714,
0.0022453305,
-0.4641160369,
0.1951025426,
0.4869790673,
-0.176805228,
0.2226197124,
0.5715606809,
0.3835652471,
-0.3834127784,
-0.3753049374,
0.053306561,
-0.4829589128,
0.1564099342,
-0.1711934954,
-0.5677267909,
0.2052214742,
-0.148982808,
0.033324793,
0.4983717203,
0.4505400658,
-0.25542593,
1.0248736143,
0.4276663959,
0.2693040669,
0.8874788284,
-0.3267890811,
-0.33205235,
-0.8790763617,
-0.366404444,
-0.4290138483,
-0.301094234,
-0.2676983774,
-0.5293912292,
0.2945936024,
-0.2673714161,
-0.0776873305,
0.2353310585,
-0.5715579391,
0.2887336314,
0.6640833616,
0.130393669,
0.1813758314,
0.1118649468,
-0.1763130873,
0.1129176095,
-0.7513448596,
-0.3163899779,
1.124271512,
0.3676144481,
0.5643396378,
0.2605952322,
0.6598253846,
0.674592793,
-0.2025174648,
-0.852195859,
0.3611407876,
-0.1278333664,
-0.3887880743,
-0.3086948693,
-0.4256714582,
-0.9187880158,
0.0647278354,
-0.434858501,
-0.2411091477,
0.2853806615,
0.3226826787,
-0.3308683932,
-0.1925994754,
-0.6591467261,
0.7000642419,
-0.0180569626,
-0.532613337,
-0.1569464952,
-0.4859965742,
0.3117969632,
-0.1540260613,
0.4840952754,
-0.4425956309,
0.0588884801,
0.6746234894,
-0.1869391054,
0.4434178472,
-0.2417629659,
-0.3428893685,
0.4450672269,
0.1954379082,
0.4669003189,
0.2924363315,
-0.2401022166,
-0.2890692651,
-0.4909974039,
-0.1728168726,
-0.6144707799,
0.4445196092,
-0.9152165651,
-0.5749437213,
0.027831167,
-0.3906520307,
-0.2520142496,
-0.0807024837,
0.6686468124,
0.7902772427,
-0.3088565171,
-0.149807632,
0.6903108358,
-0.3991063833,
0.5442767739,
0.2025731802,
-0.2323425412,
-0.7218002081,
0.8899919391,
-0.251282692,
0.4965010285,
0.3598937988,
0.5178121328,
-0.6098777056,
-0.6813778281,
-0.748049736,
0.0916837007,
-0.5619878769,
-0.0362802595,
-0.511752367,
0.3733080029,
-0.3335672617,
-0.1028084457,
-0.5085818768,
-0.5431454182,
-0.6459072828,
-0.1980506629,
0.3712429106,
0.5832736492,
-0.0795515329,
0.3829883933,
-0.7005547881,
0.3941979706,
0.2863815725,
0.1216131225,
-0.1959656477,
-0.8184785843,
-0.1418711841,
0.0779083222,
-0.3286345899,
-0.9730142951,
0.0458384529,
0.3827901185,
0.3362558484,
0.5469563007,
0.0617154017,
0.4109848142,
-0.6777644753,
0.7508810163,
0.5431669354,
-0.8473731279,
1.0224001408,
-0.64317137,
0.0488935262,
0.4709773362,
0.0527362935,
-0.5698745251,
-0.2045831829,
-0.4592438638,
-0.9637776613,
0.9037639499,
0.5818323493,
0.4254983068,
-0.1009938568,
0.3552616239,
0.4474470317,
0.3001762629,
-0.7217586637,
-0.3395902514,
-0.3942874968,
-0.2381028533,
-0.3848269582,
-0.3318291903,
-0.2746926546,
0.028782716,
0.7474065423,
0.0834159032,
0.2357255071,
0.1891648918,
0.2413343191,
-0.0870255306,
0.1552630812,
0.8022558093,
0.1476494968,
-0.0294373147,
0.0860695615,
-0.426296562,
-0.441890955,
0.7612897754,
-0.3237047791,
-0.4249112606,
0.1765046418,
-0.0730001554,
1.2325661182,
-0.1438461989,
-0.6113964319,
0.5090851188,
0.0344329923,
-0.148308903,
-0.3711889088,
0.2444875091,
-0.0589443967,
0.0518040098,
0.3773458004,
0.5125035048,
0.3591319025,
-0.457662344,
0.3495567143,
0.2610289156,
-0.4492866397,
-0.2649175823,
0.9976450205,
0.5448586941,
-0.4915010631,
0.3390861154,
-0.1592848301,
0.1595726907,
0.7771895528,
0.6221026778,
1.0346593857,
-0.1988208145,
0.5749722123,
0.5065033436,
-0.1884321719,
-0.1696095765,
-0.2731234729,
-0.3020720482,
-0.8647122979,
-0.2310493588,
-0.6844226122,
-0.2210455984,
-0.09007027,
-0.5765951276,
0.4825074375,
-0.3132979572,
-0.5721513629,
0.0280133709,
-0.5326622725,
-0.2567783296,
0.2572986782,
0.1276187748,
0.415158838,
-1.0031037331,
0.5663869977,
0.3879593611,
-0.3576055467,
-0.5901134014,
0.1486467719,
0.1080619991,
-0.5228616595,
0.5239685774,
-0.0437117592,
-0.3597186804,
0.1222543418,
-0.0783360973,
-0.8629231453,
1.0364753008,
0.4326298833,
-0.6728044748,
0.1143694595,
-0.00917337,
0.3603253067,
-0.539670825,
0.1121356785,
0.3062044084,
0.419531405,
0.7343896627,
-0.5270127654,
-0.2754651606,
-0.2893372476,
0.0061491206,
0.3877084553,
-0.4926075339,
0.5277699232,
-0.3309762776,
-0.2349532992,
-0.1432559937,
0.4595677853,
0.2757761478,
0.6937102079,
0.5727606416,
0.3352666199,
0.5948939919,
-0.1836084127,
1.0334063768,
0.0634281933,
0.1143419147,
1.1284530163,
-0.1932358146,
0.5288263559,
0.5138728619,
-0.1041181311,
0.285923183,
0.9268157482,
0.0358016193,
0.9204629064,
-0.0143059464,
-0.2760134041,
-0.1649203151,
-0.1618458331,
-0.3943039179,
0.2302556187,
-0.0493862368,
-0.3972018957,
0.3717937171,
0.28846699,
-0.0728458837,
0.1413481236,
-0.1299439818,
1.0688607693,
-0.238920629,
-0.8401028514,
0.2313769311,
-0.2932339311,
0.5381818414,
-0.4864678085,
0.1229194701,
-0.4472755492,
-0.1383492947,
-0.1223767549,
-0.7209184766,
0.1979670972,
-0.0488706306,
-0.4035832882,
-0.2679529786,
0.3013853133,
-0.6865519285,
-0.3042335808,
0.4959024489,
0.136897251,
0.0024232366,
0.1249312311,
-0.5048066974,
-0.002600631,
0.1537230462,
-0.2312709689,
0.1390921921,
0.4486998618,
0.4082891047,
0.3892897964,
0.6034882069,
0.0769802928,
-0.0363919064,
0.3323152959,
0.5045679212,
-0.1905281395,
-0.6356759071,
-0.9442154765,
0.6738903522,
0.0877349004,
-0.318034023,
0.5247408748,
0.8893121481,
0.4112986922,
-0.2044137716,
0.7129867077,
-0.0167540759,
0.2700871825,
-0.8813936114,
0.4047114849,
-0.8211186528,
0.3563098609,
-0.7879723907,
-1.19739604,
0.1437744647,
0.1423306316,
-0.0717189834,
-0.0817010626,
0.3775608838,
0.7630875111,
-0.0212943349,
-0.3612620831,
0.2489299178,
-0.2089771628,
0.2431636006,
0.4073162079,
0.9162724614,
-0.3853506744,
0.6657688022,
0.0122685218,
-0.0735486969,
-0.1704096645,
-0.8398889303,
-0.4898630381,
-0.8381317854,
-0.4564584196,
-0.4266445637,
-0.024588054,
0.7827625871,
0.5415613055,
-0.3465845883,
-0.2689907551,
-0.2706999481,
0.2114957273,
-0.1212718859,
-0.2077678889,
0.1867161095,
-0.1792306155,
-0.8852629066,
0.7295775414,
0.3767021596,
0.5284048319,
0.1157626435,
-0.5328040123,
0.1630998105,
0.3647849262,
0.7027898431,
-0.0645262152,
-0.5673630238,
-0.1592446417,
0.0341235362,
0.0864204094,
0.5526954532,
0.8431010842,
-0.3807301223,
0.6634334326,
0.5796422362,
0.3076678813,
0.7741042376,
0.2153142393,
0.879027307,
-1.0200837851,
0.3260715902,
0.1866267622,
0.1042444482,
0.3165361583,
-0.41674909,
0.4598715305,
0.2818182409,
-0.4507330656,
-0.6868350506,
0.4327738583,
-1.3685445786,
-0.1064194664,
1.5473897457,
0.2939366698,
0.2057260275,
0.033160679,
-0.6183090806,
0.3259661496,
-0.7806662917,
0.5772083998,
0.5008092523,
-0.2751840651,
-0.0953407586,
-0.2968996763,
0.791709125,
0.4387179017,
-0.4928668737,
0.014266747,
0.8962388039,
0.1929246336,
0.2145506144,
0.9224665165,
-0.0918937773,
0.3329210877,
0.0260274634,
0.0829095542,
-0.1785538048,
-0.4648450911,
-0.389259994,
0.1962478757,
0.1496513635,
-0.4638383687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09937v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09937v1
|
Compression Represents Intelligence Linearly
| 2024-04-15T17:03:41 | 2024-04-15T17:03:41 |
Yuzhen Huang, Jinghan Zhang, Zifei Shan, Junxian He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT
|
There is a belief that learning to compress well will lead to intelligence.
Recently, language modeling has been shown to be equivalent to compression,
which offers a compelling rationale for the success of large language models
(LLMs): the development of more advanced language models is essentially
enhancing compression which facilitates intelligence. Despite such appealing
discussions, little empirical evidence is present for the interplay between
compression and intelligence. In this work, we examine their relationship in
the context of LLMs, treating LLMs as data compressors. Given the abstract
concept of "intelligence", we adopt the average downstream benchmark scores as
a surrogate, specifically targeting intelligence related to knowledge and
commonsense, coding, and mathematical reasoning. Across 12 benchmarks, our
study brings together 30 public LLMs that originate from diverse organizations.
Remarkably, we find that LLMs' intelligence -- reflected by average benchmark
scores -- almost linearly correlates with their ability to compress external
text corpora. These results provide concrete evidence supporting the belief
that superior compression indicates greater intelligence. Furthermore, our
findings suggest that compression efficiency, as an unsupervised metric derived
from raw text corpora, serves as a reliable evaluation measure that is linearly
associated with the model capabilities. We open-source our compression datasets
as well as our data collection pipelines to facilitate future researchers to
assess compression properly.
|
[
-0.4230519533,
-0.3414297998,
0.6875950694,
-0.1510575116,
-0.0085176257,
0.1525765061,
-0.6847429276,
-0.3447499573,
0.1578407735,
0.1029994637,
-0.5207580924,
-0.3459799886,
-0.7670018077,
0.0773695931,
-0.6060090661,
0.8715450764,
0.4188237786,
0.0148220267,
-0.7119396925,
0.0087048467,
-0.3937162161,
-0.8752738237,
-0.1643810719,
-0.3498166203,
0.5283050537,
0.1763623059,
1.0610466003,
0.653226018,
0.6138826013,
0.3565070927,
0.0241667591,
-0.0036666451,
-0.7272936106,
0.1250050664,
-0.0461168103,
-0.5081255436,
-0.1392843425,
0.1511096954,
0.5798643231,
0.949201107,
-0.0968657285,
0.4603207111,
0.1807587743,
0.9003627896,
-0.4710482359,
0.1108527631,
-0.7196471691,
-0.2521982193,
-0.0960811004,
-0.3619382679,
-0.3956993222,
-0.5035166144,
-0.4200040102,
-0.356326282,
0.058141429,
0.2532411516,
0.8007336259,
0.8526360989,
0.0182874706,
-0.5359697342,
-0.659774065,
0.7161576152,
-0.5103808045,
0.3849542439,
0.1785500795,
0.1095131934,
-0.1232365817,
-0.5214794278,
-0.5959917307,
0.0622701496,
-0.0143285254,
-0.0809976161,
-0.305267483,
-0.1957166493,
0.4222899377,
0.5380195379,
-0.3440711796,
0.4044088125,
-0.6702564359,
-0.1294679046,
0.5436615348,
0.0399061628,
0.425550133,
0.0142064178,
-0.3584280312,
-0.2640064359,
-0.7309184074,
0.1984968781,
0.6762790084,
0.2320707291,
0.1466837823,
0.6135808825,
-0.1064706147,
0.4464896619,
-0.4864218831,
-0.1303257942,
0.2796743512,
-0.2145370692,
-0.2650050819,
-0.1005410478,
0.7887229919,
0.2023178786,
0.6710323691,
-0.4505783319,
-0.4212295711,
0.3794146478,
0.3397065401,
-0.8002427816,
-0.2600611746,
0.2634541392,
-0.5329747796,
-0.0433723219,
0.1499851942,
-0.6628758311,
-0.3300462961,
-0.6821161509,
0.2306037247,
-0.2219165266,
-0.0865432322,
0.2695325315,
-0.3029994071,
-0.1500002891,
-0.0226724483,
-0.9247097969,
0.4761309028,
1.0534530878,
0.7255535126,
-0.1303940117,
-0.167379573,
-0.4333732426,
-0.0817444548,
-0.4031452537,
1.1380518675,
-0.7232223153,
-0.2090279013,
0.2140384316,
-0.4199197888,
0.1155413687,
-0.646912694,
0.9471802711,
-0.3580504358,
0.0124183614,
-0.2571344674,
-0.610193491,
-0.0484986603,
-0.0428104475,
-0.7202703357,
1.1211521626,
0.1655624956,
-0.3932765424,
0.1719652712,
-0.2452786118,
0.0115031507,
0.1821834147,
-0.3546070158,
-0.1255507469,
0.5507947206,
0.2090585232,
0.6316446662,
-0.8491171598,
0.296625942,
-0.539534986,
-0.4355198741,
0.5927160382,
-0.4515312314,
0.4758383334,
0.0209641531,
0.4354026914,
-0.1681695729,
-0.5539188981,
0.1859565824,
-0.0371111147,
-0.696164608,
-0.2743690908,
0.0848961547,
-0.3760637343,
0.325725913,
0.2636127472,
-0.3958142698,
0.4728549421,
-0.1600361019,
0.3767799735,
0.7636214495,
-0.2437369674,
0.3121573329,
-0.7415128946,
0.1435031295,
-0.5802122951,
0.1247439981,
0.1243159771,
-0.3687593937,
-0.6624133587,
-0.5020487905,
0.3744302392,
0.4642335176,
-0.3107401133,
0.4845791459,
-1.0773799419,
-0.5336261988,
-0.559189558,
0.4355207384,
0.0658285841,
0.3294694722,
0.3841980398,
-0.0425885469,
-0.2790485024,
-0.8729148507,
-0.441154182,
-0.2352730185,
-0.4789834619,
0.2973392308,
0.4362336397,
0.0618065335,
0.6885579228,
-0.3741636276,
-0.1317874044,
-0.0533675626,
0.3633219004,
0.5779419541,
0.4242697358,
0.4916540384,
-0.5679476261,
-0.0350774191,
-0.604257226,
-0.6389892697,
-0.4107473791,
0.0813747495,
-0.0058254544,
-0.101817295,
0.4571685195,
-0.8712577224,
0.3793241978,
0.6871579289,
-0.1390700042,
0.5574716926,
-0.1932242215,
0.1530386358,
-0.5844996572,
-0.113022387,
-0.2660702467,
0.1528454721,
-0.608525753,
0.0601302236,
0.0357817113,
-0.1461179256,
-0.3521646261,
0.1093066186,
-0.4325042069,
-0.4576104879,
-0.1927263439,
0.1014736742,
0.0154997474,
0.6435030103,
-0.3306493163,
0.892082572,
0.4043614566,
-0.6200313568,
0.4767517149,
0.0829839632,
-0.7699713111,
0.2076658756,
-0.7166848779,
0.2859288752,
-0.2625999451,
0.0658914819,
-0.752019763,
-0.1539284885,
-0.3066531718,
-0.4761969447,
0.3537193835,
0.2410142869,
-0.9994293451,
-0.3075956106,
-0.4018435478,
0.327110678,
0.9184923768,
-0.4855077863,
0.5085053444,
0.2870976627,
-0.2746885717,
-0.2823142111,
-1.0359246731,
0.0980401337,
-0.3437289596,
-0.6274326444,
0.471793294,
-0.6265647411,
-0.5028472543,
0.143373698,
-0.0616980717,
0.1299726665,
0.1172400191,
0.279956758,
0.4397754669,
-0.0879479945,
0.4990782142,
-0.408550173,
0.1970088631,
0.3723411262,
-0.2223311812,
0.5891044736,
-0.0915250778,
-0.2711522281,
-0.1590656787,
0.2425238043,
0.6902406216,
0.1169035137,
0.994502008,
0.1043513194,
-0.1703327894,
-0.1681502163,
-0.5777645707,
-0.0469928756,
-0.4359454811,
-0.0747941509,
-0.1714600921,
-0.7308304906,
0.4269815683,
-0.3512982726,
-0.1230799481,
0.3827512264,
0.4663710296,
0.054451406,
0.8755101562,
0.5372945666,
-0.2299055606,
0.2238964885,
-0.1169948354,
0.2332001776,
-0.8298535943,
-0.263515234,
-0.9144410491,
-0.4346794784,
-0.4025323689,
-0.4698708951,
0.1994863451,
0.3351729512,
-0.3535215259,
-0.0387180187,
-0.4611897171,
0.5673695803,
0.3331632018,
-0.1628028005,
0.0280451439,
0.115198411,
0.1799475998,
0.0814799964,
-0.786393404,
-0.5565286875,
0.8918094039,
0.4988675714,
0.7415566444,
0.489445895,
0.3731284142,
0.4290552437,
0.2640596628,
-1.009121418,
0.536108911,
-0.3119775653,
-0.2357999533,
0.036679104,
-0.4990723729,
-0.8410645723,
-0.3149041533,
-0.4617181122,
-0.9009150863,
0.2979902923,
-0.3893989623,
-0.3068800271,
0.1720715016,
-0.6265621781,
0.2314975411,
-0.3512693346,
-0.3305447102,
-0.3929699063,
-0.3016027212,
0.3483189046,
-0.1814654768,
0.4813212156,
-0.4364875555,
-0.4529348314,
0.7316334248,
-0.3409948349,
0.5815750957,
0.3932628334,
0.1944780052,
-0.0950574502,
-0.0145196514,
0.2073317915,
-0.1843521893,
-0.3663591444,
0.4811357856,
-0.3681302667,
-0.5381432772,
-1.0522964001,
0.8232553601,
-0.8186240792,
-0.7843441367,
-0.1884089559,
-0.968775034,
-0.0972372815,
-0.1251510978,
0.0737296641,
0.8296211362,
0.36442101,
0.5146801472,
0.6559031606,
-0.1839693338,
0.5495461226,
0.4505974352,
-0.067479074,
-0.3086841702,
0.5802003145,
0.260242939,
0.3561739028,
0.4528394639,
0.2308209389,
-0.2878708541,
-0.7104777694,
-0.0805671439,
0.1829870194,
-1.0831769705,
-0.5487625003,
-0.3760060072,
-0.2412815541,
-0.5755441785,
-0.1009994373,
-0.1329063475,
-0.3848617971,
-0.1497411132,
0.0396587178,
0.3542689085,
0.9986672997,
0.1254807562,
-0.2022996098,
-0.8310781717,
0.2440278232,
0.2654972374,
0.2461451739,
-0.2002966255,
-0.5701813102,
-0.2183607519,
-0.0722145215,
0.1457799226,
-0.8325633407,
0.4289433062,
0.3421101868,
0.7384192348,
0.2377493382,
0.304505229,
0.6549915671,
-0.3694327772,
0.9913124442,
0.0116371587,
-0.7580912113,
0.2164930552,
0.0875701904,
0.4335811734,
0.4995836318,
0.6471097469,
-0.0997552946,
-0.2899810374,
-0.532684803,
-0.6722835898,
0.311524719,
0.07556393,
0.2979048491,
-0.0401585884,
0.3079711199,
0.0328584574,
0.3357785046,
-0.648480773,
-0.1153724119,
0.0301262364,
-0.4559668899,
0.0118746357,
-0.2953133583,
-0.0541847683,
-0.1257000566,
0.6096786261,
-0.0875672475,
0.3988529444,
0.0297730528,
0.005278789,
0.1917750984,
0.3446791172,
0.4092302322,
0.47711429,
-0.0054931906,
0.3650836349,
0.0016494776,
-0.2229948491,
-0.1086689085,
-0.0044591175,
0.2161457241,
-0.316516459,
0.5477509499,
0.6587607861,
0.2062588632,
-0.8052566051,
0.4425847232,
-0.2471851557,
-0.105327934,
-0.230633378,
0.1700539887,
0.0022495796,
0.2057210505,
0.6053159237,
0.3156245649,
0.024405513,
-0.760346055,
-0.1374418885,
0.4722104669,
-0.1711802632,
-0.0499633588,
0.2937921286,
0.0653419644,
-0.5233135223,
0.9245223403,
-0.0408199094,
-0.5731064677,
0.3812491298,
0.1999798715,
0.5108069181,
0.1782629937,
-0.3863838017,
0.3008962572,
0.3844365776,
-0.1519403309,
-0.003090641,
-0.178353563,
-0.6158128977,
-0.7099906802,
-0.7346498966,
0.0433344133,
0.3162384033,
-0.4702544212,
0.370559752,
-0.2236145735,
0.0468549766,
-0.1630072892,
0.1511666924,
-0.7927427888,
0.1105914637,
0.4225917459,
1.2783170938,
-0.6401703954,
0.9141628146,
0.2560643852,
-0.5354651809,
-1.0162060261,
0.1300278753,
0.0200266223,
-0.8264883161,
0.9165615439,
0.4125446975,
-0.1263874471,
-0.163254723,
-0.5647398829,
-1.1458622217,
0.9492515326,
0.669864893,
-0.4605456889,
0.0624906719,
0.2127649039,
0.5936550498,
-0.6147682667,
0.2316055596,
0.4815294147,
0.2910906971,
-0.0498256199,
-0.5632783771,
0.1118080318,
-0.5738907456,
-0.0339039899,
0.3035158813,
-0.4299642146,
0.7915412188,
0.11481224,
-0.5258967876,
0.1449438035,
0.6606934667,
-0.1001890749,
-0.060337346,
0.3891760707,
0.6967365742,
0.9246359468,
-0.1150761396,
1.3708275557,
-0.8340240121,
0.0183937158,
0.8365818858,
-0.0282718353,
1.0642794371,
0.4350476563,
-0.0230773501,
0.8763585687,
0.2324105799,
-0.1505013555,
0.2912326753,
0.2498404831,
-0.1554329544,
-0.1469664425,
-0.6054418087,
-0.0697921589,
0.2554450929,
0.5440967083,
-0.4212226272,
0.2134253383,
-0.2352376282,
0.0434864648,
0.5270938277,
-0.5532608032,
0.5971969962,
-0.1201821566,
-1.0982744694,
0.7657025456,
-0.3708469272,
0.5885059834,
-0.5402425528,
0.2231217325,
0.030906586,
-0.1477495879,
-0.2517285943,
-1.0768640041,
0.4728173018,
0.1239141598,
-0.3603902161,
-0.5466746688,
0.8077189326,
-0.3784059882,
-0.231297493,
0.3835844398,
0.4423830211,
0.55366081,
0.0868837908,
-0.5562438965,
0.509486258,
-0.3467623591,
-0.1332447529,
0.3287950456,
0.3254427016,
0.4248191416,
0.7169035077,
0.8702762127,
0.3456501067,
-0.1637036949,
0.3007003963,
1.1262435913,
-0.261590302,
-0.0240130145,
-0.9302017093,
0.2796730697,
-0.3344106674,
-0.1790484041,
0.6077745557,
0.5561224818,
0.7122550011,
0.1568433493,
0.6095302701,
0.1190553606,
0.4263308346,
-0.8034595251,
0.3772120774,
-0.3719685078,
0.6143033504,
0.203919664,
-0.7727048397,
-0.0701148435,
0.1176958308,
-0.5037254095,
-0.081615299,
0.6833463907,
0.8492282629,
0.0149959493,
-0.1357501298,
0.4198929369,
0.0240670424,
0.0668546185,
0.8428535461,
0.7915802598,
-0.1886894405,
0.7422401905,
-0.1395321935,
-0.0299907681,
0.0340302028,
-1.0459620953,
-1.0314193964,
-0.5071406364,
-0.1937470883,
-0.1698500812,
-0.1839385182,
0.9109340906,
0.6555173397,
-0.2839293778,
-0.0730422363,
-0.1624454707,
-0.0274061747,
-0.1309601963,
-0.166395992,
0.1351704895,
-0.47519961,
-0.7635835409,
0.4268405437,
0.3796504736,
-0.0319859236,
-0.6301324964,
-0.0885265917,
-0.0408050306,
0.5838343501,
0.1905648708,
0.042919565,
-0.5933524966,
-0.2473707199,
-0.1541566551,
-0.1979202777,
0.054600358,
0.8695034981,
-1.1896781921,
0.0763906911,
0.831715405,
0.7311297059,
-0.085318476,
0.0087692142,
0.4477129877,
-0.8559504151,
0.1869897395,
0.1171198264,
0.4925030172,
0.6968010068,
-0.5248923898,
0.5778913498,
0.166149348,
-0.945512414,
-0.7891390324,
0.4008671343,
-0.5790324807,
-0.5512645245,
1.2984771729,
-0.1217304543,
-0.518196106,
0.068945609,
0.1495347619,
0.2282195538,
-0.4926460087,
0.8088602424,
0.9067596197,
-0.1518584937,
-0.1314301938,
-0.826066494,
0.5203210115,
0.270919323,
-0.8453235626,
0.0702259913,
0.3682312071,
-0.2407151014,
0.5310723782,
0.1686649323,
0.2153376788,
0.0084033199,
0.1640617698,
-0.112472415,
-0.1751497537,
-0.2049891949,
-0.4792489707,
0.440241456,
0.0041254279,
0.3690365851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09932v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09932v1
|
Foundational Challenges in Assuring Alignment and Safety of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T16:58:28 | 2024-04-15T16:58:28 |
Usman Anwar, Abulhair Saparov, Javier Rando, Daniel Paleka, Miles Turpin, Peter Hase, Ekdeep Singh Lubana, Erik Jenner, Stephen Casper, Oliver Sourbut, Benjamin L. Edelman, Zhaowei Zhang, Mario Günther, Anton Korinek, Jose Hernandez-Orallo, Lewis Hammond, Eric Bigelow, Alexander Pan, Lauro Langosco, Tomasz Korbak, Heidi Zhang, Ruiqi Zhong, Seán Ó hÉigeartaigh, Gabriel Recchia, Giulio Corsi, Alan Chan, Markus Anderljung, Lilian Edwards, Yoshua Bengio, Danqi Chen, Samuel Albanie, Tegan Maharaj, Jakob Foerster, Florian Tramer, He He, Atoosa Kasirzadeh, Yejin Choi, David Krueger
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
This work identifies 18 foundational challenges in assuring the alignment and
safety of large language models (LLMs). These challenges are organized into
three different categories: scientific understanding of LLMs, development and
deployment methods, and sociotechnical challenges. Based on the identified
challenges, we pose $200+$ concrete research questions.
|
[
-0.0890717655,
-0.8465915322,
0.7889284492,
0.3523672223,
0.163870886,
0.3668374419,
-0.1411902606,
-0.789188683,
-0.4638999701,
0.8323583007,
-0.6434876323,
-0.3562562168,
-0.6932083368,
0.1882107109,
-0.6166043282,
0.8833578825,
-0.473334074,
-0.120448865,
-0.2043922991,
-0.0130676283,
-0.6320703626,
-0.6291502714,
-0.4484710693,
-0.1766400635,
0.3784996867,
0.4617722929,
0.7621552944,
0.7395650744,
1.0677827597,
0.3525869548,
-0.4302684665,
-0.1681557298,
-0.2733913958,
0.2149705738,
-0.2480356246,
-0.445725143,
-0.3518788815,
-0.255022496,
0.7361267209,
1.0434231758,
-0.1906093359,
0.035154745,
-0.0422425494,
0.7715204954,
-0.6221984625,
0.0244968086,
-0.5911950469,
-0.1865839511,
-0.4061883986,
0.1204510406,
-0.2564105392,
-0.4100905061,
0.2800085843,
-0.4077832699,
-0.126934886,
0.0912782848,
1.0831741095,
0.1766157448,
-0.879683435,
-0.6284764409,
-0.7672342658,
0.8717253804,
-0.4103764594,
0.1638455391,
0.1316742897,
0.2892173231,
-0.4575241506,
-0.3220168352,
-0.4635612071,
0.103980571,
0.201925844,
-0.4453591108,
0.1997376382,
-0.0694448948,
0.2165543288,
0.5507409573,
-0.5535039306,
0.546274066,
-0.3628213108,
-0.2239628732,
0.8868872523,
0.5199537873,
0.4512713253,
-0.073668316,
-0.3045091331,
-0.0688404888,
-1.1816228628,
-0.1362339705,
0.4176668823,
0.2360587865,
-0.4027591348,
0.7989761829,
-0.1525881439,
0.7137772441,
-0.1306716949,
-0.338055402,
0.3621360362,
-0.7014040351,
0.1155708954,
0.1200950965,
0.5738534927,
0.2496815026,
0.3554708362,
-0.0703264624,
-0.3061880469,
0.0541604646,
0.1327637136,
-0.2774779797,
0.3502728641,
0.6099804044,
-0.0628578737,
-0.5766942501,
-0.3497364819,
-0.4325440824,
-0.6025326848,
-0.2785926461,
0.380078882,
-0.3588337898,
-0.3441062272,
0.1214887351,
0.2422768325,
0.6871641874,
0.4482203424,
-1.0180270672,
0.1621045768,
1.196464777,
0.8678780794,
-0.2939901352,
-0.311147511,
0.1152030304,
0.5432235599,
-0.3685616553,
0.6450099945,
-0.2282545716,
-0.2513817549,
0.2101645768,
0.1580649316,
-0.0630172789,
-0.2928056121,
0.2831093073,
-0.3289096057,
-0.0786858574,
-0.4317971766,
-0.6668060422,
0.0721558407,
0.5782817602,
-0.5347896218,
0.8816347718,
0.0612089373,
-0.7894592285,
-0.1294939071,
-0.4033502638,
-0.4931223392,
-0.0172595698,
-0.3629440069,
-0.160040319,
0.0049772337,
-0.1462822258,
0.325001508,
-0.4566185176,
0.5751231909,
-0.1184637025,
-0.1309827864,
0.3682467043,
-0.1810236275,
1.0382113457,
0.1894462556,
-0.5322397351,
0.2582316995,
-1.0008744001,
-0.2653405368,
0.2878452837,
-0.3790246844,
-0.0102279512,
0.1719830632,
-0.0427142568,
0.0114469351,
0.4892326593,
-0.4268715978,
0.2801383138,
-0.3814010024,
0.4372561872,
0.8007768393,
0.041368451,
0.3619914651,
-0.3193410337,
0.5444420576,
0.0452746302,
0.1191993728,
-0.1056972072,
-0.5471345782,
-0.5942749381,
0.0903328806,
0.1953396201,
0.9115269184,
-0.3735210896,
0.454855144,
-0.2603678405,
-0.5667086244,
-0.289147377,
0.2786746621,
0.4533546269,
0.4061680436,
-0.0030044818,
0.0941053405,
-0.4565417469,
-0.9798917174,
0.1912426651,
-0.1429322064,
0.1599319875,
-0.0620191544,
0.8298025131,
-0.3168527782,
0.8052777052,
-0.329660207,
-0.1071268469,
-0.012095659,
0.2298234105,
0.0969169289,
0.9128111601,
0.4871076345,
-0.9430647492,
-0.3471876979,
0.3763231337,
-0.8422343135,
-0.1285639107,
0.2000975013,
0.1799524128,
0.4179533124,
0.7031653523,
-0.7609807849,
0.2224873155,
0.6210570335,
-0.0047618048,
0.691937685,
0.1037645712,
-0.0496925786,
-1.1217775345,
-0.0725506172,
-0.0471992493,
-0.0361976437,
-0.6848325133,
0.4368826747,
-0.0490415655,
-0.257617116,
-0.5152817965,
0.3617862761,
-0.6184159517,
-0.0992721841,
-0.0586172044,
0.203466326,
-0.1011728793,
-0.1251797825,
-0.0484117456,
0.5732656121,
0.708322525,
-0.7343471646,
0.6212495565,
0.1638780981,
-0.5261520743,
0.5946493149,
-0.7648351192,
0.0951145217,
-0.1179678738,
0.1060110927,
-1.0064685345,
-0.4450219274,
0.0547413118,
-0.2536640763,
0.4498476684,
0.0625743717,
-0.6310811043,
-0.0754655525,
-0.1294410676,
0.4577651918,
0.4662929475,
-0.1432138085,
0.6790457964,
0.5091320872,
-0.3465172052,
-0.9254793525,
-0.5739233494,
0.084946841,
-0.3312285244,
-0.9043413401,
0.3715299964,
-0.0542197563,
-0.5989360809,
0.0482897386,
-0.0622873381,
0.2402154207,
0.6523470283,
0.3268787861,
0.1842651069,
-0.3095056713,
-0.1443024576,
-0.2931219637,
-0.2398176342,
0.2423392385,
0.0756565854,
0.2974382639,
-0.3934018016,
-0.7037450075,
-0.2025812864,
0.515933454,
0.5067375898,
0.0381018855,
0.6923758388,
0.4649097919,
-0.6796851158,
0.1889269352,
-0.909894228,
0.2874086201,
-0.5333603024,
0.4189227521,
-0.3991206586,
-1.2308706045,
0.8393194079,
-0.0615932681,
0.3521088958,
0.3690617979,
0.7313418984,
-0.1321549118,
1.2332402468,
0.7437307835,
-0.0235515404,
0.0589336157,
0.193552494,
0.2331136018,
-0.6287485957,
-0.5735854506,
-0.9904717207,
-0.184211731,
-0.5384626389,
-0.3363926113,
0.2913445532,
0.3118530512,
-0.5065273046,
0.3417887688,
-0.3195094764,
0.4411649406,
0.2909269035,
-0.3356861472,
0.4186839461,
-0.1599796712,
-0.1847135276,
0.0161055718,
-0.2638428807,
-0.7618621588,
0.8452746272,
0.7752202749,
1.0134601593,
0.6831926107,
0.7074619532,
-0.2745051086,
0.2452154309,
-0.7783367634,
0.6224563718,
0.1341940165,
-1.0887464285,
-0.4729975462,
-0.4620545506,
-0.8571459055,
-0.0086914599,
-0.2045197487,
-1.329202652,
0.0683187246,
0.0657353178,
-0.1620345116,
-0.0000509723,
-0.3939469159,
0.6842521429,
-0.688165009,
-0.2662782371,
0.0529452264,
-0.9106621742,
0.56152004,
-0.1883556992,
0.6261054873,
-0.3424546421,
0.0732335821,
0.5802031159,
-0.329228878,
0.8886152506,
0.3485163748,
-0.6170114875,
0.2956649065,
0.1575672328,
0.6460273862,
-0.1888002157,
0.1071117669,
-0.1888307035,
0.3708611429,
-0.4478032589,
-0.2569640577,
0.7967284322,
-0.70007056,
-1.183139205,
-0.6428472996,
-0.783890605,
-0.5360487103,
0.1493931264,
0.0605427176,
0.0247968324,
-0.2647158802,
0.4093029797,
1.156493783,
-0.3195068836,
0.4531661272,
0.5152953863,
-0.4880535901,
-0.2610809505,
0.8083693981,
0.0689197704,
0.6316283345,
0.4484887719,
0.0642556697,
-0.0739809051,
-1.1215963364,
-0.3433863819,
0.1958555281,
-0.8977873921,
-0.0775469914,
-0.7002950311,
-0.3818881512,
-0.5595805645,
-0.3206298649,
-0.5557218194,
-0.2636327446,
-0.4465914667,
-0.2241568416,
0.3775781989,
1.0655121803,
-0.1136943698,
0.4239729047,
-0.9814462662,
0.0369144119,
0.1846113354,
0.310108602,
-0.0470617153,
-0.3816581964,
-0.2296447009,
-0.1645351052,
-0.3261557519,
-0.9036964178,
-0.1333554983,
-0.3779589236,
0.5301648378,
0.4593216777,
-0.1473080367,
0.5249363184,
-0.4562467337,
0.8871262074,
0.241203025,
-0.9926010966,
0.4626182318,
-0.5995878577,
-0.0696073771,
0.6125162244,
0.6693921685,
-0.3005386293,
0.0579147972,
-0.290386349,
-1.0154232979,
0.3500517309,
0.1891540438,
0.0640133843,
-0.0478972718,
0.5231933594,
-0.3634934425,
0.1243191138,
-0.9466625452,
-0.0778686181,
0.3507341146,
-0.2749095857,
0.0108870491,
-0.433198899,
-0.5403318405,
0.0454871505,
0.7005120516,
-0.0133860977,
-0.3287785649,
-0.0979255214,
-0.2845028937,
-0.2545339465,
0.4891462028,
1.2092170715,
0.7657321692,
-0.433978945,
0.1772000343,
0.1601578444,
-0.1846806109,
0.4846752882,
-0.1268377751,
-0.0269429535,
-0.3774062693,
0.6152181029,
0.7120967507,
0.4218935668,
-0.7814182043,
0.4666946232,
0.2506629825,
-0.39419505,
-0.5781459808,
-0.0803956017,
0.5085800886,
0.0485133268,
0.48533687,
-0.576213479,
-0.3349759579,
-0.6332548857,
-0.1567014903,
0.6482311487,
-0.3705053031,
-0.2659160495,
0.5044156909,
0.2124481201,
-0.3340873718,
0.3508705795,
0.2688057125,
-0.690089345,
0.7875942588,
0.7606474161,
0.5823028088,
-0.3439038396,
-0.098740302,
-0.045233693,
0.7420889139,
-0.5529878139,
0.4161697328,
0.6038006544,
-0.7709371448,
-0.4101011455,
-0.6016369462,
-0.8328182101,
0.1560147852,
-0.5609002709,
0.4243905246,
-0.4992054999,
-0.0136376163,
0.1200370789,
-0.104970865,
-0.3929768205,
0.0380392969,
0.207825318,
0.877630055,
-0.9683895111,
0.4252235591,
0.8118284345,
-0.2532868683,
-0.8674241304,
-0.6173262596,
0.3643100858,
-0.744517982,
0.8207858801,
0.0081739621,
-0.0813706964,
-0.210475266,
-0.6572905183,
-1.1932965517,
1.1199806929,
0.4713109434,
-0.8804414272,
-0.3902469575,
0.381940037,
0.3066664636,
-0.5795738101,
-0.2642223239,
0.5183037519,
0.7374472618,
0.1291807741,
-1.1871649027,
0.1433470398,
-0.0691441447,
0.045245029,
0.1693874449,
-0.5552777648,
0.9756528139,
-0.1345752478,
-0.2440670431,
0.2230153233,
0.4081118405,
0.6039800048,
0.310772866,
0.4202738702,
0.7920886278,
0.6011971235,
-0.2122476548,
1.024510622,
-0.1707749516,
0.3544445634,
0.9992344379,
-0.7490350008,
0.6112646461,
0.7832701206,
-0.2940431833,
0.420904547,
0.8577232957,
0.016591914,
0.2155584842,
0.5160312653,
-0.3362756371,
-0.0767036825,
-0.23313348,
-0.9237622023,
0.3674933612,
0.7245668769,
-0.1037385464,
-0.0169541091,
-0.0875991136,
0.0565338731,
0.0099944705,
-0.2180138975,
0.6944069862,
0.1974497736,
-0.4915651977,
0.2988120615,
0.1572776139,
0.508623302,
-0.5698143244,
-0.006283666,
0.196984604,
0.1734698266,
-0.319013387,
-0.8070085049,
0.4088106453,
-0.1848546267,
-0.1329512149,
0.0073885843,
0.6423489451,
-0.2054311931,
-0.5249829888,
0.2240613103,
0.229824543,
-0.0309343226,
0.2356996387,
-0.4939765036,
0.6782390475,
-0.3116657734,
-0.3254725635,
0.5784373879,
0.4972646236,
-0.3080365658,
0.9963205457,
0.4569790661,
-0.0881611034,
0.1655540168,
-0.1978365332,
0.6263912916,
-0.7992939949,
-0.2094095051,
-0.9776619077,
0.5888150334,
0.1507311016,
-0.0927818567,
0.6270926595,
0.174990356,
0.4853010178,
-0.0307790376,
0.6693075895,
-0.0999988392,
0.2590076327,
-0.7183138132,
0.6241000295,
-0.3098830581,
0.5951296687,
-0.5663093328,
-0.7702574134,
-0.3669036031,
0.5002661943,
-0.1696405858,
-0.028113775,
0.8504960537,
0.614633739,
0.4476182759,
-0.1529957056,
0.0337227881,
-0.0023467459,
0.3453068733,
0.684843719,
1.1731959581,
-0.3884603381,
0.4618941545,
-0.4390154779,
-0.0645204857,
-0.1773258746,
-1.425706625,
-0.8289028406,
-0.5394288898,
-0.6535412669,
-0.7772721648,
0.0389588997,
0.8500106931,
0.5875637531,
-1.1511073112,
-0.6088298559,
-0.117162846,
0.6324175596,
-0.0183909908,
-0.2118074894,
0.1506599039,
-0.1442374438,
-0.6050827503,
0.292979151,
0.2899029553,
0.4344216287,
-0.4523233473,
0.0522248521,
-0.5582529902,
-0.1217631623,
0.3837270141,
0.4574743211,
-0.8331506252,
-0.7891597748,
-0.0677981749,
-0.3415498734,
-0.3010958135,
0.8073856831,
-0.0028064486,
-0.0600746647,
0.4340714216,
1.165263176,
0.2140360028,
0.0244271085,
0.8072540164,
-0.6880484223,
0.0507695936,
0.0813522935,
0.4869138896,
0.4727650285,
-0.5105362535,
0.6959147453,
0.1813317388,
-0.6393341422,
-1.3210052252,
0.6202230453,
-1.1886389256,
-0.0885670781,
1.0879361629,
-0.1245342419,
-0.1477499902,
-0.3983818889,
0.2555211484,
0.0740419701,
0.3887497187,
0.5567305684,
1.2543286085,
-0.0986950845,
-0.4370607436,
-0.57625103,
0.4134865701,
0.4872432649,
-0.7593013048,
-0.0426467732,
0.4935255647,
0.53231287,
0.5115391612,
0.3108205497,
-0.4461241364,
0.1195833683,
-0.2222752571,
0.0766391158,
0.1360307932,
-0.3884238303,
-0.4351328611,
0.3558712602,
0.3728637099,
0.3889218569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13076v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13076v1
|
LLM Evaluators Recognize and Favor Their Own Generations
| 2024-04-15T16:49:59 | 2024-04-15T16:49:59 |
Arjun Panickssery, Samuel R. Bowman, Shi Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Self-evaluation using large language models (LLMs) has proven valuable not
only in benchmarking but also methods like reward modeling, constitutional AI,
and self-refinement. But new biases are introduced due to the same LLM acting
as both the evaluator and the evaluatee. One such bias is self-preference,
where an LLM evaluator scores its own outputs higher than others' while human
annotators consider them of equal quality. But do LLMs actually recognize their
own outputs when they give those texts higher scores, or is it just a
coincidence? In this paper, we investigate if self-recognition capability
contributes to self-preference. We discover that, out of the box, LLMs such as
GPT-4 and Llama 2 have non-trivial accuracy at distinguishing themselves from
other LLMs and humans. By fine-tuning LLMs, we discover a linear correlation
between self-recognition capability and the strength of self-preference bias;
using controlled experiments, we show that the causal explanation resists
straightforward confounders. We discuss how self-recognition can interfere with
unbiased evaluations and AI safety more generally.
|
[
-0.5030491352,
-0.0727194697,
0.8636429906,
0.1564574242,
-0.1390805244,
0.2301522493,
-0.1861647218,
-0.6851385236,
0.2087224722,
0.4037120938,
-0.2116500139,
-0.0127673317,
-0.8168081045,
0.406442821,
-0.1507603824,
1.032372117,
0.0858481228,
0.0051172446,
-0.4222164452,
-0.1653316617,
-0.2346680313,
-0.7766848803,
-0.288059324,
-0.7202092409,
0.6359149218,
0.2774095535,
0.5783967376,
0.7305975556,
0.3392005563,
0.3409232199,
0.1904392242,
-0.159619987,
-0.3837499619,
0.1475393921,
-0.225833714,
-0.3168665767,
-0.1480028778,
0.5983782411,
0.4731389582,
0.0944559574,
0.3377564549,
0.1982071102,
0.4399320781,
0.849513948,
-0.3677451313,
-0.0590214171,
-0.7320845723,
-0.0582551099,
-0.3422369659,
-0.4576087594,
-0.2414463609,
-0.30789873,
0.0862497091,
-0.1415846795,
0.3806505799,
-0.0231693368,
0.67743361,
0.5156553984,
-0.524171114,
-0.3430210948,
-0.6045096517,
0.6890839338,
-0.5516892076,
0.2547422349,
0.3829625249,
0.0911999047,
-0.0047291298,
-0.1905555576,
-0.4423690438,
-0.3310680687,
-0.1857093871,
0.1094022617,
-0.1059758887,
0.1072837636,
0.204899177,
0.4836598933,
-0.4775776267,
0.6683426499,
-0.3871211112,
-0.4693036079,
0.7338776588,
0.0559176244,
0.0167330112,
-0.4090690315,
-0.643424809,
0.0614996962,
-0.7902582884,
0.2203038335,
0.5178495049,
0.0349410102,
0.2607413828,
0.5336337686,
-0.3464529812,
0.4514959455,
0.2869790792,
-0.067363739,
0.3460607827,
-0.0642124638,
-0.1341044605,
0.0316114351,
1.0831474066,
0.2185518742,
0.4089892507,
-0.1154556572,
-0.2694121599,
0.1135386974,
0.1664836705,
-0.5170142651,
-0.1162862703,
-0.0113603249,
-0.6429578662,
-0.4006945193,
-0.0412851535,
-0.5953239202,
-0.7300483584,
-0.3146288693,
0.6330951452,
-0.0425196849,
0.0590173267,
0.0345445164,
-0.1190999895,
0.1647208184,
0.2938644588,
-1.1316102743,
-0.082342118,
0.5173497796,
0.4565297961,
-0.3705241084,
-0.6711887121,
-0.4540117085,
-0.1845457107,
-0.2913647592,
1.0413637161,
-0.476047188,
-0.4647664428,
-0.4094323814,
-0.3197327852,
0.0744643137,
-0.8010433316,
0.4364711344,
-0.3271137774,
0.0680346191,
-0.5198703408,
-0.4831264019,
0.0408767127,
-0.1062173769,
-0.4085811675,
0.8883494139,
-0.1141747162,
-0.599371314,
0.7393577099,
-0.2811849713,
-0.2267914861,
0.1154761538,
-0.4821874499,
-0.4398715198,
0.3773167133,
0.1240910664,
0.4822885692,
-0.1168078259,
0.1142810062,
-0.5461850166,
-0.304397881,
0.5131602287,
-0.8383775949,
0.5398029685,
0.2215040624,
-0.4224289954,
0.1015434414,
-0.6896417141,
-0.0768887028,
0.1143722534,
-0.6763579845,
-0.3833968043,
-0.1280331761,
-0.5897203088,
0.3084115982,
0.6925418973,
-0.4303223491,
0.2045239508,
-0.0679339841,
0.3483549058,
1.3312844038,
-0.2733585536,
0.3747105896,
-0.3794984221,
0.4033042789,
-0.1227127463,
0.12487147,
0.1266833544,
-0.3376666009,
-0.8059375882,
-0.1591563374,
0.2312024236,
0.1385104209,
-0.1224660501,
0.5376182795,
-0.0117887724,
-0.3342065811,
-0.6430469751,
0.5937581062,
0.3181886077,
0.3331170678,
0.2321959585,
-0.3204515874,
-0.4742392004,
-1.0528398752,
-0.5785811543,
-0.4602878094,
-0.0421493649,
0.4513170719,
0.1325471401,
-0.1198527738,
1.0036010742,
-0.1746194065,
-0.4675249755,
-0.081123136,
0.1474170089,
-0.00985411,
0.3070411682,
0.6635955572,
-0.2970485091,
-0.1862239987,
-0.2592991292,
-0.7941467166,
-0.4317084253,
-0.1679302454,
0.0070975958,
0.0256157201,
0.2728129327,
-0.2155905068,
0.3067772686,
0.662920177,
-0.4047431648,
0.5878188014,
-0.4683835506,
0.0586414002,
-0.5005562901,
-0.3047056198,
0.0381854177,
-0.1809647828,
-0.2462690175,
-0.1446029395,
0.1888094395,
0.563333869,
-0.2349584252,
0.6293305755,
-0.4355873466,
-0.4534721673,
-0.4015496075,
0.1047319844,
0.0449395142,
0.1807026714,
-0.0881963223,
1.0895805359,
0.3429638743,
-0.5192964077,
0.0731290951,
0.1371081471,
-0.3500100672,
0.437266767,
-0.4118859172,
0.4776940048,
-0.0737724751,
0.0512195602,
-1.0621757507,
-0.1641164869,
0.06535732,
-0.3735450804,
0.2555510104,
-0.0358414091,
-0.0137563851,
-0.5365608335,
-0.5559399128,
0.3297217488,
0.4613509476,
-1.1455415487,
0.5315449834,
0.2821788192,
0.0564292371,
-0.709802568,
-0.707272172,
0.0439826548,
-0.4329961538,
-0.0985377133,
0.1134453043,
-0.3831312954,
-0.1559968591,
-0.273057729,
-0.1299989671,
0.2578296959,
0.1685055792,
0.6669155359,
0.4219931662,
0.0836829096,
0.1235255748,
-0.0421840958,
-0.1908764839,
0.1322434992,
-0.1345357448,
0.3405825794,
-0.2370491028,
-0.423864305,
-0.2978178859,
-0.2417058349,
0.4926409423,
-0.2987577021,
0.1601944268,
0.3364317119,
0.1408219039,
0.0631016642,
-0.9974823594,
-0.1537051797,
-0.5437639356,
0.0871044844,
-0.5830339193,
-1.1274909973,
0.1779709458,
0.2223608941,
-0.244920373,
0.6610226035,
0.6791211367,
-0.2380612642,
0.9044750929,
0.237625584,
-0.5238106847,
0.4091971815,
0.1078286842,
0.0866480246,
-1.1546083689,
-0.0208984725,
-0.6296829581,
-0.3509583175,
-0.7829168439,
0.0546548925,
0.2836690843,
-0.1103218198,
-0.2459918261,
0.1034092531,
-0.7425972223,
0.6422790289,
0.6185479164,
0.0815228373,
0.5056377053,
-0.1117810532,
-0.0913647637,
-0.1865995228,
-0.3727685213,
-0.8279448152,
1.2310336828,
0.4444369376,
0.9426056147,
-0.1242585108,
1.1872652769,
0.5576981306,
0.5211154222,
-0.6185126901,
0.6073639393,
-0.1867055446,
-0.6150565147,
-0.2079503834,
-0.448833257,
-1.1142910719,
0.1391126066,
-0.1932655871,
-0.8081844449,
0.2963548601,
0.3257762492,
-0.4245094061,
0.1386056989,
-0.5505577326,
0.7351190448,
-0.5796594024,
-0.3232696354,
-0.2393582761,
-0.2353502512,
0.4034487307,
-0.2241870761,
0.0979030058,
-0.5972803235,
0.1991532743,
0.7908471823,
0.1264687777,
0.7156502008,
0.1026511937,
-0.0597244129,
0.1746860296,
0.2834382951,
0.1513494551,
0.1436159909,
-0.2149341106,
0.420712769,
-0.2196749896,
-0.1315688938,
-0.4228867292,
1.097766161,
-1.1567475796,
-1.3218336105,
-0.6354908347,
-0.1921395212,
0.0564366654,
0.169416815,
0.3365439475,
0.0610239878,
-0.2110616714,
-0.1562719494,
0.0672216341,
-0.1128472984,
0.4121353328,
0.6161544919,
-0.3196878135,
-0.2868195176,
0.8933511376,
0.3267359138,
0.4365397096,
0.024156861,
0.5547617078,
-0.5116097927,
-0.4189436734,
-0.5554438829,
0.3170345724,
-0.8695687056,
-0.1482043415,
-0.5132753849,
-0.1807618439,
-0.2100447714,
-0.0402791612,
-0.1712960452,
-0.3804228902,
-0.3754407763,
-0.3654669821,
0.1299980432,
1.2526985407,
-0.345298171,
-0.2012790143,
-0.3505970538,
0.1827716678,
1.0894993544,
0.3753411472,
0.0111773424,
-0.7096199989,
0.0938151032,
-0.1913327277,
-0.4146150649,
-0.6589609385,
0.1178559586,
-0.0795002505,
0.5618344545,
0.6175838709,
-0.083114177,
0.4052911997,
-0.3542491198,
0.6142064333,
-0.1160594001,
-0.9915385842,
0.2729569674,
-0.011939452,
0.0749507695,
0.6464443207,
0.1803035289,
-0.0753348991,
-0.3548089266,
-0.4477003217,
-0.0864366889,
0.5723698735,
0.0047230022,
0.2668309212,
-0.1831160039,
0.3846213222,
0.3060538471,
0.1331211925,
-1.0418657064,
-0.1305082142,
-0.3392393291,
0.01224944,
-0.1887417883,
-0.5721127987,
0.0342235975,
0.007739896,
0.4982509017,
-0.2271236777,
0.2428343445,
0.3042416871,
0.1375561804,
-0.3009949327,
0.4386637509,
0.4591657221,
0.3680950403,
-0.0431110449,
0.5151728392,
0.2712725103,
-0.1681783795,
0.5117257833,
-0.0725561529,
-0.0331383422,
-0.3275711536,
0.1426582932,
0.5335271358,
-0.1225575432,
-0.3276231587,
0.5215878487,
-0.1623990834,
0.0227738917,
-0.1276648939,
0.3456184268,
0.0185325965,
0.2051109523,
0.4441672266,
0.209201768,
0.214783594,
-0.6229602098,
-0.0197268091,
0.9353925586,
-0.1989923418,
-0.3584987521,
0.861610651,
0.0028004269,
-0.4742246568,
0.2779532373,
-0.2688537538,
-0.6691722274,
0.4977937639,
0.4512916803,
0.8957343698,
-0.5900832415,
0.1102743223,
0.2137920409,
0.2380415946,
0.0038866501,
0.0265565459,
-0.1331369877,
-1.0656044483,
-0.0442113876,
-0.7632627487,
-0.3124937117,
0.2114108801,
-0.50343436,
0.13318564,
-0.4892170131,
-0.2911047041,
0.0936101303,
-0.1414478868,
-0.8952818513,
0.2406437695,
0.1831534505,
0.3036293387,
-0.68704772,
0.7880780697,
0.2074944973,
-0.3273127973,
-0.8014258742,
0.1451273859,
-0.0283278432,
-1.2114316225,
0.7804418206,
0.3388235867,
-0.2016499639,
-0.0954121128,
-0.2070194334,
-0.9232938886,
0.862428844,
0.364539355,
-0.5764494538,
0.0134368306,
0.1786358654,
0.5934796929,
-0.4090936184,
0.4899586439,
0.6734730601,
0.4458120167,
-0.3338630497,
-1.0018782616,
-0.0466617271,
0.20015046,
-0.1543266028,
-0.0206625741,
-0.963625133,
0.6596179605,
-0.4643726647,
0.0196807217,
0.00890134,
0.5317732692,
0.3208506405,
0.3824480474,
0.4981665611,
0.3323120773,
0.539945662,
0.001723022,
0.9707291126,
-0.4462535977,
0.3891348839,
1.019903779,
-0.3807611763,
0.7080187201,
0.4195415676,
-0.4480990767,
0.5291987062,
0.5773941875,
0.060319189,
0.3275656104,
-0.0818901658,
-0.1840062439,
-0.3515854776,
-0.0691676214,
-0.187381044,
0.6781318784,
0.0020994216,
-0.7342457175,
0.167633459,
-0.1958663911,
-0.0192328505,
0.065310806,
-0.2701462209,
0.8416679502,
0.1469090879,
-0.8422724605,
0.5518980622,
-0.2750560939,
0.6622717381,
-0.384599179,
0.3108445406,
-0.0783011541,
-0.0307853594,
-0.4945769906,
-1.1125415564,
-0.0277268942,
-0.1413943172,
-0.1138941795,
-0.2758466601,
0.867380321,
-0.1251115054,
-0.261310488,
0.6294460893,
0.7228561044,
0.1830020696,
0.0740195736,
-0.5965443254,
0.0063173557,
0.1796253622,
-0.3738857508,
0.721283257,
0.2005242854,
0.1082822233,
0.6185632348,
0.7162911296,
0.079134427,
0.1113885343,
0.2470632792,
0.6839590073,
-0.5864142776,
-0.2628099918,
-1.2065050602,
-0.0968860015,
0.1336291283,
-0.4249024689,
0.8738664389,
0.6300134659,
0.8576310873,
-0.0624264739,
0.9417158365,
0.4070354998,
0.445140183,
-0.4101988077,
0.5380237103,
-0.476855278,
0.4408414364,
-0.2417543381,
-0.8814562559,
0.1903882772,
0.7228902578,
-0.7432681918,
0.3710979521,
0.3341713846,
0.6418278813,
0.1966748238,
-0.0698312968,
0.6751211882,
0.1454954743,
0.2798548043,
0.452134341,
1.1434277296,
0.0719180778,
0.3379255533,
-0.1702990681,
-0.2741010487,
-0.0935081169,
-0.8296387196,
-1.1159625053,
-0.4579481781,
-0.0925366133,
-0.2875102162,
-0.073730424,
1.0792768002,
0.475851208,
-0.4800656736,
-0.2594386637,
0.0936092213,
0.2601011097,
0.1073273718,
-0.1896875352,
0.0780505538,
-0.4271715581,
-0.6156107783,
0.5493583083,
0.6027681231,
0.2416636646,
-0.6300313473,
-0.2903444171,
0.4415354133,
0.2229954153,
0.2516407967,
0.2334282249,
-0.9871596694,
-0.6658470631,
-0.2590382695,
-0.2788929343,
0.6585261226,
0.7535443306,
-1.0562905073,
0.6084554195,
0.3359718025,
0.4573148787,
0.3410688043,
0.1264669597,
0.3215208054,
-0.1350210756,
-0.3337045908,
-0.0364168473,
0.5913758278,
0.4080559611,
-0.6975841522,
0.5704245567,
0.0787878111,
-1.165979743,
-0.496648252,
0.3234252036,
-0.5526744127,
0.0622159429,
1.091375947,
0.0059029115,
0.0015184946,
-0.0403163172,
-0.3560100198,
-0.0927606151,
-0.493258357,
1.2090533972,
0.6776396632,
-0.4245377779,
-0.0029723262,
-0.2266193777,
0.6219732761,
0.6633241177,
-0.5534999371,
0.0465651304,
0.2261385471,
0.6317139268,
0.1864417046,
0.7923623323,
0.0540949367,
0.1926070452,
-0.4623131752,
-0.020521909,
0.0346802585,
-0.2033969909,
-0.8278178573,
-0.1239918992,
0.7638452053,
0.0278500505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.10032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.10032v1
|
Detecting AI Generated Text Based on NLP and Machine Learning Approaches
| 2024-04-15T16:37:44 | 2024-04-15T16:37:44 |
Nuzhat Prova
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Recent advances in natural language processing (NLP) may enable artificial
intelligence (AI) models to generate writing that is identical to human written
form in the future. This might have profound ethical, legal, and social
repercussions. This study aims to address this problem by offering an accurate
AI detector model that can differentiate between electronically produced text
and human-written text. Our approach includes machine learning methods such as
XGB Classifier, SVM, BERT architecture deep learning models. Furthermore, our
results show that the BERT performs better than previous models in identifying
information generated by AI from information provided by humans. Provide a
comprehensive analysis of the current state of AI-generated text identification
in our assessment of pertinent studies. Our testing yielded positive findings,
showing that our strategy is successful, with the BERT emerging as the most
probable answer. We analyze the research's societal implications, highlighting
the possible advantages for various industries while addressing sustainability
issues pertaining to morality and the environment. The XGB classifier and SVM
give 0.84 and 0.81 accuracy in this article, respectively. The greatest
accuracy in this research is provided by the BERT model, which provides 0.93%
accuracy.
|
[
-0.1697205007,
-0.9357460141,
0.5953195691,
-0.1150145084,
-0.0690254569,
0.1984516531,
-0.1056457981,
-1.0204834938,
-0.1842924953,
0.5789535642,
-0.5240114331,
-0.451192975,
-0.5925605297,
0.3545742035,
-0.6257054806,
0.9079917669,
0.1747528464,
-0.1128595993,
-0.2091753483,
0.0489609614,
-0.3531438112,
-0.5961856246,
-0.8026147485,
-0.430473268,
0.2680094242,
-0.020896975,
0.583648622,
0.7710213065,
0.5380194783,
0.4005708992,
-0.0521600954,
0.2705707252,
-0.1691935956,
-0.0053159702,
0.0528892763,
-0.3323373199,
-0.2028763443,
0.1210408285,
0.5553412437,
-0.054638613,
0.1146232411,
0.2759366632,
0.0334099643,
0.5136569142,
-0.4149770737,
0.0754817799,
-0.9608801007,
0.2103377581,
-0.2063689977,
-0.3152312636,
-0.662555933,
-0.3169521987,
0.0760743245,
-0.344584316,
0.3022860885,
0.2678284049,
1.045566082,
0.3031083047,
-0.1643740088,
-0.9534345269,
-0.7222815752,
1.0035207272,
-0.9484314322,
0.1503326297,
0.2980276644,
0.0578733049,
-0.0738952681,
-0.6622567773,
-1.0132211447,
-0.3548325598,
-0.0564460158,
0.0949558243,
-0.1596525908,
-0.1472142786,
0.1355246007,
0.0047513247,
-0.5691375136,
0.3287760317,
-0.1634850502,
-0.2342905402,
0.9133551121,
0.0774530545,
0.8006228209,
-0.5291714668,
-0.3505467474,
-0.075444296,
-0.4277746677,
0.0975654945,
0.6299193501,
0.2388602346,
0.1192113012,
0.4913780093,
0.232136175,
0.4650034904,
-0.2508948743,
-0.0392629839,
0.1160292476,
-0.314227134,
-0.2507839799,
0.3509140313,
0.8818466067,
0.3949744105,
0.3967931569,
0.0435426496,
-0.3544522226,
0.1578099579,
0.5107350945,
-0.5773949623,
-0.0925423652,
0.103598088,
-0.8358020186,
-0.703535378,
0.1659376472,
-0.4674800932,
-0.5457506776,
-0.4045392275,
0.139757663,
-0.3650586009,
-0.0910643116,
-0.1580908,
-0.3082113266,
0.5532147884,
0.2901244462,
-0.8050031066,
-0.0780373588,
0.8335382342,
0.8078668714,
-0.1348291337,
0.0964549333,
-0.2916413844,
0.145197928,
-0.3381099105,
0.8849351406,
-0.3274364173,
-0.1410874724,
-0.0360726789,
-0.2635557652,
0.405644536,
-0.4155866504,
0.8116987348,
-0.4908972681,
0.3602440953,
-0.0952994004,
-0.7453446388,
-0.1664636433,
0.4102407396,
-0.7693712115,
1.011710763,
-0.1909183562,
-0.8196846843,
0.6898530126,
-0.7698511481,
-0.4588015079,
0.4045375884,
-0.3507249057,
-0.9779881239,
-0.1151172668,
0.1087808236,
0.5016994476,
-0.1616612226,
0.4559360743,
-0.2364608049,
-0.2033189237,
0.3086845875,
-0.7511910796,
1.0913826227,
0.1647810936,
-0.5486862659,
0.0938059092,
-0.780997932,
0.217132315,
0.1924045831,
-0.4560934603,
-0.2668577731,
0.4219370782,
0.3875543177,
0.1515791267,
0.2759683728,
-0.8643116951,
-0.1581859738,
-0.2054749727,
0.4639068246,
1.1320719719,
-0.099779889,
0.1500932425,
-0.491319865,
0.2641495168,
-0.4671064019,
-0.0809739903,
-0.1861834377,
-0.8792275786,
-0.4819092155,
-0.3178819716,
0.3298923969,
0.783867836,
-0.4648487568,
1.0229398012,
-0.1789913327,
-0.5014882684,
-0.5265666246,
-0.0844160989,
0.326541394,
0.5702874064,
0.2065237314,
-0.0196407996,
-0.5834471583,
-0.6616452932,
-0.5039870739,
-0.4716747999,
-0.1959840506,
0.443648845,
0.6148051023,
-0.3614223301,
1.1734638214,
-0.368688643,
-0.3355168104,
-0.2377129346,
0.5828535557,
-0.0337576978,
0.5728718042,
0.6489725709,
-1.0825868845,
-0.7178584933,
0.1885038167,
-1.0653736591,
-0.1695455909,
-0.5223369002,
0.1710530519,
0.5663356781,
0.4179533124,
-0.3569478095,
0.7133485079,
0.1404683441,
-0.3287833035,
0.365506649,
-0.3551404774,
0.1344794035,
-0.8240619898,
0.2725113332,
0.2058998644,
-0.4570616186,
-0.5966972709,
-0.0654922649,
-0.0244658031,
-0.1819444895,
-0.1106020883,
0.6552680731,
-0.2017130852,
0.0840562955,
-0.4585011601,
0.0209149662,
-0.0101286825,
0.1785342246,
0.2560478449,
0.5725967288,
-0.0170064196,
-0.3595860898,
0.3136468828,
0.3729475439,
-0.5457735658,
0.379704982,
-0.706759572,
0.2529088259,
-0.334071219,
0.1369783878,
-0.8860065937,
-0.0283577554,
0.3506966531,
-0.9144464135,
0.1083860844,
0.2481781095,
-0.7049046159,
-0.3437421024,
-0.256241709,
-0.2171019018,
0.650793314,
-0.5103288293,
0.7718416452,
0.4171133637,
-0.5785871148,
-0.4507890046,
-0.7945566177,
0.3161316216,
-0.1482309401,
-0.7221150398,
0.3986978829,
-0.0519061722,
-0.2551378012,
-0.0140380599,
0.1684517413,
-0.1969768852,
0.3750666976,
0.1289694309,
0.2523477972,
-0.0444668829,
0.089821361,
0.0768762529,
-0.1457655877,
0.4348934591,
0.018025903,
0.4601314962,
0.0795152485,
-0.1569707543,
-0.7726629972,
0.6367393136,
0.4415053427,
-0.2621594965,
0.6784321666,
0.8584157825,
-0.6321320534,
-0.1812732071,
-0.2555347085,
-0.0405383222,
-0.5227464437,
0.3036261499,
0.1598645449,
-0.3811759651,
0.2805278599,
0.2229173928,
0.1465332955,
0.4463107884,
0.5671567321,
-0.4458931386,
1.2648445368,
0.8036267161,
-0.221284464,
0.6174781919,
-0.0260394122,
0.546470046,
-0.3694152236,
-0.2642778754,
-0.7797356248,
-0.2063235193,
-0.7416012287,
0.1418456435,
0.0064558368,
-0.3412899077,
-0.0769048929,
0.1530243605,
-0.7916824222,
0.3795222044,
0.99360466,
0.2095507532,
0.260820657,
-0.1631330699,
0.1480736732,
0.0854239166,
-0.2766803801,
-1.1828297377,
1.1080650091,
0.2183686197,
0.2656264901,
-0.0105515867,
0.6549927592,
1.1237813234,
0.5528463125,
-0.4992522001,
0.5198395848,
-0.0670019463,
-0.7864331007,
-0.301839292,
-0.3913043439,
-0.9579234123,
-0.1793869436,
-0.61651057,
-0.7151042819,
-0.2703397274,
0.0080706021,
-0.1393207461,
0.4528217018,
-0.6198803186,
0.6703106165,
-0.5173100829,
-0.0557154417,
-0.1877446473,
-0.7530376315,
-0.030069951,
-0.2942868173,
0.0205585752,
-0.1416029781,
0.2503888607,
0.7750369906,
-0.1558379829,
0.8138551712,
-0.1088811234,
-0.2753392458,
0.4639142156,
-0.438429594,
0.560970366,
0.0282285102,
-0.3279035389,
0.24891074,
-0.3934683502,
-0.2655665278,
-0.179075256,
0.3112112284,
-0.6786990166,
-0.2702651918,
-0.5610935092,
-0.569109261,
0.3907701075,
0.5672014952,
0.5347381234,
0.0968624949,
-0.3213360906,
0.0878737345,
0.67201823,
-0.5548486114,
0.6947152615,
0.3028869033,
-0.0044229645,
-0.2291593552,
0.927687943,
0.02445581,
-0.126707837,
0.4816475511,
0.2678504884,
-0.3735575974,
-0.6494333148,
-0.6546394229,
-0.1735378206,
-0.5859827399,
-0.2369383574,
-0.6331118941,
-0.3164073825,
-0.4623799026,
-0.4473977387,
0.0780762956,
0.0917532742,
-0.6286806464,
-0.0078688143,
0.1362691522,
0.7182333469,
0.1271392107,
0.1447928846,
-0.9479179382,
0.5894390345,
0.079930976,
0.0865107849,
-0.0059625567,
-0.1253859699,
0.100245513,
0.3525607288,
-0.4356449544,
-0.6710999608,
0.5915494561,
0.1763699502,
0.5124466419,
0.4930331409,
0.1889954507,
0.0929259956,
-0.4798966348,
0.73796314,
0.1228750497,
-1.2059831619,
0.6193438768,
-0.3559194207,
-0.0196157526,
0.3391059935,
0.3668410182,
-0.4280500114,
-0.5309404731,
-0.6869145036,
-0.646279037,
0.543911159,
0.4475338161,
0.2204154134,
0.0455573685,
0.3287792504,
0.1661467999,
0.2421187013,
-0.9983875155,
0.0248779058,
0.0731657296,
-0.4930752218,
0.2952129841,
0.0629790276,
0.3501119912,
0.0738335997,
0.7578660846,
-0.0078027467,
0.4572858214,
0.0891307518,
-0.0887031853,
0.0742350817,
0.0624751076,
0.4759738147,
0.3900586963,
-0.1790695935,
-0.2452049404,
-0.1244716942,
-0.4539214075,
0.1826317459,
0.0176400468,
-0.6447177529,
0.1015710011,
0.6126875281,
0.4584720135,
-0.5879840851,
-0.8843867779,
0.5348032117,
-0.1780491769,
-0.1298399717,
-0.6502771378,
0.1943428069,
-0.1765028983,
0.1724483222,
0.5114438534,
0.4490173757,
0.2604767978,
-0.5652754307,
0.2403809875,
0.6993722916,
-0.310988307,
-0.0359373055,
0.7893630266,
0.3889480829,
-0.7115706205,
0.9709241986,
-0.4247960746,
-0.6805227399,
1.0291234255,
0.5537629128,
0.8190187216,
0.0687133297,
0.2150173634,
0.0618977249,
0.4828349948,
0.1813308597,
0.3908796906,
-0.19751966,
-0.9578566551,
-0.2945846319,
-0.4546561241,
-0.3870448172,
0.1362858862,
-0.6445542574,
0.3670204282,
-0.5212244391,
-0.2250142097,
0.2937998772,
0.1171518713,
-0.4196389616,
0.3861053288,
0.5015723109,
0.6034219265,
-1.017195344,
0.7228985429,
0.457146436,
-0.2206864208,
-0.3287546039,
0.1603520513,
0.0668726265,
-0.7151794434,
0.5319549441,
0.7618386745,
-0.2910633981,
0.0993944556,
-0.7755230665,
-0.50263834,
0.9586664438,
0.1271245331,
-0.3274631202,
0.1101994812,
0.1649009287,
0.6377844214,
-0.0870517492,
-0.0097268224,
0.31003353,
0.65618819,
-0.4196549356,
-0.5104103684,
-0.0439498052,
-0.546503365,
-0.0273160897,
0.3573442101,
-0.3465514481,
0.5330706239,
-0.1212945879,
-0.4422459006,
0.4293841422,
0.8093755245,
0.2644850016,
0.6189524531,
0.4264938235,
0.4776178002,
1.1016421318,
-0.0096376352,
0.8800315261,
-0.0739851519,
0.2960987985,
0.7166590095,
-0.5579690337,
0.7012127042,
0.131424278,
0.0598054044,
0.6513745189,
0.4423924685,
-0.5012542009,
0.4081968367,
0.2309458703,
-0.3024237156,
0.0001845869,
-0.2756446898,
-0.0919129327,
0.6462348104,
0.3787204325,
-0.6599834561,
0.2061036974,
0.0852411464,
-0.0226946827,
0.329102695,
-0.3017410636,
0.9011120796,
-0.2442294359,
-0.6588246822,
0.010223832,
0.331695497,
0.8677467108,
-0.4414101243,
-0.2016896755,
0.3553661108,
0.3157662749,
-0.163022846,
-0.863514781,
0.480750829,
0.3091262281,
-0.345719099,
-0.55429703,
1.1168242693,
-0.1937352121,
-0.6261023879,
0.1942178011,
0.1358651072,
-0.0562817343,
0.0391697623,
-0.7855621576,
-0.0966871828,
0.1718094498,
0.0827813148,
0.0182850827,
0.3169985712,
-0.0245797336,
0.6566696763,
0.871498704,
-0.0934377909,
0.0974278003,
-0.3389058411,
0.4034564495,
-0.6685999036,
-0.7335674167,
-1.0225464106,
0.3161121309,
-0.5199853778,
-0.2973740399,
0.5735592246,
0.4425466061,
0.7707669139,
-0.0330796354,
1.2248282433,
-0.240497902,
0.363420248,
-0.5969246626,
1.1240104437,
-0.3010299206,
0.1263001114,
-0.452411145,
-0.6660698056,
-0.3226006031,
0.7902463078,
-0.0490880683,
0.1213859171,
0.3137911856,
0.4901802838,
0.216881752,
0.2735095918,
0.0150833502,
-0.2970231771,
0.5817271471,
0.2359896153,
0.8261812925,
-0.3509017825,
0.464941442,
-0.0645248145,
-0.1554552764,
-0.1804666966,
-1.2983417511,
-0.8145499229,
-0.4226632416,
-0.3815402985,
-0.0968908146,
-0.1372997016,
0.6529465914,
0.6481218338,
-0.6958707571,
0.1056895331,
-0.4460648894,
0.177149266,
-0.2381026298,
-0.2805218399,
0.3577845097,
-0.1272926033,
-0.7905567884,
0.0319231972,
0.2421918958,
0.0606989637,
-0.2330192029,
0.0199572016,
-0.3302328587,
0.3387998939,
0.5594081879,
0.1114970595,
-0.672499001,
-0.5046363473,
-0.052820839,
-0.2449352294,
0.135600552,
0.6322859526,
-0.6997244954,
0.3182248175,
0.6672270298,
0.8719641566,
0.0855592266,
0.0758801922,
0.5608662367,
-0.7449611425,
-0.2281166017,
0.5096963048,
0.2585870922,
0.4445626736,
-0.7924636006,
0.407527566,
0.0697303563,
-0.8532658815,
-0.6874773502,
0.2206366956,
-0.7245692611,
-0.4118078947,
0.6875360608,
-0.1950799525,
-0.2679470778,
-0.3021219373,
-0.2847073376,
0.3854698539,
-0.43719244,
1.0786240101,
0.5600751042,
-0.124714911,
0.0578139015,
-0.2941176891,
0.2091481239,
0.2187849432,
-1.2045382261,
-0.0803427696,
0.4489577711,
-0.1011202484,
0.4744674265,
0.5388029218,
0.0837115198,
0.2918421924,
-0.1442615986,
0.2574594319,
0.1666146964,
-0.2942843437,
-0.0160785429,
0.0643684641,
-0.1912404597,
-0.0607601218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09911v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09911v2
|
ChatShop: Interactive Information Seeking with Language Agents
| 2024-04-15T16:35:41 | 2024-06-16T15:24:12 |
Sanxing Chen, Sam Wiseman, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The desire and ability to seek new information strategically are fundamental
to human learning but often overlooked in current language agent evaluation. We
analyze a popular web shopping task designed to test language agents' ability
to perform strategic exploration and discover that it can be reformulated and
solved as a single-turn retrieval task without the need for interactive
information seeking. This finding encourages us to rethink realistic
constraints on information access that would necessitate strategic information
seeking. We then redesign the task to introduce a notion of task ambiguity and
the role of a shopper, serving as a dynamic party with whom the agent
strategically interacts in an open-ended conversation to make informed
decisions. Our experiments demonstrate that the proposed task can effectively
evaluate the agent's ability to explore and gradually accumulate information
through multi-turn interactions. Additionally, we show that large language
model-simulated shoppers serve as a good proxy for real human shoppers,
revealing similar error patterns in agents.
|
[
-0.1859701723,
-0.7441825271,
0.5113484263,
0.1380275488,
0.0617894456,
0.5384970307,
-0.4753592312,
-0.7901559472,
0.1890761405,
0.2609319985,
-0.828964591,
-0.2872745395,
-0.4845861197,
-0.2166809589,
-0.2310964912,
0.5093359351,
0.0881290063,
-0.3024064004,
0.024976261,
0.2054419518,
-0.3224702179,
-0.3656598628,
-1.130338788,
-0.1354161203,
0.6393612027,
0.7009139657,
1.3314868212,
-0.0351779871,
0.3807190359,
0.4549379051,
0.2027124763,
0.2506007552,
-0.5946776867,
0.5511739254,
-0.4213179052,
-0.8159451485,
-0.2575362921,
0.1728225201,
0.2243268937,
0.4735462666,
-0.4467178285,
0.0603449158,
-0.1750912219,
0.6142733693,
-0.8254604936,
0.4660493135,
-0.5033915639,
0.0351895913,
-0.1585687548,
-0.3224193454,
-0.6605764627,
-0.0490142964,
0.4612507522,
-1.0229564905,
0.1345463097,
0.0729702562,
1.0394449234,
0.0107206944,
-0.5734658241,
-0.6273285747,
-1.1406904459,
0.6618704796,
-0.1402774006,
0.6836361289,
0.5883301497,
0.464650631,
-0.321827054,
-0.7688493133,
-0.6492931247,
-0.12441843,
-0.1020875722,
0.1741759628,
-0.7292192578,
-0.0876583681,
0.0978206769,
-0.0512327701,
-0.3351055682,
-0.4229364693,
-0.1652201563,
0.2473392636,
0.662140131,
0.0301010981,
0.6309175491,
-0.010132256,
-0.4329181612,
-0.4740025401,
-0.0833055228,
0.4543148577,
0.5426038504,
0.3070492148,
0.2632567883,
0.5053803325,
-0.2841330171,
0.43291834,
-0.056375891,
0.0179302972,
0.143001616,
-0.2993237376,
0.1031173095,
-0.1765069366,
0.506306529,
0.4181512594,
0.484033227,
-0.213647157,
-0.16971232,
-0.4058622718,
0.7852538824,
-0.3350063264,
-0.0352912582,
0.4531999528,
-0.380741924,
-0.1156827062,
0.3370523155,
-0.9434601665,
-0.136664018,
-0.0324492231,
0.3474387825,
-0.3828321099,
-0.3150988221,
0.2520755529,
-0.6043539643,
0.3210880458,
0.345150888,
-0.740342021,
0.5256237388,
0.4429544806,
0.6576810479,
-0.2601635158,
-0.4793308377,
-0.3228282928,
0.3785587847,
-0.3647772074,
0.9270249009,
-0.8522223234,
-0.3140078783,
0.1798684448,
0.0731455237,
-0.0761733875,
-0.4283540249,
0.4869144857,
-0.8530964255,
0.1327577233,
-0.3508940339,
0.0076412396,
-0.1504089087,
0.5780994296,
-0.6427835226,
0.7355831265,
0.0780526549,
-0.346400857,
0.5504071712,
-0.7410106063,
-0.2703591883,
0.4101214707,
-0.1280407459,
-0.0055451887,
0.072357811,
0.1140683666,
-0.0306795985,
-0.0292148441,
-0.2759618461,
-0.0259421282,
-0.3826254904,
0.7883558869,
-0.4159511626,
0.4151771963,
0.0639540702,
-0.5644958019,
-0.0626143441,
-0.4303604364,
0.0982468575,
0.5577647686,
-0.5567813516,
-0.458553344,
0.5016935468,
0.053831961,
0.0481716804,
0.4999963045,
-0.3772863746,
0.5598157644,
-0.2862139642,
-0.0622703396,
0.6831489205,
-0.090353176,
0.400857836,
-0.4376309216,
0.94149369,
-0.3471542895,
0.5601706505,
-0.0066452851,
-0.4972761869,
-0.9736524224,
0.064415656,
-0.0550903529,
0.5525309443,
-0.9618018866,
-0.2401835322,
-0.0104653025,
-0.448551774,
-0.3673949838,
-0.1647239923,
-0.0110460976,
-0.4643816352,
0.2304043621,
-0.3008187413,
-0.3354138136,
-0.627482295,
-0.4817767143,
-0.1762523055,
-0.1688460857,
0.4565576315,
-0.1950968206,
-0.4349672794,
0.8269568086,
-0.6593354344,
-0.4052758217,
-0.6562584043,
0.2457951009,
0.2081472874,
0.1587650776,
0.1693167239,
-0.9230480194,
-0.4665015042,
0.0459875315,
-0.1679046452,
0.1152046919,
-0.1965054572,
-0.3129844368,
0.1657690108,
0.339129895,
-1.0458230972,
0.6563324332,
0.1610824317,
-0.3588141799,
0.1420916021,
-0.4299824536,
0.2988358438,
-0.5369567275,
-0.1195652932,
-0.2887057662,
0.0471177064,
-0.7866619229,
0.1893743277,
-0.0524658673,
-0.2386051416,
-0.2292666286,
0.5971137881,
-0.7719615698,
0.0075412337,
-0.5524933338,
0.5671465397,
0.0642658323,
0.4424782991,
0.0807255432,
0.6158655882,
0.3015809059,
-0.5857248902,
0.1924557537,
0.3025039136,
-0.2876696587,
0.4998200536,
-0.3611533046,
0.28499192,
-0.2765224278,
0.0079070246,
-1.1374393702,
-0.1674572825,
0.2851040959,
-0.393376559,
0.2758743763,
-0.2071034312,
-0.4055555463,
-0.4308801293,
-0.076080136,
0.4312857985,
0.3901381493,
-0.4929160178,
0.5143301487,
0.5763532519,
-0.2932870686,
-0.6076195836,
-0.3878462315,
0.1443385631,
0.0693507195,
-0.5475142002,
0.1195719168,
0.0520047285,
-0.3530480266,
-0.3501226008,
-0.2651561201,
-0.0215962697,
0.0279165544,
-0.0807929188,
0.1540946364,
0.0790881366,
0.3460352421,
-0.4840735197,
-0.233209908,
0.2574979365,
-0.1683431566,
0.9465739727,
-0.0957709551,
-0.783308804,
-0.023525279,
0.4910364151,
0.2969391048,
-0.2719862461,
0.3087092638,
0.3037723005,
-0.2290526778,
-0.1190885007,
-0.6591770053,
-0.1448802501,
-0.6155698895,
0.4101620615,
-0.2872399092,
-0.2982588112,
0.2351998091,
-0.1186748147,
0.060938675,
0.1688437015,
0.0772409141,
-0.2781504393,
1.4519683123,
0.6666040421,
0.6462877393,
0.5001319647,
-0.0435077138,
0.628755033,
-0.3145659864,
-0.7203505039,
-0.6010176539,
-0.6965178847,
-0.5448845625,
-0.4725151956,
0.3123869002,
0.011950843,
0.0337496996,
0.2544163167,
-0.4143720865,
0.5442141294,
0.8653171062,
0.2213996202,
0.3824807405,
-0.1833849549,
0.0467817299,
-0.0700559467,
-0.5892851353,
-0.4669961035,
0.7225590944,
0.1038615555,
0.8553214073,
0.4699204862,
0.2400577068,
0.0177585166,
-0.262493372,
-1.1561799049,
0.6109690666,
0.1975108236,
-0.5094757676,
-0.3441661298,
-0.034606915,
-1.7574968338,
0.1070450917,
-0.1284705698,
-0.9559781551,
0.4527758658,
-0.0990442038,
-0.0333418772,
0.1415144652,
-0.6868258715,
0.9942461252,
-0.8480449915,
-0.4727782905,
-0.4366476238,
-0.4048786163,
-0.1626777798,
0.2395295799,
0.4483831525,
-0.1749286503,
-0.4156196415,
0.5262762904,
-0.0773946121,
0.6523445249,
-0.0698737726,
0.3198378086,
0.1443336457,
0.5698846579,
0.7417597175,
-0.3682793677,
0.2618688941,
-0.2285780907,
0.1750881523,
-0.6549344063,
-0.8628593087,
0.0946066082,
-0.4853243232,
-1.0106916428,
-0.6074086428,
-0.5022722483,
-0.3892275393,
0.2628007829,
-0.1827075034,
-0.0784182772,
-0.4064094126,
0.1055414602,
0.2585788071,
-0.1067073345,
0.3939164281,
0.8466385603,
-0.2900015116,
0.344104737,
0.7189496756,
-0.1476425678,
0.3243611753,
0.4542526305,
0.3611801565,
-0.2388765514,
-0.2916996777,
-0.2316764593,
-0.0180822816,
-0.7101457715,
0.1875042915,
-0.5648909807,
-0.0075287768,
-0.0815358236,
-0.1051808074,
-0.4420904517,
-0.0832178667,
-0.0206276998,
0.0912946239,
0.21093674,
0.9357131124,
0.0219473001,
0.5004082918,
-0.6250219941,
-0.113393642,
0.4900819361,
0.1569209546,
0.1524312198,
0.0538836792,
-0.1644130498,
0.1606276035,
-0.4414951503,
-1.0926685333,
0.4356961846,
-0.1671868861,
0.8847171664,
0.773994267,
0.2883298695,
0.5747199059,
-0.2687816024,
0.6116353273,
-0.1383721679,
-0.7310194969,
0.5297566652,
-0.2252388746,
0.5230292082,
0.4376263916,
0.8899200559,
-0.8355853558,
-0.3036047816,
-0.8139517903,
-1.1366424561,
0.9018116593,
0.2713348567,
0.1742233038,
-0.3743860126,
-0.2224211395,
-0.0682120249,
0.4488773942,
-0.6321092844,
0.0573852584,
0.1979672462,
0.3353827298,
0.120924823,
-0.2903293669,
0.0156303775,
0.1313710064,
0.6107147932,
-0.0395350121,
0.2473525852,
0.1442017555,
0.1854046285,
-0.3311091065,
0.5249216557,
0.0450740866,
0.7230631709,
-0.1641554534,
0.1383583248,
-0.1867834181,
-0.4223180115,
-0.0976393893,
0.0426470898,
0.0210682172,
-0.0363179706,
-0.0231452398,
0.5963466763,
0.5658785701,
-1.3843306303,
0.7665109038,
-0.2105139047,
0.2136582732,
-0.6209887862,
0.2005590945,
-0.0026499205,
0.5969236493,
0.5817075968,
0.0676807314,
0.3181881607,
-1.2018270493,
0.2092625946,
0.8428999186,
-0.4950214922,
-0.0263933111,
0.3441640139,
-0.0776592121,
-0.9991502166,
0.8231630921,
-0.4097647965,
-0.5746022463,
0.407772541,
0.3558804393,
0.7996460199,
-0.4597815573,
0.6195514202,
0.0867664963,
0.5646259189,
0.0296579972,
0.3886347413,
-0.2762013674,
-0.7856715322,
-0.0359244235,
-0.1409427822,
-0.8064509034,
-0.1293384731,
-0.5766304731,
0.4658969939,
0.1657473445,
-0.2407269478,
-0.2889322042,
-0.0374625996,
-0.7959709167,
-0.1344394535,
-0.2513358593,
0.6950416565,
-0.075143151,
0.5952601433,
0.470302254,
-0.3590692878,
-0.5447018147,
0.383009702,
-0.0948234126,
-0.9717975855,
0.4780486822,
0.0738660172,
-0.1721271127,
-0.5170875788,
-0.3745011687,
-1.1677316427,
0.8585211039,
-0.0877511129,
-0.4611082077,
-0.4406065941,
0.3367006779,
0.5523641109,
-0.0801864713,
0.7225677371,
0.6237309575,
0.5481875539,
0.5644102693,
-0.7004688978,
-0.053250134,
-0.3795489073,
-0.5049805045,
0.3146462142,
-0.8285484314,
0.8917815685,
-0.2507896721,
-0.5918633938,
-0.0418283939,
0.0389109738,
0.0119319055,
0.4426726997,
0.8497598171,
0.0272453073,
0.8705650568,
-0.0802956372,
0.9837584496,
0.050388474,
0.079011403,
1.1084517241,
-0.2043294162,
1.1763648987,
0.3432300687,
-0.0680745989,
0.4583086669,
0.3691997528,
0.1830541492,
0.2680995762,
0.2138664126,
-0.2096639276,
-0.4527253211,
-0.0177709665,
0.2766883969,
0.8801324964,
0.4424780905,
0.0871685371,
-0.2852060497,
-0.0789116099,
-0.1445449591,
0.0255796332,
0.0586679094,
0.8232910633,
-0.3764491975,
-0.8053745031,
0.1650126129,
-0.0442755595,
0.2359127551,
-0.9101295471,
0.0436537825,
0.03612433,
0.2063948661,
0.085639514,
-0.7829616666,
0.2086206377,
-0.3724626303,
0.2467969507,
-0.2876935303,
0.8003640771,
-0.4227074087,
-0.2383771241,
0.6079339981,
0.712567687,
0.1899779439,
-0.3187623024,
-0.7485515475,
0.0258060787,
-0.0017817745,
-0.4846301377,
0.3051169813,
0.4598489702,
0.0830700248,
0.820057869,
0.6763334274,
-0.2283555269,
-0.070473887,
-0.1344766617,
0.5383067131,
-0.7254052758,
-0.4228518605,
-0.44791013,
0.2533909678,
-0.3125842512,
-0.1112861633,
0.5991600156,
0.7286171317,
1.0415832996,
0.0633701459,
0.5969055891,
0.1318078935,
0.4219149947,
-0.2892131507,
0.52375108,
-0.6791665554,
0.3197637498,
-0.2687952518,
-0.7151222229,
0.3221506476,
0.6719465256,
-0.2387027293,
0.0322986916,
0.8095138073,
0.4087763429,
-0.2832754254,
0.3691989183,
0.3424604535,
0.2372382283,
0.2218865007,
0.5863297582,
1.1709316969,
-0.2024516761,
0.9939153194,
-0.473803848,
-0.4003399014,
-0.1763361245,
-0.6110708714,
-0.8727924824,
-0.7386819124,
-0.0795865506,
-0.2456457466,
-0.0282423627,
1.1472728252,
0.5789322257,
-0.3473656774,
-0.7207798958,
0.154155001,
0.2453490645,
-0.4269959927,
-0.2975233197,
-0.065096572,
-0.7301489711,
-1.2005037069,
0.683829546,
0.4330227077,
0.1354894042,
-0.1565330625,
0.2074495703,
-0.5190563798,
0.4672550261,
0.4529505074,
0.3067852557,
-0.5589290857,
-0.2394714803,
0.4052073956,
0.0786584392,
0.1965096742,
1.0983703136,
-0.6584050655,
0.7937941551,
0.2405316532,
0.666526854,
0.9163888097,
-0.15820162,
0.7481927872,
-0.4272554219,
0.2506271005,
0.237374261,
0.099644132,
-0.0412480757,
-0.4440957308,
0.3982768953,
-0.0905404836,
-0.4638246894,
-0.2275365144,
0.359387666,
-1.0400514603,
-0.5507393479,
1.0245999098,
0.1882600486,
-0.2203596532,
-0.3617336452,
-0.5914050937,
-0.0053366027,
-0.5850515962,
0.9446294308,
0.8185889125,
-0.1432679445,
-0.2987725139,
-0.5517100096,
0.4812558293,
0.273538202,
-0.6549285054,
0.0104201753,
0.2208766341,
-0.1773550063,
0.3687899709,
0.7093533278,
0.3679183722,
0.256953299,
-0.0284939408,
-0.0847888142,
0.5261613727,
-0.4071611762,
0.4760181904,
0.3168050647,
0.2482192814,
-0.2095338851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09897v1
|
Progressive Knowledge Graph Completion
| 2024-04-15T16:16:59 | 2024-04-15T16:16:59 |
Jiayi Li, Ruilin Luo, Jiaqi Sun, Jing Xiao, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Knowledge Graph Completion (KGC) has emerged as a promising solution to
address the issue of incompleteness within Knowledge Graphs (KGs). Traditional
KGC research primarily centers on triple classification and link prediction.
Nevertheless, we contend that these tasks do not align well with real-world
scenarios and merely serve as surrogate benchmarks. In this paper, we
investigate three crucial processes relevant to real-world construction
scenarios: (a) the verification process, which arises from the necessity and
limitations of human verifiers; (b) the mining process, which identifies the
most promising candidates for verification; and (c) the training process, which
harnesses verified data for subsequent utilization; in order to achieve a
transition toward more realistic challenges. By integrating these three
processes, we introduce the Progressive Knowledge Graph Completion (PKGC) task,
which simulates the gradual completion of KGs in real-world scenarios.
Furthermore, to expedite PKGC processing, we propose two acceleration modules:
Optimized Top-$k$ algorithm and Semantic Validity Filter. These modules
significantly enhance the efficiency of the mining procedure. Our experiments
demonstrate that performance in link prediction does not accurately reflect
performance in PKGC. A more in-depth analysis reveals the key factors
influencing the results and provides potential directions for future research.
|
[
-0.6632701159,
-0.7645246387,
0.7227967381,
-0.1969369203,
-0.0014885194,
0.487131834,
0.0407472998,
-0.4894119799,
-0.3221963048,
0.2698048353,
-0.6410586238,
-0.6172317863,
-0.63982898,
0.1160917357,
-0.1967210919,
0.6455329061,
-0.6429120302,
-0.5249388218,
-0.4870822132,
0.0594899096,
-0.6696534753,
-0.0285357405,
-0.4479697049,
-0.839193821,
0.4582819343,
0.3537291288,
0.861214757,
0.844519496,
0.1598771513,
0.2597785294,
-0.1718194038,
0.3012049794,
-0.4642463028,
0.0529336482,
0.2390294075,
-0.3790107071,
-0.4230935574,
0.1708345115,
0.6083655953,
0.9166205525,
-0.0031656753,
0.0999174938,
0.0378972441,
0.9100558758,
-0.7635010481,
0.3928158879,
-0.1900375783,
0.2927425802,
0.0113846287,
0.2382400036,
-0.1467683464,
-0.5939469337,
0.2019102424,
-0.5534343719,
0.1797449291,
0.1222995296,
0.8192735314,
-0.0581227839,
-0.6837197542,
-0.3655961752,
-0.4682767987,
0.1898900121,
-0.3644715548,
0.777849853,
0.8210830092,
0.4887956679,
-0.4262045026,
-1.2036570311,
-0.5946412086,
-0.5542708039,
-0.2366339713,
0.2345091999,
0.500631988,
0.3023334146,
0.5675370693,
0.345109731,
-0.3419962227,
-0.1699352115,
-0.4734809697,
-0.5384392142,
0.1762177795,
0.2042462975,
-0.0504852049,
-0.2155587077,
-0.105229266,
-0.1108322963,
-0.8701908588,
0.3338679969,
0.6819548011,
0.0604342148,
-0.00394363,
0.5667883158,
-0.8657763004,
0.7973613739,
-0.3151780665,
-0.1886279434,
0.4426603913,
-0.3950792551,
-0.0722838342,
-0.0357693173,
0.3428967297,
0.0328146704,
0.2498481125,
-0.5973959565,
0.1686441302,
0.2026318759,
0.6402562857,
-0.4075789452,
-0.5522370934,
0.3114848137,
-0.3395705223,
-0.2466254383,
-0.0744785964,
-0.1853792965,
-0.1297685951,
-0.462779671,
0.3039643466,
-0.4025541842,
-0.445468843,
-0.1041429937,
-0.2992570102,
0.076118581,
0.2706978917,
-0.1939012855,
-0.1313165426,
0.7527197003,
0.8429111838,
0.1984141469,
-0.3783688843,
-0.2367220074,
0.2500865757,
-0.4920002818,
0.5792785883,
-0.5441117287,
-0.4709950984,
0.0007217537,
0.020736482,
0.1027291268,
-0.3757318258,
0.8194676042,
-0.8808815479,
-0.1369045824,
-0.5238482952,
-0.5244802833,
-0.0989843979,
0.8626909852,
-0.4574082494,
1.101805687,
0.4047572911,
-1.014436245,
0.6194857955,
-0.2624068558,
-0.4988325536,
0.1454785168,
0.0871917084,
-0.4683795273,
-0.1410301179,
-0.1979014277,
0.4861183167,
-0.0105621004,
0.0478113443,
-0.3639054298,
-0.3475510776,
-0.0963877961,
0.1861504912,
0.2590302527,
0.3070213199,
-0.1844319701,
-0.2868201733,
-0.8171738386,
0.3004241288,
-0.2968639731,
-0.5677515268,
0.0161772054,
0.2226767242,
-0.8364279866,
0.2881631851,
0.1409601718,
-0.5244040489,
0.2462958843,
-0.3939216733,
0.1667616516,
0.7194308639,
0.0260931347,
0.2023040354,
-0.2277695835,
0.4663119316,
-0.1878136545,
0.2505523562,
0.1239403561,
-0.7439101934,
-0.5711135864,
0.0496188626,
0.6676890254,
0.5087893605,
-1.0410429239,
0.1496529877,
-0.4488817751,
-0.7891030908,
-0.0858346596,
-0.0658356324,
0.4468106627,
0.8524819016,
0.0550351292,
-0.3682045639,
-0.4838443696,
-0.4949151576,
-0.1777410358,
-0.6039494276,
-0.2420312017,
0.4382701516,
0.3394342959,
-0.07365302,
0.9472068548,
-0.7022605538,
-0.0707926452,
0.0811245069,
0.3165532053,
0.4641956985,
0.2953127623,
-0.076878421,
-1.1918295622,
-0.6991320848,
0.1628243923,
-0.8690260053,
0.1683541834,
0.3055872023,
-0.0703658462,
-0.4363610446,
0.5906355381,
-0.4447799027,
0.541279614,
0.2837207913,
-0.1949571818,
0.7215367556,
-0.1420889795,
0.4541724026,
-0.4772336483,
0.0819234326,
-0.3322786987,
-0.2965053022,
-0.560831368,
0.1184661835,
0.1191333905,
-0.0033448208,
-0.1735079437,
0.0920203254,
-0.4062562585,
0.1548061967,
-0.2511517704,
0.2549757659,
-0.2414582819,
0.489846766,
-0.2995699048,
0.3207205236,
0.5304149985,
-0.9565471411,
0.6178799272,
0.1186510175,
-0.5322799683,
0.472410202,
-0.3195117116,
0.1542587429,
-0.3686547279,
0.341368854,
-1.1205108166,
-0.4460025132,
0.5063010454,
-0.7011690736,
0.2558528483,
-0.383700043,
-0.6747224927,
-0.8898547292,
-0.2188608348,
0.2629697323,
0.7665030956,
-0.2781507969,
0.8073754311,
0.048128739,
0.2395861298,
-0.598086834,
-0.4024353623,
0.029884832,
0.0922215655,
-0.6262090802,
0.439186573,
0.1754983664,
0.2451361865,
0.2494496405,
-0.3590706587,
0.1153363287,
0.283523351,
0.5776869655,
0.0183345973,
0.3049092293,
-0.056212604,
-0.2322976142,
-0.3008677959,
-0.0194336232,
-0.4088150263,
0.2570877373,
0.2843259275,
-0.3538187444,
-0.3179394603,
-0.2450442165,
0.3594921529,
0.1893336028,
0.6803075075,
0.6869617701,
-0.4135226607,
0.1259341389,
-0.7108248472,
0.1942947209,
-0.4295931458,
0.3534850776,
-0.6043378711,
-1.0058841705,
0.5593964458,
-0.830278039,
0.0718259662,
0.3425320685,
0.2880679071,
-0.177292943,
1.0892760754,
0.4331203997,
0.1717321873,
0.1816458106,
-0.3455126584,
0.4586186707,
-0.995891273,
-0.7235745788,
-0.5908293128,
-0.2274135053,
-0.7540838122,
-0.1799088866,
0.6181866527,
0.5692589283,
-0.1682627946,
0.7877058983,
-0.3774894476,
0.3000651002,
0.3365318477,
0.1919439286,
0.313773185,
0.0872001052,
-0.6196724772,
0.2434048802,
-0.7924755216,
-0.205490768,
1.0807110071,
0.2062553912,
0.1483318955,
-0.2190791368,
0.4584397078,
0.4750454128,
0.5389811993,
-0.4522957206,
0.6062162519,
0.0858950019,
-0.5385143161,
-0.1405617297,
-0.7124372721,
-0.7895706296,
-0.1329598278,
-0.2843299508,
-0.6399792433,
-0.0862604976,
0.2417279333,
-0.0413370207,
0.2551972866,
-0.5743495226,
0.7641957402,
0.3520053327,
-0.3167827725,
-0.425919205,
-0.7573074102,
0.2380951047,
0.0685795099,
0.5180166364,
-0.1905766726,
0.1953594685,
0.3119957149,
-0.5781365633,
0.5839053392,
-0.4577203095,
0.0685703903,
0.5893186331,
-0.032467667,
1.1031011343,
-0.0452486947,
-0.0586956702,
-0.0882018879,
-0.377740562,
-0.4277959168,
-0.5121651292,
0.5176067948,
-0.6759971976,
-0.4129118621,
0.0672812387,
-0.1143955886,
-0.6276138425,
0.1156453714,
0.2532211542,
0.1662899703,
0.0739197135,
-0.0475766733,
0.3786334991,
0.0943892822,
0.0531577356,
-0.0751458332,
0.248491466,
-0.6987136602,
0.8628413677,
0.3710811436,
0.2446213067,
0.2122111619,
0.0840721577,
-0.3838563859,
-0.9434841871,
-0.359271735,
0.1040512323,
-0.8186860085,
-0.2103751451,
-0.8121999502,
-0.269359231,
-0.448415786,
-0.1898280978,
-0.2281544805,
-0.1533255875,
0.1947994679,
-0.1298712194,
0.0075320494,
0.7163999081,
-0.0708962083,
0.2718764842,
-0.896663785,
0.3571762443,
0.5680154562,
0.7791250348,
0.2568678558,
0.0170200318,
-0.6053570509,
0.1299160272,
-0.248669669,
-0.4270969629,
-0.3227087259,
-0.0995213017,
0.7412058711,
0.1354733855,
0.104265146,
0.7035556436,
-0.323966682,
0.7290051579,
0.1969344914,
-0.4233363867,
0.5428536534,
-0.2488749623,
0.1328034848,
0.7854325771,
0.8081312776,
-0.4918917716,
-0.262088716,
-0.7360162139,
-1.0472054482,
0.5007933974,
0.5591448545,
-0.2643203139,
0.0238608737,
0.8091210723,
-0.1889689416,
0.2504443526,
-0.4717692435,
-0.101184167,
-0.2145569474,
0.0873763561,
0.4633709788,
-0.3455485404,
-0.0469583422,
0.0884026885,
0.9773269892,
-0.0616848804,
0.0007715753,
0.2877665162,
-0.009740849,
0.0631058365,
-0.1405551285,
-0.0876941755,
0.8066569567,
-0.2358087599,
-0.0575864837,
0.3925056159,
-0.5868452191,
0.2528441548,
-0.1097357571,
-0.1471745372,
-0.3309455812,
0.6433246136,
0.5793136954,
-0.1031048372,
-0.3351646364,
0.3331243694,
0.1954745948,
-0.1442091465,
-0.2012906671,
0.1923890859,
0.0349303819,
0.3004513979,
0.2903611362,
0.0102010565,
0.0714570805,
-0.4115237296,
0.054927215,
0.1701817811,
-0.4326055646,
-0.2528205216,
0.4406198561,
0.0286697932,
-0.0835897028,
1.0543392897,
-0.6029627323,
-0.7693914771,
0.6825749874,
-0.0194346718,
0.6820590496,
0.146936506,
0.1399222463,
0.6946082115,
0.0908277854,
-0.4009165168,
0.015676206,
-0.6064149141,
-0.659319818,
-0.821151197,
-0.709597826,
-0.2257137299,
-0.5253447294,
-0.2060788721,
0.2762195766,
-0.2792397738,
-0.3680230975,
-0.4773383439,
0.2202506214,
-0.5976505876,
0.4203574359,
0.1495171934,
0.9692884088,
-0.7091343999,
0.6533623934,
0.7279112339,
-0.0040245047,
-0.9532366991,
-0.0982564092,
-0.1179785356,
-0.6970161796,
0.7146368027,
0.0909178779,
-0.0295287091,
0.1559776217,
-0.2496652305,
-0.5507085919,
1.4730075598,
-0.0326024853,
-0.2161022127,
-0.2358653843,
0.2897259295,
0.3189504445,
0.0017334188,
-0.010941416,
0.3638130426,
0.639564991,
0.8739621639,
-0.9132380486,
0.1103143692,
0.1819751859,
-0.0214775056,
0.4686982036,
-0.5195646882,
0.4482500255,
-0.0616029352,
-0.2884836793,
0.0252822824,
0.5911816359,
0.554579258,
0.3689861298,
0.8749539256,
1.0869082212,
0.6049128175,
-0.2765234709,
0.9361325502,
-0.2782559097,
0.4243939221,
0.5123541951,
-0.0271511879,
0.469818145,
-0.04577066,
-0.8945073485,
0.6560163498,
0.9173902869,
0.0646731481,
0.6624470949,
0.242368713,
-0.3879254758,
-0.5406461358,
-0.2979077697,
-0.6220005155,
0.2214253396,
0.0459739752,
-0.0519524589,
-0.2354561985,
-0.2089393437,
0.0736748502,
-0.2207732946,
-0.5684977174,
0.5071339011,
-0.1754698604,
-0.8873509765,
0.2205011249,
0.0643564388,
0.3573739529,
-0.9756678343,
-0.1242584884,
0.0379924625,
-0.0280655753,
-0.4293875396,
-0.6424927711,
0.343693763,
-0.4805266857,
-0.0089495508,
-0.2573864758,
1.0009157658,
-0.0336329304,
-0.3633019924,
0.13807033,
0.2724061012,
0.0120748123,
-0.1867700517,
-0.228457734,
-0.2424518019,
0.0309307482,
-0.1688260734,
0.4637534916,
0.5149912238,
-0.0878842697,
0.7381950617,
0.8328903317,
0.1773920506,
0.0004253915,
-0.1057228372,
1.0435019732,
-0.4770085514,
-0.4019855261,
-0.7571484447,
0.6325057745,
-0.1623022705,
0.085705854,
0.6212718487,
0.5817898512,
0.9945631623,
0.1733545065,
0.5773990154,
-0.4936456978,
0.2091545612,
-0.5213387012,
0.503025651,
-0.1893901527,
0.0855360925,
-0.3459861577,
-0.8097595572,
-0.206593588,
0.2653828859,
-0.0486956984,
0.0090913624,
0.6117443442,
0.4899390638,
0.0883199945,
0.2153625637,
0.2003259212,
0.0499627292,
0.2745783329,
0.6736789346,
0.8695306182,
-0.5297852755,
0.861765027,
-0.4015920758,
-0.1552974731,
0.3227130771,
-1.2705205679,
-0.614241004,
-0.4937007725,
-0.6888028979,
-0.7230455279,
0.066778563,
0.3302244544,
0.8161274195,
-0.5074221492,
0.0874634236,
-0.593134582,
0.4914681911,
-0.2612951994,
-0.1397061199,
0.4775149524,
-0.2655658722,
-0.1685499847,
0.230848521,
0.2489661425,
-0.0654773489,
-0.0728344396,
-0.2244799584,
-0.2365650535,
-0.647739172,
0.3714839518,
0.2964062989,
-0.313757062,
-0.5531675816,
-0.2417011559,
0.4717514217,
0.061638575,
0.9728546739,
-1.4219511747,
0.5986606479,
0.8228738904,
0.5310447216,
0.8044041991,
0.0235178061,
0.3850552142,
-0.8138307929,
-0.240573898,
-0.0661682859,
0.0778728575,
0.1730086058,
-0.2468349785,
0.8644641042,
0.815931201,
-0.4712668955,
-0.7431177497,
0.4327878058,
-0.3865780234,
0.0435745567,
0.6503505111,
-0.4737783074,
-0.0255614445,
-0.607445538,
0.2706119716,
0.5537307262,
0.2281856537,
0.7038016915,
1.1754102707,
-0.3033578396,
0.2511012256,
-0.7453221679,
0.4026681781,
-0.1509103477,
-0.376558423,
0.0854518116,
0.4813953042,
0.2588422894,
0.3364760578,
0.7551228404,
-0.1404018253,
0.1374364942,
0.1206526235,
-0.3179785609,
-0.4546891153,
-0.2482627481,
0.4928333759,
0.9070772529,
0.1929645091,
0.0727245957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09894v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09894v3
|
Glitch Tokens in Large Language Models: Categorization Taxonomy and Effective Detection
| 2024-04-15T16:06:36 | 2024-04-19T11:08:36 |
Yuxi Li, Yi Liu, Gelei Deng, Ying Zhang, Wenjia Song, Ling Shi, Kailong Wang, Yuekang Li, Yang Liu, Haoyu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
With the expanding application of Large Language Models (LLMs) in various
domains, it becomes imperative to comprehensively investigate their unforeseen
behaviors and consequent outcomes. In this study, we introduce and
systematically explore the phenomenon of "glitch tokens", which are anomalous
tokens produced by established tokenizers and could potentially compromise the
models' quality of response. Specifically, we experiment on seven top popular
LLMs utilizing three distinct tokenizers and involving a totally of 182,517
tokens. We present categorizations of the identified glitch tokens and symptoms
exhibited by LLMs when interacting with glitch tokens. Based on our observation
that glitch tokens tend to cluster in the embedding space, we propose
GlitchHunter, a novel iterative clustering-based technique, for efficient
glitch token detection. The evaluation shows that our approach notably
outperforms three baseline methods on eight open-source LLMs. To the best of
our knowledge, we present the first comprehensive study on glitch tokens. Our
new detection further provides valuable insights into mitigating
tokenization-related errors in LLMs.
|
[
-0.1632557958,
-1.0208208561,
0.5085502863,
0.0943193436,
-0.3732235134,
0.520390749,
-0.0124166775,
-0.5119040012,
0.6663502455,
0.443742156,
-0.2835580409,
-0.5107356906,
-0.7933840156,
-0.114946261,
-0.9182111025,
0.6562461853,
0.0950612947,
-0.0298702177,
-0.2512582242,
-0.0970301181,
-0.7063190341,
-0.9296132922,
-0.7297756076,
-0.0522273108,
0.4162542224,
-0.0061453111,
0.6702927351,
0.6206284165,
0.6811676025,
0.347468257,
-0.3723711073,
0.0045058201,
-0.2594906688,
0.0198691376,
-0.0399574749,
-0.5819714665,
-0.4633215964,
-0.4377180338,
0.636066556,
0.6204490066,
-0.2079162449,
0.1643003076,
-0.1114063486,
0.2401795238,
-0.6049457192,
-0.0324614905,
-0.8237615824,
0.0551237203,
-0.5885620117,
-0.1703576893,
-0.4875777662,
-0.030312283,
-0.3855943084,
-0.293735981,
0.2220802754,
0.3917820454,
0.3985458612,
0.1711613536,
-0.23985672,
-0.5400633216,
-0.4952761829,
0.7763012052,
-0.916301012,
0.0507516898,
0.2760775685,
0.3729020357,
-0.6799096465,
-0.5475798845,
-0.5903850198,
-0.2029799223,
-0.2182868272,
-0.4451402128,
-0.5265754461,
0.011069729,
0.2417190671,
0.6120558977,
-0.5602830648,
0.5696451068,
0.0271975864,
-0.5430597067,
0.2376606464,
0.5175296068,
0.5054637194,
-0.1700300425,
-0.0851612464,
0.3258709908,
-0.7364872098,
0.0155428732,
0.6487058401,
0.3265646696,
0.167988494,
0.5345870852,
0.0471495688,
0.6877018213,
-0.2624183297,
-0.0880904198,
0.1967262924,
-0.451084584,
0.0088070994,
-0.1024635807,
0.5725041628,
0.237376675,
0.1214390621,
-0.3531614244,
-0.4022996724,
0.0375658982,
0.1057385132,
-0.473241806,
0.0160533674,
0.4466700852,
-0.4498865008,
-0.483874768,
0.1302261502,
-0.5633378029,
-0.7422201037,
0.0768798441,
0.3499664366,
-0.1211177483,
-0.527747333,
0.1712888479,
-0.1728007644,
-0.0885762945,
0.1832832545,
-0.7646751404,
0.1439089179,
0.809674859,
0.977047205,
-0.4150883257,
-0.35304299,
-0.7998452783,
0.1185225993,
-0.3354487419,
0.8219193816,
-0.5153853297,
-0.5123570561,
0.2632770836,
0.069455944,
-0.0463751219,
-0.7076303959,
-0.0214593466,
-0.4855840504,
0.0127417715,
-0.1595584154,
-0.6616185308,
-0.0152488183,
0.4223362505,
-0.6191427112,
0.8635727167,
-0.0933344141,
-0.7579366565,
0.5084004998,
-0.4510267377,
-0.2415156513,
0.3099056482,
-0.0829438195,
-0.2560395896,
0.4788807333,
-0.037920136,
0.3727372587,
-0.0982505828,
0.3976384997,
-0.2926796675,
-0.7473314404,
0.6450469494,
-0.2106846869,
0.4361453652,
-0.2740440071,
-0.2446295172,
0.4403087795,
-0.6370326281,
-0.0909762755,
0.1582223475,
-0.3557045758,
-0.387780875,
0.008001402,
0.1167938113,
-0.0057131136,
0.0073009506,
-0.525883317,
0.3996455669,
-0.34985888,
0.6589366794,
0.7461739182,
0.1230564266,
0.0701824352,
-0.1758581549,
0.4868770242,
0.3604691923,
0.2260783464,
-0.551014185,
-0.4901163876,
-0.6506846547,
-0.6433613896,
0.3856182098,
0.3336385787,
-0.6584031582,
0.6087085009,
-0.1499971449,
-0.33103773,
-0.383829236,
-0.0376293659,
0.3097845316,
0.0240526255,
0.3193411231,
-0.4770669043,
-0.3448304832,
-0.6704521775,
-0.5890975595,
-0.152753517,
-0.1449081153,
-0.04655312,
0.6170937419,
-0.6538109183,
0.8845048547,
-0.1763392985,
-0.514742732,
-0.100692451,
0.0674576238,
0.2270512283,
0.3696018159,
0.713920176,
-0.3683071434,
-0.0895716846,
-0.1230578274,
-0.2874953747,
0.1280608028,
-0.0259179715,
0.3639423847,
0.3991787136,
1.0376626253,
-0.4370314479,
0.5758829117,
0.5392697453,
-0.5540074706,
0.6443164349,
-0.1286629438,
-0.0013510034,
-0.772785008,
0.223553136,
-0.4232693911,
-0.1846264601,
-0.7007971406,
0.106769301,
-0.120102033,
0.3538777828,
-0.4137740433,
0.7113819718,
-0.1863768846,
-0.2610552609,
-0.3426670432,
0.0185520891,
-0.4579543471,
0.2237963974,
-0.5610275269,
0.5437610149,
0.5951532125,
-0.3255428076,
0.5702542067,
0.1306038499,
-0.4061689377,
0.1582995802,
-0.4041899443,
0.3521048725,
-0.1628834456,
0.3080706298,
-1.3808239698,
-0.4355949759,
0.4366055429,
-0.4466953278,
0.3080485761,
-0.3126194179,
-0.9823589921,
-0.4382686019,
-0.5201190114,
0.6284495592,
0.0920327306,
-0.6434695125,
0.4991831183,
0.4028782845,
-0.0094504226,
-0.4022274911,
-0.6468706131,
0.4402564764,
-0.3631889522,
-0.2810569406,
0.0606362335,
-0.0240012351,
-0.0878195614,
0.1362415999,
-0.0593759045,
0.1756053716,
0.3317761123,
0.1925947368,
0.1821062565,
-0.0800961629,
0.1750083566,
-0.3577185571,
-0.2017274499,
-0.0605940782,
-0.0758722946,
0.9857715964,
-0.1380180568,
-0.8809233308,
-0.1962273568,
0.3127009869,
0.8731295466,
-0.1817060411,
0.7724759579,
0.5206579566,
-0.5069200397,
0.027382141,
-0.7062225938,
-0.0965607911,
-0.4832036793,
0.4564538896,
-0.0563810281,
-1.4061716795,
0.9825201631,
-0.0647768453,
-0.0738831908,
0.2767561674,
0.4795687795,
0.4092276096,
1.2251091003,
0.6432769895,
-0.4624400139,
0.449320823,
0.0867611244,
0.6148670912,
-0.7101201415,
-0.2705988586,
-0.7232581973,
-0.2194888741,
-0.6485269666,
-0.5717728734,
0.1738739908,
0.1538217217,
-0.0671153441,
-0.0222162101,
-0.2749904096,
0.6937366724,
0.3194299638,
-0.3474117517,
0.3775944412,
0.1367773712,
-0.3420891464,
0.0928484946,
-0.4740740061,
-0.272818923,
0.8758125305,
0.4772191644,
0.5118310452,
0.3384059072,
0.6726923585,
0.3350493908,
0.236507684,
-1.0909063816,
0.4476338029,
-0.2258157581,
-0.5682247281,
-0.3749583066,
-0.2622616887,
-0.8471465707,
0.1582209468,
-0.1284395009,
-1.3435224295,
0.0368493386,
0.280698061,
-0.1984243542,
0.4364501238,
-0.3503859937,
0.8293399215,
-0.137220487,
0.070133619,
-0.2668996751,
-0.2316503972,
0.3737545609,
-0.3567338884,
0.645395875,
-0.111355193,
0.139219135,
0.4769234657,
-0.2862789929,
0.8307774663,
-0.3236881793,
-0.1024524048,
0.1619550437,
0.3515181839,
0.6014350057,
-0.1213260964,
0.2036042809,
0.4405084252,
-0.0453525297,
-0.4262652099,
-0.4231653214,
0.5915995836,
-0.2694408894,
-0.5645999312,
-0.3587734103,
-0.2594390213,
-0.2577495873,
0.2481393069,
0.1950928569,
0.4415526092,
-0.0600113347,
0.1928045005,
0.2204100341,
-0.4607309401,
0.5587275028,
0.4403640032,
-0.8169818521,
-0.348536253,
1.1554865837,
0.0605167523,
0.0597159863,
-0.0462148078,
0.1280596405,
-0.09649463,
-0.998935163,
-0.2555637062,
0.244409889,
-0.6989740133,
-0.3300867975,
-0.4214954972,
-0.1540438831,
-0.0043495977,
0.039520286,
-0.1473503113,
-0.2112416625,
-0.1555178314,
-0.0867478848,
0.2128916085,
0.8954583406,
0.1241131276,
0.4769165218,
-0.884845078,
0.0518550389,
0.1709784865,
0.5543562174,
0.3426774144,
-0.3976789415,
-0.2821687758,
-0.2384779453,
0.2042261958,
-0.6588087678,
0.0869371593,
0.0358557999,
0.6253755093,
0.3879720569,
-0.4233071208,
0.6859328747,
-0.4741913974,
1.1074649096,
0.3647231758,
-1.1961550713,
0.3359332383,
-0.4005288184,
0.204786554,
0.1831129342,
-0.1704196185,
-0.9752476215,
-0.7595632076,
-0.3692088127,
-1.3466069698,
0.6033930779,
-0.1599264145,
0.4790039659,
-0.4320972264,
0.3984897137,
0.0294090714,
0.5593129396,
-0.4920399189,
-0.1052577272,
0.0384146497,
0.0779546648,
-0.095880568,
-0.4948089719,
0.0185086802,
-0.1128317788,
0.4689010978,
-0.3758897483,
0.2254788876,
-0.2323888391,
-0.3463994861,
-0.4036685824,
0.2264697254,
0.7678104043,
0.6636713743,
0.0420425683,
0.1612041593,
0.0601270497,
-0.4425792694,
0.0189053565,
-0.3576193154,
0.1498218626,
0.1435444653,
0.5424747467,
0.6658668518,
0.3570217192,
-0.7932480574,
0.7032479048,
-0.0610481091,
0.1327240318,
-0.2251384258,
0.1104275361,
0.0339413546,
0.1674916297,
0.5665867925,
-0.1282432228,
0.2689857185,
-0.5053240657,
0.0575839318,
0.7693995237,
-0.1554413885,
-0.3048370779,
0.35470891,
0.0004583843,
-0.3271814585,
0.4061717391,
-0.2475686669,
-0.7473160625,
0.6384692192,
0.5700229406,
0.9253517985,
-0.2132511586,
0.1693131477,
0.0250971392,
0.3816866279,
-0.1713702083,
-0.0725809932,
0.4130888283,
-0.6955211163,
-0.5211747289,
-0.7914329171,
-0.5541695952,
0.3178183734,
-0.4698452055,
0.1660112292,
-0.4870946407,
-0.2548903823,
0.0226192754,
-0.3908281922,
-0.5059986711,
-0.3221791983,
0.206261307,
0.9530048966,
-0.744006753,
0.5412449241,
0.8908658028,
0.0117329061,
-0.5930930376,
0.2572712898,
0.1115326732,
-1.0053542852,
0.350525856,
0.3868904114,
0.1020996347,
0.102853924,
-0.4830951691,
-0.7872113585,
0.8782937527,
0.17736803,
-0.6134656072,
0.0534928925,
0.5146985054,
0.6320261359,
-0.2375225574,
0.0693071783,
0.8292579651,
0.4574025571,
0.2351220548,
-1.1063289642,
0.1627675593,
-0.0167395808,
0.1088666841,
0.5042555928,
-0.5768752694,
0.7862213254,
0.0283641275,
-0.1017533168,
0.2443085313,
-0.0239967499,
0.2091665864,
0.172791481,
0.5383881927,
0.5930068493,
0.8877889514,
-0.2200045735,
0.7419332266,
-0.2211091667,
0.5143504739,
0.6916690469,
-0.125286743,
0.7075744867,
0.6652416587,
-0.082489118,
0.2899317741,
0.4746097922,
-0.2100499123,
0.3516525924,
0.7314007878,
-0.2397413254,
-0.3013073802,
-0.0579643548,
-0.2198433578,
0.5058248043,
0.5032126307,
-0.0385038182,
-0.3406903744,
0.1419787854,
0.1466139108,
-0.3673160374,
-0.5705815554,
0.7260212302,
-0.0535427593,
-0.2898004651,
0.346095413,
0.1634473652,
0.8816125393,
-0.334985435,
0.0562954731,
-0.3931950629,
0.2224201858,
-0.3398276865,
-0.4490531087,
0.3051556945,
-0.0425089486,
-0.0194911119,
0.1262907237,
0.7871583104,
-0.2371193469,
-0.2408814132,
0.4146607816,
0.4647576213,
0.0882012695,
-0.3752613068,
-0.2990144789,
0.5365350842,
-0.2265380919,
-0.2289387435,
0.6238073707,
0.3466982543,
-0.3749668598,
0.568379879,
0.7080759406,
0.0015423534,
0.1895500124,
-0.0414664038,
1.0364601612,
-0.6897799373,
-0.4459134936,
-1.0194311142,
0.7418343425,
0.0447193086,
-0.1139449477,
0.6033433676,
0.4524610639,
0.6575545073,
-0.0806296393,
0.674074471,
0.153150484,
0.4354272485,
-0.4627009034,
0.6286382079,
-0.4529795647,
0.5582358837,
-0.2365035713,
-0.8708080053,
-0.5610505342,
0.2301990688,
-0.1013804749,
-0.2679407299,
0.619207263,
0.7345749736,
0.1892701685,
-0.2442555279,
0.4111192524,
0.2907136977,
0.6443657279,
0.1202895865,
0.9953356981,
-0.1399095207,
0.3369634151,
0.4091340303,
-0.2172193825,
-0.6326918602,
-0.9374200106,
-1.0957270861,
-0.3412216902,
-0.318898946,
-0.2962607443,
0.0081320629,
0.7263854742,
0.1533960104,
-1.0771468878,
-0.0782709941,
-0.0597475506,
0.3187913299,
0.1518820971,
-0.2418913841,
0.1432223171,
-0.5524725318,
-0.4294495583,
0.3893561959,
0.4262638092,
0.1679333746,
-0.4200672507,
0.1615354866,
0.3360245824,
0.0945140198,
0.5590553284,
0.1288959533,
-0.8469991088,
-0.7556282878,
0.0844156221,
0.1282246709,
-0.265730381,
0.9203004241,
-0.6280754805,
0.4074418247,
0.1223447099,
0.5450817943,
0.0235001184,
-0.386826247,
0.1665696949,
-1.0170083046,
0.2523640096,
0.0653929785,
0.3492252529,
0.3200023472,
-0.2183027714,
0.2772381008,
0.4111314118,
-0.3940188885,
-1.419031024,
0.2381811291,
-0.6067758799,
-0.3047720194,
1.220656991,
0.0054001333,
-0.0139702745,
-0.1039527878,
-0.227623269,
-0.1642629951,
-0.145288378,
0.9759388566,
1.0762497187,
0.0511097386,
0.2288453579,
-0.4530844092,
0.4778132439,
0.1073440388,
-0.6462213397,
0.1457085311,
0.5958429575,
0.3895477355,
0.5437932014,
0.5140655041,
-0.1976681203,
0.2375605851,
-0.2346860468,
-0.1163706034,
-0.0698882565,
-0.2377822846,
-0.5435977578,
0.1391202956,
0.403545171,
-0.1263924837
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09889v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09889v2
|
Is Table Retrieval a Solved Problem? Exploring Join-Aware Multi-Table Retrieval
| 2024-04-15T15:55:01 | 2024-06-06T01:59:40 |
Peter Baile Chen, Yi Zhang, Dan Roth
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Retrieving relevant tables containing the necessary information to accurately
answer a given question over tables is critical to open-domain
question-answering (QA) systems. Previous methods assume the answer to such a
question can be found either in a single table or multiple tables identified
through question decomposition or rewriting. However, neither of these
approaches is sufficient, as many questions require retrieving multiple tables
and joining them through a join plan that cannot be discerned from the user
query itself. If the join plan is not considered in the retrieval stage, the
subsequent steps of reasoning and answering based on those retrieved tables are
likely to be incorrect. To address this problem, we introduce a method that
uncovers useful join relations for any query and database during table
retrieval. We use a novel re-ranking method formulated as a mixed-integer
program that considers not only table-query relevance but also table-table
relevance that requires inferring join relationships. Our method outperforms
the state-of-the-art approaches for table retrieval by up to 9.3% in F1 score
and for end-to-end QA by up to 5.4% in accuracy.
|
[
-0.623249352,
-0.7220364213,
0.8199648857,
-0.2281353772,
-0.2682949305,
0.2169277668,
0.3275122941,
-0.5762771368,
0.4740822315,
0.3831704855,
-0.6441007257,
-0.3909155726,
-0.1538058966,
-0.0940655395,
-0.2666510046,
0.6050350666,
0.1084204465,
0.017512612,
-0.6805226207,
-0.5241259336,
-0.3988082409,
-0.5942425132,
-0.2259550542,
-0.2355561405,
0.7084842324,
0.6924331784,
0.8238533735,
0.3987326324,
0.7226307392,
0.1043178216,
-0.1251637638,
0.1952417046,
-0.5941170454,
0.3329748213,
-0.0144240493,
-0.7588946819,
-0.4322864711,
0.0875215977,
0.3663303852,
0.884773314,
-0.3711532354,
0.4280640185,
-0.1967232972,
1.0836576223,
-0.7209402323,
0.0235278867,
-0.9334649444,
0.2125040144,
-0.4281333983,
-0.527551353,
-0.4776432812,
-0.5913218856,
0.0297485664,
-0.5947380066,
0.3282791674,
0.3367706835,
0.3582750857,
-0.0369323529,
-0.7231456637,
0.0174238235,
-0.7127862573,
0.3869455755,
-0.5535404682,
0.8078699112,
0.2626012266,
0.8707223535,
-0.4165735543,
-0.6557853222,
-0.6634762287,
-0.1806333363,
-0.2307371795,
0.0852907896,
0.3476071358,
-0.2020989656,
0.432602644,
0.5188434124,
-0.7527066469,
-0.4109265506,
-0.1999222636,
-0.1276269853,
0.3455106318,
0.1370672137,
0.4709376097,
0.1895226985,
-0.3583169281,
-0.2048529983,
-0.7678778172,
0.0028762766,
-0.1505496651,
0.3134708405,
0.5285640955,
0.7637425065,
-0.4152899384,
0.8618612289,
-0.378542155,
0.0689716488,
0.0274415258,
-0.5731512308,
0.2042663097,
-0.1840342283,
0.1879924834,
0.3864098191,
0.0755762309,
-0.4457743168,
-0.2586577833,
-0.0558426231,
0.2410398275,
-0.2838814259,
-0.3084432185,
0.2133836597,
-0.3570841849,
0.2661074996,
0.0064618797,
-0.8514826894,
-0.2769769728,
-0.0826623142,
0.7662129402,
-0.1547947526,
-0.443805784,
-0.5127639174,
-0.2733162344,
0.4927039444,
0.3318167329,
-0.4581100345,
0.1457626373,
0.5743629336,
0.4465956986,
-0.0682781562,
-0.1252201796,
-0.5065072775,
0.2448812276,
-0.4942124188,
0.8978224397,
-0.539789021,
-0.3726426065,
-0.0658967644,
-0.3173481822,
0.02982275,
-0.7552793622,
0.5111586452,
-0.9786896706,
0.1611564904,
-0.6950824857,
-0.3575764894,
0.0133724697,
0.4794384837,
-1.0658254623,
0.696158886,
-0.0947823897,
-0.6077660322,
0.6215010285,
-0.1920384467,
-0.3286441267,
-0.1397345513,
-0.2190475762,
-0.51634413,
0.0602254868,
0.3705036044,
0.0557724535,
-0.3363593817,
0.0430260748,
-0.4486857951,
-0.5177463293,
0.154089883,
0.0355768129,
0.2825214565,
0.0260546617,
0.2821193933,
0.0327016376,
-0.3696041703,
0.5176796317,
0.2069539875,
-0.3140613139,
-0.2785078883,
0.0326690264,
-0.5337186456,
0.3647558391,
0.2278893441,
-0.6045538187,
0.2595616877,
-0.0991659537,
0.033854723,
0.1775045544,
0.3431168199,
0.47171399,
-0.6383103728,
0.336609304,
-0.0554836728,
0.1087616682,
0.0891947597,
-0.7373862267,
-0.6413553357,
0.2819661796,
0.183694452,
0.2946446538,
-0.8321649432,
-0.1954213828,
-0.0521199964,
-0.6477874517,
-0.6317539811,
-0.4408710897,
0.3294420838,
0.5300924182,
0.7392027378,
-0.260381341,
-0.2208561599,
-0.8070403337,
-0.824278295,
-0.2180431038,
0.1365364194,
0.5214835405,
0.3020021915,
0.4579481184,
0.7705189586,
-0.8036668897,
-0.3923174143,
-0.0736484379,
-0.0379393473,
0.2760176957,
0.223508656,
0.3056723475,
-0.9080342054,
-0.6317591667,
-0.085137628,
-0.7726493478,
0.5064074993,
0.1348468661,
-0.4272081256,
-0.1059066653,
0.4240440726,
-0.6459859014,
0.5396843553,
-0.1983085275,
-0.0521120802,
0.4120501876,
-0.0861521065,
0.4417594969,
-0.6982418299,
0.3097954988,
-0.3832812905,
-0.197045058,
-0.3911526501,
0.3694402277,
0.1793477237,
-0.572983861,
-0.2545278072,
0.1836351007,
-0.8360411525,
-0.3357243538,
0.1872961521,
0.3847071826,
-0.0862411037,
0.6925593615,
-0.2419217676,
0.985555768,
0.2703916728,
-0.41089347,
0.0888796449,
0.4411348403,
-0.0610409789,
0.4465757012,
-0.2782559097,
0.5066784024,
-0.3505243361,
0.0852990076,
-1.1263053417,
-0.1745725274,
0.1842429638,
-0.628746748,
0.3516255319,
-0.1748689562,
-0.1854136139,
-0.3318584859,
-0.3813273013,
0.4155810475,
-0.0477810428,
-0.6124685407,
0.705332756,
0.6418198943,
0.0679406896,
-0.9352872372,
-0.2979025543,
-0.0971819311,
0.0558970906,
-0.5110779405,
0.5907193422,
-0.0391418673,
0.0367245525,
0.1634795368,
-0.9661703706,
-0.4328610897,
0.0352506302,
-0.0165241789,
-0.0643937886,
0.0717434213,
0.1384800971,
-0.1211170331,
-0.1073964909,
0.0951760784,
0.1349082589,
0.3839943409,
0.0401999392,
-0.4327737987,
-0.3084932268,
0.7300200462,
0.7797087431,
-0.7785186768,
0.7592528462,
0.1460755467,
-0.6261791587,
-0.1770281196,
-0.5711075068,
-0.5002529025,
-0.3678172827,
0.3081644475,
-0.6729092002,
-0.610204041,
0.9575924277,
0.0547680296,
0.3100068867,
0.3076195717,
-0.0746468753,
-0.1864178777,
0.9220438004,
0.4567914605,
0.2402972281,
0.2044818401,
-0.0908155143,
0.4384029806,
-0.6359727383,
-0.8869454265,
-0.9978677034,
-0.4385594428,
-0.4683185518,
-0.1548472494,
0.586552918,
0.0215456821,
0.0649123937,
0.4685464203,
-0.3856447041,
0.6415752769,
0.647198081,
0.4174677432,
0.7128323913,
-0.1203095242,
-0.2554811537,
0.0036723651,
-0.6591492891,
0.0980969965,
1.0630961657,
-0.2887263,
0.6004450917,
0.50166291,
1.001134634,
0.2091489732,
0.4295131266,
-0.5755184293,
0.7125313282,
0.3415391743,
-0.7746221423,
-0.5031904578,
-0.8426139355,
-0.88148278,
0.6463792324,
-0.4191858172,
-0.5148944259,
0.2036058605,
-0.0010399775,
-0.2001011819,
0.0039166887,
-0.6436302066,
0.9538291097,
-0.0564219654,
-0.1165604815,
-0.3975871205,
-0.6863316298,
0.3726385236,
-0.0908235908,
0.0136832204,
-0.2870459259,
0.0498861447,
0.8691955805,
-0.4174197018,
-0.0474847704,
-0.0968204364,
0.2536188066,
0.1884601265,
0.344384402,
0.3148627281,
0.2041663677,
-0.2596188188,
-0.4089418352,
0.3875573277,
-0.3145703077,
-1.1137546301,
0.8555929065,
-0.5552101135,
-0.7634897828,
-0.5836809874,
-0.2304810733,
-0.5947086215,
0.4017525911,
-0.049993895,
0.4692194462,
-0.1003958434,
0.1426289827,
0.3205281198,
0.114427872,
0.166511476,
0.5756909847,
-0.2643321753,
-0.3153061569,
0.7937580943,
0.4341739714,
-0.0136144171,
0.6861764193,
-0.2811559141,
-0.6436629295,
-0.4775892794,
-0.1501550823,
0.4064831436,
-0.6155720353,
-0.5588673949,
-0.3590255678,
0.0589334592,
-0.0228569396,
0.2213456035,
-0.2381038964,
-0.6958317757,
0.1062176675,
-0.0933120176,
-0.1748239845,
0.3411132097,
0.3461864293,
-0.1906017214,
-1.0041888952,
0.5027554631,
0.4914792478,
0.6906228662,
0.3350338936,
-0.086387001,
-0.0095550306,
-0.1663214266,
-0.1937789172,
-1.5363260508,
0.2038403749,
0.3978970051,
1.1534651518,
-0.1596008539,
0.5675989985,
0.5844843984,
-0.2267347127,
0.2441782206,
-0.1273435503,
-0.3561747074,
0.6281224489,
0.0111006973,
0.1195631772,
0.9291541576,
0.6622746587,
-0.2817325294,
-0.0842940584,
-0.4241129756,
-1.0379607677,
0.6180463433,
0.1717758477,
-0.3599613607,
0.0277128331,
0.5323070884,
-0.1105360985,
0.3628859818,
-0.5714173317,
-0.3469434381,
0.2307876945,
0.3796313405,
0.3452116251,
-0.3492497206,
-0.0567912236,
-0.0276611,
0.4774936438,
-0.0626149848,
0.538751781,
0.204227224,
-0.2446820289,
-0.232932955,
0.381431222,
-0.0575031415,
1.1281003952,
-0.6462177038,
0.0151349613,
-0.1521376669,
-0.1582258642,
0.002525961,
0.1378229558,
0.1264095306,
0.0611933768,
-0.0401481017,
-0.0042298455,
-0.0901281014,
-0.3064963818,
0.3709568381,
-0.3639494181,
0.06733381,
-0.0451453589,
-0.0485435426,
0.1737980247,
0.1053313911,
0.7304423451,
-0.0019277969,
0.4550501704,
-0.8296177983,
0.8056722879,
0.7020379901,
-0.5416747332,
0.0172069091,
0.7105277777,
0.2841447592,
-0.417568773,
1.2350287437,
0.0821553171,
-0.346157074,
0.4884482026,
0.4786071777,
0.370200634,
-0.2130483836,
0.1748745292,
0.5266563892,
0.2710596919,
0.0807024017,
0.786871314,
-0.2116999328,
-0.5882178545,
-0.3874441981,
-0.3397338986,
-0.5959004164,
-0.1831542104,
-0.8476831317,
-0.0454750136,
-0.183924675,
-0.3588247895,
0.1938291341,
0.160409078,
-0.4203132093,
-0.0136239287,
-0.3705574572,
1.0818929672,
-0.5206351876,
0.5353361964,
0.7076086402,
-0.6963790655,
-0.8487877846,
0.0871843621,
-0.1816107184,
-0.3818328977,
-0.0790927857,
0.2114402652,
0.0266825315,
0.1949946433,
-0.1717928946,
-0.7433683276,
1.038513422,
0.4531061649,
-0.2687643468,
-0.0250951517,
0.2389109731,
0.4013126791,
0.154927969,
0.5790336728,
0.5262485147,
0.3073472381,
0.1694204211,
-0.9693920612,
0.2020723224,
-0.1794833839,
-0.4699770212,
0.7365036011,
-0.4331229627,
0.5107324123,
-0.5781958103,
-0.3613050878,
-0.2276685089,
0.9472833276,
0.250593394,
0.7014881968,
0.2755976319,
0.5689113736,
0.8355451226,
-0.3383675218,
0.685905993,
-0.0919348374,
0.2912198603,
0.8614732027,
-0.3438169956,
1.0998156071,
0.4741542041,
-0.3040009439,
0.1015208289,
0.5202556252,
0.5464308262,
0.6072948575,
0.0690800175,
-0.2812885642,
-0.5868739486,
-0.1437679827,
-0.6674962044,
0.330029875,
0.2699733675,
0.0581276789,
-0.6530139446,
-0.4433116019,
-0.3467984498,
0.1154787913,
-0.1366963834,
0.9085022807,
0.2505069375,
-0.7694408894,
0.554210484,
-0.3472211957,
0.0065063303,
-0.3811586499,
-0.5452562571,
-0.6772293448,
-0.0726365745,
-0.2766425014,
-0.8917970657,
0.3928102255,
-0.7634462118,
-0.1118293256,
0.1720447391,
0.6148784757,
-0.546425581,
0.1408741623,
0.1102648675,
1.1687061787,
0.0057233288,
-0.5568944812,
-0.3624673188,
-0.4260731936,
0.0971237794,
0.0996559858,
0.5224173665,
0.358853817,
-0.1699037701,
0.8950706124,
0.5241760015,
-0.5137732029,
0.0471367016,
-0.0978046581,
1.1069192886,
-0.726093173,
-0.3980699778,
-0.2927246094,
0.3692582548,
-0.0551342182,
-0.0205889903,
0.4811400473,
0.8171468377,
0.8749362826,
-0.1185941994,
0.1954260916,
0.0844664797,
0.5845564604,
-0.2690473497,
0.8124591112,
-0.7619908452,
0.2239738107,
-0.0653896332,
-1.3374112844,
-0.5742449164,
0.3678764701,
-0.0701689199,
0.0773609579,
0.6774607301,
0.7950867414,
-0.0010038593,
0.0970331803,
0.1772729754,
-0.2233453542,
0.3849188685,
0.3925098777,
0.7357034087,
-0.2880533338,
1.0357052088,
-0.1715502441,
-0.2411921471,
-0.2495727837,
-0.3479185998,
-0.3502447307,
-0.6084811687,
-0.1746323258,
-0.1929006577,
0.3571754992,
0.4618908763,
0.346603781,
-0.6723906994,
-0.2136033028,
0.3160188496,
0.4245326519,
-0.5070038438,
-0.1669034064,
0.4976986051,
-0.2410556525,
-0.1523835212,
0.5099494457,
0.0352440402,
-0.2821854651,
0.1389437169,
0.4193610549,
-0.6709438562,
-0.2490538657,
0.3541429937,
0.5146622658,
-0.2430144399,
-0.2473445535,
0.4195862412,
0.0868626237,
0.2485562414,
0.9199759364,
-0.9700914621,
0.3708622754,
0.9526978135,
0.5791141391,
0.7212341428,
0.3171397746,
0.5824440718,
-0.9829955101,
-0.5684270859,
0.619677484,
0.2141102701,
0.1892405152,
-0.2083712071,
0.7726851106,
0.0325935744,
-0.6088382602,
-0.6880036592,
0.2789689898,
-1.0549445152,
-0.0885981247,
0.3024979234,
0.081204854,
-0.0444742553,
-0.3734953105,
-0.1291189045,
0.3236325085,
-0.4577226341,
0.7988761067,
0.2347720265,
-0.5641106367,
-0.4035611451,
-0.3223026395,
0.6075034738,
0.3218129575,
-0.6858186126,
0.1826289296,
0.5875108838,
-0.117367208,
0.4137482345,
0.7203990221,
-0.3624146581,
0.4292644262,
-0.0881680772,
-0.2825689018,
-0.1403633058,
-0.711617589,
0.3915152252,
0.670811832,
0.3333868682,
-0.3460239768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09868v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09868v2
|
Software Engineering Methods For AI-Driven Deductive Legal Reasoning
| 2024-04-15T15:33:29 | 2024-06-27T21:03:15 |
Rohan Padhye
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The recent proliferation of generative artificial intelligence (AI)
technologies such as pre-trained large language models (LLMs) has opened up new
frontiers in computational law. An exciting area of development is the use of
AI to automate the deductive rule-based reasoning inherent in statutory and
contract law. This paper argues that such automated deductive legal reasoning
can now be viewed from the lens of software engineering, treating LLMs as
interpreters of natural-language programs with natural-language inputs. We show
how it is possible to apply principled software engineering techniques to
enhance AI-driven legal reasoning of complex statutes and to unlock new
applications in automated meta-reasoning such as mutation-guided example
generation and metamorphic property-based testing.
|
[
-0.1642375886,
-0.9916473627,
0.972214818,
0.0615840256,
-0.2553245127,
0.0045040199,
0.0512156859,
-0.1546776146,
-0.09896864,
0.8862817883,
-0.4170301557,
-0.4836186469,
-0.2186215669,
0.1213693842,
-0.573730886,
0.5162250996,
-0.1554980725,
0.0618830621,
-0.294865936,
-0.0013298125,
-0.5732827187,
-0.3444486856,
-0.0511891432,
-0.3476946056,
-0.0968358591,
0.3513534665,
1.0551187992,
0.6361025572,
0.4562013149,
0.2884226441,
0.088867642,
-0.0990416631,
0.3030397892,
0.0282281041,
-0.118274726,
-0.685400784,
-0.3657008708,
0.14781937,
0.1790874004,
0.5288597941,
-0.1403487176,
0.0243748985,
-0.1731715053,
0.6888308525,
-0.6878506541,
0.3995622993,
-0.8144930005,
0.1092312187,
0.0515000336,
-0.3859799504,
-0.5453413129,
-0.4924188554,
-0.2276807278,
-0.7045214772,
0.0983707681,
-0.0352317989,
0.7357549071,
1.0304592848,
-0.4965263009,
-0.491019249,
-0.9885650873,
0.6096967459,
-0.8917328119,
0.3730689585,
0.389307797,
0.3700910509,
-0.4710269868,
-0.5639032125,
-0.6936955452,
-0.9493285418,
-0.1178226471,
-0.029217612,
0.019252276,
0.4510067105,
0.3912191391,
0.1936767101,
-0.8202677965,
0.210346505,
-0.3482226729,
-0.0042786077,
1.1217216253,
-0.0439450815,
0.5672056675,
0.0082348166,
0.245333001,
0.319465965,
-0.881600976,
-0.3089326918,
0.1960680187,
-0.0676339641,
0.1084981933,
0.7209451795,
0.1129053608,
0.8686536551,
-0.1671341062,
0.1000565067,
0.165186882,
-0.0786872953,
-0.45944947,
0.1599184275,
0.6042784452,
-0.0357702784,
0.5779719353,
-0.0657916591,
-0.2212965041,
0.2391178608,
0.2857606709,
-0.3005591035,
-0.1093244702,
0.4738481641,
-0.6058376431,
-0.4351442456,
0.0396899432,
-0.3042910993,
-0.4549604356,
-0.8574237823,
0.1673139185,
-0.3350395262,
-0.2404706478,
0.3928102255,
-0.3837902844,
0.521949172,
0.1618568301,
-0.7133780718,
-0.0449150689,
1.1095962524,
0.0979744345,
0.56945467,
-0.3945590556,
-0.517665863,
0.3669317961,
-0.6692584157,
0.4030033946,
-0.7759683728,
-0.1206324548,
-0.1150001511,
-0.3731285036,
0.1883944273,
-0.8157841563,
0.3908507228,
-0.7062430382,
-0.2779628634,
0.2998222709,
-0.4086179733,
-0.1773121655,
0.2904261053,
-0.5328162909,
0.5654826164,
0.1486679614,
-0.2625451982,
0.7183371782,
-1.0618456602,
-0.9205502272,
0.3061316013,
-0.6461619139,
-0.251242131,
0.1483004838,
0.1054838896,
0.1267378479,
-0.5421800613,
0.6079860926,
-0.5209975243,
-0.1882764399,
0.1606424302,
-0.2622780204,
1.3016812801,
0.6353900433,
-0.7421157956,
0.0786491111,
-0.6685422063,
-0.0196256451,
0.0505756736,
-0.2644809783,
-0.2849678397,
0.3075300157,
-0.5583753586,
0.1093346104,
-0.169256568,
-0.3310978413,
0.2561641634,
-0.6193488836,
0.9382783175,
0.5721930861,
-0.3208390772,
0.4848707318,
-0.1257156879,
0.6279196143,
-0.1453685164,
0.1546801329,
0.0674260855,
-0.2731505036,
-0.4897121489,
-0.3921754956,
0.2926743031,
0.9608005285,
-0.6209160089,
0.5114313364,
-0.1913742125,
-0.36571154,
-0.7224264145,
0.2578886449,
-0.1775470078,
0.0417155549,
0.3466319144,
0.3336845338,
-0.5619354844,
-0.8026201129,
-0.6229316592,
-0.3338511586,
-0.0295388512,
0.3089007139,
0.522543788,
-0.6759911776,
1.1628910303,
-0.395642817,
-0.0880686343,
-0.4902423918,
0.5582715273,
0.2708477378,
0.3210345805,
0.7012426257,
-0.966105938,
-0.3487168849,
-0.1361544579,
-1.0886634588,
-0.5090506673,
-0.6388837099,
0.0145529928,
0.0718358979,
0.7145069838,
-0.7744382024,
0.619196713,
-0.187199235,
-0.4286796451,
0.5685667992,
-0.3198983073,
0.1934610605,
-0.5244040489,
-0.3913528919,
-0.2130529583,
-0.2713869214,
-0.4039623141,
0.6144119501,
-0.1767051816,
-0.2437883317,
-0.3516691327,
0.2194089144,
-0.7368921041,
-0.1833888143,
-0.7198866606,
0.1045459062,
-0.0408663377,
0.0412670039,
-0.1955479085,
0.7383103371,
0.6300987601,
-0.8025277853,
0.8378574252,
0.1449028552,
0.0009940438,
0.4896198213,
-0.3811065555,
-0.0487546548,
-0.3671896458,
0.0044264365,
-0.4224680066,
-0.1487411857,
0.1201837808,
-0.222304821,
0.0921812207,
-0.2596735954,
-0.580519855,
-0.7813871503,
-0.342664212,
0.3434398174,
0.7141304016,
-0.374602735,
1.1402218342,
0.2344141006,
-0.0809286386,
-0.3735974431,
-0.9383638501,
0.394228667,
-0.3539611399,
-0.6095658541,
0.4393232763,
0.098622404,
-0.9053041339,
0.2547482848,
0.2914476991,
-0.3991900086,
0.6377025843,
0.2839862704,
0.0714717507,
-0.2741324008,
0.0358370766,
0.3271577954,
-0.0523049235,
0.5969558358,
-0.3054332733,
0.3668076992,
0.0525505617,
-0.6944437623,
-0.3769176602,
0.1946450025,
0.8459695578,
-0.3371352255,
0.2532100081,
-0.1063936204,
-0.3248003423,
-0.2905319035,
-0.5016439557,
-0.0539675765,
-0.4735223651,
0.1273090392,
-0.6946504712,
-0.6440213323,
0.0459505245,
-0.2135798037,
0.3495922685,
0.6996077299,
0.5369813442,
-0.1159947515,
0.7526646852,
0.4582259059,
-0.2172347307,
0.2684090734,
-0.177962631,
0.3485703468,
-0.2988816202,
0.2716401815,
-0.5584406853,
-0.0464145355,
-0.6239115,
-0.1355012357,
0.3200250268,
0.0126542468,
-0.4489190578,
0.4309447706,
-0.3704644442,
0.7709708214,
0.8618810773,
0.017647313,
0.3186766207,
-0.3618402779,
-0.0015650168,
0.339751482,
-0.3538115025,
-0.674017489,
1.1183017492,
0.142314896,
0.890648663,
-0.0649769455,
0.9427146912,
0.6947475672,
0.2357573956,
-0.5842723846,
0.7595027089,
-0.1215878502,
-0.6874597073,
-0.3076740205,
-0.4105351567,
-0.7205085754,
-0.0999903083,
-0.2044326812,
-0.2038960457,
-0.1098216325,
0.3239660859,
-0.4722179472,
0.1404803097,
-0.369800359,
0.7194429636,
-0.6467887163,
-0.1231755167,
-0.8683283925,
-0.5901460648,
0.3075161278,
-0.11500974,
0.4184953272,
0.057413049,
0.418514818,
0.3349740803,
-0.7603603601,
0.5919545293,
-0.3045562208,
-0.3271701932,
0.9035326242,
0.2938782275,
0.5130865574,
0.1031103134,
-0.111775659,
-0.3067881465,
0.0683145225,
-0.1366419941,
-0.7586827278,
0.3308736682,
-0.3847729266,
-1.0478484631,
-0.2393634319,
-0.5877770185,
0.0882082731,
0.1491216868,
-0.1083287224,
0.0038388534,
-0.0983523801,
-0.2231144458,
0.4631403089,
-0.3345391154,
0.3195661604,
0.6276892424,
-0.0393776484,
-0.2529895902,
0.8651099205,
0.0043799742,
-0.0530986078,
0.3831287026,
0.2843313813,
-0.1192482337,
-0.5721481442,
-0.5366204381,
0.1628829241,
-0.7138219476,
-0.1059077606,
-0.4712004662,
-0.2682412565,
-0.6618369222,
-0.4395508766,
-0.0121925948,
-0.4514480531,
-0.1530398428,
0.0430781953,
0.2076244354,
0.6396044493,
-0.053693451,
-0.3216027021,
-0.891176343,
0.7113724947,
0.424990952,
0.0308010876,
-0.5698689222,
-0.3907597661,
0.3573425412,
0.2319960147,
-0.4015631676,
-0.8003371954,
-0.0780722946,
0.1407291591,
0.7768660784,
0.2495628148,
0.117704533,
0.3502340913,
-0.6052488089,
0.4572749138,
-0.2469209135,
-0.9287974238,
0.9757588506,
-0.0529467352,
-0.1301967353,
0.4713075161,
0.1889776289,
-0.0786199942,
-0.7121155262,
-0.4221917093,
-0.398268342,
0.2438491881,
0.1098235622,
0.2620927691,
0.1080323234,
0.7471905947,
0.0131181646,
0.2531934381,
-0.7656874657,
0.2046095431,
-0.0587371476,
-0.5672333837,
0.4484435916,
-0.127105698,
-0.0145057049,
-0.4402441978,
0.6660233736,
-0.1934665143,
0.010411283,
0.0336227491,
-0.537152648,
0.3579848707,
0.610409379,
0.756664753,
0.750615716,
0.1254574358,
0.1771199554,
0.1695141494,
-0.3906071782,
0.4956558347,
0.4787982106,
-0.5972604156,
-0.1742510796,
0.2811947465,
0.3602907658,
-0.5197023749,
-0.8475734591,
0.2538403869,
0.4792668819,
-0.6404030919,
-0.6362520456,
0.261605829,
-0.0853418633,
0.5022467375,
0.2478727549,
-0.2904877961,
0.4247867465,
-0.8004315495,
0.2356081009,
0.7137845755,
0.0666329563,
0.0830169916,
1.0283257961,
0.3372587264,
-0.2551358938,
0.7701895237,
-0.1850176752,
-0.6073166132,
0.9577257037,
0.4180804789,
1.2154477835,
0.2237270772,
0.0179080255,
-0.0660632402,
0.63259238,
-0.0151555734,
0.4427396357,
-0.2708041072,
-0.4394788742,
-0.6215746403,
-0.2596817017,
-0.2364372313,
0.0040815184,
0.0842262208,
0.4996491373,
-0.4765776694,
0.0434776768,
0.0436039194,
-0.540135026,
-0.2988330722,
0.190314889,
0.3242058158,
0.8175673485,
-0.7221902609,
0.5523235798,
0.711894691,
-0.6363450289,
-0.4232317507,
0.1342795342,
0.0493477061,
-0.6565950513,
1.0830795765,
0.0697732866,
-0.2826760709,
-0.1385938823,
-0.7598052025,
-0.3034817576,
0.8852083087,
0.5901787877,
-0.4850153923,
0.0011424773,
0.8671798706,
0.4959864616,
-0.1563986987,
0.3099513352,
0.7505068183,
0.4902110994,
-0.1163911596,
-0.7886298299,
0.0002573416,
-0.1925835758,
-0.2110220492,
0.3193796575,
-0.0668181553,
0.4828441739,
-0.4458392262,
0.0401983932,
-0.2446225137,
0.6256136894,
0.2055657208,
0.5159372091,
0.6373559237,
0.7889464498,
0.6311587095,
0.0127059985,
0.8684571981,
-0.5775093436,
0.0898425207,
1.0490057468,
-0.740429461,
0.2904866636,
0.2478780299,
-0.1601678133,
0.7658253908,
0.3028333783,
-0.4216670096,
0.2235946953,
0.742190361,
-0.2074450701,
-0.43942976,
0.1750826836,
-0.0527509525,
0.4220277667,
0.0505950637,
-0.5622591972,
-0.1049335003,
0.3902697563,
-0.1540896893,
0.2597464919,
-0.3028736711,
0.9581794739,
0.0169078708,
-0.7257570624,
0.4624744952,
0.2583448291,
0.3032835424,
-0.0622716174,
-0.3058308661,
0.0263628419,
0.2437388003,
-0.2718140483,
-0.9662248492,
0.7375619411,
0.2456712723,
-0.0708957538,
-0.3016812503,
0.7637760043,
0.0970332772,
-0.4617702365,
0.0982413292,
0.0651048869,
0.2262037694,
-0.2377614528,
-0.93529737,
-0.5464003086,
-0.2681919932,
-0.0496318191,
-0.2733100057,
0.4547631145,
-0.259146899,
0.994431138,
0.3576427996,
0.01372917,
0.1340305507,
0.1767408997,
0.9057615399,
-0.9062482119,
-0.4532884955,
-1.32006073,
0.2616572976,
0.0754423514,
0.307867825,
0.3351289332,
0.6952358484,
0.5722020864,
-0.0077502141,
0.9632886648,
-0.2577300668,
0.27053231,
-0.7723296881,
0.387339592,
-0.4938631952,
0.3043013215,
-0.2369756252,
-0.7613189816,
-0.3846686482,
0.5187861323,
-0.4170631468,
-0.1076450124,
0.4353411794,
0.761007607,
-0.158572495,
-0.0150594488,
0.1186474562,
0.131298095,
0.4629258215,
0.6209756136,
0.8856213689,
-0.1575008631,
0.5058540106,
0.1734095514,
-0.2987015843,
-0.0733745173,
-0.7459332347,
-0.8885406256,
-0.1542796493,
-0.4842423797,
-0.3562917113,
-0.0857248306,
1.0510313511,
0.2806887627,
-0.6558496356,
-0.163681671,
-0.7943361998,
0.1710123271,
-0.2026479691,
-0.2536460757,
-0.0831352323,
-0.6817994118,
-0.3068798482,
0.5439721942,
0.3948283195,
0.077657558,
-0.456702888,
-0.187213704,
-0.2016125172,
0.3619399667,
0.5243521929,
0.2995290756,
-0.7246730924,
0.0606049076,
-0.336373508,
-0.1716849506,
0.0695449337,
1.0172585249,
-0.698990047,
0.1595918834,
0.7400271297,
0.9065221548,
0.222226426,
-0.0018278465,
0.8109045029,
0.1300652325,
0.2540820241,
0.4931524396,
0.4448391795,
-0.2848893404,
-0.4021654725,
0.7101947069,
0.2126151025,
-0.5827054977,
-0.7239047885,
0.6068781614,
-0.2709236443,
-0.5684106946,
0.8850072026,
0.0142284902,
-0.2277771533,
-0.3662496507,
-0.1652263701,
0.0925247967,
0.344384253,
0.8892720938,
0.5008087158,
-0.1213073581,
-0.2470430881,
-0.6927347779,
0.5404759645,
0.5830122828,
-1.297576189,
0.1183193326,
0.6851608157,
0.1499774158,
0.1867827922,
0.5905170441,
-0.0993046165,
0.4275099635,
0.0301030371,
0.0098257139,
-0.0923193246,
-0.3835941255,
-0.143930912,
-0.1650616676,
0.3999220729,
-0.0186131597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09841v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09841v2
|
Anatomy of Industrial Scale Multilingual ASR
| 2024-04-15T14:48:43 | 2024-04-16T14:55:13 |
Francis McCann Ramirez, Luka Chkhetiani, Andrew Ehrenberg, Robert McHardy, Rami Botros, Yash Khare, Andrea Vanzo, Taufiquzzaman Peyash, Gabriel Oexle, Michael Liang, Ilya Sklyar, Enver Fakhan, Ahmed Etefy, Daniel McCrystal, Sam Flamini, Domenic Donato, Takuya Yoshioka
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
This paper describes AssemblyAI's industrial-scale automatic speech
recognition (ASR) system, designed to meet the requirements of large-scale,
multilingual ASR serving various application needs. Our system leverages a
diverse training dataset comprising unsupervised (12.5M hours), supervised
(188k hours), and pseudo-labeled (1.6M hours) data across four languages. We
provide a detailed description of our model architecture, consisting of a
full-context 600M-parameter Conformer encoder pre-trained with BEST-RQ and an
RNN-T decoder fine-tuned jointly with the encoder. Our extensive evaluation
demonstrates competitive word error rates (WERs) against larger and more
computationally expensive models, such as Whisper large and Canary-1B.
Furthermore, our architectural choices yield several key advantages, including
an improved code-switching capability, a 5x inference speedup compared to an
optimized Whisper baseline, a 30% reduction in hallucination rate on speech
data, and a 90% reduction in ambient noise compared to Whisper, along with
significantly improved time-stamp accuracy. Throughout this work, we adopt a
system-centric approach to analyzing various aspects of fully-fledged ASR
models to gain practically relevant insights useful for real-world services
operating at scale.
|
[
-0.2110132724,
-0.2311534137,
-0.0946526602,
0.509177804,
-0.1148371845,
-0.0273895133,
-0.169174999,
-0.8538352251,
0.0463779829,
0.3582152128,
-0.0884407386,
-0.1672375798,
-0.6370658278,
0.2832343578,
-0.6051746011,
0.4294389784,
0.0250843391,
0.2444641739,
0.1476290971,
-0.3765299916,
-0.1339545548,
-0.8267562389,
-0.9748500586,
-0.3186839521,
0.5421236753,
0.3694894612,
0.3520222604,
0.985421598,
0.3678300381,
0.3309190571,
-0.1764569283,
-0.0284141824,
0.0206911303,
-0.1542592496,
0.3654049933,
-0.0137499804,
-0.7247657776,
-0.2255743146,
0.7853147984,
0.7525568604,
-0.4261732697,
0.3824740052,
-0.0863521099,
0.3599621058,
-0.5459347963,
0.421675235,
-0.4892873466,
0.1497333646,
-0.3517522216,
0.0792773664,
-0.3319826722,
0.1150498241,
0.1979595423,
-0.3719647527,
0.0305622425,
0.0097034071,
0.6785856485,
0.3063270152,
-0.5106591582,
-0.2687613666,
-0.9416659474,
0.4686780274,
-0.6775884032,
0.7593447566,
0.2591488957,
0.5782354474,
0.3608022332,
-0.8133304715,
-0.4232528806,
-0.0167142786,
0.1484539956,
0.0803787932,
-0.2174378484,
0.1139756367,
0.1565734148,
0.5032252073,
-0.7573488355,
0.3441408873,
-0.8329634666,
-0.3561098874,
0.7629469037,
-0.07339672,
0.2302297503,
0.2440896034,
-0.1522165835,
-0.1208356619,
-0.5054767728,
0.0217335708,
0.3392170072,
0.5302724838,
-0.1678408831,
0.4232641459,
-0.3636335731,
0.8364499807,
-0.1553767323,
-0.1010166854,
0.474209249,
0.0093614161,
-0.1560769528,
0.6404472589,
1.1063365936,
0.0746720657,
0.1553703249,
-0.2409660965,
-0.517898798,
0.3654885888,
0.3131603897,
-0.8220453262,
-0.1468915939,
0.2132118791,
-0.5570453405,
0.130526498,
-0.1652196497,
-0.3361249864,
-0.2145943642,
-0.5260803699,
0.5971487164,
-0.2743194997,
-0.3662854731,
0.3316968083,
-0.093178302,
0.3751268089,
-0.0156676453,
-0.6022084355,
0.1981224716,
0.5893192291,
0.8997112513,
-0.0229105037,
-0.3061788678,
-0.5876366496,
0.2184748948,
-0.2757139504,
0.868525207,
-0.3985277414,
-0.4544661641,
-0.1350887418,
-0.0177173894,
-0.1378995776,
-0.8199002743,
0.5056753159,
-0.5745012164,
-0.1669196635,
0.12487863,
-0.2859486043,
-0.1279824823,
0.2169797122,
-0.6684616804,
0.4635237157,
-0.5983173847,
-0.3011649251,
0.2462455332,
-0.8488705158,
-0.7729381919,
-0.0270098355,
-0.0824731812,
-0.2803228498,
-0.0415261984,
0.0611853898,
0.375169009,
-0.2309891433,
0.0880072564,
0.0672821254,
-0.1217749864,
0.2436487228,
-0.7120041251,
0.6953953505,
0.6320629716,
-0.199462086,
0.2329047769,
-1.2434555292,
-0.1067810729,
-0.3268467486,
-0.3934307694,
-0.0241508149,
0.0270465687,
0.428391546,
0.1520267129,
0.4585877955,
-0.9615932107,
-0.2865778506,
-0.4291371107,
0.6103485227,
0.3718746006,
-0.2671404481,
0.2477066666,
-0.1765378863,
0.4435129166,
0.0316449478,
0.3178336918,
-0.1355818361,
-0.3107551038,
-0.7789469361,
-0.4573095739,
0.2443700731,
0.5628539324,
-0.5172108412,
0.3027916849,
-0.3464235365,
-0.513006568,
-0.759074688,
-0.1958803833,
0.7397569418,
0.3508098423,
0.3412209749,
-0.4189883173,
-0.7658677101,
-0.9503275752,
-0.1149876118,
-0.2573844492,
-0.353849709,
0.0505710393,
0.0057848091,
-0.5119667649,
0.7104232311,
-0.3035194576,
-0.4416831732,
-0.2368707806,
0.3711306155,
0.167055741,
0.3336911201,
0.0724328756,
-0.9324995279,
-0.4377290905,
0.3546097279,
-0.6587666273,
-0.1727670729,
0.1487119198,
0.2813578546,
0.2845800817,
0.6808022857,
-0.4056544602,
0.3137579858,
0.6627223492,
-0.0070654918,
0.5693327188,
-0.326597333,
0.0017056287,
-1.1732896566,
0.2273165137,
0.0915421993,
0.0531609654,
-0.962626338,
-0.0734271631,
0.0488864332,
-0.3819485307,
-0.420078963,
0.2693970501,
-0.7560018897,
-0.4436228275,
-0.3093805909,
-0.0591821931,
-0.0462468825,
0.4037465453,
0.2137868553,
1.0478738546,
0.3717709184,
-0.8117244244,
0.3963083625,
0.3092732131,
-0.2940293849,
0.4496790171,
-0.9044222832,
0.1327304989,
0.000219097,
0.1617684215,
-0.7841787934,
-0.2133412063,
-0.2388124615,
-0.6113888621,
0.2695795,
-0.1164805889,
-0.5976049304,
-0.3612777889,
0.2316319942,
0.4524207711,
0.3510626853,
-0.5136882663,
0.8354285359,
0.9855238199,
-0.3389536738,
-0.2601315081,
-0.7571402192,
0.1183112115,
-0.1928559095,
-0.4033223689,
0.0468533449,
0.1404567361,
-0.2118127495,
-0.5632203221,
-0.3094232976,
-0.5021492839,
-0.2045968175,
0.1626051515,
0.0254937951,
-0.5141684413,
-0.0473638885,
-0.2711266577,
-0.2968239188,
0.2207602859,
-0.3885810375,
0.4543795884,
-0.146890834,
-0.3577576578,
-0.8137566447,
0.4372783303,
0.8187170029,
-0.5659187436,
0.4473270476,
0.5223478079,
-0.5408166051,
0.1902883202,
-0.5458756089,
0.1713834107,
-0.4676199257,
0.4430116415,
-0.5632978678,
-0.6492947936,
0.7715985775,
0.2158999145,
0.2273690999,
0.4055425823,
0.3681806326,
0.1115448177,
1.0224134922,
0.5367498994,
-0.3974649012,
0.4408040047,
-0.1712979525,
0.2655063868,
-0.9972962737,
-0.2763008475,
-0.6834934354,
-0.2263085693,
-0.4460497797,
-0.3877787292,
0.5663640499,
-0.3891730309,
-0.4660647213,
0.3535838425,
-0.602065146,
0.195546627,
0.3461973667,
-0.0744674876,
0.2771549523,
-0.1904091835,
0.3764994442,
0.2912684083,
-0.7555980086,
-0.5214271545,
0.892457664,
0.4843704402,
0.870164454,
0.1979119331,
0.2714320421,
0.0872604102,
0.0418663472,
-0.9026797414,
0.3371166885,
-0.6608868241,
-0.6011132598,
-0.5794264078,
-0.4262875915,
-0.9394747615,
0.4065796733,
0.2635204196,
-0.470641017,
0.4038032889,
0.3790548742,
-0.5740445256,
0.2558584511,
-0.943757534,
0.8120934963,
-0.4216793478,
0.3186853826,
-0.1126455218,
-0.8848432899,
-0.1245514899,
-0.0316518806,
0.281902045,
0.0849500895,
0.0710461512,
0.9175086021,
-0.1913695633,
0.8121376038,
-0.2808342576,
-0.1878082454,
0.120979622,
-0.3925918341,
0.1277679205,
-0.4324407279,
-0.2941240966,
0.565105021,
0.0824684948,
-0.0764453039,
-0.2929197252,
0.2547268271,
-1.022654295,
-0.0045108176,
-0.407874465,
-0.6000737548,
-0.388923496,
0.250136286,
0.3282873333,
1.0594323874,
-0.2276694626,
0.4809807241,
0.8378255963,
-0.2585359514,
0.3214374185,
0.7173117399,
-0.0267860331,
-0.4449714422,
1.0452815294,
0.5137887597,
0.2684521079,
0.579962492,
0.1446296722,
-0.4765905142,
-0.5313369632,
-0.7013728619,
-0.044817064,
-0.3961249888,
-0.249935016,
-1.0384266376,
-0.6595523953,
-0.5708934069,
0.0932684168,
-0.8111637235,
-0.3376938701,
-0.417514056,
0.1200161353,
0.4037374854,
0.6867004633,
-0.0386189185,
0.6696212292,
-0.8428248167,
0.6071547866,
0.2289977372,
0.471745044,
0.1001232117,
-0.8893483281,
-0.4542835355,
0.1110485569,
0.0179168079,
-0.280480653,
0.525244832,
0.6746965051,
0.4737718701,
0.6139410734,
0.1371770352,
0.9739029408,
-0.9583830237,
0.5974318981,
0.1154341698,
-0.7496600747,
0.2419534177,
-0.3124848008,
0.6175034046,
0.3023827672,
0.1155548096,
-0.7172879577,
-0.232227996,
-0.2922546268,
-1.1751198769,
0.7294454575,
-0.2094281763,
0.0499329679,
0.301573962,
0.299254626,
0.005950253,
0.1869675517,
-0.3889229,
-0.2236666083,
-0.2750963271,
-0.4289436638,
-0.3045683801,
-0.2449596226,
-0.1682531238,
-0.0671685934,
0.6545330286,
-0.0769403279,
0.3716270626,
-0.0363298804,
-0.2253483981,
0.1677185744,
0.3437338471,
0.6614047885,
0.4578304291,
-0.0888849199,
0.0145112015,
0.1530659795,
-0.5795425773,
0.156953156,
0.5800169706,
0.2917206585,
-0.0361896306,
0.2835576534,
0.9967463017,
0.1806188077,
-0.6524204612,
0.3147628009,
-0.1497755051,
-0.0962076411,
-0.8213977218,
-0.1995674372,
-0.0206014998,
0.3282055259,
0.5468121767,
-0.0535726584,
0.6450921297,
-0.5221372247,
0.2988011837,
0.1975561082,
-0.428915292,
-0.5003601909,
0.7720591426,
0.3136371076,
-0.5051701069,
0.5346876383,
0.06467776,
-0.5294800997,
0.6374215484,
0.4856233001,
0.9961939454,
-0.5967258811,
-0.1206592768,
0.2286746204,
0.3722557425,
-0.2418091148,
0.1538475454,
-0.0121157765,
-0.7203897238,
-0.3093127012,
-0.8343080282,
-0.5272833109,
0.1461312473,
-1.1005581617,
0.0205517448,
-0.4365559518,
-0.0463375263,
0.1296992898,
-0.3883313537,
-0.2608187497,
0.5103383064,
0.3018037081,
0.9079492688,
-0.7408178449,
0.8844619393,
0.9251812696,
-0.1668438464,
-0.9050121903,
-0.0142413406,
0.0678968355,
-0.761071384,
0.4964375496,
0.393671155,
-0.5524752736,
0.0498601384,
-0.0954000056,
-0.9026295543,
1.0655828714,
0.2150584757,
-0.7454953194,
0.0975558236,
0.2623539865,
0.8333722949,
-0.367383033,
-0.140403524,
0.6722462177,
0.0834815949,
0.3321360648,
-1.4235446453,
-0.4436804056,
-0.4024188221,
0.1960634589,
0.0743604973,
-0.7507101893,
0.6466225386,
0.1740674376,
-0.2042102665,
-0.0196389593,
0.7751746178,
0.1671339273,
0.3888501525,
0.6228343248,
0.3772174418,
0.4537043273,
0.0678637922,
0.7330784202,
-0.3888109624,
-0.2920976877,
1.1746947765,
-0.5042915344,
1.1939058304,
0.2935231924,
-0.0137474593,
0.1473580003,
0.5539280176,
0.3294045925,
0.3982570469,
-0.0599046946,
-0.337130338,
0.0205301121,
-0.2175498009,
-0.3703569472,
0.9225736856,
0.3376659155,
0.028960485,
0.1759111881,
0.4000103176,
-0.2789487541,
-0.0583186597,
-0.4075131714,
1.149135232,
0.1818670481,
-0.1037754416,
0.4609514177,
-0.1025127172,
0.8324157596,
-0.7867803574,
0.2231286913,
0.0640056878,
0.4978327155,
-0.1145810708,
-0.4367833138,
0.6215884089,
0.277074784,
-0.3698731959,
-0.4489293694,
0.382540822,
-0.5311094522,
-0.5617118478,
0.2584149837,
-0.004586074,
0.353762567,
-0.130499199,
-0.4011492133,
0.5214902759,
-0.1955291778,
-0.0126159666,
0.2110294402,
0.6728582978,
-0.1115178689,
0.7366984487,
0.5131592155,
0.2676569521,
0.1795557439,
0.2611490786,
0.6599445343,
-0.3915300071,
-0.7181777358,
-0.3261152208,
0.6582692862,
0.0821202248,
-0.1609585881,
0.6054077744,
0.7853784561,
0.8036003113,
-0.0087917754,
0.7329539657,
0.0134841846,
0.6075231433,
-0.3402781785,
0.97016114,
-0.6192882061,
0.2184670866,
-0.0550564788,
-0.4595339,
-0.4964891672,
0.8614205718,
-0.1435389221,
-0.1307077855,
0.2114086598,
0.892500937,
-0.0314276069,
0.0550766475,
0.3836574554,
0.338334918,
0.3123250008,
0.0968919024,
0.6009324789,
-0.6031875014,
0.74111408,
0.072956562,
-0.322059691,
-0.0864415094,
-0.4819762409,
-0.38498348,
-0.6749250293,
-0.3818740845,
0.0372380242,
-0.0093888389,
0.9500232339,
0.7944780588,
-1.0118023157,
-0.914216578,
0.3703954816,
-0.5486403704,
-0.264436394,
-0.1133341864,
0.0677218661,
-0.0940789431,
-0.5325645804,
0.5471317768,
0.3375808001,
-0.115081273,
-0.1295766383,
-0.0997088701,
-0.2555995286,
0.009501202,
0.7648438811,
0.5160313845,
-0.5786422491,
-0.2538074851,
-0.126769945,
0.0523500741,
0.1124586016,
0.5797656775,
-0.3683221936,
0.6776519418,
0.2420836687,
0.7346204519,
0.267363131,
-0.1072455272,
0.8118091226,
-0.8183039427,
0.4739930034,
0.1848098189,
0.3254555166,
0.5016857982,
-0.2500393391,
0.2880634964,
-0.0697191283,
-0.6463634968,
-0.9087314606,
0.1911815852,
-0.7480967641,
0.1134376377,
1.0993742943,
-0.150126189,
-0.1214784384,
-0.261855334,
-0.1106389686,
0.5096746087,
-0.4257346392,
0.7691137195,
0.4175167084,
-0.3119058311,
-0.2035623342,
-0.4326499701,
0.178612411,
-0.195302248,
-0.7428737283,
0.1519261748,
0.7164789438,
0.1896042377,
0.4758266211,
0.7511207461,
-0.2708401978,
0.1949649304,
0.1556323171,
0.5411784649,
0.0612071566,
-0.5666718483,
-0.775865078,
0.147637248,
0.2396653891,
-0.7111718059
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09830v1
|
Negation Triplet Extraction with Syntactic Dependency and Semantic Consistency
| 2024-04-15T14:28:33 | 2024-04-15T14:28:33 |
Yuchen Shi, Deqing Yang, Jingping Liu, Yanghua Xiao, Zongyu Wang, Huimin Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Previous works of negation understanding mainly focus on negation cue
detection and scope resolution, without identifying negation subject which is
also significant to the downstream tasks. In this paper, we propose a new
negation triplet extraction (NTE) task which aims to extract negation subject
along with negation cue and scope. To achieve NTE, we devise a novel
Syntax&Semantic-Enhanced Negation Extraction model, namely SSENE, which is
built based on a generative pretrained language model (PLM) {of Encoder-Decoder
architecture} with a multi-task learning framework. Specifically, the given
sentence's syntactic dependency tree is incorporated into the PLM's encoder to
discover the correlations between the negation subject, cue and scope.
Moreover, the semantic consistency between the sentence and the extracted
triplet is ensured by an auxiliary task learning. Furthermore, we have
constructed a high-quality Chinese dataset NegComment based on the users'
reviews from the real-world platform of Meituan, upon which our evaluations
show that SSENE achieves the best NTE performance compared to the baselines.
