id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01334v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01334v1
|
Augmenting NER Datasets with LLMs: Towards Automated and Refined Annotation
| 2024-03-30T12:13:57 | 2024-03-30T12:13:57 |
Yuji Naraki, Ryosuke Yamaki, Yoshikazu Ikeda, Takafumi Horie, Hiroki Naganuma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP), Named Entity Recognition
(NER) is recognized as a critical technology, employed across a wide array of
applications. Traditional methodologies for annotating datasets for NER models
are challenged by high costs and variations in dataset quality. This research
introduces a novel hybrid annotation approach that synergizes human effort with
the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). This approach not only aims
to ameliorate the noise inherent in manual annotations, such as omissions,
thereby enhancing the performance of NER models, but also achieves this in a
cost-effective manner. Additionally, by employing a label mixing strategy, it
addresses the issue of class imbalance encountered in LLM-based annotations.
Through an analysis across multiple datasets, this method has been consistently
shown to provide superior performance compared to traditional annotation
methods, even under constrained budget conditions. This study illuminates the
potential of leveraging LLMs to improve dataset quality, introduces a novel
technique to mitigate class imbalances, and demonstrates the feasibility of
achieving high-performance NER in a cost-effective way.
|
[
-0.5650380254,
-0.3922239542,
0.0848530531,
0.0116628809,
-0.3959005475,
0.5310966372,
-0.2795069516,
-0.9647886753,
0.5564147234,
0.69250983,
-0.2672335505,
-0.4216117561,
-0.5153305531,
0.4973392487,
-0.3696819246,
1.0572190285,
-0.0368151702,
0.1659658402,
-0.2952763736,
-0.4143660367,
-0.3557166755,
-0.6698755622,
-0.6930395365,
-0.6869325638,
0.5085075498,
0.1399146616,
0.6051622629,
0.6263984442,
0.5555599332,
0.2228024751,
-0.1217595041,
0.5775325298,
-0.0820578262,
0.1021059975,
-0.0584387295,
-0.3181461096,
-0.6080495119,
-0.1114815474,
0.9029214382,
0.7427034378,
0.0294382982,
0.0898443758,
0.1922048479,
0.444342792,
-0.6470192075,
0.0397063531,
-0.7225258946,
0.0500691906,
-0.4852747023,
-0.2963236272,
-0.2306141108,
-0.1352380961,
0.1607282162,
-0.70712924,
0.0370222107,
0.225931406,
0.9313488007,
0.4571578205,
-0.1660623103,
-0.01796248,
-0.8132091165,
0.6851295233,
-0.7594183683,
0.2352912128,
0.2191256583,
0.1699662805,
-0.1727109998,
-0.4029178023,
-0.7008432746,
0.0363617092,
-0.3152706325,
-0.083336018,
0.0445489958,
0.0580685474,
0.4100252092,
0.6574895978,
-0.1532167941,
0.5361777544,
-0.1485110074,
-0.41264382,
0.6804205775,
0.1270837188,
0.417952776,
-0.069912605,
-0.4568143189,
0.0615260899,
-0.6554988623,
-0.1591912508,
0.4594208002,
0.5033613443,
0.0515969433,
0.8129226565,
-0.2944265902,
0.7493578792,
-0.1976620406,
-0.2599788308,
0.5777595639,
-0.2548714876,
-0.2613054812,
0.2710651457,
0.72815907,
0.4144939482,
0.301615715,
-0.2364552617,
-0.6087164879,
0.1464838088,
-0.0116733192,
-0.5057917833,
-0.2321947813,
-0.0149853304,
-0.1211841255,
-0.3401492834,
-0.1385525763,
-0.9298810363,
-0.6434841156,
-0.6666653752,
0.4549457431,
-0.227124244,
-0.2860279083,
-0.0663281232,
-0.0213363897,
0.2126653045,
0.434554249,
-0.783228159,
0.5616187453,
0.6815292835,
0.7474108338,
-0.2582112253,
-0.0527719632,
-0.4265714884,
0.2526143491,
-0.0293675624,
0.8674180508,
-0.5434163809,
-0.1974278092,
-0.3035633564,
-0.2567075193,
0.0142948218,
-0.85623914,
0.4935402572,
-0.5512689352,
0.0664592832,
-0.0377134643,
-0.7135320902,
-0.2276757061,
0.2234083265,
-0.8819770813,
1.3903523684,
0.0559758991,
-0.9157888293,
0.6558098197,
-0.4582878947,
-0.5296060443,
0.5433574915,
-0.3232574463,
-0.4706135094,
-0.0078171706,
0.5355328321,
0.3310085237,
-0.375020504,
0.5006373525,
-0.1303606033,
-0.339836508,
0.2507682443,
-0.1621646434,
0.4136087,
-0.1334344894,
-0.288251102,
-0.0272862129,
-1.0192404985,
-0.062424235,
0.0405591689,
-0.4324769974,
-0.6688277125,
-0.0563541353,
0.2273938209,
0.1602989286,
0.1399922371,
-0.4735893309,
0.0986460224,
-0.5502821803,
0.2344621718,
0.5350453258,
0.0152836023,
0.5145562887,
-0.3532505035,
0.2985038757,
-0.1067928523,
-0.1904705316,
-0.0184803773,
-0.3956510425,
-1.0849304199,
-0.5512306094,
0.7351961136,
0.769020319,
-0.7353091836,
0.5679574609,
-0.3660168648,
-0.3332577348,
-0.9361390471,
0.1161451861,
0.1761127561,
0.594676733,
0.7323747873,
-0.3115872145,
-0.8676085472,
-1.0848383904,
-0.2025789917,
0.0899897963,
0.0402599536,
0.2973248363,
0.5215432048,
-0.3169968128,
1.1028555632,
0.0039469921,
-0.4113263488,
-0.3214770854,
0.1766581386,
0.0281800143,
0.5845711827,
0.15624322,
-0.7810752988,
-0.104721874,
-0.0145332683,
-0.6329398751,
-0.3018606007,
-0.2498826087,
-0.0198396202,
0.2363841981,
0.4561892748,
-0.1809456944,
0.3809469342,
0.3859778345,
0.1083996072,
0.330213517,
-0.0254392046,
-0.0075189155,
-0.8864180446,
-0.0603780262,
0.2342337966,
-0.2023586929,
-0.4444755912,
-0.21073623,
0.1058807522,
0.0986150354,
-0.2188904583,
0.7081288695,
-0.657420814,
-0.0197758414,
-0.4540922642,
0.1327491999,
-0.0024720076,
0.1589086652,
0.1682392806,
0.8035237193,
0.4550477266,
-0.5325289965,
0.278631866,
0.006859771,
-0.1625505537,
0.6207282543,
-0.5172460079,
-0.11899212,
-0.2863147259,
0.253480643,
-0.4409693182,
-0.3114140332,
0.4437067807,
-0.1268956959,
0.576490581,
-0.2485697418,
-0.8779166937,
-0.0547132045,
-0.0805438906,
0.2815933228,
0.2500336766,
-0.6557461023,
1.0082110167,
0.7215360403,
-0.0583786704,
-0.4436703324,
-0.8069995642,
0.568955183,
-0.3072633743,
-0.3723943532,
0.6655189395,
0.3009707332,
-0.3142711222,
0.1304305643,
-0.0815674365,
0.0914783627,
0.100069195,
0.2810443044,
0.5126190782,
-0.1373246461,
0.2363077253,
0.0772844329,
-0.3349369168,
-0.131813556,
-0.2684116662,
0.3154212534,
0.0007651677,
-0.245871529,
-0.558028698,
0.2355654985,
0.209530279,
-0.4520659447,
0.7748194933,
0.4828246832,
-0.8211829662,
-0.3275437951,
-0.9235931039,
-0.0786803514,
-0.4200651646,
0.1864424795,
-0.2048181593,
-0.9039062858,
0.4644528031,
-0.1843124479,
0.1171047539,
0.50006181,
0.2392084301,
-0.0694183856,
0.4690778553,
0.3924355507,
-0.207860589,
0.3922910094,
-0.084834829,
0.1966382265,
-1.0752569437,
-0.4467854202,
-0.3836131692,
-0.53266114,
-0.7240274549,
-0.5390174985,
0.0081382981,
0.010438229,
0.0977514982,
0.2252386212,
-0.5205054283,
0.592641294,
0.709472537,
0.015025625,
0.450481832,
0.0734606981,
-0.0149585595,
-0.2352478206,
-0.3973937333,
-0.8284629583,
1.0890868902,
0.2316345274,
0.5529758334,
-0.098563917,
1.0523152351,
0.1279623061,
0.4747644365,
-0.5743402243,
0.755962491,
-0.0562410988,
-0.450873524,
-0.1431925148,
-0.5023807287,
-0.6629940867,
0.4291880429,
-0.7369727492,
-0.6947948337,
0.1999041587,
0.192686528,
-0.2947596014,
0.6143860221,
-0.5748927593,
0.4661634564,
-0.4388682544,
-0.21378842,
0.1802551448,
-0.5573741794,
0.2010623217,
-0.2721237242,
0.2358677685,
-0.3009676933,
-0.3547939658,
0.7939617634,
-0.2801119685,
0.7099211216,
-0.006741649,
-0.0058846562,
0.1536749601,
-0.2629984915,
0.5891389251,
0.1166000292,
-0.1386234611,
0.3385014832,
-0.5298197865,
-0.176424861,
-0.4837844968,
0.7278882861,
-0.5701617002,
-0.3139074743,
-0.6286582947,
-0.6139778495,
-0.2176633775,
0.1680041999,
0.0788114592,
0.2894933522,
0.2179220617,
-0.103622146,
0.6977615952,
-0.2099333405,
0.4326521754,
0.1451964974,
-0.036144536,
-0.9225054383,
0.9220424891,
0.3937368691,
0.1749707311,
0.434987396,
-0.1048930734,
-0.1575276554,
-0.736992538,
-0.4161444604,
0.2556706369,
-0.5686157942,
-0.2774761021,
-0.9815182686,
-0.2552373707,
-0.1549922675,
-0.044736445,
-0.2282449007,
-0.5442221761,
-0.4941241145,
-0.1949108839,
0.3460359871,
0.4513440132,
0.0864076689,
0.3188772798,
-0.5426195264,
0.2152008861,
0.1272270381,
0.3844203651,
0.0167201627,
-0.3397589028,
-0.0691418648,
-0.1514183581,
0.0876641646,
-0.7061024308,
0.3577364683,
0.2360877991,
0.7040960193,
-0.0283089392,
0.0925034583,
0.7186493874,
-0.2806197405,
0.4412933588,
0.0505356304,
-0.7945832014,
0.5027335882,
-0.137734741,
-0.0350432508,
0.745955646,
0.0625080168,
-0.3458380699,
-0.3934930265,
-0.6385213137,
-1.431912899,
0.5487068892,
0.2552600801,
-0.0877099633,
0.1316754967,
0.3920363486,
0.1301617473,
0.207186386,
-1.013502121,
-0.5405498743,
0.2283895761,
-0.2869049311,
-0.1023311615,
-0.1789492518,
0.0863316357,
-0.2165899873,
1.00666821,
0.0886719078,
-0.1937199831,
0.1223968863,
-0.3548200727,
0.0046094772,
0.3590144813,
0.2769470811,
0.213317439,
-0.1226208732,
0.2396492362,
0.5034461617,
-0.3473055959,
0.061334122,
0.4942446947,
-0.563847959,
0.1485273838,
0.2199504375,
0.7889966369,
0.2748056352,
-0.6135841608,
0.1180113927,
0.1370101869,
0.1133032218,
-0.3129356802,
0.136652559,
0.0696450844,
0.2713481784,
0.4934669435,
0.1598723829,
0.1461996138,
0.0089242775,
0.1334735006,
0.3977413774,
-0.1681891382,
0.0309441388,
0.4814541936,
0.2845706344,
-0.3548214734,
0.543273747,
-0.2791790962,
-0.402202934,
0.4555569291,
0.3593959212,
0.7581753731,
0.1183211803,
-0.0440073311,
0.3943637908,
0.6271372437,
-0.2004173398,
0.10025426,
0.0625333115,
-0.6783263683,
-0.5478653312,
-0.8282214999,
-0.6448179483,
0.2199807465,
-0.6175163388,
0.5277535319,
-0.4169985652,
-0.2485705465,
0.1858388036,
-0.0980265886,
-0.591543138,
0.397051245,
0.5848833919,
0.6008866429,
-0.8223039508,
0.5551251769,
0.897390008,
-0.4046525061,
-0.6046990752,
-0.0878287703,
0.0353395715,
-0.4920571744,
0.6203156114,
0.3872389793,
0.0420247763,
0.0784374401,
-0.065635927,
-0.9153482318,
0.9591361284,
0.2629876733,
-0.7829287052,
0.0375032946,
0.3254359961,
0.5067375898,
-0.4363394678,
0.0744669288,
0.5141421556,
0.4803014696,
-0.0516088903,
-0.8249601126,
0.005426534,
-0.3141981363,
0.0492542684,
0.5841031075,
-0.1542987823,
0.5485479832,
-0.2302159816,
-0.3146179318,
-0.2564338744,
0.7609195709,
0.29668203,
0.4771929979,
0.5071838498,
0.9572086334,
0.9926748872,
-0.2677054703,
0.6599957347,
-0.0223426465,
0.1432728022,
1.4134787321,
-0.5507327318,
0.7375459671,
0.6761312485,
-0.2237211913,
0.3003082871,
0.6639862061,
-0.3516785502,
0.2146481276,
0.4737033546,
-0.4889456332,
-0.2734072208,
-0.4434073865,
-0.3145329356,
0.172145322,
0.3740318716,
-0.3608215451,
-0.2499986738,
0.1026804745,
-0.0709826499,
0.028063871,
-0.3189683557,
0.9194774032,
-0.0212386921,
-0.2242063582,
0.150893271,
-0.0726316497,
1.1036742926,
-0.185557574,
-0.028321201,
0.032885775,
-0.0313794315,
-0.3961840272,
-0.565613389,
0.1604322195,
-0.0130592128,
-0.2006730586,
-0.1468530744,
0.6851431131,
-0.489702791,
-0.6991921663,
0.4290223718,
0.3841146231,
0.0308372211,
0.0744922385,
-0.4700623155,
-0.001246053,
-0.224297896,
0.1038542315,
0.2771642506,
0.3556218445,
-0.1632538438,
0.5481671691,
0.7244203091,
0.5150367618,
0.1159045398,
0.2514482737,
0.8183526397,
-0.6136017442,
-0.2767751515,
-0.9836258292,
0.5629261732,
-0.3614633381,
-0.2676885724,
0.5589271188,
0.724163413,
1.1208257675,
0.2668600976,
0.8737655878,
0.1575701386,
0.6379465461,
-0.4154484272,
0.418830812,
-0.4760550261,
0.5848150253,
-0.373894155,
-0.9269707203,
-0.7108270526,
0.4309513867,
-0.2861943543,
-0.0720685944,
0.1830407083,
0.7381965518,
0.1274242848,
0.1634405255,
0.0306158457,
-0.2277207077,
0.1618125439,
0.2094231993,
0.9053000808,
-0.3885166645,
0.2813357711,
-0.5577914715,
-0.0482560694,
-0.202630192,
-0.9910010099,
-0.8201239109,
-0.2024546415,
-0.7903379798,
-0.2569776177,
0.1101230904,
1.2133239508,
0.4593264461,
-0.902625978,
0.0263059512,
0.0104634454,
-0.0646220222,
-0.0783413723,
-0.2048245519,
0.1990968585,
-0.1731022298,
-0.7097862959,
0.2583435476,
0.4430587292,
0.4476116896,
-0.0794207826,
0.1212657243,
-0.2979711294,
-0.1326144636,
0.3187642694,
0.1835090667,
-0.8619676828,
0.0940617546,
-0.3242914379,
-0.0761450827,
0.1376504898,
0.5987113714,
-0.9503737092,
0.3899377584,
0.1657156348,
1.0269196033,
0.181000188,
-0.064807266,
0.3357700408,
-0.6629200578,
0.002347861,
0.5630941987,
0.5550683141,
0.8152335882,
-0.4003330171,
0.5629013777,
0.2382437289,
-0.2962181866,
-1.0556409359,
-0.1893213093,
-0.9187148809,
0.2241490334,
1.0511665344,
0.2069222629,
0.0588008501,
-0.2272789627,
-0.1530294567,
0.2792431116,
-0.4889070392,
0.4515567124,
0.6128128171,
-0.0812037215,
-0.2002956271,
-0.6109807491,
0.2734798491,
0.3629300594,
-0.9601508379,
-0.0713561997,
0.5495288372,
0.1397217512,
0.1546845436,
0.2697511613,
-0.1382292807,
-0.170257017,
-0.3686400652,
0.4499683678,
-0.1431815773,
-0.1741639972,
-0.393512398,
0.0814998597,
-0.0506142415,
-0.1158986539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00303v1
|
A Comprehensive Study on NLP Data Augmentation for Hate Speech Detection: Legacy Methods, BERT, and LLMs
| 2024-03-30T09:55:58 | 2024-03-30T09:55:58 |
Md Saroar Jahan, Mourad Oussalah, Djamila Romaissa Beddia, Jhuma kabir Mim, Nabil Arhab
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The surge of interest in data augmentation within the realm of NLP has been
driven by the need to address challenges posed by hate speech domains, the
dynamic nature of social media vocabulary, and the demands for large-scale
neural networks requiring extensive training data. However, the prevalent use
of lexical substitution in data augmentation has raised concerns, as it may
inadvertently alter the intended meaning, thereby impacting the efficacy of
supervised machine learning models. In pursuit of suitable data augmentation
methods, this study explores both established legacy approaches and
contemporary practices such as Large Language Models (LLM), including GPT in
Hate Speech detection. Additionally, we propose an optimized utilization of
BERT-based encoder models with contextual cosine similarity filtration,
exposing significant limitations in prior synonym substitution methods. Our
comparative analysis encompasses five popular augmentation techniques: WordNet
and Fast-Text synonym replacement, Back-translation, BERT-mask contextual
augmentation, and LLM. Our analysis across five benchmarked datasets revealed
that while traditional methods like back-translation show low label alteration
rates (0.3-1.5%), and BERT-based contextual synonym replacement offers sentence
diversity but at the cost of higher label alteration rates (over 6%). Our
proposed BERT-based contextual cosine similarity filtration markedly reduced
label alteration to just 0.05%, demonstrating its efficacy in 0.7% higher F1
performance. However, augmenting data with GPT-3 not only avoided overfitting
with up to sevenfold data increase but also improved embedding space coverage
by 15% and classification F1 score by 1.4% over traditional methods, and by
0.8% over our method.
|
[
-0.6346042156,
-1.0070127249,
0.1877997518,
-0.172582671,
-0.3054093421,
0.071547091,
-0.1874603033,
-0.8064932823,
0.278318435,
0.3984514177,
-0.538567245,
-0.3920886517,
-0.730240643,
0.0768105388,
-0.6214532256,
1.0882250071,
0.2109854668,
0.1782332808,
-0.0134251947,
-0.2356098443,
-0.4950529635,
-0.7969779968,
-0.614407599,
-0.3177060187,
0.6895467639,
0.0571534149,
1.0283976793,
0.4744977057,
0.4617270231,
0.1733129472,
-0.3127005994,
0.0998531356,
-0.4380957186,
0.2617754638,
-0.2308427244,
-0.0745517835,
-0.2950818539,
0.033525724,
0.3917376995,
0.6236692667,
0.1905304641,
-0.1928423196,
-0.0182985794,
0.5149483085,
-0.6410084367,
-0.3858560324,
-1.163320899,
0.1518643349,
-0.3898843229,
-0.0697560087,
-0.0170654412,
-0.4160684049,
0.2257793695,
-0.450928092,
0.2944595516,
0.072384946,
0.5331650972,
0.2640154064,
-0.0521623082,
-0.4704109132,
-0.6174154878,
0.9602932334,
-0.9888314605,
0.5033814311,
0.30932796,
0.1646625102,
-0.2343519479,
-0.5696340203,
-0.9371284842,
-0.3845748603,
0.0086414618,
0.0526036434,
-0.4445775449,
0.2516613007,
0.4312604666,
0.4958285987,
-0.5842833519,
0.517978847,
-0.2888180912,
-0.3625837862,
0.4824033976,
-0.0258589927,
0.3671216965,
-0.132240504,
-0.513882041,
-0.1419771761,
-0.6128025651,
-0.3499124944,
0.5844036937,
0.483891964,
0.2068673819,
0.4603531361,
-0.0303718355,
0.8186090589,
-0.1874079704,
0.0348987989,
0.5064388514,
-0.1755116135,
-0.3334262669,
0.0799501836,
0.5135288239,
0.3882346153,
0.2796453536,
-0.3079038262,
-0.1209982857,
0.2440997809,
0.2905187607,
-0.5699439645,
-0.1009606719,
0.0815900192,
-0.1130471006,
-0.1635890454,
-0.2614765465,
-0.7213218212,
-0.6079687476,
-0.5052835345,
0.5432091355,
-0.8405318856,
0.0498754568,
-0.0648369789,
-0.4861065149,
0.2697104812,
0.4429959357,
-0.5552051067,
0.1995117217,
0.7522301674,
0.798206985,
-0.6537572145,
-0.0304832608,
-0.4000702202,
-0.0428104065,
-0.1976919174,
0.3853584826,
-0.7129960656,
-0.2017947286,
0.089852117,
-0.3007128537,
0.3090044558,
-0.7064663768,
0.8734491467,
-0.7114126086,
0.2861787975,
-0.0704619214,
-0.8340246677,
-0.3817806542,
0.3594449461,
-0.5595973134,
1.1758719683,
0.1744777709,
-0.7319429517,
0.5387315154,
-0.4757820368,
-0.5039129853,
0.2007868439,
0.0670787767,
-0.6149533391,
-0.0022100545,
0.3452217579,
0.3688698709,
0.0827375129,
0.2663458884,
-0.5315632224,
-0.4163465202,
0.1754424125,
-0.5685768723,
0.778532207,
0.2382499725,
-0.3902158737,
-0.0281200912,
-0.616786778,
-0.2851680219,
-0.0695437416,
0.0239031259,
-0.5376731753,
0.001282171,
0.3251932859,
0.1962848902,
0.0078844251,
-0.8800916672,
-0.2910415828,
-0.6037425399,
0.0455432944,
0.8984478116,
-0.1860385686,
0.1398850828,
-0.5743920803,
0.3508823216,
-0.0646983385,
0.0402032919,
0.164703086,
-0.649240315,
-0.5332055688,
-0.2285636216,
0.0698670223,
0.553650558,
-0.9009419084,
0.6013636589,
-0.2185585052,
-0.3549792767,
-0.3743211031,
0.0477088988,
0.0146052837,
0.7125487328,
0.8873238564,
-0.2948460281,
-1.0332027674,
-1.0124949217,
-0.4855286777,
0.0593162775,
-0.0749130398,
0.2463828772,
0.4871300757,
-0.1844365001,
1.1255431175,
-0.2529398203,
-0.3760937452,
-0.2128558606,
0.0521295704,
0.1459199488,
0.3847899437,
0.5974286795,
-0.9315514565,
-0.5893104672,
-0.1913321465,
-0.1854009628,
-0.2918001711,
0.0703772381,
0.2662068605,
0.1717402339,
0.2951607406,
0.1673998088,
0.5547969937,
0.5687406659,
-0.070957303,
0.5886644721,
0.1737590581,
0.2507179677,
-0.8029467463,
-0.2452620864,
0.0764720663,
-0.3350928128,
-1.0422878265,
0.1187116578,
-0.2330227047,
0.0152247874,
-0.5966777802,
0.4259656966,
-0.0623072982,
0.1672359556,
-0.4506191313,
0.2636181712,
-0.3784077168,
0.2552186549,
-0.0379605368,
0.7526593208,
0.2397390604,
-0.5158722997,
0.6718018651,
0.193675831,
-0.29840222,
0.6461256146,
-0.3990337551,
0.224212721,
-0.2312984914,
0.3603957593,
-1.053071022,
0.005900437,
0.455240339,
-0.5874962211,
0.104475379,
-0.140128538,
-0.6050932407,
-0.4353331327,
-0.5501056314,
0.3736805916,
0.5629833341,
-0.8077642918,
0.3855922222,
0.3549213409,
-0.2358583212,
-0.5965428948,
-1.0121431351,
0.3948533237,
-0.374152571,
-0.58875072,
0.7637865543,
-0.0954529345,
-0.0730943158,
-0.1887347251,
0.0563059412,
-0.1412814409,
-0.0263149161,
0.1619622856,
0.2429682016,
0.1463815719,
0.2987194955,
0.0846781954,
0.3184302151,
-0.1681578308,
-0.0762425959,
0.6569402814,
0.3128882647,
-0.1984367818,
-0.2684778869,
0.3210738003,
0.2757433653,
0.274743557,
0.7229537368,
1.1291623116,
-0.5694122314,
0.0132891787,
-0.8850641847,
-0.1509307772,
-0.3982361555,
0.2700344622,
-0.0491418503,
-1.2927256823,
0.3892418146,
0.3811013401,
0.0517004766,
0.193913877,
0.492136389,
0.0089949248,
0.6613294482,
0.0526445992,
-0.4872434139,
0.7383682728,
0.209356904,
0.3583373725,
-0.8085334897,
0.1566296667,
-0.3134508133,
-0.4654955864,
-0.5911057591,
-0.694024384,
0.6192547679,
-0.2318159789,
-0.026580207,
0.2802889645,
-0.6073090434,
0.2307252884,
0.3740677834,
0.2244195491,
0.2202792615,
0.4600636065,
0.2693378925,
-0.4760996401,
-0.3161271513,
0.0029829436,
1.1675167084,
0.4361217022,
0.4172433317,
0.2095540017,
0.559620142,
0.6431408525,
0.338501066,
-0.8222959638,
0.4931835234,
-0.4457322061,
-0.7038516998,
-0.2389358729,
-0.4174210131,
-0.7117384076,
0.3809905052,
-0.3465159833,
-0.6932131648,
0.0397721343,
0.1376796067,
-0.1362301558,
0.5950157046,
-0.4325419962,
0.3357038498,
-0.0002873077,
-0.2965458333,
-0.3513737917,
-0.2534339428,
0.2960343063,
-0.298211664,
0.2897741199,
-0.0390715115,
-0.162498042,
0.8231816292,
-0.5132470727,
0.7154807448,
-0.3466467559,
-0.254237026,
0.070240058,
-0.2035498619,
0.7915682793,
-0.4619177878,
-0.2366102189,
0.2020500153,
-0.4192608297,
-0.1562589258,
-0.566731751,
0.7636638284,
-0.2416141629,
-0.5463258624,
-0.2305498123,
-0.7891494632,
-0.3510533869,
-0.1091543809,
0.0671210513,
0.2413657904,
-0.105862163,
0.3560120165,
0.6006773114,
-0.5288300514,
0.2804863453,
0.3304019868,
-0.1381844133,
-0.545202136,
0.9319345951,
0.1636303663,
0.3100838363,
0.1264397204,
0.2667542994,
-0.4667219222,
-0.8457769752,
-0.2108576745,
-0.0830730423,
-0.4169731438,
-0.1544215083,
-0.7756681442,
-0.1678439826,
-0.729275763,
-0.3032486439,
0.0301839765,
-0.4510978162,
-0.0169988032,
0.0520920157,
0.6876452565,
0.305275619,
-0.44798401,
0.4685267508,
-0.3241621554,
0.5727741718,
0.2030298263,
0.241417706,
-0.0586125739,
-0.977127552,
-0.1164594516,
0.2164529562,
-0.1457016468,
-1.0995174646,
0.5571770668,
0.0935438275,
0.2958756685,
-0.0854365528,
-0.0114191743,
0.7658002377,
-0.4625346363,
0.9204118848,
0.2363109142,
-0.783054173,
0.503518641,
-0.3284476995,
-0.0199254453,
0.3627316058,
0.4912787974,
-0.7593403459,
-0.4431962967,
-0.5374731421,
-1.0133825541,
0.5892793536,
0.2943111956,
0.327781707,
0.0817880854,
0.0832154676,
0.2167358845,
0.2017875314,
-0.882532835,
-0.5790710449,
-0.0179110095,
-0.0735428408,
0.1235508323,
-0.1883880496,
0.0866902098,
-0.5475011468,
0.9497680068,
0.2788321078,
0.0662872717,
0.1479295045,
-0.1639960557,
0.2363758087,
0.5309844017,
0.3538057804,
0.3251353204,
-0.3630339205,
-0.2196961641,
0.5035405755,
-0.4609910548,
0.0439567566,
0.3990780413,
-0.3320264518,
0.4110867977,
0.0576329716,
0.7832856178,
-0.0363795422,
-0.5008091331,
0.459628731,
0.4252883494,
-0.2271861583,
-0.3882202208,
-0.0066606724,
-0.3727604449,
-0.0471139438,
0.510266602,
-0.227395758,
0.4148173034,
-0.3897535801,
0.4117457569,
0.740193069,
-0.4363957942,
0.0842386261,
0.4276805818,
-0.1694817543,
-0.1598601192,
0.3248316944,
-0.2017226964,
-0.7284302115,
0.2698049247,
0.6044137478,
0.7078347802,
-0.4332711995,
0.2191390544,
0.3944077492,
0.2142378837,
0.4039225876,
0.0089339381,
-0.0718364865,
-0.9562595487,
-0.5117785335,
-0.672978878,
-0.4647823274,
0.6758089662,
-0.4852176607,
0.0740615129,
-0.4168772995,
-0.040720392,
0.1417586654,
-0.0773205087,
-0.5401304364,
0.3912841082,
0.4407149851,
0.8060939312,
-0.7477944493,
0.6965758204,
0.5196845531,
-0.1052800417,
-0.4162993431,
-0.077130653,
0.2113206983,
-0.8411061168,
0.5219959617,
0.1436435431,
-0.030797042,
-0.0231691804,
-0.5247957706,
-0.6198980212,
0.5675171614,
0.015737487,
-0.5607399344,
-0.0059026163,
0.4059504569,
0.6267341971,
-0.1039976701,
0.0968033075,
0.7483776212,
0.5661221147,
0.1876549274,
-0.6757232547,
-0.0117129283,
0.1508288234,
0.134703815,
0.2774884999,
-0.0198989175,
0.5993217826,
0.322835207,
-0.2060616463,
-0.0045008077,
0.4530883133,
0.1349242181,
0.2376250774,
0.7761023641,
0.8680469394,
0.4909585416,
-0.0825487599,
0.7678854465,
0.1441271156,
0.1799221784,
1.0910760164,
-0.0878604054,
0.6395199299,
0.4699302912,
-0.4504322112,
0.4310039282,
0.4113226831,
-0.2522415221,
0.2574875057,
0.4641889036,
-0.4356144965,
0.0752409697,
-0.3624478579,
-0.4836914837,
0.263964504,
0.6633790135,
-0.4760328829,
-0.4570780694,
0.3365434706,
0.1930789202,
0.1568917483,
-0.3717904091,
0.6498917937,
-0.1679717898,
-0.2594605088,
0.6663967967,
0.0277573299,
1.300536871,
-0.4817419052,
0.0899090394,
-0.0263823848,
-0.0012635799,
-0.2578494549,
-0.8520991802,
0.4839365482,
0.2020776272,
-0.0540566929,
-0.2674712837,
0.7583406568,
-0.6305242181,
-0.1697202772,
0.4022019207,
0.2079545856,
0.2462482005,
-0.2730155885,
-0.9017003179,
0.2910675704,
0.1154383123,
0.1307276487,
0.2931691706,
-0.1517074257,
0.1771061569,
0.3703996241,
0.8236441612,
0.4911042154,
0.2068726867,
0.2649625242,
0.9023695588,
-0.5834079981,
-0.3922861814,
-0.9248023033,
0.1915703267,
-0.3724454939,
-0.0745671988,
0.8780372143,
0.584990561,
1.0815168619,
0.1075465009,
0.9062792659,
-0.1576626152,
1.0453858376,
-0.5281227827,
0.3902068138,
-0.5097258687,
0.1302350909,
-0.6405135989,
-0.9143967628,
-0.554859817,
0.4661398232,
-0.5899059176,
-0.0343942009,
0.3433490098,
1.0008403063,
-0.0691481233,
0.1651879102,
0.5168403983,
0.1599775702,
0.5468605161,
0.3939396441,
0.6543559432,
-0.6159254909,
0.4744555652,
-0.3129995167,
-0.2190634012,
-0.2200297564,
-0.7537932396,
-0.5941569805,
-0.5283569694,
-0.3339904249,
-0.3296213746,
0.3666048944,
0.9004190564,
0.4983523786,
-1.0421577692,
0.1278055757,
-0.0096637197,
0.1212147847,
-0.0389447249,
-0.337228775,
0.1322248131,
-0.392793268,
-0.9472662807,
0.6899253726,
0.136741221,
0.0922865346,
0.0021881026,
0.1135772839,
-0.3631576598,
0.0010665593,
0.7293069959,
0.153872475,
-0.907574594,
-0.4894188344,
-0.4453564882,
0.1620939523,
0.098156549,
0.7756014466,
-0.9343013167,
0.6144120693,
0.3597167432,
1.0778323412,
0.2293470353,
0.0966362432,
0.369705528,
-0.928961575,
0.2016713023,
0.4836548567,
0.3302231133,
0.5526967049,
-0.1932991892,
0.4161463678,
0.4018592536,
-0.370744139,
-0.9424371719,
0.3750448227,
-0.8555777669,
-0.2998181581,
1.0334256887,
0.2126158923,
0.0580523647,
-0.4717379808,
-0.1830746084,
0.1384103745,
-0.4922080934,
0.5592482686,
0.7934638858,
-0.1073414609,
-0.0711445436,
-0.3149713576,
0.651292026,
0.5436075926,
-0.5460739732,
-0.0320260301,
0.8679919243,
0.0469143093,
0.2182942182,
0.2601180077,
-0.112621896,
0.1306577772,
-0.3729867935,
0.0319821574,
-0.076019302,
0.1223678365,
-0.5086391568,
0.1109842882,
-0.439661622,
-0.0729542375
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00297v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00297v2
|
TRABSA: Interpretable Sentiment Analysis of Tweets using Attention-based BiLSTM and Twitter-RoBERTa
| 2024-03-30T09:20:43 | 2024-05-16T14:35:36 |
Md Abrar Jahin, Md Sakib Hossain Shovon, M. F. Mridha, Md Rashedul Islam, Yutaka Watanobe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Sentiment analysis is crucial for understanding public opinion and consumer
behavior. Existing models face challenges with linguistic diversity,
generalizability, and explainability. We propose TRABSA, a hybrid framework
integrating transformer-based architectures, attention mechanisms, and BiLSTM
networks to address this. Leveraging RoBERTa-trained on 124M tweets, we bridge
gaps in sentiment analysis benchmarks, ensuring state-of-the-art accuracy.
Augmenting datasets with tweets from 32 countries and US states, we compare six
word-embedding techniques and three lexicon-based labeling techniques,
selecting the best for optimal sentiment analysis. TRABSA outperforms
traditional ML and deep learning models with 94% accuracy and significant
precision, recall, and F1-score gains. Evaluation across diverse datasets
demonstrates consistent superiority and generalizability. SHAP and LIME
analyses enhance interpretability, improving confidence in predictions. Our
study facilitates pandemic resource management, aiding resource planning,
policy formation, and vaccination tactics.
|
[
-0.1042788252,
-0.5005124211,
0.2135886699,
0.6645548344,
-0.5235625505,
0.7740069628,
-0.2199558318,
-0.4006944895,
0.3801851273,
0.263572216,
-0.4038209915,
-0.6417691112,
-0.6956960559,
-0.1897169352,
-0.4167049229,
1.3680336475,
0.1737552881,
0.0657430589,
0.1923726499,
-0.5749125481,
-0.28942734,
-0.2554012537,
-0.4841683805,
0.0290988702,
0.6807055473,
0.4293797612,
0.7694424391,
-0.2820315361,
0.6811279655,
0.1337355524,
-0.227376923,
0.3127619028,
-0.4573136568,
-0.0572454333,
-0.4601170123,
-0.1099979505,
-0.5663095117,
-0.0584222265,
0.3605445623,
0.5097036362,
-0.1914080679,
0.5902959108,
0.0457099602,
0.6107972264,
-0.5692304373,
-0.0361240506,
-0.4098505676,
0.0405743495,
-0.1361832023,
-0.0071564778,
-0.4240943193,
-0.6908490658,
0.5550530553,
0.1806842685,
0.2855234444,
-0.1406917721,
0.8380534649,
0.0361288115,
-0.524153173,
0.0663594231,
-0.9365611076,
1.036847949,
-0.508110106,
0.2703815997,
-0.1258060485,
0.5515253544,
0.2545704246,
-0.7389172316,
-0.4848617315,
0.1752183437,
0.0448249094,
0.3896977007,
-0.4068955481,
0.0008559414,
-0.1003416926,
0.3834947944,
-0.8265404105,
-0.4943097234,
-0.3304544687,
0.0094750943,
0.3578310609,
0.1438858658,
0.1005619615,
-0.3853326142,
-0.5218461156,
-0.0775768831,
-0.3339179456,
0.1087124273,
-0.2273149192,
0.3245428801,
-0.5568521619,
0.42504403,
0.2422559112,
0.5355657935,
-0.4096162319,
0.2341737747,
0.2839173377,
-0.3227667809,
-0.7008781433,
-0.321544826,
0.7431598902,
0.3100663722,
0.185456723,
-0.2338460833,
-0.087849766,
0.1764347553,
0.5280338526,
-0.4326817095,
-0.227419436,
0.3851732612,
-0.6925607324,
-0.5312547088,
0.3253766298,
-1.2748687267,
-0.5095005035,
0.146568805,
0.1796505004,
-0.1674116701,
-0.3384529352,
0.01929464,
-0.4868067503,
0.1744596511,
0.2289061546,
-0.2426096648,
0.190250054,
0.3901096284,
1.1469858885,
-0.0319879428,
0.293615073,
-0.3995054066,
0.3666673303,
-0.2874710262,
0.8356144428,
-0.7018126249,
-0.5542929173,
-0.0168127883,
-0.482057333,
-0.0489265732,
-0.3509272933,
0.3945513368,
-0.6447865367,
0.1104047149,
-0.2686266601,
0.0897489786,
-0.4244408011,
0.4611954093,
-0.6613514423,
0.8916800022,
0.3475929499,
-0.725961864,
0.1703744084,
-1.0394617319,
-0.7386505604,
-0.1573295444,
0.4495132267,
-0.4561540186,
0.4452400804,
0.3605045378,
0.4926925898,
-0.4808290601,
0.3264905214,
-0.5813196301,
0.1220730692,
0.265422225,
-0.2424424142,
0.7097242475,
0.2942466438,
-0.2964382768,
0.3301328421,
-0.4285115898,
0.0472627245,
0.1749482751,
0.0092248889,
-0.1643882692,
0.0059411,
0.4748210609,
0.1640443504,
0.1814771444,
-0.5822477341,
-0.0532399118,
-0.4041815698,
0.7543348074,
0.6443409324,
0.3134985864,
0.3537704647,
-0.131870687,
0.7525029778,
0.2857268751,
0.6210452914,
0.2251369208,
-0.4441585541,
-0.4877287447,
-0.2618946433,
0.1523362398,
0.4198246002,
-0.561616838,
0.2174226791,
-0.6327204704,
-0.704690814,
-0.5489990711,
-0.1749177128,
0.1756339073,
0.5717844963,
0.5886220336,
-0.0938985422,
-0.8020108342,
-0.9211768508,
-0.5792387128,
-0.1274478436,
0.2708204687,
0.0085552884,
0.2677953243,
-0.2610656321,
0.9959613681,
-0.3248708546,
-0.3920123577,
-0.8756255507,
0.3550432324,
0.0912111402,
-0.0951352715,
0.5859760642,
-0.9449877739,
-0.5957614183,
0.0428303406,
-0.5158264637,
0.0613883324,
-0.0045884233,
0.0545016527,
0.1895183921,
-0.3093596995,
-0.3813159764,
0.6456650496,
0.6781343222,
-0.1306192428,
0.1270664334,
0.2224692106,
-0.0573881418,
-1.3204143047,
0.1487056017,
0.3573715985,
-0.4649769366,
-0.6823928952,
-0.2261884958,
0.0856185853,
-0.1560451984,
-0.3994932175,
0.4926923811,
-0.0611448586,
-0.3571387231,
-0.1139214709,
0.0469644144,
0.4532034397,
0.1495026648,
-0.1459724754,
0.7760440707,
0.1795787364,
-0.2188287824,
0.3570123017,
0.1892445236,
-0.3559223115,
0.2195661515,
-0.8525019288,
0.059481699,
0.0804956183,
0.6260006428,
-1.0803722143,
-0.0263427459,
0.3644137681,
-0.4593786597,
0.1009098068,
0.2773811817,
-0.426114291,
-0.6833792329,
-0.5143024921,
0.2086545229,
0.4112742841,
-0.5063255429,
1.1106910706,
0.5530767441,
0.1065172106,
-0.6511974335,
-0.7811921835,
0.4445913732,
-0.309524864,
-0.4867773056,
-0.0417291,
0.3016682267,
-0.3491380513,
0.1063241661,
-0.1718068868,
-0.0292563736,
0.1301751137,
0.085399732,
0.2979228497,
-0.0006774806,
0.0366308428,
-0.0878046378,
0.0285002459,
-0.0686441734,
-0.4581033289,
0.6042155623,
-0.3889155388,
0.2099923342,
-0.5060816407,
0.4490943551,
0.7153589129,
-0.5653030276,
0.8164935708,
0.6232227683,
-0.2481153458,
-0.2408407182,
-0.4238172174,
0.1298434287,
-0.3581583798,
0.1758386344,
-0.091365248,
-0.4059361219,
0.5329879522,
0.1516151726,
0.1188921332,
0.2239619493,
0.6674051285,
-0.4377595186,
0.9939947128,
0.5954108238,
-0.375210613,
0.56921345,
-0.4429433644,
0.6098474264,
-0.710157752,
-0.3868430853,
-0.4570783377,
-0.5411891937,
-0.3327350616,
-0.3389911354,
0.4612196982,
-0.6705111861,
-0.1553788781,
0.2693039179,
-0.3333573043,
0.2011335641,
0.372794956,
0.3760197461,
-0.1971487105,
0.0086808205,
0.3800781369,
0.1179195642,
-0.4534121156,
-0.5764898062,
0.9059686065,
0.3333653212,
0.7019332647,
0.3707423508,
0.4906995296,
0.9278135896,
0.4736225903,
-0.7836693525,
0.4591808617,
-0.3702741861,
-0.6060982943,
0.0255485866,
-0.3184863329,
-0.7175503373,
0.0783579573,
-0.045771651,
-0.6352652907,
0.1732022166,
-0.0247883499,
-0.3839687407,
0.3854859769,
-0.8495172858,
0.7981051803,
-0.1109564304,
-0.2307310402,
-0.7120167017,
-0.7604779005,
0.3359880149,
0.1581568271,
0.3178201914,
-0.0461413898,
-0.1737039983,
0.7710442543,
-0.2032071352,
0.9856800437,
-0.1849268526,
0.1455924511,
0.2621673346,
-0.006607695,
0.316249311,
-0.0088529624,
-0.2458910346,
0.286591351,
-0.0115290163,
-0.7456294298,
-0.586240232,
0.5038947463,
-0.7964761257,
-0.5207266808,
-0.4904915094,
-0.5724647641,
-0.4841578007,
-0.04772605,
0.0054268544,
0.461525321,
-0.4025899172,
0.1842608303,
0.4658105373,
-0.0582384504,
0.4601062834,
0.0387814231,
0.0387435332,
-0.5901008844,
0.9186145067,
-0.0408810787,
0.045631811,
0.654681325,
0.4188999832,
-0.3538794518,
-0.2937442958,
-0.2428801209,
0.1437249035,
-0.4963189662,
-0.3893345594,
-0.6672319174,
0.0802890435,
-0.450510025,
-0.1240450144,
-0.2137978524,
-0.4501098692,
-0.2549374402,
-0.2969529033,
0.2840512097,
0.9414101243,
0.0139435856,
0.541269958,
-1.1909403801,
0.4731282294,
-0.0873062089,
0.1346216351,
0.2208397985,
-0.3132302463,
-0.3892567456,
0.1841260195,
-0.2731527686,
-1.1759974957,
0.5727697611,
0.1925675273,
0.0802458003,
0.6222118139,
0.2121441066,
0.8290471435,
0.1484226435,
0.9703780413,
0.2690116465,
-1.2103048563,
0.700378716,
-0.2453079969,
0.0734237209,
0.3318559825,
0.0594522096,
-0.5228096247,
-0.4874992073,
-0.627386272,
-0.5232178569,
0.7583283186,
0.0897127613,
0.2372819483,
-0.0197877754,
-0.1927256435,
0.0575482957,
0.2140727192,
-0.4507322907,
-0.0154864667,
-0.5040835738,
-0.6448554993,
-0.1973822117,
-0.3683294356,
-0.228169024,
-0.1207499579,
0.5088683963,
0.2250826508,
0.1586443931,
-0.0452069454,
-0.2749540806,
-0.190888688,
0.1669739485,
0.6547483206,
0.734452486,
-0.3263425231,
0.0475415103,
0.050543569,
-0.4723899364,
-0.0786071792,
-0.2664523721,
-0.0078411363,
0.1327648759,
0.4779960215,
0.6950987577,
0.1492237449,
-0.6419472694,
0.4934981763,
-0.2179084569,
0.1562700272,
-0.2302069217,
-0.1290094107,
0.0059846146,
0.3008102775,
0.3716951311,
0.3467307687,
0.1065437719,
-0.5346786976,
-0.0952633768,
0.5096147656,
-0.5277777314,
-0.7533636689,
0.4569247067,
0.3464984596,
-0.08763019,
0.3529565632,
0.3172783256,
-0.678155899,
0.6494207978,
0.2611713409,
1.1079038382,
-0.2809796333,
0.7282941937,
0.0819097385,
0.3794744313,
0.2929237187,
0.5882434845,
-0.1036714762,
-0.5212669969,
-0.0882235169,
-0.5098044276,
-0.5314812064,
-0.0313373022,
-0.9978333712,
0.1399268955,
-0.8163222075,
-0.3904639184,
0.1418180764,
-0.075089395,
-0.7492922544,
0.4877043366,
-0.0899448171,
1.0962289572,
-0.9547489285,
0.7723087668,
1.0437406301,
-0.5108135939,
-0.6588435769,
0.361836791,
-0.2135068476,
-0.8952707052,
0.4156222939,
0.1774199009,
-0.1013303474,
-0.0671001673,
-0.5079011917,
-0.5987944007,
0.9624375105,
-0.0482646227,
-0.1612250805,
0.0900419056,
0.1880736649,
0.6754051447,
-0.2880779505,
0.2454199493,
0.6287286282,
0.5957185626,
0.0688545406,
-0.4514048696,
-0.2203071713,
-0.0041598515,
0.0384263545,
0.284753561,
-0.8217772841,
0.3186419606,
-0.3440679014,
-0.2254167944,
-0.3208257258,
0.8241372705,
-0.2082580924,
0.6221995354,
0.4257836938,
0.5463133454,
0.6818910241,
-0.0766654313,
1.0528637171,
0.0255364981,
0.3208149076,
0.9480627179,
-0.4297415912,
0.8277155161,
0.4643675685,
-0.3238605559,
0.8861278892,
0.6440263391,
0.0248036031,
0.7629415393,
-0.309202224,
-0.2577784956,
-0.2081394643,
-0.4150634706,
-0.0370664783,
0.4384333491,
0.6656779051,
-0.2662627101,
-0.5338597894,
0.4140150249,
-0.3119808733,
-0.1129394919,
-0.2842817903,
0.7547941208,
0.2998345792,
-0.2418224961,
0.0392692722,
-0.0768381655,
0.1786945462,
-0.4747596383,
0.3028165102,
-0.2725872397,
0.3257113397,
-0.2608682513,
-1.0835766792,
0.644969523,
0.3118755221,
-0.2775784135,
-0.149606958,
0.5294861197,
-0.0146808317,
-0.4747954607,
0.5343005061,
0.5445994139,
-0.1894104183,
-0.0188898072,
-0.7589738369,
0.1036902443,
0.0638146326,
-0.5409645438,
-0.018097626,
0.2745341957,
-0.2176397741,
0.7656130791,
0.559356451,
0.2042831779,
-0.1095466539,
0.3412028253,
0.7871630192,
-0.6966491938,
-0.601993978,
-0.8676817417,
0.5781330466,
-0.3135326207,
-0.0597243533,
0.5745413899,
0.395421505,
0.2904373109,
-0.1105854139,
1.1726222038,
-0.1173010468,
0.8186863661,
0.0041910871,
0.4527190328,
-0.5273367167,
0.1485647261,
0.0039703571,
-0.815652132,
-0.4820169508,
0.2478165627,
-0.6261360049,
-0.0232955404,
0.5343950987,
0.5575295091,
-0.0615119934,
0.2184448987,
0.0910783783,
0.2769803107,
0.591970861,
0.340959698,
0.804346621,
-0.2174566537,
0.8352811933,
-0.2709104717,
-0.1768432558,
-0.4569436312,
-0.7020038366,
-1.0776335001,
-0.3924836814,
-0.0316787511,
-0.6123757362,
0.1372929513,
0.8876643181,
0.436031878,
-1.0830183029,
0.0158796906,
0.0819999054,
0.2304118723,
-0.2878110111,
-0.3305459023,
0.5875540376,
-0.3323117197,
-0.5823590159,
-0.0279373936,
0.4527102709,
-0.0276770648,
-0.1791960001,
0.222815007,
-0.047256127,
0.4508455396,
0.6247767806,
0.1465585083,
-0.7772397399,
-0.2815152705,
0.0805342495,
-0.3289651573,
0.0539668649,
0.6910336614,
-0.7340041399,
0.3798912466,
0.5834362507,
0.503441453,
0.3167929649,
0.2834188342,
0.5273854733,
-0.6635313034,
0.079845123,
0.6125850677,
0.3356177509,
0.4774540365,
-0.0786956921,
0.3959188163,
0.1093019396,
-0.0355325937,
-0.8933074474,
0.1167993844,
-1.4006079435,
-0.1847056001,
1.0251106024,
-0.0849840194,
-0.3962955773,
-0.2529190481,
-0.0046993475,
0.3693723083,
-0.6321263909,
0.946875155,
0.3846630454,
0.3598473966,
-0.2397776246,
-0.2213656157,
0.1283783019,
0.3789804578,
-0.6617054939,
0.0336653739,
0.0998312309,
0.0421313085,
-0.0265885461,
0.3213743567,
0.028397439,
0.2206424922,
-0.5678470731,
0.0090337517,
0.0518952198,
-0.5067611933,
-0.2341694683,
0.309355855,
-0.3020243347,
-0.4759778678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00284v1
|
A Likelihood Ratio Test of Genetic Relationship among Languages
| 2024-03-30T08:35:08 | 2024-03-30T08:35:08 |
V. S. D. S. Mahesh Akavarapu, Arnab Bhattacharya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Lexical resemblances among a group of languages indicate that the languages
could be genetically related, i.e., they could have descended from a common
ancestral language. However, such resemblances can arise by chance and, hence,
need not always imply an underlying genetic relationship. Many tests of
significance based on permutation of wordlists and word similarity measures
appeared in the past to determine the statistical significance of such
relationships. We demonstrate that although existing tests may work well for
bilateral comparisons, i.e., on pairs of languages, they are either infeasible
by design or are prone to yield false positives when applied to groups of
languages or language families. To this end, inspired by molecular
phylogenetics, we propose a likelihood ratio test to determine if given
languages are related based on the proportion of invariant character sites in
the aligned wordlists applied during tree inference. Further, we evaluate some
language families and show that the proposed test solves the problem of false
positives. Finally, we demonstrate that the test supports the existence of
macro language families such as Nostratic and Macro-Mayan.
|
[
-0.4099929035,
-0.6836138964,
0.5102086067,
0.2057557553,
0.0726151913,
0.0856827796,
-0.0553522669,
-0.3935062885,
0.6106051207,
0.1321465969,
-0.5039635301,
-0.1227219105,
-0.3553942144,
0.6015692949,
-0.4590703547,
0.4166475832,
0.0468731076,
0.0594520494,
-0.0509485193,
-0.7642482519,
0.1396447867,
-0.7062100172,
-0.6683543921,
-0.0331899971,
0.6496335268,
0.0992185995,
1.0019415617,
0.7089115977,
0.659214437,
0.2289686948,
-0.1381019503,
-0.3157090545,
-0.2289842963,
0.1362671703,
-0.2089489698,
-0.5457255244,
-0.2069577277,
-0.0433376841,
0.624129355,
1.179935813,
0.2826087177,
0.179216072,
0.0763809979,
0.7901012897,
-0.4840188622,
-0.1726001203,
-0.7928618193,
0.1559085995,
-0.5228262544,
-0.3554786146,
-0.0752637163,
-0.713019371,
0.0233592894,
-0.3589563072,
0.5318635702,
0.1504282504,
0.8433758616,
-0.014754069,
-0.4647887647,
-0.139737606,
-0.545229733,
0.5549247265,
-0.6797735095,
0.5641474128,
0.5259667635,
-0.0094913291,
-0.5825439095,
-0.1834350526,
-0.8079610467,
-0.7933308482,
-0.1060587242,
0.0466473326,
-0.2565375865,
-0.0783513188,
0.5549889207,
0.8463941813,
-1.1271790266,
-0.3134669065,
0.020455379,
-0.2276996374,
0.2788666189,
-0.2300546467,
1.031572938,
0.2145009339,
-0.1761958748,
-0.2192614377,
-1.0069773197,
-0.0425693244,
0.6653351188,
0.2630251646,
-0.1099891812,
0.9850506783,
0.1560011655,
0.7935840487,
-0.1812182963,
-0.2028019875,
0.1807431579,
-0.6102085114,
0.2040529549,
0.3037320673,
0.6930630207,
0.3005383909,
0.6350672841,
-0.1966532916,
0.139323175,
0.4737844765,
-0.3057560623,
-0.3859565258,
-0.0642127991,
-0.2938009501,
-0.5399084091,
-0.3095769584,
0.129294619,
-0.7187256813,
0.0698169172,
0.0279091131,
0.4302811921,
-0.6404277086,
-0.4037088752,
-0.066567786,
-0.431735158,
0.4008029997,
-0.6000818014,
-0.9741251469,
0.3109951615,
0.704010725,
0.9049079418,
-0.1459209025,
-0.4152585268,
-0.4003387988,
0.0004896206,
-0.376752764,
0.4759093821,
-0.8317646384,
-0.4348891675,
-0.0893694088,
-0.0065448279,
-0.1902323663,
-0.6223806143,
0.006064679,
-0.2183761001,
0.2832016051,
-0.4578504562,
-0.5578997731,
-0.2746974826,
0.1809305698,
-0.7275694013,
0.8952091336,
0.5598396659,
-1.1135962009,
0.5354360938,
0.1241008043,
-0.6936520338,
-0.0344481766,
-0.643918395,
-0.4980813265,
0.1130809486,
-0.2098577172,
-0.0955036208,
-0.2832177281,
-0.0787592009,
-0.9239985943,
-0.1679822206,
0.3175394237,
-0.3306089044,
1.1762788296,
0.1278368235,
-0.6993040442,
-0.2831432521,
-0.6202780008,
-0.0937196538,
0.0463464782,
-0.2522169948,
-0.6352291107,
0.1935040504,
-0.4711345434,
-0.0810237601,
-0.0925139561,
-0.5577327609,
0.5164508224,
-0.3708244264,
-0.0657188073,
0.3513463438,
0.1671426594,
0.2813488543,
-0.5538346767,
0.6052027941,
-0.2896903455,
-0.0903153718,
0.27237463,
-0.8775663376,
-0.8444316983,
0.0813059211,
0.475934267,
0.6147385836,
-0.6583184004,
0.7328974009,
-0.5042383671,
-0.2759402096,
-0.1717355549,
0.1580000669,
0.4204840064,
0.3537355661,
-0.1037618443,
-0.9091565013,
-0.4486036897,
-0.9424299598,
-0.3007787168,
-0.5979495645,
-0.1248230115,
0.1990984678,
0.2053890377,
-0.0878571719,
0.8757863045,
-0.1208700836,
0.1562930346,
-0.1797388941,
-0.0213823691,
0.2152979672,
0.1124384776,
1.2175490856,
-0.4577293396,
-0.53742975,
0.4878279269,
-0.6723155379,
-0.1667429954,
0.3624329567,
-0.0138725089,
0.3537786901,
0.6085929275,
-0.0088247135,
0.538769424,
0.9673420191,
-0.6921981573,
0.3356381953,
-0.005287895,
0.312155515,
-1.0123685598,
0.2386797816,
-0.1164021045,
0.0250364989,
-0.3187664151,
0.1199724376,
-0.1264567375,
0.0178789608,
-0.1228078008,
0.4916597009,
-0.1188563183,
-0.3339383304,
-0.0475706607,
-0.2874101698,
-0.5140593648,
0.157960251,
0.0334750041,
0.9779623747,
0.4897312224,
-0.6044490933,
0.144937396,
-0.0612339713,
-0.2397838384,
0.4325378835,
-0.4429154098,
-0.1919499934,
0.1256070137,
-0.0090944562,
-0.9473691583,
-0.0489826091,
0.1532002836,
-0.5891114473,
-0.0266538877,
-0.1690808088,
-0.3792508245,
-0.2193101346,
-0.3619435728,
0.6659240723,
0.5405503511,
-0.436242342,
0.3394248188,
0.1654036641,
-0.2459288687,
-0.416175127,
-0.6811206341,
-0.1879615188,
-0.5815908313,
-0.7425166368,
0.0388133414,
-0.059231285,
-0.6094179749,
0.0543203764,
-0.2278602421,
-0.1337128431,
0.1220668107,
0.1004457325,
0.3245469332,
-0.7649127841,
-0.0222384278,
0.0286523085,
0.1041851118,
-0.1088267937,
-0.4811025262,
0.3620766401,
-0.0331899375,
-0.1542846859,
0.1054194793,
0.2169685066,
0.841113925,
-0.0398429409,
0.8062489629,
0.1991096884,
-0.2739670277,
0.3523442745,
-0.6255089045,
-0.300155282,
-0.3789931536,
0.0992045105,
-0.625754118,
-0.7970718145,
0.5141544938,
-0.0667976812,
-0.241147235,
0.6473861337,
0.4096051753,
-0.0470452495,
0.4491795599,
0.6941019893,
-0.6631563902,
0.2454664409,
0.2292576283,
0.3044979274,
-0.3914982677,
0.2671564817,
-0.8530827761,
-0.0425556898,
-1.1615407467,
-0.2355340868,
0.2899514735,
0.130817771,
-0.1875964701,
0.9254567027,
0.0821823627,
0.7092499733,
0.5294727683,
-0.2491970509,
0.4815564156,
0.327475667,
-0.5151559711,
0.0421993546,
-0.7140868902,
-0.4331705272,
1.0181888342,
-0.1728214622,
0.2321742177,
0.4786206186,
0.6260917783,
0.128630206,
0.1875617057,
-0.3936476111,
0.5337033868,
-0.525426805,
-0.561424315,
-0.3669669628,
-0.6798962951,
-1.207603693,
-0.0664664805,
-0.3202456832,
-0.8155583143,
0.3995994031,
0.056213446,
-0.1132015511,
0.300696224,
-0.5805989504,
0.7186954618,
-0.3640555739,
-0.1060028598,
-0.0012423585,
-0.6343736053,
0.4573682249,
-0.3420390785,
0.0751188099,
-0.1949599683,
0.2679301798,
0.6304293871,
-0.5225868225,
0.3564479947,
0.5883641243,
-0.0687979162,
0.211136058,
0.7716202736,
-0.0404687859,
-0.1144014671,
-0.398843497,
0.2912329733,
0.2133146822,
-0.4841097891,
-0.6984462738,
0.8982390165,
-0.4480827451,
-0.3241329491,
-0.5521110892,
-0.3094528615,
-0.1174491793,
0.3233494163,
0.2781885862,
0.184048146,
-0.3060690761,
0.0409371369,
0.3454045951,
-0.2031690776,
0.4672824144,
0.3863251507,
-0.4504778683,
-0.2450756878,
1.0674952269,
-0.2278323323,
0.5582135916,
0.396582216,
0.5452330709,
-0.1838522255,
-0.1901044697,
-0.0882594883,
0.2331107855,
-0.0093054324,
0.1558778584,
-0.1298028231,
-0.1450279951,
-0.4107109606,
-0.197560966,
0.0072362958,
-0.6451134086,
0.3642325699,
0.0678495988,
0.3584599495,
0.7738926411,
-0.0353562906,
-0.2013816237,
-0.6418374777,
0.4305222631,
0.607463479,
0.0862857401,
-0.0922543779,
-0.4490617216,
0.7448858023,
0.0424063429,
-0.2082131803,
-0.9806384444,
0.3513914049,
0.6109377742,
0.5028793812,
0.5480428934,
-0.3106264174,
0.513199091,
-0.5205423236,
0.5643739104,
0.2959388793,
-0.7776087523,
0.277253449,
-0.4844422042,
-0.1823112667,
0.6865416765,
0.7316007018,
-0.5714734793,
-0.7792838216,
-0.7834606767,
-0.5259212255,
0.2302892804,
0.8229615688,
-0.0755923837,
-0.2202789336,
0.2043953538,
0.1424609423,
-0.2652192116,
-0.6577070355,
-0.5331517458,
0.3295441866,
-0.1981204748,
-0.2272093743,
-0.1631147861,
0.1680441946,
-0.404518187,
0.2916561663,
0.0935150832,
0.1194694489,
0.1637280285,
0.1181331426,
-0.4402426779,
0.1983732134,
0.5124517679,
0.6976813674,
-0.2073536217,
0.6161822677,
0.2875635922,
-0.6502887011,
0.3976674676,
-0.1765894741,
-0.1891359538,
0.1984333396,
0.5981006026,
0.2016268969,
0.1537697911,
-0.3521807492,
0.4541953206,
-0.1046146825,
-0.1344392896,
-0.1043691486,
-0.0702191442,
0.3452955186,
-0.1342221797,
0.119070299,
-0.0056263283,
0.1185316071,
-1.2229776382,
0.5088829398,
0.4991747141,
-0.1793095469,
-0.1895216405,
0.3429416418,
0.1826996505,
-0.490563482,
0.6879477501,
-0.4383761287,
-0.838888824,
0.8823410273,
0.5359533429,
0.5055592656,
-0.5814371109,
0.0210543312,
0.6109849811,
0.4313160777,
0.0847155601,
0.231082052,
0.1586097032,
-0.6821959615,
-0.2787512541,
-0.8744125962,
-0.1345282942,
0.1381572783,
-0.3672651052,
0.3151403666,
0.022892978,
-0.1179001331,
0.1047933996,
-0.2889046967,
-0.0910485238,
-0.11600703,
0.2535198629,
0.6372672915,
-1.0438767672,
0.8730356097,
0.2622036934,
-0.234975487,
-0.7187508941,
0.4324600101,
0.0921773762,
-0.6287364364,
0.7555853128,
0.0722031519,
-0.0520831756,
-0.2017522603,
0.1192449108,
-1.0519226789,
0.7425940037,
0.82587111,
-0.8078758121,
0.3140387833,
0.2938432097,
0.6177241802,
0.007923075,
0.1371120811,
0.6773552299,
0.3348129094,
0.1078352258,
-1.1171716452,
0.1581715047,
-0.0773246139,
0.0979694054,
0.6960462928,
-0.1490583867,
0.5898860097,
-0.0761183575,
-0.2403499186,
0.3001474142,
0.6240270734,
0.3999921381,
0.2961778045,
0.6184364557,
0.6258743405,
0.470001936,
-0.0690175593,
1.2036658525,
-0.6954200864,
0.3461951911,
0.8284466863,
-0.2251160741,
0.7287759781,
0.6098377109,
-0.5747492909,
0.4432700276,
0.4648278356,
0.0884473249,
0.1825427562,
0.5437776446,
-0.6207267642,
-0.0435843393,
-0.1157999784,
-0.5346474051,
0.2477248609,
0.3826476336,
-0.4963510931,
-0.2926177084,
-0.5524766445,
-0.0473002978,
0.1067029536,
0.0039320076,
0.3436010778,
0.1674953699,
-0.6913906932,
0.3980272114,
-0.3528117537,
0.6061710715,
-0.670324862,
-0.2274285406,
-0.5335844159,
-0.0492416359,
-0.2710371614,
-0.649338007,
0.4823290706,
-0.1615662575,
0.0870075375,
0.3737386763,
0.4610489309,
-0.6109874845,
-0.7090716362,
0.4843159914,
0.5405859947,
0.2925709486,
0.1259372383,
-0.3593319356,
-0.2603189945,
0.1023722216,
0.0162822753,
0.1818711162,
0.1818676144,
-0.4605913758,
0.5250225067,
0.6773183346,
0.4180182815,
0.4434301853,
-0.0142794065,
0.2531551719,
-0.5546618104,
-0.0572258867,
-1.1480251551,
-0.4462769032,
0.1704695821,
-0.1541115195,
0.9791623354,
0.8436043262,
0.9442855716,
-0.2009200901,
0.6668390632,
-0.2935286164,
0.0650354475,
-0.4723955095,
0.6105889082,
-0.4806039929,
-0.2861846387,
-0.3772157729,
-1.43504107,
-0.5291184187,
0.6201468706,
-0.0826701447,
-0.0228618346,
1.3608304262,
0.8428350091,
-0.3950188756,
-0.1340756863,
0.4382935762,
-0.0359546654,
-0.1618842036,
0.5864783525,
0.589459002,
-0.2594268322,
0.5012559891,
-0.5261132121,
-0.3263030052,
0.0920403823,
-0.7921347618,
-0.8468262553,
-0.7329801917,
-0.3912977874,
-0.6172477007,
0.3628803492,
0.7690013051,
0.07795652,
-0.8874070644,
-0.5116183162,
-0.4813217521,
0.1811136007,
-0.2622177899,
-0.2061575204,
0.3154648542,
0.0527494289,
-0.4871405959,
0.3292223215,
0.3283392787,
0.5739412308,
0.0229335986,
0.0012181854,
-0.1169044822,
-0.0190703887,
0.3835284114,
0.7527867556,
-0.7704793811,
-0.418764919,
0.0169532876,
-0.2388903946,
-0.0720655248,
1.201841116,
-0.4945148528,
0.2600480914,
0.724875927,
0.397243917,
-0.1001742333,
-0.2793039382,
0.8905977607,
-0.5736922622,
0.2188165784,
-0.0245892294,
0.5757132769,
0.0605999827,
-0.1809342504,
0.8257725835,
0.4590562284,
-0.270159483,
-0.5366954207,
0.5450204015,
-1.2421524525,
0.0021100217,
1.3925100565,
-0.0941144899,
-0.3482348025,
-0.3532479107,
-0.0874152556,
0.1234522089,
0.102141276,
0.886908114,
0.4789443612,
0.135153085,
0.4063571393,
-0.0896245837,
0.3785425425,
0.7108323574,
-0.3809657991,
-0.148901552,
-0.0655615479,
0.5722466111,
0.3095819652,
0.4759781659,
-0.1569936424,
0.3446118534,
-0.000798471,
0.0230612345,
0.5577488542,
0.0676767379,
-0.3093154728,
-0.1565352529,
0.3750759065,
-0.1184586436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00282v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00282v1
|
Survey on Large Language Model-Enhanced Reinforcement Learning: Concept, Taxonomy, and Methods
| 2024-03-30T08:28:08 | 2024-03-30T08:28:08 |
Yuji Cao, Huan Zhao, Yuheng Cheng, Ting Shu, Guolong Liu, Gaoqi Liang, Junhua Zhao, Yun Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
With extensive pre-trained knowledge and high-level general capabilities,
large language models (LLMs) emerge as a promising avenue to augment
reinforcement learning (RL) in aspects such as multi-task learning, sample
efficiency, and task planning. In this survey, we provide a comprehensive
review of the existing literature in $\textit{LLM-enhanced RL}$ and summarize
its characteristics compared to conventional RL methods, aiming to clarify the
research scope and directions for future studies. Utilizing the classical
agent-environment interaction paradigm, we propose a structured taxonomy to
systematically categorize LLMs' functionalities in RL, including four roles:
information processor, reward designer, decision-maker, and generator.
Additionally, for each role, we summarize the methodologies, analyze the
specific RL challenges that are mitigated, and provide insights into future
directions. Lastly, potential applications, prospective opportunities and
challenges of the $\textit{LLM-enhanced RL}$ are discussed.
|
[
-0.3995414972,
-0.8956324458,
0.4948213398,
0.0906608552,
0.0644831061,
0.327878505,
-0.5249657631,
-0.5484162569,
0.1227810457,
0.6321892142,
-0.5073638558,
-0.1950306892,
-0.6298251748,
0.1496167481,
-0.1658197492,
1.0219413042,
-0.0138771376,
0.008873513,
-0.1906562746,
0.1211830601,
-0.3067730665,
-0.7411293983,
-0.9437137842,
-0.6000846028,
0.8526309729,
0.2535265982,
0.2584352493,
0.2957892418,
0.4323638678,
0.4197123647,
-0.2439094186,
0.3523306847,
-0.3917386234,
0.4421409667,
-0.1450434625,
-0.1727463305,
-0.6025878191,
-0.0735014603,
0.9188227057,
0.4271087646,
-0.236636281,
0.0377414301,
0.1748007685,
0.4441789985,
-0.7762004733,
0.4208930433,
-0.4042608142,
0.2200280577,
-0.0370518453,
-0.362944901,
-0.4457316399,
-0.0620437376,
0.1410138011,
-0.5585879683,
-0.4090825915,
-0.0596627519,
0.35362643,
0.1837045252,
-0.6514220834,
-0.3307926655,
-0.9653737545,
0.8963899612,
-0.4958005548,
0.4038242698,
0.1321748644,
0.2768978477,
-0.2189560384,
-0.6885203123,
-0.2667407393,
-0.582072258,
0.0148079721,
0.2386952341,
0.0144131649,
0.2941548824,
0.3280068338,
0.2380349338,
-0.2634799778,
0.5101025105,
-0.1672520936,
-0.1676000357,
0.7461813688,
0.3249003589,
0.0734126419,
0.0337247923,
-0.4023036361,
-0.2761504054,
-0.7342982888,
0.2501406074,
0.3146591783,
0.2805805504,
0.1160853431,
0.4365286231,
-0.3210864365,
0.7064281702,
-0.2427805066,
-0.1258934289,
0.2355397642,
-0.2918254137,
-0.1489156932,
-0.244377479,
0.5549897552,
-0.0238177422,
0.0246641431,
-0.0296219289,
-0.6437394023,
-0.4423708618,
0.1450822055,
-0.7702439427,
0.128442362,
0.079021439,
-0.3829441667,
-0.2357329279,
0.0392243788,
-0.6092009544,
-0.4802313149,
-0.405041784,
0.304651618,
-0.1375704408,
-0.7543725967,
-0.0277213678,
-0.0955421031,
0.4168644547,
0.3207817376,
-0.7373215556,
0.358173728,
0.8237279058,
0.5324916244,
-0.4414708018,
-0.3880775869,
-0.7384384274,
0.105670996,
-0.1376875192,
0.7955242395,
-0.7101444006,
-0.4327928126,
0.4369504154,
-0.1330701411,
0.0653764009,
-0.520739615,
0.5034441948,
-0.7458649874,
0.0307369642,
-0.1174144,
-0.425814271,
-0.2294446379,
0.6660142541,
-0.6594982147,
0.8335959911,
-0.149663642,
-0.4727688134,
0.2380245924,
-0.7601004243,
-0.4636161029,
0.2729326487,
-0.1764604747,
-0.3739275634,
0.0296288077,
0.116132617,
0.68285501,
-0.1081146672,
0.4014657736,
-0.1277754754,
-0.1862554252,
0.5854482651,
-0.378293395,
0.4202110469,
0.3408358991,
-0.061088074,
0.6741530895,
-0.4671224654,
-0.0002059304,
0.1421356648,
-0.6960641146,
-0.3257869482,
0.0809528902,
0.1945408881,
0.4396726191,
0.5507789254,
-0.381107837,
0.1850396991,
-0.273445338,
0.3659752607,
0.8430409431,
0.0991723537,
0.3719144464,
-0.2883702517,
0.7672464848,
-0.1626698375,
0.2744650245,
-0.0828233287,
-0.0193197429,
-0.5313776731,
-0.3432811499,
0.2331441641,
0.4624020755,
-0.8336594105,
0.3983017206,
-0.1127272919,
-0.320995003,
-0.1122197509,
0.1887627691,
0.5074276924,
-0.0744946972,
0.2271963209,
-0.2643624544,
-0.5674187541,
-0.6304948926,
-0.1529167295,
-0.0349556804,
0.2223337591,
0.5698602796,
0.5289601684,
-0.3191471696,
0.6903051734,
-0.4092757702,
-0.0659156367,
-0.7473556995,
-0.1606929004,
-0.0200254135,
0.2636675835,
0.1673285961,
-0.7898309827,
-0.35748142,
-0.01073125,
-0.4087176919,
0.0817087367,
-0.0500227474,
0.2085812092,
0.1996485293,
0.6905394793,
-0.5607113838,
-0.027101161,
0.4699772596,
-0.2618568242,
0.6791850328,
-0.4719687402,
0.0621408746,
-0.8664175272,
0.017386917,
0.1216878146,
-0.0667539462,
-0.7802348137,
0.3837639391,
0.0162569862,
0.1386196613,
-0.3129811287,
0.6665701866,
-0.5174248815,
-0.4747225046,
-0.6153939962,
0.2579569221,
-0.4537000358,
0.4315053225,
0.4629493058,
0.6502074003,
0.4763607681,
-0.802511692,
0.4290637374,
0.1027419344,
-0.2518363595,
0.3467774093,
-0.5818542242,
-0.1184509918,
-0.0226024855,
0.3904098868,
-0.7497758269,
-0.1281294525,
0.0937675536,
-0.3908228278,
0.4072154164,
0.2751250863,
-0.6666222811,
-0.2722934484,
-0.2755296528,
0.3460217416,
0.5065059066,
-0.4879757464,
0.544230938,
0.4796048403,
-0.3137411475,
-0.6932737827,
-0.2565467358,
0.0480594374,
-0.4230331779,
-0.0309368111,
0.2480285317,
-0.0129510369,
-0.3869622052,
-0.2185565829,
0.1481591761,
0.0818621814,
0.3742722571,
0.0014907639,
0.2867197692,
0.0325540416,
0.3603459597,
-0.2953111827,
-0.0137852058,
0.1993798018,
-0.1420356333,
0.6283877492,
-0.0660989881,
-0.2373538166,
0.1577659547,
0.0911235735,
0.2027385831,
-0.765752852,
0.568307519,
0.6532979012,
-0.0952842832,
-0.3520341814,
-0.3801387548,
-0.3613969982,
-0.4790506363,
0.8295964599,
-0.2295117378,
-1.2809832096,
0.3600299656,
-0.4542503059,
0.2563410401,
0.3259508312,
0.6913247108,
0.1992192715,
0.9756049514,
0.6471508145,
-0.1066186503,
0.7943253517,
-0.2558748722,
0.0553893521,
-1.0950605869,
-0.3898122311,
-0.4076001942,
-0.0530615821,
-0.5859398246,
-0.3705005348,
0.3544269204,
-0.2417957485,
-0.4765469134,
0.0495874174,
-0.2071646899,
0.0503450669,
0.263936758,
-0.0550508611,
0.2845037878,
-0.100481987,
-0.0450133532,
0.427970618,
-0.7011709213,
-0.2118458748,
1.1096799374,
0.549499929,
0.7391266823,
0.298197031,
0.6495830417,
0.2167193294,
0.1319789439,
-0.8198800087,
0.7241651416,
0.3191559315,
-0.5908361673,
-0.650968492,
-0.4559669793,
-1.1130646467,
0.4479882717,
-0.5044199228,
-0.5325784683,
-0.3602896929,
0.0977709517,
-0.1895286143,
0.2476509959,
-0.295635283,
0.6601294875,
-0.6709117293,
-0.5468996167,
-0.6444715858,
-0.4365232885,
0.5285589099,
-0.0550075248,
0.3218589127,
0.2535428405,
-0.3804357946,
0.6581888199,
0.0302900523,
0.7152296305,
-0.3192477822,
-0.3730955422,
0.1304368675,
-0.2327107489,
0.8247188926,
-0.1233231053,
0.144649744,
-0.3025482893,
-0.1437302977,
-0.1669174433,
-0.3632596433,
0.6913155913,
-0.7324620485,
-0.5099600554,
-0.5215811729,
-0.6184162498,
-0.5973445177,
-0.021942256,
-0.2869482934,
0.3534811139,
-0.3370807469,
0.2280180752,
0.8866795897,
-0.5075293779,
0.4518169761,
0.7183114886,
-0.459502697,
-0.3113339841,
0.9718475342,
-0.0943244323,
0.411983639,
0.5670914054,
0.0860578492,
-0.5298829675,
-0.8113189936,
0.1161389947,
0.0676279068,
-0.5612440109,
0.1109179109,
-0.6253586411,
-0.3551597595,
-0.3966280222,
0.1648184359,
-0.1804477423,
-0.1629710197,
-0.1005992666,
-0.2452713549,
0.3480281532,
0.9423002005,
-0.0408702083,
0.3923487961,
-0.637627542,
0.1064083949,
0.362767458,
0.4243292212,
0.3183346689,
-0.3906015456,
-0.4493659139,
-0.2680685222,
-0.1611133963,
-0.4412976205,
0.4360601902,
0.0495323613,
0.9926386476,
0.2901155949,
-0.036035005,
0.3130207658,
-0.4093918204,
0.7086763382,
0.2103744596,
-0.527356863,
0.3200520873,
-0.3883024454,
0.1779147834,
0.1321324706,
0.2067051828,
-0.6403237581,
-0.2745004296,
-0.557411015,
-1.0204356909,
0.5761776567,
-0.2100001127,
0.0949494019,
0.068566367,
0.0947962925,
-0.0299568009,
0.323995769,
-0.9010102749,
-0.1898242682,
0.1462156922,
0.0852630511,
-0.5186228156,
-0.3706081808,
0.1107972637,
-0.2047763467,
0.7950633764,
-0.1165152714,
0.1933138072,
-0.0969560817,
-0.2273429632,
0.0873825103,
0.7778155804,
0.7374806404,
0.4838506579,
-0.0497173555,
0.0100938575,
0.3183482885,
-0.2449369878,
0.1442560703,
0.0885243639,
0.0099115185,
-0.5657821894,
0.4293083847,
0.8736201525,
0.28461954,
-1.0251051188,
0.2546699643,
0.0463866256,
-0.2222320884,
-0.6344519258,
0.2078869939,
0.0070671993,
0.5885666609,
0.426970005,
-0.3837207556,
0.1820111871,
-0.6458669901,
0.1437334716,
0.8469701409,
-0.3881504536,
-0.0749545619,
0.181088537,
0.4111505151,
-0.1253739148,
0.4001481831,
-0.2379713506,
-0.5638552904,
0.5932969451,
0.5761713386,
0.7988120317,
-0.176276356,
0.1072053015,
0.3061785996,
0.2641245723,
-0.087002866,
0.1759436727,
-0.184536919,
-0.7577550411,
-0.7061690092,
-0.5344577432,
-0.4918713868,
0.4308651686,
-0.4714087844,
-0.0458224379,
-0.4013381004,
-0.0320152082,
-0.3500182927,
0.2551778853,
-0.5537460446,
-0.0728988573,
0.3033621311,
0.8500369191,
-0.634927392,
0.9079874158,
1.0090140104,
-0.3134424686,
-0.7495129108,
-0.0561262853,
-0.1888967007,
-0.5940541029,
0.8562884331,
-0.127172336,
-0.1846719831,
0.1296001673,
-0.3358649909,
-0.7594738007,
1.183506012,
-0.137338683,
-0.4357655644,
-0.0837139562,
-0.0102531407,
0.4773721993,
-0.5465630889,
0.4567143023,
0.5936685801,
0.5800909996,
-0.0097136516,
-0.8699707985,
-0.1229088679,
-0.1790013611,
0.1606289297,
0.2032218874,
-0.6748476028,
0.6958819628,
0.0574572608,
0.0812690631,
0.0485395007,
0.7025386691,
0.3360332251,
0.1064181551,
0.5619315505,
0.2627117932,
0.549964726,
0.1228541508,
1.0178442001,
-0.2777066529,
0.2830307782,
0.9707605243,
-0.4407185912,
0.8255583048,
0.3672279418,
-0.1752845645,
0.3362477422,
0.6659108996,
0.0512606911,
0.4915062487,
0.4357586801,
-0.3950478137,
-0.5076249242,
-0.2770971656,
-0.2154038996,
0.4365951419,
0.6095177531,
-0.1758499295,
-0.2333674431,
0.2680942118,
-0.3707108498,
0.2194753736,
-0.8519527316,
0.9802957773,
0.0502331145,
-0.6588036418,
0.0738504156,
0.1320403516,
1.026771307,
-0.7882555127,
-0.0843246728,
0.0459013209,
0.2257243991,
-0.1075514555,
-0.8861062527,
-0.099132672,
-0.0657009259,
0.1294813901,
-0.4119488895,
0.9288626313,
-0.4750328958,
-0.0331215113,
0.4420987666,
0.7205926776,
-0.0634392276,
0.1676271856,
-0.7657942176,
0.0675357208,
-0.3154439032,
-0.3717653751,
0.6361382604,
0.153669849,
-0.0097963018,
0.9191162586,
0.3148965836,
0.2808515429,
-0.0698182732,
0.0187658537,
0.7709896564,
-0.652505517,
-0.4851729274,
-0.6773733497,
0.4325563908,
-0.2013608068,
-0.1393397003,
0.8274347782,
0.5317396522,
0.9953303933,
-0.1328804046,
0.9723312259,
0.0159386862,
0.49948138,
-0.6230127811,
0.297849685,
-0.5641388297,
0.1888847053,
-0.1988731325,
-0.7700989246,
0.0344694443,
0.4040478468,
-0.439766854,
0.3092101514,
0.5718788505,
0.6353555918,
0.0917688385,
-0.2895803154,
0.3819307387,
-0.0635585636,
0.3577250242,
0.5883334279,
1.3207774162,
0.2787791491,
0.3754043281,
0.1407669038,
-0.0646777079,
-0.4459614754,
-0.6834153533,
-0.9176015258,
-0.6725998521,
-0.1902340204,
-0.0725739524,
0.0957993045,
1.3068660498,
0.4942086041,
-0.5020385981,
-0.485404253,
-0.0436889939,
0.2316361517,
-0.3697850108,
-0.1387510598,
0.1662445217,
-0.492292732,
-0.6759882569,
0.4131496847,
0.1735457331,
-0.2213291079,
-0.5709771514,
-0.583706975,
-0.1298491061,
-0.0395067595,
0.8774165511,
0.5621618629,
-0.645842135,
-0.1621701717,
-0.1285985559,
-0.1651891917,
-0.3067954183,
0.9836648703,
-0.608279705,
0.0774596259,
0.3935084939,
0.8317586184,
0.4000751078,
-0.2390893698,
0.4773283005,
-0.6517139673,
0.0427988321,
0.2767155468,
0.2723546922,
0.1021113694,
-0.1736627817,
0.3077901006,
-0.1084285155,
-0.5969504118,
-0.7184047103,
0.5557810664,
-0.9278697968,
-0.5448747277,
1.4948415756,
-0.0142314564,
-0.0272518359,
-0.0372454524,
-0.113714911,
0.2547615469,
-0.3845109642,
0.4177720845,
0.5132204294,
-0.1547690332,
-0.5105493665,
-0.8234054446,
0.6543216109,
0.1171995178,
-1.0376223326,
0.1726588309,
0.8024285436,
0.050639078,
-0.1294731349,
0.4844759405,
0.0177235082,
0.2840071917,
-0.4651729763,
0.284768343,
-0.3839322031,
-0.3427601457,
-0.6559098959,
0.1912762225,
0.7860219479,
0.1593363434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00267v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00267v2
|
Secret Keepers: The Impact of LLMs on Linguistic Markers of Personal Traits
| 2024-03-30T06:49:17 | 2024-04-03T17:29:12 |
Zhivar Sourati, Meltem Ozcan, Colin McDaniel, Alireza Ziabari, Nuan Wen, Ala Tak, Fred Morstatter, Morteza Dehghani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prior research has established associations between individuals' language
usage and their personal traits; our linguistic patterns reveal information
about our personalities, emotional states, and beliefs. However, with the
increasing adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs) as writing assistants in
everyday writing, a critical question emerges: are authors' linguistic patterns
still predictive of their personal traits when LLMs are involved in the writing
process? We investigate the impact of LLMs on the linguistic markers of
demographic and psychological traits, specifically examining three LLMs -
GPT3.5, Llama 2, and Gemini - across six different traits: gender, age,
political affiliation, personality, empathy, and morality. Our findings
indicate that although the use of LLMs slightly reduces the predictive power of
linguistic patterns over authors' personal traits, the significant changes are
infrequent, and the use of LLMs does not fully diminish the predictive power of
authors' linguistic patterns over their personal traits. We also note that some
theoretically established lexical-based linguistic markers lose their
reliability as predictors when LLMs are used in the writing process. Our
findings have important implications for the study of linguistic markers of
personal traits in the age of LLMs.
|
[
-0.1456989348,
-0.3667762876,
0.825874567,
0.0857307613,
0.0459846072,
0.0264333598,
-0.3109582663,
-0.8250940442,
0.3601476848,
0.7509834766,
-0.6774725318,
-0.5693086982,
-0.9179688692,
0.5023350716,
-0.1290212125,
0.9975565076,
0.0158735607,
0.2612090111,
-0.0414707772,
-0.0241354611,
-0.1944600344,
-0.9301658869,
-0.409170419,
-0.2368986607,
0.7890118361,
0.1917289048,
0.7532996535,
0.9951176643,
0.6317854524,
0.218165502,
-0.3041730225,
-0.020781558,
-0.4828174412,
0.4339654744,
0.0066027334,
-1.0119662285,
-0.3508585393,
0.3769674003,
0.4319568872,
0.6845085025,
0.1177501455,
0.266944468,
-0.126953885,
0.8401734829,
-0.6047902107,
0.2770519853,
-0.4802092314,
0.0384689942,
-0.4945087135,
-0.1352276057,
-0.2122686058,
-0.5039438009,
-0.0315312147,
-0.4607743919,
0.2313923985,
-0.0303224567,
0.6535394788,
0.1576203853,
-0.4209708571,
-0.5608009696,
-0.6842346191,
0.752198875,
-0.7696787715,
0.0591787621,
0.7481576204,
-0.0678052679,
-0.2224394232,
-0.1429740936,
-0.5152662992,
-0.3238985837,
-0.265815258,
-0.1158055514,
0.1342167407,
-0.0722346306,
0.4895450473,
0.2514603734,
-0.1508310586,
0.2757010162,
-0.3635922372,
-0.2308306843,
0.5494644642,
0.4202307761,
0.4132679403,
0.0484259799,
0.0178785175,
0.2278700769,
-1.1571779251,
0.0486673191,
0.7560443878,
0.3931049705,
0.0399371497,
0.6500256062,
-0.0728764832,
0.4364813566,
-0.1182091385,
-0.4006647468,
0.1122336015,
-0.1797362417,
0.3658183813,
-0.1205872744,
0.792247355,
0.3979497552,
0.8600959182,
-0.152945593,
0.0799666792,
0.1966679692,
-0.3276106715,
-0.5418841839,
-0.1992971152,
-0.2415304929,
-0.5014858842,
-0.2910240591,
0.1147397235,
-0.5020147562,
-0.9103527069,
-0.1111512855,
-0.0938398466,
-0.2389244139,
-0.1490298063,
-0.037686158,
-0.305380255,
0.2713055909,
0.3509591818,
-1.1906425953,
0.4455013573,
0.7720162868,
0.6959596276,
-0.2681150436,
-0.4522414505,
-0.4217267036,
0.2191668153,
-0.4215832055,
0.4943371713,
-0.9951905608,
-0.5546819568,
0.205345422,
-0.047099404,
-0.0916282162,
-0.4492020905,
0.4962706864,
-0.2512319386,
0.2549163103,
-0.6942735314,
-0.597949028,
0.2595093846,
-0.2740429342,
-0.6209358573,
0.83062011,
-0.0779657215,
-0.4150387645,
0.4762816131,
-0.2196298093,
-0.3308066726,
-0.0354308076,
-0.1653121561,
-0.4513323903,
0.4165464044,
-0.1366380453,
0.737505734,
-0.1156442314,
0.0334884711,
-0.3324158192,
-0.5733223557,
0.9158456922,
-0.1177226752,
0.483679831,
-0.1646060646,
-0.2036287785,
-0.3340319693,
-0.6017894745,
-0.2354749143,
-0.0363186561,
-0.5817869306,
-0.1858365834,
0.1232662499,
-0.3524516225,
0.1604531854,
0.38169384,
-0.7004269958,
0.3772732615,
0.0928546339,
0.2297824919,
0.9656323791,
0.0757450834,
0.3609342575,
-0.4929639995,
0.7146621346,
-0.3441947699,
0.1440968513,
-0.1160518005,
-0.86186409,
-0.6604534984,
-0.3624820113,
0.0617791042,
0.4368249476,
-0.0518470928,
0.7017533779,
-0.1787582785,
-0.5393116474,
-0.4318159819,
0.5656648278,
0.753408432,
-0.171024248,
0.0823769048,
0.091572836,
-0.3965856731,
-0.7743965983,
-0.9784222841,
-0.4210919142,
0.005386279,
0.1243524402,
0.4151065946,
-0.1175223738,
0.8001844883,
-0.6368373036,
-0.5173412561,
-0.439599961,
-0.0683235601,
0.2211816758,
0.1632896513,
0.5877029896,
-0.4123049676,
-0.4943857491,
-0.2379746139,
-0.3706633449,
-0.5868275166,
0.1097294986,
-0.0543146655,
0.1278773397,
0.5797362328,
-0.6138237715,
0.4634975195,
0.8783814907,
-0.7565580606,
0.7619214654,
0.2098006904,
-0.2018880695,
-0.698753953,
-0.1929867864,
-0.0544805676,
0.0953669772,
-0.798355937,
-0.1721000075,
0.0546486266,
0.1578758806,
-0.0878893062,
0.7067546844,
-0.7137156725,
0.1343445033,
-0.0640818253,
-0.1635942906,
-0.0140600922,
0.2883129418,
0.0472688004,
0.8001079559,
0.4502537549,
-0.4060502946,
-0.1904024929,
0.2303041518,
-0.3489760756,
0.2877224982,
-0.2030458301,
0.3678052425,
-0.1543602049,
0.0589249618,
-0.7318214178,
-0.1131572276,
0.1675187051,
-0.4145536125,
0.3941098452,
0.0841607451,
-0.530679822,
0.0050810855,
-0.477388382,
-0.318023622,
0.4697184861,
-0.0809151679,
0.7411928773,
0.2704916,
-0.4097558856,
-0.363368392,
-0.9537919164,
0.2135638297,
-0.1542180479,
-0.2983309329,
0.12386401,
-0.4128169715,
-0.5045881867,
-0.1148368344,
-0.0982376263,
0.0801007748,
0.1645573974,
0.5522745848,
0.2540880442,
-0.0430179685,
0.2645715773,
-0.1254217327,
-0.1730288565,
0.1142724976,
0.2842091024,
0.4573928118,
-0.3757786453,
0.0545877777,
-0.4338679314,
0.322445035,
0.6534713507,
-0.3141332269,
1.2434407473,
0.3962920606,
-0.0043985345,
-0.1180276424,
-0.9111121297,
-0.1109313816,
-0.4639959931,
0.1916068345,
-0.424017489,
-0.9086232781,
0.8138130307,
0.1704684049,
-0.341904819,
0.3921757936,
0.447055757,
-0.3018453717,
0.7126305699,
0.8988651633,
-0.2050921768,
0.7427819371,
-0.0510527715,
0.209015131,
-1.0178833008,
-0.0767228752,
-0.4927867055,
-0.4420599937,
-0.8534124494,
-0.16458942,
0.2312143743,
0.0244933814,
-0.0087421788,
0.0566340052,
-0.3060556352,
0.6830884814,
0.4641501009,
0.0968551487,
0.4852060676,
-0.3181804419,
0.3903289735,
-0.343672365,
-0.2309558839,
-0.905223608,
1.2423301935,
0.44981125,
0.8747015595,
0.1918367296,
0.6466292143,
0.3695333004,
0.4345552921,
-0.3750151396,
0.8375450969,
-0.3507514894,
-0.5673683882,
-0.3655947745,
-0.4007389247,
-0.5689894557,
-0.1342868209,
-0.1932621598,
-1.0130882263,
0.463780731,
-0.0083147911,
-0.1347546279,
0.2317646891,
-0.7381067276,
0.4832845628,
-0.2855704129,
-0.1627334803,
0.2510654628,
-0.6346735954,
0.1190866604,
-0.2031400949,
0.0100368187,
-0.8182150126,
-0.585819304,
0.9310119152,
-0.3390922844,
1.2754240036,
-0.0405754074,
-0.1555076987,
-0.0810428634,
0.3388059139,
0.7437328696,
-0.1433259249,
-0.4889832735,
0.5045067072,
0.0111724045,
-0.0602084734,
-0.6072705984,
0.819000721,
-1.037327528,
-0.7627150416,
-0.5990684032,
-0.4869043231,
-0.1268080026,
0.0915057436,
0.2568310499,
0.2194884419,
-0.0843754709,
-0.0085991127,
0.3578145504,
-0.0231740288,
0.4265950918,
0.797772646,
-0.0025106578,
-0.2952881455,
0.5732326508,
0.2042490542,
0.523532331,
0.3396435678,
0.6748552322,
0.061880514,
-0.5338979959,
0.0439765193,
0.7510923743,
-0.7874393463,
0.0443930738,
-0.6705617309,
-0.0540759861,
-0.3777862191,
-0.2910607457,
0.0043248874,
-0.5316052437,
-0.5062453151,
-0.105725728,
0.6797872782,
1.0331308842,
0.1637237668,
0.4681365788,
-0.530775547,
0.1551802754,
0.1445496976,
0.1894376576,
-0.4693943262,
-0.4221126139,
-0.1136710495,
-0.3141619861,
-0.0178454146,
-1.2135976553,
0.2998153269,
0.4918635488,
0.4502412677,
0.5969381928,
-0.3775287867,
0.3066828847,
-0.2760737538,
0.9411204457,
-0.0637491047,
-1.0926868916,
0.2485390007,
-0.5696566105,
0.4247739017,
0.6728901863,
0.1760569364,
-0.9121600389,
-0.9039404988,
-0.2950150669,
-0.4075380266,
0.5079749227,
0.244293794,
0.2481448501,
-0.0865082443,
0.6204406619,
0.3895397484,
0.3682461381,
-0.8349378109,
-0.3413870633,
0.2905918658,
-0.0590378605,
-0.1987989247,
-0.6592767835,
0.1221164912,
-0.2892928421,
0.3920673132,
-0.1916988343,
0.1459055692,
-0.0941771567,
0.2090962529,
-0.1517015845,
0.279715389,
0.5517137051,
0.576462388,
-0.0688851699,
0.1756422818,
0.2401905507,
-0.7552860975,
0.0783924982,
-0.2281987667,
-0.3134458661,
-0.0061903843,
0.7363806963,
0.5613759756,
0.1645734459,
-0.3842563033,
0.5604971051,
0.0485293902,
0.0517897829,
-0.6460019946,
0.2922575772,
0.2662210763,
0.0330305547,
0.2324855179,
0.2175717801,
-0.1663528532,
-0.8917927742,
-0.4005131423,
0.428925842,
-0.3220688999,
-0.4626329839,
0.2894579172,
0.128571704,
-0.4929429293,
0.3107441962,
-0.1647551656,
-0.6951752305,
0.4364028871,
0.4098603129,
1.0646057129,
-0.5193032622,
0.1119974479,
-0.1312113553,
0.371286422,
0.1370171756,
0.4625436664,
0.016952863,
-0.9095455408,
-0.2286927402,
-0.8790078163,
-0.4270525873,
-0.1715586931,
-0.5570448041,
0.2380409241,
-0.4490707815,
-0.35696733,
-0.2764925361,
0.180553332,
-0.8567581773,
-0.022245517,
0.2400383204,
0.568454206,
-0.9038127065,
0.5783717036,
0.4394123852,
-0.1397107989,
-0.3983791173,
0.0490539446,
0.3289738595,
-0.8443729877,
0.8375791311,
0.1532675028,
-0.2148755342,
-0.2363571972,
-0.4198121727,
-1.1327015162,
0.910332799,
0.3141383529,
-0.5601338148,
-0.3099418581,
0.4628935754,
0.7987910509,
-0.3539760709,
0.2453125864,
0.799726367,
0.729001224,
-0.358492434,
-0.8894551992,
0.0690101981,
-0.3340130448,
-0.0115169855,
0.4378685057,
-0.7116125226,
0.8057880998,
-0.5046405792,
-0.269798249,
0.4226970375,
0.3574304879,
0.1012320593,
-0.1927192509,
0.1696834564,
0.2568027377,
0.8223292828,
-0.2342181802,
0.9878123403,
-0.5450898409,
-0.1859534383,
0.8523949981,
-0.3666019142,
0.8552873135,
0.4851026237,
-0.0832752064,
0.8094716668,
0.0680140853,
-0.161801517,
0.3201259673,
0.3006543219,
-0.335670203,
-0.0016972193,
-0.3114171624,
-0.2933358848,
0.5512295961,
0.5019959807,
-0.7488920093,
0.3352266848,
-0.1565353125,
0.6876570582,
0.1784660816,
-0.1671913713,
0.7868880033,
0.3108206987,
-0.4079020321,
0.0249961186,
-0.1786795706,
0.7457643747,
-0.9279918671,
0.2118074,
-0.1793810129,
0.314768225,
-0.2831714153,
-1.109639287,
0.0532520227,
0.0633790269,
-0.3863401115,
-0.7160743475,
0.7879375815,
-0.3769017458,
-0.4853492081,
0.3119705617,
0.7043144703,
0.1094721258,
-0.2662073672,
-0.1337535977,
0.2297419012,
-0.2349327505,
-0.4757040143,
0.3083364069,
0.3837274015,
0.0637689307,
0.7269941568,
0.8305481672,
0.7131268978,
0.2699618638,
0.1879637241,
0.6447706223,
-0.9412976503,
-0.3215518594,
-1.0033689737,
0.1186838225,
0.0168369692,
-0.8109100461,
1.1334853172,
0.3764845729,
0.5353902578,
-0.3000911772,
0.7710266113,
0.2563833594,
0.5179890394,
-0.6783017516,
0.9500002265,
0.0215249639,
0.2234261185,
-0.3132840693,
-0.9839379191,
-0.2550032437,
0.1106676608,
-0.6568334699,
0.3311469555,
0.8142123222,
0.8479583859,
0.7672114372,
0.1178735197,
0.450977385,
0.2335769385,
0.3559091985,
0.4169662595,
1.1476010084,
0.0563274026,
0.2791378796,
-0.4814542532,
-0.2476623505,
-0.0902538896,
-0.84440732,
-1.1890702248,
-0.459743619,
-0.3094485104,
-0.1182465777,
0.2475185692,
0.6357870102,
0.2652174532,
-0.4641752243,
-0.2858817875,
0.1050377116,
-0.0570687428,
-0.151550591,
-0.2441741228,
0.1871773899,
0.0906550214,
-0.4845243692,
0.1651333719,
0.430750519,
0.1623518616,
-0.4475524724,
-0.1122573167,
0.1393497288,
0.05388432,
0.3715060651,
0.1603920311,
-1.0563678741,
-0.2366744429,
0.2680012882,
-0.2500626147,
-0.0704086572,
0.9293513894,
-0.5476495624,
0.3845731616,
0.5489417911,
-0.2532822788,
0.101115495,
-0.0382387154,
0.7060728669,
-0.5792757273,
-0.2133857608,
0.3284829855,
0.5349667072,
0.456604749,
-0.7598162889,
0.5202015638,
0.3172616959,
-0.5701790452,
-0.5705828071,
0.2576024234,
-0.6569957733,
0.0297693033,
1.5000008345,
0.0972383767,
-0.1629206389,
-0.0610879734,
-0.1851220131,
-0.2128607333,
-0.5423182249,
0.6823509336,
0.8146286011,
-0.2092025131,
-0.2219178677,
-0.5152839422,
0.8084133267,
0.2964336574,
-0.6912627816,
0.298925668,
0.2888545692,
0.2192985564,
0.1973830462,
0.6642866731,
-0.0150166089,
0.0923982635,
-0.1011783481,
0.0921524912,
-0.1641745418,
-0.2293590307,
-0.2030101866,
-0.1345758587,
0.2030198872,
0.1666694134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00264v1
|
DiLM: Distilling Dataset into Language Model for Text-level Dataset Distillation
| 2024-03-30T06:40:54 | 2024-03-30T06:40:54 |
Aru Maekawa, Satoshi Kosugi, Kotaro Funakoshi, Manabu Okumura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Dataset distillation aims to compress a training dataset by creating a small
number of informative synthetic samples such that neural networks trained on
them perform as well as those trained on the original training dataset. Current
text dataset distillation methods create each synthetic sample as a sequence of
word embeddings instead of a text to apply gradient-based optimization;
however, such embedding-level distilled datasets cannot be used for training
other models whose word embedding weights are different from the model used for
distillation. To address this issue, we propose a novel text dataset
distillation approach, called Distilling dataset into Language Model (DiLM),
which trains a language model to generate informative synthetic training
samples as text data, instead of directly optimizing synthetic samples. We
evaluated DiLM on various text classification datasets and showed that
distilled synthetic datasets from DiLM outperform those from current coreset
selection methods. DiLM achieved remarkable generalization performance in
training different types of models and in-context learning of large language
models. Our code will be available at https://github.com/arumaekawa/DiLM.
|
[
-0.1581774801,
-0.9076074958,
0.3587721288,
0.203817457,
-0.4691824317,
0.0162895676,
-0.6473193765,
-0.1083509922,
-0.0075265248,
0.4170032144,
-0.3317157328,
-0.5563850403,
-0.6214180589,
0.2441505045,
-0.7521626949,
1.1960897446,
-0.0370739959,
0.1397624165,
-0.3173696697,
-0.0392429046,
-0.4983885884,
-0.5668584108,
-0.5240388513,
-0.5994323492,
0.184893921,
0.3305718005,
0.2845424414,
0.823131144,
0.4596729279,
0.3025044203,
-0.0603168383,
0.288685143,
-0.5240850449,
0.30306077,
0.1394177526,
-0.6538479924,
-0.066735357,
0.2618922293,
0.6470929384,
0.8138971925,
-0.2823005617,
0.037383195,
0.2628269196,
0.9155782461,
-0.5138953328,
0.2793388665,
-0.9353938699,
0.0396717712,
-0.0929422453,
-0.0020342325,
-0.3925850391,
-0.4594172239,
0.2731778324,
-0.5107247829,
0.433215946,
0.0695333257,
0.6369010806,
0.3975733817,
-0.2063678503,
-0.3912069201,
-1.0787210464,
1.0148152113,
-0.7353023291,
0.0228703078,
0.4374474287,
0.4232847691,
0.1477354467,
-0.8803954124,
-0.7286804914,
-0.0961987674,
0.0268115364,
-0.0916382894,
-0.0709540322,
-0.0495701507,
0.1879158616,
0.7913637161,
-0.4540781081,
-0.2722596228,
-0.2242643535,
0.209609136,
0.6221302748,
-0.0328065306,
0.2343088984,
0.1423816681,
-0.2782336175,
-0.260759294,
-0.5028550625,
-0.4077464938,
0.4011619687,
0.6099100709,
0.1027959287,
0.5339164734,
-0.1369616985,
0.7265182734,
0.0161973853,
-0.0221040323,
0.4596327543,
-0.3763850927,
-0.3934282362,
0.294557333,
0.7533531189,
0.1228069961,
0.6922469139,
-0.1157099977,
-0.3679421246,
-0.0290519502,
0.2501167357,
-1.0962201357,
-0.5390998125,
0.279129982,
-0.4095953703,
-0.6674531698,
0.1300269365,
-0.708933115,
-0.3741372228,
-0.4880144,
0.2678198218,
-0.3804759979,
-0.2323056757,
0.2517735958,
-0.3327235281,
-0.0330048539,
-0.0596969016,
-0.9526318312,
0.4781217873,
0.5526832342,
0.955630362,
-0.2632154524,
-0.1215841174,
-0.3118678331,
-0.048496224,
-0.1905810833,
0.5445720553,
-0.5829944611,
-0.5142919421,
-0.0093141627,
-0.2128007412,
0.1037536114,
-0.8918845654,
0.5346669555,
-0.4194953442,
0.2467767149,
0.0695220679,
-0.7634319663,
-0.1550570279,
0.4521352351,
-0.917105794,
1.11244452,
-0.1692776978,
-0.9359803796,
0.3547316492,
-0.5055434108,
-0.4992258549,
-0.0600424297,
-0.1622823477,
-0.570438683,
0.290284276,
0.4198240936,
0.3822295368,
-0.4573633671,
0.4306076467,
-0.1997512132,
-0.3013851345,
0.266510278,
-0.549430728,
0.6027321219,
0.156556204,
-0.0095824478,
-0.3158225715,
-0.8295847774,
-0.123665303,
0.1686878949,
-0.4885209799,
-0.8479751348,
0.0574226007,
0.1498186439,
0.034147691,
0.3192009926,
-0.5954383016,
0.4693698883,
-0.5039390922,
0.4848588407,
0.4638349116,
-0.0074258009,
0.6281573176,
-0.191830188,
0.2943303883,
0.1607638896,
-0.1351756305,
-0.1944317967,
-0.3548348248,
-0.8830097318,
-0.423668474,
0.739775598,
0.5295259953,
-0.812363863,
0.555752635,
-0.5159506202,
-0.4591833949,
-0.394123286,
0.1607993096,
0.2776440084,
0.5362910628,
0.3089275956,
0.0719869584,
-0.5451375246,
-0.9379252195,
-0.262575537,
-0.0745188892,
-0.1143006459,
0.0306885224,
0.4992528856,
-0.1573873311,
1.3311843872,
-0.8634877205,
-0.4949106872,
-0.4371555448,
0.2708358765,
0.3837953508,
0.5696111917,
0.392984271,
-1.0257475376,
-0.6822423935,
0.0049963817,
-0.6995623708,
-0.2378172725,
-0.0447618067,
0.0801309422,
-0.1609979123,
0.5955106616,
-0.0910040885,
0.2097060382,
0.549689889,
-0.0229783766,
0.3498665392,
-0.2855097651,
-0.1079879403,
-1.6139891148,
0.2472240627,
0.1113656461,
-0.369430542,
-0.7571348548,
-0.2588350177,
0.0715094209,
-0.182063967,
-0.3636533916,
0.4512884617,
-0.5175797939,
0.2950128019,
-0.4812902808,
-0.0724650919,
0.3075129986,
0.330739826,
0.0563509241,
0.6837944388,
0.6187499762,
-0.6422088146,
0.6026975513,
0.431858778,
-0.4509322643,
0.1721257865,
-0.8433587551,
0.0849911496,
-0.2182632238,
0.1846605092,
-0.8460838795,
0.0430582128,
-0.0959461555,
-0.2622756362,
0.4806637764,
-0.3467780054,
-0.5362879634,
-0.1212576404,
-0.2919886112,
0.4494637847,
0.5390462875,
-0.5472050905,
0.4983173013,
0.4792665839,
-0.1615244746,
-0.5850643516,
-1.1372486353,
-0.0209795386,
-0.5337149501,
-0.3029600382,
0.5618833899,
-0.1058649868,
-0.2722239792,
-0.0805598646,
-0.0323627293,
-0.461330384,
-0.0446733013,
0.0722268522,
0.4494163394,
0.192320019,
0.369735539,
0.3181392848,
-0.1142625287,
-0.0356609672,
-0.585883677,
0.6084144115,
0.1862412393,
-0.000835098,
-0.2774674594,
0.2499195337,
0.288946718,
-0.184921816,
0.8985744119,
0.3744567633,
-0.5555984378,
-0.5892326832,
-0.3047454953,
-0.2870429456,
-0.4711956382,
0.4167979658,
-0.3841243684,
-0.7762039304,
0.3317024708,
-0.3032174706,
0.1931017488,
0.2443473488,
0.5277574658,
0.0941465795,
0.8349255323,
0.7430710793,
-0.3362875581,
0.6727004051,
-0.5188751817,
0.1640844941,
-0.5793800354,
-0.1051879823,
-0.7388305068,
-0.5814957023,
-0.4975595474,
-0.5459647179,
0.1875280738,
0.0532049015,
0.193981275,
0.2631114423,
-0.4781956971,
0.8507320881,
0.3506321609,
-0.0726769865,
0.5227152109,
0.5041793585,
-0.2293973565,
0.0492375307,
-0.5960604548,
-0.5802835822,
1.2240495682,
0.3589689732,
0.9092829227,
-0.2762520909,
0.8883351684,
0.3303952217,
0.26735726,
-0.9069257975,
0.3914704025,
-0.6268002987,
-0.6846562028,
-0.3365280032,
-0.6835856438,
-0.7434196472,
0.1936481446,
-0.0550409481,
-0.2981566191,
0.2575398386,
0.0572402403,
-0.1333541274,
0.183300972,
-0.5949114561,
0.6173632741,
0.1735599339,
-0.0644939467,
-0.1592288017,
-0.381415695,
0.310349822,
-0.4247089624,
0.151525721,
-0.1179687753,
-0.0418078378,
0.7973671556,
-0.5928326249,
0.7943946123,
-0.2331392616,
-0.3272419274,
0.4709572196,
-0.022741694,
0.4688383341,
0.1806847751,
-0.2821933031,
0.2710319757,
-0.2028588355,
-0.1083028913,
-0.7067002058,
0.7791398168,
-0.6695907116,
-0.153537184,
-0.3711729646,
-0.5292201638,
-0.2466143519,
0.1599483639,
0.3244151771,
0.5832814574,
-0.5008978248,
0.3184853494,
0.7993984818,
-0.1422469765,
0.5666074157,
0.2649616003,
-0.2987253368,
-0.455268085,
1.0110830069,
0.0308315419,
0.2079435289,
0.5325659513,
0.207688719,
-0.4830090702,
-0.6998265386,
-0.4183626175,
0.0092762299,
-0.4823164046,
-0.1909270883,
-0.565486908,
-0.2708286345,
-0.1238995567,
0.3445862234,
-0.5635280013,
-0.6008358002,
-0.3863883615,
0.0264494326,
0.3342565894,
0.6067274213,
0.1531437486,
0.2850089073,
-0.9800032973,
0.3821581304,
0.2793584168,
0.2615484595,
-0.2414054573,
-0.7096784711,
-0.4832074344,
0.3502844572,
-0.1496130973,
-0.5913667679,
0.6024454832,
0.642472744,
0.3422658443,
0.2093014419,
0.1134670377,
0.3793688118,
-0.7136990428,
0.574934721,
0.1754416823,
-0.8695832491,
0.6458679438,
-0.211987704,
0.329877317,
0.9716311097,
0.5379904509,
-0.5028993487,
-0.177780062,
-0.2378513366,
-0.8567635417,
0.5755598545,
0.4444209337,
0.36003986,
0.0115106981,
0.3998643756,
0.3616203368,
0.4929028749,
-0.6706414819,
-0.3699512482,
0.0353669003,
-0.5364713669,
-0.1457648426,
-0.1504951566,
-0.0482771099,
-0.2249042988,
0.7488973737,
-0.2296562344,
0.0014021153,
0.1553582847,
-0.2920473218,
0.307633847,
0.1103927344,
0.0450375825,
0.2500602305,
-0.1362542957,
0.1979056299,
0.0917216539,
-0.8065698743,
0.2774721682,
0.2910137177,
-0.2007758915,
0.1780381352,
0.188255474,
0.7308212519,
-0.2523241341,
-0.6431924105,
0.4790485799,
-0.4549105465,
-0.2583464384,
-0.1573725492,
0.1152139753,
0.0740892068,
0.1290207505,
0.4177226126,
-0.2261263132,
0.2937509418,
-0.379550457,
0.1687047035,
0.0808073506,
-0.3874792457,
-0.1971384138,
0.4041186571,
0.3263475597,
0.1174975187,
0.8955999613,
-0.0449004956,
-0.2562921643,
0.4536109567,
0.4607686102,
1.1416120529,
-0.0484559275,
0.1930028051,
0.3930422962,
0.1071358547,
-0.3122412264,
0.2093985677,
-0.0068095326,
-0.8544923067,
-0.4904620349,
-0.9972672462,
-0.1584309191,
0.2526498139,
-0.5783168077,
0.245379284,
-0.3889237642,
-0.255473882,
-0.1190802306,
0.0507688336,
-0.3826521039,
0.3145414293,
0.2247783393,
0.8947897553,
-1.0011694431,
1.0087534189,
0.7094417214,
-0.2771981657,
-0.5148149729,
0.3569513559,
-0.330129981,
-0.2714536488,
0.6005380154,
0.3096375167,
0.3051719368,
0.0324886777,
-0.5183001757,
-0.5208546519,
1.0067156553,
0.546443224,
-0.9201542139,
-0.0998447016,
0.5117388964,
0.5968602896,
-0.5409376621,
-0.0714508519,
0.7030203342,
0.2741553187,
0.0328199901,
-0.6838706136,
-0.1722711921,
-0.4706842601,
0.3955920041,
0.076344505,
-0.4591143131,
0.8025227189,
0.1685199142,
-0.2236134559,
-0.0568785667,
0.7269065976,
0.1539624929,
0.0533712693,
0.5720314384,
0.7659660578,
0.7513246536,
-0.2131049782,
0.8243237734,
-0.2303266078,
0.4328261316,
1.3913538456,
-0.3240935206,
0.6518307328,
0.5238092542,
-0.1317556649,
0.380813241,
0.4242646694,
-0.0172506981,
0.7315603495,
0.3884451985,
-0.5220290422,
-0.033400774,
-0.0795380771,
-0.3600881994,
0.5665286779,
0.2340151966,
-0.5340554714,
-0.247094363,
0.2151077092,
-0.1843310297,
0.1414957643,
0.0450963564,
0.8928223848,
0.1251408309,
-0.5079467297,
0.5841655731,
0.1280006617,
0.7263564467,
-0.5992224216,
-0.0379650816,
-0.227587074,
0.4310187399,
0.0361245982,
-0.527638793,
0.5333970189,
0.2100896835,
-0.4972653389,
-0.3469766974,
0.8833541274,
-0.8326063156,
-0.7631489635,
0.0928963944,
0.5051838756,
0.1653793454,
-0.3855907321,
-0.6302367449,
0.0078888666,
0.0739167705,
-0.4117199779,
0.2320085168,
0.6383054852,
0.2074964941,
0.5476638079,
0.6798023582,
0.1894218922,
-0.0724232793,
0.2940323055,
1.1201446056,
-0.4102303386,
-0.520465374,
-1.1708815098,
0.403339386,
-0.276632458,
-0.1480318457,
0.6403278112,
0.8559343815,
0.8195751905,
-0.2099945694,
1.11333251,
-0.0764538646,
0.4098637104,
-0.4764017761,
0.9808678031,
-0.4522362053,
0.2700728774,
-0.0614378862,
-1.2482185364,
-0.1338999867,
0.5821408033,
-0.2695352137,
0.1771181971,
0.6730375886,
0.7238693833,
-0.1118028462,
0.1196449474,
0.2496144027,
0.1341552734,
0.3527770638,
0.2913126647,
0.6730367541,
-0.4445322454,
0.4794309735,
-0.3914709091,
-0.2750842273,
0.0087779956,
-1.0527755022,
-1.1122442484,
-0.6989092231,
-0.4156350791,
-0.1511308402,
-0.098714523,
0.8082401156,
0.6567281485,
-0.8420167565,
-0.1787973344,
-0.510800302,
-0.2957193553,
-0.0153735345,
-0.2176361829,
0.1456564814,
-0.3555704355,
-1.3247740269,
0.3879688084,
0.0185027588,
0.2069378942,
-0.4020403624,
0.2177316844,
-0.2305234373,
0.0728565678,
0.4086318314,
-0.1477446407,
-0.012757632,
0.3354439735,
-0.275118649,
-0.1479765773,
0.037178345,
0.9792230725,
-0.8475387692,
0.4330554008,
0.6832413673,
0.7988219857,
0.6119778156,
-0.1036877111,
0.7903284431,
-1.2870724201,
0.3452358544,
0.2756617069,
0.3097224832,
0.4899373949,
-0.1677388251,
0.4956228435,
0.1852899045,
-0.341167897,
-0.7757483125,
0.1034617573,
-0.8013582826,
-0.3568665683,
1.2589765787,
-0.1959234923,
-0.3357664645,
0.1195518449,
-0.3246948123,
0.5312535763,
-0.3724667728,
0.8248944879,
0.7867686152,
0.4848729074,
0.327447921,
-0.2239702642,
0.5113148689,
0.1913362145,
-0.8640622497,
0.4358166456,
0.3944825828,
0.2278617024,
0.0666061342,
0.2439008504,
-0.1865180731,
-0.3547764421,
-0.0041640848,
0.0758577585,
-0.3282414377,
-0.5110087991,
-0.5026991367,
0.0643599853,
-0.1220123395,
-0.3587580025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00246v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00246v1
|
Your Co-Workers Matter: Evaluating Collaborative Capabilities of Language Models in Blocks World
| 2024-03-30T04:48:38 | 2024-03-30T04:48:38 |
Guande Wu, Chen Zhao, Claudio Silva, He He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Language agents that interact with the world on their own have great
potential for automating digital tasks. While large language model (LLM) agents
have made progress in understanding and executing tasks such as textual games
and webpage control, many real-world tasks also require collaboration with
humans or other LLMs in equal roles, which involves intent understanding, task
coordination, and communication. To test LLM's ability to collaborate, we
design a blocks-world environment, where two agents, each having unique goals
and skills, build a target structure together. To complete the goals, they can
act in the world and communicate in natural language. Under this environment,
we design increasingly challenging settings to evaluate different collaboration
perspectives, from independent to more complex, dependent tasks. We further
adopt chain-of-thought prompts that include intermediate reasoning steps to
model the partner's state and identify and correct execution errors. Both
human-machine and machine-machine experiments show that LLM agents have strong
grounding capacities, and our approach significantly improves the evaluation
metric.
|
[
-0.5239918828,
-0.9717302322,
0.7606965899,
0.4341917932,
0.0825532526,
0.4758055806,
-0.1216100305,
-0.8008823991,
0.1984640807,
0.4635819793,
-0.5107681751,
-0.2128973156,
-0.4872054756,
0.148345992,
-0.2719385028,
0.7240546346,
-0.108993344,
-0.0168171357,
-0.7959311008,
0.0474157557,
-0.7567396164,
-0.4142533839,
-0.5684161782,
-0.6151012778,
0.2253329605,
0.4237900674,
0.9017149806,
0.4838112295,
0.5659490228,
0.4779724181,
0.0509913862,
0.0981782898,
-0.5279450417,
0.2864453495,
-0.3985671699,
-0.1176663935,
-0.7968562841,
0.0946536437,
0.1608659476,
1.0428298712,
0.1673932523,
0.0270128064,
-0.1089792177,
0.4485553503,
-0.268134445,
0.366742909,
-0.4468904138,
0.0673194081,
0.3356257379,
0.0806572214,
-0.316275835,
-0.2750751078,
0.2123124748,
-0.5748320818,
0.03420626,
0.3289866745,
0.5100742579,
0.133859545,
-0.3780610561,
-0.3839485645,
-0.6917150617,
0.6686402559,
-0.2474107146,
0.3314938545,
0.5701630116,
-0.0230385344,
-0.488564074,
-0.6777136922,
-0.4244134128,
-0.4198316336,
-0.0323424265,
0.2176207453,
-0.1811411828,
0.3322300911,
0.0189828742,
0.6704389453,
-0.4724268019,
0.0897600353,
-0.3165306747,
-0.3092008531,
0.8659162521,
0.2957012057,
0.7288498878,
0.3484913111,
-0.1436111927,
-0.0283387061,
-0.1985327154,
-0.0535310619,
0.4394182265,
0.1644027233,
-0.2804734111,
0.4324210882,
-0.2145026177,
0.8487297893,
0.1147970259,
0.0005309298,
-0.2466256768,
-0.5677586198,
-0.2901466191,
-0.3074812591,
0.6563596725,
0.3457003236,
0.2202457935,
-0.4632016718,
-0.1304928809,
0.0618590377,
0.4372064471,
-0.3760221899,
-0.1471598893,
0.291400522,
-0.2848519385,
-0.1830249578,
0.0626344234,
-0.2615855336,
-0.6624020338,
-0.4724626541,
0.522228241,
0.0624622442,
-0.2745340168,
-0.0367780998,
-0.3124220669,
-0.1206851751,
0.4699705243,
-0.8777006269,
0.9925795197,
0.8231564164,
0.6013196111,
-0.2542129755,
-0.8190558553,
-0.6173996925,
-0.2544610798,
-0.4111743569,
0.5785439014,
-0.3505550623,
-0.3227779269,
-0.1402284205,
-0.089643538,
-0.0697931573,
-0.5559611917,
0.105840005,
-0.4960289598,
0.19938609,
-0.3565595746,
-0.5978600979,
-0.0492543317,
0.4044561982,
-0.8407428861,
0.7050302029,
0.2908417583,
-0.5376654267,
0.1572364271,
-0.8449850678,
-0.4760915637,
0.3084823191,
-0.3340561986,
-0.1201541573,
0.1565819234,
-0.281240344,
0.5823557377,
-0.408017993,
0.1972518712,
-0.1787286997,
-0.4004306793,
0.385368377,
-0.0169173721,
0.7644652128,
-0.098280631,
-0.3514747322,
0.3844684362,
-0.4642712176,
0.0433524624,
0.1047018766,
-0.388247788,
-0.2486116588,
0.043316178,
-0.0831103548,
0.4034783542,
0.4803569019,
-0.2965579927,
-0.0096290326,
-0.0457262918,
0.1574721187,
0.652015388,
0.111186713,
0.5180288553,
-0.5386964679,
0.6225947738,
-0.4447062612,
0.1928781569,
0.1817806065,
-0.6523812413,
-0.5456840396,
-0.2224220634,
-0.200839892,
0.4368934929,
-0.5402386785,
0.714646101,
-0.0661886185,
-0.5901366472,
-0.349193126,
0.3416576684,
0.422044158,
0.3218218088,
0.1743471622,
-0.7073607445,
-0.615732491,
-0.7658102512,
-0.2135896087,
-0.3257528543,
0.2229913026,
0.2979022563,
0.6654101014,
-0.2354670465,
1.3187091351,
-0.3118467629,
-0.0551159829,
-0.5793055296,
0.0077396603,
0.0141992476,
0.3675656319,
-0.127254352,
-0.8948140144,
-0.7202458978,
0.0882233009,
-0.8499999046,
-0.355026871,
-0.0821872503,
-0.0461271517,
0.055963099,
0.3989129364,
-0.3338676095,
0.2598626018,
0.9202334881,
-0.7164511085,
0.5943298936,
-0.502127707,
0.1159049049,
-0.7332934141,
0.0335381962,
-0.283634007,
-0.4974275827,
-0.6795002222,
0.1832565516,
-0.2372158468,
-0.1699970365,
-0.2588468492,
0.4554451406,
-0.6262112856,
-0.4467001557,
-0.3137627244,
0.4703622162,
0.1684777588,
0.2684586942,
0.0763579011,
0.6334357858,
0.4260093272,
-0.5420658588,
0.6012875438,
0.1494523287,
-0.3768080175,
0.724655807,
-0.6195608377,
0.6656485796,
0.33146137,
0.2006857544,
-0.6749505401,
-0.2455907613,
-0.0919102728,
-0.227326408,
-0.1066276282,
0.0588126704,
-0.7368114591,
-0.4139734209,
-0.2093412578,
0.1662785262,
0.1331412643,
-0.2478318959,
0.4160939455,
0.7826870084,
0.0226962622,
-0.423474431,
-0.7875465751,
0.3246035874,
0.1265793592,
-0.8982563019,
0.340282023,
-0.5085567832,
-0.8793676496,
0.172816813,
-0.0845979974,
-0.4535709321,
0.6128417253,
0.5579243898,
0.0403792746,
0.2388398796,
-0.1568033993,
-0.1482190937,
-0.1006490216,
0.1939306408,
-0.0618802868,
0.7451549768,
-0.4874970615,
-0.4287958741,
-0.272873491,
0.4209211767,
0.7831773162,
-0.1640469581,
0.7932990193,
0.4614738524,
-0.5755614638,
-0.0739045069,
-0.5631943941,
-0.0792956501,
-0.4429768026,
0.5356625915,
-0.2041319162,
-0.951382339,
0.5677820444,
0.0061664968,
-0.2325771898,
0.0982400551,
0.750577271,
0.0457859933,
0.6578152776,
0.9769581556,
-0.1396211386,
0.185107246,
-0.1963362843,
0.2824581861,
-0.6561173797,
-0.2337599397,
-0.2012383044,
-0.008390951,
-0.3411582112,
-0.5098859668,
0.2993302643,
0.0400256068,
0.0082675219,
0.6007830501,
-0.2729018629,
0.7186831832,
0.3797979951,
-0.0381078124,
0.5002726316,
-0.322247535,
-0.1819662303,
-0.0370565839,
-0.4239836633,
-0.5872766972,
0.5304375291,
0.3567067385,
0.7310351133,
0.008405285,
0.7155713439,
0.6988272667,
0.1443614662,
-0.8218753338,
0.6750636101,
0.1329959035,
-0.7202107906,
-0.3901005685,
-0.2026082724,
-0.9665616155,
0.3547522128,
-0.2255322188,
-0.6648778915,
-0.3166665435,
-0.1163763776,
-0.165285185,
0.2095450461,
-0.7301611304,
1.0913230181,
-0.1987950206,
-0.5792399049,
-0.6590496898,
-0.3989607394,
0.0031987303,
-0.0629867539,
0.5073114634,
-0.1170374379,
-0.1614158005,
0.5388598442,
-0.392711401,
1.0612204075,
0.0971275419,
-0.1637062728,
0.3919988871,
0.4430041313,
0.350857228,
-0.2269822657,
-0.3619456291,
-0.0201232061,
-0.296099335,
-0.2712794244,
-0.3494378328,
0.6681467891,
-0.8203670979,
-0.569013536,
-0.2756301165,
-0.8728363514,
-0.0519224666,
0.3175884485,
-0.0767772794,
0.3031153381,
-0.8106135726,
0.2017082721,
0.0541280098,
0.0683442578,
0.4993919134,
0.530269444,
-0.3122627735,
-0.3845292926,
0.7645395994,
0.0809238628,
0.5971863866,
0.2495902479,
0.2340138257,
0.0297394935,
-0.3930075467,
-0.2154231966,
-0.0306341927,
-0.9379675984,
0.1553414017,
-0.487479955,
0.1073584259,
-0.1391704381,
-0.5103660822,
-0.2965139449,
0.0784124136,
0.008211649,
0.0683589354,
0.0435832888,
1.2794417143,
-0.1025692299,
0.0039790371,
-0.7607077956,
0.0614632778,
0.714155376,
0.2125794441,
-0.0450878553,
-0.038205795,
-0.6041708589,
-0.2394205183,
-0.3223910034,
-0.8822849393,
0.3740174472,
-0.2472135276,
0.6566694379,
-0.2578064799,
0.021672979,
0.5255858898,
-0.1685498059,
0.7938581705,
0.11933586,
-1.4947779179,
0.2221371531,
-0.3435272276,
0.0983306244,
0.5754112601,
0.2734689116,
-0.8188649416,
-0.440547049,
-0.7549907565,
-0.571154952,
0.6288301349,
0.397605449,
-0.0432606079,
0.0710736439,
-0.0490020625,
0.0629910156,
0.2620519102,
-0.9390326142,
-0.2079898119,
0.354336977,
-0.1192292348,
0.2031705528,
0.0149611607,
-0.1461886764,
0.0139064407,
0.2549859583,
-0.2318583727,
0.1300451458,
0.425216198,
-0.2921082675,
-0.4929202497,
0.2334055156,
0.5137586594,
0.9804649949,
-0.0042462386,
0.328451395,
0.59264189,
-0.3400407135,
0.1532305479,
-0.2142433524,
0.4508742988,
-0.4217148125,
0.5940247178,
0.6139367819,
-0.016126683,
-0.6641836762,
0.706265986,
-0.3386713564,
-0.0034496086,
-0.3668836057,
0.2273308635,
0.4014861584,
0.3359773755,
0.2279646993,
0.1806589514,
0.0013705954,
-0.9219624996,
0.0430123173,
0.2803868055,
-0.5414253473,
-0.4769781828,
0.1567023396,
0.4110408127,
-0.8449928164,
0.143629685,
-0.6946568489,
-0.7898105979,
0.9727208018,
0.750249505,
0.874232471,
-0.0300518293,
0.0406002849,
-0.2218825668,
0.4357200265,
-0.1017894745,
0.2016335726,
0.0238817316,
-0.8050516844,
-0.6005317569,
-0.0597787686,
-1.0049209595,
0.0683890134,
-0.3682038188,
0.1011981741,
-0.5750806332,
0.0528338887,
-0.391528964,
0.5593389869,
-0.707929194,
0.2923859954,
0.215242967,
0.4847652316,
-1.0500500202,
0.5939797163,
0.8253657222,
-0.2309850454,
-0.367400527,
0.0623010993,
-0.0348929949,
-0.5586297512,
0.763327837,
0.2517889142,
-0.3174017668,
-0.0891013294,
-0.4600088,
-0.6941341162,
1.1832611561,
0.3279696107,
-0.4388403893,
0.2526842952,
0.038570635,
0.7644537687,
-0.6049257517,
0.3917345703,
0.2932189405,
0.3904394209,
-0.5415414572,
-1.5168377161,
0.2468800098,
-0.1368897408,
-0.1960223764,
-0.0917530656,
-0.7552614212,
0.97409302,
-0.1416409016,
-0.029915059,
-0.1491182446,
0.4037189782,
0.2899449468,
0.3361251652,
0.859610498,
0.3143098056,
1.0842660666,
0.2991293371,
1.0931415558,
-0.2780670524,
0.3124650419,
1.0832792521,
-0.3465131819,
0.5865793824,
0.3262494802,
-0.1698735207,
0.6533890367,
0.2222313583,
0.1682685763,
0.0440767929,
0.5407959819,
-0.2626177669,
-0.3565628231,
-0.4558971226,
0.020942241,
0.4907000661,
0.265730679,
0.0203815289,
0.1811948866,
-0.1344404668,
-0.0247986577,
0.5044638515,
-0.0914447233,
0.6567296982,
0.1750946343,
-0.8286052942,
0.1047314405,
-0.0329417624,
0.5087912083,
-0.2375175059,
0.0283574853,
0.0420661718,
0.2160276473,
-0.3748620749,
-0.7727246284,
0.4685387313,
-0.0292921662,
-0.2152512074,
-0.4224676788,
0.8180637956,
-0.4604710639,
0.0301621668,
0.8228166699,
0.7545346022,
0.1835970134,
-0.1800179183,
-0.7299503088,
0.5608631968,
-0.247500509,
0.0867704004,
0.2005820125,
0.1691257656,
-0.0297767241,
0.7028720379,
0.5261042118,
0.0145384325,
-0.1858430505,
0.1536840647,
0.7427431345,
-0.5809212327,
-0.4957891703,
-0.8732635379,
0.4686774909,
-0.3097962439,
-0.0739671364,
0.7515373826,
0.6299791336,
0.7871895432,
-0.0588005632,
0.7727887034,
-0.3301534653,
0.0931862667,
-0.2434430271,
0.7350375652,
-0.3937611878,
-0.0466052964,
-0.353882432,
-0.6843447089,
-0.2190094888,
0.5602106452,
-0.4121137559,
0.0249893535,
0.9530133009,
0.4915236533,
0.1338800341,
-0.0873856321,
0.595928967,
0.0861717761,
0.5312669873,
0.5634948015,
1.1017252207,
-0.3783594072,
0.4499261975,
-0.4048888683,
-0.0955562666,
-0.1530002207,
-1.0658965111,
-1.0762888193,
-0.742849052,
-0.5883838534,
-0.375028789,
-0.2097588927,
1.3821014166,
0.9453877807,
-0.5350742936,
-0.8033801913,
-0.5125157237,
0.4833224714,
-0.1842597872,
-0.187357977,
-0.0275136232,
-0.3087325692,
-0.7941077948,
0.8696829677,
0.3946602643,
-0.0388988405,
-0.5541195869,
-0.4468613565,
-0.2230306566,
-0.0915905982,
0.4966496825,
0.0077729677,
-0.5627877116,
-0.1949415803,
0.1113358438,
-0.4091996551,
-0.0841560364,
0.8312647939,
-0.5020109415,
0.7149559259,
0.8225927949,
0.6789623499,
0.2357397825,
-0.1648504585,
0.9476790428,
-0.6114203334,
0.0098300241,
0.1704653054,
0.3731724024,
0.5509308577,
-0.4049890041,
0.5746689439,
0.4700146019,
-0.9106593132,
-0.5933790803,
0.0662132576,
-0.8484682441,
-0.1585843116,
0.8042328358,
-0.3314555287,
-0.1401361078,
-0.6328427196,
-0.3365377784,
0.2926618159,
-0.2294727564,
0.7050603032,
0.8242502213,
-0.1785198301,
0.1830509901,
-0.3803795576,
0.3776150048,
0.4679013491,
-1.0805082321,
-0.0683872774,
0.3247748017,
0.0933438763,
0.4956246614,
0.9285199046,
0.4107510149,
0.2188159376,
0.1138025597,
0.1825383753,
-0.1602464467,
-0.307046622,
-0.4336203933,
0.0010274536,
0.4922423363,
0.0216683559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00242v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00242v2
|
DeFT: Decoding with Flash Tree-attention for Efficient Tree-structured LLM Inference
| 2024-03-30T04:34:54 | 2024-05-29T18:46:41 |
Jinwei Yao, Kaiqi Chen, Kexun Zhang, Jiaxuan You, Binhang Yuan, Zeke Wang, Tao Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Given the increasing demand for tree-structured interactions with LLMs, we
introduce DeFT (Decoding with Flash Tree-Attention), an IO-aware tree attention
algorithm tailored for tree-structured inference. Unlike traditional
sequence-based decoding, tree-structured decoding better accommodates modern
task requirements, including self-consistency, few-shot prompting, multi-step
reasoning, and multi-model/head coordination. However, existing sequence-based
inference systems are ill-suited for tree-structured decoding, resulting in
redundancy in computation, memory footprints, and memory access, thereby
undermining inference efficiency. To address this challenge, DeFT maintains
memory-efficient attention calculation with low memory footprints through two
key stages: (1) QKV Preparation: We propose a KV-Guided Grouping Strategy with
Tree Split to intelligently group QKV, optimizing GPU resource utilization
while minimizing memory reads/writes for KV cache between GPU global memory and
on-chip shared memory; (2)Attention Calculation: We compute partial attention
of each QKV group in a fused kernel and employ a Tree-topology-aware Global
Reduction strategy to obtain final attention. By reducing 73-99% KV cache IO
and nearly 100% IO for partial results during attention calculation (e.g.,
Softmax), DeFT achieves up to 2.52/3.82x speedup in the end-to-end/attention
latency across three practical tree-based workloads: namely, few-shot
prompting, multi-step reasoning, and speculative decoding, over
state-of-the-art attention algorithms.
|
[
0.0169457644,
-0.7955535054,
0.5052021742,
0.2056436837,
-0.4803085029,
0.1570771486,
0.2064973265,
-0.4152592123,
0.1422728449,
-0.0156584103,
-0.8056066036,
-0.3649718165,
-0.2473966628,
0.0172918197,
-0.5346884727,
0.7850680351,
0.1868773401,
-0.3316841125,
-0.2387837768,
0.0079690805,
-0.4189711213,
-0.2044780552,
-0.3983479142,
0.1883136481,
0.5892704725,
0.4782110155,
0.3666262627,
0.8553779721,
0.4428243637,
0.2710085213,
-0.234765619,
-0.0352542251,
-0.6766949296,
0.075116612,
0.2654328942,
-0.3791157603,
-0.7632265687,
-0.4188143611,
0.7379071712,
0.2362056226,
-0.0894056633,
0.2854939997,
0.0400627851,
0.7198643088,
-0.8999662995,
0.3350840509,
-0.7241555452,
0.1359500289,
-0.035031829,
-0.3960864544,
-0.6429626942,
-0.1697928458,
0.0641409755,
-0.8132161498,
0.4535470307,
-0.0028053392,
0.5324018598,
0.7055376768,
-0.3609254062,
0.4134007096,
-0.6375538707,
0.7140892148,
-0.4315216541,
0.5933108926,
0.5673324466,
0.1329127699,
0.0331726186,
-0.8728564978,
-0.2006518692,
0.1767835468,
-0.0147306398,
0.625262022,
-0.1449299455,
0.4880689979,
0.3735025823,
0.4567849636,
-0.4757204354,
-0.4078647196,
0.0355072357,
-0.065834783,
0.4923293293,
0.1065624356,
-0.0670950189,
-0.0416721627,
-0.3591103554,
0.0346948914,
-0.863063097,
0.0831156671,
-0.1107318625,
-0.0585522689,
0.0962927192,
0.1968313903,
-0.39282763,
0.5969287753,
0.1877852678,
-0.1947941035,
-0.258526057,
-0.6655269265,
-0.7265030742,
0.2655700445,
0.5520747304,
0.2221807837,
0.1320973784,
-0.1795712113,
-0.0945812613,
-0.0711308941,
0.1810363531,
-0.8007576466,
-0.4471446574,
0.3823693991,
-0.409537673,
-0.1208776608,
-0.2357198298,
-0.6445996761,
0.1120434478,
0.123245582,
0.2102313042,
-0.5855585337,
-0.3156200349,
0.0383508354,
-0.0282354653,
0.4749507606,
0.5808336735,
-1.0538549423,
0.3749447167,
0.7183510661,
0.8533579111,
0.1243001744,
0.0091510881,
-0.8305609226,
0.4522422254,
-0.0946191847,
0.7681939602,
-0.474761188,
-0.2296863049,
-0.4619803727,
-0.235186711,
-0.0520306639,
-0.1821504235,
0.4021967351,
-0.5473498106,
-0.1291146874,
-0.2157836258,
-0.3890025914,
-0.3627116084,
0.2048290521,
-0.5626205206,
1.1091274023,
0.2700336874,
-0.9715260863,
0.4431200027,
-0.5105674267,
-0.6071814299,
0.5177119374,
0.0336432718,
-0.4391048253,
0.3884643018,
0.1924561113,
0.3886021078,
-0.1436498761,
0.0605776981,
-0.2681754529,
-0.522521615,
-0.2385332733,
-0.4757860601,
0.6058661938,
0.151772365,
-0.2568122447,
0.4820976555,
-0.428468436,
0.2032773346,
0.1594142765,
-0.15617387,
-0.2757057548,
0.423849225,
-0.0159702655,
-0.2474190742,
-0.0363488868,
-0.4834688306,
0.3605464995,
-0.4823591113,
0.7389553189,
0.7580977678,
-0.1759862602,
0.1459600627,
0.0816899613,
0.4866653979,
-0.0703782737,
0.2494653463,
-0.703740418,
-0.4714703858,
-0.4759261608,
-0.440518409,
0.2999357283,
0.5135179162,
-0.6194438934,
0.2024598867,
-0.4232265949,
0.0475572832,
-0.6511816978,
-0.1657968163,
0.5879631639,
0.7406058908,
0.3220564723,
-0.2229490429,
-0.4412730336,
-0.8644819856,
0.1003976539,
-0.3606900871,
0.1396435052,
0.1761196107,
0.3497258723,
0.0892771184,
1.046664834,
-0.4254857898,
-0.1163085029,
-0.1902137995,
-0.2294436842,
-0.07208772,
0.1601613909,
0.1391198486,
-0.7349838018,
-0.7179506421,
0.1139112934,
-0.1615532488,
0.0527377762,
-0.1268108636,
0.0572991744,
0.3500639498,
0.2838549912,
-0.5756867528,
0.6982780695,
0.2700523734,
-0.3897383511,
0.5608158112,
-0.0892614052,
0.1541733444,
-0.9766605496,
0.1087499708,
-0.3168181479,
-0.6467656493,
-0.5043447018,
-0.0549977012,
0.2486656308,
0.5557032228,
-0.560715735,
0.2775642276,
-0.5498999953,
-0.4019240141,
-0.0269062072,
-0.2235623449,
0.0017474816,
0.63409096,
0.1945404708,
0.92628479,
0.4974364042,
-0.460658133,
0.2833903134,
0.1118849814,
-0.0083889542,
0.5096741319,
-0.6209387779,
0.3056785166,
0.0415634774,
0.3138087094,
-1.2694995403,
-0.2064009458,
0.1014558077,
-0.4959720373,
0.3527474999,
-0.3788139224,
-0.6705769897,
-0.2820805609,
-0.663921833,
0.8180243969,
0.6556918025,
-0.5087830424,
0.5496330857,
0.0728375167,
0.2631151378,
-0.5309081078,
-0.8408803344,
-0.1298062652,
-0.3625563681,
-0.710957706,
0.4277465045,
-0.0713236555,
-0.0270406958,
0.2238256037,
-0.6126987338,
-0.2336995602,
0.2822985351,
0.2707937956,
-0.0643590093,
-0.4842948616,
-0.1683316827,
0.0079221614,
-0.268312633,
-0.0420465842,
-0.5022868514,
0.2125557959,
-0.2296376675,
-0.3209443986,
-0.6923860908,
0.3305521905,
0.6143875122,
-0.2547132373,
0.2856316268,
0.5003736019,
-0.4113142788,
0.0417466201,
-0.4464213848,
-0.4044742286,
-0.46238482,
0.4116282165,
-0.610964179,
-1.0180268288,
0.3669824898,
0.0256445222,
0.0909085199,
0.3342730999,
0.5125294924,
-0.3556393087,
1.2231827974,
0.5140131116,
-0.1696385145,
0.5524465442,
-0.2767996788,
0.0599927902,
-0.9390415549,
-0.0688282326,
0.0454283133,
-0.5927398205,
-0.1506112516,
-0.2839867771,
0.3114950657,
0.2628025413,
-0.0951013267,
0.0422811843,
-0.7803354859,
0.8668310642,
0.6079847217,
-0.0039679077,
0.4754134119,
0.1324120462,
0.1373230666,
-0.0434948578,
-1.0595573187,
0.0508979857,
0.8870871663,
0.3593948781,
0.4994312227,
-0.0688232929,
0.6245447397,
0.2512551546,
0.3081725836,
-1.0588217974,
0.6747110486,
0.1532726139,
-0.2775111794,
-0.1531827301,
-0.4236667156,
-1.0870006084,
0.1621525437,
0.448195219,
-0.9049578905,
-0.1629447043,
0.4856178761,
-0.7557803392,
0.3709588945,
-1.0596652031,
0.952735126,
-0.0297752079,
-0.6475650668,
-0.5498227477,
-0.9139253497,
0.8144877553,
0.1135541648,
-0.1429217607,
0.1055846289,
-0.148552686,
0.5756897926,
-0.4720611274,
0.8227168918,
-0.1331535131,
0.1481567174,
0.5571116805,
0.1864826828,
0.4628915787,
0.2042395324,
0.4049325883,
-0.2136708796,
0.4370062351,
-0.4126940966,
-0.4081623256,
0.4270177186,
-0.566752553,
-0.5424501896,
-0.5333207846,
-0.7089585066,
-0.0110287247,
0.1608142853,
0.0144995395,
0.2829366624,
-0.1494208425,
0.2397670895,
0.8697071671,
0.2090530843,
0.7027083039,
0.4417425394,
-0.0186737794,
-0.5309428573,
0.8364341855,
-0.2236912996,
0.4230355322,
0.6951788664,
0.1761196107,
-0.3657139242,
-0.6892904639,
-0.3153854311,
0.1847842336,
-0.3743791878,
-0.6031208634,
-0.5259184837,
-0.2031048089,
-0.270416081,
0.0027832689,
-0.4134342372,
-0.3449989855,
-0.1225549281,
-0.0235573407,
0.87214607,
0.6515242457,
0.0410895348,
0.7965937257,
-0.8515169621,
0.5687766075,
0.2014485002,
0.4024711251,
0.0134701328,
-0.456828475,
-0.236016646,
-0.2126071304,
-0.2291471064,
-1.0907534361,
0.4199300706,
0.2852651775,
0.1837093085,
0.5128539801,
0.0296695009,
1.0282999277,
-0.3776768148,
0.2893336415,
0.0846479088,
-0.8803108335,
0.6913765669,
-0.2678819001,
0.6105467677,
0.4757816494,
0.0109176915,
-0.4958039224,
-0.16558218,
-0.8750423193,
-0.971883893,
1.4073671103,
0.2468047142,
-0.3294664919,
0.0272770282,
0.3158811033,
-0.1945840418,
-0.0508806296,
-0.6350544095,
-0.0376367234,
-0.1540646553,
-0.3528531194,
0.3694115877,
-0.4806285799,
-0.0468959361,
-0.5411245227,
0.3609818518,
-0.2536648512,
0.4227306843,
0.5851874948,
-0.2709138989,
-0.2752722204,
0.0418284722,
0.5531760454,
0.1547930241,
-0.5235275626,
0.3938685358,
0.3561550379,
-0.9179673195,
-0.0031404318,
0.0009876922,
-0.2838535905,
-0.3710958958,
0.3782736063,
0.6545989513,
0.223427549,
-0.5220950842,
0.2434571534,
-0.37069574,
-0.3493066132,
0.1426117718,
0.0765330717,
0.2179408818,
0.2454406172,
0.3993228674,
-0.2350943089,
0.1310323924,
-0.1860461682,
0.3278787732,
0.5471996069,
-0.1297586113,
-0.6549742222,
0.7003208995,
0.2635762691,
-0.2850567102,
0.7027275562,
-0.3127459288,
-0.5748148561,
0.751003623,
0.4470256865,
1.3300718069,
-0.4438446462,
-0.1587636918,
0.4172262549,
0.3009110689,
0.0207986943,
0.4831528962,
-0.7753759027,
-0.3043812811,
-0.8757339716,
-0.5387940407,
-0.1544245183,
0.239191696,
-0.2902990282,
0.0620670691,
-0.631912291,
0.1783119142,
-0.48131603,
0.0502685681,
-0.3298477232,
0.1520899534,
0.0500553846,
0.8150520921,
-0.4866891503,
1.2151975632,
0.3814536035,
0.049135346,
-0.6142014861,
0.0829082131,
0.0452295952,
-0.7221138477,
0.4271500409,
0.4849755764,
-0.2962086499,
0.6115151048,
-0.379922539,
-1.023903966,
1.400016427,
0.3135181665,
-0.7377327681,
0.1523924172,
-0.1397916675,
0.1864143163,
-0.0732545778,
0.6700387001,
0.6660327911,
0.3748374581,
0.445401907,
-0.7515915632,
0.0504732393,
-0.0988036394,
-0.2767260373,
0.3445958793,
-0.8208827376,
0.264269799,
-0.4065198898,
-0.5831281543,
-0.2673417628,
0.9486893415,
0.2442216277,
0.4149563313,
0.5696686506,
0.7015550733,
0.6460624337,
-0.1669134498,
1.1398794651,
-0.4905364215,
0.1683723032,
0.9839091897,
0.0346465521,
0.8098043203,
0.4232598543,
-0.4356827438,
-0.1326460093,
1.0292252302,
0.3911492527,
0.8091714382,
-0.121013619,
-0.4459085464,
-0.2135861367,
0.0575602762,
-0.3041779101,
0.0964879096,
0.5283014774,
0.0050435686,
-0.1997772455,
-0.5170747638,
-0.3451169431,
-0.5391052365,
-0.4347456992,
0.8628435731,
-0.0076731686,
-0.6359037161,
0.71802634,
-0.1436874568,
0.5833778381,
-0.7296134233,
-0.0342305042,
-0.3376823068,
0.2147428542,
-0.4545793831,
-0.7987995148,
0.5874813199,
-0.0175627694,
-0.3038989604,
-0.5499715209,
0.7995451093,
-0.410130024,
-0.3092927337,
0.041265212,
0.2483059317,
0.3241943121,
-0.3581264019,
-0.6611936092,
0.1750411838,
0.2819714546,
-0.5412908792,
0.2676589787,
0.586247921,
-0.1378713548,
0.6646649837,
0.5506898761,
-0.2671999931,
0.1759223938,
0.0087863766,
0.7386820912,
-0.7821201086,
-0.501809001,
-1.1084427834,
0.6074993014,
0.3255826831,
-0.1361584216,
0.5869501233,
0.7784215808,
0.401843667,
0.1288262606,
0.5653206706,
0.0153886285,
-0.1150240451,
-0.4387389719,
0.3147485256,
-0.5822580457,
0.1772372425,
-0.0248657744,
-0.9035824537,
-0.2757337689,
0.6158870459,
-0.1267077029,
0.1004017591,
0.8691879511,
0.5179114938,
-0.4179311097,
-0.0128623471,
0.3177558184,
0.3400320411,
0.2542713583,
1.1942979097,
0.6718834639,
-0.24594827,
0.6924074292,
-0.1261176914,
-0.2557789981,
-0.2838673592,
-0.9573274851,
-0.4777147472,
-0.4598544836,
-0.6294712424,
-0.0922645628,
0.0999534056,
0.504236877,
0.8690050244,
-0.5385953188,
-0.0115658436,
-0.6163212061,
0.3242492676,
-0.2491679043,
-0.2559785545,
0.5727698803,
-0.2146162242,
-0.58169204,
0.4683014154,
0.7893331051,
-0.0244645588,
-0.2824599147,
-0.1654456407,
-0.2217465937,
-0.220431447,
0.7735128403,
0.4073684216,
-0.9022655487,
-0.0818960443,
0.1387345344,
-0.0537345447,
0.4527066648,
0.7263162732,
-1.2129991055,
0.3915404379,
0.6663922668,
0.7327880859,
0.9019394517,
0.2783136368,
0.348328948,
-0.9485554099,
0.1135606766,
0.5209627151,
0.1532951593,
0.1879362613,
-0.4693766534,
0.5834712386,
0.624014914,
-0.502992928,
-0.9531285763,
0.2990010977,
-1.2692142725,
-0.1876285672,
1.1717678308,
0.0435396545,
-0.8390479088,
-0.1012712792,
-0.2746144235,
0.1583204418,
-0.4515524805,
0.4991092384,
0.6319956183,
-0.4171909392,
-0.679590404,
-0.6055933833,
0.751625061,
0.7285999656,
-0.7138597369,
0.5131127238,
0.4894647896,
0.1290355921,
-0.2912933528,
0.9368874431,
0.2282588184,
0.5858394504,
0.044793997,
-0.0559137799,
-0.0901730284,
-0.4757977724,
-0.3245998621,
0.0512539558,
0.004019361,
-0.361621052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00236v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00236v1
|
Enhancing Content-based Recommendation via Large Language Model
| 2024-03-30T03:56:53 | 2024-03-30T03:56:53 |
Wentao Xu, Qianqian Xie, Shuo Yang, Jiangxia Cao, Shuchao Pang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
In real-world applications, users express different behaviors when they
interact with different items, including implicit click/like interactions, and
explicit comments/reviews interactions. Nevertheless, almost all recommender
works are focused on how to describe user preferences by the implicit
click/like interactions, to find the synergy of people. For the content-based
explicit comments/reviews interactions, some works attempt to utilize them to
mine the semantic knowledge to enhance recommender models. However, they still
neglect the following two points: (1) The content semantic is a universal world
knowledge; how do we extract the multi-aspect semantic information to empower
different domains? (2) The user/item ID feature is a fundamental element for
recommender models; how do we align the ID and content semantic feature space?
In this paper, we propose a `plugin' semantic knowledge transferring method
\textbf{LoID}, which includes two major components: (1) LoRA-based large
language model pretraining to extract multi-aspect semantic information; (2)
ID-based contrastive objective to align their feature spaces. We conduct
extensive experiments with SOTA baselines on real-world datasets, the detailed
results demonstrating significant improvements of our method LoID.
|
[
-0.5102985501,
-0.6782175303,
0.7106254101,
0.0299502816,
-0.3605950475,
-0.2343355715,
-0.2073930055,
-0.5434945822,
0.4749322534,
0.6482290626,
-0.7288581133,
-0.7123152614,
-0.3450018167,
-0.3692936301,
-0.2888454795,
1.416593194,
0.008106241,
-0.0815885589,
-0.3231222034,
-0.1043842286,
-0.5571190119,
-0.2852367759,
-0.4203106165,
-0.4038657248,
0.843619585,
0.4580227435,
0.4957011938,
0.2168657482,
0.6134851575,
0.2308010608,
-0.0628966317,
0.3356531858,
-0.6077803373,
0.0294299852,
-0.6758081913,
-0.1103121042,
-0.6271096468,
-0.300947547,
0.3347179294,
0.6699294448,
0.2167870253,
-0.1439357698,
0.2141743004,
0.6081743836,
-0.598654449,
0.1316200644,
-0.3817438781,
-0.1621366888,
0.0199679229,
-0.0167884324,
-0.1746528,
-0.3313549459,
0.7462367415,
-0.9283539057,
-0.0396700129,
0.2230570465,
0.824215591,
-0.0331833884,
-0.539439261,
-0.2046892494,
-0.8351001143,
0.8608147502,
-0.6375622749,
0.1244775876,
0.5113416314,
-0.0870459452,
-0.0796266198,
-0.3162558377,
-0.67721349,
-0.0736040398,
-0.1198214516,
-0.0747910738,
0.1803570092,
-0.1031693965,
0.2085992396,
0.3582018018,
-0.2703939378,
0.1386304051,
-0.1854024231,
0.0040604039,
0.6737360954,
-0.1739852726,
0.4350821972,
-0.1253827661,
-0.5889812708,
-0.2273325473,
-0.7273440361,
0.0014020782,
0.2555752695,
0.2460509837,
-0.1532719582,
0.6066784263,
-0.3639371097,
0.399772495,
0.146078676,
-0.04956856,
0.4709807336,
-0.750513196,
0.0830475762,
-0.0695507973,
0.7037967443,
0.6540511847,
0.2833569348,
-0.0350999758,
-0.0230655856,
-0.1207681522,
0.2190060169,
-0.9683305621,
-0.1811617911,
0.0388512127,
-0.2791174948,
-0.2897651494,
0.4246239066,
-0.6636765003,
-0.6133230925,
-0.3419622481,
0.6568894982,
-0.6340265274,
-0.2775972784,
0.1376219392,
0.049517516,
0.0074570267,
0.4241897762,
-0.8942571878,
0.2826312184,
0.7192730904,
0.5114296675,
-0.4742160439,
-0.4219932556,
-0.5559611917,
0.2842547596,
0.0866896063,
1.2541871071,
-0.6278312802,
-0.2553451955,
0.2292792052,
0.1407946795,
0.2311448455,
-0.3650877774,
0.5120099187,
-0.6626509428,
0.135536015,
-0.5414975286,
-0.4838014543,
-0.4194394946,
0.3562475145,
-0.6364230514,
0.8474761248,
0.1369430572,
-0.8274791837,
0.3884876072,
-0.7820331454,
-0.5406560898,
-0.1880407929,
0.229559958,
-0.273393929,
0.0206489116,
0.3769458532,
0.2882934809,
-0.2306372374,
0.2449101508,
-0.5525560379,
-0.3396885991,
0.328887701,
0.0609288141,
0.2975179851,
0.1375273615,
-0.0146726025,
0.5437735319,
-0.4845962524,
-0.1451713145,
-0.0180295259,
-0.092012763,
-0.7375730276,
-0.2111720741,
0.20569022,
0.1694618016,
0.3910911083,
-0.596137166,
0.3322539032,
-0.5786269307,
0.1855190396,
0.6299655437,
0.2365005463,
0.7603250146,
-0.4080886245,
0.1168467999,
0.3195500374,
0.0087738745,
-0.1723725796,
-0.1879920363,
-0.6574400663,
-0.126301825,
0.4995798767,
0.2467503995,
-0.7350376248,
0.9837188721,
-0.4447244108,
-0.3288815916,
-0.328022927,
0.4380408227,
0.220676899,
0.1007147357,
0.3250498772,
-0.5556132197,
-0.3989682496,
-0.533875525,
0.0126619451,
-0.0327489823,
-0.0021935366,
0.5077572465,
0.1862048805,
-0.4507742822,
0.7658314109,
-0.7734244466,
-0.7181158066,
-0.428946048,
-0.0590541735,
0.1725874543,
0.4500913918,
0.2149524242,
-0.6035152674,
-0.5285189152,
0.0787818655,
-0.4675779045,
-0.0542024896,
0.2365713865,
-0.5883703232,
-0.175018236,
0.3527702689,
-0.5085934401,
0.3191546798,
0.3889021575,
-0.5283818841,
0.2412884235,
-0.2597216666,
0.3071929514,
-1.2674239874,
-0.0080845328,
0.1378323734,
-0.0990965888,
-0.2888768613,
-0.0142960055,
-0.1541924626,
-0.0227428246,
-0.4190927744,
0.7890939713,
-0.0273520146,
0.1209421754,
-0.4942017198,
0.5494573712,
0.3241665065,
0.6064709425,
0.0477338545,
0.3385976553,
0.5087114573,
-0.6051770449,
0.3844261169,
0.3686666787,
-0.467881918,
0.9071149826,
-0.5740702748,
0.1758529097,
0.0617594123,
0.3505402505,
-1.0252683163,
0.0413706303,
-0.0200036857,
-0.0038122165,
-0.0909340233,
-0.2328777313,
-0.3873441815,
0.1266052723,
-0.5315368772,
0.5710811019,
0.2638142407,
-0.5855474472,
0.72345227,
0.3718881309,
-0.4035646319,
-0.4453446269,
0.0122219957,
-0.258130759,
-0.0718804002,
-0.5545686483,
0.7100018859,
-0.4352577031,
-0.0986614674,
0.2979324162,
0.0567768924,
-0.0372462794,
-0.049329482,
0.4688611031,
0.5855442286,
-0.181774646,
0.4126902223,
0.052403044,
-0.2122183293,
-0.2305669636,
-0.5896304846,
0.6020029187,
0.0618444495,
-0.5016297102,
-0.3979851007,
0.345834434,
0.4456843138,
-0.4597508311,
0.6377126575,
0.9251337647,
-0.0657496154,
-0.174219206,
-0.6902902722,
-0.3559116721,
-0.3862216771,
0.6357273459,
-0.3428827524,
-0.9312157631,
0.2362586409,
-0.294375062,
0.0705109537,
0.4651860893,
0.3435371816,
-0.2244684249,
0.8471127748,
0.8028736711,
-0.3472951055,
0.8034793735,
-0.3943576217,
0.4245419502,
-1.1386826038,
-0.0703565776,
-0.3221785724,
-0.4678075016,
-0.1502130032,
-0.1999407411,
0.1771078259,
0.1716427356,
-0.0941130593,
0.3425146043,
-0.1335455328,
0.4079692364,
0.567666173,
0.3314896822,
0.4416676164,
0.1150907949,
-0.1792235225,
-0.0533765294,
-0.3281139135,
-0.0994815081,
1.053204298,
0.1564010233,
0.9621199369,
0.2621146739,
0.3679125309,
0.4212938845,
0.011660778,
-0.9171987772,
0.4172435999,
-0.3288986981,
-0.2274726182,
-0.404700011,
-0.0513525382,
-0.7938526869,
-0.0709467903,
-0.7140942216,
-0.5852326155,
0.2425036281,
-0.1641495973,
-0.4953427315,
0.1525451988,
-0.5836400986,
0.7743061185,
-0.167244792,
-0.5454279184,
-0.5794246197,
-0.2538829446,
0.0601674989,
-0.1519910544,
0.1012133658,
-0.1656127423,
0.248224318,
0.7446321249,
-0.4048319757,
0.6863570809,
-0.2253006101,
-0.2823059857,
0.2063729465,
0.1501626223,
0.6713526249,
0.0798873454,
0.0028527859,
0.1284495592,
0.0384034552,
-0.0915975869,
-0.8817915916,
1.1693217754,
-0.8273870349,
-0.5991333127,
-0.031979382,
-0.7407407165,
-0.2195333987,
0.339822948,
-0.0641185269,
0.4739488363,
-0.2346532345,
0.2529574633,
0.8627372384,
-0.0204846729,
0.0646215156,
0.6353700161,
-0.4934736788,
-0.384537071,
1.0703337193,
-0.0087453295,
0.0204888359,
0.4463033378,
0.2835316062,
-0.3230967522,
-0.3667494953,
-0.2024639249,
0.5391207337,
-0.605425179,
-0.0532858372,
-0.8950452209,
-0.2710407376,
-0.382045269,
-0.1155074164,
-0.2156810611,
-0.0871544778,
-0.1029880568,
-0.1351321191,
0.5317670703,
0.7194991708,
0.4091742933,
0.2646473348,
-0.6109531522,
0.3200608492,
0.4996859133,
0.6715855002,
0.0641228184,
-0.5917528272,
-0.5694347024,
-0.1955087483,
-0.1319574118,
-0.3225484788,
0.1124094874,
0.0929824486,
0.3514589071,
0.7217262983,
0.4148393273,
0.5603528023,
-0.3205978572,
0.5514787436,
0.069675833,
-0.7326173186,
0.4205089211,
-0.1411616057,
0.2859296203,
0.6308885217,
0.3721696734,
-0.4232134521,
-0.0087344563,
-0.5095610023,
-0.7367685437,
0.5282674432,
-0.1698091775,
0.2476186454,
0.3353822231,
0.1336226016,
0.2578778267,
-0.0246906523,
-0.6034010053,
0.1026372537,
-0.0724891126,
-0.4338680506,
-0.057444673,
-0.5045244694,
-0.199859634,
-0.0566120669,
0.9595914483,
-0.2513469458,
-0.0804052725,
0.1293074787,
-0.2440069914,
-0.0243822318,
0.4192868471,
0.309884131,
0.7125368118,
-0.2655649483,
-0.0165151432,
0.0815383345,
-0.3176464438,
0.0288898088,
0.0539855026,
-0.1434327662,
-0.3999268413,
0.048374705,
0.83344841,
0.3798751235,
-0.5937857032,
0.8817107677,
-0.1530306339,
-0.0035510559,
-0.3222728968,
0.2707679272,
0.0944786072,
0.2892110348,
-0.0930749848,
0.0885517076,
0.1792458296,
-0.6483469009,
0.017571589,
0.520699203,
-0.9374371767,
-0.3375275433,
0.0191809833,
0.6006458998,
-0.1277493834,
0.4601511061,
0.0948074311,
-0.2738247812,
-0.0136902314,
0.6530029774,
0.7745068669,
0.1650494933,
0.0260011218,
0.281448245,
-0.2292575538,
0.0308000352,
0.0499273688,
-0.3069961667,
-1.0434299707,
-0.5427107811,
-0.578255415,
-0.2484620959,
0.0315810479,
-0.4933382571,
0.5485522747,
-0.463165462,
-0.0972479507,
0.0718307942,
0.1850634515,
-0.7072252035,
-0.0107704531,
-0.059815079,
0.5763418078,
-0.8122618198,
1.0016103983,
0.8280938864,
-0.4400389493,
-0.5448724627,
0.1288876981,
-0.2206539512,
-0.4605909586,
0.4454692304,
0.0055292971,
-0.2798601091,
-0.0391563624,
-0.4100265801,
-0.7816077471,
0.8703625798,
-0.0146438619,
-0.3792111278,
0.1535133868,
-0.3616605997,
0.6423160434,
-0.7687312961,
0.3645804524,
0.2358868122,
0.4339161515,
0.3755169213,
-0.7147737145,
0.1427124143,
-0.3799234033,
0.0092585171,
0.0147796907,
-0.3910080194,
0.4651511312,
-0.3163740039,
0.0777314082,
0.1021711081,
0.7206214666,
0.2049515545,
0.1298212856,
0.7863940001,
0.575148046,
0.470605433,
0.2589480877,
0.9717425704,
-0.3395740688,
0.1040134504,
1.0898419619,
-0.7918260694,
1.0285065174,
0.3519625366,
-0.0036952198,
1.0257982016,
0.3317471743,
-0.0909955278,
0.5794431567,
-0.0293941349,
-0.3160111308,
-0.1903359741,
-0.7045443654,
-0.2561302185,
0.2703463733,
0.2750650644,
-0.2063041329,
0.1718223691,
0.0789929405,
-0.0273751821,
0.0739925578,
-0.1331672966,
1.4651210308,
-0.0940981656,
-0.876643002,
0.1894286126,
0.0483539477,
0.8493754268,
-0.7835032344,
-0.3148054481,
-0.1315203309,
0.1059699729,
-0.3321707845,
-0.8184540272,
-0.1157172099,
-0.1793606281,
-0.6638939381,
0.2045465112,
0.9209363461,
-0.5961956382,
-0.4221172035,
0.348167479,
0.3251460791,
-0.045009613,
-0.2292220592,
-0.2669475675,
-0.1444149613,
0.0165761169,
0.302066505,
0.4690883458,
0.4437302053,
-0.1722147614,
0.5810543299,
0.8929595947,
0.3102183938,
-0.546013236,
0.4011829793,
0.8911924958,
-0.7029328346,
-0.8442927003,
-0.608825326,
0.3570447266,
-0.1839896291,
-0.0260035079,
0.5519150496,
0.2444199026,
0.863286674,
-0.0475471541,
0.7440482974,
0.0358388573,
0.6013720036,
-0.5296748877,
0.5734708309,
-0.3420192897,
0.5973036289,
-0.3812851906,
-1.5209146738,
-0.0460274965,
0.2510211766,
-0.5223492384,
0.0842712596,
0.9028127789,
0.801291585,
-0.2059434503,
-0.1774292737,
0.3242725432,
0.3135667145,
0.1629882306,
0.404836148,
0.6518403888,
-0.3734918535,
0.4910640717,
-0.0622677021,
-0.1817278713,
-0.3904536664,
-0.6570668221,
-0.8892850876,
-0.6069760323,
-0.46077618,
-0.5475765467,
-0.0051050493,
1.0971915722,
0.8809701204,
-0.9692534208,
-0.1757336259,
0.3841288686,
0.443542093,
-0.252078861,
-0.1878861189,
0.6820875406,
-0.0798622221,
-0.6844141483,
0.2251237184,
0.3856781721,
-0.1902481467,
-0.5445764661,
-0.133551687,
-0.2528936267,
0.0329635255,
0.6181420088,
-0.029166922,
-0.6411668062,
-0.3577616811,
-0.2878699899,
-0.0814578608,
-0.0118382126,
0.8057523966,
-0.7865571976,
0.4715023935,
0.6011582613,
0.5234134197,
0.4456444979,
0.2488828152,
0.6686441302,
-0.5595090389,
0.0535749681,
-0.3909564018,
0.2831957042,
0.3723938167,
-0.3750618696,
0.2341939807,
0.2133081704,
-0.4663471878,
-0.2464000583,
0.213752985,
-1.10090065,
-0.1321793497,
1.1898801327,
-0.42495206,
-0.2664411366,
-0.1592358649,
-0.5733473897,
-0.1115150303,
-0.6343245506,
0.7299765348,
0.4992517531,
0.2562160492,
0.0698511451,
-0.1683267802,
0.4322190583,
0.3349505663,
-0.7350587845,
-0.103193827,
0.3968715668,
0.4521333277,
0.1486514956,
0.3364984393,
-0.1755932868,
0.1477461159,
-0.3824334145,
0.283157438,
-0.022426337,
-0.4787721336,
-0.2251757383,
0.1704434901,
0.3321993649,
0.1302897781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00227v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00227v1
|
A Survey of using Large Language Models for Generating Infrastructure as Code
| 2024-03-30T02:57:55 | 2024-03-30T02:57:55 |
Kalahasti Ganesh Srivatsa, Sabyasachi Mukhopadhyay, Ganesh Katrapati, Manish Shrivastava
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Infrastructure as Code (IaC) is a revolutionary approach which has gained
significant prominence in the Industry. IaC manages and provisions IT
infrastructure using machine-readable code by enabling automation, consistency
across the environments, reproducibility, version control, error reduction and
enhancement in scalability. However, IaC orchestration is often a painstaking
effort which requires specialised skills as well as a lot of manual effort.