Our ablation and case studies also demonstrate that incorporating the syntactic
information helps the PLM's recognize the distant dependency between the
subject and cue, and the auxiliary task learning is helpful to extract the
negation triplets with more semantic consistency.
|
[
-0.2703373134,
-0.7669553757,
0.3769972026,
0.167081207,
-0.2179913968,
-0.2801701128,
-0.325435549,
-0.4368356764,
0.2922228277,
0.8249336481,
-0.4859834611,
-0.5908941031,
-0.6268807054,
0.2400966734,
-0.2343725562,
0.8882095814,
0.0306178499,
-0.0457568355,
0.1907727718,
0.1571774334,
-0.817579031,
-0.1519696116,
-0.6508936882,
0.0183433723,
0.2467372119,
0.6136499047,
0.2115288228,
0.3812660873,
0.1947996616,
0.2561219931,
0.1587007791,
0.1807152331,
-0.0915809348,
-0.0502360761,
-0.2400376797,
-0.3176576495,
-0.5882469416,
-0.0687410831,
0.6887423396,
0.2744386792,
-0.0004040731,
0.0322424509,
0.3104828298,
0.6429469585,
-0.5485984683,
0.4284354746,
-0.6899500489,
-0.1265360564,
-0.2315445244,
0.0874376297,
-0.3461902738,
-0.3017540872,
0.2336121649,
-0.6910563111,
0.1318003386,
-0.320735693,
1.4247293472,
0.2867657244,
-0.7421178222,
0.3311640024,
-0.3312055171,
0.6153194904,
-0.8414113522,
0.4529180229,
0.3265767395,
0.2707935572,
0.1151146442,
-0.3677823544,
-0.6772968769,
-0.3980065286,
-0.0808533579,
0.1859029084,
0.1565414518,
0.0623058528,
0.1257731616,
0.3843148053,
-0.4273061156,
0.12191163,
-0.1597904116,
-0.2893466651,
0.2698594928,
-0.1842005104,
0.561493516,
-0.731082201,
-0.4249556661,
0.2475636303,
-0.6600096226,
-0.3688093424,
0.2628689408,
0.3615995944,
-0.02545215,
0.4819930196,
-0.1737275124,
0.7910937667,
0.2544670105,
0.1765080541,
0.5233487487,
-0.6221337914,
-0.0998530835,
-0.0533216298,
0.7950119972,
0.1908223927,
0.1642551422,
-0.2568927705,
0.0144741712,
0.1046607941,
0.2706114054,
-0.5520614982,
-0.1850000024,
-0.0859529749,
-0.2523021102,
-0.0693211406,
0.1690986156,
-0.6761912704,
-0.1730735749,
-0.5304580331,
0.4924565554,
-0.7496239543,
-0.6586838365,
0.0460697934,
-0.1679771394,
0.4421895444,
0.125325501,
-0.865921855,
0.3474884033,
0.6514853239,
0.6826402545,
-0.2636334598,
-0.3135980666,
-0.7826605439,
0.2976027429,
-0.0643298328,
0.4928298295,
-0.1006078422,
0.2742007971,
-0.5036445856,
0.3051479459,
-0.1971952319,
-0.3976250589,
0.2160816789,
-0.4536055326,
0.1967924833,
-0.0014579792,
-0.4728460014,
-0.6731080413,
0.3880734444,
-0.9199590683,
0.8302747011,
0.0190656371,
-0.4891610146,
0.4311257005,
-0.7226209641,
-0.4907687902,
0.252905339,
-0.210680902,
-0.0120773837,
0.0153316809,
0.2780024409,
0.5208294988,
-0.1916684657,
0.4947625697,
-0.0948094949,
-0.0790700391,
-0.4718652964,
-0.3227415085,
0.915297389,
-0.4213706851,
-0.5467107892,
0.2475999892,
-0.7626124024,
-0.1157117635,
-0.0303880665,
-0.0487393364,
-0.1857095659,
-0.1491441578,
-0.1293341517,
0.2893637121,
0.4477401078,
-0.8847196102,
-0.2721039057,
-0.7500742674,
0.402090013,
0.7868986726,
0.1797900796,
0.3177911639,
0.0729341283,
0.2450113297,
-0.1767119616,
-0.1945403069,
0.1240624413,
-0.2344731987,
-0.686745584,
-0.0652780384,
0.3274067044,
0.6629414558,
-0.9981275797,
0.6421446204,
-0.3934523761,
-0.0685653389,
-0.1362544149,
0.1757632047,
0.4118689001,
0.5258980393,
0.4743758142,
-0.0533617027,
-0.6897451282,
-0.9948034286,
-0.1605312228,
0.0488011949,
0.1862483323,
0.0983328223,
0.5715666413,
0.1237333566,
0.745349884,
-0.5435340405,
-0.3387914598,
-0.4757160544,
0.2012555897,
0.245126158,
0.6310944557,
0.1938833892,
-0.9083365798,
-0.7060418725,
0.1545983404,
-0.7579160929,
-0.0097767487,
0.0633251294,
-0.4405598044,
0.2393029332,
0.4235775769,
-0.3727460206,
0.4037534297,
0.3032764792,
-0.1402410567,
0.8670956492,
0.1291122437,
-0.1205205992,
-1.1592442989,
-0.0432910733,
0.0688184574,
-0.2300439775,
-0.6296940446,
0.1252980232,
0.4425234199,
0.3069736958,
-0.5714367628,
0.3786399961,
-0.6256164312,
0.0342152342,
-0.4037056863,
0.3074002564,
0.2546400726,
0.7545489073,
0.4600116611,
0.3212133348,
0.5929657221,
-0.6918238997,
0.3157340586,
0.2108476162,
0.0190862678,
0.5647808313,
-0.4970430136,
0.0522515737,
-0.0606442243,
-0.0484244898,
-0.4077355266,
-0.1229986548,
0.346929878,
-0.2684147358,
0.393830657,
-0.191383034,
-0.6773173809,
-0.214385435,
-0.1543951482,
0.154898569,
0.1843547523,
-0.5643579364,
0.7236434817,
0.331117928,
0.045854114,
-0.6046695113,
-0.589538455,
0.1119310483,
-0.1582337022,
-0.4822739065,
0.4371906817,
0.2266530395,
0.163673684,
0.116501689,
-0.442833513,
-0.1837558001,
0.1889458895,
0.0995111614,
0.551028192,
-0.4405709803,
0.1480540633,
-0.2428146005,
-0.4577954412,
0.0028218068,
-0.4940347672,
0.4391416907,
-0.3244016171,
-0.1330390722,
-0.5004574656,
0.3286184072,
0.1341220886,
-0.3446782827,
0.5792062879,
0.6615521908,
-0.6009571552,
-0.0527111627,
-0.5651931763,
-0.4369157851,
-0.4027630091,
0.4550447464,
-0.3929612041,
-0.7400429845,
0.0330793858,
0.2464903742,
0.1526922435,
0.5600670576,
-0.1399570554,
0.1606460363,
0.6904636025,
0.762978673,
0.1095999777,
0.5017659068,
-0.3158078194,
0.0477846675,
-1.1129297018,
0.0859073699,
-0.1126204878,
0.1578687727,
-0.392020762,
-0.159866631,
0.3128543794,
0.1013621315,
-0.2799333036,
0.8701634407,
-0.4121388197,
0.5411804914,
0.4382714927,
0.3797406852,
0.1601974964,
-0.0996855423,
0.0419877321,
-0.030710293,
-0.2319103777,
-0.518743515,
0.8664630055,
-0.0961391106,
-0.1163462251,
0.3323632777,
0.9350221157,
-0.2564119101,
-0.04122651,
-0.6179557443,
0.7850300074,
-0.565517962,
-0.638630271,
-0.2145247757,
-0.5073019266,
-0.7506283522,
0.5698697567,
-0.1365449876,
-1.0779086351,
0.0901294425,
-0.0487058349,
-0.3326480985,
0.3128719032,
-0.6565858126,
1.2328208685,
-0.2883176804,
-0.629499495,
-0.1076315045,
-0.758833468,
0.5950448513,
0.0173903666,
-0.1652569622,
-0.3170723617,
-0.0004367049,
0.8067817092,
-0.2914788127,
0.9564257264,
-0.1129387617,
-0.0339753665,
0.0800105184,
0.0180015303,
0.3722371161,
0.045921661,
-0.1833468378,
0.2665013969,
-0.242692396,
-0.3382754624,
-0.5166517496,
0.6104770899,
-0.3690581322,
-0.7136114836,
-0.3791299462,
-0.3722561896,
-0.1612875611,
0.6785043478,
0.0187046826,
0.4412052035,
-0.081627585,
-0.0609206706,
0.385337472,
-0.1238237172,
0.5191837549,
0.6315244436,
0.1411866993,
-0.2648808956,
1.2100368738,
0.0632443428,
0.5089598894,
0.5735874772,
0.1897305548,
-0.1584661454,
-0.4256621897,
-0.3855795264,
0.2944146395,
-0.5502517223,
-0.1598145366,
-0.7786304355,
-0.4591287076,
-0.3569595814,
0.0985715017,
-0.267007947,
-0.3982633352,
-0.346057564,
-0.3540484607,
0.3517492712,
0.6580061913,
-0.2434255779,
0.3779608607,
-0.9118526578,
0.8280128837,
0.1869121641,
0.0527376719,
-0.1062645614,
-0.0867442414,
-0.097120218,
-0.0815578401,
-0.2936351895,
-1.333029747,
0.3880174458,
0.1060561612,
0.6937410235,
0.2193933874,
-0.1996998042,
0.5810260177,
-0.3018962443,
0.7920439839,
0.2414282858,
-1.2158747911,
0.6245862246,
-0.1892216206,
0.3326387405,
0.7209974527,
-0.0112381252,
-0.3941185176,
-0.3709400594,
-0.7090787292,
-1.1003551483,
1.065708518,
0.111714527,
-0.2555423081,
-0.1059399247,
0.1660902351,
0.4004082978,
0.3496331871,
-1.1366493702,
-0.1130686179,
-0.2122852057,
-0.1689784229,
0.0522573702,
-0.1178452298,
0.4056341648,
-0.0879893601,
0.848506093,
-0.0346686654,
-0.0245189052,
-0.2388905883,
-0.3949107528,
0.5111527443,
0.1852559745,
-0.0257215407,
0.1419379562,
-0.2541682422,
0.3002615571,
0.1065903753,
-0.4133485258,
-0.0713990629,
0.128165707,
-0.155137822,
-0.1100329757,
0.4226572812,
0.6718721986,
0.2399501055,
-0.1988064349,
0.6374374032,
0.2029404044,
-0.1905207485,
-0.3040989935,
-0.0574761815,
0.0236167964,
-0.2390313298,
-0.0649419874,
0.1922849417,
0.2577282488,
-0.1270680428,
0.4969415069,
0.3462933302,
-0.3718896806,
-0.1540996134,
0.3733014464,
0.161553815,
0.1858390272,
0.6562274098,
-0.4290646613,
-0.7673974633,
0.8940934539,
0.4595674872,
1.0319484472,
0.0354753956,
0.3268193007,
0.7335911989,
0.4697206616,
0.0128487125,
0.5456574559,
-0.3776435256,
-0.9119391441,
-0.6316084266,
-0.335775733,
0.1042339206,
-0.0259700995,
-0.6472468376,
0.3528514802,
-0.2815791965,
0.2009001076,
-0.1042968705,
-0.0975954607,
-0.5701876879,
-0.0476036593,
0.1693321168,
0.3453473151,
-0.7891095877,
0.8764750361,
0.4273409843,
-0.7206576467,
-1.0784934759,
0.2017982453,
0.0767647028,
-0.7138511539,
0.9482300878,
0.6644964218,
-0.2006940246,
0.1592758596,
-0.193348676,
-0.9896002412,
0.7934982777,
0.3500515819,
-0.3214672804,
-0.0029502087,
-0.24146308,
0.1582905799,
-0.2154432684,
0.4939308167,
0.5239968896,
0.6670758128,
-0.202087447,
-0.9529506564,
0.4044152796,
-0.3713530898,
-0.1386854649,
0.3951583803,
-0.3649143875,
0.7475978732,
-0.0280936994,
-0.628202796,
-0.2414230704,
0.7053659558,
0.1522832215,
0.0032109397,
0.6440267563,
0.3526830077,
0.4784777164,
0.0351228826,
0.5914335251,
-0.1600613892,
-0.1666242927,
1.6074143648,
-0.3539938033,
0.7884403467,
0.4696094394,
0.2502830327,
0.802020967,
0.3427346647,
0.0001611993,
0.4206961095,
-0.0100480039,
-0.0471061468,
-0.2804712951,
-0.1411481351,
-0.2045381963,
0.3878355622,
0.4134599566,
-0.1349900067,
-0.5170123577,
0.2662942111,
-0.0035641973,
0.0952274799,
-0.1030050442,
0.9493309259,
0.0590827726,
-0.6507878304,
0.5385449529,
-0.1810464859,
0.6648116708,
-0.4727002084,
-0.4327505827,
0.2913156748,
-0.0582945906,
-0.4860955179,
-0.5019627213,
0.3410974741,
-0.2451378405,
-0.0515089966,
-0.2715578973,
0.5529406071,
-0.4566781223,
-0.3241922557,
0.5149260163,
0.5266261101,
0.2625409663,
-0.1869102269,
-0.5115137696,
-0.4210783839,
0.1468821764,
-0.0081668766,
-0.0387662016,
0.3775028586,
-0.0012947159,
0.1795393974,
0.5612124801,
0.1439526379,
0.1475410908,
0.0560247265,
0.4729180038,
-0.7669378519,
-0.6387239695,
-0.9346737266,
0.5178922415,
-0.4055814743,
-0.1374526322,
1.0472973585,
0.4230351746,
0.5439741015,
0.1268399954,
0.7479862571,
-0.2821488976,
0.2725841701,
-0.6156471968,
0.0804939568,
-0.4752063453,
0.3635985255,
-0.1793451309,
-0.7814192176,
-0.2677820325,
0.5126712322,
-0.5379802585,
-0.0921498463,
1.1270061731,
0.848482728,
-0.108416453,
0.516890645,
0.0099271629,
0.3242737353,
0.1217350438,
1.0149852037,
0.6897202134,
-0.4477380812,
0.3080107272,
-0.4544550776,
-0.2236815393,
0.0330022424,
-0.9517630935,
-0.6180356741,
-0.5312026143,
-0.5106371641,
-0.2391576916,
0.0001580977,
0.7126514912,
0.7767156959,
-0.7362044454,
-0.1159001365,
-0.67399472,
0.4269833267,
-0.6520374417,
-0.3707916141,
0.6293724775,
-0.2434754372,
-0.6949130297,
0.6047155857,
0.2343313843,
-0.1981315464,
0.056041643,
0.0913736671,
-0.6223049164,
-0.5091231465,
0.37411201,
0.1630608141,
-0.6871899962,
-0.2657419145,
-0.1598776877,
0.0082238913,
0.0308363885,
0.3447021246,
-0.7088202834,
0.2331139147,
0.4828193486,
0.4775222838,
0.6419541836,
-0.3678729832,
0.8417733312,
-0.5933439732,
-0.1601277143,
0.1282261014,
0.3867453039,
0.2813916504,
-0.4978260994,
0.5083813071,
0.2208510339,
-0.0914302319,
-0.4428921342,
0.3938320577,
-0.8732634187,
-0.3441841602,
1.1696432829,
-0.0434312411,
-0.4610843956,
-0.3553965986,
-0.1293990314,
0.4729476273,
-0.356435746,
0.0734955519,
0.6475499272,
-0.0734238327,
-0.1538372338,
-0.8260113001,
0.1497900635,
0.7201123834,
-0.7385391593,
-0.0423260815,
0.5939924717,
0.2719322741,
0.1630800068,
0.4689272642,
-0.1314470172,
0.4057916105,
-0.097413674,
0.3894740343,
-0.1508686393,
-0.3453647196,
-0.2726620138,
0.3396266401,
-0.3484938145,
-0.56447047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09824v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09824v1
|
Impact of Preference Noise on the Alignment Performance of Generative Language Models
| 2024-04-15T14:21:53 | 2024-04-15T14:21:53 |
Yang Gao, Dana Alon, Donald Metzler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A key requirement in developing Generative Language Models (GLMs) is to have
their values aligned with human values. Preference-based alignment is a widely
used paradigm for this purpose, in which preferences over generation pairs are
first elicited from human annotators or AI systems, and then fed into some
alignment techniques, e.g., Direct Preference Optimization. However, a
substantial percent (20 - 40%) of the preference pairs used in GLM alignment
are noisy, and it remains unclear how the noise affects the alignment
performance and how to mitigate its negative impact. In this paper, we propose
a framework to inject desirable amounts and types of noise to the preferences,
and systematically study the impact of preference noise on the alignment
performance in two tasks (summarization and dialogue generation). We find that
the alignment performance can be highly sensitive to the noise rates in the
preference data: e.g., a 10 percentage points (pp) increase of the noise rate
can lead to 30 pp drop in the alignment performance (in win rate). To mitigate
the impact of noise, confidence-based data filtering shows significant benefit
when certain types of noise are present. We hope our work can help the
community better understand and mitigate the impact of preference noise in GLM
alignment.
|
[
-0.4452034831,
-0.4346553981,
0.3891691267,
0.0740746483,
-0.4164997041,
-0.1008326039,
-0.2388484627,
-0.6672359109,
0.1178015992,
0.4644343555,
-0.3902037442,
-0.4480087459,
-0.4161564112,
-0.133424446,
-0.3425816,
1.1215945482,
0.1572906226,
-0.0940185413,
-0.578623414,
-0.066744186,
-0.3834760189,
-0.7447299957,
-0.4150677919,
-0.29855299,
0.3780484498,
0.12330845,
1.1578823328,
0.6778378487,
0.5429251194,
0.2261056006,
-0.3914420307,
-0.1280890554,
-0.5091706514,
0.4112714529,
0.2565625012,
-0.4780759811,
-0.7189161181,
-0.1613872796,
0.5999316573,
0.4991830885,
-0.2035202682,
-0.0298522878,
0.4374803305,
0.7617551088,
-0.5914812684,
0.2404135764,
-0.544105947,
0.0266877897,
-0.4577473402,
-0.26917997,
-0.2528969049,
-0.3904722333,
0.1622885168,
-0.5788127184,
0.3221283555,
0.1170174479,
1.0662398338,
0.4301995635,
0.0136838472,
-0.2346475124,
-0.7313362956,
0.9479527473,
-0.7581766248,
0.2934441268,
0.3152761161,
-0.2219609618,
-0.1522321403,
0.006536027,
-0.4482674003,
0.0941413566,
-0.2332163006,
0.1535060555,
-0.2055315673,
0.2424892336,
0.3688103259,
0.6016275287,
-0.4862999618,
0.1573649645,
-0.1640315205,
-0.0894808844,
0.6185426116,
0.1479998529,
0.1537329406,
-0.0710501745,
0.0442462787,
-0.037862923,
-0.4863389134,
0.1562598944,
0.8834990263,
0.5341734886,
-0.1960182637,
0.4751860797,
-0.290645957,
1.0801092386,
0.3807049692,
-0.2622298896,
0.4482035041,
-0.6441580057,
-0.0516993701,
0.0966418311,
0.741447866,
0.6778056622,
0.2573307753,
-0.1676425338,
-0.2208496332,
0.3415988386,
0.3510375917,
-0.7240023017,
-0.1406038702,
0.1587888747,
-0.5437434912,
-0.6487811208,
-0.316442728,
-0.940649569,
-0.3893742263,
-0.7619918585,
0.2558525801,
-0.2748758495,
-0.418127954,
0.2234754264,
0.0644248053,
0.2997844815,
0.3653784394,
-1.3110407591,
0.1498035342,
0.7672742009,
0.85104388,
-0.3593659103,
0.1884775311,
-0.4518511593,
0.0785337612,
-0.1912998855,
0.8471061587,
-0.4569508731,
-0.6947767138,
-0.0967218801,
-0.4559856653,
-0.1274905503,
-0.6258360744,
0.6121001244,
-0.437793076,
0.2984915376,
-0.3817761838,
-0.6046904325,
0.2336588353,
-0.1690530628,
-0.5871484876,
0.8415737748,
0.1399829239,
-0.7666373253,
0.7060237527,
-0.6095185876,
-0.6762658954,
-0.0995106772,
-0.2862302363,
-0.7345061302,
0.1237833723,
0.1959861517,
0.0730354264,
-0.1901780069,
0.3572076261,
-0.2764802277,
-0.5579683185,
0.2536191344,
-0.3349051774,
0.7249111533,
0.1825248748,
-0.3958371282,
0.3850767016,
-0.6431527734,
-0.0202955455,
-0.3328018188,
-0.1139437407,
-0.335108012,
0.0745178536,
-0.1732334644,
0.2519528866,
0.1423452497,
-0.231694296,
0.1907754689,
-0.4627185464,
0.1383217424,
0.9013491273,
-0.0268307943,
0.6093415618,
-0.622140348,
0.5826027393,
0.2026729435,
0.4066249728,
0.4630574286,
-0.7071447372,
-0.669148922,
-0.234336108,
0.2641976774,
0.0469713435,
-0.1250029802,
0.4996192455,
-0.3097852767,
-0.3020655811,
-0.9619288445,
0.3136031926,
0.2586139739,
0.8039565086,
0.3963300884,
-0.4710927904,
-0.5339072347,
-1.0488702059,
-0.1156812608,
-0.4554561675,
0.0171388034,
0.2155791521,
-0.0431489199,
0.1682161093,
1.3653739691,
-0.5641821027,
-0.2621673644,
-0.0108187022,
0.1500823051,
0.239476949,
0.5246747136,
0.5966261029,
-0.985175848,
-0.4970180988,
-0.2531148791,
-0.3260227442,
-0.3250906169,
0.175755769,
-0.31486395,
0.3613859117,
0.219960019,
-0.4402271211,
0.4575174749,
0.8498393893,
-0.1882955432,
0.6860563755,
0.1545937359,
0.0617769994,
-1.0138767958,
0.1750129312,
0.0839856267,
0.0780778602,
-0.7242048979,
-0.3565615118,
-0.2592728734,
0.2639836371,
-0.2131899446,
0.0716601461,
-0.3129239678,
-0.2266612351,
-0.2248151153,
-0.1033089906,
0.1418945938,
0.3950709403,
0.2667591572,
1.1318141222,
0.3202885687,
-0.6491775513,
-0.1313225329,
0.257481128,
-0.4269640744,
0.7771900296,
-0.5414190888,
0.1463698745,
-0.2553563714,
-0.0284570958,
-0.8784632683,
-0.0015803421,
0.3372498155,
-0.3250153959,
0.3444084823,
-0.3528930247,
-0.2768579125,
0.2004179955,
-0.3143288493,
0.3060835004,
0.6086463928,
-0.2550684512,
0.2779121399,
0.5127771497,
-0.1500997692,
-0.5550735593,
-0.2809920311,
-0.1981129348,
-0.4167115688,
-0.6412181854,
0.394377023,
-0.2495947927,
-0.3419948816,
0.0860140994,
-0.0472225696,
0.2895015478,
0.174679473,
0.5907227993,
0.6070253849,
-0.126352489,
0.1261266619,
-0.2545945346,
-0.2018073499,
-0.0593644418,
-0.165640682,
0.7741497755,
-0.2630584538,
-0.3220309615,
-0.3118584156,
0.2076477408,
0.6380102038,
-0.174173668,
0.7224926353,
0.4172855318,
0.0236301571,
0.3279457986,
-0.4691886604,
0.0065973536,
-0.4415578544,
0.3736532032,
-0.2760698199,
-0.6915453076,
0.3498440683,
0.3089955151,
0.1343631893,
0.5535413623,
0.496950984,
-0.3629238904,
1.2105761766,
0.3803182244,
-0.5613452196,
0.7551590204,
0.1130251363,
0.2283948213,
-1.1312274933,
0.0777870342,
-0.6639324427,
-0.4288614988,
-0.590131104,
-0.2671704888,
0.3021146655,
0.1868463457,
-0.0818585604,
0.0859901607,
-0.576600194,
0.1506550461,
0.7461808324,
-0.1355075836,
0.5921929479,
0.26335302,
0.1328692138,
-0.3003714085,
-0.5213721395,
-0.3868664205,
1.1715921164,
0.1168375686,
0.7711001039,
0.31171,
0.6164435744,
0.1378155202,
0.2140801698,
-0.7507148981,
0.3000026047,
-0.199650079,
-0.3920560181,
-0.4689491987,
-0.3270879984,
-0.8370341063,
0.1246725246,
-0.2889868915,
-0.8961074948,
0.4125208557,
0.4322047234,
-0.4293372333,
0.185903579,
-0.4056676924,
0.6901581883,
-0.1108267531,
-0.4097812474,
-0.1638737023,
-0.6564416885,
0.1611883044,
0.0940175951,
0.1928241551,
-0.1141714975,
0.4331270754,
0.6765474677,
-0.0952840745,
0.8966687322,
-0.1598425806,
-0.2699046433,
0.0149463005,
-0.1968253404,
0.6827935576,
-0.358463496,
-0.168568328,
0.3037997782,
-0.3319433033,
-0.075594686,
-0.5371745229,
0.4560749531,
-0.8794109225,
-0.7037801147,
-0.2974856496,
-0.697709918,
-0.2895516157,
-0.161381945,
0.6123914123,
0.2499677539,
-0.1429091394,
0.0988140702,
0.6520098448,
0.1526070088,
0.1750961542,
0.3019210994,
-0.4320155382,
-0.1952246726,
1.0820095539,
0.2418634892,
0.6555928588,
0.1262056381,
-0.0260787569,
-0.4056692719,
-0.6333527565,
-0.3652335107,
-0.0250031855,
-0.3076796532,
-0.0925694257,
-0.6346902251,
-0.266156733,
-0.4191086292,
-0.2093807161,
-0.2954905927,
-0.4228376448,
-0.4554160833,
-0.044846572,
0.2578835487,
0.42370978,
-0.0307514183,
0.2579376101,
-0.2931184173,
0.2517759502,
0.2100684941,
0.6187067032,
-0.1694390029,
-0.4664009213,
-0.2422482669,
0.1339348704,
-0.1638061702,
-0.5909443498,
0.222040087,
0.0045566247,
0.315726757,
0.6025444865,
0.1729549319,
0.7617557645,
-0.021750316,
0.7171740532,
0.1474154145,
-0.9201241732,
0.431584239,
-0.2921759784,
0.2370858938,
0.6225790977,
-0.2344817519,
-0.6491939425,
-0.5998340249,
-0.5998404622,
-0.7985205054,
0.6724157333,
0.3192231059,
-0.1768524796,
0.2774059474,
0.1423288584,
-0.0051547978,
0.4844448566,
-0.3802776635,
-0.4151387513,
-0.1039308906,
-0.1214718148,
-0.2412867844,
-0.472674638,
-0.3251537979,
-0.1923860312,
0.7421982288,
-0.0850615948,
0.2021929175,
-0.0796337724,
0.0222100001,
-0.4949506223,
0.5355303288,
0.7517771721,
0.1998784244,
-0.5033165812,
-0.1840371937,
-0.3222016394,
-0.3702025712,
0.1774107516,
-0.0280232728,
-0.97841537,
0.0084561789,
0.0997002497,
1.0806868076,
0.0933399051,
-0.1793241054,
0.4333422184,
-0.0463839509,
-0.1442421526,
0.0254789609,
0.2652677894,
0.1176523119,
-0.3449564278,
-0.0516005754,
0.5402747393,
0.32477054,
-0.2917511463,
-0.0406288691,
0.6974002123,
-0.5744485855,
-0.3271715343,
0.5319946408,
0.1778402328,
-0.0630338937,
0.5635329485,
-0.1023296639,
-0.5533088446,
0.4799931347,
0.5387943983,
0.8521704078,
-0.1738769561,
0.234208554,
0.2369579226,
0.0808445662,
0.0227388255,
0.1417243481,
-0.1500917077,
-1.0666774511,
-0.3855927587,
-0.8560484648,
-0.5230677724,
-0.024893837,
-1.0010464191,
0.1622646451,
0.0911665037,
-0.4086788595,
-0.0118790474,
-0.1789750904,
-0.5007444024,
-0.0006009112,
0.095315434,
0.2319462895,
-0.8426699638,
0.5890667439,
0.4907456934,
-0.2225852162,
-0.6033373475,
0.1756209433,
0.3285470605,
-0.6621167064,
0.366315484,
-0.0581268966,
-0.2692966461,
-0.0831971318,
-0.2675761878,
-0.9867062569,
0.6684235334,
0.563057065,
-0.6767106652,
0.0848906562,
0.3304644525,
0.6087472439,
-0.3060107231,
-0.0350994617,
0.6861103773,
0.622325778,
0.1746412963,
-0.9580584764,
-0.1267083883,
-0.312531352,
-0.0235325154,
0.3601011932,
-0.7996457815,
0.7207745314,
-0.093441762,
-0.3632002175,
-0.0413016342,
0.4116269946,
0.0802766979,
0.0421122685,
0.7055382133,
0.551682353,
0.8493513465,
-0.1308059394,
0.8786597848,
-0.5331984162,
0.1629329622,
1.3818787336,
-0.5283705592,
0.6248716116,
0.7592570782,
-0.3396481276,
0.309568435,
0.3522092104,
0.0307471938,
0.5777080059,
0.2694214582,
-0.4888989925,
-0.2355391234,
-0.618737638,
-0.6666361094,
0.3384826183,
0.2560965717,
-0.3132204115,
0.154891327,
-0.4369976521,
-0.0372049361,
-0.1260949224,
-0.0955402926,
1.1356642246,
-0.238489747,
-0.8411735296,
0.202286616,
-0.4621703327,
0.7940336466,
-0.5076800585,
0.1716606915,
-0.0739706382,
0.0319561884,
-0.3938825727,
-0.8235912323,
0.357357353,
-0.1658786237,
-0.5814472437,
-0.1296501905,
0.5631062388,
-0.6191568375,
-0.145252347,
0.3419084847,
0.288903147,
-0.1256321669,
-0.0962664559,
-0.281765908,
0.2002747357,
0.2610944211,
-0.1518101245,
0.7410089374,
-0.1153475195,
0.1709353775,
0.2918515205,
0.7851656079,
0.3104923666,
-0.1447027028,
0.3177029788,
0.9273016453,
-0.2574324608,
-0.4869189858,
-0.9300169945,
0.5208359957,
-0.3264374137,
-0.2661707997,
0.5635226965,
0.7057781816,
0.6169993281,
0.1106591299,
0.9365086555,
0.0224989038,
0.3048371077,
-0.524286449,
0.7568848133,
-0.2539378405,
0.34967646,
-0.5824887156,
-0.947496295,
-0.2592137158,
0.4785251021,
-0.3352206051,
-0.0932175592,
0.2424193323,
1.1066769361,
0.2675593793,
0.2521659136,
0.4007439315,
0.1224657297,
0.3666665554,
0.2649327815,
0.6836711168,
-0.1370078921,
0.4823059738,
-0.5372972488,
-0.0613839664,
-0.2458102852,
-0.8265348077,
-0.3692140281,
-0.5854967237,
-0.5525276065,
-0.4626551867,
0.243638128,
0.7359805703,
0.6931139827,
-0.9516474009,
-0.3437699974,
-0.0215432569,
0.1104656458,
-0.3284660876,
-0.2531564236,
0.415943861,
-0.4513131678,
-0.8145430684,
0.1571712792,
0.3860838711,
0.2575975358,
0.0945697129,
-0.2747983932,
0.0482252873,
-0.3000299931,
0.2796732783,
0.1897185147,
-0.6080058217,
-0.3140688241,
-0.123741731,
-0.2950135767,
0.4562059045,
0.6831762195,
-0.5488186479,
0.642119348,
0.145318985,
0.1181879118,
0.3095908463,
0.3816989958,
0.9172408581,
-0.7721536756,
0.0883919746,
0.1257505417,
0.2913611829,
0.2770368755,
-0.6467124224,
0.5020858049,
0.1781805605,
-0.6173073649,
-0.6813132167,
0.1460608989,
-0.8280284405,
0.1818225682,
1.1111863852,
0.2355653495,
0.2613163292,
-0.3122701347,
-0.3143541813,
0.24729985,
-0.7930955291,
0.8495336175,
0.9953871369,
-0.3228110969,
0.0607181787,
-0.212028861,
0.9985018969,
0.7022247314,
-0.3563045859,
0.2693103552,
0.5801180005,
-0.0489597283,
0.2936352789,
0.7099525928,
-0.2032104731,
0.12068782,
-0.2204603851,
0.1638059169,
0.1969309598,
0.0790905952,
-0.6065228581,
0.3358012736,
0.3484971523,
-0.0931426808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09785v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09785v1
|
Benchmarking Llama2, Mistral, Gemma and GPT for Factuality, Toxicity, Bias and Propensity for Hallucinations
| 2024-04-15T13:40:08 | 2024-04-15T13:40:08 |
David Nadeau, Mike Kroutikov, Karen McNeil, Simon Baribeau
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces fourteen novel datasets for the evaluation of Large
Language Models' safety in the context of enterprise tasks. A method was
devised to evaluate a model's safety, as determined by its ability to follow
instructions and output factual, unbiased, grounded, and appropriate content.
In this research, we used OpenAI GPT as point of comparison since it excels at
all levels of safety. On the open-source side, for smaller models, Meta Llama2
performs well at factuality and toxicity but has the highest propensity for
hallucination. Mistral hallucinates the least but cannot handle toxicity well.
It performs well in a dataset mixing several tasks and safety vectors in a
narrow vertical domain. Gemma, the newly introduced open-source model based on
Google Gemini, is generally balanced but trailing behind. When engaging in
back-and-forth conversation (multi-turn prompts), we find that the safety of
open-source models degrades significantly. Aside from OpenAI's GPT, Mistral is
the only model that still performed well in multi-turn tests.
|
[
-0.1601724774,
-0.7296414375,
0.7021335363,
0.4931747317,
0.0923340619,
-0.5163963437,
-0.1870087534,
-0.6858025789,
-0.1514995843,
0.457508713,
-0.2280248553,
-0.6150780916,
-0.6656455398,
0.1261132658,
-0.7603161931,
1.0967690945,
0.0716166049,
0.1049076915,
0.0620667823,
-0.2070956826,
-0.5289134979,
-0.9213984609,
-0.7028207779,
-0.1608567536,
0.6199868917,
-0.1533928514,
0.9517105222,
0.3191857934,
0.6235164404,
0.2479030341,
-0.0927283838,
-0.1544424146,
-0.5871207714,
0.3616917431,
-0.3909547329,
-0.2874937057,
-0.5010616183,
-0.0775166899,
0.2052789778,
0.3956908286,
-0.4767227173,
0.11728286,
0.1944926828,
0.272038728,
-0.7560525537,
0.2891480327,
-0.7045263052,
-0.0382382385,
0.0058643254,
0.1036749259,
-0.5305660963,
-0.5764487982,
-0.0591363385,
-0.5299841762,
-0.1213154867,
0.1163955927,
0.8572456241,
0.5562722087,
-0.4112782478,
-0.4859277904,
-0.695123136,
0.6881358027,
-0.614708364,
0.4855799079,
0.3022588193,
0.3746483624,
-0.1466774791,
-0.8988726139,
-0.3826175034,
-0.621931076,
0.1074082032,
-0.0092520462,
-0.3902226388,
0.1102703586,
0.255553782,
0.2446725667,
-0.4785040319,
0.2940396369,
-0.3935749233,
-0.2012015879,
0.4848653674,
0.4299780726,
0.3402231634,
0.0682041869,
-0.3606942892,
-0.401219964,
-0.8882332444,
-0.386482507,
0.2075218707,
0.2223947495,
0.0371859781,
0.7174577117,
-0.1000355184,
0.2488843352,
-0.0810700879,
-0.2171156853,
0.3212782741,
-0.1834853739,
-0.379219681,
-0.0478899181,
1.0172765255,
0.5342868567,
0.2994467616,
-0.4780454934,
-0.1093376577,
0.4024826884,
0.537391603,
-0.7421607971,
-0.3042839766,
0.4063266218,
-0.4953187406,
-0.5208007097,
-0.1723242402,
-0.9064084888,
-0.6667530537,
-0.2301073223,
0.6823225617,
-0.1743980348,
-0.4163979292,
0.1910832077,
0.2406084985,
0.1889877766,
0.2185762972,
-0.7737330794,
0.5183581114,
0.7783493996,
0.9947548509,
-0.5158907771,
-0.400110513,
-0.5028640628,
0.0436779372,
-0.5398737192,
0.7080771923,
-0.1952530891,
-0.3632628024,
0.0077883257,
0.0697212443,
-0.0296960082,
-0.7425289154,
0.8772344589,
-0.1043785438,
0.1137024462,
-0.63166219,
-0.0305731539,
-0.2539559007,
0.1567271054,
-0.8276179433,
1.1812403202,
-0.1758945137,
-1.0708221197,
0.4866527319,
-0.5079126954,
-0.3401766717,
-0.3359257579,
-0.2107486427,
-0.1191175207,
0.0269237775,
0.0285310987,
0.4462018013,
-0.4255966246,
0.3940461576,
-0.3875913918,
-0.2675705552,
0.1516523957,
-0.5767485499,
0.8459144831,
0.1662436128,
-0.5957154036,
0.1486367136,
-0.6200038791,
-0.1059345603,
-0.0496580005,
-0.2141337693,
-0.3629885316,
0.0610121042,
0.3362435997,
0.4299448431,
-0.1842117608,
-0.2858490944,
-0.3642192185,
0.0468398966,
0.1655894369,
0.6860946417,
-0.0026593232,
-0.2479207963,
-0.3903557062,
0.1746522784,
0.1636327207,
0.3502587974,
0.1606085151,
-0.5217955709,
-0.7525413632,
-0.2413076013,
0.1539470702,
0.7984914184,
-0.593303144,
0.3842314482,
-0.1994706243,
-0.595268786,
-0.5336710811,
-0.2849776149,
0.4415402114,
0.4302327633,
0.332544297,
-0.3496604264,
-0.3165501356,
-0.8536631465,
-0.1755866706,
-0.4249750078,
-0.111316517,
0.1601304412,
0.525400579,
-0.5076953769,
0.488384366,
-0.2507978082,
-0.2161591798,
0.1061779335,
0.1942909807,
0.0194027331,
0.2193822116,
0.5051625371,
-0.441917479,
-0.3000178933,
0.0113328341,
-1.1312096119,
-0.1998158544,
0.0099527743,
-0.1086648032,
0.374417305,
0.3078815341,
-0.8147083521,
0.3616552353,
0.5773621202,
-0.2360037118,
0.7426121235,
-0.0451599732,
0.1954265237,
-0.9913437366,
0.4227906466,
0.1332564354,
0.0550184585,
-0.9037994146,
0.1168863773,
-0.2034457326,
0.0409106538,
-0.5185568929,
0.3745081127,
-0.1854496747,
-0.0957231224,
-0.1610055417,
0.1510317922,
-0.2833412886,
0.2429091036,
0.2586526871,
0.9653702974,
0.6296685338,
-0.63667202,
0.2353752702,
0.2117691785,
-0.6047697663,
0.3749759197,
-0.9892083406,
0.2340962738,
0.0996630043,
-0.0023965503,
-0.7174790502,
-0.1346776038,
0.2053553164,
-0.1440370977,
-0.1127632037,
0.2042414099,
-0.7257958651,
-0.1068747044,
-0.2210501581,
0.1322820336,
0.5453857183,
-0.5416029096,
0.3751396835,
0.5203303695,
-0.2414732277,
-0.6868593693,
-0.7897161245,
0.2725827694,
-0.3891046941,
-0.5155067444,
0.0649871528,
0.0067830198,
-0.6900861263,
-0.0747514889,
-0.2142859548,
-0.0785083771,
0.0948187336,
0.4900366664,
0.1864101887,
-0.0628000721,
-0.0691649243,
-0.0754426345,
-0.3144496977,
0.3159129024,
0.1276173741,
0.3485426307,
-0.1985235214,
-0.3444999754,
-0.2912187874,
0.2128307074,
0.6397387981,
0.0491750687,
0.9506643414,
0.4849807918,
-0.4938907623,
-0.1677366048,
-0.6956041455,
-0.2077932358,
-0.44834131,
0.378826797,
-0.1942586154,
-0.6785066724,
0.421610415,
0.0407489203,
0.1687656343,
0.3845189512,
0.9807345271,
0.415953666,
0.7282043695,
0.554995656,
-0.3368933797,
0.0386934616,
0.1906965971,
0.52053231,
-0.440467,
-0.2324578613,
-0.6618234515,
0.2797371149,
-0.5915762782,
-0.4085578918,
0.6519143581,
-0.1882407963,
-0.4172530472,
0.2666736841,
-0.4074845314,
0.3818003535,
0.4122382998,
-0.0009040888,
0.4608159363,
-0.0191822723,
-0.1368641704,
0.015990695,
-0.2659060061,
-0.8782894015,
1.143178463,
0.6425369382,
1.1028425694,
0.0453661196,
0.3367910981,
0.1858861893,
0.4058105052,
-0.3249971867,
0.5285282135,
0.008185898,
-0.9649060369,
-0.3258174956,
-0.3810218275,
-0.6016798615,
0.5428009033,
-0.2580214739,
-0.9547174573,
0.0967090279,
-0.0659250543,
-0.2267571092,
0.2989272475,
-0.590601027,
0.703720808,
-0.2555705309,
-0.4574477971,
-0.1393296719,
-0.4699973166,
0.7198092937,
-0.1952425092,
0.131451115,
-0.1159641892,
0.12454018,
0.5940147638,
0.0239766371,
0.8541587591,
0.0134554319,
-0.2860795557,
0.2314818203,
0.2735520601,
0.471899718,
-0.1186253875,
-0.2728306353,
0.6104364991,
0.1878516823,
0.1213502064,
-0.2799663842,
0.7231423855,
-0.7338218689,
-0.5491768122,
-0.5605164766,
-0.3040067255,
-0.2240232378,
0.1832308322,
0.4223490357,
0.0995862186,
-0.4826120734,
0.2397604734,
0.7909568548,
-0.4303185642,
0.2525436282,
0.3914115131,
-0.1787113845,
-0.4770441055,
0.6004317999,
0.0243772771,
0.221997261,
-0.0419390537,
-0.0742868185,
-0.2778911591,
-0.5107311606,
-0.1138718426,
0.1303810924,
-0.9126155376,
-0.1158699393,
-0.8126060963,
-0.256672591,
-0.256208092,
0.2528767884,
-0.4187746048,
-0.2298170924,
-0.0416557342,
-0.379728049,
0.09653721,
0.9788980484,
-0.0864859,
-0.0070154644,
-0.3181636035,
0.338702172,
0.2602024078,
0.4210212529,
0.1459338218,
-0.1066107899,
-0.0795060769,
-0.1612885445,
-0.5185815096,
-0.946678102,
0.2534143329,
-0.3791103959,
0.7996526361,
0.4316720068,
0.133065626,
0.346023798,
-0.4255158305,
0.9333668947,
0.1758712977,
-1.0326538086,
0.1340065897,
-0.3962433636,
-0.4776277244,
0.6742729545,
0.5921940804,
-0.6467487216,
-0.2891822159,
-0.2502367496,
-0.8600729704,
0.4299423993,
0.5485456586,
-0.1870330423,
-0.1855906993,
0.1517789066,
0.3839001656,
0.1809511334,
-1.0096586943,
-0.1109896079,
-0.1834858209,
-0.2277030349,
-0.1261350811,
-0.2781110108,
-0.408110559,
-0.0017128286,
0.6737262011,
0.0632205904,
0.3766316772,
-0.017101381,
-0.091797024,
-0.1092020273,
0.1133172512,
0.5523193479,
0.5894762278,
-0.1111068726,
0.217205584,
0.4392079115,
-0.7182036638,
0.1479617953,
-0.1741447747,
-0.0951603875,
-0.079992339,
0.4629424214,
0.7452338338,
0.0280208066,
-0.7078245878,
0.4771755636,
-0.0443321913,
-0.1980983168,
-0.2740522921,
0.2761295438,
-0.0400833078,
0.2529935539,
0.0565460399,
-0.1741843671,
0.3317030668,
-0.7383601069,
0.0644699186,
0.2979178131,
-0.1669781655,
-0.3139162362,
0.8923574686,
0.0472007282,
-0.0909729302,
0.4642857015,
0.0992961451,
-0.1624582708,
0.4116480649,
0.48441571,
1.1908172369,
-0.2692678273,
0.1032094955,
0.3197007179,
0.6817991138,
-0.5739012957,
0.3843697906,
0.4144697189,
-0.4933571815,
-0.1290526092,
-0.3509301543,
-0.675519228,
0.5033222437,
-0.7007284164,
0.1790821999,
-0.3425459564,
-0.4123373628,
-0.202596426,
-0.164855212,
-0.4889776111,
0.145819962,
0.0594153851,
0.941806078,
-1.2049765587,
0.7670938373,
0.4415158629,
-0.3587557971,
-0.5507528186,
0.3489567637,
0.0821788758,
-0.4620889127,
0.4547484517,
0.2181390822,
-0.1996543705,
-0.4805830121,
-0.3389717638,
-0.8398668766,
1.3155071735,
0.3914025426,
-0.6138186455,
-0.1395417452,
0.2452886403,
0.7440160513,
-0.2213061154,
0.3587013483,
0.6644679904,
0.4647758603,
-0.0924473703,
-1.2555918694,
0.2042236626,
-0.2178140432,
0.0974990278,
-0.1336178482,
-0.6427989602,
0.900454402,
-0.0777816176,
-0.3554873765,
0.1420181692,
0.417629689,
0.5556380153,
0.4454339445,
0.4649655819,
0.6631141901,
0.8503630757,
-0.1514819711,
0.9654698372,
-0.4333651066,
0.1589629799,
1.094768405,
-0.6783450842,
0.9971597195,
0.2184741646,
-0.0763311312,
0.3680907786,
0.4744601548,
-0.0081963949,
0.7409791946,
0.1572970599,
0.0160971601,
0.0218745209,
0.0903900787,
-0.4282417893,
0.0635947362,
0.2983045876,
-0.2586321235,
-0.1554548591,
0.1044911444,
0.2775207162,
-0.3336701095,
0.0046008159,
0.7606785893,
0.2488662601,
-0.6564399004,
0.6318374872,
-0.0271476042,
0.4364070296,
-0.2784763873,
0.0731161833,
-0.2316569537,
0.2489709854,
-0.1654699743,
-0.6140241027,
0.2707022727,
0.2602556646,
0.1544083208,
0.2954516709,
0.5614736676,
-0.1221787333,
-0.3277518749,
0.6221965551,
0.2453994453,
0.3261517584,
-0.1449030638,
-0.4167421162,
0.4274955392,
-0.4184767306,
-0.294557482,
0.2084947675,
0.5129817128,
-0.3242546618,
0.8317050338,
0.2869583368,
0.048815392,
0.2050771415,
0.0463782027,
0.9364027977,
-0.7152200341,
-0.3950721622,
-0.6961113811,
0.4273457527,
0.0611133836,
-0.4065831304,
0.8202178478,
0.4268915653,
0.5375136733,
-0.0756549835,
0.7994241714,
0.0945061296,
0.2924341559,
-0.5970374942,
0.8242262602,
-0.190685153,
0.2694138587,
-0.5237152576,
-1.0968468189,
-0.1437409222,
0.6357861757,
-0.2470216453,
0.3145662546,
1.0124986172,
1.0388021469,
-0.036888469,
0.0700413212,
0.4237995744,
0.4774886668,
0.2925281525,
0.5698931217,
0.9304682016,
-0.3995416462,
0.4054485857,
-0.2045842707,
-0.2787476182,
-0.1814723313,
-1.0117013454,
-1.2219690084,
-0.6549627185,
-0.2150475979,
-0.5623221993,
0.3801714778,
0.7821175456,
0.7844092846,
-0.9581854939,
-0.2940873802,
0.0274760555,
-0.3021627665,
-0.3098442554,
-0.1314009726,
0.4207236469,
-0.256093353,
-0.3865477145,
0.4036862254,
0.2710550427,
0.0519038886,
-0.4175205231,
-0.1048359126,
0.3302955329,
0.2593485415,
0.6464413404,
-0.0746682584,
-0.8834414482,
-0.3397477269,
-0.0892575532,
-0.3525404334,
-0.157892555,
0.5484886169,
-0.4353388846,
-0.0296572298,
0.4291780591,
0.3518066406,
0.3092607558,
-0.0551478602,
0.438818872,
-0.1575016379,
0.0493093133,
0.0875225589,
0.2869209945,
0.2597926259,
-0.5302608013,
0.8669984937,
-0.0850348771,
-0.7032899857,
-1.0737473965,
-0.0548129939,
-0.8788277507,
-0.275503844,
1.3252019882,
-0.0611676872,
-0.0742039606,
-0.1576791555,
-0.2651630938,
0.1544961333,
-0.1061540246,
1.3669968843,
0.8058018684,
0.1161695346,
0.0643756911,
-1.0245224237,
0.7636909485,
0.2112880647,
-1.1321160793,
0.4241743386,
0.4690940678,
0.3468314707,
0.1715334803,
0.5900822282,
-0.3801905215,
0.2409293801,
0.3532132506,
0.1636461169,
-0.0003557141,
-0.7346443534,
-0.4402459562,
0.1559789479,
0.2000370473,
0.0274334401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09763v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09763v1
|
KG-CTG: Citation Generation through Knowledge Graph-guided Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T13:06:32 | 2024-04-15T13:06:32 |
Avinash Anand, Mohit Gupta, Kritarth Prasad, Ujjwal Goel, Naman Lal, Astha Verma, Rajiv Ratn Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Citation Text Generation (CTG) is a task in natural language processing (NLP)
that aims to produce text that accurately cites or references a cited document
within a source document. In CTG, the generated text draws upon contextual cues
from both the source document and the cited paper, ensuring accurate and
relevant citation information is provided. Previous work in the field of
citation generation is mainly based on the text summarization of documents.
Following this, this paper presents a framework, and a comparative study to
demonstrate the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) for the task of citation
generation. Also, we have shown the improvement in the results of citation
generation by incorporating the knowledge graph relations of the papers in the
prompt for the LLM to better learn the relationship between the papers. To
assess how well our model is performing, we have used a subset of standard
S2ORC dataset, which only consists of computer science academic research papers
in the English Language. Vicuna performs best for this task with 14.15 Meteor,
12.88 Rouge-1, 1.52 Rouge-2, and 10.94 Rouge-L. Also, Alpaca performs best, and
improves the performance by 36.98% in Rouge-1, and 33.14% in Meteor by
including knowledge graphs.
|
[
-0.2329203039,
-0.7366684675,
0.7736381888,
-0.0610597432,
-0.410218358,
-0.0709362626,
-0.1806458235,
-0.3500265181,
-0.0682454482,
0.4619700015,
-0.0810155123,
-0.7332485914,
-0.7820401192,
0.5382928252,
-0.3149344623,
0.8012415171,
0.1983431578,
0.1690150946,
-0.2968197167,
-0.0554426052,
-0.5188230276,
-0.5542969108,
-0.8300031424,
-0.7490672469,
0.844042778,
0.0784679875,
0.5216166377,
0.6416458488,
0.5258079767,
0.2017049342,
-0.2434699982,
0.4530451894,
-0.4204351306,
0.3825058639,
-0.3919962943,
-0.3219920993,
-0.1346170753,
-0.1840516329,
0.4970993698,
0.4450731575,
0.2541135252,
-0.0631469563,
0.0381657146,
0.7560994029,
-0.6313467026,
0.308200717,
-0.6513738632,
-0.2365043312,
-0.1292816252,
-0.5271965265,
-0.6959664822,
-0.6423950195,
0.0000699042,
-0.4517504573,
0.0391241647,
0.0173489358,
0.7360004187,
0.0803458542,
-0.9509419799,
-0.758186996,
-0.4377430975,
0.664752841,
-0.5985486507,
0.3544624746,
0.3215226233,
0.186509192,
-0.3360164464,
-1.0611255169,
-0.3860377967,
-0.3486181796,
-0.2088217288,
0.2701753676,
-0.2055555135,
-0.2027598917,
0.2080348879,
0.0018498464,
-0.5368067622,
0.0354526639,
-0.4215466976,
0.0469427817,
0.5590314269,
-0.1011183485,
-0.0662438571,
-0.7392988801,
-0.2356383801,
-0.3833754957,
-1.0139021873,
-0.463788569,
0.3218200803,
0.6900607347,
0.2249270231,
0.6263507605,
0.0726901665,
0.8183258176,
-0.1348892897,
-0.4235646129,
0.0298886765,
-0.3340211511,
-0.2183940858,
0.015835356,
0.982765913,
0.3630443215,
0.4525342286,
-0.4484113157,
0.2284837216,
-0.4224552214,
0.0873145685,
-0.9005666971,
-0.0514021441,
-0.089818351,
-0.5801030993,
-0.3552215099,
0.0632655323,
-0.3406715393,
-0.3909267783,
-0.6615422368,
0.1953140497,
-0.5207620263,
-0.1544785649,
-0.5005634427,
-0.2629214525,
0.0916700438,
0.2745887637,
-0.3873603046,
-0.3691035807,
0.4480780661,
1.1188778877,
-0.2612939775,
0.0768289417,
-0.3966175914,
0.4335052967,
-0.3583317995,
0.954425633,
-0.4954592884,
-0.7075369358,
0.1983650923,
-0.248246327,
-0.1785425842,
-0.586922884,
0.613997519,
-0.7200396657,
0.214677915,
-0.8131939769,
-0.6595084667,
-0.2360595167,
0.258067131,
-0.6238800287,
1.2528078556,
0.2422299087,
-1.0186884403,
0.4741471112,
-0.6579498649,
-0.2662350833,
0.1032967344,
-0.1805454791,
-0.2951930463,
-0.1700937599,
0.0146857714,
0.65539819,
-0.6108295918,
0.7005168796,
-0.1721864939,
0.0691923127,
0.0634262785,
0.1321785748,
0.7748813033,
0.7634305358,
0.0739715993,
-0.0421525687,
-0.9936352968,
0.1205231845,
0.2199041843,
-0.7371300459,
-0.5191633105,
0.1023305133,
0.2035851479,
0.2061107606,
0.0814084634,
-0.1757692248,
0.368900001,
0.1665271819,
0.4175136387,
0.4223312736,
0.1894098818,
0.1330436468,
-0.0598396547,
0.3962906301,
-0.2351799458,
-0.469398737,
-0.2721168399,
-0.275478214,
-0.4791241288,
-0.1351536363,
0.5537142754,
0.2537837923,
-0.9270164967,
0.3930566907,
-0.5773352385,
-0.5667811632,
0.2418650091,
0.1478240788,
0.3833174109,
0.6348869801,
0.1728118658,
0.1457734853,
-0.6684854031,
-0.8592922688,
-0.3055461645,
-0.3717490733,
-0.018424917,
0.4146415293,
0.5692433715,
-0.0506374948,
1.0065321922,
-0.5138006806,
-0.0827711225,
-0.3972414434,
0.3964901268,
-0.0513491295,
0.187626034,
0.9128127098,
-0.7232456207,
-0.7309843898,
0.2012943774,
-0.9590966702,
-0.4746055603,
0.2745139301,
-0.2147649229,
0.384955138,
0.8300363421,
-0.3278907537,
0.1633840203,
0.5035561919,
-0.4760825932,
0.5283606648,
-0.169655636,
0.2684514523,
-1.5333186388,
0.6404136419,
-0.1329564005,
-0.4003288448,
-0.5736160278,
0.3177861571,
0.0495654121,
-0.13420403,
-0.2407941371,
0.5377412438,
-0.437059164,
-0.0274293572,
-0.6659685969,
0.3765918314,
-0.0229058843,
0.1799855977,
0.0279147904,
0.7666389346,
0.146770522,
-0.6097596288,
0.2296140939,
0.1574753225,
-0.28176862,
0.382610172,
-0.5381397009,
0.1861537546,
-0.0147251794,
0.364172399,
-0.8729951978,
-0.1331186295,
-0.1539073884,
-0.3332832456,
0.3384602964,
-0.1191418618,
-0.9522097111,
-0.2998612225,
0.0267973226,
0.2804802656,
0.2528719306,
-0.6005900502,
0.6993911862,
0.0458545126,
-0.1717379391,
-0.4296523035,
-0.4065260291,
0.1882438064,
-0.1860937774,
-0.7057302594,
0.1530698985,
-0.0354930572,
-0.4015934765,
-0.0110612744,
0.1751325279,
0.2002122998,
-0.1698676944,
0.239906311,
-0.0089652659,
-0.1729784608,
0.4382739067,
-0.1753337532,
-0.0685185865,
-0.1135041863,
-0.3217279911,
0.7936312556,
0.2416898757,
-0.0465840697,
0.0506586246,
0.4314825535,
0.4979825914,
0.0762908906,
0.8555285931,
0.3861812055,
0.0064146346,
0.1311964542,
-0.535024941,
0.0534669124,
-0.3624404967,
0.3328908384,
-0.3638068438,
-0.7702882886,
0.5094967484,
-0.1433028877,
0.0849555731,
0.681968689,
0.7478901744,
0.2242336124,
0.6709278822,
0.5903399587,
-0.1780112088,
0.5343760252,
-0.1197487786,
0.2545836568,
-0.6990404725,
-0.3393190205,
-1.0634491444,
-0.0223717764,
-0.5805947781,
-0.2464547008,
0.3680688441,
0.3678093851,
-0.1932618469,
0.4683968723,
-0.3411304951,
0.2434896827,
0.7849091887,
-0.1811626852,
0.477724731,
0.2397410423,
-0.4328714311,
0.1424996704,
-0.8071550131,
-0.748963654,
1.4115843773,
-0.1541107595,
0.369166106,
0.1379862875,
0.6621102691,
0.38101843,
0.470813781,
-0.5975210667,
0.6326016784,
-0.1379052103,
-0.5368003845,
-0.0491128415,
-0.5611394048,
-1.2097250223,
0.443405658,
-0.3043171465,
-0.6651093364,
-0.1266595125,
-0.0439603627,
0.1697403193,
0.1839584112,
-0.5458608866,
0.3775044978,
0.0704826266,
-0.4151422381,
-0.1756166071,
-0.327852428,
0.3297315836,
-0.0910389125,
0.0917831659,
0.3008730114,
0.4633195102,
0.9057735801,
-0.4115729928,
0.4166658223,
-0.1003846526,
-0.1908470839,
0.7737876773,
0.0529609844,
0.9101320505,
-0.2822973728,
-0.3310610354,
-0.0446340404,
-0.2466574609,
-0.1450004429,
-0.39841187,
0.8532235622,
-0.7312946916,
-0.4803886116,
-0.2682939172,
-0.9696822762,
-0.0753059909,
0.3544713259,
0.3318853974,
0.40399611,
0.0309788641,
0.6041769981,
0.3095737994,
-0.2467732877,
0.5924452543,
0.5328251719,
-0.3234572411,
-0.6225144267,
0.5066313744,
0.3357664347,
0.3388870656,
0.5192953348,
0.2900870442,
-0.4077493846,
-0.6127246022,
-0.1686188579,
0.5413419008,
-1.0151801109,
-0.3810270727,
-0.9017301202,
-0.2585499287,
-0.8102326989,
-0.2639856637,
0.0251643099,
-0.4680951834,
-0.1335891783,
-0.2338557094,
0.3177555501,
0.7223663926,
0.0719056576,
0.4861833453,
-0.5889161825,
-0.0402362421,
0.3210497797,
-0.2350620329,
0.0025529445,
-0.3355205059,
-0.2635859549,
-0.4136227071,
-0.6502503157,
-1.0232385397,
0.4587332308,
-0.2041373551,
0.4673630297,
0.6276341081,
-0.2123519331,
0.7492836118,
-0.2131254077,
0.8780217767,
0.343531549,
-0.5797075629,
0.5537952185,
-0.8027879,
0.3896758556,
0.4617399275,
0.2915894985,
-0.2842130065,
-0.5054174066,
-0.7446829081,
-1.0526790619,
0.5685432553,
0.4931507111,
-0.4114739895,
-0.1423438787,
0.492143631,
0.0629134923,
0.1786985844,
-1.1164587736,
-0.2425979376,
0.0896436572,
-0.0608267598,
-0.0137272188,
-0.4730030298,
-0.1915320158,
0.2972193956,
0.8661836982,
-0.2689933181,
0.1013353691,
0.1015107781,
0.0005147695,
0.0085398788,
0.1927278936,
0.7806935906,
0.9568313956,
-0.187727645,
0.2900038064,
0.0560393184,
-0.3169413507,
-0.2672792673,
-0.0770871565,
-0.5586465597,
0.2197629362,
0.6532709002,
0.4316767752,
-0.1023293883,
-0.5280332565,
0.2341014892,
0.2527867556,
-0.5548123121,
-0.1342331469,
0.0049494188,
0.3576095402,
0.2442077994,
0.595926106,
-0.2973000705,
-0.0006390549,
-0.4628866017,
-0.2180909514,
0.5752675533,
0.0045750625,
0.05177515,
0.5908330083,
0.2050771266,
-0.1014748961,
0.3742531836,
-0.0430411324,
-0.3757702112,
0.7408955693,
0.7955095172,
0.6639003754,
0.1795502752,
0.0358017534,
0.9014669061,
0.0665135607,
-0.049243547,
-0.0040225065,
-0.3115808368,
-0.4828733504,
-0.3945501447,
-0.5850272179,
-0.0667789876,
0.4025852978,
-0.4522600472,
0.3461050689,
-0.1044552326,
-0.3182221651,
-0.1224426851,
0.2191723287,
-0.6390160322,
0.1967793554,
0.0361776166,
0.9137650132,
-0.8878489137,
0.9208822846,
0.6433255076,
-0.3231573105,
-0.9682158828,
-0.2859958708,
-0.1391244531,
-0.4896102846,
1.1728299856,
-0.1402938068,
-0.200777635,
-0.1635963023,
-0.4519960582,
-1.1325019598,
1.5857019424,
0.2694833577,
-0.4355834723,
0.1428287476,
0.0703134537,
0.4990012348,
-0.4370346665,
0.4481525421,
0.2889960706,
0.7371178865,
0.4308892787,
-0.7530493736,
0.0959255993,
-0.0972249359,
0.218177408,
0.2013149858,
-0.787610352,
0.6483880877,
0.0309997164,
-0.2159712613,
0.0661212355,
0.7492669225,
0.7262855768,
0.4706698954,
0.3278551996,
0.5340911746,
0.8155468106,
-0.2364632338,
1.1039708853,
-0.4198161364,
0.2777119577,
1.1009135246,
-0.2217866182,
0.6259288192,
0.614735961,
-0.171796605,
0.5764639974,
0.3706016541,
-0.0291987341,
0.5303903818,
-0.0437525064,
-0.0040100357,
-0.2134610116,
-0.0875262693,
-0.5748702884,
0.2989070714,
-0.0457364544,
-1.0572260618,
-0.5430798531,
-0.1110343561,
0.4911306798,
0.1452918649,
-0.3738869131,
0.6922404766,
0.0296578184,
-1.1163100004,
0.4182601273,
0.2487548292,
0.2369583845,
-0.8950411081,
0.1744669378,
-0.1989282072,
-0.0503622107,
-0.1347747147,
-0.386582613,
0.0796618015,
0.3110541105,
-0.4746055603,
-0.1217204705,
0.8393290639,
-0.1679062694,
-0.5075896978,
0.3379076123,
0.4459092319,
0.275236249,
0.1890885681,
-0.2511198819,
-0.2520002127,
0.0863963664,
-0.5020046234,
0.3930384517,
0.3283258677,
-0.2020549774,
0.7286763191,
0.7937884331,
0.0857977942,
0.1757090539,
0.3612446189,
0.7288486362,
-0.5837766528,
-0.4338926077,
-0.8310329914,
0.2023787796,
-0.279873997,
-0.2154133171,
1.0149821043,
0.7599328756,
0.478961885,
-0.0673906207,
1.0521577597,
-0.4677604139,
0.2927092314,
-0.7018290162,
0.5305569172,
-0.335347712,
0.0578946024,
-0.3251779377,
-1.0709136724,
-0.4311171472,
0.460647583,
-0.4039202929,
0.3605434299,
0.9142903686,
0.8101642728,
0.2452181131,
-0.2020440698,
0.2639852762,
0.1211062148,
0.6277352571,
0.4263087511,
0.5614325404,
-0.3356653452,
0.8299555182,
0.2539002895,
0.1743211597,
-0.379581809,
-1.1873160601,
-1.145138979,
-0.5892813206,
-0.404101938,
-0.6464211345,
0.0292453803,
0.8821540475,
0.5682432652,
-0.5426613688,
-0.0550303869,
-0.28707093,
-0.0092334067,
-0.0405035131,
-0.2820741236,
0.8077620864,
-0.3385013044,
-0.8324665427,
0.3243319988,
0.1040896699,
-0.1555551291,
-0.0187200326,
-0.2358257324,
-0.2334026396,
0.0669704452,
0.8146163821,
0.0797730163,
-0.4768021405,
-0.3144230247,
-0.1607070118,
-0.3350169659,
-0.1250728667,
1.1331620216,
-0.7895507812,
0.3972341418,
0.7016325593,
0.1879411191,
0.640313983,
0.104396604,
0.4645397663,
-0.6401699781,
-0.1308088452,
-0.1506662071,
0.4710337818,
0.3591682017,
-0.1654353738,
0.8300507069,
0.2203238308,
-0.8679717183,
-0.7176510692,
0.248402819,
-1.1593369246,
-0.5060056448,
1.6213678122,
-0.048748862,
0.0068886732,
0.0060630809,
-0.2764461935,
0.4504459798,
-0.2508776188,
0.8588346243,
0.8815751672,
-0.110644199,
0.1359262466,
-0.3352212012,
0.1648177207,
0.010863822,
-0.7013469338,
0.0018126519,
0.5610536933,
0.3842965066,
0.4540899992,
0.5218491554,
-0.2710984647,
0.0538138561,
-0.0597130843,
0.1437599212,
-0.5730074048,
-0.0986944661,
0.2456685454,
0.7694963217,
0.1458447576,
0.3165945411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09754v1
|
Resilience of Large Language Models for Noisy Instructions
| 2024-04-15T12:55:08 | 2024-04-15T12:55:08 |
Bin Wang, Chengwei Wei, Zhengyuan Liu, Geyu Lin, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the rapidly advancing domain of natural language processing (NLP), large
language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools for interpreting human
commands and generating text across various tasks. Nonetheless, the resilience
of LLMs to handle text containing inherent errors, stemming from human
interactions and collaborative systems, has not been thoroughly explored. Our
study investigates the resilience of LLMs against five common types of
disruptions including 1) ASR (Automatic Speech Recognition) errors, 2) OCR
(Optical Character Recognition) errors, 3) grammatical mistakes, 4)
typographical errors, and 5) distractive content. We aim to investigate how
these models react by deliberately embedding these errors into instructions.
Our findings reveal that while some LLMs show a degree of resistance to certain
types of noise, their overall performance significantly suffers. This
emphasizes the importance of further investigation into enhancing model
resilience. In response to the observed decline in performance, our study also
evaluates a "re-pass" strategy, designed to purify the instructions of noise
before the LLMs process them. Our analysis indicates that correcting noisy
instructions, particularly for open-source LLMs, presents significant
challenges.
|
[
-0.0100226812,
-0.7249914408,
0.6101615429,
0.2727681398,
-0.1620076299,
0.0875027776,
-0.3972985446,
-0.6012561917,
-0.1688779294,
0.8108518124,
-0.4543890953,
-0.1519064903,
-0.5490297079,
0.3846997023,
-0.5286297202,
0.8802011013,
-0.1068157554,
0.0368320644,
-0.4390373826,
-0.1457108259,
-0.6276736259,
-0.6657863855,
-0.8682948351,
-0.2204030156,
0.3409320116,
0.2319555581,
0.5271676779,
0.5926370621,
0.831598103,
0.3721970022,
-0.2485869527,
0.1724491119,
-0.4321254194,
0.4722343683,
-0.2595322132,
-0.4909871817,
-0.3916755915,
-0.349650085,
0.8427268267,
0.5989809036,
-0.2806827426,
-0.0791019499,
0.38250494,
0.7688563466,
-0.4205061495,
0.257707119,
-0.7613785267,
-0.1311145425,
-0.191803053,
-0.0711460859,
-0.6724218726,
-0.2228102535,
-0.0115589472,
-0.3659766316,
0.0495472476,
-0.0339953713,
0.498437047,
0.583406508,
0.1792724133,
-0.6370260715,
-1.0074205399,
0.8882325292,
-0.8814334273,
0.4455118775,
0.4803340435,
0.094921723,
-0.4978842735,
-0.7222419977,
-0.2834692895,
-0.3404746652,
0.2252677381,
0.0571640208,
-0.3580606878,
0.1303961277,
0.3381029665,
0.2565678358,
-0.1888087392,
0.4505297244,
-0.3553529382,
-0.1905013323,
0.4224069715,
0.3865743577,
0.5280708075,
0.1829994172,
-0.1590315253,
-0.0377647281,
-0.6322827935,
-0.18526721,
0.3244928718,
0.3511730731,
0.0148709984,
0.4791400135,
0.0596983731,
0.6253884435,
-0.0560440123,
-0.3101686239,
-0.1131664738,
-0.3055947721,
-0.1949509382,
0.2254824638,
0.826687336,
0.1572810113,
0.3390459716,
-0.2746677995,
-0.4417862892,
-0.1041827425,
0.6503410339,
-0.707847476,
-0.199411571,
0.1782710552,
-0.4953776002,
-0.1634780467,
-0.2381056398,
-0.470356673,
-0.6611800194,
-0.0996145904,
0.4359465241,
-0.582583189,
-0.065136984,
0.2855450809,
0.1589778811,
-0.1309406161,
0.5266623497,
-0.8093910217,
0.3555881977,
0.7516282797,
0.8696053624,
0.0452212207,
-0.4236933589,
-0.4254648089,
0.0030927723,
-0.2479936033,
0.8328579664,
-0.3170133829,
-0.4189240038,
-0.0763216317,
0.0379158519,
-0.2352449298,
-0.7513189316,
0.8303940296,
-0.4805521965,
-0.0579095483,
-0.2568843961,
-0.4742915034,
-0.2386722267,
0.1118546128,
-0.886204958,
0.5347259641,
-0.0666556805,
-0.8226524591,
-0.1758293658,
-0.5461908579,
-0.4641343355,
-0.2174903005,
0.0139520494,
-0.6373993754,
0.340000093,
-0.142796278,
0.3183754683,
-0.4087399244,
-0.155651629,
-0.3841234148,
-0.3865482509,
0.4044025242,
-0.738206327,
0.6633148789,
-0.0552213527,
-0.1231318563,
0.0983674228,
-1.0069797039,
-0.1930070519,
0.2152510136,
-0.7734982371,
-0.2141653299,
0.3906049728,
-0.1856032759,
0.1970300674,
0.0114860088,
-0.4001277089,
-0.0165584162,
-0.2777402401,
0.6400192976,
0.8998893499,
-0.0170289259,
0.1427749991,
-0.4719606936,
0.4430831075,
-0.0377156474,
-0.0867789835,
-0.2384064496,
-0.6292824149,
-0.7414458394,
-0.0765039846,
0.1026170254,
0.6100161672,
-0.6621533632,
0.1649652421,
-0.3815509677,
-0.4660923481,
-0.4095260501,
0.2379942983,
0.5470337272,
0.4701503217,
0.2023573965,
-0.2988672853,
-0.6513730884,
-0.6186562777,
-0.2632749379,
-0.2972470522,
-0.1024914011,
0.0376663059,
0.3816954494,
-0.393019259,
0.5334578156,
-0.1884564161,
-0.2801406384,
-0.1185927689,
0.0223843474,
-0.0023914948,
0.3460576534,
0.3339988887,
-0.3852464855,
-0.1931866258,
-0.2087477148,
-0.4392555654,
-0.3477180004,
-0.2360807806,
0.2847892344,
0.6604415774,
0.7312992215,
-0.4487020671,
0.3342599869,
0.7318366766,
-0.2616051435,
0.9139692783,
-0.3216943741,
0.0031912671,
-0.9875565171,
-0.095373705,
-0.2349684238,
-0.1011340842,
-0.5563241243,
-0.0281720422,
-0.348725915,
0.0167484395,
-0.2877934575,
0.1031321287,
-0.4770935476,
-0.1539101601,
-0.3465295136,
-0.1538584828,
-0.1289034784,
0.1062146649,
0.1946019828,
0.6689608097,
0.3190802932,
-0.5936787724,
0.2215233743,
0.0748200119,
-0.4070089459,
0.4830047786,
-0.8726283908,
0.3252245188,
-0.0518582501,
0.0360654518,
-0.9910001159,
-0.3411488235,
0.2286546677,
-0.3102974892,
0.4710196555,
-0.010389111,
-0.6347809434,
-0.1451111734,
-0.1801466793,
0.1318671554,
0.2509310842,
-0.437052995,
0.6731427312,
0.1569806933,
-0.2070254534,
-0.335249424,
-0.8603913188,
0.2111709714,
-0.1014658213,
-0.7856724262,
0.0804851577,
-0.2479180098,
-0.455219388,
0.0719750226,
-0.0155642098,
-0.1599971354,
0.4058488905,
0.705550015,
0.086510472,
-0.2997168303,
0.0192722417,
-0.5136089325,
-0.0050075557,
0.3442137837,
0.0913689807,
0.6284601688,
-0.2166218162,
-0.5871738195,
-0.5227156281,
0.3008580804,
0.9759495258,
-0.0596934333,
1.0568332672,
0.4693255126,
-0.5394400954,
-0.1194952726,
-0.5739769936,
-0.1353207082,
-0.481500864,
0.5721328259,
-0.1856336296,
-0.6979173422,
0.7713178396,
0.0924461111,
0.3144620955,
0.2639527321,
0.4584925771,
-0.1419071555,
0.6242979169,
0.5119959116,
-0.2124771327,
0.5030025244,
0.275636673,
0.1338333786,
-0.7032747865,
-0.1100716442,
-0.6639550924,
-0.216754511,
-0.4458971918,
-0.5640782118,
0.1088207811,
0.0113213435,
-0.3653659821,
0.1072241217,
-0.430480808,
0.2914865017,
0.5728951097,
0.0531670079,
0.4598510563,
0.2582986355,
0.2192617357,
-0.1249328256,
-0.6129003167,
-0.6927357912,
0.7975674868,
0.5994547606,
1.2494566441,
0.2629016042,
0.7662292719,
0.0433338918,
0.1795272827,
-0.5735493898,
0.4736142457,
-0.2707825899,
-0.4290780425,
-0.3446274996,
-0.5401045084,
-0.9601441622,
-0.1488278657,
-0.3510869443,
-0.8737450838,
-0.0372579247,
0.0388656445,
-0.5928896666,
0.6056878567,
-0.7930642366,
0.5130898952,
0.0005005924,
-0.2557425201,
-0.0427848399,
-0.4537955523,
0.3881521225,
-0.3706640601,
0.3279176652,
0.2852575779,
-0.0923154801,
0.8426519632,
-0.2302211374,
1.0765097141,
0.2561458945,
-0.3269761205,
0.3772780299,
0.3678394854,
0.6493288279,
-0.3739079237,
-0.0896064192,
0.2635839283,
-0.2539252043,
-0.0068231253,
-0.3811625838,
0.7472823858,
-0.8203580976,
-0.6191829443,
-0.2752491236,
-0.6045819521,
0.0116241891,
0.1240928695,
0.2636161447,
0.3698706031,
0.039271839,
0.4468938112,
0.8243457675,
-0.4362825155,
0.6865497231,
0.6085327864,
-0.0469453298,
-0.5733699799,
0.9198166728,
0.5439193249,
0.7132828236,
-0.0193372853,
0.093609862,
0.0475132242,
-0.8470243216,
-0.2011758685,
0.0454847366,
-0.6807740927,
-0.1643662751,
-0.59839046,
-0.4690793455,
-0.1785334349,
-0.2417028844,
-0.5932862163,
-0.2851347923,
-0.5886588097,
0.0158189461,
0.314504385,
1.0571478605,
0.0137568545,
-0.0015666522,
-1.1564893723,
0.2689007819,
0.1497405469,
0.6072434187,
0.1820688546,
-0.8255090714,
-0.2001115084,
0.0363574699,
-0.2152011991,
-0.6548912525,
0.2563169599,
0.2492087185,
0.4468052685,
0.2473277897,
0.0885227621,
0.6068274975,
-0.7036135197,
0.7328273654,
0.0898857415,
-0.6683961153,
0.3526500463,
-0.3714748025,
0.3637218177,
0.3105554879,
0.0481316224,
-0.4537937939,
-0.527304709,
-0.5156294107,
-0.8796874285,
0.7135783434,
0.0563113503,
0.0693834573,
0.0029678997,
0.3530178964,
-0.1235281304,
-0.1228122264,
-0.7132288814,
0.049999617,
-0.0575775392,
-0.091205582,
0.1360989809,
-0.663012445,
0.027435245,
0.3245542049,
0.557585001,
0.0938029438,
0.1720469594,
0.1990210861,
-0.0530703738,
-0.2912538052,
0.3543944061,
0.8153157234,
0.285425812,
-0.2388494611,
0.1562187374,
0.2210963964,
-0.8541264534,
0.1317598671,
-0.0859304816,
-0.128016144,
-0.1613891423,
0.8152096272,
0.5684642792,
0.3968317509,
-0.7624610066,
0.0144861387,
-0.203014642,
0.0096854912,
-0.3719907999,
0.0839298815,
0.4624548852,
0.1129852384,
0.1484086066,
0.2932672501,
-0.1274669766,
-0.7506411076,
0.0933366194,
0.2346435636,
-0.2827442884,
-0.3180093467,
0.683082521,
0.120979555,
-0.5916265249,
0.6739487648,
-0.0838650614,
-0.4878337979,
0.4521777332,
0.7805298567,
0.9719066024,
-0.3114492595,
-0.2139273286,
0.236915946,
0.6168501377,
-0.4296140075,
0.1868909299,
0.5031903982,
-0.8570951223,
-0.4987337589,
-0.6249209046,
-0.5268210173,
0.0929628089,
-0.6751879454,
-0.0908289254,
-0.8667069674,
-0.1268583834,
-0.2006102502,
-0.249183625,
-0.2913267612,
0.0136300353,
0.4299052656,
0.8015645742,
-0.7686572075,
0.5075117946,
0.6804715991,
-0.3005106449,
-0.7910130024,
0.1083793789,
0.1580018103,
-0.6307343245,
0.5806151628,
0.1668055356,
-0.2348112911,
-0.2849493623,
-0.3000258803,
-0.7951190472,
0.8904380202,
0.6928448677,
-0.8341757059,
0.1426248848,
0.1853852719,
0.6366205812,
0.0006478908,
0.0470738299,
0.4386382997,
0.2504864037,
0.0606655478,
-1.1361377239,
0.2417006791,
0.101119563,
-0.0842308924,
0.0963227302,
-0.761890173,
0.6773967743,
-0.3290989399,
-0.2754349709,
0.1338190287,
0.5372969508,
0.3540703654,
0.1019639149,
0.5042693615,
0.782897234,
0.7706549764,
-0.0758861676,
1.0930854082,
-0.1968377233,
-0.0360497311,
1.3667000532,
-0.2103630602,
1.1185314655,
0.362867415,
-0.2165220082,
0.4744586945,
0.2927293181,
0.097837925,
0.2609874606,
0.2317661345,
-0.2784019411,
-0.2032372355,
-0.0999891162,
-0.2480248511,
0.4812615216,
0.4839917719,
-0.4690881371,
-0.1642511785,
-0.0702306405,
-0.0148676205,
0.138646841,
-0.5113283992,
0.8389829397,
0.2915703356,
-0.5026469231,
0.5909659863,
-0.1537319124,
0.6554682255,
-0.3838059306,
-0.0829911008,
0.1588318199,
0.4185967743,
-0.3826474547,
-0.8235548735,
0.6361473799,
-0.0189654157,
-0.5657713413,
-0.0781946331,
0.9389015436,
-0.2464001775,
-0.5064089894,
0.3789815903,
0.011810896,
0.151297912,
-0.1795639098,
-0.4967678189,
0.6412708759,
0.0511145815,
-0.2375681847,
0.5681003332,
0.4381590486,
-0.0297972076,
1.0202637911,
0.595500648,
0.116200909,
0.1916293204,
0.0947781503,
0.8127024174,
-0.568130374,
-0.0136851156,
-1.0983865261,
0.4711316228,
0.1436915845,
0.0285776481,
0.8620558977,
0.2130099684,
0.615381062,
-0.0335645974,
0.6388030648,
0.3303198218,
0.460533917,
-0.5632148981,
0.8207399845,
-0.1149089932,
0.6414013505,
-0.3003559411,
-0.6957889199,
-0.400184989,
0.4597589374,
-0.1691367924,
-0.0998729095,
0.4249355793,
0.7557694316,
0.2537862659,
0.0258315019,
0.3614728749,
0.4945323765,
0.3556040525,
0.5570945144,
0.7829329371,
-0.2170369923,
0.8163319826,
-0.1210608333,
0.0266007297,
-0.2993180156,
-0.8177404404,
-0.8497159481,
-0.354636997,
-0.5253368616,
-0.7206763029,
0.1226990521,
0.7263453007,
0.2335588932,
-0.7225393653,
0.0403730571,
-0.1848043054,
0.183165133,
-0.2351620495,
-0.1712601483,
0.3168973327,
-0.4245073795,
-0.495493412,
0.3936697245,
0.3634346426,
0.1903532296,
-0.2163643837,
-0.0360412598,
0.0554820597,
0.193702966,
0.5285555124,
0.3336758018,
-0.7419884205,
-0.4956427813,
-0.078663826,
-0.1529930234,
-0.0990165472,
0.4534723759,
-0.3742518723,
0.5026807189,
0.4596518874,
0.8014631271,
-0.3472848535,
-0.1140438616,
0.6407729983,
-0.5236093998,
-0.0871066153,
0.2857024074,
0.5869762897,
0.568092823,
-0.2731544971,
0.4636625051,
0.1591862291,
-0.8708022833,
-1.0171830654,
0.1442473233,
-0.7774814367,
-0.197996527,
1.3710651398,
-0.4419723749,
-0.3455330729,
-0.2396860123,
-0.34765926,
0.0022022119,
-0.2044442892,
0.9761352539,
0.9873557091,
0.0072396165,
-0.3136317134,
-0.6140878201,
0.410025835,
0.1225170568,
-0.5013982654,
0.4177197814,
0.5351798534,
0.4286880493,
0.5294775963,
0.4372878075,
-0.1760994494,
0.2448861897,
0.2830127478,
0.0135559868,
-0.1895833462,
-0.1454306543,
-0.5394464731,
0.1282159537,
0.4852209687,
-0.2245170474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09753v1
|
Personalized Collaborative Fine-Tuning for On-Device Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T12:54:31 | 2024-04-15T12:54:31 |
Nicolas Wagner, Dongyang Fan, Martin Jaggi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We explore on-device self-supervised collaborative fine-tuning of large
language models with limited local data availability. Taking inspiration from
the collaborative learning community, we introduce three distinct
trust-weighted gradient aggregation schemes: weight similarity-based,
prediction similarity-based and validation performance-based. To minimize
communication overhead, we integrate Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) and only
exchange LoRA weight updates. Our protocols, driven by prediction and
performance metrics, surpass both FedAvg and local fine-tuning methods, which
is particularly evident in realistic scenarios with more diverse local data
distributions. The results underscore the effectiveness of our approach in
addressing heterogeneity and scarcity within local datasets.
|
[
-0.5332470536,
-0.6810159683,
0.4065189064,
0.1080359966,
0.1566782892,
0.2028040886,
-0.5470611453,
-0.3851990998,
0.3882697821,
0.5238133073,
-0.4349609017,
-0.4686400294,
-0.2590779662,
-0.1262285411,
0.0037002685,
0.9533258677,
-0.0257190466,
-0.024552064,
-0.2430665642,
-0.5762901306,
-0.4637310207,
-0.2123828083,
-1.0039211512,
-0.3198362887,
0.6348502636,
0.8873089552,
0.7307434082,
0.8364570737,
0.7152184248,
0.3300112784,
0.0995339304,
0.339774847,
-0.6758387089,
0.1394641846,
-0.4064946175,
-0.3498189151,
-0.8140202165,
-0.0778956413,
0.3785886765,
0.9596217871,
-0.5052732229,
0.2160198838,
0.1920211613,
0.7853962779,
-0.761578083,
-0.0692346469,
-0.7867363691,
-0.0549584217,
-0.0791234672,
0.0412911214,
-0.2163378149,
-0.4749553502,
0.1157901064,
-0.9032955766,
0.3638482392,
0.2508639395,
0.3472479284,
0.4878514111,
-0.1567973793,
-0.1497242749,
-0.7570627332,
1.0423915386,
-0.5539994836,
0.2591248453,
0.7111478448,
0.3090626001,
-0.1222107112,
-0.8283030391,
-0.2867641747,
-0.0584774092,
0.0692402422,
-0.0058573615,
-0.0736954287,
-0.005623064,
-0.0719251558,
0.6291335821,
-0.353602767,
0.5826700926,
-0.1336357892,
-0.2007769644,
0.7182446718,
0.1213367954,
-0.0545076467,
0.4694291949,
-0.2617388666,
0.2765834928,
-0.5765931606,
-0.0666044354,
0.0908691362,
0.6644592285,
-0.6322175264,
0.2600343823,
-0.8656628728,
0.7237564325,
0.6948848963,
-0.0510812327,
0.3859916031,
-0.5380629301,
-0.3399180472,
0.1768316925,
0.7768506408,
0.3059011102,
0.1415883601,
-0.3218763769,
-0.0261556488,
-0.3243150115,
-0.0696915612,
-0.5297653079,
-0.3926522136,
0.086968556,
-0.4889910221,
-0.45492962,
-0.2331281453,
-0.6142652631,
-0.7004816532,
-0.4013150334,
0.605817318,
0.0807705745,
0.0853796452,
0.3408071697,
0.2407520264,
-0.4159372151,
0.4918512404,
-1.2714260817,
0.5537418127,
0.5262206197,
0.8913858533,
-0.4559493065,
-0.4902556837,
-0.934604466,
0.1627533138,
0.0487688072,
0.5807476044,
-0.495154798,
-0.1715121418,
-0.1596832722,
0.0985897928,
-0.126459673,
-0.5784093142,
0.4927598536,
-0.2556201816,
0.346262008,
-0.3907051086,
-0.5159600973,
0.148702547,
-0.0215616282,
-0.5776281953,
0.9496880174,
0.2859665453,
-0.7875441909,
0.5072954297,
-0.588604629,
-0.474053055,
-0.059079811,
0.1951603144,
-0.4722449481,
0.2377960682,
0.4877301157,
0.8179219365,
-0.4474006593,
0.0264093224,
-0.6742402315,
-0.2554566264,
-0.258191824,
0.0559299625,
0.4996224642,
0.5870432258,
-0.1571493745,
0.2241971195,
-0.9903476834,
0.0539659895,
-0.0562575497,
-0.2499417961,
-0.507563591,
0.0676614568,
-0.1373034418,
-0.0811719596,
0.754431963,
-0.6340700388,
0.3351003528,
-0.2633857131,
0.5408065915,
0.7077515721,
-0.0371310078,
0.8108493686,
-0.4980866015,
0.2946903408,
-0.0587974228,
0.2126401067,
0.0553638935,
-0.2858810425,
-0.6026704907,
-0.3934025764,
0.4090024233,
0.3282741308,
-0.6243700385,
0.4458019435,
-0.4509032965,
-0.61450845,
-0.5622589588,
0.5811243653,
0.2942669094,
0.6070734859,
0.3205154836,
-0.5544641614,
-0.3301882744,
-0.7603812814,
-0.0280868448,
0.0837278515,
-0.030939186,
0.5807903409,
-0.0077870297,
-0.3825141788,
0.9647668004,
-0.5275802016,
-0.6542965174,
-0.0547168404,
0.1357167512,
0.0235808659,
0.5853265524,
0.5660200119,
-0.4113812149,
-0.7849641442,
0.6455320716,
-0.5397316217,
-0.1944171339,
-0.0087109357,
0.2189551592,
0.0466069691,
0.510223031,
-0.1216503829,
-0.2153309733,
1.0966931581,
-0.2473840714,
-0.0243880805,
-0.7414362431,
0.1763738543,
-1.2690348625,
-0.3238464594,
0.1767661273,
-0.5325298905,
-0.3781457841,
0.0128347799,
-0.1453549117,
0.115875937,
-0.2452447712,
0.6189727783,
-0.1996045858,
-0.128337279,
-0.1216543689,
0.3294450343,
-0.150325045,
0.3581089377,
-0.1899332404,
0.7081905603,
0.7507342696,
-0.518161118,
0.4631837904,
0.0658894926,
-0.2539325356,
0.7752836347,
-0.6402237415,
0.1594572067,
0.229025498,
0.0531789809,
-0.6863330603,
-0.4060580134,
-0.1215421334,
-0.1961575449,
-0.102975376,
-0.1014289409,
-0.3428048193,
-0.0112120593,
-0.2576107979,
0.347928226,
0.3815317452,
-0.8338415623,
0.5105077624,
0.6175091863,
-0.1579559892,
-0.2308433354,
-0.429171294,
-0.2744837105,
-0.2589960694,
-0.6034691334,
0.3017825186,
-0.2306171209,
-0.3065714836,
-0.2120423764,
0.1417902857,
-0.2572427988,
0.396469444,
0.4180285037,
-0.3870521784,
-0.2375196815,
0.0934140906,
0.3283419907,
0.1818895191,
-0.38963902,
-0.3051005006,
0.4687862694,
-0.2648746669,
-0.2082604468,
-0.5372051597,
-0.032716129,
0.4896436632,
-0.3101623654,
0.771378696,
0.9408989549,
-0.2739819586,
-0.2949813604,
-0.6233524084,
-0.1488099694,
-0.576808989,
0.1466264874,
-0.3449213505,
-1.3804967403,
0.8486167192,
-0.2319586724,
-0.2142023593,
0.2199185491,
0.8187925816,
-0.2605187297,
0.9229134321,
0.8226266503,
-0.5945020914,
0.5775848627,
0.0814372525,
-0.0633042753,
-0.6081562042,
-0.0254273303,
-0.6581879854,
-0.3211071193,
-0.8627176285,
-0.3240266144,
0.2656227648,
0.1551760286,
-0.4173438251,
0.2901493907,
-0.4633532465,
0.6210266352,
0.691465199,
0.1630960107,
0.5375579,
0.3080538809,
0.0418002903,
-0.000062833,
-0.7304792404,
0.0672172084,
1.1345828772,
0.3960144818,
0.9190399647,
0.0233117249,
0.6450685859,
0.5616840124,
0.1082084924,
-0.5704330206,
0.2025751621,
-0.4627746046,
-0.2776093781,
-0.4556956887,
-0.5900021195,
-1.1060448885,
-0.0008266459,
-0.2175235599,
-0.9400030971,
0.2639267743,
0.4583805501,
-0.3837974966,
0.2164983153,
-0.8790596128,
0.7466298342,
-0.0107323453,
-0.6186038256,
-0.5627610087,
-0.3697745502,
0.05530902,
-0.5028323531,
0.3038388491,
0.0418871008,
0.0583272241,
0.5694993734,
-0.442594409,
0.8092780113,
-0.1598678678,
-0.1649748385,
0.1386151761,
0.1371488124,
0.7656893134,
0.0877805501,
-0.3211116493,
0.1482528895,
-0.0800676197,
-0.416023016,
-0.4536688328,
1.3211028576,
-0.9432717562,
-0.2270829827,
0.0953121409,
-0.4927267432,
-0.592729032,
0.3093296885,
0.1117443368,
0.2754760385,
-0.1396956295,
0.5484767556,
0.5541138053,
-0.1325978637,
0.3073374331,
0.6654959917,
-0.0749469846,
-0.4814166129,
1.1600461006,
-0.1584694535,
0.3496805429,
0.3426934183,
0.3752089739,
0.0664368272,
-0.7452188134,
-0.2724096775,
0.1636930555,
-0.4009514153,
-0.0302081499,
-0.3414368033,
0.3129782379,
-0.379722774,
-0.4421496093,
-0.660119772,
-0.3761664927,
-0.4024401307,
0.071332708,
0.5910695195,
0.6731600165,
-0.1320694983,
0.7919231653,
-0.6222158074,
0.1634430289,
0.1861322224,
0.837043047,
-0.1865986586,
-0.6645750403,
-0.7841658592,
0.1434009373,
-0.0633798987,
-0.0206098128,
0.1668726802,
0.3888339996,
0.3871790171,
0.3633499146,
0.0489599332,
0.6404868364,
-0.31204018,
0.7155502439,
0.0914751366,
-0.9255091548,
0.4389701188,
-0.7147342563,
0.2696433365,
0.9289993048,
0.3355291784,
-0.3666525781,
-0.192076534,
-0.3820772469,
-0.3783168495,
0.5755265951,
-0.1387180239,
0.158427909,
0.3713311255,
0.4704456329,
0.2200535685,
0.063690044,
-0.3052076399,
-0.260792017,
-0.0084952274,
-0.4059233367,
-0.3216935396,
0.2552298605,
-0.0744279549,
-0.4396942854,
0.4534164667,
-0.4407538772,
-0.1288676262,
0.047178138,
0.0443442427,
-0.4161910415,
-0.0915639251,
0.5098884106,
0.5448302031,
-0.2538169622,
-0.2204917371,
0.4151909649,
-0.4984464943,
-0.1417512149,
0.0170962047,
-0.0099114506,
-0.4196639061,
0.06214834,
0.9296723604,
0.1968481243,
-0.4180648625,
0.3208020627,
-0.2259954363,
-0.2567744851,
-0.0446149856,
0.2050378174,
0.0451043434,
0.1963733882,
0.0100578675,
0.2484442294,
0.0781140327,
-0.3681842089,
0.0451902971,
0.5144609213,
-0.6174885631,
-0.447774291,
0.6565873027,
0.4978948236,
-0.2101054192,
0.1355538815,
-0.0790776089,
0.1203235537,
0.4038482308,
0.293461144,
0.6226539016,
-0.3605006039,
0.3855249286,
0.2367183268,
0.111267738,
-0.3939493895,
0.126114279,
-0.1244315356,
-0.900991261,
-0.3911477327,
-0.5225985646,
-0.5777117014,
0.1650646329,
-0.683609128,
0.2162528783,
-0.6750441194,
0.0022176767,
0.0236478448,
0.2228242904,
-0.5910630822,
0.3067862689,
-0.0145861758,
0.6950980425,
-0.8247736096,
1.159737587,
0.6296311021,
0.0255895779,
-0.8549227118,
-0.2031918913,
-0.2462681234,
-0.6411690116,
0.2455059737,
-0.4778129458,
-0.1616396904,
0.2549159229,
-0.4666420817,
-1.1216806173,
1.1433367729,
0.3802931011,
-0.7071236372,
0.1771353185,
-0.0411875658,
0.7929512858,
-0.4796288311,
-0.2079234123,
0.4666805565,
0.2645889223,
-0.077125527,
-1.5936026573,
-0.1033234522,
0.2916987538,
-0.2823744118,
0.0638207048,
-0.9278844595,
0.8178165555,
-0.2232236117,
0.2883382142,
0.0564522408,
0.4531039298,
-0.0432118885,
0.444381237,
0.378993243,
0.5540459752,
1.0469796658,
0.1836130321,
1.0817745924,
-0.3584094644,
0.5710007548,
1.4637675285,
-0.4843874872,
0.7270841002,
0.259916842,
-0.0965566933,
0.3103645146,
0.4706834853,
-0.0478409566,
0.6423016191,
-0.159869954,
-0.2494579256,
-0.278711915,
-0.3569148779,
-0.2698408365,
0.571544826,
0.2391798198,
-0.4142467082,
-0.0134841492,
0.0144724175,
-0.1496109813,
0.2221862972,
-0.7843278646,
0.7909918427,
-0.0059814909,
-0.528604269,
0.5311777592,
0.2485672385,
0.7902545333,
-0.2525505126,
0.4533178806,
-0.4100741148,
0.4379814565,
-0.3166861534,
-0.2493063509,
-0.0930861011,
-0.393784076,
-0.1817675382,
-0.2424451709,
0.7487066388,
-0.3547098637,
-0.3801255226,
0.2350725383,
0.7049599886,
-0.2610748708,
-0.0303640272,
-0.6147363186,
0.0714217722,
-0.0221573114,
-0.1692158133,
0.6482735872,
0.471060425,
-0.2537639439,
1.0142149925,
0.5819634199,
0.2738334537,
-0.0161666088,
0.1991354823,
0.7113648057,
-0.1614703834,
-0.4937630892,
-0.5335287452,
0.0928004608,
0.037954323,
-0.3052724302,
0.907196641,
0.5326262116,
1.1169663668,
-0.0226161648,
0.7732111216,
0.2078785002,
0.6617070436,
-0.3593629897,
0.8295819759,
-0.6386782527,
0.202491641,
-0.2930209041,
-0.7242172956,
-0.3304104507,
0.5028666258,
-0.3424312174,
0.0430572815,
0.4114046991,
0.778609395,
-0.3934214413,
-0.0029354696,
0.3043974638,
0.1235988513,
-0.0859918743,
0.4655267596,
0.2578884959,
-0.3034332991,
0.1439907253,
-0.4525037706,
-0.1011612341,
-0.3260466456,
-0.885866642,
-0.9830435514,
-0.6307840347,
-0.5383281708,
-0.1321435273,
-0.0290321019,
1.0036687851,
1.0035620928,
-0.8854585886,
-0.1745842248,
-0.1385505795,
0.1565095782,
-0.1553096473,
-0.1189528406,
0.2299602181,
-0.1021666154,
-0.6704027653,
0.3400025368,
0.0072000418,
-0.0877475888,
-0.2242686003,
-0.3144820035,
0.2802083194,
-0.1655360013,
0.5322946906,
0.3648860753,
-0.3882540464,
-0.3599433303,
-0.1901471317,
-0.133860901,
0.1239423007,
0.8295067549,
-0.9409909844,
0.3813202083,
0.4182108641,
0.6571509242,
0.3873328269,
0.2762070596,
0.5716793537,
-0.8659409881,
0.1566935629,
-0.1433712244,
0.3487574458,
0.2874186039,
-0.2932664752,
0.366085887,
0.0754609704,
-0.8300597072,
-0.8593270183,
0.0668879598,
-1.2439100742,
0.0812388062,
1.0354834795,
-0.1866400391,
0.1562658101,
-0.1551548988,
-0.1062661782,
-0.0839011371,
-0.4868512452,
0.864700973,
0.4487122893,
0.0120788589,
-0.1631990522,
-0.2902782857,
0.5619539022,
0.4354042709,
-0.859243691,
0.2028891593,
0.3915687799,
0.3865683675,
0.0538977273,
0.644081831,
0.3319162428,
0.1060062349,
-0.4474093914,
-0.0511178784,
-0.1548248529,
-0.1218383387,
-0.5665935874,
0.1733478755,
0.434353292,
-0.0291571915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09737v1
|
Quantization of Large Language Models with an Overdetermined Basis
| 2024-04-15T12:38:46 | 2024-04-15T12:38:46 |
Daniil Merkulov, Daria Cherniuk, Alexander Rudikov, Ivan Oseledets, Ekaterina Muravleva, Aleksandr Mikhalev, Boris Kashin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce an algorithm for data quantization based on the
principles of Kashin representation. This approach hinges on decomposing any
given vector, matrix, or tensor into two factors. The first factor maintains a
small infinity norm, while the second exhibits a similarly constrained norm
when multiplied by an orthogonal matrix. Surprisingly, the entries of factors
after decomposition are well-concentrated around several peaks, which allows us
to efficiently replace them with corresponding centroids for quantization
purposes. We study the theoretical properties of the proposed approach and
rigorously evaluate our compression algorithm in the context of next-word
prediction tasks and on a set of downstream tasks for text classification. Our
findings demonstrate that Kashin Quantization achieves competitive or superior
quality in model performance while ensuring data compression, marking a
significant advancement in the field of data quantization.
|
[
-0.2647250593,
-0.5979039669,
0.8167387843,
0.2278453261,
-0.5091981888,
0.0826072842,
-0.5833820105,
-0.301518023,
0.1588911414,
0.403275758,
-0.3467228413,
-0.7132700682,
-0.7165036798,
-0.1294611543,
-0.5713691711,
0.7911308408,
0.0717654526,
0.2626146078,
-0.236961931,
-0.3058090508,
-0.4983327091,
-0.8990713358,
-0.4825023413,
-0.2384624034,
0.2107262462,
0.3985556066,
0.8143810034,
0.7582108378,
0.3137979209,
0.2864784896,
0.0512970388,
-0.1765132695,
-0.449714452,
0.2779793143,
0.2040624768,
-0.9009928107,
-0.1797447652,
-0.0064366451,
0.9778362513,
0.8047352433,
-0.1616100669,
0.3072758019,
-0.1780297756,
0.8253560662,
-0.6410208344,
0.2328367233,
-0.3566914499,
-0.0115593215,
-0.2159416825,
-0.2577942908,
-0.4597217739,
-0.4261146486,
-0.3164241314,
-0.6509088278,
0.1147914082,
-0.0855763853,
0.7800852656,
0.1955726743,
-0.5566751957,
0.0105538322,
-0.832695961,
1.1803680658,
-0.6489399076,
0.6434473991,
0.7625072002,
0.4599008858,
0.072533071,
-0.3792154193,
-0.6291273832,
-0.0015680263,
-0.1778467894,
-0.2200966477,
-0.0413797162,
0.0644672289,
0.2363033444,
0.5759755373,
-0.5788695216,
0.0809143856,
-0.4442583323,
-0.0747245029,
0.7778944373,
0.1319866627,
0.1636909992,
-0.1679448634,
-0.1089685038,
-0.3463111818,
-0.6888726354,
-0.0396905132,
0.3122668862,
0.1391611099,
0.3259764314,
0.6869117022,
-0.415694952,
0.5028454065,
0.0591997467,
-0.1252650023,
0.1563938558,
-0.2161402106,
-0.2414796352,
0.0954249576,
0.7059921622,
0.1503977031,
0.0984337628,
-0.0054456652,
-0.2797568738,
0.5004194975,
0.2414893061,
-0.8223147392,
-0.0759595186,
0.3934939802,
-0.6511518359,
-0.4885900915,
-0.0514768362,
-0.6964772344,
-0.2519423962,
-0.4005787075,
0.7852455378,
-0.4203822613,
-0.0193328876,
0.3472265601,
0.1652700752,
0.0056432122,
0.0155890128,
-0.8434453011,
0.6133419871,
0.815436244,
0.9174014926,
0.2710292637,
0.1751492918,
-0.4247095883,
0.0247468799,
-0.468434453,
0.4999435246,
-0.6360188127,
-0.3938843012,
-0.0960484892,
-0.3248277605,
0.4279266298,
-0.1694511026,
0.3962266147,
-0.5015610456,
0.0117917163,
-0.254478991,
-0.7488610744,
-0.2665351927,
0.0317946859,
-0.8430587053,
0.679263413,
0.3382619917,
-0.4958975613,
0.2941961288,
-0.4268118441,
-0.4571555257,
0.1249892116,
-0.1025733724,
-0.5731137991,
0.4709028006,
0.1692379266,
0.684954226,
-0.5649810433,
0.3198512197,
-0.1559634358,
-0.2483603507,
0.2248284221,
-0.1064214855,
0.7877787352,
0.1584776789,
-0.1201393828,
-0.071988292,
-0.9767042398,
0.3105529547,
0.1602423936,
-0.189019233,
-0.5270482898,
0.2072818726,
0.106051676,
0.0042773136,
0.1975469291,
-0.7615081668,
0.4418107271,
-0.3576930761,
0.5154908895,
0.6031047106,
-0.0402157083,
0.6826111674,
-0.0145846587,
0.6422120929,
-0.1148183271,
0.0636337325,
-0.1818296909,
-0.2798074186,
-0.9549655318,
0.0044305706,
0.6508247852,
0.1627889723,
-0.5100514889,
0.6042426825,
-0.5663420558,
-0.4994418621,
-0.5293377638,
-0.168880865,
0.2261643708,
-0.174444288,
0.1922946423,
0.0954028144,
-0.5970116854,
-0.8133336902,
0.0835732222,
-0.1139695495,
-0.0728368014,
-0.2952865958,
0.2041910291,
-0.0722090453,
0.9087098241,
-0.7175441384,
-0.614682138,
-0.1551452726,
0.4079019427,
0.1639294177,
0.8107492328,
0.544451952,
-0.9939855933,
-0.5837032795,
0.2167880833,
-0.194740057,
0.0050904574,
-0.0147641646,
-0.0396944918,
0.1475554407,
0.6899575591,
-0.7315930128,
0.6238366365,
0.548271656,
-0.2605333328,
0.4024818838,
-0.0685735866,
0.0980130583,
-1.0509867668,
0.2018363625,
-0.122890085,
-0.5652196407,
-0.7436984181,
0.1902329773,
0.175273627,
-0.4593630731,
0.2275020629,
0.2263862044,
-0.3693598509,
-0.1732069254,
-0.3466898501,
-0.1312256753,
0.0557082072,
0.8160465956,
0.023168873,
0.4843524694,
0.5464140773,
-0.4342142344,
0.235589087,
0.1937231421,
-0.5473609567,
0.6415237784,
-0.8558208346,
0.0047785272,
-0.5036657453,
0.4437832832,
-0.7853149772,
-0.027577145,
-0.1442881227,
-0.7175578475,
0.2605960369,
-0.0667451173,
-0.9307846427,
-0.0526848435,
-0.3012112975,
0.7712777853,
0.7955386043,
-0.2899604142,
0.3219338953,
0.5473483205,
0.0021120566,
-0.1957971454,
-0.7367065549,
-0.1527362168,
-0.3120388091,
-0.2692703009,
0.3905127347,
-0.0508751273,
-0.1250631809,
0.0131983804,
0.0161545482,
-0.2841145396,
-0.0466211662,
0.0666858926,
-0.0300390143,
-0.1511803269,
0.4265370965,
0.1277766675,
-0.4667131901,
-0.0645640641,
-0.7895695567,
0.7549709678,
0.1238624007,
-0.0345800072,
-0.2941954434,
0.6573230028,
0.581659019,
-0.4223112762,
0.6775975823,
0.9042381048,
-0.7790175676,
-0.3017181754,
-0.2208840698,
0.1428427845,
-0.4436273277,
0.4089908004,
-0.2713393271,
-0.8282811046,
0.5168591142,
0.1683068722,
0.0116209835,
0.6028411984,
0.4263033569,
0.1748654544,
1.7356761694,
0.9386629462,
-0.0681445152,
0.2624512911,
-0.615177691,
0.5986870527,
-0.7013548017,
-0.0230029561,
-0.8219003081,
-0.4605612159,
-0.439723134,
-0.3098618388,
0.5371592045,
0.3270337284,
0.0475304276,
0.5937362313,
-0.3404915631,
0.6392809153,
0.35213238,
0.037246082,
0.1126785502,
-0.1900017411,
0.2790576816,
-0.0702814907,
-0.6255484819,
-0.0919518694,
1.0419290066,
0.3905781507,
0.5275644064,
0.2617923021,
0.6832710505,
0.2823506296,
0.0184607208,
-1.0895906687,
0.3764190972,
-0.4678019881,
-0.298407048,
-0.5369129777,
-0.53333956,
-0.8655949831,
0.1455711722,
-0.1302765608,
-1.0061737299,
0.4479186535,
-0.1522298157,
-0.5481290221,
-0.0013020695,
-0.4360040724,
0.5606153607,
0.3290406466,
0.2871271968,
-0.7664960027,
-0.4162303805,
0.3551615477,
-0.305085361,
0.2098686099,
-0.2149157673,
-0.0390955471,
0.9506342411,
-0.85469836,
0.5996112227,
-0.1037623733,
-0.1881203502,
0.1736249477,
0.2009930164,
0.4245284498,
0.3066699207,
0.0760829523,
0.0322992504,
0.3496915996,
-0.6334909797,
-1.1691536903,
0.6198375821,
-0.5960770249,
-0.3241251707,
-0.1807792336,
-0.4057416916,
-0.4193667769,
0.1875007302,
0.4927335382,
1.0252287388,
0.1809157878,
0.450411588,
0.4584612548,
-0.0214424748,
0.1956247538,
0.193978563,
-0.2269474119,
-0.6290145516,
1.0304447412,
0.3544227183,
0.2868084013,
0.6240900159,
0.3410980105,
-0.190126881,
-0.5116620064,
-0.1809840053,
0.0314599946,
-0.9536155462,
-0.7442058921,
-0.5267559886,
-0.0890283361,
-0.5017296076,
-0.19467628,
-0.49355039,
-0.8381801248,
-0.1669732928,
0.0228781626,
0.3084411323,
0.7462090254,
-0.0471434556,
0.6647524238,
-0.860683322,
0.3238410652,
0.1782985032,
0.4093501866,
0.1479550749,
-0.2952693701,
-0.8150807023,
0.1254544854,
0.0493376628,
-0.7057912946,
0.4352579415,
0.3416424096,
0.2526858747,
0.4457137287,
0.1637854576,
0.7451003194,
-0.4120829105,
0.7053468823,
0.0702667162,
-1.2283391953,
0.2448868304,
-0.0910003558,
0.4693226814,
0.6448220015,
0.5705099702,
-0.69387573,
-0.3376855552,
-0.793300271,
-0.5548099875,
0.4757705033,
0.389341712,
0.202598393,
0.0826198682,
0.1490898728,
0.1073072329,
0.2584971786,
-0.4420931041,
-0.184322983,
-0.0377767794,
-0.4576705992,
-0.3398701847,
-0.5527228117,
0.3897334635,
-0.2565624416,
0.6369000077,
-0.1294997782,
0.5017255545,
0.058894489,
-0.3510573208,
-0.1650859714,
0.0471934825,
0.4707180262,
0.5279542804,
0.1350742728,
0.0519268736,
-0.2874657214,
-0.5686317086,
0.2761685252,
-0.1194441691,
-0.0402260125,
0.2307353765,
0.2521907985,
0.7502521276,
0.2129502296,
-0.4224051535,
0.6042624116,
0.061394494,
0.0096412776,
-0.2289082259,
-0.2402020842,
-0.5829353929,
0.1069533676,
0.5965446234,
-0.1672801524,
0.2760532498,
-0.5776614547,
0.0680669174,
0.3274269998,
-0.101606898,
-0.6269909739,
0.4621762633,
-0.2151818573,
-0.1062299237,
0.2966458201,
-0.1532905549,
-0.9640746713,
0.4870560169,
0.3074683249,
1.0235363245,
-0.3201089501,
0.3356314301,
0.6657022238,
-0.0342876688,
-0.3235432208,
0.2175250202,
-0.3563657403,
-0.5959746242,
-0.6031631231,
-0.714315176,
0.2061045915,
0.089362137,
-0.7918617725,
0.5053601861,
-0.740365684,
-0.3014810383,
0.3007085919,
0.2957924902,
-0.3787765503,
0.2982758582,
0.1088621989,
0.5253999233,
-0.6965209842,
1.0321296453,
0.3194605112,
-0.225873813,
-0.5783959627,
-0.1435877085,
-0.2042853683,
-0.4622251987,
0.4743258953,
0.0841240734,
0.4414415359,
0.3310554922,
-0.7477524877,
-1.152297616,
0.7303752303,
0.1213721186,
-0.4283670485,
0.0848469883,
0.2394024432,
0.549208343,
-0.0571119078,
-0.2939889729,
0.6260007024,
0.477524668,
-0.2298421562,
-0.8686569929,
-0.0105101699,
-0.2603145838,
0.199011445,
0.7576380372,
-0.4391019344,
0.8796889186,
0.1685560346,
-0.6707031727,
0.3971072137,
0.8024644256,
-0.2191255689,
-0.3914453089,
0.4388614297,
0.4659715593,
0.6105308533,
0.0358682089,
0.9367098212,
-0.2841359377,
0.693616569,
0.5427203774,
0.1317757368,
0.8575017452,
0.4547180235,
-0.4461461902,
0.379258275,
0.2476361096,
-0.0200504325,
0.5236190557,
0.2056624293,
-0.1193559244,
-0.1559369117,
-0.2087672502,
-0.0097393533,
0.6055757403,
0.4484758079,
-0.0694728047,
-0.2347060889,
0.262550205,
0.0573847778,
0.2196148187,
-0.4621566534,
0.5750561357,
-0.0354243293,
-0.467256099,
1.0643857718,
0.5344753861,
0.433658123,
-0.6900769472,
-0.0145574138,
0.011996259,
-0.016751688,
-0.2058846653,
-0.7238596678,
0.3983817697,
-0.3375305533,
-0.225104779,
-0.3378030062,
0.600984931,
-0.7854583859,
-0.6978952289,
-0.3282035291,
-0.2053174525,
-0.0291962549,
-0.1744323522,
0.0068483558,
0.293622762,
-0.1253148615,
-0.1362318546,
0.1501821876,
0.4511193931,
-0.3231801689,
0.580591023,
0.5525764823,
0.1338525414,
-0.1253317744,
-0.1056115255,
0.664280355,
-0.602669239,
-1.0057841539,
-0.6547181606,
0.3608533144,
0.1513330042,
-0.22811836,
0.5325927138,
0.3051135242,
0.6753679514,
0.10614831,
0.5305829644,
-0.0433799177,
0.2523316145,
-0.7536498904,
0.7868430614,
-0.4675055444,
-0.240001291,
-0.1453458071,
-1.0663256645,
-0.5611694455,
0.6406094432,
0.0310110506,
-0.1519614607,
0.7941752672,
0.3036591709,
0.0920984522,
-0.0038136824,
0.493688643,
0.0305600595,
0.2278440744,
0.7072048187,
0.3484790325,
-0.6260358691,
0.1911361963,
-0.6110547781,
-0.0539808944,
-0.0489250645,
-0.5648522973,
-0.6929670572,
-1.3382226229,
-0.3467110991,
-0.1334558129,
-0.3383443952,
0.831823349,
0.8569149971,
-0.7073780298,
-0.1419318765,
-0.1917900294,
-0.1262412518,
-0.0629582107,
-0.172810927,
0.6605215073,
-0.4081014395,
-0.715940237,
0.0264152084,
0.1723656952,
0.1010981873,
-0.7842363119,
-0.0545492955,
0.0438695997,
-0.0543779954,
0.7235428095,
-0.0032324956,
-0.2715063393,
-0.1862742752,
-0.0858697519,
-0.0188110825,
0.0046730628,
1.0948694944,
-0.9647234678,
0.1631742269,
0.699816227,
0.7102104425,
0.3612698615,
0.1814991683,
0.9232734442,
-0.8901824355,
0.407471925,
0.3150504529,
0.2261465192,
0.2883773744,
-0.6087429523,
0.2792598307,
0.0816036388,
-0.3197673261,
-1.0691994429,
0.1596218497,
-0.6512961984,
-0.2582496405,
1.1963442564,
0.0002509445,
-0.5522358418,
0.2447570562,
-0.0521029308,
0.0888026208,
-0.1021750942,
0.5904213786,
0.8696750998,
0.6252156496,
-0.1501560658,
-0.4355719984,
0.6215859056,
0.5336275697,
-0.4222666621,
0.2373732775,
0.5035846829,
-0.2647633553,
0.2969314456,
0.453181982,
-0.2626424432,
0.4083806276,
-0.1139194295,
-0.032597959,
0.2516823411,
-0.3237651885,
-0.8188443184,
-0.0505265743,
-0.0430435762,
-0.1213821396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09717v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09717v1
|
Unveiling Imitation Learning: Exploring the Impact of Data Falsity to Large Language Model
| 2024-04-15T12:20:09 | 2024-04-15T12:20:09 |
Hyunsoo Cho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Many recent studies endeavor to improve open-source language models through
imitation learning, and re-training on the synthetic instruction data from
state-of-the-art proprietary models like ChatGPT and GPT-4. However, the innate
nature of synthetic data inherently contains noisy data, giving rise to a
substantial presence of low-quality data replete with erroneous responses, and
flawed reasoning. Although we intuitively grasp the potential harm of noisy
data, we lack a quantitative understanding of its impact. To this end, this
paper explores the correlation between the degree of noise and its impact on
language models through instruction tuning. We first introduce the
Falsity-Controllable (FACO) dataset, which comprises pairs of true answers with
corresponding reasoning, as well as false pairs to manually control the falsity
ratio of the dataset.Through our extensive experiments, we found multiple
intriguing findings of the correlation between the factuality of the dataset
and instruction tuning: Specifically, we verified falsity of the instruction is
highly relevant to various benchmark scores. Moreover, when LLMs are trained
with false instructions, they learn to lie and generate fake unfaithful
answers, even though they know the correct answer for the user request.
Additionally, we noted that once the language model is trained with a dataset
contaminated by noise, restoring its original performance is possible, but it
failed to reach full performance.
|
[
-0.1035667509,
-1.1878006458,
0.3142061532,
-0.1844534278,
-0.1038937792,
0.1571642607,
0.0015453357,
-0.4363457561,
-0.0988310054,
0.6781579852,
-0.4167314172,
-0.3352770209,
-0.5861361623,
-0.3415070474,
-0.8011248708,
1.0991892815,
0.0556001849,
0.0901171565,
-0.2483483106,
0.0095760403,
-0.2114251852,
-0.5265144706,
-0.4535928965,
-0.1756821871,
0.0920138285,
0.2903894782,
0.8319996595,
0.9868848324,
-0.1249003932,
0.3046790361,
0.134412542,
0.4804235697,
-0.8035923839,
0.1528962553,
0.0321135558,
-0.6157305837,
-0.3007276356,
0.3498720527,
0.6198267937,
0.5499517918,
-0.2223164141,
0.0150389411,
0.3794487715,
0.70324862,
-0.3687499762,
0.5172408223,
-0.7972910404,
-0.1679440439,
-0.1292002797,
-0.1644173861,
-0.3705497682,
-0.351554513,
0.0616386272,
-0.6995066404,
0.4812081456,
0.1697422862,
0.7928119302,
0.4481728673,
-0.2128091902,
-0.6802022457,
-0.9101116657,
0.8070434928,
-0.6234135628,
0.4164865911,
0.5262640715,
-0.0744454712,
-0.4166173041,
-0.3331010044,
-0.3828586936,
-0.2232227921,
0.0592732206,
0.0850807354,
-0.2796910703,
-0.0812640563,
0.2530069947,
0.6660988927,
-0.3706210852,
0.0829074308,
-0.2521440983,
-0.3466348052,
0.544278264,
0.2088917941,
0.2526625991,
0.416893661,
-0.1355186701,
-0.1253636032,
-0.7111195326,
0.080069907,
0.7994608879,
0.2612580061,
-0.0724472255,
0.3353404701,
-0.0868789926,
0.8355617523,
0.2035712451,
0.1754228622,
0.10687197,
-0.3453253806,
-0.1370977163,
-0.0266192872,
0.6927947998,
-0.0431333706,
0.4127315581,
-0.3052720428,
-0.314409852,
-0.0379268751,
0.3617881835,
-0.6095530987,
-0.3637917638,
0.0630148128,
-0.2158755362,
-0.507342279,
0.1441692263,
-0.9459379911,
-0.3554823101,
-0.5898122191,
0.5930404067,
-0.5454118252,
-0.165486455,
0.1488845497,
0.4129468799,
0.2941766381,
0.4400453269,
-0.9681398273,
0.5029102564,
0.8310768008,
0.7323396802,
-0.1649792343,
-0.3706174791,
-0.5754978061,
-0.1675263494,
-0.5362460017,
0.5114506483,
-0.5111171007,
-0.3083286285,
-0.0990366191,
-0.0321107991,
-0.1498230845,
-0.5888175368,
0.309389025,
-0.5262199044,
0.2167773247,
-0.1612237096,
-0.7525331378,
-0.1498369724,
-0.1424794644,
-0.8244841099,
0.9703555703,
-0.0244442653,
-0.4658746719,
0.1174388453,
-0.4512200356,
-0.4942932129,
-0.3046126366,
-0.1724261642,
-0.6623107791,
0.2394182086,
0.1139102504,
0.3272235096,
-0.2116852999,
-0.0636345819,
-0.0566134974,
-0.5888836384,
0.5304691792,
-0.8536390662,
0.7117126584,
0.0943691805,
-0.4651960135,
-0.2620906532,
-0.7978696227,
0.0414523035,
0.1623148769,
-0.3290334344,
-0.2807848454,
-0.0043282188,
-0.5174110532,
0.0469571762,
0.1928438991,
-0.3680577576,
0.1232620701,
-0.4480763376,
0.2036383301,
0.9747343659,
0.0898807347,
0.2978366315,
-0.6642588973,
0.4255305231,
0.0931838453,
0.3260356784,
-0.1319121122,
-0.5936581492,
-0.6277490258,
-0.0648803115,
0.2180417627,
0.4500177801,
-0.5083441734,
0.056085214,
-0.0374082737,
-0.3760264218,
-0.9881830215,
0.4300713539,
0.5206938982,
0.424259752,
0.3982941806,
-0.1465836763,
-0.5229280591,
-0.7985041738,
-0.382049799,
-0.0445132665,
0.2664240003,
0.3202477396,
0.4666836858,
0.0199777503,
0.7297745347,
-0.3066522479,
-0.186166808,
-0.0156650934,
0.2427234054,
0.0925465077,
0.4625528753,
0.3039312661,
-0.6009370685,
-0.495090872,
-0.1419504285,
-0.415512383,
-0.1929031312,
-0.1455398202,
0.0159701109,
0.506131351,
0.469982028,
-0.3145880699,
0.4345791936,
0.826381743,
0.0101553844,
0.8395735025,
-0.2653365433,
0.2803886831,
-0.8645043373,
-0.0232380424,
-0.2910433114,
0.0497499406,
-0.6157876849,
-0.1838721186,
-0.2055368572,
0.2054571807,
-0.2158302814,
0.2613114119,
-0.524079144,
-0.0628016889,
-0.3656948209,
-0.2139368057,
-0.095127739,
0.4733380675,
-0.1725339741,
1.0758267641,
0.5164370537,
-0.5009974837,
0.2371976823,
0.0563478656,
-0.5777224302,
-0.0387064815,
-0.6792512536,
0.2546633482,
0.0255654994,
-0.03293062,
-0.9077882171,
-0.2766325176,
0.1479643732,
-0.5570405722,
0.4262773693,
-0.2967496514,
-0.7107267976,
0.2503753304,
-0.0175348669,
0.0816804469,
0.6222689748,
-0.6202905774,
0.3014087379,
0.3728279173,
0.2651729882,
-0.7603953481,
-0.6368590593,
-0.323918134,
0.1228423044,
-0.3440822661,
0.1235221326,
-0.2285852432,
-0.2047450691,
-0.046127338,
-0.3509860933,
-0.1321852356,
0.2355833352,
0.4769396782,
0.371362716,
-0.2367360294,
0.0126632946,
0.0338709764,
0.0393341482,
0.3452635109,
-0.0923644304,
0.6226682067,
-0.3525914252,
-0.3514683545,
-0.5113108754,
0.0614627935,
0.714871347,
0.0055404357,
0.9528034925,
0.1480816901,
-0.043049898,
-0.4909747839,
-0.3647795916,
-0.2506692708,
-0.4901311398,
0.2650981247,
-0.1472032815,
-0.728919208,
0.3641673625,
-0.004864329,
0.2097223848,
-0.0223162994,
0.4513579607,
-0.1269406229,
1.0605909824,
0.2874825299,
-0.2234659195,
0.6252154708,
-0.2580855191,
-0.0344925709,
-0.4652908444,
-0.1109469831,
-0.3210665584,
-0.0026196039,
-0.6222450137,
-0.4868544936,
0.0925161466,
-0.0174487829,
-0.1663427651,
-0.0204436816,
-0.1939394027,
0.8272700906,
0.6329164505,
0.2778859735,
0.4250246882,
0.2791319191,
-0.0863040164,
-0.0303028673,
-0.5846498609,
-0.4565970302,
1.2823091745,
0.2104165107,
1.001894474,
0.0145154214,
0.5007503033,
0.2222371846,
0.0687916726,
-0.6659411788,
0.3817070723,
-0.3558402658,
-0.4611878097,
-0.2631205022,
-0.6088380218,
-0.9297882318,
-0.053880699,
-0.2151738107,
-0.3728102148,
-0.0795450136,
0.5963898897,
-0.1054005101,
0.3061507344,
-0.7055880427,
0.5536037087,
-0.3745444417,
-0.7069798708,
-0.1902239472,
-0.4655236602,
0.4129450619,
-0.1904186606,
0.289675653,
0.2709963322,
0.1261078566,
0.5755265355,
-0.1944063008,
1.2982572317,
-0.0237634536,
-0.2958914936,
0.2142396271,
0.4103445411,
0.7020736337,
-0.2097032517,
0.0430893153,
0.2901084721,
-0.1917658597,
-0.4407500625,
-0.8094175458,
0.7920462489,
-1.1203701496,
-0.6835852265,
-0.1656787843,
-0.6588171124,
-0.4121822417,
0.0144104799,
0.276344806,
0.4867225587,
-0.2649483085,
0.1292860359,
1.1057314873,
-0.271174252,
0.0295419823,
0.7814686894,
-0.1118929014,
-0.2438692302,
1.2018949986,
0.4229895771,
0.6947523952,
0.1894298494,
0.2706521749,
-0.1927217096,
-0.5014073849,
-0.2999922931,
0.3757374883,
-0.4175761044,
0.0998392776,
-0.4047623277,
-0.3794002533,
-0.3474567831,
0.1284292638,
-0.7476996183,
-0.2899717093,
-0.3050560951,
-0.0569251925,
0.2423752993,
0.9778556824,
-0.135795027,
0.2792557776,
-0.5150855184,
-0.0376280211,
0.3322991133,
0.4693369269,
0.1600099951,
-0.8629433513,
-0.4904088974,
0.4948686063,
-0.2162359655,
-0.7130196691,
0.2935542166,
0.2663083673,
0.7734998465,
0.465392381,
-0.0177226886,
0.5412006378,
-0.4168687761,
0.6109598279,
-0.3419039845,
-0.9642457366,
0.4972075522,
-0.2451861948,
0.1593991369,
0.2774090767,
0.5398716927,
-0.2840449214,
-0.5096563697,
-0.7283654809,
-0.511615932,
0.7871439457,
0.1121213585,
0.1440798342,
0.272901386,
0.3624918461,
0.4484764636,
0.1891354769,
-0.5482032299,
-0.4678054452,
-0.4651829302,
-0.1137150303,
-0.0098986002,
-0.2293059677,
-0.042009756,
-0.1608701646,
0.8676590323,
0.0228738692,
0.3746325374,
-0.2112213075,
-0.1316043139,
-0.2628558278,
0.1171806678,
0.7643168569,
0.1089887023,
-0.0979199558,
0.1209578663,
-0.1545379758,
-0.6926215887,
0.0617464855,
-0.2905836999,
-0.1820928305,
-0.2112732679,
0.4087221324,
0.8142518997,
0.2445724159,
-0.4610638022,
0.4178577363,
0.1332473755,
-0.2630813122,
-0.2176111788,
0.4907535613,
-0.1298918128,
-0.0501659475,
0.1243794635,
0.1990686953,
-0.059660133,
-0.6000902653,
0.3013518453,
0.4983779788,
-0.3598121703,
-0.5802860856,
0.448571384,
-0.0654280633,
-0.1968815029,
0.784979105,
0.0773184374,
-0.4398954213,
0.5757150054,
0.7133677006,
0.4843344986,
-0.5675364137,
0.3329003751,
0.2569207549,
0.4651087821,
-0.2036602199,
0.0965931863,
-0.0398157388,
-1.0277242661,
-0.4757668078,
-0.3698806167,
-0.4861976802,
0.543951273,
-0.7646334767,
0.0569870584,
-0.5287572742,
0.3917265236,
-0.2027285248,
-0.0033444485,
-0.2673866451,
0.0080759516,
-0.1251048148,
0.5065525174,
-1.0754548311,
1.0078340769,
0.3459894955,
-0.4084358513,
-0.6963328123,
0.25218454,
0.2953005731,
-1.1169036627,
0.4992453754,
-0.0208277795,
-0.4289278388,
0.2265266925,
-0.9486774206,
-0.8847128749,
0.6927500963,
0.5113610625,
-0.4565057755,
0.2004068345,
0.5144535899,
0.7456615567,
-0.2586298585,
-0.0316869728,
0.5791783333,
0.1770690829,
0.0510771312,
-0.6794820428,
-0.0411664024,
-0.1082958132,
-0.5194504261,
0.2161887884,
-0.7560014725,
0.7641181946,
-0.2440778464,
-0.3709692359,
0.0321681127,
0.419981271,
0.0686556324,
0.1778361946,
0.4146509171,
0.3187192678,
0.7240918279,
0.0501582995,
0.908457756,
-0.3156787753,
0.2195645571,
1.4246227741,
-0.0748211443,
0.6306654811,
0.3061820865,
-0.0842745006,
0.3659784496,
0.3344637752,
-0.0808424354,
0.4794512093,
0.1703898758,
-0.1760861278,
-0.2432545722,
0.1061445251,
-0.1468408555,
0.5048277974,
0.6774267554,
-0.5100441575,
-0.1430466026,
-0.1580430269,
0.1371082366,
0.1381775141,
-0.0985164419,
0.7038386464,
-0.2112008631,
-0.4094453752,
0.7002899051,
-0.4004850686,
0.4740677476,
-0.4862667918,
-0.2631396651,
-0.4328713119,
0.0766752288,
-0.1117058396,
-0.6628791094,
0.3509550691,
-0.161866948,
-0.3001885116,
-0.2305122763,
0.3024831414,
-0.5043919086,
-0.0502992421,
0.1414037496,
0.5959791541,
0.3125980794,
0.0218408555,
-0.8223285079,
0.153835237,
0.2796699703,
-0.2126729339,
0.582354486,
0.4058451056,
0.1376140267,
0.7361418009,
0.7811791897,
0.2088965923,
0.2607636452,
-0.2466183305,
0.7424079776,
-0.3090147376,
-0.205630511,
-0.7942999005,
0.1467582136,
0.0614973269,
-0.2792890668,
0.8318592906,
0.7010284662,
0.8773845434,
-0.1674303859,
0.7349319458,
0.3895175159,
0.7332484126,
-0.7375323176,
0.8472050428,
-0.3742253482,
0.6553883553,
-0.1998250484,
-0.4903025031,
0.023397278,
0.4911691546,
-0.3534885347,
0.1007094309,
0.4608543813,
1.2789609432,
-0.1093671694,
0.2805188596,
0.6093864441,
0.736430645,
0.1523451954,
0.2568207383,
0.9505547285,
-0.4212885797,
0.6182742715,
-0.3518034518,
-0.2886395454,
-0.1537492573,
-0.4181075394,
-0.7132324576,
-0.8036668301,
-0.3857550621,
-0.4661583006,
0.2809170485,
0.768953681,
0.5018864274,
-0.9627352357,
-0.2949924469,
-0.4075546265,
0.0784779266,
-0.4126429856,
-0.3146705329,
0.4023783207,
-0.3192893863,
-0.9106838107,
0.5667711496,
-0.1056275964,
0.4308004975,
-0.2769515216,
-0.0201662537,
0.0143880798,
0.314288944,
0.3112369478,
0.4271889627,
-0.603351295,
-0.1731941104,
0.0509809479,
-0.0840167552,
-0.0356196463,
0.9836714864,
-0.7735702395,
0.4392009079,
0.1303960532,
0.5929145813,
0.2507243156,
0.0364783034,
0.7075867653,
-0.7712625861,
-0.2062141746,
-0.0816547647,
0.062544331,
0.0505473427,
-0.6695902944,
0.427051127,
0.354390949,
-0.7666141391,
-0.8364222646,
0.2504141927,
-0.6701965332,
-0.4527260661,
1.1548942327,
-0.0967146829,
-0.3161298037,
-0.4637812078,
-0.1892781258,
0.3090193868,
-0.5807517171,
1.1484780312,
0.8526068926,
-0.3902057707,
-0.2302352339,
-0.8628430367,
0.7211158276,
0.3763952255,
-0.5528992414,
0.5278544426,
0.5856797695,
0.4889060557,
-0.1177716479,
0.0511182509,
-0.170523122,
0.3014442921,
0.2302868366,
-0.116108112,
-0.4598479569,
-0.1576637626,
-0.5496169925,
-0.0304014664,
-0.0164194722,
-0.1812109053
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09696v1
|
Are Large Language Models Reliable Argument Quality Annotators?
| 2024-04-15T11:54:27 | 2024-04-15T11:54:27 |
Nailia Mirzakhmedova, Marcel Gohsen, Chia Hao Chang, Benno Stein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.ET
|
Evaluating the quality of arguments is a crucial aspect of any system
leveraging argument mining. However, it is a challenge to obtain reliable and
consistent annotations regarding argument quality, as this usually requires
domain-specific expertise of the annotators. Even among experts, the assessment
of argument quality is often inconsistent due to the inherent subjectivity of
this task. In this paper, we study the potential of using state-of-the-art
large language models (LLMs) as proxies for argument quality annotators. To
assess the capability of LLMs in this regard, we analyze the agreement between
model, human expert, and human novice annotators based on an established
taxonomy of argument quality dimensions. Our findings highlight that LLMs can
produce consistent annotations, with a moderately high agreement with human
experts across most of the quality dimensions. Moreover, we show that using
LLMs as additional annotators can significantly improve the agreement between
annotators. These results suggest that LLMs can serve as a valuable tool for
automated argument quality assessment, thus streamlining and accelerating the
evaluation of large argument datasets.
|
[
-0.3910329938,
-0.7316120267,
0.9186902642,
-0.1153412163,
-0.6513261795,
-0.0258829203,
-0.3576797545,
-0.381536603,
0.0587465689,
0.4439864457,
0.015093714,
-0.3296252787,
-0.9570432305,
0.2525154352,
-0.3794950247,
0.7908359766,
-0.0137914056,
0.2789030075,
-0.5211157203,
-0.3395979702,
-0.4528816044,
-0.6886099577,
-0.7880486846,
-0.362796247,
0.6343645453,
0.2290451676,
0.9979527593,
0.6895391941,
0.3678232133,
0.4244317114,
-0.1996889114,
0.3374200761,
-0.0375663489,
0.3581413627,
-0.4594161808,
-0.1227748692,
-0.637531817,
-0.0142616415,
0.6304292083,
0.6101953387,
-0.0021363501,
0.1570685059,
-0.0706033483,
0.3344510496,
-0.4086927474,
-0.0215932485,
-0.916480124,
-0.2305067927,
-0.261585623,
-0.097500518,
-0.3845474124,
-0.4913330078,
0.2291457802,
-0.28163746,
-0.3527544439,
-0.1146582142,
1.0531551838,
0.4372699559,
-0.2194286138,
-0.4061169922,
-0.6058316827,
0.5414633155,
-1.3502029181,
0.1225983128,
0.164529562,
0.3262738883,
-0.4207749665,
-0.7017996907,
-0.6721123457,
-0.4847580492,
-0.1072309315,
-0.1177428961,
-0.2763544321,
-0.0738748237,
0.3712388277,
0.2766858339,
-0.1488130242,
0.6913675666,
0.0205766428,
-0.4069792032,
0.774410069,
0.1441425681,
0.2145260423,
-0.3193005919,
-0.2451894283,
0.2575349212,
-0.6721069217,
-0.0942550525,
0.6285488009,
0.2014665157,
0.2493161559,
0.5370217562,
0.0207552556,
0.8098554015,
0.006749324,
-0.2401214689,
-0.1982021481,
0.0029566309,
-0.2157394588,
-0.2325213999,
1.0803148746,
0.3089590669,
0.4738263488,
-0.0240434613,
-0.2496746927,
-0.2393596023,
0.2255085558,
-0.7211506963,
-0.2605026066,
0.4061425924,
-0.4711703658,
-0.0929235443,
0.0619064495,
-0.7368563414,
-0.7260045409,
-0.3115672767,
0.4611326754,
-0.2362008393,
-0.3507064879,
0.072916761,
0.110813871,
0.0071993978,
0.3652251959,
-0.6717554927,
0.0979301259,
0.8808786869,
0.7192672491,
-0.1073960215,
-0.1157630309,
-0.8648756742,
-0.1224288493,
-0.7114502192,
1.172565937,
-0.7720021009,
-0.1445552558,
0.1705887318,
-0.1298328489,
0.3001403213,
-0.7249621749,
1.1608818769,
-0.5792774558,
0.0713141114,
-0.4195962846,
-0.9193579555,
-0.2172650695,
0.3552298844,
-0.736153841,
0.7333430052,
-0.2117459327,
-0.4559184313,
0.5527608395,
-0.4520851076,
-0.3307186663,
0.4537043273,
-0.1420874894,
-0.3885164261,
0.2580032647,
0.2085806578,
0.7817892432,
-0.4507608712,
0.33611992,
-0.4983561933,
-0.2124914974,
0.744184494,
-0.4748324454,
0.3233320117,
0.031464614,
-0.1167273223,
0.2286813706,
-0.6822157502,
-0.0367302671,
0.1538666785,
-0.4479370713,
-0.2695468962,
0.2804934084,
-0.2270946205,
0.3827715814,
0.2652666867,
-0.5325509906,
0.1762927026,
-0.2796176374,
0.6762743592,
0.8896634579,
0.1193491295,
-0.0712073371,
0.0161906853,
0.2957133949,
-0.033699546,
-0.2011607736,
-0.2819729149,
-0.482303232,
-0.8074310422,
-0.412122041,
0.7284272909,
0.1448815912,
-0.2312601656,
0.5708206296,
-0.3073457778,
-0.5461868644,
-0.5008224845,
0.15838404,
0.0915012658,
0.1295996308,
0.1984779388,
-0.1092946827,
-0.4500605166,
-0.8525495529,
-0.439583689,
-0.4954115748,
0.0854658782,
0.1244896576,
0.4736426175,
-0.0792377815,
1.0178005695,
0.0767277628,
-0.0078721428,
-0.1938067824,
0.1536219418,
0.1293319911,
0.2016606629,
0.3782514632,
-0.2942413688,
-0.3455832303,
-0.0247288309,
-0.6412945986,
-0.2386298031,
-0.3082017303,
-0.0476404168,
0.3395553529,
0.3328731656,
-0.6517966986,
-0.0654857904,
0.597861886,
-0.2511784434,
0.711315155,
-0.1783676147,
-0.0183484722,
-1.0751358271,
0.0851468816,
0.3146284819,
-0.3434418142,
-0.5939643979,
-0.1612342149,
-0.182936579,
0.212001726,
-0.2592515647,
0.6370195746,
-0.1413592994,
0.2436921299,
-0.4642883837,
0.1999189258,
-0.059403006,
0.0062090638,
0.121202901,
0.6113147736,
0.4490909576,
-0.2904646695,
0.5555802584,
-0.0072333724,
-0.5248999,
0.8403991461,
-0.8627846837,
0.2819779813,
0.2040485591,
0.1839029342,
-1.0540982485,
-0.4635983706,
0.1542999893,
-0.2750676572,
0.2486834526,
-0.3632346988,
-0.8053070307,
-0.3034911156,
-0.1630166322,
-0.201645121,
0.291056633,
-0.6620408297,
0.7058382034,
0.3385705948,
-0.3055014908,
-0.6249551177,
-0.4078655243,
0.6216061115,
-0.3239193559,
-0.4721190333,
-0.0667912737,
0.1737857312,
-0.4634956121,
-0.0722004548,
0.109349519,
0.1016095951,
0.0839215443,
0.4195073247,
0.1203267425,
-0.2567543685,
0.2182366848,
-0.1404108107,
-0.1839999259,
0.2807607651,
-0.175043419,
0.3311572969,
-0.1141281128,
-0.6503608227,
-0.5252905488,
0.3510594964,
0.8409749866,
-0.2425983101,
0.6459756494,
0.473023355,
-0.5142797828,
0.0532567874,
-1.1326733828,
-0.0347809009,
-0.4532749951,
0.3653103709,
-0.434140861,
-1.0154087543,
0.6033983827,
-0.4244921505,
0.5126777887,
0.6602271199,
0.6323664188,
-0.091539368,
1.0480619669,
-0.0211692285,
-0.0504744537,
0.0692957565,
0.0203321055,
0.2868139148,
-0.7909324765,
-0.0107225981,
-0.61041224,
-0.199447915,
-0.2262664288,
-0.2963509262,
-0.1269966066,
0.2557241619,
-0.3861190677,
-0.0922964439,
-0.2054167688,
0.4425497651,
0.1589706689,
-0.2943776548,
0.164399296,
0.0617223419,
-0.1121966988,
-0.1977284402,
-0.4523057938,
-1.3164795637,
0.7147417068,
0.8567537665,
0.498197943,
-0.0330771618,
0.5296449065,
0.2291567028,
0.5470627546,
-0.8696792722,
0.6899302006,
-0.2610659897,
-0.4080135226,
-0.2316419035,
-0.3544796109,
-0.6414535642,
0.3025627732,
-0.3735246062,
-0.8461264372,
0.0784192383,
0.1017722636,
-0.5284014344,
0.6430818439,
-0.479190439,
0.9989808798,
-0.3193171918,
-0.4453158081,
0.0017869155,
-0.1877303123,
0.2343069017,
-0.1702916771,
0.0767577812,
-0.2936857939,
0.113027744,
1.1147236824,
-0.4896245897,
0.6283342838,
-0.1129032448,
-0.4596330523,
0.5501456857,
0.1451803893,
0.4190085828,
-0.0145596452,
-0.4594543278,
0.3756270409,
-0.0154700754,
-0.2482073009,
-0.5855953097,
0.6559220552,
-0.6881388426,
-1.1121180058,
-0.2692782581,
-0.3765230775,
-0.1941253096,
0.018631259,
-0.1234926209,
0.4142144024,
0.046542529,
0.2947281301,
0.2869335115,
-0.1421318352,
0.4671786726,
0.2848950326,
0.2123505026,
-0.5951753259,
0.9944396615,
0.1779654324,
0.1529994905,
0.0151228476,
0.5348108411,
-0.4465676546,
-0.8787434697,
-0.7387692928,
0.2658342719,
-1.0676213503,
-0.404012233,
-0.6921653748,
-0.0993728712,
0.0969576985,
-0.0493973568,
-0.413179338,
-0.3108533919,
-0.1794036031,
-0.1949302703,
0.3568024337,
0.7850118279,
0.1330818087,
0.0498850197,
-0.8647514582,
-0.1598046422,
0.5535728931,
0.3677309155,
0.0528065115,
-0.6125694513,
-0.1425267309,
0.0158688147,
-0.1720824838,
-0.825719893,
-0.0747021809,
0.0985712856,
0.7263815999,
0.6919783354,
-0.1303788722,
0.5165376663,
-0.3550661206,
1.3167934418,
0.0557090379,
-1.0329347849,
0.177201435,
-0.2344227135,
0.0555757694,
0.3599884212,
0.2050541192,
-0.4038739502,
-0.4572356641,
-0.3497275412,
-0.5801119208,
0.3745295703,
-0.3200992048,
0.2552663088,
-0.1946148425,
0.6733518243,
0.3488420546,
-0.1827800274,
-0.6684674621,
0.2861896455,
-0.1566062719,
-0.1733164638,
0.1561173797,
-0.6649373174,
-0.1484204382,
0.0394505076,
0.4995214343,
-0.2150379866,
-0.11331857,
-0.2315533757,
0.0368546359,
-0.2959037423,
0.6264669895,
0.685878396,
0.9601854086,
0.0509864576,
0.2865977883,
0.553204596,
-0.1590734124,
0.3280614913,
-0.0268932637,
0.0871106237,
0.1926534027,
0.6320521235,
0.7389730811,
-0.0574941523,
-0.6836785674,
0.4481437802,
-0.0046140593,
-0.2076676488,
-0.2150479406,
0.0160068702,
0.4971551895,
0.3238401413,
0.3018078506,
-0.1776584089,
-0.2782979906,
-0.3959231973,
-0.0004018371,
0.7621821761,
-0.2983099818,
-0.1422527432,
0.5321432948,
0.3236203492,
-0.4941350222,
0.2923890054,
0.0678782165,
-0.6688339114,
0.2267111093,
0.2108353227,
0.736361146,
-0.1508396566,
0.0532891676,
0.3051880002,
0.2291548401,
-0.1900919229,
0.1212677956,
0.3390783668,
-0.5164038539,
-0.8281029463,
-0.6397890449,
-0.7252070904,
0.238135621,
-0.3664877713,
0.1477382481,
-0.4033754468,
-0.4182047546,
0.0528126396,
0.1009192765,
-0.4685357511,
0.1901519597,
0.3387181163,
0.781865716,
-0.7629625797,
0.809786737,
1.0156407356,
-0.3419610858,
-0.6444824934,
0.0377686433,
-0.3816448152,
-0.281699121,
0.8774357438,
0.0223824345,
-0.2061655968,
-0.3992284834,
-0.4627138674,
-0.549664259,
0.7349919081,
0.6128767729,
-0.6498612165,
0.4153293669,
0.3454048038,
0.9008178115,
-0.4401043952,
0.4793196917,
0.4556604326,
0.6204960942,
0.1589308083,
-0.7952418923,
0.314273417,
0.0564417616,
0.0002942542,
-0.1327326745,
-0.3894166648,
0.6425797343,
-0.2630578578,
-0.1142543331,
0.1009485275,
1.1082540751,
0.259647876,
-0.0312576145,
0.6627942324,
0.5467427969,
0.7073181272,
-0.1002574638,
0.8537451029,
-0.3022424281,
0.200180456,
0.9613807797,
-0.4950570762,
1.3225631714,
0.3309359848,
-0.0691709965,
0.5985172391,
0.7294686437,
-0.035871163,
-0.1903822124,
0.3441643417,
-0.1010111719,
-0.9509019256,
-0.0991909429,
0.0156853963,
0.2685588598,
0.460390538,
-0.3138711154,
-0.0540860184,
-0.3947495818,
0.2655628026,
0.2285889983,
-0.1407733858,
0.8852771521,
-0.0075584874,
-0.7729362249,
0.6894999146,
0.0298448168,
0.6697281003,
-0.2993990183,
-0.176665917,
-0.1769268662,
0.0307002719,
-0.3103688657,
-1.0705254078,
-0.0342792347,
0.3181189299,
0.1192415506,
0.2243620902,
0.6905924678,
-0.2384373993,
-0.3988428116,
0.1786331832,
0.5107038021,
0.1889891624,
0.0885997638,
-0.5454586148,
0.3233749568,
-0.4782403409,
-0.3228088319,
0.2529189885,
0.308134526,
0.0155195938,
0.6594810486,
0.5972412229,
0.2901512086,
-0.0092920261,
0.1088802591,
0.7630175948,
-0.2794778943,
0.1058281735,
-1.3417953253,
0.64810431,
-0.366288811,
-0.2055001259,
0.7919050455,
0.2641549408,
0.5366906524,
0.1312676221,
0.741725266,
0.412673533,
0.5196665525,
-0.4322805703,
0.5846598148,
-0.4040950239,
0.1815140396,
-0.2896372676,
-1.0570046902,
-0.4268533587,
0.6539120078,
-0.3646771014,
0.0732824877,
0.5340070724,
0.5346640348,
-0.0802847072,
0.0856454149,
0.3745394945,
0.179184407,
0.8404813409,
0.231285423,
1.2098228931,
-0.1529546827,
0.4196226001,
0.1595013589,
-0.0235120896,
-0.3089335859,
-1.1537700891,
-1.225123167,
-0.4438478351,
-0.7322635651,
-0.3356270492,
0.0578450076,
1.2956832647,
0.622164309,
-0.8665365577,
-0.137743488,
0.3809094131,
0.1029818058,
-0.1538642198,
-0.1282682866,
0.5594992042,
-0.3491512537,
-0.6723383069,
0.2433790267,
0.3982519805,
-0.3211904466,
-0.6490524411,
-0.1833432764,
-0.1084907874,
0.5784593225,
0.7134322524,
0.1762405038,
-1.2831873894,
-0.6488345861,
-0.4680181444,
-0.0561877079,
-0.0380183868,
0.7386309505,
-0.469737947,
0.4732390046,
0.3530255258,
0.8115025759,
-0.2273739874,
0.1057987362,
0.3517669141,
-0.4528664649,
-0.2364732325,
0.1224295944,
0.7999750972,
0.6914560795,
-0.0075566629,
0.2133046091,
-0.2031743824,
-0.7385942936,
-0.856559515,
0.0044481955,
-0.7853078246,
0.0016660109,
1.6376342773,
-0.7185180783,
-0.0140317203,
-0.0313159563,
-0.3536248803,
0.021343112,
-0.3461048901,
0.8256395459,
1.1468733549,
0.0450570844,
-0.2914923429,
-0.5669013858,
0.4138324857,
0.4417777359,
-0.8772619963,
0.3410906494,
0.547162056,
0.2674172521,
0.4428943992,
0.1177571192,
-0.1058032736,
0.059317898,
-0.2278348356,
-0.1443189234,
-0.1538651586,
-0.1014402434,
-0.3271201253,
0.3863835037,
0.7764155269,
-0.0014615397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09695v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09695v1
|
LoRAP: Transformer Sub-Layers Deserve Differentiated Structured Compression for Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T11:53:22 | 2024-04-15T11:53:22 |
Guangyan Li, Yongqiang Tang, Wensheng Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) show excellent performance in difficult tasks,
but they often require massive memories and computational resources. How to
reduce the parameter scale of LLMs has become research hotspots. In this study,
we make an important observation that the multi-head self-attention (MHA)
sub-layer of Transformer exhibits noticeable low-rank structure, while the
feed-forward network (FFN) sub-layer does not. With this regard, we design a
mixed compression model, which organically combines Low-Rank matrix
approximation And structured Pruning (LoRAP). For the MHA sub-layer, we propose
an input activation weighted singular value decomposition method to strengthen
the low-rank characteristic. Furthermore, we discover that the weight matrices
in MHA sub-layer have different low-rank degrees. Thus, a novel parameter
allocation scheme according to the discrepancy of low-rank degrees is devised.
For the FFN sub-layer, we propose a gradient-free structured channel pruning
method. During the pruning, we get an interesting finding that the least
important 1% of parameter actually play a vital role in model performance.
Extensive evaluations on zero-shot perplexity and zero-shot task classification
indicate that our proposal is superior to previous structured compression
rivals under multiple compression ratios.
|
[
-0.5005582571,
-0.6901830435,
0.1859872788,
0.3870140612,
-0.324516952,
0.0700568482,
-0.2455844134,
-0.34286654,
0.4321183264,
0.4782819748,
-0.6527202725,
-0.2694309354,
-0.5195887089,
0.0276386552,
-0.3561076224,
0.7552793026,
0.1159678176,
-0.3592892289,
0.1504457444,
-0.0497167185,
-0.4145427644,
-0.6364592314,
-0.704526782,
-0.5393643975,
0.8611255884,
0.2979283929,
0.5485304594,
0.6752434969,
0.475356698,
0.3553445637,
-0.4483953118,
-0.0053149187,
-0.6649382114,
0.1468023956,
0.0462051444,
-0.2967195213,
-0.808491528,
-0.0456765741,
0.8378629088,
0.6033729911,
-0.2572684884,
0.2179875076,
0.2346965671,
0.527900219,
-0.5403471589,
0.0851645619,
-0.4778693616,
0.2090665102,
-0.0435579494,
-0.2297909707,
-0.618847847,
0.2423664033,
-0.4337040186,
-0.1687210947,
0.2475261092,
-0.0378802009,
0.8160251379,
0.7476754189,
-0.1712042391,
0.5439515114,
-0.9807175994,
0.8783703446,
-0.8666731119,
0.341271013,
-0.0318235159,
0.1990856528,
0.1063821763,
-0.4241987467,
-0.2601366639,
0.1106482968,
-0.1520708501,
0.1013557687,
-0.2328582406,
0.0937318206,
0.1743063033,
0.5777018666,
-0.2886027396,
0.4509809017,
-0.4119490683,
-0.1292121857,
0.5544759631,
0.0429321416,
-0.1194559112,
-0.2987135053,
-0.4194666147,
-0.1446916908,
-0.8173552155,
0.1103799269,
0.4675882459,
0.4896280169,
-0.077610597,
0.6251637936,
-0.2871641815,
0.5350141525,
0.1493431479,
-0.5439915061,
0.1375780702,
-0.0838523284,
-0.5217815042,
-0.0756604448,
0.7810417414,
-0.0269249696,
0.3360662162,
-0.1071630195,
-0.2392005324,
0.0980686769,
0.4538204968,
-0.8376737833,
-0.1204531565,
0.2927274406,
-0.5800836086,
-0.4282351434,
-0.3129689693,
-0.4885121286,
0.022713922,
-0.227943629,
0.3978490829,
-0.0093129901,
-0.1271739006,
0.2348048091,
0.2385078818,
0.2927144766,
0.307436496,
-0.8374279141,
0.2997308969,
0.5622691512,
0.609657526,
-0.2566550076,
-0.2326913923,
-0.2799051404,
0.1064699665,
0.0934368372,
0.8030031919,
-0.3862465024,
-0.1992111206,
-0.3917393088,
-0.0734681115,
-0.2321673185,
-0.5109294057,
0.721337676,
-0.4602679908,
0.1283816099,
0.2115729898,
-0.0251251888,
-0.053659033,
0.1543570906,
-0.6988657713,
0.9909575582,
0.3435755074,
-0.737290144,
-0.0826738775,
-0.3458539248,
-0.5000334382,
0.1306824833,
-0.1599174142,
-0.5050239563,
0.303011179,
0.4260143638,
0.458247453,
-0.3722538352,
0.1860118508,
-0.1666141152,
-0.4427413046,
0.0258251578,
-0.4563301802,
0.4389450252,
0.1632896662,
-0.0739805549,
0.2971725166,
-0.7689554095,
0.1261777729,
0.240500927,
-0.7174576521,
-0.0416277051,
-0.0876592621,
-0.0136686265,
0.5227273703,
0.0220311936,
-0.5810214281,
0.5678717494,
-0.4715031981,
0.6294344664,
0.6800675988,
0.0637871549,
0.4893860817,
-0.1502786875,
0.6445432901,
0.0063629472,
0.3517126739,
0.1340476274,
-0.2694661915,
-1.0401816368,
-0.3897917867,
0.3633647859,
0.4373447001,
-0.5353477597,
0.5214247108,
-0.4994512498,
-0.4521923661,
-0.690161407,
0.0276484601,
0.3113872111,
0.4502579272,
0.5278791785,
-0.0904273689,
-0.2801599801,
-1.3606777191,
-0.016652206,
0.0710703954,
-0.2738682032,
0.3295376301,
0.3089774847,
-0.0394749902,
0.7997504473,
-0.5280459523,
-0.4902791679,
-0.5800764561,
-0.053760495,
0.4461997151,
0.4731429517,
0.3628200591,
-0.492456764,
-0.2645038962,
-0.2678730786,
-0.2988013327,
-0.1879366785,
0.1066238657,
0.1059101969,
-0.1382242292,
0.2609860003,
-0.735868156,
0.2915211022,
0.7102931738,
-0.0027194389,
0.3330089152,
0.0477669425,
-0.1151818335,
-0.8770172596,
-0.1333274096,
-0.0034743552,
-0.2233741432,
-0.5045856833,
0.2748091817,
-0.0696605593,
-0.2671273649,
-0.7004941702,
0.1868795604,
-0.3990830779,
-0.0395509787,
-0.4536493719,
-0.2286986262,
0.0725906864,
1.1154565811,
0.0512422696,
0.6131702065,
0.3364883959,
-0.4702938199,
0.1526101828,
0.1737704724,
-0.1941459626,
0.2616198063,
-0.9526786804,
0.2475271821,
-0.129446283,
0.3229962587,
-0.7511034608,
0.1422401667,
0.2351826131,
-0.0391957387,
0.4417942166,
-0.3796180189,
-0.4721180499,
-0.3270334601,
-0.2783745229,
0.5979447365,
0.5974125266,
-0.2189774811,
0.6574726701,
0.3760896921,
-0.2636179626,
-0.4643659592,
-0.7979756594,
-0.0008425413,
-0.3861218691,
-0.7683528662,
0.6396417618,
-0.1628138274,
0.0711373761,
-0.1343540251,
-0.2995671034,
0.1543495655,
0.0176024679,
0.2842250466,
0.0489795543,
-0.5287459493,
-0.2640708089,
0.0302243996,
-0.3126915097,
-0.0573577695,
-0.0749258026,
0.6971518397,
0.064377062,
-0.2519084215,
-0.183213979,
0.5555305481,
0.3882698417,
-0.2512951493,
0.9364940524,
0.404966712,
-0.0897216499,
-0.6130839586,
-0.3725310266,
-0.1513911039,
-0.5084692836,
0.1741293967,
-0.4319265783,
-1.0530039072,
0.3684563339,
-0.0771613121,
0.0743145645,
0.5431539416,
0.6128210425,
0.0495592244,
0.9332904816,
0.7135796547,
-0.1782672554,
0.3013743758,
-0.3425900042,
0.4749174416,
-1.0224596262,
0.0393498167,
-0.6102082729,
-0.7232777476,
-0.3627381921,
-0.3929781318,
0.3698890805,
0.0730739608,
-0.0687923655,
0.4843877852,
-0.6919384003,
0.3756140471,
0.3106970787,
-0.0140017057,
0.2316919714,
0.073318243,
0.0902623758,
0.0451075286,
-0.8746611476,
-0.248894453,
0.5081563592,
0.7262248397,
1.0526040792,
0.136571303,
0.6829200387,
0.1777891964,
0.1311403066,
-1.0764806271,
0.605076611,
-0.1688627899,
-0.2288444042,
-0.3692234159,
-0.5391769409,
-0.8601109982,
0.537481606,
-0.0091060279,
-0.5973050594,
0.2048461288,
-0.0263096597,
-0.4561835825,
0.2288769633,
-0.5949959159,
0.5111021996,
0.0838850737,
-0.0896201134,
-0.0574553572,
-0.5458230376,
0.3349615633,
0.0938165635,
0.2688427567,
0.0633736849,
0.189502418,
0.8769192696,
-0.5046023726,
0.7286984324,
0.0029389325,
-0.3818761408,
0.1357145309,
0.1504974961,
0.5464178324,
-0.156959042,
0.017922271,
0.1888769567,
-0.3000834286,
-0.2879354954,
-0.5688582659,
0.7418242097,
-0.7998832464,
-0.7484968305,
-0.003214452,
-0.6519355774,
-0.1493553668,
-0.0100908633,
0.1731275767,
0.4860014617,
0.269225508,
0.6043762565,
0.5547097325,
-0.0859795958,
0.4880933166,
0.3882819414,
0.0673232004,
-0.2293932438,
0.7549287081,
0.2254962474,
0.3353473842,
0.6466454864,
0.2549382746,
0.1066054478,
-0.7659425139,
-0.0721363053,
0.445217371,
-0.9294158816,
-0.4128681421,
-0.5582394004,
-0.7070454955,
-0.4599025846,
-0.0099866102,
-0.704290092,
-0.4790327549,
-0.0170974433,
-0.0283184964,
-0.1259358823,
0.6043642163,
0.4109201729,
0.7288793921,
-0.6864207983,
0.5024839044,
0.2241232991,
0.3476115763,
0.0863035545,
-0.7670576572,
-0.3659006655,
-0.2760533392,
-0.2084335089,
-0.585863471,
0.5527511835,
0.1595411301,
0.4712750018,
0.283188194,
0.0926613137,
0.5613979697,
-0.5843695402,
0.6071912646,
-0.1328194141,
-0.6643308997,
0.2236967385,
-0.2329874486,
0.4941732287,
0.2390038669,
0.0343171097,
-0.2507912517,
-0.3926181197,
-0.682407558,
-0.9784726501,
0.7876346707,
0.4200471044,
0.032900881,
0.3374381661,
0.248086229,
-0.110754244,
0.1657467335,
-1.268935442,
-0.5373159647,
-0.1024868861,
-0.0519532859,
-0.0010950582,
-0.4238493741,
-0.1660415083,
-0.2754397094,
0.5290597677,
-0.0964459255,
0.5266734362,
0.080100432,
-0.1157966405,
-0.1848008037,
0.6356307864,
0.4996193051,
0.2980535924,
-0.1838480383,
0.3361000121,
0.0251393579,
-0.3894860744,
0.2893856466,
-0.2193959057,
-0.2291518003,
-0.2274994999,
0.5687486529,
0.8014391065,
0.4991153479,
-0.0684831366,
0.3077679276,
-0.0520818792,
-0.280210197,
0.0857647732,
0.2573777437,
0.1792183518,
0.1086893007,
0.4457685947,
0.0490959957,
-0.1222851649,
-0.2652964294,
-0.267765224,
0.2853743732,
-0.093050085,
-0.317178458,
0.3620414138,
0.1934943944,
-0.4945476353,
0.4741318822,
0.2488024235,
-0.5131554604,
0.3917657435,
0.5342268944,
0.6647305489,
-0.2411775887,
-0.0088815475,
0.1677238345,
0.5958607197,
0.0183885079,
-0.0170580968,
-0.1780323982,
-0.5629889369,
-0.745550096,
-0.923173964,
-0.1070985347,
0.5375057459,
-0.4516674578,
0.322247684,
-0.4179004729,
-0.0644969344,
0.0659541637,
-0.0305737797,
-0.4368728697,
0.3394111097,
0.1491331309,
0.8184348941,
-0.7321699262,
1.1241939068,
0.1391536891,
-0.2274985015,
-1.0908660889,
-0.1550399661,
-0.3574074209,
-0.6125262976,
0.6183983684,
0.0525592752,
-0.3076169491,
0.1633717716,
-0.4042239785,
-1.0612175465,
0.8582370877,
0.4982663691,
-0.4957480431,
-0.3661697209,
0.1652751863,
0.4638629258,
-0.362955898,
0.0941245556,
0.196576193,
0.4301227629,
0.3096257746,
-0.8299339414,
0.0015289722,
-0.2948674858,
-0.0632620379,
0.4291290343,
-0.8152564168,
1.1947267056,
0.1474381685,
-0.4172107279,
-0.2399625182,
0.6390659809,
0.0188812874,
-0.3473886251,
0.5915358663,
0.5614066124,
0.0376021937,
0.070669964,
0.9681333303,
-0.1318767369,
0.4186816812,
0.9042932987,
-0.2146187127,
0.8910837173,
0.6629007459,
-0.2635733187,
0.5394845605,
0.4167582691,
0.01500169,
0.4691648781,
0.2316820025,
0.2339474708,
-0.3513902426,
-0.1128770262,
-0.3756972253,
0.5045986176,
0.1131867841,
-0.2767085433,
-0.2632549405,
-0.2178492248,
-0.1696568727,
-0.3212183416,
-0.2749054134,
0.5581118464,
0.2051189244,
-0.7161182761,
0.8435024619,
0.318936646,
0.7725862861,
-0.7192513943,
0.1901177168,
-0.2808644176,
0.159703359,
-0.3377732635,
-0.6014339328,
0.2897051573,
-0.2213580012,
-0.2617684901,
-0.606590569,
0.8406783342,
-0.2770151496,
-0.3832660019,
0.3898761272,
0.4330905974,
0.0067476984,
-0.2675378025,
-0.5426571965,
0.258878231,
-0.2174585164,
-0.7415773869,
0.5337073803,
0.0976165831,
-0.0157049522,
0.5871392488,
0.594183743,
0.3405652046,
-0.0833381787,
0.4245204926,
1.0853921175,
-0.5644937754,
-0.5129112005,
-0.7525410056,
0.3890655935,
0.1873808354,
-0.0410002097,
0.6799080372,
0.305503577,
0.4221284091,
-0.1811518669,
0.1798389107,
0.1804740876,
0.3655245304,
-0.4933772683,
0.4898167849,
-0.5738047957,
0.3902385533,
-0.2525601387,
-1.1124651432,
-0.173857227,
0.4727351069,
-0.0618483685,
0.1388461441,
0.7160944343,
0.5345340371,
-0.2493553609,
-0.4028502405,
0.3857804537,
0.1961071342,
0.2776390612,
0.6752377152,
0.6866716146,
-0.417268604,
0.5831327438,
-0.4906291068,
-0.0145304706,
-0.1774123311,
-0.8726673126,
-0.8574553132,
-0.3916160762,
-0.357293874,
-0.0090811495,
-0.5573642254,
0.5786634088,
0.9936898947,
-0.534991622,
-0.1578105092,
0.203266561,
0.1302634031,
-0.2166869938,
-0.2368665934,
0.2311893702,
0.1564818174,
-0.5925239325,
0.7826267481,
0.5673621297,
-0.0226594191,
-0.6348730326,
0.1161597446,
-0.2478793412,
0.224748984,
0.687666595,
0.0538844727,
-0.850491643,
-0.2605696321,
0.0619117692,
-0.2208556086,
0.2245026231,
0.9545155764,
-0.8778855801,
-0.3995853961,
0.5686753392,
0.3621498346,
0.5002195239,
0.2465652972,
0.3891977668,
-1.2092190981,
0.4275001585,
0.3275404572,
0.4726934731,
0.2564133108,
-0.5189843774,
0.3416881859,
0.0438455269,
-0.5527850389,
-0.7788037658,
0.3103252947,
-1.2175804377,
-0.3657604456,
1.1847370863,
0.0237123277,
-0.5142217278,
0.2078655362,
-0.3144328892,
0.0906161666,
-0.3076085746,
0.6108168364,
0.6541283727,
-0.1806418598,
-0.6058093905,
-0.2411340475,
0.2554792762,
0.4964200556,
-0.6864863038,
0.0416444354,
0.1290826499,
0.0258461796,
0.3250273168,
0.3339377046,
0.1321654171,
-0.2237873077,
-0.1661196351,
-0.0009815906,
-0.3293475509,
-0.6374151111,
-0.4117024839,
0.6833410263,
0.0794233754,
0.0596321858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09690v1
|
Harnessing GPT-4V(ision) for Insurance: A Preliminary Exploration
| 2024-04-15T11:45:30 | 2024-04-15T11:45:30 |
Chenwei Lin, Hanjia Lyu, Jiebo Luo, Xian Xu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The emergence of Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) marks a significant milestone
in the development of artificial intelligence. Insurance, as a vast and complex
discipline, involves a wide variety of data forms in its operational processes,
including text, images, and videos, thereby giving rise to diverse multimodal
tasks. Despite this, there has been limited systematic exploration of
multimodal tasks specific to insurance, nor a thorough investigation into how
LMMs can address these challenges. In this paper, we explore GPT-4V's
capabilities in the insurance domain. We categorize multimodal tasks by
focusing primarily on visual aspects based on types of insurance (e.g., auto,
household/commercial property, health, and agricultural insurance) and
insurance stages (e.g., risk assessment, risk monitoring, and claims
processing). Our experiment reveals that GPT-4V exhibits remarkable abilities
in insurance-related tasks, demonstrating not only a robust understanding of
multimodal content in the insurance domain but also a comprehensive knowledge
of insurance scenarios. However, there are notable shortcomings: GPT-4V
struggles with detailed risk rating and loss assessment, suffers from
hallucination in image understanding, and shows variable support for different
languages. Through this work, we aim to bridge the insurance domain with
cutting-edge LMM technology, facilitate interdisciplinary exchange and
development, and provide a foundation for the continued advancement and
evolution of future research endeavors.
|
[
-0.0313922875,
-0.6738874912,
0.5714948177,
0.4521974623,
0.022065524,
0.1540062428,
0.1312259734,
-0.7373675108,
-0.1386127621,
0.2088816911,
-0.546675384,
-0.3904334605,
-0.4819166958,
-0.2921466529,
0.0121057294,
1.1973518133,
-0.1356717795,
-0.2116613239,
-0.3912298977,
0.0624187365,
-0.1838710159,
-0.4073911905,
-0.5303176641,
-0.3583752215,
0.5489187837,
0.118935965,
0.6363741159,
0.1522956789,
0.6501715183,
0.4078443348,
0.5563271046,
-0.0533297472,
-0.0483818613,
-0.2391877323,
0.1021221429,
-0.3092688322,
-0.552615881,
0.2169973701,
0.7014414668,
-0.0973375365,
-0.3681792617,
-0.1905844659,
-0.1193093359,
0.3888851702,
-0.6764859557,
0.6874396205,
-0.4768032432,
0.1758375764,
-0.1432319582,
-0.6758529544,
-0.120849438,
0.1108272597,
0.566139102,
-0.8427376747,
0.1135268584,
0.0964270979,
1.1344692707,
0.4645655453,
-0.9803252816,
-0.301330775,
-0.670620203,
0.4788973033,
-0.0420491658,
0.2787970304,
0.4915786088,
0.542953074,
0.1841906607,
-0.7140684724,
-0.6748580337,
-0.440903306,
0.1093111336,
0.543107748,
-0.5371697545,
0.4504469335,
0.2104933858,
0.3466254473,
-0.3856692612,
0.3399629593,
-0.3494330943,
-0.7357496023,
0.6805102825,
0.0631121621,
0.4321098924,
-0.2343383133,
-0.6719619632,
-0.1183393672,
-0.7414553165,
0.2971215248,
0.5815770626,
-0.3150663078,
-0.1711976379,
0.5985497832,
-0.1979852766,
0.3911848068,
-0.5368739367,
-0.4851934314,
0.5874037147,
-0.7636935711,
-0.3874639571,
-0.0324894376,
0.6662775278,
0.5900756717,
-0.0878367499,
-0.1227828711,
-0.2224289775,
0.0083763162,
0.5488553643,
-0.6269203424,
-0.006670617,
0.0767654032,
-0.2083331048,
-0.4520050883,
-0.1239181459,
-0.5544997454,
-0.2566690743,
-0.2217714787,
0.8526951671,
-0.572560668,
-0.2977086008,
0.2073779702,
-0.2229534984,
0.674410224,
0.2173295766,
-0.7143343091,
0.1272518486,
0.395919323,
0.7594177127,
0.0469665527,
-0.2348661423,
-0.0898506641,
0.3868336678,
0.0563014336,
1.0330548286,
-0.1796168387,
-0.0327809192,
0.1221943274,
-0.1141325235,
-0.018253237,
0.1166419238,
0.5803638697,
-0.4806079268,
0.0963896438,
0.2563614845,
-0.1003159359,
-0.6603261828,
0.8469306231,
-0.6820860505,
0.4197094142,
0.3818692267,
-0.7469868064,
0.6812779307,
-0.8321416378,
-0.267606616,
0.2494468689,
-0.5856902599,
-1.0650976896,
0.0412886925,
0.1075233445,
0.5123389363,
-0.36184901,
-0.0550471321,
-0.3716260195,
-0.051509656,
0.4010826945,
-0.7692114711,
0.1517032981,
-0.0372955725,
-0.2556652427,
0.2119155675,
-0.7339717746,
-0.1015118733,
0.165667057,
-0.0348604284,
-0.5251024961,
-0.1906615347,
0.1844603717,
0.2899535298,
0.1825646758,
-0.5450174809,
0.3977452517,
-0.1716986299,
0.7245941162,
0.7409793139,
0.1262648553,
0.4849663973,
-0.4172352552,
0.5557349324,
0.2818457186,
0.2417193055,
-0.1153033823,
-0.4850209355,
-0.2646736205,
-0.6887017488,
0.0496805087,
0.6473795176,
-1.1965261698,
-0.3335296214,
-0.1484188586,
-0.4163655937,
-0.2982688844,
-0.3790924251,
0.2037596405,
0.3582154214,
0.248954162,
-0.1309410185,
-0.1369942576,
-1.3288670778,
-0.0840077251,
0.1154892817,
0.2681837976,
0.2807013988,
0.5818881392,
-0.7125635743,
0.8121939301,
-0.512855649,
-0.745500803,
-0.2584971189,
0.251837492,
0.0563918911,
0.3238701522,
0.72331357,
-1.1302808523,
-0.0582198314,
0.2480062991,
-0.8306056857,
0.2849992812,
-0.3689207137,
0.2089024186,
-0.0075065484,
0.1010722294,
-0.7466353774,
0.6682017446,
0.4534890652,
-0.2805577815,
0.6348388195,
-0.7806117535,
0.2113314569,
-1.042526722,
-0.3470782042,
0.2903779149,
-0.3715019822,
-0.7987954617,
-0.1696753651,
0.3405905664,
0.0702043176,
-0.1950488687,
0.2497435212,
-0.6967677474,
-0.3563458323,
-0.1762444079,
-0.3473617136,
-0.1473067701,
0.3942317963,
-0.2750115991,
1.0054934025,
0.9114050269,
-0.6210749745,
0.5478712916,
0.1703674644,
-0.4508197904,
0.6643090844,
-0.3591800034,
-0.10878326,
-0.3353174627,
0.0483897813,
-0.5543074608,
-0.6180980802,
0.3336290121,
0.0745977908,
0.3001549244,
0.1357264966,
-0.4534996152,
-0.4728787243,
-0.3001157045,
0.4720585346,
0.1926681548,
-0.0050187386,
1.2071943283,
0.5496129394,
-0.5079681277,
-0.8558565378,
-0.7853730917,
0.2940047383,
-0.644317627,
-0.8402892947,
0.7631909251,
0.2594339252,
-0.2043281049,
0.2400760502,
-0.079215318,
-0.2243086994,
-0.0862933025,
0.3460691273,
0.3887454867,
0.0908069462,
0.399969995,
0.1438425034,
-0.4330070019,
0.1536339372,
-0.437759608,
-0.0099240122,
-0.3916985691,
-0.4835973382,
-0.6842339039,
0.2698076963,
0.3711621761,
-0.4067050815,
0.3520755768,
0.3014372885,
-0.3439195454,
-0.0688428357,
-0.6652946472,
0.2815407515,
-0.4761408865,
0.7115923762,
-0.6715348363,
-0.9279028773,
0.4400251806,
-0.0364881493,
-0.2016156167,
0.5288490653,
0.8617260456,
-0.0736051947,
0.6119407415,
0.9940556884,
0.146589905,
0.5299167037,
-0.3280372918,
0.1586105227,
-0.3341273367,
-0.4778357446,
0.1323093027,
-0.0662416816,
-0.5945664048,
-0.5361350179,
0.8856599927,
-0.6361436844,
-0.0298180003,
0.154210031,
-0.1534070522,
0.318377912,
0.4841918945,
0.3659697175,
0.5643476844,
-0.0353301391,
0.2714536488,
0.303135097,
-0.4311881959,
-0.1743824482,
1.0686380863,
0.6795455813,
0.8113085032,
0.2960843742,
0.3120727539,
0.3685695231,
0.5450618863,
-0.6988024712,
0.1129494533,
0.1014618948,
-0.4240207076,
-0.2431225628,
-0.4885056615,
-0.8513716459,
0.2500505447,
-0.2647261918,
-0.4315773547,
0.1380209178,
0.5578639507,
-0.706700623,
-0.0889239982,
-0.6984960437,
0.9346107244,
-0.5807170272,
-0.1559495181,
-0.4093126357,
-0.6185014248,
0.6159104109,
-0.3168064058,
0.2882126868,
-0.0568493642,
-0.0747329891,
0.2794130743,
-0.251850605,
0.6245751977,
-0.0117017347,
-0.2631250322,
0.3297383785,
-0.3363805413,
0.4101541042,
0.2127082497,
0.3876258135,
0.1065929532,
0.124493517,
-0.1967388988,
-0.6376169324,
0.4447697997,
-0.8047440052,
-0.1800451726,
-0.8427316546,
-0.9440406561,
-0.451015681,
0.1767119318,
0.1847239882,
0.4974856973,
-0.1170996875,
-0.1924782842,
0.4417681992,
-0.3145998716,
0.4872100353,
0.3553159535,
-0.0081105931,
-0.3645220697,
1.1413192749,
0.2863598764,
0.2490880191,
0.324421972,
0.2417307496,
-0.5935708284,
-0.6340417266,
-0.27916044,
0.1946401447,
-0.7409628034,
-0.3411455154,
-0.7202018499,
-0.2161967754,
-0.1772036254,
0.3147746921,
-0.1522500813,
-0.1088123173,
0.2022209167,
-0.4558889866,
0.4143194556,
0.6970562935,
-0.0979375392,
0.417853713,
-0.6147862077,
0.2569283545,
0.5339655876,
0.3321613073,
-0.5672365427,
0.0437016822,
-0.0850853994,
-0.3259126544,
-0.3100766242,
-0.6742762923,
0.2012704313,
0.3093690872,
0.5551301241,
0.5757621527,
-0.3000767231,
0.5760321021,
-0.8345142603,
0.3508221507,
0.3771909475,
-0.6143057346,
0.1056166738,
-0.3754501045,
-0.1316748112,
0.4709529579,
0.4767028391,
-0.1701463163,
0.0213083439,
-0.5451619029,
-0.7053930759,
0.3748754859,
0.493440479,
0.1829214692,
0.3528620601,
0.0723572597,
-0.0349083357,
0.5064869523,
-1.1170793772,
0.1816951483,
-0.4788232446,
-0.1589281559,
0.0538618192,
-0.3728297353,
-0.2470140904,
0.1736653745,
0.4276068509,
-0.2468296289,
0.5008121133,
0.2472601235,
0.0276380852,
0.3311940432,
0.3196260631,
0.9984149337,
0.3964624703,
-0.0984100327,
0.2943424284,
-0.1590387076,
-0.5252369642,
0.2208179533,
0.7128423452,
0.108551763,
-0.4381744862,
0.3803499639,
1.0091768503,
0.1032083854,
-0.561847508,
1.0709878206,
-0.0704253167,
-0.5673439503,
-0.8820458651,
-0.0876596645,
-0.4320974648,
0.3812918067,
0.3058223724,
0.1763361692,
0.3754494488,
-0.6698018312,
0.4170925915,
0.4744927883,
-0.5159487128,
-0.3913221955,
0.6748821735,
0.2338447124,
0.0895290524,
0.7086006403,
-0.219640404,
-0.4386662245,
0.5088106394,
0.4215888679,
0.6668735743,
-0.0138380695,
0.1097305417,
-0.1446407288,
0.5230947137,
-0.0151853608,
0.4526593983,
0.0823683292,
-1.0128860474,
-0.7289098501,
-0.4662482738,
-0.1920515001,
0.1330630481,
-0.2567206323,
-0.0572104603,
-0.0975639299,
-0.0587537959,
-0.1223055869,
-0.6802681088,
-1.0993163586,
0.2961584628,
0.1491409987,
0.654697299,
-0.6616843939,
0.5748257637,
0.4144916832,
-0.8388694525,
-0.7648600936,
0.0773781091,
0.3044445217,
-1.1820651293,
0.8074410558,
0.6114606261,
-0.103374213,
0.2175057232,
-0.2193373442,
-0.7744957805,
1.3709868193,
0.039979931,
-0.4216652513,
-0.6154267192,
0.3523066938,
0.3041259646,
-0.2575460672,
0.293556869,
0.4594953954,
0.4602971673,
-0.0570421033,
-0.7955608964,
-0.1761403233,
-0.0871774256,
-0.1746540368,
0.1359741092,
-0.6515426636,
0.6424793601,
-0.2305906713,
-0.0679363161,
-0.0345446207,
0.7918742299,
-0.1248933077,
0.4777030349,
0.8380373716,
0.6554140449,
0.5489262342,
-0.2176398933,
1.6548246145,
0.041071374,
0.3932419419,
0.5453363061,
-0.3134053946,
0.1008596271,
0.3448448181,
-0.1216372252,
0.4059240222,
0.6644491553,
0.0064780135,
0.65728724,
0.3189581037,
-0.708545506,
-0.2058296502,
0.0296582021,
-0.0371845737,
0.8812862039,
0.4218082428,
-0.0790177211,
-0.1325755417,
0.7626920938,
-0.4100445807,
-0.628894031,
-0.5077896118,
0.6718696952,
0.1843640059,
-0.4903329313,
-0.4254450798,
-0.0870642662,
0.3981588185,
-1.1268135309,
-0.2284897715,
0.2994461656,
0.1335098743,
0.08176139,
-0.8058604002,
0.3435231447,
-0.3481492102,
-0.0361805856,
-0.5652643442,
0.8690026402,
-0.3027754724,
-0.3292476535,
-0.028714193,
0.3265579641,
0.2060884833,
-0.3284795284,
-0.4961248636,
-0.3022300899,
-0.2351917624,
-0.2473673224,
0.3241719604,
0.6497671604,
-0.2900133729,
0.9335603118,
0.5955146551,
0.0385635123,
-0.1036958843,
0.0240252111,
0.8539420962,
-0.8356865644,
-0.7392047048,
-0.9642950892,
0.8541648388,
-0.2118245065,
-0.4433176816,
0.5727761388,
0.2458776534,
0.5724945664,
-0.1099956557,
1.0094089508,
-0.0913387761,
-0.0540448874,
-0.907486856,
0.5095510483,
-0.7943140268,
-0.1003962532,
-0.2880036831,
-0.6375260353,
-0.4676361978,
0.5329579115,
-0.5261825323,
-0.123215802,
0.5875591636,
0.5593087077,
-0.0136407167,
-0.2383684814,
0.5154768825,
0.1265837997,
0.6020206809,
0.198948741,
1.0761332512,
-0.0423906818,
0.6608514786,
-0.0671380162,
-0.5873352289,
0.0495824739,
-1.096732378,
-0.6125977635,
-0.5218666196,
-0.1621165872,
-0.2078197449,
-0.0916173831,
0.6814237237,
0.5209651589,
-0.183145225,
0.2508624196,
0.0611488745,
-0.2441313118,
-0.2731806636,
-0.1362459213,
0.3470791876,
-0.2598777115,
-0.4828347266,
0.4475430548,
0.8621739745,
0.3042272925,
-0.4210447967,
0.2191347927,
0.1923878193,
-0.2256262004,
0.7118408084,
0.0565806329,
-0.5941864252,
-0.4464830458,
-0.3016123772,
-0.0308937784,
-0.0290729012,
0.9293778539,
-0.3863847256,
0.6052958369,
0.0532955714,
1.1056046486,
0.4936649799,
0.0600187033,
0.8215031028,
-0.4619854987,
0.4705954492,
0.1632582992,
0.6144112945,
0.1213530302,
-0.5974594355,
0.51274544,
0.2754212022,
-0.7260076404,
-0.5808983445,
0.6589383483,
-1.153205514,
0.0523503423,
0.8318462968,
0.0470516793,
-0.1474779248,
-0.195186466,
-0.330865562,
-0.0765252858,
-0.1544703543,
0.4880197048,
0.557884872,
-0.4577572644,
-0.6295395494,
-0.9110780954,
0.6490584016,
0.0278084986,
-1.0847408772,
-0.5176119208,
0.3732680678,
0.3369700015,
0.2216795832,
1.0365917683,
0.0724913478,
0.3628445268,
-0.0785004646,
0.2335677892,
-0.2882472277,
-0.2793068886,
-0.3285849392,
0.1792714447,
-0.096332103,
-0.2795547247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09682v1
|
Multi-News+: Cost-efficient Dataset Cleansing via LLM-based Data Annotation
| 2024-04-15T11:36:10 | 2024-04-15T11:36:10 |
Juhwan Choi, Jungmin Yun, Kyohoon Jin, YoungBin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The quality of the dataset is crucial for ensuring optimal performance and
reliability of downstream task models. However, datasets often contain noisy
data inadvertently included during the construction process. Numerous attempts
have been made to correct this issue through human annotators. However, hiring
and managing human annotators is expensive and time-consuming. As an
alternative, recent studies are exploring the use of large language models
(LLMs) for data annotation.
In this study, we present a case study that extends the application of
LLM-based data annotation to enhance the quality of existing datasets through a
cleansing strategy. Specifically, we leverage approaches such as
chain-of-thought (CoT) and majority voting to imitate human annotation and
classify unrelated documents from the Multi-News dataset, which is widely used
for the multi-document summarization task. Through our proposed cleansing
method, we introduce an enhanced Multi-News+. By employing LLMs for data
cleansing, we demonstrate an efficient and effective approach to improving
dataset quality without relying on expensive human annotation efforts.
|
[
-0.6128128767,
-0.5625470877,
0.4375951588,
-0.064092122,
-0.7133947015,
0.4605550468,
-0.2679186165,
-0.6047378778,
0.4019174874,
0.8520448804,
-0.6453140974,
-0.6006570458,
-0.5082325935,
0.091804862,
-0.5302106142,
1.2674062252,
-0.0699399933,
-0.1136677638,
-0.0740615278,
-0.2070583403,
-0.296197325,
-0.635281086,
-0.5124583244,
-0.3192642033,
0.626827538,
0.4315072894,
0.7560894489,
0.9612501264,
0.4529345334,
0.2214358896,
-0.1494439542,
0.7665216923,
-0.4388111234,
0.2094864249,
0.1320521832,
-0.4473745525,
-0.4599952102,
0.189526394,
0.5163658857,
0.8849235773,
-0.0315808281,
0.216042161,
0.1305485368,
0.8777766228,
-0.6487567425,
0.117683053,
-0.6631009579,
-0.1668679416,
-0.2741374671,
-0.1373125315,
-0.2263938487,
-0.5426831245,
-0.4282201529,
-0.6085601449,
0.3268277943,
-0.1032655537,
0.9479719996,
0.3116115928,
-0.5450828671,
-0.1674064845,
-0.6533150673,
0.7305955291,
-0.6961230636,
0.2794260979,
0.3525617123,
-0.036042247,
-0.180777669,
-0.3264731765,
-0.5372784734,
0.1622673869,
-0.2282338291,
0.1127666458,
0.2785587311,
-0.0543759577,
0.251070112,
0.3344460726,
-0.2417308837,
0.163086623,
-0.7570027113,
-0.2056050897,
0.7140290737,
0.0424141437,
-0.0456984714,
-0.1337011158,
-0.4486525357,
0.1969293058,
-0.968506217,
-0.2022884488,
0.5943436623,
0.6573150158,
0.2770094275,
0.6483150721,
-0.536511302,
0.7271924019,
-0.4003370106,
-0.4022024274,
0.584700942,
-0.5422173738,
-0.1122988835,
0.1705746055,
0.4424279928,
0.3873497844,
0.300737977,
0.0039050316,
-0.3495050669,
0.0993636474,
0.1052340642,
-0.5901849866,
-0.2437305748,
0.4111749828,
-0.5175877213,
-0.3961820602,
0.0611194409,
-0.6865296364,
-0.9179199934,
-0.7785543799,
0.0770457536,
-0.0208158661,
-0.3190728426,
0.0741477981,
-0.2342201918,
-0.0172707736,
0.8254775405,
-0.5012663007,
0.0061871279,
0.8091815114,
0.7554787397,
0.1142931953,
-0.0005946714,
-0.6541457176,
0.2881937325,
-0.3509502113,
0.9579553604,
-0.393111676,
-0.1931507587,
-0.2347572148,
-0.3952811658,
0.2521173954,
-0.6551364064,
0.6573780775,
-0.5742976069,
0.1700503975,
-0.2634239793,
-0.6664199233,
-0.4408755004,
0.4038885832,
-1.0762150288,
0.8588686585,
-0.0219677314,
-0.7565943599,
0.5834467411,
-0.5941767693,
-0.5740463734,
0.0054091853,
-0.0586663075,
-0.6046225429,
0.1208455637,
0.624081552,
0.5660467148,
-0.1119051799,
0.5359809995,
-0.4678515196,
-0.435198307,
-0.1003056094,
-0.570877254,
0.730738461,
0.2023848146,
-0.1286973208,
0.0380684584,
-0.847287178,
-0.3303117454,
-0.3530471921,
-0.5437046885,
-0.3353497088,
0.0683603212,
-0.1554859132,
0.4348102212,
0.1288479567,
-0.5754967928,
0.4412973821,
-0.1866838485,
0.0759398937,
0.6743219495,
0.2232072353,
0.1088924333,
-0.6823402643,
0.2785881758,
0.1159656122,
0.1033299193,
-0.3347789645,
-0.4375020564,
-0.7698665857,
-0.837492764,
0.2209542394,
0.3454935551,
-0.7185210586,
0.2562972903,
-0.4392023683,
-0.4962238669,
-0.8586099148,
0.4950138927,
0.0207961947,
0.398265928,
0.520313561,
-0.0160722733,
-0.5864741802,
-0.8018325567,
-0.3147498369,
0.0520950928,
0.0672927871,
-0.007125434,
0.2833594382,
-0.0936512947,
0.9547703862,
-0.5108752847,
-0.5199790597,
-0.2391312867,
0.3319337368,
0.413334161,
0.3010767698,
0.0573651977,
-0.9330211282,
-0.0567125753,
-0.3585308492,
-0.5355462432,
-0.1441688389,
-0.3324708641,
0.1037604511,
0.1887799799,
0.6201759577,
-0.4778245389,
0.5179695487,
0.4655968249,
-0.1107845381,
0.6535952091,
-0.0408858471,
0.4000937045,
-1.0531867743,
0.0502398908,
0.0891104862,
-0.4242781699,
-0.5049222112,
-0.0724993348,
0.0633319765,
-0.0391150191,
-0.5649558306,
0.3730540276,
-0.7038114667,
0.1195350438,
-0.4453872442,
0.4092432857,
0.3133684099,
0.5325787663,
0.0755499378,
0.5292387009,
0.2070536762,
-0.6257512569,
0.3662413359,
0.1437437981,
-0.3598156869,
0.3455156386,
-0.138226226,
-0.1415414065,
-0.5030623674,
0.4982813895,
-1.12806952,
0.0000967434,
0.1769847572,
0.0134985382,
0.1490574181,
-0.2041680068,
-1.0400550365,
0.0015949045,
-0.7351158261,
-0.0373768471,
0.0321286507,
-0.8827025294,
0.4722304344,
0.3889297843,
-0.2841715217,
-0.6001387835,
-0.7368369102,
0.4011723995,
-0.3099234402,
-0.321238935,
0.1491843462,
0.2289669216,
-0.2647068501,
-0.0344694555,
-0.1973580867,
-0.1519951075,
0.2066510171,
0.2030514777,
0.4643006027,
0.0649721324,
0.3369360268,
0.1963653564,
-0.2102089375,
-0.2324002087,
0.0830705464,
0.4032019079,
0.2724741399,
-0.4989306033,
-0.4840997756,
0.2234714478,
0.6498831511,
-0.5226595402,
0.7731303573,
0.6716285944,
-0.3845854998,
-0.0354308859,
-0.9029685259,
-0.1107476652,
-0.4367641509,
0.3370639682,
-0.2579618692,
-0.6958786845,
0.4666695595,
-0.387062043,
0.4587467015,
0.4679462016,
0.3228726685,
-0.2128204405,
0.7992734313,
0.1165445521,
-0.5106476545,
0.4889153242,
-0.2639130056,
0.1470574886,
-0.8519174457,
-0.1356084198,
-0.6323710084,
-0.3967966437,
-0.3464855552,
-0.3038698435,
0.0591382384,
0.2031493485,
-0.1153096855,
0.2453118712,
-0.4175617099,
0.4839147329,
0.6861851215,
0.3571796119,
0.8060258031,
-0.0024424125,
0.2333716601,
0.3180831671,
-0.4443193674,
-0.6106517911,
1.1987023354,
0.2339433581,
0.7504019737,
-0.0468449667,
0.9560793042,
0.1145806611,
0.6159789562,
-0.4095760882,
0.4039766192,
-0.2640168965,
-0.6248046756,
-0.3793454468,
-0.5661918521,
-0.7760371566,
0.5469983816,
-0.3342361152,
-0.6215093136,
0.2737975717,
-0.1492052078,
-0.3229669929,
0.7656123042,
-0.6439009309,
0.4239535034,
-0.1201326177,
-0.0600249246,
-0.3929444849,
-0.369825393,
0.5267369151,
-0.4309061766,
0.7165689468,
-0.47057423,
-0.2867999077,
0.6435671449,
-0.5527819991,
0.8626393676,
-0.3527742922,
-0.206514284,
0.2967844307,
-0.2917907834,
0.7624983788,
0.1290854961,
-0.2302428037,
0.1783322096,
-0.4294352233,
-0.2074449807,
-0.3898777366,
0.4275825918,
-0.5233200192,
-0.4465181231,
-0.1870267689,
-0.6591565609,
-0.2260911614,
0.0993067995,
-0.0725493282,
0.7030059099,
0.3581228852,
0.3173804879,
0.4303521812,
-0.1335265189,
0.5617158413,
0.3039239347,
-0.102850996,
-0.5940795541,
0.7616709471,
0.2418639809,
0.0958854705,
0.2975764573,
-0.0291448701,
-0.361066252,
-0.62912184,
-0.3030464053,
0.1675231308,
-0.70768857,
-0.4668629467,
-0.813354969,
0.0451986194,
-0.1213662624,
0.0140680913,
-0.3121191561,
-0.6370469332,
-0.459243685,
-0.2559434772,
0.431912601,
0.5168114305,
0.1073052362,
0.3605031669,
-0.9519383907,
0.7246743441,
0.0074677896,
0.4300797582,
-0.1063731238,
-0.2335196286,
-0.4334373772,
0.3675844967,
-0.1677222103,
-0.726105392,
0.2239944786,
0.1690395772,
0.5055749416,
0.3690437376,
0.258056581,
0.7244397402,
-0.0918059871,
0.5137785673,
-0.001999479,
-0.802448988,
0.3165896535,
-0.3093374968,
0.292626828,
0.9175184369,
0.0755661279,
-0.49683097,
-0.9116073251,
-0.5096764565,
-1.1284977198,
0.550219357,
0.0789799467,
-0.0940374807,
0.1482747048,
0.4469982684,
0.1852294952,
0.5294863582,
-0.5266755819,
-0.2718259096,
0.0744733959,
-0.2561899722,
-0.0983028337,
-0.1832552254,
0.0153427608,
-0.0487134382,
1.0765584707,
0.1160183102,
-0.2430492789,
0.0432001501,
-0.3260166943,
0.1303070635,
0.3589059114,
0.3678865731,
0.6244373322,
-0.0489464961,
0.0545809455,
0.094565548,
-0.4117981493,
0.3081170619,
0.1509980112,
-0.1758089513,
0.2000602186,
0.4851287007,
0.4054045975,
0.0544064939,
-0.5672250986,
0.4612941146,
0.0667979792,
-0.0679323003,
0.0356062092,
-0.0023642657,
0.2929742336,
0.1116795167,
0.568697989,
0.2159635872,
0.2612957358,
-0.3858721554,
0.3690439761,
0.1612797081,
-0.2789445519,
0.247980997,
0.5153487325,
0.2595767677,
0.2243789732,
0.7821750045,
-0.2384290695,
-0.449025631,
0.5018726587,
-0.1313183606,
0.5939548612,
0.0745511279,
0.1451030225,
0.1871279031,
0.3719910383,
-0.3316945732,
0.3984436691,
0.1477034837,
-0.7364810705,
-0.9440900087,
-0.3998353183,
-0.4513683021,
0.0629494861,
-0.6319652796,
0.4712871313,
-0.1930328012,
-0.1478818357,
0.1673166752,
0.3629723787,
-0.5735842586,
0.4727165699,
0.260602057,
0.753680408,
-0.7709801793,
0.7532947659,
0.4237990081,
-0.4546461701,
-0.6211536527,
-0.0828185603,
0.1686648428,
-0.4873054326,
0.3762209415,
0.4068762362,
0.0438754559,
-0.1797554791,
-0.2804260552,
-0.7034388781,
0.8330178261,
0.5308843255,
-0.820858717,
0.2923314571,
0.0533574894,
0.371062547,
-0.0380821042,
0.0758552477,
0.3887119591,
0.6685259938,
-0.1486291289,
-0.6439639926,
0.070717372,
-0.1997526139,
-0.4211427569,
0.4886947274,
-0.6177462935,
0.8805839419,
-0.3441782296,
-0.1535948813,
-0.2251420617,
0.5548452735,
0.4042911828,
0.287026614,
0.7487129569,
0.5575188994,
1.1185690165,
-0.115825139,
0.7979649305,
-0.3470454216,
0.4086630642,
1.4098672867,
-0.4370783567,
0.6519287229,
0.4710617959,
-0.0340442099,
0.3280085325,
0.4841428101,
-0.3417468071,
0.4755372405,
0.4313414991,
-0.3858836889,
-0.1125926152,
-0.2222248912,
-0.1884166747,
0.4520753324,
0.0619797781,
-0.2788326144,
-0.5016765594,
0.1052562371,
0.2438008785,
-0.0304745045,
-0.4159023464,
1.0343953371,
-0.1651007682,
-0.3736508191,
0.1741713881,
0.003542718,
0.7507936954,
-0.329175055,
0.006815637,
-0.1159557253,
0.1681103408,
-0.4312095046,
-0.7987346649,
0.5094267726,
-0.0049812882,
-0.1905096918,
-0.3658307791,
0.6610739231,
-0.7720630765,
-0.5844052434,
0.1965374947,
0.6985806227,
0.181594342,
-0.6630413532,
-0.4157542884,
0.0386523083,
-0.0442601256,
-0.4209286869,
0.0846656039,
0.3315572441,
-0.0500990488,
0.6929297447,
0.8997394443,
0.4001484513,
-0.2636982203,
0.4219451249,
1.0472352505,
-0.6315561533,
-0.4257062376,
-0.9772216082,
0.5508511066,
-0.24894391,
-0.0734574497,
0.592138648,
1.0454769135,
0.7456201911,
0.27700302,
1.0312398672,
0.4158868194,
0.7770484686,
-0.4217496216,
0.8472675085,
-0.4488368332,
0.4645356238,
-0.3771017492,
-0.9484639168,
-0.5510644913,
0.1793271452,
-0.0812085196,
0.0519012213,
0.4277537465,
0.8790314794,
0.0917822048,
0.3565569222,
0.0550605804,
-0.0510016717,
0.5675936341,
0.2175266445,
0.7635831833,
-0.2653918862,
0.7230252624,
-0.3809260726,
-0.1293378323,
0.0272339303,
-0.9112467766,
-0.7738513947,
-0.2770416737,
-0.5869227052,
-0.2308388948,
0.1048548222,
1.0176887512,
0.6640928984,
-0.8625094891,
0.011435532,
0.2263662666,
0.2669728696,
-0.458555907,
-0.1594378501,
0.6628068686,
-0.3698739111,
-0.4970519841,
0.3169847429,
0.1738793254,
-0.2013347745,
-0.1479429603,
0.3146936297,
-0.3998289108,
-0.159312278,
0.4866559505,
-0.2901048362,
-0.4477438033,
-0.0993041396,
-0.4934269786,
-0.1873071492,
0.2968484759,
0.7241733074,
-0.8446403146,
0.3798903823,
0.3352613151,
0.5534533858,
0.532820642,
0.4795668721,
0.390116781,
-1.0307818651,
-0.0073522031,
0.0998847634,
0.5371451378,
0.5718764663,
-0.5628080964,
0.6042950153,
0.1568881869,
-0.158475399,
-0.7620860934,
-0.1696109325,
-0.6224512458,
-0.5118260384,
1.1664253473,
-0.0224004053,
0.0722379237,
-0.4801259935,
-0.4026159644,
0.4703068435,
-0.5828055143,
0.8148347735,
0.7050791383,
0.0152724134,
-0.082848303,
-0.5077278614,
0.2619999349,
-0.1425442696,
-1.1890138388,
0.4590735734,
0.6070961356,
0.0178891607,
-0.0471430421,
0.5723085403,
-0.1280910671,
-0.0094321761,
-0.169052124,
0.2831395268,
-0.5937664509,
-0.364954859,
-0.2661170661,
0.355684042,
-0.2905624211,
-0.3824521005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13074v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13074v1
|
Towards Compositionally Generalizable Semantic Parsing in Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-04-15T10:44:58 | 2024-04-15T10:44:58 |
Amogh Mannekote
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Compositional generalization is the ability of a model to generalize to
complex, previously unseen types of combinations of entities from just having
seen the primitives. This type of generalization is particularly relevant to
the semantic parsing community for applications such as task-oriented dialogue,
text-to-SQL parsing, and information retrieval, as they can harbor infinite
complexity. Despite the success of large language models (LLMs) in a wide range
of NLP tasks, unlocking perfect compositional generalization still remains one
of the few last unsolved frontiers. The past few years has seen a surge of
interest in works that explore the limitations of, methods to improve, and
evaluation metrics for compositional generalization capabilities of LLMs for
semantic parsing tasks. In this work, we present a literature survey geared at
synthesizing recent advances in analysis, methods, and evaluation schemes to
offer a starting point for both practitioners and researchers in this area.
|
[
-0.2488619536,
-0.8292396069,
0.9166750312,
0.5033381581,
-0.1159539148,
0.048527889,
-0.4941542149,
-0.4106445909,
0.136599496,
0.5858703852,
-0.495724082,
-0.9237551689,
-0.6417533755,
0.0137829827,
-0.5498507023,
0.8067681193,
0.1137657985,
0.1708161831,
-0.5574601889,
-0.1314999461,
-0.6541912556,
-0.6241054535,
-0.3831138015,
-0.1917064786,
0.4264913201,
-0.0807069764,
0.4057370126,
0.3261137605,
0.4766470194,
0.3544748127,
-0.3602320254,
0.1215201393,
-0.4086026251,
0.4643422365,
-0.5333835483,
-0.5842624903,
-0.5011211038,
-0.2489663512,
0.9931462407,
1.2660136223,
-0.0170317423,
0.0678379759,
0.0485677868,
0.6202864647,
-0.8153403997,
0.3312931955,
-0.8954795003,
0.1938317865,
-0.07793957,
0.0837077126,
-0.4241746366,
0.0299361721,
0.3585827649,
-0.4425332844,
0.1441620737,
-0.0513997115,
0.2645005584,
-0.0342887975,
-0.3477736712,
-0.5809575319,
-0.8762732148,
1.2059174776,
-0.700611949,
0.3774765432,
0.1082422286,
0.4032582641,
-0.1987197697,
-0.8945548534,
-0.3534680307,
-0.4385419488,
0.0086576734,
0.0810028464,
-0.1537022144,
0.241430521,
0.0612051301,
0.7645768523,
-0.5027495623,
0.0776561126,
0.288790524,
-0.0317371264,
0.5120869279,
0.5699503422,
0.5381262302,
-0.0272176079,
-0.2009508461,
0.1526992768,
-0.3984470069,
-0.0489965715,
0.2117196769,
0.0502988286,
0.0526288971,
0.7279055715,
-0.5672964454,
1.1776931286,
-0.272490412,
-0.0014515724,
-0.0946199894,
-0.6596699357,
-0.1990683377,
-0.4075190127,
0.7088577747,
0.2400636077,
-0.0029393393,
-0.4794132411,
-0.338473469,
0.0639798641,
0.0421871245,
-0.590854764,
-0.063208364,
0.279110074,
-0.4938953221,
-0.1856486797,
0.1300345957,
-0.6367768049,
-0.1308377683,
-0.6253993511,
0.068645522,
-0.1919008493,
-0.2877500355,
0.5188667178,
-0.0682501271,
0.5991926789,
0.2731169164,
-1.1445878744,
0.3933243752,
1.1365491152,
0.7935340405,
-0.323238641,
-0.3336203098,
-0.196841374,
0.4001353085,
-0.2221595645,
0.715995729,
-0.8842337728,
-0.4036224484,
0.1312423944,
-0.0965613052,
-0.4290880561,
-0.7242830992,
0.6800047159,
-0.5915336609,
0.1389052421,
-0.2658230066,
-0.8384332657,
0.0063032228,
0.6406028271,
-0.543479681,
0.675293684,
0.1826769561,
-0.6707693934,
0.1690381169,
-0.4921104312,
-0.1992374659,
-0.1025377735,
-0.2914946377,
-0.0410787202,
0.3945242167,
0.11002969,
0.596788764,
-0.5641868711,
0.6211272478,
-0.2072613835,
-0.0984815657,
0.3038045466,
-0.1654459685,
0.5173078179,
0.1448205113,
-0.1774888188,
0.2727405131,
-0.8512064815,
0.1297812015,
0.2164843976,
-0.3613365293,
-0.4177999496,
0.1379811019,
-0.1442247629,
-0.0121939275,
0.4992642999,
-0.643392086,
0.1850522757,
-0.5833383799,
0.3802464902,
0.3842732608,
-0.1295770854,
0.4670904875,
-0.1813315302,
0.383816123,
-0.0563865975,
0.0440195985,
-0.3228764832,
-0.3192778528,
-0.8530384898,
-0.2398041636,
0.4886652529,
0.4151931107,
-0.4702273309,
0.8708062172,
-0.4679984748,
-0.424618423,
-0.1363283247,
0.1942775846,
0.3854758739,
0.2785185575,
0.2428629547,
-0.206921652,
-0.4231008589,
-1.025011301,
-0.4311111569,
0.0996404737,
-0.3027663529,
0.1236086637,
0.2591280341,
-0.4489777982,
1.1323356628,
-0.6977262497,
-0.3152325153,
-0.4681864679,
-0.1185873821,
0.1806793511,
0.4874379337,
0.4083914757,
-0.5828671455,
-0.4319730401,
0.1651557684,
-0.7902582884,
-0.0202337634,
0.2718747556,
-0.1832599342,
-0.1657181531,
0.5984752774,
-0.6920048594,
-0.0330754519,
0.5496442318,
-0.2654897273,
0.5022025108,
-0.0154134724,
-0.2412731051,
-0.9438863993,
0.2328405678,
-0.2152507305,
-0.1840570867,
-0.7338860035,
0.4144798517,
-0.1844926924,
-0.0729054883,
-0.145662412,
0.3617404699,
-0.3469911814,
-0.0968656912,
-0.2421967983,
-0.0177801698,
0.0589336567,
0.2636627257,
0.0783992037,
0.3151890635,
0.6083207726,
-0.4557314813,
0.4169341326,
0.0912164748,
-0.3131937981,
0.4556109011,
-0.7784470916,
-0.0507590175,
-0.3449059129,
0.3581543565,
-1.1330075264,
-0.3489603698,
0.0485226363,
-0.1025948152,
0.1786231846,
-0.1470388472,
-0.4540453255,
0.0031714151,
-0.2266543806,
0.7745325565,
0.0607669018,
-0.1885607094,
0.9206367135,
0.268119961,
-0.1318551004,
-0.3939054608,
-0.6223217249,
0.1643453687,
-0.0625598058,
-0.86675632,
0.4098847806,
-0.062278796,
-0.3990835249,
-0.1524575353,
-0.0525582284,
-0.1546301395,
0.0771627128,
-0.1454497576,
0.1027876064,
-0.3630396128,
0.0695128366,
0.0316193141,
-0.1150353178,
0.170459494,
-0.3548265994,
0.9493194818,
-0.3980229795,
-0.5241529346,
-0.092777878,
0.6112391353,
0.3942066729,
-0.4566419423,
0.65058887,
0.4695293605,
-0.2560826838,
-0.2594996095,
-0.7295574546,
0.2128521502,
-0.4001435637,
0.3980875313,
-0.3112369776,
-1.2085369825,
0.6329627037,
-0.1804034114,
-0.04146754,
0.7197890282,
0.5260629058,
0.2005403787,
0.8161100149,
0.4641650617,
-0.0105453944,
0.2834946513,
-0.3949481845,
0.1258106679,
-0.8183960915,
-0.3465700448,
-0.5641222,
-0.0088852709,
-0.455478847,
-0.4642080367,
0.2006513178,
-0.1766667366,
0.1108536124,
-0.050117258,
-0.3597630858,
0.8370764852,
0.2402553558,
-0.0645154864,
0.6391260028,
-0.1510022134,
-0.1450127065,
0.0267666876,
-0.3812042475,
-0.446672976,
1.0186092854,
0.3820623457,
0.4870711863,
0.2315352261,
0.6324217319,
0.2629005611,
-0.0972888246,
-1.14532125,
0.7606672645,
-0.393646121,
-0.4498021305,
-0.4393684864,
-0.3038781583,
-1.1349223852,
0.6293708682,
-0.0617138073,
-0.6061111689,
0.0993167087,
-0.0594892427,
0.0055439323,
0.1835304648,
-0.5242817402,
0.9789524674,
-0.019012887,
-0.019979259,
-0.150683105,
-0.7124815583,
0.5035967827,
-0.0836078301,
0.0448810942,
-0.194272086,
-0.2861485481,
0.4890302122,
-0.1960574985,
0.82989645,
-0.13722381,
-0.365827024,
0.2804175913,
0.0395378843,
0.3674975336,
-0.2065953612,
0.1037693769,
0.0139186541,
0.143540889,
-0.5493489504,
-0.6981123686,
0.7697428465,
-0.4430118501,
-0.4875331223,
-0.1754296869,
-0.5247536898,
-0.6420951486,
0.1815798134,
0.0668331906,
0.4219711423,
-0.4764556885,
0.3482566476,
0.8758730888,
-0.1000215709,
0.3644292951,
0.2840615511,
-0.3529913723,
-0.358062923,
0.9717079997,
-0.0854329392,
0.3205203414,
0.636548996,
0.3278402388,
-0.2316132933,
-0.8717737794,
-0.1809288412,
0.2971149981,
-0.7018548846,
0.0439541601,
-0.8961988688,
-0.1127598956,
-0.3083056211,
-0.0176003706,
-0.4092594385,
-0.5650847554,
-0.3958904445,
0.1219455898,
-0.4697521627,
0.768250823,
0.4661642611,
0.3837132156,
-0.6487287283,
0.2030195743,
0.5426331758,
0.3971703947,
0.2707313299,
-0.1572808474,
-0.0722720027,
-0.2388151586,
-0.2933511734,
-0.5290687084,
-0.0269235428,
0.2361764461,
0.6316125989,
0.3030035198,
-0.2375202775,
0.5016925335,
-0.3673416078,
1.0028190613,
0.3640903234,
-1.1086679697,
0.4638842344,
-0.7385678291,
0.3561723232,
0.6711773276,
0.2338373661,
-0.6421917081,
-0.3360804021,
-0.3386453986,
-0.9735640883,
0.2813761532,
0.0875558779,
0.4845660329,
-0.061555136,
0.1561633199,
0.1968417168,
0.2801392376,
-0.7517952919,
0.0393825844,
0.0991057679,
-0.2757260203,
0.0496645011,
-0.58420223,
-0.0528112948,
-0.3178797364,
0.3736768067,
-0.0746974424,
0.0447462685,
0.0575456582,
-0.3545097113,
0.4117177427,
0.6484822035,
0.5507504344,
1.0095953941,
0.0098801591,
0.1725722551,
0.0219267048,
-0.1853415668,
0.1378674507,
-0.0112578869,
-0.2410054952,
-0.103870146,
0.5318363905,
0.541590929,
0.3236660063,
-0.9037766457,
0.8145669699,
-0.0728941783,
-0.1392728388,
-0.3576905131,
0.1661885977,
0.1672654152,
0.1540121883,
0.0666162372,
-0.3933061361,
0.4501102865,
-0.6318233013,
-0.2117043585,
0.6324117184,
-0.1450344026,
-0.3138715029,
0.298161149,
0.0243042074,
0.2526216805,
0.3977475166,
0.0718411058,
-0.2263462543,
0.3158507645,
0.6428813934,
1.0548708439,
-0.2139626145,
0.0731631517,
0.0259799846,
0.0570111237,
0.0288215224,
0.0393304564,
-0.236664325,
-0.7232763171,
-0.6044546366,
-0.9573224783,
-0.4151934087,
0.0518595912,
-0.5478906035,
-0.0567103438,
-0.4631316662,
-0.1280746013,
0.1131721511,
-0.3038561046,
-0.4445565641,
0.0331533216,
-0.020877406,
0.6973973513,
-0.7856408954,
0.3755142093,
0.8957087398,
-0.0794037282,
-0.3505981863,
-0.0356773995,
-0.4851125777,
-0.5559130907,
0.4105138183,
0.0594650432,
0.0315863863,
-0.1333066821,
-0.5472447872,
-0.7244133949,
0.8709723949,
0.4571518302,
-0.3055530488,
-0.358595103,
0.7018432617,
0.8333082199,
-0.5027732253,
-0.0147272721,
0.9935267568,
0.4574245214,
0.1194292903,
-0.7939833999,
-0.1100687459,
-0.2074846923,
0.5377448797,
0.1848489791,
-0.6362476349,
0.752820015,
0.49873963,
-0.0104111992,
0.346421808,
0.6321219206,
0.0342738032,
0.3867358863,
0.3701630235,
0.89526546,
0.5105425715,
-0.1000177264,
0.9884679317,
-0.1546405405,
0.3980275691,
1.2169573307,
-0.1243751198,
0.5641397834,
0.3305507004,
-0.342112124,
0.4071429372,
0.2096405327,
0.0241132509,
0.2330659926,
0.5047464371,
-0.7129867077,
-0.3837221861,
-0.3904429376,
-0.2845125496,
0.7644987106,
0.4940034151,
-0.6193174124,
-0.5062940717,
-0.0171861276,
-0.0874952599,
0.2390874624,
-0.3668572605,
1.2098044157,
-0.0480002984,
-0.6724509001,
0.41239205,
0.1860782802,
0.5193416476,
-0.7721163034,
0.1193787456,
0.0575389676,
-0.1360495389,
-0.2685921192,
-0.7200536728,
0.5029558539,
-0.1658566743,
-0.3852635026,
0.0617782474,
0.9468572736,
-0.4750760794,
-0.3816112578,
0.3256916106,
0.6691179276,
-0.0718587488,
-0.2694210112,
-0.4012832046,
0.2289478332,
-0.1224172115,
-0.1255263984,
0.447652936,
0.3747817278,
0.1362240165,
0.4769775271,
0.5163303614,
-0.0834360793,
0.324316293,
0.0905004963,
1.1129965782,
-0.8701235056,
-0.366813004,
-0.95024544,
0.4526584446,
0.0225275923,
-0.0576801561,
0.6210128069,
0.7485954762,
0.9009922743,
-0.3959499896,
0.7030661702,
0.0328654535,
0.4029041231,
-0.6584943533,
0.2689958811,
-0.3585572839,
0.2134235501,
-0.3179232776,
-1.3292620182,
-0.5601488352,
0.1511043161,
-0.4236856997,
-0.0531804189,
0.5508015156,
0.6042659879,
-0.2346553952,
0.1969981194,
0.6149014235,
-0.0628632829,
0.3560862839,
0.3364361823,
1.1971997023,
0.0506801531,
0.1824977547,
-0.1150311753,
-0.1535967886,
-0.0058730068,
-0.7593655586,
-0.7595841885,
-0.5485300422,
0.0557791479,
-0.1318366677,
-0.1662927568,
0.8254874945,
0.2903701365,
-0.7971845865,
-0.2997480929,
-0.2642546296,
-0.0511451997,
0.3130402267,
-0.2091255337,
0.2386457026,
-0.7015411258,
-0.8290146589,
0.3449667394,
0.3052870333,
-0.0200068727,
-0.328900069,
0.2505117655,
0.0158889592,
0.1087920591,
1.1759607792,
0.1180357784,
-0.7925511003,
-0.0103687989,
-0.2137917429,
0.1297013909,
-0.0275644455,
1.0071817636,
-0.263849169,
0.4604389668,
0.5925998688,
1.0723543167,
0.3428288698,
-0.0363015905,
0.3557497263,
-0.722086966,
-0.0750983134,
0.4255871475,
0.4827727079,
0.2270047069,
-0.0197166167,
0.5780819058,
0.3198761046,
-0.6074727774,
-0.5269105434,
0.5064601898,
-1.4162997007,
-0.278670758,
1.129873991,
-0.1689804494,
-0.1623263061,
0.0144410683,
-0.196027264,
-0.1767497808,
-0.0308574978,
0.4102219343,
0.8563941121,
-0.0495420732,
0.3425389528,
-0.2625541091,
0.1118094325,
0.5749410987,
-0.9707376957,
0.2411008179,
0.8281196356,
0.3466269672,
0.0694920346,
0.5191482306,
-0.3987056911,
-0.0134372236,
-0.3463121057,
-0.2514717579,
0.1964644641,
-0.2365250736,
-0.5071582794,
0.4318549037,
0.3785831928,
0.2267912924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09656v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09656v2
|
Learn Your Reference Model for Real Good Alignment
| 2024-04-15T10:44:31 | 2024-05-21T15:04:12 |
Alexey Gorbatovski, Boris Shaposhnikov, Alexey Malakhov, Nikita Surnachev, Yaroslav Aksenov, Ian Maksimov, Nikita Balagansky, Daniil Gavrilov
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
The complexity of the alignment problem stems from the fact that existing
methods are considered unstable. Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback
(RLHF) addresses this issue by minimizing the KL divergence between the trained
policy and the initial supervised fine-tuned policy (SFT) to avoid generating
out-of-domain samples for the reward model (RM). Recently, many methods have
emerged that shift from online to offline optimization, reformulating the RLHF
objective and removing the reward model (DPO, IPO, KTO). Despite eliminating
the reward model and the challenges it posed, these algorithms are still
constrained in terms of closeness of the trained policy to the SFT one. In our
paper, we argue that this implicit limitation in the offline optimization
methods leads to suboptimal results. To address this issue, we propose a class
of new methods called Trust Region (TR-DPO, TR-IPO, TR-KTO), which update the
reference policy during training. With this straightforward update approach, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of the new paradigm of language model alignment
against the classical one on the Anthropic-HH and Reddit TL;DR datasets. Most
notably, when automatically comparing TR methods and baselines side by side
using pretrained Pythia 6.9B models on the Reddit TL;DR task, the difference in
win rates reaches 8.4% for DPO, 14.3% for IPO, and 15% for KTO. Finally, by
assessing model response ratings grounded on criteria such as coherence,
correctness, helpfulness, and harmlessness, we demonstrate that our proposed
methods significantly outperform existing techniques.
|
[
-0.3596463501,
-0.4513542354,
0.5305140018,
-0.3741233051,
-0.2590417564,
0.2417761683,
-0.3565624356,
-0.6523875594,
0.0126626948,
0.1952082366,
-0.8419550061,
-0.2794753611,
-0.4118113518,
-0.0388945229,
0.0651419163,
1.1350694895,
-0.2544600666,
0.1678572148,
-0.2024860382,
-0.3183046281,
-0.2938026786,
-0.5118221045,
-0.3836026788,
-0.6809165478,
0.4641897678,
0.5822440386,
0.9837959409,
0.9220868349,
0.7936344147,
0.1856139153,
-0.0652837828,
0.2808858454,
-0.7220447063,
-0.0584593117,
-0.3203124404,
-0.4406011105,
-0.3139903545,
0.2662192285,
0.371601969,
0.241604805,
-0.630114913,
0.0173767861,
-0.2037528455,
0.7285782695,
-0.7271316648,
-0.0829714537,
-0.5541359782,
0.1816612184,
0.1608184725,
-0.0676421672,
-0.4516880214,
-0.7476396561,
0.505549252,
-0.8519569635,
0.1158239543,
0.3368721902,
1.3443650007,
0.5045593977,
-0.1426601708,
-0.2622606456,
-0.8806201816,
0.9544094205,
-0.6978415847,
0.6091644764,
0.4912216067,
0.4807174206,
-0.2646602094,
-0.4696654081,
-0.6416224837,
-0.4746158421,
-0.0540164188,
0.11628557,
-0.051293727,
0.0008871427,
0.0372496061,
0.1196706668,
-0.2847532034,
0.1416526735,
-0.2090834379,
-0.3402530551,
0.5532783866,
-0.1795362085,
0.0865788683,
0.1635325551,
-0.5324493647,
-0.5599691272,
-0.7881496549,
0.0465179943,
0.4249956012,
0.2476376444,
-0.1644665599,
0.2814936638,
0.0070717479,
0.6902905107,
0.4661020339,
-0.4983966649,
0.0195512213,
-0.3432630897,
0.0663107187,
0.0866207331,
0.630302012,
0.1982220262,
0.3123623729,
-0.3745837808,
-0.2049082667,
-0.0697622448,
0.4625590444,
-0.2579535842,
-0.0767603591,
-0.0396709144,
-0.3392688632,
-0.3424483538,
0.236795634,
-0.4255238771,
-0.2889692485,
-0.473652482,
0.2481292188,
-0.2913945019,
-0.0746146291,
-0.2063477635,
0.253882885,
0.2788830698,
0.3363738358,
-0.7299253345,
0.1913027167,
0.7195254564,
0.6063799262,
-0.1273943633,
-0.3847907186,
-0.5606533289,
-0.0719934925,
-0.4398573637,
0.5891392231,
-0.439809829,
-0.118871145,
0.0470212214,
-0.131107673,
-0.0122146662,
-0.6126846075,
0.5521538854,
-0.7596030235,
0.4803516865,
-0.3587538898,
-0.545846045,
-0.1507166773,
0.329328537,
-0.7348723412,
0.9511271715,
0.2075805664,
-0.71811831,
0.3961679339,
-0.5510526896,
-0.1313531995,
-0.5535997748,
0.0970450565,
-0.8760789633,
-0.1529080272,
0.1747673005,
0.07323993,
-0.2469352931,
0.3974650204,
-0.6018763185,
-0.5084794164,
0.3556047678,
0.1142063513,
0.352799505,
0.3300018609,
-0.4634100199,
0.3115411699,
-0.6229460239,
0.2147680372,
-0.0408556461,
-0.2397579104,
-0.3996614516,
0.0036646966,
-0.2442918867,
0.488222748,
0.154638499,
-0.464574337,
0.1864764839,
-0.4453475475,
0.5171329975,
0.7840946913,
-0.0440242551,
0.5728132725,
-0.3614511192,
0.6957995892,
-0.027869679,
0.1844653785,
0.4119421244,
-0.0876759067,
-0.6761397123,
-0.1266548485,
0.720546186,
0.430973351,
-0.673225522,
0.4907349348,
-0.4493100941,
-0.520593822,
-0.9311208129,
-0.0765125602,
0.8098402023,
0.6895648837,
0.5106273293,
-0.3324820399,
-0.4252441227,
-0.9057956934,
-0.2361473292,
-0.3871328831,
0.3312272131,
0.1940158606,
0.508688271,
-0.0301738307,
1.1290063858,
-0.2462198585,
-0.2769663632,
-0.03170022,
0.2695351541,
-0.2033797055,
0.5071257353,
0.2128284574,
-0.6969689131,
-0.5856190324,
0.1106517985,
-0.4870012403,
0.0226106886,
-0.1509291977,
-0.1738072187,
0.2780299783,
0.3038095832,
-0.3688942492,
0.130644843,
0.620960772,
-0.2166434228,
0.3920090497,
-0.2153740227,
0.1754554808,
-1.0371985435,
0.1448305249,
0.0684489831,
-0.560093224,
-0.3487718105,
0.3198472559,
0.0459257923,
0.0421919934,
-0.5136104822,
0.3939240873,
-0.4073545635,
-0.1237712875,
-0.1497728527,
0.3233686686,
-0.185635671,
0.7005372047,
0.2456649542,
0.7799252272,
-0.0541195087,
-0.5502770543,
0.2889166176,
0.3808219135,
-0.2493318021,
0.4380016029,
-0.5470147729,
0.2856889963,
-0.0542444177,
0.5296533108,
-0.5469557047,
-0.1851729453,
0.4817827344,
-0.3375590146,
0.4326573014,
0.0950223505,
-0.1326075196,
-0.2337255329,
-0.2246177346,
0.3796544373,
0.4469749928,
-0.6933776736,
0.3015919626,
0.3430171013,
0.2978572249,
-0.9565699697,
-0.4126519561,
-0.2949870527,
-0.3071142733,
-0.3066187799,
0.540201962,
0.1467673779,
-0.2128435075,
0.1794585735,
-0.2819875777,
-0.2336768955,
0.1073544994,
-0.0418162234,
0.2875882685,
-0.0039122566,
-0.0045891292,
-0.2549960315,
-0.2324763387,
-0.262704432,
-0.2257687002,
0.2048133463,
-0.1546754092,
-0.3434488475,
-0.8817240596,
-0.0469675809,
0.436307162,
-0.2831460834,
0.6414882541,
0.4567661881,
-0.1869364828,
-0.0053620832,
-0.3604775071,
-0.4713839591,
-0.3692570627,
0.4303542972,
-0.1665010303,
-0.9832302332,
0.3523904979,
-0.0178780891,
0.0143654738,
0.0775279254,
0.4013901353,
-0.1440146416,
0.9385972619,
0.83815974,
-0.2032479495,
0.6546420455,
0.0260996744,
0.3395286202,
-0.6662154794,
-0.0880519003,
-0.5553312302,
-0.3584869206,
-0.7414831519,
-0.3104333878,
0.2243343443,
0.3092238009,
-0.3490285575,
0.5561602712,
-0.4521137178,
0.4069756866,
0.7073531747,
0.4344011545,
0.2780509293,
-0.041160278,
-0.2964918613,
-0.4666011631,
-0.8814359307,
-0.3826995194,
0.9736869335,
0.582152307,
0.9536685944,
0.1097088158,
0.7787285447,
0.3206719458,
0.4562604427,
-0.7231832147,
0.1472402066,
0.3019309044,
-0.4496861696,
-0.331523329,
-0.5141841769,
-0.6368271708,
0.1476355791,
-0.4468213022,
-0.553673923,
0.1910872012,
0.6603586674,
-0.5602068305,
0.2272416651,
-0.5493622422,
0.8114620447,
-0.183651194,
-0.517950058,
-0.2340836078,
-0.979731977,
0.4217314124,
-0.0178278964,
0.1362328827,
0.1359387636,
0.1906888932,
0.6831498742,
-0.5619310737,
0.5961039662,
-0.0526184626,
-0.0992979258,
0.3896059394,
0.0267684236,
0.8858009577,
-0.234873414,
0.1259862781,
-0.1597900242,
0.0548622236,
-0.3229610026,
-0.7130461335,
0.5784246325,
-0.9992936254,
-0.3023333251,
-0.6301063299,
-0.4336154461,
-0.4460525811,
0.0719096363,
0.2034039497,
0.0482840613,
-0.2594263256,
0.1023682505,
0.7293137312,
-0.0021346656,
0.1512417197,
0.5159009099,
0.1107229218,
-0.5330013633,
0.8599409461,
-0.2631288171,
0.5289797783,
0.5863546729,
0.3276148736,
-0.6000494957,
-0.2181558758,
-0.3037164509,
0.3871941566,
-0.7246118784,
-0.2314697802,
-0.0881686285,
0.126127407,
-0.307733953,
-0.0627402216,
-0.6799740791,
-0.3901954293,
-0.1330159754,
-0.0119538922,
0.019690169,
0.5898752213,
-0.1282449663,
0.4395212531,
-0.8033610582,
-0.0388050228,
0.1775352359,
0.3148480654,
-0.0772570148,
-0.5139952898,
-0.4709016979,
0.2604339123,
-0.4868535697,
-0.7126495242,
0.1540632993,
0.1484631896,
0.4617822766,
0.2826696932,
0.2505988479,
0.9297100902,
-0.2828619182,
0.4115679562,
0.2511229217,
-0.8202832341,
0.2221533358,
-0.1863617301,
0.135202229,
0.7613201141,
0.5976852775,
-0.5586713552,
-0.2009884715,
-0.7723165154,
-0.4814040661,
0.7604393363,
0.0372346751,
-0.4452824891,
0.4008991122,
0.6669169068,
-0.0971280113,
0.2560872138,
-0.9637237787,
-0.0771108419,
-0.151249513,
-0.348015219,
0.2899205387,
-0.057238251,
-0.3373447061,
-0.0061429744,
1.0829414129,
-0.2984508872,
0.2964556217,
0.3912852108,
-0.0722492039,
-0.5778010488,
0.322291702,
0.8571863174,
0.9302152991,
-0.2359206825,
-0.1233903542,
0.007793156,
-0.1994668841,
0.2366441935,
-0.2274771035,
-0.3348630071,
-0.2504501939,
0.4694628417,
0.9400245547,
0.2801913023,
-0.5260418057,
0.4265420437,
-0.0640703887,
-0.2284518629,
-0.1207056195,
0.0301405881,
-0.1204738319,
0.0937983841,
-0.0856221989,
0.1352226883,
-0.2949073613,
-0.5095308423,
0.3707844913,
0.3872180581,
-0.9887005091,
-0.365137428,
0.6595786214,
0.1340918392,
-0.1822265089,
0.6255666018,
-0.2115050107,
-0.8124380112,
0.3413368762,
0.5542419553,
0.6190000772,
-0.1044535339,
0.3249333501,
0.5498303771,
0.2949160635,
-0.4594535828,
-0.0491659343,
0.0402058437,
-0.8553543091,
-0.3969378471,
-0.3641395271,
-0.670247972,
0.0677466467,
-0.8774932623,
0.1810140908,
-0.3896288574,
-0.2092685699,
-0.4053323567,
0.0471883044,
-0.3555867076,
0.2457319498,
-0.0915336832,
0.5698795319,
-0.7475760579,
1.0430772305,
0.8540996909,
-0.4148739576,
-1.0271310806,
0.1995456368,
0.0622910261,
-0.7973031998,
0.4944606721,
-0.3080803156,
-0.1751433462,
0.0425070822,
-0.6173192859,
-1.0340870619,
1.0711160898,
0.3607372642,
-0.7811715007,
-0.3554334939,
-0.0867034644,
0.6174556613,
-0.3797209263,
0.1246801093,
0.4965478182,
0.5103065968,
0.0584942698,
-1.098310709,
0.0172104891,
0.2785381079,
0.0819915459,
0.3692448735,
-0.7494436502,
0.4404704571,
-0.4351739883,
-0.1790432334,
0.075781554,
0.7905508876,
0.3826571405,
-0.0766396299,
0.6419597864,
0.828214705,
0.7500769496,
-0.204208374,
1.0163836479,
-0.277720809,
0.7702688575,
1.382353425,
-0.2453165352,
0.9463669062,
0.7900019288,
-0.096011728,
0.5985075235,
0.8495372534,
0.0978164226,
0.8210524321,
0.1330432147,
0.1552760005,
-0.4134325981,
-0.1817787886,
-0.2931849658,
0.3109188378,
-0.1760427952,
-0.1819561273,
-0.2371857762,
-0.2336766422,
0.1950963736,
0.6060683131,
0.0300952625,
0.6594353318,
0.0492214076,
-1.1589676142,
0.6174250841,
0.1168192476,
0.5025852323,
-0.6756845713,
-0.1584347337,
-0.0105794175,
0.5014404655,
-0.0776860565,
-0.1925362349,
0.2077591717,
-0.3686319888,
-0.1493442804,
-0.0659115016,
0.432069093,
-0.6454207897,
-0.0525929742,
0.2193267792,
0.3037567437,
-0.3252171278,
0.3541088402,
-1.0210038424,
-0.0697798282,
0.1671958715,
-0.1643804759,
0.3665497005,
0.0520111024,
-0.409563601,
0.8626959324,
0.5852746964,
0.0792462975,
-0.1789298505,
-0.3032731116,
0.5511161685,
-0.6598182321,
-0.6799160242,
-0.5277828574,
0.1442789137,
0.1096454561,
-0.4376404285,
0.4380676746,
0.2435089201,
1.2353136539,
0.0265697259,
0.608009696,
-0.0907142088,
0.6992990971,
-0.5575175881,
0.5455980897,
-0.6665988564,
0.1084437221,
-0.1691657305,
-0.8420963287,
-0.1512099355,
0.9343853593,
-0.31910339,
0.0557666272,
0.9893590212,
0.7767917514,
-0.1137076467,
-0.0731722265,
0.0655614138,
0.0179192014,
0.2274642885,
0.4870586991,
0.8135609031,
-0.4884677231,
0.5053405762,
-0.6072633862,
-0.0968239084,
-0.2056567818,
-1.0864795446,
-0.5515295863,
-0.4990670681,
-0.5156807303,
-0.6448825598,
0.2674840987,
1.3988004923,
0.8784071803,
-0.9504448175,
-0.2479349375,
-0.1816354096,
0.2450641394,
-0.5949275494,
-0.2155276984,
0.3718869686,
-0.2418589592,
-0.5920447707,
0.1822846681,
-0.1256025583,
0.1175553948,
-0.3088606596,
-0.5598845482,
-0.412533015,
-0.2706146538,
0.0962112397,
0.5635520816,
-0.8598047495,
-0.5431156158,
0.1201026663,
-0.3110193014,
0.1849357635,
0.8410893083,
-0.5477226973,
0.4528809488,
0.4961135983,
0.6938286424,
0.2596254051,
0.4472919106,
0.8997194767,
-0.5719551444,
0.0619004481,
0.3188890517,
0.2378659397,
0.3232517838,
-0.2338114828,
0.6045230031,
0.2927091718,
-0.6966264844,
-0.7712823749,
0.2980850935,
-0.7240858674,
-0.0802031606,
0.9326497316,
-0.369236052,
-0.4946206808,
0.0695363134,
-0.0701496676,
0.497222811,
-0.4793857932,
1.2284047604,
0.7566771507,
-0.1726562679,
-0.0403435975,
-0.1441270858,
0.8556447029,
0.6700913906,
-0.652525723,
-0.0487469137,
0.5140585899,
0.2370171249,
0.2588759363,
0.510476172,
-0.1312340796,
0.4449792504,
-0.4315995872,
0.281306833,
-0.0266515296,
-0.440415889,
-0.3416992724,
-0.0897282884,
0.4471569359,
-0.0876329616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09645v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09645v1
|
Real-world Instance-specific Image Goal Navigation for Service Robots: Bridging the Domain Gap with Contrastive Learning
| 2024-04-15T10:24:32 | 2024-04-15T10:24:32 |
Taichi Sakaguchi, Akira Taniguchi, Yoshinobu Hagiwara, Lotfi El Hafi, Shoichi Hasegawa, Tadahiro Taniguchi
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Improving instance-specific image goal navigation (InstanceImageNav), which
locates the identical object in a real-world environment from a query image, is
essential for robotic systems to assist users in finding desired objects. The
challenge lies in the domain gap between low-quality images observed by the
moving robot, characterized by motion blur and low-resolution, and high-quality
query images provided by the user. Such domain gaps could significantly reduce
the task success rate but have not been the focus of previous work. To address
this, we propose a novel method called Few-shot Cross-quality Instance-aware
Adaptation (CrossIA), which employs contrastive learning with an instance
classifier to align features between massive low- and few high-quality images.
This approach effectively reduces the domain gap by bringing the latent
representations of cross-quality images closer on an instance basis.
Additionally, the system integrates an object image collection with a
pre-trained deblurring model to enhance the observed image quality. Our method
fine-tunes the SimSiam model, pre-trained on ImageNet, using CrossIA. We
evaluated our method's effectiveness through an InstanceImageNav task with 20
different types of instances, where the robot identifies the same instance in a
real-world environment as a high-quality query image. Our experiments showed
that our method improves the task success rate by up to three times compared to
the baseline, a conventional approach based on SuperGlue. These findings
highlight the potential of leveraging contrastive learning and image
enhancement techniques to bridge the domain gap and improve object localization
in robotic applications. The project website is
https://emergentsystemlabstudent.github.io/DomainBridgingNav/.
|
[
-0.4368868768,
-0.6310001016,
0.5052397251,
-0.5745985508,
-0.4335674644,
0.0612516664,
0.2963818312,
-0.5837158561,
0.0549076609,
0.4001876116,
-0.5869855285,
-0.5713403225,
-0.4335965216,
-0.1931355,
0.0483210012,
0.4533667862,
0.0845568702,
-0.286593765,
-0.2504334152,
-0.3898898661,
-0.2498675138,
-0.2582441568,
-0.6750113964,
-0.2098122388,
0.4585918188,
0.6882762909,
0.9407877326,
0.570700109,
0.6901331544,
0.2697624862,
0.1643096805,
0.5076435208,
-0.4792793691,
-0.0719017535,
-0.3530909419,
-0.5736594796,
-0.1757905036,
-0.3067663908,
0.0886228159,
0.5488162041,
-0.1288139224,
-0.1054234579,
0.1287730038,
0.7599184513,
-0.8555055857,
-0.2428917885,
-0.3424427211,
0.2336346954,
0.0960885808,
-0.0914533734,
0.0612272322,
0.093792215,
0.1770825088,
-1.0883467197,
0.4549045563,
0.2542850077,
1.4014122486,
0.4191403985,
-0.0947302133,
0.190550819,
-0.6327700615,
0.9651526809,
-0.5235099792,
0.4423183203,
0.314335078,
0.6456972957,
-0.0242025554,
-0.3991241753,
-0.3481656909,
0.0587461367,
0.0826518908,
0.599568665,
-0.4125316143,
-0.054322321,
-0.0529721491,
0.0754855499,
-0.7926297188,
0.2670870423,
-0.408857286,
0.0057148673,
0.4022322595,
0.1743850112,
0.2087651491,
0.1534176469,
-0.6431074739,
-0.2668404281,
-0.6154153943,
0.2122021616,
0.2378370762,
0.4802527726,
-0.3324048519,
0.1897219419,
-0.448949784,
0.7505888939,
0.1615487486,
-0.0682177171,
0.344691813,
-0.3424829245,
-0.2621959746,
-0.1432483047,
0.3271455467,
0.5925277472,
-0.0918278396,
-0.072461538,
-0.2302594185,
0.1887554824,
0.467731148,
-0.7048021555,
-0.1133407205,
0.2047361881,
-0.6175121665,
0.1699553132,
0.0902464092,
-0.5615971684,
-0.1122318208,
-0.1654464304,
0.3592346609,
-0.3792428672,
-0.0168962758,
0.1111665294,
0.0941093937,
0.244367823,
0.6817594767,
-0.5061939359,
0.2885596752,
0.3684377074,
0.9466145635,
-0.1764285266,
-0.2302755117,
-0.6461594105,
0.2963612974,
-0.4450188875,
1.0294588804,
-0.5295194387,
-0.3192776144,
0.0630544797,
0.1321170032,
0.2490030974,
-0.970759213,
0.3212195635,
-0.6850137115,
-0.0558877848,
0.181074515,
-0.2121530622,
-0.6275218725,
0.4014933407,
-0.4314377308,
0.8107864261,
0.3673112392,
-0.1189910844,
0.3712441623,
-0.3698682785,
-0.3856505454,
0.0384489931,
-0.053028889,
-0.758445859,
-0.0977540538,
0.2632672191,
0.5859869719,
-0.3675100505,
-0.3979936838,
-0.1969344914,
-0.4207805991,
-0.3069793284,
0.2061355412,
0.4507457018,
0.1018826067,
-0.2011958063,
0.0796848387,
-0.5130726695,
-0.0964514688,
0.1114820614,
0.1522270888,
-0.5597247481,
-0.3868002892,
-0.0924074352,
0.3527934551,
0.05334723,
-0.4263450205,
0.233464554,
-0.1074200496,
-0.2022079974,
0.5812404156,
-0.014961631,
0.4382043183,
-0.4510678947,
0.7014146447,
0.3013218641,
0.4600073993,
-0.2030192763,
-0.4646755159,
-0.7467133999,
-0.2697935104,
0.1740977317,
0.595255971,
-0.9711909294,
0.4757191837,
0.0002726213,
-0.4038228393,
-0.4373049736,
0.154040426,
0.6538506746,
0.7125831842,
0.7875021696,
-0.6897456646,
-0.347997725,
-0.9135775566,
0.2612879872,
0.1112602949,
-0.090390645,
0.7170458436,
0.4558882415,
-0.384736836,
0.5242472291,
-0.5405573845,
-0.9154050946,
-0.102968432,
0.0550169162,
0.1640260667,
0.5572649837,
0.5244625807,
-0.9196521044,
-0.2807479501,
0.1660742164,
-0.807700634,
0.1450098753,
-0.3377652764,
-0.3207119405,
0.1551793963,
0.3497864008,
-0.0935547575,
0.5250150561,
0.7255636454,
-0.0033818837,
0.2398686409,
-0.3001726866,
0.466999054,
-0.8697741032,
-0.1972396076,
0.3848832846,
-0.3977010846,
-0.4958634675,
0.0849167034,
-0.2347995192,
-0.0198543686,
-0.8061273694,
0.1616916358,
-0.4635961354,
-0.540792048,
-0.3519297242,
0.3827375174,
-0.0107799135,
0.5110007524,
0.2270508856,
0.7341747284,
0.8660404682,
-0.8516310453,
0.2568331659,
0.291389972,
-0.1971206516,
0.8649781942,
-0.5343512297,
0.2636567652,
0.1849705875,
0.104080759,
-0.7898240685,
0.0506126806,
0.3852212131,
-0.2529838085,
-0.0239457861,
-0.5071350336,
-0.1235913262,
0.0726039037,
-0.0235424098,
0.5810936093,
0.7134873867,
-0.7280471325,
0.515811801,
0.0525109842,
0.1548208892,
-0.5109760165,
-0.7341641188,
-0.0146967284,
-0.0377126113,
-0.5814353824,
0.6413683891,
0.2182178646,
0.1171692982,
0.2965510488,
-0.3195899427,
-0.1917018145,
0.0820350721,
0.204791531,
0.5278888345,
-0.1868186593,
-0.2644576728,
0.052885931,
-0.3859382272,
-0.4133296907,
-0.2043376267,
0.3906278908,
0.0167712849,
-0.4253809452,
-0.7238662243,
0.1578100324,
-0.0388106406,
0.1127328426,
0.4476422071,
0.485291034,
-0.2958403826,
-0.4655434787,
-0.1526685506,
-0.3001220822,
-0.4841520786,
0.2665787041,
-0.6723375916,
-0.757655561,
0.4427762628,
-0.5647953153,
-0.2710404396,
0.1533146948,
-0.0799724385,
-0.3975890577,
0.6450833082,
0.8397365808,
0.0881987661,
0.6431004405,
-0.7914969921,
0.082481958,
-1.0466359854,
-0.2528623641,
-0.3632825017,
-0.4361341298,
-0.2804194093,
-0.723436892,
0.4580142498,
0.1432732344,
-0.0871194154,
0.3867527544,
-0.4833675325,
0.4295655191,
0.508918643,
0.5687190294,
0.3226294816,
0.2139792442,
0.0446883067,
-0.0367152542,
-1.0244499445,
-0.4671858847,
0.7701146603,
-0.2306162119,
0.7210829258,
0.0248260852,
0.8437304497,
0.65849787,
-0.1581211388,
-0.6940086484,
0.6709553599,
-0.3354699314,
-0.2847155333,
-0.3540515304,
-0.3573430181,
-1.2457280159,
0.4212673306,
-0.1603873819,
-0.333458662,
0.5238980651,
0.218896538,
-0.493443042,
0.4089578986,
-0.3007555306,
0.8982854486,
-0.4230652153,
-0.8206939101,
-0.4271315038,
-0.8142220974,
0.0173386093,
0.1803996563,
0.1078484803,
-0.2426588833,
-0.396428138,
0.3712019622,
-0.2068494707,
0.8066776395,
-0.2578401268,
-0.075041756,
0.226362139,
0.1157768965,
0.4305337071,
-0.3117001951,
0.0477023497,
0.4452372491,
-0.5383114815,
-0.717933476,
-0.7818400264,
0.4288699031,
-0.7810281515,
-0.6016660929,
-0.3750035167,
-0.3075424135,
-0.1389702559,
0.1647988856,
0.0101300003,
0.1904895157,
-0.3024288118,
0.03431895,
0.6222779155,
-0.26862517,
0.0969250873,
0.4055207074,
0.0703616738,
-0.0091334078,
1.0599054098,
-0.0739215016,
0.4167776704,
0.4723379016,
-0.0718022659,
0.0515858419,
-0.6558041573,
-0.5860604048,
0.0153811285,
-0.492418021,
-0.4888920784,
0.0039820159,
0.0802892819,
-0.1314622611,
-0.7815266848,
-0.6302277446,
-0.1638282388,
-0.5955305099,
0.3330409229,
0.040001478,
0.3011070788,
-0.1921265721,
0.5210644007,
-0.7970153093,
0.7415722609,
0.4488171339,
0.1565860212,
-0.2956393361,
-0.8763740659,
-0.3297989666,
-0.0120024122,
-0.0584596582,
-0.2704246044,
0.3444763422,
0.1849532872,
0.6563063264,
0.4632905722,
0.1047558039,
0.8859385252,
-0.1889935434,
0.7622725368,
0.4107449055,
-0.6971717477,
0.7872377038,
-0.0926646069,
0.2525368929,
0.5196184516,
0.5899914503,
-0.3984627724,
-0.0575253256,
-0.5324652791,
-0.914157331,
0.7946392894,
0.0672306344,
0.0013343487,
0.5509312153,
0.4192355573,
0.2955166101,
-0.3232326508,
-0.2136656195,
-0.288972199,
-0.2930215299,
0.0444829911,
-0.0135022458,
0.2661209404,
-0.2538392246,
0.2005743533,
0.8663509488,
-0.3393562734,
0.204851523,
0.3229292929,
-0.3197345734,
-0.1065489277,
0.0518319756,
0.4643777311,
0.5077061653,
-0.16523543,
-0.0387537479,
0.0273215324,
-0.1590603143,
0.3855276406,
0.0100377565,
-0.3070866466,
-0.166179657,
0.123412028,
0.5569306016,
-0.1106759831,
-0.5390958786,
0.3985034525,
0.2455081642,
-0.2119279206,
0.159024775,
0.3569597602,
-0.4737822711,
0.5793824792,
0.4148655832,
0.2325579673,
0.3815712929,
-0.5986105204,
0.2545505762,
0.2622419596,
-0.4374881983,
-0.1554820389,
0.5158708692,
0.4009481072,
-0.2265028656,
0.5973954797,
-0.343134135,
-0.3537366092,
0.9017930031,
0.6061734557,
0.7697618008,
-0.2107699811,
0.4185658991,
0.3682161272,
0.2810446918,
-0.0793569833,
0.1596497893,
-0.0477761403,
-1.0553407669,
-0.0109699853,
0.0462286137,
-0.7818970084,
-0.1384091675,
-0.5545422435,
-0.0089277327,
-0.4573988914,
0.0084447088,
-0.3062630594,
-0.2746111155,
-0.6783804297,
0.5929093361,
0.0596142411,
0.4194765985,
-0.7929816246,
0.6719251275,
0.9004971385,
-0.6851165295,
-0.2581044137,
0.1149184629,
-0.107013911,
-0.9534387589,
0.7075530291,
0.0876379907,
-0.8258265853,
-0.1876893491,
-0.4810875952,
-0.7419745922,
1.1360892057,
0.1093072742,
-0.7946469188,
0.3600432575,
0.0131645082,
0.3440577388,
-0.6076488495,
0.0233818907,
0.1679357737,
0.2699125707,
-0.0263910536,
-0.3155483007,
0.1538673043,
-0.054022532,
0.3986907303,
0.0042385967,
-1.0640207529,
0.2312337756,
-0.4145939052,
-0.0868698508,
0.1596073061,
0.7049797773,
0.1909030378,
0.3413098454,
0.7886970639,
0.6995703578,
0.4516861737,
-0.0511158668,
0.8567448258,
-0.0341109633,
0.0920304358,
0.9625335336,
-0.3414524198,
0.5646819472,
0.4735783041,
-0.0001925147,
0.670308888,
0.5916172862,
-0.2851299345,
0.9308716655,
-0.0432999991,
-0.0613712743,
-0.5318340659,
-0.3995753825,
-0.2602834702,
0.3238529265,
0.2472496182,
-0.1265118718,
-0.0265086759,
0.2900730073,
-0.4558711052,
0.130351007,
-0.3822622895,
0.6087247729,
-0.1684432477,
-0.315117389,
0.6258139014,
-0.2675328255,
0.8046041727,
-0.4143832922,
-0.4387733936,
-0.5682615638,
0.1882855743,
-0.4212529659,
-0.6754763126,
0.0242686588,
-0.2168863863,
0.0793778747,
0.0569966249,
0.7180211544,
-0.131659016,
-0.1550440192,
0.3873817921,
0.6932340264,
0.3483060896,
0.2133938223,
-0.8836201429,
0.117270425,
-0.1161455438,
-0.1001005024,
0.4148344994,
0.2980485857,
0.0861572102,
0.6947370768,
0.5803229213,
-0.1663447171,
-0.3785143197,
0.1906255931,
0.7944356799,
-0.6511947513,
-0.3220814168,
-0.11226888,
0.3514711857,
0.0063863057,
-0.3877548277,
0.5797350407,
0.7749912739,
1.3190779686,
-0.0205124989,
0.6253659725,
0.1103957593,
0.244660005,
-0.5605902672,
0.1582747251,
-1.0366232395,
0.1714941263,
-0.2649164498,
-0.7684637904,
-0.4955536425,
0.8904039264,
-0.1869364679,
0.140212208,
0.4703868926,
0.9886900783,
-0.5674825311,
-0.7392649651,
0.8925418258,
-0.2079038918,
-0.0910932422,
0.5936460495,
0.8995315433,
-0.7139317393,
0.822193563,
-0.4280653,
-0.1282568574,
-0.4634129405,
-0.5785921216,
-0.481182754,
-0.2349574417,
-0.8241522908,
-0.1315789372,
0.6968157887,
0.4655454159,
1.1318843365,
-0.6521675587,
-0.2128392607,
-0.1062686145,
0.1413521916,
-0.7261875868,
-0.1390991062,
0.3504012227,
-0.2607390583,
-0.7838470936,
0.4201846123,
0.5088942051,
0.0601843186,
0.0806178227,
-0.2422444969,
-0.3175135255,
-0.1278503835,
0.3535574079,
0.6214609742,
-0.5872800946,
-0.4176866412,
-0.2219727635,
-0.0301367138,
0.6056630611,
0.6007302999,
-0.799526751,
0.3866236806,
0.2237054259,
0.7414520383,
0.7863515019,
0.1898637563,
0.0733604953,
-0.5634895563,
0.3175918758,
0.1488261372,
0.3786492646,
0.3684971929,
-0.2886030674,
0.9395136833,
0.2345967591,
-0.3882081807,
-0.2464260459,
0.291157186,
-1.1504012346,
-0.4844776392,
0.8181963563,
-0.4994279444,
-0.321882993,
-0.3001532257,
-0.31173563,
0.3180609941,
-0.6595523357,
0.9879635572,
-0.0608613081,
-0.5825491548,
-0.5205112696,
-0.248489514,
0.1542603076,
0.6975957751,
-1.1361278296,
-0.329625994,
0.7540736794,
-0.0232966375,
0.2734442949,
0.0662151724,
0.1287083626,
0.6745579243,
0.0603315495,
0.348900497,
-0.0971332639,
-0.41634354,
-0.3686361611,
0.1286184192,
-0.3020603061,
-0.7172349095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09615v1
|
If there's a Trigger Warning, then where's the Trigger? Investigating Trigger Warnings at the Passage Level
| 2024-04-15T09:37:52 | 2024-04-15T09:37:52 |
Matti Wiegmann, Jennifer Rakete, Magdalena Wolska, Benno Stein, Martin Potthast
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Trigger warnings are labels that preface documents with sensitive content if
this content could be perceived as harmful by certain groups of readers. Since
warnings about a document intuitively need to be shown before reading it,
authors usually assign trigger warnings at the document level. What parts of
their writing prompted them to assign a warning, however, remains unclear. We
investigate for the first time the feasibility of identifying the triggering
passages of a document, both manually and computationally. We create a dataset
of 4,135 English passages, each annotated with one of eight common trigger
warnings. In a large-scale evaluation, we then systematically evaluate the
effectiveness of fine-tuned and few-shot classifiers, and their
generalizability. We find that trigger annotation belongs to the group of
subjective annotation tasks in NLP, and that automatic trigger classification
remains challenging but feasible.
|
[
-0.5200957656,
-0.4908633828,
0.5184927583,
0.0075613298,
-0.138031587,
-0.4429095387,
0.1556592137,
-0.7454432249,
-0.2227598727,
0.2327169478,
-0.5547621846,
-0.5268820524,
-1.0198608637,
0.343380034,
-0.8584119081,
1.1981788874,
0.2538868785,
-0.5368107557,
0.224400565,
0.1010629535,
-0.3494955599,
-0.4598783851,
-0.494684726,
-0.1102248356,
1.0319069624,
-0.0546068624,
0.2029040903,
0.3665852845,
0.6925169826,
0.192178309,
-0.3844700456,
-0.4895001054,
-0.1317727417,
0.364346683,
-0.0629551709,
-0.7723923326,
0.0686927661,
0.0781925395,
0.5710195899,
0.4630944729,
0.4580727518,
0.0355960652,
-0.0356585756,
0.5001549721,
-0.8703778982,
-0.0747190341,
-0.7682636976,
0.3340847492,
-0.3518124819,
-0.100249052,
-0.6451998949,
-0.3924460113,
0.2074426562,
-0.4837601483,
0.4033010006,
0.0279584508,
0.464523077,
0.4522877932,
-0.8465448618,
-0.5511408448,
-0.5120620728,
0.4412306845,
-0.2516369522,
-0.0596584827,
0.4339713156,
-0.1685087532,
-0.1210601255,
-0.4367433488,
-0.5134977102,
-0.00591035,
-0.356536448,
-0.0068504917,
-0.3546012938,
-0.0023052334,
0.7425421476,
0.1728126854,
-0.6255606413,
0.1238751113,
-0.3654270172,
-0.5636364222,
0.6867073178,
-0.0016153937,
0.1563024372,
-0.1053211764,
-0.4733768702,
-0.0168632101,
-0.863548696,
0.0863751993,
0.5248998404,
0.2918058336,
0.0021959897,
0.3493775129,
0.3337589502,
0.9102451205,
0.2730692923,
0.2702576816,
-0.0310658794,
-0.1995505691,
0.1970400065,
0.4334185421,
0.919092536,
0.3773999214,
0.2908125222,
0.1798387021,
-0.2793685496,
-0.095896259,
0.5755286813,
-0.5707728863,
0.0117488736,
0.2118172795,
-0.0574786402,
-0.341927141,
-0.0783127174,
-0.4219586253,
-0.7812786698,
0.2348736376,
0.4011406898,
-0.2667842209,
-0.0733298361,
-0.2494167984,
-0.2374213934,
0.2526239753,
0.3794668317,
-1.077139616,
-0.1713584661,
0.8369364738,
0.7292302847,
0.0084654307,
-0.2858918309,
-0.3952327073,
0.0478689186,
-0.5101773143,
1.3962392807,
-0.3938370645,
-0.664368391,
0.505433917,
0.0345679969,
0.1200868338,
-0.3460537791,
1.0889416933,
-0.4016423821,
0.4830422997,
-0.3771042526,
-0.691103816,
-0.1033308133,
0.1894696504,
-0.6957399845,
1.1200803518,
0.05475742,
-1.0838967562,
0.8484953046,
-0.4492425621,
-0.6827602386,
-0.028867146,
-0.0262339264,
-0.2887539268,
0.0597672202,
-0.1369480193,
0.1988693476,
0.1370058656,
-0.1440493912,
0.1581744105,
-0.3240736127,
0.3276293576,
-0.0051123807,
0.7224962115,
0.0790076628,
-0.2326880395,
0.3192206323,
-0.4317028224,
-0.5154293776,
-0.1928742826,
-0.4533403814,
-0.5187640786,
-0.1584659219,
-0.0840345398,
0.4021764398,
-0.0562637672,
-0.4620935619,
0.3657873571,
-0.0825937763,
-0.228238821,
0.6435632706,
0.5559023619,
0.4659696519,
-0.3932654262,
0.4245530963,
0.2005947232,
0.3994411826,
-0.4122833908,
-0.9993426204,
-0.5142281055,
0.277638644,
0.1140221804,
0.511598587,
-0.3258554637,
0.8027763963,
0.3269856572,
-0.3599310517,
-0.1519072205,
0.0543823875,
0.4861247241,
0.8399822116,
0.0650705397,
0.3311577439,
-0.2909533978,
-0.7260292768,
-0.5810072422,
-0.4795711637,
-0.1869594306,
-0.2189003974,
0.5316930413,
0.2803497314,
0.6981363893,
-0.7073106766,
-0.5942652822,
0.0807111561,
0.5261335373,
0.2711560726,
0.1711390167,
0.6233098507,
-0.8328757882,
-0.3975931406,
-0.2741551697,
-0.9391189814,
-0.5298439264,
-0.3811511695,
-0.1306082457,
0.0276930854,
0.7561276555,
-0.1834011227,
0.4669379294,
0.0554411039,
-0.4103823006,
0.4886746705,
-0.0032827426,
0.0704740286,
-0.7544905543,
-0.0797158107,
0.1011044234,
0.1957518756,
-0.8192377687,
-0.4903213382,
0.3448561132,
-0.0354058184,
-0.571624577,
0.3909011781,
-0.2613494396,
0.2598789036,
-0.2742578685,
0.1986143738,
-0.0089801177,
0.0662479475,
0.1660165042,
0.4641608596,
0.4828549623,
-0.6376059651,
0.0660253093,
0.5391526818,
-0.2943341136,
0.6105861068,
-0.1344324052,
0.1610401422,
-0.2571641207,
0.3249478042,
-0.7701606154,
-0.3791266084,
0.2480747104,
-0.3041036725,
0.3738755286,
-0.2986875772,
-0.1437239498,
-0.4945418835,
-0.3606120348,
0.1677309424,
0.2410075068,
0.0411282741,
0.1517963111,
0.4718374908,
-0.1469571143,
-0.5980644226,
-0.657035768,
-0.0023936315,
-0.2964267731,
-0.3097300231,
-0.2130440921,
0.155114457,
-0.2418194115,
-0.3433581889,
-0.2624109089,
0.1848215461,
0.3089517057,
0.7738819122,
-0.1101792008,
0.1146506891,
0.6474410892,
0.1646803617,
-0.5859779716,
0.3223119378,
-0.0505405515,
0.0523380116,
0.1242351979,
-0.2570382059,
-0.0621054284,
0.7339482307,
-0.0970550552,
0.0602329187,
0.4777136445,
0.5157477856,
-0.8340461254,
-0.2950064242,
-0.3461742401,
-0.2791640759,
-0.3537254035,
0.0821563676,
-0.1519751549,
-0.6373939514,
0.59658885,
0.037910793,
-0.1239969656,
0.9143698812,
0.5299680233,
-0.179671362,
0.5338802338,
0.5062829256,
-0.0246913489,
0.740342021,
-0.0615642332,
0.319180876,
-0.6639393568,
-0.4127601385,
-0.832021296,
-0.4055479765,
-0.3323495388,
-0.0838044509,
0.8241065145,
0.1874548197,
0.0267728232,
0.5152041912,
-0.7456738353,
0.7286148667,
0.5744457841,
-0.127836436,
0.261626482,
-0.400575608,
0.0812964216,
0.1875000745,
-0.3866009116,
-0.6960166097,
0.9276096821,
0.0857227966,
0.482434988,
0.0242893472,
0.7675195336,
0.514080584,
0.610671699,
-0.5977364779,
0.3559752107,
0.0824608058,
-1.4293404818,
-0.4230421782,
0.1550044119,
-1.0214877129,
-0.0727680698,
-0.5071213841,
-1.0171642303,
0.5686294436,
0.0504248329,
-0.5465431213,
0.0493562073,
-0.9808884263,
0.8050700426,
-0.0329469442,
-0.0991973579,
0.2441004962,
-0.8316797614,
0.3596877754,
-0.5409911871,
0.3098917007,
-0.4196327329,
-0.100150004,
0.7649815083,
-0.2282854766,
0.9646890759,
-0.1174186692,
-0.5232303739,
0.5805447698,
0.1612672657,
0.4146079421,
-0.3413721621,
-0.3517790437,
-0.0181508549,
-0.0757197961,
-0.0603967346,
-0.3731799126,
0.4276367724,
-0.2775991857,
-0.5243837833,
-0.6966745853,
-0.2651746571,
-0.0115753645,
0.2641423047,
0.9312026501,
0.3124377429,
0.085550569,
-0.2093024254,
0.2700656652,
-0.1878354102,
0.6803234816,
0.5547773242,
-0.0211104192,
0.1149139628,
0.4132387638,
0.1116926372,
0.1296572685,
0.3505212367,
0.422811538,
-0.448161751,
-0.7116999626,
-0.2058998495,
-0.1645704657,
-1.1222977638,
-0.3282436132,
-0.6439405084,
-0.0841044262,
-0.40677163,
-0.3650974035,
0.1970731616,
-0.1281440705,
-0.2505896091,
-0.3890259564,
0.4292232096,
0.9108287692,
-0.281162709,
0.357370615,
-0.9137963057,
0.0908700675,
0.2590803206,
0.1899929792,
-0.3657839596,
-0.4244882166,
-0.3488422036,
-0.5972757339,
-0.4804272056,
-1.15414536,
0.1048470885,
0.1977062523,
0.3402324617,
0.7587059736,
0.5969307423,
-0.3163875341,
-0.1963808686,
0.8738096356,
0.2278171331,
-0.7158036232,
1.0958606005,
-0.590067029,
0.2349760383,
0.582796514,
0.9969847202,
-0.6214627028,
-0.7730028033,
-0.3977261782,
-0.7177290916,
0.577991724,
-0.0301982835,
0.0164615046,
-0.569834888,
0.2085171044,
0.3016926348,
-0.036412511,
-0.7091832161,
-0.0967598334,
0.1839891374,
0.1143808141,
0.0878172517,
-0.299623847,
-0.2809939682,
0.1151760221,
0.3148337901,
-0.1632608771,
0.1315107942,
0.3264104128,
-0.2796025574,
-0.5538563132,
0.3107359707,
0.5970289707,
0.6354845762,
-0.3736365139,
0.4821362197,
0.0298168883,
-0.7086411715,
0.2106482387,
-0.0719280615,
-0.4817812443,
-0.1217889413,
1.1033984423,
0.6349152327,
0.3350113928,
-0.2015215456,
0.8389214277,
0.2385974526,
-0.1312430352,
-0.3579959273,
0.2505384684,
-0.3672367334,
0.2369817197,
0.6810771823,
-0.4093650281,
0.4038916826,
-0.5633375645,
0.3031993806,
0.0575596169,
-0.4448508322,
-0.2592901587,
0.558157742,
0.3388942182,
-0.4321670532,
0.4381256998,
-0.1398825049,
-1.0057660341,
0.4433946013,
0.3862361312,
1.0532109737,
-0.2026057839,
0.0933337361,
0.6623814106,
0.5373865962,
0.4918107986,
0.1769457161,
0.1033442914,
-0.6495378017,
-0.3059799373,
-0.6327233315,
-0.3188181221,
-0.1942563653,
-0.5096574426,
0.2111381143,
-0.3470411301,
-0.6185669899,
0.5381597281,
-0.2412193716,
-0.3326188028,
0.2062744796,
0.6241937876,
1.0960515738,
-1.4765936136,
0.5488678217,
0.4071573615,
-0.5092026591,
-0.2822035849,
0.2639856637,
0.3152240515,
-0.4901105464,
0.6432890892,
0.1826183349,
0.2622933686,
-0.2650852501,
-0.4686956406,
-0.1902826428,
0.5702694654,
0.056732595,
-0.41231215,
-0.1943532526,
0.1294477582,
0.5836942792,
-0.0309389755,
0.2097925395,
0.5161656737,
0.7681898475,
0.1142536178,
-0.4857904315,
0.1481671482,
-0.3435557783,
-0.5073405504,
0.5860339403,
-0.1270392388,
0.6504685283,
-0.3021427691,
-0.1284410805,
-0.4746097922,
0.0602446049,
-0.346324414,
0.6039981246,
0.5947876573,
0.3029457033,
0.6850978732,
-0.5674032569,
1.3645395041,
-0.1010136828,
0.0639531761,
0.977357626,
-0.2532530725,
0.8777523041,
0.3270605505,
-0.2594737113,
0.5085334778,
0.7425155044,
0.0365974903,
0.4983461201,
0.264157027,
-0.8888193369,
-0.3425444663,
-0.2401666343,
-0.4040289521,
0.194119662,
0.4648987353,
-0.3641087413,
-0.2653573453,
0.2113607973,
-0.1869883537,
-0.1705236435,
-0.3322729468,
1.2337259054,
0.2593480647,
-0.6279294491,
0.3652354479,
-0.5413674116,
0.3730254769,
-0.5923306346,
0.296448648,
-0.1757192314,
0.1256856173,
-0.3786658645,
-1.2375358343,
0.6445976496,
0.2155322134,
-0.2455158681,
-0.2954998612,
1.0163949728,
-0.1622391343,
-0.2904919088,
0.3571701348,
0.0812274069,
0.271399498,
-0.532340765,
-0.4358186722,
0.0583572537,
-0.3673605919,
-0.3269622028,
0.2425903231,
0.80167377,
-0.3236036003,
0.2313210964,
0.5719226003,
-0.2445458323,
0.4432486594,
0.0351507664,
0.7285986543,
-0.8289784193,
-0.3099810779,
-0.4635187685,
0.8754116297,
-0.0270873848,
-0.7668591738,
0.5357278585,
0.5475677252,
0.6024562716,
-0.2234574109,
0.7685086131,
0.0081531024,
0.3758298755,
-0.3207088709,
0.7148664594,
-0.1360895634,
-0.0839396417,
-0.3301574886,
-0.751388371,
-0.6566017866,
0.5164638758,
-0.6932701468,
-0.0705620274,
0.9022945166,
0.5351606011,
0.4200733006,
0.1807150543,
0.4071514904,
0.2489572316,
0.1016296297,
0.5992243886,
1.1223285198,
-0.3056225181,
0.4212944806,
-0.3540174067,
-0.1659957618,
-0.4087640941,
-1.2868155241,
-0.6688545346,
-0.9315004349,
-0.6500581503,
-0.4104318917,
-0.0908366814,
0.4381194413,
0.354082346,
-1.0767477751,
0.3243663609,
0.0698219538,
0.4848903418,
0.257869035,
-0.1309910119,
0.3434788585,
-0.446714282,
-0.535282135,
0.2218393236,
0.2872476876,
0.3193714321,
0.1701550186,
0.2770783603,
-0.4496453106,
-0.197566539,
0.3536337018,
0.5047853589,
-0.4535414279,
-0.575522542,
-0.3766644299,
-0.3035658598,
-0.2698638439,
0.9445575476,
-0.531358242,
0.4372652173,
0.6078662276,
0.0795237571,
0.4648065269,
-0.2946925461,
0.4041051865,
-0.9545772672,
0.3154253066,
0.3813358843,
0.328664422,
0.2065914422,
-0.4925163984,
0.6345695853,
0.0461896472,
-0.4875108004,
-0.7250685096,
0.2278589159,
-0.9594778419,
-0.1675625145,
1.0409952402,
-0.2693548203,
-0.2347843349,
-0.3466677368,
-0.3151938915,
0.4318623841,
-0.1359638274,
0.7962763309,
0.8206849694,
-0.0185575485,
-0.0538545102,
-0.5061426759,
0.9047567844,
-0.0336445794,
-0.9344163537,
0.1075663045,
0.579993844,
-0.1409173012,
0.6158505678,
0.3678018451,
-0.0324446931,
0.2288663685,
0.2154826224,
0.0837251469,
0.1948771626,
-0.3364910781,
-0.5381112099,
0.2221426815,
0.141900599,
-0.1371046156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09593v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09593v1
|
Improving Recall of Large Language Models: A Model Collaboration Approach for Relational Triple Extraction
| 2024-04-15T09:03:05 | 2024-04-15T09:03:05 |
Zepeng Ding, Wenhao Huang, Jiaqing Liang, Deqing Yang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Relation triple extraction, which outputs a set of triples from long
sentences, plays a vital role in knowledge acquisition. Large language models
can accurately extract triples from simple sentences through few-shot learning
or fine-tuning when given appropriate instructions. However, they often miss
out when extracting from complex sentences. In this paper, we design an
evaluation-filtering framework that integrates large language models with small
models for relational triple extraction tasks. The framework includes an
evaluation model that can extract related entity pairs with high precision. We
propose a simple labeling principle and a deep neural network to build the
model, embedding the outputs as prompts into the extraction process of the
large model. We conduct extensive experiments to demonstrate that the proposed
method can assist large language models in obtaining more accurate extraction
results, especially from complex sentences containing multiple relational
triples. Our evaluation model can also be embedded into traditional extraction
models to enhance their extraction precision from complex sentences.
|
[
-0.2710287571,
-0.5742278099,
0.9052981734,
0.2043755203,
-0.0128484303,
-0.0058605,
-0.435693264,
-0.8085801005,
0.0490172729,
0.6364289522,
0.0315160491,
-0.5284819007,
-0.6020917892,
0.0364072509,
-0.1702446193,
0.8032135963,
-0.068782039,
-0.0357941873,
-0.0184940137,
0.0979776233,
-0.4861418307,
-0.4081405997,
-0.538386941,
-0.5863003731,
0.499663353,
0.5026904941,
0.6875534654,
0.4970325828,
0.5551309586,
0.1931975335,
-0.129303351,
0.3882771432,
-0.4720011652,
0.0377943292,
-0.3407380879,
-0.3380827606,
-0.6665167809,
-0.1367215961,
0.8190228939,
0.8702477217,
-0.063512139,
0.0679996982,
0.0129573001,
0.7200518847,
-0.8382162452,
0.6295102239,
-0.450958401,
-0.0950275138,
0.0118835419,
0.1263570189,
-0.4681221247,
-0.3921782076,
0.3988194168,
-0.4489085078,
-0.1441483796,
0.1629099846,
0.772110939,
-0.3359028101,
-0.4157396257,
-0.2133015394,
-0.7993196845,
0.6299698949,
-0.5735878944,
0.3054509163,
0.3933628798,
0.2463224083,
-0.1197718829,
-0.6469310522,
-0.5310183167,
-0.223962456,
-0.2675025761,
-0.1062995419,
-0.0482751615,
0.1945840716,
0.2778865397,
0.6079428792,
-0.0437454768,
0.1118122712,
-0.2839480639,
0.1078089997,
0.6410550475,
0.0506046079,
0.314188689,
-0.4805212319,
0.0310306679,
0.2016228288,
-0.8367846608,
-0.306894958,
-0.008149826,
0.5747989416,
0.1454685032,
0.6154760718,
-0.2813772857,
0.701426208,
-0.0927762687,
-0.0825458765,
0.2409196496,
-0.4687161744,
-0.2583497763,
-0.1705235243,
0.9430143237,
0.1728885025,
0.368388921,
-0.2817023098,
-0.2349936515,
-0.2008164078,
0.0119149797,
-0.7727803588,
-0.5895446539,
-0.0948547423,
-0.6230268478,
-0.3334091306,
0.3578772545,
-0.8104928136,
-0.2289732099,
-0.3152311146,
0.5646209121,
-0.3712579906,
-0.3997984231,
0.3826867342,
-0.0847395584,
-0.0894198716,
-0.0171456859,
-0.9684581757,
0.6236662865,
0.7847696543,
0.5733919144,
-0.1941527575,
-0.3226061761,
-1.1853597164,
0.4691326618,
-0.0628550574,
0.3773100674,
-0.5462361574,
-0.071832113,
0.0264685657,
-0.1878086776,
0.0026517841,
-0.6524444818,
0.1391516179,
-0.7973412871,
0.1935763806,
0.0165736321,
-0.549292028,
-0.3246751428,
0.3059960008,
-1.0509043932,
0.8565818071,
-0.0615409724,
-0.434987545,
0.1725013852,
-0.5797697902,
-0.4962312281,
0.1487119198,
-0.286455214,
-0.4803921878,
0.0134513741,
0.502276659,
0.6264965534,
-0.6929435134,
0.4707320035,
-0.6012247801,
-0.4945333898,
-0.2853557169,
0.0520833768,
0.8579397798,
-0.199666068,
-0.2498820722,
0.0588457473,
-0.7139864564,
0.0634349585,
0.0485135913,
-0.4612330198,
-0.4843751192,
-0.2948657274,
-0.2912401259,
0.218781516,
0.0087875351,
-0.3491419852,
0.1877036244,
-0.5744420886,
0.1975525767,
0.2516105771,
0.4806666076,
0.6417660117,
-0.0168117248,
0.3502624631,
-0.1602025777,
-0.2156951278,
-0.1123133898,
-0.3092183173,
-0.7818616629,
-0.2567001879,
0.513666153,
0.2845147252,
-0.9385549426,
0.667345047,
-0.6760563254,
-0.199309364,
-0.2745709717,
0.5061972141,
0.6392021775,
0.2248374075,
0.3126682043,
-0.1905456036,
-0.5876370668,
-1.0058754683,
-0.3239673078,
-0.2512591779,
-0.1499738544,
0.1667772382,
0.6251000166,
0.0946812704,
0.7643066049,
-0.6614856124,
-0.2466742694,
-0.3693449497,
0.2132642865,
0.3374748528,
0.4022439718,
0.3081786633,
-0.8663518429,
-0.515191853,
0.0924910977,
-0.9611551166,
0.2974307835,
0.2054376453,
-0.2091424018,
0.007375672,
0.3781671524,
-0.7673760653,
0.3002170324,
0.1579075456,
0.0106916949,
0.3406916559,
-0.0112982197,
-0.0701821893,
-1.0770292282,
0.1619841009,
-0.0224684011,
-0.3944046199,
-0.3645415902,
0.2286575437,
0.2540113926,
0.1888695508,
-0.1775501221,
0.3053272069,
-0.7451114058,
-0.2796440125,
0.089632906,
0.5332613587,
0.5115539432,
0.3929559588,
0.1433200836,
0.2175362855,
0.246559754,
-0.6528850198,
0.5785760283,
0.2484168261,
-0.5468853116,
0.4131234288,
-0.3425724208,
0.2488588095,
0.1633553207,
0.1096730679,
-0.6482413411,
-0.2504478097,
0.2204769701,
-0.0786120892,
0.4298423529,
-0.1688726544,
-0.7509639859,
-0.5761770606,
-0.18193838,
0.0856039375,
0.0981243551,
-0.9589446783,
0.8211638927,
0.6018525958,
-0.2431387156,
-0.5261538029,
-0.4072810709,
0.0917180628,
-0.0575099774,
-0.5525221825,
0.3598956764,
0.1875146776,
-0.3030120134,
0.1796407253,
-0.004721866,
-0.277325511,
0.2527148426,
0.1035279334,
0.5645400882,
-0.3695799112,
0.6057568192,
-0.3075850904,
-0.0339886062,
0.2915051877,
-0.1775502861,
0.2983766496,
-0.4534256458,
0.0368171893,
-0.2765142918,
0.5103856325,
0.4605598152,
-0.3216447532,
0.7170214653,
0.581541419,
-0.6696372628,
0.111239776,
-0.6477711797,
-0.1856030822,
-0.333660692,
0.5456100702,
-0.7106970549,
-0.9549948573,
0.1167178452,
-0.0712649971,
-0.2149164528,
0.5202965736,
0.3436543345,
0.0763076544,
1.0207493305,
0.6697728634,
-0.1738679409,
0.2392675132,
-0.3331228197,
0.4508490562,
-0.8838784695,
-0.2008788586,
-0.4925494492,
0.1743601859,
-0.1367134452,
-0.101224564,
0.1240075678,
0.4459031522,
-0.2087168992,
0.2572018802,
-0.0209778231,
0.7932976484,
0.5703104138,
0.292289257,
0.6252295971,
0.0860989392,
-0.0433421656,
0.0351712853,
-0.5548030138,
-0.4521397054,
0.8532299995,
0.198707521,
0.2104929239,
0.4261817634,
0.9507880807,
-0.2759004533,
0.39716658,
-0.9888677597,
0.3521586359,
-0.1775235981,
-0.6613574028,
-0.2293910086,
-0.6568827033,
-0.5606492162,
0.2964291275,
-0.5139763355,
-0.8791354299,
0.0793068334,
-0.0294132233,
-0.9129821062,
0.3423998058,
-0.7481745481,
0.7598333359,
-0.0479608178,
-0.6903762221,
-0.2477916181,
-0.6590275168,
0.7739974856,
-0.2853516936,
0.1577774584,
-0.0701519325,
0.3203327358,
0.7021672726,
-0.1245609522,
0.6884368658,
-0.0234445408,
0.0758106485,
0.2330010831,
0.3505497873,
0.4956050217,
0.0725031272,
-0.4368376136,
-0.0851030648,
-0.1649194956,
-0.0958086923,
-0.6110872626,
0.773530066,
-0.5205898285,
-0.5118527412,
0.0045975884,
-0.415912509,
-0.2905748487,
0.5146181583,
-0.3372066915,
0.2658298612,
-0.3122745752,
0.4163542688,
0.3849751055,
-0.0395406596,
0.5590807796,
0.2963065505,
-0.6322040558,
-0.6035290956,
0.6987066269,
-0.1481440663,
0.2812936306,
0.4181112349,
0.2047953606,
-0.1186984777,
-0.3584528863,
-0.2992520332,
0.3885549009,
-0.6357300282,
-0.4646897316,
-0.8004757762,
-0.1240649,
-0.4980403483,
0.3433130085,
-0.3885705769,
-0.4650653601,
-0.1932158619,
-0.1175217479,
0.1989892274,
1.0279132128,
-0.1657587737,
0.2669401467,
-1.1675128937,
0.5783387423,
0.5558663607,
0.433798939,
0.2139919847,
-0.1302071512,
-0.3019274473,
-0.1375488192,
-0.1260569841,
-0.5786622167,
0.285772264,
0.2242935002,
0.3979308605,
-0.0017155374,
-0.1281261593,
0.7774502039,
-0.3032072186,
0.557923913,
0.3718454242,
-1.2319885492,
0.4695033133,
-0.1601596922,
0.1274272054,
0.6637629271,
0.2234143019,
-0.2841747403,
0.2175029516,
-0.541942656,
-0.7323657274,
0.8485172391,
0.2473994493,
-0.2515252233,
-0.0892814919,
0.6055358648,
-0.1278375834,
0.0980484113,
-0.8795142174,
-0.0084977355,
0.6317528486,
-0.1473006606,
-0.0179546606,
-0.5590262413,
-0.1904090345,
-0.1556291431,
0.7464047074,
0.126745984,
-0.1422096491,
-0.0490158647,
-0.2849814296,
-0.2062266022,
0.1076921225,
-0.0176132377,
0.7043706179,
-0.4277284145,
0.2053870261,
0.0439796224,
-0.0515523665,
-0.1999147534,
0.1610084027,
0.2450853884,
-0.2173994184,
0.5537613034,
0.5532718897,
0.439678371,
-0.2215216309,
0.8851508498,
-0.0852607265,
-0.0230702907,
-0.2985923588,
-0.0872558132,
0.4157170355,
0.2125318199,
0.0476341993,
0.1243040562,
0.3555957973,
-0.6338647604,
0.4607788324,
0.129852578,
-0.3920503557,
-0.1144903526,
0.2285152972,
0.2090786248,
-0.3955207765,
0.9040868878,
-0.0931177214,
-0.6497839093,
0.529399395,
0.5666643381,
0.6921361685,
-0.170917213,
0.0356206149,
0.6297044754,
0.0273983255,
-0.4272986054,
0.0657897517,
-0.0619589053,
-0.8290823102,
-0.5887389779,
-0.4204246104,
-0.1386442482,
0.0405881181,
-0.9305973053,
0.4047833681,
-0.2532411814,
0.1871884167,
0.3502163291,
0.1919214576,
-0.7409793735,
0.0809399039,
0.2874168158,
0.3976378441,
-0.769433856,
1.053955555,
0.2252450734,
-0.6683748364,
-1.0385496616,
-0.2255762517,
-0.1024379879,
-0.5061329603,
0.8669421673,
0.4684908986,
-0.3452506065,
-0.0742601901,
-0.4966695607,
-0.8248848319,
0.9205123782,
0.2974739373,
-0.7379013896,
-0.1365270615,
-0.3213479221,
0.5227738619,
-0.9400568008,
0.2250618786,
0.9156458378,
0.3269377649,
0.1144823134,
-1.0344408751,
0.1666891575,
-0.2323363274,
0.1414729059,
0.2341640294,
-0.1583273411,
0.6872485876,
-0.3420220613,
-0.1545605063,
0.1732399613,
0.4881570935,
0.4102698863,
0.1008842066,
0.6639504433,
0.1561220735,
0.8492879272,
0.2685442865,
1.1305423975,
0.1865540594,
0.3782117665,
2.0104396343,
-0.5400090814,
1.1283583641,
0.4252590537,
0.1246854812,
0.4928564131,
0.2327450663,
0.0262473691,
0.2111054361,
0.0988721773,
-0.1858006865,
-0.4933979213,
-0.0997261703,
-0.0756677017,
0.4489794374,
0.5445653796,
-0.8548275828,
0.1326733679,
-0.1981726736,
0.098197557,
0.1356863379,
-0.1076756269,
0.9496594667,
0.230349198,
-0.7830492258,
0.3646241426,
-0.2401498556,
0.1256447732,
0.0774306357,
-0.4476357698,
0.221446991,
0.4483900368,
-0.1945590675,
-0.6490855813,
0.1186215207,
-0.3271829784,
-0.4865020514,
0.098353155,
0.673602581,
-0.7115249038,
-0.4072596729,
0.7874338627,
0.6021906137,
0.0697952732,
-0.4413019121,
-0.3759644032,
0.168653354,
0.1544855535,
-0.0647522062,
-0.1753737032,
0.2955764234,
0.0850563943,
0.1874347478,
0.4719470739,
0.2141966224,
-0.2883703113,
0.3368864655,
0.7323893309,
-0.7504934669,
-0.1530655026,
-1.0300649405,
0.3361555338,
-0.6616529226,
0.1538349986,
0.4706362486,
0.6647603512,
0.5799406767,
0.0648389012,
0.5814412236,
-0.0045151687,
0.5769373775,
-0.4998445213,
0.5394949913,
-0.3677484691,
0.5344245434,
-0.3755454719,
-1.241610527,
-0.9203159213,
0.5518654585,
-0.5070290565,
-0.0570507981,
0.9499747157,
0.6401836276,
-0.1900961846,
0.2457711697,
0.2587055564,
0.4022892416,
0.5582653284,
0.7494170666,
0.7567901015,
-0.7884102464,
0.7914507985,
-0.4930325747,
-0.1394879967,
-0.2035541832,
-0.9743261337,
-0.9029211998,
-0.3255806267,
-0.2701996863,
-0.458201617,
-0.0005912248,
0.9993379712,
0.8703308702,
-0.680901587,
-0.2569279671,
0.0202023536,
0.3119453192,
-0.0212064348,
-0.2000823468,
0.5220525861,
-0.0182646438,
-0.6797209978,
0.4637885988,
0.4108613431,
-0.1736474633,
0.0700278804,
0.0097329337,
-0.6159034371,
-0.6148201823,
0.7082065344,
-0.0549729764,
-0.5935614705,
-0.6859506965,
-0.3315292597,
-0.143439129,
0.1580846161,
0.5405598879,
-0.7600082755,
0.6239536405,
0.3479427993,
0.5935744643,
0.8060000539,
-0.3162497878,
1.0780658722,
-0.5873677731,
-0.1771269888,
0.1294913739,
0.4484985173,
0.5269334912,
-0.4843325615,
0.8624173999,
0.0314112455,
-0.3883578181,
-0.6315507889,
0.1719612628,
-0.7133783698,
-0.1416214705,
1.1611917019,
-0.4411827028,
-0.1800572872,
-0.161879167,
-0.0819203481,
0.3696347475,
-0.1979678124,
0.6413314342,
0.837982595,
0.0991317108,
-0.0384067222,
-0.3201917112,
0.1962989569,
0.274331212,
-0.6605661511,
0.1770847142,
0.6075680852,
0.3131451607,
0.402461201,
0.3963859379,
-0.219707489,
0.3101429939,
-0.3072603941,
0.3243146837,
0.1203051656,
-0.5007807016,
-0.6144895554,
0.4344550967,
0.1390283853,
0.0657142624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09579v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09579v1
|
Modelling Language
| 2024-04-15T08:40:01 | 2024-04-15T08:40:01 |
Jumbly Grindrod
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper argues that large language models have a valuable scientific role
to play in serving as scientific models of a language. Linguistic study should
not only be concerned with the cognitive processes behind linguistic
competence, but also with language understood as an external, social entity.
Once this is recognized, the value of large language models as scientific
models becomes clear. This paper defends this position against a number of
arguments to the effect that language models provide no linguistic insight. It
also draws upon recent work in philosophy of science to show how large language
models could serve as scientific models.
|
[
-0.1030818373,
-0.4744014144,
0.8871535063,
0.3152460754,
-0.0162090454,
-0.1833580285,
-0.6110100746,
-0.7741470337,
0.2742134333,
0.6298992038,
0.1141866744,
0.1751249582,
-0.740971148,
0.1949530244,
-0.6092018485,
0.5554340482,
0.4220272005,
0.4450718462,
-0.3315684199,
-0.0462078229,
-0.1499914676,
-0.4994682372,
-1.0933521986,
-0.6301210523,
0.6289625764,
0.0112577714,
0.9680691361,
0.5921196938,
0.4041377008,
0.4426709116,
-0.3457762003,
-0.3602141142,
-0.300121814,
0.2689909041,
-0.5893337727,
-0.7072355151,
-0.1703612357,
0.1941270232,
1.0469216108,
1.1510651112,
0.1564995497,
0.2028363943,
-0.2985629737,
0.4874694347,
0.0158816464,
0.7767943144,
-0.4613553286,
-0.2573986351,
-0.4093280137,
0.0205175988,
-0.6613493562,
-0.2878094912,
0.3274790049,
-0.3337241113,
0.1351945847,
-0.0224410482,
0.7333381772,
-0.1662072688,
-0.5277754068,
-0.1301054507,
-0.9760438204,
1.0182784796,
-1.0914672613,
0.5041123629,
0.4529322982,
0.2907981277,
-0.190010041,
-0.4656817019,
-0.8427996039,
-0.7171185017,
-0.0868476182,
-0.1033651605,
0.3362954259,
0.1365330815,
0.2981468737,
0.1870621294,
-0.2838255763,
0.3541495502,
-0.7975566387,
-0.0258345772,
0.8264531493,
-0.003917729,
0.4579662979,
-0.0115349619,
0.3111146688,
0.0124914786,
-0.7773136497,
0.1870427281,
0.3785954714,
0.4698220491,
0.0913264751,
0.8617802858,
0.048901327,
0.5695215464,
-0.5637273192,
-0.2448113859,
0.0192362107,
0.0790217072,
-0.0102354186,
0.2947048843,
0.7632204294,
0.065851301,
0.5232163668,
-0.1296279132,
0.1121838763,
0.3612592816,
0.1659770608,
-0.8520982265,
-0.1859759688,
0.0604405031,
-0.1647213846,
-0.1796450764,
-0.081193909,
-0.5871250629,
-0.2411574274,
-0.2727377117,
-0.131160304,
-0.3308083415,
-0.6567781568,
0.3422890902,
-0.2341471761,
0.0431518964,
0.4215546846,
-1.1104623079,
0.444347918,
1.0207227468,
0.7307735682,
0.2535180449,
-0.3411535025,
0.0859285742,
0.2141756713,
-0.9110025764,
0.6453281045,
-0.9955000877,
-0.4969231188,
-0.1035867408,
0.1834211349,
0.0960074142,
-0.2450723946,
0.4646030962,
-0.6142876744,
0.1519503444,
-0.5192981958,
-0.518969655,
-0.5539588928,
-0.1765917242,
-0.7494900823,
0.7276128531,
-0.2137587368,
-0.41723454,
0.272969991,
-1.067902565,
-0.3401537538,
0.5411096215,
-0.1201251894,
-0.0909312442,
0.3748758137,
-0.6226280332,
0.1675441712,
-0.4941549301,
0.7115120888,
-0.7544205189,
0.0888951719,
0.655841589,
-0.2628175914,
0.7237073779,
0.2297764421,
-0.2144692242,
-0.2837889493,
-0.6348736286,
0.1032330319,
0.1280145645,
-0.127972573,
-0.7730458379,
0.4846875966,
0.2103658766,
0.2099600732,
0.024958251,
-0.9160354733,
0.3087668717,
-0.8855660558,
0.7630899549,
0.2963821292,
-0.5140811205,
0.6898498535,
-0.0636465326,
0.4031025469,
-0.5739267468,
-0.2758088112,
0.1746425331,
-0.7607197762,
-0.6099365354,
-0.2211501002,
0.4933436513,
0.101240918,
-0.2682029009,
0.0627101734,
-0.1713600159,
-0.5068691969,
-0.5047411919,
0.0124443378,
0.2149721086,
0.2242343873,
-0.0328780934,
-0.328821063,
-0.7805654407,
-0.9624631405,
-0.2792090178,
-0.599111557,
0.168234542,
0.2773683369,
0.7063553333,
-0.0057698251,
0.9429831505,
-0.1363561302,
0.1612875015,
-0.0765375793,
0.0667425841,
0.1298443228,
0.291464597,
0.7302164435,
-0.8152654171,
-0.163052842,
0.192709133,
-1.1876004934,
-0.1806168407,
0.3514701724,
0.2073604017,
0.0623581,
0.3834611773,
-0.8970350027,
-0.0077281184,
0.5608006716,
-0.458365947,
0.5381059051,
-0.289113462,
0.108803682,
-0.7208667397,
0.271897912,
0.2206234038,
-0.0447022468,
-0.8962579966,
0.2109809816,
-0.1457023919,
-0.3106968701,
-0.3757070303,
1.0219227076,
-0.4060567915,
0.0295299869,
-0.6696133018,
0.0135514438,
-0.0217762217,
-0.5180037022,
0.457703948,
0.2239285111,
0.6481946707,
-0.5177813172,
0.451677531,
-0.0660028979,
-0.552183032,
0.1665241122,
-0.8276127577,
-0.2939013243,
-0.3300036192,
0.1450067461,
-0.7657275796,
-0.4271994531,
-0.0251283851,
-0.3776339591,
0.3905373216,
-0.1573725343,
-0.4605468512,
-0.6515586972,
0.2295887023,
0.3223145008,
0.3642534614,
-0.0527526103,
0.4003986418,
0.7002550364,
-0.5432365537,
-0.1739533693,
-0.6970577836,
0.0395961702,
-0.3063732684,
-0.7520148158,
-0.0415192768,
0.0478302017,
-0.8519262075,
0.1226850078,
-0.0193644054,
-0.2476522177,
0.2190495133,
0.2828897834,
0.2488358915,
-0.6988866329,
0.5608711839,
-0.2112721801,
-0.1600675732,
0.4890928566,
-0.3346615434,
0.403511107,
-0.0477084182,
-0.0512366854,
-0.1721159816,
0.4824381769,
1.0048438311,
-0.170643419,
1.021853447,
-0.0872687995,
-0.3178547025,
-0.0042137303,
-0.5118272901,
-0.2950178385,
-0.4475453496,
0.55488801,
-0.1862151027,
-0.9447839856,
0.3089183867,
0.1924023181,
-0.107553713,
0.5675285459,
0.5948438048,
-0.1495723575,
0.7914457917,
0.7502948046,
-0.0061948649,
0.4243734181,
0.0036290667,
0.6516858935,
-0.5921825767,
-0.1608183831,
-0.8362560272,
0.2778691947,
-0.3670158386,
-0.2302532792,
0.073386848,
-0.0993620828,
-0.3901093006,
0.2716022134,
-0.3496717811,
0.3311446607,
0.1936781257,
-0.2674053311,
0.1257973164,
-0.2784281075,
0.246199578,
-0.1811813861,
-0.5820028186,
-1.0663950443,
0.7828131318,
0.4901886582,
0.8359475136,
-0.0800206885,
0.1258335412,
-0.2426785231,
0.4648344219,
-0.8067104816,
0.6546676159,
-0.0249604899,
-1.017518878,
-0.5731868148,
-0.4073969424,
-1.0140345097,
0.5482497811,
-0.1035066992,
-0.5986196399,
0.1262721419,
0.2435850203,
-0.0708624795,
0.4138101935,
-0.7173834443,
0.7351362705,
-0.2812309563,
-0.1957450509,
-0.4153574705,
-0.2336827964,
0.6688141823,
-0.1229882091,
0.762622416,
-0.3367214203,
0.183832109,
1.1086125374,
-0.2419810593,
0.9388776422,
-0.0130957467,
-0.2476260811,
0.3489485681,
0.2415509373,
-0.0484987572,
0.1928700805,
-0.2026432604,
0.0312547907,
0.4205602109,
-0.5411342978,
-0.4195934236,
0.9471617341,
-0.7075799108,
-0.9713873863,
-0.5739597678,
-0.6889090538,
0.0067432541,
0.2986766696,
-0.1756279022,
0.2467598021,
-0.2485656738,
0.3784729838,
0.6333835125,
-0.093762897,
0.526632905,
0.6110914946,
-0.3860409558,
0.1591474712,
0.6953080297,
0.3597524464,
0.6669681668,
0.1526869237,
0.6356341839,
-0.1780679375,
-0.3947033286,
-0.1274073124,
0.614084661,
-0.5913600922,
0.3493697047,
-0.9555407763,
-0.1358012557,
-0.3851357102,
-0.0322901085,
-0.6615926027,
-0.4601079226,
0.1025177389,
0.0517618544,
0.6290101409,
0.9232694507,
-0.1750295609,
0.0995382145,
-0.6418802738,
0.0262345504,
0.2546340227,
0.3107480705,
0.1153918281,
-0.3938353658,
-0.1639687866,
0.3577848673,
0.0839747861,
-0.7362940311,
0.5721411705,
0.2872006595,
0.8036780357,
0.3594319522,
-0.3379139602,
0.3775150478,
-0.8209971786,
0.8644528985,
0.062081337,
-1.088237524,
0.4463233352,
-0.2317541242,
0.0826860145,
0.1453455836,
0.7632318735,
-0.6470941901,
-0.469596535,
-0.6357578039,
-0.6026756167,
0.4281421006,
-0.1508696675,
0.3423632383,
-0.145038873,
0.1586436927,
0.0685870945,
0.3297514319,
-1.0084079504,
0.1763141751,
-0.1859064251,
0.1569673568,
-0.5865427256,
-0.3962360322,
-0.1918882132,
-0.257483989,
0.6918078661,
-0.0739360973,
0.0991245285,
-0.0626769811,
0.1879495084,
-0.3016256094,
0.40276739,
0.5688960552,
0.7060385942,
0.1859213561,
0.2479370236,
-0.1724284589,
-0.4628717601,
0.1740293503,
-0.0875949562,
-0.0775329322,
-0.1067957655,
0.5084756017,
0.3975803256,
0.4609659314,
-0.6319617033,
0.1664842367,
0.4551314116,
-0.085829556,
-0.1998534054,
-0.0817712843,
0.3837189376,
0.2815701067,
0.016255524,
0.1810208708,
-0.0923188478,
-1.1871697903,
-0.1016744971,
0.6078992486,
-0.2073050141,
-0.7803436518,
0.5304961205,
-0.0930045545,
-0.2240321487,
0.473076731,
0.2221784294,
-0.7257865667,
0.7193288207,
0.7677820325,
0.3101817966,
-0.5784286857,
0.2673231363,
0.1947142631,
0.3837341964,
-0.6546788216,
0.2034222484,
0.4417014718,
-0.7280489206,
-0.6769974232,
-0.8267765045,
-0.3431379497,
0.1072708666,
-0.269136548,
0.1671112925,
-0.2970572412,
-0.1470513493,
0.6748841405,
-0.2581059933,
-0.2619792223,
0.2194566131,
0.2783588171,
0.7321158051,
-1.1304469109,
1.1375074387,
0.4044462442,
-0.4724135697,
-0.6880170107,
-0.6605055332,
-0.1335055381,
-0.4679881036,
1.3719812632,
-0.0386249125,
-0.3511330187,
-0.3464977741,
-0.6761696935,
-1.2318907976,
0.3952113092,
0.6232845783,
-0.384016633,
-0.1508944631,
-0.0085632391,
0.9502727985,
-0.5509576201,
0.2122045606,
0.0244656149,
0.6551015973,
0.2407398373,
-1.0755422115,
0.1143866405,
-0.3111262619,
0.1089380458,
0.2250991911,
-0.5068143606,
1.0691901445,
-0.2938635945,
-0.2211563885,
0.1887619942,
0.5954700112,
-0.0948206484,
0.0980967954,
0.0547346734,
0.135803774,
0.4129762352,
-0.0123940315,
1.1905436516,
-0.0620307103,
0.3925167024,
0.720271945,
-0.5753690004,
0.8544998169,
0.3735648394,
-0.1909881681,
0.3138773441,
0.4169964492,
-0.0419463888,
0.5528943539,
0.4836838841,
-0.2583987415,
-0.3239596188,
-0.0053406507,
-0.5147814155,
0.5203331709,
0.748770237,
-0.5907372832,
-0.1139712036,
0.039953202,
0.1603205502,
0.3838309646,
-0.3674919903,
0.2984252274,
0.377168119,
-0.6822974086,
0.3468332589,
-0.0862053707,
0.160666272,
-0.6573607326,
-0.0452234372,
0.3994325399,
0.1562223434,
-0.2250322849,
-0.8977493048,
0.6063283682,
-0.2250178456,
-0.180844292,
-0.2334068716,
0.668082118,
-0.3700170219,
-0.6447205544,
0.3630498052,
0.1746821851,
0.2519695759,
0.3411317766,
-0.2011917084,
0.1324134469,
-0.3026615679,
-0.1832271516,
0.2547493279,
0.5440259576,
-0.2101811171,
0.8160049915,
0.7559497952,
0.5332331657,
0.028047841,
-0.0860956609,
0.4529716969,
-0.9044642448,
-0.2578032315,
-1.0875226259,
0.0709695071,
-0.1707853228,
-0.1142200679,
0.8005213141,
0.5778797269,
0.6833468676,
-0.25776124,
0.8400486112,
-0.1450626403,
0.2641718686,
-0.3531552553,
0.8594320416,
-0.2475844771,
0.0973280147,
-0.323348403,
-0.6987145543,
-0.5652397275,
0.8687525988,
-0.7812511921,
0.1481221318,
0.7580982447,
0.5249829292,
0.0536071993,
0.3312025666,
0.5660485029,
0.6404801607,
0.5073239803,
0.0452340581,
0.9139831662,
0.0221497659,
-0.1944813877,
0.0152320629,
-0.2574876547,
-0.0170458611,
-0.8654190302,
-1.0500109196,
-0.6964349151,
-0.1371156573,
-0.4075339735,
-0.0663279593,
0.7777157426,
0.8723025322,
-0.7187110186,
-0.5932354927,
0.0355448462,
-0.1633931845,
-0.1423380524,
-0.2405842692,
0.0458576307,
-0.296048671,
-0.715914607,
0.5788146257,
0.4366721511,
-0.0092803966,
-0.5601638556,
0.2887443602,
-0.1966632158,
0.4979161918,
0.92793262,
0.6884415746,
-0.9977487326,
-0.5316040516,
-0.1432561278,
-0.0668525398,
-0.1116093174,
0.776784718,
-0.5618458986,
0.3619178832,
0.2219450027,
0.4421611726,
0.5335687399,
-0.8283880353,
0.891364336,
0.0150764687,
0.3314779997,
0.2899701297,
0.6593698859,
0.4521524608,
-0.2469016612,
0.3451376855,
0.3233060539,
-0.5306801796,
-0.9955955744,
0.3712114096,
-0.8376136422,
-0.2421507835,
1.1286851168,
0.0039983229,
-0.6198672652,
-0.0927840248,
-0.1190127209,
-0.0153558291,
-0.3091785908,
0.9269891977,
1.0202698708,
0.1572520584,
-0.4267780781,
-0.9579550028,
0.3721850514,
0.3411464691,
-0.5289764404,
0.0487332083,
0.1346723586,
0.3048619032,
0.5334098935,
0.4007516503,
-0.3485517204,
0.0043016807,
0.0998075902,
-0.0495758988,
0.2482512444,
-0.2302286029,
-0.0730386674,
0.2001966387,
0.4847083986,
0.466480881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09577v1
|
Transformers, Contextualism, and Polysemy
| 2024-04-15T08:38:43 | 2024-04-15T08:38:43 |
Jumbly Grindrod
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The transformer architecture, introduced by Vaswani et al. (2017), is at the
heart of the remarkable recent progress in the development of language models,
including famous chatbots such as Chat-gpt and Bard. In this paper, I argue
that we an extract from the way the transformer architecture works a picture of
the relationship between context and meaning. I call this the transformer
picture, and I argue that it is a novel with regard to two related
philosophical debates: the contextualism debate regarding the extent of
context-sensitivity across natural language, and the polysemy debate regarding
how polysemy should be captured within an account of word meaning. Although
much of the paper merely tries to position the transformer picture with respect
to these two debates, I will also begin to make the case for the transformer
picture.
|
[
-0.7958244681,
-0.6448052526,
0.3291444182,
-0.1283614635,
-0.2428381592,
-0.0748113468,
-0.0922873169,
-0.3777926862,
0.3557082713,
0.5296179652,
-0.4007962346,
0.4487066567,
-0.8412480354,
0.0579759516,
-0.8308090568,
0.744102478,
0.0872955769,
-0.3011508882,
-0.2396717072,
-0.2467146218,
-0.6352185011,
-0.3436117172,
-0.3717687428,
-0.3602882624,
0.4906045198,
-0.1366966516,
1.2177541256,
0.2692062855,
0.5546241403,
0.4110444486,
-0.1540101171,
-0.4132884145,
-0.1659882516,
0.4416808784,
-0.5649479628,
-0.6533014178,
-0.0022715488,
-0.0752678514,
0.5711981058,
0.6832510829,
0.1027837247,
0.2907036245,
0.0198664647,
0.6642432809,
-0.3615061939,
0.1218612567,
-0.7092579603,
0.0176354665,
-0.1864091456,
-0.1538798958,
-0.3878092468,
0.0740126297,
0.2358920723,
-0.0363796465,
0.3261563182,
0.1010576412,
1.1303521395,
0.3710365593,
-0.8532081246,
-0.381621778,
-1.1261793375,
0.6217362881,
-0.0966766253,
0.2153770477,
-0.2132091671,
0.7824985385,
0.1263255477,
-0.8888216019,
-1.0565216541,
0.1359960884,
-0.5035446286,
0.2857385576,
-0.5619491935,
-0.3709151447,
0.3133870661,
0.6047303081,
-0.3275743723,
-0.3027505279,
-0.612539947,
-0.0947637036,
0.3194238842,
0.2405758053,
0.6438646913,
-0.6694741845,
-0.6852629185,
-0.1214585751,
-0.4261879623,
0.1521444023,
0.0781160519,
-0.0715083033,
-0.1434813887,
0.3379586339,
0.4942937493,
0.4552980065,
-0.0617356449,
0.178306058,
-0.1127424762,
-0.1887603998,
-0.2478050441,
0.045114018,
0.7421699166,
0.441868633,
0.3948719203,
-0.0957086459,
0.0841818973,
0.6030418277,
0.8797146082,
-0.6772516966,
-0.2022445351,
-0.073328048,
-0.3555408418,
-0.202025786,
0.3255668879,
-0.5132954717,
-0.0324254297,
-0.3068034351,
-0.003124651,
-0.1806315333,
-0.4294143617,
-0.0435235463,
-0.0900363103,
0.8370804191,
0.159899801,
-1.1265579462,
0.2457879037,
1.054848671,
0.5792627335,
0.1039126888,
-0.006329122,
0.3561471403,
0.3769729435,
-0.6150614619,
1.1825255156,
-0.5858664513,
-0.6181160212,
-0.0584647954,
0.2369303405,
-0.2606184483,
-0.2163025141,
0.5293303728,
-0.2991107106,
0.863900125,
-0.1414014995,
-0.4209971726,
-0.3174063861,
0.1674423814,
-0.6983092427,
0.8991830945,
-0.0223952811,
-0.6576117873,
0.2298309803,
-0.8367987275,
-0.4523844123,
0.6259183884,
-0.648974359,
-0.0448757634,
0.5129649639,
-0.1328850389,
0.19605878,
-0.3467354774,
0.3931340277,
0.1440762877,
-0.382645607,
0.3650510907,
-0.3788168728,
0.7246052623,
0.1076893657,
-0.7121222615,
-0.233977899,
-0.2582885325,
-0.2080370784,
0.2640594244,
0.1309775263,
-0.3761878014,
0.4508578181,
-0.0002084646,
0.4152214825,
-0.0367232263,
-0.5480947495,
0.0569114164,
-0.7938110232,
0.6337832808,
0.761503458,
-0.4596609473,
0.8160509467,
-0.3828337491,
0.3668155968,
-0.0740711093,
0.1548921466,
-0.4244040549,
-0.6117805839,
-0.8012243509,
0.0667444617,
-0.1035751328,
0.533960104,
-0.4742910266,
0.4627184272,
-0.5695939064,
-0.4399100542,
-0.3618695736,
-0.3944926858,
-0.0217642616,
0.5475426912,
0.23806943,
-0.4061872959,
-0.2764216959,
-1.3369165659,
-0.4102539718,
-0.2430378348,
-0.2392618805,
0.6265077591,
0.3604313731,
-0.3972022533,
1.0019677877,
-0.6037277579,
-0.052175343,
-0.2606345415,
-0.0184521899,
0.3480555713,
0.23558034,
0.9738045335,
-1.0761487484,
-0.5414064527,
0.0048621581,
-0.5311097503,
0.2484147996,
-0.1858540773,
-0.3765256405,
-0.0958143622,
0.4836217165,
-1.0535430908,
0.4805953205,
0.267665118,
-0.2510192096,
0.2080377787,
0.2458779067,
0.1212777123,
-1.7417615652,
-0.0095855584,
-0.3679469228,
-0.1378654689,
-0.7402781248,
-0.025844669,
-0.0308393259,
-0.2696890235,
-0.5099620223,
0.6527093649,
-0.1674311906,
0.2879377902,
-0.5874930024,
0.2036030591,
0.0559820645,
-0.0707782283,
-0.0765781403,
0.5966445804,
0.5666056871,
-0.3139307797,
0.5949692726,
0.5257335901,
-0.3280106783,
0.7951255441,
-0.587199688,
0.1477351487,
-0.3900364339,
0.670219779,
-1.2259073257,
-0.36927104,
0.2990197539,
-0.2018394023,
0.0627893507,
0.0885029882,
-0.2530688941,
-0.7285600305,
-0.2046999484,
0.4462254643,
0.7126074433,
-0.4751226008,
0.9808998704,
0.5192886591,
-0.0303588379,
-0.2988190651,
-0.7015490532,
0.3006926179,
-0.4287738204,
-0.7780506611,
0.6426258087,
0.2861180604,
-0.5203162432,
0.1699834913,
-0.225648433,
-0.1486754119,
0.008698103,
0.515768528,
0.3704901934,
-0.41112414,
0.2783474922,
-0.1889730841,
-0.4354861677,
0.4082999527,
-0.0260498859,
0.4562423229,
-0.3043814003,
-0.0551439449,
-0.1929266751,
0.375626564,
0.5346894264,
0.0755457059,
0.7908434272,
0.5907694101,
-0.2711341679,
-0.0902959034,
-0.3369920254,
-0.2503879368,
-0.4942300916,
-0.0204134192,
-0.5423289537,
-0.8449076414,
0.3865533471,
-0.3080977499,
0.0523546562,
0.691214025,
0.705483079,
-0.6033865809,
0.5805698633,
0.7074949741,
0.0555692129,
0.6490908265,
-0.077596195,
0.71415025,
-0.9110300541,
-0.0375782885,
-0.6225039363,
-0.6462138891,
-0.8278214931,
-0.2196814567,
0.2149638236,
-0.3822507858,
-0.2822404504,
0.784784317,
-0.7042804956,
0.577309072,
0.2208625674,
-0.2687016726,
-0.0586375035,
-0.1835062206,
0.0406778604,
-0.0533976145,
-0.4802253544,
-1.1190502644,
0.6648811102,
0.026621975,
0.571412921,
0.3249831498,
0.1614068896,
0.0090080798,
0.4052436054,
-0.9016930461,
0.6129915714,
-0.0130767236,
-0.9194692969,
0.2263179868,
0.0632720292,
-1.3325802088,
0.4721428156,
0.0541338362,
-0.8519767523,
0.1985656172,
0.0954658389,
-0.094801642,
0.521104753,
-0.609991312,
0.9567403197,
-0.1987898201,
0.0913712829,
-0.3027332425,
-0.9639513493,
0.5951915383,
0.1139495149,
0.4256770313,
-0.1358914673,
0.0555249378,
0.4361602366,
-0.1498625576,
0.6658625603,
0.313876152,
-0.235400483,
0.3380816877,
0.3055862188,
-0.0978181213,
-0.2023777366,
0.4058100581,
0.0287438277,
0.0731177032,
-0.3856768012,
-0.8061769009,
0.4515829682,
-0.5489346385,
-0.8681079745,
-0.4185701311,
-0.570925355,
0.0397031978,
0.0979823619,
0.1170322374,
0.6051343679,
-0.2875854969,
0.5067961812,
0.4007468224,
-0.2654315531,
0.6447345018,
-0.0266372394,
-0.1302693486,
0.0703863949,
0.3765295744,
-0.2356501967,
0.4557322264,
0.6753656864,
0.2191005349,
-0.2894185781,
0.3034399152,
-0.2619237006,
0.0420599058,
-0.8981682658,
0.0580990985,
-0.4402017295,
-0.3575536609,
-0.2115476429,
-0.4386808872,
-0.4095152617,
-0.2977740765,
0.136874184,
0.1096864417,
-0.0463817716,
0.7734149694,
0.5502308607,
0.4316012263,
-0.6493912339,
0.4997833967,
0.5956093073,
0.121030286,
-0.1785310656,
-0.4270655513,
0.0737230033,
-0.0385363586,
-0.6800994277,
-0.7679750323,
-0.0974020138,
0.1479649544,
0.5609606504,
0.455897361,
-0.2005408555,
0.4589621723,
-0.8733124733,
1.1363153458,
0.1524576694,
-0.7606784105,
0.6175575256,
0.0060654827,
0.3902997077,
0.2385722101,
0.4951413274,
-0.9220756292,
-0.3384556472,
-0.9318304658,
-0.7812446952,
0.4525039494,
0.1223112494,
1.2044167519,
-0.1658563316,
0.0364948623,
0.0964654386,
0.1290940791,
-0.9872208238,
-0.3101564646,
-0.4098230004,
-0.1301551461,
-0.0472556092,
-0.2592142224,
-0.1896620095,
-0.3872440457,
0.1104910076,
-0.0996415094,
0.5937565565,
-0.1014954299,
-0.2890367806,
-0.0381768607,
0.5884865522,
0.342731446,
0.6742168069,
0.3372752368,
0.6518144011,
-0.1080016866,
-0.446963042,
0.131627351,
-0.4620162547,
-0.1647257805,
0.1290088743,
0.4389821589,
1.1183462143,
0.5561605692,
-0.2465192378,
0.6010249853,
-0.0187646579,
-0.2133338898,
-0.2685088515,
0.0903089866,
0.360997051,
0.3735743463,
0.3555758893,
0.469555527,
-0.0712618828,
-0.8823335171,
0.2654653788,
0.4951589406,
-0.4990552962,
-0.5083391666,
0.7674546838,
0.0008015999,
-0.7027804255,
0.3930271566,
0.0698637664,
-0.7721927166,
0.4549534619,
0.5926084518,
1.1171536446,
-0.3360018432,
0.3020789325,
0.3024683595,
0.4552980363,
0.078737475,
-0.1375396848,
-0.3676484525,
-1.059373498,
-0.2103240937,
-0.6052872539,
-0.3777441382,
-0.1896007657,
-0.5337295532,
0.2695954144,
0.0402579159,
-0.0152401701,
0.1441816241,
-0.516931653,
-0.4115088284,
-0.120880492,
0.4076341987,
0.5791506767,
-0.678815484,
0.6652523279,
0.5533385873,
-0.0647365004,
-0.664758265,
0.3906616271,
-0.1905798465,
-0.4435694814,
0.5624158382,
0.5504533052,
-0.2476710677,
0.0380894579,
-0.2652713358,
-0.7002004385,
0.9816968441,
0.5107610822,
-0.4341973662,
-0.0421652161,
0.2716730833,
0.5930015445,
-0.2752482593,
0.3097528517,
0.4855753183,
0.5256860852,
0.0237540752,
-0.8239086866,
0.0256308038,
-0.2528600693,
0.3089676201,
0.5964434147,
-0.4167323709,
0.7617871761,
0.2427154332,
-0.763140738,
-0.1283462048,
0.3551733792,
-0.6469650865,
-0.1933177859,
0.3722754717,
0.4252699018,
0.0200730506,
-0.3643503189,
1.4100177288,
-0.3643265665,
0.5004752278,
0.7560949922,
-0.0034707549,
0.6515760422,
0.4994780719,
-0.3993769288,
0.8428230882,
0.2899885178,
-0.0599330664,
0.3668120205,
-0.0708084553,
-0.3534916341,
-0.0828736797,
0.0356136076,
-0.1397077888,
0.742133677,
0.2813138068,
-0.3824552894,
-0.5749124885,
0.1965787113,
-0.1401620209,
0.2207166255,
0.0251299571,
0.9649499059,
0.3361863792,
-0.5022118092,
0.345534265,
-0.3172472119,
0.4476507902,
-0.2572250664,
0.3656575084,
0.0302946847,
-0.0391207002,
0.0134968264,
-0.9488376379,
0.8402027488,
-0.2388298959,
0.0498952195,
-0.6368280053,
1.0022826195,
-0.1346851736,
-0.4970911145,
0.392470479,
0.611145854,
0.095547244,
0.2157708108,
-0.8874260187,
-0.1762279868,
-0.5355472565,
-0.2660656571,
-0.0707555413,
0.2077457756,
-0.0386084095,
0.3381786346,
0.4240617752,
-0.2666930258,
-0.081087932,
-0.0049087731,
0.7207093835,
-0.7854415774,
-0.4402650595,
-1.1857587099,
0.3812631369,
0.0216404274,
-0.170862034,
0.5773022771,
0.4617157876,
0.8328137994,
0.0115537057,
0.4087807834,
-0.4247543812,
0.1573875546,
0.0061078398,
0.6543043256,
-0.3662721515,
-0.1026316434,
-0.2514179051,
-1.112146616,
-0.3291038275,
0.7668757439,
-0.6426045299,
-0.3022725582,
0.8549627662,
0.5833590031,
-0.3373300135,
0.2803424895,
0.2789925337,
0.1121763065,
0.2897925675,
0.4963598251,
1.0719147921,
-0.6416680217,
0.3431967497,
-0.0008848106,
0.0370629169,
-0.0526022241,
-0.603194952,
-0.6518353224,
-0.9351825714,
0.015059052,
-0.0824885517,
-0.5778639913,
0.6189438701,
0.3218779862,
-0.5133839846,
-0.3485870659,
-0.2571067512,
0.2961493433,
-0.1495020092,
-0.298258096,
0.0861467347,
-0.3560982049,
-0.9313150048,
0.1523421407,
0.5794527531,
-0.0608237237,
-0.364235878,
0.3485714495,
-0.0473989546,
0.4159630239,
0.8829059601,
0.0038937435,
-0.9405800104,
-0.7120443583,
-0.2041934878,
-0.248333022,
0.4210955501,
0.8477451205,
-0.7027378082,
0.4436040223,
0.3647955954,
0.7219367623,
0.4399908781,
-0.0151817836,
0.5701681972,
-0.251377672,
0.3656051457,
0.2099257261,
0.46106565,
0.0991910696,
0.0214072317,
0.3483140469,
0.4438126981,
-0.2153724283,
-0.8594449162,
0.770496428,
-0.8616825938,
-0.3926475048,
0.6145512462,
0.369057864,
-0.5358653069,
0.0603015274,
-0.2724967003,
0.1173691824,
0.4208563566,
0.8521403074,
0.820037365,
-0.1046144664,
-0.2009311318,
-0.7283813357,
0.3375686705,
0.3867202699,
-0.760281086,
-0.321660161,
0.1198992431,
0.2445925623,
0.6197139621,
0.2955651581,
-0.2525276542,
0.0854998156,
0.0438265502,
-0.1435377151,
0.5894456506,
-0.1940889508,
0.0760404021,
0.4389691949,
-0.54952842,
-0.1397485137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09576v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09576v1
|
Large language models and linguistic intentionality
| 2024-04-15T08:37:26 | 2024-04-15T08:37:26 |
Jumbly Grindrod
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Do large language models like Chat-GPT or LLaMa meaningfully use the words
they produce? Or are they merely clever prediction machines, simulating
language use by producing statistically plausible text? There have already been
some initial attempts to answer this question by showing that these models meet
the criteria for entering meaningful states according to metasemantic theories
of mental content. In this paper, I will argue for a different approach - that
we should instead consider whether language models meet the criteria given by
our best metasemantic theories of linguistic content. In that vein, I will
illustrate how this can be done by applying two such theories to the case of
language models: Gareth Evans' (1982) account of naming practices and Ruth
Millikan's (1984, 2004, 2005) teleosemantics. In doing so, I will argue that it
is a mistake to think that the failure of LLMs to meet plausible conditions for
mental intentionality thereby renders their outputs meaningless, and that a
distinguishing feature of linguistic intentionality - dependency on a
pre-existing linguistic system - allows for the plausible result LLM outputs
are meaningful.
|
[
-0.2312924415,
-0.8030649424,
1.0584602356,
-0.0111143226,
-0.2007085979,
-0.2765387595,
-0.3280445933,
-0.5801816583,
0.4065506756,
0.5759921074,
-0.5102745295,
0.1256158799,
-0.6996905804,
0.2355096638,
-0.7051499486,
0.7082750201,
0.0831179172,
-0.0762497336,
0.0825711042,
-0.0737117827,
-0.5342537761,
-0.586607933,
-0.5603113174,
-0.4316111207,
0.7363441586,
0.0352819785,
1.0608377457,
0.6315481067,
0.4845025241,
0.441510886,
0.1849911958,
0.0642464235,
-0.4830435216,
0.1618388593,
-0.2937926948,
-0.6927238107,
-0.2183606178,
0.4395429492,
0.752382338,
0.8978962898,
-0.174247086,
0.0670271814,
0.0293415375,
0.3031832278,
-0.2315273732,
0.1133998334,
-0.8836442828,
0.1176142097,
-0.1929812282,
-0.4494139552,
-0.6080892682,
-0.1171827614,
0.0079015289,
-0.2804112136,
-0.1592381001,
0.2867756784,
0.7287260294,
0.1319939494,
-0.2716989517,
-0.4948864579,
-1.2076375484,
0.9820920825,
-1.0330621004,
0.319559902,
0.6096883416,
0.3315986097,
-0.2376576662,
-0.480084002,
-0.8382511735,
-0.4555946589,
-0.2262373865,
-0.1314990073,
-0.1364691854,
0.0904332027,
0.6585518718,
0.2691096663,
-0.3051397204,
0.1978441179,
-0.4998992682,
0.155431807,
0.6594337225,
0.3867643476,
0.5553122163,
-0.2008352131,
-0.0434904471,
0.4141002595,
-0.7991551757,
-0.1783185154,
0.500269115,
0.2824254632,
0.185575828,
1.0164426565,
-0.0092118289,
0.4098739922,
-0.2997633219,
-0.3558642864,
-0.0732643381,
-0.1190238521,
-0.3490668535,
-0.0256133564,
0.9691911936,
0.2501966655,
0.9772774577,
-0.4519774318,
-0.1841875613,
0.4146139622,
0.3834822178,
-0.7057392597,
-0.1530242562,
0.3610784411,
-0.2971217036,
-0.4378103316,
0.115821436,
0.0272283982,
-0.1686133891,
-0.6118465662,
0.2034714669,
-0.3973554075,
-0.4087438881,
0.30846259,
-0.0726687014,
0.0496426001,
0.2259892374,
-0.9895355701,
0.1787565798,
0.8295359612,
0.5482856035,
0.0519516282,
-0.5856552124,
-0.1678434461,
0.3162660003,
-0.6396988034,
0.6611118913,
-0.8911795616,
-0.2035134435,
0.059157677,
-0.0091943918,
-0.0538064428,
-0.3201659322,
0.1330423802,
-0.5565518737,
0.2181300819,
-0.5427610278,
-0.7419379354,
-0.3581060767,
0.086348623,
-0.5499113202,
0.6256449819,
-0.2607467175,
-0.4755711257,
0.470472604,
-0.3953159153,
-0.3574233353,
0.243734628,
-0.2931364775,
0.1510889083,
0.3273720741,
-0.4626900256,
0.7414296865,
-0.3449291587,
0.7133340836,
-0.4068322182,
-0.4621526003,
1.0040323734,
-0.6509230137,
0.4850331247,
0.0791494548,
-0.4058478773,
-0.320858568,
-0.4120557308,
0.1287513226,
0.1844378561,
-0.2883501351,
-0.3726884723,
0.4786984622,
-0.2350745946,
0.3130087852,
-0.0793543234,
-0.3722169995,
0.0523889028,
-0.4090791643,
0.4945531785,
0.7198623419,
-0.340174973,
0.4494414628,
-0.4660820067,
0.4084425867,
-0.3277496994,
0.0370942429,
-0.0738677606,
-0.6767343879,
-0.7188315392,
-0.1782646328,
0.1336704493,
0.5062046051,
-0.5088596344,
0.3012818992,
-0.4105409682,
-0.4755252004,
-0.3084456623,
0.029068036,
0.2459464222,
0.0590204746,
-0.0139477309,
-0.3999353647,
-0.5500562787,
-0.9391592741,
-0.730584383,
-0.3349646032,
-0.0935156718,
0.5017569661,
0.4195887148,
-0.383838594,
0.8376016021,
-0.1668847948,
-0.0597241111,
-0.3304860294,
0.0237696245,
0.2797893286,
0.0320472866,
0.5659903884,
-0.5734051466,
-0.1778534651,
-0.1449531764,
-0.9997622967,
-0.1686306745,
-0.051272966,
0.3023458719,
-0.0677945912,
0.4251543581,
-0.8298365474,
0.2891347408,
0.6507480741,
-0.3576877415,
0.722461164,
-0.0690210462,
0.2158313394,
-0.9285845757,
0.0766818076,
-0.2709845603,
-0.2818980217,
-0.8807644844,
-0.1518807709,
-0.2316824347,
0.0810837597,
-0.5563456416,
0.6189104319,
-0.2738818824,
-0.0756176412,
-0.6805266142,
0.2198721021,
-0.3128437698,
0.2321154177,
-0.109925501,
0.5657399893,
0.2006677538,
-0.669842422,
0.3554646969,
-0.1087227166,
-0.3647230268,
0.3963859677,
-0.6481646895,
-0.1010967046,
-0.2640837133,
0.239261359,
-0.9078327417,
-0.4960511923,
0.3632308841,
-0.2200119942,
-0.0011417817,
-0.0081188567,
-0.5748417377,
-0.3103289902,
0.0216655694,
0.4935707152,
0.5796515346,
-0.1557224393,
0.4286760092,
0.5308101177,
-0.1222739518,
-0.3086212277,
-1.0868337154,
0.3300304711,
-0.4173460901,
-0.4204674661,
0.079540886,
-0.0172908641,
-0.6366623044,
0.0248173345,
0.3661001325,
0.1792423874,
0.0226432215,
0.3852510154,
0.1778057069,
-0.2124172747,
0.2110579014,
-0.3548752964,
-0.0540307872,
0.3600172698,
-0.0668169931,
0.644061923,
-0.0462271385,
-0.4549325109,
-0.4300818145,
0.2940711081,
0.4602809548,
0.0695790201,
0.9114356637,
0.2485716045,
-0.4349286258,
-0.1232733428,
-0.752300024,
-0.3051863313,
-0.496507287,
0.2451103777,
-0.3626778722,
-0.9415928125,
0.5029537082,
-0.0258051902,
0.0629581809,
0.478063792,
0.5462111831,
-0.3854603171,
0.952924192,
0.4826358855,
0.1317421794,
0.4724304974,
-0.2219326794,
0.5264922976,
-0.9656519294,
0.0355763808,
-0.4270478189,
-0.3868210614,
-0.6696401834,
-0.3834140897,
-0.1203291789,
-0.2466209084,
-0.1420716941,
0.4843066633,
-0.0460688174,
0.705898881,
0.2027405947,
-0.2800293267,
0.3037951291,
-0.0712790638,
0.0237757862,
-0.1013359874,
-0.6624538898,
-1.1224626303,
1.0421537161,
0.2761651576,
0.7533346415,
0.0864554122,
0.3637827933,
0.154700458,
0.5029851198,
-0.7604981661,
0.7593239546,
-0.0914944336,
-0.7045362592,
-0.3818801045,
-0.3916775584,
-1.2909225225,
0.199932009,
-0.1745343953,
-1.0210194588,
-0.0090277977,
0.0070811077,
-0.1464083642,
0.5802775621,
-0.422167927,
0.5824455619,
-0.1237300187,
0.0715714917,
-0.3843647838,
-0.262442559,
0.6633232236,
-0.1806097478,
0.6306394339,
-0.5000336766,
-0.302613467,
0.8895282745,
-0.1233467236,
0.95908916,
0.1264969707,
-0.2755319178,
0.3831380606,
0.3034631312,
0.4728228748,
-0.1515095681,
0.0435798094,
0.1909414679,
-0.0785474554,
-0.228179425,
-0.5609228015,
0.5521230102,
-0.5812990665,
-0.6962704659,
-0.2559752762,
-0.5947073102,
-0.0159548745,
0.3281700015,
0.1336642951,
0.5231731534,
-0.3458639979,
0.0132745551,
0.5764729381,
0.0209406577,
0.4385412335,
0.5705506206,
-0.5418192148,
-0.1981403828,
0.8238474727,
0.3177864254,
0.4449968636,
0.1416371465,
0.1657518297,
-0.0165427998,
-0.3026845157,
-0.12705037,
0.6926232576,
-0.7894775867,
0.1679843962,
-0.7446382046,
-0.3385733068,
-0.0077266665,
-0.0489944406,
-0.3029434979,
-0.2865366042,
-0.0957000479,
0.025594078,
0.0245644003,
1.0645920038,
0.2394476384,
0.4445830584,
-0.7337720394,
0.2952873707,
0.3570354283,
0.1344196796,
-0.066395618,
-0.7156056762,
-0.0310948119,
0.3592768312,
-0.0869798213,
-0.9206031561,
0.100247018,
0.1661370546,
0.5316973925,
0.6687605381,
-0.4319978654,
0.5446297526,
-0.8490895629,
0.7083104849,
0.1038321033,
-0.7049449086,
0.4035441577,
-0.4408088028,
0.2009595931,
0.2230329216,
0.5336684585,
-0.9841192365,
-0.9397835732,
-0.9828275442,
-0.3394645154,
0.4897931814,
0.1142613068,
0.6954783797,
-0.3529496491,
0.3957995772,
0.1548627019,
0.2638056278,
-0.8332627416,
-0.0197862424,
0.4882185459,
-0.0707771704,
-0.198831737,
-0.5404974818,
0.0492987335,
0.0149074802,
0.6334162354,
-0.115925692,
0.4032555819,
-0.0805474743,
-0.0831624568,
-0.24191989,
0.1721882969,
0.5917255282,
0.9587854147,
0.3461557031,
0.3238934577,
0.2177029252,
-0.4326730371,
0.1379192322,
-0.4651479423,
-0.2702991068,
0.0311431605,
0.4973297119,
0.7329421043,
0.5380522609,
-0.7326177955,
0.4339539707,
0.0488513485,
-0.1343796849,
-0.4121820927,
0.3478525579,
0.2479608357,
0.3547371328,
0.0914982706,
0.1861703694,
0.0882799029,
-1.0020713806,
-0.0250078831,
0.6833990812,
-0.0513066426,
-0.6014438868,
0.6695736051,
-0.1264154762,
-0.4496855438,
0.5477744937,
-0.2266139835,
-0.5467652678,
0.5076325536,
0.3913006186,
1.0131654739,
-0.4870526791,
0.1280906796,
0.3053106368,
0.6051536798,
-0.3627654612,
0.2887276411,
0.2594230473,
-1.1015539169,
-0.7867369056,
-0.6378565431,
-0.2931922376,
0.1011407673,
-0.0936033875,
0.3660884202,
-0.1930371523,
-0.3464370966,
0.1587445587,
-0.3265265822,
-0.6999985576,
0.0878796428,
0.4607832432,
0.5682178736,
-1.0696883202,
0.7549217939,
0.3529218733,
-0.1445954442,
-1.0034893751,
-0.1288809776,
-0.1710032225,
-0.7729511261,
0.3913529217,
0.3170129657,
0.0325766169,
-0.1276964396,
-0.2990502715,
-1.0309939384,
0.880001545,
0.4002333581,
-0.4600247443,
-0.2111046314,
0.7357823253,
0.4501489997,
-0.4031966627,
0.2501980066,
0.6338528991,
0.6624027491,
0.0627560318,
-1.0648300648,
0.1624594629,
0.0114949532,
0.2172787338,
0.3261212409,
-0.3848443031,
0.6554479003,
-0.4016761184,
-0.4816727936,
0.0620012991,
0.5564992428,
0.0488681644,
0.0113219097,
0.3205774426,
0.5547817945,
0.701031208,
-0.0591631569,
1.2067122459,
-0.0047804932,
0.2517442107,
0.7212034464,
-0.1316365749,
0.8064470291,
0.5439262986,
-0.5194582939,
0.3707549274,
0.4374784231,
-0.0471012704,
0.3063425124,
0.1771902591,
0.0177351404,
-0.1578357071,
0.0188946836,
0.0054976079,
0.6053228378,
0.4595145285,
-0.5556069016,
0.0416541733,
0.0653360859,
0.2571362853,
-0.2488753945,
-0.1354113966,
0.7400124073,
0.4843073487,
-0.8459686637,
0.4104399383,
0.0987316892,
0.5471606851,
-0.473721534,
0.2727080882,
0.0256225765,
-0.06519223,
-0.2647226751,
-0.7998716831,
0.599480629,
0.0428643115,
-0.0163681041,
-0.2681201696,
0.7097576857,
-0.4506219029,
-0.6037349701,
0.0495415553,
0.647185266,
0.6269406676,
-0.0211982299,
-0.3115075231,
0.0249863174,
-0.3627600074,
-0.4024890661,
0.1040203497,
0.6228893399,
0.1415266544,
0.65730232,
0.6645682454,
0.4962162077,
0.1267192215,
-0.0466462299,
0.468350172,
-0.7587310672,
-0.2462124527,
-1.3506361246,
0.2525907159,
0.2011900693,
-0.1177081913,
0.67955935,
0.44589746,
0.7142324448,
0.0255160145,
0.6245706677,
-0.136941582,
0.070701234,
-0.5268750191,
0.6709501147,
-0.3515116572,
0.3821220696,
-0.4127624631,
-1.2949643135,
-0.0770822689,
0.4636902511,
-0.6806214452,
0.3691701591,
0.8540946841,
0.7142723799,
-0.2009824365,
0.3025657535,
0.6654151678,
0.3665798306,
0.1989891976,
0.4541875422,
1.1859692335,
-0.3794094622,
0.1725001037,
-0.0484108925,
-0.2047655284,
-0.2072644532,
-0.7980610728,
-1.0238183737,
-0.638507247,
-0.2309633791,
0.0564540587,
-0.1912684143,
0.6884381175,
0.4219173789,
-0.4385402799,
-0.2747362256,
-0.0784375519,
-0.1194758341,
0.0205825232,
-0.2145358324,
-0.046280846,
-0.4785864055,
-0.6695144773,
0.2344678044,
0.3284542263,
0.144449085,
-0.4953083098,
-0.1061070561,
0.092249237,
0.6186999679,
0.8697966337,
0.007380798,
-1.1373347044,
-0.5195198059,
-0.066611886,
-0.2953867614,
-0.1315842122,
0.7365288138,
-0.7609039545,
-0.0541485287,
0.311490804,
0.2901926637,
-0.1225909218,
-0.3733618557,
0.5201887488,
-0.2609459758,
-0.0000286503,
0.3152052164,
0.5838837028,
0.2619290948,
-0.1843573898,
0.3944395483,
0.2331806719,
-0.5380393863,
-0.7730000019,
0.4515011609,
-0.57477808,
-0.236047551,
1.4073181152,
0.1559588164,
-0.3639750779,
0.0918297917,
-0.1530209929,
0.0554415584,
0.160645619,
0.998652339,
0.9456897974,
0.1248126999,
0.0692297369,
-1.0684198141,
0.3853956163,
0.3678982854,
-0.6648322344,
0.2106628269,
0.2900758684,
0.2857180536,
0.1126338989,
0.7288083434,
-0.004299745,
0.2790282369,
-0.1944715679,
-0.2273623347,
0.2125757337,
-0.3805808723,
0.1568730623,
-0.1841924787,
0.1752728671,
0.2809411585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09565v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09565v1
|
Reliability Estimation of News Media Sources: Birds of a Feather Flock Together
| 2024-04-15T08:27:47 | 2024-04-15T08:27:47 |
Sergio Burdisso, Dairazalia Sánchez-Cortés, Esaú Villatoro-Tello, Petr Motlicek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Evaluating the reliability of news sources is a routine task for journalists
and organizations committed to acquiring and disseminating accurate
information. Recent research has shown that predicting sources' reliability
represents an important first-prior step in addressing additional challenges
such as fake news detection and fact-checking. In this paper, we introduce a
novel approach for source reliability estimation that leverages reinforcement
learning strategies for estimating the reliability degree of news sources.
Contrary to previous research, our proposed approach models the problem as the
estimation of a reliability degree, and not a reliability label, based on how
all the news media sources interact with each other on the Web. We validated
the effectiveness of our method on a news media reliability dataset that is an
order of magnitude larger than comparable existing datasets. Results show that
the estimated reliability degrees strongly correlates with journalists-provided
scores (Spearman=0.80) and can effectively predict reliability labels
(macro-avg. F$_1$ score=81.05). We release our implementation and dataset,
aiming to provide a valuable resource for the NLP community working on
information verification.
|
[
-0.1375634074,
-0.5015470982,
0.7019935846,
0.5562999845,
-0.1444121748,
0.0712982267,
-0.1695880741,
-0.2815305889,
0.147609368,
-0.0562215671,
-0.5316748619,
-0.1998631507,
-0.6310629845,
-0.0278921518,
-0.2437217683,
1.0334179401,
0.3057117462,
0.1049882025,
-0.516125083,
-0.1920947284,
-0.0829932988,
-0.0844520181,
-0.5466214418,
-0.0595808215,
0.8062475324,
0.0592310168,
0.8077844381,
0.4901843071,
0.4785461426,
0.3053463399,
-0.1234159991,
0.3530915678,
-0.4943530262,
-0.1315845549,
-0.3552266359,
-0.267703712,
0.0115039377,
0.3799694479,
0.4938759804,
0.6410185695,
-0.0751127154,
0.3436774909,
-0.1186959073,
0.8092772961,
-0.8403885365,
0.1716883779,
-0.538734138,
0.2337293476,
0.031178806,
-0.6732425094,
-0.5652557015,
-0.6624772549,
-0.0910231397,
-0.6488081813,
-0.1754817814,
0.0685757026,
0.6097174287,
0.1657199115,
-0.6865404248,
-0.1830783337,
-0.8769718409,
0.8149374723,
-0.5148716569,
0.3444482088,
0.6521053314,
0.2846432328,
-0.4375465214,
-0.4104863703,
-0.4642672837,
-0.2980750203,
0.2017752975,
0.2926026583,
0.0266536698,
-0.3805167973,
-0.042343244,
0.1492830664,
-0.5898864269,
-0.1594963372,
-0.4360279441,
-0.1225699931,
0.6284080148,
-0.3968671858,
0.0427904762,
-0.2201678455,
-0.5306174159,
-0.001539531,
-0.1167856753,
0.2411641628,
0.6061492562,
0.211524874,
0.1780364513,
0.1909167618,
-0.1564434618,
0.8182343841,
0.0326686054,
-0.4863108099,
0.4417510927,
-0.1488842219,
-0.0473257303,
0.078893356,
0.8552290797,
0.1525730491,
-0.099793829,
-0.4306281507,
-0.0595383532,
-0.4392819107,
0.5229412317,
-0.0760866702,
-0.1176317483,
0.2097097933,
-0.5410951376,
-0.7756935954,
0.5267060399,
-0.4706992805,
-0.467115283,
0.025573764,
0.6672924161,
-0.4327357113,
-0.777997911,
-0.2420214564,
-0.2446657419,
-0.0919478834,
0.198188439,
-0.4548156559,
-0.4132296443,
0.6302572489,
0.9104427099,
-0.0024946241,
-0.6171079278,
-1.0373923779,
0.0918162614,
-0.4453856945,
0.7108986378,
-0.4443996847,
-0.021633435,
0.0637834296,
-0.0851647705,
0.140777871,
-0.1271582842,
0.812140286,
-0.7254252434,
0.0440315455,
-0.2956304252,
-0.7459124327,
-0.2622081339,
0.4230207503,
-1.0226169825,
0.5426660776,
0.3989193738,
-1.0022845268,
0.4532302618,
0.0924169496,
-0.3703974783,
-0.1474606544,
-0.0074632941,
-0.6367377639,
0.1451660991,
0.1851522774,
0.1272672266,
0.4104411602,
0.2567876577,
-0.8353891969,
-0.3359583914,
0.3974279761,
-0.6573877335,
0.8877435327,
0.0049595013,
0.0671195015,
0.0995959491,
-0.9963348508,
-0.0347803272,
-0.1489456296,
-0.6953924298,
-0.330486834,
0.1714581251,
-0.0422109142,
0.3719247282,
-0.0094181448,
-0.475491792,
0.1220442727,
-0.0701061934,
0.2061082721,
0.6545152068,
0.3262054026,
0.3034748733,
-0.5069568753,
0.3292471766,
0.3117854893,
0.4072404206,
-0.09183079,
-0.059469942,
-0.3192096055,
0.1464247257,
0.4352718592,
0.213668108,
-0.9132815599,
0.2886354923,
-0.3069871664,
-0.6520738006,
-0.0763373449,
0.1665249318,
0.4378002286,
0.6340193152,
0.4870515466,
0.1077938005,
-0.690747261,
-0.23476322,
-0.5270684361,
-0.6323083043,
-0.0040288847,
-0.2704772949,
0.2516703606,
0.3444921672,
1.1361752748,
0.0543206371,
-0.168004334,
-0.1772869676,
0.5125983953,
0.0988524258,
0.4301845729,
0.4554145038,
-1.0272198915,
0.0706701726,
-0.3339078426,
-0.9180030227,
0.5000211,
-0.3568027914,
0.1309283674,
0.556784451,
0.3699150383,
-0.1822303683,
0.2541505694,
0.8718165755,
-0.246130839,
0.7263149619,
0.0498890541,
0.271800667,
-0.6154346466,
0.0376220308,
0.5266290903,
-0.402918905,
-0.2351835668,
-0.3325411677,
-0.0686371848,
0.0919167772,
-0.7295886874,
0.2929246128,
-0.2674033642,
-0.2763609886,
-0.2326859534,
-0.0745797604,
0.0256718397,
0.4511822462,
0.0415196866,
0.4280028343,
0.0707443506,
-0.5634440184,
0.4763025641,
0.0395892821,
-0.6048471928,
0.838730216,
-0.3836469948,
-0.2283892184,
-0.2352279127,
0.462100774,
-0.7057865262,
-0.0002991233,
0.0765462294,
-0.8878852725,
0.0475092568,
-0.2613652349,
-0.1462125331,
-0.3564180732,
-0.1858730465,
0.1242585108,
0.0427317843,
-0.6154932976,
0.365901053,
0.4860994816,
0.0312041286,
-0.9531826973,
-0.4858995676,
-0.0459044427,
0.2489229143,
-0.7078998089,
-0.1088290066,
0.1106197536,
-0.1133321896,
0.5207919478,
-0.5132761002,
-0.4199481606,
0.0800252706,
0.3202933371,
0.0131582543,
-0.2846633494,
0.4506571591,
-0.2645587325,
-0.0819923729,
-0.0014185742,
-0.1264876872,
0.0290532392,
-0.2412087917,
-0.4869925976,
-0.2988937199,
0.0917638466,
0.4609738886,
-0.3197032809,
0.8783327937,
0.7455135584,
-0.0537253246,
-0.1628354341,
-0.6048719287,
-0.0351935737,
-0.4031537175,
0.3855296671,
-0.0432454869,
-0.3569874465,
0.237860173,
-0.0219261628,
-0.0471927039,
0.3847683966,
-0.0449276082,
-0.3971294165,
0.8332312703,
0.8426753283,
-0.4218953848,
0.3542360663,
-0.0827576444,
-0.1817794889,
-0.1976798624,
-0.3921131492,
-0.2858287096,
-0.2716988921,
-0.1781179607,
-0.143286556,
0.4975988567,
0.2906876504,
-0.2379711568,
0.0590627752,
-0.1488326937,
0.5329933763,
0.8078948855,
0.2298258841,
0.7212131619,
0.1291461587,
0.2185800523,
0.3498218656,
-0.6868685484,
-0.1855797917,
0.8625256419,
0.34614411,
0.4119430482,
0.1158987209,
0.6062802076,
0.5028689504,
0.213161394,
-0.6251598001,
0.1962621957,
0.1771621555,
-0.3746550679,
-0.7651534081,
-0.6966037154,
-0.7203322053,
-0.145729512,
-0.2796593606,
-0.2208078355,
0.2064673752,
0.0239278264,
-0.3441819251,
0.3516387641,
-0.088739939,
0.5530356765,
-0.3138691783,
-0.2021388412,
-0.2191208452,
-0.5162189007,
0.6475694776,
0.0726668984,
0.4113263786,
-0.0495848767,
0.0242181867,
0.7540883422,
-0.572897017,
0.4834464192,
-0.1961528659,
0.203766048,
0.2856700718,
-0.1226263419,
0.5019301772,
0.3471038342,
-0.6432284713,
0.2131561637,
0.0263484232,
-0.3995401859,
-0.7035642266,
0.6021327972,
-0.9119922519,
-0.007987598,
-0.9206185937,
-0.3326613009,
-0.5504081845,
0.0840596259,
0.1931143254,
0.2890204489,
-0.1831298769,
0.3998218179,
0.3382223845,
-0.0679647997,
0.8645038605,
0.8271299601,
0.0040644202,
-0.6021592021,
1.1620510817,
0.3912205696,
-0.0833966136,
0.1428106129,
0.1227645576,
-0.2351908386,
-0.24957335,
-0.417809397,
0.0589089952,
-0.5019763112,
-0.2863649726,
-0.4711503983,
-0.6055567861,
0.0842982382,
-0.0749878436,
-0.5138860941,
-0.2818388343,
-0.2510475814,
-0.1920190006,
0.2560595572,
0.3702204227,
-0.2945060134,
-0.0047929995,
-1.0066720247,
0.1029740348,
0.4519594312,
0.5527056456,
-0.0806535035,
-0.3547997177,
-0.436940819,
0.2452673912,
-0.4272179008,
-1.0230147839,
0.2332588434,
0.1663718969,
0.772813499,
0.2478291541,
0.4288291335,
0.3482395113,
-0.2678897381,
0.6645139456,
0.4052264392,
-0.7194703817,
0.6863648891,
-0.5168723464,
-0.0304935407,
0.8514339924,
0.6685730815,
-0.3453796506,
-0.5446421504,
-0.8048764467,
-0.5601654053,
0.4301980138,
0.0152322045,
-0.15489842,
-0.1225086302,
0.1185715869,
-0.0807000175,
0.3327468634,
-0.5517277718,
-0.0904407725,
-0.5087231398,
0.1259407997,
-0.0718826056,
-0.3411954939,
-0.1217961237,
-0.1785801798,
1.1065881252,
0.0081184655,
-0.1075569242,
0.1022580862,
-0.3820375204,
-0.4628243148,
0.040525157,
0.7473837137,
1.2431688309,
-0.43743366,
0.0894628689,
-0.3501108289,
-0.1559864581,
0.3900639713,
-0.1110777706,
-0.1081189066,
0.43425107,
0.3391203582,
0.6001425385,
0.2024045587,
-0.2982619107,
0.9058045149,
0.0740175173,
-0.1518633515,
-0.6763789654,
-0.1883036792,
0.0730877146,
0.3280848265,
0.834171176,
0.2835338712,
0.0268917661,
-0.5583560467,
0.7562573552,
0.3033784628,
-0.7336927056,
-0.1275388598,
0.3428783417,
0.5468681455,
-0.1811993867,
0.7294825912,
-0.4387454689,
-0.1539411098,
0.768096149,
0.3987719417,
0.6617093682,
-0.1829078197,
0.9388439655,
0.4649661183,
0.343863219,
-0.6724845171,
0.0064588571,
0.3828808665,
-0.6566759944,
-0.6502715945,
-0.9530364871,
-0.6443943381,
0.4203076363,
-0.5989971161,
0.1107686907,
-0.2290352136,
-0.0809540972,
-0.0773643553,
0.2326229215,
-0.2623549402,
0.295022428,
0.1591133177,
0.9742753506,
-1.1044148207,
0.6287477016,
0.4623483717,
-0.9893712997,
-0.9014112353,
0.2546027601,
0.3296824694,
-0.4709654152,
0.5605846047,
0.1390739381,
0.1335800588,
0.0851455554,
-0.3145727217,
-0.9238472581,
0.8732670546,
0.4238305986,
-0.5346483588,
0.2205603868,
-0.2154697031,
0.0948608667,
0.1480401754,
0.4740004838,
0.2335409373,
0.6566900611,
0.2161803842,
-0.6912748218,
-0.0773125961,
-0.3701091707,
-0.0278285649,
-0.1315636933,
-0.7763515115,
0.5004985332,
-0.4004695714,
0.0937617794,
-0.2432520092,
1.2169597149,
0.3300600052,
0.4848993719,
0.8430438042,
0.4289101958,
0.8432565331,
0.1393565834,
0.8017209768,
-0.3022920787,
0.550306797,
1.0597602129,
0.3874555528,
0.9949220419,
0.3149830699,
-0.379781872,
0.667112112,
0.5753082037,
-0.3756639063,
0.4067180157,
-0.0519233681,
-0.3109638691,
-0.3046956658,
-0.0632389486,
-0.3148908913,
0.6124045849,
-0.1553462595,
-0.4654720724,
-0.2083169818,
0.2360196561,
0.003354406,
0.0520835593,
-0.3967252672,
0.6076205373,
-0.0661127344,
-0.5727805495,
0.3157612085,
-0.149462536,
0.4188374281,
-0.4094996154,
0.077742584,
-0.2468548864,
-0.0503701791,
-0.5201894641,
-0.807651937,
0.4392253757,
-0.4256627858,
-0.6036113501,
0.2142884731,
0.5308711529,
-0.5765318871,
-0.9759044647,
-0.0986198485,
0.4001703262,
0.0212836508,
-0.3405262232,
-0.3752769232,
0.3324404657,
-0.3421330154,
-0.7585530877,
0.5389024615,
0.1657483131,
0.2262982577,
0.6911325455,
0.7199249268,
0.2450539619,
-0.0758641958,
-0.2719146907,
0.4779568017,
-0.3334749341,
-0.3419789076,
-0.6695884466,
0.5662897229,
-0.2819591165,
-0.2768064737,
0.6522862315,
0.4884094,
0.8056692481,
-0.0179281346,
1.2150927782,
0.0565661453,
0.3780961633,
-0.3519871235,
0.9052396417,
-0.5087004304,
0.1817608923,
-0.0963251665,
-0.76401788,
-0.1533622146,
0.6349041462,
-0.1451562345,
-0.0121069001,
0.6321949363,
0.5223867893,
-0.1325910091,
0.1360074133,
0.1750668138,
0.0024838021,
0.1923600435,
0.4398135245,
0.6818378568,
-0.2448695153,
1.009496212,
-0.6974850893,
-0.3327252269,
-0.3815222979,
-1.2934390306,
-0.4060811102,
-0.6744322181,
-0.5116581917,
-0.5906016231,
0.270606786,
0.6757060289,
0.6798180342,
-0.5187564492,
0.1114261076,
-0.0613606758,
0.5544722676,
-0.7984398007,
-0.2433754653,
0.3796688616,
-0.7557122111,
-0.245344609,
0.3848979473,
0.2696127892,
-0.5241441727,
-0.4472858012,
-0.1170242876,
-0.4196347296,
0.0558569357,
0.3505748808,
0.7966050506,
-0.5172891617,
-0.6789614558,
-0.310508877,
-0.1736668348,
-0.108912833,
0.4611780941,
-0.9814160466,
0.3301558197,
0.6598743796,
0.667941153,
0.0784916729,
0.3578214645,
0.4858691692,
-0.9990353584,
0.0515245907,
0.1774451733,
0.0573738962,
0.2407876104,
-0.3158683181,
0.4917902052,
0.4788965881,
-0.637845397,
-0.9015773535,
0.1482343674,
-1.109860301,
-0.2177989185,
1.101560235,
-0.3878135085,
-0.2993123531,
-0.0776638165,
0.4636422992,
0.5122722983,
-0.1888687164,
0.9009299278,
0.5329748988,
0.1497537196,
-0.5936948061,
-0.3463965058,
0.5506087542,
0.0021827221,
-0.5861275792,
-0.3802120686,
0.4355899096,
0.503885448,
0.2973095775,
0.6282597184,
0.129600361,
0.4499984384,
-0.0413220115,
-0.1721091419,
-0.7024495602,
-0.5261781812,
-0.0102585386,
0.5012149215,
-0.2957540154,
-0.2582975626
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09529v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09529v1
|
Prepacking: A Simple Method for Fast Prefilling and Increased Throughput in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T07:49:10 | 2024-04-15T07:49:10 |
Siyan Zhao, Daniel Israel, Guy Van den Broeck, Aditya Grover
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
During inference for transformer-based large language models (LLM),
prefilling is the computation of the key-value (KV) cache for input tokens in
the prompt prior to autoregressive generation. For longer input prompt lengths,
prefilling will incur a significant overhead on decoding time. In this work, we
highlight the following pitfall of prefilling: for batches containing
high-varying prompt lengths, significant computation is wasted by the standard
practice of padding sequences to the maximum length. As LLMs increasingly
support longer context lengths, potentially up to 10 million tokens, variations
in prompt lengths within a batch become more pronounced. To address this, we
propose Prepacking, a simple yet effective method to optimize prefilling
computation. To avoid redundant computation on pad tokens, prepacking combines
prompts of varying lengths into a sequence and packs multiple sequences into a
compact batch using a bin-packing algorithm. It then modifies the attention
mask and positional encoding to compute multiple prefilled KV-caches for
multiple prompts within a single sequence. On standard curated dataset
containing prompts with varying lengths, we obtain a significant speed and
memory efficiency improvements as compared to the default padding-based
prefilling computation within Huggingface across a range of base model
configurations and inference serving scenarios.
|
[
-0.583761096,
-0.7235632539,
0.4829321802,
0.6289322376,
-0.514760375,
0.2103885114,
-0.3100114167,
-0.2481588125,
0.2600006461,
0.5887765288,
-0.6033774018,
-0.3424508572,
-0.4342465997,
0.1581360251,
-0.1190693751,
0.8187024593,
0.0871031582,
-0.4567067325,
-0.2687769532,
0.2925681174,
-0.632165134,
-0.7241190076,
-0.3998864591,
0.139662385,
0.5221998096,
0.475145936,
0.572360158,
0.7195141912,
0.1989818811,
0.4033606052,
-0.0226234235,
0.1089959368,
-0.4280725121,
0.2540996075,
0.1277597845,
-0.6288889647,
-0.6129303575,
0.1714850515,
0.5744929314,
0.3065536916,
0.1011266783,
0.1576903909,
-0.072388269,
0.6301771998,
-0.9618953466,
-0.094004564,
-0.4952450991,
-0.183553502,
-0.6693123579,
-0.4332590401,
-0.7216510177,
-0.0872815475,
0.1667239368,
-0.6719579697,
0.1615462899,
0.1029509604,
0.8040316701,
0.3425003886,
0.0800612569,
-0.1476942301,
-0.6079941988,
0.7349077463,
-0.8683353066,
0.2301749438,
0.4114391804,
0.22733742,
-0.3180201352,
-0.9173522592,
-0.5809076428,
0.1113731489,
-0.3171781301,
-0.1100861207,
-0.1346439123,
0.2730252445,
0.5104573965,
0.1695871502,
-0.6056509614,
0.1048407108,
-0.3440922797,
-0.3099327981,
0.4164355695,
-0.2455257475,
0.1708349437,
-0.0294071995,
-0.2172658294,
-0.5008613467,
-0.8827539086,
0.2935801744,
0.4609058499,
0.4768165648,
-0.0529469252,
0.3489603698,
-0.2361375391,
0.9704936147,
0.2783870697,
-0.1853851527,
0.2355300635,
-0.345941633,
-0.3781103492,
0.1384379864,
0.5916922092,
-0.0066618007,
0.6576908827,
0.1086750031,
-0.0443308875,
-0.1734645069,
0.3971214592,
-1.1013834476,
-0.2638536096,
0.4334343374,
-0.1835978776,
-0.2872635722,
0.029325949,
-0.8554048538,
-0.0104451096,
-0.3043319583,
0.2854529023,
-0.1903240234,
0.0665608793,
0.379686296,
0.1326621324,
0.0154412445,
0.0468336642,
-0.6859679222,
0.0884275064,
0.6152145863,
0.7112565041,
-0.0310857315,
-0.2689271271,
-0.9505569935,
0.0238486622,
-0.1982036829,
1.0278947353,
-0.7101234794,
-0.5715686083,
-0.0527973138,
0.1210140735,
0.0302496757,
-0.3499285281,
0.4089409113,
-0.7347506285,
0.0371529162,
-0.3258316219,
-0.5193016529,
0.2459846884,
0.1735271215,
-0.7807883024,
0.6909889579,
-0.027139388,
-0.390624553,
0.2742779851,
-0.4277929664,
-0.7631213069,
0.2008717358,
-0.0943410844,
-0.4126696587,
0.2271756679,
0.5500116944,
0.5958135128,
-0.2258309424,
0.351079911,
0.0619230457,
-0.5310342312,
0.1757759005,
-0.1681601554,
0.5156226158,
0.2252210081,
-0.1527126729,
0.2765756845,
-0.6182898879,
0.0050053978,
-0.0461108312,
-0.2989859283,
-0.17280595,
-0.24803482,
-0.2430751771,
0.1831996739,
0.1309051067,
-0.2323948592,
0.5188301802,
-0.4183941782,
0.3037055433,
0.8231955767,
-0.2610586584,
0.5751497746,
-0.1663968414,
0.8780148625,
0.1968390644,
-0.0381276235,
-1.0690850019,
-0.3150433898,
-0.4308436811,
-0.4267784059,
0.5891212821,
0.5223543048,
-0.7387849689,
0.4203648269,
-0.3973636925,
-0.3950932324,
-0.4306738973,
-0.0815454125,
0.6302651167,
0.6753686666,
0.537799418,
-0.236127913,
-0.6007891893,
-0.7752808332,
-0.3426399231,
-0.1179026663,
-0.1634460539,
0.1547246128,
0.0759795383,
-0.1028588638,
1.1577239037,
-0.7229549885,
-0.1172313169,
-0.2411559671,
0.3270306587,
0.3249658346,
0.6534618139,
0.4165723622,
-0.6629615426,
-0.407792002,
-0.5249068737,
0.0435148142,
-0.3596599102,
-0.2369889617,
-0.1596533209,
0.3332958221,
0.7529911995,
-0.9120948315,
0.4977113307,
0.6256393194,
-0.285782814,
0.998147428,
-0.2859089971,
0.1787525117,
-0.8584478498,
0.0411557257,
-0.3992907703,
-0.1234108955,
-0.6090458632,
-0.1765736341,
0.1856793612,
-0.0896003544,
-0.630474627,
0.7547791004,
-0.5978969336,
0.0372538455,
-0.1977399588,
-0.1728559881,
0.4362874925,
0.3859913051,
0.0649093166,
0.987799108,
0.2324270904,
-0.7554712296,
0.0984544232,
0.1353348345,
-0.4026426673,
0.2268969715,
-0.6642848849,
0.2864147425,
-0.2420642972,
0.7054234743,
-1.0982202291,
-0.0855475143,
-0.0146783339,
-0.2705255151,
0.5344706178,
-0.3492928147,
-0.418225795,
-0.4582280815,
-0.3133898675,
0.9689489007,
0.6978933215,
-0.4564267397,
0.7761284709,
0.1523787975,
-0.2716342509,
-0.7053012252,
-0.5350056887,
-0.144596234,
-0.4172796309,
-0.6371921897,
0.6717298627,
-0.238847211,
0.1482340842,
-0.2744069397,
-0.09177351,
0.1971505135,
-0.0245896541,
0.0381376483,
0.2217684984,
-0.2768888772,
0.2750737369,
-0.0497144051,
-0.5009338856,
-0.1706933677,
-0.4278623462,
0.9300209284,
-0.0561453737,
-0.2523751557,
-0.0181928314,
0.3454258442,
0.4488696456,
-0.4008340836,
0.7598791718,
0.362224251,
-0.2401675582,
-0.1345476359,
-0.8994876146,
-0.3940866292,
-0.5536809564,
0.1991739273,
-0.7429561615,
-0.8785229325,
0.5784447193,
-0.2432203889,
0.0841485113,
0.1226788461,
0.2253722847,
-0.0525063686,
0.5641507506,
0.6056317687,
-0.1716776639,
0.3864462972,
0.0917630345,
0.5853188634,
-0.40903458,
0.0095585547,
-0.6913431883,
-0.3350167274,
-0.5454560518,
-0.8328564763,
-0.0107433088,
0.3595384359,
-0.2832226753,
0.3180415928,
-0.408223927,
0.8451126218,
0.50361377,
-0.1901779175,
0.191139698,
-0.0082824407,
-0.0843930468,
0.0596022122,
-0.6849725842,
-0.2787836194,
1.0087755919,
-0.0062815198,
0.6195108294,
-0.3994373679,
0.5706553459,
-0.1126198769,
0.196260646,
-0.6384302974,
0.5361146331,
-0.2146286219,
-0.3510855436,
-0.3621424735,
-0.1526591927,
-0.9280834794,
-0.1079338267,
-0.1512325108,
-0.8389547467,
0.1418421119,
0.6883118749,
-0.7730332613,
0.1416079849,
-0.6817842722,
0.8923919201,
-0.141134128,
-0.1529440135,
0.0472384356,
-0.8727775216,
0.2814262807,
-0.1899488717,
0.129978165,
0.0712623075,
0.1608899832,
0.7177264094,
-0.3909218609,
0.6685798764,
-0.1193932816,
0.004556776,
0.1910350025,
-0.0212332122,
0.7794944644,
-0.2081637681,
0.1672120988,
-0.0113413623,
0.0044814525,
-0.5569162965,
-0.7492649555,
0.3266169131,
-0.4376154244,
-0.8193936944,
-0.1062516943,
-0.3614720702,
-0.3097743392,
0.2374001592,
0.5872312188,
0.6136118174,
-0.0887753814,
0.0883885548,
0.8603944778,
-0.5285838842,
0.5066046715,
0.2122054696,
-0.3144108355,
-0.136729151,
0.7706869841,
0.1636989415,
0.2669715583,
0.5750266314,
0.2745001018,
-0.3486484289,
-0.3842827678,
-0.212729156,
0.3312990963,
-0.4904836416,
-0.2934820056,
-0.8882945776,
-0.1216622815,
-0.6199875474,
-0.5766320229,
-0.5940648317,
-0.2909981012,
0.0031317333,
-0.036424242,
0.3381150663,
0.1464614868,
0.0566257164,
0.8915418386,
-0.9771392345,
0.4022797942,
0.155053854,
0.3506743014,
-0.0354369357,
-0.1761709303,
-0.2413549721,
-0.0743414313,
0.0609413385,
-0.6703834534,
0.3913486898,
-0.1072389707,
0.303468883,
0.5552099943,
0.3102287948,
1.1430653334,
-0.6616088748,
0.6116870642,
-0.0558047704,
-0.9420747757,
0.4480580986,
-0.1329999119,
0.771361351,
0.6128172874,
0.3103574812,
-0.4297004938,
0.021514656,
-0.6480692625,
-1.2513315678,
0.5210975409,
-0.0484098122,
0.0607240535,
-0.132109344,
0.2053268254,
-0.0174572635,
0.2657672465,
-0.2461395562,
-0.0697302595,
0.0274790749,
-0.0111631099,
-0.6922001243,
-0.6299189925,
-0.047630351,
-0.3200488389,
0.5606396794,
-0.1880842447,
0.2709497511,
0.0023642718,
-0.358548373,
0.228423506,
0.3718433082,
0.8980226517,
0.5182747841,
-0.1433228105,
0.226195693,
0.0250297692,
-0.6390513182,
0.1351604015,
0.2301522642,
0.1078855246,
-0.0973415747,
0.4182177782,
0.8783096075,
0.3555316627,
-0.8051341772,
0.4527877271,
-0.1630520076,
0.2020531893,
-0.158170864,
-0.237218976,
0.1833001524,
-0.0345734991,
0.1848827451,
-0.1361262947,
-0.232663244,
-0.2561251819,
0.2363422066,
0.213872999,
0.0780978948,
-0.3359568417,
0.2505982518,
0.136062935,
-0.3115622103,
0.9336667657,
0.1512395293,
-0.5359233618,
0.629779458,
0.5842456222,
0.8875417113,
-0.5601739287,
0.0089136045,
0.3376276791,
0.185268119,
-0.1764225066,
-0.0179594643,
-0.367556572,
-0.7843086123,
-0.7893722057,
-0.9146948457,
-0.0063245515,
0.283847034,
-0.417337656,
0.3438269198,
-0.1237826496,
-0.1382187903,
-0.2797990739,
-0.0994980112,
-0.8736172915,
0.24171637,
-0.0542989448,
1.1371700764,
-0.8870478868,
0.72353369,
0.3740727007,
0.1666708291,
-1.0127341747,
0.127280131,
-0.0960579589,
-0.5195592046,
0.5688676834,
0.6318522692,
-0.113665536,
0.159077093,
-0.3603658974,
-0.9199964404,
0.7239578962,
0.3281943798,
-0.7147690058,
-0.2383560538,
0.2955363691,
0.2549031973,
-0.517678082,
0.2427593172,
1.027977705,
0.6895034909,
0.2180129886,
-0.5872034431,
0.2722079754,
-0.3435110152,
-0.0787876546,
0.1004004031,
-0.1428849399,
0.7662805915,
-0.0865669996,
-0.2180638611,
-0.0610887296,
0.5548480749,
0.7078957558,
0.0028343278,
0.6636995673,
0.582986474,
0.7340929508,
-0.0890886709,
1.1509766579,
-0.3729423285,
-0.2937852144,
1.2231839895,
-0.1220558956,
0.6188319921,
0.6680442691,
-0.0707812458,
0.3815273643,
0.6304234266,
0.4016601145,
0.4449993372,
0.5704834461,
-0.1876584291,
-0.2319406569,
0.1587513387,
-0.4189884365,
0.2644734085,
0.3382548094,
-0.0298466142,
-0.0859757438,
0.0232172925,
0.1716246605,
-0.2974954844,
-0.0168609433,
0.5985425711,
0.1302514821,
-1.1387586594,
0.4626873434,
-0.2068094462,
0.7130627036,
-0.692694962,
0.1142234579,
-0.1081525907,
0.0399178676,
0.0306486282,
-0.5333035588,
0.1685232967,
-0.0510770418,
-0.2348041385,
-0.6162775755,
0.8078511357,
-0.3367464542,
-0.2357149571,
0.1061746255,
0.5150045156,
0.126972422,
-0.3675142825,
-0.1338370889,
0.2628082037,
-0.3283163607,
-0.8798243403,
0.3801589608,
0.3037987351,
-0.286129266,
0.5147635341,
1.0485752821,
0.0757173002,
0.2048449963,
0.1050403938,
1.0122554302,
-0.5780125856,
-0.9969904423,
-1.1029070616,
1.0423932076,
0.0206353553,
-0.157587558,
0.4491265714,
0.3612502515,
0.8321395516,
-0.3702895045,
0.410964936,
0.1973517984,
0.0502046943,
-0.645529747,
0.5856337547,
-0.1984004527,
0.2160215378,
-0.3914167583,
-0.9729257822,
-0.2484016716,
0.4084842801,
-0.4032150507,
-0.0186217744,
0.4729649127,
0.7557958961,
-0.0622503161,
-0.1519979239,
0.3191394806,
0.1953289658,
0.3866750598,
0.3444963694,
0.6116989255,
-0.0722386613,
0.3004445434,
-0.2740498185,
-0.2321765572,
-0.20787552,
-1.3790735006,
-0.79520154,
-0.6988459229,
0.0204056054,
-0.2583887577,
-0.0502964407,
0.8341144323,
1.1066502333,
-0.7290361524,
-0.0421226583,
-0.1029637754,
-0.0574270152,
0.0199174881,
-0.2254221886,
0.3370856941,
-0.4659900665,
-0.5692216754,
0.4596996903,
0.230689615,
0.2564612925,
0.0129332682,
-0.0374468565,
-0.1416362524,
0.409609586,
0.5348311067,
0.4996015728,
-0.5256004333,
-0.0482330844,
0.0121688619,
0.2129983902,
0.1091982573,
1.2645082474,
-1.3007013798,
0.4587160647,
0.644056201,
0.874399662,
0.747992456,
0.3706874847,
0.9939444065,
-1.0663638115,
0.5821560621,
0.182584703,
0.2179919183,
0.1372852176,
-0.4793376625,
0.1780513972,
-0.0942099318,
-0.4528540373,
-0.9351456165,
0.5379760265,
-0.8786113262,
-0.4567604959,
0.633826375,
-0.4170843661,
-0.1970018595,
0.0678585321,
-0.0951495171,
0.3250419497,
-0.2785145342,
0.6212413311,
0.869143486,
0.1206817403,
-0.232292071,
-0.2384691685,
0.8680247664,
0.3965584636,
-0.8154895306,
0.0961849317,
0.1594194025,
-0.0808125511,
0.4102338254,
0.8823578358,
-0.0308801048,
0.1335370541,
-0.2070865929,
-0.1977591068,
-0.2550759912,
-0.7256839275,
-0.2229894549,
0.2029325515,
-0.3405545056,
0.0910029039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09516v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09516v1
|
State Space Model for New-Generation Network Alternative to Transformers: A Survey
| 2024-04-15T07:24:45 | 2024-04-15T07:24:45 |
Xiao Wang, Shiao Wang, Yuhe Ding, Yuehang Li, Wentao Wu, Yao Rong, Weizhe Kong, Ju Huang, Shihao Li, Haoxiang Yang, Ziwen Wang, Bo Jiang, Chenglong Li, Yaowei Wang, Yonghong Tian, Jin Tang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
In the post-deep learning era, the Transformer architecture has demonstrated
its powerful performance across pre-trained big models and various downstream
tasks. However, the enormous computational demands of this architecture have
deterred many researchers. To further reduce the complexity of attention
models, numerous efforts have been made to design more efficient methods. Among
them, the State Space Model (SSM), as a possible replacement for the
self-attention based Transformer model, has drawn more and more attention in
recent years. In this paper, we give the first comprehensive review of these
works and also provide experimental comparisons and analysis to better
demonstrate the features and advantages of SSM. Specifically, we first give a
detailed description of principles to help the readers quickly capture the key
ideas of SSM. After that, we dive into the reviews of existing SSMs and their
various applications, including natural language processing, computer vision,
graph, multi-modal and multi-media, point cloud/event stream, time series data,
and other domains. In addition, we give statistical comparisons and analysis of
these models and hope it helps the readers to understand the effectiveness of
different structures on various tasks. Then, we propose possible research
points in this direction to better promote the development of the theoretical
model and application of SSM. More related works will be continuously updated
on the following GitHub:
https://github.com/Event-AHU/Mamba_State_Space_Model_Paper_List.
|
[
-0.6364663243,
-0.5499175787,
0.4325589538,
0.0166122094,
-0.2677765787,
-0.096620582,
0.068168506,
-0.2867652178,
0.5477024913,
0.4255898297,
-0.4182472229,
-0.1504552066,
-0.6175184846,
0.0452095605,
-0.8052427769,
0.4836365283,
-0.2890393436,
-0.1850298941,
-0.292483896,
0.0069328714,
-0.4625581205,
-0.4869767129,
-0.6958299279,
-0.3391731977,
0.3254648745,
-0.103746146,
0.5625872016,
0.2878095806,
0.6799700856,
0.4485687017,
-0.3474951982,
0.0928973779,
-0.3986353278,
-0.0012205077,
-0.0760373548,
-0.3156596422,
-0.4473194778,
0.2086546719,
0.9869300723,
0.6537067294,
-0.1378010511,
0.142413646,
0.015424571,
0.8550195098,
-0.6510540247,
0.2480675876,
-0.6857141852,
0.3793992102,
0.051932916,
-0.1058432311,
-0.4333367646,
-0.4734638631,
0.0811558962,
-0.5102561712,
0.2741577625,
-0.0100967865,
0.8708360791,
0.5740815997,
-0.6485056281,
0.1370854974,
-1.0967999697,
0.6066536903,
-0.6196194291,
0.5117664337,
-0.257481575,
0.5749639273,
-0.2116071433,
-0.7121583223,
-0.7518954873,
-0.1461379677,
0.118467778,
0.4273804426,
-0.6049345136,
-0.1084918156,
-0.0398624279,
0.7003353238,
-0.1882582754,
0.0724844858,
-0.3374004364,
0.0550800823,
0.3882796466,
0.4016869962,
-0.030159317,
-0.6529175639,
-0.9051753283,
0.0524417907,
-0.7155038118,
0.1136814058,
0.3733408749,
0.3674844205,
-0.0211000014,
0.6083501577,
-0.4435223043,
0.576208055,
0.1004378721,
0.3343046308,
0.2153360844,
-0.4718276262,
-0.3152570724,
-0.311488539,
0.8614785075,
0.2444220185,
-0.0995343998,
-0.1647260934,
0.0136087649,
0.1232750416,
0.8137415648,
-0.7577184439,
-0.0955775604,
-0.0766156465,
-0.9377174973,
-0.1448406726,
-0.0935411826,
-0.6400844455,
-0.4450390041,
-0.4233677089,
0.229656443,
-0.3673961461,
-0.619814992,
-0.0309081022,
0.160038963,
0.3261221945,
0.3003596663,
-0.295290947,
0.4002220035,
0.5315877795,
1.1519290209,
-0.4958673716,
-0.0016234649,
0.1392451674,
-0.2767718732,
-0.3196280897,
0.8501728177,
-0.3186616302,
-0.4367986321,
-0.1609449089,
0.1941912621,
-0.3088229895,
-0.2675686479,
0.3299977183,
-0.7299997807,
-0.0263756197,
-0.0908290669,
-0.7029806376,
-0.3308383226,
0.1951615959,
-0.9518210292,
0.7597637773,
0.1258758903,
-0.5139026642,
0.2913514674,
-0.8946403861,
-0.4558286965,
0.0154382689,
0.1981727183,
-0.5196908116,
0.1673232168,
-0.081238009,
0.6082732081,
-0.2236417383,
0.2447422892,
-0.4611531496,
-0.1748267114,
0.1891990453,
-0.3578693867,
0.4792996645,
0.539731741,
-0.1563437283,
0.1668856591,
-0.7152922153,
-0.1075252816,
0.4247801602,
-0.3114397228,
-0.0477057062,
0.48898682,
-0.1284673661,
0.3736095726,
0.0699812174,
-0.7719323039,
0.0364649706,
-0.4470439851,
0.5588564277,
0.4075955749,
0.0549812689,
0.8165744543,
0.1612545401,
0.6881281137,
0.1629847139,
0.5326395035,
-0.3902516067,
-0.1634552181,
-0.7633273005,
0.0686152428,
0.2525064051,
0.2506995499,
-0.653842032,
0.4179062545,
-0.3228161335,
-0.5483680964,
-0.3346010149,
-0.0974564925,
-0.1374428123,
0.3959477246,
0.5184108615,
-0.2191551328,
-0.6530521512,
-0.9776014686,
0.0487205647,
0.0856747478,
0.4634104967,
0.2667685449,
0.4422618449,
-0.1362892091,
1.140478611,
-0.4623367786,
-0.2205565721,
-0.6275886893,
-0.4865677357,
0.1515668184,
0.2645531297,
0.3546981215,
-0.7301664352,
-0.1148881465,
-0.2125585526,
-0.6342408657,
0.4223828018,
0.074909173,
0.0524078608,
0.0174356587,
0.4039610922,
-0.776299119,
0.7324892879,
0.5708906651,
-0.0507467352,
0.338250041,
0.121728152,
0.2199693471,
-1.4351551533,
0.0892004818,
0.4026339054,
-0.0135277612,
-0.8228335977,
0.2395164222,
0.1193104982,
-0.5014201999,
-0.6754202247,
0.4806196988,
-0.5714046359,
-0.0817538798,
-0.7333431244,
0.0786225498,
-0.1885378361,
0.5453698635,
-0.1484100074,
0.5208291411,
0.3202400804,
-0.7214717865,
0.2321825624,
0.3061210513,
-0.4749628007,
0.2557752728,
-0.7148526311,
-0.0508887842,
-0.108423315,
0.5292495489,
-1.3877414465,
0.1792479306,
0.1488521099,
-0.2978146076,
0.2525927424,
-0.1526176184,
-0.4718832076,
-0.754812181,
0.0573929399,
0.2593360245,
0.4678607881,
-0.6399280429,
0.608980298,
0.7167606354,
0.200489983,
-0.1592997313,
-0.4785511196,
0.3145086169,
-0.1429767162,
-0.5088012815,
0.3398137689,
0.2979413867,
0.1635310203,
0.116613403,
-0.2575267255,
-0.0155153247,
0.3215297759,
0.4675172269,
0.4001760483,
-0.3130251765,
-0.0570300743,
-0.1180455014,
-0.4653497934,
-0.0245719478,
-0.3150254786,
0.5758511424,
-0.3441001475,
-0.3880924881,
-0.5713196993,
0.2262188196,
0.3137183487,
-0.4057264626,
0.7437013984,
0.3863746524,
-0.3914182186,
-0.0067903521,
-0.4153545797,
-0.0384038389,
-0.4611423314,
0.4909913242,
-0.1932665706,
-1.0699081421,
0.31065768,
-0.5349580646,
-0.0078196824,
0.5632629991,
0.4292362928,
-0.2392927557,
0.9354456663,
0.7939317226,
-0.2256527394,
0.6137347817,
-0.4731498361,
0.6158123612,
-1.0966176987,
-0.1259837151,
-0.3697616458,
-0.6121868491,
-0.5342931747,
-0.4088918865,
0.2170337737,
-0.0064718514,
0.0566185527,
0.6646841764,
-0.490332067,
0.2855621874,
0.084613584,
-0.1021755785,
-0.0248899106,
-0.017436441,
0.0605115891,
0.1738922298,
-0.9963052273,
-0.594412446,
0.8830478787,
0.4748969674,
0.7640970945,
-0.0343184881,
0.3432583213,
0.0147811957,
0.3467651606,
-0.7746133208,
0.7091089487,
-0.2994688451,
-0.6648278236,
-0.4904963374,
-0.4869852066,
-1.2107999325,
0.4935620129,
-0.1714656651,
-0.6115757823,
0.1712230295,
0.2096069902,
-0.3283745944,
0.8277640939,
-0.7050357461,
0.5741913319,
0.086373888,
-0.1063879952,
-0.272359252,
-0.4558919668,
0.4597012401,
0.1696747839,
-0.2287327498,
-0.1300825328,
0.1613604426,
0.4994493723,
-0.4496670365,
0.8672657013,
-0.4554133415,
0.0409362502,
0.6112499237,
-0.0561003089,
0.3560075164,
-0.2357093245,
-0.1238238662,
0.428052783,
-0.3130480945,
-0.0746617615,
-0.4734713435,
0.6342839003,
-0.7245169282,
-0.5616208911,
-0.0957129747,
-0.4442915022,
-0.1607735306,
0.3347978294,
-0.0150866089,
0.5579518676,
-0.2908512354,
0.7137739062,
0.5646531582,
-0.2259111553,
0.6514747739,
0.2929938734,
-0.1622822434,
-0.0916117504,
0.5586509705,
0.1574888825,
0.1037233546,
0.5473892689,
-0.0494749695,
-0.5969837904,
-0.5459929109,
-0.2880486846,
-0.0776730478,
-0.5073094964,
-0.2141975909,
-0.8439301848,
-0.5764329433,
-0.2928270698,
0.3030744791,
-0.7238165736,
-0.3264107406,
-0.2116097063,
-0.1638911813,
0.0610494502,
0.6238768697,
0.3724219501,
0.5403473973,
-0.2114483863,
0.5135856271,
0.007479215,
0.6199079156,
0.4648860395,
-0.3373176157,
-0.2553074658,
-0.2506764233,
-0.6350077987,
-0.9594953656,
0.1192587391,
-0.0704577118,
0.8914346099,
0.2483621985,
-0.197801888,
0.5771409273,
-0.7636751533,
0.7729449272,
0.5529722571,
-0.7255726457,
0.5197073221,
-0.1111264527,
0.3666119576,
0.3585316241,
0.230186075,
-0.5489076972,
-0.2464170158,
-0.5508620739,
-0.7726979852,
0.5536411405,
0.3003162146,
0.2377165109,
0.0061759781,
0.5260382295,
-0.045208592,
0.2399968952,
-0.6904430985,
-0.4531021118,
-0.5996882915,
-0.0462681688,
-0.1799051017,
-0.0028477763,
0.342658937,
-0.1879065484,
0.5706170797,
-0.1516277492,
0.6517793536,
0.1140421405,
-0.1766949147,
-0.0161270574,
0.4115816057,
0.2755917013,
0.6090288758,
0.3143484294,
0.0850980952,
0.4691955447,
-0.2174874842,
0.5206297636,
0.0805725083,
-0.4160063565,
0.048846256,
-0.152658388,
1.1629354954,
0.4911622703,
0.1794589758,
0.534326911,
-0.0346034653,
-0.5046624541,
-0.3255037367,
0.4082804322,
0.2544754148,
0.3699100614,
0.269623518,
0.4828790128,
0.2364396751,
-0.1556918919,
-0.164888382,
0.5693994164,
-0.5260369778,
-0.3069173992,
0.840433836,
0.2152788639,
-0.4252182245,
0.3396453857,
-0.0569760054,
-0.3274251819,
0.5981048346,
0.5287721157,
0.7863074541,
-0.2722206712,
0.3308551013,
0.3251429498,
0.5181227326,
0.1028431505,
0.1011034101,
-0.0548270606,
-0.8972647786,
-0.5431998372,
-0.5829476714,
-0.2078549117,
0.4259024858,
-0.5821629167,
-0.0607946739,
-0.5322583318,
-0.6509606838,
-0.1623605341,
0.0526399724,
-0.8338291049,
0.2760143876,
0.2164702564,
1.1315808296,
-0.6395581365,
0.6923307776,
0.6676251292,
-0.0883731991,
-0.7291799188,
-0.2277970612,
-0.1707389057,
-0.4317299426,
0.2523561418,
0.0819758922,
-0.2783682942,
-0.0581238307,
-0.3097560704,
-1.2518355846,
1.1882810593,
0.0936905518,
-0.5908794403,
0.1466842294,
0.0371125601,
0.5535676479,
-0.1678324044,
0.0810362324,
0.1822966635,
0.262341857,
-0.0737611577,
-0.1995810866,
0.0014523253,
-0.4963220656,
0.5215228796,
0.5232100487,
-1.0635697842,
0.7479476929,
-0.0271772426,
-0.4228146374,
0.161104545,
1.22204566,
0.134677887,
0.1992007941,
1.016772151,
0.3822168708,
0.4060118496,
-0.1775697619,
0.9767712951,
-0.3789438903,
0.4469303191,
0.9778398871,
-0.5456097126,
0.7677924037,
0.5734869242,
-0.4023403823,
0.4118051529,
0.5789486766,
-0.3181644976,
0.4517133832,
0.1614882052,
0.2830799222,
-0.1214853153,
0.1977354139,
-0.3628592193,
0.2943882048,
-0.0470527187,
-0.1585962474,
-0.2526643276,
-0.0276295617,
-0.3232286274,
-0.170820117,
-0.3553121686,
0.5502291322,
0.2084952444,
-0.3974019885,
-0.0369615927,
0.1397229135,
0.5921786427,
-0.5663163662,
0.2234937996,
-0.2686872482,
0.1251506507,
-0.1705173105,
-0.654878974,
0.3554013669,
0.1264578253,
-0.4152855277,
-0.2359022349,
1.0234508514,
0.1494541615,
-0.3954696655,
0.2242694795,
0.4424043894,
0.0758902952,
0.0813917667,
-0.7148191333,
-0.1528623253,
-0.3135803938,
-0.4470278919,
0.0860512629,
-0.0475974977,
0.1247422993,
0.7835583091,
0.6769298315,
0.0518665537,
0.4076112211,
0.2988337278,
0.611780405,
-0.6063068509,
-0.9362447262,
-0.6016981602,
0.3732538223,
-0.208714813,
-0.2987897992,
0.9372107387,
0.5092417002,
0.6793426275,
-0.0136854509,
0.7915538549,
0.0508145913,
0.4026043117,
-0.3885449767,
0.6662366986,
-0.7041594386,
-0.2225189209,
-0.343315661,
-1.0006184578,
0.1259750724,
0.5429140925,
-0.3659915924,
0.2929404676,
0.7448477745,
0.5578476787,
-0.1940650046,
0.5778181553,
0.1895530373,
0.0820790529,
0.2383056283,
0.3807359934,
1.4318271875,
-0.5339711905,
0.5980452299,
-0.0189088862,
0.0527977757,
-0.2926518917,
-0.7391633391,
-0.6580907106,
-0.8187060952,
-0.3091570139,
-0.0041897977,
-0.4723356366,
0.4575313628,
1.1496118307,
-0.6260160804,
-0.0187184811,
-0.0909987837,
0.0553710908,
-0.1905789375,
-0.180454731,
0.1805746704,
-0.1680931896,
-0.4309514761,
0.5894767046,
0.33231619,
0.0470195971,
-0.5154226422,
-0.0189140029,
-0.1398101747,
0.0823839158,
0.7867829204,
-0.0259791203,
-0.6436354518,
-0.0862779021,
0.1371668875,
-0.093009986,
0.2317474484,
0.9788011909,
-0.6896634698,
0.066427663,
0.3915182948,
0.7503352165,
0.6942517161,
-0.0817221478,
0.1380953193,
-0.4565733969,
-0.1285197139,
-0.1407674104,
0.6977342963,
0.2906652987,
-0.3641872704,
0.4353697002,
0.1278652996,
-0.3358824849,
-0.5283960104,
0.2299955636,
-0.9471043348,
-0.3936975598,
0.9559838772,
0.1041137204,
-0.4249722362,
0.1800028384,
-0.0103309164,
0.6002219319,
-0.0463408828,
0.8261292577,
0.4868371189,
-0.0805887431,
-0.2151079029,
-0.5252984762,
0.0157425217,
0.3371861875,
-1.0263543129,
-0.1928683966,
0.1464828104,
0.2537648082,
0.1245285943,
0.4912680089,
-0.304792583,
0.0754611939,
-0.2461972833,
0.157763496,
-0.2604213655,
-0.643943727,
-0.6518137455,
0.4928507209,
-0.4811337292,
-0.4432500005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09492v1
|
Bridging the Gap between Different Vocabularies for LLM Ensemble
| 2024-04-15T06:28:20 | 2024-04-15T06:28:20 |
Yangyifan Xu, Jinliang Lu, Jiajun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Ensembling different large language models (LLMs) to unleash their
complementary potential and harness their individual strengths is highly
valuable. Nevertheless, vocabulary discrepancies among various LLMs have
constrained previous studies to either selecting or blending completely
generated outputs. This limitation hinders the dynamic correction and
enhancement of outputs during the generation process, resulting in a limited
capacity for effective ensemble. To address this issue, we propose a novel
method to Ensemble LLMs via Vocabulary Alignment (EVA). EVA bridges the lexical
gap among various LLMs, enabling meticulous ensemble at each generation step.
Specifically, we first learn mappings between the vocabularies of different
LLMs with the assistance of overlapping tokens. Subsequently, these mappings
are employed to project output distributions of LLMs into a unified space,
facilitating a fine-grained ensemble. Finally, we design a filtering strategy
to exclude models that generate unfaithful tokens. Experimental results on
commonsense reasoning, arithmetic reasoning, machine translation, and
data-to-text generation tasks demonstrate the superiority of our approach
compared with individual LLMs and previous ensemble methods conducted on
complete outputs. Further analyses confirm that our approach can leverage
knowledge from different language models and yield consistent improvement.
|
[
-0.4156343639,
-0.5776690841,
0.4377910793,
-0.0431923904,
-0.1832498014,
0.8677177429,
-0.3779141307,
-0.4279568195,
0.2827396691,
0.598629117,
-0.3716846108,
-0.5234311819,
-0.5060005188,
0.0281892568,
-0.3844740987,
0.7220404148,
-0.1040121987,
-0.023397956,
-0.4397616982,
0.0062241452,
-0.5850000381,
-0.1879729331,
-0.3720629513,
-0.4724315107,
0.3389760852,
0.3504181504,
0.4395152926,
0.5546987653,
0.3489851058,
0.3946559727,
-0.0077350568,
0.8886774182,
-0.4645859003,
0.2668968141,
-0.2740240991,
-0.3275103867,
-0.3918800652,
-0.3810941875,
0.6692479849,
0.6409364343,
-0.2149112076,
0.0821323842,
0.3745363951,
0.395239234,
-0.7304041386,
-0.4082416892,
-1.2509596348,
-0.1113293171,
-0.4666372836,
-0.2075571567,
-0.3685970008,
0.0867383257,
-0.2313620746,
-0.5577445626,
0.0864115283,
0.1413250417,
0.8923022151,
0.2488981038,
-0.029589165,
0.0392617099,
-0.6205772161,
0.8863220215,
-0.6540957689,
0.2097097635,
0.0018362537,
0.009927189,
-0.2595579624,
-0.5220558047,
-0.7855538726,
0.3298630118,
0.0909415409,
0.1747008115,
-0.2624920607,
0.1755358279,
-0.3534759283,
0.2386181802,
-0.3892739117,
0.654376328,
-0.3375529051,
-0.3252774179,
0.650767982,
0.1102981195,
0.3063583672,
-0.1456850022,
-0.7040760517,
-0.2514947653,
-0.9298884869,
-0.2594765425,
0.5642891526,
0.6035898328,
-0.0699459165,
0.6746196151,
0.2401818931,
0.525688529,
0.097661078,
0.0748966634,
0.1528093964,
-0.3461135924,
-0.2951963842,
0.2451404184,
0.7994644642,
0.2787985504,
-0.0361162424,
-0.2226012349,
-0.3857432604,
0.1204804555,
0.21084252,
-0.2376632094,
0.1227126047,
0.4168554842,
0.0811038166,
-0.3843097091,
0.0088675134,
-1.074706912,
-0.1662095785,
-0.4097673893,
0.5575631261,
-0.2160336077,
-0.1537637115,
-0.0382510386,
-0.0524790101,
-0.0422730967,
0.1572220623,
-0.8780886531,
0.4119843245,
0.891313374,
0.7574400306,
-0.2422130257,
-0.4122228026,
-0.7263787985,
0.2848373652,
-0.4287356734,
0.7012236714,
-0.7455815077,
-0.3472019136,
0.2050303221,
-0.2903196514,
-0.1228787675,
-0.4514231384,
0.2592380941,
-0.4600234032,
0.1593588144,
0.1797570288,
-0.8708777428,
0.0694675222,
-0.0007025447,
-0.3155392408,
1.270496726,
-0.0200033113,
-0.5310703516,
0.1772342622,
-0.2581872046,
-0.0582417697,
0.3582287431,
-0.4141852856,
-0.1031489521,
0.2284770161,
0.347699672,
0.4790611565,
-0.1431916356,
0.2234848589,
-0.1948699653,
-0.1745556444,
0.1561475545,
-0.4682433009,
0.3713424504,
0.2521300316,
0.0168876946,
0.1850896031,
-0.618734479,
0.0752759501,
-0.1661037058,
-0.2639934421,
-0.6443237066,
-0.0579913855,
0.0728472546,
-0.1257930845,
0.5049042702,
-0.4222527444,
0.3612779379,
-0.5723792911,
0.3368315101,
0.9734867811,
-0.2215485871,
0.6790088415,
-0.4217589498,
0.4828864038,
0.0063376515,
-0.3975054622,
-0.0582994297,
-0.1493400931,
-0.6733896136,
-0.4423820674,
0.6322212815,
0.502060771,
-0.7579115033,
0.8866007328,
-0.5448414683,
-0.5031475425,
-0.7096927166,
0.4100340009,
0.3372736275,
0.3447732031,
0.2561059296,
-0.3048712313,
-0.5942510962,
-0.5950425267,
-0.1131352261,
-0.2455052286,
-0.1179816648,
0.0390695184,
0.2471571565,
-0.0768396631,
0.8186876178,
-0.1877399385,
-0.1946332753,
-0.3612282872,
0.0165219586,
0.1049187481,
0.4121155739,
0.1715334803,
-0.5077819228,
-0.1389733553,
0.3266869485,
-0.3585276902,
-0.4031442702,
-0.2553073466,
-0.5782210231,
0.2027256042,
0.5742420554,
-0.5540314317,
0.0606424585,
0.663602829,
-0.2079023719,
0.2794651091,
-0.2167341858,
-0.1020196453,
-1.367718339,
-0.2900804579,
-0.1519516706,
-0.2052612901,
-0.5777668953,
0.0926566124,
-0.1253076941,
0.3077906072,
-0.4564258754,
0.9063776731,
-0.5024753809,
-0.1207970232,
-0.0907521769,
0.4169887602,
0.1205283254,
0.3062929511,
-0.1336407512,
0.5773289204,
0.6069414616,
-0.6031227112,
0.0527673624,
0.3331310749,
-0.2730240226,
0.3200522065,
-0.1777818501,
-0.0706136078,
-0.021380106,
0.1402598768,
-0.9723066688,
-0.3995154202,
-0.0301614087,
-0.3879390955,
0.5606786013,
0.0191064682,
-0.3511312008,
-0.1795539707,
-0.2088460922,
0.4572784901,
0.6840746999,
-0.7791105509,
0.8099220991,
0.4777806699,
-0.2447634488,
-0.6826093793,
-0.5732661486,
0.1154986098,
-0.6321541071,
-0.6746941209,
0.7163642645,
0.3423925936,
-0.5496698022,
-0.0811774731,
-0.1548120528,
0.1795801073,
0.0448295251,
0.0322649032,
0.5767681003,
-0.2465878278,
0.5096305013,
0.1472635269,
0.3612979352,
-0.3648947179,
-0.3144038618,
0.854251802,
0.0617574826,
-0.5232704282,
0.0026253411,
0.3381049335,
0.5267491341,
-0.3368396163,
0.5963249803,
0.442760855,
-0.4047450721,
-0.5107076764,
-0.634835124,
-0.0952735543,
-0.5076269507,
0.2655054331,
-0.1304674149,
-0.955209136,
0.5781168938,
-0.0805680156,
0.4083127975,
0.4421418309,
0.5766812563,
-0.0134525131,
0.6909458637,
0.4354918003,
-0.1552875191,
0.3110702932,
-0.0273177754,
0.356041491,
-1.0574311018,
0.0178471431,
-0.34217152,
-0.4114738405,
-0.6630163193,
-0.685537219,
0.2639847994,
0.3763027191,
-0.2227794975,
0.2176375836,
-0.5702211857,
0.5466920137,
0.4094573557,
-0.1343025863,
0.2400952131,
0.3729761541,
-0.2052014917,
0.1608578712,
-0.8566464186,
-0.7455300689,
1.1430991888,
0.2118340731,
0.629563272,
0.2879839838,
1.128898859,
0.1003839895,
0.1321221441,
-0.4424009323,
0.5440131426,
-0.3243789077,
-0.0737519413,
-0.4930018485,
-0.2833470404,
-1.0998747349,
0.5910182595,
-0.3187574446,
-1.0592684746,
0.0022097109,
0.0044529312,
-0.5794696808,
0.5651931167,
-0.6514555216,
0.467320323,
-0.2529328167,
-0.6502099037,
-0.1362766176,
-0.4076170325,
0.5368668437,
-0.3031281829,
0.3781932294,
-0.2073254734,
-0.143048659,
0.4874437451,
-0.5401108265,
0.8818405867,
0.2818603516,
-0.2007001191,
0.4630564153,
0.1649615616,
0.4408883154,
-0.1593661159,
0.0167071167,
0.3775011897,
-0.2341820747,
-0.2895153761,
-0.372284174,
0.8684619069,
-0.6190570593,
-0.7297542691,
-0.2111092061,
-0.572637856,
-0.3609527349,
-0.0393549427,
0.2994603217,
0.2920955718,
-0.2768647671,
-0.1589137912,
0.3908141851,
-0.0867883787,
0.575607717,
0.2071806639,
-0.2643834651,
-0.3196955025,
0.9726747274,
-0.014170073,
0.4134347737,
0.529640913,
0.0389958955,
-0.3806760311,
-0.4880039096,
-0.5191485286,
0.0306447577,
-0.380744338,
-0.4561578929,
-0.486928165,
-0.2565245628,
-0.5064193606,
-0.3508058786,
-0.3097728789,
-0.3619336486,
-0.3239800632,
-0.0691457689,
0.4798211455,
0.4874276817,
-0.3161102533,
0.2741779089,
-0.9458964467,
-0.1050816253,
0.1959422082,
-0.0797364637,
0.1499243081,
-0.4809393585,
0.1281706989,
0.0525260903,
-0.5698161721,
-0.6562655568,
0.5611567497,
0.3693259954,
0.4781202376,
0.3427215219,
-0.1116860136,
0.9492699504,
-0.5701517463,
0.9489312172,
0.5135461688,
-1.0113084316,
0.3360078037,
-0.3111519516,
0.0912017524,
0.3287996054,
-0.2214676738,
-0.4988117516,
-0.6232737899,
-0.759264648,
-1.277710557,
0.2152911872,
0.3862164319,
0.190508604,
-0.1708428264,
0.0202398449,
0.2150484771,
0.1187516898,
-0.3886157274,
0.1671595722,
0.2275190055,
-0.5579468012,
-0.1416863799,
0.3066613078,
-0.2588459551,
-0.1407327354,
0.7395489812,
-0.2195355743,
-0.0188169945,
0.0366107784,
-0.000184739,
-0.2457462996,
0.3690227568,
0.3742229044,
0.3189640343,
0.3781329095,
0.4064822495,
0.4301348925,
-0.0769624785,
0.0158053394,
-0.0511032157,
0.1738073379,
0.0178019833,
0.543332696,
0.6828620434,
0.346036464,
-0.9168125987,
0.3696891963,
0.3173267543,
-0.1465688944,
-0.227128908,
0.2697437406,
0.2302878499,
0.3088884652,
0.184442997,
0.1249669865,
-0.3727806509,
-0.523455739,
0.3091565967,
0.6328214407,
0.1176964045,
-0.0960850567,
0.5079701543,
0.2436649054,
-0.3090804517,
0.433303237,
-0.040672984,
-0.4649652541,
0.7190209627,
0.3539429009,
0.7686977386,
-0.2587866187,
0.1174222007,
0.2404815257,
0.0643126294,
-0.2912795544,
0.0355469845,
-0.0893584266,
-1.1381764412,
-0.4846101999,
-0.9724241495,
-0.2590662539,
0.2562933564,
-0.4873186946,
0.3581376076,
-0.0144252758,
0.1427796781,
0.0151731363,
-0.2292816341,
-0.6940043569,
-0.2663315535,
0.3170957565,
0.7681050301,
-0.8387960792,
0.6119844913,
0.4359919131,
-0.2164462209,
-0.8632971048,
0.092937164,
0.0102426112,
-1.1621783972,
0.3678373098,
-0.0238796659,
-0.0656282753,
-0.1012332588,
-0.4134507477,
-0.8685789108,
0.9958157539,
0.0668126717,
-1.0302810669,
-0.0529725924,
0.1015261337,
0.5674338341,
-0.7513971329,
-0.0403662734,
0.6011253595,
0.411138624,
0.2851762772,
-0.82744205,
-0.276524663,
-0.040603593,
-0.0738899112,
0.5512108803,
-0.5220160484,
0.6199999452,
-0.0433422886,
-0.4211479127,
0.37878263,
0.6672282219,
0.5702305436,
0.2210318446,
0.6317668557,
0.7438679338,
1.0761275291,
-0.0427648947,
0.6287593842,
-0.2675800323,
0.0299424436,
1.2735774517,
-0.5397340655,
1.1000515223,
0.8646370769,
-0.1403658241,
0.3837954998,
0.7522988915,
-0.1172638312,
0.3538859785,
0.5267164111,
-0.4408361614,
-0.539560318,
-0.1458225399,
-0.1366900057,
0.5650616884,
0.577549994,
-0.1041325331,
-0.3004564047,
-0.1371124536,
-0.2581948638,
0.3757043183,
-0.4991812408,
0.7643513083,
-0.024815131,
-0.9163326025,
0.4953759611,
-0.2551141083,
0.8317863345,
-0.3469701111,
-0.0069896099,
-0.1068534926,
0.0037459207,
-0.2503848672,
-0.7683342695,
0.1333771646,
0.2277167737,
0.1879640073,
-0.1460303366,
0.6353680491,
-0.8068273067,
-0.6427029967,
0.2149995118,
0.8195439577,
0.3407688439,
0.510727942,
-0.2068794668,
0.0484401584,
0.011868543,
-0.0027303607,
0.4204789996,
0.4879806638,
-0.1537252665,
0.384172529,
0.5760620236,
0.3815692067,
0.1004201919,
0.1791920811,
0.6882716417,
-0.2105802298,
-0.3428010941,
-0.9649261236,
0.4909359217,
-0.1585631073,
-0.444191426,
0.4868343174,
0.4903643727,
0.9795919061,
0.2296962738,
0.7660155296,
0.1790262014,
0.2923214436,
-0.821470499,
0.3707261682,
-0.7750729322,
0.6106897593,
-0.0499781556,
-0.9821895361,
-0.077405408,
0.3633500338,
0.1030085608,
-0.3036522865,
0.3349457979,
0.9903553128,
-0.1528373361,
-0.1537510604,
0.4695380032,
0.1945720762,
0.1490241438,
0.4910750389,
0.9145311117,
-0.2105830759,
0.3307647705,
0.1763753444,
-0.0215105321,
-0.0033045236,
-0.8321465254,
-0.6184297204,
-0.5926100016,
-0.2070504278,
-0.1891073585,
-0.0207403023,
1.063755393,
0.4183738828,
-0.4245545268,
-0.236334309,
-0.3993198276,
0.2664031386,
-0.2172033638,
-0.2250638604,
0.2132397443,
-0.4161466658,
-0.9715641737,
0.5359535217,
0.180029586,
0.1935866177,
-0.5269436836,
-0.0860086158,
0.0835000798,
0.4600489438,
0.2302406132,
0.043439392,
-1.0654430389,
-0.4624896049,
-0.1426243037,
0.0555219166,
0.1298999786,
0.4522998929,
-0.7694227099,
0.2539414763,
0.5277680159,
0.8157770038,
0.1052757278,
-0.1165681928,
0.6221481562,
-1.1187911034,
-0.0380466953,
0.2544843554,
0.5913378596,
0.41844666,
-0.3926614821,
0.404629916,
-0.1406784207,
-0.4872713089,
-1.1203118563,
0.2382565886,
-1.0122065544,
-0.4864222109,
1.2474000454,
0.2383998036,
-0.2254433781,
0.1978700608,
-0.0231369045,
0.311976105,
-0.4264749587,
0.866556704,
0.9699918032,
0.0290801078,
0.2625032067,
-0.1559868753,
0.1264113784,
0.5359901786,
-0.6712206006,
0.2077438384,
0.2623053491,
0.015755916,
0.3510524929,
0.1894548386,
0.0495246202,
-0.0577273555,
-0.0946586281,
0.3157925308,
0.2933433354,
-0.1703116894,
-0.4216698706,
0.1828182936,
-0.2390814126,
-0.224844709
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09486v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09486v1
|
MMCode: Evaluating Multi-Modal Code Large Language Models with Visually Rich Programming Problems
| 2024-04-15T06:15:46 | 2024-04-15T06:15:46 |
Kaixin Li, Yuchen Tian, Qisheng Hu, Ziyang Luo, Jing Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.SE
|
Programming often involves converting detailed and complex specifications
into code, a process during which developers typically utilize visual aids to
more effectively convey concepts. While recent developments in Large Multimodal
Models have demonstrated remarkable abilities in visual reasoning and
mathematical tasks, there is little work on investigating whether these models
can effectively interpret visual elements for code generation. To this end, we
present MMCode, the first multi-modal coding dataset for evaluating algorithmic
problem-solving skills in visually rich contexts. MMCode contains 3,548
questions and 6,620 images collected from real-world programming challenges
harvested from 10 code competition websites, presenting significant challenges
due to the extreme demand for reasoning abilities. Our experiment results show
that current state-of-the-art models struggle to solve these problems. The
results highlight the lack of powerful vision-code models, and we hope MMCode
can serve as an inspiration for future works in this domain. The data and code
are publicly available at https://github.com/happylkx/MMCode.
|
[
-0.4918213785,
-0.5351602435,
0.5544144511,
0.3424629867,
-0.1699631661,
-0.0423566513,
-0.0799371228,
-0.4138329029,
-0.158528015,
0.420830965,
-0.7333362103,
-0.4308332205,
-0.5116244555,
0.2468829453,
-0.3929667473,
0.6795610785,
-0.0210408363,
0.1561894268,
-0.4968777597,
-0.0075255088,
-0.5578585267,
-0.6058403254,
0.1003001779,
0.3058046103,
0.2706563473,
0.5985468626,
0.5504089594,
0.4316516221,
0.823833406,
0.3544102013,
0.2860438228,
0.4263848364,
-0.4437993467,
-0.0387506895,
0.1651383042,
-0.5164416432,
-0.2615501881,
0.0351030938,
0.2627726495,
0.6329621673,
0.1558429301,
0.4609376788,
-0.1672646105,
0.4106090367,
-0.6485669613,
0.5776056051,
-0.4647300839,
0.0861055553,
0.0938691795,
-0.5323926806,
-0.5540862679,
-0.2536919415,
-0.253724426,
-0.5248107314,
-0.070359461,
0.0836922675,
0.4588641226,
0.1898196638,
-0.5881898999,
-0.6412815452,
-0.5915112495,
0.7888495922,
-0.4879889488,
0.4690819979,
0.436785996,
0.3547578752,
0.0964810401,
-0.4401648045,
-0.655120194,
-0.4541042447,
0.4168541133,
0.0968817994,
-0.2756837606,
-0.2456846833,
0.4384536147,
0.1909622699,
-0.6060445905,
-0.1718239039,
-0.7068032622,
-0.071723856,
0.5439514518,
0.2602566779,
0.406948626,
-0.4599747956,
-0.1298147589,
-0.1981938034,
-0.2708070278,
0.0256927814,
0.2456216663,
-0.1341707855,
-0.3926202953,
0.8567904234,
-0.2892918587,
0.7668542266,
-0.5081775188,
-0.3182567656,
0.3879743814,
-0.5338424444,
-0.1950027347,
-0.4248563945,
0.4274591804,
0.7771704197,
0.4913403988,
0.1694275737,
-0.3664692938,
0.389464438,
0.2242371589,
-0.8242602348,
-0.2139299512,
0.1342711151,
-0.6654233336,
-0.2567292154,
0.0977074504,
-0.7695476413,
-0.3764374852,
-0.3887532949,
0.3193327188,
-0.3165600002,
-0.1755699515,
0.3377564549,
-0.2503365874,
0.1288086325,
0.424479425,
-0.4724426866,
-0.3145149052,
0.5050374269,
0.6762108803,
0.376331687,
-0.4927789867,
-0.4921295643,
-0.0932010487,
-0.3876649737,
0.4538873434,
-0.8284625411,
-0.2735571563,
-0.0199849736,
-0.2458718121,
0.0880225673,
-0.6220559478,
0.2709932923,
-0.4242774546,
-0.1141814366,
-0.0022371109,
-0.1490672231,
0.0432421379,
0.3397736549,
-0.7509166002,
0.5444968939,
0.1795346141,
-0.54090482,
0.2514300346,
-0.8249348402,
-0.1417188495,
-0.1118407473,
-0.4211125374,
-0.2479034513,
0.35463503,
0.2506619692,
0.4861203134,
-0.3708196878,
0.0805567205,
-0.4521375597,
-0.3413923383,
0.7128144503,
-0.600697279,
0.6458390951,
0.4760085642,
-0.2269628048,
0.1953097582,
-0.9375357628,
0.0875454172,
0.4605898261,
-0.3883306384,
-0.0827634558,
-0.1102821305,
0.1688151956,
0.5476747751,
0.0950897262,
-0.4054016173,
0.4650329351,
0.1444243789,
0.5582296252,
0.7074661255,
-0.2007743716,
0.0703822151,
-0.1120769233,
0.6441777349,
0.1059585735,
0.4862001538,
-0.5398344994,
-0.8167879581,
-0.6235647202,
-0.1591190547,
0.1821385473,
0.5308961272,
-1.2427848577,
-0.1266022623,
-0.3146736324,
-0.1957626343,
-0.6185042858,
0.267457962,
0.4934520721,
0.1550648659,
0.2494001836,
-0.4345095754,
-0.3181968033,
-0.8939976096,
0.2152297646,
0.2081459463,
0.0019651265,
0.771689117,
0.8356110454,
-0.6692793965,
0.7116157413,
-0.7258923054,
-0.1129355133,
-0.0819380432,
0.2311448604,
-0.0234708544,
0.5515492558,
0.5979893804,
-0.9159738421,
-0.0824472085,
0.066175513,
-0.9085103273,
-0.2678909004,
-0.2533282042,
0.0155620407,
-0.0500516742,
0.4852354527,
-0.3336017132,
0.3391369283,
0.9723199606,
-0.5009489059,
0.8699982762,
-0.3576230109,
0.6289879084,
-0.6773211956,
0.1629580855,
0.1334693283,
-0.0249852762,
-0.2888720334,
0.5600287914,
0.2047717422,
-0.6563260555,
-0.2978077531,
0.1804606766,
-0.6156705022,
-0.278580606,
-0.0866748914,
-0.2182576358,
-0.0127468463,
0.7033733726,
-0.2962296605,
0.9204472303,
0.5476804376,
-0.3530207574,
0.6942791939,
0.0844318792,
-0.6749543548,
0.5783248544,
-0.4703444242,
0.2015249878,
-0.1819554418,
-0.1378601938,
-0.7786948085,
-0.4157037437,
-0.0249068253,
-0.4173818231,
-0.045116812,
-0.322432965,
-0.6550872326,
-0.6121363044,
-0.2436810881,
0.749861598,
0.40203619,
-0.3285985887,
0.2237371206,
0.2139981687,
0.0424301215,
-0.2053634226,
-0.747500658,
0.2329676151,
0.1173258796,
-0.5758469701,
-0.1525162458,
-0.483643502,
-0.0912787691,
-0.0510511398,
-0.0938097984,
-0.4833753705,
0.0895334408,
0.2189331502,
0.2027067244,
-0.1426262558,
-0.3262233436,
-0.1496520191,
-0.3186548352,
0.2155746967,
-0.1851734668,
0.5139678717,
-0.1494663507,
-0.8464251161,
-0.356713891,
0.6797049046,
1.0350714922,
-0.840082109,
0.4703466594,
0.5218191743,
-0.2974654138,
-0.3276900351,
-0.3931710124,
0.1676176935,
-0.4659935832,
0.6306378841,
-0.6536664367,
-0.8421149254,
0.3933773935,
-0.164071396,
-0.1955375075,
0.0543284118,
0.5770032406,
0.0334008299,
1.4564315081,
0.7190247178,
0.3479709327,
0.4297704995,
-0.4113892913,
0.0777269825,
-0.5236337781,
-0.6131417751,
-0.3618516624,
-0.1487465203,
-0.0769371539,
-0.9884598255,
0.650270164,
0.1837075204,
0.1560572535,
0.1301974058,
-0.5623311996,
0.5865987539,
0.6432033181,
0.2370851487,
0.2883279026,
-0.1907444298,
-0.1602536142,
-0.0787570029,
-0.7353883982,
-0.113243252,
1.0840576887,
0.2468556166,
0.8257719278,
0.2353123724,
0.3484964967,
0.4922406971,
0.0864066258,
-0.7001290321,
0.5342521667,
0.082341373,
-0.3535410464,
0.1098542511,
-0.8718065023,
-0.7300712466,
0.0521173477,
-0.3502497673,
-0.1659679562,
0.1458437443,
0.1466336399,
-0.1770241112,
-0.0473515615,
-1.153449893,
1.2306135893,
-0.5905858278,
-0.218313545,
-0.2694409192,
-0.4344849288,
0.5277457237,
-0.169063583,
0.5556092262,
-0.001687647,
0.1276072413,
0.3885442913,
-0.2150323987,
0.7644207478,
-0.1808823347,
-0.053873565,
0.265539974,
0.2993376851,
0.1867425889,
0.0080198823,
0.1770425141,
-0.1439851969,
0.1175624728,
-0.4937973022,
-0.7109174728,
0.5280500054,
-0.4882927537,
-0.0033016831,
-0.1184887066,
-0.6542144418,
-0.0956787542,
0.262414515,
-0.1720525473,
0.9131202698,
0.2123669088,
0.3354480267,
0.5789598227,
-0.4917903841,
0.373010546,
0.1888955832,
-0.3540878594,
-0.3745139837,
1.0897897482,
0.0190288015,
0.1702564657,
0.0442718789,
-0.1523486674,
0.1726075411,
-0.715276897,
-0.8223662376,
-0.2400945574,
-0.9042611122,
-0.4144124389,
-0.3264127374,
-0.0159324147,
-0.1067533046,
-0.1767650694,
-0.3576452434,
-0.0278682392,
-0.0323550291,
0.2664723992,
-0.03133367,
0.9122413397,
0.0637049451,
-0.1170974001,
-0.8915493488,
0.5417270064,
0.551881969,
0.768676579,
-0.0090766158,
0.1588590294,
-0.5793738365,
0.0140614361,
0.0214747116,
-1.1216979027,
0.3328777254,
-0.0020118325,
0.5503715873,
0.3047367632,
-0.1618786901,
0.821213305,
-0.3988194168,
0.529761374,
0.3832633793,
-1.0960261822,
0.6138489246,
-0.2092511058,
0.579785645,
0.3160384595,
0.2571598887,
-0.3228625357,
-0.0289123897,
-0.305955708,
-0.4698396027,
0.5216414332,
0.249634847,
0.1179190204,
-0.0882935226,
0.1145807803,
0.045959238,
0.382627517,
-0.794221282,
-0.0483959019,
-0.3663421869,
-0.2811900079,
0.0818872303,
-0.4380401075,
-0.0684342682,
-0.3289200068,
-0.088458851,
-0.4565887749,
0.6111472845,
0.0390999205,
-0.5760933161,
0.1039183214,
0.2306221426,
0.9878218174,
0.8900785446,
0.0345706977,
0.2581810653,
-0.2094277442,
-0.3432630599,
-0.129156515,
0.0959025621,
0.1725214869,
-0.4618496895,
0.4925447702,
0.5350108743,
0.3530037105,
-1.3431475163,
0.9545401931,
0.0165205747,
-0.3198096752,
0.1161748394,
0.1299615502,
-0.149545297,
0.4470053613,
0.4402216077,
0.4607426226,
0.4249065518,
-0.6129053831,
0.2126504183,
0.4303025007,
-0.1719407588,
-0.322724849,
0.7771738172,
0.4349887967,
-0.1425507218,
0.663952589,
-0.5116805434,
-0.5987190008,
0.7315419316,
0.5661708713,
0.469047904,
0.2324580848,
0.1321130246,
0.0875126868,
0.5214700699,
0.3953237236,
0.4576766789,
-0.1858867407,
-0.4850819111,
-0.7899667025,
-0.543284297,
-0.2139753699,
-0.2301200628,
-0.4381331801,
0.0216459092,
-0.5899605155,
0.0007054157,
-0.0286297966,
-0.241169706,
-0.7552884817,
0.1603997946,
0.7155764103,
0.828858614,
-0.7703160048,
0.6924242973,
0.6656543612,
-0.4921698272,
-0.4503513575,
-0.3755883574,
0.0033501261,
-0.784350872,
0.5301517844,
0.3390662074,
-0.168464601,
-0.0635352284,
-0.9207046032,
-0.5885541439,
0.8935007453,
0.4920141995,
-0.2999331951,
0.1491992623,
0.0318521485,
0.1782354712,
-0.5145350695,
0.3241100013,
0.2205476314,
0.4333232641,
0.0426317528,
-1.1726938486,
-0.2995857,
-0.7593964934,
-0.0384745598,
0.0962680876,
-0.3895490468,
0.8675882816,
-0.4374514222,
-0.0362163,
-0.0722463951,
0.3103177845,
0.2195811421,
0.5117564201,
0.2770751119,
0.5435617566,
0.4445575178,
0.0025288875,
1.0894582272,
-0.3543176353,
0.3969129026,
0.6029786468,
-0.0835095942,
0.7402633429,
0.2981116772,
-0.0935645849,
0.3348544836,
0.1508397162,
-0.2546070218,
0.4183319509,
0.1031067073,
0.1978230029,
-0.4165146947,
-0.0330493003,
-0.4686378539,
0.7244490981,
0.2508867979,
-0.267516166,
-0.0143892132,
0.4232678711,
-0.2588630021,
-0.0541901253,
-0.4385937452,
0.5289478898,
-0.2398094982,
-0.3149074614,
0.5435153842,
0.348192811,
0.7184975743,
-0.4174610376,
-0.448043555,
-0.1448426098,
0.0571694858,
-0.3123076856,
-0.8226436973,
0.3253335655,
0.1192058101,
-0.2559480965,
-0.3402050138,
0.4351742268,
-0.2594178915,
-0.5576596856,
0.0105648516,
0.7488268018,
-0.0219809543,
-0.128685534,
-0.804515779,
0.3949255645,
0.2490713149,
0.1078089327,
0.1320489347,
0.6954137683,
0.0906789079,
0.8785934448,
1.0224637985,
-0.3546200991,
0.5800873637,
0.1325149834,
1.1288796663,
-0.6879401207,
-0.4615222216,
-0.618494451,
0.7250691056,
0.0327792279,
-0.4448598325,
0.7935085893,
0.7736943364,
0.8362067938,
-0.422483623,
0.5320137143,
-0.040343862,
-0.1646921188,
-0.6730928421,
0.4660001397,
-0.682272315,
0.1720944643,
-0.4186472893,
-0.8418285847,
-0.5355426669,
0.6381365061,
-0.2514789104,
0.1188350841,
0.4183061123,
0.686070621,
-0.3701742887,
-0.1646608859,
0.4121461809,
-0.0468476787,
0.2271686643,
0.8824706674,
1.0048520565,
-0.1647940576,
0.818031311,
-0.3761259913,
-0.598867178,
-0.420620352,
-0.6119715571,
-0.7315804958,
-0.6178768277,
-0.244432047,
-0.2577376068,
-0.2272044718,
0.8746253848,
0.9359423518,
-0.5003454685,
-0.1755298525,
0.1407351196,
0.0223088823,
-0.2749027908,
-0.1754208952,
-0.1441403776,
-0.0435034186,
-0.6400546432,
0.2845039368,
0.4671335518,
0.0523364097,
-0.3087854087,
-0.2197469026,
0.0515060276,
0.0468961559,
0.9594262838,
0.0464012735,
-0.375422895,
-0.0580314212,
0.1840719581,
-0.2341378927,
0.0750102848,
0.9439844489,
-0.5921331644,
0.7693119645,
0.365283221,
0.6479226947,
0.3633676469,
-0.0329600461,
0.1699979454,
-0.596347332,
0.1807477921,
0.2524731755,
0.3877687156,
0.180049926,
0.1299141794,
0.3552332222,
0.3765487671,
-0.4315484464,
-0.8790484071,
0.3720146418,
-1.1378040314,
-0.4441893697,
0.932829082,
0.1122520491,
-0.1639348716,
-0.0264220778,
-0.4019097984,
-0.2932076752,
-0.1390392035,
0.5257089734,
0.5687245131,
-0.1022604927,
-0.6620187163,
-1.068602562,
0.1456355602,
0.2304890305,
-0.8875120878,
-0.1167064831,
0.9436252713,
-0.1161868647,
0.2624675035,
0.5147576332,
-0.0872361585,
0.6446964741,
0.4648314118,
0.1092995703,
-0.5692311525,
-0.7159377933,
-0.318954438,
0.5956122279,
0.1908894032,
-0.1065150276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09480v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09480v1
|
Mitigating Hallucination in Abstractive Summarization with Domain-Conditional Mutual Information
| 2024-04-15T06:06:43 | 2024-04-15T06:06:43 |
Kyubyung Chae, Jaepill Choi, Yohan Jo, Taesup Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
A primary challenge in abstractive summarization is hallucination -- the
phenomenon where a model generates plausible text that is absent in the source
text. We hypothesize that the domain (or topic) of the source text triggers the
model to generate text that is highly probable in the domain, neglecting the
details of the source text. To alleviate this model bias, we introduce a
decoding strategy based on domain-conditional pointwise mutual information.