Automation of IaC is a necessity in the present conditions of the Industry and
in this survey, we study the feasibility of applying Large Language Models
(LLM) to address this problem. LLMs are large neural network-based models which
have demonstrated significant language processing abilities and shown to be
capable of following a range of instructions within a broad scope. Recently,
they have also been adapted for code understanding and generation tasks
successfully, which makes them a promising choice for the automatic generation
of IaC configurations. In this survey, we delve into the details of IaC, usage
of IaC in different platforms, their challenges, LLMs in terms of
code-generation aspects and the importance of LLMs in IaC along with our own
experiments. Finally, we conclude by presenting the challenges in this area and
highlighting the scope for future research.
|
[
-0.6799794436,
-0.4988405704,
0.4534270763,
0.4234788418,
-0.0206346978,
-0.0939685702,
-0.2748207748,
-0.4772093892,
0.1196981892,
0.6415468454,
-0.3027478755,
-0.5015793443,
-0.3403578997,
0.4768036604,
-0.8565238714,
0.8815431595,
-0.1665130556,
0.0275241937,
-0.1934457272,
-0.2677476406,
-0.5562384129,
-0.8485504985,
-0.560929358,
-0.2050295025,
0.302084595,
0.4668358564,
0.4085484445,
0.6832135916,
0.7080415487,
0.4037503004,
-0.0798195601,
0.1365421116,
-0.0202024784,
-0.0502059944,
-0.0467493832,
-0.3844036758,
-0.5608537793,
-0.2748010457,
0.7161381841,
0.7057459354,
-0.2864443362,
0.3099849522,
-0.0657112673,
0.7476840019,
-0.612907052,
0.3663149774,
-0.9071654081,
-0.1658056974,
-0.0269073527,
-0.0161078684,
-0.3324249387,
0.0205494948,
-0.2974963486,
-0.0655701235,
-0.4061353803,
0.233718127,
0.6819796562,
0.229152739,
-0.6007704139,
-0.8222317696,
-0.8092963696,
0.6426627636,
-0.8172641397,
0.1704560518,
0.2539551258,
0.2488837987,
-0.1452416033,
-0.8837407827,
-0.5369873643,
-0.5922621489,
0.1717696339,
-0.1650007218,
-0.0408113673,
-0.1292452663,
0.2366613448,
0.3855745494,
-0.3000469804,
0.6582034826,
-0.5750575662,
0.0057282611,
0.4705711603,
0.439253509,
0.4798060656,
-0.2202255577,
-0.1809816062,
0.2426559478,
-1.1190361977,
-0.2431792319,
0.4855603576,
0.0791788325,
-0.1574466974,
0.6237120628,
-0.0393921994,
0.5360995531,
-0.5636712909,
0.2205054015,
-0.0597085319,
-0.1264784187,
-0.2606213391,
-0.162754938,
0.6464812756,
0.0268559679,
0.5200518966,
-0.1569329053,
-0.5246480703,
0.1822103858,
0.7584596872,
-0.5632261038,
-0.161525771,
0.4466391504,
-0.5840448737,
-0.3401248455,
-0.1122350991,
-0.522849679,
-0.0372297354,
-0.6702301502,
-0.1017440334,
0.0453315862,
-0.3949575424,
-0.018259,
0.3440813124,
0.5804485083,
0.094947584,
-0.7343533635,
0.2277934551,
0.7955331206,
1.0330388546,
-0.177174136,
-0.2764758766,
-0.2340726107,
0.0993207768,
-0.4918916523,
0.6675773263,
0.044201605,
-0.5554224849,
0.3208094835,
-0.0871397108,
0.3387601376,
-0.4977217913,
0.1146930307,
-0.7701955438,
-0.3818262517,
0.3679392636,
-0.3764323592,
0.2977097034,
0.3229106963,
-0.7541226745,
0.4481103718,
-0.0611119196,
-0.5853553414,
-0.0355677605,
-0.9295547009,
-0.5123445392,
0.0532757901,
-0.3671967685,
-0.4856318533,
0.1862372607,
0.0889305845,
0.4125708342,
-0.5623911619,
0.508870244,
-0.2862671018,
-0.1605349034,
0.5421316624,
-0.3475616574,
0.6315333843,
0.5433998108,
-0.5944190025,
0.0652898178,
-0.685955286,
-0.0871008858,
-0.0866429582,
-0.5604385734,
0.0689480528,
0.2247876674,
0.3464797735,
0.3294802904,
0.179549858,
-0.2500942647,
0.3483016193,
-0.3444822729,
0.8751823306,
0.9706249237,
-0.2710431218,
0.4470355213,
-0.0761363655,
0.5569823384,
-0.0081263017,
0.0185526721,
-0.2233709246,
-0.3400490284,
-0.9060816765,
-0.11968714,
0.4686360359,
0.4469985068,
-0.7743608952,
0.335603416,
-0.3930042982,
-0.4760718942,
-0.2729358971,
0.1731572151,
0.2232346386,
0.0742210671,
-0.074338831,
-0.0984954983,
-0.753698051,
-1.1577978134,
0.2424432784,
-0.2891406715,
0.0203290675,
0.5681010485,
0.8548125625,
-0.5543541312,
0.7712609768,
-0.4807974398,
-0.1217043325,
-0.2390210927,
0.0242184699,
0.166212067,
0.5749545097,
0.3722116649,
-0.8964256644,
-0.1779606938,
0.1873609722,
-0.891903758,
-0.1129762754,
0.0561691448,
0.0372984894,
0.62607342,
0.9502182007,
-0.5022225976,
0.3579083681,
0.8140100837,
0.0167612992,
0.7468966842,
-0.2764172852,
0.1871109009,
-1.2383105755,
0.5724207759,
-0.3239717484,
-0.0834703669,
-0.4184595644,
0.6279945374,
-0.0139676575,
-0.4950982928,
-0.4455763102,
0.3972794414,
-0.7198777199,
-0.3632950485,
-0.4874170721,
-0.1375101805,
-0.2528087199,
0.3911771774,
-0.0409468673,
1.0027161837,
0.7082005739,
-0.8553060293,
0.23702842,
0.2692135274,
-0.8374617696,
0.2340035141,
-0.7112817168,
0.350579679,
-0.022469312,
0.3341449499,
-0.6770174503,
-0.228422001,
-0.2040690929,
-0.1082902253,
0.0183057282,
-0.0682797804,
-0.8181458116,
-0.3728735745,
0.3408081532,
0.4599070251,
0.6879482269,
-0.6117259264,
0.5413728952,
0.5961475372,
-0.1487582773,
-0.3829952478,
-1.076608181,
0.6291493773,
-0.4270661771,
-0.7099384665,
0.0246873032,
-0.1664877385,
-0.5517935157,
-0.3509854972,
0.2281373441,
-0.1322703809,
0.3086315989,
0.6637208462,
0.2024019957,
-0.4432783425,
0.1192900911,
-0.4144823253,
-0.0533840619,
0.2686882317,
-0.5241995454,
0.5431056023,
-0.2640916109,
-0.5399471521,
-0.3332285285,
0.8693495393,
0.9619358182,
-0.458121717,
0.964412868,
0.140686512,
-0.2329506129,
-0.391443342,
-0.6267036796,
-0.0367311575,
-0.4902335703,
0.4223699272,
-0.3551528752,
-0.9722086191,
0.8205473423,
-0.5246781111,
0.3515575528,
0.2085757703,
0.7459636331,
-0.1361317039,
0.9798521996,
0.7299044728,
-0.334952116,
0.3072267473,
-0.3752084672,
0.4101332724,
-0.5480291247,
-0.0306553468,
-0.9501515627,
-0.2652550936,
-0.6557013392,
-0.1356159151,
0.5925510526,
-0.0892541707,
-0.3367867172,
0.2482308447,
-0.2651375234,
0.1538169384,
0.1394162923,
-0.1230497956,
0.3155699074,
0.0412149951,
0.2162127495,
0.4681822062,
-0.6806792617,
-0.6500355601,
1.070520997,
0.5501807928,
0.5570829511,
0.3413744569,
0.3803983927,
0.3546129167,
0.5233036876,
-0.6325929761,
0.5265935659,
-0.1466979533,
-0.6623802185,
-0.2096077204,
-0.536293149,
-0.9000133872,
-0.3376648724,
0.0456189588,
-0.6491942406,
0.0302683562,
0.1583639681,
-0.02183537,
0.452239424,
-0.5717374086,
0.5132995844,
-0.2197733968,
0.0865255669,
-0.3424826562,
-0.3376660347,
0.3068616688,
-0.2245121449,
0.5286750793,
0.3746226728,
-0.1397348195,
0.3632357717,
-0.6068532467,
0.5656678677,
0.2230837494,
-0.3842295408,
0.6778193712,
-0.0319937877,
0.8588435054,
0.0655277967,
-0.3236124218,
0.4282473624,
-0.457696408,
-0.3511315882,
-0.3950741887,
0.9966062307,
-0.8328768611,
-0.5940273404,
0.0206687395,
-0.5936667323,
-0.091164358,
-0.1404779851,
0.0805913433,
0.7707214355,
-0.0424888842,
0.4459377527,
0.5179003477,
-0.1669537574,
0.8640936613,
0.4521977305,
-0.234505713,
-0.3710334003,
0.6519522071,
0.0664040893,
0.2434561104,
0.1121736318,
-0.3740908504,
-0.0222211014,
-0.9567314982,
-0.5955421329,
-0.0908549353,
-0.5987490416,
-0.3377390802,
-0.7874476314,
-0.3724017143,
-0.2920453548,
-0.3980464041,
-0.3670437932,
-0.0391303003,
-0.3127512336,
0.0332848318,
0.2596492767,
1.0552675724,
0.2113380283,
0.4216533899,
-0.5840698481,
0.1962156594,
0.1780819595,
0.6195732951,
0.0792953745,
-0.1596164107,
-0.5451965332,
-0.1172235534,
-0.0116991773,
-0.7261042595,
0.4116229415,
-0.1213030964,
0.2431352139,
-0.0384047441,
-0.2406045049,
0.41653198,
-0.6157220006,
0.78245157,
0.0170727801,
-0.8731253147,
0.3586987257,
-0.3825087845,
0.3842385411,
0.4492592216,
0.2294171602,
-0.2602655888,
-0.267891258,
-0.5348345637,
-1.0429971218,
0.385666281,
0.272261411,
0.2547523081,
0.0502868593,
0.3971321583,
-0.3304694891,
0.4087602198,
-0.8418818116,
-0.0814772695,
0.0795566067,
0.0848440975,
-0.0215633661,
-0.1514511257,
0.0045427918,
0.3651582003,
0.6419988871,
-0.2883220613,
0.1288886666,
-0.0661044419,
-0.0791179314,
0.0927812532,
0.4896834493,
0.4420463741,
0.8691449761,
0.2797779441,
-0.0941191316,
0.2548112869,
-0.1320896,
0.1052772701,
-0.4879082441,
-0.0312724076,
-0.267270565,
0.3120494783,
0.6485291719,
-0.0358720087,
-0.9659312367,
0.4722986221,
-0.0074912966,
-0.22284545,
-0.8229894042,
-0.0689967498,
0.309330672,
0.1708826423,
0.2037864774,
-0.0160950813,
0.0057544978,
-0.5527637601,
0.0781208053,
0.6391700506,
-0.2574775517,
0.1673125029,
0.430588603,
0.3573629856,
-0.5157477856,
1.0706495047,
0.0779472291,
-0.1779272407,
1.0756407976,
0.5478659272,
0.7568463087,
0.2414755225,
-0.2443563491,
0.0794484094,
0.3967217505,
-0.0150539605,
0.1854097992,
0.0862291008,
-0.4333068132,
-0.6765598655,
-0.8460427523,
-0.0900733396,
0.3772689402,
-0.3321181834,
0.4938381016,
-0.660866797,
-0.0735572428,
-0.3367534578,
-0.3685530126,
-0.7034579515,
0.0118315453,
0.3159509897,
1.1974943876,
-0.8665451407,
0.7987394929,
0.9570689201,
-0.3085087836,
-1.3002824783,
-0.2660811543,
-0.3094342053,
-0.4249102771,
0.6787847877,
-0.0741370618,
0.1210780293,
0.0990812182,
-0.6532242298,
-0.5898523331,
1.0887522697,
0.2046127319,
-0.6711627841,
-0.1619441062,
0.3183150887,
0.6264681816,
-0.7499732971,
0.2906610668,
0.3664961159,
0.4615681767,
-0.1445394009,
-0.9356154203,
-0.2641157806,
-0.4633494616,
0.3290394843,
0.1498168856,
-0.6546427011,
0.8819307089,
0.0950141996,
-0.0029992121,
0.3197746277,
0.7902114391,
0.3858060539,
0.0609307624,
0.5988465548,
0.170816958,
0.1247666255,
0.2723524868,
1.0935475826,
-0.6209431291,
0.0363693126,
0.7582315207,
-0.1368880719,
0.7761095762,
0.5894585252,
-0.1139132529,
0.7008634806,
0.3434852958,
-0.0092253108,
-0.0615716465,
0.647597909,
-0.1056070626,
-0.1713275909,
-0.1544873565,
-0.3423611522,
0.8119057417,
0.333224088,
-0.3974226117,
0.0855927989,
0.054890696,
-0.075266771,
0.1178771406,
-0.7090203166,
0.9336457849,
0.4414577782,
-0.8267505765,
0.4489053488,
0.2334736437,
0.6603915691,
-0.6352350116,
-0.0870179832,
-0.1764374375,
0.0327275209,
-0.2458126992,
-0.5671458244,
0.4569441974,
0.2524165809,
-0.302569896,
-0.3348456323,
0.4826945066,
-0.0697613657,
-0.3935676217,
0.139269352,
0.2645744979,
0.1996416748,
-0.1245952249,
-0.3289375305,
0.2335401922,
0.0106778806,
0.0495916456,
0.5432696939,
0.3557456434,
-0.1571508944,
0.9900385141,
0.6605985165,
0.3217276037,
-0.0479561053,
-0.0074857906,
0.8452525139,
-0.3556485772,
-0.6958189607,
-0.753049016,
0.7822631598,
0.1497371495,
-0.4160929024,
0.437838614,
0.4247453511,
0.4615428448,
-0.4696340859,
0.7430979609,
-0.0477644503,
-0.1482772529,
-0.5542532206,
0.9337447286,
-0.5082579255,
0.6536425352,
-0.2142675221,
-0.9745425582,
-0.0354940332,
-0.0255191009,
-0.0378149413,
-0.150305137,
0.4886043966,
1.1354306936,
-0.1242828667,
0.0695624053,
0.2862362266,
0.1523577124,
0.4299927354,
0.4396530092,
0.9045001268,
-0.2881327868,
0.7549614906,
0.1795125753,
-0.1121398062,
-0.1816943288,
-0.936609149,
-0.7177376151,
-0.7946686149,
-0.3400998712,
-0.3755119443,
-0.0045149652,
0.8023680449,
0.6824933887,
-0.9662106037,
-0.5147934556,
-0.4472493827,
-0.0075809355,
0.1313217431,
-0.1055305302,
0.178357482,
-0.2584834099,
-0.6652112603,
0.2535493672,
0.3579829037,
-0.0866504759,
-0.8798213005,
-0.0446353853,
-0.2744065821,
0.0065917335,
0.4545525014,
0.3164665401,
-0.5305285454,
-0.2234395742,
-0.1184451431,
-0.4663157463,
-0.1770691425,
1.1956169605,
-0.686013639,
-0.1193449199,
0.3760879338,
0.976985693,
0.1520853341,
-0.3107320964,
0.7887769341,
-0.5616213679,
0.0841802806,
0.1891918778,
0.4441198707,
0.217595607,
-0.3329692483,
0.415496707,
-0.2510402203,
-0.9989612699,
-0.9214704633,
0.4917742014,
-0.7371743321,
-0.3925726414,
1.2581214905,
-0.1548018605,
-0.3499851525,
-0.2017188966,
-0.0313822702,
0.0306024868,
0.0448084623,
0.8607897162,
0.4759270847,
0.1899100542,
-0.0516892262,
-0.6125228405,
0.2418774366,
0.3996798098,
-1.1013987064,
0.0011049347,
0.4483383894,
0.188749209,
0.2080866396,
0.5051233768,
-0.135291487,
0.0804409981,
0.0531695783,
0.2653633654,
-0.1111771613,
-0.537194252,
-0.4220674336,
0.5367279053,
0.3644508719,
0.2299504727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00226v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00226v2
|
Design as Desired: Utilizing Visual Question Answering for Multimodal Pre-training
| 2024-03-30T02:56:54 | 2024-04-08T13:05:11 |
Tongkun Su, Jun Li, Xi Zhang, Haibo Jin, Hao Chen, Qiong Wang, Faqin Lv, Baoliang Zhao, Yin Hu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Multimodal pre-training demonstrates its potential in the medical domain,
which learns medical visual representations from paired medical reports.
However, many pre-training tasks require extra annotations from clinicians, and
most of them fail to explicitly guide the model to learn the desired features
of different pathologies. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to
utilize Visual Question Answering (VQA) for multimodal pre-training to guide
the framework focusing on targeted pathological features. In this work, we
leverage descriptions in medical reports to design multi-granular
question-answer pairs associated with different diseases, which assist the
framework in pre-training without requiring extra annotations from experts. We
also propose a novel pre-training framework with a quasi-textual feature
transformer, a module designed to transform visual features into a
quasi-textual space closer to the textual domain via a contrastive learning
strategy. This narrows the vision-language gap and facilitates modality
alignment. Our framework is applied to four downstream tasks: report
generation, classification, segmentation, and detection across five datasets.
Extensive experiments demonstrate the superiority of our framework compared to
other state-of-the-art methods. Our code will be released upon acceptance.
|
[
-0.5089268088,
-0.7386939526,
0.6828435063,
-0.1323483884,
-0.5036996007,
-0.2149678767,
0.2217390239,
-0.5131955147,
0.4954501987,
0.5382914543,
-0.8311603069,
-0.2437510937,
-0.6565766335,
0.0189929698,
-0.1861403733,
1.1297876835,
-0.1801613122,
0.514603734,
-0.5498899817,
-0.2216192782,
-0.477886647,
-0.4314733744,
-0.1631167084,
0.0975960121,
0.7146689892,
0.2119590789,
0.377644062,
0.3826895654,
0.7864057422,
0.3447711468,
0.4423641562,
0.1152087972,
-0.1927638203,
0.0477553867,
0.0603631698,
-0.5726205111,
-0.5914570689,
-0.0120567977,
0.3112472296,
0.594451189,
0.0901993886,
0.2118233144,
-0.2656117082,
0.2451829016,
-0.5103282928,
-0.0285255816,
-0.2001498491,
0.238400653,
-0.2049084455,
-0.6263418794,
-0.1115798056,
-0.1818050146,
0.4588895738,
-0.9686599374,
0.0935030133,
-0.0044360068,
1.0482889414,
0.4262025952,
-0.5413470864,
-0.156964168,
-0.3211375475,
0.483032167,
-0.2722389102,
0.2441827506,
0.4838625491,
0.5881778598,
0.4553337693,
-1.1509449482,
-0.5462775826,
-0.0085618878,
-0.4502752125,
0.3421367407,
0.0052861562,
0.163881883,
0.0314802192,
0.2887521982,
-0.8833742142,
-0.2242934406,
-0.4750751555,
-0.4525480866,
0.3444728255,
0.3493086696,
0.4557422996,
-0.1576971263,
-0.5832474828,
-0.0334972776,
-0.2801105082,
0.0889501423,
-0.3278720379,
-0.0369701721,
-0.2102424502,
0.4792602062,
-0.271677196,
0.5916358232,
-0.0636615753,
-0.3050186038,
0.6519045234,
-0.769710362,
-0.0700002089,
-0.2808589935,
0.5587685108,
0.5042452812,
0.0154632721,
-0.0533959866,
-0.0122465165,
0.016432438,
0.5861740708,
-0.9817032814,
-0.4012058377,
0.1789193898,
-0.7359393239,
-0.3622946441,
-0.1119166613,
-0.7921826839,
-0.1587745994,
-0.255092293,
0.7793295979,
-0.3930725157,
-0.2428394854,
0.1327479333,
-0.1142489091,
0.2319457978,
0.5616350174,
-0.628210187,
0.0586307384,
-0.1010205448,
0.3515403867,
0.1471517831,
-0.297886759,
-0.7231553197,
0.3375405371,
-0.1071067303,
0.8688411117,
-0.6460185051,
-0.2059502453,
-0.0845436379,
0.1927446723,
-0.1886216998,
-0.4081223309,
0.1884819567,
-0.4800043702,
0.5005714893,
-0.3770816624,
-0.0030231699,
-0.1264855117,
0.5440144539,
-0.5607048273,
0.5717270374,
0.3991381526,
-0.8469353914,
0.4290418923,
-0.6769508719,
-0.363186866,
0.269243896,
-0.5398108363,
-0.4280692935,
0.0273297299,
0.6365276575,
0.3782127202,
-0.2147723138,
0.1254767329,
-0.0946539938,
-0.1680183858,
0.2245638222,
-0.2607167363,
0.3039260507,
0.1168610603,
-0.2125540525,
0.5913492441,
-0.6025527716,
0.2695858479,
0.1565844864,
-0.1504468173,
-0.2065270692,
-0.357375741,
0.1208097786,
0.4515835643,
0.2330061793,
-0.4059716165,
0.0839942098,
-0.1918890923,
0.1935717463,
0.4997833967,
-0.0681805462,
0.3201851845,
-0.3988772631,
0.9337179065,
0.468262583,
0.5973494053,
-0.4710030556,
-0.364261657,
-0.5675587058,
-0.6218711138,
0.1674517542,
0.5765190125,
-1.4352625608,
-0.2509991825,
-0.3545289338,
-0.2252329141,
-0.6940692663,
-0.0116983047,
0.7903215885,
0.7316334844,
0.754919827,
-0.4714357555,
-0.4584541917,
-1.0175942183,
0.1996717453,
-0.1569164097,
0.0125720175,
0.3984588683,
0.4179770052,
-0.2945405245,
0.6344797611,
-0.645432055,
-0.5017605424,
-0.2141079754,
0.1275676936,
-0.3495786786,
0.228576839,
0.697591722,
-1.2935903072,
-0.1666386873,
-0.0526701435,
-0.7691506147,
0.0239359923,
-0.0020149322,
0.0398272499,
-0.2039872408,
0.6088554859,
-0.3386009336,
0.5960850716,
0.4222342968,
-0.118754141,
0.4728369415,
-0.3519538045,
0.6103789806,
-1.2460123301,
0.137145713,
-0.1911913753,
-0.2679577768,
-0.6285282969,
0.0088167693,
0.1013636813,
-0.1332319379,
-0.6088714004,
0.4803653657,
-0.2003204823,
0.3792370558,
0.143701449,
-0.1970889717,
0.1444537789,
0.4146461785,
0.1756146252,
0.6815037727,
0.6509580612,
-0.4878405631,
0.1378122121,
0.4460053444,
-0.0500667654,
0.9149926305,
-0.5339856744,
-0.0757376403,
-0.5276740789,
0.1206417009,
-0.9863706231,
-0.4527090788,
0.2632631958,
-0.5484235287,
0.2139087319,
-0.0580797009,
-0.0822082832,
-0.5211649537,
-0.3267101049,
0.7200914025,
0.2040902823,
-0.0949167907,
0.6740435362,
0.3152809143,
-0.2612543106,
-0.6186792254,
-0.7901449203,
-0.0821416304,
-0.1947459579,
-0.5853797793,
0.2941423059,
-0.2768481672,
0.1643180251,
0.0096559646,
-0.0876416117,
-0.4965662658,
-0.1687747538,
0.1494659036,
0.2950033545,
-0.4505821168,
0.370018661,
-0.0851630718,
-0.2095512003,
-0.1173487976,
-0.0778645128,
0.355342865,
-0.0987752303,
-0.47726354,
-0.3643365204,
0.7248647809,
0.444031626,
-0.7110631466,
0.3507186472,
0.8483579159,
-0.1532801241,
0.2105025947,
-0.3727040589,
-0.1707974374,
-0.4398402572,
0.7390601635,
-0.526168108,
-0.9249651432,
0.1691703349,
-0.0376226939,
-0.2257395834,
0.1388284564,
0.5606221557,
-0.5377961993,
0.8318098783,
0.8857226372,
0.5614510775,
0.3239603937,
-0.0222075973,
0.0990581736,
-0.4955970645,
-0.5210670829,
-0.1693606079,
-0.1380955875,
-0.2133266926,
-0.5822607875,
0.7147437334,
-0.0671837926,
0.1316217482,
0.0119631952,
-0.524287641,
0.2861403525,
0.3316338062,
0.4207808673,
-0.0919215009,
-0.1937666833,
-0.031746354,
-0.1102643088,
-0.6549224257,
-0.2675329745,
1.0799324512,
0.1648796499,
0.6974266768,
-0.1110466421,
0.6902269125,
-0.0830272511,
0.3249118626,
-0.5181398988,
0.4105412662,
-0.170378238,
-0.6656047702,
-0.2868094742,
-0.2403861284,
-0.7614254355,
0.3354197741,
-0.5256897211,
-0.2237775177,
0.105824329,
0.5026984811,
-0.585760355,
0.0818259865,
-0.7618185878,
1.2606949806,
-0.5910577178,
-0.0878804699,
0.1385150552,
-1.1008218527,
0.2045552731,
-0.0187000334,
0.2621902823,
0.2904520631,
-0.1910026073,
0.4943802059,
-0.2782614529,
0.8074749112,
-0.2120930105,
0.2542690933,
0.0222962741,
-0.2455278933,
-0.195349738,
0.2434604913,
0.6082550883,
-0.1487932503,
0.531111002,
-0.5853627324,
-0.4990718961,
0.0699424446,
-0.4967858791,
-0.4954579771,
-0.3151161373,
-0.5662043095,
-0.4301406741,
0.2003448457,
0.386231184,
0.6307427883,
-0.0822160393,
0.1404673755,
0.9087172151,
-0.2144580483,
0.3150103688,
0.2548619807,
-0.1356292069,
-0.4338746369,
0.932471633,
-0.2028055787,
0.3383160532,
0.6441425085,
0.0487503596,
-0.1247031987,
-0.7980313301,
-0.6501589417,
0.0606273562,
-0.6374592781,
-0.0863817483,
-0.6832872033,
-0.2945070863,
-0.2277407646,
-0.0837691054,
-0.0800131485,
0.0050794506,
-0.3288138211,
0.1363842338,
-0.0180171691,
0.5081165433,
0.2885966599,
0.2490062863,
-0.9749540687,
0.8084611297,
0.7466027141,
0.1959694773,
-0.4197872281,
-0.2703124881,
-0.2570241392,
-0.0356233902,
-0.1911234856,
-0.7600882649,
0.187860325,
0.2573498189,
0.6370153427,
0.2967389822,
-0.1129100993,
0.8204624057,
-0.5695713758,
0.7204090357,
0.6468762159,
-0.4535280168,
0.7377253175,
-0.0173197128,
0.3754552901,
0.8546103239,
0.728328526,
-0.2107124776,
-0.0597835481,
-0.2799289525,
-0.5629276633,
0.524716258,
0.0587540977,
0.1962316334,
0.0222457163,
0.0948259681,
0.3339543641,
0.4266837835,
-0.701662004,
-0.247327432,
-0.6863657832,
-0.3036547601,
-0.243691951,
-0.2459829152,
-0.4757624567,
-0.4320172966,
0.0430104248,
-0.494100064,
0.3439664245,
0.4310390651,
-0.5723767281,
0.1994970292,
0.3499757648,
0.7111698389,
0.8508146405,
-0.0167205073,
0.3300243616,
0.0581052527,
-0.7951995134,
0.05936151,
0.2421790361,
0.1322783232,
-0.0137208849,
0.533095479,
0.7944494486,
-0.0224423967,
-0.8148753643,
1.0014666319,
-0.3467870653,
-0.4556338191,
-0.0758515373,
-0.0545486696,
0.1389667541,
0.273620218,
0.0827505738,
0.1388940066,
0.2280467302,
-0.4709687531,
0.3982091546,
0.3508080244,
-0.806778729,
-0.4359188676,
0.6861342788,
0.239373669,
0.1427534819,
0.4223756194,
0.1224409789,
-0.4585850835,
0.414999634,
0.2625409663,
0.3258013129,
-0.160089612,
0.4871693552,
-0.0221987981,
0.2929188013,
0.474793911,
0.6908823252,
-0.2088574469,
-0.3341433704,
-0.3658057749,
-0.5605301261,
0.0637105703,
0.0420754068,
-0.5583797693,
0.2888065279,
-0.2473255992,
-0.1659065634,
0.2328990102,
-0.5321984291,
-0.7176337838,
0.8010163903,
0.2685695887,
0.5231599808,
-0.8413884044,
0.8402662873,
1.0501335859,
-0.9631590247,
-0.6129533052,
-0.0217485204,
-0.1142417714,
-0.8414632678,
0.7379893064,
0.1496893466,
0.0597317405,
-0.2486125976,
-0.5215015411,
-0.5375342369,
1.0018888712,
0.4099010825,
-0.1633046269,
-0.4242605269,
0.2765558362,
0.5166938305,
-0.3796034753,
0.4480617046,
0.0622973628,
0.2720500529,
0.2886731029,
-1.1257860661,
0.0074077295,
-0.457596451,
-0.1295630038,
0.1582364291,
-0.3320436478,
0.817265749,
-0.4470812678,
0.1519021541,
0.0163784213,
0.2390654087,
-0.0366359912,
0.4135978818,
0.4608004689,
0.4581026137,
0.5343942046,
-0.1654965132,
1.0862830877,
0.0562757961,
-0.0822260976,
0.8945677876,
0.1375941932,
0.5372173786,
0.7218025327,
-0.0467796326,
0.3583443165,
0.4982362688,
0.3373541534,
0.6511465907,
0.1121623442,
-0.1851568967,
-0.601939261,
-0.1106175482,
-0.7267594337,
0.4746020138,
0.0605076626,
-0.3908495605,
-0.1913199127,
0.3604838252,
-0.4136071801,
-0.1614152044,
-0.3187326491,
0.8656058311,
0.1324164569,
-0.2423606664,
0.5675386786,
-0.4390648305,
0.5558721423,
-0.9765245318,
-0.2283469141,
-0.0853691548,
-0.1172858104,
-0.2166660875,
-0.6753948331,
0.130042091,
-0.4875842035,
-0.326933533,
-0.2790824175,
0.4527734816,
-0.4639272392,
-0.4218494892,
0.0014892214,
0.7244394422,
0.0446277447,
0.0481757671,
-0.6058775783,
-0.2424693555,
-0.138098821,
-0.1209294051,
0.4426874816,
0.5381754041,
-0.3808002174,
0.5741272569,
0.437579602,
-0.1258873194,
0.1019022465,
0.1865181476,
1.1986532211,
-0.4380302429,
-0.5149959922,
-0.3547149599,
0.8168204427,
-0.0071683261,
-0.4963367581,
0.2157781273,
0.2499752045,
0.8242642879,
-0.3425192833,
0.521273315,
-0.0864542723,
0.2082376927,
-0.5865246654,
0.7412848473,
-1.0791345835,
-0.1646241248,
-0.2654053867,
-0.5421048999,
-0.2957241833,
0.3292010128,
-0.2025720626,
0.2210834175,
1.1948301792,
0.7063275576,
-0.1141471714,
-0.1407102346,
0.5342695117,
-0.0638808385,
0.1703942418,
0.727474153,
0.9033151865,
-0.2663786709,
0.8221619725,
-0.2656119764,
-0.2985835969,
-0.0757180974,
-0.5658608079,
-0.9916756749,
-0.7934724689,
-0.1914109737,
-0.1571662426,
0.095169425,
0.5102286935,
1.1501071453,
-0.6076272726,
0.2809336185,
0.477003783,
-0.4462537467,
0.0091429045,
-0.0735152587,
0.4394358993,
-0.3521485627,
-0.191933468,
0.050437104,
0.4068465233,
0.0410879105,
-0.0020625673,
-0.0231867637,
-0.2385359854,
-0.3198388517,
0.5911965966,
0.1241205335,
-0.5197936893,
-0.1917237192,
0.1542002857,
-0.1970388442,
0.3646363318,
0.9504464269,
-0.9002325535,
0.7146499157,
0.2292330265,
0.7874930501,
0.5610413551,
-0.0033764509,
0.2899362147,
-0.4465116858,
0.2443221658,
0.5760998726,
0.1069504395,
0.113592729,
-0.2451273054,
0.0870246589,
0.257846266,
-0.1365614086,
-0.5408593416,
0.3668827116,
-1.1641718149,
-0.4305586815,
0.6563905478,
-0.2321596444,
-0.1745501757,
-0.3774378002,
-0.5606620312,
-0.0294904858,
0.1946024001,
0.4186972976,
0.3450835049,
-0.3337113857,
-0.4436523318,
-0.5287669897,
0.6265671253,
0.4779106379,
-1.2237546444,
-0.5763840079,
0.5198826194,
0.3502146602,
0.0789456815,
1.0346769094,
-0.4713239372,
0.7014080882,
-0.122370474,
0.1570239216,
-0.3033296168,
-0.5253970027,
-0.1574845612,
0.3924593627,
-0.0854724199,
-0.3871773779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00224v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00224v1
|
Classification and Clustering of Sentence-Level Embeddings of Scientific Articles Generated by Contrastive Learning
| 2024-03-30T02:52:14 | 2024-03-30T02:52:14 |
Gustavo Bartz Guedes, Ana Estela Antunes da Silva
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scientific articles are long text documents organized into sections, each
describing aspects of the research. Analyzing scientific production has become
progressively challenging due to the increase in the number of available
articles. Within this scenario, our approach consisted of fine-tuning
transformer language models to generate sentence-level embeddings from
scientific articles, considering the following labels: background, objective,
methods, results, and conclusion. We trained our models on three datasets with
contrastive learning. Two datasets are from the article's abstracts in the
computer science and medical domains. Also, we introduce PMC-Sents-FULL, a
novel dataset of sentences extracted from the full texts of medical articles.
We compare the fine-tuned and baseline models in clustering and classification
tasks to evaluate our approach. On average, clustering agreement measures
values were five times higher. For the classification measures, in the
best-case scenario, we had an average improvement in F1-micro of 30.73\%.
Results show that fine-tuning sentence transformers with contrastive learning
and using the generated embeddings in downstream tasks is a feasible approach
to sentence classification in scientific articles. Our experiment codes are
available on GitHub.
|
[
-0.0838605762,
-0.6135002375,
0.5922580957,
0.097886689,
-0.3511185348,
-0.0041044625,
-0.2448289543,
-0.4366504848,
0.2530385852,
0.2565361857,
-0.1365181357,
-0.7899583578,
-0.8535270691,
0.6210929751,
-0.5458035469,
1.2514755726,
-0.0434943885,
0.2139862925,
-0.5221557021,
-0.0895420909,
-0.0157842897,
-0.121332936,
-0.3842954636,
-0.1750239581,
0.6171867847,
0.2004741877,
0.3086946011,
0.8210154772,
0.5587379336,
0.307572782,
-0.3592864275,
0.1671867818,
-0.3598545194,
-0.0033205939,
-0.2749820054,
-0.4915754199,
0.0067334673,
0.0058970242,
0.5460106134,
0.8074902296,
-0.0791765004,
-0.0345105939,
0.2201410383,
0.460465312,
-0.2634760737,
0.3021609783,
-0.5568862557,
0.3755190969,
-0.0181987267,
-0.0670985952,
-0.5983837843,
-0.2832360566,
0.1680044979,
-0.4978083372,
0.4714657664,
0.2112629861,
0.7821434736,
0.2134653181,
-0.4470336437,
-0.4864633381,
-0.4036695957,
0.8933823109,
-0.6699779034,
0.1891675442,
0.0352160558,
-0.2183398455,
0.0898661241,
-0.8813672066,
-0.385646224,
-0.2666676641,
-0.3928420246,
0.1485312879,
-0.5518062711,
-0.0640143752,
0.1094107255,
0.2834005654,
-0.6752255559,
0.3386631608,
-0.6257086992,
0.1581166387,
0.4711022973,
0.2216933072,
0.0592764951,
-0.2475014478,
0.0145151932,
-0.0415578112,
-0.6776584983,
-0.3108496368,
0.0421967953,
0.1815397292,
-0.1978900135,
0.708478868,
-0.2494640499,
0.4504161179,
0.2901437581,
0.2094853073,
0.5037919283,
-0.6023990512,
-0.0243819021,
0.1220300496,
0.9312263131,
0.3685016632,
-0.0418230928,
-0.2419333607,
0.067463778,
0.1865205616,
0.5435863137,
-0.8791801929,
-0.273793906,
0.0440697633,
-0.5669092536,
-0.6464172006,
0.2994153798,
-0.7162041068,
-0.2605105042,
-0.1370818913,
0.1636540592,
-0.2498933673,
0.2056715935,
0.1199917421,
0.1258224994,
-0.262052089,
0.104784973,
-0.6196373105,
0.3627959788,
0.5353650451,
1.0556564331,
-0.468183428,
-0.1352151781,
-0.2169121057,
0.0361754633,
-0.2439314276,
0.9443868995,
-0.5279741287,
-0.2726919949,
0.1376016736,
0.1014368981,
-0.2276846468,
-0.6771730781,
0.6484930515,
-0.3431691527,
0.4763141572,
0.1663642675,
-0.7211425304,
0.0046612476,
0.1401448846,
-0.4437630475,
0.5520896912,
-0.01159437,
-1.0411943197,
0.2487878948,
-0.7641835809,
-0.7253454328,
-0.1782471687,
-0.1679457128,
-0.6653850675,
0.2583878934,
0.2179125994,
0.7544161081,
-0.1344831586,
0.3992114663,
-0.0317192078,
-0.0594409928,
0.4628675878,
0.036433246,
0.2765066922,
0.4347179532,
-0.2914949954,
0.2991806865,
-0.7848598361,
-0.3771178424,
-0.0786791742,
-0.3758960068,
-0.4749410748,
0.099078767,
-0.0085518742,
0.1264163852,
-0.0157478862,
-0.8894074559,
0.1468138695,
-0.4966028929,
0.7358283401,
0.2936439812,
0.2137622088,
0.4855159223,
-0.2274440229,
0.2377416342,
0.5175310373,
0.0013360897,
-0.2247298807,
-0.4310438931,
-0.7946740389,
-0.041533459,
0.3988696635,
0.450987339,
-0.6521632671,
0.8070500493,
-0.2256661803,
-0.6052022576,
-0.6773875952,
-0.0894893408,
0.492692709,
0.6784816384,
0.7055196762,
0.0373457074,
-0.478045553,
-0.9989454746,
-0.099588789,
0.2443994582,
-0.1360700279,
0.1589695513,
0.746661365,
-0.4289777279,
0.4691944122,
-0.9294889569,
-0.1851890385,
-0.0114258593,
0.4776058495,
0.2957614064,
0.6494956613,
0.3037786782,
-0.7313962579,
-0.5321509242,
0.2173164189,
-0.8142387271,
-0.1524117589,
-0.0946100652,
0.1634446979,
0.1420088112,
0.8505690098,
-0.6078326702,
0.1632973552,
0.3934668005,
-0.3997218013,
0.6183749437,
-0.1851909161,
0.1424795985,
-1.2697170973,
0.0395420864,
0.3618950546,
-0.1172168925,
-0.5358724594,
-0.1098650545,
-0.1103143692,
-0.0906515941,
-0.2824161053,
0.0604375973,
-0.3240162432,
0.3079119325,
-0.2996656001,
-0.0045982925,
-0.0650589168,
0.0614781119,
0.0848675296,
0.5872608423,
0.3896192908,
-0.4904181063,
-0.0105925966,
0.4910521209,
-0.4681392908,
0.381739229,
-0.8341736794,
-0.168119818,
-0.1104199812,
0.2651720345,
-0.653516531,
-0.0344303995,
0.0207008813,
-0.2568261325,
0.235448882,
0.4245572984,
-0.4774897695,
-0.3542900383,
-0.2504055202,
0.1163240746,
0.455477953,
-0.2620353103,
0.1769516766,
0.1539174318,
-0.5052175522,
-0.2048746794,
-0.6492034197,
-0.0954902396,
-0.2065912038,
-0.3483741879,
0.6711673737,
0.0018503841,
-0.1557513326,
0.3898480535,
-0.117932342,
-0.0017585871,
-0.2549041808,
0.2815108299,
0.0324223824,
-0.3422435522,
0.222935915,
0.6048922539,
-0.1220748276,
-0.0072765332,
-0.1114342958,
0.4155712128,
-0.13133955,
-0.017997928,
-0.3989215493,
0.4746049345,
0.3695883751,
0.0163658969,
0.8418316245,
0.5956102014,
-0.235447526,
-0.0453348346,
-0.3916656971,
-0.3196355104,
-0.4101665914,
0.5020021796,
-0.0244502686,
-1.2029185295,
0.2212315947,
-0.1296347827,
-0.0667188838,
0.8249346018,
0.3892154992,
-0.2929853797,
0.9201432467,
0.6609053612,
0.1404364407,
0.2851096094,
-0.1937689632,
0.1374946088,
-0.581371963,
-0.4882073998,
-0.9038314819,
-0.2584360242,
-0.5562118292,
-0.4118839204,
0.4697641134,
-0.0123422537,
-0.2489133179,
0.3434711099,
-0.7477395535,
0.5717372298,
0.4793089628,
0.3317984641,
0.3915611506,
0.2873815298,
-0.1020886824,
-0.1798918545,
-0.6854551435,
-0.5121494532,
0.7990882397,
0.258520931,
0.6979238391,
-0.3739306331,
0.7877712846,
0.2262388468,
0.2503234744,
-0.6635183096,
0.2700283229,
-0.5922561884,
0.0612471513,
0.047416117,
-0.5791577697,
-1.1559206247,
0.1661405861,
-0.5348545909,
-0.329998672,
0.3086698651,
-0.2181457877,
-0.2785254121,
0.1160104424,
-0.6236335039,
0.8340955973,
0.0618308485,
0.0218063872,
-0.5605347157,
-0.7547703385,
0.1102870852,
-0.0986234099,
0.0593865924,
0.3194251955,
0.014718106,
0.9389778972,
0.0035333759,
0.971853435,
0.0788139328,
0.169177562,
-0.0428763963,
-0.1505880505,
0.2063168436,
0.0432371497,
0.0640323907,
0.1945040673,
0.0073463903,
-0.3955317736,
-0.3488675654,
0.7924778461,
-0.7320208549,
-0.3441401124,
-0.6524448395,
-0.4409212768,
-0.0982377678,
0.0860756338,
0.4252292514,
0.1150669381,
-0.2498501837,
0.5345486403,
0.7266553044,
-0.3997137547,
0.2587619126,
0.571806848,
0.2224618495,
-0.4260506034,
0.7266723514,
-0.1031502932,
-0.0663427562,
0.6376522779,
0.2053806931,
0.0309025198,
-0.9485296011,
0.1252436042,
0.4404781461,
-0.3074998558,
-0.5185528398,
-0.9501318336,
-0.3670231998,
-0.4465736449,
-0.3180188239,
-0.0388820693,
-0.3356831074,
-0.8364796042,
-0.4057541788,
0.1256769001,
1.0047781467,
0.0441876873,
0.2444808334,
-1.0128962994,
0.2047182173,
-0.0502221808,
0.148577109,
-0.0862136781,
-0.3477084339,
-0.5302404761,
-0.1819520295,
-0.6400033832,
-0.7909223437,
0.3854516149,
0.3686160445,
0.4654302597,
0.5815622807,
0.0002500984,
0.3551184237,
-0.7238277793,
0.8365995288,
0.4763804376,
-0.7732095718,
0.6807243824,
-0.1688180566,
0.2068556547,
0.5172034502,
0.7141732574,
-0.2774514258,
-0.5753509998,
-0.6468598247,
-0.9339755177,
0.3775914609,
0.0589402355,
0.1741355509,
-0.3803865612,
0.3844214082,
0.4671380818,
0.3350673616,
-0.8463365436,
0.1520450562,
-0.0937387422,
-0.5852476954,
-0.2770745158,
-0.2101303786,
-0.2352101803,
-0.382584244,
0.641649425,
-0.0886958987,
0.2172333151,
0.3284226358,
-0.3769670725,
-0.0066442266,
0.4534957111,
0.7092552781,
0.4693315029,
0.0538490377,
0.3282369077,
-0.019592233,
-0.4452506304,
-0.0648586676,
0.2471693009,
-0.3333493471,
0.0549837872,
0.4055179358,
0.7049517035,
0.3296611607,
-0.6395727992,
0.3837224543,
0.1961852014,
-0.3142983615,
0.0967191607,
-0.0779246762,
0.1736999303,
0.4055304229,
0.2973530889,
0.246513173,
0.3822428882,
-0.2243712991,
0.2922727466,
0.1388779879,
-0.3291057944,
-0.5303903818,
0.4550164044,
0.2706294358,
0.0989477336,
0.5684509277,
-0.1652411371,
-0.2706434131,
0.5089938641,
0.8868831396,
0.667514205,
-0.1462618709,
0.5550827384,
0.4163400829,
0.1701990515,
-0.1412718445,
-0.116781801,
0.2138602138,
-0.5634405017,
-0.4885129333,
-0.835144341,
-0.2826822102,
0.0083970949,
-0.601939559,
0.0686774552,
-0.118011646,
0.0563083179,
0.352088213,
-0.1043145582,
-0.3660387397,
-0.033681199,
-0.0705035478,
0.7743123174,
-1.2609225512,
0.6146004796,
0.8411524296,
-0.4487413168,
-0.2002186328,
-0.2181034684,
-0.3780789077,
-0.2997588515,
0.6179110408,
0.2127329111,
0.2400587499,
-0.108151108,
-0.6917254329,
-0.4577897191,
0.9667016864,
0.1846220791,
-0.7138956189,
-0.0472502187,
0.0233159792,
0.9402509928,
-0.7700119019,
-0.1804861575,
0.3084515631,
0.3087396622,
-0.0900181532,
-0.7657254338,
0.0934634656,
-0.4196690619,
-0.1101075113,
0.0015004047,
-0.2981000543,
0.7721518874,
-0.1450288445,
0.0145116616,
0.1594121754,
0.7202270031,
0.1850178391,
0.5848228335,
0.2255856395,
0.7525936365,
0.6324928999,
-0.1656553596,
0.7856101394,
-0.0895699263,
0.4264706373,
0.8097834587,
-0.2337330133,
0.9813725948,
0.5650509,
-0.3120731711,
0.8410010934,
0.5317234993,
-0.5810033679,
0.729637742,
0.3261568248,
-0.1799397618,
0.1455109715,
-0.2186572701,
-0.4269530773,
0.1395986676,
0.4916137159,
-0.7467458248,
-0.1240895912,
0.403704375,
0.0991326943,
0.3971653581,
-0.3481455147,
1.0297186375,
0.3272911012,
-0.4515075684,
0.252807349,
0.0215432737,
1.0315359831,
-0.3315177262,
0.0369808972,
-0.1149162427,
0.1282305419,
-0.4926204085,
-0.6594005823,
0.5419320464,
0.1543647796,
-0.4615642428,
-0.050588984,
0.6133545041,
-0.6898400187,
-0.569922626,
-0.0457972698,
0.4274399579,
0.1170513183,
0.0767707974,
-0.5059226751,
-0.2415289134,
-0.0515588485,
-0.0815841556,
0.4548247457,
0.2166597992,
0.1332158595,
0.3006882071,
0.5273874402,
0.196927309,
-0.0205121096,
-0.0046919724,
0.8851432204,
-0.6210042834,
-0.5734456778,
-0.6615587473,
0.2808097005,
-0.2655412257,
-0.1830402762,
0.5276229382,
0.8327382803,
0.6865063906,
-0.6217647791,
0.5100283027,
-0.0013449903,
0.5201053619,
-0.5733512044,
0.783441186,
-0.4130629599,
-0.0624912977,
-0.1400395036,
-0.7876098752,
-0.6820116639,
0.619173646,
-0.1034580246,
-0.1838265061,
1.184428215,
0.465367943,
-0.2853363454,
0.084446758,
-0.0661569461,
0.5579838753,
0.1286253333,
0.3771128058,
0.5387915969,
-0.2360619754,
0.4250166416,
-0.3332565129,
-0.0635674149,
-0.1690461338,
-0.804230094,
-0.7959088087,
-0.585994184,
-0.6550930738,
-0.2802245319,
0.1079378724,
0.7324345708,
0.4657855332,
-1.1510759592,
-0.0426153801,
-0.3622219563,
-0.1565243155,
-0.3042151034,
-0.2602169514,
0.642536819,
-0.5454069376,
-0.5505049825,
0.3814333677,
0.1421261877,
-0.0419762358,
0.1490764022,
0.1683642268,
-0.3029631972,
-0.169944495,
0.737896502,
0.1316908002,
-0.604016602,
-0.1312976629,
0.0531225912,
-0.176737234,
0.1744249165,
0.9039316773,
-0.6191640496,
0.097009182,
0.4295083582,
0.5937911272,
0.6279006004,
-0.0685168654,
0.3401628435,
-0.8783311248,
-0.0603995733,
0.3682018816,
0.3572817445,
0.3324176073,
-0.3001001477,
0.5526632667,
0.1451970041,
-0.7156361341,
-0.7764639854,
-0.0423477702,
-1.1583551168,
-0.4601502717,
1.0396831036,
-0.2239723951,
-0.0587590598,
0.0348379388,
-0.1698658615,
0.4962615967,
-0.3225100636,
1.0986809731,
0.5315521359,
-0.3041658103,
-0.1497582197,
-0.130820021,
0.3377563059,
0.361641109,
-1.1886729002,
-0.2781862915,
0.4959024191,
0.2949661314,
0.6008692384,
0.0276019592,
-0.3760134876,
0.0684598163,
-0.1078110933,
-0.107345067,
-0.1218080446,
-0.3263797462,
-0.5250990987,
0.4615015686,
-0.264126122,
0.0333651267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00217v1
|
Rationale-based Opinion Summarization
| 2024-03-30T02:22:57 | 2024-03-30T02:22:57 |
Haoyuan Li, Snigdha Chaturvedi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Opinion summarization aims to generate concise summaries that present popular
opinions of a large group of reviews. However, these summaries can be too
generic and lack supporting details. To address these issues, we propose a new
paradigm for summarizing reviews, rationale-based opinion summarization.
Rationale-based opinion summaries output the representative opinions as well as
one or more corresponding rationales. To extract good rationales, we define
four desirable properties: relatedness, specificity, popularity, and diversity
and present a Gibbs-sampling-based method to extract rationales. Overall, we
propose RATION, an unsupervised extractive system that has two components: an
Opinion Extractor (to extract representative opinions) and Rationales Extractor
(to extract corresponding rationales). We conduct automatic and human
evaluations to show that rationales extracted by RATION have the proposed
properties and its summaries are more useful than conventional summaries. The
implementation of our work is available at
https://github.com/leehaoyuan/RATION.
|
[
-0.7657955885,
-0.2092312723,
0.3287114799,
0.4772768915,
-0.5267499685,
-0.2366337627,
-0.0889961943,
0.0615685657,
0.7580417991,
0.4355643988,
-0.3786384463,
-0.3576485813,
-0.3607499599,
0.1646032631,
-0.1775982082,
1.4762752056,
0.1007224843,
0.3600975275,
0.0444662198,
-0.4774860442,
-0.4004615545,
-0.5573918223,
-0.2888071835,
-0.3115882277,
0.6644937396,
0.3876861334,
0.6373769641,
0.4262552559,
0.3673898876,
0.2017127573,
-0.0389035791,
0.2671511173,
-0.4201934338,
-0.0050638593,
-0.2633910179,
-0.2105189562,
-0.5954967141,
0.4195002317,
0.3924703002,
0.6172302961,
-0.2274692357,
0.2489936352,
0.1942954957,
1.1642149687,
-0.6508529186,
0.2351592332,
-0.3479587138,
0.0100221839,
0.1081711799,
-0.3198317885,
-0.1517494321,
-0.7376130819,
0.2344977558,
-0.7414456606,
0.360242337,
-0.1924367398,
0.7193907499,
-0.1093541309,
-0.3346884847,
-0.3652454019,
-0.695412457,
1.0590147972,
-0.8387175798,
-0.0867823511,
-0.1696283668,
0.503213048,
0.0308853127,
-0.5001100898,
-0.6289030313,
0.0970922559,
-0.1437643617,
0.6037170887,
0.0677065328,
-0.1523610801,
0.3294714987,
0.6451478004,
-0.2944771051,
-0.6830812693,
-0.2997117043,
0.1195291281,
0.8318789601,
0.0990545973,
0.2172545642,
-0.4519187212,
-0.3534933627,
0.050654985,
-0.4613575339,
0.1388925612,
0.2867727876,
-0.1503901333,
0.1650599986,
0.7423996925,
-0.5075052381,
0.1159167364,
0.1139499694,
-0.2405557185,
0.2056234032,
-0.3003362119,
-0.1932103485,
0.0776602775,
0.8548488021,
0.9101440907,
0.4703561962,
0.1399612576,
-0.3264937401,
0.0566541776,
0.0201810133,
-0.7492440343,
-0.2422630042,
0.3517028093,
-0.9126598835,
-0.6302871704,
0.552952826,
-1.0387699604,
-0.4544697106,
-0.5771887898,
0.0205938257,
-0.2057133764,
-0.4806621671,
-0.0720593408,
-0.9529474378,
0.2545914054,
0.6247082949,
-0.8226729035,
0.1994225383,
0.7240973711,
0.9763430357,
-0.6101472378,
-0.0503702164,
0.0053189388,
0.2339527458,
-0.1857167631,
1.1295838356,
-0.2690901756,
-0.457873255,
-0.2003369033,
-0.0538834222,
0.2756578624,
-0.693513751,
0.1554620862,
-0.4035049677,
0.2915106416,
-0.7378022671,
-0.5290812254,
-0.3529466391,
0.3753660917,
-0.8983302712,
0.5374646187,
0.20610331,
-0.940418303,
0.2816229463,
-0.7150452137,
-0.3362018764,
-0.1292123348,
-0.1562324166,
-0.1967887878,
0.1472746283,
0.5054857731,
0.1916666031,
-0.4539803565,
0.2880170643,
-0.3861041665,
-0.0991086438,
0.5928009152,
-0.433147043,
1.0588959455,
0.6105740666,
0.0756712109,
0.3973025978,
-0.4447563291,
-0.045688767,
-0.0598125942,
-0.2383063138,
-0.0836401954,
0.0136089064,
0.1107592881,
0.0710064992,
0.1762998849,
-0.3763721287,
0.0419719517,
-0.3360328376,
0.3314733207,
0.6998283267,
0.558075428,
0.804179132,
-0.8176727295,
0.6795423031,
-0.0599316284,
0.1149824485,
-0.3040476143,
-0.1496655047,
-0.3415316045,
-0.5300559998,
0.3493957222,
0.6668737531,
-0.4948493838,
0.5076402426,
-0.2569535673,
-0.3075298369,
-0.1001455635,
0.1281951815,
-0.041716259,
0.4790947437,
0.1725645661,
-0.3757827282,
-0.5410355926,
-0.9207059741,
-0.6081131101,
-0.1737462133,
-0.4002504647,
-0.0035312106,
0.1563768387,
0.2224361748,
1.2455699444,
-0.7504060268,
-0.2728683949,
-0.8999160528,
0.0966576785,
0.2538639307,
0.1943414956,
0.3122552037,
-0.7057002187,
-0.3114243746,
-0.0309723895,
-1.024674654,
-0.2452461421,
-0.1436827779,
-0.2121488303,
-0.021639036,
0.243422389,
-0.7893557549,
0.1762467474,
-0.2299199253,
0.2627287507,
0.5811378956,
0.1376560628,
0.2547537982,
-1.2221757174,
0.0416263975,
0.1555660367,
0.0060629584,
-0.1368460357,
-0.2271858901,
-0.1907862276,
-0.0975038409,
-0.3144626021,
0.4639789164,
-0.2330571562,
-0.0128692714,
-0.4323852956,
0.1658889502,
0.3401839137,
0.5807412267,
0.1316374242,
0.3658946753,
-0.0662877932,
-0.2851866782,
0.593264699,
0.0894762948,
-0.2565160692,
0.449305594,
-0.6314288378,
-0.3910458684,
-0.4971283078,
0.6739231944,
-0.6850052476,
-0.460036397,
0.2203851491,
-0.4685736299,
-0.0826993287,
-0.2217077911,
0.112016499,
-0.067421928,
-0.9712285399,
0.2819480598,
0.5577743053,
-0.3984567225,
0.7270525098,
0.8588342667,
-0.5851061344,
-0.4777377546,
-0.1595506221,
-0.3978714347,
-0.4329651296,
-0.3570787013,
-0.0998869091,
0.0140267899,
-0.659697175,
-0.0485482551,
-0.3401100338,
-0.0940056145,
-0.2711824179,
-0.0111435419,
0.4549502432,
-0.0805829093,
-0.0906128138,
0.1685608178,
-0.3386722505,
0.4301470816,
-0.1723859459,
0.0805044323,
-0.0621481352,
0.1600957662,
-0.250664115,
0.8869422078,
0.9359950423,
0.0013814083,
0.1391381174,
0.1412219703,
-0.3443950117,
-0.4387637079,
-0.4676635861,
-0.2272200137,
-0.3440460265,
0.3195069432,
-0.1042216867,
-0.4503963888,
0.5661915541,
-0.2035997063,
0.3798246086,
0.6186698079,
0.6386380196,
-0.3396708667,
1.0915102959,
0.1756481677,
-0.2613284886,
0.5800247192,
-0.2331887335,
0.2425305098,
-0.6228598356,
-0.1849289238,
-0.2733965814,
-0.2548198998,
-0.3422411382,
0.238491863,
0.3525966704,
0.13906762,
0.136107862,
-0.0613094755,
-0.4804987311,
0.8606829643,
0.3976540565,
-0.0376047157,
0.329130441,
0.1650842875,
0.2010612488,
-0.0133309178,
-0.7038577199,
-0.8400514722,
1.0832586288,
0.1293983907,
0.5248011947,
-0.0471685454,
0.5132872462,
0.4632441103,
0.8047066331,
-0.8632736206,
0.6050928831,
0.0295140296,
-0.5019518137,
-0.5177724957,
-0.4793738723,
-0.6169926524,
0.5981523991,
-0.1644278318,
-0.128579095,
0.2054164708,
0.2758647799,
-0.3916587234,
-0.0098707648,
-0.8458939195,
0.8120966554,
0.071851328,
0.0161960777,
-0.4238645732,
-0.552443862,
0.7506241798,
0.174048245,
0.1818094999,
-0.3176531494,
0.322447896,
0.7765882015,
-0.7663956881,
0.2644090354,
-0.24705033,
0.1403275132,
0.5621263981,
-0.0203416031,
0.0961829424,
0.6296445727,
0.0060096686,
0.3211867213,
0.0834812224,
-0.4902202785,
-1.1035410166,
0.7736520767,
-0.6487967372,
-0.5702264905,
-0.7538095713,
-0.670574367,
-0.0431885161,
0.0396145172,
0.417483747,
0.3918733895,
-0.3426906168,
-0.0254842062,
0.4826008677,
0.0433260724,
0.4903111756,
0.1960029751,
-0.2456624359,
-1.1367089748,
0.9656354189,
0.4264492095,
-0.0446623899,
0.2323802859,
0.347699672,
-0.1631011218,
-0.2502964437,
-0.603484869,
0.0499148108,
-0.5901705623,
-0.1790440977,
-0.5578895807,
-0.3019292355,
-0.2826406062,
-0.2810485363,
-0.1285234243,
-0.9923439622,
0.0787987188,
-0.0993680134,
0.2134248763,
0.6813529134,
0.0507318005,
0.1997026354,
-0.7633595467,
0.6272998452,
0.4652436376,
0.120439209,
0.0601206422,
-0.2149236053,
-0.0823062509,
-0.093859449,
-0.5608770251,
-0.9885497093,
0.6608006954,
-0.3568606675,
0.1721965969,
0.6072126627,
0.3681233227,
0.3763511777,
-0.1224684641,
0.7786021829,
0.4627625942,
-0.6970350742,
0.5267310143,
-0.5442237258,
0.3082771301,
0.55010885,
0.237916559,
-0.2168915868,
-0.2130339444,
-0.5671104789,
-0.8044120669,
0.5494603515,
0.3167534769,
-0.2389394343,
-0.1563643366,
0.2923083901,
0.3612906337,
0.3718455732,
-0.5978019238,
-0.0960902423,
-0.7761891484,
-0.3468396962,
0.0940144137,
-0.3389559686,
-0.2613688111,
-0.136470899,
0.7253580093,
0.0437596329,
-0.0833927467,
0.3735156357,
-0.0141896456,
0.1321729869,
0.4835523963,
0.4346243739,
0.7975712419,
-0.3909020126,
0.0387482494,
0.2402863801,
-0.2934467196,
-0.0931360498,
-0.0567569248,
-0.5811066628,
0.1801373065,
0.1613237411,
0.196098581,
-0.2961822152,
-0.4370031059,
0.7286613584,
-0.2668422163,
-0.0202621222,
-0.5479303002,
-0.0561195426,
-0.1633761823,
-0.1006257609,
0.1852612793,
0.4033362865,
0.3625942767,
-0.5040379167,
0.1556954831,
0.5615990162,
-0.1135044619,
-0.3577365577,
0.183938846,
0.3921650648,
0.0953565761,
0.0948325023,
-0.0436095893,
-0.1074970439,
0.6601167321,
0.3729163408,
1.064884305,
-0.0451092571,
0.1748434603,
0.5402432084,
0.059731286,
-0.3310301602,
0.3202267587,
-0.1320969462,
-0.5824701786,
-0.4567199349,
-0.3481174707,
-0.513554275,
-0.0305571239,
-0.6897037029,
0.2963857055,
-0.6371600628,
-0.1155351773,
0.1749825776,
-0.3101059794,
0.1841888428,
0.0528218634,
-0.4717724919,
0.7471706867,
-0.6331436634,
0.4196980894,
0.4224895537,
-0.6316676736,
-0.789164722,
-0.0258983243,
0.0251382329,
-0.0908358172,
0.0604238138,
0.1393993497,
-0.1647694409,
-0.3461033106,
-0.615840435,
-0.3855334818,
1.1077818871,
0.4400286078,
-0.2863047421,
0.2662577927,
-0.350237906,
0.3171884716,
-0.766782701,
0.3113539219,
0.4389155209,
0.3666956127,
0.1516277343,
-0.2816992104,
-0.0437803343,
-0.5509719849,
-0.0148221711,
0.1151563078,
-0.6110930443,
0.5125764012,
-0.1930964589,
-0.1718634814,
-0.0500559956,
0.8422917724,
0.4158683419,
0.6839555502,
0.3272197247,
0.3403786123,
0.6442442536,
0.0762735978,
1.174975872,
-0.2849704325,
0.1703865826,
0.9717808366,
-0.316762656,
0.5524293184,
0.5187937617,
0.0613671131,
0.480999589,
0.2791557312,
0.1474851519,
0.3791902959,
0.1953170002,
-0.5155957341,
-0.0460401215,
-0.0790747926,
-0.2934192419,
-0.1791568547,
0.1468415856,
-0.2630499899,
-0.239427343,
-0.386820972,
0.0070103565,
0.113818869,
-0.4451710582,
1.0135737658,
0.27212587,
-1.0679916143,
0.1080587655,
0.0062092533,
0.2465355694,
-0.6080175042,
-0.3820751011,
-0.4024725258,
0.0891827717,
-0.4006734192,
-0.6114453673,
0.3242371082,
0.0764580742,
-0.7892494798,
-0.2904501855,
0.5712316632,
-0.3549983501,
-0.3855639994,
-0.2390279472,
0.5348669887,
0.0645858496,
-0.0798115656,
-0.1764088273,
-0.361671865,
0.0615668446,
-0.3330358863,
0.2846206427,
0.7557709813,
-0.3207420707,
0.3812538981,
0.9910040498,
0.3192451298,
-0.3472075462,
0.3686089516,
0.7717797756,
-0.7727635503,
-0.7053928971,
-0.9322957397,
0.3566935062,
-0.4872840047,
-0.3697692156,
0.9231842756,
0.8087065816,
0.4589776695,
-0.3915156424,
1.1958767176,
0.1475387216,
0.6234314442,
-0.3550999165,
0.6883935332,
0.0087179933,
0.5413203835,
-0.2132747173,
-1.2715746164,
-0.3122254014,
0.7674202323,
-0.1232526153,
-0.0731288269,
0.880402267,
0.8245384097,
0.119919613,
0.3978938758,
-0.1277172863,
-0.0692186877,
0.1400298029,
0.194431141,
0.864870131,
-0.1089630648,
0.5031298995,
0.1348636746,
-0.5775751472,
0.1057361215,
-0.8309323788,
-0.8052774668,
-0.2269367278,
-0.2902323604,
-0.5739018321,
-0.3201072216,
1.165938735,
0.4045130908,
-1.1162904501,
-0.4230684936,
-0.3413383365,
0.4571385086,
-0.2684710026,
-0.3252848685,
0.262620151,
-0.1545987874,
-0.4258615673,
-0.0067318184,
0.372967571,
-0.0105184242,
-0.0996341109,
-0.2687844336,
0.3668018281,
0.4284549654,
0.6321610808,
0.4427138865,
-0.6311401725,
0.0861322731,
-0.1596259475,
0.0492826365,
0.0214664917,
1.4027459621,
-0.6127111912,
0.1745793223,
0.7233613133,
0.2772597671,
0.2121727765,
0.4513167739,
0.8874342442,
-0.3790010214,
-0.1407202929,
0.0995404795,
0.4866710901,
0.0427796692,
-0.1125651598,
0.3501625955,
0.4299885333,
-0.3508948684,
-0.4904097021,
0.306484431,
-1.4105467796,
-0.2338776737,
1.3315111399,
-0.138485536,
-0.1443489045,
-0.2526264787,
-0.6590229869,
0.0796555802,
-0.7857602239,
1.0398130417,
0.7596094012,
-0.2310168743,
0.028472105,
-0.1355101466,
0.5096341372,
0.3030186296,
-0.9436584115,
0.2976598144,
0.7100328207,
0.3089748919,
0.1301813424,
0.6716859937,
-0.613411665,
0.4516491294,
-0.2332222164,
0.1544448137,
-0.0890681446,
-0.2183681875,
-0.4208705425,
0.7673330903,
-0.2269062698,
0.0049000122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00216v1
|
Is Factuality Decoding a Free Lunch for LLMs? Evaluation on Knowledge Editing Benchmark
| 2024-03-30T02:08:28 | 2024-03-30T02:08:28 |
Baolong Bi, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Lingrui Mei, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) enables them to convey
factual knowledge in a more human-like fashion. Extensive efforts have been
made to reduce factual hallucinations by modifying LLMs with factuality
decoding. However, they also pose risks of hindering knowledge updates, as they
make models overly confident in known facts. In this work, we first revisite
the current factuality decoding methods and verified their effectiveness in
enhancing factual accuracy. Subsequently, we conduct further evaluation of
several strong factuality decoding methods on the knowledge editing benchmark.
All these decoding methods significantly diminish the performance of llama2
models compared to their original decoding, with the largest decrease being a
staggering 81.3\%. This further indicates that the current existing decoding
methods still cannot perfectly address the factual hallucinations, as they
overlook the importance of preserving the flexibility for knowledge editing.
Therefore, our work suggests that research into factual alignment should
simultaneously focus on the effectiveness of knowledge editing.
|
[
0.0672951117,
-0.6351754069,
0.7443911433,
0.0239930786,
-0.3667588234,
0.0995138064,
-0.3212756515,
-0.7006149292,
0.0676880926,
0.5067510009,
-0.2381612808,
-0.6458941102,
-0.680764854,
0.4339237511,
-0.4677808881,
0.8436911702,
-0.1049502417,
0.0793999955,
-0.6276635528,
-0.2299616337,
-0.4799728692,
-0.553611815,
-0.2493858635,
-0.1633086503,
0.2843800485,
0.4095954895,
0.699859798,
0.8676862121,
0.4921865463,
0.1847783178,
-0.4095202386,
0.4092280567,
-0.775862813,
0.065705426,
-0.1504537761,
-0.8368724585,
-0.5293842554,
-0.0067974883,
0.6892022491,
0.7874034047,
-0.1314570755,
0.3066759109,
0.0609083138,
0.8011905551,
-0.7420238256,
0.1628506184,
-0.782951057,
0.1428724825,
-0.0979522318,
-0.1509734094,
-0.5419613123,
-0.6624507904,
-0.1345012635,
-0.6274806261,
0.3040281832,
0.1757918149,
0.5774809718,
0.5044487119,
-0.4384331703,
-0.3527915776,
-0.8065198064,
0.5789116621,
-0.7364102006,
0.5415482521,
0.2287009805,
0.0150513668,
-0.1393163502,
-0.5872001648,
-0.6704807878,
-0.0855927616,
0.0449999236,
0.0306562576,
-0.367431581,
0.0963676721,
0.5075932741,
0.3218051493,
-0.4156775475,
0.02919106,
-0.3139130175,
-0.3344661295,
0.564823091,
0.3000253141,
0.0964522883,
-0.0979633331,
-0.3956030309,
-0.17024149,
-0.7730779052,
-0.0037040822,
0.2386827767,
-0.0298679359,
0.1306187809,
0.7696886063,
-0.4345009327,
0.3516020477,
-0.1807051152,
-0.4894426763,
0.1166277751,
-0.4152753949,
-0.2646102607,
0.4317453206,
0.3967652321,
0.8287605643,
0.0957192257,
-0.527221024,
-0.1534855068,
0.2092591524,
0.1375911981,
-0.6653724909,
-0.0807806924,
0.0817451328,
-0.4914366305,
-0.3480314612,
-0.1111931428,
-0.7441188097,
-0.6227670312,
-0.0209061708,
0.1673753411,
-0.4248850048,
-0.0948092565,
0.3918376565,
-0.0632983819,
0.3712320626,
0.512619853,
-0.8106228113,
0.319762975,
0.7926491499,
0.7647415996,
-0.0038078341,
-0.1327878535,
-0.2290132344,
0.3288848698,
-0.5927500725,
1.0594035387,
-0.3946565986,
-0.5198804736,
-0.0282772519,
-0.1618832052,
-0.0502284244,
-0.6645235419,
0.8128699064,
-0.775750339,
-0.1517473459,
-0.9967657924,
-0.8994964957,
-0.3857759833,
0.3957502246,
-0.7076517344,
0.6786590219,
-0.167409867,
-0.8222436309,
0.3123733997,
-0.2698246837,
-0.3867991269,
-0.3167990744,
0.053791441,
-0.237447992,
0.2166273594,
0.3915114105,
0.1134457365,
-0.3135206401,
0.2260772884,
-0.2071514875,
-0.5013728142,
0.5696473718,
-0.6108376384,
0.5266641974,
0.0886219814,
-0.3836472929,
-0.1126775816,
-0.8588315845,
-0.2011309117,
0.0469578914,
-0.5704945922,
-0.0515227132,
0.1353179812,
-0.4184189141,
0.0624515824,
0.1309619695,
-0.4692265689,
0.3211859167,
-0.2795906365,
-0.2015119344,
0.8708254099,
0.1137931868,
0.2906225026,
-0.5179809928,
0.3934715092,
0.0583953075,
-0.1250065863,
0.1678108722,
-0.4445272982,
-0.9256997108,
-0.2980152071,
0.4697034061,
0.876038909,
-0.5986367464,
0.2143164724,
-0.3656935096,
-0.2528112531,
-0.8317492604,
0.1980850399,
0.452814132,
0.7831670046,
0.3970357478,
-0.224902302,
-0.7004212141,
-0.8882099986,
-0.6102705002,
-0.2985981405,
0.1885168403,
-0.0803200677,
0.3403251469,
-0.2847637236,
0.8515815735,
-0.439629823,
0.0302787591,
-0.1653201282,
-0.0988050774,
-0.0757197142,
0.2652250826,
0.417883724,
-0.3459178507,
-0.0383267775,
-0.2782933116,
-1.0025182962,
0.0026493913,
0.0232506003,
-0.0536028072,
0.6389961839,
0.3279919624,
-0.8986704946,
0.4613087475,
0.3614708483,
-0.3639392555,
0.8259620667,
-0.0439617932,
0.4027699828,
-0.763512969,
0.0981686711,
-0.2556008697,
-0.0604097955,
-0.5857356191,
-0.108501792,
0.234016493,
0.1571121067,
-0.1581690013,
0.2829719484,
-0.4905280769,
-0.1603115946,
-0.1689905822,
0.2050448656,
0.0745075271,
0.2321911901,
-0.2588792443,
0.9095611572,
0.2375499457,
-0.4449269474,
0.3584062457,
0.2995359898,
-0.8810670972,
0.2386764437,
-0.440305531,
0.1828922331,
-0.1827346981,
0.2949807346,
-0.869795382,
-0.1375381202,
0.3715538383,
-0.2254596055,
0.322072506,
0.1467232555,
-0.7556618452,
0.0300676357,
-0.5217865705,
0.2919628322,
0.5667780042,
-0.5811623335,
0.2392927259,
0.2101119608,
0.0826635286,
-0.812656939,
-0.7376049161,
0.3888792396,
-0.0072815046,
-0.7349358797,
0.227958709,
-0.1873233467,
-0.5377613306,
0.3431575894,
-0.4216426313,
0.2921274006,
0.1466083229,
-0.1248699948,
0.366925329,
-0.311309129,
-0.0675163642,
0.096988067,
-0.0810852796,
0.4232339263,
-0.0212605391,
0.0649309531,
0.0076858592,
-0.4045303166,
-0.784602046,
0.0407622196,
0.5144943595,
-0.2719587982,
1.0431725979,
0.390163213,
-0.3797504008,
0.0109978495,
-0.9234617949,
-0.0691716745,
-0.4296624362,
0.3424112797,
-0.1804914325,
-0.9126977324,
0.539578259,
-0.1395813078,
-0.1904205829,
0.4655674994,
0.2937227786,
-0.0171853062,
0.6822776198,
0.5679026246,
-0.0670398474,
-0.0378880613,
-0.1705628484,
0.273757726,
-0.8188356757,
-0.5578456521,
-0.3995035589,
-0.1618171483,
-0.4240188003,
-0.4971652627,
0.2273202091,
0.1338138431,
0.4194917083,
-0.1211338416,
-0.1652322859,
0.6228300333,
0.2548244894,
0.1969413012,
0.4893636107,
0.1795466244,
-0.1407521516,
-0.1656790823,
-0.7497224808,
-0.6393277049,
1.306322813,
0.3000920117,
0.6833053827,
0.2508451045,
0.3970848918,
0.4507972896,
0.2136243284,
-0.7404383421,
0.6586430669,
0.0111723235,
-0.4549200535,
-0.1236206666,
-0.4813711941,
-0.457677424,
0.1372111142,
-0.4722873867,
-0.534245491,
0.2580104172,
0.1575677544,
-0.2807762921,
0.7546085715,
-0.628913343,
0.6827887297,
-0.0543722138,
-0.3903050423,
-0.3293089569,
-0.4789230227,
0.6808995008,
0.0935338587,
0.454793632,
-0.1453730911,
-0.0404875614,
0.844034493,
-0.2226546109,
0.834682107,
-0.1430634111,
-0.2838231027,
0.2643941939,
0.196106717,
0.6864883304,
0.2074616849,
-0.3443095386,
0.0852619559,
0.0774053931,
-0.3952706754,
-0.7150810957,
0.515200913,
-0.7545995712,
-0.9198518991,
-0.4305311739,
-0.6944106221,
-0.4354502857,
-0.0118559347,
0.1020948738,
0.4043880999,
-0.3153041303,
0.1056703329,
1.0843930244,
-0.0094260713,
0.1292123497,
0.3849962056,
0.121178925,
-0.5916695595,
0.7833065391,
0.2133761495,
0.1829480678,
0.4081206322,
-0.0154823065,
-0.3630698323,
-0.9504333735,
-0.2545745373,
0.3900422454,
-1.0364793539,
-0.2521946728,
-0.6703200936,
-0.0634547621,
-0.737483561,
-0.1277669966,
-0.2873928845,
-0.6175575256,
-0.397785753,
-0.3085230291,
0.316301614,
0.8832588196,
-0.2112010568,
-0.0459084585,
-0.7918547392,
0.4324623644,
0.3142338693,
0.3603982627,
-0.00144398,
-0.5558603406,
-0.3735976815,
-0.0212131329,
-0.0267056208,
-0.9436177015,
0.0209291484,
-0.1942044348,
0.6367963552,
0.3947770596,
0.2743996084,
0.7317840457,
-0.4263228476,
0.7453454733,
-0.067607224,
-0.9531342387,
0.2695705295,
0.1456992328,
0.0763371512,
0.5579980612,
0.2157242,
-0.5437553525,
-0.1718970239,
-0.4254239202,
-0.5407529473,
0.7037116885,
0.0905092135,
-0.0887824148,
0.0907245353,
0.54782933,
0.2439537793,
0.2389244139,
-0.4401126504,
-0.2016065419,
-0.0930734947,
-0.165996775,
-0.0322482549,
-1.0808235407,
-0.3071897924,
-0.3778041005,
0.7910154462,
0.239299193,
0.2545144856,
0.3720161021,
-0.3814398646,
-0.1261390299,
0.499382019,
0.830794394,
0.7049409151,
-0.427069664,
0.2597417533,
0.5555481315,
-0.438147217,
0.1003924757,
-0.0728633553,
-0.1808640212,
0.0290996004,
0.6030747294,
0.8683386445,
0.3269014955,
-0.6243373752,
0.3448749185,
-0.2063410133,
-0.3371219635,
0.0497107767,
0.2819381058,
0.0909737498,
0.4351635277,
0.2295982093,
0.2916385531,
0.1104498431,
-0.4086899757,
-0.109953694,
0.3701933324,
0.113341555,
-0.3621181846,
0.6640083194,
0.1968483627,
-0.0325677358,
0.6103717685,
-0.2825241387,
-0.4716488421,
0.4715885222,
0.7786497474,
0.7866563797,
-0.1002339274,
0.0343177617,
0.4053781033,
0.7481942773,
-0.2649731338,
0.0166448727,
-0.1132095531,
-0.794130981,
-0.282142818,
-0.5739224553,
-0.6123161316,
0.0541006699,
-0.6376062632,
0.0549244992,
-0.3954954147,
0.0943608806,
-0.4875660539,
0.1072557345,
-0.4048830569,
0.1421627998,
0.0995146409,
1.1389614344,
-0.5905039907,
0.7747949958,
0.5228151679,
-0.0309136342,
-0.545243144,
0.2686942518,
0.0931189582,
-0.5238901377,
0.2905671299,
0.132638976,
-0.4396948218,
-0.0985296443,
-0.5844169259,
-1.026155591,
1.2338273525,
0.7194506526,
-0.464188844,
-0.1329700947,
0.3199001849,
0.345328033,
-0.1892390549,
-0.1833464354,
0.7838843465,
0.4971988797,
0.024350604,
-0.5580738187,
0.3691211045,
-0.1230420619,
0.0720463991,
-0.316767633,
-0.5139797926,
0.5501050949,
-0.3832796514,
-0.4643070996,
0.0033401826,
0.7553467155,
0.1268732697,
0.4151876271,
0.3022741377,
0.7790713906,
1.0373159647,
0.1039136425,
0.9993014932,
-0.36094594,
0.2482681274,
0.9074972868,
-0.453528583,
0.7505583763,
0.4405197501,
-0.1937386245,
0.5077342391,
0.390484482,
0.0099572083,
0.5514038801,
-0.1672804356,
-0.4227545559,
-0.2133047283,
0.0426224135,
-0.5802569985,
0.3276711106,
0.3797599971,
-0.0470417626,
-0.1554760635,
-0.2279405296,
0.3598365784,
0.1221858412,
-0.0802614093,
0.6241784692,
-0.1748198271,
-0.4928896725,
0.7759305835,
0.2635730505,
0.5043278337,
-0.4079173505,
0.0558668412,
-0.4680145681,
0.0255694594,
-0.2841462493,
-0.6458337903,
0.401448518,
0.3334240913,
-0.31682989,
0.0835523233,
0.8011782765,
-0.3073030114,
-0.3867745996,
0.1586258411,
0.3080163598,
0.0303743333,
0.1280018836,
-0.4128024876,
0.5241048932,
0.0509239957,
-0.1937685162,
0.0578879453,
0.3635711074,
0.2383819371,
0.4555777013,
0.6857097745,
0.0873938948,
0.116855219,
-0.1175105348,
0.9439915419,
-0.8236533403,
-0.1904517263,
-0.8874880672,
0.4087890983,
-0.0391420126,
0.0567711182,
0.9786728024,
0.6515012383,
0.9892657399,
-0.1488385648,
0.7669505477,
0.2663708031,
0.226232633,
-1.0243383646,
0.8487101793,
-0.3506728709,
0.5557909608,
-0.1667393893,
-0.8654099703,
-0.4741438031,
0.2173739374,
-0.3399091661,
-0.1834439337,
0.8793629408,
0.9454651475,
0.1428631693,
0.2600484192,
0.3926245272,
0.412409693,
0.1069628373,
0.2419440448,
0.8969503045,
-0.4597392678,
0.5380946398,
-0.4602141976,
-0.1625446528,
-0.4093649089,
-0.7671713233,
-0.8033507466,
-0.1819892675,
-0.2792652547,
-0.4321469963,
0.4656167924,
0.8519970775,
0.1754520237,
-0.6800824404,
-0.2277046591,
0.1950874478,
0.4357312322,
-0.2440828532,
-0.141411975,
0.3702371418,
-0.412814796,
-0.3791168034,
0.6040615439,
0.2476427108,
-0.0189439319,
0.1579139233,
-0.0814580321,
-0.2295947075,
0.29259938,
0.7666549087,
0.2471197098,
-0.6899002194,
-0.4238544106,
0.1248377711,
-0.1383755654,
0.1690803468,
0.768425107,
-0.7199965119,
0.5133467317,
0.258461535,
0.9080795646,
0.2475824654,
0.0208087061,
0.1031775475,
-0.4124414623,
0.1405553073,
-0.126925692,
0.3577528298,
0.5295031071,
-0.5078268647,
0.3181952834,
0.6567837596,
-0.5547472239,
-1.0772540569,
-0.0285610128,
-1.0097202063,
-0.1771576852,
1.1906040907,
0.084940508,
-0.5605784059,
0.0767585859,
-0.1559835225,
0.5728165507,
-0.1853965074,
1.0310878754,
0.8320348859,
-0.1334248334,
0.0135169541,
-0.5169124603,
0.590303421,
0.4123062789,
-0.8064023256,
0.267609179,
0.6839207411,
0.4103623331,
-0.1521457583,
0.4433319867,
-0.1078528538,
0.3913189471,
0.2310881615,
0.1077214554,
-0.2184247226,
-0.335134089,
-0.4906398356,
0.0872683525,
0.3494076729,
-0.1109814271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00213v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00213v2
|
Injecting New Knowledge into Large Language Models via Supervised Fine-Tuning
| 2024-03-30T01:56:07 | 2024-04-02T20:09:45 |
Nick Mecklenburg, Yiyou Lin, Xiaoxiao Li, Daniel Holstein, Leonardo Nunes, Sara Malvar, Bruno Silva, Ranveer Chandra, Vijay Aski, Pavan Kumar Reddy Yannam, Tolga Aktas, Todd Hendry
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable
performance in generating human-like text, proving to be a valuable asset
across various applications. However, adapting these models to incorporate new,
out-of-domain knowledge remains a challenge, particularly for facts and events
that occur after the model's knowledge cutoff date. This paper investigates the
effectiveness of Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) as a method for knowledge
injection in LLMs, specifically focusing on the domain of recent sporting
events. We compare different dataset generation strategies -- token-based and
fact-based scaling -- to create training data that helps the model learn new
information. Our experiments on GPT-4 demonstrate that while token-based
scaling can lead to improvements in Q&A accuracy, it may not provide uniform
coverage of new knowledge. Fact-based scaling, on the other hand, offers a more
systematic approach to ensure even coverage across all facts. We present a
novel dataset generation process that leads to more effective knowledge
ingestion through SFT, and our results show considerable performance
improvements in Q&A tasks related to out-of-domain knowledge. This study
contributes to the understanding of domain adaptation for LLMs and highlights
the potential of SFT in enhancing the factuality of LLM responses in specific
knowledge domains.
|
[
-0.3083510101,
-1.001858592,
0.5132122636,
-0.1625146866,
-0.1844563335,
0.0106147612,
-0.4712556899,
-0.3926029205,
-0.1392654628,
0.5229610205,
-0.5363194942,
-0.4335432649,
-0.5737338662,
-0.1433841586,
-0.2470102012,
1.2918884754,
0.0089682974,
-0.0541792102,
-0.3202961981,
-0.1582416296,
-0.6239219904,
-0.7160138488,
-0.912093997,
-0.298417747,
0.1985774487,
0.4076324105,
0.603853941,
0.7900105119,
0.7224562764,
0.2274496257,
0.0166468509,
0.6924189329,
-0.7996963859,
-0.142743215,
-0.5316455364,
-0.5967997313,
-0.3691829741,
0.0529617295,
0.6125802398,
0.7089012265,
-0.0746276006,
0.184675172,
0.0214661919,
0.6811772585,
-0.5314980149,
0.4199537933,
-0.9898756146,
-0.0550194569,
-0.1754227579,
-0.5499276519,
-0.295878619,
-0.219618395,
0.1234113798,
-0.9165765047,
0.369871527,
0.1738911271,
0.9172640443,
0.4752868116,
-0.3791184127,
-0.3297825754,
-0.5830693841,
0.7193655372,
-0.7883318067,
0.2896081507,
0.31107077,
0.2624008656,
-0.3959334493,
-0.4491883218,
-0.3937979341,
-0.0210629515,
-0.1296347976,
-0.0795218125,
-0.1083380207,
-0.0077122147,
0.3474942744,
0.0454328582,
-0.250477463,
0.1879684925,
-0.1816920042,
0.0756710172,
0.7477151752,
0.2830549777,
0.1141399592,
0.0128169777,
-0.180054605,
0.199554041,
-0.894749403,
0.1228475347,
0.1064823493,
0.6770331264,
0.0254778769,
0.4406630695,
-0.5783386827,
0.6555540562,
0.5014902353,
-0.3754963577,
0.0746973231,
-0.3960131705,
-0.1679561585,
-0.0595819727,
0.3491010368,
0.5997047424,
0.444221437,
-0.352717191,
-0.0795565695,
-0.3207802176,
0.00281914,
-1.0038691759,
-0.3102703393,
-0.0965931267,
-0.1854024529,
-0.4117164612,
0.1129923537,
-0.2696356773,
-0.4724705517,
-0.6326032877,
0.6492005587,
-0.3969326317,
-0.1158559844,
0.4087258875,
-0.2114699334,
0.0903575048,
0.5262967348,
-1.031868577,
0.1615333408,
0.7065648437,
0.5541023016,
-0.3590349853,
-0.1109797731,
-0.9179130197,
0.2895987928,
-0.3416653275,
0.8171106577,
-0.4034257829,
0.0810174569,
0.145975396,
0.0322765857,
0.0046708668,
-0.7200986147,
0.2141389847,
-0.6464018226,
-0.029827131,
-0.3851496279,
-0.8657745123,
0.0621518902,
0.2898528278,
-0.1717430055,
1.0515755415,
0.0691599622,
-0.6976391673,
0.8607289195,
-0.7056602836,
-0.648750782,
0.0479880981,
-0.0472518615,
-0.3320842087,
0.151732102,
0.6437396407,
0.7879713178,
-0.1311266124,
0.3894768059,
-0.2618487775,
-0.3612528741,
0.2512511611,
-0.2423629165,
0.4170911014,
-0.07111644,
-0.1118689328,
-0.0895131901,
-0.8063148856,
-0.0924571529,
-0.0740858316,
-0.4853855371,
-0.3866924644,
0.084273167,
-0.2919753194,
0.155770734,
0.1351368874,
-0.4348062277,
0.4055829346,
-0.5148437619,
0.4958570898,
0.6748097539,
0.4325809181,
0.6065496206,
-0.3563859761,
0.2419948727,
0.2305772901,
0.1859996915,
-0.0870975778,
-0.2189389467,
-0.6053763032,
-0.2170302123,
0.2395937741,
0.4160456955,
-1.0013011694,
0.3801339269,
-0.4011744261,
-0.3368810713,
-0.2232606709,
0.2326692045,
0.0010289364,
0.6737415791,
0.3665628731,
-0.1561089903,
-0.4216524661,
-0.6554626822,
-0.3746571541,
-0.0927150026,
-0.0687070638,
0.6027292013,
0.3811168671,
0.0571366288,
0.9875316024,
-0.7368319631,
-0.5014136434,
-0.0296804216,
0.1370218992,
0.111298807,
0.426125735,
0.6974255443,
-0.6810037494,
-0.353744626,
0.1565853357,
-0.7168321013,
-0.0164028946,
-0.314199388,
-0.1005489156,
0.1594450325,
0.6331087947,
-0.2732703686,
0.1806845367,
0.4332671762,
-0.3239968419,
0.5286474824,
-0.2019100636,
0.3875634074,
-0.9904586077,
-0.1924601793,
-0.0618596599,
-0.4374876022,
-0.6471863389,
-0.06104495,
0.105304718,
0.2060006857,
-0.6679346561,
0.4913015664,
-0.2447576523,
0.1609252542,
-0.3628328443,
0.163879931,
0.0175076034,
0.3851307034,
0.1147382185,
0.9186843038,
0.4852437675,
-0.7222402692,
0.2702779174,
0.2444850802,
-0.665229857,
0.5711666942,
-0.1985889971,
-0.059605442,
-0.1071505174,
0.1572001576,
-0.6802922487,
-0.3144564331,
-0.1634896398,
-0.2688654959,
0.3573217094,
-0.3496256173,
-0.6533600688,
-0.0988037139,
-0.11777246,
0.3531380892,
0.3729995787,
-0.7302988768,
0.2767134011,
0.5291591883,
-0.2290852666,
-0.2305413634,
-0.5626653433,
-0.0309743006,
-0.3727516532,
-0.4990289509,
0.0957498103,
-0.0115176886,
-0.1092081442,
-0.0498392396,
-0.1497660726,
-0.2395806611,
0.1540807337,
-0.0459891595,
-0.0133552114,
-0.4924516678,
0.3607491553,
0.2447428107,
0.2193191946,
-0.0309432484,
-0.4980449378,
0.1603441983,
0.0967837647,
-0.1922684759,
-0.5685884953,
0.0384850688,
0.2526586652,
-0.1430757344,
0.846339345,
0.4439607859,
-0.2285067439,
-0.3786916137,
-0.611952126,
-0.4995306432,
-0.4443728328,
0.5243199468,
-0.3650047481,
-1.3701425791,
0.3711125255,
-0.551004231,
0.0141599532,
0.4970122576,
0.6490110159,
-0.3013877869,
0.9989038706,
0.6572775841,
-0.1051721498,
0.7093542814,
-0.0376404263,
0.1088160127,
-0.6932675242,
0.0975023955,
-0.36699301,
-0.2489800453,
-0.4633170068,
-0.5931133628,
0.3176704049,
0.1723869741,
-0.213904202,
0.2555212975,
-0.1863197982,
0.744374156,
0.3487829864,
0.2020580918,
0.4950935841,
-0.1301558167,
0.2348279804,
-0.0990853533,
-0.9433550239,
-0.1363289803,
1.2071222067,
0.2109392285,
0.7326177359,
0.0162300076,
0.4563578665,
0.2411928177,
0.5235902667,
-0.7286204696,
0.1002399772,
-0.2976709604,
-0.6873186231,
-0.6717931032,
-0.513987124,
-0.5564237833,
0.0554512106,
-0.3159045279,
-0.5283034444,
0.224108696,
0.2014303207,
-0.5333504677,
0.3601210713,
-0.7576044202,
0.4462677538,
-0.0201067552,
-0.2716332972,
0.073316969,
-0.3913214803,
0.3622829318,
-0.5188391805,
0.452246815,
-0.2007117867,
0.1890497208,
0.7225833535,
-0.3942323923,
0.8862575889,
-0.1881790161,
-0.2803616822,
0.2048744708,
-0.0023494409,
0.8303253651,
0.3631917238,
-0.0546903946,
-0.0489021838,
0.0448173359,
-0.3989913762,
-0.9322327971,
0.5843490362,
-0.6346893311,
-0.7469912171,
0.1308446527,
-0.894184649,
-0.6154688597,
0.0821206644,
-0.0152396392,
0.3902215064,
-0.1778309643,
0.3772804737,
0.8222487569,
-0.1737133861,
0.0095455898,
0.7684971094,
-0.0431433767,
-0.113216199,
0.8737906814,
0.24696666,
0.3249895275,
0.6228256822,
0.2208188772,
-0.233099997,
-0.8429810405,
-0.462256372,
0.1861618459,
-0.4037081897,
-0.57848984,
-0.4436969161,
-0.0009374517,
-0.5539416671,
-0.2495296299,
-0.3264445961,
-0.5750684738,
-0.2351291776,
-0.2668953538,
0.6435832381,
0.6750923395,
-0.1426736116,
0.4907704294,
-0.5749426484,
0.1292083114,
0.1711090803,
0.3381493092,
-0.3166628778,
-0.8680645823,
-0.6669721603,
0.0698624328,
-0.1538273394,
-0.3692022562,
0.1247210279,
0.4371365905,
0.333659023,
0.4160443246,
0.0935774073,
0.7489191294,
-0.6044186354,
0.7980830669,
-0.1232275218,
-0.7486404777,
0.6540095806,
-0.6438567042,
0.31507653,
0.6075307727,
0.190187335,
-0.3906897008,
-0.5860270262,
-0.5334678888,
-0.5778034925,
0.787466526,
-0.0362790152,
0.2676751912,
0.0104166511,
0.7779428959,
0.2639566958,
0.4121489823,
-0.2626800835,
-0.0372755155,
0.1516071409,
-0.0972930044,
-0.3053898811,
-0.0616495386,
-0.0295507628,
-0.5095533729,
0.8399598002,
-0.4280176461,
-0.1512428671,
-0.1381723732,
-0.1828600615,
-0.2174193859,
0.1038514301,
0.4965736866,
0.7216544747,
-0.2202793807,
0.0388389006,
0.582801044,
-0.2388205528,
-0.1229127347,
-0.0033263762,
-0.2660076022,
-0.2730270922,
0.380011797,
0.7200225592,
0.4862035215,
-0.5315060616,
0.5031951666,
0.1942778528,
-0.5680549741,
0.4236975014,
0.2393395156,
0.014722283,
0.4149427116,
0.2769103944,
-0.060885936,
-0.0148215275,
-0.620259583,
0.5193601847,
0.3814808726,
-0.3030822873,
-0.0760261044,
0.681953609,
0.1266154796,
0.209430173,
0.4086835682,
0.0201307237,
-0.3847664893,
0.3314794004,
0.5190039277,
0.2839151919,
0.0707087368,
0.1965077966,
0.3645856977,
0.0868409052,
-0.0784452409,
0.0970746577,
0.0048453212,
-0.8890854716,
-0.7508333325,
-0.7577428818,
-0.2246066779,
0.1535655409,
-0.609752655,
0.1094619706,
-0.2857092917,
-0.1819720417,
0.1275218129,
0.2007871568,
-0.8650676012,
0.2680446208,
-0.2861942351,
0.9836910367,
-1.0317155123,
0.9333640933,
0.7244206667,
-0.4651985466,
-0.816998601,
0.0384925492,
-0.1163093597,
-0.7588893771,
0.7966399789,
-0.4612396359,
0.2372543067,
0.2939729989,
-0.5993574858,
-0.8569456339,
0.9455714822,
0.4320263565,
-0.3970521986,
-0.0452803224,
0.3973997533,
0.5432912111,
-0.2813815475,
-0.2292589247,
0.7864493132,
0.4546669424,
0.1291531622,
-0.8825542927,
0.1351219267,
0.3590682745,
-0.24729909,
0.3011545539,
-0.6882809997,
0.5495907664,
-0.3190516531,
0.0222727228,
-0.1575731486,
0.8279674053,
-0.0212547462,
0.0108054532,
0.312600553,
0.3971557021,
1.0000671148,
-0.1452282369,
0.8571116328,
-0.0224844739,
0.4881043136,
1.21948421,
-0.1450169384,
0.7718521953,
0.4869080782,
-0.1411999762,
0.097187005,
0.4605585635,
-0.1355506331,
0.6355833411,
0.35410887,
-0.0640096664,
-0.5181699991,
-0.2433021218,
-0.2132359296,
0.3827557564,
0.3601018786,
-0.1564033777,
-0.3939816952,
0.1472442746,
0.1562952399,
0.0602020174,
-0.357832551,
1.0896296501,
-0.1229156479,
-0.4979263246,
0.4443380237,
0.0207415298,
0.6669831276,
-0.3206793666,
0.0664374977,
-0.3627969623,
0.2616191804,
-0.1188941598,
-0.7396404743,
0.1866911501,
0.1447772831,
-0.4139856696,
-0.2374014854,
0.6597449183,
-0.5232441425,
-0.4472943544,
-0.2188742608,
0.5361758471,
0.1560784876,
-0.3257397711,
-0.463350594,
-0.0654179081,
-0.0816891342,
-0.1989429146,
0.5458174944,
0.9533723593,
-0.2393244207,
0.4716065228,
0.7645104527,
0.3135846257,
0.0855991542,
0.2006348222,
0.8539099693,
-0.3286944628,
-0.2492278665,
-0.6947963238,
0.2240665853,
0.0631854534,
-0.1764862537,
0.7175599337,
0.8252096176,
0.9865682721,
-0.1070231274,
0.9502487779,
0.2243016213,
0.4200541973,
-0.5614911914,
0.866173625,
-0.6583914161,
-0.101664111,
-0.0910755917,
-0.3381761014,
-0.5338908434,
0.2818670273,
-0.3972298503,
-0.1874826849,
0.4951774776,
0.8078411818,
-0.0466543436,
0.0002088589,
0.5364730358,
0.3617632687,
0.5179624557,
0.4917915165,
0.5848047137,
-0.433581531,
0.3589376211,
-0.0183344465,
-0.4293309152,
-0.3662847281,
-0.922586441,
-1.1345281601,
-0.6054567695,
-0.4320824146,
-0.0683650523,
0.51178056,
0.8084313273,
0.8594476581,
-0.9815303683,
0.107822068,
0.0557468422,
-0.0796583444,
-0.357096523,
-0.2192265391,
0.59088099,
-0.73734653,
-0.6865064502,
0.3661456704,
0.1227608547,
-0.0395419411,
0.1735529602,
0.1494615376,
-0.131230697,
0.1901033521,
0.9807642698,
0.1359656006,
-0.4634015858,
-0.7105785012,
-0.0985185876,
0.1049815342,
0.0041632871,
0.8115429282,
-0.8229537606,
0.1429969668,
0.3276085258,
0.8869802952,
0.4828602672,
0.1909415126,
0.6568481922,
-0.9827890396,
-0.009465307,
-0.130575791,
0.0189368613,
0.2087676674,
-0.5189762712,
0.4554941654,
0.3043188155,
-0.5324317217,
-0.8147279024,
-0.0703731775,
-0.7201471925,
-0.2678171992,
1.3609610796,
0.2261378169,
-0.0155221857,
-0.1730536968,
-0.3119361699,
0.3298605978,
-0.3530366719,
0.9080852866,
0.8658630252,
-0.2677832544,
0.177733779,
-0.7128792405,
0.9116684794,
0.1348386407,
-0.8764164448,
0.4876401722,
0.3146227002,
0.4516995549,
-0.3969896436,
0.5306224227,
0.1054152101,
0.1087373942,
-0.3755068183,
-0.2754097879,
-0.2218364626,
-0.3129515052,
0.1257197112,
0.151196599,
0.0773210451,
0.042902302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00211v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00211v1
|
Multi-Conditional Ranking with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-30T01:26:05 | 2024-03-30T01:26:05 |
Pouya Pezeshkpour, Estevam Hruschka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Utilizing large language models (LLMs) to rank a set of items has become a
common approach in recommendation and retrieval systems. Typically, these
systems focus on ordering a substantial number of documents in a monotonic
order based on a given query. However, real-world scenarios often present a
different challenge: ranking a comparatively smaller set of items, but
according to a variety of diverse and occasionally conflicting conditions. In
this paper, we define and explore the task of multi-conditional ranking by
introducing MCRank, a benchmark tailored for assessing multi-conditional
ranking across various item types and conditions. Our analysis of LLMs using
MCRank indicates a significant decrease in performance as the number and
complexity of items and conditions grow. To overcome this limitation, we
propose a novel decomposed reasoning method, consisting of EXtracting and
Sorting the conditions, and then Iterativly Ranking the items (EXSIR). Our
extensive experiments show that this decomposed reasoning method enhances LLMs'
performance significantly, achieving up to a 12% improvement over existing
LLMs. We also provide a detailed analysis of LLMs performance across various
condition categories, and examine the effectiveness of decomposition step.
Furthermore, we compare our method with existing approaches such as
Chain-of-Thought and an encoder-type ranking model, demonstrating the
superiority of our approach and complexity of MCR task. We released our dataset
and code.
|
[
-0.4556449056,
-0.5884085894,
0.8258702755,
0.108217746,
-0.2203782201,
0.1928445548,
-0.3717309833,
-0.1770070493,
0.2029944956,
0.4222090244,
-0.3571153283,
-0.8162076473,
-0.9559718966,
0.1782835275,
-0.1536522508,
0.8206467032,
0.2071136832,
-0.090563342,
-0.4221457839,
-0.3382674456,
-0.3441130817,
-0.7547202706,
-0.7106686831,
-0.2713831961,
0.6187332273,
0.5644621849,
0.705180347,
0.2079207599,
0.7830061316,
0.4316419959,
-0.1831639558,
0.3391824067,
-0.5341902971,
0.4777054489,
-0.2801621258,
-0.1976915896,
-0.4230797887,
0.1106248721,
0.4255174994,
0.630816102,
-0.4683833122,
0.205909878,
-0.0194965135,
0.6040315628,
-0.7498435378,
0.3025833666,
-0.6035550237,
-0.1388532072,
-0.0320771448,
-0.3352642357,
-0.7168684006,
-0.3696981966,
-0.0297594927,
-0.2237877846,
-0.0267845578,
0.2747763097,
0.3580602407,
0.2472253591,
-0.7434676886,
-0.153769955,
-0.3126011789,
0.8894869685,
-0.5858398676,
0.6823176146,
0.2608212531,
0.5016381145,
-0.1978495717,
-0.7647279501,
-0.3499996364,
-0.2768653631,
-0.1734022796,
0.1391382068,
0.0926654935,
0.1382074058,
0.3535546064,
0.3385131955,
-0.4957027733,
0.0381641649,
-0.0863671824,
-0.1031379029,
0.3662056029,
0.1611416787,
0.2275507748,
-0.1773495674,
-0.3455577493,
-0.2143890709,
-0.4839043319,
0.2627431154,
0.225001663,
0.4899383485,
0.1154063269,
0.8979362845,
-0.6124438047,
0.7849068046,
-0.1525307447,
-0.5088537931,
0.293083936,
-0.4613270164,
-0.1707552373,
0.0766296983,
0.5093708634,
0.5338632464,
-0.0148300994,
-0.212374121,
-0.2375951856,
0.2206939012,
-0.1048945561,
-1.0391851664,
-0.2884261906,
0.1807322353,
-0.6247828007,
-0.0106454883,
0.0208251812,
-0.631054759,
-0.5078879595,
-0.3356975019,
0.4345660508,
-0.1952584088,
-0.0933676064,
0.2141970396,
-0.1024781689,
-0.1797634214,
0.336412847,
-0.6206799746,
0.209306106,
0.7572670579,
0.6075221896,
-0.1386599094,
-0.369566083,
-0.8214339018,
0.1229960397,
-0.1819677949,
0.823695004,
-0.8995566964,
-0.2978049517,
-0.0966412053,
-0.1470642686,
-0.0241626035,
-0.5727630854,
0.95089221,
-0.5746979117,
0.0168610811,
-0.4678857923,
-0.5014307499,
0.0291756205,
0.4940612018,
-0.5250806808,
0.8528321981,
-0.1426242739,
-0.7450440526,
0.4117537737,
-0.3096530735,
-0.4827982187,
-0.2298534065,
-0.030523954,
-0.1426120996,
-0.026405815,
0.196154952,
0.5487675667,
-0.5317628384,
0.445158124,
-0.7582139969,
-0.3229874969,
0.1083046868,
-0.3760291636,
0.2940886915,
0.2619604468,
-0.0329096168,
-0.0675993785,
-0.4513150454,
0.2578694522,
-0.2105367929,
-0.8427878618,
-0.4537112117,
0.2250194252,
-0.4488054514,
0.5106491446,
0.2685179412,
-0.5246111751,
0.453531146,
-0.3033107817,
0.3991334438,
0.5677820444,
0.1797436029,
0.4732959569,
-0.3048532307,
0.3134937286,
-0.1496061832,
0.2446079254,
-0.1043066531,
-0.5498731136,
-0.9569575787,
-0.4550524056,
0.2571440339,
0.3841483295,
-0.8813300729,
0.0405742563,
-0.3481215835,
-0.0801773891,
-0.5112680793,
0.0772937313,
0.5774052739,
0.1983141899,
0.5842499137,
0.3036067784,
-0.4063293636,
-0.8948115706,
-0.3383549154,
-0.0415570699,
0.1175955161,
0.1435448378,
0.1633210629,
-0.3050096035,
0.4570404887,
-0.6138194203,
-0.2903267443,
-0.1794364899,
0.1016738936,
0.6158696413,
0.1390719712,
0.1418464333,
-0.8250901699,
-0.2337440848,
-0.1844780892,
-0.3815467358,
0.0031702991,
0.3407717645,
-0.1880248338,
0.1331423968,
0.6466349959,
-0.6099309325,
0.3431990445,
0.6067153811,
-0.273189187,
0.4310708046,
-0.3702352047,
0.5482673645,
-0.8065838814,
-0.1439051181,
0.007717838,
-0.3295665085,
-0.2174433023,
0.2813153863,
0.0219540242,
-0.2526519597,
-0.2309205085,
0.4374532402,
-0.3886726499,
0.0338686667,
-0.0267976169,
0.0716738626,
0.0140848504,
0.5499061942,
0.0208751876,
0.4019882083,
0.3695802391,
-0.7594977021,
0.027907921,
0.1500337869,
-0.5623443723,
0.6697305441,
-0.484554857,
-0.1274299473,
0.002723475,
0.408180356,
-0.9629827142,
0.283875078,
-0.1233366206,
-0.1641406715,
0.3056766987,
-0.4499103725,
-0.8431894779,
-0.3029332757,
-0.4366240203,
0.523924768,
0.0448256768,
-0.694803834,
0.5225851536,
0.3624440134,
-0.3578718901,
-0.6311087608,
-0.2767122388,
0.1899882704,
-0.070220761,
-0.5573887229,
0.7886719108,
-0.556114912,
-0.4391576648,
-0.0108939987,
-0.4287379682,
0.244280979,
-0.0733811334,
0.1272813678,
0.0720139369,
-0.0033410233,
0.0911905989,
0.2362217009,
-0.3173260093,
-0.207037881,
-0.0458015017,
0.4491350949,
-0.1197647825,
-0.4583737552,
0.1171025038,
0.4188897312,
0.8519616127,
-0.3560711443,
0.7270866036,
0.2733613253,
-0.1260605901,
-0.3917913735,
-0.734205246,
0.0162233133,
-0.5304000974,
0.0751909763,
-0.7394915223,
-0.728847146,
0.215738982,
-0.1329444498,
-0.0271117408,
0.2456994504,
0.6617165804,
0.0552379414,
1.5923196077,
0.4750261307,
-0.0771564692,
0.2182063311,
-0.3431107104,
0.4921236932,
-0.8346552253,
-0.5964336395,
-0.6479880214,
-0.3418809175,
-0.7631620765,
-0.4945072532,
0.4115298092,
0.1706469357,
-0.3899985254,
-0.0851179883,
-0.3943873942,
0.6264366508,
0.515501976,
0.3308477104,
0.5561934114,
-0.3274720013,
-0.8010796309,
0.4197922945,
-0.6623273492,
-0.21382761,
0.9604297876,
-0.1449390352,
0.6272236109,
0.5754139423,
0.8146525621,
0.5309152603,
0.3634775877,
-0.8768772483,
0.6692438126,
-0.3772869408,
-0.4093276262,
-0.2543986738,
-0.6491848826,
-0.8596681356,
0.767570734,
-0.2786537707,
-0.6100723147,
0.2785181105,
-0.2599754333,
-0.0268907528,
0.0624755882,
-0.723454833,
0.6500595212,
-0.2590844333,
-0.1684324741,
-0.199697867,
-0.4556441605,
0.5083277225,
0.0661517382,
0.4983490109,
-0.3392890096,
-0.0964905471,
0.5550730824,
-0.5276340246,
0.2158246189,
-0.1185841486,
0.1235140413,
-0.2052435875,
0.1918200999,
0.7114550471,
0.3590434492,
-0.6343720555,
-0.0530078299,
0.342682302,
-0.3560038209,
-0.6425955892,
1.261099577,
-0.5174096227,
-0.7813834548,
-0.4227381647,
-0.3667561114,
-0.4045514762,
0.4066063166,
0.1509722173,
0.5225076675,
0.1746162027,
0.3551831245,
0.5362674594,
-0.1827425659,
0.3459046483,
0.7119074464,
-0.3484447002,
-0.4497742355,
0.8597606421,
0.1077201664,
-0.0481065623,
0.7000586987,
0.2107691318,
-0.560829103,
-0.669814527,
0.0697693899,
0.2751113772,
-1.1582618952,
-0.3208613694,
-0.6446474791,
0.22389853,
-0.4389188588,
0.0899388567,
-0.0978964716,
-0.3748569489,
0.0859928429,
-0.0932851359,
-0.0913049877,
0.3828464448,
0.2978614271,
-0.3797345757,
-0.5625969768,
0.7369467616,
0.325071454,
0.7049630284,
0.007265192,
-0.3681119978,
-0.1188139468,
-0.2364025712,
0.045687478,
-0.5820103288,
0.2386206836,
0.1192683652,
1.1395777464,
0.2977666557,
0.4889657497,
0.6194555759,
-0.5799494982,
0.2387219071,
0.0987257659,
-0.6905629635,
0.2680792511,
-0.1772393137,
0.2884738147,
0.864079535,
0.3442603946,
-0.2707878947,
-0.4344165325,
-0.3592338562,
-0.9960067868,
0.5326854587,
0.1826975346,
-0.2095320523,
-0.2193320841,
0.1247047558,
-0.0989149436,
0.3262802064,
-0.6385222077,
-0.54101789,
0.0696059242,
-0.090899758,
-0.628841579,
-0.5009661317,
-0.0140688056,
-0.4729535282,
0.6848165393,
0.0909176022,
0.2318798155,
-0.0355436057,
-0.4141069055,
0.3877246082,
0.4831869006,
0.5447347164,
0.7093365788,
-0.4556315243,
0.4558228254,
0.0861244351,
0.085271351,
0.3098032773,
0.094677113,
0.2860379219,
-0.1684464514,
0.1519872099,
0.3104525805,
0.5663577318,
-0.5883660316,
0.4310379326,
-0.2575205266,
-0.0060846624,
0.1290288866,
-0.0794337317,
0.2615081966,
0.3872744441,
0.2347887903,
0.1110865697,
0.3965934217,
-0.6492971778,
0.0896069929,
0.3606188893,
-0.0728187859,
0.0645464286,
0.1780952811,
0.2324077636,
-0.2507357001,
0.5250880718,
-0.3991785347,
-0.6384390593,
0.3778900206,
0.4419695735,
0.4145008326,
-0.0316697359,
0.2428115904,
0.1934241205,
0.4796976149,
-0.4143956304,
0.2564248741,
-0.2958403826,
-0.6078544259,
-0.3806759119,
-0.8149718046,
-0.5762293935,
-0.0777894631,
-0.605371356,
0.4082669318,
-0.2776608467,
-0.2819115222,
0.1743905097,
0.0122047355,
-0.8900123239,
0.1749983877,
-0.0010140882,
0.7885484099,
-0.5599139333,
0.7225573063,
0.6762132049,
-0.3667715788,
-0.5981016755,
-0.0594003052,
-0.1326609403,
-0.5290452242,
0.6597262025,
0.2931311131,
-0.4492125213,
0.0807440281,
0.0657720193,
-1.0486781597,
0.8964340091,
0.5369394422,
-0.4060668349,
0.3300097883,
-0.2181492895,
0.4404663742,
-0.245134905,
0.559499979,
0.4257540107,
0.7436924577,
-0.0131100249,
-0.6364099979,
0.1896786541,
-0.4822889268,
-0.1164494902,
0.5302024484,
-0.6455245614,
0.7321850657,
-0.2794339359,
-0.0482634678,
0.1036497429,
0.2044285238,
0.395480603,
0.5089002848,
0.4416035712,
0.8524557352,
0.8373164535,
-0.0225629844,
1.3637937307,
-0.2571463883,
0.4269999266,
1.0747330189,
-0.4915904701,
1.0156729221,
0.225262627,
-0.1436036378,
0.6854056716,
0.7536239624,
0.2558116615,
0.7507205606,
0.3707332313,
-0.0972556844,
-0.6885020733,
-0.0040327623,
-0.3536098003,
0.4041962028,
0.1836252213,
-0.2458236963,
-0.2363533974,
0.1430334896,
-0.1370570511,
-0.1110070273,
-0.2741085291,
0.7258588672,
0.096820645,
-0.8276681304,
0.6366133094,
0.391140312,
0.7665163875,
-0.3663881123,
-0.1293890625,
-0.4108073413,
0.1485880315,
-0.1458739191,
-0.4805827737,
-0.2330621928,
-0.1477843523,
-0.6389844418,
-0.428332895,
0.6334913373,
-0.2425905019,
-0.8185713291,
0.4621955752,
0.3713826239,
-0.0458770953,
-0.2046315372,
-0.7292996645,
0.1223245487,
-0.3059981763,
-0.2423479259,
0.7183583379,
0.4052412808,
-0.014284255,
1.0636820793,
0.7800863385,
-0.0923079178,
-0.1773337275,
0.3900026679,
0.7617759705,
-0.5713299513,
-0.4942527711,
-0.839166224,
0.1423655003,
-0.089839071,
0.1354764849,
0.8192024827,
0.641048491,
0.6078935266,
0.4101657867,
0.4732588232,
0.3741047084,
0.5427976251,
-0.7226088643,
0.4937467575,
-0.6983523369,
0.8524224162,
-0.4061751366,
-1.0907987356,
-0.2994345129,
0.1667395234,
-0.3099344373,
0.1948714256,
0.9924972653,
0.6973022819,
-0.1463329494,
-0.4037461579,
0.4174066186,
0.1018514857,
0.2657178044,
0.3633101583,
0.9268775582,
0.0118864216,
0.8455266953,
-0.2488049567,
-0.1410458237,
-0.2950224578,
-0.9814656973,
-0.7648203373,
-0.3432616591,
-0.3434021473,
-0.2719275951,
0.0552458949,
0.8470740914,
0.6447840333,
-0.6362259984,
-0.1282791197,
0.39502424,
0.6939498186,
-0.3053492606,
-0.1980512291,
0.3788734376,
-0.170036763,
-0.6466197968,
0.716440618,
0.3863097727,
-0.5348254442,
0.0077683809,
-0.1201964095,
-0.3982391357,
0.0390315205,
1.0761277676,
-0.1653987914,
-0.8431596756,
-0.2191468328,
-0.0762244686,
0.0283141732,
-0.1598360538,
0.8246220946,
-0.8232781887,
0.5034962893,
0.8068090081,
0.3652375042,
0.7085166574,
0.0940550566,
0.1767236888,
-0.645945847,
-0.3134303987,
0.0683975518,
0.5962195992,
0.1233487055,
-0.1114748716,
0.3645620942,
-0.0689418167,
-0.5255324244,
-0.9646629691,
0.1813199073,
-1.0341352224,
-0.5752177238,
1.3395681381,
-0.0884237736,
0.4715391099,
-0.1312292665,
-0.0558133721,
0.0278565716,
-0.6265204549,
0.7704026699,
0.444934994,
-0.1441485584,
-0.1952415258,
-0.3652001023,
0.1146430969,
0.3185966909,
-0.6996677518,
-0.2624932826,
0.4546392262,
0.3720937669,
-0.0293773953,
0.5837753415,
0.046956636,
-0.0758889019,
-0.4349048436,
-0.2408799976,
-0.1599789411,
-0.4518510103,
-0.0068018222,
0.6390485764,
0.2715474963,
0.1046323106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00209v1
|
EventGround: Narrative Reasoning by Grounding to Eventuality-centric Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-03-30T01:16:37 | 2024-03-30T01:16:37 |
Cheng Jiayang, Lin Qiu, Chunkit Chan, Xin Liu, Yangqiu Song, Zheng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Narrative reasoning relies on the understanding of eventualities in story
contexts, which requires a wealth of background world knowledge. To help
machines leverage such knowledge, existing solutions can be categorized into
two groups. Some focus on implicitly modeling eventuality knowledge by
pretraining language models (LMs) with eventuality-aware objectives. However,
this approach breaks down knowledge structures and lacks interpretability.
Others explicitly collect world knowledge of eventualities into structured
eventuality-centric knowledge graphs (KGs). However, existing research on
leveraging these knowledge sources for free-texts is limited. In this work, we
propose an initial comprehensive framework called EventGround, which aims to
tackle the problem of grounding free-texts to eventuality-centric KGs for
contextualized narrative reasoning. We identify two critical problems in this
direction: the event representation and sparsity problems. We provide simple
yet effective parsing and partial information extraction methods to tackle
these problems. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach consistently
outperforms baseline models when combined with graph neural network (GNN) or
large language model (LLM) based graph reasoning models. Our framework,
incorporating grounded knowledge, achieves state-of-the-art performance while
providing interpretable evidence.
|
[
-0.155819118,
-0.7195283771,
1.1597423553,
0.0590218343,
-0.3006692827,
-0.1411615759,
0.0216223542,
-0.2281779945,
-0.0425519086,
0.5518221259,
-0.585909605,
-0.717615664,
-0.5899313092,
-0.3026500642,
-0.3976716995,
1.1992310286,
-0.2750030756,
-0.5528098345,
-0.4275503755,
-0.3959464133,
-0.5642976165,
-0.7264893651,
-0.5109545588,
-0.4940129817,
0.4400648475,
0.4654538631,
0.5453865528,
0.721919775,
-0.1601872742,
0.1425862908,
-0.1394671947,
0.1517471522,
-0.4655735195,
0.2795891166,
-0.2980845571,
-0.2571801543,
0.0243356209,
0.1493662745,
0.4962702096,
0.9583486319,
0.1042306572,
-0.1160938665,
0.1563040763,
0.3367828727,
-0.3488787711,
0.3451627195,
-0.5214095712,
0.209536761,
-0.0197148621,
-0.3820359409,
-0.6679454446,
-0.0842071697,
0.0492667034,
-0.8281131387,
0.1961077154,
0.0950547233,
0.8310751319,
0.0196078066,
-0.4996674955,
-0.3933671117,
-0.4254225791,
0.4360869527,
-0.2685308754,
0.2502472997,
0.3676498532,
0.0980361477,
-0.2674966753,
-0.8346745968,
-0.5076175928,
-0.1250369102,
-0.213631168,
0.2457495481,
-0.1610238105,
-0.0210845806,
0.2364307046,
-0.1134177893,
-0.479249686,
-0.1371211857,
0.3278656304,
0.0595618598,
0.1333784908,
0.2186290175,
0.4580615759,
-0.3824256063,
-0.3843327463,
0.1725094318,
-0.6733262539,
0.3162149489,
0.0960219577,
0.2795465291,
-0.2421752214,
0.6443615556,
-0.3552904129,
0.7307029366,
0.0916760862,
0.0215084963,
-0.0463422909,
-0.2212287039,
-0.1590504646,
0.2467785478,
0.3502122462,
0.5530439615,
0.1078094393,
-0.5263374448,
0.1896126866,
0.1148557514,
-0.0057090884,
-0.591576457,
0.0970670357,
0.346101284,
-0.4412122071,
-0.3839092553,
-0.2421012819,
-0.4531643093,
-0.6403785348,
-0.5269535184,
0.2201212198,
-0.700528264,
-0.2398674786,
-0.1755723357,
-0.417289108,
0.077183336,
0.5341540575,
-0.4735332727,
-0.1117168963,
0.618135035,
0.8450474143,
0.0875257328,
-0.2425731719,
-0.5758419633,
0.736320436,
-0.2612394392,
0.9083872437,
-0.221113354,
-0.1343492717,
-0.0800416023,
0.0790608451,
-0.117813535,
0.1033061594,
0.8179838657,
-0.5884440541,
0.2437195629,
-0.2526119649,
-0.6592969298,
-0.2420330346,
0.4635383487,
-0.2714799047,
0.8127025962,
-0.0688005909,
-1.0739637613,
0.5026051998,
-0.0773236454,
-0.589458704,
0.043943055,
-0.4160399735,
0.0772195831,
0.0349015929,
0.3952394128,
0.4677090049,
-0.0639677942,
1.0259480476,
-0.1359573305,
-0.2349228263,
-0.0195947383,
-0.3739024997,
0.6292182207,
-0.0270823315,
-0.4754290879,
0.0549696088,
-0.9667187929,
-0.0185030196,
0.0683688447,
0.0101345656,
-0.4982662797,
0.5102508664,
-0.155662775,
0.3328216672,
-0.0033408639,
-0.1613367945,
0.0798832104,
-0.401224196,
0.0375469811,
0.6589400768,
0.1548073888,
0.5650897026,
-0.0786349252,
0.1498984247,
0.1343463212,
-0.248917982,
-0.7422044277,
-0.6625671387,
-0.78193295,
0.0396587253,
-0.0812085643,
0.6435981393,
-0.9929343462,
0.5660692453,
-0.1891706884,
-0.1729387641,
0.3141908348,
-0.5092654824,
0.3201129436,
0.9699512124,
0.4058743417,
0.2337134928,
-0.8300059438,
-0.6711937785,
-0.3271707296,
-0.3732745647,
0.0067825266,
0.0252351929,
0.0119914254,
-0.0474992916,
1.4454665184,
-0.3890317678,
-0.1958912164,
-0.5504205823,
0.3012035787,
0.3784911633,
0.4716539979,
0.3827676177,
-0.759429574,
-0.1098505557,
0.1815283895,
-1.2783579826,
-0.2235257179,
-0.2063817233,
-0.2923360467,
-0.0068172007,
0.419946909,
-0.6869315505,
0.5947695374,
0.0971684679,
-0.889508307,
0.3748297691,
0.0463477373,
0.1692504287,
-0.8906369209,
0.0694877058,
-0.0247136056,
-0.3754090071,
-0.7795733809,
-0.1652983278,
-0.1514539421,
-0.2561781108,
0.0428922027,
0.7686756849,
-0.2694572806,
-0.0327827223,
-0.3635343611,
0.4458579719,
0.2621130347,
0.4310206473,
0.375369817,
0.4159332514,
0.2221253067,
-0.4627565444,
-0.0742836222,
0.2497799098,
-0.1354241222,
0.4186109304,
-0.2831511796,
-0.169770956,
-0.4780888259,
0.4734957218,
-0.8622969389,
-0.2634193301,
0.3135559261,
-0.628038466,
0.1635432094,
-0.6402295828,
-0.4139540493,
-0.113282226,
0.2265090942,
0.044168625,
0.3871477842,
-0.4691418409,
0.7011245489,
0.3679943979,
-0.2174154967,
-0.5662065148,
-0.3334017694,
0.2464924902,
-0.1786593348,
-0.7488467693,
0.2351646274,
0.1747668535,
-0.4390846789,
0.2305175066,
-0.0706856772,
-0.0662539527,
0.0339521766,
0.4037945271,
0.1065755635,
-0.2227586955,
0.0682873502,
0.3732410073,
-0.734767735,
-0.0725972429,
-0.75655967,
0.3863322437,
0.0077215321,
-0.4316447675,
-0.0906498879,
0.5539426804,
0.3174294829,
0.2599390745,
0.8991371989,
0.3138105571,
-0.7495533824,
0.0875319019,
-0.6288185716,
0.3116098344,
-0.3161723912,
0.1954635531,
-0.3249737918,
-0.8464640379,
0.6343806982,
-0.2144672126,
-0.0395241529,
0.626260519,
0.4296023548,
-0.1078461483,
1.0114086866,
0.4894171059,
0.3414551616,
0.2167609334,
0.015595356,
0.1477632821,
-0.514398396,
-0.4578395784,
-0.3941295743,
0.1667278856,
0.2984098792,
-0.4745055735,
0.2518005371,
0.6361911297,
-0.268404305,
0.2331829071,
-0.2193370163,
0.6390757561,
0.2876287997,
-0.226089254,
0.5230979919,
0.1133942306,
-0.4764967561,
-0.2051373124,
-0.661473155,
-0.8654752374,
0.6512191892,
0.1113796458,
-0.0692617148,
-0.2661379576,
0.2809846103,
0.2208546549,
0.4742880464,
-0.1456656158,
0.3686164618,
0.0969807804,
-0.5772534609,
-0.2616161108,
-0.3573144376,
-0.6574584246,
0.5886440277,
0.0797671825,
-1.2716546059,
0.3150110245,
-0.2145166844,
-0.2423619777,
0.2612390816,
-0.7001324892,
0.9945845604,
-0.0545485839,
-0.4423204958,
0.180142343,
-0.827521801,
0.1984651089,
0.2688594162,
0.7763471603,
-0.4372055531,
0.2589859664,
0.6978953481,
-0.2585964501,
0.7840284109,
-0.4178661406,
0.1039034501,
0.6867998838,
0.2176868767,
0.6685703993,
0.4712269604,
-0.2390883267,
0.1325350553,
-0.0977443904,
-0.2111112028,
-0.6057175398,
0.4799709916,
-0.671146214,
-0.5048048496,
-0.3546618819,
-0.4504393935,
-0.5615491867,
0.3485794365,
0.4151812196,
0.6929104328,
-0.3323123455,
-0.0487239063,
0.5728307962,
-0.0873914063,
0.4341201782,
0.5484190583,
-0.325702697,
-0.5600438714,
0.75258255,
0.1368581355,
-0.2326726168,
0.3723724782,
0.0359902382,
-0.1527951509,
-0.6195117235,
-0.8979120255,
-0.2559329569,
-1.0872353315,
-0.3495082855,
-1.1774914265,
-0.3036502004,
-0.1025765315,
-0.662016809,
-0.1186000705,
-0.5912794471,
-0.5793741941,
-0.5570756793,
0.1403018534,
0.4020901322,
-0.1594439298,
0.4944677055,
-0.842936635,
0.4757564068,
-0.2847216725,
0.0811063945,
0.1194145307,
-0.3480642438,
-0.346324861,
-0.0908870175,
-0.2967844605,
-1.010155201,
0.2914821804,
-0.2469953746,
0.761839509,
0.5307232738,
0.0618985817,
0.6339023113,
-0.6419537663,
0.7008592486,
0.4378601909,
-1.0035116673,
0.8771485686,
-0.6545942426,
-0.0855601951,
0.6387187839,
0.2878232598,
-0.8172435164,
-0.4078447521,
-0.8410840034,
-1.0530751944,
1.0003545284,
0.5349253416,
-0.1246667877,
-0.1276991069,
0.4919739962,
0.3163053393,
0.1825372726,
-0.9387939572,
-0.1761356592,
-0.1789491773,
-0.3521131277,
-0.1472534537,
-0.4360280931,
-0.2072892636,
-0.196724847,
0.579318583,
-0.3143911362,
-0.0239431281,
0.2509245574,
-0.2867148817,
-0.0540182367,
0.1606279165,
0.1336144954,
0.7513068318,
-0.0257020742,
0.3278032541,
0.1580218524,
-0.0574521497,
0.4215702116,
0.4264981747,
-0.5351852775,
-0.0573723316,
0.7329154015,
0.8866869807,
0.4196923375,
-0.6789258718,
0.6303325295,
-0.085556969,
0.0476887524,
-0.275072068,
-0.1812716126,
0.14892295,
0.3481526077,
0.6396557689,
-0.0291736349,
-0.0226528458,
-0.3490413129,
0.4071822464,
0.0139203221,
-0.5566276908,
-0.2081002295,
0.6697331071,
0.0273283608,
0.1164179891,
0.4808059037,
-0.3725291789,
-0.3858659565,
0.8316270113,
0.6230089664,
0.6194325686,
0.207880795,
0.3383089006,
0.267544955,
0.2939932048,
0.0919867307,
-0.0721582174,
0.0096955746,
-0.871315062,
-0.4649851322,
-0.6196113825,
-0.2487823069,
-0.1274675727,
-0.2643603981,
0.3412003517,
-0.1962523609,
0.0856886208,
-0.3227414191,
-0.2746880054,
-0.2746548355,
0.4348903596,
0.3935712278,
0.7019722462,
-0.780013442,
0.3711279929,
0.6066035032,
-0.4641967118,
-0.666790843,
0.0694652423,
-0.1882410496,
-0.4949414134,
0.5474052429,
0.5804017782,
0.2030697167,
-0.0348841585,
-0.2887532115,
-1.0468127728,
1.1073778868,
0.4169256985,
-0.3684863746,
-0.2842885554,
-0.0627726763,
0.4637611806,
-0.5937069058,
0.3618089855,
0.3619838059,
0.3998875618,
0.4030252993,
-0.1669438481,
0.0865183845,
-0.1321995109,
-0.1991899759,
-0.0592593849,
-0.2226783186,
0.5772907138,
-0.0523805656,
-0.4454095364,
-0.1115949154,
0.8755133748,
0.6618233323,
0.9852828383,
0.3205617964,
0.8031082153,
0.8490301371,
-0.2735358179,
1.0526417494,
-0.2973966897,
0.2291535884,
1.0835059881,
-0.4824588001,
0.2470854521,
0.2089860439,
0.0729535148,
0.5832089186,
0.7027212977,
0.6941910386,
0.7274495959,
0.0540329032,
-0.3066264987,
-0.4544167817,
-0.2606215477,
-0.5086299181,
0.1090523228,
0.4908019602,
-0.2340279967,
-0.5720464587,
0.2351968884,
0.2273402512,
-0.0703684017,
-0.3320437372,
0.7143256068,
0.1342444718,
-0.724781692,
0.0218360797,
0.3095066249,
-0.0193014778,
-0.6703397036,
-0.023025237,
-0.1458627284,
0.1410879046,
-0.0172031224,
-0.7745886445,
0.4604802132,
0.1505824178,
-0.4237948656,
-0.4349530935,
1.1759316921,
-0.1833978891,
-0.4641351402,
0.3986461163,
0.7740775943,
-0.211620748,
-0.2562611699,
-0.1313193142,
0.0074540568,
-0.0813364387,
-0.4450003505,
0.375515908,
1.0392810106,
-0.195670858,
0.3817035258,
0.6679111123,
-0.2922984064,
-0.2284443229,
0.1176597774,
1.0857759714,
-0.6570641398,
-1.0549030304,
-0.8290076852,
0.7570719123,
-0.2972629368,
-0.1356179863,
0.5707176328,
0.530010879,
0.155549109,
0.3047828674,
0.9094876051,
-0.0240721274,
0.3831657767,
-0.717258513,
0.6892393231,
-0.2693052888,
0.0251918957,
-0.3780103922,
-0.6041340232,
-0.4343990982,
0.4819919169,
-0.3201326132,
-0.1906012744,
0.7727791667,
-0.151570037,
0.0996685699,
0.4659536779,
0.2679672241,
-0.0729601011,
0.2627078891,
0.5566799641,
1.2389658689,
-0.1485503912,
0.418010056,
0.0536711998,
-0.5617870688,
0.0262047574,
-1.2097220421,
-0.7507330775,
-0.6169269085,
-0.1850373745,
-0.4555638433,
0.4747840166,
0.5551171303,
0.5212789774,
-0.6025523543,
0.2046489567,
-0.4709065855,
0.4216171801,
0.1462288052,
-0.2264897525,
0.3767805398,
-0.4803946614,
-0.0332756415,
0.6007815003,
0.4617599547,
0.0178920962,
0.363375634,
-0.0125240646,
-0.0666505545,
0.0679738522,
0.7416983247,
0.1583375037,
-0.4628767967,
-0.5529279113,
-0.4157738686,
0.1201244891,
0.1323977262,
1.1293814182,
-1.1716481447,
0.0077630756,
0.1173619777,
0.6108400226,
0.5684824586,
0.0628506169,
0.5306897759,
-1.0422519445,
0.5738552809,
0.1959304214,
0.5774973035,
0.2309054434,
-0.646245122,
0.5988093019,
0.7037013769,
-0.2418893874,
-0.7212318182,
0.192764163,
-0.8468737006,
-0.3277968764,
1.2924515009,
-0.2156454474,
0.1275880337,
-0.4554438889,
-0.1896398813,
0.5623995066,
-0.0799964741,
0.2019860893,
1.0242928267,
-0.2311203927,
-0.0490626246,
-0.4514829516,
0.1826283336,
0.101335153,
-0.9544790983,
0.3862277567,
0.7649133205,
-0.0871758685,
0.185595423,
1.2064769268,
-0.0441590734,
-0.0708255321,
0.2169342935,
-0.0279007945,
-0.2326429635,
-0.6613644958,
-0.0510270745,
0.6030554771,
-0.3617367744,
0.4274660647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00207v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00207v1
|
Causal Inference for Human-Language Model Collaboration
| 2024-03-30T01:08:25 | 2024-03-30T01:08:25 |
Bohan Zhang, Yixin Wang, Paramveer S. Dhillon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we examine the collaborative dynamics between humans and
language models (LMs), where the interactions typically involve LMs proposing
text segments and humans editing or responding to these proposals. Productive
engagement with LMs in such scenarios necessitates that humans discern
effective text-based interaction strategies, such as editing and response
styles, from historical human-LM interactions. This objective is inherently
causal, driven by the counterfactual `what-if' question: how would the outcome
of collaboration change if humans employed a different text editing/refinement
strategy? A key challenge in answering this causal inference question is
formulating an appropriate causal estimand: the conventional average treatment
effect (ATE) estimand is inapplicable to text-based treatments due to their
high dimensionality. To address this concern, we introduce a new causal
estimand -- Incremental Stylistic Effect (ISE) -- which characterizes the
average impact of infinitesimally shifting a text towards a specific style,
such as increasing formality. We establish the conditions for the
non-parametric identification of ISE. Building on this, we develop
CausalCollab, an algorithm designed to estimate the ISE of various interaction
strategies in dynamic human-LM collaborations. Our empirical investigations
across three distinct human-LM collaboration scenarios reveal that CausalCollab
effectively reduces confounding and significantly improves counterfactual
estimation over a set of competitive baselines.
|
[
-0.3633294404,
-1.2075961828,
0.6783638597,
0.414056927,
0.0431752242,
0.0534901172,
-0.3209098577,
-0.7018627524,
0.5105798244,
0.6012907624,
-0.8591995835,
-0.3138903975,
-0.4932893813,
0.2343674451,
-0.3619495928,
0.7613451481,
-0.035119351,
0.0550882332,
-0.3713582456,
-0.2577100992,
-1.0281741619,
-0.305432111,
-0.7884147763,
-0.4678740203,
0.8261960149,
0.4780915976,
0.7324110866,
0.4322569072,
0.4788440168,
0.430839479,
0.0940630212,
-0.0428893752,
-0.4692851007,
0.2080158591,
-0.3942712545,
-0.2916285694,
-0.3656965792,
0.1135407835,
0.3329639137,
0.7652052641,
-0.1455249488,
-0.0667252541,
0.1024014354,
0.6683092117,
-0.4926714897,
-0.0951861814,
-0.4609660506,
-0.1614276022,
-0.1466207206,
-0.4238594472,
-0.6103712916,
-0.3332035244,
0.2403272539,
-0.5814833045,
0.1519153416,
0.0333880968,
0.7745478749,
0.3258552551,
-0.356997937,
-0.3376707733,
-0.7215820551,
0.6680765152,
-0.7296651006,
0.4313349426,
0.3864407837,
-0.186497122,
-0.5111505985,
-0.677946806,
-0.5750662684,
-0.2399667054,
-0.3951381743,
0.0120948069,
-0.2147864997,
0.1790614277,
0.3617008924,
-0.0999126211,
-0.5756796598,
0.2879355848,
-0.2194316387,
-0.0809408054,
0.7487754226,
0.1928286552,
0.7691271901,
0.0336800478,
-0.2948116958,
0.1118974388,
-0.5745870471,
0.0554428846,
0.1530972868,
0.1319922358,
-0.199758023,
0.3600318134,
0.0322590396,
0.4532439113,
0.1837904006,
0.1213145852,
-0.2459444702,
-0.71959728,
-0.3816101253,
0.1876895428,
0.7353859544,
0.346942544,
0.1756274402,
-0.2575509548,
0.2052557915,
0.1097520962,
0.3665365577,
-0.5243635774,
-0.2652494907,
0.1502068043,
-0.1971404403,
-0.2802943885,
-0.0083928593,
-0.8033728004,
-0.5293583274,
-0.6643584967,
0.6005806923,
-0.2137504071,
-0.0995388702,
-0.1106308103,
-0.2658902407,
-0.1150308773,
0.3871205747,
-0.6958644986,
0.3031609058,
0.4206713736,
0.6706758142,
-0.0001301738,
-0.6415295601,
-0.406032145,
0.1128628328,
-0.4927203357,
0.8208831549,
-0.3651612997,
-0.5772089958,
-0.1666089594,
-0.0817307532,
-0.287552774,
-0.2487266511,
0.5245475769,
-0.377214551,
0.6615172625,
-0.4462902546,
-0.69231987,
-0.1137973815,
-0.0483515002,
-0.7674158216,
0.6902408004,
-0.1347807795,
-1.0058488846,
0.577958405,
-0.5568444133,
-0.3781108558,
-0.039766591,
-0.2804203928,
-0.756131947,
-0.0976966321,
-0.1670278162,
0.1228237078,
-0.568885684,
0.7154619098,
-0.5198171735,
-0.39835307,
0.3801857531,
-0.2803301513,
0.765974462,
-0.0639534444,
-0.4735665917,
0.5987383127,
-0.5391069651,
-0.2406486273,
0.0681545734,
-0.1142729074,
-0.7200630307,
0.1916796863,
-0.0692391843,
0.2570998669,
0.1591363251,
-0.453017354,
0.1689383239,
0.0850551203,
0.0273803659,
0.7372717261,
0.4611353576,
0.4754965603,
-0.5402283669,
0.2855491042,
-0.4792348146,
0.2287676185,
0.0310515929,
-0.3707954288,
-0.5950455666,
-0.478461206,
-0.0869613364,
0.3076146245,
-0.7838219404,
0.2641561925,
-0.0636735633,
-0.3874298334,
-0.1260477751,
0.1288414747,
0.5797333717,
0.5422043204,
0.3317482471,
-0.2168374211,
-0.6063332558,
-0.9277975559,
-0.6320605278,
-0.3339146078,
0.0099802185,
0.1051612496,
0.2537552416,
-0.171355322,
1.2415467501,
-0.3980671763,
-0.0874953046,
-0.1997032464,
0.7277318835,
0.0056081573,
0.4967944622,
0.52913481,
-0.6795171499,
-0.5074164867,
-0.3984516859,
-0.7372263074,
-0.7292487621,
-0.536724329,
-0.328209579,
0.3291118443,
0.9976494312,
-0.3054536879,
0.5416690111,
0.5739709735,
-0.6190077066,
0.7952467799,
-0.2850319147,
0.6028974652,
-0.7780892849,
0.1668489128,
0.2406057417,
0.2291420251,
-0.785836637,
-0.2469348609,
0.0356794409,
0.0547625609,
-0.2314842194,
0.677377224,
-0.3034137189,
0.1883484274,
-0.0257192235,
0.2821163833,
0.0521205775,
0.690724194,
0.1915505677,
0.485912472,
-0.0318514332,
-0.3858281076,
-0.256624788,
0.149825722,
-0.1456618607,
0.9360211492,
-0.7253678441,
0.1169256568,
-0.0523486882,
0.3254145682,
-1.2150506973,
-0.2226382941,
0.0295355897,
-0.3258959949,
0.2466155142,
0.0403952189,
-0.6097750664,
-0.1378520429,
-0.4439791143,
0.3086617589,
-0.0689725056,
-0.4317308366,
0.5642520189,
0.1708239466,
-0.3616569936,
-0.2634809911,
-0.4681684971,
0.4198783338,
-0.4829981923,
-0.8968495131,
0.4025555551,
-0.3342864513,
-0.6133544445,
-0.0506054834,
0.2169817537,
-0.2585033178,
0.3670156002,
0.2598430514,
0.5162222981,
0.1898422986,
0.0507412553,
0.2247625589,
-0.001814316,
0.1467436701,
0.3077886403,
0.3780670166,
0.307374239,
-0.3342853189,
-0.606903851,
0.3089896739,
0.580144465,
-0.2690411806,
0.8440365791,
0.4353918731,
-0.0442982018,
-0.0096039604,
-0.6710086465,
-0.3789696693,
-0.4458387196,
0.4116480947,
-0.0659004673,
-0.6265292168,
0.4636822939,
0.0387350097,
0.0211761128,
0.1903068274,
0.503935039,
-0.0152071333,
0.7748861313,
0.5507112145,
-0.1113060266,
0.786595881,
0.1667206585,
-0.0324289836,
-0.6710513234,
-0.2398738861,
-0.6154725552,
-0.4621291757,
-0.7306557894,
-0.0879951492,
0.5798513889,
0.0757016316,
-0.3084070981,
0.5801618099,
-0.0244671199,
0.291705668,
0.6152208447,
0.1420924813,
0.4601174891,
-0.4078967869,
-0.2019431889,
-0.100608699,
-0.5972050428,
-0.151433453,
0.5372574329,
0.1165076345,
0.6561992168,
0.4458615184,
0.5048817396,
0.3751530349,
0.4576672316,
-0.3747090399,
0.567244947,
0.1918194592,
-0.6652934551,
-0.5158491731,
-0.3475553989,
-1.0676658154,
0.3419897556,
-0.5870908499,
-1.0133236647,
0.2394946963,
0.1582693458,
0.1027825996,
0.0645582974,
-0.7572881579,
0.9264135361,
0.0223022923,
-1.0094980001,
-0.480020076,
-0.7714066505,
0.4240661561,
-0.4239221513,
0.4214227796,
0.1243273914,
0.3279131949,
0.7668771744,
-0.4848047197,
1.045525074,
0.0525893904,
-0.1562586129,
0.0956246778,
0.484039098,
0.6202816963,
-0.2003176808,
-0.0501270369,
0.2531737685,
-0.1143233627,
-0.2622440159,
-0.6551120877,
0.7567195892,
-0.4775977731,
-0.5944555402,
-0.2330858111,
-0.7317499518,
-0.3555877805,
0.1722563654,
0.2291671634,
0.7163870335,
-0.5457868576,
0.1216227934,
0.2132557034,
-0.4251614213,
0.6409367919,
0.8452960253,
-0.0952395573,
-0.4245581329,
0.4593495131,
-0.0060077221,
0.43763116,
0.4374882579,
0.4635505676,
-0.2393119037,
-0.1765292287,
-0.219142884,
0.4813647866,
-0.4525606632,
0.3025496304,
-0.4555075467,
0.2968379557,
-0.1482265443,
-0.6685493588,
-0.0324173644,
-0.0991684496,
-0.2681856155,
0.210286811,
0.185598135,
0.7112859488,
-0.0380641371,
0.1548586339,
-0.6674409509,
-0.177102387,
0.198067233,
0.0663816854,
0.20553945,
-0.5208651423,
-0.3779666424,
-0.140690133,
-0.2734300792,
-0.840954423,
0.2749288976,
-0.1139739454,
0.3864702284,
0.1157068312,
-0.0259256829,
0.7407674193,
-0.529774189,
0.599840641,
0.2805508971,
-0.9226045609,
0.1465815306,
-0.6418107152,
0.4012914002,
0.501103878,
0.2612652183,
-1.0428907871,
-0.6514360309,
-0.666760087,
-0.7224733233,
0.6741573811,
0.2689571977,
-0.2890910804,
-0.1527262479,
0.2042231411,
-0.1106352583,
0.143161878,
-0.4592965543,
-0.1455204785,
0.3315607905,
-0.0838741958,
-0.0077167377,
-0.2499762923,
-0.0593548119,
0.0439876132,
0.7227477431,
0.2741553187,
-0.036738582,
0.3082429171,
-0.1871492416,
-0.4954454601,
0.2968643308,
0.8054515719,
0.7092321515,
-0.260375917,
0.1043263152,
0.1054263562,
-0.1326687038,
-0.0115399016,
0.0190954432,
-0.0050711958,
-0.1512435675,
0.98362571,
0.7184967995,
0.588457942,
-0.5154659748,
0.412178129,
-0.1953006834,
-0.1512246281,
-0.036765039,
-0.0617421269,
-0.0255137067,
0.2024920583,
0.0807601139,
0.0790272877,
0.1086350828,
-0.5050900578,
0.5150963664,
0.4354398251,
-0.6136392951,
-0.4582229555,
0.7678897977,
0.2723864019,
-0.4798904061,
0.2242927402,
-0.0360729285,
-0.4263057709,
0.6354644895,
0.3753543794,
1.016290307,
-0.3405992687,
0.1776828766,
0.3233191967,
0.0333277509,
0.1292760968,
-0.1947138309,
0.1887732446,
-0.6620358825,
-0.5329028964,
-0.1994374543,
-0.4385918081,
-0.0152770095,
-0.4620578587,
0.5199261308,
-0.1618975103,
0.0420158543,
0.1721190214,
-0.0823373199,
-0.3796191514,
0.0213631932,
-0.1954964399,
0.4089565873,
-0.9905388355,
0.6749153733,
0.5334292054,
-0.6907381415,
-0.7234922647,
0.090823926,
0.7136667967,
-0.4617649913,
0.7900140285,
-0.2935135365,
-0.2713913321,
-0.0111218821,
-0.4291521013,
-0.6656743884,
1.0231866837,
0.2062360346,
-0.5307810903,
0.1370721012,
-0.0024678484,
0.6710336208,
0.1754948497,
0.2730185091,
0.5110610723,
0.4846199453,
0.0863406956,
-1.0981184244,
0.2358162105,
-0.1369785368,
-0.1268310547,
0.5051927567,
-0.6021143794,
0.6379608512,
-0.1839828491,
-0.2350999415,
0.2119432241,
0.374987334,
0.1566825807,
0.3380268812,
0.6198693514,
0.4027439952,
0.5797272921,
0.2212269157,
1.1511414051,
-0.2444212139,
0.3353214264,
1.3493800163,
-0.1574619114,
0.4484939277,
0.5339684486,
-0.1401865929,
0.6789177656,
0.4227781296,
0.3000336289,
0.3167519867,
-0.0102244811,
-0.4029577971,
0.0138854207,
-0.356805563,
0.0259219613,
0.2844027877,
-0.0130576128,
-0.2203027457,
-0.1523241997,
-0.2203224003,
0.6923288107,
0.3386566639,
0.0805105567,
0.8742928505,
-0.1800868213,
-0.9092691541,
0.297588706,
-0.0268301666,
0.4935073555,
-0.5955730677,
-0.0964154229,
-0.3021528125,
0.0848187357,
-0.1462740898,
-0.5417454839,
0.1441652924,
-0.2209438831,
-0.1946297288,
0.0168935582,
0.480045557,
-0.9365347028,
-0.2090699822,
0.4466409981,
0.3627281487,
-0.3547617495,
0.0747119337,
-0.6360374093,
0.2230641395,
-0.0903372765,
-0.03520355,
0.430552274,
0.3790426254,
-0.3316549659,
0.4558444321,
0.6552658081,
-0.0507556871,
-0.460303098,
0.2103395164,
0.6094183922,
-0.468295306,
-0.3744105995,
-1.114560008,
0.5072476864,
-0.1131539792,
-0.0573775396,
0.9662777781,
0.215210557,
0.4987605214,
0.046599146,
0.5175981522,
0.0358019024,
0.3028356433,
-0.5250297189,
0.644991219,
-0.6100732684,
0.3340205252,
-0.9519659281,
-0.6215682626,
-0.4107030034,
0.1775511503,
-0.3960880339,
-0.0775984973,
1.066557765,
0.7352423072,
0.3035476506,
0.1269658208,
0.2307760417,
0.3721915781,
0.6376873851,
0.0891124755,
0.5662790537,
0.032267563,
0.0751082376,
-0.2678403258,
-0.3757726252,
-0.164541468,
-1.0951275826,
-0.7156334519,
-0.7468947172,
-0.4313082993,
-0.2813136578,
0.045448035,
1.2456332445,
0.1895287782,
-0.4122718871,
-0.5486205816,
-0.2705155015,
0.3145410717,
-0.1448253393,
-0.2709175646,
0.514883101,
-0.3277686238,
-0.7401134968,
0.270886749,
0.4188835919,
-0.1529265195,
-0.1638711542,
0.0567627065,
-0.7006537914,
0.4315554798,
0.7395451069,
0.2988704741,
-0.5473641753,
-0.5014709234,
-0.0575255342,
0.0106545379,
-0.1141362116,
1.1229202747,
-0.4148500264,
0.7561457157,
0.5001246929,
0.4726978242,
0.1769190878,
0.1219921187,
0.7278589606,
-0.7518094182,
0.1532857716,
-0.27987957,
0.4441871643,
0.2079763263,
-0.30448699,
0.6335333586,
0.5730641484,
-0.7359241843,
-0.565556109,
0.0661005974,
-0.6938361526,
-0.5941506028,
1.0852279663,
0.0515165441,
0.0996529087,
-0.265424639,
-0.4380179048,
0.314145416,
-0.3008966446,
0.9769969583,
0.7408857346,
-0.3665489554,
0.2210223675,
-0.2308186442,
0.536331296,
0.4118377268,
-0.8773595095,
0.1517736614,
0.8230566978,
0.0668686777,
0.0751665235,
0.7306914926,
0.0938568339,
0.202553764,
-0.1910026222,
0.283041358,
0.1146726906,
-0.2878431678,
0.0096894084,
-0.3115583956,
0.1005582064,
0.3340303898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00205v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00205v1
|
Conceptual and Unbiased Reasoning in Language Models
| 2024-03-30T00:53:53 | 2024-03-30T00:53:53 |
Ben Zhou, Hongming Zhang, Sihao Chen, Dian Yu, Hongwei Wang, Baolin Peng, Dan Roth, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conceptual reasoning, the ability to reason in abstract and high-level
perspectives, is key to generalization in human cognition. However, limited
study has been done on large language models' capability to perform conceptual
reasoning. In this work, we bridge this gap and propose a novel
conceptualization framework that forces models to perform conceptual reasoning
on abstract questions and generate solutions in a verifiable symbolic space.
Using this framework as an analytical tool, we show that existing large
language models fall short on conceptual reasoning, dropping 9% to 28% on
various benchmarks compared to direct inference methods. We then discuss how
models can improve since high-level abstract reasoning is key to unbiased and
generalizable decision-making. We propose two techniques to add trustworthy
induction signals by generating familiar questions with similar underlying
reasoning paths and asking models to perform self-refinement. Experiments show
that our proposed techniques improve models' conceptual reasoning performance
by 8% to 11%, achieving a more robust reasoning system that relies less on
inductive biases.
|
[
-0.3554725051,
-0.5481648445,
1.0115209818,
-0.0133202681,
-0.1344597489,
0.0460838154,
-0.1535685807,
-0.5409200788,
-0.202845484,
0.3842018545,
-0.2705737352,
-0.482952565,
-0.4487333,
-0.0352403075,
-0.5825869441,
0.6410861611,
-0.0874591619,
0.0001359257,
-0.5626920462,
-0.1452496201,
-0.3286033869,
-0.4170987308,
-0.6494327784,
-0.6959576011,
0.2035741061,
0.1748096496,
0.8793491721,
0.5744394064,
0.342318505,
0.2685649693,
-0.1528393477,
0.1748125553,
-0.0793194324,
0.4295594096,
-0.6640214324,
-0.4730266333,
-0.1768101752,
-0.0606142394,
0.4355465174,
0.9611247778,
-0.3696762919,
0.1158786416,
-0.2717612088,
0.51566571,
-0.7778083682,
0.3121388555,
-0.9854435325,
-0.0609794632,
0.1095156446,
0.0914444327,
-0.4412206113,
-0.101476416,
0.2220612764,
-0.8591017723,
0.2201848775,
0.0952761322,
0.7278620601,
0.3165509999,
-0.2799549699,
-0.1633422822,
-0.7969005108,
0.7758461833,
-0.8124659657,
0.4527208805,
0.3959431052,
0.220908463,
-0.1324853003,
-0.8036745191,
-0.6819033623,
-0.4817908406,
-0.2001524121,
-0.1936393976,
-0.2121029645,
-0.1227770746,
0.2810600996,
0.1417650282,
-0.1391128451,
-0.0905063525,
-0.3257159591,
-0.1180958748,
0.8332195878,
-0.0331211798,
0.2052966505,
-0.1033961028,
-0.0943245962,
0.0507706851,
-0.8095592856,
-0.217738077,
0.118301928,
0.0778436661,
0.0628796741,
0.4659754932,
-0.5503111482,
0.5851821899,
0.1507712603,
0.2108810395,
0.0405112021,
-0.3713722229,
-0.0753816515,
0.0235622209,
0.6457855105,
0.2254867256,
0.6934212446,
-0.1225406155,
-0.3482978344,
0.4000190794,
0.2918092906,
-0.5782757998,
-0.2050501704,
0.4728758335,
-0.305997014,
-0.3694246411,
-0.0080937799,
-0.3039990962,
-0.3202857375,
-0.3777620494,
0.2436833084,
-0.440828681,
-0.518627584,
0.5177875757,
-0.3441669047,
0.0086346157,
0.6011013985,
-0.9847317934,
0.1502655447,
0.5711289644,
0.4679684937,
-0.0345628597,
-0.1264086068,
0.0654702038,
0.4691687822,
-0.6551753879,
0.9025811553,
-0.7248752117,
-0.3328762352,
-0.0098304395,
-0.4446499944,
0.1810645312,
-0.4991563857,
0.3132589161,
-0.4044387043,
0.104745172,
-0.3462544382,
-0.4781038463,
-0.0330599956,
0.2142661065,
-0.4725962877,
0.9227858186,
-0.049209062,
-0.8224729896,
0.3867256939,
-0.8499832153,
-0.4352459311,
-0.0667518675,
-0.4002639055,
0.0098240068,
0.3503979445,
0.3453986347,
0.5277445912,
-0.5889823437,
0.4579375386,
-0.5792850852,
-0.0422780402,
0.4180306792,
-0.0318120867,
0.6377779841,
0.5351991653,
-0.2878319621,
0.1375418603,
-0.7063636184,
0.1918392479,
0.4105328321,
0.0932543054,
-0.7337342501,
0.0808850899,
-0.256398946,
0.1592496485,
-0.0353363268,
-0.4686881006,
-0.0903185382,
-0.5524190068,
0.7279257774,
0.6150891185,
-0.0154092219,
0.6421937346,
-0.1586861908,
0.1048181504,
0.3329854012,
-0.1558046639,
-0.0525828265,
-0.4448796213,
-0.6613841653,
-0.0842417404,
0.4518366456,
0.2064742297,
-0.6285017729,
0.4060833454,
-0.1724207401,
-0.3581346571,
-0.7114070654,
0.0110510197,
0.3827445507,
0.5511803627,
0.2121004164,
-0.2591460049,
-0.2961102426,
-0.832429409,
-0.2783820927,
-0.3056818545,
-0.1174668074,
-0.311778605,
0.8767995834,
0.0832092166,
1.0064979792,
-0.4985286295,
0.1155239791,
-0.2050745934,
0.1140163168,
0.0035235428,
0.5837106705,
0.2778067887,
-0.6576736569,
-0.0784249827,
0.0868224949,
-1.1978527308,
0.0786795244,
-0.1005915925,
-0.2154307961,
-0.1196959913,
0.650192976,
-1.1414359808,
0.4130452871,
-0.0532444045,
-0.4061293304,
0.4887332916,
-0.1611288637,
-0.273747623,
-0.9751560688,
-0.148228541,
0.1444705278,
-0.0189477522,
-0.4209252894,
0.5144171715,
-0.2266340107,
-0.0093339654,
-0.1233823225,
0.9250586629,
-0.5041960478,
0.0669993535,
-0.269320488,
0.2231837511,
0.179191798,
0.2088494748,
0.3518981934,
0.5786979795,
0.5102039576,
-0.5913568735,
0.3089387417,
0.2072076946,
-0.5285771489,
0.6039146185,
-1.0415740013,
0.0461855158,
-0.4025279582,
0.3500230312,
-0.9122250676,
-0.194491595,
0.0662070811,
-0.5728868246,
0.2101572603,
0.2001917064,
-0.4542665184,
-0.1424320191,
-0.056910295,
0.5415071249,
0.400256753,
-0.466955483,
0.6241112351,
0.3528879583,
0.0403147526,
-0.5637172461,
-0.4663869441,
-0.1966444552,
-0.0294580497,
-0.76547122,
0.38442716,
0.1858325154,
-0.8201234341,
0.3244279623,
-0.4224128723,
-0.1022635028,
0.2107022703,
0.1162435561,
0.0523017347,
-0.2142235786,
0.344712615,
0.4310790896,
-0.2641188502,
0.4069612026,
-0.6639422178,
0.2515060306,
-0.018504858,
-0.6083605886,
-0.4424111247,
0.4800139368,
0.684779942,
-0.5576634407,
0.7185411453,
0.2995669842,
-0.6147431731,
-0.3380013108,
-0.5952602029,
-0.5519433022,
-0.3784946501,
0.37918818,
-0.5739819407,
-0.8688971996,
0.4621677697,
-0.0439083502,
0.0501871035,
0.5090069771,
0.7599970102,
-0.1079315469,
1.2866051197,
0.389559865,
0.1185239777,
-0.0026563753,
-0.1413812339,
0.4051053226,
-0.5722244978,
-0.3049226999,
-0.6552481651,
0.0831320211,
-0.2236593366,
-0.3903135061,
0.062256664,
0.0482848026,
-0.4385534823,
-0.0904284194,
-0.6094438434,
0.4505695105,
0.6350066662,
-0.1406329572,
0.5906075835,
0.0118004763,
-0.5355744958,
0.214480862,
-0.4420196414,
-0.5791402459,
1.0915447474,
0.4884083867,
0.812607646,
-0.1209498718,
0.5045080185,
0.2021531165,
0.2676608562,
-0.4849398136,
0.3793466985,
0.3694432378,
-1.1056207418,
-0.5425330997,
-0.2115287632,
-0.5240957737,
0.5751838088,
-0.3293097019,
-0.7371023297,
0.1672063321,
0.151596278,
-0.4142066836,
0.160157159,
-0.6670438051,
0.7299565673,
0.0974324495,
-0.1378436983,
-0.4294778705,
-0.5036514401,
0.5527291298,
0.0001226273,
0.2256036252,
-0.3009404242,
0.28121984,
0.4612958133,
-0.4876735806,
0.6390411258,
-0.1730566919,
-0.3638106585,
0.4109126627,
0.1008202359,
0.423966229,
0.2898782492,
-0.1003335938,
0.2053437978,
0.2028784156,
-0.4056251645,
-1.1453185081,
0.5109015703,
-0.566467762,
-0.9549236894,
-0.4503228068,
-0.5617747903,
-0.4517262578,
0.1349133551,
0.2048685253,
-0.0140058147,
-0.0367260091,
0.0841751099,
0.7345722318,
0.1400371939,
-0.0501475669,
0.3418208957,
-0.398756206,
-0.0977227092,
0.3633998632,
-0.1246862411,
0.4152557254,
0.3190295696,
0.1276454031,
-0.5432943106,
-0.6641587615,
-0.2431158721,
0.3242314458,
-0.8878991604,
-0.0198591594,
-0.4760989547,
-0.2768919468,
-0.4345780015,
-0.0365473852,
-0.4979852736,
-0.8088254333,
0.2515852749,
-0.3650833368,
0.0572190769,
0.4831007123,
0.0615990981,
0.1682084799,
-0.3144444525,
0.2643820345,
0.4605563879,
0.1024885327,
0.4018778801,
-0.3744166195,
-0.0122742867,
0.1629600525,
-0.2224984616,
-0.6174688935,
-0.0815384239,
-0.2065820694,
0.4784140289,
0.5656707883,
0.1958018541,
0.4976747036,
-0.4764864743,
0.4431111515,
0.4092678428,
-1.0069185495,
0.6101891398,
-0.3288630843,
0.2901350856,
0.3233735859,
0.2574480772,
-0.3554851115,
-0.643078208,
-0.5465316176,
-0.4906792641,
0.3441755772,
0.3748221695,
0.2745383382,
-0.0949463844,
0.547218442,
-0.1217133254,
0.1814440638,
-0.6218126416,
-0.1149083599,
-0.3193894029,
-0.211737141,
0.147775501,
-0.1317974478,
-0.2984744012,
-0.6978471279,
0.5687384605,
-0.2747375071,
0.1689241081,
0.149479419,
0.1374227554,
-0.2010605335,
0.3779144883,
0.2863520086,
0.8979558349,
-0.0098129353,
0.1734855622,
0.2032924592,
-0.0111208223,
0.2895739079,
-0.0212037284,
-0.4286187291,
0.0425310135,
0.4335610867,
0.7182676792,
0.171462521,
-0.5106091499,
0.3320340812,
0.0097319866,
-0.2693453729,
-0.4228101969,
0.1219284907,
0.5315741897,
0.2103114426,
0.2913423479,
0.0395325124,
-0.0469157584,
-0.4925189018,
0.0609145425,
0.72583884,
-0.1762269586,
-0.3268101811,
0.8733635545,
0.0858464837,
0.2557060719,
0.687430203,
-0.1123465374,
-0.1200046912,
0.4222052097,
0.7642801404,
0.6861841083,
-0.2802313268,
0.3664317131,
0.2740840614,
0.2809870839,
-0.2836476862,
0.146638453,
-0.1791987568,
-1.3488476276,
-0.5749707222,
-0.688408494,
-0.2841736078,
0.1578633934,
-0.5031474829,
0.0022894896,
-0.67708534,
-0.2449723184,
0.3553122878,
-0.2835358977,
-0.4018885195,
0.4769872725,
-0.0484387577,
1.0115075111,
-0.6269966364,
0.8386191726,
0.8576203585,
-0.5883991122,
-0.8214040399,
-0.1702168584,
-0.158483997,
-0.7927660942,
0.7378584146,
-0.0110687409,
-0.322493881,
-0.1548185199,
-0.7825838923,
-0.9340384007,
0.8650013804,
0.5026871562,
-0.2429462373,
-0.3875553608,
-0.0297960993,
0.5605400801,
-0.6663733125,
0.2749303281,
0.7302144766,
0.5094242692,
0.5503221154,
-0.7424388528,
0.3301430345,
-0.2712347507,
0.2383630276,
0.0786355138,
-0.2325363308,
0.7707465291,
-0.4921100736,
-0.2225860953,
0.0404037125,
1.0267122984,
0.4069811702,
0.3560579717,
0.3751183152,
0.8809463382,
0.7713522911,
0.006937725,
1.0243608952,
-0.2275956571,
0.2242910862,
0.9896519184,
-0.4791635573,
0.7141211629,
0.5055206418,
-0.02582426,
0.7470514178,
0.4101552665,
0.266014576,
0.517670989,
0.291342169,
-0.281157583,
-0.7346493602,
-0.1718988866,
-0.5548817515,
0.6222569346,
0.373039186,
-0.2813875079,
-0.2906549573,
-0.3802531958,
0.3024649322,
0.3966260254,
-0.1872767955,
0.4512377977,
0.387934953,
-0.8389322162,
0.5169252157,
0.2879613638,
0.2099056989,
-0.5379784703,
-0.0273675807,
-0.1625549346,
0.2730433941,
-0.1460814029,
-0.5634917021,
0.391063422,
-0.1957643032,
-0.269246757,
0.0145029901,
0.7530298233,
-0.2362559885,
-0.4959888756,
0.1369863451,
0.8801697493,
-0.2017668635,
-0.3306005597,
-0.5767796636,
-0.1987878233,
-0.167406261,
0.0125945695,
0.2942636311,
0.6498624086,
-0.4216809571,
0.9216703773,
0.8638845682,
0.1993225813,
-0.2857397497,
0.0990986899,
0.7767213583,
-0.672218442,
-0.4494566023,
-0.8472293615,
0.5029932857,
-0.3077460825,
-0.2661974132,
0.6381556988,
0.0996492356,
1.1615320444,
-0.2066817135,
1.0731002092,
0.1178904548,
0.4052858651,
-0.6024791598,
0.7939002514,
-0.5314679146,
0.2418088168,
-0.3082724512,
-0.8357338905,
-0.4208738804,
1.0104976892,
-0.4072963297,
0.1810487211,
0.8753312826,
0.6074359417,
-0.1092731804,
0.1921977252,
0.3001457155,
0.1492219269,
0.2135194987,
0.3980072439,
1.2145227194,
-0.1223070696,
-0.0061713401,
-0.1402315944,
-0.0430606827,
0.2966576517,
-0.7686777115,
-1.0655061007,
-0.6433078647,
-0.3558537662,
-0.32440871,
0.0998005271,
0.8967322707,
0.8323680758,
-0.9296146035,
-0.2435582578,
-0.1426113099,
0.4851740003,
-0.1866499782,
-0.2202224433,
0.1709215641,
-0.6547571421,
-0.4699119627,
0.1439108998,
0.246770516,
-0.2143051177,
-0.4659613669,
-0.0534504429,
-0.1181068644,
0.4061100781,
0.5343973041,
0.1424929798,
-0.9762920737,
-0.4566137195,
-0.2909303904,
0.1239419058,
-0.0680057853,
0.8956742883,
-0.7052440047,
0.2687555552,
0.2504485846,
0.499078244,
0.4019428194,
0.0161428563,
0.7777850628,
-0.5476566553,
0.1543217599,
0.1378595382,
0.4915908575,
0.2647393942,
-0.1789646894,
0.5181288123,
0.3210355341,
-0.1321807653,
-0.8580886722,
0.6036249399,
-0.4489284754,
-0.5536441207,
1.0356968641,
-0.0678221658,
-0.2144951373,
-0.1306596547,
0.0479752831,
0.0646946579,
-0.4566156566,
0.9495344758,
0.9490866661,
-0.1397065967,
-0.0114772785,
-0.2238535136,
0.5453829765,
0.5964189172,
-0.8664016128,
0.0361401923,
0.506224215,
0.3527916968,
0.4748464823,
0.6698077321,
-0.2212636769,
0.2913937569,
0.1312294304,
-0.0542653687,
-0.0615882687,
-0.4497029185,
-0.0942004845,
0.2906112373,
0.3585037589,
0.0279207751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00189v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00189v1
|
GPTA: Generative Prompt Tuning Assistant for Synergistic Downstream Neural Network Enhancement with LLMs
| 2024-03-29T23:04:04 | 2024-03-29T23:04:04 |
Xiao Liu, Jiawei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study introduces GPTA, a Large Language Model assistance training
framework, that enhances the training of downstream task models via prefix
prompt. By minimizing data exposure to LLM, the framework addresses the
security and legal challenges of applying LLM in downstream task model
training. GPTA utilizes a new synergistic training approach, optimizing the
downstream models with parameter gradients and LLMs with the novel ``dialogue
gradient''. The framework not only demonstrates significant improvements in
model performance across six NLP benchmark datasets, but also reduces
overfitting in low-resource scenarios effectively. The detailed analyses
further validate that our pioneer framework provides a cost-efficient and
adaptive method for downstream task model training with LLM support.
|
[
-0.3248625994,
-0.6705595851,
0.5334698558,
0.3046793342,
-0.2869307399,
0.1792327464,
-0.0500324667,
-0.4240007997,
0.1450004429,
0.4016554952,
-0.9461963773,
-0.4043624401,
-0.654173255,
0.3441165686,
-0.0549923852,
0.958229661,
0.2665152252,
0.5024793148,
0.109623909,
-0.0305207781,
-0.9166457057,
-0.4947547615,
-1.4390921593,
-0.1128367186,
0.7002728581,
0.1947160959,
0.4702533484,
0.3390960693,
0.4558808208,
0.3593719602,
-0.2013831288,
0.0841762051,
-0.1372396946,
0.4349097908,
-0.1739530414,
-0.6611685753,
-0.6103714108,
-0.3636279404,
0.6157807112,
0.5890913606,
-0.1987439245,
0.1395846754,
0.2334851623,
0.7638218999,
-0.6124862432,
0.1653596759,
-0.7038853765,
-0.0981616229,
-0.1595094651,
-0.5301703811,
-0.368834883,
-0.110777624,
-0.140810743,
-0.6898323894,
0.3106071651,
0.1165187433,
0.6864916682,
0.6799598932,
-0.1683517098,
0.0161519926,
-0.4288497567,
0.4674237669,
-0.7340206504,
0.2048665136,
0.1069074795,
0.4900700748,
-0.3658692241,
-0.942063272,
-0.5685229301,
-0.1865607947,
-0.0076408004,
0.0208694376,
-0.2937308252,
0.4749160111,
0.4815355837,
0.4282300174,
-0.5626574755,
0.4134407341,
0.040650174,
-0.3417505324,
0.3280058801,
0.5334478021,
0.4055429995,
0.0456791371,
-0.3125909865,
-0.0033155063,
-0.8508053422,
0.0756946206,
0.5620105863,
0.7321041226,
-0.0988656282,
0.2785584033,
-0.4100427628,
0.9331128597,
-0.0685705915,
0.1062977016,
0.1871189922,
-0.3927691579,
-0.5106165409,
-0.0936969593,
0.7089091539,
0.1428338885,
-0.0586985834,
-0.1718289107,
-0.3433262706,
0.0048243785,
0.1112165004,
-0.7638351321,
-0.117606394,
0.0117124179,
-0.3325176537,
-0.0874531716,
-0.2286195904,
-0.7514510751,
-0.6015995741,
-0.5736331344,
0.2714297771,
-0.0270678252,
-0.292470783,
0.0160318408,
-0.3079436123,
0.3553386033,
0.3418412805,
-1.2769432068,
0.2803933024,
0.764940083,
1.032777667,
-0.0212935694,
-0.1524149179,
-0.9589525461,
0.0037428131,
-0.136818558,
0.8472176194,
-0.5585563183,
-0.5296925306,
-0.0687194541,
0.3245662153,
-0.2602469027,
-0.5470581055,
0.5318844318,
-0.7024909854,
0.0556123219,
-0.4714230001,
-0.3568140268,
-0.1067534909,
-0.0320913047,
-0.8019861579,
0.9198907614,
0.2310074568,
-0.6038452387,
0.4994681478,
-0.8533334732,
-0.2505800128,
0.460180521,
-0.1394519955,
-0.1802670062,
-0.1008776724,
0.3908503354,
0.3786619306,
-0.5171194077,
0.3563360572,
-0.0801715553,
-0.3162210882,
-0.1359979957,
-0.3890309036,
0.8659587502,
0.1581127942,
-0.2456195652,
0.7234376073,
-0.7419917583,
-0.1115989238,
-0.0255514979,
-0.4366225302,
-0.2113017142,
-0.2903519571,
0.164688915,
0.0953790173,
0.0908258781,
-0.2493658811,
0.3366852105,
-0.3546760678,
0.4122874737,
0.8412635326,
0.1928087026,
0.3902912736,
-0.1444559693,
1.0872085094,
-0.2517694831,
0.1324966848,
-0.2184132934,
-0.7138265967,
-0.810963273,
-0.3998968303,
0.3744926453,
0.6556739807,
-0.8542335033,
0.6232065558,
-0.2027439475,
-0.0978415906,
-0.5852898955,
0.3907123506,
0.17763035,
0.8374356031,
0.4146218896,
-0.3102456033,
-0.8187747002,
-0.8958883882,
-0.1739157885,
0.0478384197,
-0.174964115,
0.0503339916,
0.2135349959,
0.0033197484,
0.9481521845,
-0.070956409,
-0.3581058383,
-0.5664457083,
0.1409094632,
0.4302545786,
0.4517223835,
0.5059844255,
-0.6522199512,
-0.5441878438,
-0.2563072741,
-0.4438277483,
-0.274659723,
-0.1472006291,
-0.2248593867,
0.1679287106,
0.6127281785,
-0.740585506,
0.0630848631,
0.6749814153,
-0.5302816629,
0.432721287,
-0.0697565824,
0.0074581057,
-1.4209586382,
0.2366256714,
0.107928209,
-0.2331852466,
-0.6209847927,
-0.0221088901,
-0.0743753091,
-0.0774249136,
-0.1820716262,
0.4357492328,
-0.5940728188,
-0.1269629747,
-0.49635306,
-0.2358785421,
-0.1094431579,
0.5432497859,
0.1603598595,
1.3199967146,
0.8592724204,
-0.5680618286,
0.5037810206,
0.3412987888,
-0.2439795285,
0.518410027,
-0.7233857512,
0.0900674984,
-0.1199649498,
0.2173453569,
-1.069840312,
-0.168499276,
0.48211959,
-0.306255132,
0.5408465266,
-0.416757971,
-0.3981479406,
-0.1569132358,
-0.0904515162,
0.1103478894,
0.6808745265,
-0.6907518506,
0.6549649239,
0.1409498453,
-0.5967178941,
-0.6736938953,
-0.4446619451,
0.3307310641,
-0.4535385668,
-0.3702413142,
0.3228562474,
0.0548836887,
0.0344291367,
-0.3754324317,
0.1156730205,
0.1030627266,
0.302646935,
0.1997804791,
0.4113102555,
-0.2728004158,
0.1214988977,
0.1100166589,
-0.2983572483,
0.2386225611,
-0.1619416773,
0.6336297393,
0.0748520494,
-0.0389639549,
-0.632291913,
0.3283551633,
0.1071460322,
-0.1611816287,
0.5896615982,
0.5548594594,
0.0576310121,
-0.2915382683,
-0.2677470744,
-0.2458635569,
-0.5977116823,
0.4356567562,
-0.3957364857,
-0.8471031785,
0.6439626217,
-0.13868168,
-0.2372055203,
0.3004079461,
0.5129089355,
0.3521850109,
1.0096862316,
0.8596299291,
-0.4055028558,
0.8324629068,
-0.1537899822,
0.023420332,
-0.9702583551,
-0.1357397884,
-0.601831615,
-0.1864354312,
-0.4809493124,
-0.1942187399,
0.3010383546,
0.2683128417,
-0.3364471495,
0.2062141746,
-0.4883985817,
0.3761288822,
0.5907922983,
0.1155265793,
0.3492458761,
-0.049652867,
0.0571118295,
0.1145664081,
-0.8638907075,
-0.4507569969,
0.9602171183,
0.4978390336,
0.6167458892,
0.0988679528,
0.2839671969,
0.3633729815,
0.4700179994,
-0.9613833427,
0.6573204994,
0.1716910899,
-0.3416200876,
-0.3633577526,
-0.3858920634,
-0.788592279,
0.1550095081,
-0.0380283445,
-0.693462491,
0.1892808527,
0.3601624072,
-0.4955580831,
0.2162439674,
-0.6436141729,
0.8774682283,
0.0203459263,
-0.2790262103,
-0.0280435216,
-0.7141187191,
0.2820856273,
0.074766688,
-0.2926928997,
-0.2035861015,
-0.3786021769,
0.6429523826,
-0.6073614359,
0.9687103629,
-0.6452876925,
-0.3199501038,
0.0331259966,
-0.2377688587,
0.7779024243,
0.0910361111,
0.1673337966,
0.0317117795,
-0.5372300744,
-0.2994173467,
-0.7347645164,
0.5087944865,
-0.3979106843,
-0.8238914609,
-0.130622223,
-0.5902218223,
-0.6040759683,
-0.0648843944,
0.2671355307,
0.3606942594,
0.2654886246,
-0.1713896394,
0.4655201435,
-0.0555470772,
0.7592429519,
0.4750483632,
0.2568005621,
-0.5001521707,
0.6148771048,
-0.4686515331,
0.2431592345,
0.3453781605,
-0.1181898564,
-0.6398780346,
-0.8673458695,
-0.6765648127,
-0.0951628387,
-0.8907698989,
-0.577183187,
-0.5600800514,
-0.1129019931,
-0.2329998016,
0.2246309519,
0.0121150445,
-0.3491228819,
-0.3891844153,
-0.18137151,
0.7775601149,
0.4556229115,
0.1249196306,
0.6462084651,
-0.7017896175,
0.1260166615,
0.3366163969,
0.3527191877,
0.0718974322,
-0.6158699989,
-0.115842469,
-0.2438047528,
-0.1424700618,
-0.8115524054,
0.3562139273,
0.3130438924,
0.7199215889,
0.1734839082,
-0.2448935956,
0.6099101901,
-0.5075452924,
0.9603815079,
0.3537691534,
-1.002448082,
0.6416461468,
-0.5005935431,
0.1945925951,
0.5438619852,
0.4050709605,
-0.2494141757,
-0.3409204483,
-0.1689818799,
-0.8961002827,
0.6045596004,
-0.1424595565,
0.2884399295,
0.1078334153,
0.3053848743,
0.1610859334,
0.2192305624,
-0.6151205301,
-0.2624836862,
-0.0326764844,
-0.357480824,
-0.1245262399,
-0.1851950884,
-0.0738643929,
-0.3773064911,
0.7023125887,
-0.5473489165,
0.2703311443,
0.0845727175,
0.0671793222,
-0.0353421308,
0.3623974323,
0.5177040696,
0.5601148009,
0.0796464756,
-0.3186899722,
0.3337417245,
-0.5685226321,
0.3286890984,
0.2350053638,
-0.1473544091,
0.0735569,
0.2782819569,
1.1643543243,
0.0862750858,
-0.5382542014,
0.3822442889,
-0.1411244571,
-0.1139343306,
-0.0748650655,
0.4185491204,
0.0318945386,
0.3254936039,
0.575003624,
0.07138367,
0.4407397211,
-0.1891500056,
-0.0481760465,
0.622241199,
-0.20484972,
-0.2747362554,
0.7766022086,
0.4019710124,
-0.2405044138,
0.4599048197,
-0.0615026988,
-0.3770638406,
0.6005933881,
0.5198265314,
1.1765838861,
-0.3565937877,
0.2063955516,
0.3754480183,
0.0547126122,
-0.0094153006,
0.4895839393,
-0.2693029344,
-0.5874513984,
-0.7955797315,
-0.7077969909,
-0.4288842976,
0.3682872653,
-0.706833899,
0.2084563226,
-0.4633658826,
-0.3862425685,
0.0495466702,
-0.1699826717,
-0.4788048863,
0.073308602,
0.0152541632,
1.0675170422,
-0.7742083073,
0.9426935911,
0.640689075,
-0.5826771259,
-0.93794173,
-0.0377338789,
-0.3070860803,
-0.7833332419,
0.9516769648,
0.1465335339,
-0.1909934133,
0.397189796,
-0.4905226827,
-0.673253119,
1.1595489979,
0.6999705434,
-0.8137931228,
-0.173450321,
0.0287904982,
0.4966890216,
-0.4032844901,
0.185681507,
0.6430910826,
0.3294944465,
-0.0318590701,
-1.0240775347,
0.3950172365,
-0.382078141,
0.4695239365,
0.1668134183,
-0.4279748797,
0.5978329778,
-0.107396774,
-0.3923638463,
0.4026285708,
0.5197153091,
0.2306564599,
-0.0116749005,
0.5908195376,
0.4417921007,
0.6389675736,
-0.1568117738,
1.0649074316,
-0.3948384523,
0.0579989441,
1.1171234846,
-0.2915649712,
0.6960074306,
0.804231286,
-0.2789434791,
0.5559180379,
0.8724463582,
-0.1745091826,
0.7162006497,
0.2093848288,
-0.5485925078,
-0.198921755,
-0.3513787389,
-0.4321965575,
0.1184837967,
0.3008201718,
-0.4419357479,
-0.2746674716,
0.1080339924,
-0.3032368124,
-0.0889677256,
-0.6026594043,
1.021042943,
0.0893960297,
-0.6264317632,
0.7328389287,
-0.0830906779,
0.8293681741,
-0.7888864279,
-0.0840421841,
-0.3854913712,
-0.0751486495,
-0.1919340789,
-0.2977470458,
0.1430319101,
-0.0234324709,
-0.1636707634,
-0.1444732696,
0.637524724,
-0.3124416173,
-0.1100042164,
0.4005208611,
0.4762859643,
-0.2280842513,
-0.1101571247,
-0.8833655119,
0.00325455,
-0.2659804821,
-0.215715453,
0.2992085814,
0.0360896438,
0.1576738209,
0.7451936603,
0.744648397,
0.3560120165,
0.066020295,
0.6599144936,
1.0448642969,
-0.5925287008,
-0.780010283,
-0.8114397526,
0.6691295505,
-0.1727876365,
-0.3050864637,
0.6175122857,
0.3610629737,
0.606837213,
-0.2673695385,
0.8844632506,
0.1655472219,
0.3410168588,
-1.0808501244,
0.484251529,
-0.3278342485,
0.4312942624,
0.0444389395,
-0.9349389672,
-0.1438749135,
0.2156699896,
-0.1708545089,
0.2559735477,
0.5814749599,
1.1572492123,
-0.0436308235,
0.1517753452,
0.2197119147,
-0.2868098617,
0.1424091011,
0.6138533354,
1.0359151363,
-0.2457372546,
0.217642352,
0.0739635229,
-0.0964151248,
0.0129778739,
-0.7654126287,
-0.8936306238,
-0.5164601803,
-0.2417202592,
-0.1303501278,
0.2016657293,
0.8920667171,
0.8344572186,
-0.8719266653,
-0.1036804244,
-0.7049530149,
-0.184377566,
-0.1903079301,
-0.3303551078,
0.1661820263,
-1.0475369692,
-0.8142265081,
0.7623354197,
0.1293145269,
0.3565483093,
-0.3860805035,
-0.2281550318,
0.1283784807,
-0.237230286,
0.2691209018,
0.2853534222,
-0.6010904312,
0.0688797012,
-0.174221307,
0.046376612,
0.1674925834,
1.1078394651,
-0.7203137875,
0.2069040984,
0.4527454078,
0.8716099262,
0.0720413774,
0.0749644265,
0.9707226157,
-1.0077269077,
0.5327962041,
0.1689385772,
0.4957657754,
0.5804439187,
-0.745890677,
0.3911837339,
0.1712702662,
-0.3668450415,
-0.7001802325,
0.2344847322,
-0.9607200027,
-0.1341342032,
1.0600756407,
-0.1562508047,
0.0352896154,
-0.2690210938,
-0.2116680294,
0.1392226219,
-0.4645560384,
0.4661120176,
0.4113133252,
-0.0726607293,
-0.3986097276,
-0.7037193775,
1.078371644,
0.5949542522,
-1.0639845133,
0.0231173895,
0.4729894102,
0.3238620162,
-0.1934808344,
0.6820028424,
0.1850224435,
0.3802419305,
-0.0723902434,
-0.0017985201,
-0.2693527341,
-0.2872420847,
-0.9375498295,
-0.0160666183,
0.3172379434,
-0.3673819304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00188v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00188v1
|
DataAgent: Evaluating Large Language Models' Ability to Answer Zero-Shot, Natural Language Queries
| 2024-03-29T22:59:34 | 2024-03-29T22:59:34 |
Manit Mishra, Abderrahman Braham, Charles Marsom, Bryan Chung, Gavin Griffin, Dakshesh Sidnerlikar, Chatanya Sarin, Arjun Rajaram
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Conventional processes for analyzing datasets and extracting meaningful
information are often time-consuming and laborious. Previous work has
identified manual, repetitive coding and data collection as major obstacles
that hinder data scientists from undertaking more nuanced labor and high-level
projects. To combat this, we evaluated OpenAI's GPT-3.5 as a "Language Data
Scientist" (LDS) that can extrapolate key findings, including correlations and
basic information, from a given dataset. The model was tested on a diverse set
of benchmark datasets to evaluate its performance across multiple standards,
including data science code-generation based tasks involving libraries such as
NumPy, Pandas, Scikit-Learn, and TensorFlow, and was broadly successful in
correctly answering a given data science query related to the benchmark
dataset. The LDS used various novel prompt engineering techniques to
effectively answer a given question, including Chain-of-Thought reinforcement
and SayCan prompt engineering. Our findings demonstrate great potential for
leveraging Large Language Models for low-level, zero-shot data analysis.