This strategy adjusts the generation probability of each token by comparing it
with the token's marginal probability within the domain of the source text.
According to evaluation on the XSUM dataset, our method demonstrates
improvement in terms of faithfulness and source relevance. The code is publicly
available at \url{https://github.com/qqplot/dcpmi}.
|
[
-0.2865863442,
-0.5862469673,
0.7177978754,
0.1794635504,
-0.5397332311,
-0.1071782634,
0.0502186641,
-0.3591068089,
0.484400928,
0.3275642693,
-0.653406024,
-0.6392554045,
-0.624344945,
0.2154333293,
-0.4034104943,
1.0564336777,
0.0148417158,
-0.0433809347,
-0.5910995603,
-0.1013013273,
-0.3629402816,
-0.91585958,
-0.5679207444,
-0.3250066042,
0.3826338649,
0.2940387428,
0.6341643333,
0.4498274624,
0.5160599351,
0.1469246894,
0.0181796197,
0.1549058408,
-0.6242168546,
0.2206978947,
-0.1523443311,
-0.4230247438,
-0.7041991949,
-0.3216711581,
0.5825304985,
0.8633314371,
-0.0094836643,
-0.1337638199,
0.0926935822,
0.8044499159,
-0.7939019799,
0.4095429182,
-0.6374254823,
0.2046184838,
0.1934302151,
-0.621525228,
-0.3756827712,
-0.3137437999,
0.1283061057,
-0.6289605498,
0.3933687508,
0.011088118,
0.8285499215,
0.1419743747,
-0.5859210491,
-0.1061569601,
-0.6150200367,
0.5525221825,
-0.6458166838,
0.0694489405,
0.810649693,
0.1228140593,
-0.0453216545,
-0.6981580853,
-0.7940582037,
-0.0167051796,
-0.3502105772,
0.2315367013,
-0.3098722398,
0.2345194817,
0.224103719,
0.4604183435,
-0.6050055027,
-0.5473522544,
-0.1951231211,
-0.4059293568,
0.6520582438,
0.3225947917,
0.2909092605,
-0.4183389544,
0.0115809524,
-0.169254303,
-0.7075922489,
-0.1537592113,
0.2447639257,
0.156327039,
-0.0655833408,
0.8000953197,
-0.2629893422,
0.3355412483,
0.2459229082,
-0.0559575111,
0.4080963135,
-0.6785257459,
0.039926488,
0.4025144577,
0.338663727,
0.7185701728,
0.0339743979,
-0.2625219524,
-0.4230343401,
0.116709061,
0.0792713165,
-0.9082664847,
-0.5615834594,
0.5242247581,
-0.6414420009,
-0.130118832,
0.3185145855,
-0.4370161295,
-0.1368623227,
-0.3896377087,
0.7434692383,
-0.4609206617,
-0.4029924572,
-0.0248508547,
-0.6313123107,
-0.0304437485,
0.1214539781,
-0.9077492952,
0.4556226432,
0.7279580235,
1.1386047602,
-0.4764052927,
-0.3398442268,
-0.7298801541,
0.3588416874,
-0.138416484,
0.7307785153,
-0.3158691823,
-0.5495958924,
0.0138374157,
-0.1428998709,
0.0142211253,
-0.6058452725,
0.3264390528,
-0.4093921781,
0.2293571085,
-0.7318733931,
-0.5374605656,
-0.2744359374,
0.025611531,
-0.7174585462,
0.49742347,
0.2063912153,
-1.172257781,
0.3776630163,
-0.3426917493,
-0.7743034959,
-0.245792076,
-0.4288636148,
-0.5496692061,
0.2103542835,
0.163609758,
0.360758692,
0.2667495608,
0.4657384157,
-0.120958291,
-0.5983652472,
0.2287148684,
-0.1700225174,
0.474093467,
0.1736128181,
-0.5480791926,
0.2362383306,
-0.8463227153,
-0.372209847,
0.1523263454,
0.2194668949,
-0.6408427954,
0.2000343502,
-0.1568774134,
0.1098215953,
0.0147876181,
-0.0918166935,
0.0493118353,
-0.1850358993,
0.0202182028,
0.7000414133,
0.5494991541,
0.5368696451,
-0.6914733052,
0.3874571919,
0.299764961,
-0.286634326,
-0.2651669681,
-0.4145485461,
-0.4719395638,
-0.5223030448,
0.2524751723,
0.4018337131,
-1.0234053135,
0.5381364822,
-0.2056821138,
0.1324065626,
-0.1986322999,
-0.397467196,
0.3399874866,
0.6494830251,
0.3144721091,
-0.2385794967,
-0.6508856416,
-0.7243978381,
0.0548306443,
-0.0271010157,
-0.2487177104,
0.065035589,
0.5068123937,
-0.2291415334,
0.9717884064,
-0.7878742814,
-0.3649779558,
-0.4402886331,
0.3988591135,
0.1892834753,
0.4509676397,
0.5360392332,
-0.9721497297,
-0.2931314707,
-0.3145858645,
-0.9957968593,
-0.2869385183,
-0.3556343019,
-0.2157079875,
0.2562331259,
0.5123739243,
-0.7645280957,
0.8084098697,
0.4154335558,
-0.5066248775,
0.6949062347,
-0.3436839581,
0.5002568364,
-1.1143440008,
0.2683596015,
-0.2042366564,
-0.2628020644,
-0.5563071966,
-0.1270439178,
-0.1045724303,
-0.052374687,
0.0615026429,
0.3048252761,
-0.6098056436,
0.0128277801,
-0.7855424881,
0.3192600012,
0.0985374674,
0.5606374741,
0.3634326756,
0.7892656922,
0.4624123573,
-1.0067610741,
-0.3070271909,
0.4867934287,
0.0481606275,
0.3207941651,
-0.7732234597,
-0.199807331,
-0.3307724893,
0.4209212065,
-0.7687225938,
-0.2492035329,
0.4763601422,
-0.6008185744,
0.1296271533,
0.1342763007,
-0.2769581079,
0.2347756177,
-0.6711630225,
0.746689558,
0.4465266168,
-0.5495605469,
0.4627534449,
0.5646510124,
-0.3783318996,
-0.5850594044,
-0.5223235488,
0.1262412071,
0.0023412239,
-0.5843621492,
0.7560412884,
-0.2824518085,
-0.5020920038,
0.1897388101,
-0.4618555009,
0.0202901084,
-0.0355021507,
0.504960537,
0.3362939358,
0.0627162978,
-0.102757968,
0.6421705484,
-0.2800010443,
0.5071592927,
-0.3069137037,
0.4925843775,
0.3823948801,
-0.1802595258,
-0.5565351248,
0.7922217846,
0.3162581325,
0.0764137283,
0.8543391824,
0.3010352254,
-0.5818915367,
-0.1913550496,
-0.0064619626,
-0.7063041329,
-0.3979635835,
0.3373545706,
-0.6607093811,
-0.6226734519,
0.7415758967,
0.2988203168,
-0.2069338709,
0.6075181961,
0.4707399309,
0.2131840885,
1.1685299873,
0.8943913579,
-0.0150612602,
0.266336292,
-0.2219250202,
0.3186213672,
-0.4957575798,
-0.3006296456,
-0.368683815,
-0.0184823051,
-0.3223350942,
-0.1032599434,
0.5017770529,
-0.0816363096,
0.3045068085,
0.1328021735,
-0.2883298695,
0.460945636,
0.7539359927,
0.2390269488,
0.6433916092,
0.2364801317,
-0.1515558809,
-0.0348330699,
-0.7841968536,
-0.2029527277,
0.9699681401,
-0.0521623008,
0.3908427656,
0.1666190475,
0.7810986042,
0.637619555,
-0.1272699088,
-0.5633904338,
0.5725206137,
0.3162544668,
-0.3338697255,
-0.2870911956,
-0.8889557719,
-0.8560441732,
0.4464802146,
-0.4852204025,
-0.5311057568,
0.4428034127,
0.1680835038,
-0.2582527697,
0.0991386995,
-0.3950460851,
0.4952844083,
0.4010175765,
-0.1580164135,
-0.6159706116,
-0.6877458096,
0.5236629248,
-0.1627064794,
0.0604129434,
0.0903674588,
0.0595590845,
0.6438381672,
-0.6705389619,
0.6985270381,
-0.1668146253,
-0.0182989053,
0.2332183272,
0.2110788822,
0.5906327963,
0.4435376227,
-0.0055800448,
0.3498045206,
0.1278022528,
-0.6110557318,
-0.4990558326,
0.4689842165,
-0.6283016801,
-0.5707360506,
-0.7806168199,
-0.6375256777,
0.0303918347,
0.1020844579,
0.7243152857,
0.4284081459,
-0.1891158074,
-0.3509720266,
0.691257894,
-0.0519338213,
0.4778746068,
0.0699004531,
-0.2972845733,
-0.5783373117,
0.9255806208,
-0.1332193464,
0.1219086871,
0.5895115137,
-0.0007879661,
-0.1348070949,
-0.8178866506,
-0.0983376801,
0.4580312967,
-0.8669682145,
-0.2337074876,
-0.8821076155,
-0.335945785,
-0.5082172751,
-0.122439608,
0.0600171126,
-0.9147447348,
-0.3140342832,
-0.271240741,
0.124588035,
0.5319985151,
-0.4119037986,
0.0908549204,
-0.8749107718,
0.604172349,
0.164162755,
0.0740789622,
0.0722323954,
-0.7429844737,
-0.241431132,
0.0544930175,
0.0684600174,
-0.7879251838,
0.4899941385,
0.1185605973,
0.4839014411,
0.5238828659,
0.5721037388,
0.4342353642,
-0.4164472818,
0.5864247084,
0.2532204986,
-1.2158987522,
0.372521311,
-0.2540183365,
0.3119958937,
0.7095865607,
0.634596467,
-0.4210052788,
-0.5890607834,
-0.4684970081,
-0.9386723638,
0.5469330549,
0.6017957926,
0.0262165759,
-0.1427890509,
0.5484065413,
0.4766472578,
0.3561409116,
-0.86803478,
-0.3491084576,
-0.3116907477,
-0.1008042619,
-0.0578957573,
-0.5220815539,
-0.2006011307,
-0.3308905661,
0.7259575725,
0.0215567946,
0.3173539639,
0.6147865653,
-0.2829897106,
-0.2682033181,
-0.2759766877,
0.9422885776,
1.0552426577,
-0.6300454736,
0.4748781323,
-0.171706453,
-0.7637355924,
-0.0438979417,
-0.0399473496,
-0.4052975476,
0.4525301754,
0.5323688984,
0.5529340506,
-0.0604652315,
-0.5074945092,
0.8256837726,
-0.385042876,
-0.5893453956,
-0.3808248341,
-0.033734411,
-0.3563245833,
0.1703329831,
0.7785098553,
0.1303677261,
0.4501839578,
-0.4554239213,
0.6307998896,
0.2553194463,
-0.1666725725,
-0.6734914184,
0.7507184744,
0.1540170163,
-0.0326595381,
0.467695415,
-0.5948473215,
-0.4945656657,
0.3537755609,
0.7126037478,
1.008898139,
0.0908446014,
0.2755141854,
0.5304230452,
0.1951295286,
0.0404366031,
0.3016704023,
-0.2076728791,
-0.4570267797,
-0.4873378277,
-0.1491108239,
-0.5139656067,
-0.1494212151,
-0.6615088582,
0.2453039736,
-0.2011051476,
-0.0911722854,
-0.2995745838,
-0.3327645361,
0.1155351028,
0.1065298021,
-0.0926192626,
0.6747529507,
-0.9335995317,
0.8241866827,
0.1868519187,
-0.4313169718,
-0.3076618016,
0.581954062,
-0.0977348834,
-0.3974827826,
0.3288213611,
0.0957389325,
-0.285207212,
-0.1610566974,
-0.3158883154,
-0.6627810001,
1.108753562,
0.1532281488,
-0.3895427883,
-0.0364030972,
-0.0629322305,
0.190005064,
-0.3501999974,
-0.0505996086,
0.4134699106,
0.2475851178,
0.1680997014,
-0.4953475893,
0.540763557,
-0.3220822513,
-0.3158253431,
0.1560616344,
-0.2131727487,
0.8081403971,
-0.4631385207,
-0.3866710067,
-0.1500710398,
1.0727106333,
0.3151231706,
0.8966765404,
0.5136013031,
0.1720126569,
0.9418588281,
0.1826819032,
0.9524486065,
-0.4836688042,
0.1078089997,
1.0568332672,
-0.1193270758,
0.6617056131,
0.5499081612,
0.1225386858,
0.2773298323,
0.5131185055,
0.2082739472,
0.9534523487,
0.1314715296,
-0.4824890494,
-0.0287491754,
0.1048202887,
-0.6780173182,
0.2236653715,
0.0671608672,
-0.1220350191,
-0.0648671985,
0.0397619493,
0.0701446906,
0.1883798987,
-0.2309531718,
0.7827475667,
0.3352223039,
-0.6926171184,
0.7016503215,
0.0454941094,
0.5553122759,
-0.5559702516,
-0.3028019965,
-0.7058445811,
-0.0998312011,
-0.3355415463,
-0.0828701183,
0.6370541453,
-0.25854671,
-0.5264121294,
0.1116450652,
0.5142769814,
-0.4556000531,
-0.212405026,
0.1737820804,
0.4219264984,
0.094616212,
-0.5869012475,
-0.0895012915,
-0.004167547,
0.1980254799,
0.0791832879,
0.4756563604,
0.5631904602,
-0.0296186805,
0.4245202541,
0.4671181738,
0.1553796679,
-0.3650586903,
0.1436882019,
0.8731065989,
-0.8371422291,
-0.724293232,
-0.9937609434,
0.2947813869,
-0.2098288089,
-0.0563079044,
0.9381513,
0.6748624444,
0.5475080609,
-0.2006181031,
0.7969020605,
0.1375787258,
0.181181252,
-0.6643148065,
1.1204253435,
-0.4710738659,
0.4823370576,
-0.4735905528,
-1.0598106384,
-0.4832468331,
0.5134066343,
0.0253387447,
-0.2004440725,
1.2541542053,
0.6598237157,
-0.0109702991,
-0.0071335388,
0.4470169544,
-0.0554659627,
-0.0157200359,
0.3504900932,
0.7146829367,
-0.3844164312,
0.6618872881,
-0.3647169173,
-0.5286270976,
-0.3093675673,
-0.9792998433,
-1.1291338205,
-0.8978569508,
-0.6384869814,
-0.6390551329,
0.1368234307,
0.6927236915,
0.5731992126,
-0.892393589,
-0.1050067022,
-0.1030953601,
0.3730523586,
-0.3173232377,
-0.2200420797,
0.6599681973,
-0.2746822834,
-0.6232399344,
0.1199224815,
0.3275893629,
0.1735761911,
0.1892925501,
-0.1256045848,
0.1885530949,
0.3207219243,
0.7111433148,
0.002122967,
-0.1841247231,
-0.1936368942,
0.0116093718,
-0.1148343086,
0.2844991982,
1.1363860369,
-0.5947324038,
0.0588874668,
0.6113511324,
0.4579724967,
0.5830379725,
0.1111955196,
0.8293078542,
-0.6696564555,
0.2403701991,
0.1516478211,
0.3274223804,
0.0582911223,
-0.5766046643,
0.3287682235,
0.420427531,
-0.5170273781,
-0.8216097355,
0.1389694661,
-1.2334676981,
-0.6750919223,
0.9011228681,
0.0693631917,
-0.2355663031,
-0.1202826649,
-0.298481524,
0.2615692616,
-0.437305361,
1.3641506433,
0.4770181179,
-0.1290768981,
0.0216658022,
-0.1338929385,
0.7505522966,
0.5304887295,
-0.7259589434,
0.0420031734,
0.6566470265,
0.0072959266,
-0.033269804,
0.8734337687,
0.0359084532,
0.5259157419,
0.4036173522,
0.1155477837,
0.0028980118,
-0.4203368425,
-0.4782135785,
0.2507492006,
0.0643662214,
-0.1210266128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13071v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13071v2
|
Modeling Emotions and Ethics with Large Language Models
| 2024-04-15T05:30:26 | 2024-06-25T04:36:08 |
Edward Y. Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.0
|
This paper explores the integration of human-like emotions and ethical
considerations into Large Language Models (LLMs). We first model eight
fundamental human emotions, presented as opposing pairs, and employ
collaborative LLMs to reinterpret and express these emotions across a spectrum
of intensity. Our focus extends to embedding a latent ethical dimension within
LLMs, guided by a novel self-supervised learning algorithm with human feedback
(SSHF). This approach enables LLMs to perform self-evaluations and adjustments
concerning ethical guidelines, enhancing their capability to generate content
that is not only emotionally resonant but also ethically aligned. The
methodologies and case studies presented herein illustrate the potential of
LLMs to transcend mere text and image generation, venturing into the realms of
empathetic interaction and principled decision-making, thereby setting a new
precedent in the development of emotionally aware and ethically conscious AI
systems.
|
[
-0.0688182488,
-0.6164689064,
0.860689342,
0.1371880323,
-0.1812978536,
0.2078001052,
-0.4445612133,
-0.4870562553,
0.1076380089,
0.6532289386,
-0.5145443678,
-0.318290025,
-0.2702573538,
0.0379892774,
-0.1193711981,
0.9373039603,
0.0864247382,
0.4264654815,
-0.1391721815,
-0.3347476125,
0.1701758504,
-0.8850116134,
-0.7418960333,
-0.447067678,
0.6678471565,
0.2131074816,
0.5912809372,
0.5837481618,
0.4544450045,
0.265538305,
0.1486980617,
-0.1184547022,
-0.7473779917,
0.2160557508,
-0.3260935247,
-0.1369723082,
-0.5208954811,
0.5521499515,
0.2724150419,
0.2966709435,
-0.3403729796,
0.2100494951,
-0.0807246715,
0.6906536818,
-0.4049280584,
0.0108197341,
-0.2160564363,
0.3080781102,
0.2729046345,
-0.4770556986,
-0.4285996854,
-0.3278551698,
0.115056619,
-0.356246233,
-0.4276551902,
0.204037711,
0.3723686039,
0.3776004612,
-0.6518822312,
-0.5531685352,
-0.557415545,
1.1640290022,
-0.6780489683,
0.3347995281,
0.2657874823,
-0.1985633671,
0.0101717524,
-0.5481982827,
-0.6432963014,
-0.2636432648,
0.1689520627,
0.288136512,
-0.1791577786,
0.2837259173,
0.0330736637,
0.2242328823,
-0.1656333953,
0.4361213446,
-0.1389413923,
0.1649018824,
1.0439355373,
0.3681195378,
0.4401308894,
-0.2598137856,
-0.0927999541,
0.0544690304,
-0.7181425095,
-0.0415279493,
0.8087793589,
-0.0013024734,
-0.2369099259,
0.32876724,
0.2348087132,
0.1693129689,
0.0544655472,
0.0037538162,
0.2475323379,
0.0199220311,
-0.2560179234,
0.0420834757,
1.0051562786,
0.6981880069,
0.6145138741,
0.1550088078,
-0.204827711,
0.1000348479,
0.6283872724,
-0.899594605,
-0.031377282,
0.578158021,
-0.9686217308,
-0.8566718698,
-0.3673642278,
-0.8189222217,
-0.6361845136,
-0.7156392932,
0.2828767598,
-0.2543123662,
-0.4185965657,
0.1429990977,
0.3199919164,
0.4036532938,
0.3362022638,
-0.6614319086,
0.2752071321,
0.7494723797,
0.2966849208,
0.2354739457,
-0.1602039486,
-0.5422741771,
0.0897509158,
-0.5271873474,
0.0889612883,
-0.876427114,
-0.5186994672,
0.0514003895,
-0.0874287933,
0.4488702118,
-0.1222248077,
0.6401154399,
-0.4234495461,
0.3377236426,
-0.2147583067,
-0.605278492,
-0.2842660546,
0.1977058351,
-0.4006019235,
0.7438763976,
-0.004222679,
-0.6018368006,
-0.1326366663,
-0.9865620136,
-0.3645705879,
0.1561295688,
-0.4407862723,
-0.3212197423,
0.256790936,
-0.2253561765,
0.7321594357,
-0.5471295118,
0.4359896779,
-0.4367086589,
-0.1125946566,
0.2164838314,
-0.2852802575,
0.8297149539,
0.2549754977,
-0.395709902,
0.2813644707,
-0.4703604579,
-0.0038075927,
0.3270767629,
-0.0842548087,
-0.3621562123,
0.1492088288,
0.3056716621,
0.2652187049,
0.2587103248,
-0.4508819878,
-0.0402192138,
-0.1244719476,
0.8043729663,
1.121568799,
-0.0450950339,
0.648984313,
-0.2236833125,
0.6213003397,
-0.3691377044,
0.2933264375,
-0.0757772475,
-0.1023558974,
-0.6117931008,
-0.1065829918,
-0.2526103854,
0.534625113,
-0.1312724501,
0.5528156757,
0.0401474833,
-0.3143347204,
-0.8548957705,
0.1203316003,
0.3638292849,
0.4816967249,
0.1180638075,
-0.0757206231,
-0.2720656097,
-0.9615095258,
-0.2136766911,
-0.412943095,
0.0589957871,
0.6577497721,
0.5203840137,
-0.4298805594,
0.6777150631,
-0.0025025436,
0.0139202289,
0.0253268648,
0.4087693393,
-0.1961793303,
0.696749568,
0.4699991047,
-0.8895503283,
-0.143536523,
0.0323274024,
-1.1310762167,
-0.1651689708,
-0.242305994,
-0.0867494047,
0.145191133,
0.4672884345,
-0.3977289498,
0.2727501392,
0.5318318009,
-0.1354813725,
0.4465170205,
-0.2440761626,
0.4459437132,
-1.1868844032,
-0.1311763525,
0.0561084375,
-0.1569368243,
-0.5253258348,
0.1190374345,
0.0849360377,
0.0238457676,
-0.7437927127,
0.6655496359,
-0.5430127978,
-0.0793216079,
-0.283496201,
-0.0593603589,
0.0513080768,
0.3476341069,
-0.0462683998,
0.404450357,
0.5419562459,
-0.2642436922,
0.7392041683,
0.2186200023,
-0.0283533148,
1.0795437098,
-0.6489945054,
0.3694478273,
-0.4501695931,
0.4332979918,
-0.2924875021,
-0.3648493886,
0.3282479346,
-0.2767437398,
0.0738652572,
-0.0982722491,
-0.6112486124,
-0.242321223,
-0.4597103,
0.5041902661,
0.9112144709,
-0.4265130162,
1.0012567043,
0.4918739796,
-0.3488203585,
-0.3356963992,
-0.6902707219,
0.4125169516,
-0.3744477332,
-0.5554882288,
0.086059764,
-0.2019066662,
-0.6227584481,
0.0968610197,
0.4981685281,
0.1214013696,
0.1689264178,
0.5167506337,
0.2016527653,
0.071223855,
0.2514203787,
0.0745403022,
0.1017873734,
0.3968580663,
-0.1637064219,
0.2838125527,
-0.6890361309,
-0.4810046256,
-0.6220730543,
0.6769663095,
0.5940442085,
-0.3840641975,
0.4904665947,
0.6351425648,
-0.6134747863,
-0.0662843436,
-0.6617035866,
-0.2791346908,
-0.4467799067,
0.3260452747,
0.03025054,
-1.1715630293,
0.3478766382,
-0.0040259208,
0.041003637,
0.2151590437,
0.965893209,
-0.5262504816,
1.0193411112,
0.6136214733,
-0.011578152,
0.3791679144,
-0.139560312,
0.3314407468,
-1.0907592773,
-0.120239079,
-0.2032328993,
-0.3209237158,
-0.8775078654,
-0.4026588798,
0.1530241668,
-0.159592703,
-0.5255575776,
-0.4348475337,
-0.4538490474,
0.6808135509,
0.3873734474,
0.0453451499,
0.0285232365,
-0.2920648754,
0.1712320298,
-0.0530852675,
-0.2981728017,
-1.0135655403,
0.9491505623,
0.6182427406,
1.0179057121,
0.0466212109,
0.9097249508,
0.4221561849,
0.6976693869,
-0.8195261955,
0.5917937756,
-0.155830279,
-0.4221943915,
-0.3197669685,
-0.4753426015,
-0.7812339067,
-0.1392326206,
-0.1238527298,
-1.0555433035,
0.0321348161,
-0.0384899788,
-0.4296113551,
0.206795752,
-0.4656428993,
0.6882334352,
-0.6781426072,
-0.5794113278,
-0.6916104555,
-0.9345659018,
0.36494717,
-0.2454107851,
0.4001656473,
-0.2723219395,
-0.0405798219,
0.7034543157,
-0.1721206456,
1.0540094376,
0.1037963554,
-0.2375437021,
0.2248774618,
0.2747350335,
0.3214960992,
0.068861872,
-0.2856212556,
0.0897314325,
-0.1789172441,
-0.2259900272,
-0.4436297417,
0.8533968329,
-0.8804463744,
-0.6348795891,
-0.306825757,
-0.5755568743,
-0.1384089887,
0.1162589341,
-0.307287842,
0.1766949743,
-0.3364107609,
0.273835659,
0.7575538754,
-0.7033805251,
0.2971435785,
0.4955923855,
-0.2732160091,
-0.3413740695,
0.8351817131,
-0.2941099405,
0.1299618334,
0.1106355637,
0.5298683047,
-0.3630469143,
-0.0342702866,
-0.3670432568,
0.3788888156,
-0.7996810675,
-0.0738874674,
-0.7196158767,
-0.0762150809,
-0.2080682218,
-0.6194806099,
-0.405269742,
0.1098133028,
-0.6606912613,
-0.2515116036,
0.5779198408,
0.9889501333,
-0.2546015978,
0.2180940062,
-0.9750936627,
0.2066199183,
0.2873733044,
0.5198397636,
0.1873229742,
-0.4392292202,
0.1925881058,
0.0496747382,
-0.1506457776,
-0.7749091387,
0.4093782902,
0.0073484876,
0.4015730321,
0.4062752724,
0.1827171445,
0.3514072597,
-0.5869897604,
0.6951898336,
0.3355062008,
-1.2648125887,
0.4134044945,
-0.5870187879,
-0.2646269202,
0.3524985909,
0.5351684093,
-0.697108686,
-0.2384805083,
-0.7713081837,
-0.5747773051,
0.4568433166,
0.1214067414,
0.5853480697,
0.0265940651,
0.5097334981,
-0.0209394749,
0.1544719487,
-0.6838885546,
0.1075871736,
0.0588199161,
-0.8606882095,
0.1495065242,
-0.2670536041,
-0.2711959481,
0.1054982767,
0.4622063935,
-0.0334099457,
0.0555205084,
0.1494169235,
-0.0141414674,
-0.3524092734,
0.2438883334,
0.2989188135,
0.3372620642,
-0.0595161952,
-0.0009483744,
-0.0879041553,
0.0215931349,
0.3810938895,
-0.223624289,
0.3468426168,
-0.7092229724,
0.204032436,
0.4305663109,
0.1249845624,
-0.7766729593,
0.719456315,
-0.1495729238,
-0.0761839151,
-0.3591628671,
-0.3595003486,
0.4027507901,
0.5717593431,
0.3024834096,
-0.4062594473,
0.3024359643,
-0.7747402787,
0.2012003511,
0.3957228661,
-0.2887839675,
-0.3358646333,
0.5628163218,
0.6209971309,
-0.5398920178,
0.5812645555,
-0.2728192806,
-0.8060720563,
0.6371966004,
0.0759538412,
1.0569009781,
-0.3299736381,
0.2095415592,
-0.0453059636,
0.2564672828,
-0.2175279409,
0.4512640536,
0.0720964447,
-0.7790845037,
-0.5053309202,
-0.5349837542,
-0.728192091,
0.0227372088,
-0.6900701523,
-0.0869938582,
-0.630474329,
-0.0252808984,
-0.166593194,
0.0054221861,
-0.6241667867,
0.3753141761,
0.4095314145,
0.3689378202,
-0.6729108095,
0.5969044566,
0.5588108301,
-0.4328584373,
-0.6876540184,
-0.1556811035,
0.0565601289,
-0.8807781935,
0.788962841,
0.2973896265,
-0.3654499352,
0.0450073443,
-0.9150598645,
-0.3729462624,
0.8249220848,
0.2652883828,
-0.5388678908,
0.0999661535,
-0.0733781159,
0.7846372724,
-0.6695607901,
0.1945484877,
0.2422459722,
0.3792492747,
-0.2464217395,
-0.5995993018,
0.1113913581,
-0.2301217467,
-0.087327823,
0.1479556412,
-1.0018785,
0.7263016701,
-0.3576667905,
-0.1442049146,
-0.0544286035,
0.4626763761,
0.1624587476,
0.2203412354,
0.4749810398,
0.4218971729,
0.7993338704,
0.2278701216,
1.0684424639,
-0.4802069664,
0.2607955039,
0.9327389598,
-0.643250525,
0.6317808032,
0.5298107862,
0.0960432366,
0.2708812058,
0.7258090377,
-0.0282013416,
-0.0313172452,
0.5730667114,
-0.234258458,
-0.4468176663,
-0.6425654292,
-0.1471012533,
0.5701768994,
0.4297700524,
-0.5415102839,
0.2663177252,
-0.0667045712,
-0.0004107977,
0.0923264101,
-0.3443421721,
0.6373924613,
0.3511312008,
-0.2050656825,
-0.1357022673,
0.0684820488,
0.6806482673,
-0.0846632645,
-0.1599626094,
0.0083396006,
-0.2022450566,
-0.1858210266,
-1.0420473814,
0.1285921782,
0.2931878269,
-0.0167813413,
-0.6736543775,
0.606941402,
-0.377145052,
-0.5872293711,
0.5887376666,
0.5277534127,
0.2358596623,
0.0741474479,
-0.758644402,
0.3188020885,
-0.0615346543,
-0.5407001972,
0.2593081295,
0.5858758688,
0.0379362442,
0.7548054457,
0.7575734854,
-0.094479233,
-0.3359319866,
0.3336106241,
0.5355550647,
-1.0074869394,
-0.4709261656,
-1.0276277065,
0.3383634984,
-0.0647156313,
-0.1028653532,
0.1002479494,
0.0986701623,
0.4969384968,
0.2709268928,
0.9898398519,
0.2302518189,
0.1719527394,
-0.4674654305,
0.7935432792,
-0.7248290181,
-0.0096114799,
-0.3252860904,
-0.5348774791,
-0.0583606139,
0.8405358195,
-0.2687135339,
0.1570983976,
0.2196342647,
0.4537678659,
0.3573625982,
0.2283355147,
0.489828229,
0.2472954541,
0.4107407928,
0.5445914268,
1.2168591022,
-0.0476262607,
0.1198108941,
-0.2056860179,
-0.3518748879,
-0.3048601747,
-1.3419626951,
-0.6832415462,
-0.4052025974,
-0.2900482416,
-0.1792400777,
-0.1354102939,
1.4278035164,
0.6469045877,
-0.3084222376,
-0.2381124496,
0.1121990457,
0.0406075791,
0.3901158571,
-0.2398807406,
0.0928941965,
-0.0596068837,
-0.7776222825,
0.0359842628,
0.7293194532,
0.1150533929,
-0.6393336654,
-0.3805715144,
0.088152118,
0.501978755,
0.7105394602,
0.0051821386,
-0.8947930336,
-0.4743226469,
-0.1162028909,
-0.3975291252,
-0.070487991,
0.7734228373,
-0.3402339518,
0.3073722422,
-0.0086659212,
1.0658661127,
0.0240631029,
-0.0129758986,
0.7999041677,
-0.2516943812,
-0.1215428784,
0.7555895448,
0.5935586691,
0.5072833896,
-0.6021122336,
0.5601932406,
-0.0462462567,
-0.8303917646,
-0.8419827819,
0.4452901483,
-1.0170983076,
-0.1083256081,
1.2715852261,
-0.1726533175,
-0.3298986852,
0.3168634176,
-0.200183481,
0.2677440643,
-0.5343734026,
0.8565251827,
0.7372195125,
-0.2903391719,
-0.2756484151,
-0.3439396322,
0.2070997059,
0.552293241,
-1.0760856867,
0.286226511,
0.8213800788,
0.1881756634,
-0.0645116717,
0.5212693214,
-0.1179035231,
0.1773147434,
-0.2574861646,
0.3852776587,
0.2211205959,
0.0378736369,
-0.4510363638,
-0.2144068927,
-0.1505489349,
0.3301573098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09416v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09416v1
|
Automatic Knowledge Graph Construction for Judicial Cases
| 2024-04-15T02:08:28 | 2024-04-15T02:08:28 |
Jie Zhou, Xin Chen, Hang Zhang, Zhe Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we explore the application of cognitive intelligence in legal
knowledge, focusing on the development of judicial artificial intelligence.
Utilizing natural language processing (NLP) as the core technology, we propose
a method for the automatic construction of case knowledge graphs for judicial
cases. Our approach centers on two fundamental NLP tasks: entity recognition
and relationship extraction. We compare two pre-trained models for entity
recognition to establish their efficacy. Additionally, we introduce a
multi-task semantic relationship extraction model that incorporates
translational embedding, leading to a nuanced contextualized case knowledge
representation. Specifically, in a case study involving a "Motor Vehicle
Traffic Accident Liability Dispute," our approach significantly outperforms the
baseline model. The entity recognition F1 score improved by 0.36, while the
relationship extraction F1 score increased by 2.37. Building on these results,
we detail the automatic construction process of case knowledge graphs for
judicial cases, enabling the assembly of knowledge graphs for hundreds of
thousands of judgments. This framework provides robust semantic support for
applications of judicial AI, including the precise categorization and
recommendation of related cases.
|
[
-0.4316983223,
-0.8863115311,
1.059317708,
-0.1444253922,
-0.2809585631,
0.056409508,
-0.2972649038,
-0.5978584886,
0.3060923815,
0.8288047314,
-0.1958744824,
-0.4579845667,
-0.5373822451,
-0.2881282568,
-0.4995987713,
0.910871923,
0.1931221038,
0.0285740569,
-0.4092937112,
-0.1639842391,
-0.7182477117,
-0.5516960025,
-0.628805697,
-0.1551188231,
0.2947994769,
0.1333023906,
0.5471143723,
0.5598795414,
0.6467419863,
0.4281130433,
0.1966009885,
0.113805607,
0.2372481376,
0.058217261,
-0.2849355936,
-0.3605270684,
-0.6154345274,
0.0799978673,
0.1490751207,
0.5921558738,
-0.2899427414,
-0.0239357445,
-0.4897982776,
0.922260344,
-0.5999617577,
0.6593646407,
-0.916585803,
0.2913468182,
-0.3427210748,
-0.1653492451,
-0.4911126196,
-0.3234272599,
0.2739112675,
-1.083327055,
0.1241228059,
0.4448063374,
0.8629650474,
0.5108256936,
-0.8483191133,
-0.6198650002,
-0.6991804838,
0.3701451421,
-0.519481957,
0.3086575866,
0.3395930231,
0.6115304232,
-0.2168738544,
-1.117779851,
-0.7709842324,
-0.2588251531,
-0.2675959468,
0.2506068349,
-0.2818120718,
0.2048523426,
0.3593218029,
0.0155196125,
-0.4968215823,
-0.3482918739,
-0.4367771149,
-0.3178591728,
0.8510844111,
0.0495742112,
0.5283609033,
-0.4518747032,
0.0865952,
0.1186266467,
-0.3317085803,
0.1518163085,
0.2455818206,
0.3421775997,
0.2957271934,
0.6947438717,
-0.2444969863,
0.8126787543,
0.165168047,
-0.0687100515,
0.1918849498,
-0.2845003605,
-0.2868596613,
0.4900875092,
1.0805258751,
0.2914551497,
0.628898263,
-0.2369914502,
0.0193924606,
0.0389010049,
0.7483515739,
-0.230318889,
-0.1925027072,
0.1925871223,
-0.425481379,
-0.1857518256,
0.1172895804,
-0.2709384859,
-0.40816468,
-0.6895552874,
0.0445675924,
-0.6959188581,
-0.1003611684,
0.1487125903,
-0.2829781771,
0.110030286,
0.3256978691,
-0.5590202808,
0.4658112228,
0.6189382672,
0.3044662774,
0.1699686348,
0.3445920348,
-0.5472701788,
0.5560767055,
-0.1702074111,
0.8191035986,
-0.3767415285,
0.0197792947,
0.151538834,
-0.0339007415,
-0.1593210399,
-0.5047630072,
0.8158358335,
-0.9483776689,
-0.054973349,
-0.0262408517,
-0.8231835365,
-0.3817425966,
0.2511619031,
-0.8249983788,
0.4490554333,
-0.0488011017,
-0.7352212667,
0.8407857418,
-0.957434237,
-0.9077864289,
0.4156160057,
-0.4834222794,
-0.3996044397,
-0.1214051321,
0.380661279,
0.4452565014,
-0.1873971075,
0.6156317592,
-0.3092734218,
0.1590392441,
-0.1680373102,
0.3008363545,
1.1878587008,
0.1345952451,
-0.1835356355,
-0.0249389745,
-0.6853325963,
-0.0239774548,
0.3179259002,
-0.2867363393,
-0.6491473317,
0.3746079206,
-0.2589367032,
0.2301604003,
0.0752647296,
-0.4671806693,
0.110639371,
-0.5218619704,
0.6205394268,
0.411069572,
0.2648285031,
0.5018786788,
-0.1300976574,
0.1539498866,
0.0698869601,
0.1162880585,
0.4006689191,
-0.701151073,
-0.8032637835,
0.178595677,
0.4164845645,
0.9124868512,
-0.8670379519,
0.7250288725,
-0.4484566748,
-0.2373885512,
-0.2373076081,
0.1897732317,
0.1392677426,
0.6676926613,
0.4842351079,
-0.4029995501,
-0.6352420449,
-0.9992328882,
-0.4499295652,
-0.7502161264,
0.1968702376,
0.3840730786,
0.5717917681,
-0.0075699217,
1.3035262823,
-0.4766244292,
-0.5367958546,
0.0380441882,
0.2296581417,
0.1500759572,
0.3810345829,
0.6694244146,
-0.943721056,
-0.3365853727,
0.2495058775,
-1.1435270309,
0.3133040965,
-0.0467009991,
-0.3110796511,
-0.08281333,
0.5756459832,
-0.7030914426,
0.4563797116,
-0.47990641,
-0.5655195117,
0.3081715405,
-0.0375531726,
0.0516363569,
-0.8898907304,
-0.1940020174,
0.0681604967,
-0.575525105,
-0.6398584843,
0.0430618897,
0.1460642368,
0.2752940953,
-0.3983112574,
0.1565739661,
-0.1977560669,
-0.2216795236,
0.0096346876,
0.4941583872,
-0.0289905835,
0.6346780658,
0.0408234634,
0.1655697078,
0.0940253809,
-0.5853973627,
0.7710289955,
0.3279314935,
-0.3043130636,
0.8583782911,
-0.3510894477,
0.0010613505,
0.0414127186,
-0.0480501689,
-0.3654481471,
-0.2024567574,
0.4183607399,
-0.2165147811,
0.4053627551,
-0.4266649485,
-0.6676208377,
-0.5665434003,
0.147114113,
0.1334012598,
0.2929856777,
-0.0697566643,
1.036108017,
1.041916132,
-0.2277016342,
-0.2047408968,
-0.5907120109,
0.1922560334,
-0.2336415946,
-0.6414774656,
0.6340825558,
0.209270522,
-0.5240457058,
0.4484613538,
0.1252490133,
-0.449095726,
0.13520661,
0.3828800917,
0.0995959863,
-0.3324768245,
0.5658536553,
0.2366262674,
0.0725917444,
0.580529213,
-0.3671030402,
0.1773106009,
-0.2221967876,
-0.4267405272,
-0.3387919068,
0.1740946919,
0.3570119143,
-0.3601208031,
0.2820707858,
0.2545199096,
-0.608615458,
0.035796389,
-0.7549514174,
0.2759438157,
-0.4296573699,
0.0084320726,
-0.368785888,
-0.7561513186,
0.2730353773,
-0.0829329416,
0.2095433325,
0.925421834,
0.3687081933,
-0.1520521045,
0.7784244418,
0.5198099613,
-0.3892086744,
0.5892839432,
-0.0171537772,
0.40824458,
-0.5862698555,
-0.0764079913,
-0.4560981691,
0.1963402182,
-0.4237293601,
0.036266908,
0.3535603583,
0.0177403372,
-0.2690942883,
0.6375521421,
-0.5228298903,
0.2534581423,
0.7554703951,
0.1663488448,
0.6452581882,
-0.0287395082,
-0.2158823907,
0.2157083154,
-0.5662869215,
-0.4695503712,
1.162394166,
-0.1795289516,
-0.13378869,
0.1204449385,
0.6693322659,
0.5816836953,
0.1102385148,
-0.7600498199,
0.6269665956,
-0.258977294,
-0.6789332032,
-0.4213675261,
-0.4118336737,
-0.8770074248,
-0.1178165153,
-0.5180313587,
-0.6057348847,
0.0420046821,
-0.1778565645,
-0.605466485,
0.011933947,
-0.7079978585,
0.7714538574,
-0.2350643277,
-0.0770709887,
-0.4039412141,
-0.6321483254,
0.5600284934,
0.0030640708,
0.3905404806,
-0.0588344373,
0.5014830232,
1.0213176012,
-0.7182183862,
0.4293379784,
-0.2082153112,
0.2737655044,
0.6503521204,
-0.122183837,
0.3939566016,
0.3061133921,
-0.0010307378,
-0.3190409243,
0.0349400304,
-0.0727380887,
-0.7955256701,
0.2921474874,
-0.5109769106,
-0.7333995104,
-0.3006197512,
-0.6273771524,
-0.1612099856,
0.3783625066,
-0.3323546648,
0.1578693092,
-0.1117162928,
-0.0080004847,
0.3145550787,
-0.0077648745,
0.5104085207,
0.6222406626,
0.1028210372,
-0.2515836656,
0.935316205,
0.4231773019,
-0.4187089205,
0.2251788229,
-0.0536324754,
-0.0722064003,
-0.4038814604,
-0.5624492168,
0.0986662284,
-0.8233287334,
-0.1943132281,
-0.7968117595,
-0.447383374,
-0.6170964837,
-0.046280399,
-0.2668033838,
-0.6781235337,
0.1140586957,
-0.0834165439,
0.5541081429,
0.7446807027,
0.3858255148,
-0.1061718687,
-0.6549727321,
0.5134865046,
0.696840167,
0.0537193641,
-0.338378042,
-0.2135252059,
-0.1058029234,
-0.3073711991,
-0.2951056957,
-0.740747273,
0.1552468687,
0.1706260443,
0.6154327393,
0.4552318454,
0.3489103615,
0.8409083486,
-0.7318878174,
0.4837531149,
0.0470936745,
-0.8659142852,
0.9616293311,
-0.1330627501,
-0.2629588842,
0.7013399601,
0.125663355,
-0.0642944053,
-0.6915971041,
-0.7759237289,
-0.6385533214,
0.6335049868,
0.2960437238,
-0.0355681144,
-0.0147546791,
0.6816094518,
-0.5381384492,
0.2835661471,
-0.6823956966,
-0.0192243103,
-0.1582980454,
-0.4631126821,
0.5109154582,
0.1523501277,
-0.3331347108,
-0.5793415308,
0.6913813353,
-0.2102109343,
0.170017615,
0.1275100112,
-0.4829279184,
0.1830814332,
-0.0157441739,
0.1361142993,
0.4400155246,
-0.0977894813,
0.0549604408,
0.1174677983,
-0.3213364482,
-0.0195956901,
0.3165618479,
-0.1756365597,
-0.2059720755,
0.6131222844,
0.5183647275,
-0.1538389772,
-0.578430295,
0.6427783966,
-0.4157678783,
-0.3060317934,
-0.883377254,
0.1559284776,
0.2763326168,
0.4696379602,
0.1708976477,
-0.0158051196,
0.4518384039,
-0.7093726993,
0.4283538163,
0.4996315241,
-0.46051386,
0.273804754,
0.6043097377,
0.0274906754,
-0.1151557639,
0.8210999966,
-0.5177510977,
-0.458371371,
0.8552715182,
0.0989224687,
0.5429815054,
0.2543836534,
0.0075220959,
0.2338619083,
0.3559089005,
-0.0273249261,
0.0090063959,
-0.2218298316,
-0.837397337,
-0.2152529508,
-0.4368144274,
-0.2622653246,
-0.3882676661,
-0.6752821207,
0.2661344111,
-0.5988149643,
-0.3887661695,
0.357504338,
0.26301682,
-0.8066744208,
0.3065734208,
-0.1184502989,
0.3872885704,
-0.5769511461,
1.0012860298,
0.7995799184,
-0.7574121952,
-0.7544540167,
-0.2913824618,
0.0844842792,
-0.5796609521,
0.7935813665,
-0.0075397459,
0.1875167638,
-0.1280638576,
-0.3007613122,
-0.576417625,
1.200240612,
0.2527927458,
-0.6426071525,
-0.1895906627,
0.1667265445,
0.553768456,
-0.5563025475,
0.1174184904,
0.7155958414,
0.5121878386,
-0.2086331248,
-0.5578354597,
0.4079396725,
-0.4754711986,
-0.3293091357,
0.1631643623,
-0.2223348767,
0.5212376118,
0.1256000102,
-0.3969582915,
-0.4362206459,
0.708108902,
0.0186878741,
0.4234692752,
0.873893261,
0.6900479198,
0.9581367373,
-0.2333315015,
1.0020189285,
-0.7858325243,
0.0455694869,
1.1978303194,
-0.3724845946,
0.5209029913,
0.5842023492,
-0.201467976,
0.6817346215,
0.3495787084,
-0.2062685788,
0.3312782943,
0.2207991034,
-0.0262763817,
-0.5115113258,
-0.2805653512,
0.0987076312,
0.2199704796,
0.4789204001,
-0.457013309,
0.0353776775,
-0.0691590682,
-0.0467663631,
0.1621046215,
-0.2501640618,
1.0363574028,
0.0718119815,
-0.6357408762,
-0.1984566897,
0.1067285463,
0.0159789659,
-0.2748562992,
-0.1287218779,
0.307951957,
-0.1227178946,
-0.3516811728,
-0.8173271418,
0.5472974777,
0.01795361,
-0.41050753,
-0.0338007212,
0.9001889825,
-0.0372075103,
-0.5743408203,
0.5508471727,
0.56794554,
-0.0850682184,
-0.1856001616,
-0.8716663718,
-0.6268763542,
-0.372721523,
-0.3560193777,
0.0777896494,
0.6568385363,
-0.5282010436,
0.4623506367,
0.7661996484,
-0.0055711833,
0.0974224731,
0.2643815279,
1.0752016306,
-0.7520222068,
-0.322676897,
-0.7356881499,
0.5274720788,
-0.5561071634,
-0.1356306225,
0.2586483955,
0.3263759315,
0.6641167402,
0.3375133872,
0.796982944,
-0.4512190223,
0.2833248079,
-0.7325171232,
0.7443238497,
-0.4263620973,
0.1969596893,
-0.3616361022,
-0.5142160654,
-0.4455191493,
0.6746275425,
-0.5170669556,
-0.2232405841,
0.7335093021,
0.4757997692,
-0.0888271406,
0.1219012141,
0.0852199793,
-0.0025239524,
0.3346384168,
0.7957056165,
0.4061177671,
-0.5296621323,
0.7390320897,
-0.2946949899,
0.1678280085,
-0.0966590345,
-0.6319556236,
-0.9489793181,
-0.4621303082,
-0.426379025,
-0.1091762409,
-0.0291685499,
0.741754353,
0.7862086296,
-0.8022412658,
-0.0955536515,
-0.4536432624,
0.3797432482,
-0.11883834,
-0.2807093561,
0.3937373459,
-0.5786830783,
-0.2875939608,
0.4809187353,
0.2989379466,
-0.4244255126,
0.2101175189,
-0.0263684355,
-0.563794136,
-0.0699464679,
0.6176643968,
0.101110056,
-0.7712717056,
-0.4634927809,
-0.4688781798,
-0.2082513273,
0.0797695741,
0.9587010741,
-0.720264852,
0.5757772923,
0.3548908234,
0.768109262,
0.6630811095,
-0.2024684697,
0.8162850142,
-0.5429427028,
0.0244257394,
0.1194324642,
0.8433086276,
-0.0873773545,
-0.329192549,
0.7687426209,
0.524038136,
-0.3952009976,
-0.4041316807,
0.2458253801,
-1.0030721426,
-0.3615332246,
0.3995501101,
-0.2944140136,
-0.3996282518,
-0.6296086907,
-0.056697607,
0.6154651046,
-0.3453694582,
0.7707222104,
0.7904871106,
-0.2854996026,
0.1091079488,
-1.0399295092,
0.5207154155,
0.1730792671,
-0.9736605883,
-0.4558426738,
0.4311430752,
0.1965574175,
0.7284311652,
0.6222113967,
-0.2031589895,
0.2844381034,
-0.1396790147,
0.2994437814,
-0.1068630293,
-0.1197756231,
0.155645445,
0.5373862386,
-0.2848467827,
0.3610646129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09405v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09405v2
|
Few-shot Name Entity Recognition on StackOverflow
| 2024-04-15T01:43:14 | 2024-04-28T01:58:10 |
Xinwei Chen, Kun Li, Tianyou Song, Jiangjian Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
StackOverflow, with its vast question repository and limited labeled
examples, raise an annotation challenge for us. We address this gap by
proposing RoBERTa+MAML, a few-shot named entity recognition (NER) method
leveraging meta-learning. Our approach, evaluated on the StackOverflow NER
corpus (27 entity types), achieves a 5% F1 score improvement over the baseline.
We improved the results further domain-specific phrase processing enhance
results.
|
[
-0.6409154534,
-0.8900236487,
0.5495431423,
-0.2131315023,
-0.1327751726,
0.1395119429,
0.0133497352,
-0.6160395741,
0.3409935534,
0.59943223,
-0.7176575661,
-0.6349039674,
-0.8244433999,
0.4602797925,
-0.1593613625,
1.4393285513,
0.2110031694,
-0.0375594199,
-0.1631602198,
-0.097925581,
-0.240372479,
-0.2852404118,
-0.932962358,
-0.0524277873,
0.8392674327,
0.4665113091,
0.3034783006,
0.2076761276,
0.989226222,
0.1494690627,
-0.1012414023,
0.4182603061,
-0.4342499077,
-0.0024960814,
-0.0374118164,
-0.3449927866,
-0.5036718845,
-0.136366874,
0.7236802578,
0.3432163596,
0.0321884602,
0.5252961516,
-0.2703162134,
0.2580657303,
-0.9925612211,
-0.1226418316,
-0.8380359411,
0.1891201884,
-0.550208807,
-0.3217067719,
-0.5979158878,
-0.2987935841,
0.131928429,
-0.6972369552,
-0.0268993136,
0.1836458445,
0.9678164721,
0.3631428182,
-0.3306079209,
-0.1447720379,
-0.7324744463,
0.9335106015,
-0.4779218435,
-0.0250634123,
0.3307770193,
0.7184824347,
-0.1469407976,
-0.5236065984,
-0.684792459,
0.2156623602,
-0.2102380544,
0.0249721166,
-0.4338609278,
-0.1660416871,
0.3717491627,
0.0007234227,
-0.5581146479,
-0.0279351696,
-0.6553202868,
-0.1247438341,
0.4549853504,
0.4323499501,
0.3354022205,
-0.3733776808,
-0.5808818936,
0.2747205794,
-0.8882983923,
-0.3789430857,
0.11864461,
0.3068248034,
0.2438683659,
0.4612418413,
0.0783404708,
0.9678021073,
0.0710515678,
-0.1797638983,
0.4427498579,
-0.0540448688,
-0.2441218048,
-0.0633475259,
0.597473681,
-0.0320410691,
0.1342802793,
-0.1408418864,
0.1163873374,
-0.4367273748,
0.2646063566,
-0.8510716558,
-0.0528255254,
0.3308164775,
-0.2117960155,
-0.1341147274,
0.3439390957,
-0.667742312,
-0.3796364069,
0.1137847751,
0.4188517034,
-0.377567023,
-0.2746433616,
-0.2902074158,
-0.5406704545,
0.3394691646,
0.7016131282,
-0.654227376,
0.2897221744,
0.8838219047,
0.8831413388,
-0.3249675632,
-0.2604852617,
-0.7062065005,
0.3592854142,
-0.1297893226,
1.2501276731,
-0.7223040462,
-0.5287405849,
-0.2874394059,
-0.1310247034,
0.0815558359,
-0.5626763701,
0.2569617927,
-0.6563720703,
0.3965980709,
-0.0725366399,
-0.7651264668,
-0.2119039744,
0.552734077,
-0.6682437062,
0.8285284638,
0.0484297276,
-0.8146570921,
0.6852273345,
-0.8758245111,
-0.3879390955,
0.4384501874,
-0.1323526651,
-0.4445178807,
-0.0404359251,
0.0597563535,
0.3339533508,
-0.0351486281,
-0.3322557211,
-0.0771718696,
-0.2627361119,
0.2936667204,
-0.0035936635,
0.6810262203,
0.0220376998,
-0.0461994112,
-0.1881168485,
-0.965387404,
0.2710400224,
-0.079324834,
-0.3528156281,
-0.5417494774,
-0.3729076385,
0.2674513459,
0.2764052153,
-0.1417080313,
-0.4375522137,
0.563138485,
-0.4126697779,
0.1895047575,
0.288097769,
0.4548455775,
0.5802681446,
-0.2417996228,
0.7605753541,
0.0377920642,
0.0383048765,
-0.208071515,
-0.7573966384,
-0.6287661195,
-0.6075512171,
0.5826864839,
0.5764322877,
-0.550933063,
0.1334964782,
-0.1415502876,
-0.4659095109,
-0.7139155269,
0.2363902181,
0.6120915413,
0.6164187789,
0.832237184,
-0.1330863386,
-0.8219509125,
-0.7647439241,
-0.2107556611,
0.0765533745,
-0.1554310471,
0.6354580522,
0.8586063981,
-0.2853802741,
0.9850926995,
-0.8125988841,
-0.7805758119,
-0.1913927644,
0.8233683705,
0.334456265,
0.3462456167,
0.473123312,
-0.7506954074,
-0.6139850616,
-0.2393561006,
-0.3814408481,
0.0255054832,
0.0743025169,
-0.1439124793,
0.1914979964,
0.2925583422,
-0.7558969855,
0.2912926376,
0.2470449805,
0.1452245563,
0.2041242272,
0.266671598,
0.1077549458,
-1.301992774,
-0.0472018197,
-0.2098201811,
-0.3868015707,
-0.4189768136,
0.066561766,
-0.0648170337,
-0.167492941,
-0.9588112831,
0.8510864377,
-0.8343040943,
-0.1900305599,
-0.5513966084,
0.3800235689,
-0.0314150192,
0.1081451252,
0.2967897356,
0.664239943,
0.6049569249,
-0.7360472679,
0.1978640705,
0.3708799183,
0.0208416786,
0.9255939722,
-0.5293530822,
0.306842804,
-0.1764284372,
0.5828686953,
-0.9371148348,
-0.3770568371,
0.1676079482,
-0.6016423106,
0.3101242483,
-0.5935707092,
-0.4243990481,
-0.2388346046,
-0.2646812201,
0.303994447,
0.6001557112,
-0.3785692453,
0.5208805799,
0.47330603,
0.2004535496,
-0.6477820873,
-0.931381762,
0.092468828,
-0.0829704925,
-0.2417565435,
0.6219878197,
0.2800833881,
-0.1327457279,
0.2196392119,
0.1754968315,
-0.5352480412,
-0.0555877611,
0.3616191745,
0.1779937446,
-0.4066333175,
0.5476548076,
-0.3606968522,
-0.5620499849,
-0.2918511927,
-0.2115624696,
0.3525912762,
-0.1974206716,
-0.1748542488,
-0.4383617043,
0.2748203576,
0.1605458558,
-0.350895077,
0.8000549078,
0.8455963135,
-0.6590191722,
-0.5319489241,
-0.4843435585,
-0.1945018768,
-0.3786019981,
-0.0964456499,
-0.2927208245,
-0.9629338384,
0.3373905718,
-0.0853384361,
-0.0924698487,
0.8748051524,
0.2937546074,
-0.2405107319,
0.4965438843,
0.6600579023,
-0.0669919103,
0.2872278094,
-0.2916629016,
0.0569341369,
-1.0682195425,
0.0295920651,
-0.4977559447,
-0.4332042336,
-0.3831555545,
-0.6092105508,
0.4406241775,
-0.0915711895,
0.1200381666,
0.7643134594,
-0.6372737885,
0.8448715806,
0.4030819535,
-0.0329679064,
0.3548095524,
-0.5876496434,
0.2154968828,
-0.1155479848,
-0.2695452273,
-0.4478788376,
1.0649749041,
0.0125327148,
0.6487578154,
0.3848742843,
1.2049683332,
0.1893347353,
0.4712618291,
-0.7302958369,
0.4617168903,
0.0284755845,
-1.199242115,
-0.2846382558,
-0.3200199306,
-0.7897799611,
-0.0612439588,
-0.594574213,
-0.7755228877,
-0.1040810868,
0.0768810883,
-0.6911289692,
0.1544257253,
-0.3520240188,
0.8464452028,
-0.2655033171,
-0.0592353791,
-0.1064450294,
-0.5847875476,
0.4722927809,
-0.00469467,
0.0144024827,
-0.1533866674,
-0.249091506,
0.4106725752,
-0.3904105425,
0.7479510903,
-0.0633039102,
0.2790286541,
0.4249752164,
-0.0860801116,
0.3455361724,
0.2242644578,
0.0584585406,
0.2269105166,
-0.1862878948,
-0.2491926253,
-0.6055467129,
0.5279875398,
-0.281114161,
-0.3004992902,
-0.5505475402,
-0.0694217756,
-0.021594746,
0.3677474558,
0.5278164744,
0.1823583543,
-0.3403263688,
0.1776388139,
0.5905091166,
0.0360860527,
0.4087706208,
0.6200294495,
-0.3809499443,
-0.364449352,
0.5512905121,
0.2555423081,
0.0613494106,
0.773545742,
-0.1155609041,
-0.0579966605,
-0.3771970868,
-0.6471099854,
0.093531765,
-0.7057624459,
-0.6073336601,
-0.8341181874,
-0.3948179483,
-0.1500494182,
-0.2485553622,
-0.2186842263,
-0.5335792899,
-0.5885253549,
-0.1148012355,
0.7140262723,
0.5690062642,
0.37698403,
0.324324578,
-1.0017625093,
0.4231295288,
0.3040544391,
-0.0338703543,
-0.360255003,
-0.5452064276,
0.1795027405,
-0.3174853623,
-0.1488103569,
-1.0209051371,
0.0312117562,
0.6027008295,
0.5311478972,
0.5002858043,
-0.0163764637,
0.8821448088,
-0.7819560766,
0.6609025002,
0.1112740636,
-0.8487887979,
0.9404354095,
-0.0023962406,
0.2901027501,
0.7095916271,
0.7217196226,
-0.2480210513,
-0.3379131556,
-0.8679264784,
-0.5920729041,
0.2554546297,
0.0829154328,
0.4116654694,
-0.3692454994,
0.3623858094,
0.1204299852,
0.0337573849,
-0.6719363332,
-0.1247488931,
0.4193964303,
0.0037327001,
0.339854449,
-0.2450975776,
-0.0328573622,
-0.0964993164,
0.6362996697,
-0.0816144794,
0.1161660478,
0.0652535558,
-0.4105636179,
-0.092686139,
0.584487021,
0.6845139265,
0.6464235783,
-0.162567988,
0.1516043395,
0.6372563243,
-0.2628267705,
-0.1386866271,
-0.2377430946,
-0.230091691,
0.4287270308,
0.429746002,
0.5671662092,
0.6267264485,
-0.5456858277,
0.7310559154,
0.2178985775,
-0.030609617,
-0.4922725558,
0.3697413802,
-0.0132917445,
0.4060365558,
0.5779153109,
0.1063363254,
0.3692742586,
-0.5876561999,
0.5297954679,
0.6515606046,
-0.4388251901,
-0.1338905394,
0.4829079807,
0.2088787854,
-0.4388771057,
0.4072492421,
-0.4872194827,
-0.5499922633,
0.502776742,
0.6676211953,
0.8183222413,
0.0094807856,
0.2806306183,
0.6959766746,
0.2003870904,
0.0356296562,
0.2445710152,
-0.1453724205,
-0.6067962646,
-0.1287966967,
-0.5701834559,
-0.7943393588,
-0.2483159453,
-0.4989694953,
0.7029694915,
-0.7905201316,
-0.5279884338,
0.492441237,
-0.1318316311,
-0.5301944613,
0.2167468667,
0.11169976,
0.7249535322,
-0.5820447206,
0.7097587585,
0.7361766696,
-1.0483404398,
-0.3891023993,
0.0392361544,
0.2852497697,
-0.6641517878,
1.1490514278,
0.1252542138,
-0.2942325473,
0.1577707678,
-0.4274393022,
-0.7622721791,
1.1914916039,
-0.1828434616,
-0.4349089861,
0.1143912151,
-0.3072896898,
0.6211356521,
-0.554887712,
0.5148513317,
0.0692907944,
0.6310927868,
0.2190033942,
-0.7046001554,
-0.2338598818,
-0.1585993022,
-0.1666625738,
0.5473161936,
-0.4085204601,
0.8772075772,
-0.4829039276,
-0.3886085153,
-0.0137010142,
0.6380569935,
0.1533793062,
0.4195401371,
0.296058923,
0.7388744354,
0.8750214577,
-0.1309284121,
0.9460608959,
0.0966726393,
0.6325618029,
1.4413511753,
-0.3477726579,
1.4885530472,
0.4538942873,
-0.2951254249,
0.698348701,
0.3135851622,
-0.4847253263,
0.5372231007,
0.2633024454,
-0.2320164293,
-0.1116706878,
-0.088586174,
-0.3107851446,
0.5692908764,
0.3141901791,
-0.4227015078,
-0.331245929,
0.1315082759,
0.0538640022,
-0.2525719106,
-0.3178130388,
1.0845047235,
0.1450181901,
-0.3590918779,
0.3329866827,
-0.0842821002,
0.760381639,
-0.2897135019,
-0.2684268951,
0.1015168577,
0.0071093263,
-0.4891769886,
-0.758806169,
0.5783751607,
0.3414362073,
-0.2684262693,
0.0344689749,
0.9201942682,
-0.4169702232,
-0.5010672808,
0.1367924064,
0.454344511,
0.4605835378,
-0.0432277173,
-0.584848702,
-0.4585289061,
-0.7000011802,
0.1255580783,
0.0531809628,
0.5210197568,
0.1920325905,
0.4441106021,
0.5586777329,
0.0495673902,
0.3391965628,
0.0288456231,
0.5290545225,
-0.6403510571,
-0.2620416284,
-0.9995242953,
0.6167386174,
-0.2824600637,
-0.8116591573,
0.855076611,
0.495428592,
0.8637778163,
-0.321531713,
0.6190935969,
-0.0754088312,
0.7917460203,
-0.6005617976,
0.6066653728,
-0.6576960683,
0.0403541587,
-0.4593413174,
-0.9151978493,
-0.7859396935,
0.5499541163,
-0.4024322331,
-0.0362885259,
0.7575631738,
0.455832541,
-0.2493059784,
-0.3107325137,
0.2854915261,
-0.1773451865,
-0.1375914365,
0.7256860137,
0.928727448,
-0.6099087,
0.6182019114,
0.0560687296,
0.1778321117,
-0.7700914741,
-1.1113455296,
-0.9077617526,
-0.2836928666,
-0.5026776195,
-0.1915729493,
0.097650826,
0.8138440251,
0.8906196952,
-1.0167448521,
0.527646482,
-0.0303664636,
0.3948282301,
-0.0619738847,
-0.2478320897,
0.0378354229,
-0.38760674,
-0.6030727029,
0.1806712002,
0.6534346342,
-0.1702845395,
-0.2113883346,
0.0330136046,
-0.4020939469,
-0.0529770069,
0.3950662017,
0.5857411623,
-0.7915803194,
-0.3849539459,
0.025876049,
-0.3675477207,
0.2376536727,
0.6201068759,
-0.4823686481,
0.1901414692,
0.6470738053,
1.0245835781,
0.5217449665,
0.2610975802,
0.0830953568,
-1.0853391886,
0.0436608866,
0.4833705127,
0.2361954749,
0.2485377342,
-0.4154507816,
0.5573079586,
0.0860241577,
-0.4412123263,
-0.547534287,
0.2800143063,
-1.0123713017,
-0.1400313079,
1.1137906313,
-0.1325829625,
-0.3324613571,
-0.030022867,
-0.1915412843,
-0.1889875531,
-0.2709801495,
0.6030438542,
0.7340508699,
-0.2052587122,
-0.6342493892,
-0.6223281026,
0.4336201847,
0.1234028488,
-1.2851320505,
-0.5821716189,
0.4564206302,
0.4939828217,
0.5896446109,
0.7924101353,
-0.1322117001,
0.5072127581,
-0.1899746954,
0.0497294515,
0.0244310424,
-0.6588195562,
-0.2255375087,
0.2116043866,
-0.0053573935,
-0.4615546763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09385v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09385v2
|
A Large-Scale Evaluation of Speech Foundation Models
| 2024-04-15T00:03:16 | 2024-05-29T21:24:40 |
Shu-wen Yang, Heng-Jui Chang, Zili Huang, Andy T. Liu, Cheng-I Lai, Haibin Wu, Jiatong Shi, Xuankai Chang, Hsiang-Sheng Tsai, Wen-Chin Huang, Tzu-hsun Feng, Po-Han Chi, Yist Y. Lin, Yung-Sung Chuang, Tzu-Hsien Huang, Wei-Cheng Tseng, Kushal Lakhotia, Shang-Wen Li, Abdelrahman Mohamed, Shinji Watanabe, Hung-yi Lee
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, eess.SP
|
The foundation model paradigm leverages a shared foundation model to achieve
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance for various tasks, requiring minimal
downstream-specific modeling and data annotation. This approach has proven
crucial in the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP). However, the speech
processing community lacks a similar setup to explore the paradigm
systematically. In this work, we establish the Speech processing Universal
PERformance Benchmark (SUPERB) to study the effectiveness of the paradigm for
speech. We propose a unified multi-tasking framework to address speech
processing tasks in SUPERB using a frozen foundation model followed by
task-specialized, lightweight prediction heads. Combining our results with
community submissions, we verify that the foundation model paradigm is
promising for speech, and our multi-tasking framework is simple yet effective,
as the best-performing foundation model shows competitive generalizability
across most SUPERB tasks. For reproducibility and extensibility, we have
developed a long-term maintained platform that enables deterministic
benchmarking, allows for result sharing via an online leaderboard, and promotes
collaboration through a community-driven benchmark database to support new
development cycles. Finally, we conduct a series of analyses to offer an
in-depth understanding of SUPERB and speech foundation models, including
information flows across tasks inside the models, the correctness of the
weighted-sum benchmarking protocol and the statistical significance and
robustness of the benchmark.
|
[
-0.4144961536,
-0.6757276058,
-0.0253867805,
0.5143126249,
-0.1135161817,
-0.0155284656,
-0.2356950343,
-0.6044211984,
0.1171513125,
0.5188378692,
-0.4720797241,
-0.3395096362,
-0.5837216973,
-0.0240472164,
-0.7116225958,
0.6624580622,
0.5625201464,
0.2372724414,
-0.1960443854,
-0.1920577437,
-0.4537529647,
-0.5243601799,
-0.5110325217,
-0.648160398,
-0.3050773144,
0.1775331348,
0.5042020679,
0.610648334,
0.4963604808,
0.2436060905,
-0.24016653,
-0.3498760462,
-0.5254225731,
0.1945525706,
-0.3420650363,
-0.0562237091,
-0.5515047312,
-0.0805885047,
0.7509705424,
0.9855175614,
-0.5072799325,
0.303136915,
0.1780278087,
0.5443128347,
-0.6165644526,
0.2669343948,
-0.6571722627,
-0.0641514957,
-0.3391214609,
0.1165927127,
-0.1693424284,
-0.0410017334,
0.3422821164,
-0.2639880776,
0.1856526434,
-0.3875317574,
0.2941844165,
0.2598694861,
-0.0467602685,
-0.03933331,
-0.6196405888,
0.656663537,
-0.625602901,
0.7167367339,
0.0154305175,
0.3284855485,
-0.1392050982,
-0.6661740541,
-0.4722259045,
-0.3767083585,
0.3543652892,
-0.1331320852,
-0.4882466495,
0.0431464426,
-0.0009602848,
0.4759186208,
-0.6183683872,
0.0216517672,
0.0410438254,
-0.3269347548,
0.4852182567,
-0.0547546148,
0.0110335043,
-0.1668045372,
-0.4235021472,
-0.1343287975,
-0.4460116625,
0.2363645136,
-0.3540166616,
0.7480243444,
-0.1515454054,
0.3562268615,
-0.6977982521,
0.8132636547,
-0.1630092263,
-0.2603809536,
0.2441653907,
-0.3631997705,
-0.4446881711,
-0.0770032257,
0.7531320453,
0.2028703839,
0.2180565596,
-0.5473122001,
-0.0620222539,
0.4844866991,
0.0567990951,
-0.6933423877,
0.1067342013,
-0.081361182,
-0.0572246872,
-0.0096770991,
-0.3094008267,
-0.6361812353,
-0.4437301159,
-0.5159012079,
0.3751138747,
-0.1615687311,
-0.4243809581,
0.3075008094,
0.0090881176,
-0.1220975518,
-0.0774805993,
-0.8729516864,
0.8484953046,
0.8609461188,
0.7260343432,
-0.4031728804,
-0.2926437259,
-0.7573649883,
0.0805729553,
-0.2498221397,
0.8821006417,
-0.6430642605,
-0.296874851,
-0.2410527319,
-0.4106767476,
-0.1648524404,
-0.6247170568,
0.6974750757,
-0.1601601839,
-0.4310213327,
-0.2518846989,
-0.5682300925,
0.0106099173,
-0.0493705384,
-0.6305710077,
0.9469427466,
-0.2051828057,
-0.4000403583,
0.2979135513,
-0.7449141145,
-0.4988516271,
0.0684373975,
-0.3255241513,
0.0334072858,
0.2331505269,
0.1171112061,
0.81315732,
-0.7175546288,
0.8559024334,
-0.0940388665,
-0.4566923082,
-0.0789793283,
-0.3097364306,
0.6733537912,
0.0260886587,
-0.8716149926,
0.099302724,
-1.0214118958,
-0.002806616,
-0.2203557342,
-0.1475723237,
0.0162049849,
-0.2104455233,
0.3907568455,
0.1789119393,
-0.0337776877,
-0.5370012522,
-0.2215951979,
-0.2672451735,
0.7538822889,
0.5308282375,
-0.4435268044,
0.1464181542,
-0.0610792935,
0.2731104195,
-0.520088315,
-0.066806525,
0.0474107787,
-0.57066679,
-0.4648136497,
-0.2258221507,
0.4118146896,
0.4021522105,
-0.1885782778,
0.2883460522,
-0.3737159669,
-0.6074805856,
-0.366622895,
-0.007160007,
0.7294416428,
0.5750761032,
0.4551218748,
-0.5879228115,
-0.5513927341,
-0.9549000859,
-0.15542382,
0.1355151683,
0.1269271374,
0.1540418714,
0.380492866,
-0.0963837057,
1.0320147276,
-0.0984151363,
-0.3019037247,
-0.1972367913,
0.338612318,
0.246461466,
0.6703672409,
0.290373832,
-0.8580293059,
-0.2000308484,
-0.2934101224,
-0.6672517061,
0.0125344209,
0.385392487,
0.0273989365,
0.0431573354,
0.2421383113,
-0.6881865859,
0.1902585626,
0.7744606137,
-0.1946404725,
0.793368876,
0.241842702,
0.1844779402,
-0.7161670327,
0.4550870657,
0.1230940744,
-0.0864985138,
-0.7802951932,
0.4693553746,
-0.2575553358,
-0.3896998167,
-0.2366117388,
0.3723136485,
0.0218287203,
-0.538599968,
-0.0821525082,
0.168100968,
-0.1115695462,
0.3552487791,
0.1099844649,
0.8316055536,
0.9040820599,
-0.5411249399,
0.3295536935,
-0.0149151292,
-0.5228739381,
0.8898976445,
-0.9075402617,
0.1714993864,
0.1758742779,
0.3939766884,
-1.1280063391,
-0.2050298452,
-0.3053702414,
-0.3750365973,
0.1578060687,
0.1818058342,
-0.4762217104,
-0.3239661753,
0.0101022832,
-0.0224552341,
0.120956704,
-0.2884116471,
0.5948297977,
0.796949923,
-0.3507844508,
-0.6880705953,
-0.6556859612,
0.3015524149,
0.0327032804,
-0.8328058124,
0.6471271515,
-0.2316832691,
-0.1028003171,
-0.1897218972,
-0.5973724723,
-0.2096952498,
0.2262187153,
0.3677332401,
-0.1488838494,
-0.4137803614,
0.1082492843,
-0.1469863951,
-0.3551869094,
-0.1022321135,
-0.1633540243,
0.6740252972,
-0.4949946105,
-0.0637255758,
-0.7352458835,
0.406842798,
0.6838779449,
-0.3645008802,
0.3257010281,
0.4815211892,
-0.7606868744,
-0.0208774749,
-0.8235578537,
-0.0978790596,
-0.3577537537,
0.3904544711,
-0.5683709979,
-1.0811361074,
0.3505209982,
-0.0874093026,
0.2560263574,
0.4741379917,
0.3580990434,
0.1596936136,
0.8299996853,
0.8290240765,
-0.2848652303,
-0.013601278,
-0.3787472844,
-0.174168244,
-0.7450047135,
-0.1575850993,
-0.9368428588,
0.0591143034,
0.1122033969,
-0.5044748783,
0.1673090905,
0.5666061044,
-0.0931691378,
0.5842267275,
-0.5589143634,
0.2542437315,
0.5026513934,
-0.2307930291,
0.5119034052,
0.1231130213,
-0.249374494,
0.002811857,
-0.5457143188,
-0.4600838125,
1.0542008877,
0.0474053882,
0.2578549385,
-0.0519891046,
0.3448618948,
0.3831670582,
0.3779862523,
-0.3164896071,
0.6237336993,
-0.6606223583,
-0.6882403493,
-0.5684717298,
-0.319378674,
-0.6160446405,
0.6156646609,
-0.4001964629,
-1.0918323994,
-0.0518233441,
0.1775859892,
-0.5096340179,
-0.062098071,
-0.4354473352,
0.9876506329,
0.2985683084,
-0.2158328742,
-0.5860828757,
-0.5156632662,
0.2873035371,
-0.0533240363,
0.3586331308,
-0.3475227356,
0.4523167014,
0.9744285345,
0.0858639181,
0.6913089156,
-0.1490538716,
0.1026311591,
0.1384360194,
-0.0844797641,
0.1733132154,
0.0138308937,
-0.5217781067,
0.4576703906,
-0.0226631109,
-0.0643542334,
-0.3100283444,
0.9079685211,
-0.6042732596,
-0.4009695351,
0.0502621569,
-0.4701547325,
-0.6949455738,
0.3367065489,
-0.0106398603,
0.9408298731,
-0.4959417582,
0.6879467964,
0.4866257608,
0.3786041737,
0.3117000163,
0.6754159331,
-0.059103433,
-0.3110271692,
0.7243727446,
0.2621512711,
0.0968267024,
0.4784626663,
0.3882806897,
-0.5127023458,
-0.6581454277,
-0.5945832729,
-0.0800082237,
-0.5194855332,
0.0339573473,
-0.7788411379,
0.027217852,
-0.7569675446,
0.0147607075,
-0.7151798606,
-0.4152052701,
0.1281781197,
-0.0619078688,
-0.0750575736,
0.5740264058,
-0.3270061612,
0.2065291256,
-0.4141518176,
0.6592905521,
0.566247642,
0.5232490897,
0.2195326239,
-0.1637548506,
0.0283292141,
0.2033642381,
-0.1857601106,
-0.6132337451,
-0.2281008959,
0.5303681493,
0.8799680471,
0.1298408061,
-0.0324632861,
0.6935841441,
-0.4569847584,
0.7268423438,
0.3414230347,
-1.4153798819,
0.3625512719,
-0.2351864129,
0.3222148418,
0.7594748139,
0.1207434833,
-0.534270227,
-0.277446121,
-0.4424090683,
-0.6704187989,
0.5463691354,
0.236634776,
-0.0537122265,
0.1462185979,
0.0896945298,
0.1650373042,
0.5242786407,
-0.466645807,
-0.5017265081,
-0.158365652,
0.2995431125,
-0.3670373261,
0.0012523178,
-0.3285726905,
-0.1611998528,
0.6351632476,
-0.147462666,
0.0473869815,
-0.0715752691,
0.0033148264,
-0.2104665935,
0.4940118492,
0.4899348021,
1.0637897253,
-0.1824189872,
-0.0561029874,
-0.0319370292,
-0.3132943213,
0.0126371207,
0.5345445275,
0.0249616615,
0.0281154122,
0.3521110117,
0.7408483028,
0.8040825129,
-0.7381448746,
0.5133456588,
0.0056699631,
-0.0514549315,
0.2313262224,
0.0890548304,
0.4125467539,
0.2277567089,
0.6077005863,
0.4482497573,
0.52013129,
-0.6006349921,
0.4907685816,
0.4562217593,
-0.4888934195,
-0.2372929156,
0.6758460402,
0.3396870196,
-0.3625224829,
0.1985207498,
-0.0675629899,
-0.3345139623,
0.6366764903,
0.6642526388,
0.6852833033,
-0.4475462437,
0.4086931348,
0.1714681834,
0.1185197681,
-0.3723276854,
0.285744071,
-0.3600327671,
-0.5806415677,
-0.728820622,
-0.9028692842,
-0.4120012522,
0.2478287518,
-0.9618155956,
-0.2011080831,
-0.3146781027,
-0.3125405014,
0.4958470762,
-0.012407532,
-0.7067018747,
0.5090098977,
0.2755588293,
0.9618521929,
-0.798275888,
0.6632291079,
0.5591139793,
0.0999252573,
-0.7603396773,
-0.1815848202,
0.1496366411,
-0.7720949054,
0.3734105825,
0.5276159644,
-0.4964671731,
0.1107819602,
-0.2478699535,
-1.1066857576,
0.9203262329,
0.7746084332,
-0.7419661283,
0.1668354869,
0.1934380531,
0.6804019213,
-0.4079013169,
-0.0326020531,
0.6930612326,
0.1726684868,
0.248735562,
-1.4562277794,
0.0559598356,
-0.2151338756,
0.0577787794,
-0.087068215,
-0.4815843701,
0.8149166703,
-0.1033377796,
-0.34703812,
0.1575666815,
0.5633788109,
0.5614647269,
0.3057020307,
0.6508898139,
0.760376215,
0.7400892377,
-0.0851759836,
0.7183037996,
-0.3946087658,
0.3495506942,
1.2148559093,
-0.3534202576,
1.2102862597,
0.1508634984,
-0.4404923022,
0.2022854388,
0.049458947,
0.338644892,
0.5853406787,
0.4459218979,
0.0330777355,
-0.4138928354,
-0.6050898433,
-0.8239984512,
0.7409210205,
0.2476618141,
0.1247734204,
-0.3136616945,
0.1503314227,
-0.2216144055,
0.1071385592,
-0.4349729419,
0.351408422,
0.111395441,
-0.5195159912,
0.6503040791,
-0.0233070496,
0.790633738,
-0.5970566869,
0.0748263896,
0.0177210458,
0.0797781199,
-0.0483968817,
-0.3777083457,
0.2752892673,
0.0639103055,
-0.2856399417,
-0.1341965795,
0.4540295303,
-0.063893877,
-0.3746900856,
0.5111900568,
0.3205294609,
0.0785860047,
-0.3078622818,
-0.7736749053,
0.4340736866,
-0.3079421818,
-0.1767046601,
0.324883461,
-0.1032982096,
0.1018915102,
0.7200378776,
0.7544435859,
0.0639625043,
-0.0798741803,
0.4125008285,
0.732088685,
-0.3465528488,
-0.8556500077,
-0.7157447338,
0.5079395771,
-0.0668158308,
-0.6119155884,
0.4484235644,
0.455019027,
0.7366588712,
0.2573201358,
0.5807827711,
-0.1019497439,
0.6471843719,
-0.3280304372,
0.6348798275,
-0.4131057262,
-0.0579678454,
-0.7624839544,
-0.9961369038,
-0.2968225777,
0.6316682696,
0.0982722566,
-0.2097119391,
0.4256564975,
0.5610309243,
0.1907821,
0.6710324883,
0.4124651849,
0.2443810254,
0.1204880998,
0.355207175,
0.3962289989,
-0.2878828347,
0.3436866403,
-0.5234141946,
-0.5391231179,
0.028218599,
-0.8592624664,
-0.5834383368,
-0.7341186404,
-0.2319480926,
0.0040689963,
0.5368691683,
0.791413784,
1.3592514992,
-0.9913348556,
-0.5764312744,
-0.1706467122,
-0.2779137194,
-0.715026319,
-0.1941750199,
0.4070835114,
0.1103446931,
-0.4823904932,
0.9662334919,
0.3680064082,
-0.4564533532,
-0.4490279257,
0.1431948394,
-0.0298131052,
-0.2347541302,
0.5346633196,
0.2252324671,
-0.8769931793,
0.0451087877,
-0.094045423,
-0.0323628187,
-0.2105989903,
0.8073045611,
-0.7788393497,
0.5526035428,
0.0491860919,
0.8581317067,
0.2501453757,
-0.103632085,
0.5857857466,
-0.5417222381,
-0.2065531462,
0.2073127776,
0.2983319461,
0.4798779786,
-0.0724031478,
0.606867969,
0.3152054846,
-0.3882648349,
-0.9596484303,
-0.0394038484,
-0.8744270802,
-0.1103629842,
0.7979707718,
-0.1492648423,
0.3354757428,
-0.1700924188,
0.2559165061,
0.1710647494,
-0.6308002472,
0.6822017431,
0.7565475702,
-0.2798941433,
0.2003640682,
-0.6067628264,
0.3444805443,
0.4434653819,
-0.6368365288,
0.171918422,
0.4292841554,
0.3146825731,
0.5363216996,
0.9123892188,
0.087777026,
0.3349599242,
0.0431166515,
-0.019523073,
-0.061040815,
-0.5818663239,
-0.4310877621,
0.7309294343,
-0.3068235517,
0.0977747515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09384v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09384v1
|
Tasks People Prompt: A Taxonomy of LLM Downstream Tasks in Software Verification and Falsification Approaches
| 2024-04-14T23:45:23 | 2024-04-14T23:45:23 |
Víctor A. Braberman, Flavia Bonomo-Braberman, Yiannis Charalambous, Juan G. Colonna, Lucas C. Cordeiro, Rosiane de Freitas
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, F.3.1; D.2.4; D.2.5; I.2.7
|
Prompting has become one of the main approaches to leverage emergent
capabilities of Large Language Models [Brown et al. NeurIPS 2020, Wei et al.
TMLR 2022, Wei et al. NeurIPS 2022]. During the last year, researchers and
practitioners have been playing with prompts to see how to make the most of
LLMs. By homogeneously dissecting 80 papers, we investigate in deep how
software testing and verification research communities have been abstractly
architecting their LLM-enabled solutions. More precisely, first, we want to
validate whether downstream tasks are an adequate concept to convey the
blueprint of prompt-based solutions. We also aim at identifying number and
nature of such tasks in solutions. For such goal, we develop a novel downstream
task taxonomy that enables pinpointing some engineering patterns in a rather
varied spectrum of Software Engineering problems that encompasses testing,
fuzzing, debugging, vulnerability detection, static analysis and program
verification approaches.
|
[
-0.4827692807,
-0.5832425356,
0.7028813362,
0.4581228495,
0.1994068027,
0.2225033194,
0.3588939309,
-0.1401250809,
-0.243301183,
0.4748412669,
-1.2190686464,
-0.2937844396,
-0.5359213352,
0.3999139965,
-0.5461078882,
1.0785593987,
-0.2859588563,
-0.2162339985,
-0.2067709118,
0.1419137269,
-0.6383137107,
-0.3511581421,
-0.5178869963,
-0.2883927822,
0.7433340549,
0.3777983785,
0.2227726728,
0.4312102497,
0.0884747058,
0.2211655229,
-0.0361102708,
-0.0384631194,
-0.1043146849,
0.4048292935,
0.1164733395,
-0.6192036271,
-0.1008730605,
0.1154803187,
0.2744860351,
0.5067533255,
0.3408390284,
0.5823013186,
0.4751281142,
0.5485566854,
-0.5349573493,
0.223899588,
-0.4203637242,
-0.140038237,
-0.4378159344,
-0.4330241084,
-0.6133311987,
-0.0213424992,
-0.1162300482,
-0.2472252995,
0.3263176084,
0.1947208196,
0.6216032505,
0.4472090006,
-0.5495463014,
-0.2961244881,
-0.5105531812,
0.7984778881,
-0.2674289644,
0.2864435613,
0.175346449,
0.1364700943,
-0.4645212293,
-0.4338844717,
-0.3066242337,
-0.3761872649,
-0.0180600714,
-0.0981459543,
-0.1820415109,
0.0003841714,
0.3908226788,
0.4116245508,
-0.5922231674,
0.1169555858,
-0.2702641189,
-0.4770232141,
0.7386481762,
0.3966666758,
0.527254045,
0.0003468752,
-0.5449354649,
0.4342003465,
-0.9906835556,
0.3793097138,
0.3921709359,
0.1886311769,
-0.1416643858,
0.3739180863,
-0.2450280041,
0.9023030996,
0.0925368294,
-0.1108255759,
-0.1409019083,
-0.3757322729,
-0.1365188658,
-0.2501350343,
0.3678111136,
0.0317704231,
-0.13537471,
-0.1594000906,
-0.6000694036,
-0.1322533637,
0.3348611295,
-0.2127967179,
-0.3767419159,
0.6971537471,
-0.3651752472,
-0.3313322961,
-0.2282787561,
-0.3410251737,
-0.8144119978,
-0.5662112236,
0.2865608633,
-0.1279565692,
-0.2194115371,
-0.267516613,
-0.1960632354,
0.4518084526,
0.4193204343,
-0.8260614276,
0.1047818288,
1.1644836664,
0.7998127341,
-0.3064283133,
-0.3570842147,
-0.7618117332,
-0.1976774633,
-0.161144644,
0.9172081947,
-0.210702464,
-0.3783400059,
-0.0426925756,
0.0389392637,
0.2736399174,
-0.3966642916,
0.4988362193,
-0.5593046546,
0.0152861355,
-0.6456627846,
-0.3594439328,
-0.0968753844,
0.5758919716,
-0.5823676586,
1.2360379696,
0.302241385,
-0.6108624339,
0.3601923287,
-0.66973418,
-0.2326438576,
0.5726501346,
-0.3807192147,
0.1528714299,
0.0606363155,
0.0213377196,
0.5586913228,
-0.4859765768,
-0.0453705676,
0.0845800191,
-0.3522306383,
0.1260386705,
0.1532375365,
1.0663769245,
0.2820549011,
-0.4358879924,
0.4707397521,
-0.3470828533,
-0.1366474628,
-0.1180261448,
-0.3416843712,
-0.1480998844,
0.1130898893,
-0.1448159516,
0.3264953494,
0.2200790942,
-0.4968849123,
0.2743424475,
-0.1526869982,
0.7353355885,
0.9999505877,
0.2818047702,
0.3967113197,
-0.6643867493,
0.9276335239,
0.0918641686,
0.3768174052,
-0.4539568126,
-0.9358728528,
-0.597722888,
-0.3276760578,
-0.0038025584,
0.804639101,
-0.584931016,
0.3103452027,
0.0314417742,
-0.562828958,
-0.3115313351,
0.4245518148,
0.1838296354,
0.4635170698,
0.1333673596,
0.1204511225,
-0.4607260823,
-0.7274520993,
-0.3254439533,
-0.4037488103,
-0.2557555735,
0.1093300208,
0.5664455295,
-0.1865467578,
1.0848565102,
-0.3895814419,
-0.072456941,
-0.3312856555,
0.364210397,
0.4193595052,
0.1050852761,
0.3987604976,
-0.8724085093,
-0.3197681904,
-0.3332765996,
-0.3824764192,
-0.5045467615,
-0.3647373915,
-0.0559146628,
0.3301210999,
0.7620705366,
-0.4475736916,
-0.0727648288,
0.5209850669,
-0.4172272384,
0.8685096502,
0.2890850604,
0.1416553557,
-0.7280625701,
0.0602518506,
0.0812899172,
-0.0069402931,
-0.5334883928,
0.4183631837,
0.0149016902,
-0.0625235066,
-0.480833739,
0.8277506232,
-0.7715129256,
-0.0436238796,
-0.3077242672,
-0.0246180613,
-0.2156251222,
0.3485636413,
-0.4662033021,
0.9501140714,
0.6534765363,
-0.8804864287,
0.4532367587,
0.0047283676,
-0.0999518186,
0.4837359786,
-0.657677412,
0.1370828599,
-0.1591750085,
0.1808452457,
-1.4989928007,
-0.3904334307,
0.3084169924,
-0.4315290153,
-0.0084629701,
-0.2794522345,
-0.6260399818,
-0.620431006,
-0.2514405251,
0.2531834543,
0.8058950305,
-0.2620268762,
0.6271328926,
0.1401607096,
-0.2755698562,
-0.4769493937,
-0.626378119,
-0.0458214246,
-0.2480274588,
-0.7222935557,
0.3018116951,
-0.0219980702,
-0.528023243,
-0.2854863107,
-0.2796927691,
-0.1024254709,
0.6693980694,
0.5626233816,
0.502106905,
-0.0862665698,
0.1321676373,
-0.0550864562,
-0.2656138539,
0.5202601552,
-0.286341846,
0.321696192,
0.2213160098,
-0.5064181089,
-0.209883973,
0.4931610227,
0.4248707891,
-0.1294122338,
-0.003345879,
0.2851002216,
-0.3804367781,
-0.3046088219,
-0.5680584311,
-0.2656994164,
-0.5229418874,
0.0401147678,
-0.4469330609,
-1.1367632151,
0.7511424422,
-0.262068361,
0.5492463708,
0.3564895689,
0.5448422432,
-0.069874756,
0.7369981408,
0.6873210669,
-0.1595337987,
0.2492846996,
0.2353178263,
0.2451662123,
-0.5598058701,
-0.0775068179,
-0.6986082196,
-0.2909273207,
-0.3799797297,
-0.4095893204,
0.4913562536,
0.0730815977,
-0.2624703646,
0.1390044093,
-0.6603482962,
0.5374107361,
0.4680569768,
-0.0135656791,
0.2029996067,
-0.3339395225,
-0.1418621093,
0.1378344744,
-0.2509896457,
-0.721416533,
0.7439156771,
0.3798540235,
0.4011317492,
-0.0408037454,
0.9072993398,
0.7162477374,
0.5531369448,
-1.029930234,
0.8550665975,
0.2508642673,
-0.7845375538,
-0.2377384901,
0.0174040515,
-0.9570788145,
-0.4532317221,
0.3189239502,
-0.7613280416,
-0.0846856534,
0.2613655031,
-0.6554971337,
-0.0746737719,
-0.4699571133,
0.6772301197,
-0.0992178842,
-0.0894654095,
0.1037474573,
-0.5444859862,
0.5135762095,
-0.05520235,
0.166317299,
-0.2435929328,
-0.4343964458,
0.5610778332,
-0.3263283372,
0.9357884526,
-0.3460695148,
-0.5889984369,
0.4219267368,
0.2784332633,
0.6826727986,
-0.2351424843,
0.0166116077,
-0.2045489252,
-0.1249089092,
-0.4299085438,
-0.4862166047,
0.5348843932,
-0.3790357411,
-0.9366922379,
-0.3435302675,
-0.3849892616,
-0.4208675623,
0.1308713257,
0.2968140244,
0.240163058,
0.2124916464,
-0.5485233665,
0.7531122565,
-0.0848344788,
0.4035713971,
0.3810670376,
-0.153204307,
0.0909091756,
0.6719181538,
0.0121067194,
0.1323508918,
0.3155657351,
-0.0954227224,
-0.2128746361,
-0.8852357864,
-0.3912929893,
0.0224298202,
-0.7690526843,
-0.1033726856,
-0.52801615,
-0.0267987344,
-0.3399088681,
-0.3655835986,
0.1651161015,
-0.0589954592,
-0.2521782815,
0.0503725149,
0.4706749022,
0.9890235066,
0.3738313913,
-0.0113612693,
-1.0951738358,
0.1174499318,
0.2858384848,
-0.0425182804,
0.0452258661,
-0.3592133522,
0.1327501833,
-0.2192047983,
-0.3642635047,
-0.9935200214,
0.0965416506,
-0.4089032114,
0.8467534184,
0.089552179,
0.2835745513,
0.3101302981,
-0.2829363942,
1.2994688749,
0.0531040058,
-1.0692303181,
0.7751422524,
-0.471496582,
0.2517060935,
0.3948966861,
0.7914081812,
-0.774492979,
-0.4886524975,
-0.2234588116,
-0.94466573,
0.4009592831,
-0.1803556681,
0.1789902151,
-0.0322328173,
0.5117745399,
0.3266505301,
-0.0831467509,
-0.4404393137,
-0.3461455405,
0.3165158927,
-0.2064140737,
0.2948913574,
-0.3806156218,
-0.2641557455,
0.0831892416,
0.5660808086,
-0.3485095501,
0.3403716087,
0.251409471,
-0.0923023745,
0.2634557784,
0.5733898282,
0.606020689,
0.5020660162,
0.2701726258,
0.1796148866,
-0.0048295585,
-0.4418552816,
0.5543391705,
-0.1253293157,
-0.2770784795,
-0.1559504122,
0.3419040442,
0.3372643888,
0.0803543329,
-0.5614629984,
0.4531901479,
0.3152230084,
-0.3645642996,
-0.3340713382,
0.3590649068,
-0.0169723574,
0.419995755,
0.9225512147,
-0.0116634183,
0.4265339375,
-0.4533489943,
0.0836051255,
0.1543895304,
-0.4278800488,
-0.4059762061,
0.5479944944,
0.5152368546,
-0.4250785708,
0.6172971129,
-0.621781528,
-0.4976433814,
0.5976587534,
0.1765492558,
1.1888962984,
0.0081376219,
0.1534998119,
0.2634019256,
0.306099087,
-0.044603575,
0.6906865835,
-0.2980041802,
-0.4100592732,
-0.7958762646,
-0.2780635059,
-0.5586567521,
0.1026100665,
-0.3613471985,
0.459605962,
-0.3751000762,
-0.0926095992,
0.125677675,
-0.1547387689,
-0.2335286587,
-0.2155379355,
0.459027648,
1.2099115849,
-0.8707407713,
0.4221331477,
1.0744193792,
-0.1868074089,
-0.8711372614,
0.294816494,
0.5782007575,
-0.5901039243,
1.0972914696,
0.3086597919,
0.0533392131,
0.0383264124,
-0.6727383733,
-0.6669015884,
1.1653609276,
0.2682887316,
-0.319896996,
-0.2462132126,
-0.0718922615,
0.2017166466,
-0.1915869564,
0.0562288463,
0.273234129,
0.5413425565,
0.0327176265,
-0.7625428438,
0.5031743646,
-0.4939958155,
-0.0506513864,
0.3597241938,
-0.4063822925,
0.8510751128,
-0.2881577909,
-0.5025192499,
0.1846963316,
0.5900722146,
0.7145577669,
0.4526323378,
0.7606586218,
-0.0624189712,
0.8090651035,
-0.3680574,
1.0534331799,
-0.3766637743,
-0.0691358894,
0.9457512498,
-0.5399743319,
0.5073353052,
0.7047468424,
-0.5299399495,
0.6352873445,
1.1097285748,
-0.1528111547,
0.1330563575,
0.5052252412,
-0.4092850387,
-0.4618464708,
-0.0904306769,
-0.0577185117,
0.1300036162,
0.2063917518,
-0.1507731974,
-0.2861666977,
0.1257246882,
-0.1934903562,
-0.2675769925,
-0.4830439389,
0.4535810053,
0.0057568154,
-1.157194972,
0.2824272513,
-0.1741079539,
0.7547518611,
-0.4036191404,
0.0536472574,
-0.1351131797,
-0.1041832492,
-0.3392784894,
-1.0298446417,
0.4154809415,
-0.1771522164,
-0.2807742357,
-0.6748558283,
0.790968895,
0.1729640216,
0.0498836152,
0.0791550875,
0.513363421,
0.1338118613,
-0.3740738034,
-0.6745683551,
-0.0484892316,
0.0348644853,
-0.1410996467,
0.1033487096,
0.434019804,
-0.2060775459,
0.8890589476,
0.4405200481,
-0.1915124357,
0.2466520816,
-0.1369099617,
0.735529542,
-0.5976113677,
-0.5300892591,
-1.0744534731,
0.8603988886,
0.2296381891,
-0.5182504058,
0.9619336724,
0.3583628237,
0.5621147156,
-0.1500845104,
0.8261713386,
-0.1538701802,
0.3996389806,
-0.3419934809,
0.3517436981,
-0.3260914981,
0.2915768921,
-0.0476872213,
-0.5144193172,
-0.1249250919,
-0.2153170556,
-0.1841136217,
0.0575498827,
0.4912331104,
0.906819582,
0.2239921987,
0.2132478207,
-0.0372030772,
-0.0205390174,
0.1930806637,
0.5686963797,
1.2432062626,
-0.1679320931,
0.3316129446,
0.0839457437,
-0.338401556,
-0.2761948109,
-0.8862920403,
-0.6996213198,
-0.9350374937,
-0.7069792151,
-0.3784903884,
-0.2566551268,
0.8434951901,
0.5829191804,
-0.7568309307,
-0.0284450054,
-0.60101372,
0.3138971031,
-0.4706086814,
-0.2832897604,
-0.3144691586,
-0.6778677702,
-0.3771700859,
0.2383271009,
0.4280765057,
0.1373775005,
-0.7140020132,
-0.0635759383,
-0.0513727181,
-0.1325180978,
0.5746391416,
0.2745262086,
-0.8749466538,
-0.0708619878,
0.3875105083,
-0.3084895015,
-0.2909384966,
1.2379206419,
-0.6542301774,
-0.1709500551,
0.9184971452,
0.6896651983,
-0.0703771636,
-0.2506613135,
0.6426985264,
-0.8005996943,
-0.2870695293,
0.3549050093,
0.3015814722,
0.0152278533,
-0.7094564438,
0.6598886847,
0.2755737305,
-0.7367184758,
-1.0139496326,
0.440263778,
-0.978703022,
-0.1866757721,
1.3173731565,
-0.3642818332,
-0.2830429077,
-0.8317226171,
-0.2271143198,
-0.0634008572,
-0.1986542791,
0.6487169862,
1.0095444918,
-0.374812007,
-0.4171117246,
-0.4996028543,
0.4952548146,
0.3094517887,
-1.005487442,
0.2865706086,
0.4273142517,
0.4169640541,
0.3293920755,
0.7865495086,
-0.0196457319,
0.4780187309,
-0.1527875215,
-0.1259340793,
-0.0740927756,
-0.0822222829,
-0.331176281,
0.1962395608,
0.3855915666,
-0.0589278825
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09383v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09383v1
|
Low-Resource Named Entity Recognition with Cross-Lingual, Character-Level Neural Conditional Random Fields
| 2024-04-14T23:44:49 | 2024-04-14T23:44:49 |
Ryan Cotterell, Kevin Duh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Low-resource named entity recognition is still an open problem in NLP. Most
state-of-the-art systems require tens of thousands of annotated sentences in
order to obtain high performance. However, for most of the world's languages,
it is unfeasible to obtain such annotation. In this paper, we present a
transfer learning scheme, whereby we train character-level neural CRFs to
predict named entities for both high-resource languages and low resource
languages jointly. Learning character representations for multiple related
languages allows transfer among the languages, improving F1 by up to 9.8 points
over a loglinear CRF baseline.
|
[
-0.2255466878,
-0.2309967726,
0.3980448544,
0.2577017248,
-0.152491197,
0.1499293894,
-0.5329102874,
-1.0115169287,
0.2460801899,
0.5738392472,
-0.6496022344,
-0.3227780163,
-0.6731160283,
0.4501644075,
-0.109049283,
0.9424772859,
-0.1144941971,
0.014260741,
0.0714224428,
-0.3096784055,
-0.509260416,
-0.6590790749,
-1.2891247272,
-0.2732272446,
0.79601264,
0.3345714509,
0.3849133551,
0.2589671612,
0.6768302917,
0.3206370175,
0.1641981304,
0.1654858589,
-0.3928169012,
0.1946212202,
-0.5048139691,
-0.6288151741,
-0.1770822108,
-0.4534869194,
0.6945454478,
0.7694637775,
0.1875098795,
0.0217703767,
-0.1411071718,
0.3671383858,
-0.4921952188,
0.4662574828,
-0.7150653601,
0.64073807,
-0.1770822108,
-0.2796162665,
-0.6531900764,
0.0287490319,
0.4830930531,
-0.9511445761,
0.0996753499,
0.372628212,
0.9246848226,
-0.0775096714,
-0.2574280798,
-0.018664496,
-0.723741591,
0.9352878928,
-0.3109588623,
0.5166563988,
0.4002233148,
0.2495254129,
0.0621912144,
-0.6662190557,
-0.5441914201,
-0.1865562201,
-0.4270923734,
-0.1944940388,
0.0583475828,
0.0874756947,
0.3959695697,
0.115165025,
-0.3257686496,
0.358561337,
-0.3408150971,
-0.5296441317,
0.6981117129,
0.063935414,
0.4578493834,
-0.1597553343,
-0.7719318867,
-0.1665811688,
-0.6506985426,
0.177314803,
0.0149994614,
0.7024893165,
-0.2369284481,
0.3189280927,
-0.1465291679,
0.4727752209,
0.2242150903,
-0.2004282326,
0.1611938179,
-0.3130882978,
-0.2451107502,
0.27614972,
0.8824464679,
-0.0973784551,
0.4173449576,
-0.4355224371,
-0.3264264762,
-0.439143151,
-0.1567303836,
-0.7819018364,
-0.3263955414,
-0.2996469438,
-0.4287412465,
-0.1506246477,
-0.2945258617,
-0.8595653772,
-0.5858704448,
-0.0991534814,
0.1922138631,
-0.6257194281,
-0.121362783,
-0.1919286847,
0.0788714439,
0.0280094016,
0.4812424481,
-1.1132439375,
0.0920133889,
0.0195839331,
0.6038010716,
-0.3148003817,
-0.3917657435,
-0.7097330093,
0.2567839921,
-0.0782293379,
0.8323338032,
-0.6045229435,
-0.3924300671,
0.1269585937,
0.2883116305,
-0.2403153032,
-0.3125212491,
0.4277645051,
-0.6493602991,
0.1287805438,
-0.5961691141,
-0.1579963267,
-0.2903713286,
-0.002485866,
-0.878887713,
0.8337074518,
0.5264618397,
-0.6725016236,
0.5366627574,
-0.3496021032,
-0.8639578223,
0.3717881739,
-0.2332049608,
-0.0208732989,
-0.2403304726,
0.2489379644,
0.4257318377,
-0.2230621576,
-0.2089021504,
-0.2716843784,
-0.0801190436,
0.1924386322,
-0.3093111515,
0.6520670056,
0.2993726432,
-0.089385435,
-0.3176117837,
-0.9874343276,
0.1679663807,
0.0445788689,
-0.5211706161,
-0.5454553366,
-0.3787711263,
0.256634146,
0.2602589726,
0.1854964197,
-0.3614267111,
0.150429219,
-0.0938198119,
0.4119003415,
0.332829982,
0.1958381981,
1.0014505386,
-0.1311034709,
0.6820548773,
0.3123480082,
-0.3663467765,
0.0760635287,
-0.2521212101,
-0.8768125176,
-0.2955165803,
0.7939604521,
0.699175179,
-1.3293839693,
0.2690825164,
-0.13501212,
0.03267093,
-0.4949554801,
0.1833335012,
0.4516365826,
0.7175830603,
0.6817979217,
-0.209585309,
-0.7916823626,
-1.0223128796,
-0.1671010256,
-0.3320104182,
0.0946863219,
0.3056891859,
0.1873037815,
0.1016052961,
0.3673017919,
-0.0739269629,
-0.6481525302,
-0.6192907095,
0.2777400911,
-0.1537505239,
0.4400005937,
0.611794889,
-0.7663109303,
-0.67932868,
0.3851348758,
-0.5255236626,
0.1215351596,
-0.5996670127,
-0.2556061149,
0.3274391294,
0.4643517435,
-0.7808597684,
0.1050098538,
0.5114709139,
-0.2239723951,
-0.0196951814,
-0.110963732,
0.2819362581,
-0.9465897679,
0.0621694289,
0.1959910989,
-0.5137065053,
-0.3182860911,
-0.2637443244,
-0.0276624393,
-0.271715045,
-0.6277867556,
0.8709184527,
-0.797909677,
-0.1957436651,
0.0224017277,
0.2044636905,
-0.0088105528,
0.7824335098,
0.5798067451,
0.6487672329,
0.4967728257,
-0.4680508971,
0.1550583988,
0.2867250144,
-0.2436151206,
0.8300298452,
-0.1213510931,
-0.0799509436,
0.1282551885,
0.2845307291,
-0.2686270475,
-0.0007209785,
0.3780467212,
-0.2568515241,
0.6067354679,
-0.447188735,
-0.208093375,
-0.019434778,
0.4446513951,
0.5840820074,
0.4480336905,
-0.4667030275,
0.7117461562,
0.4394957721,
-0.1737956852,
-0.7747540474,
-1.068772316,
0.0126026319,
0.0749105588,
-0.5085414648,
0.7313509583,
0.4307411015,
0.1514077634,
0.3877139688,
0.002032975,
-0.4133440256,
-0.0583795048,
0.1252986193,
0.2937679291,
-0.4350023568,
0.1378473639,
-0.0878346786,
0.0915755779,
-0.2162445933,
-0.2436448634,
0.3326300681,
-0.0175539814,
0.0366484262,
-0.5109626055,
0.2994444966,
0.1344562918,
-0.4044799209,
0.6807549596,
0.6944556236,
-0.7372536063,
-0.7444249392,
0.0167922266,
-0.0047136201,
-0.4089767337,
0.5998457074,
-0.6102085114,
-0.850708425,
0.6398597956,
0.1049999148,
-0.1587633342,
0.8104371428,
0.252046138,
0.000772142,
0.6258974671,
0.9324472547,
-0.0648918748,
0.5595759153,
-0.1716509014,
0.4039692879,
-0.482034713,
-0.4052452147,
-0.4391511977,
-0.5457820296,
-0.6746971607,
-0.4492469728,
-0.3087042868,
0.3611934781,
0.0056140032,
0.8494083285,
-0.1679256409,
0.5551189184,
0.3427756727,
-0.065692082,
0.3423139751,
0.2702746987,
-0.260140568,
-0.0083086053,
-0.7260199785,
-0.1642306894,
0.5818077326,
0.3278522491,
0.6244883537,
-0.106283471,
0.9697189927,
0.4581323862,
0.2948174477,
-0.850923121,
0.7426221967,
-0.4255129695,
-0.4028636813,
-0.482886523,
-0.6221902966,
-0.5797990561,
0.0560443588,
-0.8064528108,
-0.7074924111,
0.73223418,
-0.0374131985,
-0.6581076384,
0.477871865,
-0.6127378345,
0.4867267609,
-0.2887054682,
-0.0705730617,
-0.1059490666,
-0.4311199188,
0.3793272674,
-0.0745155439,
-0.0979588106,
-0.1080927253,
0.0606517978,
0.7057435513,
0.0275888294,
0.6159600019,
-0.2070405781,
0.0880126581,
0.2997536659,
0.2090649754,
0.5764158964,
0.4115869999,
-0.0140547147,
0.3886697292,
0.0813709348,
-0.1344814897,
-0.4757515788,
0.9087975025,
-0.6725201607,
-0.0927828699,
-0.6396947503,
-0.5925800204,
-0.3634877801,
0.5327720642,
0.3544926047,
-0.0824244246,
-0.2052378953,
-0.0101642944,
0.7984501719,
-0.2528660595,
0.5846666098,
0.3418475986,
-0.0071964636,
-0.3898988962,
0.8875710368,
0.2135822326,
-0.0783450678,
0.7513977885,
-0.4547116756,
-0.1304212064,
-0.5005434155,
-0.7756651044,
0.1094924361,
-0.7641803026,
-0.4590578377,
-0.6521965265,
-0.5925437808,
-0.1656793654,
-0.0946929604,
-0.2846178412,
-0.6642847061,
-0.4837711751,
0.0264130458,
0.2482747138,
0.3810567558,
0.0922396034,
0.2326633185,
-0.9897522926,
0.3015919328,
0.0389380641,
0.3471179903,
-0.0625578687,
-0.4853412807,
-0.337673068,
0.0183802303,
0.0678629726,
-0.6908914447,
0.4677858055,
0.5421748757,
0.5915766954,
0.216056332,
0.2516103685,
0.6189424992,
-0.4999944568,
0.3820258081,
0.6268185973,
-0.7800889015,
-0.0051263534,
0.0958644897,
-0.2104858756,
0.7766843438,
0.5963271856,
-0.6891822219,
0.0657706931,
-0.455850333,
-0.4194398224,
0.9742341638,
0.0285699759,
-0.0467074774,
0.0637638867,
0.2814595401,
0.1232174635,
-0.2079573572,
-0.8916615248,
-0.0708922446,
0.1575208604,
-0.2432433218,
0.150821209,
0.0611859597,
-0.0725311562,
0.159069404,
0.5768760443,
-0.0862910673,
0.5028477907,
0.3251522183,
-0.466109544,
-0.4878694117,
0.1669115275,
0.4721843302,
0.1824502349,
-0.0622524731,
0.24491705,
0.4837135971,
-0.3299131095,
0.1608660966,
0.3645090461,
-0.1222891361,
0.057959836,
0.4709506035,
0.9326666594,
0.3841173053,
-0.335110873,
0.3749092817,
-0.1528154165,
-0.3040027022,
-0.2823317647,
-0.0014095072,
0.2205421031,
0.559687674,
0.186436832,
0.3412733674,
-0.0692403093,
-0.5506209731,
0.2711967826,
0.2861573994,
-0.4496017694,
-0.4800746739,
0.3600340784,
0.3734540045,
-0.4254869521,
0.7166180611,
-0.3711323142,
-0.5436378717,
0.6206842661,
0.5720224977,
0.8662993908,
0.0330885798,
0.3560784161,
0.492647022,
0.3046082556,
-0.2637354136,
0.281029582,
-0.0042715506,
-0.6132913232,
-0.4731019437,
-0.8610941768,
-0.2894982696,
0.2089583725,
-0.5037566423,
0.6992143989,
-0.6881821156,
-0.2368548959,
0.2221371979,
0.1432716697,
-1.22706604,
0.2726038098,
0.7554770112,
0.7852195501,
-0.677370429,
1.0287777185,
0.6400666237,
-0.8488712907,
-0.6587572694,
-0.1500179023,
-0.5686988831,
-0.9423686266,
1.2899862528,
-0.0577575713,
0.1016089618,
-0.0300177243,
-0.0324911363,
-1.3186546564,
1.0279517174,
0.4830496907,
-0.9463653564,
-0.5992248654,
0.1896100044,
0.5839582086,
-0.6193754673,
0.0500653647,
0.0655360594,
0.4456557333,
-0.1788193136,
-0.8433321118,
0.3070484698,
0.138358295,
0.0908337906,
0.1011191159,
-0.6523338556,
0.7275633812,
-0.5064524412,
-0.6589246392,
0.0424735732,
1.1188943386,
0.0339758806,
0.1477961987,
0.6751798987,
0.5191403031,
0.6967710853,
0.0600365773,
0.6609582901,
-0.4195430875,
0.2733196616,
1.0779016018,
-0.4996617138,
0.9419589639,
0.4360018373,
-0.1184323654,
0.6203362346,
0.6335359216,
-0.252776742,
0.7597080469,
0.2922518253,
-0.2562670112,
-0.4528419673,
-0.2292349637,
-0.1760257334,
0.3874291778,
0.2660042048,
-0.6378104687,
-0.2741665542,
0.1809259355,
-0.2617890537,
-0.247078687,
-0.3426761627,
0.4840530753,
0.4907958508,
-0.8001258373,
0.4956136942,
0.1607621908,
0.5646288395,
-0.5175303221,
-0.388569504,
-0.3308003545,
0.0397430062,
-0.3237913549,
-0.5733067989,
0.0469143167,
-0.1903463602,
-0.4224203229,
-0.3757068813,
0.9935225844,
-0.8548751473,
-0.483491987,
0.532425046,
0.3842592835,
-0.0843097121,
0.3956362009,
-0.7674832344,
-0.4920804799,
-0.0575310029,
-0.2075734288,
0.6675957441,
0.6956097484,
-0.3452535272,
0.4593405724,
0.4540397227,
0.4866671562,
0.2377047539,
0.0464876704,
0.4226735532,
-0.5984269977,
-0.4716062248,
-0.3138123155,
0.0513401218,
0.0123388739,
-0.4725927114,
0.257569313,
0.0286552329,
1.2215111256,
-0.0400438979,
0.9702616334,
-0.2920925021,
0.265327692,
-0.6952260137,
0.8458830118,
-0.4236940742,
0.1510571539,
0.1806241274,
-1.0157688856,
-0.2025278807,
0.4870484769,
-0.1327884793,
-0.028053131,
0.9197156429,
0.3239208162,
-0.1029670388,
-0.159951821,
0.5998550057,
-0.2539688647,
-0.0372501649,
0.9733585715,
0.665862143,
-0.3251170814,
0.7691863179,
-0.8179504871,
0.1204019189,
-0.2043708414,
-0.855910182,
-0.9782167077,
-0.5395503044,
-0.369410336,
-0.3517762125,
0.0693934709,
0.9658031464,
0.7386553884,
-1.017156601,
0.1870600879,
0.1140129492,
0.1053569764,
-0.2718285918,
-0.190273121,
0.4458996058,
-0.5653773546,
-0.7160390019,
0.4030934274,
0.0108852759,
0.0065108826,
-0.2481141686,
0.0121835014,
-0.1927316338,
-0.0996961668,
0.4825668931,
0.7448766232,
-0.5431539416,
-0.4420457184,
0.1050394848,
-0.5731491446,
-0.0483447537,
0.8984773755,
-0.7066562176,
-0.027475208,
0.7990913391,
1.0191409588,
0.2942844331,
-0.4333829284,
0.4588301778,
-0.7502485514,
0.1206715629,
0.4972188175,
0.7048596144,
0.3837323487,
-0.7531657219,
0.2547575533,
0.3989997506,
-0.3125108778,
-0.70492661,
0.1488033831,
-1.1850817204,
0.0488507263,
1.0647259951,
-0.4430686533,
-0.1404983103,
0.1593924314,
0.1334828287,
0.4187120497,
-0.4654953778,
0.4793596864,
0.6365858316,
-0.0769437551,
-0.3910399675,
-0.4202642441,
0.8442620039,
0.3737519085,
-0.7140251994,
-0.065173097,
0.1930755973,
0.3349714577,
0.2957693636,
0.6278536916,
-0.0845067427,
0.1199869737,
0.0118581513,
0.4355944395,
0.0410025865,
-0.5527498126,
-0.160446167,
0.040880993,
0.0641681328,
0.0272340532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09375v1
|
Deceptive Patterns of Intelligent and Interactive Writing Assistants
| 2024-04-14T23:05:10 | 2024-04-14T23:05:10 |
Karim Benharrak, Tim Zindulka, Daniel Buschek
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models have become an integral part of new intelligent and
interactive writing assistants. Many are offered commercially with a
chatbot-like UI, such as ChatGPT, and provide little information about their
inner workings. This makes this new type of widespread system a potential
target for deceptive design patterns. For example, such assistants might
exploit hidden costs by providing guidance up until a certain point before
asking for a fee to see the rest. As another example, they might sneak unwanted
content/edits into longer generated or revised text pieces (e.g. to influence
the expressed opinion). With these and other examples, we conceptually transfer
several deceptive patterns from the literature to the new context of AI writing
assistants. Our goal is to raise awareness and encourage future research into
how the UI and interaction design of such systems can impact people and their
writing.
|
[
0.0100113256,
-0.9807082415,
0.8613391519,
0.2532374561,
-0.0502569377,
0.0755099878,
0.1903423518,
-0.8520294428,
0.2458252162,
1.0379523039,
-0.5776991248,
-0.2966186702,
-0.4506834149,
0.0433509834,
-0.5269218683,
0.7460902333,
-0.0261474848,
-0.12416289,
-0.2380452454,
0.2378797829,
-0.6882935166,
-0.6566813588,
-0.9040403962,
-0.0982475728,
0.4399477541,
0.2896849811,
0.6771991253,
0.474733144,
0.5367104411,
0.3512108028,
0.2460946292,
0.2644492388,
-0.3175991178,
0.2709556222,
0.1785134971,
-0.7195476294,
-0.3363340497,
0.3278364241,
0.302198261,
0.5135775805,
0.0492959768,
-0.0927173197,
0.259583801,
0.5543373227,
-0.5597047806,
0.5496399999,
-0.3454553485,
0.1334898323,
-0.2594496906,
-0.1853407621,
-0.9565084577,
-0.556931138,
0.0289601423,
-0.8732987642,
-0.0320918709,
0.230883047,
0.6085355282,
0.2132955641,
-0.0964453965,
-0.8547990322,
-0.8343203068,
0.5152503848,
-0.5884289145,
-0.014100546,
0.5660318136,
0.2449529022,
-0.313205421,
-0.7154260874,
-0.7779967785,
-0.5830210447,
-0.4025024176,
0.1655852795,
-0.4000132382,
0.2344524562,
0.4415878654,
0.1972915381,
-0.4815936387,
0.1576132476,
-0.1852805614,
-0.0772436336,
0.7148374319,
0.1731308699,
0.6853347421,
0.2469813079,
-0.149566099,
-0.0102525242,
-0.5811249614,
-0.0464775935,
0.6769447923,
-0.0597193614,
-0.3435321748,
0.5768891573,
-0.0852026939,
0.870316565,
0.0178485643,
-0.0812764317,
0.1154225245,
-0.0568614379,
-0.1185586676,
0.1921096295,
0.6243312359,
0.4608814716,
0.654294312,
-0.076899156,
-0.3063929677,
0.18695122,
0.1937543154,
-0.5091709495,
-0.4161262214,
-0.1259885281,
-0.6861562133,
-0.7428958416,
0.0100707263,
-0.6989716291,
-0.8975445032,
-0.3794502318,
0.3406539261,
-0.4256080687,
-0.1791869849,
-0.0185725074,
-0.4493840933,
0.3340246379,
0.6017746925,
-0.8242233992,
0.3427426815,
0.6327791214,
0.7216114998,
-0.0912026912,
-0.3343220651,
-0.3148827553,
0.1864734739,
-0.3450860679,
0.883713603,
-0.9516666532,
-0.5273882151,
0.1129538342,
-0.1363410354,
-0.1404249519,
-0.2578293085,
0.3813697398,
-0.5452816486,
0.5747842193,
-0.0547463037,
-0.3787072301,
-0.1812248379,
0.1622238606,
-0.8576258421,
0.4880105555,
0.1247774586,
-0.5107697248,
0.2869262993,
-1.0168497562,
-0.4384229481,
0.250185132,
-0.2811781764,
-0.1796263009,
0.0456487611,
-0.0717550814,
0.3513923287,
-0.1001723334,
-0.2325847447,
-0.0331057049,
-0.4509223998,
0.7435182929,
-0.9143365026,
0.9157620072,
0.3093598187,
-0.3075605929,
-0.0642800853,
-0.7811342478,
-0.3288538754,
0.128108263,
-0.3885453045,
-0.6830611229,
-0.1622123569,
0.0310662091,
-0.0848877132,
0.3082491457,
-0.5033365488,
0.4589330852,
-0.1928003877,
0.2851471007,
0.8055530787,
0.1338495314,
0.3496142328,
-0.7542135715,
0.8133659959,
-0.2293962091,
0.3483338952,
-0.3457544446,
-0.7167807221,
-0.5373851061,
-0.2372381091,
0.1347866952,
0.5639872551,
-0.7840687037,
0.1966245025,
0.0219082516,
-0.3566512764,
-0.5406855941,
0.0266953819,
0.5832646489,
0.3489237428,
0.0071786968,
-0.0711442083,
-0.130215928,
-0.8452892303,
-0.3783672452,
-0.0602383949,
-0.1064386442,
0.0719051361,
0.1837756038,
0.0088854963,
0.7841190696,
-0.5250819325,
-0.4096156955,
-0.335855335,
0.2927267551,
0.0417553745,
0.5144998431,
0.8400910497,
-0.9794821739,
-0.8559356928,
-0.0915553644,
-0.4763762355,
-0.2617794871,
-0.6309221387,
-0.0166190863,
0.4154950678,
0.7703874707,
-0.6866170168,
0.5823213458,
0.6746336818,
-0.612082243,
0.6328203082,
-0.1233756468,
0.136360094,
-1.0181951523,
0.0053859851,
-0.1200216115,
0.1148510426,
-0.6782903671,
-0.0383733101,
-0.1963926256,
-0.0673609152,
-0.1594944894,
0.4880180955,
-0.7700287104,
0.3935142756,
-0.3736186326,
0.0758793801,
0.1505551934,
0.6197191477,
-0.105240576,
0.839979589,
0.2379630059,
-0.3389426768,
0.2042094171,
0.1303433031,
-0.4603543282,
0.4961714745,
-0.686122179,
0.1608657688,
-0.3515756428,
0.3089540005,
-0.9271757007,
-0.2732053697,
0.5034764409,
-0.4691413641,
0.2447959632,
-0.0640549958,
-0.5946125388,
-0.0846615583,
-0.2041610479,
0.2887768447,
0.7264109254,
-0.2415271401,
0.6100611091,
0.251500994,
-0.2380207628,
-0.3882316947,
-0.9130973816,
0.1257357299,
-0.1267158687,
-0.3082621098,
0.1425353885,
-0.1535311639,
-0.5107606053,
-0.0341168493,
0.4791039526,
0.0060229902,
0.1953621805,
0.4664230347,
0.2534870505,
-0.2272907346,
-0.0962641537,
-0.0759401098,
-0.0275734607,
0.2148550004,
-0.0304124914,
0.7451027036,
0.3004896343,
-0.610034883,
-0.8647778034,
0.5509952307,
1.0435961485,
-0.1661632061,
0.6431334615,
0.2740902603,
-0.208075434,
-0.1548614055,
-0.6577171683,
0.0719439685,
-0.5417844653,
0.0814835057,
-0.4541583955,
-0.5253797174,
0.608366847,
0.209376201,
0.1293300092,
0.236803934,
0.2636152804,
0.0591410138,
1.0692394972,
0.8106122613,
0.0350796729,
0.8602918386,
0.0647756159,
0.1874744296,
-0.5102755427,
-0.3843495846,
-0.5772452354,
-0.1974971741,
-0.7221104503,
-0.1751651615,
0.1001788601,
-0.1398055851,
0.0185187049,
0.1944776475,
-0.7744227052,
0.7003545165,
1.0870690346,
-0.0330394544,
0.4459249079,
-0.0680853352,
0.1102739275,
0.2226793915,
-0.4516800046,
-0.6113886833,
0.8692520261,
0.208320573,
0.8583775759,
0.1393024474,
0.2874019742,
0.7447254062,
0.3516836166,
-0.6951028705,
0.4680581093,
-0.0818863884,
-0.2871557772,
-0.4814553559,
-0.039337825,
-1.0858778954,
-0.0714107454,
-0.0733930096,
-0.8046694994,
0.3971121609,
0.2246301025,
-0.2668419182,
0.2043964863,
-1.0956370831,
0.5843804479,
-0.1246227324,
-0.1691905856,
-0.1597912461,
-0.481252104,
0.3085049689,
-0.0442979522,
-0.0156751797,
-0.1199378744,
0.1510362774,
0.5184021592,
-0.2912140787,
1.3302598,
-0.0890198797,
-0.2437140048,
0.3077505529,
0.3881312311,
0.7363452315,
-0.2990914881,
-0.2519545555,
-0.01142071,
-0.0997044891,
-0.3311752677,
-0.5967873335,
0.485724479,
-0.6549701095,
-0.600769937,
-0.467829138,
-0.5500756502,
-0.0281576142,
0.3749142885,
0.2482063025,
0.5016292334,
-0.3025999665,
0.0006241504,
0.5916902423,
-0.2669547796,
0.4770123363,
0.5042006969,
0.0661088675,
0.0609046966,
0.8577795029,
-0.0937420502,
0.4137208164,
0.6014872193,
0.0465860926,
-0.0405358486,
-0.6614341736,
-0.4680152535,
0.1420432627,
-0.5120126605,
0.055057589,
-0.593244493,
-0.2917709351,
-0.7083880305,
-0.4754861295,
0.1676310301,
-0.4986806512,
-0.4223372638,
0.1974223405,
0.4838884771,
1.1042455435,
0.1725818515,
0.5943875313,
-0.7416513562,
0.172372371,
0.2489261329,
0.3272049427,
0.0609653555,
-0.1363760084,
-0.0317738838,
0.15986377,
-0.2275691181,
-0.8133297563,
0.3197520375,
-0.2161757201,
0.7366058826,
0.6062229276,
0.1032723114,
0.2143120319,
-0.4921562374,
0.9099162817,
0.2394478023,
-0.6640893817,
0.4423425496,
-0.3933160603,
0.3203181624,
0.4520060122,
0.2320929319,
-0.8348614573,
-0.5811482668,
-0.481488198,
-0.3358697593,
0.7396520972,
0.1763826162,
0.3455252945,
0.1870189458,
0.2622124851,
0.3767460883,
0.263035804,
-0.8678613901,
-0.1289429367,
-0.1554764956,
-0.3524310887,
0.3320626318,
-0.4845435023,
-0.0970561132,
0.2858283818,
0.425734967,
-0.0671171844,
0.4243604243,
-0.0066141742,
0.0560657196,
0.1211036295,
0.0747617483,
0.9311916232,
0.4927283227,
0.2242096812,
0.0020806815,
-0.2510467768,
-0.7975754142,
-0.1940996796,
0.1103113741,
-0.4267328084,
0.0683437064,
0.4906152487,
0.735227406,
-0.1652130336,
-0.6077272892,
0.5503393412,
-0.0857502446,
-0.3301964402,
-0.7477170229,
0.4355578125,
-0.3096323609,
0.1613105386,
0.1999692172,
0.0767845288,
0.3090360165,
-0.7829529047,
-0.3045189679,
0.5683319569,
-0.4156775475,
-0.2237666845,
0.5266778469,
0.4324171245,
-0.7368737459,
0.745307982,
-0.1385627985,
-0.2943980396,
0.5431212783,
0.529363811,
0.9653143287,
-0.1647678018,
0.3600851595,
-0.2493633032,
0.4203071892,
0.0519843586,
0.1326335669,
-0.27222085,
-0.5777356625,
-0.2557734847,
-0.3885625303,
-0.5353249907,
0.2258944064,
-0.2988082469,
0.4181402624,
-0.4102575481,
0.3546034992,
0.074455522,
-0.322003603,
-0.4388129115,
-0.1249219328,
0.0508195423,
0.759234488,
-0.517565608,
0.6970195174,
0.5570766926,
-0.6877983212,
-0.4991423488,
0.2298204154,
-0.1082784608,
-1.0151782036,
0.3181036115,
0.0559881516,
-0.3666069508,
-0.1401990503,
-0.7366951704,
-0.8152709007,
0.827306509,
0.1094653979,
-0.4128363729,
-0.6237650514,
0.4453854859,
0.5200275183,
-0.3085757494,
0.2637407184,
0.3718679845,
0.6104300618,
-0.0808151364,
-0.8416675329,
0.2807815671,
-0.4206963181,
-0.1525312364,
0.1144234836,
-0.852160871,
0.7698354125,
0.0754916444,
-0.2527137995,
0.3392655253,
0.1151006073,
-0.0218877941,
0.4267854989,
0.3901303709,
0.0254805777,
0.6806406379,
0.1036797389,
1.0056080818,
-0.3195648491,
-0.3732895851,
0.95747751,
-0.1777440906,
0.3438695669,
0.3638156354,
0.2342918664,
0.9075659513,
0.2225594819,
-0.2834067047,
0.402616024,
0.2214875519,
-0.2686894238,
0.0701850727,
-0.2319732457,
-0.3678813577,
0.5235853195,
0.6592169404,
-0.65109694,
0.0842844024,
0.1506151408,
0.1116201505,
0.2137303352,
-0.0191897675,
1.0458118916,
0.0036884833,
-0.7294593453,
0.0884868652,
-0.0863235816,
0.6140930653,
-0.5982661843,
-0.5378376245,
-0.1437097192,
-0.0017062757,
-0.048836343,
-0.7957170606,
-0.0021789412,
-0.1777422726,
-0.1217029318,
-0.6117920876,
0.8524027467,
-0.1420191675,
-0.4085980058,
-0.2398765832,
0.3813332617,
0.1726890802,
-0.1094823405,
-0.5785871148,
-0.0338795222,
0.0575440191,
-0.2939554751,
0.1117096767,
0.7235391736,
-0.2122802734,
0.6040214896,
0.7313930988,
0.0179887917,
-0.1266615242,
0.0890460908,
0.6343526244,
-0.5915155411,
-0.8441542387,
-0.7808354497,
0.3220086098,
-0.4579914808,
-0.4149715304,
0.9070224166,
0.4318493605,
0.6203699112,
-0.1421420574,
1.1073417664,
0.0991258547,
0.4527430832,
-0.717663765,
1.104714036,
-0.3494541049,
0.3168529272,
-0.445499599,
-0.7107359767,
-0.2663158178,
0.3035970032,
-0.2694672048,
0.0911677182,
0.6587170959,
0.6937222481,
0.0193227399,
0.3486474156,
0.4890772104,
0.2277943492,
0.3820646405,
0.3231748939,
1.121584177,
0.0453602225,
0.6830049753,
-0.1943884492,
-0.3311296999,
-0.4634616971,
-0.5198939443,
-0.9434716702,
-0.6080738902,
-0.2990075648,
-0.380387187,
0.1641882658,
0.5873672962,
0.4018887281,
-0.5152605176,
-0.0027314399,
-0.3905584514,
0.1739125103,
-0.1747443974,
-0.30536744,
0.248428449,
-0.0417030677,
-0.9945108294,
0.1423065066,
0.1975481808,
0.6303566694,
-0.4361315966,
0.4382120073,
0.2072476298,
0.355473578,
0.6659464836,
0.3484546244,
-0.5682180524,
-0.2085307986,
0.0331733674,
-0.2586539388,
-0.1241872907,
1.0963083506,
-0.7414360642,
0.1788771152,
0.4795861542,
0.4099562168,
0.123424761,
-0.0288087893,
0.8022661805,
-0.4414480329,
0.2123161107,
0.3425182402,
0.0198022295,
0.1276036203,
-0.8642984033,
0.280703932,
0.157185629,
-0.4754808843,
-0.7104005814,
0.312764734,
-0.8451132774,
-0.5913890004,
1.2070060968,
0.09499944,
-0.0979727209,
-0.447758019,
-0.6699984074,
-0.0733501166,
-0.5203261971,
1.0322003365,
0.7559164166,
-0.5550082922,
-0.0975497961,
-0.5507099032,
0.7769720554,
0.1684390455,
-0.8879498839,
0.1828447282,
0.8168006539,
-0.0441155545,
0.342948705,
0.7765721679,
-0.1040278375,
0.3493507206,
0.434278965,
-0.031469442,
-0.1191040128,
-0.2130194902,
-0.0537714101,
0.2361833304,
0.2410031855,
-0.3669025302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09371v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09371v1
|
The Effect of Data Partitioning Strategy on Model Generalizability: A Case Study of Morphological Segmentation
| 2024-04-14T22:22:58 | 2024-04-14T22:22:58 |
Zoey Liu, Bonnie J. Dorr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Recent work to enhance data partitioning strategies for more realistic model
evaluation face challenges in providing a clear optimal choice. This study
addresses these challenges, focusing on morphological segmentation and
synthesizing limitations related to language diversity, adoption of multiple
datasets and splits, and detailed model comparisons. Our study leverages data
from 19 languages, including ten indigenous or endangered languages across 10
language families with diverse morphological systems (polysynthetic, fusional,
and agglutinative) and different degrees of data availability. We conduct
large-scale experimentation with varying sized combinations of training and
evaluation sets as well as new test data. Our results show that, when faced
with new test data: (1) models trained from random splits are able to achieve
higher numerical scores; (2) model rankings derived from random splits tend to
generalize more consistently.
|
[
-0.4843698442,
-0.6758888364,
0.4427073002,
0.5564795136,
-0.5599599481,
0.1055720672,
-0.2114175111,
-0.4371538162,
0.0437177829,
0.0285596643,
-0.4771224558,
-0.4407993853,
-0.5627408028,
0.251884073,
-0.399348706,
0.543230176,
0.1833444685,
0.3679302633,
-0.2110630274,
-0.4882079065,
-0.4444074631,
-0.7749482989,
-0.3332929313,
-0.0151577294,
0.3381203711,
0.0914809927,
0.8732455373,
1.4247890711,
0.5794993043,
0.3315250576,
-0.4492945969,
-0.0636658445,
-0.2241703421,
0.35259673,
-0.2581854165,
-0.7679252625,
0.0839409456,
-0.225791052,
0.9418304563,
1.0812950134,
-0.3036729693,
-0.1635449231,
-0.2747733295,
0.4227561057,
-0.663444519,
-0.0662436858,
-0.671546936,
0.1183623299,
-0.3493917882,
0.3348556459,
-0.3137921095,
-0.4249987304,
0.4104104936,
-0.4410969019,
0.3390430212,
-0.2601038516,
0.7207787633,
0.1554536372,
-0.3244082928,
-0.2631218433,
-0.7786042094,
0.7951292992,
-0.5532024503,
0.5684788823,
0.1654632688,
0.3008691072,
0.1201196089,
-0.422001332,
-0.0921367109,
0.0729682371,
0.2541947365,
-0.3205008507,
-0.2407739162,
-0.0363533348,
0.2597984374,
0.5281600952,
-0.5601025224,
0.5437633395,
-0.4364599288,
-0.3609012067,
0.6940665245,
0.4399391115,
0.768292129,
-0.1088302955,
0.0087978644,
-0.4114346504,
-0.5255432129,
-0.0692161247,
0.7429068685,
0.582831502,
-0.050303597,
0.5965650082,
-0.2289499491,
0.9073812366,
-0.2011776567,
0.0056579472,
0.4927012622,
-0.6258160472,
-0.1516025215,
-0.4393360615,
0.6421890259,
0.1595379561,
0.0569522083,
-0.1992679387,
-0.1721793413,
0.0318209641,
0.1830793172,
-0.6132819057,
-0.0832510069,
0.1456853002,
-0.4505833387,
-0.2094161659,
-0.1140205786,
-0.9264540672,
-0.2689520419,
-0.3150101602,
0.1412342936,
-0.6555960178,
-0.2936925888,
0.2233737707,
-0.3623479307,
0.2470828891,
0.3076331317,
-1.2443617582,
0.4029138982,
0.7879132628,
0.9904673696,
-0.5571064949,
-0.2872644663,
0.0073575801,
-0.2566326261,
-0.5171124935,
0.6959693432,
-1.1114341021,
-0.5905459523,
-0.2582804859,
-0.1340025663,
-0.6741096377,
-1.1000858545,
0.3490558565,
-0.1856768131,
0.1523556262,
0.0288322512,
-0.4461913109,
-0.2030599564,
-0.0051722806,
-0.8595220447,
0.3953010142,
0.0354034305,
-0.6208636165,
0.7490978837,
-0.4054412842,
-0.4275837839,
-0.0207180511,
-0.2076776028,
-0.4427103996,
0.4771625102,
0.1368883252,
0.2017184496,
0.0029261771,
0.1903114766,
-0.5423395634,
0.1108399704,
-0.0029218134,
-0.3944952488,
0.6114850044,
0.363350898,
-0.0510213263,
0.1839316636,
-0.9287988544,
0.1941146404,
0.2238825709,
-0.3045420945,
-0.7264171243,
0.1994792968,
-0.1440611929,
-0.1713964194,
-0.1737490147,
-0.4572565556,
0.3969180882,
-0.4349603653,
0.3598099649,
0.4992639124,
0.0793241039,
0.6971564889,
-0.1337070018,
0.586179018,
0.1759713292,
0.3456707895,
-0.1361278147,
-0.5683256984,
-0.7352280021,
-0.4002094567,
0.7621658444,
0.2278207988,
-0.3952917159,
0.1831588596,
-0.1047746018,
-0.505969584,
-0.5228908658,
-0.3424761295,
0.2025997043,
-0.068004705,
0.0486278534,
-0.5948207974,
-0.552923739,
-1.3558706045,
0.0668097958,
-0.0285868924,
-0.0490090959,
0.216856733,
0.4787459373,
-0.3893733919,
0.8795918822,
-0.5140593648,
0.3593907356,
-0.2773966193,
0.0628770217,
0.0971529856,
0.6605163217,
0.5106720924,
-0.9454882741,
-0.1982355714,
0.0335903652,
-0.4554753006,
0.3268316686,
0.2188146114,
0.0166829806,
-0.0468155481,
-0.0908290148,
-0.3830562532,
0.4004213512,
0.4199904501,
0.1582413316,
0.5235138535,
-0.2793977261,
-0.0747647807,
-0.8441253304,
-0.0943011269,
0.1093075275,
0.1490992904,
-1.0187237263,
0.2739063501,
-0.0171775818,
-0.0662082955,
-0.3722146451,
0.3557209074,
-0.33959198,
-0.1580707282,
-0.0061051734,
-0.6653080583,
-0.5581983924,
0.1933808178,
0.2333555222,
0.4722833633,
0.7326042652,
-0.6357295513,
-0.1484888941,
0.1875659823,
-0.4840963185,
0.1305578649,
-0.5729362369,
0.1848622411,
-0.1296795756,
-0.0387404189,
-0.8824022412,
-0.5700317621,
0.1190378666,
-0.014599097,
0.2568770349,
-0.3615582883,
-0.3366577923,
-0.1545417309,
-0.1543198228,
0.8689684868,
0.3386248052,
-0.432284981,
0.4181551933,
0.6910068393,
-0.3457507193,
-0.1760895699,
-0.3371561766,
-0.2356392741,
-0.6066331863,
-0.9350784421,
0.043648649,
-0.2216219753,
-0.4525117874,
-0.2602018118,
-0.1326822191,
-0.6571990848,
0.3179124594,
0.0803648904,
0.1387828737,
0.0113883391,
-0.0303365532,
0.2274720669,
0.1637499034,
-0.154219076,
-0.1416666806,
0.9701793194,
0.1667536497,
-0.4020113647,
0.0205140114,
0.154026255,
0.4678856432,
-0.3573505878,
0.5676908493,
0.0080641964,
-0.3652377129,
-0.4150657654,
-0.3924643099,
0.158932671,
-0.404601723,
0.434748739,
-0.47368595,
-0.8547208905,
0.7282198071,
0.1242802963,
0.1426592916,
0.4491609633,
0.6030409336,
0.4333517551,
1.3677273989,
0.5451216102,
-0.1004145145,
0.320823431,
-0.1959407926,
-0.0952054337,
-0.5928564072,
-0.3406288922,
-0.6489374638,
-0.2294882685,
-0.8024536967,
-0.5787055492,
0.1630505621,
-0.290189445,
0.3374333084,
-0.0576515608,
-0.6288915277,
0.6485099196,
0.3236564994,
-0.0013184423,
0.2102472931,
0.3398294747,
-0.3880456388,
-0.0312317163,
-0.6759604812,
-0.2232580632,
1.183965683,
0.4724002779,
0.699516952,
-0.1192748919,
0.8028175235,
0.0216740798,
-0.1168891564,
-0.754948616,
0.3803366721,
-0.340903163,
-0.7828531265,
-0.6169373393,
-0.5510668159,
-1.1871757507,
0.8801559806,
0.2316263765,
-0.7870628238,
0.6660403609,
-0.2945952117,
-0.3070547581,
0.1805357784,
-0.8041808009,
0.4763357639,
-0.1512874812,
0.02831099,
-0.1831370145,
-0.6021196842,
0.4681610763,
-0.3342686594,
0.4114366472,
-0.131930396,
-0.0282715056,
1.033392787,
-0.4644116461,
0.5988919139,
-0.0728700683,
0.1004440188,
0.0676583573,
-0.0065919277,
-0.1359056234,
-0.2626360357,
-0.0749055818,
0.083830297,
0.0132901184,
-0.3984827995,
-0.550820291,
0.3759142458,
-0.7809214592,
-0.6899463534,
-0.3307487667,
-0.7973602414,
-0.4439774454,
0.1686354131,
0.3618987799,
0.4238839149,
-0.4084082544,
0.2421199083,
0.6136317253,
-0.1600365192,
0.3845422268,
0.3855785429,
-0.2946961224,
-0.5813162327,
1.1204009056,
0.4709298611,
0.3493209779,
-0.0221076757,
0.2281649113,
-0.2244928628,
-1.1387666464,
-0.4282370508,
0.2653577626,
-0.3424759209,
0.3636903763,
-0.4595460892,
-0.3221759498,
-0.1442833543,
0.1980071813,
-0.3355603516,
-0.6980924606,
-0.0432101376,
-0.2493035942,
-0.345602721,
0.9630084038,
-0.2131252736,
0.1707648784,
-0.466539979,
-0.0133017348,
0.15930067,
0.3196001947,
0.1317281574,
-0.2371329516,
-0.0415817983,
0.0410886183,
-0.0244484525,
-0.6885874867,
0.2754695117,
-0.0479996912,
0.8494849801,
0.3148040771,
-0.4633369446,
0.5245125294,
-0.5607030392,
0.5034664273,
0.1570686847,
-0.6420130134,
0.3814462721,
-0.5364348888,
0.2879885137,
0.6817883849,
0.5534513593,
-0.4357229173,
-0.3722418249,
-0.6419332623,
-0.9220047593,
0.7261452675,
0.2576696575,
0.1178559065,
0.070252344,
0.0887150541,
0.5757063031,
0.0849717557,
-0.3308840692,
-0.1441688985,
0.1779112369,
0.0284202565,
0.0471919961,
-0.2821697295,
-0.037120413,
-0.3498519361,
0.2378294021,
0.1433818191,
-0.1423402131,
-0.1794632524,
-0.2203641981,
0.2005355358,
0.3031661212,
0.7125794291,
0.8353223801,
-0.0614321344,
-0.1068813801,
-0.034318693,
-0.5924383998,
0.4945153296,
0.0280827731,
-0.4857062101,
0.1656531245,
0.3345532119,
0.9989982247,
0.0052189343,
-0.3217401803,
-0.0053612869,
-0.1985489279,
-0.3966917992,
0.3915002346,
0.2686626017,
0.0035359159,
0.0518052578,
0.3344909251,
0.0316515453,
0.1585077792,
-0.5017228127,
0.2493236065,
0.4048126638,
0.0730623826,
-0.478505373,
0.3404797018,
0.0985829905,
-0.1898013353,
0.7634943128,
-0.0777064785,
-0.5146308541,
0.8699235916,
0.3700827062,
0.7268955112,
-0.6382331252,
0.5094127655,
0.2623585165,
0.1794638634,
-0.2285996079,
0.050117638,
0.1604445577,
-0.6716184616,
-0.2290338725,
-0.6887614131,
-0.5841982961,
0.0558350645,
-0.729428947,
0.0163198765,
-0.5479735732,
-0.3054700792,
0.1620099694,
-0.3467677534,
-0.47036466,
0.4281037748,
0.2756367922,
0.808868885,
-0.9955393672,
0.4148093164,
0.6946139336,
-0.2876011431,
-0.8621193767,
-0.1403378248,
0.0196764953,
-0.9040897489,
0.4718620777,
0.1150387451,
0.6050896645,
-0.2591694295,
-0.3332100511,
-1.1415725946,
0.666225493,
0.3599598408,
-0.3546408713,
-0.2920337915,
0.6146141887,
0.7567811012,
-0.4746279716,
0.3270259202,
0.8381870389,
0.4587754905,
0.3565048873,
-0.9203854203,
-0.2715416849,
-0.2262496203,
0.1521202624,
0.2843375206,
-0.7747104764,
0.9197465777,
0.0736634061,
-0.5016939044,
0.2079859972,
0.2663859129,
0.284689188,
0.1826118082,
0.7753502727,
0.7697439194,
0.9119749069,
-0.1947263479,
1.1516624689,
0.1458230168,
0.1365838945,
0.9509778619,
-0.2274750471,
0.5406377912,
0.2076278329,
-0.3071517944,
0.2641614974,
0.9686778188,
-0.4343465269,
0.5930659175,
0.4498761594,
-0.0665085092,
-0.1854492873,
-0.3964658678,
-0.3350043297,
0.5877334476,
0.1591168344,
-0.3690558374,
-0.4738171101,
-0.044452522,
-0.1519853622,
-0.3794554472,
-0.2327327728,
0.7658080459,
-0.2065960765,
-0.5356316566,
0.5369939208,
-0.0439394824,
0.3720629215,
-0.7479998469,
0.1497877091,
-0.4539934397,
-0.1049795374,
-0.3434179723,
-0.5996454954,
0.2708865106,
-0.0782305226,
-0.2809307277,
0.2452138215,
0.5814421773,
-0.3105321229,
-0.6146649122,
0.152520299,
0.6103803515,
0.1384048909,
0.1080131531,
-0.2469591498,
0.5118256807,
0.3507352769,
-0.0827889815,
0.7945432663,
0.1792334467,
-0.5041136146,
0.8510972857,
0.6366631389,
0.0948157907,
0.5471510291,
0.2561277449,
0.9513623118,
-0.3015385568,
-0.4814193249,
-1.0210402012,
0.5042979717,
-0.1162147895,
-0.1838745624,
0.7927641869,
1.029609561,
0.9188213348,
-0.0141978078,
0.8589904308,
0.0961062089,
0.312850982,
-0.2921391428,
0.4078830481,
-0.311080575,
0.0856835246,
-0.121575363,
-1.0724773407,
-0.4334416091,
0.1952321529,
-0.5831089616,
0.0041108797,
0.5154982209,
0.4794867337,
-0.1752994806,
0.0967029333,
0.3806827068,
-0.129460454,
0.2844047546,
0.2107067108,
0.9751415253,
0.1371773481,
0.1807956547,
-0.4768259525,
-0.1877621561,
0.1090244055,
-0.2141464502,
-0.6158310771,
-0.6718583107,
-0.165126428,
0.2444353104,
0.0828204229,
0.5429615378,
0.8615810871,
-0.8113301396,
-0.5528945923,
0.2170478702,
0.2582919896,
0.2919357121,
-0.186604023,
0.1686200351,
-0.4016025066,
-0.8657777905,
0.462002188,
0.3382308185,
0.2014222592,
-0.0665400326,
0.233047232,
-0.0123940511,
0.1008430794,
0.2736686766,
0.3093575835,
-0.388106972,
-0.0426345654,
-0.0923451409,
0.1669585854,
0.2518013716,
0.7883651853,
-0.2213628143,
0.620759666,
0.5208699107,
0.6757602692,
0.4546667337,
0.2994989157,
0.9557054639,
-0.2828536332,
0.136521399,
0.1606247276,
0.3549410403,
0.2930901945,
0.0272035543,
0.9061467052,
0.2311542183,
-0.2384974211,
-1.0362725258,
0.1616880149,
-0.5720595717,
-0.3139180243,
1.1252807379,
0.0653393716,
-0.3530691862,
0.0759356543,
0.0320218168,
-0.1338034421,
-0.2174452096,
0.5370177031,
0.987496376,
-0.1614067256,
0.1849738359,
-0.1034448072,
0.2768730223,
0.4554479122,
-0.7324339747,
0.0034116905,
0.5985233784,
0.5874436498,
0.2857421637,
0.1719605476,
-0.1257023215,
0.1328310668,
-0.003125133,
-0.2657985389,
0.1059525385,
-0.3435100019,
-0.8237201571,
0.4020110071,
0.0497174971,
-0.2019527555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13070v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13070v2
|
Evidence from counterfactual tasks supports emergent analogical reasoning in large language models
| 2024-04-14T21:51:02 | 2024-04-29T19:48:56 |
Taylor Webb, Keith J. Holyoak, Hongjing Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We recently reported evidence that large language models are capable of
solving a wide range of text-based analogy problems in a zero-shot manner,
indicating the presence of an emergent capacity for analogical reasoning. Two
recent commentaries have challenged these results, citing evidence from
so-called `counterfactual' tasks in which the standard sequence of the alphabet
is arbitrarily permuted so as to decrease similarity with materials that may
have been present in the language model's training data. Here, we reply to
these critiques, clarifying some misunderstandings about the test materials
used in our original work, and presenting evidence that language models are
also capable of generalizing to these new counterfactual task variants.
|
[
-0.1751973182,
-1.060109973,
0.9692825675,
-0.3872292042,
-0.1870436221,
-0.3018008769,
0.1586428732,
-0.480640471,
0.1794800907,
0.3833521903,
-0.6569008827,
0.110298112,
-0.4767464697,
0.1753858924,
-0.831151247,
0.8337138891,
-0.253520906,
0.082485199,
-0.3172050118,
-0.246774748,
-0.3145312071,
-0.6495550871,
-0.6757192612,
-0.6619612575,
0.5994559526,
0.2457772493,
0.8339141011,
0.5678536892,
0.2052845359,
0.360455215,
0.2548356056,
-0.3053317368,
-0.3023546338,
0.3162806928,
-0.3734013438,
-0.6772113442,
-0.2033143491,
0.2444543093,
0.4665544927,
0.8948840499,
-0.0326048285,
0.2154219002,
-0.128397271,
0.3044205606,
-0.4319821298,
-0.1904870719,
-0.7870201468,
-0.0098185409,
0.0924597457,
-0.1685309261,
-0.5900990963,
0.100702785,
0.1635188609,
-0.7244946957,
0.4275510907,
0.0544178933,
0.713226676,
-0.1204490215,
-0.3540017605,
-0.2882376611,
-1.0316822529,
0.8581147194,
-0.8206558824,
0.2627736926,
0.1553792059,
0.0631983057,
-0.030278692,
-0.7452006936,
-1.1631804705,
-0.3569717407,
-0.0851228684,
-0.0082776621,
-0.3119923472,
-0.0561226569,
0.7221124768,
0.2865675092,
-0.6582896113,
0.1089388877,
-0.0498333797,
0.0318889171,
0.1761271805,
0.1548973769,
0.5385285616,
0.2832151353,
-0.248167783,
-0.0026790835,
-1.0103411674,
-0.1815946698,
0.3705892265,
0.1017268077,
-0.085989587,
0.6959121227,
-0.1908532977,
0.4817862809,
0.0835714415,
0.3606304526,
0.2974239886,
-0.2517461181,
-0.28610906,
0.0898844674,
0.5998161435,
0.5064445138,
0.5067121983,
-0.2126320601,
-0.0802260488,
0.4460858405,
0.2803559601,
-0.7930611372,
-0.1879966259,
0.1433085352,
-0.3788697124,
-0.1047657803,
0.0082511464,
-0.4096814692,
-0.0734440312,
-0.1885461956,
0.6319583058,
-0.2195814252,
-0.2338675261,
0.0354381204,
-0.2891488373,
0.0016063972,
0.445066601,
-1.096118927,
0.4086873233,
0.572784543,
0.6406505704,
0.223005116,
-0.4940178096,
-0.4413556755,
-0.0829479098,
-0.7673475146,
1.1161221266,
-0.8277350068,
-0.3214922845,
-0.0304213241,
0.1993024945,
-0.2597565949,
-0.7678536773,
0.1149908826,
-0.2642707527,
0.3509226143,
-0.5808010101,
-0.4865038395,
-0.2283110619,
0.4600330591,
-0.4333241284,
0.8492752314,
0.1244515702,
-0.6446179748,
0.3422967196,
-0.4328082502,
-0.4206629097,
-0.1566535681,
-0.3721429408,
-0.2242305577,
0.2763080895,
-0.0210949443,
-0.0702220574,
-0.4117974341,
0.0731217265,
-0.7233133912,
-0.6071869135,
0.547757864,
-0.5452710986,
0.8075321913,
0.1348204911,
-0.7005320191,
-0.0837335885,
-0.4869424403,
-0.1666759849,
0.2869433761,
0.0881308317,
-0.648004353,
0.0662833676,
-0.1492453814,
0.3816615343,
0.0439199284,
-1.039891243,
0.2792844772,
-0.4279522598,
0.2728535831,
0.5915681124,
-0.0793154612,
0.3667703867,
-0.6858389974,
0.4304007888,
0.134626627,
-0.3082974851,
-0.5959886312,
-0.6009830236,
-0.6646422148,
0.0595623292,
0.1591129005,
0.4565175474,
-0.936673522,
-0.0741358101,
-0.1854881495,
-0.4164096713,
-0.2461739033,
-0.068689093,
0.5705077052,
0.6536716819,
0.3839511871,
-0.401335001,
-0.8147233725,
-0.9725969434,
-0.3337243199,
-0.4648983181,
-0.177405104,
0.1678149104,
0.7756878734,
0.0209034737,
0.829741776,
-0.3294999003,
0.2730435729,
0.0536656827,
0.7378795147,
0.2876497507,
0.5650606155,
0.7411230803,
-0.6850847006,
-0.3865353465,
-0.2073455602,
-0.9828648567,
-0.319879204,
-0.2981063426,
0.4545622468,
0.3704138994,
1.0523178577,
-0.9233936667,
0.3136847615,
0.4184348285,
-0.482531935,
0.7853324413,
-0.1234492585,
0.3720139563,
-0.7432721853,
0.2853581905,
-0.2694594264,
-0.1075617,
-0.9415737391,
0.2728412449,
-0.1655200571,
0.2030972093,
-0.5325205922,
0.7338419557,
-0.1977667809,
0.0662840083,
-0.4466203153,
-0.0712043494,
-0.2037522942,
0.2455355525,
0.4163654149,
0.7695963383,
0.345023334,
-0.3800738156,
0.2374359071,
0.0860655382,
-0.3132294714,
0.775026083,
-0.8198131323,
0.0594635941,
-0.205364719,
0.2960501611,
-1.2002091408,
0.2161255777,
0.36207214,
-0.3500656784,
-0.0821085498,
0.025948137,
-0.5825664401,
-0.4184230864,
-0.3487132192,
0.6071695685,
0.6942455173,
-0.3087812364,
0.2827599943,
-0.2251879126,
-0.2197850049,
-0.4500074983,
-0.8103420138,
0.1100750789,
-0.1437867135,
0.0096667036,
0.1268858761,
-0.3938762248,
-0.6705743074,
0.0915638432,
-0.3658764362,
0.0402314551,
0.127149716,
0.2177545279,
0.302597791,
-0.5486628413,
0.0156885386,
-0.1215876266,
0.0478486642,
0.3700255454,
-0.1791066825,
0.442094326,
0.3351891339,
-0.620896399,
0.0888698623,
0.3837786317,
0.6015405655,
0.2178597003,
0.7714226246,
0.0330504663,
-0.3099454045,
0.049460724,
-0.5254344344,
-0.2866855264,
-0.4163550138,
0.4105720222,
-0.4904803634,
-0.6775012016,
0.7004956007,
0.1879210621,
0.1157175601,
0.56355685,
0.5021721125,
-0.1895176321,
0.7728275061,
0.2403627336,
0.4646356404,
0.3487268984,
-0.0798198804,
0.2122126967,
-0.69131428,
0.0976266935,
-0.5347915292,
-0.0064425268,
-0.4478985071,
-0.140098244,
-0.1392791122,
-0.2950967848,
-0.5229316354,
0.3094108701,
-0.0016374711,
0.4247552454,
0.3889369071,
0.1830107272,
0.2633336782,
-0.1703009754,
-0.1995095164,
0.0622570403,
-0.7543051243,
-0.4914776385,
1.2854465246,
0.1659881473,
0.396800369,
-0.0016205347,
0.3266958594,
0.0710019544,
0.6054198146,
-0.4972040355,
0.6939041615,
-0.3305548429,
-1.0297942162,
-0.2952948511,
-0.1516483724,
-1.0901095867,
0.4215477109,
-0.5004627109,
-0.915848434,
0.2197137326,
0.277559042,
-0.1773228049,
0.5034080744,
-0.6745012403,
1.0301504135,
0.1955619156,
-0.212654829,
-0.2964398861,
-0.4259509444,
0.3465482891,
-0.2374576032,
0.2520703673,
0.2996905148,
0.1625810862,
0.8265749216,
-0.4922357798,
0.9630750418,
0.0301289912,
-0.3175625801,
0.4719815254,
0.3314222395,
0.3936481774,
-0.3285772502,
0.0032133369,
0.0477060862,
0.0443515368,
-0.5307607055,
-0.8282877803,
0.5673546195,
-0.4334094524,
-0.8121926188,
-0.6580021381,
-0.770021081,
-0.1176979393,
0.3533304036,
0.1979106069,
0.7185189128,
-0.5570183396,
0.3713245094,
0.7112947702,
0.0277763419,
0.6337949038,
0.7233753204,
-0.018196322,
0.2117739618,
0.6494274139,
0.3992930949,
0.6080688834,
0.6072804928,
-0.0659411773,
-0.1028275713,
-0.8174955249,
-0.4305152595,
-0.0271860175,
-0.5883937478,
0.2617943287,
-0.4797000289,
-0.0294161532,
-0.3679069877,
-0.1753413826,
-0.2716848552,
-0.431863308,
0.0044398545,
0.0222093258,
-0.1717758179,
0.7804451585,
0.0882608443,
0.2447504401,
-0.7329499722,
0.6079387665,
0.5840290189,
0.1528736651,
0.2979971766,
-0.7805527449,
-0.328407228,
0.2581751049,
-0.182299912,
-0.7446074486,
-0.0835191533,
-0.1229735762,
0.6716668606,
0.3721582592,
0.1013179794,
0.4342481196,
-0.9663139582,
0.9358687997,
0.2352318317,
-0.7974485159,
0.0472773276,
-0.599963963,
0.6388707757,
0.2819761932,
0.5733620524,
-0.525015533,
-0.5450014472,
-0.9914816022,
-0.5605968237,
0.4178957045,
0.0482856929,
0.3139480948,
-0.2344226241,
0.1907702088,
0.3167713583,
0.4471580386,
-0.8730335832,
-0.1447063684,
-0.1859846413,
-0.2270423621,
-0.2548090219,
-0.458393544,
-0.0416894034,
0.0568384789,
0.3425064683,
-0.1112345159,
0.2462085634,
0.381811291,
-0.1041749194,
-0.4232138991,
0.4337773621,
0.6213713884,
0.826548636,
-0.1515025347,
0.5962958336,
0.2846693993,
-0.5026262403,
0.4561605752,
0.0805120766,
-0.5424512625,
0.024538517,
0.8902052641,
0.4332161248,
0.3781070709,
-0.832443893,
0.4249323905,
0.429382503,
-0.5125914216,
-0.3459677994,
-0.0476396345,
-0.014804964,
0.2614958584,
0.3915794492,
0.081165038,
0.1279604435,
-1.2356784344,
0.1816105545,
0.6756007671,
-0.3136388659,
-0.5258021355,
0.6245975494,
-0.0703634322,
-0.3881273568,
0.5631571412,
-0.1198693216,
-0.3909725845,
0.7577028871,
0.8481354713,
0.8058251739,
-0.4225786626,
0.134000212,
0.227612555,
0.4082587957,
-0.2955087721,
0.2512847185,
0.1366226673,
-0.8718885183,
-0.4696308374,
-0.1513707191,
-0.4458447099,
0.4130136073,
-0.2918376923,
-0.1107222363,
-0.3831233084,
0.2938432992,
0.1062148735,
-0.4950199425,
-0.3283400238,
0.4562138319,
0.0488525406,
0.7536054254,
-1.3383749723,
0.7948628068,
0.8177363276,
-0.4269671738,
-0.3849624693,
0.2170222849,
-0.0075359899,
-0.5966839194,
0.9491734505,
0.1311412454,
-0.2047208846,
-0.4279723167,
-0.5393069983,
-0.7143574357,
0.5889792442,
0.4822242558,
-0.4795036018,
-0.180385232,
0.0722173825,
0.817607522,
-0.6226152778,
0.6053571105,
0.2160568684,
0.2840177119,
0.238995105,
-1.116433382,
0.5127954483,
-0.4884052277,
-0.1684956104,
0.0652669594,
-0.1947573572,
1.0846847296,
-0.2234327346,
-0.2325644344,
0.4099693596,
0.5031473041,
0.0544344336,
0.5590186715,
0.7633411288,
0.7789125443,
0.0286017153,
0.1577170938,
1.0552669764,
0.1728494018,
0.0869673267,
1.267393589,
-0.4841913283,
0.9057871699,
0.7818478942,
-0.2856841683,
0.876019299,
0.4141511917,
-0.0602074489,
0.3872361481,
0.0840042531,
-0.1529274434,
-0.3882236481,
-0.1190808117,
-0.2154998481,
0.2634037733,
0.0379777178,
-0.2376660854,
-0.3692871034,
-0.3409885764,
0.0263313521,
0.4094306827,
-0.2155033052,
0.4261649251,
0.0746467337,
-0.8571462631,
0.6003282666,
-0.2499449104,
0.3476562798,
-0.4582335353,
-0.459571898,
0.0745909289,
0.0478593409,
0.0731970072,
-0.7208909988,
0.4255484939,
-0.3132351041,
-0.0785554573,
-0.2315317392,
0.3949812055,
-0.2919674516,
-0.1513623148,
-0.0293602198,
0.591501236,
0.0456013456,
-0.1065754965,
-0.4861905277,
-0.2850163281,
-0.1598660946,
-0.3035998642,
0.3740257323,
0.4706029594,
-0.0980432108,
0.5104088783,
0.5724109411,
0.0511033498,
-0.2790654898,
-0.2571573853,
0.6734343767,
-0.7184354067,
-0.5275367498,
-1.0584666729,
0.1961123347,
0.0091980947,
-0.2216034234,
0.7804370522,
0.4839117825,
1.0366076231,
-0.2373868525,
0.6162356138,
0.0007916581,
0.5441212654,
-0.6349802613,
0.2986640632,
-0.4985026121,
0.1709190011,
-0.4461429417,
-0.9752383828,
-0.094760336,
0.5329781771,
-0.6148979664,
0.2224315256,
1.2742700577,
0.6993271112,
-0.4442592859,
-0.0643828511,
0.3330705166,
0.5902791023,
0.0053387932,
0.5303064585,
0.7229866982,
-0.5862497687,
0.4037321508,
0.2859729826,
-0.0141903209,
-0.1385734379,
-0.9647091031,
-0.9268019199,
-0.6643934846,
-0.3920764923,
-0.3036778867,
0.2935025692,
0.8071042895,
0.2985016704,
-0.8328850269,
-0.0997954607,
-0.430313766,
0.141694814,
-0.4056492746,
-0.1267874241,
0.1063892022,
0.0207914989,
-0.6535292864,
0.1544103175,
0.0629556477,
0.2783174813,
-0.0224540215,
0.1106469259,
-0.6659016013,
0.5079830289,
0.5302313566,
0.6228446364,
-0.8136943579,
-0.7361419201,
-0.07882265,
-0.0141835557,
-0.0742866769,
0.9603343606,
-0.9102674127,
0.1870169044,
0.6017314792,
0.3384838998,
0.4676599801,
-0.2174545079,
0.6017184854,
-0.2498944849,
0.3935091794,
-0.0947958305,
0.519497335,
0.2026762515,
-0.0294225197,
0.3225342333,
0.6191997528,
-0.1803429723,
-0.9525267482,
0.7309734225,
-0.6692944765,
-0.6973306537,
1.0152449608,
-0.3784657419,
-0.1569419056,
-0.2509336174,
-0.0190700218,
0.1710920483,
-0.0225799866,
0.886246562,
0.8586161137,
-0.0187686943,
-0.3146432638,
-0.5721284151,
0.063000448,
0.8117575049,
-0.5372441411,
0.0029654182,
0.3356252909,
0.2182232291,
0.4559144378,
0.8360131383,
0.0115545606,
0.5788068175,
0.5164542198,
-0.1187283173,
-0.0005672693,
-0.1190498844,
-0.2155151814,
0.0202028546,
0.2485828549,
0.0022977006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09366v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09366v1
|
Understanding the Role of Temperature in Diverse Question Generation by GPT-4
| 2024-04-14T21:38:50 | 2024-04-14T21:38:50 |
Arav Agarwal, Karthik Mittal, Aidan Doyle, Pragnya Sridhar, Zipiao Wan, Jacob Arthur Doughty, Jaromir Savelka, Majd Sakr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We conduct a preliminary study of the effect of GPT's temperature parameter
on the diversity of GPT4-generated questions. We find that using higher
temperature values leads to significantly higher diversity, with different
temperatures exposing different types of similarity between generated sets of
questions. We also demonstrate that diverse question generation is especially
difficult for questions targeting lower levels of Bloom's Taxonomy.
|
[
-0.9939729571,
-0.8142539263,
0.5648240447,
-0.0416877568,
-0.3771187961,
0.0298655368,
0.1391039044,
-0.5337901115,
-0.0279765017,
0.1271228939,
-0.4008068144,
-0.1758569926,
-0.3332971334,
0.3041380346,
-0.1519505084,
1.1689277887,
-0.0020981163,
-0.3750441968,
0.1058067679,
-0.0060910159,
-0.1716550291,
-0.6500197053,
-0.5297580957,
-0.2125039846,
0.7133809328,
0.6135267019,
0.6493864059,
-0.045355387,
0.5598954558,
0.2713207006,
-0.085877873,
-0.2092900276,
-0.5563856959,
0.7646362782,
-0.1196336299,
-0.6692127585,
0.2679057717,
-0.0762175694,
0.6129655242,
0.3717479408,
0.0322558843,
0.0365296938,
-0.1884075254,
0.4057521224,
-0.4812955856,
-0.2860430479,
-1.0961129665,
0.01843681,
-0.5640768409,
-0.1429853886,
0.1712951958,
-0.3932147324,
0.3473388851,
-0.091191113,
0.8359094858,
-0.2417015731,
0.9323143363,
-0.0217146482,
-0.8075615168,
-0.1639079452,
-0.9143148661,
0.6656028032,
-0.4409880638,
0.2451470792,
0.1210403889,
0.0340056196,
0.1755553931,
-0.4569087625,
-0.6035068035,
0.2677219212,
0.2857424915,
0.4945272207,
-0.0024686351,
-0.2825236022,
0.6122428179,
0.829854846,
-0.8335784078,
-0.4498182833,
-0.7022043467,
-0.064199701,
0.3199746609,
0.4756507576,
0.4163364768,
-0.2183825076,
0.0533577017,
-0.0849137381,
-0.443644166,
0.171353668,
0.8237943649,
0.2339147627,
0.3535405993,
0.0713627189,
0.1414376795,
0.502268672,
-0.0684665218,
0.3358401656,
0.1743627936,
-0.7624354959,
0.1409250796,
-0.4140305519,
0.2714572549,
0.5359346271,
-0.2419739217,
-0.0307670273,
0.1949768513,
-0.2048228532,
0.1520487517,
-1.0347652435,
-0.5556647182,
0.1337854564,
0.2697545588,
-0.028578328,
0.3186873496,
-0.958255291,
0.2311608493,
0.1390248537,
0.0857456401,
-0.1765097678,
-0.681406796,
-0.0751795396,
-0.7578322887,
0.6687386036,
0.4100931883,
-1.2382276058,
0.4427752793,
0.5437833667,
0.634501338,
-0.3706311285,
-0.253770411,
0.230440855,
0.3042991161,
-0.2441950738,
0.8926513791,
-0.8492596149,
-0.6870251298,
-0.4879425466,
-0.1764061004,
-0.2199401855,
-0.5094202161,
-0.1106672585,
-0.8827605844,
0.666272819,
-1.3145620823,
-0.1941548437,
-0.150763467,
0.6282328367,
-0.5365105271,
0.9088242054,
0.2142661363,
-1.0505366325,
0.9283204079,
-0.6119868755,
-0.2038650066,
0.3863321245,
-0.1662869155,
-0.4564735591,
-0.1945547611,
0.1326620132,
-0.0649065897,
-0.1541484743,
-0.4736226797,
-0.2183968425,
0.0503281392,
0.1634945869,
-0.2483985126,
0.3645999134,
0.4375062883,
-0.5104539394,
-0.0628880113,
-0.1337592304,
0.3957433105,
-0.0059255366,
-0.395582974,
-0.2534102201,
-0.4590094388,
-0.4004335403,
-0.2097341567,
0.0707013309,
-0.3963621259,
0.3315306008,
-0.1324829012,
0.2698494494,
0.4507930875,
0.9850494266,
0.4315354526,
-0.4443296492,
1.0098626614,
0.2463663071,
-0.0600041598,
0.0932663903,
-1.3754887581,
-0.4108673632,
0.2665657103,
-0.067672275,
0.7371526957,
-0.4071913958,
-0.5351991057,
0.6106132269,
-0.8626816273,
0.0411195084,
0.3344355226,
0.0618586689,
0.4359386861,
0.2365636528,
-0.1459386796,
-0.3174042702,
-0.4621883929,
-0.2658329606,
-0.1231738254,
0.0547443628,
0.644451499,
0.7255308628,
-0.061513409,
0.9804737568,
-0.7622841001,
0.6572632194,
-0.1578806341,
0.3620038331,
0.5305172205,
0.4907085001,
0.8970553875,
-1.0668990612,
-0.7188221216,
-0.0766413361,
-0.4525117278,
0.1595969498,
0.2077028602,
-0.3842898905,
-0.0373523645,
0.0474942029,
-1.0908927917,
0.1777178943,
0.1937209368,
-0.2996926904,
0.4636972547,
-0.1224594712,
0.702275455,
-1.2222084999,
-0.3728106916,
-0.2324648052,
0.2528304458,
-0.8465903401,
0.2425673306,
-0.1530508101,
-0.370960623,
-0.3661573529,
0.1817417741,
-0.4836406112,
-0.0080320071,
-0.0001248842,
-0.2837507725,
0.1569701135,
-0.1032619029,
-0.3624461293,
0.7874507904,
0.7107818723,
-0.7737906575,
0.7366296053,
0.2150826305,
0.0536372103,
0.1884153783,
-0.6416990757,
0.4464805424,
-0.0508482605,
-0.0551347509,
-1.0582969189,
-0.5027520061,
-0.0252735186,
-0.3979844451,
0.0741709247,
-0.1704781055,
-0.4871472418,
-0.6659611464,
-0.1569227129,
0.894469142,
0.7149136066,
-0.2193363905,
0.1080169454,
-0.1154964492,
-0.4339360297,
-0.0044112075,
-0.5947241187,
-0.2299258113,
-0.7411696911,
-0.8428340554,
0.2577780485,
-0.5179451704,
-0.5640286207,
-0.3163352907,
-0.0713720247,
0.0029491277,
0.0265835505,
-0.1566583961,
-0.2983009517,
-0.5896107554,
0.1620875597,
0.2157930881,
0.4090185463,
0.2249105424,
-0.2563135624,
0.6949582696,
-0.436838001,
-0.4381856322,
0.133038193,
0.9605129361,
0.3975493014,
-0.0836999565,
0.5363555551,
0.6787648797,
-0.178959474,
-0.0334714204,
-0.4330345094,
-0.5380320549,
-0.5352455974,
0.0389031097,
-0.634580493,
-0.9091944695,
1.1401115656,
0.5303705931,
0.082932815,
0.6717349291,
0.9383709431,
0.1479505152,
0.915596664,
0.1500106901,
0.3620415032,
0.3497093022,
-0.0110190436,
-0.1824677438,
-0.2426571548,
-0.2723241746,
-0.5413803458,
-0.3884201944,
-0.9045487046,
-0.3796535432,
0.4591844976,
-0.011420452,
-0.5374672413,
-0.0691793337,
-0.5671685338,
0.7130070925,
0.955350697,
0.2234992981,
-0.0419879667,
-0.3398981094,
0.1596188545,
-0.1790001839,
-0.5446861386,
-0.0696667805,
1.0421507359,
0.148007229,
0.6983847022,
0.5403910875,
1.2642674446,
-0.3108434975,
0.0332898945,
-0.1352533847,
0.2213175446,
0.2515611649,
-1.3074765205,
-0.6457309127,
-0.3780261874,
-0.9641497135,
0.3816096187,
0.2136335671,
-0.4984689355,
-0.1091110334,
0.0552464277,
-0.4884423018,
0.5236614943,
-0.9189696312,
0.8237606287,
-0.1953842193,
-0.3186075687,
0.3828240633,
-0.6756411791,
0.4042893648,
-0.1097740754,
-0.0877155885,
-0.1159353331,
0.1768712848,
0.9118525982,
-0.4229234159,
0.6121516824,
-0.2664814591,
-0.1911208183,
0.6633163095,
0.1439741552,
0.0601648279,
0.6476718187,
-0.2462279946,
-0.1962504536,
0.0280122906,
-0.7747115493,
-0.3192781508,
0.7348003387,
-1.0024400949,
-1.211137414,
-0.5330812335,
-0.8858422637,
-0.4136606157,
0.1491950154,
0.8486011028,
0.0295264535,
0.1779182404,
0.011951481,
0.8266422153,
-0.2098905295,
0.2484052032,
0.1552687883,
-0.0887319148,
-0.0739343911,
0.6125015616,
0.277046591,
0.6604790092,
-0.0202782042,
0.4948966205,
0.0541280918,
-0.6491619349,
-0.1102840826,
-0.0306517482,
-0.8297045231,
-0.170368135,
-0.6662059426,
-0.1628816426,
-0.748214066,
-0.1537857354,
0.0830995888,
-0.1537222564,
-0.6931322813,
-0.5421404839,
0.9256199598,
0.7862936258,
-0.1696437895,
0.3049856722,
-0.7788830996,
0.2605289817,
0.9825588465,
0.047483433,
-0.4375249147,
-0.4829831719,
0.2909013629,
-0.2031451613,
-0.7336139083,
-1.3453719616,
0.232545957,
0.323282361,
0.7531573772,
0.5201134086,
0.0472930036,
0.6149432659,
-0.1842481196,
1.3435821533,
0.1245615184,
-0.8665997982,
0.9317061901,
-0.7946789265,
0.9645080566,
0.4998444915,
0.601978302,
-0.0307677891,
-0.9945608377,
-0.9575961828,
-0.9140837789,
0.1613540798,
0.3079211712,
0.6655657291,
-0.21335949,
0.6544342637,
0.6205848455,
-0.1209893897,
-0.6597286463,
-0.2010872662,
-0.6649023294,
0.498837769,
0.0497051403,
-0.3106821179,
-0.2359946519,
-0.4456040859,
0.0242244992,
0.1043271422,
0.3189463317,
0.0973689556,
0.460209012,
-0.3126501143,
0.5539911985,
0.8892177343,
0.7051243186,
-0.5382170677,
0.1042123213,
0.7129848003,
-0.5043526888,
-0.3143696487,
-0.2516087592,
-0.1621583104,
0.0631012321,
0.1904061735,
0.4949243665,
-0.370028019,
0.3896302581,
-0.0387133695,
-0.2849338949,
-0.6729360223,
0.0046217493,
0.5621776581,
0.1079875529,
0.1903990507,
0.5111961961,
0.1215351149,
0.1313320696,
-1.0316271782,
0.7024182081,
0.5944609046,
-0.0800599828,
-0.6281596422,
0.7457796931,
0.1688919961,
0.0572519042,
0.8256151676,
-0.1832753271,
-0.8942652941,
0.867829144,
0.8497310877,
0.2589300871,
-0.532697618,
0.1409700066,
0.6258580089,
0.3951956034,
0.2552530169,
1.2377154827,
-0.1317895502,
-0.7653551102,
0.1909519583,
-0.3124775589,
-0.8221646547,
-0.0719250366,
-0.7312702537,
-0.2364944667,
-0.6663435102,
-0.5959182978,
-0.2646548152,
-0.246200338,
-0.8341965675,
0.4922365844,
0.0227512941,
0.4889146686,
-0.8931462169,
0.3908011615,
0.4153280258,
-0.6906612515,
-1.0394433737,
0.3564294577,
-0.2758172452,
-0.5019596815,
0.7741754651,
-0.0795856342,
0.1896705031,
-0.1036366299,
-0.6193813086,
-0.93035537,
1.2632620335,
0.2845457792,
0.0144138439,
-0.17583327,
0.306334734,
0.6071345806,
-0.0423850082,
0.316503346,
0.6546859741,
0.6548855305,
0.7375508547,
-0.7663576007,
0.0682685375,
-0.4495822489,
-0.2682924569,
0.3646870255,
-0.4700174034,
1.5292948484,
-0.5435193777,
-0.0168745667,
-0.212902993,
0.6119919419,
0.1328121871,
0.4432742298,
0.1920223236,
0.4528573453,
0.9099715352,
-0.4792427719,
1.1099953651,
-0.0644924492,
0.3072013557,
0.4780336022,
-0.2631945908,
0.3968030214,
0.5365666151,
-0.352350086,
0.4936150014,
1.0436733961,
-0.2814494669,
0.5722641349,
0.4985002875,
-0.5591218472,
-0.2318172008,
0.3810765743,
-1.2488502264,
0.193791464,
0.403626591,
0.1125268862,
-0.2167643011,
-0.1004327014,
-0.168359071,
-0.3618988097,
-0.2766977549,
0.8079681993,
0.0261062924,
-0.7140638828,
0.2524554431,
-0.4997260273,
0.6158498526,
-0.5399087667,
0.2726846337,
-0.610919714,
-0.2568771839,
-0.2848092318,
-1.0367037058,
0.4678639472,
-0.1410158873,
-0.4055150747,
-0.1700889468,
0.4913132191,
-0.2323645651,
-0.3356390595,
-0.1754671931,
0.4474749863,
0.2873454988,
-0.212020576,
-0.6373423338,
-0.1073320806,
-0.0450535752,
-0.5390543938,
0.2212774605,
0.6734492779,
0.1804055423,
0.2617219388,
0.4761741459,
-0.187148273,
0.4178332686,
0.0524089001,
0.7912216187,
-0.8763448,
-0.5511044264,
-0.8394287229,
0.322106719,
-0.0167704728,
-0.611236155,
0.9641880989,
0.5807361603,
0.5680667162,
-0.2098676711,
0.8360621929,
0.0542343333,
0.5127626061,
-0.41135481,
0.5159131289,
-0.4046278298,
0.1204866692,
-0.7180618644,
-1.1876803637,
-0.2615223229,
0.0503652394,
-0.743072331,
0.624314189,
0.8503288627,
0.7092107534,
-0.0572327673,
0.2820477784,
0.2896302044,
-0.1664918363,
0.758079946,
0.4680131376,
0.9221007824,
-0.1013156101,
0.7360022664,
-0.2444578707,
-0.1791165918,
0.3330014944,
-0.565293014,
-0.8546257615,
-0.7007337213,
-0.2514966726,
-0.2818164825,
-0.1308677942,
0.3678219914,
0.6080771089,
-1.0170433521,
0.1079345867,
-0.1317534149,
-0.0085199932,
0.3181352615,
-0.2970318496,
0.0205289181,
-0.3081127703,
-0.5985218883,
-0.0238312371,
0.034670677,
0.4581249654,
-0.0064048157,
0.1370895356,
0.0041420776,
0.2415005565,
0.2905601561,
0.3637466431,
-0.3713985384,
-0.3076944649,
-0.0889319256,
0.0495344512,
0.1597700417,
0.6792016625,
-0.191587925,
0.0312390439,
0.8689350486,
0.3977177441,
0.8141296506,
0.1683546454,
0.7459823489,
-0.7325855494,
-0.1869649142,
0.3969346285,
0.2268375754,
0.2670515776,
-0.5906456709,
0.0252369493,
0.4648431242,
-0.7363665104,
-0.5415490866,
0.8444550633,
-0.8735877872,
-0.1865434945,
1.3609685898,
0.1247629002,
0.1766240448,
-0.1913342774,
-0.2499812841,
-0.1042023301,
-0.4689325988,
0.9017060399,
0.8550904393,
-0.7004488111,
-0.541872561,
-0.6001481414,
0.4721764326,
0.4316004217,
-1.0071593523,
-0.2501216829,
0.1632879525,
0.6720022559,
0.203714937,
0.4887653887,
0.0970759988,
0.4428802431,
0.1733892858,
-0.4286011457,
0.3865949512,
0.3875732422,
0.4035865068,
0.7553955913,
0.2518052459,
0.0858997703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09356v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09356v1
|
LLeMpower: Understanding Disparities in the Control and Access of Large Language Models
| 2024-04-14T20:49:53 | 2024-04-14T20:49:53 |
Vishwas Sathish, Hannah Lin, Aditya K Kamath, Anish Nyayachavadi
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.ET, K.4.0; K.7.4
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are a powerful technology that augment human
skill to create new opportunities, akin to the development of steam engines and
the internet. However, LLMs come with a high cost. They require significant
computing resources and energy to train and serve. Inequity in their control
and access has led to concentration of ownership and power to a small
collection of corporations. In our study, we collect training and inference
requirements for various LLMs. We then analyze the economic strengths of
nations and organizations in the context of developing and serving these
models. Additionally, we also look at whether individuals around the world can
access and use this emerging technology. We compare and contrast these groups
to show that these technologies are monopolized by a surprisingly few entities.