|
[
-0.2265873104,
-1.0296155214,
0.5900351405,
0.1933997571,
-0.0316130146,
0.0851949155,
-0.3005815744,
-0.3609855771,
-0.1919325441,
0.391333878,
-0.3850029707,
-0.5371087193,
-0.3625513911,
0.1914691329,
-0.5188550949,
0.9577584267,
-0.2092089504,
-0.0841735229,
-0.0239048228,
0.0659411326,
-0.703707695,
-0.4133436978,
-0.6811748743,
-0.2795457244,
0.492128849,
0.5100386739,
0.9283900857,
0.5080056787,
0.5108042359,
0.2411553413,
0.1893997788,
-0.1859016865,
-0.4467335045,
0.2530094683,
-0.0554337054,
-0.6722533107,
-0.2101472169,
0.1567093134,
0.4788119495,
0.9287499785,
-0.0527413264,
0.3109844923,
-0.3526088297,
0.5650413632,
-0.507481277,
0.593734324,
-0.5541412234,
0.0553238466,
-0.2875487804,
-0.076157324,
-0.5406133533,
-0.4940351546,
0.2407831103,
-0.6746870875,
0.2296741754,
-0.0488042235,
0.7122481465,
0.3839633763,
-0.136906758,
-0.2369942367,
-0.8948342204,
0.8511416316,
-0.5536395907,
0.1795883775,
0.4722618461,
0.6378418803,
-0.1284409761,
-0.4099043906,
-0.5898865461,
-0.3840707541,
0.0302314628,
0.1021174341,
-0.2553925812,
-0.225106135,
0.5014317632,
0.2718701363,
-0.8897776008,
0.1740527004,
-0.3189078867,
0.0764983818,
0.5040873289,
0.2689034641,
0.4427623153,
-0.1171523184,
0.1013004631,
-0.2127814293,
-0.5227555633,
-0.1002647802,
0.245982334,
0.5599634051,
-0.0149203576,
0.6830053329,
-0.5182344913,
0.9256024361,
-0.5399957299,
0.3437179923,
0.1697138101,
-0.2504261136,
-0.3024134636,
0.0481265262,
0.7855427265,
0.02254848,
0.549015224,
-0.356215775,
-0.088595517,
0.1355555803,
0.0577239245,
-0.9078651667,
-0.2613704205,
0.4974477291,
-0.1887674183,
-0.4142073095,
0.0241893921,
-0.8992190361,
-0.4516136646,
-0.3500273824,
0.2818788886,
-0.2936370373,
-0.3614905775,
0.0910195857,
-0.1725445986,
0.3502744734,
0.187566191,
-0.4981024265,
0.3228928745,
0.6135831475,
1.0991631746,
-0.1599414349,
-0.2891348898,
-0.6421168447,
-0.0199841391,
-0.6360623837,
0.7022114992,
-0.8061208129,
-0.4046595097,
-0.1840167642,
-0.1756087691,
-0.0626891777,
-0.3997279704,
0.3673182428,
-0.5897627473,
0.2110858709,
-0.1886134148,
-0.3490213752,
0.1777490079,
0.1347124279,
-0.7822205424,
0.9756504893,
0.3099502027,
-0.5552604795,
0.3853341639,
-0.9193174839,
-0.2410567105,
0.2684652805,
-0.4025544822,
0.0028018504,
0.0811546221,
0.4394489527,
0.4751798511,
-0.7729406953,
0.439329803,
-0.3008157313,
-0.5332304239,
0.3605017662,
-0.5497674942,
0.6330860257,
0.2703255713,
-0.1273599118,
-0.1859631538,
-0.7592080235,
0.0449307449,
0.3084312379,
-0.0270429887,
-0.3234415054,
-0.0813680813,
-0.0432707779,
0.0771737099,
-0.1725113094,
-0.7377327085,
0.4712789953,
-0.5103335977,
0.1896361113,
0.4760159254,
-0.0499186218,
0.1087245569,
-0.153569892,
0.5242980123,
-0.1710040867,
-0.0865814462,
-0.2882091999,
-0.6129464507,
-0.4225772321,
-0.1459565312,
0.2160674036,
0.5640492439,
-1.3103466034,
0.0312938169,
-0.4306541085,
-0.8544123769,
-0.599054873,
-0.0328299627,
0.2195792645,
0.6708568931,
0.4119874835,
-0.0100040808,
-0.443784982,
-0.7157707214,
-0.3113766313,
-0.3291011751,
-0.2270208895,
0.1326215267,
0.5824008584,
0.0631916746,
1.2560429573,
-0.9148873687,
0.1325600147,
-0.1899034679,
0.5931552052,
0.7094981074,
0.2836173773,
0.3680587709,
-0.6947371364,
-0.5126565695,
0.2231437862,
-1.0720300674,
-0.2321327031,
0.0769727901,
0.1202326342,
0.0887885839,
0.204292044,
-0.8367888331,
0.3931854069,
0.1039886922,
-0.147175163,
0.5420273542,
-0.0721167251,
0.330049485,
-0.7835736275,
0.53126055,
0.1323257536,
0.1818201095,
-1.0217438936,
-0.0276294276,
-0.0851789117,
-0.6223998666,
-0.3549452722,
0.5677033067,
-0.3100342155,
-0.1248566732,
-0.4264207184,
-0.1172766015,
-0.3241334856,
0.322576344,
0.074334681,
1.0618418455,
0.7485697269,
-0.5964676142,
0.681610465,
0.207778126,
-0.4355882704,
0.4996004999,
-0.9112814665,
0.4076696336,
-0.3093097806,
0.0801112056,
-1.0095465183,
-0.4725642204,
-0.0314702094,
-0.5179815292,
0.2330903411,
-0.3343469501,
-0.8241790533,
-0.5912721157,
-0.2232569754,
0.2657435536,
0.4189198911,
-0.437312007,
0.1673224866,
0.2451275736,
-0.5080540776,
-0.3918643892,
-0.6269481182,
0.1558698863,
-0.1227464974,
-0.4804149568,
-0.0781516135,
0.0056620603,
-0.3478057384,
-0.1279658079,
-0.1159430444,
-0.3997301161,
0.0912007466,
-0.0937581658,
0.5209215283,
-0.2618127167,
0.1372922361,
-0.3525321484,
-0.3135007918,
0.0969659463,
-0.0129091851,
0.4972039461,
-0.2024601698,
-0.3876389861,
-0.0900176689,
0.2293030173,
0.5599477887,
-0.1813065261,
0.6039949656,
0.4559179842,
-0.3706970811,
0.0274608377,
-0.3627634048,
0.0224365797,
-0.423445642,
0.4469438493,
-0.464147836,
-0.612688005,
0.4053127766,
0.1404311359,
0.1509968936,
0.222681582,
0.3464021683,
0.2621943951,
1.121465683,
0.3752993047,
-0.407536447,
0.1298482567,
-0.1573694199,
0.1485243738,
-0.36035344,
0.0555306524,
-0.8475681543,
0.0105744777,
-0.4687701762,
-0.365273118,
0.381101191,
-0.2854243219,
-0.340793103,
0.4001565874,
-0.5084484816,
0.6286526918,
0.3231917024,
-0.1950985044,
0.3412834704,
-0.0992659628,
0.3898878694,
0.2235309184,
-0.4292280376,
-0.4526275992,
1.234056592,
0.2733258605,
1.002412796,
0.0841353908,
0.2754016221,
0.1680489033,
0.2929633558,
-0.7908688188,
0.4889247417,
-0.0064044823,
-0.5174505115,
-0.4593138397,
-0.7594649792,
-0.9170674682,
0.070804365,
0.3028383553,
-0.8588958383,
0.0874420777,
-0.2192642838,
-0.2524836361,
0.0227179751,
-0.86057657,
0.853085041,
-0.0526091233,
-0.2462608814,
0.1691889465,
-0.5489454269,
0.33613801,
-0.2755075991,
0.2078949362,
-0.1152025238,
-0.0365486406,
0.6628485322,
-0.2687370479,
0.6040202379,
-0.5595704317,
-0.1249842346,
0.3590074778,
0.2274753004,
0.4346411526,
0.0018372653,
-0.4307357073,
0.0453993604,
0.1642522961,
-0.4956144392,
-0.8944300413,
0.7529922128,
-0.7867773175,
-0.5095176697,
-0.3479411304,
-0.6848853827,
-0.4355814159,
0.0024645519,
-0.1237688214,
0.3418040872,
-0.2226450294,
0.2158919722,
0.476195842,
-0.1532139033,
0.5450293422,
0.736328125,
-0.2197870612,
-0.2008078992,
1.1537802219,
0.3355561197,
0.1978951693,
0.2906071544,
0.2635708451,
-0.0658522323,
-0.2592969835,
-0.7125452757,
-0.030634474,
-0.4067323506,
-0.2128601968,
-0.4167707264,
-0.1982872039,
-0.2016477287,
0.1114476025,
-0.3259757161,
-0.3447524905,
0.0575824976,
0.0485845581,
0.4202077091,
0.7159207463,
0.3934469223,
0.2985644937,
-0.6989285946,
0.2691374719,
0.239145115,
0.3794009984,
-0.1111032739,
-0.1933184862,
-0.2592642903,
-0.0167655498,
0.0029997698,
-1.0453705788,
0.2516045272,
-0.004169934,
0.5271861553,
-0.0286975969,
0.0082663996,
0.6010629535,
-0.2093060315,
0.8837228417,
-0.1805187613,
-0.78910321,
0.804605484,
-0.5483400822,
0.6360505819,
0.473210007,
0.5443089008,
-0.5056104064,
-0.2110276818,
-0.2387105823,
-0.7189334631,
0.9449957609,
0.5430318117,
-0.0280423611,
-0.0428446792,
0.2805786729,
0.1965236813,
0.4320690632,
-0.3766185045,
-0.0953323171,
-0.2554662526,
-0.2580640614,
-0.0831415132,
0.2892352343,
0.0062125158,
-0.1542215645,
0.5739890933,
-0.5188595057,
0.3037043512,
0.212752834,
-0.0917446911,
-0.0195384696,
0.5257094502,
0.2509498298,
0.6934130788,
-0.3126666546,
-0.0603503957,
0.1190559044,
-0.5668165684,
0.1903088689,
0.4848892689,
-0.2341282666,
-0.0691882148,
0.2759840786,
0.5016855597,
-0.1465783417,
-0.6822130084,
0.4512700737,
-0.0770546868,
0.1030746996,
0.1378109306,
0.0718613192,
-0.3143713176,
-0.2116975039,
0.5211017132,
-0.271833241,
0.0698001832,
-0.583619535,
0.1671117246,
0.1278164387,
-0.4912680686,
-0.4084473252,
0.330770731,
0.0292081162,
0.0164236259,
0.7968912125,
0.0617076755,
-0.0281764381,
0.8350470066,
0.5328514576,
0.7982013822,
-0.216796577,
0.4760611355,
0.1720861495,
0.2592228651,
-0.0567702539,
0.485950917,
0.1344809383,
-0.5131718516,
-0.7964416742,
-0.3390389085,
-0.5900056362,
0.222715199,
-0.6300055385,
0.2908337712,
-0.3271748126,
0.0851982459,
0.1625031829,
-0.0029171582,
-0.939039886,
0.222343564,
-0.0976432711,
0.9511130452,
-0.9044633508,
0.6906720996,
0.6978206038,
-0.7220289707,
-0.7430306673,
-0.0352516696,
-0.0083136074,
-0.8111412525,
0.700591743,
0.2909315228,
0.2027806789,
0.0054262853,
-0.820110321,
-0.7284085155,
1.0664589405,
0.4357202351,
-0.2140840441,
-0.0179678109,
0.3598922491,
0.7113634944,
-0.2044498026,
0.8186903596,
0.8021787405,
0.4637057185,
0.1589716971,
-1.0270680189,
0.0797703862,
-0.3973866403,
-0.089619115,
0.2583367825,
-0.5144581795,
0.8437355757,
0.1198437065,
-0.0659929439,
0.0408629887,
0.5083950758,
0.218978554,
0.3551858068,
0.3096652329,
0.3773839474,
0.8360173106,
-0.0970249102,
1.1487201452,
-0.2373765558,
0.3173498511,
1.1719825268,
-0.7034437656,
0.6857151389,
0.3237335384,
-0.3108407557,
0.3015829921,
0.2956255972,
-0.2343565971,
0.4480021894,
0.2832250595,
-0.1615531892,
0.0596854202,
-0.4372754395,
-0.3633583784,
0.501970768,
0.2682297826,
0.0391514301,
-0.4533278048,
0.0953887701,
-0.0868038759,
-0.2680788934,
-0.1699501574,
0.6119510531,
-0.1147674099,
-0.7422536612,
0.4527866244,
-0.1788364798,
0.1963354498,
-0.6604323983,
-0.226524815,
-0.2245457172,
-0.0309489556,
-0.0831549093,
-1.1026633978,
0.3730692863,
0.4344295859,
0.1148374304,
-0.0083844531,
0.7071418762,
-0.0675048009,
-0.3706432581,
-0.0216748938,
0.7153740525,
0.410279572,
-0.344406873,
-0.4801918864,
-0.0183157269,
-0.2886833549,
-0.2839155197,
0.0140477559,
0.3251864612,
-0.0506204516,
0.7871453166,
0.7162111998,
0.1578548402,
-0.2163437605,
0.4387712181,
1.0406882763,
-0.7889847755,
-0.1237586364,
-0.9385472536,
0.3356488943,
-0.1821152121,
-0.2222695202,
0.6875754595,
0.7295547128,
0.6745166183,
-0.0454842895,
1.0422270298,
-0.195820421,
0.5877867937,
-0.4015424848,
0.4606897533,
-0.1279210746,
0.1884316355,
-0.4640821815,
-0.8855748773,
-0.2153144181,
0.285784632,
-0.5530253649,
0.0425159931,
0.543391943,
0.8088264465,
-0.0761904418,
0.4377339184,
0.3063524961,
0.2673402131,
0.6367230415,
0.5259005427,
0.9449103475,
-0.4296244681,
0.6582359672,
-0.0317976736,
-0.3891507983,
0.289623946,
-0.508928299,
-0.973539412,
-0.196276322,
-0.2064290345,
0.0385123603,
0.0016228269,
0.8296144009,
0.599206984,
-0.7827544212,
-0.3580525219,
-0.2580523789,
-0.0730012208,
0.0470680185,
-0.3022613823,
0.2857908905,
-0.3406657279,
-0.7047400475,
0.72856462,
0.1931341887,
-0.002129439,
-0.3621082902,
0.1600800157,
-0.1030900404,
-0.0386943258,
0.3841569126,
0.2923585474,
-0.3464633524,
-0.2509566545,
0.3010228872,
-0.0188010037,
-0.0204877555,
0.8275001049,
-0.8595442772,
0.7005105615,
0.4848902225,
0.8182333708,
0.3887655437,
0.046923425,
0.810424149,
-0.8741551638,
-0.0189309381,
0.1937979013,
0.0519140512,
0.3482439816,
-0.4246806204,
0.8090119958,
0.0956499204,
-0.5996858478,
-0.7881836891,
0.1425857842,
-0.5801371932,
-0.1767834574,
1.00073421,
0.0320609584,
-0.187139824,
-0.3567092419,
-0.31343472,
0.1478877813,
-0.4781804979,
0.5558124781,
0.8988928199,
-0.181649521,
-0.0040469058,
-1.1023725271,
0.1949235648,
0.3104614317,
-1.1391232014,
0.2115743905,
0.3142787218,
0.0748350397,
0.2343284339,
0.5669053197,
-0.024355609,
0.1881276965,
0.0406083539,
-0.0490383729,
-0.1021743864,
-0.3778271377,
-0.2895022035,
0.1832888275,
0.0259784721,
-0.0805536136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01332v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01332v1
|
Wait, It's All Token Noise? Always Has Been: Interpreting LLM Behavior Using Shapley Value
| 2024-03-29T22:49:43 | 2024-03-29T22:49:43 |
Behnam Mohammadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) has opened up exciting
possibilities for simulating human behavior and cognitive processes, with
potential applications in various domains, including marketing research and
consumer behavior analysis. However, the validity of utilizing LLMs as
stand-ins for human subjects remains uncertain due to glaring divergences that
suggest fundamentally different underlying processes at play and the
sensitivity of LLM responses to prompt variations. This paper presents a novel
approach based on Shapley values from cooperative game theory to interpret LLM
behavior and quantify the relative contribution of each prompt component to the
model's output. Through two applications-a discrete choice experiment and an
investigation of cognitive biases-we demonstrate how the Shapley value method
can uncover what we term "token noise" effects, a phenomenon where LLM
decisions are disproportionately influenced by tokens providing minimal
informative content. This phenomenon raises concerns about the robustness and
generalizability of insights obtained from LLMs in the context of human
behavior simulation. Our model-agnostic approach extends its utility to
proprietary LLMs, providing a valuable tool for marketers and researchers to
strategically optimize prompts and mitigate apparent cognitive biases. Our
findings underscore the need for a more nuanced understanding of the factors
driving LLM responses before relying on them as substitutes for human subjects
in research settings. We emphasize the importance of researchers reporting
results conditioned on specific prompt templates and exercising caution when
drawing parallels between human behavior and LLMs.
|
[
0.0562228039,
-0.9426637888,
0.6486774087,
0.3846757412,
-0.1635337472,
-0.0076788226,
-0.2133193314,
-0.517049551,
0.4232811332,
0.3814375401,
-0.5533995032,
-0.1853621453,
-0.4111053646,
-0.1557755321,
-0.1710219532,
0.7780219316,
0.4480740726,
0.4829751849,
-0.4459729195,
0.0242672469,
-0.4673286974,
-0.9356488585,
-0.8371064663,
-0.4243164957,
0.5722560883,
0.2427195162,
0.6830152869,
0.2868011296,
0.2434334159,
0.2422249019,
-0.2950000167,
-0.1914787889,
-0.5553880334,
0.1987914145,
0.04842069,
-0.6517469883,
-0.3199911714,
0.281065464,
0.4100033045,
0.8802384138,
-0.0591042228,
0.2412943989,
0.2219119668,
0.4358307123,
-0.487737149,
0.2747316062,
-0.4946660399,
-0.0772495866,
-0.2980579138,
-0.2215515226,
-0.320503056,
-0.1063559204,
-0.1094442084,
-0.6753910184,
0.012841071,
0.3665359914,
0.7950203419,
0.1000123173,
-0.2349578142,
-0.4626939297,
-0.3904466033,
1.1342036724,
-0.5703295469,
0.1845143884,
0.3255299032,
-0.2144536227,
-0.4668982029,
-0.4613515437,
-0.6332383752,
-0.464468807,
0.078538835,
0.2187113613,
-0.3236165941,
0.1774725914,
0.2013838291,
0.3496441543,
0.1557765007,
0.199864015,
-0.3959922194,
-0.5029498935,
0.4805219769,
0.5475823283,
0.2873755097,
-0.3720705807,
-0.5179410577,
0.1359818727,
-0.3664757907,
0.8633923531,
0.5884355903,
0.1695463061,
-0.2242809832,
0.4208398759,
0.1073215306,
0.6049810648,
0.3989704549,
-0.1929546744,
0.0155086033,
-0.4616899192,
0.0159222968,
-0.0009898631,
0.7947180271,
0.4551791251,
0.1519225389,
-0.253828913,
-0.1913158894,
-0.0924147293,
-0.0041544088,
-0.7541161776,
-0.3222026229,
0.3013373017,
-0.8229174018,
-0.7946835756,
-0.0253409036,
-0.6493818164,
-0.6365271807,
-0.4083408117,
0.2589541078,
-0.3390963972,
-0.4076517522,
0.0461614542,
-0.2631747127,
0.3439285159,
0.1046411917,
-0.8895204067,
0.4709441364,
0.931874454,
0.9690266848,
-0.9271150827,
-0.4003142416,
-0.7148319483,
-0.028250834,
-0.4491121173,
0.876381278,
-0.6099132299,
-0.6304932833,
-0.2428006381,
-0.3066076636,
0.1179700941,
-0.5935608745,
0.7885660529,
-0.4912413657,
-0.050024569,
-0.8692811131,
-0.4148824811,
0.2517756224,
0.1915458292,
-0.6021959186,
0.8421509862,
0.110359937,
-0.6499835849,
0.5427435637,
-0.7145768404,
-0.4428991079,
0.107693173,
-0.3810862899,
-0.2479640692,
0.2896512747,
-0.0728579089,
0.127980262,
-0.129921332,
0.472198844,
-0.4550720751,
-0.6161615849,
1.0926396847,
-0.6615234017,
0.9491508007,
0.181403026,
-0.0833010003,
0.2349318117,
-0.3993992209,
-0.0824285746,
-0.0484746583,
-0.3495768011,
-0.198456049,
-0.2334619313,
-0.0828949362,
0.1083450764,
0.401332289,
-0.3910964429,
-0.1817014217,
-0.1223935485,
0.5200653672,
1.1225978136,
0.1764896512,
0.4891219735,
-0.5646499991,
0.7070953846,
0.3391101062,
0.3886588812,
-0.1727965921,
-0.6380007863,
-0.5650587082,
-0.5268496275,
0.2128654122,
0.0963430405,
-0.1861618757,
0.0701057017,
-0.0243213028,
0.1354583353,
-0.3440085649,
-0.1418904811,
0.003047104,
0.4928739071,
-0.0944729447,
-0.2131088972,
-0.6471672058,
-0.6988262534,
-0.5640572309,
-0.309782654,
0.0224282835,
0.5317166448,
0.2758873403,
0.2484970093,
1.1451683044,
-0.2170179486,
-0.0799578428,
-0.0380774811,
0.1225317046,
0.3340762854,
0.0842954069,
0.290899992,
-0.5129323602,
0.0002683634,
-0.493190676,
-0.4246051013,
-0.3926018476,
-0.1908435076,
-0.1088327095,
0.0416608378,
0.3955346942,
-0.4108527601,
0.1883419305,
0.6457632184,
-0.5255047083,
0.9102272391,
0.1266263872,
0.2121232897,
-0.7419010401,
0.0842753127,
-0.338516295,
-0.0223064627,
-0.4000871181,
-0.2317098081,
-0.3192462921,
0.008022923,
-0.3355020881,
0.6199414134,
-0.3286536038,
-0.3339317739,
-0.3543313444,
0.017047042,
0.0743842423,
0.3338006139,
-0.2448897064,
1.3184100389,
0.4114243984,
-0.8368781209,
0.3164624572,
0.1454514116,
-0.2734143734,
0.9466100335,
-0.6845805645,
-0.067103453,
-0.0767111555,
0.1644037217,
-1.0428248644,
-0.1506258994,
0.4877170324,
-0.541377902,
-0.2600242794,
-0.1126003116,
-0.3912311196,
-0.0639763772,
-0.4078473449,
0.5413442254,
0.6119924188,
-0.3686150014,
0.6674362421,
0.622000277,
-0.1189081818,
-0.4451237321,
-0.6592662334,
0.3337576091,
-0.3837829828,
-0.6955063343,
0.0853850469,
-0.2731191814,
-0.7651398778,
-0.2174310982,
-0.203638956,
-0.0221482497,
0.2888026237,
0.7171064019,
0.4130122364,
-0.0167945288,
0.0633094832,
-0.3928200305,
-0.2403398901,
0.6815513968,
-0.5034578443,
0.6246873736,
-0.0894440487,
-0.4646895826,
-0.2694675624,
-0.0005881897,
0.1848794222,
0.0674527958,
0.3795982003,
0.5633506775,
0.1555466056,
-0.0799731389,
-0.5117411613,
-0.2433661222,
-0.5543481708,
0.2344447821,
-0.217852667,
-0.7565741539,
0.7753869295,
-0.1142735928,
-0.3307315409,
0.0159928631,
0.529756248,
-0.3571034074,
0.7556234002,
0.3167045414,
-0.1267816424,
0.7019419074,
0.1747437716,
0.0652548298,
-0.8296102881,
-0.4574464858,
-0.3321557343,
-0.3595435917,
-0.2096859962,
-0.523396194,
0.4933861494,
0.0013991565,
-0.1039926112,
-0.5965843201,
-0.2282867134,
0.7266535759,
0.5314158201,
0.2781596482,
0.5717071891,
0.0060485848,
0.0390230902,
-0.2184032351,
-0.6557781696,
-0.3357390463,
1.0198026896,
0.0527928174,
0.6403518319,
0.0642901957,
0.5548440218,
0.5234145522,
0.2213024944,
-1.0393674374,
0.5466429591,
0.24820216,
-0.4785909355,
-0.2984487712,
-0.4449900985,
-1.2179989815,
0.1275640428,
-0.1649620235,
-0.7042826414,
0.0204894729,
0.0153282471,
-0.5811215043,
0.2793556452,
-0.2843194902,
0.478285253,
-0.4632863402,
-0.5611249208,
-0.2611269951,
-0.2030444294,
0.6497535706,
0.0172326006,
0.4950890839,
-0.2718445361,
-0.2548290789,
1.0160930157,
-0.1687206179,
1.1702631712,
0.0598625429,
-0.1411557496,
0.4626896679,
0.3365898132,
0.5862385035,
0.078375712,
-0.2266654074,
0.4423671961,
0.0537221953,
-0.6753906608,
-0.3539314866,
0.8113423586,
-0.8789442182,
-0.5648308992,
-0.5281602144,
-0.8435445428,
-0.0514359921,
0.1380223036,
0.1170609668,
0.2607625723,
-0.4044888616,
-0.217321679,
0.7080411315,
-0.0878953114,
0.4945418239,
0.4016959965,
-0.2550850809,
-0.3482553065,
0.7493842244,
-0.1338748485,
0.2275334746,
-0.121003218,
0.5270662904,
-0.4079796374,
-0.7319535613,
-0.0183422584,
0.1121058837,
-0.7271109819,
0.0743623003,
-0.4797445238,
0.3288177848,
-0.1085913852,
-0.1974548697,
0.0414716899,
-0.2667450309,
-0.344032228,
-0.0336842239,
0.3415899575,
0.8148080111,
-0.2486651987,
0.1807226539,
-0.4830170572,
0.2892541885,
0.4723758101,
0.4951379895,
0.188748017,
-0.5892603993,
-0.0828492418,
0.298909992,
-0.0975122228,
-0.7598693371,
0.0194358621,
-0.1558774412,
0.6805001497,
0.3626643121,
0.1363393962,
0.7946805358,
0.0883553177,
1.3217999935,
0.329618603,
-1.2438592911,
-0.0171462912,
-0.5139947534,
-0.1149683669,
0.4810979068,
-0.2876257896,
-0.6884601712,
0.0235653296,
-0.8074750304,
-0.5082306266,
0.6235558987,
0.0711520612,
0.2623101771,
-0.1457757503,
0.4936792254,
0.1440979242,
0.3056913316,
-0.6448672414,
-0.2170774341,
-0.0107831778,
0.0092245098,
0.2447819561,
-0.4160729349,
-0.1471639723,
-0.0823347867,
0.3349084854,
-0.0359728821,
0.0383344702,
0.0248249732,
-0.0177151747,
-0.2966546416,
0.1214440539,
0.4317882359,
0.6721977592,
0.0744190067,
0.190608263,
0.3593294621,
-0.3605101407,
0.0905432552,
-0.5043973923,
-0.2332611084,
-0.0545997918,
0.333514154,
0.4304440618,
0.565205276,
-0.8000436425,
1.0785652399,
0.138834998,
-0.1598002613,
-0.517041266,
0.089387618,
0.097854659,
0.279518187,
0.2822389901,
0.2730892897,
0.1966548711,
-0.5743539929,
0.3224785626,
0.7201257348,
-0.5040785074,
-0.5328546166,
0.7852852345,
0.3977889121,
-0.4634174109,
0.458768338,
-0.3087561131,
-0.2100606561,
0.5883260369,
0.4245926142,
0.6914806962,
0.3751071692,
0.3462886214,
0.0243537799,
-0.1223788708,
-0.1605127603,
0.2921717465,
-0.08450564,
-0.7561733127,
-0.6027011275,
-0.4198875427,
-0.5991603136,
0.1187750623,
-0.7739043236,
0.1945739686,
-0.5593398213,
-0.3892754316,
-0.1052035093,
-0.0304043908,
-0.6496948004,
-0.4193733037,
0.1751451194,
0.4876542389,
-0.6408038139,
0.4094256759,
0.4070030749,
-0.5054584742,
-0.6543690562,
0.262511909,
-0.0550651327,
-1.3981206417,
0.7483333349,
-0.1334975362,
-0.3490780294,
-0.1412049085,
-0.9540468454,
-0.805183053,
1.0460762978,
0.2709260285,
-0.2930478454,
0.2454335541,
0.4745919704,
0.3503725827,
-0.2332138419,
0.3083797991,
0.6447951794,
0.6778579354,
0.2497573048,
-0.6271073818,
0.2221198827,
0.2151422948,
-0.0513539538,
-0.1834027767,
-0.9641541243,
1.0726824999,
-0.4737159908,
-0.2540090978,
0.0113234138,
0.5170801878,
0.7181482315,
0.5036446452,
0.5270946026,
-0.0780473128,
1.1172658205,
0.1080079451,
0.8286716938,
-0.4286125004,
0.1097423658,
0.7251771092,
-0.1953548342,
0.439835906,
0.8895881176,
-0.470924139,
0.3912474513,
0.4706498682,
-0.0184302647,
0.1183797121,
0.5998135209,
-0.1535397917,
-0.489504844,
-0.3949450552,
0.0588434152,
0.282246232,
0.2348264307,
-0.0690392405,
0.0822031274,
-0.333339572,
0.2494116724,
0.0305662267,
-0.2807417512,
0.6506544948,
0.2380330116,
-0.3953119516,
0.2069971561,
-0.2374355048,
1.1278700829,
-0.4178347588,
0.0576843992,
-0.2250369489,
-0.1295793802,
-0.1651863456,
-0.7985702157,
0.0233477484,
-0.2151257992,
-0.2600268424,
-0.1781055331,
0.498097688,
-0.0793698505,
-0.4482488334,
0.0073851086,
0.6201217175,
0.3071023822,
-0.31966874,
-0.7248210311,
0.376654774,
0.0425657704,
-0.0637768507,
0.3762373924,
0.5224707127,
-0.0006740495,
0.669018805,
1.1241179705,
0.2700800598,
0.0337161422,
-0.0203967392,
0.7109216452,
-0.8517885804,
-0.7712165713,
-0.998052299,
0.3853167892,
-0.2507196367,
-0.4543963969,
0.6678649187,
0.5074424744,
0.3779329062,
0.2121462077,
0.9609231949,
0.3275605738,
-0.0189553462,
-0.565654397,
0.5390404463,
0.0832060799,
0.6371560693,
-0.0163324121,
-0.4338005781,
0.0648684651,
0.3015144765,
-0.2670199573,
0.0188983977,
0.5043414831,
0.6347732544,
0.1465465724,
0.1967945397,
0.4314857721,
0.2209321409,
0.4616107047,
0.1274793893,
1.3650085926,
-0.0747825578,
0.7867996693,
0.0316285864,
-0.0596182533,
-0.3068443239,
-0.8902335763,
-0.9687432051,
-0.4511933625,
-0.0705308244,
-0.6634571552,
0.0144083677,
0.8568906784,
0.54846102,
-0.6919271946,
-0.2979035079,
0.1050025523,
0.1154764369,
-0.411637187,
-0.3135679364,
0.203865543,
-0.5267030597,
-0.4717852771,
0.2333702743,
-0.0126322843,
0.098883152,
-0.3589504659,
-0.2512817085,
0.5330640078,
0.4643944502,
0.4165616333,
-0.0651303381,
-0.9473150969,
-0.1986924112,
0.2320744097,
-0.0919172466,
0.289185077,
1.172629714,
-0.7815293074,
0.1277772337,
0.2589090466,
0.1452346593,
0.3923662305,
0.1989139915,
0.4778555036,
-0.6472328305,
0.265742451,
0.3289678395,
0.1419028342,
0.2190231681,
-0.5584708452,
0.0482381135,
0.3078570068,
-0.3843293488,
-0.7074617743,
0.4350489974,
-1.0938900709,
-0.4165069759,
1.5063977242,
0.1761722267,
-0.4880089164,
-0.3838483095,
-0.3942410648,
-0.1520477682,
-0.8698682785,
1.1155991554,
0.7897430062,
-0.3719713688,
-0.1375941932,
-0.3560028076,
0.5213160515,
0.4329690635,
-0.4545788765,
0.2569244802,
0.5300369263,
0.5547278523,
-0.1017125174,
0.8981382847,
-0.0606131218,
0.0545562319,
0.2831162214,
-0.0809872821,
-0.5987664461,
0.3671333194,
-0.5363332629,
0.0551631376,
0.3516633213,
-0.2510433793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00184v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00184v1
|
Word Ladders: A Mobile Application for Semantic Data Collection
| 2024-03-29T22:41:40 | 2024-03-29T22:41:40 |
Marianna Marcella Bolognesi, Claudia Collacciani, Andrea Ferrari, Francesca Genovese, Tommaso Lamarra, Adele Loia, Giulia Rambelli, Andrea Amelio Ravelli, Caterina Villani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Word Ladders is a free mobile application for Android and iOS, developed for
collecting linguistic data, specifically lists of words related to each other
through semantic relations of categorical inclusion, within the Abstraction
project (ERC-2021-STG-101039777). We hereby provide an overview of Word
Ladders, explaining its game logic, motivation and expected results and
applications to nlp tasks as well as to the investigation of cognitive
scientific open questions
|
[
-0.2906682789,
-0.5330944657,
0.0279666334,
0.503588438,
-0.3064250648,
0.1415594816,
0.3969399035,
-0.4591846764,
0.6318196654,
0.3938248158,
-0.5511182547,
-0.9500331879,
-0.5511283278,
-0.2747584283,
-0.8118649721,
0.9961708784,
-0.007095173,
-0.1723787934,
-0.2880806923,
-0.3677286506,
-0.5374976993,
-0.1805190146,
-0.4821435809,
-0.4038689435,
0.5905930996,
0.8442571163,
1.2157417536,
0.8908454776,
0.9067572355,
0.1749882698,
0.0806049109,
-0.153605938,
-0.3746441603,
0.1755339354,
-0.3575296104,
-0.7384133935,
-0.326241672,
0.2240234762,
0.3601934016,
0.2913018763,
-0.3833037317,
0.8669186831,
-0.1776567549,
1.0602091551,
-0.894097507,
0.3735764325,
-0.6803663969,
0.4667099714,
-0.3271216154,
-0.6578474641,
-0.1483307034,
-0.5873845816,
-0.1765893996,
-0.500254035,
-0.024441069,
0.2622875571,
0.8137249947,
0.1168982759,
-0.5652329326,
-1.0311757326,
-0.4173963368,
0.4814881384,
-0.1420606375,
0.5398280025,
0.6682622433,
0.344784677,
-0.3786469102,
-0.7804008722,
-0.5256854892,
-0.1974636614,
0.1564888805,
0.2274161428,
-0.2095382363,
-0.0608614571,
-0.0784204453,
0.6184747815,
-0.4861873686,
-0.1368867606,
-0.4833216369,
-0.0812249556,
0.806252718,
0.55115062,
0.8725426197,
-0.2669378519,
-0.4234907627,
-0.0679813847,
-0.8180277944,
0.6550355554,
0.110772714,
0.1532903314,
-0.3147861362,
1.3810516596,
-0.0053542173,
0.8175544143,
-0.3731717169,
-0.2316704988,
0.2809281647,
-0.2195219845,
0.0772842169,
0.470551312,
0.787800312,
0.928208828,
0.1148142219,
-0.451305896,
0.0482844226,
0.6790339351,
-0.1668165326,
-0.4773654044,
-0.2042748332,
0.6576709151,
-0.6216074824,
-0.4922722876,
-0.403960675,
-0.6163057089,
-0.6332159042,
0.1854859143,
0.2568666041,
-0.3236929178,
-0.0812836215,
0.280564189,
-0.8426764011,
0.5044178367,
-0.2518838048,
-1.1006150246,
0.3607822359,
0.6430654526,
1.1061946154,
0.0777487457,
-0.1603810638,
-0.8122897148,
-0.009047538,
-0.6013608575,
0.5221796036,
-0.6927441955,
-0.9814866185,
-0.0911005288,
-0.1801963896,
-0.116912663,
-0.4384643435,
0.9319192171,
-0.5748302341,
-0.0225208066,
-0.0690478981,
-0.6851117015,
-0.1021541506,
0.1883142889,
-0.6684177518,
1.3300410509,
-0.2997641265,
-1.260311842,
0.4334979057,
-0.760435462,
-0.2030469179,
0.2046604007,
-0.2458320707,
0.2977128327,
0.0141519634,
0.1109305918,
0.4673410952,
-0.3147426248,
-0.0742500499,
-0.0205371697,
-0.3116889298,
-0.02419593,
0.4976339638,
0.8622912169,
0.6258372664,
-0.120541431,
0.2554588914,
-0.7413965464,
0.1932458282,
-0.0854273438,
-0.3814606071,
-0.7604523897,
0.8430433869,
-0.2874441445,
0.5374751091,
0.2681030929,
-0.9894158244,
0.2017540634,
-0.1361443996,
0.1431658268,
0.2136169374,
-0.3850170374,
0.3765715063,
-0.3700979948,
0.5425878763,
0.319253087,
-0.2608110607,
0.071331732,
-0.906342566,
-0.3799359202,
-0.1900588125,
0.5810983777,
1.2826553583,
-1.1031271219,
0.5281775594,
-0.6695219874,
-0.9715390801,
-0.5311578512,
0.1245053709,
0.2202621549,
0.3078811169,
0.1253201514,
-0.2945982516,
-0.4189701974,
-0.6220106483,
-0.5801632404,
-0.2530293465,
-0.3543272614,
0.3180543482,
0.6871406436,
-0.1958106607,
1.2944540977,
-0.3442592323,
-0.6467154026,
-0.1404199898,
0.1569651961,
0.0679777935,
0.27472049,
0.376590699,
-0.7152315378,
-0.2871561944,
-0.0670637265,
-0.9685362577,
0.1461213231,
0.1942531914,
-0.0111458255,
-0.5878109932,
0.5852985382,
-0.5368372202,
0.4123532176,
0.975917697,
-0.8103972077,
0.0680305958,
-0.0452733897,
-0.1514420211,
-1.2814729214,
0.0120571926,
0.074075073,
-0.0208873209,
-0.3499805629,
0.4027451873,
-0.114199698,
-0.1357078403,
-0.4606413841,
0.5786430836,
-0.3523840606,
-0.0965566263,
0.0045024478,
0.9001359344,
-0.5668822527,
-0.0654733703,
0.1976518482,
0.6304816008,
0.7485735416,
-0.6772748828,
0.614030242,
0.5282699466,
-0.3579937816,
0.2215849012,
-0.3763135672,
-0.1667804718,
-0.3123438358,
0.1347905099,
-1.0787495375,
0.0133874128,
0.1367930472,
-0.765337944,
-0.7127265334,
0.396066457,
-0.4327844679,
-0.6470840573,
-0.7320563793,
0.2214546055,
0.5038998127,
-0.5365359187,
0.3298242092,
1.0600224733,
0.0166951157,
-0.7261115313,
-0.8568056822,
0.2146291286,
-0.204156816,
-0.7258366346,
0.0494699106,
0.4263862669,
-0.364825815,
0.273850441,
-0.0671262369,
-0.0575995222,
-0.2194132656,
0.4393853545,
0.0829831511,
-0.2371706367,
0.4079466462,
-0.1280074567,
0.0742835104,
0.1445548087,
0.1186116487,
0.5076928139,
-0.3632694185,
0.041798003,
-0.1711501032,
0.2583884001,
0.4926963151,
-0.3990255296,
0.6454448104,
0.1942978203,
-0.3111310601,
0.197590813,
-0.1637943685,
0.4660123885,
-0.4715762138,
-0.0449838825,
-0.4819100499,
-1.0551908016,
0.7957217693,
-0.0326523408,
0.4024476409,
0.543748796,
0.351768285,
0.2257250845,
1.193528533,
0.3883866072,
-0.4180293977,
-0.0832943171,
-0.1369981468,
0.1401185244,
-0.7889261842,
-0.5700287223,
-0.9469172359,
-0.6426639557,
-0.9452739954,
-0.4393520653,
-0.1134712026,
0.1822259426,
-0.0684781447,
0.2570246458,
-0.7531666756,
0.5020110607,
0.545670867,
-0.0270913597,
0.5325939059,
-0.0930594876,
-0.4762885273,
-0.1314617693,
-0.6787745357,
-0.4439305365,
1.0582939386,
0.4692002833,
0.889123559,
0.0281591732,
0.9510349035,
0.2590082586,
0.1609285772,
-1.3770846128,
0.9004838467,
-0.1599519253,
-0.8145990372,
-0.292581141,
-0.2101020664,
-1.244258523,
0.2299605012,
-0.3056178093,
-1.1040680408,
0.2366309464,
0.159941569,
0.0554332733,
0.4298816323,
-0.4891475141,
0.6659392118,
-0.2224632353,
-0.1517887414,
-0.2531656325,
-0.7034986019,
0.5764793754,
0.2432512194,
0.6101005673,
-0.2167421132,
-0.2345809937,
1.0995063782,
-0.5400304794,
0.3295643032,
-0.3485192955,
-0.1028528959,
0.8727171421,
0.4486593008,
0.4066165388,
-0.2187685221,
0.183969304,
0.0110097649,
0.4209334254,
-0.1553140432,
-0.1702773124,
0.626447022,
-0.276035428,
-0.1321908981,
-0.6863008738,
-0.7168881297,
-0.4044903815,
0.2357691526,
0.1618988663,
0.162179023,
-0.0704143271,
0.5838106275,
0.2096053213,
-0.2719683349,
0.3920585513,
0.1603696644,
-0.8208326101,
0.063133426,
1.1125254631,
-0.0367604233,
-0.4290799201,
0.3783956468,
0.3075509369,
-0.5954508781,
-0.5333977938,
-0.5047717094,
-0.1725592613,
-0.3055800796,
-0.0446425155,
-0.3017049134,
-0.1354106963,
0.241123572,
-0.0543954521,
-0.049350623,
-0.8072499633,
0.3293662071,
-0.2725225687,
0.563313663,
0.6700060368,
-0.0682344362,
0.3457385004,
-1.2471250296,
0.6806773543,
0.1030043736,
0.5280447006,
-0.1235638633,
0.3002913594,
-0.0378459208,
0.3532860875,
-0.3427377045,
-0.7946876884,
0.2614502609,
0.3800997734,
0.2486791462,
0.2104398757,
-0.1756194234,
0.7570803165,
-0.6858851314,
1.3196060658,
0.6668098569,
-1.0094072819,
0.6103722453,
-0.5417405963,
0.2946459055,
0.4199033082,
0.6772670746,
-0.7303162813,
-0.4752054214,
-0.4240834117,
-0.8385033011,
0.6055189371,
0.2930608094,
0.1167457625,
-0.405777216,
0.1104776636,
-0.4748935997,
0.2378714532,
-0.6005558372,
-0.2135099918,
-0.2110767215,
-0.4012522399,
-0.0813619494,
-0.1870839,
-0.1043304726,
-0.4609442353,
0.293258965,
0.3138976693,
0.1048638299,
0.2216756642,
-0.191215232,
0.0362301953,
0.2541202307,
0.2292979807,
0.2163534462,
-0.2377736568,
0.1518249214,
-0.0382998548,
-1.0828408003,
0.1695138663,
-0.3503859341,
0.1498448402,
0.2519395053,
0.072129257,
0.3260195255,
0.0019745426,
-0.965095818,
0.4074937999,
-0.1005022824,
-0.3334940672,
-0.0277485847,
-0.0032410754,
0.633854568,
0.020171959,
0.3839274347,
-0.3417195082,
0.4382250011,
-0.7399665713,
0.4259978533,
0.6735036969,
-0.5894257426,
0.2002144903,
0.8695035577,
0.2074947059,
-0.5518045425,
0.7176641822,
-0.1234079078,
-0.1268243939,
0.4630112052,
0.5029255748,
0.617482543,
-0.4663056135,
0.5889844894,
0.2225503325,
0.3808114529,
-0.095268175,
0.7141774297,
-0.1457928866,
-0.7780323625,
-0.2554881871,
-0.7494431138,
-0.3646432757,
-0.2835009694,
-0.5779681206,
0.3303104341,
-0.316547811,
-0.3465357721,
0.0927004889,
-0.3920093477,
-0.2231218964,
0.3963904679,
-0.0239985604,
1.5530794859,
-0.5468908548,
0.6631658673,
0.5796471834,
-0.3391529024,
-1.0443885326,
-0.3336888254,
0.106365107,
-0.807698667,
1.1964662075,
-0.1302687526,
-0.7018806934,
0.1452283263,
-0.480276227,
-0.7090762854,
0.9416779876,
-0.1030850559,
-0.0800112709,
-0.4302969277,
0.5881918669,
0.6233557463,
-0.3868446648,
0.0074078501,
0.4221633375,
0.2115384042,
0.219106093,
-0.9622188807,
0.0241195429,
-0.596073091,
-0.1006905288,
0.442370683,
-0.0087468782,
0.6364143491,
-0.0122653348,
-0.431654036,
0.0308399294,
0.4240757227,
0.1451483816,
0.5180743337,
0.2920860052,
0.8458145261,
0.5426678061,
-0.0686957687,
1.1099963188,
-0.6048746705,
0.3628245592,
0.9160221815,
-0.1820998639,
1.1803555489,
0.3614670634,
-0.1485833079,
0.7258474827,
0.6544336081,
0.3225468397,
0.4033111036,
0.4352895319,
-0.161443457,
0.3244969845,
-0.1497859806,
-0.4825324714,
0.7105619907,
0.8832364082,
-0.269343853,
-0.7650710344,
-0.1327323318,
-0.1412131637,
-0.1228358001,
-0.7003874183,
0.4645313621,
0.1180553809,
-0.4822879732,
0.6423351169,
0.0792250559,
0.5508078933,
-0.6720004678,
0.0951438248,
0.1374584734,
0.1632394493,
-0.7193139791,
-1.0039154291,
0.4847024083,
0.018265523,
0.4369579256,
0.1278880686,
0.7017480135,
-0.1914366633,
-0.2399735898,
0.3442220986,
0.6663136482,
0.2622778416,
0.2451754063,
-0.6924294233,
-0.273767978,
-0.365822494,
-0.1162226498,
0.0379193574,
0.1279325187,
-0.3626717627,
1.0589692593,
0.6899235845,
0.2818607688,
0.43168661,
-0.4793724716,
0.6377803087,
-0.942180872,
-0.7575466633,
-0.632799685,
0.5540168285,
-0.0103303473,
-0.3018662035,
1.2152783871,
1.1952402592,
0.5011056066,
-0.1341358572,
0.5155079961,
-0.4561806321,
0.6432791948,
-0.4290353954,
0.6470080018,
-0.6581922174,
0.0381273814,
-0.3384646177,
-0.9087972045,
-0.5584951043,
0.4704891741,
-0.2776950896,
-0.6197767854,
0.8451643586,
0.5395525694,
-0.0330874734,
0.4936803877,
-0.1056327,
-0.3005478382,
-0.0581730455,
0.5025661588,
0.8376863599,
-0.4548200369,
0.3604339063,
-0.0315432921,
-0.4140278399,
-0.002067196,
-0.5819851756,
-0.8403905034,
-0.8434081078,
0.1862626523,
-0.4101986885,
0.0196469501,
0.8328633308,
0.0254730191,
-0.7110450268,
-0.8599578738,
-0.3428555727,
0.139044553,
0.0242790747,
-0.2647934258,
0.399572134,
-0.2055500895,
-0.3068574667,
0.1429320276,
0.069856815,
-0.404281199,
0.2700743377,
0.0800232068,
-0.5712561011,
0.1573794335,
1.0854147673,
0.6386620998,
-0.2931778729,
-0.2005939633,
0.0556595176,
0.0178880822,
0.0561991371,
0.9165728092,
-0.8717415929,
0.5737912655,
0.8380156755,
0.6208447814,
0.3132611811,
0.095578596,
0.2549125552,
-0.6043733358,
0.5633110404,
0.221473977,
0.1341846585,
-0.164165169,
-0.0598864816,
0.7488617301,
-0.0319947004,
-0.3542491496,
-0.7922785282,
0.1855041236,
-0.8317608833,
0.0024721855,
0.9094088674,
0.2834932804,
-0.1779547036,
-0.1668066382,
-0.1698948145,
0.0095840748,
-0.1455775946,
0.7210442424,
0.923864603,
-0.5614027381,
0.2752996981,
-0.7809635997,
0.7095004916,
0.0985524431,
-0.6580955982,
-0.218678236,
0.5380526185,
0.0188625846,
0.5823338032,
0.7413908243,
-0.4989371896,
0.2227206677,
0.2482094914,
-0.0224084184,
0.3414231837,
-0.0865855739,
-0.1360419393,
0.3525084853,
-0.0680624247,
-0.8023076057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00176v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00176v1
|
The LSCD Benchmark: a Testbed for Diachronic Word Meaning Tasks
| 2024-03-29T22:11:54 | 2024-03-29T22:11:54 |
Dominik Schlechtweg, Shafqat Mumtaz Virk, Nikolay Arefyev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lexical Semantic Change Detection (LSCD) is a complex, lemma-level task,
which is usually operationalized based on two subsequently applied usage-level
tasks: First, Word-in-Context (WiC) labels are derived for pairs of usages.
Then, these labels are represented in a graph on which Word Sense Induction
(WSI) is applied to derive sense clusters. Finally, LSCD labels are derived by
comparing sense clusters over time. This modularity is reflected in most LSCD
datasets and models. It also leads to a large heterogeneity in modeling options
and task definitions, which is exacerbated by a variety of dataset versions,
preprocessing options and evaluation metrics. This heterogeneity makes it
difficult to evaluate models under comparable conditions, to choose optimal
model combinations or to reproduce results. Hence, we provide a benchmark
repository standardizing LSCD evaluation. Through transparent implementation
results become easily reproducible and by standardization different components
can be freely combined. The repository reflects the task's modularity by
allowing model evaluation for WiC, WSI and LSCD. This allows for careful
evaluation of increasingly complex model components providing new ways of model
optimization.
|
[
-0.4523224533,
-0.5314915776,
0.5095180273,
0.0363671295,
-0.3025391698,
-0.2078387141,
-0.2539412081,
-0.5475618243,
-0.0639859736,
0.2555924952,
-0.8154148459,
-0.8290899396,
-0.3674053252,
0.0917245746,
-0.4594180882,
0.7904723883,
-0.4214725494,
0.050168816,
-0.1849121451,
-0.4558864832,
-0.3760517538,
-0.2634462118,
-0.1706309617,
-0.3038302958,
0.4833818972,
0.145070225,
0.6757853031,
0.4064397216,
0.4394396842,
0.2283315957,
-0.3203050792,
-0.0175452568,
-0.290096432,
0.2551935911,
-0.5184685588,
-0.2927251756,
-0.3961684406,
0.1474794149,
0.5049756765,
0.9805675149,
-0.4662044346,
0.335150212,
0.1056401506,
0.5930576921,
-1.2160315514,
0.4810712337,
-0.783329308,
0.0189324487,
-0.3536340296,
0.3007249832,
-0.1328920722,
-0.2744001746,
-0.0160108991,
-0.6146655083,
0.2815838158,
-0.1596903503,
0.8317933083,
0.4150879681,
-0.1058325842,
-0.2940551341,
-0.499026835,
0.7050509453,
-0.8146135807,
0.8709287047,
0.3181377649,
0.4572114348,
-0.1005925164,
-0.8879137039,
-0.6629914045,
-0.1921360493,
0.1398780644,
0.2329901457,
-0.2008496225,
0.0685418472,
0.3609690666,
0.3510055244,
-0.2948724329,
0.3167469501,
-0.1261415184,
-0.3834809363,
0.4405952096,
0.4050841033,
-0.0645314604,
-0.1501408964,
-0.2000562698,
-0.2824864686,
-0.5012235641,
0.0004364482,
0.0876034647,
0.3878524601,
-0.1217786744,
0.6095622182,
-0.6028982997,
0.7637358904,
-0.190990299,
-0.0285039581,
0.5141533017,
-0.5487952828,
-0.3077976704,
0.2300592661,
0.3524520695,
0.4470437765,
0.0713478103,
-0.0597112142,
-0.4926303327,
0.7431073785,
0.0688667297,
-0.7521308064,
-0.0828079954,
0.0113443695,
-0.5100058913,
-0.2082639337,
-0.0835974216,
-0.4112612009,
-0.3227216601,
-0.5364995599,
0.1022181064,
-0.4990614355,
-0.11042393,
0.3021918833,
-0.1305514872,
0.0402366631,
0.1787827164,
-0.760368824,
0.5360332727,
0.6959796548,
0.6002625823,
-0.6386739612,
-0.4175869524,
-0.1877504885,
-0.0273223575,
-0.535050869,
0.7941192985,
-0.250654012,
-0.4790800214,
-0.025040973,
0.1580986083,
-0.0410151407,
-0.6808369756,
0.5200194716,
-0.5671247244,
-0.1253249198,
-0.4437808096,
-0.7383106351,
0.2025475949,
0.3781107366,
-0.7090142369,
1.4924561977,
0.4921564162,
-1.0048532486,
0.7528807521,
-0.4576012194,
-0.0633735955,
0.3169571757,
-0.2004875541,
-0.1797071695,
0.0939152166,
-0.1030762717,
0.3422127962,
-0.2441447824,
0.2458917797,
-0.2493437082,
-0.487950772,
0.1641917676,
-0.1476314813,
0.536380589,
0.3944228292,
-0.3110544682,
0.0408287123,
-0.8951349258,
0.1569383442,
0.0054348097,
-0.2911157608,
-0.8652350307,
0.2539774477,
0.049219124,
0.0917046592,
0.3396126926,
-0.7781149149,
-0.0381017998,
-0.2380325049,
0.3203083277,
0.7655395269,
-0.1011461318,
0.1107757539,
-0.0975366756,
0.1365516782,
0.3371370733,
0.4170975685,
-0.0030310396,
-0.3445542455,
-0.5107862949,
-0.1851400137,
0.2717023492,
0.3835609853,
-0.5699922442,
0.4709253609,
-0.1950955838,
-0.6618958116,
-0.5461556315,
-0.0587311201,
0.3379397988,
0.4826917648,
0.5311425924,
-0.5072860122,
-0.2308183312,
-1.0845383406,
-0.247630775,
-0.1336343437,
0.0869818553,
0.1104934067,
0.6067022681,
-0.4291498959,
1.0218709707,
-0.6253031492,
-0.1587459743,
0.041960299,
0.170490697,
0.2129705399,
0.1026303396,
0.2397983372,
-0.7029596567,
-0.0659161657,
-0.1832973808,
-0.6056490541,
-0.4750014544,
0.1076885685,
0.0905101299,
0.2004254758,
0.9511329532,
-0.3985452056,
0.6286492348,
0.6021746993,
-0.4159133434,
1.0392314196,
-0.1450098008,
0.2133375257,
-0.9237915277,
-0.0698809847,
-0.175180763,
0.0414567031,
-0.3887572587,
0.3841958344,
0.5548347235,
0.0348524079,
-0.6586849689,
0.2801757157,
-0.3259193599,
-0.5116471648,
-0.0519355051,
0.30641976,
-0.1261244267,
0.1192515865,
-0.1160718054,
0.8139252067,
0.2636620998,
-0.6726372242,
0.3076125681,
0.0611310303,
-0.8564462066,
0.7225997448,
-0.6676511168,
-0.1376420707,
-0.0282590874,
0.1403653324,
-0.8203517199,
0.2648383677,
-0.0527973808,
0.0754915625,
-0.1253644079,
0.4134683609,
-0.735781908,
-0.4638561904,
-0.3476139009,
0.6303457618,
0.2401189357,
-0.5344907045,
0.2589743733,
0.1337095499,
0.2107177377,
-0.3253313005,
-0.7200959921,
-0.0709439069,
0.0907767862,
-0.3722385168,
0.8028481007,
-0.2956267297,
-0.5080013871,
0.3004225194,
-0.3206043839,
0.1697249562,
0.1069387272,
0.2527067363,
0.2885124087,
-0.1421342343,
0.2049583644,
0.1339195371,
-0.184330672,
-0.0861499235,
0.0664106905,
0.6228646636,
-0.0386045352,
-0.7542657852,
-0.4662242532,
0.2602097392,
0.5533147454,
-0.2455388308,
0.4645922482,
0.4962423444,
-0.5481989384,
-0.3809871376,
-0.5429856777,
-0.1560095698,
-0.4615325034,
0.5261976719,
-0.6023209691,
-0.8046119213,
0.5084293485,
-0.2247240692,
0.1398649067,
0.4910701215,
0.5967116356,
0.0399313867,
0.913765192,
0.3977512419,
-0.0341452509,
0.401954025,
-0.0549628511,
-0.023749806,
-1.0546004772,
-0.2554711401,
-0.628421545,
-0.2905002236,
-0.6824257374,
-0.4880123734,
0.3082564473,
0.2440026253,
-0.3922245502,
0.4842772186,
-0.5876364708,
0.2732752562,
0.1154004037,
0.1796454936,
0.3322679698,
-0.3452842534,
-0.4748850465,
-0.3763194084,
-0.3340845704,
-0.2614667714,
0.8252746463,
0.0438448489,
0.8403888345,
-0.0488350466,
0.7174262404,
0.5146760941,
0.1482700557,
-0.7352714539,
0.855646193,
-0.2627823651,
-0.0807540044,
-0.1281439811,
-0.0933911353,
-0.9507088661,
0.3113996983,
-0.2354040742,
-0.8041250706,
0.3149694204,
-0.1837146282,
0.1052815914,
0.2815009654,
-0.4454256892,
0.8200176954,
0.1854147911,
-0.079760775,
-0.5811929703,
-0.2020398825,
0.2825855017,
-0.1399561167,
0.4078471661,
-0.4013890326,
-0.200102061,
0.7578241229,
-0.4563806653,
0.7379214764,
-0.2548630536,
-0.1528980732,
0.0620485358,
0.3772013783,
0.5043724179,
-0.2585427165,
-0.4161029756,
0.2099305093,
0.3799923956,
-0.1930045038,
-0.3317379951,
0.8189929128,
-0.7785176635,
-0.389711529,
-0.460368365,
-0.6811598539,
-0.2678048015,
0.2070577145,
0.0545983389,
0.3532965779,
-0.5459655523,
-0.1286716759,
0.6080170274,
-0.2000297457,
0.4099517167,
0.6066660881,
-0.0958953127,
0.1734717935,
0.422984004,
0.0172996894,
0.5095552802,
-0.049166806,
0.2820261717,
-0.172371015,
-0.6932201982,
-0.2332375199,
0.0855534598,
-1.0500575304,
-0.1192703769,
-0.2812210023,
-0.2459223568,
-0.3231971562,
-0.185622856,
-0.5495600104,
-0.2057618797,
-0.1548068225,
-0.0126951421,
0.3353068233,
0.5560392737,
0.0562134124,
-0.1521578431,
-0.4753957987,
0.3986920714,
0.1499600708,
0.3471948802,
-0.1531691104,
-0.2072345018,
-0.0686758608,
0.080510214,
-0.1410271674,
-0.8897281289,
0.0129361497,
0.1750299335,
0.7235744596,
0.2817947865,
0.1289559156,
0.6412855983,
-0.4437297881,
1.0308265686,
0.3383055031,
-1.0653077364,
0.5483996868,
0.0001666416,
0.6992592216,
0.6815701723,
0.2011948526,
-0.7731779218,
-0.3335962892,
-0.4401281774,
-0.7932953835,
0.5031217933,
-0.1853194386,
-0.1149640903,
-0.1920905113,
0.3963269293,
0.2404029667,
0.040840812,
-0.2616439462,
-0.1054861248,
-0.2254021764,
-0.1732069254,
-0.0262951031,
-0.12724635,
-0.1657954454,
-0.3365754783,
0.4280038774,
-0.2233388424,
-0.0721662194,
0.2524317205,
-0.2500514388,
0.2436359525,
0.3957696557,
0.3011995554,
0.6955246925,
-0.1274984777,
0.1896603405,
0.5269224048,
-0.5901916623,
-0.2348822355,
0.0519195832,
-0.307192266,
0.0835924149,
0.3867026269,
0.8049657345,
0.6292778254,
-0.7521407604,
0.5000969768,
0.0621270463,
-0.3700416982,
-0.1253372133,
0.0642181262,
0.2850075364,
0.1994401067,
0.217688933,
-0.0611916147,
0.2111917138,
-0.6709668636,
0.283039391,
0.2780006826,
-0.5383015871,
-0.2239329815,
0.5317826867,
-0.3365889192,
-0.1401227713,
0.6288475394,
-0.3511022627,
-0.3458562791,
0.5423020124,
0.5927073359,
0.7347776294,
-0.2935667038,
0.2166435421,
0.3672043979,
0.0768353939,
-0.0732517317,
0.397978425,
-0.3635337055,
-1.1489876509,
-0.0493168086,
-0.7338514328,
-0.4173626602,
-0.0313012637,
-1.1794975996,
0.4355649054,
-0.3151663244,
-0.2706657648,
0.2966550589,
-0.1975643933,
-0.7844096422,
0.2138198316,
0.173338294,
1.2563018799,
-0.7659711242,
0.9377385974,
0.5376429558,
-0.0049472395,
-0.6595420837,
-0.1005528495,
0.1174404472,
-0.8028042912,
0.6979566813,
-0.0185312014,
-0.217274949,
-0.1692484915,
-0.3280083239,
-0.5864087939,
1.4275107384,
0.0071042287,
-0.9313492179,
0.2310942709,
0.2110006511,
0.6735978723,
-0.2814863622,
0.1015476957,
0.9448484182,
0.5619463325,
-0.043288108,
-1.0026805401,
0.2352107316,
-0.0506411307,
0.3720392287,
0.3114932775,
-0.2010831833,
1.0395870209,
-0.1237097755,
-0.4854549766,
0.0809314623,
0.3496335745,
0.5359319448,
0.2839094102,
0.9799560308,
0.8392458558,
0.6897156835,
-0.3098052442,
0.92450881,
-0.3978630602,
0.3707791567,
1.0747858286,
-0.7039601207,
1.0909738541,
0.6101458073,
-0.4306910038,
0.7554192543,
0.8588768244,
-0.0806042999,
0.896135509,
0.4971169829,
-0.2891937196,
-0.0698274896,
-0.3574253619,
-0.4615343809,
0.381840378,
0.5476753116,
-0.097979404,
-0.6866810322,
-0.0653819293,
-0.081700772,
0.2671273947,
-0.4482897222,
0.6516033411,
-0.0536077954,
-0.5334271789,
0.6684408188,
0.204081893,
0.781298399,
-0.8542588949,
0.247862488,
-0.1258370727,
0.4456821382,
-0.2460145205,
-0.7154223919,
0.42165187,
-0.243853122,
-0.0964822769,
0.0326870494,
0.6558127403,
-0.2327042818,
-0.3417881727,
0.762879312,
0.4548089802,
0.023944661,
0.093428649,
-1.0251871347,
0.5425000191,
-0.3117648959,
-0.2638360858,
0.5043072701,
0.2705991864,
-0.6937109232,
0.3730378449,
0.7085182667,
0.2689190805,
-0.1048271954,
0.6879683137,
1.047748208,
-0.5599976778,
-0.6001564264,
-0.5778357983,
0.0696092322,
-0.0659166723,
-0.4950931072,
0.471601516,
0.5721928477,
0.9113267064,
0.0929379389,
0.4850423932,
-0.1007187366,
0.3200831115,
-0.4781288207,
0.5355496407,
-0.5253364444,
0.2396814227,
-0.3964809477,
-1.0562316179,
-0.1075198278,
0.2640523016,
-0.0339739434,
-0.283673048,
1.1621963978,
1.007470727,
-0.1131718606,
0.4600344598,
0.2256466746,
0.2381211966,
0.0996847153,
0.4690027833,
0.6725854278,
-0.403080374,
0.1006994173,
-0.3659452498,
-0.4065388143,
0.2691187561,
-1.0213656425,
-0.5433854461,
-0.9988367558,
-0.5353855491,
-0.4103189111,
0.2730300426,
0.562159121,
0.5182693005,
-0.9021167159,
-0.2372161299,
-0.1596272439,
-0.258812964,
-0.6594873667,
-0.2842305005,
0.6665480733,
-0.2728878558,
-0.492506057,
0.4503982365,
0.1698959917,
-0.2104951888,
-0.3870803118,
-0.0207484718,
-0.1309169531,
0.0020173748,
0.6947405338,
-0.0264407676,
-0.7268679142,
-0.4882911146,
-0.1249501035,
-0.2829619944,
-0.3421533108,
0.8927366138,
-0.863435328,
0.3578803539,
0.4686652124,
0.4388536811,
0.8943535089,
-0.2814601958,
0.0912872702,
-0.5279727578,
0.394566983,
0.0245805588,
0.4198408723,
0.2650397718,
-0.0481322706,
0.5742825866,
0.4875964224,
-0.2767084539,
-0.8500923514,
0.2626803815,
-1.1052668095,
-0.5703085065,
1.176484108,
-0.1178553924,
-0.2516621649,
-0.1408636123,
0.130784601,
0.199097231,
-0.0896217749,
0.7426899076,
0.7495089173,
-0.0110377902,
0.1719734371,
-0.535528481,
0.4391155541,
0.3128224313,
-0.7801674008,
0.1861148179,
0.4268809855,
0.5388664603,
-0.0093018701,
0.6225126386,
-0.4040606916,
0.2904890478,
0.0393241234,
0.4065507948,
-0.066003792,
0.1573396027,
-0.0339200459,
-0.1063388214,
-0.1111497283,
-0.2442723811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00165v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00165v1
|
Individual Text Corpora Predict Openness, Interests, Knowledge and Level of Education
| 2024-03-29T21:44:24 | 2024-03-29T21:44:24 |
Markus J. Hofmann, Markus T. Jansen, Christoph Wigbels, Benny Briesemeister, Arthur M. Jacobs
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Here we examine whether the personality dimension of openness to experience
can be predicted from the individual google search history. By web scraping,
individual text corpora (ICs) were generated from 214 participants with a mean
number of 5 million word tokens. We trained word2vec models and used the
similarities of each IC to label words, which were derived from a lexical
approach of personality. These IC-label-word similarities were utilized as
predictive features in neural models. For training and validation, we relied on
179 participants and held out a test sample of 35 participants. A grid search
with varying number of predictive features, hidden units and boost factor was
performed. As model selection criterion, we used R2 in the validation samples
penalized by the absolute R2 difference between training and validation. The
selected neural model explained 35% of the openness variance in the test
sample, while an ensemble model with the same architecture often provided
slightly more stable predictions for intellectual interests, knowledge in
humanities and level of education. Finally, a learning curve analysis suggested
that around 500 training participants are required for generalizable
predictions. We discuss ICs as a complement or replacement of survey-based
psychodiagnostics.
|
[
-0.4752922654,
-0.3548576236,
0.6869247556,
-0.0106584216,
0.1867244095,
-0.0943016112,
-0.5425313115,
-0.3972164989,
0.1514721513,
0.200058192,
-0.6826127172,
-0.7883585095,
-0.5828112364,
0.0538673326,
-0.3441341519,
1.1486968994,
0.1007511988,
0.0793874636,
-0.5019595623,
0.0238531381,
-0.2884355485,
-0.693813622,
-0.4229417145,
-0.118244946,
0.5064303875,
0.2793569267,
0.5479178429,
0.3499151766,
0.4171740115,
0.2300516516,
-0.1308967471,
-0.2477044016,
-0.5197269917,
-0.1279285401,
-0.3688819408,
-0.5977367759,
-0.2213618457,
0.3970972598,
0.3072008789,
0.8314143419,
0.1301454306,
0.0939059332,
0.3412622511,
0.5347721577,
-0.46634835,
0.0317809023,
-0.751763463,
0.0672395676,
-0.0163903236,
-0.15496701,
-0.3203601241,
-0.4497725666,
0.5377744436,
-0.6339122057,
0.548992455,
-0.02833784,
0.6117997766,
0.0632403195,
-0.2356591374,
-0.5651934743,
-0.5964963436,
0.5949599743,
-0.3273088634,
0.2819068134,
0.6949870586,
0.1774104387,
0.0372482687,
-0.4359633029,
-0.487036109,
-0.265162617,
-0.2707027793,
0.1976212263,
-0.1005257964,
-0.0944201797,
-0.0015234381,
0.3013523221,
-0.6964231133,
0.3748787344,
-0.8064715266,
-0.2075910866,
0.4785543084,
0.2330848277,
0.3003484309,
0.0613000765,
-0.4868631959,
-0.2284750193,
-0.4157903194,
0.3811351359,
0.9892846942,
0.3044117987,
-0.1495763212,
0.6616743207,
-0.2109642476,
0.2159264535,
-0.0559861623,
-0.1185669601,
0.3487675786,
-0.2972880304,
0.119535163,
0.1716891974,
0.8112143278,
0.0860043243,
0.6014696956,
-0.4153768122,
0.0552439652,
0.2790473998,
0.5736451149,
-0.6170318723,
-0.3312577009,
0.3832322657,
-0.72587955,
-0.2492416799,
0.3721061647,
-0.9142000079,
-0.1955257356,
-0.2797989547,
-0.1076918244,
-0.8039413691,
-0.2014429867,
-0.0370721892,
-0.0717984289,
-0.31980896,
0.2742884159,
-1.0819610357,
0.4557518065,
0.5738517046,
0.850538671,
-0.5603474379,
-0.4993282557,
-0.1428905278,
-0.3112922609,
-0.3186179101,
0.8293057084,
-0.7574111223,
-0.3494396508,
0.1785414517,
-0.1778938621,
-0.0393201523,
-0.3865727782,
0.4683754742,
-0.4922923744,
0.4159742892,
-0.1373514384,
-0.5184597373,
-0.092209436,
0.1725255549,
-0.6243956089,
0.7528882623,
0.436247915,
-0.9591636658,
0.4412184358,
-0.6550711393,
0.0999730751,
-0.0209826473,
-0.2985025346,
-0.0148261944,
0.1144102067,
-0.0682430491,
0.3984928727,
0.117618762,
0.244228676,
-0.5887190104,
-0.2879371941,
0.6585450172,
-0.1360710114,
0.5922408104,
0.0525364056,
-0.149085477,
0.1879320145,
-0.7615253329,
0.0572288409,
-0.3607884347,
-0.572422564,
-0.6416053176,
0.0597272888,
-0.1484761238,
0.3772978187,
0.3425493538,
-0.812812984,
0.2893738151,
-0.6015287042,
-0.0407419614,
1.0799385309,
-0.1671396047,
0.3871578574,
0.0129263718,
0.5760865211,
0.3401045501,
-0.2015384734,
0.0849694014,
-0.6224849224,
-0.1538933963,
-0.3402343392,
0.2293670177,
0.3641502857,
-0.0338222459,
0.5433138013,
-0.3697504401,
-0.4152044952,
-0.6364266276,
0.0434078164,
0.4708811939,
0.2339925319,
0.339974463,
-0.3414452076,
-0.5403043032,
-1.091817975,
-0.3076617122,
-0.2392326593,
-0.6072441936,
0.4514781833,
0.7389557958,
-0.1166069955,
1.0166326761,
-0.7074484825,
-0.3292193711,
0.3254732192,
0.2356966436,
-0.010109744,
0.1394040287,
0.3678773642,
-0.7039551139,
-0.3015238345,
0.0423484147,
-0.8324104548,
0.3061519265,
0.2491929829,
-0.0142228715,
0.0756400824,
0.3540949821,
-0.1238109246,
0.6610326171,
0.5032142997,
-0.7689971924,
0.6480318904,
-0.1953878701,
-0.1140922159,
-0.7575210929,
0.1071586758,
0.4177258313,
0.2785529196,
-0.284783721,
-0.1839995086,
-0.0510172844,
0.1203400344,
-0.080996722,
0.6042072773,
-0.3715787828,
-0.225924328,
-0.2085657716,
0.2347258329,
-0.4535382688,
0.4996131659,
0.0012383598,
0.9870427847,
0.4427406192,
-0.6392984986,
-0.0344681479,
0.50252527,
-0.5739021301,
0.3134848177,
-0.4802220166,
0.2158275545,
-0.3907772005,
-0.0069784913,
-1.2211223841,
-0.377874583,
-0.2587674558,
-0.860324502,
-0.1303137541,
0.4799729884,
-0.2819351852,
-0.3857930005,
-0.3417378962,
0.0426660813,
0.3315558434,
-0.5729282498,
0.3845726848,
0.1147716269,
-0.1897157431,
-0.4093663096,
-0.5710732937,
-0.1800959557,
-0.1329553872,
-0.6164897084,
0.5011537671,
-0.4372130334,
-0.3949215412,
0.2157974243,
0.2016901225,
-0.1545770317,
0.0467556864,
0.5278959274,
0.5271508098,
-0.0539631322,
0.3676861525,
-0.1753234565,
0.0535529479,
0.2278574556,
-0.2383799851,
0.5911515355,
-0.3689700365,
-0.0343836509,
-0.1847714037,
0.3953343928,
0.3282467723,
-0.2151778489,
0.962731719,
0.5195541978,
-0.238587752,
-0.0634513348,
-0.3629046082,
-0.3483512104,
-0.3610681891,
0.3954755664,
-0.4813008606,
-1.0345470905,
0.6955764294,
0.1608897001,
-0.3161354959,
0.5502312779,
0.6780646443,
0.0273584127,
0.8645536304,
0.9138180017,
-0.0142598562,
0.1273480505,
-0.0948212892,
0.1553155184,
-1.0214377642,
-0.4908333719,
-0.5299425125,
-0.2885862291,
-1.0887731314,
0.0335707478,
0.502823472,
-0.1474351585,
-0.3991267681,
-0.0219342746,
-0.7395112514,
0.2215730846,
0.6995276809,
0.2554730177,
0.2071451098,
0.2151214033,
-0.3458444476,
-0.2360192835,
-0.0745556206,
-0.6221709251,
1.4567857981,
0.3537713885,
0.4788600206,
0.151551038,
0.3971348405,
0.1170241386,
0.3411034048,
-0.6747586131,
0.3322694898,
-0.2819122374,
-0.8572956324,
-0.3778668344,
-0.1610996276,
-0.7926004529,
-0.1299597919,
-0.2447435111,
-1.3837584257,
0.2231581509,
-0.1555413455,
-0.3658825457,
0.225498274,
-0.443236202,
0.5124919415,
-0.0483687557,
-0.2237980217,
-0.1195245683,
-0.7543054223,
0.4476327002,
-0.2747402787,
0.051981844,
0.0543060154,
-0.2824227214,
0.72097826,
0.0239088684,
0.839122653,
0.1649573445,
0.2849408686,
0.1077214405,
-0.0353816897,
0.2523308992,
-0.1747755706,
-0.2579664588,
0.1216210797,
-0.164795965,
-0.1079315171,
-0.4528543055,
0.8209357858,
-1.2559702396,
-0.2670113146,
-0.4582901001,
-0.3304368556,
-0.3763049543,
-0.0095609426,
0.6439954042,
0.2231624424,
-0.4621894956,
0.4165832698,
0.8815736771,
-0.3220686615,
0.2620100677,
0.2719337642,
-0.0747303143,
-0.3740453422,
0.5838282704,
-0.0235377699,
0.1286653578,
0.3018600345,
0.39909482,
-0.1895983517,
-0.434912324,
0.0328253508,
0.2036118209,
-0.544511199,
0.1363531947,
-0.9311228395,
-0.0885917991,
-0.6929978132,
-0.1720420122,
-0.1455121636,
0.0083658863,
-0.6250001788,
-0.2889308631,
0.2485110164,
0.858448565,
0.0303371772,
0.2013558745,
-0.2957382202,
0.1536321491,
0.2155635506,
0.644045949,
0.1398936957,
-0.4440136254,
-0.1329132617,
-0.1339760721,
-0.4424794018,
-0.9096832871,
0.5450149775,
0.052285403,
0.5426691771,
0.7635717988,
-0.1884021014,
0.1445725709,
-0.2766989172,
0.8664008379,
0.3863948584,
-0.5272572041,
0.4874031544,
-0.4878284931,
0.0096746041,
0.8463068008,
1.0547941923,
-0.3335595131,
-0.2516151071,
-0.6847952604,
-0.5967843533,
0.6807969809,
0.0545862466,
0.0566034429,
-0.180532068,
0.3539881408,
0.4989219606,
0.2093759924,
-0.6868223548,
-0.2444777638,
-0.3196774721,
-0.3215766847,
-0.0569375418,
-0.2289465219,
0.0156265534,
-0.282874614,
0.6289339662,
-0.3797004223,
0.5387252569,
0.2949495316,
0.6029329896,
0.0279397462,
0.3561914563,
0.4267340302,
0.7504291534,
-0.4765298069,
-0.0480122194,
-0.1007405892,
-0.6724043489,
0.0053033554,
-0.1056752801,
0.0392323099,
-0.0634646267,
0.1002191976,
0.7365762591,
0.0774025023,
-0.7798839808,
0.7538284063,
-0.0241343975,
-0.2407488525,
-0.8560230136,
0.0584111549,
0.2548125982,
0.0211946275,
0.3416934609,
-0.0431657135,
0.234775126,
-0.9072147012,
-0.0689685717,
0.3215543032,
-0.6675002575,
-0.5544043183,
0.7090661526,
-0.2238784283,
-0.2664711773,
0.8583186865,
-0.301632911,
-0.2966455221,
0.5695372224,
0.4746025205,
0.9610001445,
-0.1490053833,
0.1253063232,
0.7636638284,
0.1454373747,
-0.0662036166,
0.0383382291,
0.3280015886,
-0.7980401516,
-0.0060224552,
-0.8882048726,
-0.2707797289,
0.4515611231,
-0.7662707567,
0.3641850948,
-0.3801028728,
0.0538029298,
0.1231958121,
-0.0051697455,
-1.0804948807,
0.5625699759,
0.1460671425,
0.8985376954,
-0.7664576769,
0.6506217718,
0.7725430727,
-0.5467765331,
-0.7899792194,
0.1133283451,
0.1442893893,
-0.5395206213,
0.836697638,
0.2741108239,
0.1972971559,
-0.4706561267,
-0.5625534654,
-1.0336860418,
1.039437294,
-0.0720889494,
-0.4028443396,
-0.5802583694,
-0.1040105671,
0.7791013122,
-0.8361749053,
0.4414733052,
0.3724502623,
0.2565788329,
-0.1017282456,
-0.687309444,
-0.1544011235,
-0.272657007,
0.1110391021,
-0.0926834643,
-0.3890991807,
1.090649724,
-0.3071906865,
-0.092877835,
0.1588154882,
0.8117081523,
0.2595790923,
0.3327465355,
0.4273253977,
0.424831748,
0.9463378191,
0.1993932724,
1.1078695059,
-0.3914407194,
0.2053731233,
1.1922706366,
0.0030185862,
0.9569783807,
0.1548431516,
-0.3150746226,
0.9667600989,
0.6899952888,
-0.1191722602,
0.6766711473,
0.1961962283,
-0.2604365051,
0.0818314776,
0.046199929,
-0.1530097127,
0.8697453141,
0.3586893976,
-0.8409317732,
0.0395374224,
0.2368856072,
0.1226001009,
0.3643784225,
-0.2267202586,
0.7460942864,
-0.2284846306,
-1.0546592474,
0.0069161071,
-0.1098714396,
1.0358208418,
-0.5910182595,
0.2280627489,
0.0823568329,
0.1763574481,
-0.330132544,
-0.937656939,
0.2252354622,
0.0505904071,
-0.5245834589,
-0.047560852,
0.830462575,
-0.2557047307,
-0.3204838932,
0.4533329904,
0.586974144,
0.525483489,
-0.3572008312,
-0.0508598313,
-0.4458283186,
0.1590533108,
-0.2827869654,
0.7228296399,
0.4272625744,
0.0879860669,
0.4891526401,
0.5597698689,
0.2214111388,
-0.1038311794,
-0.3414151073,
0.9136055112,
-0.6764134765,
-0.7186990976,
-0.6063261032,
0.3129382133,
-0.1069403142,
-0.8884931803,
0.4758110642,
0.7155461311,
1.0243326426,
-0.1657910049,
1.1262495518,
0.2450903505,
0.7302359939,
-0.2277424186,
0.5782855153,
-0.3470923007,
-0.0733001754,
-0.0687269717,
-0.7148948312,
0.4117864668,
0.3238243163,
-0.6225548387,
0.1220675185,
0.9666397572,
0.5032963157,
-0.0516567156,
0.223379299,
0.3046988249,
0.1992535144,
-0.0362922922,
0.450656116,
0.3409774005,
0.0216657296,
0.4822255671,
-0.3315158188,
-0.5032042265,
-0.1287678033,
-0.4640425742,
-1.0044068098,
-0.9167880416,
-0.0746533498,
-0.531093061,
-0.1001820937,
0.7124963403,
0.3633858263,
-0.491697818,
-0.0369918868,
-0.0470225364,
-0.3074829578,
-0.1226449981,
-0.3047463894,
0.3967594802,
-0.234841451,
-0.5638634562,
0.1625254899,
0.0724852234,
-0.1342994422,
-0.7351058125,
0.2703653872,
-0.132414639,
0.0622497946,
0.4276753366,
0.100379169,
-0.7629454136,
-0.5018960834,
0.3400267065,
-0.261662215,
0.2658510506,
0.7323030829,
-1.0760142803,
0.4772512615,
0.3177932203,
0.2480005771,
0.3631463647,
0.0843318924,
0.2849286795,
-0.6082488894,
-0.1318055391,
0.3862527907,
0.2221214771,
0.3625479043,
-0.807185173,
0.6344084144,
0.057919398,
-0.5152421594,
-0.4356629252,
0.0773248151,
-0.9401981831,
-0.4670278728,
1.3134737015,
-0.3485808969,
-0.39057374,
-0.0619479269,
0.1037754491,
0.0678526089,
-0.5444303751,
1.0403530598,
0.9620541334,
-0.2675774097,
0.3891847134,
-0.7526911497,
0.3640538454,
0.0196478721,
-0.777413249,
-0.1651206017,
0.3608493805,
0.4441323578,
0.5035434365,
0.6052486897,
-0.1976040751,
0.1023889333,
0.2318477929,
0.3483651578,
0.0947509184,
-0.4380724728,
-0.1477281749,
0.5126803517,
-0.190748319,
-0.0718753785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01331v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01331v2
|
LLaVA-Gemma: Accelerating Multimodal Foundation Models with a Compact Language Model
| 2024-03-29T21:32:50 | 2024-06-10T20:59:48 |
Musashi Hinck, Matthew L. Olson, David Cobbley, Shao-Yen Tseng, Vasudev Lal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We train a suite of multimodal foundation models (MMFM) using the popular
LLaVA framework with the recently released Gemma family of large language
models (LLMs). Of particular interest is the 2B parameter Gemma model, which
provides opportunities to construct capable small-scale MMFMs. In line with
findings from other papers in this space, we test the effect of ablating three
design features: pretraining the connector, utilizing a more powerful image
backbone, and increasing the size of the language backbone. The resulting
models, which we call LLaVA-Gemma, exhibit moderate performance on an array of
evaluations, but fail to improve past the current comparably sized SOTA models.
Closer analysis of performance shows mixed effects; skipping pretraining tends
to reduce performance, larger vision models sometimes improve performance, and
increasing language model size has inconsistent effects. We publicly release
training recipes, code and weights for our models for the LLaVA-Gemma models.
|
[
-0.3056893945,
-0.7855542898,
0.3246850669,
0.8073563576,
-0.4044656456,
-0.0947956219,
-0.0755314678,
-0.7643976808,
0.3969533741,
0.3890409768,
-0.3859297335,
-0.0224897899,
-0.9393945336,
0.0967555344,
-0.4730826914,
0.4222753346,
-0.1497531831,
0.4130572975,
-0.3019291759,
-0.1766723245,
-0.5822554827,
-0.1881375611,
-0.5666061044,
-0.392005384,
0.5447638631,
0.5462222099,
0.7664370537,
0.5138085485,
0.6510971189,
0.2211398035,
-0.1898365319,
0.2010343373,
-0.5626530051,
0.0010694513,
0.1685596257,
-0.4546456635,
-0.7300145626,
-0.1085416228,
0.7848796248,
0.7457122207,
0.072344549,
0.2995384037,
0.0524689853,
0.5765226483,
-0.8224389553,
0.2951215506,
-0.3089413047,
-0.0596472546,
-0.3360809386,
-0.2897994816,
-0.6264482737,
0.082375899,
-0.2448239177,
-0.2735229135,
-0.0542143397,
0.0524944849,
0.8333969116,
0.2931872606,
-0.7234525681,
-0.2558456659,
-0.5952710509,
0.7011275291,
-0.1938028485,
0.7388163209,
0.3913552761,
0.4443359375,
-0.1738063693,
-0.8948897719,
-0.3388548493,
-0.2916561067,
0.0267489403,
-0.0289674066,
-0.0323796123,
0.1656035632,
-0.0460583046,
0.5521495342,
-0.4303889275,
0.1098139063,
-0.4259344935,
-0.075856626,
0.5176991224,
0.3546536267,
-0.0571086891,
0.2715200484,
-0.5405629873,
-0.174029693,
-1.2435665131,
0.0353805088,
0.2934206426,
0.2726981938,
-0.3784019947,
0.8804266453,
-0.292637527,
0.8389299512,
0.2239438593,
-0.6494833231,
0.2047148943,
-0.4512568712,
-0.3899394274,
-0.2572543919,
0.5382592678,
0.2187444419,
0.0645759404,
0.0286187697,
-0.1762500405,
0.3206685483,
-0.0173877832,
-1.3056608438,
-0.1808295399,
0.1132397056,
-0.5159189701,
-0.2375371307,
-0.5529904962,
-0.6621148586,
-0.3947308958,
-0.1022730619,
0.5109779239,
-0.0878368616,
-0.407204479,
0.4653080404,
0.1812291443,
0.399993062,
0.3969209194,
-1.3334753513,
0.2876901031,
0.1152077019,
0.6015988588,
-0.0003528034,
-0.3671315014,
-0.4978478551,
0.0060249502,
-0.4622394741,
0.9425797462,
-0.7311092019,
-0.6434909701,
-0.1581390649,
-0.0515106544,
-0.1042624563,
-0.4303083122,
0.2955755591,
-0.4714162648,
-0.1497259587,
-0.1593008339,
-0.1722225696,
-0.0045329244,
0.2155052572,
-0.6824581027,
0.9702301621,
0.1654668897,
-0.5990395546,
0.3154397607,
-0.4446475208,
-0.4350295067,
-0.2956841886,
-0.3538711369,
-0.3767143488,
0.2281827927,
0.2828952074,
0.5480675101,
-0.7271333933,
0.2673924863,
-0.3434897363,
-0.4290530682,
-0.0453342758,
-0.3617669344,
0.8181679249,
0.2779121697,
-0.2281782776,
0.1074334458,
-0.9128268957,
-0.3493189514,
0.2904623449,
-0.5530101061,
0.1529197395,
-0.2398466617,
0.1265654266,
0.2292612791,
0.3474724889,
-0.3018583655,
0.1165642813,
0.0315611288,
0.0436879285,
0.5420450568,
-0.3025524616,
0.4982433617,
-0.3269070685,
0.6974864602,
0.1138735637,
0.3697726429,
-0.3371483088,
-0.817417264,
-0.8522800803,
-0.6536512375,
0.376642704,
0.1067667603,
-0.6878812313,
-0.2231542617,
-0.2635193765,
-0.5296040177,
-0.4100169837,
0.4390579164,
0.6258999705,
0.1312047243,
0.2758186162,
-0.7657276392,
-0.562990129,
-0.9632081985,
0.1140334979,
-0.360296905,
0.1439646631,
0.3489133716,
0.4451247454,
-0.4613705873,
0.8583248854,
-0.2987746,
-0.3591442406,
-0.4192273915,
-0.0461294465,
-0.0441040583,
0.3027204871,
0.986800313,
-0.8880324364,
-0.2888920903,
-0.2467619479,
-0.6615861058,
-0.0504616089,
0.1754467189,
0.1630137414,
-0.0588820614,
0.3155720234,
-0.8613811135,
0.3672353625,
1.0982403755,
-0.4080998302,
0.8773877025,
0.1584521979,
0.1054520011,
-1.0392463207,
-0.2303636372,
-0.2520234585,
-0.2002895176,
-0.4956038594,
0.580524385,
0.2459803522,
-0.1286016554,
-0.8808957934,
0.763019979,
-0.6974987984,
-0.4151958823,
-0.1817421615,
0.1750283986,
0.3519245982,
0.4647190571,
-0.0543709733,
1.0533202887,
0.7446226478,
-0.6104716063,
0.2806708217,
0.3153653443,
-0.2861675322,
0.3890871108,
-0.6843184233,
-0.0424906351,
-0.0651828498,
0.1910590827,
-1.246617198,
-0.500295043,
-0.0848855898,
-0.3163557351,
0.5806545615,
-0.1632333398,
-0.6502566338,
-0.1100734249,
-0.3837377429,
0.7122496367,
0.2056811005,
-0.822334528,
1.0540758371,
0.4346111119,
0.045907177,
-0.6133276224,
-0.8285352588,
0.0919163078,
-0.2356487066,
-1.1013998985,
0.3960434794,
-0.1430694759,
-0.2983155847,
-0.2352872342,
0.0810729936,
-0.326076746,
0.3234815001,
0.3535709083,
0.0305834226,
-0.4522229731,
0.127106145,
-0.0162521582,
0.0637099966,
-0.0261878185,
0.089978002,
0.6448436379,
-0.3832445741,
-0.2581963539,
-0.2474517822,
0.1049428433,
0.5122081637,
-0.3402433097,
0.9577462077,
0.5336924791,
-0.1595791131,
0.2578190863,
-0.446967721,
0.0139761167,
-0.4932132363,
0.3464415669,
-0.7360966802,
-1.0526918173,
0.3684739172,
-0.3301917613,
0.0435802788,
0.2195154577,
0.9157999754,
0.1757758707,
0.8730100393,
1.0509520769,
0.2299457341,
0.5611696839,
-0.2856026292,
-0.0050112423,
-0.8230941296,
-0.2157426924,
-0.4551819265,
-0.0098777292,
-0.3605113924,
-0.6683741212,
0.0778059214,
0.3638980091,
0.1509323269,
0.4231539965,
0.2030277997,
0.3655348122,
-0.0350394584,
-0.0456809364,
0.3428501487,
-0.0519689992,
-0.3576401472,
0.3027065992,
-0.6991276741,
-0.3874338269,
1.4111198187,
0.4765330553,
1.1458662748,
0.5962445736,
0.334833324,
-0.0528972857,
0.5020513535,
-0.7437137365,
0.508964479,
-0.1023066416,
-0.8152140379,
-0.0215245094,
-0.1665484607,
-0.8338599801,
0.5017253757,
-0.5007439852,
-0.5474140048,
0.3660956919,
0.3333835304,
-0.1191576123,
-0.0344996452,
-0.8529241085,
0.7586573362,
-0.0967988968,
-0.6285629869,
-0.3695197105,
-0.4022281468,
0.7492387891,
-0.2845565975,
0.1173988953,
-0.103487961,
0.1599168628,
0.2769405544,
-0.0064805551,
0.9504908919,
-0.0092273531,
-0.1684557348,
0.3098291457,
0.1538737714,
0.4785145819,
0.1318062246,
0.0820191428,
0.1167706549,
-0.3666421771,
-0.6536493301,
-0.4058170021,
0.4597373605,
-0.7340029478,
-0.7803753614,
0.1172744408,
-0.5455592871,
-0.4185899794,
0.10511446,
0.0863242075,
0.8561084867,
-0.1542918682,
0.6123678088,
0.5558686256,
0.1357835978,
0.4702697694,
0.3048003614,
-0.7446990609,
-0.2167104185,
0.4054336548,
-0.1419866383,
0.5159916878,
0.3746275008,
-0.0256852247,
-0.3528011143,
-0.8024006486,
-0.7190642357,
0.2616046965,
-0.8090117574,
-0.0400188565,
-0.5365315676,
0.0264066327,
-0.4323461652,
0.0791270956,
-0.687155962,
-0.7179862857,
-0.2894675136,
-0.0402393043,
0.0560455769,
0.8720160723,
0.3115782142,
0.7262434959,
-0.6352501512,
0.2767206132,
0.4972282648,
0.3508431911,
-0.2094661444,
-0.6091558933,
-0.4863319397,
-0.1885551959,
-0.6437729001,
-0.5742855668,
0.0480582081,
0.3985669911,
0.3532412052,
0.6315509081,
-0.416134268,
1.0047684908,
-0.4632314742,
0.8736461401,
0.4164034426,
-0.5446984768,
0.2653551698,
-0.2648177147,
0.2294330597,
0.3925283253,
0.4114199281,
0.2916747034,
-0.3124073446,
-0.3385604918,
-0.5029111505,
0.0665267259,
0.2733615339,
0.1991817206,
-0.2035346776,
0.1865378022,
0.0666610971,
0.1388969421,
-0.8322347999,
-0.2180230916,
-0.1868176758,
-0.0808903873,
-0.1915715039,
-0.8549258113,
-0.038724836,
-0.0054666782,
0.4702208936,
-0.3652921617,
0.3142505288,
-0.0205969829,
-0.4772171378,
-0.1906604916,
-0.0513102524,
0.8666377068,
0.8945608139,
-0.1263723522,
0.1681878865,
0.1443574131,
-0.6948640943,
0.2342167199,
-0.1222791299,
0.2002693862,
-0.1402119845,
0.5609187484,
0.8101829886,
0.5236187577,
-0.6948430538,
0.7511926293,
-0.4325410426,
-0.257142365,
-0.3612731099,
0.1138257682,
0.3281807005,
0.386218816,
0.108301796,
0.1298330426,
0.0315942317,
-0.5707082152,
0.0308364332,
0.3751112819,
-0.2138271481,
-0.4593198895,
0.7771672606,
0.281835407,
-0.0781077147,
0.2971348166,
0.0737432912,
0.1330402493,
0.4518530965,
0.8734775782,
0.6131277084,
-0.3322475851,
-0.0634780303,
0.0534059592,
0.3241689503,
-0.1585244983,
0.1908696741,
-0.1738709807,
-0.8612259626,
-0.6673833132,
-0.9707440734,
-0.3092751503,
-0.134736523,
-0.568582654,
0.452519536,
-0.5249476433,
-0.2947799563,
-0.1807274371,
0.1218116358,
-0.6410030723,
0.3964825869,
-0.0695392787,
1.3083223104,
-1.007021904,
1.2448652983,
0.6956914663,
-0.4142801166,
-0.7976936698,
-0.190587908,
0.0678448454,
-0.8476926088,
0.8691264391,
0.4260978997,
-0.5299575925,
-0.0436621793,
-0.1833249629,
-1.1030079126,
1.4749982357,
0.6402703524,
-0.4725546539,
0.0643432289,
0.1723952591,
0.4027751088,
-0.8455806375,
0.2553975582,
0.5023728609,
0.1204099506,
0.3116575778,
-0.9431477785,
-0.2296639532,
-0.3188598156,
0.1344146878,
0.0605745316,
-0.9691764116,
1.0890382528,
-0.248846665,
-0.1934639513,
0.4338340163,
0.6750656962,
0.5485448241,
-0.0128000425,
0.5427342653,
0.6988955736,
0.4641602337,
0.0833046213,
1.316277504,
-0.4380226731,
0.2930571735,
0.9306750298,
-0.3106769025,
0.8698806763,
0.6531904936,
-0.1369864643,
0.4251253605,
0.776884973,
0.4402365088,
0.6274479032,
-0.2346791625,
-0.2523658276,
-0.2695576251,
-0.2843513191,
-0.4160889089,
0.7724570632,
0.3755153418,
-0.310010165,
-0.1009880677,
-0.0546682104,
-0.0197171625,
-0.1635966152,
-0.3617239892,
0.2670985758,
0.2226768732,
-0.2095571607,
0.7579252124,
0.0994928479,
0.3538488448,
-0.5475822687,
0.002998126,
-0.5654104352,
0.0397037826,
-0.0578332469,
-0.3885890245,
0.3456096947,
-0.2072151899,
-0.0677437484,
-0.1448414028,
0.721485734,
-0.21481812,
-0.4026319981,
0.7532989979,
0.3490719199,
0.1764986217,
0.2785274982,
-0.4454612732,
0.3049705923,
-0.2800220549,
-0.3301268518,
0.5117642879,
0.1799167544,
-0.1642104387,
0.8719742894,
0.6169849634,
-0.0284517221,
0.2460320741,
0.2661649287,
1.1689953804,
-0.3921665251,
-0.3242533207,
-0.7964293361,
0.4896756709,
0.3212735951,
-0.341486305,
0.5964300632,
0.4752457738,
0.6187303066,
-0.0753146335,
-0.0220672227,
0.0924376249,
-0.1331656128,
-0.8905078173,
0.3584178388,
-0.8567178249,
0.4363664985,
-0.1608764529,
-1.1355777979,
-0.5346568227,
0.2894964814,
0.06910754,
0.0638843849,
0.7928838134,
1.0026102066,
-0.1142591015,
-0.0462975502,
0.6630579233,
0.3599541783,
0.3278635442,
0.4596011937,
0.8389441967,
-0.4418969452,
0.5475623012,
-0.0707622468,
-0.3078994155,
-0.5303640366,
-0.88654387,
-1.2332847118,
-0.3683017492,
0.0689839721,
-0.0684139207,
0.052373454,
0.6238393188,
0.9152117968,
-0.4005061388,
-0.3354926705,
0.1260216981,
-0.0966302752,
0.0340448692,
-0.0994945392,
0.1891196519,
-0.2401490062,
-0.5157914162,
0.7101949453,
0.4359636009,
0.1906688213,
-0.5458977222,
-0.2515254319,
-0.2637464106,
0.1704173386,
0.8418786526,
0.0123994015,
-0.6768600345,
-0.3249593675,
-0.1161621958,
-0.1228712797,
0.1858616173,
0.6051255465,
-0.7195771933,
0.3053483069,
0.148808375,
0.7248548269,
0.8497459292,
-0.2108601928,
0.4277466238,
-0.9197589159,
0.7944612503,
-0.3284228742,
0.7999385595,
0.4073733985,
-0.1625222564,
0.622854054,
0.1562139541,
-0.3254797459,
-0.7189136744,
0.5785149932,
-0.840755403,
-0.0893890485,
0.9811910987,
-0.2116219699,
-0.4529272616,
0.0440209694,
0.0316515975,
-0.2050330639,
0.1529527009,
0.7164536119,
0.5688672066,
-0.1002214998,
-0.3492209911,
-0.5673540831,
0.2079392523,
0.4045816362,
-0.5430602431,
-0.2093984783,
0.3717391193,
0.415289253,
0.2584527731,
1.0341027975,
-0.4627452493,
0.571202457,
0.4367496073,
0.0128478799,
-0.1772607416,
-1.0373023748,
-0.439807713,
0.2008055449,
0.6435594559,
0.0467818864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00152v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00152v2
|
On-the-fly Definition Augmentation of LLMs for Biomedical NER
| 2024-03-29T20:59:27 | 2024-04-23T17:43:31 |
Monica Munnangi, Sergey Feldman, Byron C Wallace, Silvio Amir, Tom Hope, Aakanksha Naik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite their general capabilities, LLMs still struggle on biomedical NER
tasks, which are difficult due to the presence of specialized terminology and
lack of training data. In this work we set out to improve LLM performance on
biomedical NER in limited data settings via a new knowledge augmentation
approach which incorporates definitions of relevant concepts on-the-fly. During
this process, to provide a test bed for knowledge augmentation, we perform a
comprehensive exploration of prompting strategies. Our experiments show that
definition augmentation is useful for both open source and closed LLMs. For
example, it leads to a relative improvement of 15\% (on average) in GPT-4
performance (F1) across all (six) of our test datasets. We conduct extensive
ablations and analyses to demonstrate that our performance improvements stem
from adding relevant definitional knowledge. We find that careful prompting
strategies also improve LLM performance, allowing them to outperform fine-tuned
language models in few-shot settings. To facilitate future research in this
direction, we release our code at https://github.com/allenai/beacon.
|
[
-0.2610604167,
-0.8427579403,
0.5243914723,
0.0000133476,
-0.2217060924,
0.2211309075,
-0.2159936726,
-0.6932812929,
0.2784163952,
0.1426027864,
-0.52514714,
-0.380956322,
-0.5209515691,
0.6018406153,
-0.1932611465,
1.0636833906,
0.0453061275,
0.2062665224,
-0.5363535285,
-0.1031765938,
-0.3089252114,
-0.160043776,
-0.6584041119,
-0.537592411,
0.7903660536,
0.3300894499,
0.4226041734,
0.8499386311,
0.7852066755,
0.2303184271,
-0.4955382347,
0.4535246491,
-0.4066545367,
0.1081456244,
-0.2035839856,
-0.3333780766,
-0.6256443262,
-0.3774551749,
0.5849826932,
0.8184482455,
0.0111856032,
0.0036662526,
0.0759779364,
0.6345819235,
-0.6131139398,
-0.0504588448,
-0.4994145632,
-0.0511537641,
-0.0600978509,
-0.4597621262,
-0.1540848911,
-0.4249967933,
0.2923950851,
-0.8138650656,
0.2559432685,
-0.2545211613,
0.7647864223,
0.525113821,
-0.3022552133,
-0.3216482699,
-0.4400690794,
0.309782207,
-0.6415773034,
0.4775485396,
0.2547332644,
0.1179337874,
-0.1663176715,
-0.9039700627,
-0.4786107838,
-0.3513649702,
-0.3020689189,
0.1342816651,
-0.1085663438,
0.398330003,
0.4573749006,
0.1624186486,
-0.332813859,
0.1624712646,
-0.5833745599,
-0.3125808537,
0.3301360905,
0.1925244331,
-0.0492857024,
-0.0418194905,
-0.2945800722,
0.0528135709,
-0.8006808758,
-0.1212453395,
-0.1168462783,
0.1689245701,
-0.1805204451,
0.7969969511,
-0.456038326,
0.7964754701,
0.4418781698,
0.1663375944,
0.6565773487,
-0.6829334497,
-0.0278071985,
0.0086820358,
0.4646278024,
0.2592080832,
-0.2958910167,
-0.1245757788,
-0.2940185964,
-0.1369228959,
0.1860863566,
-1.0137580633,
-0.0658867583,
0.0973489732,
-0.0810286254,
-0.3436754942,
-0.3985439539,
-0.6506152153,
-0.682313323,
-0.3044636846,
0.7984938622,
-0.7706386447,
0.0554425642,
0.2174368203,
-0.2933095694,
0.5382456779,
0.3714969158,
-0.6215820312,
-0.001738442,
0.4932057261,
0.9701949358,
0.024321219,
0.095355086,
-0.719845295,
0.2060689777,
-0.2308258861,
0.7921157479,
-0.3837614954,
-0.5835148096,
-0.3731000125,
-0.2467460334,
-0.0138804028,
-0.4776900709,
0.1947178096,
-0.5870358944,
0.1490935087,
-0.1371794492,
-0.8166791797,
-0.0326700397,
0.2594715953,
-0.3865453303,
0.8512690067,
0.1904075593,
-0.6953940392,
0.4427500665,
-1.2309666872,
-0.6633427143,
0.4491417706,
-0.3843179047,
-0.1128515974,
0.302247256,
0.4323486388,
0.5142878294,
0.0958093405,
0.0918767378,
-0.014024361,
-0.3641625345,
0.4089302719,
0.0012027347,
0.5110940337,
-0.0764403716,
-0.2999073267,
0.1578039229,
-0.8538116813,
0.2060394883,
-0.3647196889,
-0.4428988695,
-0.0972483978,
-0.1856305152,
-0.4339461029,
-0.1464176774,
0.3366415501,
-0.4865656197,
0.1714546829,
-1.0010563135,
0.2478756011,
0.6874907017,
0.2808870375,
0.4596500993,
-0.4808532894,
0.4611895084,
-0.2573202848,
0.1459610313,
-0.144650802,
-0.4972732663,
-0.7681496143,
-0.4971513748,
0.3671669364,
0.6515783668,
-0.8378285766,
0.458997339,
-0.2205528915,
-0.5143937469,
-0.7686558366,
0.1490649134,
0.4276568592,
0.8970700502,
0.751283288,
-0.0090453364,
-0.6806380153,
-0.7473469377,
0.1372821331,
-0.040128991,
-0.274682343,
0.3140326142,
0.3919135928,
-0.7686148882,
0.9822469354,
-0.36609447,
-0.1363647282,
-0.1619420201,
-0.0083420668,
0.3835642934,
0.3055451214,
-0.0141244577,
-0.4520970881,
-0.197657913,
0.2677676678,
-0.719833672,
-0.3822764158,
0.0539540462,
0.0919752568,
0.0354512632,
0.7212777138,
-0.4347786009,
0.4984578788,
0.2573664784,
-0.206844151,
0.5731368065,
-0.5906623602,
0.0915445387,
-1.1223143339,
0.2211795002,
-0.2507037818,
-0.0110454662,
-0.7409612536,
0.1157389209,
0.1845604777,
0.3469624817,
-0.6663944125,
0.7375926971,
-0.486133486,
0.2984709442,
-0.4712881446,
0.1036085859,
0.1455557793,
-0.2259420305,
-0.0785574764,
0.8649091721,
0.879163444,
-1.0268983841,
0.2958468795,
0.6295483708,
-0.2095556557,
0.3394993544,
-0.900267303,
0.0904517546,
-0.2993680537,
0.1703906208,
-0.7397000194,
-0.4808247387,
0.1519472301,
-0.6327252984,
0.3697170615,
0.1060725302,
-0.2951548696,
-0.3175052404,
-0.1164027378,
0.2848818004,
0.6611062288,
-0.5833341479,
0.6521340013,
0.1056028455,
0.1023146138,
-0.4404329956,
-0.8012729883,
-0.0026565958,
-0.1892752796,
-0.567343235,
0.7069266438,
-0.3100652695,
-0.2242552489,
-0.17761904,
0.068006888,
0.096487388,
-0.0030019474,
0.3030325472,
0.3549478352,
-0.0401068293,
0.5075552464,
0.1708415747,
-0.0420889668,
-0.0698399991,
0.0147534236,
0.2672312856,
-0.0720510557,
-0.2418944836,
-0.4964958429,
-0.1616416574,
0.1594445407,
-0.0255750418,
0.5758052468,
0.8913991451,
-0.2659904659,
-0.0786805525,
-0.6398637891,
-0.7629848719,
-0.5896166563,
0.2212695181,
-0.3801220655,
-1.2002383471,
0.4680881798,
-0.188448742,
-0.2093215287,
0.1171272621,
0.4493300319,
-0.1986818761,
0.6494453549,
0.8737424016,
0.2941126525,
0.2481286824,
-0.1615862101,
-0.0258194525,
-1.1013627052,
-0.367156297,
-0.1891207248,
-0.3147834539,
-0.4653297365,
-0.9520638585,
0.8638051152,
0.0892886296,
0.0685839951,
0.0275302064,
-0.6079318523,
0.6590697765,
0.1731185019,
0.5567573309,
0.2898148894,
0.0314506665,
-0.4129313827,
0.1867977828,
-0.8281502724,
-0.2393506169,
1.3165094852,
0.2739107609,
0.6890624762,
-0.1467580497,
0.7546361089,
0.0278610475,
0.3791161478,
-0.9205141068,
0.5865336061,
0.2433965206,
-0.3584436476,
-0.1900956184,
-0.4930412173,
-1.0722090006,
-0.2066229731,
-0.3613543808,
-0.4884209633,
0.1587781459,
0.3536831141,
-0.8409511447,
-0.016086705,
-0.3524299264,
0.3216639161,
-0.2720595598,
-0.3504000008,
-0.2260053754,
-0.7665380239,
0.1631829888,
-0.3891067803,
0.1031010225,
-0.0621210821,
-0.6110433936,
0.6726231575,
-0.3730966151,
0.9220392108,
-0.0288278274,
0.1022716388,
0.2019304335,
-0.2450141758,
0.5381932855,
0.1115126759,
-0.3830079734,
0.1866942197,
-0.2056164742,
-0.2121547461,
-0.4943258762,
0.5695052147,
-0.4586952031,
-0.4089007974,
-0.0672888085,
-0.5992557406,
-0.4654093683,
0.1333660185,
0.504324019,
0.4172261655,
-0.0961820185,
0.2858627737,
0.964140892,
-0.422947824,
0.2578865588,
0.8144584298,
-0.1929226369,
-0.6755489111,
0.5942206383,
-0.1116248742,
0.3042454123,
0.4108886123,
0.4367901981,
-0.5916823745,
-0.9419329166,
-0.3440599442,
0.3152021766,
-0.4970181584,
-0.3394984305,
-0.6983787417,
-0.1320921481,
-0.5140212178,
-0.3440181613,
0.0546672307,
-0.3731238544,
-0.4402609169,
-0.3290807903,
0.8932821155,
0.6915246844,
-0.3560139537,
0.5034130216,
-0.9303866029,
0.2221726477,
0.0328084826,
0.3920824826,
-0.5391728878,
-0.8505392075,
-0.480588913,
0.1074908301,
-0.079598479,
-0.8093379736,
0.2902473807,
0.4443348944,
0.6542141438,
0.3489708304,
-0.1704445779,
0.8687782288,
-0.4013772905,
0.4813383818,
0.1901779771,
-0.7325466275,
0.8168113828,
-0.3452636898,
0.2934388816,
0.6785334945,
0.3292618096,
-0.177357927,
-0.3292630613,
-0.4313934147,
-0.9102813601,
0.3301186562,
-0.0492206775,
0.1531318128,
-0.1136915162,
0.7188619971,
0.1226440817,
0.1843511164,
-0.3599635363,
-0.1096059531,
0.2601933479,
-0.0415222757,
-0.1402420253,
0.089895159,
-0.2387446314,
-0.573448956,
0.7006182075,
-0.3998831809,
0.2846910655,
0.4276553094,
-0.0636506155,
-0.1156387031,
0.1110508591,
0.4846560359,
0.7266774774,
-0.0554304905,
-0.1668277532,
0.5916998386,
-0.3498893082,
0.0230565127,
0.3086105585,
-0.3537600935,
-0.1061029732,
0.2042625695,
0.7912569642,
0.1109782606,
-0.7906166911,
0.2643273175,
0.2583673298,
-0.4127250016,
0.1096820459,
0.3071089387,
0.008419225,
0.293102771,
0.3098697066,
0.0142480591,
0.2063161433,
-0.0457331799,
0.5248370767,
0.5522468686,
-0.246418193,
-0.1315933019,
0.5462878346,
0.1987092048,
0.0567989349,
0.4333554208,
-0.4020412564,
-0.2091030329,
0.3907444477,
0.5873396397,
0.5623065233,
-0.1976536512,
0.2338031083,
0.4668419063,
0.2375994623,
0.0900574774,
0.4335360825,
0.012242537,
-0.884816587,
-0.9814130664,
-0.7112004757,
-0.5726203322,
0.2079522014,
-0.4090295434,
0.5072520375,
-0.6063708067,
-0.2852211893,
0.0180198066,
-0.1796052903,
-0.5726903081,
0.099178113,
0.0643658862,
1.0713574886,
-0.4112842679,
0.5760521889,
0.9657287598,
-0.2911220789,
-0.9128177762,
-0.2031076103,
-0.0018661759,
-0.8321410418,
0.5480461717,
0.2383826673,
-0.0496185198,
0.3178255558,
-0.4119781256,
-0.9458847642,
1.1777331829,
0.0831451863,
-0.5238702893,
-0.0856890976,
0.1132020429,
0.7283566594,
-0.1965550333,
0.4870482683,
0.3564296365,
0.7199885249,
0.2238384783,
-1.0011680126,
0.0531473346,
-0.1825961769,
-0.3315907121,
0.1771204025,
-0.1989508718,
0.3235281408,
-0.6129006743,
-0.153765142,
-0.0000405039,
0.5634388924,
0.1779474169,
0.610258162,
0.1763332784,
0.5199235678,
0.9888789654,
0.0831347108,
0.7983239293,
-0.4029201865,
-0.1659746319,
0.9669413567,
-0.2932569683,
0.725358665,
0.6171233058,
-0.0885377154,
0.4290572405,
0.5258849859,
0.019460354,
0.2646616101,
0.3496358395,
-0.5713448524,
-0.0262331441,
-0.3546815813,
-0.5570042133,
0.3938604295,
0.8097297549,
-0.1779549867,
-0.3209680617,
0.4622653723,
-0.2924560308,
-0.1225616857,
-0.4783167541,
1.1229262352,
-0.0937401876,
-0.3636001647,
0.7788277268,
-0.1803596169,
0.9147179723,
-0.7200793028,
0.0787969232,
-0.1832007617,
0.0254745912,
-0.3510335982,
-0.5734500289,
0.4419017732,
-0.0860946476,
-0.0838320926,
-0.1213585138,
0.9546736479,
-0.3747108877,
-0.3815424144,
0.2268218994,
0.9296243787,
0.2009013295,
0.0113104777,
-0.6346709728,
-0.0874411538,
0.0541113168,
-0.1049403995,
0.2236140966,
0.3073589206,
0.0675900429,
0.8053923845,
0.7890606523,
0.3559843004,
0.1419332772,
-0.0293395966,
1.079122901,
-0.53123945,
-0.1672393829,
-0.8226280212,
0.509380281,
0.0665245727,
-0.1279383898,
0.5777170062,
0.6571161151,
0.6655104756,
-0.0836463794,
0.7053479552,
-0.1749389172,
0.7838429809,
-0.4498010278,
0.6882686019,
-0.3879563808,
0.2960019112,
0.1851154864,
-0.5601859093,
-0.5092225671,
0.5592651367,
-0.370090723,
-0.1055097952,
0.6397987008,
1.3660466671,
0.1443073004,
-0.2038122863,
0.3648342192,
0.2988469303,
0.1454581916,
0.4258999228,
0.8527296782,
-0.1476762593,
0.4375689328,
-0.2324317992,
-0.3731021583,
-0.226948902,
-1.1527248621,
-0.7816941142,
-0.1806229353,
-0.5369116068,
-0.4733185172,
0.2591687441,
1.0186215639,
0.6926579475,
-0.5200406313,
0.1278769672,
-0.3650090694,
-0.0346887335,
-0.1363316923,
-0.1845644116,
0.1677460521,
-0.6094483733,
-0.3803825676,
1.1586681604,
0.1803883612,
0.22550565,
0.1303378195,
-0.2766273022,
-0.0993793756,
0.1649786532,
0.5131424069,
0.2196660191,
-0.385820955,
-0.0722646564,
0.2068645358,
-0.0876857489,
-0.0085413083,
0.5397235751,
-1.2650587559,
0.5714021921,
0.4636331499,
0.9560446143,
0.2840445638,
0.1377182901,
0.4354580045,
-0.9149571657,
-0.2064225227,
0.4559600949,
0.0041748635,
0.4880612493,
-0.5566091537,
0.6001558304,
0.3152729869,
-0.5695987344,
-0.6689320803,
0.0336619169,
-0.9595395923,
0.055265259,
1.2321721315,
0.2844626904,
-0.0919308811,
-0.1103502139,
-0.1010567546,
0.3216895461,
-0.2624070644,
0.7261508107,
0.2132325768,
-0.5118764043,
0.0915596113,
-0.4585786462,
0.8510180712,
0.4807112217,
-1.0078002214,
-0.2948765755,
0.7320206165,
0.3398254216,
0.0728909299,
0.7794296145,
-0.0968282223,
0.3783654273,
-0.4778752327,
0.0676949248,
-0.42352736,
-0.1647467017,
-0.5593690276,
-0.0500142239,
-0.1122239083,
-0.1512234807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00141v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00141v1
|
Classifying Conspiratorial Narratives At Scale: False Alarms and Erroneous Connections
| 2024-03-29T20:29:12 | 2024-03-29T20:29:12 |
Ahmad Diab, Rr. Nefriana, Yu-Ru Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Online discussions frequently involve conspiracy theories, which can
contribute to the proliferation of belief in them. However, not all discussions
surrounding conspiracy theories promote them, as some are intended to debunk
them. Existing research has relied on simple proxies or focused on a
constrained set of signals to identify conspiracy theories, which limits our
understanding of conspiratorial discussions across different topics and online
communities. This work establishes a general scheme for classifying discussions
related to conspiracy theories based on authors' perspectives on the conspiracy
belief, which can be expressed explicitly through narrative elements, such as
the agent, action, or objective, or implicitly through references to known
theories, such as chemtrails or the New World Order. We leverage human-labeled
ground truth to train a BERT-based model for classifying online CTs, which we
then compared to the Generative Pre-trained Transformer machine (GPT) for
detecting online conspiratorial content. Despite GPT's known strengths in its
expressiveness and contextual understanding, our study revealed significant
flaws in its logical reasoning, while also demonstrating comparable strengths
from our classifiers. We present the first large-scale classification study
using posts from the most active conspiracy-related Reddit forums and find that
only one-third of the posts are classified as positive. This research sheds
light on the potential applications of large language models in tasks demanding
nuanced contextual comprehension.
|
[
-0.8223926425,
-1.0250569582,
0.7641372681,
-0.051297348,
-0.2700020075,
0.0257095657,
-0.3334681392,
-0.5364737511,
0.1416574568,
0.2789470553,
-0.2834979296,
-0.2509002686,
-0.9124994278,
0.129260838,
-0.7741032243,
1.0325664282,
0.2353549898,
-0.1673334986,
-0.0029066161,
0.2055760473,
-0.0587791428,
-0.6190925837,
-0.4855267704,
0.043829456,
0.7376537919,
0.1156399995,
0.5509825349,
0.5778715611,
0.5916190743,
0.3419042826,
-0.0009965182,
0.0506151319,
-0.4908003807,
-0.0856445879,
-0.2389929891,
-0.4977869689,
0.1478336453,
0.1645282358,
0.0637676641,
0.6078308225,
-0.0729938969,
0.0856373906,
-0.1657839566,
0.1120498106,
-0.5504026413,
0.0094769336,
-0.6429575682,
-0.2330327183,
0.0939513221,
0.0818004385,
-0.7028619647,
-0.6697074175,
0.4049608707,
-0.6556751132,
0.4572696388,
-0.0153824883,
0.7368335724,
0.0560497828,
-0.8102726936,
-0.6844160557,
-0.8300471306,
0.654548943,
-0.3099496961,
0.1357432753,
0.2134254724,
0.3766075373,
0.0175352041,
-0.7341323495,
-0.7938740253,
-0.1780044436,
-0.4037694633,
-0.2659450769,
-0.4384677708,
0.0153635098,
0.3534361124,
0.2799964547,
-0.6339733601,
0.0126107763,
-0.3161222637,
-0.3044167161,
0.4120768309,
-0.0678496286,
0.1597303748,
-0.2435840964,
-0.2851832807,
-0.013386705,
-0.4700672328,
0.0489939936,
0.2739169896,
0.2243728191,
-0.2821581066,
0.168800056,
-0.1345105469,
0.5932179689,
0.4104445279,
-0.205338791,
-0.0369827524,
-0.1055804789,
-0.3116360009,
0.1060473397,
0.5271391273,
0.4133956432,
0.089826189,
-0.0288287047,
0.2274210006,
0.524935782,
0.5664420128,
-0.7639972568,
-0.1883070767,
-0.1241626069,
-0.3825148344,
-0.3597079515,
0.5206538439,
-0.6629084945,
-0.7469624281,
-0.2307525277,
0.4920076728,
-0.0849633738,
-0.3218896687,
-0.0807601437,
-0.3232696354,
0.0498715751,
0.8028556705,
-0.4235211015,
-0.0533891618,
0.6446588039,
0.6602066755,
0.2766193449,
0.139155671,
0.0806583911,
0.135708198,
-0.3914488256,
0.8375126123,
-0.3233301044,
-0.1157843396,
0.2773553729,
0.0502849221,
0.2023114264,
0.0968382657,
0.7488340139,
-0.7861127257,
0.5473525524,
-0.3376077116,
-0.6151807308,
-0.4016911387,
0.6305614114,
-0.4752565026,
0.3126738966,
-0.2160065174,
-0.9739719629,
0.540966332,
-0.4918254614,
-0.6063367724,
-0.1756612957,
-0.314583689,
-0.3341927826,
0.0304911043,
0.0672337264,
0.4731445909,
-0.2714663744,
0.5477760434,
-0.0334373526,
-0.2404529154,
0.382997334,
-0.4004431665,
0.656187892,
0.5280930996,
-0.6309573054,
-0.0304819532,
-0.6205598116,
-0.204867214,
-0.115649417,
-0.2702337503,
-0.4213321507,
0.0383299068,
-0.1589113623,
0.0945960432,
0.0823931918,
-0.5851144195,
0.1723465025,
-0.2131766081,
0.341317296,
0.5398347378,
0.2513136864,
0.3391454816,
-0.32091254,
-0.0257857777,
0.1086826101,
0.3006545007,
-0.0732098743,
-0.6091187596,
-1.1096688509,
-0.0007195384,
-0.2152692378,
0.3130769432,
-0.6855597496,
0.646489799,
-0.3105688989,
-0.9279446006,
0.1176715046,
-0.6090574861,
0.342463851,
0.3516883552,
0.5583307147,
0.446246177,
-0.56870538,
-0.9051314592,
-0.40140903,
-0.4719102085,
-0.4661071897,
-0.0887903795,
0.3278733194,
-0.1578805894,
0.865283668,
-0.6287619472,
-0.0999442041,
-0.0826963335,
0.6917069554,
0.2896598876,
0.2534089088,
0.3100284338,
-1.0803697109,
-0.4032095373,
0.0551714264,
-0.6014764309,
0.3591656089,
-0.2499752939,
0.3233346939,
0.0126797259,
0.5850621462,
-0.5856382847,
0.3342045546,
0.170244053,
-0.6087796092,
0.1461817771,
0.0019403048,
0.6599339247,
-0.9029390216,
-0.1263765693,
0.0786303505,
0.0326114558,
-0.9372140169,
-0.0778629631,
0.1397631019,
0.1912317723,
-0.3564624488,
-0.1826531291,
-0.1884079427,
0.3660316467,
-0.2146289349,
-0.0401036255,
-0.2110491097,
0.4215494394,
0.1086358279,
0.0539385006,
0.3494823277,
-0.5368031263,
0.3300847411,
0.1969690025,
-0.5795365572,
0.5424631238,
-0.0390118696,
0.1949499846,
-0.105339013,
0.6226087809,
-1.0663422346,
-0.6117309332,
0.0174585786,
-0.5905666351,
0.1693179905,
-0.3515056372,
-0.3444162607,
-0.191077739,
-0.1891147792,
0.1978435069,
0.5014163852,
-0.4630790055,
0.4603941441,
0.4634914398,
0.3151503205,
-0.2694027722,
-0.7469013333,
0.0948127508,
-0.4611173272,
-0.4478736818,
0.0470656939,
0.1922730953,
-0.6065164804,
-0.2374411225,
-0.1421417892,
-0.2741186321,
0.084416613,
0.4676686227,
-0.0747352391,
-0.1733427197,
0.3792093992,
-0.2315456569,
-0.0158133265,
0.3259058297,
-0.1820415258,
0.3016322553,
-0.0011631076,
-0.1101147309,
-0.4843993485,
0.3020678461,
0.777556181,
0.3924042583,
1.0327612162,
0.5132903457,
-0.5065621138,
-0.2483221292,
-0.8332375288,
-0.2584224045,
-0.3982849717,
0.084221229,
-0.0715701357,
-1.176143527,
0.2882399261,
-0.0874580368,
0.0442486592,
0.7429016232,
0.3910793066,
-0.1366000772,
0.7563502789,
0.5906708241,
0.0850469843,
0.3096509278,
-0.0464441516,
0.3711243868,
-0.123153016,
-0.2052365839,
-0.7037578225,
-0.1637261361,
-0.7238281369,
-0.1717869043,
0.3793721199,
-0.1583193839,
-0.542108953,
0.4117802083,
-0.5830689073,
0.6356455088,
0.2524263561,
0.0858494565,
0.2325856984,
0.0215761513,
0.4407714307,
0.2159338892,
-0.4816883504,
-0.5363085866,
1.0173350573,
0.3027085066,
0.6047163606,
0.4414170384,
0.1624448448,
0.6495093703,
0.751971662,
-0.5077568293,
0.4529375732,
0.0151206832,
-0.8800882101,
-0.4196560085,
-0.4575457871,
-0.790935874,
0.1156006604,
-0.2764278054,
-0.4719931185,
0.2578378618,
-0.0598933324,
-0.4846982658,
0.521720171,
-0.7681747675,
0.6955122352,
0.0538907871,
0.153245911,
-0.6286550164,
-0.8699858785,
0.4126465321,
-0.1760143787,
0.5465163589,
0.0874032602,
0.1875094622,
0.6590873003,
-0.1463662535,
0.8869054317,
-0.1720358133,
-0.1895644069,
0.3388323188,
0.1272605658,
0.3522531986,
0.1557094008,
0.2232078761,
0.459980458,
-0.1897349805,
-0.2066681534,
-0.4168424904,
0.7157503366,
-1.0027887821,
-0.7984422445,
-0.3474007249,
-0.2236951441,
-0.0958588719,
0.0195372421,
0.5317598581,
0.411074847,
-0.2809604406,
0.436144501,
0.7638834119,
-0.0392408818,
0.1573883742,
0.2734520733,
0.1328406632,
-0.1617848873,
0.5926585197,
0.2138575017,
0.299157232,
0.7748962641,
0.2329685539,
-0.1735889614,
-0.7490916252,
-0.0696052685,
-0.0789175406,
-1.0118328333,
-0.3022818565,
-0.6642937064,
-0.1140549257,
-0.3774914443,
-0.4817464054,
-0.0968661085,
-0.3574108779,
-0.0908265859,
-0.1777501255,
0.1818728298,
0.9146225452,
0.0311504081,
0.4482376277,
-0.4714337587,
0.3100767732,
0.5438697934,
0.0631828532,
-0.3050643504,
-0.5836509466,
-0.4043027759,
0.0919291005,
-0.2542084754,
-1.0203106403,
0.0172826685,
-0.2272521257,
0.3321236074,
0.8420357704,
0.5135301352,
0.5534504652,
-0.117880486,
0.8698971272,
0.2983324826,
-0.8223032355,
0.6818301678,
-0.5534650087,
-0.0993675441,
0.2923714519,
0.7659027576,
-0.4051563442,
-0.6088994145,
-0.8059891462,
-0.3360483646,
0.6388005018,
0.2086229175,
-0.0012797012,
-0.3184783161,
0.1608237624,
0.2058328986,
0.2038390338,
-0.8364905715,
-0.2158551514,
-0.2777084708,
-0.0758586004,
0.0064858678,
-0.1751584262,
-0.4480117559,
-0.013578997,
0.4674517512,
-0.1909315437,
0.3613211513,
0.3059467375,
-0.2703993618,
-0.2747655511,
0.3377244771,
0.6830036044,
1.0160886049,
0.0240106508,
0.7137995362,
0.1982005686,
-0.4797926843,
0.2241083235,
-0.2138000876,
-0.0240079239,
-0.1405649781,
0.7664177418,
0.3356403112,
0.1771751493,
-0.2917869687,
0.6725748181,
-0.3147993982,
-0.1799189597,
-0.4986255169,
0.034070503,
-0.0929863304,
0.3134497106,
0.5903821588,
0.296497494,
-0.0584753454,
-0.7959487438,
0.166492328,
0.2361464649,
0.0263725873,
-0.3791442513,
0.2419135422,
0.3318553567,
-0.1434714049,
0.6007188559,
-0.1323829889,
-0.5936443806,
0.5431720614,
0.0430868492,
0.7625584602,
-0.3053609133,
0.1960566491,
0.770857811,
0.6959562302,
0.0418187492,
-0.4485358298,
-0.0008149426,
-0.8845155239,
-0.1221125945,
-0.4259930253,
-0.1853943467,
0.417842865,
-0.3664561212,
0.3587367535,
-0.7787319422,
-0.1626087576,
0.2000734955,
-0.1202788427,
-0.4723469019,
0.2105297893,
0.3665004075,
0.7412766814,
-1.0412558317,
0.6447373033,
0.3274988532,
-0.332639575,
-0.4118078649,
0.4109421968,
0.2545368373,
-0.2251056582,
0.4645184875,
0.4361765683,
0.1397182494,
-0.103775382,
-0.6159567833,
-0.7946674228,
0.7837113738,
0.1811147779,
-0.4775642753,
-0.0391933136,
0.24602516,
0.5226045847,
-0.4031682611,
0.2733004093,
0.313033998,
0.689609468,
0.1651581228,
-0.8804923892,
0.2279837728,
0.0819245651,
-0.5231664181,
0.4324447811,
-0.381071955,
0.7975748777,
-0.0276807752,
-0.4186656773,
-0.2390533835,
0.5595695972,
-0.3727035224,
0.4364138842,
0.8413525224,
0.4722240865,
0.4774692655,
-0.5013776422,
0.7975103259,
0.0268238485,
0.512427628,
0.5957000852,
0.3060114384,
0.4700282514,
0.4047173262,
-0.3707986772,
0.6620441079,
0.6880027652,
-0.0259193107,
0.4818557501,
0.1981052756,
-0.1149673238,
-0.4935928583,
0.1470205337,
-0.2967350483,
0.2182329595,
0.5788080096,
-0.2359526455,
-0.3464794457,
0.0212331638,
0.1391356289,
0.1245908961,
-0.4221332669,
0.8807075024,
-0.1985582858,
-0.628198266,
0.4111237824,
-0.0011196191,
0.625048399,
-0.6306948662,
0.0248985291,
-0.0160700344,
0.2632551789,
-0.3480846882,
-0.7204474807,
0.3853513896,
0.1535748243,
-0.0743951052,
-0.2336171567,
0.4756827652,
-0.2427326888,
-0.2095044702,
0.0359885544,
0.2966367602,
-0.0321146026,
-0.3048575819,
-0.167853266,
0.110049963,
0.1042738557,
-0.2853300571,
0.2421624064,
0.6184176207,
-0.1970333308,
0.3931246102,
0.8171727657,
-0.5868830085,
-0.0202509146,
-0.0986869335,
0.9169427752,
-0.5959734917,
-0.8316764832,
-0.9013185501,
0.4583300352,
-0.2908622921,
-0.2529576123,
0.9508799314,
0.4455438554,
0.9490561485,
-0.0606557168,
0.7188631296,
-0.3234019876,
0.5450130105,
-0.2424046695,
0.7637999058,
-0.1194122285,
0.2366166562,
-0.1772527844,
-0.5267151594,
-0.4771320522,
0.7478301525,
-0.4642488956,
-0.1668996811,
0.7316204309,
0.4741442502,
-0.0006429823,
0.4199751019,
0.385340631,
0.5332963467,
0.4322883487,
0.4400764108,
1.2942667007,
-0.1056546643,
0.7060277462,
-0.1025216654,
-0.3818942904,
-0.4881648421,
-0.6896998286,
-1.1228586435,
-0.7028295398,
-0.4129383862,
-0.13202627,
-0.2401294559,
0.7524146438,
0.6416429281,
-0.6975146532,
-0.0383008234,
-0.4358187616,
0.2323754579,
0.1726862192,
-0.2720091045,
0.289921999,
-0.1247588173,
-0.3997491598,
0.2493050843,
0.0919525027,
-0.1448469162,
-0.3457750082,
0.1287861615,
-0.2669250667,
0.2173134387,
0.5071519613,
-0.0056840684,
-0.9740968347,
-0.7644373178,
-0.3263808787,
-0.0699687153,
-0.2034363449,
1.0640615225,
-0.6756096482,
0.1001131535,
0.4462669492,
0.4657876492,
0.3291015923,
-0.1709180474,
0.1836898178,
-0.564852953,
-0.0109991208,
0.1805835068,
0.2439649254,
0.0945619717,
-0.5994139314,
0.2604180276,
0.412112534,
-0.5927029848,
-0.631998539,
0.2843351066,
-0.8532524109,
-0.6668724418,
0.9467797279,
-0.2217478603,
0.133823514,
-0.5615836978,
-0.0286715496,
0.3730033338,
-0.2322710305,
1.2075766325,
0.7130683661,
-0.1832252294,
0.068282783,
-0.2890947461,
0.6806530356,
-0.330747515,
-0.9850326777,
0.1480273306,
0.7462171912,
-0.0810782686,
0.8386751413,
0.1743963212,
0.239008382,
0.2618847191,
0.0193663035,
-0.3457871377,
0.0665177852,
-0.3601227701,
-0.0732253045,
0.7936111689,
-0.4158954322,
0.107340239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00124v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00124v1
|
Where Are You From? Let Me Guess! Subdialect Recognition of Speeches in Sorani Kurdish
| 2024-03-29T19:27:04 | 2024-03-29T19:27:04 |
Sana Isam, Hossein Hassani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Classifying Sorani Kurdish subdialects poses a challenge due to the need for
publicly available datasets or reliable resources like social media or websites
for data collection. We conducted field visits to various cities and villages
to address this issue, connecting with native speakers from different age
groups, genders, academic backgrounds, and professions. We recorded their
voices while engaging in conversations covering diverse topics such as
lifestyle, background history, hobbies, interests, vacations, and life lessons.
The target area of the research was the Kurdistan Region of Iraq. As a result,
we accumulated 29 hours, 16 minutes, and 40 seconds of audio recordings from
107 interviews, constituting an unbalanced dataset encompassing six
subdialects. Subsequently, we adapted three deep learning models: ANN, CNN, and
RNN-LSTM. We explored various configurations, including different track
durations, dataset splitting, and imbalanced dataset handling techniques such
as oversampling and undersampling. Two hundred and twenty-five(225) experiments
were conducted, and the outcomes were evaluated. The results indicated that the
RNN-LSTM outperforms the other methods by achieving an accuracy of 96%. CNN
achieved an accuracy of 93%, and ANN 75%. All three models demonstrated
improved performance when applied to balanced datasets, primarily when we
followed the oversampling approach. Future studies can explore additional
future research directions to include other Kurdish dialects.
|
[
-0.6815334558,
-0.7827724814,
0.3243046701,
-0.2934200764,
-0.6344959736,
0.2763722241,
-0.2391517758,
-0.31672135,
0.3513415456,
0.4428114891,
-0.7793121934,
-0.5840774775,
-0.8157184124,
0.1227470934,
-0.2317868471,
0.8320137262,
0.211956352,
0.5771589279,
-0.0226550512,
-0.3519759476,
-0.3075431883,
-0.6361266375,
-0.4890114665,
-0.2987697423,
0.0554605909,
0.6427246332,
0.330499202,
-0.0910580903,
-0.0934720188,
0.2037058026,
-0.3353433609,
0.098971352,
-0.301931113,
-0.0719489083,
-0.3037441969,
-0.4473664165,
0.2244483382,
0.1666550636,
0.4611815512,
0.5927484632,
-0.2469381094,
0.4437067211,
-0.2737023532,
0.3729675114,
-0.68150419,
-0.4248265326,
-0.5005803704,
0.5483527184,
-0.171782583,
-0.1053815782,
0.0387611501,
-0.6984545588,
0.5197412968,
-0.0046103285,
0.5371563435,
-0.1604997367,
0.7525836229,
0.1221909001,
-0.553165257,
-0.2182023674,
-0.7511280179,
0.7731714845,
-0.8063631058,
0.6016846299,
0.8038366437,
0.6233147979,
-0.1201039478,
-0.5795065761,
-0.5708810687,
-0.2032250315,
-0.1036041006,
0.139348045,
-0.4322034717,
-0.402600348,
0.3370196819,
0.26445207,
-0.6214436889,
0.0997635499,
-0.8075832725,
-0.3711439967,
0.6406591535,
-0.2087792754,
0.0541999787,
-0.2275610417,
-0.1593092382,
0.264157325,
-0.6824135184,
0.304605484,
0.6301094294,
0.3673277199,
-0.0599428341,
0.6640256643,
-0.5011740327,
0.4799252152,
0.2390786111,
-0.1041434482,
0.1127720922,
-0.3127556145,
-0.3880383372,
0.4670854807,
0.970941484,
0.0578447469,
0.389038533,
0.1168218926,
0.3768015504,
-0.320761174,
-0.1258938015,
-0.4643978179,
-0.3547882736,
0.0586531609,
-0.7033811808,
-0.0840758681,
-0.3942573965,
-0.6763276458,
-0.6972463131,
-0.1398617774,
-0.1320331693,
-0.3653206825,
-0.4049289823,
-0.2137262225,
0.1632177532,
0.0457833,
0.0339726321,
-1.135861516,
0.3029627204,
0.5158835053,
0.77577281,
0.2785672843,
-0.0616296344,
-0.6067749858,
-0.5296559334,
-0.4710177481,
0.8042955995,
-0.5733587742,
-0.5801215172,
-0.0694280639,
0.0549627468,
-0.0374661051,
-0.8889299631,
0.740052402,
-0.4247036874,
0.4488089383,
-0.4270839691,
-0.2449251562,
-0.2985671759,
0.1332020611,
-0.4433181286,
1.1261819601,
0.1439116746,
-0.9108324647,
0.6069470048,
0.2019590437,
-0.4214158058,
0.1518597752,
-0.5302116275,
-0.4283670485,
0.2183416188,
0.5970757604,
0.5252919197,
-0.2703469992,
0.2864610851,
0.1502398252,
-0.3286617994,
0.354850173,
-0.5938482285,
1.1240662336,
0.3339290917,
-0.4848611653,
-0.0685330853,
-0.7836696506,
-0.1119375974,
-0.232464239,
-0.4669139981,
-0.0981608033,
0.0346433371,
0.0573131293,
0.1463121772,
0.0941638499,
-0.8950762153,
0.0248361193,
-0.380433619,
0.3632225394,
0.5531263947,
0.0282816477,
0.4161219895,
-0.0480796807,
0.8012010455,
0.0485524982,
-0.1815556139,
0.4807115495,
-0.2581559122,
-0.6223598123,
-0.1633536369,
0.6986111999,
0.6811783314,
-0.538081944,
0.2155848294,
-0.1882130802,
-0.7852104306,
-0.6301840544,
-0.1116061732,
0.1855513006,
0.7028475404,
0.3788771331,
-0.2672044933,
-1.1468327045,
-1.0408835411,
-0.0802250355,
-0.3116494417,
-0.2249912769,
0.4899915755,
0.2816938162,
-0.137920171,
0.9291718602,
-0.1483016461,
-0.5594096184,
-0.6872683167,
0.2406935394,
0.3557214439,
0.328601867,
0.3480975628,
-0.819259882,
-0.684720099,
0.2433272898,
-0.5357797742,
-0.0185815264,
0.2326015085,
0.1330366582,
0.43021366,
0.7715470195,
-0.4702680707,
0.3846985102,
0.5825551748,
-0.2661974728,
0.6003392935,
0.105669722,
0.0580803901,
-1.0673027039,
-0.1039255038,
-0.2890675366,
-0.2700242996,
-0.5055795312,
-0.3943943679,
-0.3438331187,
-0.0656562075,
-0.5091161132,
0.1239661351,
-0.1606111974,
-0.0623778738,
0.1996353865,
-0.1298937201,
-0.5041502118,
0.2459681183,
0.2423490435,
0.8634702563,
0.6956806183,
-0.1593379974,
0.5618079305,
0.183595866,
-1.1228612661,
0.6500345469,
-0.4413723648,
0.2356603444,
-0.3268478513,
0.4462568164,
-0.9055997729,
-0.3467119038,
0.462800324,
-0.642463088,
0.0671963468,
-0.5147770643,
-0.1496820748,
0.1047673374,
0.3667166233,
0.4062730968,
0.5338341594,
-0.3550695181,
1.0216118097,
0.6072001457,
-0.4821977615,
-0.6333497763,
-0.6201328635,
-0.0421198756,
-0.5732197762,
-0.1920089424,
-0.2551617026,
0.5242461562,
-0.3891034722,
-0.1027788445,
-0.1396715492,
-0.0941872373,
-0.17952393,
0.3975093961,
-0.1820162684,
-0.396548599,
0.0628622994,
-0.0666643381,
0.1867580861,
-0.0876513943,
-0.3353331983,
0.723951757,
0.0738138482,
-0.1551597118,
-0.6349856853,
0.5730935335,
0.49111256,
-0.0781784728,
0.4990732074,
0.8001278043,
-0.3623204827,
-0.0152318636,
-0.6451093554,
-0.0324737914,
-0.4029652774,
0.5969111919,
-0.4354664981,
-0.918412745,
0.4913688302,
-0.2340073436,
-0.1858073026,
0.1286438853,
0.4967999756,
-0.5062016845,
0.8350811005,
0.4819616079,
-0.4829751253,
0.3636363447,
-0.1885616034,
0.462015152,
-0.5583502054,
-0.4152583778,
-0.5093101859,
-0.5064710379,
-0.7991968393,
-0.4273990095,
0.2962774634,
0.1060960963,
-0.0003300356,
0.2307898998,
-0.0550147444,
0.4715912044,
0.894580543,
0.0902897567,
-0.002967936,
0.2044265717,
-0.2152686119,
-0.3117183745,
-0.9048910737,
-0.4350344837,
0.9298399091,
0.3619088531,
0.8119594455,
0.2207071483,
0.6788901091,
0.2966424227,
-0.0248283204,
-0.6337605715,
0.5719954967,
-0.3432612717,
-0.3986922503,
-0.5311134458,
-0.2902683318,
-0.9644939303,
0.0598230809,
-0.2972415984,
-0.7946857214,
0.2513289154,
0.0805015638,
-0.7422617674,
0.1291911155,
-0.5019695759,
0.7440517545,
-0.0045351619,
0.2272763401,
-0.0433163159,
-0.710481286,
0.0452133529,
0.2556586564,
0.5370577574,
-0.3363500535,
0.6721555591,
0.747320056,
-0.2760065198,
0.659612596,
-0.2590228915,
0.0541922525,
0.4801235199,
0.1491376162,
0.1931235045,
0.091058135,
-0.003265138,
0.4165519476,
0.1737297177,
-0.3421955407,
-0.5582540035,
0.6323001385,
-1.0134090185,
-0.5729133487,
-0.4048855603,
-0.2707444429,
-0.2788448334,
0.1091351211,
0.8257405758,
0.6601344943,
-0.2725408375,
0.3539431095,
0.6499967575,
-0.2425766736,
0.2365753949,
0.3473306596,
-0.0953694656,
-0.3660421073,
0.8549305797,
0.3335351646,
0.0447492525,
0.2330537438,
0.3860804439,
-0.6381108165,
-0.486327976,
-0.6197276115,
-0.0463622548,
-0.9653301835,
0.225119561,
-0.5685144067,
-0.3477494419,
-0.8780828714,
0.1438858509,
-0.2426716834,
-0.4293621182,
-0.2743956447,
-0.6782114506,
0.115238741,
0.6287958026,
-0.221698001,
0.2247143984,
-0.6745328903,
0.0965392664,
0.6234819889,
-0.1371826082,
-0.2879104018,
-0.6648609638,
-0.1521683484,
0.0326425731,
0.003703319,
-0.8522095084,
0.6106008887,
0.4420934319,
0.5498470664,
0.0915300623,
0.1756109297,
0.7123287916,
-0.5582435131,
1.0030260086,
-0.1435891092,
-0.6971535683,
0.6595152617,
-0.0229035988,
0.4058109224,
0.6457598209,
0.5821646452,
-0.6095191836,
-0.363211751,
-0.5003271103,
-0.7815007567,
0.5192010403,
0.0550344586,
0.2546875477,
0.2277937979,
0.005975442,
0.1991338879,
0.0268209912,
-0.5394062996,
-0.2468069643,
-0.2602799833,
-0.1804130673,
-0.413008064,
-0.3574103117,
-0.3040158451,
-0.0368838049,
0.5947920084,
-0.0127410935,
0.0135157043,
0.4478695393,
-0.0279933084,
-0.2556231022,
0.4497918487,
0.7347201109,
0.7382787466,
-0.1755916625,
0.5840472579,
0.7617726326,
-0.5242923498,
0.0556594469,
0.1086403877,
-0.2015481293,
0.486613214,
0.5245153308,
0.7942661047,
-0.1035526991,
-0.9473199248,
0.3159391582,
-0.4774817228,
-0.1031431183,
-0.7417051196,
-0.1760988235,
-0.0842271671,
0.66025424,
0.6480124593,
0.1176527217,
0.1823787093,
-0.6937542558,
-0.0232936274,
0.3989909589,
-0.7559022307,
-0.1233073324,
0.3662242889,
-0.0730450675,
-0.4599553645,
0.7915943265,
0.1511713564,
-0.8439691067,
0.612093389,
0.1391217858,
0.8921058178,
-0.2027908415,
0.339415431,
0.5763298273,
0.2125390023,
0.4688037634,
0.4086074531,
-0.4748722911,
-0.7294410467,
-0.3012310266,
-0.7695705295,
-0.304261446,
0.2798152566,
-0.6893983483,
0.1848662496,
-0.3994007409,
-0.1537411362,
-0.146907419,
0.0563096441,
-0.5594460368,
0.3985114694,
0.3995920718,
1.0210319757,
-1.3962562084,
0.7476865649,
0.6823633909,
0.0522130132,
-0.796043992,
0.1225502938,
-0.0513822511,
-0.6370472312,
0.8613427877,
-0.0776223987,
-0.0834556893,
0.0331172049,
-0.4578948915,
-0.9832206964,
0.6546111703,
0.0762349591,
-0.6531636119,
0.2001721561,
0.2163759768,
0.3987857997,
-0.0619051233,
-0.0112179704,
0.9579023123,
-0.0770353228,
0.0586972088,
-1.1706867218,
-0.2010678947,
-0.0198322758,
-0.2123567164,
-0.080650717,
-0.5937942863,
0.6677707434,
-0.0222332738,
-0.2212819904,
0.2977420986,
0.7729162574,
0.4310913682,
0.2451363951,
0.360696435,
0.5849151015,
0.6429897547,
-0.0973077193,
0.6866875291,
0.2825289071,
0.1750467718,
1.2411839962,
0.087594606,
0.8555203676,
0.6238013506,
-0.3747562468,
0.5100233555,
1.18749547,
0.2183283865,
1.0303707123,
0.0521243364,
-0.6790751219,
-0.2958599031,
-0.6208894253,
-0.5148329735,
0.6967055202,
0.3710330129,
-0.1704052091,
-0.2317783386,
0.2149331868,
-0.3316079378,
-0.0703799352,
-0.3364312649,
0.8107609749,
0.0903710052,
-0.8774165511,
0.5479782224,
-0.2169938982,
0.2946813107,
-0.4614392519,
0.0189081635,
-0.3028089702,
0.0588844009,
-0.3921449184,
-0.5301867723,
0.2716291547,
-0.0788367167,
-0.1706229299,
-0.2310185432,
0.456389308,
-0.5692295432,
-0.6964332461,
-0.1234835088,
0.2655768394,
0.4994635284,
0.3006623387,
-0.3157641888,
0.1840149611,
0.1209523305,
0.1857945919,
0.3222921193,
0.5340012312,
-0.2226077765,
0.439670682,
0.6503504515,
0.3320924342,
0.3551357687,
0.211030975,
0.5863462687,
-0.225255087,
-0.4426609278,
-0.8691071272,
0.2027653605,
0.2590109706,
-0.6127080321,
0.878778398,
0.7026881576,
1.3741871119,
-0.1214915588,
1.0981662273,
-0.2379815131,
1.0129132271,
-0.6546671987,
0.5925580859,
-0.2550867796,
-0.1008543298,
-0.1216450855,
-0.5837674141,
0.0433569439,
1.0356334448,
-0.4485881329,
-0.2957290113,
0.3065467179,
0.7586311102,
-0.0374171399,
0.1158834025,
0.3693106472,
0.25001809,
0.0685799867,
0.29702878,
1.1982374191,
-0.2983703017,
0.3887861669,
-0.518101275,
-0.1638846695,
-0.1321154684,
-0.5316894054,
-0.9465634227,
-0.5873492956,
-0.3178179562,
-0.3048673272,
-0.0203170124,
1.1669837236,
0.9759440422,
-1.2687784433,
-0.330610007,
-0.044035662,
0.0705083162,
-0.0563278571,
-0.1742051393,
0.395691663,
0.3631262183,
-0.8540181518,
0.6687898636,
-0.0956272185,
0.0742586032,
-0.1259305179,
0.1340008378,
-0.3687639534,
-0.4284499586,
0.3554165363,
0.5792905688,
-0.979156971,
-0.4184958637,
0.1021125168,
0.0121003278,
-0.2822317481,
0.7849526405,
-0.945974648,
0.650164187,
0.5537752509,
0.4692846239,
0.5301355124,
0.3337623179,
0.7387978435,
-0.93543607,
0.3870761395,
0.6065248251,
0.5294049978,
0.4330752492,
-0.3555551469,
0.4148108065,
0.165255338,
-0.5549653172,
-0.9093493223,
0.3124575019,
-0.5619822741,
-0.2157183588,
1.055285573,
-0.3686664104,
0.110163942,
-0.5700818896,
-0.6451243162,
0.4106180966,
0.0269904323,
0.9180620313,
0.7155758142,
-0.3730979562,
-0.6659855247,
-0.5897155404,
0.6364843249,
0.5524073243,
-0.2924015224,
-0.420112431,
0.4117802382,
0.4578895867,
0.0845398009,
0.8956323862,
0.2958484292,
0.4534813464,
-0.1755957454,
-0.4128903151,
0.3864754438,
-0.2191147655,
-0.4623883963,
0.0923528522,
-0.1101009473,
-0.4738754034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20331v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20331v1
|
Unsolvable Problem Detection: Evaluating Trustworthiness of Vision Language Models
| 2024-03-29T17:59:53 | 2024-03-29T17:59:53 |
Atsuyuki Miyai, Jingkang Yang, Jingyang Zhang, Yifei Ming, Qing Yu, Go Irie, Yixuan Li, Hai Li, Ziwei Liu, Kiyoharu Aizawa
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces a novel and significant challenge for Vision Language
Models (VLMs), termed Unsolvable Problem Detection (UPD). UPD examines the
VLM's ability to withhold answers when faced with unsolvable problems in the
context of Visual Question Answering (VQA) tasks. UPD encompasses three
distinct settings: Absent Answer Detection (AAD), Incompatible Answer Set
Detection (IASD), and Incompatible Visual Question Detection (IVQD). To deeply
investigate the UPD problem, extensive experiments indicate that most VLMs,
including GPT-4V and LLaVA-Next-34B, struggle with our benchmarks to varying
extents, highlighting significant room for the improvements. To address UPD, we
explore both training-free and training-based solutions, offering new insights
into their effectiveness and limitations. We hope our insights, together with
future efforts within the proposed UPD settings, will enhance the broader
understanding and development of more practical and reliable VLMs.
|
[
-0.3100241423,
-0.5435239077,
0.9877874255,
0.0905226767,
-0.2645423114,
0.2719756961,
0.1742398888,
-0.4875623286,
-0.3571249247,
0.6534829736,
-0.4867254198,
-0.2884159982,
-0.6056637764,
-0.1822209209,
-0.7487235069,
0.6176875234,
-0.2308389693,
0.1279560477,
-0.6635761261,
-0.2728867233,
-0.6063865423,
-0.5959920287,
-0.6577578783,
-0.1824789047,
-0.1406936347,
0.3368148208,
0.7109264135,
0.576497376,
0.7691116929,
0.3289418519,
-0.2610193193,
0.044203978,
-0.1753418744,
0.0654329807,
0.0127728209,
-0.477746278,
-0.0664260089,
-0.1459724158,
0.5543215871,
0.6347648501,
-0.2982379794,
0.2151113302,
0.0391961262,
0.6883733273,
-0.6968112588,
0.1418046057,
-0.9744748473,
0.0631185919,
-0.2972405255,
0.0559699386,
-0.1781677902,
-0.0406318679,
0.1693118513,
-0.4577982426,
0.1474725306,
-0.0623336472,
0.9398002625,
0.5288722515,
-0.2165995836,
-0.1015863046,
-0.7697106004,
0.6570618153,
-0.583897233,
0.2205920368,
0.307782352,
0.3926230669,
-0.153586641,
-0.5810120106,
-0.8683300614,
-0.109917447,
0.1769964248,
0.0611165985,
-0.514606297,
-0.0689597875,
0.2732535005,
0.3345651031,
-0.5601014495,
-0.115184404,
-0.3626979589,
-0.2332042903,
0.3361155093,
0.3782782853,
0.3239353597,
-0.1092612073,
-0.3433922231,
0.0916729569,
-0.4465630352,
0.412709862,
-0.0640866458,
-0.2708104551,
0.0459823273,
0.7174502611,
-0.3907194436,
0.8868971467,
-0.271299094,
0.3112250865,
0.197290346,
-0.3367629945,
-0.3121066689,
-0.4127781391,
0.2914182246,
0.4693730474,
0.652823925,
0.0484322384,
-0.3907306492,
0.2127375156,
0.3329252899,
-0.1691741645,
-0.2763598859,
0.2446229011,
-0.3308092654,
-0.6542559862,
-0.2063988,
-0.5768762827,
-0.4813314676,
-0.1268028021,
0.6294676065,
-0.2363765538,
-0.3188356459,
0.1254650205,
-0.1400467902,
0.4661534429,
0.5557153821,
-0.5427373052,
-0.0932571068,
0.3582973182,
0.6871137619,
-0.2971180081,
-0.300714761,
-0.5299519897,
-0.1990506649,
-0.5181210041,
0.7654596567,
-0.4327168763,
-0.2472992688,
0.0336710028,
-0.1075736657,
-0.1700386405,
-0.6651420593,
0.3594096303,
-0.3338520527,
0.0878007635,
-0.4114223719,
-0.5633410811,
0.0092434334,
0.6676806808,
-0.3883521557,
1.0923207998,
0.4330962896,
-0.8653578162,
0.2360900193,
-0.6481541395,
0.2208520174,
0.3412266076,
-0.4148347676,
-0.3049649894,
0.3186608851,
0.1473870724,
0.4632548392,
-0.1355006397,
0.1405851394,
-0.5596747994,
-0.2976610959,
0.3881211579,
-0.6898175478,
1.0585423708,
0.2170081884,
-0.3590848446,
0.150725767,
-1.159632206,
0.3749116957,
0.3981465399,
-0.1907798946,
-0.5331549644,
-0.0942470655,
-0.0294821598,
0.17750597,
0.2411250621,
-0.8465362191,
-0.1997994184,
-0.1110176817,
0.3678666055,
0.8968012333,
-0.0511185043,
-0.1101802066,
0.0370095447,
0.4870804548,
0.3489887714,
0.5008497238,
0.0434038751,
-0.7184051871,
-1.0397582054,
0.0812742859,
-0.1105542257,
0.6878849864,
-1.3554165363,
-0.3822028041,
0.1383931935,
-0.2942935824,
-0.5846802592,
0.2001163214,
0.9595785737,
0.7835404873,
0.5014989376,
-0.3016284704,
-0.336804837,
-0.9819365144,
-0.2465443015,
-0.421746701,
0.1822345108,
0.0080762198,
0.744920671,
-0.0531471036,
0.8611119986,
-0.4920451939,
-0.331289202,
-0.1049623638,
-0.0553054214,
-0.2548595667,
0.2847352326,
0.5416568518,
-1.0190855265,
-0.4784488678,
-0.0962140337,
-1.091373682,
0.1657089889,
0.3000853658,
0.4685695171,
0.4559058845,
0.7461506128,
-0.4519023597,
1.0042783022,
0.5892542601,
-0.5594796538,
0.5690742135,
-0.5004953742,
0.1725620925,
-0.8492187858,
-0.0963050872,
0.0592893362,
-0.1432778388,
-0.7419425249,
0.1916780472,
0.040442355,
-0.16418387,
-0.7801605463,
0.3803732991,
-0.4333037734,
-0.3688475192,
0.012442206,
0.0741602331,
-0.0909362584,
0.3655629456,
0.0597966388,
0.7945976257,
0.6336525083,
-0.3918260336,
0.5772202611,
0.3709876239,
-0.4612017274,
0.84070611,
-0.9428984523,
-0.0079022022,
-0.1385820359,
-0.3904691041,
-1.1602267027,
-0.0332492404,
0.4453110993,
-0.6573202014,
0.1320561171,
-0.0824266151,
-0.1493095011,
-0.6641787291,
-0.0693538338,
0.4453257918,
0.4643833637,
-0.586225152,
0.3727788329,
0.3462888598,
0.1584683806,
-0.8025691509,
-0.6542578936,
0.0676030368,
-0.1178401858,
-0.7549970746,
-0.0775515735,
-0.2623520195,
-0.580883801,
0.3852181435,
-0.3104361296,
-0.539517045,
0.1920168847,
0.101219289,
0.2927223742,
-0.1141083911,
-0.1074124351,
-0.5207386017,
-0.2486790121,
0.2083596438,
-0.1864172071,
0.2627837956,
-0.674140811,
-0.6997270584,
-0.2353883982,
0.5087808967,
0.7841156721,
-0.5928482413,
0.6319095492,
0.5650999546,
-0.5043898225,
-0.1212742031,
-0.4338173866,
0.2859543264,
-0.4793634117,
0.3984340727,
-0.3752791584,
-0.919495821,
0.6192619801,
0.3925912976,
-0.1623945236,
0.0909794718,
0.4930675328,
-0.4130280912,
1.0830503702,
0.9536141157,
0.2625272572,
0.1357663572,
-0.1275013089,
0.0814763084,
-0.7788643837,
-0.4930781424,
-0.5502976179,
0.2663103044,
-0.3577736616,
-0.3016115427,
0.4102010727,
0.0724137574,
-0.0077042491,
0.2088402212,
-0.5389793515,
0.6391949058,
0.5180080533,
-0.0982502848,
0.4689180255,
-0.164902091,
-0.1832694709,
-0.075219065,
-0.6394543052,
-0.2233402729,
1.172909379,
0.2186825275,
0.482737422,
0.0304606613,
0.4265727997,
0.2035148293,
0.0327694826,
-0.4186799526,
0.6291046739,
-0.1588860005,
-0.6237959266,
-0.6201286316,
-0.2169936895,
-0.6264344454,
0.4577963352,
-0.2019042075,
-1.0950894356,
0.2776287496,
0.4280386567,
-0.0969002545,
0.4898839891,
-0.6378583908,
1.1020952463,
-0.3028255105,
-0.0460059829,
0.1420368552,
-0.6937103868,
0.4904112518,
-0.1304033846,
0.0945992768,
-0.0139906695,
0.2715709805,
0.6482619643,
-0.3731258214,
0.4773866832,
-0.2848779559,
-0.1437868625,
0.3386411369,
-0.0461570248,
0.2712768912,
-0.0531930365,
0.4716553092,
0.1658857465,
0.3483527005,
-0.5597715974,
-0.7422133088,
0.4916595817,
-0.5227054954,
-0.7261529565,
-0.7277191281,
-0.5016217232,
-0.5929657221,
0.272157371,
0.4526631534,
0.6198474765,
0.0551557876,
0.3425813615,
1.0670325756,
-0.140911743,
0.6658481359,
0.7323088646,
-0.4716997147,
-0.0128197325,
0.8446813822,
-0.0409891196,
0.4751625657,
0.0838161483,
-0.3102959692,
-0.3351264298,
-1.0647598505,
-0.5802576542,
-0.0658133775,
-0.9613156319,
0.0346416384,
-0.2476859093,
-0.4892382324,
0.0097817341,
0.2384763211,
-0.7168961763,
-0.2134969682,
-0.1437562406,
0.0190469697,
0.1298051924,
0.6563836932,
-0.015422984,
0.0349013768,
-0.7387587428,
0.537962079,
0.4301237166,
0.449903816,
-0.2700745165,
-0.5393503904,
-0.1485814154,
0.1577554345,
-0.0243727658,
-0.7916494012,
0.1504354924,
-0.1689588279,
0.6433470249,
0.1693607569,
0.2006636709,
0.5071893334,
-0.1840995699,
0.7619472146,
0.2281021923,
-1.0147320032,
0.5864431858,
-0.1826357991,
0.129309833,
0.5245453119,
0.3340789378,
-0.3734987676,
-0.441231221,
-0.5345546603,
-0.6218779683,
0.3328586817,
0.4353767633,
-0.0585161187,
0.2355564833,
0.3564218283,
-0.5063636303,
0.2949718535,
-0.656201601,
-0.4280803502,
-0.2041373551,
-0.0267914347,
-0.0816601813,
-0.3680153489,
-0.2409633547,
-0.3051937819,
0.3663980365,
-0.065354161,
0.1048328727,
0.3553517461,
-0.0672933832,
-0.0572740622,
0.3129231036,
0.6512789726,
0.8810785413,
-0.3898642659,
-0.0747627988,
-0.0202109385,
-0.5546835065,
0.2086165398,
-0.12852633,
-0.4088283479,
-0.1097978279,
0.3212319314,
0.7794263959,
-0.1430038363,
-0.7409303188,
0.8986472487,
-0.4225635827,
-0.4266799688,
-0.6255596876,
0.0557970516,
-0.0667480603,
0.3598649502,
0.4131764472,
0.502253592,
0.0259599146,
-0.4295170903,
0.3439517915,
0.8329772353,
-1.0083819628,
0.0252040233,
0.6677613258,
0.0966333449,
-0.2653353214,
0.714609623,
-0.1841368228,
-0.697238028,
0.6949805617,
0.2828256488,
0.6460716128,
-0.0188308004,
0.6335519552,
-0.4171520472,
0.5695693493,
0.1157305762,
0.5385530591,
0.2379528433,
-1.2595869303,
-0.4132051766,
-0.3749795556,
-0.5815097094,
0.5276128054,
-1.1501841545,
-0.1876312494,
-0.3067716658,
0.1273739934,
-0.0384888761,
-0.1216666773,
-0.6066464782,
0.5096248984,
0.0846022666,
0.8158531189,
-0.6982004642,
0.9274687171,
0.9121564627,
-0.4411402941,
-0.8899618387,
-0.0354122892,
0.3414098918,
-1.2124826908,
0.4634265602,
-0.1090200096,
-0.3087567687,
0.2266636044,
-0.6347373724,
-0.5919325352,
1.07802701,
0.5070510507,
-0.199099645,
0.136023283,
0.0448631085,
0.555675447,
-0.2734910548,
-0.0117484089,
0.7840558887,
0.4749396145,
0.171523869,
-1.0495041609,
-0.1685151607,
-0.4561551213,
0.2136123031,
-0.0056468826,
-0.4725503922,
0.8520359993,
-0.598326385,
-0.1591548026,
0.268753767,
0.4253129959,
0.2443614751,
0.557367444,
0.5457245708,
0.7890281081,
0.6083331108,
-0.2686829269,
1.0389492512,
0.0147797242,
0.4338495731,
0.9138146043,
-0.0642291456,
0.8871216774,
0.7754458189,
-0.029820364,
0.1184058711,
0.3876697719,
-0.1198871806,
0.5841674805,
0.0918677002,
-0.1387547404,
-0.6386486888,
-0.0051943986,
-0.6208513975,
0.8923937082,
-0.0031198787,
0.0542706661,
-0.3479008675,
0.1874016523,
-0.2234750837,
0.3346236646,
-0.5175683498,
0.3961156905,
0.0123634264,
-0.4943482876,
0.6864982843,
-0.2635257542,
0.3440914154,
-0.3977197707,
-0.1641694456,
-0.5035554767,
0.5510164499,
0.0089912219,
-1.1256401539,
0.3824460208,
0.1048985496,
-0.1959034503,
0.0152511727,
0.7967983484,
-0.4351544678,
-0.4681588411,
0.381594032,
0.8603816628,
-0.0028613277,
-0.2536978126,
-0.8396723866,
0.1924483627,
0.2397414297,
-0.1313487291,
0.5624240041,
0.536310792,
-0.0559124015,
1.3466904163,
0.5733944774,
0.0644224286,
0.1758596897,
-0.303769052,
0.8543643355,
-0.3641141951,
-0.2729340196,
-0.6066141725,
0.7448419929,
-0.130408287,
-0.4823669195,
0.9572296739,
0.0130592193,
1.1345472336,
-0.2269717753,
0.7884343266,
0.1457634717,
0.5481077433,
-0.6731085181,
0.6832444072,
-0.7806283832,
0.5401163697,
-0.4401093125,
-0.8262110949,
-0.4047221839,
0.5508312583,
0.0665981174,
-0.0850980356,
0.8939305544,
0.559484899,
0.2174294144,
-0.1735381633,
0.6815145612,
0.0815173462,
0.3043358624,
0.7640244961,
1.1436003447,
-0.2746912837,
0.9838556647,
-0.3321044743,
-0.1163885742,
0.0333616547,
-0.8775241971,
-0.8368574977,
-0.8230528235,
-0.3876589239,
-0.4383885562,
0.2018713802,
0.1006410345,
0.4897133708,
-0.859141767,
0.1399909705,
-0.2380127758,
0.250469774,
-0.1549669951,
-0.2052736878,
0.2391977459,
-0.1381443441,
-0.2753335536,
0.1203346848,
0.3881532252,
0.379948616,
-0.3131254613,
-0.1252504438,
0.1323525459,
0.0238714274,
0.4693955779,
0.5919813514,
-0.8142273426,
-0.760851264,
0.0404239669,
0.1428115368,
-0.1191934645,
0.6316518188,
-0.6491889358,
0.5132294893,
0.1699319929,
0.721323967,
0.3585080206,
-0.0153915789,
0.413311094,
-0.56416291,
-0.0627601668,
-0.0578130931,
0.4648887813,
0.3556111157,
-0.0916212276,
0.509378612,
0.5206647515,
-0.4438256323,
-1.0563830137,
0.4437827468,
-1.038813591,
-0.195577383,
0.9028633833,
-0.3815942705,
-0.1144214198,
-0.5656169057,
-0.1149511561,
-0.2489408255,
0.0406890251,
0.5177944899,
0.7947204709,
-0.2767670453,
-0.4675033987,
-0.6277646422,
0.693524003,
0.4216933548,
-0.6496011615,
0.2257353365,
0.558673203,
0.4116244316,
0.2015163302,
0.8918678761,
-0.1823417991,
0.4641153216,
0.0383782089,
-0.2498592883,
-0.5510702133,
-0.5597450137,
-0.5578408241,
0.2456273735,
0.1812188178,
-0.5040901303
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20329v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20329v1
|
ReALM: Reference Resolution As Language Modeling
| 2024-03-29T17:59:06 | 2024-03-29T17:59:06 |
Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Soundarya Krishnan, Melis Ozyildirim, Prathamesh Saraf, Halim Cagri Ates, Yuan Zhang, Hong Yu, Nidhi Rajshree
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Reference resolution is an important problem, one that is essential to
understand and successfully handle context of different kinds. This context
includes both previous turns and context that pertains to non-conversational
entities, such as entities on the user's screen or those running in the
background. While LLMs have been shown to be extremely powerful for a variety
of tasks, their use in reference resolution, particularly for
non-conversational entities, remains underutilized. This paper demonstrates how
LLMs can be used to create an extremely effective system to resolve references
of various types, by showing how reference resolution can be converted into a
language modeling problem, despite involving forms of entities like those on
screen that are not traditionally conducive to being reduced to a text-only
modality. We demonstrate large improvements over an existing system with
similar functionality across different types of references, with our smallest
model obtaining absolute gains of over 5% for on-screen references. We also
benchmark against GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, with our smallest model achieving
performance comparable to that of GPT-4, and our larger models substantially
outperforming it.