We conclude with a qualitative study on the ethical implications of our
findings and discuss future directions towards equity in LLM access.
|
[
-0.2924789488,
-0.3719674051,
0.7060648203,
0.0757907629,
0.0289302599,
0.476531148,
-0.1127601862,
-0.7239478827,
-0.0542138778,
0.6335735917,
-0.3648495972,
-0.0725424439,
-1.0711740255,
0.0437771082,
-0.2976562381,
0.4732237458,
-0.0289412457,
0.1407211125,
-0.2543795705,
-0.0950720832,
-0.2355633527,
-0.73127985,
-0.2925739884,
-0.5380854607,
0.3109999597,
0.525020659,
0.9814586639,
0.6407419443,
0.6060022712,
0.4220685959,
-0.1676534116,
-0.299182266,
-0.6097505093,
-0.1057867706,
-0.2722422183,
-0.6395134926,
-0.4382579923,
0.1143786758,
0.7796888351,
0.988514483,
-0.2161213905,
0.2801983058,
0.3137918711,
0.7090343833,
-0.5113279819,
0.0706445202,
-0.832288146,
0.0343907475,
-0.2271150053,
0.2240013778,
-0.0945550799,
-0.3341309726,
-0.0535893813,
-0.4881148636,
0.0723148957,
0.443485558,
0.6133223772,
0.4241710901,
-0.5548545718,
-0.4199148118,
-0.6616845727,
1.2203794718,
-0.5845266581,
0.247984916,
0.3694301248,
0.2015760839,
-0.1371931136,
-0.7824237943,
-0.3410978019,
-0.0724075511,
-0.0218000747,
0.0186831225,
-0.4564862549,
0.196262747,
0.4064929485,
0.5301280022,
-0.0866862163,
0.6691695452,
-0.6139757037,
0.0132169584,
0.7196033597,
0.1202006862,
0.445982188,
-0.0802436695,
-0.21917364,
0.2171920687,
-0.7180976272,
-0.1326839179,
0.7219047546,
0.3089039028,
-0.2320708781,
0.9010339379,
0.2022429109,
0.4947147071,
-0.3914085627,
-0.3178793788,
-0.0623491034,
-0.1483172476,
-0.5133426785,
0.3379204869,
0.4757604599,
0.0810803771,
0.4150727987,
-0.073172994,
-0.0271575768,
-0.4053092003,
0.1802227497,
-0.7237992287,
0.4742836952,
0.3009395003,
-0.7820174098,
0.0937101096,
0.0755804032,
-0.59633255,
-0.7306794524,
-0.5587129593,
0.2175571322,
0.0879061967,
-0.5190793276,
0.1472930312,
-0.3800541162,
0.2180770785,
0.1119689047,
-1.1744302511,
0.489418298,
0.7206555605,
1.0049790144,
0.0378875174,
-0.2378523499,
0.0828905255,
0.0067457664,
-0.0788506269,
0.182075575,
-0.3731536865,
-0.7455304861,
0.1575517058,
-0.00062282,
0.1250448525,
-0.8100463748,
-0.0175201874,
-0.5997822285,
-0.1482003629,
-0.328102529,
-0.6213179827,
0.138576299,
-0.2713774443,
-0.8113513589,
0.5257896185,
0.0074575567,
-0.7745731473,
0.3065260351,
-0.7433671951,
-0.3582016528,
0.1766889393,
-0.3127351105,
-0.1679657251,
0.3992285132,
-0.2185818404,
0.3603939712,
-0.6141360402,
0.2853381038,
-0.4670979977,
-0.1791891158,
0.2248235345,
-0.3655394614,
1.174887538,
0.3737799823,
-0.391731292,
-0.1677035242,
-0.763145566,
-0.1927270889,
0.213546738,
-0.1788820028,
-0.5236982703,
0.2176574022,
-0.3027207553,
0.1910199821,
0.4610464275,
-0.363594085,
0.3120674789,
0.0712476224,
0.5069976449,
0.9637015462,
-0.253446877,
0.6953927279,
-0.1538328379,
0.7271751761,
-0.276971966,
0.4015682638,
0.3138632476,
-0.3222380579,
-0.4917642176,
-0.4939256907,
0.1288160533,
0.4018648863,
-0.5382431746,
0.1910430491,
-0.1437453032,
-0.3210561872,
-0.7246220112,
0.437797308,
-0.0120223686,
0.1009553522,
0.0999261588,
-0.054086253,
-0.3076308072,
-1.205188036,
-0.1768140793,
-0.0572574064,
-0.2998283803,
0.5951536298,
0.5186987519,
0.0627112687,
0.8055759072,
-0.181956172,
-0.2187020332,
-0.4124578834,
-0.205927521,
0.3108653724,
0.1769573987,
0.1175447777,
-0.9544839263,
-0.1045285389,
0.1213435233,
-1.0230628252,
-0.3245191574,
0.0627527088,
-0.0090087242,
-0.1600188166,
0.646957159,
-0.2409641296,
0.0993544832,
0.8103724122,
-0.1680302024,
0.2972610295,
-0.2934478223,
0.0540472455,
-1.009729147,
0.0124538168,
-0.0048035001,
-0.0949165896,
-0.3290436566,
-0.061152488,
-0.1940790713,
-0.1261693537,
-0.5566160083,
0.3820095062,
-0.8578705788,
-0.476270467,
-0.4012144804,
0.2916837633,
-0.2090814412,
-0.1055415198,
-0.1686685383,
0.8037797809,
0.5854383111,
-0.53507936,
0.2955034673,
0.0698595494,
-0.5351421237,
0.2786077261,
-0.768447578,
-0.1097475961,
0.0345427915,
-0.127015844,
-0.4825567603,
-0.4204012156,
-0.4114333987,
-0.0026382825,
0.128371045,
-0.0736740083,
-0.5254318118,
-0.2522628903,
-0.0018928734,
0.2914419174,
0.7000271678,
-0.4035661817,
0.5710740685,
0.9777143598,
-0.3807154,
-0.7707995176,
-0.9477525353,
0.1380228698,
-0.2654593885,
-0.5879186988,
0.188084662,
0.1336705238,
-0.9902502298,
0.0224249959,
0.163244009,
-0.0310343206,
0.3265177011,
0.6128938794,
-0.0530787818,
-0.0593934841,
0.2485378832,
0.0786128119,
0.0897409096,
0.1113142297,
-0.2525564134,
0.4338907599,
-0.0572705306,
-0.6957603097,
-0.2044901997,
0.4598738849,
0.7442824244,
-0.0436992608,
0.8153042197,
-0.0574563704,
-0.4059484899,
-0.225325346,
-0.5200967193,
-0.0084099909,
-0.5280764699,
0.4668376744,
0.0947549716,
-1.2086941004,
0.4476562142,
-0.2618934214,
0.2314868122,
0.3553475142,
0.8131269217,
0.2205230296,
0.7534077168,
1.1456418037,
-0.3432812095,
0.4641488194,
-0.137808606,
0.3145211339,
-0.5528459549,
-0.3431253731,
-0.6433842182,
-0.4507373571,
-0.8684350252,
-0.2331039906,
0.2756411433,
0.20324485,
-0.431723088,
0.0040939897,
-0.2299345732,
0.7041796446,
0.7709588408,
-0.1489308625,
0.6741905212,
0.0665955991,
-0.0556737334,
-0.1156738028,
-0.9041605592,
-0.8177319765,
0.9514251947,
0.6063922048,
1.0164622068,
0.3117547035,
0.5004581213,
0.4435085058,
0.3052421212,
-0.8605722189,
0.4076428413,
-0.2489885837,
-0.7828418016,
-0.3187572956,
-0.4587846696,
-0.9662899375,
0.0864199921,
-0.1158113554,
-0.8125634789,
0.2835137844,
0.0498434491,
-0.1171852127,
0.7602871656,
-0.8909500241,
0.5674675703,
-0.4534935355,
-0.6051288843,
-0.4087373614,
-0.5165172219,
0.4719046652,
-0.1343956888,
0.4875302315,
-0.2162252516,
-0.0949406996,
0.5677773356,
-0.3450085819,
0.8826249242,
-0.0508819818,
-0.2299913168,
0.3296262324,
-0.1830824614,
-0.0007074478,
-0.136804089,
-0.3684636354,
0.5452652574,
-0.3909279406,
-0.6760417819,
-0.143830657,
0.7810505033,
-0.9746576548,
-0.7740487456,
-0.472497642,
-0.5819741488,
-0.127721563,
0.2545723915,
0.1937451363,
0.0863061771,
-0.2543720007,
0.3761361241,
0.6046266556,
-0.3697904646,
0.5623161793,
0.3074846566,
-0.3163200319,
-0.0222864207,
0.5350154638,
0.5247325301,
0.6472362876,
0.1153870523,
0.0845264867,
-0.2791465223,
-0.4395321906,
-0.0832485035,
0.3209483922,
-0.5872333646,
0.1420641243,
-0.3408883214,
-0.2156403959,
-0.2775113285,
-0.177970469,
-0.2425346375,
-0.1785642207,
-0.3241614699,
-0.1649941653,
0.2007377893,
1.2840942144,
-0.2122515887,
0.6189686656,
-0.4590648115,
0.1560835689,
0.4904711246,
0.321192503,
0.0444260947,
-0.3630249798,
-0.3443113565,
-0.2389441282,
-0.3990692198,
-0.6825561523,
0.2598019242,
-0.2140298188,
0.5872012973,
0.2061500102,
-0.0645803064,
0.3536751866,
-0.6471819878,
0.8505851626,
0.4148600101,
-1.1335368156,
0.0622864626,
0.0360417552,
0.1745633334,
0.219449833,
0.7205966711,
-0.3944687545,
-0.474727869,
-0.8039962053,
-0.9603512287,
0.5056889057,
0.1549940705,
0.365940541,
0.4301380217,
0.2126009762,
-0.0518643372,
0.4956732392,
-0.7477306724,
-0.1894521415,
-0.0436969362,
-0.1234891862,
0.0713480338,
-0.2627698183,
-0.0823206902,
0.0279375743,
0.6588282585,
0.0559899546,
0.1058466956,
0.104965277,
0.0199802909,
-0.0711099431,
0.4932667315,
0.2163553834,
0.9747469425,
0.0431411006,
0.298785001,
0.2443113327,
-0.4530159235,
0.3024117053,
-0.0173700806,
0.3010325134,
-0.1756355464,
0.3633881509,
0.6969643831,
-0.1959551722,
-0.7297516465,
0.3609628975,
-0.0839987844,
-0.3493146896,
-0.2332645953,
0.0821534842,
0.2535733283,
0.6128228307,
0.5272579789,
-0.3325529993,
0.0180979595,
-0.5249459147,
-0.131724596,
0.647098124,
-0.3253627121,
0.0492495447,
0.6367022395,
0.2170540541,
-0.3587896526,
0.4033767581,
0.0851322934,
-0.2834965885,
0.6769417524,
0.3804601133,
0.6508383155,
-0.0780168474,
-0.1593259722,
-0.0150608653,
0.8714570999,
-0.1340459436,
-0.0090781376,
0.1995476186,
-0.6833811402,
-0.4024102986,
-0.5337802172,
-0.784450829,
0.2738937736,
-0.6581354737,
0.157890439,
-0.510376513,
-0.4306982458,
-0.0614751577,
0.0875616893,
-0.5975344777,
-0.1605156511,
0.2225994766,
0.8255066872,
-0.7897660732,
0.6734131575,
0.1868019998,
-0.2271954715,
-0.5781145096,
-0.058402393,
0.0282446016,
-1.0553776026,
0.7468992472,
0.0513844378,
-0.1375335604,
0.0192937627,
-0.6842319965,
-0.6671790481,
1.2661851645,
0.6852017641,
-1.0311183929,
-0.0821480229,
0.265576154,
0.2502304018,
-0.2223456353,
0.0513967015,
0.6009130478,
0.4039344192,
-0.3559314311,
-1.0390454531,
-0.2119924724,
0.183360979,
-0.0134112081,
0.1291045398,
-0.79730618,
0.8068725467,
-0.1985637546,
-0.1634819806,
-0.2102685273,
0.4820776582,
0.1991433799,
0.3907832205,
0.3511886597,
0.1071942374,
0.9382833242,
0.0428868681,
1.3618719578,
-0.3996714652,
0.4073565304,
0.68909657,
-0.6245867014,
0.4871088862,
0.5865192413,
-0.3419992924,
0.2226974815,
0.3721113205,
0.0842531845,
0.0509989224,
0.6491935253,
-0.4784896374,
-0.18625395,
-0.4778105021,
-0.2912438512,
0.2307213247,
0.2846551836,
-0.5330311656,
-0.0642153174,
0.002098582,
0.0729521662,
0.2447417825,
-0.6072673798,
0.6140899062,
0.6491413713,
-0.2347647548,
0.1858139485,
-0.0324423835,
0.6095394492,
-0.7804062366,
0.204806298,
-0.021272311,
0.1592212319,
-0.2015516907,
-0.7028763294,
0.2601654828,
0.3960881531,
-0.1233972684,
-0.2786390185,
0.627205193,
-0.1247330457,
-0.5285177231,
0.7028169036,
0.8691735268,
0.2381867617,
0.1356534213,
-0.7071405649,
0.1794591397,
-0.1707042456,
-0.0844625086,
0.4312831461,
0.5019857883,
-0.0508076958,
0.6923536658,
0.2981217802,
0.4190796912,
0.1681573689,
0.165169239,
0.5643333793,
-0.5286036134,
-0.1126935259,
-1.134313941,
0.1376558244,
-0.3893800378,
-0.2450963557,
0.8459426165,
0.4868862629,
0.6762733459,
0.1996155977,
1.1818168163,
-0.1755223125,
0.2015682161,
-0.6475575566,
0.8425418139,
-0.7483816743,
0.2463379353,
0.0290814731,
-0.8461170793,
-0.269879669,
0.4364345372,
-0.4838970304,
0.0705179647,
0.4286538959,
0.7106253505,
-0.1781596988,
-0.0818455666,
0.6039251089,
0.3172826469,
0.2791736424,
0.276851505,
0.8662768602,
0.0552776381,
0.1743570715,
-0.0659295022,
-0.4016631544,
-0.0932909921,
-1.1375859976,
-0.5886494517,
-0.267544657,
-0.0558231026,
-0.2672774494,
-0.1445792168,
1.1292248964,
0.6469605565,
-0.5973456502,
-0.8861367106,
0.0027323209,
0.5992496014,
0.0989860445,
-0.1545554549,
0.087542288,
-0.1677560508,
-1.0496412516,
0.0875889361,
0.3548226953,
0.2374022603,
-0.5555045605,
0.0464896858,
-0.0025446354,
0.3016164303,
0.7098922133,
0.2992959619,
-0.4923147857,
0.1919642836,
0.0349126644,
-0.1212602928,
-0.1100979596,
1.2175556421,
-0.2465089262,
0.2623527348,
0.1711128056,
0.8241446614,
0.0691472217,
-0.0610795654,
0.5020759702,
-0.539516747,
0.3479774892,
0.1791981608,
0.6331391335,
0.4802975357,
-0.1971977204,
0.2225895077,
0.1993746012,
-0.9340173006,
-0.8181225061,
0.3120898008,
-0.7339413762,
-0.4682183266,
1.1799166203,
0.0695435703,
-0.2881273329,
-0.181389302,
-0.1659259498,
0.2374358028,
-0.2763868868,
0.7300388217,
0.8154318333,
-0.1201870814,
0.0902570188,
-0.9310255051,
0.2043098807,
0.1268349439,
-0.7896179557,
0.1975685805,
0.5254077911,
0.1571100652,
0.0506767929,
0.5614279509,
-0.144400537,
-0.397429198,
-0.0284901857,
0.3211335242,
0.1023518518,
-0.3197733462,
-0.6654466987,
0.3596023917,
0.4221894443,
0.0468763411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09339v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09339v1
|
Towards Practical Tool Usage for Continually Learning LLMs
| 2024-04-14T19:45:47 | 2024-04-14T19:45:47 |
Jerry Huang, Prasanna Parthasarathi, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Sarath Chandar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) show an innate skill for solving language based
tasks. But insights have suggested an inability to adjust for information or
task-solving skills becoming outdated, as their knowledge, stored directly
within their parameters, remains static in time. Tool use helps by offloading
work to systems that the LLM can access through an interface, but LLMs that use
them still must adapt to nonstationary environments for prolonged use, as new
tools can emerge and existing tools can change. Nevertheless, tools require
less specialized knowledge, therefore we hypothesize they are better suited for
continual learning (CL) as they rely less on parametric memory for solving
tasks and instead focus on learning when to apply pre-defined tools. To verify
this, we develop a synthetic benchmark and follow this by aggregating existing
NLP tasks to form a more realistic testing scenario. While we demonstrate
scaling model size is not a solution, regardless of tool usage, continual
learning techniques can enable tool LLMs to both adapt faster while forgetting
less, highlighting their potential as continual learners.
|
[
-0.1983634531,
-0.6639844775,
0.6214353442,
0.453669399,
-0.3041007519,
0.15811418,
-0.3809608817,
-0.3184866309,
-0.2873471975,
0.400031507,
-0.6420535445,
-0.3852463067,
-0.3807367682,
0.1670835018,
-0.3445519507,
0.6755422354,
-0.0581399277,
-0.0434824452,
-0.5113989711,
-0.5523697734,
-0.7891350389,
-0.5081681013,
-1.1512777805,
-0.5332304239,
0.7591775656,
0.5146403313,
0.4160507917,
0.4180777073,
0.4278814495,
0.1902273297,
-0.0626335517,
-0.0040417905,
-0.5767970085,
0.2115864903,
-0.2847854793,
-0.5619140267,
-0.2416725606,
-0.0035081571,
0.7394265532,
1.029058814,
-0.4790835083,
0.3819277585,
0.3030717969,
0.3509014845,
-0.283751756,
-0.0469453521,
-1.0105397701,
0.0626240671,
0.0650219992,
-0.0971759707,
-0.5444971919,
-0.1501429826,
0.0136773782,
-0.5643103719,
0.0929726958,
-0.0570656285,
0.6630564332,
0.5059284568,
-0.22943452,
-0.3252937794,
-0.7746010423,
0.9989669919,
-0.7950403094,
0.5384771824,
0.175237745,
0.3461578786,
-0.2298697531,
-0.8505648971,
-0.3475328088,
-0.5923929811,
0.2025193572,
-0.0743064657,
0.1995548755,
-0.2394893169,
0.5471313596,
0.1258298457,
-0.4036525786,
0.3711095154,
-0.274725765,
-0.1247474998,
0.4577425122,
0.3383566439,
0.1837327331,
0.4434137642,
-0.4119616151,
0.0314380154,
-0.9868302941,
-0.0451537035,
-0.1966791898,
0.0492843688,
-0.1206601635,
0.3218696713,
0.3495210409,
0.777623117,
-0.2517700493,
-0.5831979513,
0.2490501702,
-0.2223277837,
-0.2050729692,
-0.3918627501,
0.4263318479,
0.3159972727,
0.3295558989,
-0.4402170181,
-0.3340634108,
-0.1968811303,
0.6583932042,
-0.5419329405,
-0.1402635574,
0.0019594284,
-0.1791968048,
0.0425828658,
-0.565898478,
-0.4407666028,
-0.1886788309,
-0.5494181514,
0.4336668253,
-0.3962812126,
-0.2573937178,
0.0476462729,
-0.1536200643,
0.2191412598,
0.4881328046,
-0.523940742,
0.3676187694,
0.5037468672,
1.3813747168,
-0.4325735569,
-0.3407940567,
-0.6089529395,
0.0561952479,
-0.5928782821,
0.5620438457,
-0.1824153662,
-0.6085785627,
-0.0878133252,
0.208374694,
-0.0401799306,
-0.9358340502,
0.1640981883,
-0.3729110658,
-0.1880173236,
-0.3327786326,
-0.4754341841,
-0.0425592028,
0.4295853674,
-0.5186400414,
1.3307570219,
0.3594155312,
-0.2996307909,
0.5711528659,
-0.4699144661,
-0.1930206865,
0.2456945032,
0.1020012349,
-0.5565907955,
0.2032090873,
-0.3197972775,
0.4769568145,
-0.1115317121,
0.4283305109,
-0.5211037397,
-0.2946611345,
0.1071105152,
-0.2934241593,
0.5077643991,
-0.0022167373,
-0.2782622576,
0.0146329561,
-0.5683128834,
-0.1480196714,
0.1889093667,
-0.3759483993,
-0.1940215528,
0.2035446465,
-0.05810415,
0.3405360878,
0.3631759286,
-0.6639202237,
0.1408668756,
-0.3956544101,
0.34277457,
0.7937224507,
0.1539534777,
0.2000042349,
-0.6404077411,
0.5677829981,
-0.1343034953,
0.0211574826,
0.1033897027,
-0.1496974528,
-0.9606251121,
-0.0016463706,
0.1265662163,
0.4299292266,
-0.7405478358,
0.234908402,
-0.2977763116,
-0.8317109942,
0.1724978834,
0.6684931517,
0.165936783,
0.4686156809,
0.3384050131,
-0.4848100841,
-0.479403317,
-0.5088436604,
-0.1233236194,
-0.0590388402,
-0.3851009905,
0.4065154195,
0.5725238323,
-0.2090051472,
0.8230860829,
-0.1662460566,
-0.2182253599,
-0.4527237713,
0.1035702899,
0.3289765418,
0.3128443062,
0.4465349615,
-0.5217328668,
-0.5161107779,
-0.0516910739,
-0.9580487013,
-0.1140416041,
-0.663143456,
0.3207367957,
0.2745469809,
0.9282444119,
-0.4189720452,
-0.009965877,
0.5167668462,
-0.0054862844,
0.7901784778,
-0.4934798479,
-0.6702692509,
-0.6063860655,
0.2536472678,
0.117894806,
-0.5674063563,
-0.4433705807,
0.0022923285,
0.2026451677,
-0.0789686292,
-0.5365607142,
0.9668802023,
-0.5598013401,
-0.0935774818,
-0.334736973,
0.3154502213,
-0.3083990812,
0.4361977577,
0.030015504,
1.1146942377,
0.441835314,
-0.8722557425,
0.2496769875,
-0.2024536282,
-0.2431291491,
0.4026593864,
-0.9119189978,
0.142504096,
0.2188021988,
0.0716326535,
-0.5354560614,
0.2029532045,
-0.1392685622,
-0.0787794665,
0.3789500892,
0.033284571,
-0.9054929018,
-0.2871231139,
-0.1315968186,
0.0496981628,
0.7967203259,
-0.5988309979,
0.7129059434,
0.3017743528,
-0.2394103259,
-0.3147364557,
-0.452955842,
0.1649888456,
-0.4244261086,
-0.2410354912,
0.3264775276,
-0.2370651513,
-0.180162847,
-0.2403444499,
-0.5769443512,
0.1443985403,
0.4210832119,
0.3020942211,
0.2081684172,
-0.1804070324,
0.6389042735,
-0.2734805644,
-0.0925924182,
0.2062356621,
-0.2755258679,
0.5355728269,
-0.148212254,
-0.2892009914,
0.0751755387,
0.1224648729,
0.6399034858,
0.002462314,
1.0798668861,
0.5477770567,
-0.2227770388,
-0.49501127,
-0.8679382205,
-0.2415524125,
-0.5258651376,
0.3477254212,
-0.2347231507,
-0.9721884131,
0.4433576167,
-0.672179997,
0.5601357818,
0.3315267563,
0.6118918657,
-0.287094444,
0.5327088833,
0.9644706845,
-0.1232214198,
0.4097674787,
-0.1682499349,
0.0561330654,
-1.0160791874,
-0.1183042377,
-0.3121936917,
-0.1690617353,
-0.3064665198,
-0.4502297044,
0.4499513209,
0.3381308913,
-0.2631153762,
0.4461091459,
-0.3255181015,
0.3395241201,
0.297601521,
0.0880227536,
0.0591307692,
-0.2419542521,
-0.3223711848,
0.0919080749,
-0.9230831861,
-0.4487765729,
1.3244290352,
0.421100378,
0.4653262198,
-0.1273223907,
0.5933329463,
0.096718289,
0.6333538294,
-0.7527350187,
0.7538878322,
0.1053433642,
-0.2216614038,
-0.3388684094,
-0.3406407237,
-0.9920602441,
0.0258452855,
0.1954601109,
-0.7056488395,
-0.2121650875,
0.2707097232,
-0.0664089769,
0.3044328094,
-0.4879899323,
0.8099316955,
-0.2999027371,
-0.5219627023,
-0.4148164093,
-0.4147871435,
-0.1233290881,
-0.3904240131,
0.2584595382,
-0.137806505,
-0.3589983582,
0.6009210348,
-0.2362898737,
1.1310530901,
-0.2231790125,
-0.0198667441,
0.235005796,
0.0855291262,
0.4417277575,
0.1778750718,
-0.0969498828,
0.1271049678,
0.135189265,
-0.4957405031,
-0.571828723,
0.6886596084,
-0.5769178867,
-0.8039928675,
-0.4770223796,
-0.7140231133,
-0.3569724858,
0.1261758804,
-0.2170608491,
0.4463918209,
-0.115216434,
0.5249347687,
0.7941505909,
-0.1528955549,
0.480614692,
0.4954725802,
-0.1814316809,
0.1015962139,
0.8192268014,
0.2488351613,
0.5019481778,
-0.007545413,
0.2983684838,
-0.2268312722,
-0.7177987099,
0.0088930288,
0.441562742,
-0.8754329085,
0.0227158163,
-0.5250290036,
-0.1931532174,
0.0951100662,
-0.432202369,
-0.2055240273,
-0.2047321945,
-0.2540520132,
0.0716332793,
0.442766428,
0.300892204,
-0.1118687466,
0.1561876088,
-0.8159980774,
0.2018740922,
0.3412237763,
0.2962811291,
0.0235711783,
-0.7202911377,
-0.2695631981,
-0.1702682525,
-0.3854676783,
-0.4752081335,
0.4879886508,
0.4912046194,
0.7737320662,
-0.0397710428,
-0.0421696603,
0.4503192604,
-0.5948176384,
0.8534465432,
-0.040290866,
-0.707828939,
0.3569782376,
-0.2746067345,
0.7925263643,
0.5861626863,
0.7635377049,
-0.7878525257,
-0.428378731,
-0.587916851,
-0.8186829686,
0.1631990075,
-0.1467216909,
0.3757091761,
-0.0186779536,
0.7094936371,
0.134500131,
0.2123289853,
-0.9111784697,
0.0714032948,
0.0922489762,
-0.083400242,
-0.3119571805,
-0.2048917413,
-0.0176622123,
-0.3200002313,
0.6670427322,
-0.2590951324,
0.119324334,
-0.0984762087,
-0.2908868194,
0.2375205159,
0.1490470171,
0.4028499424,
1.1178346872,
-0.1457295716,
0.0406381972,
0.8266605139,
-0.5013971329,
0.0979658589,
-0.4604094326,
0.0645791739,
0.1057725921,
0.3381046653,
0.382805109,
0.4617854655,
-1.1640845537,
0.1020936742,
0.1921959072,
-0.1890601963,
-0.8676669598,
0.3599080741,
0.6136125922,
0.0230557043,
0.1027804986,
0.0489121862,
-0.2664243579,
-0.5556931496,
0.3611000478,
0.4492942393,
-0.4803211391,
-0.0300828964,
0.2107404619,
0.1497755349,
-0.4797090292,
0.7196362615,
-0.355602324,
-0.3152368963,
0.5875038505,
0.6172611117,
0.5046438575,
-0.1879257411,
-0.0425153784,
0.5620709062,
0.3875583112,
-0.3329739273,
-0.0394523218,
-0.2993836999,
-0.6033073664,
-0.5193750262,
-0.631953299,
-0.5478530526,
0.2836871445,
-0.4783235788,
0.2742629051,
-0.7741434574,
-0.0297967605,
-0.2990053296,
-0.0472354554,
-0.7159504294,
0.2338230908,
-0.3118899763,
1.0981599092,
-0.5826432109,
1.079762578,
0.5081780553,
-0.1460448205,
-0.7633299828,
-0.2377251089,
0.2818853259,
-0.6790649891,
0.6762833595,
0.3164879084,
-0.1746173203,
0.0330284685,
-0.4704239368,
-0.7270172834,
1.1971732378,
0.2234735042,
-0.793143034,
-0.1161297634,
-0.135543108,
0.6203323603,
-0.1860462129,
-0.0250410642,
0.4285625815,
0.1829379946,
0.2532636225,
-1.0349372625,
-0.0003001532,
-0.2648265958,
0.0545764863,
0.252561152,
-0.3335647881,
0.6417553425,
0.0136466967,
-0.2542229295,
-0.1549180895,
0.2995033562,
0.4208674431,
0.3201572299,
0.6671335101,
0.5567151308,
0.5065232515,
0.0151739251,
0.9108997583,
-0.1773960888,
0.3021584451,
1.2840025425,
-0.4788702726,
1.0181493759,
0.6100485325,
-0.1636751145,
0.5067686439,
0.5557230711,
-0.3343326747,
0.2348212749,
0.3688260615,
-0.377551198,
-0.4427405,
-0.0598276258,
-0.07965938,
0.1653295457,
0.6030579805,
-0.0637097135,
-0.3188983202,
0.3033336401,
0.0509808026,
0.0942835212,
-0.3240289986,
0.8233565688,
0.4854773879,
-0.6040477157,
0.7929301262,
-0.1488465667,
0.7002367377,
-0.796307683,
0.1290786117,
-0.006761333,
0.2880994081,
0.1317706853,
-0.5394898653,
0.6856587529,
-0.0441353507,
0.0278140977,
-0.4741205573,
0.5696743131,
-0.0732003823,
-0.6190223694,
0.3622380793,
0.435113281,
0.0077207694,
-0.0469285809,
-0.7750766277,
-0.080639571,
-0.2326244116,
-0.1694191694,
0.6761702895,
0.2966187596,
0.0960215926,
1.3077286482,
0.6602011323,
0.3592891991,
-0.0176741369,
0.0492712855,
0.7955433726,
-0.5405914187,
-0.1498643607,
-0.7349296808,
0.4683098495,
-0.2388707399,
-0.3112256527,
0.9045197964,
0.3283317983,
1.0045185089,
0.057986889,
0.5044873357,
0.1628283709,
0.5484434366,
-0.7440612316,
0.4962815344,
-0.7515854239,
0.4259908497,
0.1679257154,
-0.8096362352,
-0.2667272687,
0.5673292875,
-0.2904136777,
0.0024007002,
0.983951807,
0.6328449249,
-0.003349113,
-0.3499188423,
0.464050889,
0.0150484461,
0.317850858,
0.5701779127,
0.4868349731,
0.0620118231,
0.3861572742,
-0.3076648414,
-0.0865402371,
-0.0260020588,
-1.0531016588,
-1.0733141899,
-0.6133098006,
-0.4252589643,
-0.0557412095,
0.06211216,
0.84960711,
0.6351198554,
-0.4811454117,
-0.5219030976,
-0.3897949457,
-0.0743573159,
-0.4154842496,
-0.1556605697,
-0.0054291827,
-0.8978761435,
-0.2555521429,
0.3864173591,
0.4682142735,
-0.1485006213,
-0.4537077248,
0.053338699,
-0.2731370926,
-0.0418092422,
0.6409038305,
0.4435892105,
-0.6455404162,
-0.4963105321,
0.1600579768,
0.2183449417,
0.1372035593,
0.8424645066,
-0.9845055342,
0.4140143991,
0.0720728785,
0.8324172497,
0.6820341945,
-0.4661031067,
0.6748229861,
-0.8223338723,
0.2737654746,
0.3960618377,
0.328310132,
0.3419420123,
-0.1395547986,
0.5995967984,
0.1071709469,
-0.7679852843,
-0.9324516654,
0.2577947974,
-0.8632867336,
-0.2904114723,
1.0725634098,
-0.4799723029,
-0.0346411914,
-0.5964156389,
0.0149348294,
0.0355160683,
-0.0218898412,
0.7829698324,
0.6636505723,
0.049531322,
-0.5826194286,
-0.8999337554,
0.3150146902,
0.4851281345,
-0.8637755513,
-0.0025710613,
0.058050815,
0.6701708436,
0.1367640942,
0.5778049231,
0.0042017065,
0.3621087372,
0.0601925626,
-0.1078810468,
0.0368107781,
-0.4131258726,
-0.2118074596,
0.0884647593,
0.5595538616,
0.279050827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09338v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09338v1
|
Entropy Guided Extrapolative Decoding to Improve Factuality in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-14T19:45:35 | 2024-04-14T19:45:35 |
Souvik Das, Lifeng Jin, Linfeng Song, Haitao Mi, Baolin Peng, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit impressive natural language capabilities
but suffer from hallucination -- generating content ungrounded in the realities
of training data. Recent work has focused on decoding techniques to improve
factuality during inference by leveraging LLMs' hierarchical representation of
factual knowledge, manipulating the predicted distributions at inference time.
Current state-of-the-art approaches refine decoding by contrasting early-exit
distributions from a lower layer with the final layer to exploit information
related to factuality within the model forward procedure. However, such methods
often assume the final layer is the most reliable and the lower layer selection
process depends on it. In this work, we first propose extrapolation of critical
token probabilities beyond the last layer for more accurate contrasting. We
additionally employ layer-wise entropy-guided lower layer selection, decoupling
the selection process from the final layer. Experiments demonstrate strong
performance - surpassing state-of-the-art on multiple different datasets by
large margins. Analyses show different kinds of prompts respond to different
selection strategies.
|
[
-0.2189631015,
-0.7214744091,
0.7671068311,
0.1569401622,
-0.5082750916,
0.1108260229,
-0.4077976346,
-0.506284833,
0.2234863937,
0.4507475197,
-0.3537199795,
-0.5324819684,
-0.5435011387,
0.0638624206,
-0.3138365448,
0.9786612988,
0.233928293,
0.0425591134,
-0.3993074298,
0.1873839796,
-0.100499317,
-0.7233935595,
-0.7315468788,
-0.5965752602,
0.4269197285,
0.2905790806,
0.5474793911,
0.60748595,
0.3126042485,
0.2412525117,
-0.3313219547,
0.4135013819,
-0.4346856177,
0.2425033748,
0.0528856553,
-0.701210618,
-0.2838035524,
-0.0535162725,
0.6217924953,
0.6796173453,
-0.2689721882,
0.0437732711,
0.1428326964,
0.6906937957,
-0.779268086,
0.4519996345,
-0.8364747167,
0.1250716597,
0.0323032811,
-0.6306427121,
-0.8259475231,
-0.2546826005,
0.0475130416,
-0.4489994049,
0.2670489252,
0.1630293578,
0.5732867718,
0.2042481303,
-0.2557758093,
-0.1595742851,
-0.8554443717,
0.7146478891,
-0.8401204348,
0.6620090604,
0.627632618,
0.0383718349,
-0.1040506363,
-0.5754036307,
-0.4387835264,
-0.487816453,
-0.0263058189,
0.105911307,
-0.0835720748,
0.1087709144,
0.1485266834,
0.1875505745,
-0.2144004852,
0.1962221414,
-0.1065163389,
-0.4728710353,
0.4613996446,
0.0269882735,
0.0496206693,
-0.0483466424,
-0.2222911865,
-0.344135195,
-0.6970647573,
-0.0304697044,
0.3042335212,
0.3064823151,
-0.0016528692,
0.5153113008,
-0.4155058563,
0.547349751,
0.0850007236,
-0.1620448828,
0.3758150339,
-0.0567809641,
-0.3732751906,
0.3076745868,
0.4794765413,
0.4473151565,
-0.0513558649,
-0.2436419129,
-0.3032452464,
-0.2713087797,
-0.1290297508,
-0.6215271354,
-0.390101403,
0.3351885974,
-0.5327731967,
-0.331695497,
-0.0109273456,
-0.7083397508,
-0.5333787203,
-0.4510638118,
0.0920356214,
-0.5132610202,
-0.1953486502,
0.3335688412,
-0.1873278916,
0.2364819944,
0.3615702391,
-0.8823450208,
0.135579437,
0.7291838527,
0.930746913,
0.0270309169,
-0.2425795496,
-0.8004854321,
0.3621703982,
-0.4364635944,
0.8426222801,
-0.7330598235,
0.0377520211,
-0.1413314193,
-0.2791931033,
0.0981074497,
-0.5164130926,
0.8372967243,
-0.9897525311,
0.0595737696,
-0.5204864144,
-0.4856103063,
-0.3188492954,
0.4187012911,
-0.7135783434,
0.7712331414,
-0.2570890188,
-0.9039424658,
0.4528104067,
-0.1929669827,
-0.3999316394,
-0.0589773618,
-0.080750145,
-0.3423033059,
0.4708576798,
0.4782897234,
0.6668176055,
-0.3814586103,
0.2483514547,
-0.4406996071,
-0.1818538308,
0.3107742071,
-0.8789991736,
0.5873057842,
0.2414139807,
-0.2858322263,
-0.1126981229,
-1.0861442089,
0.10175962,
-0.1396835297,
-0.5820304751,
-0.4341936707,
0.0248080567,
-0.2251692712,
0.1257670075,
-0.0291341823,
-0.3588219881,
-0.1023173854,
-0.2991813421,
0.2819927335,
0.8745262027,
-0.1565968543,
0.2777877152,
-0.1796479672,
0.3513055444,
0.2500859201,
-0.0994463265,
-0.0059239883,
-0.2795487642,
-0.6279606819,
-0.5688658357,
0.3752485514,
0.6429340839,
-0.9676578045,
0.5751307011,
-0.315079987,
-0.2725365162,
-0.476547122,
0.0809287727,
0.3684004545,
0.5515648127,
0.4206454158,
-0.0995555595,
-0.7456686497,
-0.7254321575,
-0.1713615805,
-0.5672783852,
0.1307944804,
0.0540077128,
0.2631269693,
-0.1977746785,
0.7622278929,
-0.5627194047,
0.0105195744,
-0.2297370881,
0.0751275271,
0.2667972445,
0.4142210782,
0.1272810996,
-0.6831296682,
-0.2459875941,
0.1373120844,
-0.6724091172,
-0.0234254636,
-0.3698735535,
-0.2171106786,
0.2964620292,
0.6223844886,
-0.8360612988,
0.0931074023,
0.5302324891,
-0.2065114975,
0.8253472447,
-0.3303565085,
0.1304120719,
-0.8154034615,
-0.0082818586,
-0.0312958956,
-0.3084893823,
-0.6048990488,
0.0911493972,
-0.1534546763,
0.5000926852,
-0.1016451046,
0.2527065575,
-0.7184619308,
-0.025000181,
-0.2366488725,
-0.2292314619,
0.1261138469,
0.2642198205,
0.2745536864,
0.4612653553,
0.6573752761,
-0.509372592,
0.6195362806,
0.0327378586,
-0.6103165746,
0.1455716789,
-0.4664230943,
0.1884914786,
-0.3059750199,
0.562825799,
-0.9568352699,
-0.341083467,
0.1707463115,
-0.3147202134,
0.3781143725,
-0.202698186,
-0.7024867535,
-0.0844852701,
-0.6080744267,
0.4341709018,
0.5211858153,
-0.6854711175,
0.619083941,
0.2314249277,
-0.0652747005,
-0.7553667426,
-1.0621453524,
0.396710664,
-0.3093996942,
-0.432992667,
0.1758527607,
-0.0351428315,
-0.3683153689,
-0.1672902554,
-0.1046849415,
0.0995310768,
-0.0129566863,
-0.1167152002,
0.3834412694,
-0.2823913395,
-0.0970930308,
0.158173427,
-0.1122261584,
0.2859036922,
-0.5074434876,
0.6413883567,
0.0155749265,
-0.4120465517,
-0.4157493114,
0.2767184973,
0.6016531587,
-0.0843092874,
1.177123189,
0.7223206162,
-0.3643027246,
-0.2796275616,
-0.7990227938,
-0.2968022525,
-0.4787674546,
0.4130519629,
-0.3968632817,
-0.6391166449,
0.7119445801,
0.1127434745,
-0.1426703036,
0.1238280386,
0.6405726671,
0.090918988,
0.9371724129,
0.556152463,
-0.0541182123,
0.2971494496,
-0.1880307347,
0.2871851027,
-0.8165697455,
-0.640247941,
-0.2827163041,
0.0031388048,
-0.3576654792,
-0.427018106,
0.3344556987,
0.2057443112,
0.1201043129,
-0.1347886175,
-0.1642418355,
0.6540580988,
0.5995648503,
0.4263355434,
0.33049348,
0.4880650043,
-0.338580966,
0.1229584962,
-0.7765235901,
-0.3060649931,
0.8609137535,
0.4453776181,
0.7939862013,
0.0254137497,
0.6423600912,
0.2890499234,
0.0200732667,
-0.6765762568,
0.497384578,
0.040442992,
-0.4094164371,
-0.4121778011,
-0.6584498286,
-0.4764862657,
0.3955608904,
-0.2184441388,
-0.66502738,
0.2651036382,
0.2575074434,
-0.4604635239,
0.5022139549,
-0.7887785435,
0.2209188789,
0.0777627826,
-0.2841871381,
-0.0486299098,
-0.6972122192,
0.4879383147,
0.0034830212,
0.2269137502,
0.1944470555,
0.0292919092,
0.5556394458,
-0.2420671731,
0.9929071665,
-0.1097709239,
-0.4689047635,
0.2418617308,
0.1327284425,
0.9338011742,
0.0793658793,
-0.4434457421,
-0.0488308631,
-0.0691720918,
-0.2847782075,
-0.6171849966,
0.5048469305,
-0.677770853,
-0.702039957,
-0.1695804596,
-0.5078744888,
-0.4396232665,
-0.0670298859,
0.4998311996,
0.6598469019,
0.1617846936,
0.3685700595,
0.8142517209,
-0.1871851236,
0.2387832254,
0.2664621174,
0.0989066586,
-0.4115720987,
0.9863139987,
0.071848765,
0.2829594314,
0.6742996573,
0.3631315529,
-0.5925570726,
-0.9412513375,
-0.1541791409,
0.0899493694,
-1.1243134737,
-0.3502525985,
-0.8493084311,
-0.2535960376,
-0.6384502649,
0.0090915225,
-0.224570632,
-0.378867656,
-0.3797686696,
-0.5297407508,
0.1461298615,
0.4110292792,
-0.4636249542,
0.0115787843,
-0.8894997835,
0.1673255563,
0.1989948899,
0.2781212032,
0.125852555,
-0.7019377351,
-0.3834618628,
-0.0535169505,
0.2363869846,
-0.6747353673,
0.3130850196,
0.1701141894,
0.6153306365,
0.3851076365,
0.2883179486,
0.6222337484,
-0.4524072409,
0.6236245632,
0.3447372615,
-0.8162056208,
0.2512203753,
-0.132113114,
0.0860493481,
0.5028897524,
0.0858305544,
-0.348336041,
-0.4635387659,
-0.445514679,
-0.9914451241,
0.6830043793,
0.1939098984,
0.2843490541,
0.0140394941,
0.3875403106,
0.338945508,
0.1263911724,
-0.6390687823,
-0.1510370672,
-0.0413801558,
-0.173746109,
-0.0805426463,
-0.5458675027,
-0.2351102829,
-0.2962674797,
0.7227362394,
-0.2215493917,
0.1574643701,
0.2100820839,
-0.0847991928,
0.0165701844,
0.3632923067,
0.5767251253,
0.6135283113,
-0.2770999968,
0.6519418955,
0.3558164537,
-0.5366387367,
0.1094163358,
0.0310138389,
-0.1764890999,
0.0123822363,
0.8929226398,
0.9240290523,
-0.2251531333,
-0.5249047279,
0.2659059167,
0.017884519,
-0.0038976278,
-0.0690293983,
0.156177029,
-0.1562110037,
0.5442888737,
0.5650174618,
0.1281220764,
0.3279793262,
-0.6663347483,
0.2459707558,
0.48073861,
-0.0286250506,
-0.4499497712,
0.454220593,
0.1050442904,
0.1828716248,
0.4607807696,
-0.1098949313,
-0.614543438,
0.5340627432,
0.6940783858,
0.9482944012,
0.1272291243,
0.4457141757,
0.1433217674,
0.4187117219,
-0.4382508993,
0.0940309539,
-0.1829858869,
-0.8724048138,
-0.7162359357,
-0.6176770329,
-0.2264364958,
0.3073345721,
-0.7755931616,
0.2232093811,
-0.425750196,
-0.0194622446,
-0.4848124981,
-0.082999818,
-0.4151745737,
0.4472833872,
0.6639384627,
0.9393362999,
-0.8062517643,
0.7189890146,
0.5092152953,
0.0952093825,
-0.7453932166,
0.3989472687,
-0.1342536956,
-0.7659425139,
0.5800405145,
0.0978303179,
-0.5471785069,
-0.0386517383,
-0.7501436472,
-0.9338575602,
0.9846725464,
0.8991419077,
-0.4770279527,
-0.1908611059,
-0.0427367911,
0.4609733522,
-0.3816078007,
0.4602946341,
0.7204514742,
0.2969954312,
0.4512461424,
-0.4923069477,
0.3221401274,
-0.0717641562,
0.0738564879,
-0.3466237783,
-0.5469070077,
0.684066236,
-0.3712885678,
-0.1854497045,
-0.1807590127,
0.8663529754,
0.515642941,
0.3521543741,
0.5627347827,
0.4489982128,
1.0242801905,
0.271966368,
1.0862854719,
-0.3025556803,
0.3732939661,
1.1436146498,
-0.1975198835,
0.8528584242,
0.4794131219,
-0.0125891343,
0.5459069014,
0.7194570303,
0.2026826739,
0.8142946362,
0.0363435522,
-0.2848675251,
-0.5393391848,
-0.0708041191,
-0.4939756989,
0.3976627886,
0.3385962844,
-0.3184390664,
-0.1745142788,
-0.1277251244,
0.0440729596,
-0.271058172,
-0.1700837761,
0.6778132915,
-0.0245979615,
-0.5926045775,
0.7595028877,
0.0924496055,
0.543361485,
-0.4186062515,
-0.0966858119,
-0.2780151963,
0.0275491122,
-0.3720100522,
-0.7426301241,
0.0482042655,
-0.0656865239,
-0.258177191,
-0.0988536179,
0.7619290352,
-0.4816268682,
-0.5376476049,
0.2760764956,
0.3514503837,
0.0706608742,
-0.1686778516,
-0.518048048,
0.3549514413,
0.0431833528,
-0.5386508107,
-0.0527364351,
0.7107412219,
0.2636788189,
0.6993032098,
0.8560976982,
0.362323314,
0.2215041071,
0.1919056773,
1.0411684513,
-0.5820992589,
-0.6809900403,
-1.3092330694,
0.4220857918,
-0.0940338224,
-0.0036285366,
0.6907522678,
0.4861317277,
0.7583700418,
0.0202221386,
0.8369889855,
0.1476660818,
0.056271717,
-1.2473231554,
0.4335432649,
-0.3426923752,
0.6922202706,
-0.1584140807,
-0.9230942726,
-0.4599000812,
0.3586451411,
-0.1007908285,
0.0468340255,
0.6326076388,
0.7603058219,
-0.1071259752,
0.0183647443,
0.4716532528,
0.4237677455,
0.389062494,
0.3729337454,
1.1141010523,
-0.0588036403,
0.4146612883,
-0.1433672905,
-0.3478707969,
-0.3024068773,
-0.9277454019,
-1.0128570795,
-0.5374882817,
-0.2984986901,
-0.5936022997,
-0.0360295773,
1.1668510437,
0.7812097073,
-0.8424909115,
0.0488450043,
0.0370292962,
0.1521722376,
-0.1568188965,
-0.1791072339,
0.3829304874,
-0.422373414,
-0.4546085894,
0.4744723439,
0.2138588279,
-0.0499914624,
-0.214944154,
-0.0851998329,
0.0581609234,
0.2887782156,
0.930817008,
-0.0110188946,
-0.5678681731,
-0.28434816,
-0.1084810942,
-0.0693468526,
0.0482144617,
0.9275974631,
-0.6837393045,
0.1404999346,
0.7408276796,
0.8143187165,
0.263276279,
-0.0199616775,
0.5907981992,
-0.8313871026,
0.0886011422,
0.1066606715,
0.3095640838,
0.5254546404,
-0.657223165,
0.2659778297,
0.3604579568,
-0.2347302288,
-1.1685243845,
0.1572240293,
-0.7077163458,
-0.3459312916,
1.5484012365,
-0.0624209344,
-0.3847226202,
-0.034557499,
-0.0349405371,
0.2560639083,
-0.379368037,
0.9504171014,
0.9769546986,
-0.0882473215,
-0.3216933906,
-0.3655653894,
0.5357441306,
0.4110034406,
-0.7681005001,
0.4210418761,
0.5161750317,
0.1130248457,
0.0990496501,
0.5255467892,
0.0438421741,
0.0653302446,
0.0055526639,
-0.3699965775,
-0.1450876594,
-0.6503024101,
-0.4888685048,
0.1412907243,
0.0696456358,
-0.0531849936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09336v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09336v1
|
Self-Selected Attention Span for Accelerating Large Language Model Inference
| 2024-04-14T19:36:04 | 2024-04-14T19:36:04 |
Tian Jin, Wanzin Yazar, Zifei Xu, Sayeh Sharify, Xin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) can solve challenging tasks. However, their
inference computation on modern GPUs is highly inefficient due to the
increasing number of tokens they must attend to as they generate new ones. To
address this inefficiency, we capitalize on LLMs' problem-solving capabilities
to optimize their own inference-time efficiency. We demonstrate with two
specific tasks: (a) evaluating complex arithmetic expressions and (b)
summarizing news articles. For both tasks, we create custom datasets to
fine-tune an LLM. The goal of fine-tuning is twofold: first, to make the LLM
learn to solve the evaluation or summarization task, and second, to train it to
identify the minimal attention spans required for each step of the task. As a
result, the fine-tuned model is able to convert these self-identified minimal
attention spans into sparse attention masks on-the-fly during inference. We
develop a custom CUDA kernel to take advantage of the reduced context to attend
to. We demonstrate that using this custom CUDA kernel improves the throughput
of LLM inference by 28%. Our work presents an end-to-end demonstration showing
that training LLMs to self-select their attention spans speeds up
autoregressive inference in solving real-world tasks.
|
[
-0.4762126207,
-1.0529397726,
0.767508924,
0.4464685023,
-0.2351656556,
-0.0181410518,
-0.4016578496,
-0.4788623452,
0.1905005276,
0.3848242462,
-0.4758430123,
-0.069146879,
-0.542738378,
0.1037130058,
-0.0456923991,
0.7548979521,
0.1787404269,
-0.3661834896,
-0.2472330928,
0.0794654787,
-0.1609808803,
-0.1902740598,
-0.8582470417,
-0.147912547,
0.5059363246,
0.4431579113,
0.3984726667,
0.9004973173,
0.3432127237,
0.2590381205,
-0.2221461236,
0.3088921905,
-0.4349833429,
0.0580095053,
0.1306100637,
-0.1928948313,
-0.3627116382,
-0.0624777675,
0.6238408089,
0.7166488171,
0.0362767838,
0.4483045936,
-0.0305534434,
0.6140864491,
-0.9401359558,
0.11020457,
-0.6816616654,
0.1052777469,
-0.243657425,
0.1078276262,
-0.3893270493,
-0.1697625965,
-0.0094128801,
-0.6214014888,
0.213437736,
0.039575424,
0.4595727921,
0.7041735053,
-0.199632749,
0.2463619411,
-0.4278119802,
0.7210723162,
-0.7884157896,
0.4511033297,
0.3953205347,
0.1334803104,
-0.0469722748,
-0.6201756001,
-0.4202138782,
-0.2532760203,
0.0114883911,
0.0505957715,
-0.1603618711,
0.0577016287,
0.512257874,
0.3180576265,
-0.4398112595,
0.364782691,
-0.3574104905,
-0.0868112668,
0.5515062809,
0.2685918808,
-0.0337493047,
0.0516615137,
-0.0361639298,
0.1811639667,
-0.5997231603,
-0.0590507202,
0.3189243078,
0.0565426797,
-0.1019831374,
0.4882222414,
-0.4367969334,
0.8490870595,
0.385104537,
0.1262601912,
0.1896171868,
-0.1105467975,
-0.6280287504,
-0.0550072826,
0.727743268,
0.0272869002,
0.2812044919,
-0.249252975,
-0.1331490874,
0.182796672,
0.0783774182,
-0.8166364431,
-0.2071844339,
0.1226872355,
-0.185511291,
-0.0336191282,
-0.465892911,
-0.6938365102,
-0.0207520034,
-0.2177685052,
0.2007169724,
0.0478499681,
-0.024860261,
0.2478659898,
0.0093925614,
0.0033879478,
0.3071319163,
-1.2556176186,
0.2676864862,
0.4372941256,
0.8404302001,
-0.4791679382,
-0.0751048028,
-1.0111193657,
0.2489939332,
-0.33298558,
0.890887022,
-0.7391524911,
-0.203301847,
-0.4068288207,
-0.1599955857,
-0.2900817692,
-0.5509132743,
0.5602481365,
-0.5499398708,
-0.1792224497,
-0.069988206,
-0.6346766949,
0.210923776,
0.0810211524,
-0.6936549544,
1.1557260752,
0.143776089,
-0.684232831,
0.0559972189,
-0.6291363239,
-0.6952073574,
0.035796795,
-0.0780852064,
-0.4700193405,
0.34506163,
0.5947033763,
0.5627931952,
-0.1446763426,
0.0415791683,
-0.534976244,
-0.2119519114,
-0.1199526787,
-0.3681794703,
0.6281073093,
0.4304670095,
-0.2641818523,
0.1563545614,
-0.6464368105,
-0.1165282205,
-0.0693317726,
-0.4124963582,
-0.3937093318,
-0.0664474145,
-0.1895001233,
0.1139318421,
0.3968604803,
-0.495770812,
0.1654839069,
-0.5162470341,
0.582957983,
0.665496707,
-0.0597247891,
0.42789644,
-0.033181753,
0.5573788881,
-0.1541424841,
0.1464167237,
-0.1844464988,
-0.3104607761,
-0.9707301259,
-0.359392941,
0.0980099291,
0.2783337831,
-0.4661432803,
0.2400134653,
-0.0109912921,
-0.2733731568,
-0.6726090312,
0.4345290959,
0.3052898645,
0.8564422131,
0.3930713236,
-0.0209168121,
-0.3812233508,
-0.9909678698,
-0.2197510898,
0.0832815319,
-0.0254476368,
0.4117403626,
0.3226387203,
-0.157542184,
0.7686418891,
-0.6529004574,
-0.1977802217,
-0.2790237665,
0.0123520391,
0.2322604954,
0.3298846781,
0.3608796299,
-0.5474364161,
-0.4948719442,
-0.1419964135,
-0.4821096957,
-0.5530263186,
-0.1446374059,
-0.2135311514,
0.2934603691,
0.8869120479,
-0.5489170551,
0.1327960044,
0.4708610773,
-0.4609576464,
0.6317685246,
-0.3986360729,
-0.1654669791,
-0.6801558733,
0.0401212312,
0.1998681426,
-0.3402738571,
-0.3019351363,
0.0031036644,
0.3631998003,
0.2220722288,
-0.3237702549,
0.9233413339,
-0.6321627498,
-0.3031448722,
-0.347773701,
0.2241409123,
-0.1182617992,
0.6798079014,
0.0670339391,
0.9227061868,
0.4504656196,
-0.75224334,
-0.0656199902,
0.2050554752,
-0.4638269246,
0.1621860117,
-0.6585127115,
0.1574939042,
0.0322789997,
-0.147014901,
-1.0081591606,
-0.218382597,
-0.0776058286,
-0.1656702161,
0.1886581033,
0.026805371,
-0.4607857168,
-0.4442105293,
-0.1072415337,
0.3445246518,
0.3927095234,
-0.603862524,
0.6843360662,
0.6188439727,
-0.2058239281,
-0.4703944623,
-0.7378566265,
0.0393638201,
-0.0876216888,
-0.3092879653,
0.2153657824,
-0.3194716871,
-0.2710551023,
-0.1842963547,
-0.1740480065,
0.1097251698,
0.3716457784,
0.1292655468,
0.1801631153,
-0.1541718841,
0.185095489,
0.3587534726,
-0.072558403,
0.1129757538,
0.0292001236,
0.3165430427,
-0.0589479469,
-0.1526066214,
-0.3330237269,
0.1583523601,
0.5650321841,
-0.563326478,
0.2269979119,
0.491971612,
-0.188267827,
-0.2254332453,
-0.8936522007,
-0.2900684774,
-0.4564381242,
0.4555645585,
-0.3714975119,
-1.0926091671,
0.3435101807,
0.1314440519,
0.2341005802,
0.4889879227,
0.8511270285,
0.1011430323,
0.927624166,
0.5849213004,
-0.3658270836,
0.6124756336,
-0.1602273732,
-0.1404648125,
-1.1061314344,
0.0057689431,
-0.3662139177,
-0.1964616477,
-0.1463927627,
-0.449048996,
0.304549396,
-0.3368341029,
-0.2558930814,
0.0403132252,
-0.3418402076,
0.7506628633,
0.4983335137,
0.1218767017,
0.4308253527,
0.0284764636,
-0.0578913428,
-0.0666936561,
-0.71304667,
-0.1289204955,
0.9589884877,
0.3257995844,
0.9979208708,
-0.141759783,
0.2599632442,
0.2422987819,
0.5389646888,
-0.7053464055,
0.4814432561,
-0.2878035903,
-0.477830261,
-0.3838613927,
-0.4624451399,
-0.7063180208,
0.3246139884,
-0.0754080862,
-0.6610069275,
-0.0280685555,
0.3559562862,
-0.7027745247,
0.0791188851,
-0.8863309026,
0.9989551902,
-0.0651529357,
-0.5742461681,
-0.5422492623,
-0.5566390753,
0.3714417219,
-0.1545791477,
0.0134706805,
-0.3476313055,
-0.0576752163,
0.6371579766,
0.0023919046,
1.0294210911,
0.0344381742,
-0.111623764,
0.0888097733,
0.0932839364,
0.5672855377,
0.1479806304,
-0.1449389458,
-0.0901039466,
-0.4984076917,
-0.2334801853,
-0.4432217777,
0.8777135015,
-0.5604420304,
-0.8854526877,
-0.1987659633,
-0.9125438333,
-0.3943351209,
0.1967752427,
-0.1121203601,
0.1686459184,
-0.0175689328,
0.0580055043,
0.8000971079,
0.0481473058,
0.8657628894,
0.6086773872,
0.0938654989,
-0.3349894285,
0.5129345059,
0.0939965099,
0.4026267231,
0.3784127831,
0.1716852933,
-0.421520263,
-0.5202938914,
-0.6253087521,
0.3781535923,
-0.5224025249,
-0.0740553588,
-0.9447543025,
-0.0511502773,
-0.4025606513,
-0.1103829518,
-0.2489725202,
-0.4518917501,
-0.514811039,
-0.0498620272,
0.1593518406,
0.2853422761,
0.1973406971,
0.4942081273,
-0.4726998508,
0.6118733287,
0.6056025028,
0.2360214591,
0.058071401,
-0.8182278275,
-0.3431817889,
-0.2911646068,
-0.331122756,
-0.4948064983,
0.5296123624,
0.3483690619,
0.6408464909,
0.2985368073,
-0.0387136787,
0.9232897162,
-0.5146505237,
0.2588578165,
-0.1534312814,
-0.8584483862,
0.3495711386,
-0.1532345116,
0.6336565614,
0.3703146875,
0.1413353086,
-0.286811471,
-0.7254962921,
-0.464732796,
-0.6632826328,
0.5168964267,
0.159811005,
0.0813590586,
-0.2164302468,
0.5320560932,
-0.0794347227,
0.0333184674,
-0.5255279541,
-0.200549826,
0.2913782299,
-0.2576090097,
-0.309068054,
-0.3750697672,
0.1624774635,
-0.3897401989,
0.571919024,
-0.3927110136,
-0.0142466621,
0.307834506,
-0.4050559998,
-0.2752601504,
0.0546231605,
0.6442419887,
0.762158215,
-0.0183554459,
0.2400708795,
0.5333666205,
-0.5053707957,
-0.2476932257,
0.2986034155,
-0.0597024746,
-0.1171897799,
0.143209964,
0.8575990796,
0.314350754,
-0.8001940846,
0.1842992455,
-0.132146284,
0.1009915769,
-0.2608108222,
0.2795217335,
0.3810067475,
0.529063344,
0.5793373585,
-0.1990653425,
0.1913738549,
-0.0986477509,
0.0964484215,
0.6380134225,
-0.0222397242,
-0.1296866536,
1.0513238907,
0.145854637,
-0.0811613128,
0.4306875467,
-0.035398405,
-0.1941558421,
0.9089302421,
0.6931166053,
0.9711877108,
-0.2583256364,
-0.1045614704,
0.3559905291,
0.3307973146,
-0.0782553777,
0.1162320003,
-0.2682954073,
-0.5329324603,
-0.8873625994,
-0.8268615007,
-0.3734380007,
0.2425455302,
-0.3904591203,
0.0750559494,
-0.3394636512,
-0.0798960999,
0.3195916712,
0.0573833659,
-0.3242503703,
0.2047194093,
0.3030897379,
1.0229537487,
-0.8438926339,
0.8401039839,
0.3302491605,
0.1184853688,
-0.4497068226,
-0.2061260343,
-0.4897888005,
-0.8202232718,
0.7845107913,
0.2198953182,
-0.1331668496,
0.2767803073,
-0.5121142268,
-0.7029516697,
0.7170280814,
0.7779120207,
-1.0168961287,
-0.0139191644,
-0.2215506434,
0.4596709609,
-0.5278210044,
0.2045081407,
0.7624004483,
0.4026385546,
-0.0297310129,
-0.8557608724,
-0.0807449222,
-0.0627194196,
-0.0100296624,
0.3032896817,
-0.6280701756,
0.735406816,
-0.5595812798,
0.1175760925,
-0.1751703322,
0.9573256373,
0.2931147814,
0.2255373597,
0.6246480346,
0.8960350752,
0.5612380505,
0.1283462644,
0.9792038798,
-0.4244993627,
0.3671512306,
1.3099088669,
-0.0100501776,
0.8840245008,
0.6603682041,
-0.046605017,
0.0837507322,
0.7636182308,
-0.06065429,
0.4633437395,
-0.0915140659,
-0.3987187743,
-0.7893362045,
0.11192967,
-0.0053543258,
0.0847908035,
0.5831394196,
-0.4202269018,
-0.3648932278,
0.0022073404,
0.0204539504,
-0.1323530972,
-0.6235799193,
0.5953864455,
0.2010133862,
-0.8549089432,
0.4388896525,
-0.1339548528,
0.5113341212,
-0.5003471375,
0.1024482697,
-0.3869570494,
0.3075530529,
-0.0473155528,
-0.6781474352,
0.3052119017,
-0.0344210938,
-0.19576478,
-0.1564471722,
0.5496683121,
-0.5361019373,
-0.5676344633,
0.1162007153,
0.4467665851,
0.0406651385,
-0.2649210393,
-0.5010948181,
0.0130941747,
-0.0933644772,
-0.5258870125,
0.268101424,
0.3229753077,
-0.180928275,
0.9590872526,
0.6206275821,
0.1158640012,
0.1911121458,
0.1200827733,
0.8980545402,
-0.5576224923,
-0.631218195,
-1.1773844957,
0.0408417247,
-0.0148995118,
-0.4035412073,
0.7840486169,
0.8733779192,
0.6442703605,
-0.1929849833,
0.7294304371,
0.0819022357,
0.2815073729,
-0.532761693,
0.5684229732,
-0.5471423268,
0.1181439459,
0.0537286252,
-0.6759341359,
-0.3408894837,
0.548573792,
-0.5087932348,
-0.0300583374,
0.4542766809,
0.6755597591,
-0.3066829145,
-0.4003029466,
0.4496770501,
0.4307191372,
0.1368288547,
0.7523843646,
0.3502332866,
-0.0143312113,
0.5023091435,
-0.2399466336,
-0.0832937136,
-0.288184166,
-0.9542664289,
-1.159881115,
-0.266998142,
-0.4548094571,
-0.0551280081,
0.0571986847,
0.8138155341,
0.7423027754,
-0.6171717644,
-0.1887497753,
-0.1203944534,
0.0877576023,
-0.1626914889,
-0.1741323024,
0.5020299554,
-0.7808940411,
-1.0289622545,
0.3934172094,
0.4261130095,
-0.0047517759,
-0.3043663204,
0.0557157844,
-0.1917458624,
-0.0614255741,
0.7107447386,
0.4445614219,
-0.5806382895,
-0.0970913842,
0.1298140138,
-0.1673840433,
0.2331990153,
0.7039794922,
-0.9601342678,
0.3778201342,
0.3846163154,
0.977615118,
0.9884456992,
-0.0571794435,
0.3681744039,
-0.6246731281,
0.1755430102,
0.1665074974,
0.4659568369,
0.2143126875,
-0.4226251245,
0.472899437,
0.2058943957,
-0.6262128353,
-0.7227069736,
0.0974138379,
-0.9928195477,
-0.3056295514,
1.2242357731,
-0.0156879723,
-0.563583672,
-0.1733408272,
-0.2116519213,
0.1958992779,
-0.3841694891,
0.9738388062,
0.4389385283,
-0.2145080268,
-0.365888238,
-0.7810029387,
0.4529491067,
0.6986147761,
-0.9250789285,
0.4252838492,
0.4479312897,
0.4848612249,
-0.1813491136,
0.6198132038,
0.1539038122,
0.3540011644,
-0.3873873949,
-0.0089092795,
-0.2495318204,
-0.267056793,
-0.327226758,
0.0483330414,
-0.0376040488,
-0.0973432735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09329v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09329v2
|
Large Language Models are as persuasive as humans, but how? About the cognitive effort and moral-emotional language of LLM arguments
| 2024-04-14T19:01:20 | 2024-04-21T07:07:08 |
Carlos Carrasco-Farre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are already as persuasive as humans. However, we
know very little about how they do it. This paper investigates the persuasion
strategies of LLMs, comparing them with human-generated arguments. Using a
dataset of 1,251 participants in an experiment, we analyze the persuasion
strategies of LLM-generated and human-generated arguments using measures of
cognitive effort (lexical and grammatical complexity) and moral-emotional
language (sentiment and moral analysis). The study reveals that LLMs produce
arguments that require higher cognitive effort, exhibiting more complex
grammatical and lexical structures than human counterparts. Additionally, LLMs
demonstrate a significant propensity to engage more deeply with moral language,
utilizing both positive and negative moral foundations more frequently than
humans. In contrast with previous research, no significant difference was found
in the emotional content produced by LLMs and humans. These findings contribute
to the discourse on AI and persuasion, highlighting the dual potential of LLMs
to both enhance and undermine informational integrity through communication
strategies for digital persuasion.
|
[
-0.4328635931,
-1.1530969143,
0.8677449822,
-0.0024516354,
-0.3355571032,
0.1708613485,
-0.7346387506,
-0.0419935025,
-0.1103430018,
0.3975602984,
-0.6055290103,
-0.5865380764,
-0.3773028553,
0.2116669714,
-0.0841829479,
0.923193574,
0.2054327875,
0.2927557826,
-0.5334120989,
0.133639127,
-0.1683670282,
-0.8658452034,
-0.7631752491,
-0.6222116351,
0.743514061,
0.4090494514,
0.6833016872,
0.4372911155,
0.3448428214,
0.3794026375,
-0.1814673692,
-0.0966235697,
-0.4982776046,
0.0183721129,
-0.3893119097,
-0.7218903899,
-0.2113669962,
0.1853332222,
0.2754794061,
0.2494366616,
-0.009821781,
0.1393990964,
-0.1256937832,
0.7946377397,
-0.4947184324,
-0.0185991246,
-0.7038913369,
-0.0424990356,
-0.3709924519,
-0.387809366,
-0.5497597456,
-0.4930348396,
0.054591611,
-0.3457853198,
-0.1884624362,
-0.0381071344,
0.7823588848,
0.1356817186,
-0.6210554838,
-0.8016859293,
-0.6973504424,
1.0902392864,
-0.8493076563,
0.0403251536,
0.3605087698,
-0.2095245272,
-0.0962546915,
-0.3562379479,
-0.7274552584,
-0.581448555,
0.2554452121,
0.1125093251,
-0.3004432917,
0.1350506097,
0.1871368587,
-0.1019641161,
-0.2854745388,
0.4771588147,
-0.1184871793,
-0.0480634347,
1.0156948566,
0.2493670136,
0.356723696,
-0.3943728507,
-0.2177522629,
-0.4997760057,
-0.7953407764,
0.1912771463,
0.6544374228,
-0.0654071942,
-0.1564332694,
0.7709902525,
0.2650508583,
0.3359805346,
0.2991555333,
-0.1320235133,
-0.338545084,
-0.2288003564,
-0.2572266161,
0.1558870375,
1.1133217812,
0.4481779337,
0.7513606548,
0.304657042,
-0.1791215986,
0.3858341277,
0.3369608819,
-0.5976169705,
-0.0164082609,
0.2180578113,
-0.6387675405,
-0.4824173748,
-0.0627932549,
-0.5889048576,
-0.6465252638,
-0.2134266943,
0.2693273723,
-0.3914621472,
-0.1077005491,
0.3551854491,
-0.0094682164,
0.3577955961,
0.3396866024,
-0.7799461484,
0.2207726985,
0.8820508718,
0.4099000096,
-0.1379419565,
0.1835462898,
-0.2573674321,
0.0573569164,
-0.7418103814,
0.7704033852,
-0.7017645836,
-0.4655562043,
-0.0075632976,
-0.2111048996,
0.1894759089,
-0.545799017,
0.9751467705,
-0.4186856151,
0.1848012805,
-0.502515316,
-0.5363981724,
-0.3972676992,
0.3248306811,
-0.3742247224,
0.3808299303,
-0.399828136,
-0.3998121321,
0.1437932253,
-0.888235569,
-0.5497450829,
-0.0886452124,
-0.3380596638,
-0.108922109,
0.3635829687,
0.1406824887,
0.6729301214,
-0.7518758774,
0.4174035788,
-0.280480653,
0.0434789583,
0.8268013,
-0.715313971,
0.6836046576,
0.1859082729,
-0.6207208037,
0.0496316701,
-0.2582404613,
-0.1743423194,
0.627684474,
-0.7018678188,
-0.5603458285,
0.5256262422,
-0.2957586348,
0.1612036973,
0.3202071488,
-0.5431842804,
0.1426519006,
-0.3272002935,
0.7162488699,
1.0274908543,
-0.2242984027,
0.2340357006,
-0.24265939,
0.4842728674,
-0.1771758497,
0.0432666577,
0.1335350871,
-0.3149536252,
-0.7601037621,
-0.0179897882,
-0.3052447438,
0.4036724269,
-0.2694564164,
0.118993178,
-0.217460826,
-0.4856766164,
-0.2805730402,
0.0580806993,
0.4697497785,
0.2043453008,
0.0654795468,
0.1523030102,
-0.2394706607,
-0.9387004375,
-0.4272952974,
-0.6199337244,
0.0532707907,
0.5140054822,
0.3557285666,
-0.0527806655,
0.5801997781,
-0.2325076759,
0.2147789448,
-0.2515607476,
0.1688615531,
0.0975075588,
0.0024723434,
0.5097920299,
-0.8102687001,
-0.3303757608,
-0.1107766107,
-0.9671939015,
-0.0482910238,
-0.2902587652,
0.1187453717,
0.3277206421,
0.4322514832,
-0.650806725,
0.2077275217,
0.4289259017,
-0.426756829,
0.5570774674,
0.0264293347,
0.2557877302,
-0.8321548104,
-0.5495958328,
0.2304314822,
0.0078010191,
-0.5867821574,
0.0272443034,
-0.1996726096,
0.0047465381,
-0.65405792,
0.4883223474,
-0.4582195878,
0.3568439484,
-0.1470001638,
0.2080187351,
-0.0450334735,
0.1732674539,
0.1112734228,
0.5695946813,
0.4499130547,
-0.6627927423,
0.5831828117,
0.0335603952,
-0.138340801,
0.7866460681,
-0.9088590145,
0.2733976841,
-0.1833221763,
0.294980973,
-1.0295929909,
-0.1327212453,
-0.0339039266,
-0.2974265814,
0.1896262765,
0.0903415605,
-0.300830394,
-0.506303966,
-0.4510817528,
0.1319866627,
0.4736253023,
-0.3197360337,
0.6812253594,
0.2494269758,
-0.3779821694,
-0.305947274,
-0.7814472914,
0.611608088,
-0.590389967,
-0.9608738422,
0.3047562242,
-0.1563914716,
-0.9564034343,
-0.2158576697,
0.3344040215,
0.415689379,
0.1438045651,
0.4170107245,
0.2432421595,
-0.2999403775,
0.3887678385,
-0.2351216227,
0.0844506845,
0.422051847,
-0.0662446842,
0.8426170349,
-0.437843293,
-0.5755087137,
-0.6160901785,
0.4389902651,
0.6999936104,
-0.0287909284,
0.6804230809,
0.2224062532,
-0.0659017935,
0.2427610457,
-0.9217411876,
-0.4919124246,
-0.4996762276,
0.4121406376,
-0.2466915995,
-0.8149402142,
-0.151347816,
-0.2846956253,
0.3840799332,
0.4931691885,
0.7862048745,
-0.4391784966,
1.1397730112,
0.1806047112,
-0.0885655582,
0.3596267402,
-0.1977858394,
0.1114994884,
-0.6115794778,
-0.1189168617,
-0.5512605309,
-0.3174466193,
-0.3856391609,
-0.3299899399,
0.1803553402,
0.1347240657,
-0.6520997286,
-0.0478323102,
-0.5142207742,
0.1665273607,
0.4839830101,
-0.2036785781,
0.3007028699,
0.4261980355,
0.0141342273,
-0.2409067154,
-0.5640976429,
-1.151083231,
1.0170553923,
0.4107886851,
0.9528709054,
0.2787788808,
0.5845052004,
0.4736722708,
0.2952465415,
-0.9731304049,
0.9590103626,
-0.3466573656,
-0.4111799598,
-0.1665738672,
-0.3736821711,
-1.100494504,
-0.0857587755,
-0.6354516149,
-0.6841858625,
0.0533187427,
-0.0895509198,
0.0577828102,
0.5308101773,
-0.5608908534,
0.4357055724,
-0.7693271041,
-0.2941702008,
-0.760730207,
-0.2155080736,
0.1998841166,
-0.133540988,
0.4035474956,
-0.1293652505,
-0.1558779329,
0.8960393667,
-0.2708530128,
0.8380390406,
0.1038075536,
-0.5081305504,
0.4182683527,
0.0781349987,
0.7287403941,
-0.0799818859,
-0.3586238027,
0.2089102864,
-0.4914867878,
-0.1272054166,
-0.2953779995,
0.6123780012,
-0.7890110612,
-1.0026372671,
-0.0942312032,
-0.4184342325,
0.0313964188,
-0.1423561573,
0.2619532347,
0.398363471,
-0.5263681412,
0.4672664404,
0.6121208668,
-0.7092330456,
0.7267916203,
0.4181751013,
0.1870493591,
-0.4991398156,
1.0184434652,
-0.1691224724,
0.4979273975,
0.3460345268,
0.6922511458,
-0.5187696218,
-0.3033483922,
-0.3286423087,
0.5672850609,
-0.6170461774,
0.1756310165,
-0.6330784559,
0.1282578856,
-0.3886844516,
-0.6593383551,
-0.4937621355,
-0.1616312116,
-0.313986063,
0.0738006979,
0.4560053945,
1.0456197262,
0.0820618868,
0.1525492072,
-0.7179067731,
0.2214123905,
0.5221666098,
-0.2829709947,
0.0306107327,
-0.1760335118,
0.2748731971,
0.3423321545,
-0.4122915268,
-0.7801618576,
0.1348993331,
-0.1196919531,
0.3413767815,
0.6935542822,
0.2574113607,
0.5345782638,
-0.1836137772,
1.0303263664,
0.4433971941,
-0.9112377763,
0.2611911595,
-0.3230897188,
0.0510472134,
0.0921954662,
0.4173808694,
-0.327744782,
-0.2273030132,
-0.570971489,
-0.8077493906,
0.4836127162,
0.10353183,
0.4732217789,
-0.1896394789,
0.1329755634,
-0.2434904873,
0.2169805318,
-0.8948100805,
-0.0861612186,
0.0268244445,
-0.314937979,
-0.0639881864,
-0.3577982187,
-0.4365017712,
0.0994276851,
0.447085917,
-0.0013576429,
0.038680926,
0.1996411234,
0.0849185437,
-0.1126097515,
0.4571395814,
0.6424868107,
0.2077856809,
0.2742592692,
0.0390174277,
-0.0239278451,
-0.3443877995,
0.5017156601,
-0.3012520075,
-0.1053326577,
-0.4168691635,
0.6997653842,
0.8717116714,
-0.1427047104,
-0.7909238338,
0.4090673625,
-0.3099476695,
-0.4795170128,
-0.3213628531,
0.0039271428,
0.8045835495,
0.5130435824,
0.30082196,
-0.4433333576,
-0.4579108357,
-0.8963453174,
-0.539018333,
0.8161357641,
-0.1412951201,
-0.1338251829,
0.6562275887,
0.3605513275,
-0.666447103,
0.5280995369,
0.131918177,
-0.3801366985,
0.6197181344,
0.4672323465,
0.6499183774,
0.00690185,
0.3403533697,
0.095840022,
0.1570260525,
0.0021734021,
0.1294452995,
-0.0155622642,
-0.6951863766,
-0.2888020277,
-0.3337611854,
-0.2694056332,
0.1146129742,
-0.2737462819,
0.1618617624,
-0.6148272753,
-0.4268901348,
0.104409717,
0.0941533595,
-0.383602798,
0.2146369815,
0.3008493483,
0.4955917299,
-0.432838738,
0.247062847,
0.9535965919,
-0.2761265337,
-0.7574730515,
0.1050674543,
0.2190440893,
-0.575673461,
0.6418713927,
-0.0032285219,
-0.431463927,
-0.1029379815,
-0.9197202921,
-0.5395919085,
0.703553021,
0.6947111487,
-0.6573846936,
0.0489648357,
0.1521226019,
0.4067952931,
-0.4630394876,
0.0511010662,
0.1126978695,
0.8526613712,
-0.0921903402,
-0.4128704071,
0.2138825208,
-0.0665924773,
-0.1778565347,
-0.0439283364,
-0.8083595037,
0.7780937552,
-0.5432294011,
-0.4726773202,
-0.0585480928,
0.7066227198,
0.3350845277,
0.2800734937,
0.7699800134,
0.1006509587,
0.7197322845,
0.0454429239,
1.2104263306,
-0.1212548241,
-0.1308409572,
0.5518786907,
-0.4053246379,
0.7123552561,
0.4094853103,
-0.1029293463,
0.6635656357,
0.5600357652,
0.04397754,
-0.1125100628,
0.5375329852,
-0.3303330243,
-0.6978101134,
-0.3161818981,
-0.0758676156,
0.5216466188,
0.5096774697,
-0.1292814761,
0.224511832,
-0.0311324205,
0.457292825,
0.4037781656,
-0.1348719001,
1.053319931,
0.2900436819,
-0.8545427322,
0.7309515476,
0.1605743468,
0.7910358906,
-0.5591762066,
0.2039505392,
0.1351029277,
-0.0474437438,
-0.2135202587,
-1.0041048527,
-0.1000432521,
0.3103990257,
-0.0161833744,
-0.0107474439,
0.6884489059,
-0.0919539183,
-0.3282674551,
0.4408278167,
0.3757945299,
0.217598781,
-0.0032242343,
-0.7331981063,
-0.0807137936,
0.1173426285,
-0.5122748017,
0.2753296494,
0.3208406866,
-0.2318552434,
1.0056376457,
1.0263326168,
0.2188985348,
-0.2892096937,
0.1884509176,
0.767200768,
-0.9082659483,
0.069795236,
-1.3959164619,
0.3288363516,
-0.2340412885,
-0.0275172945,
0.5810723305,
0.1629231274,
0.4941884279,
-0.037858773,
0.7381013632,
0.0661322251,
-0.2348655164,
-0.5598369837,
0.4840535223,
-0.6737792492,
0.2634852231,
-0.4750153124,
-0.8260570168,
0.1784290969,
0.6042000651,
-0.279741019,
0.102583766,
0.5392452478,
0.7242683768,
0.2845146358,
0.1321799308,
0.2033382207,
0.5190616846,
0.6098340154,
0.7284638286,
1.1992864609,
0.2648313046,
0.5355804563,
0.1954288185,
-0.1788151264,
-0.0877194554,
-1.1123429537,
-1.1033573151,
-0.2564364672,
-0.3116935492,
-0.1746891439,
0.0249598585,
1.0780881643,
0.5713735223,
-0.2616251111,
-0.4677530825,
-0.0631329194,
0.1653127968,
0.0861584395,
-0.2064567655,
0.3070127964,
0.1109809875,
-0.8577327728,
0.4679570794,
0.4623014033,
-0.05155655,
-0.5523225665,
-0.2448480874,
-0.3333854079,
0.7529590726,
0.7683224678,
0.0664579496,
-1.0939400196,
-0.1565184891,
-0.0904157534,
-0.2659870386,
0.0368590504,
0.7977260947,
-0.4377213717,
0.1281070858,
0.5247120261,
0.4033786356,
0.1154137924,
0.1572364569,
0.7686348557,
-0.0615911372,
-0.1163155511,
0.2129352391,
0.3166810572,
0.4441430867,
-0.3383662403,
0.336872071,
0.1423110664,
-0.5762156248,
-0.4275092483,
0.2399767637,
-0.768006146,
-0.4886591733,
1.5298314095,
0.0500526465,
-0.2251496017,
-0.0049909703,
-0.5329460502,
0.0820832923,
-0.5952880979,
0.6509493589,
0.9193383455,
0.0096544446,
0.1833162457,
-0.3167048395,
0.2217611521,
0.5976145864,
-0.8273383975,
0.2822214961,
0.5336820483,
0.072943151,
0.1856533438,
0.5674928427,
-0.2270502448,
-0.093229562,
-0.2239557505,
0.0335817449,
0.0440756194,
-0.0988176242,
-0.1783745587,
0.1963264346,
0.1112795621,
0.3640000224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09299v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09299v1
|
Reap the Wild Wind: Detecting Media Storms in Large-Scale News Corpora
| 2024-04-14T16:47:38 | 2024-04-14T16:47:38 |
Dror K. Markus, Effi Levi, Tamir Sheafer, Shaul R. Shenhav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Media Storms, dramatic outbursts of attention to a story, are central
components of media dynamics and the attention landscape. Despite their
significance, there has been little systematic and empirical research on this
concept due to issues of measurement and operationalization. We introduce an
iterative human-in-the-loop method to identify media storms in a large-scale
corpus of news articles. The text is first transformed into signals of
dispersion based on several textual characteristics. In each iteration, we
apply unsupervised anomaly detection to these signals; each anomaly is then
validated by an expert to confirm the presence of a storm, and those results
are then used to tune the anomaly detection in the next iteration. We
demonstrate the applicability of this method in two scenarios: first,
supplementing an initial list of media storms within a specific time frame; and
second, detecting media storms in new time periods. We make available a media
storm dataset compiled using both scenarios. Both the method and dataset offer
the basis for comprehensive empirical research into the concept of media
storms, including characterizing them and predicting their outbursts and
durations, in mainstream media or social media platforms.
|
[
-0.5976090431,
-1.0076973438,
0.48381266,
0.7182440162,
-0.4793805182,
0.625592947,
-0.2707323134,
-0.0750829875,
0.6817468405,
0.4011760354,
-0.8368217945,
-0.4762048721,
-0.8455755115,
-0.0403967313,
-0.9521278739,
0.8591236472,
-0.0824441686,
-0.6358074546,
0.4328732789,
0.1627987474,
-0.1933281422,
-0.2729074061,
-0.1436418146,
0.2343982458,
0.7079586983,
0.2581015825,
0.7231981754,
0.364000082,
0.8603197932,
0.2928096056,
-0.3108456731,
0.4637472928,
-0.494281143,
0.1859377921,
-0.4216543436,
0.0717787072,
0.1571052074,
0.1385107934,
0.82253474,
0.4832314551,
-0.2705195248,
0.370744735,
0.0534601659,
0.5223771334,
-0.7213585377,
-0.4420517981,
-0.865865171,
0.1346500069,
-0.6938562989,
-0.9684146643,
-0.2556993663,
0.083746314,
-0.0090298597,
-0.3877504468,
0.5704792738,
0.1764515936,
0.9859419465,
0.2698400617,
-0.6877527833,
-0.3758221865,
-1.0733931065,
0.7305644751,
-0.0632595122,
0.366903156,
0.166831851,
0.2698174417,
-0.5661463141,
-0.4591093659,
-0.5240299702,
0.0705859214,
0.3091711402,
0.1945480108,
-0.8950817585,
-0.3751402795,
-0.0094652986,
0.493031472,
-0.5427210331,
0.1583146453,
-0.6536040306,
-0.1176520512,
0.6591336727,
0.2928087115,
0.0122193107,
-0.3230914772,
-0.4054775834,
0.0250242967,
-0.3826630712,
-0.044782754,
0.4832735658,
0.0508696772,
-0.2595276237,
0.363620013,
0.0986021683,
0.442335546,
0.0663841292,
-0.5047680736,
0.1720259339,
-0.2248524278,
-0.1802237779,
0.1518999934,
0.9074355364,
0.4546719193,
-0.2465123385,
-0.035517104,
-0.3192860782,
-0.0836078376,
0.4176060855,
-0.3978702128,
0.0471630618,
0.0895057246,
-0.5122835636,
-0.8751521707,
0.0399400219,
-1.1776714325,
-0.7885722518,
-0.24597691,
0.3190583587,
0.1471778154,
-0.6212256551,
-0.0481853783,
-0.4835658073,
-0.3257789314,
-0.0178146921,
-0.4491897821,
-0.1179977357,
0.4489485323,
1.0669711828,
-0.119762361,
-0.3651589751,
-0.4527437687,
-0.1267114431,
-0.5233278275,
1.3437241316,
-0.4198550582,
-0.184024483,
0.2615451217,
0.1359874159,
-0.0034591283,
-0.3585805297,
0.7272350788,
-0.7488267422,
-0.1102554351,
0.1265569776,
-0.1947187185,
-0.1620383412,
0.237315014,
-0.6875112653,
0.5843176842,
0.244432345,
-1.0335009098,
0.4650443494,
-0.2944874465,
-0.5078448057,
-0.285571903,
0.2416225076,
-0.5682947636,
0.5330843925,
0.4133266211,
0.2531392872,
-0.4837090075,
0.3288847208,
-0.4340055883,
-0.1565224081,
0.210317716,
-0.734005332,
0.6766687632,
0.6300882697,
-0.3192560971,
0.0617097504,
-0.7662028074,
-0.3522759974,
0.0944361836,
-0.1980409324,
-0.306238085,
-0.026415566,
0.2991685569,
-0.0288865734,
-0.5056381822,
-0.1924591511,
0.2907749414,
0.1312704831,
0.5176528692,
0.4715414047,
0.6775072813,
0.3793562055,
-0.048423171,
0.4920991957,
0.5508926511,
0.1485138535,
-0.5463159084,
0.0295100193,
-0.2286130339,
-0.3844486475,
0.2063170075,
0.4735185802,
-0.6903321147,
0.3101573586,
-0.0397589691,
-0.7184102535,
-0.3475410938,
0.3237340748,
-0.2051587552,
0.0573018752,
0.0382705145,
0.102486454,
-0.9414479733,
-0.4535748363,
-0.4939830005,
0.1389030069,
0.047018975,
-0.2366930991,
0.2262475342,
-0.5333606601,
1.0758558512,
-0.4144033492,
-0.5040409565,
-0.1573650688,
0.7706487179,
0.379547745,
-0.1364225149,
0.41488415,
-0.9829161763,
0.0650440902,
-0.1918654889,
-0.8591666818,
-0.4356788993,
-0.4761450589,
0.2943159044,
0.0291120838,
0.7745322585,
-0.1253228635,
0.3865197003,
0.6288285851,
-0.4500317276,
0.661426425,
-0.0101555148,
0.2967121601,
-0.7732205391,
-0.2091787308,
0.311604172,
0.0258592349,
-0.4694424868,
-0.3278136551,
-0.1276102215,
0.0092313038,
-0.1765743643,
0.1526980996,
-0.4424314797,
-0.1771975905,
-0.60199821,
0.2565265,
0.1561162174,
-0.0602880716,
0.0052241613,
0.2046368718,
0.6021820307,
-0.4327004552,
0.5276027918,
-0.2532141507,
-0.5852907896,
0.5071445704,
-0.2905852497,
-0.0633200705,
-0.5395219326,
0.4196566045,
-0.7367374301,
-0.2715823352,
0.0624235198,
-0.3454251885,
-0.0305007044,
-0.0058341729,
-0.6951165795,
-0.7618893385,
-0.2365425825,
-0.0440809429,
0.1432587206,
-0.7724201679,
0.4972156882,
0.6275750995,
0.087681815,
-0.243653059,
-0.2393416464,
0.3515396416,
-0.5778989792,
-0.626482904,
0.2718961835,
0.3069849908,
-0.6479119658,
0.0258731786,
-0.1952292025,
-0.1882345229,
0.327920109,
0.2915896773,
-0.0166243073,
-0.3183303773,
0.0827498361,
0.0500933416,
0.1194473356,
0.2172358185,
-0.2507371008,
0.3553270102,
-0.0126340184,
-0.017605748,
-0.4072212279,
0.6383568645,
0.87372756,
-0.3004596829,
0.3158061802,
0.8474577665,
-0.3629213572,
-0.1457932591,
-0.5193208456,
-0.2546866834,
-0.4377696216,
0.3427083194,
-0.0667064786,
-0.1618228555,
0.6196453571,
-0.3157220781,
0.1654114276,
0.4640680254,
0.3863971233,
-0.1939679533,
0.9446502328,
0.7269179225,
-0.3456600904,
0.5654170513,
-0.3150391877,
0.0580574647,
-0.6068056822,
-0.0981519669,
-0.3822408319,
-0.4483738244,
-0.4291020334,
-0.0983008444,
0.3008001447,
0.2793070674,
-0.0601997152,
0.0802446082,
-0.430550456,
0.5133327246,
0.2452185899,
-0.203050822,
0.5205998421,
0.2453517616,
0.3159594834,
-0.0149480943,
-0.3965454102,
-0.3005929887,
0.7894527912,
0.4594055414,
0.8341689706,
0.0829937309,
0.5612764359,
0.7786133289,
0.6754183173,
-0.6306754947,
-0.0853712782,
0.1427749991,
-0.6397054791,
-0.1563521624,
-0.2154206932,
-1.0402439833,
0.3891902566,
-0.294817239,
-0.708162725,
0.4383752942,
0.0063337875,
-0.4408092201,
0.237974152,
-0.4648395181,
0.4854780734,
-0.2281646878,
-0.1111828089,
-0.3210055232,
-0.3933431208,
0.5316393971,
-0.2875923514,
0.9049255848,
-0.0348276608,
0.0638363659,
0.6172769666,
-0.0897850096,
0.7896586657,
0.1019629166,
-0.2384137064,
0.8246375918,
-0.0819077864,
0.6044508219,
0.1660152376,
0.5131083727,
-0.0731747672,
-0.2110948414,
-0.2170990407,
-0.406476289,
0.5635039806,
-0.8107677698,
-0.3633512259,
-0.4961659014,
-0.5544795394,
0.0064641521,
0.0584494956,
0.5871779919,
0.5300157666,
-0.0650027469,
0.08300782,
0.4327955544,
0.3047427535,
0.7710702419,
0.7789223194,
-0.5559478402,
-0.5125461221,
0.9211719036,
0.3834902644,
-0.1403869539,
0.0647659302,
0.2692656219,
0.1372244656,
-0.440546304,
-0.4578221142,
-0.0279725138,
-0.585188508,
-0.3191695511,
-0.764283061,
-0.0655211285,
0.0108312657,
-0.063893728,
-0.2529966235,
0.2817560732,
-0.2752631605,
0.0344281718,
0.2415439934,
0.5727082491,
-0.1929282844,
0.6071201563,
-0.889308691,
0.2173501551,
-0.1400071383,
-0.0827379152,
-0.1490380019,
-0.8143134117,
-0.0043853922,
-0.1898421943,
-0.9434791803,
-1.1302644014,
0.6920253634,
0.0970509574,
0.2154293656,
0.9761742353,
0.1087411419,
0.6406177878,
-0.3606759012,
0.4660534561,
0.2048674673,
-0.6985257268,
0.6451482177,
-0.7252306938,
0.1897360831,
0.2717363238,
0.491497606,
-0.4244858027,
-0.7132824659,
-0.9569357634,
-0.6697156429,
0.2124388069,
0.0107691558,
0.1077618897,
-0.0695100501,
-0.3323106468,
-0.081323579,
0.2579343617,
-0.1799885035,
0.1237035319,
-0.2875994146,
0.2748166919,
-0.1629718244,
-0.1007024348,
-0.1713501364,
-0.0990795866,
0.2414755374,
-0.0130310832,
0.0117783491,
0.4438719451,
-0.1031805649,
-0.4452470839,
0.3114275336,
0.8491537571,
0.5936958194,
-0.3798475862,
0.6304389834,
-0.17085585,
-0.7131094933,
-0.1205117181,
0.1253789067,
0.1176597103,
0.7092289925,
0.5601999164,
0.5058115721,
0.630977571,
-0.7722132802,
0.4682804644,
0.1688704044,
-0.2677516043,
-0.6874694824,
-0.5385071635,
-0.0733998418,
0.474907726,
0.932731092,
0.077419579,
0.3568103313,
-1.1041753292,
0.2081554979,
0.1403301507,
-0.3043558896,
-0.4299578965,
0.4103187025,
0.166132912,
-0.2298888266,
0.5276159048,
-0.3795814216,
-0.5440536141,
0.8619889617,
0.7776526213,
0.6786979437,
-0.0935471877,
0.2802575231,
0.0032888744,
0.5993797183,
-0.164409548,
0.1088777035,
0.2353614718,
-0.6450357437,
-0.2869967818,
-0.5149331689,
-0.1040835306,
0.5680583119,
-0.6180576086,
0.5200405717,
-0.2020580471,
-0.3555031121,
0.7009136677,
-0.1487229317,
-0.5379804373,
-0.0827692449,
0.4347326458,
1.1334666014,
-1.2852641344,
0.3664433956,
0.550607264,
-0.1837705821,
-0.7127918601,
0.286909163,
0.5600017309,
-0.3062551618,
0.3168900907,
0.1355675012,
0.2440778166,
-0.0391360708,
-0.4420784116,
-0.8696834445,
0.9485527277,
-0.0083093978,
-0.938772738,
0.175453648,
-0.286021322,
0.4125572145,
-0.4182801545,
0.2803502083,
0.8218838573,
0.7220239043,
0.2415658832,
-0.784766376,
-0.4078921378,
-0.0408974476,
-0.4455060959,
0.4649854302,
-0.5660095811,
0.3728493154,
-0.5580688715,
-0.2339709252,
-0.4499155581,
0.8417934775,
0.0257419124,
1.1489610672,
0.8082761168,
0.0739104077,
0.9528587461,
0.0005028266,
1.0777785778,
-0.1051261723,
0.4802717268,
0.6526382565,
0.0490913764,
0.4733541608,
0.5294240117,
-0.030656632,
0.5013529658,
0.8529599309,
-0.210524857,
0.7757049799,
0.1692154706,
-0.2323120832,
-0.2013335079,
-0.2581089139,
-0.1468424201,
0.5619350672,
0.5240284801,
-0.4671909213,
-0.5292041302,
0.5902274847,
0.366689235,
0.116099827,
-0.7265031338,
0.4934477806,
0.0890172347,
-0.6558792591,
0.7086093426,
-0.0564895049,
0.6614257693,
-0.2084409595,
0.3515811861,
-0.1729934812,
0.3041464686,
-0.4182969034,
-0.8003030419,
0.7299979925,
0.1426219195,
-0.5990926623,
0.0686136708,
0.5929533839,
-0.1945496202,
-0.5749456882,
0.1122985184,
0.3818061948,
0.220466435,
-0.4011434913,
-0.1462251544,
0.5790945888,
-0.2587260306,
-0.5410168171,
0.2191668302,
0.6314210892,
-0.4030730128,
0.380492121,
0.490465194,
-0.077375561,
-0.0380583405,
0.1958822012,
0.87939924,
-0.6906406879,
-0.4628454447,
-0.935857892,
0.1754586846,
-0.3780890703,
-0.6018201709,
0.5247914195,
0.4569424093,
0.1461581737,
-0.0024800971,
0.7382200956,
-0.1179439351,
0.2333686352,
-0.1135320291,
0.5419545174,
-0.2600115538,
0.2398182005,
-0.2782093585,
-0.6713047624,
-0.1945753992,
0.0641660914,
-0.3035845459,
-0.7080538273,
0.7877852321,
0.6779673696,
0.0636504591,
0.4111822546,
-0.1137623861,
0.105553709,
0.2514530718,
0.0507633016,
1.1365664005,
-0.0034057605,
0.7496808767,
-0.1103098467,
-0.6439314485,
-0.4977875948,
-1.0391857624,
-0.8107146025,
-0.8011373878,
-0.2413544804,
-0.4222155213,
0.1852676868,
0.8356336355,
0.5081743002,
-0.4013625681,
0.242031619,
0.0546925403,
0.5076270103,
-0.7813031077,
-0.2862294018,
0.4843052626,
-0.4378264546,
-0.4799049795,
0.4961925745,
0.1223671809,
-0.1010801569,
-0.4553483725,
0.5772747397,
0.151981473,
0.297681123,
0.5975307822,
0.301474005,
-0.5035069585,
-0.0581695475,
0.1142889783,
-0.075848341,
-0.3485070765,
1.0671998262,
-0.6453434825,
0.0321355499,
0.4591939151,
0.3428848684,
0.3332237005,
-0.0432826206,
0.2235786915,
-0.9115872383,
0.3226427138,
0.0424282737,
0.1646711528,
0.1036104336,
-0.5331636071,
0.3451666832,
0.4393649995,
-0.6007090807,
-1.3729718924,
-0.2050780803,
-1.0626792908,
-0.0894688591,
1.2200738192,
0.1995262653,
-0.2883795798,
-0.3250876367,
-0.1324164122,
-0.3283368945,
-0.3883999288,
1.1905162334,
0.526981473,
0.113287352,
-0.1858464032,
-0.6967973709,
0.0847966075,
-0.222695902,
-0.5555956364,
0.2116034776,
0.0810107067,
0.3449385464,
0.6992328763,
0.1619947553,
0.0888907686,
0.365580827,
0.1770151109,
-0.407169342,
-0.0335975364,
-0.6829717755,
-0.0288762264,
0.3910392225,
-0.4526096284,
-0.1666483283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09296v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09296v1
|
Cross-Data Knowledge Graph Construction for LLM-enabled Educational Question-Answering System: A~Case~Study~at~HCMUT
| 2024-04-14T16:34:31 | 2024-04-14T16:34:31 |
Tuan Bui, Oanh Tran, Phuong Nguyen, Bao Ho, Long Nguyen, Thang Bui, Tho Quan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In today's rapidly evolving landscape of Artificial Intelligence, large
language models (LLMs) have emerged as a vibrant research topic. LLMs find
applications in various fields and contribute significantly. Despite their
powerful language capabilities, similar to pre-trained language models (PLMs),
LLMs still face challenges in remembering events, incorporating new
information, and addressing domain-specific issues or hallucinations. To
overcome these limitations, researchers have proposed Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) techniques, some others have proposed the integration of LLMs
with Knowledge Graphs (KGs) to provide factual context, thereby improving
performance and delivering more accurate feedback to user queries.
Education plays a crucial role in human development and progress. With the
technology transformation, traditional education is being replaced by digital
or blended education. Therefore, educational data in the digital environment is
increasing day by day. Data in higher education institutions are diverse,
comprising various sources such as unstructured/structured text, relational
databases, web/app-based API access, etc. Constructing a Knowledge Graph from
these cross-data sources is not a simple task. This article proposes a method
for automatically constructing a Knowledge Graph from multiple data sources and
discusses some initial applications (experimental trials) of KG in conjunction
with LLMs for question-answering tasks.
|
[
-0.5419410467,
-1.0684075356,
0.6725448966,
-0.3287784755,
0.0985737592,
0.5518559813,
0.1396243721,
-0.2875682414,
0.287458241,
0.5508311987,
-0.4367247522,
-0.5891179442,
-0.4218660593,
0.0462263413,
-0.4383535683,
0.6654721498,
-0.3610074818,
0.0713760033,
-0.8115881681,
-0.1018098518,
-0.5935375094,
-0.5292651057,
-0.5940084457,
-0.4401074648,
0.4695275128,
0.5243574381,
0.3402169943,
0.4119954407,
0.1621884853,
0.2795094252,
0.2589625418,
0.4180853963,
-0.5229733586,
0.2559380531,
-0.1927660257,
-0.3433389366,
-0.52488482,
-0.0518080145,
0.7189549804,
0.8741515875,
0.1134838685,
0.1727855504,
0.2160285413,
0.5045623779,
-0.4368878007,
0.1534732431,
-0.5426948071,
0.1059014723,
-0.1834681928,
-0.3189538717,
-0.227899313,
-0.5234221816,
0.0973064899,
-0.6786345243,
-0.0847550482,
0.1345219165,
0.6671928167,
0.1262880117,
-0.4368775189,
-0.4983052611,
-0.5218074918,
0.6422707438,
-0.4823843539,
0.7034499645,
0.4288576543,
0.6651848555,
-0.1819857657,
-0.9911310673,
-0.5579441786,
0.2551711202,
-0.1700481921,
0.0716132149,
0.2450682223,
-0.269171983,
-0.0306692682,
0.1334811002,
-0.4032986164,
-0.1103203967,
-0.3707346022,
-0.2693973184,
0.4938889444,
0.5593299866,
0.2201669067,
-0.3460716903,
-0.3267069459,
0.0843324438,
-0.8837519884,
-0.0403672978,
0.2949530184,
0.4469100535,
0.0607994087,
0.8670358062,
-0.3614023626,
0.8555357456,
-0.1484393924,
-0.2145054191,
0.1347589791,
-0.4184468091,
-0.0403986685,
0.0493798628,
0.5978079438,
0.2864682972,
0.4199682176,
-0.3226031661,
0.1303290576,
-0.1249427125,
0.0909336656,
-0.6966508031,
-0.1980075836,
0.1002645195,
-0.1243895441,
-0.1006685868,
-0.2849220634,
-0.7557287812,
-0.3835893571,
-0.4363149405,
0.444436729,
-0.3428428769,
0.0289728343,
-0.1847243905,
0.091123946,
0.2075704336,
0.2802113891,
-0.3234061599,
0.1444754153,
0.3319052458,
0.3980845809,
-0.2044405043,
-0.2639428377,
-0.2250395417,
0.4550514221,
-0.0933692455,
0.5680785775,
-0.7293192744,
-0.4945134223,
0.0965973511,
-0.2121246904,
-0.2394851744,
-0.3802250028,
0.4509994686,
-0.9968878627,
0.5092770457,
-0.2792966664,
-1.1124703884,
-0.2005750239,
0.6851670742,
-0.3463702202,
1.112662673,
0.3289003372,
-0.9192817211,
0.0985553116,
-0.5550465584,
-0.4483384192,
0.2395052761,
-0.3961845636,
-0.2862751186,
-0.7183718681,
0.420945555,
0.5635092854,
-0.4469635189,
0.2432682663,
-0.3413463831,
-0.0463229679,
0.1494009495,
-0.0683086663,
0.8649904728,
0.0574068725,
0.0248978026,
-0.3288978338,
-0.6768229008,
0.3707692027,
0.3257192075,
-0.6197550297,
-0.5371406078,
0.0791575089,
-0.4106706381,
0.0891729519,
0.4723151326,
-0.4913812876,
0.1276614964,
-0.0692270696,
0.0949316397,
0.421888113,
0.217071265,
0.1592281014,
-0.2927797437,
0.6707988977,
-0.116931133,
0.106623657,
0.1666188836,
-0.5007400513,
-0.6676505208,
0.0737465397,
0.2921750247,
0.8106445074,
-1.2595469952,
0.2934536934,
-0.3356084526,
-0.3399855494,
-0.5267565846,
0.3882769942,
0.1987278908,
1.0722687244,
0.4320962429,
0.120295696,
-0.6841117144,
-0.5948932767,
-0.0842889547,
-0.1983457804,
-0.0062101972,
0.775275588,
0.2909522057,
-0.3468826413,
1.3071770668,
-0.8282814026,
-0.1800029576,
-0.3089863658,
-0.1931546032,
-0.1011035368,
0.114073962,
0.4214875102,
-0.7010926604,
-0.5540630817,
-0.1144097373,
-0.8656103015,
-0.1811092496,
0.3716355264,
-0.3794266582,
0.0819645524,
0.4511651695,
-0.3998618722,
0.2940345705,
0.3721304834,
-0.3453995883,
0.5390120149,
0.2531189919,
0.3315081894,
-1.2103441954,
0.0435667597,
-0.266997546,
-0.1462989897,
-0.5272872448,
-0.0558062978,
-0.1906557381,
-0.0403849781,
-0.3420197964,
0.7453452945,
-0.1783550978,
-0.1148541123,
-0.1208997741,
0.695110023,
0.048967652,
0.4194566011,
-0.0866474062,
0.6208697557,
0.577722013,
-0.6951050162,
0.6212496758,
0.5158237815,
-0.1110288352,
0.7245797515,
-0.4495047331,
0.0790227279,
0.0674690679,
0.24906905,
-0.7599672675,
-0.2300741524,
0.5462397933,
-0.4606561363,
0.0487338565,
-0.095856145,
-0.4570098221,
-0.5192173719,
-0.1853377372,
0.5988054872,
0.2880191505,
-0.6202299595,
0.7497979403,
0.6407831311,
-0.3074597716,
-0.5737166405,
-0.3035234511,
0.1576092392,
-0.0929474533,
-0.7879000306,
0.0398603827,
-0.1911705136,
-0.1195635274,
0.2641263902,
0.1531169266,
-0.1337822825,
0.0042671938,
-0.0023636951,
0.5253679752,
-0.234757632,
0.151566878,
0.2527539134,
0.2438039184,
0.120608829,
-0.1859688312,
0.646966815,
0.1997157633,
-0.5382074714,
0.0595623627,
0.1990838647,
0.3340190351,
-0.1227371246,
0.4960755706,
0.280339241,
-0.3509546518,
-0.4868608415,
-0.4814687073,
-0.1441319287,
-0.4707485437,
0.1547031254,
-0.3677606881,
-0.9650810957,
0.5137431026,
-0.2210636437,
-0.008876035,
0.2683400512,
0.4548674822,
-0.0435667746,
0.7253564596,
0.2974720597,
-0.0550899282,
0.2221809477,
-0.224430576,
0.2018999308,
-0.8280897141,
-0.5475054383,
-0.5195257068,
-0.150540635,
-0.4184732437,
-0.4076170027,
0.4864012897,
0.0800683573,
-0.2138919681,
0.0632559955,
-0.3064599633,
0.3173367083,
0.4269020259,
0.0305164121,
0.3688583076,
0.0736906901,
-0.3553111553,
0.2894726694,
-0.9719725251,
-0.3841892183,
1.2940114737,
0.1106811389,
0.7419838905,
-0.1759770364,
0.7087976336,
0.1798723042,
0.3696595728,
-0.5203648806,
0.8135137558,
-0.0984350592,
-0.6994345784,
-0.5662388802,
-0.6270222664,
-0.9324282408,
0.1142343953,
-0.3136454821,
-0.4420346916,
-0.1264732778,
-0.0129048582,
-0.0426021442,
0.4381334186,
-0.3917508125,
0.5177671909,
-0.2824983597,
-0.3486718833,
0.0883751512,
-0.594268322,
0.4035663605,
-0.1872506291,
0.2158869356,
0.1189747453,
0.1304105967,
0.8952860832,
-0.2996495068,
0.7560679913,
-0.2431825101,
-0.1118149161,
0.7678502798,
-0.0824618638,
0.5388594866,
-0.0834629014,
-0.0624264032,
-0.1337440461,
-0.1172901094,
-0.2918547392,
-0.6481375098,
0.6327763796,
-0.7927452326,
-0.6119115353,
0.0565326959,
-1.0099670887,
-0.6415007114,
0.3032609224,
-0.3055969179,
0.3782697618,
-0.0205600653,
0.0459149703,
0.5999187231,
-0.3042290509,
0.0369429886,
0.5539849401,
-0.6089273691,
-0.5368366241,
1.0110262632,
0.3690226078,
0.1168348193,
0.3174315691,
0.1150363311,
-0.4852276444,
-0.4930566549,
-0.486789465,
0.3238534331,
-0.833247602,
-0.2754037082,
-0.6830744147,
-0.6782089472,
-0.7720431089,
-0.1591188908,
0.1110288724,
-0.4325132966,
-0.1007231399,
-0.1264026314,
0.4452939332,
0.8059356213,
0.2283866405,
0.2111134529,
-0.7426729202,
0.4992182255,
0.6641050577,
0.3934578598,
0.0033168406,
-0.2022530437,
-0.3395752609,
0.1128580421,
-0.1706352979,
-0.7215170264,
0.0441904105,
0.0449559204,
0.8167717457,
0.0786992088,
0.1569232047,
0.5251482129,
-0.3097577691,
0.4535557628,
-0.1445413977,
-0.5154334903,
0.3559611738,
-0.3218400776,
0.047252275,
0.4645026326,
0.5726037025,
-0.5185640454,
-0.6103782654,
-0.503551662,
-0.9346382618,
0.6210144758,
0.100518778,
-0.1126712412,
0.2031599283,
0.5005397797,
0.2228092253,
0.3640366793,
-0.443316251,
-0.5246935487,
-0.1159358397,
-0.4964178503,
0.0515494198,
-0.0647823438,
-0.3185753822,
-0.3316566646,
0.9032520652,
-0.1049291641,
-0.1969173551,
-0.0676377267,
-0.1601580232,
0.028171625,
0.2089696527,
0.0976516008,
0.7602404952,
-0.0905909166,
0.1400201172,
0.4054426253,
-0.4073743224,
0.0640330091,
0.2356469482,
-0.490458101,
-0.2193895876,
0.1009379327,
0.4916520119,
-0.0530497804,
-0.667011857,
0.2852656543,
0.0865351558,
-0.0316477492,
-0.2275419384,
0.1536975205,
0.4895006716,
0.3833793998,
0.4325344265,
-0.6785004735,
-0.0763040036,
-0.4526164234,
0.4019058049,
0.5754977465,
-0.025320299,
0.1561237723,
0.6125833392,
0.3379030526,
-0.3135132492,
0.7366392612,
-0.0171115529,
-0.6754802465,
0.5625106096,
0.5136758089,
0.4546318948,
-0.2156659365,
0.3814437389,
0.2706654072,
0.0775888339,
0.3111093342,
0.413720578,
-0.103848815,
-0.8228468895,
-0.2647859156,
-0.695384264,
-0.592263341,
-0.0020037387,
-0.3569357693,
0.2635130584,
-0.2134695351,
-0.0204806775,
-0.230470553,
0.1885227859,
-0.6564496756,
0.5860872269,
0.1175704747,
0.8133487701,
-0.8073299527,
0.8045768142,
0.8854685426,
-0.1701961011,
-0.890814662,
-0.3554596901,
-0.3362852633,
-0.9822836518,
0.6614421606,
-0.3492135406,
-0.0987414569,
0.2763632238,
-0.3292706907,
-0.7970955372,
1.3758891821,
0.1965219527,
-0.446862191,
-0.1475723237,
0.6950341463,
0.4529356658,
-0.5245270729,
0.0144767193,
0.5394990444,
0.6131343246,
0.3159178495,
-0.3962870836,
0.0468344353,
-0.0222254191,
-0.4639229476,
0.3028738797,
-0.4141784906,
0.7413957715,
0.0151335252,
-0.1728708297,
-0.2324433476,
0.5613691211,
0.4753161669,
0.6104067564,
0.3953432441,
0.7547339201,
0.7028869987,
0.0851822793,
0.7516320348,
-0.5569975972,
0.1383799314,
1.2566649914,
-0.1609052122,
0.5493433475,
0.5156323314,
-0.3548630774,
0.4262314141,
0.5391846895,
-0.0323457941,
0.2410506904,
0.1337450147,
-0.1810170561,
-0.3276352882,
-0.1773571074,
-0.5399459004,
0.2160882205,
0.3525564671,
-0.237918973,
-0.5374922752,
-0.0832549557,
-0.0776122287,
-0.0176182538,
-0.4381985962,
0.5058632493,
0.0428611301,
-0.5030566454,
0.2136992365,
-0.152877599,
0.2703324258,
-0.5927256942,
-0.0911614671,
-0.2119447887,
-0.3515308201,
-0.2707210183,
-1.1074714661,
0.0221428592,
0.0588743947,
-0.0288228057,
-0.025972994,
0.889714241,
-0.6930168867,
-0.6445628405,
0.403134644,
1.0662299395,
0.1747145951,
0.5571393371,
-0.5426707864,
-0.1188641861,
-0.1406815648,
-0.3287402689,
0.2002292871,
0.4627872705,
-0.1418879926,
0.815089345,
0.4319427013,
0.0349533148,
0.4427523613,
0.1103758961,
0.8939320445,
-0.366641432,
-0.3887120783,
-0.4087567627,
0.3264436424,
-0.0497600883,
-0.0445089824,
0.9273509383,
0.747143805,
0.9270064235,
0.2998544574,
1.0610748529,
-0.3393543959,
0.7976800203,
-0.4057579339,
0.8109041452,
-0.6405256987,
0.2222047746,
-0.1489816159,
-0.8218868971,
-0.1586933434,
0.0437756032,
-0.3764222264,
0.209515661,
0.5134456754,
0.6108771563,
0.0435056053,
-0.0749239028,
0.2042644322,
0.0917084068,
0.166879341,
0.4625685513,
0.9287257195,
-0.2869719565,
0.9074794054,
-0.2264064848,
0.1838704497,
-0.1369993836,
-0.5353725553,
-0.9859628677,
-0.5466513038,
-0.2674928308,
-0.2915478349,
0.0245506112,
0.5367494226,
0.1892578751,
-0.7372653484,
-0.1878198981,
0.2456301451,
0.5888017416,
0.318159163,
-0.256639719,
0.5962430835,
-0.2586651742,
-0.6077686548,
0.3939641714,
-0.1110154018,
0.1082278192,
-0.4046185613,
-0.2695320547,
-0.4267588258,
0.2698296905,
0.5724719763,
0.3168539107,
-0.2411516607,
-0.4575086236,
-0.0048754914,
-0.1073039323,
-0.0047896258,
0.6881844401,
-0.9980949163,
0.3102463186,
0.6742414236,
1.034271121,
0.4209409058,
0.1286232173,
0.1971877515,
-0.6567046046,
-0.4520897865,
0.1958557814,
0.2721893489,
0.3862275481,
-0.2049693465,
0.504031539,
0.3104467094,
-0.5214197636,
-0.8353408575,
0.2450837493,
-0.728769362,
-0.4154289365,
0.8624102473,
0.024925502,
-0.1698613763,
-0.4115239978,
-0.114748098,
0.5462406278,
0.0386236347,
0.9620750546,
0.6771149039,
-0.3966364861,
0.2209941,
-0.5054650903,
0.1558594853,
0.1382030547,
-1.1744821072,
-0.1183189601,
0.565689683,
0.3932707906,
0.0547981001,
0.5066737533,
-0.0820283666,
-0.0629321933,
-0.043917954,
0.0600925274,
-0.3070578277,
-0.4143009484,
0.3520585001,
0.675753057,
-0.1607523561,
-0.1067629829
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13069v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13069v1
|
Subtle Signs of Scribal Intent in the Voynich Manuscript
| 2024-04-14T14:54:01 | 2024-04-14T14:54:01 |
Andrew Steckley, Noah Steckley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study explores the cryptic Voynich Manuscript, by looking for subtle
signs of scribal intent hidden in overlooked features of the "Voynichese"
script. The findings indicate that distributions of tokens within paragraphs
vary significantly based on positions defined not only by elements intrinsic to
the script such as paragraph and line boundaries but also by extrinsic
elements, namely the hand-drawn illustrations of plants.
|
[
0.0624589808,
-0.402896136,
1.008353591,
0.2961266339,
-0.3028628826,
-0.1048909426,
0.1558285654,
-0.6426446438,
0.8216820955,
0.4356049001,
-0.8025031686,
-0.5738386512,
-0.7449496388,
0.0915306956,
-0.5706752539,
0.8197553158,
-0.277970165,
0.3544611931,
0.1713728458,
-0.1570836008,
0.2313601375,
-0.4144296646,
-0.1583409905,
0.0713611618,
0.9802854061,
0.3742561042,
0.3570182621,
0.7388624549,
0.7817276716,
0.2239892483,
-0.2171701789,
-0.2639424205,
-0.2024986595,
0.1899003536,
-0.409517467,
-0.9737553596,
0.0135139115,
0.0217887945,
0.5709888339,
0.7112361789,
0.2375285476,
0.2951726317,
-0.0912237912,
0.5746203065,
-0.3750711977,
0.0402320996,
-0.5947461724,
0.1603250802,
-0.7721700668,
-0.3981926739,
-0.4731473923,
-0.3930624723,
0.7563900352,
-0.4577155411,
0.5530871153,
-0.0790534467,
1.1183885336,
0.0081088096,
-0.4000449777,
-0.8889084458,
-0.3567457795,
0.934731245,
-0.3852134049,
-0.2922817171,
0.0080238795,
0.1071305797,
-0.2648466527,
-0.9645330906,
-0.5243063569,
-0.3864250481,
-0.1867925823,
0.0078183785,
-0.2145731449,
0.1873968095,
0.5893627405,
0.4269106388,
-0.4752281308,
0.0502966158,
-0.2443929762,
-0.5562109351,
0.4414666593,
0.3136563897,
0.7262399197,
-0.498355478,
-0.5237039328,
-0.0847803578,
-0.5482962132,
0.263661921,
0.5995180011,
0.1309626848,
0.1077742353,
1.1322050095,
-0.0591991208,
0.4318934083,
-0.3294081688,
0.2108712643,
0.0105291447,
-0.5648471117,
0.358355552,
0.1609913111,
0.5214059949,
0.8195698857,
0.1745391935,
0.1951286048,
-0.0393945873,
0.8439313173,
-0.0799673721,
-0.5603080988,
-0.3753324449,
0.145356223,
-0.7610961199,
-0.5776893497,
0.2881839275,
-0.3805271089,
-0.5087839365,
-0.0745673329,
0.0017751829,
-0.4205552042,
0.0172169674,
-0.1066902801,
-1.2852978706,
0.4919554591,
0.4002619386,
-0.88343364,
0.0750910938,
0.5103415251,
0.7755687833,
-0.5091927052,
-0.4448424876,
-0.2740602493,
0.1244408786,
-0.3430881798,
1.1547478437,
-0.7461836338,
-0.5656553507,
0.0572437942,
0.3150042892,
-0.0017870917,
-0.342348665,
0.7335601449,
0.3411510289,
0.1057795733,
-0.7577488422,
-0.4785420895,
-0.3834303021,
-0.313134402,
-0.6275355816,
1.245270133,
0.4394629896,
-0.8089947701,
0.6402323842,
-0.3463334441,
-0.3805423677,
0.0017188943,
-0.5785730481,
-0.0496470891,
0.6726866961,
-0.5406720042,
0.3131381571,
0.3184871674,
-0.3621638119,
-0.2238229662,
-0.5121634603,
0.8199703097,
-0.3576218188,
0.8971346617,
-0.1104619876,
-0.7779214382,
0.3618165553,
-0.6958807111,
0.2221098691,
-0.1429938525,
-0.1358312219,
-0.5217710733,
-0.1699095815,
0.3823763132,
0.0830013007,
0.4117021263,
-0.5701470971,
0.6835317612,
-0.2366695404,
0.5766156316,
0.5111379623,
0.4931302369,
0.6138235331,
-0.4603239894,
0.6278096437,
0.0547968149,
0.2195533067,
-0.2777657807,
-0.6638391614,
-0.9993351102,
-0.0875003487,
0.3354706764,
0.5315685868,
-0.6599898934,
0.2182873785,
0.0182053279,
-0.605697453,
-0.823091507,
-0.1621237844,
0.3689824939,
-0.1005073041,
-0.01685003,
-0.1351120174,
-0.2240883559,
-1.293300271,
-0.7543227077,
0.137977466,
0.0963692069,
0.2772735357,
0.5181111097,
-0.2433742136,
0.4370942414,
-0.546421051,
-0.3552848101,
-0.3442790806,
0.3963069618,
0.1078882292,
0.0881523713,
0.790759325,
-0.6126766801,
-0.8428774476,
0.1824128926,
-0.1370183378,
-0.3348014653,
-0.4005763531,
-0.1676287353,
0.0436771289,
0.6950233579,
-0.8939723969,
1.1023691893,
0.335557729,
-0.566137135,
0.5572171211,
-0.053356152,
-0.1560447067,
-0.7686262727,
0.0307944566,
-0.3570350409,
0.0913357809,
-0.5534664392,
-0.0400610305,
0.1679989249,
0.1727093458,
-0.4228366911,
0.4072245657,
-0.695941031,
-0.0226946622,
0.0065833535,
0.3502878845,
0.1525774449,
0.3925664127,
0.2502653003,
0.4586798549,
0.7118623257,
-0.3281055689,
-0.0684620589,
-0.2047745734,
-0.2376521677,
0.5057194829,
-0.5669996142,
-0.2331877053,
-0.2415478975,
-0.022461744,
-1.3242766857,
-0.4057262838,
0.4540908635,
-0.3869775236,
-0.0262119845,
0.0400549583,
0.1635027826,
-0.0981885642,
-0.6528933644,
0.3201889396,
-0.0018404667,
0.0475914665,
0.7548952699,
-0.0947962478,
-0.3314368129,
-0.3881639838,
-0.707541883,
-0.1121209934,
-0.1851032078,
-0.1070015803,
0.5183875561,
0.0107300924,
-0.3599227071,
-0.008016279,
-0.1064455509,
0.140218854,
-0.1278382093,
0.6682615876,
0.1049491614,
-0.0013604525,
-0.3124538362,
0.3311712146,
-0.0671449304,
0.0380034298,
0.1192316562,
0.6522009373,
-0.0458343215,
-0.5788984895,
-0.9725582004,
0.6700966358,
0.941868484,
0.250287056,
0.1469669789,
0.5856573582,
-0.0901712552,
-0.1914176345,
-0.1703721285,
-0.1537835151,
-0.3916881979,
0.0479574911,
-0.3431669176,
-0.4040158987,
0.8461015224,
-0.4042471647,
-0.3669503331,
0.7821112871,
0.0682187229,
-0.4966059327,
0.9393087029,
0.3249653876,
0.2667089403,
0.7003484368,
-0.4208707809,
-0.0060782386,
-1.0078496933,
-0.3487962782,
-0.5675234795,
-0.6124078035,
-0.7571905851,
-0.5045267344,
0.2976228297,
0.170596838,
0.4810290039,
0.4341461062,
-0.8103738427,
0.743119359,
0.6894978285,
0.1052997261,
-0.0231114887,
0.0082619144,
-0.4512371421,
-0.3264779747,
-0.4596222639,
-0.6557232141,
0.9844389558,
0.3808532953,
0.2771964669,
0.1536872983,
0.6619434357,
0.3415635526,
0.1073124632,
-0.9049582481,
0.5384113789,
0.1427287757,
-0.3882749081,
-0.5802698135,
0.1295321584,
-1.0647745132,
0.2261233479,
-0.1469442099,
-1.010833025,
0.5427898765,
-0.0959317535,
-0.3453203142,
-0.2539100051,
-1.0206744671,
0.8183214664,
-0.2977305651,
-0.000470041,
-0.0676335841,
-0.4790194631,
-0.1178789064,
0.5660841465,
-0.1996206641,
-0.027737502,
-0.1287854612,
0.5965928435,
-0.3358147442,
0.9264416695,
-0.1299437732,
-0.1125749797,
0.6691328883,
0.529199183,
0.9093869328,
-0.0094958432,
-0.0304200407,
0.1908930838,
0.3340529501,
-0.5554707646,
-0.4336639643,
0.5132887363,
-0.2426739335,
-0.5101553202,
-0.9236642718,
-0.1426804662,
0.5831927061,
0.5800874233,
1.0417895317,
0.5533379316,
-0.3935225606,
0.043062456,
0.5268881917,
-0.0242219791,
0.7632719278,
0.2139401734,
-0.2676281035,
-0.0541581325,
0.8767131567,
0.1739431471,
0.2999250591,
0.3492202461,
0.2951076925,
-0.3406355977,
-0.7269333601,
-0.3813713491,
0.1676829606,
-0.8872709274,
0.3209764063,
-0.4162383378,
-0.0228109751,
-0.0901927724,
-0.4316294789,
0.0493970625,
-0.8048704267,
-0.7042811513,
-0.0693561509,
0.3806701005,
0.99957335,
0.340287447,
0.5884695053,
-0.5359233022,
0.1472762227,
0.0247951616,
-0.0256893132,
-0.2602739036,
-0.1505361348,
0.3376897275,
-0.039947588,
-0.1213100702,
-1.1107831001,
-0.0973540395,
0.0295670088,
0.5184233189,
1.0107836723,
-0.2870048881,
0.3250949681,
-0.3420765102,
1.1875164509,
0.3300926387,
-0.9337765574,
0.5198016167,
-0.9674600959,
0.3508115709,
0.6377050877,
0.4019900858,
-0.7825587988,
-0.3632100821,
-0.907800436,
-0.826895833,
0.3770052493,
0.1710773408,
0.165184021,
-0.1501639336,
0.3981140554,
0.3971782625,
0.2178696841,
-0.9312260151,
-0.2514306903,
0.0283469856,
-0.2345070839,
0.5856260657,
-0.3621041775,
-0.4099595845,
-0.417573452,
-0.2401040643,
0.002213076,
0.2452678084,
0.5356882215,
-0.1367257684,
0.0024063629,
0.0012124729,
1.0253194571,
0.921803236,
0.1741136461,
0.3529104292,
0.0264117289,
-0.7499697804,
-0.1969317049,
-0.5108584762,
-0.4537968636,
0.6469776034,
0.7155451775,
0.7730315328,
0.296715796,
-0.680211246,
0.9124420881,
0.1499320269,
-0.2110251039,
-0.7871589065,
0.5873329639,
-0.0608162917,
0.1393742412,
0.1869246215,
0.4963784218,
0.5554444194,
-0.9089334011,
-0.1454281658,
0.5137646198,
-0.6273289323,
-0.4696688056,
0.1862434745,
0.0234739482,
-0.5587341785,
0.3224563003,
-0.3573785126,
-0.6961454153,
0.4249326289,
0.179657951,
0.7098020315,
-0.2962264121,
0.7975030541,
-0.2608273327,
0.338011235,
0.1742734462,
1.0747402906,
-0.1232922077,
-0.098849833,
0.0582942329,
-0.3730370104,
-0.2187703848,
-0.2792550325,
-0.7166827917,
0.3377673924,
-0.4896947742,
-0.2513973415,
0.4179390669,
-0.7312207222,
-0.7937233448,
-0.1804662794,
-0.3829069138,
0.8914840221,
-0.6954738498,
0.4354171455,
0.3279755712,
-0.224051699,
-0.7895293832,
0.1691947728,
-0.1437749416,
-0.9086400867,
0.7377329469,
0.0683894306,
-0.2736487389,
-0.0946090594,
-0.4354159534,
-0.8653094172,
0.8690764904,
-0.1618783176,
-0.5597139597,
-0.2817746699,
0.3775550723,
0.6921029091,
-0.2162338346,
0.4911673665,
0.3716062605,
0.6303496957,
-0.1372669935,
-0.6042317152,
0.1473311037,
-0.1902937591,
0.077671349,
0.2819627225,
-0.6813822389,
0.9523008466,
-0.3115322888,
-0.711827755,
0.1320649087,
0.2798762321,
-0.130192548,
0.4177781045,
0.0670835823,
0.3205935657,
0.9290143251,
-0.3195103407,
1.1364034414,
-0.1196461096,
-0.0663731322,
0.4939422607,
-0.3815710247,
0.8366882801,
1.050109148,
-0.1463858485,
1.2159416676,
0.6221037507,
-0.0655640885,
0.5252563953,
0.5473903418,
-0.5279332995,
0.2940025628,
-0.3589755595,
-0.190150246,
0.5448958278,
0.7884883881,
-0.6431245208,
0.0678449795,
-0.0828592107,
-0.0596822426,
-0.0481555723,
-0.1855140477,
0.7877304554,
0.3092415035,
-0.71015203,
0.0781126767,
-0.3108191788,
0.3517255187,
-0.5705475211,
-0.4753204584,
0.2436193824,
0.0589604415,
-0.3568435311,
-0.8788841367,
0.0381233431,
-0.602256,
-0.2642928958,
-0.2797655463,
0.8730108738,
-0.2118394971,
-0.4937938452,
0.085945189,
0.0863368884,
0.2944898307,
-0.0646521971,
-0.4134345353,
0.2724421918,
0.143018052,
-0.3218845129,
-0.0241045356,
0.9562256336,
-0.2458490282,
0.4538263679,
0.7411943078,
0.5273622274,
0.204488337,
0.1417160183,
0.5793732405,
-0.9160885811,
-0.7048042417,
-0.740392983,
0.6465004683,
-0.3757498264,
-0.7859768271,
1.1773955822,
0.3870876133,
0.4383701384,
-0.611143887,
0.7723067999,
0.0480102859,
0.4226945043,
-0.5871548057,
0.5484104156,
-0.0347166173,
-0.1291466206,
-0.5436362624,
-0.9441227913,
0.0223933086,
0.6340245605,
-0.1684645414,
-0.3351652324,
1.2574468851,
0.5454795361,
0.2507414818,
0.0403932519,
-0.168446973,
-0.0835486874,
-0.2456084937,
0.269500494,
1.2735152245,
-0.2212423086,
0.1613691896,
0.087508291,
-0.3093498647,
-0.5955793858,
-0.8581932783,
-0.9698142409,
-0.6987250447,
-0.1848723739,
-0.2826395631,
-0.4298775792,
0.5380559564,
0.1025374234,
-0.6739225388,
0.1312645823,
-0.442458719,
0.0749133006,
-0.3619616032,
-0.3553209901,
0.6379657984,
0.2852653861,
-0.6031389832,
0.1660231054,
0.6242787242,
0.7517794967,
-0.3937067389,
0.2509263158,
0.200837031,
0.0283352286,
0.381342411,
-0.042728167,
-0.9802154303,
-0.4954708517,
0.4496546984,
-0.2891976833,
-0.3308530152,
1.5147236586,
0.0048647844,
0.2433308065,
0.8458786011,
-0.1985500157,
0.4311129749,
-0.200353682,
0.2499313802,
-0.7108265758,
0.4533470273,
0.584497869,
0.2893835008,
-0.1694861203,
-0.9172881842,
0.0070934705,
0.3134236634,
-0.2937025726,
-0.9253188372,
0.4431430399,
-1.3926619291,
-0.4380799234,
1.2291184664,
0.0598468333,
-0.4087032676,
-0.2218324691,
-0.8503163457,
0.0135082426,
-0.1849658042,
0.8549827933,
1.327873826,
-0.6901255846,
0.082820408,
-0.6471149325,
1.0428309441,
0.562628746,
-0.4521075487,
0.2158965468,
0.2907815874,
0.1623184085,
0.5148943663,
0.6829404235,
-0.07637766,
0.3418650627,
0.3278355598,
-0.2709768414,
0.6741453409,
-0.4559998214,
0.1081244946,
-0.0230262969,
0.1907154024,
-0.1961634606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09275v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09275v1
|
TrafficVLM: A Controllable Visual Language Model for Traffic Video Captioning
| 2024-04-14T14:51:44 | 2024-04-14T14:51:44 |
Quang Minh Dinh, Minh Khoi Ho, Anh Quan Dang, Hung Phong Tran
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Traffic video description and analysis have received much attention recently
due to the growing demand for efficient and reliable urban surveillance
systems. Most existing methods only focus on locating traffic event segments,
which severely lack descriptive details related to the behaviour and context of
all the subjects of interest in the events. In this paper, we present
TrafficVLM, a novel multi-modal dense video captioning model for vehicle ego
camera view. TrafficVLM models traffic video events at different levels of
analysis, both spatially and temporally, and generates long fine-grained
descriptions for the vehicle and pedestrian at different phases of the event.
We also propose a conditional component for TrafficVLM to control the
generation outputs and a multi-task fine-tuning paradigm to enhance
TrafficVLM's learning capability. Experiments show that TrafficVLM performs
well on both vehicle and overhead camera views. Our solution achieved
outstanding results in Track 2 of the AI City Challenge 2024, ranking us third
in the challenge standings. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/quangminhdinh/TrafficVLM.
|
[
-0.2987244725,
-0.6930035949,
0.4217834473,
0.3131801486,
-0.3750027716,
0.1875354499,
-0.0311831161,
-0.2297598124,
-0.0657227784,
0.4242519736,
-0.351126194,
-0.3656278253,
-0.2602928579,
-0.2809357941,
-0.6290383935,
0.5575919151,
-0.1740407795,
0.3538762033,
-0.315487951,
-0.2347200066,
-0.496981442,
-0.6540218592,
-0.6380188465,
0.3148009479,
0.4031736851,
0.1795223206,
0.4843945801,
0.6938765645,
0.759172678,
0.3739249706,
0.4512806833,
0.4789403677,
-0.2295993567,
-0.1132200584,
0.0497165732,
0.0949683115,
-0.3516978025,
-0.3082640171,
0.8654335141,
0.2693738639,
-0.2478197068,
-0.0561217703,
-0.1970237941,
0.3268855214,
-0.6207738519,
0.2480062097,
-0.7460434437,
-0.3162284791,
-0.1919206977,
-0.3473103344,
-0.043413844,
0.0056561572,
-0.025311524,
-0.3743598163,
0.212211132,
0.3910228014,
1.0154640675,
0.5361284018,
-0.5105262399,
0.3368909061,
-0.9233519435,
0.7696199417,
-0.2154277861,
0.5247473717,
0.1289315224,
0.6847265959,
0.3407981396,
-0.5066541433,
-0.7849218845,
-0.1275336444,
-0.0294078588,
0.1144238189,
0.0934013575,
0.2089979351,
-0.0901575759,
0.0138398232,
-0.6449643373,
-0.1361400634,
-0.6448400617,
-0.3175106645,
0.8459561467,
0.8718462586,
0.0227946062,
-0.0191790387,
-0.7335349917,
0.2365494668,
-0.4408872128,
0.2365068048,
0.11459589,
0.1507793516,
-0.3670427799,
0.4576987326,
-0.306743741,
0.6589673758,
-0.4681924582,
-0.2081161886,
0.2418016344,
-0.3343141675,
-0.5723955035,
-0.3340890408,
0.913231492,
0.5844370127,
0.1153992638,
-0.1226560324,
-0.2885611057,
-0.2528391182,
0.2956089675,
-0.7344570756,
-0.3839076161,
0.3008240759,
-0.3287212551,
-0.1247619614,
0.2941848636,
-0.7166156769,
-0.2531140745,
-0.568646729,
0.2366449237,
-0.1641723216,
-0.2033896893,
0.2623641491,
0.1092204824,
0.6443222761,
0.8871207237,
-0.4279233217,
0.1463875622,
0.4176517725,
0.8607261181,
-0.3749824464,
-0.3760308027,
-0.7646435499,
0.4725573063,
-0.0857865289,
0.5102748275,
-0.4591322839,
0.0751363412,
0.1506546438,
0.0839969292,
-0.045237083,
-0.2361578494,
-0.1510601342,
-0.6361181736,
-0.1226393804,
0.2014484107,
-0.1513512284,
-0.3293337226,
0.238558501,
-0.5387681127,
0.4826060832,
-0.0695443824,
-0.3711586297,
0.2821196914,
-0.5934400558,
-0.6647142172,
0.5398233533,
-0.3143590689,
-0.630102694,
-0.1904190183,
-0.0985833108,
0.390350014,
0.1631015688,
0.4370566308,
-0.1173128486,
0.1202603728,
0.203276515,
-0.4838716388,
0.4680635333,
0.3116212487,
-0.0793728605,
0.5922089815,
-0.7204351425,
-0.3778307736,
0.1458390802,
-0.2093386799,
-0.0676744059,
0.0976631269,
0.473004818,
0.0449316725,
0.1945416182,
-0.5229413509,
0.0374104083,
0.0395701639,
0.5018022656,
0.6934500337,
-0.0491867475,
0.29912588,
0.0813215449,
0.7175180912,
0.2533506155,
0.5830876231,
-0.2134066671,
-0.5703171492,
-0.6134515405,
-0.3778761327,
-0.1638757586,
0.5380753279,
-0.8744689226,
-0.0335379802,
-0.3157848716,
-0.1917955279,
-0.4304011464,
0.1455495358,
0.3539114296,
0.4818143547,
0.2588549554,
-0.2063330859,
-0.5111552477,
-0.8913571835,
0.2827856839,
-0.0791474581,
0.1900520176,
0.4745110273,
0.4635995924,
0.034898866,
0.7020301223,
-0.4560842514,
-0.5859766603,
-0.3399053514,
-0.1786662042,
-0.4499798715,
0.4926107228,
0.6005643606,
-1.2773782015,
-0.4681515694,
0.0834259987,
-0.5417268276,
0.2218047976,
-0.384973973,
-0.1198816448,
0.0615075193,
0.7192783356,
-0.3487316668,
0.6530596018,
0.228550747,
-0.2774702013,
0.5116189122,
-0.2684727311,
0.1097436249,
-0.5835291147,
-0.1339370608,
-0.1360884309,
-0.9609908462,
-0.4402614832,
0.2497531325,
-0.0669593662,
-0.1393227875,
-0.9021899104,
0.3427040279,
-0.2453439534,
-0.1006799415,
-0.1891351193,
0.1221892759,
0.019992942,
0.8156972528,
0.292909801,
0.4904941916,
0.9448077679,
-0.7159267068,
0.6895737052,
0.1994655877,
-0.4824565351,
0.3259802163,
-0.3464557528,
-0.1467158347,
-0.4594231844,
-0.0552150048,
-1.0904432535,
-0.5310634375,
0.14542678,
-0.2681640387,
-0.0209026486,
-0.1693828404,
-0.5104212165,
-0.3493567705,
0.074583739,
0.5137911439,
0.3810006678,
-0.1686580926,
0.7467198372,
0.6330285072,
-0.041989319,
0.0241428521,
-0.5428443551,
0.3137433827,
-0.439891547,
-0.5121860504,
-0.1827407777,
-0.249223873,
-0.2142890692,
-0.2549093068,
0.2924496233,
-0.5889797807,
0.1346617043,
0.2256029695,
0.3748514056,
0.0800816342,
0.2161118686,
-0.4040856063,
0.1264627576,
0.1153288782,
-0.159296006,
0.4646808505,
-0.3093160093,
-0.128919974,
-0.5375858545,
0.5545867682,
0.75582546,
-0.719610095,
0.4976841807,
0.8040972352,
-0.1649778038,
0.2430733144,
-0.258135736,
0.0504687056,
-0.469145298,
0.7209605575,
-0.3263220191,
-0.8483965993,
0.3195392191,
0.344384104,
-0.0813742951,
0.0593073107,
0.7020850182,
-0.3315143883,
1.4177359343,
0.4963715971,
-0.0030925735,
0.6202660203,
-0.1732084155,
0.1199498028,
-0.4166207016,
-0.6903625131,
-0.0456493236,
-0.1617437452,
-0.2393666357,
-0.5200965405,
0.7500503659,
-0.2148091346,
-0.3158369064,
0.0424758382,
-0.2322659642,
0.525937438,
0.3420103192,
0.011285983,
0.3483021855,
-0.0761305317,
0.4038665295,
-0.06995143,
-0.7454971671,
-0.2119941264,
0.6252613068,
0.2770626545,
0.737930119,
0.3477789462,
-0.00578517,
0.5190439224,
0.1174688935,
-0.4873293936,
0.7635242939,
-0.0106860977,
-0.6365828514,
-0.360629648,
-0.2505151033,
-0.7970186472,
0.1449293792,
0.0292702504,
-0.6084809303,
-0.1727375984,
0.3274285197,
-0.6652572155,
0.340344578,
-0.2445620894,
0.9663206339,
-0.5996494293,
-0.5323807597,
-0.2878402472,
-0.8840556145,
0.5152537823,
0.1294963956,
0.455897361,
-0.052882161,
-0.1246817783,
0.3191742003,
-0.5276642442,
0.7566255331,
-0.1136459038,
0.1092523113,
0.5530187488,
0.0673780069,
0.4509835541,
0.3430095315,
0.722035706,
0.0705154166,
-0.2892613113,
-0.4434963167,
-0.3215897679,
0.5212491751,
-0.2279889286,
-0.4453063905,
0.0037022529,
-0.4970543385,
0.2670568824,
0.174284339,
0.044115942,
0.8161205649,
0.1178487539,
0.1713522524,
0.5504244566,
-0.2517832816,
0.6322321892,
0.6615312099,
-0.5355678797,
-0.3941225708,
1.2429498434,
-0.4283837974,
0.2015493661,
0.6065251827,
-0.1221740767,
-0.2345337123,
-0.5850452781,
-0.7846345901,
-0.2642247677,
-0.5753839612,
-0.2098320723,
-0.6946761608,
-0.1605675817,
-0.4470142722,
-0.2176615745,
-0.5680295825,
-0.1498883069,
-0.0929322764,
-0.1531574428,
0.1508266032,
0.6373437047,
0.0339972861,
0.3517207801,
-0.5815671086,
0.4798129499,
0.589966476,
0.4106222391,
-0.0254719537,
-0.2122039199,
-0.4561145008,
-0.2996588945,
-0.2133048773,
-0.4970545173,
0.6372555494,
0.0216003638,
0.2359093279,
0.6347537041,
-0.2384424359,
0.7266303301,
-0.5388009548,
0.9652228951,
0.2223609835,
-0.663721323,
0.4609247446,
-0.4790752828,
0.2364004254,
0.3832478821,
-0.0110022603,
-0.1412610412,
-0.6428874731,
-0.3577899933,
-0.9526649714,
0.3018442094,
0.4762489796,
0.2054311484,
0.0946558937,
0.0600117333,
-0.0790118799,
0.507791996,
-1.0308097601,
-0.2309564203,
-0.5259566307,
-0.0879748464,
0.1003636494,
0.0632320642,
-0.0195873864,
-0.5626778603,
0.3615544736,
-0.0059470315,
0.0964566618,
0.3497906625,
-0.183395505,
-0.0293414127,
-0.0022171545,
1.0148861408,
0.5677030683,
-0.226690948,
0.2424223125,
-0.0054640654,
-0.3859809935,
-0.0886773616,
-0.0751421973,
-0.4099393785,
0.0864808187,
0.3691841364,
0.9415916204,
-0.2140976191,
-1.0336556435,
0.8347126245,
0.1085209474,
-0.1606841087,
-0.8193632364,
-0.1196104884,
-0.4718053341,
0.2971036136,
0.3596130013,
0.1777970046,
0.3642710447,
-0.3325793743,
-0.0162786022,
0.5045075417,
-0.7499040365,
-0.3982190192,
1.6284905672,
0.470221132,
-0.2350469977,
0.272655338,
-0.6239038706,
-0.7334097028,
0.7624206543,
-0.2233379036,
0.9770331979,
0.0694920123,
0.1017764732,
0.2361685783,
0.3365390003,
0.3592406511,
0.4535082877,
-0.0275490694,
-0.5220139027,
-0.5467305779,
-0.5462418795,
0.0200398769,
0.4511705637,
-0.53596735,
0.2116588056,
-0.3324891925,
0.1710295528,
-0.1020884067,
-0.5586265326,
-0.9214296937,
0.3426045775,
0.4994315207,
0.8078199029,
-0.6683706641,
0.8720964193,
0.7627676725,
-0.4751753211,
-0.4916106761,
-0.3741319478,
0.0113781467,
-0.6207880378,
0.5618779063,
0.1354249567,
-0.0872906521,
0.0142515069,
-0.9388777018,
-0.5730078816,
0.9198651314,
-0.1153894588,
-0.6808222532,
-0.0365232304,
0.2375595719,
0.3003827035,
-0.6020397544,
-0.1949275434,
0.2696206868,
0.6691977382,
0.1200864315,
-0.7253943086,
-0.3355053663,
0.1360277832,
-0.0758387446,
-0.0952739716,
-1.1125847101,
0.5453389287,
-0.4594710469,
-0.0257514324,
0.3830210268,
0.7340512872,
-0.2377470136,
0.4262875319,
0.5643344522,
0.2299729586,
0.2545444965,
0.0096777789,
1.0834790468,
-0.003189448,
0.1193748415,
1.2474864721,
-0.1053459719,
0.3922017515,
0.4211815596,
-0.1049690172,
0.403180033,
0.1828640997,
-0.2653452158,
0.8549928665,
0.0920207202,
-0.1534124911,
-0.9529559612,
-0.1320360899,
0.1439407766,
0.8224679232,
0.0512888096,
-0.096789144,
-0.0193917695,
0.533888936,
-0.3197170198,
0.0428339876,
-0.7966973782,
0.8238767982,
-0.2822237611,
-0.523853004,
0.1240534037,
-0.013537813,
0.1006002873,
-0.5718038678,
-0.019841807,
-0.1052034497,
0.0851704925,
-0.0131270969,
-0.8274239898,
0.3829495013,
-0.030205613,
-0.0928137079,
-0.2689494193,
0.3453095853,
-0.8672428727,
-0.5721843243,
-0.0764221251,
0.1977342665,
0.4349374771,
-0.2421597838,
-0.3250385821,
0.0499546565,
0.1682315767,
0.0328130499,
-0.0519240424,
0.2325794101,
-0.2985696793,
0.9710094333,
0.2466629446,
0.041676309,
0.4705768526,
0.3454883695,
0.7181714177,
-0.6656476855,
-0.6358984709,
-0.8727312684,
0.9072730541,
-0.1671123356,
-0.1561181992,
0.7475755811,
1.0021995306,
0.7329958081,
-0.2387317121,
1.0531637669,
-0.0443275794,
0.2208107561,
-0.6052716374,
0.1798604578,
-0.7524554729,
0.217174992,
0.0952354744,
-0.5266028047,
-0.3183630109,
0.1696385145,
0.1253013313,
-0.323477596,
0.3238885105,
0.631309092,
-0.2388831079,
-0.44004035,
0.5338815451,
0.1330531389,
0.4087809622,
0.587146759,
0.9664924741,
-0.2716979086,
0.9846976399,
-0.1022768915,
0.0454833955,
-0.3877575397,
-0.7357544303,
-0.8503665924,
-0.77488029,
-0.6740196347,
-0.0169341955,
0.0003006208,
0.279189229,
1.0427063704,
-0.6493769884,
-0.0274312794,
-0.1110593081,
0.0964346677,
-0.0548131019,
-0.3059374988,
0.1303415149,
0.0692360476,
-0.818594873,
0.2783791125,
0.6082133055,
0.2572151721,
-0.6300153732,
-0.3319521844,
0.0926437229,
0.0681856945,
0.4824505746,
0.2304038703,
-0.7533540726,
-0.5085324645,
-0.3164785802,
-0.2559628785,
0.1824250072,
0.8891561627,
-0.5573958755,
0.5605046749,
0.3235818148,
0.1525224596,
0.5527578592,
0.2966486216,
0.5896068811,
-0.9399473667,
0.364910543,
0.0068864538,
0.4529207945,
0.4769281149,
-0.1065698639,
0.2948988378,
0.3651499748,
-0.39059937,
-0.5886539221,
0.4566829801,
-1.3775737286,
-0.2983329892,
1.2357190847,
0.1306566298,
-0.2048274279,
-0.4413591027,
-0.2548978329,
-0.097730726,
-0.4620043039,
0.6904122829,
0.154588297,
0.1505858749,
-0.3947006166,
-0.8359834552,
0.5038421154,
0.0075452612,
-0.4954939485,
0.1935967356,
0.6650344729,
0.1010686979,
-0.0999881476,
0.6234520078,
0.0452069789,
0.4196529686,
-0.488671422,
0.1148945838,
-0.5246097445,
-0.6935396194,
-0.2914685309,
0.305847019,
-0.417876333,
-0.5286403298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09260v1
|
JaFIn: Japanese Financial Instruction Dataset
| 2024-04-14T14:01:53 | 2024-04-14T14:01:53 |
Kota Tanabe, Masahiro Suzuki, Hiroki Sakaji, Itsuki Noda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE
|
We construct an instruction dataset for the large language model (LLM) in the
Japanese finance domain. Domain adaptation of language models, including LLMs,
is receiving more attention as language models become more popular. This study
demonstrates the effectiveness of domain adaptation through instruction tuning.
To achieve this, we propose an instruction tuning data in Japanese called
JaFIn, the Japanese Financial Instruction Dataset. JaFIn is manually
constructed based on multiple data sources, including Japanese government
websites, which provide extensive financial knowledge. We then utilize JaFIn to
apply instruction tuning for several LLMs, demonstrating that our models
specialized in finance have better domain adaptability than the original
models. The financial-specialized LLMs created were evaluated using a
quantitative Japanese financial benchmark and qualitative response comparisons,
showing improved performance over the originals.
|
[
-0.2842302322,
-0.9103091955,
0.2400508672,
-0.0639808923,
-0.2023703307,
0.1904482543,
-0.3441907763,
-0.1814931184,
-0.1549872756,
0.9743397236,
-0.6516785026,
-0.7481164932,
-0.5962131619,
-0.0273001771,
-0.0660457835,
1.0263233185,
-0.0361710973,
0.0782185271,
-0.2259318531,
0.1512413174,
-0.5767574906,
-0.1417207122,
-1.0678315163,
-0.3519403636,
0.1964661479,
0.7412598133,
0.8102345467,
0.7255166769,
0.7404338121,
0.3579996228,
0.5385546088,
-0.0219173394,
-0.6249957085,
-0.1278736442,
-0.2508833706,
-0.8186352849,
-0.6823120713,
-0.1649568081,
0.7462469935,
0.8172668815,
-0.1558275819,
0.2628810108,
-0.1946070492,
0.881459713,
-0.760482192,
0.7549364567,
-0.3474055827,
-0.0147733353,
-0.3820082545,
-0.4302037656,
-0.5560984015,
-0.4786444902,
0.3164486885,
-1.0295621157,
0.1982193589,
0.3483601809,
0.5297922492,
0.1291703731,
-0.4852865934,
-0.3285665512,
-0.5676361322,
0.6973842382,
-0.6818151474,
0.4077009261,
0.5879223943,
0.5149237514,
-0.4005808234,
-0.4785121977,
0.0066221948,
0.0162350275,
0.1169469655,
0.3028447628,
-0.0210662577,
0.1273847222,
0.3573080003,
0.4110991657,
-0.4774349332,
0.2449151576,
-0.3071090281,
-0.0051775509,
0.8046341538,
0.3458307385,
0.1837287396,
0.1095990613,
-0.3011292517,
-0.637155056,
-0.5937979817,
-0.2199457437,
0.508235395,
0.6356188059,
-0.3309409022,
0.2704761326,
-0.0933826268,
0.8710657954,
0.0294103958,
-0.8622634411,
0.0199534167,
0.0372887589,
-0.4428294301,
0.4887195528,
0.3882542551,
0.4502338469,
0.6172144413,
0.1084623039,
-0.2689386904,
-0.5415325761,
0.2803865075,
-0.440374583,
-0.1872742921,
-0.2941307425,
-0.2864319086,
0.023608366,
0.2752952278,
-0.7917537689,
-0.191253081,
-0.4069347382,
0.473263979,
-0.2642230988,
-0.136161834,
0.4916583896,
-0.337091893,
0.4739046991,
0.1527642161,
-1.1393482685,
0.6990860701,
0.7822518945,
0.6219826341,
0.0192305297,
-0.0790189579,
-0.0671311095,
0.5423333049,
-0.4909834266,
0.6889152527,
-0.71477139,
-0.8458336592,
-0.0868432745,
0.3410995305,
-0.3728758395,
-0.3562207222,
0.0995794833,
-0.6247422695,
0.3897748888,
-0.1308960319,
-0.8736695647,
-0.3755738437,
-0.0680824444,
-0.6288861632,
0.585283041,
0.4873593748,
-0.5844192505,
0.2113091499,
-1.1275857687,
-0.5340663791,
0.2069514245,
0.3141855299,
-0.5860610604,
0.0096513396,
0.2371628284,
0.3217001557,
-0.6090139747,
0.2649258077,
-0.5119990706,
-0.6481881142,
0.5599657297,
-0.5268949866,
0.5534088016,
0.1116791964,
-0.1527600735,
-0.3878193796,
-0.8994047642,
-0.2551841736,
0.3186311424,
0.0511656739,
-0.9041965604,
-0.0672084168,
-0.4007939994,
-0.5473761559,
0.3121938109,
-0.1096525788,
0.2615579665,
-0.5745925903,
-0.0029931765,
1.1557879448,
0.3785754144,
0.388348043,
-0.4018602073,
0.9461016059,
-0.0857526287,
0.3163919151,
-0.3406016529,
-0.2021045536,
-1.0723180771,
-0.036729034,
0.3912328184,
0.4759016931,
-0.6179667711,
0.14213489,
-0.2760454714,
-0.1801445484,
-0.4843515456,
0.1062263325,
0.4358793497,
0.5744049549,
-0.1236861274,
-0.2182263434,
-0.4781396389,
-1.0374982357,
-0.0835252926,
0.156909436,
0.2445549071,
0.3345364928,
0.452298224,
0.0927534848,
0.4476824403,
-0.8877784014,
0.1314473003,
0.0248087253,
-0.0576732941,
0.5063060522,
0.3012152016,
0.7488439679,
-0.5326515436,
-0.5698103905,
0.2348013073,
-0.6346918344,
0.0587887019,
-0.3264325559,
-0.4218145311,
-0.0993096754,
0.2450629324,
0.3437174857,
0.181168288,
0.3346218169,
-0.4744257033,
0.0901511312,
-0.1827732176,
0.3687942624,
-1.1872719526,
0.0079707587,
0.2286723554,
-0.5544989705,
-0.3979062438,
0.0768552423,
-0.0078355204,
-0.1456606835,
-0.210559532,
0.5950699449,
-0.4194645584,
-0.5799428225,
-0.5481856465,
0.069757469,
-0.0288616233,
0.5431292057,
-0.1538196653,
1.2860844135,
0.6471657157,
-0.7504187822,
0.5487294197,
0.3332386613,
-0.716191411,
0.6238851547,
-0.4809410572,
0.1056953371,
-0.0868394077,
-0.1981705725,
-0.8004880548,
-0.5773309469,
0.4698581398,
0.1875825226,
0.5231835842,
-0.0661300123,
-0.1996409297,
-0.3271606565,
-0.0517576225,
0.0053902399,
0.4735279083,
-0.5157415867,
0.2084708363,
0.3911278248,
-0.7181104422,
-0.5272254944,
-0.5298504829,
-0.1885177493,
-0.3098339438,
-0.1377355158,
0.0929611772,
-0.0927757919,
-0.2609368861,
0.0519454703,
-0.0435924679,
0.0259533543,
0.5560328364,
0.2204698026,
0.7646633387,
-0.7535344958,
0.0118236542,
0.4571795464,
-0.2917776704,
0.1781480312,
-0.2849481106,
0.1195037588,
0.0917499214,
-0.3085451424,
-0.2469911575,
-0.0755561814,
0.4267439842,
0.4399339855,
0.7142858505,
0.0509360358,
-0.0705376342,
-0.3087207675,
-0.3052870929,
0.192323789,
-0.5788787603,
0.2834365964,
-0.4845479429,
-1.0741032362,
0.3521553576,
-0.3192594647,
0.184757039,
0.6199886203,
0.3730399013,
0.1004037932,
0.8865026236,
0.9402603507,
-0.261135906,
0.626054287,
-0.0269103609,
-0.0163067579,
-0.6045449376,
-0.1777280122,
-0.3943178058,
-0.3140164316,
-0.4875408113,
-0.1711264253,
0.4564342797,
-0.1302745789,
-0.4889074862,
0.2351815253,
-0.0346106105,
0.9409538507,
0.3869461119,
0.0678147078,
0.2259207815,
0.2507973015,
0.0443810746,
-0.0194734409,
-0.6891185641,
-0.2651093006,
1.4471652508,
0.4259549975,
0.9501469731,
0.0341843627,
0.2277981341,
0.5281279087,
0.4120776653,
-0.5769941807,
0.279417038,
-0.5467299819,
-0.5900384784,
-0.2199356109,
-0.6043353081,
-0.7137328982,
-0.2220284045,
-0.0207374394,
-0.2992813885,
-0.0706144869,
-0.246608451,
-0.3762749434,
-0.0721383542,
-0.6019064188,
0.7036421299,
-0.4056065083,
-0.1626091152,
-0.118299529,
-0.2085760236,
0.7527710199,
-0.5918058157,
0.3696433604,
-0.2753688693,
-0.0828515813,
1.0462578535,
-0.3800633252,
1.1125500202,
-0.2299018353,
-0.3962959945,
0.0034180908,
-0.3530120552,
0.2601593733,
0.2389195263,
-0.2606428862,
-0.1737864912,
-0.1707751453,
-0.4980034232,
-0.7460560203,
0.8529270291,
-1.159701705,
-0.8109529018,
-0.2600288093,
-0.714863658,
-0.5117192864,
0.1798780859,
-0.0995156392,
0.4316312969,
-0.3456526101,
0.1129981726,
0.7293698788,
-0.2252793163,
0.224740386,
1.0260510445,
-0.3077138662,
-0.6500343084,
0.8373206258,
-0.0224862769,
0.2275822461,
0.4908657968,
0.173850283,
-0.3752550781,
-0.1131403744,
-0.5070487857,
0.271546334,
-0.8205066919,
-0.2917616665,
0.1241726354,
-0.3752274215,
-0.525329411,
-0.5084375739,
-0.3179750144,
-0.3761253953,
-0.1829223037,
-0.1841537356,
0.8443187475,
0.7955980897,
0.1136492565,
0.676646769,
-0.7229322791,
0.3123599589,
0.2872087657,
0.6821004152,
-0.1575888097,
-0.8156337738,
-0.6208643317,
0.2050255835,
0.0673082173,
-0.4312831163,
0.1729933321,
0.5210672617,
0.7357558608,
0.7566006184,
0.0186743308,
1.082686305,
0.0254044812,
0.4142573476,
0.1732777804,
-0.909368217,
0.6888766289,
-0.2775432169,
0.5648980141,
0.5306805372,
0.6746799946,
-0.3926816285,
-0.3949079514,
-0.5238739252,
-0.4483528435,
0.9606553316,
-0.2966199219,
0.1876663119,
0.1923207045,
0.8708874583,
0.7363929152,
0.1329579204,
-0.34052068,
-0.4333642423,
-0.0476785861,
-0.2576934993,
-0.4548973739,
-0.1700209975,
-0.095830217,
-0.1670525372,
0.8588672876,
-0.3259629309,
0.1653012037,
-0.4151685536,
0.0259334408,
-0.3592529595,
0.0129748676,
0.3950788379,
0.6966632605,
-0.1032357141,
-0.2006212622,
0.2537588179,
-0.4276340008,
0.3001849651,
-0.096228458,
-0.2250095457,
-0.091919668,
0.5096307397,
1.3971011639,
0.9990460873,
-0.6859619617,
0.2532593012,
-0.1262259483,
-0.4068009257,
-0.4139735401,
0.8540863395,
-0.1076390669,
0.177227214,
0.1342836916,
-0.2045369297,
0.0563263148,
-0.6036390066,
0.1007838547,
0.0328302495,
-0.1142808646,
-0.1128554121,
0.6076233983,
0.0764777437,
-0.0965047702,
0.8202584386,
0.3343459964,
-0.1372136921,
0.7525182962,
1.0800818205,
0.7853190303,
-0.3371346891,
0.2877850533,
0.4994101822,
-0.0391745754,
-0.3948555589,
0.328315556,
-0.0884109661,
-0.6826199293,
-0.4448887408,
-0.724116385,
-0.796274662,
-0.0129024247,
-1.2019302845,
0.2225102037,
-0.9786260724,
-0.2768602967,
-0.022003023,
0.1781543046,
-0.5892415047,
0.3491008878,
0.2368918061,
0.8854678869,
-0.9763638973,
0.7830651999,
0.642234385,
0.0006032074,
-0.3862846792,
-0.3519620001,
-0.1031326801,
-1.1268459558,
0.2902033627,
-0.1895855516,
-0.0836319029,
0.1960253865,
-0.5608885884,
-1.1181211472,
1.1198006868,
0.5642565489,
-1.1709780693,
0.2530175447,
0.4035314023,
0.1870131791,
-0.4856454134,
-0.0542464852,
0.8358361125,
0.696156323,
0.0543079823,
-0.3918272257,
-0.3464569449,
-0.2792421281,
0.218737334,
0.431812942,
-0.8951628208,
0.3181329966,
0.0252663661,
-0.1328721792,
-0.1268899888,
0.6464883685,
0.1301708817,
0.4262697995,
0.3840135336,
0.2924788892,
1.0076541901,
-0.1827600598,
0.994396925,
-0.5217552185,
0.1525096297,
1.0010632277,
-0.3351324499,
0.6387738585,
-0.1075571775,
-0.3876552582,
0.6237800717,
0.5941005945,
-0.3317005038,
0.5742157698,
0.0118429754,
-0.137530297,
-0.3514283299,
-0.0201429743,
-0.3774495125,
0.608289063,
0.550889194,
-0.3033665121,
0.1383688301,
0.3316256702,
-0.0037668191,
-0.0337810069,
-0.5466032624,
0.9348003268,
0.3091941774,
-0.5843376517,
0.2273600549,
0.2730051279,
0.1636533737,
-0.9445261955,
0.2454243749,
-0.5058717132,
0.2127669454,
0.2496416867,
-0.6169313788,
0.2715797722,
0.2807117403,
-0.3454965353,
-0.2209108621,
0.7423471212,
-0.1902231872,
-0.929556489,
0.0937936604,
0.2268097252,
0.1193066388,
0.7089432478,
-0.8292523623,
0.0474103056,
0.0631561726,
-0.3782097101,
0.5723617077,
0.392703414,
0.0166836139,
0.5925089121,
0.7685323954,
-0.0173921473,
-0.1813620627,
0.4086638391,
0.5883145928,
-1.0697374344,
-0.5432649851,
-0.6473959088,
0.0251410585,
-0.0364283025,
-0.5116667151,
0.9065512419,
0.5807236433,
1.0016367435,
-0.2150564641,
0.9456489682,
0.6486313343,
0.3169403672,
-0.9430872202,
0.4908435345,
-0.4933067858,
0.3013457954,
-0.1533067822,
-0.870978117,
-0.3117265403,
0.652926147,
-0.4347915351,
0.0018424974,
0.3651132286,
0.7422110438,
-0.2853517532,
0.4274739027,
0.4326465428,
0.2026769221,
-0.2010604292,
0.7441555262,
0.5932421088,
-0.5248800516,
-0.1131670326,
-0.3398234546,
-0.0716675967,
-0.3873903155,
-0.7144750357,
-0.9279984832,
-0.2247419357,
-0.7018630505,
0.2416997105,
0.4569641352,
0.7848883867,
0.3880369067,
-0.9058238864,
-0.5557911992,
0.2343860269,
0.0583701432,
-0.1719917655,
-0.2421290576,
0.1921294332,
-0.3527721465,
-0.8306717277,
0.7091119885,
0.5718231797,
0.2259604186,
-0.2322164625,
-0.1700490117,
0.3494309187,
0.3345572352,
0.2581027746,
0.090745315,
-0.1155538261,
-0.2509417832,
-0.0091970311,
-0.1601171494,
-0.0909043923,
0.8132645488,
-0.1850411445,
0.5428027511,
0.1776691973,
0.6063315272,
0.4770540893,
-0.0419796444,
1.0015819073,
-0.557525456,
0.2149932534,
-0.3854146004,
0.3264679313,
0.1170975566,
-0.4862706065,
0.4768121839,
0.1428192556,
-0.3213868141,
-0.3637946248,
-0.2291346341,
-0.7621459365,
-0.5250249505,
0.7888772488,
-0.2407781333,
-0.7822267413,
-0.0294338465,
0.0763810799,
0.1738877594,
-0.2960312068,
0.6722180843,
0.7343301773,
0.3577448428,
-0.3289070129,
-0.6207851171,
0.0867578983,
0.1098999083,
-0.6650153399,
-0.0460509844,
0.3154961467,
0.4794861078,
-0.4685017467,
0.4321353734,
0.0136900796,
0.4780694544,
0.217815578,
-0.1615777463,
-0.2734511197,
-0.2784641683,
-0.3159608245,
0.2111877054,
0.266707629,
0.0343748219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09249v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09249v1
|
Test Code Generation for Telecom Software Systems using Two-Stage Generative Model
| 2024-04-14T13:25:15 | 2024-04-14T13:25:15 |
Mohamad Nabeel, Doumitrou Daniil Nimara, Tahar Zanouda
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In recent years, the evolution of Telecom towards achieving intelligent,
autonomous, and open networks has led to an increasingly complex Telecom
Software system, supporting various heterogeneous deployment scenarios, with
multi-standard and multi-vendor support. As a result, it becomes a challenge
for large-scale Telecom software companies to develop and test software for all
deployment scenarios. To address these challenges, we propose a framework for
Automated Test Generation for large-scale Telecom Software systems. We begin by
generating Test Case Input data for test scenarios observed using a time-series
Generative model trained on historical Telecom Network data during field
trials. Additionally, the time-series Generative model helps in preserving the
privacy of Telecom data. The generated time-series software performance data
are then utilized with test descriptions written in natural language to
generate Test Script using the Generative Large Language Model. Our
comprehensive experiments on public datasets and Telecom datasets obtained from
operational Telecom Networks demonstrate that the framework can effectively
generate comprehensive test case data input and useful test code.
|
[
-0.5292763114,
-0.7558943629,
0.0601131506,
0.4769318998,
-0.1167459562,
-0.3469153643,
0.1774271131,
-0.143270269,
-0.146814242,
0.7080485821,
-0.5710095763,
-0.3426297903,
0.1430177242,
0.0651875213,
-0.6772272587,
0.9843717813,
-0.161324814,
-0.2188723981,
0.2484017462,
0.0490829274,
-0.3093727827,
-0.4564014375,
-0.3136472404,
-0.3378652334,
-0.1489846706,
0.4003277421,
0.5070893764,
0.120798178,
0.2049963027,
0.2015428245,
0.3247220814,
-0.0823228583,
-0.1023556069,
0.3199981749,
0.2625498474,
-0.4465279877,
-0.2685919702,
-0.1562154442,
0.5855336785,
0.4826397896,
-0.5543153286,
0.5704078078,
-0.0807516351,
0.2382231057,
-0.3034005463,
0.2491327524,
-0.652130425,
0.3077971935,
-0.2063847482,
-0.3276446164,
-0.5007740855,
-0.6064660549,
-0.002135287,
-0.4836017489,
0.3403621614,
0.0495345071,
0.8991748691,
-0.0030862661,
-0.8315258026,
-0.0367399976,
-1.0143923759,
0.7333504558,
-0.7128144503,
0.287425369,
0.1482784003,
0.6796474457,
-0.2259527296,
-0.4932349324,
-0.6153888106,
-0.5194911957,
0.4224905074,
0.1657491773,
0.0881174728,
-0.2700798512,
0.4738148749,
0.3666529655,
-0.7119843364,
0.248898983,
-0.6240522265,
-0.1105014458,
0.725549221,
0.2974716723,
0.1283559799,
-0.1532158256,
-0.2906316817,
0.1401174814,
-0.9050735831,
-0.1321697384,
0.5821944475,
0.1896627545,
-0.143524155,
0.9580663443,
-0.294005245,
0.6985571384,
-0.2490248531,
0.0589160286,
0.1714530736,
-0.3115786314,
-0.5449262857,
0.0640064552,
0.5333536863,
0.4012170732,
0.4159624279,
-0.1476994753,
-0.2736451924,
0.4337722957,
0.5342695713,
-1.0085754395,
-0.110425204,
0.3675824106,
-0.4643953443,
-0.8392581344,
0.1357649267,
-0.9751859307,
-0.1266658306,
-0.2264878154,
0.1929271221,
-0.194000423,
-0.6320447326,
0.1922109425,
0.0657820776,
0.6161063313,
-0.1596520245,
-0.3909710348,
0.3037358224,
0.4916890562,
0.5631830096,
-0.0160192978,
-0.2946027219,
-0.8102147579,
0.3225105703,
-0.5625338554,
0.1475652903,
0.0320200883,
-0.4106811881,
0.295075804,
-0.114629522,
0.0207276028,
-0.5484519601,
0.0733265728,
-0.873663187,
0.3675429523,
0.5221424699,
-0.3948325515,
0.2064975053,
0.1322963536,
-0.4996528029,
1.1556193829,
0.2095860839,
-0.6677885056,
0.2730519772,
-0.9565742612,
-0.4487096965,
-0.0145215904,
-0.1434628218,
-0.7938971519,
-0.2543225586,
-0.0769014508,
0.3493013084,
-0.5061738491,
0.2361171544,
-0.5079182982,
-0.1977952868,
0.3200632632,
0.0110088959,
0.7786605358,
0.3696361184,
-0.8501231074,
-0.3362081349,
-0.8010200858,
0.5127521157,
0.1208701953,
-0.2513274252,
-0.0456307903,
0.1112705767,
0.266144067,
0.1692108363,
-0.2562037706,
-0.8674070239,
0.0881272033,
-0.3287527263,
0.4481497407,
0.4995721579,
0.0885496587,
0.2934100032,
-0.0448532067,
0.7704773545,
0.3326880634,
0.6507360339,
-0.3271166086,
-0.3223825991,
-0.8363085985,
0.2995918691,
0.4630780518,
0.8538407087,
-0.7011374235,
0.6893930435,
-0.2912020087,
-0.4170935452,
0.1835363209,
0.1214025617,
0.3337738514,
0.2420811355,
-0.033652395,
-0.3082172275,
-0.303586036,
-0.8511523008,
0.4813777506,
-0.2158902586,
-0.3675226569,
0.1859898269,
0.426843226,
-0.2899217606,
0.9286177158,
-0.8815505505,
-0.4243527949,
-0.1725009531,
0.2208328545,
-0.1859124601,
0.3641497493,
0.5654827952,
-1.0228233337,
0.2920061648,
0.1231286153,
-0.6357937455,
-0.2291898429,
0.073577106,
0.0697897151,
0.2866927385,
0.5675595999,
-0.0653127879,
0.4119566381,
0.8514071107,
-0.2880199254,
0.8373582959,
-0.162368983,
0.0096927034,
-1.4400043488,
0.1830019802,
0.0292064007,
0.0065627806,
-0.3147664368,
0.096516341,
-0.0366234668,
-0.798781395,
-0.2981695831,
0.0440590903,
-0.2141262889,
-0.4075998664,
0.0534512512,
-0.383671999,
-0.0782195702,
0.2099681497,
-0.2998475134,
0.9596177936,
0.430477947,
-0.9510106444,
0.3321821988,
0.0877543613,
-0.5298371315,
0.3554559648,
-0.832562089,
-0.1405007839,
0.198725611,
0.4289770722,
-0.8065305352,
-0.3946498632,
-0.1065249592,
-0.077228941,
-0.4097314477,
-0.3548001051,
-0.7842250466,
-0.5330439806,
0.2952896953,
0.3587981462,
0.761307478,
-0.3302189112,
0.4389944077,
0.4621373117,
-0.2634649873,
-0.107350409,
-0.7543314099,
0.1154955924,
-0.2434486896,
-0.8725044131,
0.2819809914,
0.1742738485,
-0.1189110354,
-0.2844471931,
0.1776326448,
-0.5636187196,
0.1315655261,
0.624132216,
0.3228237033,
-0.3314971924,
0.103970103,
0.0210051369,
0.0199767128,
0.3389004171,
-0.7691006064,
0.5161713362,
-0.015837254,
-0.540114522,
-0.2515013516,
0.748722136,
0.6672611833,
-0.4955998063,
0.1968508363,
0.4753405452,
-0.1480936408,
-0.795786798,
-0.4206103086,
-0.0111903157,
-0.4593764842,
0.1258672774,
-0.4286015928,
-0.5301809311,
0.5117221475,
-0.3274241388,
0.2647105157,
0.2303889543,
0.4484540224,
0.3944680095,
1.0123736858,
0.6551705003,
0.1657216996,
0.3762097955,
-0.4774027765,
0.3071205318,
-0.2568200827,
0.0290687885,
-0.3628192842,
0.1885701418,
-0.4484570026,
-0.000233248,
0.8345570564,
-0.1757912189,
-0.2715792656,
0.3888453841,
-0.3157178462,
0.223103255,
0.2404104769,
0.1361081302,
0.1453451961,
0.2015655488,
-0.542183876,
0.2133387625,
-0.4376285374,
-0.305434376,
1.1206258535,
0.1794935167,
0.7479043007,
0.3952666819,
0.5921567678,
0.4385335147,
0.1536989361,
-0.3580271006,
0.4051996171,
-0.0583434999,
-0.4537661672,
-0.2864225805,
-0.6654887199,
-0.8346668482,
-0.3218573034,
0.2786863446,
-0.2644302249,
-0.025994312,
0.1782160103,
-0.5299510956,
0.0900475904,
-0.8791952729,
0.7214629054,
0.1050129384,
-0.0533601455,
-0.1057847068,
-0.4839571714,
0.6094626784,
-0.4402012825,
-0.1295598894,
0.2681555152,
0.2979516983,
0.4725967944,
-0.6041995287,
0.7601866722,
-0.2948046029,
-0.2641479671,
0.3403184116,
0.3480852246,
0.343393147,
0.276037395,
-0.397685796,
-0.0100306347,
0.000145373,
-0.2170838416,
-0.3402942419,
0.3808998466,
-0.3919888139,
-0.0509443805,
-0.1831672937,
-0.3769199252,
-0.1637403071,
0.2374450862,
0.3884204626,
0.8681917787,
-0.2501745224,
-0.1225011423,
0.7620326281,
-0.3563943803,
0.2371992469,
0.4209132195,
-0.5386302471,
-0.1456038505,
0.5578547716,
0.0348433219,
0.5380995274,
-0.1122656539,
-0.1534853578,
-0.391086489,
-0.4941772819,
-0.6038917899,
-0.2145814002,
-0.1834076345,
-0.2680261433,
-0.4842787683,
-0.4184158742,
-0.425083667,
-0.0369187556,
-0.4409398139,
-0.2790891528,
0.1305744499,
0.2187488526,
0.3464181721,
0.7448987365,
0.2610681057,
0.315593183,
-0.6781873107,
0.5282984972,
0.3162813485,
0.4634498656,
-0.2057701349,
-0.0760378465,
-0.013286368,
-0.0371282175,
-0.751930356,
-0.5352187157,
0.3220269978,
0.1583610028,
0.0738839954,
0.1820212454,
0.3141281307,
0.3878000379,
-0.5978161097,
0.9589207768,
0.2631703615,
-0.9786625504,
0.755518198,
-0.5471999049,
0.1073929891,
0.1554323435,
-0.2088013738,
-0.3222386241,
-0.4121956229,
-0.6019227505,
-0.7022299767,
0.4968119562,
0.2986681461,
0.2177480757,
0.3428412676,
0.2912329733,
0.1013042182,
0.1298908889,
-0.3797998428,
0.0128659569,
-0.358046174,
0.021274494,
0.012984884,
0.0360718556,
-0.3928208947,
0.1549883634,
0.2566724718,
-0.2345366627,
0.2945780754,
0.218904838,
0.1503074765,
-0.0363062955,
0.4425692558,
0.6342733502,
0.7767772675,
-0.0235444997,
-0.2592783272,
0.139274016,
-0.4427735209,
0.4310498536,
0.4419108629,
-0.4019879997,
0.1807478368,
-0.3359996974,
0.4555240571,
-0.0168571752,
-0.4766285419,
0.7124804258,
-0.0633372217,
-0.4306876361,
-1.052072525,
0.3182228804,
-0.0905962363,
0.0388736129,
0.4775931239,
-0.1107812002,
0.1093080044,
-0.2706917524,
0.6365055442,
0.0839181989,
0.065613389,
-0.2567184865,
0.9071287513,
0.4350468516,
-0.0777075887,
0.6723415852,
-0.4472343028,
-0.5961300731,
1.0222767591,
0.6964635849,
0.7902151346,
-0.3087412715,
0.452555716,
0.1462785304,
0.1351322979,
-0.1737948507,
0.4047089219,
0.1599410474,
-0.3430030048,
-0.6865641475,
-0.6876225471,
-0.2446976006,
0.3507055342,
-0.6065627337,
0.4323621988,
-0.4362630844,
-0.2198162228,
0.0501282699,
-0.2277619541,
-0.7192018628,
0.3096077144,
-0.0968801677,
1.000007391,
-0.7501323223,
0.7555705309,
0.4255457819,
-0.1583723426,
-1.1464025974,
0.3250170946,
-0.2157741189,
-0.501583457,
1.1262081861,
0.1130243987,
0.1469264627,
0.2753887177,
-0.040362291,
-0.4012957513,
1.0331571102,
0.0944576934,
-0.3846879601,
-0.013951255,
0.5084928274,
0.3610433638,
-0.4517727196,
0.1673760861,
0.0858866051,
0.3259295225,
0.0211084504,
-1.013982296,
-0.0657312945,
-0.3916078806,
0.3433793783,
0.6051385403,
-0.4682976604,
0.7691085935,
-0.2786487341,
-0.2639600933,
0.0545521602,
0.3321289122,
-0.0507221483,
0.2744958997,
0.8997907639,
0.4016276896,
0.1368968487,
-0.0952411368,
1.1265437603,
-0.1870376319,
0.2555353343,
0.7687166333,
-0.8053843379,
0.5582675934,
0.0521482602,
-0.0995228067,
0.3957272768,
0.447432518,
-0.4517392814,
0.2206128389,
0.6191781759,
-0.2378080189,
-0.1162025779,
0.0222695265,
-0.5134815574,
0.66805619,
-0.1285958439,
-0.3527198434,
-0.508125484,
0.0829974562,
-0.124424547,
-0.3836896718,
0.0255821422,
0.5209095478,
-0.0719363317,
-0.8968413472,
0.6515384912,
0.2030896544,
0.3894681036,
-0.9118939638,
-0.1087982953,
-0.0934686437,
0.3598140478,
-0.0982422009,
-0.5803807974,
0.4217358232,
0.166794613,
-0.0699869245,
-0.0596418455,
0.2974151075,
-0.1788975,
-0.5718520284,
0.1478326619,
0.1439957768,
0.0783376917,
0.0332842134,
-0.4432359934,
0.0056474027,
0.0180155728,
-0.164354369,
0.0695749,
0.3082684278,
-0.0377940349,
0.6955955029,
0.8182582259,
0.3034673929,
0.419302702,
0.3301249444,
0.6332813501,
-0.4780270755,
-0.8117899895,
-0.3595761061,
0.4558272958,
-0.195206359,
-0.6694445014,
0.5605467558,
0.7223902345,
0.588354826,
-0.156473428,
1.1176782846,
-0.2727796733,
0.1517586559,
-0.4800595939,
0.6334721446,
-0.3696621358,
0.2254314274,
-0.0062084747,
-0.7899658084,
-0.0965595245,
-0.0839633942,
0.0353598893,
-0.1296007782,
0.4543800056,
1.2161324024,
-0.457235992,
0.3427887559,
-0.005614792,
0.0507160313,
0.5565354228,
0.5935073495,
0.7993592024,
-0.7146323323,
0.8059344888,
-0.2367794514,
-0.4014838934,
-0.1895475686,
-0.7570171356,
-0.5125006437,
-0.6802979708,
-0.3440955877,
-0.8004361987,
-0.0409039408,
0.352896601,
0.8178614974,
-0.6165068746,
-0.2995171547,
-0.4474698603,
-0.4073545635,
-0.2448286861,
-0.3831891119,
0.0107069463,
-0.3726483881,
-0.5834745169,
-0.0271987244,
0.0685827211,
0.2074472308,
-0.7030851245,
0.0825288892,
0.472653389,
-0.1814794391,
0.5541968942,
0.1078524217,
-0.32787323,
-0.1458078474,
0.0760741159,
-0.0810572058,
-0.4460247159,
1.0506951809,
-0.4856697023,
0.1359126568,
0.184996143,
0.4243697524,
0.2936959863,
-0.1054496616,
1.031639576,
-0.6413733959,
0.0875149369,
0.2659143806,
0.0329926871,
0.0033564712,
-0.4605617225,
0.6570885181,
-0.0326834954,
-0.6482117772,
-1.1266371012,
0.575710237,
-1.038066864,
0.1245121136,
1.4177930355,
-0.1238103062,
0.0667846501,
-0.3411495388,
0.1151979491,
0.3640507758,
-0.0245828815,
0.9419673681,
0.3709512055,
0.0717310831,
0.3572687805,
-0.6634821296,
0.2722735405,
0.3013490438,
-1.1207646132,
0.3111291826,
0.4301475585,
0.640430212,
0.1003971845,
0.3368131816,
-0.4535932541,
0.3134809732,
0.0934754312,
0.0980876014,
-0.2323563248,
-0.1028615609,
0.0417759307,
0.3827747703,
-0.311470896,
-0.4898177087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09248v1
|
Knowledgeable Agents by Offline Reinforcement Learning from Large Language Model Rollouts
| 2024-04-14T13:19:40 | 2024-04-14T13:19:40 |
Jing-Cheng Pang, Si-Hang Yang, Kaiyuan Li, Jiaji Zhang, Xiong-Hui Chen, Nan Tang, Yang Yu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement learning (RL) trains agents to accomplish complex tasks through
environmental interaction data, but its capacity is also limited by the scope
of the available data. To obtain a knowledgeable agent, a promising approach is
to leverage the knowledge from large language models (LLMs). Despite previous
studies combining LLMs with RL, seamless integration of the two components
remains challenging due to their semantic gap. This paper introduces a novel
method, Knowledgeable Agents from Language Model Rollouts (KALM), which
extracts knowledge from LLMs in the form of imaginary rollouts that can be
easily learned by the agent through offline reinforcement learning methods. The
primary challenge of KALM lies in LLM grounding, as LLMs are inherently limited
to textual data, whereas environmental data often comprise numerical vectors
unseen to LLMs. To address this, KALM fine-tunes the LLM to perform various
tasks based on environmental data, including bidirectional translation between
natural language descriptions of skills and their corresponding rollout data.
This grounding process enhances the LLM's comprehension of environmental
dynamics, enabling it to generate diverse and meaningful imaginary rollouts
that reflect novel skills. Initial empirical evaluations on the CLEVR-Robot
environment demonstrate that KALM enables agents to complete complex
rephrasings of task goals and extend their capabilities to novel tasks
requiring unprecedented optimal behaviors. KALM achieves a success rate of 46%
in executing tasks with unseen goals, substantially surpassing the 26% success
rate achieved by baseline methods. Furthermore, KALM effectively enables the
LLM to comprehend environmental dynamics, resulting in the generation of
meaningful imaginary rollouts that reflect novel skills and demonstrate the
seamless integration of large language models and reinforcement learning.
|
[
-0.3345499337,
-0.7827121615,
0.7850240469,
-0.1223039925,
-0.0073553491,
0.5578228831,
-0.4215351641,
-0.3286673725,
0.0317159332,
0.7592663765,
-0.7427480817,
-0.5476413369,
-0.3960594833,
-0.3398562074,
-0.1236542687,
1.2070307732,
-0.0862943307,
-0.2479590625,
-0.2120601684,
-0.239756152,
-0.3159191012,
-0.3567670584,
-0.3512968421,
-0.8481906652,
0.4660682976,
0.4558264911,
0.5925798416,
0.3083538115,
0.152874276,
0.3335351348,
-0.1910263896,
0.6204024553,
-0.6211941242,
-0.0637360811,
-0.4334789515,
-0.4174002111,
-0.1811986715,
-0.0720234364,
0.6774852872,
0.4870438576,
-0.2351784259,
-0.0906234309,
0.05117682,
0.7632478476,
-0.4798810482,
0.563110292,
-0.7768973708,
0.2664560974,
0.1718412638,
-0.2661393285,
-0.5506989956,
-0.314121753,
0.1701076925,
-0.963545382,
-0.2455968112,
-0.1214131564,
0.8474174142,
0.317409277,
-0.6381161809,
-0.6412374377,
-0.8874976635,
0.7425143719,
-0.7513463497,
0.199384138,
0.2545065284,
0.6056959629,
-0.4422084093,
-0.5646851063,
-0.6321522593,
-0.5482946038,
0.0256917644,
0.1972849369,
0.1235193089,
0.1562623233,
0.1199792251,
0.0701170117,
-0.2025104165,
0.1516851485,
-0.2152029723,
-0.0506702811,
0.4983404279,
0.0196464341,
0.2423498034,
0.1432566494,
-0.4083561003,
-0.3623713851,
-0.5924112797,
0.3709687293,
0.3692942262,
0.6111881137,
-0.0532156713,
0.6609536409,
-0.3041835725,
0.5122888684,
0.0050754626,
-0.2995210588,
0.3367835283,
-0.003230202,
0.0828772709,
-0.0847973377,
0.2435955405,
0.0674520805,
0.0801142529,
-0.2528646886,
-0.6045449972,
-0.3608621657,
0.4095756114,
-0.2385169864,
0.0328164473,
0.0899384618,
-0.2484433055,
-0.4200592339,
0.0982039422,
-0.6717554927,
-0.4232212007,
-0.5073670745,
0.6420778632,
-0.4122775495,
-0.4306305945,
-0.1846356392,
-0.1628645658,
0.3199945986,
0.3957471251,
-0.3907774687,
0.2230338752,
0.671800077,
0.9014019966,
0.1703578234,
-0.2879718542,
-0.6815077066,
0.2039979994,
-0.2171069682,
0.7641387582,
-0.2706787586,
-0.1319857389,
0.3190018833,
-0.0213530399,
-0.2102611065,
-0.450856179,
0.1636973619,
-1.0366197824,
0.008526911,
-0.013217153,
-0.6557887793,
-0.5347431302,
0.5829882026,
-0.5285125375,
0.8654721975,
0.3186127245,
-0.362395972,
0.3054838777,
-0.9770238996,
-0.2277063131,
0.1017675027,
0.0999286771,
-0.5342261791,
-0.1374149323,
-0.16897282,
0.4282377958,
0.1709463447,
0.1854532957,
-0.4375698566,
-0.0399014503,
0.1977260113,
0.1822549552,
0.4897783399,
0.1913440377,
-0.5693391562,
0.2064900696,
-0.4862775207,
0.3463406265,
0.1901557744,
-0.4443110824,
-0.3324314356,
0.0599602349,
0.0422423892,
0.6139580607,
0.3090770543,
-0.2531641722,
0.1352246702,
-0.5060683489,
0.3768043518,
0.6986953616,
0.0744877979,
0.4472410977,
-0.5873314738,
0.6425423026,
-0.2037169188,
-0.0347922966,
-0.032675907,
-0.3246798515,
-0.6386275887,
-0.4010335207,
-0.1365635991,
0.5979929566,
-1.0920469761,
0.6126518846,
-0.2291205674,
-0.8334324956,
-0.0298282672,
0.3422839046,
0.6815629601,
0.2963658273,
0.2723618746,
0.255856365,
-0.3244350255,
-0.4594800174,
-0.2711399794,
-0.273088336,
0.1872576326,
0.6511579156,
0.7111554146,
-0.3861477375,
1.0152467489,
-0.5222088695,
-0.5155682564,
-0.5869184732,
0.3558648527,
0.092711769,
0.1995600909,
0.1083626598,
-0.8556185365,
-0.4321197867,
0.3876699805,
-0.7215250731,
0.0751366243,
-0.1936504543,
-0.0697799549,
0.3032352626,
0.5653848648,
-0.7640019655,
0.1884004027,
0.4213755131,
-0.5048657656,
0.3489461839,
-0.7868342996,
-0.1108587906,
-0.7488241196,
0.0669740662,
-0.2057611793,
-0.5622658134,
-0.8296992183,
0.1649989188,
0.0744342133,
0.0800140798,
-0.8138939142,
0.7193245292,
-0.5459603071,
-0.3232019842,
-0.3338620365,
0.4163944721,
-0.0504483208,
0.6634509563,
0.1877232343,
0.2599551082,
0.2102626115,
-0.7889377475,
0.3100597262,
0.377492249,
-0.1273926347,
0.0995982364,
-0.3508146107,
0.0646983534,
-0.3316025734,
0.5456779599,
-0.6038243771,
-0.1605797708,
0.1886329502,
-0.1405118853,
0.0639809296,
0.0655941144,
-0.4966739118,
-0.0709293634,
-0.1229410321,
0.1375691146,
0.7986739278,
-0.6525301933,
0.8406897187,
0.6129510999,
0.1104853749,
-0.2565522194,
-0.330163151,
-0.2506706715,
-0.488207072,
-0.306932956,
0.0250041336,
0.2249920517,
-0.2254353166,
0.0010528615,
0.1693825424,
-0.0878530815,
0.0331995413,
0.3199512661,
0.1049896181,
-0.0014459955,
0.23640953,
-0.1551615745,
0.0092952084,
0.1196970195,
-0.3680894971,
0.4421824515,
-0.2147347331,
-0.4110501409,
0.0932068974,
-0.1124071255,
0.802708149,
-0.1566662043,
0.9745726585,
0.4875761867,
-0.2943322957,
-0.5971460938,
-0.3108259141,
-0.1639775336,
-0.4041223824,
0.4884062707,
-0.2649747133,
-0.6499428749,
0.55680722,
-0.4806359708,
0.2847414613,
0.3389075994,
0.4551600516,
-0.1963231564,
1.1141382456,
0.7213667631,
0.1637171507,
0.538577199,
-0.5333397985,
0.1826667637,
-0.5989877582,
-0.705021739,
-0.1660246551,
0.0005249713,
-0.4710023105,
-0.6744087338,
0.3489916623,
0.0112836733,
-0.1748903245,
0.1709815115,
-0.0979543701,
0.275631398,
0.3998731077,
0.42698282,
0.2190186083,
-0.1141853854,
-0.1867568046,
0.254532665,
-0.6178899407,
-0.6183547378,
0.9587823153,
0.5433363914,
0.442109853,
0.1817119718,
0.4275587797,
0.7173377275,
0.2745060921,
-0.6792988777,
0.4806002975,
0.1715234369,
-0.3622640371,
-0.5188392997,
-0.4075622559,
-0.7366814613,
0.2451980412,
-0.302187413,
-0.4714929163,
-0.1699203998,
0.2176569402,
-0.1354214847,
0.472292155,
-0.4270135462,
0.7014859319,
-0.3624055386,
-0.032161314,
-0.5809441805,
-0.6952705979,
0.4168177545,
-0.4564038515,
0.5174182653,
-0.2291702777,
-0.2813445926,
0.5646281242,
-0.5061821938,
0.8613177538,
-0.6117196083,
-0.3164166808,
0.2886174917,
-0.2060735673,
1.1610872746,
-0.1106532812,
0.2216105759,
0.1118125618,
-0.1475711018,
-0.4206643999,
-0.9131342769,
0.5635190606,
-0.9612109065,
-0.2734623253,
-0.3741809428,
-0.7644556761,
-0.3669320345,
0.1806220114,
-0.0578159578,
0.1713428348,
-0.1671799421,
-0.1255480945,
0.8350957036,
-0.3133636713,
0.2641206682,
0.8272463083,
-0.4167207479,
-0.3645581603,
1.081064105,
0.1176714301,
0.6096948981,
0.4717307389,
0.1540409327,
-0.5832489729,
-0.256742388,
-0.1779181957,
0.1263940781,
-0.8687132001,
-0.0451381803,
-0.8635528684,
-0.3321996033,
-0.0637152791,
-0.3837015629,
-0.4374099374,
-0.1683751494,
0.0187572911,
-0.1006983295,
0.4219397008,
1.0957630873,
-0.0747427195,
0.2223606259,
-0.7898094058,
0.2751873434,
0.2529830635,
0.0582917295,
-0.0461714678,
-0.7142894268,
-0.4774532616,
0.3388229609,
-0.207666114,
-0.7907927036,
0.5513312221,
0.3627450466,
0.8272996545,
0.5730657578,
0.2467291206,
0.5114116073,
-0.3406814635,
0.4293073118,
-0.1466214657,
-0.8540560603,
0.5834900141,
-0.5410815477,
0.2686728835,
0.3757854998,
0.170060575,
-0.3768119216,
-0.6949034929,
-0.6316590905,
-1.0240364075,
0.8562535644,
0.2594277263,
0.0241045617,
0.2262118459,
0.1255926937,
0.1765253693,
0.2035556287,
-0.6325508356,
-0.0815215632,
-0.1371490955,
-0.1012995467,
-0.4706212878,
0.051659707,
-0.0533146113,
0.1178326905,
1.0860900879,
-0.2500950098,
0.0566178001,
-0.029065391,
-0.5080051422,
0.0171763394,
0.2770970166,
0.7934495807,
0.560447216,
-0.2604200244,
0.1557337791,
0.5570116639,
-0.2102698535,
0.4887301326,
-0.194171384,
-0.206048578,
-0.0859311298,
0.3826773763,
0.6574081779,
0.2947580516,
-1.2728642225,
0.3439786136,
0.078550294,
-0.2440727055,
-0.6811594367,
0.0577506237,
-0.0873130485,
0.5018838048,
0.2165814936,
0.008355435,
-0.1082593575,
-0.3631389737,
0.3279033005,
0.5616868734,
-0.5116730928,
-0.2480655313,
0.1558961719,
0.196638003,
-0.1683603227,
0.5382181406,
-0.4110264182,
-0.7271426916,
0.7679823637,
0.5438335538,
0.6868391633,
0.1034920737,
0.5540801287,
0.2134285271,
0.1309185922,
-0.2267890573,
0.0773737133,
-0.1515605599,
-0.716332078,
-0.26003021,
-0.1808685064,
-0.5443114638,
0.0507752784,
-0.6193702817,
0.3356858492,
-0.5035972595,
0.0411188789,
-0.4961080253,
0.0955440477,
-0.6105408669,
0.1367760748,
0.2039385736,
0.7900341749,
-1.2749644518,
0.6283474565,
1.1504164934,
-0.3899744153,
-0.9012325406,
0.0293131433,
0.0785141066,
-0.7837920189,
0.927883327,
0.1900376081,
-0.0672339872,
0.2452718616,
-0.1281031519,
-0.9358743429,
1.1812551022,
0.3178572953,
-0.2641575634,
-0.0009933496,
0.2703310251,
0.4373230636,
-0.4891672432,
0.5389502645,
0.2761902213,
0.6291386485,
0.1593482941,
-0.6205365062,
0.1304935515,
-0.1657863855,
0.0284190848,
0.2573443949,
-0.6765490174,
0.4809616804,
-0.2318684161,
-0.0427497625,
-0.3035473228,
0.667704761,
0.6249011159,
0.4387283027,
0.9489129186,
0.4765720963,
0.8711798191,
0.1766979694,
0.7313482761,
-0.3735324442,
0.4252469838,
0.9217436314,
-0.2979958653,
0.7683804035,
0.4187817872,
-0.0074580568,
0.6583692431,
0.4655811489,
0.2810425758,
0.9215422869,
0.2991046906,
-0.573923409,
-0.32872805,
-0.344352603,
-0.1387074292,
0.3882539272,
0.2016389817,
-0.0725251287,
-0.4784190953,
0.5014541149,
0.0383996814,
0.3241174221,
-0.439835012,
1.0698049068,
0.0264511108,
-0.7475523949,
0.2615058422,
-0.0472926199,
0.4280723631,
-0.7220653296,
-0.398761034,
0.0209346041,
0.5121126175,
-0.2097103447,
-0.6318996549,
0.3040193617,
-0.135380134,
-0.2224824876,
-0.3784804046,
0.6017817855,
-0.5589827895,
-0.2745678425,
0.4877372682,
0.5628997087,
0.1553292274,
-0.0157754086,
-0.5330955982,
-0.3379318714,
-0.1180991605,
-0.328576684,
0.4204853475,
0.5404958129,
-0.1815456897,
1.0230584145,
0.7255365849,
0.344747901,
0.103382118,
-0.1902952343,
0.9721877575,
-0.568333745,
-0.7391962409,
-0.6834641695,
0.748758018,
-0.0200867448,
0.0071743256,
0.7525731325,
0.3023991883,
0.7255440354,
-0.2168326378,
0.8731454611,
-0.0480011851,
0.5735285282,
-0.7116327286,
0.8052657843,
-0.4453096986,
0.2147808075,
-0.0291287806,
-0.7552309036,
0.1063952073,
0.3084970713,
-0.3619723022,
0.1573866457,
0.5361173153,
0.7084403634,
0.0756700858,
-0.4355870187,
0.5736452341,
0.0803939924,
0.5059229732,
0.5643321276,
1.1151274443,
-0.0164999422,
0.5530639291,
-0.2106930614,
-0.2355804443,
-0.261117816,
-0.8909012675,
-1.1162971258,
-0.61319381,
-0.2891279757,
-0.3475661278,
0.3069585562,
1.1761981249,
0.8463760614,
-0.782725811,
0.053601522,
-0.5450409055,
0.2927805781,
-0.2772733867,
-0.2418025583,
0.0872902349,
-0.6269436479,
-0.3450365961,
0.4846021533,
-0.0174061395,
-0.0976605937,
-0.4252769947,
-0.717643857,
-0.2791942954,
0.1647337377,
0.4407867789,
0.6475883126,
-0.776465416,
-0.126974389,
-0.2534997165,
-0.0146943843,
-0.233822003,
0.62064147,
-0.858694315,
0.1967032105,
0.4472567439,
0.6896864772,
0.2732820511,
-0.0090935584,
0.7314760685,
-0.7108740807,
0.1424196661,
0.1135621518,
0.1122195497,
0.1751886755,
-0.4609497488,
0.224151656,
-0.0886093825,
-0.5986089706,
-0.854732275,
0.0204520095,
-0.5478557944,
-0.1932361871,
1.28606987,
-0.596406877,
-0.142885536,
-0.3216939569,
-0.1802252978,
0.4132287204,
-0.3801059127,
0.769261241,
0.4343122244,
-0.0172917433,
-0.2020663917,
-0.648537159,
0.4469361305,
0.3269814849,
-1.1631399393,
-0.0496423207,
0.2683256269,
0.1384298801,
0.0953753442,
0.364333123,
0.2712155879,
0.0184009299,
-0.2388566434,
0.363838166,
-0.3528809547,
-0.2821358442,
-0.4703623056,
0.0704649538,
0.3091139197,
-0.0374836661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09221v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09221v2
|
Exploring and Improving Drafts in Blockwise Parallel Decoding
| 2024-04-14T11:49:38 | 2024-06-05T05:00:35 |
Taehyeon Kim, Ananda Theertha Suresh, Kishore Papineni, Michael Riley, Sanjiv Kumar, Adrian Benton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite the remarkable strides made by autoregressive language models, their
potential is often hampered by the slow inference speeds inherent in sequential
token generation. Blockwise parallel decoding (BPD) was proposed by Stern et
al. as a method to improve inference speed of language models by simultaneously
predicting multiple future tokens, termed block drafts, which are subsequently
verified and conditionally accepted by the autoregressive model. This paper
contributes to the understanding and improvement of block drafts in two ways.
First, we analyze the token distributions produced by multiple prediction
heads. Secondly, we leverage this analysis to develop algorithms to improve BPD
inference speed by refining the block drafts using n-gram and neural language
models. Experiments demonstrate that refined block drafts yield a +5-21%
increase in block efficiency (i.e., the number of accepted tokens from the
block draft) across diverse datasets.
|
[
-0.6014527082,
-0.7861227989,
0.5451637506,
0.4896277785,
-0.6089060307,
0.2942449749,
-0.2414197475,
-0.5623884201,
0.0856905058,
0.4837785065,
-0.4847624302,
-0.3071395457,
-0.9629898667,
0.1878856122,
-0.3795734942,
0.7032119632,
-0.1118622795,
0.1595354527,
0.1040283963,
0.1674256474,
-0.5183435678,
-0.4538614452,
-0.8552376032,
-0.4207024872,
0.1952067018,
0.2145936042,
0.4592634141,
1.1889933348,
0.5235313177,
0.3324684799,
-0.0841402486,
0.1215301305,
-0.2855331898,
0.2488346249,
-0.1443827152,
-0.1608719975,
-0.3952983618,
-0.1806744337,
0.6491265893,
0.873226285,
0.0803265274,
0.0251436867,
0.0237771887,
0.9418336749,
-0.5804741979,
0.3605418801,
-0.6531968117,
-0.1127146184,
-0.3010087609,
-0.2897301912,
-0.5192693472,
-0.3205951154,
0.1619984806,
-0.2384988517,
0.5667473078,
0.2362523973,
0.4055015743,
-0.0001713392,
-0.0979086459,
-0.0758882314,
-0.4027274847,
0.4925656319,
-0.6337743402,
0.5246264935,
0.500115335,
0.2695332766,
-0.2853755057,
-0.8519529104,
-0.5434936285,
0.1490894258,
-0.0149629833,
-0.1992581934,
0.0436631292,
0.4252327681,
0.2299660742,
0.4122993946,
-0.5246011615,
0.0729212612,
-0.3251351714,
-0.4672207832,
0.9066565037,
0.2679601908,
-0.1929760873,
-0.2881834507,
-0.1545773,
-0.4089407921,
-0.4112507403,
0.0447764508,
0.6375621557,
0.3109234869,
0.013337086,
0.2548038661,
-0.5612601042,
1.2374134064,
0.2099550813,
0.0055770483,
0.310962826,
-0.6833620667,
-0.3138189018,
-0.1863920689,
0.4521382749,
0.4452027082,
0.1208502874,
-0.1485468596,
-0.3264887333,
-0.0581424423,
0.1772083789,
-0.9390986562,
-0.5976604223,
0.6150082946,
-1.042787075,
-0.1641551256,
0.0569645613,
-0.7492120862,
-0.4690797329,
-0.442874074,
0.0696638227,
-0.6064751744,
-0.484847188,
0.5015561581,
-0.6962624788,
-0.1198783293,
0.3328197002,
-1.0626089573,
0.3827622533,
0.8003300428,
0.7290281057,
-0.2540987134,
-0.5182756186,
-0.542171061,
-0.2125414908,
-0.3859457076,
1.2399306297,
-0.4370398819,
-0.4174683094,
-0.2183842957,
-0.3109693527,
-0.149444133,
-0.6196358204,
0.294457525,
-0.370798111,
-0.658554554,
-0.3949933946,
-0.514834702,
-0.015944507,
0.0647806153,
-0.615193665,
0.6124524474,
-0.0322241522,
-0.9107774496,
0.5221874714,
-0.4297914803,
-0.4735609293,
-0.1217420101,
0.0606589541,
-0.2614308,
0.5364996791,
0.5383940935,
0.5148230195,
-0.2277418822,
0.3564435244,
-0.3309072554,
-0.3016132414,
0.099459976,
-0.2887710035,
0.6719270945,
0.4545148313,
-0.2734428346,
0.2007221133,
-0.9043372273,
0.1889403164,
-0.1747451425,
-0.1884848326,
-0.1331674308,
0.0377233177,
0.0416220836,
0.0088198064,
-0.1849193424,
-0.6231607795,
0.0573280379,
-0.1070405245,
0.2989583313,
1.0537345409,
0.1944137961,
0.3084814548,
-0.4401333928,
0.314298749,
0.0838467553,
0.1590169817,
-0.3938807547,
-0.4977135956,
-0.5864579678,
-0.4643148482,
0.5585337281,
0.0574407727,
-0.6410280466,
0.3425923586,
0.0593532845,
-0.2990468442,
-0.6364629269,
-0.0351160578,
0.6040782928,
0.345499903,
0.3245505989,
-0.7219656706,
-0.7905042768,
-0.7898064852,
-0.5821867585,
-0.4774158299,
0.309155494,
-0.040013995,
0.1970946938,
0.1038792953,
0.6347860694,
-0.3980870843,
0.2919010818,
-0.3947444856,
0.7361957431,
0.019464964,
0.7660190463,
0.2383493334,
-0.3881702423,
-0.5644550323,
-0.1384093612,
-0.2877025604,
-0.3410250843,
-0.213738814,
-0.5252177715,
0.1430688053,
0.754745245,
-0.3141015768,
0.6067746878,
0.4988610744,
-0.6455035806,
0.7610891461,
-0.2393736243,
-0.1616801769,
-0.5177792907,
-0.1612201333,
-0.272613138,
-0.2757183313,
-0.6572758555,
0.1505728513,
0.2833185196,
0.2147094011,
-0.0871293768,
0.3815985322,
-1.0058504343,
-0.2485389709,
-0.7327955961,
-0.161211431,
0.0046204408,
0.1794530302,
0.3218521774,
0.5784544945,
0.7086969018,
-0.5565914512,
0.0654989928,
0.0024281635,
-0.3511972725,
0.3669101,
-0.5754634738,
0.2223764062,
-0.6092944145,
0.4376025498,
-0.8749907613,
0.0472414866,
0.0610648729,
-0.2358307242,
0.3588228524,
-0.161775887,
-0.5196222663,
-0.5180844665,
-0.3782450259,
0.5692987442,
0.4760844707,
-0.4773551226,
0.3958317339,
0.3649974465,
-0.0221528132,
-0.5986890793,
-0.7137391567,
-0.2448637336,
0.3849912286,
-0.546253562,
0.3264722824,
-0.3190886974,
-0.3905289173,
0.2432332933,
-0.2897500098,
-0.0986322463,
-0.0546336062,
0.0875800923,
0.0053278897,
-0.0299818479,
-0.1823820621,
0.1016114652,
-0.2373567969,
0.1156723052,
-0.8213738799,
0.8024365306,
0.1242812425,
-0.2719456255,
-0.4535157681,
0.4732200801,
0.3185800314,
-0.4052260518,
0.6696223617,
0.5357820988,
-0.229894504,
-0.4319195151,
-0.8898993134,
-0.2296817899,
-0.4570755363,
0.0742931366,
-0.7373256683,
-0.6284819245,
0.6832458377,
0.0908281282,
-0.0808056295,
0.2646126449,
0.4708001018,
0.323830694,
0.7126889825,
0.8941750526,
0.1236749217,
0.49549824,
-0.4715902507,
0.0672734603,
-1.0126391649,
-0.3190137744,
-0.4956912994,
-0.3803858757,
-0.4042239785,
-0.6622366905,
-0.0759875551,
0.2475455254,
0.1731880158,
0.2806666791,
-0.4531241357,
0.6155686378,
0.747289598,
0.2236701995,
0.4121543765,
0.0164232049,
-0.4625118971,
0.2774846852,
-0.6010050774,
-0.0059272279,
1.4613133669,
0.1932684034,
0.3424327075,
-0.2294964939,
0.9078646898,
0.1588253379,
0.3268122077,
-0.3799501956,
0.3899433315,
0.0680460185,
-0.6692345142,
-0.1400294304,
-0.3354670703,
-0.7563188672,
0.4839735031,
-0.1224041656,
-0.7189115286,
0.7173959613,
0.3091356754,
-0.2777753472,
0.3152008355,
-0.7629817128,
0.8660126328,
0.2107093185,
-0.265480727,
-0.6353476644,
-0.4811028838,
0.5273687243,
-0.1875737458,
0.0722547099,
-0.3232548535,
0.1427251995,
0.4812262952,
-0.8027606606,
0.4254180193,
-0.4365460873,
0.194483757,
0.3968341649,
0.0259276032,
0.6951431632,
0.0699271932,
-0.4933190048,
0.1340016127,
-0.3044330776,
-0.7371628881,
-0.4877251983,
0.4558749497,
-0.7164732218,
-0.47842291,
-0.2074599117,
-0.9301502705,
-0.1125510782,
0.2534707487,
0.2588940263,
0.7279545665,
0.0355159156,
-0.3104098737,
0.3179946244,
0.0810875148,
0.8444800973,
0.3088667691,
-0.1457754821,
-0.475361824,
0.5863569975,
0.1550415158,
0.4403874278,
0.175640747,
0.0147927497,
-0.4602054358,
-1.5632514954,
-0.2708469927,
0.3172253966,
-0.6791251898,
-0.1597138047,
-0.7734240294,
-0.1044650376,
-0.5530042052,
-0.0538373515,
-0.2579142153,
-0.5607534051,
0.3219296038,
-0.3450706005,
0.3276110888,
0.8093294501,
-0.5607619286,
0.2932056785,
-0.4314751327,
0.5901950002,
0.1077015996,
0.5726937056,
0.2735392153,
-0.3056616485,
-0.1546479166,
-0.326587826,
-0.0130437994,
-0.7734575272,
0.3629923463,
-0.252256453,
0.6518856883,
0.4297307432,
0.1848234981,
0.9958020449,
-0.5544884801,
0.3894004524,
0.161158368,
-1.1375594139,
0.2796954513,
-0.1447474211,
0.3338086903,
0.6106240749,
0.057619486,
-0.4940714538,
-0.4470216334,
-0.5988874435,
-0.7507631779,
0.8337060213,
0.2487894297,
-0.3444364369,
-0.1857169569,
0.1672626138,
0.5587707162,
0.3530793488,
-0.0675468072,
-0.3701620996,
-0.404473573,
0.0387497917,
-0.0703809261,
-0.4659224749,
0.2886990011,
-0.4653120637,
0.5070078373,
-0.0215624645,
0.5051729083,
0.3800461888,
0.0794223174,
-0.0139854215,
-0.0939795971,
0.3927454948,
0.9508618712,
-0.3661144078,
0.2635304034,
-0.1975264102,
-0.623400867,
0.113294825,
0.4340244532,
-0.0341831632,
0.2043634802,
0.2704980969,
1.0083696842,
-0.4850207269,
-0.5243833661,
0.3001315296,
-0.3420805633,
-0.3107426167,
0.0313315988,
-0.2901718915,
-0.0173287261,
0.3103723228,
0.3753043115,
0.4509311914,
0.2516272068,
-0.3832841218,
0.3057073653,
0.3605368733,
0.1905122399,
-0.3057145476,
0.5971490145,
0.2919617891,
-0.3090887964,
0.7318605781,
-0.5000116229,
-0.2639306486,
0.6611104608,
0.6608269215,
1.1643693447,
0.0900973454,
0.1692216396,
0.3547758758,
0.3504459858,
-0.3372679353,
0.6958631277,
-0.2730796933,
-0.7892135978,
-0.6814723015,
-0.7073974013,
-0.3125701547,
0.0521801226,
-0.5618920922,
-0.050461594,
-0.8531889915,
-0.3186627924,
0.0189720914,
0.0227290075,
-0.7990144491,
-0.0677939728,
0.1693833619,
1.2375676632,
-0.7047777772,
1.0097385645,
0.3988415897,
-0.0318267606,
-0.7888021469,
0.3325430751,
-0.0995684341,
-0.732177794,
0.712325871,
0.0529046282,
-0.0641699657,
0.2093518227,
-0.0334897712,
-0.9319735169,
0.7475919127,
0.2273505628,
-0.4339273274,
0.2525638342,
-0.136076957,
0.3390543759,
-0.4438520372,
0.4219154119,
0.8376152515,
0.6989196539,
-0.3512834311,
-0.9644380212,
0.2257006466,
-0.4793183804,
0.4239168167,
0.2265497893,
-0.5053395033,
1.0537695885,
-0.2363514602,
-0.1398202479,
0.1807240248,
0.7965451479,
0.2903969288,
0.3398535848,
0.5250972509,
0.5319291949,
0.8679602742,
-0.0029035707,
1.2499681711,
-0.6507325768,
-0.0967467278,
0.7513422966,
0.0993718356,
0.8577703238,
0.4205481112,
0.0043890784,
0.6947347522,
0.6387694478,
0.2401712984,
0.647074163,
0.5405546427,
-0.2627654672,
-0.1440711021,
-0.0897061452,
-0.2786375284,
0.1313708872,
0.2998286784,
-0.3129534125,
-0.1449493468,
-0.0728290826,
-0.237461701,
0.2279535532,
-0.4837910831,
0.486230284,
-0.0787584335,
-0.9078014493,
0.8453563452,
0.4099421203,
0.7022589445,
-0.3021668792,
0.1868942678,
-0.4577590525,
0.2733703852,
-0.0037956471,
-0.5461708307,
0.4290303886,
-0.0171976164,
-0.2703140676,
-0.5954697728,
0.6425593495,
-0.3086680174,
-0.4266366959,
0.4157718718,
0.6910328269,
0.3311336339,
-0.2181554139,
-0.627425611,
0.6656461954,
-0.1833366752,
0.0022531149,
0.1617627591,
0.5874863267,
-0.0006247465,
0.392726928,
0.8098523021,
0.4020907581,
0.4377797544,
0.0095857251,
0.7858276963,
-0.758838594,
-0.5860118866,
-0.9662216306,
0.3880216181,
-0.2804194987,
-0.2791323662,
0.7178964615,
0.473908633,
1.2042837143,
-0.1720898151,
0.9595547915,
-0.051847741,
0.4039667249,
-0.6782936454,
0.4927998781,
0.0587270111,
0.1265486628,
-0.1909834594,
-0.6777579188,
-0.1998455375,
0.4050617218,
-0.149351716,
-0.2407641709,
1.1959475279,
0.7498759627,
-0.0120073147,
0.1244865507,
0.0542855784,
0.1006301269,
0.1338587701,
0.4929099083,
0.6749145389,
-0.3585437238,
0.3777315617,
-0.7323458791,
-0.0628663376,
-0.1900387853,
-1.0156424046,
-1.1780287027,
-0.5134584904,
-0.246436879,
-0.3323749304,
0.4666725397,
0.9077007771,
0.9183222651,
-0.7556753159,
-0.5987103581,
-0.6823688149,
0.2115153223,
-0.6731800437,
-0.162549749,
0.3557821512,
-0.600805223,
-0.8616473675,
0.4560987949,
0.1251493245,
0.0497196391,
-0.1418225169,
-0.0406174585,
0.0725610331,
0.2401873916,
0.5098521113,
0.2105215192,
-0.5341418386,
-0.177493751,
-0.1984428167,
0.107849285,
-0.0918349028,
1.323969245,
-0.9652776718,
0.571629107,
1.1415256262,
0.7259917259,
0.7505623102,
0.251015842,
0.988787055,
-0.4363424778,
0.4960407615,
-0.1644763649,
0.2640402317,
0.2861186862,
-0.1630413681,
0.2667187154,
0.4566535354,
-0.2027256042,
-0.8479127288,
0.3796372712,
-0.5309650302,
-0.6298635006,
0.8217638135,
-0.096135363,
-0.3559997082,
-0.4853005409,
0.0171211567,
0.0844531134,
-0.4656030238,
0.7106906772,
0.6792838573,
-0.3783061206,
-0.0922926888,
-0.4093948901,
0.6826984286,
0.428817749,
-0.4448494911,
0.5058099031,
0.4877872467,
0.0198148657,
-0.2022502273,
1.3075163364,
-0.1193903685,
0.3477889895,
0.4237992465,
-0.061041221,
-0.429286927,
-0.5724799633,
-0.4468915164,
0.2233270109,
0.3091180921,
-0.2909920216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09220v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09220v1
|
Compass: Large Multilingual Language Model for South-east Asia
| 2024-04-14T11:48:33 | 2024-04-14T11:48:33 |
Sophia Maria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have exhibited significant proficiency in languages
endowed with extensive linguistic resources, such as English and Chinese.
Nevertheless, their effectiveness notably diminishes when applied to languages
characterized by limited linguistic resources, particularly within the
Southeast Asian linguistic landscape, such as Indonesian. The scarcity of
linguistic resources for these languages presents challenges associated with
inadequate training, restricted vocabulary coverage, and challenging evaluation
processes. In response to these exigencies, we have introduced CompassLLM, a
large multilingual model specifically tailored for Southeast Asian languages,
with the primary aim of supporting the developmental requirements of Shopee.
Our methodology encompasses several key strategies. To progressively enhance
multilingual proficiencies, we implemented a multi-stage pre-training strategy
integrated with curriculum learning, gradually intensifying the focus on
low-resource languages. Concurrently, to better accommodate low-resource human
instructions, we curated and generated a repository of high-quality
multilingual human instructions, culminating the CompassLLM-SFT model through
supervised instruction fine-tuning. Finally, to reinforce the model's alignment
with human preference behaviors, we have embraced the principle of Direct
Preference Optimization (DPO) to obtain CompassLLM-DPO model. Preliminary
evaluation of the CompassLLM model yields promising results, with our model
surpassing benchmark models like Vicuna-7b-v1.5, Sealion, Falcon and SeaLLM,
across diverse evaluation tasks, as verified through both automated and
human-driven assessments. Notably, our model exhibits its superior performance
in South-east Asia languages, such as Indonesian language.
|
[
-0.395735532,
-0.1695076972,
0.2913023829,
0.3782995343,
-0.2646028399,
0.2248602211,
-0.7118393779,
-0.3771381974,
-0.0203075986,
0.7033526897,
-0.5794337392,
-0.4153321385,
-0.3868441284,
0.3616254926,
0.0921159685,
0.6148359776,
-0.0337791219,
0.3742361367,
0.4436360598,
-0.3679606915,
-0.46514377,
-0.6485273242,
-0.5912786722,
-0.2989923954,
0.3085117936,
0.9167254567,
0.7357196808,
0.7276294231,
0.3933674097,
0.2344626188,
0.0016935511,
0.0066887368,
-0.4211542606,
0.0208771452,
-0.2828189731,
-0.4645583034,
-0.5513487458,
0.2351134866,
0.5310768485,
0.8101453781,
-0.1098617911,
0.2404942811,
0.1230072081,
0.7288984656,
-0.4120976031,
0.3024226725,
-0.4986729324,
-0.2211993188,
-0.0887142569,
0.1439236999,
-0.3999596238,
-0.2763053775,
0.315893352,
-0.645986557,
-0.0541241877,
0.0716606155,
0.7766547799,
-0.1126832739,
-0.6625463367,
-0.1726983637,
-0.6722123623,
1.2260016203,
-0.5198254585,
0.4831850827,
0.4682090878,
0.3647274971,
0.0939779654,
-0.0818084553,
-0.419084847,
-0.3329849541,
0.107129626,
0.0373425037,
0.300978452,
0.1762107313,
-0.0895805508,
0.2423019409,
-0.709394753,
0.1579881907,
-0.2359726727,
0.2239238769,
0.7597746849,
0.1149584055,
0.3101744056,
-0.30763188,
-0.3520671725,
-0.246533826,
-0.9769980907,
-0.2460921854,
0.4112809002,
0.6815549135,
0.1302752942,
0.7544394135,
-0.1805679947,
0.6463678479,
0.0976263955,
-0.5633035898,
0.0428283773,
-0.4710284173,
-0.0079832328,
0.0892599672,
0.4064497352,
0.4643165767,
0.0967855081,
0.0635045543,
-0.1389406025,
0.0344793871,
-0.2400059104,
-0.707079649,
-0.2204562724,
0.167942211,
-0.4746080935,
-0.0997515544,
0.0326623544,
-0.9897325039,
-0.5215657949,
-0.6527708769,
-0.0376935117,
-0.2320313901,
-0.9810711145,
0.1925087571,
0.1788156331,
0.413035661,
0.1277426928,
-0.7918426991,
0.0485582799,
0.6363440156,
0.760730803,
-0.2779362798,
-0.6574700475,
-0.2635605931,
0.3377373219,
-0.2969655395,
0.579241693,
-0.8067327142,
-0.4893217981,
0.124380663,
0.3448411524,
-0.0903127939,
-0.5830511451,
0.5568419695,
-0.300770551,
0.111161381,
-0.3791567683,
-0.1513424665,
-0.373849839,
0.2423631549,
-0.7190951705,
0.9425415397,
0.4162510335,
-0.4789065719,
0.5759567022,
-0.6648153067,
-0.559743464,
0.1023456752,
-0.0388192721,
-0.3118268251,
0.0266951136,
0.1192937195,
0.3518513143,
-0.5191310644,
0.1935906708,
-0.2892781794,
-0.310375303,
0.056473881,
-0.2235613465,
0.8841804862,
0.3410112858,
-0.4791810513,
0.327406019,
-0.8023491502,
0.2226572633,
0.2564771175,
-0.2786965072,
-0.5603168011,
-0.3413849473,
0.3120512068,
0.3715529442,
0.2926901281,
-0.3657409549,
0.305975467,
-0.5089306235,
0.470934391,
0.6111915708,
-0.2452479899,
0.812943995,
-0.1253244877,
0.8002986908,
0.1337684095,
0.1255858094,
-0.3324544132,
-0.1416228712,
-0.9239336252,
-0.3711722493,
-0.0966490582,
0.7613949776,
-0.6569912434,
0.2560999393,
-0.0875947252,
-0.5082660317,
-0.5336444378,
0.3298511207,
0.4172542989,
0.0934533179,
0.314109534,
-0.0686424747,
-0.6993450522,
-0.6553401947,
-0.2769855261,
-0.1409323812,
-0.0691305622,
0.2303947061,
0.0993067697,
-0.3455016613,
0.6098896861,
-0.391481787,
-0.4884750545,
-0.7946538329,
-0.0251329094,
0.4202807248,
0.3266838789,
0.5986012816,
-0.6277635694,
-0.5841744542,
0.2153915316,
-0.3299100399,
-0.3307325542,
-0.00812387,
-0.1044337526,
0.3776227534,
0.2835816145,
-0.5593666434,
0.2899002135,
0.6623447537,
-0.1606726199,
0.9494654536,
-0.2574917972,
0.1839319021,
-1.1099888086,
0.1234867796,
-0.0508659072,
0.122800447,
-0.6504091024,
0.2860917151,
-0.0008770082,
-0.5167171955,
-0.3965726197,
0.6189405322,
-0.8074390292,
-0.016854763,
-0.4187461734,
0.3794805706,
0.0463130735,
0.5140889883,
0.4765180647,
0.9090405107,
0.2953211963,
-0.6710938811,
0.328889966,
0.0295254085,
-0.0976494476,
0.9516877532,
-0.6262249947,
0.0020173583,
0.0847350284,
-0.1833013445,
-0.7961017489,
-0.1260253489,
0.1344208717,
0.0882703289,
0.470420599,
-0.3586749136,
-0.3542533517,
-0.4043883681,
-0.2631958723,
0.510696888,
0.0894282535,
-0.6428177357,
0.505715549,
0.5425165296,
-0.3648822606,
-0.4770244956,
-0.3813934922,
0.2015563846,
-0.4784819782,
-0.4937519729,
-0.1957172006,
0.1527898461,
-0.311083734,
-0.3787185848,
0.212623477,
-0.0860971808,
0.0204502475,
0.0550570786,
0.3977363408,
-0.3171772659,
0.1159063578,
0.0875651762,
-0.4586414099,
-0.0665567145,
-0.6081771255,
0.6029881835,
-0.4505403936,
-0.4707763791,
-0.2079283893,
0.3475206792,
0.5038753748,
-0.6240828037,
0.6651553512,
0.5929048061,
-0.1690273285,
0.0566239469,
-0.5880254507,
-0.2195682079,
-0.4481882155,
0.6342411041,
-0.5586093068,
-0.5879234672,
0.4211210608,
-0.4353258908,
0.039909035,
0.1489489228,
0.3805113733,
0.4700024128,
1.4397964478,
0.6778490543,
-0.3035601079,
0.3712981343,
-0.1736507714,
0.424654305,
-0.8166233897,
0.0101657128,
-0.6257808805,
0.113240853,
-0.6523878574,
-0.4165956378,
0.2972213626,
0.2726659179,
-0.4856392741,
0.3861624897,
-0.5904146433,
0.5438815951,
0.4054595828,
-0.1209952608,
0.6516491771,
-0.0491153002,
-0.3760489821,
-0.3150431216,
-0.9486446381,
-0.960401237,
1.1829488277,
0.1833925545,
0.979808569,
0.0785042495,
0.478833288,
-0.3232528269,
0.2804123759,
-0.586458087,
0.5019000769,
-0.1485987008,
-0.3756839931,
-0.3266114295,
-0.0576780774,
-0.9458967447,
0.4747625589,
-0.0679844394,
-0.3803537786,
-0.0220991224,
0.0090265702,
0.0009127719,
0.1944675148,
-0.8059731722,
0.9294241667,
-0.5850299597,
-0.445137471,
-0.3786503077,
-0.5976082683,
0.4381324649,
0.077976115,
0.282953918,
-0.2482558042,
-0.0979745016,
0.3917253017,
-0.3724490106,
0.727761507,
-0.2230257243,
0.0077231578,
0.2401877195,
0.1298960894,
0.1889474988,
0.2801756561,
-0.1422540545,
0.1779517382,
0.1859572828,
-0.6537256837,
-0.2478016317,
0.701818645,
-0.9261871576,
-0.5731723309,
-0.685539186,
-0.2368490547,
-0.1677190661,
0.6363725662,
0.0496018007,
-0.0530453473,
-0.3052929938,
-0.2951587439,
0.5926659107,
-0.4613905847,
0.0395317227,
0.704842627,
-0.7158794999,
-0.4517357647,
0.9458006024,
-0.1432120353,
0.3729683161,
0.0054474054,
0.2731001973,
-0.4064210951,
-0.271989435,
-0.7181429267,
0.6351943612,
-0.530000627,
-0.1610129625,
-0.1854434013,
-0.0748455897,
-0.2986218929,
-0.2142556459,
-0.577388525,
-0.2511526048,
-0.3409167528,
0.0317501202,
0.0730319396,
0.8461980224,
0.0016267156,
0.2604840696,
-0.6269960999,
-0.02110512,
0.205081895,
0.2352213115,
0.1816134602,
-0.2874989212,
-0.2231823057,
0.480505228,
-0.2299845666,
-0.6816751957,
0.4887826443,
0.2716159225,
0.444306761,
0.6249067783,
0.1710776091,
0.8871860504,
-0.3646211624,
0.6247529984,
0.1565342546,
-0.8587521315,
0.5343108773,
-0.29651317,
0.5712598562,
0.4602954388,
0.2874464095,
-0.8756815195,
-0.4006385803,
-0.1530140489,
-0.8072886467,
0.5279535055,
-0.480027169,
-0.0556769036,
-0.0443704166,
0.2872710526,
0.1935866922,
0.290247798,
-0.6440435052,
0.1287121624,
-0.449300468,
-0.0659978241,
-0.1647844017,
-0.2849310637,
-0.0705471635,
-0.1488120705,
0.7214087248,
-0.3417128623,
-0.0267056264,
0.0033606535,
-0.3671605885,
-0.1470087767,
0.3770146072,
0.6061806083,
1.0117303133,
0.2352025062,
-0.0156459566,
0.1393874586,
-0.5857673883,
0.2647150755,
0.0650196522,
-0.1377375573,
-0.1538529247,
0.0981756151,
0.5530709028,
0.3580781519,
-0.844186008,
0.4706724286,
-0.0525995381,
0.13381657,
-0.5781727433,
-0.2229553759,
-0.0176703092,
0.073761113,
0.5231918097,
-0.2855215967,
-0.1346186846,
-0.3018740416,
-0.1234421805,
0.4544820189,
-0.3171114028,
-0.4491544068,
0.6890413761,
0.3747540414,
0.0178280659,
0.6929526329,
-0.4155331254,
-0.9841137528,
0.2946132123,
0.5534191728,
0.7028516531,
-0.5991395712,
0.4161789715,
0.5643284917,
0.587705791,
-0.2420287728,
0.4212743938,
0.3666407466,
-0.4076723754,
-0.3948287964,
-0.5501271486,
-0.4009064734,
0.0432291627,
-0.6020990014,
0.7116086483,
-0.4350417256,
-0.0040781009,
-0.8171579838,
0.4975152016,
-0.7325977087,
-0.1243914962,
-0.3673337102,
0.8251355886,
-0.8998801112,
0.7924101353,
0.695798099,
-0.5157438517,
-0.9066380858,
-0.3100928366,
0.0488604307,
-0.8351417184,
0.6754011512,
0.3260462582,
-0.3047802448,
-0.1362130046,
-0.0859919861,
-0.8239256144,
0.9571465254,
0.2920324802,
-0.5206155181,
0.0518942215,
0.4784269333,
0.680948019,
-0.5377176404,
0.2472526878,
0.6334038377,
0.6338118911,
0.0487754717,
-1.0182654858,
0.0016336527,
0.0751677826,
0.2911257744,
0.1637293398,
-0.7852496505,
0.6800196767,
-0.5065899491,
-0.3600123823,
0.54164958,
0.5113040805,
0.4178302288,
0.197165519,
0.3045940995,
0.2402204722,
0.7673761249,
-0.0904271379,
0.5304716825,
-0.663058579,
0.1456645578,
1.081586957,
-0.7045255899,
0.8941130042,
0.473947078,
-0.2055074573,
0.1725063622,
0.6470662355,
0.2594919801,
0.226750806,
0.1261566281,
-0.2634033263,
-0.0734078437,
-0.3223424852,
-0.4563979506,
0.7278928757,
0.2741444707,
-0.0678679794,
0.1064216867,
0.2191930115,
0.3992962241,
0.2922669351,
-0.4987822473,
0.543366313,
-0.0573789999,
-0.64635849,
0.6100554466,
0.0839580595,
0.5897182226,
-0.4977954328,
0.0301866047,
-0.224593699,
0.4568938315,
-0.1352679431,
-0.4091869593,
0.1870683134,
-0.2083463073,
0.0357767828,
-0.1449627429,
0.6603525877,
-1.0523321629,
-0.7425510287,
0.2122544944,
0.4467395544,
-0.0814041272,
-0.0803352073,
-0.7187786102,
0.1527097672,
-0.2968070805,
0.0354297161,
0.3704448044,
0.3589752018,
-0.1519453377,
0.7803398967,
0.6853451133,
0.3427095115,
-0.0932408199,
0.0313195474,
0.6739551425,
-0.5272766948,
-0.6440836191,
-0.4790868163,
0.0281693581,
-0.2546178997,
-0.3176256716,
1.0747272968,
0.7172185779,
1.1000671387,
-0.1496144384,
0.8022720218,
0.3492328823,
0.8968743086,
-0.2653052807,
0.8238552809,
-0.3576794863,
0.3728596866,
-0.4738650024,
-1.2449398041,
-0.3769501746,
0.9578235745,
-0.3381482065,
0.1329574883,
0.6888291836,
0.7160790563,
0.0586083867,
0.1336030662,
0.1189849004,
0.0994365439,
0.2491299659,
0.81482023,
0.705816865,
-0.1795983166,
0.608443439,
-0.2570509911,
-0.5280028582,
-0.260605514,
-0.9753417969,
-1.103666544,
-0.6140148044,
-0.0660317317,
-0.2870115638,
-0.120565027,
1.0649780035,
0.6827872396,
-0.7377316356,
-0.8910142183,
0.205227524,
0.298222363,
-0.447611481,
-0.2032305896,
0.2320103645,
-0.2381233275,
-0.7146018744,
0.0808224231,
0.5806934237,
0.0284932442,
-0.8178444505,
-0.4494443834,
-0.2825659215,
-0.2919194698,
0.8256152272,
0.4532085657,
-0.7060233355,
-0.1332429796,
0.4064936936,
-0.1174243093,
-0.0844437703,
0.9888041019,
-0.4572113156,
0.5284916162,
0.0652815029,
0.5173009634,
0.2740642726,
-0.2012531161,
0.7631671429,
-0.2694435418,
0.5623791218,
0.1255385131,
0.1624371856,
0.4730503261,
-0.1553840339,
0.5326353312,
0.1716175377,
-0.5916261673,
-0.704985559,
0.4699973464,
-0.5999825597,
-0.2030522972,
1.2678248882,
-0.2496229708,
-0.2045345008,
-0.3453600705,
-0.6767683625,
0.0860871896,
-0.2127601206,
0.8208453655,
0.7752024531,
0.0994919315,
-0.3401755691,
-0.2043221742,
0.4642541707,
0.4533856511,
-0.5396190882,
0.4132323563,
0.509198308,
0.1544155627,
-0.0204552598,
0.2928826809,
-0.0551319569,
0.3493816555,
-0.2481238544,
-0.1888267547,
0.1415961683,
-0.3260554671,
-0.4059628546,
-0.1404945254,
0.629519105,
0.1406581998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09206v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09206v1
|
DKE-Research at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Incorporating Data Augmentation with Generative Models and Biomedical Knowledge to Enhance Inference Robustness
| 2024-04-14T10:02:47 | 2024-04-14T10:02:47 |
Yuqi Wang, Zeqiang Wang, Wei Wang, Qi Chen, Kaizhu Huang, Anh Nguyen, Suparna De
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Safe and reliable natural language inference is critical for extracting
insights from clinical trial reports but poses challenges due to biases in
large pre-trained language models. This paper presents a novel data
augmentation technique to improve model robustness for biomedical natural
language inference in clinical trials. By generating synthetic examples through
semantic perturbations and domain-specific vocabulary replacement and adding a
new task for numerical and quantitative reasoning, we introduce greater
diversity and reduce shortcut learning. Our approach, combined with multi-task
learning and the DeBERTa architecture, achieved significant performance gains
on the NLI4CT 2024 benchmark compared to the original language models. Ablation
studies validate the contribution of each augmentation method in improving
robustness. Our best-performing model ranked 12th in terms of faithfulness and
8th in terms of consistency, respectively, out of the 32 participants.
|
[
0.0465422533,
-0.9530804157,
0.5699821115,
0.1784807742,
-0.2960249186,
0.0421076007,
0.0174974985,
-0.517881453,
-0.1789191663,
0.6469660401,
-0.4153827429,
-0.6744023561,
-0.5829019547,
0.4633126557,
-0.0359105803,
0.695112884,
0.1753683239,
0.3624394536,
-0.2719809115,
-0.3857629895,
-0.4744209945,
-0.5124026537,
-0.3890146911,
-0.3458724022,
0.3782167137,
0.0591193624,
0.621137321,
0.5167895555,
0.6331916451,
0.2789039016,
-0.1335000098,
0.3224559426,
-0.2441608757,
0.2279521376,
-0.2102227509,
-0.507699728,
-0.7064926624,
-0.2050560117,
0.3615697324,
0.9275572896,
-0.0760883018,
-0.5765427351,
0.0038302529,
0.3436665833,
-0.5262184143,
0.0782583654,
-0.6934330463,
-0.3454488218,
-0.061053209,
-0.0951932222,
-0.4715876281,
-0.2545311153,
0.2151747793,
-0.7398923039,
0.1971614957,
-0.2110012472,
0.7125223875,
0.5396211147,
-0.5535154343,
-0.1792221218,
-0.3034445941,
0.9049155712,
-1.2425154448,
0.4829137623,
0.5182135105,
0.1222510859,
-0.3340577781,
-0.7846841216,
-0.4590786099,
-0.2739945352,
-0.04035661,
0.1332985461,
-0.1941027939,
0.3691270649,
0.3528732061,
0.1362429261,
-0.4913783669,
0.1490112394,
-0.2417529523,
-0.2297081202,
0.5028547645,
0.0537413992,
0.4566507041,
-0.1541213989,
-0.2526335716,
-0.1978410929,
-0.7045229673,
-0.2668846548,
0.190050751,
0.3218230605,
0.019729834,
0.4815054536,
-0.2263881266,
0.7501763701,
-0.0810366422,
0.0946195573,
0.790420115,
-0.6931277514,
-0.3711991012,
-0.0256258864,
0.5200976729,
0.3595593572,
-0.2900272012,
-0.1934796423,
0.280839771,
0.3042092025,
0.5303487182,
-0.8958320618,
-0.287992835,
0.4761024714,
-0.1728528887,
-0.6064590216,
-0.3798280954,
-0.8705940843,
-0.2573708296,
-0.2278644443,
0.4357857704,
-0.8911703825,
-0.1374688298,
0.4461701512,
-0.0283384658,
-0.1573593467,
0.3842676282,
-0.6919385195,
0.2200222164,
0.4914034605,
0.5547107458,
-0.2216442376,
-0.1447587907,
-0.5717180371,
0.1360133588,
-0.2155049443,
0.7323747873,
-0.4825502634,
-0.3799492121,
-0.2326633036,
0.149337694,
-0.1186328456,
-0.4587999582,
0.8370239735,
-0.4941534698,
0.2618795335,
-0.1774910092,
-0.6737746,
-0.2658943832,
0.2146020234,
-0.6468646526,
0.8025099635,
0.1074602455,
-0.7800691128,
0.5476237535,
-0.6315613985,
-0.5472698212,
0.1655948758,
-0.2935965359,
-0.6370639801,
0.0549338423,
0.5364860296,
0.2364209592,
0.0496481434,
0.4558503032,
-0.7364838719,
-0.0746034533,
0.2457562834,
-0.3703689277,
0.865852952,
0.1951772571,
-0.288302362,
-0.1193292513,
-0.9047449827,
-0.1219936907,
-0.0591527894,
-0.1311329752,
-0.5620678663,
-0.3173269928,
-0.1607699245,
-0.0101717953,
-0.0029918964,
-0.7388810515,
0.1082538515,
-1.091347456,
0.4417622387,
0.3268044889,
0.2272889614,
0.4324420393,
-0.205617249,
0.4092014134,
0.1626765728,
0.0867616385,
-0.1249075755,
-0.4875101745,
-0.2080787718,
-0.5718612075,
0.6242043376,
0.4211294055,
-0.8869900107,
0.4389420748,
-0.2184364945,
-0.2800851464,
-0.420399487,
-0.0724365711,
0.1544686407,
0.8144500256,
0.6936023235,
-0.0543531254,
-0.7247002721,
-0.9055739045,
-0.1158733219,
0.0188573189,
-0.1344675124,
0.0339979008,
0.6076369286,
-0.6670925617,
0.6261348128,
-0.2760210633,
0.0760663077,
-0.2675211132,
0.3033857942,
0.2403297722,
0.6760078073,
0.5653029084,
-0.7616058588,
-0.0084935129,
-0.1343519837,
-0.7251082063,
-0.3238404393,
-0.1999306828,
-0.3407538533,
-0.0266790893,
0.2373421341,
-0.4085734785,
0.6385797262,
0.3645305037,
-0.1748092026,
0.1514129043,
-0.4325529933,
0.5241696835,
-1.1083773375,
-0.0412776098,
-0.2290109843,
-0.2425773889,
-0.9026486278,
-0.058046516,
0.2048469931,
0.2467248738,
-0.2063779533,
0.3952453434,
-0.1721433103,
0.3860303164,
-0.5065819621,
-0.1581963003,
0.4206131399,
0.0549761876,
-0.0341710001,
0.6253801584,
0.5394604802,
-0.5243946314,
0.0107010473,
0.7921532989,
-0.2257767022,
0.2661411464,
-0.8451979756,
0.0093637444,
-0.3194684982,
0.2186142057,
-0.8868924379,
-0.4309757352,
-0.1206780002,
-0.5507742763,
0.2878466845,
0.0439905562,
-0.369392395,
-0.3202942014,
-0.2178975642,
0.3730411232,
0.5743961334,
-0.4170348942,
0.5889860392,
0.431499809,
-0.2766228914,
-0.4596149623,
-1.0768197775,
0.0956728086,
-0.2658209205,
-0.7047532201,
0.6914838552,
-0.014204571,
-0.2272129655,
-0.1436012536,
0.019797571,
-0.2167633921,
0.1400297433,
-0.0196955428,
0.5049137473,
0.0798017457,
0.2455946356,
0.5290498137,
0.0502830669,
-0.1118612215,
0.1546296775,
0.1180602387,
0.3362208009,
-0.5259004235,
-0.481037885,
0.4570780098,
0.5840488672,
-0.1005147249,
0.5804179907,
0.3611186147,
-0.7339477539,
0.0056682709,
-0.5264683366,
-0.5926234722,
-0.43816486,
0.4352440834,
-0.2685702145,
-0.8147586584,
0.2666516602,
-0.0831814855,
0.1066033319,
0.4093931019,
0.7022511959,
0.0817020461,
1.2042536736,
0.20648247,
0.3537303507,
0.0727602094,
-0.0478440598,
0.2183767408,
-0.7582607269,
-0.0278437417,
-0.3641058803,
0.1015926525,
-0.2808691263,
-0.7295382619,
0.5873317122,
-0.0578341447,
0.0005761248,
0.3124255836,
-0.4353814125,
-0.0267595723,
0.2430975586,
0.5044559836,
0.3338357508,
0.0829219371,
-0.3152037263,
-0.3092372715,
-0.6946330667,
-0.4904575944,
1.2719461918,
0.345785588,
0.6708589792,
0.0678440854,
0.6384599209,
0.1646630019,
0.2378469259,
-0.2524774373,
0.1324482113,
-0.0973978341,
-0.7429412007,
-0.0180496294,
-0.3640633821,
-0.8968445063,
0.2555754483,
-0.3238019645,
-0.6778284311,
0.3668419421,
0.2195516378,
-0.7191348672,
-0.0603741854,
-0.5191035867,
0.7620614171,
-0.2174995691,
-0.6866711974,
-0.1759108454,
-0.7038525343,
0.3302637637,
-0.2037300766,
0.3569723368,
-0.1546273381,
-0.0682584345,
0.3136357069,
-0.4620190263,
0.8182245493,
-0.1381761134,
0.0194634236,
0.1454751641,
-0.2966101766,
0.6585146785,
0.2722325325,
-0.3790339828,
0.0730184019,
0.1560554355,
-0.5031777024,
-0.5950897932,
0.6637988687,
-0.3509628475,
-0.2967816591,
-0.3553396463,
-0.6813205481,
-0.5903907418,
0.0720031708,
0.2715853155,
0.6891582012,
-0.0864846408,
0.3651692271,
0.5928714275,
-0.5963688493,
-0.1144202948,
0.3473877907,
0.2692015469,
-0.7094872594,
0.4036501348,
-0.2898091078,
0.4561044574,
0.2883450687,
0.1086847708,
-0.7622113824,
-1.0551692247,
-0.3668022752,
0.1052072793,
-0.6280292869,
-0.0917266309,
-1.1013585329,
0.098744005,
-0.8207922578,
0.0051971902,
-0.3925067782,
-0.4172334671,
-0.2199886441,
-0.2866483331,
0.3603176773,
0.3666503727,
-0.0507959388,
0.2766756117,
-0.9583674073,
0.2899155021,
0.0565849356,
-0.1061120108,
-0.4168944061,
-0.6690270901,
-0.0174063575,
0.2712514997,
-0.2333157212,
-0.9188534617,
0.5889424086,
0.2370812744,
0.7092360854,
0.063735798,
0.0616302043,
0.7050551772,
-0.4162489772,
0.5528407693,
0.19532758,
-0.543351531,
0.6965094209,
-0.5224718451,
0.3810753524,
0.9703618288,
0.1603530198,
0.1891315877,
-0.4309073687,
-0.7095947266,
-0.8962697387,
0.2137774378,
0.6133019328,
-0.0399261191,
-0.1232869551,
0.4037885666,
0.3351475894,
0.2613680661,
-0.2875909805,
0.0410637893,
-0.0450216122,
-0.6255212426,
0.1675884426,
-0.1532796472,
-0.230831936,
-0.4843690097,
0.7853776217,
-0.4065266252,
0.1614339501,
0.4133051336,
0.0003834115,
0.2069003284,
0.3101577759,
0.4622649848,
0.6629473567,
-0.1849536598,
0.0466260388,
0.6389362812,
-0.5344924927,
-0.0249905586,
0.5164703727,
-0.1031153202,
-0.0818904787,
0.4376048446,
0.7550547719,
0.212105006,
-0.8108069301,
0.3602875471,
-0.1570701003,
-0.4153874516,
0.0006518696,
-0.0624988154,
-0.0800482929,
0.1787561625,
0.1159782931,
0.1745563596,
0.664521277,
-0.2039805353,
0.5557848215,
0.3527911007,
-0.3050559759,
-0.3399453163,
0.9699536562,
0.1974155307,
0.4443641007,
0.1731056124,
-0.0153029561,
-0.3392461538,
0.5037010312,
0.4598328769,
0.5315383077,
-0.1646974087,
-0.026197236,
0.6532765031,
0.108618699,
-0.065108113,
0.510941267,
0.2601026595,
-0.6931696534,
-0.7656211257,
-0.5347578526,
-0.4103899598,
0.188616693,
-0.4754647613,
0.2735048532,
0.0393568017,
-0.3905282319,
0.2414362282,
-0.2123678327,
-0.4243210256,
0.3565798998,
0.0317313373,
0.6895544529,
-0.7386561632,
0.9628072381,
0.681597054,
-0.2279692739,
-0.5707996488,
-0.3256780803,
-0.0252266452,
-0.4350534081,
0.4606063664,
0.1545428187,
0.1151915342,
-0.1388089508,
-0.3294221759,
-0.7014948726,
0.9708738923,
0.3800142109,
-0.5985456109,
-0.209533751,
0.2285289764,
0.5134879947,
-0.269246906,
0.3417511582,
0.6956071258,
0.3873725533,
0.4116311073,
-0.6683962941,
0.0390691385,
-0.2228400409,
-0.1063009575,
-0.0168086402,
0.0228499733,
0.412943989,
-0.1989964396,
0.0038704849,
0.3551287949,
0.5407100916,
0.5392588377,
0.4117542505,
0.540353179,
0.7630555034,
0.9361051917,
-0.1189564764,
0.9733439088,
-0.369307518,
0.1711528897,
1.0564967394,
-0.5061590672,
0.3158974946,
0.5309114456,
-0.2726798356,
0.375708431,
0.4051478505,
0.0228211414,
0.741522193,
-0.0248227902,
-0.4749115407,
-0.3885517716,
-0.0561639927,
-0.277130723,
0.3651919067,
0.5836171508,
-0.4092953801,
-0.1718689799,
0.3643029332,
0.0133695593,
0.0700035319,
0.242536515,
0.6742258668,
0.0280782711,
-0.6310089827,
0.6367267966,
-0.305767715,
0.5173041224,
-0.55685395,
-0.2868870497,
0.0750233233,
0.4401680231,
-0.0179530866,
-0.3036351502,
0.4695023894,
-0.0864444673,
0.2403093129,
0.1047593057,
0.7982146144,
-0.3388852477,
-0.7056299448,
0.2247726172,
0.3642295599,
-0.1246772334,
0.0527752452,
-0.7199771404,
0.1155574769,
0.1193859577,
-0.0793134272,
0.136778906,
0.262866497,
0.1292012781,
0.4351805151,
0.6337836385,
0.1513237357,
-0.0533029437,
0.2727084756,
1.0076334476,
-0.3580624461,
-0.2871636152,
-0.8240503669,
0.5974403024,
-0.4622186422,
-0.1672270149,
0.7106586099,
0.4309078753,
0.2140630782,
0.0021433074,
0.9503988028,
0.0194365792,
0.7730275393,
-0.5173925161,
0.4624916911,
-0.5428202152,
0.1627345085,
-0.1323682517,
-0.3088351786,
-0.5203453898,
0.4817435145,
-0.3880744278,
-0.0074907793,
0.7011948824,
0.8388793468,
-0.0042558257,
0.3345772028,
0.3836894333,
0.3091673553,
0.5273043513,
0.4583008885,
0.5153825283,
-0.6042407751,
0.0822707042,
-0.5216012597,
-0.4547206461,
0.0032975732,
-0.8741257191,
-0.897821486,
-0.3044900596,
-0.4946414828,
-0.3411969543,
0.2221047282,
0.8937343955,
0.810885489,
-1.0332276821,
0.5021800995,
-0.5501793623,
-0.3260261118,
-0.1402478516,
-0.1621339619,
0.2854774594,
-0.570107758,
-0.9650507569,
0.8775066733,
0.2977939844,
0.1174887046,
0.1101228818,
-0.0139981508,
-0.41834113,
0.1532747447,
0.4375199676,
-0.0055789398,
-0.4763264358,
-0.024789948,
0.157914266,
-0.0363429822,
0.0079249023,
0.4268870056,
-0.8050824404,
0.7923656702,
0.6458473802,
1.0018130541,
0.481081605,
0.2262144834,
0.8712138534,
-0.4252259135,
0.2826192975,
0.5592973232,
0.3855462372,
0.4921781719,
-0.346775353,
0.568215251,
0.2831756771,
-0.7431100607,
-0.8291858435,
0.1000838801,
-0.9824429154,
-0.2424420416,
1.090724349,
-0.0475465842,
-0.3155594468,
-0.4667768478,
-0.1476065367,
0.3578276932,
-0.210267067,
0.618483305,
0.4586547017,
-0.2362844795,
0.1347635984,
-0.9061412811,
0.636723578,
0.7885054946,
-1.0129351616,
-0.1477300972,
0.5566517115,
0.2205655724,
-0.0196117293,
0.4779418707,
-0.4502536654,
0.3211835325,
-0.0854737237,
-0.1338878572,
0.0690288171,
0.0045891497,
-0.3303130269,
-0.0383522585,
-0.0678704455,
-0.1623536199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09173v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09173v3
|
TransformerFAM: Feedback attention is working memory
| 2024-04-14T07:43:45 | 2024-05-07T13:23:46 |
Dongseong Hwang, Weiran Wang, Zhuoyuan Huo, Khe Chai Sim, Pedro Moreno Mengibar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While Transformers have revolutionized deep learning, their quadratic
attention complexity hinders their ability to process infinitely long inputs.
We propose Feedback Attention Memory (FAM), a novel Transformer architecture
that leverages a feedback loop to enable the network to attend to its own
latent representations. This design fosters the emergence of working memory
within the Transformer, allowing it to process indefinitely long sequences.
TransformerFAM requires no additional weights, enabling seamless integration
with pre-trained models. Our experiments show that TransformerFAM significantly
improves Transformer performance on long-context tasks across various model
sizes (1B, 8B, and 24B). These results showcase the potential to empower Large
Language Models (LLMs) to process sequences of unlimited length.
|
[
-0.5148868561,
-0.4990307987,
0.388056457,
0.5435448885,
0.0931178778,
0.0728082582,
-0.4005979002,
-0.1870400757,
0.3226082027,
0.8105869293,
-0.6086760163,
0.0553082898,
-0.62700212,
0.0539416224,
-0.4438605309,
1.1755549908,
-0.00404514,
-0.113564387,
-0.214069739,
-0.2145732343,
-0.5511770248,
-0.5004833937,
-0.8025270104,
-0.7160992622,
0.801394999,
0.3941981792,
0.821700573,
0.3867397904,
0.4348341823,
0.3235274255,
-0.0078848172,
0.1221220195,
-0.7770533562,
0.3233637512,
-0.3172951639,
-0.6170150638,
-0.5314349532,
0.086432904,
0.814486146,
0.7178946733,
0.0320776105,
0.142706722,
0.0378378518,
0.9456386566,
-0.5353158116,
0.103174068,
-0.2606704235,
0.3610300422,
0.2852131426,
-0.0049933237,
-0.8786955476,
-0.1434198618,
0.3786039352,
-0.1533437222,
0.2416770011,
-0.0151238544,
0.6117088795,
0.7788777351,
-0.0143869584,
-0.0103655104,
-1.3356993198,
0.5143709779,
-0.4393168092,
0.6496580839,
0.1783678681,
0.2527725399,
-0.1801473945,
-0.9481660724,
-0.7005600333,
-0.1442380995,
-0.0444496423,
0.2348992229,
-0.3945666254,
0.1650305092,
0.3935494423,
0.6282706857,
-0.1762785167,
-0.1898644418,
-0.3598192334,
0.0221389327,
0.2451454997,
0.2518862188,
-0.0893261135,
0.1743411273,
-0.3871269822,
-0.0002646202,
-0.3919115961,
0.0026955849,
-0.0065764277,
-0.046356611,
0.0454916656,
0.3250383437,
0.0658324808,
0.4440636337,
0.5041227341,
0.1625713706,
0.0707184449,
0.1406621486,
-0.6029158831,
-0.2653125226,
0.8263595104,
-0.0331096873,
0.1205477193,
-0.7397775054,
-0.3174250126,
-0.1776891053,
0.7025893927,
-0.8267800212,
-0.3627339303,
0.0993935838,
-0.3407966495,
0.0292268489,
0.1135788858,
-0.8608927131,
-0.1666907817,
-0.3467777073,
0.5360959768,
-0.1420143247,
-0.1484036297,
0.0881412029,
0.1522458047,
0.1486749351,
0.2350378186,
-0.878223002,
0.4720483422,
0.5172537565,
0.9598762989,
-0.4037140012,
-0.3477526605,
-0.7140781283,
0.0797805637,
-0.2687723637,
0.6485165954,
-0.5489733815,
-0.3438232839,
-0.1689199805,
0.3742575645,
-0.1718670428,
-0.6441922188,
0.0874751434,
-0.9128804207,
0.2509130538,
0.1290906668,
-0.4724429846,
-0.2239981741,
-0.0083044246,
-1.0239231586,
1.1827744246,
0.2599564493,
-0.3449168503,
-0.096135661,
-0.9329819083,
-0.6150995493,
0.0909591317,
0.0588766113,
-0.6180471182,
0.3608255088,
-0.1575595886,
0.571739912,
-0.2809287906,
0.2134816796,
-0.0885921046,
-0.4947594404,
0.3775072992,
-0.3984689415,
0.168632105,
-0.0553610139,
-0.7098061442,
0.1449747831,
-0.5645153522,
-0.441069901,
0.128394857,
-0.3533487916,
0.2561656833,
-0.3034293056,
-0.0946595594,
0.4309311807,
-0.0539322346,
-0.4728023112,
0.2255562246,
-0.5602380037,
0.6645780206,
0.8099190593,
-0.2355099618,
0.7980456948,
-0.3198807836,
0.7811542153,
0.092136696,
0.0467833765,
-0.5502272248,
-0.1251764148,
-1.3889499903,
-0.0548100285,
0.2718555033,
0.1349394619,
-0.6469846964,
0.256701678,
-0.4211118817,
-0.2756583393,
-0.5485529304,
0.2823262811,
0.1448255032,
0.3109855056,
0.4280564785,
-0.3505059183,
-0.4282205403,
-0.8862320185,
0.2104455382,
0.1548827142,
-0.1080703512,
0.4770354331,
0.4552966058,
-0.5533317924,
0.9144104123,
-0.5164124966,
-0.4671946168,
-0.2259125113,
0.0718507916,
0.2338581085,
0.1638612151,
0.3554061651,
-0.4984753132,
-0.312441498,
-0.3545451462,
-0.300408572,
0.1812776476,
-0.2888051271,
-0.1580428332,
0.30725348,
0.4144293666,
-0.8172513843,
0.252048105,
0.4774624109,
-0.3041446209,
0.1557946205,
-0.0008693811,
-0.2276937664,
-1.0308003426,
0.240053609,
-0.1549347639,
-0.4531616867,
-0.4935841262,
-0.2239548564,
-0.0294881593,
-0.2570346296,
-0.3427792192,
0.5180214643,
-0.4300474226,
-0.1152739003,
-0.7115212679,
-0.0604532883,
0.1640446037,
0.9565726519,
0.0416137613,
0.8495382071,
0.1974360943,
-0.6410272717,
0.4666475952,
0.2648709416,
0.016110938,
0.2622765601,
-0.6346966624,
0.5330433846,
-0.177380085,
0.4472896159,
-1.234159112,
-0.119962737,
0.2072419822,
-0.3704184592,
0.5825954676,
0.1776965857,
-0.4291021526,
-0.7844929695,
-0.0894472152,
0.2695014477,
0.5542264581,
-0.7434962988,
1.0164901018,
0.2482580096,
-0.0202563591,
-0.4720341265,
-0.7213719487,
0.0563560612,
0.2562744915,
-0.3771952093,
0.2329168171,
-0.1691081971,
0.3614543676,
0.0251708608,
-0.1738143414,
0.0844823644,
0.0397663638,
0.6197530627,
0.2655632794,
-0.3534698188,
0.2853734493,
-0.2662655115,
-0.3283065856,
0.3364588618,
-0.4313736856,
0.6680968404,
-0.1993283927,
-0.0143840257,
-0.3988411129,
0.3851174116,
1.1360567808,
-0.2064367533,
0.5151941776,
0.6024556756,
-0.2736813128,
-0.6731869578,
-0.607154429,
-0.4143837094,
-0.5152562261,
0.3626516461,
-0.0311726108,
-1.474309206,
0.3587677777,
-0.2253785133,
0.0608098321,
0.3117944598,
0.9367008209,
-0.1497408152,
0.736548245,
0.8561894298,
-0.4983084798,
0.5214880705,
-0.5205346346,
0.5588986278,
-0.9187011719,
-0.2417509258,
-0.140004009,
-0.6837670803,
-0.0883316249,
-0.6569492221,
-0.1519501358,
-0.088025108,
-0.2089781314,
0.3203283548,
-0.7018431425,
0.5746308565,
0.3872401714,
0.158874765,
-0.0027889691,
-0.3544126451,
-0.0811646506,
-0.0223400183,
-0.6365953088,
-0.3230798244,
0.8468453288,
0.7605469227,
0.8950107098,
-0.1535084695,
0.2992632687,
0.2853790522,
0.6535588503,
-1.1686753035,
0.4600483477,
-0.0693486482,
-0.2600235641,
-0.1945473254,
-0.0618289523,
-0.8781523108,
-0.1316767335,
0.1427801251,
-0.606151104,
0.006934253,
0.3233941197,
-0.7673403025,
0.4059988856,
-0.3835426569,
0.4742653072,
-0.0470900089,
-0.5565722585,
-0.1271403283,
-0.64411515,
0.2284960896,
0.0558239929,
-0.2559654117,
0.0793385431,
0.1000410318,
0.7808101773,
-0.2453582883,
0.9993262291,
-0.0173180997,
-0.0740985721,
0.2266159356,
0.0266481359,
0.3730727434,
0.137258783,
0.2781025767,
-0.0320310481,
-0.741568625,
-0.1944871247,
-0.7680377364,
0.8086339831,
-0.8592624068,
-0.9005679488,
-0.3171809912,
-0.7176886797,
-0.3782892227,
0.1841189265,
0.00132771,
0.0829597563,
0.016061008,
0.549664855,
1.1990823746,
0.1850013584,
0.8209515214,
0.4951736331,
-0.3211126029,
-0.5956500173,
0.7142941356,
0.1794486493,
0.1999797821,
0.405169487,
-0.1008174047,
-0.1454655677,
-0.1512916088,
-0.3800257444,
0.2365172505,
-0.5719096661,
-0.3667346239,
-1.1467323303,
-0.477006048,
-0.1322110891,
-0.0091951638,
-0.6949646473,
-0.0995962992,
-0.3491593003,
-0.2110616863,
0.4033578038,
0.8121988773,
0.1387721896,
0.4113800228,
-0.8003218174,
0.490683496,
0.5978165269,
0.8029498458,
0.6126346588,
-0.574734807,
-0.6426116228,
-0.272687465,
-0.5577806234,
-0.5439555049,
0.2329025269,
0.1612326652,
0.4607283771,
0.398188591,
-0.1669909209,
0.3114181161,
-0.7209484577,
0.8500250578,
0.2386472821,
-0.9036524892,
0.1871870309,
0.061047215,
0.7849481702,
0.3488105536,
0.3847658932,
-0.5331353545,
-0.4901261926,
-0.4515147507,
-0.7060332298,
0.8544114828,
0.1164484695,
0.5146606565,
-0.2385718077,
0.4423820674,
0.1133937389,
0.1010445729,
-0.611450851,
-0.3531763554,
-0.3492269516,
0.0025541207,
0.026987277,
-0.4156108201,
-0.1257495582,
-0.3257175386,
0.4472374916,
-0.2447496951,
0.8828374743,
0.2193026692,
-0.1014794484,
-0.3925825953,
0.0937389955,
0.6860064864,
0.4462068081,
0.1545915157,
0.2925459146,
0.257358551,
-0.6277579069,
0.2675942183,
-0.0933379754,
-0.0418398567,
0.2134027183,
0.1056812927,
1.005800724,
0.5791693926,
-0.3290573657,
0.565936625,
-0.2505089939,
-0.3458084464,
-0.368922919,
0.3051602542,
0.5436093211,
0.4217920005,
0.619125545,
0.2269635201,
0.0114721553,
-0.2617779374,
0.6153211594,
0.0379895344,
-0.7759511471,
-0.5063846111,
0.889410913,
0.2161169797,
-0.6238598228,
0.5606389642,
0.4276743829,
-0.6978981495,
0.6232810616,
0.7139305472,
1.0944157839,
-0.4488717616,
0.0676951781,
0.1983703226,
0.1341887712,
-0.0745521858,
0.1525398344,
-0.2507129312,
-0.5518620014,
-0.6419354677,
-0.6812099218,
-0.3149318397,
0.3871822953,
-0.7922298312,
0.0732529312,
-0.8407866955,
-0.3152420819,
0.0562588274,
-0.3273843825,
-0.8067753911,
0.3740144372,
0.2537885606,
0.7939463258,
-0.543764472,
0.9533708096,
0.4463911951,
-0.2236810178,
-0.7711391449,
0.0300157797,
-0.5021901131,
-0.5845028758,
0.6555713415,
0.541349709,
-0.4299057126,
0.1048969924,
-0.5352258086,
-0.8533622026,
1.085580945,
0.3766093552,
-0.8128404617,
-0.0449105576,
0.1873188913,
0.614084363,
-0.460809648,
0.2395645082,
0.6419757009,
0.2348901629,
0.2342610359,
-0.5644406676,
0.0412010588,
-0.2615086734,
0.1360745877,
0.4842129946,
-1.1808364391,
0.573004663,
-0.2086302489,
-0.1753173321,
-0.1376559287,
1.0401633978,
-0.2464276552,
0.0530196838,
0.4680111408,
0.8386303782,
0.4604312479,
-0.0866629332,
0.8727106452,
-0.3975427449,
0.3877823949,
1.3208954334,
-0.1812773198,
0.6635401845,
0.6286113858,
-0.0837480053,
0.5116927624,
0.3676719069,
-0.2428734601,
0.5733156204,
0.1168380305,
-0.0303576719,
-0.1808121502,
-0.1169950217,
-0.1348167062,
0.1832749695,
0.2246935517,
-0.7428519726,
0.0576483011,
0.3917093873,
0.1225876436,
-0.0818918049,
-0.349742651,
0.9430170655,
0.4191946983,
-0.8155812621,
0.4472733438,
-0.3077862859,
0.5933904052,
-0.3025964797,
-0.153475672,
-0.3475784659,
0.3539848328,
-0.2328929007,
-0.6487479806,
0.5160767436,
-0.3738999367,
-0.7794983387,
-0.2414447069,
0.5359313488,
-0.4489793777,
-0.144246459,
0.6739200354,
0.087857455,
-0.3554948568,
0.1162752807,
-0.4317437708,
0.0461313799,
-0.178381145,
-0.634976089,
0.1350729913,
0.2843357623,
0.321647644,
0.7596051097,
0.4792232215,
-0.3912265599,
0.1614626199,
0.0676223785,
1.1662169695,
-0.7070413828,
-0.4765904546,
-0.9616029859,
0.3624214828,
0.1576576233,
-0.3147450089,
0.5254275799,
0.4426251948,
0.731595695,
-0.320302397,
0.6719994545,
0.3240930736,
0.1793235838,
-0.0900802761,
0.6826974154,
-0.3157500625,
-0.066840522,
0.0070354352,
-0.9651522636,
-0.2131887227,
0.4323572814,
-0.255448252,
0.0108507825,
0.8151136637,
0.4505328536,
-0.0487761386,
0.2795319259,
0.3906186223,
0.3054817021,
0.1694865078,
0.8992572427,
0.7804802656,
-0.4522791505,
0.5132327676,
-0.2760280371,
-0.0426699892,
-0.3886661828,
-0.5609516501,
-1.0938768387,
-0.4394133091,
-0.1708851904,
-0.4942739904,
-0.2886489928,
0.8536990881,
0.83541888,
-0.8898434043,
0.0261552595,
-0.0676869676,
-0.0023403685,
-0.1305996329,
-0.3092394471,
0.246162191,
-0.4310891926,
-0.7792397141,
0.2707180679,
0.8757125735,
-0.0978483185,
-0.7484660149,
-0.2263819724,
0.0132990805,
0.2156122774,
0.7457649112,
0.2271878868,
-0.6226998568,
-0.3932129145,
0.5095069408,
-0.3562138975,
0.3941654861,
1.0194996595,
-0.8617968559,
0.5497657061,
0.3368636966,
1.2112658024,
0.7202912569,
-0.4484006464,
0.852122128,
-0.4103220403,
0.0974537134,
0.5986793041,
0.3508401215,
0.1987853497,
-0.6707276106,
0.4407105446,
0.1316315085,
-0.7616958618,
-0.498039335,
0.0671775565,
-1.0842169523,
-0.0250091292,
0.878431201,
-0.2886981368,
-0.4919385016,
-0.0619412288,
-0.126685515,
0.2536557317,
-0.427467674,
0.8787548542,
0.8578044772,
-0.0736655071,
-0.6726331711,
-0.3548342884,
0.3016536534,
0.6965104938,
-0.3633637726,
0.0113181164,
0.134003967,
0.2451837212,
0.3865788877,
0.5089039803,
-0.067350693,
0.6527065635,
-0.4312404096,
0.0541119054,
-0.1320565045,
-0.7383992672,
-0.3888956904,
0.5153354406,
-0.1087620854,
-0.0629422516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09170v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09170v2
|
Post-Semantic-Thinking: A Robust Strategy to Distill Reasoning Capacity from Large Language Models
| 2024-04-14T07:19:27 | 2024-04-16T07:38:51 |
Xiaoshu Chen, Sihang Zhou, Ke Liang, Xinwang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chain of thought finetuning aims to endow small student models with reasoning
capacity to improve their performance towards a specific task by allowing them
to imitate the reasoning procedure of large language models (LLMs) beyond
simply predicting the answer to the question. However, the existing methods 1)
generate rationale before the answer, making their answer correctness sensitive
to the hallucination in the rationale;2) force the student model to repeat the
exact LLMs rationale expression word-after-word, which could have the model
biased towards learning the expression in rationale but count against the model
from understanding the core logic behind it. Therefore, we propose a robust
Post-Semantic-Thinking (PST) strategy to generate answers before rationale.
Thanks to this answer-first setting, 1) the answering procedure can escape from
the adverse effects caused by hallucinations in the rationale; 2) the complex
reasoning procedure is tightly bound with the relatively concise answer, making
the reasoning for questions easier with the prior information in the answer; 3)
the efficiency of the method can also benefit from the setting since users can
stop the generation right after answers are outputted when inference is
conducted. Furthermore, the PST strategy loose the constraint against the
generated rationale to be close to the LLMs gold standard in the hidden
semantic space instead of the vocabulary space, thus making the small student
model better comprehend the semantic reasoning logic in rationale. Extensive
experiments conducted across 12 reasoning tasks demonstrate the effectiveness
of PST.
|
[
-0.5982989073,
-1.0069217682,
0.8310705423,
-0.2042925805,
-0.6018410325,
-0.0669783726,
-0.2315213233,
-0.0481606089,
0.3062804341,
0.7517887354,
-0.8840341568,
-0.1060751379,
-0.4313944578,
0.0891947001,
-0.1876501441,
0.9046279788,
-0.0755487755,
-0.0284537748,
-0.0839456841,
0.0670243278,
-0.4093903005,
-0.5272533894,
-0.4986186326,
-0.2780644,
0.4597738981,
0.2473004162,
0.6268389225,
0.3851076663,
0.5108308792,
0.2831347585,
0.0160950199,
0.2711504102,
-0.5412940383,
0.1108191162,
-0.6783567667,
-0.5119063258,
-0.4266754091,
-0.0585331656,
0.4433481097,
0.7834048867,
-0.2032993287,
0.1116792783,
0.1337730736,
0.5256387591,
-0.6925414801,
-0.1468506604,
-1.0652723312,
-0.0586627908,
0.0108063929,
-0.4481754303,
-0.4454864562,
-0.1857789308,
0.5223018527,
-0.6773595214,
-0.1287635565,
-0.1687500775,
0.6615856886,
0.363771528,
-0.1106345803,
-0.1148053706,
-0.6783047915,
0.8718720078,
-0.6792218089,
0.2405874431,
0.2927173376,
0.3769965172,
-0.2905636728,
-0.7758055925,
-0.6221923828,
-0.0457216352,
0.1801776886,
0.1905238926,
0.1074838489,
0.090515621,
0.6245722175,
0.2462440431,
-0.4388619363,
-0.4318173528,
-0.2892508805,
-0.2096263468,
0.420581907,
0.0195420478,
-0.0489814691,
-0.1152496561,
-0.4848310351,
-0.1517742872,
-0.5899617672,
-0.1301860958,
0.0721923411,
0.3373085856,
0.7299034595,
0.8327022791,
-0.5108326077,
0.594653964,
0.2052517682,
-0.1787238419,
-0.0989964902,
-0.4047774971,
-0.2770974934,
0.2271070778,
0.6266151667,
0.3358308375,
0.4189040959,
-0.0870631635,
-0.3746345937,
0.6304410696,
0.4517997801,
-0.8987678289,
-0.3994763196,
-0.0249239225,
-0.3776964843,
-0.0523403697,
-0.0765450373,
-0.7113345265,
-0.0230347142,
-0.6725966334,
0.6148408651,
-0.6947639585,
-0.396073848,
0.5178852677,
0.0325024873,
0.3230580986,
0.3923264444,
-0.7109900117,
0.6964485049,
0.566478014,
0.7373820543,
-0.0654542297,
-0.2542841434,
-0.5186508894,
0.1634030938,
-0.3251244724,
0.9240013957,
-0.2524933219,
-0.0008303276,
-0.1678505242,
-0.0324802808,
-0.1417025924,
-0.2733692229,
0.4198046029,
-0.5795888901,
0.2018006593,
-0.6749992371,
-0.7416697741,
-0.1147864088,
0.4367177188,
-0.3606082499,
0.7168655396,
-0.0562214442,
-0.9384515882,
0.2483046055,
-0.3892423511,
-0.3119831383,
-0.037686009,
-0.2166392356,
-0.0649354458,
0.2380008101,
0.1720797867,
0.4200288355,
-0.143707037,
0.2526601553,
-0.2843090594,
-0.2676333785,
0.1292430013,
-0.3920979202,
0.7492842674,
0.3153659403,
-0.4038268924,
0.2871680856,
-0.5879124999,
0.3794074655,
0.2373515218,
0.1246665865,
-0.5597966313,
0.0267997794,
-0.4592314363,
0.5478579402,
0.0940452442,
-0.3585063219,
0.1283263713,
-0.6110896468,
0.5147042871,
0.7604106665,
0.1021125242,
0.521545589,
-0.4721576273,
0.4480207264,
-0.1408884823,
0.0434792936,
0.0293293353,
-0.2944803238,
-0.6764547229,
0.0068834061,
-0.0188606977,
0.6658838987,
-1.1312131882,
0.5157532692,
-0.1204360053,
-0.5770384073,
-0.4567430615,
0.1597150415,
0.3196253777,
0.7225143909,
0.4369732738,
-0.2438532859,
-0.5580436587,
-0.7134202123,
-0.2272175997,
-0.1697121561,
-0.0847562701,
-0.1128562316,
0.6221083403,
-0.1086504906,
0.8224650621,
-0.7378234863,
0.0695182011,
-0.4393738806,
-0.1569156647,
-0.0460497737,
0.4498952925,
0.0721311793,
-0.5139414072,
-0.0566944666,
-0.2417364568,
-0.4939203262,
0.0582557544,
-0.2733956575,
-0.7057953477,
0.0933599621,
0.3796785772,
-0.9130963683,
0.3901929259,
-0.0898252949,
-0.3551550806,
0.872287035,
-0.1787558049,
0.038701281,
-1.1110883951,
-0.1808159351,
-0.1966470629,
-0.0396600962,
-0.3092617989,
-0.0121433511,
-0.2065701038,
-0.0170602147,
-0.3459257483,
0.1332455575,
-0.2670496106,
0.0997637957,
-0.272303462,
0.413456291,
0.058682479,
0.4553621709,
0.2805669308,
0.5169094801,
0.5614392757,
-0.525493145,
0.2773655951,
0.1887263805,
-0.4657635391,
0.4958695173,
-0.6157828569,
0.0999499783,
-0.1114662737,
0.2889322639,
-0.8965088129,
-0.0456709713,
-0.0686386004,
-0.1085612401,
-0.1558662355,
0.2410181165,
-0.6448925138,
-0.5617588162,
-0.2696072161,
0.3038410246,
0.5382086039,
-0.352419585,
0.4892381728,
0.18810229,
-0.1235072315,
-0.2022707462,
-0.7369855046,
-0.1709530652,
-0.4182623327,
-0.8587456942,
0.2061537504,
-0.096527338,
-0.435423106,
-0.138823837,
-0.3344735801,
0.016331898,
0.1195611805,
-0.3948976398,
0.3901770115,
-0.4047498107,
0.1420786977,
0.22448273,
-0.2516848445,
0.2170096934,
-0.6916131377,
0.7674916983,
-0.4444006383,
-0.2744251192,
-0.5569061041,
0.4209268987,
0.5357469916,
-0.3210636079,
0.6838903427,
0.3197365999,
-0.5319495797,
-0.3463803232,
-0.5969014168,
-0.8128750324,
-0.4302472472,
0.2555707693,
-0.5726848245,
-0.8649228811,
0.5647951365,
-0.2899401486,
-0.0500485115,
0.3499616981,
0.5377355218,
0.0295658018,
1.0060118437,
0.4966923594,
0.5229184628,
0.3493947089,
-0.417326659,
0.5501326919,
-0.6457547545,
-0.0817512199,
-0.1111142933,
-0.0360409208,
-0.3396319449,
-0.3676599264,
-0.1350482702,
0.6110035181,
-0.1811055541,
0.3764769435,
-0.688621819,
0.5933045745,
0.486261189,
0.2303907424,
0.1909085065,
0.0464274846,
-0.2444763929,
-0.0804606676,
-0.801479876,
-0.691426456,
0.8853164315,
0.1237450913,
0.6967431903,
-0.0345075093,
0.7366386652,
-0.3265846372,
0.0639465451,
-0.9806681871,
0.8391819596,
0.1625747234,
-0.2988570929,
-0.4532518685,
-0.4954456389,
-0.5060382485,
0.5259526372,
-0.1934496909,
-0.814504087,
-0.1940401196,
0.0955147743,
-0.678986609,
0.3756247759,
-0.8288025856,
0.9293759465,
-0.0362989381,
-0.5421604514,
-0.2358981967,
-0.7022826672,
0.3805519044,
0.040803697,
-0.1961456239,
0.1279993802,
0.1209143326,
0.9833788872,
-0.980363965,
0.5781772137,
-0.0883607045,
-0.0556464866,
0.7892379165,
0.2733135819,
0.5684514642,
-0.1441580653,
0.0873014331,
-0.3280553222,
0.2517583668,
-0.5476216674,
-0.7887707353,
0.6165760159,
-0.4137280285,
-0.9453527927,
-0.3760426342,
-0.6965815425,
-0.4134209156,
0.5050162673,
0.4088341892,
0.4697102308,
0.1269696206,
0.019591732,
0.9522482753,
0.0931418166,
0.2262297422,
0.1184518188,
-0.1649369001,
-0.4329411387,
0.5872061849,
0.4939474761,
0.708360672,
0.0628500655,
0.5930327177,
-0.4801369905,
-0.4459934235,
-0.2330122739,
0.250916332,
-0.700861752,
-0.0669440776,
-0.6415792108,
-0.2265369147,
-0.4818047583,
-0.4472058117,
-0.4803897738,
-0.4380559921,
0.1867790073,
-0.2544393837,
0.4349738955,
0.3350073695,
0.1915965974,
0.2281560153,
-0.4097013175,
0.1475239545,
0.4590005279,
0.2488345504,
0.2152557373,
-0.2903860509,
0.2157126069,
0.2050979584,
-0.4028324187,
-0.7488008142,
0.1003453061,
-0.2002420574,
0.4721524715,
0.492574513,
0.3580590487,
0.8613888025,
-0.5563802123,
0.6462071538,
0.3565552533,
-0.9249107838,
0.9603896141,
-0.3910252154,
0.5355250239,
0.7047471404,
0.2967214882,
-0.1139635742,
-0.5751116872,
-0.7737053037,
-0.7639346123,
0.4848902225,
0.2665465474,
-0.0273120124,
-0.3706323206,
0.4013768137,
-0.0065712356,
0.157145232,
-0.6410204768,
0.2165296376,
-0.307988435,
-0.0535598285,
0.1680242121,
-0.2935824394,
0.0415816307,
-0.488098979,
0.6816847324,
-0.2249926329,
-0.0077096513,
0.4995369315,
0.0007140324,
-0.0865824446,
0.2045174539,
0.5565199852,
0.930203557,
-0.2043863833,
0.5205620527,
0.3596099913,
-0.3402818441,
-0.1296869665,
-0.1723048687,
-0.1859032065,
-0.2156175375,
0.3525112569,
0.5467686057,
0.0128112501,
-0.7439301014,
0.5093902946,
0.0299176201,
-0.4565469921,
-0.2585553229,
0.0206800271,
-0.0452496298,
0.2085679919,
-0.058658231,
0.3816524744,
0.1025351807,
-0.5396623611,
0.472578913,
0.2559094727,
-0.3441412449,
-0.1763998717,
0.5095824599,
-0.2708413899,
-0.0747093335,
0.452711612,
-0.2336602807,
-0.7056012154,
0.3358056247,
0.8347942829,
0.7667883039,
-0.3210448325,
0.1639867127,
0.3559437096,
0.2741332948,
-0.5778462887,
0.4995845258,
-0.2302026153,
-0.7353534698,
-0.7720494866,
-0.5611136556,
0.0473208837,
0.0931536779,
-0.6886848211,
0.2911208272,
-0.7140716314,
-0.1291476041,
-0.2096909285,
0.2004326433,
-0.356318444,
0.1218640953,
-0.0304743964,
0.9819193482,
-0.7538958192,
0.9852800965,
0.4290906787,
-0.4717733562,
-1.0114842653,
0.152637288,
-0.1637957394,
-0.3393680453,
0.3389890194,
0.3242450953,
-0.5277659893,
-0.066711165,
-0.3365547657,
-0.8427043557,
0.9585541487,
0.2586977482,
-0.5038269162,
-0.0306852162,
-0.0948614478,
0.6004568338,
-0.347342968,
-0.0861105248,
0.6731126904,
0.1374679506,
0.5695519447,
-0.6841105223,
0.3649253547,
-0.0507433787,
0.04265121,
0.2076178044,
-0.266464144,
0.8587779999,
-0.3650750816,
-0.208867535,
0.1324079484,
0.7113449574,
0.4507693648,
0.0876379311,
0.7434452772,
0.767156899,
1.0404273272,
0.0512996092,
1.0297592878,
0.0071066041,
0.1943179816,
1.1965148449,
-0.3138041198,
1.0567365885,
0.8417260647,
0.1185969189,
0.3152282834,
0.5157020688,
0.277747184,
0.9890219569,
0.6042976379,
-0.114780955,
-0.6338744164,
-0.063176319,
-0.3189958334,
0.2826138437,
0.341244489,
-0.000643948,
-0.266664803,
0.1683498472,
0.0771687552,
0.3935084045,
-0.4471383095,
0.7964965701,
0.2618073523,
-0.9906204939,
0.6951220036,
-0.3861810267,
0.4667343795,
-0.6237003207,
0.074843809,
0.1377674341,
0.5357096195,
-0.0384409204,
-0.6789509654,
0.6677759886,
-0.1779808402,
-0.2281162143,
-0.4275794923,
0.7961778641,
-0.4857019186,
-0.6551417708,
0.3477135897,
0.5867005587,
0.0911604539,
-0.1301161647,
-0.5562869906,
-0.1035186499,
-0.1452138275,
-0.2411846519,
0.1475899071,
0.9322371483,
-0.1560154855,
0.525921464,
0.5357538462,
0.0218572002,
0.0182290226,
0.0716883019,
1.0438847542,
-0.3700917065,
-0.7231013179,
-0.9754522443,
0.3378420472,
-0.1939645559,
-0.3259457052,
0.8217546344,
0.3904311955,
1.0787701607,
0.0052558025,
0.4958028495,
0.1287149042,
0.3040252924,
-0.674475193,
0.5504445434,
-0.3974873126,
0.2260821462,
-0.6781824827,
-0.9285981655,
-0.3175167143,
1.0892078876,
-0.7825568318,
-0.2627100646,
1.1125410795,
0.7066401243,
0.0082178321,
0.3306720257,
0.2340551466,
0.1186096296,
0.1626436263,
0.8045057058,
1.001529336,
-0.2777529657,
0.4113052487,
-0.4402310848,
-0.4336886704,
0.1992377639,
-0.6180710196,
-1.0628604889,
-0.4846686125,
-0.2423107028,
-0.5641353726,
-0.2419197708,
0.9668910503,
0.5488901734,
-0.7355033755,
-0.1400121301,
-0.5439151525,
-0.0431879833,
-0.3820637763,
-0.2372971326,
0.5203562379,
-0.506486237,
-0.1085329279,
-0.0257566832,
0.1418539137,
-0.1269804239,
-0.1956525147,
-0.0086099124,
-0.4114729166,
0.3925372362,
0.9143372774,
-0.2335951626,
-0.9694110751,
-0.5082279444,
0.1682461947,
0.0152081447,
-0.3016980886,
0.9484703541,
-0.7216917276,
0.3069373071,
0.5217369199,
0.7462316751,
0.268512249,
-0.1415687948,
0.5193486214,
-0.1683200598,
0.2955306172,
0.4209402204,
0.4898855388,
0.0512993261,
-0.2560461164,
0.2647517323,
0.3563973308,
-0.3104158044,
-0.6963204145,
0.3932197988,
-1.040579915,
-0.6163861156,
0.9662052989,
-0.1252090186,
-0.3210916519,
-0.0434375517,
-0.4278672934,
0.1952919066,
-0.0958687887,
0.9641545415,
0.8841978908,
-0.0311016664,
-0.014250664,
-0.4441320896,
0.5682516098,
0.634439528,
-0.7376958728,
0.2057100683,
0.3359124959,
0.0493411124,
0.275228411,
0.7736523151,
-0.2137653977,
0.1847018152,
0.169837594,
-0.4366011918,
0.1851798594,
-0.5249223113,
0.2646790743,
0.1998048574,
-0.0822759941,
-0.0301714446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.14419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.14419v1
|
Enhancing Fault Detection for Large Language Models via Mutation-Based Confidence Smoothing
| 2024-04-14T07:06:12 | 2024-04-14T07:06:12 |
Qiang Hu, Jin Wen, Maxime Cordy, Yuheng Huang, Xiaofei Xie, Lei Ma
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) achieved great success in multiple application
domains and attracted huge attention from different research communities
recently. Unfortunately, even for the best LLM, there still exist many faults
that LLM cannot correctly predict. Such faults will harm the usability of LLMs.
How to quickly reveal them in LLMs is important, but challenging. The reasons
are twofold, 1) the heavy labeling effort for preparing the test data, and 2)
accessing closed-source LLMs such as GPT4 is money-required. To handle this
problem, in the traditional deep learning testing field, test selection methods
have been proposed for efficiently testing deep learning models by prioritizing
faults. However, the usefulness of these methods on LLMs is unclear and under
exploration. In this paper, we first study the effectiveness of existing fault
detection methods for LLMs. Experimental results on four different
tasks~(including both code tasks and natural language processing tasks) and
four LLMs (e.g., LLaMA and GPT4) demonstrated that existing fault detection
methods cannot perform well on LLMs (e.g., seven out of eight methods perform
worse than random selection on LLaMA). To enhance existing fault detection
methods, we propose MuCS, a prompt Mutation-based prediction Confidence
Smoothing method for LLMs. Concretely, we mutate the prompts and compute the
average prediction confidence of all mutants as the input of fault detection
methods. The results show that our proposed solution significantly enhances
existing methods with the improvement of test relative coverage by up to
97.64%.
|
[
-0.4761710465,
-0.6749132872,
0.7674260736,
0.2557211518,
-0.1897290349,
0.2132500708,
-0.4811269641,
-0.2621098161,
0.0779396296,
0.3984692991,
-0.6066941619,
-0.6218610406,
-0.6126707792,
0.1946995109,
-0.0603867024,
0.7945066094,
-0.1222158819,
-0.1078708321,
-0.1856603175,
0.1648842245,
-0.3245067,
-0.3804239035,
-0.8323656917,
-0.3101049662,
0.5689367056,
0.6296877265,
0.6786370277,
0.268756777,
0.3723569512,
0.3699526191,
-0.3530555665,
0.5295596123,
-0.5242287517,
0.3991761506,
0.2429396361,
-0.5963124037,
-0.4718772769,
-0.4117018282,
0.5739349127,
0.6320137978,
0.1569108516,
-0.2150695026,
0.3650592566,
0.4946231842,
-0.6459578276,
0.1981417388,
-0.7836492658,
0.0587027967,
-0.2933495045,
-0.2120313942,
-0.4082795084,
-0.5044199824,
-0.3542276621,
-0.5062618256,
0.2152242213,
-0.138537243,
0.6568693519,
0.3847557604,
-0.3278024495,
-0.0531351343,
-0.5547411442,
0.921233952,
-1.0029984713,
0.3791305423,
0.3942476809,
0.2219578922,
-0.8736345172,
-0.5208542943,
-0.6439369917,
-0.386059612,
0.1275285035,
-0.2321686,
0.0512134954,
0.1456314921,
0.4211300313,
0.5924774408,
-0.7069490552,
0.4958541989,
0.0968642235,
-0.5448687673,
0.5242781639,
0.0726451203,
-0.1299320012,
0.1325958669,
-0.1279007345,
-0.3179161847,
-0.8759311438,
0.0487583019,
0.3963114917,
0.2574643493,
0.1801479012,
0.2268196791,
-0.3146115541,
0.7261170149,
-0.1795468628,
-0.3245092332,
0.5899303555,
-0.1931282282,
-0.3003740311,
-0.3396109343,
0.7541025877,
0.0803728104,
0.3935213685,
0.0718291625,
-0.2509448528,
0.0388415754,
-0.1497544348,
-0.8264737129,
-0.1457244754,
0.316178441,
-0.0909256041,
-0.3059367537,
-0.0877165943,
-0.9536197186,
-0.6881926656,
0.0053881314,
0.0689768121,
-0.4401106238,
-0.1952954084,
0.3175841272,
0.3211036325,
-0.0810051262,
0.2471458167,
-0.7308229208,
-0.1807685345,
0.5787690282,
0.6341084242,
-0.280508101,
-0.3232989013,
-0.6620670557,
-0.205408603,
-0.3620720804,
0.7790818214,
-0.4534387589,
-0.3606097996,
0.0530955344,
0.0482082702,
-0.0342675447,
-0.4572816491,
0.8345413208,
-0.3060226738,
-0.101960592,
-0.2592844665,
-0.463264823,
-0.0366264619,
0.4358094633,
-0.5885611176,
1.2108882666,
0.0340748653,
-0.674051106,
0.1412884444,
-0.3290343881,
-0.6559405923,
-0.2382042259,
-0.0813816711,
-0.8193612099,
-0.1194283292,
0.4924161136,
0.6613938212,
-0.2054426074,
0.3953153491,
-0.6903333664,
-0.6140272617,
0.3543515801,
-0.5236983299,
0.432423085,
0.186581403,
-0.6671364307,
0.1817395389,
-0.5942116976,
0.2356168032,
0.0313250758,
-0.4047020972,
-0.1935408413,
0.0655017048,
-0.3477012217,
0.1925848275,
-0.1531451941,
-0.4279097617,
0.3980860412,
-0.5117791295,
0.1261287034,
1.023840785,
-0.0823948905,
0.1870412678,
-0.147577852,
0.6564971209,
0.1878453344,
0.3352070451,
-0.3845099807,
-0.8145672083,
-1.0901483297,
-0.2661267817,
0.2939756215,
0.4129163623,
-0.7981674671,
0.6599802971,
-0.206223622,
-0.3797542751,
-0.4089047015,
0.2334787101,
0.393522203,
0.3230038285,
0.4325158298,
-0.1645945162,
-0.3131056726,
-0.7343047261,
-0.3239197433,
-0.1374944597,
-0.0745018721,
0.1559309661,
0.2767514586,
-0.4026824534,
0.627648592,
-0.7137515545,
-0.1365290135,
-0.1465062797,
0.0423090048,
0.3234992325,
0.3614107668,
0.3524424136,
-0.7223702669,
-0.2753522098,
-0.1062530801,
-0.3436935842,
-0.1184087694,
-0.0788800046,
0.0556435362,
0.2847678363,
0.5150325894,
-0.4550120533,
0.4708014131,
0.7754983306,
-0.2163459212,
0.5182914138,
-0.0029842441,
0.347753495,
-0.9143131971,
-0.1894033104,
-0.0543736741,
-0.3592901528,
-0.462757051,
0.0011388091,
0.2232656479,
0.1315952688,
-0.2699998319,
0.4840739071,
-0.4878229797,
0.0247827731,
-0.3822376728,
-0.152821511,
0.0219235346,
0.5151574016,
-0.4691963196,
0.6259000897,
0.6869395375,
-0.6628568769,
0.1773324609,
-0.0788125396,
-0.1971485764,
0.1167997271,
-0.3149737716,
0.317338407,
0.196424365,
0.2956383526,
-1.06985569,
-0.0544302016,
0.3029790521,
-0.3719317317,
0.6298909783,
-0.1903591454,
-0.5321341157,
-0.5662120581,
-0.5092272162,
0.2647325993,
0.4391136169,
-0.6201118231,
0.5010447502,
0.0814024284,
-0.3045312762,
-0.616094768,
-0.7166544199,
0.0429833494,
-0.2042286694,
-0.806836009,
0.2759698331,
-0.4124146104,
0.045010712,
-0.3352304101,
-0.1229762882,
0.073588945,
0.4087280929,
0.4352933764,
0.1384615153,
-0.3285093904,
0.3152679205,
0.2075629979,
-0.2906983197,
-0.3024576604,
-0.2624905407,
0.4812264144,
-0.2183961421,
-0.6513546109,
-0.0498275869,
0.2050056458,
0.5588052869,
-0.3703710735,
0.485011965,
0.4705936015,
-0.233075887,
-0.4270471334,
-0.784935832,
-0.3842025399,
-0.5285372734,
0.4184493423,
-0.2695707679,
-1.2556586266,
0.4588634372,
-0.4397818148,
-0.1377908885,
0.254109472,
0.6718805432,
0.1500893533,
0.8435605168,
0.7055515051,
-0.470610708,
0.2592376173,
-0.0461281464,
0.3781949282,
-0.5405976176,
-0.0382941328,
-0.7469960451,
-0.304644227,
-0.4598735571,
-0.6988729835,
0.4111022055,
-0.0306627061,
-0.0561959557,
-0.0217042938,
-0.3084200323,
0.546794951,
0.3680994809,
0.0538606532,
0.5033026338,
0.082081221,
-0.3739342391,
-0.1883683801,
-0.3633300364,
-0.1721980721,
1.0419151783,
0.4701933563,
0.8727211952,
-0.1614585519,
0.5342005491,
-0.0232548919,
0.2363442034,
-0.6185411811,
0.4816753864,
-0.0788565278,
-0.2227634639,
-0.3715797067,
-0.6765552759,
-0.8245764375,
0.1778899431,
-0.1260742098,
-0.4188486338,
0.2359399348,
0.3472378552,
-0.3373579383,
0.5388074517,
-0.6822584271,
0.7225517631,
-0.2670639753,
-0.1317981184,
-0.0569305085,
-0.4210906327,
0.5239188075,
-0.3336397707,
0.3033953309,
-0.1768452525,
0.230572924,
0.3729067147,
-0.3081404865,
0.7925264239,
-0.1177937165,
-0.2122488022,
-0.0918001533,
0.1439785957,
0.8410248756,
0.0888719186,
-0.3176151812,
0.1616890877,
-0.6026178598,
-0.2979967594,
-0.5691122413,
0.9894350767,
-0.2573281825,
-0.4875535965,
-0.4884266257,
-0.6170655489,
-0.601952076,
0.2299023122,
0.2158374488,
0.1094507128,
0.1849644929,
-0.0343108289,
0.9254440069,
-0.4865919352,
0.4589986205,
0.4979377985,
-0.2631620765,
-0.0449504107,
0.7349807024,
-0.2134422958,
0.3347682953,
0.0477676578,
0.2260684967,
-0.015449007,
-1.0240364075,
-0.1947622746,
0.1428601295,
-0.6597663164,
-0.5444679856,
-0.5630627275,
-0.096245788,
-0.4610800147,
0.0114784315,
-0.49645257,
-0.2603262365,
-0.1666068584,
-0.2051014155,
0.5078157187,
0.4320799112,
0.0571291782,
0.1392981857,
-0.4509886801,
0.3163404763,
0.2032706887,
0.5427626967,
-0.1205619723,
-0.5034802556,
-0.0686791912,
0.0230270941,
-0.4328371584,
-0.6793705821,
0.271735996,
0.2011788189,
0.488402307,
0.2735260129,
0.1627670527,
0.7156565785,
-0.338568002,
0.5684706569,
-0.0130464807,
-0.6898656487,
0.4473657012,
-0.1262131035,
0.1413818151,
0.5204243064,
0.311521709,
-0.4322720468,
-0.7491781116,
-0.4378876984,
-0.9886338115,
0.3639668822,
0.1704848558,
0.0531775504,
0.110330902,
0.4016340375,
0.1585493833,
-0.0147080394,
-0.594209075,
-0.4874292016,
0.0367639475,
-0.0473389551,
-0.363768518,
-0.403197974,
0.2380108535,
-0.205411464,
0.7988948822,
-0.4315592945,
0.1719629616,
0.2061192393,
0.0199642275,
-0.1634528488,
0.4000194073,
0.6891456842,
0.3853062093,
-0.0662726536,
0.198872447,
0.2483991235,
-0.5159417391,
0.1352020651,
0.2132211924,
-0.1987761706,
0.0278336369,
0.2347844839,
0.7564206719,
0.3394555449,
-0.5938612819,
0.4778034687,
-0.0335803889,
0.0478958786,
-0.1113216728,
0.1521641165,
0.2507739365,
0.2516551316,
0.316598475,
0.1451751441,
0.0975646973,
-0.2950982153,
0.3686097264,
0.3894646466,
-0.3654087484,
-0.0053064516,
0.237722531,
0.091490306,
-0.0581411682,
0.5338298082,
-0.4361091852,
-0.8286732435,
0.6102885008,
0.3904927671,
0.7299830914,
-0.5596182942,
0.047672648,
0.2097994089,
0.5253049731,
-0.1560511291,
0.3338550031,
0.4882923365,
-0.7204455137,
-0.7354625463,
-0.5800260901,
-0.3710621297,
0.3640471399,
-0.1332590878,
0.3749900162,
-0.2024438977,
-0.1056847125,
-0.2963845432,
-0.0393212028,
-0.4394847453,
0.1506780684,
0.3927449584,
0.9053220153,
-0.7565976977,
0.9825018644,
0.2703119516,
0.0165752769,
-1.0332715511,
0.2151105106,
0.004608559,
-0.7309350967,
0.258009851,
0.3064753115,
0.0897441283,
-0.0789343193,
-0.3730764985,
-0.7314561009,
0.9842677116,
0.8738518953,
-0.7688140869,
0.2161660939,
0.0798633248,
0.2622416615,
-0.0449648201,
0.329295665,
0.5899180174,
0.7929393053,
0.2394575328,
-0.7889329791,
0.1964951009,
-0.1825748384,
-0.1246894673,
0.4215198159,
-0.3687013388,
0.8780438304,
-0.3957922757,
0.137851119,
0.067452006,
0.6131697893,
0.5765687823,
0.3541266322,
0.7554021478,
0.5921571255,
1.1174038649,
-0.2697515786,
1.3655357361,
0.1564780623,
0.5093576312,
0.9498480558,
-0.3235094249,
0.6176130176,
0.4206857681,
-0.2255402952,
0.499229759,
0.7942007184,
-0.085314475,
0.2435019761,
0.633757472,
-0.1458235234,
-0.3984704614,
0.0012117844,
-0.5440211296,
-0.0321755819,
0.1817661673,
-0.2812343836,
-0.1494608372,
0.0188665297,
0.315458566,
-0.1732665896,
-0.2238420993,
0.2396774739,
0.1955411285,
-0.695215106,
0.6812853217,
0.089216128,
0.9656586647,
-0.7584986687,
-0.0811825097,
-0.6032406092,
0.4385893643,
-0.2957138419,
-0.6558359265,
0.0514119342,
-0.1144611016,
-0.0248177554,
0.0036116305,
1.022816658,
-0.3351141214,
-0.589781642,
0.5444874167,
0.1089595854,
0.0949287713,
-0.6341072321,
-0.5495890975,
0.2695105672,
0.120323956,
-0.4859144986,
0.4457360208,
0.3293075562,
-0.0976522565,
0.8341490626,
0.8874631524,
0.2147805542,
0.3339738846,
0.0755442753,
1.1537870169,
-0.5191437602,
-0.3538000584,
-0.8772143126,
0.6152306795,
-0.0475892611,
-0.2734735012,
0.6577011943,
0.3690026999,
0.6603670716,
-0.0912557095,
0.7151598334,
0.2615973651,
0.4265924096,
-0.7347829938,
0.6164398193,
-0.4168897271,
0.3919565082,
-0.3866355121,
-0.9009230733,
-0.5840991139,
0.3300368488,
-0.1286133975,
0.2663054466,
0.9459558129,
1.1256309748,
-0.0272812676,
-0.0905617028,
0.4329784513,
0.5441372991,
0.3940493166,
0.8733197451,
0.7835225463,
-0.3535253108,
0.6219862103,
-0.3698172271,
-0.4010724127,
-0.3531358242,
-1.117784977,
-0.954051435,
-0.3172648549,
-0.35180372,
-0.4169302583,
0.033659827,
0.5072239637,
0.6829225421,
-1.0248724222,
0.1771117598,
-0.0022962168,
0.4176816344,
-0.1593896747,
-0.1510903984,
0.3324169815,
-0.4217419922,
-0.5595217347,
0.8060269952,
0.3017734587,
-0.031248888,
-0.2346504033,
-0.369453907,
-0.0037082278,
-0.2972284853,
0.2818265557,
0.2686056495,
-0.6205463409,
-0.2145307362,
0.1914669722,
-0.0563905314,
-0.0065420703,
0.9225645661,
-0.7541020513,
0.302274555,
0.3616609573,
0.8966950178,
0.4296057522,
-0.4319929481,
0.589191556,
-0.6613757014,
0.2493157387,
0.3498460054,
0.5504544377,
0.488404423,
-0.6862515807,
0.5301567316,
0.306066364,
-0.6632121205,
-0.9141048193,
0.3505588174,
-0.9564656019,
-0.1659599245,
1.3356183767,
-0.3599554896,
-0.0167865604,
-0.226105094,
-0.0352119468,
0.158662349,
-0.2694564164,
0.6324791908,
0.4680651128,
0.1930175275,
-0.0246541388,
-0.5038977861,
0.559284687,
0.7219478488,
-0.8697428107,
0.0419568159,
0.2083169669,
0.2936062515,
0.038358897,
0.4693905413,
-0.1762627363,
0.1896082759,
-0.5477257371,
0.3157257438,
-0.2825112045,
-0.2541163862,
-0.5495665669,
-0.0205154568,
0.2674205005,
0.0375086553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09163v1
|
GeMQuAD : Generating Multilingual Question Answering Datasets from Large Language Models using Few Shot Learning
| 2024-04-14T06:55:42 | 2024-04-14T06:55:42 |
Amani Namboori, Shivam Mangale, Andy Rosenbaum, Saleh Soltan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) with capabilities like
In-Context Learning (ICL) has ushered in new possibilities for data generation
across various domains while minimizing the need for extensive data collection
and modeling techniques. Researchers have explored ways to use this generated
synthetic data to optimize smaller student models for reduced deployment costs
and lower latency in downstream tasks. However, ICL-generated data often
suffers from low quality as the task specificity is limited with few examples
used in ICL. In this paper, we propose GeMQuAD - a semi-supervised learning
approach, extending the WeakDAP framework, applied to a dataset generated
through ICL with just one example in the target language using AlexaTM 20B
Seq2Seq LLM. Through our approach, we iteratively identify high-quality data to
enhance model performance, especially for low-resource multilingual setting in
the context of Extractive Question Answering task. Our framework outperforms
the machine translation-augmented model by 0.22/1.68 F1/EM (Exact Match) points
for Hindi and 0.82/1.37 F1/EM points for Spanish on the MLQA dataset, and it
surpasses the performance of model trained on an English-only dataset by
5.05/6.50 F1/EM points for Hindi and 3.81/3.69 points F1/EM for Spanish on the
same dataset. Notably, our approach uses a pre-trained LLM for generation with
no fine-tuning (FT), utilizing just a single annotated example in ICL to
generate data, providing a cost-effective development process.
|
[
-0.3132050931,
-1.1593315601,
0.3884499371,
-0.0307481177,
-0.1659931391,
0.2855164409,
-0.2301069498,
-0.2619229257,
-0.1434996575,
0.4120442271,
-0.5440332294,
-0.7510230541,
-0.0654430464,
0.0774864033,
-0.4503183365,
1.2067081928,
0.1232726052,
0.1931387037,
-0.2250291556,
-0.0905708,
-0.2991234362,
-0.2930587828,
-0.4532656372,
-0.1504608393,
0.1581318527,
1.0009607077,
0.5327678919,
0.1634919345,
0.2517746985,
0.1609816551,
-0.0427373722,
0.3682243526,
-0.6518796682,
-0.0612879992,
0.1047003493,
-0.4009111822,
-0.2513758838,
-0.1996908486,
0.7900378704,
0.8178830147,
-0.4578211308,
0.3841051161,
0.3225444853,
0.1489496529,
-0.4487574697,
0.0202399697,
-0.6865187287,
-0.1004063636,
-0.3177501261,
0.1331968755,
-0.322704941,
-0.3252635002,
-0.0087302364,
-0.3821872771,
0.5387195945,
0.0386255421,
0.8537049294,
0.0210517086,
-0.2114089429,
-0.1071943045,
-0.6212825775,
0.8923193812,
-0.9575599432,
0.1071805432,
0.4053167403,
0.3991311789,
0.0466830991,
-0.4163057208,
-0.771225512,
0.1787652522,
0.0275822841,
0.0929014981,
0.0129165621,
-0.1560498774,
0.2638895214,
0.3994648457,
-0.909745574,
0.0790266469,
-0.4861442149,
-0.0297470726,
0.687741518,
0.1595428288,
0.3152592182,
-0.3869225383,
-0.3039144576,
0.0194524843,
-1.0064516068,
0.0656368285,
0.250908196,
0.7963862419,
-0.4462468922,
0.652636826,
-0.3444463015,
0.5927322507,
-0.0729915053,
-0.3274963498,
0.1654065102,
-0.2205905169,
-0.1873933524,
0.115675427,
0.7775998116,
-0.1684495658,
0.162048921,
-0.1815757602,
-0.0903583243,
-0.1640444249,
-0.2201126516,
-0.7195559144,
-0.2940638661,
0.2138752937,
-0.0363247469,
-0.1612797827,
-0.3430143297,
-0.8551832438,
-0.1662477702,
-0.1414450854,
0.3728837371,
-0.4573925436,
-0.0139339752,
-0.1055481508,
0.4170286655,
0.5277297497,
0.1824884266,
-0.8012371063,
0.222325772,
0.2847745121,
0.7099567056,
-0.2669083774,
-0.4595522285,
-0.7774963975,
0.1477668434,
-0.5091834664,
0.7674059272,
-0.3673978746,
-0.4846566319,
-0.0368302129,
-0.2040091753,
0.0642023906,
-0.5366161466,
0.4290113151,
-0.5066014528,
0.25576666,
-0.0688637793,
-0.391851455,
-0.0106181363,
0.4172277451,
-0.372372508,
1.2966746092,
0.2417572439,
-0.6409127712,
0.2904337347,
-0.3230986595,
-0.6276712418,
0.3751665354,
-0.2337607443,
-0.4448938668,
-0.0497366115,
0.6119429469,
0.6978703141,
-0.7332369089,
0.4459254444,
-0.2962706089,
-0.2006247491,
-0.034036167,
-0.2898834944,
0.6879271269,
0.1893292964,
-0.0651157647,
-0.0916001499,
-0.7236520648,
0.3383207023,
0.1484221816,
-0.4017008245,
-0.1237352639,
-0.1815293729,
0.1967607588,
0.4102531075,
-0.1549581885,
-0.6635544896,
0.015026127,
-0.6635455489,
0.1597737223,
0.6895139813,
0.2187337279,
0.3343359232,
-0.0395003967,
0.795479238,
-0.0227746498,
0.0668675154,
0.0407687724,
-0.3311628401,
-0.8357511759,
-0.3258355856,
0.3535993099,
0.5652660728,
-1.3196015358,
-0.1594538242,
-0.4455696642,
-0.4146856368,
-0.8410626054,
0.7570766211,
0.5315377712,
0.7118691802,
0.4724900126,
0.0382239409,
-0.1180528998,
-0.9812960029,
0.0026603153,
-0.1742512882,
0.0797055736,
0.2288605273,
0.4850876927,
0.1573421806,
1.059762001,
-0.5721139908,
-0.2682825029,
-0.7729433179,
0.2232122123,
0.4392448366,
0.40797472,
0.2851403952,
-0.7728828788,
-0.7620792389,
-0.114359498,
-0.823921144,
0.0118474057,
-0.0366383009,
-0.2213781625,
0.0142444214,
0.1958016157,
-0.4741721153,
0.1336655766,
0.519986093,
0.0311657973,
0.3394153714,
-0.0623951182,
0.0292986091,
-1.4896576405,
-0.0334570706,
0.1821995527,
-0.1787436008,
-0.6914379597,
0.2167062461,
0.1382328421,
-0.6041111946,
-0.8081521392,
0.7382979989,
-0.4481784701,
0.1049648523,
0.0293308757,
0.1097357348,
-0.1799612194,
0.5899322629,
0.2569583952,
0.9579645991,
0.7343425751,
-0.5126045942,
0.3154377043,
0.4517056346,
-0.4822805226,
0.5972139835,
-0.824650526,
0.1467435509,
-0.1694223881,
-0.2444072813,
-0.8340175152,
-0.4073860943,
-0.1990887821,
-0.3536103666,
0.4917006493,
-0.4051606953,
-0.7404823899,
-0.2376231402,
-0.1351220906,
0.4289423823,
0.4846018255,
-0.7042707205,
0.417961508,
0.422398746,
-0.4656136632,
-0.4456846714,
-0.846228838,
0.0697981641,
-0.281935215,
-0.5802112222,
-0.1887045354,
-0.0772479102,
-0.1002147421,
-0.3227364719,
0.1557165235,
-0.1437776983,
0.0224171188,
-0.1202047467,
0.3769043982,
-0.2944711447,
0.275028348,
0.1579316258,
-0.1404605657,
-0.2605675757,
0.0716038942,
0.4214489162,
-0.0705743209,
-0.3644010723,
-0.1621435285,
0.6818089485,
0.1995701641,
-0.3541016877,
0.7012681365,
0.5114002824,
-0.3818208873,
-0.7864694595,
-0.2270418704,
-0.1184199527,
-0.4193472564,
0.3339291811,
-0.5615434051,
-0.652489543,
0.4026919603,
0.044659853,
0.065761216,
0.3513338566,
0.6571285725,
-0.1775629073,
1.2206172943,
0.7029764652,
-0.3132095039,
0.110653311,
-0.4676772654,
0.3802464604,
-0.7057397366,
-0.0995840803,
-0.4983145893,
0.021791758,
-0.5353989601,
-0.4529524744,
0.7385806441,
0.2297379076,
-0.0569480322,
0.0107776886,
-0.1939364821,
0.6067613363,
0.5547116995,
0.115583919,
0.2533507645,
0.0391842723,
-0.0659814179,
0.0994266272,
-1.061981082,
-0.4882946312,
1.2469022274,
-0.0664565265,
1.2770709991,
0.419970721,
0.6364747882,
0.1932362169,
0.1772354096,
-0.556030333,
0.5385559201,
0.0523476414,
-0.6770755053,
-0.1211091429,
-0.5520836115,
-0.6299540401,
0.0769573972,
-0.3801926076,
-0.6762230396,
0.1194807664,
0.1379503757,
-0.4189815521,
0.1336447448,
-0.9338772297,
0.8223641515,
-0.2806682885,
-0.7748661637,
0.0583503097,
-0.7179065943,
0.6110370159,
-0.2641819417,
0.1608767807,
-0.1920254678,
0.4159200788,
0.6522976756,
-0.3208711147,
0.8370324373,
-0.0831768215,
-0.0671552867,
0.3815896511,
0.0839002207,
0.6114989519,
0.5217000842,
-0.1028091162,
-0.0163628235,
0.027928615,
-0.7147137523,
-0.2843087912,
0.8129684329,
-0.7209139466,
-0.4377143383,
-0.4180376828,
-0.6606554389,
-0.6503075361,
0.0975773111,
0.2045471817,
0.6173912287,
-0.0962216109,
0.0830998346,
0.7391762733,
-0.2652031481,
0.449426651,
0.5353592038,
0.0219991431,
-0.1390278786,
0.9583397508,
-0.0905453488,
0.4211755395,
0.2558630407,
0.0289403684,
-0.4246983528,
-0.5770564675,
-0.8120076656,
0.2928397954,
-0.8235527277,
-0.4105231464,
-0.3998577893,
-0.1485877484,
-0.3843027353,
-0.0129952263,
-0.357450515,
-0.0929683745,
-0.2287844419,
-0.0102159539,
0.2452302128,
0.3520433307,
0.2519103587,
0.3619178236,
-0.7777857184,
0.5883014798,
0.5177326202,
0.0073487307,
-0.1440743953,
-0.4251236916,
-0.4805765748,
0.2287992537,
-0.1964090765,
-0.7854098678,
0.5647767186,
0.5659298301,
0.4778710008,
0.2515293658,
0.2692524791,
0.8432047367,
-0.3493902981,
0.8716961145,
-0.0683901161,
-0.8780000806,
0.7784103751,
-0.3255239129,
0.6200680137,
0.7010242343,
0.5369906425,
-0.4407088757,
-0.419485718,
-0.6137479544,
-0.7403681874,
0.8810742497,
0.1550788283,
0.3504625559,
-0.0034671619,
0.2273371816,
0.2021403462,
0.1884782165,
-0.6376118064,
-0.1501520723,
0.2531787157,
-0.400939852,
-0.441309303,
-0.1325162798,
-0.0841014236,
-0.2236371189,
0.9377365112,
-0.587346673,
-0.0519130714,
-0.0129768224,
-0.4749208093,
0.0121866679,
0.4362333417,
0.1150284782,
0.7984113693,
-0.0389917828,
0.143968448,
0.456338644,
-0.2878522277,
0.0006780822,
0.1482077092,
-0.3406086266,
-0.1121436432,
0.4351947904,
0.6150865555,
-0.1639634371,
-0.9678832889,
0.4584101439,
0.0534032695,
0.1586789042,
0.0502927639,
0.0317279212,
-0.0961243808,
0.2952003479,
0.4404752254,
-0.3865113854,
0.0095123732,
-0.6543799639,
0.0947554931,
0.4776418805,
-0.2040137947,
-0.4360420108,
0.6683825254,
0.0336391255,
0.1663251668,
0.9280309677,
-0.2466243356,
-0.3775268197,
0.2901085019,
0.6754231453,
0.5740863085,
-0.2347845286,
0.4288226664,
0.4326602221,
0.1746342182,
0.1429546624,
0.5476411581,
-0.1615633518,
-0.7398321629,
-0.4356809556,
-0.7863819003,
-0.3799920678,
0.0068709087,
-0.6135937572,
0.5396906137,
-0.186940074,
0.2196456045,
-0.0683163106,
0.137837857,
-0.7231945395,
0.305362761,
0.1297949106,
0.5201300979,
-1.2963855267,
1.0027935505,
0.7592449188,
-0.5044543147,
-0.848333776,
-0.1197674572,
-0.0789394751,
-0.8045822382,
0.2361907363,
-0.2805139124,
-0.0104098367,
0.347948879,
-0.6115019321,
-0.6390962005,
0.8662506342,
0.5015444756,
-0.2276677489,
-0.0016283956,
0.2780481577,
0.4288693964,
-0.1566022784,
0.1939672828,
0.4194275439,
0.0256885961,
0.3303804696,
-0.6476280093,
-0.1273136586,
-0.3718838096,
0.0359679237,
0.3001417816,
-0.5183777213,
0.7251173258,
-0.4307939112,
-0.3488999605,
0.0545188859,
0.446939379,
0.2862967849,
0.0353837125,
0.0330927372,
0.5841569901,
0.7574895024,
-0.071775116,
1.1355667114,
-0.0579304434,
0.5981812477,
1.1465216875,
-0.3609451354,
0.9695968628,
0.5413541794,
-0.2229228616,
0.0467634611,
0.8928757906,
0.0789275616,
0.6542007923,
-0.1287688315,
-0.3203374743,
-0.5577526093,
-0.2509641647,
-0.1406692266,
0.5414466262,
0.1855234355,
-0.0234228857,
-0.6763082743,
0.2757176161,
-0.0750827417,
-0.0378675349,
-0.1603153795,
0.8771079183,
-0.0495944172,
-0.2687021494,
0.8325933218,
0.0491064414,
0.4230732024,
-0.7231740952,
-0.1390663087,
-0.5835368633,
0.0405489691,
-0.1741436422,
-0.7644415498,
-0.0641613752,
0.4150520861,
-0.1397786587,
-0.2085599899,
0.4296141863,
-0.676631093,
-0.8700138927,
-0.1684155613,
0.9609943032,
0.26840657,
0.147479564,
-0.7349529862,
-0.3647356331,
-0.034294609,
-0.1250578016,
0.3001766503,
0.2878159285,
-0.2630853951,
0.6734147668,
0.6910803318,
0.1982333213,
0.0583416186,
0.09879224,
0.8908151388,
-0.3737585247,
-0.4292569458,
-0.6351607442,
0.5100587606,
0.0303882044,
-0.4458584487,
0.9835857749,
0.9201207757,
0.9072816968,
0.069981575,
0.7068228126,
-0.153536275,
0.7552547455,
-0.7366412282,
0.6518169045,
-0.6756288409,
0.4024775922,
-0.3611421585,
-0.9326037169,
-0.332875222,
0.294711113,
-0.3319242001,
0.045729924,
0.5918602943,
1.0681614876,
-0.3726781309,
-0.164346844,
0.3579442799,
0.1694791764,
0.2264425308,
0.7817530632,
0.9153569937,
-0.4705836177,
0.4681894183,
-0.4466003776,
0.0931144282,
0.1676385701,
-0.4516652524,
-0.8672170043,
-0.6617507935,
-0.3964090347,
-0.1551557779,
-0.1967286617,
0.827259481,
0.8325694799,
-0.931538403,
-0.3343551755,
0.1506589055,
0.2236503363,
0.0480586737,
-0.2318021506,
0.6942338943,
-0.3637980223,
-0.8841032386,
0.4456817508,
-0.010287188,
-0.0073403628,
-0.0673486218,
-0.0737126693,
-0.5875149369,
-0.218758449,
0.5768787861,
0.3430781662,
-0.4182117879,
-0.0890859812,
-0.0689190924,
0.0203040056,
0.1331175119,
0.3583447635,
-0.8139832616,
0.6174699068,
0.3696180582,
0.6915112734,
0.7273917794,
0.1518103182,
0.3873272538,
-1.1880744696,
0.1825162172,
0.4582433701,
0.1095239073,
0.4522219598,
-0.1903793663,
0.3301798403,
0.0093012638,
-0.2228143066,
-0.9320045114,
-0.0527257361,
-0.6741594672,
-0.1947566718,
1.2102677822,
-0.0415960066,
-0.2824062705,
-0.0896136314,
-0.091288887,
0.0950769559,
-0.2770803273,
0.5927515626,
0.4589961469,
-0.148879841,
-0.4874017835,
-0.6993255019,
0.3812251687,
0.2699423432,
-1.1170448065,
-0.0211987514,
0.5447424054,
0.2313121259,
-0.1985436231,
0.3332650959,
0.0730311722,
0.2878924012,
-0.2865053713,
0.2424687147,
0.2571066022,
-0.3601682186,
-0.3549444079,
0.2842513025,
0.300067842,
-0.0308965407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09155v1
|
Mitigating Heterogeneity among Factor Tensors via Lie Group Manifolds for Tensor Decomposition Based Temporal Knowledge Graph Embedding
| 2024-04-14T06:10:46 | 2024-04-14T06:10:46 |
Jiang Li, Xiangdong Su, Yeyun Gong, Guanglai Gao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent studies have highlighted the effectiveness of tensor decomposition
methods in the Temporal Knowledge Graphs Embedding (TKGE) task. However, we
found that inherent heterogeneity among factor tensors in tensor decomposition
significantly hinders the tensor fusion process and further limits the
performance of link prediction. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a
novel method that maps factor tensors onto a unified smooth Lie group manifold
to make the distribution of factor tensors approximating homogeneous in tensor
decomposition. We provide the theoretical proof of our motivation that
homogeneous tensors are more effective than heterogeneous tensors in tensor
fusion and approximating the target for tensor decomposition based TKGE
methods. The proposed method can be directly integrated into existing tensor
decomposition based TKGE methods without introducing extra parameters.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in mitigating
the heterogeneity and in enhancing the tensor decomposition based TKGE models.
|
[
-0.4855051637,
-0.6436870098,
0.5909065604,
0.2235812098,
-0.4047696888,
0.4886080325,
0.0427509844,
-0.1258233786,
0.4171432853,
0.1107800007,
-0.7761154771,
-0.7662734985,
-0.4527620971,
-0.3579147458,
0.3070338964,
0.5051842332,
-0.1985962093,
0.257781446,
-0.3704840839,
-0.5199102759,
-0.0744671673,
-0.1968364865,
-0.3886138499,
-0.7643404603,
0.4533644915,
-0.1700332016,
0.5643972754,
0.8837014437,
0.3557294309,
0.2403815538,
0.0448849462,
0.11601381,
-0.5924090743,
0.1996127516,
0.0772957131,
-0.4386584759,
-0.444039464,
0.3178676963,
1.0191407204,
1.1597927809,
-0.0296264384,
0.2298268676,
-0.0065611643,
0.4158171117,
-0.700725913,
0.2811076939,
-0.1323201358,
0.5109721422,
-0.009816112,
-0.6096453071,
-0.229830876,
-0.4563395083,
0.2793783545,
-0.752776742,
0.4923144579,
0.4225587547,
0.3757041693,
0.4296163321,
-0.4771271348,
0.1829457134,
-0.8649542928,
0.7325488925,
-0.4471823275,
0.7084152699,
0.3038566113,
0.3147872984,
-0.1340842992,
-0.6146847606,
-0.2635983825,
-0.183013916,
-0.1530928314,
-0.0252350457,
0.0014948779,
0.1127827466,
0.0909605697,
0.1515021026,
-0.5060294867,
-0.0023340562,
-0.0999190807,
-0.4528757632,
0.2017594427,
0.3475264013,
0.2728290558,
-0.0008190915,
-0.6955919862,
0.1145924553,
-0.7328621149,
-0.2675415277,
0.6601267457,
0.0637907013,
-0.1163901761,
0.678617239,
-0.0284537338,
0.2640011013,
-0.0243690889,
-0.3593030274,
0.2619499266,
-0.2221489996,
-0.084349297,
-0.0670796782,
0.4807813764,
0.4286095202,
-0.2914593518,
-0.7778741121,
0.0259509198,
0.3215259314,
-0.0729422346,
-0.7861578465,
-0.1435046196,
0.0699436069,
-0.6716143489,
-0.3490844965,
-0.117222935,
-0.8152854443,
-0.3307602406,
-0.0643830448,
0.3963680267,
-0.154766649,
-0.4682062268,
-0.0695423037,
-0.3871349394,
0.0715443864,
0.1081517264,
-0.3776731193,
0.2271726578,
0.693364799,
0.6779190898,
-0.0060830018,
-0.2482156754,
-0.6128836274,
0.7333365679,
-0.1997826248,
0.4703227878,
-0.6815187931,
-0.5158886313,
0.2476641089,
-0.2053686827,
-0.0405345,
-0.2830854654,
0.0291712899,
-0.4381599724,
0.4689791501,
-0.4979508817,
-0.830624342,
-0.2140282542,
0.1177384406,
-0.7141545415,
0.6253975034,
0.3870093524,
-0.6610955596,
0.5343771577,
-0.7632786632,
-0.3830698431,
0.0292013176,
-0.1954250038,
-0.5137424469,
0.0986125469,
0.2189516723,
0.8452080488,
-0.4889486134,
0.0881949514,
-0.8684203625,
-0.1569373757,
-0.0789196864,
-0.0425697155,
0.7709479332,
0.262596637,
-0.4094699621,
-0.1023649797,
-0.2339347899,
-0.0219083428,
0.0157533623,
-0.1533794701,
-0.496160239,
0.0712311566,
-0.1954815984,
0.0583022609,
-0.0671043471,
-0.5170570612,
0.4659361541,
0.2064069957,
0.0055819517,
0.8978168368,
0.2118070871,
0.8897114396,
-0.2527950406,
0.6316578388,
0.1674448997,
0.2277202457,
0.5990227461,
-0.3280656636,
-0.4591060281,
-0.508853972,
0.2225831002,
0.0147932824,
-1.0492964983,
0.1342864186,
-0.3456151187,
-0.5812857747,
-0.3800084293,
-0.0855470523,
0.4757654965,
0.719545126,
0.320028156,
-0.1808797121,
-0.3186763823,
-0.7882143855,
-0.3110340834,
-0.4113920629,
-0.1163666695,
0.2263222933,
0.1294776648,
-0.3844336867,
0.6277492642,
-0.8461084962,
-0.3829400539,
0.1455129385,
0.5206715465,
-0.3245666623,
0.5226498246,
0.8761187196,
-0.6772793531,
-0.1263835877,
-0.282961309,
-0.9010538459,
0.0444228873,
0.219976306,
-0.0754525289,
0.52223593,
0.7986625433,
-0.2043594271,
0.5065072179,
0.5133273005,
-0.9938845634,
0.1229258552,
-0.016205905,
0.1091256291,
-1.0109772682,
0.0015610732,
0.3194596469,
-0.3507700264,
-0.5069201589,
-0.0426589027,
-0.1381265372,
-0.2863940895,
-0.2006938159,
0.3889269233,
-0.4051068723,
-0.0735362098,
0.0710107461,
-0.319142729,
-0.2533899248,
0.7731207609,
-0.3644166887,
0.1218078956,
0.4293043911,
-0.5035769939,
0.0816233754,
0.0542974547,
-0.1854207218,
0.5757164359,
-0.4791549742,
-0.0503044873,
-0.3562873602,
0.5303148031,
-0.8277648091,
-0.0382262878,
0.4142129421,
-0.2035810202,
0.6113957167,
-0.4499181807,
-0.1858623624,
0.0165406745,
-0.5616781712,
0.5774129033,
0.6023175716,
-0.5610285401,
1.3619742393,
0.4430110753,
0.1547138393,
-0.4891696572,
-0.5058383942,
-0.5997998118,
-0.4386882782,
-0.8323200345,
0.4944166243,
-0.0840525255,
-0.1344419867,
0.7626342773,
-0.4487414062,
0.199865073,
0.1320407093,
0.2393042296,
0.4138555825,
-0.3224146664,
0.1870024353,
-0.0394748971,
-0.413220197,
0.0976016894,
-0.5976213813,
0.8546607494,
-0.0015445086,
-0.5141689777,
-0.1342182159,
0.5790872574,
0.568659544,
-0.1392470747,
1.041388154,
1.5101214647,
-0.4203833044,
-0.0852035061,
-0.8915749788,
-0.1393621564,
-0.4919363558,
0.3338913023,
-0.1216703132,
-1.1270577908,
0.777449131,
-0.3415230513,
-0.1541249007,
0.7566983104,
0.5343356133,
-0.1419682354,
1.0020891428,
0.7583114505,
-0.4154793322,
0.4525187314,
-0.4789425135,
0.2093253732,
-0.7767945528,
-0.5580480099,
-0.5080115795,
-0.5499931574,
-1.1658133268,
-0.5177816749,
0.6255792975,
-0.2696940005,
-0.3012389839,
-0.3082879782,
-0.0603090227,
0.223729074,
0.4172630608,
0.2227497399,
0.0574722141,
0.3135279119,
-0.2259035856,
0.1326025128,
-0.9707522392,
0.1563296914,
1.0647690296,
0.332544595,
0.8958123326,
0.1501250565,
0.7865579128,
0.3018629551,
0.2203029394,
-0.484406352,
0.4828051031,
-0.114180021,
-0.2593763769,
-0.2704817057,
-0.9082947969,
-0.5277914405,
-0.0415287465,
-0.4434311688,
-0.693929255,
0.4332966208,
-0.0384653844,
0.0307500809,
0.7355726957,
-0.7607685328,
0.373906523,
0.5225358605,
-0.3525718451,
-0.2737039626,
-0.4357018769,
0.0375402682,
0.120701395,
-0.1919804811,
-0.379907161,
-0.1408105493,
1.1623899937,
-0.4854401946,
0.5699953437,
-0.795732975,
0.3709369302,
0.1385827065,
0.1589058489,
0.5248365998,
0.205329299,
-0.0555500276,
0.2166898847,
-0.4204143882,
-0.7850624323,
-0.8888412714,
0.8066887259,
-1.0209475756,
-0.6404855251,
-0.2368764579,
-0.7777366042,
-0.5862575173,
-0.1136457473,
0.1793231368,
0.6289045811,
0.0195725765,
0.4049081206,
0.6199638844,
0.0581082776,
0.5815403461,
0.2942264974,
-0.140115723,
-0.4947911799,
0.8861144185,
0.238633424,
0.210930407,
0.1539878547,
0.3791027665,
-0.35318771,
-0.5200095177,
0.249470517,
0.4168649912,
-0.688008368,
-0.0631662086,
-0.6239871383,
0.2348611653,
-0.4951114655,
-0.4195845425,
-0.4086934924,
-0.5390610099,
0.0514726825,
0.0142690111,
0.2494989485,
0.7382495403,
-0.2155997008,
0.0872102305,
-0.4513448775,
0.3956491649,
0.4092536867,
0.8982573152,
-0.0876368806,
0.0965389237,
-0.126273945,
-0.2422174513,
0.2555777729,
-0.513040781,
0.0493135601,
-0.164389208,
1.0060774088,
0.2220366746,
-0.0560375862,
0.6238418818,
-0.2011945844,
0.6449356079,
0.3446109593,
-0.6700103283,
0.0024210003,
-0.6016613245,
0.147293061,
0.2792697549,
0.7156578302,
-0.2009869367,
-0.2037751079,
-0.8714271784,
-0.8827059269,
0.4931837618,
0.3093944788,
-0.4124371707,
0.4681108892,
0.1762164682,
-0.0183106177,
0.091876857,
-0.1945480108,
-0.7683788538,
-0.1646880358,
-0.048885446,
-0.3010579348,
-0.40585199,
-0.4187051952,
-0.2809680998,
0.7800061703,
-0.2141655236,
1.0382339954,
0.0881004706,
0.0731344298,
-0.413097024,
-0.3088811934,
0.3956560791,
0.5956324935,
-0.4173081815,
-0.0658215582,
-0.0286537372,
-0.5695121288,
0.2804128528,
0.3759813011,
-0.0346165746,
0.0315466896,
0.5137420893,
0.6391436458,
-0.1452665031,
0.6178146005,
0.1637042314,
-0.2899042368,
-0.197706759,
0.0789808184,
-0.0328754485,
0.1209552214,
0.6233677268,
0.5337785482,
0.2529457808,
-0.2935528159,
-0.3971387446,
-0.0546084605,
0.2453736216,
-0.5060244799,
-0.227518633,
0.5665488839,
0.1997603476,
-0.2010084242,
0.4598321915,
-0.2025060356,
-0.6743261814,
0.4379391372,
0.4071702361,
1.1604288816,
-0.3924203813,
0.3217572868,
0.1262604147,
0.2070225924,
0.0832754597,
0.3331915438,
0.251947403,
-0.6166243553,
-0.1953164339,
-0.4422516525,
-0.1903764755,
-0.0812439397,
-0.5240898132,
-0.132292524,
-0.597866118,
0.0048184637,
-0.0955336615,
0.2366732955,
-1.2831149101,
0.0907622427,
-0.0913422182,
0.3673529327,
-0.9949572086,
0.5914343596,
0.6008223295,
-0.2979372442,
-1.0328961611,
0.3771382868,
0.1434179544,
-0.7142601013,
0.2875545025,
-0.3454491794,
-0.0978827104,
-0.1011404321,
-0.4105806649,
-0.6443488598,
1.4680262804,
0.6128592491,
0.2008157969,
0.0723097026,
0.4500342906,
0.2521352768,
-0.5365689397,
-0.1350006163,
0.1010994911,
0.6433258057,
0.093737185,
-0.3730686307,
0.3338872492,
-0.3241293132,
0.073605068,
0.3017528355,
-0.5996616483,
0.6935107112,
0.2817594111,
-0.0054159006,
-0.4938969016,
0.7186113,
-0.0347724035,
0.3302211165,
0.8540223241,
0.520154655,
0.7911347151,
-0.2877161205,
1.1691000462,
-0.0156612452,
0.5261361599,
0.5861068964,
-0.0052916463,
0.0041528586,
0.7131268382,
-0.0780422986,
0.4475698173,
0.2930903733,
0.1777684987,
0.7464050651,
-0.0668712109,
-0.4543789029,
-0.4114276469,
-0.5354052186,
-0.5951004028,
0.3089759648,
0.2568306625,
-0.1408583671,
-0.306283921,
-0.1285024434,
0.1510258466,
-0.3863200843,
-0.4380781353,
0.447131604,
-0.1314911097,
-0.3812040985,
0.2893954515,
-0.0999720916,
0.4762796462,
-0.692463398,
0.1031049564,
-0.3247609735,
0.0662535131,
-0.2420607358,
-0.3905296922,
0.1946921945,
-0.5071496367,
-0.0383142792,
-0.275675714,
1.1179075241,
-0.5864392519,
-0.4673114419,
0.3334012628,
0.6568350792,
-0.5559108257,
0.2140856981,
-0.1326984316,
-0.0838348493,
0.0599236563,
-0.6957286,
0.3541047871,
0.3440912068,
0.0834652334,
0.77094239,
0.5624639988,
-0.1981529295,
0.1140760705,
-0.0570323654,
1.1225537062,
-0.4513397515,
-0.5623573661,
-0.6944391727,
0.5736938715,
0.019769704,
-0.1390678734,
0.6813260317,
0.2403221428,
0.659878552,
-0.0841469839,
0.7236357927,
-0.0778645203,
0.0467526466,
-0.5694753528,
0.9120625257,
-0.8018169999,
0.2536900342,
-0.3816229403,
-1.1226806641,
-0.4142417908,
0.082619153,
-0.144984588,
0.2579476833,
0.9227143526,
0.7278162837,
-0.1896740198,
0.1905052215,
0.2596033216,
0.0481714755,
0.5397552848,
0.2325520366,
0.4608689547,
-0.168421492,
0.3055580854,
-0.5500255227,
-0.0450383611,
-0.2436365932,
-1.119187355,
-1.1672259569,
-0.8424815536,
-0.5405219197,
-0.4648455977,
0.0301536936,
1.0309957266,
0.5307510495,
-0.3536553681,
0.2159007341,
0.3308724165,
0.1451884657,
-0.0115477601,
-0.1554118991,
0.7061168551,
-0.1204845384,
-0.3911615312,
0.268794328,
0.275616765,
0.0219273791,
-0.6631996036,
-0.3537549376,
-0.3523910046,
-0.3629106581,
0.2838488221,
-0.0259292889,
-0.2340370864,
-0.7280108333,
0.0324249417,
-0.0718085021,
-0.2495210618,
1.136058569,
-0.7711848617,
0.3870759904,
0.9258544445,
0.8333849311,
0.7986245155,
-0.4237357974,
0.9062100649,
-0.9152938128,
0.3232353926,
0.3551766574,
0.6344227195,
0.0981657431,
-0.4547546506,
0.9317512512,
0.7343692183,
-0.2589983642,
-0.5610530376,
0.1035562456,
-1.0802086592,
-0.1623250991,
1.2796040773,
-0.3391815424,
-0.4413057566,
-0.200873822,
0.5275815129,
0.9304593205,
-0.1863294542,
0.7366389632,
0.5165537596,
0.0933452994,
0.4546539485,
-0.0167869665,
0.3260624409,
0.5904299021,
-0.5704161525,
-0.5063823462,
0.2717391253,
0.3301029801,
0.101013042,
0.5507668853,
-0.1770388782,
0.2387922406,
0.1233331114,
-0.1731967628,
-0.7011547089,
-0.1765602231,
0.0097769145,
0.4868378937,
-0.3766816854,
-0.1457750797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09145v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09145v2
|
ToNER: Type-oriented Named Entity Recognition with Generative Language Model
| 2024-04-14T05:13:37 | 2024-06-11T14:05:03 |
Guochao Jiang, Ziqin Luo, Yuchen Shi, Dixuan Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Deqing Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, the fine-tuned generative models have been proven more
powerful than the previous tagging-based or span-based models on named entity
recognition (NER) task. It has also been found that the information related to
entities, such as entity types, can prompt a model to achieve NER better.
However, it is not easy to determine the entity types indeed existing in the
given sentence in advance, and inputting too many potential entity types would
distract the model inevitably. To exploit entity types' merit on promoting NER
task, in this paper we propose a novel NER framework, namely ToNER based on a
generative model. In ToNER, a type matching model is proposed at first to
identify the entity types most likely to appear in the sentence. Then, we
append a multiple binary classification task to fine-tune the generative
model's encoder, so as to generate the refined representation of the input
sentence. Moreover, we add an auxiliary task for the model to discover the
entity types which further fine-tunes the model to output more accurate
results. Our extensive experiments on some NER benchmarks verify the
effectiveness of our proposed strategies in ToNER that are oriented towards
entity types' exploitation.
|
[
-0.4190209806,
-0.5756857395,
0.388917923,
0.1701681465,
-0.3831043243,
-0.0234627631,
-0.1147812754,
-0.6292889118,
0.3190874159,
0.8283335567,
-0.1490458697,
-0.3350609243,
-0.520796597,
0.3455363214,
-0.6264096498,
0.9648349285,
0.0056253588,
0.1005598381,
-0.1190664619,
-0.1291352212,
-0.4831818342,
-0.5760142207,
-1.0056141615,
-0.2987690568,
0.4230304956,
0.3007801175,
0.1663485616,
0.5938173532,
0.6855316162,
0.3109732568,
-0.2857869267,
0.0644883588,
-0.3023540974,
0.2552773654,
-0.0675332546,
-0.6194448471,
-0.3316127658,
-0.4804577827,
0.6721640229,
0.3689209819,
-0.2083992362,
0.1695619524,
-0.0628113598,
0.608341217,
-0.4747190177,
0.1900812238,
-0.8186176419,
0.045358479,
-0.3765775859,
-0.2106860727,
-0.6083956361,
-0.3494972289,
-0.1375827044,
-0.3289883435,
0.439602226,
0.2114001662,
0.9456576705,
0.2095614225,
-0.5231234431,
-0.4239908159,
-0.9310306907,
0.3015905321,
-0.6676418781,
0.4037411213,
-0.0291925464,
0.3791614175,
-0.1481783837,
-0.5981834531,
-0.7411087155,
-0.1945189685,
-0.0208200943,
0.0357735083,
-0.0859861299,
0.3014441431,
0.3357123435,
0.7113016248,
-0.1786682308,
0.0858216807,
-0.1272662431,
-0.115556702,
0.1554402709,
0.0589290336,
0.5395648479,
-0.1554373503,
-0.3756707013,
0.0593761131,
-0.623503387,
0.0908557475,
0.3298051953,
0.5493740439,
0.160434261,
1.0430232286,
-0.2758494318,
0.9684036374,
0.5633923411,
-0.0463696159,
-0.0079339016,
-0.0260001346,
-0.2269584537,
0.3491095901,
0.4741995931,
0.0406200886,
0.2531864047,
-0.2960124314,
-0.5672251582,
0.2138190866,
0.1858557761,
-1.0234476328,
-0.191014573,
-0.1259666383,
-0.5797483921,
-0.3750022352,
-0.0152472071,
-0.8750144839,
-0.3888878226,
-0.2305337787,
0.2633845806,
-0.6219562888,
-0.2764244676,
0.0388073623,
0.0168770496,
0.3500560224,
0.2790970206,
-0.9891805053,
0.3497419953,
0.7679679394,
0.6582736969,
-0.0036253489,
0.2509188652,
-0.6025698781,
0.2286377847,
-0.0668945909,
1.0299065113,
-0.7175056338,
-0.3472434282,
-0.0336212926,
-0.1905364543,
-0.074374482,
-0.6543832421,
0.5776380897,
-1.0108948946,
0.0877241492,
-0.1216115728,
-0.9183116555,
-0.3510024548,
0.3045285344,
-1.06552279,
0.7235587835,
0.1302683502,
-1.0328680277,
0.6289970875,
-0.6048999429,
-0.4631382823,
0.4590835571,
-0.147266075,
-0.5187584162,
0.2909444869,
-0.0008673822,
0.2343576252,
-0.339904964,
0.4469657242,
-0.2407188118,
-0.053547278,
0.2858112752,
-0.1950313002,
0.5216606259,
0.0417496115,
-0.1886450946,
0.0630010441,
-1.0327347517,
0.0250172466,
0.091241315,
-0.6808918118,
-0.5056254864,
0.0039138999,
0.2786003649,
0.1838988513,
0.1447909772,
-0.5406352282,
0.0569900051,
-0.3786732256,
0.2243229598,
0.3269448876,
0.0240506344,
0.5903522372,
-0.1342665702,
0.5820208192,
-0.0730717704,
-0.3780736923,
0.0291454457,
-0.3368661702,
-1.2179929018,
-0.2309187204,
0.6039347053,
0.5355980396,
-0.8484783769,
0.3586268723,
-0.2963812351,
-0.3902244866,
-0.5559464097,
-0.1169940829,
0.5154628158,
0.7221306562,
0.3966401815,
-0.3194566369,
-0.7373177409,
-0.8462917805,
-0.3761339188,
-0.1744678468,
0.118727304,
0.3915149271,
0.3259876668,
-0.1372856349,
1.066955328,
-0.4379753768,
-0.4283160269,
-0.4985429645,
0.1836956143,
0.0108438702,
0.496914804,
0.3645772636,
-1.0297551155,
-0.4155064225,
-0.0323120058,
-0.4794619083,
0.0777546465,
0.1069472209,
0.113111794,
0.0826911554,
0.5936259627,
-0.4987358153,
-0.0580419078,
0.3271991014,
-0.3083078563,
0.5239821672,
-0.0154612819,
-0.1490205228,
-1.2225660086,
0.05096687,
0.0791632682,
-0.2581636906,
-0.7642653584,
0.1445222944,
0.1256342977,
-0.3186814487,
-0.0462813117,
0.6478138566,
-0.6294307709,
-0.0662538335,
-0.3195194006,
-0.2882384956,
-0.0951984823,
0.2758728862,
0.1920181066,
0.7086133957,
0.537525475,
-0.6503375173,
0.1857767254,
0.1455928683,
-0.3483912349,
0.6701289415,
-0.6525021791,
0.3249218166,
-0.4346112609,
0.0923695788,
-0.4738336504,
-0.2198852599,
0.3671146333,
-0.1572621316,
0.6553848386,
-0.5464897156,
-0.4797216654,
-0.2543216348,
0.449516952,
0.4470841885,
0.1578030139,
-0.4976391196,
1.0589113235,
0.3501804471,
-0.2265714705,
-0.3718489707,
-0.5454192162,
0.1098955199,
-0.4651780128,
-0.2202132344,
0.7879108787,
0.1566966325,
0.036943458,
0.2175699174,
-0.2593479156,
-0.2893951833,
-0.1359402984,
0.1360580325,
0.218988061,
-0.4950437546,
0.1582227647,
-0.0899502262,
-0.2303652316,
-0.0979835391,
-0.3092525601,
0.7338292003,
-0.2132010311,
-0.3375610113,
-0.2563703358,
0.3179714382,
0.2939941883,
-0.669387579,
0.5956306458,
0.4458954632,
-0.6065554619,
-0.0969299078,
-0.7399907112,
-0.0043996978,
-0.4732037783,
0.3724543154,
-0.5978028774,
-0.9386341572,
0.2836295068,
-0.1085441262,
-0.3041312695,
0.4016556144,
0.141510576,
0.215435192,
0.7025356293,
0.9314302802,
-0.0308099501,
0.7481352687,
-0.0306011327,
0.4062134027,
-0.9145011902,
-0.3892116547,
-0.51445508,
-0.0507010929,
-0.6135718226,
-0.3496136665,
-0.1144507825,
0.220553726,
0.0318998545,
0.7084840536,
-0.6072054505,
0.3294666409,
0.4696160257,
-0.0473485515,
0.3516063392,
-0.1035538986,
-0.1982356459,
0.0396655276,
-0.3829910457,
-0.5815085769,
0.6794700027,
0.0554095283,
0.597237885,
0.0753962323,
1.0460425615,
-0.0112000601,
0.4606562555,
-0.8536776304,
0.7902579904,
-0.4444905818,
-0.6611784101,
0.0597525723,
-0.5037738085,
-0.7311679125,
0.0023162742,
-0.2367156595,
-0.6033550501,
0.456112057,
0.2795523703,
-0.1780254096,
0.2971057296,
-0.4845578671,
0.6993215084,
-0.3477673531,
0.3317857087,
0.0441034436,
-0.2673622072,
0.2350509167,
0.0870551914,
-0.0231406968,
-0.0735572428,
0.1640092432,
0.6995494366,
0.0045067309,
0.563809216,
-0.244136557,
-0.0427348502,
0.2177577466,
0.0804638192,
0.5642027259,
-0.0012927678,
-0.1014314666,
-0.147066623,
-0.5554521084,
0.0421559513,
-0.5572938919,
0.3391522765,
-0.1614293307,
-0.5073185563,
-0.2151544988,
-0.3251346648,
0.0538032353,
0.6217924356,
0.4205450416,
0.6452612877,
-0.3760393262,
-0.0306192487,
0.7428770065,
0.007061345,
0.3733707368,
0.4910247922,
-0.3028968275,
-0.49237445,
1.0947464705,
-0.0921578109,
0.1691140682,
0.9956121445,
-0.2946012318,
-0.2432069927,
-0.7762542367,
-0.3395062089,
0.1371522844,
-0.5686720014,
-0.4468798637,
-1.0157123804,
-0.2870620787,
-0.2382473201,
0.0271042418,
-0.2651059031,
-0.2954703271,
-0.5238879323,
0.1332450509,
0.3357277513,
0.551187396,
0.3597101867,
0.2454699725,
-0.5371038914,
0.5831556916,
0.474304378,
0.4875707328,
-0.0849787667,
-0.3572554588,
0.1482626498,
-0.1124666855,
-0.0281326976,
-1.0236938,
0.4801103473,
0.1805084646,
0.4465523362,
0.6526067257,
-0.0747027695,
0.637092948,
-0.6744098067,
0.1100051254,
0.1582986861,
-0.8315989375,
0.5460381508,
-0.061936859,
-0.1371039897,
0.5697296858,
0.0957882702,
-0.5156773329,
-0.3012969196,
-0.5250778794,
-0.9149599075,
0.5305700898,
0.0970212445,
0.0521095619,
-0.216145277,
0.4087373316,
-0.1347998977,
0.251912266,
-1.0663323402,
-0.25111413,
-0.2360203713,
-0.2988093197,
0.0835297927,
-0.4112399518,
0.2947116792,
0.26140064,
0.6138197184,
-0.0551571324,
0.4425285161,
0.1455751657,
-0.3959452212,
0.3153585792,
0.7081070542,
0.3055874705,
-0.1953511983,
-0.2016873211,
0.155896157,
-0.0160208531,
-0.2684194148,
0.1472581625,
0.6706216931,
-0.6041947007,
0.1663565338,
0.0635683239,
0.904517889,
0.278480351,
-0.4640254974,
0.073689051,
-0.0161234383,
0.3636505008,
-0.4182216525,
0.307089299,
0.2829708457,
0.2246341705,
0.145783022,
0.3288810551,
0.4214054048,
-0.3652926683,
0.0716193467,
0.5881067514,
-0.6252006292,
-0.158008799,
0.702994287,
0.1451332569,
-0.725925982,
0.5991087556,
-0.6985960603,
-0.7881709933,
0.9174298644,
1.0121023655,
0.9450420737,
-0.1963555068,
0.1676869839,
0.4931836128,
0.052171208,
-0.2453139424,
0.3029170334,
0.0842413902,
-1.0889571905,
-0.1714867949,
-0.7401079535,
-0.2535260916,
0.0417769365,
-0.891707778,
0.4091259241,
-0.3159488142,
-0.2751201093,
0.3831808269,
-0.2923656404,
-0.6380349994,
0.2478963882,
0.2775064707,
0.8546916842,
-0.4949111938,
0.6824811697,
1.0505604744,
-0.6796800494,
-0.8012725115,
0.1690839231,
-0.2508353293,
-0.5658290982,
0.8651915789,
0.5700985193,
-0.0462434739,
0.5245495439,
0.0295902696,
-1.0739831924,
0.9378200769,
0.3125080764,
-0.6863803864,
-0.3338562548,
0.003412772,
0.4382329881,
-0.7021110654,
0.1046879739,
0.1745833308,
0.3593558371,
0.0133350194,
-0.5180678964,
0.306941539,
-0.3268953264,
0.380150944,
0.4667561352,
-0.340857327,
0.7728919983,
-0.420976907,
-0.6693289876,
0.179769516,
0.8407763243,
0.2455878556,
0.1232426837,
0.7100066543,
0.7970132232,
0.6721589565,
-0.0582927093,
0.8809607029,
-0.2768463492,
0.3913185298,
1.2879732847,
-0.4030238688,
0.7491388917,
0.1360966414,
-0.0769185349,
0.7018822432,
0.2404947877,
-0.4807466269,
0.6204809546,
0.3061272204,
-0.562579751,
-0.038043011,
-0.343273133,
-0.2364686131,
0.5534527302,
0.3768401444,
-0.372126013,
-0.2299111485,
0.0014047802,
0.0140622612,
-0.0242435988,
-0.4417863488,
1.0372512341,
-0.0406684503,
-0.7255431414,
0.1017518267,
0.2501055002,
0.8431728482,
-0.2104537934,
-0.1326065361,
-0.0143467737,
0.0904061347,
-0.0802734643,
-0.3492447138,
0.1663665473,
0.0737865716,
-0.5085732341,
-0.0584250055,
1.0943133831,
-0.7128279209,
-0.6809442639,
0.2901931107,
0.185733676,
-0.143298611,
-0.2223323733,
-0.4267078936,
-0.5111276507,
-0.1750710309,
0.1799025536,
0.2054602504,
0.5918735862,
0.179996103,
0.7164951563,
0.5067952275,
0.1552904397,
0.0205475986,
0.2957431972,
0.722091794,
-0.9217181802,
-0.5297182798,
-0.7330203652,
0.2109802365,
-0.1436694711,
-0.1398872435,
0.4028306305,
0.7037632465,
0.677556932,
-0.1429370493,
0.5731805563,
-0.3577685356,
0.4332253933,
-0.5658154488,
0.5188776255,
-0.2457292378,
0.0026241629,
-0.2614277899,
-0.9228568077,
-0.1906455755,
0.4113974273,
-0.0941910893,
0.1156794578,
0.5295336246,
0.6937817931,
-0.0750351027,
-0.0582153276,
-0.0202170741,
0.1217968985,
0.2071734816,
0.3210739493,
0.7817193866,
-0.1342969388,
0.6097739935,
-0.2559548318,
0.026944533,
-0.4071815908,
-0.9367622733,
-0.740447998,
-0.4845187664,
-0.3586445153,
-0.2336992919,
0.0746466592,
0.6818624139,
0.4360097349,
-1.0060973167,
0.2008995712,
-0.6121764183,
0.108090274,
-0.1737723947,
-0.3124970794,
0.1454455256,
-0.3224119842,
-0.674036622,
0.1454827189,
0.3003700078,
0.3858571649,
0.2033379376,
0.3014289737,
-0.0112368884,
-0.1009768546,
0.4134479165,
0.3654708862,
-0.8023263812,
-0.1004715338,
0.0487788767,
-0.1999312937,
0.0472565554,
1.1081310511,
-0.7452347875,
0.4196615517,
0.2412019372,
0.7849143744,
0.3789429069,
-0.0914636925,
0.4686897695,
-0.4291104972,
-0.1904955208,
0.4167250991,
0.6592896581,
0.6356489062,
-0.4742462039,
0.25474298,
0.0218275432,
-0.294001013,
-0.6423184872,
0.3940077424,
-1.0412032604,
0.2011144906,
1.2126235962,
-0.1659779102,
0.2666962743,
-0.2119783908,
-0.1435869187,
0.5543605685,
-0.4033319056,
0.683203578,
0.5416343212,
0.0072268685,
-0.2269916683,
-0.2842055559,
0.3562166691,
0.2210184336,
-0.8745003343,
-0.1220558882,
0.3949401975,
0.456040889,
0.3243950307,
0.7098347545,
-0.1045010909,
0.0370462351,
-0.0410742015,
0.3623504937,
-0.0390491225,
-0.2259963155,
-0.3432447314,
0.2195419669,
0.210361436,
-0.0985783637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09138v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09138v1
|
From Bytes to Borsch: Fine-Tuning Gemma and Mistral for the Ukrainian Language Representation
| 2024-04-14T04:25:41 | 2024-04-14T04:25:41 |
Artur Kiulian, Anton Polishko, Mykola Khandoga, Oryna Chubych, Jack Connor, Raghav Ravishankar, Adarsh Shirawalmath
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the rapidly advancing field of AI and NLP, generative large language
models (LLMs) stand at the forefront of innovation, showcasing unparalleled
abilities in text understanding and generation. However, the limited
representation of low-resource languages like Ukrainian poses a notable
challenge, restricting the reach and relevance of this technology. Our paper
addresses this by fine-tuning the open-source Gemma and Mistral LLMs with
Ukrainian datasets, aiming to improve their linguistic proficiency and
benchmarking them against other existing models capable of processing Ukrainian
language. This endeavor not only aims to mitigate language bias in technology
but also promotes inclusivity in the digital realm. Our transparent and
reproducible approach encourages further NLP research and development.
Additionally, we present the Ukrainian Knowledge and Instruction Dataset (UKID)
to aid future efforts in language model fine-tuning. Our research not only
advances the field of NLP but also highlights the importance of linguistic
diversity in AI, which is crucial for cultural preservation, education, and
expanding AI's global utility. Ultimately, we advocate for a future where
technology is inclusive, enabling AI to communicate effectively across all
languages, especially those currently underrepresented.
|
[
-0.3366837204,
-0.3636466563,
0.1482647657,
0.0333893858,
-0.3330450654,
0.2751224339,
-0.372592926,
-0.5860275626,
0.1145517826,
0.4465254843,
-0.3232308626,
-0.7539241314,
-0.7227844596,
0.1883992851,
-0.2501314878,
0.7945626378,
0.1474204957,
0.4807439446,
-0.14784877,
-0.3179826736,
-0.6406434178,
-0.3682914078,
-0.5468565822,
-0.4267090559,
0.0998805091,
0.618719697,
0.8085753918,
0.7222954631,
0.4614681005,
0.3049995303,
-0.1338566542,
0.2831435502,
-0.528136909,
0.196641624,
-0.5166910887,
-0.8267732859,
-0.2250835001,
-0.4029843807,
0.6676210165,
0.7271447778,
-0.2782736123,
0.2045805156,
0.214450255,
0.86712116,
-0.4157341719,
0.1367649436,
-1.0121006966,
0.2543935776,
-0.322650224,
-0.228768453,
-0.4060174525,
-0.2351809293,
-0.2909873426,
-0.5235589147,
0.2816877961,
0.0247105602,
0.8667144775,
0.1781195402,
0.0124260606,
-0.2700696588,
-0.8056592345,
0.8491687775,
-0.540305078,
0.650452435,
0.4404347241,
0.1162751317,
-0.3356527388,
-0.7742546201,
-0.1611479223,
-0.1151739955,
0.3220214248,
0.0718473643,
-0.5873020887,
0.034467414,
0.0084009953,
0.3939189315,
-0.3384080827,
0.3906724453,
-0.5857618451,
-0.4924250841,
0.4263983369,
0.3396993279,
0.1659641117,
0.316208899,
0.0910496861,
-0.0356498733,
-0.7659093142,
0.0224517845,
0.437933594,
0.5506057143,
-0.2639262378,
0.8013682961,
-0.3559937477,
0.6999379396,
0.389221251,
0.1367795765,
0.1188247353,
-0.3708749712,
-0.1791498512,
0.0810410902,
0.7502034307,
0.1263153404,
0.3605687618,
-0.4586660862,
0.0361771733,
0.1147795394,
0.3399993181,
-0.9567484856,
-0.1240290105,
0.2692156434,
-0.3612818122,
-0.1015390605,
0.1126620397,
-0.9762865901,
-0.4999485314,
-0.299783349,
0.1909397542,
-0.4566918314,
-0.0759927705,
0.5409597754,
0.0563083477,
-0.0432040468,
0.205608353,
-1.3904223442,
0.3422402143,
0.6707669497,
0.8782747984,
0.2649260461,
-0.1489081532,
-0.5771078467,
0.0813385323,
-0.7426453829,
0.6269035339,
-0.6700864434,
-0.5685893297,
0.1518739611,
-0.1551960409,
0.5968977213,
-0.8902432323,
0.2691397369,
-0.365372926,
-0.2050593197,
-0.1356069744,
-0.3820863068,
0.1171136349,
-0.0188887734,
-0.6365123391,
1.0957965851,
0.0745322332,
-0.77681458,
0.4445100129,
-0.3436040282,
-0.2594523728,
0.21644862,
-0.2106946409,
-0.1394760311,
0.4722492397,
0.0664098263,
0.6103476882,
-0.2938627601,
0.3018052578,
-0.2644924819,
-0.1162274405,
0.1302236021,
-0.3969060481,
0.5943358541,
0.0893651396,
-0.2771932781,
0.1966671646,
-0.9515464306,
0.1059164628,
-0.305793792,
-0.4779264033,
-0.1030801907,
0.0871684104,
0.054315336,
0.1194863617,
0.5387402773,
-0.6092736721,
0.1962264925,
-0.6523227692,
0.6371257901,
0.5499776602,
-0.6613459587,
0.7531417608,
-0.254142791,
0.6549845338,
0.1750013679,
0.1223779097,
-0.0923046097,
-0.4670230746,
-0.7187330127,
-0.226019159,
0.4879141152,
0.3171803653,
-0.6629877687,
0.6182118654,
-0.4657769203,
-0.6922069788,
-1.3993479013,
0.2346146703,
0.1758441776,
0.1988567412,
0.4854530394,
-0.3160972595,
-0.660420835,
-0.9872024655,
-0.0231950227,
-0.2034577578,
-0.0360570997,
0.1295043081,
0.1894904077,
-0.261718899,
1.0982781649,
0.0715299696,
-0.4231278896,
-0.2924391031,
0.0848584771,
-0.0126074217,
0.5002325773,
0.2834649086,
-0.5419074297,
-0.3700379431,
0.4536814988,
-0.3800373077,
-0.1809496135,
0.300059557,
0.0133619709,
0.4610458016,
0.6967431307,
-0.5460894108,
0.3985483944,
0.7855067849,
-0.4817455709,
0.5427808762,
-0.3594258726,
0.1480533034,
-1.3089033365,
0.054096017,
-0.223599866,
-0.346675247,
-0.4909815192,
0.2109486461,
0.0503250919,
-0.1915479898,
-0.3064564168,
0.6486120224,
-0.4361749887,
-0.1540413648,
-0.1078284085,
0.1485991478,
-0.0443786569,
-0.0980378613,
-0.0849000216,
1.0246257782,
0.7903501987,
-0.3401423395,
0.1597235501,
0.1654779166,
-0.6189010143,
0.2752795815,
-0.6140684485,
-0.0608681366,
-0.0811034665,
-0.1117452383,
-0.7536364198,
-0.0969860107,
0.1065203175,
-0.6041251421,
0.4114588797,
-0.2813311815,
-0.7207032442,
0.143180728,
-0.2109873742,
0.3812763393,
0.5758208632,
-0.4642144144,
0.5978801847,
0.4483763874,
-0.1627280712,
-0.7501762509,
-0.9222955108,
0.2734076083,
-0.1180308834,
-0.6973303556,
0.5907945633,
-0.0918459743,
-0.3966781795,
-0.0941644385,
-0.0107766539,
-0.0975737572,
-0.0393195115,
0.1992160082,
-0.1793382168,
-0.5048695803,
0.159801811,
0.0726383924,
-0.1908932328,
-0.2661475837,
-0.4565174878,
0.9807148576,
-0.2173689157,
-0.1946388334,
-0.4429598153,
0.3079114556,
0.5868406296,
-0.5217909217,
0.8200472593,
0.8289871216,
-0.2693922818,
-0.4065141678,
-0.4553621709,
-0.0555604436,
-0.4964313507,
0.5609727502,
-0.3300097883,
-1.2953858376,
0.8277184963,
-0.0171995703,
-0.0225845017,
0.2325785011,
0.7075391412,
0.101008743,
0.8019754291,
0.9343867898,
-0.4636872411,
0.4899875224,
-0.2192448676,
0.0823258534,
-0.6164531708,
-0.1830669343,
-0.9449786544,
-0.2566072345,
-0.6561367512,
-0.4278063178,
0.0579565056,
0.5154095292,
0.1234671175,
0.1347117275,
-0.4471462667,
0.3769902587,
0.4475801289,
0.0540082902,
0.2645825446,
0.1868515015,
-0.3238143623,
-0.1964399666,
-0.8071192503,
-0.6688699126,
1.0707056522,
0.2845976651,
0.8451502919,
0.0325122774,
0.6263768673,
0.1590503156,
-0.0158606824,
-0.8461565971,
0.5175926089,
-0.4084727466,
-0.5070740581,
-0.3475171328,
-0.2708684504,
-1.1948111057,
0.0895391479,
-0.3776002526,
-0.907487154,
0.1876553893,
0.2599137425,
-0.1551258713,
0.4382510185,
-0.465655148,
0.6884035468,
0.3221735954,
-0.6430720687,
-0.6342412829,
-0.2522659004,
0.0088350764,
0.0551730469,
0.2209653407,
-0.0280493814,
-0.1104405597,
0.4388688207,
-0.3272469342,
0.9641283154,
0.0598687455,
-0.2907989919,
0.2304909676,
0.2423970401,
0.1731316298,
0.0517295711,
-0.3593118787,
0.5802307129,
0.0234813783,
-0.4445294142,
-0.2865971625,
0.5499702692,
-0.7494540811,
-0.4609180093,
-0.0643675253,
-0.5535213947,
-0.098702848,
0.0744415522,
0.3417068124,
0.710855484,
-0.2782498002,
0.427374959,
0.6374880672,
-0.2024751455,
0.3189496398,
0.5822982788,
-0.3683774471,
-0.4242388904,
0.7536005974,
0.1255185157,
0.1900176555,
0.5746720433,
0.0602954626,
-0.0956289545,
-1.0717881918,
-0.4972422719,
0.1226486489,
-0.7330544591,
-0.3145172298,
-0.3423814774,
-0.0512401238,
-0.2642316818,
-0.2100557387,
-0.4370669425,
-0.2148218155,
-0.698874712,
-0.0488311127,
0.4496522546,
0.9150828123,
-0.2207408398,
0.4385362864,
-0.9328490496,
0.1979397386,
-0.0754156485,
0.6226232648,
0.0019495324,
-0.6991084814,
-0.6609091759,
0.0972142667,
-0.3575489223,
-0.5857089758,
0.3161115944,
0.1167294607,
0.3164891601,
0.2415347397,
-0.3713700473,
0.8252356052,
-0.7651790977,
0.720969975,
0.0468763262,
-1.0431360006,
0.328907311,
-0.4141641259,
0.406129092,
0.6603187919,
0.2400161624,
-0.5577173829,
-0.5116157532,
-0.4734086096,
-0.6917658448,
0.7063878179,
0.0516250953,
0.3298617303,
-0.0353216007,
0.3253677189,
0.400043726,
0.1375805289,
-0.5872637033,
0.0008630517,
-0.0197285824,
-0.6541701555,
-0.0217394624,
-0.212490499,
0.265689373,
-0.2208262533,
0.6819555163,
-0.1036140248,
0.0884375945,
0.1044988781,
-0.0983367413,
-0.3016963303,
0.3382730782,
0.5725727677,
0.7554507256,
0.137452215,
-0.0095432959,
0.1040856987,
-0.8378184438,
-0.0346797779,
-0.0424137264,
-0.1737335771,
0.1099300608,
0.3986253142,
0.6259790063,
0.0706633925,
-0.7745423913,
0.155477047,
0.0115688797,
-0.0715937614,
-0.1425840259,
0.1681876183,
0.2588760257,
0.3568111658,
0.2828738689,
0.3192135096,
-0.0982555076,
-0.634793222,
0.1501824856,
0.6799958944,
-0.494594574,
-0.6054823399,
0.5062986612,
0.1919424534,
-0.6315863729,
0.2376615852,
-0.1414815187,
-0.0996398106,
0.51120013,
0.555280447,
0.6173321605,
-0.4400339425,
0.3200997114,
0.3408536911,
0.5048918724,
-0.2582043111,
0.5029757619,
0.0433828384,
-1.0067574978,
-0.2256499082,
-0.7564378381,
-0.1018921137,
0.3375452757,
-0.7360229492,
0.6105567217,
-0.6787313819,
-0.2956229746,
0.0207921471,
0.0135551579,
-0.6184206009,
0.0685793236,
-0.0050366605,
1.0824984312,
-0.5908184052,
0.8616662621,
0.6980614066,
-0.1826798171,
-0.3670276105,
-0.1156276241,
-0.3824625313,
-0.7590609193,
0.6664823294,
0.0577224456,
-0.2110163271,
0.3212638199,
-0.5631175637,
-0.8317593336,
0.8982557654,
0.7507526278,
-0.9229947329,
0.1722100228,
0.3553025424,
0.7858717442,
-0.2516223192,
0.0976280943,
0.4669588506,
0.2827431262,
-0.4457605183,
-0.9669175744,
-0.4167748988,
-0.1322576702,
-0.1418181062,
0.4186028242,
-0.5626834631,
0.5008990765,
-0.0733908117,
-0.3833996952,
0.3056851029,
0.7501617074,
0.2017785758,
-0.0053762575,
-0.0679640844,
0.5722293258,
0.7136957049,
-0.0608728491,
0.7812593579,
-0.4417486787,
-0.0518337861,
0.8248180151,
0.0181955695,
1.0226305723,
0.4951514304,
-0.331302762,
0.3281573653,
0.4302996993,
-0.0464788228,
0.4630517364,
0.3399426043,
-0.2968731821,
-0.1516126841,
-0.2941640317,
-0.0937907323,
0.5656228662,
0.6022494435,
-0.0955453739,
-0.3099265397,
0.0344875902,
-0.0195168629,
0.4195149839,
-0.615139544,
0.8348973393,
-0.0138825756,
-0.326017499,
0.5670404434,
0.3297241628,
0.8605312109,
-0.7133401632,
-0.0561322048,
-0.3409618139,
0.013240831,
-0.2970117927,
-0.6985364556,
0.2997473776,
0.1396760195,
-0.4139335752,
0.0105762724,
0.6750586629,
-0.73370713,
-0.557765007,
0.5244682431,
0.2453505993,
0.2377661616,
0.2769358456,
-0.5121663213,
0.233107999,
0.0969448313,
0.274523437,
0.2446681261,
0.8549537659,
-0.0615211762,
0.8685714006,
0.2687591314,
0.5780491829,
0.2829889357,
0.0560549945,
0.665368855,
-0.4729308486,
-0.4241896272,
-1.0399996042,
0.6909763217,
0.3196751475,
-0.5555422306,
0.4422614276,
0.70803684,
1.0594812632,
-0.0982386693,
0.7908543348,
0.1072379276,
0.1873849183,
-0.8259270191,
0.813514173,
-0.4551242292,
0.0071516442,
0.1612429917,
-0.6990929842,
-0.2004252672,
0.4744520187,
0.0807211399,
-0.0034455638,
0.4748483598,
0.9562618136,
-0.2821816206,
-0.1238783374,
0.6041476727,
0.4405704737,
0.1129450798,
0.1734583527,
0.6778164506,
-0.3230200708,
0.4864593446,
-0.050365746,
-0.0358358398,
-0.1653975695,
-0.798304379,
-1.0333852768,
-0.8539911509,
-0.0615081117,
-0.1617102325,
0.1007476225,
0.9341047406,
0.6646972895,
-0.9003006816,
-0.3979091346,
-0.2600989044,
-0.2083493769,
0.1217460781,
-0.1407342106,
0.1197099388,
-0.6216102242,
-0.742875874,
0.4397200346,
0.5541692972,
0.1981281489,
-0.5001645684,
0.0700183585,
0.228570044,
-0.0112108123,
0.5350502133,
0.050798554,
-0.8795140982,
-0.252928108,
-0.0224443506,
-0.0287962053,
0.3607165515,
0.6632256508,
-0.8497407436,
0.5430757999,
0.4250178933,
0.8127825856,
0.2912371457,
-0.2058926225,
0.7148654461,
-0.7629969716,
0.3214550316,
0.2670128047,
0.4663090408,
0.6370561123,
-0.2244738489,
0.2013716549,
-0.1473549902,
-0.3803601265,
-0.7931305766,
0.4121514857,
-0.8435355425,
-0.2607618868,
1.0093637705,
0.0039706696,
-0.0103415754,
-0.3871189058,
-0.3054324687,
0.3485057056,
-0.4108181596,
1.1544553041,
1.0715378523,
0.5120255947,
-0.064881593,
-0.6471523046,
0.6898387074,
0.5847767591,
-0.8107824326,
0.4596298933,
0.3227942288,
0.0589883141,
0.2111192346,
0.5399761796,
-0.2437327504,
0.0972953513,
-0.0081467628,
0.4159270823,
-0.0639101118,
-0.4993783236,
-0.7509604096,
-0.0613770001,
0.30856058,
0.0447242595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09136v1
|
TLDR at SemEval-2024 Task 2: T5-generated clinical-Language summaries for DeBERTa Report Analysis
| 2024-04-14T04:14:30 | 2024-04-14T04:14:30 |
Spandan Das, Vinay Samuel, Shahriar Noroozizadeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces novel methodologies for the Natural Language Inference
for Clinical Trials (NLI4CT) task. We present TLDR (T5-generated
clinical-Language summaries for DeBERTa Report Analysis) which incorporates
T5-model generated premise summaries for improved entailment and contradiction
analysis in clinical NLI tasks. This approach overcomes the challenges posed by
small context windows and lengthy premises, leading to a substantial
improvement in Macro F1 scores: a 0.184 increase over truncated premises. Our
comprehensive experimental evaluation, including detailed error analysis and
ablations, confirms the superiority of TLDR in achieving consistency and
faithfulness in predictions against semantically altered inputs.
|
[
0.1058415174,
-0.7468665242,
0.7283246517,
0.5068286061,
-0.2021135241,
-0.2267026007,
0.059405148,
-0.4755741954,
0.247290805,
0.6327358484,
-0.4749799967,
-0.6432495713,
-0.6577744484,
0.4548048377,
-0.2043789178,
0.9219055176,
-0.1767399162,
0.144075051,
-0.0382155105,
-0.2576843798,
-0.6767309308,
-0.3266477585,
-0.3230760694,
-0.2768241465,
0.5940843821,
0.3853710592,
0.4425911605,
0.2294385135,
0.776655972,
0.1973711699,
-0.0254017338,
0.0516298637,
-0.377504319,
-0.0289320424,
-0.0997822732,
-0.4465965033,
-0.7719358802,
-0.0147959394,
0.308350414,
0.8291290402,
-0.1486848742,
-0.0253300481,
-0.0482312702,
0.5134478211,
-0.6425187588,
0.0695236698,
-0.4502248466,
0.2195669711,
-0.0478264764,
-0.4311028719,
-0.6869685054,
-0.5795717239,
0.376311332,
-0.5533720255,
0.4058287442,
-0.0716736615,
0.9037383795,
0.5133137703,
-0.7032930255,
-0.5333672166,
-0.6101516485,
0.920013845,
-1.2873188257,
0.1134850159,
0.1530785412,
0.314248085,
-0.1612178683,
-1.0257776976,
-0.4318242073,
-0.0997565836,
-0.3941013813,
0.2460167855,
-0.3927719891,
0.2535186112,
0.3473920226,
-0.0313449502,
-0.6795928478,
-0.0608789697,
-0.6281371713,
-0.1091693193,
0.7695601583,
0.374985218,
0.4244686365,
-0.0750613734,
-0.1365522146,
0.2796429098,
-0.9621238708,
-0.1943918616,
-0.2491954714,
0.1466506422,
-0.0492103882,
0.6831201911,
-0.1497659087,
0.6830353141,
0.0201727245,
-0.2112729549,
0.5738091469,
-0.6281687617,
-0.5229761004,
0.375492841,
0.7438338399,
0.8365601897,
0.0010532503,
-0.3672155142,
-0.0199087877,
0.1287257373,
0.1791956276,
-0.9791176915,
-0.1424880028,
0.6446291208,
-0.3496074677,
-0.5893087387,
-0.2273791134,
-0.7780881524,
-0.1888616234,
-0.1726391166,
0.6063729525,
-0.5412179828,
-0.0212641805,
0.1847414672,
-0.433521837,
0.3226658702,
0.5242676735,
-0.5618963242,
0.3944180608,
0.3700477183,
0.4764891863,
-0.2130452394,
-0.2023957074,
-0.8305414915,
0.3047587574,
-0.309767127,
0.6919185519,
-0.3737033606,
-0.4170063734,
-0.0663517267,
0.1199800149,
-0.3379961252,
-0.5917916894,
0.7581728101,
-0.3763252497,
0.5370704532,
-0.372012496,
-0.6832774282,
-0.2037445605,
0.2716586888,
-0.5866166353,
0.6762708426,
0.0163923111,
-0.8971464634,
0.4404622614,
-0.7228264809,
-0.6442776918,
-0.0597170219,
-0.1274930984,
-0.4351512492,
0.094802767,
0.2381041497,
0.1155767366,
-0.1654915214,
0.6089678407,
-0.267971009,
-0.0778106898,
0.205475986,
-0.1891290694,
0.8368685246,
0.2062515765,
-0.8118839264,
0.0337995216,
-0.5755280852,
0.0690800548,
-0.0525269769,
-0.0231244601,
-0.1661319435,
-0.0204676054,
0.0502619259,
0.1318719834,
0.219214499,
-0.7419217229,
-0.1992958486,
-0.8016835451,
0.4121383429,
0.1602352411,
0.3150541484,
0.2960461974,
-0.2126150578,
0.4828930199,
0.0544235595,
0.0712757036,
0.035339307,
-0.4919545054,
-0.6914703846,
-0.0673447177,
0.5164333582,
0.5405883789,
-0.6554614902,
0.2694900632,
-0.3236208856,
-0.3021775484,
-0.3522176445,
-0.3624323905,
0.5263392329,
0.6965470314,
0.478302896,
0.1219628081,
-0.8838037252,
-1.0458371639,
-0.2383578122,
0.0801573023,
-0.0613951422,
0.0229171123,
0.8780480027,
-0.2963489294,
1.0416539907,
-0.5590811968,
-0.5168352723,
-0.5798044205,
0.4246637821,
0.1973959059,
0.3643709719,
0.6760491729,
-0.6944714189,
-0.3706794977,
-0.2445806116,
-0.9206519723,
-0.4759002924,
-0.0635926798,
0.0960561708,
0.4332325757,
0.4008777142,
-0.378336221,
0.8185119629,
0.228091374,
-0.508289516,
0.2595996857,
-0.26734671,
0.3238407969,
-1.0709882975,
0.1918880641,
-0.2662910521,
-0.3378256261,
-0.7998870611,
-0.1518214345,
0.0280432235,
0.2568701506,
-0.291069299,
0.4207283556,
-0.1838898659,
0.0748880282,
-0.192584306,
0.2077215612,
0.263643533,
0.2324078828,
0.0207283963,
0.698392272,
-0.0087319547,
-0.4704351127,
-0.1402692944,
0.4732259512,
0.1519584507,
-0.0250003859,
-1.2360095978,
-0.1670276672,
-0.1379230917,
0.2725851834,
-1.1125841141,
-0.4227555096,
-0.0369373672,
-0.5306195021,
0.1497530192,
0.3481283486,
-0.2565875649,
-0.1868253648,
-0.4455193281,
0.2233631909,
0.5728136301,
-0.1807964593,
0.7605344653,
0.4056472778,
-0.1676963419,
-0.4604500234,
-0.9726356268,
0.188271746,
-0.260646522,
-0.4712258875,
0.5394173861,
0.1064510867,
-0.4976628125,
0.1495774537,
0.1393632889,
-0.2159636915,
-0.033500433,
0.0504801348,
0.1675706357,
-0.3432865143,
-0.0956970826,
0.2239357084,
0.1367751062,
0.3431052864,
0.2622994184,
0.1184483096,
-0.0796659514,
-0.2281699777,
-0.3667600453,
0.4109399021,
0.439293623,
-0.1986857653,
0.5130797029,
0.2503790557,
-0.4279493392,
-0.0591680855,
-0.4250288308,
-0.0199977849,
-0.3875604868,
0.0467768312,
-0.2927756011,
-0.8424220681,
0.2813540995,
0.1695303768,
0.2328249812,
0.7418022156,
0.6417826414,
-0.0796139911,
0.9269240499,
0.3257865608,
0.4006887078,
-0.0846062675,
-0.1855558008,
0.3489618897,
-0.6926167011,
-0.1515798718,
-0.3536117375,
-0.0119091813,
-0.3887856603,
-0.4834629595,
0.796633184,
-0.1391245574,
-0.1101829559,
0.2080670893,
-0.2624004483,
0.3562501967,
0.250402838,
0.0991334617,
0.3528613746,
-0.1723772287,
-0.0661597252,
-0.4455244839,
-0.5220489502,
-0.574350059,
1.213866353,
0.2468633801,
0.2977523804,
0.5648344159,
0.7558178902,
0.3900665939,
0.4185688496,
-0.4979331791,
0.3745267987,
-0.1462259293,
-0.6394988894,
-0.1871297061,
-0.0821455717,
-0.8863511086,
0.289814204,
0.0699153319,
-0.6730604768,
0.021607168,
0.0235997308,
-0.5356886387,
-0.3126802146,
-0.7811408043,
0.9701660275,
-0.0382886529,
-0.2978478372,
-0.1533951312,
-0.9934833646,
0.482654959,
-0.0801528096,
0.0146536576,
-0.0628247485,
-0.0552051105,
0.5919840932,
-0.6698048115,
1.0349723101,
-0.2956338525,
-0.1907445639,
0.3288734257,
-0.0267627835,
0.4970602691,
0.1242591441,
-0.3329702318,
-0.2327076942,
0.2499280125,
-0.3476445973,
-0.7033939362,
0.3173662722,
-0.429128319,
-0.435021162,
-0.5892820954,
-0.3792055249,
-0.2141635269,
0.2996386588,
0.3763895333,
0.9323673248,
-0.6527614594,
0.0732344612,
0.5633996129,
-0.436755091,
0.2647835314,
0.6428871155,
0.1057485864,
-0.4797676504,
0.4992082417,
-0.1957222074,
0.3178938925,
0.6050270796,
0.1690376252,
-0.5475557446,
-0.7445058227,
-0.2387313396,
0.2926523685,
-0.695823431,
-0.1166535541,
-0.8658897877,
-0.1875180304,
-0.7450919151,
-0.1039649323,
-0.0989974365,
-0.6325777173,
-0.3228325546,
-0.1352300346,
0.1021870375,
0.8065469265,
0.1650101542,
0.1442777812,
-0.8502836227,
0.261531055,
-0.2049438059,
-0.325737983,
-0.2947536409,
-0.6900972724,
0.1256174892,
0.0112403575,
-0.4809117019,
-0.7261564136,
0.6826733351,
0.4144111276,
0.3910802603,
0.2249355614,
0.2864686847,
0.8157145381,
-0.8776451945,
0.8155130148,
0.2223623246,
-0.8991544247,
0.8939198256,
-0.3986180127,
0.2073243409,
0.6350311637,
0.1400111169,
-0.1345753074,
-0.7072288394,
-0.7669392824,
-0.8371937275,
0.5859979987,
0.6226498485,
-0.2631747425,
0.0007201695,
0.0570525117,
0.1740129441,
0.1639020145,
-0.4599345326,
0.0305388458,
-0.0548537858,
-0.6444534659,
-0.0273241363,
-0.4762606323,
-0.4066250026,
-0.2602384388,
0.5292641521,
-0.282920748,
0.2980079353,
0.6694169044,
-0.1859035641,
0.1226363182,
0.4828481376,
0.9517509937,
1.1276725531,
-0.5260184407,
0.157139942,
0.6444974542,
-0.2326971292,
-0.0648479164,
0.1150519624,
-0.1269995868,
0.2662026882,
0.9194626808,
0.8304120302,
0.2408944219,
-0.9351143837,
0.8286391497,
-0.2224478275,
-0.5691355467,
-0.7896261215,
-0.0343114063,
0.0000642587,
0.1549115032,
0.0651146546,
-0.1133978739,
0.7240876555,
-0.2877393067,
0.4802590013,
0.0631389618,
-0.3825102746,
-0.5400054455,
0.9522055387,
0.2483659685,
0.2847214639,
0.271966517,
-0.1535050422,
-0.3642990887,
0.7631106973,
0.6944792271,
0.8549242616,
0.0986838117,
0.2028903812,
0.6041964889,
0.2014251351,
0.1024242565,
0.5620334148,
0.4310469627,
-0.6157096028,
-0.5235099792,
-0.438649416,
-0.4177161753,
0.0802362487,
-0.5726807117,
0.2007030398,
-0.146260947,
0.1594833881,
0.311376214,
-0.2588426471,
-0.2275636941,
0.3749680519,
0.0115484521,
0.852119863,
-0.6322595477,
0.7793516517,
0.5229255557,
-0.476506412,
-0.9183788896,
0.0424105339,
0.1118563488,
-0.4098449945,
0.9765746593,
0.1115121692,
-0.2388332933,
-0.2052690387,
-0.4452341497,
-0.6622237563,
1.3196284771,
0.1737861484,
-0.2787993252,
-0.231884554,
0.3987217546,
0.7708364725,
-0.5008863211,
0.4575586021,
0.8165367246,
0.3282842934,
0.3638114333,
-0.952835083,
0.3463588655,
-0.103291072,
-0.0958140641,
0.0575817898,
-0.3240710199,
0.5417762399,
-0.4824618399,
-0.0753005072,
0.2493726313,
0.6193080544,
0.3836715817,
0.650595665,
0.3492203951,
0.5473626852,
0.6973015666,
-0.0962158889,
1.0260543823,
-0.0654750094,
0.3904167414,
1.2535401583,
-0.7308419943,
0.7071568966,
0.6087503433,
-0.1326087415,
0.4186706543,
0.4581089914,
0.1262397617,
0.7796921134,
-0.0773679242,
-0.2691531181,
0.0087840343,
-0.2039712369,
-0.2101895362,
0.3218332827,
0.4407349527,
-0.3638135195,
-0.4480881393,
-0.0717997104,
0.1330950409,
-0.1145919859,
0.2105626315,
0.8281676769,
0.1465973854,
-0.994982779,
0.7362331152,
-0.0491806045,
0.2242211699,
-0.4265746772,
-0.2372655421,
-0.1467320621,
0.5671156049,
-0.1627711058,
-0.592897594,
0.6409286857,
0.174146533,
0.0510482751,
0.0084979003,
0.7127797008,
-0.4241650701,
-0.562236011,
0.2202448696,
0.3453463614,
0.049894359,
0.3514506817,
-0.4832156897,
-0.2498119175,
0.2594583929,
-0.1861151457,
-0.111219652,
0.7032753825,
-0.1352828592,
0.4186429083,
0.1884497106,
-0.0594204701,
-0.0956104249,
0.3520672321,
0.8633737564,
-0.684971571,
-0.3271077871,
-0.9108523726,
0.461243242,
-0.2637326419,
-0.4107779264,
0.7019195557,
0.7622879744,
0.1734976768,
-0.212376982,
0.8600221872,
-0.4577707648,
0.7920069098,
-0.6566987634,
0.4535984695,
-0.7087142467,
0.1162063405,
-0.1424066424,
-0.2039946616,
-0.5556178689,
0.1236663312,
-0.4719171226,
-0.4046210945,
1.1136312485,
0.7093249559,
-0.0053137159,
0.2693799734,
0.1077618971,
0.4001993239,
0.5357587337,
0.7619488835,
0.563847065,
-0.8204128146,
0.3233083189,
-0.0059604896,
-0.0641656071,
-0.295342207,
-0.7942560315,
-1.0511851311,
-0.2145390809,
-0.2990823984,
-0.4932289422,
0.0930033699,
0.8313511014,
0.1690774262,
-1.2278773785,
0.0936695486,
-0.3722265065,
-0.1349432915,
-0.0194629598,
-0.2432878315,
0.4539865553,
-0.639477849,
-0.7576121092,
0.3479924202,
0.1547453701,
-0.0578779802,
0.1947742552,
-0.2020878047,
-0.1986212432,
-0.1095180809,
0.6248189211,
-0.088444978,
-0.8919282556,
-0.2153700888,
0.0725845769,
-0.2929219007,
0.0536726564,
0.686354816,
-0.690351367,
0.2081285864,
0.6059467793,
0.6054996848,
0.525295794,
0.061989367,
1.0939359665,
-0.6122196317,
0.1862332523,
0.4677954018,
0.2927900553,
0.1685875058,
-0.1941991448,
0.9187448025,
0.192506358,
-0.3717800379,
-0.7706680894,
0.0377471671,
-1.0266610384,
-0.2889193892,
1.2190726995,
-0.1483220756,
-0.4441605806,
-0.288290292,
-0.2255808115,
0.2708535492,
-0.146696493,
0.5235551,
0.4733525217,
-0.2465313971,
0.0357939452,
-0.9795370102,
0.7395133972,
0.6543390155,
-0.9872384667,
-0.1738498062,
0.546839118,
0.3913981915,
0.0296914168,
0.9572950006,
-0.3271258473,
0.3275126517,
-0.2100888044,
-0.147898674,
0.305114001,
-0.0761078149,
-0.1593331248,
0.0859142318,
0.0000949296,
-0.1268122792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09135v1
|
Unveiling LLM Evaluation Focused on Metrics: Challenges and Solutions
| 2024-04-14T03:54:00 | 2024-04-14T03:54:00 |
Taojun Hu, Xiao-Hua Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Processing (NLP) is witnessing a remarkable breakthrough
driven by the success of Large Language Models (LLMs). LLMs have gained
significant attention across academia and industry for their versatile
applications in text generation, question answering, and text summarization. As
the landscape of NLP evolves with an increasing number of domain-specific LLMs
employing diverse techniques and trained on various corpus, evaluating
performance of these models becomes paramount. To quantify the performance,
it's crucial to have a comprehensive grasp of existing metrics. Among the
evaluation, metrics which quantifying the performance of LLMs play a pivotal
role. This paper offers a comprehensive exploration of LLM evaluation from a
metrics perspective, providing insights into the selection and interpretation
of metrics currently in use. Our main goal is to elucidate their mathematical
formulations and statistical interpretations. We shed light on the application
of these metrics using recent Biomedical LLMs. Additionally, we offer a
succinct comparison of these metrics, aiding researchers in selecting
appropriate metrics for diverse tasks. The overarching goal is to furnish
researchers with a pragmatic guide for effective LLM evaluation and metric
selection, thereby advancing the understanding and application of these large
language models.