|
[
-0.3847395182,
-0.3926948309,
0.7133138776,
-0.1918861717,
-0.2391397208,
0.1520445943,
-0.202413857,
-0.729752481,
-0.0138335489,
0.68295151,
-0.2761564851,
-0.2406178266,
-0.3143543005,
0.1128163114,
-0.4497818351,
0.6786537766,
-0.0478947572,
-0.1590908319,
-0.5115973949,
-0.3324607611,
-0.3566821516,
-0.8321681023,
-0.3518332839,
-0.5401750207,
0.3938879073,
0.6087822318,
0.6436892152,
0.6685094833,
0.8012893796,
0.3544631898,
0.0087447353,
0.4426957965,
-0.623398304,
0.2824318707,
-0.4523037076,
-0.3984249532,
-0.4619784355,
0.1717635244,
0.6404833198,
0.7335716486,
-0.1268728077,
-0.0363021381,
-0.0588245615,
0.6456663609,
-0.3677904606,
0.0853851959,
-0.8931769729,
-0.0848860443,
-0.2961345911,
-0.480828315,
-0.6429978609,
0.0771249533,
0.0989617482,
-0.7667377591,
0.476038605,
0.5245034695,
0.9131427407,
0.2383304983,
-0.7017080784,
-0.1652787924,
-1.0700368881,
0.7605447769,
-0.5407877564,
0.6614772081,
0.2320581824,
0.2478128225,
-0.0430570319,
-0.7169487476,
-0.5479402542,
-0.3311516643,
-0.0017400881,
-0.0499446504,
-0.336345315,
0.2025125623,
0.4917390645,
0.3863197267,
-0.189295277,
-0.0601176023,
-0.3033985496,
-0.2901640832,
0.032124728,
0.3120490015,
0.0729822814,
-0.1973660886,
-0.2433540523,
0.3890725076,
-1.0918443203,
-0.5432714224,
-0.3528811634,
0.4625926316,
0.1574421674,
0.3959344327,
0.0313067324,
0.9190669656,
0.3130223751,
-0.3731113672,
-0.1970672309,
-0.0138322422,
-0.281239599,
-0.3998591006,
0.2590893209,
0.461285919,
-0.2623769343,
-0.3825412989,
-0.2645511925,
-0.124966599,
0.3258211613,
-0.8534350991,
-0.0713623613,
-0.2098010629,
-0.3288187981,
0.0980830416,
-0.4189956188,
-0.2143670768,
-0.5428335667,
-0.6178708673,
0.1685070693,
-0.3971165121,
-0.1050681844,
-0.483445406,
0.3424848616,
-0.1026164666,
0.6389381886,
-0.9230492711,
0.4516240954,
0.4380169213,
0.9241634011,
-0.1469639689,
0.2544881701,
-0.6840745807,
0.4142069817,
-0.3925002217,
0.9363681674,
-0.4224251509,
-0.8733517528,
-0.118490912,
-0.2900920212,
0.0329033025,
-0.8737255335,
0.4801658988,
-0.9633935094,
-0.0583972782,
-0.2423266768,
-0.6489287019,
-0.1470545977,
0.2537640035,
-0.7765886188,
0.7239558697,
0.240350917,
-0.3207122982,
-0.0390139669,
-0.532241106,
0.1642674208,
0.3965754211,
-0.1178961173,
-0.0158231296,
0.3173875213,
-0.1779167801,
0.2449022084,
-0.7046951652,
0.2067591995,
-0.1023444384,
-0.2250956297,
0.1572961658,
-0.1248657554,
0.161582619,
0.4922816455,
0.2174518406,
0.0259243269,
-0.6284746528,
-0.027302891,
-0.0744436309,
-0.3690418303,
-0.6836488247,
0.0320562199,
-0.065293014,
0.2192422897,
0.246421203,
-0.3338940144,
0.1242368743,
-0.1492711157,
0.4423028529,
0.2806156874,
-0.197671175,
0.5418024063,
-0.2978523374,
0.1996217668,
0.151329577,
-0.2815326154,
-0.053916987,
-0.3626562059,
-1.1012713909,
0.0104442826,
0.2803992331,
0.2636384368,
-1.175470829,
-0.1570711583,
-0.4704918861,
-0.4290505946,
-0.0318440162,
0.2173579037,
0.3496759832,
0.7894384861,
0.3395440578,
-0.1281848252,
-0.5692269206,
-0.727805078,
-0.1695116758,
-0.6440153718,
-0.1281561553,
0.5945756435,
0.3058597744,
-0.3125273585,
1.198123455,
-0.2390356511,
-0.2936830819,
-0.0404286422,
-0.0518057235,
0.2291624546,
0.3772724867,
0.2677636147,
-1.0258703232,
-0.3598051369,
0.1811058223,
-0.7729330063,
-0.3895843327,
0.0726910532,
0.0568165779,
0.22351408,
0.6166867614,
-0.2846077979,
-0.0016839303,
0.8099035621,
-0.3106788993,
0.5711633563,
-0.2688202262,
0.1392878443,
-0.88031286,
0.312766403,
0.2753056884,
-0.6096425056,
-0.7400447726,
0.3881539702,
0.2569653988,
-0.4285498857,
-0.6003826261,
0.6122711897,
-0.6229982972,
-0.0524132699,
-0.3869649768,
0.5166014433,
-0.0319650806,
0.4056972861,
0.2387496978,
0.8846337795,
-0.0118547231,
-0.7985351682,
0.7738772035,
0.1071591154,
-0.2239739895,
0.7517314553,
-0.2260587662,
0.4674228132,
0.0217608921,
0.146770522,
-0.6546728015,
-0.0023823651,
0.0043847072,
-0.1394230872,
0.3199202418,
-0.108053796,
-0.4057551026,
-0.227250874,
0.1205482259,
0.5523289442,
0.1843121797,
-0.6313898563,
0.7966406941,
0.5251595974,
-0.1212443262,
0.0134692797,
-0.5155902505,
0.1763346642,
-0.188975051,
-0.3957771659,
0.9073095918,
-0.2367880344,
-0.4174671471,
0.116061233,
-0.2172139734,
-0.2258230746,
-0.2775610089,
0.2788196504,
0.5537952185,
-0.338111192,
0.2438386232,
-0.2928200364,
-0.3641456366,
-0.2344667166,
-0.1565514803,
0.1698443741,
-0.3789360225,
-0.552596271,
-0.0287122373,
0.269272387,
0.64761132,
0.1236865744,
0.5845493078,
-0.161485821,
-0.6335551739,
0.1053412557,
-0.8736479282,
-0.0912245885,
-0.4758186042,
0.3059596419,
-0.6755567789,
-1.244779706,
0.5965412259,
-0.4663017988,
0.0836648792,
0.2195306122,
0.5374212265,
0.1041265205,
0.665371418,
0.7947875857,
0.0673059449,
0.5692818165,
-0.0306743756,
0.4714342356,
-1.1390800476,
-0.2106016129,
-0.6934648156,
0.1186026335,
-0.5271936655,
-0.8439795375,
0.3059108257,
0.3656960428,
-0.1095521152,
0.5324964523,
-0.1992809623,
0.5678051114,
0.4270791709,
0.0243629236,
0.8492305279,
0.0198679697,
-0.3552704453,
-0.5206834674,
-0.6900301576,
-0.8059678674,
0.5750230551,
0.4787117839,
0.699067831,
0.3765535951,
0.3937168419,
0.3396559358,
1.0798506737,
-0.9908820391,
0.7388048172,
-0.3576889634,
-0.7162543535,
-0.2042857558,
-0.5216709375,
-0.5367000699,
0.6624207497,
0.1048436314,
-0.8091204166,
0.2440268546,
0.1559771597,
-0.4005922675,
0.5090298653,
-0.5721629858,
0.5306642652,
0.2404880673,
-0.6520223618,
-0.2065538913,
-0.1589201987,
0.2885012031,
-0.1973067075,
0.1693390459,
-0.2757448852,
-0.2216944695,
0.714468658,
-0.6419554353,
0.771586597,
0.0796658993,
-0.2013380378,
0.5612192154,
0.3575907946,
0.3566177189,
0.0200843886,
-0.2879691124,
0.0730129778,
0.0150823919,
-0.1465148926,
-0.6873095632,
1.0484105349,
-0.7371265888,
-0.8045854568,
-0.3353891671,
-0.5615165234,
-0.4762413502,
0.2260261178,
0.0139921363,
0.6400758028,
-0.3271173537,
0.0726869851,
0.6699995399,
0.1224617288,
0.2419974953,
1.2576630116,
-0.5007104874,
-0.2009489983,
1.0250669718,
0.1395978183,
0.2779406607,
0.5373786688,
-0.2570853531,
-0.4895591438,
-0.3465036154,
-0.4858514965,
0.4250919521,
-1.0329605341,
-0.4614871144,
-0.2722037435,
-0.3008402586,
-0.1949836612,
0.023112841,
-0.1455236524,
-0.2753694952,
-0.3162185848,
0.0258835144,
0.0342600234,
0.6149912477,
-0.0976352096,
0.3437712491,
-0.9877853394,
0.3412744701,
0.5921706557,
0.3286605179,
-0.1698764563,
-0.7524556518,
-0.2755777538,
-0.1147880852,
-0.541064024,
-0.8263092041,
0.6092185378,
0.135382846,
0.4365369976,
0.2181291133,
0.0282827299,
0.8699753284,
-0.6679283381,
0.759827137,
0.2074078321,
-1.0846060514,
0.241297558,
-0.4248984158,
0.2058588862,
0.3635256886,
0.1536776274,
-1.0565060377,
-0.3513413668,
-0.6319608092,
-0.6755450964,
0.6808367372,
0.2120051682,
0.0778408796,
-0.0484584793,
0.6053211093,
-0.3099444807,
0.2189144045,
-0.7265850306,
-0.277669996,
0.1769220382,
0.2804072499,
-0.0226905365,
-0.4746807218,
0.0473833159,
-0.1267452687,
0.8091897964,
-0.085983865,
0.5293799639,
0.0478331894,
-0.2654986084,
-0.4011068046,
0.2526224256,
0.5072566867,
0.5570854545,
-0.074734427,
0.3638740182,
0.4081996679,
-0.2649327517,
0.1694741249,
-0.1277546585,
-0.0287609454,
0.1117794067,
0.2923302054,
0.706279397,
0.4215611815,
-0.474702239,
0.1022682786,
0.0597740449,
0.0231087971,
-0.0658542961,
-0.0836715847,
0.2205353975,
0.0218436029,
0.5608420968,
0.2277989089,
0.0475203618,
-0.4444101751,
0.0703970492,
0.1892323941,
-0.6340896487,
-0.1519278884,
0.5941275954,
0.8902692795,
-0.3365496695,
0.8504531384,
-0.0158653371,
-0.5240676403,
0.4093786776,
0.9737570882,
0.5391712189,
-0.3637067378,
0.0966016725,
0.2052893341,
-0.0242440235,
0.1659889817,
-0.2019208223,
-0.182456091,
-1.2603610754,
-0.5149427056,
-0.4165218771,
-0.937112093,
0.4030544162,
-0.4602288902,
-0.067803517,
-0.3991954029,
-0.4429504275,
-0.0892746225,
0.1595747173,
-0.5623770952,
0.1934012324,
0.2071775049,
0.9614050984,
-0.5748906136,
0.8869068027,
0.9421119094,
-0.2096059918,
-0.5890284181,
-0.1159038991,
0.097156629,
-0.5511844158,
0.8643708229,
0.0458706841,
-0.4169032872,
0.2447410822,
-0.3098835051,
-0.9096801877,
0.855335772,
0.4852552712,
-0.7977499366,
-0.1586086899,
0.0216377471,
0.6444057822,
-0.4235930741,
0.3069895506,
0.5178892612,
0.2575984299,
0.2207609415,
-1.1836489439,
0.145844698,
-0.2837630212,
0.6007137895,
0.2809180021,
-0.6890167594,
0.6024891734,
-0.1268987656,
-0.4409891665,
0.1424505115,
1.0181155205,
0.439401865,
0.0182638522,
0.4543145001,
0.2682671845,
0.6572029591,
-0.2098511904,
0.7896056771,
-0.5043621659,
0.5233790278,
0.8458644152,
-0.6017380357,
0.7862622142,
0.7029352784,
-0.3068599999,
0.5002722144,
0.4652347267,
0.5493872762,
0.4492051899,
0.1619861126,
-0.740933001,
-0.5205165148,
-0.3747175932,
-0.2255747914,
-0.1434243619,
0.7359315157,
-0.1133906618,
-0.4140223861,
0.0173112042,
-0.2929320633,
0.3334897757,
-0.5165278912,
0.5535694361,
0.2446684986,
-0.5806806087,
0.4296581149,
0.3508429527,
0.5439051986,
-0.3848240376,
-0.095264107,
-0.1861008555,
0.2875079811,
-0.2379269451,
-0.2088653296,
0.4256178141,
0.1022338569,
-0.4304756522,
-0.3757206798,
0.9209359884,
-0.3732666075,
-0.2048517168,
0.2135268599,
0.6001489162,
0.2480654866,
-0.0266799368,
-0.4434136748,
0.042833738,
0.0711205676,
-0.0654032826,
0.2484831661,
0.4071979225,
-0.2659410834,
0.8875892758,
0.4684615135,
0.116668202,
-0.1446817517,
0.1021090746,
0.9500004649,
-0.6917049885,
-0.2584278584,
-0.5616005659,
0.164337039,
-0.0519435629,
-0.0771078318,
0.5414220095,
0.5954265594,
0.5815337896,
-0.0400435776,
0.6664553285,
-0.1103996187,
0.7355442047,
-0.4886867702,
0.2257669568,
-0.3893416524,
0.5961172581,
-0.0982218981,
-0.9609542489,
-0.5676116943,
0.6919771433,
-0.4675143659,
0.1287784427,
0.8985128999,
0.7817456126,
0.0210770965,
0.0249473639,
0.8163706064,
0.0952657983,
0.5836552382,
0.5512111187,
0.8861150742,
-0.343739152,
0.632399857,
-0.0633765012,
-0.2556992173,
-0.4920960665,
-1.0587671995,
-0.6022990346,
-0.8089849353,
-0.3999240398,
-0.4433178902,
0.0401430912,
0.7786177397,
0.9291265011,
-0.7941173315,
-0.3372194767,
0.2254861593,
0.0286325347,
0.1092844233,
-0.1719748825,
-0.1213912368,
-0.2930028737,
-0.8653225899,
0.5575367212,
0.2668198347,
0.1263940483,
-0.3588627875,
-0.2135602683,
0.335182637,
0.0033357418,
0.7591192722,
0.3756655753,
-0.788659215,
-0.4096805453,
-0.1100797132,
-0.6438122988,
0.0434504859,
1.2344766855,
-1.0730828047,
0.3484793305,
0.2703408599,
0.3380227983,
0.7371686101,
0.1605450362,
0.4878736734,
-0.7784137726,
0.1272810102,
0.2864431441,
0.4647558033,
0.471844703,
-0.2857600152,
0.4664303362,
0.473264128,
-0.527164638,
-0.4811185598,
0.3574444056,
-0.8476346135,
-0.0771443248,
0.9826595187,
-0.0729768202,
-0.1311614364,
-0.2804172933,
-0.3622543812,
0.1256822497,
-0.4886040092,
0.5282307267,
0.8636247516,
-0.4127315879,
-0.2128196657,
-0.4650485516,
0.3136101365,
0.3103219569,
-0.6154839993,
0.159604311,
0.8255763054,
0.275873214,
0.7204281092,
0.9452121258,
-0.1260036379,
-0.0045489292,
-0.1985335201,
-0.0573457628,
-0.03088855,
-0.2373171449,
-0.106333144,
0.1889263839,
0.5108926296,
0.1409308016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20327v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20327v1
|
Gecko: Versatile Text Embeddings Distilled from Large Language Models
| 2024-03-29T17:56:40 | 2024-03-29T17:56:40 |
Jinhyuk Lee, Zhuyun Dai, Xiaoqi Ren, Blair Chen, Daniel Cer, Jeremy R. Cole, Kai Hui, Michael Boratko, Rajvi Kapadia, Wen Ding, Yi Luan, Sai Meher Karthik Duddu, Gustavo Hernandez Abrego, Weiqiang Shi, Nithi Gupta, Aditya Kusupati, Prateek Jain, Siddhartha Reddy Jonnalagadda, Ming-Wei Chang, Iftekhar Naim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present Gecko, a compact and versatile text embedding model. Gecko
achieves strong retrieval performance by leveraging a key idea: distilling
knowledge from large language models (LLMs) into a retriever. Our two-step
distillation process begins with generating diverse, synthetic paired data
using an LLM. Next, we further refine the data quality by retrieving a set of
candidate passages for each query, and relabeling the positive and hard
negative passages using the same LLM. The effectiveness of our approach is
demonstrated by the compactness of the Gecko. On the Massive Text Embedding
Benchmark (MTEB), Gecko with 256 embedding dimensions outperforms all existing
entries with 768 embedding size. Gecko with 768 embedding dimensions achieves
an average score of 66.31, competing with 7x larger models and 5x higher
dimensional embeddings.
|
[
-0.3258737624,
-0.9221096635,
0.5580884814,
0.1577628851,
-0.6367740035,
0.1901926398,
-0.4777136147,
-0.4150525331,
0.3347817063,
0.4432242811,
0.1556040496,
-0.6971740127,
-0.7627657652,
-0.0071302047,
-0.6100029945,
1.0250481367,
0.0960315093,
-0.0829373151,
-0.2454083264,
-0.098833859,
-0.3256573677,
-0.5903250575,
-0.2059172094,
-0.4877461493,
0.425019294,
0.4156107605,
0.9297300577,
0.8383828402,
0.2008625716,
0.2751195729,
-0.3900327384,
0.1465809643,
-0.7185066342,
0.2922115624,
-0.2572019994,
-0.3786840737,
-0.0629601553,
0.0751828775,
0.6707711816,
0.6084349751,
-0.7125638723,
-0.1040314883,
0.3537625968,
0.5173102617,
-0.7396903634,
0.1325794458,
-0.6686145067,
0.1352624297,
-0.4416529238,
0.1099798456,
-0.7313425541,
-0.6584222317,
0.1756605059,
-0.638990283,
0.2505574822,
0.1607588679,
0.758063972,
-0.0169991124,
-0.6179564595,
-0.6851276159,
-0.7417038679,
0.9116514921,
-0.5412558913,
0.2881072164,
0.3299673498,
0.4543817341,
-0.0961349607,
-1.0859589577,
-0.4832881093,
-0.2643910646,
-0.1150956452,
-0.2905273139,
-0.2502518892,
-0.124759905,
0.038979765,
0.7253828049,
-0.5463715196,
-0.0200825781,
-0.0567221195,
-0.2172180712,
0.5231257677,
0.0770456493,
0.3865507543,
-0.0582104325,
-0.2955899835,
-0.2733542323,
-0.6166984439,
-0.1911439002,
0.568631649,
0.2577908933,
0.4783632159,
0.5292586684,
-0.0986294448,
0.62725389,
-0.0271714367,
-0.0056563108,
0.1358530223,
-0.2797735631,
-0.1266556382,
0.2143070102,
0.9155293703,
0.1615998745,
0.1824212372,
-0.1925060302,
-0.3014968932,
-0.0762552693,
0.381623894,
-1.0280421972,
-0.4406533837,
-0.1654294282,
-0.3351005614,
-0.4446187317,
0.066086784,
-0.8556898832,
-0.5519896746,
0.0956999063,
0.3348823488,
-0.6853564382,
-0.088989459,
0.3456147313,
-0.5870036483,
0.2367946506,
0.3809026778,
-1.2519952059,
0.5330241919,
0.7178771496,
0.6762831807,
0.2605603337,
-0.0038322008,
-0.6009040475,
0.116619505,
-0.4608074725,
0.6340840459,
-1.1732656956,
-0.8086493611,
-0.0494678691,
-0.0760959014,
0.3384347856,
-0.5017434359,
0.6166655421,
-0.6386330128,
0.1378641874,
-0.4014950991,
-0.6884353161,
-0.4144588113,
0.2988059521,
-0.7974755764,
1.0987944603,
0.0436555073,
-0.7302184105,
0.1712822467,
-0.0323982388,
-0.4651722312,
0.0253075473,
0.0421376191,
-0.2648697197,
0.1439669132,
0.2096222788,
0.4496403039,
-0.511654675,
0.1002868041,
-0.4676268101,
-0.3895352483,
0.0868949294,
-0.3084492087,
0.3553026021,
0.11110612,
0.1764384508,
-0.3728365004,
-0.6388363838,
0.0608315282,
0.2705056071,
-0.512293458,
-0.9561907053,
0.1318188906,
-0.0214716848,
-0.0434140638,
0.4594003856,
-0.6488251686,
0.4553129673,
-0.2095804811,
0.7532346249,
0.5383719206,
-0.1125927716,
0.5291138887,
0.1265588403,
0.3861786425,
-0.2632026672,
0.0082577346,
0.0668493286,
-0.4892971814,
-0.4608983397,
-0.1248846799,
0.4889688194,
0.3653882444,
-0.7599595189,
0.210270077,
-0.2171998322,
-0.878570497,
-0.3317165673,
0.541157186,
0.52206707,
0.3351958394,
0.2756857574,
-0.3318654299,
-0.1003816202,
-0.9053268433,
-0.0605713017,
0.1462975889,
0.0034152796,
0.422829777,
0.5010624528,
-0.3791187108,
0.6396545768,
-0.8485053182,
-0.135767445,
-0.3616368175,
0.2164153755,
0.2314205319,
0.2302361578,
0.58331424,
-0.8539714217,
-0.7480284572,
0.2567037046,
-0.8596617579,
0.2840542495,
0.3715090752,
-0.0456159525,
-0.2060753405,
0.3835303485,
-0.3804816604,
0.03978144,
0.7005413771,
-0.2710619569,
0.4454582632,
-0.6369401217,
0.0339824371,
-1.1608493328,
0.1493397951,
0.1618017703,
-0.4425600767,
-0.3779076338,
0.0955500901,
0.4099701345,
-0.1627420336,
-0.3522490263,
0.3045407534,
-0.6758633256,
0.0187536012,
-0.0940338597,
0.7347294092,
0.3063326776,
0.1544297785,
-0.4572561681,
0.8523784876,
0.2923613787,
-0.5750395656,
0.7778134346,
0.4118364453,
-0.4481719434,
0.1788440943,
-1.0198144913,
0.3428673744,
0.0454579853,
0.3768377602,
-1.0652586222,
-0.2439806908,
-0.1262378395,
-0.1870392114,
0.6647417545,
-0.1352578849,
-0.662058413,
-0.4760849774,
-0.685957551,
0.328853935,
0.5511856079,
-0.4995637536,
0.4201706648,
0.7548341751,
-0.4565691054,
-0.83748281,
-0.5846623182,
0.3284681141,
-0.1218823195,
-0.5536551476,
0.482011497,
0.1224023327,
-0.0266056489,
0.3873470128,
0.1568358392,
-0.0455089025,
0.0005616658,
-0.0567835234,
0.2335618287,
-0.1339157969,
0.2505116761,
0.1942340881,
-0.2742825747,
-0.371211499,
-0.2519552708,
0.6420168877,
-0.2428218126,
-0.2030941695,
-0.0454904363,
0.3331656456,
0.3791849315,
-0.3662518859,
0.6679894924,
0.3339817822,
-0.2611460686,
-0.4456895888,
-0.3153811097,
0.1460262984,
-0.5193505287,
0.3441013098,
-0.2570206821,
-1.0285838842,
0.5854997039,
-0.0745492503,
-0.1116653234,
0.378054738,
0.4046083093,
0.1623526216,
1.0723421574,
0.8341500759,
-0.2871924639,
0.4908959866,
-0.1243847758,
0.0579178184,
-0.8368636966,
-0.2151223719,
-0.7038046122,
-0.3886969984,
-0.5651980639,
-0.4612539709,
0.0090913698,
0.3140769899,
0.0287697464,
0.646633625,
-0.7773250341,
0.7017055154,
0.5515179038,
-0.0138031607,
0.2354517132,
-0.1991011351,
-0.4770786464,
-0.0110392775,
-0.2120613605,
-0.7889572978,
1.3103353977,
0.1404105574,
1.2532274723,
0.2747424245,
0.63270998,
0.3802532554,
0.1602600813,
-0.7791920304,
0.5797360539,
-0.488093853,
-0.5824199915,
-0.3941326439,
-0.22586371,
-0.9020690322,
0.5145779252,
-0.0353692994,
-0.9586600661,
-0.1228100434,
-0.0128070004,
-0.186710611,
0.2223556489,
-0.6470350027,
0.8029875755,
0.0690066144,
-0.277808845,
-0.541731298,
-0.3958707154,
0.3432808518,
-0.1614566147,
-0.1399240196,
-0.1156043634,
-0.0864182413,
0.5905877352,
-0.4276816845,
0.6801182628,
-0.1380033493,
-0.253030479,
0.3943734169,
0.1634767056,
0.8874139786,
0.1612224877,
-0.412866056,
-0.0285808351,
-0.0838100836,
-0.1529955566,
-0.7720341086,
1.0091007948,
-0.7521964312,
-0.6841455102,
-0.348318994,
-0.1087597609,
-0.0910739377,
0.3304472268,
0.2117440552,
0.7192265987,
-0.5682941079,
0.9133214355,
0.9501243234,
-0.4912950099,
0.3268763721,
0.4168987274,
-0.3960762024,
-0.4829782844,
0.958748579,
0.1928669065,
0.1143385842,
0.6340215206,
0.2045685351,
-0.6712043881,
-0.4406176209,
-0.4264755249,
0.2522103786,
-0.9478594661,
-0.0446602702,
-0.5899241567,
-0.1658712626,
-0.1431367844,
-0.1747230738,
-0.5950881839,
-0.2688102424,
-0.3875869811,
-0.1363905221,
0.1677721292,
1.0177628994,
0.0953967348,
0.1465310454,
-1.0251744986,
0.1501602083,
0.5774150491,
0.3551914394,
-0.0983600244,
-0.4665156007,
-0.1979641467,
-0.0178667922,
-0.4861650169,
-0.8637417555,
0.4683854878,
0.3040118814,
0.7773816586,
0.5338972807,
0.1326461583,
0.4240289032,
-0.7267388105,
0.977938652,
0.156204015,
-1.0158373117,
0.7564370036,
-0.2958759367,
-0.217898652,
0.4725044072,
0.3790482283,
-0.5896192789,
-0.2723609209,
-0.4465917945,
-0.7794435024,
0.3997375071,
0.0342249982,
0.4322789609,
-0.0795722976,
0.300914973,
0.2722884119,
0.2095466852,
-0.2790260017,
-0.0424425974,
-0.1128469482,
-0.0770710185,
-0.5504019856,
-0.5761044621,
-0.0823808685,
-0.1032374948,
0.5967593789,
-0.0767801926,
0.1785271168,
-0.1337070763,
-0.3124110103,
0.2910984457,
0.3259025216,
0.4815110564,
0.3264841139,
-0.1802097857,
0.2600116134,
0.2371171266,
-0.6988316774,
0.235592857,
0.1985988021,
0.269868046,
0.1913360357,
0.1382751763,
0.509508729,
0.4597540498,
-0.4495197833,
0.5639849901,
-0.2848917842,
0.0871326327,
-0.0216598548,
0.4064289927,
0.3245568275,
0.1329888999,
0.2581626177,
-0.4240248799,
0.3494371772,
-0.5038987398,
0.236544013,
0.3239557445,
-0.4026916921,
-0.3418752551,
0.6886292696,
0.3299928308,
-0.0608730055,
0.7973648906,
-0.1859106272,
-0.2488884777,
0.5180820227,
0.6369950771,
0.8001589775,
-0.1960954368,
0.3214412332,
0.1924641132,
0.0523899645,
-0.3408260942,
-0.0172097664,
-0.0798458606,
-0.6942999363,
-0.1729578227,
-0.7884768844,
-0.6880949736,
-0.3051376343,
-0.8398967385,
0.2771209776,
-0.457339406,
-0.2204631567,
0.2066634744,
0.2881462574,
-0.5042312145,
-0.0993214846,
0.1555620283,
1.0860645771,
-0.6189735532,
1.2425431013,
0.6550545096,
-0.4289902747,
-0.8804789186,
-0.1568659246,
0.1458254457,
-0.8694477677,
0.3756796718,
0.2274805307,
-0.1263795346,
0.0196155962,
-0.4620543122,
-0.735678494,
1.3767104149,
0.5899100304,
-0.847235024,
0.0676606148,
-0.1180790886,
0.5882655382,
-0.0972954556,
0.1653110236,
0.4241786599,
0.2298776507,
0.1802978218,
-0.7814813256,
0.1331818849,
-0.4417932034,
0.4256273806,
0.3919535279,
-0.7365339994,
1.013461709,
-0.0767083094,
-0.2990925908,
-0.0672609657,
0.4333069921,
0.0470627286,
-0.0937234834,
0.1921372265,
0.7993187308,
1.2218000889,
-0.207513839,
1.3800895214,
-0.3512639403,
0.6877521276,
1.0030118227,
-0.4713209569,
1.1077064276,
0.2523602247,
-0.111004144,
0.8102870584,
0.4595208168,
0.0765360966,
0.7562251091,
0.0863794833,
-0.3877041042,
-0.4279495776,
0.1134192646,
-0.6485096216,
0.4175269306,
0.4963632226,
-0.4783042967,
-0.5285910964,
0.0581960455,
-0.0597043261,
0.1527103931,
0.1138320863,
0.6398960352,
0.293965131,
-0.42497769,
0.368809104,
0.114027366,
0.5655912757,
-0.7645788193,
-0.0934163034,
-0.2247408777,
0.551148057,
0.1673762798,
-1.3087660074,
0.0204092469,
-0.0794674158,
-0.2120254487,
-0.2258292884,
1.0413740873,
-0.3148539662,
-0.1567628086,
0.4838016033,
0.0724862665,
0.05178646,
-0.0725082234,
-0.4119148552,
0.1933326125,
-0.0270674005,
-0.5911928415,
0.3973227739,
0.8936048746,
0.1493127197,
0.932728529,
0.6582516432,
-0.1119316965,
-0.2028586864,
-0.1136287078,
1.2184827328,
-0.7711144686,
-0.6415877342,
-1.0650128126,
0.2942660749,
-0.2991773784,
-0.246456787,
1.0476515293,
0.6349996924,
0.462126106,
0.0413863622,
0.8091781735,
0.0687453151,
0.2288713306,
-0.3779061437,
0.7942029834,
-0.5775351524,
0.1899235994,
-0.308617264,
-0.9673594236,
-0.1528433561,
0.5467410088,
-0.3725799918,
-0.2615579665,
0.3878978491,
0.7793233395,
-0.1521216184,
0.2307097912,
0.3864936829,
-0.0326658227,
0.6870265603,
0.7103239894,
0.8541954756,
-0.3888216615,
0.7773533463,
0.0964472815,
-0.1128231883,
-0.6563613415,
-0.8719198108,
-0.7305198312,
-0.3525320888,
-0.1065712422,
-0.2242474109,
-0.0907673761,
0.5033488274,
0.5446149111,
-0.6401652098,
0.2082886249,
0.1207523197,
0.1957077235,
0.0281044226,
-0.1775086224,
0.1146273017,
-0.3224527538,
-0.8684782386,
0.2697783113,
0.4830425084,
0.0046419185,
-0.296531707,
-0.2002708018,
-0.013846783,
0.1550216377,
0.6872378588,
0.236280337,
-0.3785417974,
-0.5865488052,
-0.1576928198,
-0.7622466087,
-0.1652046442,
0.5306050181,
-0.5570731163,
0.7571840882,
0.6716120243,
0.7187843323,
0.7180002332,
-0.1379792392,
0.6648111939,
-0.9002794027,
0.2400939465,
0.1815950274,
0.5322318077,
0.3174758852,
-0.2535915375,
0.4062266946,
0.1335892081,
-0.6092802882,
-0.6361815333,
-0.2323344946,
-0.9111664891,
-0.4309974909,
1.3274028301,
-0.2683523595,
-0.1924215108,
0.1537975818,
-0.3045782149,
0.0928348452,
-0.453853786,
0.5188571215,
1.0516824722,
0.3081146777,
0.1879761517,
-0.5532180071,
0.17228055,
-0.1721707582,
-0.4837845564,
-0.0268566217,
0.5089616776,
0.5303607583,
0.3589409292,
0.5088659525,
-0.2773783207,
-0.0292311031,
0.4703751802,
-0.0099706696,
-0.144750759,
-0.3822300434,
-0.085817121,
0.4202300608,
0.0621956401,
-0.3310240209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20322v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20322v2
|
Towards a Framework for Evaluating Explanations in Automated Fact Verification
| 2024-03-29T17:50:28 | 2024-05-19T15:07:07 |
Neema Kotonya, Francesca Toni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As deep neural models in NLP become more complex, and as a consequence
opaque, the necessity to interpret them becomes greater. A burgeoning interest
has emerged in rationalizing explanations to provide short and coherent
justifications for predictions. In this position paper, we advocate for a
formal framework for key concepts and properties about rationalizing
explanations to support their evaluation systematically. We also outline one
such formal framework, tailored to rationalizing explanations of increasingly
complex structures, from free-form explanations to deductive explanations, to
argumentative explanations (with the richest structure). Focusing on the
automated fact verification task, we provide illustrations of the use and
usefulness of our formalization for evaluating explanations, tailored to their
varying structures.
|
[
-0.237567082,
-1.0039442778,
0.9467996955,
0.3882350922,
-0.0849655047,
-0.3858243823,
-0.3268148899,
-0.2184336782,
-0.1686934382,
-0.0498304442,
-0.4939743578,
-0.2613868117,
-0.529755652,
0.1960308254,
-0.5005831122,
0.9475646019,
-0.2236306667,
0.068088688,
-0.5010879636,
0.0349949487,
-0.4238066673,
-0.2494838536,
-0.5980221629,
-0.6212152839,
0.6940769553,
0.2080049068,
1.0363652706,
1.1541192532,
0.2815257609,
0.4399241209,
0.0219170395,
0.218600139,
-0.0792338923,
0.2674871981,
-0.4684544802,
-0.4131579399,
-0.4239727259,
0.0795835108,
0.5384536982,
1.2684826851,
0.1873372793,
0.1287551969,
-0.0902200118,
0.7908985615,
-0.5047329068,
0.419454217,
-0.461373806,
0.2227621526,
0.3405282795,
-0.4385295212,
-0.3430440128,
-0.4738743901,
0.3810456693,
-0.6209665537,
0.3565957844,
0.165791586,
0.9346383214,
0.2834359109,
-0.4446365833,
-0.3318607509,
-0.8691764474,
0.5957844257,
-0.4475211799,
0.4778468013,
0.3436751366,
0.6643384695,
-0.1346094608,
-0.7116006017,
-0.4708094001,
-0.4281575978,
-0.4066769183,
-0.0250809137,
-0.0955660269,
0.3953927457,
0.3980107605,
0.5718888044,
-0.5819669366,
-0.1580065042,
-0.2555363178,
-0.3802869618,
0.8098269701,
0.0965446457,
0.3014419079,
-0.0838794187,
-0.4566851854,
0.3498127759,
-0.4380249083,
0.0740472525,
0.3194409311,
0.0103905946,
-0.1477114558,
0.5618002415,
-0.255381912,
0.6036326289,
0.2241154611,
0.1772268414,
-0.1881145835,
-0.4153744578,
-0.5487441421,
0.2418721616,
0.3948384821,
0.3390989304,
0.2050835043,
-0.48212865,
-0.337552309,
0.318425566,
0.0205383524,
-0.8891355395,
-0.2335316539,
0.7996908426,
-0.7909092903,
-0.2872309387,
-0.0477727577,
-0.4931550622,
-0.4021014869,
-0.7884126902,
0.2298083603,
-0.1600924879,
-0.1575319618,
0.6921221614,
-0.3087133169,
0.1155006811,
0.6671130657,
-0.9208626747,
0.3191090524,
0.9700465202,
0.6349062324,
0.1480332613,
-0.1289152503,
-0.4222308397,
-0.1584107429,
-0.7323285341,
0.8171967864,
-0.3096115291,
0.2813912928,
-0.0541591831,
0.05774514,
-0.0050723692,
-0.1686872691,
0.7841106653,
-0.6110959649,
0.2880711854,
-0.4551592469,
-0.6776980758,
-0.7258575559,
0.5659493804,
-0.653850019,
0.2490917593,
-0.0318250507,
-0.6505156755,
0.6158576012,
-1.1568504572,
-0.3344803452,
0.0345243104,
-0.011203249,
-0.0701273382,
0.0525889136,
0.18023628,
0.6194936633,
-0.4728892148,
0.7803888917,
-0.5428652763,
-0.1652034819,
0.565395534,
-0.6668662429,
1.0958909988,
0.3450337052,
-0.6628495455,
0.3740862608,
-0.944098413,
0.0058903731,
-0.0252949689,
-0.0617497787,
-0.1302780211,
0.2471495569,
-0.5418351889,
-0.1362179369,
0.1390355527,
-0.2592912614,
-0.1205649823,
-0.7228159308,
0.4999750853,
0.7117592096,
0.1305283457,
0.7789046764,
-0.2667298317,
0.5138936639,
0.0044168103,
0.3172729313,
-0.3592583835,
-0.1913342625,
-0.6998676062,
-0.4370202422,
0.4842035174,
0.3294126391,
-0.088180013,
0.4713297188,
-0.1174177229,
-0.1182134226,
-0.0572137646,
-0.2451065034,
0.2525058985,
0.6765488386,
0.3133794069,
0.2487560213,
-0.9498723149,
-1.1729137897,
-0.3700618744,
-0.1960894316,
-0.2734112144,
0.077424556,
0.6638083458,
-0.3630641699,
1.133026123,
0.0610187277,
0.3276928365,
-0.0935397819,
0.3047422469,
0.2528798282,
0.4986063242,
0.4263289273,
-0.8969361186,
0.1838250905,
-0.2911133766,
-0.8830926418,
-0.0083262455,
-0.6005291343,
-0.20668827,
-0.1705334485,
0.3922796845,
-0.65591079,
0.3991131485,
0.1149953008,
-0.4991078973,
0.5543353558,
-0.0189942755,
0.1489307284,
-0.30278036,
0.0803288817,
-0.0417063385,
-0.3789006472,
-0.4484891295,
0.21800901,
-0.3815081418,
0.1693855226,
-0.0037736744,
0.389025569,
-0.3319256306,
-0.0947747231,
0.0576766469,
0.342564851,
0.5247915983,
0.3112719655,
-0.1211235821,
0.1446626037,
0.5479097366,
-0.858199358,
0.5458257794,
0.0663908646,
-0.3717820346,
0.2946440279,
-1.2148504257,
-0.4385347366,
-0.3246449232,
0.4738402367,
-1.0573215485,
-0.4488781691,
0.3984696269,
-0.3604206443,
-0.1830267161,
-0.6495399475,
-0.3532080352,
-0.1859131306,
-0.2017643303,
0.3615112305,
0.1479011774,
-0.7541827559,
0.8121314049,
-0.0307783131,
0.3112487197,
-0.6149885654,
-0.5813691616,
0.0006744177,
-0.3159520328,
-1.0769290924,
0.4423790276,
-0.1766917408,
-0.9207623005,
-0.0595391691,
-0.4248264432,
-0.3598186076,
0.8066276312,
0.4219419956,
0.1645165533,
-0.7484066486,
0.2907650471,
0.0933896005,
-0.2992025912,
0.4456707239,
-0.4444139004,
-0.0387230068,
-0.5530699492,
-0.4294959307,
-0.3832887113,
0.3294037282,
0.5777403116,
-0.1057217047,
0.532749176,
0.4669563472,
-0.5776877999,
-0.4072159827,
-0.3519837856,
-0.4397052824,
-0.3979618549,
-0.0684666634,
-0.4417769313,
-0.6484460831,
0.758171618,
-0.0785963237,
0.2512521744,
0.8823155761,
0.7444372177,
0.0565648116,
1.3872873783,
0.4493195713,
0.6302419305,
-0.195548445,
-0.178545624,
0.5297561288,
-0.2457764894,
-0.4923993647,
-0.6433221698,
-0.0626663193,
-0.3331131339,
-0.3222254515,
-0.1300324798,
0.5175642967,
-0.2159912586,
-0.0336025544,
-0.5232291222,
0.6815199256,
0.0429723077,
-0.3602242172,
0.2432470024,
-0.2341101319,
-0.0336516909,
0.3295421898,
-0.7855479717,
-0.8789148927,
0.5542533398,
0.8648661971,
0.4444232583,
-0.0907841772,
0.29232198,
0.4102549851,
0.4793783724,
-1.1284521818,
0.4042901397,
0.145299226,
-0.9877609015,
-0.5955373645,
-0.2848408818,
-0.8966351748,
0.5499113798,
-0.1425907314,
-0.3561890721,
0.4081144631,
0.4825079143,
-0.7485384345,
-0.1557288021,
-0.759318471,
1.1253494024,
-0.3550157249,
-0.2139531225,
-0.3544377089,
-0.3670171797,
0.7213983536,
0.3655410409,
0.2398177534,
-0.3029557168,
0.0582145564,
0.5136839747,
-0.6218098998,
0.7122828364,
-0.3743399084,
-0.2165465057,
0.2532402873,
0.2188362926,
0.1329666376,
0.5236780047,
-0.3856828213,
-0.0432953425,
-0.0312955342,
-0.2575621605,
-1.1466914415,
0.3192905188,
-0.3550297618,
-0.6836199164,
-0.1396577656,
-0.441162467,
0.077177383,
0.1433737129,
0.017887257,
0.7175173163,
-0.1110495776,
0.4346567988,
0.8983225226,
0.1199011803,
0.2225137949,
0.2457049936,
-0.1187707856,
-0.1314433664,
0.5554462075,
-0.0396445245,
-0.3544751704,
0.3355956674,
0.6918838024,
-0.5586972237,
-0.7701067924,
-0.6238645315,
-0.2119194269,
-1.0484876633,
-0.0116701769,
-0.5628310442,
0.1174841002,
-0.1451705247,
-0.3896762133,
-0.0795225576,
-0.941980958,
-0.0690548345,
-0.347663492,
0.2625059485,
0.6571689844,
-0.0821737722,
-0.0848440528,
-0.4796043038,
0.7433956861,
0.4112761915,
0.6613269448,
0.007719446,
-0.5008808374,
-0.072316952,
0.3764083982,
0.2077542245,
-0.5667292476,
-0.1015838608,
0.1714473665,
0.6340138316,
0.4373347759,
0.0867042392,
0.7175674438,
-0.3402653635,
0.7205328345,
-0.0351135805,
-1.1495825052,
0.6309168935,
-0.2213502973,
-0.2255105227,
0.3985272944,
0.5158695579,
-0.2717835009,
-0.0211801846,
-0.7867367864,
-0.9039977193,
0.3130762279,
0.0599894486,
-0.0569854863,
0.1088822857,
0.5788404346,
0.204160735,
0.0626260117,
-0.855335474,
-0.0775349289,
-0.5293849707,
-0.165215373,
0.3131870925,
-0.4840362966,
-0.8024396896,
0.0243440047,
0.6513161659,
-0.3174301684,
0.0934115052,
0.6198897958,
-0.419442445,
-0.0314342976,
0.3425706327,
0.7665942907,
1.1651884317,
0.0753915831,
0.3007213473,
-0.1193238795,
0.4075814486,
0.0585905872,
0.1593911946,
-0.2295546234,
0.156774953,
0.7749571204,
0.7577979565,
0.2139725685,
-0.4091641307,
0.6657943726,
-0.0516903959,
-0.5249284506,
-0.335515976,
0.0094693583,
-0.1387542337,
0.2811004221,
0.1585539132,
0.2152110487,
0.5823975801,
-0.5165879726,
0.2741469741,
0.2954006195,
-0.174715206,
-0.4088190496,
0.5009528399,
0.1593738496,
0.0835619271,
0.2355574518,
-0.2399231941,
-0.7037029266,
0.8340475559,
0.1868502498,
1.1212915182,
0.1836100966,
0.3144139051,
0.3110136092,
0.3497239053,
-0.1401818246,
0.0795044228,
-0.4895961583,
-0.6063267589,
-0.858148396,
-0.5302705765,
-0.496165812,
0.05798693,
-0.2415869385,
0.0144785354,
-0.7522239685,
0.2250915766,
0.720467031,
-0.2188110054,
-0.3256807327,
0.5860364437,
0.1763979942,
0.9112644196,
-0.7911387682,
0.2506841421,
0.5103640556,
-0.5669173598,
-0.8267225623,
-0.1717674732,
-0.0105247032,
-0.6524521112,
0.9099737406,
0.1636489928,
-0.4912854731,
-0.782543242,
-0.7524081469,
-0.6746606827,
0.5423283577,
0.6115252376,
-0.3089681268,
0.0146934539,
-0.0881921202,
0.7659947276,
-0.5555045009,
0.2650554776,
0.4645638764,
0.9559776187,
-0.125902921,
-0.2538502514,
0.3674380183,
-0.1072812229,
-0.1337802112,
-0.3695003986,
0.0152831124,
0.4853473306,
-0.3725463748,
-0.3327375054,
-0.073069863,
0.7855392694,
-0.0250024609,
0.4011371136,
0.9036534429,
0.0471028164,
0.767834425,
-0.3872383237,
1.1002403498,
-0.3134537935,
0.0536750928,
1.0000612736,
0.194285512,
0.0500233732,
0.228729859,
0.0667649582,
0.828030169,
0.8521617055,
-0.2241441607,
0.0211432818,
0.6242030263,
0.1978221089,
-0.4620526135,
-0.0844487995,
-0.1528872102,
0.5817483068,
0.4049127102,
-0.5012522936,
-0.3756002784,
-0.3927675188,
-0.0806767568,
0.1835432649,
-0.4186820686,
0.5527323484,
-0.0905658752,
-1.0320786238,
0.8662695885,
0.2487057149,
-0.0179321896,
-0.4780752361,
-0.1966852695,
0.0898882225,
0.2330509126,
-0.6359405518,
-0.7213222384,
0.7093403339,
-0.1283537596,
-0.6367514133,
-0.6808802485,
0.6551523805,
-0.4189625382,
-0.0456674285,
0.0462617539,
0.1567515433,
0.0125720985,
-0.0760151744,
-1.0143613815,
0.0121253058,
-0.1400550306,
-0.4125375152,
-0.2904008329,
0.8460701108,
-0.1695787311,
0.6123357415,
0.8457330465,
-0.3563278615,
-0.2361394614,
0.4820718169,
0.508962512,
-0.324149698,
-0.4790436924,
-1.1525150537,
0.8097701669,
0.0099365367,
-0.0712133721,
0.6793977022,
0.5538372993,
0.3562937975,
0.0268631205,
0.6403732896,
-0.0248158816,
0.1509167105,
-0.5823861361,
0.4531945884,
-0.4391109943,
0.4594956934,
0.0619603693,
-0.79960531,
-0.6369066834,
0.9457759857,
-0.2180260867,
-0.1353568286,
0.6338256001,
0.5411158204,
-0.1548115164,
0.4690086246,
0.1321340054,
0.5649597645,
0.1080398783,
-0.0613682345,
1.054366827,
-0.2880668342,
0.4679280818,
-0.2567447722,
-0.3580235243,
-0.2625898421,
-1.5022958517,
-0.7023813725,
-0.5336129665,
-0.6196380258,
-0.4643549621,
0.0000174472,
0.8126720786,
1.0320210457,
-0.9363848567,
-0.0037796614,
-0.492082864,
0.847792685,
-0.3953377008,
-0.2236523032,
0.3689440489,
-0.6372596025,
-0.2429942042,
0.6165303588,
0.4828861356,
-0.0415448695,
-0.4532685876,
0.0264969952,
0.2124570012,
0.4963879585,
0.8887161613,
0.1757706404,
-0.9513037801,
-0.4299162924,
-0.1324627995,
0.1971761733,
0.1234133095,
1.1431778669,
-0.67053473,
0.2469128966,
0.7492626309,
0.7011486292,
-0.1162515208,
-0.037832465,
0.9776034355,
-0.2210298777,
-0.0980114713,
0.4288691878,
0.6664431095,
0.3280051351,
-0.4327927232,
0.5699023604,
0.0821952373,
-0.3475144804,
-1.0349241495,
0.3469615579,
-0.9796705842,
-0.2702803612,
0.9134412408,
-0.4244164228,
-0.2272204012,
-0.4389766157,
0.1011788324,
0.1987203956,
-0.0557884723,
0.8949148059,
0.7176525593,
-0.0314830095,
0.1621266305,
-0.2141360939,
0.7775578499,
0.4854512811,
-0.9432784319,
0.5893990993,
0.716555357,
0.1121088564,
0.3208464086,
0.2012418658,
-0.3130104542,
0.6785994172,
-0.0956807956,
-0.3857046962,
-0.0947625712,
-0.6492656469,
-0.4484318793,
0.352270931,
-0.0326361023,
0.08640448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20308v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20308v1
|
ChainNet: Structured Metaphor and Metonymy in WordNet
| 2024-03-29T17:22:53 | 2024-03-29T17:22:53 |
Rowan Hall Maudslay, Simone Teufel, Francis Bond, James Pustejovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The senses of a word exhibit rich internal structure. In a typical lexicon,
this structure is overlooked: a word's senses are encoded as a list without
inter-sense relations. We present ChainNet, a lexical resource which for the
first time explicitly identifies these structures. ChainNet expresses how
senses in the Open English Wordnet are derived from one another: every nominal
sense of a word is either connected to another sense by metaphor or metonymy,
or is disconnected in the case of homonymy. Because WordNet senses are linked
to resources which capture information about their meaning, ChainNet represents
the first dataset of grounded metaphor and metonymy.
|
[
-0.3453891873,
-0.4167255461,
0.4390955865,
-0.0322359912,
-0.2445527166,
0.1392340362,
0.0596063025,
-0.5677194595,
0.7260441184,
0.3153179288,
-0.5913704634,
-0.2281008512,
-0.3294860125,
0.0747985691,
-0.5388239026,
0.6856150031,
-0.1765328795,
-0.1431786567,
-0.1752892882,
-0.4659516513,
-0.0767044276,
-0.8290216327,
-0.5901098847,
-0.488047123,
1.0984745026,
0.0789371729,
0.9871631265,
0.9257979393,
0.5115695596,
0.3760748208,
-0.2975588739,
0.15835765,
-0.3555924296,
-0.0713867918,
-0.6963273287,
-0.264249593,
-0.1383181065,
0.394033134,
0.6898826361,
1.1835604906,
-0.1040218696,
0.2664291561,
0.1840499192,
0.9115449786,
-0.8282636404,
-0.0155334054,
-0.7988472581,
0.2624683976,
-0.2618767321,
-0.543694675,
-0.0441066511,
0.0598386936,
0.0779871121,
-0.8573638201,
0.0651571378,
0.5346261859,
1.1684515476,
-0.1531261951,
-0.3271894753,
-0.3433371782,
-0.4320061207,
0.4048534632,
-0.0835990161,
0.4020445347,
0.4866225719,
0.2654961348,
-0.2005111277,
-1.067813158,
-0.6919519305,
-0.4155527055,
-0.1777998507,
0.3219597936,
0.0965071544,
0.1271723807,
0.1992376149,
0.6714574099,
-0.4996570945,
-0.0867555737,
-0.5731425881,
-0.1511680931,
0.234169811,
0.222791627,
0.4746464789,
-0.3141252697,
-0.8623864651,
-0.1651159525,
-0.5253898501,
-0.1640362591,
0.6237364411,
0.449028939,
-0.1441004425,
0.6355826259,
-0.0197400451,
0.6191952229,
-0.4147353768,
-0.1152127981,
0.1989076734,
-0.2149124891,
-0.4660388827,
0.3424834311,
0.6705500484,
-0.0060459799,
0.5668567419,
-0.3105205595,
-0.1714735329,
0.4030380249,
0.3219620883,
-0.3261990547,
-0.1532832533,
0.1074566841,
-0.773812294,
-0.629578948,
0.545533061,
-0.213369146,
-0.2627721131,
-0.3422555625,
0.5107156634,
-0.0712562352,
-0.3309698105,
-0.062506035,
-0.7700067759,
0.053873051,
-0.0856099352,
-0.5654551387,
0.8584148288,
0.6201921701,
1.0499134064,
-0.1019787043,
-0.6533716321,
-0.190333575,
0.2121546865,
-0.4148149192,
0.5629844666,
-0.3357445002,
0.070634149,
-0.0537068807,
0.349421978,
0.2623031139,
-0.5561863184,
-0.2448901087,
-0.551897645,
0.3067456782,
-0.0561819337,
-0.6916922331,
-0.3083248138,
0.4266282022,
-0.9786933661,
0.8483073115,
0.1117244437,
-1.2432872057,
0.4005967975,
-0.3923437893,
-0.0709996894,
0.3905695975,
-0.2187654078,
0.7237098217,
0.1493216306,
-0.4687952101,
0.0829337835,
-0.2109821439,
0.1435862333,
-0.3334371448,
-0.2945975661,
0.4262997508,
-0.1756556034,
0.7281413674,
0.2066428959,
0.0483459346,
0.1532593369,
-0.8923817277,
-0.0477177799,
0.0213296581,
-0.1308397055,
-1.0448071957,
0.1772811413,
0.1485271007,
0.4557215571,
0.0686388537,
-0.6295240521,
0.1101244092,
-0.6954895854,
0.4081959426,
0.8510457873,
-0.0852618739,
0.198839739,
-0.4133470356,
0.288993746,
0.406658262,
-0.0585561581,
0.0389014967,
-0.3135448098,
-0.6327136755,
0.1333298534,
0.4073651135,
0.4635295868,
-0.7758516073,
0.1623915881,
-0.2919310033,
-0.2703266144,
-0.1126740947,
-0.1582846493,
0.1904243231,
0.334392488,
0.1622187048,
-0.5015835166,
-0.5232342482,
-0.9426890016,
-0.4869627059,
-0.3817771971,
-0.197897464,
0.3493371904,
0.7242355347,
-0.0705936179,
0.6464236379,
-0.2258752286,
-0.2603136897,
0.1720601171,
-0.1024999768,
0.4592848122,
0.2673057914,
0.1597735882,
-0.5808238983,
0.04785496,
0.0630607828,
-0.9498289824,
0.129585892,
-0.0973994583,
-0.447106272,
-0.4916378856,
0.4684644043,
-0.1899788678,
0.4302876592,
0.6485692263,
-0.5838159323,
0.7277292609,
0.0522208735,
-0.1648700088,
-1.3987387419,
0.1266226321,
-0.4939826727,
-0.2132343799,
-0.2750927806,
0.3139328957,
-0.2358057648,
-0.1200504452,
-0.6692947149,
0.7800647616,
-0.6763663292,
-0.2722572982,
-0.253880024,
0.5248334408,
0.3443254828,
0.2655252218,
-0.0307801832,
0.8141059875,
0.6933866739,
-0.644510746,
0.6479005814,
0.221273005,
-0.3315229416,
0.5581467748,
-0.6798737049,
0.1009619534,
-0.2096854895,
-0.1820493639,
-0.6808384061,
-0.3800482452,
0.2134079337,
-0.1045962796,
-0.188411057,
0.162337333,
-0.5414846539,
-0.4996412694,
-0.2469142675,
0.759939909,
-0.0552687906,
-0.7668844461,
0.1891099811,
0.3525242805,
0.7287139297,
-0.477488637,
-1.0338797569,
0.1488362849,
-0.1222184896,
-0.4391391873,
0.3480475545,
0.0742292181,
-0.6951938272,
0.1805031151,
-0.3410841227,
-0.5519832373,
0.1196048558,
0.4949658811,
-0.0606572963,
-0.1644525081,
0.5302041769,
-0.3517890871,
0.0483664833,
0.1782053858,
-0.765914619,
0.324872762,
-0.0945169255,
-0.034773808,
-0.0864937007,
0.5611315966,
0.5901216865,
0.2435686737,
1.0942124128,
0.0340703204,
-0.6285855174,
-0.2783976793,
-0.059630882,
-0.1127318591,
-0.4325797558,
-0.1498876363,
-0.6793588996,
-0.8039940596,
0.6405088305,
-0.2600125074,
-0.4246502519,
0.4459553659,
-0.001721923,
-0.1980600059,
0.104794763,
0.2391207963,
-0.0716443583,
0.1460574865,
0.0956007242,
0.0214801244,
-0.8729821444,
-0.1050162315,
-0.4275834858,
-0.6160424352,
-0.8277395368,
-0.0399603881,
0.2460989058,
0.450448364,
-0.5305509567,
0.5577343702,
-0.388756454,
0.2839612067,
0.7617273927,
0.4115964174,
0.291408062,
0.2470934391,
-0.8689830899,
0.2562814653,
-0.9425795078,
-0.5349500775,
0.5482070446,
0.193828553,
0.5670723915,
-0.0605299287,
0.5344415903,
0.3044565916,
-0.0713298917,
-0.9119169712,
0.7141737938,
0.1525280178,
-0.6406233311,
0.091937758,
-0.4437013566,
-1.2241206169,
0.0667395815,
-0.1838480979,
-0.887494266,
0.2993666828,
0.0268413089,
0.1553036571,
0.5320734382,
-0.1939664334,
0.536696434,
-0.0769787952,
-0.4536310136,
-0.0498151369,
-0.6355644464,
0.454696238,
0.144446224,
0.2761236727,
-0.1682958156,
-0.1624559015,
0.9529006481,
-0.8879160285,
0.5929240584,
0.3682574332,
0.3193971217,
0.447307229,
0.4846498668,
0.2546561956,
-0.3192396164,
-0.0611942895,
0.5756323934,
0.2512712777,
-0.3746150732,
-0.451436013,
0.5164909959,
-0.4628430903,
-0.1122333929,
-0.650252223,
-0.3241584301,
0.1182408482,
0.3665546775,
0.2046361864,
0.6401060224,
-0.2514584959,
0.1478557289,
0.0349243954,
-0.213351652,
0.3948743641,
-0.0285022613,
-0.3061268926,
-0.376996696,
0.345040977,
0.2258398682,
0.1726631671,
0.4177022874,
0.5258133411,
-0.083356522,
-0.0785334408,
0.013576488,
0.0113043217,
-0.7020136714,
-0.2797627747,
-0.1154711694,
-0.5731500387,
0.3260617852,
0.0362259634,
-0.2359659821,
-0.3340245485,
-0.0001373666,
-0.3216771483,
0.5668358803,
0.9106146097,
-0.080328472,
0.3805048764,
-0.6809009314,
0.4910623729,
0.2930686474,
0.8154028654,
0.0486233346,
-0.1285619289,
-0.3559596539,
-0.1213538721,
0.3536786735,
-1.2260030508,
0.2432545125,
0.1764716208,
0.2630715668,
0.7466249466,
-0.2765875459,
0.8188810349,
-0.6536028981,
0.9264035821,
0.4224178195,
-1.0030093193,
0.5298681259,
-0.4091991782,
0.2008500993,
0.455124259,
0.5312368274,
-0.7356939316,
-0.0539553799,
-0.8699609041,
-0.9504891634,
0.3318833411,
0.2910934687,
0.0194282345,
-0.563996613,
0.3875687122,
0.1867092103,
0.7120653391,
-0.8900728822,
-0.4735966623,
-0.0844832659,
0.1001504734,
0.170623526,
-0.4004482925,
-0.2923971415,
-0.3360906243,
0.1089129597,
0.1004766822,
0.2634016573,
0.3690238595,
-0.2526348829,
-0.1242223457,
-0.0203196071,
0.1731563658,
0.8821154237,
0.0385639295,
1.0045360327,
-0.1567914486,
-0.7287213802,
0.248084709,
-0.5823317766,
0.100706324,
0.1664693058,
0.7295301557,
0.8177930713,
0.4122219682,
-0.3441551924,
0.2557508349,
0.427791357,
-0.254155308,
-0.4692474604,
0.0046275156,
-0.1220406815,
0.1117337197,
0.3168829978,
-0.0838129297,
0.2381243855,
-0.7836178541,
0.3862556815,
0.3580822349,
-0.3275913596,
-0.259319663,
0.4675021768,
-0.3397930562,
-0.3569101393,
0.6030797958,
-0.0306368452,
-0.483423084,
0.3759558797,
0.6430023313,
1.027915597,
-0.0197845176,
-0.0158681143,
0.5095438361,
0.5845590234,
-0.0153914718,
0.5324067473,
-0.1548700631,
-1.2173032761,
0.0955737606,
-0.8138032556,
-0.1726058424,
0.3500496745,
-0.7352309823,
-0.2748219371,
-0.5548629761,
-0.0361254998,
-0.2156045288,
-0.3161527216,
-0.8078700304,
0.3469111025,
0.0953173861,
1.179723382,
-0.8232133985,
0.73072052,
0.6423121691,
-0.4732412398,
-1.3982661963,
0.0070790341,
-0.1975309402,
-0.5899434686,
0.9201449752,
0.2120605856,
-0.2619486153,
0.1616670936,
-0.7443141341,
-0.8254545331,
0.9450507164,
-0.0580754094,
-0.5554730892,
0.0531649403,
0.0634458438,
0.3434334695,
-0.4485371709,
0.355422765,
0.2043386102,
0.5929273367,
-0.2234942466,
-0.7712325454,
0.2945260108,
-0.4235920906,
0.4137308002,
0.1849527061,
-0.2333465815,
1.1438100338,
0.5080393553,
-0.5585445762,
-0.2429044247,
0.4772681296,
0.1209625304,
0.1350806653,
0.5312166214,
0.609508872,
0.7583442926,
0.112189047,
1.0495364666,
-0.3468049169,
0.0944941342,
1.0398693085,
-0.283357352,
0.7534273267,
0.8641240001,
-0.2814147472,
0.8418387175,
0.790556252,
0.1353102922,
0.3388867378,
0.6082538962,
-0.2527728379,
0.1756988913,
-0.1463674009,
-0.2736871839,
0.6863746643,
0.2977239192,
-0.5874410272,
-0.2727887034,
-0.1582131982,
-0.3842375875,
0.0454087667,
-0.5718613267,
0.9223766923,
0.3450328708,
-0.2848696709,
0.6342229843,
-0.3475182056,
0.3462853432,
-0.5816246867,
-0.1680677682,
-0.078323558,
-0.2186918557,
-0.2498043627,
-0.7556109428,
0.4555464089,
-0.4413103759,
-0.2987861037,
-0.0210109502,
1.0459102392,
-0.3207484484,
-0.2254733741,
0.7728780508,
0.8377665877,
0.6927930713,
-0.1766754985,
-0.5376054645,
-0.1346672624,
-0.7911522388,
-0.3246539235,
0.1145930812,
0.6817564368,
-0.1007220149,
0.2959073186,
0.7522784472,
0.4450471103,
0.098524116,
0.1061183363,
0.8288624883,
-1.0647016764,
-0.7875350714,
-0.9365077615,
0.2742959559,
-0.1622653604,
-0.2419110388,
0.7870000601,
0.2467789501,
0.9226938486,
-0.1779412627,
0.3632219136,
0.0384193808,
0.0525401346,
-0.4666927457,
0.7431630492,
-0.6488958001,
-0.1077553928,
-0.3104178309,
-0.9805771112,
-0.0597700961,
0.5981575251,
0.2118110955,
-0.0559442379,
1.2205117941,
0.7015220523,
-0.421615988,
-0.2304332554,
0.4748544395,
0.1981810331,
-0.6291143894,
0.2432191968,
0.98543185,
-0.4941166937,
-0.127064988,
-0.0834675059,
-0.0999073759,
0.1438075602,
-0.8873774409,
-0.7658732533,
-0.7908068299,
0.0527500957,
-0.6809057593,
0.2306803912,
0.8773067594,
0.6268857121,
-0.5870207548,
-0.6074631214,
-0.7281010747,
0.1779644638,
-0.378854841,
-0.3279936314,
0.1359682381,
-0.1350287795,
-0.0937226564,
0.7085771561,
0.4376686215,
-0.1528711766,
-0.4396105707,
0.2087308764,
-0.4963560998,
0.2490079254,
0.64827317,
0.0570977964,
-0.6250820756,
-0.5421728492,
-0.3507539928,
-0.2646926641,
0.0317534879,
0.864362061,
-1.0231097937,
0.4828069508,
0.7398932576,
0.2181332558,
0.194684431,
0.0356551185,
0.5215259194,
-1.0306311846,
0.7839236856,
-0.0439661555,
0.421842128,
0.048939053,
-0.3176516891,
0.6102310419,
0.7049769759,
-0.0112995738,
-0.5944197774,
0.4601958096,
-1.0551371574,
-0.4801793993,
0.987036109,
-0.0533049628,
-0.4235767424,
-0.0624391772,
0.2542260885,
0.4159890711,
0.2829934359,
0.3573666513,
0.8718489408,
0.3755531907,
-0.0145961931,
-0.5631344914,
0.2109244317,
-0.0218025185,
-0.557066083,
-0.5198283195,
0.4370671809,
0.156863153,
0.1783397794,
0.4077694416,
0.1071250737,
-0.1166752875,
0.427511692,
0.1985216886,
-0.068798922,
-0.7251313329,
-0.0191507395,
0.5573504567,
-0.2120852917,
-0.5701332092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20289v1
|
Emotion-Anchored Contrastive Learning Framework for Emotion Recognition in Conversation
| 2024-03-29T17:00:55 | 2024-03-29T17:00:55 |
Fangxu Yu, Junjie Guo, Zhen Wu, Xinyu Dai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Emotion Recognition in Conversation (ERC) involves detecting the underlying
emotion behind each utterance within a conversation. Effectively generating
representations for utterances remains a significant challenge in this task.
Recent works propose various models to address this issue, but they still
struggle with differentiating similar emotions such as excitement and
happiness. To alleviate this problem, We propose an Emotion-Anchored
Contrastive Learning (EACL) framework that can generate more distinguishable
utterance representations for similar emotions. To achieve this, we utilize
label encodings as anchors to guide the learning of utterance representations
and design an auxiliary loss to ensure the effective separation of anchors for
similar emotions. Moreover, an additional adaptation process is proposed to
adapt anchors to serve as effective classifiers to improve classification
performance. Across extensive experiments, our proposed EACL achieves
state-of-the-art emotion recognition performance and exhibits superior
performance on similar emotions. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Yu-Fangxu/EACL.
|
[
-0.5052103996,
-0.4233106673,
0.3200938702,
0.1244100109,
-0.1841107458,
0.1121213809,
-0.3030830622,
-0.6840679049,
0.4285654128,
0.0762939528,
-0.6169747114,
-0.61020118,
-0.4403543174,
0.1556157768,
0.0098645603,
1.0145602226,
-0.0390322842,
-0.0600143038,
-0.2769094706,
-0.6216844916,
-0.1476717889,
-0.5704718232,
-0.7794978619,
-0.4353342354,
0.4023192227,
0.7528104186,
0.0890883356,
0.2901616096,
0.1773176193,
0.323440969,
-0.2194166929,
0.2583626211,
-0.6562524438,
0.3635012209,
0.2563775778,
-0.3269684613,
-0.3993148208,
-0.3135976195,
0.2202994674,
0.3590239882,
-0.38713184,
-0.2822405994,
0.3210783005,
0.8102847338,
-0.6576088071,
0.400906682,
-0.4958471954,
0.2122519761,
0.2231087536,
-0.1840347052,
-0.4890855849,
-0.1194346622,
0.3430858552,
-0.4326405823,
-0.0235850643,
0.3035099804,
0.7245655656,
0.0226986185,
-0.5881844759,
-0.6259228587,
-0.3737085462,
0.5641103387,
-0.4772847593,
0.5357685685,
0.3060492873,
0.043299865,
0.2843210399,
-0.4165325761,
-0.4420277774,
0.0216928888,
0.1625932008,
0.5514557362,
-0.1712434441,
0.4071614444,
0.0084829945,
0.3824031353,
-0.6778113842,
0.0482952856,
0.0098814331,
0.0051171887,
0.3468299508,
0.2156160027,
0.155427143,
0.2024649978,
-0.350813508,
-0.254345566,
-0.6584305763,
0.236258924,
0.3266838789,
0.1864999533,
-0.2996376157,
-0.0525846258,
-0.2638792396,
0.1784352958,
0.3325447142,
0.2171714902,
0.6978363991,
0.516824007,
-0.097407572,
0.5602833033,
0.4408230186,
0.4841589332,
0.0452506132,
0.2129310966,
-0.0909392312,
0.0976895615,
0.054484766,
-0.7832264304,
-0.4313086867,
0.4121993482,
-0.5119292736,
-0.2199405879,
0.1160678044,
-0.8335629106,
-0.3833806813,
0.0038839495,
0.1627492011,
-0.1856129318,
-0.1523667574,
0.0748234317,
0.1597961336,
0.274692148,
0.2506783009,
-0.9921290278,
0.5121789575,
0.5606631637,
0.6485930681,
-0.1961873174,
0.0329350047,
-0.5647673011,
0.0488593914,
-0.2512645721,
0.7710453868,
-0.6140601635,
-0.5293681622,
0.4668948352,
-0.0030141864,
0.2580923736,
-0.4200424552,
0.7169587612,
-0.5956916213,
0.0102248769,
-0.2390256822,
-0.6798195839,
-0.3115565479,
0.4698703885,
-0.6467868686,
0.8416469693,
-0.227483809,
-0.7488554716,
0.071437791,
-0.5943566561,
-0.4438467026,
-0.0477563106,
0.0432509668,
-0.5297704935,
0.3286905587,
0.1034334525,
0.290578723,
-0.010490316,
-0.2816433012,
-0.5073945522,
-0.3338097036,
0.4087195098,
-0.2129234225,
0.2947209179,
0.3499993086,
-0.2934662104,
0.1912416369,
-0.9534154534,
-0.0648645759,
-0.1191684902,
-0.3097074032,
-0.4823989868,
0.1535541862,
0.0204633642,
0.215620175,
0.0667867139,
-0.563159287,
-0.2679606676,
-0.4189679325,
0.0243783314,
0.8792128563,
-0.0344805829,
0.4516455233,
-0.0531178638,
0.3446859419,
0.4044104218,
-0.213773936,
-0.494550705,
-0.3938710988,
-1.2066147327,
-0.0451085418,
-0.026447244,
0.4225987792,
-0.5505127311,
0.4269075692,
0.0502110235,
-0.2324649692,
-0.6359513402,
-0.103103146,
0.504856348,
0.7290714383,
0.4191167653,
-0.2616420388,
-0.6775788069,
-0.576335609,
-0.064823173,
-0.3872092962,
-0.0611257292,
0.6912459135,
0.2687183917,
-0.1279112399,
0.592893362,
-0.5982608795,
-0.2228648812,
-0.0436855331,
0.5867328644,
-0.1377366036,
0.5520704985,
0.3085529804,
-1.0081011057,
-0.6898358464,
0.235741809,
-0.6012812257,
-0.354323566,
0.0646577701,
0.0101333987,
0.3867590725,
0.4613263309,
-0.0101141073,
0.3136728108,
0.608568728,
-0.2307425886,
0.2053166628,
-0.1339367777,
0.4651955962,
-0.8948300481,
-0.1832614243,
-0.0700946525,
-0.2567293346,
-0.7559276819,
-0.5431501865,
0.1752189547,
-0.1135383546,
-0.5582283139,
0.2981774807,
-0.528408289,
0.0461564139,
-0.2742509246,
0.0566869564,
0.1409278065,
0.7209464312,
0.5435674191,
0.2410781682,
0.567268908,
-0.5283523798,
0.2650687695,
0.3488194942,
-0.0900194198,
1.0439604521,
-0.5341494679,
0.4598096311,
-0.2791418433,
0.3450402021,
-1.0635015965,
-0.3432095051,
0.2103946954,
-0.3745401204,
0.4622527957,
0.0366923399,
0.0914854333,
-0.0324868709,
-0.3512314558,
0.3879663646,
0.6549534202,
-0.8814455867,
0.8140869141,
0.2278341651,
-0.3535987735,
-0.4372612238,
-0.8788849115,
-0.2974832356,
-0.3608525097,
-0.319683075,
0.4880802631,
-0.2472622544,
0.110972032,
0.0936226174,
-0.1820750087,
-0.0432989635,
-0.0551038943,
0.5635790825,
-0.0054548271,
-0.1450318545,
0.4496997595,
0.1933365613,
-0.1284350008,
0.1881238669,
-0.0722242072,
0.3253697157,
-0.5250374079,
-0.4894238114,
-0.2870785892,
0.6907197237,
0.2730332613,
-0.162169382,
0.7651876807,
0.7171345949,
-0.5595272183,
-0.2487645894,
-0.5046772361,
-0.0954554901,
-0.4954478741,
0.65941149,
-0.3541314304,
-1.0692397356,
0.8547545671,
-0.1720964611,
-0.1393389553,
0.2802996337,
0.4553937614,
-0.3038744032,
1.0939869881,
0.583275497,
-0.0688622296,
0.6807002425,
0.2129517645,
0.1042817235,
-0.8887009025,
-0.34710446,
-0.48784554,
-0.3233082294,
-0.4045609236,
-0.2739388049,
0.1222586259,
-0.1930674165,
-0.3559958935,
0.008389866,
-0.2806283236,
0.4517013431,
0.111333698,
0.2145690173,
0.1473849863,
-0.2171974182,
0.1312923729,
-0.2891992033,
-0.5634627938,
-0.2549764216,
0.6539965868,
0.4226283431,
0.7992225885,
0.0355132297,
1.1096382141,
0.1696529686,
0.620750308,
-0.6523563266,
0.4237573743,
0.0754556507,
-0.2791383862,
0.2187816054,
-0.5414645076,
-0.5738847256,
-0.0030104045,
-0.3638874292,
-1.078635335,
0.4617248178,
0.2502659261,
-0.0747261494,
0.0779829398,
-0.6206036806,
0.8598436713,
-0.3194833696,
-0.327033788,
-0.2344405949,
-0.7894336581,
0.0570416041,
0.158554107,
0.0893377364,
0.0292701107,
-0.0398251079,
0.7394645214,
-0.1938376427,
0.7671641111,
-0.0572589859,
0.0722443014,
0.4810676575,
0.0241266266,
0.4992936552,
-0.0505116843,
-0.1144744381,
-0.0316187963,
-0.5090460777,
-0.1561856866,
-0.7017620206,
0.6994784474,
-0.4404636621,
-0.2710478008,
-0.3245205581,
-0.3480522037,
-0.2713454664,
-0.2654003203,
0.1370208114,
0.3514316082,
-0.6374740601,
0.302438587,
0.8965644836,
-0.3479126692,
0.3767633736,
0.3986827731,
0.0136482976,
-0.6001508236,
1.1331839561,
-0.3219227493,
0.1579060704,
0.4877397716,
-0.0618684739,
-0.4366493225,
-0.2755617201,
0.0916802436,
-0.0813833848,
-0.9986752272,
-0.3571642339,
-0.5981908441,
0.1849583238,
-0.1705395728,
-0.3982742131,
-0.3728343248,
-0.0107510006,
-0.6164767146,
-0.2763800025,
0.4026956856,
0.5889447331,
-0.2490078658,
0.2000943273,
-0.8524079323,
0.0774790198,
0.5391956568,
0.4516929984,
0.0981117859,
-0.5189883113,
-0.2589032352,
-0.1022045314,
-0.4052314758,
-1.0415520668,
0.6103494167,
0.6727881432,
0.2841268182,
1.0018684864,
0.4809852839,
0.6462996602,
-0.4521465898,
0.5167071819,
0.4891686738,
-1.2087023258,
0.3908566236,
0.0401268303,
0.1711632162,
0.6531205177,
0.5696202517,
-0.5154701471,
0.0544928461,
-0.6901504397,
-1.0827412605,
0.6664609313,
0.0824748427,
0.0496352427,
-0.208692804,
-0.0203519389,
-0.1315921545,
0.3123341203,
-0.7413517237,
-0.3657384217,
-0.0674759969,
-0.6611325145,
0.1667352617,
-0.5182865262,
-0.0965439975,
0.24727723,
0.6172848344,
-0.3081989884,
0.4408833086,
0.3046274781,
-0.1984601915,
-0.1653415114,
0.3180482388,
0.3097729981,
-0.2691187263,
-0.4118861854,
0.1759277582,
0.5893926024,
-0.1159820557,
0.0192017574,
0.0908573493,
0.5501185656,
-0.1185968742,
0.1402582973,
0.9946027398,
0.5996504426,
-0.8578796387,
0.4699653983,
-0.0713394359,
-0.0933033079,
-0.0473503582,
-0.2326969355,
0.2747717202,
0.4610150754,
0.3901318312,
-0.1020590439,
0.5194916129,
-0.7017993331,
0.2531399131,
0.0353539251,
-0.7606449723,
-0.2913328409,
0.4617731273,
0.6553008556,
-0.3620951474,
0.4884785414,
-0.3269523084,
-1.1086804867,
0.5088499784,
0.6413894892,
1.0761772394,
-0.5593653917,
0.0577746183,
0.244653821,
-0.2940784693,
0.2096350342,
0.3525915444,
-0.5104243159,
-0.6700470448,
0.0072163614,
-0.3148759604,
-0.8562912941,
-0.407777667,
-1.0243364573,
-0.0048355591,
-0.2165850848,
0.0878120959,
-0.650203824,
-0.2404255718,
-0.5992846489,
0.1716847271,
0.6899868846,
0.5750739574,
-1.0545681715,
0.4840202332,
0.8460564017,
-0.0913427249,
-0.5922112465,
-0.2124977857,
0.2569270432,
-0.2650428414,
0.5088377595,
0.5986145735,
-0.2852193415,
-0.0716289431,
-0.34211725,
-0.3530843556,
0.9533996582,
0.0869675651,
-0.5846849084,
0.2631704211,
-0.111287117,
0.7592489719,
-0.990958333,
0.5170147419,
0.266713351,
0.0749266818,
0.1983162612,
-0.3927485943,
-0.1734292209,
-0.3658534884,
-0.1542251408,
-0.1382108182,
-0.5931685567,
0.5950145125,
-0.0225642603,
-0.2543719709,
-0.166125834,
1.1024008989,
0.485462904,
0.6642387509,
0.5231100917,
0.4192043245,
0.808777988,
-0.3005592227,
0.5418194532,
-0.3618805408,
0.483459264,
1.216868639,
-0.5016897917,
1.1127554178,
0.3342292905,
-0.0335809998,
0.7101925611,
0.6496895552,
0.3395665884,
0.524884522,
0.1269136518,
-0.4992845058,
-0.2179570794,
-0.408841908,
-0.2363032997,
0.2644669116,
0.7418808937,
-0.3972423673,
0.0813998282,
0.0764144138,
-0.2203639746,
-0.0036943958,
-0.4903729856,
0.949213922,
0.2929505706,
-0.3346857131,
0.3177612424,
-0.5335231423,
0.6454794407,
-0.5044357777,
-0.3539146781,
-0.0971764624,
0.1473743618,
-0.4742354751,
-0.6988322139,
0.0683655888,
0.1666359007,
0.0175215974,
-0.0992472991,
0.7777843475,
-0.9657075405,
0.0756612644,
0.4673016369,
0.0767098516,
0.1511643678,
0.0711464956,
-0.5997614264,
0.4829941392,
0.0490466505,
-0.4914222062,
0.3148911893,
0.6440605521,
0.5087552667,
0.5246955156,
0.256067872,
-0.2546364367,
-0.2682106495,
0.1156957746,
0.9070496559,
-0.5030613542,
-0.8903517723,
-0.5597445369,
0.8756165504,
-0.2428002059,
-0.2479184419,
0.2811258137,
0.2063279003,
0.6910617948,
-0.2007920295,
0.415220201,
0.0341136456,
0.1764579564,
-0.3607204556,
0.4400966763,
-0.6125910878,
0.1743188798,
-0.6853405237,
-0.9483959079,
-0.3132026792,
0.9286701679,
0.0677222013,
0.0314008035,
0.677616179,
0.5981423855,
0.1351335198,
0.3941696584,
0.3888372183,
0.1906814873,
0.2478034347,
1.09930408,
0.7900378108,
-0.3750836551,
0.7147834897,
-0.1228462979,
-0.2397310585,
-0.5397850275,
-1.1499797106,
-0.7440320253,
-0.7400988936,
-0.5688563585,
-0.3945150077,
0.2402007431,
1.2034196854,
0.540407598,
-0.9409123063,
-0.0701446906,
-0.1511440277,
-0.0415355675,
-0.1330412179,
-0.2123651356,
0.4246799946,
-0.117429167,
-0.8851797581,
0.2642402053,
0.4500891268,
0.1225574836,
0.3193574846,
-0.6120781898,
-0.0851250291,
-0.0266903061,
0.419893533,
0.6199391484,
-0.394577533,
-0.4811900854,
-0.3020379841,
0.0137276612,
0.3439634144,
0.6314427257,
-0.5498354435,
0.797534883,
0.4566781819,
0.9278168678,
0.578579545,
0.1237783059,
0.5105236173,
-0.7614046931,
0.1069144905,
0.3748589754,
0.5691037774,
0.4813892245,
-0.2487380803,
0.2980802357,
-0.0504591763,
-0.7111622691,
-0.7654821873,
0.4131503701,
-1.2583762407,
0.2918433845,
0.7619467974,
-0.7025753856,
-0.1848778874,
0.0343647599,
-0.5131403804,
0.331015259,
-0.8489547968,
0.623467207,
0.7261222601,
-0.4255546927,
-0.4125196934,
0.2689464986,
0.4877317846,
0.5469033718,
-0.8303957582,
0.1009288877,
0.4218979478,
-0.0800855234,
0.1771821678,
0.3814211488,
0.0828178003,
0.4113370776,
0.1827195287,
0.2236903906,
0.0068407389,
-0.270224005,
-0.7652138472,
0.2047160864,
-0.0594463162,
-0.1429222673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20288v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20288v2
|
Can LLMs Correct Physicians, Yet? Investigating Effective Interaction Methods in the Medical Domain
| 2024-03-29T16:59:13 | 2024-05-06T14:13:51 |
Burcu Sayin, Pasquale Minervini, Jacopo Staiano, Andrea Passerini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore the potential of Large Language Models (LLMs) to assist and
potentially correct physicians in medical decision-making tasks. We evaluate
several LLMs, including Meditron, Llama2, and Mistral, to analyze the ability
of these models to interact effectively with physicians across different
scenarios. We consider questions from PubMedQA and several tasks, ranging from
binary (yes/no) responses to long answer generation, where the answer of the
model is produced after an interaction with a physician. Our findings suggest
that prompt design significantly influences the downstream accuracy of LLMs and
that LLMs can provide valuable feedback to physicians, challenging incorrect
diagnoses and contributing to more accurate decision-making. For example, when
the physician is accurate 38% of the time, Mistral can produce the correct
answer, improving accuracy up to 74% depending on the prompt being used, while
Llama2 and Meditron models exhibit greater sensitivity to prompt choice. Our
analysis also uncovers the challenges of ensuring that LLM-generated
suggestions are pertinent and useful, emphasizing the need for further research
in this area.
|
[
-0.1911851764,
-0.8068276048,
1.3784557581,
0.1646988094,
-0.1453957409,
-0.0424607135,
-0.3443970084,
-0.8543602228,
0.0405045934,
0.3113294542,
-0.4380433857,
-0.2740640342,
-0.6757057309,
0.2823998332,
-0.0654403791,
0.4837765396,
-0.0329191051,
0.6528694034,
-0.3867996037,
-0.1143495962,
-0.7153578401,
-0.8493230939,
-0.9764505625,
-0.5847047567,
0.7171936035,
0.2070419788,
0.9909934402,
0.4240499437,
0.5800768137,
0.3277701437,
-0.4364521503,
0.3529385626,
-0.2631471157,
0.3913767934,
-0.3591022491,
-0.5782185197,
-0.4495783746,
0.0075617903,
0.2672149539,
1.0182623863,
-0.2701171041,
-0.0898149684,
0.1565764248,
0.4225412607,
-0.0723267645,
-0.0346987657,
-0.3207289875,
-0.0111007001,
-0.0917488188,
-0.3313452005,
-0.4221970439,
-0.200079903,
0.3121972382,
-0.4868926406,
-0.0880041942,
0.1278725266,
0.5565245748,
0.5406873226,
-0.5258775949,
-0.4787762463,
-0.905737102,
0.5473275781,
-0.934491396,
0.3627575338,
0.5509200692,
0.1992632896,
-0.518550396,
-0.7573719621,
-0.4202386439,
-0.3435970843,
-0.1872573644,
0.0708777905,
-0.4525204301,
0.3883138299,
0.5548174381,
0.0178636853,
-0.0402674377,
0.5151596665,
-0.3431785107,
-0.0110305455,
0.5283695459,
0.5020090342,
0.3785601556,
-0.1131814718,
-0.0722213984,
0.4295065701,
-0.8295319676,
0.217624858,
-0.0837571099,
0.0245837234,
0.0411620401,
0.8668157458,
0.0966660604,
1.0726059675,
0.2325989902,
-0.2126640826,
-0.1476579159,
-0.4330199361,
-0.2173963338,
-0.0873940811,
0.7325879335,
0.6900464892,
0.1067507118,
0.0955224261,
-0.2263328731,
-0.1373746246,
0.4902070165,
-0.6133186221,
-0.1931882054,
0.680793345,
-0.6428587437,
-0.3389196694,
-0.2954360545,
-0.40603742,
-0.8183757067,
-0.581346333,
0.4680534005,
-0.2142189145,
-0.1068335921,
0.2545984387,
-0.0267553329,
0.0337595791,
0.673879385,
-0.5620920062,
0.2701062858,
0.5523604155,
0.6095834374,
-0.0764902011,
-0.057411816,
-0.6090254784,
-0.0129417777,
-0.5942800641,
0.9205240011,
-0.527181685,
-0.7506893873,
-0.0990511551,
-0.2271752805,
-0.2204935253,
-0.8574705124,
0.3949848115,
-0.3386106491,
0.2409377098,
-0.5564938784,
-0.6956536174,
0.0745624527,
0.2016250789,
-0.6368826628,
0.6511893868,
-0.0043371925,
-0.7772772908,
0.1920196265,
-0.4973410964,
-0.2787368596,
0.0657392293,
-0.6870337725,
-0.1215463355,
0.2744374275,
0.2537401319,
0.4929991364,
-0.4566430151,
0.4894146323,
-0.082160823,
-0.103854619,
0.9244630337,
-0.3201745152,
0.510592103,
0.0610807426,
-0.1254077703,
0.2182789296,
-0.513020575,
-0.1190013364,
0.0394375436,
-0.4400130212,
-0.3306132853,
0.1282983422,
-0.2642701566,
0.2848235667,
0.1026078835,
-0.3901474774,
0.350859195,
-0.1569712758,
0.4054550231,
0.7326661348,
0.2908696532,
0.1778481454,
-0.6357207894,
0.740675509,
-0.2636629939,
0.3140883148,
-0.1370692253,
-0.7250146866,
-0.6045456529,
-0.3495292962,
0.4358233809,
0.4454920888,
-0.9380335808,
0.0731672645,
0.0676090196,
-0.5521171689,
-0.5213581324,
0.0888297185,
0.4115822017,
0.8638637066,
0.1076830849,
-0.0983405486,
-0.2576678395,
-0.6672211289,
-0.3540758193,
-0.3683686256,
0.0134188021,
0.6030246615,
0.0530957505,
-0.1713173687,
1.057720542,
-0.4525654018,
0.1531111598,
-0.3272792399,
-0.0855414644,
0.4416045547,
0.1798861325,
0.5827768445,
-0.6165085435,
-0.267813623,
-0.0358804278,
-0.880854845,
-0.5128369331,
-0.2716714442,
0.0961304456,
-0.0143373422,
0.554305017,
-0.7333296537,
0.2160118669,
0.4882417023,
-0.3408149481,
0.4913015366,
-0.4973563552,
0.3288939893,
-1.0292828083,
0.1072771996,
0.1195551828,
-0.2650209069,
-1.1065815687,
-0.1662720293,
0.0524825491,
0.1024999917,
-0.546456337,
0.7740622759,
-0.2874053121,
0.2853721082,
-0.3144070208,
-0.1208410487,
-0.2416226864,
-0.0778248087,
0.0479872599,
0.9204969406,
0.4448201954,
-0.7061571479,
0.262108326,
0.3475467861,
-0.3414734602,
0.8385438919,
-1.0166833401,
0.1014795452,
-0.1608406156,
0.197144568,
-1.0542584658,
-0.4084495306,
0.4792939723,
-0.4926425517,
0.2383781672,
-0.2715161443,
-0.6272192597,
-0.3663880229,
-0.0332162194,
0.504449904,
0.357108891,
-0.5094299912,
0.6471869946,
0.1671891063,
-0.6585128307,
-0.3502344489,
-0.5417656898,
0.2250004262,
-0.0963632837,
-0.4090386927,
0.0940560624,
-0.2350075096,
-0.5164929628,
-0.2390249372,
-0.1454696953,
-0.0801783651,
0.0108941644,
0.4256003499,
0.6674666405,
0.2332357615,
0.2879495621,
0.0313147157,
-0.0664344579,
0.1782179177,
0.2605707943,
0.4978677034,
0.3388060033,
-0.7222319841,
-0.4777154028,
0.2034435719,
0.6711995602,
-0.1923517585,
0.5602671504,
0.1454460174,
-0.4989366233,
0.2014003843,
-0.7118359208,
-0.2270632982,
-0.4695117176,
0.1726891249,
-0.2418120503,
-1.0108971596,
0.4868207872,
-0.2005600333,
0.259280771,
0.2038000524,
0.6642557383,
-0.3331253529,
1.2468947172,
0.3678511381,
0.2223413885,
0.167541191,
0.0857688114,
0.1712955087,
-0.8619716763,
-0.6060009599,
-0.5149519444,
-0.2139173448,
-0.3090242743,
-0.5299623609,
0.7187245488,
0.0631780252,
0.0479920581,
-0.0141904457,
-0.4332790077,
0.2565575838,
0.4543823898,
0.298745364,
0.2264295667,
-0.2168432474,
-0.2569949925,
-0.1605959237,
-0.8803690672,
-0.4040438831,
0.9378321767,
0.5447325706,
1.0792998075,
0.2165039033,
0.6743009686,
0.1528904438,
0.3240902126,
-0.9475006461,
0.4594402611,
0.239042446,
-0.4249314666,
0.0213903133,
-0.4225060642,
-1.1171057224,
0.1632212102,
-0.4908520579,
-0.5802773833,
0.1299564093,
0.1927855611,
-0.727612555,
0.1087125093,
-0.519600451,
0.3988366425,
-0.5297774076,
-0.2589610815,
-0.1364167184,
-0.7551085949,
0.0356467403,
-0.274143517,
0.2808231413,
-0.00318336,
-0.3775976002,
0.5485461354,
-0.3818897605,
1.0573664904,
0.0240212195,
-0.505135417,
0.0408091322,
0.1887668818,
0.1831820309,
0.1138610467,
-0.1912345141,
0.1727925241,
0.0347933806,
-0.059586443,
-0.6766507626,
0.4949508011,
-0.5816895962,
-0.8981723189,
-0.6202762127,
-0.4607170522,
-0.3952413201,
0.13781932,
0.1760305017,
0.6487488747,
-0.0853190422,
-0.2313125134,
0.6923075914,
-0.344036907,
0.2154378891,
0.7345163226,
-0.2293476909,
-0.4282847047,
0.3389898837,
0.2182716429,
0.2651769519,
0.0489144213,
0.241777122,
-0.3927640021,
-0.5503223538,
-0.4387851655,
0.5485953689,
-0.7272197008,
-0.2134359032,
-0.5752336383,
-0.3147686124,
0.0841188058,
-0.1427455246,
0.0279193819,
-0.1927354038,
-0.3181800544,
-0.0537487268,
0.3224042952,
1.127199173,
0.0536895618,
0.2603063285,
-1.106366396,
0.1057179645,
0.257874161,
0.3198747933,
0.0203197561,
-0.3675047159,
0.0940971076,
-0.1891258955,
-0.0874047279,
-1.0854337215,
-0.0544013977,
-0.2423579395,
0.9214853048,
0.4307158589,
-0.1468671709,
0.4958215654,
-0.7373157144,
1.0402060747,
0.389172256,
-0.7083081603,
0.6003140211,
-0.3199498951,
0.3559045792,
0.3046424687,
0.4304619133,
-0.7786916494,
-0.4294012487,
-0.4619341195,
-0.5022409558,
0.4837730229,
0.1346513629,
0.1309447885,
-0.171822831,
0.6410909295,
0.1049899086,
0.2029801309,
-0.3932668567,
-0.2503907382,
0.6291906834,
-0.234981969,
0.0747041926,
-0.4383980036,
-0.4802402854,
-0.1752970517,
0.1696285456,
0.0848105177,
0.1939323097,
0.4721879959,
0.2939620316,
-0.2196834087,
0.375723362,
0.7124912739,
1.1046248674,
0.162384823,
0.2268972397,
0.301607877,
-0.2078048587,
0.130251646,
0.0834138021,
0.1445286125,
0.1484730393,
0.4948594272,
0.3828071058,
0.0420993455,
-0.920930624,
0.5508170128,
-0.3243586719,
-0.1766408235,
0.0353231058,
0.0961023495,
0.1505779475,
0.6415040493,
0.1835724115,
0.2583326101,
0.0149001898,
-0.2256626487,
0.0540425479,
0.5890689492,
-0.2428067774,
-0.0571159981,
0.7853580117,
0.4269974828,
-0.4674088061,
0.4470428228,
0.2996141613,
-0.6095500588,
0.5080991387,
0.5017552972,
0.2743582129,
-0.3402298391,
0.047115311,
0.1232531816,
0.0678254887,
-0.1956343949,
0.3141427636,
0.0501654372,
-0.6255434752,
-0.6796094179,
-0.0631525442,
-0.8445868492,
0.0093667693,
-0.5281077027,
0.1228461489,
-0.4401898086,
-0.7407799363,
0.2456920892,
-0.2506493926,
-0.6121167541,
0.0564970113,
0.1014470086,
0.8888704777,
-0.5247772932,
0.5662875175,
1.0692024231,
-0.2505797148,
-0.978161335,
-0.0596242137,
0.1840837449,
-0.8496378064,
0.5487362742,
-0.0349162184,
-0.1247278601,
-0.3315234184,
-0.639097929,
-0.5499136448,
1.0083799362,
0.3371632099,
-0.5314175487,
-0.0114000272,
0.0483590811,
0.6461825967,
-0.1006142125,
0.244574964,
0.4544000328,
0.3410105109,
0.1730537266,
-1.2955166101,
0.0672012791,
-0.2411575615,
0.0390626974,
0.2277786136,
-0.4668299258,
0.6661209464,
-0.6018042564,
0.0116393585,
0.4270459712,
0.2456459403,
0.4796730876,
0.3921555877,
0.5304529071,
0.3608602583,
1.0022650957,
0.0196318422,
1.2344220877,
-0.3624701202,
0.048645366,
0.9027852416,
-0.4380903542,
0.80970788,
0.7794767618,
-0.183148101,
0.09755449,
0.8179873824,
0.0562617444,
0.2164906561,
0.1211677119,
-0.4900853634,
-0.3687119782,
-0.3446429372,
-0.5203509331,
0.0679188818,
0.476293087,
-0.4330913424,
0.1002269387,
-0.0664333776,
0.2990394831,
0.0140185971,
-0.2670044005,
0.7985451221,
0.312160641,
-0.8305786252,
0.3974376321,
-0.0564740933,
0.4615954459,
-0.4427022338,
-0.2440127134,
-0.1302530766,
-0.0674405769,
-0.4436543584,
-1.0579226017,
-0.2530469298,
0.0983527228,
-0.1391540468,
-0.0271986667,
0.793215394,
-0.4414303005,
-0.3221085668,
0.0386348255,
0.953032434,
0.0586182103,
0.2851781845,
-0.5007064342,
0.2222949117,
-0.0816633776,
-0.1057555228,
0.1646047235,
0.1899037361,
0.1581247002,
0.900305748,
0.652232945,
0.4684858024,
-0.0927131474,
0.2257442921,
0.8637215495,
-0.4178892672,
-0.1226400584,
-0.9104859829,
0.3636268377,
-0.1607277095,
-0.0081279064,
0.5600172877,
0.1537656039,
0.5036545992,
-0.0023585078,
0.7458814979,
0.1597607881,
0.4871469736,
-0.6970022321,
0.4738688469,
-0.508462429,
0.506162405,
-0.0403464623,
-0.7215203643,
-0.4006170332,
0.5519924164,
-0.3516978323,
0.236373499,
0.627282083,
0.6751151681,
0.0227706209,
-0.067909956,
0.3023263812,
0.2413500696,
0.4869154692,
0.4709456265,
1.1986131668,
0.1238692477,
0.1887111068,
-0.0412473865,
-0.3793591261,
-0.239443928,
-0.6219325662,
-1.0325427055,
-0.2525188923,
-0.2098888904,
-0.4357562065,
0.0797017962,
1.3903198242,
0.4744983912,
-0.280501008,
-0.166224122,
0.3008807302,
-0.0201497171,
-0.0627239943,
-0.0870666429,
0.2089489698,
-0.3168729544,
-0.6749571562,
0.4282197356,
0.3293758333,
0.3156412244,
0.0937535614,
-0.1814941168,
0.2634466588,
0.2367041707,
0.6491991878,
0.0642144904,
-0.8812823296,
-0.2169426233,
0.155670464,
-0.3758613765,
0.0943008736,
1.0067030191,
-0.5730935335,
0.6175790429,
0.1798392236,
0.8917704821,
-0.129561469,
0.1843889207,
0.7293509841,
-0.3529280424,
-0.3299427032,
0.1724979579,
0.5299263597,
0.3061161339,
-0.507673502,
0.4285844266,
-0.0637146086,
-0.7746844292,
-0.5943371654,
0.2452769279,
-1.0199021101,
-0.3063696325,
1.4916262627,
0.0980386883,
0.1321489811,
-0.1889837235,
-0.948313117,
0.0372795649,
-0.2754053473,
0.6641121507,
0.7531606555,
-0.7074674368,
-0.1657605618,
-0.7760763168,
0.5460038781,
0.64329952,
-0.7979972363,
-0.1595638841,
0.6469219923,
0.4275762737,
-0.066331692,
0.9114747047,
-0.135812059,
0.4555632472,
-0.4916218519,
-0.3204062283,
-0.0469537862,
-0.1482677311,
-0.6075995564,
-0.2757717073,
0.8093321323,
-0.0549828596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20284v1
|
LayerNorm: A key component in parameter-efficient fine-tuning
| 2024-03-29T16:53:11 | 2024-03-29T16:53:11 |
Taha ValizadehAslani, Hualou Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning a pre-trained model, such as Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT), has been proven to be an effective
method for solving many natural language processing (NLP) tasks. However, due
to the large number of parameters in many state-of-the-art NLP models,
including BERT, the process of fine-tuning is computationally expensive. One
attractive solution to this issue is parameter-efficient fine-tuning, which
involves modifying only a minimal segment of the model while keeping the
remainder unchanged. Yet, it remains unclear which segment of the BERT model is
crucial for fine-tuning. In this paper, we first analyze different components
in the BERT model to pinpoint which one undergoes the most significant changes
after fine-tuning. We find that output LayerNorm changes more than any other
components when fine-tuned for different General Language Understanding
Evaluation (GLUE) tasks. Then we show that only fine-tuning the LayerNorm can
reach comparable, or in some cases better, performance to full fine-tuning and
other parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. Moreover, we use Fisher
information to determine the most critical subset of LayerNorm and demonstrate
that many NLP tasks in the GLUE benchmark can be solved by fine-tuning only a
small portion of LayerNorm with negligible performance degradation.
|
[
-0.7453240752,
-0.7457783818,
0.2816143632,
0.2450626194,
-0.4229449332,
-0.2135997415,
-0.5525025725,
-0.5744732022,
-0.2589680552,
0.6821551323,
-0.7285426855,
-0.3832241595,
-0.6111527085,
-0.2218507975,
-0.2434594482,
1.0385348797,
0.0882093459,
-0.1608101279,
-0.157460019,
-0.0538619384,
-0.198188141,
-0.2033516765,
-0.8896571994,
-0.5552902818,
0.7164928317,
0.4059389234,
0.7164691687,
0.7407536507,
0.6213445067,
0.2526896894,
-0.2944685519,
0.4608007073,
-0.5437099338,
0.1764888763,
-0.2046852112,
-0.5002797246,
-0.3571476936,
0.0499210134,
0.5839636326,
0.9628612399,
0.1282665133,
0.4265302718,
0.440508306,
1.0111693144,
-0.536704123,
0.0618305393,
-0.9513364434,
-0.0376171917,
-0.0671813786,
-0.3181523681,
-0.2373730689,
-0.1288613826,
0.4098723531,
-0.2339042723,
0.3457839489,
-0.0510018729,
1.1171245575,
0.5831319094,
-0.1727808416,
0.0087807197,
-0.8926399946,
0.9511272311,
-0.912104845,
0.5553492904,
0.311417371,
-0.0136740254,
-0.2658649981,
-0.5257864594,
-0.3528263867,
-0.1535928249,
0.0594032221,
-0.0931307226,
0.0245757345,
0.3334569335,
0.0418877043,
0.2377537638,
-0.2751397192,
0.4949554503,
-0.3796082735,
-0.1737082154,
0.4067404866,
-0.0550270602,
0.2164861858,
-0.3354898989,
-0.5915123224,
-0.0950904042,
-0.4570228457,
0.2584991157,
0.4015154243,
0.5059041977,
0.1649377793,
0.3790695667,
-0.0388841443,
0.8254976869,
0.0085735517,
0.0253558196,
-0.1250344813,
-0.0744920149,
-0.4785843492,
0.1343616545,
0.444655478,
0.221503213,
0.4452291131,
-0.2468847334,
-0.2283862978,
-0.1818187386,
0.4549543858,
-0.7940033078,
-0.4205662608,
0.4268648326,
-0.4608322084,
-0.0742338523,
-0.1873920709,
-0.1513937116,
-0.0270763468,
-0.7617399096,
0.5074236393,
-0.7052579522,
0.0185865555,
0.375951767,
-0.1624434441,
0.3071328104,
0.4366301298,
-0.8456972241,
0.199743852,
1.1305594444,
0.7121346593,
-0.1621992886,
-0.2730800211,
-0.4074859023,
0.1526662111,
-0.4308509529,
0.6391342878,
-0.5547558069,
0.2341558486,
-0.1788973808,
-0.1333562583,
-0.3457532823,
-0.8324522972,
0.7901453972,
-0.5032229424,
0.1383009553,
-0.3556129634,
-0.7517813444,
-0.3056274951,
0.0765658841,
-0.5674431324,
0.9711947441,
0.0317504741,
-0.5883480906,
0.4304483831,
-0.464086026,
-0.4317185879,
-0.0653280988,
0.2233293951,
-0.4527615905,
0.3727035522,
0.4071345031,
0.8136864901,
-0.1775545627,
-0.0122426655,
-0.1647882462,
-0.3940530121,
-0.0394877456,
-0.2575161159,
0.8538112044,
0.0301598124,
-0.2381695509,
-0.0173629262,
-0.8725480437,
0.0912506133,
-0.2090408057,
-0.485648334,
-0.4935986698,
0.1464584023,
-0.0700304881,
0.0642964393,
0.3697037399,
-0.5569317341,
-0.0214256048,
-0.4674421549,
0.4715763628,
0.9400296211,
0.060499467,
0.5725829005,
-0.2864928246,
0.1526153982,
0.2253043056,
0.2113001049,
0.0840691999,
-0.5931273103,
-1.1878653765,
-0.2736342847,
0.5733318329,
0.2415267378,
-0.4206822813,
0.4567094445,
0.2323986143,
-0.5763685107,
-0.8664478064,
0.4658423662,
0.3090327084,
0.5816690922,
0.5042567253,
-0.1914378405,
-0.5049273372,
-1.299182415,
-0.5647473335,
-0.041640453,
-0.2105073333,
0.3575834036,
0.0811352134,
-0.360342294,
0.769279182,
-0.234093979,
-0.5590872169,
-0.2194417417,
0.291695863,
0.3795317411,
0.810970664,
0.569881618,
-0.3931279778,
-0.4806425571,
-0.0266536754,
-0.1917741746,
-0.1448139697,
-0.4111793637,
-0.3302944601,
0.1018041968,
0.5158017874,
-0.6107178926,
-0.0189449023,
0.6213607192,
0.0474660881,
0.331946671,
-0.5949679017,
-0.2543692887,
-0.4907161891,
-0.1950337142,
0.0812797397,
-0.1601747125,
-0.682328105,
0.3595454395,
0.1409348696,
0.1068548486,
-0.324295938,
0.0343528315,
-0.4811330438,
0.2264414281,
-0.0056031784,
0.2265240401,
0.0997791961,
0.7661773562,
-0.3075988591,
0.6562295556,
0.3495257795,
-0.8608877659,
-0.0638421848,
-0.0360184163,
-0.5909158587,
0.1615284979,
-0.8644620776,
0.3596611917,
-0.3786216974,
-0.2752970457,
-0.8649502397,
0.1368617862,
-0.0812937096,
-0.0361477882,
0.508125782,
-0.1602209359,
-0.5156105161,
-0.0867115781,
-0.3867402375,
0.0393995158,
0.5396620035,
-0.6545468569,
0.5877020359,
0.3321962059,
0.0263593085,
-0.3409709632,
-0.5557216406,
-0.1708646268,
-0.0442016274,
-0.8489878774,
0.6836767793,
-0.0507739782,
0.1832420528,
-0.183425948,
-0.298015058,
-0.0114740487,
0.253035605,
0.0598452203,
-0.0640368834,
-0.4191862345,
-0.1249186024,
0.3710559309,
-0.2867074311,
0.2402759939,
-0.2100085616,
0.6973135471,
-0.2447413802,
-0.2229178548,
-0.4900405407,
0.0280058011,
0.3696303368,
-0.2955685556,
0.7889541984,
0.8864924908,
-0.2776542008,
-0.7644857764,
-0.6903668642,
-0.1416705698,
-0.5248021483,
0.4325226843,
-0.264908433,
-0.9027873278,
0.6626111865,
-0.1406978965,
0.0601149052,
0.4830978513,
0.3369489908,
-0.5066186786,
1.1170947552,
0.6045247912,
-0.1209371611,
0.3120230436,
-0.3685756028,
0.3154543638,
-1.1880463362,
-0.221996516,
-0.667576313,
-0.8464024663,
-0.6406793594,
-0.4951470792,
0.3149598241,
0.5103555918,
-0.1070545316,
0.5631070733,
-0.5736920238,
0.6428912282,
0.870093286,
0.2363305688,
0.1083253101,
-0.0754214302,
-0.2525120676,
-0.1557923406,
-0.827069521,
-0.5160665512,
0.671292007,
0.5488805175,
0.5111768246,
0.0966449454,
0.6810073256,
-0.0461194254,
-0.5435144901,
-0.6335362792,
0.737569809,
-0.7329384685,
-0.4443537295,
-0.2581485212,
-0.2458157986,
-0.9481991529,
0.1224972978,
-0.1003165916,
-0.6871646643,
0.4688743353,
0.2252848595,
-0.4585611224,
0.3957107663,
-0.832197547,
0.7182094455,
0.0832183436,
-0.2478165776,
-0.3348175585,
-0.5798587203,
0.1756285876,
0.0681699589,
-0.3894820213,
-0.4257259369,
0.0183470398,
0.6699656844,
-0.1765312999,
0.6973142624,
-0.3267980814,
-0.2259747237,
-0.0230000783,
0.1943781823,
0.381116569,
0.1535498798,
-0.123957783,
0.2696900368,
0.0715194792,
-0.372400105,
-0.5370970368,
0.8510634899,
-0.9997982979,
-0.6967899799,
0.0064889989,
-0.536339581,
-0.3246118724,
-0.0396836698,
0.054953713,
0.5230791569,
0.1173090413,
0.7019594312,
1.0423983335,
-0.4132195115,
0.4891786277,
0.2493000925,
0.0466325954,
0.3032912612,
0.9296352863,
0.2460732758,
0.2982222736,
0.5316890478,
0.2192343324,
0.0260751173,
-0.7998764515,
-0.1862887889,
0.0934885517,
-0.5387520194,
-0.2423477769,
-0.6115861535,
-0.6686424613,
0.089293316,
-0.1263834834,
-0.6506721377,
-0.5639879107,
-0.578717351,
0.1183617413,
0.1478312314,
0.421040386,
-0.1021146178,
0.173802942,
-0.6765889525,
0.5658737421,
0.7133511305,
0.6759082079,
0.1537635326,
-0.4957651496,
-0.256391108,
0.1812799275,
-0.0507030115,
-0.2214234471,
0.1183309257,
0.706604898,
0.560919404,
0.5498610139,
0.0289988816,
1.006455183,
-0.5715663433,
0.9004170299,
-0.3664017916,
-0.9086480737,
0.5875308514,
-0.2410366237,
0.417762965,
0.5683557987,
0.1371194422,
-0.1587977409,
-0.586291194,
-0.4604967833,
-0.9913834333,
0.7393912077,
0.2531530559,
0.3986822069,
0.1853125542,
0.4040552676,
0.2140993178,
0.0405579731,
-0.1852162629,
-0.2472196072,
0.0722737312,
0.0736517832,
-0.0080872141,
-0.5718516111,
0.013056946,
-0.6853761673,
0.6730110049,
0.0582008548,
0.2079267055,
0.1421000957,
-0.3028872907,
-0.2064959258,
0.1703969538,
0.6738390923,
0.6758872271,
-0.8369222879,
0.3086708188,
0.0931277871,
-0.3923277557,
-0.4282488227,
-0.008093087,
-0.27362746,
0.1370082647,
0.5090322495,
1.0195100307,
0.4623893499,
-0.4056353867,
0.2088064849,
0.1153917015,
-0.2671709061,
-0.0461148173,
0.6815307736,
0.0660461709,
0.408890754,
0.4552157223,
0.4623880386,
0.0655593202,
-0.3795052767,
0.1275702417,
0.5658940673,
-0.4701634943,
-0.2651868761,
0.7247724533,
0.0779120997,
-0.3777419925,
0.6711748242,
0.0144553417,
-0.5681359768,
0.6130303144,
0.347964853,
0.9539034963,
-0.0324016809,
0.3492653966,
0.1132692173,
0.6003639102,
0.2139993012,
0.1948427707,
-0.0521629974,
-0.8665777445,
-0.4550883472,
-0.8856809139,
-0.2141599506,
0.1798165292,
-0.8469228745,
0.108911708,
-0.7466605902,
-0.0631086156,
0.2636495233,
0.0465772413,
-0.9688603878,
0.2431970984,
0.1914836466,
0.9893148541,
-0.3789362013,
0.8935251236,
0.4581363499,
-0.0694530681,
-0.7196467519,
-0.0822402164,
-0.4166229367,
-0.9080546498,
0.5767489672,
-0.0172710642,
-0.1857842207,
0.0496403389,
-0.591748178,
-0.7472016811,
0.7012068033,
0.7041577697,
-0.7020039558,
0.0242743474,
0.365204066,
0.7566615939,
-0.2445438802,
0.0982757434,
0.8377637267,
0.3155433834,
-0.2595511079,
-0.8357075453,
-0.2182328254,
-0.004688614,
0.5740448236,
0.2562818229,
-0.6607249379,
1.0357294083,
-0.0670128167,
-0.1648836583,
-0.2020937204,
0.5921845436,
-0.0361621529,
-0.2271496505,
0.6702800393,
0.5037148595,
0.5964797139,
-0.2221813351,
0.7710521221,
-0.5765652657,
0.257227391,
1.1577479839,
0.1772832423,
1.1054054499,
0.6615464687,
-0.0721344724,
0.5877062678,
0.4190927446,
0.0620068647,
0.5867407322,
0.0024148177,
0.2151351124,
-0.4296831191,
0.0113561098,
-0.2839444876,
0.559591651,
0.1980371922,
-0.3780667484,
-0.1819903105,
-0.1595612168,
-0.1957561672,
-0.0644564629,
-0.3253955841,
0.9774177074,
0.1350069493,
-0.403365165,
0.8109536171,
0.1713183671,
0.566744864,
-0.6578158736,
0.1463869065,
-0.1903882325,
0.4559937716,
-0.2142739594,
-0.655834198,
0.2791058123,
-0.3379440904,
-0.3072471917,
-0.4700474739,
0.8269579411,
-0.5701552033,
-0.4105046093,
0.464150697,
0.2433832884,
-0.1998130977,
-0.2337245047,
-0.8204205036,
0.0636352375,
0.0505655929,
-0.4104356468,
0.3633391559,
0.4678126872,
0.4880928397,
0.6653341651,
0.7406979799,
0.314504534,
0.2870553136,
0.4043775797,
0.9215040803,
-0.5536493659,
-0.2890915871,
-0.7341762185,
0.6572341323,
-0.1115733162,
-0.4427165091,
0.7433240414,
0.3676844239,
1.026422143,
-0.1210108399,
0.2672874331,
0.3911426365,
0.6481426358,
-0.726061523,
0.799464345,
-0.5125510097,
0.5372300744,
-0.4189246893,
-1.2806977034,
-0.1807781607,
0.703373313,
0.0267044026,
-0.157559678,
0.463822037,
0.6928859949,
-0.2511886656,
0.2911063731,
0.1032972932,
0.417542696,
0.1610607356,
0.4549311101,
0.5591151714,
-0.6274588704,
0.1373325735,
-0.7527936697,
0.1610922664,
-0.088397041,
-0.9212530851,
-1.0634655952,
-0.6246401072,
-0.5079607964,
0.0305462796,
-0.0281647258,
0.9314617515,
0.8713614345,
-1.0983812809,
-0.1241035759,
0.0061018304,
0.0609451495,
-0.47780478,
-0.2284024954,
0.341997236,
-0.7758793235,
-0.7250455618,
0.302444607,
0.585037291,
-0.325699389,
-0.4713071585,
0.118756339,
-0.254032135,
0.2356108576,
0.8477044106,
-0.2269652337,
-0.8935444951,
-0.5517250896,
-0.178432256,
0.1014032066,
0.1180818379,
0.6441123486,
-0.6374951005,
0.5813096166,
0.4378541112,
0.9193262458,
0.6518285871,
-0.0379957519,
0.6822431087,
-1.0727225542,
0.1519617736,
0.3273331523,
0.1852756441,
0.1877196282,
-0.2812612057,
0.330327481,
-0.3074284494,
-0.6308555007,
-0.9140591621,
-0.0494952612,
-1.0948038101,
-0.3475788534,
0.9257810116,
0.2215525657,
-0.2305364162,
-0.0245382581,
-0.219076395,
0.0767123625,
-0.22900033,
0.7581839561,
0.6410964131,
-0.1327180117,
-0.5238177776,
-0.4169065952,
0.8084884882,
0.6812499762,
-0.3552703261,
-0.116349645,
-0.1195427477,
0.0717864782,
0.1221008822,
-0.0252029058,
0.3555788994,
-0.2134451717,
-0.4660821259,
-0.4386155605,
-0.1128106192,
-0.5056151152,
-0.0639362931,
0.3128543496,
0.0912843645,
-0.189344123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20279v1
|
LUQ: Long-text Uncertainty Quantification for LLMs
| 2024-03-29T16:49:24 | 2024-03-29T16:49:24 |
Caiqi Zhang, Fangyu Liu, Marco Basaldella, Nigel Collier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capability in a
variety of NLP tasks. Despite their effectiveness, these models are prone to
generate nonfactual content. Uncertainty Quantification (UQ) is pivotal in
enhancing our understanding of a model's confidence in its generated content,
thereby aiding in the mitigation of nonfactual outputs. Existing research on UQ
predominantly targets short text generation, typically yielding brief,
word-limited responses. However, real-world applications frequently necessitate
much longer responses. Our study first highlights the limitations of current UQ
methods in handling long text generation. We then introduce \textsc{Luq}, a
novel sampling-based UQ approach specifically designed for long text. Our
findings reveal that \textsc{Luq} outperforms existing baseline methods in
correlating with the model's factuality scores (negative coefficient of -0.85
observed for Gemini Pro). With \textsc{Luq} as the tool for UQ, we investigate
behavior patterns of several popular LLMs' response confidence spectrum and how
that interplays with the response' factuality. We identify that LLMs lack
confidence in generating long text for rare facts and a factually strong model
(i.e. GPT-4) tends to reject questions it is not sure about. To further improve
the factual accuracy of LLM responses, we propose a method called
\textsc{Luq-Ensemble} that ensembles responses from multiple models and selects
the response with the least uncertainty. The ensembling method greatly improves
the response factuality upon the best standalone LLM.
|
[
-0.182680428,
-0.9366025329,
0.8503894806,
0.1871793866,
-0.2215738446,
0.2262762636,
-0.1280353814,
-0.5728851557,
0.2447451204,
0.3737077713,
-0.4340696633,
-0.4925492406,
-0.4798665643,
0.0866395235,
-0.7288029194,
1.0025732517,
0.1016169563,
-0.2878795564,
-0.3878163397,
-0.0539598018,
0.0001459773,
-0.5120723248,
-0.4982698262,
-0.2632570565,
0.603441,
0.152984485,
0.8948773146,
0.1315101534,
0.5363621712,
0.2040835023,
-0.112997219,
0.1935902983,
-0.4796515405,
0.2096223533,
0.0531811975,
-0.5224317312,
-0.6025738716,
-0.117332153,
0.6591191888,
0.6520473361,
-0.2808619738,
0.208934918,
0.1121426746,
0.7393128872,
-0.8950865269,
-0.2325399965,
-0.6405459046,
0.1043831185,
-0.3013885021,
0.1054576784,
-0.3936700821,
-0.2758584321,
0.0294689555,
-0.6211017966,
0.0815091208,
0.3261412382,
0.8028701544,
0.3028996885,
-0.6306025386,
-0.2111395895,
-1.062253356,
1.0105837584,
-0.9598124027,
0.1917981952,
0.375559926,
0.0042706947,
-0.1341088116,
-0.8180045485,
-0.7236152887,
-0.1264280379,
0.0929102376,
0.4663206041,
-0.1101686135,
0.1675887108,
0.1376192421,
0.4274324477,
-0.6459510922,
0.1278724223,
-0.1931802183,
-0.399971962,
0.7250400782,
0.1671973318,
-0.1415956318,
-0.2360672355,
-0.4500056803,
0.005103121,
-0.7751160264,
0.1305738837,
0.4325815737,
-0.1545877606,
0.1846698821,
0.7461764216,
-0.2480311841,
0.5958800316,
0.0300141945,
-0.3301279545,
-0.0621666908,
-0.3356413841,
-0.4553735554,
0.0078156469,
1.0360805988,
0.2335124016,
-0.1432051212,
0.0988771096,
-0.4895292222,
-0.0614344552,
0.0417127945,
-0.649291575,
0.0582938157,
0.6402164102,
-0.2138242126,
-0.369767338,
0.1483959705,
-0.769117713,
-0.3144703209,
-0.1129457355,
0.6429504752,
-0.4499908984,
-0.0632480606,
0.0227295179,
0.1428685188,
0.1216282547,
0.3701279163,
-0.6423309445,
0.1512529403,
0.5153311491,
0.5113735199,
-0.3475799859,
-0.0613474064,
-0.497612536,
0.14219594,
-0.5691839457,
0.5445236564,
-0.2861526608,
-0.5150089264,
0.0512227453,
-0.3108062446,
0.0748375803,
-0.3243122399,
0.7734857202,
-0.6438707113,
0.3420162499,
-0.0882486701,
-0.8853676319,
0.1270402968,
0.2868064046,
-0.6720644832,
1.364405632,
0.1157922521,
-0.9360377789,
0.2535916567,
-0.3283290565,
-0.1657660306,
0.11818064,
-0.2715553939,
-0.4604089558,
0.2965599,
0.2835047543,
0.4976831675,
-0.2838099301,
0.2551842034,
-0.2693112195,
-0.4686820507,
0.7557013631,
-0.5927103162,
0.2616713643,
0.3632099032,
-0.0861620978,
0.0017610257,
-0.7090093493,
0.2824904025,
-0.0541135408,
-0.3729061186,
-0.2358814776,
0.0351187736,
-0.061553292,
-0.0587171577,
0.423532784,
-0.5343674421,
-0.0392632633,
-0.5265454054,
0.2917793095,
0.5693151951,
0.0791793689,
0.4347242117,
-0.3113352358,
0.4928190708,
-0.0743191093,
0.2116918713,
0.0463140383,
-0.5747421384,
-0.7456859946,
-0.1314638108,
0.4952102304,
0.6129637957,
-0.9110212922,
0.5361934304,
-0.2444824129,
-0.3893190622,
-0.4031324685,
0.0733370706,
0.1831436306,
0.4138809741,
0.2203184068,
0.0267310068,
-0.3515134752,
-0.7527034283,
-0.2286968082,
-0.2968990505,
-0.2781375647,
0.0202195514,
0.5789366364,
-0.1958111972,
1.1197351217,
-0.5068174601,
0.1898981035,
-0.073091194,
0.4361149073,
0.4492628574,
0.1088387594,
0.3873733878,
-0.7776317596,
-0.3879105151,
-0.3059423268,
-0.7099886537,
0.2491730899,
-0.2423250079,
-0.0456587076,
0.48822698,
0.3991207182,
-0.9564510584,
0.5564442873,
0.6881230474,
-0.0268688798,
0.5616039038,
-0.194076851,
0.1888593435,
-1.0964503288,
0.0075584711,
-0.1110873818,
-0.1922247857,
-0.40908885,
0.0409579501,
0.1881539822,
0.1044156551,
-0.3824636638,
0.4001300335,
-0.2605811059,
-0.1447317153,
-0.2437132895,
0.2057400644,
0.1037488952,
0.1531635672,
-0.0062195281,
0.67944175,
0.3252970278,
-0.6622761488,
0.5480771661,
-0.0995038599,
-0.559317112,
0.544192493,
-0.7168713808,
0.1921934336,
-0.1489626169,
0.2601009309,
-1.0145866871,
-0.5030322075,
0.0576050691,
-0.5576500893,
0.2297340482,
0.0650854781,
-0.5113644004,
-0.5703888535,
-0.4000076652,
0.2430081218,
0.6215804219,
-0.2492741942,
0.528467834,
-0.018535139,
-0.2069820911,
-0.907768786,
-0.6855717897,
0.0593897887,
-0.2790074348,
-0.7650492191,
0.4263633192,
-0.3565479517,
-0.4493870735,
-0.233999297,
-0.3503818214,
-0.0835478529,
0.1262246817,
0.1133049726,
0.2425888777,
-0.1532993764,
0.4702451527,
0.1202797294,
0.1015508175,
0.0884282887,
-0.2088301629,
0.3010639846,
-0.0984574035,
-0.5418109894,
-0.1767842025,
0.2465531826,
0.3582045734,
-0.0742835552,
0.6985872388,
0.8690902591,
-0.3419116139,
-0.2337819636,
-0.4619065225,
-0.2662859559,
-0.4550474882,
0.2524678707,
-0.0838532597,
-1.0128135681,
0.4418234229,
0.1521298587,
0.0364312343,
0.5539718866,
0.47560817,
-0.5300602317,
0.800175488,
0.5484424233,
-0.1551401168,
0.0536866523,
0.1612008512,
0.2477129847,
-0.4580624402,
0.0464795642,
-0.3955604434,
-0.1430176795,
-0.5033292174,
-0.587475419,
0.525419116,
0.2012357563,
-0.1585773528,
-0.2606724799,
-0.2478260547,
0.3532409668,
0.5589752793,
0.1094807833,
0.4174817801,
0.0140752327,
0.1155266017,
-0.1928136498,
-0.403263092,
-0.4542353749,
1.2487466335,
0.3923444152,
1.0825786591,
0.369841814,
0.7516611814,
0.316146791,
0.1525182128,
-0.8265814185,
0.443946749,
0.1586330533,
-0.6225837469,
-0.6354107857,
-0.6325992346,
-0.9266830087,
-0.0614391267,
-0.545527935,
-0.6161510348,
-0.1263059229,
0.1756523848,
-0.9348633885,
0.1897580773,
-0.2706736028,
0.204701215,
-0.2828601003,
-0.3160656989,
0.0647950023,
-0.8437499404,
0.5242592096,
-0.5233032107,
0.3435339332,
-0.1219961047,
-0.1984440386,
0.5626530647,
-0.2548873425,
0.8220344782,
0.2880036235,
-0.5401543975,
0.5462756753,
0.1732180864,
0.8795173168,
0.5180150867,
-0.1144151166,
-0.1340238005,
0.0628663227,
-0.4282697439,
-0.5041496158,
0.6069657803,
-0.7381809354,
-0.367705524,
-0.5107665658,
-0.4840948284,
-0.3260973692,
-0.103340365,
0.7305620313,
0.1705653667,
-0.2006708384,
0.2412255853,
0.9955337644,
-0.4221411049,
0.5926036835,
0.3595073223,
-0.3806878328,
-0.3452701271,
0.5261598229,
-0.0182600953,
0.3930652738,
0.6260647774,
0.1230650917,
-0.4200391173,
-0.5821569562,
-0.1196404025,
0.0514031723,
-0.5754562616,
-0.2714883983,
-0.3518292606,
-0.3506692946,
-0.5570054054,
0.0682489797,
-0.4006796777,
-0.4720199704,
-0.2918499708,
-0.1930427104,
0.3523778617,
0.7724449039,
-0.008893827,
0.4530528188,
-1.0331110954,
0.2340665758,
0.5692740083,
-0.0018717996,
-0.4938870966,
-0.7285736203,
-0.2395150661,
0.2194724232,
-0.2188853323,
-0.9366451502,
0.5249714255,
0.3235135078,
0.4585324526,
0.3735248148,
0.4243711233,
0.268258512,
-0.08814504,
1.1134541035,
0.1320699304,
-0.9767124653,
0.5061004758,
-0.4577485025,
0.1550188214,
0.2897073925,
0.3727088571,
-0.4218192995,
-0.4408994615,
-0.7278968692,
-1.0926669836,
0.1968055665,
0.5819603801,
0.2200094014,
0.1009839401,
0.6517207026,
-0.1556033492,
0.443087399,
-0.9514729977,
-0.2478330135,
-0.091584757,
-0.4403686523,
-0.0944190174,
-0.5043905973,
-0.2600954771,
0.1094422638,
0.5663875937,
-0.3652488291,
0.3856551945,
0.3969002962,
-0.1069705784,
-0.2332234383,
0.4932917356,
0.6641660333,
0.6170131564,
-0.4939177632,
0.1392004192,
0.3318632543,
-0.3520535827,
-0.0633920953,
-0.1017914489,
-0.1871491969,
0.0616653524,
0.4354038537,
0.4884026945,
-0.0161660686,
-0.6527728438,
0.6096904278,
-0.0634048581,
-0.2974895239,
-0.5825429559,
-0.0309579615,
0.1401939243,
0.1096168384,
0.6082382202,
0.0003179617,
0.1378372461,
-0.405827105,
0.1596887708,
0.3392669261,
-0.3125419319,
-0.1289341599,
0.5155335069,
0.168263793,
0.1199097037,
0.7092441916,
-0.2567070127,
-0.1873215586,
0.6695709825,
0.3737623692,
0.3758023083,
-0.066553995,
0.3078211248,
0.4188580513,
0.3538164198,
-0.2454329282,
0.3721657991,
0.3392778933,
-0.921470046,
-0.7988376021,
-0.6387645602,
-0.5095034838,
0.2828403413,
-0.7905107737,
-0.0299799684,
-0.3710812926,
-0.4915275574,
-0.4344743788,
-0.049861975,
-0.3244475424,
0.3347043097,
0.3465732336,
0.7475982308,
-0.6865490675,
0.7951158285,
0.488350451,
-0.1250680834,
-0.8032165766,
0.1660133451,
0.0729741976,
-0.6828498244,
0.4774995148,
-0.094761759,
-0.0780566782,
-0.0287280474,
-1.0364053249,
-0.9732419848,
1.2275621891,
0.2874766588,
-0.7580599785,
0.0780796483,
0.3023636043,
0.4709839523,
-0.007085762,
0.2233398259,
0.4150072336,
0.4549625516,
0.2583192289,
-0.7325609326,
-0.06593889,
0.1889428496,
-0.0828792602,
0.2993327975,
-0.6288437843,
1.0175235271,
-0.2813994288,
-0.1935249865,
0.5005956888,
1.053871274,
0.4770924449,
0.3946922421,
0.3785689473,
0.5403091908,
1.2143498659,
-0.1458931565,
0.9405498505,
-0.3512283266,
0.5894489288,
1.1472256184,
-0.368193835,
1.0282117128,
0.6458613276,
-0.389939487,
0.3011499047,
0.7936399579,
0.0546408743,
0.0893523246,
0.3095711768,
-0.5991030931,
-0.4772391617,
0.1313508749,
-0.363144964,
0.2579089105,
0.6891690493,
-0.1746045798,
0.1113698706,
-0.2508919835,
0.1029780507,
-0.0069058612,
-0.2152224183,
0.4435527921,
0.2913361192,
-0.6238420606,
0.404047966,
0.1039335504,
0.9942840934,
-0.6806291342,
0.2657116055,
-0.4269086123,
0.0200017188,
-0.1940136105,
-0.9525487423,
0.0842748284,
-0.1697908938,
-0.0673095956,
0.0468644761,
0.7114058733,
-0.4045761228,
-0.6608536839,
0.014388972,
0.758264482,
0.1445833296,
-0.3287909031,
-0.6395193338,
-0.1872653812,
0.0388782062,
-0.436082691,
0.3116569221,
0.6515540481,
0.1370036602,
0.6880435944,
0.5212419629,
-0.0706359074,
-0.0375527814,
-0.1254524738,
0.3690018952,
-0.6705552936,
-0.0412952676,
-0.8496367335,
0.404746145,
-0.0907972082,
-0.3779425323,
0.8045776486,
0.4005399644,
0.4674211144,
-0.0970724672,
0.7814750075,
-0.012880072,
0.5749729276,
-0.8802983165,
0.5582028031,
-0.5938897729,
0.4311861098,
-0.1358623356,
-0.8564814329,
-0.2471295744,
0.4862678051,
0.1304815412,
0.0698710978,
0.8039106131,
0.7374101877,
0.2677571774,
-0.0924585313,
0.6097915769,
0.194752261,
0.1179154366,
0.6434213519,
1.1252807379,
-0.4741298556,
0.7599625587,
-0.2062437981,
0.0529687926,
-0.0994940773,
-1.0754545927,
-0.6527143121,
-0.3439709544,
-0.2259424627,
-0.5245052576,
-0.1293790936,
0.8718709946,
0.6346413493,
-0.5785574317,
-0.0724320486,
0.0861851573,
0.1196729317,
0.02379678,
-0.2146976441,
0.3699554503,
-0.2752372921,
-0.6775246263,
0.4306437969,
0.0831317008,
0.497269392,
-0.1975715607,
-0.059378393,
0.1349722296,
0.3773198128,
0.6160104871,
0.1240326464,
-0.657168448,
-0.3610649705,
0.2067356706,
-0.2715632021,
-0.0930445194,
0.4493562579,
-0.5897186399,
-0.0238112286,
0.3957099617,
0.3853042722,
0.5250464678,
-0.0262687225,
0.6431757808,
-1.2020632029,
-0.0572028011,
0.3577044606,
0.3391478062,
0.2357238233,
-0.5280485749,
0.5807107687,
0.273050487,
-0.7265039086,
-0.7146798968,
0.3973082602,
-1.1096605062,
-0.4114192724,
1.2963271141,
-0.0768490285,
-0.2055020332,
0.0533511713,
-0.0335309021,
0.0060686744,
-0.5589193106,
0.6263650656,
0.811894238,
-0.1216480732,
-0.1156569272,
-0.6503520012,
0.5630341768,
0.4942138195,
-0.901686132,
-0.1460677236,
0.4493618608,
0.1258042753,
0.297406435,
0.5178374052,
0.1714829206,
0.0462187454,
-0.1702385545,
0.1206373051,
0.517753005,
-0.120934017,
-0.0663529411,
0.2179404348,
0.2504334748,
0.1749645174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20266v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20266v1
|
Latxa: An Open Language Model and Evaluation Suite for Basque
| 2024-03-29T16:16:48 | 2024-03-29T16:16:48 |
Julen Etxaniz, Oscar Sainz, Naiara Perez, Itziar Aldabe, German Rigau, Eneko Agirre, Aitor Ormazabal, Mikel Artetxe, Aitor Soroa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce Latxa, a family of large language models for Basque ranging from
7 to 70 billion parameters. Latxa is based on Llama 2, which we continue
pretraining on a new Basque corpus comprising 4.3M documents and 4.2B tokens.
Addressing the scarcity of high-quality benchmarks for Basque, we further
introduce 4 multiple choice evaluation datasets: EusProficiency, comprising
5,169 questions from official language proficiency exams; EusReading,
comprising 352 reading comprehension questions; EusTrivia, comprising 1,715
trivia questions from 5 knowledge areas; and EusExams, comprising 16,774
questions from public examinations. In our extensive evaluation, Latxa
outperforms all previous open models we compare to by a large margin. In
addition, it is competitive with GPT-4 Turbo in language proficiency and
understanding, despite lagging behind in reading comprehension and
knowledge-intensive tasks. Both the Latxa family of models, as well as our new
pretraining corpora and evaluation datasets, are publicly available under open
licenses at https://github.com/hitz-zentroa/latxa. Our suite enables
reproducible research on methods to build LLMs for low-resource languages.
|
[
-0.1497070938,
-0.6920863986,
0.7202761173,
0.2944281995,
-0.0429625697,
0.3039741516,
-0.3760280609,
-0.4560517967,
-0.0201737229,
0.8187866211,
-0.1855205595,
-0.5081849098,
-0.4850617051,
0.0012992925,
-0.6118798256,
0.8156716824,
-0.3848379552,
-0.0265702792,
0.0690739155,
-0.2091638446,
-0.320109576,
-0.4441944659,
-0.7927317619,
-0.4146537781,
0.6458255053,
0.6262301803,
0.7254413366,
0.2789594233,
0.0350603089,
0.2699924707,
0.0032123774,
-0.1891139597,
-0.7159320116,
-0.0306501929,
0.0191546213,
-0.844446063,
-0.3263065219,
-0.1870260686,
0.7465570569,
0.4845763147,
-0.2234769613,
0.2410517633,
-0.0924010426,
0.5302560925,
-0.5726730227,
-0.1398344934,
-0.5647047162,
-0.0500193425,
-0.4440195858,
0.1786533892,
-0.3230780959,
-0.7428497672,
0.049471397,
-0.3243328035,
-0.1065285504,
-0.164601773,
0.6493750811,
0.4614577889,
-0.3329274356,
-0.1387209147,
-0.57433635,
0.8925178647,
-0.4645650089,
0.6588503122,
0.5072155595,
0.3609178066,
-0.1255711615,
-0.7971444726,
-0.4425885975,
-0.3346226215,
0.4732768834,
0.2237313986,
-0.4214307964,
-0.1530348212,
0.0031278175,
0.1757760942,
-0.6696923971,
0.4776376188,
-0.7240224481,
-0.0119699314,
0.4139831364,
0.0721870586,
0.2692705691,
0.3554567993,
-0.3890274763,
-0.1751645505,
-1.0006219149,
0.0785199851,
0.5787575245,
0.0778805763,
-0.1869751215,
0.5238388181,
-0.0683937371,
0.6812059879,
-0.3604481518,
-0.0382207558,
0.3756922781,
-0.0948866457,
-0.1712376773,
-0.0949226022,
0.9090900421,
0.0155631853,
0.2249436527,
-0.3518401384,
-0.0737066269,
0.1782305539,
0.1805715561,
-0.3941205442,
0.2055294812,
0.7088597417,
-0.2035935521,
-0.1404899955,
-0.3359688818,
-0.9839823246,
-0.1417513192,
-0.1761624813,
0.443856746,
-0.2858554721,
-0.3144892752,
0.6954732537,
0.0312728696,
0.2425426543,
0.5439005494,
-0.5114997625,
0.5161609054,
0.487434566,
0.7238102555,
-0.4487356544,
-0.5195153952,
-0.4943835437,
-0.3390576243,
-0.2138976604,
1.0620727539,
-0.5804265738,
-0.3958700001,
-0.1410560608,
-0.1309138387,
-0.1578502506,
-0.5408263206,
0.8367506862,
-0.5855717063,
0.2816566527,
0.029544834,
-0.1900977194,
-0.0786494464,
0.0190003272,
-0.9127374887,
1.6973460913,
0.429376334,
-0.4554770589,
-0.1589196771,
-0.7599386573,
0.3299319446,
0.0255456306,
-0.0890001953,
-0.1019061208,
0.0586178377,
-0.0040810318,
0.2514716685,
-0.7588776946,
0.150519684,
-0.1388479471,
-0.3369286656,
0.1257034242,
-0.1486086696,
0.8642655015,
0.4443216026,
-0.2259992659,
0.2002571523,
-0.812820673,
0.3968291581,
0.0371260867,
-0.4189353287,
-0.2334833443,
-0.2648766935,
0.157280162,
0.2594418824,
0.3655949533,
-0.6234238148,
0.0109716589,
-0.4457238019,
0.3859632909,
0.7186900973,
-0.3184750676,
0.2258117348,
0.0137018487,
0.940249145,
-0.393609345,
0.1758703589,
0.1371752173,
-0.5520188212,
-0.6860895753,
-0.1635969281,
0.5385439396,
0.652071178,
-0.5180782676,
0.3069718778,
-0.191212371,
-0.6728528142,
-0.575869441,
-0.0074532903,
0.4996259809,
0.2296487093,
0.1686755866,
-0.1771475077,
-0.3266718686,
-0.9930706024,
-0.0362838767,
0.0102658859,
-0.0322219767,
-0.1115287691,
0.7420197129,
-0.248185724,
0.7513824701,
-0.395406723,
0.1714211702,
-0.4466703832,
0.0144444946,
0.3157731295,
0.0150356926,
0.7652206421,
-0.3209734857,
-0.578245461,
0.2223091125,
-0.2524986267,
-0.2473841608,
0.4967779815,
-0.1971971691,
0.0588067174,
0.2846038938,
-0.3591891229,
0.1762102693,
0.8344314098,
-0.5273573995,
0.549631834,
-0.0826448798,
0.0017189779,
-1.0550596714,
0.0715265945,
-0.3847251534,
-0.3069890738,
-0.5849397779,
0.1244502291,
0.0322697721,
-0.0834820196,
-0.811712563,
1.0124907494,
-0.1356390268,
-0.0828749612,
-0.053618297,
0.3266005814,
-0.1574900597,
0.4341425002,
0.0871302783,
0.8827813268,
0.501625061,
-0.3729092479,
0.3987905979,
0.2276590466,
-0.5779654384,
0.3021583259,
-0.8676677346,
0.3470321894,
-0.0721721053,
0.1036882624,
-0.614302814,
-0.0839138851,
0.0534190983,
-0.2218379974,
-0.2461646348,
0.1283144206,
-0.5987388492,
-0.3662266731,
-0.4259771407,
0.45038414,
0.4876070321,
-0.6616134644,
0.3317376673,
0.5194404721,
-0.2995793819,
-0.768322885,
-0.2793627381,
0.0003886691,
-0.3206193745,
-0.6275731325,
0.0460924692,
-0.2060945481,
-0.3936870396,
-0.0837804154,
0.0446208343,
-0.3576577008,
0.0837031752,
0.0109448638,
0.0063297949,
-0.1990449876,
0.2061735094,
-0.249779731,
-0.0442786701,
-0.2608118951,
-0.1142527685,
0.8724147081,
-0.3882305324,
-0.2346840799,
-0.0951206237,
0.2423537374,
0.4865401387,
-0.346421361,
0.538831234,
0.4370085001,
-0.3239496946,
-0.4456233084,
-0.5187771916,
0.2937153578,
-0.3922144175,
0.4933879673,
-0.3455061913,
-1.095308423,
0.7223539352,
-0.0686715692,
0.004996479,
0.5317940116,
0.8688129783,
0.2596545517,
0.5606125593,
0.4878364503,
-0.1423355341,
0.2858290672,
-0.2206399143,
-0.0476874337,
-0.5075101256,
-0.100855574,
-1.1082667112,
-0.0104332073,
-0.3048098385,
-0.7452605367,
0.4763821661,
0.2077020407,
-0.336212188,
0.4037642479,
-0.2217192054,
0.8078073859,
0.6406559944,
-0.0129411835,
0.3606585562,
0.0652052462,
-0.2603132129,
0.0623778217,
-0.698279798,
-0.7849107981,
1.664437294,
0.6531027555,
0.8188215494,
0.2175244242,
0.6914491653,
0.1323844045,
0.2299205065,
-0.7237169147,
0.3968729675,
-0.035535492,
-0.5022377372,
-0.3080252409,
-0.2806224525,
-1.1032015085,
0.1033040658,
-0.0240624882,
-1.071472168,
0.0148315895,
-0.1228104606,
-0.5237681866,
0.2674071789,
-0.7282650471,
0.8977089524,
-0.6286889315,
-0.532581985,
-0.24582389,
-0.2776445746,
0.4789358079,
-0.486320734,
0.1323651969,
0.0013889313,
-0.2367637306,
0.8709759712,
-0.3678472638,
0.6996847391,
0.1037280038,
-0.4099713266,
0.435849756,
-0.1671668142,
0.345028013,
-0.0292076375,
-0.3976812065,
0.2783619165,
0.386613816,
-0.3290762901,
-0.456764251,
0.7284101844,
-1.1426296234,
-0.119334437,
-0.5475335717,
-0.2972192466,
-0.3566321731,
0.2131626457,
0.0708006993,
0.2731163204,
-0.4895521104,
0.2708078027,
0.6562356353,
-0.5141701102,
0.2824029624,
0.4997145236,
-0.4884713292,
-0.6680172086,
0.6940823793,
-0.1106072813,
0.2986975908,
0.2684671879,
0.1809800118,
-0.6094760299,
-0.590516448,
-0.3247173131,
0.4057375491,
-0.5576909781,
-0.035656549,
-0.4086207747,
-0.0345807932,
0.0287394542,
0.1664452255,
-0.6564587355,
-0.6881636977,
0.0912997946,
0.0155344391,
0.258122921,
1.1808415651,
0.223342225,
0.6221023798,
-0.7810998559,
0.2967232764,
0.1485521793,
0.7738518119,
-0.2808739841,
-0.3881127536,
-0.3119715154,
-0.1924408972,
-0.4704388976,
-0.9116954207,
0.2137450874,
-0.0943850353,
0.653930068,
0.1044349521,
-0.059019804,
0.3774750233,
-0.5940669775,
0.8420600891,
0.2581918836,
-0.8339534402,
0.3606209159,
-0.3850863874,
0.1281086653,
0.4797994494,
0.4100590646,
-0.3041995764,
-0.254780829,
-0.6586153507,
-0.6712439656,
0.7844306827,
0.2937169075,
-0.1758272648,
0.1247357279,
0.3772381246,
0.4707127512,
0.1480312198,
-0.9520841837,
0.0201056786,
0.0410483554,
-0.3152301908,
-0.2832749188,
-0.3185151517,
-0.1481079161,
-0.0304033384,
0.6235426068,
0.0049843811,
0.2720250785,
-0.1520448327,
0.0879935846,
-0.0576771237,
0.6444091797,
0.7184866667,
0.7991418839,
-0.2926520109,
-0.1546566486,
0.2747178972,
-0.6182203293,
0.0776802227,
0.0822493359,
0.0017396446,
-0.076594837,
0.2368383259,
0.840697825,
0.1693210453,
-1.1631157398,
0.1884992123,
-0.1720963866,
-0.3317030966,
-0.5559225082,
0.0737566799,
0.0900903791,
0.3021628857,
0.0306674149,
-0.2673895359,
-0.2337574512,
-0.5233277082,
-0.1079270914,
0.2770223618,
-0.1428009272,
-0.5130933523,
0.6574622989,
0.2446377426,
-0.0998098701,
0.2107570469,
0.2244578153,
-0.4921263158,
0.4663071036,
0.4024496675,
0.7775402665,
-0.4217798412,
0.2760639787,
0.3862355947,
0.360003382,
-0.5830278397,
0.7931421995,
0.1186374575,
-0.6000072956,
-0.3422577381,
-0.9841865301,
-0.610632956,
0.5208802819,
-0.3208602369,
0.5787245631,
-0.1936230063,
-0.1537500471,
-0.3609468937,
-0.0135381399,
-0.6948136091,
0.0361519679,
-0.0716778412,
1.1762772799,
-0.7146161795,
1.0357775688,
0.5672782063,
-0.4650252461,
-0.6878735423,
-0.2200717926,
-0.2749660909,
-0.8952003121,
0.7753075361,
-0.1311471462,
-0.3243233263,
0.0645201802,
-0.3584673107,
-1.0103243589,
0.9812422991,
0.812456727,
-0.5355782509,
-0.1453611404,
0.526209116,
0.6145507693,
-0.3041208684,
0.4741241038,
0.7544981837,
0.4474408627,
-0.1816168278,
-1.4076685905,
-0.4080743492,
-0.1952013969,
-0.2442134917,
0.2809031606,
-0.7493569255,
0.9167292118,
0.0330040716,
-0.0825074986,
0.2895166576,
0.0468499959,
0.2346325815,
0.0177709404,
0.3175596893,
0.9166519046,
0.7340131998,
-0.2428371012,
1.0140637159,
-0.3084892333,
0.2016768157,
1.3025742769,
-0.2945039868,
1.316506505,
0.4136885405,
-0.5537391901,
0.3743750453,
0.7002372146,
0.4998382032,
0.1390432864,
0.2321654707,
-0.2992933095,
-0.1625455618,
0.0075432961,
-0.5217936635,
0.7188244462,
0.4262152314,
-0.1967719346,
-0.4957734346,
-0.2429397851,
0.0700590536,
0.2568461299,
-0.5012438297,
0.3748937249,
0.0598519966,
-0.7585617304,
0.8183830976,
0.0557689779,
0.3008136451,
-0.8831754327,
0.038238205,
-0.1281798184,
0.2523312271,
-0.1058247238,
-0.950712502,
0.1444057524,
0.283990413,
0.1961099058,
-0.2560382783,
0.4235388637,
-0.3395708799,
-0.4502174258,
0.6009141803,
0.8000719547,
0.3639725745,
-0.0068190303,
-0.5944080949,
0.4219685197,
-0.0787065774,
-0.2411364168,
0.2414669693,
0.2781137526,
-0.3122570515,
0.5668769479,
0.3957167566,
0.2000038773,
0.2161028087,
0.2401487976,
0.766308248,
-0.5559176207,
-0.5136769414,
-0.4011528194,
0.5213020444,
0.1787185967,
-0.462887615,
0.5055420995,
0.6967924833,
0.8425977826,
-0.1765750647,
0.9652448893,
0.1471619755,
0.8005124927,
-0.6494699717,
0.527603507,
-0.5410932302,
0.3307450116,
-0.021293683,
-1.0744720697,
-0.2778529525,
0.3649863303,
-0.4060045779,
-0.0169331916,
0.7445825338,
0.6625224948,
-0.1441535652,
-0.0378163829,
0.4689330459,
0.3669490814,
0.0260215718,
0.7931149006,
1.030274868,
-0.3903715312,
0.5846794248,
-0.0565989837,
-0.4175708294,
0.0544436201,
-0.7450643182,
-1.0107997656,
-0.6263318062,
0.035898637,
-0.2921362221,
0.174653247,
1.0105171204,
0.2698403895,
-0.6765629649,
-0.7295296788,
0.0543915182,
0.0542731583,
0.2218715549,
-0.1215756088,
0.4143265784,
-0.1563970745,
-0.8976240754,
0.5681075454,
0.2038974911,
-0.1542736739,
-0.3180964291,
-0.2775823176,
-0.1107324064,
-0.0617114343,
0.5868201256,
0.5907757878,
-0.7916813493,
-0.2648479939,
0.0236608014,
0.2018818706,
0.1163571551,
0.516466856,
-0.8267109394,
0.372964263,
0.3683471382,
0.4809765816,
0.42667377,
-0.3070983291,
0.6494927406,
-0.348908931,
0.2985177636,
0.24517335,
0.3171159923,
-0.0011814912,
-0.0011605171,
0.7380307317,
-0.1500171274,
-0.5193889141,
-0.8883858919,
0.2460841388,
-1.0729769468,
0.0367485993,
1.0493065119,
0.0578515306,
-0.3045809865,
-0.2443247437,
-0.3553403914,
-0.162752673,
-0.4039563239,
0.5863904357,
0.6548994184,
-0.2572233379,
-0.2729793191,
-1.1699825525,
0.4221301675,
0.2060568631,
-0.9867420793,
-0.0539406091,
0.4270333946,
0.5005194545,
0.0807612389,
0.8970982432,
-0.3504389226,
0.531288743,
-0.1496114582,
0.2886604965,
0.2382896543,
-0.3471265733,
-0.418556869,
0.2214968204,
0.3843628168,
0.0586063974
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20262v1
|
ELITR-Bench: A Meeting Assistant Benchmark for Long-Context Language Models
| 2024-03-29T16:13:31 | 2024-03-29T16:13:31 |
Thibaut Thonet, Jos Rozen, Laurent Besacier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Research on Large Language Models (LLMs) has recently witnessed an increasing
interest in extending models' context size to better capture dependencies
within long documents. While benchmarks have been proposed to assess long-range
abilities, existing efforts primarily considered generic tasks that are not
necessarily aligned with real-world applications. In contrast, our work
proposes a new benchmark for long-context LLMs focused on a practical meeting
assistant scenario. In this scenario, the long contexts consist of transcripts
obtained by automatic speech recognition, presenting unique challenges for LLMs
due to the inherent noisiness and oral nature of such data. Our benchmark,
named ELITR-Bench, augments the existing ELITR corpus' transcripts with 271
manually crafted questions and their ground-truth answers. Our experiments with
recent long-context LLMs on ELITR-Bench highlight a gap between open-source and
proprietary models, especially when questions are asked sequentially within a
conversation. We also provide a thorough analysis of our GPT-4-based evaluation
method, encompassing insights from a crowdsourcing study. Our findings suggest
that while GPT-4's evaluation scores are correlated with human judges', its
ability to differentiate among more than three score levels may be limited.
|
[
-0.3098864555,
-0.6816945076,
0.8765336275,
0.1470976025,
-0.0018616861,
-0.2699680626,
-0.5103327036,
-0.840243578,
-0.1955904365,
0.2741042674,
-0.3273812234,
-0.4345928133,
-0.5175075531,
0.3568888903,
-0.6226123571,
0.7088615894,
-0.1559299082,
0.0061252564,
-0.4675345421,
-0.4349609911,
-0.4028672874,
-0.5457823873,
-0.5457274318,
-0.1505728513,
0.4403924048,
0.2145668417,
0.3706327975,
0.5411402583,
0.3054401278,
0.3394124806,
-0.1149061844,
-0.0130582182,
-0.1329598278,
0.1957554966,
-0.0673002675,
-0.1747663915,
-0.6454808712,
0.2930654883,
0.691945076,
0.8607817888,
-0.3219940364,
0.2501398921,
0.2081031501,
0.542573452,
-0.3920363784,
0.1877996325,
-0.661131382,
-0.2002380192,
-0.2653388381,
0.2508451045,
-0.1999107003,
-0.1623728573,
0.2405408025,
-0.4551423788,
0.1377291828,
-0.0056218645,
0.6903306246,
0.3443628252,
-0.3743971586,
-0.1354031265,
-0.5716126561,
0.700340271,
-0.6039053202,
0.6351465583,
0.6402546167,
0.6237820387,
-0.0412516184,
-0.802928865,
-0.5783822536,
-0.5400876999,
0.0722365379,
-0.0514319353,
-0.0932909176,
-0.0786832273,
0.5381224751,
0.1736600548,
-0.5623613,
0.0938416272,
-0.1674790829,
0.10611967,
0.2293774337,
0.0785154477,
-0.0808919817,
-0.0810120851,
-0.2448288053,
0.1331210583,
-0.5116748214,
-0.1096731275,
-0.1351905614,
0.2188853323,
-0.1107405722,
0.3664941788,
-0.345811218,
0.7290716767,
-0.0867405683,
0.1626163423,
0.2566560209,
-0.3536089361,
-0.1331510097,
-0.2382036,
0.7521466017,
0.4514366984,
0.1849166304,
-0.2975285649,
-0.2718139291,
-0.3687347472,
-0.079904668,
-0.7210892439,
0.0880777165,
0.1290543377,
-0.1960784644,
0.2371012866,
-0.1195832044,
-0.7220147252,
-0.297288239,
-0.4698005915,
0.4456093609,
-0.2085569501,
-0.1106293127,
-0.2199490219,
0.0546641126,
0.3679299653,
0.5408280492,
-0.6637998223,
0.7774027586,
0.7009444833,
0.8974113464,
-0.3479657471,
-0.4810882211,
-0.961907804,
0.1096325219,
-0.1362314522,
0.8087199926,
-0.346506834,
-0.4170410633,
-0.0923482403,
-0.1355475187,
-0.0461481512,
-0.6734337807,
0.51138556,
-0.216373086,
0.3638947904,
-0.372502327,
-0.6054650545,
0.2714413404,
0.4888082445,
-0.6112647057,
1.1939102411,
0.2736058533,
-0.2637135983,
0.5548388958,
-0.6735528111,
-0.33972013,
0.2523526549,
-0.665275991,
-0.3203397393,
-0.1683115959,
0.3324112594,
0.2679598033,
-0.4664029479,
0.2516129911,
-0.2891131639,
-0.3293426931,
0.3778600395,
-0.4010294676,
0.2861323655,
-0.0242692623,
-0.4508569539,
0.089598909,
-0.8839949965,
0.1452870965,
-0.1586835235,
-0.3703878522,
-0.2326153666,
0.0458818637,
0.1786382645,
0.097985819,
0.3347674608,
-0.5051577091,
-0.128862381,
-0.1977192611,
0.4139650762,
0.8611215353,
-0.2052398473,
0.1688467562,
-0.3907188177,
0.2942371368,
-0.4465132356,
0.0342057236,
-0.0142628262,
-0.3794230521,
-0.4853231013,
-0.3940016329,
0.3235110343,
0.253857553,
-0.1571592689,
0.6186906695,
-0.5089390874,
-0.3411284089,
-0.333091408,
0.1646910459,
0.420791775,
0.5665138364,
0.441999495,
-0.2008346468,
-0.3197310865,
-0.9186633825,
-0.4740571976,
-0.0355411768,
-0.3434573412,
0.5755115151,
0.4156217873,
0.0191656295,
1.1163140535,
-0.0631924644,
-0.3470436037,
-0.0457842238,
0.2975500524,
0.3281244934,
0.2203559875,
0.4365745783,
-0.5838426352,
-0.6482251287,
0.0138090476,
-0.5236671567,
-0.3469686806,
0.1534155607,
0.2740297616,
0.2663840055,
0.508664012,
-0.6772091985,
0.4069129527,
0.5024971962,
-0.1800604016,
0.4716412127,
-0.1523278952,
0.2580512464,
-0.8747031093,
0.2849502563,
-0.062257681,
-0.5060462356,
-0.3499699831,
-0.1860790849,
0.1831119806,
-0.2122397572,
-0.4193580449,
0.8755994439,
-0.5394735932,
-0.5133146644,
-0.2596969604,
0.3198561072,
-0.0568775795,
0.4890948534,
0.1089670658,
1.083797574,
0.1437158585,
-0.444349885,
0.1863133758,
0.2846370637,
-0.5738810301,
0.8272715211,
-0.8567623496,
0.5057279468,
0.4038870633,
0.3822168112,
-0.787119627,
-0.3985628188,
-0.2638425827,
-0.3399761617,
0.1034458205,
-0.1761956513,
-0.6652027369,
-0.220794186,
-0.2403493524,
0.539236486,
0.3818038702,
-0.6247555017,
0.6111944318,
0.3062252998,
-0.3147065938,
-0.2757897973,
-0.48625651,
0.3207285702,
-0.1441860795,
-0.390338093,
0.4206694961,
-0.302495867,
-0.3462814093,
-0.2247232348,
-0.3260451257,
-0.1450893879,
-0.1050215587,
0.3128235638,
-0.0245552417,
-0.1538268328,
0.0057840394,
-0.330236882,
0.0799990222,
0.1394747049,
0.1833379567,
0.4541002214,
-0.406580627,
-0.4987235665,
-0.3874210119,
0.5058789849,
0.7492523193,
-0.1167377904,
0.407561779,
0.2080160677,
-0.4861872792,
-0.0012490778,
-0.9539055824,
0.1328853965,
-0.4640352726,
0.4842817485,
-0.51150316,
-0.7595083714,
0.5654034019,
-0.0459395684,
0.041429963,
0.2453837842,
0.5911628604,
0.1696325541,
0.7547354698,
0.3282139301,
-0.3167718053,
0.5028378963,
0.2383894622,
-0.2619880438,
-0.9132848978,
0.0042832759,
-0.6689418554,
-0.0782325119,
-0.2349408269,
-0.4297986627,
0.5439160466,
-0.2219769806,
-0.3053096533,
0.4869782031,
-0.3014911711,
0.6441836953,
0.567445457,
-0.0685753599,
0.2542598248,
-0.4589785337,
0.0841854811,
0.1593313962,
-0.2422904372,
-0.5381906033,
1.0847048759,
0.2871524096,
0.3596951067,
0.1281051785,
0.6783140898,
0.1260445714,
0.4389102161,
-0.4532051086,
0.720235467,
0.1647305489,
-0.6284326315,
-0.5971369147,
-0.4630530775,
-0.9400964975,
0.1907744706,
0.1346048713,
-0.9151681066,
-0.0709696338,
-0.1595924199,
-0.2624189556,
-0.0772383139,
-0.6331290603,
0.9797552228,
-0.4390029311,
-0.4478389919,
0.0152899986,
-0.5160754919,
-0.0335146785,
-0.296330452,
0.2922827899,
-0.429715693,
-0.1888390183,
0.8874459267,
-0.3492245674,
0.6524615288,
-0.129479304,
0.0309752561,
0.0722772703,
-0.1460580826,
0.5285292268,
0.0079020793,
-0.3723112643,
0.1285907626,
0.13044855,
-0.2409646362,
-0.3838876486,
0.8820998073,
-0.7528033257,
-0.5040743351,
-0.3676869869,
-0.4583421648,
-0.6492038369,
0.3846403658,
-0.0350773931,
0.4571712613,
-0.5834876895,
0.2728567421,
0.0899059772,
-0.0870688558,
0.3956007063,
0.8294090629,
-0.0374160446,
-0.4428161085,
0.3270150721,
0.1766510308,
0.1785863638,
0.2815175354,
0.120722957,
-0.3598254919,
-0.6026305556,
-0.3179144561,
0.0593353659,
-0.6196213961,
-0.1699012667,
-0.3673751652,
-0.0410823226,
-0.5081735253,
0.1485382468,
-0.2958062589,
-0.3646593094,
-0.1076905504,
-0.0843254551,
0.3000989258,
0.5177842379,
0.0912465975,
0.0091631813,
-0.7164224386,
0.3774844408,
0.5868519545,
0.7228284478,
-0.3041233122,
-0.5080754757,
-0.1607112288,
-0.1356905252,
-0.2476229817,
-0.681132555,
0.140986383,
0.2979322672,
0.7609586716,
0.0031200722,
-0.0452947207,
0.7874400616,
-0.7507629395,
0.7448632121,
0.1264194399,
-0.9068358541,
0.481869936,
-0.6299741268,
0.450363487,
0.9536960721,
0.0793019682,
-0.4158074856,
-0.3181815743,
-0.407225132,
-0.8820098639,
0.6128205061,
0.2761685848,
-0.0242175553,
-0.3520641625,
0.2452156842,
0.2217872888,
0.1873017401,
-0.9104816914,
0.1975880861,
0.0446519852,
-0.0400555097,
-0.0631394237,
-0.1073499694,
-0.2320637703,
-0.3018506765,
0.254321456,
0.0188101623,
0.1749807447,
0.1921443939,
-0.0677704588,
-0.2089805454,
0.4839585721,
0.4811753929,
0.9032319188,
-0.5256912112,
-0.0173603985,
0.6260665059,
-0.0602625608,
-0.2129631191,
0.6225241423,
0.400909245,
-0.0318908542,
0.3883447349,
0.4911141396,
0.407854408,
-0.819675386,
0.7373726964,
-0.206194073,
-0.3680735826,
-0.6206213236,
-0.1184380278,
-0.012656237,
0.1921241283,
0.5131064057,
-0.2971862555,
0.1393768787,
-0.5963682532,
0.3494217098,
0.4278983176,
-0.3341378868,
-0.1559352279,
0.6709805131,
0.4826593101,
-0.561424017,
0.5267471671,
0.0662663952,
-0.2083654553,
0.3897059262,
0.2400437593,
0.8176004291,
-0.2412033677,
-0.4354139864,
0.3015352786,
-0.0482107438,
-0.1378146857,
0.028728744,
-0.3393341601,
-0.3193508387,
-0.4341284633,
-0.5624079704,
-0.8376837373,
0.4817276001,
-0.7348716855,
0.3020060956,
-0.2743806839,
-0.1890243292,
0.0099506686,
-0.0057756882,
-0.7993057966,
-0.0564645045,
0.061442133,
0.9101339579,
-0.3975428939,
0.8493369818,
0.4252875149,
-0.2214293182,
-0.6296895742,
-0.009430577,
-0.030733237,
-0.6440058351,
0.4959664941,
0.565895319,
-0.0830123797,
-0.2584309578,
-0.3273802102,
-0.6022811532,
1.2407860756,
0.2596690059,
-0.8134581447,
-0.2044488788,
0.2374528795,
0.5701050162,
-0.208960861,
0.3368804157,
0.6615965962,
0.5451202393,
-0.1263675541,
-1.6072759628,
0.0494362637,
-0.3307572603,
-0.3771267533,
0.1847480386,
-0.4179164767,
0.6756799221,
0.259472847,
-0.0841677338,
0.6184008121,
0.5202884674,
0.3201079965,
0.4183283746,
0.6461256146,
0.4134273827,
0.5865383148,
0.0457327813,
0.9680264592,
-0.3352501392,
0.1076115593,
1.4888039827,
-0.8193507195,
1.1236412525,
0.5291484594,
-0.3439313173,
0.336199671,
0.3010255694,
-0.0224417802,
0.3638031483,
0.3433149159,
-0.3284167349,
-0.0286317449,
0.1260867566,
-0.480706811,
0.3569120765,
0.283962369,
-0.1672188491,
-0.3534038067,
-0.1010662988,
-0.256634146,
0.2848575413,
-0.1201715916,
0.8982653022,
0.1848933101,
-0.8588714004,
0.5169846416,
-0.2423781157,
0.3681020737,
-0.5408590436,
-0.0432111844,
-0.1815690249,
0.2575689852,
0.1772123873,
-0.6899486184,
0.075101234,
0.2909524143,
-0.024463091,
-0.2767473757,
0.210961476,
-0.3014656901,
-0.190100193,
0.31877473,
0.6629828215,
0.3333695233,
-0.2623442113,
-0.6715570688,
0.0832728595,
-0.5365314484,
-0.3966648281,
0.5895293355,
0.5542665124,
-0.0248126891,
0.4391784966,
0.4066658616,
-0.0618936494,
-0.2708269358,
0.3580275178,
0.8282778859,
-0.6941295862,
-0.3567239642,
-0.6576680541,
0.1294029057,
-0.3294388354,
-0.5182261467,
0.5551368594,
0.7831978798,
0.5308035016,
0.234928757,
0.6002560258,
0.1020374522,
1.0836971998,
-0.4302225113,
0.6096152663,
-0.3899051547,
0.4197331965,
-0.2669119835,
-0.9257218242,
-0.1640202999,
0.5869644284,
-0.5973036885,
0.3482703865,
0.7351351976,
0.6108468175,
-0.1468491852,
-0.130847156,
0.4008363187,
0.0962747261,
0.4436662495,
0.6454335451,
0.8748248219,
-0.1888563633,
0.7520114183,
0.0276529156,
-0.4070862532,
-0.1674458832,
-1.055013895,
-0.9711828828,
-0.6565568447,
-0.1453976929,
-0.0440868326,
0.2334447354,
1.0204199553,
0.7932940125,
-0.4928620756,
-0.4050914645,
-0.0935491547,
-0.3200137317,
-0.1804739833,
-0.1860321611,
0.4716277122,
-0.1368081421,
-0.7625302076,
0.6692393422,
0.1031644344,
-0.0526360236,
0.0843139589,
-0.1261251122,
-0.0867726579,
-0.0298460927,
0.4548707604,
0.4522441924,
-0.7682871819,
-0.5959607959,
-0.0722062066,
-0.1493510008,
0.0834077895,
0.4885650277,
-0.8698195219,
0.1926595718,
0.0529806726,
0.5909995437,
0.6491951346,
-0.0172629189,
0.7330164909,
-0.9229307175,
-0.0917388871,
0.3084488213,
0.576345861,
0.4398956299,
0.0664075911,
0.6660683751,
-0.1445976049,
-0.8417829871,
-0.9832850099,
0.0876217484,
-1.3069933653,
-0.0760727897,
1.3055394888,
-0.1007901803,
-0.134965539,
-0.118896313,
-0.1894322634,
0.0994681194,
-0.3998226225,
0.8096140027,
0.760150969,
-0.2112819552,
-0.1455244124,
-0.6777875423,
0.4117103815,
0.3114919662,
-1.0091129541,
0.4433849454,
0.5783926845,
0.3781201243,
-0.012031598,
0.9489629865,
-0.2006276995,
0.5565101504,
-0.3408106267,
-0.1392294466,
-0.2176565975,
-0.043410141,
-0.0802309811,
0.0480880626,
0.3362837136,
-0.0640400127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20252v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20252v1
|
Using LLMs to Model the Beliefs and Preferences of Targeted Populations
| 2024-03-29T15:58:46 | 2024-03-29T15:58:46 |
Keiichi Namikoshi, Alex Filipowicz, David A. Shamma, Rumen Iliev, Candice L. Hogan, Nikos Arechiga
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We consider the problem of aligning a large language model (LLM) to model the
preferences of a human population. Modeling the beliefs, preferences, and
behaviors of a specific population can be useful for a variety of different
applications, such as conducting simulated focus groups for new products,
conducting virtual surveys, and testing behavioral interventions, especially
for interventions that are expensive, impractical, or unethical. Existing work
has had mixed success using LLMs to accurately model human behavior in
different contexts. We benchmark and evaluate two well-known fine-tuning
approaches and evaluate the resulting populations on their ability to match the
preferences of real human respondents on a survey of preferences for battery
electric vehicles (BEVs). We evaluate our models against their ability to match
population-wide statistics as well as their ability to match individual
responses, and we investigate the role of temperature in controlling the
trade-offs between these two. Additionally, we propose and evaluate a novel
loss term to improve model performance on responses that require a numeric
response.