|
[
-0.2467536926,
-0.7141523361,
0.7187319994,
0.359793812,
-0.1784868538,
0.411218971,
-0.3560665548,
-0.5821506977,
0.0236733593,
0.3471577168,
-0.4555037022,
-0.6852394938,
-0.8129592538,
0.4667378664,
-0.2959268391,
1.1356105804,
0.1237969846,
0.3735693991,
-0.7804261446,
-0.2236408442,
-0.4408021271,
-0.4771720171,
-0.6606988907,
-0.6620745659,
0.5227746964,
-0.0161032174,
0.4772705138,
0.5035374165,
1.1210614443,
0.2930346429,
-0.4810546339,
0.2105295807,
-0.3937152326,
0.1572320461,
-0.1058170944,
-0.4880679548,
-0.5162114501,
-0.0803495273,
0.9426532984,
1.2120636702,
0.1288678795,
0.482234478,
0.2352322042,
0.8255813122,
-0.5069640279,
0.0070520788,
-0.5699240565,
0.2639941275,
-0.2891461551,
-0.3870328665,
-0.1398332119,
-0.3964447379,
0.1738507897,
-0.2949777246,
0.021192085,
-0.0168505665,
0.4441849589,
0.43395257,
-0.2230210751,
-0.4050725996,
-0.6408025622,
0.9309483171,
-0.8464042544,
0.467150718,
0.0646736249,
0.2586763203,
-0.2925595045,
-0.7621591091,
-0.1572314203,
-0.3612223268,
0.0542681366,
0.0061957943,
-0.3238596618,
0.0353127643,
0.1233181432,
0.6962754726,
-0.6968770623,
0.4942570329,
-0.2600901425,
-0.1876441091,
0.5167611837,
0.4939716458,
0.2053289115,
-0.1420757324,
-0.3284094632,
0.2387138158,
-0.5093101859,
-0.1639560908,
0.0945592523,
0.1246867403,
-0.0586503334,
0.6686942577,
-0.1165311262,
0.5998206735,
-0.3797860742,
-0.2621402442,
0.3715737462,
-0.612097621,
-0.21008192,
-0.3849637806,
0.9506630301,
0.3331175148,
0.2424534857,
-0.3797878623,
-0.2228065878,
-0.0346212983,
0.3669564724,
-0.7075940967,
0.2837736309,
0.3136929572,
-0.5513605475,
-0.17285797,
-0.4753979743,
-0.8389405012,
-0.3927365839,
-0.2244673669,
0.1448934823,
-0.4475366771,
-0.0254189353,
0.3882846236,
-0.1900706142,
0.1748681366,
0.1472829431,
-0.7019703388,
0.6130018234,
1.0250635147,
1.1236710548,
-0.5905835032,
-0.0600080788,
-0.2801109552,
-0.2119441926,
-0.3079547286,
0.8361905813,
-0.3089622259,
-0.508890748,
0.0355235077,
-0.4293334186,
-0.105345048,
-0.8310291171,
0.834009409,
-0.33368361,
-0.0916573629,
-0.0519077852,
-0.8091502786,
0.0070650037,
0.3954261541,
-0.5392799973,
1.0158153772,
-0.0181771386,
-0.7962836623,
0.4083983898,
-0.8707537651,
-0.3013583422,
0.2974822223,
0.0204827059,
-0.4156973362,
0.4789262414,
0.0472333506,
0.6082458496,
-0.6014949083,
0.1404142082,
-0.2677116096,
-0.2281294465,
0.5355388522,
-0.2485693693,
0.5618107915,
0.1194036156,
0.0488057807,
0.189062953,
-0.7484592199,
0.1223610789,
0.0064779813,
-0.3503038883,
-0.1481726766,
0.1148821786,
-0.137216717,
-0.1217721179,
0.3933326304,
-0.4616681933,
-0.1606364548,
-0.6414693594,
0.2988767326,
0.4203640521,
0.1410481334,
0.376950264,
-0.2764303684,
0.6725801826,
-0.4595698714,
0.2155625522,
0.12932688,
-0.4696361423,
-0.3759455979,
-0.4301917255,
0.3442863822,
0.5344307423,
-0.1720638722,
0.4129761457,
-0.2699509263,
-0.7723659277,
-0.819016695,
0.3633102477,
0.3620319366,
0.4653698206,
0.3845315576,
-0.3722302616,
-0.4942792654,
-1.0241105556,
-0.567147851,
-0.1927176565,
-0.2781974971,
0.2106910944,
0.5184782147,
-0.2670285404,
0.9582001567,
-0.4663287699,
-0.2750715017,
-0.544198215,
0.1001169235,
0.3585842848,
0.1858057976,
0.4395840764,
-0.3804419637,
-0.0820493773,
-0.0413512141,
-0.7008972764,
-0.5103732347,
-0.0320524201,
0.0124936774,
-0.1439617723,
0.4793510735,
-0.4430175722,
0.1633855253,
0.5779827833,
-0.1959413141,
0.9147650003,
-0.1759693623,
-0.0721777305,
-0.6181285977,
0.2360193133,
0.2627958655,
-0.3394114077,
-0.4925994277,
0.1887919605,
-0.1920834631,
0.333871454,
-0.3657488823,
0.6482288241,
-0.3184810281,
-0.3683212698,
-0.1907114387,
0.3748216927,
-0.0288602468,
0.0724446625,
-0.2186583877,
0.6074271798,
0.4473319352,
-0.6296076179,
0.3094044924,
0.23510167,
-0.4831053019,
0.4660826921,
-0.8380278349,
-0.0544148162,
0.0032594607,
0.0841189697,
-0.8335754275,
0.310651809,
0.0620633885,
-0.6057499647,
0.2060461491,
0.1838453561,
-0.7113227844,
-0.3977198601,
-0.3662031293,
0.3459950089,
0.3851158321,
-0.1573101431,
0.1838583499,
0.6609547138,
-0.210011676,
-0.5251432061,
-0.4742105603,
0.2942031622,
-0.4174715281,
-0.3913391531,
0.3458340764,
-0.2202332169,
-0.5351484418,
-0.2186266929,
-0.1234803945,
0.1725489348,
0.4472027719,
0.014210335,
0.2199928015,
-0.206518352,
0.1976008117,
-0.145964697,
-0.3002821505,
0.4333052933,
-0.0945722908,
0.3939068317,
-0.2612722814,
-0.3502690196,
-0.3788836002,
0.1444699317,
0.2847242355,
-0.3644340932,
0.6326989532,
0.7082699537,
-0.4084654748,
-0.0417649075,
-0.5272876024,
-0.0327347368,
-0.3782659471,
0.8437319994,
-0.0521148778,
-0.8500318527,
0.5954998732,
-0.3674083054,
0.1484597325,
0.543684721,
0.8620477915,
-0.0579492301,
0.9322438836,
0.6346652508,
0.063827239,
0.2878144681,
-0.1157338992,
0.3447318077,
-1.0490123034,
-0.4302802086,
-0.6923374534,
-0.24686037,
-0.5987986326,
-0.6157248616,
0.4899812341,
0.1108261496,
0.0769701377,
0.0059773391,
-0.3112425506,
0.3518298864,
0.0962934196,
-0.2473116219,
0.491982311,
-0.1557240337,
-0.2277963012,
-0.2157538533,
-0.5945207477,
-0.9210399389,
1.1631543636,
0.7458389401,
0.4849431217,
-0.0102465982,
0.5548859835,
0.2914066911,
0.3676822782,
-1.1196581125,
0.689783752,
-0.2621875405,
-0.4157586694,
-0.2681916952,
-0.527472198,
-0.9771027565,
0.3539766371,
-0.3908432424,
-0.9185937643,
-0.4486163259,
-0.2761287987,
-0.3246510923,
0.2788190544,
-0.3451763093,
0.892564714,
-0.4359856546,
-0.1776939183,
-0.3549476862,
-0.4576267898,
0.2745562196,
-0.2378286868,
0.2040021569,
-0.4134971499,
-0.4372635484,
0.8683828712,
-0.0402990729,
0.5854326487,
0.1960645169,
-0.1618165821,
0.0043575405,
0.0073754629,
-0.2351278961,
0.219962433,
-0.2251334339,
0.6440699697,
0.3230856955,
-0.207355693,
-0.4342890382,
0.6012313962,
-0.4978838265,
-0.3422325552,
-0.319879204,
-0.5158171058,
-0.4772255123,
0.0330299772,
0.0948522687,
0.1931658387,
-0.5305820704,
0.1452411562,
0.4848957658,
-0.633059144,
0.4390507042,
0.4446414411,
-0.397233963,
-0.2703029513,
0.5718758106,
-0.1593558937,
0.3420101404,
0.5774663091,
0.2272824943,
-0.5710712671,
-1.0496258736,
-0.2935185134,
0.4592839479,
-0.5604265332,
-0.2333211601,
-0.723017931,
-0.1661778241,
-0.1892218441,
0.0719856396,
-0.326269418,
-0.3971142769,
-0.2955291867,
-0.0876667723,
0.1240420192,
0.8149496317,
-0.104580842,
0.1415909082,
-0.8476378918,
0.344484359,
-0.1245097443,
0.5605148673,
-0.0465006307,
-0.5429326296,
-0.3650528491,
-0.158563152,
-0.2743458152,
-0.7459970117,
0.4814237356,
0.2757032812,
0.7946609855,
0.0199051574,
-0.3381231129,
0.4389946163,
-0.603775382,
0.6882296801,
0.2047927976,
-0.7528660893,
0.4359146059,
-0.091323927,
0.2995128632,
0.539005816,
0.3065518141,
-0.6248894334,
-0.6482304335,
-0.3693219423,
-1.0611127615,
0.1894059628,
0.2343946099,
0.0184615273,
-0.0246154703,
0.3897160292,
0.2220371068,
0.1347031295,
-0.5748875141,
-0.2607958615,
0.5229066014,
-0.2362571657,
-0.2152720988,
-0.2125915885,
-0.0915265083,
-0.1193765029,
0.4384748042,
-0.0631791577,
0.1321783662,
0.0389692783,
-0.238556385,
0.1709119529,
0.3519881368,
0.4490163028,
0.8366476297,
-0.3321729302,
-0.2512730956,
0.3318824768,
-0.4747225046,
-0.240711242,
-0.0846213624,
0.1803536266,
0.2408106774,
0.643714726,
0.5362496376,
0.2508613169,
-0.9415293932,
0.3875875473,
-0.1655679792,
-0.0414577015,
-0.2236090451,
-0.0177978259,
0.2234718651,
0.1424487084,
0.4233049154,
-0.0471302532,
0.293627739,
-0.261136651,
0.2172688842,
0.6115353703,
-0.3389959335,
-0.1603768021,
0.4942705035,
0.0988269597,
-0.4462580979,
0.3032127619,
-0.0331746005,
-0.3318608105,
0.6794650555,
0.5061579347,
0.9628326297,
0.0990877151,
0.226577878,
0.3480278254,
0.282595247,
0.2162628621,
0.0061228094,
0.2047935873,
-0.6874358058,
-0.7603860497,
-1.1906064749,
-0.4929834306,
0.1602212191,
-0.7365968823,
0.0902518108,
-0.4658993781,
-0.4364283383,
0.214181006,
0.3153839111,
-0.8321654201,
0.1413597316,
0.2879606485,
0.9713674188,
-0.5952136517,
0.2990314066,
0.6587135196,
-0.0736390501,
-0.175224334,
-0.1790118814,
0.0671633035,
-0.8006605506,
0.6045516133,
0.0210616291,
-0.1566868871,
-0.1638084203,
-0.132994622,
-0.61455971,
0.7712080479,
0.3040243089,
-0.4929758012,
0.1100539863,
0.3774517477,
1.0370573997,
-0.4292193949,
0.4738724828,
0.9627138376,
0.2762466967,
-0.2019754946,
-1.0722309351,
-0.1338617206,
-0.1195592955,
0.0143892849,
0.1094507799,
-0.3156217933,
0.3049030006,
-0.3123574853,
-0.0601556487,
0.188812539,
0.5093405247,
0.4043183625,
0.3738790452,
0.2024567276,
0.4081918895,
0.7717027068,
-0.0356350057,
1.1001230478,
-0.3061525822,
0.3095558584,
0.7450981736,
-0.1939924955,
0.9415726662,
0.5398910046,
-0.7375644445,
0.2038899511,
0.6974730492,
0.0480964072,
0.0771325678,
0.6030489206,
-0.3116038442,
-0.0656124726,
-0.3040971756,
-0.2478214949,
0.5998557806,
0.5986974239,
-0.2717502713,
-0.2851648927,
-0.2043497264,
-0.142548427,
0.1839363128,
-0.4104074538,
0.8763397336,
0.3200731575,
-0.3584098518,
0.396109283,
0.2209293693,
0.7484976053,
-0.692943871,
0.143590048,
-0.1516452581,
0.0765483007,
-0.2959603071,
-0.8209215999,
0.5781725049,
0.3527347744,
-0.128080979,
-0.2970710993,
0.517658174,
-0.0655990914,
-0.590544641,
0.5659272075,
0.8464168906,
0.328953743,
0.0920259282,
-0.8177517653,
-0.0065385588,
-0.1881494522,
-0.1768892556,
0.4197042882,
0.3641392887,
0.2054700255,
0.9479691982,
0.599448204,
0.5983465314,
-0.146377638,
0.2888952792,
0.469245106,
-0.703546226,
-0.243717283,
-1.2193832397,
0.3411422074,
0.0083345063,
-0.3683459759,
0.6635636091,
0.6615656614,
0.6303928494,
0.1630168706,
0.6113151312,
0.3289206028,
0.7737026811,
-0.5695911646,
0.679191649,
-0.6332865953,
0.5703365803,
-0.3259221911,
-0.9426394701,
-0.599997282,
0.4837058187,
-0.396283567,
-0.0459443182,
0.7357973456,
0.4517238438,
0.4246784151,
-0.151922673,
0.309343487,
0.0374188423,
0.3032732308,
0.4934074581,
0.922539711,
-0.1408289522,
0.3787109256,
0.0224847123,
-0.1299182177,
-0.1587278396,
-1.0874239206,
-0.5902737379,
-0.320705682,
-0.330409199,
-0.023240488,
-0.0988276899,
0.6827658415,
0.3346249461,
-0.647505939,
-0.452914685,
0.2354400456,
0.2990219593,
-0.1303661466,
-0.2259663343,
0.2027927488,
-0.5407021642,
-0.6934258342,
0.299033016,
0.6684041619,
-0.1008167863,
-0.4235302806,
-0.0182692111,
-0.1315674633,
0.1441391259,
0.6722943187,
0.1039058343,
-0.60204041,
0.1420275271,
-0.0934680104,
-0.2316485792,
0.1712659448,
0.7935265303,
-0.7678494453,
0.117419064,
0.4827454686,
0.978534162,
0.2168690264,
-0.2259729207,
0.7058182359,
-0.6501109004,
-0.2240541726,
0.6143618226,
0.3399083018,
0.6217715144,
-0.1447224915,
0.7716876268,
0.0336127803,
-0.6530205607,
-1.0847855806,
0.0836839303,
-0.832518518,
-0.1892550737,
1.132817626,
0.0212996025,
-0.0392397977,
-0.0757073015,
0.0414508395,
0.2109892964,
0.0362636559,
0.6887998581,
0.6990900636,
-0.3179942369,
0.1316302419,
-1.0361822844,
0.5357608199,
0.7450504303,
-0.860471189,
-0.0918616578,
0.3061645031,
0.2012138814,
0.1200510412,
0.6431369781,
-0.3527647853,
-0.1061967388,
-0.3661347032,
-0.0632136464,
0.334654808,
0.0046647801,
-0.5742656589,
0.0902051404,
0.211454317,
-0.0730227232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09129v1
|
When Hindsight is Not 20/20: Testing Limits on Reflective Thinking in Large Language Models
| 2024-04-14T02:47:32 | 2024-04-14T02:47:32 |
Yanhong Li, Chenghao Yang, Allyson Ettinger
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies suggest that self-reflective prompting can significantly
enhance the reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). However,
the use of external feedback as a stop criterion raises doubts about the true
extent of LLMs' ability to emulate human-like self-reflection. In this paper,
we set out to clarify these capabilities under a more stringent evaluation
setting in which we disallow any kind of external feedback. Our findings under
this setting show a split: while self-reflection enhances performance in
TruthfulQA, it adversely affects results in HotpotQA. We conduct follow-up
analyses to clarify the contributing factors in these patterns, and find that
the influence of self-reflection is impacted both by reliability of accuracy in
models' initial responses, and by overall question difficulty: specifically,
self-reflection shows the most benefit when models are less likely to be
correct initially, and when overall question difficulty is higher. We also find
that self-reflection reduces tendency toward majority voting. Based on our
findings, we propose guidelines for decisions on when to implement
self-reflection. We release the codebase for reproducing our experiments at
https://github.com/yanhong-lbh/LLM-SelfReflection-Eval.
|
[
-0.534198761,
-0.6758266091,
0.8309010267,
0.7554931641,
-0.0743189901,
-0.22131823,
-0.48561427,
-0.4454652965,
-0.1004064158,
0.8112055659,
-0.4537505805,
-0.1089713052,
-0.480612129,
0.4074437618,
-0.4187765718,
1.0071917772,
0.0003428116,
0.2157326639,
-0.2442947477,
-0.2071501613,
-0.5614118576,
-0.3413353264,
-0.2796855271,
-0.2052713633,
0.6421275735,
0.5789350271,
0.4463085234,
0.2698859274,
0.4359420538,
0.3273102045,
0.2304722369,
-0.0149318641,
-0.3395368159,
0.328248769,
-0.3325697482,
-0.415882498,
-0.1554962248,
0.2568820715,
0.7499586344,
0.4494607747,
-0.2539498806,
0.354572475,
0.3388248086,
0.7837858796,
-0.7554567456,
-0.1312019229,
-0.3742909431,
-0.0413430259,
0.0499055088,
-0.0762565136,
-0.5202339292,
-0.3172223866,
0.1008758023,
0.1227123365,
0.1234725192,
-0.0569335967,
0.4954269826,
0.2920025587,
-0.6125400662,
-0.1826540083,
-0.9009902477,
0.878015101,
-0.9805820584,
0.5938245654,
0.1989459395,
0.2381487191,
0.0316291712,
-0.5947537422,
-0.5284421444,
-0.5238223672,
0.065023765,
0.1411184669,
0.0373733416,
-0.0011850356,
0.3799012005,
0.4145061672,
-0.3228527308,
0.028910106,
-0.6293080449,
0.0719582438,
0.7773581743,
0.2281742692,
-0.2186900526,
-0.0495744199,
-0.4915021658,
0.0779437423,
-0.7186009884,
-0.1251091212,
0.3597265482,
0.4224827588,
0.3049635887,
0.5018863082,
-0.2572767437,
0.4743902087,
0.2476532161,
0.1127588153,
0.0075470484,
-0.3594267368,
-0.0388169773,
-0.3824213743,
0.8232507706,
0.3374903202,
0.1194656417,
0.0356478877,
-0.343769908,
-0.1084810719,
0.5033610463,
-0.8306794763,
-0.2505784631,
0.2417088747,
-0.3169335127,
-0.2111003995,
-0.1017737389,
-0.8468426466,
-0.385043025,
-0.195873946,
0.6568784118,
0.0858914182,
-0.2201346308,
-0.0509621128,
0.0435541831,
0.2463757694,
0.4343846738,
-0.6568602324,
0.4655847251,
0.4467523694,
0.6967009306,
-0.2279707789,
-0.5605130792,
-0.4815721512,
-0.3276417553,
-0.52986902,
0.6413890123,
-0.211968258,
-0.3433303237,
-0.0974475816,
0.0499270409,
0.1557507664,
-0.6516851783,
0.3945246339,
-0.3733553886,
0.5195395947,
-0.5954647064,
-0.4345758259,
-0.2463779896,
0.2867658734,
-0.4712994397,
0.738284111,
-0.1548167169,
-0.5430527329,
0.3833319247,
-0.4192439616,
-0.4383814931,
-0.0728132501,
-0.2467093766,
-0.3615060151,
0.2328937203,
0.1190314367,
0.4053097069,
-0.2063779831,
0.2339400649,
-0.4406371713,
-0.3032852113,
0.2906035781,
-0.625967145,
0.5763938427,
0.0758698136,
-0.8460575938,
0.1474216431,
-0.4024350345,
0.288949281,
0.0811490044,
-0.2419638932,
-0.2060963959,
-0.1551816314,
-0.3010292351,
0.4290439188,
0.0999795273,
-0.6013736725,
0.0642552823,
-0.18869856,
0.1999798715,
0.9287948012,
0.1080533341,
0.2200076133,
-0.3559803665,
0.5886085033,
-0.172392562,
0.4755874276,
0.1520555317,
-0.6135376096,
-0.8326502442,
0.1944350302,
0.1165937632,
0.3321730793,
-0.5966277719,
-0.0006282775,
0.2437657118,
-0.5304530263,
-0.4862693846,
0.44744277,
0.641613543,
0.328854531,
0.3925493062,
-0.4976000786,
-0.5799976587,
-0.9932219982,
-0.4089438319,
-0.2088233382,
0.3132244945,
0.2568357587,
0.7471296191,
0.0765286237,
0.6847830415,
-0.3994431496,
-0.408613652,
-0.2645873427,
-0.0414515622,
0.2134847194,
0.4524596334,
0.2397217304,
-0.6608489156,
-0.3694384992,
-0.6609198451,
-0.7552852631,
-0.1703561693,
0.0026989703,
0.1009042412,
0.3115020692,
0.3380876482,
-0.4703585505,
0.3513032794,
0.8325174451,
-0.4531903565,
0.8047922254,
-0.2577312589,
0.2751245201,
-0.2798362672,
-0.0317540765,
0.0596425086,
-0.0350411944,
-0.5153746009,
0.3021230996,
0.0475141928,
0.3398924768,
-0.363342315,
0.6192574501,
-0.5465109944,
-0.0005745416,
-0.5669985414,
0.1786408722,
0.2255690098,
0.3379912972,
-0.0820216611,
0.8481539488,
-0.0962556079,
-0.7559421659,
0.3094519675,
0.194944039,
-0.4961378872,
0.5154865384,
-0.551563859,
0.3921184838,
0.1414137185,
0.288470149,
-1.0393329859,
0.12050464,
0.1282488853,
-0.373580426,
0.1041151732,
0.3241190612,
-0.2779711187,
-0.5608094335,
-0.5455283523,
0.2507317066,
0.41853562,
-0.7164518237,
0.5098387599,
0.1505096406,
0.069336392,
-0.7115270495,
-0.8998057246,
0.1009958684,
-0.1907458752,
-0.4994617701,
-0.2689524293,
-0.3344610333,
-0.6521527767,
-0.2601903975,
0.1175749674,
0.294734329,
0.0549429767,
0.3282486796,
0.1469597369,
-0.1132560968,
0.1937371641,
-0.1548980474,
0.1652575135,
0.3464998305,
-0.1730719656,
0.3141434491,
-0.4902976751,
-0.3913474083,
-0.153899014,
0.3807251155,
0.2718796134,
-0.1314788312,
0.6941290498,
0.2881726027,
0.0134468367,
-0.3589308858,
-1.1509356499,
-0.5807513595,
-0.5305706263,
0.1776525229,
-0.3650743663,
-0.9590229988,
0.5682120323,
0.2902675569,
0.1511371583,
0.5736563802,
0.7899454236,
-0.1901332885,
1.0484039783,
0.5394292474,
0.2837779224,
0.1927256435,
-0.2405599952,
0.098114185,
-1.2811099291,
-0.1153810471,
-0.2794539928,
-0.0967820063,
-0.7732604742,
-0.3064968884,
0.0842350423,
-0.3781119585,
-0.1799235642,
-0.0393869691,
-0.5615265965,
0.3472239673,
0.4736777246,
0.2111041099,
0.5594388247,
-0.6660577059,
0.0723778233,
-0.3764662147,
-0.6191765666,
-0.2827032506,
0.9799426794,
0.3994603455,
0.8876535892,
0.0634151399,
0.6985116005,
0.1423712075,
0.724688828,
-0.711484015,
0.746295929,
0.0632034838,
-1.1694592237,
-0.4986646473,
-0.6016511917,
-0.6972883344,
0.5421975851,
0.1499255002,
-0.3565936685,
0.3302101493,
0.1300901175,
-0.3199448586,
0.2529553175,
-0.7096986175,
0.7495296597,
-0.3764480948,
-0.708583951,
-0.164482221,
-0.4994013906,
0.5933899283,
-0.0894611776,
0.2480458319,
0.0607469119,
-0.0269481428,
0.7730416656,
-0.1950807422,
1.0530971289,
-0.399851799,
-0.5279211402,
0.5952426791,
0.343195796,
0.5410757661,
-0.1601941884,
0.1287064999,
-0.0234468635,
0.1327012032,
-0.2314251065,
-0.7980383039,
0.7311139107,
-0.3164176643,
-1.3734650612,
-0.4591657817,
-0.3044998348,
-0.3904969096,
0.0652305931,
0.1780138165,
0.219583258,
0.0192860812,
0.1283225715,
0.444720149,
0.0368036106,
0.2417643368,
0.7499097586,
-0.8061085939,
-0.4075074792,
0.7799379826,
0.6151713729,
0.5731181502,
-0.2966299355,
0.5258137584,
-0.4212100208,
-0.5423028469,
-0.3379151821,
0.5019997954,
-1.0316163301,
0.0462396331,
-0.2866339087,
0.0679318756,
-0.3911218941,
0.3348920345,
-0.4833606184,
-0.4023081958,
-0.0091168778,
-0.0498586372,
0.0858744159,
1.0664349794,
-0.2420570254,
-0.3810171783,
-0.6778621674,
-0.2032099664,
0.4936220348,
0.3943724632,
0.3950803578,
-0.7526153326,
-0.3256706893,
-0.2234136164,
-0.3051152527,
-0.7026433349,
0.0166712124,
0.0595659688,
0.3118492961,
0.3595826626,
0.3371261358,
0.5857203603,
-0.4976871312,
0.8229081631,
-0.1215490028,
-0.8896670341,
0.3966912031,
-0.306681186,
0.5555388927,
0.7434481382,
0.1800604165,
-0.4549539685,
-0.8820194602,
-0.5414924622,
-0.5492192507,
0.1203644276,
-0.0535491705,
0.4013032913,
0.0094671519,
0.5232713819,
0.272267133,
0.230964005,
-0.7693879604,
0.0367299765,
-0.0615400001,
0.2962805033,
-0.1398227513,
-0.4169121087,
-0.3879979551,
-0.3392053246,
0.5760017037,
-0.2612079978,
0.2217330635,
0.5329426527,
0.2528200746,
-0.3034472466,
0.325322777,
0.7468200922,
0.8762891889,
-0.0123194102,
0.2656455934,
0.6278768778,
-0.3597038686,
0.1220951229,
-0.2699818015,
-0.0341514908,
-0.1966309398,
0.5611442327,
0.3231695294,
-0.0068303682,
-0.5187608004,
0.4899350107,
-0.0748772547,
-0.1936540902,
-0.4249736965,
0.1563030928,
-0.1542811692,
0.6086809039,
0.3852404356,
-0.245141834,
0.3696320951,
-0.7514776587,
0.2207021415,
0.4680253267,
-0.4187375009,
-0.3720125854,
0.5319789648,
0.0991990268,
-0.2642041743,
0.4758558273,
-0.0455854274,
-0.7793494463,
0.360750556,
0.4653310478,
0.8250822425,
-0.5374368429,
0.100550659,
0.2587768137,
0.3255572021,
-0.185878396,
0.4723169804,
-0.2827899754,
-0.6008407474,
-0.7117624283,
-0.200889051,
-0.6745317578,
-0.0292855129,
-0.6990117431,
-0.1152241826,
-0.5991294384,
-0.4210673571,
-0.3565884233,
0.2341336012,
-0.3258953094,
0.471897155,
-0.0790445954,
0.8226633668,
-0.5926423669,
0.4129836261,
0.1662185192,
-0.356544137,
-0.7546036243,
0.144265756,
-0.034714587,
-0.6186698675,
0.6931840181,
0.1347476691,
-0.3861533105,
-0.2616672218,
-0.8066898584,
-0.6535221934,
0.7250067592,
0.1392658055,
-0.6453956366,
-0.0352277532,
-0.2737619281,
0.7345191836,
-0.1184338629,
0.2419411093,
0.3695741594,
0.6355267167,
0.1558289379,
-1.1507002115,
0.5105797052,
-0.0130176963,
-0.1422871947,
0.060806945,
-1.1995979548,
0.7259455919,
-0.6507961154,
-0.1239100099,
0.0219827127,
0.6886851788,
0.2378494442,
0.2448506504,
0.5888711214,
0.3888860047,
0.3193691075,
-0.0111239348,
1.1559360027,
0.0780764744,
0.3228543401,
1.2854337692,
-0.413939625,
0.983787477,
0.7248694301,
-0.2400912344,
0.6205469966,
0.3226604164,
-0.2268406749,
0.5933722854,
0.1856572479,
-0.0951306298,
-0.3222972751,
-0.0514106676,
-0.3978675902,
0.5452343225,
-0.0037682424,
-0.3404186368,
0.1352424771,
0.123328574,
0.0236377679,
0.1375892162,
-0.0421063341,
0.57356143,
0.4397348762,
-1.0058671236,
0.4429913163,
-0.2242372334,
0.4721568823,
-0.2591694295,
-0.0277537778,
-0.1927569956,
0.443444401,
-0.3079507351,
-1.1220026016,
0.4013241529,
-0.2310420275,
0.1147150993,
-0.2469171733,
0.5059449077,
-0.1547099054,
-0.1364774704,
0.5995102525,
0.7069759369,
-0.0151566416,
-0.1819649637,
-0.501499176,
0.1192464605,
-0.0541964732,
-0.7205781937,
0.318874687,
0.4084887207,
0.1438915581,
0.8806266785,
0.4650204778,
0.1297678053,
-0.1141548455,
0.2255228609,
0.7561794519,
-0.7175472975,
-0.339738518,
-0.9834222794,
0.310375452,
0.1131959707,
-0.4233390689,
1.3200426102,
0.4095577598,
0.6147453785,
0.1126490757,
0.5224097967,
0.2196133584,
0.4476806223,
-0.561348021,
0.5510883331,
-0.5299310684,
0.2764618397,
-0.2548692226,
-0.9001572132,
-0.1587616354,
0.5039580464,
-0.8155153394,
0.4942949712,
0.7201648951,
0.5044150352,
0.4769007266,
0.2374529392,
0.4789701998,
0.4186357558,
0.3676170111,
0.3253839612,
1.386325717,
-0.2723461986,
0.5656402707,
-0.3708872199,
-0.1035503447,
-0.0008584647,
-0.5605691671,
-1.0391628742,
-0.8108606935,
-0.2396541834,
-0.6876530647,
0.0149272671,
0.6238898635,
0.5746262074,
-0.6103167534,
-0.3092611134,
0.0464592762,
0.0207224581,
-0.1033055782,
-0.2416627407,
0.1663476974,
-0.2138442397,
-0.3962409496,
0.3501928449,
0.1991649568,
-0.1084030122,
-1.0875231028,
-0.1411417276,
-0.1982234716,
0.2757522762,
0.3544184864,
0.2203166634,
-0.6646254659,
-0.6632035375,
0.1481104344,
0.0019971153,
0.184983179,
0.6127797365,
-0.7021417022,
0.5860471725,
0.3226973414,
0.1639659703,
0.6386101842,
-0.0702263415,
0.604329586,
-0.3509983718,
-0.2469384968,
0.499356389,
0.0815328136,
0.4027559459,
-0.4151225984,
0.5512693524,
0.0946052596,
-0.8833919168,
-1.0057067871,
0.3015446961,
-0.2505581677,
-0.055754669,
1.0857435465,
-0.2487931252,
-0.1982018203,
0.0215671584,
-0.1986580193,
-0.1243489757,
-0.1767337918,
1.1095662117,
0.9707585573,
-0.4177593887,
-0.6023773551,
-0.7591128349,
0.3701427281,
0.62127918,
-0.6165981889,
0.1035205722,
0.2462414503,
0.425380528,
0.3416764736,
0.5925757289,
0.0252950564,
0.3663814664,
0.0571818165,
-0.1620638371,
0.1019240692,
-0.4402939081,
-0.5992929339,
0.1285624653,
0.4082654715,
0.1639544517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09127v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09127v3
|
Confidence Calibration and Rationalization for LLMs via Multi-Agent Deliberation
| 2024-04-14T02:40:43 | 2024-05-10T16:38:23 |
Ruixin Yang, Dheeraj Rajagopal, Shirley Anugrah Hayati, Bin Hu, Dongyeop Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Uncertainty estimation is a significant issue for current large language
models (LLMs) that are generally poorly calibrated and over-confident,
especially with reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). Unlike
humans, whose decisions and confidences not only stem from intrinsic beliefs
but can also be adjusted through daily observations, existing calibration
methods for LLMs focus on estimating or eliciting individual confidence without
taking full advantage of the "Collective Wisdom": the interaction among
multiple LLMs that can collectively improve both accuracy and calibration. In
this work, we propose Collaborative Calibration, a post-hoc training-free
calibration strategy that leverages the collaborative and expressive
capabilities of multiple tool-augmented LLM agents in a simulated group
deliberation process. We demonstrate the effectiveness of Collaborative
Calibration on generative QA tasks across various domains, showing its
potential in harnessing the rationalization of collectively calibrated
confidence assessments and improving the reliability of model predictions.
|
[
-0.4131056666,
-0.5402852893,
0.8025358915,
-0.1191555113,
-0.1786263734,
0.4457735121,
-0.4351346195,
-0.1680656672,
0.1303356737,
0.2002038062,
-0.5856294036,
-0.7375671864,
-0.3945605457,
0.0949812308,
0.5151288509,
0.62301898,
-0.0711154491,
0.4075023234,
-0.4732140303,
-0.3297093213,
-0.5854973793,
-0.5130541921,
-0.3262129128,
-0.7033824325,
0.6401766539,
0.427175343,
0.8342345953,
0.0185032282,
0.1270663738,
0.3725354671,
0.2578951418,
0.7497799993,
-0.639113009,
0.2363821566,
-0.2164696157,
-0.7936269045,
-0.5107665062,
0.4958888888,
0.4284512699,
0.7513180375,
-0.4330223203,
-0.042601984,
0.1186045036,
0.5105406046,
-0.869517386,
0.3642345369,
-0.7042047381,
-0.1379380375,
0.534756124,
-0.4579648077,
-0.573332727,
-0.7862591743,
0.1769248992,
-0.9234979749,
0.0030114674,
-0.0048728143,
0.2099537104,
0.648629427,
-0.3871509135,
-0.1750466377,
-0.8434243798,
1.1776860952,
-0.4678941965,
0.2348549366,
0.8219872713,
0.2122044116,
-0.3378778696,
-0.2787642181,
-0.4074086845,
-0.0538179316,
0.3183889687,
0.2930454612,
0.2940632999,
0.1822651476,
-0.1454804838,
0.1345236003,
-0.2821702063,
-0.0101578962,
0.0129033569,
-0.3637773097,
0.8074102998,
-0.0123605076,
-0.035490863,
0.446721375,
-0.3700322509,
-0.4373362362,
-0.7283713818,
-0.0095539493,
0.2943135798,
0.3357580602,
-0.0300766733,
0.2701058388,
-0.0259874426,
0.3522040546,
0.2120519131,
-0.27537781,
0.3632703722,
-0.4693987072,
-0.1952332258,
-0.075818114,
0.8078117967,
0.5375103951,
0.2036950141,
-0.2946692109,
-0.1718198657,
0.2425975353,
0.1510919333,
-0.5774100423,
-0.1673246622,
0.3008729517,
0.1630121469,
-0.2983451188,
0.1084817126,
-0.3960386217,
-0.6214849353,
-0.5371710062,
0.558393836,
-0.209098056,
-0.3382547498,
0.1224186048,
-0.003590469,
0.3026907742,
0.8050494194,
-0.6241729259,
0.1646115035,
0.6559543014,
0.3426868021,
0.0719618872,
-0.4971550107,
-0.6026848555,
0.1938374639,
-0.6850358844,
0.7051160932,
-0.231496349,
-0.6711519957,
-0.236150831,
-0.2478430867,
-0.2453236729,
-0.3966161609,
0.2536484003,
-0.6684988141,
0.3380404413,
-0.5258640647,
-0.6275498867,
-0.2400480509,
0.6945526004,
-0.6122039557,
0.6839666367,
0.1224170923,
-0.5928215981,
0.4998780191,
-0.0276655853,
0.0622323826,
0.2110749036,
-0.6402574182,
-0.184174031,
-0.0062131574,
0.2268875092,
0.195026651,
-0.4317196012,
0.3032206595,
-0.6429659724,
-0.5589159727,
0.3835760653,
-0.5620343089,
0.5081655383,
-0.0479109176,
0.0028731942,
0.4751739502,
-0.3598086238,
0.5046623349,
-0.3166790009,
-0.2934443355,
-0.2984251976,
-0.037215136,
-0.3898559213,
0.2213068455,
0.3332386613,
-0.3120123446,
0.1470434666,
-0.465372473,
0.079134956,
0.8428927064,
0.2201632708,
0.5710770488,
-0.8313956261,
0.6529929638,
-0.1877107769,
0.1307244003,
0.258683145,
-0.3966468871,
-0.4784449935,
-0.243664518,
0.1900906712,
0.5236461163,
-0.9902679324,
0.6504401565,
-0.5015636086,
-0.564897716,
-0.4980239868,
0.3265272081,
0.362374872,
0.1446536332,
0.1526468694,
-0.5801281333,
-0.2290409207,
-0.4416349232,
0.0488153063,
-0.5486348867,
-0.096881263,
0.1748670191,
0.2203973234,
-0.1252104938,
1.0079169273,
-0.1953472495,
-0.3158917129,
-0.1525664181,
0.471257031,
-0.1663186848,
0.3827458024,
0.1806416065,
-0.5903895497,
-0.4357281625,
-0.1151482314,
-0.5745847225,
0.2148279548,
0.087408483,
-0.2294153273,
0.2480570376,
0.1885896176,
-0.4484711587,
0.4064151347,
0.7412061095,
0.0449526049,
0.6835290194,
-0.473382026,
0.4643476307,
-1.0620155334,
-0.2944267988,
-0.1403262168,
-0.4820783734,
-0.290908426,
0.1416347027,
-0.3100435138,
0.6320105791,
-0.2369010597,
0.2977899611,
-0.4814091623,
0.0607725829,
-0.259098351,
0.5239254236,
0.1985916197,
0.5541908145,
0.1165636778,
0.9086332917,
0.3053849041,
-0.2902388871,
0.4993701577,
0.2196510285,
-0.2661809325,
0.7987425923,
-0.3815093338,
0.4481474459,
-0.0266995337,
0.551974237,
-0.7984008789,
-0.2891536951,
0.1498661488,
-0.4372763932,
-0.1209329441,
-0.0048232707,
-0.4499872625,
0.023623094,
-0.5351105332,
0.5267114043,
0.2776827514,
-0.2783062458,
0.8235341907,
0.5453365445,
-0.0257704426,
-0.6937186718,
-0.6850432158,
-0.1834435165,
0.1192317978,
-0.6393084526,
0.151504308,
-0.3255331516,
-0.3361150622,
-0.2624807656,
-0.127882123,
-0.1370334625,
0.0232355837,
0.4913079143,
0.3509909213,
0.2023723274,
0.3948878944,
-0.0962804854,
-0.0253624525,
0.0063581066,
0.0334562548,
0.5997921824,
-0.3557425737,
-0.7507622242,
-0.4827664495,
0.0350103229,
0.5999641418,
-0.225646317,
0.8697561026,
0.480554074,
-0.4149193168,
-0.3809925318,
-0.8299978971,
-0.4237750769,
-0.4734808505,
0.0892139226,
-0.2117050886,
-1.0030016899,
0.6127155423,
-0.2507780194,
-0.0340436623,
0.103617087,
0.6509759426,
0.0973180607,
0.9215021133,
0.6123554707,
-0.1232922971,
0.1754722595,
-0.1356533617,
-0.0814840943,
-0.6531559229,
-0.1800491959,
-0.3973463476,
-0.0298591051,
-0.5262228251,
-0.9348942041,
0.526432097,
0.0132585838,
-0.3116590381,
-0.0241675749,
-0.1933826506,
0.6133981347,
0.784396112,
0.4696190953,
0.4720028937,
-0.1142244786,
-0.3874114156,
-0.0448828712,
-0.5549312234,
-0.570448935,
1.063824892,
0.070897758,
0.8508093953,
-0.0322668143,
0.8311069608,
-0.0234907083,
0.5877678394,
-0.8913838267,
0.4811888635,
0.3001079857,
-0.3774879575,
-0.5669100881,
-0.7457150817,
-0.66402179,
0.3033565283,
-0.2276825756,
-0.6888423562,
0.2138269991,
0.1700807065,
-0.5655943155,
0.1934624016,
-0.5609933138,
0.7066271901,
0.0834522024,
-0.4425036907,
-0.6380349398,
-0.6440373063,
0.1864847392,
-0.2941594124,
0.3957886398,
-0.2883652747,
0.0838867873,
0.2702767849,
-0.4611411393,
1.0415092707,
-0.1243919581,
-0.3047809303,
0.5944202542,
0.1327090114,
0.6647714376,
0.0159540903,
-0.4536304176,
-0.1420312524,
0.1511610895,
-0.1555969566,
-0.6768891215,
0.6159684658,
-1.0034147501,
-0.5256730318,
-0.3251678944,
-0.7781845331,
-0.6963919997,
-0.1129467413,
0.0337267779,
0.1813609451,
-0.49706918,
0.2584361136,
0.3109183609,
-0.1438531429,
0.1645603031,
0.2780202329,
-0.1314211637,
-0.8852615356,
0.6875172853,
-0.0607987978,
0.6426760554,
0.2012588978,
0.1028929427,
-0.4268978834,
-0.169899717,
-0.0536789373,
0.166413933,
-0.7997673154,
-0.1863195747,
-0.0709481761,
-0.016923802,
-0.4109072983,
-0.1128446609,
-0.4465169609,
-0.3205854297,
-0.4084563553,
-0.1446076185,
0.1148283705,
0.5353504419,
-0.1170436144,
0.3470690548,
-1.0035881996,
-0.1756320447,
0.4544605911,
0.2520115674,
-0.2699512243,
-0.2858601809,
-0.219633922,
0.5427083969,
-0.3691211641,
-0.7396642566,
0.4196015,
0.0119565008,
0.5187613964,
0.0938433558,
0.3856581151,
0.6565762758,
-0.1573493779,
0.5807008147,
0.2460861951,
-0.9064008594,
0.2085602134,
-0.1186155826,
0.3641628623,
1.0614469051,
0.1123220176,
-0.4745979905,
-0.3486828208,
-0.2153616995,
-0.4251689613,
0.4293212295,
-0.1285810769,
0.0007089583,
0.2881318927,
0.1795691103,
-0.0814297348,
0.3857414126,
-0.4019904435,
0.0210037101,
0.0187231153,
-0.3468643129,
-0.2981176972,
0.0187210999,
-0.5737943053,
-0.0669516549,
0.8264051676,
-0.5336662531,
-0.119647719,
0.2588481009,
-0.0993134081,
-0.5513709188,
0.4051615596,
0.3454967737,
0.6906726956,
-0.1658166349,
0.1733751744,
0.2551404536,
-0.3005920351,
0.3038750291,
0.0306516085,
0.0231868178,
-0.3618113995,
0.2733300328,
0.6221083403,
0.2009016573,
-0.4046734869,
0.7853811383,
-0.3172026277,
-0.4232206047,
-0.3479507565,
0.087517187,
0.1012919024,
0.3598331809,
0.2587577701,
0.3674236536,
-0.1617840677,
-0.1664532125,
0.2090320587,
0.776812911,
-0.4472498596,
-0.3477724195,
0.3201467693,
0.2692735791,
0.0022967902,
0.5067899823,
-0.388001889,
-0.5590059757,
0.4630695283,
0.073849462,
0.972612083,
-0.5192980766,
0.5115470886,
0.2433552146,
0.4485203028,
-0.3519645631,
0.2385939509,
-0.0206438657,
-1.3839147091,
-0.8299434185,
-0.4072958529,
-1.0171581507,
-0.1600847393,
-0.4705725312,
0.0453170761,
-0.4004851878,
-0.4834793806,
-0.5112046599,
0.3305600882,
-0.6640711427,
0.1498132497,
0.021036014,
0.4835437536,
-0.6173689961,
0.9297130108,
0.5923500061,
-0.3356901109,
-1.2785052061,
0.0007473171,
0.099977009,
-0.6241915822,
0.2573007345,
0.3132342994,
-0.7100449204,
0.0279764961,
-0.7995834351,
-0.7451912761,
1.3722239733,
0.5428942442,
-0.3632409573,
0.0026561001,
0.2349013537,
0.5996433496,
-0.3008740544,
0.3472257853,
0.1819264144,
0.4584748745,
0.5061576962,
-1.118904233,
-0.0178296007,
0.0790420324,
-0.1349519789,
-0.2688704431,
-0.6076461673,
0.6290057302,
-0.3192573488,
-0.2094763517,
0.05211512,
0.5867837667,
0.6820466518,
0.1266253144,
0.8309583068,
0.4770509303,
0.9810183644,
-0.0414867438,
0.7612973452,
-0.5054901838,
0.4166074991,
1.4908560514,
-0.6666374207,
0.8416273594,
0.5311036706,
-0.1055793762,
0.4891245067,
0.4271196425,
0.3741472363,
0.3223845065,
0.1207724065,
-0.8789014816,
-0.8600763679,
-0.1731179655,
-0.1372698843,
0.3291725218,
0.4728474021,
-0.0437327921,
-0.0650772303,
-0.2393213212,
-0.2160943449,
0.0991695821,
-0.1907311827,
0.7475622296,
0.18704696,
-1.0007300377,
0.3766793013,
-0.0546699353,
0.4902993739,
-0.3146366477,
0.0101774996,
0.065297395,
0.3683670461,
-0.0258423593,
-0.4820287526,
-0.0668434352,
-0.6033427715,
0.1294899434,
-0.2105243355,
0.5524067879,
-0.8236944079,
-0.2394560874,
0.2871664464,
0.9735854268,
-0.0328655317,
-0.3150704205,
-0.3969194591,
0.0597060099,
-0.1649662703,
-0.3347433209,
0.0245764423,
0.3252230585,
0.1587704271,
0.7531955838,
0.6674488187,
-0.0164827295,
-0.1435152888,
0.3689052165,
0.884439528,
-0.1222516522,
-0.2290672809,
-0.6226717234,
0.3100352287,
0.1340091079,
0.1007646546,
0.487395674,
0.1862510294,
0.965095818,
0.0690098554,
0.8460923433,
0.4862642586,
0.3994572163,
-0.207618624,
0.6553012729,
-0.3500916958,
0.3373095393,
-0.1341235638,
-0.8598989248,
-0.5448905826,
0.8798512816,
-0.3975630105,
0.2842481732,
0.5871156454,
0.9842730165,
0.3921757638,
0.2450566441,
0.5796189904,
0.0731058121,
0.3092829585,
0.5989035964,
0.7375285625,
-0.2227325439,
0.3844816089,
-0.4074025452,
-0.4247512519,
0.1139272973,
-0.9761910439,
-0.795519948,
-0.4601551294,
-0.3064353168,
-0.2019889504,
-0.1101466417,
1.5556906462,
0.7165676951,
-0.7009974122,
-0.3037211895,
-0.2104715407,
0.182483077,
-0.1034567207,
-0.1633513123,
0.0922279581,
-0.2496110946,
-0.74519068,
0.4064043164,
0.1288504452,
0.0710202903,
-0.5387188196,
-0.4250769913,
-0.0366292745,
0.2347214669,
0.3875009716,
-0.0213676747,
-0.7137818336,
-0.5268318653,
-0.1176420227,
-0.4734468758,
0.0337605514,
0.3941387832,
-0.9514316916,
0.6442113519,
0.3884330094,
0.5672900081,
0.2112875432,
0.3253470659,
0.9211188555,
-0.8967007995,
-0.0283059645,
0.2122646719,
0.2206108123,
0.4209843576,
-0.0648297891,
0.5194451213,
0.2674930692,
-0.9367452264,
-0.5793627501,
0.1228183955,
-0.8057038188,
0.04949582,
0.9498161077,
-0.5005671382,
0.0573096611,
-0.0802544057,
-0.2647646368,
0.4159785807,
-0.4978151917,
0.7179595232,
0.9862027168,
0.2068374455,
-0.1751915663,
-0.1065946519,
0.3749547005,
0.3277778029,
-1.0256855488,
0.0963066295,
0.9754188061,
0.0962660536,
0.4097346961,
0.8432412148,
0.0673542544,
0.2483153492,
-0.1450778246,
0.3588579595,
0.1167359874,
-0.3086971045,
-0.2236073017,
0.1796265393,
0.3721261322,
0.0003860495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09123v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09123v1
|
Provable Interactive Learning with Hindsight Instruction Feedback
| 2024-04-14T02:18:07 | 2024-04-14T02:18:07 |
Dipendra Misra, Aldo Pacchiano, Robert E. Schapire
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We study interactive learning in a setting where the agent has to generate a
response (e.g., an action or trajectory) given a context and an instruction. In
contrast, to typical approaches that train the system using reward or expert
supervision on response, we study learning with hindsight instruction where a
teacher provides an instruction that is most suitable for the agent's generated
response. This hindsight labeling of instruction is often easier to provide
than providing expert supervision of the optimal response which may require
expert knowledge or can be impractical to elicit. We initiate the theoretical
analysis of interactive learning with hindsight labeling. We first provide a
lower bound showing that in general, the regret of any algorithm must scale
with the size of the agent's response space. We then study a specialized
setting where the underlying instruction-response distribution can be
decomposed as a low-rank matrix. We introduce an algorithm called LORIL for
this setting and show that its regret scales as $\sqrt{T}$ where $T$ is the
number of rounds and depends on the intrinsic rank but does not depend on the
size of the agent's response space. We provide experiments in two domains
showing that LORIL outperforms baselines even when the low-rank assumption is
violated.
|
[
-0.4996720254,
-0.8555955291,
0.5063229203,
0.0720719099,
0.2816467881,
0.0328751914,
-0.2649187148,
-0.3121324778,
0.1837025434,
0.2339218706,
-0.8073046207,
-0.3563035727,
-0.4354917407,
-0.2176531702,
0.078126274,
1.0677583218,
0.1242638379,
0.3357087076,
-0.3099774718,
-0.0326968506,
-0.5056260824,
-0.4420152605,
-1.0973633528,
-0.2131563723,
0.7209722996,
0.8411946893,
0.4858405292,
0.5608758926,
0.8537560701,
0.3796546757,
0.1354073435,
0.1160206199,
-0.8812767267,
-0.0021378302,
-0.0996170938,
-0.5370336175,
-0.5078245997,
0.3192977011,
0.6616006494,
0.7561311126,
-0.3140017092,
0.0201385636,
0.2062477469,
0.5199474692,
-0.6791704893,
0.1863725036,
0.0342356637,
0.4213099778,
0.3143355846,
-0.2145240754,
-0.749704361,
-0.6890274286,
0.3589267731,
-0.7603165507,
-0.1120108292,
0.3345955312,
0.3901754618,
0.4623649716,
-0.4639649391,
-0.4152609706,
-1.0762435198,
0.9993964434,
-0.3539878428,
0.4168272316,
0.4603421092,
0.6598468423,
-0.1647192538,
-0.9141449332,
-0.4485598505,
-0.5892184377,
-0.0356011875,
0.400954932,
-0.0559307598,
0.3805729151,
0.3985413015,
0.1555793434,
-0.3231985569,
0.3930698335,
-0.2272874266,
-0.0403292999,
0.7034894824,
0.3250609338,
-0.2093048245,
0.1841900945,
-0.617536962,
-0.5005654097,
-0.4178400338,
0.5200267434,
0.5281969309,
0.0903766826,
0.0067350948,
0.4664700329,
-0.0034714167,
0.7028847337,
0.2514784932,
-0.1148489937,
-0.0622857958,
0.0713555142,
-0.0128444694,
0.0103091961,
0.4146437645,
0.3803788126,
0.187483415,
-0.0522865169,
-0.2430223078,
-0.2569915652,
0.5860546827,
-0.7066121697,
-0.4250531793,
0.1056849808,
-0.2670560181,
-0.2551463246,
-0.0277418904,
-0.8430026174,
-0.2305508256,
-0.2986644208,
0.6890701056,
-0.388858974,
0.4182539582,
-0.4445543885,
0.1936632395,
0.0455669872,
0.7460518479,
-0.5933744311,
0.3968461156,
0.3755527437,
0.4330273271,
-0.041669406,
-0.305020541,
-1.1346161366,
-0.1216919646,
-0.3749927878,
0.7531205416,
-0.6995067596,
-0.3983334601,
-0.2194077224,
-0.2250224948,
-0.0600833669,
-0.4124064445,
0.1347202808,
-0.782051146,
0.3049405217,
-0.1857668012,
-0.7099535465,
-0.4905513525,
0.5007317662,
-0.491489917,
0.584076941,
0.062156152,
-0.6102305055,
0.3798702955,
-0.5498095751,
-0.0966357365,
-0.0258772057,
-0.0706923679,
-0.4325300455,
-0.2062106431,
-0.2093965411,
0.1505452245,
0.1995430738,
-0.1281584054,
-0.4038241506,
-0.6131004691,
0.4113354981,
-0.3932403326,
0.2005571574,
-0.0170019064,
-0.3476748466,
0.3032267392,
-0.7976184487,
0.2580066025,
0.0357250348,
-0.7019540668,
-0.2304631323,
0.2477827072,
-0.4817150831,
-0.0707072541,
0.1693625599,
-0.4051845968,
0.2982957065,
-0.360684514,
-0.0511487462,
0.903504312,
0.4436343312,
0.6452338099,
-0.2077706754,
0.4496635795,
-0.2060963213,
0.4848577082,
0.0502896793,
-0.2869355679,
-0.9357283711,
0.0213458426,
0.5901110172,
0.6645869613,
-0.8411587477,
-0.1079749092,
0.0449985713,
-0.1807089001,
-0.2929466963,
-0.2273096442,
0.7275053263,
0.54999578,
0.4513719082,
-0.5185235143,
-0.3741835654,
-0.8568444252,
-0.0155704636,
-0.2670033574,
-0.1033889875,
0.5875844359,
0.2811443508,
0.0945389792,
0.8362003565,
-0.6930499077,
-0.4066433907,
0.145436883,
0.4080958068,
-0.2525694966,
0.5528511405,
0.4018593132,
-0.845295608,
-0.4745794833,
-0.1443688273,
-0.8255440593,
0.3968929052,
0.0559702441,
0.1238835379,
-0.03729463,
0.302580446,
-0.0562767982,
0.7869755626,
0.2284303159,
0.0008638654,
0.3866588175,
-0.4439005554,
0.2232925743,
-0.4785708785,
-0.1998502016,
-0.0730333403,
-0.2699446976,
-0.6466467381,
-0.0254669208,
-0.2243156433,
-0.069224067,
-0.3373468518,
0.348798573,
-0.3315337002,
-0.3209835589,
-0.3975653052,
0.2008916736,
-0.3963867426,
0.9794957042,
0.2845794261,
0.731200099,
-0.0009306541,
-0.5146725178,
0.3001036346,
0.310929656,
0.0134207401,
0.5756542683,
-0.4216734171,
0.2515332997,
-0.1344588846,
0.2387797385,
-0.8632246256,
-0.2519821525,
0.4635593593,
-0.4043833911,
0.3957258165,
-0.1979844868,
0.110096544,
-0.3203722835,
-0.2450957149,
0.073524788,
0.5992629528,
-0.3520908952,
0.396063596,
0.1222317219,
-0.1214703098,
-1.0233124495,
-0.4357650578,
-0.3094774485,
-0.0768226311,
-0.0691881031,
0.0018179355,
-0.3763213456,
-0.5162344575,
0.1157154366,
0.1444383562,
0.0968841091,
0.0332258083,
0.4142539799,
0.0406222902,
-0.1210481748,
0.0800513476,
-0.0464523286,
-0.2659545541,
0.1423851997,
-0.2800626457,
0.2248981595,
-0.2797551453,
-0.5559179187,
-0.2648307979,
0.4615186155,
0.2299832106,
-0.0591618568,
0.8147807717,
0.4416618347,
-0.3474493921,
-0.3195807636,
-0.2773577869,
-0.5794295669,
-0.4617916048,
0.1865372658,
-0.109074302,
-0.6733003855,
0.5043928027,
-0.195694983,
0.2933344543,
0.0630678385,
0.3958103955,
-0.4988746047,
1.1601381302,
1.0232747793,
0.624327004,
0.5060910583,
-0.538446486,
0.1144544408,
-0.6888886094,
-0.5954959989,
-0.1502339244,
-0.788230598,
-0.5716824532,
-0.3111874461,
0.6229314208,
0.137150079,
-0.405159086,
-0.0555035062,
-0.4578471184,
0.3077473938,
1.126778841,
0.3822632432,
0.1491914839,
-0.0956609249,
-0.2827005386,
-0.1681053489,
-0.8859967589,
-0.3639077842,
0.8037316799,
0.2353123277,
0.7013840079,
0.12385609,
0.8844083548,
0.506662488,
0.5881404281,
-1.0327465534,
0.7200154662,
0.1712886095,
-0.1716450751,
-0.6068660617,
-0.3673526049,
-0.9043313861,
0.0357347168,
-0.4367587864,
-0.794845283,
0.551109314,
0.4264165461,
-0.4560030103,
0.2134393156,
-0.7860843539,
0.6515122652,
-0.1015461087,
-0.6440159678,
-0.3077882528,
-0.9421473742,
0.1446878314,
-0.0203713682,
0.1382071674,
0.3538820744,
-0.0505359061,
0.8703311682,
-0.7857105136,
1.0389974117,
-0.488623172,
0.20192945,
0.3893403113,
0.3084305823,
0.7734948993,
0.0486679599,
0.1406859756,
-0.4737378657,
-0.4010817409,
-0.3460410833,
-0.820415616,
0.5018619299,
-0.8667986393,
-0.7078544497,
-0.3159351945,
-0.6157848835,
-0.4740433693,
0.0274312124,
0.266541779,
0.4049423933,
-0.1071043685,
-0.0510271303,
0.7737054825,
-0.1597544402,
0.4614636302,
0.7248212099,
-0.0948386416,
-0.3742361367,
1.1061403751,
0.5560075641,
0.0691495389,
0.423576653,
0.0604584925,
-0.1711402833,
-0.6665408015,
-0.2387991399,
-0.0565833896,
-0.8904122114,
-0.1276182383,
-0.4230450988,
-0.2564152181,
0.2265946269,
-0.4437630475,
-0.3378458023,
-0.4309223592,
-0.144336015,
-0.1276743263,
0.163706854,
1.0360797644,
-0.4477272928,
0.3912264705,
-0.6503791809,
-0.2813882232,
0.789463222,
0.0273892563,
0.4024204016,
-0.3627339303,
-0.4061287045,
0.2566635907,
-0.577118516,
-0.9347997904,
0.2225272357,
0.0926890746,
0.7590659857,
0.5944156051,
0.4616468251,
0.4011742771,
-0.5209715366,
0.6635026336,
0.0810092762,
-0.5455225706,
0.5963619947,
-0.1448163837,
0.028410919,
0.3346917927,
0.709477067,
-0.1286125332,
-0.5507876873,
-0.8663756251,
-0.7308108807,
0.8741290569,
0.1178779677,
-0.1438695043,
0.1810301989,
0.3750188351,
0.197041288,
0.3453674912,
-0.4749483168,
-0.2364577353,
-0.1042261571,
0.0302564986,
-0.1791601032,
-0.3262481093,
-0.37967816,
0.1301824898,
0.4947547317,
-0.1657663733,
0.6702250242,
0.1555013508,
-0.0218131039,
-0.1552854627,
0.1393100768,
0.8181436062,
0.6337476373,
-0.4039446712,
0.1629340947,
0.4139541686,
-0.4225702882,
0.2799361348,
0.0247158036,
0.0506863222,
-0.5506094694,
0.7535176873,
0.8789941669,
0.3914711475,
-0.5889773369,
0.4102876484,
-0.0943529904,
-0.2926171124,
-0.2488003671,
0.2606381476,
-0.2532662451,
0.7837975025,
0.6208590269,
0.3091111779,
0.3750306964,
-0.3111008108,
0.4390751719,
0.1370603442,
-0.7172986269,
-0.2785245776,
0.7240704894,
0.0884996578,
-0.7713532448,
0.9376820922,
-0.2740499079,
-0.4891174138,
0.74672997,
0.2912611067,
0.584995091,
-0.3057200313,
0.474829942,
0.3119954765,
0.1106048599,
0.3036724031,
0.0084137311,
-0.3175335228,
-0.4623999894,
-0.4215140641,
-0.3873826563,
-1.0564348698,
-0.2325694561,
-0.935692668,
-0.2655956745,
-0.7196657062,
-0.2538715303,
-0.0572648756,
0.1649423391,
-0.5293256044,
0.4406886995,
-0.0007986992,
0.6588928699,
-0.601282537,
0.4671973288,
0.9409204721,
-0.3773893416,
-1.0778867006,
0.2126115412,
0.0039847014,
-0.8648110628,
0.8596856594,
-0.0347911045,
-0.193437025,
0.3460778296,
-0.5373313427,
-0.6054050922,
0.9515600204,
0.3417316079,
-0.4322197437,
-0.0646771938,
-0.3169437647,
0.6229530573,
-0.2462332398,
0.4498442411,
0.0721124634,
0.5256909132,
0.342577666,
-0.6518772244,
-0.2231934518,
-0.0236181598,
-0.206550017,
0.0383996852,
-0.9352892637,
0.7229939699,
-0.6540415287,
0.0225031152,
-0.1968142688,
0.892784059,
0.1884283423,
0.5853641629,
0.4746817052,
0.4103908539,
0.6404903531,
-0.2447997928,
1.0435963869,
0.2021474689,
0.4507492185,
0.8973174095,
-0.0751852691,
0.9734161496,
0.3377664685,
-0.2853969932,
0.7076442242,
0.965066433,
0.1725593209,
0.7878200412,
0.0035175302,
-0.1542499065,
-0.421764195,
-0.2315875739,
-0.1439401358,
0.3904211819,
0.3178049326,
-0.0632755682,
-0.3032451868,
0.604444623,
-0.2977838814,
0.2168731093,
-0.4349712431,
0.9466664195,
0.0512830764,
-0.7204833627,
0.4179527462,
-0.0920834914,
0.040874891,
-0.4694431126,
-0.5125303864,
-0.3313732743,
0.3759902418,
-0.1096321344,
-0.8612476587,
-0.0498241298,
-0.3741177619,
-0.0810221657,
0.0284941513,
0.47718364,
-0.3999577761,
-0.0151677225,
0.1747429967,
0.3473398387,
0.2434884161,
0.5841247439,
-0.6119836569,
-0.0700782388,
-0.0034817143,
-0.7843683958,
0.5608494282,
0.1209545508,
-0.2257582098,
1.1231677532,
0.3480627835,
-0.2996242344,
0.017585272,
-0.5476938486,
0.8981099129,
-0.1956637949,
-0.6973057985,
-0.3355997205,
0.5786883831,
-0.1260291189,
0.1098691598,
0.7808405161,
0.3055244684,
0.7913712859,
-0.1524813026,
0.5311976075,
0.0952202603,
0.3608572781,
-0.6331091523,
0.2187594473,
-0.5102772713,
0.274077028,
0.13363038,
-0.9095330834,
-0.1180800721,
0.7329460382,
-0.8037705421,
0.3721819222,
0.6845053434,
0.3629387617,
-0.0026095933,
0.0361676589,
0.3308752179,
0.0880776569,
-0.0949067026,
0.6653144956,
1.0833444595,
-0.0110259606,
0.5244014859,
-0.3870349824,
-0.4599581063,
-0.4380431771,
-0.5754079819,
-0.8575124145,
-0.4106703997,
-0.2773729563,
-0.36462304,
0.3567428291,
0.6888548136,
0.7151588798,
-0.7534709573,
0.0656062588,
0.0719919205,
0.3001374304,
-0.6543709636,
-0.252304405,
0.5850433111,
-0.3625608087,
-1.0122215748,
0.4677619636,
0.1910024881,
0.3055671751,
-0.2542198896,
-0.404045105,
-0.0464072041,
0.152144745,
0.4054942429,
0.4178037345,
-0.4063442647,
-0.6189371943,
-0.0346849747,
0.0033707274,
0.0166653451,
0.6995331645,
-0.8991041183,
0.5335589051,
0.2906305194,
0.448748678,
0.736616075,
0.1452941,
0.5824397206,
-0.9831414819,
0.1377505064,
0.4164498746,
-0.1449832469,
-0.0359100699,
-0.5913181305,
0.6104471087,
0.2307073921,
-0.7829341292,
-0.9439046979,
0.2374263704,
-0.90727669,
-0.1803261787,
0.6716864109,
-0.5484808087,
-0.112684764,
0.1865752339,
-0.216130361,
0.0820036232,
-0.2185076326,
0.6219003201,
0.417584151,
-0.563579917,
-0.4254146218,
-0.5107249618,
0.5341363549,
0.2362263352,
-0.4943844378,
-0.3226265609,
0.5453461409,
0.0038023579,
0.2629156113,
0.5255197883,
0.4340288639,
0.3713481724,
0.4150900543,
0.0159862805,
-0.4061974883,
-0.7031854391,
-0.0733912438,
0.5333868861,
0.184080869,
-0.4078514278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09091v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09091v2
|
Semantic In-Domain Product Identification for Search Queries
| 2024-04-13T22:18:14 | 2024-05-29T16:01:27 |
Sanat Sharma, Jayant Kumar, Twisha Naik, Zhaoyu Lu, Arvind Srikantan, Tracy Holloway King
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Accurate explicit and implicit product identification in search queries is
critical for enhancing user experiences, especially at a company like Adobe
which has over 50 products and covers queries across hundreds of tools. In this
work, we present a novel approach to training a product classifier from user
behavioral data. Our semantic model led to >25% relative improvement in CTR
(click through rate) across the deployed surfaces; a >50% decrease in null
rate; a 2x increase in the app cards surfaced, which helps drive product
visibility.
|
[
-0.3383791149,
-0.616025269,
0.4861979783,
0.4267520607,
0.1007760093,
0.353872925,
0.2116406709,
-0.7873193622,
-0.1792511046,
0.4385526478,
-0.7479528785,
-0.8179940581,
-0.2355196327,
-0.262085259,
-0.5067667961,
0.6880034804,
0.0311287828,
-0.2110475302,
-0.4338231385,
-0.1359728128,
-0.426597923,
-0.4946685135,
-0.8022799492,
-0.2284037769,
0.4644952416,
0.3879554868,
0.8580459356,
0.1813284308,
0.425416708,
0.4426077306,
0.0230948068,
0.0899713933,
-0.3843440115,
0.1752805561,
-0.1776702553,
-0.475856781,
-0.0927818194,
-0.0467317998,
0.1303965151,
0.6689631939,
-0.055233229,
0.1267898679,
0.1602039933,
0.5830947757,
-0.8132458925,
0.2604328692,
-0.6366835237,
0.288610816,
-0.0193586797,
-0.3083461523,
-0.4929887056,
-0.3566411734,
0.2993488014,
-1.1397806406,
0.7724197507,
0.2074912339,
0.9086616039,
-0.0517022535,
-0.6638852954,
-0.2475944459,
-0.9649945498,
0.6704592705,
-0.4827651381,
0.7520798445,
0.281390518,
0.4707413316,
-0.6207441092,
-1.0146900415,
-0.8168936372,
-0.0349686444,
-0.150055334,
0.0328686908,
0.0932223126,
-0.0409094356,
0.283834964,
0.2189036906,
-0.6386187077,
-0.1340317428,
-0.5062758923,
-0.3621559143,
0.827172637,
0.3343718648,
0.4358105958,
0.3046659827,
-0.6463816166,
-0.0369006321,
-0.4125976562,
0.4048870504,
0.1649941951,
0.1881313771,
0.2813309431,
0.6458710432,
-0.6702767611,
0.7660742402,
0.3295581639,
-0.2393935621,
0.4742347002,
-0.2552480996,
-0.2232872844,
0.2958424389,
0.3696289957,
0.2612332404,
-0.0787439421,
-0.4151161313,
-0.4178802967,
0.0662168339,
0.4113073945,
-0.7873112559,
-0.0579762049,
0.168189168,
-0.4052456915,
-0.1191570833,
0.4431502223,
-0.2280588597,
-0.5743121505,
-0.4901384711,
0.7714289427,
-0.2982074916,
-0.0722102597,
0.3379001617,
-0.4817411005,
0.7489125133,
0.3489829302,
-0.7325597405,
0.7266276479,
0.9464760423,
0.5859860182,
-0.3324365914,
-0.0886166766,
-0.397806257,
0.4148587883,
-0.3945001066,
1.0087428093,
-0.7181234956,
-0.6943941712,
0.0898430049,
0.2790592611,
-0.3146071136,
-0.7912959456,
0.3934655786,
-1.2069826126,
0.1772653162,
-0.3936031163,
-0.6842234135,
-0.4323519468,
0.2988963425,
-0.8107088208,
1.1921855211,
0.1740581691,
-0.6131334305,
0.878238976,
-0.74548316,
-0.5690167546,
0.3657825589,
-0.0564121194,
-0.4412223697,
0.2729306221,
-0.042120859,
0.3292144835,
0.0535257049,
-0.0156786256,
-0.4143402576,
-0.3402493,
0.4183702171,
0.0085145701,
0.576335609,
0.3051860631,
-0.2932398915,
0.1275452375,
-0.9639012218,
-0.0829251185,
0.1960529983,
-0.4325968027,
-0.4525902271,
-0.1829481572,
0.3252072632,
0.4355773032,
0.2785835266,
-0.9727044702,
0.0409424007,
-0.4916165173,
-0.0732531548,
0.5780440569,
0.3356838524,
0.272290051,
-0.0970136523,
0.4216660261,
0.1501758695,
0.5732423067,
0.2341067791,
-0.8462548852,
-0.6477160454,
-0.1790857762,
0.1656192541,
0.2338278145,
-0.4235728383,
0.3243442476,
-0.4241246283,
-0.501639843,
0.0824615359,
0.2614769936,
0.2908844948,
0.8806512952,
0.0899728239,
-0.5936309695,
0.0624831691,
-0.7207614183,
-0.3526130319,
0.0215549506,
-0.3945313096,
0.7162761092,
0.4310567081,
-0.3387394249,
1.3614010811,
-0.6861691475,
-0.5783086419,
-0.0931154341,
0.4550091624,
0.1389988363,
0.1031410992,
0.4286060631,
-1.2572530508,
-0.772826314,
0.1494126469,
-0.4012682736,
-0.0346998982,
0.1093355939,
-0.2474217862,
0.3057510853,
0.5442029238,
-0.5276020169,
0.8060359359,
0.0330953673,
-0.5676084757,
0.2212277055,
-0.3079492152,
0.0794246122,
-0.7464951277,
0.0988080427,
0.3556536138,
0.0654504225,
-0.4569633603,
-0.2613380849,
0.0776686296,
-0.4615395665,
-1.1099076271,
0.66458565,
-0.234426558,
-0.3118264675,
-0.0724505708,
-0.0838225409,
0.2942606807,
0.5883725882,
0.240604043,
0.9989334345,
0.2809102535,
-1.1931555271,
0.3667952418,
0.6154789329,
-0.3829297721,
0.5907759666,
-0.8565433025,
-0.0493004471,
-0.2193236202,
0.2628403008,
-1.2670608759,
-0.1777081639,
0.0079009905,
-0.3570299447,
0.0361719467,
-0.1032262743,
-0.795927763,
-0.3315645754,
-0.3070167899,
0.3333941698,
0.2926491797,
-0.8962832689,
1.0055692196,
0.2432123274,
0.2794044614,
-0.200930208,
-0.3052497804,
-0.3575252891,
-0.4082820117,
-0.9158505797,
0.747798264,
0.0147338351,
0.1038591191,
0.023941258,
-0.3716134131,
-0.2536900043,
0.1615663618,
0.4773241282,
0.0855573863,
-0.093993865,
0.259159714,
-0.1820320934,
-0.4003120363,
0.0160210226,
-0.2404258698,
0.3722041547,
-0.0353087038,
-0.5053811669,
-0.6464373469,
0.1391352564,
0.3870019317,
-0.3371292353,
0.7369564772,
0.6872825027,
-0.3016604185,
-0.1913268566,
-0.4465172887,
-0.0329678804,
-0.6597304344,
0.0828636959,
-0.5714538097,
-0.3582768142,
0.679353416,
-0.3231292963,
-0.3893130124,
0.6760207415,
0.3375378549,
-0.0586989112,
1.6625779867,
1.0355465412,
0.0594598763,
0.5092122555,
-0.3935332894,
0.3411647081,
-0.5604237318,
-1.0417516232,
-0.5668928027,
-0.3641566932,
-0.5926046968,
-0.0199707597,
0.4575581253,
-0.1622665524,
-0.5569349527,
0.4298417866,
-0.4309196472,
0.2732422948,
0.9365692139,
0.4770626724,
0.1172961667,
0.0549580529,
-0.0839903206,
0.1000582427,
-0.4202034473,
-0.0875181109,
0.9751725793,
0.1939452291,
0.9463078976,
0.2627584934,
0.3529460132,
0.4633609951,
0.0440000519,
-0.8057022095,
0.5485377908,
0.0600961074,
-0.7535976768,
-0.147864297,
0.0443289205,
-0.9541817307,
-0.1359747499,
-0.1958506256,
-0.7730318308,
0.5803878903,
0.0148175126,
-0.4672748148,
-0.3339314163,
-0.7984305024,
1.1614428759,
-0.5892236829,
-0.5020181537,
-0.3120238185,
-0.5102367997,
-0.0886805281,
-0.2116777152,
-0.2075974345,
-0.1559927613,
-0.2394618243,
0.9241803885,
-0.8110098839,
0.6311151385,
-0.3758360744,
0.160494566,
0.1495486945,
-0.0805621743,
0.6441716552,
-0.1943428814,
0.2256924212,
-0.1716639847,
-0.091952242,
-0.4042328596,
-1.0664199591,
0.5420960784,
-0.5138679147,
-0.4442413151,
-0.4263395667,
-0.2083531618,
-0.6948993206,
0.33169958,
0.0368443616,
0.431535989,
-0.2087635398,
0.2517702281,
0.9380652308,
-0.4863773882,
0.3066818714,
0.7956945896,
-0.0536574386,
0.0336695798,
1.0104943514,
-0.2263344526,
-0.0664230511,
0.4321952462,
0.2340945899,
-0.8324340582,
-0.43143332,
0.0016137159,
0.2053128034,
-0.7899087071,
-0.0586008169,
-0.7559649348,
-0.2583025396,
-0.2204328179,
-0.0889978111,
-0.2570556402,
-0.1844350249,
-0.3441736698,
-0.1078845337,
0.5052998662,
0.7488650084,
0.4603405893,
0.69904989,
-0.5594751239,
0.3992097676,
0.5218874812,
0.7918447852,
-0.1959305406,
-0.3518670201,
-0.059690427,
-0.1238464192,
-0.4328228235,
-0.5011442304,
0.3414851725,
0.5506668091,
1.0629006624,
0.6456523538,
0.1687618792,
0.5922353268,
-0.1540243775,
0.8504452705,
-0.0262731984,
-0.6204457879,
0.5659195185,
-0.0496923104,
0.0896557719,
0.6505454183,
0.9640976191,
-0.372187525,
0.0622416772,
-0.6938099265,
-1.0857228041,
0.7479660511,
-0.0525176115,
0.2488021255,
0.0644547045,
0.0085861934,
0.1240981445,
0.1216092482,
-0.1138608381,
-0.1458339393,
-0.0012545106,
-0.1760131121,
0.1691671461,
-0.341140449,
0.1951869726,
-0.3385468125,
0.8758053184,
-0.1922485679,
0.1204562709,
0.055724062,
-0.4210323393,
0.3394402266,
-0.2720459402,
0.3035485148,
0.6947439313,
-0.2858497202,
-0.1696057469,
-0.1110814437,
-0.5963366032,
-0.1213452965,
-0.0851848423,
-0.0247283932,
-0.0439996123,
-0.125535816,
0.4458543062,
0.1826812327,
-0.5707482696,
0.8385393023,
-0.3460507989,
-0.15214324,
-0.3863953948,
0.106210269,
-0.3832525611,
0.2310982198,
0.3704517782,
-0.1527339369,
0.9021642804,
-0.5102492571,
0.4415163696,
0.574742794,
-0.6274396181,
-0.1929917783,
0.8607218862,
0.3393202424,
-0.2805775404,
0.8734994531,
0.047389783,
-0.613592267,
0.5733816624,
0.611468792,
1.115473032,
-0.0625666454,
0.316334784,
0.1619902402,
-0.3902847767,
-0.0359561853,
0.1937946975,
-0.566686213,
-0.8470945358,
0.0678054914,
-0.6261975169,
-0.4311667085,
0.0734175518,
-0.5413153768,
0.5153883696,
-0.3451484442,
-0.1849473268,
0.5176770687,
0.3380483091,
-0.8921464682,
0.5065843463,
0.1779657453,
1.0559533834,
-1.0334759951,
0.5642322898,
0.469725579,
-0.7502064109,
-0.5313818455,
-0.170511201,
0.0880332068,
-0.5948155522,
0.8923779726,
0.2526463866,
-0.4448816776,
-0.2659392357,
-0.4985874295,
-0.7703065872,
1.1691223383,
-0.1203047037,
0.0184369385,
0.3933976293,
0.5630014539,
0.6552664042,
-0.3980969489,
0.2603513598,
0.4880933166,
0.3542708457,
0.575745523,
-0.5499818325,
-0.1084954515,
-0.4832816422,
0.421664089,
-0.2393193692,
-0.1930392683,
0.2628052235,
0.1478070468,
-0.3613910079,
-0.1711688638,
0.6686165929,
0.1710135937,
0.7284936905,
0.4585638642,
0.3829843104,
0.7107702494,
0.1099013463,
1.0363274813,
-0.3514009118,
0.1325455159,
0.8735527396,
-0.3757238984,
0.8925786614,
0.2345749438,
-0.0271247625,
0.4193426669,
0.6449462175,
0.0473239794,
0.8738210797,
0.1025127992,
-0.5024897456,
-0.0732589364,
-0.2650240958,
-0.276684016,
0.2639016807,
0.4927742183,
-0.2884469628,
-0.1291258335,
0.1374672502,
-0.1772844642,
0.0541571304,
-0.1373141706,
1.1360909939,
-0.344278723,
-0.180228889,
0.4745256901,
0.0357013345,
0.6471420527,
-0.5095707178,
-0.0614266321,
-0.3775030375,
0.5466643572,
-0.5948175192,
-0.7863779068,
0.3030170202,
-0.4435946941,
-0.1074341685,
-0.0007600024,
0.8394771218,
-0.0438815169,
-0.590919733,
0.2515914142,
0.0796560124,
0.0342725478,
-0.5153402686,
-0.6904678345,
-0.0159766991,
-0.4546138644,
-0.4170285165,
0.124670513,
0.3543860614,
-0.5064280629,
0.8537176251,
0.6502243876,
-0.4295966923,
0.4240166843,
0.157134667,
0.8350400925,
-0.7019898295,
-0.5110512376,
-0.2907110751,
0.4165832996,
-0.4428749084,
-0.0348193608,
0.9726625085,
1.1603748798,
1.0841705799,
-0.2351065725,
0.6321154237,
0.101981014,
0.3821658492,
-0.0788742006,
0.7563242316,
-0.6126791835,
0.293200016,
-0.1194911748,
-0.9981154203,
-0.3801652193,
0.3456693292,
-0.424014926,
0.0881080553,
0.3863633573,
1.1186983585,
-0.5998615623,
-0.0407455079,
0.2379464358,
-0.1119653881,
0.4251509905,
0.1494897455,
0.7962340117,
-0.5366855264,
0.4198033512,
-0.4541610181,
-0.093629308,
-0.3568470776,
-0.6909262538,
-0.5237542987,
-0.6190081239,
-0.5231701732,
-0.2896155417,
-0.0198239647,
0.5467109084,
0.8604624271,
-0.9209077954,
-0.0296875257,
-0.2482586503,
-0.0612375066,
-0.4170270264,
-0.2461419702,
0.2923441827,
-0.4139366746,
-0.4026272297,
0.210728541,
0.1378261447,
0.0120767048,
0.0560021959,
-0.0675027817,
0.1464853436,
0.3504391015,
0.7464586496,
0.5733131766,
-0.4444285333,
-0.2372246087,
0.1049796417,
0.0810704455,
0.1885056198,
0.68108356,
-1.1306858063,
0.5173720717,
0.6545980573,
0.5439109206,
0.959882915,
0.3058698475,
0.5004992485,
-0.7919530272,
0.1435522586,
0.0016494504,
-0.0052002105,
0.2049298435,
-0.4090901315,
0.4377945662,
0.1950660795,
-0.1810439974,
-0.3932151198,
0.0532379821,
-1.2212712765,
-0.0829112083,
1.2030775547,
0.0178493187,
-0.6438828707,
-0.5590416193,
-0.2207601815,
-0.1713043451,
-0.3587044775,
0.7568840384,
-0.0014202201,
-0.2904498577,
0.3530949652,
-0.3438191414,
0.556185782,
-0.250203222,
-0.5643496513,
-0.3725066185,
0.4023739994,
0.4540559053,
0.0951589793,
0.4941838086,
-0.3176054955,
0.3378713131,
0.0119346986,
0.0686075091,
-0.0937512144,
-0.4603104591,
-0.1205269843,
0.1519643664,
0.2141093463,
-0.6196020246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09077v1
|
CuriousLLM: Elevating Multi-Document QA with Reasoning-Infused Knowledge Graph Prompting
| 2024-04-13T20:43:46 | 2024-04-13T20:43:46 |
Zukang Yang, Zixuan Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
In the field of Question Answering (QA), unifying large language models
(LLMs) with external databases has shown great success. However, these methods
often fall short in providing the advanced reasoning needed for complex QA
tasks. To address these issues, we improve over a novel approach called
Knowledge Graph Prompting (KGP), which combines knowledge graphs with a
LLM-based agent to improve reasoning and search accuracy. Nevertheless, the
original KGP framework necessitates costly fine-tuning with large datasets yet
still suffers from LLM hallucination. Therefore, we propose a reasoning-infused
LLM agent to enhance this framework. This agent mimics human curiosity to ask
follow-up questions to more efficiently navigate the search. This simple
modification significantly boosts the LLM performance in QA tasks without the
high costs and latency associated with the initial KGP framework. Our ultimate
goal is to further develop this approach, leading to more accurate, faster, and
cost-effective solutions in the QA domain.
|
[
-0.5065540075,
-0.8204169273,
1.0232585669,
-0.1489183307,
0.0091585284,
0.344700247,
0.1379764527,
-0.3180172145,
0.3133659661,
0.534802258,
-0.8007509708,
-0.5835331678,
-0.2657724321,
0.1457654834,
-0.0671088621,
0.386416167,
0.0579597391,
-0.1828352064,
-0.5118636489,
-0.0451549962,
-0.6192212105,
-0.206611529,
-0.7991746068,
-0.4719839096,
0.8967618346,
0.4517832994,
0.8432899714,
0.1717922688,
-0.0709278136,
0.2481395006,
-0.002803134,
0.9816249609,
-0.5225849152,
0.4357031882,
-0.120309554,
-0.824681282,
-0.327947557,
-0.1261533797,
0.3282966018,
0.5182522535,
-0.0093556745,
-0.1749768257,
-0.1956081688,
0.8131789565,
-0.3766178191,
0.400043726,
-0.3857929707,
-0.1559206545,
0.2578003407,
-0.5799030662,
-0.4483406842,
-0.5665808916,
0.1185143292,
-0.8869789243,
0.0532695763,
0.2083311826,
0.7425841689,
0.3898261487,
-0.5052446723,
-0.2628709674,
-0.4193748236,
0.0311406385,
-0.5674001575,
0.6155354977,
0.3189946711,
0.1914070547,
-0.4040539265,
-0.8967007399,
-0.8471871018,
-0.1982571781,
-0.0476305559,
0.2405674011,
-0.1010334566,
0.0212533567,
0.3512102962,
-0.0586065613,
-0.5964632034,
-0.0852372944,
0.0172488615,
-0.1349297613,
0.4782091975,
0.1316038966,
0.4922417104,
0.0530257411,
-0.0721851513,
-0.1473483145,
-0.7320894003,
0.1934410036,
0.3573563695,
0.1958364844,
0.3074547052,
0.6613990664,
-0.6465787292,
0.6980759501,
0.1224104166,
0.0943804756,
0.1300734878,
-0.1200537235,
0.0913876519,
-0.1111947969,
0.5180286169,
0.5731039643,
0.2400225103,
-0.3255885839,
0.0961832777,
-0.1856686771,
0.3671855628,
-0.8197385073,
-0.3831197321,
0.6991620064,
0.1028964147,
-0.0975101069,
-0.0966151729,
-0.4773977995,
-0.6696878672,
-0.1431250125,
0.4720373452,
-0.6202527881,
-0.1657003313,
0.2749844491,
-0.2271386683,
0.2721593678,
0.5870446563,
-0.6745502949,
-0.2528935969,
0.4754454195,
0.3759328127,
-0.1504041255,
-0.432302624,
-0.5983582139,
0.2084072679,
-0.5069631934,
1.1612861156,
-0.5662454367,
-0.4364801943,
0.1180656999,
-0.0342686251,
-0.1125398055,
-0.4519257545,
0.5251290798,
-1.2090804577,
0.5180234313,
-0.6524609327,
-0.6131638885,
-0.4904046059,
0.8503312469,
-0.4285701513,
1.3106844425,
0.4737302363,
-0.7329542041,
0.3399342299,
-0.7368337512,
-0.1886068285,
0.4047295153,
-0.1289781332,
0.0429127999,
-0.3942262828,
0.6409617662,
0.4516995251,
-0.2035909742,
0.1037663668,
-0.3955258429,
-0.2375028133,
0.3374712467,
-0.0422548689,
0.5281634927,
0.0573805086,
0.149010241,
0.2555846572,
-0.5524680018,
0.5662918687,
0.2247491032,
-0.4003326297,
-0.3364568949,
-0.2529298067,
-0.5723281503,
0.2594808936,
0.3889977336,
-0.2529321313,
0.5493402481,
-0.4425407052,
0.0393496342,
0.5702199936,
0.1910994798,
0.3140601814,
-0.6316959858,
0.8001449108,
-0.2352691442,
0.0396971777,
-0.1295609027,
-0.8514468074,
-0.6665296555,
-0.218123883,
0.0133343562,
0.5523626208,
-1.1145921946,
0.0172586553,
-0.2380984724,
-0.4699405134,
-0.6588208675,
0.1022052839,
0.0686509013,
0.7337543964,
0.3731170297,
0.060215503,
-0.0661797523,
-0.4648624063,
-0.2068102658,
-0.3780672848,
-0.135729149,
0.6971731186,
-0.0981826186,
-0.4873919785,
1.1125228405,
-0.9096266031,
-0.0876313522,
-0.3373716176,
-0.0084119877,
0.2958250046,
0.0486653745,
0.3609383702,
-0.8423218727,
-0.6572586894,
0.0414774716,
-0.7725870013,
-0.3267564476,
0.1207661703,
-0.3859358132,
-0.1492881179,
0.4754206836,
-1.1373901367,
-0.0362133868,
-0.0408805571,
-0.3815066218,
0.6138170958,
-0.2524065673,
0.4724294543,
-1.0701856613,
-0.118472971,
-0.5240371227,
-0.0332036018,
-0.710467279,
0.4767768085,
0.2400949448,
-0.1941397786,
-0.4512293935,
0.7464883327,
-0.4421278834,
0.1892316788,
-0.2501671016,
0.5151461959,
0.4465776384,
0.5170052648,
-0.244536981,
0.9743074179,
0.6072359681,
-0.7254982591,
0.6216129661,
0.4943511188,
0.2647399306,
0.575429976,
-0.4363264441,
0.5512342453,
-0.3445377946,
0.166622147,
-0.9583646059,
-0.3890138865,
0.2958357036,
-0.5417467356,
0.3999658525,
-0.1044148505,
-0.7936241627,
-0.5787410736,
-0.4194050729,
0.0584283844,
0.3107596934,
-0.7305868268,
0.9422056079,
0.0268927962,
-0.1433845907,
-0.4726512432,
-0.1611540467,
0.1606226563,
-0.0487456955,
-1.0297847986,
0.0161212534,
-0.377141118,
-0.0152753461,
-0.0338643342,
0.0183527898,
0.0209007282,
0.225157693,
0.0969926789,
0.2937287986,
-0.1570639014,
0.351680249,
0.2384473681,
-0.0109478626,
0.2463728786,
-0.6753624678,
0.6034898162,
-0.0054671769,
-0.4952741265,
-0.2196965069,
0.3296492398,
0.4260107875,
-0.201161623,
0.3168586195,
0.5244485736,
-0.185317114,
-0.3903706074,
-0.6295317411,
-0.4167970121,
-0.4935319126,
0.2624889612,
-0.6948309541,
-1.0980250835,
0.5634695888,
-0.3879005313,
-0.2294583023,
0.2965407372,
0.5740753412,
-0.1861693859,
1.0814958811,
0.3581548929,
0.1440563649,
0.0498422235,
-0.1158098355,
0.2355816066,
-0.6764625907,
-0.5338237286,
-0.4418396354,
0.1241721511,
-0.3511086702,
-0.6884341836,
0.5069936514,
0.1832819432,
0.286357075,
-0.0532934107,
-0.5025978684,
0.6239740252,
0.5553749204,
0.0194739662,
0.367394805,
-0.2821157575,
-0.4576292038,
0.2742281258,
-0.9684092999,
-0.3096524179,
1.0054439306,
-0.0438215248,
0.6455020905,
0.2369622439,
0.6105765104,
0.2418243736,
0.277759403,
-0.7182154655,
0.5956614017,
0.5064306855,
-0.4611739218,
-0.5185008049,
-0.2707545161,
-1.1160923243,
0.3632407784,
-0.1567177325,
-0.7955419421,
0.0750341117,
0.0868222564,
-0.4210419357,
0.092537798,
-0.7402766347,
0.5674299598,
0.0477030575,
-0.2546428442,
-0.0602059066,
-0.5665054917,
0.35334602,
0.0403876975,
-0.0914554074,
-0.045553349,
0.0041222409,
0.3347868323,
-0.3173838556,
0.5202898979,
-0.0895821005,
-0.3362500072,
0.3829966784,
0.1811970472,
1.0599678755,
0.2142433971,
-0.0623511896,
-0.5248522758,
-0.0885579214,
-0.3300646544,
-0.9718516469,
0.7404871583,
-0.6021224856,
-1.0053926706,
-0.0976520926,
-1.0084232092,
-0.8935194016,
0.4817485511,
-0.1136972234,
0.1439493448,
0.0803080946,
-0.151188463,
1.0396922827,
-0.0918434337,
-0.0044168904,
0.8620573878,
-0.6159831285,
-0.0785712972,
0.916161418,
-0.0142110633,
0.1845189333,
0.6262338758,
0.2664010525,
-0.7781711817,
-0.5259407163,
-0.566095531,
0.2685912251,
-0.9045020342,
0.0243051946,
-1.1876605749,
0.0160702653,
-0.6684384942,
-0.1181394383,
0.029204132,
-0.3343804479,
-0.445168972,
-0.2414459735,
0.5468575954,
0.4495016634,
0.3544264436,
-0.0048228926,
-0.9477867484,
0.5450124741,
0.9135276675,
0.1407446712,
-0.0102474717,
-0.357853055,
-0.0277409721,
-0.196629554,
-0.1224674061,
-1.0065481663,
0.2835754454,
-0.2683945894,
0.657356739,
0.3399733901,
0.4143278897,
0.3233263195,
-0.0778313205,
0.5032151937,
-0.1573227793,
-0.4343881607,
0.40679726,
-0.5612092018,
0.4586888552,
0.4803632498,
0.4373954535,
-0.5927121639,
-0.7073364258,
-0.5500453711,
-0.7029304504,
0.5827002525,
-0.0221546274,
0.0210101139,
0.0159883611,
0.4055791199,
0.0274134278,
0.2828114331,
-0.2040527612,
-0.2477838099,
-0.135068804,
0.0861029997,
0.2650672793,
-0.2899392247,
-0.3492406607,
0.0016914892,
0.7842395306,
-0.8343275189,
0.0804489702,
0.466479063,
-0.0945859775,
0.0701480359,
0.4817198813,
0.349903971,
0.6920676827,
-0.3384099603,
0.1920101643,
0.2583018243,
-0.2596037388,
0.0918710232,
0.421875,
-0.3703871369,
-0.2041911185,
-0.0394577384,
0.5433717966,
-0.1925647259,
-0.8049790263,
0.3741743565,
-0.0981512889,
-0.1743799746,
0.142261222,
0.3605757654,
0.6442729831,
0.5393877625,
0.5840893984,
-0.3899039924,
0.1031317413,
-0.3780932128,
0.1181949824,
0.348495543,
-0.4683541358,
0.0886909887,
0.77148664,
0.103585206,
-0.278458178,
0.5837942958,
-0.5916609168,
-0.6588562727,
0.6314982176,
0.3183266521,
0.7984995842,
0.1279190928,
0.5663679242,
-0.0680307522,
0.4389004707,
0.1365797073,
0.7086225748,
0.0085179517,
-0.9312257767,
-0.4621899426,
-0.1056088805,
-0.7123740911,
-0.1569322795,
-0.2359981686,
0.0056480113,
-0.1645955294,
0.0967326462,
-0.1110946909,
0.1499655843,
-0.5022425056,
0.2371048927,
-0.137230739,
0.9082199931,
-0.35533759,
0.8857315183,
0.751394093,
-0.4671514928,
-1.243044138,
0.0408221595,
-0.1464798898,
-0.9186949134,
0.3182739615,
0.2238024771,
-0.1952821165,
0.364700526,
-0.5047608018,
-0.5670040846,
1.4153096676,
0.362862587,
-0.2160180807,
-0.0168316662,
0.0412791371,
0.579647541,
-0.2830649316,
0.382037431,
0.264732331,
0.6615613699,
0.2101793587,
-0.2744822204,
0.4174466133,
-0.2327955812,
-0.3459951282,
0.1138982326,
-0.8545444012,
0.5767999291,
-0.6457138658,
-0.159173727,
-0.206392929,
0.5911111236,
0.5618569851,
0.6088705659,
0.4360414445,
0.4871622026,
1.3613843918,
0.0741482377,
1.1678802967,
-0.429938823,
0.0174626932,
0.9885055423,
-0.6088563204,
0.4057870805,
0.4096345901,
-0.3440837264,
0.3653683662,
0.7033495307,
0.2328782082,
0.1306103468,
-0.0786619037,
-0.3160916567,
-0.5147947669,
-0.4295504391,
-0.4946496189,
-0.098249808,
0.1123942435,
0.1230511963,
-0.1413640529,
-0.2147497982,
-0.0256484225,
0.0260261502,
-0.1471690238,
0.6547163725,
-0.0281068068,
-0.8606402278,
0.4016054273,
-0.1531923264,
0.1934072524,
-0.7783896327,
0.0310070664,
-0.4657412767,
-0.341607362,
-0.1900799721,
-0.8409869671,
-0.2034906149,
-0.4901181757,
-0.2593670487,
-0.1649727821,
0.9784879684,
-0.5799319148,
-0.0686092526,
0.348721087,
1.0479582548,
0.0652107596,
-0.4610621035,
-0.5874204636,
-0.4768432081,
0.0592161119,
-0.3465709984,
0.3706923127,
0.7297306061,
-0.0952956304,
1.2190691233,
1.0402699709,
-0.1838423759,
0.0537327342,
0.461922437,
1.2658696175,
-0.5722976327,
-0.6713266373,
-0.3684280515,
0.3255095482,
-0.0961403996,
-0.0934056267,
0.8649819493,
0.4906362891,
0.4573641717,
-0.042720452,
0.5496452451,
0.1689894497,
0.5045874119,
-0.66310817,
0.7424388528,
-0.6293478608,
0.3454779088,
-0.0454154685,
-0.6409957409,
-0.1062020287,
-0.1336690187,
0.0072788997,
-0.0393770486,
0.890604496,
1.1309432983,
0.2467799634,
0.0019990685,
0.5323486924,
0.2398916185,
0.3810864985,
0.3962955773,
1.0460962057,
0.0774495676,
0.6028969884,
0.0206458494,
0.0245806873,
-0.335824281,
-0.6811128855,
-0.9289574027,
-0.3115322292,
-0.3144516349,
-0.5217356086,
-0.0157743227,
0.8213047385,
0.3885656595,
-0.4375414848,
0.4330233634,
0.0102928868,
0.7064372897,
-0.2617414594,
-0.2854041159,
0.4378861487,
-0.4575183988,
-0.5730505586,
0.7232334018,
0.4566374123,
0.0230108835,
-0.3703441024,
-0.2761569023,
-0.4239042401,
0.2538926899,
0.5349515676,
0.3103143871,
-0.5254665613,
-0.2816080749,
0.3270097673,
-0.1869997233,
0.1759508252,
0.5915033817,
-0.9560285807,
0.8063458204,
0.6862262487,
1.0137109756,
0.6500666142,
-0.0357167237,
0.5583856702,
-0.5789586902,
-0.2591255009,
0.2596710324,
0.0820225403,
0.3035770953,
-0.724006474,
0.6061052084,
0.3600802422,
-0.3739280999,
-0.6442183256,
0.2608597875,
-1.058485508,
-0.2602196634,
1.1837104559,
-0.2002890855,
-0.1049957275,
-0.417368263,
-0.5590618849,
0.1245474666,
-0.604405582,
0.814045608,
0.7316907048,
-0.3376661539,
-0.3461575508,
-0.3559924066,
0.4311272204,
0.4232635498,
-1.1893947124,
0.0024842685,
0.5124586225,
0.1187949777,
0.1615044326,
0.921931088,
0.1631889939,
0.4665598571,
-0.0399800017,
0.0005905618,
-0.3887366354,
-0.1804999411,
0.0451811738,
0.5675584674,
0.4107940197,
0.093502827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09066v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09066v1
|
CodeCloak: A Method for Evaluating and Mitigating Code Leakage by LLM Code Assistants
| 2024-04-13T19:30:58 | 2024-04-13T19:30:58 |
Amit Finkman, Eden Bar-Kochva, Avishag Shapira, Dudu Mimran, Yuval Elovici, Asaf Shabtai
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
LLM-based code assistants are becoming increasingly popular among developers.
These tools help developers improve their coding efficiency and reduce errors
by providing real-time suggestions based on the developer's codebase. While
beneficial, these tools might inadvertently expose the developer's proprietary
code to the code assistant service provider during the development process. In
this work, we propose two complementary methods to mitigate the risk of code
leakage when using LLM-based code assistants. The first is a technique for
reconstructing a developer's original codebase from code segments sent to the
code assistant service (i.e., prompts) during the development process, enabling
assessment and evaluation of the extent of code leakage to third parties (or
adversaries). The second is CodeCloak, a novel deep reinforcement learning
agent that manipulates the prompts before sending them to the code assistant
service. CodeCloak aims to achieve the following two contradictory goals: (i)
minimizing code leakage, while (ii) preserving relevant and useful suggestions
for the developer. Our evaluation, employing GitHub Copilot, StarCoder, and
CodeLlama LLM-based code assistants models, demonstrates the effectiveness of
our CodeCloak approach on a diverse set of code repositories of varying sizes,
as well as its transferability across different models. In addition, we
generate a realistic simulated coding environment to thoroughly analyze code
leakage risks and evaluate the effectiveness of our proposed mitigation
techniques under practical development scenarios.
|
[
-0.25599581,
-0.583681643,
0.340405345,
0.3501463234,
-0.3860096335,
0.5889691114,
-0.0786744952,
-0.4774858057,
0.334626466,
0.7736859322,
-0.6577992439,
-0.4896112382,
-0.3530991673,
-0.0080874134,
-0.1222659945,
0.8657690883,
-0.3067605197,
-0.154576242,
-0.4306429625,
0.1354386061,
-0.7709973454,
-0.3718259335,
-0.7561873794,
-0.0623068325,
0.1591090113,
0.4947270453,
0.5256554484,
0.3990572691,
0.4409065843,
0.2501059771,
0.1046261787,
0.0959790498,
-0.434895128,
0.1254564673,
0.2513350546,
-0.5492709279,
-0.3972485363,
-0.1980051249,
-0.1045173854,
0.0121894199,
-0.2099453658,
0.2718416154,
0.0421903878,
0.7446708083,
-0.7847240567,
0.0595900714,
-0.4526245594,
0.2761719227,
0.0428907722,
-0.4333053827,
-0.3737858832,
-0.6187348366,
-0.1308105886,
-0.6027714014,
-0.2108863294,
-0.2437981963,
0.2197582275,
0.5275657177,
0.0430916734,
-0.7469819784,
-0.5065700412,
0.4302988052,
-0.6622177362,
-0.0670316741,
0.4099606872,
0.3159722984,
-0.016340008,
-0.2950835526,
-0.3758101165,
-0.6367330551,
0.1409393996,
0.0873118266,
-0.0472147502,
-0.1161935776,
-0.0902648345,
0.3233439624,
-0.6442730427,
0.0014631427,
-0.3807739913,
-0.5153301358,
0.6666043401,
0.091879636,
0.4477814138,
0.1683740467,
-0.8423321247,
-0.1760955751,
-0.8899496198,
0.2606811821,
0.5841926932,
-0.1428378969,
-0.0259464402,
0.2265457362,
0.0597172566,
0.3336283565,
-0.1222037449,
-0.1225478947,
0.3330216408,
-0.2631270885,
-0.0379988551,
0.0851500481,
0.4536877573,
0.1972081512,
0.1871682405,
-0.2676449716,
-0.286408782,
0.13043046,
0.4341298044,
-0.3963245153,
-0.3412112296,
0.2349001914,
-0.4325597584,
-0.8437713981,
0.2199370861,
-0.8135293722,
-0.6477461457,
0.0060557248,
0.1077728719,
-0.0463558249,
-0.3525024056,
-0.1027375832,
0.0238316469,
0.2243825197,
0.2465878278,
-0.5376768708,
0.2470730245,
0.8062315583,
0.7006472945,
-0.5313621759,
-0.2267945409,
-0.5437002182,
0.1662913561,
-0.4725259542,
0.6950641274,
-0.3936920166,
-0.8501368761,
0.2356515229,
-0.0892043114,
0.3277046382,
-0.6638026237,
0.0809776261,
-0.6729406714,
-0.4390056729,
0.0955836028,
-0.3731393516,
0.1368008256,
0.3205782771,
-0.7797522545,
0.6856406927,
0.0448387414,
-0.1555279493,
0.0250369776,
-0.5480379462,
-0.346005708,
-0.0480064563,
-0.18985264,
-0.3122486472,
-0.0745074674,
0.40573138,
0.3385152817,
0.1962996125,
-0.0205099192,
-0.1658883542,
-0.538282454,
0.5240049362,
-0.4707620442,
0.7409927845,
0.3670711815,
-0.278396368,
0.148676157,
-0.4566126764,
-0.0130057819,
-0.0313108824,
-0.5077869892,
-0.2270751745,
-0.6252556443,
-0.4299894869,
0.0893088356,
0.3529706597,
-0.3865567446,
0.5926539302,
-0.2545906901,
0.1134954914,
0.9429326653,
0.2475498021,
0.5715180635,
-0.3749405742,
1.1261594296,
-0.3115568459,
0.3892337084,
-0.2913053632,
-0.4061215818,
-0.3132516146,
-0.2947412729,
0.1820810288,
0.7135673761,
-1.0701528788,
0.081771642,
-0.1362470537,
-0.504196167,
-0.5462140441,
0.680773735,
0.8201480508,
0.2728859484,
0.1170309633,
-0.2801336944,
-0.2822448313,
-0.60068959,
-0.2683327794,
-0.1093914583,
0.0897368193,
0.2954847217,
0.2558430433,
-0.3913061619,
0.5802070498,
-0.4810450077,
-0.0786801577,
-0.1886755526,
-0.1290943176,
-0.1024291441,
0.6027417183,
0.3482749164,
-0.5844163895,
-0.2688800693,
-0.1368464082,
-0.4674105048,
-0.2009785175,
-0.3634241521,
-0.1244193688,
0.2997508347,
0.7192780375,
-0.4170847535,
0.6357876658,
0.8468998671,
-0.3113549352,
0.6558116078,
-0.2570485175,
0.0947245508,
-0.7457580566,
0.0739055648,
-0.6587793827,
-0.2594271898,
-0.3150424063,
0.1750377566,
0.066722028,
-0.3716697991,
-0.6895009279,
0.4951242805,
-0.4386889637,
-0.24262923,
-0.418263793,
0.0516144484,
0.1194936782,
0.5416475534,
-0.2035456747,
1.2457017899,
0.217111662,
-0.7199972868,
0.3869878352,
0.1659518927,
-0.1183266342,
0.0350800604,
-0.5317917466,
0.6377808452,
0.3940306902,
0.3752805591,
-0.792968452,
0.2538586557,
0.6000676751,
-0.6054245234,
0.200841099,
-0.2891943455,
-0.3052345514,
-0.149118796,
-0.8349522352,
0.3056373298,
0.4835238755,
-0.7199694514,
0.2298996449,
0.4381347895,
-0.329188168,
-0.7799997926,
-0.8561303616,
0.0650860295,
-0.183209464,
-0.6643142104,
0.3437469602,
-0.2976490855,
-0.1712674946,
0.1096198112,
-0.446759522,
-0.0929195359,
0.4271314144,
0.5794918537,
0.4810143113,
-0.0012441817,
0.0853824988,
0.0395643301,
-0.5076670051,
0.2442234904,
-0.0832245499,
0.4193827808,
-0.1776854992,
-0.4838199317,
-0.1627617925,
0.2099924088,
0.3398948312,
-0.2630349696,
0.3655661941,
0.3137334585,
0.0149360634,
-0.3329188526,
-0.3960995376,
-0.0441654846,
-0.5145757794,
0.0687926486,
-0.296656251,
-0.6231316924,
0.5347903967,
-0.4431305826,
-0.0469472297,
-0.0631498769,
0.460806936,
0.0106622083,
0.3974035084,
0.7816104293,
-0.2621916533,
0.5916888714,
-0.5562036037,
0.0109472908,
-0.870326817,
-0.071428813,
-0.177047208,
-0.0318423286,
-0.2039626539,
-0.515644908,
0.1370691806,
0.1453376859,
0.2167449743,
0.5804837346,
-0.4778669775,
0.6024034023,
0.4462931156,
0.1099545285,
0.3355747759,
-0.0959277824,
-0.0040308172,
0.498180002,
-0.4852743447,
-0.6465470195,
1.1228957176,
0.5759986639,
0.8551553488,
0.1499644518,
1.0296400785,
0.485787034,
0.3041678667,
-0.4513709247,
0.4335335493,
0.2157740146,
-0.3515192568,
-0.3004866242,
-0.2813424766,
-0.8265890479,
-0.0381373316,
0.1242500469,
-0.4938929975,
0.3450125456,
0.3811301589,
-0.4487138391,
0.124000974,
-0.7457112074,
0.7867782712,
-0.1371468902,
-0.1951473057,
-0.2524476051,
-0.2777786851,
0.4948067069,
-0.0396869034,
0.1815518737,
0.0468660071,
-0.4856657386,
0.5525423884,
-0.3942882121,
0.7562861443,
-0.3165570796,
-0.3841749728,
0.6317310333,
0.6363062859,
0.79341501,
0.5012551546,
0.0028851649,
0.1447140425,
-0.0245058816,
-0.3729480207,
-0.6893620491,
0.7435565591,
-0.6852961779,
-0.4567584693,
-0.1485772431,
-0.4001350999,
-0.2390183359,
-0.130528301,
0.1173248142,
0.2058663219,
-0.0331392102,
0.0407130271,
0.4730961621,
-0.5063854456,
0.5452013612,
0.4526377618,
-0.2899768651,
-0.4295863211,
0.9266299009,
-0.4385741353,
0.3260360062,
0.1147788242,
0.2241304815,
0.0605490915,
-0.6456947327,
-0.2459782809,
-0.1081287116,
-0.709351778,
-0.5625650287,
-0.0851750374,
0.0219323486,
-0.2532491386,
-0.4539993107,
-0.2892951369,
-0.3099697232,
0.0402961075,
-0.2759860754,
0.3965146244,
0.4430017173,
-0.004130485,
0.2273187637,
-0.8007717729,
0.2960296571,
0.2944393456,
0.2927685082,
-0.1323078722,
-0.1578586549,
-0.1335532069,
-0.0388248712,
-0.1122794226,
-0.8738646507,
0.444933027,
-0.346853286,
0.6516525745,
0.2515877783,
0.1189066023,
0.4072597623,
-0.1484965533,
0.8942139149,
0.003652724,
-0.8605977297,
0.7875300646,
-0.102760829,
0.0796820447,
0.8796931505,
-0.2188186646,
-0.2533301115,
-0.4251178205,
-0.6341192722,
-0.8646094799,
0.3737669289,
0.3063957989,
0.0854186416,
0.1752290279,
0.3090444207,
0.2957237363,
0.3817672133,
-0.6018967628,
-0.1497829109,
-0.1820997894,
-0.0567293242,
0.080786705,
-0.246197775,
-0.2836816609,
0.2854965627,
0.4935896993,
-0.0992309228,
0.3056131303,
0.2650237978,
-0.6309778094,
0.1248659343,
0.2521925271,
0.9373524189,
0.6053309441,
0.040150173,
0.1786038429,
0.2358512878,
-0.8520418406,
0.1405132115,
-0.1779795289,
-0.0534505434,
-0.1673485935,
0.5910944939,
0.3739568889,
0.3063869774,
-0.8663113713,
0.6042003632,
0.0531549528,
0.0806230307,
-0.4992710948,
0.2733229697,
0.0386591926,
0.1938192397,
0.2318027765,
0.3880566359,
0.2256581187,
-0.585860312,
0.2604117393,
0.1588488668,
-0.2825663388,
-0.0580673628,
0.1909891665,
0.4860294759,
-0.4712015092,
0.2170993984,
-0.2698898613,
-0.4704510272,
1.2019541264,
0.3792639673,
1.0389157534,
-0.2092908025,
0.1819912344,
-0.1788820624,
0.3688363731,
0.2700330019,
0.1266447604,
-0.1813115627,
-0.4289247394,
-0.2407132238,
-0.0095827486,
-0.3924025595,
-0.1513422281,
-0.4238784611,
0.0111411791,
-0.6170548201,
0.1728103608,
-0.4925772846,
0.1732420772,
-0.5389662981,
-0.4384050667,
0.2377038896,
1.1540220976,
-0.5046391487,
0.8361929059,
0.4588833749,
-0.4787690043,
-0.674700439,
0.2717733979,
0.183978647,
-1.2253698111,
0.5422728658,
0.0508146808,
-0.3399873376,
-0.4194708765,
-0.4560868442,
-0.6193042397,
1.4690444469,
0.3687468171,
-0.4740285277,
0.3786377907,
-0.0459778421,
0.2853488028,
-0.356289506,
0.092686519,
0.4851146042,
0.4136379361,
-0.2968531549,
-0.6725330949,
0.2503011525,
-0.2300562859,
0.1796283722,
-0.1007975191,
-0.343737483,
0.3658044338,
-0.3243800104,
0.0229012109,
0.1982029676,
0.2005085349,
0.5268188119,
0.4866999984,
0.6020897627,
0.0610083342,
0.686009407,
0.512744844,
1.1006647348,
-0.4891879559,
0.1334914565,
0.8603309989,
-0.035862077,
0.7059144974,
0.6060334444,
-0.1178438142,
0.3375987113,
0.3679533601,
0.0571629405,
0.776047945,
0.3915328979,
-0.1847106069,
0.3228984773,
0.1649233699,
-0.4090531766,
0.0842637941,
0.236495629,
-0.0065897568,
0.0036622435,
0.1420781761,
0.1464954615,
0.1796432585,
-0.2607581913,
0.9008036256,
0.1223765388,
-0.5385283232,
0.398481369,
-0.330896914,
0.689137578,
-0.4452504516,
-0.2269281596,
-0.5027605891,
0.1413076371,
-0.1485287398,
-0.6657723784,
0.4412848651,
0.0572051071,
0.2623810768,
-0.1869781464,
0.9009411335,
-0.2377693653,
-0.0515093543,
0.341763854,
0.1972361803,
0.1006429717,
-0.028433051,
-0.8367027044,
0.4576576948,
0.0975442156,
-0.1288003474,
0.2592293322,
0.1714500189,
0.2444271147,
0.8619940281,
0.7831955552,
0.223904416,
0.1403195113,
-0.0918650627,
0.8979541659,
-0.3328699768,
-0.6117178202,
-0.714535296,
0.3624296486,
-0.0686271265,
-0.3602443337,
0.6706818938,
0.4421837032,
0.525764823,
-0.4132939875,
0.5682215691,
0.30019328,
0.0492812805,
-0.8571707606,
0.4159859419,
0.1305131614,
0.9137154818,
-0.3899598122,
-0.6391425729,
-0.1231920943,
0.4074621499,
-0.2714485228,
-0.1343321502,
0.5658146739,
0.8970168829,
0.2208405733,
-0.2063214034,
0.2312677056,
-0.1106811091,
0.3876255453,
0.7454788089,
0.9786833525,
-0.2360644341,
1.0922509432,
-0.5082831979,
-0.3183416128,
-0.397818923,
-0.7353191376,
-0.7497810125,
-0.1153212711,
-0.3917618394,
-0.2086291015,
0.2610999048,
0.5648559928,
0.6626814008,
-0.6245660186,
0.0240873825,
-0.2863810956,
0.4268699288,
-0.4823690951,
-0.238045156,
0.2495626509,
-0.3744502366,
-0.1217124313,
0.543587625,
0.1047838554,
-0.103360936,
-0.5742555857,
-0.3188435435,
0.3754712045,
-0.0945496336,
0.3059148788,
0.4964921772,
-0.6086323261,
-0.2254477441,
0.0687653571,
-0.1696415395,
-0.0301493742,
1.0496331453,
-1.0039105415,
0.1667883843,
0.3844233453,
0.9588393569,
0.2480240315,
0.0784938484,
0.6362779737,
-0.9313697815,
0.315531075,
0.3163073063,
0.107510142,
-0.0762646496,
-0.89539814,
0.6335872412,
-0.3261171579,
-0.4495762289,
-0.7349643707,
0.1416282803,
-0.8020540476,
-0.5266343355,
0.9490707517,
-0.365906179,
-0.0637319982,
-0.112331301,
-0.4832009077,
-0.142227903,
-0.5774355531,
0.7309405804,
0.3562600613,
-0.0743388608,
-0.3040332794,
-0.7527908087,
0.7655417323,
0.0136747127,
-0.998246789,
0.1072257832,
0.0668293387,
0.2681573927,
0.2525963783,
0.6265928745,
-0.2721078992,
0.5562365055,
0.1185760722,
0.2152130157,
-0.5796527267,
-0.3401162028,
-0.6940230727,
0.0043556136,
-0.0410200804,
-0.6726064086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09047v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09047v1
|
Multilingual Evaluation of Semantic Textual Relatedness
| 2024-04-13T17:16:03 | 2024-04-13T17:16:03 |
Sharvi Endait, Srushti Sonavane, Ridhima Sinare, Pritika Rohera, Advait Naik, Dipali Kadam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The explosive growth of online content demands robust Natural Language
Processing (NLP) techniques that can capture nuanced meanings and cultural
context across diverse languages. Semantic Textual Relatedness (STR) goes
beyond superficial word overlap, considering linguistic elements and
non-linguistic factors like topic, sentiment, and perspective. Despite its
pivotal role, prior NLP research has predominantly focused on English, limiting
its applicability across languages. Addressing this gap, our paper dives into
capturing deeper connections between sentences beyond simple word overlap.
Going beyond English-centric NLP research, we explore STR in Marathi, Hindi,
Spanish, and English, unlocking the potential for information retrieval,
machine translation, and more. Leveraging the SemEval-2024 shared task, we
explore various language models across three learning paradigms: supervised,
unsupervised, and cross-lingual. Our comprehensive methodology gains promising
results, demonstrating the effectiveness of our approach. This work aims to not
only showcase our achievements but also inspire further research in
multilingual STR, particularly for low-resourced languages.
|
[
-0.378018558,
-0.7261013389,
0.5247772336,
0.4135445952,
-0.3771359026,
0.0234321468,
-0.4446887374,
-0.96425879,
0.2834653854,
0.5878360271,
-0.8075596094,
-0.4623584151,
-0.4843550324,
0.5551727414,
-0.1685306877,
0.8918268085,
-0.0886773393,
0.1476724595,
-0.5974515676,
-0.6289002895,
-0.6343794465,
-0.5475791693,
-0.3512203097,
-0.3193297684,
0.491858542,
0.1701899618,
0.6016551256,
0.2714046538,
0.8387672305,
0.3649094999,
0.1216196939,
0.1985540986,
-0.2142312378,
0.3462446928,
-0.5223460793,
-0.4649384618,
-0.0737428814,
-0.4017831683,
0.4611465633,
0.703915298,
0.2323232591,
0.0218698196,
0.3168110251,
0.7316890359,
-0.4784756899,
0.2010345161,
-0.55385077,
0.0249783453,
-0.4016985595,
-0.4956274331,
-0.446914345,
-0.2421073914,
0.0993920714,
-0.6526234746,
0.2659364641,
-0.1860294938,
0.9157090783,
0.3085168302,
-0.7643678784,
-0.5942162871,
-0.5995489955,
0.8845812082,
-0.5324100852,
0.6333537102,
0.6242937446,
0.169660002,
0.2004317194,
-0.7289782166,
-0.4385128021,
0.0129172867,
-0.2030727714,
0.3562816978,
0.1984773129,
-0.4003133476,
-0.0881887823,
0.3717778325,
-0.5329785347,
-0.2085491419,
-0.2062412947,
-0.2146588266,
0.3972371817,
0.0971113592,
0.6645299792,
-0.4158556163,
-0.6372108459,
-0.0271604136,
-0.6469427347,
0.0311075728,
0.3501467407,
0.3206787407,
-0.2601094842,
0.7924249768,
-0.1393865049,
0.609778583,
-0.3745792508,
0.1068716198,
0.3258807659,
-1.05600214,
0.2152505815,
0.0142742516,
0.759455204,
0.4473082423,
0.132184431,
-0.0921817794,
0.2631114125,
0.3097546697,
0.0416663326,
-0.4749177992,
0.1832935661,
-0.0203300864,
-0.4054628611,
0.1468431652,
0.0261335913,
-0.7950828671,
-0.1152165905,
-0.3948355317,
0.2123213261,
-0.6923108697,
-0.3459121585,
0.0459022969,
-0.0436501652,
0.4504299462,
0.0474791266,
-0.8648585677,
0.2158846259,
0.9508180022,
0.785358429,
-0.3529529572,
-0.526030302,
-0.1543127149,
0.2848710418,
-0.1661607772,
0.911487639,
-0.7760491371,
-0.0711619034,
0.0332251638,
0.2178856134,
-0.279677093,
-0.3055690825,
0.8150120378,
-0.6030083895,
0.2530466914,
-0.2179366052,
-0.4471893311,
-0.3134904802,
0.3649254143,
-0.8921624422,
1.2166039944,
-0.2364993244,
-1.1342318058,
0.5985098481,
-0.3527400792,
-0.5134723186,
-0.0351788439,
-0.0465569906,
-0.1956257373,
0.0321666785,
0.1480009109,
0.5476425886,
-0.1767536104,
0.320156306,
-0.3258083165,
-0.1280115396,
0.0898677036,
-0.1932457238,
0.5588912964,
0.3213258982,
-0.033124648,
0.3570008874,
-0.6776411533,
0.1338264793,
-0.093849428,
-0.044538334,
-1.083788991,
-0.1816372275,
0.3104678392,
0.4525409043,
0.3548975885,
-0.4278100729,
-0.2990605831,
-0.8710493445,
0.4596719146,
0.2184773684,
0.0903900191,
0.3967325985,
-0.1358599216,
0.2845189571,
-0.0742640346,
-0.1135361418,
-0.2886989713,
-0.466321677,
-0.6261520982,
-0.1276940554,
0.2311418355,
0.431004554,
-1.0288318396,
0.1631257236,
-0.4783109426,
-0.4262300134,
-0.4823982716,
0.1842505485,
0.3987061083,
0.1696320176,
0.4403454363,
-0.3354545832,
-0.5690228939,
-0.8519096375,
-0.6257871389,
0.0284739602,
-0.0182518568,
0.0492587388,
0.558652401,
-0.3636950552,
0.6881366372,
-0.1833309233,
-0.5212829709,
-0.4126647711,
0.0510164611,
0.0027113413,
0.2144698948,
0.3097316623,
-1.0194063187,
-0.7013916969,
0.3647406995,
-0.8962078691,
-0.0253791679,
0.1603199691,
-0.2253124565,
0.474881947,
0.4458344579,
-0.3635858297,
0.3141052723,
0.5081552863,
-0.4573540986,
0.0255313702,
-0.3772088289,
0.3970046937,
-1.4291884899,
-0.0145114716,
-0.0076998323,
-0.0646879226,
-0.4409405887,
0.4097770452,
0.1363745183,
-0.1576187909,
-0.4886537492,
0.5748265386,
-0.4651053846,
-0.0957555771,
-0.0624656565,
0.2125955522,
0.1231169552,
0.3158300519,
0.363062948,
0.7678351402,
0.0628377423,
-0.5494374037,
0.1958954781,
0.3148356378,
-0.1779801995,
0.7061705589,
-0.6246503592,
-0.2308037579,
-0.0658230484,
0.0600447394,
-0.7871040106,
-0.2537981272,
-0.1269426346,
-0.5192443728,
0.0936056525,
0.1796329468,
-0.469705373,
0.1464789212,
-0.6695300341,
0.6199246049,
-0.1336132437,
-0.2516159713,
0.6129488945,
0.4384813309,
-0.4310296774,
-0.5098085403,
-0.8031985164,
0.2750618458,
-0.3229856491,
-0.9501459599,
0.2724985182,
0.1113121584,
-0.3116990328,
0.0781565309,
-0.0033612365,
-0.4084710479,
-0.0062274882,
0.1477488577,
0.3319523335,
-0.3035403192,
0.285209775,
-0.1563533098,
-0.2653264105,
-0.0569102839,
-0.1241931692,
0.5401421785,
-0.3293153942,
-0.4026096165,
-0.0321938619,
0.6784101129,
0.2657197118,
-0.4452930689,
0.7729254365,
0.9014153481,
-0.4269945621,
0.056391269,
-0.4704945087,
-0.0479248054,
-0.3560972512,
0.3078008294,
-0.6262999177,
-0.8897203803,
0.4601888955,
0.0094592534,
-0.2210205346,
0.8068143725,
0.5458058715,
0.178910315,
0.5417098403,
0.9992132783,
0.4784832895,
0.1299471408,
0.0478905402,
0.3702909946,
-0.6353397369,
-0.4188330173,
-0.6777312756,
0.4029610157,
-1.0446448326,
-0.6484142542,
0.107468918,
-0.1498493254,
0.2003200799,
0.6226805449,
-0.3102601767,
0.4102048576,
0.2726488411,
-0.1489780992,
0.715165019,
0.0461669639,
-0.3439507782,
-0.674951911,
-0.516022265,
-0.6306521893,
0.758125186,
0.1124092638,
0.3920556009,
0.2720476985,
0.4814526141,
0.1913220286,
-0.1882506907,
-0.6929401755,
0.4649128616,
-0.1229200661,
-0.5785005689,
-0.3370915651,
-0.3111822307,
-1.1131981611,
0.377315402,
-0.4725532234,
-0.4873486161,
-0.2123161554,
-0.4089025259,
0.2843231559,
-0.0240407437,
-0.5984014869,
0.914468646,
-0.0867441669,
-0.7460782528,
-0.3971397579,
-0.8605441451,
0.2952184379,
-0.2354840338,
0.5234336257,
-0.1972595751,
-0.3777974248,
0.6258102655,
-0.3836404979,
0.6467645764,
0.43604514,
-0.3036549687,
0.1175650209,
-0.0710967332,
0.0190069433,
-0.0321200043,
-0.1336141974,
0.4291613102,
0.4441402555,
-0.472628355,
-0.4179013371,
0.9826408029,
-0.5376104712,
-0.0636451989,
-0.5743867755,
-0.4226947725,
-0.4037236273,
0.3582882285,
0.252078265,
0.3923661709,
-0.3525850475,
0.2654234469,
0.4405063689,
-0.2455369681,
0.5138314962,
0.3900758624,
-0.0506451391,
-0.2863957882,
0.9985217452,
-0.058684919,
0.1666213125,
0.7964937687,
0.0440492295,
-0.6000657082,
-0.1874627173,
-0.4601278603,
0.4026164114,
-0.8305532336,
0.0682008415,
-0.8135225773,
-0.0554458015,
-0.3239930272,
-0.2685534954,
-0.2346938699,
-0.4815368056,
0.1565081775,
-0.0704481825,
0.3746952713,
0.7750142813,
0.2448881418,
-0.2099728882,
-1.012655139,
0.2922132313,
0.0213960558,
0.3817380965,
-0.0425496995,
-0.2275984585,
-0.1487173587,
-0.2574544251,
-0.0711319447,
-0.6966426969,
0.3776214719,
0.4189483523,
0.5143549442,
0.011035962,
0.212166816,
0.6361976862,
-0.5350340009,
0.8186813593,
0.2662890553,
-0.9610213041,
0.7104560733,
-0.4433635175,
0.3092100024,
0.8349447846,
0.6837739348,
-0.5686899424,
-0.4815229177,
-0.3627690673,
-1.3155510426,
0.2992077172,
0.2441016287,
0.2533102036,
-0.068200767,
-0.2182788253,
0.3563522995,
-0.014303524,
-0.8983122706,
-0.0534929745,
-0.1772605181,
-0.4330319166,
-0.0844101235,
-0.2179082632,
0.2035467923,
0.0642637908,
0.553760767,
-0.0749366954,
-0.0146906702,
0.3196640611,
-0.4264246225,
0.285818845,
0.7265307307,
0.4039511085,
0.7224369645,
0.0671230853,
0.333670646,
0.3356468678,
-0.6072353721,
0.0136373481,
0.0024779248,
-0.0078931516,
0.1523624361,
0.7963404059,
0.4436922073,
0.6454520822,
-0.6231178045,
0.5541742444,
-0.3021546006,
0.2601812482,
-0.3605248034,
-0.3435153067,
0.2721405625,
-0.0641585812,
0.2460275292,
0.1689805388,
0.3079194427,
-0.744587481,
0.2589502037,
0.3540559709,
-0.8777474761,
-0.3497717679,
0.5764158368,
0.4166182876,
-0.0772099048,
0.0228156764,
0.1033701748,
-0.4674067795,
0.4213321805,
0.5415102243,
0.5382366776,
-0.088704586,
0.0469135158,
0.6169592738,
0.3402377069,
0.1162890345,
0.0978726372,
-0.2884351015,
-0.5954133272,
-0.805976212,
-0.7273062468,
-0.2910017669,
-0.319884479,
-0.8780620098,
0.4623803198,
-0.0037833361,
-0.029249534,
-0.014302521,
0.0881835967,
-0.5512334704,
0.1163723245,
-0.1265559644,
0.6685346365,
-0.8592479825,
0.7322900295,
0.8762722015,
-0.492177099,
-0.556707859,
-0.0676327795,
0.041351039,
-0.5396682024,
0.6883051395,
0.3633509278,
-0.3856090903,
-0.2025817335,
0.1460794955,
-0.5781571865,
0.9024637341,
0.0574628897,
-0.1816569418,
0.1313945055,
0.2700546384,
0.7964044809,
-0.1458963454,
0.337859869,
0.3260025382,
0.3166176379,
0.136144489,
-0.8864424229,
0.0059849112,
-0.6113795638,
0.054700613,
0.403811276,
-0.4564297795,
0.454403311,
-0.0196874849,
-0.4591611624,
-0.017564198,
0.6785514951,
0.1196610779,
0.677126646,
0.1963038892,
0.4942380786,
0.5572178364,
0.0065447656,
0.9706745744,
-0.4326455593,
0.2286474407,
1.1561615467,
-0.5136784315,
1.1419788599,
0.6754623652,
-0.1686955541,
0.4881201088,
0.5376403332,
0.2641794086,
0.416482538,
-0.2360384315,
-0.2157312483,
-0.0972743854,
-0.6113954782,
-0.6043897867,
0.5372971296,
0.3154988587,
-0.0339960679,
-0.2719207406,
0.1551535726,
-0.0636523366,
0.77982831,
-0.2319435775,
0.983769238,
0.1988497674,
-0.7150467038,
0.28798455,
-0.0164633207,
0.9368269444,
-0.9027095437,
-0.1901596487,
0.1231244504,
0.0619720481,
-0.3118855059,
-0.8406563997,
0.9819675088,
0.145120576,
-0.1367699653,
-0.1597718894,
1.0804681778,
-0.5321983099,
-0.5389037132,
0.8967471719,
0.7837340832,
-0.0143520292,
0.3050358295,
-0.3716519475,
0.0861522406,
-0.1131324768,
0.1756689101,
0.3867698014,
0.6979176998,
-0.2281485647,
0.5472903252,
0.6902090311,
0.0680317953,
0.0015127027,
0.1110865176,
0.4473096132,
-0.8986749053,
-0.5094926357,
-0.7519031167,
0.189962551,
-0.117131345,
-0.2959696651,
1.1979207993,
0.5832815766,
1.2926170826,
-0.1260531992,
0.7092196941,
0.0685163215,
0.5601868629,
-0.7150277495,
0.5601872206,
-0.5648912191,
0.3203690052,
-0.5133725405,
-1.0099670887,
-0.3876613677,
0.5799965858,
-0.3483505249,
-0.2659011185,
1.1001745462,
0.5003020763,
-0.2063523978,
0.2294116169,
0.4112818539,
-0.1436365396,
-0.3271896243,
0.5698738098,
1.0379651785,
-0.5820459723,
0.5366674662,
-0.1817468703,
0.1034419239,
0.0150156654,
-0.9717161655,
-0.8552544117,
-0.9246155024,
-0.1660714447,
-0.2733079791,
-0.1651053727,
0.7845944166,
0.2968574166,
-0.7249526978,
-0.1640256345,
0.0731919482,
0.2198805362,
0.0260704216,
-0.2289183438,
0.357065469,
-0.2989926934,
-0.6311499476,
0.149703756,
0.5672754645,
-0.2712951601,
-0.1060134917,
-0.0243074056,
-0.4918057919,
0.0836295784,
0.9039804935,
0.0246069189,
-0.7081558108,
-0.0722631291,
0.0219231732,
-0.2853990197,
-0.06253694,
0.7983546853,
-0.488184154,
0.5169073343,
0.7720643878,
0.891987741,
0.4500116706,
-0.163479507,
0.4726019204,
-0.5384320617,
0.3528442979,
0.1260607541,
0.3737936318,
0.7706120014,
-0.2419732064,
0.8990662694,
0.10512238,
-0.3678876758,
-0.4833613038,
0.3340406716,
-0.9678065777,
-0.2738493383,
0.9916697741,
-0.3089414239,
-0.2863948941,
-0.5802389383,
-0.1160905287,
0.3153457642,
0.0571014807,
0.4735584855,
0.8906294107,
0.0753230006,
0.0992930159,
-0.8151518703,
0.3128060997,
0.4203741848,
-0.8050556779,
-0.2131186128,
0.3472801745,
0.139916718,
0.2998842895,
0.6030043364,
-0.2871296406,
0.0792587101,
-0.1157712787,
0.0004751621,
0.2397525609,
-0.196643889,
-0.4376282394,
0.142917335,
-0.0749468878,
0.180337131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09045v1
|
Adapting Mental Health Prediction Tasks for Cross-lingual Learning via Meta-Training and In-context Learning with Large Language Model
| 2024-04-13T17:11:35 | 2024-04-13T17:11:35 |
Zita Lifelo, Huansheng Ning, Sahraoui Dhelim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Timely identification is essential for the efficient handling of mental
health illnesses such as depression. However, the current research fails to
adequately address the prediction of mental health conditions from social media
data in low-resource African languages like Swahili. This study introduces two
distinct approaches utilising model-agnostic meta-learning and leveraging large
language models (LLMs) to address this gap. Experiments are conducted on three
datasets translated to low-resource language and applied to four mental health
tasks, which include stress, depression, depression severity and suicidal
ideation prediction. we first apply a meta-learning model with
self-supervision, which results in improved model initialisation for rapid
adaptation and cross-lingual transfer. The results show that our meta-trained
model performs significantly better than standard fine-tuning methods,
outperforming the baseline fine-tuning in macro F1 score with 18\% and 0.8\%
over XLM-R and mBERT. In parallel, we use LLMs' in-context learning
capabilities to assess their performance accuracy across the Swahili mental
health prediction tasks by analysing different cross-lingual prompting
approaches. Our analysis showed that Swahili prompts performed better than
cross-lingual prompts but less than English prompts. Our findings show that
in-context learning can be achieved through cross-lingual transfer through
carefully crafted prompt templates with examples and instructions.
|
[
-0.3348202407,
-0.9278663993,
0.54273206,
0.37456429,
-0.2462494373,
-0.1941792667,
-0.406139493,
-0.5872437954,
0.3490839601,
0.2584007084,
-0.9756820798,
-0.436252594,
-0.7818858027,
0.4072377682,
0.0422580019,
1.008805871,
-0.1800677329,
0.2279446125,
0.0028671471,
-0.0994498506,
-0.7071967125,
-0.429941982,
-0.8236899376,
-0.3906080723,
0.7599950433,
0.6723106503,
0.5292561054,
-0.0863527879,
0.0510041229,
0.127807647,
0.1361688524,
0.3688592315,
-0.4250831902,
-0.1823380142,
-0.4946711659,
-0.1635138094,
-0.2425994128,
-0.2217436731,
0.0521499813,
0.5030039549,
-0.1684614271,
0.4416563511,
0.3612472117,
0.4293331802,
-0.5542678833,
0.2490840405,
-0.4685759246,
0.2841947377,
-0.0155648915,
-0.0817227066,
-0.2164367586,
-0.0795715377,
0.0503611229,
-0.3783136606,
-0.1671211272,
-0.4043383002,
0.4672866166,
0.3836005926,
-0.6634225249,
-0.2836213112,
-0.640560329,
0.6459750533,
-0.773194313,
0.0899766535,
0.7027639151,
0.6191687584,
-0.1018352285,
-0.4465471506,
-0.2760861516,
0.3865311146,
-0.1353695244,
0.1397442967,
-0.1925083995,
-0.1055813134,
0.2835617363,
-0.0575626493,
-0.3968659043,
0.1527781636,
-0.2055902928,
-0.1508980244,
0.7636625171,
0.2551941276,
0.5772513151,
-0.3989651799,
-0.1171301305,
0.2314163595,
-0.4506341219,
0.1748838574,
-0.1428882033,
0.4255740643,
-0.4111419916,
0.5016873479,
0.0388432704,
0.3592261672,
0.2401811182,
-0.6640292406,
0.2000898421,
0.0050530368,
-0.1523695737,
0.1658128947,
0.8415145278,
0.2885538042,
0.3017598391,
-0.0096674832,
-0.1630442739,
-0.135095194,
0.3106362224,
-0.7788912654,
-0.0437700152,
0.0586601533,
-0.6003676057,
0.2672010064,
-0.5482152104,
-0.8675012589,
-0.3070773184,
-0.2711800933,
0.5572023988,
-0.6456685662,
-0.2167531252,
-0.0750061497,
0.4341753423,
-0.1516539603,
0.3597311378,
-0.9105216861,
0.1156027541,
0.3964380026,
0.9498823285,
-0.0748851672,
-0.2609298825,
-0.4632384181,
0.2169090509,
-0.1477800012,
0.3599709272,
-0.3813662827,
-0.3680496812,
0.0671430826,
0.2242929339,
-0.2596171796,
-0.2134136409,
0.6153306961,
-0.1262184232,
0.1800779998,
-0.5572687984,
-0.2004756182,
-0.3682693541,
0.0222306214,
-0.5981237888,
0.9223468304,
0.469591856,
-0.9204724431,
0.1315446347,
-0.5446045995,
-0.9600551128,
-0.1763662398,
0.0862541944,
-0.235684678,
0.2038449347,
0.603361547,
0.7494671345,
-0.3165906072,
0.3504280448,
-0.5382249355,
-0.3751181662,
0.2320667058,
-0.3119044304,
0.8562195301,
0.1143851727,
-0.5671585798,
-0.0634106919,
-0.5696471334,
-0.0305522401,
0.0856188089,
-0.1553581804,
-0.4758844972,
0.0040759603,
0.0962696224,
0.6658803821,
-0.0199151114,
-0.3784468174,
-0.1532529444,
-0.3037326634,
0.4775794148,
0.5337677002,
0.1200905442,
0.0818731189,
-0.1821550429,
0.6077247858,
0.0309220739,
0.2715925276,
-0.0142759681,
-0.4855799079,
-0.1231215969,
-0.4964725971,
0.21621719,
0.9054922462,
-0.9013570547,
0.44701612,
-0.2632052302,
-0.4940723777,
-0.6038297415,
0.3843942881,
0.2505611479,
0.6554740071,
0.5887678266,
-0.0758122504,
-0.6526383758,
-0.6125051379,
-0.3844718039,
0.088831529,
-0.05864539,
0.5976622105,
0.569922328,
-0.9229717851,
0.5223037004,
-0.1188213229,
-0.3887055218,
-0.4531536698,
0.274738282,
0.2121708989,
0.0447727516,
0.5948424935,
-0.5804385543,
-0.7850303054,
0.0157927498,
-0.7231258154,
-0.2633086145,
0.0571869314,
0.0684776157,
0.2151898742,
0.2347491086,
-0.425639987,
0.2306972891,
0.8325454593,
-0.2850796878,
0.4270251095,
-0.013817111,
-0.1307513863,
-1.3707488775,
-0.0496723428,
0.1364264488,
-0.3828491569,
-0.5135853887,
-0.4245620668,
0.1431753933,
-0.3720628917,
-0.3151955307,
0.6608451605,
-0.3479273617,
0.0342213698,
-0.4074557424,
-0.0727249011,
-0.3128522336,
0.3560236096,
-0.0083167385,
0.6434381008,
0.6381675601,
-0.4753879607,
0.0753481165,
0.1693033427,
-0.5773181319,
0.6207565069,
-0.4887001514,
-0.1892917901,
-0.1595783681,
0.4531277418,
-0.8869710565,
-0.2121568173,
0.2866898775,
-0.2057674527,
0.2562387884,
0.0517069288,
-0.3322462142,
-0.3415670395,
0.2146381736,
0.5422446728,
0.2965250611,
-0.5417085886,
0.7403954864,
0.4333369434,
-0.4860419631,
-0.7370448709,
-0.7394358516,
0.0278697889,
-0.3534102142,
-0.2041236758,
0.3924436569,
0.1425990611,
-0.0422335714,
0.0175675023,
0.0390744247,
0.1477015018,
0.3584621549,
0.4558608532,
0.1365497112,
0.0162574295,
0.3092611432,
0.2592858374,
-0.108910583,
0.2863153815,
-0.0548052192,
0.3610738516,
0.1637387872,
-0.2004217356,
-0.2631406188,
0.4993245304,
0.4970546663,
-0.1323908418,
0.919794023,
0.9195922017,
-0.6250443459,
-0.2493167371,
-0.3233361244,
-0.1615614146,
-0.346736908,
0.1970521063,
-0.4075244963,
-0.6973923445,
0.4798620045,
-0.2130322158,
-0.0702742487,
0.2844848931,
0.6011812687,
-0.2766675055,
1.0916649103,
0.8809208274,
-0.4737323523,
0.6202895045,
-0.1299068183,
0.1991321892,
-0.7015532851,
0.0146951908,
-0.0643480048,
-0.4232991934,
-0.5201838017,
-0.4361377656,
0.5635843277,
0.0509441048,
-0.1781298369,
0.105576463,
0.099679485,
-0.0209468622,
0.1239227951,
0.5548436046,
-0.0537176579,
0.0073064622,
-0.4230703413,
-0.3095625341,
-0.7392255068,
-0.2309774309,
0.9793950915,
0.1711852551,
0.7129316926,
-0.0826536193,
0.6771164536,
0.4340749979,
0.6304017305,
-0.7717516422,
0.1914031655,
0.0143544739,
-0.4049187899,
-0.532808125,
-0.5018224716,
-0.8913040757,
0.233088091,
-0.2359725833,
-0.6927143931,
0.1162212715,
-0.1512396783,
-0.3425000608,
0.2957594395,
-0.3156512976,
0.7962920666,
-0.6133161783,
-0.1645898223,
-0.5050722361,
-0.6337550282,
0.3991708457,
-0.4382252693,
0.7199906707,
-0.3634085953,
0.0212228,
0.6113054752,
-0.2050212771,
1.2560181618,
-0.1230323985,
-0.4278231859,
0.1303937584,
-0.1210273802,
0.3390020728,
0.3019101918,
-0.2007877827,
0.1869021356,
0.128738746,
-0.5271477699,
-0.657536447,
0.6098546386,
-1.0212384462,
-0.6268550158,
-0.1770446002,
-0.528202951,
-0.4349538684,
0.2833718657,
0.3962934911,
0.368609637,
-0.3952392042,
-0.1848347485,
0.5588778853,
-0.5320931077,
0.4538762271,
0.7428677678,
-0.2443859875,
-0.7264429927,
0.5813297629,
0.2636125386,
0.0680911914,
0.3462674618,
0.2942336202,
-0.1609895378,
0.0725965202,
-0.34628582,
0.4339758456,
-0.720720768,
-0.3816769123,
-0.6628718376,
-0.254963398,
-0.4636136889,
-0.1408556402,
-0.1769150347,
-0.0657484308,
-0.3656121492,
-0.1466444284,
0.3448235691,
0.5668252707,
-0.3791459203,
0.049574092,
-0.8464491963,
0.4055897295,
0.3191467822,
0.1723823845,
0.3362921476,
-0.6330527663,
-0.5782415867,
0.3364470601,
-0.225306645,
-1.1612278223,
0.4317872524,
0.4416818321,
0.5352136493,
0.6281579733,
0.3093591332,
0.8470439315,
-0.6173753142,
0.4416750968,
0.3115542531,
-0.9061389565,
0.7872025967,
-0.1239982918,
0.263422519,
0.6263456941,
1.0999650955,
-0.9351851344,
0.0964188278,
-0.3281724155,
-0.5416173935,
0.4743693769,
-0.3386442363,
0.1998142302,
-0.1980873346,
0.3831306994,
0.3928959668,
-0.1271027029,
-0.7443554997,
-0.2216092497,
-0.3200117052,
-0.3018761873,
-0.6966947913,
-0.4256030619,
-0.2695227265,
-0.6156500578,
0.6209940314,
-0.4517340958,
0.1935224533,
0.2282245904,
-0.4239881337,
-0.5518077612,
0.2865618765,
0.2501871586,
0.7343435287,
0.006130096,
-0.0045984103,
0.5078986287,
-0.2586024106,
0.318703413,
0.0375581458,
-0.1503233314,
0.2660277486,
0.5587142706,
1.0475912094,
0.6957365274,
-0.7560096979,
0.5240786672,
0.0133130448,
-0.0738439634,
-0.1420706064,
-0.082282871,
0.1318803877,
0.4379563034,
0.2469544113,
-0.3401720226,
0.1115113422,
-0.9014630318,
0.0219808333,
0.4450167716,
-0.4664242268,
-0.5807759166,
0.4449041784,
0.1504654288,
-0.3726430237,
0.4008285999,
0.2090896815,
-0.506940186,
0.1905027777,
0.9695512652,
0.7895656228,
-0.6377629638,
0.592297256,
0.4803525209,
0.237075299,
-0.0794163942,
0.6206858158,
-0.1704763621,
-0.6106951237,
-0.4638661146,
-0.5846583843,
-0.3193089664,
0.1987039596,
-0.9729569554,
0.3228551149,
-0.2294353992,
-0.4245539308,
-0.3227312863,
0.2602008283,
-0.8524861336,
0.4357428551,
0.4094034433,
1.0607569218,
-1.2939366102,
0.997692287,
0.8047094345,
-0.1148964912,
-0.6742383242,
0.281068027,
-0.0275856704,
-0.530303359,
0.2083687633,
0.4630575478,
-0.0219263099,
-0.1956304163,
0.00411649,
-1.0442937613,
1.1312659979,
0.5691235065,
-0.5014939308,
-0.0392515399,
0.2169114798,
0.6621761918,
-0.4198001921,
0.3313371837,
0.3314487636,
0.5766557455,
-0.181455642,
-0.8942545652,
0.2019712031,
-0.0490012318,
0.0353648216,
-0.063694939,
-0.5706959963,
0.5732700825,
-0.4771134853,
-0.551250875,
-0.320450753,
0.7148379683,
0.0082439892,
0.2350355685,
0.5329189301,
0.5200254917,
0.9165715575,
0.3025661409,
0.8768482208,
-0.4612426758,
0.1075492799,
1.1014465094,
-0.4040212929,
0.9463130236,
0.212470904,
-0.0385192968,
0.8812220693,
0.9253214598,
0.2753631473,
0.7139943838,
-0.1266544312,
-0.1026750877,
-0.1826952547,
-0.0441045538,
-0.3024947941,
0.2444321215,
0.6748862267,
-0.4655121565,
-0.2378213853,
0.506885767,
-0.0508864783,
-0.0906003639,
-0.5181592703,
0.7591916323,
0.4791738987,
-0.4684333801,
0.736086905,
0.0996638983,
0.6481670141,
-0.5010386705,
0.257969439,
-0.0849491805,
0.0261250697,
-0.1726734042,
-0.4533922374,
0.424315244,
-0.1874965578,
-0.307754606,
-0.1398611814,
0.9600675106,
-0.5192481875,
-0.8336688876,
0.8710836172,
0.7443177104,
-0.0553956069,
0.015332588,
-0.8230267167,
-0.34960109,
-0.2862181664,
-0.0898803249,
0.6067605615,
0.7519480586,
-0.2782850266,
0.7749723196,
0.2999984324,
0.2637416422,
-0.2922852635,
-0.09970247,
0.5415031314,
-0.7698226571,
-0.5659415722,
-1.0142589808,
-0.0054708584,
0.2720816731,
-0.2473374605,
0.8240005374,
0.0614183322,
0.6592811346,
-0.1830973029,
0.990706265,
0.0900870413,
0.5751060843,
-0.3445409536,
0.5604963303,
-0.7894718051,
-0.2218144834,
-0.4050846994,
-0.6681568623,
0.1779703498,
0.4464613497,
-0.5724728107,
-0.186285004,
0.6110446453,
0.427320689,
-0.1335936189,
-0.2086106837,
0.276304245,
0.1761407405,
-0.0940868482,
0.7922769785,
0.5985366702,
-0.2333697677,
0.1454000473,
-0.4186828434,
-0.0843112543,
-0.5193426609,
-0.8159098625,
-1.2025408745,
-0.5458900332,
-0.0051053921,
-0.1581401229,
0.1133072451,
0.9626831412,
0.530246377,
-0.7650781274,
-0.1318771988,
0.4518405199,
0.214231059,
-0.7254413962,
-0.1543034613,
0.334879905,
-0.2663987577,
-0.2515275776,
0.2808337212,
0.1391495019,
-0.0341428071,
-0.3603543043,
-0.073049821,
-0.1898622364,
0.1778682619,
0.908690989,
0.2758357525,
-0.7891017795,
-0.0332094133,
-0.3408622742,
-0.344989121,
-0.0913845003,
0.666901052,
-0.7084622383,
0.0626081973,
0.1594765037,
0.7200776339,
0.3915855587,
-0.0426895283,
0.6704423428,
-0.3672342896,
-0.0505947284,
0.0451774448,
0.5240724683,
0.4071741998,
-0.6835981607,
0.5069956183,
0.0177362692,
-0.2450307012,
-0.6786899567,
0.1235602722,
-0.4423709214,
-0.5064942837,
1.1520417929,
-0.4067299366,
-0.4235287011,
-0.0608144887,
-0.2230910063,
0.5744798779,
-0.1194683611,
1.1698353291,
0.5972450972,
0.0017159374,
-0.3377168477,
-0.6337878704,
0.4475240111,
0.4936337769,
-0.6815207005,
0.0348220505,
0.0574559718,
0.6395125985,
-0.1606891006,
0.52515167,
0.0608410835,
0.4421928227,
-0.5717812777,
0.031956289,
0.2621031106,
-0.3812687099,
-0.4580634832,
-0.222025156,
-0.3408045471,
0.3671381772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09043v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09043v2
|
Do LLMs Play Dice? Exploring Probability Distribution Sampling in Large Language Models for Behavioral Simulation
| 2024-04-13T16:59:28 | 2024-06-18T05:27:45 |
Jia Gu, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) for handling
complex language tasks, an increasing number of studies are employing LLMs as
agents to emulate the sequential decision-making processes of humans often
represented as Markov decision-making processes (MDPs). The actions in MDPs
adhere to specific probability distributions and require iterative sampling.
This arouses curiosity regarding the capacity of LLM agents to comprehend
probability distributions, thereby guiding the agent's behavioral
decision-making through probabilistic sampling and generating behavioral
sequences. To answer the above question, we divide the problem into two main
aspects: sequence simulation with known probability distribution and sequence
simulation with unknown probability distribution. Our analysis indicates that
LLM agents can understand probabilities, but they struggle with probability
sampling. Their ability to perform probabilistic sampling can be improved to
some extent by integrating coding tools, but this level of sampling precision
still makes it difficult to simulate human behavior as agents.
|
[
-0.4534033537,
-0.800539434,
0.8251812458,
0.2668854892,
-0.1611379981,
0.0822752416,
-0.1724087596,
-0.2734504938,
0.1542842686,
0.7494081855,
-0.7583148479,
-0.4107897282,
-0.2635363936,
-0.0880150422,
-0.1816415936,
0.8015016913,
0.2649281323,
0.2579202652,
-0.2160650939,
0.2685602009,
-0.159245804,
-0.6421670914,
-0.8881000876,
-0.4868505597,
0.3562600017,
0.1707621068,
0.6696115136,
0.3822283149,
0.4772602022,
0.3568517864,
0.0257385187,
0.0209855773,
-0.4250970781,
0.2481226325,
-0.2239612192,
-0.725871861,
-0.2537665963,
0.139001146,
0.8766046166,
0.917858243,
-0.4315085411,
-0.0769006535,
-0.1935161948,
0.5174308419,
-0.308874011,
0.0440872312,
-0.3747887313,
0.2195990384,
-0.1974811703,
-0.3064665794,
-0.53581357,
-0.3759739101,
-0.0345402248,
-0.3953782618,
0.2436211854,
0.0047759074,
0.0587356687,
0.1274323314,
-0.5895873904,
-0.2806277871,
-1.0564337969,
0.6769645214,
-0.5424619317,
0.0711784214,
0.509239614,
0.3081648648,
-0.6123446226,
-0.2024474442,
-0.6500172019,
-0.4239948094,
0.5494922996,
-0.001819377,
0.1929349601,
0.2017404139,
0.4037612379,
0.25510782,
-0.2797629833,
0.4558943212,
-0.2788625956,
-0.0798086822,
1.0350766182,
0.3871878088,
0.1387450844,
0.0652559623,
-0.1678865701,
-0.5788367987,
-0.6213407516,
0.2264807224,
0.7947433591,
0.0294123385,
0.1317532361,
0.8860031366,
0.0156607106,
0.6395346522,
-0.1952212751,
-0.298268944,
0.2454455346,
0.0602251142,
-0.2696836293,
-0.1325976104,
0.783390522,
0.3840841055,
0.650509119,
0.1422589868,
-0.3628132045,
-0.1679500043,
0.2840668261,
-0.2797275782,
-0.3073401153,
0.4539669156,
-0.3885310292,
-0.333571732,
0.035767626,
-0.7961329818,
-0.6131048203,
0.0622793436,
0.2338712513,
-0.4373147488,
-0.3591074049,
0.3535737991,
-0.2782096565,
0.1240828112,
0.3403174877,
-0.7618473768,
0.3909436464,
0.4720980525,
0.4424187541,
-0.2456548065,
-0.3561491668,
-0.4767147303,
0.137861684,
-0.5890136361,
0.9799160957,
-0.4805959165,
-0.5757303834,
0.3850230873,
-0.307597369,
0.0802276284,
-0.7438175082,
0.2806495428,
-0.5241904855,
-0.3605306149,
-0.2680160403,
-0.7619440556,
0.0582131706,
0.3168056905,
-0.8048092723,
0.8075529337,
-0.0486301035,
-0.5708513856,
0.4662210941,
-0.2952398956,
-0.3544051051,
0.0119086811,
-0.3526162207,
-0.2476166487,
0.1856328249,
-0.1525477171,
0.6071351171,
-0.0832529664,
0.0563886203,
-0.5976372361,
-0.2761244774,
0.9446488619,
-0.4832830131,
0.6618095636,
0.4294101298,
0.0464987047,
-0.1085371599,
-0.4769964516,
-0.1502273381,
0.0517181233,
-0.4646074474,
-0.1143792197,
0.4178557992,
-0.0015539267,
0.383587122,
-0.1888999343,
-0.2319774479,
0.5889669657,
-0.1607763916,
0.0799045563,
0.8822225928,
0.3210531175,
0.7456992865,
-0.6872113943,
0.6656668186,
0.2747050226,
0.0193333142,
-0.069755286,
-0.5226991773,
-0.2998520434,
-0.3354128599,
0.1425774992,
0.7084172368,
-0.8840436339,
0.2749552131,
0.2839266658,
-0.4815554321,
-0.3185425401,
-0.0267233867,
0.1379323155,
-0.1627910286,
-0.0918517783,
-0.3243364692,
-0.3591128886,
-0.6328126192,
-0.218316406,
-0.3391019106,
-0.0767322853,
0.1399106383,
0.4460434318,
-0.108967565,
0.9358152747,
-0.5127375126,
-0.3664520085,
-0.4964595437,
0.1760531664,
0.1977569759,
0.4035567641,
0.4084733725,
-0.6361253858,
0.1282863617,
-0.5447042584,
-0.5985863805,
-0.1520610154,
-0.3080375791,
0.1517916173,
0.3227625787,
0.4769744873,
-0.7769009471,
0.3095701039,
0.4755140245,
-0.1736202091,
0.6971591115,
-0.6595851183,
0.0274915881,
-0.8304664493,
-0.3870764077,
0.1782990992,
-0.0640962869,
-0.6015121341,
0.1068725437,
-0.3287856281,
0.1652458757,
-0.394125104,
0.510984838,
-0.6218867898,
-0.502543807,
-0.2139675319,
0.0559705831,
-0.5033628345,
0.0415537916,
0.2788505554,
0.776062429,
0.4987128377,
-0.9864420891,
0.3248460591,
-0.0513915867,
-0.7027795911,
0.3520848155,
-0.2123147696,
-0.2017172724,
-0.330271095,
0.5886279345,
-0.9674835205,
-0.1874006689,
0.2228088081,
-0.295509398,
0.0220964774,
0.0449306481,
-0.8154138327,
-0.3226412535,
-0.3665372133,
0.3005719781,
0.9771406054,
0.0272384062,
0.3028871715,
0.7745342851,
-0.0829998702,
-0.5606050491,
-0.686329782,
-0.1540641934,
-0.1652915478,
-0.365694344,
0.0293441694,
-0.1990624219,
-0.8762939572,
-0.3275053203,
0.1074362323,
0.0773178861,
0.0983098671,
0.1581924409,
-0.1020996422,
0.074272491,
0.3348430395,
-0.2541672587,
0.117926836,
0.2486426383,
-0.3781220019,
0.8795419931,
0.4825306237,
-0.7365086675,
-0.0433263481,
0.3082939088,
0.193804279,
-0.0066214423,
0.6631724834,
0.3770960271,
-0.2669809163,
-0.4061831236,
-0.7214431763,
-0.2621509135,
-0.4456217885,
0.2479258776,
-0.3982186019,
-0.7088758945,
0.7149137855,
-0.0752930865,
-0.0164510161,
0.0699543804,
0.7284734249,
-0.6522740126,
1.0060081482,
0.494921118,
0.073335655,
0.4197767079,
-0.1789019108,
0.0100073544,
-0.5522870421,
-0.1540624201,
-0.4353034496,
-0.2547005713,
-0.7925758958,
-0.9882574081,
0.382668525,
-0.1264722496,
0.007370125,
-0.2782734036,
0.0714103505,
0.3973842561,
0.8051787615,
0.0948483571,
0.2034679651,
0.0867803842,
-0.1895574778,
0.0533381328,
-0.4679715931,
-0.4969673455,
1.0322011709,
0.2565316856,
1.1286678314,
0.1043086573,
1.057615757,
0.3955794573,
-0.0312941559,
-0.5700964332,
0.8004607558,
0.1278029233,
-0.6305840611,
-0.3562925458,
-0.3947347105,
-1.0513786077,
0.0033374489,
-0.2842994332,
-0.8497304916,
-0.0333959535,
0.1921552122,
-0.1639060378,
0.5089676976,
-0.3817074001,
0.4595799744,
0.051616285,
-0.0555422157,
-0.4066274166,
-0.361900121,
0.5386072993,
0.1457700431,
0.6004232168,
-0.1967263222,
0.006478976,
0.6549906731,
-0.0902465731,
0.8803984523,
-0.2475140691,
-0.41543293,
0.6182484627,
0.3760045171,
0.5878922343,
0.2149702758,
-0.1630821228,
-0.3762037456,
0.0041974047,
-0.3817138374,
-0.4197858572,
0.3137800694,
-0.7525370121,
-0.6444205046,
-0.6011531949,
-0.7063778043,
-0.2578888237,
-0.3377841115,
0.2043398172,
0.1266013682,
-0.3557966053,
-0.2121173888,
0.9221098423,
-0.3538832963,
0.452683568,
0.4261770844,
-0.3104872704,
-0.2011509836,
0.7443779111,
0.2572811246,
0.3030866086,
0.4027059674,
-0.1232583076,
-0.3643791378,
-0.6531195045,
-0.1465336233,
0.3036928177,
-0.6739777327,
0.2384609729,
-0.6201637983,
-0.106884189,
-0.419483304,
-0.0596173443,
-0.0151170604,
-0.2585431337,
-0.0238769427,
-0.2937770486,
0.3193968236,
0.9498464465,
-0.324395448,
0.4262225032,
-0.8321423531,
0.3070503771,
0.2873087227,
0.2054901421,
-0.1849555075,
-0.2120088488,
0.0419111513,
0.141948238,
-0.1551067531,
-1.2411780357,
0.477321595,
-0.1221948341,
0.7099195719,
0.3885371089,
0.129215464,
0.4861768186,
-0.7273591757,
0.8446893692,
-0.213754043,
-0.4589243233,
0.1893735528,
-0.5159166455,
0.15526402,
0.3060013652,
0.257352531,
-0.7260411382,
-0.7148316503,
-0.8184850216,
-0.537315011,
0.8343011141,
0.1155088693,
0.2556928098,
-0.3480825722,
0.2222088277,
-0.0276113823,
0.2474253476,
-0.496129483,
-0.1619027257,
0.4568957686,
-0.2494991273,
-0.5782498121,
-0.3669188917,
-0.0995599478,
0.0720110163,
0.4172486663,
-0.0227621142,
0.5029513836,
0.067787528,
-0.1561561078,
-0.1276015937,
0.1189241335,
0.6677059531,
0.4670163691,
-0.3351151645,
0.2789634764,
0.129685536,
-0.5675069094,
0.4428252876,
-0.0610114075,
-0.050034292,
-0.2282023579,
0.1881133765,
0.3082656562,
0.1346248388,
-1.1708989143,
0.2660563588,
-0.0535854101,
-0.1903717071,
-0.741820991,
0.4178152978,
0.2918687463,
0.5408504009,
0.4954658449,
-0.1380346119,
0.2569617927,
-0.7531709075,
0.3309464157,
0.478574723,
0.0146637717,
-0.1593324244,
0.3535289466,
0.0521316491,
-0.7648555636,
0.7818301916,
-0.5243734717,
-0.2836842537,
1.0029885769,
0.6302179098,
0.542660594,
-0.1554185748,
0.4788252115,
0.0791284069,
0.2905484736,
-0.4843352139,
0.5388616323,
0.0388979539,
-0.896843195,
-0.5164344907,
-0.4828257263,
-0.6739251018,
-0.1230525449,
-0.5091163516,
0.2120528817,
-0.3123882711,
-0.1796294302,
-0.3646137416,
-0.000084672,
-0.6186090112,
0.1289981902,
0.3486352265,
1.1936819553,
-0.923478961,
0.8873041272,
0.7337734699,
-0.2977158427,
-0.5310088992,
0.1588086635,
-0.0844288841,
-0.8105974197,
0.5805116892,
-0.1138479561,
0.1652884334,
0.0876660421,
-0.5353502035,
-0.550103128,
0.8466931581,
0.1435104162,
-0.3695751429,
-0.0365214013,
0.2936774492,
0.4337399602,
-0.2191531956,
0.3302552104,
0.6573343873,
0.3248538375,
0.0197866745,
-0.6766496897,
-0.20559825,
-0.0213913377,
0.076512605,
0.1563886702,
-0.404697746,
1.0206100941,
-0.4879785478,
0.1293465942,
-0.0875180289,
0.6547663212,
0.9183521867,
0.3116677105,
0.5686866641,
0.4831978679,
0.7009646893,
0.1837972999,
1.2027856112,
0.0727646574,
0.2325169742,
0.8554269671,
-0.6914027333,
1.002384305,
0.612580359,
-0.4545818567,
0.3054717183,
0.9258906245,
0.1645751595,
0.3125970066,
0.6634859443,
-0.4617970586,
-0.4584627151,
0.2945695221,
0.0101515604,
0.3510993421,
0.5175922513,
-0.1880126595,
-0.131559357,
0.0302969832,
-0.232711792,
0.1154892668,
-0.1950974464,
0.8630524874,
0.1227749288,
-0.9443255067,
-0.1604965031,
0.0655255541,
0.5559756756,
-0.5302354097,
-0.1299934685,
-0.2246378064,
0.1236210018,
0.1922306865,
-1.3874657154,
0.0657802001,
-0.1786694378,
0.0029171493,
-0.2144038975,
0.465203613,
-0.3650678098,
-0.2759318352,
0.0569400266,
0.5880488753,
0.5341886282,
-0.0732229948,
-0.3933184147,
-0.0321281701,
-0.3028613925,
-0.4553234279,
0.6219396591,
0.5924386978,
-0.2022118121,
0.989957273,
0.6822937131,
0.2903115153,
0.3226950467,
0.1983185112,
0.4566444457,
-0.7359204292,
-0.5912428498,
-1.0135986805,
0.4387421608,
-0.0952181742,
-0.091926448,
0.4377971888,
0.2559049726,
0.8178146482,
-0.4575961828,
0.733197391,
0.110146448,
0.1754491329,
-0.7029585242,
0.4502773881,
-0.0953197181,
0.2305432111,
-0.0647381991,
-0.8976297379,
-0.1433430314,
0.820656836,
-0.3221493363,
0.1395889521,
0.5095484853,
0.6050845981,
0.178959623,
-0.3204276562,
0.3857192695,
0.0427144803,
0.4012920558,
0.6468265057,
1.0764368773,
-0.0525433905,
0.3800701499,
-0.1090833023,
-0.0266981199,
-0.4307479858,
-0.9317889214,
-0.8254408836,
-0.5401166677,
-0.0539764836,
-0.2327143997,
-0.1041451469,
1.322021246,
0.3615458012,
-0.4778671861,
-0.6809334159,
0.02090385,
0.3221235871,
-0.4572349191,
-0.2213402092,
-0.1391300112,
-0.5544707179,
-0.8731861115,
0.0829465091,
0.0647629425,
0.2291557491,
-0.3541457355,
-0.0110794352,
-0.1775603741,
0.2690635324,
0.3390829563,
0.2181675285,
-0.5186857581,
-0.1014385223,
-0.0598685108,
-0.2609467804,
-0.2129412889,
0.9192073345,
-0.7541900277,
0.1661176533,
0.5647754073,
0.4296446741,
0.3864797056,
-0.1977893859,
0.7911717296,
-0.7334921956,
0.2704803646,
0.3006466627,
0.2800538838,
0.0004127672,
-0.103354007,
0.3488807976,
0.0996506214,
-0.6520314217,
-0.9790414572,
0.5638508797,
-0.9483489394,
-0.3238478899,
1.5310887098,
0.1323010474,
-0.3743560016,
-0.1370257735,
-0.3662784398,
0.1924448758,
-0.2827677429,
0.7002460361,
0.8209543824,
-0.197827816,
-0.281789273,
-0.9259294271,
0.5980184078,
0.1500659436,
-0.6527311802,
-0.0392952114,
0.3281668425,
0.3068712056,
-0.1419124901,
1.1522783041,
0.274356395,
0.2766387165,
0.0264600813,
0.2432206124,
0.3559856713,
-0.1734286398,
-0.4058797956,
0.0985233337,
0.4384197295,
-0.0535246767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09027v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09027v1
|
MING-MOE: Enhancing Medical Multi-Task Learning in Large Language Models with Sparse Mixture of Low-Rank Adapter Experts
| 2024-04-13T15:28:52 | 2024-04-13T15:28:52 |
Yusheng Liao, Shuyang Jiang, Yu Wang, Yanfeng Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models like ChatGPT have shown substantial progress in natural
language understanding and generation, proving valuable across various
disciplines, including the medical field. Despite advancements, challenges
persist due to the complexity and diversity inherent in medical tasks which
often require multi-task learning capabilities. Previous approaches, although
beneficial, fall short in real-world applications because they necessitate
task-specific annotations at inference time, limiting broader generalization.
This paper introduces MING-MOE, a novel Mixture-of-Expert~(MOE)-based medical
large language model designed to manage diverse and complex medical tasks
without requiring task-specific annotations, thus enhancing its usability
across extensive datasets. MING-MOE employs a Mixture of Low-Rank Adaptation
(MoLoRA) technique, allowing for efficient parameter usage by maintaining base
model parameters static while adapting through a minimal set of trainable
parameters. We demonstrate that MING-MOE achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA)
performance on over 20 medical tasks, illustrating a significant improvement
over existing models. This approach not only extends the capabilities of
medical language models but also improves inference efficiency.
|
[
-0.0694661811,
-0.8954253793,
0.5035495162,
0.3146342337,
-0.3078963459,
0.0006981462,
-0.385694921,
-0.49171561,
0.1826092601,
0.3228761554,
-0.27221632,
-0.2989688516,
-0.9487977028,
-0.051366251,
0.1706450433,
1.017758131,
0.2374763638,
0.4382932782,
-0.0451484025,
-0.355233252,
-0.7254256606,
-0.4529189765,
-0.5704376698,
-0.1977193505,
0.3147727847,
0.50477314,
0.5049432516,
0.4287849665,
0.3804055452,
0.1999730468,
0.175521642,
0.5850978494,
-0.6822428107,
0.2734750807,
-0.0472208858,
-0.4909659624,
-0.7465130687,
-0.1989479512,
0.5476446152,
0.8108198643,
-0.274364233,
-0.1724921167,
0.1734112501,
0.4848970771,
-0.7235837579,
0.2797117829,
-0.7837582827,
-0.1022013947,
-0.1108550578,
-0.2930988967,
-0.5078513026,
0.2210416943,
0.2392963767,
-0.9151588678,
-0.0764665157,
0.0391552001,
0.6140882373,
0.3956531286,
-0.6375938058,
-0.0172245968,
-0.3991867006,
0.9607585669,
-0.6516700983,
0.3289447129,
0.3168697059,
0.3140517771,
-0.3717085719,
-0.4315642416,
-0.1839903891,
-0.272741735,
0.1208875179,
0.3080624044,
0.1716198921,
0.1271508932,
-0.0528266244,
0.2284315228,
-0.357853353,
0.0699590594,
-0.2775045931,
0.0405413546,
0.5058400035,
0.0361025296,
0.5135211349,
0.06669043,
-0.4300608933,
0.1608200371,
-0.6788827181,
-0.2403937876,
-0.4024752676,
0.1209351793,
-0.3243679404,
0.3048981428,
-0.2590379715,
0.634993732,
0.0695360005,
-0.5392042994,
0.2869419456,
-0.0246632528,
-0.2951907814,
-0.1662364304,
0.8961809874,
0.1894839406,
0.0599843077,
-0.1589102894,
0.0424794108,
-0.2861975729,
0.0632634535,
-0.8970351219,
-0.6775821447,
0.1162777916,
-0.5845919847,
-0.3186720312,
-0.333678484,
-0.6627252698,
-0.7543142438,
-0.0350945406,
0.4733630121,
-0.7258435488,
-0.3707812726,
-0.0663657337,
0.0373030417,
-0.2322416604,
0.5309557319,
-0.9286327958,
0.183690086,
0.5000960827,
0.7700755,
-0.4123700261,
-0.2960905731,
-0.8735541105,
0.3068788052,
-0.3199936152,
0.6837269664,
-0.8125816584,
-0.543142736,
-0.4513482153,
-0.1510954797,
-0.4275528789,
-0.798464179,
0.3664084673,
-0.1094966829,
0.0416174866,
0.0660292953,
-0.3762708604,
-0.3736028671,
0.2189248502,
-0.244636327,
1.0039373636,
0.1957195252,
-0.5372443199,
0.3782601058,
-0.7093625665,
-0.7397683263,
0.324160248,
-0.3214057386,
-0.1545134932,
0.2655403912,
0.4953312278,
0.7592956424,
-0.379391104,
0.4407021105,
-0.3914136887,
-0.1712397039,
0.1915761381,
-0.5285625458,
0.7075679898,
0.1397639215,
-0.0352200568,
0.3259832561,
-0.9181802869,
-0.2793798745,
0.1463765502,
-0.5482370853,
-0.729899466,
0.2287290096,
0.1985529512,
0.2824635804,
0.2571152449,
-0.41318205,
0.3145563006,
-0.2895643711,
0.5687326193,
0.5884077549,
0.0915861502,
0.2447759509,
-0.5132215619,
0.356133014,
0.2327777445,
0.1308337897,
-0.0518842936,
-0.9258244038,
-0.5941047668,
-0.9167360067,
0.2799784243,
0.6221903563,
-0.9803935885,
0.2092503905,
-0.4326075017,
-0.7835826874,
-0.811624229,
0.3050780296,
0.1885248572,
0.5746923089,
0.5494320393,
-0.3982566297,
-0.2274900079,
-0.5862211585,
-0.0869799778,
-0.0365126543,
-0.0183583405,
0.6558176279,
0.3084465861,
-0.460157454,
0.5983459353,
-0.5935179591,
-0.3131265044,
-0.2972540259,
0.1790793687,
0.0213927329,
0.7714704871,
0.6044710279,
-0.76851964,
-0.6987083554,
0.4130649269,
-0.6453126073,
-0.1054975986,
-0.1959022433,
-0.3496916294,
-0.0755497068,
0.1754339039,
-0.3173734546,
-0.1395938694,
0.8788679242,
-0.0198228806,
0.4487795234,
-0.5551152229,
0.2092585266,
-1.4603345394,
0.0766890571,
-0.0735770464,
-0.4071367383,
-0.7537910938,
0.3898743093,
0.1548478603,
-0.1158320084,
-0.2013115734,
0.7643634677,
-0.4079623222,
0.4455463588,
-0.4869665802,
-0.0618829019,
-0.2564494312,
0.5610383749,
0.1369064599,
0.6237596869,
0.9788526297,
-0.534817338,
0.1043584719,
0.1256250441,
-0.0479295775,
0.7006258965,
-0.4761142433,
0.0085516004,
0.1572493613,
0.1545576453,
-0.8932236433,
-0.4277783036,
0.3135469556,
-0.3956031799,
0.2532662153,
-0.3416949213,
-0.339271754,
0.1228440776,
-0.156320706,
0.5052524805,
0.6430461407,
-0.2183835208,
0.7696554661,
0.6258229017,
-0.5050314069,
-0.4448113441,
-0.5468710661,
0.050914824,
0.0547416247,
-0.4378333092,
0.2424653322,
-0.1423612684,
-0.0280053187,
-0.2465424985,
-0.0767576993,
-0.5758974552,
0.4352893233,
0.3300788403,
0.5014475584,
-0.4515016079,
0.2176755071,
0.4534826577,
-0.0741026178,
-0.3409186602,
-0.0398833379,
0.4204359949,
0.368939817,
-0.3402451575,
-0.2631236613,
0.5075528026,
0.8191897869,
-0.3581551909,
0.7443545461,
0.6030068398,
-0.4665754735,
-0.0514728315,
-0.5251054168,
-0.2713089883,
-0.3900758028,
0.8590884805,
-0.2488536835,
-0.7325630188,
0.2373894751,
-0.209945783,
0.3148658872,
0.3887413442,
0.9385810494,
-0.029642297,
1.0815119743,
0.4284456074,
-0.2620307207,
0.4315769672,
0.2609535754,
-0.0223200787,
-0.8223443627,
0.0519029424,
-0.1723581702,
-0.2219195366,
-0.4413759708,
-0.7941628695,
0.783434689,
-0.0924664661,
0.106716007,
-0.1796115935,
-0.4052121937,
0.0868652686,
0.5549203753,
0.4818549752,
0.3432344496,
-0.2279967368,
0.0460437536,
0.3135615289,
-0.8461745977,
0.0633422434,
1.2409137487,
0.1588025242,
0.8097985983,
-0.0923385844,
0.6437472105,
0.0636376441,
0.3746736348,
-0.7529050708,
0.4272283614,
-0.5798662305,
-0.6522792578,
-0.1353024691,
-0.5117154121,
-0.7616933584,
0.7583590746,
-0.58110255,
-0.4840870202,
-0.0039453125,
0.2837602198,
-0.5286750197,
0.1336200535,
-0.9139716625,
0.812663734,
-0.0609138757,
-0.1619805694,
-0.4208317697,
-0.6285617948,
0.4358508587,
-0.2468550503,
0.283090502,
-0.378757596,
-0.1243012697,
0.6600176096,
-0.3039847612,
0.9111046195,
-0.287297219,
-0.0778376386,
-0.1049552038,
0.0403753705,
0.4676344991,
0.0154301254,
0.0258475281,
0.1360376328,
0.1669359058,
-0.6973944902,
-0.296325177,
0.7020213604,
-0.7038461566,
-0.3990946114,
-0.1391519606,
-1.0881478786,
-0.6842327118,
0.2578120828,
0.1770755649,
0.4461669326,
-0.0569597483,
0.3198936284,
0.4857369959,
-0.270210892,
-0.1261871755,
0.3965553343,
0.0947266519,
-0.2554491162,
1.1625385284,
0.1478650272,
0.4118216932,
0.4289811552,
0.3187175691,
0.2539922595,
-0.587689817,
-0.5996937156,
0.1720822155,
-0.5186069012,
0.1009557545,
-0.822234869,
-0.1326880902,
-0.3872497976,
-0.1599810869,
-0.2619142532,
-0.2271187007,
-0.2581468225,
0.3859375715,
0.2594049573,
0.4767679274,
0.3739815652,
0.372933507,
-1.0592311621,
0.6129332781,
0.3709895909,
-0.016438853,
0.0928703472,
-0.4500500262,
-0.3261238635,
0.0982289538,
-0.2760911584,
-0.8406116962,
0.2633661628,
0.4048989713,
0.6746646762,
0.5178804398,
0.0573390536,
0.7751663327,
-0.5905489326,
0.6623237133,
0.235911265,
-0.6494631767,
0.2274567932,
-0.4152492285,
0.1909449846,
0.4321232736,
0.2053584605,
-0.5722856522,
-0.6257010698,
-0.1987572163,
-0.7888872027,
0.5569503307,
-0.0465454161,
0.1206427664,
0.0806306899,
-0.0359186307,
0.5178899765,
0.0679702014,
-0.4863330424,
-0.2340799272,
0.1621004343,
-0.5709053874,
0.0458272733,
-0.2694097161,
-0.1898684502,
-0.2566386461,
0.8363775611,
-0.410362184,
0.1257296354,
-0.0103058238,
-0.412560761,
0.1643451452,
0.4020377398,
0.6022493839,
0.4880123436,
-0.0090752123,
-0.063850522,
0.5181330442,
-0.7826554775,
-0.1661704034,
0.3456412852,
0.1296911985,
-0.0512644388,
0.4433220923,
0.6483635902,
0.5611673594,
-0.9745817184,
0.566714406,
0.2983380854,
-0.0781474784,
0.3796268702,
0.3790020049,
0.1813034415,
0.1071855575,
0.5005497932,
0.4041599333,
0.2449409813,
-0.3832137585,
0.027763512,
0.2520140409,
-0.4161479473,
-0.2061009109,
0.8096065521,
0.4685271084,
0.2265316844,
0.1635159552,
-0.0143702291,
-0.1690729856,
0.4259827137,
0.5837691426,
0.5068184137,
-0.438167125,
-0.0433803089,
0.0129682282,
-0.0403110646,
-0.0936941281,
0.395206809,
-0.0758218989,
-0.5622701645,
-0.5040640831,
-0.212676391,
-0.3798159659,
-0.1457508504,
-0.5257903934,
0.2335055172,
-0.181520462,
-0.0472285487,
0.0379428379,
-0.3324030638,
-0.2786192596,
0.1317280978,
0.054212898,
0.7225359678,
-0.7307228446,
1.1756840944,
0.8972223997,
-0.1044918597,
-0.5769700408,
0.1585998684,
-0.0629649609,
-1.2066810131,
0.3172271848,
0.0659177452,
0.1698288321,
-0.0367367975,
-0.2615014613,
-0.3587723374,
0.857408464,
0.5327733755,
-0.501352489,
-0.2817414105,
-0.2696507871,
0.3598669171,
-0.2189010382,
0.1705823839,
0.2628975213,
0.1602007151,
-0.0820035413,
-1.1962983608,
0.0380585939,
-0.3042930961,
-0.2252773941,
0.1022751927,
-0.6468211412,
0.9667834044,
-0.2706539929,
0.2120465189,
0.2080130726,
0.4143756926,
0.5166394114,
0.213819921,
0.5553982854,
0.1472842842,
1.0259603262,
0.1587385833,
0.9305824637,
-0.538734436,
0.3152709901,
0.9812811017,
-0.3464637697,
0.9385828376,
0.3878985345,
-0.0295101218,
0.3749720752,
0.3767055571,
0.1304797381,
0.4890559316,
-0.2597286105,
-0.300434351,
-0.6044049263,
-0.1136947945,
-0.494094938,
0.2796098888,
0.4495636225,
-0.4773791134,
-0.1366564631,
0.2666430771,
0.1106946915,
-0.2156922817,
-0.3817336261,
0.8126761913,
0.1538383365,
-0.5176251531,
0.6065539718,
-0.0419109128,
0.942840457,
-0.6857132316,
-0.2231674045,
0.1504034549,
0.0440292656,
-0.0555920862,
-0.3685730696,
-0.2825833261,
-0.1842401475,
-0.1326389015,
0.2606689036,
0.6561828256,
-0.6585706472,
-0.5985794067,
0.0794879422,
0.6108139753,
0.1097115204,
-0.2200798839,
-0.5848311782,
-0.3570693433,
-0.0647102818,
0.0154111078,
0.553183198,
0.482609421,
-0.0215776768,
0.7648070455,
0.5847614408,
0.3393424153,
0.2164320201,
-0.1746071875,
0.7515583038,
-0.205508709,
-0.714605093,
-0.7485509515,
0.2832316756,
0.0156156002,
-0.3595474064,
0.3497592807,
0.4306514263,
0.4058845043,
-0.3071682751,
1.042540431,
-0.083676748,
0.4802859128,
-0.516322732,
1.0456995964,
-0.9452132583,
-0.2279408276,
-0.1655421257,
-0.3987673521,
-0.3342666328,
0.488265276,
-0.3011224866,
0.1524266303,
0.5980846882,
0.5156943202,
-0.2453611642,
-0.2908969522,
0.6517345905,
0.4512942433,
0.2655900419,
0.9149950147,
0.4153316915,
-0.1286122352,
0.4102883041,
-0.1524237394,
-0.3894765079,
-0.7200958133,
-0.5145028234,
-0.8367781639,
-0.519726932,
-0.2537281513,
0.1677177846,
0.1077065095,
1.3322464228,
1.2363226414,
-0.983176291,
0.0816692412,
0.3467712998,
-0.1914987415,
-0.6599187851,
-0.1630560458,
0.3874486089,
-0.4709758759,
-0.9411314726,
0.5681914687,
0.4172736108,
-0.3071203828,
0.0536707751,
-0.1388917863,
-0.1054068357,
0.0133373076,
0.6210492849,
0.1136578992,
-0.7130363584,
-0.1378777623,
-0.1393154562,
-0.3254436851,
0.2866933048,
0.5386657715,
-0.5261322856,
0.72429353,
0.3809550107,
0.9648005366,
-0.0025652801,
-0.0001616793,
0.6059504151,
-0.6390333176,
0.2103045881,
0.1423625946,
0.6798513532,
0.1271839142,
-0.4224092364,
0.3841847777,
0.3951790631,
-0.5073750615,
-0.7350621819,
-0.0911983252,
-1.3221286535,
-0.4744146466,
1.2504016161,
-0.2768327296,
0.0886328742,
-0.3341197968,
-0.7510112524,
0.2092409134,
-0.5324642062,
0.8587155342,
0.7247835398,
-0.1742850244,
0.028272761,
-0.8269917965,
0.0186995137,
0.6534159184,
-0.9348959923,
0.0339748785,
0.3019447327,
0.5513389707,
-0.1055350229,
0.8432385921,
0.0606170744,
0.5568603277,
-0.1404047161,
-0.0164422318,
-0.0893682763,
-0.1680104584,
0.0361080691,
0.2302875668,
0.3743404746,
-0.5186159015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09022v1
|
Navigating the Landscape of Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Review and Analysis of Paradigms and Fine-Tuning Strategies
| 2024-04-13T15:03:03 | 2024-04-13T15:03:03 |
Benjue Weng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
With the surge of ChatGPT,the use of large models has significantly
increased,rapidly rising to prominence across the industry and sweeping across
the internet. This article is a comprehensive review of fine-tuning methods for
large models. This paper investigates the latest technological advancements and
the application of advanced methods in aspects such as task-adaptive
fine-tuning,domain-adaptive fine-tuning,few-shot learning,knowledge
distillation,multi-task learning,parameter-efficient fine-tuning,and dynamic
fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.5912709832,
-1.2555239201,
0.3066253662,
0.0905348584,
-0.137767002,
0.1666856408,
-0.6182127595,
-0.4883041978,
-0.3533394337,
0.4817897379,
-0.5146206021,
-0.1945352554,
-0.6203578711,
-0.2233902663,
-0.4027286172,
0.8659691811,
0.2029630989,
0.0663464442,
0.4079758823,
0.1961092502,
-0.678661406,
-0.4195089042,
-1.1039321423,
-0.4239591658,
0.4111709595,
0.3457648456,
0.8403944373,
0.5810987949,
0.6524866819,
0.3027219772,
-0.3744566739,
0.245871678,
-0.6556476951,
0.252063632,
-0.3170981109,
-0.3116150498,
-0.5882480741,
-0.2702198923,
0.8128065467,
0.8252951503,
-0.1827370971,
0.2127832025,
0.1983392686,
0.5916236639,
-0.5703099966,
0.3863773048,
-0.9282158017,
-0.0468461514,
-0.3866335452,
-0.421333313,
-0.3646348417,
-0.0648926124,
0.2575727105,
-0.585976243,
0.0354810283,
0.2567488253,
0.5805326104,
0.1530575603,
-0.4855765402,
-0.3700498044,
-1.1736494303,
0.9318082333,
-0.7803218961,
0.4623971879,
0.1782963425,
0.6334155202,
-0.3879371881,
-0.7969234586,
-0.3495762646,
-0.305998385,
0.4196218848,
-0.185212478,
-0.2053645402,
0.2078992277,
0.2758795321,
0.5275588036,
-0.4927019179,
0.6040918231,
-0.3019193113,
0.1161568761,
0.5943366885,
0.2279704511,
0.2426705509,
0.3117238283,
-0.0105168987,
0.0237888638,
-0.8611121178,
-0.2464857548,
0.1633080393,
0.6721206307,
0.0537700951,
0.3703465462,
-0.5459589958,
1.1282585859,
0.0878856033,
-0.0998601913,
-0.0387838706,
-0.3093713522,
-0.5085267425,
-0.1307749152,
0.6430305839,
0.3605464995,
0.5513731837,
-0.0476147979,
-0.0788092986,
-0.4026096761,
0.192267701,
-0.7192744017,
-0.2639099658,
0.0646217093,
-0.498624146,
-0.188604176,
-0.5648462176,
-0.9109024405,
-0.5996213555,
-0.6773379445,
0.5088305473,
-0.325982064,
-0.4327934384,
0.4851180315,
-0.0381723233,
0.34577021,
0.5460991859,
-1.0786415339,
0.229674086,
1.1380395889,
0.9926704168,
0.030202413,
-0.142383948,
-0.3491248786,
-0.0376061276,
-0.4969037473,
0.7035992742,
-0.6615509987,
-0.1678838134,
0.3359022737,
-0.1099326089,
-0.040670611,
-0.4621807337,
0.3713436425,
-0.8070631623,
-0.0451149866,
-0.1979884058,
-0.6659529209,
-0.4493338764,
0.4637343884,
-0.4867278636,
0.6235764027,
-0.1251618117,
-0.61947155,
0.2204737216,
-0.8071006536,
-0.4493666291,
0.0646465346,
0.3860110044,
-0.1801139265,
0.119417429,
0.1443388909,
0.7719902992,
-0.4505946338,
0.2022746354,
-0.2369529456,
-0.1369982362,
0.0104138274,
-0.4896018803,
0.6569328904,
0.5564553738,
-0.1910564303,
0.2710090876,
-0.7694776058,
-0.0747588202,
0.1210500523,
-0.2930215299,
-0.2834205925,
0.231085211,
0.2352115214,
0.147490412,
0.3046798706,
-0.2047732919,
0.4252944589,
-0.317730099,
0.9280959368,
0.537694931,
0.1352162212,
0.3948118687,
-0.2022311091,
0.3794791996,
-0.198336184,
0.1758543104,
-0.354373157,
-0.2689215243,
-0.8301921487,
-0.0235779844,
0.4986667633,
0.4892714918,
-0.56164819,
0.2335838377,
-0.3814512193,
-0.8966212273,
-0.3260880113,
0.0743656009,
0.1802238226,
-0.1264985949,
0.3862440586,
-0.1456261575,
-0.2954316437,
-0.8008868098,
-0.3666375577,
0.2589222789,
0.0298010781,
0.2033524066,
0.2503022552,
-0.2086952031,
0.4664936066,
-0.5672380328,
-0.1241838038,
-0.35258919,
0.2647178471,
0.090231061,
0.5732170939,
0.4493032992,
-0.8213251233,
-0.6258214116,
0.5081864595,
-0.236179322,
0.1357960999,
-0.1632889658,
0.0916659608,
-0.1234767735,
0.9296197295,
-0.5180850625,
-0.3193998635,
0.5604832768,
-0.0943796113,
0.5230817199,
-0.297453016,
0.1103362143,
-1.0659370422,
-0.0544801019,
0.2733952105,
-0.3871851265,
-0.7931230664,
0.5043910146,
-0.0634504557,
-0.11839246,
-0.1973883659,
0.4366418421,
-0.6577067375,
0.1610800773,
-0.5083885193,
0.1409546435,
-0.4539700449,
0.250364989,
-0.1308179796,
0.5572177768,
0.8810115457,
-0.7012897134,
0.5387517214,
-0.0171236694,
-0.6038006544,
0.2615161538,
-0.4843998551,
0.0571558028,
-0.0866232961,
0.1495131105,
-0.9602649212,
-0.2689365149,
-0.0733662769,
-0.1501807123,
0.5890770555,
-0.2859709561,
-0.7202942371,
-0.2576841414,
0.050748352,
0.2553080022,
0.5488411188,
-0.3918505311,
0.3742077053,
0.6443132758,
-0.4524806142,
-0.2873145938,
-0.1716778278,
0.2636493742,
-0.4024372101,
-0.4277342856,
0.1865013689,
-0.0010271218,
-0.2816917598,
-0.5594708323,
0.149868533,
-0.1465494335,
0.2803355455,
-0.1583078653,
-0.0759722292,
-0.3709819913,
0.0537512638,
0.0104258442,
-0.0153326774,
-0.2069821209,
-0.4069652557,
1.0247712135,
-0.0828909352,
-0.1340288669,
-0.2787029445,
0.1164536998,
0.7284708023,
-0.4955297709,
0.57945472,
0.7473023534,
-0.4124053717,
-0.2007533312,
-0.6603569388,
-0.0885408372,
-0.5013935566,
0.6813082695,
-0.3610022664,
-1.1927711964,
0.5349177122,
-0.619797945,
0.2942664921,
0.4577995539,
0.9406901598,
0.2281061262,
1.2761794329,
0.9350954294,
-0.1444942057,
0.7121430635,
-0.0493419655,
0.4777737558,
-0.6311452389,
0.1454285979,
-0.7619693279,
-0.350549072,
-0.9758020043,
-0.2982807755,
0.3235607147,
0.0575143248,
-0.5149074793,
0.3312885165,
-0.2947425544,
0.5143011808,
0.5855746269,
-0.1572246403,
0.5562075377,
-0.1406597346,
0.1540382355,
0.2271494269,
-0.75280267,
-0.2980034053,
0.8913315535,
0.5905266404,
0.8269208074,
0.0010211809,
-0.0869613588,
0.0310133435,
-0.2134389579,
-0.8819862604,
0.4726776481,
-0.3819794059,
-0.8483119011,
-0.492920965,
-0.2783457339,
-0.9740440845,
0.353797704,
-0.4001306295,
-0.8605844975,
-0.0552038141,
0.3259905279,
-0.498142451,
0.459785223,
-0.6607944965,
0.8110564351,
-0.0718709528,
-0.2133530229,
-0.6703845263,
-0.4899838865,
0.2761094272,
-0.2112798095,
0.1862666011,
-0.0372728221,
0.2268633693,
0.4710923433,
0.1812085509,
0.9154784083,
-0.0127445199,
-0.3666213453,
0.0718169585,
0.3410923183,
0.4834430814,
-0.2262254953,
0.0755780414,
0.159855783,
0.2543160319,
-0.2773034871,
-0.2871111035,
0.8585938215,
-0.551224947,
-0.4927682579,
-0.137552917,
-0.6125536561,
-0.5871002078,
0.3823628724,
0.2033182085,
0.4630069733,
-0.3036763072,
0.5499203205,
0.7396458983,
-0.3768738806,
0.4309387207,
0.49662444,
-0.2509091496,
0.106082283,
0.9459415078,
0.2085333914,
0.461882025,
0.4345269501,
0.1610603034,
-0.0856755823,
-0.9509337544,
-0.2148611397,
0.1263538152,
-0.4275722206,
-0.1838832647,
-0.5207179189,
-0.3804916441,
-0.3604026139,
-0.0478018261,
-0.6402833462,
-0.1861159056,
0.062237259,
0.1564428359,
0.2961055934,
0.7468040586,
0.2308912575,
0.6786777377,
-0.7476727366,
0.0615781769,
0.2635822892,
0.4339698851,
0.2534351647,
-0.4624008834,
-0.431512475,
0.1449986398,
-0.4857973158,
-0.331617862,
0.2753538489,
0.2796383202,
0.3677333891,
0.4117546082,
-0.2816969752,
0.7183320522,
-0.8213844895,
0.8968372345,
-0.0323554687,
-0.9284684658,
0.396972537,
-0.8766490221,
0.4460141659,
0.1652548164,
0.4507117867,
-0.950709343,
-0.0659073144,
-0.3277029395,
-0.9364050627,
0.3120869398,
-0.1736696959,
0.4618423581,
0.2969440222,
0.3189222515,
0.1551083773,
0.3038353622,
-0.4723165333,
0.1442081034,
0.2738863528,
0.0043748971,
-0.2773444653,
-0.1650284827,
0.0632121116,
-0.3134481907,
0.8664393425,
-0.2863198221,
-0.0039940253,
-0.4193473458,
-0.0772362649,
-0.1817028224,
0.4001888931,
0.6059163809,
0.971611619,
-0.0685216412,
-0.1668777019,
0.2018136382,
-0.3419634998,
-0.3673936129,
-0.0434222333,
-0.079640016,
-0.291182369,
0.224064365,
1.1100139618,
0.3894239366,
-0.6408216357,
0.2528369129,
0.2290693671,
-0.2028132826,
-0.222171098,
0.309640944,
0.1670128107,
0.4959326684,
0.1528710574,
-0.120747529,
0.2036927938,
-0.6261854172,
-0.2710236907,
0.7496846914,
-0.5003080368,
-0.3030132651,
0.5281284451,
0.1633294374,
-0.1200493649,
0.3968122303,
0.0762482062,
-0.3237905204,
0.2940437496,
0.5096765161,
0.6991696954,
-0.3412494659,
-0.0355095081,
0.3925660253,
0.3292620182,
-0.4971036315,
-0.0045457049,
0.0956044644,
-0.6366821527,
-0.6968304515,
-0.6683652997,
-0.448065877,
0.5104199052,
-0.3526373506,
0.3861840963,
-0.4258821905,
-0.1718358099,
0.4940894842,
0.031031834,
-0.5929711461,
0.1033392325,
0.2572481036,
1.1479110718,
-0.6196050048,
0.7866097689,
0.7401080132,
-0.0814612135,
-0.5796450377,
0.1138882115,
0.155131653,
-0.7412695289,
0.4337641001,
-0.2135024667,
-0.0291171204,
0.2951623499,
-0.6327566504,
-0.9803864956,
0.8329798579,
0.2022891194,
-0.951100111,
-0.1091197133,
-0.084429726,
0.662401557,
-0.1033591181,
0.0938493833,
0.7885470986,
0.466270566,
0.0156536307,
-1.5537867546,
-0.1886798888,
0.0532844067,
0.1645054966,
0.440823406,
-0.8082791567,
0.8372234702,
0.2331869304,
-0.102669172,
0.0343454145,
0.3803734183,
-0.3402701318,
-0.0714233369,
0.468464613,
0.1321663857,
0.6266140342,
-0.1326601058,
0.7338306904,
-0.3209294975,
0.6043579578,
0.9729144573,
-0.2461449206,
1.0592153072,
0.198643297,
-0.0914515704,
0.0569498055,
0.6333166957,
-0.121533744,
0.3568854332,
0.3344053328,
-0.1039396077,
-0.4769070446,
0.038881775,
-0.3177015483,
0.7458145022,
0.7185000181,
-0.2297399193,
-0.498287648,
0.3036351204,
0.1433815956,
-0.179266423,
-0.615237534,
1.0488789082,
0.1520415395,
-0.7555532455,
0.7093264461,
0.2885055542,
0.7054254413,
-0.5862350464,
0.1077632383,
0.1792276949,
0.4571501315,
0.0723017082,
-0.7617556453,
0.1166353449,
-0.1360085458,
0.0974383131,
-0.1455979496,
0.8970986605,
-0.3810933828,
-0.1970709562,
0.1841565222,
0.5250356197,
-0.1601638943,
-0.3612197936,
-0.6875582337,
0.071514599,
-0.1498130262,
-0.2744739354,
0.4914096594,
0.4354420304,
-0.1596159041,
0.9392920732,
0.5282909274,
0.0946352556,
0.0215129629,
0.0081487475,
0.7721599936,
-0.6145011187,
-0.4591895342,
-0.8871161938,
0.2456759363,
0.0231543388,
-0.3446728289,
0.7015844584,
0.4792900383,
0.8365995884,
-0.1501451731,
0.7670274377,
0.1032805517,
0.6397917271,
-0.6909478903,
0.8077730536,
-0.5852531791,
-0.0451325998,
-0.2534313202,
-1.0874572992,
-0.5022288561,
0.531612277,
-0.4223186076,
0.0702252164,
0.3192387819,
0.7155395746,
-0.3835139275,
0.1483874768,
0.3312643468,
0.5774259567,
0.4118080139,
0.2801967263,
0.6420810819,
-0.2476520687,
0.1622355282,
0.1198748946,
-0.3536502123,
-0.5362781882,
-1.0396927595,
-0.8765687346,
-0.8610537052,
-0.3331905007,
-0.0528149642,
0.1102533564,
0.9527201056,
1.0118470192,
-0.9029375911,
-0.335396111,
0.0548459142,
-0.2660608292,
-0.3139719367,
-0.1497037411,
0.1295223981,
-0.6550921798,
-0.9593396187,
0.2598456442,
0.3314569592,
-0.0600423366,
-0.4414568841,
0.3282883763,
-0.1463008076,
0.139207527,
0.9645388126,
0.3276136518,
-0.4616957903,
-0.2352316529,
-0.1075129732,
0.1135165766,
-0.032274466,
0.8939455748,
-0.2560739815,
0.3079131544,
0.6350096464,
0.6805310249,
0.5828368068,
-0.1755161583,
0.7716606259,
-0.5096956491,
0.0571193472,
0.0167734306,
0.3234377503,
0.3248012066,
-0.1037269309,
0.3061782718,
-0.2546802461,
-0.9177356958,
-0.7972413301,
0.2589325011,
-1.0359660387,
-0.5492065549,
1.2061662674,
0.2803900838,
0.0858755633,
-0.1387008727,
-0.4487527907,
0.1979775727,
-0.1302787662,
0.8199183345,
0.9753814936,
0.0468576662,
-0.2248639762,
-1.1774175167,
0.7514458895,
0.1129032522,
-0.7596591711,
0.4304944277,
0.4945013523,
0.320214808,
0.2447118461,
0.1886609793,
-0.0384568647,
-0.079352349,
-0.2109555751,
-0.3518459797,
0.1923165619,
-0.3351133764,
-0.3262442648,
0.1236905083,
0.5667879581,
0.0439353995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13067v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13067v1
|
Towards Efficient Resume Understanding: A Multi-Granularity Multi-Modal Pre-Training Approach
| 2024-04-13T14:31:24 | 2024-04-13T14:31:24 |
Feihu Jiang, Chuan Qin, Jingshuai Zhang, Kaichun Yao, Xi Chen, Dazhong Shen, Chen Zhu, Hengshu Zhu, Hui Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the contemporary era of widespread online recruitment, resume
understanding has been widely acknowledged as a fundamental and crucial task,
which aims to extract structured information from resume documents
automatically. Compared to the traditional rule-based approaches, the
utilization of recently proposed pre-trained document understanding models can
greatly enhance the effectiveness of resume understanding. The present
approaches have, however, disregarded the hierarchical relations within the
structured information presented in resumes, and have difficulty parsing
resumes in an efficient manner. To this end, in this paper, we propose a novel
model, namely ERU, to achieve efficient resume understanding. Specifically, we
first introduce a layout-aware multi-modal fusion transformer for encoding the
segments in the resume with integrated textual, visual, and layout information.
Then, we design three self-supervised tasks to pre-train this module via a
large number of unlabeled resumes. Next, we fine-tune the model with a
multi-granularity sequence labeling task to extract structured information from
resumes. Finally, extensive experiments on a real-world dataset clearly
demonstrate the effectiveness of ERU.
|
[
-0.253782481,
-0.8047651052,
0.5902298093,
0.367204845,
-0.0590432249,
-0.3818231523,
-0.0477010459,
-0.1673526913,
0.1784515828,
0.2830430865,
-0.8095264435,
-0.4261341989,
-0.3063170612,
-0.0819696188,
-0.1808072776,
1.2129853964,
0.1362836212,
-0.2200765461,
-0.3832473457,
-0.0956569314,
-0.6832122207,
-0.2995707095,
-0.2777693868,
-0.4435377419,
0.4320506155,
0.4070965946,
0.106233947,
0.6746850014,
0.2222603112,
0.3194813132,
0.1872731298,
0.0969453231,
-0.6457515955,
-0.1546494663,
-0.0871605501,
-0.337659955,
-0.6786887646,
0.0531930849,
0.6271316409,
0.66092062,
-0.3821645379,
0.2808097899,
0.0538138486,
0.655944109,
-0.5304329991,
0.3333297968,
-0.3780429065,
0.0529640988,
-0.0324853472,
-0.2216216326,
-0.5881851315,
0.2011731416,
-0.1409012526,
-1.0673573017,
0.4056046605,
-0.0096226614,
0.996663034,
0.0152025744,
-0.5226276517,
-0.0774602443,
-0.5134923458,
0.6547024846,
-0.1058412045,
0.8617457151,
0.4456854165,
0.410838455,
0.1336386949,
-0.6797711849,
-0.4898010492,
0.2444042712,
-0.2991001904,
0.5253154635,
0.2622332871,
0.3016636074,
-0.0650539845,
0.5909254551,
-0.6454027295,
0.2685073614,
-0.3251530826,
-0.1349517703,
0.2025494128,
-0.0514833555,
0.2250641137,
-0.3226167858,
-0.4639773369,
-0.2518412471,
-0.1077557877,
0.1635985672,
0.323420465,
0.0162492264,
-0.1684901565,
0.2856095433,
-0.273006171,
1.1039624214,
0.1128330305,
-0.3218787611,
0.3131898642,
-0.7110093236,
-0.4550738335,
-0.3883704245,
0.5279836059,
-0.0593406223,
-0.2585406601,
-0.3997397125,
-0.3599389791,
-0.1930827349,
0.9649789929,
-0.586638391,
-0.1982830018,
0.0976808369,
-0.9391782284,
-0.1883963943,
0.4847575128,
-0.6126316786,
0.0271717738,
-0.3895897567,
0.5056629777,
-0.6018251777,
0.1013912708,
-0.031914372,
-0.0579719543,
0.2711204886,
0.8679028153,
-0.7053772211,
-0.1254649758,
0.7177960277,
0.6650643945,
-0.0225847661,
-0.3846468031,
-0.6521393061,
0.2671526074,
0.2607317269,
0.8419274092,
-0.6654077768,
-0.2510451376,
-0.1623343229,
0.077724129,
-0.5509169698,
-0.1196729764,
0.6035829782,
-0.7544848919,
0.2584455907,
0.1563833803,
-0.1873525828,
-0.5966257453,
0.6989542842,
-0.7590808272,
0.7913967967,
0.4542340636,
-0.5311402678,
0.5171009898,
-0.8099117279,
-0.4033872485,
-0.2958853543,
-0.5296497941,
-0.3839960992,
0.0435898714,
0.3254805207,
0.4479523301,
0.1049325168,
0.0848316997,
0.2601669431,
-0.2869001627,
-0.0653810427,
0.0095162084,
0.3128765523,
0.3803679347,
0.1872936487,
0.3366142213,
-0.6620032787,
-0.2501567304,
-0.1129468903,
-0.8724962473,
-0.0163008757,
-0.3237427473,
0.183819443,
0.441216886,
0.1877760291,
-0.2917172611,
0.3198253214,
-0.0814772844,
-0.0666307434,
0.7831915021,
-0.2828564644,
0.7253968716,
-0.4546897113,
0.704390049,
0.2282289267,
0.1450465173,
-0.8700389266,
-0.0764352158,
-0.3563155532,
-0.6583583355,
0.1119186059,
0.5744078159,
-0.4963620901,
0.7395915389,
-0.35566172,
-0.4563366175,
-0.3314748704,
0.2472763658,
0.4546373785,
0.7891650796,
0.5219239593,
-0.5601484179,
-0.5014101267,
-0.8168212175,
-0.6154577136,
0.0624710955,
-0.0262517799,
0.5744503736,
0.3709404469,
-0.5662277341,
0.8477894664,
-0.4099967778,
-0.705477953,
-0.4095758498,
0.3331758976,
0.4314510822,
0.5605021715,
0.1222738251,
-1.0212007761,
-0.1165514886,
0.0643653944,
-0.8378913403,
0.2854728997,
-0.7399142385,
-0.2100911289,
-0.4885816276,
0.3773500919,
-0.5036222935,
0.365811795,
0.145080924,
-0.3853400648,
0.4082325995,
-0.6242812872,
0.4214293361,
-0.907845974,
0.1853610128,
0.4367119968,
-0.4862489998,
-0.6815411448,
0.1954210997,
0.4834755361,
-0.2739748955,
-0.3340296149,
0.1985153258,
-0.6261365414,
0.013998541,
-0.0677359477,
0.0042484328,
0.2442722768,
0.4249879122,
-0.0242969133,
0.4944055676,
0.3030779362,
-0.7441141009,
-0.049505543,
0.5963564515,
-0.338683337,
0.822463572,
-0.3238710165,
0.2075186372,
-0.7646746039,
0.9291322827,
-1.1971790791,
-0.4157821834,
-0.1272085607,
0.0083508352,
0.4909273684,
-0.4496375322,
-0.3301182687,
-0.4404579699,
-0.247874096,
0.7311660051,
0.2007540464,
-0.5699375868,
1.1470435858,
0.4103247523,
0.1454330236,
-0.6946865916,
-0.6263592839,
-0.3700774312,
-0.2715650201,
-0.6797960997,
0.8449161053,
0.1937098801,
-0.0427848697,
-0.6225573421,
-0.1111736521,
-0.6445741057,
0.2012955248,
0.3706830442,
0.3828759193,
0.0826596841,
0.1234675795,
-0.0201967489,
-0.0697350055,
-0.3446573913,
-0.2564064264,
0.5103955865,
-0.183702901,
-0.4539301693,
-0.8249087334,
0.1528194398,
0.4588148594,
-0.2314714044,
0.8277847171,
1.0109624863,
-0.1392514557,
0.0959025621,
-0.9638497829,
-0.1259611547,
-0.4098978341,
0.399410516,
-0.4719651341,
-0.5273518562,
0.5635341406,
-0.4369607568,
0.1736602485,
0.5104003549,
0.3343719542,
-0.1566175073,
0.3611641228,
1.0238679647,
0.1097549051,
0.7031133771,
-0.2875462174,
-0.0000043439,
-0.6969436407,
-0.7387331724,
-0.2908754349,
-0.3376999199,
0.1118356064,
-0.4427513182,
0.3825788498,
0.0782464221,
0.1563720107,
0.423060149,
-0.4727351367,
0.4852622151,
0.2773139775,
0.4728383124,
0.2358536422,
-0.2632671893,
0.2317249328,
0.2182438076,
-0.5694274902,
-0.427565217,
0.8900811672,
0.3451271951,
0.9241663218,
-0.1779630035,
0.78203547,
0.2315265089,
-0.0612057038,
-0.6101831198,
0.1216483563,
0.0053940429,
-0.2190751433,
-0.2327178419,
-0.3104388714,
-0.8853986859,
0.4898947775,
-0.2239490896,
-0.7089300156,
0.2232485265,
0.1670896709,
-0.6181753278,
0.0830488056,
-0.6146720052,
1.2058745623,
-0.2142015994,
-0.0149232401,
-0.4025754333,
-0.7990056276,
0.2663907409,
-0.4862941206,
0.8463789821,
0.2359195203,
0.0460720994,
1.0415940285,
-0.2059602439,
0.6555319428,
-0.0056102858,
-0.0107176546,
-0.0091178212,
-0.0175675098,
0.471968621,
0.1746362895,
-0.3625448048,
0.0826842114,
-0.0112304259,
-0.3981766701,
-0.342867285,
0.6138442755,
-0.6393300891,
-0.1144669056,
-0.0717898011,
-0.915869236,
0.2917566895,
0.3581015766,
0.249780491,
0.4114530683,
-0.5399277806,
0.1619307399,
0.6309127212,
-0.3684849739,
0.2544391155,
0.2761713564,
-0.0466487482,
0.0558138154,
0.7543544769,
0.0861133859,
-0.2366206795,
0.5544199347,
-0.1663096845,
-0.3082391024,
-0.185939014,
-0.5210202932,
0.2466656417,
-0.7472267747,
0.0377377607,
-1.1247969866,
0.2457549572,
-0.6033420563,
-0.4201289117,
-0.1634757072,
-0.1897987723,
-0.3864433467,
0.1294807345,
-0.1908967495,
1.0366469622,
-0.0834105089,
0.6089071631,
-0.844699502,
0.7102633119,
0.4156351388,
0.3298952878,
-0.0339674801,
-0.7542119026,
-0.4666511118,
-0.1173761636,
-0.586525619,
-0.8391599655,
0.2928321362,
0.6257211566,
0.989677608,
0.6566850543,
-0.24018538,
0.7527339458,
-0.358581543,
0.5641924739,
0.1414675266,
-0.6253128648,
0.9197559357,
-0.5154514313,
0.253352046,
1.0921543837,
0.6275757551,
-0.3226556778,
0.2894240022,
-0.7541823387,
-0.8783194423,
0.9951909781,
0.043911539,
0.0282060243,
-0.0409207232,
0.4139021337,
0.6477298141,
0.2294436544,
-0.7105225325,
-0.1164008379,
-0.2988014519,
-0.1255816966,
0.0677905306,
-0.203840673,
-0.1915789843,
-0.3977533281,
0.4727289975,
0.0255521983,
0.4110479653,
0.0304064937,
-0.8968021274,
0.3119565248,
0.3660489321,
0.5026308894,
1.1466649771,
-0.179155454,
0.0639318526,
0.240634948,
-0.3345709145,
0.0337880403,
0.0299216174,
0.4815588892,
-0.0571787804,
-0.0000604636,
0.4769888818,
0.3339740038,
-0.444879055,
1.0175296068,
-0.192760244,
-0.0470653586,
-0.2644990683,
-0.0839961767,
-0.3213187158,
0.0892478824,
0.3852072954,
0.0163178053,
0.0674401075,
-0.7338531613,
0.3975883424,
0.3859649003,
-0.3822682798,
-0.3203805387,
0.5804876685,
0.2433605194,
-0.2718406022,
0.8434335589,
0.0336445458,
-0.2240732014,
0.4188847542,
0.6920987368,
0.3488139212,
-0.1422730088,
0.2168266177,
0.269985348,
-0.1941662878,
-0.2475910932,
0.1576442271,
-0.4980753958,
-0.5140635371,
-0.4113667607,
-0.6830351353,
-0.1484031826,
-0.0705894679,
-0.8465762734,
0.2223214209,
-0.3783356845,
0.1761924028,
-0.1427490711,
-0.6782665849,
-1.2690707445,
0.4141512215,
0.0244426113,
0.6288826466,
-1.036668539,
0.5684824586,
1.0090516806,
-0.6100018024,
-0.5444464087,
-0.3311644793,
-0.1146378219,
-0.7907032371,
0.7635160685,
0.8677089214,
0.1114036664,
0.124448292,
0.0683622062,
-0.3376643658,
1.2135077715,
0.3021695316,
-0.3025801182,
-0.4247810245,
-0.4297982156,
-0.0659204051,
-0.4230166674,
0.902548492,
0.4371751547,
0.5567337871,
-0.1462585926,
-1.1044325829,
-0.0810036957,
-0.305508703,
-0.1917335987,
-0.0233573318,
-0.4307982326,
1.0611857176,
-0.1125871465,
-0.2444394827,
-0.4503802061,
0.8626076579,
-0.0632561296,
0.1880052835,
0.7626669407,
0.7049781084,
1.0230824947,
0.0413079634,
1.0765583515,
-0.3095782101,
0.4554463327,
0.9862317443,
0.3474774361,
0.3444943428,
0.3043138087,
-0.0266759358,
1.1280577183,
0.6274507046,
0.0890891403,
0.2839665115,
-0.185573265,
-0.1194039211,
-0.6984600425,
0.0301931407,
-0.5170900822,
0.7801026106,
0.1527891457,
-0.6303291917,
-0.6078236699,
0.3624266982,
-0.2983368635,
0.0009797075,
-0.407758832,
1.1084829569,
-0.1200645268,
-0.46704337,
0.3735598326,
0.0637890622,
0.775375843,
-0.6139681339,
-0.1026421487,
0.2388575822,
-0.0101814969,
-0.660512805,
-0.5766018629,
0.0568453856,
-0.3719468117,
-0.4042266011,
-0.5150305629,
0.912514925,
-0.2178107798,
-0.2456964254,
-0.1440849006,
0.7665320039,
0.3961638212,
-0.4293554723,
-0.5065763593,
-0.0911453068,
-0.263595283,
-0.1742508113,
0.6104360223,
0.3355870247,
0.3878300488,
0.4117460251,
0.6126169562,
-0.3460884392,
-0.1871855408,
0.0886800513,
0.9077209234,
-0.5987481475,
-1.3068242073,
-0.7851822972,
0.6194829345,
-0.1640255749,
-0.1745492667,
0.5585381985,
0.6838358045,
0.7898675203,
-0.3488617539,
0.6418502927,
0.0132826995,
0.0564259887,
-0.4553849995,
0.8613663912,
-0.5296051502,
0.0412403829,
-0.2604756653,
-1.0512417555,
-0.0755989105,
0.9711036086,
-0.4374222755,
0.2209118158,
0.5271087289,
0.5033211112,
-0.6024934053,
-0.1118107587,
0.1415711641,
-0.1299787909,
0.219091177,
0.330840379,
0.43199718,
-0.3308051825,
0.432233125,
-0.1532525271,
-0.4398007095,
-0.4446610212,
-0.8162278533,
-0.8237931132,
-0.5858157277,
-0.0832072496,
-0.3171141744,
-0.1852753013,
0.8004007936,
0.999453187,
-0.3934001327,
-0.2018408179,
-0.0172888376,
0.0157641321,
-0.2717553079,
-0.2323786616,
0.2692518234,
-0.5210338831,
-0.2067914456,
0.9961130619,
0.2562725246,
-0.1285906881,
0.0925500989,
0.0969617888,
-0.448176533,
-0.2414111048,
0.6562172771,
0.3886868656,
-0.4394025207,
-0.2120104581,
-0.482586503,
-0.0228064451,
0.389527142,
0.9817811847,
-1.1274242401,
0.6589019895,
0.5726929903,
0.9003193974,
0.4440889955,
0.6163155437,
0.5527212024,
-0.9234926701,
0.1111467257,
-0.0715636835,
0.4413452148,
0.2050143629,
-0.6902551055,
0.5016530752,
0.0533138588,
-0.5582425594,
-0.5329380035,
0.1701256931,
-1.2781541348,
-0.2465706766,
0.9606618881,
-0.2812182307,
-0.1594310552,
-0.3915654719,
-0.1753120422,
0.590842545,
-0.3019757271,
0.8540722728,
0.2000404,
-0.2973740101,
0.0705339387,
-0.3544838727,
0.0442907438,
0.4084830582,
-0.8839671016,
-0.2481867522,
0.5079581738,
-0.0273698699,
0.1737906933,
0.9034459591,
0.03360736,
0.5424279571,
-0.210318923,
-0.1415645629,
-0.4969803989,
-0.6045426726,
-0.2681772113,
0.3188646138,
-0.2282150984,
-0.2646695375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.09002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.09002v1
|
WikiSplit++: Easy Data Refinement for Split and Rephrase
| 2024-04-13T13:07:32 | 2024-04-13T13:07:32 |
Hayato Tsukagoshi, Tsutomu Hirao, Makoto Morishita, Katsuki Chousa, Ryohei Sasano, Koichi Takeda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of Split and Rephrase, which splits a complex sentence into multiple
simple sentences with the same meaning, improves readability and enhances the
performance of downstream tasks in natural language processing (NLP). However,
while Split and Rephrase can be improved using a text-to-text generation
approach that applies encoder-decoder models fine-tuned with a large-scale
dataset, it still suffers from hallucinations and under-splitting. To address
these issues, this paper presents a simple and strong data refinement approach.
Here, we create WikiSplit++ by removing instances in WikiSplit where complex
sentences do not entail at least one of the simpler sentences and reversing the
order of reference simple sentences. Experimental results show that training
with WikiSplit++ leads to better performance than training with WikiSplit, even
with fewer training instances. In particular, our approach yields significant
gains in the number of splits and the entailment ratio, a proxy for measuring
hallucinations.
|
[
-0.6738644242,
-0.7626746893,
0.3109158874,
-0.0163519122,
-0.586938858,
-0.0412293635,
-0.4299009144,
-0.6202731729,
0.6604768634,
0.4491908848,
-0.8913453221,
-0.1912901402,
-0.3881523013,
0.5795433521,
-0.4487383366,
0.8992953897,
-0.1103476807,
0.1198897809,
-0.172505483,
-0.0137045411,
-0.3559721708,
-0.2817007005,
-0.5666901469,
-0.3626190126,
0.8781480789,
0.6881278753,
0.6580670476,
0.4685342014,
0.3063790202,
0.2323865145,
0.1119778082,
0.7000777125,
-0.4573547542,
0.5834959149,
-0.328440547,
-0.2569991648,
0.0457112119,
-0.2055133283,
0.1182229891,
1.012264967,
-0.0943403691,
0.0316634104,
0.0258015003,
0.8642286062,
-0.7045180202,
-0.355171293,
-0.5217488408,
-0.0335556529,
-0.0274407789,
-0.2641369402,
-0.4020213485,
-0.3163811266,
0.1689400077,
-0.8943559527,
0.6437031031,
-0.086331442,
0.8348922133,
0.3364922702,
-0.3146264553,
-0.2383122295,
-0.4837056398,
0.5554593801,
-0.5946067572,
0.566532433,
0.2013045102,
0.1512258947,
-0.3446648121,
-0.9963587523,
-0.8986286521,
-0.2102440745,
-0.3543890715,
-0.1240810603,
0.1820402294,
-0.1369116604,
0.4187499881,
0.2200737447,
-0.4775471389,
-0.217170164,
-0.655754745,
-0.0535343811,
0.6278660297,
0.040811453,
0.367859602,
-0.442687571,
-0.0231625978,
-0.0176760405,
-0.3802486956,
-0.410319984,
0.4099274278,
0.4213227928,
0.3629299104,
0.9239835143,
-0.6261790395,
0.3695944846,
0.1592749804,
-0.0562320389,
0.7145451307,
-0.0636785105,
-0.2829110324,
0.1611302793,
0.4489411116,
0.1765317917,
0.3803170919,
-0.5739725232,
0.1800741553,
0.1717699617,
0.7797598839,
-0.7515540719,
-0.3164258897,
0.5416795015,
-0.3846761584,
-0.3919568062,
0.1428550184,
-0.7133777142,
-0.5293598771,
-0.7498370409,
0.5345174074,
-0.7005283833,
-0.2619751394,
0.4350396693,
-0.5008794069,
0.0516567081,
0.6333088875,
-0.6021977067,
0.4493026435,
0.8891701698,
0.6535870433,
-0.3420867324,
-0.4813516736,
-0.5229202509,
0.0838110894,
-0.1341052502,
0.8106170893,
-0.2502634525,
-0.0242098719,
-0.1479140073,
0.0776140764,
-0.1006988063,
-0.4309073985,
0.8147272468,
-0.1887044907,
0.6334249377,
-0.2978650331,
-0.7402746081,
-0.2817251086,
0.5723891854,
-0.9029119611,
0.701659143,
-0.101326637,
-1.1881701946,
0.3924274147,
-0.7354353666,
-0.7115299106,
-0.0004334632,
-0.1639531553,
-0.3521458507,
0.4126916826,
0.1719204187,
0.0891631916,
-0.015359465,
0.0382180475,
-0.3063896,
-0.501576066,
0.0514955968,
-0.624353826,
0.6164065599,
0.2752029598,
-0.3725909889,
-0.0206092298,
-1.1278477907,
0.2401324958,
-0.1365951747,
-0.3462694585,
-0.4269444346,
0.1597750038,
0.4134111106,
0.1222960949,
0.0576352105,
-0.7719890475,
0.3209606409,
-0.7528599501,
0.0469701774,
0.3637754619,
0.0413376242,
0.2849811316,
-0.2038537264,
0.1542203575,
0.0342573822,
0.2311666459,
0.1324794888,
-0.2650541663,
-1.1900248528,
-0.3150334656,
0.2222720087,
0.388035357,
-1.0024604797,
0.536506474,
-0.3128997684,
-0.4086038172,
-0.9169976711,
0.1449389607,
-0.1507147551,
0.3959727883,
0.711638689,
-0.0454175286,
-0.6547244191,
-1.0129008293,
-0.3101228178,
0.3581879735,
-0.289601624,
-0.5069005489,
0.5508503914,
-0.3510919809,
0.8035301566,
-0.6560559869,
-0.0897327662,
-0.2884798646,
0.0659715608,
-0.0523088798,
0.5530074835,
-0.10498216,
-1.1357192993,
-0.5033879876,
-0.0210779365,
-0.5760186315,
-0.0422271192,
-0.0886894539,
-0.2539615035,
-0.0884580836,
0.3818988204,
-1.2776441574,
0.508754015,
-0.1485231817,
-0.5039919615,
0.570663631,
-0.1320791394,
0.0695723668,
-1.3140944242,
0.0869494826,
-0.397846967,
-0.246798858,
-0.744376123,
0.3092465699,
-0.1037166342,
0.0931808874,
-0.171499148,
0.0519995168,
-0.3719809055,
0.2790046334,
-0.3980596364,
0.0339653157,
0.2765387893,
0.2930173278,
0.1968283802,
0.0338845365,
0.2548240721,
-0.3540199995,
0.6157946587,
0.0071263537,
-0.4068363309,
0.4261461198,
-0.3667932451,
0.2842171788,
-0.3112278581,
0.2012525499,
-0.8235838413,
-0.3558230102,
0.4575163424,
-0.3423348665,
0.3390871882,
0.2136611938,
-0.69276613,
-0.0459437333,
-0.6470147967,
0.1396579891,
-0.0407009497,
-0.7371921539,
0.6997748613,
-0.2562228143,
0.1303316504,
-0.5945592523,
-0.6737030745,
0.1664326489,
-0.284109503,
-0.5053129196,
0.4455960989,
-0.1579378545,
-0.4081410468,
-0.0080029145,
-0.236419782,
-0.1217530891,
0.0033967621,
0.3788736761,
-0.1885688603,
-0.0210106056,
0.3389876485,
0.2499292344,
-0.2663860023,
-0.2644999325,
0.0541960523,
0.63905406,
0.4174833298,
-0.2156384736,
-0.4308300912,
0.7715440989,
0.6335594058,
0.0105320951,
0.8201983571,
0.6965058446,
-0.6052981615,
-0.4289391935,
-0.7090231776,
-0.2249527425,
-0.4942521751,
0.1113201529,
-0.6220138669,
-0.6432878375,
0.0818515271,
0.0060100798,
0.2963487208,
0.343955189,
0.2210652381,
-0.3035955727,
0.860249579,
0.5417463779,
0.1959830076,
0.1834861785,
0.0223875884,
0.3126732707,
-0.4312556386,
-0.2986524105,
-0.5413721204,
-0.4952851534,
-0.6404696107,
-0.2413342148,
-0.3571971059,
0.2020951062,
-0.103172332,
0.1597645581,
-0.7595752478,
0.6086791754,
0.175432831,
0.2467052042,
0.4775553346,
0.477317065,
0.188921988,
-0.2495761961,
-0.2717532218,
-0.2636871636,
0.7647843957,
0.1042907164,
0.5115062594,
0.0860217586,
0.9170252085,
0.2177734077,
0.4303360581,
-0.7229904532,
0.3514133394,
-0.2897646725,
-0.3370247185,
-0.4252356887,
-0.5462397337,
-0.8193846345,
0.5983560085,
-0.2717648149,
-0.5003999472,
0.4334817529,
-0.3718402684,
0.0171842352,
0.0356724411,
-0.9210554361,
0.5694870949,
0.0773460045,
0.0709055588,
-0.3847390711,
-0.2046733052,
0.1290637404,
-0.1487410665,
0.177668646,
0.0424569435,
-0.0970216766,
0.6102644205,
-0.9962892532,
0.5548357368,
-0.2099084109,
0.0470048748,
-0.0191070251,
0.0394680277,
0.3697368801,
0.1000280157,
-0.0899312422,
-0.2638027668,
-0.0533486046,
-0.3341704011,
-0.8563103676,
0.806412518,
-0.7401906252,
-0.3813897073,
-0.0877774283,
-0.3734499812,
-0.2829806209,
0.1811919957,
0.817027688,
0.1847950369,
0.1285027713,
0.3989154696,
0.6257251501,
-0.0361007303,
-0.0304276142,
0.4461934566,
-0.1457036734,
-0.7184864879,
0.4780704975,
0.4051097333,
-0.0748281926,
0.3075047135,
-0.0152491136,
-0.0377706774,
-0.3441165984,
-0.1284086704,
0.3055138588,
-0.599136889,
-0.1351664066,
-0.6163833737,
-0.0751050189,
-0.4863659143,
-0.0882867351,
-0.4097169936,
-0.8165400028,
-0.2637056112,
-0.5120132565,
0.6089936495,
0.4112149477,
0.0714928508,
0.0497907177,
-0.2442622334,
0.91844064,
0.1805210263,
0.3186235726,
-0.0397529304,
-0.3769178689,
-0.286855787,
-0.0289821345,
-0.032231722,
-0.9347213507,
0.1962278038,
0.0898644626,
0.1911460906,
0.114437744,
0.3260934353,
1.1531153917,
-0.6447735429,
0.5679025054,
0.3105691075,
-0.665743649,
0.476036191,
0.12605609,
0.2818387151,
1.095813632,
0.337525934,
-0.576462388,
-0.5297598243,
-0.5322293043,
-1.1062264442,
0.3359342515,
0.3715144694,
0.2473258674,
-0.0727054626,
0.7730006576,
0.5193498731,
0.1079916582,
-0.6514297724,
-0.2198799998,
-0.3086028993,
-0.4373898506,
-0.0316100605,
-0.1666337401,
-0.0475851893,
-0.5813393593,
0.6357820034,
0.145301953,
-0.0980072543,
0.4751968682,
-0.2324376404,
-0.201471433,
0.2664074004,
0.0610466413,
0.5507641435,
-0.1471389085,
0.2383550406,
0.2297071368,
-0.7446716428,
0.1062586233,
0.2104718089,
-0.2548309565,
0.4829090834,
0.5277928114,
0.3814192116,
-0.0162606984,
-0.4911040664,
0.2853844464,
-0.2414665073,
-0.3719469309,
-0.2692517936,
0.2382572144,
0.1085129604,
0.2679460049,
0.5354799032,
-0.056927871,
0.4012551606,
-0.3638908267,
0.4624949992,
-0.0861447752,
-0.0707004368,
0.0041508051,
0.2077229917,
0.0931803733,
-0.4567576945,
0.8435581326,
0.0232762564,
-0.2704663277,
0.2539591491,
0.2706884444,
1.0812294483,
0.0261697154,
0.1935015768,
0.3017939329,
0.415222168,
-0.2337811589,
0.4370295107,
-0.3450617492,
-0.8682361245,
-0.5594604611,
-0.4670852423,
-0.2303570062,
0.4268054068,
-0.9728204012,
0.3334844708,
-0.3481404483,
-0.1729076952,
0.3030086458,
0.4273810089,
-0.6245573759,
0.4397180974,
0.1402634978,
1.1540780067,
-0.5879718065,
1.0551617146,
0.4260746837,
-0.3869869411,
-0.586611867,
0.2836922705,
-0.4418810904,
0.2504583001,
0.3511075377,
0.6457015872,
-0.018400088,
-0.2640560865,
-0.6571934223,
-0.5246499777,
0.7557637691,
0.4803739786,
-0.7298827767,
-0.2138534635,
0.2292304635,
0.7929942012,
-0.1181660369,
-0.1086686552,
0.5851855278,
0.5050989389,
-0.213810578,
-0.6268093586,
0.0671505928,
-0.5508903265,
-0.2524247766,
0.178915292,
-0.2137748301,
0.682477653,
0.1087874249,
-0.3254945874,
0.0165974144,
0.6556800604,
0.1691773385,
0.3234042227,
0.7479502559,
0.6968700886,
0.8064918518,
-0.0036061429,
0.6468058228,
0.1280735433,
0.2407226264,
1.4219043255,
-0.22047171,
1.1064689159,
0.9189425111,
0.1136003509,
0.7756978869,
0.3840044439,
-0.050453186,
0.5957478881,
0.1509772986,
-0.1716532558,
-0.2751704156,
0.2441976219,
-0.3527467251,
0.1721424609,
0.2681676149,
-0.2846116126,
-0.2979695499,
0.3229354918,
0.1454707682,
0.0943586528,
0.0337225869,
0.777305305,
0.0118277976,
-0.6366074085,
0.3869145215,
0.0647492409,
0.7958065867,
-0.6379821897,
-0.0534437336,
-0.2621198893,
0.3017451465,
-0.7430297732,
-0.5892578363,
0.4919033051,
0.3411380947,
-0.3139721751,
-0.028503187,
0.8470996618,
-0.4920431674,
-0.5562288165,
0.4236731231,
0.2178744078,
0.0549140833,
-0.2521908581,
-0.5527243018,
-0.0396137945,
0.287073642,
-0.6843883991,
0.158724457,
0.656678915,
0.1621659845,
0.5265988111,
0.7755445242,
0.0644825697,
-0.066087462,
0.4654712677,
0.9019361138,
-0.6832057238,
-0.3964942098,
-0.7731647491,
0.6871598959,
-0.4927931726,
-0.1341079921,
0.8411705494,
0.8098641634,
0.806237638,
0.0337954499,
0.6187019944,
-0.0129980566,
0.6570745111,
-0.2198278606,
0.8109455109,
-0.4921114445,
0.1654272676,
-0.1441032887,
-0.8684169054,
-0.3567021191,
0.8024363518,
-0.1482387781,
-0.4740088284,
0.4915416837,
0.5928704739,
-0.0021006761,
0.2147477716,
0.0168225262,
0.098952733,
0.3274007738,
0.18194969,
0.8023674488,
-0.5290311575,
0.5104340911,
-0.6358422041,
0.1606907994,
0.1021190062,
-0.4312859476,
-0.6301999092,
-0.3871212602,
-0.505361557,
-0.4152980149,
-0.0509086326,
1.0918594599,
0.4203258753,
-0.7465254068,
-0.0302056354,
-0.1751477122,
0.0861168578,
-0.3652589321,
-0.2813613713,
0.4855807126,
-0.4462276995,
-0.4175913632,
0.4851690829,
0.0881799236,
-0.3448093832,
-0.2569835484,
-0.0648927316,
-0.1228151843,
0.2499097586,
0.7504098415,
-0.1187957898,
-0.4670149088,
-0.2281129509,
-0.3282064199,
-0.0770405084,
0.0581339709,
0.755166173,
-0.8549286127,
0.6473436952,
0.7713965774,
0.3443806469,
0.777564168,
0.028849721,
0.5198330879,
-0.7905653715,
0.1497279108,
0.0428041406,
0.2165911347,
0.4027358294,
-0.4370373785,
0.6140636206,
0.1804192513,
0.0058357078,
-1.0959657431,
0.0396362841,
-0.8760021925,
-0.7892229557,
0.8781667948,
0.2034818977,
-0.0465540625,
-0.3826830983,
-0.4201015532,
0.4294271171,
-0.0243007541,
1.0296753645,
0.7112302184,
-0.0247253142,
-0.1394793987,
-0.3939538896,
0.6972651482,
0.1760300398,
-0.9688909054,
0.2206698358,
0.5477823615,
0.6071522236,
0.4790105224,
0.3059206605,
0.0919510871,
0.3673899174,
0.1280158311,
0.0237608273,
-0.1277840734,
-0.2664899528,
-0.1865153462,
0.6168888211,
-0.2358475775,
-0.1817337424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08997v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08997v1
|
Labeled Morphological Segmentation with Semi-Markov Models
| 2024-04-13T12:51:53 | 2024-04-13T12:51:53 |
Ryan Cotterell, Thomas Müller, Alexander Fraser, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present labeled morphological segmentation, an alternative view of
morphological processing that unifies several tasks. From an annotation
standpoint, we additionally introduce a new hierarchy of morphotactic tagsets.
Finally, we develop \modelname, a discriminative morphological segmentation
system that, contrary to previous work, explicitly models morphotactics. We
show that \textsc{chipmunk} yields improved performance on three tasks for all
six languages: (i) morphological segmentation, (ii) stemming and (iii)
morphological tag classification. On morphological segmentation, our method
shows absolute improvements of 2--6 points $F_1$ over the baseline.
|
[
-0.1982071698,
-0.6712703705,
0.2785407007,
0.1837979108,
-0.671212554,
0.193828553,
-0.0138544189,
-0.8050312996,
0.2700083256,
0.2969565392,
-0.5842600465,
-0.7317931652,
-0.323767215,
0.1815038919,
-0.2515746951,
0.7567731142,
0.3616972864,
0.3117803931,
0.1142647043,
0.2369503677,
-0.3446249664,
-0.312998414,
-0.6771306396,
-0.5666448474,
0.6146366,
0.0892369747,
0.8034582734,
1.3824548721,
0.4433172643,
0.3029409647,
-0.2694901526,
0.1238267049,
0.2625773847,
0.3751105368,
-0.0921947956,
-0.7759361863,
-0.2572215497,
-0.0563809611,
0.5993288159,
0.8068714142,
-0.0463927835,
-0.1034731716,
-0.4047990739,
0.2925138474,
-0.3560448587,
0.2175464928,
-0.693271935,
0.1637391001,
-0.5430774689,
-0.3740117848,
-0.5588861704,
0.0270055812,
-0.0173661094,
-0.4363309443,
-0.0157317556,
-0.3053680658,
0.7669685483,
0.212228179,
-0.0768788233,
0.0626690313,
-0.6358016133,
0.7599477768,
-0.3398725092,
0.2175098956,
0.4302852154,
0.0969510302,
-0.037199676,
-0.6001987457,
0.1394087821,
-0.2500164807,
0.3896335065,
0.175887078,
-0.2428843826,
0.186048314,
0.2923286557,
0.2160938233,
-0.2435714602,
0.537828207,
-0.2741543055,
-0.4248856008,
0.6828193665,
0.1385259926,
0.759595871,
-0.258202076,
-0.363008678,
0.0303682685,
-0.4854460359,
-0.1217732951,
0.3965253532,
0.1978643239,
0.126349777,
0.8196595311,
-0.0508584417,
0.9702854156,
-0.1628604829,
-0.3661681116,
0.3074589074,
-0.000797849,
-0.0991430357,
0.0567306392,
0.4718680084,
0.2383106202,
0.1855322868,
-0.1356412321,
-0.2782272398,
0.2824476361,
0.2236008942,
-0.4040338099,
-0.7918887734,
-0.0070150588,
-0.5426219106,
-0.1661759615,
-0.1893723607,
-0.5576390624,
-0.3592692316,
-0.1943788975,
0.1587064713,
-0.8552062511,
-0.2342235148,
0.0504890792,
-0.2913392186,
0.3371793628,
0.6157411337,
-0.8963791728,
0.2069168389,
0.7000044584,
1.3129388094,
-0.3401125968,
-0.0397292301,
-0.1520076245,
0.031345021,
-0.6260704994,
1.356546998,
-1.1950970888,
-0.4860490561,
-0.2064572126,
-0.0073955962,
0.0160994977,
-0.7464341521,
0.2685676217,
-0.1609356105,
-0.3677020967,
0.1078012511,
-0.5416695476,
-0.2962061167,
0.1451820284,
-0.6099594831,
1.1576925516,
-0.1294597536,
-0.7949053049,
0.2518402636,
-0.6767026782,
-0.548258841,
0.4661723673,
-0.1802616864,
-0.1055637151,
0.2121848017,
-0.0880486369,
0.6394455433,
0.0203958731,
0.1145881638,
-0.3052248359,
0.115475215,
0.3468878269,
0.0056158789,
0.9315097332,
0.3470321596,
-0.2044176012,
0.4395754933,
-1.0899677277,
0.0195746217,
0.0000866377,
-0.5197792649,
-0.7451501489,
0.1962815523,
0.0075247493,
0.3007367253,
0.1217181161,
-0.7444052696,
0.4146783352,
-0.5549025536,
0.3759256303,
0.5021089911,
-0.0201083981,
0.4052515626,
-0.2751463056,
0.4672980011,
0.2201485336,
-0.0204557236,
-0.3377814293,
-1.0484868288,
-0.7402173877,
-0.7606196404,
0.6034346819,
0.3793590069,
-1.0010145903,
0.3633521199,
-0.0314659104,
-0.6985734105,
-0.3388409317,
-0.4814062715,
0.4479832351,
0.1679036021,
0.1790023148,
-0.5859206319,
-0.6440854073,
-1.2675646544,
0.0201113317,
-0.274064362,
-0.0732667595,
-0.3257142007,
0.597383976,
-0.0289609376,
0.6908154488,
-0.4710640013,
-0.0614535697,
-0.1211264357,
0.5836546421,
-0.0346393846,
0.7435881495,
0.1257264018,
-0.7703410983,
-0.3169237971,
0.2743807435,
-0.0475430004,
-0.2742429078,
0.08302854,
0.0641200542,
0.2650363445,
0.2431915253,
-0.5670801997,
0.3663848639,
0.1903648973,
0.0569032691,
0.4127549231,
-0.4320871532,
-0.1517868638,
-1.0157953501,
-0.0659944117,
0.1195718125,
-0.3038470447,
-0.954764843,
-0.0064836978,
0.0799458921,
0.167322576,
-0.5630910993,
0.4268610477,
-0.6510070562,
-0.3726076782,
-0.3555660844,
-0.2117767632,
-0.6084890962,
0.3459953368,
0.5890883803,
0.3137539327,
0.9235770702,
-0.5735436082,
0.2594940662,
0.0968525335,
-0.3441211283,
0.3780804276,
-0.289491266,
-0.0071514328,
-0.0515660942,
0.1494331807,
-1.1770147085,
-0.2532384992,
0.46682477,
-0.6071954966,
0.1107436195,
-0.4196232855,
-0.8211997151,
-0.0513461791,
-0.3632379174,
0.2721732259,
0.4989597499,
-0.3811148703,
0.3082394898,
0.8497443795,
0.108809121,
-0.1366595924,
-0.7233752012,
-0.0435291976,
-0.24449265,
-0.3535333574,
0.4704190195,
0.0707839802,
-0.2412534058,
-0.1192327812,
-0.174001947,
-0.4939416647,
0.280875206,
0.3172252476,
0.2871526182,
-0.0652034432,
0.3299795389,
-0.0991136134,
-0.3074884713,
-0.1744484901,
-0.5332632661,
0.6979084015,
0.4147081375,
-0.1399000585,
-0.3569069207,
0.2534706295,
0.03369122,
-0.7836318016,
0.2693184018,
0.5473537445,
-0.8254363537,
-0.1360264421,
-0.1958966702,
0.2128657252,
-0.3387078643,
0.406688422,
-0.6337830424,
-0.7291023731,
0.5751889944,
-0.1828120202,
0.1013071463,
0.7808645368,
0.8452100158,
-0.1256978363,
1.4240978956,
0.5317733884,
0.4955578744,
0.4976122081,
-0.1253406554,
-0.0331761651,
-0.6512361765,
-0.6134387851,
-0.8370999098,
-0.2567273378,
-0.8147625923,
-0.7062674165,
-0.0269061793,
-0.1147606522,
0.394662261,
0.2783812582,
-0.8105431199,
0.4838069081,
0.4452970326,
0.0702440292,
0.110918358,
0.0407301076,
-0.4334339201,
0.0796580315,
-0.5457606912,
-0.715254128,
0.5755595565,
0.4990262389,
0.938215971,
-0.0294181481,
0.769762516,
0.2588392496,
0.1307826042,
-1.1018497944,
0.6817121506,
-0.2944147587,
-1.0080958605,
-0.2231656164,
-0.2184695899,
-1.1739333868,
0.6076558828,
-0.0893614441,
-1.3177933693,
0.2382425517,
0.0993558615,
-0.4376026988,
0.3816820979,
-0.744107306,
0.7528170347,
-0.1058563665,
0.1757499725,
-0.1703016013,
-0.6658740044,
0.2801951468,
-0.0442399345,
0.0932327285,
-0.7503641844,
-0.6518486738,
1.2014645338,
-0.1099521518,
0.9230167866,
-0.1370987445,
0.0003679897,
0.0685548782,
0.261824131,
-0.0521101914,
-0.1262246072,
0.269944191,
0.1975666583,
0.4987101257,
-0.2102779448,
-0.2193653136,
0.458122015,
-0.3393884897,
-0.357588321,
-0.623042345,
-0.5800486207,
-0.0452411287,
0.3635385931,
0.1815658808,
0.5002877712,
-0.0013739243,
-0.0429101251,
0.6968121529,
-0.0950702727,
0.5455364585,
0.3265253305,
-0.2980572283,
-0.0327461325,
0.6320512295,
0.2132827342,
0.0910064653,
0.7210314274,
0.2134962827,
-0.3368707001,
-0.8622721434,
-0.1219539121,
0.3321782053,
-0.7778827548,
-0.2032460421,
-0.8500382304,
-0.1198798493,
-0.0885113776,
0.3203813732,
-0.4848876297,
-0.7086228728,
-0.251621902,
0.15080598,
0.1027720943,
0.9421947002,
-0.2490839511,
0.4070639312,
-0.7811171412,
0.3339819014,
-0.1234896183,
0.3139307499,
-0.3000382781,
-0.4338300228,
-0.2651546001,
-0.0580482371,
-0.2493604869,
-1.216925621,
0.3409449458,
0.0762126967,
0.5608597994,
0.3552723825,
-0.2676530778,
0.7999541759,
-0.7965478301,
0.542504251,
0.2558715045,
-0.7683370113,
0.5605996847,
-0.2264115214,
0.678625226,
0.0214777421,
0.482747227,
-0.4751577973,
-0.5112251639,
-0.6972398758,
-0.5853962898,
0.9727442861,
0.2084376216,
0.0477690995,
-0.4819835722,
0.1446633637,
0.4280720651,
-0.3266000152,
-0.4605956376,
-0.2989973128,
0.2335773706,
-0.0636776462,
-0.1289831996,
-0.5093121529,
0.0696066171,
-0.5268856883,
0.7755920291,
0.0088978931,
0.3687118292,
0.0472504348,
-0.3014962673,
0.0254645422,
0.1953125,
0.7777315378,
0.8333477974,
-0.0790617093,
0.6005110741,
-0.1439915895,
-0.3492521942,
0.2322999835,
0.0628764704,
-0.0195682291,
0.439130336,
0.502887547,
0.4586287141,
0.3025451601,
-0.3583569825,
-0.0095132384,
0.0447025299,
-0.1533107758,
-0.0312007982,
0.0794619396,
0.2981525362,
0.2776473761,
0.0522213019,
0.1882500201,
0.3737804592,
-0.4566296041,
0.3724904954,
0.4437149465,
-0.3192833364,
-0.5764727592,
0.2314425558,
0.1513401568,
-0.5877099037,
0.1996120811,
0.0161880888,
-0.5459329486,
0.5311048031,
0.6047166586,
0.743922174,
-0.7653896213,
0.464017719,
0.3771772385,
0.3097749054,
-0.1496540308,
0.2190051377,
-0.2819067836,
-0.6072525978,
-0.3442384601,
-0.6430442333,
-0.1707285643,
-0.0327852853,
-0.4991260469,
0.1916381121,
-0.4241680205,
-0.3531812429,
0.9425546527,
-0.1912592798,
-0.2488519251,
0.4325014353,
0.3810422421,
0.9912418723,
-0.708661437,
1.2187532187,
1.2875283957,
-0.1456696093,
-0.4253420532,
-0.2868659794,
0.0160799883,
-0.9784770012,
0.6593996286,
0.3988447189,
-0.0149602368,
0.077085115,
-0.3518528044,
-0.8032619357,
0.522913754,
0.2864832282,
-0.3266111612,
0.1054199114,
-0.044946067,
0.6852030754,
-0.4871551991,
0.2475796491,
0.6008039117,
0.3966486156,
0.2738795578,
-0.7963261008,
-0.3171184063,
-0.3080617487,
0.4241216481,
0.5742793083,
-0.028391324,
0.6851756573,
0.0146952048,
-0.5785918236,
0.2198674083,
0.4394035935,
-0.1704933792,
-0.2473890334,
0.5798957944,
0.3659702539,
0.6710956693,
-0.2746629715,
0.9217034578,
0.0417313501,
0.3801850975,
0.9300063252,
0.285625428,
0.7080693245,
0.5357636809,
-0.1428811401,
0.0073457579,
1.4183892012,
-0.1224241853,
0.4562255442,
0.339687705,
0.023864802,
-0.7975773811,
-0.3750675023,
-0.088143602,
0.7499257326,
0.1548967063,
-0.2154585421,
-0.4151766896,
-0.0188439582,
0.0517060347,
-0.0954427868,
-0.395280242,
0.7635578513,
-0.0065818368,
-0.546512723,
0.5017399788,
0.4898008108,
0.5642436743,
-0.5275866985,
-0.337198168,
0.0366006196,
-0.0606190152,
-0.331050843,
-0.9524594545,
0.4320527017,
-0.0157679375,
0.0765720978,
-0.0518835187,
0.8716832995,
-0.462268889,
-0.4591959417,
0.2046229392,
0.2658197284,
0.6444812417,
0.134181723,
-0.8325905204,
0.1646213979,
0.0620595664,
0.1181599721,
0.0366681963,
0.1654513329,
-0.3063055277,
0.9262480736,
0.3214516938,
0.0544715002,
0.5303083658,
-0.0127805015,
0.5517305136,
-0.571151495,
-0.6284644604,
-0.9921204448,
0.5643594265,
-0.003041669,
-0.0954629779,
0.5086302757,
0.6193295121,
1.0659085512,
-0.3465456665,
0.3636886477,
-0.175031513,
0.3879602849,
-0.617148757,
0.238308832,
-0.579831183,
0.0320479162,
-0.0921166241,
-1.0492728949,
-0.8888796568,
0.6527302861,
-0.3566264212,
0.0820261538,
0.9451401234,
0.5278379917,
-0.0169360954,
-0.1830448806,
0.7915646434,
-0.0481927395,
0.0678273812,
0.2326373011,
1.3845473528,
0.3009835482,
0.1143053845,
-0.6633823514,
-0.2786519527,
0.081497319,
-0.4274740219,
-1.1218212843,
-0.9847083092,
-0.5671709776,
0.2306993157,
-0.006789939,
0.8519633412,
0.7887504101,
-0.6696379185,
-0.3129734099,
0.4271782339,
-0.0019325528,
-0.0536024459,
-0.1192285419,
0.1708287895,
-0.5359771848,
-0.7535122037,
0.1324648112,
0.9167420268,
0.0176286455,
0.0744903013,
0.2231554687,
-0.737501502,
0.0211801175,
0.3130372167,
0.0632733703,
-0.9988206625,
-0.3118997514,
-0.3833886087,
0.0457276478,
0.6427721977,
0.8948462605,
-0.2138283104,
0.6613253355,
0.3134025037,
0.5552008748,
0.3700556159,
-0.0278040115,
0.0582442731,
-0.4972765148,
0.0865148529,
0.2311760932,
0.3761242926,
0.3794001043,
-0.0461356156,
0.4078217447,
0.2591450214,
-0.0025810176,
-0.6572734714,
0.4555454254,
-0.9436507225,
-0.4282093644,
1.003788352,
-0.2688240409,
-0.5325777531,
-0.2404165715,
-0.3014388084,
0.5648984909,
-0.1882123947,
0.4594120681,
0.6929014325,
-0.3300465643,
-0.3636213541,
-0.2795613408,
0.4226668477,
0.2886979282,
-1.0492378473,
-0.1831461489,
0.5203747749,
0.3221276402,
0.369156301,
0.6790585518,
-0.4165973663,
0.2547825575,
-0.1573224515,
0.2991515696,
0.1432042122,
-0.5208154321,
-0.6417369843,
-0.0884670839,
0.4740629792,
-0.6943969727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08977v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08977v2
|
RoNID: New Intent Discovery with Generated-Reliable Labels and Cluster-friendly Representations
| 2024-04-13T11:58:28 | 2024-04-18T06:54:55 |
Shun Zhang, Chaoran Yan, Jian Yang, Changyu Ren, Jiaqi Bai, Tongliang Li, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
New Intent Discovery (NID) strives to identify known and reasonably deduce
novel intent groups in the open-world scenario. But current methods face issues
with inaccurate pseudo-labels and poor representation learning, creating a
negative feedback loop that degrades overall model performance, including
accuracy and the adjusted rand index. To address the aforementioned challenges,
we propose a Robust New Intent Discovery (RoNID) framework optimized by an
EM-style method, which focuses on constructing reliable pseudo-labels and
obtaining cluster-friendly discriminative representations. RoNID comprises two
main modules: reliable pseudo-label generation module and cluster-friendly
representation learning module. Specifically, the pseudo-label generation
module assigns reliable synthetic labels by solving an optimal transport
problem in the E-step, which effectively provides high-quality supervised
signals for the input of the cluster-friendly representation learning module.
To learn cluster-friendly representation with strong intra-cluster compactness
and large inter-cluster separation, the representation learning module combines
intra-cluster and inter-cluster contrastive learning in the M-step to feed more
discriminative features into the generation module. RoNID can be performed
iteratively to ultimately yield a robust model with reliable pseudo-labels and
cluster-friendly representations. Experimental results on multiple benchmarks
demonstrate our method brings substantial improvements over previous
state-of-the-art methods by a large margin of +1~+4 points.
|
[
-0.5552936196,
-0.7833050489,
0.7821483016,
-0.1194009706,
-0.3571137488,
-0.2804688513,
-0.2683009803,
-0.2413113117,
0.3722037375,
0.080979839,
-0.5166175961,
-1.0494390726,
-0.4256579876,
-0.0170737188,
-0.1752900481,
0.869594574,
-0.0260114484,
-0.1693088114,
-0.2089690715,
-0.1757161468,
-0.4113225639,
-0.2135847509,
-0.7478609085,
-0.1498067677,
0.8207066655,
0.5924561024,
0.0962066427,
0.5416252017,
0.2774715424,
0.1910903007,
-0.1337173134,
0.3868780732,
-0.6028473377,
0.1002073959,
-0.1754233986,
-0.2018835247,
-0.672975421,
0.0012315543,
0.5445488095,
0.6197192669,
-0.2253397703,
0.1655266881,
-0.0609550476,
0.5021702647,
-0.6613807678,
0.0842004195,
-0.7071951032,
-0.2472242415,
-0.3340593576,
-0.1289119273,
-0.8140846491,
-0.3068816662,
0.2469655424,
-0.9745796323,
0.1499211639,
0.31275931,
0.7433100939,
0.0523847826,
-0.364410162,
-0.2399366349,
-0.7767208219,
1.0555405617,
-0.493050456,
0.3511953354,
0.4258944392,
0.5204100013,
-0.1618073583,
-0.5162421465,
-0.379444629,
-0.1442221552,
-0.0608226806,
-0.0786410049,
0.1478350461,
-0.0071963351,
-0.0433291458,
0.0148853306,
-0.6288366914,
-0.1962678134,
0.0706235617,
-0.1152349263,
0.7126767635,
0.0719853565,
0.1420221329,
0.1889424324,
-0.6261710525,
-0.2067918032,
-0.9473178983,
0.0800041258,
0.2696315348,
0.442102313,
-0.0346777476,
0.5750419497,
-0.0958259851,
0.6094872952,
0.4973390996,
-0.0280123409,
0.3334797025,
-0.4073442221,
0.1433944851,
0.4780808985,
0.4776442349,
0.3295018375,
-0.2281662226,
-0.3290120065,
-0.3520831466,
-0.0031467814,
0.3323726952,
-0.8553324342,
-0.2065507919,
0.3097442389,
-0.8878446817,
-0.1421349347,
0.2554048002,
-0.4707238674,
-0.1330917031,
-0.3419131041,
0.8346542716,
-0.5538964272,
-0.4680121839,
0.0822911784,
-0.1328239739,
0.245624274,
0.5073639154,
-0.6719099283,
0.0007985978,
0.5998901129,
0.7863326669,
-0.3834799826,
-0.0024088738,
-0.5377748013,
0.5629833341,
-0.5373384953,
0.9679327011,
-0.5999958515,
-0.5231203437,
-0.2124378234,
-0.0366257504,
-0.0782770514,
-0.4970043004,
0.5091765523,
-0.4305813909,
0.0354718156,
-0.4516132474,
-0.5809589624,
-0.3614833057,
0.5886700749,
-0.6550947428,
0.7697723508,
0.1967180669,
-0.6812620759,
0.5700172186,
-0.9575837851,
-0.4621558189,
-0.0623850413,
-0.2502878606,
-0.6115138531,
0.132827431,
-0.0995274186,
0.5076949,
-0.0113664875,
0.352514863,
-0.4922222495,
-0.5790397525,
0.2401298583,
-0.3087699413,
0.5440894961,
0.0407630689,
-0.2896209359,
0.4670650959,
-0.9863786101,
-0.1399728954,
0.0388688594,
-0.174985826,
-0.5709670782,
0.0044576949,
-0.1609337926,
0.0010137422,
0.3836266398,
-0.9296244979,
0.036419902,
-0.0497191139,
-0.1579903662,
1.0115190744,
0.2085951418,
0.708419919,
-0.3436933756,
0.2369455844,
0.0543518811,
0.4928069413,
-0.0640030801,
-0.6597355008,
-0.3712522388,
-0.2194542438,
0.2567879558,
0.2582497597,
-0.7630807757,
0.4627404809,
-0.3288701475,
-0.4810656905,
-0.0490274914,
-0.049359832,
0.3453960419,
0.2826221585,
0.5091032982,
-0.177717194,
-0.2836984396,
-0.6105758548,
-0.0054160506,
-0.1136085913,
0.2150383741,
0.53640908,
0.267279923,
-0.5550863147,
1.0176575184,
-0.2374782115,
-0.489307493,
-0.3912704289,
0.2416864038,
0.3442662358,
0.3766742349,
0.523665905,
-0.9143398404,
-0.669219017,
0.3198681474,
-0.3867788315,
-0.0693130121,
-0.0403853878,
-0.4527550042,
0.0032797724,
0.5092610121,
-0.355289042,
0.5384383798,
0.2583549917,
-0.4546287358,
0.3882041276,
-0.0312542804,
0.1233404353,
-1.0445878506,
0.108032316,
0.0895634219,
0.0885704309,
-0.5160642862,
-0.659850955,
0.0440283455,
0.2455767244,
-0.5829485655,
0.60092026,
-0.3835516572,
0.2046166807,
-0.3517791033,
-0.154098317,
-0.0955155045,
0.3092099726,
0.177749455,
0.5463261008,
0.5812774301,
-0.9879572988,
-0.1875374913,
0.2085722536,
-0.1705085188,
0.7332726717,
-0.4171666205,
0.0328664407,
-0.3679114878,
0.1647872925,
-1.2519534826,
-0.3166935146,
0.4048671722,
-0.5135074854,
0.6696481109,
-0.4183907211,
-0.2495383918,
0.1074732766,
-0.4163287878,
0.8048833609,
0.3437957764,
-1.0095903873,
0.9492550492,
0.3902605474,
0.1476810724,
-0.4152102768,
-0.3724426329,
-0.3881919682,
-0.3674961925,
-0.6199969053,
0.7520805001,
0.0457144082,
0.0462505184,
0.1617274582,
-0.0963388011,
0.0459357202,
-0.0386877358,
0.3316318095,
0.1870353371,
-0.0729730949,
0.0544333234,
0.1960339397,
-0.4956626594,
0.0623122118,
-0.1346565485,
0.5373803377,
0.2200997472,
-0.5095757842,
-0.4446763694,
0.6014537215,
0.4977837801,
-0.2343629301,
0.7817677855,
1.0143710375,
-0.2850126326,
-0.6559906006,
-0.1312054098,
-0.3456718028,
-0.4829988182,
0.1553335786,
-0.4485044777,
-0.8330913782,
0.2493099123,
-0.6433397532,
0.2854799926,
0.1789285541,
0.1886161566,
-0.0939443037,
1.1932810545,
0.5847008228,
0.3513788581,
0.5878694057,
-0.3776394129,
0.6357855201,
-1.2875890732,
-0.5393803716,
-0.3030651808,
-0.4120577872,
-0.2489640415,
-0.4922509789,
0.6720747948,
-0.0070114573,
0.0614704005,
0.2694895267,
-0.6101384163,
0.1192702726,
0.6089397669,
0.1384257823,
0.0381659046,
0.1322488487,
-0.2759189606,
0.1093413308,
-0.6879604459,
-0.5656626821,
1.627904892,
0.0836688131,
0.9877058864,
0.4432450831,
1.2222177982,
0.2818729281,
0.5312556028,
-0.4972084463,
0.6558720469,
-0.0786322057,
-0.6688066125,
-0.1165887043,
-0.348162353,
-1.0029587746,
-0.010867754,
-0.233291328,
-0.8003090024,
0.5751615763,
0.3795135617,
-0.3623391986,
0.2916111946,
-0.8646496534,
0.775981307,
-0.310666889,
-0.761406064,
-0.1805485189,
-0.4690000117,
0.3084459603,
0.1876311451,
0.0739216134,
-0.2016057223,
0.0964907855,
0.6049134731,
-0.0541771092,
0.7774705887,
-0.5636659265,
-0.2144747525,
0.5093538165,
0.0546927601,
0.686016798,
0.2060433179,
-0.0289179739,
0.0503935963,
-0.255897969,
-0.1377278715,
-0.4317791462,
0.8236449957,
-0.3223049045,
-0.2204652429,
-0.2912770808,
-0.2257066816,
0.0991109684,
0.2560802698,
0.3376149833,
0.6289514899,
-0.4716840386,
0.1772696376,
1.0574874878,
-0.2324992418,
0.4118051529,
0.2777846456,
-0.3405347764,
-0.4247134328,
1.4325649738,
-0.0917994678,
0.1053009629,
0.4804958403,
0.0464577451,
-0.7299243212,
-0.7072439194,
-0.3908176422,
0.2017731071,
-0.4537605941,
-0.0901873559,
-0.5474043489,
0.1417129338,
-0.246733278,
-0.0980348811,
-0.6190863848,
-0.1476601809,
-0.3041307628,
0.0901996866,
0.0969745144,
0.7784317732,
-0.2075336874,
0.1832501292,
-0.4546650946,
0.473782599,
0.1748768389,
0.5397343636,
-0.1310189217,
-0.017873548,
-0.400673449,
-0.0704226419,
-0.1891272366,
-0.7989583611,
-0.0353418514,
0.0460380092,
0.8333183527,
0.8425574303,
0.2970741987,
0.1742912233,
-0.3198759854,
0.4895578921,
0.0581779368,
-0.5415639281,
0.549508214,
-0.2664180696,
-0.2077085227,
0.5849341154,
0.4486547112,
-0.1569933295,
0.3208588362,
-0.6030603647,
-1.0496621132,
0.6353381872,
0.1931496561,
-0.2592734993,
-0.4018100202,
0.3871757686,
0.3492045105,
0.1043408215,
-0.6834397912,
-0.5013123751,
-0.0306268204,
-0.4218288362,
0.1495324969,
-0.2826454341,
-0.0118977334,
-0.2145813853,
1.0633924007,
-0.107644923,
0.7275066972,
0.4247297347,
0.0879250243,
0.1111157462,
0.2103264034,
0.2840500772,
0.4234740734,
-0.5179411173,
0.2066261172,
-0.3018512726,
-0.3171932101,
0.4032293558,
-0.0200003963,
-0.4777932167,
0.3001838624,
-0.1876840144,
0.5977277756,
-0.1567695588,
-0.5690444112,
0.6993892193,
-0.2318555862,
-0.3401554227,
-0.3234517276,
0.3683236837,
-0.2022516727,
-0.0034174046,
0.144619137,
0.249611944,
0.4691116214,
-0.3076114058,
0.2673678696,
0.8122370243,
-0.4627560973,
-0.4516630471,
0.47301808,
0.2853249907,
-0.1717606634,
0.0595886521,
-0.9067556262,
-0.2937752604,
0.2756578028,
0.6938139796,
0.8939520121,
-0.4343712926,
0.5171661377,
0.7009888887,
0.2210730314,
-0.1559140831,
0.4133562446,
-0.3481865823,
-0.7641256452,
-0.2377508879,
-0.2515627146,
-0.1907897741,
-0.0968965739,
-0.6542906165,
0.3380446732,
-0.352789849,
-0.4238247275,
-0.4158834517,
-0.2389240861,
-0.4317675233,
0.1367139071,
-0.004124261,
0.4787720442,
-0.7934922576,
0.7618057132,
0.9434660673,
0.211440146,
-0.6458402276,
-0.1275634915,
0.0124925794,
-0.2465785891,
0.1018291041,
0.5525105,
-0.3304845691,
0.1916216612,
-0.4938222766,
-1.0380983353,
1.2967159748,
0.0238235667,
-0.6460701823,
0.2920604348,
-0.0734268501,
0.0268123914,
-0.5961598158,
0.1741638184,
0.187838465,
0.7160124779,
0.0819134563,
-0.1374939382,
0.1699088663,
-0.3255670667,
-0.0367470905,
0.4222146869,
-0.3633784354,
0.7377084494,
-0.33071509,
-0.468221128,
0.1511283368,
0.4569308162,
0.552377522,
0.8707838058,
0.6660658121,
0.7796918154,
0.7121595144,
-0.2538068295,
0.8705702424,
-0.2106647342,
0.1325089633,
0.9480712414,
-0.2883109152,
0.7175153494,
0.7298846841,
0.0429325141,
0.6382068396,
0.5983986259,
0.2457098812,
0.987724781,
0.1301671416,
-0.5465004444,
-0.2363337576,
-0.2087902725,
-0.1315139383,
-0.0114013087,
0.6649717689,
-0.3441724479,
-0.2078283429,
-0.0442200601,
-0.3964848518,
-0.0725157559,
-0.1083292738,
0.8303555846,
-0.3536325395,
-0.5405657887,
0.1954771429,
0.047913719,
0.8423303366,
-0.4025131166,
-0.5035620928,
0.0450163074,
0.2267708927,
-0.224526003,
-0.3537530899,
-0.0108846882,
-0.4598682523,
-0.250069499,
0.0608225875,
0.7285577059,
-0.5954563618,
-0.276355356,
0.3019840717,
0.1788831502,
-0.0261891037,
-0.1045366675,
-0.3560335636,
0.3273936808,
0.2572377324,
0.0218549892,
0.0818058997,
0.5297650099,
-0.1226154864,
0.3970166445,
0.8341675401,
-0.139636755,
0.2341784537,
0.0090823695,
0.6310151815,
-0.5214114189,
-0.3085803986,
-0.5387294292,
0.4571474493,
-0.2249462605,
-0.2866999805,
0.6763201952,
0.6079393029,
0.8386283517,
0.1446657032,
0.6850445271,
-0.2505219877,
0.5990614295,
-0.5492155552,
0.3986145258,
-0.4717588723,
0.4520877898,
-0.246067971,
-1.2000665665,
-0.1305322051,
0.9604118466,
-0.264921248,
0.2616800666,
0.6137865782,
0.9458478689,
-0.4339245558,
-0.0451018773,
0.1124967039,
0.1158024147,
0.620075047,
0.5764047503,
0.9934267402,
-0.3553984761,
0.3741820455,
-0.3822125793,
-0.2899177074,
-0.3148929179,
-0.7353454232,
-0.8760737181,
-0.6827797294,
-0.5528414249,
-0.027308736,
-0.1784195453,
0.7783688903,
1.1190979481,
-0.5835879445,
0.0292798467,
-0.4849048555,
0.200462386,
-0.183921665,
-0.3191512823,
0.5081179738,
-0.382302016,
-0.5699464083,
0.5562269688,
0.561203301,
0.2496664077,
-0.0603150576,
-0.5013765693,
-0.2402381152,
-0.0874006227,
0.6374281049,
0.0287279766,
-0.4420632124,
-0.1414681673,
-0.1039040163,
0.1974274665,
-0.052363921,
0.7961163521,
-0.601328671,
0.4130828679,
0.2483710945,
0.6609474421,
0.4752469063,
0.2055708766,
0.380158782,
-0.6463925242,
-0.1326825768,
0.1495236158,
0.1409973949,
0.352817297,
-0.3206092715,
0.3261143863,
0.0188463293,
-0.3998100758,
-0.6254290342,
0.2013980597,
-1.2847316265,
-0.3684814572,
1.2332845926,
-0.1127988249,
-0.7193686366,
-0.4160681963,
-0.4319243729,
0.0677405596,
-0.7329260111,
0.7073122859,
0.2398524284,
-0.4106892049,
0.0802273005,
-0.0232376233,
0.5212483406,
0.4310712516,
-0.5615621209,
-0.1703768969,
0.4697756171,
0.2283138931,
0.3149058223,
0.4916658998,
-0.4109832048,
0.2511898279,
-0.194111675,
-0.0006842227,
-0.1125581264,
-0.9266523123,
0.2624700069,
0.118606478,
0.1266943961,
-0.5472210646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08974v2
|
OOVs in the Spotlight: How to Inflect them?
| 2024-04-13T11:40:06 | 2024-05-28T10:21:38 |
Tomáš Sourada, Jana Straková, Rudolf Rosa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We focus on morphological inflection in out-of-vocabulary (OOV) conditions,
an under-researched subtask in which state-of-the-art systems usually are less
effective. We developed three systems: a retrograde model and two
sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models based on LSTM and Transformer. For
testing in OOV conditions, we automatically extracted a large dataset of nouns
in the morphologically rich Czech language, with lemma-disjoint data splits,
and we further manually annotated a real-world OOV dataset of neologisms. In
the standard OOV conditions, Transformer achieves the best results, with
increasing performance in ensemble with LSTM, the retrograde model and
SIGMORPHON baselines. On the real-world OOV dataset of neologisms, the
retrograde model outperforms all neural models. Finally, our seq2seq models
achieve state-of-the-art results in 9 out of 16 languages from SIGMORPHON 2022
shared task data in the OOV evaluation (feature overlap) in the large data
condition. We release the Czech OOV Inflection Dataset for rigorous evaluation
in OOV conditions. Further, we release the inflection system with the seq2seq
models as a ready-to-use Python library.
|
[
-0.2749506533,
-0.6832036972,
0.3559778929,
0.1200960875,
-0.4568260312,
0.2269854099,
-0.0863438621,
-0.6541247368,
0.0700687021,
0.6771070957,
-0.3696852624,
-0.1610406041,
-0.1976212412,
0.2880355418,
-0.4357862771,
0.8374964595,
0.1573793739,
0.3817875981,
-0.3109535873,
-0.2253199965,
-0.1625735909,
-0.2986967564,
0.171159029,
-0.5408743024,
-0.1047266722,
0.8252145052,
0.8422845006,
0.402785331,
0.5417544842,
0.1809760183,
-0.4216872156,
0.1555450559,
-0.2547217011,
0.3643518388,
-0.0963562801,
-0.234889701,
-0.3626272082,
-0.4919340909,
0.7590726018,
1.0303183794,
-0.0211603846,
-0.0149524678,
0.0530527756,
0.440395385,
-0.4064995646,
-0.1962762922,
-0.5944653749,
-0.0811747909,
-0.2984243035,
0.039864853,
-0.296890974,
-0.3396373093,
0.1785351783,
-0.3518439233,
-0.2003598809,
0.0515662618,
0.9663350582,
0.0426300876,
-0.0183903985,
-0.1880848557,
-0.6070227027,
0.523666203,
-0.8119086623,
0.5844985843,
0.1293596327,
0.1861086786,
-0.3662849963,
-0.653541863,
-0.4832946062,
-0.3067927957,
0.051041469,
0.2240543216,
-0.1846292466,
-0.0561368018,
0.1646023542,
0.4013252258,
-0.7168675661,
0.1950080246,
-0.5938124657,
0.1847556531,
0.386387229,
0.2080650777,
-0.0801959559,
-0.3311476111,
-0.4988511503,
-0.0136661939,
-0.9151543975,
0.1559252292,
0.7368984818,
0.6340199113,
0.4498566985,
0.9829770327,
-0.0198827051,
0.6255615354,
0.320941478,
-0.2029981762,
0.4647335112,
-0.6303355694,
-0.4190637171,
-0.0577675216,
0.4728029072,
-0.0545496605,
-0.0496547855,
-0.401807338,
-0.4284627736,
-0.1186035872,
0.1371654421,
-0.6295062304,
0.0697709247,
0.1437552273,
-0.1784303337,
-0.1270325184,
0.1366654038,
-0.8899760842,
-0.4569811821,
-0.1348315477,
0.8808192611,
-0.7981187105,
-0.3200194538,
0.4139975011,
-0.3128990829,
0.2130179256,
0.1364128888,
-0.7217416167,
0.8043130636,
0.5937507153,
0.7908516526,
-0.211464107,
0.0032299226,
-0.4313158989,
-0.4056158066,
-0.2938582301,
0.5915081501,
-0.5737114549,
-0.439212203,
0.1174585447,
-0.0598379895,
-0.0187380221,
-0.8572595119,
0.1122011021,
-0.1872833073,
0.1590745151,
0.3934001327,
-0.4947747588,
0.1172737926,
0.0643799976,
-0.3468303978,
1.4482895136,
0.47357288,
-0.566529274,
0.5034163594,
-0.4349538982,
-0.3792319596,
0.3171220124,
-0.0798641592,
-0.3375687301,
0.2780220211,
-0.064802438,
0.2588853836,
-0.301900655,
0.0895859078,
-0.112328656,
-0.1978285909,
0.1188791618,
0.1751419455,
0.8124734163,
0.0458793342,
-0.2672364116,
0.3345579803,
-0.8074924946,
-0.1975989193,
-0.0646136478,
-0.2032203525,
-0.4472462833,
-0.1661356539,
0.2164869159,
0.1588033289,
-0.1796821505,
-0.8202806711,
0.4276848137,
-0.8899464607,
0.8390287161,
0.1680712551,
-0.0312940404,
0.7322850227,
0.1815889478,
0.4913262725,
0.0944715515,
0.5598353148,
-0.3470871747,
-0.8107327819,
-0.5804647803,
-0.4497960806,
-0.0336244032,
0.5663833618,
-0.8919007182,
0.3855580688,
-0.2349101603,
-0.6888321042,
-0.4416731596,
0.0463616103,
0.526642859,
0.5920230746,
0.3874988258,
-0.4142751098,
-0.2808883786,
-0.8410944939,
-0.1135018468,
-0.2978225052,
0.356726855,
0.1315747201,
0.7652398348,
-0.0723261312,
1.1629300117,
-0.103681542,
-0.219424516,
-0.4020036757,
0.1373570561,
0.6183897257,
0.3997230232,
0.4032598436,
-1.000079155,
-0.3084745407,
0.1238437593,
-0.2319140285,
0.2244407684,
0.3393508196,
0.1815697253,
0.4854545891,
1.1019514799,
-0.54063344,
0.6934215426,
0.2758948207,
-0.5384630561,
0.5125169754,
-0.1116192266,
-0.2116796225,
-0.9301663041,
0.0574776307,
-0.2452053726,
-0.2667718828,
-0.8950027823,
0.0862050354,
0.2152803093,
-0.0109396381,
-0.7444248796,
0.4508995712,
-0.397788614,
0.0311195329,
0.2300041169,
0.0677930191,
-0.1997350007,
0.1957141608,
-0.0258475505,
0.2681298852,
0.6628575921,
-0.5388707519,
0.4061507285,
0.2464493811,
-0.6763159633,
0.4079396427,
-0.5999248028,
-0.0605511107,
-0.270132184,
-0.1815682352,
-1.4633607864,
-0.3821451962,
0.5304592848,
-0.4763857424,
0.653421104,
-0.4120443761,
-0.715946734,
-0.3598461151,
-0.2699144781,
0.7542355061,
0.5687748194,
-0.6324808598,
0.6232455969,
0.5185353756,
-0.0777559504,
-0.5052565336,
-0.7253898978,
0.0221625641,
-0.5406378508,
-0.6649580598,
0.4429176152,
0.0289289709,
-0.5819410086,
0.1346998364,
0.1375486553,
-0.1891425401,
-0.2159191668,
0.4365706742,
0.2624529004,
-0.2851983309,
0.3953078389,
-0.2883741856,
0.3145298362,
-0.383461982,
-0.5124736428,
0.5711002946,
-0.3142948449,
-0.2631415427,
0.0882902145,
0.0621725135,
0.62832582,
-0.0820797607,
0.3494653106,
0.121890679,
-0.4333066642,
0.0057492601,
-0.3839728236,
-0.2350694984,
-0.3653485775,
0.436121881,
-0.2489343584,
-0.6813895702,
0.50271523,
-0.0084211817,
0.1185397878,
0.38276124,
0.4376471937,
0.0690839961,
0.7803994417,
0.8458616734,
0.2523448765,
0.7095098495,
-0.2530941665,
0.0615731999,
-0.7671406865,
-0.4968836308,
-0.5035579801,
0.0964220986,
-0.5101181269,
-0.5189760923,
0.4995750189,
0.1509416103,
0.2452210784,
0.7362192273,
-0.2525853217,
0.1956980824,
0.1428222209,
-0.0914116055,
0.1131050289,
0.1085169315,
-0.2833022475,
0.0698817819,
-0.8248842955,
-0.2718167901,
0.761366725,
0.3938091397,
0.8952196836,
0.0858974159,
0.5690792799,
-0.1077640653,
0.0090539306,
-1.1766345501,
0.3934970498,
-0.1083618775,
-0.7072039843,
-0.7738426924,
-0.1020857543,
-1.1086593866,
0.2776188552,
-0.2417295575,
-0.7982983589,
0.7383852005,
0.0945302919,
-0.4844031036,
0.1672396213,
-0.1493939608,
0.7527367473,
0.0320546106,
-0.3958163559,
-0.0586210825,
-0.880872786,
0.2686566114,
0.0412252396,
0.4070946276,
0.0187748764,
-0.2088377476,
0.2728172541,
-0.4212138951,
0.9004707932,
0.089590244,
-0.1791446656,
0.2583798468,
-0.0045533446,
0.2907081246,
0.0799647197,
-0.1547252983,
0.2047655284,
-0.1692919731,
-0.0780817196,
-0.4462862909,
0.4415091276,
-0.374037385,
-0.2180623412,
-0.4452349544,
-0.3213116527,
-0.2419691384,
0.1890044063,
0.6688418388,
0.7407242656,
-0.6363484263,
0.2110909224,
0.6444448233,
0.0061272979,
0.4669646621,
0.3186593056,
-0.5256762505,
-0.6844995022,
0.7770036459,
0.4049189687,
0.5353805423,
0.3192041814,
0.241513297,
-0.2350747883,
-0.5620900989,
-0.7680808306,
0.4251005948,
-0.8729524016,
-0.1988370121,
-0.3556990921,
-0.1504522115,
-0.774704814,
0.2804298997,
-0.3332475126,
-0.7974489927,
-0.1233639345,
0.2594657838,
0.4014205039,
1.2012985945,
0.1118873358,
0.0201553833,
-0.4460961223,
0.0672405362,
-0.010384473,
0.0325666443,
-0.6182497144,
-1.1347980499,
-0.4632053077,
-0.3794754744,
-0.1614221483,
-0.8199961185,
0.6091085076,
0.5131542087,
0.4318424761,
0.4529280066,
-0.1419706792,
0.8066331744,
-0.6023419499,
0.7681016326,
0.1865959913,
-1.0354198217,
0.454111129,
-0.1093515605,
0.1552753299,
0.2903033197,
0.279653579,
-0.3849620223,
-0.6572059393,
-0.6602791548,
-1.4689230919,
0.56101197,
0.2714970112,
0.0102660889,
-0.154466629,
0.6310938597,
0.6134979129,
0.2571241558,
-0.2042236477,
0.0789166093,
-0.4052984416,
0.0466326587,
-0.4226623178,
0.0636045486,
0.0112150759,
-0.3713881671,
0.6319178939,
-0.3234440684,
-0.1460636854,
0.3928333819,
-0.4143437743,
-0.2631241083,
0.1354495585,
0.7687577605,
0.6246660352,
-0.2672779262,
0.1955565661,
0.2836936116,
-0.6476979852,
-0.1216405258,
-0.3521330059,
-0.1069024056,
0.3162360787,
0.3626665771,
0.7097852826,
0.4160528183,
-0.7633009553,
0.5539242625,
0.1756845117,
-0.3308919072,
-0.3256024122,
-0.1554079801,
-0.1745380014,
0.4605036676,
0.188659817,
0.3141514361,
0.2596036792,
-0.876121223,
-0.2214692086,
0.5289220214,
-0.6411325336,
-0.6214222908,
-0.0410601348,
-0.1290523112,
-0.1558524221,
0.6288758516,
0.0917794779,
-0.3794946671,
0.528093338,
0.6345641613,
0.7304189801,
-0.0795881376,
-0.097310856,
0.3533873856,
0.3302314281,
-0.4379307628,
0.5927927494,
0.0528483875,
-0.6128059626,
-0.1137770563,
-0.4353307486,
-0.3922760189,
0.021973839,
-1.0766963959,
0.5707657337,
-0.376334548,
-0.4060336351,
-0.0459222756,
-0.3640384674,
-0.4620757103,
0.1496105343,
-0.0177124981,
1.2225142717,
-0.8343095183,
0.7689655423,
1.0178151131,
-0.3714133799,
-0.1889358163,
-0.1109738871,
-0.1549755633,
-0.8138180971,
0.8985003233,
-0.0758925006,
-0.4081523716,
-0.0735532567,
-0.6181131005,
-1.0476623774,
0.8187221885,
0.5130956769,
-0.3021489084,
0.148464933,
0.0627066717,
0.5649818778,
-0.4849417508,
0.0364986658,
0.6913992763,
0.5868531466,
0.2085421234,
-1.0919458866,
-0.1861902326,
-0.3709210753,
-0.1975654364,
0.3580997288,
-0.3626119494,
1.0179233551,
-0.4232006073,
-0.2960725725,
0.5506359935,
0.5774773359,
-0.31285128,
0.0517880842,
0.520922184,
0.455414325,
0.6092060804,
-0.1046378314,
0.8168302774,
-0.0424465649,
0.0153483655,
0.799066484,
-0.1449432373,
1.1523672342,
1.0580239296,
0.2444521189,
0.350759387,
0.5581507683,
-0.0160108544,
0.5640021563,
0.2848309278,
0.1177854389,
-0.4176200926,
-0.265817225,
-0.3641316593,
0.5015212297,
0.5459700227,
-0.0824222043,
0.0863957331,
0.2405651808,
-0.1918611377,
0.0194402356,
-0.4060355127,
0.787406683,
-0.0200060401,
-0.6304967999,
0.5531017184,
-0.3291469216,
0.5339381099,
-0.5656406283,
0.0285531469,
-0.1904240698,
0.4487166703,
-0.3595988452,
-0.9437458515,
0.2246903479,
-0.2579688132,
-0.1626690924,
-0.2366100401,
0.4763755202,
-0.6767652035,
-0.4382522702,
0.4371623993,
0.3692661524,
0.5480595231,
0.0164092947,
-0.1433414966,
-0.0627228171,
-0.6390398741,
-0.0930843279,
0.2763769031,
0.5108731985,
-0.34021613,
0.4214555025,
0.0971778557,
0.2817093432,
0.1276310831,
0.2450065464,
1.1928505898,
-0.5842487812,
-0.2749199569,
-0.877058804,
0.5574179888,
0.1391064376,
-0.7685194612,
0.9283396006,
0.6853704453,
0.880849421,
-0.1341057718,
0.3841654658,
0.0653966516,
0.4350918233,
-0.5878814459,
0.311493367,
-1.0211213827,
-0.1733397245,
-0.3301924169,
-0.7185329795,
-0.653255403,
0.4181595743,
0.0564985946,
-0.3156653047,
0.5405642986,
0.8462622166,
-0.0613429695,
-0.2999912798,
0.7319681644,
0.4240014553,
0.1173077077,
0.2359030694,
1.1308995485,
-0.4312976897,
0.5820680857,
-0.152717188,
-0.2510235906,
-0.6896651387,
-0.8985402584,
-0.9441258311,
-0.7170531154,
-0.2487254441,
-0.4583134055,
0.1735724807,
1.1468187571,
0.7803393006,
-0.6743896008,
-0.606813252,
-0.0672749579,
-0.0725545213,
-0.4491879344,
-0.1085016951,
0.0970784873,
-0.4219879508,
-0.4771969318,
0.8471139669,
0.7809509039,
0.108528316,
-0.3212848604,
-0.1052491069,
0.0222220328,
0.2525914907,
0.5002118349,
0.4730077684,
-0.8528956175,
-0.0607960895,
0.4089255631,
0.041469045,
0.3074745834,
0.9492237568,
-0.8995466232,
0.590431869,
0.8113696575,
-0.1498831511,
0.323913008,
-0.189740777,
0.4059664011,
-0.5277513862,
0.2819437981,
0.5441563129,
0.4669740796,
0.4002804756,
-0.134660393,
0.3794326484,
0.3088694215,
-0.1399559677,
-1.2784729004,
0.3950837851,
-0.6606927514,
-0.2779445648,
1.1018412113,
-0.0025806052,
-0.3923649192,
-0.6158860922,
-0.1563532352,
0.1424149126,
-0.3210583627,
0.5456067324,
0.5282168984,
-0.3625992239,
0.1415105909,
-0.276563406,
0.6334401965,
0.3033043146,
-0.4739288092,
0.0513928607,
0.0665617958,
0.1697164625,
0.5313075781,
0.0218048282,
-0.5057719946,
0.3367515504,
0.006896893,
0.1415265054,
-0.1445466131,
-0.7152917981,
-0.8726804852,
0.0294517484,
0.0674371347,
0.1380527467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08958v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08958v1
|
AMU-Tuning: Effective Logit Bias for CLIP-based Few-shot Learning
| 2024-04-13T10:46:11 | 2024-04-13T10:46:11 |
Yuwei Tang, Zhenyi Lin, Qilong Wang, Pengfei Zhu, Qinghua Hu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recently, pre-trained vision-language models (e.g., CLIP) have shown great
potential in few-shot learning and attracted a lot of research interest.
Although efforts have been made to improve few-shot ability of CLIP, key
factors on the effectiveness of existing methods have not been well studied,
limiting further exploration of CLIP's potential in few-shot learning. In this
paper, we first introduce a unified formulation to analyze CLIP-based few-shot
learning methods from a perspective of logit bias, which encourages us to learn
an effective logit bias for further improving performance of CLIP-based
few-shot learning methods. To this end, we disassemble three key components
involved in computation of logit bias (i.e., logit features, logit predictor,
and logit fusion) and empirically analyze the effect on performance of few-shot
classification. Based on analysis of key components, this paper proposes a
novel AMU-Tuning method to learn effective logit bias for CLIP-based few-shot
classification. Specifically, our AMU-Tuning predicts logit bias by exploiting
the appropriate $\underline{\textbf{A}}$uxiliary features, which are fed into
an efficient feature-initialized linear classifier with
$\underline{\textbf{M}}$ulti-branch training. Finally, an
$\underline{\textbf{U}}$ncertainty-based fusion is developed to incorporate
logit bias into CLIP for few-shot classification. The experiments are conducted
on several widely used benchmarks, and the results show AMU-Tuning clearly
outperforms its counterparts while achieving state-of-the-art performance of
CLIP-based few-shot learning without bells and whistles.
|
[
-0.5232134461,
-0.8438110948,
0.1519970745,
-0.3008238375,
-0.5331061482,
0.1867575198,
-0.1271611005,
-0.607314229,
0.4222626686,
0.196271494,
-0.7947961092,
-0.4276797771,
-0.4124874771,
-0.1070574522,
0.0784370899,
0.8324506283,
0.2782406509,
0.3305400908,
0.287283659,
-0.3713707924,
-0.6609504223,
-0.3370476365,
-0.3514509499,
-0.3806536496,
0.1396377087,
0.5187660456,
0.4255732894,
0.6360427737,
0.4192687571,
0.1529299915,
-0.1288697124,
0.0183922555,
-0.642161727,
-0.5788193941,
0.2660233676,
-0.8799845576,
-0.3973081112,
-0.0394059755,
0.8018320203,
-0.0763077661,
0.0001548624,
0.1981508434,
0.211818561,
0.4429981112,
-1.0599691868,
-0.2545649409,
-0.9431903958,
0.1957645416,
-0.6113831401,
-0.3380075991,
-0.3497485816,
-0.1110575646,
-0.1756890714,
-0.6987356544,
0.5888986588,
0.2597352266,
1.0328799486,
0.3718636632,
-0.1964841336,
0.4651905894,
-0.4355646074,
1.0870962143,
-0.6411463618,
0.3766510487,
0.1213440821,
0.4190312922,
-0.0236685053,
0.0543590635,
-0.2718556523,
0.4621913433,
-0.0971137062,
0.1291936338,
-0.2012144327,
0.3163808286,
0.332260251,
0.159093827,
-0.391071558,
0.3943358362,
-0.2635184228,
-0.3921423256,
0.6514719129,
0.2272759825,
-0.0436395295,
-0.2556226552,
-0.5738619566,
-0.233403936,
-0.8816128373,
0.2249857187,
0.4741791785,
0.2273979336,
-0.1233792752,
0.3260325491,
-0.220251143,
0.859387219,
0.147547856,
-0.4909505546,
0.16598095,
-0.486630857,
-0.205707103,
0.1142590195,
0.5911585093,
0.5248847008,
0.1325982958,
0.2006258518,
-0.0815116391,
0.236700654,
0.2023719698,
-0.7010013461,
-0.3653656542,
-0.2207038701,
-0.3042610288,
-0.5833487511,
0.0817475915,
-0.9277424812,
0.0036181277,
-0.1517882347,
0.5590165854,
-0.4168074429,
-0.0312086139,
-0.2967195511,
-0.1045645103,
0.4339525402,
0.3297090828,
-1.0500799417,
0.1919741184,
0.5157957077,
0.9353109002,
-0.4016879797,
-0.4873066545,
-0.7033464909,
-0.0157388821,
0.0344252698,
1.0858393908,
-0.5177051425,
-0.3488632739,
0.0252875909,
-0.3126601875,
-0.2230467796,
-0.6122273207,
0.3670395017,
-0.1931900829,
-0.1851961911,
-0.1205730885,
-0.4533647895,
-0.4407419264,
0.1995114088,
-0.5153620839,
0.8037137389,
-0.1432748884,
-0.614466548,
0.9882394075,
-0.5173122287,
-0.3157401681,
0.1212523952,
-0.4124789238,
-0.7611987591,
0.1999916583,
0.6010146141,
0.3696052432,
0.1442137957,
-0.3319658339,
-0.5600096583,
-0.5785237551,
0.2776146531,
-0.3913749158,
0.642429173,
-0.2303446978,
-0.0971560851,
0.1344325244,
-0.7240158916,
0.2941200137,
-0.3594047427,
-0.1194834188,
-0.1319953054,
-0.2835204601,
0.1607558429,
-0.2427027822,
-0.2683471441,
-0.7546853423,
0.3168502152,
-0.4710898101,
0.2196459174,
0.7710338235,
0.1957323849,
0.5558382273,
-0.2658037245,
0.4221294522,
0.055500403,
0.3469086885,
-0.3019419909,
-0.3600179851,
-0.6547489166,
-0.596624732,
0.225014925,
0.6419097185,
-0.259037286,
0.1723942459,
0.1447640955,
-0.0279650167,
-0.6059044003,
0.6332595944,
0.5178954601,
0.3779524267,
0.482283473,
-0.4246840775,
-0.6889671087,
-0.7771174908,
-0.4114667773,
-0.2671306133,
-0.0385747589,
0.6916900277,
0.3126802146,
0.0500479899,
1.1024124622,
-0.9210804701,
-0.7695954442,
-0.1949508935,
0.2181241512,
0.1601451635,
0.3040501177,
0.6494079232,
-0.4539698064,
-0.3858449459,
-0.0378410555,
-0.7199885845,
-0.0310902186,
0.0149636334,
-0.4924289584,
0.0476422459,
0.0998341367,
-0.4744791389,
0.7921364307,
0.0766086057,
-0.2558226883,
0.5675255656,
0.3633835614,
0.0812901333,
-0.480690062,
-0.0378528088,
-0.01628864,
-0.386816889,
-0.3411128521,
-0.0010769906,
0.1957705021,
0.0099119563,
-0.907587409,
0.4230890274,
-0.023725532,
0.1174893677,
-0.6492388248,
-0.1753195226,
0.0584260486,
0.6686657071,
0.026716819,
0.4557622969,
0.6399267316,
-0.7980610132,
0.2083316147,
0.3520831168,
-0.2196698189,
0.650421083,
-0.4181513488,
0.0193247385,
0.1025558487,
0.1533269584,
-0.3978921175,
-0.1886138469,
0.2149441242,
-0.2512669563,
0.6576721072,
-0.553920567,
-0.2475080639,
-0.2441294044,
-0.5885108709,
0.6188117862,
0.4766085446,
-0.6772503257,
0.3754867911,
0.164302513,
0.4977040291,
-0.807387948,
-0.3692074716,
-0.5502102375,
-0.4379246533,
-0.4120818675,
0.3188795745,
0.1010301411,
0.0951108932,
0.033001624,
-0.3474716842,
-0.041308362,
0.0667066649,
0.214351207,
0.5575926304,
-0.3119870722,
-0.0205342229,
0.0492581278,
-0.2677532136,
-0.4496733844,
-0.1939179897,
0.0983183831,
-0.2163899839,
-0.2143299729,
-0.2452486753,
-0.0729535371,
0.0483816788,
-0.0454414487,
0.1752812862,
0.8549261093,
-0.1557368934,
-0.2617327273,
-0.8002592325,
-0.5753000975,
-0.4257004559,
0.3624540567,
-0.3595124483,
-0.876319468,
0.3006098866,
-0.0825631917,
0.0999313965,
0.2473003268,
0.5953412056,
-0.1926872879,
0.6372087598,
0.9411970973,
-0.4244441986,
0.7804106474,
-0.4022729993,
-0.1231555492,
-0.8756830096,
-0.0216485336,
-0.0244506616,
-0.7001019716,
-0.3520537317,
-0.23073636,
0.7018264532,
0.2849563062,
0.2521704435,
0.2976003289,
-0.2179682106,
0.9848906398,
0.5768132806,
0.4525151849,
0.3494018316,
-0.0618001632,
-0.1293729842,
-0.0122377491,
-0.8536106944,
-0.0831848159,
1.1118518114,
0.347735256,
1.3488520384,
-0.0816411227,
0.8405592442,
0.1499321163,
-0.2800982594,
-1.1176937819,
0.171045959,
-0.1030364037,
-0.8598645329,
-0.4809101522,
0.0206561889,
-0.53012079,
0.6118337512,
-0.7455384731,
-0.8640292287,
0.2825893462,
0.7651759982,
-0.4240114689,
0.3878662288,
-0.7444996238,
0.8084962368,
-0.3082482517,
-0.6794983745,
-0.370737195,
-0.6128119826,
0.7071815729,
-0.0013744493,
-0.2449899018,
-0.3871287405,
0.2473413646,
0.6430433393,
-0.4399514794,
1.021266818,
-0.0920694172,
0.5207790732,
0.4963303506,
-0.2076411098,
0.1643732488,
0.3929535151,
0.2584092915,
0.4363135695,
0.1056196392,
-0.6046504974,
-0.5852870345,
0.3728447556,
-0.6630327702,
-0.3486262262,
-0.2598895133,
-0.0366932116,
-0.0703214258,
0.3148248792,
0.8847556114,
0.4234911799,
-0.5260897279,
-0.1569978893,
0.5802364945,
0.3076691329,
0.5572114587,
0.4204861224,
-0.2091127187,
-0.3178995252,
0.7844965458,
-0.0541004576,
-0.0145646213,
0.5021333098,
0.3150190711,
-0.080965206,
-0.2758722305,
-0.6034577489,
0.3506093919,
-0.5625625849,
-0.7762483954,
-0.0785402358,
-0.045709718,
0.0313582234,
-0.2523430288,
-0.5478965044,
-0.2632513642,
-0.410585463,
-0.0656120405,
0.2664317191,
0.5675697327,
0.0533932038,
0.6737484336,
-0.6640815735,
0.2351191044,
0.4020052254,
0.4782732129,
-0.1314026117,
-0.4426684678,
-0.4438622594,
-0.1879563779,
-0.7482420802,
-0.6364998221,
0.1460992843,
0.7624930143,
0.639413476,
0.6783360839,
-0.1302392483,
0.8496209979,
-0.6679822206,
0.4522306621,
0.4423914552,
-0.9503099918,
0.8550963998,
0.1412937045,
0.5987792611,
0.886364162,
0.058575999,
0.2195224911,
-0.248066172,
-0.4824917018,
-0.4518405199,
1.0282804966,
0.2140018493,
-0.1343738735,
0.4783962369,
0.1370458305,
0.3927257359,
0.1269950569,
-0.5944646001,
-0.3287502229,
-0.4529360533,
0.2174291015,
-0.0193544347,
-0.2104768753,
-0.1167866811,
-0.3542388678,
0.7167677879,
-0.3895936906,
0.2145123333,
-0.1704280376,
-0.4552040696,
-0.4740733206,
0.4123617113,
0.5013145208,
0.5157124996,
-0.6215922236,
0.0446604267,
0.5133982301,
-0.6191317439,
0.2050293684,
-0.3709180057,
-0.6249143481,
0.1882893741,
0.2706534266,
1.300999999,
0.5685920715,
-0.3118900061,
0.6509556174,
0.1615125388,
-0.2161668688,
0.0541144237,
0.3391884565,
-0.8782305717,
0.3090078831,
0.448707968,
0.3015786409,
0.2334368825,
-0.2819751799,
0.4064587653,
0.8082873821,
-0.4238730669,
-0.6501476169,
0.5074049234,
0.325025022,
0.0021668051,
0.3445086777,
-0.0173578262,
-0.7474354506,
0.1379710585,
0.5473347306,
1.0247575045,
-0.0904386789,
0.0666589737,
0.6176981926,
0.2742658556,
0.1376899928,
-0.077897422,
-0.1796246171,
-0.8239855766,
-0.3237047493,
-0.7338961959,
-0.383787334,
0.0935034007,
-0.6890363693,
0.911180675,
-0.6431594491,
-0.4391423762,
0.0289709754,
-0.1035553962,
-0.9194812775,
-0.0566936284,
0.3306398392,
0.5968496799,
-1.1932086945,
0.8238495588,
0.8799758554,
-0.1637301743,
-0.4951502979,
0.0268843882,
0.4077306092,
-0.8931047916,
0.3851457536,
0.1706505567,
-0.3011699617,
0.0354407281,
-0.7366364598,
-0.6662724614,
0.9551141262,
0.2710779607,
-0.5092704296,
0.0390255451,
-0.4049061239,
0.04494958,
-0.3646411896,
0.3518941998,
0.6812748313,
0.0611833557,
0.4015728831,
-0.9698588252,
-0.2692373991,
0.0337100327,
-0.0686286017,
0.53929919,
-0.977186501,
0.3382773995,
-0.2744623125,
-0.1242082566,
-0.3426648676,
0.6431633234,
0.1099676192,
0.4775405526,
0.4170342684,
0.6449297071,
0.6476724148,
0.1175588518,
0.6426711082,
-0.0103259319,
0.5332356095,
0.8991467953,
0.1398648918,
0.9326986074,
0.4314719439,
-0.4780377746,
0.3798661828,
0.3088736236,
-0.3793711066,
0.7049588561,
-0.142146036,
-0.3561133444,
-0.4616857767,
0.0428821407,
-0.070434846,
0.734357059,
0.2237849683,
-0.0856105611,
-0.2801675797,
0.1409157068,
-0.2035674304,
-0.3844512403,
-0.3848420382,
1.0551532507,
0.193290174,
-0.3558749259,
0.7302568555,
-0.1413510144,
1.0428532362,
-0.5785530806,
-0.1124673933,
-0.006512898,
0.1574390233,
-0.6179195046,
-0.4088920057,
-0.0375945754,
0.0617546402,
-0.2456974089,
0.4049200118,
0.8695399165,
-0.1350249052,
-0.5432727337,
-0.15565148,
0.227390945,
0.0962498337,
0.1550390571,
-0.6037667394,
0.1785179824,
0.1579771489,
0.3159709871,
0.3902894557,
-0.0779649317,
0.1678887308,
0.4048315287,
0.1743733585,
0.018459823,
0.4696439803,
-0.2310599834,
0.7533475161,
-0.6242442131,
-0.5791346431,
-1.1484793425,
0.4265471995,
0.168119207,
-0.3930963874,
0.6813416481,
0.7583304644,
0.8280686736,
-0.2149030715,
0.8138554692,
0.058718659,
0.4725696445,
-1.0967162848,
0.3690180182,
-0.3119874597,
0.1453669071,
-0.4531148076,
-1.1022757292,
-0.4405702651,
0.7481328845,
-0.0777307004,
-0.302428484,
0.8039708734,
0.650239706,
-0.4104592204,
-0.1025103107,
0.5850697756,
-0.0577810816,
0.0186050907,
0.6889936924,
0.4411236644,
-0.5749584436,
0.544750452,
-0.5918181539,
-0.3788582683,
-0.7245602608,
-0.7419595122,
-1.1741894484,
0.0091217747,
-0.5014643669,
-0.0062848032,
0.0288014058,
0.8687992096,
0.9112094045,
-0.9919058084,
-0.2592316568,
0.1880024821,
0.2638305128,
-0.2113536447,
-0.1832458377,
0.1913445443,
-0.5343761444,
-0.5856750607,
0.3274486959,
0.2150568664,
0.2466141582,
-0.0071868957,
-0.151862219,
-0.151109159,
-0.3278560936,
0.6468245983,
0.7245417237,
-0.9788066745,
-0.2573644221,
0.0193729196,
0.4422731698,
0.5063602328,
1.0125485659,
-1.1299306154,
0.7805262804,
0.2518586218,
0.3982207477,
1.0340768099,
0.4805611968,
0.4754166305,
-1.0993973017,
0.3083733916,
-0.012579523,
0.1437617391,
0.0094457297,
-0.3916796148,
0.4902121723,
0.4963726699,
-0.3547029197,
-0.7187886834,
0.2659584284,
-0.9860855341,
0.1241496056,
0.9216668606,
0.0921542048,
-0.2558919787,
0.204210788,
-0.3383719921,
0.2349669933,
-0.6221117377,
0.4766961038,
0.5169090629,
-0.6903319359,
-0.5287721157,
-0.2662601769,
0.6502608657,
0.5202912688,
-0.3034001589,
-0.2128664553,
0.5001595616,
0.1462066025,
-0.0606257394,
0.3725014329,
0.1080671474,
0.5046192408,
-0.0538146123,
-0.1888863891,
0.0619515106,
-0.3116607666,
-0.6339452863,
-0.2594462633,
0.4781805575,
-0.5407938957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08949v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08949v1
|
Multimodal Cross-Document Event Coreference Resolution Using Linear Semantic Transfer and Mixed-Modality Ensembles
| 2024-04-13T10:01:58 | 2024-04-13T10:01:58 |
Abhijnan Nath, Huma Jamil, Shafiuddin Rehan Ahmed, George Baker, Rahul Ghosh, James H. Martin, Nathaniel Blanchard, Nikhil Krishnaswamy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Event coreference resolution (ECR) is the task of determining whether
distinct mentions of events within a multi-document corpus are actually linked
to the same underlying occurrence. Images of the events can help facilitate
resolution when language is ambiguous. Here, we propose a multimodal
cross-document event coreference resolution method that integrates visual and
textual cues with a simple linear map between vision and language models. As
existing ECR benchmark datasets rarely provide images for all event mentions,
we augment the popular ECB+ dataset with event-centric images scraped from the
internet and generated using image diffusion models. We establish three methods
that incorporate images and text for coreference: 1) a standard fused model
with finetuning, 2) a novel linear mapping method without finetuning and 3) an
ensembling approach based on splitting mention pairs by semantic and
discourse-level difficulty. We evaluate on 2 datasets: the augmented ECB+, and
AIDA Phase 1. Our ensemble systems using cross-modal linear mapping establish
an upper limit (91.9 CoNLL F1) on ECB+ ECR performance given the preprocessing
assumptions used, and establish a novel baseline on AIDA Phase 1. Our results
demonstrate the utility of multimodal information in ECR for certain
challenging coreference problems, and highlight a need for more multimodal
resources in the coreference resolution space.
|
[
-0.84839499,
-0.7197144032,
0.5890806317,
-0.1152007952,
-0.3911923766,
0.0199433248,
-0.7678872943,
-0.9502354264,
0.2366812527,
0.2558085024,
-0.3344343007,
-0.4438209534,
-0.8655278087,
0.0591048375,
-0.3980271816,
0.8059827685,
-0.2408468425,
0.0320795886,
-0.444047451,
-0.3314756751,
-0.3026737571,
-0.5068800449,
-0.4191116393,
-0.3222851753,
0.4853732884,
0.5263342857,
0.5233597159,
0.3568262756,
0.7319998741,
0.3269716501,
0.0288888663,
0.3119750917,
-0.030665895,
0.0609752946,
-0.4430086315,
-0.248203516,
-0.2603375316,
-0.0244536083,
0.4327005446,
0.4808858335,
0.2538179755,
0.1691560149,
0.0193984415,
0.0749110132,
-0.7806522846,
0.1254623979,
-0.6403519511,
-0.167860359,
-0.3410363197,
-0.3748246729,
-0.4066029489,
0.2219362408,
0.2712188959,
-0.6035535336,
0.4381698072,
0.0958084315,
0.8163176179,
-0.0596847236,
-0.4442390501,
-0.6723232865,
-0.7126028538,
0.8504086733,
-0.2754787207,
0.3272051811,
0.3139635026,
0.0390175879,
0.3614813983,
-0.5695203543,
-0.817555666,
0.1162690744,
-0.1434325427,
0.0150132924,
-0.3980555534,
0.0490126088,
0.2115822136,
0.0524463654,
-0.4304272234,
0.0126095414,
-0.4418299794,
-0.3503244817,
0.2668398619,
-0.0992110893,
0.2584269643,
-0.2173690498,
-0.4374810755,
-0.1652282178,
-0.2819009423,
-0.0826607272,
-0.1268523335,
0.2034642845,
-0.1281420439,
0.4900592566,
0.1260591745,
0.5736851096,
0.5890198946,
-0.3391004503,
0.2136746198,
-0.6298915744,
0.2063570023,
0.169242084,
0.5671963692,
0.8057816029,
0.1200625971,
-0.1278906316,
0.0784486681,
0.3389683068,
-0.1009024605,
-0.6273285747,
0.0206839647,
0.1231256127,
-0.3851432502,
0.2438587099,
-0.2090925723,
-1.0485165119,
-0.3206960559,
-0.5449219346,
0.4047732949,
-0.6007282734,
-0.0205498431,
-0.319937855,
-0.2386236638,
0.3405158818,
0.5313969851,
-0.4840247929,
0.0117963757,
0.3605724573,
0.5940410495,
-0.0189936627,
-0.164450109,
-0.2962417006,
0.1443366557,
0.0580635145,
1.225481987,
-0.8379095793,
-0.6280628443,
-0.0219805054,
-0.0513502248,
-0.1006009653,
-0.3791249096,
0.876416862,
-0.1539907902,
0.1183909178,
-0.1164979413,
-0.4873101115,
-0.1878610253,
0.3677124083,
-0.5441965461,
0.7266927958,
-0.5723000765,
-0.5439609885,
0.3508888483,
-0.1895650178,
-0.2462677211,
0.0612641387,
-0.4141290784,
0.0039618118,
-0.0937395841,
0.5609152317,
0.4754967093,
-0.3434581459,
0.0042388719,
-0.3630782366,
0.2236190885,
0.2198605835,
-0.1142480373,
0.0683382452,
-0.1369180083,
-0.1190974787,
0.1231070682,
-1.0052275658,
-0.0521856509,
-0.2083246857,
0.0624764077,
-0.8630499244,
-0.0616858043,
0.4294950068,
0.4765538573,
0.4439480603,
-0.6792273521,
0.0860682726,
0.2550469935,
0.0565160736,
0.5043516755,
-0.0571780764,
0.6204217672,
-0.1549832672,
0.1594379097,
0.2765384912,
0.0442587547,
-0.4762954414,
-0.7120369077,
-0.8678483963,
-0.3031819463,
0.1491066366,
0.4713713527,
-0.8357050419,
0.3264166713,
-0.3640041947,
-0.3942533731,
-0.4760835171,
-0.1148181185,
0.45983392,
0.4991101921,
0.5809685588,
-0.3369744122,
-0.7010248303,
-1.0498443842,
0.0600980483,
-0.1312595308,
0.1937449425,
0.4254977107,
0.575964272,
-0.0767332986,
0.7357170582,
-0.0793372691,
-0.5143922567,
-0.1636134982,
0.7140481472,
0.0654236823,
0.6798840165,
0.7092325687,
-0.8461941481,
-0.285753727,
0.2750695348,
-0.2970784903,
-0.0795455799,
-0.2726024985,
-0.0169753265,
0.1424631029,
0.1770772636,
-0.3169924617,
0.5355457067,
0.7622119784,
-0.4556616247,
0.4404069781,
-0.0601754859,
0.5444777012,
-1.0343376398,
0.0842461661,
0.1430985183,
-0.4418358803,
-0.4449638724,
-0.02528782,
0.2103098184,
0.0354196616,
-0.2280575186,
0.491161406,
-0.5705085397,
0.1749752015,
-0.3937427998,
0.5251652598,
0.1067406833,
0.5165770054,
0.2717212439,
0.4091020525,
0.5451985002,
-0.4591231942,
0.5559653044,
0.352538377,
-0.187741369,
1.3346469402,
-0.160319075,
0.3066091537,
-0.1872309148,
0.3516978025,
-0.9995336533,
0.1427601725,
0.1005054042,
-0.2765453756,
0.2901335359,
-0.0788187906,
-0.2189090103,
-0.0442887209,
-0.0497789793,
0.8358928561,
0.1521428674,
-0.513739109,
1.1057749987,
0.2593901455,
-0.2330444306,
-0.4362677336,
-0.725107193,
0.1275271475,
0.0536232255,
-0.8108434677,
0.7929633856,
-0.0770667046,
-0.1470586956,
0.2028612792,
-0.0608164296,
-0.1751641035,
-0.6219489574,
0.4050742686,
0.4600349069,
-0.1105244234,
0.0361697786,
-0.1915797591,
-0.1537378132,
-0.242666319,
-0.0716635063,
0.3086123466,
-0.2823665738,
-0.515429616,
-0.3480786979,
0.7697791457,
0.3978518546,
-0.2328601331,
0.6154333949,
0.7324058414,
-0.6316303611,
0.2602087259,
-1.0059659481,
-0.058545664,
-0.2710762024,
0.1470132619,
-0.4866153896,
-0.5656226873,
0.8475751877,
-0.2539151013,
0.1240001693,
0.4221214652,
0.5947309136,
-0.1562216729,
0.5808236003,
0.4165620804,
0.2262151092,
0.4711931348,
-0.0913477018,
-0.0346914083,
-1.1232266426,
-0.2944543362,
-0.8047946095,
-0.5977278352,
-0.0554882698,
-0.9138686061,
0.2665709853,
0.2041552067,
0.4852927923,
0.4047091603,
-0.1295794696,
0.4341044128,
0.4778495729,
0.264329046,
0.5768526196,
-0.2775891125,
-0.2958680987,
-0.368796438,
-0.4497981966,
-0.1556135565,
0.7772457004,
-0.0881404579,
0.7318617105,
0.0325560197,
0.390666455,
0.2463909537,
0.3065127134,
-0.6766062975,
0.4885975718,
-0.1090001985,
-0.5075089931,
0.129139781,
-0.1479195356,
-0.7505486012,
0.4139318168,
-0.549927175,
-0.8395850658,
0.9349565506,
-0.0625346303,
-0.1783728302,
0.2616722882,
-0.5052621365,
0.548999548,
-0.0432153158,
-0.3330714107,
-0.5444146395,
-0.5728897452,
0.0598892793,
-0.0469682552,
0.6664031744,
-0.1872554868,
-0.0568851605,
0.7518836856,
0.0584555939,
0.846758008,
0.3454419076,
0.0537680574,
0.2266506404,
0.0349695981,
0.6250779033,
-0.2535313368,
0.0333390832,
0.2271612436,
0.0928959027,
-0.3721417189,
-0.5556691289,
0.7794982791,
-0.5891336203,
-0.247411117,
-0.1535085291,
-0.4685121775,
-0.0547031909,
-0.0423403978,
0.364028126,
0.8335754275,
-0.3535627425,
0.2508817613,
0.3722061217,
0.0847893134,
0.6090264916,
0.4325454831,
-0.1091050059,
-0.4724576771,
0.5475644469,
0.1696221083,
0.1435027421,
0.4567530453,
-0.143856734,
-0.2846243978,
-0.3708522618,
-0.4918718636,
0.2236995697,
-1.0938830376,
-0.3417624831,
-0.5617513061,
0.1735386848,
-0.4659377933,
-0.4659713805,
-0.3763687611,
-0.5007523298,
-0.3227752745,
0.0633747354,
0.2621845007,
0.1562311649,
-0.3513488173,
0.0283560082,
-0.8720965981,
0.2797243893,
-0.0216819998,
0.0411703102,
-0.3071510494,
-0.4287876785,
-0.2062328011,
-0.2342474461,
-0.2605738044,
-1.089707613,
0.2162748128,
0.6002633572,
0.4977000356,
0.5407626629,
0.177762866,
1.0038679838,
-0.3554143608,
0.6663346887,
0.5342377424,
-1.0536893606,
0.6590125561,
0.0061210338,
0.2864924669,
0.378003031,
0.2279907018,
-0.7368040085,
-0.4217318892,
-0.6660627723,
-0.9251353145,
0.3992510438,
0.1179793626,
-0.2045826167,
-0.0857198462,
0.1826267391,
0.0231047999,
-0.1642864943,
-0.5635370016,
-0.2868652642,
0.1276222914,
-0.0756815299,
-0.0869589224,
-0.0689204186,
-0.3810159266,
-0.0925344825,
0.4864053428,
-0.3009669185,
0.1603829861,
0.5856321454,
-0.478376776,
-0.2104372233,
0.6127328873,
0.5195903182,
0.6519491076,
-0.0073469258,
0.5518762469,
0.1743012965,
-0.350004375,
-0.0347507559,
0.3329155743,
0.1049661264,
0.1865426004,
0.6137309074,
0.7090258598,
0.6185830235,
-0.7041687965,
0.4531079531,
0.1038492471,
-0.0759723336,
-0.0953223333,
-0.4732369184,
-0.1512318552,
0.519916296,
0.5842256546,
0.3478341699,
0.170319587,
-0.4657245278,
0.3786692321,
0.3080007732,
-0.4137757421,
-0.3840223253,
0.2300937474,
0.6207033396,
0.0986507162,
0.3069359958,
0.0726523027,
-0.4325775802,
0.4667197466,
0.4224349856,
0.5291092396,
-0.1420411021,
0.0979146957,
0.5455568433,
0.4511250556,
0.3220494092,
0.0163636394,
-0.1648435295,
-1.0370537043,
-0.5170062184,
-0.4434988201,
-0.4943732619,
-0.1502195746,
-0.7552281022,
0.1700788885,
-0.2746941149,
-0.4554522336,
0.1623031497,
-0.2079324126,
-0.865917027,
0.0228824839,
0.6676023006,
0.6445605755,
-0.5801361799,
0.6485264301,
0.8870680928,
-0.3208144605,
-0.3103803098,
-0.3511778712,
0.1069423333,
-0.4929919243,
0.4453569353,
-0.057061661,
-0.1121461615,
-0.1211552024,
-0.195402205,
-0.6550092697,
0.9236090779,
0.1180450693,
-0.8128529787,
0.0232889596,
-0.0205069147,
0.224331066,
-0.5632351637,
0.4941548109,
0.3241101503,
0.6478990316,
0.2331949621,
-1.2724761963,
0.154727459,
-0.1797530949,
-0.0279667489,
0.2676277161,
-0.4009456336,
0.6529892683,
-0.1566851288,
-0.536791563,
0.0255591962,
0.8319823742,
-0.0092168227,
0.3482880294,
0.5963853598,
0.6569786668,
0.5889371634,
-0.2290864438,
0.7536398768,
-0.3785246313,
0.4726526439,
1.1412607431,
-0.3325340748,
0.8752271533,
0.8600836992,
0.0869576484,
0.4796356857,
0.3913680613,
0.1236303896,
0.3069289923,
-0.3295631409,
-0.4645911157,
-0.5795540214,
-0.464545995,
-0.4747625589,
0.2354391664,
0.7062215805,
-0.4087856412,
-0.7180036306,
0.4983232617,
-0.2392901629,
0.1957232356,
-0.468090713,
0.6947634816,
-0.0908335596,
-0.4691305459,
0.1834400445,
0.0222891383,
0.8367729187,
-0.4557497501,
-0.0602101274,
0.1238874644,
0.3372332752,
-0.0351901203,
-0.8259358406,
0.381908834,
-0.0968420953,
-0.3165157735,
-0.1487954706,
0.9309304953,
-0.6445068717,
-0.6085888743,
0.5693873167,
0.4186347425,
0.0324918479,
0.031662643,
-0.5551729202,
0.1172776669,
-0.2505650818,
0.0064150803,
0.2853012979,
0.5361056328,
0.0154438391,
0.30279392,
0.5461342335,
-0.0415236168,
0.3384558558,
0.0157143865,
0.7748619914,
-0.517164588,
-0.2353390157,
-0.4859825969,
0.3256885409,
-0.0235342775,
-0.6019599438,
0.3583610952,
0.3806313276,
0.7761695385,
0.0425217748,
0.6607795358,
-0.3830092847,
0.2346078306,
-0.4933316112,
0.0257828813,
-0.4068757296,
-0.1617541015,
-0.3341281712,
-0.581859827,
-0.3677832782,
0.5035505295,
-0.320661366,
-0.3239412904,
0.7452488542,
0.6713730693,
-0.1384422779,
0.09064091,
0.4217532277,
0.0986874178,
0.1010254398,
0.71495682,
0.8192372918,
-0.4176092148,
0.7692704201,
-0.3817470074,
-0.4335611463,
-0.280929476,
-0.8611963987,
-0.6301760077,
-1.0793267488,
-0.5583010912,
-0.4043667912,
0.0790409669,
1.1438752413,
0.6924724579,
-0.7521207333,
0.0841436386,
0.5635746121,
-0.0555506758,
-0.3306844532,
-0.1680221707,
0.1914587915,
-0.1666264534,
-0.9836937189,
0.171200484,
0.2487551719,
-0.0781018436,
-0.1953058392,
0.2044349462,
-0.5487807393,
0.0655731037,
0.5867691636,
0.0628744885,
-0.7989633679,
-0.5327608585,
-0.3436972499,
-0.1969487816,
0.1096341014,
1.1328623295,
-0.6088370681,
0.4591776431,
0.5616980195,
0.5498223901,
0.6151792407,
-0.1383196563,
0.4154376686,
-0.8372186422,
0.4797663391,
0.1628088653,
0.7017591,
0.2317976505,
-0.272112757,
0.1790378988,
0.4479318857,
-0.3507737219,
-0.3306230605,
0.2086052746,
-1.5988487005,
-0.1983544976,
0.9938838482,
-0.1751585007,
-0.2044148892,
-0.3567188084,
-0.3711521327,
0.0230352692,
-0.4975897074,
0.4632172883,
1.0399816036,
-0.2608220875,
-0.6455198526,
0.0009909652,
-0.090459913,
0.1276239455,
-0.6094923019,
-0.2647788525,
0.7069196701,
-0.0417210795,
0.891941905,
0.4651749134,
-0.1328998804,
0.3094531,
0.1074307039,
0.5293006301,
0.2132124156,
-0.331941396,
-0.0022532458,
0.374078393,
-0.4615371227,
-0.1135501191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08940v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08940v1
|
Introducing Super RAGs in Mistral 8x7B-v1
| 2024-04-13T09:33:00 | 2024-04-13T09:33:00 |
Ayush Thakur, Raghav Gupta
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The relentless pursuit of enhancing Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to
the advent of Super Retrieval-Augmented Generation (Super RAGs), a novel
approach designed to elevate the performance of LLMs by integrating external
knowledge sources with minimal structural modifications. This paper presents
the integration of Super RAGs into the Mistral 8x7B v1, a state-of-the-art LLM,
and examines the resultant improvements in accuracy, speed, and user
satisfaction. Our methodology uses a fine-tuned instruct model setup and a
cache tuning fork system, ensuring efficient and relevant data retrieval. The
evaluation, conducted over several epochs, demonstrates significant
enhancements across all metrics. The findings suggest that Super RAGs can
effectively augment LLMs, paving the way for more sophisticated and reliable AI
systems. This research contributes to the field by providing empirical evidence
of the benefits of Super RAGs and offering insights into their potential
applications.
|
[
-0.3341251016,
-0.3234544396,
0.4656155407,
-0.0013786755,
-0.3017407954,
0.2770782709,
-0.0741050094,
-0.8047273755,
0.2689912915,
0.5735844374,
-0.0534819812,
-0.1067292467,
-0.5658660531,
-0.1448935866,
-0.8714250326,
1.0531926155,
0.322715193,
0.0202420373,
-0.1484809518,
-0.1597501487,
-0.3412041366,
-0.750256896,
-0.5186908841,
-0.126934886,
0.4363347888,
0.3446748257,
0.9467577934,
0.7457834482,
0.4996238649,
0.4044203758,
-0.3519358635,
0.7340834141,
-0.7808657289,
0.3420860469,
-0.3197268546,
-0.7262182236,
-0.6008813977,
-0.3194293082,
0.4048166573,
-0.0373406373,
-0.1901942343,
0.2636546493,
0.1520939916,
0.6713818908,
-0.8517850637,
0.0525153168,
-0.5360961556,
-0.4547537565,
-0.5303402543,
-0.2061491311,
-0.2144308984,
-0.2853841782,
-0.1229953393,
-0.6139761209,
0.320325166,
-0.1431393772,
0.7433133125,
0.2894667685,
0.1652488261,
-0.4832572043,
-0.7481697798,
0.5483794212,
-0.8363210559,
0.6213164926,
0.0770062581,
0.34353742,
-0.1447159052,
-0.9475372434,
-0.7669649124,
-0.232604906,
0.0202037841,
0.123197414,
-0.0428639315,
-0.1704854071,
-0.1091536134,
0.4346859753,
-0.1856825352,
0.1626577675,
-0.4432063997,
0.0094437916,
0.6131062508,
0.5186519623,
0.3073522151,
-0.0773159713,
-0.4048011005,
0.1582087278,
-0.7015336156,
-0.1998769045,
0.0737293288,
0.3713403046,
0.0218060352,
0.1067535132,
-0.0103470311,
0.639108479,
0.0808150619,
-0.2377569377,
-0.0102722105,
-0.3987651169,
0.0168634094,
0.0665259436,
0.3975570202,
0.2738360763,
0.2104786783,
-0.2636344731,
-0.5138069391,
-0.012624016,
0.2944388092,
-0.5449433923,
0.0385699496,
-0.0407132432,
-0.1954395026,
-0.3909600973,
0.182761997,
-0.4054103494,
-0.9583517313,
-0.6180719137,
0.320980072,
-0.564989388,
-0.4434739947,
0.1188765988,
-0.3524622321,
0.3780765831,
0.5814964175,
-0.7754219174,
0.3201616108,
0.9883431792,
0.694596231,
0.0730608478,
-0.1171834618,
-0.390050441,
0.2872014046,
-0.8629941344,
1.0409214497,
-0.6035194993,
-0.4185266793,
0.0256159995,
-0.4831061661,
0.3326675892,
-0.9571154714,
0.5831109285,
-0.8039875031,
-0.2475147992,
-0.3105485141,
-0.5013455749,
-0.0792780668,
-0.0870818496,
-0.5044748783,
1.3831613064,
0.4829190671,
-0.6921557188,
0.2442570329,
-0.2192174196,
-0.1385688782,
0.4921686649,
-0.118535243,
-0.035859473,
0.547381103,
0.1242800429,
0.37449646,
-0.6790147424,
0.1164887697,
-0.1479578614,
-0.758185029,
0.2348053306,
-0.3871876895,
0.607319057,
0.1548101157,
-0.2922615707,
-0.1660265923,
-0.6677718759,
-0.0731472224,
-0.1364027113,
-0.3635824323,
-0.5760095716,
-0.1968263686,
0.3052747548,
-0.0751110539,
0.4415082932,
-0.2412896901,
0.1448017955,
-0.4527154565,
0.0837299526,
1.0834789276,
-0.317958504,
0.33071509,
-0.3853878379,
0.4763331711,
-0.219540745,
0.2599436343,
-0.3079116046,
0.0674219429,
-1.1369271278,
-0.4142331779,
0.5331614614,
0.4669518769,
-0.8811426163,
0.136387974,
-0.2590917349,
-0.7505577207,
-0.7074110508,
0.3306742609,
0.5564351082,
0.3514411449,
0.5270623565,
0.0155436778,
-0.6633275747,
-0.7101281881,
-0.2417346835,
0.0019638608,
0.2399840206,
0.3642993569,
-0.0588565208,
-0.3370512128,
0.8708292246,
-0.2470369935,
-0.1868762821,
-0.6429872513,
-0.3110643625,
0.381192565,
0.3176638484,
0.5898410082,
-0.7803969979,
-0.663777113,
0.2170082331,
-0.7073562741,
-0.2902786136,
0.1001277566,
-0.1651768982,
0.3952137828,
0.7449210882,
-0.471075505,
0.4992573559,
0.4151968658,
-0.0819563046,
0.8783390522,
-0.3981347382,
0.2114220262,
-0.9349043369,
-0.1913402528,
0.0291381162,
-0.306148082,
-0.6276854873,
0.3679733276,
0.3984814584,
0.3776129186,
-0.4124544263,
0.5723665357,
-0.50742203,
0.034359511,
-0.6052674651,
0.0403697267,
-0.1418742687,
-0.0368077531,
-0.4718174934,
1.1734594107,
0.4866315126,
-0.8057442904,
0.2856556475,
-0.0812370777,
-0.2681322396,
0.5509884357,
-0.6966249943,
0.30034554,
-0.4541349113,
0.2394868284,
-0.7919778228,
-0.0460756905,
-0.0870645195,
-0.450419426,
0.5942541957,
-0.0678925589,
-0.4849795997,
0.0293654259,
-0.3032866418,
0.1631939262,
0.5103421211,
-0.8161305189,
0.511292994,
0.6709897518,
-0.2332519889,
-0.5829306245,
-0.3139007986,
0.3332478702,
-0.2092287838,
-0.3221096396,
0.4533955157,
0.0125070801,
-0.3208356798,
-0.0816573128,
-0.446292758,
0.1499518752,
-0.0514403842,
0.0581023097,
0.5556114316,
-0.4629834592,
-0.1116540954,
0.0700198039,
-0.4480378926,
-0.4224686623,
-0.3873217702,
0.5296788812,
0.0258697234,
0.1491494477,
-0.3005307615,
0.0662476495,
0.6617090106,
-0.3213256299,
0.6307978034,
0.3864180446,
-0.2589813471,
-0.5107072592,
-0.898357451,
0.2715019882,
-0.5705602169,
0.3204736114,
-0.3156170547,
-0.8489198685,
0.2589936554,
-0.0331402794,
0.0684970841,
0.2799396813,
0.3359344006,
-0.1307610869,
0.8424603343,
0.7719045281,
-0.2782077491,
0.6612156034,
-0.4180754125,
0.0151284793,
-0.998623848,
-0.1411511004,
-0.7376922965,
-0.1231854707,
-0.4756681323,
-0.7845379114,
0.6943976283,
0.366884768,
-0.2535634637,
0.3095062077,
-0.3277316093,
0.7205328345,
0.5450857282,
0.2346344143,
0.2914412022,
-0.2728016078,
0.2220656574,
0.0801109076,
-0.8280485272,
-0.5238698721,
1.0528501272,
0.1083038151,
1.0324736834,
0.2362858206,
0.7597686648,
0.5100799203,
0.6845162511,
-0.3750220239,
0.567303896,
-0.6385857463,
-0.3803029656,
-0.2089290768,
-0.1040090322,
-0.7648013234,
0.3699685335,
-0.1804165989,
-0.5839540362,
0.1660027504,
0.3098219633,
-0.4964708388,
0.0596722253,
-0.5903307199,
0.2493868172,
-0.2681906819,
-0.5855014324,
-0.2378201187,
-0.2292021513,
0.3227586746,
0.0079074297,
0.3790740073,
0.2227469534,
-0.3479035199,
0.6366099119,
-0.3409516811,
0.5795240402,
-0.0325519741,
-0.2015396506,
0.3639168739,
0.1167545095,
0.5071634054,
0.0243643764,
-0.1731577963,
0.2841099799,
-0.27280882,
-0.1820623428,
-0.8717903495,
1.0091087818,
-0.7368830442,
-0.8304494619,
-0.2428903133,
-0.6718167067,
-0.27474159,
0.0652205274,
-0.1176033318,
0.9545740485,
0.249663502,
0.2173205465,
0.9382727742,
-0.2587822974,
0.2945702374,
0.6207323074,
-0.4424211383,
-0.4887637198,
1.0900365114,
0.5777158141,
0.2078678459,
0.3553015888,
0.4111561775,
-0.4995771348,
-0.6600310206,
-0.6272531748,
0.2335071117,
-0.5985521078,
-0.5063539147,
-0.5753221512,
-0.2649432719,
-0.7925019264,
-0.25252527,
-0.4065523148,
-0.3828852773,
-0.0904135182,
-0.1225773543,
0.3648797572,
1.194308877,
-0.2396880835,
0.3317815959,
-1.0578670502,
0.4569103122,
0.0823989883,
0.3554386199,
0.0854319856,
-0.9390205145,
-0.7339652181,
-0.3012764156,
-0.1380580664,
-0.7234305143,
0.2755256593,
-0.0772622749,
0.7969802022,
0.3803223372,
-0.1472785622,
0.9714491367,
-0.4735535681,
0.5521581173,
-0.002161124,
-0.7964765429,
0.1365862489,
-0.3675338328,
0.0677188709,
0.353621155,
0.2609118223,
-0.4514389932,
-0.518814981,
-0.6987076402,
-0.9787656665,
0.6946088076,
-0.2682569623,
0.3457938135,
0.1625647247,
0.5131722093,
0.242172122,
0.0640120804,
0.0758115649,
-0.4922930896,
0.126578033,
-0.1856554002,
-0.3659214675,
-0.4362862408,
0.3831923902,
-0.1187131554,
0.8035280108,
0.129194811,
-0.2391808629,
0.1496556103,
-0.1603852659,
0.142385751,
-0.0639853254,
0.3589885533,
0.8539516926,
0.2150049061,
0.1086844429,
0.2194813788,
-0.5679274201,
-0.0246095285,
0.0868599415,
-0.2389085293,
0.0827051327,
0.4552872777,
0.4505061805,
0.4180631042,
-0.5816515088,
0.1507945359,
0.2450596392,
0.3523679376,
-0.0897687748,
0.5313636661,
0.1365889013,
0.5512972474,
0.6122007966,
0.0216538217,
0.3590591252,
-0.419400394,
0.2339633554,
0.3578137755,
-0.3222563863,
-0.1103170067,
0.5429375768,
0.1541786939,
-0.6039340496,
0.2455852479,
0.0746164024,
-0.7327547073,
0.4198523462,
0.7076517344,
0.5791472793,
-0.4338111877,
-0.0042552948,
0.1296198964,
0.4313741624,
-0.0535965301,
0.2607292533,
-0.127116859,
-0.5866895318,
-0.4220487475,
-0.7383027077,
-0.4183690548,
0.0610870123,
-0.4934175014,
0.3063697517,
-0.3062806726,
0.0774128288,
-0.2018704861,
-0.2208486646,
-0.5758727193,
0.1618350744,
0.2779850662,
1.2661608458,
-0.5434643626,
0.5715854764,
0.639308989,
-0.3545198441,
-0.872966826,
0.0487622507,
-0.1437202841,
-0.9225370884,
0.4412876666,
-0.0849916786,
-0.2600590289,
0.0661605,
-0.646987915,
-1.0464560986,
0.8744677305,
0.6261566281,
-0.5610945821,
0.070241496,
0.0894311219,
0.5833458304,
0.0681580678,
0.5258406997,
0.7831138372,
0.2300538123,
-0.1348871738,
-1.0372952223,
-0.2187807858,
-0.2371269017,
0.2999135256,
0.3591845334,
-0.8439818025,
0.8051255941,
-0.2309923768,
-0.0494833849,
0.050183598,
1.0860742331,
0.468031168,
0.1823335439,
0.411002934,
0.593752861,
0.6601195335,
0.2418841124,
1.1298419237,
-0.4717781842,
0.1859127432,
1.1124309301,
0.0118937502,
0.7583689094,
0.3724622726,
-0.3008339405,
0.4891720116,
0.0729909688,
0.7986329198,
0.1809471548,
0.2369675189,
-0.453684032,
-0.2548341751,
-0.3574245274,
-0.6066306233,
0.3164591193,
0.6245005727,
-0.0679278448,
-0.2585550547,
-0.1887757778,
0.1768405288,
0.2051538527,
-0.5832915902,
0.7422284484,
0.0552645102,
-0.5218095779,
0.5232517719,
-0.1017860472,
0.8714895248,
-0.6268057227,
-0.3939937949,
-0.6989087462,
0.3959774971,
-0.283178091,
-0.5700083971,
-0.0487306416,
0.2547182441,
-0.0795798376,
-0.1352192909,
0.9885494709,
-0.1199033782,
-0.5505073667,
0.1195840463,
0.5244966149,
0.0642249137,
0.0601239316,
-0.5010406971,
0.4645023048,
-0.3445052803,
-0.1564476192,
0.4174410403,
0.6823990941,
-0.0100883292,
0.5477570891,
0.7736644149,
0.2788512111,
0.1696633399,
0.0519096069,
1.1528408527,
-0.6104388237,
-0.5473302007,
-0.7874233723,
0.5789081454,
0.0359792747,
-0.2784285843,
0.8698508143,
0.7660832405,
0.8728699088,
0.2740705609,
1.080288291,
-0.0584207699,
0.7341566086,
-0.396538347,
0.5836500525,
-0.4916189909,
0.3631466329,
-0.3648388684,
-0.6506844759,
0.0652537048,
0.3571639061,
0.0362824649,
0.0387168713,
0.2795673311,
1.1313658953,
-0.1239679605,
-0.0384324901,
0.4452007115,
0.303311646,
0.3195981383,
0.1539666355,
1.0054730177,
-0.4351046383,
0.5367442369,
-0.1689672172,
-0.5105341673,
-0.1777982563,
-0.511641562,
-0.2787834704,
-0.4491114914,
0.1640422195,
-0.516073823,
0.47088781,
0.7071807981,
0.5641097426,
-0.6609724164,
-0.3354900181,
0.1615650654,
0.0570074134,
-0.1138093621,
-0.2031615824,
0.2212483287,
-0.6696876287,
-0.8873701692,
0.5876052976,
0.5604516864,
-0.2702173591,
-0.5203312635,
-0.1831331551,
0.0508948043,
0.3410303891,
0.5445935726,
-0.049403511,
-0.394244343,
-0.1607236415,
0.1895508319,
-0.2182886451,
-0.228985548,
0.9114307165,
-1.0028614998,
0.2342782468,
0.5203495622,
0.928301692,
0.3232707679,
0.0765671209,
0.420450747,
-0.0857465267,
-0.156866312,
0.0545734428,
0.2606688142,
0.2105096728,
-0.3823222518,
0.4140377939,
0.2098416984,
-0.506319046,
-1.0114623308,
-0.2042157799,
-0.4636697173,
-0.1479842365,
1.1410319805,
0.0409059897,
-0.2419523448,
-0.3528729379,
-0.5447901487,
0.1281265914,
-0.2524524629,
0.8569618464,
0.3187404275,
-0.2223183662,
0.0716594458,
-0.5829126835,
0.3421781063,
0.2750531137,
-0.7403688431,
0.1659244448,
0.4841878414,
0.0705809519,
0.1298294663,
0.9060014486,
-0.0490591377,
0.5149576664,
0.0442625359,
-0.1717441082,
-0.1876850724,
-0.6042258143,
-0.125960663,
0.2299437225,
0.0443813577,
0.0201402418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08938v1
|
Enforcing Paraphrase Generation via Controllable Latent Diffusion
| 2024-04-13T09:24:32 | 2024-04-13T09:24:32 |
Wei Zou, Ziyuan Zhuang, Shujian Huang, Jia Liu, Jiajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Paraphrase generation aims to produce high-quality and diverse utterances of
a given text. Though state-of-the-art generation via the diffusion model
reconciles generation quality and diversity, textual diffusion suffers from a
truncation issue that hinders efficiency and quality control. In this work, we
propose \textit{L}atent \textit{D}iffusion \textit{P}araphraser~(LDP), a novel
paraphrase generation by modeling a controllable diffusion process given a
learned latent space. LDP achieves superior generation efficiency compared to
its diffusion counterparts. It facilitates only input segments to enforce
paraphrase semantics, which further improves the results without external
features. Experiments show that LDP achieves improved and diverse paraphrase
generation compared to baselines. Further analysis shows that our method is
also helpful to other similar text generations and domain adaptations. Our code
and data are available at https://github.com/NIL-zhuang/ld4pg.
|
[
-0.0444660783,
-0.7512415051,
0.5607748032,
0.5412662029,
-0.4339977205,
0.1901940256,
0.2008275986,
-0.0235627852,
0.041755192,
0.804432869,
-0.0935036391,
-0.3525154591,
-0.6222140789,
0.0646549389,
-0.469940275,
1.0605655909,
-0.2605660856,
-0.2833977938,
-0.0041609565,
-0.1805717796,
0.0943386182,
-0.2234408408,
-0.7183068395,
-0.282715559,
0.392914176,
0.2398008555,
0.856050849,
0.455475688,
0.265309155,
0.2020898759,
-0.5466688275,
0.1494325697,
-0.2875756919,
0.1732443869,
-0.2890411615,
-0.0547043048,
-0.5694863796,
-0.1582029909,
1.0406079292,
0.7239176631,
-0.3696084619,
-0.3884329498,
0.6368156672,
0.4808372557,
-0.7547745109,
-0.1709250808,
-0.6664747,
0.1470800191,
-0.172506094,
-0.3934987485,
-0.3498549163,
-0.61401999,
-0.0330650732,
-0.4459297657,
0.2188931704,
-0.278000474,
0.7553567886,
0.2633225024,
-0.3630785942,
-0.3712270558,
-0.5011867881,
0.5859504938,
-0.7510824203,
0.1619784832,
0.3160919249,
0.0932398289,
-0.1208176687,
-1.0258508921,
-0.6795073152,
-0.06101989,
0.1232496724,
0.0048973444,
-0.2668810189,
-0.0402486287,
-0.1823637486,
0.3995521963,
-0.4507097602,
-0.1341728568,
-0.3098572195,
-0.0659233555,
0.1736919284,
0.0502729751,
0.2188073099,
-0.3618951738,
-0.3811813891,
-0.0205652509,
-0.5601688623,
-0.1103723794,
0.2373061776,
-0.2174026817,
0.0315816328,
0.5052693486,
-0.2626819611,
0.4958882928,
0.2595905066,
0.0250578262,
0.1853080392,
-0.333928138,
-0.0075365617,
-0.2170008719,
0.7630949616,
0.5092290044,
-0.065657258,
-0.1799359173,
-0.2944846451,
-0.3068253994,
0.029220866,
-0.7841941714,
-0.5975538492,
0.0437791571,
-0.3095355332,
-0.3518496752,
-0.2187734544,
-1.14217031,
-0.2542672455,
0.1768022478,
0.3293790221,
-0.624373436,
-0.1652597785,
-0.0011837273,
-0.4446273148,
0.0406337082,
0.1443977058,
-0.7160258889,
0.2636028826,
0.527176559,
1.2220250368,
-0.7019376159,
-0.4833571315,
-0.7183395028,
0.5598822236,
-0.2826368809,
0.7828310132,
-0.5974273682,
-0.4266198874,
-0.2046776414,
-0.3678718507,
-0.0028199954,
-0.7680277228,
0.5242997408,
-0.8002410531,
0.288330853,
0.1032356471,
-0.6936436892,
0.2102490515,
-0.1515640914,
-0.5171356797,
0.5833144188,
0.1145575568,
-0.8671565652,
0.4370695055,
-0.5317180157,
-0.3400976956,
0.2648679018,
-0.1975797415,
-0.6300391555,
0.0000683048,
0.310226053,
0.3537632227,
0.0040611792,
0.3632962704,
-0.333640039,
0.1843925267,
0.2431234121,
-0.5169897676,
0.7410663962,
0.5643684268,
-0.2062868327,
0.0452747084,
-0.6478558779,
0.0254606195,
-0.0043434007,
-0.5660245419,
-0.275562197,
0.0000392094,
0.113835223,
0.169733882,
0.3586556017,
-0.4561995864,
-0.016080495,
-0.2993196845,
0.5666029453,
0.8955389261,
0.6797121167,
0.8798951507,
-0.4654474854,
0.7541068792,
0.0923835039,
0.0863652155,
0.3565452695,
-0.3789409399,
-0.2421463728,
-0.3799108565,
0.1509643346,
0.4572224617,
-1.2423232794,
0.5463434458,
-0.0981478244,
-0.3503299952,
-0.0837025568,
0.3308562934,
0.1922056079,
0.7026103735,
0.4211899638,
-0.0024135595,
-0.0509850085,
-0.6372492313,
-0.0755700544,
0.1200867221,
-0.1542069167,
0.0126950676,
0.2255809307,
0.1557542384,
0.8300082684,
-0.6609033346,
0.0464205667,
-0.5799672604,
0.0560954437,
0.0789197013,
0.7902964354,
0.5960209966,
-1.0005824566,
-0.5862039924,
-0.3152477145,
-0.7422623634,
-0.5344527364,
-0.3738858998,
-0.5769609213,
-0.2432440817,
0.6955366135,
-0.6060178876,
0.2316020429,
0.5323818922,
-0.5206236243,
0.366035372,
-0.5210608244,
0.1409851313,
-1.2966654301,
0.0944217667,
-0.2549746931,
-0.1913221329,
-0.3132584691,
0.2525872588,
0.0877862945,
-0.2600528896,
-0.6024371982,
0.4816895723,
-0.2970004082,
0.3115876615,
-0.6652786732,
0.0901552737,
0.1780364364,
0.2217729539,
0.1517038792,
0.8806079626,
0.5579470396,
-0.9652209878,
-0.0565713421,
0.4985478818,
-0.194145903,
0.6641458273,
-0.79317981,
-0.1798747182,
-0.0084396396,
0.5197119713,
-0.6586806774,
-0.0915813968,
0.3226100504,
-0.22422342,
-0.0025936302,
0.111014463,
-0.5507742167,
0.083841078,
-0.3216770887,
0.2771059573,
0.8487762213,
-0.60436517,
0.1978087127,
0.2398685515,
-0.3775480986,
-0.2905676961,
-0.3747676611,
0.3186095953,
-0.5863736272,
-0.4535270929,
0.4319182932,
-0.4606445432,
-0.0967747718,
-0.1869544387,
-0.1613535285,
-0.4825241566,
0.0852208883,
-0.329998076,
-0.1445463598,
-0.0347106829,
-0.2446313053,
0.8490409255,
-0.0497939438,
-0.140708074,
-0.4477144778,
0.4053973854,
0.5842940807,
0.0336612388,
-0.4427193105,
0.5601614714,
0.6109433174,
-0.1769897193,
0.8067344427,
0.244051069,
-0.0170476232,
-0.6093848944,
0.1215294972,
-0.1057441607,
-0.5606093407,
0.1233224198,
-0.4395547211,
-0.6666998863,
0.2330446094,
-0.170214206,
0.2022021115,
0.2867527902,
0.4719920456,
0.0047872392,
0.5926687717,
0.4551935792,
0.4221795499,
0.5936718583,
-0.093520917,
-0.1773192137,
-0.8680446744,
0.1568007022,
-0.3590783477,
-0.3251870275,
-0.3333407938,
-0.6842048764,
0.45931077,
0.652998805,
0.2444625944,
0.2849701345,
-0.4652736783,
0.5519073606,
0.6022315025,
0.2966957092,
0.2639248967,
0.0666059479,
-0.2109267861,
-0.1876223981,
-0.7620643377,
-0.6512092352,
0.8418722153,
0.027222136,
0.7524141073,
0.3093830347,
1.1535521746,
0.6519209146,
-0.222602576,
0.0767452568,
0.7580970526,
-0.3279725909,
-0.3063638508,
-0.1537320018,
-0.5698028803,
-1.0308613777,
0.4081835449,
0.145836547,
-0.5156399012,
0.270429492,
0.3657821715,
-0.1988856345,
0.4199696481,
-0.4602102637,
0.7884653211,
0.2814112008,
-0.4782008827,
-0.0832621753,
-0.5693260431,
0.1751155704,
-0.2968016565,
-0.1672094911,
-0.0721473172,
-0.345754981,
0.8513961434,
-0.6111840606,
0.5341607332,
-0.4236313701,
-0.2779481709,
0.4026077986,
0.2959201932,
0.4897734523,
0.0823090449,
-0.2423407584,
-0.1230812818,
-0.1921504438,
-0.7836393118,
-0.4488836527,
0.7548539639,
-0.4029211104,
-0.4729025662,
-0.1199565381,
-0.4941668212,
0.0463017523,
0.2284689099,
0.7013121247,
0.0281912722,
-0.0170931723,
0.3481915891,
0.8097724319,
-0.3669823706,
0.3865677118,
0.243229568,
0.0392141603,
-0.5510761142,
1.0391607285,
-0.1406822503,
0.7550871372,
0.6002743244,
0.5499287248,
-0.1743116379,
-0.9441919923,
-0.3301377296,
0.0918665379,
-0.9259267449,
0.0190934502,
-1.0608054399,
-0.1762402803,
-0.4877750874,
-0.4902309477,
-0.0138212014,
-0.6857795119,
-0.3816865087,
0.0590652823,
0.2733212411,
0.3076114357,
-0.2953190804,
0.5772994161,
-0.7275096178,
0.6803709269,
0.274715364,
-0.0072641978,
0.0352904089,
-0.7792342305,
0.1127851605,
-0.1545730084,
-0.6547582746,
-0.9001470208,
0.3628662527,
0.5813777447,
0.502617538,
0.1115382537,
0.3629104197,
0.2341875434,
-0.776239872,
0.9162440896,
0.0763442814,
-1.0446772575,
0.7063860893,
-0.3767076731,
0.3927409947,
0.3812365532,
0.1419109851,
-0.1588534117,
-1.1646236181,
-0.7146074772,
-1.0517870188,
0.3843388557,
0.6528178453,
0.172856763,
-0.1691274643,
0.4492659569,
0.3532642424,
0.2385904193,
-0.9003453851,
-0.0862588733,
-0.2613663971,
-0.3648405373,
0.0108328518,
-0.0798397884,
0.0280162971,
0.1751403809,
0.5030100346,
0.2032140642,
-0.0330592804,
0.1527865082,
-0.2764590085,
0.0929474235,
0.2911985219,
0.5057774186,
0.7099321485,
0.0627111867,
0.3389566243,
-0.0185359698,
-0.4263297319,
0.3819335103,
0.0435458012,
-0.7624233365,
0.1474461257,
0.3223471344,
0.5376187563,
-0.0329441875,
-0.4044190049,
0.419800669,
0.176579088,
-0.3501282334,
0.0121048596,
0.2584788799,
0.0627040267,
0.4817287326,
0.3147991002,
-0.038905628,
0.322799623,
0.1301775128,
0.7140257955,
0.1016016528,
0.1314726025,
-0.2209574729,
1.1928595304,
0.3026958406,
-0.1886444241,
0.2491568923,
-0.376298666,
-0.273669064,
0.2305339277,
0.5066770315,
0.9374560714,
-0.203173399,
0.2852526307,
0.0919109583,
0.0670255348,
0.0253371373,
0.0676660761,
-0.4431369305,
-0.4898215234,
-0.2366392463,
-0.8751104474,
-0.3906793296,
-0.0553327166,
-0.3516936004,
-0.0446432084,
-0.7582728863,
0.2024454474,
0.1757167876,
-0.7157855034,
0.0152633069,
0.0627806708,
-0.0302503798,
0.5722185373,
-0.7719137669,
0.9946431518,
0.3585786521,
-0.4576865733,
-0.2567599416,
0.6520796418,
-0.4281029403,
-0.6274005175,
0.7273372412,
-0.3364903033,
-0.1292458177,
0.1258372962,
-0.2947006524,
-0.6057482362,
0.8388875127,
0.279722333,
-0.1023294479,
-0.2366140932,
-0.1723899543,
0.403780818,
-0.0637961701,
-0.448566556,
0.2708728611,
0.1825920045,
0.2224181592,
-0.592468679,
0.0376559272,
-0.1164776087,
0.1023259088,
0.2969408333,
-0.4466311038,
0.8994934559,
0.0661806911,
0.0519398823,
0.2901873589,
1.0273917913,
0.4624062181,
0.3242447376,
0.4761017263,
0.4373586476,
0.4426062405,
0.2789177001,
0.8636407852,
-0.2474693507,
0.1336352974,
1.3596932888,
-0.345821172,
0.8735409379,
0.6745758057,
-0.0998278111,
0.3998327553,
0.3094884753,
0.3080424964,
1.009434104,
0.2453193963,
-0.7163629532,
-0.0478123128,
0.0630552024,
-0.1705193967,
0.2434121519,
0.2418901473,
-0.4908998013,
-0.4534321725,
0.1579695195,
0.0184054095,
0.3895204663,
0.0378857553,
0.8186641335,
0.0260142144,
-0.7356451154,
0.7687911391,
-0.0189780351,
0.7082425952,
-0.7342680097,
-0.1452514529,
-0.3525753021,
0.4009155929,
0.0245795958,
-0.8628715277,
0.470612824,
0.1008394957,
-0.0809422806,
-0.6295909286,
0.3052281141,
-0.520506084,
-0.3215384185,
0.2702557147,
0.3060004711,
0.287995249,
0.0931684449,
-0.8351551294,
-0.2653235495,
0.2910389602,
-0.2183066458,
0.2392309159,
0.7085592151,
0.0585063733,
0.4327524304,
0.3313105404,
0.3864036798,
0.3608270288,
-0.1126517057,
0.6242343783,
-0.407523036,
-0.9419083595,
-0.9068504572,
0.2970807552,
-0.2680848539,
-0.4685862362,
0.855035603,
0.4345011413,
0.4608241916,
-0.0355448276,
0.7355296016,
-0.1987188309,
0.4968387485,
-0.6712059975,
0.8448065519,
-0.5363770127,
0.1585759819,
-0.5055416822,
-0.9234130979,
-0.1524052471,
0.6833330989,
0.0165051799,
-0.0282089338,
0.8332992196,
0.5715941191,
-0.2440203726,
-0.4034006298,
0.3466041088,
-0.0612228699,
0.7402559519,
0.6019129157,
0.7453095913,
-0.1987078041,
0.7739387751,
-0.2777380049,
-0.4274727106,
0.0844517276,
-0.8616397381,
-0.5717952847,
-0.527318716,
-0.6409292221,
-0.5567445159,
-0.0307894591,
0.3207275867,
0.4387386143,
-0.4901286364,
-0.1525333375,
-0.7221375704,
0.1190908775,
-0.2429445833,
-0.2729145586,
0.495503068,
-0.3394546509,
-0.9048069715,
0.3558884859,
0.2441516668,
0.2035944462,
-0.0710477531,
-0.2774950564,
-0.372552067,
0.074064739,
0.281257838,
0.1253941208,
-0.65169245,
-0.0306037888,
-0.3486949205,
-0.0812085122,
0.085665606,
0.8592218757,
-0.3712850213,
0.1479397267,
0.4840231836,
0.7558799982,
0.2908678651,
-0.0773011595,
0.694063127,
-1.0100518465,
0.2508484423,
0.5441973209,
0.2724528611,
0.3066400886,
-0.1959162652,
0.0826342255,
0.320861727,
-0.7480913401,
-0.5844194293,
0.2558073103,
-0.7825417519,
-0.6492929459,
1.1626931429,
-0.4140529633,
-0.1322757155,
-0.0173060223,
-0.2306393683,
0.3550526202,
-0.5713909268,
0.6466882229,
0.4845378399,
-0.0088995844,
-0.2139897048,
-0.2825120986,
0.5381228924,
0.5750894547,
-0.8105431795,
0.3545636535,
0.6372033954,
0.4317645431,
-0.1263590157,
0.8558001518,
-0.0874909163,
0.4038237631,
0.1104050875,
-0.1462496072,
0.3763625622,
-0.0815001056,
-0.3415644169,
0.4575170577,
0.2899850607,
-0.3731578887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13066v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13066v2
|
Leveraging Large Language Model as Simulated Patients for Clinical Education
| 2024-04-13T06:36:32 | 2024-04-25T02:39:24 |
Yanzeng Li, Cheng Zeng, Jialun Zhong, Ruoyu Zhang, Minhao Zhang, Lei Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Simulated Patients (SPs) play a crucial role in clinical medical education by
providing realistic scenarios for student practice. However, the high cost of
training and hiring qualified SPs, along with the heavy workload and potential
risks they face in consistently portraying actual patients, limit students'
access to this type of clinical training. Consequently, the integration of
computer program-based simulated patients has emerged as a valuable educational
tool in recent years. With the rapid development of Large Language Models
(LLMs), their exceptional capabilities in conversational artificial
intelligence and role-playing have been demonstrated, making them a feasible
option for implementing Virtual Simulated Patient (VSP). In this paper, we
present an integrated model-agnostic framework called CureFun that harnesses
the potential of LLMs in clinical medical education. This framework facilitates
natural conversations between students and simulated patients, evaluates their
dialogue, and provides suggestions to enhance students' clinical inquiry
skills. Through comprehensive evaluations, our approach demonstrates more
authentic and professional SP-scenario dialogue flows compared to other
LLM-based chatbots, thus proving its proficiency in simulating patients.
Additionally, leveraging CureFun's evaluation ability, we assess several
medical LLMs and discuss the possibilities and limitations of using LLMs as
virtual doctors from the perspective of their diagnostic abilities.
|
[
-0.2442955971,
-1.0427080393,
1.0082585812,
-0.0304757133,
-0.209354341,
0.2474452406,
-0.4653070569,
-0.4671306908,
0.4004802406,
0.6297881007,
-0.4424327612,
-0.3936282098,
-0.4447830617,
0.242707625,
-0.1281846017,
0.6287206411,
0.0666404292,
0.7732688189,
-0.6226955056,
0.0446174704,
-0.5674855709,
-0.6280758381,
-0.868538022,
-0.342723906,
0.3507880867,
0.1635636538,
0.5147691369,
0.5289575458,
0.3786081672,
0.4196567237,
0.2666988969,
0.1194339544,
-0.6668528318,
0.1151503026,
-0.1081177071,
-0.5625224113,
-0.1878087223,
-0.0052049258,
0.538200736,
0.8456023335,
-0.4065171778,
-0.4194592237,
-0.4213967621,
-0.0801793188,
-0.0853279084,
0.0739290267,
-0.4111861289,
0.2554403543,
0.10581135,
0.0110235577,
-0.5142921209,
-0.3567444682,
0.3254978657,
-0.7027439475,
0.1489672363,
-0.3531728983,
0.6931880116,
-0.0427704901,
-0.4374081194,
-0.3571898937,
-0.7281182408,
0.5412325263,
-0.9398534894,
0.3459647894,
0.202090621,
0.8041234016,
-0.4693571329,
-0.8369013071,
-0.7090547681,
-0.6241163015,
-0.0641820133,
0.3134498298,
0.1826880723,
0.5843116641,
0.3334917426,
0.5353055,
-0.3871855736,
0.369254142,
-0.4464872479,
-0.1277494133,
0.5331757069,
0.4050344527,
0.5341969728,
0.0453766771,
-0.4727460146,
-0.0178993735,
-0.4264838696,
-0.1972598284,
-0.2209205776,
0.142637074,
-0.2512196898,
0.3790753186,
0.1315299422,
0.8251670599,
-0.4000106454,
-0.4362259209,
0.0020112202,
0.1014207229,
-0.4400438964,
0.0679682791,
0.7316047549,
0.2886372209,
0.370665282,
-0.098892875,
0.1767785847,
0.425791353,
0.5505867004,
-1.1153948307,
-0.2085280865,
0.5135415792,
-0.285605967,
-0.4135815799,
-0.2411457151,
-0.683942318,
-0.3974692523,
-0.5296651721,
0.3565342128,
-0.5788820982,
-0.2664625347,
0.4929945469,
0.16177921,
-0.070156239,
0.8221971989,
-0.5144103169,
0.5405653119,
0.7258300781,
0.6146163344,
-0.0120989298,
0.0341011286,
-0.6396477818,
0.060053546,
-0.2502279282,
0.6534075141,
-0.7505938411,
-0.9180413485,
0.2221742421,
0.0227760728,
-0.2622312307,
-0.5872135162,
0.4177197814,
-0.127518028,
0.3666480184,
-0.107095629,
-0.8894706368,
-0.0092675146,
0.5275367498,
-0.2874022424,
0.4326234758,
0.3579007089,
-0.3291916847,
0.0410357565,
-0.6192867756,
-0.3642141521,
0.5266045332,
-0.765257895,
-0.2722808719,
-0.0282090195,
0.0446357094,
0.4198475182,
-0.3820651174,
0.6238310933,
-0.3583352566,
-0.4002049267,
0.4328958392,
-0.325214535,
0.5940911174,
0.19595927,
0.0285670348,
0.2411765605,
-0.3828456402,
0.0396259017,
0.152122438,
-0.1413651407,
-0.3072272837,
-0.1974934787,
0.0286609866,
0.3436424732,
-0.2707986534,
-0.6026981473,
0.6298760176,
-0.738325417,
0.347427249,
0.4305147827,
0.2181640565,
0.0077690291,
-0.4655452073,
0.9611873031,
0.0463650152,
0.4357773662,
-0.4200463891,
-0.5702648163,
-0.7086671591,
-0.5706689954,
0.2466905415,
0.512765944,
-0.8740941882,
-0.2499430478,
-0.1550104916,
-0.5138919353,
-0.6583035588,
-0.1199469417,
0.2990923524,
0.8468495607,
0.2018588483,
-0.1066125482,
-0.303647846,
-0.8240972161,
0.0516571999,
-0.1928829402,
-0.1301200241,
0.5629972219,
0.3716901541,
-0.5667427182,
0.6029618979,
-0.6263762712,
-0.4195102751,
-0.4141343534,
-0.3855393231,
0.076073803,
0.4257683754,
0.5564738512,
-0.8090977073,
-0.5025145411,
0.0381671265,
-0.7761528492,
0.0095540723,
-0.4991429448,
0.0362493955,
-0.2232758403,
0.5252967477,
-0.5154719949,
0.5158661604,
0.3932698667,
-0.1784657687,
0.673925519,
-0.696185708,
0.3953579962,
-1.217154026,
0.1072312519,
0.0674777254,
-0.4159338772,
-0.6933460236,
0.110296689,
0.0238699224,
-0.4032454193,
-0.3998059034,
0.7486790419,
-0.0998699442,
0.3612746298,
-0.2325272709,
0.3971840739,
-0.0655267313,
-0.0556827858,
0.2571313679,
0.5099102855,
0.5869290233,
-0.272505641,
0.3526698947,
0.3339259624,
-0.3188910484,
0.8344117403,
-0.7237889767,
-0.1160760298,
0.1037444621,
0.6235430241,
-0.4886774719,
-0.5212804079,
0.0472839065,
-0.2709284127,
0.2953773141,
-0.1539698392,
-0.6046217084,
-0.6094918847,
0.1436560303,
0.3107283413,
0.4561547339,
-0.2826451659,
0.4608943164,
0.2557796538,
-0.1419853568,
-0.2657872438,
-0.2525516748,
0.3294875026,
-0.2267562747,
-0.6035525203,
0.312012732,
-0.3026187122,
-0.2382296175,
-0.3133281469,
0.3769308925,
-0.0755838826,
0.0689465404,
0.4299153686,
0.5678375959,
-0.4098342061,
0.2815169394,
0.3186720312,
-0.0419769511,
0.1001949683,
0.0156284235,
0.5392975211,
-0.0514371432,
-0.7186997533,
-0.5387610793,
0.5165064335,
0.8165456057,
-0.2058952153,
0.846157372,
0.2343296111,
-0.6033340693,
-0.2546177804,
-0.9259411097,
-0.6227941513,
-0.438614279,
0.5690542459,
-0.0879113078,
-1.0879467726,
0.4597970843,
-0.6325021386,
0.067389369,
-0.0388403647,
0.6435489058,
-0.0393944196,
1.0407586098,
0.515729785,
0.321790725,
-0.0873192698,
0.0089923721,
0.1874391288,
-0.5233373046,
-0.5370209217,
-0.2465873808,
0.0496044308,
-0.1377791464,
-0.8313289285,
0.6544682384,
0.0595147759,
-0.1113606021,
-0.1080816165,
-0.2064462006,
0.3053165376,
0.1030852571,
0.2790794671,
0.1264872551,
-0.0353982151,
-0.4599321485,
-0.2368229479,
-0.6073765755,
-0.2965830266,
0.8894476891,
0.5899403691,
0.4091281593,
-0.0682414398,
0.6139924526,
0.2048895508,
0.6818966269,
-0.9379156828,
0.4977501333,
-0.1185906455,
-0.3453965485,
0.0089103887,
-0.4382228851,
-0.7628673315,
0.3462991416,
-0.4069343805,
-0.6638363004,
-0.1739241779,
0.1196658164,
-0.5557345152,
0.2863048017,
-0.5582566857,
0.9217969179,
-0.3296308815,
-0.2200529724,
-0.501092732,
-0.6780195832,
0.3681356609,
-0.3188447058,
0.3904715776,
0.1443199515,
0.3252013326,
0.3280808032,
-0.8216592669,
0.9169775844,
-0.0992845148,
-0.0373771638,
0.033927314,
0.3191754818,
0.0653132275,
0.4353438914,
-0.0865952,
0.0202103537,
0.2511920631,
-0.3716139793,
-0.5392180681,
0.9422612786,
-0.6226161122,
-0.8552573323,
-0.3053240478,
-0.4371044934,
-0.6091336608,
0.1846671402,
-0.1508221179,
0.5623015165,
-0.4684986472,
-0.063849628,
0.6804860234,
-0.7071297765,
-0.2140949816,
0.7317221761,
-0.6378244758,
-0.4268221557,
0.633531034,
-0.2848177254,
0.6095992327,
0.1286428273,
0.6046435833,
-0.3019017875,
-0.2477087379,
-0.6666801572,
0.7246414423,
-0.6385356188,
-0.1512351036,
-0.7874799967,
-0.4308455586,
-0.3953062296,
-0.5862068534,
-0.1659220159,
0.0744806901,
-0.2167964876,
-0.0765715986,
0.3609338999,
0.5506244302,
0.1521745771,
0.4712373018,
-0.7091551423,
0.3056382537,
0.2080968469,
0.1871039718,
-0.0605342947,
-0.4699712694,
-0.0892807841,
0.2447260618,
-0.0564139709,
-0.7592061162,
0.511888206,
0.1076344997,
0.7045886517,
0.9181203246,
0.0531550944,
0.8021367788,
-0.6440289617,
0.6012086272,
0.4888352752,
-0.590231657,
0.5602940917,
-0.4633841217,
0.0602382161,
0.5200616717,
0.3998897374,
-0.825104773,
-0.4527319968,
-0.5142191052,
-0.3687304854,
0.6512386203,
-0.1166015789,
0.4087242484,
-0.227407828,
0.5002987385,
0.0965285525,
0.1889800727,
-0.5034238696,
-0.115464896,
-0.00544023,
-0.3191289306,
-0.1270293891,
-0.2845113873,
-0.4225225449,
-0.2755907178,
0.3427584171,
0.0140151856,
0.0639065132,
0.3123573959,
0.2755852938,
-0.0585227124,
0.0691064969,
0.6692851782,
0.3292014897,
-0.0973494351,
-0.1605745107,
0.2132297307,
-0.6813373566,
-0.1779005826,
0.0772647187,
0.2263530493,
0.003593208,
0.2300045639,
0.6073540449,
0.4435919821,
-1.2290561199,
0.8020726442,
-0.2150166333,
-0.1415516585,
-0.4818560779,
0.1922973096,
0.3786146045,
0.235962972,
-0.1577958614,
-0.0924467146,
0.0883100256,
-0.3128692806,
0.3155367076,
0.3583355844,
-0.7734110951,
-0.1131333262,
0.7787929177,
0.23919487,
-0.514729619,
0.8544670343,
0.2877152264,
-0.5915369987,
0.7096248865,
0.9972689748,
0.4025985003,
-0.5457270145,
0.482922852,
0.2937695384,
-0.051857058,
-0.2326346785,
0.0364867486,
0.2007935047,
-0.354881078,
-0.486757189,
-0.6997339725,
-0.5636526942,
0.3507937789,
-0.3296837211,
0.6405472159,
-0.5831896663,
-0.1419911385,
-0.0875072777,
-0.1958679259,
-0.5390186906,
0.4161079526,
0.198897481,
0.9846599698,
-0.8219505548,
1.0930900574,
0.8414905071,
-0.2318696976,
-0.8509445786,
-0.3020118773,
0.044041086,
-0.8291790485,
0.5067788959,
0.3671934307,
0.1927868128,
-0.204083249,
-0.2614561021,
-0.0882230997,
0.747887969,
0.445348233,
-0.6450840831,
-0.1842588186,
0.4893691242,
0.9028624892,
-0.5596780777,
0.4654410481,
0.0848471373,
0.0872708112,
0.2960810363,
-1.0726823807,
-0.057358034,
-0.2916807532,
-0.1097175702,
-0.0908810943,
-0.3493863642,
0.6156842709,
-0.4997296035,
-0.007912227,
0.094997637,
0.2287849635,
0.3920261264,
0.2165293097,
0.4718055725,
0.3162329793,
0.577308476,
0.2326228172,
1.1465489864,
-0.1473407298,
0.1781101227,
0.796123147,
-0.3654418886,
0.6502787471,
0.476611048,
-0.1277900338,
0.3892286122,
0.436756134,
-0.0751209855,
0.0054626064,
0.6454885006,
-0.7057392597,
-0.6908845305,
-0.2619028687,
-0.5274365544,
0.3791313767,
0.8710387349,
-0.4007347524,
-0.089968197,
0.4237782955,
0.1506917179,
0.4706328809,
-0.1362481415,
0.4603057206,
0.4572777748,
-0.3952994347,
0.406247884,
-0.0057669315,
0.3119147718,
-0.7553115487,
-0.3985565603,
-0.1749313325,
0.2807194293,
0.0001902335,
-0.2977644205,
-0.2299830317,
-0.2336601168,
0.1888143867,
-0.0278750509,
0.4579669833,
-0.4501084983,
-0.8926514983,
0.1870534122,
0.2856112421,
0.2533001006,
0.1994493455,
-0.7216342092,
0.1812291443,
0.0389859937,
0.2835062444,
0.4626561999,
0.3158549368,
-0.106417276,
0.9779148102,
0.7669573426,
0.4287078083,
-0.487834543,
0.4124348462,
0.8582081199,
-0.1821134388,
-0.5516088605,
-0.5877167583,
0.3970711529,
-0.187598601,
-0.0982195362,
0.4510688782,
0.5947954655,
0.5176782012,
-0.2603159845,
0.617215693,
0.4961459637,
0.6832441688,
-0.3389489055,
1.0291370153,
-0.6100124717,
0.4878957868,
-0.49113065,
-0.3737712801,
-0.4131520689,
0.7402306199,
-0.3474600017,
0.0177597255,
0.3847694099,
0.5057944059,
-0.2549097836,
0.053150069,
0.7947548628,
0.338233918,
0.739893496,
0.6047047973,
0.7268829942,
-0.1337247789,
0.0317636169,
-0.2863904238,
-0.4485510886,
-0.5179545283,
-0.5149618387,
-1.1259796619,
-0.393517524,
-0.4373604357,
-0.3882651031,
0.0232271533,
1.0335649252,
0.5936516523,
-0.5983067155,
-0.2025247812,
0.1895032227,
-0.3818448484,
0.268307209,
-0.2167956829,
0.4616454542,
0.0176336225,
-0.6665678024,
0.5305598974,
0.3370478451,
0.2471769005,
-0.4199143946,
0.025617253,
0.2076745629,
0.228813082,
0.6191382408,
0.3095423877,
-0.6722054482,
-0.0652239397,
0.1589765996,
-0.2419374287,
-0.0961115956,
0.810786128,
-1.1654170752,
0.8969672322,
-0.3641014099,
0.7480834126,
0.3389120102,
-0.0197032131,
0.7454504371,
0.076423645,
0.3157587349,
0.4870726466,
0.172451809,
0.2011584789,
-0.4835484028,
0.0328816175,
0.189868629,
-0.4575298429,
-1.0580258369,
0.192786485,
-1.0124118328,
-0.4151415229,
1.051563859,
-0.4278683662,
0.2450323552,
-0.1340211481,
-0.5666091442,
0.0603286065,
-0.0491508394,
0.917747736,
0.1742715538,
-0.2775007486,
0.0904777348,
-1.027001977,
0.4730046988,
0.4361377954,
-0.994566083,
-0.2740896642,
0.6188730597,
0.499499023,
-0.1852201223,
0.6619457006,
-0.3386408687,
0.140238747,
-0.2452274412,
-0.1387831867,
-0.1951508224,
-0.0807301775,
0.0500733592,
-0.0632659048,
-0.1089345589,
0.2943669558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.13065v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.13065v1
|
Intellecta Cognitiva: A Comprehensive Dataset for Advancing Academic Knowledge and Machine Reasoning
| 2024-04-13T06:11:25 | 2024-04-13T06:11:25 |
Ajmal PS, Ditto PS, Jithin VG
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Intellecta dataset emerges as an innovative synthetic dataset, engineered to
enhance the cognitive processing capabilities of contemporary language models.
With a composition of 11.53 billion tokens, integrating 8.01 billion tokens of
synthetic data with 3.52 billion tokens of rich textbook data, Intellecta is
crafted to foster advanced reasoning and comprehensive educational narrative
generation. Leveraging the Mixtral-8x7B-Instruct-v0.1 model, the dataset
facilitates the generation of complex thought processes and detailed,
textbook-style explanations, thus enabling language models to engage in both
critical thinking and profound educational discourse. This hybrid dataset
stands as a testament to the potential of synthetic data in pushing the
boundaries of AI, offering a repository that is not only vast and varied but
also refined to align with ethical standards and intellectual rigor.
|
[
-0.5024208426,
-1.0679506063,
0.5429091454,
-0.1389187872,
0.0200202689,
0.2557825446,
-0.1711365432,
-0.3418995142,
0.2281220853,
0.2965503335,
-0.8112127185,
-0.3130116463,
-0.2898671925,
-0.2573245764,
-0.4604665041,
0.9720292687,
0.2302974164,
0.2075783312,
-0.5617186427,
-0.1197052225,
-0.5850098729,
-0.6959569454,
-0.558863163,
-0.4008147717,
0.4458933771,
0.9190320373,
0.4254738092,
0.1636079699,
0.5201701522,
0.2469318062,
0.3658121228,
0.2210132629,
-0.5959507227,
0.031504035,
-0.5645951033,
-0.6935347319,
-0.5593252182,
0.0915029198,
0.4327834249,
0.8101029992,
-0.0214235056,
0.407420516,
-0.1722884625,
0.9057920575,
-0.5516322851,
0.316209048,
-0.5717695355,
0.088830255,
-0.3263339102,
0.0760255009,
-0.5292859077,
-0.5207516551,
0.4225722253,
-0.78733778,
-0.0209326018,
0.1467617005,
0.6387864351,
0.417784363,
-0.3221486807,
-0.1299983561,
-0.7758185267,
0.8863664865,
-0.1758031249,
0.2372212112,
0.1555438787,
0.5167720914,
-0.171731934,
-0.9922833443,
-0.9736439586,
0.3026769459,
0.273157835,
0.3565348387,
0.0955589637,
-0.1662210971,
0.1750067025,
0.5546619296,
-0.5238232017,
0.0816129744,
-0.618858397,
-0.0935292244,
0.7746781707,
0.2835961282,
0.6244401336,
0.0678990558,
-0.2141384482,
-0.3867225349,
-0.7289192677,
0.0873913616,
0.4152178168,
0.034273088,
0.1266456693,
0.6650180221,
-0.3137661517,
0.7471784949,
-0.0515564121,
0.2982946038,
0.2628884614,
-0.2585722506,
-0.27006042,
0.328871578,
0.6963480115,
0.285694927,
0.5220245123,
-0.2322904468,
0.1594707817,
0.4878205061,
0.3424426317,
-0.7988073826,
-0.4430178702,
0.4592030346,
-0.1565888971,
0.0127754137,
0.1251041144,
-0.9684029222,
-0.0403316021,
-0.908364594,
0.2756038308,
-0.7357925177,
-0.0567033552,
0.2422836572,
-0.2334546149,
-0.0039611026,
0.3908619881,
-1.0803464651,
0.4218698442,
0.7364109755,
0.4731127918,
-0.4373829067,
-0.1302169114,
0.1158776879,
0.118917048,
-0.3935964406,
0.9925931096,
-0.8468059301,
-0.1852703542,
-0.2146683186,
-0.2557620108,
-0.2441386133,
-0.5880470872,
0.8169211745,
-0.49400419,
0.5601736307,
-0.2092805058,
-0.9826260805,
-0.844371438,
0.1893231422,
-0.8819956183,
1.1420384645,
0.2433773279,
-0.4363126755,
0.5791614652,
-0.8285333514,
-0.0423513427,
0.3337237835,
-0.4073251784,
-0.1305944622,
-0.1436816752,
0.2078761756,
0.374940902,
-0.6726819277,
0.9319378734,
-0.2715878785,
-0.2930886149,
0.3271102607,
-0.4746511877,
0.9817349315,
0.1274838895,
-0.3103977144,
0.0264569391,
-1.126337409,
0.2069361508,
0.1771385968,
0.0710642859,
-0.5895335078,
-0.0069839032,
-0.1382289231,
0.2931570411,
0.511719346,
-0.4406184554,
0.1976628751,
-0.2802165747,
0.3498493433,
0.7203035951,
0.0694389567,
0.4248824418,
-0.4925550818,
0.3427605331,
0.0688363537,
0.0728572458,
-0.0276085436,
-0.59847188,
-0.8655312061,
-0.3683465123,
0.0054268814,
0.8455042243,
-0.5768530369,
0.5068371892,
-0.3524108231,
-0.7313421369,
-0.6514820457,
-0.1390260607,
0.0957332104,
0.8438410759,
0.5404144526,
0.0110019455,
-0.6535364389,
-1.1782494783,
-0.2530422807,
0.0675819591,
-0.0882602036,
0.438849926,
0.7696843743,
-0.0092521794,
0.958311379,
-0.3744817674,
-0.1537244618,
-0.0411505625,
-0.1298095882,
0.3035112917,
0.7391394377,
0.4605869651,
-0.8444942236,
-0.4300332069,
-0.2355599105,
-1.2410497665,
0.2131810337,
-0.1914298981,
-0.453183502,
-0.2042373568,
0.2045413554,
-0.4661503434,
0.3626314998,
0.324547261,
-0.6008113027,
0.2986771464,
0.0286722835,
0.3001359999,
-1.1632522345,
0.0382625349,
-0.2052260339,
0.2546813488,
-0.5560930967,
0.1222142801,
-0.0643235743,
-0.0618159734,
-0.4025201499,
0.5255914927,
-0.1000186652,
0.2328906208,
0.3159126639,
0.3389688432,
0.1463944167,
0.5828529596,
-0.2431922853,
0.9628152251,
0.5568448305,
-0.5871319771,
0.5652824044,
0.6965377331,
-0.5344361663,
0.8554241061,
-0.6723979712,
0.3132381737,
0.0463581495,
0.0837554634,
-0.4320639968,
-0.4691120088,
0.1477626711,
-0.2798437178,
-0.0915280059,
0.5146009326,
-0.4414330423,
-0.2860810757,
-0.1292841136,
0.5907587409,
0.3727303147,
-0.7537642121,
0.7742168307,
0.7219900489,
-0.3786229789,
-0.4566491246,
-0.6833376884,
0.3790938854,
-0.1627803743,
-0.7954887748,
0.5197731853,
-0.3348806798,
-0.6688839197,
0.0409236923,
0.426320225,
-0.062171068,
-0.0854500756,
0.2968968153,
0.7734076977,
-0.1192036048,
0.2579993904,
0.3201547861,
0.0387125351,
0.2526172996,
-0.3701400459,
0.590655148,
-0.0775482878,
-0.3527372777,
-0.5927571058,
0.3292173445,
0.7487030625,
-0.0478307903,
0.9334639311,
0.090980038,
-0.5093491077,
-0.4428808987,
-0.2905591428,
-0.2757617533,
-0.4303838313,
0.2531189322,
-0.4770920873,
-0.6804860234,
0.5813567638,
0.0577038676,
-0.0888876915,
0.6517223716,
0.6898950934,
0.2410419583,
0.8750321865,
0.3693506122,
-0.0630028471,
0.2665531933,
-0.4891547859,
0.3717254996,
-0.8937994838,
-0.999102056,
-0.3576683998,
-0.3450471163,
-0.3688772023,
-0.3189100325,
0.1306147873,
-0.3249078095,
-0.4139324725,
-0.1101440415,
-0.8142057657,
0.5001248121,
0.8136979342,
0.2594026327,
0.2875346243,
-0.0190178249,
-0.0676767677,
-0.2161032856,
-0.841078639,
-0.752061069,
1.4839849472,
0.0078068497,
0.3889383674,
0.1927554458,
0.2704595327,
0.2739956379,
0.2612192333,
-0.8574755788,
0.7576012015,
-0.1647128016,
-0.9320400357,
-0.2037290186,
-0.1117153093,
-0.5998205543,
-0.0637131408,
-0.3241300285,
-0.6977065802,
0.39127177,
-0.0523133539,
-0.2153871059,
0.1737314612,
-0.9120289683,
0.7766184211,
0.004982681,
-0.544123888,
-0.6309325695,
-0.2297900766,
0.551826179,
-0.3838970959,
-0.0448831767,
-0.0305808783,
0.1499018967,
0.9823964238,
-0.4115103781,
0.6518152356,
0.0153975422,
0.1976251751,
0.7052701712,
-0.0620410815,
0.3834270239,
0.0032031725,
-0.2988402843,
0.0816121697,
-0.2243100554,
-0.5060151815,
-0.5086121559,
0.6077548265,
-0.8673225045,
-0.6505070329,
-0.3691776097,
-0.9206354022,
-0.2520171106,
0.1665440053,
0.0852328539,
0.6239432096,
-0.5424543023,
0.4759730101,
0.7783563137,
-0.1499654651,
0.2293868512,
0.2851851285,
-0.0038045065,
-0.3214201033,
1.1785051823,
0.5606755018,
0.02186976,
0.1179230586,
-0.2147150934,
-0.3106352389,
-0.5435292125,
-0.469568491,
-0.1677316576,
-0.8538127542,
0.1106708273,
-0.8889762163,
-0.1869901866,
-0.2396297008,
-0.2979854047,
-0.1815666854,
-0.8029716015,
-0.4409662783,
-0.4496623874,
0.414357096,
0.7207039595,
0.2018074989,
-0.0082718395,
-0.5666376948,
0.2513924539,
0.5517623425,
0.1183606088,
0.0164675433,
-0.4622273147,
-0.1648297757,
0.0387677439,
-0.0247015599,
-0.6223553419,
0.4600993991,
0.4620895684,
0.5841702223,
0.2371394485,
0.0261327736,
0.4010341465,
-0.4789784253,
0.9126393199,
-0.1058616415,
-0.8901375532,
0.5331959128,
-0.3501653075,
0.0994699299,
0.5932505131,
0.3970599174,
-0.1148950458,
-0.4488284886,
-0.9115732312,
-0.9203980565,
0.5880466104,
-0.006910034,
0.0483230464,
0.0777900144,
0.3491075337,
0.4758408964,
0.0693524405,
-0.2490661293,
-0.1682107747,
-0.4704589546,
-0.8205131888,
0.0040180595,
0.0163675211,
-0.4127890766,
-0.5763899684,
0.8882672191,
-0.3465764821,
-0.0478701331,
-0.0616777241,
-0.0701601133,
0.2341484427,
0.1085412577,
0.3797517419,
0.8617312908,
-0.0182795413,
-0.0103299795,
0.1350923181,
-0.7929177284,
0.2045644075,
0.1248240992,
-0.4058153927,
-0.4524398744,
0.0590993986,
0.6471280456,
-0.1774382889,
-1.1128790379,
0.0753774717,
-0.2732203305,
-0.1224652678,
-0.737627089,
0.4999136031,
0.0314927064,
0.2087085396,
0.5870354176,
0.3627395332,
0.3422827423,
-0.6171556711,
0.4017096758,
0.2049877197,
-0.317717731,
-0.5060973763,
0.7877579927,
0.1675200909,
-0.1273336411,
0.9699690938,
0.0951035693,
-0.3733737767,
0.9079045653,
0.4324616194,
0.8185836673,
0.0784004256,
0.3639125228,
0.6142405868,
0.1600630283,
0.0028914029,
0.4345912933,
0.1311742663,
-0.9706919789,
-0.3167810142,
-0.4088166654,
-0.686322391,
0.0223523043,
-0.7019876838,
0.1106466576,
-0.6033404469,
0.0216253214,
0.2067938894,
-0.0144116161,
-0.808599472,
0.8212490082,
-0.0755120069,
0.9871929288,
-0.8441590071,
0.9208501577,
0.4884359241,
-0.621718049,
-0.8957650065,
-0.443223983,
-0.0380932875,
-0.8050822616,
0.8044080138,
0.2022965252,
-0.0084377481,
0.1789282709,
-0.7040385008,
-0.7622427344,
1.0879009962,
0.401871562,
-0.6466549039,
0.278595686,
0.1267234087,
0.6147446632,
-0.5734886527,
0.0269586146,
0.8132228851,
0.6603612304,
0.0119593702,
-0.1745571494,
0.0243757926,
-0.6602175832,
-0.6391458511,
-0.1223602071,
-0.84397614,
0.9586441517,
-0.1234943941,
-0.1901559979,
-0.2489249408,
0.6977874637,
0.2657826841,
0.3667315245,
0.0073242579,
0.9003676772,
1.2447888851,
-0.4765487611,
0.9400115013,
-0.493368566,
-0.1180562824,
1.1190032959,
-0.2305570692,
0.6969695687,
0.4861732721,
-0.1752887666,
0.9785758257,
0.7888327837,
-0.1081286445,
0.2201447636,
-0.3205574155,
-0.5225520134,
-0.224463433,
-0.4519377351,
-0.128113091,
0.534453392,
0.8473913074,
-0.0344847813,
0.52863276,
-0.067664966,
-0.0825828463,
0.2970237434,
-0.3197032511,
0.8232596517,
-0.0203424413,
-1.1250272989,
0.2297665179,
-0.590716064,
0.2730035484,
-0.1750472188,
-0.1799990088,
-0.046300061,
0.387798667,
-0.1313470751,
-0.906604588,
0.3199611902,
-0.1454205662,
-0.2888188362,
-0.0684855059,
0.6376510859,
-0.3497203588,
-0.5357536674,
0.0899521187,
0.5306892991,
0.0238068048,
0.186088264,
-0.6256787777,
-0.2331647277,
-0.1084130704,
-0.3245239556,
0.111918129,
0.782703042,
-0.1285386086,
0.916211307,
0.7116538286,
-0.0704097748,
-0.0872513875,
0.098043412,
0.9504704475,
-0.7672462463,
-0.4775242805,
-0.6203350425,
0.5364452004,
-0.3854932785,
-0.4386794567,
0.7620940208,
0.6985089183,
0.7634832859,
0.0190267432,
1.1096606255,
-0.0401293524,
0.4535168707,
-0.4669238031,
0.5429922342,
-0.2977392673,
0.06712237,
0.1317843944,
-0.8149999976,
-0.2185119689,
0.3597770631,
-0.3490497172,
0.0226501934,
0.6805934906,
0.4989909828,
0.1452653259,
0.5110516548,
0.1409939677,
0.1407901645,
0.3103162944,
0.5595325828,
0.7214250565,
-0.4195917547,
0.1088406593,
-0.0982847139,
-0.2755054832,
-0.1323652118,
-0.4386535585,
-1.0047318935,
-0.5702236295,
-0.2084240019,
-0.2315198928,
-0.0400361046,
0.9682015777,
0.5493299961,
-1.0853561163,
-0.0011639639,
-0.4288641214,
0.0616142265,
-0.0638795048,
-0.3453015387,
0.4162862599,
-0.2137875259,
-1.1897619963,
0.4636084735,
0.4491701126,
0.1261584908,
-0.6612161398,
-0.0025490217,
-0.2824594676,
0.7097685337,
0.5711580515,
0.1471801996,
-0.2732823789,
-0.3584821522,
0.2444077134,
-0.0529535487,
-0.1090280265,
0.6149647236,
-1.158873558,
0.7173478007,
0.627363801,
0.6401886344,
0.3163886368,
-0.2759525776,
0.8515649438,
-0.203403756,
0.5974457264,
0.5802673697,
0.3618445396,
0.4675620794,
-0.4680330753,
0.6580933332,
0.3446377516,
-0.6244773865,
-0.6157534719,
0.109932363,
-0.9688165188,
-0.400172323,
0.4250055552,
-0.0233662426,
-0.4447642267,
-0.4059088826,
-0.1880915761,
0.1697528958,
-0.5418263078,
1.2260007858,
0.8178357482,
-0.1741713732,
0.0430164039,
-0.5384021997,
0.4781056941,
0.5926614404,
-1.1816122532,
-0.3010451794,
0.6554258466,
-0.2452127784,
0.2137443125,
0.3573539257,
-0.1236624941,
0.3332346082,
0.3731918037,
0.0522040054,
0.1442042291,
-0.5335224867,
0.2096451521,
0.3893475533,
-0.3825632632,
0.1588909328
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.