|
[
-0.4806065261,
-0.4916769564,
0.7066507936,
0.1339501441,
-0.1034511775,
0.0108882105,
-0.5145895481,
-0.2053496093,
0.1254125983,
0.4071621299,
-0.3030877411,
-0.3934642673,
-0.1015854776,
-0.0428110175,
-0.1052071154,
0.3506550491,
-0.0110048912,
0.2497226149,
-0.3976355195,
-0.0188897736,
-0.3527880907,
-0.5704866052,
-0.6257981658,
-0.7126341462,
0.5320783854,
0.6047991514,
0.7386279702,
0.5451059937,
0.3448114991,
0.2057513744,
0.0257064085,
0.2570213974,
-0.7316046953,
0.1276578754,
-0.4487158954,
-0.3210378587,
-0.2275269628,
0.1695169657,
0.4094735682,
0.6667462587,
-0.3986897767,
0.1552026421,
-0.0265569501,
0.5125244856,
-0.6376110911,
-0.2722029984,
-0.8845559359,
-0.2137154341,
0.1202502474,
-0.1952030212,
-0.2226753086,
-0.5332655311,
0.1176943183,
-0.2856658697,
0.2341164351,
0.3807881773,
0.847628653,
0.3885197043,
-0.6166732907,
-0.1426815838,
-0.881966114,
1.0295374393,
-0.8648042679,
0.3779176176,
0.5195849538,
-0.085139364,
-0.2699190378,
0.111530818,
-0.6270578504,
-0.2920947969,
0.0568135157,
0.1125382185,
-0.0010632536,
0.1124925986,
0.2239045948,
0.1950908303,
-0.5499705672,
0.5419052243,
-0.1510255337,
-0.0999481753,
0.9115538597,
0.6131057143,
0.0120638702,
-0.0488141701,
-0.4470710754,
-0.0163931996,
-0.6358009577,
0.3343567252,
0.5057890415,
0.5139735341,
-0.112938121,
0.6800557971,
-0.3229734302,
0.5485029817,
0.1527635455,
-0.1273923665,
-0.0001410343,
-0.2861648202,
-0.3024718463,
-0.0537375696,
0.5686016083,
1.2214081287,
0.4697959423,
0.0752154067,
-0.2322587967,
0.2358713597,
0.2372571528,
-0.7631115913,
0.0043661399,
0.0500882193,
-0.4990382493,
-0.2711050212,
-0.1247650683,
-0.674967289,
-0.4336021841,
-0.7149917483,
0.2209415138,
0.0206218828,
-0.3008187711,
0.5727465749,
-0.0980629176,
0.4584237635,
0.2883254886,
-1.3448348045,
0.5515595675,
0.559307158,
0.7874920368,
-0.4219928682,
0.0475876033,
0.0911299288,
0.3373908997,
-0.2116205394,
0.8075071573,
-0.795909822,
-0.7784354687,
-0.0026233769,
-0.1431911588,
0.0021567324,
-0.571860075,
0.2436791509,
-0.4706115723,
-0.0667796135,
-0.8193243742,
-0.6961517334,
0.005721387,
0.4064447582,
-0.3560358286,
0.7995433211,
-0.1253751516,
-0.451146841,
0.4059813023,
-0.5228770375,
-0.3282585144,
-0.2895154953,
-0.0546883307,
-0.3898115754,
0.2134857923,
-0.1244333759,
0.4609321654,
-0.4888883531,
0.0697018579,
-0.6727639437,
-0.3452394009,
0.418313086,
-0.2362249941,
0.3302923739,
0.3393737078,
0.0783295706,
0.279489696,
-0.2801528275,
-0.0737251043,
0.1730409861,
-0.5230045915,
-0.5846921206,
0.3900421858,
0.0650518239,
-0.1438847333,
0.5095521212,
-0.5283596516,
0.3813229203,
-0.2909807265,
0.3274895847,
0.9156591296,
-0.072768122,
0.6325842142,
-0.644890964,
0.6047176719,
-0.1791696995,
0.1049325839,
0.3393725753,
-0.2264439315,
-0.5596277118,
0.0962632969,
0.0324358232,
0.568351388,
-0.1384095252,
0.2932877243,
0.1226096153,
-0.5222190022,
-0.0344128162,
0.0069050645,
0.1123325899,
0.5584192872,
0.1489562094,
-0.1657425463,
-0.5095974803,
-1.1612329483,
-0.3491481543,
-0.3259118497,
-0.1150007471,
0.6398345828,
0.2278172374,
-0.1681165695,
1.0394794941,
-0.705876112,
0.2040305436,
-0.1440228224,
-0.2237060517,
0.1560507715,
0.410897702,
0.5824121833,
-0.7529168725,
-0.4750337303,
0.1164648458,
-0.4956614077,
-0.0927437991,
0.1755742729,
0.0403505974,
0.0064948187,
0.2576390803,
-0.4871812761,
0.2934470475,
0.4428613782,
-0.0348577388,
0.5143868327,
-0.2906820476,
0.4648095667,
-1.1285326481,
-0.1771678627,
0.6405686736,
-0.0970752165,
-0.6304513812,
-0.3296448886,
-0.0602772497,
0.2258161306,
-0.6084560156,
0.6617928147,
-0.1171724945,
-0.0065126684,
-0.3540019393,
-0.1269487143,
-0.1020251364,
0.0403105505,
0.0541811772,
0.9381608367,
0.4026512802,
-0.857088685,
0.4556793869,
0.2806804776,
-0.1509889364,
0.4276365936,
-0.7368898988,
0.2823218405,
-0.3129971027,
-0.0273137931,
-0.8281419277,
-0.4206908047,
0.0576709211,
-0.3427069485,
0.024847595,
-0.0151631217,
-0.4282821715,
-0.1773839742,
-0.283438921,
0.3256174326,
0.7368237376,
-0.150420785,
0.537389636,
0.5227943063,
-0.0854908228,
-0.1910219938,
-0.2742672265,
-0.1160241738,
-0.7488476634,
-0.381062597,
0.3850839138,
-0.3302888572,
-0.6176092029,
-0.2601828873,
-0.1319781095,
0.0848023817,
0.1680624485,
0.0965139717,
0.3107310236,
-0.0460280143,
0.3002698421,
-0.2447259873,
-0.108942993,
0.0040765414,
-0.2056878805,
0.6518830657,
-0.0830246657,
-0.3662934601,
-0.1100537479,
0.45289886,
0.5139375329,
-0.0997165516,
0.6057469249,
0.0236219205,
-0.533131361,
-0.0164481942,
-0.6758579612,
-0.2430059612,
-0.5498365164,
0.4141536355,
-0.2038851976,
-0.9739274383,
0.4353466034,
-0.2545230985,
0.0054190517,
0.0446076989,
0.9492704868,
-0.4203047454,
1.2967587709,
0.755143404,
-0.2124753892,
0.4587334692,
0.2764091194,
0.2668923438,
-0.7622418404,
-0.2912809253,
-0.7548441291,
-0.4439989328,
-0.6789765358,
-0.0942975655,
0.3209849298,
-0.0959251225,
-0.4874399304,
0.2574148774,
-0.3755436838,
0.5411900878,
0.5339134336,
0.3088213801,
0.0402538255,
-0.0102852518,
-0.0276580751,
-0.2322277427,
-0.5814247727,
-1.0100624561,
1.0138156414,
0.2341154665,
1.2547168732,
0.1861005127,
0.3992252648,
0.283685416,
0.3287066519,
-0.8091675043,
0.5280046463,
-0.304920882,
-0.7422450185,
-0.4821590781,
-0.3676181436,
-1.0484365225,
0.19114241,
-0.1146002412,
-1.0189361572,
-0.0490742847,
0.5230536461,
-0.4275669456,
0.4519213736,
-0.6949145794,
0.8015891314,
-0.5905612707,
-0.4283991754,
-0.3592623174,
-0.4745905697,
0.2577995062,
-0.121640116,
0.1158227548,
-0.686846137,
-0.0524214655,
0.5551445484,
-0.1614596993,
0.6900013089,
-0.0531635843,
-0.0692759678,
-0.1792930663,
-0.227867201,
0.3425441682,
0.0397054069,
-0.5905451179,
-0.0144625995,
0.1762135625,
-0.4110737741,
-0.5056788921,
0.7298791409,
-0.8074627519,
-0.9640115499,
-0.195549652,
-0.6201640964,
-0.4060561657,
0.1061465591,
0.033035893,
0.1469035894,
-0.3688547611,
-0.0740595534,
0.9249764085,
-0.3677944541,
0.0829434395,
0.7628288269,
-0.3120269775,
-0.1234120801,
0.6889738441,
-0.1285244375,
0.5173770785,
0.2370934635,
0.5181473494,
-0.4254500568,
-0.5990027785,
-0.003958133,
0.256354481,
-0.575727284,
-0.0660710409,
-0.2165666223,
0.2123196125,
-0.4112489223,
-0.2650619745,
-0.2617432177,
0.2383286953,
-0.5280013084,
-0.0510892533,
0.3704733849,
0.711253643,
-0.0027899542,
0.4706910551,
-0.4242303371,
0.366927892,
0.3875386715,
0.3631314933,
-0.2266866118,
-0.3607174158,
-0.1344055533,
0.3188253641,
-0.1241781265,
-0.8552254438,
0.3382432461,
-0.0652162656,
0.6745292544,
0.2650641203,
0.3141303957,
0.6688881516,
-0.4391330481,
0.6097612381,
0.2005377263,
-0.7551649809,
0.5160156488,
-0.3770455122,
0.1500097066,
0.6934895515,
0.5435501933,
-0.7000820041,
0.0344583802,
-0.2832045257,
-0.5782135129,
0.3264779747,
-0.0736089423,
0.4056772292,
-0.0659552142,
0.492962569,
0.0174360313,
0.2864433229,
-0.3481541276,
-0.2049431205,
0.0068793143,
-0.3551005423,
-0.2478716075,
-0.0618957318,
-0.1100616977,
-0.2782209814,
0.6778616905,
-0.1843375117,
-0.0438703001,
-0.0823554546,
0.294174552,
-0.3237092793,
0.2449021786,
0.8374086618,
0.5747278929,
-0.4786931872,
0.1700203866,
0.4306981266,
0.0023060148,
0.36504668,
-0.1972455829,
-0.3340961933,
-0.3220116496,
-0.3947030902,
0.5345723033,
0.20806247,
-0.6401653886,
0.1971058697,
-0.2864686251,
-0.2943580747,
-0.2008460015,
0.2286439091,
0.4429435134,
0.1804617792,
0.0987440869,
0.1742860377,
-0.0636928529,
-0.51370579,
-0.0483040102,
1.0043644905,
-0.4175849259,
-0.2285293937,
0.7486702204,
0.3226375878,
-0.5752062201,
0.4386868179,
0.1051210165,
-0.5694147944,
0.7198752165,
0.4444827139,
0.5506115556,
-0.2619860768,
-0.1814454198,
0.2959641218,
0.3981860876,
-0.2781127691,
0.2381527275,
0.1993341297,
-1.1730595827,
-0.1756028235,
-0.5662237406,
-0.692453146,
0.0428722203,
-0.761051774,
0.3551593721,
-0.2871915102,
-0.4973396361,
-0.0690747947,
-0.1224485189,
-0.8360255361,
0.1277154684,
0.2644168735,
0.8560646772,
-1.0367056131,
0.7187972069,
0.8155168295,
-0.2760868073,
-0.8817144632,
0.0088170702,
0.0299171787,
-0.9119432569,
0.4047612846,
-0.0921985283,
-0.2903433144,
0.0293225832,
-0.8944838047,
-1.0574979782,
0.8698726296,
0.4501546025,
-0.72887218,
0.0411300883,
0.1166420877,
0.2565927207,
-0.4606561959,
-0.0291965567,
0.8248141408,
0.5666666627,
-0.0025985176,
-1.0760225058,
-0.0431149825,
0.1168259904,
0.0452311225,
0.2006305456,
-0.9652215838,
0.5535188317,
-0.1993835121,
-0.0386562645,
0.1062297672,
0.54283005,
0.4585925341,
0.515694201,
0.739349246,
0.362644881,
0.8076550364,
0.0944351405,
0.8298792243,
-0.337631315,
0.5459008217,
0.8007515669,
-0.9505904913,
0.6870749593,
0.6345160604,
-0.4607833028,
-0.0367939472,
1.0002884865,
0.0219536126,
0.6361498833,
0.5486239195,
-0.3383693397,
-0.6622431874,
-0.4047012925,
-0.2735019028,
0.2089954168,
0.550211966,
-0.0010453853,
0.0007095096,
-0.2065667361,
-0.1561364681,
0.2484799474,
-0.2993580997,
0.7443223596,
0.1350242049,
-0.55024755,
0.2966194749,
0.0803553164,
0.751067102,
-0.4329461455,
0.2092716098,
-0.1035356596,
0.029042758,
-0.30011186,
-0.6508792043,
0.1857839823,
-0.0550593995,
-0.5036409497,
-0.3261412978,
0.7321349978,
-0.4750072956,
-0.4500442743,
-0.0555170886,
0.3639198244,
0.2107997835,
0.2184366286,
-0.5882772207,
0.1665797979,
0.0466136076,
-0.1428712308,
0.299646616,
-0.1578636318,
0.074836202,
0.7460214496,
0.568408668,
0.1088396907,
-0.2188314646,
0.1702041775,
0.7321637869,
-0.7427842021,
-0.2119448781,
-0.9894485474,
0.2355123758,
-0.0628741756,
-0.2688548267,
0.8244908452,
0.7460694909,
0.6926560402,
0.0655191317,
1.1226453781,
0.3462997079,
0.5874273181,
-0.6355493665,
0.2889122665,
-0.4844401479,
0.3351400197,
-0.0133872814,
-0.9789934754,
-0.0997736081,
0.6175075173,
-0.4243474305,
0.1595829129,
0.3269950747,
0.9782109261,
0.0504646376,
-0.1498234421,
0.4976859987,
-0.106266275,
0.3956601322,
0.4516720474,
1.0695229769,
0.1312302947,
0.0097108707,
0.055124741,
-0.1486729383,
-0.2285359055,
-0.9229879975,
-0.850931108,
-0.1483838856,
-0.2991966903,
-0.2192491889,
-0.0581743605,
1.4344005585,
0.7564505935,
-0.6959005594,
-0.5142950416,
0.2216087729,
0.1241976395,
0.1670227349,
-0.162276119,
-0.1787692308,
-0.0594027042,
-0.6833200455,
0.3372788131,
0.3088795841,
0.1641995758,
-0.4879075885,
-0.2707363963,
0.040665783,
0.4855466187,
0.3863278925,
0.3000895381,
-0.9876470566,
-0.5688655376,
0.3306237757,
-0.156360209,
0.1648837179,
0.9901041985,
-0.5017973781,
0.1939370632,
0.2905733585,
0.4652783573,
0.5036587715,
0.3648112118,
0.8615655303,
-0.4032590985,
-0.2680165768,
0.1470270157,
0.5072978139,
0.4486551583,
-0.1910236031,
0.1445441544,
-0.0470883958,
-0.8272388577,
-0.637576282,
0.5068667531,
-1.0690207481,
-0.1498152018,
1.3625930548,
0.2350331694,
0.0099635795,
-0.1708996147,
-0.23439987,
0.1157872081,
-0.6775357127,
0.8073680401,
0.667544961,
-0.2866153419,
-0.1496520191,
-0.5057951212,
0.2309963107,
0.4333027899,
-0.7673968673,
0.0778464749,
0.3944353163,
0.4978384674,
-0.2324586362,
0.5259410143,
0.5448499918,
-0.0779399499,
-0.5460958481,
0.0541998446,
0.3328428864,
0.318834275,
-0.4521965683,
-0.0028907787,
0.3503353,
0.0199662801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20222v1
|
Shallow Cross-Encoders for Low-Latency Retrieval
| 2024-03-29T15:07:21 | 2024-03-29T15:07:21 |
Aleksandr V. Petrov, Sean MacAvaney, Craig Macdonald
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Transformer-based Cross-Encoders achieve state-of-the-art effectiveness in
text retrieval. However, Cross-Encoders based on large transformer models (such
as BERT or T5) are computationally expensive and allow for scoring only a small
number of documents within a reasonably small latency window. However, keeping
search latencies low is important for user satisfaction and energy usage. In
this paper, we show that weaker shallow transformer models (i.e., transformers
with a limited number of layers) actually perform better than full-scale models
when constrained to these practical low-latency settings since they can
estimate the relevance of more documents in the same time budget. We further
show that shallow transformers may benefit from the generalized Binary
Cross-Entropy (gBCE) training scheme, which has recently demonstrated success
for recommendation tasks. Our experiments with TREC Deep Learning passage
ranking query sets demonstrate significant improvements in shallow and
full-scale models in low-latency scenarios. For example, when the latency limit
is 25ms per query, MonoBERT-Large (a cross-encoder based on a full-scale BERT
model) is only able to achieve NDCG@10 of 0.431 on TREC DL 2019, while
TinyBERT-gBCE (a cross-encoder based on TinyBERT trained with gBCE) reaches
NDCG@10 of 0.652, a +51% gain over MonoBERT-Large. We also show that shallow
Cross-Encoders are effective even when used without a GPU (e.g., with CPU
inference, NDCG@10 decreases only by 3% compared to GPU inference with 50ms
latency), which makes Cross-Encoders practical to run even without specialized
hardware acceleration.
|
[
-0.5507739782,
-0.4835907519,
0.6525250077,
-0.1470260471,
-0.2579577267,
0.0125923678,
-0.3003986478,
-0.6695522666,
0.1246364117,
0.1477969438,
-0.3445132971,
-0.3873494565,
-0.6608662009,
-0.0590834878,
-0.4481784999,
0.8260555863,
0.3332092464,
-0.0412276722,
-0.163978219,
-0.0070154108,
-0.2022566348,
-0.2648223042,
-0.6688745618,
-0.4355290532,
0.8517481089,
0.3254500329,
0.964147687,
0.2433589399,
0.7504428029,
0.2040074468,
-0.2631378472,
-0.1678600013,
-0.5978074074,
0.0586902387,
-0.0354831181,
-0.5634075403,
-0.177342698,
-0.1760681272,
0.3603934944,
0.7385023236,
0.0065692742,
-0.0358882472,
0.058302056,
0.6992147565,
-0.7932313085,
-0.3078195453,
-0.6081343293,
0.41245839,
-0.3035452962,
0.0545807779,
-0.4845299125,
-0.1684321016,
0.417746067,
-0.2276017815,
0.7099094391,
0.1217275336,
0.8202157617,
0.4493382275,
-0.1298380047,
-0.1641336828,
-0.9208975434,
0.7936185002,
-0.7515372634,
0.9595048428,
0.2680544853,
0.3062862158,
0.3783824742,
-0.8597934246,
-0.3528092206,
-0.2636913061,
-0.3828083873,
0.20031856,
-0.3725783527,
0.0668565482,
0.4777064621,
0.611716032,
-0.6611045003,
0.2137119919,
-0.3892860413,
-0.0715641007,
0.3177596033,
0.1467717439,
-0.1364541203,
-0.1883808225,
-0.1632736623,
-0.1108993366,
-0.4219242632,
0.2145115435,
0.3480265439,
0.2306856215,
-0.1989982128,
0.5050465465,
-0.0911339223,
0.3846452236,
0.5080342889,
0.2407810688,
0.0214920547,
-0.5307776332,
-0.0100793354,
0.1528024673,
0.7262704372,
-0.0695710778,
-0.0106199868,
-0.680404067,
-0.396954149,
0.0698683113,
0.5778153539,
-1.0122725964,
-0.2611249387,
-0.0565083139,
-0.7366735339,
-0.0232278761,
0.0836519077,
-0.7946625352,
-0.1488469988,
0.0141833024,
0.3866574764,
-0.3209882379,
0.5984381437,
0.1087768227,
-0.1807107627,
0.3846139312,
0.2748300731,
-1.0151224136,
0.5591621995,
0.2890057564,
0.9119312167,
-0.2017219961,
0.1279867291,
-0.500113368,
-0.0848405287,
-0.1327827871,
0.6228055358,
-0.8559532762,
-0.5537499189,
-0.27377823,
0.0592368469,
0.2621261179,
-0.2841801941,
0.7945147157,
-0.6938360333,
0.39287889,
-0.3184897006,
-0.1441739798,
0.1830720007,
0.0105952667,
-0.9287218451,
1.1651873589,
0.0346392617,
-0.8128849268,
0.3854780495,
-0.4282020032,
-0.6395892501,
-0.112360999,
-0.131937921,
-0.535766542,
0.2472525537,
0.4401565194,
0.4266991913,
-0.6914485693,
-0.2175855488,
-0.1630649567,
-1.0056786537,
-0.3723312616,
-0.702334106,
0.2478447109,
0.083994247,
-0.5446938872,
-0.3293494284,
-0.3444391191,
-0.0405695848,
-0.05946628,
-0.4253370762,
-0.292359978,
-0.0748214424,
0.0676590502,
0.1010178998,
0.2012792528,
-0.6810623407,
0.2240667492,
-0.4999673963,
0.432233423,
0.4072273374,
-0.2336083353,
0.8840919137,
-0.0956290364,
0.3843069673,
0.0504691042,
0.2271698415,
0.2242760658,
-0.5315992236,
-0.6173918843,
0.0338784754,
0.6387974024,
0.4167646766,
-0.9166490436,
0.4058200717,
-0.5063079,
-0.737814188,
-0.8557417989,
0.1047072113,
0.2151790857,
0.3838361204,
0.8158116937,
-0.4959779382,
-0.3820633888,
-0.8896837831,
-0.0486158133,
0.1531070322,
-0.3318364024,
0.8679519892,
0.3814118207,
-0.562425971,
0.6684772968,
-0.4059497416,
-0.1818637401,
-0.1652249992,
0.1515798867,
0.4129357934,
0.3398788869,
0.5132859349,
-0.7988889813,
-0.5099131465,
-0.0267876554,
-0.4934186637,
0.1113611087,
0.0411499962,
0.0988069102,
0.1279300302,
0.2672734559,
-0.6898007393,
0.5557892323,
0.3910994232,
-0.015777491,
0.1268653125,
-0.3383255601,
0.1403390318,
-0.5049002767,
0.0321855433,
0.1018865779,
-0.1351730675,
-0.3089989424,
-0.4916574359,
-0.0309854895,
-0.2046344727,
-0.3283800483,
0.4410106838,
-0.3110519648,
-0.1084955335,
0.0162715577,
0.1935142428,
0.0611770377,
0.4790490866,
0.1240739226,
0.8598512411,
0.3934932947,
-0.6267024875,
0.2247640193,
0.1349701583,
-0.1783118397,
0.2818491161,
-0.9828881025,
0.3897942305,
-0.2287159562,
0.2286035269,
-0.6937864423,
0.27072227,
-0.0087448619,
-0.3651224673,
0.3511657715,
-0.2901002467,
-0.2880117893,
-0.4355351925,
-0.3718247414,
0.5433089733,
0.6830847859,
-0.7114470005,
0.6864029169,
0.0341598019,
0.0516858026,
-0.8683002591,
-1.0240631104,
-0.0447146781,
0.1790310442,
-0.5693024397,
0.7780752182,
-0.0184756089,
0.2278330773,
0.2502892315,
-0.3387460411,
0.1895042062,
-0.2362235188,
0.2684647441,
0.0942636207,
-0.3405268192,
0.1562348753,
-0.0209737141,
-0.1721988022,
-0.252294153,
-0.556663394,
0.4520022869,
-0.3079426289,
-0.3440841734,
-0.0052886899,
0.3103759587,
0.1651841104,
0.0221618395,
0.6932451725,
1.1073737144,
-0.3420639932,
-0.1276747733,
-0.652195096,
-0.513876915,
-0.4691218138,
0.0917872861,
-0.4201298058,
-1.0210740566,
0.3026095927,
0.1901944578,
-0.3667553663,
0.5423497558,
0.3894313574,
-0.2031899542,
0.856865108,
0.7564797997,
-0.3345271349,
0.4773014486,
-0.4368445873,
0.4451696873,
-0.7091875672,
-0.3392027617,
-0.7504461408,
-0.8889003396,
-0.9117942452,
-0.4973855019,
0.3536134362,
-0.0433751158,
-0.0983744562,
0.3767775595,
-0.6983908415,
0.3881748319,
0.8379701376,
0.3630782068,
0.1729699522,
0.0998253673,
-0.2192394286,
-0.2443810552,
-1.0006715059,
-0.20517537,
0.7576640248,
0.2089353949,
1.4137229919,
-0.0599674024,
0.5899577141,
0.5346025825,
-0.0955705792,
-0.7306725383,
0.3342197537,
-0.6405325532,
-0.4336433411,
-0.4319183528,
-0.65982306,
-1.0180753469,
0.006053166,
-0.2142517865,
-0.5439590216,
0.7145166397,
-0.1570024788,
-0.3411041796,
0.5401247144,
-0.6273645163,
0.7913538218,
-0.4343719184,
-0.7214618325,
-0.1188840419,
-0.7923856378,
-0.1208505183,
0.0992571712,
-0.4442542493,
0.3178708255,
-0.1992251724,
0.6872466207,
-0.0986809433,
0.5380008221,
-0.2444661409,
0.1091031432,
0.1566995382,
-0.0255811196,
0.7286695838,
0.1603446603,
-0.2320979089,
0.4285649061,
-0.3485817015,
-0.4395588934,
-0.6681594849,
0.7752562165,
-0.8808246255,
-0.3596207798,
-0.1701942682,
-0.2315997779,
-0.1298113912,
0.1941595972,
0.6360119581,
0.1930746287,
-0.0307439473,
0.8418858051,
0.9019313455,
-0.1589686424,
0.4485824406,
0.1303582042,
0.5282341242,
-0.1846795231,
0.6854071617,
0.1972161233,
-0.141195491,
0.8149672151,
0.0010752878,
-0.3376030028,
-0.4710439742,
-0.1719320565,
0.1243299618,
-0.5664716363,
-0.2191202939,
-0.8895118833,
-0.2650783658,
-0.2672235966,
-0.3339623809,
-0.5554060936,
-0.3358844221,
-0.2713381052,
0.0029334729,
0.0845678449,
0.450283587,
-0.0387720205,
0.4080741704,
-0.7439668179,
0.4984641075,
0.320600301,
0.6977958679,
0.0647893697,
-0.5903824568,
-0.6601721644,
-0.132675156,
-0.153891623,
-0.325506568,
0.1806023121,
-0.0024864108,
0.5598599911,
0.1613022685,
0.0877349153,
0.5260672569,
-0.521278441,
0.8230397105,
0.076133877,
-0.8467362523,
0.4440768063,
0.1110668555,
0.4759479463,
0.5720689297,
0.6720033288,
-0.4269395173,
0.0718303919,
-0.5584201813,
-0.8757303357,
0.745259583,
0.3664733469,
0.0823233947,
0.2722919583,
0.3128154576,
0.192872718,
0.2036530077,
-0.5845167041,
-0.1296316832,
-0.2991014719,
-0.1501554102,
-0.1741992682,
-0.3103032112,
0.2058863789,
-0.1892250031,
0.5785304904,
-0.2035564929,
0.6923594475,
0.4320690632,
-0.1425717026,
-0.1374078393,
0.4080186188,
0.1977786124,
0.036185611,
-0.4827023745,
0.2316329628,
0.4301620126,
-0.5604671836,
0.0222397596,
0.2714751959,
-0.307077527,
0.2212693393,
0.3669942319,
1.0372647047,
0.3584721982,
-0.2736571133,
0.4393787086,
-0.2937566936,
-0.0053749266,
0.1569852233,
0.0699643195,
-0.1207999364,
0.4353454411,
0.3539654613,
0.274980247,
0.3578684926,
-0.295075953,
0.1144122109,
0.5608299971,
-0.683116138,
-0.191636309,
0.8775579333,
0.192222774,
-0.1360413134,
0.8545818925,
0.1546525359,
-0.2631120086,
0.3266071975,
0.1757945418,
1.0144388676,
0.1470132917,
-0.0718046054,
0.0684862584,
0.6910973787,
-0.0908777118,
0.0474432111,
-0.6173172593,
-0.4463939965,
-0.1942812651,
-0.6389770508,
-0.5771464109,
-0.108833313,
-0.5066190958,
0.1598528028,
-0.2458995283,
-0.4565598667,
-0.057981357,
0.3263685405,
-1.1461954117,
0.2618874907,
0.2574746013,
0.9563934803,
-0.3188692927,
0.6971164942,
0.3363238275,
-0.4337182343,
-0.3444607854,
0.0432038903,
-0.6520555019,
-0.3690286577,
0.6133557558,
-0.040819183,
-0.3247791529,
-0.2121746689,
-0.3833850026,
-0.7136992812,
1.2792806625,
0.4106198549,
-0.8781745434,
-0.6375001073,
0.2809782326,
0.7759357691,
-0.1986676306,
0.7619565725,
0.2929193079,
0.5333319902,
0.0399868414,
-0.6794741154,
0.0612393767,
-0.2239022702,
0.1277101487,
0.0874353573,
-0.6955373287,
0.8315503597,
-0.316867888,
-0.0565924346,
-0.0881764367,
0.4545485973,
-0.2949413061,
0.3538483679,
0.3196616471,
0.5966402292,
0.629142642,
-0.3729993701,
1.3682904243,
-0.2946533859,
0.3648742139,
0.7904869914,
-0.0944585726,
0.6442273855,
0.4201460183,
-0.0935857967,
0.6169672012,
0.4716334045,
-0.2114680707,
0.7152830362,
-0.2205636799,
0.0945911556,
-0.4451701343,
-0.0595709644,
-0.4994786382,
0.1248408854,
0.0849131122,
-0.5433796048,
-0.0071675908,
-0.0300691016,
-0.5451201797,
-0.384758383,
-0.2426799089,
0.6609774232,
0.285556823,
-0.2863144875,
0.4225299358,
0.1101994365,
1.0006066561,
-0.6079030037,
0.1454532444,
-0.3845762312,
0.2634527087,
-0.395642072,
-0.670501411,
0.0768432245,
-0.0344328955,
-0.5275037289,
-0.1603147388,
1.2053289413,
-0.2455764264,
-0.4488462806,
0.5591640472,
0.5947899818,
-0.0794258565,
-0.0903295502,
-0.4785080552,
-0.0443087183,
-0.3480078578,
-0.3848959506,
0.1964876652,
0.5374541879,
0.1400903463,
0.5483142138,
0.576644063,
0.0729519948,
0.078828074,
0.2302654982,
0.8427740932,
-0.9763252735,
-0.432780683,
-0.5838852525,
0.2623091638,
0.0470118821,
0.1727204472,
0.6915258169,
0.6140344739,
0.9828099012,
-0.1179158762,
0.7419694662,
-0.0095966822,
0.0299256034,
-0.4410383701,
0.5959908962,
-0.7175787687,
0.4966333807,
-0.1409756243,
-0.9807778001,
-0.0114642866,
0.4178714156,
-0.5524427891,
0.4841337502,
0.6668765545,
0.6544490457,
-0.4008806646,
0.0805018842,
0.487534523,
0.0242407992,
0.1214433387,
0.822927177,
0.6145244837,
-0.8344092369,
0.9287077188,
-0.3671842515,
0.3144258261,
-0.3435443938,
-0.3783840835,
-0.9658432007,
-0.1449608803,
-0.0178435519,
-0.268227011,
0.2843248844,
0.5423099399,
0.9172902107,
-0.7462182045,
0.0704651773,
0.1268368512,
0.2466179579,
-0.1505309343,
-0.1954392493,
0.2559258938,
-0.2167957723,
-0.7286441922,
0.3872962892,
0.2645771503,
0.014129838,
-0.2397800088,
-0.3286837041,
-0.1304488927,
0.0892114788,
0.5844612122,
0.0067684744,
-0.5044208169,
-0.3620307446,
0.2754662633,
-0.5092090368,
0.2180815041,
0.8750503063,
-1.3387317657,
0.1431092322,
0.7350085974,
0.9587415457,
1.0800430775,
-0.0902932733,
0.2105639428,
-0.8785852194,
-0.097175099,
0.5736927986,
0.2198211998,
0.2908900976,
-0.5898101926,
0.7193353772,
0.3386433125,
-0.5788373947,
-0.5509195924,
-0.2049591839,
-0.9167704582,
-0.0319702327,
0.7113842964,
0.2809451818,
-0.1735060811,
0.1626687497,
0.0463081263,
0.1421471387,
-0.6470463276,
0.799000442,
0.4221475422,
-0.1590677202,
-0.2979311347,
-0.3496614397,
0.3501642048,
0.5732679963,
-0.475641191,
-0.4463662803,
0.0548401698,
-0.1231326833,
0.3128125966,
0.3643595278,
0.0095273741,
0.1695913821,
0.2866880298,
-0.1605454385,
0.1036753953,
-0.4708553851,
-0.1986275017,
0.4702010751,
-0.3887287974,
0.0798070207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20215v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20215v1
|
Advancing the Arabic WordNet: Elevating Content Quality
| 2024-03-29T14:54:19 | 2024-03-29T14:54:19 |
Abed Alhakim Freihat, Hadi Khalilia, Gábor Bella, Fausto Giunchiglia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
High-quality WordNets are crucial for achieving high-quality results in NLP
applications that rely on such resources. However, the wordnets of most
languages suffer from serious issues of correctness and completeness with
respect to the words and word meanings they define, such as incorrect lemmas,
missing glosses and example sentences, or an inadequate, Western-centric
representation of the morphology and the semantics of the language. Previous
efforts have largely focused on increasing lexical coverage while ignoring
other qualitative aspects. In this paper, we focus on the Arabic language and
introduce a major revision of the Arabic WordNet that addresses multiple
dimensions of lexico-semantic resource quality. As a result, we updated more
than 58% of the synsets of the existing Arabic WordNet by adding missing
information and correcting errors. In order to address issues of language
diversity and untranslatability, we also extended the wordnet structure by new
elements: phrasets and lexical gaps.
|
[
-0.5070288181,
-0.2418842018,
0.1060821414,
0.1383866519,
-0.1606984884,
0.4163884521,
0.0082776062,
-0.3902844191,
0.3589725792,
0.4046549499,
-0.0453771502,
-0.7969508171,
-0.9651796818,
0.1051585153,
-0.5598093271,
0.9609060287,
-0.2678993046,
-0.3796705306,
0.238882333,
-0.7824742794,
-0.52953583,
-0.2269499451,
-0.6392533779,
-0.1294051409,
0.7613168955,
0.4902842641,
1.5269519091,
0.5731759667,
0.434612602,
0.3341571987,
-0.4241662323,
0.7105711699,
-0.1490984261,
0.050681293,
-0.4912451208,
0.0892809182,
-0.5054854751,
-0.4292314351,
0.6969641447,
0.9350216985,
-0.20298706,
-0.0284962542,
0.0964438245,
1.2387869358,
-0.9137361646,
-0.0599902458,
-0.4542554319,
0.004075726,
-0.1050492898,
-0.0528896637,
0.218915239,
-0.1568946838,
-0.0230109561,
-0.489061892,
0.0258536153,
-0.2135299146,
0.8199389577,
0.1049306765,
-0.4846625924,
-0.3195534348,
-0.55108428,
0.4845924377,
-0.7394150496,
0.3663291335,
0.5751063228,
0.1486710906,
-0.3294624686,
-0.7535616159,
-0.4445971251,
-0.0636423454,
0.1708095521,
0.1436219513,
-0.2741776407,
0.0891114846,
-0.0761166885,
0.379986614,
-0.1851392984,
-0.1260665059,
-0.2749050558,
-0.4012045562,
0.6081491113,
-0.0471946485,
0.6583222151,
0.1438198835,
0.1170262471,
-0.2574515343,
-0.7156216502,
-0.1273695081,
0.4151553512,
0.1568707228,
0.1163162142,
0.6828693748,
-0.4489454329,
0.6043482423,
-0.6079189181,
0.0372570939,
0.3606586754,
-0.703705132,
0.0783510581,
0.3373252153,
0.11422728,
0.2619354129,
-0.1912630945,
0.0082358681,
-0.37044698,
-0.1310246885,
0.5703065395,
-0.5180104375,
0.0618071742,
0.5896359086,
-0.3744126856,
-0.0056926846,
0.2817205787,
-0.1883642077,
-0.4565729201,
-0.2259000689,
0.4895554185,
-0.6859986782,
-0.2649768293,
0.3744333088,
-0.150991708,
0.1178217307,
0.6216659546,
-0.4828236997,
0.0599443689,
0.6871449947,
1.0499147177,
0.1256018728,
-0.2625275254,
-0.0217814911,
0.1759478897,
-0.8353531957,
0.4785057008,
-0.2912729383,
-0.1626438349,
0.3979755342,
-0.1886833012,
0.3302309215,
-0.558160603,
0.6404794455,
-0.8302099705,
-0.1048174798,
-0.3878144324,
-0.4363005161,
-0.5319147706,
0.5492569208,
-0.771815002,
0.7500843406,
0.3944438994,
-0.784622252,
-0.0640745163,
-0.7243593335,
-0.3648213148,
0.0269683935,
0.1327796727,
-0.2259305418,
0.2680984735,
0.1817317605,
-0.0335923955,
0.1830891669,
-0.1442477703,
0.4414133132,
-0.3575356901,
0.4623173475,
-0.1429608166,
0.5260224342,
0.3523814976,
-0.2195558399,
0.2222540826,
-0.8562915921,
0.2086805999,
-0.321172744,
-0.3745539784,
-0.3281103969,
0.0807151422,
0.1570167243,
0.3492178917,
0.3606416881,
-0.6176058054,
0.022477366,
-0.6047536731,
0.1642756611,
0.4952527285,
0.0076298583,
0.3210959435,
-0.5571905971,
0.371214211,
0.4730087221,
0.2599332333,
-0.0888001993,
-0.4043874145,
-1.074075222,
0.0554447807,
0.6520947814,
0.3036908805,
-1.1496280432,
0.4600575566,
-0.2233800888,
-0.5240819454,
-0.559235394,
0.1229352057,
0.1294720471,
-0.149077937,
0.6580348611,
-0.7210819125,
-0.2779143453,
-0.6515423656,
-0.0638136789,
-0.2050778568,
-0.0519349873,
0.0682762265,
0.4600817263,
-0.4767066538,
0.6989294291,
-0.1644757986,
-0.5514400601,
-0.3670944273,
0.069137089,
0.267234236,
0.4059035778,
0.2087457776,
-0.6481280923,
-0.4172157645,
0.1432389617,
-0.3090371788,
-0.0889695063,
-0.0096420841,
-0.2464283705,
0.1344232708,
0.371394068,
-0.3810420632,
0.5446482301,
0.7125356197,
-0.5352275968,
0.4523249865,
-0.2007177174,
0.1517923176,
-1.2884224653,
-0.0667352825,
-0.4044726491,
0.0430962034,
-0.51557827,
0.3355327249,
-0.2196961194,
-0.177675575,
-0.5119642019,
0.4417690337,
-0.3766670227,
-0.0817977041,
-0.7040930986,
0.1577711254,
0.2842920125,
-0.0432691388,
-0.4946786463,
0.902659297,
0.5376111865,
-0.4904627502,
0.5655027628,
0.4511430264,
-0.4043894708,
0.3209246993,
-0.8055926561,
-0.0973269865,
-0.4517456591,
0.1736182868,
-0.6147980094,
0.0494190603,
0.2346752435,
-0.4819085896,
0.1093675122,
0.1266197115,
-0.4886156917,
0.0994966179,
-0.3296660781,
0.5409862399,
0.1435806155,
-0.2232126445,
0.4440368414,
0.2090494931,
-0.0705227554,
-0.9430626631,
-0.3652831018,
0.7170194387,
0.5641214848,
-0.6225908399,
0.6007214189,
0.46582219,
-0.3093265593,
0.2841654718,
-0.2719019651,
-0.2600594163,
0.0985769778,
0.0460701436,
-0.376737237,
-0.1850738227,
0.2170772851,
-0.0594503842,
-0.0751735196,
-0.2732301354,
-0.7288426757,
0.5277991295,
0.0497109219,
-0.4698810577,
-0.4686635137,
0.728222847,
0.3761138916,
-0.6045500636,
1.1081451178,
0.8123897314,
-0.4648296535,
-0.0693756565,
-0.4075416028,
0.0075730579,
-0.4308345318,
0.7002674937,
-0.1273745,
-0.9151688218,
0.5373991728,
0.0773749799,
0.3447310328,
0.5994238853,
0.1976382732,
-0.0766239539,
0.959290266,
0.8630189896,
-0.1052094325,
0.2069908381,
-0.1185269877,
0.2156125605,
-0.9890308976,
-0.0854491293,
-0.7055463195,
-0.4887599647,
-0.8489410281,
-0.6252408028,
0.39340204,
0.0550779775,
-0.1933502704,
0.4222899973,
-0.105052352,
0.2090189904,
0.5886077285,
0.0933698639,
0.2488925159,
0.3810168207,
-0.2355230451,
0.08250276,
-0.6563520432,
-0.6321358681,
0.5764180422,
0.3237599134,
0.4499930739,
0.8371130228,
0.4912648201,
0.6611018181,
0.0123181883,
-0.5488269925,
0.179784596,
-0.1819333434,
-0.4436043799,
-0.4289917946,
-0.4012929499,
-1.0828353167,
0.3636799157,
-0.008184134,
-0.3333971202,
0.1524963677,
-0.0780257657,
-0.3390716016,
0.3576979637,
-0.0180871449,
0.6178041101,
0.2277971357,
-0.3254621625,
-0.6098774076,
-0.4979824126,
-0.3052536547,
-0.0018415499,
0.0752392411,
-0.2970942259,
-0.4441340864,
0.6182635427,
-0.82371521,
0.5114687085,
0.0617806427,
-0.2994018197,
0.6715218425,
0.2454006374,
0.1017413586,
-0.0302329194,
-0.1309485883,
0.3169060946,
0.1350634992,
-0.9775794148,
-0.6676012278,
0.3901600242,
-1.0597199202,
-0.3732294142,
-0.5618970394,
-0.4730441272,
-0.311131537,
-0.0093815261,
-0.2346086204,
0.6743600368,
-0.110486567,
0.1282348186,
0.3653343618,
-0.7255442142,
0.2955414057,
0.2432559282,
-0.0343373939,
-0.4846440554,
0.9258095622,
0.2622621655,
0.1472631991,
0.313308388,
-0.0609132163,
-0.3296557367,
-0.9182528853,
-0.5418044925,
-0.0940896124,
-0.7832972407,
-0.2859248817,
-0.4558560252,
-0.6871432662,
-0.2369160205,
0.0271826554,
-0.4032172561,
-0.5225865245,
-0.0823551491,
0.1242330745,
0.3308573663,
0.7459801435,
-0.2649933398,
0.4630753994,
-1.3982099295,
-0.03965538,
0.0677323416,
0.2895949781,
0.1484847814,
-0.8060606718,
-0.511574924,
0.0270996857,
-0.4163544178,
-0.6513137221,
0.2431794703,
0.3478395939,
0.0769727603,
0.1160094962,
-0.0850448981,
0.4734550416,
-0.6062505245,
0.8690392971,
0.2640696168,
-0.8712289929,
0.5290942192,
-0.1508844942,
0.7469264865,
0.6846843362,
0.2978178859,
-1.3291165829,
-0.2081347406,
-0.6444609165,
-1.0612556934,
0.2460239679,
0.4991784692,
0.5912329555,
-0.0015403384,
0.3911648095,
-0.1239487976,
0.2185178846,
-0.0986282602,
-0.2177203596,
-0.5308123231,
-0.2991352677,
0.1947319806,
-0.5458275676,
-0.0605439283,
0.0244612265,
0.8899914622,
-0.1745503992,
0.0562441163,
0.2777908742,
-0.2667527795,
0.2222367078,
0.5574889779,
0.6866790652,
1.1733481884,
0.1084129289,
0.4443548322,
0.1787404865,
-0.6532013416,
0.4113773108,
-0.1255634278,
-0.3508611023,
0.303132683,
0.543494761,
0.513656795,
-0.2754222453,
-0.4321385026,
0.5577370524,
0.1761015803,
0.1989027411,
-0.3072746694,
-0.073754169,
-0.0727158636,
0.0066585494,
0.2962081432,
0.267726481,
0.0751639828,
-0.5811573267,
0.3509233594,
-0.0264967866,
-0.7630681396,
-0.1809459776,
-0.087452583,
0.2648636699,
-0.0617761202,
0.6901535988,
-0.3460749984,
-0.6099457741,
0.4607857168,
0.3044060767,
0.3586643934,
-0.1840425134,
0.5059460402,
0.4080418944,
0.430141747,
0.0912258476,
0.6907233596,
0.2711420059,
-1.079621315,
-0.7425256968,
-0.6428215504,
-0.4636024237,
-0.185043335,
-0.2324866652,
-0.2612012923,
-0.6008230448,
-0.2539805174,
-0.4815732837,
0.1025646701,
-0.337508589,
0.3440814614,
0.0256351735,
1.1504635811,
-0.3003916442,
0.6620090604,
0.842895627,
-0.4697885215,
-0.7652400732,
-0.1237459555,
-0.3026202321,
-0.6765502095,
0.4925723672,
-0.019859435,
-0.2028595358,
0.1383009106,
-0.2954663932,
-1.1799526215,
0.7284239531,
-0.0445681512,
-0.2931986153,
0.2558000088,
0.5426545143,
0.4260367155,
0.1898571551,
0.2098346502,
0.1815046072,
0.4509792328,
0.0855607912,
-0.6294323206,
0.063323319,
-0.0881696716,
0.4770917296,
0.2157697976,
-0.3915963769,
0.5416555405,
-0.0933128372,
-0.2419901043,
0.1905017495,
1.1100480556,
-0.1182857752,
-0.2439410985,
0.3204269409,
0.7975747585,
0.5889586806,
-0.2836908996,
0.8168084621,
-0.4654913843,
0.0266090557,
0.7289148569,
-0.1594925821,
0.7923274636,
0.2342507392,
-0.1715444177,
0.4651173353,
0.5391711593,
0.2638972402,
0.2113930732,
0.4972669482,
-0.7814676762,
0.0466656871,
-0.819536984,
-0.5266587138,
0.7114146948,
0.434156239,
-0.1718313098,
-0.4492506385,
-0.2172202766,
0.1023054868,
0.2087891847,
-0.5293793082,
0.6263298392,
0.0068442887,
-0.340957582,
0.3942758739,
0.7494958043,
0.4770923853,
-0.4352531135,
-0.1667374671,
-0.4789029658,
0.0494914949,
-0.4175620079,
-0.7248609066,
0.699467957,
-0.3180171549,
0.1206662878,
0.0069748298,
0.7496159673,
-0.3349074721,
-0.4842621386,
0.138280198,
0.7706118822,
0.1241839007,
-0.272985518,
-0.6961129904,
0.2659825683,
-0.3243229091,
0.32756266,
0.1156020164,
0.5550217032,
-0.0064205718,
0.3106488585,
0.6349625587,
0.3959079981,
-0.0542199239,
0.4967209399,
0.7378132939,
-0.6988897324,
-0.3888946176,
-0.7350049019,
0.3928972781,
-0.334861815,
-0.4313819408,
0.4913963079,
0.3448401392,
0.9364340305,
0.365054518,
0.5647614002,
-0.1319155246,
0.1149868518,
-0.4795626998,
0.9983801842,
-0.5704572201,
-0.0803721994,
-0.0152842291,
-1.0559207201,
-0.4194594324,
0.6990629435,
0.41933617,
0.065086633,
0.6629922986,
0.7925817966,
0.053000953,
-0.0418391451,
0.4911909401,
0.2188997865,
0.1845480055,
0.3284790516,
0.9877497554,
-0.7610250711,
0.2749502361,
-0.2369917184,
-0.143660754,
0.0413777418,
-0.7613850236,
-0.3296405971,
-0.7606040835,
-0.5579880476,
-0.7529691458,
0.4536079466,
1.1526647806,
0.4445557892,
-1.0574595928,
-0.1988443136,
0.0653574392,
0.2718872428,
-0.4023946822,
-0.0906894356,
0.5682795048,
-0.4340204895,
-0.2852657437,
0.2017980665,
0.4100386202,
0.0172558129,
-0.1653735936,
0.0987445191,
-0.260217011,
0.0441984311,
0.9167998433,
0.2179078311,
-0.3955194354,
-0.5964038968,
-0.2719578445,
-0.2621066272,
0.1130326539,
0.5645551085,
-0.3082998693,
0.0811260343,
0.3768685758,
1.246737361,
-0.1252353191,
-0.2338320464,
0.4205677807,
-0.9128396511,
0.1336830556,
0.2969351709,
0.4125536084,
0.7464023829,
0.1698717475,
0.4302639365,
0.077470772,
-0.2462202609,
-0.0837688372,
0.591168642,
-0.6824388504,
-0.3045844436,
1.1170113087,
-0.0880714804,
-0.2215493023,
-0.3808006346,
-0.3382753432,
0.4693054259,
-0.1332990825,
0.9218523502,
0.8648039699,
0.2848598063,
-0.0836278871,
-0.6236900687,
0.3740289509,
0.7347265482,
-0.5620560646,
-0.3340523839,
0.4391865134,
-0.0253091585,
0.3184569478,
0.4002546966,
-0.2765476704,
0.3181862831,
-0.1622817218,
0.2224808633,
0.1574905217,
-0.4222960174,
-0.0550039522,
0.1055070385,
0.5381175876,
-0.2024192512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20196v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20196v2
|
Automatic Alignment of Discourse Relations of Different Discourse Annotation Frameworks
| 2024-03-29T14:18:26 | 2024-04-06T13:54:43 |
Yingxue Fu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing discourse corpora are annotated based on different frameworks, which
show significant dissimilarities in definitions of arguments and relations and
structural constraints. Despite surface differences, these frameworks share
basic understandings of discourse relations. The relationship between these
frameworks has been an open research question, especially the correlation
between relation inventories utilized in different frameworks. Better
understanding of this question is helpful for integrating discourse theories
and enabling interoperability of discourse corpora annotated under different
frameworks. However, studies that explore correlations between discourse
relation inventories are hindered by different criteria of discourse
segmentation, and expert knowledge and manual examination are typically needed.
Some semi-automatic methods have been proposed, but they rely on corpora
annotated in multiple frameworks in parallel. In this paper, we introduce a
fully automatic approach to address the challenges. Specifically, we extend the
label-anchored contrastive learning method introduced by Zhang et al. (2022b)
to learn label embeddings during a classification task. These embeddings are
then utilized to map discourse relations from different frameworks. We show
experimental results on RST-DT (Carlson et al., 2001) and PDTB 3.0 (Prasad et
al., 2018).
|
[
-0.4396620393,
-0.5047891736,
0.5359854698,
0.159496069,
-0.2418698072,
0.2708288431,
0.1177056357,
-0.5953838825,
0.2145394385,
0.3550627232,
-0.1777242422,
-0.5595434904,
-0.5457428694,
0.2405218184,
-0.0521163344,
0.9112858176,
-0.397929281,
0.1139476672,
-0.3019768,
-0.657569468,
-0.3123870194,
-0.2427070737,
-0.2658189833,
-0.2235455811,
0.3810219467,
0.0216949638,
0.7932546735,
0.8449992537,
0.4317865074,
0.3861558139,
-0.2134995908,
0.2005408555,
-0.0847826302,
0.1047919914,
-0.5591922402,
0.0160178971,
-0.2784354389,
-0.2247518301,
0.5428289771,
0.8774752021,
0.2246028334,
0.0643305182,
0.3027130663,
0.1532270163,
-0.7441667914,
0.2242884189,
-0.411165148,
0.1689332128,
-0.0799771175,
-0.2654148042,
-0.4237931073,
-0.3857664466,
0.410338074,
-0.7159411907,
-0.092153728,
0.1927306801,
1.2739654779,
0.2182195187,
-0.7456386685,
-0.4365131259,
-0.3499904573,
0.6458063126,
-0.4936895072,
0.1636654139,
0.1578682065,
0.20885773,
0.1156877428,
-0.5172071457,
-0.1866172701,
0.1812736392,
-0.82722193,
0.0981552526,
-0.05797543,
0.2846413851,
0.1279875934,
0.3597094715,
-0.4123737514,
0.3263296783,
-0.2098524123,
-0.3767734468,
0.1101713926,
0.0495057739,
0.1694243252,
-0.2514125705,
-0.7836892009,
0.0292224251,
-0.5133352876,
-0.3804118931,
0.1732039303,
0.1695953906,
-0.2553180754,
0.4154561162,
0.351742357,
0.8127660751,
0.2908759713,
-0.0121970624,
0.5167730451,
-0.34534958,
-0.3222833872,
0.1393453181,
1.0424160957,
0.1951926053,
-0.1361173093,
0.0688024908,
0.0847123265,
-0.1133897156,
0.0307643991,
-0.5501635075,
-0.2470239848,
-0.0554147139,
-0.2138092369,
-0.2303485274,
0.0076471916,
-0.7671963573,
-0.4443624616,
-0.4278658032,
0.3036447763,
-0.2481632531,
-0.2293092757,
-0.4500095546,
0.1187674925,
0.4233421385,
0.174442634,
-0.877466917,
0.4312015474,
0.7146196961,
0.8190937042,
-0.4776741266,
-0.0626646951,
-0.4875907898,
0.5551115274,
-0.2467462122,
0.8961763978,
-0.7429859638,
-0.0991691053,
0.3565601707,
0.2115126401,
-0.267823875,
-0.4537534416,
0.5478923917,
-0.5374314189,
0.5706976652,
-0.1792222857,
-0.7848923206,
-0.3545387089,
0.442189157,
-0.6261030436,
0.8957713842,
0.1474509239,
-1.2963294983,
0.0066029574,
-0.451403141,
-0.4743988514,
-0.1078342348,
-0.4187494218,
-0.5777547956,
-0.2987814844,
0.3173855841,
0.5008795261,
-0.2894255519,
0.586545825,
-0.4551438689,
-0.1988682896,
0.1605093926,
0.1241518632,
1.2040840387,
0.0267934445,
-0.3928436339,
0.4526360035,
-0.6746179461,
-0.1845316589,
-0.3856503069,
0.2264567912,
-0.6541759968,
-0.3918803334,
-0.0950940475,
0.1605564207,
0.2042081207,
-0.3482641578,
-0.0682185069,
-0.6043820381,
0.2089402229,
0.8273552656,
0.1654069573,
0.5753010511,
-0.0977912396,
0.5215802789,
0.3574995697,
-0.2918629646,
-0.3908750713,
-0.3019724488,
-0.810033083,
-0.3810230494,
0.7473753691,
0.7328802943,
-0.5164224505,
0.6151618361,
-0.2470192611,
-0.3553388417,
-0.6273399591,
-0.1076248661,
0.7847786546,
0.8390500546,
0.6042584181,
-0.3200553656,
-0.7018036246,
-1.0761104822,
0.0537502021,
-0.2113803029,
0.0124375932,
0.1984880269,
0.4950381815,
-0.0027347838,
1.0005016327,
-0.6512061954,
-0.3760159612,
0.5112553835,
0.5304664373,
-0.3949312568,
0.5497408509,
0.657264173,
-0.7500601411,
-0.7677410841,
0.2504602969,
-0.7906913757,
-0.3703106344,
-0.0811752006,
-0.4827911854,
0.2345369607,
0.5581576824,
-0.2001496404,
0.1949150711,
0.3767209649,
-0.1737068594,
0.3711387515,
0.1098599359,
-0.0092744445,
-1.3841153383,
0.1228756979,
0.1842802316,
-0.1589639634,
-0.3931044042,
-0.1702100933,
0.1671648175,
0.1172938943,
-0.4164643288,
0.574875772,
-0.5965589285,
-0.378460139,
0.088742815,
0.3363314271,
0.2464415431,
0.6099265218,
0.2800067067,
0.5384750962,
0.4990818501,
-0.4848527312,
-0.0014720726,
0.4579350054,
-0.0057994043,
0.856515944,
-0.3429132998,
0.0240478255,
0.2054882199,
0.3382267058,
-1.1598936319,
0.016270645,
0.7177456021,
-0.1692541838,
0.3463682532,
-0.288346231,
-0.2712685466,
0.2158180773,
-0.28774786,
0.3857854605,
0.0630100369,
-0.5468646884,
0.6219975948,
0.6880289912,
-0.2416206151,
-0.9004288912,
-0.5759404302,
-0.1321837753,
-0.4560532868,
-0.4012117684,
0.7380183339,
0.1087648422,
-0.4072079062,
0.2876585722,
0.0374607109,
-0.2942297757,
-0.0281520374,
0.3048618436,
0.3012757003,
-0.3132871687,
0.2250033021,
0.4862252474,
-0.1658646464,
-0.0710330978,
-0.2929503322,
-0.0594914816,
-0.0774442628,
-0.3197377324,
-0.5097776651,
0.2905925512,
0.3286956847,
-0.1553697586,
0.592256844,
0.4598059654,
-0.3654535413,
0.3966825306,
-0.5847595334,
0.1776853055,
-0.4428872466,
-0.0278697237,
-0.5355088711,
-0.8785942197,
0.5512861609,
-0.2853814065,
0.2146454453,
0.497094661,
0.2509203255,
-0.008038057,
0.6848825812,
0.6606227756,
0.060921248,
0.164041087,
0.1527518481,
0.0816041082,
-0.8627986312,
-0.0004624904,
-0.5376121998,
-0.2286798954,
-0.8369963765,
-0.4178351462,
-0.0742314234,
-0.0870575085,
-0.3537788391,
0.5139536262,
-0.5880444646,
0.3744441271,
-0.0105862673,
-0.3645702004,
0.387744993,
-0.0443477146,
-0.5908173323,
-0.2261577845,
-0.419339329,
-0.5807054043,
0.6066280603,
0.1937609762,
0.2116659284,
0.044117704,
0.8080406785,
-0.0670340955,
0.7513138652,
-0.6696459651,
0.3882575035,
-0.0205080137,
-0.3528650403,
0.0220959224,
-0.3333676457,
-0.933334291,
0.5399471521,
-0.0955355167,
-0.7261211872,
0.6045849323,
0.1043929756,
-0.3043968976,
0.1226023436,
-0.6316197515,
0.9630932808,
-0.1361530721,
-0.5577392578,
0.2799567878,
-0.9776749015,
0.3620755374,
-0.0199442245,
0.2949842215,
-0.1036265865,
-0.2417546809,
0.7834422588,
-0.1550236344,
0.8790698647,
-0.066722855,
-0.3023863435,
0.1388555914,
-0.0399685726,
0.0737706274,
-0.2991541028,
-0.1007001474,
-0.0558030419,
0.0760256797,
-0.2605151534,
-0.5773198605,
0.6301725507,
-0.6130568385,
-0.4719284773,
-0.6469450593,
-0.3907060027,
-0.3821716309,
0.2656409144,
0.0311587173,
0.1935048401,
-0.542562604,
-0.0973937958,
0.6727080345,
-0.0786478817,
0.2266091108,
0.5286992788,
-0.1811399907,
-0.6931313276,
0.844892025,
0.15877074,
-0.0097269323,
0.7536799312,
0.1302204132,
-0.3172150254,
-0.2024764121,
-0.3714978695,
0.2715533376,
-0.6979069114,
-0.5327777267,
-0.7910535932,
-0.0428735614,
-0.3239216506,
-0.444571197,
-0.1958116144,
-0.5597177744,
-0.4657864571,
-0.2314851284,
0.1832880229,
0.4769678712,
-0.0561848767,
0.2171250731,
-0.5889023542,
0.1277798414,
0.1141389012,
0.0294816215,
-0.011065213,
-0.3996857703,
-0.0511357896,
-0.2023525983,
-0.5769737363,
-1.0905030966,
0.1381008327,
0.1182861328,
0.3157562315,
0.6225404143,
0.1726296842,
0.9132537246,
-0.4008879066,
0.5225646496,
0.3263949454,
-0.9731920362,
0.3936609626,
-0.4189432561,
0.3178554475,
0.6621164083,
0.7575380802,
-0.1504586637,
-0.4065432549,
-0.7124413252,
-0.9856084585,
0.4757183194,
0.0765209273,
-0.2632907331,
0.0673727244,
0.0466249362,
0.3690403998,
0.0464609303,
-0.7365857959,
-0.1397881061,
-0.0407276787,
-0.5302255154,
0.3245500326,
-0.2290534675,
-0.5559164286,
-0.263530761,
0.8149085641,
-0.2457786202,
0.0459030457,
-0.1286325902,
-0.2828407586,
0.0351432525,
0.4127448201,
0.3308835328,
0.860524416,
0.0897274837,
0.3989778161,
0.1282468885,
0.0060491972,
0.3930540383,
0.5554013848,
-0.3718765676,
0.1580934078,
0.1019656807,
0.7386696339,
0.7269924283,
-0.2636799812,
0.5414822698,
0.0339602754,
-0.1570616066,
-0.2741594911,
-0.4571611881,
0.4982436299,
0.078654632,
0.0578403771,
-0.0110832788,
0.0512966141,
-0.335516274,
0.4078426957,
0.2621713281,
-0.5041748881,
-0.1479084343,
0.3292196989,
0.406886369,
-0.1407475322,
0.2594605684,
-0.4772974253,
-0.5509291887,
0.4402852058,
0.4965326488,
0.8444861174,
-0.3681796193,
0.3715910614,
0.5103333592,
-0.0869503245,
0.0272421204,
-0.2402939647,
-0.1661779135,
-0.5963189602,
-0.5055099726,
-0.4983115494,
-0.798030138,
0.0359680466,
-0.8598615527,
0.3618699908,
-0.3570923507,
0.0576312654,
0.2169075459,
0.0135256974,
-0.4018980861,
-0.0712731406,
0.085326992,
0.2900369167,
-0.9989325404,
0.7276813388,
0.8540305495,
-0.3709357083,
-0.5491569638,
0.2439709753,
0.1319359541,
-0.3251571953,
0.6001346111,
0.2702328563,
-0.292575568,
-0.1311162263,
-0.0355407484,
-0.7861716747,
0.9624904394,
0.6398304105,
-0.5561357141,
0.0554053001,
0.0580384657,
0.6218326092,
-0.7149785161,
0.3435967565,
0.430236876,
0.421693325,
0.1022964343,
-0.9492920041,
0.3630156815,
-0.2623656094,
-0.0302201882,
0.2855837643,
-0.4327355325,
0.2690887153,
0.2183059901,
-0.3855791688,
0.0223192591,
1.0183334351,
0.3298892677,
0.3473875821,
0.5704804063,
0.6138555408,
0.782002449,
-0.0026772611,
0.1037775055,
-0.3486272693,
0.1101439819,
1.576031208,
-0.4511618316,
0.7041431665,
0.4229084253,
-0.0386900678,
0.7948009372,
0.7595976591,
-0.2916597724,
0.353207022,
0.075706467,
-0.0833920017,
0.0305354036,
-0.2631257474,
-0.392132014,
0.3151842058,
0.5969642401,
-0.5432301164,
-0.2753997445,
-0.0044844192,
0.2468334436,
0.4211975038,
0.0751722157,
0.9073864818,
0.0966115743,
-0.9831140041,
0.6388561726,
-0.2009821385,
0.5587227345,
-0.2993043661,
-0.0885938853,
0.1600580364,
-0.0134020811,
-0.4001258314,
-0.7347480059,
0.4918260574,
-0.1093310863,
0.1180333793,
-0.2928292155,
0.7069485188,
-0.583029449,
-0.2335942984,
0.5929543376,
0.4266118407,
-0.0146848215,
0.6357095242,
-0.7263073921,
0.1972444057,
-0.0304056834,
-0.0227990244,
0.572635293,
0.4095824957,
-0.0890779495,
0.173690632,
0.030739421,
-0.4229405224,
-0.2294087857,
-0.1980795562,
0.8841156363,
-0.3332398534,
-0.5625847578,
-0.6826588511,
0.4574073255,
-0.4889039099,
-0.221815303,
0.5956174731,
0.7118831277,
0.8036574721,
0.1854297668,
0.6295639873,
0.0073165833,
0.5958844423,
-0.2848571241,
0.3210150898,
-0.2546418905,
0.2150190324,
-0.5128314495,
-1.0523914099,
-0.4410839975,
0.7426284552,
-0.4871979952,
-0.3724228144,
0.9819655418,
0.7081013918,
-0.2518817186,
0.1749217808,
-0.2047608495,
0.1650085002,
0.0660233945,
0.3464477956,
0.4493815601,
-0.294231683,
0.7120838761,
-0.3677847087,
-0.2335354835,
0.0015900395,
-0.9830226898,
-0.7934696674,
-0.8900906444,
-0.901394546,
-0.1919872165,
0.2156792581,
0.6908350587,
0.3187609613,
-0.79589957,
-0.3612500727,
-0.0003745929,
0.244374916,
-0.3192473948,
-0.2788508534,
0.8888047934,
-0.2021597624,
-0.6788530946,
0.142055437,
0.2621835172,
0.1065538153,
-0.2287323028,
0.1499023736,
-0.6073812842,
0.0031147185,
0.3807934523,
0.4627201259,
-0.5747634172,
-0.2805790901,
-0.5032007098,
-0.0198123567,
0.3921658695,
0.7258502245,
-0.7298061252,
0.414080888,
0.6356863976,
0.7622795105,
0.4819679856,
0.1520273387,
0.6325129867,
-0.8831430674,
0.1113974154,
0.367919147,
0.3044700623,
0.6850965619,
-0.0746833161,
0.6211820841,
-0.0036979185,
-0.4086779654,
-0.9792715907,
0.3987838328,
-0.9912852049,
-0.1882727295,
0.9336463809,
-0.6247739196,
-0.1173165888,
-0.3680998981,
-0.2506549358,
0.531816721,
-0.0962942243,
0.6370304823,
0.626894176,
-0.2923838198,
-0.1275488585,
-0.1536924392,
0.5634035468,
0.4609695077,
-0.7904415727,
0.1404571831,
0.3602312803,
0.0443303548,
0.5482800007,
0.6979526877,
-0.2485664487,
-0.0670718253,
-0.2585884333,
-0.3297567368,
0.2745264173,
0.0732769743,
-0.1269211173,
0.5134471059,
-0.2408420891,
-0.1656543016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20184v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20184v1
|
Exploring Pathological Speech Quality Assessment with ASR-Powered Wav2Vec2 in Data-Scarce Context
| 2024-03-29T13:59:34 | 2024-03-29T13:59:34 |
Tuan Nguyen, Corinne Fredouille, Alain Ghio, Mathieu Balaguer, Virginie Woisard
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Automatic speech quality assessment has raised more attention as an
alternative or support to traditional perceptual clinical evaluation. However,
most research so far only gains good results on simple tasks such as binary
classification, largely due to data scarcity. To deal with this challenge,
current works tend to segment patients' audio files into many samples to
augment the datasets. Nevertheless, this approach has limitations, as it
indirectly relates overall audio scores to individual segments. This paper
introduces a novel approach where the system learns at the audio level instead
of segments despite data scarcity. This paper proposes to use the pre-trained
Wav2Vec2 architecture for both SSL, and ASR as feature extractor in speech
assessment. Carried out on the HNC dataset, our ASR-driven approach established
a new baseline compared with other approaches, obtaining average $MSE=0.73$ and
$MSE=1.15$ for the prediction of intelligibility and severity scores
respectively, using only 95 training samples. It shows that the ASR based
Wav2Vec2 model brings the best results and may indicate a strong correlation
between ASR and speech quality assessment. We also measure its ability on
variable segment durations and speech content, exploring factors influencing
its decision.
|
[
-0.1973711997,
-0.5362538099,
0.2597767115,
0.157161504,
-0.5080540776,
0.1788132638,
-0.2756074667,
-0.4966177046,
0.1962951273,
0.3950065076,
-0.4411791265,
-0.250541836,
-0.8090421557,
-0.3146048486,
-0.2437656224,
0.6195546389,
0.2575290501,
0.5130136013,
-0.2481638938,
-0.3706605732,
-0.846642077,
-0.239166826,
-0.6744983792,
-0.2261331528,
0.1751109809,
0.4618265331,
0.329647541,
0.6844057441,
0.5722916126,
0.2217031121,
-0.0966961831,
-0.2554193139,
-0.3005623817,
0.3282622993,
0.1531443298,
0.064952895,
-0.3579722643,
0.1882122159,
0.5823553801,
0.6173580885,
-0.294798255,
0.3738865256,
0.2106390297,
0.4885391593,
-0.5312603712,
-0.01546486,
-0.6072059274,
0.0355318077,
-0.3028064072,
-0.0554050244,
0.0629608631,
-0.2243002206,
0.5073004961,
-0.2495206147,
-0.0639704987,
-0.4652915597,
0.7004357576,
0.6541971564,
-0.2369496524,
-0.395840168,
-0.7370962501,
0.6427537203,
-0.4780631363,
0.5281995535,
0.5843279362,
0.6786026955,
0.3699962497,
-0.7092103958,
-0.1370341927,
-0.2387076318,
0.3863381445,
0.4314504564,
-0.3979937136,
-0.0592392869,
0.0923028216,
0.307448715,
-0.7347524762,
0.4372541904,
-0.6304898262,
-0.7596647143,
0.5575893521,
0.0513763465,
0.143743217,
-0.2449163496,
-0.3309549689,
-0.0796252266,
-0.3769518137,
0.3380453587,
-0.0029737239,
0.267850697,
0.189400807,
0.2989061177,
0.0319751352,
0.4282137156,
-0.2268177569,
-0.0465878248,
0.4616864622,
-0.2956941724,
0.0266084261,
0.4268592,
0.9404075742,
0.1393344551,
-0.0850160792,
0.0560857058,
-0.0046922853,
0.2397909611,
0.3637268245,
-0.732245326,
-0.3762469888,
0.4610236287,
-0.4286327064,
-0.14108859,
-0.0530110672,
-0.7420699596,
-0.2423980385,
-0.1595859528,
0.4713065922,
-0.4255434573,
-0.4230036736,
-0.2051745057,
-0.1121334061,
0.0908197239,
0.1664998531,
-0.6465676427,
0.4206247628,
0.3749608397,
0.7762051225,
-0.2972993553,
0.1800330132,
-1.0352659225,
-0.2602855861,
-0.2840444148,
0.9796928167,
-0.538377285,
-0.5397790074,
-0.1976092905,
-0.2937747538,
0.2272422165,
-0.7005454302,
0.7996127009,
-0.1477994919,
-0.0026771033,
-0.1013458669,
-0.2960243225,
0.1553388834,
-0.2148040533,
-0.5433271527,
0.9362636209,
0.221515432,
-0.359872818,
0.5687577128,
-0.4493251145,
-0.6431424022,
0.3627961874,
-0.3859967887,
-0.4003633261,
0.0790521502,
0.0462587848,
0.1053391472,
-0.0931346938,
0.0605875663,
-0.1222896948,
-0.2827384472,
0.3222687542,
-0.5631992221,
0.4235156476,
0.2571429908,
-0.2290670127,
0.1652112752,
-0.9691067338,
0.343246907,
-0.2727432847,
-0.4627609253,
-0.3464439809,
0.0017776758,
0.1323639005,
0.495265156,
-0.0886953026,
-0.6710389853,
-0.5492733717,
-0.7110720873,
0.4929447472,
0.3921994567,
0.1895575225,
0.090607658,
-0.1427208036,
0.350592196,
-0.2619570196,
0.3666120172,
0.3309427798,
-0.5844244361,
-0.5174459815,
-0.3314501941,
0.495180279,
0.5436292887,
-0.3138288558,
0.4432655275,
-0.2787368,
-0.4821572006,
-1.0744645596,
-0.1549893469,
0.531390667,
0.5175355077,
0.5903582573,
-0.6779661179,
-0.4585315585,
-0.6253948808,
-0.0294144526,
-0.1779232621,
-0.3644356132,
0.5498989224,
0.0423433408,
-0.1200293526,
0.8101176023,
-0.1589906514,
-0.5713593364,
-0.0728450418,
-0.0825771019,
0.0690677613,
0.5896074772,
-0.3169344068,
-0.6908300519,
-0.1974138916,
-0.2833122909,
-0.4114994109,
-0.1579422802,
0.2416696697,
0.1962658316,
-0.0628351495,
0.2866121233,
-0.0411507227,
0.4376325607,
0.5453874469,
-0.28284958,
0.4966383278,
-0.200502947,
0.2014027387,
-0.5845251083,
-0.1008159742,
-0.1110093519,
-0.1915404052,
-0.7082440257,
-0.253924638,
-0.1839034855,
-0.3864424825,
-0.2843214869,
0.2579288781,
-0.2286180109,
-0.2810909152,
-0.4149010181,
0.1249396205,
-0.0415434167,
0.1396132708,
0.1619531959,
0.414603591,
0.607647717,
-0.2719089687,
0.2164726704,
0.3343894184,
-0.4359734952,
0.2091741413,
-0.8773531914,
0.3902919888,
0.3222700059,
0.0293598417,
-0.9542320371,
-0.1629722416,
0.0816477686,
-0.9477861524,
0.4617167115,
-0.2286759019,
0.0737505034,
-0.4497740865,
-0.1192834601,
0.2160185426,
0.860139966,
-0.1157382354,
0.402110368,
0.7843974829,
-0.4772321582,
-0.3637248278,
-0.650475502,
0.0525746159,
-0.118204549,
-0.631385982,
0.2314044237,
-0.1262782216,
-0.2451803237,
-0.0833033323,
-0.4966256618,
-0.1706239432,
0.0665189996,
0.5472703576,
0.0938135162,
-0.3443515301,
0.1594802439,
0.2793036103,
-0.3934598267,
0.103796564,
-0.3085528016,
0.4412252009,
0.016460197,
-0.4430069327,
-0.8015227914,
0.2978372276,
0.5557014346,
-0.4600878358,
-0.1233981997,
0.6815157533,
-0.5135269761,
0.1446221024,
-0.6939480305,
-0.1794573218,
-0.4296726584,
0.5182033181,
-0.4039902985,
-0.7795081139,
0.2506798506,
-0.0485213324,
-0.1668484956,
0.4987627566,
0.5859614611,
-0.2795620263,
0.9088100195,
-0.0174192283,
0.1266282797,
0.3552370965,
-0.1472121626,
-0.1624476463,
-0.7514272928,
-0.3870719671,
-0.511441648,
0.0813354701,
-0.4889318943,
-0.6881987453,
0.6881117225,
-0.0098099802,
0.0894568935,
-0.0816515684,
-0.6793386936,
0.1527887136,
0.3548917174,
0.4401693344,
-0.0674674064,
0.077484414,
0.2003652155,
-0.2401609272,
-0.5295444727,
-0.41371876,
1.0728045702,
0.5831419826,
0.1012943462,
-0.0106993699,
0.4797771573,
0.3725086749,
-0.076297231,
-1.0046520233,
0.1960471272,
-0.4333404899,
-0.2646768987,
-0.761458993,
-0.360948056,
-0.8431982398,
0.1125760302,
-0.3279774785,
-0.5504196882,
0.3536105156,
0.0105365217,
-0.8512639999,
-0.3697026372,
-0.2373368144,
0.6771063805,
-0.2404710799,
-0.3504598141,
-0.4852775335,
-0.9610809684,
-0.0051524974,
-0.1062446386,
0.3445045054,
-0.2277613878,
0.1628518105,
1.1769946814,
-0.511482358,
0.2120690197,
-0.4743134379,
0.3071952462,
0.3855033219,
-0.0709842891,
0.2510510385,
0.1741463244,
-0.2694584429,
0.3942274749,
0.0244250037,
-0.430424124,
-0.6288667321,
0.5452663302,
-0.8525253534,
-0.388492465,
-0.253808558,
-0.1347192079,
-0.6945246458,
-0.0880707949,
0.3267070651,
0.9033043981,
-0.2016279548,
0.0917352065,
0.7351816893,
-0.2340362966,
0.0940213427,
0.5357362032,
0.4863800704,
-0.6248405576,
1.1976203918,
0.2229551673,
0.2834103107,
-0.1248708144,
0.5976151228,
-0.3916820586,
-1.0512952805,
-0.4750609994,
-0.0804090351,
-0.4683439732,
-0.0138181578,
-0.7139188051,
-0.4893679619,
-0.4714994729,
0.2528664172,
-0.6718025804,
-0.2984708846,
-0.3851349056,
-0.0567794703,
0.184415251,
0.4504358172,
-0.2829961777,
0.0039587901,
-0.5976023674,
0.2542632222,
0.5035768151,
0.1615921706,
-0.2581153214,
-0.9696427584,
-0.105250217,
0.0174389929,
-0.0935732201,
-0.5789321065,
0.4409294426,
0.3408493698,
0.4865766764,
0.4900369644,
-0.0762560368,
0.7118700743,
-0.4171389639,
0.8407984376,
0.3392172754,
-0.8323627114,
0.8637055159,
0.1109874845,
0.0933586136,
0.9921563268,
0.1159171537,
-0.2993535995,
-0.5269839764,
-0.737783432,
-0.9869692326,
0.5539013743,
0.3081660867,
-0.1639211625,
0.3054763973,
0.215711683,
0.2177930176,
-0.197756812,
-0.0104964757,
-0.1193393916,
-0.6697917581,
-0.0880646631,
-0.1394682974,
-0.3811186552,
-0.075270839,
-0.4122429788,
0.5630552173,
0.0767498463,
0.4397731721,
0.361246258,
-0.0194817632,
-0.0753263682,
0.2542530596,
0.2411557287,
0.480302304,
-0.2883509696,
-0.0228374694,
0.1900777221,
-0.7609132528,
0.1954934597,
0.4282155633,
0.28637591,
0.0803825557,
0.4401462674,
0.9208011031,
-0.1122260988,
-0.8069525361,
0.9171987176,
-0.1197776496,
-0.1354871392,
-0.3902106881,
0.0779080614,
-0.1207589582,
0.2081090361,
0.2842544913,
0.1418236643,
0.5349408984,
-0.2646837234,
0.5421574712,
0.1886541396,
-1.3320529461,
-0.1893185973,
0.4957663417,
0.310918659,
-0.4853718579,
0.9267799258,
-0.1028173566,
-0.2037702352,
0.4604679048,
0.2713117301,
0.6474931836,
-0.4833432138,
0.0047964086,
0.3370637894,
0.0293343812,
0.1734684408,
0.3204126954,
-0.1367478222,
-0.4181039929,
-0.2937867343,
-0.7657577395,
-0.2205741107,
0.2196400017,
-1.0181267262,
0.1600729525,
-0.3449279964,
-0.1041877419,
0.2044933885,
0.208268553,
-0.4065998793,
0.4425429404,
0.4273207784,
0.7592160702,
-0.7884817123,
1.0518238544,
0.3459080458,
-0.335480243,
-0.9918760657,
0.1495815068,
0.1734110713,
-0.900662899,
0.4030668736,
0.0871827751,
-0.1300063282,
-0.073815994,
-0.0197451767,
-0.8955144882,
0.9683791399,
0.1673248261,
-0.6610324383,
0.2908211052,
-0.0500831008,
0.7742136717,
0.0235992428,
0.3242978454,
0.7951259613,
0.2850886881,
0.4569260478,
-1.0729357004,
0.0813803673,
-0.3196533024,
-0.1469686329,
-0.1275278628,
-0.3421097994,
0.2141918838,
-0.3223342299,
-0.3909368813,
0.0042306539,
0.6572254896,
0.2810832262,
0.5549058318,
0.5889775157,
0.2336441875,
1.0063827038,
0.0011466512,
0.6964222789,
-0.0681934878,
0.1411928833,
0.8567811847,
-0.193815425,
0.91803056,
0.3372199237,
-0.2415918112,
0.3931520879,
0.7437161803,
-0.091698572,
0.7238700986,
0.4283426702,
-0.2439544052,
-0.3790263832,
-0.3708844185,
-0.3080064952,
0.7827652693,
0.4907617569,
-0.1770680398,
0.1946981996,
0.3755175173,
-0.3678436577,
-0.0716160387,
-0.1941802353,
1.0965679884,
0.1457383484,
-0.3816696107,
0.6167476773,
-0.3283585012,
0.3968734741,
-0.5833975673,
0.023594752,
-0.0438492671,
-0.1349523813,
-0.0866550282,
-0.6298851967,
0.5159044862,
0.0265275426,
-0.1275848895,
-0.0820221901,
0.6859177351,
-0.230513081,
-0.428914994,
0.2657513618,
0.3870628178,
0.5280407071,
-0.2201984972,
-0.6137254834,
0.1238197237,
-0.1494917274,
-0.0988449678,
0.4257684052,
0.0180745199,
0.1418244541,
0.4189872146,
0.5209518671,
0.4224576652,
-0.3731587827,
0.2420593649,
0.6935194135,
-0.2979494035,
-0.4640053809,
-0.6407468319,
0.4967527688,
-0.0920085609,
-0.4297310412,
0.1791291833,
0.508695364,
0.2987301648,
0.5850260854,
0.7376444936,
0.1709130257,
0.7209170461,
-0.5576102138,
0.8564407825,
-0.4725328982,
0.2171074748,
-0.2359782755,
-0.2345513552,
-0.2156417221,
0.5467068553,
-0.2902065217,
-0.2256080955,
0.5555695295,
0.6378222704,
0.1242930889,
0.1016373187,
0.5159307718,
0.431235075,
0.2768313885,
0.6973090768,
0.9367719889,
-0.3018387854,
0.6897277236,
-0.043026235,
-0.6972754002,
0.009581943,
-0.106106624,
-0.3958193958,
-0.6244359612,
-0.4513189793,
-0.6203504801,
0.3438282907,
0.9939125776,
0.8092354536,
-0.7458571196,
0.0154663762,
0.135299623,
-0.224283129,
-0.427729398,
-0.1400201917,
0.8102426529,
0.0581326671,
-0.1644590199,
0.825143218,
0.4080673158,
-0.15797849,
-0.0561839417,
-0.0440170579,
0.4140536189,
-0.0788609609,
0.3623464406,
0.1429672539,
-0.6615732908,
-0.1872952729,
-0.3199647367,
-0.0584088452,
0.259919405,
0.6962894201,
-0.9506475925,
0.6624861956,
0.1902797818,
0.4524322152,
0.4379077852,
0.0529327951,
0.3445490897,
-0.3370137811,
-0.1963126212,
0.8894822001,
0.0742163286,
0.3267472088,
-0.3129377961,
0.0338572636,
0.3114237189,
-0.4571528435,
-0.8311933875,
-0.0716737211,
-1.129565835,
-0.2663436234,
1.3818070889,
-0.1781237274,
0.1103100404,
-0.5030828714,
-0.0185406413,
0.4262304604,
-0.4856578112,
0.5154970288,
0.1264079511,
-0.4180413783,
0.1770296246,
-0.6668411493,
0.6823869348,
0.2098182589,
-0.6157847643,
0.0138160307,
0.4547040761,
0.5962872505,
0.0441544205,
0.6506488919,
-0.2643375099,
0.6046586037,
0.1972183436,
-0.0769182965,
-0.227058202,
-0.2054403275,
-0.7817092538,
0.3164356649,
0.0566910766,
-0.3547290564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20180v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20180v1
|
Measuring Taiwanese Mandarin Language Understanding
| 2024-03-29T13:56:21 | 2024-03-29T13:56:21 |
Po-Heng Chen, Sijia Cheng, Wei-Lin Chen, Yen-Ting Lin, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The evaluation of large language models (LLMs) has drawn substantial
attention in the field recently. This work focuses on evaluating LLMs in a
Chinese context, specifically, for Traditional Chinese which has been largely
underrepresented in existing benchmarks. We present TMLU, a holistic evaluation
suit tailored for assessing the advanced knowledge and reasoning capability in
LLMs, under the context of Taiwanese Mandarin. TMLU consists of an array of 37
subjects across social science, STEM, humanities, Taiwan-specific content, and
others, ranging from middle school to professional levels. In addition, we
curate chain-of-thought-like few-shot explanations for each subject to
facilitate the evaluation of complex reasoning skills. To establish a
comprehensive baseline, we conduct extensive experiments and analysis on 24
advanced LLMs. The results suggest that Chinese open-weight models demonstrate
inferior performance comparing to multilingual proprietary ones, and
open-weight models tailored for Taiwanese Mandarin lag behind the
Simplified-Chinese counterparts. The findings indicate great headrooms for
improvement, and emphasize the goal of TMLU to foster the development of
localized Taiwanese-Mandarin LLMs. We release the benchmark and evaluation
scripts for the community to promote future research.
|
[
0.1834929734,
-0.9998723865,
0.7086163759,
0.4335481524,
-0.513117075,
0.3571983874,
-0.7156768441,
-0.1235085949,
-0.2825241387,
0.3402466774,
0.0423979126,
-0.6079093218,
-0.4498665035,
0.1111155674,
-0.0762517229,
0.2698826492,
-0.2487613112,
0.3580939174,
0.167860359,
-0.2500016093,
-0.5534219146,
-0.2162393183,
-0.9508582354,
-0.678168714,
0.2897973657,
0.3261731565,
0.625954926,
0.3000344336,
0.2322298139,
0.2085046917,
-0.4052403271,
0.3367405236,
-0.7299620509,
-0.3839851916,
-0.1198325902,
-0.4348137379,
-0.61708498,
0.0702724978,
0.9250769019,
0.6816651821,
-0.076652132,
0.1662977338,
0.148413837,
0.4108117819,
-0.3554035127,
0.162736401,
-0.4719536006,
0.3461200595,
-0.1797773391,
-0.2791602612,
-0.7550936341,
-0.4140775502,
0.2578876913,
-0.6170216799,
-0.3697951138,
-0.0028838988,
0.7464193702,
-0.0356300324,
-0.7995704412,
0.2172781527,
-0.6434935927,
0.8910568953,
-0.7989993095,
0.5493255258,
0.0091388486,
0.325668484,
-0.1457956284,
-0.5145070553,
-0.360432297,
-0.6958984733,
-0.1241998076,
0.2632060349,
-0.2343619466,
0.1154893041,
0.0704402104,
0.4885238707,
-0.8959046006,
0.2852645814,
-0.3057351112,
0.1047161743,
0.5777141452,
0.2499684393,
0.4641555548,
-0.2060477585,
-0.415864259,
0.3795931339,
-0.6822687387,
0.0885356441,
-0.2062173784,
0.1986608952,
-0.3036881685,
0.5557684302,
0.1410277784,
0.8114253283,
-0.0251060352,
-0.2645379901,
0.0236999243,
-0.598670125,
-0.5989570618,
-0.0504178368,
0.7746835947,
0.1864069253,
0.5152006745,
-0.3656490445,
-0.2285911292,
-0.4768555164,
-0.1541841477,
-0.5479255915,
-0.0558116361,
0.1237867773,
-0.5631377101,
-0.0598140582,
0.0219662804,
-0.0015894559,
-0.3947830796,
-0.3803340495,
0.3928332925,
-0.4139461219,
-0.7541698217,
0.1568980366,
-0.2106410265,
0.6677087545,
0.5017926097,
-0.4138405919,
0.1619360894,
0.8204573393,
0.8802076578,
-0.6006625295,
-0.4894697964,
-0.246375978,
0.291777581,
-0.5472408533,
0.4544857144,
-0.3702130616,
-0.3913620412,
-0.311009109,
0.0013301629,
-0.279709518,
-0.6844039559,
0.5706217885,
-0.2231090665,
0.1226450875,
-0.1542085409,
-0.5466352105,
-0.2263564169,
0.5285125375,
-0.5068472624,
1.0514119864,
0.3965006769,
-0.5287391543,
0.2319772542,
-0.4757707417,
-0.4757491946,
0.4649943411,
-0.1613586247,
-0.1110158637,
0.1331033856,
0.0553029254,
0.3916093707,
-0.3251013756,
0.8597204685,
-0.2821270227,
-0.7455656528,
0.0354105532,
-0.4954329431,
1.2312806845,
0.0258896407,
-0.352481693,
0.4235754013,
-0.3092921078,
-0.0033867159,
0.3301804066,
-0.6011299491,
-0.2396835089,
-0.3220138848,
0.0874654725,
-0.0608101264,
0.4269473553,
-0.4979176819,
0.0178708714,
-0.2252980173,
0.8405541182,
0.6676338315,
-0.3542951345,
0.4088123143,
-0.0899818093,
0.3989645839,
0.0894044563,
0.2129807025,
0.0199990328,
-0.2333103269,
-0.7268798351,
0.0748835951,
0.1273181289,
0.384926945,
-0.6461037397,
0.3206802905,
-0.326998353,
-0.673491478,
-0.3971915543,
0.1830914468,
0.3294662535,
0.5204202533,
0.2164172828,
-0.1735619754,
-0.2523470223,
-0.6366488338,
-0.3650232852,
-0.4412793219,
-0.2237745672,
0.5201390982,
0.1195625365,
-0.019181082,
0.4237735868,
-0.1978561282,
-0.0977587253,
-0.7382052541,
-0.2515324354,
0.1770423949,
0.1830272228,
0.4863813818,
-0.5343573689,
-0.4189785719,
0.4021865726,
-0.9098134041,
0.1034974977,
0.0332419202,
-0.2628148198,
0.2360102981,
0.3834018707,
-0.6966869235,
0.1580657959,
0.4434222877,
-0.5260040164,
0.8203082681,
-0.1979074329,
0.1162266955,
-0.8022040725,
0.0064786542,
0.1685036719,
-0.1753135771,
-0.7943795323,
0.4373727739,
0.1871901006,
-0.0946725607,
-0.6074051261,
0.7162438631,
-0.3804463744,
-0.1686941385,
-0.0071486677,
0.726709187,
0.2662367523,
0.3124890625,
0.2622343898,
0.5343732238,
0.1269986182,
-0.3916682601,
0.5015271902,
-0.273034513,
-0.3639826775,
0.2758151889,
-0.8273353577,
0.0571341105,
0.1649831682,
0.3269587159,
-0.9098744392,
0.0232875478,
0.0090059983,
-0.2984206975,
0.314027369,
0.2149662822,
-0.3399147689,
-0.3320728242,
-0.1490631253,
0.3935695887,
0.2167738825,
-0.4389975667,
0.8800774217,
0.198789373,
0.3292399347,
-0.4771937132,
-0.6381032467,
0.227297321,
-0.4273372293,
-0.6877705455,
0.0654362142,
0.0545893647,
-0.5787519217,
-0.086565055,
-0.1226670593,
-0.1896199733,
0.5062245131,
-0.3723129928,
0.2396156937,
-0.9229467511,
0.2529561818,
-0.0092846463,
0.2383758724,
0.2859698832,
-0.3773268163,
0.3902686238,
-0.3938274682,
-0.1803262681,
-0.2849106491,
-0.2454281002,
0.4115378559,
-0.3244352639,
0.3881914318,
0.8379846215,
-0.4254707098,
-0.0791376904,
-0.4618000686,
0.169689253,
-0.4021379054,
0.6838901639,
-0.4415553212,
-0.908097446,
0.2389726043,
0.1284384131,
0.3430578411,
0.359577626,
0.6642459631,
0.1516369432,
0.5811351538,
0.3753533363,
-0.2401711345,
0.2849512696,
0.0518055409,
0.2644254565,
-0.6658778787,
-0.2467493415,
-0.2866733968,
-0.0779987499,
-0.3756418824,
-0.7283876538,
0.2235436141,
0.2333300412,
-0.5679011345,
0.2528903782,
-0.2019537538,
0.4425729811,
0.3580425382,
0.3357008994,
0.7551228404,
-0.3845716119,
-0.0013342417,
0.140396595,
-0.5622106791,
-0.7374305129,
0.9196497798,
0.644895196,
0.6036906242,
0.3380016983,
0.350756228,
0.0560428277,
0.312618345,
-1.1099919081,
0.5919404626,
-0.4077751637,
-0.2785642743,
-0.7003450394,
-0.6017769575,
-0.6684363484,
0.5369779468,
0.1874984801,
-0.4853899777,
-0.5713474154,
-0.0834835842,
-0.1352177709,
0.4545573294,
-0.8437213302,
0.9949352741,
-0.5930630565,
0.0100118695,
-0.4462077916,
-0.2083358616,
0.9644548297,
-0.1639377922,
-0.0526455604,
-0.3378448784,
-0.0899949521,
0.5831987262,
0.0201696455,
0.548227489,
-0.126540184,
-0.2339043617,
0.264359802,
0.1111210659,
-0.0821845829,
0.1162442788,
-0.3459349871,
0.3008480668,
-0.1656256914,
-0.5751883388,
-0.5738232136,
0.5353651047,
-0.8164352775,
-0.8980984092,
0.0659513921,
-0.4840187728,
-0.0391294025,
0.2733516395,
-0.1245349571,
0.0102590052,
-0.5276154876,
0.0706060305,
0.7275828719,
-0.650423944,
0.3924940526,
0.6984918118,
-0.2675009966,
-0.0609766208,
0.713570714,
-0.0428584516,
0.5028319955,
0.6121551394,
0.8095827699,
-0.1636359245,
-0.5536343455,
-0.7356972098,
0.270580709,
-0.6095385551,
0.2102099955,
-0.2902159691,
-0.4521406591,
-0.3047822416,
0.0896114856,
-0.0891556069,
-0.2729635537,
-0.3593580425,
-0.2973974943,
-0.1109030694,
0.9265310168,
0.5073164105,
0.1610635966,
-0.7290836573,
0.1397515833,
0.0840121135,
0.1432639062,
0.5744171739,
-0.886874795,
-0.2951191366,
-0.1539124846,
-0.4211561978,
-0.5262642503,
0.0855537206,
0.2345190197,
0.7623816133,
0.5154505372,
-0.0922207162,
0.8552484512,
-0.3593662679,
0.9840732217,
-0.0087192925,
-1.2946190834,
0.6103187203,
-0.3337028325,
0.4582562447,
0.0708841756,
0.1262578368,
-0.6247807145,
-0.670247972,
-0.4127522409,
-0.4114912748,
0.5437976718,
-0.0694391057,
0.1014919654,
0.2946010828,
0.3950440288,
-0.1500062793,
-0.0862479657,
-1.1390242577,
-0.2610750198,
0.03123568,
-0.0132317143,
-0.0943920836,
-0.0997860208,
0.1856459081,
-0.4320234358,
0.3478600383,
-0.0808210671,
-0.1852208823,
0.05052967,
-0.2695451975,
-0.233352229,
0.3959023952,
0.6741020083,
1.0482318401,
-0.0823998153,
0.2084353864,
0.5652836561,
-0.4753836691,
0.0117667513,
-0.2121150643,
0.0678486899,
0.1164041758,
0.7799758315,
0.7470831871,
0.1473216861,
-0.8117130399,
0.442375809,
-0.2320135087,
-0.0046828394,
-0.2457525432,
0.0000797496,
0.3555891812,
0.1689831913,
0.4073372185,
-0.5829741359,
-0.0029677167,
-0.5755298138,
-0.0322662778,
0.3159176707,
-0.5415266156,
-0.4118365645,
0.5013189316,
0.2208265364,
-0.1625262499,
0.6334033608,
-0.0273915082,
-0.5694631338,
0.7528500557,
0.4996225536,
0.7868843079,
-0.4704056084,
0.1017772257,
0.4285989404,
0.6462991238,
0.0446686447,
0.2815572917,
-0.0141999526,
-0.7236081362,
-0.5535707474,
-0.4785291851,
-0.5163875818,
0.2596920431,
-0.4661116302,
0.5112297535,
-0.4060860574,
0.1473371387,
-0.2947977781,
0.252992332,
-0.3184724748,
0.0731482059,
0.301737994,
1.2387801409,
-0.742036283,
1.0705339909,
0.6872066259,
-0.1167823151,
-1.2424685955,
0.0296842754,
-0.1180622056,
-1.1883802414,
0.7127218246,
0.1920029074,
-0.0033823731,
-0.2640595734,
-0.118735604,
-0.5661418438,
1.1103265285,
0.4799202979,
-0.4759502113,
-0.3107749522,
0.2604807317,
0.68993783,
-0.2894565463,
0.6330291629,
1.1104944944,
0.5929769874,
-0.1223659441,
-1.3096376657,
0.1690909117,
0.0481695943,
-0.073877871,
-0.0307150651,
-0.9562558532,
0.8355692029,
-0.3283755779,
-0.1440706551,
-0.0385156311,
0.5911456943,
0.6761552691,
0.4646802545,
0.4340603948,
0.4532081783,
0.7214277983,
-0.2872877717,
0.6140404344,
-0.0153651545,
0.2767608762,
1.0144097805,
-0.0997216851,
0.9024274945,
0.2808408439,
-0.313808918,
0.2456502169,
0.9815859795,
0.1174245402,
-0.1185171604,
0.4704317153,
-0.1653308272,
-0.3262953162,
-0.4099423289,
-0.044523742,
0.4846017063,
0.5341897011,
-0.3002164364,
-0.2456295639,
-0.1321242303,
0.0518754534,
-0.0158042312,
-0.6422591805,
0.6619493961,
0.5692085028,
-0.6290748715,
0.7872629762,
0.0368860997,
0.4507386386,
-0.1101780608,
0.0755016431,
-0.3442005813,
0.0750214607,
-0.3121946454,
-1.1077598333,
0.1322726011,
-0.0309861898,
0.3514553607,
0.0585558377,
0.5717052221,
-0.5486557484,
-0.2995798886,
0.5637705326,
0.6033164263,
0.2881026566,
0.1937075257,
-0.6932942867,
0.0005877313,
0.1360725909,
-0.302185595,
-0.0148947434,
0.8460053802,
-0.1830614507,
0.6619955897,
-0.0489107631,
0.0900246799,
-0.1660132557,
0.5287760496,
0.5694128871,
-0.8418857455,
-0.0916042104,
-1.1474027634,
0.2824158072,
0.1575631201,
-0.4559054673,
0.897814095,
0.6335552931,
0.9805942178,
0.1459861845,
0.6739717722,
0.3469155133,
0.1284701675,
-0.4739226997,
0.6732139587,
-0.6766847372,
0.3054336607,
-0.172510162,
-0.7447498441,
-0.2048740238,
0.2868133187,
-0.4004339576,
-0.0556040294,
0.5804972649,
0.2121659964,
-0.0049997088,
0.0713935345,
0.6319749355,
0.3587006927,
0.2936696708,
1.0137178898,
0.9559324384,
-0.2797671556,
0.5556458235,
-0.1007558256,
-0.2958283126,
0.0080304835,
-0.6810985208,
-1.2919578552,
-0.0552745983,
-0.0848634839,
-0.2661663592,
-0.094873406,
0.7808999419,
0.4826113582,
-0.6467843056,
-0.7119038105,
0.2099191099,
0.5003063679,
-0.002163223,
-0.2813943326,
0.4955785275,
-0.2107862979,
-0.7277636528,
0.4062164128,
0.4466535747,
0.0501509756,
-0.6103343964,
-0.2805944383,
0.2238703072,
-0.1690748185,
0.9873774052,
-0.172518,
-1.2882374525,
-0.2035716921,
0.2884827554,
-0.2012779564,
0.2037523687,
0.7538984418,
-0.5035600662,
0.2763510048,
0.4022931159,
0.5834546089,
0.277344048,
-0.0491739586,
0.8066057563,
-0.44269979,
-0.0533650853,
0.2254325449,
0.5978690386,
0.2262015641,
-0.3502260447,
0.6310554147,
0.0155441063,
-0.4252248704,
-0.8624773026,
-0.0463948064,
-0.9905571938,
-0.3667237759,
1.1766471863,
-0.5447193384,
-0.187645331,
-0.1492411494,
-0.0530356318,
0.348343879,
-0.2169895321,
0.4950737953,
0.7953783274,
-0.0561469272,
-0.4226002693,
-0.4488494396,
0.0639258772,
0.3840807974,
-0.7357651591,
0.2940226793,
0.0956059322,
0.3002748489,
-0.2142034322,
0.6503637433,
-0.0768635795,
0.4229387939,
-0.4485022426,
-0.2847555578,
0.194295913,
-0.0125595201,
-0.5683281422,
-0.2252991796,
0.6083094478,
0.3457967341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08664v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08664v1
|
Identifying Banking Transaction Descriptions via Support Vector Machine Short-Text Classification Based on a Specialized Labelled Corpus
| 2024-03-29T13:15:46 | 2024-03-29T13:15:46 |
Silvia García-Méndez, Milagros Fernández-Gavilanes, Jonathan Juncal-Martínez, Francisco J. González-Castaño, Oscar Barba Seara
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Short texts are omnipresent in real-time news, social network commentaries,
etc. Traditional text representation methods have been successfully applied to
self-contained documents of medium size. However, information in short texts is
often insufficient, due, for example, to the use of mnemonics, which makes them
hard to classify. Therefore, the particularities of specific domains must be
exploited. In this article we describe a novel system that combines Natural
Language Processing techniques with Machine Learning algorithms to classify
banking transaction descriptions for personal finance management, a problem
that was not previously considered in the literature. We trained and tested
that system on a labelled dataset with real customer transactions that will be
available to other researchers on request. Motivated by existing solutions in
spam detection, we also propose a short text similarity detector to reduce
training set size based on the Jaccard distance. Experimental results with a
two-stage classifier combining this detector with a SVM indicate a high
accuracy in comparison with alternative approaches, taking into account
complexity and computing time. Finally, we present a use case with a personal
finance application, CoinScrap, which is available at Google Play and App
Store.
|
[
-0.2392741889,
-0.8206447363,
0.3837943375,
0.2123124748,
-0.6384513974,
0.402102381,
-0.0790729821,
-0.827321589,
0.4584855437,
1.0452085733,
-0.2426548898,
-0.6154115796,
-0.5932138562,
0.1165703833,
-0.6362376809,
1.1604673862,
0.0371611901,
-0.0456201322,
-0.4155674577,
-0.2203761786,
-0.3794132471,
-0.7378793359,
-0.7179014087,
-0.3235557079,
0.1470750719,
0.3309979737,
0.3466190696,
0.4319543242,
0.6101570725,
0.429739207,
-0.0762797967,
0.199990809,
0.0845890418,
0.0035768596,
0.0042216307,
-0.4701661766,
-0.2078972012,
-0.366953522,
0.4221842587,
0.3444837332,
0.0619189814,
0.220816344,
0.2569144666,
0.6487437487,
-0.367677331,
0.2532581389,
-0.0992228091,
-0.0160474367,
-0.4727658927,
-0.2916282415,
-0.2248650193,
-0.4126274884,
0.3624952137,
-0.1936322749,
0.2612864971,
0.2942351103,
0.8086050153,
-0.2262898535,
-0.443215102,
-0.6629710793,
-0.7743738294,
0.662760675,
-0.2688548863,
0.1078379229,
0.3429191411,
0.6004759073,
-0.0899956003,
-0.5042552948,
-0.1800927371,
0.0123399403,
-0.5358218551,
-0.2659285069,
-0.2091815621,
-0.0153609524,
0.1103307158,
0.0013569039,
-0.5594224334,
0.1222654507,
-0.5878527164,
-0.4931613505,
0.2597020566,
0.2202735841,
-0.3249529898,
-0.1951303184,
-0.6371665597,
-0.097889021,
-0.1977137178,
0.3849962354,
0.3838843107,
0.4081265032,
-0.0324594751,
0.3185146749,
-0.1793893278,
0.8019750118,
-0.2044826746,
-0.3041567504,
0.1008227766,
-0.0817088634,
-0.416423589,
0.3578161001,
0.5817266107,
0.100917004,
-0.0042627738,
0.0146569535,
-0.4738859534,
-0.1995295733,
0.1652238071,
-0.6300523877,
0.0685625672,
-0.1588910967,
-0.6690962315,
-0.5284750462,
0.1671582013,
-0.710229218,
-0.4378656149,
-0.3012004495,
0.3135047853,
-0.2479125112,
0.2909641862,
-0.0405821316,
-0.218569234,
0.0397877023,
0.1180179492,
-0.7407985926,
0.7767235041,
0.9188917875,
0.9411636591,
-0.0622327998,
0.1441692114,
-0.6458166242,
0.3821382821,
0.0711864233,
0.936291039,
-0.3989186287,
-0.5008661747,
-0.0629837662,
-0.0637933761,
0.1474880576,
-0.7410745621,
0.6867498159,
-0.61727494,
0.1345450878,
0.0676117241,
-0.8225784302,
0.0073112221,
0.6275082827,
-0.5486502051,
0.6890999079,
0.3471803963,
-0.7602313161,
0.1545721292,
-0.5214273334,
-0.6716284752,
0.4847746789,
0.0177808441,
-0.8944734335,
-0.0219607595,
-0.1802734584,
0.6350229383,
-0.3916886151,
-0.1240488961,
-0.2244553119,
-0.6579502821,
0.7622087598,
-0.2258974463,
0.413601011,
0.2108990848,
-0.0351098068,
-0.0871584415,
-0.838436842,
-0.4030887187,
0.1088117063,
-0.2512377799,
-1.0165623426,
-0.234930858,
0.1932360977,
-0.1345470697,
0.4830507338,
-0.3277053237,
0.2004769742,
-0.4394817948,
0.5380140543,
0.7200116515,
-0.0370804556,
0.5146870017,
-0.2484798878,
0.5309237242,
0.3213508129,
0.2872740328,
-0.1895324588,
-0.3911762536,
-0.5051235557,
-0.304225564,
0.5739246011,
0.6943560243,
-0.3873596489,
0.4718243182,
-0.11052306,
-0.2691216767,
-0.0379519463,
0.2500404418,
0.3282815516,
0.7201539278,
0.3628803194,
-0.514264524,
-0.4198353887,
-1.1600718498,
-0.5721933246,
-0.1475196034,
-0.0210725795,
0.4259117246,
0.2804394364,
-0.6097931266,
1.0043321848,
-0.8536838293,
-0.6684951186,
-0.001001179,
0.5153813362,
0.1933740973,
0.3136225343,
0.7085237503,
-0.946418345,
-0.4101814628,
0.0893873572,
-0.0388250723,
0.1175656989,
-0.4787041843,
-0.0047772736,
0.1748085022,
0.2093939632,
-0.348380208,
0.5127590895,
0.1206256598,
-0.5371162295,
0.2356452942,
-0.4923414886,
0.157354027,
-1.1121497154,
-0.273791939,
0.4462214112,
-0.6477853656,
-0.5910855532,
-0.6910509467,
0.2632640898,
0.0791712925,
-0.0876809061,
0.5896846652,
-0.0873084366,
-0.3233076632,
-0.6158269644,
0.0826958194,
-0.1488140076,
0.3493335247,
-0.0043482501,
0.2411465645,
0.4210364521,
-0.7632735968,
0.4455510676,
0.195786953,
-0.3848453462,
0.6544420123,
-0.3083632886,
-0.0904088467,
0.0371387303,
0.2087160796,
-0.9461077452,
-0.0919508189,
0.7277718186,
-0.376738131,
0.2579820752,
-0.3543448746,
-0.3791682124,
-0.6293466091,
-0.1240090579,
0.2377491146,
0.6253903508,
-0.5022115707,
0.7751576304,
0.1768550128,
-0.1695055664,
-0.4469324648,
-0.8055621982,
0.0590627417,
-0.4910296798,
-0.4592607617,
0.3638928533,
0.3466304243,
0.0334354229,
0.0879602209,
-0.1802232862,
-0.4261007309,
0.4061905146,
0.3106709421,
0.530762136,
0.0520235226,
0.2768012285,
0.2264767438,
-0.319542706,
0.0765026286,
-0.4551801085,
0.2994247675,
-0.1341805309,
-0.0666860417,
-0.3813587725,
0.2857606709,
0.1288718283,
-0.1662770063,
0.6543118358,
0.5807216167,
-0.384971112,
-0.1712493002,
-0.4584530294,
0.0954801962,
-0.5471165776,
-0.0951221809,
-0.4313982427,
-1.1151165962,
0.6150829792,
-0.2137221545,
-0.1966480166,
0.518026948,
0.2477833629,
-0.1784712374,
0.6081566215,
0.7061462402,
-0.112194635,
0.7310650945,
0.0128773553,
0.3234149814,
-0.2180683017,
-0.3918057978,
-0.7764477134,
-0.3081927598,
-0.4584000707,
-0.4577078223,
0.0783661753,
0.0701201633,
0.212209776,
0.6831646562,
-0.4638054967,
0.630908668,
0.4495481849,
-0.0849812105,
0.0331216715,
0.0555787943,
-0.0705616847,
0.1030225307,
-0.0851041302,
-0.435144037,
0.7574536204,
0.2951634228,
0.7284255028,
-0.1869550049,
1.1122934818,
0.9539160728,
0.3386773467,
-0.5361921787,
0.4648597836,
-0.3087756932,
-0.1077977717,
-0.0337089635,
-0.7147727609,
-0.923915565,
-0.0220656842,
-0.2114644051,
-0.4353270829,
-0.0050892802,
-0.0305965841,
-0.6205141544,
-0.0027650706,
-0.6824359298,
0.9093364477,
-0.5012441278,
-0.0188316088,
-0.1892474741,
-0.5771858096,
0.33333987,
-0.2489584684,
0.5335873961,
-0.0060033207,
-0.1261022687,
0.9128478169,
-0.6048083901,
0.5517842174,
-0.219464764,
0.1297670752,
0.4463122189,
-0.0548654236,
0.5739571452,
0.0936053544,
0.6507250071,
0.116705209,
0.1854441613,
-0.5394115448,
-0.5085010529,
0.7462128401,
-0.3228339851,
-0.0996754318,
-0.5841807127,
-0.0259208772,
-0.082501635,
0.3407420814,
-0.2048650086,
0.1833854318,
-0.2947970927,
0.1408759952,
0.5905274153,
-0.1044151187,
0.37492612,
0.4886405766,
-0.1345210522,
-0.368457526,
0.9355201125,
-0.1326243728,
-0.2811139226,
0.7173838615,
0.4636805952,
-0.541505754,
-0.4529880583,
-0.2729430795,
0.1504404545,
-0.6607487202,
-0.4235141575,
-0.4898301363,
0.1641559154,
-0.7442556024,
-0.2475658506,
-0.0423640385,
-0.4480558336,
-0.4751741886,
0.0258637555,
0.4340825081,
0.7141068578,
0.0363699347,
0.466108948,
-1.4120180607,
0.4899945855,
0.2761749029,
0.4310091138,
-0.1730971634,
-0.2638036907,
-0.8514155746,
-0.2193813175,
-0.1794155985,
-0.9455782771,
0.5503586531,
-0.1269871593,
0.4076350629,
0.6196919084,
0.0491558239,
0.7013565302,
-0.0536258481,
0.419041276,
0.4605023265,
-0.9154161811,
0.373622328,
0.2202578634,
-0.0826029852,
0.4233267307,
0.3548065126,
-0.8208739758,
-0.3172957599,
-0.5722745061,
-0.7084857225,
0.6902366281,
0.0693277121,
-0.0590242036,
-0.110731326,
0.6228208542,
0.335665822,
0.1319484562,
-0.4152689278,
-0.1220044792,
0.1158756986,
-0.4813647568,
-0.0348496921,
-0.4596213698,
0.1129239276,
-0.0493556261,
0.6216498017,
-0.0719332024,
0.2325141281,
-0.0631147102,
-0.210755989,
0.2165994793,
0.3637730777,
0.6405155063,
0.3687358499,
-0.0669062585,
-0.0274981931,
0.0832164958,
-0.4733843505,
0.0932246372,
0.2995829284,
-0.2043990195,
0.2452807575,
0.1652763039,
0.3425318301,
0.4389623106,
-0.8144360781,
0.7577126622,
-0.3609657586,
-0.2080986947,
-0.7705273628,
-0.1258306205,
0.0058655664,
0.5275552273,
0.3639246523,
0.4221633375,
0.5101623535,
-0.327712059,
0.1986689866,
0.2442262769,
-0.5086129904,
-0.0461713262,
0.3324602842,
0.2790857255,
-0.6015490294,
0.5902416706,
-0.3616050184,
-0.5933403969,
0.66977036,
0.2690905035,
1.2167804241,
-0.0025882002,
0.165794611,
-0.0095202429,
0.037119098,
-0.3531950712,
-0.0146873957,
-0.5683547258,
-0.3787944913,
-0.2747615278,
-0.8908465505,
-0.445730418,
-0.2308910936,
-0.8352327943,
0.6643901467,
-0.5378479362,
-0.1803693324,
0.260684222,
0.0090038851,
-0.5155896544,
-0.0367256589,
0.5380621552,
0.6484845877,
-0.8435419202,
1.0693583488,
0.5338961482,
0.1004942283,
-0.0037653625,
-0.4114085436,
-0.1999415606,
-0.3892009854,
0.6105383039,
0.4821020961,
-0.1009037197,
-0.7186532617,
-0.0997854546,
-0.305713743,
0.9640591741,
-0.104433462,
-0.8813302517,
0.0067187762,
0.4010151625,
0.5848562717,
-0.4313645661,
-0.1800127178,
0.7115283608,
0.3680897057,
0.12088833,
-0.543243289,
-0.2749529183,
0.2110361308,
-0.0358606279,
0.6066127419,
-0.5554925799,
0.6427919865,
0.3097003102,
0.0939500183,
0.2063842714,
0.692054987,
-0.0177616328,
0.781000793,
0.6789977551,
0.483920753,
0.8502810001,
-0.1314495057,
0.8956334591,
-0.0638010427,
0.5097055435,
0.9021425843,
-0.0794975683,
0.5554865003,
0.3508950174,
-0.0876217932,
0.593878448,
0.7270637751,
-0.1663797945,
0.3770371974,
0.4014684856,
-0.2218917161,
-0.3104375303,
0.2630884945,
-0.0222197268,
0.2320340425,
0.4704118371,
-0.5423409939,
-0.051413808,
0.4425342977,
-0.3807961643,
0.113223508,
-0.487829417,
0.8238762617,
0.1801235974,
-0.1730580926,
0.0817027166,
0.4796880186,
0.8501959443,
-0.7499879599,
0.1006839722,
-0.0577483065,
0.4957698882,
-0.0570280105,
-0.4222320616,
0.412030369,
0.0675084665,
-0.299991101,
-0.6579670906,
1.2789422274,
-0.3593787849,
-0.5260650516,
0.1878253967,
-0.0252739564,
0.2386356741,
-0.0759139955,
-0.8464218378,
-0.2997902632,
-0.3156910241,
-0.0721990466,
0.5204870105,
0.5428751707,
-0.2830318511,
0.517991066,
0.3569572866,
-0.1779988557,
-0.0276110899,
-0.111974746,
0.6211149096,
-1.2081750631,
-1.1870797873,
-1.0887957811,
-0.1765128821,
-0.3007588387,
-0.0596785024,
0.8502041101,
1.0234918594,
0.813025713,
-0.1361735463,
0.5677078962,
0.3784712553,
0.9408060908,
-0.2204238772,
0.2757024169,
-0.3450639248,
0.4612429738,
-0.1178544238,
-0.765901804,
-0.2972663939,
0.3867361248,
-0.2227644473,
-0.4608608186,
0.3726714551,
0.3056478798,
-0.1067609861,
0.0753492787,
0.1344583333,
-0.119306758,
0.2389360517,
0.4020652175,
0.7893584371,
-0.2404586971,
1.0676716566,
-0.4153570235,
0.0851572827,
-0.8337492347,
-0.5779244304,
-1.0839685202,
-0.3596947789,
-0.4831377268,
-0.508559227,
-0.3940127492,
0.8969576359,
0.205900535,
-0.7265338898,
-0.4228777587,
0.1895165592,
0.3142007887,
-0.3361000717,
-0.2328077853,
0.2771798372,
-0.1205057278,
-0.4976794422,
0.0605420247,
0.6641385555,
0.5791188478,
-0.186137706,
-0.1550775617,
0.3403292596,
0.182169646,
0.535502851,
0.3719079792,
-0.3362575173,
-0.1917680353,
-0.0754336342,
-0.2138345093,
-0.1048337072,
1.3830829859,
-0.7172446251,
0.1458565444,
0.5818631649,
0.7586361766,
0.884447813,
0.154445231,
-0.0455637611,
-0.7633034587,
0.1395693272,
0.5701099038,
0.2480006218,
0.108369939,
-0.5222182274,
0.0244217403,
0.4973176122,
-0.3373041749,
-0.6344058514,
-0.0431517884,
-1.2316348553,
-0.5927661657,
0.6575980186,
-0.1433428377,
-0.7982041836,
-0.3581277728,
-0.326166302,
-0.1168104261,
-0.4029172659,
0.7522969842,
0.6685097814,
-0.0671696737,
0.2303135842,
-0.2131659091,
0.4921090305,
0.0729257539,
-0.4632093906,
-0.0864923969,
0.435633868,
0.3529560566,
0.2491091192,
0.8173494339,
0.0686006546,
0.2613506615,
-0.4458357692,
-0.2845062017,
-0.1543428153,
-0.1543112546,
-0.5181596875,
0.3204789758,
-0.1997136921,
-0.2649012804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20158v1
|
ChatGPT v.s. Media Bias: A Comparative Study of GPT-3.5 and Fine-tuned Language Models
| 2024-03-29T13:12:09 | 2024-03-29T13:12:09 |
Zehao Wen, Rabih Younes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In our rapidly evolving digital sphere, the ability to discern media bias
becomes crucial as it can shape public sentiment and influence pivotal
decisions. The advent of large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, noted
for their broad utility in various natural language processing (NLP) tasks,
invites exploration of their efficacy in media bias detection. Can ChatGPT
detect media bias? This study seeks to answer this question by leveraging the
Media Bias Identification Benchmark (MBIB) to assess ChatGPT's competency in
distinguishing six categories of media bias, juxtaposed against fine-tuned
models such as BART, ConvBERT, and GPT-2. The findings present a dichotomy:
ChatGPT performs at par with fine-tuned models in detecting hate speech and
text-level context bias, yet faces difficulties with subtler elements of other
bias detections, namely, fake news, racial, gender, and cognitive biases.
|
[
-0.7440386415,
-0.8036426306,
0.3855369091,
0.2579490542,
-0.0984076783,
0.2774179876,
-0.2917571962,
-0.3016684949,
-0.204911992,
0.3342127502,
-0.7153789401,
-0.0158709623,
-0.9318256378,
-0.2064243853,
-0.4168552756,
1.2125892639,
0.2561331093,
0.5886312127,
0.308427155,
-0.0871932358,
-0.4065261483,
-0.5366947651,
-0.5597981215,
-0.4036998749,
0.2319815904,
0.1944464594,
0.6822130084,
0.0816351324,
0.6005206108,
0.1406482011,
-0.3217152357,
-0.0455015786,
-0.5939657688,
-0.3066164255,
-0.2191459984,
-0.2721398473,
-0.156716913,
0.4478313625,
0.4719637632,
0.281784147,
0.1061865464,
0.2763403058,
0.2157402188,
0.8386765122,
-0.4541872144,
-0.0547222607,
-1.0318251848,
-0.0630086884,
-0.3080188036,
-0.2537085712,
-0.3713821173,
-0.3994368017,
0.1934672743,
-0.0183629058,
0.5345360041,
0.1728573889,
0.8673347831,
0.3775231242,
-0.6194560528,
-0.3773023784,
-0.7236166596,
0.6935488582,
-0.5751901865,
0.6085056663,
0.3434728384,
0.2817388177,
-0.1244321093,
-0.2722705007,
-0.5838186145,
-0.2177903801,
0.2648925185,
0.3094409108,
-0.1935181022,
-0.0340762995,
0.5290000439,
0.4917552471,
-0.6114427447,
0.2148079425,
-0.5583343506,
-0.2523116469,
0.3355183303,
-0.2321766615,
0.2342690676,
-0.301435858,
-0.3660432994,
0.2211639434,
-0.7672664523,
-0.4025147855,
0.6727087498,
0.0890366733,
0.1414068639,
0.5167376399,
-0.2909026146,
0.3980898261,
-0.0361917168,
-0.1522561014,
-0.0218251236,
0.0436978564,
-0.2851944268,
0.097879082,
0.7732478976,
0.6906537414,
0.5114074945,
0.1987758726,
-0.0690205395,
0.42399472,
0.2662152648,
-0.7123429179,
-0.259442538,
-0.1812093109,
-0.5721243024,
-0.3106327951,
-0.2795634568,
-0.659217298,
-0.8176929355,
-0.1512091458,
0.339083463,
-0.3229587078,
-0.2637369931,
-0.0782751366,
-0.1802234948,
0.3612535894,
0.1441107988,
-0.8550191522,
0.2403841317,
0.7119528651,
0.9251971841,
-0.3295907378,
0.0984694064,
-0.1978416145,
-0.2314279526,
-0.1103326604,
0.9739454389,
-0.6940672994,
-0.2023582309,
-0.040608108,
-0.2486017197,
0.1891623288,
-0.6341626048,
0.8028470874,
-0.6409582496,
0.4900254309,
-0.5730626583,
-0.5926101208,
-0.0988466889,
0.2618193328,
-0.7208350897,
0.8647135496,
0.3324425519,
-1.1209285259,
0.8439912796,
-0.4295780361,
-0.1099902019,
-0.2262598127,
-0.1739614755,
-0.577890873,
-0.0164885707,
0.3959691226,
0.240308091,
-0.3213602901,
0.269215107,
-0.6421069503,
-0.4697101414,
0.2222523838,
-0.8754221201,
0.7297346592,
0.4347494245,
-0.2608940303,
-0.1933190376,
-0.6155734658,
-0.3705092967,
-0.0355469584,
-0.5406032801,
-0.129197374,
0.2276063263,
0.2657630146,
0.2634570897,
-0.1095923632,
-0.5012248755,
0.1375171989,
0.1758464426,
0.5102744102,
0.6575806737,
-0.1024752706,
0.3361555636,
-0.2439640015,
0.2803376317,
0.0245789122,
-0.0025890563,
0.2242553234,
-0.5111813545,
-0.6469899416,
-0.2808227837,
0.3629837036,
0.5189616084,
-0.5170556307,
-0.0163531825,
-0.0468979292,
-0.5075031519,
-0.4190336168,
-0.0229552221,
0.1806856096,
0.4484826028,
0.3183088303,
-0.4062768221,
-0.6106091142,
-1.1117049456,
-0.754837811,
0.0152674867,
-0.1433911771,
0.3021648526,
0.2331412286,
-0.0910359696,
0.7468932867,
-0.2168392241,
-0.414037466,
-0.1650824249,
0.116888836,
0.1620115638,
0.0252814479,
0.4257998466,
-0.7546668053,
-0.4832659364,
-0.1482687891,
-0.315477103,
-0.7402589917,
0.0309312269,
0.234553054,
-0.1418829411,
0.4659966826,
-0.3740015924,
0.2295671999,
0.5281914473,
-0.3536712527,
0.653124094,
0.3570322692,
0.1824011952,
-0.788275063,
-0.2019276917,
0.2671291828,
-0.2714945972,
-0.5943080187,
-0.2701531947,
-0.004100082,
0.165493086,
-0.4299380183,
0.2957775593,
-0.2862716913,
-0.3368286192,
-0.4811449647,
0.2021205276,
-0.3760686517,
0.39593485,
0.1145927459,
0.8553721905,
0.2603809834,
-0.4429835975,
0.1170856655,
-0.0405211635,
-0.648887217,
0.7787289023,
-0.4272621572,
-0.012697666,
-0.1863919348,
0.4747463763,
-1.0550062656,
-0.1694631577,
0.2388595194,
-0.5089424253,
0.1190989539,
-0.4652677476,
-0.4294840097,
-0.2163812071,
-0.0633265525,
0.3084210753,
0.5526946187,
-0.3044677675,
0.1313872784,
0.5872672796,
-0.1920986921,
-0.5231693387,
-0.4351757467,
-0.2384280413,
-0.3898362815,
-0.2847961783,
0.0533148237,
0.0075000511,
-0.1849696189,
-0.3197201192,
-0.2881686091,
-0.1673976183,
-0.1593371183,
0.2152231187,
0.0424981862,
-0.2471592575,
-0.0477606878,
-0.1041722447,
0.1238780543,
-0.0698998794,
-0.0987303704,
0.7069849968,
-0.1876529306,
-0.488609761,
-0.0449306481,
0.0595002659,
0.6424720883,
-0.0508374684,
0.1877118945,
0.9591354728,
-0.1536314934,
0.1547018439,
-0.9990766048,
-0.2674497664,
-0.4113362432,
0.4361914694,
0.0478933826,
-1.0557106733,
0.4428805113,
0.0103444317,
-0.1899213046,
0.2472056448,
0.9457082748,
0.2360013127,
1.1988646984,
0.3843372464,
-0.5029153228,
0.747307539,
0.1015719995,
0.1498735696,
-0.8551276326,
0.3121765256,
-0.3822230697,
-0.3483884633,
-0.9599385858,
-0.0238061082,
0.1885542125,
-0.2397346646,
-0.4358051121,
0.1298389137,
-0.4757139385,
0.705477953,
0.5774476528,
0.0306922235,
0.3251535296,
0.049684979,
0.1183023006,
-0.1612550467,
-0.5412369967,
-0.6505369544,
0.9910647273,
0.5701056719,
0.4585700333,
0.1450995952,
0.2479579598,
0.4614652395,
0.6851013899,
-0.7012274861,
0.4343511164,
0.0041204602,
-1.1316804886,
0.0978189632,
-0.2031063288,
-0.5970609784,
0.599583447,
-0.1714615822,
-1.0480463505,
0.0498783551,
0.0634789094,
-0.0877735242,
0.3290500939,
-0.9383314252,
0.7080532908,
0.1129946187,
-0.5194317698,
-0.2454875112,
-0.3323435485,
0.5985061526,
-0.1514517963,
0.3427317739,
-0.5972680449,
0.1590379179,
0.7314881086,
-0.0509947017,
0.6241303086,
-0.1119207069,
0.1507920176,
0.1893317103,
0.1623350978,
0.1666999161,
0.0002020772,
0.1194683835,
-0.023779368,
0.0218436383,
-0.3112916946,
-0.1944663227,
0.5564564466,
-0.7681031823,
-0.4277936518,
-0.3408743143,
-0.4602265656,
-0.4005218446,
0.3774742782,
0.4618161321,
0.1719224155,
-0.381729275,
0.2046767324,
0.6000761986,
-0.1325512826,
0.4030631781,
0.7567592263,
-0.2421367764,
-0.0612598285,
0.8386362195,
0.0838352814,
0.366334796,
0.0940529183,
0.1656845808,
-0.0266725123,
-0.4565887749,
-0.2696328163,
0.0104293656,
-0.5580148101,
-0.0436306819,
-0.4773975313,
-0.2253098786,
0.0164963845,
0.0815342963,
-0.491324991,
-0.0337557457,
0.1494378,
0.0534911193,
-0.046217218,
0.6609944701,
-0.0246781036,
0.7614318132,
-0.3112316132,
0.4268581867,
0.3730520904,
0.5627446175,
-0.3744282424,
-0.611202538,
0.0411470905,
0.0835492089,
-0.7810842395,
-1.1397104263,
0.3395817876,
-0.177789703,
0.2306969762,
0.4399808645,
-0.3313623071,
0.2344224453,
-0.5778172612,
0.7629640102,
-0.1156004816,
-0.6326326728,
0.304250896,
-0.7672312856,
0.1493985653,
0.4836952686,
0.639046073,
-0.5248909593,
-0.5165365338,
-0.8944894671,
-0.3212556839,
0.6038311124,
0.2931119204,
0.0134748705,
-0.1619185507,
-0.3217203915,
0.0367631391,
0.319635421,
-1.0645416975,
0.0158137139,
-0.1344970167,
0.1649821252,
0.1522198468,
-0.5084112287,
0.0585521609,
-0.0203016624,
0.6464730501,
0.0618543848,
0.4658946991,
0.0920953676,
-0.2376786172,
0.1210285574,
0.4728316665,
0.780384779,
0.5234850645,
-0.4408586919,
0.0576662794,
0.2247916311,
-0.763805449,
-0.0212022737,
0.0172733516,
-0.2395060211,
0.0977844074,
0.174057886,
0.6639752984,
0.0008945725,
-0.3596638441,
0.7656456828,
-0.0843985006,
-0.2585742474,
-0.118066594,
0.0130233429,
0.0145686697,
0.3624862432,
0.2996797562,
0.0965507776,
0.3681236207,
-0.5180153847,
0.177998051,
0.7461166978,
-0.7531564236,
-0.0684473664,
0.7100511789,
0.1491233557,
-0.1813912839,
0.4653454125,
-0.1514154524,
-0.7991099954,
0.4236784875,
0.3696375191,
0.7478259802,
-0.2389961779,
-0.0101045994,
0.113655448,
0.5023044944,
-0.2072643489,
0.0005867025,
0.0814083815,
-1.1258519888,
-0.3775842488,
-0.4588671923,
-0.3207621276,
0.55292207,
-0.5484874845,
0.4004865587,
-0.4947621226,
-0.3984770477,
0.3706225455,
0.0368305296,
-0.7221103311,
0.2063962072,
0.5492056012,
0.6906577945,
-1.0453749895,
0.6977855563,
0.3092009723,
-0.2457068861,
-0.6262990832,
0.3104734719,
0.449534446,
-0.9535984993,
0.4857254922,
0.3079316616,
0.050292775,
-0.0765761957,
-0.5740991235,
-0.505491972,
0.6874850988,
0.2801974416,
-0.5025906563,
0.2493703216,
0.0603578724,
0.4395367205,
-0.1613965183,
0.8091977239,
0.8620647788,
0.2912055254,
-0.0000866201,
-1.2493597269,
-0.2436537892,
0.029913947,
-0.1318474263,
0.1799878627,
-0.9249879122,
0.532638073,
0.1941779554,
-0.0843975469,
-0.5742678642,
0.3508089185,
0.0873698741,
0.2478196621,
0.3509602249,
0.3231885731,
0.4347768724,
-0.248009637,
0.7853363156,
-0.2673361599,
0.4090491533,
0.941305995,
-0.115096055,
0.5886264443,
0.3511478007,
-0.3141191602,
0.252929002,
0.8501224518,
-0.0746617466,
0.645983696,
0.1944930404,
-0.3206607401,
-0.0880173519,
-0.0909396559,
-0.3740413189,
0.4921401739,
0.6166978478,
-0.3845478594,
-0.2461149991,
-0.1123752445,
0.3609265387,
-0.1773446947,
-0.4716683626,
0.6207226515,
0.1566003412,
-0.7411271334,
0.2952373624,
-0.0605401881,
0.841491878,
-0.3773104548,
0.2803238928,
-0.2148126513,
0.1621260643,
-0.1892287135,
-0.790333271,
0.2656005621,
-0.007308587,
-0.131686762,
0.0800473541,
1.0691559315,
-0.2563262582,
-0.1332484037,
-0.0716433898,
0.6058472991,
0.0297631081,
-0.4103376269,
-0.6989455819,
0.3522682786,
0.1814766079,
-0.4233226776,
0.3227053881,
0.1836037636,
-0.0727721751,
0.8475028872,
0.4385252893,
0.0967107639,
0.1358960122,
0.1801075935,
0.6740908027,
-0.3913572729,
-0.2342390269,
-1.0784999132,
0.0836060941,
-0.2602013052,
-0.2761149406,
0.6827831864,
0.5933778286,
0.9156922102,
-0.1915035397,
1.0516566038,
-0.1137066409,
0.7910225391,
-0.5386389494,
0.624789536,
-0.058293201,
0.158041209,
-0.5994778275,
-1.16796875,
-0.2010582983,
0.7137365341,
-0.785592258,
0.2758283615,
0.6389381289,
0.9933928847,
-0.3310509026,
0.3453402519,
0.0665296316,
0.0069606844,
0.3200381696,
0.4132250249,
0.9813955426,
-0.207552284,
0.5814341903,
0.1775693893,
-0.2904620767,
-0.3789162636,
-0.957965672,
-1.0623698235,
-0.4348699152,
-0.143835023,
-0.2886876166,
0.0342751816,
0.7731932998,
0.7131076455,
-0.5496171117,
0.0581040494,
0.0935920179,
0.2312637269,
-0.0395130515,
-0.257083118,
0.0404019617,
-0.1219854429,
-0.708065033,
-0.0753881633,
0.1331807524,
-0.0867914259,
-0.2736878693,
0.1491303295,
0.0304377638,
0.1994608194,
0.6451524496,
0.2229443938,
-0.7113663554,
-0.472990185,
-0.2147663087,
-0.1078182459,
0.0636137575,
1.0388637781,
-0.6074626446,
0.2340685725,
0.4292408526,
0.4246270955,
0.5776484013,
-0.0391065255,
0.4903531969,
-0.6530676484,
0.0814360455,
0.097014457,
0.3673295975,
0.4339052439,
-0.0532847978,
0.5663845539,
0.2883146703,
-1.0896258354,
-0.7295256853,
0.5134230256,
-1.0621476173,
-0.0691212937,
1.4526592493,
0.5051205754,
0.1750279367,
-0.1120725274,
-0.7656784654,
0.137529701,
-0.3481882513,
0.8922765255,
1.0373971462,
0.0580827892,
-0.4138650298,
-1.1641395092,
0.741063118,
0.3874494731,
-0.2836756408,
-0.0198989995,
0.5242066979,
0.4434801638,
-0.0869665518,
0.8222683668,
0.0089673353,
0.1817956269,
-0.1472005546,
-0.1934530288,
0.3085215986,
0.1259187907,
0.103555575,
-0.1331321746,
0.1744847,
-0.0287400354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20157v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20157v1
|
A Systematic Analysis of Subwords and Cross-Lingual Transfer in Multilingual Translation
| 2024-03-29T13:09:23 | 2024-03-29T13:09:23 |
Francois Meyer, Jan Buys
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual modelling can improve machine translation for low-resource
languages, partly through shared subword representations. This paper studies
the role of subword segmentation in cross-lingual transfer. We systematically
compare the efficacy of several subword methods in promoting synergy and
preventing interference across different linguistic typologies. Our findings
show that subword regularisation boosts synergy in multilingual modelling,
whereas BPE more effectively facilitates transfer during cross-lingual
fine-tuning. Notably, our results suggest that differences in orthographic word
boundary conventions (the morphological granularity of written words) may
impede cross-lingual transfer more significantly than linguistic unrelatedness.
Our study confirms that decisions around subword modelling can be key to
optimising the benefits of multilingual modelling.
|
[
-0.6270032525,
-0.5002121329,
0.1394982189,
0.2315616161,
-0.5770615339,
-0.1304010451,
-0.1459861398,
-0.9003382325,
0.3046709299,
0.30181849,
-0.5015910268,
-0.1305962503,
-0.6665249467,
0.2463831306,
-0.2829222977,
0.7201738358,
-0.171831876,
0.2215527594,
-0.2113937438,
-0.2192294598,
-0.4404978752,
-0.7426111102,
-0.4787861407,
-0.8305985332,
0.6930883527,
-0.0610164218,
0.825633347,
0.6194911003,
0.6083852649,
0.2659132183,
-0.1378582567,
0.0639399663,
-0.3254920244,
-0.1534015238,
-0.6712773442,
-0.6565793157,
-0.4278329313,
-0.0531772189,
0.5351688266,
1.0418406725,
0.0549081899,
-0.1037836,
0.0430044346,
0.5229049921,
-0.4304534197,
0.0853326395,
-0.425424099,
0.1695027053,
-0.3846401572,
-0.0273839999,
-0.2106942087,
0.1501531154,
0.3348039985,
-0.509010911,
0.041094061,
0.314925611,
0.889500916,
0.1879163533,
-0.1152272522,
-0.2047413439,
-0.343510747,
0.8681411743,
-0.6618229747,
0.7794721127,
0.044945769,
-0.1195168942,
0.1067796275,
-0.3831880391,
-0.349309504,
0.1170204356,
-0.5261388421,
0.1036898941,
-0.1717794538,
0.2065886408,
0.0960318223,
0.2691900432,
-0.318341285,
0.3529757261,
-0.593870759,
-0.3584352136,
0.5609897375,
-0.0524981171,
0.5833443403,
-0.1674382985,
-0.5832981467,
0.1023798063,
-0.6337633133,
-0.0768819824,
0.2687931657,
0.5799569488,
-0.2946878672,
0.5316511989,
0.1477564275,
0.5644679666,
-0.0289818384,
-0.3917565346,
-0.0467603058,
-1.0449926853,
-0.1205169857,
0.1125633046,
0.6535409689,
0.3986138105,
0.5962361097,
-0.304189533,
-0.0021636155,
0.1257701516,
-0.0927970558,
-0.5435239673,
-0.188233614,
-0.1724640429,
-0.5391950607,
0.2907477915,
-0.2273950428,
-0.6412739158,
-0.1283032149,
-0.3210588992,
-0.0076554748,
-0.5881695151,
-0.1963280141,
0.3015953004,
-0.270666033,
0.2467035651,
0.2251078784,
-1.0307611227,
0.3669174612,
0.5555315018,
0.6308531761,
-0.3226451278,
-0.6813679338,
-0.075122349,
0.1703407466,
-0.6094436049,
0.7513831258,
-0.4339442849,
-0.5410924554,
-0.2312467992,
0.2158896178,
-0.5420398116,
-0.6506519914,
0.0234293174,
-0.3590413332,
0.4033223391,
-0.2285302281,
-0.3429385424,
-0.4877765179,
-0.0065432047,
-0.6620990634,
0.7037892938,
0.0762313604,
-0.5583820343,
0.624142468,
-0.5416079164,
-0.8308702111,
-0.0693138167,
0.1214380488,
-0.0120267812,
0.3807732165,
0.4278079569,
-0.0373264179,
-0.3313486576,
-0.1858116537,
-0.2066416442,
0.0262967963,
0.0499771275,
-0.0555213653,
0.4394611716,
0.1579744816,
-0.0385075919,
0.121589385,
-0.0694714636,
-0.1165599376,
-0.2895093262,
-0.2084150165,
-0.7122372389,
-0.5166842341,
0.2412579358,
0.558214128,
0.3775583506,
-0.6083139777,
0.1484164298,
-0.2773540914,
0.1062032804,
0.2273654938,
-0.0531572513,
0.806548059,
-0.4594658017,
0.6864356399,
0.3874328136,
0.0438010171,
0.1240626872,
-0.4612435699,
-0.5694277287,
-0.2946859598,
1.1404951811,
0.6560129523,
-0.873267591,
-0.1268669963,
-0.1609877944,
-0.2895828187,
-0.9295547605,
0.3609707355,
0.6089467406,
0.0876051039,
0.4307635128,
-0.7540422082,
-0.5484781265,
-1.1335166693,
-0.3267463148,
-0.012877305,
0.3982466757,
0.142808184,
0.1954336315,
-0.2869952917,
0.6008995175,
0.1480841339,
-0.4543894529,
-0.7890254259,
0.3096263707,
-0.2156977803,
0.7100967169,
0.8703745604,
-0.8208387494,
-0.8073270917,
0.3823425174,
-0.3975170553,
-0.4942718446,
-0.2985060215,
-0.2765910029,
0.5313542485,
0.5115231872,
-0.5886532068,
0.4202202559,
0.7189126611,
0.0109901596,
0.1814260483,
-0.2438625395,
0.0220787711,
-0.9058451056,
0.1128805131,
-0.1137705296,
-0.2841670513,
-0.4469580054,
0.163103506,
-0.152461201,
0.1153697893,
-0.9406715631,
0.6400929093,
-0.7182964087,
-0.3966288269,
-0.3317144215,
0.3600670695,
-0.0014814218,
0.1726723313,
0.2195107639,
0.7693888545,
0.5065227747,
-0.3116428554,
0.1931022853,
0.1317439973,
-0.1967885941,
0.5459375978,
-0.5541560054,
-0.0826631859,
0.0045408965,
-0.0429270118,
-0.7436051965,
0.1312079132,
0.1618805826,
-0.1740045846,
0.6230348349,
-0.2692030072,
-0.4869006574,
0.2520275116,
0.075939998,
0.6600376368,
0.3764392436,
-0.1176686585,
0.5694950819,
0.593636632,
-0.3798047304,
-0.0942592546,
-0.9156893492,
0.0615733154,
-0.1991814226,
-0.7077729702,
0.6058728099,
0.2530103922,
-0.3998598754,
0.344421804,
-0.0454043821,
0.1346462965,
-0.0719368309,
-0.2295923084,
0.0948204249,
0.0067231138,
-0.3082709908,
0.0982264131,
-0.2053635269,
-0.3302473426,
-0.3165025413,
0.7140612006,
0.1941947937,
-0.2405543923,
-0.2430404276,
0.7782646418,
0.6398940682,
-0.3948530853,
0.6598138809,
0.7186048627,
-0.2852870524,
-0.1894419491,
-0.2445376515,
-0.0747177154,
-0.3273625374,
0.3450314105,
-0.7999101281,
-0.6468373537,
0.5328131914,
-0.1076141968,
0.0596393198,
0.40065974,
0.5171245337,
0.1151280925,
0.9225600958,
1.1887490749,
-0.073483184,
0.5851484537,
0.122327812,
0.3018338978,
-0.9223104119,
-0.1005583033,
-0.2042907327,
-0.5611860752,
-0.6795673966,
-0.5435382724,
0.2727687955,
0.3593087494,
0.7716233134,
0.6772766113,
0.0630956143,
0.2130766511,
0.5359742045,
-0.4313100278,
0.1083768234,
0.1428014785,
-0.6207039952,
-0.3080617189,
-1.2278009653,
-0.1986461282,
0.2350248545,
0.1974947602,
1.1774562597,
0.0141361738,
0.6821423173,
0.0093986774,
0.3209873438,
-0.8899421692,
0.4747308195,
-0.4959262311,
-0.6266804934,
-0.2703209221,
-0.3175990283,
-1.0345875025,
0.774699986,
-0.2739908397,
-0.5281544328,
0.449221462,
-0.303868562,
-0.3099156916,
0.3129579723,
-0.8188890815,
0.9489791989,
-0.2820605338,
-0.2646197081,
-0.2692183554,
-0.5326007009,
0.0688017085,
-0.2779736817,
0.3770617545,
0.0665016249,
-0.08975254,
0.6984081864,
-0.211594224,
0.6769731641,
0.3317575157,
-0.300549835,
0.1983597875,
0.3444383442,
-0.0568673015,
-0.3710013032,
0.1024562865,
0.4862875342,
0.3553033471,
-0.525370717,
-0.4170156717,
0.4255489409,
-0.5021051764,
-0.5877420902,
-0.2651023269,
-1.07231915,
-0.1078986451,
0.4607347846,
0.3739045858,
0.1218456998,
0.1067351624,
0.0869043842,
0.3302975893,
-0.1708157659,
0.407723397,
0.4579031765,
-0.5165056586,
-0.1601816118,
0.5941429734,
0.4596338868,
0.4673009217,
0.5502798557,
0.1067902893,
-0.5217329264,
-0.5753507614,
-0.6007776856,
0.4925580025,
-0.5934943557,
0.1902132034,
-0.3701992333,
-0.1059685275,
-0.8052846193,
-0.2328687906,
-0.3244810998,
-0.4914439023,
0.1405116767,
-0.0099971844,
-0.1120568365,
0.5345051885,
-0.5433954,
0.1229190603,
-1.0276975632,
0.1954014301,
0.0688661039,
-0.1019947231,
-0.2741706073,
-0.4051786661,
-0.5427351594,
-0.1010779887,
0.1074827313,
-0.748057723,
0.4153650999,
0.0846677125,
0.7259942889,
-0.1579346508,
-0.1722526699,
0.931850493,
-0.5267715454,
0.6420297623,
0.2947160006,
-1.0202490091,
0.0566215627,
-0.119917877,
0.5306458473,
0.3976634145,
0.470964551,
-0.9086521864,
-0.1984927952,
-0.4227313995,
-0.9033020139,
0.6010804176,
-0.0865637884,
-0.2791451812,
0.2858700156,
-0.0491042472,
0.2640874982,
0.2092703432,
-0.5876457095,
0.0931522027,
0.2254980654,
0.1609997302,
-0.1208496764,
-0.0876959264,
-0.1611622274,
0.0916506872,
0.6381847858,
-0.0442419462,
-0.2054962963,
0.2696996331,
-0.3209013939,
-0.3548870981,
0.4442670941,
0.5079393983,
0.6785395145,
0.2103048116,
0.191995129,
0.3881027997,
-0.2163383067,
-0.0413023718,
0.2005399019,
-0.1872193515,
0.2931530476,
0.8079400659,
0.5738125443,
0.1978481561,
-0.229142502,
-0.0438779779,
0.2292377502,
-0.2512224913,
0.7000212073,
-0.284365803,
0.2062734962,
0.1433565319,
-0.2281403244,
0.073043339,
-0.1675778329,
-0.896487534,
0.2692244947,
0.3853634596,
-0.2415079325,
-0.515933454,
0.3626005352,
0.1709496379,
-0.1152024791,
0.2550100684,
0.1772982329,
-0.893345654,
0.3734003305,
0.5901094079,
0.5757707953,
-0.1983309835,
-0.0817694664,
-0.1187657267,
0.7203006148,
0.1610097736,
0.4841308296,
0.0552088059,
-0.6108237505,
-0.5841321945,
-0.7030581832,
-0.4494489133,
-0.2241349518,
-0.5956568122,
-0.1021973789,
-0.1189499125,
-0.196483016,
0.1516564935,
-0.0568324625,
-0.5443245769,
0.128064096,
0.4607800841,
0.9312623739,
-0.7715231776,
1.0288243294,
1.0198677778,
-0.2901453972,
-0.7812383175,
-0.1483714581,
-0.268542707,
-0.5939956307,
0.7546691895,
-0.1417722255,
-0.2591358721,
-0.222169891,
0.0499294177,
-0.8004444838,
0.5522280931,
0.2178513408,
-0.6681574583,
-0.1070137694,
0.4854427874,
0.7074391842,
-0.4525912106,
-0.2420425266,
0.5417981148,
0.6567652225,
-0.0229709912,
-1.5795918703,
0.1620682627,
0.081188634,
0.1303538084,
0.491717279,
-0.713149488,
0.9876494408,
0.0419451781,
-0.4132736325,
0.0496804565,
0.4819998145,
-0.2666680515,
-0.0582508706,
0.5112415552,
0.6687732935,
0.2046862096,
-0.1156018823,
1.1350355148,
-0.6330599189,
0.1756564528,
0.7209454179,
-0.3794483542,
0.5141675472,
0.8455023766,
-0.0645712763,
0.4180320799,
0.6727069616,
0.2484308928,
0.7438876629,
0.1317370236,
0.2653397322,
-0.3947906792,
-0.5947904587,
-0.4159691632,
0.464147836,
0.3611401916,
-0.1671082079,
-0.5921397209,
-0.089795284,
-0.0737941638,
0.0069977124,
-0.4288314879,
0.789876461,
0.4954819679,
-1.0036152601,
0.5900717974,
0.3395121396,
0.7120568156,
-0.5807340145,
0.2125260234,
-0.5678735375,
0.3565645814,
-0.3380551338,
-0.5718080997,
0.6723316908,
-0.466457963,
-0.0254802499,
-0.5874361992,
0.9608415961,
-1.0045263767,
-0.3036098778,
0.7068033218,
1.0922987461,
0.1705597341,
0.4045994282,
-0.9501846433,
-0.0526435003,
-0.1227688044,
0.2552894652,
0.518370688,
0.7116293907,
-0.3649592102,
0.2151190937,
0.6953404546,
0.5130464435,
0.3752989769,
0.2214958221,
0.5826464295,
-0.5327929854,
-0.6031428576,
-0.7759140134,
0.1508465409,
0.2138208151,
-0.2014748305,
1.1418224573,
0.5339507461,
1.2885822058,
-0.1110215485,
0.6086800694,
-0.0928794891,
0.1949812174,
-0.5348446965,
0.3876141906,
-0.7123584151,
-0.1238982379,
-0.2260880619,
-0.8226272464,
-0.2647880614,
0.5654610395,
-0.5536921024,
-0.1313959062,
0.8383056521,
0.6120404005,
-0.2616144419,
-0.3603165448,
0.5269275308,
-0.2296304554,
-0.0166990031,
0.6046043038,
0.7390323877,
-0.2620117962,
0.4028457701,
-0.4127102196,
-0.0872598365,
-0.0794647187,
-0.6760917902,
-0.9636323452,
-0.1702125818,
-0.2789149284,
-0.153717652,
0.0548334122,
0.7198133469,
0.928661406,
-0.6803769469,
-0.6566542983,
0.1957958192,
0.2939243615,
-0.4816221595,
-0.1837962717,
-0.0679156333,
-0.4802829027,
-0.9877551794,
0.386662811,
0.4743807018,
0.2200549245,
-0.3879352212,
0.2007229477,
-0.5529804826,
0.3065265119,
0.4977152646,
0.1425124854,
-0.5824508667,
-0.0447044633,
0.0359119587,
-0.2554634809,
-0.0441186391,
0.9714593887,
-0.3697570264,
0.2079439759,
0.8143975735,
0.6012378335,
0.4757825732,
0.1183647588,
0.7312515378,
-0.6314069629,
0.39570117,
-0.0349122435,
0.5650525689,
0.4598108828,
-0.2379450053,
0.5685020685,
0.5971822739,
-0.0566753373,
-0.5350449681,
0.5310624242,
-0.5199877024,
-0.4920726717,
1.1862151623,
-0.1469956636,
-0.4621620178,
-0.1541074663,
-0.2097208649,
0.1986412257,
-0.0711632445,
0.2964517474,
1.0097234249,
-0.3005566001,
-0.2748359442,
-0.1121006683,
0.3758430481,
0.7324742079,
-0.644726634,
-0.1549847573,
0.2882817686,
0.2231967151,
0.594052434,
0.4550354779,
-0.2713031471,
0.1339321882,
0.1629025191,
-0.0488862842,
0.0599478632,
-0.5979353189,
-0.1528499126,
0.1416070908,
-0.1626374871,
-0.2213102281
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20147v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20147v2
|
IndiBias: A Benchmark Dataset to Measure Social Biases in Language Models for Indian Context
| 2024-03-29T12:32:06 | 2024-04-03T11:59:19 |
Nihar Ranjan Sahoo, Pranamya Prashant Kulkarni, Narjis Asad, Arif Ahmad, Tanu Goyal, Aparna Garimella, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The pervasive influence of social biases in language data has sparked the
need for benchmark datasets that capture and evaluate these biases in Large
Language Models (LLMs). Existing efforts predominantly focus on English
language and the Western context, leaving a void for a reliable dataset that
encapsulates India's unique socio-cultural nuances. To bridge this gap, we
introduce IndiBias, a comprehensive benchmarking dataset designed specifically
for evaluating social biases in the Indian context. We filter and translate the
existing CrowS-Pairs dataset to create a benchmark dataset suited to the Indian
context in Hindi language. Additionally, we leverage LLMs including ChatGPT and
InstructGPT to augment our dataset with diverse societal biases and stereotypes
prevalent in India. The included bias dimensions encompass gender, religion,
caste, age, region, physical appearance, and occupation. We also build a
resource to address intersectional biases along three intersectional
dimensions. Our dataset contains 800 sentence pairs and 300 tuples for bias
measurement across different demographics. The dataset is available in English
and Hindi, providing a size comparable to existing benchmark datasets.
Furthermore, using IndiBias we compare ten different language models on
multiple bias measurement metrics. We observed that the language models exhibit
more bias across a majority of the intersectional groups.
|
[
-0.2526428998,
-0.2412750572,
-0.0618226118,
0.7575503588,
-0.2242212892,
0.289183259,
-0.4367580116,
-0.4922653735,
0.2466663569,
0.2276487947,
-0.2302840948,
-0.3909815252,
-0.6276069283,
0.0546112135,
-0.5298537016,
0.7578630447,
0.0916647837,
0.5788292885,
-0.4318500757,
-0.5258151293,
-0.4851588309,
-0.1245784536,
-0.3271358311,
-0.3331759274,
0.0124156373,
0.4873951077,
0.466902554,
0.4624405801,
0.3372737765,
0.1915929615,
-0.0487971827,
0.2243333161,
-0.3937037289,
0.2199979126,
-0.3648153543,
-0.2932505012,
0.2291282713,
0.0319500156,
0.7774189115,
0.878903985,
-0.0430912971,
0.4986533225,
0.0851085037,
0.5350947976,
-0.762738049,
0.1374585032,
-0.697997272,
-0.1478467882,
-0.6881469488,
-0.1376544088,
-0.1244744882,
-0.8931164742,
-0.2033175677,
0.0481168404,
0.0941296443,
0.0188292172,
0.5422426462,
0.2515184581,
-0.3966792226,
-0.2471363395,
-0.5079073906,
0.664752841,
-0.6623240113,
0.4669644237,
0.348975569,
0.2738439441,
0.0188546479,
-0.2090670764,
-0.4267029464,
0.0207820106,
-0.0519514978,
-0.1896015853,
0.228675127,
-0.5277301073,
0.1927826703,
0.3370497227,
-0.2966677845,
-0.0424045771,
-0.5396452546,
-0.0074536055,
0.7038873434,
0.2438557893,
0.4971477389,
-0.1275039762,
-0.3705219924,
-0.0866472349,
-1.0481653214,
0.3564253151,
0.7947847247,
0.4697215259,
-0.4727264345,
0.3851522505,
-0.4044945836,
0.655801177,
-0.0945698917,
0.0106497975,
0.4950831532,
-0.2284611017,
0.012254891,
0.1321949959,
0.7938337922,
0.2846654654,
0.603177011,
-0.2595469952,
-0.0138184009,
0.4367984533,
-0.2159602791,
-0.5593783855,
0.4165914357,
-0.0140605429,
-0.2307716161,
-0.1465783864,
-0.3776405454,
-1.2200394869,
-0.8308335543,
-0.3629376292,
-0.3785979152,
-0.3670763671,
-0.322334677,
-0.2554172575,
-0.0214457214,
0.7729408741,
-0.1634793729,
-1.1800431013,
0.4832545519,
0.6901353598,
0.8370295763,
-0.1613491625,
-0.3890555799,
-0.2477416992,
0.0927353501,
-0.4988792837,
0.9737918377,
-1.2923928499,
-0.3488146067,
0.5413423777,
-0.3600506485,
0.0928682834,
-0.5274555087,
0.6393862963,
-0.0874497294,
-0.2324326038,
-0.5993896127,
-0.3037462234,
0.0347757675,
0.3231058121,
-0.1420161575,
1.1305029392,
0.0313735902,
-0.7636796832,
0.6518234015,
-0.3642456532,
-0.6453824043,
0.2587869167,
-0.8073039055,
0.0799959973,
0.0707027391,
0.364882499,
0.2942853868,
-0.861627996,
0.417247504,
-0.549831152,
-0.5021298528,
0.0724496618,
-0.2555832863,
0.9718476534,
0.2448701411,
-0.1449958533,
0.0329784602,
-0.8336707354,
-0.187620461,
0.0207252409,
0.050308615,
-0.7614876032,
0.1090388075,
0.100644812,
0.1444126964,
0.179977119,
-0.9209616184,
-0.1156674474,
-0.3655384779,
0.4770299792,
0.8148779273,
-0.1840891391,
0.4407011271,
-0.200669989,
0.4069283009,
-0.0487226248,
0.346270442,
0.058157444,
-0.2458880544,
-0.7062963843,
-0.157124117,
0.1621631533,
0.3523507118,
-0.2436974049,
-0.1038508043,
-0.4153031409,
-0.7179834843,
-0.7399528623,
0.3468085825,
0.5692493916,
0.2868455648,
-0.0965493396,
-0.4201453626,
-0.4148134291,
-1.2745820284,
-0.6461413503,
0.1153866947,
0.1936208159,
0.0640918314,
0.404022783,
-0.1638682336,
0.9086371064,
0.0689485744,
-0.2966775894,
-0.0741666779,
-0.1333841085,
0.0419147648,
0.3780798316,
0.4530494213,
-0.6335715652,
-0.758831203,
-0.1013246551,
-0.7473297119,
-0.4820061326,
0.2234179378,
-0.1655913591,
0.0315441228,
0.389431566,
-0.2761002183,
0.4868468344,
0.6925025582,
-0.3636057675,
0.2182193547,
0.1486959755,
0.1349309087,
-1.1092509031,
-0.1456156671,
0.4322776198,
0.1513063014,
-0.3877781332,
-0.1422657967,
0.1196866632,
0.1757534742,
-0.4171762466,
0.7987007499,
-0.4092195034,
-0.3852334023,
0.1970555633,
0.2125781476,
-0.3355660141,
0.3484418988,
-0.2509483695,
0.9648720026,
0.589872539,
-0.3640357852,
0.2066460103,
0.5217348337,
-0.6558631063,
0.894085288,
-0.7637022734,
0.0636308268,
-0.2101325542,
-0.024751721,
-0.9881232977,
-0.2687346935,
0.1730932593,
-0.4519633353,
0.1091984063,
-0.1558554024,
-0.5533581376,
0.0825887993,
-0.4263580143,
0.5262904167,
0.1928107142,
-0.5356379151,
0.6044576168,
0.9754177928,
-0.2083111852,
-0.7417108417,
-0.8376764655,
0.0127069624,
-0.3653820753,
-0.6001625657,
-0.0091267396,
-0.0454622507,
-0.72123909,
-0.2744769752,
0.1462170184,
0.0854369029,
-0.3518901765,
0.5540193915,
0.044619523,
0.2684314847,
0.0826630518,
0.1301769912,
0.1224935949,
0.1548663825,
0.309502095,
0.8695580959,
-0.2962210178,
-0.3981307447,
-0.0600354373,
0.2714781463,
0.7080225945,
-0.532315433,
0.5078140497,
0.420930922,
-0.5220859051,
-0.0868093744,
-0.9466871023,
0.1040706113,
-0.4009958208,
0.1227604896,
-0.1922954768,
-0.4065549672,
0.845426321,
0.1022182256,
0.0728723854,
0.1691372395,
0.6802441478,
0.3934772313,
0.8376986384,
0.5496890545,
-0.549364984,
0.5160053372,
-0.0024972877,
0.3304410577,
-1.1765334606,
-0.3731127977,
-0.7214387059,
-0.1157565042,
-0.6192755699,
-0.1777075529,
0.1444757283,
-0.5319378376,
-0.5161981583,
0.0488632061,
-0.5903018713,
0.554901123,
0.5226899981,
-0.1447277367,
0.1411314905,
0.082518369,
-0.071459353,
-0.3363078237,
-0.4563868642,
-0.6508761644,
1.2165766954,
0.171991989,
0.8376991749,
0.0934109762,
0.3232776523,
0.5777406096,
0.6337290406,
-0.0810031891,
0.5419454575,
0.0007440356,
-0.8591042161,
-0.1210681796,
-0.1567722261,
-0.6548786163,
0.3230225742,
-0.144065991,
-0.82508111,
0.582164526,
-0.1991423219,
-0.1102608219,
0.2740270793,
-0.7979776263,
0.6624341011,
-0.3566353321,
-0.8635010719,
-0.2003011107,
-0.5338133574,
0.6411790252,
0.1884336025,
0.5240879059,
-0.6195492744,
0.0673588589,
0.6939701438,
-0.2023099512,
0.9623185396,
-0.0545361601,
0.2451037616,
0.029773565,
-0.0310871247,
0.3343610168,
0.1425243616,
-0.2364863008,
0.4216919839,
0.1930286139,
-0.4814067483,
-0.0130962292,
1.0361254215,
-0.9375479221,
-0.0167909041,
-0.821688354,
-0.695456028,
-0.557317853,
-0.0716208294,
-0.0322024152,
0.5868826509,
-0.2563120425,
0.1575889289,
0.3567238748,
-0.2848879099,
0.3654364049,
0.6379674077,
-0.0507571474,
-0.1919009835,
0.5778201818,
0.1338789165,
0.0997086912,
-0.0434691347,
0.0186995212,
-0.3732246459,
-0.4231950343,
-0.4807134569,
0.366939187,
-0.7674484253,
-0.1922104955,
-0.5035007,
-0.0916155726,
-0.7713167071,
-0.0950670242,
-0.4455619156,
0.1539950818,
0.4954623282,
0.018969195,
0.4604739249,
0.9707078934,
-0.2590327561,
0.1806537658,
-0.2612198889,
0.1652987897,
0.1373958141,
0.7935346365,
-0.0548751913,
-0.4927845299,
0.0074367807,
0.0058229626,
0.0621589981,
-0.815182209,
0.6143332124,
-0.1028507575,
0.5425733328,
0.3782366812,
-0.0855788067,
0.6458681822,
-0.254306525,
0.5452444553,
-0.1146660894,
-0.8414573073,
0.3832963109,
-0.4216206968,
0.1409504712,
0.9001617432,
0.3253128529,
-0.9919665456,
-0.2914292514,
-0.2284195423,
-0.8945699334,
0.5976528525,
0.1355380267,
0.2330355346,
-0.2313379645,
0.2710031569,
0.1987937689,
0.1752085239,
-0.6425685883,
-0.3567607701,
0.088080287,
-0.3008707166,
-0.0500272512,
-0.3941935599,
-0.260158211,
-0.3768983781,
0.7891414762,
0.1414941698,
-0.2426547706,
0.0983622372,
-0.1462851465,
-0.1764172167,
0.2345402986,
0.3549260497,
0.8866022825,
-0.2385097444,
-0.1958562583,
0.3515523672,
-0.4237320721,
-0.1059533954,
0.2132267952,
-0.5132337213,
-0.0801912472,
0.0586830266,
0.5579225421,
0.1057719514,
-0.8316534162,
0.4253144264,
-0.3261229992,
0.5491167903,
-0.8801460862,
-0.307728231,
-0.0501650348,
0.1861399412,
0.3224110305,
-0.0678940713,
0.0204154253,
-0.6929959655,
-0.2426309437,
0.5482939482,
-0.6778901219,
-0.0828228965,
0.6344099641,
0.4572357833,
-0.4861741662,
0.3168660998,
-0.0132061597,
-0.285454601,
0.5121991038,
0.2286854088,
0.6601161957,
-0.2127619386,
0.1480713487,
0.5254483819,
0.6778241396,
0.0326389633,
0.1033061072,
-0.017036289,
-0.7369285226,
-0.1666878462,
-0.731454134,
-0.5916705132,
0.0316989757,
-0.5269752145,
0.372842133,
-0.438062638,
0.15087834,
-0.2879097164,
-0.0317624211,
-0.9333013892,
0.0503166616,
0.2522054613,
0.8605698943,
-1.2349277735,
0.6803432107,
0.4717826247,
-0.6780625582,
-0.4726779163,
-0.2177822441,
0.0763687789,
-1.0099650621,
0.4907525182,
0.1695468426,
-0.1737818867,
-0.3460670412,
-0.6893778443,
-1.0164552927,
0.7494379282,
0.2886427939,
-0.4769503772,
0.3738802373,
0.5926619172,
0.5774216056,
-0.6538203955,
0.600941956,
1.0009419918,
0.4106756151,
-0.3804064989,
-0.6428693533,
-0.0313378721,
-0.5799793601,
0.2159138173,
0.0867570564,
-1.0365982056,
0.7825733423,
0.3107841909,
-0.1499982178,
-0.1882743537,
0.4514660537,
0.1144929007,
0.2433218956,
0.4096293747,
0.4927070141,
0.5017901063,
-0.2115257233,
1.1882989407,
-0.7161018252,
-0.1368207335,
1.2424737215,
-0.6777696609,
0.5659073591,
0.5862140656,
-0.2749615908,
0.4145649076,
0.6479840875,
0.3560614586,
0.2903186083,
0.243998006,
-0.150049597,
-0.1149987504,
-0.6516826153,
-0.6139221787,
0.6411521435,
0.6799814701,
-0.025410153,
-0.1873407662,
-0.2562104464,
0.109003,
0.6292552948,
-0.2019729167,
0.3911653161,
-0.1286176145,
-0.7147945762,
0.1869754791,
-0.3828806281,
0.9271225929,
-0.9125646949,
0.1714849025,
-0.7519699335,
0.3894878626,
-0.1619377881,
-0.7409204841,
0.3966071308,
0.1515985131,
-0.0027241954,
-0.0269087981,
0.5956491828,
-0.6265234351,
-0.7314488888,
0.5982711911,
0.3110506833,
0.1882842183,
0.1390315294,
-0.265127182,
0.4921784997,
-0.0790076554,
0.2329197973,
0.3740195334,
0.2535751164,
-0.177028507,
0.8460599184,
0.4870229065,
0.3090272546,
0.3383694589,
0.2462220192,
0.6879841089,
-0.470833987,
-0.1437909305,
-0.7616015673,
0.1797765046,
-0.5011466742,
-0.6776201129,
1.0349160433,
0.6934911013,
1.0929784775,
0.3394422829,
1.0105692148,
-0.1105508432,
0.8330715895,
0.0586885884,
0.7086071372,
-0.4276794493,
0.1855353266,
-0.2073463351,
-0.8736490607,
0.0213934164,
0.4439749122,
-0.5732895136,
-0.0533767082,
0.1119450033,
0.9379960895,
0.0332217664,
0.094837904,
-0.0482970849,
0.163871184,
0.2482142597,
0.4247603714,
0.7582633495,
-0.4408822656,
0.398245126,
-0.3932914138,
-0.3076722622,
0.0696766376,
-0.7017815709,
-0.9698853493,
-0.6194506884,
-0.0336570702,
-0.234513849,
0.2359186262,
1.1787042618,
0.6281648874,
-0.8657869697,
-0.6509506702,
0.2854500413,
0.1481453776,
0.1156294495,
-0.2187752277,
0.1043029428,
-0.3312756419,
-0.9847890139,
0.1649957299,
0.3619146347,
-0.419858098,
-0.6801874638,
0.0100934999,
-0.5037431717,
0.2827169597,
0.3951007724,
0.558285296,
-0.4318191409,
-0.0939394906,
-0.3862596154,
-0.1665440053,
0.084389545,
0.7628236413,
-0.6319326758,
0.5728616714,
0.5619228482,
0.5678339601,
0.3783260286,
-0.2811200023,
0.5464977622,
-0.6538906097,
0.5836167336,
0.1123559326,
0.6847586632,
0.9735170603,
0.0317271426,
0.8762272,
0.0628295615,
-0.4462757409,
-0.9572969675,
0.0904297754,
-0.7921209931,
0.1165543646,
1.4855189323,
0.4321094155,
-0.2099948227,
-0.285936892,
-0.0126809599,
0.2878406346,
-0.5525332689,
1.1320415735,
0.6082609296,
0.3401786685,
0.1596084088,
-0.5673456788,
0.360522151,
0.3954719603,
-0.6331527233,
0.1149361432,
0.3217198551,
0.3641195297,
0.1288616508,
0.7846938968,
-0.2907274365,
-0.0699236318,
-0.0407478027,
0.349491775,
0.3426086307,
0.0263867564,
-0.1731718481,
-0.0876958743,
-0.204508394,
-0.0803377554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20145v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20145v2
|
Fine-tuning Large Language Models for Automated Diagnostic Screening Summaries
| 2024-03-29T12:25:37 | 2024-04-04T10:36:48 |
Manjeet Yadav, Nilesh Kumar Sahu, Mudita Chaturvedi, Snehil Gupta, Haroon R Lone
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Improving mental health support in developing countries is a pressing need.
One potential solution is the development of scalable, automated systems to
conduct diagnostic screenings, which could help alleviate the burden on mental
health professionals. In this work, we evaluate several state-of-the-art Large
Language Models (LLMs), with and without fine-tuning, on our custom dataset for
generating concise summaries from mental state examinations. We rigorously
evaluate four different models for summary generation using established ROUGE
metrics and input from human evaluators. The results highlight that our
top-performing fine-tuned model outperforms existing models, achieving ROUGE-1
and ROUGE-L values of 0.810 and 0.764, respectively. Furthermore, we assessed
the fine-tuned model's generalizability on a publicly available D4 dataset, and
the outcomes were promising, indicating its potential applicability beyond our
custom dataset.
|
[
-0.4374363124,
-0.5109610558,
0.8922135234,
0.0605007112,
-0.2797752321,
-0.0891395584,
-0.2741986215,
-0.3951003551,
0.3821890056,
0.69611305,
-0.3869786561,
-0.7069393992,
-0.8290942311,
0.4543839693,
-0.6425615549,
1.4067685604,
-0.007267355,
-0.0539442264,
0.2815587223,
-0.0487522297,
-0.2735552788,
-0.2070523649,
-0.8124373555,
-0.4751882553,
0.2674129307,
0.387150377,
0.9305280447,
0.4641057849,
0.6576308608,
0.1751908064,
0.0095205037,
0.6170774698,
-0.5810815096,
0.2041507065,
-0.2415600717,
-0.205293566,
-1.0365151167,
-0.0203287099,
0.408088088,
0.7383000851,
-0.2730791271,
0.4657875001,
-0.0497428365,
0.4837079942,
-0.6068524122,
0.2418966442,
-0.438323915,
-0.1030803546,
0.1385711879,
0.0484162942,
-0.2506544292,
-0.4604997337,
-0.1725221276,
-0.3252187967,
0.2831988335,
-0.3526104987,
0.8459052444,
0.3567120433,
-0.4764069617,
-0.0250686556,
-0.7686703801,
0.4070462584,
-0.9209097028,
-0.0558946654,
0.6998098493,
0.553499341,
0.0100254109,
-0.7663440704,
-0.3105507195,
-0.1545997411,
-0.1656970084,
0.1820644885,
-0.4105341136,
0.2977241278,
0.3207464218,
0.4963844717,
-0.4797049165,
0.41420573,
-0.4098352194,
-0.3176611662,
1.1628056765,
0.8808367252,
0.1493410021,
0.04824242,
0.3940945566,
0.1362495422,
-0.5080864429,
-0.1430786997,
0.0508290827,
0.355507195,
-0.475012809,
0.6183618307,
-0.6767212152,
0.6594292521,
0.1747123599,
-0.3650661707,
-0.2321132123,
-0.5681055188,
-0.303365618,
-0.4015145302,
0.7059075236,
0.9978086352,
0.6470548511,
0.016271688,
-0.7091217041,
0.1104352251,
0.1630883068,
-1.0468814373,
-0.4884245098,
0.3336935639,
-0.5174130797,
-0.1641852409,
-0.1733371466,
-0.7162407637,
-0.6692266464,
-0.5062725544,
0.1702082604,
-0.3567430675,
-0.1313405484,
0.3380687535,
0.0003359607,
-0.2112683952,
0.4983256161,
-0.9174767733,
0.4729532003,
0.5039432645,
0.9615628123,
-0.2800677121,
0.082227245,
-0.6425819993,
0.0227320995,
-0.4598097205,
0.7472045422,
-0.4767028391,
-0.489885211,
-0.0410411395,
-0.0583514795,
-0.0512739234,
-0.671892643,
0.3546690643,
-0.1244656071,
-0.2165003717,
-0.1556638926,
-0.4003837407,
0.1734310836,
0.3116658628,
-0.5675922036,
0.5268393755,
0.4944895804,
-0.6114236116,
0.4708198011,
-0.399404645,
-0.503839612,
-0.0439560637,
-0.0444116667,
-0.3388499916,
0.1915939152,
0.5648403168,
0.632628262,
-0.3757443428,
0.4749435782,
-0.333212316,
-0.6073980331,
0.0287967008,
-0.2655030489,
0.6465662122,
0.1133914515,
-0.1733171046,
0.3370309472,
-0.6727100015,
-0.0619324148,
-0.0429363102,
-0.0764315724,
-0.1676842719,
-0.0407195613,
-0.0265411455,
0.0900928006,
0.0797621682,
-0.2786639333,
0.1326882839,
-0.5224362612,
0.3004884124,
0.4168992937,
0.3220184445,
0.0455115438,
-0.4489789903,
0.8700757027,
-0.0270124599,
0.245234251,
-0.398624599,
-0.3455435038,
-0.5534481406,
-0.8223388195,
0.2039727569,
0.5469709039,
-0.2776494622,
0.5589891672,
-0.1693658531,
-0.535058856,
-0.6425107121,
-0.1270803064,
0.1022450179,
0.452044636,
0.2925218046,
-0.2982363701,
-0.5273817778,
-1.1815308332,
-0.0799392834,
0.0108277481,
-0.2462629676,
0.2270032465,
0.6069527268,
-0.6209522486,
0.8363873959,
-0.9384860396,
-0.2857522964,
-0.6252835393,
-0.1468811631,
0.3408888578,
-0.0508465208,
0.671559155,
-0.2135806382,
-0.3906818032,
0.0182297714,
-0.5678473115,
-0.3382196128,
0.1136770695,
0.234458074,
0.177727446,
0.3832943439,
-0.505096972,
0.5297384262,
0.5131621361,
-0.3749377728,
0.8555756807,
-0.5343065262,
0.1298889816,
-1.1473299265,
0.1035455018,
0.291980952,
-0.4825182557,
-0.4348750412,
0.1443172246,
-0.0059008398,
-0.2234246135,
0.2199653536,
0.7361474633,
-0.0507638231,
0.1874544472,
-0.441619873,
0.2894406021,
-0.103776969,
0.0930403993,
-0.2967018187,
0.5432553887,
0.6180325747,
-0.7035567164,
0.1708935797,
-0.0030345859,
-0.181875214,
0.4028096497,
-0.7370687127,
-0.3794166446,
-0.0337920673,
0.4781918824,
-0.8317863941,
-0.6849630475,
-0.2087473273,
-0.0021618698,
0.2063004524,
0.1082831249,
-0.527908206,
-0.4065439403,
-0.3016653061,
0.2180259526,
0.6032625437,
-0.1739230901,
0.072986193,
0.7404685616,
-0.3718118668,
-0.163925007,
-0.4338649213,
0.0225291029,
-0.296299845,
-0.3101799488,
0.0660516992,
0.1608880311,
-0.4437463582,
-0.4821188748,
-0.024173962,
-0.163325265,
0.1953351647,
0.0605594069,
0.1998766512,
-0.144973889,
0.00324659,
0.2910153866,
-0.1456513405,
0.1163207516,
0.0639135465,
0.4801945388,
-0.1083942354,
-0.2392478138,
-0.4743944108,
0.4221037328,
0.7110906243,
-0.4080711603,
0.4591454864,
0.4545170665,
-0.7245988846,
-0.2923417985,
-0.2448372692,
-0.4433278143,
-0.4128452837,
0.6059539318,
-0.0706374124,
-0.8575959206,
0.6614638567,
0.0439140834,
0.1231225282,
0.4233796299,
0.6984185576,
0.0279386304,
1.596342802,
0.9919540286,
-0.1507852674,
0.0863316208,
-0.2130212486,
0.4293840528,
-0.6096473336,
0.2105761021,
-0.3621667922,
-0.2432252765,
-0.7708698511,
-0.1429547518,
0.7402653098,
-0.0689674988,
-0.1710498035,
-0.0502055399,
-0.2972707748,
0.350720644,
-0.0745534822,
0.1611465216,
0.4982590079,
-0.1167222559,
-0.1019731015,
-0.1446355283,
-0.3841510117,
-0.8972324729,
1.1322832108,
0.2940215468,
0.9217267632,
0.0324777104,
0.637181282,
0.2886437476,
0.533964932,
-0.6422522068,
0.5688399076,
-0.6195033789,
-0.3501564264,
-0.4062524438,
-0.1710461378,
-0.9080209136,
0.1700995415,
-0.0126590105,
-0.9986355901,
-0.0810840726,
0.3772259951,
-0.7802172899,
0.1728091538,
-0.5919231176,
0.5807988644,
0.0778585523,
0.2353720814,
-0.525816679,
-0.3046310842,
0.937204659,
-0.425803721,
0.0236785244,
-0.3609430194,
0.0316962563,
0.4120132327,
-0.4766991735,
0.8490527868,
-0.0045104804,
-0.2937447131,
-0.1265836358,
0.1128179654,
0.1774882674,
0.4746884406,
-0.3474625647,
-0.1854649931,
0.2240962833,
-0.1878360659,
-0.5341895223,
0.3734682798,
-0.4513781667,
-0.7173013687,
0.0474243723,
-0.7963073254,
-0.3885844648,
0.3502273858,
0.2118528187,
0.5845966339,
-0.2846483886,
-0.3129542172,
0.4466129839,
-0.3297817707,
0.1628090739,
0.7112795711,
-0.4739319086,
-0.2491017431,
0.6443899274,
0.1860370636,
0.2657242417,
-0.0965374708,
0.2328735292,
-0.0440005474,
-0.6730931997,
-0.4829681516,
0.5226547718,
-0.5114582181,
-0.3143332899,
-0.7923352718,
-0.3521082997,
-0.5712721944,
-0.0569430217,
-0.2494262457,
-0.3613843322,
-0.0230421145,
-0.1814074814,
0.3782360256,
0.9137676954,
0.0418355875,
0.2533659339,
-0.6619998217,
0.5955780149,
-0.0638546348,
0.5250357389,
-0.0548805781,
-0.7694550753,
-0.600253284,
0.1656923443,
-0.4234676957,
-0.8231720924,
0.5323479772,
0.2690925896,
0.3944351077,
0.5744495392,
0.3386474848,
0.8242553473,
-0.2694531083,
0.6568234563,
-0.1618442386,
-0.6329125166,
0.7648099065,
-0.6456504464,
0.5691155195,
0.6003277898,
0.2143407613,
-0.4676758051,
-0.9585441947,
-0.3818775713,
-0.7898035049,
0.6384848952,
0.0062191267,
0.0172079168,
-0.0440767333,
0.401873827,
0.1712691337,
-0.0239718072,
-0.176275894,
-0.1577094048,
0.1736556441,
-0.4831083119,
-0.4366265535,
-0.0840987489,
-0.4630841017,
-0.359875977,
0.3828414977,
-0.2817612886,
-0.0718652308,
0.2140642554,
-0.0469306186,
-0.0723771527,
0.1162471101,
0.713111639,
0.751547873,
-0.1624723673,
-0.0253061764,
0.2393213809,
-0.7181911469,
0.096484445,
0.3095183074,
-0.3709813058,
0.1136147007,
0.3908644021,
0.7439037561,
-0.1399810612,
-0.9478120804,
0.3388106227,
-0.3105671704,
-0.1590566933,
-0.0508442372,
0.3699630499,
0.0472982563,
0.2461069375,
-0.0237826314,
-0.0949692503,
0.3875440657,
-0.3153947294,
0.1972806454,
0.4672604203,
-0.1218996048,
-0.4681822658,
0.5376271009,
0.0738443211,
-0.2786660194,
0.6852747202,
-0.371421963,
-0.1448920369,
0.7058494091,
0.6289328933,
0.8434188962,
-0.1012903303,
0.4282582104,
0.5835691094,
0.5767305493,
-0.2808540761,
0.4442180991,
0.2200216651,
-0.5776980519,
-0.3141064346,
-0.5981597304,
-0.5328136683,
0.4482522607,
-0.7792432308,
0.4568143785,
-0.3273603618,
-0.4553999603,
-0.1659794748,
0.0449958108,
-0.6268414259,
0.4533452988,
0.2276160568,
0.9431461692,
-0.8958649635,
0.6379914284,
0.6301791072,
-0.2741143405,
-0.8863477111,
0.2416650653,
-0.1644192785,
-0.4049874544,
0.0175494235,
0.2202324569,
-0.1472098827,
-0.1421105415,
-0.1955944002,
-0.9675114751,
0.9680825472,
0.7652965188,
-0.5430855751,
-0.0486942418,
-0.0098939547,
0.9488964081,
-0.4758768976,
0.4514137208,
1.1751765013,
0.5055303574,
-0.539263308,
-1.2722504139,
0.016108999,
-0.1434092075,
-0.2289274484,
0.1882253438,
-0.3975653648,
0.7251006365,
-0.6310966015,
-0.3756968975,
0.0764147416,
0.2825298309,
0.5309550166,
0.3269349635,
0.3007803857,
0.3848478794,
1.0474653244,
-0.060268458,
1.3602581024,
-0.4767978191,
0.1852178723,
1.2064836025,
-0.4546801448,
0.5676900148,
-0.1296651959,
-0.1059151068,
0.2201083601,
0.8264840245,
-0.0065456945,
0.172259137,
0.1818004698,
0.0294041168,
-0.2549283206,
-0.065165624,
-0.0675472766,
0.4467403591,
0.6065124869,
-0.4734463096,
-0.4133129716,
-0.0972821712,
-0.0909416899,
0.1249413565,
-0.5598403215,
0.6273251176,
0.1992492527,
-0.8410131335,
0.6764267087,
0.2555484474,
0.4633898735,
-0.4735354185,
0.2437748611,
-0.6613416076,
0.390858978,
-0.3935714364,
-0.7083671093,
0.4683226049,
0.3854729235,
-0.25843817,
0.0434583277,
0.5043906569,
-0.4100149572,
-0.6942425966,
0.2194447815,
0.517157793,
0.227059707,
0.0272072516,
-0.3844898939,
-0.259845227,
-0.1664540321,
-0.0961907431,
0.3104273677,
0.3219572008,
-0.652844131,
0.7310580611,
0.0779993385,
0.5281255245,
-0.2218411267,
0.548210144,
0.6390877366,
-0.6202742457,
-0.669231236,
-0.9613665938,
0.4139015377,
-0.106584318,
-0.4266662002,
0.5755729079,
0.4865709245,
0.5536631346,
0.0036978559,
0.8085178137,
0.3316235542,
0.5204066634,
-0.2637381554,
0.9296518564,
-0.5737201571,
0.1221396923,
-0.2314556241,
-0.4712481201,
-0.3373936117,
0.3063614368,
-0.1467439979,
0.1890985817,
0.6173725128,
1.0127776861,
-0.0338936225,
-0.2182015032,
0.4847775698,
0.2626652718,
0.3744633198,
0.3342785835,
0.4079829752,
-0.1410123706,
0.0471788831,
-0.0949730799,
-0.331988126,
-0.3138649464,
-0.6321111321,
-0.8639343977,
-0.378587842,
-0.3862752914,
-0.0930213481,
0.0580784827,
0.6906878948,
0.7315770984,
-0.8908327222,
-0.3134377003,
0.3306519091,
0.0189523734,
-0.3464749455,
-0.1568237096,
0.2807863951,
-0.1920780689,
-0.6870155931,
0.1708847284,
0.5900170207,
-0.0868690461,
-0.4393726587,
0.1245494932,
0.3822380006,
0.2987996936,
0.7737276554,
-0.0819881782,
-0.775313735,
-0.0969062895,
-0.1658570021,
-0.4538066685,
-0.242588222,
0.7310282588,
-0.7174572945,
0.3066246212,
0.2859571576,
0.3974013031,
0.2189288139,
0.1235064194,
0.9538019896,
-0.3754531741,
-0.0868570805,
0.2850491405,
0.5781639218,
0.2460440844,
-0.4201419652,
0.4408195317,
-0.2776344717,
-0.4895136058,
-1.0646985769,
0.3818100095,
-0.6729496121,
-0.061468903,
1.1157792807,
0.0090346113,
0.1781160235,
-0.2561885417,
-0.2601812482,
0.4326480627,
-0.2655966878,
1.0343408585,
0.5473583341,
-0.4975833595,
0.0722839385,
-0.5132139921,
0.586978972,
0.231727913,
-0.9580087662,
0.3235714436,
0.4661263824,
0.3723433018,
-0.2674682438,
0.9385033846,
-0.046146553,
0.485902518,
-0.3503216505,
-0.0957771242,
0.1384240538,
-0.1532937437,
-0.6726952791,
-0.0808892697,
0.047801502,
0.3669984937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01327v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01327v1
|
Entertainment chatbot for the digital inclusion of elderly people without abstraction capabilities
| 2024-03-29T12:10:21 | 2024-03-29T12:10:21 |
Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Francisco J. González-Castaño, José A. Regueiro-Janeiro, Felipe Gil-Castiñeira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Current language processing technologies allow the creation of conversational
chatbot platforms. Even though artificial intelligence is still too immature to
support satisfactory user experience in many mass market domains,
conversational interfaces have found their way into ad hoc applications such as
call centres and online shopping assistants. However, they have not been
applied so far to social inclusion of elderly people, who are particularly
vulnerable to the digital divide. Many of them relieve their loneliness with
traditional media such as TV and radio, which are known to create a feeling of
companionship. In this paper we present the EBER chatbot, designed to reduce
the digital gap for the elderly. EBER reads news in the background and adapts
its responses to the user's mood. Its novelty lies in the concept of
"intelligent radio", according to which, instead of simplifying a digital
information system to make it accessible to the elderly, a traditional channel
they find familiar -- background news -- is augmented with interactions via
voice dialogues. We make it possible by combining Artificial Intelligence
Modelling Language, automatic Natural Language Generation and Sentiment
Analysis. The system allows accessing digital content of interest by combining
words extracted from user answers to chatbot questions with keywords extracted
from the news items. This approach permits defining metrics of the abstraction
capabilities of the users depending on a spatial representation of the word
space. To prove the suitability of the proposed solution we present results of
real experiments conducted with elderly people that provided valuable insights.
Our approach was considered satisfactory during the tests and improved the
information search capabilities of the participants.
|
[
-0.5981832147,
-0.8119705319,
0.4682548046,
0.1618417203,
-0.333178848,
0.2108433545,
-0.1263440102,
-0.6838759184,
0.7038012743,
0.063828811,
-0.6330105066,
-0.4769432545,
-0.3446276486,
-0.1937855482,
-0.0947051793,
0.6146251559,
0.3460272849,
-0.0839468166,
-0.5072168708,
-0.0640379414,
-0.4018973708,
-0.3585931659,
-0.9110300541,
-0.1822966635,
0.1043308452,
0.4948562086,
0.8833820224,
-0.0204225499,
0.4198481441,
0.4660575688,
-0.0916938111,
0.2232230008,
-0.400734663,
0.1188357621,
0.0623818487,
-0.7035039663,
-0.684885323,
-0.3893603981,
-0.1169978976,
0.3597357869,
-0.0894288644,
-0.1799883693,
-0.2773082852,
1.1238056421,
-0.5105736852,
0.3191134334,
-0.3409068286,
0.1841525286,
0.0347107202,
-0.4078549743,
-0.0248873066,
-0.5106391311,
-0.1105572283,
-0.5418348908,
-0.108686693,
0.1207682639,
0.648013413,
0.6194677949,
-0.0298667867,
-0.6809781194,
-1.1843636036,
0.5105209947,
-0.7136957645,
0.3725965023,
0.8202906847,
0.5555039048,
-0.0612490885,
-0.1829945147,
-0.7674806118,
-0.5382723212,
0.0689117461,
0.3637008965,
-0.4136109948,
0.1640940309,
-0.3047127724,
0.310136795,
-0.4497518241,
-0.1184287593,
-0.5867304802,
0.033747375,
0.5762889385,
0.1809776723,
0.6246735454,
-0.2012144029,
0.132348299,
0.3176388144,
-0.1832935065,
0.0855660513,
0.6670243144,
-0.2123174816,
-0.3306043744,
0.6670094132,
-0.5467661619,
0.3672812581,
0.2339719087,
-0.0016129997,
0.5351002812,
-0.1224615201,
0.3373152614,
0.3509858251,
0.430845052,
0.6001912355,
0.5919861794,
-0.2251888365,
0.0066310158,
0.1630124599,
0.1626928151,
-0.262862891,
-0.385625571,
0.746961236,
-0.5283941627,
-0.0077574123,
0.2302454412,
-0.6568351984,
-0.2474868894,
-0.1083954647,
0.146860525,
-0.5886474252,
-0.3561656475,
0.233847633,
-0.5777298808,
-0.0257296003,
0.4619928896,
-0.8712784648,
0.3094072044,
0.248770982,
0.7698280811,
0.107662268,
0.3941996396,
-0.2769303024,
0.2792745531,
0.2884495854,
0.8072785139,
-0.7149002552,
-0.4523074329,
-0.1378522068,
-0.0337049477,
0.4392051995,
-0.4132445157,
0.5030562282,
-0.6964866519,
0.6785827875,
0.5249624252,
-0.1466419548,
-0.0910368487,
0.1637954712,
-0.6368210316,
0.7154231071,
0.3011217713,
-0.4861952364,
-0.0111436304,
-1.1289032698,
-0.4465197325,
0.2504076064,
-0.0018096194,
-0.396294713,
0.1398707479,
0.4682314694,
-0.1659302264,
0.0244355667,
-0.1916308701,
-0.4212912917,
-0.5363624692,
0.2538780868,
-0.4508598149,
0.4918911159,
0.3510816693,
-0.4215425849,
-0.0951740369,
-0.5098558664,
0.1634120792,
0.0425120629,
-0.3373652697,
-0.4202896357,
0.3374198973,
0.2830128074,
0.2426888347,
0.333571136,
-0.5124433041,
-0.1314086169,
-0.4130464792,
0.5304311514,
0.3386313915,
-0.1700956374,
0.611933589,
-0.5660313368,
0.4793172181,
0.0144938249,
0.3711531162,
-0.1884327978,
-0.3851888478,
-0.6619000435,
-0.1692678481,
0.2902784646,
0.8592739105,
-0.7818520665,
0.9930033088,
-0.5377919674,
-0.2630006075,
-0.6082014441,
0.0550698936,
-0.2791287899,
-0.2487751245,
0.2039166093,
-0.4339897335,
-0.3927197158,
-0.591339767,
0.1472893208,
-0.4312830865,
-0.5528356433,
0.6247392893,
-0.1175288334,
-0.3162357807,
0.8277786374,
-0.1125480905,
-0.6871035695,
-0.2171689421,
-0.0078117512,
0.0564326085,
0.3944371641,
0.0673367828,
-1.1830934286,
-0.0476762913,
0.0987794474,
-0.8177724481,
-0.2389541417,
-0.1542260349,
0.2970367074,
0.1588037014,
0.2804646492,
-0.6264089346,
0.5269007087,
0.4971795976,
-0.0451760776,
0.0009999304,
-0.3439784944,
0.2767828703,
-0.7177845836,
-0.1165941656,
-0.1957865208,
-0.1858561933,
-0.4802495241,
-0.4844878912,
-0.476460278,
-0.436817944,
-0.4215511382,
0.434078753,
-0.638048172,
-0.0568827279,
-0.3908354342,
0.6632399559,
-0.1326352954,
0.3801675141,
-0.0423538797,
0.2159639597,
0.3295184672,
-0.4382397234,
0.4037128687,
0.1821875721,
0.1307514608,
0.7530862093,
-0.5921375155,
0.4463517964,
-0.632168591,
0.3803333342,
-1.2960760593,
-0.3028164208,
0.4904350936,
-0.8209284544,
-0.057466682,
0.2939962447,
-0.0788003802,
-0.4078063071,
-0.4094960988,
0.3600726128,
0.6413847208,
0.1411194205,
1.0381836891,
0.6351066828,
-0.7592929006,
-0.0673223138,
-0.5561501384,
0.4005283415,
-0.2907430232,
-1.0009322166,
0.5470920205,
-0.1455345452,
-0.3007512987,
0.4403747022,
0.1784682721,
-0.1158814207,
-0.1321422905,
0.2955063283,
0.2298331261,
-0.174700141,
0.2573760748,
0.163516432,
-0.2280780524,
-0.2835895121,
0.0395331308,
0.85255301,
-0.3659548163,
-0.6333877444,
-0.8162531257,
0.6872455478,
0.8743826151,
-0.1411322951,
0.5085396767,
0.5791807175,
-0.2486162186,
0.1784764081,
-0.798062861,
-0.0359148495,
-0.5395300984,
0.2302726805,
-0.0312849395,
-0.8282685876,
0.3973170519,
-0.1926901937,
0.0369637571,
0.0985517353,
0.5175065398,
-0.3032703102,
1.1525634527,
0.4728552699,
0.1162741259,
0.8768719435,
0.1629699916,
0.2919203937,
-0.4566304088,
-0.3522232473,
-0.3414153457,
-0.6701702476,
-0.566486001,
-0.122334443,
0.2902106345,
-0.0090285651,
0.0442530625,
-0.1229043752,
-0.5211920142,
0.2147074938,
0.5975087285,
0.4838000834,
0.4288980663,
-0.2061691582,
0.6770758629,
0.0424142815,
-0.5962061286,
-0.5697447658,
0.3851599097,
0.3487867117,
1.0444856882,
0.4259375036,
0.7764998078,
0.7840052843,
0.3480004966,
-1.0145944357,
0.4925452769,
-0.1774151325,
-0.5209534764,
-0.4455902576,
-0.4297491908,
-0.8280188441,
-0.5966284871,
-0.0906027704,
-0.7532969117,
0.2545399666,
-0.1625882536,
-0.4194276929,
-0.0374729894,
-0.7931947112,
0.069489345,
-0.6061990857,
-0.2031808794,
-0.5096092224,
-0.7310426831,
0.078367807,
0.0416628309,
0.6208619475,
-0.3064261973,
-0.0418745913,
0.3662846684,
-0.1040915623,
0.8008705378,
-0.1443575323,
0.4685513973,
0.3489603996,
-0.0687060952,
0.3967065215,
-0.2025268227,
0.0550208539,
0.0607583523,
-0.0364417844,
-0.3959066868,
-0.588265717,
0.6330474019,
-0.8546470404,
-0.8309571147,
0.0579664037,
-0.4916527867,
-0.1018865183,
0.0340823233,
-0.2154205889,
0.3368342221,
-0.142121017,
0.5666880012,
0.1982282102,
-0.4812554717,
0.3427231312,
0.3334259689,
0.0563275628,
-0.3526705503,
0.821389854,
-0.0233917609,
0.1739930958,
0.3871088326,
0.1039462313,
-0.4230374694,
-0.3354977667,
-0.4599889219,
0.0793640986,
-0.6997706294,
0.3007929623,
-0.8796103001,
-0.2289872915,
-0.2144413739,
-0.3032966852,
0.1521236598,
-0.5416064262,
-0.1665599048,
0.188623786,
0.2395122051,
0.5571736097,
-0.1639622897,
0.4459291101,
-1.1067614555,
0.4650785327,
0.3122195005,
0.3007838726,
-0.0637600645,
0.023204932,
-0.1221557111,
0.0936689451,
-0.4453609884,
-0.8023800254,
0.2683665156,
0.5252053738,
0.8738523126,
0.3171816766,
0.2934480608,
0.3537355065,
-0.4028873146,
0.8054077625,
0.2791150212,
-0.7040118575,
0.5281233788,
-0.3193410933,
0.2913639843,
0.6558614373,
0.3131792843,
-0.6470034719,
-0.655667007,
-0.6320949793,
-0.99345541,
0.2968754768,
0.2027759701,
0.5812568665,
-0.0625669286,
-0.1160575524,
-0.0852143914,
0.3028740883,
-0.5669372678,
-0.1696985364,
-0.427039057,
-0.5446217656,
0.5351224542,
0.0494833998,
0.0996462554,
-0.085105285,
0.4229561388,
0.2366109788,
0.6537103653,
0.1372142285,
0.0484946631,
-0.2484697402,
0.2812473774,
0.2950007319,
0.5690581203,
-0.2635657191,
0.0902002454,
0.0021833745,
-0.2981632352,
0.1621113867,
0.0447702408,
0.2899461091,
0.1926540285,
-0.1231948733,
0.4094088972,
0.1879545003,
-0.980749011,
0.3277172744,
-0.3209186792,
0.1689167321,
-0.8417455554,
0.3902870119,
0.4851115048,
0.3018521667,
0.5122189522,
0.2595462799,
0.1456671804,
-0.8955420852,
0.6098017097,
0.4509671926,
-0.7518575191,
-0.0026547939,
0.8313227892,
0.5576201081,
-1.2530388832,
0.5373257399,
-0.2658461034,
-0.3371472061,
0.3717507124,
0.300224483,
1.0571888685,
-0.1697712094,
0.2911273539,
-0.0902733803,
0.1658892184,
0.3037061989,
0.2466855496,
-0.1811816841,
-0.6703268886,
-0.295147717,
-0.3417586386,
-0.5018021464,
-0.1260927916,
-0.2681101263,
0.402556777,
-0.3352912366,
-0.3202344477,
-0.0811754912,
-0.386879921,
-0.692071259,
0.0538723432,
0.4434660971,
0.6922447085,
-0.6530500054,
0.4087657332,
0.5209135413,
-0.3431115746,
-0.0454138853,
0.4364921153,
-0.1189994663,
-0.698841989,
0.5135954618,
0.1530124396,
-0.3366684318,
0.2040641606,
-0.4045167565,
-0.4166919589,
0.8969022632,
-0.103447631,
-0.2971251905,
-0.1504677683,
0.020707136,
0.6132340431,
-0.3784145117,
0.690525651,
0.1364943087,
0.6638085842,
0.4397138357,
-0.6859312654,
-0.2595569491,
-0.7377625704,
-0.3763918281,
0.1961349249,
-0.7889730334,
0.4024900794,
-0.1218942776,
-0.409204036,
0.0395794772,
0.6438538432,
0.1317012161,
0.5869864225,
0.8379475474,
0.165107429,
0.5598967671,
-0.0463723391,
0.7992709279,
-0.4277018905,
0.0464371331,
0.6028422117,
-0.0376347154,
0.5517556071,
0.3883544505,
-0.2337132096,
0.8184998035,
0.3519974649,
0.4311448634,
0.7026059031,
0.1063032076,
-0.6591595411,
-0.0496688336,
-0.3596901298,
-0.0897720233,
0.4635228813,
0.6413022876,
-0.2654842734,
-0.313847661,
-0.0310418215,
-0.1091160476,
0.075338237,
-0.0949354246,
0.9178801775,
0.1219952106,
-0.2482595593,
0.3469084799,
-0.0033693549,
0.7994793057,
-0.8097467422,
-0.1524018496,
0.0257263593,
0.1824313551,
-0.2670202553,
-0.5484845638,
0.3581692278,
-0.3668260276,
0.1143364236,
0.2581558228,
0.8777199984,
-0.3606830537,
-0.4081069529,
0.1428668499,
0.8712425828,
0.3893244565,
-0.0386039689,
-0.7652128935,
-0.0108162053,
-0.1148975566,
-0.0225961283,
-0.0268952157,
0.6377589107,
-0.0535268374,
0.7362382412,
0.6786231399,
0.2816967666,
-0.3313329816,
-0.0648217797,
0.848901391,
-0.7059613466,
-0.8326807022,
-0.6496713758,
0.6823193431,
-0.2832421958,
-0.3128043711,
0.4083300531,
0.2047716379,
0.315697521,
0.1888206601,
0.9521218538,
-0.5930049419,
0.0463039242,
-0.3050999939,
0.640834868,
-0.5676722527,
0.1916643232,
-0.0865820646,
-0.835482657,
-0.111091353,
0.4713036418,
-0.4907138646,
0.2167496532,
0.3511424065,
0.801428318,
-0.0757005662,
0.3213706911,
0.518951714,
-0.2606706917,
0.4762459993,
0.6766813993,
1.0831270218,
0.0366360359,
0.4962288439,
0.0095957126,
-0.5684668422,
-0.7271197438,
-0.6669880152,
-0.8776419163,
-0.4973703325,
0.2205580324,
-0.1045207158,
0.3001095951,
1.1533231735,
0.434640348,
-0.6829118133,
0.1367625445,
0.1075580567,
-0.0922568887,
-0.3096269965,
-0.3179886639,
0.2409710139,
-0.0496969037,
-1.0073744059,
0.1792498082,
0.5160279274,
0.0914282873,
-0.5931726694,
0.1163517088,
0.186427474,
0.0659157336,
0.4058413506,
0.2442688197,
-0.5545045137,
-0.6944875717,
0.2170673013,
0.0891158581,
0.4249556363,
0.3725420833,
-0.6401866674,
0.6804066896,
0.6369556189,
0.5545588136,
0.4567999244,
0.3459407389,
0.5014228225,
-0.3709576726,
0.3636415005,
0.6226907969,
0.0858120918,
0.4780941904,
-0.6847918034,
0.2250767797,
0.0610601455,
-0.4889984131,
-0.3368671536,
0.0946656242,
-0.8591471314,
-0.2250739187,
0.9754200578,
0.2654410899,
-0.3287056386,
-0.8890829086,
-0.5853094459,
0.2334684879,
-0.7224979997,
1.4100804329,
0.5888287425,
-0.3526128829,
-0.2880694568,
-0.8218057156,
0.0706197321,
0.2078984529,
-0.8386968374,
-0.3066783845,
0.4538611174,
-0.0562255196,
0.5063984394,
0.8453223109,
-0.3360848129,
0.3691574335,
0.0695244223,
0.1299042255,
-0.4398807585,
-0.0605464056,
-0.037649475,
0.3421594203,
-0.2200045884,
-0.232437551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20134v1
|
User Modeling Challenges in Interactive AI Assistant Systems
| 2024-03-29T11:54:13 | 2024-03-29T11:54:13 |
Megan Su, Yuwei Bao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Interactive Artificial Intelligent(AI) assistant systems are designed to
offer timely guidance to help human users to complete a variety tasks. One of
the remaining challenges is to understand user's mental states during the task
for more personalized guidance. In this work, we analyze users' mental states
during task executions and investigate the capabilities and challenges for
large language models to interpret user profiles for more personalized user
guidance.
|
[
-0.3540388346,
-0.9560523629,
0.9341428876,
0.147514239,
0.2798817158,
0.0066292803,
-0.1855377406,
-0.6176486015,
-0.1055221558,
0.6732943058,
-1.1659318209,
-0.1369821578,
-0.5385345817,
0.3286949396,
-0.3364330232,
0.8986778855,
-0.1922662705,
-0.0510180742,
-0.3592996299,
0.1993624121,
-1.2020485401,
-0.7576588988,
-0.8589023948,
-0.3833526075,
0.2146308571,
0.4052560329,
0.8230729699,
0.0824309513,
0.6223709583,
0.4792784452,
0.114606075,
0.1487887502,
-0.1264323741,
0.4218507707,
-0.1764127761,
-0.493057996,
-0.3723968565,
-0.0033999328,
0.1867868006,
0.789665997,
-0.2817877531,
0.2481780052,
-0.1479172707,
0.2691215873,
-0.4101962447,
0.3887682855,
-0.2408852279,
0.1191587374,
-0.4200793207,
0.1206355691,
-0.3988764882,
-0.0881161243,
0.3729910254,
-0.9019162655,
-0.0409673974,
0.1797075868,
0.8656941652,
0.5852963924,
-0.579134047,
-0.3762222826,
-1.2154673338,
0.4556247592,
-0.6945652366,
0.1835272908,
0.5167880058,
0.6391968131,
-0.3692750931,
-0.5475020409,
-0.9498393536,
-0.4017394483,
-0.2088349313,
-0.0740044564,
-0.3679870069,
0.183352977,
0.6112322807,
-0.0359976143,
-0.2309401631,
0.1456081122,
-0.2482257038,
-0.0091255764,
0.8264083266,
0.6555454135,
0.8012583852,
-0.1236254424,
0.062832728,
0.0150187714,
-0.0061394512,
0.213200286,
0.4386994541,
-0.0084737679,
-0.2646141946,
0.8399967551,
-0.2938699126,
0.7480152845,
0.1218883991,
0.0729832202,
0.1153502762,
-0.205205515,
-0.2849140465,
-0.466208905,
0.7483060956,
0.1980422735,
0.6512410045,
-0.1358486861,
-0.3488925695,
-0.1110943481,
0.4805127382,
-0.1999433786,
-0.3018736243,
0.3257015049,
-0.3076895773,
0.2044609785,
0.057713706,
-0.3381075263,
-0.638207972,
-0.7594602704,
0.5321119428,
-0.5826401711,
-0.0955609977,
0.0533381552,
-0.040638499,
-0.0257731192,
0.8972912431,
-0.9947645664,
0.5050749183,
0.5908885598,
0.660797596,
-0.188279137,
-0.3046515584,
-0.2075364292,
0.1015066132,
0.0751151666,
0.6784814596,
-0.7281438708,
-0.5347201228,
-0.2369505912,
-0.0599109158,
-0.3818030655,
-0.5322949886,
0.1603097916,
-0.585156858,
0.2440346926,
-0.6016628742,
-0.4178062677,
-0.3104797602,
0.0931872278,
-0.5012773871,
0.7865788341,
0.2744113505,
-0.3948633671,
0.0584137104,
-1.1638902426,
-0.4399098456,
0.3511999249,
-0.2027239799,
0.184537366,
0.0856741294,
0.1457836479,
0.520591557,
-0.0913874134,
0.2191279083,
-0.1784736663,
-0.3598338962,
0.4562209845,
-0.1101271585,
1.0465152264,
0.245951727,
-0.3091131449,
0.5420054197,
-0.5766659379,
-0.3136026263,
0.2068205178,
-0.1290995777,
-0.177951768,
0.2614469528,
0.2321673781,
0.2064221948,
0.559292376,
-0.3422884643,
0.6267867684,
0.0169705767,
0.2652622759,
0.8998561502,
0.0455012321,
-0.0480422974,
-0.0815836117,
0.8345826268,
-0.0283057969,
0.2245194614,
-0.2415721118,
-0.8090516925,
-0.430082798,
-0.1438460946,
0.000293359,
1.1200032234,
-0.572037816,
0.5394361615,
-0.0252656676,
-0.1537403017,
-0.6186373234,
0.305552274,
0.2056733817,
0.5333934426,
0.1979336739,
-0.1833820939,
-0.177287221,
-1.0064073801,
-0.0408004671,
-0.2389277965,
-0.288212955,
0.6718389392,
0.5924140811,
-0.6677078605,
0.9402638674,
-0.6949897408,
-0.4779472649,
-0.1152855828,
0.4128231108,
-0.121683605,
0.3362653553,
0.344165206,
-0.9142963886,
-0.329057157,
0.2588298619,
-0.9919961095,
-0.3331621587,
-0.5029137731,
0.0872518644,
0.0799259543,
0.4925187826,
-0.7847744226,
0.5670385957,
0.0220429637,
-0.6613487005,
0.4857527316,
-0.4828834236,
0.2911644578,
-0.7558820844,
0.2910980284,
0.2625372708,
-0.0561703704,
-0.6993846893,
0.1043284312,
-0.3347707391,
-0.4084638655,
-0.1221869886,
0.5260034204,
-0.3276063204,
-0.173230201,
-0.364449501,
0.209274739,
-0.3004136086,
0.6244212389,
-0.1530410051,
0.7815506458,
0.3474068344,
-0.3691316843,
0.6987189054,
0.4328961074,
-0.3065291643,
0.6752297878,
-0.7859709859,
0.3504376113,
-0.1836435497,
0.189906776,
-0.994063139,
-0.5713600516,
0.2533029318,
-0.2986450791,
0.103643395,
0.3029823899,
-0.8068438768,
-0.3169325888,
0.1866902113,
0.5241107345,
0.4213555753,
-0.2263192981,
0.8694545031,
0.4652294517,
-0.2800915837,
-0.1903912425,
-0.2214208394,
0.2795448601,
-0.2421062142,
-0.681491673,
0.3186788857,
-0.3171533942,
-0.6872121692,
0.0172164422,
0.3866602182,
0.1140252873,
0.4525199831,
0.5179386139,
0.2854882479,
0.1662106514,
-0.095882155,
0.0287261643,
0.2058923692,
0.4090479016,
0.3785361946,
0.470318079,
-0.1506310999,
-0.5921930075,
-1.3964929581,
0.7869312167,
0.6316046715,
-0.346814096,
0.9064612985,
0.5887941718,
-0.6683984399,
0.3164964914,
-0.5293661952,
-0.1219119206,
-0.5120283961,
0.29457739,
-0.6743460298,
-0.7632955909,
1.0043851137,
0.0940849632,
0.197409153,
0.3359547853,
0.8231984973,
-0.5287345052,
1.8473501205,
0.7907482386,
-0.0534237362,
0.466008544,
-0.0229603853,
0.0912101641,
-0.720132947,
-0.7255931497,
-0.3670062423,
-0.5318377018,
-0.2869369686,
0.0603009127,
0.3764610589,
0.0170315616,
-0.2162211686,
0.2708236873,
-0.3821185529,
0.0874025226,
0.7135583162,
0.1674309373,
-0.012638431,
-0.275631696,
0.228793323,
0.0797569901,
-0.1574673355,
-0.5620594025,
0.6447683573,
0.4080612957,
0.8965861797,
0.286023885,
0.3707119524,
0.6540127397,
-0.0286398437,
-0.8574730158,
0.6062838435,
0.0649162456,
-0.6086127162,
-0.422968179,
-0.1156292409,
-0.9717539549,
-0.1560523361,
-0.4006369114,
-1.6104052067,
0.0120189888,
0.4393103123,
-0.6548905969,
-0.0443690047,
-1.0572547913,
0.7732857466,
-0.2557710111,
0.1475668103,
-0.3483096659,
-0.7492508292,
0.1744760871,
0.0047751744,
-0.0185332932,
-0.1224074289,
0.1397638023,
0.9221377373,
-0.3272647262,
0.8373799324,
-0.2029450983,
0.1068468392,
0.2359101921,
-0.0755717605,
0.4142653942,
-0.1439971626,
-0.1129088104,
-0.0257544201,
0.1860330999,
-0.3358469605,
-0.9302854538,
0.6482972503,
-0.8933839798,
-1.1193323135,
-0.3384130299,
-0.8651112914,
-0.297816813,
0.2099211514,
-0.0137156509,
0.279951781,
0.0680310428,
-0.3442736268,
0.4513096213,
-0.1741212904,
0.3100416958,
0.3144689202,
-0.1546707749,
0.268019259,
0.7358796597,
0.0637410954,
-0.1438973695,
0.018026283,
-0.127315253,
-0.1866929233,
-0.5945317745,
-0.6749426723,
0.2197204828,
-0.620944798,
0.2779298723,
-0.623578012,
-0.0664561987,
-0.4689065814,
0.0353857018,
0.1244799197,
-0.128037706,
-0.7476118207,
0.257486105,
0.3081125617,
1.3348294497,
0.3706702292,
0.7071959376,
-0.5654976964,
0.4407922924,
0.3757410645,
0.2703740001,
-0.0702766776,
-0.2942530513,
-0.2758907378,
-0.2129686326,
-0.4065823257,
-1.3261635303,
0.110489957,
-0.0793455243,
0.7630675435,
0.5653284192,
-0.0988414437,
0.6467902064,
-0.4580225646,
0.9165402055,
-0.3223432302,
-1.0632103682,
0.717415452,
-0.2460750192,
0.5341914892,
0.5051514506,
0.5720590353,
-0.6582852602,
-0.1209349185,
-0.3309038281,
-0.6022307277,
0.8902082443,
0.2471174896,
0.116157487,
0.0912290737,
0.8719657063,
-0.1868917048,
-0.0046640248,
-0.4297200441,
-0.2121873945,
0.2662421763,
-0.409960568,
0.0724146515,
0.0995444134,
0.0109167723,
-0.2273371518,
0.4965113997,
-0.0942468345,
0.4096065462,
-0.0353074335,
-0.0322950743,
-0.3418690562,
-0.0786807686,
0.8271833062,
0.64451015,
-0.3102116883,
-0.4056856036,
0.3457993269,
-0.2852258086,
-0.051868543,
0.3202579916,
0.001653801,
-0.4058904648,
0.563177228,
1.062040925,
-0.1452788413,
-0.9547855258,
0.2708628178,
-0.4396762252,
0.1555851102,
-0.527741909,
0.5490918159,
-0.1069395393,
0.4397544563,
0.4794196784,
0.1617942899,
0.3040494025,
-0.6782607436,
-0.1440331638,
0.7117775679,
-0.3858043551,
-0.6759147644,
0.763728559,
0.1173838526,
-1.0206389427,
0.9487576485,
0.0030610508,
-0.5092955828,
0.5740923882,
0.4622145891,
0.7538909912,
-0.3763741255,
-0.1068980843,
-0.1502372622,
0.0355929695,
0.0774285421,
0.5210546851,
-0.0803137571,
-0.5261178017,
-0.3240464032,
-0.1680676341,
-0.6847060323,
0.1816955358,
-0.8081104755,
0.3718886375,
-0.4276249707,
-0.4992204309,
0.2835733294,
-0.1619692594,
-0.9457680583,
0.4100237787,
0.3805643916,
0.6794855595,
-0.852861166,
0.7637726665,
1.1389670372,
-0.2265048325,
-0.654584527,
0.051186122,
0.2120690197,
-0.4752468765,
0.7140806317,
-0.0349399634,
-0.2601205707,
-0.1487128735,
-0.4280760288,
-0.6031780243,
0.8577423096,
0.3515565097,
-0.2569100261,
-0.5212036371,
0.002451116,
0.7798509002,
-0.3230404258,
0.4349269569,
0.6608451605,
0.5211681128,
-0.3564880192,
-1.1730413437,
-0.0927899331,
-0.5374248028,
-0.0778199583,
0.0082186339,
-0.5289235115,
0.9339931607,
-0.2116733342,
-0.2622714937,
0.1055305377,
0.8579897881,
0.1333771795,
0.415574789,
0.8881698251,
0.2555524707,
0.8297262788,
0.1477604061,
1.2830195427,
-0.0584455542,
0.0408452749,
0.9364839196,
-0.3351904154,
0.830170691,
0.3413354456,
-0.1399847418,
0.7770714164,
0.8465895057,
0.0977375954,
0.0303489957,
0.116963543,
-0.2945723832,
-0.2316752821,
-0.1108250543,
-0.1100119799,
0.5568770766,
0.5840337276,
0.119280383,
0.225239113,
0.5245978832,
-0.1640919745,
0.2268504053,
-0.0993534327,
0.8059382439,
-0.18940337,
-1.0268957615,
0.0775939971,
0.1591952145,
0.4221119285,
-0.4261230528,
-0.2960253954,
0.0425798446,
0.1121918634,
-0.2513102293,
-0.8881320953,
0.1959701329,
0.2130607367,
-0.2215455025,
-0.1375555545,
0.4555548429,
0.0113267247,
-0.4335694313,
0.1834871471,
0.26343894,
0.2425909936,
-0.0080234678,
-0.9589229822,
0.0910578296,
-0.0612897761,
-0.5472122431,
0.2030081749,
0.1342766136,
-0.5099319816,
1.1875911951,
0.3622297645,
-0.1844718903,
-0.0078369183,
-0.0546681546,
0.5979717374,
-0.8151012063,
-0.4443064332,
-0.9163350463,
0.4040149152,
0.0720333681,
-0.4552365839,
0.606790483,
0.0738424063,
0.6585151553,
-0.2147249281,
0.6788563132,
-0.2098763287,
0.24482283,
-0.381983906,
0.8154196143,
-0.7894003987,
0.4155417979,
-0.176079765,
-0.45273754,
-0.1224610433,
0.5097826719,
-0.3045105636,
0.3469040692,
0.1975681186,
0.4680922031,
-0.0629430637,
0.0225688014,
-0.0059226085,
-0.0261323843,
0.5260421634,
0.5581061244,
0.897687912,
0.1230043247,
-0.0069125746,
-0.4650785923,
-0.2533074319,
-0.3914792538,
-0.4871523082,
-0.9714188576,
-1.0169507265,
-0.353739053,
-0.0323012024,
0.0484073758,
1.1186372042,
0.9622071385,
-1.0451248884,
-0.4537697136,
0.2251921892,
-0.0619665906,
-0.1553189009,
-0.2944037318,
0.2234041393,
-0.0520780496,
-1.0750607252,
0.433273524,
0.0456240624,
0.2650635839,
-0.5535666347,
0.1775873452,
-0.3116283119,
0.2623876929,
0.4285959899,
0.4736726284,
-1.0003223419,
-0.5356891751,
0.059649162,
-0.1914513111,
-0.2348343581,
0.742929399,
-0.7788956165,
0.5926207304,
0.3574054539,
0.5879089832,
0.4210425615,
0.3811487854,
0.8599339724,
-0.5141730905,
-0.0528816059,
0.0915994719,
0.3114266098,
0.2260543555,
-1.1079428196,
0.2764756978,
-0.0509732217,
-0.5307562947,
-0.8333453536,
0.2356743664,
-1.360627532,
-0.3071864545,
0.686653614,
-0.4151163101,
-0.1041271538,
-0.2769132257,
-0.70626086,
0.4336351752,
-0.2330310792,
0.8715129495,
0.8640794158,
-0.9661298394,
-0.3079651296,
-0.776101768,
0.4730039239,
0.5444217324,
-1.0874419212,
-0.1889301091,
0.4220016897,
-0.0088793272,
0.1974718124,
0.5019862652,
0.505269587,
0.3649983108,
-0.4751407802,
-0.174561128,
-0.2618072331,
-0.4818267524,
-0.3782606125,
0.2069250643,
0.0753590539,
0.0086666001
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15359v1
|
Constructing Multilingual Visual-Text Datasets Revealing Visual Multilingual Ability of Vision Language Models
| 2024-03-29T10:53:07 | 2024-03-29T10:53:07 |
Jesse Atuhurra, Iqra Ali, Tatsuya Hiraoka, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Tomoya Iwakura, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large language models (LLMs) have increased interest in vision language
models (VLMs), which process image-text pairs as input. Studies investigating
the visual understanding ability of VLMs have been proposed, but such studies
are still preliminary because existing datasets do not permit a comprehensive
evaluation of the fine-grained visual linguistic abilities of VLMs across
multiple languages. To further explore the strengths of VLMs, such as GPT-4V
\cite{openai2023GPT4}, we developed new datasets for the systematic and
qualitative analysis of VLMs. Our contribution is four-fold: 1) we introduced
nine vision-and-language (VL) tasks (including object recognition, image-text
matching, and more) and constructed multilingual visual-text datasets in four
languages: English, Japanese, Swahili, and Urdu through utilizing templates
containing \textit{questions} and prompting GPT4-V to generate the
\textit{answers} and the \textit{rationales}, 2) introduced a new VL task named
\textit{unrelatedness}, 3) introduced rationales to enable human understanding
of the VLM reasoning process, and 4) employed human evaluation to measure the
suitability of proposed datasets for VL tasks. We show that VLMs can be
fine-tuned on our datasets. Our work is the first to conduct such analyses in
Swahili and Urdu. Also, it introduces \textit{rationales} in VL analysis, which
played a vital role in the evaluation.
|
[
-0.407553792,
-0.4164513052,
0.5825486183,
0.1833692938,
-0.2546714246,
-0.0595329888,
-0.3414826691,
-0.6292847991,
-0.1904031485,
0.7608392835,
-0.3595747352,
-0.5363372564,
-0.4275164902,
0.2753827572,
-0.4028768241,
0.8212156892,
-0.2443325818,
0.3144491017,
-0.1569169015,
-0.5347626805,
-0.6177390218,
-0.5377061963,
-0.1047924235,
0.0432108305,
0.6375888586,
0.3549157679,
0.4168789089,
0.5196572542,
0.7666205168,
0.3186187148,
0.1727665663,
0.2310374677,
-0.3244119883,
-0.0234544892,
-0.071879901,
-0.4819130301,
-0.0792784318,
-0.2864180803,
0.7918601036,
0.577439189,
0.0269839298,
0.3185167611,
0.1229079217,
0.7789517045,
-0.6261848807,
0.3341287076,
-0.5757103562,
0.1212160364,
-0.4828659892,
-0.1477819532,
-0.3447363377,
0.0385088176,
0.1313614994,
-0.4612982869,
0.2100123614,
0.0989675447,
0.7852966785,
0.172944054,
-0.5184589624,
-0.0565434396,
-0.6253652573,
0.8126421571,
-0.5050140023,
0.677944839,
0.2546702921,
0.5187093616,
0.2298036665,
-0.6144188643,
-0.5582907796,
-0.1201108173,
-0.0581685603,
0.1949765533,
0.0660011545,
-0.2325909883,
0.339283675,
0.2936108112,
-0.7606133819,
-0.0186889358,
-0.5595604181,
-0.1838658899,
0.5187437534,
0.3103950024,
0.4073264003,
-0.0765387267,
-0.3220100701,
-0.0887612849,
-0.6124774218,
0.1036297232,
0.1066332832,
0.2332748026,
-0.3712706566,
1.0573964119,
-0.3260085881,
1.0454348326,
-0.5698848367,
-0.3685427606,
0.2979562283,
-0.9278229475,
-0.1066759005,
-0.2975490689,
0.7306144834,
0.5136047602,
0.7843761444,
0.0797806978,
-0.1763373315,
0.1479669064,
-0.007681936,
-0.4934383929,
-0.0797737911,
-0.230418995,
-0.5811527967,
-0.186608538,
-0.0858675838,
-0.6311402321,
-0.4474765062,
-0.5042452812,
0.2098157853,
-0.3043601811,
-0.2481051385,
0.1173027977,
-0.2434314489,
0.5293732285,
0.3272573054,
-0.8018764853,
0.1768856347,
0.2538768351,
0.6839385033,
-0.2964825928,
-0.7665182948,
-0.3566597402,
0.0533635132,
-0.376500994,
0.8078582287,
-0.5862505436,
-0.0601064116,
0.2190736979,
-0.0616812222,
-0.0172993243,
-0.4226510227,
0.3031259775,
-0.2545187473,
0.2428117841,
-0.5290222764,
-0.1503240168,
-0.3042243421,
0.4113171101,
-0.7049330473,
0.8149798512,
-0.0039014348,
-0.8229289055,
0.5192761421,
-0.3650823534,
-0.4369016886,
0.2020002156,
-0.523401916,
-0.2082426846,
0.1603182107,
0.4835771918,
0.5807102919,
-0.3593276739,
0.1166529581,
-0.2723434865,
-0.1942764372,
0.2342493236,
-0.5558367372,
0.7108852267,
-0.0330070145,
-0.2830359936,
0.2655996084,
-0.6805023551,
0.1106004268,
0.2298372388,
-0.2318382412,
-0.2480509579,
0.0240066163,
0.3346709013,
0.3214995265,
0.2471748739,
-0.2153544128,
0.0399612412,
-0.3060878515,
0.2454599589,
0.5790446401,
-0.2748474479,
0.2726849616,
-0.0052225282,
0.5188738108,
0.0768512264,
0.3013038039,
-0.3499821723,
-0.7000370026,
-0.9186006188,
-0.1574761569,
-0.0388707966,
0.6645503044,
-1.2327501774,
-0.2794889212,
-0.2903386652,
-0.362744242,
-0.2909331322,
0.4007428885,
0.5628195405,
0.4132657945,
0.2246534824,
-0.1713305563,
-0.4450134933,
-1.1268998384,
-0.3480239213,
-0.0173445381,
0.2593229413,
0.2830044329,
0.5964248776,
-0.0493370928,
0.7173147202,
-0.3904432058,
-0.2810763717,
-0.4858521819,
-0.2041685432,
0.1489481926,
0.0277242921,
0.7519577146,
-1.1216592789,
-0.6160382032,
0.334410876,
-1.0094071627,
0.0186130647,
0.0972266197,
-0.0785675719,
0.3062524498,
0.3296528757,
-0.2817838788,
0.5384219289,
0.5992822051,
-0.4688934088,
0.6845367551,
-0.17116265,
0.2208082229,
-0.8936668634,
-0.0948206335,
0.2300235033,
-0.1527795494,
-0.6934897304,
0.165931344,
0.0647532493,
-0.1506942958,
-0.6405152678,
0.7758777738,
-0.6896686554,
-0.3682645559,
-0.0996450409,
0.0937235728,
-0.1567471325,
0.5690615177,
0.2436859459,
0.6506667137,
0.8448939323,
-0.4049158692,
0.4037767053,
0.180417791,
-0.4987355769,
0.6744953394,
-0.543425858,
-0.2531026602,
-0.2121487111,
-0.3291507959,
-0.7981752157,
-0.3028235435,
0.387665987,
-0.1618451327,
0.0014736279,
-0.1038647145,
-0.3917154372,
-0.404671967,
-0.1776158065,
0.4684531689,
0.2672825754,
-0.4901211858,
0.5873777866,
0.4058303535,
-0.1859100461,
-0.6206896901,
-0.7699664235,
0.3118855953,
-0.1509033591,
-0.5569816828,
-0.1106211767,
-0.1378975809,
-0.3765847683,
-0.0119746309,
0.1683313102,
-0.2168012559,
-0.1339681447,
0.0420522541,
0.4777236283,
-0.2641156614,
-0.0543638505,
-0.3023824096,
-0.053459093,
-0.1311409324,
-0.2501880229,
0.4501104653,
-0.4098114073,
-0.5344668627,
-0.1707193255,
0.3053977787,
0.481818974,
-0.7343536019,
0.4835692346,
0.8579248786,
-0.2727149129,
0.1170039549,
-0.5811359882,
0.1000830457,
-0.3970403671,
0.5370420814,
-0.5729541779,
-0.8897076845,
0.3769408464,
0.4159531295,
0.0234886948,
0.4431449771,
0.8010867834,
-0.0014199356,
1.0605787039,
0.8273577094,
0.0166552085,
0.5604851842,
-0.081846647,
0.1624007672,
-0.5478377938,
-0.2835744619,
-0.251845181,
-0.0045727957,
-0.6779545546,
-0.5114464164,
0.4165584445,
-0.1528582275,
0.0389388204,
-0.0108911376,
-0.3439100087,
0.5767276287,
0.4008547068,
-0.0188486166,
0.2728669047,
0.270965457,
-0.0747525692,
-0.2272158861,
-0.692450285,
-0.444283545,
1.1871819496,
0.1294281036,
0.5773473382,
0.0765774027,
0.3824173808,
0.0372603126,
0.1046965644,
-0.5640599728,
0.5655629635,
-0.2519878745,
-0.3427613974,
-0.3333379626,
-0.295702219,
-0.6575914025,
0.48768574,
-0.3015946746,
-0.6580830216,
0.1139070094,
0.1382997334,
0.0602263547,
0.0204459857,
-0.8191784024,
0.9860460162,
-0.5749296546,
-0.2471802086,
-0.0882081538,
-0.6127151847,
0.496619463,
-0.0953788236,
0.2657428682,
-0.0835234895,
-0.0598228686,
0.6063488126,
-0.0667563081,
0.8274231553,
-0.1090093553,
-0.1817484051,
0.1247090772,
-0.2831800878,
0.1680027992,
-0.0187694561,
0.1923945844,
0.3626486361,
0.058192689,
-0.5082911253,
-0.5352903605,
0.5651983023,
-0.3594363034,
-0.3700503409,
-0.4176803231,
-0.528635025,
-0.14771007,
0.5443906784,
0.155465126,
0.6723771095,
-0.1240212247,
0.1442339122,
0.4757270217,
-0.2881010175,
0.3740307987,
0.5200564861,
-0.5809358358,
-0.3511870205,
1.0909259319,
0.2117100805,
0.1680013835,
0.3322693706,
0.1132219136,
-0.300075084,
-0.6967335939,
-0.6579972506,
0.2259977609,
-0.8164044619,
0.0572163649,
-0.320553571,
-0.1148216426,
-0.1912578493,
0.0329219736,
-0.0957452059,
-0.0438166,
0.08298859,
0.15405339,
0.2985164821,
0.9047781229,
0.1907042861,
-0.0309587214,
-0.7815827131,
0.6810087562,
0.313968569,
0.3294024765,
-0.1531523019,
-0.225101456,
-0.4078414738,
0.097188957,
0.1346978694,
-0.8229255676,
0.4177921414,
0.2878854871,
0.6866801977,
0.2153582275,
-0.393464148,
0.7076761723,
-0.7713947892,
0.710850656,
0.1166429296,
-0.749827683,
0.4927698076,
-0.3966911733,
0.3309341669,
0.2886697352,
0.1524616778,
-0.5019438267,
-0.3189442754,
-0.1058174148,
-0.7076518536,
0.5214900374,
0.4487241507,
-0.0348729417,
0.239572227,
0.2403711081,
0.0621460788,
0.2962595224,
-0.8648726344,
-0.2824299634,
-0.2621079087,
-0.4081452489,
-0.3124589622,
-0.3616609573,
-0.0015693892,
-0.3722368479,
0.1885448992,
-0.3048876524,
0.0329066031,
-0.0097468151,
-0.3108403683,
0.3048414886,
0.1165827811,
0.7204999328,
0.76840204,
0.2325232625,
0.2197960615,
0.1926890165,
-0.612716794,
0.0275643133,
0.0851595178,
-0.0753227025,
-0.1006756723,
0.7266676426,
0.966822505,
0.0949607641,
-0.9069623947,
0.510704875,
-0.299033016,
-0.1432118863,
-0.3186039031,
-0.0648660287,
-0.0390204452,
0.3329725862,
0.1948995292,
0.0954751968,
0.1837953627,
-0.4741874337,
0.0348852016,
0.4403626621,
-0.3536793292,
-0.2636106014,
0.3789540827,
0.0178344082,
-0.0256667417,
0.4060192406,
-0.0275201257,
-0.6189644933,
0.5172668695,
0.4698005617,
0.4620179534,
-0.0371804982,
0.2531368136,
0.1756727993,
0.4835088253,
-0.1437754929,
0.6979663968,
0.064218536,
-0.876211226,
-0.5262877941,
-0.5971452594,
-0.2036442757,
0.018948907,
-0.6125079989,
0.3329759836,
-0.0616848506,
0.1419644803,
0.040777795,
-0.2821323574,
-1.0333673954,
0.256598562,
0.2452720404,
0.5858541727,
-0.9719545841,
0.7599688172,
0.8501340747,
-0.3930517435,
-0.6398346424,
-0.1842942685,
-0.0231433753,
-1.0225129128,
0.8251881599,
0.1635068506,
-0.0605738647,
-0.087309882,
-0.3760831654,
-0.8352683187,
0.7668482661,
0.44822824,
-0.6841686368,
0.1781820059,
0.3937700987,
0.5926167369,
-0.3322038651,
0.0924811587,
0.4607445598,
0.7215082049,
-0.2186926603,
-0.9473387003,
-0.1607543528,
-0.5136063099,
0.1197529435,
0.1788346916,
-0.298933357,
0.7180821896,
-0.4031259716,
-0.1070355102,
0.0231686998,
0.5809215903,
0.1724124998,
0.2600312531,
0.4267001152,
0.3718503714,
0.5199452043,
-0.1515785009,
1.2349040508,
-0.1125800759,
0.0664469302,
1.0283013582,
-0.3786949813,
0.9071826339,
0.5393446088,
-0.0793563575,
0.1241931319,
0.3400106132,
-0.2056005597,
0.4450191259,
-0.0127986269,
-0.0587881021,
-0.3796632886,
-0.2030031234,
-0.2769629657,
0.7184318304,
0.1793348342,
-0.2393913865,
-0.1545743048,
0.4390869141,
-0.4129709601,
0.0330175534,
-0.2530068755,
0.6698645353,
0.0692900568,
-0.360339582,
0.5710658431,
-0.2639301121,
0.4630506039,
-0.5447349548,
-0.1722355336,
0.0039126738,
0.1066943482,
-0.0960821286,
-1.1466170549,
0.179723233,
0.316821605,
-0.2803868353,
-0.1484995931,
0.7795940042,
-0.6243851185,
-0.8782581091,
0.2163829207,
0.701952517,
0.2015431225,
-0.0749654844,
-0.5860430002,
0.2376665324,
0.2199930102,
-0.1647369415,
0.2546399534,
0.4518614709,
-0.4145963788,
0.7366539836,
0.6042639613,
0.2731026709,
0.1338936538,
0.3924943507,
0.7414202094,
-0.7974666357,
-0.1427824348,
-0.9677907228,
0.5757493377,
-0.1215976402,
-0.4145897925,
0.9791798592,
0.6359294057,
0.9206946492,
-0.2566178143,
0.983460784,
0.1000672653,
0.2397794574,
-0.8190289736,
0.5987094641,
-0.8416721821,
-0.0070881411,
-0.3372912705,
-0.9195196033,
-0.5181074142,
0.5841662288,
-0.2614428401,
0.0025619674,
0.6716905236,
0.6121786833,
0.0080772471,
-0.2989646792,
0.4509504735,
0.0968837887,
0.2740853727,
0.3970953822,
0.8296636343,
-0.2899749577,
0.583941102,
-0.309028089,
-0.1372594982,
0.0448902249,
-0.8544015884,
-1.1591926813,
-0.7745105624,
-0.0563007332,
0.081593588,
0.0618052706,
0.3088622391,
0.4026074111,
-0.6415131092,
-0.2851707041,
-0.0017770999,
0.1127980947,
-0.1434983164,
-0.1092987284,
0.3348089159,
-0.0768636838,
-0.5517044067,
0.2672052383,
0.5443295836,
0.1911590695,
-0.3765129745,
-0.1749448627,
0.0202053767,
-0.3346157968,
0.9257861972,
0.2275025994,
-0.9456259012,
-0.1515875459,
0.1553305686,
-0.0856434405,
-0.037800584,
0.570271194,
-0.6212399006,
0.5500127673,
0.4971303344,
0.4454969168,
0.3909581006,
-0.427398771,
0.6698285937,
-0.4563543797,
0.367405653,
0.0109311417,
0.676900804,
0.5487667918,
0.0021914474,
0.5132812858,
0.2274285257,
-0.2264260203,
-0.7796733379,
0.3268820345,
-1.0432692766,
-0.072908476,
1.1518381834,
0.0522244126,
-0.2556081712,
-0.1662724465,
-0.681399405,
0.0475532748,
0.1420734823,
0.3557596505,
0.7082887292,
-0.0058712251,
-0.477765888,
-0.7160698175,
0.3335616589,
0.2295127064,
-0.9551833272,
0.0577200651,
0.5190916657,
0.0910564959,
0.002362493,
0.6597109437,
-0.0231107902,
0.3847994804,
-0.1314936727,
0.0221253708,
-0.0238541123,
-0.529581964,
-0.311355263,
-0.0109772272,
0.1816675961,
-0.0468962304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20103v1
|
NLP for Counterspeech against Hate: A Survey and How-To Guide
| 2024-03-29T10:32:44 | 2024-03-29T10:32:44 |
Helena Bonaldi, Yi-Ling Chung, Gavin Abercrombie, Marco Guerini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, counterspeech has emerged as one of the most promising
strategies to fight online hate. These non-escalatory responses tackle online
abuse while preserving the freedom of speech of the users, and can have a
tangible impact in reducing online and offline violence. Recently, there has
been growing interest from the Natural Language Processing (NLP) community in
addressing the challenges of analysing, collecting, classifying, and
automatically generating counterspeech, to reduce the huge burden of manually
producing it. In particular, researchers have taken different directions in
addressing these challenges, thus providing a variety of related tasks and
resources. In this paper, we provide a guide for doing research on
counterspeech, by describing - with detailed examples - the steps to undertake,
and providing best practices that can be learnt from the NLP studies on this
topic. Finally, we discuss open challenges and future directions of
counterspeech research in NLP.
|
[
-0.8388954997,
-0.9631442428,
-0.0062680002,
0.297074914,
-0.1541296691,
0.1711178869,
0.0576466136,
-0.6339085698,
0.6004199982,
0.5042799711,
-0.8070945144,
-0.1783721596,
-0.8458222747,
0.3560770452,
-0.6032393575,
1.1467744112,
0.0493469425,
0.2437923104,
-0.2492324561,
-0.2475681305,
-0.4458269775,
-0.8483592272,
-0.8022931218,
-0.0038240827,
0.4736088514,
0.3189951777,
0.356267035,
0.1278327852,
0.6062133312,
0.2373550087,
-0.1341019422,
-0.1529904455,
-0.509779036,
0.4933659136,
-0.25787884,
-0.1192442253,
-0.1894762665,
0.0335811637,
0.1678676456,
0.1537327468,
-0.2793645263,
0.277615726,
-0.0188331231,
0.4222193956,
-0.4732356071,
-0.2858099937,
-0.5539962649,
0.3164671361,
-0.6354714036,
-0.1700499207,
-0.296076268,
-0.3476423919,
-0.2844222188,
-0.5878413916,
0.5312951207,
0.0310028959,
0.2832942605,
0.2391186059,
-0.1790768504,
-0.4628493488,
-0.5706012249,
0.9971205592,
-0.8700897694,
0.2693049014,
0.5973662734,
0.3093335927,
-0.1679612249,
-0.5029109716,
-0.6550242901,
0.0824029073,
0.0064570424,
0.1104704961,
-0.3631920218,
-0.3339111209,
0.6101927757,
0.2291782647,
-0.5704324245,
0.0030143387,
-0.18018125,
-0.1195084304,
0.6519294977,
0.1901281029,
0.4784205854,
-0.0970605165,
-0.5360609293,
0.2116332203,
-0.4430475831,
-0.2477644533,
0.5639041066,
0.3338044882,
0.0555461273,
0.5315471888,
-0.3507155776,
0.7959963083,
-0.0515209064,
-0.0420050547,
0.0329736918,
-0.1961319596,
0.1857949644,
0.0470321551,
0.715428412,
0.6294316053,
0.357544601,
-0.1519214064,
0.018895749,
0.2216642797,
0.7701584697,
-0.7902408838,
-0.0913640559,
0.2174096107,
-0.4270354807,
-0.3043883443,
-0.6289052963,
-1.3024921417,
-0.5243623257,
-0.247509107,
0.144316256,
-0.3116320074,
-0.5112111568,
-0.4542980492,
-0.5160459876,
0.2324390411,
0.2184500396,
-0.8230150938,
0.9301508665,
0.5430313945,
0.9447228312,
-0.3039967716,
-0.0527799465,
-0.5534155369,
-0.3467059433,
-0.1896898597,
0.9533703327,
-0.3584297001,
-0.5402110219,
0.0349627323,
-0.4804589152,
0.247128889,
-0.5113979578,
0.4219301641,
-0.5090143085,
0.2539776564,
-0.4097403884,
-0.5144463181,
-0.0150403744,
0.687045157,
-0.5652256608,
1.1822533607,
-0.0570252016,
-1.1178944111,
-0.0164226759,
-0.7683435678,
-0.398971349,
0.1885893494,
-0.0150930416,
-0.4485673308,
0.1595821679,
0.1003833935,
0.0638709813,
-0.3364276886,
-0.0973879248,
-0.1983460039,
0.2012224346,
-0.0177515112,
0.065632768,
1.3002932072,
0.3353010416,
-0.5770987272,
0.1095346957,
-0.7135906219,
-0.0150665473,
0.4494631588,
0.1745198369,
-0.4021536708,
0.186275959,
0.2320469469,
0.1548701078,
-0.2953613698,
-0.8645424247,
0.0922939628,
-0.2499236315,
0.1207225621,
0.586183846,
0.1435480565,
0.0880212635,
-0.2573051453,
0.8395746946,
-0.4050229192,
0.3852006197,
0.2904522121,
-0.8687677979,
-0.553699851,
0.2886082232,
-0.0283315461,
0.6007005572,
-0.8379541636,
-0.0148918349,
0.4782654047,
-0.6572241187,
-0.3776459396,
-0.0832146555,
0.563886404,
1.0039365292,
1.0532655716,
-0.6605660319,
-1.1199176311,
-0.5416443348,
-0.4735367596,
-0.1398523897,
0.1637791246,
0.0248676501,
0.383105725,
-0.0075280848,
1.0097821951,
-0.5780923367,
-0.3672997355,
-0.2643263042,
0.6455987692,
-0.4010427892,
0.2507483363,
0.5638948083,
-0.9201749563,
-0.8283150196,
-0.6708327532,
-0.4633575678,
-0.5082763433,
0.3497794569,
-0.0423909202,
0.1346338093,
0.6101688147,
-0.0406650715,
0.598762393,
0.4702939391,
-0.2156800181,
0.8107815981,
0.7858992219,
0.3225746751,
-1.0891143084,
0.0391934067,
-0.1550251693,
-0.0736920536,
-1.0583440065,
0.5322140455,
-0.5979422331,
-0.1435202658,
-0.5272060633,
0.609160006,
-0.0113340402,
0.2289151102,
-0.3247688711,
-0.070385091,
-0.4544638991,
0.1610384881,
0.2535237968,
0.5045455098,
0.0512967706,
-0.4472826421,
0.5044217706,
0.5209462643,
-0.3198659122,
0.8895608187,
-0.3749687374,
0.2978018224,
0.014928923,
0.1019701064,
-0.6212673187,
0.3716602921,
0.3817521632,
-0.8436975479,
-0.1144545451,
-0.4359618723,
-0.2873420715,
-0.2574819624,
-0.2452816069,
0.5410300493,
0.4087973237,
-0.2772932053,
0.5886895061,
0.7918980122,
-0.2342487872,
-0.9494358301,
-0.642105639,
0.3455948532,
-0.290618211,
-0.0252117235,
0.3042836785,
-0.5660147071,
-0.810546279,
-0.2347521484,
0.3112231791,
-0.316954881,
0.1305227131,
0.3650989234,
-0.2350626737,
0.1529851854,
-0.1381530166,
-0.5838350058,
-0.2963158786,
0.3093552589,
0.1070864573,
0.811165452,
0.2297861725,
-0.0817278773,
0.1488732249,
0.7942177653,
-0.1903869957,
-0.0817885473,
0.5957536697,
0.8459782004,
-0.3776163757,
-0.3816056252,
-0.577460289,
-0.1860969961,
-0.3839299083,
0.1651492864,
-0.0588213652,
-0.7447162867,
0.405410558,
0.0920900032,
0.3517818451,
0.6712637544,
0.8106102347,
-0.180502072,
0.684977293,
0.6787256002,
0.0345961191,
0.2737748027,
0.1326900572,
0.35256055,
-0.4583162665,
-0.2719067335,
-0.9218066931,
-0.1853081137,
-0.2863577902,
-0.5584046245,
0.0707690865,
-0.1178646907,
-0.1275776774,
0.5897810459,
-0.8054913878,
0.2916810811,
0.4570941627,
-0.4072293639,
0.1492562145,
0.03424301,
-0.0697733238,
-0.5974617004,
-0.6352789998,
0.0253373608,
0.675540626,
-0.0864962041,
0.3252290487,
0.3815469146,
0.6611564159,
0.5183625221,
0.3895298839,
-0.8616724014,
0.7434809804,
0.0609892346,
-1.014759779,
-0.3277327418,
-0.4285713434,
-0.7648486495,
-0.0427271873,
-0.3010621369,
-0.4516429901,
-0.2629131973,
0.3139612079,
-0.1158250123,
0.6524105072,
-0.2168459296,
0.5818436742,
-0.1456667036,
-0.0693693534,
-0.3581679761,
-0.5677908659,
0.2744899988,
0.0449732505,
0.530890584,
-0.0760503858,
0.2298403084,
1.0093638897,
-0.478327632,
0.9623298049,
-0.3624062836,
0.0370295234,
0.5248020887,
0.3286165893,
0.1260252744,
-0.5198897123,
-0.0107835131,
0.4344159365,
-0.056080047,
-0.3221517801,
-0.1572512835,
0.4803658724,
-0.3892689347,
-0.3161635101,
-0.674254179,
-0.3134624362,
-0.2868571579,
0.3225305378,
0.3187951446,
0.2022105157,
-0.6962270737,
-0.1854975522,
0.7405599356,
-0.2944145501,
0.4597705603,
0.5946208239,
-0.5743247271,
-0.4205118418,
0.8646790981,
0.3614858985,
0.039597407,
0.5504364371,
0.4204713702,
-0.4344479442,
-0.5819836855,
-0.3865893781,
-0.245586291,
-0.5353339911,
-0.35178262,
-0.7802090049,
-0.2580362856,
-0.837718606,
-0.168019399,
-0.4365361333,
-0.3734597862,
0.0109932413,
0.0971630886,
0.8751845956,
1.001483798,
-0.4310342371,
0.3853599131,
-0.3774168193,
0.8591080904,
0.505664587,
0.5228486061,
0.2296434939,
-0.5045607686,
-0.1331306249,
-0.3425305486,
0.044522617,
-1.1381752491,
0.6762784123,
-0.3284950852,
0.3585170507,
0.0039858371,
0.5839712024,
0.9054168463,
-0.7628908753,
0.7912496328,
0.4398400187,
-0.6369802952,
0.5363675952,
-0.1914749444,
0.1205506176,
0.5948044658,
0.8892506957,
-1.0629931688,
-0.2814755142,
-0.9231147766,
-1.0266569853,
0.4036561549,
0.1661171019,
-0.0065147653,
-0.1546028554,
-0.2517615855,
0.037336655,
0.2473677546,
-0.7336184382,
-0.2632840574,
-0.5065639019,
0.0721982867,
0.0386448726,
-0.3292313218,
-0.5243917704,
-0.1445530504,
0.7783065438,
0.2084565461,
0.1339831799,
-0.0409405008,
-0.2380671203,
-0.1103690565,
0.1728215069,
0.4775975347,
0.4186709523,
-0.2305810302,
0.2594463229,
0.4232586026,
-0.5326433778,
-0.07408344,
-0.0981336012,
-0.3169797063,
0.1202961877,
0.3193919361,
0.2846062183,
-0.0720097721,
-0.4395007491,
0.5123305917,
-0.2834083736,
-0.3472647965,
-0.7746995091,
-0.2333303988,
0.0136669856,
-0.1674570292,
0.2960185409,
-0.0821888596,
0.0838265792,
-0.2728251815,
0.4022534788,
0.3163611293,
-0.4708487391,
-0.033101365,
0.3820699453,
0.2301430702,
-0.8201738596,
0.5847007036,
-0.4016602635,
-0.6348831654,
0.4505198598,
0.6843461394,
0.7394246459,
-0.4300926924,
0.3720949292,
0.6408946514,
0.2996344864,
0.2188622355,
0.212100029,
-0.152237758,
-0.7097546458,
-0.2696883082,
-0.85439533,
-0.7301539183,
0.2863367796,
-0.6977901459,
-0.0684299022,
-0.8845722675,
-0.071049951,
0.0807962716,
0.0534359142,
-0.4569968581,
0.2862666547,
0.2017725855,
0.8474274874,
-0.8381796479,
0.2216987759,
0.3730039001,
-0.4254167974,
-0.3512450755,
-0.1759229302,
0.7784636617,
-0.7857539654,
0.4012767971,
0.0380172469,
-0.3741176426,
-0.0328723714,
-0.7315747142,
-0.6101568937,
0.0447294079,
-0.4136986136,
-0.4248231351,
0.3268229365,
0.3354545832,
0.6939349771,
-0.077723816,
0.343365252,
0.3377692103,
0.3855560124,
-0.134689644,
-0.5532598495,
-0.0087240497,
-0.5328419209,
-0.4889070392,
0.2835949659,
-0.53054142,
0.701515317,
0.2885870636,
-0.1577329785,
-0.1175609007,
0.1829416752,
-0.0235860851,
0.2132094502,
0.6011013985,
1.0752594471,
0.0745025575,
0.0675866753,
0.7966540456,
0.0787355229,
0.0435175821,
1.3104655743,
-0.0207512286,
0.920271039,
0.4033966064,
-0.4747591615,
0.5154457688,
0.216946125,
-0.1422439665,
-0.040786393,
0.4350754917,
-0.3405731022,
0.0104963342,
-0.4988224208,
-0.3041214943,
0.4055885673,
0.2466497719,
0.0607465692,
-0.539652288,
-0.0527983084,
0.1540923417,
0.5283840895,
-0.3085568547,
0.9956133366,
0.046168454,
-0.4079885483,
0.2503795624,
0.1356845796,
0.8321737051,
-0.6910450459,
-0.1684173048,
-0.0730665252,
-0.1529224813,
-0.3556773067,
-0.7984874249,
0.9422811866,
0.5232774019,
-0.3508823216,
-0.6457906961,
0.823304534,
-0.0847432613,
-0.2208829969,
0.5245814919,
0.3914073706,
0.4417852759,
-0.173917219,
-1.0476772785,
-0.0097580831,
0.0567411557,
-0.118013382,
0.7418417335,
-0.1055769622,
-0.0757811591,
0.5168927908,
0.7538753152,
0.3569528759,
0.1371600926,
0.2536467314,
0.5280141234,
-0.9011726379,
-0.3289725184,
-0.6942064762,
0.3948257565,
-0.372667104,
-0.4868803024,
0.8982661366,
0.5194934011,
1.0944693089,
0.1046968624,
0.6177384257,
-0.5745031238,
1.3477432728,
-0.0504974052,
0.6047567129,
-0.3216732442,
-0.3556311727,
-0.4093440771,
-0.6419087648,
-0.4780937731,
0.4868187904,
-0.1045779064,
-0.351280272,
0.4463089705,
0.8177964687,
0.2200020254,
0.0710244104,
0.2094929069,
0.2408798784,
0.3029373288,
-0.0032057692,
0.770447731,
-0.3222560287,
0.6136142015,
-0.4601477087,
-0.1479289681,
-0.1044107229,
-0.8826037049,
-0.6870299578,
-0.5593851805,
-0.1438010335,
-0.405130744,
-0.0566037707,
0.7467585802,
0.3645818532,
-1.0511847734,
-0.3705540299,
0.0670168847,
0.2268468738,
-0.3138783574,
-0.197821036,
-0.201827839,
-0.2435150146,
-0.6545194387,
0.3939492106,
0.0860358104,
-0.1695604175,
-0.042126473,
0.1268299967,
-0.5955661535,
0.1501780599,
0.7138627768,
0.8239612579,
-0.4440979958,
0.1165669858,
-0.2548498809,
0.0262252409,
0.0355704278,
1.2058823109,
-0.790325284,
0.7827032804,
0.5702561736,
0.6493500471,
0.4080260992,
-0.0551163144,
0.3970453143,
-0.9295905828,
0.0773976594,
0.8275543451,
-0.0426366255,
0.2544941604,
-0.0708125979,
0.6497036219,
0.3569808602,
-0.4317004085,
-0.851318121,
0.6951964498,
-0.6780648828,
-0.4969811141,
0.8444803953,
0.2317430824,
0.2871977687,
-0.7434341908,
-0.0661117956,
0.5412630439,
-0.163601771,
1.0736069679,
0.591807425,
-0.333327353,
-0.2665312588,
-0.446454376,
0.9680280089,
0.4482140839,
-0.8188192844,
0.2108999789,
0.2010631561,
0.0277724955,
0.4309561849,
0.9058893919,
-0.2257426679,
-0.0106676584,
0.3084030151,
0.430858463,
0.1534523219,
-0.2326076031,
-0.0525124483,
0.3761387467,
-0.0948772952,
0.3918053806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20101v1
|
RealKIE: Five Novel Datasets for Enterprise Key Information Extraction
| 2024-03-29T10:31:32 | 2024-03-29T10:31:32 |
Benjamin Townsend, Madison May, Christopher Wells
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
We introduce RealKIE, a benchmark of five challenging datasets aimed at
advancing key information extraction methods, with an emphasis on enterprise
applications. The datasets include a diverse range of documents including SEC
S1 Filings, US Non-disclosure Agreements, UK Charity Reports, FCC Invoices, and
Resource Contracts. Each presents unique challenges: poor text serialization,
sparse annotations in long documents, and complex tabular layouts. These
datasets provide a realistic testing ground for key information extraction
tasks like investment analysis and legal data processing.
In addition to presenting these datasets, we offer an in-depth description of
the annotation process, document processing techniques, and baseline modeling
approaches. This contribution facilitates the development of NLP models capable
of handling practical challenges and supports further research into information
extraction technologies applicable to industry-specific problems.
The annotated data and OCR outputs are available to download at
https://indicodatasolutions.github.io/RealKIE/ code to reproduce the baselines
will be available shortly.
|
[
-0.2350873202,
-0.5800400972,
0.3861861527,
-0.0797996372,
-0.1359010786,
0.2767929435,
-0.1994967163,
-0.8530554175,
0.2541649044,
0.9051642418,
-0.7787799835,
-0.65056777,
-0.455353111,
0.2269473821,
-0.2370856106,
0.8690181375,
0.1494053006,
-0.3879977465,
-0.0034475306,
-0.1369136572,
-0.5959041119,
-0.4802038968,
-0.0035121278,
0.2310890108,
0.2099849433,
0.768411994,
0.4212318063,
0.7803069353,
0.8648548126,
0.1503621489,
0.1142744198,
0.0282138418,
-0.1425133049,
0.4523001015,
0.163594678,
-0.5135729313,
-0.3931584358,
0.427131623,
0.3934909105,
0.3998903334,
-0.1111431718,
0.6436615586,
-0.4856735468,
0.502949357,
-0.9301524162,
0.4871792197,
-0.7540242672,
0.2882417142,
-0.3995254934,
0.0777389482,
-0.4037864506,
-0.4139839411,
0.0642961562,
-1.0121860504,
0.1813084483,
0.2767069638,
1.5917775631,
0.0020998681,
-0.194861412,
-0.6201357841,
-0.7070200443,
0.6531277299,
-0.6256807446,
0.4082619548,
0.2498509884,
0.5703498125,
0.1853196174,
-1.3817849159,
-0.5277311802,
-0.1732666641,
0.020103734,
0.4543362558,
-0.1426268667,
-0.0438112579,
0.5947600603,
0.2605397701,
-0.1744431555,
0.3144454062,
-0.6601516008,
0.013240681,
0.3870165944,
0.1709864587,
0.0428578332,
-0.1635155827,
-0.0964973271,
-0.391492337,
-0.737973392,
0.0419238843,
0.6150033474,
0.3401109278,
0.071477361,
0.5024649501,
-0.2130506188,
0.4228319526,
-0.0698961616,
-0.0584089309,
0.2925125957,
-0.4093640149,
-0.3406971395,
0.176640451,
0.4656865001,
0.1164953634,
0.1212738529,
-0.3421749771,
-0.0849695057,
-0.2244477272,
0.4910286665,
-0.5885080695,
-0.5520012975,
0.5328919888,
-0.7481316328,
-0.6224411726,
0.3498422503,
-0.9613915682,
-0.4328168631,
-0.2220085412,
0.1140101627,
-0.2393308729,
-0.4070121646,
-0.1109610945,
-0.7111551762,
0.5063180327,
0.322034657,
-0.8429914713,
0.2946196496,
0.8829253912,
0.5899063945,
0.3045628369,
0.1385954767,
-0.4879860282,
0.2317214161,
-0.5016310215,
0.5906496048,
-0.7692982554,
-0.1235117465,
0.0125204157,
0.0343933254,
0.2446923554,
-0.93311131,
0.7704063654,
-0.5155459642,
0.0590777285,
-0.4363350868,
-0.5752744675,
-0.0970486253,
0.1468608081,
-1.198585391,
0.9206529856,
0.2166242898,
-0.573333621,
0.8014867902,
-0.772970736,
0.0616212673,
0.562268436,
-0.5152314901,
-0.55447191,
0.1900645494,
-0.0458816737,
0.5141947865,
-0.5499616861,
-0.0179693308,
-0.3269248009,
0.0964535847,
0.0992349312,
-0.1234088168,
0.702927351,
0.3151648939,
-0.1881503761,
-0.2786209285,
-1.1964644194,
-0.0106427195,
0.4200987816,
0.0545326248,
-0.5204423666,
-0.2781402767,
0.1926864982,
0.1039361209,
0.4328427017,
-0.5890648365,
0.386877358,
0.0684347525,
0.3982529044,
0.463722229,
0.2276551276,
0.1280809194,
0.1167920679,
0.5456585884,
0.2133481055,
0.376753211,
-0.2782969475,
-0.3087425828,
-0.3683503568,
-0.6765847206,
0.8749728799,
0.7322931886,
-0.1560731977,
0.5535692573,
-0.5491217375,
-0.568762064,
-0.8522032499,
-0.1593618393,
0.1949123293,
0.460095644,
0.2518700063,
-0.3893104494,
-0.6394434571,
-1.2328083515,
-0.3675888479,
-0.1606998593,
-0.2042470574,
-0.0477435514,
0.4753576517,
0.1601210237,
1.1492420435,
-0.5874322057,
-0.4622437954,
-0.1780698895,
0.5910317898,
0.4175749719,
0.2147621959,
0.2547036111,
-0.9619365931,
-0.2676683366,
0.0610658377,
-1.0095965862,
0.1002711207,
-0.4961343706,
0.2478859574,
-0.4506631494,
0.4500690997,
-0.5834026337,
0.2907250822,
0.0055429661,
-0.0990958661,
0.5859165192,
0.01311344,
-0.06392847,
-0.9119516015,
0.423151046,
-0.0267066341,
-0.3225293756,
-0.6670668721,
0.1595055461,
0.5835642815,
-0.2153594345,
-0.2267613262,
0.2305363566,
-0.6764996648,
-0.2552093267,
0.3881919682,
0.2931685448,
0.3257055283,
0.030991083,
-0.0055652377,
0.6981136203,
0.0709954947,
-0.4113965631,
0.5854689479,
0.5067496896,
-0.4685045481,
0.3547077775,
-0.3452902138,
-0.0102961408,
-0.077505514,
0.0258727968,
-0.5218616724,
-0.245706439,
0.1053086147,
-0.3127236366,
0.422210753,
-0.2983817756,
-0.5273529291,
0.0006632108,
-0.5152190328,
-0.4851996303,
0.4443000555,
-0.3888625801,
0.5649807453,
0.6358686686,
-0.3819479346,
-0.5817445517,
-0.6514826417,
0.5062035322,
-0.5317596197,
-0.352211237,
0.3262497485,
0.5462063551,
-0.3920826614,
0.2222615927,
-0.1495952904,
-0.3399741352,
0.3222866654,
0.2110099196,
0.402061969,
-0.0829892084,
-0.0657929108,
-0.2406395078,
-0.2832432389,
-0.0641912445,
-0.1992959529,
-0.132605359,
0.2116359919,
0.1232171878,
-0.4405444264,
0.1229688004,
0.3310565054,
-0.2731565237,
0.5691178441,
0.5042908192,
-0.702198565,
0.053627152,
-0.5708695054,
-0.0732907876,
-0.3829101324,
0.4763484895,
-0.8147340417,
-0.1871383786,
0.7904937267,
-0.4405639768,
0.6264004707,
0.5813096166,
0.2545828819,
-0.1071752161,
0.3819676638,
0.6757551432,
0.0058130976,
0.4603010118,
-0.6910304427,
0.4860226214,
-0.6586526036,
-0.2762636244,
-0.8727811575,
-0.0125487642,
-0.5409127474,
0.0609554201,
0.0661244094,
0.1110440716,
0.3456655443,
0.7279809713,
-0.3257907331,
0.4472929239,
0.5225071311,
-0.3141880035,
0.2155661732,
-0.1561891139,
0.0262847114,
-0.3638352156,
-0.4677194059,
-0.9048299789,
1.1858494282,
0.6078905463,
0.5250279307,
0.0197503511,
0.7364441156,
0.5603450537,
0.1741016954,
-0.4762672484,
0.1551632881,
-0.2067030519,
-0.7834835649,
-0.5070582032,
-0.2444047332,
-0.7762560248,
-0.0693907738,
-0.412902683,
-0.8166467547,
0.5718104839,
-0.0903006271,
-0.5794579983,
0.0594140403,
-0.7871918082,
1.0586420298,
-0.0260769613,
-0.3977627158,
0.0404309854,
-0.796361804,
0.3296487033,
-0.1516646296,
0.3101257384,
-0.2501364648,
-0.1555798054,
0.9430778623,
-0.1953223646,
0.5079972148,
-0.3171481192,
0.1475073099,
0.1854820997,
-0.0645200461,
0.8635182381,
0.0938904807,
-0.0221781377,
0.2121535987,
0.3702550828,
-0.2370737642,
-0.4417856038,
0.1730422378,
-0.3829624355,
0.0216201004,
-0.484382987,
0.0647936016,
-0.1120985523,
0.1707016081,
0.3284052312,
0.4113987386,
-0.1474236399,
0.4180945754,
0.7028726339,
0.057610929,
0.3808688819,
0.20161964,
0.4172899723,
-0.5839370489,
0.9278075099,
0.5718405843,
-0.0453161262,
0.4917004704,
-0.233096391,
-0.4461416602,
-0.4526259303,
-0.379779011,
0.0249721408,
-0.9367848635,
-0.2393313199,
-0.6821012497,
0.0435582101,
-0.5355741382,
0.0641731992,
-0.5576577187,
-0.9544545412,
-0.3624900579,
-0.433257401,
0.097107619,
0.8516415954,
0.2378532588,
0.0826913938,
-1.0660068989,
0.5565282702,
0.1985328197,
0.1527421474,
-0.3493776023,
0.0175561849,
-0.5569140911,
-0.3760143518,
-0.3308705986,
-0.9971269369,
0.4340811074,
0.1034257933,
0.6342206001,
0.2011219114,
0.1151336581,
0.7055090666,
-0.1026387289,
0.9216742516,
0.0194841661,
-0.5764792562,
0.2799469531,
-0.0496386401,
-0.3537570238,
1.0632762909,
0.436810106,
-0.5511229038,
-0.1775010228,
-1.2513773441,
-1.2506166697,
0.6159956455,
0.4201377034,
-0.4859855473,
0.3122524321,
0.6198010445,
0.1961432099,
0.3764564395,
-0.4215249121,
-0.0332201719,
0.0433232412,
-0.5129358768,
0.5067817569,
-0.3065493703,
-0.041741617,
0.5259880424,
0.6740038991,
0.241900444,
0.1968789101,
0.2015878856,
-0.4210540652,
0.1422425359,
0.0305204708,
0.234596774,
0.7910376787,
-0.667336762,
-0.1124608442,
-0.0297188573,
-0.9318045378,
-0.0968560502,
-0.0548733175,
-0.1835258305,
0.2245071828,
0.716375351,
0.5828028321,
-0.1412039548,
-0.570892334,
0.3662072718,
-0.5262342691,
-0.1154395416,
-0.7518537641,
-0.1096892655,
-0.2108373642,
0.1335603446,
0.6159015298,
-0.6271265149,
0.3701070249,
-0.4266287684,
0.2486268878,
0.123106055,
-0.2921616435,
-0.2942459285,
0.668838799,
0.275619179,
-0.0216553882,
0.8393802643,
-0.0490850098,
0.0158559922,
0.7562514544,
0.1159051955,
1.0865995884,
0.4207915664,
-0.1972766519,
0.2525153756,
0.5193066597,
0.1072493717,
0.1428251863,
-0.1015506834,
-0.3638327718,
-0.1164570823,
-0.3080660105,
-0.9432527423,
0.5045938492,
-0.6775804758,
0.5509032607,
-0.5341251493,
-0.2226945907,
0.5059137344,
0.4606678784,
-0.7906939983,
0.2910058796,
-0.1625005156,
1.0533304214,
-0.9696552157,
0.6978881955,
0.4537824392,
-0.8164978623,
-0.3519004583,
-0.0751682967,
-0.1345686316,
-0.4613746107,
0.5771935582,
0.0345554464,
0.5362398624,
-0.0910079554,
-0.3771992028,
-0.3784691393,
1.2000433207,
0.0744670033,
-0.839330554,
-0.2231172621,
0.134597376,
0.0401723646,
-0.3900057673,
0.3859052062,
0.8003764749,
0.6836302876,
-0.4634548724,
-0.4371465445,
-0.1726303101,
-0.213860333,
-0.1836307496,
0.1120970473,
-0.4808444977,
0.5812787414,
0.4474269748,
-0.0979007483,
-0.3093654513,
0.6988862753,
0.2080436349,
0.1779243201,
0.3995237947,
0.4897178113,
0.977493763,
-0.0078225164,
0.6799118519,
-0.3811462522,
0.1848774701,
1.0901924372,
-0.4951245189,
0.6579078436,
0.462026,
-0.2087865621,
0.2288933098,
0.7289487123,
-0.1629476696,
0.4409374893,
0.0895323902,
-0.0892863274,
0.1054610312,
-0.0052412883,
-0.25098297,
0.2104717493,
0.5999512076,
-0.0404496938,
0.1036199853,
-0.3277514577,
0.0718477294,
-0.2089000195,
0.2897462845,
1.1360096931,
-0.1360761225,
-0.1187455058,
0.1081442833,
0.1917954832,
0.360543102,
-0.8316470981,
-0.3613593578,
-0.1066283658,
-0.0679097325,
-0.211237371,
-0.5919350982,
0.199561581,
0.1837046593,
-0.0559362173,
-0.2236848176,
0.8124866486,
-0.0634405613,
-0.1733758152,
-0.1181483492,
-0.0214292407,
0.2584679723,
-0.0547097474,
-0.5455908179,
-0.0551037118,
-0.0796221644,
-0.3588353992,
0.1842736453,
0.8021612167,
-0.2987940013,
0.3075227439,
0.5661728978,
0.5152922273,
0.2790652514,
-0.1305626184,
0.562977612,
-1.0825066566,
-0.5773463249,
-0.5433552265,
0.5951577425,
-0.7101231217,
-0.4781927466,
0.5190214515,
0.9844739437,
0.6276102662,
-0.2340826392,
1.1400668621,
-0.2388225794,
0.5894197226,
-0.6285383701,
0.3232769966,
-0.0427938178,
0.2461363077,
-0.0847112462,
-0.8501041532,
-0.1940973699,
0.3828348219,
0.0811083987,
-0.5107742548,
0.6267077327,
0.5865319967,
-0.201272577,
0.1595582664,
0.329644382,
0.1948285997,
0.6678698063,
-0.0447466262,
0.4747163355,
-0.7469934821,
0.4970114231,
-0.5211697817,
-0.1772196293,
-0.3930536211,
-1.0398895741,
-0.2122659683,
-0.6659204364,
-0.4246491194,
-0.3573226035,
0.1050763205,
0.8964981437,
0.7145920992,
-0.8052614927,
-0.0914630964,
-0.1054192111,
-0.0382871516,
-0.2715381384,
-0.2536859214,
0.2423233837,
-0.5119190812,
-0.4410879314,
0.2577236295,
0.4730787575,
-0.0479300171,
-0.0368028507,
0.3579152226,
-0.2546685636,
-0.145027101,
0.112239331,
0.4476750195,
-0.2632815838,
-0.2167642862,
-0.0709686279,
-0.0055008694,
0.1131557226,
0.7770240307,
-0.5165427327,
0.3636654913,
0.5641856194,
0.5973998904,
0.7503029704,
0.0592246875,
0.4048095047,
-0.8383522034,
0.4047067165,
0.3142319322,
0.106193006,
0.1001743749,
-0.4823479652,
0.8285769224,
0.3636627197,
-0.2430806011,
-1.0043987036,
-0.091268599,
-0.7863491774,
-0.1583931893,
0.4024637043,
-0.3012599945,
-0.5447285175,
-0.4140102267,
-0.0251421221,
0.3026700318,
-0.3323866129,
0.6995648146,
0.7885224819,
0.0270002242,
-0.0912812874,
-1.0062395334,
0.5643994212,
-0.0710460246,
-0.9542936683,
0.5601001382,
0.4540455937,
-0.0246911552,
0.3029903471,
0.6007544994,
-0.3758556843,
0.1806134135,
0.365719229,
0.489739269,
-0.1019819751,
-0.587956965,
-0.4293202162,
0.4248198271,
0.2532625198,
-0.4598181248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20088v1
|
An Efficient Approach for Studying Cross-Lingual Transfer in Multilingual Language Models
| 2024-03-29T09:52:18 | 2024-03-29T09:52:18 |
Fahim Faisal, Antonios Anastasopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The capacity and effectiveness of pre-trained multilingual models (MLMs) for
zero-shot cross-lingual transfer is well established. However, phenomena of
positive or negative transfer, and the effect of language choice still need to
be fully understood, especially in the complex setting of massively
multilingual LMs. We propose an \textit{efficient} method to study transfer
language influence in zero-shot performance on another target language. Unlike
previous work, our approach disentangles downstream tasks from language, using
dedicated adapter units. Our findings suggest that some languages do not
largely affect others, while some languages, especially ones unseen during
pre-training, can be extremely beneficial or detrimental for different target
languages. We find that no transfer language is beneficial for all target
languages. We do, curiously, observe languages previously unseen by MLMs
consistently benefit from transfer from almost any language. We additionally
use our modular approach to quantify negative interference efficiently and
categorize languages accordingly. Furthermore, we provide a list of promising
transfer-target language configurations that consistently lead to target
language performance improvements. Code and data are publicly available:
https://github.com/ffaisal93/neg_inf
|
[
-0.3838524222,
-0.6327854395,
0.2123217583,
0.3818686604,
-0.0623590276,
-0.0198671669,
-0.4529671669,
-0.6689501405,
0.2825336158,
0.3129207194,
-0.3705798984,
-0.135930419,
-0.6693691015,
0.0820450708,
-0.2564418614,
0.8445341587,
-0.1698853672,
0.2927589417,
0.0487679094,
-0.148168996,
-0.332336992,
-0.679627955,
-0.537317276,
-0.4987050593,
0.621098876,
0.4935785532,
0.2832187712,
0.0935250521,
0.4672775865,
0.2069382668,
0.2791190147,
-0.4283017516,
-0.8458390832,
-0.1516532302,
-0.6454848051,
-0.4954769015,
-0.4505808353,
-0.1684212685,
0.7808068991,
0.6450884938,
0.1767481267,
0.3891803622,
-0.0301258024,
0.3287945092,
-0.882093668,
0.0064097173,
-0.6879851222,
0.1777478606,
-0.4885317683,
-0.320440948,
-0.6609960198,
-0.025804203,
-0.0419196598,
-0.4555152059,
-0.130041495,
-0.2573101819,
0.5932449102,
-0.0867454186,
-0.5952079296,
0.0548494682,
-0.9260413647,
0.8782483935,
-0.6797360182,
0.4449306428,
0.230411604,
0.3190787733,
0.1581636071,
-0.2005497813,
-0.5746407509,
-0.3080855608,
-0.2108293772,
0.1278096139,
-0.2782081962,
-0.028970195,
0.0473887138,
0.1464229822,
-0.6553124785,
0.1300489753,
-0.2159540206,
-0.21995233,
0.5934002995,
-0.2017084658,
0.6735268235,
0.1736299545,
-0.3605537415,
0.0004989163,
-0.6784721613,
-0.0340119265,
0.3474301696,
0.484888345,
-0.150259614,
0.5462700129,
-0.1427473426,
0.942700088,
0.0014919736,
-0.1567222774,
0.195580557,
-0.7834737301,
-0.0159706231,
0.0991994366,
0.4749039114,
0.1113646105,
0.5195006132,
-0.4961591661,
-0.007529512,
-0.0773575455,
0.0771078542,
-1.025386095,
-0.0113949561,
-0.3038563728,
-0.1577665955,
0.0570487119,
-0.3104561567,
-0.4384151399,
0.0374212116,
-0.2567819655,
0.8860908747,
-0.3918324411,
-0.5687032938,
0.1439640969,
-0.0002255409,
0.4037766755,
0.0620679297,
-0.810575366,
0.1343180239,
0.2751785815,
0.7698587775,
-0.2382728159,
-0.5940693021,
-0.7044455409,
0.2933704257,
-0.4248129725,
0.7016462684,
-0.5176173449,
-0.1628029794,
-0.0784219876,
0.1320219338,
-0.6300973892,
-0.323010236,
0.1089766994,
-0.3460235596,
0.126770556,
-0.1198927164,
-0.470790267,
-0.4509511292,
0.3963502049,
-0.5307351947,
0.6134767532,
0.1145204306,
-0.3684180677,
0.2058045715,
-0.6485227942,
-0.8045048714,
0.0752755553,
0.0594842918,
-0.0080168108,
0.0120967841,
-0.0380534492,
0.4020611048,
0.1472058296,
0.0264612343,
-0.5854921341,
-0.4724828601,
0.1279218942,
-0.4118176401,
0.7918753624,
0.0448789001,
-0.5247178674,
-0.029939428,
-0.7286180258,
0.0072428887,
-0.1018530577,
-0.123751685,
-0.4610303044,
-0.4972696006,
0.135843873,
0.5503492951,
0.2669197619,
-0.5839528441,
0.1206682399,
-0.1516056359,
-0.1076379344,
0.3365778029,
-0.2458737493,
0.972135067,
-0.0349759348,
0.8629542589,
-0.0017632326,
0.0726809576,
-0.1446792483,
-0.1001559868,
-0.8364554644,
-0.1578777134,
0.3273576498,
0.5870841742,
-1.0160850286,
-0.0655504167,
-0.0625509396,
-0.4061295092,
-0.5480712056,
0.2591874301,
0.5406579375,
0.4731619656,
0.2994536161,
-0.3745910525,
-0.2864690125,
-0.9351571202,
-0.4843616784,
-0.0174198616,
0.4404594302,
0.2061073482,
0.156107232,
-0.0989450067,
0.4302426279,
-0.1430055946,
-0.1511120051,
-0.5707525015,
0.033777196,
0.1915481687,
0.4583680034,
1.0738807917,
-0.4227084219,
-1.1536985636,
0.4976540804,
-0.6355803609,
-0.2293286026,
-0.2300128937,
-0.5523018837,
0.4364665151,
0.54828161,
-0.424213022,
0.1516576409,
0.9000166655,
-0.3649083078,
0.5194924474,
-0.1137307286,
0.2878690064,
-0.8529685736,
0.5286691189,
-0.0169102866,
-0.3811456859,
-1.1956208944,
-0.1074695438,
0.2855319679,
0.1089511514,
-0.8149298429,
0.8595999479,
-0.5916203856,
-0.0088739628,
-0.3445849419,
0.0030025644,
-0.21595487,
0.6130635142,
0.090884082,
0.6708024144,
0.7199112773,
-0.5334796906,
-0.1401862055,
-0.1318794936,
-0.156596154,
0.8663722873,
-0.2268682271,
0.0849603415,
-0.18665272,
0.0109037794,
-0.8753312826,
0.3183809519,
0.63737607,
-0.3662581146,
0.793825984,
-0.3743799031,
-0.0400997847,
0.2187013328,
-0.0507096238,
0.6990574598,
0.1442436725,
-0.3542776406,
0.3777309656,
0.3240367174,
-0.1688125134,
-0.7267687321,
-0.7171444893,
0.182545051,
-0.3476361632,
-0.3282716572,
0.22229895,
-0.2330579609,
-0.0681992322,
0.0129593676,
-0.0585719869,
-0.2781463861,
0.05723162,
-0.2693497241,
0.3134805262,
-0.358794868,
-0.0671341568,
-0.09584032,
-0.1851771921,
-0.1636625379,
-0.3574552238,
0.3846573532,
-0.0415605605,
-0.362767756,
-0.2683560252,
0.2880280316,
0.5596823692,
-0.2955494225,
0.7286407948,
0.9405471087,
-0.1414026767,
-0.187084496,
-0.3065961599,
0.0023818635,
-0.3837707937,
0.6563335061,
-0.5794075727,
-0.7744954824,
0.4150615633,
0.2278494835,
-0.0337021947,
0.3485685587,
0.4825638831,
0.3281930387,
0.900942564,
0.939771533,
-0.3133203387,
0.8416321874,
-0.0790877789,
0.3567173481,
-0.5030857325,
-0.05995683,
-0.4003025889,
-0.3100731671,
-0.3473073244,
-0.5414714217,
0.0519081429,
0.4681959152,
0.0139513668,
0.8040518761,
0.1184760705,
0.4830165803,
0.1469779164,
-0.424313128,
0.355058074,
-0.0363520756,
-0.0126344021,
-0.0366681777,
-0.9995216131,
-0.0949864537,
1.0176204443,
0.1205529571,
0.7877606153,
0.4209158123,
0.5805187821,
-0.0051293303,
0.5521141887,
-0.6985898018,
0.3671293557,
-0.3507916033,
-0.6640911698,
-0.3061868548,
-0.6014283299,
-0.8580219746,
0.6296929121,
-0.2683925927,
-0.7691957355,
0.2070552409,
0.0949651822,
-0.0493867733,
0.366412878,
-0.8834304214,
1.0233082771,
-0.4994841516,
-0.5780277252,
-0.2745165527,
-0.3751859665,
0.4511352479,
-0.3651941717,
0.1807757467,
-0.0990853682,
0.180609256,
0.3614416718,
0.1165214032,
0.6173496842,
-0.1222127974,
-0.302403897,
0.0130946077,
0.4336770475,
0.2263914049,
-0.1375506371,
-0.1575061381,
0.5080761313,
0.0776140764,
-0.6741186976,
-0.6159853339,
0.7071706057,
-0.5096321702,
-0.3118459284,
-0.1223086193,
-0.6737215519,
-0.1279678047,
0.5380560756,
0.1828327477,
0.2163557857,
-0.3331381083,
-0.0370182432,
0.303047806,
-0.206706062,
0.6019382477,
1.059732914,
-0.4824441373,
0.074803099,
1.204318881,
0.4533501863,
0.6186125875,
0.7967335582,
0.0407115705,
-0.4058211148,
-0.5143690705,
-0.9064890146,
0.2903880179,
-0.4077729285,
0.0863478631,
-0.4261863828,
-0.1666381359,
-0.4722785354,
-0.0826296881,
-0.5730773211,
-0.5514612794,
-0.1706058681,
0.034679547,
-0.0235409997,
0.6111873984,
-0.3071928024,
0.0706750005,
-0.9497392178,
0.1601678133,
0.0676379353,
0.3424520493,
-0.0123810535,
-0.6092002988,
-0.5656220317,
0.0777867585,
0.0375159867,
-0.8637994528,
0.4401014149,
0.4810709059,
1.0182043314,
0.4832842946,
0.0484208316,
0.831821382,
-0.3858046532,
0.4152460098,
0.3448276222,
-1.0395898819,
0.0209237728,
-0.2026732415,
0.4983832538,
0.6610683799,
0.5398114324,
-0.7266450524,
-0.3088098168,
-0.2660048008,
-0.7127364874,
1.0334843397,
0.1658466458,
0.1016889438,
0.1262222826,
0.0437157303,
0.176874429,
0.1605602056,
-0.8481020927,
-0.3995349407,
-0.015786225,
0.2789479196,
-0.6342588663,
0.0610320047,
0.254630357,
-0.2551614046,
0.7875522375,
-0.1997601241,
-0.1473760605,
-0.0203649607,
-0.7142227888,
-0.2735943496,
0.3682731092,
0.6475455165,
0.6146480441,
-0.1443178505,
0.3832590282,
0.4840144813,
-0.2506032884,
0.2888814509,
0.0526652709,
-0.152514562,
0.1434381157,
0.3648088276,
0.7583683729,
0.3391181231,
-0.4494201243,
0.4785315692,
0.0541583821,
-0.1697272658,
0.1113209501,
-0.1299567819,
0.155210346,
0.1668962538,
-0.1765150428,
0.0354260541,
0.143673867,
-0.7055662274,
0.2486670166,
0.540805757,
-0.6465661526,
-0.7210983634,
0.1325505972,
0.2872621119,
-0.2538896799,
0.3608105183,
-0.344746381,
-0.5465242863,
0.3785334826,
0.8568354845,
0.7506124973,
-0.486437887,
0.3420212269,
0.4911909401,
0.3738769889,
0.1145247221,
-0.0287336279,
-0.2747929096,
-0.8337557316,
-0.8572116494,
-0.476546824,
-0.1642484218,
0.1016859561,
-0.6686479449,
0.2375634313,
0.1500471532,
0.0250027925,
-0.0268102475,
-0.0906787738,
-0.6108567119,
-0.2643086016,
0.6007832885,
0.7925413251,
-0.8701848388,
1.1415925026,
0.6974232793,
-0.2078850567,
-0.6254716516,
-0.1635720283,
-0.1863500774,
-0.82287848,
0.5057895184,
0.052679617,
-0.4767077565,
0.0511601865,
0.0771760568,
-0.8955593109,
0.5866795778,
0.7969117165,
-0.6903005838,
0.3545457721,
0.3410717845,
0.5167961717,
-0.1937191784,
0.5792834759,
0.587931633,
0.5981431603,
0.0986971855,
-1.1083786488,
-0.0550839901,
-0.3542406559,
-0.1495569199,
0.4605020583,
-0.5852221847,
0.8186296821,
-0.1543498188,
-0.2514877319,
-0.1693711579,
0.2128263563,
-0.2377473861,
0.2656401992,
0.3998784423,
0.4351790845,
0.3282370567,
0.4639109671,
0.8085938692,
-0.5942090154,
0.4456944168,
1.0744968653,
-0.4246274531,
0.8884719014,
0.7204108238,
0.0024571046,
0.1967542022,
0.215984717,
0.3101020753,
0.5077923536,
0.2909556031,
-0.2879267037,
-0.4305254221,
-0.0893837214,
-0.5438152552,
0.4965395629,
-0.0586455241,
-0.0210625567,
-0.5909338593,
0.090696007,
0.2040268332,
-0.1912124604,
-0.2373932153,
0.6591053009,
0.1051441357,
-0.7593798041,
0.6849805713,
-0.0729281306,
0.8938715458,
-0.8396753073,
-0.1093184799,
-0.3637255728,
0.3918894827,
-0.2754077017,
-0.496318996,
0.4996405542,
-0.1376492977,
-0.0320319608,
-0.3887097836,
0.8855760098,
-0.9893115759,
-0.6039568782,
0.8232101798,
0.8241381049,
0.3523808122,
-0.1152119339,
-0.5381008983,
-0.4079912603,
0.2234066278,
-0.0798024982,
0.8114914298,
0.2344145924,
-0.1623642892,
0.2149500996,
0.6606216431,
0.3443701863,
0.2656149864,
0.1445844024,
0.3425402641,
-0.5747935176,
-0.3319996297,
-0.8892680407,
0.309422195,
0.2263586521,
-0.3129262924,
1.0889161825,
0.5379624367,
1.2501941919,
-0.1500451416,
0.6899707913,
0.005798731,
0.1010862738,
-0.3375409842,
0.9392984509,
-0.7634724975,
0.0491766408,
-0.3368840516,
-1.0483700037,
-0.3282770216,
0.5182392597,
-0.3218615651,
-0.1889268011,
0.5039619803,
0.8267876506,
-0.2182751596,
-0.3335573971,
0.7309783697,
0.141080603,
0.2429059744,
0.6813137531,
0.9043642879,
-0.2373447269,
0.7784163952,
-0.4432735145,
-0.3206895292,
-0.2139884233,
-0.9049370885,
-0.8126810789,
-0.1490523815,
-0.3249775469,
0.0011010766,
0.1010218263,
0.5796960592,
0.9551819563,
-0.8391194344,
-0.8278204203,
0.0961941779,
0.2572961748,
-0.3252986968,
-0.177768141,
0.0202348251,
-0.5309334397,
-0.7685664892,
0.5466454625,
0.3675056696,
-0.0703243539,
-0.2295199335,
-0.2611108124,
-0.4336088896,
-0.044752568,
0.9248487353,
0.4407432079,
-0.2070945948,
-0.1082218364,
0.2421521395,
0.0340910032,
-0.1147511601,
0.9999271035,
-0.3798289597,
0.5603185296,
0.5604683757,
0.5999769568,
0.7050459385,
-0.3461295366,
0.7356247306,
-0.5023376346,
0.1930029541,
0.0336186513,
0.2391767949,
0.1560228765,
-0.2647352219,
0.3464771211,
0.2095894814,
-0.1441513747,
-0.6336132288,
0.1730432659,
-0.8229057789,
-0.5152326822,
1.3704606295,
-0.2060916126,
-0.0947975293,
-0.1071177348,
-0.034040384,
0.2474609464,
-0.0952364504,
0.4639587402,
0.7083056569,
-0.3235460818,
-0.1010768265,
-0.4151836634,
0.1530178636,
0.7013257146,
-0.7546702623,
-0.2596935928,
0.2294239402,
0.4402363896,
0.1360408217,
0.7713799477,
-0.1958020478,
0.0840910748,
-0.0598068647,
0.1923247725,
0.0757650658,
-0.4955874681,
-0.7294504642,
-0.0331235081,
0.0730398595,
-0.3138507009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20084v1
|
IPA Transcription of Bengali Texts
| 2024-03-29T09:33:34 | 2024-03-29T09:33:34 |
Kanij Fatema, Fazle Dawood Haider, Nirzona Ferdousi Turpa, Tanveer Azmal, Sourav Ahmed, Navid Hasan, Mohammad Akhlaqur Rahman, Biplab Kumar Sarkar, Afrar Jahin, Md. Rezuwan Hassan, Md Foriduzzaman Zihad, Rubayet Sabbir Faruque, Asif Sushmit, Mashrur Imtiaz, Farig Sadeque, Syed Shahrier Rahman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) serves to systematize phonemes in
language, enabling precise textual representation of pronunciation. In Bengali
phonology and phonetics, ongoing scholarly deliberations persist concerning the
IPA standard and core Bengali phonemes. This work examines prior research,
identifies current and potential issues, and suggests a framework for a Bengali
IPA standard, facilitating linguistic analysis and NLP resource creation and
downstream technology development. In this work, we present a comprehensive
study of Bengali IPA transcription and introduce a novel IPA transcription
framework incorporating a novel dataset with DL-based benchmarks.
|
[
-0.0758759454,
-0.1990972161,
0.017392505,
0.575810194,
-0.178422153,
0.1487720311,
-0.0418099649,
-0.7003113627,
0.4128374755,
0.6856160164,
-0.1661809087,
-0.4606446922,
-0.4070171714,
0.5731188655,
-0.08660914,
0.5187461376,
0.1618542373,
0.0346817784,
0.506332159,
-0.1623746902,
-0.5860307813,
-0.6345492005,
-0.3231802583,
-0.0256348196,
0.5002855659,
0.2289458513,
0.4774753153,
0.6127784252,
0.6559446454,
0.0580010824,
-0.3950306773,
0.2227337211,
0.0959227756,
0.4459601343,
0.0819989815,
-0.4983099401,
-0.4860108793,
-0.1449114233,
0.9665398598,
1.1578036547,
0.2388641983,
0.3364588022,
-0.1184465885,
0.7404103279,
-0.7070121765,
0.4325754642,
-0.5558242798,
-0.0484364294,
-0.5564286709,
-0.3003721833,
-0.6103706956,
-0.4808866382,
0.0696504936,
-0.2492082417,
-0.1079688221,
0.1292469651,
0.4684255123,
0.317103833,
-0.4410948157,
-0.409158498,
-0.5022816658,
0.3824327886,
-0.5098978877,
0.4814254045,
0.359128207,
0.1656657755,
-0.035439752,
-0.5888079405,
-0.3407111466,
0.1480320841,
-0.0017191605,
0.0750938505,
0.1309981793,
0.1814485788,
-0.0428421386,
0.6271432638,
-0.7566618919,
-0.0012211357,
-0.5913684964,
-0.2757091522,
0.4325509667,
-0.0906827077,
0.4780305028,
-0.2808411419,
-0.2293830067,
0.0040007476,
-0.9388867021,
0.2236855477,
0.4906409979,
0.769272089,
-0.0045140269,
0.7256461382,
-0.0799103528,
0.9219441414,
-0.1098197177,
-0.2141937166,
0.6045178771,
-0.139947772,
-0.18332313,
0.6891702414,
0.3950683177,
0.242588371,
0.271917671,
-0.0782440603,
-0.2848584652,
-0.2425178736,
0.2144613266,
-0.488070488,
0.1161257401,
0.2599383295,
-0.597648859,
0.1961738169,
0.1162998974,
-0.5709430575,
-0.3677024245,
-0.4173181653,
-0.0570054054,
-0.5708500147,
-0.4942417145,
0.1777911633,
-0.5740721822,
0.2944613993,
-0.0444450304,
-1.1110135317,
0.0705365837,
0.6763510704,
0.8948045373,
-0.1828527749,
-0.2098196,
-0.0357610919,
0.3470813334,
-0.6706192493,
0.8290976286,
-0.6535189152,
-0.6992769837,
0.3978283703,
-0.2802022994,
-0.0689504892,
-0.9403141141,
0.5831077099,
-0.5047645569,
-0.3546816409,
-0.2582023442,
-0.6087588668,
-0.2042702138,
0.0709261075,
-0.8306338191,
0.926725924,
0.0960076377,
-0.6725673079,
0.4581547379,
-0.6289265752,
-0.5769559145,
0.3235166073,
-0.1077808291,
0.1510659605,
0.1015877798,
0.1939457953,
0.3072244525,
-0.1524290591,
-0.0451317653,
0.1361808628,
-0.7793423533,
0.2289033979,
-0.2520243824,
1.3913844824,
0.2826211452,
-0.0445031486,
-0.1466075778,
-1.1030758619,
0.0695494041,
-0.2536323071,
-0.4999241233,
-0.6418407559,
-0.4662281275,
0.1437302232,
-0.4576847255,
0.3067922294,
-0.5107924342,
0.9328277111,
-0.3673888743,
0.3257291615,
0.4254285097,
0.3248534799,
0.4851767123,
-0.3266554475,
0.3530710936,
-0.3786122203,
0.1072693318,
-0.65378654,
-0.6275229454,
-0.2192376107,
-0.7224717736,
0.7272048593,
0.6483572721,
-0.1063351184,
0.701279819,
-0.3545094728,
-0.3275641799,
-0.9570741057,
-0.1859175414,
0.2133511454,
0.2060497403,
0.3689087331,
-0.3614095747,
-0.9729307294,
-0.9032834768,
-0.1875427365,
-0.7100132108,
0.0326270796,
-0.1605828702,
-0.0487060994,
-0.2266025245,
0.9254992604,
0.0833308846,
-0.2956316471,
-0.2713721991,
0.5490507483,
0.3905878365,
0.3126517236,
0.6520912647,
-1.0225476027,
-0.4751826823,
-0.3087762892,
-0.5614927411,
-0.6246730685,
-0.1594227254,
0.2739377916,
0.2365808338,
0.5560065508,
-0.4290068746,
0.398489356,
0.4505862296,
-0.0415713824,
0.6850802898,
0.2220990062,
0.4680407941,
-0.6959699988,
0.2730236053,
-0.3891864419,
0.1808734089,
-0.3754246235,
-0.0812793672,
0.2201489508,
-0.0203910302,
-0.3124893904,
0.593880713,
-0.5337558389,
-0.2605879903,
-0.0424063131,
-0.372823,
-0.0433720611,
0.2438823879,
0.0147469658,
1.0358763933,
0.2372310013,
-0.4473738372,
-0.0327643231,
0.485349983,
-0.4542074203,
0.4345312715,
-0.4315114617,
-0.0610137992,
0.1614396423,
0.1715592444,
-0.9828498363,
-0.0485565253,
0.1864830703,
-0.7056606412,
0.5278041363,
-0.4760127962,
-0.7099260092,
-0.0398625247,
-0.1233400553,
0.4773926139,
0.6363742948,
-0.3249059916,
0.4231932759,
0.6915163398,
-0.6526041627,
-0.8857611418,
-0.7383591533,
0.4405868053,
0.0863227621,
-0.4166994393,
0.3184581101,
0.0359772258,
-0.671946764,
-0.32637918,
-0.0974209085,
-0.1969282031,
-0.1777668595,
0.4143438041,
0.0652495995,
-0.2288242131,
-0.0190425329,
0.0899474695,
-0.0572754964,
-0.0001566213,
-0.2385130972,
0.5370707512,
0.1736791432,
-0.0544101745,
-0.6677063107,
0.6935433149,
0.9064962864,
-0.2717920244,
0.2122146785,
0.107873708,
-0.236777246,
-0.2623873055,
-0.5432188511,
0.2685772777,
-0.3691883385,
0.0440942049,
-0.5336439013,
-0.3053467274,
0.7331940532,
-0.2434789985,
-0.0019920219,
0.1476606876,
0.5505679846,
-0.0588715449,
0.4991254807,
0.480003655,
-0.1635531783,
0.3506361246,
-0.1289722025,
0.2267142087,
-0.8879892826,
-0.1995017678,
-0.8616822958,
-0.0237359218,
-0.4437839389,
0.0193849262,
0.2573343217,
0.0079892408,
-0.2304501086,
0.3242856264,
-0.5462551117,
0.2512001693,
0.6816812158,
-0.2780866921,
0.1908906996,
-0.0232438128,
-0.3244924843,
-0.260440141,
-0.2740543187,
-0.7599749565,
0.9784620404,
0.1579103172,
0.555459857,
0.1396599114,
0.78575629,
0.7161001563,
-0.0393573344,
-0.5193890333,
0.5177124143,
-0.1661820263,
-0.8920902014,
-0.179720819,
0.0048010196,
-0.6643742919,
-0.0442422889,
0.1431491077,
-0.6308315396,
0.5482293367,
0.0267611165,
-0.2137235403,
0.1641041189,
-0.7097412944,
0.4294816852,
0.0032088929,
0.0946338102,
0.3435322642,
-0.7890999317,
-0.031415049,
0.1511201262,
0.0872266218,
0.0223622136,
-0.2099221498,
0.7706058025,
-0.0167083815,
0.9126747847,
-0.1347751468,
-0.3341531754,
0.4493594766,
0.1510835588,
-0.0715709701,
-0.0958840325,
-0.4991258085,
0.5904021859,
0.0541958138,
-0.194764629,
-0.387976855,
0.2484403551,
-0.4287373722,
-0.1990969926,
-0.3847322166,
-0.4304060638,
-0.2439017147,
0.4355786145,
0.1766503453,
0.3614069819,
-0.0569592752,
0.2373145074,
0.6358915567,
-0.1225026697,
0.2704126835,
0.2673447132,
-0.1727176458,
-0.5548809171,
0.7106950879,
0.545150876,
-0.153110683,
0.6161354184,
-0.0448408052,
-0.3301952183,
-0.9877678752,
-0.4688757658,
-0.0797239095,
-0.8347831368,
-0.1701260358,
-0.4314942658,
-0.2142878771,
-0.9396677613,
-0.0683469474,
-0.3407262266,
-0.5842419267,
-0.0348542184,
-0.0280515496,
0.0880818889,
0.7694385052,
-0.3344970345,
0.0433620736,
-1.0365992785,
0.3686712682,
0.1130475178,
0.3037601113,
-0.1871598661,
-0.3853830099,
-0.1662807465,
-0.1788431108,
0.1699314117,
-0.9781751037,
0.1990310699,
0.1820843965,
0.5269420743,
0.1211780757,
0.2482717931,
0.5786584616,
-0.6335372925,
1.1370466948,
-0.0948064551,
-0.963722527,
0.5293644667,
-0.4097024202,
0.2567164004,
0.7390447259,
0.4255465269,
-0.624101162,
-0.3079563379,
-0.283156395,
-0.9845171571,
0.003933745,
0.1376499385,
-0.2440499812,
-0.1705652177,
0.6328629255,
0.5305219889,
0.1616020501,
-0.2384717017,
-0.2887672782,
-0.0490554124,
-0.3786642551,
0.3104510009,
-0.5244272351,
-0.0109503111,
-0.0940225497,
0.5034515262,
0.0132808704,
0.2259946465,
0.4518662691,
-0.0998770073,
0.1967982054,
0.345801264,
0.3023569584,
0.6432734132,
-0.3829512894,
-0.0832504481,
-0.4542225003,
-0.7760663629,
0.1989310086,
0.0436531603,
-0.506043613,
0.2986518443,
0.9705791473,
0.3109576404,
0.1511416286,
-0.8978926539,
0.343754977,
-0.0470441729,
-0.0589197427,
-0.5951105952,
0.0266277771,
-0.1423826814,
0.1414420903,
0.9779856801,
0.1696926057,
0.2961924672,
-0.7074813843,
0.1854843348,
-0.0977623686,
-0.1247097477,
-0.3557979167,
0.3605456948,
0.2706016898,
-0.5894780159,
0.5420140028,
0.0218681432,
-0.5115023255,
0.5711251497,
0.5045422912,
0.7598196864,
-0.2022739947,
-0.1129491702,
0.2748868465,
0.4033499956,
-0.0377448685,
0.6628872752,
-0.2146954834,
-0.4966320097,
-0.3498032987,
-0.6271597147,
-0.6391875744,
-0.0223898981,
-0.9114099145,
0.1807363778,
-0.4014544189,
-0.2457983643,
0.0178424362,
-0.1669395268,
-0.3449517488,
0.1386310309,
0.3184136152,
1.1566557884,
-0.6564227939,
0.7418906093,
0.6345369816,
-0.4318755269,
-0.5360976458,
0.1553991735,
-0.0261256471,
-0.8330247998,
1.1551737785,
0.3531362414,
-0.2122998089,
-0.1539862603,
-0.5111491084,
-0.6737353206,
0.5938449502,
0.3691174984,
-0.6796116829,
-0.0408568382,
0.1506539285,
0.554887414,
-0.4380804002,
-0.1011687592,
0.6071109772,
0.7236074805,
-0.1598741114,
-1.1347801685,
-0.3670036793,
-0.5131233931,
-0.1209450737,
0.008212815,
-0.5303577781,
0.7801839709,
0.0964158103,
-0.2389571071,
0.2013086826,
0.5195340514,
0.0550964139,
0.0877515152,
0.1697382778,
0.3050220013,
0.8355439901,
0.0174176116,
0.7721315026,
-0.3912568688,
-0.3674518764,
1.0004546642,
-0.7991010547,
0.9536286592,
0.6780835986,
-0.1143327057,
0.3758826554,
0.8719258308,
0.1515314132,
0.519998312,
0.198294282,
-0.164762646,
0.086839512,
-0.2394717336,
-0.5150633454,
0.8151818514,
0.5298705697,
-0.0835170001,
0.3373659253,
-0.0278883856,
-0.3799481988,
0.181937173,
-0.3521299958,
0.8633316755,
-0.2772527337,
-0.6415632367,
0.5249532461,
-0.5173621178,
0.6596087813,
-0.7247105837,
-0.3609860241,
-0.1340759099,
0.0456323177,
-0.0136068203,
-0.6312993169,
0.5096116662,
-0.1135996878,
-0.4245823324,
-0.288166374,
0.3001107574,
-0.1538782865,
-0.2173102349,
0.4790902436,
0.0429633111,
0.2159747183,
0.0768197104,
-0.3240405321,
0.6311039329,
-0.052130729,
-0.0448765345,
0.0033035693,
0.6012980342,
0.2364585698,
0.4459400773,
0.3746421635,
0.5996018648,
0.2051887512,
0.1358856261,
0.2387224883,
-0.7831909657,
-0.71519804,
-0.4143410027,
0.4241865873,
-0.0398599319,
-0.6137263775,
0.5991125703,
0.5452216268,
0.76868397,
-0.1310771704,
1.2322528362,
-0.0644304156,
0.7745075822,
-0.7307254672,
0.757732451,
-0.3706088364,
0.2139587104,
-0.0197835509,
-0.8716013432,
-0.8340469599,
0.5056709051,
0.1827708483,
-0.3448776603,
0.5763073564,
0.5416691303,
0.4252563417,
0.3398787081,
0.0849562734,
0.0762986392,
0.3217185438,
-0.1107415631,
0.4942393899,
-0.465659678,
0.2310004532,
-0.0481142923,
-0.2008482963,
-0.3915220201,
-0.7778304219,
-0.6973074675,
-0.9906093478,
0.03856159,
-0.2012636065,
0.3451954424,
1.1451591253,
0.533072412,
-0.6910184622,
-0.3308708966,
0.445725888,
-0.0053644911,
-0.5916106701,
-0.2174715847,
0.6473665833,
-0.4005507231,
-0.7483639717,
0.6808552742,
0.5270642638,
0.141576767,
-0.1351623535,
0.1651337594,
-0.3104998171,
0.1060522497,
0.289470464,
0.6090291142,
-0.4958475232,
-0.2948468029,
0.0762170926,
-0.1419304162,
0.237112686,
1.2948099375,
-0.4502484798,
0.5104577541,
0.6862006187,
0.8960720301,
-0.0477671586,
-0.2781317234,
0.6848638058,
-0.8207554817,
0.402595371,
0.5990607738,
0.5078961253,
0.4785662591,
-0.2898066938,
0.5446570516,
0.079888992,
-0.4833046794,
-0.9909992218,
0.1110037342,
-1.1608332396,
-0.2686097026,
1.0257169008,
-0.1442527175,
-0.3287381828,
-0.6379269958,
-0.5085664392,
0.190009132,
-0.5730076432,
0.6928610802,
0.7766602039,
-0.1763135642,
0.1131475493,
0.0426838174,
0.3334195316,
0.0381934643,
-0.0470726974,
0.3791441023,
0.283896327,
-0.1082037836,
0.5293987393,
0.8619154692,
-0.22720927,
0.1773332655,
0.4002413154,
0.3020123541,
-0.0495613925,
-0.7031180859,
-0.4072607756,
0.5999845862,
0.0313545801,
0.0263796952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20056v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20056v1
|
Cross-Lingual Transfer Robustness to Lower-Resource Languages on Adversarial Datasets
| 2024-03-29T08:47:15 | 2024-03-29T08:47:15 |
Shadi Manafi, Nikhil Krishnaswamy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual Language Models (MLLMs) exhibit robust cross-lingual transfer
capabilities, or the ability to leverage information acquired in a source
language and apply it to a target language. These capabilities find practical
applications in well-established Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks such
as Named Entity Recognition (NER). This study aims to investigate the
effectiveness of a source language when applied to a target language,
particularly in the context of perturbing the input test set. We evaluate on 13
pairs of languages, each including one high-resource language (HRL) and one
low-resource language (LRL) with a geographic, genetic, or borrowing
relationship. We evaluate two well-known MLLMs--MBERT and XLM-R--on these
pairs, in native LRL and cross-lingual transfer settings, in two tasks, under a
set of different perturbations. Our findings indicate that NER cross-lingual
transfer depends largely on the overlap of entity chunks. If a source and
target language have more entities in common, the transfer ability is stronger.
Models using cross-lingual transfer also appear to be somewhat more robust to
certain perturbations of the input, perhaps indicating an ability to leverage
stronger representations derived from the HRL. Our research provides valuable
insights into cross-lingual transfer and its implications for NLP applications,
and underscores the need to consider linguistic nuances and potential
limitations when employing MLLMs across distinct languages.
|
[
-0.5417010784,
-0.6374028921,
0.2204361409,
0.3418333828,
-0.0131940488,
0.2285317332,
-0.4596908987,
-0.7580410242,
0.0800312608,
0.4133589566,
-0.1860123575,
-0.0099907937,
-0.8451782465,
0.3794591427,
-0.4708660245,
1.0129241943,
-0.2590003312,
0.1071768925,
0.1659071594,
-0.3750998378,
-0.2228779644,
-0.8634089231,
-0.8395861387,
-0.3271663189,
0.7748050094,
0.0423048846,
0.9237710238,
0.3726043701,
0.6495966315,
0.2679109275,
-0.0444326103,
-0.0818681344,
-0.4067796469,
0.0315175317,
-0.5014812946,
-0.4414950907,
-0.1676788628,
-0.3144235015,
0.9506854415,
0.8903521895,
0.1463117748,
0.0875807777,
0.3022611141,
0.4077503085,
-0.7319951653,
-0.0480707139,
-0.7924336791,
0.2723711729,
-0.4431543052,
-0.0166844353,
-0.4238893092,
0.0169023387,
0.2269536555,
-0.5112112164,
0.0622515753,
0.0563558862,
1.0612080097,
0.2017282546,
-0.322999984,
-0.211041674,
-0.8124625683,
0.7589185834,
-0.5390508771,
0.7807270885,
0.4941106737,
0.3181910813,
0.0411345549,
-0.4875123203,
-0.4107137918,
-0.4988542795,
-0.3582176268,
-0.2345805764,
-0.3777363002,
-0.3570670784,
0.4368403554,
0.042255614,
-0.608590126,
0.2673365176,
-0.2729316056,
-0.3373202384,
0.4314385951,
-0.2467868477,
0.6352837682,
-0.1735438704,
-0.5771246552,
-0.085313648,
-0.8618233204,
0.1217326969,
0.3327896595,
0.7339276075,
-0.080357641,
0.6301541924,
0.1620346457,
0.685230732,
-0.0031144049,
-0.001988882,
-0.0445692241,
-0.6458833814,
-0.1284228861,
0.2342759073,
0.772134304,
-0.0598606803,
0.3688586652,
-0.529859066,
-0.2362210304,
-0.2879184783,
-0.0395401344,
-0.7084040046,
-0.2779660821,
-0.4625920355,
-0.3288961947,
-0.0485631265,
-0.1595523506,
-0.747446835,
-0.4157619476,
-0.1814134717,
0.3451522291,
-0.5474202633,
-0.2227479219,
-0.2948622406,
0.148394689,
0.2133136839,
0.01487354,
-0.9195376635,
0.3256611228,
0.3633888662,
0.7106263638,
-0.5101109743,
-0.5411447287,
-0.8401625752,
0.1128922328,
-0.2413514555,
0.660775423,
-0.5237756371,
-0.3311730027,
-0.2075380683,
0.2146246284,
-0.4363536239,
-0.5336195827,
0.3212260008,
-0.676472187,
0.1712046862,
-0.4886482954,
-0.199318096,
-0.1913187206,
0.2610192895,
-0.9655299187,
0.8670498729,
0.1608997434,
-0.7649914622,
0.4127537906,
-0.4968274236,
-0.8710792661,
-0.0210909713,
-0.145291701,
-0.100807026,
-0.1873654276,
0.2656988502,
0.3348133266,
-0.2351631224,
-0.0140022701,
-0.4608852565,
-0.1888928413,
0.4979367852,
-0.8110665083,
1.0276423693,
0.0801732689,
-0.4810599089,
-0.3129423261,
-0.7988697886,
0.0130602131,
0.2282707393,
-0.5179415941,
-0.7768653631,
-0.3426898718,
0.2550091743,
0.3013485074,
0.1418447942,
-0.3261092603,
0.0208990742,
-0.1464821249,
0.1228136197,
0.4830153286,
-0.2603634298,
0.6509937644,
-0.0267722849,
0.6966813207,
-0.1418942213,
-0.2483512014,
0.3733898699,
-0.2399284989,
-0.5994957089,
-0.1318237484,
0.7697798014,
0.8113567829,
-1.2896592617,
-0.0578682423,
-0.2570925057,
-0.2398828417,
-0.4697376192,
0.3545428216,
0.5360456705,
0.5097491741,
0.3456671238,
-0.20217821,
-0.5783132315,
-1.0059062243,
-0.2860031426,
-0.1469774842,
0.1259842813,
0.3947984278,
0.3124320805,
-0.0473974608,
0.4772894084,
0.0154296551,
-0.146894142,
-0.4547369182,
0.1286788732,
-0.1653091162,
0.2568826973,
0.9152605534,
-0.9344453216,
-0.7687529325,
0.4023109972,
-0.6529626846,
-0.1520840526,
-0.208636865,
-0.2367007434,
0.4911589026,
0.3083535433,
-0.4008677602,
0.1095675752,
0.9837741852,
-0.3523971438,
0.3976547122,
-0.016476335,
0.1862411797,
-1.0911744833,
0.3550263047,
-0.1252683699,
-0.2031309903,
-0.7428917289,
0.0632233545,
0.0270346105,
0.0559495687,
-0.8110149503,
0.9016233087,
-0.7318953276,
-0.4387183487,
-0.1215042025,
0.1696713865,
-0.0495284572,
0.4020582736,
0.1715800017,
0.9757103324,
0.5635828376,
-0.6034103036,
0.4052756727,
0.076573655,
-0.2380941212,
0.8985005021,
-0.4595258236,
0.1041360497,
0.2509200871,
-0.2432283312,
-0.4028223753,
0.1759002358,
0.4032766819,
-0.3050152361,
0.6423354149,
-0.3196407259,
-0.3387827575,
0.2326561809,
0.173810035,
0.5191468596,
0.2064836472,
-0.6109249592,
0.5420377851,
0.2930408418,
-0.3670446575,
-0.7870284915,
-1.0858458281,
0.3622677922,
-0.4053585231,
-0.4896014631,
0.3526932001,
0.163131088,
-0.1870808899,
0.4594049752,
0.1813416332,
-0.2052849382,
0.1352745742,
-0.0129725449,
0.4751360416,
-0.4781607389,
-0.132220611,
-0.3437475562,
0.1135126576,
-0.0374411792,
-0.0110248961,
0.3539500237,
-0.1178929508,
-0.488502413,
0.1212405115,
0.2853471041,
0.5897429585,
-0.306774348,
0.8855519891,
0.9004234076,
-0.4675434232,
-0.193465665,
-0.1151199192,
0.0543114021,
-0.366666466,
0.5786011219,
-0.716473043,
-0.7225028276,
0.7056943774,
0.364472568,
-0.0911430418,
0.4237229526,
0.4668494761,
0.2108566612,
0.7869466543,
0.5852541924,
-0.4388878047,
0.6089881063,
-0.0395367816,
0.1826769412,
-1.0923870802,
0.0740324035,
-0.5421707034,
-0.3644995689,
-0.6413544416,
-0.3616300821,
-0.1094812825,
-0.0082376394,
0.0446106046,
0.7976725698,
0.0108966315,
0.2221824527,
0.5487943292,
-0.3468708992,
0.2814488113,
0.2248515934,
-0.2994205654,
-0.2375448495,
-0.8709831238,
-0.3437904119,
0.8635832667,
0.2078142166,
0.8243127465,
0.3556462526,
0.4402718544,
0.2282207459,
0.2911170125,
-0.5645103455,
0.5949124098,
-0.5655800104,
-0.4956684709,
-0.4008338749,
-0.6553361416,
-1.2185351849,
0.488296181,
-0.3987362981,
-0.7699024081,
0.3439587951,
-0.2295291871,
-0.2222370952,
0.6041837335,
-0.5190811157,
0.7218131423,
-0.7068461776,
-0.324734211,
0.2981226742,
-0.4177317321,
0.2914506197,
-0.3763987422,
0.1293970197,
0.0218691938,
0.0342890173,
0.5549503565,
0.1823815107,
0.4031016231,
0.1149422824,
-0.2934516966,
-0.0944088623,
0.3225059807,
0.5518987179,
-0.1665941477,
-0.0844742209,
0.4705676734,
-0.1570401639,
-0.2019590586,
-0.7978659868,
0.7476770878,
-0.6286497712,
-0.4491944015,
-0.2784301043,
-0.7020304203,
-0.1708965749,
0.5027281642,
0.3739334047,
0.2453360111,
-0.1627002507,
0.2763287723,
0.4061855078,
-0.2087054849,
0.2816596925,
0.620478332,
-0.4098070264,
-0.1734406799,
1.0881098509,
0.4275673628,
0.4998871088,
0.4979221225,
-0.1562075913,
-0.2757689059,
-0.5505256653,
-0.9333252907,
0.020397028,
-0.6454373002,
0.071008496,
-0.4659967124,
-0.4868406653,
-0.2957512438,
-0.1850475669,
-0.4290070832,
-0.459302038,
-0.2929036021,
0.0791172236,
-0.0972954184,
0.4003438056,
0.001625807,
-0.3427529931,
-0.9775413871,
0.4101767838,
0.2988016307,
0.1552767307,
-0.2810080349,
-0.6214447618,
-0.1768627912,
0.13221623,
0.3524279296,
-0.9990041256,
0.4073423743,
0.2169778943,
0.8831056952,
0.0764177218,
0.1352432519,
0.6467311382,
-0.3737086058,
0.540155828,
-0.0991596356,
-0.717666328,
0.0666903257,
0.0316534527,
0.180243656,
0.4198497832,
0.3441282511,
-0.4957432747,
-0.5350670218,
-0.3530549109,
-0.6852815747,
0.6577330828,
0.3930397332,
-0.047197096,
0.3549033701,
-0.0764287412,
-0.0213803332,
-0.0904023498,
-0.8280969262,
-0.2390767485,
0.0563325286,
0.1319522411,
-0.1079725623,
0.1078067347,
-0.0304470994,
0.2595024407,
0.6484862566,
-0.0939440802,
-0.0804096386,
0.2164114714,
-0.4182299376,
-0.088007018,
0.4510760307,
0.4520087242,
0.1954637915,
0.1545510739,
0.4702163339,
0.5191037059,
-0.4348088503,
0.2310107201,
0.6505907774,
-0.4510124922,
0.1308126003,
0.5244749188,
0.8518725634,
0.3902451098,
-0.4343487322,
0.0743011311,
-0.1680983603,
0.069025971,
0.1139635295,
-0.18488805,
-0.013415887,
0.4293845594,
0.11593353,
0.1781715006,
0.2827614248,
-0.5421581864,
0.0554160327,
0.7093096375,
-0.2599897683,
-0.40152511,
0.5204799771,
-0.0936672539,
-0.1351808012,
0.5881774426,
-0.3704775274,
-0.7801502943,
0.646268487,
0.662512958,
0.7486427426,
-0.2020508647,
0.0425413102,
0.0822433308,
0.5449614525,
0.1756367981,
-0.1176666766,
-0.0156090641,
-0.9535202384,
-0.4856152534,
-0.5376166701,
-0.4616307914,
0.1352070719,
-0.7370068431,
0.2226557285,
-0.052663628,
-0.2863745093,
0.0483298749,
-0.0615798049,
-0.8327606916,
-0.1063148379,
0.5836298466,
0.593536973,
-0.7601317167,
0.8846808076,
1.0760887861,
-0.2670863569,
-0.9595190883,
-0.0765816644,
-0.0486443117,
-0.8181705475,
1.037473917,
-0.2649388313,
-0.1995366514,
-0.2131137997,
0.1879228503,
-1.350794673,
0.816265285,
0.7280349135,
-0.4314118326,
-0.1527488679,
0.3209789097,
0.5723282695,
-0.1753712893,
-0.1704724729,
0.4492096603,
0.59576267,
0.1146629751,
-1.2553577423,
0.4027190506,
-0.2451560199,
0.076501593,
0.3068726063,
-0.448962152,
0.9329425693,
-0.2998330891,
-0.5772869587,
-0.1782954037,
0.5387398005,
0.2833949924,
0.0868979245,
0.5587521195,
0.4230175912,
0.617442131,
0.0382897854,
1.0819696188,
-0.4473068118,
0.170187965,
1.1365021467,
-0.5590742826,
0.9308213592,
0.4689767361,
-0.331363976,
0.445335716,
0.2641411424,
-0.1533670127,
0.5076631904,
0.0035860918,
0.0692136809,
0.0902888626,
-0.2514480054,
-0.3549360633,
0.4735377133,
0.1639764756,
-0.3647281229,
-0.2314685285,
0.2241384089,
0.1468108445,
-0.2430809289,
-0.2258328795,
0.4714618027,
0.121429421,
-0.7357397079,
0.5811957717,
-0.1758509427,
0.67754668,
-0.5094791055,
0.0056850538,
-0.1624388397,
0.1441091448,
-0.1665490568,
-0.8192414045,
0.4484941959,
0.1856413931,
-0.055508893,
-0.3210756183,
0.9913773537,
-0.7622531056,
-0.6220043302,
0.7158314586,
0.6401796341,
0.1818488389,
0.1173860058,
-0.7548437119,
-0.0906269774,
-0.0154654859,
-0.3455502093,
0.6975168586,
0.4389338195,
-0.161841616,
0.5737942457,
0.7778241038,
0.7057812214,
0.2900330722,
0.0682947263,
0.4992783368,
-0.4659246504,
-0.1450207084,
-0.7717234492,
0.0864690393,
0.1611329317,
-0.0018974697,
1.1145889759,
0.3339359164,
1.0740394592,
0.1603401899,
0.8568848372,
-0.1659331769,
0.1934523731,
-0.7932516336,
0.833316803,
-0.5226755738,
0.1682984531,
-0.1192738563,
-1.0099890232,
-0.1841040999,
0.4611065686,
-0.1483519077,
0.0796363428,
0.6239827275,
0.5322089791,
-0.1003219485,
-0.4118973017,
0.5936607718,
0.0719719082,
0.1331106126,
0.829175055,
0.8129276037,
-0.1410939693,
0.8146262169,
-0.510842979,
0.1869959384,
-0.1091533974,
-0.772353828,
-0.7452719212,
-0.4188975096,
-0.3454957902,
-0.3515221179,
0.1364534795,
0.6338312626,
0.6296598911,
-0.882723093,
-0.0354309082,
0.3483853042,
0.3019342721,
-0.2173347771,
-0.2514210045,
0.4184325039,
-0.0622990727,
-0.8937776685,
0.5586507916,
0.1201568544,
0.27836743,
-0.5213514566,
-0.1180362031,
-0.2009975761,
-0.13035281,
0.6316675544,
0.5731519461,
-0.6902387142,
-0.2639916837,
0.2975226641,
-0.5299713612,
-0.2571784556,
0.6768515706,
-0.5678962469,
0.2391338497,
0.5065778494,
0.9941348433,
0.0344562605,
-0.1464712471,
0.6183468103,
-0.6789988875,
-0.0074764364,
0.0887218714,
0.7201518416,
0.635356009,
-0.4982614219,
0.556709826,
0.137510851,
-0.3228437304,
-0.8192542791,
0.1306996197,
-0.6630513668,
-0.2231537998,
1.465550065,
-0.3547255993,
0.0298690032,
-0.1341553628,
-0.0859782845,
0.2609933317,
-0.1153604463,
0.4228809476,
1.0106699467,
-0.0598689839,
-0.3012405932,
-0.5804892778,
0.2986215055,
0.5135665536,
-0.7219278812,
-0.206993103,
0.18337062,
0.3102735877,
0.3858144879,
0.3314148486,
-0.0550914481,
0.1396443695,
0.0255884472,
-0.1492555141,
-0.0842131972,
-0.302475065,
-0.4349769652,
0.2068882138,
0.0932736099,
-0.1054267883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20046v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20046v2
|
Can LLMs Learn from Previous Mistakes? Investigating LLMs' Errors to Boost for Reasoning
| 2024-03-29T08:30:34 | 2024-06-07T06:27:50 |
Yongqi Tong, Dawei Li, Sizhe Wang, Yujia Wang, Fei Teng, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent works have shown the benefits to LLMs from fine-tuning golden-standard
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) rationales or using them as correct examples in few-shot
prompting. While humans can indeed imitate correct examples, learning from our
mistakes is another vital aspect of human cognition. Hence, a question
naturally arises: \textit{can LLMs learn and benefit from their mistakes,
especially for their reasoning? } This study investigates this problem from
both the prompting and model-tuning perspectives. We begin by introducing
\textsc{CoTErrorSet}, a new benchmark with 609,432 questions, each designed
with both correct and error references, and demonstrating the types and reasons
for making such mistakes. To explore the effectiveness of those mistakes, we
design two methods: (1) \textbf{Self-rethinking} prompting guides LLMs to
rethink whether they have made similar previous mistakes; and (2)
\textbf{Mistake tuning} involves finetuning models in both correct and
incorrect reasoning domains, rather than only tuning models to learn ground
truth in traditional methodology. We conduct a series of experiments to prove
LLMs can obtain benefits from mistakes in both directions. Our two methods
offer potentially cost-effective strategies by leveraging errors to enhance
reasoning capabilities, which costs significantly less than creating
meticulously hand-crafted golden references. We ultimately make a thorough
analysis of the reasons behind LLMs' errors, which provides directions that
future research needs to overcome. \textsc{CoTErrorSet} will be published soon
on \texttt{\url{https://github.com/YookiTong/Learn-from-Mistakes-CotErrorSet}}.
|
[
-0.1639559567,
-0.6872082353,
0.7392861843,
-0.0285443421,
-0.1711306721,
-0.0351209156,
0.0862879008,
-0.2612627745,
-0.1792744845,
0.724586606,
-0.9109525084,
-0.1515555084,
-0.1588745713,
0.2616827488,
-0.0254587214,
0.9339159727,
-0.0780351087,
0.2939130068,
-0.3227179348,
0.0645103082,
-0.9773808122,
-0.4924170077,
-0.8648310304,
-0.538449049,
0.9026182294,
0.7600697279,
0.3501308858,
0.4621838927,
0.3026689291,
0.1967462152,
-0.0826662406,
0.7450737953,
-0.620167017,
-0.0068987468,
-0.4702146947,
-0.9413961172,
-0.4986246526,
0.3365861475,
0.337880373,
0.3885343373,
-0.2087134421,
0.0064050718,
0.2984037399,
0.966509521,
-0.6739441752,
-0.0117129907,
-0.9210787416,
-0.020490922,
0.0065705758,
-0.6908668876,
-0.5510416031,
-0.4065609872,
-0.3046198785,
-0.4695869982,
0.3660136759,
0.0913590714,
0.6409212351,
0.6368377805,
-0.2232408524,
-0.3161374927,
-0.6053916216,
0.8147804141,
-0.6517422199,
0.2723360956,
0.4074267149,
0.3091315329,
-0.507337451,
-0.6868373156,
-0.4159103334,
-0.0730712712,
0.0715348423,
0.234891504,
0.0681923106,
-0.3397419751,
0.5870700479,
0.1142217293,
-0.1827614754,
0.0124495085,
-0.3131737709,
-0.2191686928,
0.6149456501,
0.2198899537,
-0.0024418531,
-0.1347841173,
-0.3459595442,
-0.3950327039,
-1.1599495411,
-0.0294300672,
0.4557388723,
0.1715771258,
0.2063147873,
0.3618550301,
-0.0207192805,
0.7946700454,
0.448871851,
-0.0336230472,
-0.0370168909,
-0.2919268906,
-0.1321782619,
0.0343650617,
0.2823319137,
0.4359045625,
0.5553979874,
-0.0663144886,
-0.2664104402,
-0.0755941197,
0.5299278498,
-0.238526091,
-0.4324229658,
-0.0742406547,
-0.1717352569,
-0.3313370049,
-0.1192622483,
-0.6172167063,
-0.6672546864,
-0.5369445086,
0.3957003355,
-0.3741270304,
-0.1092682779,
0.2783825696,
-0.1292323172,
0.3845542371,
0.6997702122,
-0.6506296396,
0.0650139153,
0.6908117533,
0.6338226795,
-0.123284094,
-0.4981282055,
-0.575294137,
-0.2026372552,
-0.4784757793,
1.2081941366,
0.0016486907,
-0.6473252773,
-0.1673993319,
-0.1202308908,
-0.1894780844,
-0.8580803871,
0.8200992942,
-0.4770561755,
-0.2595300078,
-0.8586261868,
-0.610245049,
-0.1061635688,
0.2999094129,
-0.4792622924,
0.6716192961,
-0.1229305938,
-0.7440517545,
0.2894630432,
-0.1586759835,
-0.166113168,
-0.3623757362,
-0.3103370667,
-0.3855141699,
0.3249576092,
0.1791954488,
0.2950544655,
-0.3068595231,
-0.0686380342,
-0.1747032404,
-0.2354312986,
0.6513770223,
-0.6289445162,
0.8419826627,
-0.0352871567,
-0.108046107,
-0.2518091202,
-0.7639101148,
0.2624995112,
0.1115745902,
-0.2571283877,
-0.1167541146,
0.0092813512,
-0.6077984571,
0.3182255626,
-0.0278877299,
-0.1915299743,
0.083022669,
-0.0766561925,
0.2259985805,
0.9990128279,
0.2302178591,
0.187196672,
-0.9002733231,
0.3629911244,
0.1236220077,
0.118322663,
-0.1320511848,
-0.231099695,
-1.0282508135,
0.2919024527,
0.2388043255,
0.5920667052,
-0.6580872536,
0.0870776474,
0.2047575712,
-0.4421820343,
-0.3795885444,
0.4249956608,
0.4267732799,
0.8531111479,
0.4372827709,
-0.1578824222,
-0.6765756011,
-0.5382369161,
-0.5645413399,
-0.3600327373,
0.2484953254,
0.4090347886,
0.4952359796,
-0.0757125691,
0.8779524565,
-0.3117130101,
0.0165798869,
-0.025361754,
0.1974601895,
0.0180806238,
0.5858294964,
0.3554674387,
-0.6342350245,
-0.0871168375,
-0.2531950474,
-0.6825829744,
-0.2078014314,
-0.377039969,
-0.3100874424,
0.1755812764,
0.5695726871,
-0.4941785038,
0.2723266482,
0.3648134172,
-0.2016417533,
1.1319930553,
-0.2031866461,
0.0380860455,
-0.7872828245,
-0.3895606399,
-0.28098014,
-0.1310360134,
-0.2358343452,
-0.4312583804,
0.2033780217,
0.5763341188,
-0.5369900465,
0.4407105744,
-0.5464354157,
-0.0431161523,
-0.3495624959,
0.0631576329,
-0.0317804553,
0.4584919214,
-0.2410220653,
0.8078731298,
0.2713577151,
-0.7181686759,
0.3012211025,
0.0893593878,
-0.1940150559,
1.0240054131,
-0.6883341074,
0.3776094019,
-0.1052040607,
0.2482452393,
-0.861843884,
-0.1747606695,
0.3558955491,
-0.6206781268,
0.4109430015,
-0.1485845447,
-0.4460103512,
-0.2710112631,
-0.253426224,
0.100942716,
0.451790899,
-0.7932781577,
0.3732306063,
-0.0504940525,
-0.00656967,
-0.7281142473,
-0.6968953013,
-0.1324765235,
-0.0436700545,
-0.445132345,
0.008901272,
-0.3024908602,
-0.3484151661,
-0.0454514138,
-0.4703061581,
0.1808803678,
0.2300655097,
0.3043532968,
0.3867593706,
-0.1022796407,
0.3893471062,
-0.1381668001,
-0.4086672664,
0.1443254352,
-0.327255249,
0.3583944142,
-0.3854402006,
-0.5512115359,
-0.3087487519,
-0.0731759295,
0.3604590297,
-0.1835309118,
0.4532428682,
0.14475815,
-0.2304957509,
-0.2772384286,
-0.9483810067,
-0.3932142556,
-0.4253286421,
-0.0279233232,
-0.1794789433,
-0.6104100347,
0.313806355,
-0.1857267469,
0.2501214445,
0.3766996861,
0.3503848314,
-0.6736171246,
0.7373235226,
0.5012121797,
0.1791866869,
0.4133668244,
-0.4180654883,
-0.2018963993,
-1.0616109371,
-0.0113150496,
-0.3551213145,
-0.2551798224,
-0.4967429638,
-0.5987495184,
0.3073844016,
0.3407775164,
-0.2582918108,
-0.0779207647,
-0.1155483648,
0.6624598503,
0.6260327101,
0.290004611,
0.4715730846,
0.000257952,
-0.2083822638,
-0.0849120021,
-0.826028049,
-0.6356389523,
1.0958759785,
0.092236191,
1.1386722326,
-0.1404592991,
0.9291291833,
-0.0034879525,
0.4662901759,
-0.7182551622,
0.4074859321,
0.3056557178,
-0.4254778624,
-0.0683018714,
-0.5398849249,
-0.8192253113,
0.1477627605,
-0.2531335354,
-0.4940552115,
0.4403800368,
0.6677553058,
-0.4367953837,
0.3792224824,
-0.5446614623,
0.7545205355,
-0.6042528152,
-0.6263906956,
-0.1051900536,
-0.6450362206,
0.4531095326,
-0.1098185703,
-0.0424294285,
0.0673849061,
0.1520663351,
0.6344023347,
-0.1967457682,
1.1138541698,
0.0973078758,
-0.0725993663,
0.4795036912,
0.2229970992,
0.8078593612,
0.1571163833,
-0.0752195194,
-0.1026440412,
-0.1257081479,
-0.265545547,
-0.9067307711,
0.6586497426,
-0.743483007,
-0.7621335387,
-0.4443356097,
-0.4756657779,
-0.3814467788,
0.1498419046,
0.4562273324,
0.351283133,
0.0622935407,
0.0796535164,
0.9577204585,
0.0564997867,
0.2784257829,
0.7521882653,
0.0797985345,
-0.4704171717,
0.6072605252,
0.2587836683,
0.4285197258,
-0.0194708444,
0.1878865063,
-0.3334386647,
-0.5307685137,
-0.1806667596,
0.5848566294,
-0.8082026839,
-0.4590038359,
-0.5093917847,
-0.0839324594,
-0.1790521145,
-0.191951558,
-0.430501461,
-0.2522934079,
-0.5113568902,
-0.3743714988,
0.2516869009,
0.5779708028,
-0.4820944071,
0.1021715701,
-0.7075232267,
-0.0048721139,
0.6035422087,
0.1023919135,
0.1091544256,
-0.3423222601,
-0.1546880454,
0.3946275115,
-0.6659207344,
-0.9457250237,
0.1766678542,
-0.2180893719,
0.6589322686,
0.1002065986,
0.0749058723,
0.816283226,
-0.5855189562,
0.5870882273,
0.0552862883,
-0.5390503407,
0.6928337216,
-0.11949718,
0.2001927495,
0.6273244619,
0.0970676914,
-0.5792435408,
-0.2051783949,
-1.0111815929,
-0.4304003716,
0.5427200794,
-0.0112803588,
-0.2107555866,
-0.2013172358,
0.9176243544,
0.0126216784,
-0.0054105422,
-0.5484868884,
-0.2736571729,
-0.0073269946,
0.1822667122,
-0.2675276399,
-0.4017550945,
-0.2241816223,
-0.1134679168,
0.8059532642,
-0.3239761293,
0.1448895037,
0.543222487,
-0.2968141139,
-0.2600440383,
0.1972525716,
0.6335945725,
0.838609159,
0.0386359207,
0.3704836071,
0.5238065124,
-0.0191517174,
0.1419197321,
-0.2409292012,
-0.135225758,
-0.1475417912,
0.3285077512,
0.5657653213,
0.2791918218,
-0.4804443419,
0.1735724956,
-0.1156900525,
-0.0745942518,
-0.3062725663,
0.2318398654,
0.1055135876,
0.4764868319,
0.1187868714,
0.3598573804,
-0.0807540342,
-0.6245317459,
0.3482915461,
0.3221052289,
-0.2930892408,
-0.1932777166,
0.4278787076,
0.0553642549,
-0.3920650482,
0.4729409814,
-0.0402714051,
-0.4130991995,
0.5912309289,
0.7027781606,
0.786416173,
-0.1525735259,
0.32701087,
0.2772090435,
0.239980951,
-0.5376948714,
0.2331061959,
-0.1841783524,
-1.0229091644,
-0.3328406215,
-0.2380456179,
-0.6891784072,
-0.1179167852,
-0.729018867,
0.2087766081,
-0.5735192299,
-0.2241220325,
-0.2513383627,
-0.0466163456,
-0.6642481685,
0.1068723872,
-0.0612548329,
0.9102809429,
-0.6022120714,
0.3810071647,
0.7052856684,
-0.4292388558,
-0.9133426547,
0.0141490456,
0.1901437789,
-0.8311071992,
0.6015143991,
-0.1038732827,
-0.4487863779,
-0.0708554983,
-0.7489736676,
-0.7537203431,
1.0493854284,
0.3237738311,
-0.7169365883,
0.019045312,
-0.2374313772,
0.3682258725,
-0.2291275263,
0.1165014133,
0.7303689122,
0.3415021896,
0.340082854,
-0.680125773,
-0.0262702405,
0.1634189487,
-0.1278478652,
0.1248724163,
-0.7971974611,
1.0457793474,
-0.6839358807,
-0.2139122933,
0.0658731163,
0.4847248495,
0.5287548304,
0.3761603236,
0.4615717828,
0.504930079,
1.3280225992,
-0.0603300408,
0.9833893776,
0.0677865595,
0.4553927481,
1.5292657614,
-0.1625002027,
0.8700497746,
0.5964452028,
-0.0076773325,
0.4702596366,
0.74237746,
0.1497313231,
0.4982348382,
0.1521879137,
0.0109079862,
-0.5266062617,
0.2966633737,
-0.3625496328,
0.0209535267,
0.5036597252,
-0.2636779249,
-0.308790803,
-0.2338388562,
0.0076192529,
-0.0474491157,
-0.367048651,
0.7384700775,
0.431594491,
-0.7970793247,
0.7073380351,
-0.4455558956,
0.4641231,
-0.3346276879,
-0.108606115,
-0.4010409713,
0.4521328807,
-0.2264534384,
-0.7106138468,
0.1637564301,
-0.1710630059,
-0.2117406577,
-0.2637446225,
0.8966107965,
-0.1814109683,
-0.5207141638,
-0.1279935092,
0.8266522884,
0.0644892603,
-0.050271906,
-0.7436613441,
-0.0967115536,
-0.008214457,
0.103937842,
0.0000975653,
0.4081425071,
0.057301335,
0.7895571589,
0.5543484688,
0.1915382147,
0.0903517678,
-0.0925562829,
0.5725671053,
-0.9081841707,
-0.1712253094,
-0.8834812045,
0.4915972054,
-0.1360056698,
-0.413359195,
0.7286087275,
0.2080425918,
1.0532977581,
-0.0923377946,
0.7683902383,
0.3741964698,
0.6103308201,
-0.9023702741,
0.318836689,
-0.6518534422,
0.4855783582,
-0.119304195,
-0.6297094822,
-0.2310354114,
0.8443098068,
-0.4890861511,
-0.0063287765,
0.8494693041,
0.9668917656,
0.2506676912,
0.2514280677,
0.2965942919,
0.3810734749,
0.3330406547,
0.7571187019,
1.3712253571,
-0.3097337782,
0.3161642551,
-0.1284819841,
-0.1760646254,
-0.3905988932,
-0.8383846283,
-0.8963225484,
-0.2106526196,
-0.3959627151,
-0.5097930431,
0.4679589272,
0.9509224892,
0.2020997405,
-0.5332015157,
-0.0686465427,
-0.4322471619,
0.6901456118,
-0.4007322788,
-0.0976022035,
0.0596954413,
-0.6537146568,
-0.3492965996,
0.3084685206,
0.1291915625,
0.3567362428,
-0.0784693584,
-0.1495713294,
-0.0077597112,
0.0792663619,
0.3860425055,
0.4765694439,
-0.5849476457,
-0.398152411,
0.0793103799,
-0.0284987204,
0.132338047,
1.1851744652,
-0.8082042933,
0.351757139,
0.2983133197,
0.5852378011,
0.317309171,
-0.1074147746,
0.6656540036,
-0.4148775637,
-0.3590396345,
0.174060449,
0.540359199,
0.4471232593,
-0.4026149213,
0.6417359114,
0.4173353314,
-0.7432442307,
-0.7705664635,
0.3911564052,
-0.7189460993,
-0.0733323693,
1.1599354744,
-0.0980839804,
-0.3033148944,
0.0221227407,
-0.639185667,
0.2537585497,
-0.061312899,
0.9432047606,
0.8923223615,
-0.4276027381,
-0.3036171794,
-0.612886548,
0.688046217,
0.6361778378,
-0.7539207935,
0.165396452,
0.6216600537,
0.556768775,
0.1058246717,
0.5114047527,
-0.1494122446,
0.8724859357,
0.029849695,
-0.413182795,
-0.0008102332,
-0.4805141687,
-0.356764555,
-0.402425319,
0.284088552,
-0.1200563759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20041v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20041v2
|
Transformer-Lite: High-efficiency Deployment of Large Language Models on Mobile Phone GPUs
| 2024-03-29T08:26:53 | 2024-05-21T01:21:19 |
Luchang Li, Sheng Qian, Jie Lu, Lunxi Yuan, Rui Wang, Qin Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Large Language Model (LLM) is widely employed for tasks such as
intelligent assistants, text summarization, translation, and multi-modality on
mobile phones. However, the current methods for on-device LLM deployment
maintain slow inference speed, which causes poor user experience. To facilitate
high-efficiency LLM deployment on device GPUs, we propose four optimization
techniques: (a) a symbolic expression-based approach to support dynamic shape
model inference; (b) operator optimizations and execution priority setting to
enhance inference speed and reduce phone lagging; (c) an FP4 quantization
method termed M0E4 to reduce dequantization overhead; (d) a sub-tensor-based
technique to eliminate the need for copying KV cache after LLM inference.
Furthermore, we implement these methods in our mobile inference engine,
Transformer-Lite, which is compatible with both Qualcomm and MTK processors. We
evaluated Transformer-Lite's performance using LLMs with varied architectures
and parameters ranging from 2B to 14B. Specifically, we achieved prefill and
decoding speeds of 121 token/s and 14 token/s for ChatGLM2 6B, and 330 token/s
and 30 token/s for smaller Gemma 2B, respectively. Compared with CPU-based
FastLLM and GPU-based MLC-LLM, our engine attains over 10x speedup for the
prefill speed and 2~3x speedup for the decoding speed.
|
[
-0.31479913,
-0.8620526791,
0.6654403806,
0.4980251789,
-0.3902313709,
0.1637466848,
-0.3347305357,
-0.2653832734,
0.0498811975,
0.2886376381,
-0.2309138328,
-0.3180014789,
-0.3834613264,
-0.1098785549,
-0.3123857975,
0.2915542424,
0.0439547412,
-0.1797531247,
-0.0434229113,
0.011408994,
-0.3385881782,
-0.2830136418,
-0.6509928107,
-0.3745784163,
0.3545824885,
0.3111200035,
1.0338141918,
0.7430622578,
0.4528127909,
0.2840774357,
-0.2093064934,
0.1636262536,
-0.5664627552,
0.0128999669,
0.2524216771,
-0.7122222781,
-0.4234910607,
-0.1128303185,
0.6473110318,
0.3303515017,
-0.3161132634,
0.1945646405,
-0.2334192693,
0.4656575918,
-0.9075982571,
-0.109648563,
-0.6203836799,
0.1694546938,
-0.1057205647,
0.0456965975,
-0.6351746321,
-0.6980619431,
-0.1495740563,
-0.6075408459,
0.0511469916,
0.1833314002,
0.7048886418,
0.5864740014,
-0.6094416976,
0.0326857232,
-1.0094920397,
0.9424711466,
-0.7502866983,
0.712174952,
-0.0442359969,
0.3690164983,
-0.1339026839,
-1.0453321934,
-0.7258728147,
-0.0300070718,
0.1078291312,
0.1048463359,
-0.1555690914,
0.2116140425,
0.4169775546,
0.4350684583,
-0.4174392521,
0.046736531,
-0.0133031653,
-0.1359048188,
0.6990680695,
0.0622953773,
0.2527621686,
0.0616712756,
-0.3135981858,
0.0878723934,
-1.1043370962,
-0.0221652202,
0.1953077763,
-0.06287729,
-0.1935060769,
0.4181186855,
0.1524938643,
0.3604788482,
-0.1328437328,
-0.4898627698,
0.4300168455,
-0.2235543877,
-0.3684547842,
0.095619522,
0.8218731284,
0.2760375142,
0.0026485678,
-0.2783299387,
-0.3614139259,
0.1546399295,
0.2658172548,
-1.1865508556,
0.0698859617,
0.1276697218,
-0.609472394,
-0.0610064529,
-0.357946068,
-0.8122032285,
-0.2993865907,
-0.0314066149,
0.4532644749,
-0.1766936779,
-0.1963969916,
0.3239827752,
0.1417893022,
0.342305243,
0.2537203133,
-1.1430952549,
0.1496619284,
0.5412035584,
0.8787103295,
-0.3218719959,
0.1030233949,
-0.6227003932,
0.104998216,
-0.1242718473,
0.5218569636,
-0.4683715403,
-0.7564889789,
-0.0971581936,
-0.0337652117,
-0.5209211111,
-0.5496392846,
1.2661079168,
-0.5110893846,
-0.0639719814,
0.0409545451,
-0.455375582,
-0.3004076481,
-0.3193105459,
-0.5553140044,
1.4064331055,
0.0484847575,
-0.5517888665,
0.1439136267,
-0.5989513397,
-0.6646766067,
0.1516233087,
-0.1218027472,
-0.5837464333,
0.4862164259,
0.1420215964,
0.5684229732,
-0.5459474921,
0.1254420578,
0.0121901333,
-0.831276834,
-0.3126865327,
-0.3540075719,
0.5541824698,
0.5753322244,
-0.6505166888,
0.3084366918,
-0.481544733,
0.0557838939,
0.2409788966,
-0.2693591416,
-0.0285743531,
0.2892333567,
0.1575957388,
0.0339393504,
0.1296070963,
-0.6173325181,
0.2952203751,
-0.2424712479,
0.6141432524,
0.2855072916,
-0.5076621175,
0.6294172406,
0.1663462669,
0.6530570388,
-0.2787272334,
0.4957115352,
-0.3353790343,
-0.576764524,
-0.6243019104,
-0.422149241,
0.213737607,
0.8189052343,
-0.8616446257,
0.2257103324,
-0.4853652716,
-0.5370970368,
-0.4318849146,
0.0268716812,
0.29706496,
0.4083830416,
0.2311416864,
0.3421631455,
-0.1767592877,
-0.8655132651,
-0.2614679337,
0.0606353618,
-0.1287782639,
0.5098385215,
0.1615018547,
-0.5446182489,
0.7202088237,
-0.6197362542,
0.3376229107,
-0.3713860214,
-0.1749673486,
0.2421904057,
0.2153532356,
0.5462132692,
-0.9147594571,
-0.4157411456,
0.013011653,
-0.598038137,
-0.1549059451,
-0.0070023453,
0.0015308351,
0.1024551615,
0.5107377172,
-0.857406795,
0.3025803566,
0.8940429688,
-0.2647052705,
0.3978610337,
-0.3307320476,
-0.0119545329,
-1.1049408913,
-0.1006121412,
0.1036861241,
-0.2298349589,
-0.6388963461,
-0.0710451603,
0.3431076407,
-0.1714908928,
-0.489464134,
0.5717043281,
-0.3908218443,
0.0050968337,
-0.2220133245,
0.0876880586,
0.0097162751,
0.1797074229,
-0.1395945251,
1.3140978813,
0.3635063171,
-0.5337372422,
0.1832519174,
0.0151467724,
-0.3198219538,
0.0448611975,
-0.7246669531,
0.0845715776,
0.041896563,
0.1115052029,
-0.8347004652,
0.1020457819,
-0.2145533711,
0.1988961697,
0.0620472729,
-0.0824424326,
-0.5854409933,
-0.4240668714,
-0.2827748358,
0.6124710441,
0.8067445755,
-0.8345640302,
1.2340576649,
0.4914707839,
0.0621063113,
-0.5495451093,
-0.4623542726,
0.0843172669,
-0.5149046183,
-1.0713049173,
0.8193302751,
0.0855750367,
-0.0772173554,
-0.4650034606,
-0.1143740118,
0.2784645855,
0.1645784378,
0.4185010791,
0.1435266584,
-0.4008392394,
-0.0521880239,
0.2172837406,
-0.0825005695,
-0.0442193486,
0.108609274,
0.6388507485,
-0.1654787958,
-0.1910140514,
-0.3788329363,
-0.0540280715,
0.5995539427,
-0.1897799075,
0.5785393119,
0.9100524783,
-0.1476198584,
-0.205905661,
-0.8360885978,
-0.1535688341,
-0.5154185295,
0.2002459019,
-0.6709557176,
-0.7208133936,
0.5729144216,
-0.615439117,
0.1525940597,
0.3255376816,
0.583991766,
0.2068030983,
1.0305200815,
0.6341638565,
-0.1625689715,
0.628926456,
-0.2511999607,
0.5729672909,
-0.8536129594,
-0.2167939544,
-0.5152288079,
-0.1804166138,
-0.6767846346,
-0.7058342099,
0.4186098576,
0.3372627199,
-0.0847629979,
0.2676087916,
-0.4038386047,
0.2591598332,
0.4050778747,
0.073795341,
0.4429644346,
0.1518019736,
-0.2070615888,
0.12893489,
-0.8743273616,
-0.6272282004,
0.9038374424,
0.555180192,
1.142062068,
-0.0115728723,
0.2598297894,
-0.07719744,
0.2983579934,
-0.8128457665,
0.6559699774,
-0.2151814699,
-0.1303420961,
-0.0943590701,
-0.4834455848,
-0.8098455071,
0.5509160757,
-0.1629445255,
-0.5570133328,
0.0453668013,
0.0969519839,
-0.3179314435,
0.2678356171,
-1.1018183231,
0.8540966511,
-0.2172135711,
-0.5273769498,
-0.3455666304,
-0.2636471689,
0.4467610717,
-0.1061526984,
0.1309399158,
-0.2069778889,
-0.1725104153,
0.3514133394,
-0.2651928365,
0.2522872686,
-0.3298785388,
-0.33501333,
0.2530609965,
-0.2372167856,
0.7663280368,
0.0981694162,
-0.3603798747,
0.1109250262,
-0.2351207137,
-0.2249080688,
-0.7142872214,
0.6867114305,
-0.6451936364,
-0.4318526983,
0.0806271806,
-0.5434790254,
-0.131547004,
0.0593741573,
0.3917492628,
0.2832658589,
-0.0375966765,
0.2735497057,
0.8613201976,
-0.5475241542,
0.879817009,
0.0472667776,
-0.4858880043,
-0.1108467206,
0.782453537,
-0.1386560053,
0.2090848982,
0.2176574916,
0.2699529827,
-0.6642721891,
-0.8737559319,
-0.815086484,
0.2921705544,
-0.2280118316,
-0.1123986989,
-0.7112363577,
-0.1382492483,
-0.003327254,
-0.1515927613,
-0.6413459182,
-0.2657415867,
-0.0807024017,
0.2978492379,
0.3660948873,
0.3576870263,
0.5529903173,
1.0572057962,
-0.5691285133,
0.53847754,
0.0361993015,
0.31626302,
-0.2059546858,
-0.5805137753,
-0.365760237,
0.0998983458,
-0.4156592786,
-0.3242495358,
0.2051900923,
0.1580322832,
0.4951804578,
0.3058643639,
-0.1731642932,
0.6027907729,
-0.4809592366,
0.7087441087,
0.1449688673,
-0.9683001041,
0.2413479239,
-0.3205286264,
0.4218217432,
0.2403800189,
0.275290519,
-0.399176091,
0.0030473021,
-0.3469613791,
-0.7574011683,
0.3089241087,
0.2559013963,
0.3640175462,
0.2016281486,
0.591855526,
-0.3066609204,
0.0949004292,
-0.3959697783,
-0.4022481441,
-0.1084533632,
-0.3107471466,
0.0391593911,
-0.4778349996,
0.2135964185,
-0.3475882709,
0.6292687058,
-0.2446525991,
0.3785125911,
0.0042079315,
-0.3785248101,
0.2317127138,
0.064040646,
0.9588088393,
0.6192963719,
-0.0302596316,
0.1019796059,
0.3578404784,
-0.9235140085,
0.1580224186,
0.1779406369,
-0.2719451189,
0.2231930494,
-0.1047961041,
1.0647470951,
0.2726198435,
-0.6397915483,
0.5092874169,
-0.3356557786,
-0.0042304494,
-0.2144242674,
0.1997524202,
0.4012837112,
0.3608107567,
0.5201721787,
-0.3274207115,
-0.022071423,
-0.2163506746,
-0.0984556824,
0.5552847385,
0.1606583744,
-0.2512723804,
0.9285499454,
0.3242349625,
-0.2417404652,
0.6483949423,
-0.0550066493,
-0.3482192755,
0.409581989,
0.5958691239,
0.8324382901,
-0.615639329,
-0.0724065378,
0.2618217468,
0.2256177813,
-0.3384117782,
0.4643314481,
0.1962459832,
-0.8238079548,
-0.9212392569,
-0.8082825541,
-0.177663058,
-0.000308786,
-0.0869582742,
0.2764561474,
-0.188144058,
-0.3755268455,
-0.0629625171,
-0.0473933034,
-0.4512658119,
0.1981379837,
0.0917272493,
1.0245062113,
-0.4434341192,
1.1105496883,
0.30240646,
0.1966787577,
-1.0248911381,
-0.3481661677,
-0.3456466496,
-0.6951752901,
0.6684191823,
0.072173655,
-0.4619141221,
0.2256325334,
0.0342896469,
-0.6971800923,
1.2269396782,
0.6552780867,
-0.8200433254,
-0.2338948101,
0.3232544661,
0.209135592,
-0.4123327434,
0.8227003813,
0.6243676543,
0.5745112896,
0.0875962675,
-1.0530873537,
0.2132442892,
-0.0501993597,
0.3574437201,
0.4191340804,
-0.8083571196,
0.5235690475,
-0.2789865434,
-0.1907107681,
-0.1589293331,
0.4745836854,
0.013455187,
0.1056635529,
0.5431702137,
0.6103277802,
0.6977612376,
-0.2788735628,
1.0844737291,
-0.5988793373,
0.3306566477,
0.5072639585,
-0.2173734903,
0.8934422731,
0.4201783836,
-0.1220679581,
0.355017513,
0.4891323149,
0.0401727781,
0.2771329284,
0.2524769604,
-0.7754877806,
-0.0066741453,
0.0023276657,
-0.2468510717,
0.4625782371,
0.3615460992,
-0.5778486729,
-0.191612497,
0.1421255916,
0.1009816602,
-0.3043460846,
-0.3165635765,
0.4331593812,
0.2426416129,
-0.3997549713,
0.9010611176,
0.2780323029,
0.9044693112,
-0.2930057049,
0.2835533321,
-0.3663936853,
0.2921806872,
-0.4841028452,
-0.2784404755,
0.2891138494,
-0.275033325,
-0.1153242067,
-0.3246422112,
0.6961936951,
-0.1650755703,
-0.3974967599,
0.142968908,
0.3657274842,
0.1584188789,
-0.4583253264,
-0.5267572403,
0.6249960065,
0.0252239555,
-0.4946283102,
0.1816202104,
0.1960440278,
-0.1097072363,
0.9091393948,
0.6067297459,
-0.1350161135,
0.4611774385,
0.3048272133,
0.7808418274,
-0.6412722468,
-0.1819739342,
-1.0797617435,
0.4001782238,
-0.0401479714,
-0.0778668597,
0.824169755,
1.179521203,
0.2616648972,
-0.0609619915,
0.4428236187,
0.1246830598,
0.0064073959,
-0.617523849,
0.5134891272,
-0.4384175241,
0.3413286805,
-0.0975559279,
-1.3984222412,
-0.1846178472,
0.6018647552,
-0.4053395987,
-0.070199348,
0.7118200064,
0.9152650833,
-0.3105921149,
0.2330615371,
0.3531460464,
-0.1254792362,
0.4193499386,
0.490962863,
0.5300378203,
-0.7143193483,
0.6238261461,
-0.1860692352,
-0.0524996519,
-0.2864611447,
-0.9895938039,
-0.6985936761,
-0.2738234699,
-0.2322843224,
-0.2162536383,
-0.0650521219,
0.6735466719,
0.9662197828,
-0.1241644323,
-0.3684662282,
-0.158427,
0.0944830775,
0.143635273,
-0.2130419761,
0.4267621934,
-0.3657439053,
-0.9569362402,
0.5658032298,
0.4241699278,
-0.0945497975,
-0.1295939535,
-0.0689818412,
0.1353777647,
-0.0338469483,
1.1676547527,
0.0391546749,
-0.6478264332,
-0.0481095277,
0.0886462927,
-0.075989075,
0.3583903909,
1.1003835201,
-0.7212553024,
0.0123051023,
0.4231249094,
0.9209347963,
1.0183639526,
0.1266595572,
0.599866569,
-0.289290458,
0.4701945186,
0.2114652991,
0.3645041585,
0.067266807,
-0.3631770313,
0.4739898443,
0.1261480153,
-0.6591570973,
-0.8156092167,
0.2022736669,
-0.95562011,
-0.0163795948,
1.189999938,
-0.0353903845,
-0.377828002,
0.1035637334,
-0.2333692908,
0.1359073371,
-0.4159771502,
0.516621232,
0.1942558587,
-0.2145887315,
-0.5187546015,
-1.0195474625,
0.5945162773,
0.5659806728,
-1.0659210682,
-0.0364287421,
0.1692022383,
0.2089518458,
-0.0179311838,
0.3560493588,
-0.0187572315,
-0.0349694006,
-0.0131345792,
0.2632765174,
0.0892212316,
0.0011546641,
-0.1474969834,
0.1185627803,
-0.0900722072,
-0.0620452799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20026v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20026v1
|
FSMR: A Feature Swapping Multi-modal Reasoning Approach with Joint Textual and Visual Clues
| 2024-03-29T07:28:50 | 2024-03-29T07:28:50 |
Shuang Li, Jiahua Wang, Lijie Wen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Multi-modal reasoning plays a vital role in bridging the gap between textual
and visual information, enabling a deeper understanding of the context. This
paper presents the Feature Swapping Multi-modal Reasoning (FSMR) model,
designed to enhance multi-modal reasoning through feature swapping. FSMR
leverages a pre-trained visual-language model as an encoder, accommodating both
text and image inputs for effective feature representation from both
modalities. It introduces a unique feature swapping module, enabling the
exchange of features between identified objects in images and corresponding
vocabulary words in text, thereby enhancing the model's comprehension of the
interplay between images and text. To further bolster its multi-modal alignment
capabilities, FSMR incorporates a multi-modal cross-attention mechanism,
facilitating the joint modeling of textual and visual information. During
training, we employ image-text matching and cross-entropy losses to ensure
semantic consistency between visual and language elements. Extensive
experiments on the PMR dataset demonstrate FSMR's superiority over
state-of-the-art baseline models across various performance metrics.
|
[
-0.346778065,
-0.5995898843,
0.5962626934,
-0.1344254017,
-0.531814754,
-0.0896629393,
-0.0400871113,
-0.558975935,
-0.1797806919,
0.3090569973,
-0.5781359076,
0.1158858836,
-0.650816083,
0.06871555,
-0.3821448684,
0.5906048417,
-0.3501268923,
0.243360579,
-0.3563864231,
-0.236203745,
-0.4176658392,
-0.5336397886,
-0.1841798276,
-0.2776187956,
0.6852847338,
0.0640752763,
0.9989000559,
0.5658318996,
0.7693687677,
0.4165270627,
-0.0887541398,
0.2845560014,
-0.1943509877,
0.0581305698,
-0.3519365489,
-0.3673229814,
-0.145293802,
-0.236247912,
0.4471253753,
0.1018160507,
0.1600277424,
0.0178294368,
0.0140033662,
0.2111376375,
-0.6740061045,
0.3184951544,
-0.7930791974,
-0.083387129,
-0.3406889141,
-0.4387069345,
-0.2661831379,
0.1430472881,
0.134497568,
-0.593354702,
0.3967255056,
0.0138979126,
0.9227844477,
0.4434602261,
-0.3762664199,
0.0082455482,
-0.6262155771,
0.6561074257,
-0.3498558998,
0.9438021183,
0.1663985997,
0.4019668102,
0.2921128273,
-0.3638558984,
-0.9666724801,
0.0984853432,
-0.3042476475,
-0.1605165601,
0.0500175841,
-0.2751167417,
0.0132914754,
0.4991803765,
-0.4326164424,
-0.5257127881,
-0.140930146,
-0.3616207242,
0.3256306648,
0.2951990962,
0.2741226554,
-0.0158162955,
-0.7735238075,
-0.2494160682,
-0.0391217917,
0.2719131708,
-0.0587567165,
0.4145310819,
0.0124938292,
0.7521622181,
-0.0682255924,
0.8413250446,
0.1319093555,
-0.4098785818,
0.4464192092,
-0.819242835,
-0.3284010589,
-0.2360596359,
0.5143683553,
0.5797892213,
-0.3098845482,
-0.0286872014,
-0.573839128,
0.4296129048,
0.1475407332,
-0.6711444855,
0.1134970114,
-0.3060546219,
-0.9048451185,
-0.0805498287,
0.0939308703,
-0.6725685,
-0.1905060709,
-0.4245172739,
0.9144833088,
-0.6716864109,
-0.322152704,
0.2733655274,
-0.4502074718,
0.2741696239,
0.6852881312,
-0.7875388861,
-0.0771590397,
0.5589829683,
0.6596168876,
-0.0246607494,
-0.5764719248,
-0.2300402671,
0.3846504688,
0.1501854956,
0.8054505587,
-1.1127040386,
-0.0467996635,
-0.2681743503,
0.1855596751,
-0.3974283338,
-0.1402514577,
0.0867597237,
-0.449734807,
0.3732593656,
-0.3878571689,
-0.0414927192,
-0.3733353019,
0.4785651565,
-0.734475553,
0.9862326384,
-0.0198963247,
-0.9592792988,
0.5133913159,
-0.4300537705,
-0.2411743104,
-0.2869711518,
-0.3545544147,
-0.2865436077,
0.0683255568,
0.2852393985,
0.3249797523,
-0.4759009778,
0.2801733017,
-0.2562138736,
-0.4394955933,
0.6445627213,
-0.6976133585,
0.0632959828,
0.2147791237,
-0.147720933,
0.1653839052,
-0.4266090095,
-0.2263102382,
0.214832142,
-0.3337496817,
-0.4975735545,
0.0463106483,
0.5054722428,
0.6366135478,
0.3791921139,
-0.2910360396,
-0.066073291,
-0.033561226,
0.3155130446,
0.3093730807,
-0.1936205477,
0.6160597801,
-0.5327429771,
0.3980785906,
0.5166724324,
0.4232832491,
-0.7590251565,
-0.5752291679,
-0.7433641553,
-0.4047379494,
0.1029565558,
0.7526320219,
-1.1754658222,
0.1570211947,
-0.0262473207,
-0.1580906957,
-0.7127228379,
0.0064066923,
0.5649934411,
0.2076679915,
0.6464550495,
-0.2865816057,
-0.1834390759,
-0.7844421268,
-0.4140412211,
0.1467357278,
0.1563986391,
0.1347723305,
0.5189633965,
-0.4789286852,
0.8007208109,
-0.1733163148,
-0.4117167294,
-0.3531290591,
0.1906329095,
-0.3404843807,
0.3538191617,
0.4417000711,
-1.1371994019,
0.0415853634,
0.158830896,
-0.3728195429,
0.2168780416,
-0.3797025979,
0.0464535803,
0.2806934714,
0.4293023646,
-0.6735490561,
0.6531102657,
0.1869163364,
-0.5066349506,
0.147435382,
-0.0121075539,
0.6802609563,
-1.0964992046,
0.0860056356,
0.0679995492,
-0.0854845271,
-0.2909638584,
0.0719975904,
0.073887594,
-0.0658810288,
-0.2945275307,
0.8053125143,
-0.5850972533,
0.06518884,
-0.2128198147,
-0.1604014635,
0.2340064347,
0.2740430534,
0.0717061386,
0.7289166451,
0.4171149135,
-0.1806555837,
0.2420528084,
0.3705848753,
-0.3034292459,
0.6648784876,
-0.1484692395,
-0.1607793123,
-0.3430418074,
-0.0207456332,
-1.0683684349,
-0.0011090494,
0.4125598967,
-0.327801168,
0.3476994038,
-0.1039344668,
-0.4576404393,
-0.3371106386,
-0.1017576531,
0.5523962975,
-0.1225006282,
-0.2953059375,
0.9168592095,
0.1082252786,
-0.2308943272,
-0.8080732822,
-0.7963350415,
0.0045740586,
0.0877595022,
-0.5763242841,
0.6210381985,
-0.0506056771,
0.0060011079,
0.2280816734,
-0.3462836146,
-0.3229574859,
-0.3902670741,
0.1347236186,
0.2993734181,
-0.5355679989,
0.2013384104,
0.0706934929,
-0.4881655574,
-0.3426006436,
0.1661944538,
0.4197556674,
-0.2921273112,
-0.6807040572,
-0.5294497013,
0.4929178655,
0.7564421296,
-0.5275893211,
0.4610826075,
0.7160526514,
-0.3388159871,
0.317091167,
-0.7582296729,
-0.2443615794,
-0.4326368272,
0.3648979664,
-0.7945805192,
-1.1253842115,
0.3410847485,
0.0131147364,
-0.2075643837,
0.1514359713,
0.5353422165,
0.1414702237,
1.0037944317,
0.7678502798,
0.1994762272,
0.6761732101,
0.1121761948,
0.3837732971,
-0.417671591,
-0.6403617263,
-0.3178491592,
-0.3412486911,
0.1016095206,
-1.3834918737,
0.130774051,
0.0728837326,
-0.1403177977,
0.0667945668,
-0.4916092157,
0.7621608377,
0.3366767764,
0.3645720184,
0.285048306,
-0.0817874447,
-0.4193848968,
-0.2773718834,
-0.4650531411,
-0.4282412827,
0.4215854704,
0.3008230031,
1.0759694576,
-0.00928602,
0.2329237759,
-0.1214019656,
-0.0431802124,
-0.8021355271,
0.7387369871,
-0.1548098326,
-0.3669988215,
-0.2165927291,
-0.1706234366,
-0.4943420887,
0.6481771469,
-0.508731246,
-0.2607677281,
0.2773908973,
0.1295924187,
-0.0459062532,
0.4492290616,
-0.4599446654,
1.0752836466,
-0.5620872378,
-0.207022205,
-0.3820889294,
-0.8152736425,
0.1834751815,
0.1063478738,
0.1443974823,
-0.0633704066,
-0.1784920841,
-0.0209790431,
-0.2956109345,
0.8770267367,
-0.0225813258,
0.1739089042,
-0.1395476758,
0.1097942442,
-0.0004763968,
-0.1527499557,
0.0010195161,
0.1518225819,
0.0064120968,
-0.0204093978,
-0.5955120921,
0.3592896163,
-0.5797095895,
-0.4198950529,
-0.5286969543,
-0.7807971239,
0.1723593026,
0.1167476848,
0.0581302419,
0.4950478077,
-0.2781462371,
0.0998471752,
0.6048724055,
-0.0699260905,
0.5393509269,
0.3537791669,
-0.3239738941,
-0.580727458,
0.6985782385,
-0.2042789906,
0.1785804927,
0.9118777514,
-0.0327576511,
-0.4115346372,
-0.044206541,
-0.6640256643,
0.1356721818,
-0.7862377763,
-0.4146439433,
-0.7803060412,
-0.1983782798,
0.0377938226,
-0.4571416676,
-0.2835047245,
-0.2625953257,
-0.1923375726,
0.3481046557,
0.5400543213,
0.1985448152,
0.147930041,
0.1712499708,
-0.8742753267,
0.6396142244,
0.4865088463,
0.4316750467,
-0.0531973168,
-0.4982509315,
-0.0764446035,
-0.0091661271,
-0.1494685858,
-0.9856979251,
0.1900230348,
0.0531296842,
0.8220931888,
0.5101821423,
-0.3351792097,
0.8513101339,
-0.494168818,
0.6014385223,
0.5753368139,
-1.2465741634,
0.5800490379,
-0.2299116403,
0.4781698883,
0.43811813,
0.1539654881,
-0.5282869339,
-0.4253560901,
-0.1823673993,
-0.6272249222,
0.6318116188,
-0.0242114458,
-0.0186782777,
0.0607250445,
0.0387848541,
0.4081179202,
0.2867414355,
-0.7369866967,
0.1323212385,
-0.7042990327,
-0.2964464426,
0.1139248163,
-0.0683274642,
-0.0760644227,
-0.5185644627,
0.2681185901,
-0.4118997455,
0.5821748972,
0.0571456254,
-0.5405800939,
-0.177598834,
0.5838394761,
0.7161858082,
0.6310184002,
0.1052481681,
0.4424199462,
0.0628755689,
-0.2579513788,
0.1324053705,
0.4682262838,
-0.0575152747,
0.114471443,
-0.0360366516,
1.0015003681,
0.61749506,
-0.4522435963,
0.7940659523,
-0.0997603983,
-0.0815536007,
0.2731309235,
0.0736070201,
0.0905495584,
0.7455967665,
0.4048727453,
0.6829643846,
0.0773474425,
-0.4052219987,
0.3336913586,
0.5319178104,
-0.3256131709,
-0.181176424,
0.8091262579,
0.0344600268,
-0.1727909148,
0.2495850027,
0.1555072665,
-0.5208833814,
0.3702796996,
0.6821251512,
0.5307652354,
-0.4981665313,
0.3958462179,
0.0429500975,
0.5587964654,
-0.2190914452,
0.7071570754,
-0.1197106168,
-0.9461789131,
-0.2964633107,
-0.570040226,
-0.3009699285,
-0.1464331299,
-0.5187051296,
0.40211308,
-0.2303664088,
-0.2114903778,
0.1502597928,
-0.7251982093,
-0.7884613872,
0.2353412807,
0.2509772182,
0.8034600019,
-0.9222504497,
0.863879025,
0.8927630186,
-0.7583310604,
-0.3425504565,
0.1939394623,
0.2523312569,
-0.8224048018,
0.5220214725,
0.5474215746,
-0.4522299767,
-0.4058775008,
-0.1724018008,
-0.8219858408,
1.2699674368,
0.3345009685,
-0.4171589017,
-0.0028890395,
0.2026355565,
0.2459188849,
-0.5478932858,
0.3612350523,
0.0575059094,
0.5100700259,
0.4163029492,
-1.0889714956,
0.2714358866,
-0.4774480462,
0.4518152475,
0.4393055737,
-0.6055864096,
1.1188160181,
-0.3871849477,
-0.0661787391,
0.1308156997,
0.5053488016,
0.1887445748,
0.587820828,
0.7595701814,
0.7140025496,
0.4659172297,
-0.1288383007,
0.5387341976,
-0.2248448133,
0.2073474675,
0.7310732007,
-0.5196877718,
1.0787372589,
0.7936558127,
0.2135701776,
0.5874457955,
0.351658076,
-0.0165736023,
0.7072070241,
-0.3830741942,
-0.2866859138,
-0.6928966641,
0.1725829393,
-0.624284327,
0.6310126781,
0.3070910871,
-0.5633541942,
-0.3965885639,
0.3434835672,
-0.1730537117,
-0.0468398817,
-0.2122311145,
0.6516993046,
-0.2056531161,
-0.2270591706,
0.3416517675,
0.091621846,
0.9280266166,
-0.5930600762,
-0.1936808527,
0.117144309,
0.4742049575,
0.088116385,
-0.8287473321,
0.4302037656,
-0.3035227954,
-0.8127381802,
-0.5655832887,
1.099850297,
-0.7052702904,
-0.4428981543,
0.310795635,
0.6389628053,
-0.2273270786,
-0.1095948741,
-1.0653636456,
0.2338977605,
-0.2280361354,
0.0509243235,
0.4638039768,
0.7729981542,
-0.1005248502,
0.5695775747,
0.7171602249,
-0.4626537859,
-0.0629334301,
0.1229427978,
1.1686611176,
-0.94514364,
-0.7045965195,
-0.6403620839,
0.7276887894,
0.0252532121,
-0.2356782407,
0.3094664812,
0.5940520763,
0.6387890577,
-0.3083813488,
0.5889893174,
0.0678419769,
0.3733947277,
-0.6676184535,
0.7692994475,
-0.8109053969,
-0.1222147644,
-0.2737324834,
-0.6805192828,
-0.2751428783,
0.9498460889,
-0.0937878489,
0.0530867651,
0.9097406864,
1.0807937384,
-0.524192512,
0.2139742374,
0.2773621082,
-0.0005085047,
-0.138191998,
0.374818027,
1.1196981668,
-0.4224872589,
0.6487065554,
0.068642363,
-0.1575263143,
-0.3534020782,
-0.8211364746,
-0.7974734902,
-0.9182830453,
-0.107930474,
-0.1190377176,
-0.0597799458,
0.6678001881,
0.5311843157,
-0.5230267644,
0.0298059825,
0.4116285443,
0.1365157217,
-0.5269491076,
-0.2489965707,
-0.1649752408,
-0.2530311048,
-0.2587663829,
0.4181345701,
0.6387965679,
0.1722013801,
-0.2293872982,
-0.0534243546,
-0.4846745431,
0.1847558916,
0.7363160849,
-0.0452027917,
-1.252448082,
-0.4097626209,
0.1947888434,
-0.3444367647,
0.0656464398,
1.2301832438,
-0.8202799559,
0.5101203322,
0.7516535521,
0.7548992038,
0.3995243311,
-0.2975604534,
0.4339864552,
-0.5073382258,
0.4572162628,
-0.120403409,
0.4578406215,
0.4154397547,
-0.2951379716,
0.2277897745,
0.4088637233,
-0.3156304955,
-0.646966517,
0.1773003787,
-1.2698620558,
-0.4622193575,
0.7921508551,
0.2258229852,
0.0360847861,
-0.2785206437,
-0.4310931265,
0.2158808112,
-0.3059239388,
0.6774461865,
0.6025356054,
-0.0088046258,
-1.0019445419,
-0.3146627247,
0.2296113819,
0.3562172651,
-0.7962757945,
-0.0685164258,
0.7756068707,
0.3772523403,
0.2583801746,
0.7189007401,
-0.204707399,
0.3858276606,
0.0364888087,
0.1122331023,
-0.1039577872,
-0.5851216912,
-0.2487762421,
0.0722921193,
-0.3931932151,
-0.2796573639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20015v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20015v1
|
Adverb Is the Key: Simple Text Data Augmentation with Adverb Deletion
| 2024-03-29T07:01:39 | 2024-03-29T07:01:39 |
Juhwan Choi, YoungBin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the field of text data augmentation, rule-based methods are widely adopted
for real-world applications owing to their cost-efficiency. However,
conventional rule-based approaches suffer from the possibility of losing the
original semantics of the given text. We propose a novel text data augmentation
strategy that avoids such phenomena through a straightforward deletion of
adverbs, which play a subsidiary role in the sentence. Our comprehensive
experiments demonstrate the efficiency and effectiveness of our proposed
approach for not just single text classification, but also natural language
inference that requires semantic preservation. We publicly released our source
code for reproducibility.
|
[
-0.2919027507,
-1.1978337765,
0.3350984454,
-0.1415417194,
-0.4732515514,
-0.3608433902,
-0.0991861597,
-0.3439297676,
0.2145093679,
0.7923125029,
-0.8851248026,
-0.5475683212,
-0.2699697912,
-0.0089704124,
-0.469307363,
1.0519555807,
0.1399243921,
-0.1560140699,
-0.4556664526,
-0.0387380198,
-0.4960149229,
-0.110548228,
-0.5898823738,
-0.084627457,
0.0977007523,
0.6878170371,
0.9492868185,
1.2850157022,
0.5607095957,
0.1859606057,
-0.2492616475,
0.7743115425,
-0.208058238,
0.1548993886,
-0.2510081828,
-0.4383090138,
-0.5204144716,
-0.0262934621,
0.5848497152,
0.7129496932,
-0.2003502697,
-0.2876267135,
-0.3130272031,
0.9039013982,
-0.5433425307,
0.1742963344,
-0.8044003844,
-0.1778570116,
0.0339494199,
-0.1889442503,
-0.3680701256,
-0.6462185383,
-0.0727146566,
-0.5292590857,
0.4543860257,
-0.2210011929,
0.8887872696,
0.3483364582,
-0.6822388172,
-0.1380864978,
-0.6560455561,
0.4882304668,
-0.4066596329,
0.2116528451,
0.242413193,
-0.1827102602,
-0.5241059065,
-0.6133753657,
-0.8827873468,
0.1184672043,
-0.2430256009,
0.0274239834,
0.0867145136,
0.2840209007,
0.0397733822,
0.4971394837,
-0.3011872172,
-0.1019257307,
-0.2055184245,
-0.2379879057,
0.6618158221,
0.1569882184,
0.5178841352,
-0.3824853003,
-0.5443986654,
-0.0784521252,
-0.7164192796,
-0.0684263781,
0.269720763,
0.4311037362,
0.1855370104,
0.6892436147,
-0.268951714,
0.4045465887,
-0.155415535,
-0.0935523435,
0.4626618922,
-0.6510058045,
-0.2415824085,
0.0539755411,
0.6541242599,
0.4409414828,
0.1941502839,
-0.3233987391,
0.2164005786,
0.5924797654,
0.2329405397,
-0.5325415134,
-0.3532453179,
-0.018155124,
-0.2171848416,
-0.3126850128,
0.1809664816,
-0.6183432341,
-0.5244238377,
-0.2034605145,
0.4484189153,
-0.6043072343,
0.0664650649,
0.149023369,
-0.3785738945,
0.0864135921,
0.5081012845,
-0.6305612922,
0.5629048944,
0.8744983077,
0.4030170143,
0.0661381036,
-0.1634861827,
-0.4728752375,
0.3074539304,
-0.4230699837,
0.5942248702,
-0.4948501587,
-0.4978223741,
-0.3314655423,
0.248385042,
0.1400091648,
-0.3614482284,
1.0321455002,
-0.4224710166,
0.6071607471,
0.0888180733,
-0.7753160596,
-0.4725129306,
0.0198473167,
-0.6826159954,
0.7502084374,
-0.3420066237,
-0.6949386597,
0.6288377643,
-0.5756605268,
-0.9274600148,
0.0095212068,
0.1213274524,
-0.574074626,
0.0242454428,
0.3487638235,
0.1394400001,
0.0561583564,
0.0030997251,
-0.2206129581,
-0.348590225,
0.0332977399,
-0.697593689,
0.5554582477,
0.2561802268,
0.0221127085,
-0.3979532421,
-0.8447521925,
-0.1494775265,
-0.0424801409,
-0.4382032454,
-0.8341711164,
0.2093887329,
-0.0166670475,
0.0090947496,
0.0848971978,
-1.0176202059,
0.6400063038,
-0.9311777353,
0.044574067,
0.5201717019,
0.245891884,
0.7520381808,
-0.3005044758,
0.3564323187,
-0.0058083292,
-0.0162459221,
-0.4041326642,
-0.2981602252,
-0.6431732178,
-0.8833343983,
0.2885707319,
0.7088919878,
-0.7645327449,
0.501052022,
-0.3686510921,
-0.3869864643,
-0.5383678675,
0.3669304252,
0.1003492102,
0.508939743,
0.46091488,
0.1315356791,
-0.6466420293,
-0.9657559991,
-0.4920027554,
-0.0252292883,
0.1977730244,
-0.0508940816,
0.1635055244,
-0.3618283272,
1.195227623,
-0.925747931,
-0.5042842031,
-0.364518553,
-0.0316768065,
-0.0828335807,
0.647762835,
0.2381448448,
-1.3042622805,
0.0510770828,
-0.1125257835,
-0.525780201,
-0.1415290385,
-0.2136967182,
-0.1939050555,
0.1561252028,
0.5202879906,
-0.8024041653,
0.7266415358,
-0.048750326,
-0.4737095237,
0.0190771781,
-0.5290221572,
0.2133530974,
-1.0351822376,
-0.4209482074,
-0.1225008816,
-0.4718353152,
-0.712697506,
-0.0355535783,
0.3674887717,
0.1527182013,
-0.2960104048,
0.5133644342,
-0.3723516166,
0.9141649604,
-0.4408297241,
0.2073536813,
0.4152769148,
0.1409561783,
0.1265059263,
0.2560100555,
0.2371533811,
-0.9167599082,
0.5831705332,
0.5282452106,
-0.0733863115,
0.3334950209,
-0.3678769171,
-0.2241819203,
-0.7289646268,
0.245936498,
-1.1443020105,
-0.0522051714,
0.4330271184,
-0.3620404005,
0.29437837,
-0.1327688694,
-0.48090446,
-0.2100011557,
-0.6129090786,
-0.1157730818,
0.4867405295,
-0.5040979981,
0.4452316165,
0.5833982825,
-0.0810433105,
-0.522449255,
-0.9598432183,
0.2967655063,
-0.4879725575,
-0.5891960859,
0.4666322172,
0.205155313,
-0.2203731537,
0.2522991896,
-0.2093591392,
-0.2538821101,
0.1457782239,
0.2376388907,
0.5228743553,
0.1850955933,
0.7716953158,
0.2290064842,
-0.0729145408,
-0.1354375333,
-0.1239060834,
0.0025703069,
0.1789797246,
-0.0178602096,
-0.4650553167,
0.3834081888,
0.4121020138,
-0.0956544951,
0.7389197946,
0.5445590615,
-0.4524709284,
-0.4635793269,
-0.3782171607,
-0.1435533017,
-0.476565063,
0.2548139989,
-0.4295252264,
-0.2898507714,
0.1147545725,
-0.0741822496,
0.0205018483,
0.2933887541,
-0.0629799664,
0.0441448502,
0.7307513356,
0.4613810778,
0.4197288156,
0.4454907477,
-0.1805429608,
0.3065581918,
-0.4911456704,
-0.1206747144,
-0.3316981196,
-0.0096317241,
-0.8111073375,
-0.2751172483,
0.2311314493,
-0.0529200658,
0.327029556,
0.534609437,
-0.3253116608,
0.5112663507,
0.526606977,
0.5667330027,
0.4221031964,
0.0337814689,
0.2606578469,
-0.2918590903,
-0.4866423309,
-0.4651504159,
0.8149654269,
0.1015298069,
0.9266347289,
0.1851882637,
0.8697385788,
0.4522282481,
-0.2244978696,
-0.9203855991,
0.8437135816,
-0.5524212122,
-0.5096989274,
-0.2724936903,
-0.6589546204,
-0.8226593733,
0.3855320215,
-0.4653612077,
-0.4909504652,
0.0255754627,
0.3752905428,
0.0835620016,
0.1619995236,
-1.1290955544,
0.9064304233,
0.2472329587,
-0.5797225237,
-0.1439570338,
-0.4977482855,
0.2036519796,
-0.0708834603,
0.4688855112,
-0.0003780602,
-0.4196821749,
0.6152490377,
-1.0161807537,
0.4732916951,
-0.2668530941,
0.0430800021,
0.6663034558,
0.1417513192,
0.8844693303,
0.033004418,
0.1056729183,
-0.6272363067,
-0.1240547001,
-0.2351755649,
-0.8336185813,
0.80222857,
-0.1655271053,
-0.3441419303,
-0.2659686208,
-0.2589108646,
-0.3663912117,
0.1415981054,
-0.0993331149,
0.6168153286,
-0.3513939977,
0.3734041154,
0.5306892991,
-0.0731300861,
0.4940909743,
0.3129103184,
0.1438158453,
-0.2856767774,
0.831597805,
-0.0481189862,
0.2846288383,
0.5958148241,
0.5606356859,
-0.7203143239,
-0.4643249512,
-0.1810809225,
0.177554369,
-0.7291761041,
0.0572156534,
-0.8552209735,
0.3722461462,
-0.7089526057,
-0.1588621438,
-0.2857382894,
-0.8925890326,
-0.0336558856,
-0.3720364571,
0.8213614225,
0.4348550141,
-0.1405171901,
0.398165226,
-0.8410608768,
0.6154008508,
0.204302296,
0.1262301058,
-0.5022798777,
-0.3740098476,
-0.1015414745,
0.2512469292,
-0.0288425777,
-0.5423127413,
0.4656906128,
0.62237221,
0.4439702332,
0.2826220393,
0.4622588158,
0.7204087377,
-0.3721144795,
0.6996182799,
0.0403703749,
-1.0163081884,
0.7413352728,
-0.3302140236,
0.2726468742,
0.6688146591,
0.0942797214,
-0.469109863,
-0.4294102192,
-0.7759136558,
-1.1426150799,
0.7569411993,
0.1435385942,
0.27604267,
-0.138633281,
0.2951352894,
0.2242005616,
0.4247395396,
-0.4217827916,
-0.3022667766,
0.0514462478,
-0.766582489,
0.1392994225,
-0.0103537235,
0.1411116272,
-0.1292892098,
0.7550253272,
0.1796508133,
-0.3084802032,
0.4152468145,
-0.2669735551,
0.3717424572,
0.4572920799,
0.0635306388,
0.1651203185,
-0.2760770023,
0.200685367,
0.0769220814,
-0.9343683124,
0.3528136909,
-0.0904420689,
-0.6015368104,
0.0308226477,
0.2176261395,
0.397444278,
0.0351966769,
-0.4757279158,
0.6363549232,
-0.1246102825,
-0.2381688654,
-0.0675747916,
0.1782594025,
-0.1581680328,
-0.2939248979,
0.2098147124,
0.3559394479,
0.3489832878,
-0.5362558365,
0.7441280484,
0.2791454196,
-0.3556415439,
0.1066850498,
0.6387606263,
0.1780536026,
-0.098265633,
0.1344240606,
-0.3209502101,
-0.3387285769,
0.3987084329,
0.2232294828,
0.8529334664,
0.1651348472,
0.2775934339,
0.0273277853,
0.4494996071,
-0.2406513095,
0.1341657341,
0.1446293592,
-0.8434259295,
-0.2837584913,
-0.2629456222,
-0.0424027517,
-0.1098765433,
-0.4025380313,
0.5245093107,
-0.4286149144,
-0.0608013049,
0.3822618127,
-0.0298422277,
-0.3563252687,
0.6077119708,
0.0222261399,
0.6971957088,
-0.8465062976,
0.7878024578,
0.9863972068,
-0.2768201828,
-0.4277023673,
-0.00935975,
0.1964502633,
-0.4029849172,
0.5557485819,
0.0954183489,
-0.3315586448,
-0.2350376993,
-0.6058188677,
-0.3251824975,
0.4420043826,
0.0654338449,
0.0801938325,
-0.0029456173,
-0.2181190252,
0.5518934131,
-0.199517101,
-0.0929683894,
0.3478507102,
0.4783352911,
0.3019562662,
-0.524265945,
0.1407589018,
-0.3020675778,
-0.0076654465,
0.4334027171,
-0.2988453507,
0.7134454846,
-0.3380410075,
-0.4948386252,
-0.040026933,
0.5304634571,
-0.6227765083,
0.126269564,
0.7545322776,
0.5376472473,
0.6295645237,
-0.2261868864,
0.7843033671,
0.1620212495,
0.4228583574,
1.1892535686,
-0.1603408158,
0.4077384174,
0.4876900315,
-0.1107836515,
0.4467154443,
0.1217011362,
0.213124603,
0.8631512523,
0.1441413462,
-0.4493740797,
-0.3512713611,
-0.1159316301,
0.0228430852,
0.9839490652,
0.3520055413,
-0.103070043,
-0.1908846945,
0.0648424402,
0.4529852569,
0.5778774619,
-0.1650350094,
0.9538650513,
-0.4696839452,
-0.5261414051,
0.3290063739,
-0.0399728641,
0.629414916,
-0.6097422242,
-0.2177818418,
-0.0125709204,
0.6645225286,
-0.2804534435,
-0.6005234718,
0.4631310403,
-0.2157042027,
-0.2527611852,
-0.0614186116,
0.8073826432,
-0.8209804296,
-0.4167126119,
-0.0406948403,
0.1607060283,
-0.1183310822,
0.116100952,
-0.1977411807,
-0.3472420573,
0.0997115821,
-0.0632854626,
-0.0885482803,
0.6801428795,
0.1898801923,
0.7831696272,
0.5588974357,
0.5001097322,
-0.184588626,
-0.1380984187,
0.6461677551,
-0.8974000812,
-0.7546849847,
-0.877184689,
0.4264040887,
-0.336304009,
-0.1042188779,
1.056012392,
0.5313490629,
0.5163629651,
0.0175425,
0.9986928105,
-0.0076013771,
0.8809578419,
-0.5931197405,
0.4021775424,
-0.4889496863,
0.3339717388,
-0.6249871254,
-0.4844044745,
-0.5597810149,
0.3744355142,
-0.1265788376,
-0.458655268,
0.7413135767,
0.9012671709,
0.0534677878,
0.284961015,
-0.044603575,
0.0539547838,
0.3232818842,
0.3517693579,
0.5003934503,
-0.7825410366,
0.6392097473,
-0.3325770795,
-0.3588959575,
-0.1665181816,
-0.849988997,
-0.5165464878,
-0.2708500326,
-0.6485998034,
-0.2964663208,
-0.0014865575,
1.0734890699,
0.3640354276,
-0.7287546396,
0.2856106162,
-0.2757378221,
0.3917713463,
-0.392250061,
-0.2993546426,
0.4505416155,
-0.1511206776,
-0.7613028288,
0.6427305937,
-0.0538149811,
0.3219753206,
0.296135664,
0.3463602662,
-0.5430357456,
0.1460059136,
0.5361583233,
0.0375225022,
-0.3571046889,
-0.356359452,
-0.1567120999,
-0.1788417548,
-0.0494048968,
0.5060654879,
-0.9063145518,
0.7003906965,
0.889993608,
0.7028774619,
0.2490789294,
0.6269592047,
0.685169816,
-0.8740074635,
0.483807534,
-0.0335744768,
0.1503457129,
0.4620527327,
-0.4330178201,
0.5054734945,
0.6658559442,
-0.2545948625,
-0.7303007841,
0.0927063972,
-0.8723369241,
-0.4250414968,
1.1159409285,
0.0608992949,
-0.2975053489,
-0.1720367968,
-0.5530004501,
0.2093987018,
-0.5387399197,
0.3313038945,
0.4285065532,
0.1128268242,
0.189174965,
-0.1462388486,
0.7331315875,
0.0374865159,
-0.621186018,
0.3151682019,
0.878017962,
0.1802868396,
0.0580594093,
0.3306366801,
0.0204420257,
0.1281240284,
0.3524907231,
0.0590371303,
-0.3918160498,
-0.2731685042,
-0.3465876877,
0.2292302549,
-0.2995871603,
-0.7645750046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20014v1
|
PURPLE: Making a Large Language Model a Better SQL Writer
| 2024-03-29T07:01:29 | 2024-03-29T07:01:29 |
Tonghui Ren, Yuankai Fan, Zhenying He, Ren Huang, Jiaqi Dai, Can Huang, Yinan Jing, Kai Zhang, Yifan Yang, X. Sean Wang
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Model (LLM) techniques play an increasingly important role in
Natural Language to SQL (NL2SQL) translation. LLMs trained by extensive corpora
have strong natural language understanding and basic SQL generation abilities
without additional tuning specific to NL2SQL tasks. Existing LLMs-based NL2SQL
approaches try to improve the translation by enhancing the LLMs with an
emphasis on user intention understanding. However, LLMs sometimes fail to
generate appropriate SQL due to their lack of knowledge in organizing complex
logical operator composition. A promising method is to input the LLMs with
demonstrations, which include known NL2SQL translations from various databases.
LLMs can learn to organize operator compositions from the input demonstrations
for the given task. In this paper, we propose PURPLE (Pre-trained models
Utilized to Retrieve Prompts for Logical Enhancement), which improves accuracy
by retrieving demonstrations containing the requisite logical operator
composition for the NL2SQL task on hand, thereby guiding LLMs to produce better
SQL translation. PURPLE achieves a new state-of-the-art performance of 80.5%
exact-set match accuracy and 87.8% execution match accuracy on the validation
set of the popular NL2SQL benchmark Spider. PURPLE maintains high accuracy
across diverse benchmarks, budgetary constraints, and various LLMs, showing
robustness and cost-effectiveness.
|
[
0.0276028495,
-0.7126668096,
0.4458433986,
0.3662798107,
-0.4271610677,
0.0233282838,
-0.3360032141,
-0.1937031299,
0.1325272322,
0.7622355223,
-0.360368073,
-0.4623064995,
-0.4918475747,
0.3360625803,
-0.4983960092,
0.8554732203,
0.2625276744,
0.1806456447,
0.0674687177,
-0.1614258587,
-0.6198380589,
-0.4743389487,
-0.5297023058,
-0.2007645965,
0.437374711,
0.1672789752,
0.669588685,
0.6243227124,
0.3423286974,
0.3975865245,
-0.169140473,
0.4821371734,
-0.5929813981,
0.1653012037,
-0.221720472,
-0.9148383737,
-0.5087944269,
-0.1185680702,
0.5388351679,
0.5653985739,
-0.4996396899,
-0.182244271,
-0.0635477453,
0.6860454082,
-0.6116887331,
0.3619544208,
-0.9483628273,
0.207385093,
-0.2016296685,
-0.2559934556,
-0.741799593,
-0.618062675,
-0.2875151336,
-0.6670607924,
-0.2602416873,
0.1087750867,
0.6258262396,
0.2493696809,
-0.9967817068,
-0.1962202936,
-0.8249878883,
0.9864372611,
-0.7707623243,
0.4779731929,
0.00761759,
0.6888375878,
-0.290812552,
-0.917265296,
-0.8438392282,
-0.2024043202,
-0.1126020551,
0.1437230259,
-0.2155801803,
-0.0279490966,
0.340115577,
0.2742230296,
-0.1786623746,
0.1003615558,
-0.4530108869,
-0.2202602029,
0.528544426,
0.3707943559,
0.1713702381,
-0.2243361175,
0.0084127067,
0.0818237066,
-0.793284893,
-0.2287450284,
0.212631613,
0.4032795727,
0.0612935014,
0.920623064,
-0.1786144525,
0.923283875,
0.0924561098,
-0.2766089439,
0.1375051439,
-0.4497206807,
-0.2671647966,
-0.1300532967,
0.7985635996,
0.6392341256,
0.5615431666,
-0.2170702368,
-0.3603383005,
0.2233345956,
0.2203202099,
-0.9694677591,
-0.3632561266,
0.3246904314,
-0.4058198631,
-0.2309645563,
-0.3262705803,
-0.5254787803,
-0.8030641675,
-0.7989163399,
0.0809125528,
-0.5799518228,
-0.3286141157,
-0.1133773774,
-0.0345897935,
0.2808388472,
0.3491748273,
-0.8636859655,
0.2583143413,
0.7400273085,
0.513918519,
-0.4083677232,
0.0909041464,
-0.705024302,
0.3388687074,
-0.8008173108,
0.5766169429,
-0.3172419071,
-0.0674347281,
0.0484099835,
-0.0181462225,
0.2178155482,
-0.7063708305,
0.5326622128,
-0.8156336546,
0.2798666358,
-0.3247525096,
-0.6784547567,
0.0076563237,
0.2265262455,
-0.3769861758,
0.7955091,
0.275103271,
-0.4704703093,
0.4810682535,
-0.4917064011,
-0.363216579,
0.1688054204,
-0.3858810067,
-0.2005716413,
0.1563390642,
0.2097976953,
0.3827846944,
-0.2486738265,
0.1824417561,
-0.2253188342,
-0.4110831618,
0.3856885433,
-0.0051587988,
1.0519065857,
0.2022173107,
-0.0763465166,
0.3267487586,
-0.7439877391,
0.2242579013,
0.0189514644,
-0.4300903678,
0.0570744984,
-0.1298873425,
-0.0149867674,
0.1856714636,
0.1303061545,
-0.3284648955,
0.1945231259,
-0.6717582941,
0.5341871381,
0.7877333164,
-0.1345977336,
0.7331979871,
0.0194617733,
0.7241771817,
-0.0019391206,
0.0149509963,
0.0704665184,
-0.2175521851,
-0.7301303744,
-0.4581555426,
0.5718290806,
0.8166603446,
-0.781262219,
0.4704620838,
-0.1942084283,
-0.5376516581,
-0.349406898,
0.2046014518,
0.2297891378,
0.6830095053,
0.4062746465,
-0.0874915197,
-0.76725775,
-1.1226952076,
-0.3090655208,
0.0734114274,
-0.1931597888,
0.2328557372,
0.3030934036,
-0.3483654857,
0.7997477651,
-0.522359848,
-0.4417342842,
-0.3216643333,
-0.2110515982,
0.5730166435,
0.2587288022,
0.3976575136,
-0.5441281796,
-0.7320360541,
0.2248676866,
-0.7688504457,
-0.0574774519,
0.1200516745,
-0.3269380331,
0.591807127,
0.6495152116,
-0.7882199287,
0.03952251,
0.3826972544,
-0.2143527865,
0.6895765066,
-0.1788313985,
0.1484917104,
-1.1612262726,
-0.0176062565,
-0.1811645478,
-0.1475151479,
-0.5394546986,
0.0715777203,
0.3619104326,
-0.1513962895,
-0.4574921131,
0.3833386004,
-0.6453376412,
-0.1493532956,
-0.2651720345,
0.1683489829,
-0.2105173171,
0.3911744952,
-0.077839449,
0.7556468844,
0.4589423835,
-0.5807377696,
0.602037549,
0.4009376764,
-0.3074032962,
0.7957305312,
-0.6972203851,
0.0545501336,
-0.0066696182,
0.2491531074,
-0.8467772603,
-0.208294645,
0.1768471599,
-0.2267316878,
0.4186347425,
-0.4516740739,
-0.7138692737,
-0.1199193522,
0.0095508331,
-0.3900371492,
0.8801034689,
-0.3065603971,
0.8969023228,
0.3828878105,
-0.327091217,
-0.6905460954,
-0.9367328286,
0.3969736993,
-0.1853790581,
-0.673635602,
0.3354746401,
0.1442904025,
-0.1976477057,
-0.3882931769,
-0.0767903998,
-0.2536049485,
0.0193733796,
-0.0416949652,
0.3038470745,
-0.2938194275,
0.1960387081,
-0.0471902415,
-0.1515610814,
0.1833689213,
-0.2388557494,
0.5600878596,
0.0181487091,
-0.015997909,
-0.356603384,
0.3100892603,
0.4136870205,
-0.3881808519,
0.9956233501,
0.2773739696,
-0.1609200835,
-0.4452604651,
-0.4544268548,
-0.5495541096,
-0.5118142366,
0.555218935,
-0.2975906432,
-0.558015883,
0.1631942689,
-0.0752980486,
0.19587183,
0.1954211146,
0.399604708,
-0.4475136995,
1.1558718681,
0.7045305967,
0.2621095479,
0.4868317246,
-0.0202636681,
0.2668807805,
-0.7162837386,
-0.1508263052,
-0.5477949977,
-0.2427874058,
-0.5918185711,
-0.5334474444,
0.2517112195,
0.4475569427,
-0.2992975414,
0.2714308798,
-0.6450923681,
0.5706115961,
0.4269019663,
0.123356007,
0.3617291749,
0.4560843706,
-0.009079298,
-0.4775477648,
-0.5491289496,
-0.5663428307,
1.1263437271,
0.0769584104,
0.5917925239,
0.3513897657,
0.4079588652,
-0.1296554804,
0.2563753724,
-0.5119051933,
0.8110725284,
-0.2988664508,
-0.4477909803,
-0.1944434941,
-0.5350126624,
-0.8369248509,
0.2134280354,
-0.4072707295,
-0.3792624772,
-0.0420121402,
0.6033348441,
0.0629842356,
-0.1658626795,
-0.6866491437,
0.9171872735,
-0.4412235618,
-0.2978840172,
-0.1934260726,
-0.4613880217,
0.3759446144,
-0.0862796009,
-0.0283335112,
0.3186606169,
-0.4024293721,
0.5935403109,
-0.410623759,
0.6184910536,
-0.125548467,
-0.1838566959,
0.0582020767,
0.2435374111,
0.928395927,
-0.2849673629,
-0.377904892,
-0.0266548544,
-0.3850467503,
-0.3498139381,
-0.8780627251,
0.469960928,
-0.4436922669,
-0.4850638211,
-0.2387726605,
-0.59929353,
-0.3345074356,
0.2868492603,
0.0690013096,
0.1302654743,
0.3942322731,
0.3677591383,
0.7592359781,
-0.2738786638,
-0.0324293822,
0.6223556399,
-0.4150889218,
-0.4442914426,
0.799108386,
0.153639555,
0.2504841387,
0.3963495791,
0.1459051967,
-0.6539768577,
-0.9971290827,
-0.5075923204,
0.4154079556,
-0.8480961323,
-0.1575438678,
-0.9027801156,
-0.0040030461,
-0.514308095,
-0.1265945733,
-0.1413480341,
-0.7239393592,
-0.1557268798,
-0.1448791176,
0.5323681831,
0.3572889566,
0.2031168342,
0.2906796336,
-0.5862899423,
0.3252509534,
0.385178417,
0.1167576388,
-0.3402012587,
-0.7348099947,
0.1090774387,
-0.005482682,
-0.3270449936,
-1.1692771912,
0.4201713502,
0.0796388015,
0.5479835272,
0.099264659,
-0.0460747182,
0.8276434541,
-0.5516821146,
0.578011632,
0.4017317295,
-0.7728906274,
0.7005234361,
-0.4247106016,
0.2249582112,
0.4797750115,
0.2764348984,
-0.3172284067,
-0.3585337996,
-0.2542297244,
-0.8284304142,
0.6522641778,
0.1991909593,
-0.0700570494,
0.0727479458,
0.3332812786,
-0.2880082726,
0.4788767099,
-1.1271282434,
-0.2380588651,
-0.0559635423,
-0.2973101735,
-0.0037082769,
-0.3554378152,
-0.0857961178,
-0.0401686691,
0.8089214563,
-0.2933922112,
0.0629314333,
-0.3702266812,
-0.1431144774,
0.0469779633,
0.3276987374,
0.2232943326,
0.7381245494,
-0.0447340049,
-0.1025847495,
0.4658558965,
-0.0909479409,
-0.0198383927,
0.073595494,
-0.352008611,
-0.1163791195,
0.4126988947,
0.4745167792,
-0.1210424677,
-0.6487447023,
0.4227068722,
0.0488618501,
0.0496687964,
-0.400218904,
0.2695619166,
0.7800360918,
0.1115678549,
0.0251092147,
-0.0612920262,
0.1976846308,
-0.6421504617,
0.0039984505,
0.5838615298,
-0.3835287094,
0.1988611221,
0.4409913123,
0.3852588236,
-0.4164783657,
0.9809144139,
-0.2763187289,
-0.501650095,
0.6410297751,
0.5968983173,
0.4108214378,
-0.2132748514,
-0.1446172893,
0.4725948572,
0.4048570693,
0.0174303818,
0.6625927687,
0.1251253486,
-0.5127270818,
-0.7045984268,
-0.5699909329,
-0.2536434233,
-0.1487721652,
-0.3098703027,
0.673613131,
-0.213727951,
0.1186678112,
-0.1090779155,
-0.0058628367,
-0.3393840194,
0.1396178752,
-0.1235506758,
1.0016283989,
-0.6858922839,
0.8367007971,
0.5430950522,
-0.3446502686,
-1.0454660654,
-0.587775588,
-0.2065131068,
-0.4223000109,
0.8792753816,
-0.0194537919,
0.2255254686,
-0.1193064675,
-0.2599032223,
-0.4606584907,
0.9691551328,
0.8522618413,
-0.969624877,
0.0076865163,
0.4176261723,
0.7144364119,
-0.273608923,
0.5006915927,
0.5240431428,
0.5253622532,
0.0589113384,
-0.6459935904,
0.0248997621,
0.0028006013,
0.0575016402,
0.3669193685,
-0.3392679393,
0.8751431704,
-0.2299774736,
-0.2286277115,
0.0983196571,
0.7970717549,
0.6208507419,
-0.0321566053,
0.5404458046,
0.3531454504,
0.893825531,
-0.1759491265,
1.1756755114,
-0.1452619433,
-0.1133842841,
1.342666626,
-0.448628664,
0.8613631129,
0.4940527976,
-0.3044268191,
0.4162217677,
0.3513262272,
-0.0882836878,
0.3846925795,
0.4357869923,
-0.0637561381,
-0.3938056231,
-0.0468998775,
-0.4066812992,
0.2147949487,
0.2118502855,
-0.4953325093,
0.0798275992,
-0.2823657691,
-0.0239468142,
0.5300068259,
-0.1617617607,
0.8076700568,
0.126924172,
-0.8031055331,
0.6006624699,
0.0494029932,
0.6288020015,
-0.7866111398,
-0.3113638163,
-0.3762360513,
0.3676716983,
-0.3855267465,
-0.7595154047,
0.3883709311,
-0.0576771237,
-0.205937162,
-0.2088787109,
0.4848477542,
-0.5115324259,
-0.6949073672,
0.2068450749,
0.1257591248,
0.1955146194,
-0.1406104863,
-0.7428993583,
-0.0122599294,
0.1404682547,
0.0068055023,
0.1489134133,
0.7429382801,
-0.0226113144,
0.7007879019,
0.7718697786,
0.3554672897,
0.1509233713,
-0.0605813414,
0.4784007072,
-0.69243747,
-0.5582492948,
-0.7073120475,
0.4662196338,
-0.5826850533,
-0.2177091986,
0.9097906351,
0.6640651822,
0.4939270914,
-0.3580558002,
0.5414392352,
0.022445688,
0.6608563662,
-0.5396235585,
0.6830122471,
-0.4610210955,
0.3534421623,
-0.0392999686,
-1.1373836994,
-0.1146699563,
0.6690016985,
-0.0048623895,
0.0694429651,
0.6989066601,
1.2097337246,
-0.0178087056,
-0.0329084247,
0.2789694965,
0.6942625642,
0.424328506,
0.4903980792,
0.9196078777,
-0.3999443054,
0.9081689715,
-0.2055053264,
-0.1393539906,
-0.0755094662,
-1.1417020559,
-0.9225869179,
-0.1352336705,
-0.5133143067,
-0.5887769461,
0.082425952,
0.6836718321,
0.9006783962,
-0.9403098822,
-0.3082812726,
-0.2794413567,
-0.0305708703,
-0.2026021481,
-0.1986552924,
0.2378544956,
-0.2568885982,
-0.7140821218,
0.4032978415,
0.1864002347,
-0.1547841728,
-0.1631317288,
-0.1996755898,
0.0359352678,
0.1076984555,
0.7797000408,
-0.0613903254,
-0.6997376084,
0.1084543616,
-0.002301038,
-0.3133303225,
-0.0588090681,
0.4635348022,
-0.8109669089,
0.1923924536,
0.409173727,
0.6874700189,
0.472017765,
-0.4019894898,
0.7667124867,
-0.6139091253,
-0.0066686347,
0.534209609,
0.4665243328,
0.4371052384,
-0.2556497753,
0.7489814162,
-0.0224184431,
-0.4485155642,
-0.8901131153,
0.4042308629,
-1.1537860632,
-0.2793804109,
1.274704814,
0.1861370653,
-0.276089251,
-0.0795896202,
-0.4107656777,
0.1847853661,
-0.3342702687,
0.6805013418,
0.431628406,
0.0557341762,
-0.1775327176,
-0.3904631436,
0.3874914646,
0.5127287507,
-1.0444039106,
0.1618301868,
0.7271981835,
0.4238078594,
0.0115333246,
0.6102593541,
-0.310046941,
0.5190855265,
-0.1692589521,
0.1025939286,
-0.1334984154,
-0.0275864676,
-0.2062234581,
0.3608473241,
0.1141574681,
0.2356899977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20009v1
|
On Large Language Models' Hallucination with Regard to Known Facts
| 2024-03-29T06:48:30 | 2024-03-29T06:48:30 |
Che Jiang, Biqing Qi, Xiangyu Hong, Dayuan Fu, Yang Cheng, Fandong Meng, Mo Yu, Bowen Zhou, Jie Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models are successful in answering factoid questions but are
also prone to hallucination.We investigate the phenomenon of LLMs possessing
correct answer knowledge yet still hallucinating from the perspective of
inference dynamics, an area not previously covered in studies on
hallucinations.We are able to conduct this analysis via two key ideas.First, we
identify the factual questions that query the same triplet knowledge but result
in different answers. The difference between the model behaviors on the correct
and incorrect outputs hence suggests the patterns when hallucinations happen.
Second, to measure the pattern, we utilize mappings from the residual streams
to vocabulary space. We reveal the different dynamics of the output token
probabilities along the depths of layers between the correct and hallucinated
cases. In hallucinated cases, the output token's information rarely
demonstrates abrupt increases and consistent superiority in the later stages of
the model. Leveraging the dynamic curve as a feature, we build a classifier
capable of accurately detecting hallucinatory predictions with an 88\% success
rate. Our study shed light on understanding the reasons for LLMs'
hallucinations on their known facts, and more importantly, on accurately
predicting when they are hallucinating.
|
[
-0.174569726,
-1.1561155319,
1.0783686638,
0.0587299801,
-0.0706370845,
-0.0159812737,
-0.2253451943,
-0.5068275928,
0.3209885955,
0.6760109067,
-0.4905050695,
-0.4166454673,
-0.6421051025,
-0.0835527107,
-0.6637778878,
0.7850866318,
0.1621502638,
0.1007024422,
-0.204084754,
0.0513964556,
-0.4204492569,
-0.8521748781,
-0.5541248322,
-0.3265726864,
0.6131954193,
0.0342977233,
0.7423906922,
0.7118945122,
0.2678205073,
0.2674951255,
-0.1726022363,
0.2237475216,
-0.6592481136,
0.5459638238,
0.103390485,
-0.6843485236,
-0.1643277109,
-0.1641255766,
0.5063373446,
0.7662006021,
-0.3099001348,
-0.1331126541,
0.0774190277,
0.55382514,
-0.3265329003,
0.1883331537,
-0.9163252711,
0.1431137323,
-0.1047674045,
-0.5811649561,
-0.4853779972,
-0.5318196416,
0.0798287392,
-0.2592360973,
0.3716549873,
0.2224102169,
0.792209506,
0.6400420666,
-0.4265581071,
-0.6473612189,
-0.8199114203,
0.4940420389,
-0.3771849275,
0.483730197,
0.4221072495,
0.3557549119,
-0.3378097415,
-0.4939998984,
-0.5593857765,
-0.5576438308,
-0.1075854823,
-0.1832671762,
0.1772119105,
-0.0561456382,
0.5273031592,
0.227450937,
-0.4131858349,
0.1542897224,
-0.3549330235,
-0.3111616075,
0.4850818217,
0.2426861376,
0.1983267665,
-0.1647554636,
-0.2776958048,
0.2740526795,
-0.6206561923,
-0.3679940999,
0.421836257,
0.2970367968,
0.0321577303,
0.6524923444,
0.1526341438,
0.4897024333,
0.0245008841,
-0.2034698427,
0.2404358536,
0.0617682971,
0.0451206341,
0.3511247635,
0.4449465871,
0.0937350765,
0.4821371734,
-0.5191216469,
-0.3148267269,
-0.0898173228,
0.2785485387,
-0.6246480346,
-0.2922528088,
0.4223587513,
-0.3013620675,
-0.174029246,
0.0442433879,
-0.8010662198,
-0.8671863675,
-0.4133463204,
0.5094712377,
-0.4192920327,
-0.4367307127,
0.2730820775,
0.0026514905,
0.3216841519,
0.4070590138,
-0.8445331454,
0.3801905215,
0.801553607,
1.0635750294,
-0.5150634646,
-0.3974996805,
-0.6585865617,
0.0891360641,
-0.442214489,
0.7297413349,
-0.2624899149,
0.0166286286,
0.0927202255,
0.0343499295,
-0.1521677524,
-0.7170837522,
0.3304481208,
-0.757737875,
-0.1179191545,
-0.4789127111,
-0.7678572536,
-0.411000073,
0.1383143216,
-0.7226557732,
0.8034574986,
-0.4070563912,
-0.7660893202,
0.3871650696,
-0.2722696662,
-0.255294323,
-0.081083104,
-0.3192005754,
-0.1679010838,
0.3951638043,
-0.3822708726,
0.6671058536,
0.0925748348,
0.5532608032,
-0.3829693198,
-0.5281935334,
0.4892659783,
-0.5093353391,
0.5478593111,
0.05301838,
-0.4664609432,
0.0557307862,
-0.8581063151,
-0.4046512544,
0.1030565649,
-0.1885515302,
-0.1496093273,
0.3366388679,
-0.4148878157,
-0.0463776365,
-0.0819478855,
-0.2447744906,
0.2481991053,
-0.0964414924,
0.0014695443,
0.7876533866,
0.1889137775,
-0.0114533752,
-0.4669539332,
0.2913240492,
0.1137585714,
-0.3229106367,
0.2103403807,
-0.4996012747,
-0.9660692215,
-0.3200496435,
0.0580938533,
0.4726026058,
-0.572385788,
0.2963846624,
-0.2884011269,
-0.2108758539,
-0.1599762291,
-0.1339635998,
-0.0772923827,
0.4706742465,
0.1759812236,
0.2525666058,
-0.5303977728,
-0.7030966878,
-0.0185849201,
-0.2785255909,
0.1308646649,
0.1121387929,
0.6276987791,
-0.1382735074,
0.453669548,
-0.4667524993,
-0.0752046555,
-0.1667776853,
0.3960187435,
0.2846524119,
0.0945058689,
0.3358899951,
-0.7210234404,
0.117886588,
-0.1147609875,
-1.022094965,
-0.1489422768,
-0.358397305,
-0.0037771105,
0.5354086161,
0.6709071398,
-0.7259113193,
0.3804942667,
0.3331990242,
-0.3927735686,
0.7351447344,
-0.1965395361,
0.028950002,
-0.7380527258,
-0.2547355294,
-0.3648251593,
-0.0767838433,
-0.5862460732,
-0.1558101922,
-0.2990621626,
0.6073078513,
-0.1944508702,
0.2796645463,
-0.5461083055,
-0.439688772,
-0.2637780309,
0.2900182307,
-0.4287715852,
0.4795492291,
0.2747153938,
0.4874115884,
0.6830060482,
-0.9875112772,
0.6436452866,
-0.1024743021,
-0.5344330072,
-0.0849635229,
-0.2349522412,
0.0330200642,
-0.2170901299,
-0.0901553631,
-1.0018841028,
-0.3999774158,
0.1657824963,
-0.366373986,
0.2093512267,
0.0272625517,
-0.6533339024,
-0.1671385169,
-0.040753603,
0.1036672592,
0.5274299979,
-0.5736662745,
0.6365085244,
0.3644988835,
0.1389234662,
-0.6343740821,
-0.7147187591,
-0.0125581799,
-0.2405585051,
-0.4933708906,
-0.0234935675,
-0.1571689695,
-0.5100320578,
-0.1051613912,
-0.2193074673,
0.1444980502,
0.1879897118,
0.4274188578,
0.2009318769,
-0.317812562,
0.3810350895,
-0.2239155471,
0.1207710207,
0.4876858592,
-0.067019783,
0.9877040982,
-0.0228930824,
-0.5328329802,
-0.2821747363,
0.000866028,
0.7888499498,
0.2843437195,
1.0540232658,
0.4847866595,
-0.5376024842,
-0.223273024,
-0.696732223,
-0.4027797282,
-0.3442630768,
0.3510926068,
-0.6968927383,
-0.8242439628,
1.0557332039,
0.2541454434,
-0.1254788637,
0.302375257,
0.8949956298,
0.0849778801,
0.987629354,
0.3487524092,
0.3764110208,
-0.0738637224,
-0.189810738,
0.3396389782,
-0.558534205,
-0.5614099503,
-0.3775450587,
-0.1153268069,
-0.8122063279,
-0.3597639203,
0.1782986224,
0.0613984168,
-0.1453347951,
-0.208314091,
-0.1998122036,
0.3904126585,
0.3088841736,
0.1386623234,
0.2123585939,
0.0336239748,
-0.2589107752,
0.0256448239,
-0.4554774463,
-0.5857517123,
0.8317658305,
0.4022885859,
0.8331673741,
0.2932323217,
0.6658958793,
0.3245587945,
0.0606933571,
-0.9618207812,
0.7070554495,
0.3500512838,
-0.6997548342,
-0.4443665147,
-0.4373317957,
-0.5786107183,
0.2631002367,
-0.19785662,
-0.9183288813,
0.0589830913,
0.1347308159,
-0.4139668643,
0.5956224799,
-0.2821218073,
0.5506711602,
-0.4409318864,
-0.611544311,
-0.1316803545,
-0.6044683456,
0.6629904509,
-0.2516286075,
0.1560516655,
-0.2219642997,
0.0368437208,
0.6269173026,
-0.1993628293,
0.8478831649,
-0.0956268758,
-0.3250888884,
0.2384963036,
0.3724379539,
0.439252466,
-0.0197692867,
-0.1233579814,
0.1131241545,
-0.0480954237,
-0.2085410506,
-0.7352568507,
0.7108601332,
-0.6552459598,
-1.0258384943,
-0.6965302229,
-0.590082109,
-0.1666275263,
-0.1668619663,
0.2560709417,
0.282994777,
0.0128457686,
0.0396296866,
1.048158288,
-0.2330373675,
0.3150896728,
0.3453430235,
-0.8614704013,
0.1041159108,
0.8521103859,
0.3479704261,
0.3208118975,
0.2174015343,
0.2305701524,
-0.3637492955,
-0.7439650893,
-0.262740761,
0.6337879896,
-0.8459094763,
0.1020606235,
-0.9441910982,
-0.5492243767,
-0.3592725992,
0.1656673104,
-0.0761127248,
-0.3282448649,
-0.3152349293,
-0.4970288277,
0.2789099216,
0.9743843675,
-0.234085083,
-0.1287970692,
-0.4630101025,
0.4722657204,
0.4284270406,
0.1200601161,
0.1768949628,
-0.7540219426,
0.010267294,
-0.0972033888,
-0.0097608343,
-1.1620620489,
0.2700499296,
-0.1193892583,
0.6485463977,
0.644633472,
0.0613012128,
0.5458698273,
-0.3973561823,
0.8506301641,
-0.2153479755,
-0.6885825396,
0.2021916658,
-0.1274193823,
-0.064529255,
0.1460850388,
0.5558142066,
-0.5719869137,
-0.588735342,
-0.4421288073,
-0.4676076472,
0.559218049,
-0.0264883693,
0.2214001268,
-0.1710067987,
0.4181883633,
0.4031965435,
0.1838358641,
-0.8395935297,
-0.1142303795,
-0.0695374534,
0.0123165213,
0.2325361967,
-0.6510483623,
-0.0399969704,
-0.3729602396,
0.786460042,
-0.0361636356,
0.3405557573,
-0.0401577279,
-0.1656854749,
-0.1327169836,
-0.14568986,
0.9871107936,
0.8946068287,
-0.4533171654,
0.5666596889,
0.1913014948,
-0.3705497682,
-0.0301107876,
-0.2256973535,
-0.1252703518,
0.1023501903,
0.611540556,
1.0565749407,
0.0037960198,
-0.5630966425,
0.5322682261,
-0.0411127694,
-0.3274928629,
-0.6962555051,
0.2315462381,
0.1610417068,
0.2502370477,
0.3693234622,
0.0602894425,
0.1675954461,
-0.7196702361,
0.3063295782,
0.4027981758,
-0.371396184,
-0.4537061155,
0.680765152,
-0.1822800934,
-0.3085258305,
0.7385125756,
-0.3306821883,
-0.8455331922,
0.6307867169,
0.6202121973,
0.8462209702,
-0.1630862951,
0.1766459346,
0.3553479016,
0.2510262728,
-0.1581518948,
0.3438852727,
0.0381823368,
-0.9269399643,
-0.4196871817,
-0.8389483094,
-0.046515502,
0.4375137389,
-0.5496730208,
0.4644845724,
-0.2896204591,
-0.007160414,
-0.0967630744,
-0.2967078388,
-0.2762363255,
-0.0636698082,
0.5142293572,
0.661606133,
-0.9027856588,
0.7684803605,
0.2942560017,
-0.3192002177,
-0.5544422865,
0.3079387248,
0.1340297163,
-0.9291339517,
0.8805392981,
0.3800838888,
-0.5052585006,
-0.0978292003,
-0.6503144503,
-0.8841881156,
0.7943570018,
0.3140771091,
-0.3997843862,
-0.2180315405,
0.0794396773,
0.5931044221,
-0.335391432,
0.0322500467,
0.7097350359,
0.5351124406,
0.5111043453,
-0.5002880096,
0.1171454042,
0.2111819088,
-0.3235022426,
0.1552718878,
-0.4365799129,
0.7671601772,
-0.6435217261,
-0.40111956,
0.0965232104,
0.7461373806,
0.3926264048,
0.3260252178,
0.4943480194,
0.3759636879,
1.0658435822,
-0.1781430542,
0.9765527248,
-0.3144278824,
0.1268272698,
1.0174541473,
-0.4067730904,
0.7109545469,
0.5643558502,
0.1557269841,
0.6092671156,
0.6664920449,
0.0206974763,
0.4604402483,
0.5177398324,
-0.1531983465,
-0.5357738733,
0.0855318382,
-0.1447479874,
0.3959668577,
0.4799702466,
-0.2278362513,
0.1742693335,
0.118711926,
0.1805303693,
-0.0960314795,
-0.0551628694,
0.6899766922,
-0.0203587357,
-0.634513557,
0.8010921478,
-0.4513884187,
0.3279787898,
-0.3143025041,
-0.1661342978,
-0.2986937165,
-0.0543701723,
-0.2051957846,
-0.7490173578,
0.3859477937,
-0.1529317051,
-0.2033234537,
0.0602563657,
0.3984587491,
-0.4790345728,
-0.3196252584,
0.4262159169,
0.5914050937,
0.7507318258,
-0.0274918638,
-0.2377108634,
0.208791405,
0.0968791991,
-0.2711133063,
-0.0865659192,
0.7965957522,
-0.0361840203,
0.9217408895,
0.2555521429,
0.3835682571,
0.5584006906,
0.1977533549,
0.4771475494,
-0.7002381682,
-0.0903486758,
-1.0800805092,
0.2227082253,
-0.1300369501,
-0.1272950321,
0.7065399885,
0.5583153367,
0.5484977365,
0.0060521136,
0.5161026716,
0.1126435399,
0.635223031,
-0.9683551192,
0.7177585959,
-0.6356281638,
0.5818604827,
0.2066917568,
-0.9833168387,
-0.3082467914,
0.5685381293,
-0.2095654905,
0.0270577837,
1.0292998552,
0.8855377436,
0.136061132,
0.122578606,
0.641725421,
0.807585597,
0.0484021567,
0.2857474089,
1.2204335928,
0.0153663997,
0.259349525,
-0.0954565778,
-0.0775972754,
-0.4138180614,
-0.7337065339,
-0.9316489697,
-0.8232467771,
-0.3204159737,
-0.4663085938,
0.036558453,
0.7335269451,
0.4307508469,
-0.907579422,
-0.3116104603,
-0.009587504,
0.406775862,
-0.0659561455,
-0.2778913677,
0.4557862878,
-0.4867333174,
-0.4612570703,
0.0954650119,
0.284775883,
0.191087395,
-0.4435854852,
-0.0642265901,
-0.1780476272,
0.2913453877,
0.4724768996,
-0.067237325,
-1.0180835724,
-0.5885500312,
0.0909283683,
-0.2051923275,
0.0139882611,
0.7885951996,
-0.7610106468,
0.1818512827,
0.3846930861,
0.5571947098,
0.4566259086,
-0.2501612008,
0.2418758124,
-0.3433491588,
-0.0102369767,
0.1910690665,
0.3850719929,
0.3908188343,
-0.4200752079,
0.4884766936,
0.4926821291,
-0.6469135284,
-1.0653705597,
0.3118825555,
-0.8954293132,
-0.4270842075,
1.3790249825,
0.2971968949,
-0.4004435837,
-0.1430418789,
-0.1560248733,
0.4037391245,
-0.0332089588,
1.1563415527,
1.0640786886,
-0.364587307,
-0.1080594286,
-0.8338903785,
0.6546402574,
0.2166520655,
-0.599810183,
0.4262990952,
0.7258589268,
0.0463099629,
0.3308594227,
0.3150165677,
0.1346471757,
-0.0050150068,
-0.0060283733,
-0.0415828265,
0.2423086911,
-0.6302677989,
-0.2674191296,
0.3563705385,
0.1857934743,
-0.0299240258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.20005v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.20005v1
|
Large Language Model based Situational Dialogues for Second Language Learning
| 2024-03-29T06:43:55 | 2024-03-29T06:43:55 |
Shuyao Xu, Long Qin, Tianyang Chen, Zhenzhou Zha, Bingxue Qiu, Weizhi Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In second language learning, scenario-based conversation practice is
important for language learners to achieve fluency in speaking, but students
often lack sufficient opportunities to practice their conversational skills
with qualified instructors or native speakers. To bridge this gap, we propose
situational dialogue models for students to engage in conversational practice.
Our situational dialogue models are fine-tuned on large language models (LLMs),
with the aim of combining the engaging nature of an open-ended conversation
with the focused practice of scenario-based tasks. Leveraging the
generalization capabilities of LLMs, we demonstrate that our situational
dialogue models perform effectively not only on training topics but also on
topics not encountered during training. This offers a promising solution to
support a wide range of conversational topics without extensive manual work.
Additionally, research in the field of dialogue systems still lacks reliable
automatic evaluation metrics, leading to human evaluation as the gold standard
(Smith et al., 2022), which is typically expensive. To address the limitations
of existing evaluation methods, we present a novel automatic evaluation method
that employs fine-tuned LLMs to efficiently and effectively assess the
performance of situational dialogue models.
|
[
-0.1243714243,
-0.8853174448,
0.5316057801,
0.0736199319,
-0.169542864,
0.3039025068,
-0.3808547258,
-0.2761846185,
-0.1686752737,
0.4921810627,
-0.4135945439,
-0.4184603095,
-0.2751218677,
-0.1160242632,
-0.1127237082,
0.7611305714,
0.0880972221,
0.3516821265,
-0.1964599043,
-0.127113834,
-0.8443159461,
-0.4826581478,
-1.0872775316,
-0.4885638654,
0.2360333353,
0.6286550164,
0.5323619246,
-0.0169524141,
0.328458935,
0.3617194295,
-0.1419077814,
0.1564980447,
-0.3545315862,
0.1363606304,
-0.2648954988,
-0.3341582417,
-0.1864469945,
0.0321481004,
0.7638059855,
0.8179190159,
-0.4297910035,
-0.0261622462,
-0.0011184352,
0.3607826829,
-0.181422323,
0.2570062876,
-0.5460264087,
0.1612037718,
0.3403310478,
-0.019015966,
-0.4579230547,
-0.2092615217,
0.387956351,
-0.2893758714,
-0.0103333332,
-0.2025350928,
0.4091568887,
-0.0139301829,
-0.6013479233,
-0.2400725186,
-0.8742431402,
0.7436972857,
-0.7028263807,
0.4104465246,
0.310869664,
0.5941473842,
-0.283788532,
-0.5209428072,
-0.5519552827,
-0.6761240959,
0.0440129451,
0.1242701486,
0.1399577707,
0.1702257693,
0.2104279697,
0.3179793358,
-0.4545730948,
0.3646326959,
-0.2658070028,
-0.1482658684,
0.4826283157,
0.4518771172,
0.3274966478,
-0.0983883515,
-0.1224169061,
-0.0605317913,
-0.4671641588,
0.1814571172,
0.3250473142,
0.3656907976,
-0.3170989156,
0.4829086065,
-0.1780644506,
0.8083138466,
-0.2563107014,
-0.2319431454,
0.0179978777,
-0.2075043619,
-0.0402918607,
-0.4781779349,
0.5564695597,
0.4635749161,
0.2150062919,
-0.0805585906,
-0.2542185187,
-0.103976585,
0.1280829757,
-0.9024590254,
-0.2237715721,
0.228400588,
-0.2571384013,
-0.3158895671,
-0.1767327935,
-0.8102511168,
-0.2154648751,
-0.4623495042,
0.257735461,
-0.2178037316,
-0.3985180259,
0.0053946534,
0.131330803,
0.3121533394,
0.6269258857,
-0.8331238031,
0.4165267348,
0.6658300161,
0.8893571496,
-0.135322541,
-0.1551719606,
-0.7591856718,
0.0551616773,
-0.5566134453,
0.6114385724,
-0.5930659771,
-0.7262761593,
0.3007502854,
-0.1010402143,
-0.0845623612,
-0.6543200016,
0.3814553022,
-0.402200222,
0.3428357244,
0.1676973253,
-0.5068247318,
-0.0434538759,
0.5223732591,
-0.4252674282,
0.7381831408,
0.2289870083,
-0.3085628152,
0.0022873385,
-0.7879039645,
-0.5794048905,
0.3448529243,
-0.2853045464,
-0.3197038472,
0.0291323606,
-0.2012767047,
0.3345806599,
-0.2670885026,
0.5410783887,
-0.227758795,
-0.2930958271,
0.391030401,
-0.5700624585,
0.4409593046,
0.2374566942,
-0.0365327708,
0.1620506942,
-0.3959290385,
0.3328380287,
0.1340480596,
-0.4903185964,
-0.1384599805,
-0.0105893929,
0.2052392364,
0.3518917859,
0.174170211,
-0.1834230572,
0.3060510457,
-0.7232508659,
0.4978022873,
0.3728508651,
0.1871054024,
0.3447712362,
-0.1622985303,
0.6059190631,
0.0304340627,
-0.0286520366,
-0.2478375286,
-0.3932249546,
-0.9527121186,
0.0628162622,
0.2914901078,
0.8052557707,
-0.5713352561,
0.2148786783,
-0.0553640798,
-0.3922303021,
-0.2707017064,
0.3407598138,
0.548453927,
0.4061513245,
0.1840495318,
-0.3243314326,
-0.5303630829,
-0.8568221927,
-0.110908322,
-0.3074519932,
0.0403426103,
0.2996973693,
0.4811046124,
-0.3200839758,
0.8809254766,
-0.5103442073,
-0.1247835681,
-0.7219052315,
0.2428462356,
0.1444361061,
0.5540864468,
0.2475332171,
-0.7540162802,
-0.5242052674,
0.0556932278,
-0.4833676219,
0.2257181853,
-0.103831917,
0.1963515282,
0.4941554368,
0.6820161343,
-0.444722563,
0.1596387774,
0.5652578473,
-0.2104587108,
0.5533450246,
-0.4740166664,
0.0647024885,
-1.2623231411,
-0.0821191519,
0.2041819245,
-0.3590061963,
-0.6627213359,
-0.044474408,
-0.0838126838,
-0.6387134194,
-0.4498524666,
0.9470377564,
-0.2156409919,
-0.1312152594,
-0.35034284,
0.2590812445,
-0.1156925708,
0.4932415187,
0.4536607265,
0.7004517913,
0.3413904011,
-0.4639305472,
0.3401724994,
0.3128630817,
-0.728905797,
0.5741983056,
-0.7062461376,
0.0967126787,
0.3087217808,
0.6455324888,
-0.9112255573,
-0.2838540971,
0.1804309338,
-0.2445157915,
0.3136616945,
-0.4636061788,
-0.3670444787,
-0.3567579687,
0.2291301042,
0.1913291514,
0.5136509538,
-0.4075652957,
0.2087196857,
0.3211879432,
-0.5248533487,
-0.3403254747,
-0.321084559,
0.3180114031,
-0.2439548224,
-0.4629824162,
-0.0914004371,
-0.3082000613,
-0.4968401492,
-0.4773117304,
-0.0010792743,
-0.2272196412,
0.2394765615,
0.2007052153,
0.3709108531,
-0.0652497709,
0.3461277783,
-0.0281388853,
-0.2063092589,
-0.1032590494,
-0.3538924754,
0.6438946724,
-0.3725997806,
-0.4473842978,
-0.6585233212,
0.5446575284,
0.4993909597,
-0.2290531844,
0.6175797582,
0.4067749977,
-0.4827623963,
-0.2302933186,
-0.6540343761,
-0.2055875957,
-0.4499849379,
0.7790678144,
-0.3351790607,
-0.8987900615,
0.3892527819,
-0.3926864862,
0.1056746319,
0.085435003,
0.5494811535,
-0.2686063051,
1.0601444244,
0.5766111612,
0.0650221407,
0.5518811345,
-0.3579633534,
0.3942986429,
-0.7271173,
-0.4434905052,
-0.3355063796,
0.0786875635,
-0.2524543405,
-0.6685453057,
0.1964515001,
0.1266428828,
-0.1877639592,
0.0009500089,
0.0575143024,
0.6142026782,
0.3674558103,
-0.0397333428,
0.1796723753,
-0.0714766905,
-0.1660537571,
0.0532721467,
-0.5109013915,
-0.720828414,
0.877620995,
0.3816286027,
0.4121949077,
0.2673402429,
0.5674602389,
0.3552948833,
0.2510057986,
-1.1045085192,
0.664388895,
0.0357511155,
-0.3517885208,
-0.552077651,
-0.4997656047,
-0.8772916794,
0.4709130228,
-0.1008398309,
-0.8484030366,
-0.3001196086,
0.1044685096,
-0.3672487736,
0.1212662831,
-0.8203575611,
1.0670218468,
-0.2337220311,
-0.2048772573,
-0.5476272702,
-0.4647711813,
0.1723760217,
-0.073122479,
0.289588064,
-0.0121628409,
0.0790139958,
0.5781758428,
-0.4991084635,
1.1255199909,
-0.2738012969,
-0.2669069171,
0.5229560137,
0.1537462771,
0.4995654821,
0.3867854774,
0.0350035541,
-0.0253334381,
0.0143247917,
-0.3611244857,
-0.692971766,
0.6318070889,
-0.6851991415,
-0.7677356601,
-0.3072081208,
-0.5029364228,
-0.6126694679,
-0.0787873343,
-0.0635810643,
0.5805463195,
-0.6344382763,
-0.0169808324,
0.5989032388,
-0.2268028408,
0.3443471491,
0.8660929799,
-0.2552866638,
-0.3271197081,
0.9287737012,
-0.0611495078,
0.5468006134,
0.331220597,
0.2076311857,
-0.4533859491,
-0.6913682818,
-0.4812196493,
0.0876259431,
-0.729763329,
-0.0513417386,
-0.6237877607,
-0.1943669766,
-0.3448341191,
-0.1313256323,
-0.2943150103,
-0.4226957262,
-0.0547751933,
-0.0808801726,
0.0279761367,
0.6106244922,
-0.0655473843,
0.43572402,
-0.7245405316,
0.129544124,
0.6366620064,
0.2742653787,
-0.0962957591,
-0.8227199912,
-0.4041711688,
0.1994065642,
-0.4655593634,
-0.5008539557,
0.3387444317,
0.2463176847,
0.6948046088,
0.3796005547,
-0.1520623565,
0.4836706221,
-0.5869494081,
0.663965106,
0.3629198074,
-0.9307383299,
0.8430164456,
-0.4862641394,
0.1070417613,
0.5574523211,
0.0062043639,
-0.9400234818,
-0.3011506498,
-0.5780777335,
-0.6896278858,
0.6440881491,
-0.1817639172,
0.3197131753,
0.0236165747,
0.2283569872,
-0.1589506865,
0.1263234764,
-0.747323513,
0.0907612368,
0.0290222131,
-0.1317589283,
-0.4973139763,
-0.2794703245,
-0.4525164366,
-0.2105126083,
0.5730702281,
-0.3259156942,
0.0153432041,
-0.1681880057,
-0.1645112336,
-0.0272906963,
0.5507199764,
0.6126153469,
0.6040642262,
-0.0739532709,
-0.2843208015,
0.5677092075,
-0.1605859399,
0.2734359801,
0.0490914397,
0.1096337959,
-0.0848065838,
0.1931052953,
0.6835587621,
0.5791370273,
-1.0953639746,
0.6148123145,
-0.0837476477,
0.0613756366,
-0.6866713166,
0.2171697915,
0.213888675,
0.4537908733,
0.0089376783,
-0.0344744846,
0.0843872577,
-0.7949852943,
0.0341125056,
0.5136040449,
-0.4306569099,
-0.1522506177,
0.1103390083,
0.6231271029,
-0.7812703252,
0.7380524278,
-0.2043565661,
-0.5655440688,
0.7547101974,
0.6530895233,
0.6913710237,
-0.4135722518,
0.4475623667,
0.5005888939,
0.0899913013,
-0.3241840899,
0.0962752029,
-0.0945744142,
-0.7464160919,
-0.3827884197,
-0.5228381753,
-0.9434995651,
0.4197579324,
-0.5906033516,
0.4047571123,
-0.3821373284,
0.099516429,
-0.3051585555,
0.3034891784,
-0.5595279932,
0.3361310065,
0.2791917324,
0.8172625303,
-0.8392425776,
0.9594385624,
0.8303289413,
-0.170476228,
-0.7012181878,
0.018936079,
-0.0298161823,
-0.5159941912,
0.5386893153,
0.3112833798,
-0.0578511171,
-0.2135183513,
-0.2898218334,
-0.4595855474,
0.8426162004,
0.2448616028,
-0.7201330662,
0.0493496843,
0.108785741,
0.7320272326,
-0.4979367852,
0.3088501096,
0.4603745937,
0.2269107848,
0.3771904707,
-0.8039821386,
-0.3887961209,
-0.2930865288,
0.1294381022,
0.0131256683,
-0.8016402721,
0.3694366813,
-0.4599854648,
-0.0375426933,
0.3251746893,
0.6548684239,
0.2444763184,
0.4015346766,
0.6188853383,
0.3896915019,
0.790076673,
0.0242353231,
0.8583112359,
-0.0775565654,
0.2908471525,
1.4603676796,
-0.5129466653,
1.0826429129,
0.300049752,
-0.1087472811,
0.4811480045,
0.8166128993,
0.0132629368,
0.3182709813,
0.4276905954,
-0.4237636924,
-0.6690064669,
0.0378221907,
-0.2920747697,
0.5008644462,
0.6575007439,
-0.0016982633,
0.002796052,
0.0268203691,
-0.118831411,
0.1557668,
-0.2552844286,
0.8717210889,
0.1612692773,
-0.9863237739,
0.3959915042,
0.1444270611,
0.3983186781,
-0.6501134038,
-0.111223951,
-0.2559177876,
0.1031795591,
0.0236666929,
-0.6185682416,
0.1501298547,
0.1132656485,
0.0097245248,
-0.0826900899,
0.4292989075,
-0.6929764152,
-0.5749511719,
0.2243576348,
0.5459158421,
0.2440538108,
0.2433162779,
-0.5947740674,
-0.2280192077,
-0.1017874181,
-0.151233986,
0.5839375854,
0.2094588131,
-0.0964695215,
0.8132921457,
0.4370074272,
-0.1121870279,
-0.507429719,
0.3940904737,
0.562600255,
-0.5157160163,
-0.5488113165,
-0.3834017813,
0.56434232,
-0.10492412,
-0.3792133629,
0.3616819382,
0.7199656367,
0.7928317189,
0.0109682335,
1.0082706213,
0.3100754917,
0.5927260518,
-0.6358688474,
0.5320125222,
-0.4706461132,
0.3519190252,
-0.1071927994,
-0.8693605661,
-0.063298285,
0.9072264433,
-0.4418821037,
0.0716270953,
0.5292031765,
0.6230313778,
-0.0179276392,
0.1681167334,
0.6404445171,
0.1011324972,
0.4128884673,
0.4945271909,
1.165252924,
-0.1200232357,
0.6256965995,
0.0279096346,
-0.2644637823,
-0.406128943,
-0.7021559477,
-1.0980143547,
-0.7024780512,
-0.4961461127,
-0.2978533804,
0.2917380929,
1.1214727163,
0.7453476787,
-0.7356607914,
-0.5076183677,
-0.1025909036,
0.020586824,
0.0202951096,
-0.2041044682,
0.0442731455,
-0.560094595,
-1.0267546177,
0.696543932,
0.1164701134,
0.3116151094,
-0.3234401941,
-0.3556033373,
0.0024164373,
0.1550297588,
0.6771985292,
0.3975825608,
-0.6802456379,
-0.3008421361,
-0.4531624019,
-0.0420860052,
-0.1154444441,
1.0109889507,
-0.6802241802,
0.3300448656,
0.0542339012,
0.611741364,
0.441981256,
-0.2374304533,
0.6741123199,
-0.5644745231,
0.4190985262,
0.3734492958,
0.3410651982,
0.4521496296,
-0.1252568662,
0.4806135297,
0.1626339108,
-0.4490086138,
-0.9464604259,
0.5137177706,
-0.8763964772,
-0.177651003,
1.2277047634,
-0.342640698,
0.526503861,
-0.1960155517,
-0.2498576492,
0.1874649227,
-0.363968581,
0.6866286993,
0.7001237273,
-0.0155058568,
-0.0909758508,
-0.791903615,
0.2942726612,
0.5507757664,
-0.9753057957,
0.0336503349,
0.5598735213,
0.4259749353,
-0.0719165951,
0.5124935508,
0.1763992608,
0.2225726545,
-0.2650288641,
-0.1978873014,
0.2402924597,
-0.4679715633,
-0.448898375,
-0.0607337207,
0.2218288332,
0.0320977494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19995v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19995v1
|
Development of Compositionality and Generalization through Interactive Learning of Language and Action of Robots
| 2024-03-29T06:22:37 | 2024-03-29T06:22:37 |
Prasanna Vijayaraghavan, Jeffrey Frederic Queisser, Sergio Verduzco Flores, Jun Tani
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO, 68T35, 68T40, I.2.9
|
Humans excel at applying learned behavior to unlearned situations. A crucial
component of this generalization behavior is our ability to compose/decompose a
whole into reusable parts, an attribute known as compositionality. One of the
fundamental questions in robotics concerns this characteristic. "How can
linguistic compositionality be developed concomitantly with sensorimotor skills
through associative learning, particularly when individuals only learn partial
linguistic compositions and their corresponding sensorimotor patterns?" To
address this question, we propose a brain-inspired neural network model that
integrates vision, proprioception, and language into a framework of predictive
coding and active inference, based on the free-energy principle. The
effectiveness and capabilities of this model were assessed through various
simulation experiments conducted with a robot arm. Our results show that
generalization in learning to unlearned verb-noun compositions, is
significantly enhanced when training variations of task composition are
increased. We attribute this to self-organized compositional structures in
linguistic latent state space being influenced significantly by sensorimotor
learning. Ablation studies show that visual attention and working memory are
essential to accurately generate visuo-motor sequences to achieve
linguistically represented goals. These insights advance our understanding of
mechanisms underlying development of compositionality through interactions of
linguistic and sensorimotor experience.
|
[
0.0463860333,
-0.7182980776,
0.5302395225,
-0.1104835942,
-0.0906163827,
0.1591601074,
-0.4235832095,
-0.2643589079,
0.4985261559,
0.3743858039,
-0.3977490366,
-0.2577939928,
-0.2987808883,
-0.220472306,
-0.1690442711,
0.8250036836,
-0.0145260859,
-0.0100854076,
-0.1543675959,
-0.026801439,
-0.4300192595,
-0.4373818934,
-0.3521656394,
-0.6601409912,
0.5879012942,
0.0159427226,
0.570178926,
0.9401679635,
0.4548120201,
0.5071451664,
0.1142555028,
0.2099959105,
-0.0469894074,
0.1828252226,
-0.1880415231,
-0.750967741,
-0.1817569137,
-0.1138534844,
0.599503696,
1.0809428692,
-0.2651023865,
-0.3299110532,
0.1266260594,
0.5593349934,
-0.5803451538,
0.4380735755,
-0.511171937,
0.2882073522,
0.4419573545,
-0.0772024766,
-0.1178988963,
0.1441417783,
-0.0500445366,
-0.6838632226,
0.3061849773,
-0.3149876595,
0.4082841575,
0.3844407201,
-0.2996495962,
-0.2553730607,
-0.8510758281,
0.6421172023,
-0.3133871853,
0.4218082428,
0.3102571964,
-0.0968915075,
-0.235128656,
-0.4363749623,
-0.7749290466,
-0.2274414897,
-0.1452068985,
0.4545457065,
-0.1820617616,
0.3601950407,
-0.0621800013,
-0.0814495906,
-0.6240501404,
-0.0030533767,
-0.5281056166,
-0.0841187686,
0.5296251178,
0.168230772,
0.7770283818,
-0.1603486389,
-0.2410645336,
-0.3741777539,
-0.0891320109,
-0.0504199192,
0.5009948611,
0.4668133855,
-0.2115450799,
0.6658605337,
-0.2029890567,
0.6516628265,
-0.0634444281,
0.1347629279,
0.2647301555,
-0.2786185443,
-0.121533215,
-0.0682292357,
0.9079431295,
0.3008287549,
0.2938244343,
-0.6140627861,
-0.2162730545,
0.5478748083,
0.6622505784,
-0.2415645272,
-0.440889895,
0.1996589452,
-0.3508976698,
-0.1466944665,
0.3528705537,
-0.2721428275,
-0.1284600049,
-0.6682426333,
0.604483366,
-0.450365752,
-0.4073628187,
0.3202699721,
-0.1608636528,
0.002055038,
0.0553870536,
-1.3004082441,
0.2997410893,
0.7731445432,
0.6937698126,
-0.3186815977,
-0.6182195544,
0.0287657492,
0.3083450496,
-0.4382655919,
0.6175763011,
-0.5226891637,
-0.2404357195,
-0.0949732587,
0.0296387989,
-0.5330770016,
-0.6269769073,
-0.2536854446,
-0.4532049894,
0.1806123108,
0.1760224104,
-0.443474561,
-0.5649514794,
-0.0620404631,
-0.7954714298,
0.3565998673,
0.2915223241,
-0.205798462,
0.2031579763,
-0.9316641092,
-0.7373999357,
0.0237061903,
-0.232065931,
-0.044863116,
0.3533612192,
-0.3864559233,
0.3831572533,
0.1823340654,
0.2348576337,
0.1997460723,
-0.1630160213,
0.5218479037,
-0.0537520908,
0.4272324741,
0.0115438318,
-0.3383592367,
0.3822870851,
-0.6225220561,
-0.1449649483,
0.0247466471,
-0.3701748848,
-0.2519523203,
0.1283393353,
-0.391918689,
0.0417601429,
0.2891811132,
-0.5195103884,
-0.1076610312,
-0.6988054514,
0.2539369166,
0.5908088088,
0.1709779054,
0.9035263062,
-0.4234434664,
0.5053482652,
0.0595607162,
-0.0772463456,
-0.1319208443,
-0.1672231704,
-0.873942852,
0.0063986508,
-0.1907527745,
0.5738765597,
-0.6685560942,
0.7479803562,
-0.1011437625,
-0.3543833792,
-0.1127202213,
0.370464623,
0.4171925485,
0.4329561293,
0.305518657,
-0.6695465446,
-0.5017037988,
-0.6983075738,
0.124887675,
-0.165373072,
-0.3103922904,
0.0212663133,
0.3846557438,
-0.160223186,
0.6075435281,
-0.3769264519,
-0.1258639842,
-0.2554727197,
0.1303167641,
0.0790923461,
0.6938534975,
0.3353176415,
-0.594874382,
-0.1064335182,
0.3502154946,
-1.076238513,
0.2947956324,
-0.1163753644,
-0.2133867741,
0.0526356734,
0.2528887093,
-0.7969828248,
0.1544868797,
0.5048165917,
-0.2897738218,
0.1008128002,
-0.4050752819,
-0.1208893433,
-0.9433205128,
0.0405797698,
-0.2349572778,
0.4205469489,
-0.7075413465,
0.1853735298,
-0.302544415,
-0.1515993774,
-0.4669456184,
0.3144804835,
-0.394256562,
-0.1354255825,
-0.7726503611,
-0.1420669109,
-0.0736960918,
0.8571175933,
0.2441020757,
0.3968503177,
0.5682354569,
-0.8784047961,
0.4262146354,
0.0376135707,
-0.1897347569,
0.1696565002,
-0.7657626867,
0.0173169784,
-0.3487119377,
-0.2322755903,
-0.8103164434,
-0.3228147328,
0.2356809229,
-0.4816011488,
0.3013517857,
0.2711463869,
-0.2634807527,
-0.1406695098,
0.1568768024,
0.2214202285,
0.4402894676,
0.0381861143,
1.009375453,
0.2272923142,
0.1460047066,
-0.3444589972,
-0.7891857028,
-0.3233473599,
0.1457089484,
-0.4447542727,
0.1892592609,
-0.1423997879,
-0.3415710926,
0.0168190785,
-0.1351620704,
-0.0144161973,
0.2164103836,
0.2862127125,
0.2583523095,
-0.060245879,
0.2057958543,
0.0387465656,
-0.0171651226,
0.2220048606,
-0.2174023241,
0.828037262,
0.1396638304,
-0.3774584532,
-0.3887507617,
0.4434090555,
0.452927947,
-0.2648877501,
0.6352484226,
0.384257704,
-0.3032172918,
-0.1610900164,
0.045993723,
-0.6189841032,
-0.4881317616,
0.5050344467,
-0.150488019,
-0.7384730577,
0.5887827873,
0.1525061578,
-0.1300139576,
0.111695312,
0.5350788236,
-0.289273113,
0.7040192485,
0.7523312569,
0.2912857234,
0.7798863649,
-0.5770738125,
-0.0706074014,
-0.810395062,
-0.4284179211,
-0.0168031789,
-0.6743421555,
-0.5824050903,
-0.6873810887,
0.170794636,
-0.2921027839,
-0.3761672676,
0.5156450272,
-0.4807035029,
0.5447688699,
0.6416015625,
0.4950747788,
-0.0483524837,
0.0966241658,
-0.3720753491,
0.217197448,
-0.5415390134,
-0.3640890121,
1.0148615837,
-0.1419428289,
0.5786530375,
0.0862335265,
0.6466552019,
0.1719737649,
-0.1066504642,
-0.9864304066,
0.596798718,
-0.2751034498,
-0.4720236957,
-0.1187587902,
-0.1324354708,
-1.151496172,
0.2802208662,
-0.107091181,
-0.6454991102,
0.2663076222,
0.1021751314,
-0.2387450337,
0.3059240282,
-0.6071680188,
0.7979187965,
-0.4302606583,
-0.4019066393,
-0.2967498899,
-0.9415795803,
-0.0935254022,
-0.008559159,
-0.0024877694,
-0.0656731799,
-0.3184287548,
0.5967514515,
-0.1134105176,
1.2248053551,
-0.2410277724,
-0.1098026708,
0.5154773593,
0.1820884347,
0.0507554226,
-0.5993905663,
-0.0018540719,
-0.0315692201,
-0.720430553,
-0.3706325591,
-0.8963345289,
0.2868492007,
-1.1114928722,
-0.2679384649,
-0.0503736399,
-0.5868369341,
-0.0827186033,
0.1860180944,
0.0863531679,
0.0227159001,
-0.2904697061,
0.114062205,
0.670247674,
0.1831253767,
0.631267488,
0.4581020772,
0.0996953771,
-0.4713760316,
0.9167075157,
-0.1335402131,
0.3448020518,
0.7995593548,
0.2190693468,
0.1076536849,
-0.2392927557,
-0.0774734169,
0.2345012277,
-0.523884058,
-0.1417797506,
-0.6633275747,
-0.186026141,
0.0075443587,
-0.3558985889,
-0.464314729,
-0.3704660237,
-0.4872626662,
-0.3155680299,
0.0553438626,
0.8975383639,
-0.3257107437,
0.7276711464,
-0.5175318718,
0.3562968671,
0.4166564643,
-0.0484324135,
0.3303520679,
-0.3393698633,
-0.3979327083,
0.3104953766,
-0.4434735477,
-0.5281566978,
0.2927823067,
0.2905182838,
0.6593589783,
0.4486224949,
-0.2816338539,
0.133387208,
-0.3518359661,
0.6866448522,
0.4619813859,
-0.7234418988,
0.6811419129,
-0.5236008167,
0.3346498907,
0.2514891624,
0.4678950608,
-0.4797759652,
-0.2340725958,
-0.5606620908,
-0.847063303,
0.3091960549,
-0.1076777205,
0.5928421021,
-0.2054031193,
0.3071449995,
0.1908187121,
0.4050526917,
-0.7668570876,
0.0208396651,
-0.3939063251,
-0.3070427179,
-0.1735588908,
0.2038675249,
-0.1303768009,
-0.213377133,
0.1430062354,
-0.384690851,
0.6137173772,
0.0117678912,
0.0416315682,
-0.2536703348,
-0.0339287259,
0.6623317599,
0.472276032,
0.3110408485,
0.0299470294,
-0.2995922565,
-0.4408626854,
0.2858171463,
-0.3230388463,
-0.2228049487,
-0.2761479616,
0.4297731221,
0.8923050165,
0.1860244274,
-0.5409830213,
0.2922959924,
0.291647315,
-0.2581965327,
-0.1918428987,
0.6233305335,
0.1198663116,
0.3829647303,
0.3678382933,
0.3847439587,
0.0013449409,
-0.7557935715,
0.1941637397,
0.3358765841,
-0.4981157184,
-0.7520372868,
0.5940478444,
-0.0756520331,
-0.175722599,
0.4947743118,
0.0154855801,
-0.472088784,
0.8346524239,
0.5749727488,
0.9201315641,
-0.4227977097,
0.160735026,
0.281358391,
0.2605834603,
0.0881029665,
0.5784835815,
-0.3951879144,
-1.2510384321,
-0.4582943022,
-0.706376195,
-0.3044163287,
-0.3354851604,
-0.3479393721,
-0.1331444979,
-0.6159539223,
-0.0581962205,
-0.1861100644,
-0.2654795945,
-0.4977683127,
0.3747813404,
0.1172486991,
0.0586969294,
-1.0715212822,
0.4438087642,
1.0167566538,
-0.6698787212,
-0.964453876,
-0.1019519269,
-0.3384503722,
-0.8235789537,
0.7854833603,
0.096823521,
-0.2531501651,
-0.1718252599,
-0.6369256973,
-0.7412800193,
0.970708251,
0.2769574523,
-0.1894918382,
-0.123612158,
0.1652665585,
0.7258412242,
-0.50760746,
-0.052273158,
0.1609977633,
0.2436216623,
0.1838852465,
-0.6212970018,
-0.1831450015,
-0.3197170496,
0.038065102,
0.2207616866,
-0.8896309137,
0.8839796782,
-0.2265732586,
-0.1050947905,
0.218993485,
0.7954905033,
-0.0834691226,
0.1123692617,
0.0654871017,
0.503259778,
0.5317319036,
0.1410628259,
0.6717454791,
-0.3092807531,
-0.0980638117,
0.9151722193,
-0.212241292,
0.7422969937,
0.4934481084,
-0.1081296206,
0.8831433654,
0.013296728,
-0.0063143303,
0.6916407347,
0.4180310369,
-0.5822656751,
-0.1331803203,
-0.2507631481,
0.1686301678,
1.1848648787,
0.3631153107,
-0.5571820736,
0.1960218102,
0.5021097064,
-0.0613895692,
0.4608086944,
-0.1878859997,
1.0662965775,
-0.0873264745,
-0.6602242589,
0.1516601592,
-0.2801418304,
0.7256606817,
-0.7309523821,
0.0391616113,
-0.0663457587,
0.1746848822,
-0.1567844301,
-0.6201403737,
0.3660483658,
-0.5025731325,
-0.3309319019,
-0.1449837238,
0.6130639315,
-0.435787499,
-0.2267423272,
0.31393677,
0.7843376994,
0.2095324695,
0.0590151176,
-0.208965376,
0.0343825333,
-0.0673523694,
-0.0679037943,
0.2849954069,
0.3559851646,
0.2210694104,
0.5297374725,
0.6126186848,
0.2200884223,
-0.0407766216,
-0.0362187587,
0.8520746827,
-0.6667843461,
-0.3210780025,
-0.6724706888,
0.6490781307,
0.3027686477,
-0.0505145863,
0.2597820759,
0.4721418023,
1.0288881063,
-0.39681229,
0.6891127825,
-0.1056593359,
0.0749149397,
-0.4860850275,
0.8974558115,
-0.4680009484,
-0.3681957126,
-0.0351655707,
-0.9173680544,
-0.4194580317,
0.9166429043,
-0.0491779335,
0.3492542803,
0.7001247406,
0.5997003913,
-0.0518031344,
-0.1261609346,
0.5468871593,
-0.1608389318,
-0.0266819485,
0.3940044641,
0.5828516483,
-0.3488813043,
0.1643154621,
-0.6294384003,
-0.1647052914,
0.1588662863,
-0.447786212,
-0.697712779,
-0.6630759835,
-0.3988983035,
0.1387457997,
0.03525801,
0.8263572454,
0.5911325812,
-0.5426051617,
-0.6630324125,
-0.589797914,
-0.1191597953,
-0.2528947294,
-0.2107473314,
0.0534243323,
-0.5090223551,
-0.6851024628,
0.5366423726,
0.2948542833,
0.3176896572,
-0.2655858397,
-0.0029018659,
-0.0955738053,
-0.1895487159,
0.7016827464,
0.4469391704,
-0.4136803448,
-0.1441776156,
0.290320456,
0.125167504,
0.1171323285,
0.8776668906,
-0.6202553511,
0.5822946429,
0.373742491,
0.5386711955,
0.0880644917,
-0.0893785059,
0.7024288774,
-0.7966163158,
0.2518081367,
0.3606034517,
0.393434912,
0.4502818286,
-0.2690971494,
0.4433117211,
0.4454078078,
-0.4633570313,
-0.0969073847,
0.4117340147,
-1.0438371897,
-0.194953531,
0.8427174091,
0.059469644,
-0.5790697336,
0.1717603952,
-0.0277322456,
0.675131917,
-0.2409312278,
0.6061390042,
0.5184057951,
-0.6072419286,
-0.1301658601,
-0.1819982231,
-0.0365856141,
0.4367678463,
-0.5426365137,
-0.0113067264,
0.5739494562,
0.1487997174,
0.5024269223,
0.2382009327,
0.1579967588,
0.3602622747,
0.2348995507,
0.5500949621,
0.115696758,
-0.4795758128,
-0.1020114794,
0.0743361264,
-0.0857471749,
-0.4775547087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19962v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19962v1
|
Enhancing the General Agent Capabilities of Low-Parameter LLMs through Tuning and Multi-Branch Reasoning
| 2024-03-29T03:48:12 | 2024-03-29T03:48:12 |
Qinhao Zhou, Zihan Zhang, Xiang Xiang, Ke Wang, Yuchuan Wu, Yongbin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Open-source pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit strong language
understanding and generation capabilities, making them highly successful in a
variety of tasks. However, when used as agents for dealing with complex
problems in the real world, their performance is far inferior to large
commercial models such as ChatGPT and GPT-4. As intelligent agents, LLMs need
to have the capabilities of task planning, long-term memory, and the ability to
leverage external tools to achieve satisfactory performance. Various methods
have been proposed to enhance the agent capabilities of LLMs. On the one hand,
methods involve constructing agent-specific data and fine-tuning the models. On
the other hand, some methods focus on designing prompts that effectively
activate the reasoning abilities of the LLMs. We explore both strategies on the
7B and 13B models. We propose a comprehensive method for constructing
agent-specific data using GPT-4. Through supervised fine-tuning with
constructed data, we find that for these models with a relatively small number
of parameters, supervised fine-tuning can significantly reduce hallucination
outputs and formatting errors in agent tasks. Furthermore, techniques such as
multi-path reasoning and task decomposition can effectively decrease problem
complexity and enhance the performance of LLMs as agents. We evaluate our
method on five agent tasks of AgentBench and achieve satisfactory results.
|
[
-0.7066207528,
-0.9023838043,
0.7845514417,
-0.1802896261,
-0.2444382757,
0.1900163442,
-0.5641024113,
-0.5092576146,
0.0905578956,
0.7697618008,
-0.6053752303,
-0.5631853938,
-0.2607966065,
0.0590255037,
0.097407572,
0.8981919885,
0.073846072,
-0.0071927588,
-0.006019678,
0.1224828735,
-0.4214694798,
-0.4544631839,
-0.855474472,
-0.4002591372,
0.5704987645,
0.4587016106,
0.9045543671,
0.6901080012,
0.4393958449,
0.3931836486,
0.0109722856,
0.8723886013,
-0.5204835534,
0.2689478099,
-0.4545795918,
-0.4628361762,
-0.7708488107,
-0.0868221521,
0.4476131201,
0.3198422492,
0.1154688448,
-0.0939722955,
-0.0038297274,
0.4902271628,
-0.3221709728,
0.435813427,
-0.8249439001,
-0.3667410314,
-0.0923997313,
-0.4475635886,
-0.3633841872,
-0.2373040915,
-0.2351299375,
-0.600715816,
0.2793206573,
-0.0082092201,
0.9154573083,
0.5260550976,
-0.2798992395,
-0.3411492109,
-0.8190533519,
0.6304950714,
-0.780343473,
0.1727302969,
0.362137109,
0.3473937809,
-0.4490632415,
-0.4366425276,
-0.1403287053,
-0.4842125475,
0.0051262528,
-0.1669598222,
0.0127876084,
0.4393225908,
0.4373707175,
0.0270727705,
-0.4383934736,
0.2704996467,
-0.1965211779,
-0.4020727575,
0.5537839532,
0.3128565848,
0.0273197424,
0.1572709382,
0.168053776,
-0.1347225308,
-0.6995911598,
0.0786245838,
0.5638688207,
0.7674469948,
0.3803618848,
0.5045626163,
-0.4778604805,
0.7226654291,
0.1475958079,
-0.2038665116,
-0.1365852356,
-0.5066598058,
-0.1054449379,
-0.201026395,
0.395986706,
-0.0245824717,
0.5057333708,
-0.3588899374,
-0.3899625838,
0.1720380634,
0.3683371246,
-0.8455361128,
-0.0389017463,
0.1511950493,
-0.2108712494,
-0.1244596988,
-0.221537739,
-0.4339071214,
-0.3883988261,
-0.7337137461,
0.3708778322,
-0.5676212311,
-0.0394799337,
0.0476245955,
-0.0572140329,
0.3019571602,
0.5387824178,
-0.7416439056,
0.278675139,
0.5885940194,
0.5659724474,
0.0226062126,
-0.2813818455,
-0.6272827983,
0.2997432351,
-0.5019851327,
0.9659126997,
-0.717607677,
-0.0923382863,
-0.2153482139,
0.1112659425,
0.0302115399,
-0.6846499443,
0.3765871525,
-0.3743584752,
-0.2686673105,
-0.2664026618,
-0.3512849808,
-0.0939276144,
0.3252179027,
-0.5231373906,
0.6715327501,
0.0866243318,
-0.2418040633,
0.1772066951,
-0.6594927311,
-0.376570493,
-0.0229681749,
-0.1599069238,
-0.3042788804,
0.162520662,
0.5664598942,
0.6059581041,
-0.3114953339,
0.1811960787,
-0.2846517861,
-0.4692719281,
-0.0296550132,
-0.3168613911,
0.3202502728,
0.2427249551,
-0.220205754,
0.4786774218,
-0.5085385442,
0.3117693067,
-0.0050989864,
-0.291541934,
-0.1495389491,
0.1263456941,
-0.358002454,
0.0604342893,
0.1905260235,
-0.0519106947,
0.4453965425,
-0.5351067781,
0.3862257004,
0.775703311,
-0.0137474574,
0.418833226,
-0.6137410998,
0.5306690335,
-0.015814906,
0.071496211,
-0.0439865813,
-0.4149706364,
-0.7340860367,
-0.4702143073,
0.0333776288,
0.4009181559,
-0.9711661339,
0.3911628425,
-0.0725754872,
-0.6243190765,
-0.5414356589,
0.3956271112,
0.188418895,
0.1708733737,
0.4694559872,
-0.060085766,
-0.2805046737,
-0.8497040868,
-0.2216169238,
0.0129778674,
-0.0271944497,
0.4195953608,
0.3723989129,
-0.3023951948,
0.8324849606,
-0.3745607436,
-0.1864502728,
-0.3314780295,
0.024886366,
0.1744317114,
0.3196626008,
0.4011261165,
-0.4233157933,
-0.3035559952,
0.1591896713,
-0.5271140337,
-0.0757517293,
-0.0272482168,
-0.1890253723,
0.2684440017,
0.5208534598,
-0.9312336445,
0.2560268641,
0.1622255892,
-0.3994263709,
0.5892750025,
-0.4255016744,
0.0452457927,
-0.853520453,
-0.2929144204,
-0.1125070751,
-0.3317179084,
-0.7019121647,
0.1353118569,
-0.0548756607,
0.0078812167,
-0.3975453973,
0.6500441432,
-0.8093729019,
0.0243586414,
-0.5295747519,
0.1402567029,
-0.2033317983,
0.547899127,
-0.0729839429,
0.8117828369,
0.6463785172,
-0.6699674129,
0.5863859653,
-0.1155346632,
-0.0884048939,
0.4486662447,
-0.4808475971,
0.2779282928,
-0.260534972,
0.0640200227,
-0.6622885466,
-0.2792254686,
0.2624627054,
-0.248291567,
0.3481870294,
-0.0826411992,
-0.6283994317,
-0.168781206,
-0.2314151675,
0.0675707906,
0.4337424934,
-0.3653018475,
0.7465967536,
0.0233894605,
-0.1205079332,
-0.2919398248,
-0.2933550775,
-0.0406650677,
-0.3975923657,
-0.6102023125,
0.2150442898,
-0.0592628717,
-0.3069065511,
0.0946694836,
-0.1582148373,
0.0870649293,
0.1332667619,
0.1825046539,
0.0076177469,
-0.3141306639,
0.3764821887,
0.2307379246,
-0.0805771723,
-0.1965957433,
-0.3316706419,
0.5730637908,
-0.4052125514,
-0.4999221265,
-0.0496441387,
0.1497168839,
0.4474041164,
-0.4521791041,
0.6013545394,
0.5903983712,
-0.2590782344,
-0.6112698913,
-0.5861129761,
-0.574406147,
-0.5159435272,
0.3831493855,
-0.5941429734,
-0.9044984579,
0.5585573316,
-0.3593315482,
-0.1500337273,
0.170359835,
0.8988066316,
0.1956711113,
1.0547937155,
0.4265339375,
-0.0689862296,
0.4469999671,
-0.1770923883,
0.1563631892,
-0.5911229849,
0.030097438,
-0.6291442513,
-0.16801171,
-0.6606087089,
-0.6292772889,
0.2383632064,
0.0903563425,
-0.3831130862,
0.1723621041,
-0.6707265973,
0.6535266042,
0.5179491639,
0.2283536345,
0.4171113372,
-0.0231297668,
0.0239306763,
0.3955208659,
-0.5110173821,
-0.7948128581,
0.9406098723,
0.4022997916,
1.0803922415,
0.0565279201,
0.6544561386,
0.0618590117,
0.0390403122,
-0.7879208326,
0.6176136732,
0.0001423196,
-0.7011429667,
-0.7429313064,
-0.3397787809,
-1.0576751232,
0.4360349476,
-0.0059188688,
-0.8199453354,
0.0009078187,
0.1000570804,
-0.2151935846,
0.1023258567,
-0.7833068967,
0.6457941532,
-0.2827112079,
-0.3498999774,
-0.313546598,
-0.3654099703,
0.1413577348,
-0.0242531672,
0.0603019036,
-0.3836833239,
-0.1426290125,
0.2698843181,
-0.4829880297,
0.8550917506,
-0.2957241237,
-0.1238833144,
0.331073314,
-0.1043980718,
0.8997942805,
0.0997028872,
-0.2256255448,
-0.1910686642,
-0.0167236067,
-0.4493338168,
-0.6489564776,
0.7237722278,
-0.9300194383,
-0.9022066593,
-0.00436205,
-0.8515046239,
-0.5879701376,
0.149061203,
-0.0890684724,
0.2351416498,
0.0202247053,
0.2131582201,
0.5411336422,
-0.0417613164,
0.4127806723,
0.6036548615,
-0.0178775452,
-0.1006061733,
0.8462558985,
0.2223762125,
0.3520470858,
0.1727785617,
0.0314268544,
-0.2368893027,
-0.7050469518,
-0.3199127913,
0.2816600502,
-0.7242077589,
-0.3148017228,
-0.2819027007,
-0.2790739536,
-0.3721500933,
-0.0901484862,
-0.2947490811,
-0.0683040246,
-0.3299873471,
-0.040613018,
0.4034573138,
0.4755208194,
0.0631698966,
0.4361616671,
-0.5876368284,
0.4885246456,
0.3058643937,
0.3458347619,
-0.1111375466,
-0.3219258487,
-0.4117235243,
0.1313479692,
-0.3601369262,
-0.7745039463,
0.2878289521,
0.1662044525,
0.8323290944,
0.2949387729,
0.0652581081,
0.6283948421,
-0.2758769095,
0.4246025681,
-0.4499013126,
-0.8708773255,
0.6107238531,
-0.6258683205,
0.2899571657,
0.3227013946,
0.1544187367,
0.1992606372,
-0.8176742196,
-0.3905610144,
-0.6656906009,
0.9141479731,
0.2511991858,
0.037723396,
0.2813618779,
0.4733945131,
-0.0452653691,
0.2233552486,
-0.4367316067,
0.0669023693,
-0.1696790159,
-0.1093146652,
-0.3387068212,
0.1422733963,
-0.0786975324,
-0.3614542484,
0.6776934862,
-0.6171290278,
0.1363262534,
0.0034188156,
-0.0391811803,
-0.1546620876,
0.4626489878,
0.7030050755,
0.7307416201,
-0.2529507875,
0.1514907181,
0.2883024216,
-0.1683107913,
0.3404126763,
0.2030945867,
0.0133133614,
-0.2462155074,
0.3400430679,
0.9211496711,
-0.2967465818,
-0.6331292391,
0.0073096892,
0.0662987083,
-0.2381059825,
0.0277331993,
0.5384690166,
0.3737352788,
0.6996737123,
0.1871454865,
-0.1610111296,
-0.0976788476,
-0.681050539,
-0.0387902036,
0.7024233341,
-0.1188709587,
-0.1266258061,
0.367330879,
0.0039612879,
-0.2716567516,
0.4687076807,
-0.3767563105,
-0.1405916661,
0.8466228247,
0.5666532516,
0.691542089,
-0.2543914914,
0.2036147416,
-0.0048408052,
0.6227429509,
-0.1142056733,
0.3198190928,
0.0872108936,
-0.7730778456,
-0.6524822116,
-0.5250846148,
-0.4912067652,
0.2910987437,
-0.2942657471,
0.3156337738,
-0.4151389897,
-0.3061478436,
-0.0338567235,
0.2924915552,
-0.7365642786,
0.1018291935,
-0.0371045992,
0.6544495225,
-0.5527937412,
1.0736840963,
0.8511399627,
-0.414331466,
-1.0851173401,
-0.0342776701,
-0.2586664259,
-0.7140369415,
0.3889477849,
0.0531850457,
-0.2541097999,
0.0982650965,
-0.615496099,
-0.7726708651,
1.0586167574,
0.7474621534,
-0.4752183259,
-0.293168813,
0.2306918353,
0.8220694661,
-0.3571565747,
0.3983765543,
0.6321723461,
0.76620543,
0.0624137372,
-0.9304772019,
0.2815629542,
-0.0115212528,
-0.0071468255,
0.2448239326,
-0.6233073473,
0.9435207248,
-0.1547240764,
0.0813993067,
-0.021647349,
0.3923020959,
0.4023092687,
0.2020787746,
0.375977397,
0.2179289013,
0.8911337852,
-0.2227469981,
0.8229851127,
-0.3409484029,
0.142436713,
0.9513568878,
-0.2282507122,
0.4579269588,
0.3790616691,
0.1403277367,
0.2571045458,
0.6000733972,
-0.0605760291,
0.4590930641,
0.4213852882,
0.0336209461,
-0.6902253628,
-0.1414626986,
-0.2384855449,
0.3939723372,
0.525508225,
-0.0747600719,
-0.3695654869,
0.0637542382,
-0.1036197916,
-0.0357906073,
-0.507833004,
0.835078299,
0.1121205911,
-0.7456284165,
0.7107462287,
0.0829550996,
0.4336151481,
-0.6298806667,
-0.0186004508,
-0.2539620399,
0.3881116509,
-0.1620305479,
-0.4451259375,
0.28526932,
-0.1336907744,
-0.0713708401,
-0.1288771182,
1.0015345812,
-0.3545269668,
-0.2644954622,
0.3688123524,
0.8488335609,
0.2427438647,
-0.4695897698,
-0.4710129499,
-0.0254145581,
-0.1856544465,
-0.3512264788,
0.4319367409,
0.7294978499,
-0.3569116592,
0.8135294318,
0.6054390669,
0.4404783249,
-0.1557342559,
0.0538067669,
1.0981116295,
-0.7767110467,
-0.2339117825,
-0.8866094351,
0.3067431152,
0.1177849472,
0.0784661025,
0.6311910152,
0.3129802048,
0.6982280612,
-0.202699393,
0.6950845718,
0.2633816898,
0.4960224628,
-0.6269592643,
0.4592313766,
-0.541059196,
0.2932673991,
-0.1390507519,
-0.9621481895,
-0.0923451036,
0.3990454972,
-0.3504544497,
0.2536073327,
0.6296653152,
1.2055613995,
-0.0193720367,
-0.3218037188,
0.552556932,
0.1443541348,
0.5966511369,
0.5502376556,
1.0235881805,
0.1406524032,
0.6579614878,
0.013035506,
-0.0292627253,
-0.2377045453,
-0.5908442736,
-1.3137767315,
-0.3067276776,
-0.0065825051,
-0.0006809439,
0.246021539,
0.9358168244,
0.820871532,
-0.748039484,
-0.1600592732,
-0.0021174641,
0.3210842311,
-0.2430141419,
-0.1778948605,
0.1529661268,
-0.7996507287,
-0.7049337029,
0.6857779026,
0.1945092082,
-0.0022812486,
-0.3227938414,
-0.3365875185,
0.0944567397,
0.4199645817,
0.534894228,
-0.00696699,
-0.9134343863,
-0.3959546089,
0.0076234341,
-0.1685257256,
-0.0111476248,
0.6143656969,
-0.622001946,
0.1637261659,
0.4242468774,
0.4949806333,
0.4668551981,
0.300334841,
0.3993318975,
-0.5681089759,
0.1233058721,
0.3244385421,
0.1661065519,
0.0605910458,
-0.3759763539,
0.4582154751,
-0.0636829659,
-0.7185674906,
-0.6431357861,
0.2020805478,
-0.8390842676,
-0.5373443365,
1.1748254299,
0.0567947887,
-0.0116164293,
-0.2311469316,
-0.6180037856,
0.3341173232,
-0.5911231041,
0.551833272,
0.6895077229,
-0.463486135,
-0.2027349025,
-0.5427165627,
0.6436243057,
0.2213932127,
-1.2080070972,
-0.0154340267,
0.6199812293,
0.0669709221,
0.0472488366,
0.6010584235,
0.2155639231,
0.0255376026,
-0.0318966135,
-0.0382257476,
-0.4805387855,
-0.5787585378,
-0.1233834848,
0.2618475556,
0.5559325814,
0.0390064195
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19936v1
|
SLFNet: Generating Semantic Logic Forms from Natural Language Using Semantic Probability Graphs
| 2024-03-29T02:42:39 | 2024-03-29T02:42:39 |
Hao Wu, Fan Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Building natural language interfaces typically uses a semantic parser to
parse the user's natural language and convert it into structured
\textbf{S}emantic \textbf{L}ogic \textbf{F}orms (SLFs). The mainstream approach
is to adopt a sequence-to-sequence framework, which requires that natural
language commands and SLFs must be represented serially. Since a single natural
language may have multiple SLFs or multiple natural language commands may have
the same SLF, training a sequence-to-sequence model is sensitive to the choice
among them, a phenomenon recorded as "order matters". To solve this problem, we
propose a novel neural network, SLFNet, which firstly incorporates dependent
syntactic information as prior knowledge and can capture the long-range
interactions between contextual information and words. Secondly construct
semantic probability graphs to obtain local dependencies between predictor
variables. Finally we propose the Multi-Head SLF Attention mechanism to
synthesize SLFs from natural language commands based on Sequence-to-Slots.
Experiments show that SLFNet achieves state-of-the-art performance on the
ChineseQCI-TS and Okapi datasets, and competitive performance on the ATIS
dataset.
|
[
-0.1473150402,
-0.7658888102,
0.6044023633,
0.0385836512,
0.077737093,
-0.2679639161,
-0.0124472287,
-0.4342105687,
0.3096005917,
0.7160134912,
-0.7075200677,
-0.4022490978,
-0.4877032936,
0.039670825,
-0.4473724365,
0.9001103044,
0.2378966212,
0.0496442467,
-0.1934445202,
-0.2119828314,
-0.1304204613,
-0.4700623751,
-0.8104813099,
-0.4142074883,
0.6297638416,
0.0152614489,
0.8288485408,
0.5565672517,
0.3865121007,
0.3961165547,
0.0624145456,
0.0906868279,
-0.1330664307,
0.0929440185,
-0.2373688519,
-0.3217578828,
-0.210762158,
-0.2522817254,
0.7143888474,
0.9050264359,
0.0648357719,
0.1945162266,
-0.3122905493,
0.7976826429,
-0.6064286828,
0.386115253,
-0.5598882437,
0.4616102278,
-0.1599234492,
-0.2343719751,
-0.5380470753,
-0.1356637031,
0.3966441453,
-0.5845246911,
0.0176721849,
0.0151316067,
0.7088341117,
0.1554259658,
-0.4081325829,
-0.0366714969,
-0.4858039916,
0.5024635792,
-0.9547165632,
0.5110451579,
0.0122617753,
0.2766811848,
-0.6276146173,
-1.0813093185,
-0.4019362628,
-0.1148973554,
-0.2387197316,
0.0391271897,
0.1361466795,
0.2100881636,
0.3054881692,
-0.1263795644,
-0.7005733848,
-0.2040515393,
-0.2577851415,
-0.1477222592,
0.7743237615,
0.1859012693,
0.2499707341,
-0.2723951936,
-0.4828110635,
0.0374699943,
-0.5341509581,
0.1701678187,
0.2504441142,
0.5601348877,
0.3508302867,
0.6437411904,
-0.5175303817,
1.1695221663,
-0.1157230586,
-0.3029313982,
0.3903472424,
-0.3776434064,
-0.4335834682,
0.445245415,
1.0074298382,
0.0906129181,
0.2840014994,
-0.2413825542,
-0.2031858712,
0.0757101774,
0.2151498497,
-0.6453728676,
0.0377052724,
0.1606486887,
-0.4078450799,
-0.3655641973,
0.2488632798,
-0.2681798339,
-0.389701128,
-0.6503028274,
0.3713486493,
-0.5133823752,
-0.1807778031,
0.3783676028,
-0.0952737555,
0.291370362,
0.0113728689,
-0.6273372173,
0.5175751448,
0.6501665711,
0.5633836389,
-0.269377619,
-0.5410231352,
-0.7331944704,
0.223833859,
-0.1706445068,
0.7031270266,
-0.206909731,
0.1855837554,
-0.0912762061,
-0.2086574137,
-0.1938433349,
-0.2579565942,
0.3423863053,
-0.6096419096,
0.1179982722,
0.1730682552,
-0.6270373464,
-0.026948249,
-0.0955877006,
-0.7184147239,
0.9334239364,
-0.0428495333,
-0.9390955567,
0.2756663859,
-0.7754497528,
-1.0209805965,
0.1391178519,
-0.4354313314,
-0.0525300168,
0.0393315293,
-0.1300346404,
0.6325865388,
-0.1125796735,
0.5596800447,
-0.4545505643,
0.0337182283,
0.4077917933,
-0.1605917066,
0.7509773374,
0.2604392171,
-0.346839577,
0.421987623,
-0.9372417927,
0.2149400413,
0.223821491,
-0.1110871062,
-0.2293428183,
0.3463184536,
-0.1817506701,
0.7529317141,
0.0067924606,
-0.4483989775,
-0.353069067,
-0.9840935469,
0.8812640905,
0.6455141306,
-0.0902043134,
0.6843798161,
-0.1709432155,
0.0894207433,
0.1053892076,
0.0874950886,
0.0385785699,
-0.5813818574,
-0.7618137002,
0.3348009586,
-0.0318855308,
0.6626579165,
-0.7236433625,
0.6063923836,
-0.3737425506,
-0.1006182432,
-0.156484589,
0.0428053588,
0.0801961198,
0.6778574586,
-0.0088011501,
-0.2712360322,
-0.5705773234,
-0.8001717329,
-0.1924988329,
-0.0568414666,
0.179963991,
0.0793819427,
0.2982372642,
0.074981831,
1.3867644072,
-0.6265106797,
-0.3387649655,
-0.3681252599,
-0.0285265073,
0.4334610701,
0.1901718229,
0.3419326842,
-0.9107031226,
-0.0647091866,
0.0070189331,
-0.7032113075,
0.129035145,
-0.0967297107,
-0.6460297108,
0.3545805514,
0.5477510095,
-0.7520067096,
0.5493888855,
0.0817081556,
-0.4393367171,
0.3012900054,
-0.0821655765,
-0.2568969727,
-1.0159214735,
0.0217789095,
-0.0178873371,
-0.2403158545,
-0.8251857758,
-0.015785832,
-0.2541361451,
-0.302424252,
-0.7055482864,
0.6056826115,
-0.0926041231,
-0.3334488869,
-0.0080817593,
0.2756467462,
0.0451401584,
0.7562684417,
0.3310958743,
0.1432879567,
0.3696348369,
-0.5855292082,
0.4256021678,
0.0758112967,
-0.2498503029,
0.1981160045,
-0.5410215259,
-0.061745517,
-0.2788113654,
0.1138418168,
-0.9415820241,
-0.183940351,
0.3295555115,
-0.4671266973,
0.0788358375,
0.1266254485,
-0.5119271278,
-0.3909602463,
0.0269788876,
0.1875088662,
0.0863792971,
-0.1288561076,
0.8027106524,
0.4001040459,
0.0004636331,
-0.5376383662,
-0.9176341891,
-0.0249008071,
0.1077065691,
-1.062306881,
0.2929791212,
0.0814273506,
-0.147203058,
0.0403621048,
-0.0797684565,
-0.0637440383,
0.079868488,
0.2517548203,
0.2004524022,
-0.3913920522,
0.2882009447,
-0.0853502601,
-0.1776248962,
0.3894716501,
-1.052793622,
0.4027637541,
-0.2563312948,
-0.3559182286,
-0.1413682699,
0.4865750372,
0.3811452389,
-0.4231829047,
0.6592332721,
0.6052583456,
-0.6323291063,
-0.3723268807,
-0.2493084222,
-0.171492219,
-0.4408404231,
0.371752888,
-0.2972599566,
-0.9802394509,
0.3030221462,
0.153131023,
0.0584396496,
0.3760205209,
0.3025064468,
0.1735977978,
1.1379727125,
0.3341096938,
-0.0136352917,
0.5541133285,
-0.0737991333,
0.4723140001,
-0.0090652639,
0.0156793911,
-0.2369736582,
-0.3167856634,
-0.4179175496,
-0.1330134273,
0.2608883977,
0.0553297922,
-0.5229582191,
0.3677274883,
-0.4589165449,
0.3171320558,
0.6643215418,
0.1448441446,
0.1683787107,
0.2863875628,
-0.3047133684,
0.1328551173,
-0.950328052,
-0.2002452463,
0.7344216108,
0.0430345237,
0.5723680258,
0.0342612304,
0.8869223595,
0.2092963904,
-0.0072738109,
-0.8815436363,
0.7837592363,
-0.3103298247,
-0.2149379849,
-0.5580254197,
-0.6341558099,
-0.903827548,
-0.0181983337,
-0.1971405298,
-0.8509130478,
-0.1528432816,
-0.0781567618,
-0.4136024117,
0.0714611709,
-0.826177001,
0.9585935473,
-0.401559025,
-0.2771345377,
0.1642024368,
-1.1733058691,
0.3139515817,
0.3807953298,
0.1959996223,
-0.0671899021,
0.3379864395,
0.7266820073,
-0.6755535603,
0.8290256858,
-0.0307412334,
0.0411967933,
0.5051372647,
0.0235138182,
0.3561078012,
0.1794914454,
-0.0929923058,
-0.1520349979,
-0.1922122687,
-0.2034085095,
-0.8073689342,
0.6680591106,
-0.7457614541,
-0.3639928102,
-0.4643715918,
-0.4511565566,
-0.2564925253,
0.609341085,
0.3301516473,
0.8267019987,
0.0288328808,
-0.4028559327,
0.6513255835,
0.0978795141,
0.4736197591,
-0.0192283243,
-0.2606917918,
-0.5376836658,
1.0454173088,
0.2152961642,
0.3346098661,
0.8402563334,
0.3160901368,
-0.2945485711,
-0.2091726512,
-0.3317817748,
0.115482688,
-0.9384413958,
-0.2919602692,
-0.6428486705,
-0.7996452451,
-0.7233095765,
-0.0743768066,
-0.1719066799,
-0.625551939,
-0.1483606547,
-0.0890176222,
0.6305417418,
0.730774343,
0.266174823,
0.0195169691,
-0.6235449314,
0.273001641,
0.228033796,
0.4366785586,
0.0549692847,
-0.0835339352,
0.0205529742,
-0.0229541808,
-0.0258431025,
-0.8140787482,
0.3838177919,
0.3590924144,
0.6906225085,
0.286957562,
0.1724822968,
0.4589649141,
-0.651161015,
0.4401836693,
0.4591939151,
-0.8497005105,
0.7929525971,
-0.1744036078,
0.4762049317,
0.4004820585,
0.1588191986,
-0.557526052,
-0.4612776339,
-0.7657860518,
-1.0139712095,
1.1226267815,
0.2697867155,
-0.233523339,
-0.298419565,
0.2540084124,
-0.1732640713,
0.2939715087,
-0.7385765314,
-0.4151982665,
-0.3693752587,
-0.583425343,
0.1691700667,
0.2812048495,
0.0360964686,
-0.1417538077,
0.5194672942,
-0.4166484475,
0.4842101932,
0.2932169735,
-0.2525513768,
0.2779390514,
0.1704272628,
0.7003615499,
0.5599945784,
0.0038343049,
0.3984428048,
0.0116160866,
-0.258282572,
0.0459792167,
0.291018635,
-0.2308159322,
-0.0647270083,
0.2506689429,
1.1145508289,
0.2116418779,
-0.6604822874,
0.4642927647,
-0.059310019,
-0.1341349334,
-0.4181860685,
0.1743983924,
0.2778243423,
0.0866828114,
0.1009994224,
0.3179091513,
0.3852257729,
-0.1823542267,
0.5006584525,
0.1451198608,
-0.4897533059,
0.0036825682,
0.3762202561,
-0.0198807828,
-0.416680634,
0.4895010591,
-0.3111290038,
-0.4581571817,
0.6135876179,
0.6153562069,
0.7553757429,
0.2585552037,
0.3393800557,
0.3226050138,
-0.0331144556,
-0.0474613048,
0.2396638691,
-0.0779194385,
-0.8684075475,
-0.5200237632,
-0.774933517,
0.1492830515,
0.0165414456,
-0.4368566275,
0.3080406487,
-0.7381621003,
-0.3556638658,
0.1253160536,
-0.2825450003,
-0.6444970369,
0.1667997539,
0.408780843,
0.8413267732,
-0.6501410007,
0.6456536055,
0.9212216735,
-0.4141903818,
-0.8800286055,
-0.5299434066,
-0.1438292563,
-0.5359624624,
0.8603688478,
0.380848825,
-0.2207166404,
0.0380125567,
-0.4047275484,
-1.0438430309,
1.0585509539,
0.4287387729,
-0.1719373912,
-0.225715965,
0.5557070971,
0.340702951,
-0.5737585425,
0.2612933815,
0.5540628433,
0.2715448141,
0.1389044523,
-0.424608469,
0.1638138592,
-0.4723212123,
0.3463835418,
0.4930282235,
-0.3121900558,
0.5222275257,
-0.1503879875,
-0.246423915,
-0.0741464868,
1.0072811842,
0.2736984789,
0.1197667494,
0.5694377422,
0.5995086432,
0.4487074912,
-0.0106412219,
0.7652480006,
-0.247743085,
0.0499583222,
1.2929754257,
-0.5329936147,
0.8319680691,
0.5613222122,
0.0064393566,
0.4480590224,
0.4333258867,
0.346568048,
0.5475245118,
0.5590350032,
-0.1994088739,
-0.4268170595,
-0.178031221,
0.0620258525,
0.2787077725,
0.5156484246,
-0.4234929085,
-0.4390867651,
0.1857159734,
-0.2359220684,
0.0515177771,
-0.1765663773,
0.9067601562,
0.1778543144,
-0.7615460157,
0.2954378426,
0.0867254212,
0.4941927791,
-0.9030342102,
-0.035797894,
0.0645307377,
0.1735457182,
-0.2789636254,
-0.920725584,
0.3153124452,
-0.5426838994,
-0.2984344661,
-0.2933620512,
1.1148079634,
-0.4190428853,
-0.6087742448,
0.5604102015,
0.3367285728,
-0.1259581894,
0.2979191542,
-0.8372526169,
-0.3482707441,
-0.3009027243,
-0.3089157939,
0.3916790187,
0.4490027726,
-0.293579936,
0.4905213416,
0.5999480486,
-0.0074692066,
0.3123298585,
0.4522410929,
0.5050759912,
-0.5329155922,
-0.6958435178,
-0.6301929355,
0.3853495121,
-0.1460153908,
-0.430860877,
0.1278387159,
0.14200674,
0.9855730534,
-0.0015482123,
0.7070817351,
-0.3145674765,
0.0559186786,
-0.6944922209,
0.7783734798,
-0.3627331555,
-0.221888274,
-0.2009917945,
-0.4602888823,
-0.4471228421,
0.7031889558,
-0.1413201243,
-0.1198509485,
0.6523725986,
0.8131746054,
0.0101974439,
0.2473692745,
0.1945957541,
0.0772562101,
0.0261671785,
0.9444513321,
0.5867752433,
-0.4152766764,
0.5501294136,
-0.3861364126,
-0.0311152861,
0.1837457269,
-1.0378323793,
-0.8003435731,
-0.642875433,
-0.2689695656,
-0.4384121597,
0.0526918247,
1.1866430044,
0.6580222249,
-0.9336899519,
-0.4323627353,
-0.561973989,
0.3726860583,
-0.303257823,
-0.2954272032,
0.3880538046,
-0.6767230034,
-0.1682092994,
0.219726935,
0.4085430205,
-0.0916446,
-0.1075505465,
-0.1207220182,
-0.5981135964,
-0.1431632042,
0.9223943353,
0.15085724,
-0.8475924134,
-0.3013021052,
0.246877268,
-0.3398459256,
-0.0013417461,
0.7954742908,
-0.9365007877,
0.1971814483,
0.9028024077,
1.007021904,
0.2219623625,
-0.5925869942,
0.8129989505,
-0.8359007835,
0.0466185734,
0.1046981514,
0.4956293404,
0.120029822,
-0.4458284676,
0.4339525104,
0.4386175275,
-0.1666972488,
-0.3210879862,
0.450817287,
-0.9815707207,
-0.2541781962,
1.103640914,
0.0150215514,
-0.61383003,
-0.0803804845,
-0.0973749161,
0.3931873143,
-0.4360325933,
0.0712961406,
0.6056863666,
-0.3987856209,
0.1475463957,
-0.4655589759,
0.520847261,
0.4948931336,
-0.7938486338,
-0.1829612255,
0.3197252452,
0.1417101771,
0.3483519256,
0.6478725076,
-0.0185670014,
0.2880792618,
-0.3323438168,
-0.1911360919,
-0.0266841035,
-0.3247020841,
-0.1625258625,
0.227323845,
-0.0728767663,
0.245875299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19930v1
|
Are LLMs Effective Backbones for Fine-tuning? An Experimental Investigation of Supervised LLMs on Chinese Short Text Matching
| 2024-03-29T02:36:54 | 2024-03-29T02:36:54 |
Shulin Liu, Chengcheng Xu, Hao Liu, Tinghao Yu, Tao Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recent success of Large Language Models (LLMs) has garnered significant
attention in both academia and industry. Prior research on LLMs has primarily
focused on enhancing or leveraging their generalization capabilities in zero-
and few-shot settings. However, there has been limited investigation into
effectively fine-tuning LLMs for a specific natural language understanding task
in supervised settings. In this study, we conduct an experimental analysis by
fine-tuning LLMs for the task of Chinese short text matching. We explore
various factors that influence performance when fine-tuning LLMs, including
task modeling methods, prompt formats, and output formats.
|
[
-0.2362363189,
-0.8246399164,
0.7531303167,
0.2187807709,
-0.6675071716,
-0.2023664713,
-0.6231986284,
-0.7244278789,
-0.0724638477,
0.5657405257,
-0.5178861022,
-0.6964254379,
-0.4348848164,
0.4860839844,
-0.3526229858,
0.9653673172,
0.0060981559,
0.122836411,
-0.0258638635,
-0.2355387211,
-0.5646327734,
-0.2887857258,
-1.0168914795,
-0.5954068899,
0.7186790109,
0.6020420194,
0.7128793001,
1.1474423409,
0.60421592,
0.2465640455,
-0.3622592986,
0.424649626,
-0.7541424036,
-0.1235091761,
-0.2914846838,
-0.7078568935,
-0.5327800512,
-0.0882036388,
0.832290411,
0.7631129622,
0.2442106605,
0.1796894968,
0.5590338707,
0.6305558681,
-0.4913660884,
-0.0555919819,
-0.7599487901,
-0.0313730761,
-0.5342721939,
-0.3327092528,
-0.3306311965,
-0.1254531741,
-0.0006078901,
-0.6130487323,
0.5142033696,
0.3138308525,
0.9043012261,
0.1600486934,
-0.4383533597,
-0.323900938,
-0.6115476489,
0.8163770437,
-0.9271117449,
0.0752371177,
0.2881779671,
0.1517976075,
-0.3423089683,
-0.5235827565,
-0.3890571892,
-0.1690154374,
-0.3919730186,
-0.0053322292,
0.2955990732,
0.5481384993,
0.3556424081,
0.7371639013,
-0.6231017113,
0.8824251294,
-0.1597676426,
-0.1628210545,
0.605927527,
0.6319795847,
0.2925522923,
-0.2127025574,
0.0133167049,
0.090525724,
-0.619374454,
0.2695716023,
0.3546961844,
0.7594796419,
-0.1531083137,
0.6617259979,
-0.5523765087,
1.0994012356,
-0.0246460177,
-0.2128512561,
-0.2438497245,
-0.8000608683,
-0.4976102412,
-0.0818541124,
0.6024258137,
0.4683121741,
0.4924452603,
-0.1888194233,
-0.4851399362,
-0.1132717654,
-0.1192733124,
-0.8718490601,
-0.3561739028,
-0.0464274436,
-0.6777667403,
-0.2516008914,
-0.0724544227,
-0.2474478632,
-0.3795931041,
-0.5601143837,
0.4188191891,
-0.2450454235,
0.1526398063,
0.3072088659,
-0.1417528689,
0.5270121694,
0.3766493499,
-1.0921851397,
0.2854292691,
0.8903325796,
0.973233819,
-0.5654921532,
-0.2266454697,
-0.7461634278,
-0.0757452995,
-0.4302500784,
0.6654421687,
-0.3408825397,
-0.3757017553,
0.0837153792,
0.1927989572,
-0.1582419127,
-0.596788764,
0.760633409,
-0.5079649091,
0.0277846958,
-0.3694439828,
-0.738345027,
0.146030888,
0.3029592931,
-0.4888222218,
0.7384954691,
-0.2686503828,
-0.5254787803,
0.4379079044,
-0.4257139564,
-0.5937133431,
-0.0168145839,
0.0562407002,
-0.3440625072,
0.1563066691,
0.2912074327,
0.7702335715,
-0.2070566714,
-0.0591001138,
-0.3514127433,
-0.9887518883,
0.0558065996,
-0.3235874176,
0.5352310538,
0.0673763826,
-0.0416249372,
0.3094053566,
-0.6838464141,
-0.1386729777,
0.0427269377,
-0.4488161504,
-0.4864087403,
0.0219011623,
0.0982143879,
-0.1033418626,
0.3445882201,
-0.3399680257,
0.240254581,
-0.7034547329,
0.4338286221,
0.7041975856,
-0.1001101136,
0.6381083131,
-0.4379916191,
0.2699237466,
-0.1923872977,
-0.0810689777,
-0.3907500505,
-0.1753338277,
-0.8957930803,
-0.2218291759,
0.4289167225,
0.4500837028,
-0.5788705349,
0.1828333437,
-0.0119698308,
-0.4294703305,
-0.3769055903,
0.5258477926,
0.5113164783,
0.2971719801,
0.2481554896,
-0.2120135278,
-0.3013279438,
-1.034458518,
-0.5676245689,
0.2303443849,
-0.2975245416,
0.5550829768,
0.1948119402,
-0.1106953621,
0.8134723306,
-0.5284340978,
-0.6019340754,
-0.3577308357,
0.0925581902,
0.524356842,
0.3119416237,
0.7367708087,
-0.4834965765,
-0.7019598484,
0.0155820874,
-0.432204932,
-0.2227834761,
-0.173133716,
0.0245252866,
0.1168154478,
0.6616328359,
-0.3981074691,
0.104355976,
0.5965077281,
-0.1092764884,
0.5888237953,
-0.354913801,
0.1459306479,
-1.0880733728,
-0.117372565,
0.350924015,
-0.2862212658,
-0.6926100254,
0.1568720043,
0.2533553839,
0.1616918445,
-0.5714134574,
0.5264584422,
-0.6284396648,
-0.0770493895,
-0.7020903826,
0.5575460196,
-0.0351806954,
0.41864869,
-0.1095063761,
0.8507882953,
0.5953482389,
-0.9301759601,
0.1752838641,
-0.1212437898,
-0.4834342003,
0.4502983987,
-0.8712579012,
0.0435849316,
-0.0382765755,
-0.0389168374,
-1.0545015335,
-0.3558386862,
0.0124866003,
-0.0579258315,
0.2622410655,
-0.0866431966,
-0.6728916168,
-0.116396375,
-0.3640630245,
0.3284615278,
0.382340759,
-0.5484269857,
0.2430585325,
-0.2030948699,
0.0757794753,
-0.2942521274,
-0.5455709696,
0.1351228654,
-0.351072073,
-0.4125207365,
0.605050683,
-0.0816277713,
-0.1863968074,
-0.4095254838,
-0.0488630421,
-0.034284994,
0.4367701411,
-0.0818037242,
0.0091155795,
-0.4144869447,
0.1369359195,
0.0608137958,
0.1195921227,
-0.1559605002,
-0.0234924294,
0.3467496037,
0.0218703877,
-0.2711344063,
-0.6548954844,
-0.1319479793,
0.2684676647,
-0.0956002325,
0.6116430759,
0.4787875414,
-0.3717470467,
-0.4175904989,
-0.4424012601,
-0.2891656458,
-0.5635908842,
0.4649319947,
-0.352119714,
-1.1828221083,
0.6377722025,
-0.0237508044,
0.0520881563,
0.2948176265,
0.4478217363,
-0.2862476408,
1.0159697533,
0.9777625799,
-0.4112307429,
0.5724195242,
0.2257112265,
-0.0607426763,
-0.7647858262,
0.2549243271,
-0.6917755604,
-0.5102549195,
-0.803567946,
-0.2625547051,
0.1202881932,
0.3551493883,
0.0022997896,
0.3605296016,
-0.3574542701,
0.7752092481,
0.4589790106,
0.1551656872,
0.580006361,
-0.3991852701,
0.0755285621,
0.0045883567,
-0.54448843,
-0.6314572692,
0.7560491562,
0.4086058736,
0.9222350121,
-0.0009796241,
0.3928013742,
0.0349964499,
-0.0508458093,
-0.8385171294,
0.6383504272,
-0.55018574,
-0.2206781805,
-0.5186040998,
-0.1116836891,
-1.0976234674,
0.254519552,
-0.2059004307,
-0.7390342951,
-0.2789893746,
0.2505790591,
-0.3405393064,
0.0965145454,
-0.387168467,
0.7874574661,
-0.3471413553,
-0.1878456473,
-0.2609623373,
-0.4492735863,
0.4925007224,
-0.1964970082,
-0.1549872011,
-0.165129438,
0.0633735359,
0.6408506632,
0.0317892767,
0.9807377458,
0.2327573299,
-0.197876513,
-0.0469467044,
-0.1435066462,
0.5524439216,
0.1991132498,
-0.1055210903,
0.0420425646,
-0.0502521396,
-0.3447408974,
-0.5307218432,
0.8216171265,
-0.6143568158,
-0.9340696335,
-0.0085838679,
-0.6734189391,
-0.152907446,
0.4135440588,
0.2030446827,
0.2361473441,
-0.168098107,
0.522274971,
0.8774383068,
-0.2022737563,
0.5475534201,
0.7125244737,
-0.1458994001,
0.1549531966,
0.6473454833,
0.1069616824,
0.344869405,
0.5281408429,
0.1616340876,
-0.04255189,
-1.0493941307,
-0.4549944103,
0.2573832273,
-0.464397341,
-0.0854274035,
-0.3357678056,
-0.2390424907,
-0.2419294417,
-0.113109678,
-0.2623952925,
-0.0848083869,
-0.8346115947,
0.0086538885,
0.2001305073,
0.617926836,
0.3282083571,
0.5101779103,
-0.8022138476,
0.4850607216,
0.242819041,
0.6404744983,
-0.1580964476,
-0.7337078452,
-0.6374917626,
0.1399684548,
-0.1266162395,
-0.5265176296,
0.0048701754,
0.3093960285,
0.6150595546,
0.5005789995,
0.0376402102,
0.9163517356,
-0.425489217,
1.0253155231,
-0.3443113565,
-0.9257779717,
0.5686243176,
-0.5148814321,
0.4810357094,
0.4958768785,
0.0592474416,
-0.4099456966,
-0.5601429939,
0.0461940169,
-0.5695443153,
0.7236702442,
0.202930674,
0.2266439945,
0.2384523898,
0.7402262092,
-0.0535752513,
-0.0219640918,
-0.5669587851,
-0.2251130641,
0.3961071372,
-0.0823266581,
-0.5137767196,
-0.2891120017,
0.0825926811,
-0.0852627978,
0.3833816648,
-0.310796082,
-0.2410912663,
-0.0069545251,
-0.144674629,
-0.0792544857,
0.2579099834,
0.8214437962,
0.5489418507,
-0.1318361163,
-0.11217013,
0.6047250628,
-0.2382449061,
-0.2797542214,
-0.0149798784,
-0.1459218264,
0.0185475759,
0.4874307811,
0.8640885353,
0.2165659368,
-0.6049636602,
0.2513387799,
-0.054068245,
-0.1989586353,
0.0263966899,
0.4627549946,
0.1247806549,
0.3937141895,
0.2584038973,
-0.3561291099,
0.136105299,
-0.492041707,
0.011177321,
0.8091924787,
-0.2617770135,
-0.170398891,
0.6921259165,
0.1559257209,
-0.4293974042,
0.6223776937,
0.0826319456,
-0.3076655865,
0.7325798273,
0.4935737252,
0.6182214022,
0.1915633231,
-0.2802428305,
0.163741231,
0.3518437445,
-0.3792043924,
-0.1354430467,
-0.1119444594,
-0.7579214573,
-0.6132162809,
-0.6623449326,
-0.6876756549,
0.143345803,
-0.7230371237,
0.6680010557,
-0.1358942538,
-0.0510792471,
-0.1639416963,
0.2585805953,
-0.7071228027,
0.3292824924,
0.2371895015,
1.0980815887,
-0.7788313031,
1.1363391876,
0.5992990732,
-0.1086858287,
-0.8608142734,
0.1143373027,
-0.2185551375,
-0.6759039164,
0.5187434554,
0.2890995145,
-0.1767371744,
-0.0407933742,
-0.5408796668,
-0.7563433051,
1.262791872,
0.2997930348,
-0.7393231988,
-0.0765617192,
0.4140253961,
0.8845633268,
-0.2124918848,
0.0322511382,
0.867000699,
0.2832240164,
-0.2860638499,
-1.3713543415,
-0.0682529956,
0.0869752169,
0.1964091808,
0.0493429303,
-0.8651791215,
0.945290029,
-0.1037808135,
-0.3006045222,
0.4537770152,
0.7786163092,
0.2965495586,
0.4242335856,
0.451055795,
0.2807104588,
0.6886485219,
-0.0866492987,
0.69680053,
-0.383433491,
0.3062232435,
1.1236083508,
-0.3015294969,
0.7104773521,
0.4307468534,
0.0822644085,
0.1828475147,
0.8445162773,
-0.0963165537,
0.4022087455,
0.3766134381,
0.2111802995,
-0.3967905343,
-0.1917524189,
-0.1535376757,
0.4075720012,
0.3633315861,
-0.4778972268,
-0.0843634382,
0.0431594215,
-0.2068431675,
0.2905076146,
-0.5681164265,
0.8666449785,
0.2052876204,
-0.6511227489,
0.4339356422,
0.3627172112,
1.0791569948,
-0.4759868979,
0.1222622991,
-0.3639389873,
0.2431465387,
-0.2070500255,
-0.9634366632,
0.2135506868,
-0.0934373736,
-0.2478962392,
-0.169517085,
1.0258431435,
-0.4153696895,
-0.1455021054,
0.3329025805,
0.3731840253,
0.0309727769,
-0.0919263363,
-0.4819159508,
0.0469366908,
-0.1560164839,
-0.3322319984,
0.648686409,
0.5320522189,
-0.0348920412,
0.6423249245,
0.5276380777,
0.0502692461,
-0.2585759461,
0.1194125861,
0.6850257516,
-0.7658509612,
-0.3762597144,
-1.1738753319,
0.2460395694,
-0.0279216319,
-0.2943359315,
1.1035054922,
0.6232982278,
0.985011518,
-0.0916377157,
0.5033612251,
0.579059422,
0.4433117509,
-0.7556542158,
0.6820358038,
-0.6715241671,
0.258361876,
-0.1822331101,
-0.9442617297,
-0.4673447907,
0.2069014162,
-0.1604431272,
-0.1114953905,
0.3560045958,
0.9655922651,
-0.0121888313,
-0.0727452561,
0.5667596459,
0.071498543,
0.3170263469,
0.5494375229,
0.5136740804,
-0.3456425965,
0.6370482445,
-0.2845773399,
0.0759508163,
-0.3337520361,
-1.0432780981,
-1.39308846,
-0.1553012282,
-0.0534378141,
-0.0267183725,
0.2234544307,
0.7472020388,
0.428566277,
-0.7467178702,
-0.3091634214,
-0.0236764662,
0.2157529891,
-0.2637052238,
-0.2276234478,
0.3525721431,
-0.5693361163,
-1.0805277824,
0.2950267494,
0.3008906841,
0.1020037159,
-0.1247176453,
-0.0681084692,
0.0527716763,
0.0725892782,
0.7093846202,
0.0999151021,
-0.8508573771,
-0.4662885964,
0.3186989725,
-0.5172284842,
-0.1044961587,
0.8018152118,
-0.5150724649,
0.2657315433,
0.5996085405,
0.6757698059,
0.3147946596,
0.2784226835,
0.6350089312,
-0.7636772394,
0.0069294199,
-0.0446019098,
0.3955341578,
0.2778803408,
-0.4085559547,
0.4128478765,
-0.017156519,
-0.8985530734,
-0.8314569592,
-0.0663890615,
-1.0940759182,
-0.2573037148,
1.2953197956,
0.1008636281,
0.1110864058,
-0.0626592115,
-0.3679386079,
0.3841213286,
0.0143275969,
0.6407877207,
0.7886304855,
-0.2357737124,
-0.2097225785,
-0.4886728227,
0.6339494586,
0.6013845205,
-0.4665393233,
-0.0086076343,
0.178737253,
0.2351253629,
-0.2659962177,
0.4468534291,
0.424636215,
0.1841105074,
-0.5606889725,
-0.5564905405,
0.0455358922,
-0.0262033194,
-0.4267423749,
-0.035554152,
0.5098703504,
-0.101601623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19928v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19928v2
|
DiJiang: Efficient Large Language Models through Compact Kernelization
| 2024-03-29T02:32:15 | 2024-04-01T09:17:01 |
Hanting Chen, Zhicheng Liu, Xutao Wang, Yuchuan Tian, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In an effort to reduce the computational load of Transformers, research on
linear attention has gained significant momentum. However, the improvement
strategies for attention mechanisms typically necessitate extensive retraining,
which is impractical for large language models with a vast array of parameters.
In this paper, we present DiJiang, a novel Frequency Domain Kernelization
approach that enables the transformation of a pre-trained vanilla Transformer
into a linear complexity model with little training costs. By employing a
weighted Quasi-Monte Carlo method for sampling, the proposed approach
theoretically offers superior approximation efficiency. To further reduce the
training computational complexity, our kernelization is based on Discrete
Cosine Transform (DCT) operations. Extensive experiments demonstrate that the
proposed method achieves comparable performance to the original Transformer,
but with significantly reduced training costs and much faster inference speeds.
Our DiJiang-7B achieves comparable performance with LLaMA2-7B on various
benchmark while requires only about 1/50 training cost. Code is available at
https://github.com/YuchuanTian/DiJiang.
|
[
-0.3744792938,
-0.7104972005,
0.4748513103,
0.4615427554,
-0.3580651879,
-0.0926530808,
-0.5901919007,
-0.1991658509,
-0.1323117167,
0.0831783116,
-0.3927018046,
-0.4005964696,
-0.6855872869,
-0.1180238128,
-0.6135188341,
0.6618608832,
0.2113696188,
-0.0923930109,
0.1163662001,
0.2242898643,
-0.2945489287,
-0.2903902233,
-0.6986292601,
-0.2524864972,
0.5067307353,
0.1643735468,
0.3715259135,
0.3803702295,
0.5707620978,
0.4141247869,
-0.1921711564,
-0.0634855926,
-0.7048141956,
-0.4558847249,
0.1143322885,
-0.3975016177,
-0.6113066077,
-0.0687120333,
0.5061780214,
0.8538404703,
-0.4099844694,
0.0867861211,
-0.007026603,
0.5462220907,
-0.4530717432,
0.2419848293,
-0.7900078297,
-0.0249330048,
-0.1357000321,
0.1691311747,
-0.7637448311,
-0.305614233,
0.23341389,
-0.9564222097,
0.2516177893,
-0.1400746852,
0.6245734096,
0.588825345,
-0.5297964215,
-0.1154887453,
-1.0349873304,
1.3549507856,
-0.5712204576,
0.4270307124,
0.2040574998,
0.6038205624,
-0.1519727409,
-1.1227329969,
-0.83917588,
-0.2669486701,
-0.337128073,
0.1676707119,
-0.4569334686,
0.0247904975,
0.3674577773,
0.382894367,
-0.3335475922,
-0.2268307358,
-0.2186889946,
0.1005987301,
0.532089293,
-0.0942769349,
0.0182575881,
0.1058722883,
-0.4850220978,
-0.361579597,
-0.4754846394,
0.0789456889,
-0.0234925635,
-0.0074113109,
-0.1406577379,
-0.0551857986,
-0.23989214,
0.7545821667,
0.4256571531,
-0.4013272822,
0.1542707384,
-0.0776910707,
-0.3467337787,
0.0741355643,
0.6755675673,
-0.0527343489,
0.1804888099,
-0.1544317454,
-0.309248656,
0.0670451745,
0.4202139676,
-0.8726801872,
-0.6501933336,
0.3839888275,
-0.4540933073,
-0.2748428285,
-0.1451664269,
-0.710231483,
0.095637247,
-0.4115090668,
0.4061362147,
-0.5289023519,
-0.3417250216,
0.1995131224,
0.2413910478,
0.2492569089,
0.6078243256,
-1.1864671707,
0.379935354,
0.7116991282,
0.5522403121,
-0.014922536,
0.1075918972,
-0.4878287315,
-0.1182603613,
-0.3754304349,
0.5694798827,
-0.4290875494,
-0.241695419,
-0.2291972488,
-0.2991131246,
-0.0382502824,
-0.5677176714,
0.635350585,
-0.8053221107,
-0.1593387872,
-0.1179975793,
-0.0247610603,
-0.2186238766,
0.2199673355,
-0.6727716923,
1.0723769665,
0.4434549809,
-0.6842569709,
0.1965625435,
-0.2233352959,
-0.4435954094,
0.0094267791,
-0.0208104383,
-0.4566879272,
0.0679785758,
0.2478655726,
0.4896929264,
-0.4591600001,
0.43657583,
-0.11891637,
-0.6934859157,
0.1124910489,
-0.4122648537,
0.713221252,
0.5147138834,
-0.3880304694,
-0.0693959966,
-1.1598031521,
-0.2861662805,
0.2077953964,
-0.2390777171,
-0.6949929595,
-0.0628148168,
0.2401570231,
0.0770880431,
0.2403856814,
-0.5009675622,
0.3988190293,
-0.5196868777,
0.4640564919,
0.6025294065,
-0.4849711955,
0.7356101871,
-0.0073133046,
0.2044379264,
0.250736028,
0.4454031885,
-0.08884684,
-0.1825849563,
-0.9646982551,
-0.6409161091,
0.3998303711,
0.188294217,
-1.040171504,
0.2867293358,
-0.4846610427,
-0.7603235841,
-0.4304008782,
-0.1137103289,
0.2580147088,
0.5024031401,
0.4624753892,
-0.0297848284,
-0.3625331223,
-0.8434183598,
0.3430522978,
0.0692467317,
-0.3163217008,
-0.0174473487,
0.1514514983,
-0.2951075435,
0.979065001,
-0.8231799603,
-0.376218617,
-0.182959944,
-0.0300964508,
0.6521168947,
0.2953371704,
0.8485762477,
-1.010717988,
-0.8427491784,
0.2806701958,
-0.4137404263,
-0.1398453265,
-0.0897887796,
0.0817205831,
-0.0472927392,
0.3896714151,
-0.4513968825,
0.1497390419,
0.8147161007,
0.1799138337,
0.038827952,
-0.0872229189,
0.0256197285,
-1.0642662048,
0.1241182908,
0.1033707336,
-0.2308529168,
-0.9718577862,
-0.3430616558,
0.3479652107,
0.1814565063,
-0.4050770998,
0.1556379646,
-0.4006645381,
0.3022161424,
-0.297506988,
0.2242889106,
-0.1176889911,
0.8459036946,
0.05227663,
0.6442136168,
0.5026756525,
-0.6112512946,
0.3980998993,
0.320217222,
-0.4719779193,
0.4308614433,
-0.754160285,
0.1310526133,
-0.201961562,
0.3703833222,
-1.0411552191,
0.0556466766,
0.1068841144,
-0.0934276953,
0.4112589657,
-0.2472978383,
-0.1560124755,
-0.3645905852,
-0.3780420721,
0.5932334661,
0.8464688063,
-0.8746276498,
0.6069788933,
0.5091667175,
0.0434147194,
-0.7612504959,
-0.4454326928,
-0.1559419781,
-0.3083032966,
-0.5809808373,
0.5423890948,
-0.000323931,
-0.2373063564,
-0.2232742012,
-0.0223440081,
-0.1975684464,
0.0454616509,
-0.264722079,
0.1008183733,
-0.1879962087,
0.1442865878,
0.1512438655,
-0.3487446904,
-0.1738045067,
-0.5078858733,
0.7372586131,
0.1865888238,
0.1030425355,
-0.4201626182,
0.1090275869,
0.3238206506,
-0.3173294365,
0.5337529182,
0.7090451717,
-0.3510700166,
-0.8295773268,
-0.4232590497,
-0.0722045079,
-0.5683737397,
0.6426917911,
-0.5004552007,
-0.8731721044,
0.1542425752,
-0.3375526667,
0.0412042886,
0.5020167828,
0.7246628404,
0.1283390671,
0.5982621312,
0.7269592881,
-0.1267313659,
0.5659041405,
-0.2500401139,
0.4752213359,
-0.6827654243,
-0.02398967,
-0.3740592003,
-0.1527890414,
-0.5124320388,
-0.6546415687,
0.5752631426,
-0.1369412094,
0.1326612085,
0.7688663006,
-0.6866283417,
0.3349689543,
0.3562113941,
-0.0699773878,
0.32060498,
-0.0880335346,
0.3999023736,
0.1684371233,
-0.7198261023,
-0.2686854303,
0.9871791005,
0.375736922,
1.0617742538,
0.1257965267,
0.4269831479,
-0.0114544509,
0.428052187,
-0.6758945584,
0.4195542932,
-0.5170235634,
-0.0490375087,
-0.4974268377,
-0.6267766953,
-0.8591455817,
0.4405889809,
-0.0889115483,
-0.515330255,
0.2188371718,
0.3094039261,
-0.4869703054,
0.0615749918,
-0.8870646358,
0.5626739264,
0.1578929275,
-0.1678922623,
-0.4125510156,
-0.3611100018,
0.5707018971,
-0.7529993057,
0.2420132905,
0.0084792199,
0.4439570308,
0.5787163973,
-0.2621417344,
0.7489157319,
-0.2782894075,
-0.470474571,
0.3530985415,
-0.2289643586,
0.6986403465,
0.2387670428,
0.0898088142,
0.4894972742,
0.0919369683,
-0.2548146844,
-0.5192911029,
0.8081672192,
-0.7414862514,
-0.4602598846,
-0.2761591375,
-0.5910838842,
-0.1606491208,
0.0337056704,
0.0456540994,
0.3370041847,
-0.1518295407,
0.2466698289,
0.9467771053,
-0.468169421,
0.5654921532,
0.2661409378,
0.0574519299,
-0.2836199701,
0.8119499683,
0.2296495587,
0.1979968548,
0.8205040693,
0.2399031222,
-0.0941080675,
-0.4646659195,
-0.1753892899,
0.1856126785,
-0.5518384576,
-0.1579930931,
-0.7432633638,
-0.0920603871,
-0.4921073318,
-0.0441619232,
-0.6630166769,
-0.5254698396,
0.2004757524,
0.3234450817,
0.234994188,
0.7011808753,
0.1638082862,
0.7735846043,
-0.6226911545,
0.3962987661,
0.5661045313,
0.331581533,
0.3718740344,
-0.6160696745,
-0.6373335719,
-0.1544509381,
-0.3521486819,
-0.1858958006,
0.3122062087,
0.0127540007,
0.4116696119,
0.2608497143,
0.1961917132,
0.6470528841,
-0.7893666029,
0.5296935439,
0.2376577556,
-1.1902387142,
0.0373052284,
-0.2821274102,
0.2353653759,
0.2306121439,
0.2327986956,
-0.6532317996,
-0.1321051568,
-0.1749885082,
-0.9072851539,
1.1058911085,
0.2789199352,
0.24329108,
0.0725199878,
0.3175563514,
0.0309405252,
-0.0004632979,
-0.5951176882,
-0.3040337861,
-0.2070654035,
-0.486969769,
-0.1594603658,
-0.503729403,
0.0028278772,
-0.2825059295,
0.650945127,
-0.0276567582,
0.2630765438,
0.1771475822,
-0.1943722367,
0.07444565,
0.1037427485,
0.696187675,
0.3181677163,
-0.0906510502,
0.3294707537,
0.5060813427,
-0.8430994153,
0.1815600246,
0.12426278,
0.1059703007,
-0.0929392576,
0.2860794961,
0.4621439874,
0.3614557683,
-0.355851531,
0.6743226051,
-0.4503442347,
-0.2123394459,
-0.5771123767,
0.0365785472,
0.208009243,
0.3084731996,
0.4374099672,
-0.3183656633,
0.1761249006,
-0.0103476942,
0.3726653457,
0.0998903438,
-0.2735001445,
-0.5189483762,
0.8575581312,
0.3800004423,
0.1515392214,
0.5347800851,
-0.0031099543,
-0.1709376723,
0.5325710773,
0.4275221229,
0.8206402063,
-0.5175586939,
-0.0880066678,
0.5057504773,
0.3215313554,
-0.047886584,
-0.2270044535,
-0.2650604844,
-0.5261672735,
-0.7157766819,
-0.8847648501,
-0.2274359912,
0.0776112378,
-0.3844846785,
0.5424895883,
-0.4126080573,
0.0048197671,
0.1968070716,
-0.1930661649,
-0.3483806551,
0.4684232175,
0.2776175439,
0.772162199,
-0.6149841547,
1.6018686295,
0.2657595873,
0.0735052675,
-0.7875509858,
0.0653049797,
-0.3861750662,
-0.5309397578,
0.7038443089,
0.100344561,
-0.0721660629,
0.1250760704,
-0.2665270567,
-0.8483531475,
1.2131617069,
0.3939799964,
-1.1826581955,
0.2321163416,
0.3629840612,
0.5551616549,
0.0861986205,
0.3371996284,
0.6583740115,
0.2889598608,
0.2204172313,
-0.9595712423,
-0.1058711633,
-0.1000779271,
0.3644101024,
0.3957359791,
-1.1036652327,
1.2018384933,
0.1658277661,
-0.2150290161,
-0.273426801,
0.8810423613,
-0.1709925383,
0.1180091351,
0.9316180348,
0.4311579168,
0.5684543252,
-0.2332340032,
0.7828578949,
-0.4487141669,
0.8654461503,
0.6763603091,
-0.4062012136,
0.4956034422,
0.6179776788,
-0.4678331316,
0.0897034556,
0.2823386788,
0.0525360927,
0.871931076,
0.3634693325,
-0.4600442946,
-0.2113416642,
0.2901137769,
-0.1448190361,
0.5525667071,
0.0378488787,
-0.0256352127,
-0.294985503,
-0.0293511264,
0.0718814358,
0.1871673167,
-0.0521902107,
0.586782515,
0.3381973803,
-0.4739979208,
0.8750254512,
0.3236367106,
0.8429578543,
-0.8638113141,
-0.1764425486,
-0.2572402358,
0.5158295631,
-0.0167007744,
-0.1727632731,
0.4702948034,
-0.0400993526,
-0.164044261,
-0.2707369924,
0.463981241,
-0.6164541841,
-0.4294899106,
0.3727808893,
-0.3301495612,
-0.214612484,
-0.1330025494,
-0.1254803836,
0.21420829,
0.073171638,
-0.606277287,
0.2825628519,
0.5572906137,
-0.2477431446,
0.3441481888,
0.6615130305,
-0.2945496142,
-0.0414394736,
-0.077683717,
1.06425035,
-0.4322119355,
-0.3610660732,
-0.8072409034,
0.4396332204,
0.0037590659,
-0.0134516824,
0.5826285481,
0.37502262,
0.9874644876,
-0.404600352,
0.7223383188,
-0.2130011171,
0.3347282708,
-0.5068131685,
0.9476007223,
-0.4277544916,
0.3670750558,
-0.3311149776,
-1.0296248198,
-0.3101920485,
0.7225981355,
-0.3998358548,
0.0348479524,
0.6553604007,
0.6482864022,
-0.2958260775,
-0.2539549768,
0.8639386296,
0.4366233349,
0.6118944883,
0.9475867748,
0.5882793665,
-0.669573307,
0.612880528,
-0.7295769453,
-0.5970198512,
-0.0278473962,
-0.7683565021,
-0.9939033985,
-0.7622983456,
-0.1437609196,
0.0645103753,
-0.3240397274,
0.8299987316,
0.8045269251,
-0.8480636477,
-0.1088620871,
0.2510888875,
-0.2000698894,
-0.2419225574,
-0.1186839864,
0.6573656201,
-0.4205349684,
-1.4033328295,
0.2493195087,
0.3287174106,
-0.3135357201,
-0.1246504337,
0.1174710467,
0.0694021955,
0.1650452465,
0.9469840527,
-0.3003169596,
-0.3315025568,
-0.3788499236,
0.064910844,
-0.2126157731,
0.0547496527,
0.5528183579,
-0.6889654994,
0.3246431053,
0.2131410688,
0.5218286514,
0.7154432535,
-0.1340323091,
0.358304292,
-0.7658003569,
0.7416270971,
-0.0731933787,
0.2363512814,
0.1827959269,
-0.2618069351,
0.4375723898,
0.2781117857,
-0.4312335849,
-0.6532114148,
0.0186595377,
-1.4609897137,
-0.1109131426,
1.2004755735,
-0.1444426775,
-0.6539880037,
-0.0416059494,
-0.4318556786,
0.2533362806,
-0.2283512503,
1.1723923683,
0.5053494573,
0.486924082,
0.0502466597,
-0.3976325393,
0.5645749569,
0.2186651528,
-0.6299933791,
0.1879358143,
0.0629904941,
0.2533884048,
0.2106350511,
0.6818039417,
-0.1310401112,
0.0957693905,
0.1411768645,
0.3566978872,
0.1913150698,
-0.2518023252,
-0.3014698029,
-0.0123921921,
0.0080174198,
-0.118437998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19913v1
|
MANGO: A Benchmark for Evaluating Mapping and Navigation Abilities of Large Language Models
| 2024-03-29T01:53:24 | 2024-03-29T01:53:24 |
Peng Ding, Jiading Fang, Peng Li, Kangrui Wang, Xiaochen Zhou, Mo Yu, Jing Li, Matthew R. Walter, Hongyuan Mei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
Large language models such as ChatGPT and GPT-4 have recently achieved
astonishing performance on a variety of natural language processing tasks. In
this paper, we propose MANGO, a benchmark to evaluate their capabilities to
perform text-based mapping and navigation. Our benchmark includes 53 mazes
taken from a suite of textgames: each maze is paired with a walkthrough that
visits every location but does not cover all possible paths. The task is
question-answering: for each maze, a large language model reads the walkthrough
and answers hundreds of mapping and navigation questions such as "How should
you go to Attic from West of House?" and "Where are we if we go north and east
from Cellar?". Although these questions are easy to humans, it turns out that
even GPT-4, the best-to-date language model, performs poorly at answering them.
Further, our experiments suggest that a strong mapping and navigation ability
would benefit large language models in performing relevant downstream tasks,
such as playing textgames. Our MANGO benchmark will facilitate future research
on methods that improve the mapping and navigation capabilities of language
models. We host our leaderboard, data, code, and evaluation program at
https://mango.ttic.edu and https://github.com/oaklight/mango/.
|
[
-0.3917945325,
-1.0303678513,
0.6862092018,
0.3458882868,
-0.2422561944,
0.1229041964,
-0.4248449504,
-0.2745159566,
-0.1828866601,
0.6225112081,
-0.2661888301,
-0.6633973122,
-0.5734119415,
0.1051394045,
-0.526268959,
0.7371902466,
-0.1056655422,
-0.4299285412,
-0.2047952861,
-0.1728650331,
-0.9404804707,
-0.4065739512,
-0.7805268168,
-0.1626830399,
0.3101170659,
0.3406578004,
0.8466485143,
0.5718503594,
0.4518046677,
0.2999053597,
0.1331773847,
0.0463661775,
-0.6929113269,
0.3873429596,
-0.2646947503,
-0.4279790819,
-0.2935448885,
0.0484435223,
0.4485094547,
0.3995238543,
-0.1355775744,
0.2096562833,
0.0178723298,
0.67576617,
-0.2636861503,
0.4235182703,
-0.6124967933,
-0.037869975,
-0.3635517657,
0.0208067503,
-0.3198133707,
-0.7481592894,
0.1843894422,
-0.7190660238,
-0.1616542041,
0.3668248057,
0.7882005572,
0.2594937086,
-0.7522269487,
-0.1827951521,
-0.5302960873,
0.8907401562,
-0.4324221611,
0.5485169888,
0.6381956935,
0.6741003394,
-0.205894962,
-0.6270529628,
-0.4550411701,
-0.2311436534,
0.3004251719,
0.0232474934,
-0.1501803398,
-0.0427921005,
0.2251797169,
0.0975349545,
-0.6531297565,
-0.280307889,
-0.2332497239,
-0.0978789851,
0.6505478024,
0.1138370931,
0.633538425,
-0.0986062959,
-0.158690244,
-0.0507549085,
-0.6127573252,
0.1589820534,
-0.0501614548,
0.0995215997,
-0.0974723995,
0.7405472398,
-0.162171483,
0.8906581402,
-0.4190132022,
-0.1373467147,
0.3260803819,
-0.5584505796,
-0.0032789675,
-0.1379027814,
0.8946639299,
0.7669920921,
0.6996711493,
-0.3532380164,
-0.2560219467,
-0.032681834,
0.2933689952,
-0.7694316506,
-0.4472898543,
0.1978101432,
-0.2404375076,
0.2247797847,
-0.4905490875,
-1.0823534727,
-0.6766979694,
0.1797649264,
0.5913445354,
-0.6228502989,
-0.2048244923,
0.0762660056,
-0.1471114308,
0.4076974988,
0.2059379071,
-0.9545826316,
0.6279514432,
0.8913114667,
1.0023514032,
-0.3423478007,
-0.4506405294,
-0.6975514293,
-0.1567915529,
-0.4790850282,
0.6145329475,
-0.8304588199,
-0.6261223555,
-0.1943629384,
-0.4039201438,
-0.3638656139,
-0.636597991,
0.7783418298,
-0.1888742447,
-0.0063722371,
-0.272134006,
-0.4248941839,
-0.5273657441,
0.5801343322,
-0.5249279141,
1.2616510391,
0.0687906072,
-0.4466310441,
-0.0654511526,
-0.66540277,
-0.632273376,
-0.0045274752,
-0.2306220233,
-0.088414222,
0.0296752285,
0.6298249364,
0.3154986501,
-0.8123717308,
0.4527442157,
0.1472726166,
-0.4892150164,
0.2332213074,
-0.3117838204,
0.5795120001,
0.1482683867,
-0.5476621389,
-0.0892403647,
-0.5862987041,
0.053947024,
0.1051713899,
-0.5989646316,
-0.2953410447,
0.3565596342,
-0.0917346254,
0.2451662719,
0.2217548043,
-0.4859927595,
0.3568834662,
-0.3371194303,
0.2471429855,
0.4150697589,
-0.0051534716,
0.3031542301,
-0.2774369419,
0.7212299109,
-0.2009205967,
0.0548525415,
-0.4740177989,
-1.2701002359,
-0.630425334,
-0.1059576869,
0.38895455,
0.6122792363,
-0.9043929577,
0.1178519949,
-0.5892211199,
-0.7253405452,
-0.6561797261,
-0.1035312787,
0.3487915993,
0.7239209414,
0.5443400741,
-0.4094410837,
-0.3708024025,
-0.7005186081,
-0.4615181684,
-0.1461059004,
-0.089534618,
0.6128268242,
0.4724060297,
-0.3190974295,
0.9767214656,
-0.3295638561,
-0.0206257943,
-0.0963876173,
0.072362408,
0.2750400305,
0.2057899088,
0.3905435801,
-0.9099668264,
-0.5551301837,
0.1906860918,
-0.5856591463,
-0.2383024842,
0.219926253,
-0.0586041063,
-0.3024299741,
0.200051263,
-0.573172152,
0.2484810203,
0.701061666,
-0.4361617267,
0.3898909092,
-0.1840685755,
0.6390830874,
-0.8253610134,
0.1445030421,
-0.156138286,
-0.2734058201,
-0.602925241,
0.1804629117,
0.0600470789,
-0.2563998997,
-0.2171729505,
0.7377489209,
-0.3026506901,
-0.1738419384,
0.0981133208,
0.4758494794,
-0.1067082882,
0.5251801014,
-0.1962479502,
1.0249893665,
0.7062337995,
-0.5595220327,
0.4555519819,
0.1315286309,
-0.5071692467,
0.5952004194,
-0.558427453,
0.1541151255,
0.1175468415,
0.2397145778,
-1.3080375195,
0.1830375791,
0.0670739561,
-0.4248740077,
-0.21746701,
-0.1131523103,
-0.513764143,
-0.4064218402,
-0.2667030394,
0.5687366128,
0.9064002633,
-0.3226518333,
0.9120900631,
0.6427871585,
-0.2178081125,
-0.2677120864,
-0.6386343837,
0.3820753992,
-0.2889212966,
-0.5745394826,
-0.031764131,
-0.1532903165,
0.0267240349,
-0.2056270689,
-0.0627600774,
-0.1240084395,
0.1863418072,
0.4894678593,
-0.0493580699,
-0.3214103878,
-0.0689117461,
-0.2930904031,
-0.1348561198,
0.0810418054,
-0.3630725145,
0.5876093507,
-0.0778365806,
-0.110049285,
0.1578683108,
0.0755850077,
0.5608538389,
-0.7965683341,
0.4184479713,
0.1153433919,
-0.3188463449,
0.1088162661,
-0.5455119014,
0.3151400983,
-0.4263938367,
0.3804907501,
-0.6186357737,
-0.6053006649,
0.4181342721,
-0.2907295227,
0.1998978853,
0.4119110107,
0.4876699448,
0.1971403807,
0.9040336609,
0.3639066517,
-0.2335364223,
-0.0484619215,
-0.1111367717,
0.2998434901,
-0.8042086363,
-0.3674874604,
-0.9274634123,
-0.3991737664,
-0.5678395033,
-0.9860787392,
0.2595682144,
-0.216691643,
-0.2194772363,
0.4449107945,
-0.3017190099,
0.6452111602,
0.5324719548,
-0.3166003227,
0.3922325969,
-0.4415974319,
-0.6188727021,
-0.1211007759,
-0.7437109947,
-0.3910340369,
1.2336528301,
0.238266781,
0.630563736,
0.1627619863,
0.6860718727,
-0.0788252726,
0.3425906003,
-0.5303946733,
0.8772734404,
0.0461953357,
-0.6687139273,
-0.3672623634,
-0.6245298386,
-1.1940931082,
0.4080682695,
-0.14423953,
-1.0890926123,
-0.2632888854,
-0.1416242868,
-0.1426155567,
0.1643504053,
-0.8508892655,
1.0957565308,
-0.4847761393,
-0.246163547,
-0.0845542699,
-0.4462761581,
0.3697509766,
-0.3395310342,
0.6678824425,
-0.2219573557,
-0.3596939445,
0.8111774921,
-0.0967180058,
0.2466372997,
-0.0998813584,
-0.0171590727,
0.2786018252,
0.3943607211,
0.297834605,
-0.2936094999,
-0.2543883026,
0.0630531982,
-0.1162982285,
-0.1765798479,
-0.4954743683,
0.8596208096,
-0.6344735026,
-0.4259079993,
-0.387118876,
-0.4283449352,
-0.4842962027,
0.3276843727,
0.0101039857,
0.4507935941,
-0.2439070791,
0.1687636226,
0.5845220089,
-0.4237605929,
0.3651845753,
0.3365510106,
-0.8629813194,
-0.1204332039,
1.13436234,
0.1517394334,
-0.1717378795,
0.5066469312,
0.2213413268,
-0.6910129786,
-0.8582273126,
-0.5510077477,
0.0023024925,
-0.489256829,
-0.0412672684,
-0.5461362004,
-0.0292419512,
0.1217468381,
0.0145468106,
-0.4762975872,
-0.2549334168,
0.3105249107,
0.1160367727,
0.0597077869,
0.8675944209,
0.4298281968,
-0.0521040633,
-0.7114073038,
0.569075048,
0.4580598176,
0.5009194016,
0.0511544608,
-0.2850172818,
-0.1191589609,
-0.0007271892,
-0.3379049897,
-1.0800077915,
0.0500417836,
0.1870892048,
0.5143152475,
0.0005851926,
-0.1313289255,
0.5034014583,
-0.8510904908,
1.016302228,
-0.03756015,
-0.9212169051,
0.507343173,
-0.492152065,
0.6842843294,
0.6783440709,
0.3356079757,
-0.7414466143,
-0.5531842709,
-0.3021407425,
-0.7857267857,
0.3228698075,
0.5262923837,
-0.1604098529,
-0.1141697168,
0.1224022806,
-0.0547728278,
0.3167891502,
-0.5789843202,
-0.0778038651,
-0.0604737811,
-0.2649181187,
-0.6690174937,
-0.0118604433,
0.2271215469,
-0.1903476864,
0.4876084924,
0.1785156578,
-0.0593483001,
-0.1149371043,
-0.0906195864,
0.1381565928,
0.1344464421,
0.2402378321,
0.672621429,
-0.1208496243,
0.2506893277,
0.0954618901,
-0.6642516255,
0.3035939336,
0.3929837644,
-0.1441208869,
-0.1661715657,
0.2268559784,
0.4203375578,
0.3991723359,
-1.0471255779,
0.5161743164,
-0.3889031708,
0.164512679,
0.5182816386,
0.3555724025,
0.400377661,
0.130734548,
0.3203534484,
-0.2163014561,
0.4054010808,
-0.6142299175,
0.0134575199,
0.3146619797,
-0.3007135689,
-0.0614409372,
0.9675668478,
0.5929666162,
-0.753513515,
0.7626918554,
-0.0509315096,
-0.601986289,
0.5750988126,
0.3359959126,
0.7788826823,
-0.4440302253,
0.1379079074,
0.4740519822,
0.6353487372,
-0.1688546538,
0.2843815088,
-0.2350417227,
-0.2652121484,
-0.3531632125,
-0.5650205016,
-0.3915767074,
-0.2341121435,
-0.0284883156,
0.0550078936,
-0.0063975365,
-0.1171557084,
-0.256010592,
0.1242260858,
-0.8369332552,
0.4690319896,
0.0507410727,
1.1314754486,
-0.5926027894,
0.8736678958,
0.5549480915,
-0.0947177038,
-0.7552941442,
0.0423941799,
-0.096625492,
-0.5826987028,
0.1224484369,
0.3833235502,
-0.1887042969,
0.0994712859,
-0.1632019728,
-0.6788589954,
0.9144274592,
0.2087671906,
-0.7363615632,
0.152507484,
0.3143676519,
0.5992373228,
-0.1820162684,
0.49208799,
0.9004510045,
0.5884335041,
-0.1361308992,
-1.1341323853,
0.0535974465,
-0.3214793503,
0.1612446904,
0.3919674158,
-0.3804360628,
0.7637888193,
-0.1015330851,
-0.2285207659,
0.2558998168,
0.3263866603,
0.1645084918,
0.2572388947,
0.3992275596,
0.5511654019,
0.9400861263,
-0.3972966671,
1.3843214512,
-0.2784835398,
0.2526478171,
1.0086305141,
-0.2865549326,
1.1045680046,
0.3748155236,
-0.1887124777,
0.2859762311,
0.5473195314,
0.3642986119,
0.6647927165,
0.5637381077,
0.1170741096,
0.117271319,
0.1507107019,
-0.3669465482,
0.4249565899,
0.3291456997,
0.1584086716,
-0.3501068056,
0.0864214972,
0.0179907437,
0.1513070017,
-0.2229899019,
0.543176055,
-0.0371016935,
-1.126698494,
0.6276378632,
0.1256216466,
0.4270755649,
-0.7582104802,
-0.047975909,
-0.5458003879,
-0.043299064,
0.2402234674,
-1.0181401968,
-0.054981973,
0.1629793495,
0.5359516144,
0.0060391151,
0.3705893159,
-0.4587004781,
-0.2201240063,
0.2829030156,
0.4517112374,
0.2743835449,
-0.1433652341,
-0.7070443034,
0.3444646299,
-0.0143384608,
-0.33139202,
-0.0181301422,
0.5118120313,
-0.0140890302,
1.0006796122,
0.3605111241,
-0.1633102,
0.228962332,
-0.3197526038,
0.5168536901,
-0.7776303887,
-0.6578973532,
-0.9679775238,
0.405569315,
-0.0975188464,
-0.5527572036,
1.0831665993,
1.1578578949,
0.3516123593,
0.1198563725,
0.7092093229,
0.083826296,
0.2793178558,
-0.48436746,
0.6213636994,
-0.5278650522,
0.2978464067,
-0.3076384664,
-1.3261811733,
-0.12410748,
0.5663899183,
-0.5173811316,
0.1532957405,
0.8069028854,
0.6375775337,
-0.3260349035,
0.0521292947,
0.386292547,
0.5229420662,
0.4803704917,
1.0690890551,
0.7652859092,
-0.4151109457,
0.5894355178,
0.055196099,
-0.3429516554,
-0.1610319167,
-0.8206331134,
-0.9461323023,
-0.9121339321,
-0.1784277707,
-0.176878646,
0.3318612278,
0.4711305797,
0.7185173631,
-0.4429743886,
-0.4926429987,
0.032688763,
0.258848995,
-0.2541374266,
-0.0928608924,
0.3080724776,
0.0600827523,
-0.6103565693,
0.5306296945,
0.748754859,
-0.172607705,
-0.1368329525,
-0.155779779,
-0.3857951462,
0.3752529025,
0.4628690779,
0.3312124908,
-0.4170609415,
-0.0926130489,
-0.0116944518,
-0.1751122475,
0.2388497591,
0.6706584692,
-0.9307582378,
0.8569054008,
0.2396799177,
1.048593998,
0.7923433185,
-0.0168922208,
0.6390929818,
-0.5021438003,
-0.1002346203,
0.2219191045,
0.2729445398,
0.5610869527,
0.231688723,
0.7230296731,
-0.2156859487,
-0.6342129707,
-0.4452608526,
0.0075333235,
-0.9220312834,
-0.0957114771,
1.1196781397,
-0.0339209959,
-0.4544531405,
-0.3898264468,
-0.748066783,
-0.136202842,
-0.2592805028,
0.6651905179,
0.8814082742,
0.1247877404,
-0.0742367133,
-0.9667235613,
0.4771504998,
0.2346179932,
-1.0618493557,
0.0093529895,
0.3272509873,
0.1895534545,
-0.0612911098,
1.1114811897,
0.0616194867,
0.2958165705,
-0.0215280708,
-0.3051464558,
0.219915852,
-0.3296082616,
-0.1707704365,
0.2268207967,
0.1897199899,
-0.4644429982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19889v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19889v1
|
Towards a Robust Retrieval-Based Summarization System
| 2024-03-29T00:14:46 | 2024-03-29T00:14:46 |
Shengjie Liu, Jing Wu, Jingyuan Bao, Wenyi Wang, Naira Hovakimyan, Christopher G Healey
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This paper describes an investigation of the robustness of large language
models (LLMs) for retrieval augmented generation (RAG)-based summarization
tasks. While LLMs provide summarization capabilities, their performance in
complex, real-world scenarios remains under-explored. Our first contribution is
LogicSumm, an innovative evaluation framework incorporating realistic scenarios
to assess LLM robustness during RAG-based summarization. Based on limitations
identified by LogiSumm, we then developed SummRAG, a comprehensive system to
create training dialogues and fine-tune a model to enhance robustness within
LogicSumm's scenarios. SummRAG is an example of our goal of defining structured
methods to test the capabilities of an LLM, rather than addressing issues in a
one-off fashion. Experimental results confirm the power of SummRAG, showcasing
improved logical coherence and summarization quality. Data, corresponding model
weights, and Python code are available online.
|
[
-0.072619997,
-0.6385241747,
0.3090267777,
0.1148433611,
-0.2523780763,
0.2697488964,
-0.1530419886,
-0.3442019522,
0.2675391734,
0.5258774161,
-0.1131087169,
-0.188563183,
-0.6515982151,
0.3278170824,
-0.7611157894,
1.2362462282,
0.1751549542,
-0.1139572784,
-0.2866258621,
-0.3427167833,
-0.5710722804,
-0.815331161,
-0.3762466609,
-0.3041596413,
0.3029549718,
0.1104430631,
0.6098275781,
0.3104971647,
0.7264658809,
0.3084087074,
-0.3822909892,
0.242991358,
-0.8573782444,
0.7040240765,
-0.1817071438,
-0.6567670107,
-0.8587209582,
-0.3165132105,
0.794323504,
0.6103516817,
-0.3520266414,
0.2614945471,
0.1933810413,
0.4780859351,
-0.7474352121,
-0.1114062145,
-0.8690639734,
-0.2485409379,
0.0360216014,
-0.2523540556,
-0.5632364154,
-0.2881209254,
-0.1836356819,
-0.2927308977,
0.08659897,
0.1914438605,
0.895282805,
0.3726819158,
-0.2765114009,
-0.4005457461,
-0.6220858693,
0.8795585036,
-0.9084826708,
0.2832187116,
0.3482786119,
0.47352615,
-0.260599494,
-0.8476554155,
-0.3454159498,
-0.2099927813,
-0.0655320808,
0.3038468957,
0.0285662264,
-0.3143112361,
0.2142998427,
0.6027204394,
-0.6315960884,
-0.049988687,
-0.1205322295,
-0.1175694913,
0.552729249,
0.5025480986,
0.3112993836,
-0.2655093074,
-0.2226181924,
0.1812189668,
-0.7298836112,
-0.1959600151,
0.3313697875,
0.5038627982,
-0.1321453601,
1.0014797449,
-0.2368476838,
0.8165450096,
-0.204109773,
-0.5807520747,
-0.0509149097,
-0.5105515122,
-0.2232968658,
-0.0867506415,
0.5006674528,
0.404601723,
0.1235674322,
-0.0627603382,
-0.7193456888,
-0.0682836473,
0.3140566945,
-0.9597985148,
-0.0734696537,
0.3129428625,
-0.4561673105,
-0.5837026238,
-0.0251784679,
-0.4574627876,
-0.3173058629,
-0.0720205307,
0.6832467914,
-0.4169109762,
-0.1715627909,
0.084784545,
-0.3048939109,
0.155350104,
0.3181295991,
-0.8449692726,
0.3813897967,
0.831656158,
0.9502810836,
-0.312614888,
0.0134730199,
-0.9066369534,
0.3401061893,
-0.2732744813,
0.8778101206,
-0.3010519743,
-0.4289958775,
-0.1371610761,
-0.2151778191,
0.0236321166,
-0.8846509457,
0.5726395249,
-0.7384204865,
0.2086653113,
0.0011027438,
-0.7109777331,
0.0514835119,
0.5418218374,
-0.665938437,
0.8499123454,
0.1930884272,
-1.1771149635,
0.1263499558,
-0.1500306129,
-0.57007128,
-0.0389803723,
-0.1789608151,
-0.500171423,
0.1204217449,
0.0554253161,
0.3931162953,
-0.0392715335,
0.3940598071,
-0.1904206574,
-0.5747994781,
0.2565874159,
-0.336266309,
0.8040213585,
0.3691712022,
0.2039503604,
0.0742548183,
-0.721531868,
-0.1724657714,
0.0682241693,
-0.6852754951,
-0.4202544689,
0.0905494615,
-0.0357153676,
-0.1138006821,
0.4221022427,
-0.1018728167,
0.1101976857,
-0.5401893258,
0.0628140569,
0.4286293983,
0.0319617093,
0.2504669428,
-0.7716559172,
0.7170374393,
-0.2384376228,
-0.3506146073,
-0.63286376,
-0.1587125659,
-0.5684269071,
-0.5757526159,
0.4727558494,
0.7967239022,
-0.7853839993,
0.4307561219,
-0.4147517085,
-0.3376691639,
0.075992845,
0.1309221536,
0.3186211586,
0.8514904976,
0.1224960685,
-0.1857433319,
-0.6884605885,
-0.609782815,
-0.3943276405,
-0.2733798921,
-0.2863860428,
-0.0755492821,
0.5701598525,
-0.070898816,
0.7833783031,
-0.3774558604,
0.0169820283,
-0.769403398,
-0.0102703916,
0.4951860607,
0.3196348548,
0.428851217,
-0.7025708556,
-0.2834672928,
-0.1997388452,
-0.8912979364,
-0.2846094072,
0.0117835673,
0.1463478804,
0.2323508561,
0.5902746916,
-0.497181654,
0.4631167054,
0.306073606,
-0.0083346618,
0.7701106668,
-0.2235107273,
-0.0091837244,
-1.3858029842,
0.4052147269,
-0.3835865557,
-0.5160418749,
-0.3903612196,
0.3469245732,
-0.0141887469,
-0.1772872359,
-0.2989502251,
0.5331377387,
-0.3468358219,
-0.3170607984,
-0.4704087377,
0.344622761,
0.0949010104,
0.092853196,
-0.1926711053,
0.8967664242,
0.2251230031,
-0.7275375724,
0.2151474506,
0.3343882263,
-0.3476769924,
0.8814655542,
-0.900295794,
-0.2594282627,
-0.3218174577,
0.3656927049,
-0.9266184568,
-0.5639004111,
-0.1719622761,
-0.6113964319,
0.6175199151,
-0.0924166366,
-0.5374789834,
0.1076154783,
-0.3975430727,
0.2640819848,
0.4668232501,
-0.3794580996,
0.6604697704,
0.6643040776,
-0.6663514376,
-0.6827899218,
-0.4810825884,
0.2639755309,
-0.4803860486,
-0.5497403145,
0.0161829032,
0.0261651017,
-0.5550368428,
-0.2362782806,
-0.1597491652,
0.0738197044,
0.3462117314,
0.0396179929,
0.5016803741,
-0.0215145033,
0.0478004776,
-0.0510818921,
-0.0621444955,
-0.1101451516,
-0.077883862,
0.3913886845,
-0.1003834829,
-0.2646527588,
0.0784632489,
0.4047185779,
0.3824721277,
-0.3553232253,
0.5808223486,
0.4394044578,
-0.5366409421,
-0.3356489837,
-0.3618679643,
-0.0404638648,
-0.4536091089,
0.5288445354,
-0.2511426806,
-0.9467932582,
0.7902492881,
-0.1007065922,
0.2715374529,
0.3756365776,
0.6768190861,
-0.24484469,
0.913310349,
0.6270840168,
0.0318547562,
0.2496150136,
-0.122365348,
0.0324078389,
-0.8857588768,
-0.1519637406,
-0.7255482078,
-0.150514245,
-0.2949024737,
-0.2001954913,
0.6559070349,
0.2468725741,
-0.1295069307,
0.1083995327,
-0.1342842132,
0.5079062581,
0.1492405534,
-0.21067819,
0.663099587,
-0.0314827375,
-0.1895035058,
-0.0401315875,
-0.8247757554,
-0.7610086799,
0.877019465,
0.1704387069,
1.1271514893,
0.4592836201,
0.5575125813,
0.2820322812,
0.4495591819,
-0.8294283748,
0.5803135037,
-0.1380727589,
-0.5579317808,
-0.2946138978,
-0.588203907,
-1.10044837,
0.3862185478,
-0.2838252485,
-0.7056740522,
-0.2784169018,
0.0220782124,
-0.4236845374,
0.2844061553,
-0.3329280615,
0.415664345,
-0.1677639782,
-0.3361912072,
-0.1159899607,
-0.8038582206,
0.6705451012,
-0.1357692182,
0.2581349015,
0.0794687197,
-0.27328372,
0.5943239927,
-0.6056697965,
0.5588422418,
0.2912024856,
-0.2460534573,
0.2458170205,
0.3370208442,
0.4157602191,
0.0085262451,
-0.2909132242,
-0.3889418542,
0.0586491935,
-0.3030898273,
-0.7153741121,
0.6644061804,
-0.3477019668,
-0.5304893255,
-0.4183698893,
-0.8184236884,
-0.3271335959,
0.4542871118,
0.1351381093,
0.8681185842,
-0.146804899,
0.4371612072,
0.8277992606,
-0.4165529907,
0.3909141123,
0.512188971,
-0.6570900679,
-0.5018647313,
1.028740406,
0.2285440713,
0.316377908,
0.5875771046,
0.1522515714,
-0.3422099352,
-0.6217734218,
-0.3398805559,
0.1567032486,
-0.7526968718,
-0.454157263,
-0.5432444215,
-0.2386633456,
-0.4063096046,
0.0277660526,
-0.1550431699,
-0.7543093562,
-0.1338567585,
-0.0856884122,
0.0812291056,
0.846034646,
0.1180217117,
0.0117539978,
-0.8984515071,
0.4923962653,
0.0555388816,
0.3830948174,
-0.0579213835,
-0.8950055838,
-0.3917077184,
-0.2231979072,
-0.243235454,
-0.7884956002,
0.6243224144,
0.2006243765,
0.6001669168,
0.0720442906,
0.3082541823,
0.3966394961,
-0.3247658908,
0.7416827679,
-0.2556440234,
-0.6272600889,
0.5646672845,
-0.803016901,
0.4734525681,
0.5407779813,
0.1916572452,
-0.1410118192,
-0.6990362406,
-0.5266927481,
-0.9284516573,
0.2925614715,
0.1189187095,
0.0968651921,
0.0375894159,
0.444945842,
0.0528323725,
0.2285356075,
-0.3142213523,
-0.0108374842,
0.0075916336,
-0.3922691643,
0.0585598908,
-0.3427067101,
-0.0442301631,
0.1777023971,
0.7447921038,
-0.0739432797,
-0.2087305337,
0.198474735,
-0.3155511618,
0.1614688933,
0.3042773604,
0.7717529535,
0.8024143577,
-0.4123066664,
0.3135144114,
0.392149806,
-0.5196855664,
0.0714077279,
-0.0590686165,
-0.4043088853,
0.1897411346,
0.5537890196,
0.3192428946,
0.3096778691,
-1.0253609419,
0.4964731038,
-0.315728426,
0.1020832583,
-0.2409393191,
0.1397742182,
0.1202823892,
0.0476538204,
0.3937471211,
-0.0455268472,
0.3072841465,
-0.4903187752,
0.3193838,
0.6288199425,
-0.0200061295,
-0.1132720485,
0.8519005179,
0.0156596601,
-0.2821087539,
0.3413577676,
-0.1854631156,
-0.4898022711,
0.3481099308,
0.7150478959,
0.568762362,
-0.0845149234,
-0.267467171,
0.4128767252,
0.3896807432,
-0.2359397262,
0.2749706805,
0.0478252359,
-0.4562833607,
-0.612146318,
-0.6247090697,
-0.6812692285,
-0.1054591462,
-0.7971407175,
0.299590081,
-0.1467134356,
-0.2222220451,
-0.5183997154,
-0.0110044479,
-0.0603318736,
0.120895274,
-0.2118942887,
1.0364918709,
-0.5705382228,
0.5386853218,
0.6916338801,
-0.2148020416,
-0.8187882304,
-0.2036078721,
-0.0891173035,
-0.4754562974,
0.2752377093,
-0.0159221683,
-0.3029891849,
-0.3185493946,
-0.5109075308,
-0.7121814489,
1.258150816,
0.5437074304,
-0.2185287625,
0.1076133847,
-0.1714957356,
0.588607192,
-0.1721083969,
0.1746528,
0.2401075661,
0.0882358104,
0.2232641131,
-1.0505017042,
-0.0947664902,
-0.3846043646,
0.0050783572,
0.0751400888,
-0.7413314581,
0.75559026,
-0.4478069544,
-0.3203207254,
0.4543963075,
0.888374269,
0.6543868184,
0.2757619321,
0.2127977461,
0.6635465622,
0.9504662752,
0.0480093621,
1.4060781002,
-0.2355527729,
0.2695716619,
1.5631040335,
-0.4166370034,
1.1759684086,
0.349470228,
-0.0173407439,
0.3175695539,
0.0940451548,
0.2878635228,
0.2599374056,
0.2743190527,
-0.3019248545,
-0.1727226228,
-0.1381423771,
-0.3623722494,
0.3546861708,
0.3578895032,
-0.0941337645,
-0.2849571109,
-0.3273478746,
-0.0253575742,
0.3172732294,
-0.3380727768,
0.8229337335,
0.1598863304,
-0.7614713311,
0.5203508139,
0.0909241214,
0.7835075855,
-0.5676483512,
-0.0885064751,
-0.4695895314,
0.2183301747,
-0.2858362198,
-0.6225591898,
0.6561619043,
0.2405222952,
0.0014294068,
0.0704925954,
1.1717710495,
-0.4316285551,
-0.6994359493,
-0.1876568794,
0.7661789656,
0.2079694122,
0.3369152546,
-0.1647243798,
0.3723585904,
-0.3044176102,
-0.1972544789,
0.5978716612,
0.4289424717,
-0.0687296614,
0.9986380935,
0.3836488426,
0.1639412791,
-0.1141912788,
0.1338175833,
0.7256531715,
-0.4160232246,
-0.5008825064,
-0.8452159762,
0.5170858502,
0.1166608185,
0.1929216087,
1.0077495575,
0.816192627,
0.5596202612,
0.0273019206,
0.837864399,
0.0893807188,
0.9239116907,
-0.4421711862,
0.9949766994,
-0.5232747793,
0.6381530762,
-0.2567155659,
-0.8312749863,
-0.4856820107,
0.6196004152,
0.1120797247,
0.0994713157,
0.2987718582,
0.8710874319,
-0.0161034279,
-0.1386019737,
0.4153553545,
0.199506551,
0.3194351196,
0.2189552486,
0.9870156646,
-0.3746261001,
0.5875661969,
0.2090747952,
-0.1042232141,
-0.2100889832,
-1.0829741955,
-0.9065842628,
-0.3897609413,
-0.022145221,
-0.4899074733,
0.0670567304,
0.7187412381,
0.3745015562,
-0.6366947293,
-0.4430928528,
0.3705430329,
0.2218110561,
0.127779007,
-0.2082047909,
0.0970730335,
-0.4043083787,
-0.6181462407,
0.3683683872,
0.3645834923,
0.0544056669,
-0.2202252448,
-0.1073579267,
-0.0552163906,
0.1470243931,
0.7232180834,
0.1868673712,
-0.3266830146,
-0.1269581616,
0.0534542426,
-0.1849543303,
-0.227941975,
0.6267054081,
-0.7570354939,
0.3102629483,
0.7358247042,
0.7885468006,
0.2641766369,
0.3496794105,
0.6641877294,
-0.7478072047,
-0.0300596245,
0.2732686102,
0.5359902978,
0.5590854883,
-0.0010850013,
0.5990361571,
-0.0985244289,
-0.6938939691,
-1.1880249977,
0.0700033158,
-1.0637663603,
-0.0275181327,
1.0456782579,
-0.2133859396,
-0.0320946537,
-0.1936866045,
-0.2556230426,
0.227603212,
0.010104904,
0.6860830784,
0.6223596334,
-0.120164834,
0.0642836317,
-0.5051537156,
0.1306909174,
0.3652659059,
-0.8473705053,
-0.0391790234,
0.6219974756,
0.407859534,
0.1305858642,
0.6188367009,
-0.3340303302,
0.1796723902,
-0.0484293513,
-0.3864218295,
-0.1632074714,
-0.2827279866,
-0.4710595608,
0.389342159,
0.3000387549,
0.3449190855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00076v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00076v2
|
A Backdoor Approach with Inverted Labels Using Dirty Label-Flipping Attacks
| 2024-03-29T00:09:48 | 2024-04-07T04:38:37 |
Orson Mengara
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.SP
|
Audio-based machine learning systems frequently use public or third-party
data, which might be inaccurate. This exposes deep neural network (DNN) models
trained on such data to potential data poisoning attacks. In this type of
assault, attackers can train the DNN model using poisoned data, potentially
degrading its performance. Another type of data poisoning attack that is
extremely relevant to our investigation is label flipping, in which the
attacker manipulates the labels for a subset of data. It has been demonstrated
that these assaults may drastically reduce system performance, even for
attackers with minimal abilities. In this study, we propose a backdoor attack
named 'DirtyFlipping', which uses dirty label techniques, "label-on-label", to
input triggers (clapping) in the selected data patterns associated with the
target class, thereby enabling a stealthy backdoor.
|
[
-0.1919795424,
-0.8471294641,
0.2218549848,
-0.0057422854,
-0.0377500504,
0.1876720786,
0.5188885927,
-0.3765996993,
0.0362826437,
0.9199320674,
-0.5106540322,
-0.4887353778,
-0.711312294,
-0.518791914,
-0.7842536569,
1.329007864,
0.4388535023,
-0.053266339,
0.201053232,
0.0857316107,
-0.2798542678,
-0.7939966321,
-0.4987639487,
-0.6797070503,
0.6689035296,
0.3618413508,
1.176466465,
0.4402534366,
0.3616237044,
0.2333025634,
-0.133894071,
-0.346342206,
-0.6468556523,
0.2639533281,
-0.0313196145,
-0.4264172316,
-0.5221527219,
0.3664719462,
0.2165975571,
0.4445815384,
0.0785646513,
0.2679148316,
-0.2702635229,
0.7883139849,
-1.0221489668,
-0.2370261103,
-0.7312901616,
0.4411202073,
-0.2227598727,
-0.3851694465,
-0.5333725214,
-0.2354604602,
-0.3757814765,
-0.3647803962,
-0.2129434794,
-0.20242019,
0.5962287188,
0.3578237593,
0.0173514448,
-0.1493939161,
-0.8152941465,
0.2125167996,
-0.6070115566,
0.624949038,
0.6329287291,
0.3692015111,
-0.3098056018,
-0.7499398589,
-0.4888265431,
-0.0600675941,
0.2266779095,
0.4215978384,
-0.1312680542,
0.0375923365,
0.427834481,
0.1713312268,
-0.2746271491,
0.3837495744,
-0.3856970966,
-0.0139786117,
0.7462525368,
0.0637620986,
0.4198346138,
0.1079710573,
-0.8933565617,
-0.5064410567,
-0.7918328047,
0.041864194,
0.8928807974,
0.2326765507,
0.0793119222,
0.5472432971,
-0.06393224,
0.7363116741,
0.2492727041,
-0.0171903782,
0.1492085904,
-0.0710935518,
-0.3265591562,
0.5833004117,
0.5767019987,
0.4241797924,
-0.0641236901,
-0.4265099466,
-0.5999658108,
-0.1300993264,
0.3705326021,
-0.7638627291,
-0.6315644383,
0.6104030013,
-0.4143694043,
-0.9886550307,
0.1475669444,
-0.9381677508,
-0.5804479718,
0.053463798,
0.9844195843,
-0.3888705075,
-0.0828282535,
-0.121252194,
-0.653634131,
0.1720408648,
-0.0855236948,
-0.6037387848,
0.6072679162,
1.0682327747,
0.7773323655,
0.0493365787,
-0.283049196,
-0.8933116794,
0.439514488,
-0.2450965643,
0.3275592029,
-0.6573146582,
-0.4650729597,
-0.1631427109,
-0.4176414013,
0.1529193521,
-0.6077370048,
0.0520894788,
-0.9835458398,
-0.068654947,
0.1465919763,
-0.2709656358,
-0.3091754913,
0.1893839985,
-0.7611495852,
0.8961547613,
-0.4897888899,
-0.8771717548,
0.3303856552,
-0.503472209,
-0.4338742197,
-0.2223661095,
-0.0032563424,
-0.8162842393,
-0.0719296932,
0.3032003641,
0.6370068789,
0.3635685146,
0.2332758158,
-0.5173052549,
-0.7474114895,
0.7434129715,
-0.4945443869,
1.391418457,
0.2729411721,
-0.4547375143,
-0.1345490515,
-1.0014240742,
0.0134163154,
0.0340117253,
-0.2783074081,
-0.6290473938,
-0.2232797593,
-0.1680526584,
0.4584272206,
-0.378904283,
-0.5981582999,
0.3669760823,
-0.3800851703,
-0.0011164221,
0.6845737696,
0.2724228203,
0.1265828311,
-0.3745160401,
0.3963250816,
0.3498965502,
0.2610281408,
-0.2017394155,
-0.6699358225,
-0.2764092982,
-0.3173934221,
0.4459432065,
0.7912592888,
-0.8927316666,
0.1109397113,
-0.0738599673,
-0.713263154,
-0.7031760216,
0.1088090912,
0.6380473971,
0.5479338765,
0.5594881773,
0.0382281803,
-0.2592014968,
-0.8295970559,
-0.6230266094,
0.078109622,
-0.1228479967,
0.2028821856,
0.6333085299,
-0.2130231559,
0.6328287125,
-0.4025944769,
-0.4170325994,
0.4097409248,
0.3322407901,
0.1722892076,
0.6000881195,
0.1886281222,
-0.9421246052,
-0.0082118614,
-0.2366891056,
-0.4209682047,
-0.1117075384,
-0.2156180739,
0.1475209594,
-0.0604263991,
0.684120059,
-0.2173432708,
0.8812335134,
0.606544435,
-0.0459378064,
0.4701448381,
0.2784470916,
0.0255900081,
-0.6720358133,
0.0948058218,
-0.272949934,
0.1063222513,
-0.8995186687,
0.1319456547,
-0.013496195,
-0.6250258088,
-0.8693699241,
0.2906197309,
-0.2285699248,
-0.0376725309,
-0.0876742154,
-0.0748216808,
0.0436041206,
0.3971426785,
-0.1267161667,
0.5175594091,
0.5599559546,
-0.6871404052,
0.4939864576,
0.0984962136,
-0.053548187,
0.3144056797,
-0.3455655575,
0.6812298298,
0.1484527737,
0.5119029284,
-1.1974928379,
-0.0534809791,
0.6705903411,
-0.6967853308,
0.8029649258,
-0.4143296182,
-0.4038264453,
-0.2440035343,
-0.6293298602,
0.5414360762,
0.253275156,
-1.0411877632,
0.3742503822,
0.3920443058,
0.2614302933,
-0.8406226635,
-1.1536816359,
0.1923250854,
-0.2805781364,
-0.52390486,
0.366494149,
0.4100175798,
-0.3220872283,
-0.3638455868,
-0.1241717786,
-0.0393504798,
0.4038458169,
0.4691458941,
-0.1213056743,
0.0114265801,
-0.0549102165,
0.087941356,
-0.2356894314,
0.4102909267,
-0.3472549915,
0.3546387255,
0.181207791,
-0.3031167686,
-0.8886144161,
0.4410183132,
0.4089408815,
0.1920451373,
0.6176693439,
0.3301502466,
-0.3027710021,
-0.2063258737,
-0.2264939696,
-0.5496140718,
-0.6014536023,
0.2273781151,
-0.4183540046,
0.1781128198,
0.4381370842,
-0.0785145909,
-0.0352032185,
-0.1331542879,
0.2408726662,
-0.5188760757,
0.952501595,
0.2283637673,
-0.0952535272,
0.2049716115,
-0.3861601353,
0.0755857527,
-0.5608592033,
-0.4454021454,
-0.5232358575,
-0.6511850953,
-0.6076844335,
-0.1204608902,
0.1533771157,
0.0850703716,
-0.3072313964,
-0.0013918845,
-0.5947309732,
0.2507291138,
0.6727252007,
0.4471092522,
0.3317706883,
0.0538864136,
-0.1187297776,
0.2064139098,
-0.7230926752,
-0.2374733388,
0.9202668667,
0.6468536258,
1.1594065428,
0.0438432507,
1.1388485432,
0.1950517744,
0.3033719063,
-0.6691142917,
0.4932411611,
-0.0056258799,
-0.8123012185,
-0.3356857002,
-0.0994181857,
-0.941042006,
0.156484738,
-0.1262377799,
-0.8495189548,
0.3680110276,
0.3034802973,
-0.1044207066,
0.7723210454,
-0.6671041846,
0.3915040493,
-0.5500836372,
-0.3329555392,
0.2809488773,
-0.6871353984,
0.5512174368,
-0.0479989685,
0.3924004436,
0.2768276036,
-0.0488916412,
1.2304378748,
-0.6450628042,
1.2774273157,
-0.5661125183,
-0.3292104602,
0.2314126939,
0.4244065583,
0.4330817759,
0.1031591445,
-0.006324565,
0.5940510035,
-0.2216628194,
-0.2606978416,
-0.8675233722,
0.4940262735,
-0.7189719677,
-0.8349452615,
-0.5151305199,
-0.1556202471,
-0.4211294651,
-0.0057802983,
0.4458988309,
0.2916110456,
0.266735971,
0.0131461555,
0.5328104496,
-0.1267863214,
0.4865543544,
0.3005893528,
-0.4437429309,
-0.5908460021,
1.2840092182,
0.3242487311,
0.4420114458,
0.2995654047,
0.4611258209,
0.0288922321,
-0.4597371519,
-0.3879117966,
-0.2522200346,
-0.4823369384,
-0.4035214186,
-0.6310607791,
-0.2039513737,
-0.4583544135,
-0.0934026018,
-0.4886823893,
-0.6383888125,
-0.236935243,
-0.1903680414,
0.3887825608,
0.5372970104,
-0.170631364,
0.4664220512,
-0.674377203,
0.511058569,
0.3783686757,
0.5440368652,
0.2160754502,
-0.5096977949,
0.0623969994,
0.2575610876,
-0.6238241196,
-1.6070517302,
0.1547590345,
-0.093306981,
0.3965837061,
0.598213017,
0.0569146872,
0.4212476909,
-0.2524404228,
0.61764884,
0.2224713266,
-0.8598172665,
0.7043681741,
-0.5570308566,
0.0937605053,
0.5610228777,
0.5828008652,
-0.4785374105,
-0.5050587058,
-0.8176196218,
-1.0997025967,
0.7038128376,
0.2027922571,
0.0966982543,
0.4986179769,
0.1383270323,
0.3697352409,
0.3889778852,
-0.684151113,
-0.6995579004,
-0.6663323641,
0.3183268011,
0.0984698534,
0.0364465304,
-0.2990574539,
-0.2745295465,
0.6818234921,
0.2334050536,
0.2419849038,
0.0201217476,
-0.0650772974,
0.2421528697,
0.1450036019,
0.4123230875,
0.0725682601,
-0.1050904468,
0.2603459656,
0.0877785832,
-0.8712271452,
0.2755440474,
-0.0127724521,
-0.5579555631,
-0.2032868862,
0.2424510419,
0.607144773,
0.4638860524,
-0.0308532063,
0.5146585703,
0.2875673473,
-0.1523595899,
-0.0436090529,
0.3152118325,
-0.0265550353,
-0.0463635437,
0.5138604045,
0.0975276828,
0.4932420552,
-0.7611317039,
0.4830267429,
0.3275312483,
-0.7370272875,
-0.1449763626,
0.5996071696,
0.1264959276,
-0.7725282907,
0.7800332308,
0.5440760255,
-0.7869862318,
0.6651545167,
0.7907209992,
0.8559069633,
-0.5043861866,
0.1886800975,
-0.252545625,
0.2189789265,
0.4965124428,
0.2374370098,
-0.3084251583,
-0.4902094603,
0.0699449852,
-0.21878241,
-0.6614403129,
0.5121678114,
-0.9671883583,
0.1235365868,
-0.722823143,
-0.1573829502,
0.114962928,
-0.4209119976,
-0.5546838045,
0.4756851494,
0.3295340836,
0.8622226715,
-0.9543116093,
0.6409232616,
0.5948944092,
-0.1755326837,
-0.4411601722,
0.1996866912,
0.1591740698,
-0.6974942684,
1.068202734,
0.1212204695,
-0.4132324159,
-0.248850137,
-0.9235681891,
-0.6827836633,
0.4771107733,
-0.0150478836,
-0.2629553676,
0.1785232723,
0.2160452604,
0.3334098458,
0.170750618,
0.0343510248,
0.5730946064,
0.8466396332,
-0.1891782582,
-0.4597174525,
0.0746823251,
-0.1679898202,
-0.4440845251,
-0.007699192,
-0.7176043987,
0.5138893723,
-0.2106041908,
-0.0696711391,
-0.5191819668,
0.6256197691,
0.4202230573,
0.9552061558,
0.3744420707,
0.5257047415,
0.8348152637,
-0.0940606743,
0.8910246491,
0.1814716905,
-0.1392035335,
1.1479072571,
-0.1961775869,
0.9360522628,
0.7876780629,
-0.0404267237,
0.3229753077,
0.3276959658,
-0.4616914093,
0.6979666352,
0.4593567252,
0.0670042038,
0.0922455937,
0.5118820667,
-0.499317646,
0.7754458189,
0.627810359,
-0.1592080593,
0.1204456165,
0.4741903543,
0.2350853831,
-0.1099409685,
-0.5475968122,
0.8923520446,
0.1087872609,
-0.3895666599,
0.6359378099,
-0.1576191485,
0.6709193587,
-0.0419685319,
-0.1616200209,
0.0456123203,
0.0257187821,
-0.5337391496,
-1.0218669176,
0.0888930932,
-0.3954303861,
0.0944698974,
-0.2186054885,
0.8188276291,
-0.1162751615,
-0.3959949613,
0.4471085072,
-0.0141519187,
0.2621674538,
0.0668687895,
-0.6649499536,
0.1619113684,
-0.2096332312,
-0.5514938235,
0.3817731738,
-0.0057255346,
-0.0104483198,
0.9569667578,
0.745857656,
0.0560719222,
0.4461701512,
-0.0759608373,
1.0557730198,
-0.8217715025,
-0.7382031083,
-0.7594057322,
0.2730247378,
-0.2014768422,
-0.1095585674,
0.8163718581,
0.6943024993,
0.7900874019,
-0.0289808866,
0.624951005,
0.6853943467,
0.2448785752,
-0.7061662674,
1.3218375444,
-0.3842453361,
0.3588319123,
-0.7076326609,
-0.4453912079,
-0.3447781205,
0.139981702,
-0.3353154361,
0.1721249074,
0.3668395281,
0.5724275708,
-0.2497967929,
0.4660693109,
0.3479179144,
0.6698056459,
0.4375997484,
0.2385779023,
0.9320915937,
-0.7335961461,
0.6329872012,
-0.7377093434,
-0.2430895418,
-0.3756072819,
-0.7977412939,
-1.0537830591,
-0.4093364775,
-0.5705070496,
-0.7229444981,
0.5117101669,
-0.0593591183,
0.6731450558,
-0.8516680002,
0.1534474194,
0.4313272834,
0.3927926421,
-0.559689045,
-0.2409312874,
0.408405602,
0.1559337676,
-0.2941351533,
0.6890711188,
0.1066406295,
0.0810943767,
-0.3251274228,
0.3673259616,
-0.2780680954,
-0.0186910462,
0.1116327941,
0.5310782194,
-0.4027764797,
-0.2400434315,
-0.4813582897,
-0.0655017868,
-0.0688512772,
0.7696510553,
-1.16962111,
0.3982121646,
0.4912124276,
0.5839691758,
0.6824473143,
0.3382377326,
0.2587020397,
-0.8865727186,
0.1955000609,
0.4964039624,
-0.2525434494,
0.1455394626,
-0.806902349,
0.0265885051,
0.1241282895,
-0.3505052924,
-1.1141412258,
0.0093671856,
-0.691544652,
-0.5646689534,
1.1243954897,
0.0930017978,
-0.5728366971,
-0.5351241827,
-0.0963540226,
0.2028687447,
-0.4136550426,
0.9637911916,
0.2947981954,
-0.1790935844,
0.4372361302,
-0.4547394514,
0.5305407643,
0.2406698167,
-0.2968401909,
0.0472944044,
0.0884815082,
0.3471906185,
0.3020952642,
0.0822374076,
-0.3193492293,
0.4897440076,
0.3776437342,
-0.3315634429,
-0.6693626046,
-0.6535267234,
-0.530603826,
0.6334466934,
-0.6597921848,
-0.582162261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19887v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19887v2
|
Jamba: A Hybrid Transformer-Mamba Language Model
| 2024-03-28T23:55:06 | 2024-07-03T14:30:33 |
Opher Lieber, Barak Lenz, Hofit Bata, Gal Cohen, Jhonathan Osin, Itay Dalmedigos, Erez Safahi, Shaked Meirom, Yonatan Belinkov, Shai Shalev-Shwartz, Omri Abend, Raz Alon, Tomer Asida, Amir Bergman, Roman Glozman, Michael Gokhman, Avashalom Manevich, Nir Ratner, Noam Rozen, Erez Shwartz, Mor Zusman, Yoav Shoham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present Jamba, a new base large language model based on a novel hybrid
Transformer-Mamba mixture-of-experts (MoE) architecture. Specifically, Jamba
interleaves blocks of Transformer and Mamba layers, enjoying the benefits of
both model families. MoE is added in some of these layers to increase model
capacity while keeping active parameter usage manageable. This flexible
architecture allows resource- and objective-specific configurations. In the
particular configuration we have implemented, we end up with a powerful model
that fits in a single 80GB GPU. Built at large scale, Jamba provides high
throughput and small memory footprint compared to vanilla Transformers, and at
the same time state-of-the-art performance on standard language model
benchmarks and long-context evaluations. Remarkably, the model presents strong
results for up to 256K tokens context length. We study various architectural
decisions, such as how to combine Transformer and Mamba layers, and how to mix
experts, and show that some of them are crucial in large scale modeling. We
also describe several interesting properties of these architectures which the
training and evaluation of Jamba have revealed, and plan to release checkpoints
from various ablation runs, to encourage further exploration of this novel
architecture. We make the weights of our implementation of Jamba publicly
available under a permissive license.
|
[
-0.7601405382,
-1.0777425766,
0.1776892096,
0.3503198922,
-0.162841484,
0.4308190048,
-0.394556731,
-0.5706769228,
0.3119262755,
0.827907145,
0.0064490214,
-0.1035976559,
-0.6388513446,
-0.2847579122,
-0.2717008889,
0.7040739059,
0.1374150813,
-0.1646566838,
-0.1470058858,
-0.1812607497,
-0.9899161458,
-0.4393222332,
-0.4199835658,
-0.3487529755,
0.1773991287,
0.2470792979,
0.9627668262,
0.5451955795,
0.1314540356,
0.3386203349,
-0.3167555928,
0.0578513667,
-0.1715626717,
-0.0903950185,
-0.287643522,
-0.4797431231,
-0.6777009964,
-0.342343241,
0.6035936475,
0.8549393415,
-0.4155181944,
0.0617496409,
-0.1861380935,
0.4416100383,
-0.7242709398,
0.3618002236,
-0.7633607984,
-0.2529167533,
-0.4983392954,
0.3177176118,
-0.6579287052,
0.0779075548,
-0.1239866167,
-0.1892163604,
-0.2524164319,
0.0987175182,
0.6448790431,
0.2950217128,
-0.5415065289,
-0.058174938,
-0.9631186128,
0.9273843169,
-0.6499099731,
0.4321115613,
0.176241383,
0.7388890386,
-0.16638349,
-0.2905585468,
-0.6235750318,
-0.287838906,
0.0992348716,
0.1718662083,
-0.1649859399,
0.0063013686,
0.1727243662,
0.7087429762,
-0.3410060704,
0.1354341805,
-0.5877963305,
-0.1687785536,
0.5145075321,
0.2582677603,
0.2877332866,
-0.0615012199,
-0.2189562917,
0.097648792,
-0.6415670514,
0.0083734281,
0.3870928288,
0.2438132465,
-0.1831501275,
0.3982092142,
-0.0065464415,
1.0054543018,
-0.1611366123,
-0.4063492715,
0.211103186,
0.0431371219,
-0.3314761519,
-0.0334021002,
0.8168238401,
-0.1229003444,
-0.1316882372,
-0.1748149246,
-0.1579102576,
0.0031205676,
0.6122588515,
-0.6802683473,
-0.4405058324,
0.0509596206,
-0.3741013408,
-0.1657634974,
-0.1855556965,
-0.8398460746,
-0.3661060929,
-0.1579349488,
0.4409365356,
-0.5443999767,
-0.6510044932,
0.1144060269,
0.2103069425,
0.1169953793,
0.1839864403,
-1.0449845791,
0.6460567117,
0.6231682301,
0.6185550094,
-0.053034924,
0.0314836279,
-0.0589489937,
0.4331328273,
-0.331605345,
0.5184869766,
-0.8983105421,
-0.7193405628,
-0.3126927316,
-0.2971520424,
0.02660699,
-0.8380824924,
0.4860230684,
-0.620443821,
0.2022691965,
0.2261667848,
-0.4125827551,
-0.6965881586,
0.0220754612,
-0.8192403316,
0.8610540032,
0.3951148093,
-0.3307849765,
0.1441079229,
-0.9453136921,
-0.7163701653,
0.3134236038,
-0.192657575,
-0.5333946347,
0.1789292693,
0.2540830672,
0.3294235468,
-0.7576256394,
0.626614213,
-0.1655706018,
-0.2315650433,
0.209446013,
-0.2375941277,
1.1080428362,
0.4873147905,
-0.220811218,
0.0618692935,
-0.8342040777,
-0.3062576056,
0.2875363231,
-0.3832508624,
-0.3383778036,
-0.1559476107,
0.0064038197,
0.1342853755,
0.3148219883,
-0.5746816397,
0.4712255299,
-0.0713220686,
0.3013555408,
0.496950686,
-0.258969456,
0.5512919426,
-0.1070436463,
0.6206246614,
0.2495088428,
0.3541102111,
-0.5659977198,
-0.9764356613,
-0.716213882,
-0.519730866,
0.4130173028,
0.4089775681,
-0.5406585336,
0.6334826946,
-0.0374918729,
-0.7099799514,
-0.6680986881,
0.1333216429,
0.3281637132,
0.4630552232,
0.4671011865,
-0.5564725399,
-0.4119624197,
-1.3620378971,
0.0817951113,
-0.0329995155,
0.0250842255,
0.5708917975,
0.1361000836,
-0.2975241542,
1.0363022089,
-0.3798948526,
-0.0154721858,
-0.5829362273,
0.1405265629,
0.5220309496,
0.5787386894,
0.9098414183,
-0.9469722509,
-0.3996736705,
0.2391503155,
-0.4310791492,
-0.1629427373,
-0.1339368969,
-0.0778214112,
0.0834102258,
0.1781594902,
-0.5854109526,
-0.0652598143,
0.9456670284,
0.1396829188,
0.4585686028,
0.0369098149,
0.0303654689,
-1.4876868725,
0.1250075251,
-0.3364908695,
-0.1023614034,
-0.5278829932,
0.2969651818,
0.2293994725,
-0.2794577479,
-0.2927636206,
0.5898710489,
-0.4162740409,
-0.147775501,
-0.5831068754,
-0.3652319908,
-0.1105183586,
0.5727899671,
-0.1703087091,
0.8895674944,
0.7808942199,
-0.5628277063,
0.5996547937,
0.1917030811,
-0.5757474899,
0.1569366753,
-0.5635015965,
0.0825114399,
0.2161103636,
0.4084664285,
-0.732355535,
-0.4087745547,
0.128827855,
-0.2992433012,
0.5746275783,
-0.3337464333,
-0.378277719,
-0.6717108488,
0.2943314016,
0.5215929151,
1.003051281,
-0.3049489558,
1.2482721806,
0.951849401,
-0.3261916339,
-0.6392241716,
-0.6174370646,
0.3372401595,
-0.0261655133,
-0.5954846144,
0.3482844234,
-0.0635996684,
-0.1323699951,
-0.0849176645,
0.2490904033,
-0.3023732007,
0.4150266647,
0.5122395754,
0.3503030241,
-0.4170928001,
-0.2005363852,
0.2686543465,
-0.1233403534,
0.0053328392,
-0.244891122,
0.8619814515,
-0.1332511008,
-0.2727555931,
-0.141366303,
0.4391938746,
0.6742067933,
-0.5632587671,
1.2047451735,
0.4595773816,
-0.3497703373,
-0.2057511806,
-0.7250137925,
0.2331901789,
-0.4831036329,
0.3886096179,
-0.6470758915,
-0.7327947617,
0.6424985528,
-0.2366245091,
0.3569898009,
0.3188722134,
1.1121697426,
0.2624850571,
0.8402428031,
0.8577747941,
-0.298969388,
0.5747298002,
-0.0895807371,
0.3706299663,
-0.8260966539,
-0.239421621,
-0.3598181307,
-0.3007937074,
-0.2540711164,
-0.4518985152,
0.3249501586,
0.1817078143,
0.0033161498,
0.5896271467,
-0.127741605,
0.6539170742,
0.660769403,
-0.1172219217,
0.098580204,
-0.4101202488,
-0.2466121763,
0.3867576718,
-0.7736046314,
-0.4871458113,
1.0051922798,
0.4323741794,
0.6935599446,
0.1039396524,
0.3834964335,
-0.112226814,
0.5363407731,
-0.6142275333,
0.6563162208,
0.0759505332,
-1.0639756918,
0.023579821,
-0.3756888211,
-0.6644591093,
0.3377376795,
-0.3028908372,
-0.6361435652,
-0.2509534657,
0.2198860347,
-0.3282415569,
0.6847862601,
-0.7912585139,
0.8365772963,
-0.099951528,
-0.0829407498,
-0.3695226312,
-0.6432836652,
0.8596009612,
-0.4103614688,
0.2506901324,
-0.0369358175,
0.2116061002,
0.502802074,
-0.1750386506,
0.6331656575,
-0.0520583615,
-0.1319021881,
0.4740594327,
0.2938577533,
0.270897001,
-0.289288193,
-0.0956308395,
0.5176652074,
-0.6063687801,
-0.5865185857,
-0.5743006468,
0.5426940918,
-0.8257568479,
-0.7048882246,
0.1451523751,
-0.9908021688,
-0.3892902434,
0.2473596185,
-0.0463294573,
0.4116359353,
-0.0108378865,
0.5521496534,
0.395889014,
-0.5549377203,
0.2461494356,
0.4535669684,
-0.4034877717,
-0.2783124745,
0.7947116494,
-0.0490923822,
0.2591300309,
0.4358499348,
0.170394212,
0.0176752172,
-0.8213499784,
-0.6935165524,
0.0974041075,
-0.3747648001,
-0.1002350822,
-0.9296017885,
-0.2781940103,
-0.3756663501,
-0.2029207945,
-0.7895682454,
-0.3563108146,
0.2082789093,
0.0563064851,
0.133418411,
0.9130362868,
0.3029682636,
0.500818789,
-1.0813527107,
0.2545541823,
0.1652791947,
0.4108295143,
0.1508471072,
-0.4491267204,
-0.622548461,
-0.1401681453,
-0.5338950753,
-0.6799190044,
0.2396392226,
-0.2932346463,
0.8119809628,
0.4001417756,
-0.1287796944,
0.5236015916,
-0.6666203737,
0.9354337454,
0.2281557471,
-1.0224080086,
0.2876056731,
-0.4343225658,
0.1355463564,
0.2323722243,
0.2909641266,
-0.2400700301,
-0.6696574092,
-0.5511507392,
-0.8124701381,
0.6479085088,
0.1102160141,
0.2498168945,
0.1592923403,
0.0221242029,
0.4868771136,
0.2578342855,
-0.6486061215,
-0.3310311437,
-0.112135455,
-0.2074367404,
-0.0230179522,
-0.3191685081,
-0.2008618861,
-0.0462350547,
0.715284884,
0.0668802261,
0.1226735562,
-0.777228713,
-0.2599745095,
-0.0903491601,
0.3236955404,
0.4153074324,
0.6863703132,
-0.065883927,
-0.2279750258,
0.2825629413,
-0.4490259588,
-0.0356807522,
0.0156612284,
-0.1876324713,
-0.1522812992,
0.0666138008,
0.8771823645,
0.301386714,
-0.7337191105,
0.3731018901,
0.1899096668,
0.062973462,
-0.0862007812,
0.4221846461,
0.3501962721,
0.328330934,
0.2933332622,
0.266831249,
0.03953477,
-0.6103902459,
0.0526858978,
0.4288760722,
0.1481959373,
-0.3055021763,
0.7872132659,
0.4635851979,
-0.2022303343,
0.3804466426,
0.1001654342,
-0.5184325576,
0.5159306526,
0.6553590894,
0.789245069,
-0.5283610225,
-0.1251766682,
0.2054987848,
0.301797986,
0.1931666732,
-0.1259664148,
-0.2283432037,
-0.6591302156,
-0.5072995424,
-0.9320540428,
-0.8278737068,
0.0747710615,
-0.6574836969,
0.2991448343,
-0.6026699543,
-0.1107321084,
0.0233631264,
-0.1877253354,
-0.2660698891,
0.1503679305,
0.4884944558,
0.9660864472,
-0.7152372599,
1.1476404667,
0.6979082227,
-0.2314399481,
-0.7938306332,
-0.2864368856,
-0.199040994,
-0.7557076216,
0.3986961544,
0.1158017814,
0.0686845034,
-0.3015298545,
-0.2141986787,
-0.7603179216,
1.08872962,
0.4549454749,
-0.7471343279,
0.032545995,
-0.0388176218,
0.2404405028,
-0.2287273556,
0.3691403568,
0.502124846,
0.4209920764,
0.1698841453,
-1.0998796225,
-0.1646704823,
-0.2505707145,
-0.0179328378,
0.6008421779,
-0.9417875409,
1.1182421446,
-0.1011528149,
-0.0799589753,
0.1421187073,
0.9711638689,
0.1110337898,
-0.1723347008,
0.5788725019,
0.5682976246,
0.6318469048,
-0.1240845025,
1.3353909254,
-0.5212073922,
0.1798717976,
0.9805566072,
-0.3070424199,
0.64054811,
0.0936720967,
-0.2974026203,
0.6621168256,
0.2670958638,
0.0652058348,
0.3269523084,
-0.1079848707,
-0.3200471699,
-0.2875058055,
-0.1039754078,
-0.4173393548,
0.4673651159,
0.4855194688,
-0.3265464604,
-0.0448202789,
0.0855497792,
-0.0030431256,
-0.0828446746,
-0.333106786,
0.6266486645,
0.0799622387,
-0.6021239161,
0.3288106322,
0.2962121069,
0.6919649839,
-0.7570447922,
0.2488456517,
-0.037825454,
0.2454571873,
0.0786124617,
-0.8210828304,
0.3572014272,
-0.0949947685,
-0.127260834,
-0.0059918547,
0.5009118915,
-0.4974911213,
-0.4114258885,
0.3314517438,
0.3327161372,
0.0352528989,
0.0726081207,
-0.705653131,
0.2787469923,
-0.2281002849,
-0.3030148745,
0.3186939955,
0.1499822736,
-0.157059595,
0.6064495444,
0.6497785449,
0.0419738069,
0.2933256328,
0.0836358145,
1.019215107,
-0.6856642962,
-0.7102100849,
-0.6510834694,
0.4133763313,
-0.0155956326,
-0.105103083,
0.6682390571,
0.6628794074,
0.7889643312,
-0.1551295668,
0.8303653598,
-0.0970000699,
0.4840660989,
-0.487940073,
0.6476643682,
-0.5529097319,
-0.0625464544,
-0.2507448196,
-1.1592917442,
-0.2644924521,
0.3233149052,
-0.2713530958,
0.0990090221,
0.2680529952,
0.6229239702,
-0.2944672406,
0.2274472415,
0.6007743478,
0.5218728185,
0.5960715413,
0.8192007542,
0.6944582462,
-0.2094661444,
0.4846478403,
-0.2527351081,
-0.4073302448,
-0.4903554916,
-0.6659887433,
-0.9416202903,
-0.5420427918,
-0.1122853383,
-0.034850847,
-0.3316997588,
0.8849824071,
0.8485375643,
-0.9224001765,
-0.2705686688,
0.2451283187,
-0.0428459756,
-0.1210351065,
-0.2112256289,
-0.1405353397,
-0.029793147,
-1.0060237646,
0.606562674,
0.6966328621,
0.0286673177,
-0.4398127198,
-0.0210633092,
0.0725751296,
0.2512525618,
0.5963383913,
0.3268930912,
-0.712369144,
0.1193559766,
-0.2877390087,
-0.1527645439,
0.0894500539,
0.8132794499,
-0.7879363894,
0.5761929154,
0.3357366323,
1.1335923672,
0.4333473742,
-0.1487421244,
0.7905976176,
-0.4932973981,
0.4982949495,
0.2987233996,
0.7857422233,
0.261762023,
-0.0505087636,
0.1776820868,
0.0428801514,
-0.3142185807,
-0.6790460944,
0.3842724562,
-1.2530755997,
-0.4127139449,
0.8658077717,
-0.0662246123,
-0.4416662455,
-0.1291133612,
-0.4411543608,
0.140471369,
-0.2901940346,
0.8110883236,
0.815854907,
0.1866440773,
-0.2264887542,
-0.4603656828,
-0.1833394617,
0.4277657568,
-0.7168475389,
-0.0227519237,
0.396658361,
0.1722289622,
0.5057660341,
0.3807414472,
-0.3266380429,
0.2658037543,
0.1564468741,
0.2710208595,
-0.5128658414,
-0.6383594275,
-0.0319295377,
0.2848121524,
-0.1826944947,
-0.076953426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19851v1
|
Localizing Paragraph Memorization in Language Models
| 2024-03-28T21:53:24 | 2024-03-28T21:53:24 |
Niklas Stoehr, Mitchell Gordon, Chiyuan Zhang, Owen Lewis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Can we localize the weights and mechanisms used by a language model to
memorize and recite entire paragraphs of its training data? In this paper, we
show that while memorization is spread across multiple layers and model
components, gradients of memorized paragraphs have a distinguishable spatial
pattern, being larger in lower model layers than gradients of non-memorized
examples. Moreover, the memorized examples can be unlearned by fine-tuning only
the high-gradient weights. We localize a low-layer attention head that appears
to be especially involved in paragraph memorization. This head is predominantly
focusing its attention on distinctive, rare tokens that are least frequent in a
corpus-level unigram distribution. Next, we study how localized memorization is
across the tokens in the prefix by perturbing tokens and measuring the caused
change in the decoding. A few distinctive tokens early in a prefix can often
corrupt the entire continuation. Overall, memorized continuations are not only
harder to unlearn, but also to corrupt than non-memorized ones.
|
[
0.0005294028,
-1.0759049654,
0.4206382334,
0.3138021827,
-0.1745758653,
-0.1185187623,
-0.2841736376,
-0.0792889968,
0.0027378632,
0.6028524637,
-0.1618226767,
-0.4685129523,
-0.2850643396,
-0.1734957099,
-0.5281174183,
0.9877390862,
-0.1530739665,
0.2057320476,
-0.2137776315,
-0.2263763696,
-0.2338421047,
-0.6924126148,
-0.8502795696,
-0.6527129412,
0.5970640182,
0.2796551883,
0.4214259982,
0.9779331088,
0.4050632715,
0.3905683458,
-0.4209189415,
-0.2947873175,
-0.5950628519,
-0.1393808573,
-0.0834530219,
-0.8948010206,
-0.2500165403,
-0.203739211,
0.9243377447,
1.2458765507,
-0.2225848585,
-0.0920403674,
0.1319490224,
0.5124990344,
-0.4727448821,
0.008576232,
-0.6119292974,
0.277736336,
-0.3225051463,
-0.2634023726,
-0.2332588434,
0.0425220951,
0.2777121365,
-0.4948996902,
0.6584537029,
-0.0372070037,
0.593539834,
0.0007401342,
-0.228411153,
-0.0091536418,
-0.7867913246,
0.9164136648,
-0.6456328034,
0.2644445598,
0.6171973348,
-0.1531172395,
-0.1327415705,
-0.6755254269,
-0.2161501348,
-0.0735868886,
-0.0608762912,
0.0137088634,
-0.1865664124,
0.0959295556,
0.4676548839,
0.4689308703,
-0.4170234799,
0.1256044209,
-0.410674572,
-0.3194134533,
-0.0326855518,
0.1841619313,
0.4928128421,
-0.0177800097,
-0.6308099627,
0.1119745746,
-0.8918790221,
0.2167615592,
0.1998473853,
0.2225890905,
-0.0633930787,
0.4049319923,
-0.2428578585,
0.5144198537,
0.0418027937,
-0.3780210018,
0.4249769151,
-0.2231235057,
-0.3232409954,
0.0168756079,
0.5455005169,
-0.0281044319,
0.2076209188,
-0.4466242492,
-0.3074145913,
-0.3619490862,
0.2595131993,
-0.5650512576,
-0.3165996075,
-0.0557753034,
-0.6392559409,
0.0911478773,
-0.1083750874,
-0.5253461003,
-0.3449087739,
-0.4374865294,
0.2907160223,
-0.6768071651,
-0.0524637811,
0.4240737855,
-0.1807324886,
0.1984946877,
0.1277389079,
-0.9183593988,
0.3046882153,
0.5747978091,
0.8103928566,
0.0328285173,
-1.1344673634,
-0.2474252433,
0.2695729136,
-0.1251966953,
0.920915246,
-0.5459690094,
-0.170342952,
0.2010113895,
0.0446259119,
-0.5094961524,
-0.6606162786,
0.4317735136,
-0.2297658175,
0.1424975693,
-0.50226897,
-0.6524911523,
-0.1715189666,
-0.0539015047,
-0.4367605448,
1.0684562922,
0.0544519685,
-0.9835518003,
0.0462417677,
0.0704768002,
-0.6209746599,
-0.2963743806,
0.157457307,
-0.3433352709,
0.4447445869,
0.1258673221,
0.3176778257,
-0.0256348345,
-0.0713176057,
-0.2031318098,
-0.5606612563,
0.2344529331,
-0.3294574916,
0.5548661947,
-0.0565862507,
-0.203068614,
0.0383249559,
-0.8313699365,
-0.2700237036,
0.0100813499,
-0.445843786,
-0.571277082,
-0.0174180791,
-0.349703908,
0.0517266281,
0.2888971865,
-0.472955972,
0.096700184,
-0.3001621664,
0.5307253003,
0.5183129311,
0.3590395153,
0.9227955937,
-0.4168205559,
0.3280192912,
0.5695025921,
-0.1076897383,
-0.472981602,
-0.2351342589,
-1.1036227942,
-0.4299663305,
0.1940927804,
0.5311042666,
-0.314632982,
0.2447978705,
-0.0449207313,
-0.4550962746,
-0.2495934069,
0.0933069289,
0.5955688953,
0.8617554903,
0.2766120136,
-0.4787327945,
-0.3149828017,
-0.9277447462,
-0.2314279675,
0.0196891706,
-0.0682093054,
0.094324179,
0.5689661503,
-0.0081075728,
0.8716991544,
-0.3918925226,
-0.4902312458,
-0.2711603045,
0.4950146973,
-0.1362544745,
0.5037714839,
0.4761140943,
-0.2772100866,
-0.156290397,
-0.1106811836,
-0.562900126,
-0.1884145886,
-0.4301491678,
-0.0899827778,
-0.0492199138,
0.8355752826,
-0.7026993036,
0.2490575016,
-0.2104177177,
-0.417155087,
0.17786856,
-0.6516041756,
-0.400921911,
-0.6564152837,
0.1394990683,
-0.1846727729,
-0.0790069774,
-0.8617784977,
0.0664481893,
0.0372142904,
0.1142298058,
-0.3465248346,
0.4118219912,
-0.4499483109,
-0.2347068191,
-0.113933228,
0.3373095691,
0.0517702214,
0.8709141016,
0.1025581956,
0.6642751694,
0.6965793967,
-0.6073619127,
-0.1306726187,
0.2129316628,
-0.528190434,
0.4115966856,
-0.6322811842,
0.0043852776,
-0.5990285873,
0.2097001523,
-0.8285708427,
0.1263867766,
-0.1189761832,
-0.1727497578,
0.2511831522,
-0.0177536383,
-0.2820551395,
0.0639699176,
-0.3026570082,
0.4375360906,
0.4827378094,
-0.3680364192,
0.2990266979,
0.462415874,
-0.1631589681,
-0.6042391658,
-0.5983689427,
-0.2906294763,
-0.3548173308,
-0.2465027124,
0.2759412825,
0.2337862402,
-0.0772462562,
-0.1627822816,
-0.162114501,
-0.2255124301,
0.1629434675,
0.2048110515,
-0.3156799972,
-0.1818775684,
0.0283688176,
-0.1715055555,
0.0644676611,
0.0357893147,
-0.494754523,
0.8253535628,
-0.1059436128,
-0.2467164844,
-0.280292213,
0.4108396471,
0.5563778281,
-0.6183778048,
0.7073560357,
0.710169673,
-0.5793492794,
-0.2931005061,
-0.5003496408,
-0.0726602674,
-0.4071787,
0.512557447,
-0.3929635286,
-0.6221699119,
1.2680449486,
-0.0212924462,
-0.2905258834,
0.0770371258,
0.4218530655,
-0.1933366507,
0.7232133746,
0.5593369007,
-0.2747434378,
0.629301548,
-0.3628993034,
0.2636429071,
-1.1485359669,
-0.2605858445,
-0.6273060441,
-0.3314503431,
-0.1566108018,
-0.309684962,
-0.0307216663,
0.957395792,
-0.2865867615,
0.2064149678,
-0.0371509641,
0.8319349885,
0.8064968586,
0.0275023822,
0.1136826128,
0.3498756886,
-0.7266058922,
-0.2175503671,
-0.6700804234,
-0.2995610237,
0.7313606143,
0.5539489388,
0.6691010594,
-0.120656319,
0.6850842237,
-0.0080075357,
-0.1390170604,
-0.5300325155,
0.5486454964,
-0.103550449,
-0.0960906819,
-0.3369130194,
-0.3532928228,
-0.983250916,
0.3986688256,
0.2037953585,
-0.9904577732,
0.2671896219,
0.0905635059,
-0.2486794889,
0.4508189261,
-0.579344511,
0.9777079225,
0.1278026402,
-0.1752542406,
0.0288887173,
-0.4428135753,
0.029358292,
0.0745053366,
0.0276184436,
0.0396208391,
0.1128576025,
0.7737550139,
-0.2329986244,
1.110730648,
-0.1876588017,
-0.2152766138,
0.2780402601,
0.2076364756,
0.550810039,
-0.0813782066,
0.2085328847,
0.2294419706,
-0.3452186882,
-0.4483208656,
-0.4950430393,
0.6232829094,
-0.8294172883,
-0.4081328809,
-0.2343671769,
-0.477304548,
-0.0658985302,
0.5124945641,
0.466593802,
0.633333981,
-0.1987598985,
0.0390245691,
0.9607030749,
-0.174862504,
0.5028628707,
0.7022833824,
-0.0669739991,
-0.2876857817,
1.2270979881,
0.2530356348,
0.0621785372,
0.6353783607,
0.1080294102,
0.0257916953,
-0.8850336671,
0.0545290783,
0.4148139954,
-0.8889030218,
0.0708981603,
-0.509876132,
-0.1192976236,
-0.0571294613,
-0.1906540841,
-0.2771739066,
-0.5139437318,
-0.4337402284,
-0.180760324,
-0.1448025405,
0.6970234513,
0.0010177385,
0.3950726688,
-0.5881301165,
0.194772765,
0.0361161679,
0.3269099295,
0.2520005703,
-0.7095741034,
-0.4066928029,
-0.1684549302,
-0.1480940133,
-0.5694245696,
0.4769788682,
0.1051808223,
0.3407709002,
0.6375920773,
-0.2097487748,
0.8218243122,
-0.8362912536,
0.7175331712,
-0.0489677675,
-1.0005161762,
0.1956225783,
-0.7086185813,
0.685587883,
0.3492833376,
0.0265301354,
-0.876371026,
-0.8001634479,
-0.41591838,
-0.9921788573,
0.7021903396,
-0.1778847426,
0.280613333,
-0.4044929743,
0.5463026166,
-0.1383452415,
0.1184785366,
-0.6024440527,
-0.1664788276,
-0.0924117267,
-0.0488312431,
0.1363681257,
-0.5181463957,
-0.0690115914,
-0.2426361889,
0.3871550262,
0.0662476942,
0.4921408594,
0.3664652407,
-0.4170820713,
-0.0843741372,
0.2275663763,
0.8745723367,
0.7884064913,
-0.1806683391,
0.1853229403,
0.255978018,
-0.4567872882,
-0.1376826316,
-0.2086917758,
-0.690974474,
-0.0237904303,
0.6457271576,
1.0681849718,
0.7497680783,
-0.2590456009,
0.469583571,
-0.0170989707,
-0.0907539651,
-0.4916340709,
-0.1159677356,
0.0960302576,
0.0941448063,
0.1455303133,
0.1189560667,
-0.0144511741,
-0.4953671694,
0.2299576402,
0.4228895903,
-0.382588625,
-0.4554725885,
0.6452884674,
0.1103892773,
-0.178500697,
0.8602016568,
-0.0332202576,
-0.6371504664,
0.5850946307,
1.0102248192,
0.7769367099,
-0.205038175,
0.1322183609,
0.4535810947,
0.2726895511,
-0.3138972223,
0.1858065724,
-0.1533754468,
-0.772970736,
-0.1346462518,
-0.5966728926,
-0.0234384611,
0.2230636477,
-0.8703804612,
-0.081672892,
-0.5783794522,
0.0099639324,
-0.0772251263,
-0.3249281645,
-0.3471406996,
0.0636621192,
0.1860978156,
0.8478547335,
-0.6123588085,
0.9670155644,
0.5982359648,
-0.4140567183,
-0.4409770668,
0.0792358145,
-0.1936218292,
-0.7652111053,
0.6369893551,
0.1343496889,
0.01901857,
-0.1069982424,
-0.0975271836,
-1.0580893755,
0.975259006,
0.303083092,
-0.2893693745,
-0.390147537,
0.2943706214,
0.7285560369,
-0.2009087801,
0.3273860216,
0.6231520176,
-0.050485231,
-0.2343840152,
-0.8693162799,
-0.2954905629,
0.0111949276,
0.2264122218,
0.399469465,
-0.8431277275,
1.3651924133,
-0.2141378373,
-0.3749957979,
0.0977660492,
0.4448729753,
-0.2475325912,
-0.1361856014,
0.0601423196,
0.9381705523,
0.9797861576,
-0.0552801564,
1.0818952322,
-0.3861869574,
0.4320710301,
1.2559562922,
-0.3927568495,
0.9908142686,
0.4070980847,
0.0802688003,
0.3117567003,
0.2816365361,
-0.010616825,
0.5604326129,
0.300634712,
-0.3097543418,
-0.1688248664,
-0.1382515728,
-0.0837772563,
0.4996627271,
0.1699781716,
-0.3338741064,
-0.3523519635,
0.1720001847,
0.228614375,
-0.0610632673,
-0.5855872631,
0.8106796741,
0.112532042,
-0.7266926765,
0.6639873981,
0.2537442744,
0.1725010425,
-0.7201041579,
0.1553409398,
-0.7172299027,
0.5785108209,
-0.0909933969,
-0.3581618071,
0.2718024254,
-0.259335041,
-0.3755221069,
-0.380502671,
0.5123742223,
-0.8187920451,
-0.1964488775,
0.3163172305,
0.3020436168,
-0.0355536491,
0.0351107754,
-0.4103366137,
-0.2711338103,
0.0759373233,
-0.5028578639,
0.5921025872,
0.5041851997,
-0.1733069569,
0.8818899989,
0.4738017917,
0.2179883868,
0.4505785108,
0.3643653095,
0.4746318758,
-0.693005383,
-0.5423662066,
-0.7882921696,
0.3557160199,
0.0856669918,
-0.4292608202,
0.9742094874,
0.5086570382,
1.1657958031,
-0.2283281684,
0.3750896156,
0.4265426695,
0.4657897651,
-0.687643528,
0.647028625,
-0.1782007664,
0.2713137865,
0.0215384774,
-0.9752203822,
-0.3904387057,
0.8467859626,
-0.1474648565,
-0.2046121359,
1.0950554609,
0.6239596009,
-0.0140558742,
-0.1863117516,
0.2334117889,
0.355792135,
-0.1496836841,
0.5917131901,
0.649500072,
-0.2999742329,
0.35286659,
-0.3870759904,
0.0743688494,
0.218411833,
-0.517036438,
-1.1981914043,
-0.550731957,
-0.2664696276,
-0.1572107822,
-0.2857143879,
0.5903870463,
0.3249754608,
-0.8265815973,
-0.3318921924,
-0.3307959735,
0.2074178308,
-0.1771814078,
-0.1950955391,
0.4064099491,
-0.7391113043,
-0.6433001161,
0.3131193221,
0.3661768734,
0.2263980359,
-0.2256608456,
0.2580116391,
-0.1083619893,
0.118739441,
0.498806864,
0.4650368094,
-0.7207099199,
-0.1364186257,
-0.1010853499,
-0.2775764763,
0.2171649933,
1.3842664957,
-0.7588804364,
0.1099222898,
0.6412937045,
0.3800390363,
0.3310040534,
-0.0906049609,
0.5582880378,
-1.3114310503,
0.4077463448,
-0.0463669561,
0.879283011,
0.291275382,
-0.0429077186,
0.1884432584,
0.1665207893,
-0.537094295,
-0.7956475019,
0.2037725002,
-0.5226865411,
-0.180583328,
1.0282024145,
-0.4806206822,
-0.354608953,
-0.0507696681,
-0.1713076383,
0.0779024959,
-0.0577390157,
0.6851702929,
0.9298353195,
0.1042217612,
-0.1663871258,
-0.3252956867,
0.7313172221,
0.6563519239,
-0.395288676,
0.4741735458,
0.388227582,
0.4519237876,
0.2566613853,
0.724778831,
-0.1140546203,
0.0659408048,
0.0060572396,
-0.1502765864,
0.077060163,
-0.5481275916,
-0.8410984874,
0.1159075499,
0.1063624173,
0.0135341343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19839v1
|
The New Agronomists: Language Models are Experts in Crop Management
| 2024-03-28T21:20:27 | 2024-03-28T21:20:27 |
Jing Wu, Zhixin Lai, Suiyao Chen, Ran Tao, Pan Zhao, Naira Hovakimyan
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Crop management plays a crucial role in determining crop yield, economic
profitability, and environmental sustainability. Despite the availability of
management guidelines, optimizing these practices remains a complex and
multifaceted challenge. In response, previous studies have explored using
reinforcement learning with crop simulators, typically employing simple
neural-network-based reinforcement learning (RL) agents. Building on this
foundation, this paper introduces a more advanced intelligent crop management
system. This system uniquely combines RL, a language model (LM), and crop
simulations facilitated by the Decision Support System for Agrotechnology
Transfer (DSSAT). We utilize deep RL, specifically a deep Q-network, to train
management policies that process numerous state variables from the simulator as
observations. A novel aspect of our approach is the conversion of these state
variables into more informative language, facilitating the language model's
capacity to understand states and explore optimal management practices. The
empirical results reveal that the LM exhibits superior learning capabilities.
Through simulation experiments with maize crops in Florida (US) and Zaragoza
(Spain), the LM not only achieves state-of-the-art performance under various
evaluation metrics but also demonstrates a remarkable improvement of over 49\%
in economic profit, coupled with reduced environmental impact when compared to
baseline methods. Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/jingwu6/LM_AG}.
|
[
-0.1882856637,
-0.847029686,
0.6651338935,
0.2934264243,
0.1229504272,
0.4634126127,
-0.4326281846,
-0.3770477772,
-0.0478063673,
0.3424794376,
-0.5388735533,
-0.3611560464,
-0.6008344889,
0.0497960374,
-0.4541826844,
0.94356215,
-0.0429534279,
0.0809553266,
-0.1808240563,
0.0239268783,
-0.3879696429,
-0.2845977843,
-0.9261562824,
-0.6164929271,
0.4647731185,
0.4434270561,
1.0265517235,
0.6534641981,
0.6201165318,
0.3936313987,
-0.2287446111,
0.2747876048,
-0.1065436751,
0.139743194,
-0.456972152,
-0.2721811235,
-0.1839876473,
0.1506977677,
0.355894655,
0.4443002939,
-0.2775435448,
0.1614893377,
-0.1240257993,
0.4824197292,
-0.5298250914,
0.2840408683,
-0.5595562458,
0.5009548068,
0.3626352549,
-0.31352669,
-0.454584986,
-0.5888137817,
-0.1825384349,
-0.785533607,
-0.2939164937,
-0.0627689213,
1.0442078114,
0.3981018662,
-0.2281366438,
-0.2440410256,
-1.0691940784,
0.5898125172,
-0.4064296782,
-0.0128761726,
0.1945887506,
0.77821064,
-0.3081831932,
-0.5895427465,
-0.5650445819,
-0.2422425151,
0.2206089944,
0.5582037568,
-0.1054684296,
0.0771445334,
-0.1596178859,
0.322189182,
0.0458989926,
0.3637478054,
-0.5513044,
-0.112562336,
0.420089215,
0.1518166363,
0.3079124987,
0.0721594244,
-0.5854967237,
-0.5327668786,
0.0082547208,
0.3370510042,
0.0569381714,
0.305626303,
0.3055051267,
0.3782321215,
-0.2037878335,
0.4437957704,
-0.1743573397,
-0.0378617384,
0.0393649414,
-0.1231147423,
-0.5557345152,
-0.3399935663,
0.7378175259,
0.3195050359,
0.3243061304,
0.016284069,
-0.5337546468,
0.431206882,
0.143411532,
-0.4836253822,
-0.4501126111,
-0.0299833771,
-0.1293793917,
-0.4803398252,
-0.0838591978,
-0.5995184183,
-0.5137827396,
-0.2734619975,
0.3262014091,
-0.8519200683,
-0.2367586046,
0.0967030972,
-0.1394692957,
0.4498660266,
0.5057715178,
-0.4454429746,
0.7555967569,
0.6544707417,
0.745687604,
-0.0521943644,
-0.3332572579,
-0.5073419809,
-0.1422457546,
-0.7404981852,
0.5091320872,
-0.6463202834,
-0.2853902876,
-0.2671985328,
-0.0589770265,
-0.3581697643,
-0.5988976359,
0.1806090921,
-0.6942124963,
-0.0614712872,
0.0979048982,
-0.5349808335,
-0.5312411785,
0.4110844731,
-0.4150871336,
0.9945369363,
0.2091723979,
0.1618061066,
0.5186575651,
-0.6506903172,
-0.2400041968,
0.2911672294,
-0.4752800763,
-0.5019724965,
-0.0648059398,
0.0891357288,
0.3469955623,
-0.1203713939,
0.5618820786,
-0.1033250615,
-0.0657541454,
0.379299134,
-0.4854016602,
0.4304038286,
0.5698543191,
0.0073562493,
0.4384582639,
-0.4679405987,
0.265981555,
0.2700976729,
-0.6515620947,
0.0877009556,
-0.1335797906,
0.1299433261,
0.1276671886,
-0.0971911028,
-0.3895891309,
0.2736587226,
-0.3610830903,
0.6025277972,
0.6200430989,
-0.044741869,
0.7191693783,
-0.133257553,
0.8531221747,
0.1663169414,
0.3933470845,
-0.309495002,
0.1005820483,
-0.8358995318,
-0.1203589514,
0.3568374515,
0.8757693768,
-0.8960569501,
0.0026733386,
-0.0336645693,
-0.2387538254,
-0.0954907238,
-0.1457398683,
0.3046699166,
0.4217835367,
0.5476934314,
-0.1777199954,
-0.0858080983,
-0.8037438393,
-0.3499294221,
0.1901459396,
0.4429946542,
0.2524500787,
0.5955643654,
-0.1465709507,
1.1124689579,
-0.5633807182,
-0.5054939389,
-0.4795913994,
-0.1538637429,
0.3865746558,
0.4855266213,
0.6463116407,
-0.647752285,
-0.4120287597,
0.3588863313,
-0.6640017629,
0.3273616135,
-0.2524169087,
0.0460814871,
0.1458218545,
0.640568316,
-0.5908849239,
0.3501687646,
0.4072383344,
-0.5646839738,
0.5350207686,
-0.6839627624,
-0.1164909601,
-0.7649638653,
-0.2365937084,
0.2197139561,
-0.6540956497,
-0.1630293727,
0.3282266855,
0.1502589881,
-0.2300578505,
-0.5308474302,
0.4074736536,
-0.4152302146,
-0.4124403,
-0.3740758598,
-0.3501050472,
0.1112408191,
0.6399799585,
-0.3558733463,
1.1613615751,
0.6405087709,
-0.7753620148,
0.7099775076,
0.191167742,
-0.273663342,
0.3784123659,
-0.3743899167,
-0.5178788304,
-0.3521276116,
0.280629307,
-0.4691896141,
-0.1856529266,
0.674737215,
-0.3401116133,
0.2118174434,
0.1238952056,
-0.2301425785,
-0.4525834918,
0.1703251898,
-0.0575361364,
0.7148073912,
-0.1373447776,
0.9305994511,
0.1424449682,
-0.24048841,
-0.0761205107,
-0.5547730923,
0.2626640797,
-0.2057253122,
0.0275949258,
-0.0959795937,
0.3403792381,
-0.1537540257,
0.2731696665,
-0.2010123134,
-0.2913489342,
0.3184272349,
0.0802128166,
-0.18708691,
0.0338092782,
0.5533825755,
0.2176209986,
-0.1642041206,
0.2316251397,
-0.6927494407,
0.4061701596,
-0.2579924762,
0.0845338702,
-0.5706379414,
0.0168593526,
0.4393039644,
-0.5921719074,
0.4132248461,
0.2519023716,
-0.1746996641,
-0.4373329878,
-0.1036874577,
-0.3069496751,
-0.4890275002,
0.7344532609,
-0.4352394044,
-0.3724949658,
-0.0559220947,
-0.8429644704,
0.0482730232,
0.3234890103,
-0.1822769642,
-0.1961543262,
0.7469165921,
0.6847528219,
0.0624228381,
0.5556076169,
-0.5260048509,
-0.2927735746,
-0.6506419182,
-0.536907196,
-0.0947472602,
-0.2976014018,
-0.0189706981,
-0.9645558596,
0.3289658725,
0.0142509853,
-0.6547785997,
0.1022325307,
-0.3124265075,
0.8260374069,
0.6170871258,
0.2677643597,
0.2101587802,
0.0988236293,
-0.3061856031,
0.3246566951,
-0.9979340434,
-0.661839962,
0.5532503128,
0.6150707603,
0.7124683261,
-0.1285467148,
0.530392766,
0.4806267023,
0.2895327508,
-0.9736177325,
0.6491234899,
-0.3945500851,
0.1298927367,
-0.4520713091,
-0.5975432396,
-0.7300522923,
0.3906793892,
-0.510050118,
-0.4748860598,
-0.0424072929,
0.3855358064,
-0.624132514,
0.3474183083,
-0.5861526728,
0.7335404158,
-0.6886154413,
-0.2094399035,
-0.2053560317,
-0.350459367,
0.001280168,
0.1070997268,
0.5020870566,
-0.4101963639,
0.015740905,
0.5756038427,
-0.4668240547,
0.691732645,
-0.2904230654,
-0.008504861,
0.2890184224,
0.2954191267,
0.5194360018,
0.1349501908,
-0.1729395241,
-0.2015873343,
-0.1779563427,
-0.1584881693,
-0.3886713982,
0.7423245907,
-1.1195098162,
-0.4966167212,
-0.7533085942,
-0.6297086477,
-0.076602295,
0.2899024189,
-0.3217072487,
-0.0788502395,
-0.1729650795,
0.1702375263,
0.6549617052,
-0.6724125147,
0.4988740385,
0.3418369889,
-0.7310469151,
-0.5176637173,
0.8935441375,
0.1510238945,
0.1361112893,
0.2998944521,
0.4877123535,
-0.1902129203,
-0.2703174651,
-0.4864274263,
-0.2751861811,
-0.6580434442,
-0.6405720115,
-0.8967280388,
-0.368561089,
-0.0296603218,
0.098274067,
-0.4578565657,
-0.1293332279,
-0.2686990798,
-0.524835825,
0.6514985561,
0.7036283016,
0.1710676998,
0.8160939217,
-0.5258342028,
0.1880527437,
0.236981824,
0.3493656814,
-0.0125477863,
-0.2381242812,
-0.2071695477,
0.2908130884,
-0.5512990355,
-0.9226078391,
0.7927116156,
0.6511861682,
0.2374029011,
-0.0616291724,
-0.228862226,
0.4791052639,
-0.4507687986,
0.2734308839,
0.4169076383,
-1.07733953,
0.4452545047,
-0.2301669568,
0.5315762162,
0.3750283718,
-0.0104578361,
-0.4146914184,
-0.5335441232,
-0.2678871751,
-1.1266384125,
0.8316847086,
0.0690429956,
0.0429115482,
0.0984059274,
0.381544739,
0.2015656978,
0.1874276549,
-0.6130197048,
-0.0044653341,
-0.2304880917,
-0.2431136817,
-0.0874911249,
-0.0531011075,
0.0940694883,
-0.3738682568,
0.7688630223,
-0.2642149627,
-0.2900636792,
0.2343059629,
-0.000012223,
-0.0432203971,
0.2549989522,
0.2157647908,
0.6572600603,
0.2469803989,
0.1628333479,
0.4097225368,
-0.1999985576,
0.3776161969,
0.1030891687,
-0.4153115749,
-0.3497566879,
-0.1493642777,
0.9864770174,
0.2744759321,
-0.3141306639,
0.3117046654,
0.1426177323,
-0.5502423644,
-0.5642929673,
0.3210735023,
0.1214715317,
0.602381289,
0.5379470587,
0.4400629699,
0.0426618457,
-0.3313095868,
0.4017427564,
0.1966172755,
-0.4143692255,
0.0740483552,
0.647369206,
0.480437696,
-0.2699696422,
0.5243151188,
-0.2457387,
-0.6929064989,
1.1944309473,
0.4670341611,
0.3269245625,
-0.0200285371,
0.8464565277,
0.1979536563,
0.3668276072,
-0.1507480592,
0.5577380657,
0.1910693198,
-0.6645957828,
-0.5016704202,
-0.8186548352,
-0.3424614668,
-0.0013983258,
-0.4845248461,
-0.1629491597,
-0.7620410323,
-0.3989770114,
0.083883144,
-0.0495056361,
-0.9225962162,
0.6759582162,
-0.0006453603,
0.9898008704,
-0.8684553504,
0.6779687405,
1.0984152555,
-0.3113816977,
-1.0490357876,
-0.4442958832,
-0.4870533049,
-1.0266917944,
0.8121669888,
0.1760412902,
-0.1056275368,
0.2636856437,
-0.4263117909,
-0.8380792141,
1.1224719286,
0.1350948066,
-0.846319139,
0.2706954479,
0.1052468419,
0.4333496988,
-0.1772483736,
0.2642633319,
0.3065792322,
0.5979614258,
0.1718274057,
-0.622276485,
-0.1479294151,
0.0573560484,
0.302007854,
0.5176301599,
-0.7657664418,
0.9654390812,
-0.2963478863,
-0.5046668649,
-0.0042690476,
1.0314323902,
0.0360229984,
0.4461891055,
0.415533483,
0.5100395083,
0.7056369781,
-0.295247972,
0.8685229421,
-0.5216742158,
0.4631241858,
1.0158878565,
-0.3212278783,
0.5344716907,
0.6270434856,
-0.1135554463,
0.3502223194,
0.6160153151,
-0.2622421682,
0.2656966746,
0.5041514039,
0.0212548617,
-0.6033461094,
-0.2520083785,
-0.1958729923,
0.5591480732,
0.3997568488,
-0.4310239255,
-0.4123091996,
0.3622508645,
-0.0826121792,
0.8123422265,
-0.6177514195,
0.9208791256,
0.1870902479,
-0.491987139,
-0.1190116927,
0.1143018529,
0.4063012302,
-0.610417366,
-0.2857430875,
-0.2171212137,
0.5145758986,
-0.0429426506,
-0.9636852741,
0.2991822958,
-0.2579537034,
-0.0764652118,
-0.4325667918,
0.4974668026,
-0.5343099833,
-0.7882917523,
0.3443286419,
0.5871370435,
0.0078145154,
0.1524271071,
-0.6316951513,
0.0680762902,
-0.4052111506,
-0.0803778321,
-0.0647608265,
0.4317674637,
-0.1833301932,
0.935875535,
0.5505154133,
0.4498369694,
-0.0397524461,
-0.1980008781,
0.9998525977,
-0.9615412951,
-0.7163769007,
-0.7160586715,
-0.0501667634,
-0.2267824113,
-0.141190961,
0.5874860883,
0.5858873129,
0.9219221473,
-0.2604283988,
1.0136572123,
0.1073231399,
0.1134034842,
-0.4408669174,
0.5606844425,
-0.3365733027,
0.0533280894,
0.2217737734,
-0.7250348926,
-0.0072300797,
0.4809045494,
-0.5069153905,
0.1817878038,
0.3964745402,
0.3398887813,
-0.0168509558,
-0.2902262807,
0.3747728467,
0.1828925461,
0.3478522301,
0.6330970526,
1.0034015179,
-0.1739746183,
0.5369410515,
-0.1480871439,
-0.3503050208,
-0.0934669897,
-0.8125327229,
-0.2123808712,
0.1687317193,
-0.2540961504,
0.1356727779,
0.549777627,
1.0895093679,
0.5026190877,
-0.5516684651,
-0.3174916506,
-0.6076465249,
-0.0231853537,
-0.5640861392,
-0.3061115742,
0.0856453255,
-0.5094550252,
-0.5773758888,
0.380291909,
0.4769800603,
0.1799461246,
-0.0970738083,
-0.217032671,
-0.0540328622,
0.111998789,
0.528542459,
0.3988550901,
-0.5150034428,
-0.062955305,
0.0199402776,
-0.0824093372,
-0.1010489166,
0.4296323359,
-1.1215955019,
0.2091330588,
0.0465848669,
0.7587797046,
-0.0375480913,
0.047354538,
0.6983429193,
-0.3568821847,
0.0327180624,
0.4988191724,
0.0510327853,
0.1959875375,
-0.4210964441,
0.2184890658,
-0.1574472785,
-0.4037913084,
-0.2747375667,
0.5361667275,
-0.6496957541,
-0.522346139,
1.1229537725,
-0.1318079084,
-0.49701792,
0.326926887,
-0.3459012508,
0.3021749258,
-0.731993556,
0.5320093632,
0.1781682074,
0.2303751558,
-0.4100053906,
-0.2451576442,
0.4213455021,
0.5352807045,
-0.8854244947,
-0.3133497834,
0.4434332252,
0.1602361798,
-0.0577217825,
0.4567476809,
0.2775261402,
0.1214856356,
-0.1721469313,
0.261612922,
-0.5152645707,
-0.7947800159,
-0.2290520966,
0.0480791628,
0.1768167168,
-0.4600081444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19837v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19837v3
|
Concept-based Analysis of Neural Networks via Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-28T21:15:38 | 2024-04-10T23:47:34 |
Ravi Mangal, Nina Narodytska, Divya Gopinath, Boyue Caroline Hu, Anirban Roy, Susmit Jha, Corina Pasareanu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LO
|
The analysis of vision-based deep neural networks (DNNs) is highly desirable
but it is very challenging due to the difficulty of expressing formal
specifications for vision tasks and the lack of efficient verification
procedures. In this paper, we propose to leverage emerging multimodal,
vision-language, foundation models (VLMs) as a lens through which we can reason
about vision models. VLMs have been trained on a large body of images
accompanied by their textual description, and are thus implicitly aware of
high-level, human-understandable concepts describing the images. We describe a
logical specification language $\texttt{Con}_{\texttt{spec}}$ designed to
facilitate writing specifications in terms of these concepts. To define and
formally check $\texttt{Con}_{\texttt{spec}}$ specifications, we build a map
between the internal representations of a given vision model and a VLM, leading
to an efficient verification procedure of natural-language properties for
vision models. We demonstrate our techniques on a ResNet-based classifier
trained on the RIVAL-10 dataset using CLIP as the multimodal model.
|
[
-0.5428608656,
-0.5902097225,
0.3621393144,
-0.1164318398,
-0.343357116,
0.1151348576,
-0.2508210242,
-0.6670534015,
0.1340292841,
0.6552231908,
-0.5138632059,
-0.4499007165,
-0.3233659565,
0.0597569533,
-0.6392672658,
0.4186414182,
-0.1532869786,
0.0420391858,
-0.4330155551,
-0.1738691181,
-0.3969556987,
-0.3828410804,
-0.3816888034,
-0.1071722358,
0.4061072767,
0.0188089199,
0.4589825571,
0.3253410161,
0.861782372,
0.4278411567,
-0.1173960119,
0.54730618,
-0.2159387767,
0.0433992781,
-0.2607378066,
-0.3213800192,
-0.3250092268,
0.0430849195,
0.7206004858,
0.4983299375,
0.0826971829,
0.3785223365,
-0.0775564313,
0.5390755534,
-0.7299948931,
0.2923114002,
-0.6928424835,
0.2498383373,
-0.0327840373,
-0.3067346215,
-0.4686892927,
0.0001216121,
0.2628052831,
-0.5351427794,
0.2317095399,
0.0186119061,
1.1497678757,
0.3459570408,
-0.3342655599,
0.0118455412,
-0.6683958173,
0.5194201469,
-0.4208390713,
0.7199323773,
0.2024632394,
0.741558373,
0.0729364753,
-0.9718823433,
-0.8853852749,
-0.5353061557,
-0.4109550118,
0.0691121742,
-0.0168147571,
0.1835147589,
0.2883433998,
0.3466562629,
-0.3328728378,
-0.1634634584,
-0.5544086695,
-0.2389949411,
0.709425211,
0.189719528,
0.2382074594,
-0.0920725092,
-0.5337077975,
-0.0084857047,
-0.4980466366,
-0.0352534391,
-0.0629872158,
0.1287653744,
-0.1764739454,
0.7131317258,
-0.5250421166,
1.0416868925,
-0.1351303458,
-0.0233329125,
0.1265475452,
-0.62393713,
-0.5037343502,
-0.2231953591,
0.7138846517,
0.6674345732,
0.526697278,
-0.1587572992,
-0.3223539591,
0.4510958195,
0.3562079966,
-0.8333795667,
-0.27637133,
0.0024001875,
-0.5382553339,
-0.5093486905,
-0.2042789012,
-0.6860203743,
-0.5640625954,
-0.6303892732,
0.3872595727,
-0.4013252556,
-0.3577249944,
0.2824310064,
-0.0978427604,
0.2591580749,
0.4148908854,
-0.4237414002,
0.2420624346,
0.4655086398,
0.7988417745,
0.1076644585,
-0.2365246862,
-0.1910804212,
-0.1938347518,
-0.499612987,
0.7049900293,
-0.3269959688,
-0.102722019,
-0.06631843,
-0.0645554364,
-0.0770280138,
-0.3842352331,
0.3169602156,
-0.634521842,
-0.0624728352,
-0.0744649768,
-0.6819593906,
-0.4802724123,
0.7799317837,
-0.7461506128,
0.795075953,
-0.0982232839,
-0.622161448,
0.3226597011,
-0.7403939366,
-0.421661824,
0.1708108932,
-0.5497442484,
-0.1780126244,
0.1929143816,
-0.013865822,
0.5534232855,
-0.353710562,
0.4421179891,
-0.3298857212,
-0.1500485837,
0.5011717677,
-0.3657391071,
0.7581944466,
0.21855326,
-0.2996315658,
0.2472444177,
-1.0944404602,
0.1843398064,
0.0237440113,
-0.0015774212,
-0.2878519297,
0.2726227939,
-0.0402595587,
0.2508158088,
0.1436655223,
-0.604564786,
-0.035566926,
-0.1266077608,
0.4876992404,
0.5003718734,
-0.2921544909,
0.1397575438,
0.0733258799,
0.4037458599,
-0.0009328799,
0.3895365596,
-0.3534013033,
-0.4163668156,
-1.0960100889,
-0.2380336672,
0.1628512591,
0.3362469375,
-0.9616838694,
0.1428100318,
-0.2200722992,
-0.3948846459,
-0.2927576602,
-0.1120773628,
0.4575461447,
0.9060319662,
0.3254005611,
-0.2364689261,
-0.7534624338,
-1.1144160032,
0.2794494629,
-0.3125580847,
0.4094896913,
0.40991503,
0.6727046967,
-0.0747813582,
1.2168121338,
-0.5832696557,
-0.1323035657,
-0.2144787759,
-0.2847771049,
-0.1315241903,
0.277805835,
0.7060933113,
-1.2319790125,
-0.1429690421,
0.0540235899,
-1.0326606035,
0.1753849834,
-0.0281797498,
-0.0239310954,
-0.1606645882,
0.7461951971,
-0.3743302524,
0.7200279832,
0.4919121265,
-0.4965493083,
0.8075588346,
-0.0339936838,
0.0109749576,
-0.8357028365,
0.1898051798,
0.4541254342,
-0.289453119,
-0.5743415356,
0.5264859796,
0.1040530577,
-0.120000273,
-0.5400827527,
0.5175510049,
-0.2710856795,
-0.1701827496,
-0.1008886993,
-0.0577957854,
0.4286149144,
0.3895578384,
0.5788695812,
0.5227941275,
0.695223093,
-0.6973409653,
0.8134303093,
0.1738443226,
-0.6359116435,
0.7415956855,
-0.7908789515,
-0.1931209862,
-0.1119297147,
0.1899986267,
-0.9244933128,
-0.0265438315,
0.3250635266,
-0.2918068171,
0.0338905789,
-0.2742056847,
-0.4207196534,
-0.4529981911,
0.2279762328,
0.3842927516,
0.1494922787,
-0.5008772612,
0.810557723,
0.2632724047,
0.5875779986,
-0.4802566767,
-0.7160815001,
0.2940659225,
-0.0298583247,
-0.9466430545,
0.4574351013,
-0.0356377438,
-0.4640247226,
0.1730964482,
0.1788991392,
-0.5061332583,
0.3570881486,
0.3152402639,
0.56043607,
-0.5588220358,
0.2128640413,
-0.5103797317,
0.0165042058,
-0.0275099073,
-0.3905726969,
0.2789966464,
-0.5081871152,
-0.3994965851,
-0.597761333,
0.0775452852,
0.8042777181,
-0.8040052652,
0.4487216175,
0.4894649982,
-0.4616588056,
-0.3157042265,
-0.4557631314,
-0.3355475962,
-0.497418642,
0.5304604769,
-0.5467475653,
-0.6527315378,
0.4692688584,
-0.1112984195,
-0.1786058098,
0.3835059106,
0.4453763962,
-0.3553597927,
0.5125676394,
0.7933431864,
0.4423857927,
0.4938955009,
-0.6376978755,
0.0410514846,
-0.8000519276,
-0.5047510862,
-0.154791683,
-0.6446496248,
-0.1827327013,
-0.4581986368,
0.1512139887,
-0.1398724616,
0.0148426797,
0.4191566706,
-0.4366927445,
0.5869642496,
0.4697421789,
0.0857549161,
0.2221820354,
-0.089881748,
-0.3963442147,
0.1314026862,
-0.4284636974,
-0.2691369355,
0.819331944,
0.3620699644,
0.6819929481,
-0.1631665081,
0.3519143164,
0.1071269661,
0.0778726041,
-1.0030678511,
0.7703482509,
-0.425555855,
-0.7297358513,
-0.1345258802,
-0.2990482152,
-0.3808150291,
0.503117919,
-0.3086842597,
-0.5831000209,
0.528265357,
0.280433625,
-0.5452592969,
0.3878563941,
-0.5831192136,
1.019112587,
-0.5155912638,
-0.2058072537,
-0.2398601919,
-0.4994545877,
0.6556175947,
0.2206271291,
-0.04579686,
-0.1560759246,
0.2181390971,
0.2708490789,
-0.4319930971,
1.1332685947,
0.021621557,
-0.1492319703,
0.4915880561,
0.1883802712,
0.1093183607,
0.0630552098,
0.0890172869,
0.1565818489,
-0.0203840379,
0.0537426546,
-0.7883608341,
0.2133069485,
-0.423117429,
-0.2092484981,
-0.1311296374,
-0.280803889,
-0.1522836238,
0.2875249088,
0.2203977555,
0.9514861107,
-0.1140412614,
0.1720872819,
0.5978342295,
-0.0648271143,
0.3066074848,
0.5504125357,
-0.4987404346,
-0.0867242739,
1.0233969688,
0.0341390073,
0.2317383438,
0.4072556198,
0.277061373,
-0.3634802103,
-0.7379284501,
-0.6238801479,
-0.1989689469,
-0.7792406678,
-0.1712922603,
-0.185196802,
-0.50144732,
-0.0712025687,
0.0923255756,
-0.5455904007,
-0.3659671247,
-0.157314077,
0.0062885839,
0.2372406572,
0.6074952483,
0.2120571584,
0.1227478385,
-0.6761267781,
0.543287456,
0.3581623435,
0.5964981914,
-0.0903946757,
-0.3382421434,
-0.3143599331,
0.1005040556,
-0.0101322513,
-0.6638205647,
0.0971328095,
0.3371411562,
0.6101993322,
0.4234175384,
-0.0599421002,
0.5978716016,
-0.5350865722,
0.7002954483,
0.3465415537,
-0.8096305132,
0.6385643482,
0.1410526335,
-0.1900295168,
0.400000602,
-0.0735373124,
-0.7082039118,
-0.0607256554,
-0.4357618093,
-0.4404257536,
0.4006086588,
0.1643697917,
0.0548416376,
0.0491766818,
0.4621422589,
-0.2891922593,
0.2409767956,
-0.4698502123,
-0.2401148528,
-0.5425165892,
-0.3527931869,
0.0359694809,
-0.1369915307,
-0.2755277455,
-0.3458672762,
0.0998772979,
-0.3617771566,
-0.1087550446,
0.3209685087,
-0.3056810796,
0.4583693445,
-0.1091089621,
0.8811643124,
0.7194545269,
-0.172003597,
0.5327267051,
-0.1188753396,
-0.4173772335,
0.1928746253,
-0.0267476961,
-0.4266120493,
0.2051689923,
0.5075656772,
1.0586386919,
0.253624171,
-0.7381406426,
0.5723493695,
-0.2517399788,
-0.2649973035,
-0.1580290347,
-0.0227332953,
-0.0483531356,
0.374918282,
-0.0395750739,
0.3541896343,
0.1355091333,
-0.3414480686,
0.482237488,
0.3677969277,
-0.6482617855,
-0.4308481514,
0.3017111123,
0.4940134883,
0.0066319169,
0.666924417,
-0.2406336963,
-0.7503273487,
0.9598745704,
0.2978793383,
0.8310878873,
0.2618284225,
0.4288956821,
0.3277117908,
0.4137245417,
0.0309295785,
0.3138555884,
0.0328789651,
-1.217550993,
-0.5863962173,
-0.6409976482,
-0.195743531,
0.0497796908,
-0.4785539508,
0.2648989856,
-0.6332532763,
-0.2265772521,
0.2579777241,
-0.4021927714,
-0.8136562705,
0.5889396071,
0.5503395796,
1.1436942816,
-0.5551298857,
0.932059586,
0.7924853563,
-0.5141015649,
-0.6656191349,
-0.3666948676,
-0.0900029689,
-0.9246396422,
1.3177751303,
0.0858594254,
-0.3935793042,
-0.0991293639,
-0.4986563921,
-0.7537511587,
0.8921947479,
0.5376860499,
-0.6744706035,
-0.0900277868,
-0.1100333631,
0.4677222371,
-0.530898571,
0.1119145826,
0.3273807466,
0.3721898794,
0.2863497436,
-0.9208986759,
-0.094258517,
-0.324716866,
-0.0420876145,
-0.0240670778,
-0.4907349348,
0.9491644502,
-0.3469285369,
-0.2865104377,
-0.042523656,
0.5985808372,
-0.0889370739,
0.1417422146,
0.7094857097,
0.6816213131,
0.708106935,
0.0197485201,
1.1305129528,
-0.2503570318,
0.4033833444,
1.295943737,
-0.2339861989,
0.9344556928,
0.445179224,
-0.1510742456,
0.4638014138,
0.4312045574,
-0.3546084464,
0.5011504889,
0.3372404277,
-0.0396125428,
-0.6129937768,
-0.205033645,
-0.2306551635,
0.8985407948,
0.4087446034,
-0.5165458918,
-0.2679267526,
-0.1013825387,
-0.6127985716,
0.1063900664,
-0.3363595009,
0.6240605712,
0.0657920018,
-0.3811329305,
0.5638561845,
-0.0601458736,
0.5391562581,
-0.4571289718,
-0.0211498998,
0.0155698443,
0.3706299365,
-0.1389220953,
-0.9032748938,
0.4451528192,
-0.0972308144,
-0.2663353682,
0.0159996562,
0.7939851284,
-0.4289395809,
-0.8021746874,
0.2626726627,
0.259180367,
-0.1443264484,
-0.2006260455,
-0.7051147223,
0.2094518989,
-0.2957502007,
0.0792359486,
-0.121016115,
0.2866910696,
-0.0507704392,
0.8370752931,
0.5301667452,
0.0936264247,
0.160424009,
0.2142174095,
0.7723576427,
-0.3960036635,
-0.4273484945,
-1.0479841232,
0.6577674747,
-0.3093235195,
-0.373506844,
0.4304982722,
0.427515775,
0.8506693244,
-0.0225885082,
0.7189768553,
-0.092136085,
-0.0045017814,
-0.7002034783,
0.8312540054,
-0.8659410477,
-0.0038809471,
-0.0128134182,
-0.5673723817,
-0.366286844,
0.822961688,
0.0022003031,
-0.3462309241,
0.6225023866,
0.7160842419,
-0.2621011138,
0.0577229373,
0.3561065793,
-0.0432945304,
0.3356871307,
0.4232035577,
1.1491066217,
-0.1911404729,
0.5365614891,
-0.4662341177,
-0.0430376083,
-0.267234385,
-1.0874650478,
-0.7983680367,
-0.7052839398,
-0.5164939761,
-0.3488872945,
-0.1298195124,
0.483166337,
1.0340548754,
-0.6845294237,
-0.1692172885,
-0.0898958296,
0.2182330042,
-0.2469100952,
-0.1354679763,
0.354221344,
-0.1756374836,
-0.3693082333,
0.3942162395,
0.3426622748,
0.1960271597,
-0.7606659532,
-0.1318473816,
0.0441657603,
-0.0665884465,
0.7479813099,
0.1118311435,
-0.9856433272,
-0.2989013195,
0.1149129197,
-0.1486825645,
-0.1072872803,
0.9532812834,
-0.8854554296,
0.7798144817,
0.5304901004,
0.6510980129,
0.1830933541,
-0.4526410401,
0.662627399,
-0.7784816623,
0.1982024163,
0.1785191298,
0.8057503104,
0.4304667115,
-0.0671112835,
0.5932694077,
0.4959970713,
0.1837141663,
-0.8105850816,
0.5019750595,
-1.0457681417,
-0.3639987111,
0.9517683387,
-0.3564546406,
-0.2190903276,
0.1216217652,
-0.262264967,
0.067745693,
0.1615386158,
0.5998514295,
0.6319701076,
0.2398783863,
-0.4161970913,
-0.5191142559,
0.5291717649,
-0.0141051123,
-0.7039853334,
0.0527675077,
0.406093657,
0.1536552459,
0.5153310895,
0.3548313081,
-0.0279533006,
0.3461303711,
-0.0003732281,
0.009089401,
-0.4111700356,
-0.5651571751,
-0.0149876038,
0.2577240467,
-0.2519218028,
-0.6368841529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19836v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19836v2
|
Target Span Detection for Implicit Harmful Content
| 2024-03-28T21:15:15 | 2024-06-27T22:28:27 |
Nazanin Jafari, James Allan, Sheikh Muhammad Sarwar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Identifying the targets of hate speech is a crucial step in grasping the
nature of such speech and, ultimately, in improving the detection of offensive
posts on online forums. Much harmful content on online platforms uses implicit
language especially when targeting vulnerable and protected groups such as
using stereotypical characteristics instead of explicit target names, making it
harder to detect and mitigate the language. In this study, we focus on
identifying implied targets of hate speech, essential for recognizing subtler
hate speech and enhancing the detection of harmful content on digital
platforms. We define a new task aimed at identifying the targets even when they
are not explicitly stated. To address that task, we collect and annotate target
spans in three prominent implicit hate speech datasets: SBIC, DynaHate, and
IHC. We call the resulting merged collection Implicit-Target-Span. The
collection is achieved using an innovative pooling method with matching scores
based on human annotations and Large Language Models (LLMs). Our experiments
indicate that Implicit-Target-Span provides a challenging test bed for target
span detection methods.
|
[
-0.5917509794,
-0.8575699925,
0.2976456583,
0.1227096915,
-0.0698861554,
0.1001851782,
-0.0334862806,
-1.0277285576,
0.0585976392,
0.2946564555,
-0.8348644972,
-0.3097682297,
-1.0107632875,
-0.0137425577,
-0.8993496299,
1.2781472206,
-0.0160190128,
-0.3168175519,
0.3310735822,
0.0565363206,
-0.4225188494,
0.0241053421,
-0.9254187942,
0.263728261,
0.8876956105,
0.1325211525,
0.3421860337,
0.5843753815,
0.3747497499,
0.1970182806,
-0.0007981146,
0.0808792487,
-0.6761893034,
0.4343851209,
-0.030048186,
-0.1448808461,
-0.1272522807,
0.1841600835,
0.6932701468,
0.3091239035,
0.5934827924,
0.2231603861,
0.0292229615,
0.3122909367,
-1.0214087963,
-0.196437493,
-0.7619018555,
0.2275690436,
-0.5066239834,
0.0980992541,
-0.3019683361,
-0.370616734,
-0.1333939284,
-0.3510139287,
0.1381758749,
0.1230674833,
0.5552137494,
0.4025168717,
-0.3808506727,
-0.4803383052,
-0.6947905421,
0.6331456304,
-0.3095805347,
0.3383466899,
0.3838304579,
0.2683290243,
0.0242124237,
-0.2705541253,
-0.5596823692,
-0.2995992899,
-0.2329297066,
-0.1412106007,
-0.9459571242,
0.0146669121,
0.4203599095,
0.033284232,
-0.4744185507,
0.5652711391,
-0.5894787312,
-0.4666491151,
0.7740466595,
-0.0576969832,
0.4302813113,
-0.0519957282,
-0.5270329118,
0.1737903059,
-0.5736906528,
-0.3664357066,
0.9023005366,
0.5466976166,
-0.0106876129,
0.7727573514,
-0.0075687133,
0.4093543589,
0.2574799657,
0.1541195661,
-0.0316964649,
0.1138641089,
0.2791938484,
0.4653829932,
0.5152441263,
0.448670119,
0.577722609,
-0.0177885406,
0.0541640259,
0.5400111079,
0.4647819996,
-0.590374589,
0.0452715605,
0.0092880707,
-0.0420119874,
-0.2492744327,
-0.1380619556,
-0.6502600312,
-0.7493243217,
0.0315855108,
0.1706374586,
-0.3272965252,
-0.4381774366,
-0.3126510382,
-0.3777168691,
0.1221565902,
0.0464031622,
-0.7496041059,
0.5236684084,
0.6932005882,
0.6452587843,
-0.4831110239,
0.0134721166,
-0.8920299411,
0.3285146952,
-0.1353160441,
0.6436553001,
-0.6565826535,
-0.0629682243,
0.1634857357,
-0.2143435925,
0.2769239545,
-0.3646141589,
1.078289628,
-0.4174194932,
0.0976285413,
-0.1297256649,
-0.6784287095,
-0.0956751928,
0.3047927022,
-0.7939392924,
1.1447088718,
0.1444179416,
-0.8673271537,
0.5576528907,
-0.5469833612,
-0.3820407689,
0.1009875685,
0.0658164173,
-0.5975622535,
0.0299788564,
0.0549829192,
0.5877487063,
0.142624408,
-0.1588485986,
-0.4494856298,
-0.5083981156,
-0.0624411143,
-0.4236846566,
0.4749247432,
0.1239212155,
-0.8537980914,
0.31760481,
-0.4424755573,
-0.2177164555,
0.0594320633,
0.0022377451,
-0.7361636162,
0.0261216033,
0.4861906469,
0.3516640365,
0.1077605709,
-0.6362989545,
-0.118224293,
0.0372615829,
-0.0730604157,
1.1013067961,
-0.1352048516,
-0.0005304138,
-0.1431535631,
0.4876419902,
-0.1970213503,
0.2389632165,
0.4997729957,
-0.382475853,
-0.4861226678,
-0.7101899981,
-0.2867842913,
0.2132205814,
-0.090733707,
0.3912490904,
0.0535860769,
-0.4074879885,
-0.3276276588,
-0.0798408389,
0.7174757123,
0.3917836547,
0.7280774117,
0.1704571098,
-0.930632174,
-1.0841299295,
-0.5950256586,
-0.1860409677,
0.0020587705,
0.2009751201,
0.5240088105,
-0.1638989449,
0.7561224699,
-0.5999225974,
-0.4502298534,
-0.0822727382,
0.3414287865,
-0.4464572072,
0.2171093374,
0.5979834199,
-1.1336952448,
-0.8101428747,
-0.4917485118,
-0.240647912,
-0.6624169946,
0.1961165965,
-0.1702674627,
-0.2016326189,
0.5972283483,
-0.1628620476,
0.2466797829,
0.5657860637,
-0.592366457,
0.7275337577,
0.7265930176,
0.3053286374,
-0.621955514,
-0.0826756954,
0.4007631242,
-0.2003901005,
-0.7506244183,
-0.3451693654,
-0.2480276227,
0.314312309,
-0.6343402863,
0.6602939963,
-0.247496888,
-0.1668881327,
-0.428634584,
0.2169702202,
-0.3858828247,
0.2592097819,
0.1130535901,
0.4205587208,
0.2034891546,
-0.3731579483,
0.1909437925,
0.0525025316,
-0.000374852,
0.9309407473,
-0.4036715031,
0.0184315145,
-0.2311959863,
0.2018319666,
-1.0510075092,
-0.0788620785,
0.7729558349,
-0.264146775,
0.1136766598,
-0.365246743,
-0.176606372,
-0.4179033935,
-0.5271230936,
0.6392338872,
0.1262106299,
-0.3811338842,
0.1868128181,
0.5360427499,
0.0212980211,
-0.8711942434,
-0.5124429464,
-0.1965007484,
-0.5889261961,
-0.3230315447,
0.6704306602,
-0.0846821219,
-0.4455825686,
0.0484720096,
-0.2724216282,
-0.0787416622,
0.1011498868,
0.7068084478,
0.1667758971,
0.029351037,
-0.069549948,
0.2107117623,
-0.0236016288,
0.24130705,
-0.0258025583,
0.4558102787,
-0.036549978,
-0.4002639651,
-0.1589399874,
0.6837348342,
0.4481568038,
-0.0249028485,
0.5579997301,
0.9619279504,
-0.7355154753,
-0.4329447746,
-0.7105886936,
-0.2260234356,
-0.4140734375,
0.3375235796,
-0.1037636623,
-1.2707041502,
0.2151717097,
0.1877885312,
-0.07387124,
0.6873486042,
0.2922799587,
0.0286127347,
1.1163115501,
0.626454711,
-0.3385073245,
0.5242143869,
0.1716432869,
-0.1069492772,
-0.7601583004,
-0.1994543821,
-0.6002175808,
-0.3609898388,
-0.347677052,
-0.3264836967,
0.3706199229,
-0.076665692,
-0.3591589034,
0.5636719465,
-0.5877028704,
0.5134603381,
0.1977749318,
0.0320818573,
0.2846252024,
0.2165091932,
0.1454172432,
-0.3060700893,
-0.040275611,
-0.2706869245,
0.8141794205,
0.4594278336,
0.3194203079,
0.1352106631,
0.3415220082,
0.922080636,
0.5416986942,
-0.7656213641,
0.4557563961,
-0.1806215942,
-1.0034373999,
-0.2696480453,
-0.3239889145,
-0.7998754382,
0.032619223,
-0.2859218121,
-0.8837279677,
-0.1006975248,
0.1215361729,
-0.1117332503,
0.4112531245,
-0.1748057008,
0.7687678933,
-0.2108256817,
-0.4942473769,
-0.2859407961,
-0.430521816,
0.5267782807,
-0.1020994633,
0.0852467194,
-0.5472993851,
-0.1280652136,
0.7839269638,
-0.0061288942,
0.9756714702,
-0.2605388165,
-0.1994259208,
0.1214286834,
0.1016694307,
0.4006791711,
-0.4532244802,
-0.1252976209,
0.1506285518,
-0.6001836658,
-0.1441679746,
-0.1534772962,
0.5758449435,
-0.3686727881,
-0.1093455106,
-0.4119388163,
-0.4723091424,
-0.3233853281,
0.2477406263,
0.1361053437,
-0.0499349274,
-0.4218569696,
-0.166830942,
0.6097487807,
-0.0325107016,
0.2070810497,
0.591177702,
0.148553133,
-0.0010528185,
0.602804482,
-0.188797608,
0.0681963712,
0.2745276988,
-0.0252415724,
-0.6105149388,
-0.6185262203,
-0.1263817251,
0.1707824469,
-0.4852679968,
-0.1041208431,
-0.691972971,
-0.202221334,
-0.282476306,
-0.4145531058,
-0.2504928112,
0.0490601324,
-0.0804335326,
-0.3264999688,
0.5114023089,
0.8055437207,
-0.3743965924,
0.2961425185,
-0.2554174662,
0.471655041,
0.2999368906,
0.225449115,
-0.4102940261,
-0.4937520027,
0.0876267105,
-0.0315343626,
0.1793955863,
-1.234970212,
0.3302238882,
0.0231933296,
0.5812163353,
0.4121743143,
0.1628856361,
0.506685853,
-0.5190122724,
0.3737102747,
0.2858691812,
-0.8195703626,
0.7878988981,
-0.4325302243,
-0.3350164294,
0.5454753041,
1.0937516689,
-0.6152129173,
-0.5207316279,
-0.3391171396,
-0.8048878908,
0.5660142899,
0.3338695168,
0.0381107666,
-0.3027713597,
0.125224039,
0.0780667439,
0.2210312635,
-1.0568780899,
-0.4624118209,
0.1773613691,
-0.2627580762,
0.3036474586,
-0.3899734616,
-0.346290499,
-0.0369708389,
0.7515006065,
-0.0803749934,
0.0197918732,
-0.2618731856,
-0.2943989336,
-0.4450109005,
0.183054477,
0.2612367272,
0.0981660485,
-0.0979858339,
0.2305753231,
0.0256474707,
-0.6047572494,
0.1762155294,
0.4090557396,
-0.1142657176,
-0.1444226652,
0.2841758728,
0.6540473104,
0.2524535358,
-0.8828789592,
0.7495834231,
0.1110262051,
0.0539844409,
-0.4398417473,
0.005086523,
-0.3432646096,
0.3607576787,
0.4720353782,
-0.2146494985,
0.4542869627,
-0.3529106081,
0.564370513,
0.5120550394,
-0.8518896699,
-0.0157760605,
0.6180512309,
0.0221534446,
0.1314969063,
0.5558335185,
-0.1398382634,
-0.8165554404,
0.4996914864,
0.6269662976,
0.8715173006,
-0.2673036158,
0.4380266964,
0.3850124776,
0.3872205317,
0.358043164,
-0.138050124,
-0.1050435975,
-0.6713232398,
-0.2857113183,
-0.7747493982,
-0.1144722402,
0.1589522064,
-0.5457457304,
0.3520784974,
-0.4771190286,
0.1235021129,
0.362423867,
-0.0074039963,
-0.2147969455,
0.2108738273,
0.8837910891,
0.4668782353,
-1.3406476974,
0.1636456996,
0.1636592597,
-0.3023893833,
-0.6953914762,
0.0361983478,
0.5158711076,
-0.787905395,
0.8458727002,
0.3692498207,
-0.482570678,
-0.0347160548,
-0.5688043237,
-0.594476223,
0.5976865888,
0.3882113695,
-0.4986251891,
-0.0306893662,
0.3064764142,
0.5071421862,
-0.3219139874,
0.2907983363,
0.5088922381,
0.6230877042,
0.1463932097,
-0.6731312871,
0.4524292648,
-0.1794311404,
-0.4196245074,
0.452409178,
-0.3158609271,
0.8957372308,
0.1711624563,
-0.2486215979,
-0.2816746235,
0.477009654,
0.4792094231,
0.2100335211,
1.01092875,
0.3964274526,
0.5334331989,
-0.1683156192,
0.730617702,
0.2746887505,
-0.1200983748,
1.0488753319,
-0.0653286204,
0.6255031228,
0.2235355228,
-0.0996439382,
0.5847354531,
0.4173544049,
-0.331075877,
0.232751593,
0.6543796659,
-0.6799769998,
-0.1111270115,
-0.5841805935,
-0.2769473493,
0.4482345879,
0.7576279044,
-0.386184752,
-0.2933140993,
0.1651401669,
0.4565383792,
0.2867668867,
-0.6175885201,
0.5138474703,
-0.2651896775,
-0.4234578013,
0.2582238019,
0.1239023879,
1.0418221951,
-0.6927468777,
-0.1033751369,
0.1757652462,
-0.032095436,
-0.384858191,
-0.6304571033,
0.5333471298,
0.4190098643,
-0.1051091403,
-0.1468454897,
1.021079421,
-0.5741657019,
-0.138331458,
0.656547606,
0.2175367624,
0.1859147698,
-0.5740546584,
-0.9414439201,
0.3628757298,
-0.2178830504,
-0.013277526,
0.1502735466,
-0.1297909468,
-0.2352171838,
0.3329571486,
0.5492099524,
0.1262947619,
0.4740733206,
0.0805961043,
0.8096818328,
-0.3237915635,
-0.4147491753,
-0.773735404,
0.5813729167,
-0.343367815,
-0.3388037682,
0.9476223588,
0.6142333746,
0.8996983171,
0.0959574133,
0.7338771224,
-0.4167155623,
0.6362248063,
-0.1826662421,
0.4517410696,
-0.5672405958,
-0.0410701223,
-0.7460580468,
-1.0104587078,
-0.3758591413,
0.4640493095,
-0.4811597168,
0.0852856562,
0.3989263475,
0.6920958161,
-0.1037746817,
-0.122623086,
0.1144171506,
0.3109107912,
0.2465742975,
0.4107238054,
1.0915104151,
-0.2587432563,
0.8387707472,
-0.2158228755,
-0.1120118722,
-0.2163341492,
-0.892280221,
-0.7990659475,
-0.4764613211,
-0.6199487448,
-0.3921289146,
0.4300911725,
0.7880924344,
0.8203062415,
-0.8707190156,
0.1225781888,
-0.0321915783,
0.0979913622,
-0.3475587666,
-0.2485663146,
0.2453084588,
0.1358145177,
-1.1214497089,
0.5596482754,
0.303104043,
0.0168786999,
-0.2566802204,
0.0807834715,
-0.4967233241,
-0.0269178599,
0.5371565223,
0.5852066875,
-0.5925218463,
-0.4986346066,
-0.2226559222,
-0.1124434993,
-0.5203664303,
0.739292562,
-0.4551104903,
0.0337778181,
0.079325445,
0.5954657197,
0.6735984087,
0.0161303263,
0.1935470104,
-1.2902605534,
0.1123318449,
0.6154552698,
0.1839725524,
0.2367429137,
-0.4848430455,
0.4521358907,
0.227460742,
0.026672598,
-0.869568944,
0.4118797481,
-1.1211313009,
-0.4073402286,
1.2266340256,
0.0513705015,
0.0590931475,
-0.347689867,
-0.3733092844,
0.4630046487,
-0.3218079507,
0.7027701139,
0.3253608942,
-0.0446464308,
-0.0160319097,
-0.3190865219,
0.837687254,
0.2960965633,
-0.8586347699,
-0.0139171351,
1.0374602079,
0.2265809923,
0.1669861227,
0.4998503923,
-0.0682914108,
0.221230492,
0.0471783988,
-0.1139235049,
0.0004133376,
-0.5231103897,
0.0081161307,
0.4638624191,
-0.4428467751,
-0.1301003546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19827v1
|
Language Models Learn Rare Phenomena from Less Rare Phenomena: The Case of the Missing AANNs
| 2024-03-28T20:35:10 | 2024-03-28T20:35:10 |
Kanishka Misra, Kyle Mahowald
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models learn rare syntactic phenomena, but it has been argued that
they rely on rote memorization, as opposed to grammatical generalization.
Training on a corpus of human-scale in size (100M words), we iteratively
trained transformer language models on systematically manipulated corpora and
then evaluated their learning of a particular rare grammatical phenomenon: the
English Article+Adjective+Numeral+Noun (AANN) construction (``a beautiful five
days''). We first compared how well this construction was learned on the
default corpus relative to a counterfactual corpus in which the AANN sentences
were removed. AANNs were still learned better than systematically perturbed
variants of the construction. Using additional counterfactual corpora, we
suggest that this learning occurs through generalization from related
constructions (e.g., ``a few days''). An additional experiment showed that this
learning is enhanced when there is more variability in the input. Taken
together, our results provide an existence proof that models learn rare
grammatical phenomena by generalization from less rare phenomena. Code
available at https://github.com/kanishkamisra/aannalysis
|
[
-0.1311830133,
-0.8947914243,
0.3826121092,
0.0866977647,
-0.1621673107,
-0.1937947124,
-0.1567229331,
-0.3928448856,
0.3972189724,
0.408441633,
-0.4968602657,
-0.2876523435,
-0.4934524298,
0.2966923416,
-0.7220441103,
0.8481352329,
0.2991556525,
0.0904009715,
0.0536901392,
-0.2691013515,
-0.060664244,
-0.5392878056,
-0.3812789619,
-0.1758822203,
0.5798999667,
0.0499653891,
0.8453330994,
0.8068686724,
0.6013274789,
0.2287936509,
-0.2751574814,
0.2078983784,
-0.2676377296,
-0.1762779802,
-0.1445455551,
-0.7444537282,
-0.3227635324,
-0.0433596857,
0.6187646389,
1.2258192301,
-0.2494537681,
-0.0880719572,
-0.0850064531,
0.9412165284,
-0.671354115,
0.1109815761,
-0.723556459,
0.3424724638,
-0.1352640688,
0.3316093981,
-0.350153625,
-0.263763696,
0.1310201138,
-0.6399825811,
0.5722585917,
-0.1428199559,
1.1330262423,
0.1816870421,
-0.538957417,
-0.2825100124,
-0.8897408247,
0.807705462,
-0.6039867997,
0.4795434177,
0.4521767497,
0.0483458228,
-0.0206140876,
-0.6698681712,
-0.6592502594,
-0.6153243184,
-0.0269774348,
-0.0181550495,
-0.5285291076,
0.024075428,
0.2860589921,
0.4680975378,
-0.8003371954,
0.1311098188,
-0.5677765608,
-0.117744714,
0.5073464513,
0.1007451192,
0.3375011981,
-0.384093076,
0.1011295542,
-0.0992771685,
-0.8382148743,
-0.1822611988,
0.4982842207,
0.2470885962,
-0.370270282,
0.4932918847,
-0.0770311281,
0.5520038009,
-0.0523297451,
0.327229917,
0.4814390838,
-0.2351768762,
-0.1539767832,
-0.3369375467,
0.6936575174,
-0.1660350561,
0.3951189518,
-0.2507808805,
-0.1394037455,
0.3800416291,
0.3014763594,
-0.4028519988,
-0.6137164235,
-0.2640079856,
-0.6361368895,
-0.3697224259,
-0.1034269929,
-0.1915499717,
-0.1015227139,
-0.2539530993,
0.2648739815,
-0.4164009094,
-0.3103154004,
-0.0437785685,
-0.0601918586,
-0.1124065369,
0.1681303531,
-0.9227027893,
0.276968658,
0.5353351831,
0.6668353677,
-0.3020660281,
-0.4533195496,
-0.4858517051,
-0.4362185001,
-0.5738122463,
0.7098058462,
-0.536446631,
-0.1500106007,
-0.0197153352,
0.0712673441,
-0.2920928597,
-0.754760623,
0.2007413954,
-0.6348478198,
0.1138228625,
0.0819004402,
-0.518565774,
-0.3375009,
0.0950319245,
-0.8607689142,
0.5788301229,
-0.0233463645,
-0.3865290284,
0.2305310071,
-0.5064531565,
-0.4656207561,
-0.1993575245,
-0.1002495885,
-0.4874583185,
0.7443104982,
-0.247613728,
0.2561054826,
0.1064113453,
0.1904159784,
-0.1812439859,
-0.1366200894,
0.2086360455,
-0.6629790664,
0.7763487697,
0.2995530665,
-0.2909552157,
-0.0922089443,
-1.2476140261,
-0.2735693157,
0.2094250172,
-0.5286594629,
-0.5364336371,
-0.1202161163,
0.0950710177,
0.0774462447,
-0.1220139861,
-0.3931414187,
0.2710921466,
-0.8506520391,
0.1878836155,
0.3162766397,
-0.0148927867,
0.6361816525,
-0.3020990193,
0.2383960336,
0.5122460723,
0.0823442936,
-0.1075635254,
-0.3446942568,
-1.1822010279,
0.0506054685,
0.3719328642,
0.3182573915,
-0.6716367006,
-0.0286529157,
-0.291811347,
-0.1502693594,
-0.4173682332,
0.4765532017,
0.5602989793,
0.1277614087,
0.3608718216,
-0.5162373185,
-0.6712510586,
-0.9886872768,
-0.3459436893,
-0.3435570896,
0.0896102637,
0.0003371792,
0.5619425178,
-0.2647661269,
0.624329865,
-0.2015121132,
-0.2384164929,
-0.1840377599,
0.522536099,
0.0345728546,
0.3044554293,
0.6457793713,
-0.8397805095,
-0.3221596777,
-0.1116710082,
-0.8336631656,
0.2077170312,
-0.0854898095,
0.5289107561,
0.6619560122,
0.6813990474,
-0.6140449643,
0.5450583696,
0.5242131352,
-0.1142472103,
0.6563321352,
-0.179886654,
-0.4697510302,
-0.820658803,
-0.2286876142,
-0.175456211,
-0.3086930513,
-0.6056447029,
0.080000557,
0.0585124753,
0.1590302587,
-0.5908406377,
0.4603084326,
-0.5752776861,
0.1257631928,
-0.5455000997,
-0.3878734112,
-0.2276208997,
0.5239027143,
0.1615397632,
0.275947243,
0.4702350199,
-0.7295408845,
0.0267354529,
0.1151561961,
-0.1319424361,
0.1251570433,
-0.3186266124,
0.2270550132,
-0.3865527809,
-0.1588509381,
-0.5542524457,
-0.2844897211,
0.0467369147,
-0.3439924121,
0.0194867793,
-0.118016094,
-0.2400255501,
-0.0937239528,
0.1192165986,
0.1774895191,
0.4994081259,
-0.4578034878,
0.7091822028,
0.082037136,
-0.10235551,
-0.4021368027,
-0.793977797,
0.2583270669,
-0.0643437356,
-0.0704386309,
-0.0045942953,
-0.0106203407,
-0.5543317795,
0.4547453225,
-0.14866364,
-0.2909685671,
0.4611211717,
0.2842237055,
0.1253090054,
-0.4914553761,
0.2867235839,
-0.2476969659,
0.089618437,
0.2266508788,
-0.1176812947,
0.5147686601,
-0.3301397264,
-0.4227826297,
-0.2866923213,
0.4288009405,
0.3973897099,
0.0321161747,
0.8011069298,
0.5369108915,
-0.569033742,
-0.296490103,
-0.5144292712,
-0.2223311216,
-0.3661682308,
0.6212918758,
-0.3732508123,
-0.6202103496,
0.5077795386,
0.2699455023,
0.0789300576,
0.7911717892,
0.265760541,
-0.0752588585,
0.9256510139,
0.9286028743,
-0.0732928589,
0.5930187702,
-0.3857564032,
0.0516277105,
-0.4414820373,
-0.0598591156,
-0.2130497545,
-0.0924038738,
-0.8220838308,
-0.1218239516,
0.3771425486,
-0.0410002731,
-0.2038960755,
0.1730513424,
0.071203582,
0.5197144151,
0.5589634776,
0.0485105067,
0.4305305481,
0.1234307662,
-0.401165843,
-0.0603458881,
-0.734048903,
-0.4922236502,
1.0102000237,
0.229140684,
0.6370081306,
0.1809760034,
0.8951556683,
0.1815556288,
0.2883199453,
-0.8045116663,
0.4029549658,
-0.5337818861,
-0.4248432219,
-0.1372962594,
-0.6066270471,
-1.0542314053,
0.232766822,
-0.3414799273,
-0.4628843367,
0.4280603826,
0.2584454119,
-0.3979439735,
0.0806211233,
-0.5277440548,
0.5737968683,
-0.1660677046,
-0.2046248466,
-0.4768484533,
-0.7894554138,
0.3330671191,
0.0811730325,
0.4235544801,
0.114026919,
0.2406407148,
0.532230258,
-0.509960711,
1.1049484015,
0.161537692,
0.0002878275,
0.0371548906,
0.2324031293,
0.4166089594,
-0.0634555593,
0.2941481769,
-0.0003038838,
-0.4663895965,
-0.4046351612,
-0.6184899807,
0.5590919256,
-0.7753777504,
-0.4034689963,
-0.5307158828,
-0.5238173008,
-0.0928665474,
0.0923441648,
0.3943206668,
0.351205796,
-0.4944594502,
0.1550924927,
0.6628751755,
0.0138464468,
0.8364555836,
0.6843493581,
-0.1724824756,
-0.1431118399,
0.8672599196,
0.1623101681,
0.3684431314,
0.3578091562,
0.2752641737,
0.2293870747,
-0.5357999802,
-0.2730080783,
0.3241196573,
-0.67841506,
0.0436998829,
-0.945851922,
-0.5027726293,
-0.2097017765,
0.179115504,
-0.6974722147,
-0.825070858,
-0.4976355135,
-0.1877684146,
0.287225008,
0.9006605744,
-0.4012883604,
0.1266432106,
-0.8311470747,
0.5350120664,
0.4408262372,
0.0173071008,
0.1899890602,
-0.5961833,
-0.2861588597,
0.2044647485,
-0.3886069357,
-0.6186702251,
0.5587242246,
0.7265832424,
0.3869331777,
0.4807640314,
-0.3280367553,
0.4826639891,
-0.5991739631,
0.7255868912,
0.2161197066,
-0.6760210395,
0.4348698854,
-0.2965497673,
0.5349482298,
0.3697861135,
0.3178740442,
-0.6128149629,
-0.6255363226,
-0.9605626464,
-1.1033664942,
0.3106946647,
0.1658718735,
0.5192355514,
-0.273437798,
0.3791754246,
0.2399771661,
0.1336780041,
-1.0732030869,
-0.6002913713,
-0.238113001,
-0.079823792,
-0.1571772099,
-0.2124952227,
0.1436624676,
-0.0746165887,
0.6333582401,
-0.0550056957,
0.0583170392,
0.1482066959,
-0.7686291933,
0.0100703333,
0.3772826493,
0.7689903378,
0.5216536522,
0.0701720789,
0.46175313,
0.1929500997,
-0.7045066357,
-0.0661474541,
-0.044881586,
-0.2361382693,
0.3818536103,
0.6498497128,
1.0674747229,
0.3698925674,
-0.3516677022,
0.4384601116,
-0.1161512807,
-0.1656506807,
-0.5024214387,
0.1907292753,
0.1638462096,
0.0464774407,
0.5648036599,
0.4614798427,
0.3164710999,
-0.8938857317,
0.1864007562,
0.2790891826,
-0.3829799294,
-0.8196984529,
0.5662592053,
-0.1869672239,
-0.2677830458,
0.6433094144,
-0.6522714496,
-0.4876342714,
0.6767876148,
0.5517038703,
0.9629437327,
-0.2763730586,
0.277523756,
0.2792994976,
0.3154042959,
-0.4163033664,
0.2754686475,
0.2353853583,
-0.7454932928,
-0.233414799,
-0.6919789314,
-0.2243213058,
0.2684991658,
-0.6021572948,
0.2065125406,
-0.4241890609,
0.1150740981,
0.215281263,
-0.3504941463,
-1.0018177032,
0.1833857149,
0.2551985979,
0.4500148892,
-1.3566942215,
0.5421950817,
0.9562812448,
-0.5338215232,
-0.8278049827,
-0.0736448169,
0.1873157769,
-0.6847422719,
0.8912770152,
-0.1438317597,
0.0963568464,
-0.0808838829,
-0.4890690744,
-0.842595458,
0.2239620388,
0.3757738769,
-0.7918128371,
-0.16844666,
0.2341070026,
0.9753051996,
-0.2715191245,
0.219463855,
0.3887723088,
0.0908497721,
-0.0256958473,
-1.2188183069,
-0.2114217579,
-0.4255647361,
-0.0620682761,
0.0030192456,
-0.530087471,
0.8964932561,
-0.4450457394,
-0.1085899025,
0.0833266899,
0.7328339815,
-0.1277712286,
0.2753917575,
0.401589036,
0.7083286047,
0.7846226096,
0.1924813986,
1.005918026,
0.223573938,
0.2631614208,
1.0868942738,
0.0654374808,
0.9139620662,
0.4152309,
0.0007601063,
0.6459001899,
0.3219815195,
0.1509944797,
0.7107311487,
0.1862256378,
-0.1748826802,
-0.3764536679,
-0.0688841939,
-0.3225053251,
0.795184195,
0.2920730412,
-0.4256313145,
-0.2297685146,
0.5092197657,
0.0692451745,
0.1285267323,
-0.3764151633,
0.9688482285,
0.5119879842,
-0.4076735675,
0.8400162458,
-0.2399763018,
0.5329313278,
-0.2025128901,
-0.0402991399,
-0.4437585175,
0.2276940048,
-0.174102217,
-0.0218532681,
0.6471379399,
-0.077576749,
-0.5471875668,
-0.0254369769,
0.4053710699,
-0.3766230643,
-0.8477888107,
0.0706285909,
0.7510687113,
0.2228085995,
0.2379203886,
-0.3667240441,
-0.1829539686,
-0.2380152941,
-0.2416251451,
0.375449568,
0.3817501068,
-0.4768383205,
0.7304362655,
0.4626446068,
0.3828162551,
0.2358380258,
0.3992896378,
0.7401961684,
-0.685680449,
-0.5583061576,
-0.9268903732,
0.2738409042,
0.2166555375,
-0.3738680482,
0.691985786,
0.7067601681,
0.7876663208,
-0.4208227396,
0.6941050291,
0.1859275103,
0.5333836079,
-0.6261284947,
0.8066924214,
-0.5630341172,
0.4331516623,
-0.0819504112,
-0.8194287419,
-0.5164417028,
0.7545324564,
-0.2025867403,
-0.1994708627,
1.0112657547,
0.6221852899,
-0.3639578819,
-0.0647597462,
0.298617363,
0.440992415,
-0.0309707094,
0.4093288779,
1.0267937183,
-0.4974137247,
0.3335068524,
-0.1737408936,
0.2579055429,
-0.2088716477,
-0.7982299328,
-0.8165355325,
-0.6835668087,
-0.6369624138,
-0.0684737638,
0.4558684528,
1.177064538,
0.4204983711,
-0.983179152,
-0.0863466263,
-0.4668030441,
0.1997698247,
-0.2754441202,
-0.1988685429,
0.3579126894,
-0.3704639673,
-0.5714176297,
0.4464096427,
-0.0054268665,
0.1852831095,
-0.0123848822,
0.2537516654,
-0.1175896525,
-0.110992223,
0.3646011651,
0.45475173,
-0.677990973,
-0.353207767,
0.2467202544,
-0.1477228105,
0.2610908449,
0.513661027,
-0.7294596434,
0.1773504913,
0.4097259045,
0.3392342925,
0.4672703445,
-0.3075468838,
0.5176963806,
-0.8238341808,
0.153907463,
0.3078312576,
0.3886431456,
0.3598346114,
-0.1953871548,
0.2714902163,
0.4600776434,
-0.1318535954,
-0.9083492756,
0.3460695148,
-0.5498028398,
-0.1488810182,
1.2043281794,
-0.0903719217,
-0.2607322037,
-0.2359033376,
0.4158734679,
0.1897685081,
-0.0735209212,
1.1491373777,
0.6643862724,
-0.166687727,
-0.2093393356,
-0.6142256856,
0.5344241858,
0.7538223267,
-0.5819100142,
-0.3226352334,
0.582549572,
0.6027117968,
0.364328593,
0.2356908619,
0.0705480054,
0.6693738103,
-0.1030781642,
-0.0308402088,
-0.0215180162,
-0.5715551972,
-0.6471740603,
0.1824279279,
0.143424049,
-0.1286147833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19822v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19822v1
|
Multi-Stage Multi-Modal Pre-Training for Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-03-28T20:23:39 | 2024-03-28T20:23:39 |
Yash Jain, David Chan, Pranav Dheram, Aparna Khare, Olabanji Shonibare, Venkatesh Ravichandran, Shalini Ghosh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advances in machine learning have demonstrated that multi-modal
pre-training can improve automatic speech recognition (ASR) performance
compared to randomly initialized models, even when models are fine-tuned on
uni-modal tasks. Existing multi-modal pre-training methods for the ASR task
have primarily focused on single-stage pre-training where a single unsupervised
task is used for pre-training followed by fine-tuning on the downstream task.
In this work, we introduce a novel method combining multi-modal and multi-task
unsupervised pre-training with a translation-based supervised mid-training
approach. We empirically demonstrate that such a multi-stage approach leads to
relative word error rate (WER) improvements of up to 38.45% over baselines on
both Librispeech and SUPERB. Additionally, we share several important findings
for choosing pre-training methods and datasets.
|
[
-0.4422554374,
-0.457769841,
0.2633306086,
0.1597943306,
-0.5449302197,
0.1192170158,
-0.2431040555,
-0.2955729961,
-0.069070369,
0.1139477417,
-0.6519522071,
-0.2483378798,
-0.7970424294,
0.2035916597,
-0.4391973615,
0.7453047037,
0.0511443578,
0.6529213786,
-0.0336902253,
-0.0401200615,
-0.395794034,
-0.7236435413,
-0.6221818328,
-0.3310191631,
0.5192292333,
0.3875133097,
0.2413160652,
0.2457324415,
0.4063672125,
0.3744871616,
0.2329545468,
0.1766123027,
0.0396805145,
0.0138396947,
0.1992778033,
-0.148776114,
-0.4779217541,
0.1425121427,
0.7486775517,
0.6641494036,
-0.1906787455,
0.1881322116,
0.2875439823,
0.4609582126,
-0.6985264421,
0.1547560543,
-0.5961198807,
-0.0018465496,
-0.4837166071,
-0.4966601431,
-0.2662109733,
0.12631163,
0.1809187084,
-0.7577759624,
0.2208538651,
-0.1613012701,
0.3712982237,
0.500913918,
-0.5288030505,
-0.2315471321,
-0.9326305389,
0.6355037689,
-0.6677313447,
0.9106327891,
0.4146848023,
0.1791204512,
0.0563004054,
-0.7185904384,
-0.7435314655,
-0.1647238731,
-0.0455775745,
0.1236066893,
-0.0589311644,
0.2429555953,
0.2061615288,
0.1382343024,
-0.5807964802,
0.1177911237,
-0.254745096,
-0.5310598016,
0.3822781146,
-0.2839392126,
0.0565807894,
0.148330912,
-0.3505008221,
-0.2931751013,
-0.3574545681,
0.2410926074,
0.1203695908,
0.7289373279,
0.0214102026,
0.3244428337,
-0.2396508157,
0.7172445655,
0.2431185842,
-0.2939726412,
0.6414324641,
-0.6597335339,
-0.1012243032,
0.2867606878,
0.8163105845,
-0.0754336417,
0.3362599611,
-0.0472456031,
-0.363001436,
0.2103648633,
0.253059864,
-0.7898858786,
-0.1334127039,
-0.0749132484,
-0.343814224,
0.0138207329,
0.2446974218,
-0.2387990654,
-0.0586318076,
-0.5366384387,
0.9604836702,
-0.2386470437,
-0.0596766621,
0.0716376379,
0.1395394355,
0.0233087707,
0.3401932418,
-0.4855310321,
0.2416489571,
0.1593096256,
0.5735544562,
0.1135613695,
-0.6287589669,
-1.1183041334,
0.206338495,
-0.2598269582,
0.8187624216,
-0.5081323981,
-0.4317874014,
-0.1451825351,
-0.131206423,
-0.4276386201,
-0.4161166549,
0.7094381452,
-0.3550711274,
0.2463265508,
-0.0702540055,
-0.3304540217,
-0.1367545128,
-0.0450619124,
-0.54060179,
0.8980612159,
-0.3657817245,
-0.6553884149,
0.6748582125,
-0.781426847,
-0.9002732038,
-0.2231449187,
-0.1491036713,
-0.5024841428,
0.1976542473,
0.5639442801,
0.5523094535,
-0.1486021876,
0.15147686,
-0.0003844658,
-0.2375611067,
0.2897591889,
-0.7251805067,
0.2937705517,
0.1395082772,
-0.4147080481,
0.3145077229,
-1.0026236773,
0.0594118312,
-0.1648886204,
-0.5340171456,
-0.2731573284,
0.0301060546,
0.2760124803,
0.4998721182,
0.2437308878,
-0.549585104,
-0.1814596951,
-0.2512302995,
0.2629887462,
0.4612806737,
-0.1829503626,
0.4612778127,
-0.2140166312,
0.2860159874,
0.4189537764,
0.2558918297,
-0.2531540394,
-0.2147143483,
-0.8530136347,
-0.3510191441,
0.4353340268,
0.6828277707,
-0.9083539248,
0.6415220499,
-0.0564107709,
-0.3157278299,
-0.5053291917,
0.1149226949,
0.8304236531,
0.5231041908,
0.6935892701,
-0.6348923445,
-0.5978486538,
-0.5342981815,
-0.3035676777,
-0.0229120087,
-0.025417259,
0.0440232418,
0.1777470112,
-0.3417570591,
0.7325585485,
-0.2387996167,
-0.7232674956,
-0.1631983966,
0.5355890393,
-0.0089774271,
0.6184021235,
0.1586433351,
-0.8010204434,
-0.498716265,
-0.1882736981,
-0.0902754739,
-0.1395087242,
-0.0876399428,
0.2801688015,
0.1670785844,
0.6046049595,
-0.3526596129,
0.3470623791,
0.5714426637,
-0.104780741,
0.3901210129,
-0.5240489244,
0.377399385,
-1.1463804245,
-0.0110891052,
-0.0784925818,
-0.3483835757,
-1.0154870749,
-0.5342636704,
0.1050738618,
-0.1043964326,
-0.3916710317,
0.1322602481,
-0.60629493,
-0.2407581508,
-0.3679260314,
-0.0900488868,
-0.1123990715,
0.2657220662,
-0.0515224449,
1.0601015091,
0.8101368546,
-0.6004661322,
0.0470274203,
0.2399593592,
-0.1996932924,
0.4585881531,
-0.5103619695,
0.3842904866,
-0.0614380091,
0.451806277,
-0.9488577843,
-0.0343581438,
-0.0812878907,
-0.4587556124,
0.5506528616,
0.0535367429,
-0.5571614504,
-0.3435237408,
0.0610042363,
0.5029767156,
0.0995429605,
-0.3490820825,
0.7798866034,
0.358653754,
-0.2028461248,
-0.5315253735,
-0.4958459735,
-0.1528808475,
-0.1330298334,
-0.180583626,
0.3767429888,
-0.2727888525,
0.3831127286,
-0.3672705293,
-0.456974715,
-0.2923050225,
-0.0747937039,
0.3073785007,
-0.024749497,
-0.0804639906,
-0.0090581886,
-0.0600448065,
-0.4330371618,
-0.22604011,
-0.5118765235,
0.6206478477,
-0.1048776358,
-0.5422821045,
-0.8521012068,
0.2741831541,
0.5713708997,
-0.7064348459,
0.3841081262,
0.8575391769,
-0.4359951317,
0.0559132434,
-0.7756589651,
-0.2462358028,
-0.4430932105,
0.3749518991,
-0.4115321636,
-0.7107338905,
0.0864241719,
-0.1506498307,
-0.1574273854,
0.1501922756,
0.3848163784,
-0.1505423933,
1.1253734827,
0.688290894,
-0.2661271989,
0.750270009,
-0.1226193234,
0.1359464973,
-0.6189723611,
-0.2818398476,
-0.6170573831,
-0.1627632827,
-0.2222700566,
-0.7259879112,
0.6124312878,
0.2881013155,
-0.1921268106,
0.18404378,
-0.2875781357,
0.2859721482,
0.7459186316,
0.184915483,
0.4312229753,
-0.1025340855,
-0.0743297413,
0.1189769804,
-0.7061179876,
-0.20847179,
1.1454190016,
-0.0787366405,
0.6350975633,
-0.3116675317,
0.6395556927,
0.2122491151,
-0.0552176349,
-0.6730707288,
0.4230697751,
-0.5355809331,
-0.3504678905,
-0.5572901964,
-0.3523599803,
-0.8345277905,
0.2903811932,
-0.5094312429,
-0.2339051217,
0.1989723742,
0.5391774774,
-0.6166205406,
-0.095466353,
-0.6313162446,
0.759611845,
-0.5112970471,
0.3134716451,
-0.2951830626,
-0.897290647,
-0.2726389468,
-0.4673673213,
0.4721641243,
0.0848845765,
0.140100047,
0.7931759953,
-0.1847997159,
0.6891480684,
-0.6217569709,
0.1436731517,
-0.0126233371,
-0.346898973,
0.5256134272,
-0.0907503739,
0.2360922694,
0.1711310595,
0.0642165616,
-0.089958556,
-0.4653100073,
0.1491808891,
-0.8788427711,
-0.2830014229,
-0.5479322076,
-0.6904429197,
-0.6576036811,
0.3305092156,
0.3480746448,
0.8877678514,
-0.1946599483,
0.2684210539,
0.5679104924,
0.0740284249,
0.479806751,
0.6455563307,
0.0810176507,
-0.4927658439,
0.7331077456,
0.3046633601,
0.2038496584,
0.542556107,
0.1776395887,
-0.4245232046,
-0.8301739097,
-0.3980019689,
-0.119457446,
-0.3632128835,
-0.2047191113,
-0.7373276949,
-0.2982410491,
-0.5197434425,
0.0052983118,
-0.7153005004,
-0.2424473315,
-0.3654027581,
0.1769941896,
0.015164271,
0.4304310977,
-0.2956803441,
0.6508389711,
-0.8309780955,
0.629349649,
0.5065242052,
0.0764832795,
-0.4050987661,
-0.7252387404,
-0.3470266461,
0.1622577161,
-0.0348666348,
-0.631772697,
0.2638711929,
0.6725629568,
0.5931090713,
0.4544490278,
-0.056359008,
0.9796923399,
-1.0104900599,
0.3518242836,
0.5255209208,
-1.0412082672,
0.7185028195,
-0.0689594969,
0.4485100806,
0.7266004086,
0.3576366901,
-0.1925023347,
-0.154503271,
-0.2064109147,
-0.7315185666,
0.6750038266,
0.0716881454,
-0.0619393773,
0.4847841263,
0.0238913856,
0.037328966,
0.422997117,
-0.4029393494,
-0.2906516194,
-0.4753225446,
-0.0408788286,
-0.7131814957,
-0.04098114,
-0.2152789235,
-0.5320296884,
0.5863353014,
-0.2341065407,
0.0454773903,
0.1218560189,
-0.5250241756,
-0.0162015874,
0.4972145557,
0.7333997488,
0.5236011147,
-0.094659172,
0.164823845,
0.3004111946,
-0.6787998676,
0.362763226,
0.8396276832,
0.0104262941,
-0.0655765235,
0.1654564291,
1.0864099264,
0.4209237099,
-0.3142542541,
0.7219852805,
-0.1155661866,
-0.167469576,
-0.3639553487,
-0.2120908499,
-0.2339663059,
0.5713876486,
0.7125529051,
0.4396079779,
0.3046662211,
-0.4838064313,
0.382542938,
0.3621537089,
-0.4597076774,
-0.3899179697,
0.7068223953,
0.2513014972,
-0.2668896317,
0.2949478924,
-0.0248314105,
-0.6346862912,
0.0341974087,
0.6364889741,
0.9078627825,
-0.6646056175,
0.14260979,
0.0990492031,
0.2493554056,
-0.170617044,
0.3974309266,
-0.2360296696,
-0.8105428219,
-0.5873174667,
-0.8568519354,
-0.2190990448,
0.0933398455,
-0.7888482809,
0.1166344434,
-0.0636671409,
-0.1881090999,
-0.0198890045,
-0.0637714714,
-0.7687212825,
0.6207944155,
0.3211826086,
0.4879552126,
-0.8605270386,
1.240930438,
0.8427333832,
-0.3209574521,
-0.8696000576,
0.3916215301,
0.0910436288,
-0.4676641822,
0.548265934,
0.2485792935,
-0.446283251,
0.2927039862,
0.0115002543,
-1.1142883301,
1.0889891386,
0.2456346452,
-0.7233886123,
-0.0884591863,
0.215226993,
0.381516993,
-0.3820430934,
-0.0157075431,
0.4083847404,
0.3293810487,
0.0502263755,
-1.4310575724,
-0.3729943335,
-0.1355237216,
0.1245763078,
0.063350834,
-0.2828328311,
0.6889744997,
-0.2050250173,
-0.1259123683,
-0.2512323558,
0.7698506713,
0.255238384,
0.4083223641,
1.1935276985,
0.4035437405,
0.7001094818,
0.0025298959,
0.5720763803,
-0.4548416138,
0.1026697829,
1.2840878963,
-0.1955293268,
0.9921230674,
0.4056177139,
-0.0793546513,
0.1850851178,
0.3624334335,
0.3554724157,
0.8534918427,
-0.0847459882,
-0.3022331595,
-0.4045593143,
-0.010912546,
-0.4446984529,
0.8429290652,
0.266146183,
0.0542343818,
-0.1140934378,
0.6677586436,
-0.1829516441,
-0.0486662053,
-0.3388054967,
0.8711565733,
0.0312869698,
-0.2710157335,
0.4122965634,
-0.2603025436,
0.858461082,
-0.8028764725,
0.2599385977,
0.1230839044,
0.2157803476,
-0.0619999506,
-0.237582773,
0.0710019916,
0.0164182093,
-0.3445573449,
-0.4961663485,
0.7139371037,
-0.588653028,
-0.522687614,
0.356431067,
0.6986936927,
-0.037866503,
-0.3908345997,
-0.6750607491,
-0.0002590514,
-0.3642653227,
-0.309099555,
0.270632416,
0.4158837199,
0.0045722383,
0.3312751651,
0.9062203765,
0.1056383923,
0.3725106418,
0.5332151651,
1.0283873081,
-0.3141131699,
-0.5523355603,
-0.4342440069,
0.6593182087,
0.0946408957,
-0.1765375882,
0.5859357119,
0.6346824765,
1.1267734766,
0.0491949096,
0.7752052546,
-0.025042057,
0.8041926622,
-0.5512850881,
0.6102666855,
-0.7045030594,
-0.0775473639,
-0.4264971018,
-0.8409785032,
-0.4087537229,
0.8020358086,
-0.0440964922,
0.2109886855,
0.7188518643,
0.7238191366,
-0.0760117471,
-0.1397930533,
0.5013418198,
0.1921915114,
0.1518916786,
0.1807350516,
0.7585445642,
-0.3939336836,
0.6119169593,
-0.4565963447,
-0.3267172277,
-0.0445685871,
-0.6501173377,
-0.7616249919,
-0.9807819128,
-0.1074074358,
0.0049428428,
0.1630584747,
1.0293705463,
0.9417087436,
-1.0237152576,
-0.2077157944,
0.0839237198,
-0.6904458404,
-0.2715271115,
0.0182718486,
0.2292701155,
-0.57332623,
-0.6821585298,
0.9380062819,
0.2636016011,
0.0182460286,
-0.0084493076,
-0.1327821612,
-0.313351959,
-0.0748442486,
0.7173540592,
0.1202052161,
-0.5405490398,
-0.2262364328,
-0.1803249866,
0.0532518737,
0.0185614266,
0.9696516991,
-0.8127806783,
0.5995500684,
0.3566767871,
0.5493236184,
0.707852602,
0.1386035979,
0.5389918089,
-0.8496120572,
0.3786330521,
0.1427831799,
0.3498299718,
0.2802323103,
0.0463425592,
0.1708253473,
0.2158488333,
-0.6797392964,
-0.7796391249,
0.1936811358,
-0.9996044636,
0.0088954531,
0.7929614782,
-0.0178025197,
0.5174972415,
-0.2163542658,
-0.2105845064,
0.6737731099,
-0.3621430099,
0.52966851,
0.331956923,
-0.2253433466,
-0.1144158468,
-0.5380276442,
0.5634818077,
0.3674090505,
-0.8867165446,
-0.2332086861,
0.6576502919,
0.1560722291,
0.2239945978,
0.8439695835,
0.0959587842,
0.2155573219,
-0.1773539931,
0.0737803206,
-0.1947853416,
-0.8146300316,
-0.4056213498,
-0.0535730124,
0.0563912541,
-0.524050355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19802v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19802v1
|
Developing Healthcare Language Model Embedding Spaces
| 2024-03-28T19:31:32 | 2024-03-28T19:31:32 |
Niall Taylor, Dan Schofield, Andrey Kormilitzin, Dan W Joyce, Alejo Nevado-Holgado
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) often struggle on out-of-domain
datasets like healthcare focused text. We explore specialized pre-training to
adapt smaller LLMs to different healthcare datasets. Three methods are
assessed: traditional masked language modeling, Deep Contrastive Learning for
Unsupervised Textual Representations (DeCLUTR), and a novel pre-training
objective utilizing metadata categories from the healthcare settings. These
schemes are evaluated on downstream document classification tasks for each
dataset, with additional analysis of the resultant embedding spaces.
Contrastively trained models outperform other approaches on the classification
tasks, delivering strong performance from limited labeled data and with fewer
model parameter updates required. While metadata-based pre-training does not
further improve classifications across the datasets, it yields interesting
embedding cluster separability. All domain adapted LLMs outperform their
publicly available general base LLM, validating the importance of
domain-specialization. This research illustrates efficient approaches to
instill healthcare competency in compact LLMs even under tight computational
budgets, an essential capability for responsible and sustainable deployment in
local healthcare settings. We provide pre-training guidelines for specialized
healthcare LLMs, motivate continued inquiry into contrastive objectives, and
demonstrates adaptation techniques to align small LLMs with privacy-sensitive
medical tasks.
|
[
-0.034607619,
-0.3200272024,
0.7275353074,
-0.1313296556,
-0.261418581,
0.210943535,
-0.2563927174,
-0.2749482989,
0.0956134945,
0.7449859381,
-0.3166255951,
-0.8236784339,
-0.7896721959,
0.0270343702,
0.0505260676,
0.8364607096,
-0.2775119245,
0.1501830667,
-0.5132042766,
-0.3276990652,
-0.0824256316,
-0.8475331664,
-0.2673760951,
-0.2956548929,
0.3706202209,
0.3745782971,
0.5222607255,
0.6408687234,
0.7367625237,
0.2608227134,
0.2606261075,
0.2563048899,
-0.3642580211,
-0.1660145223,
0.006471233,
-0.3392851055,
-0.3271422386,
-0.0853033215,
0.6845960021,
0.9297018647,
-0.3140918314,
-0.1137717515,
0.1640058905,
0.4127246141,
-0.5697646737,
0.220381707,
-0.4539214075,
0.1640065163,
-0.1835497022,
-0.1621857136,
-0.216773048,
-0.2822419703,
0.2941249609,
-0.5390283465,
0.126421079,
0.099859111,
0.7026668191,
0.5784531236,
-0.4987932444,
-0.4547149539,
-0.5190287828,
0.6154702902,
-0.7701863647,
0.6654782891,
0.5416696668,
0.1644109488,
0.0466472842,
-1.1080664396,
-0.1013133526,
-0.1749998331,
-0.3333730102,
0.1088462025,
-0.1950535476,
0.2068513334,
-0.092119731,
0.3964668512,
-0.5079315305,
0.6029224396,
-0.2211401612,
-0.0490401015,
0.3451262414,
0.2202415168,
0.1179209128,
0.1105132177,
-0.0709800348,
0.0618794672,
-0.7550627589,
-0.299710542,
-0.1673565209,
0.1692044586,
-0.4636951685,
0.2930310071,
0.175949201,
0.336822331,
0.1148503274,
-0.3522167504,
0.4281879067,
-0.1904003322,
-0.6055878401,
-0.0831340551,
0.4466983676,
-0.0979001299,
-0.0442161225,
-0.1684288681,
-0.1353528351,
0.02648375,
0.5306664705,
-0.7585009336,
-0.4870449007,
0.0617261231,
-0.5988439918,
-0.1721298099,
-0.3926964104,
-0.2804009914,
-0.6760135293,
-0.3696515262,
0.2688774765,
-0.1702022702,
0.0866402313,
0.3821322918,
0.4298340082,
-0.0529867001,
0.2659460902,
-0.9231157899,
0.7458415627,
0.6915044188,
0.6930480599,
-0.2983344197,
0.01799828,
-0.2470592856,
0.0891551152,
-0.226085186,
0.5289983749,
-0.4790868461,
-0.2924487293,
0.3646419346,
0.3253311515,
-0.2521703243,
-0.730148077,
0.561847508,
-0.4825218916,
0.2118409276,
0.0880100355,
-0.6747655869,
0.0822216272,
0.3450637758,
-0.6475925446,
0.4934245646,
0.6030907631,
-0.878873229,
0.4568796456,
-0.6297026873,
-0.4400499761,
0.1818375885,
-0.4692101777,
-0.6983001828,
0.2730789781,
0.3107865155,
0.620159328,
-0.2313514054,
0.0225475673,
-0.183990702,
-0.1717006862,
0.0758040994,
0.0598061457,
0.5055252314,
0.157933414,
-0.0264100432,
0.167798087,
-0.606154263,
-0.1843032092,
0.0278638117,
-0.3616018891,
-0.5366069078,
-0.0647570342,
-0.0009885537,
-0.0264938343,
0.0618840791,
-0.1730533838,
-0.0155101027,
-0.6195596457,
0.4950009286,
0.4067344964,
-0.0097904047,
0.6555165648,
-0.4278998077,
0.6452252269,
0.2018689215,
0.2708580494,
-0.0482216217,
-0.1922612935,
-0.5796417594,
-0.5619254112,
0.3960136175,
0.3877703249,
-0.7027984262,
0.6124104857,
-0.2721613646,
-0.2783751488,
-0.8369969726,
0.11450091,
0.2877670228,
0.6105781198,
0.3261450529,
-0.4458882511,
-0.4333723783,
-0.9175771475,
0.2149213403,
0.1722653508,
-0.0300700236,
0.5383591056,
0.561601162,
-0.8719940186,
0.5417064428,
-0.5471033454,
-0.6138469577,
-0.085980311,
-0.2426164448,
0.1685194969,
0.4827857912,
0.3951625824,
-0.7087464333,
-0.4604195952,
0.1310806274,
-0.5213852525,
0.0297775604,
0.1049537063,
0.2609142661,
-0.0490504093,
0.6226785779,
-0.1365706921,
0.2689383626,
0.984326601,
0.0980039388,
0.1592378169,
-0.5307201743,
-0.0676086769,
-1.2647773027,
0.0029099248,
-0.1817184538,
-0.4009009302,
-0.7297113538,
0.0815840662,
0.1039999872,
-0.1646469831,
-0.355802834,
0.6583419442,
-0.6335456371,
-0.0291989073,
-0.240074873,
-0.1677999645,
0.1054213718,
0.2092974782,
0.3832093477,
0.408896476,
0.5435302258,
-0.4997490644,
0.0829282105,
0.4153497815,
-0.5127379298,
0.2712553144,
-0.5733579397,
0.299413532,
0.0379591621,
0.295814544,
-0.6041654944,
-0.3412198126,
0.1192445979,
0.0988854915,
0.4649010599,
-0.1723283082,
-0.5686846375,
-0.1730055958,
-0.1245908663,
0.5380336642,
0.6027159095,
-0.4117355049,
0.334666431,
0.8255563378,
-0.2726803422,
-0.3095609248,
-0.9362482429,
-0.1964739859,
-0.3044916689,
-0.3471706212,
0.611613512,
0.125271365,
-0.1895766705,
0.0217348281,
-0.0013811957,
-0.3695789874,
0.2812096477,
0.2638708949,
-0.0457570553,
-0.3598466516,
0.3464775383,
0.1280336082,
-0.0438691527,
-0.1270747632,
-0.4854156673,
0.3411798179,
-0.0431589633,
-0.5865377784,
-0.2241298258,
0.4336191714,
0.2107356489,
-0.0807133615,
0.6759672761,
0.4507956207,
-0.7154570818,
-0.1921250373,
-0.5150077343,
-0.1738554835,
-0.4836735427,
0.5580317974,
0.004870906,
-1.3391722441,
0.3462208807,
-0.447224915,
0.0450392663,
0.1322127283,
0.6855180264,
-0.2719978392,
0.4892293215,
1.0688244104,
0.052891165,
0.2261423618,
0.0251305141,
0.0896403566,
-0.7645508647,
-0.304702878,
-0.5269919038,
-0.0123965163,
-0.8537428975,
-0.8728572726,
0.4573071897,
-0.1454350203,
-0.2773286998,
0.0731556192,
-0.4600516558,
0.2046987861,
0.1887483597,
0.2664766312,
0.0945695266,
0.0275503471,
-0.0353021696,
-0.2757503688,
-0.7273854613,
-0.3636559546,
0.9526260495,
0.7390061021,
1.021315217,
-0.030912485,
1.0130200386,
0.2377387732,
0.6595918536,
-0.6538053155,
-0.0790626183,
-0.7679575086,
-0.1731492728,
-0.1282560825,
-0.1963895559,
-1.0687270164,
0.0202386528,
-0.2483180761,
-0.4368146062,
0.3693833351,
0.1118955687,
-0.4612255394,
-0.0435400195,
-0.5087237954,
0.805569768,
-0.1699670255,
-0.0106262201,
0.0784538463,
-0.5146483779,
0.0080338288,
-0.5491108298,
0.3345487714,
0.1073601246,
-0.3589605987,
0.6047235727,
-0.2714714706,
1.0720524788,
0.0576441512,
-0.2169779688,
-0.1648536026,
-0.1986069381,
0.3557800651,
-0.0142498873,
0.0451429971,
0.1939169466,
-0.0714336783,
-0.4598304927,
-0.5054704547,
0.5525901318,
-0.859488368,
-0.572501421,
-0.1642096192,
-0.3339251876,
-0.8186193109,
0.188237533,
0.2858175337,
0.3310519159,
-0.4852674603,
0.3562504053,
0.917376399,
-0.4810101688,
-0.0913292319,
0.6089820266,
0.1278225929,
-0.3735873401,
0.4794385731,
-0.0402248427,
0.116186969,
0.6898481846,
0.3830037415,
-0.392298162,
-0.8632830381,
-0.0256341659,
0.3127860725,
-0.8813416362,
-0.1169005036,
-0.6857327223,
-0.5005610585,
-0.6149488091,
-0.5184762478,
-0.2106663287,
0.0210807621,
-0.5187505484,
-0.1404201537,
0.0871001706,
0.7319637537,
0.0763183013,
0.5569533706,
-0.9794420004,
0.0873612612,
0.2186803669,
0.3379174173,
-0.3830773234,
-0.7261554003,
-0.6010255218,
-0.310831964,
0.165497601,
-0.6437193155,
0.4744530618,
0.136286512,
0.7712766528,
0.3535391688,
-0.0588077493,
0.4897543788,
-0.7517126203,
0.4806832373,
0.2416420877,
-0.7010716796,
0.3873895407,
-0.2569112182,
0.2541434169,
0.8236175179,
0.6176555753,
-0.2880452275,
0.0192253161,
-0.5760949254,
-0.5912163854,
0.3083080053,
-0.1253180355,
0.3497691453,
0.1982250214,
0.4294841886,
0.2128955722,
0.3010985851,
-0.6209901571,
-0.083389774,
0.0177567955,
-0.4265505373,
-0.2895663977,
-0.2157156765,
-0.4367875457,
-0.1370823532,
0.1469928622,
-0.3317441344,
0.2295442224,
0.0731768161,
-0.2837212682,
0.3211967647,
0.2925593853,
0.5120797157,
0.5606222749,
0.0771472454,
0.2659997642,
0.2329925448,
-0.5415045619,
0.1192292944,
0.2005627453,
0.1458065659,
-0.007155078,
0.5706087947,
0.7882349491,
0.5791888237,
-0.4304672182,
0.6461885571,
-0.0639624596,
-0.2191876173,
-0.1072600782,
-0.1433352977,
0.3614874184,
0.0454147719,
-0.1855815649,
-0.2978235781,
0.076838702,
-0.4396807849,
0.3405256271,
0.0328489468,
-0.5352448225,
-0.1937221587,
0.3551422656,
0.3717484474,
-0.0917493328,
0.465680033,
0.2438715696,
-0.1805829853,
0.380661875,
0.5998123884,
0.8506782055,
-0.3671426475,
0.1594088972,
-0.1263704151,
0.3593429327,
-0.0057361182,
0.0373123512,
-0.0101448875,
-0.7979755998,
-0.3296894133,
-0.6027768254,
-0.5173620582,
0.2413596213,
-0.5752844214,
0.0636104569,
-0.7052502632,
-0.089224413,
-0.1423274875,
0.1510393769,
-1.1040712595,
0.4570634067,
0.2877621949,
0.8612521887,
-0.8640697002,
1.0172926188,
0.7331055403,
-0.0559814684,
-0.692122817,
0.1207998246,
-0.0607844144,
-1.057918787,
0.5106343627,
-0.0636200756,
0.0867434815,
-0.1533082128,
-0.3289992511,
-0.6821138859,
0.8785582185,
0.4331126511,
-0.7971041799,
-0.2770457566,
0.2385558486,
0.7940095067,
-0.7509078383,
-0.1876650155,
0.5927994251,
0.0984910652,
-0.3711663783,
-0.9399058223,
0.1180984452,
0.0798490644,
-0.1002905518,
-0.2457370311,
-0.4118002057,
0.6978469491,
-0.1460596174,
-0.1316117346,
-0.016819803,
0.3131227195,
0.1871897727,
0.258133322,
0.3671252429,
0.5413185358,
1.1392029524,
0.0397531763,
1.1150636673,
-0.0754365847,
0.1183517501,
1.1834812164,
-0.6202198267,
0.6145958304,
0.2591992319,
0.0107017476,
0.6870034933,
0.6494491696,
0.0136566665,
0.7933019996,
0.4335684478,
-0.3898523152,
-0.1110736951,
-0.3129652739,
-0.5096706748,
0.4675142467,
0.6603030562,
-0.6554846168,
-0.1030566096,
0.1865845621,
0.0535002053,
0.1297752261,
-0.3211619854,
0.984056294,
0.5353218317,
-0.1989988238,
0.3027602136,
0.0448055938,
0.5590684414,
-0.7251836061,
0.1825008094,
-0.200129509,
0.3071389496,
-0.3272767067,
-0.3418026268,
0.2276225686,
-0.181614399,
-0.1932501942,
-0.4490674734,
0.8580443263,
-0.2875312567,
-0.4236034155,
0.2518595457,
0.5307728052,
0.0521191694,
0.2027587742,
-0.7671388984,
0.1360553801,
-0.3098430932,
-0.0109664826,
0.7408072948,
0.5220760107,
-0.0560112409,
0.2837192714,
0.5961869955,
0.3113047183,
-0.2717553377,
0.4878783822,
1.0496157408,
-0.3831734657,
-0.8166132569,
-0.5781403184,
0.2276715636,
0.0935163721,
-0.1575189233,
0.4674217105,
0.3854726255,
0.7186980844,
-0.1427464336,
0.8242358565,
0.4988664687,
0.4148598611,
-0.6774143577,
0.8124469519,
-0.5753206611,
0.1358311325,
0.0111924605,
-0.4501982331,
-0.536722362,
0.5722541809,
-0.3213193119,
-0.0051800907,
0.7930499911,
0.6076188087,
-0.0949705541,
-0.372267127,
0.6104144454,
0.0627651289,
0.2555720806,
0.647341907,
0.7497400641,
-0.1201066375,
0.0648492053,
-0.1622493416,
-0.2872687578,
-0.240482688,
-0.9983515143,
-0.9425756931,
-0.4484886825,
-0.5142831206,
-0.2630670071,
0.0834634528,
0.805860877,
1.1647131443,
-0.8064124584,
0.1148418337,
0.1572070569,
-0.1587757915,
0.1094172969,
-0.0751694068,
0.7035591602,
-0.1509472132,
-0.4727462232,
0.4458031952,
0.480471015,
0.1797746271,
-0.2219009399,
-0.1051742062,
0.2061265409,
0.009116888,
0.4284992218,
0.2302560657,
-0.5032110214,
-0.144841671,
-0.0116297165,
-0.4665111303,
0.0982776806,
1.1519248486,
-0.5925036669,
0.1779266149,
0.135729894,
1.1043668985,
0.3824345171,
-0.094468452,
0.2950000465,
-0.8787888288,
0.3029071689,
0.7398968339,
0.4760170281,
0.5056148767,
-0.457103163,
0.3393690288,
0.0450311638,
-0.5561646223,
-0.8443302512,
0.0952917561,
-0.8025898337,
-0.2929615974,
1.0777512789,
-0.4604254663,
0.0104228621,
-0.4433870316,
0.0853221118,
0.0437697247,
0.1461461782,
0.6840609312,
0.4299396574,
-0.1424490511,
-0.1868819445,
-0.2500906587,
0.7967009544,
0.228079617,
-1.2542612553,
-0.0508920699,
0.1674849242,
0.4000084996,
0.0291689597,
1.2065464258,
-0.3776743412,
0.1076587439,
-0.0262927562,
-0.2415273637,
-0.0329048298,
-0.1810886711,
-0.6412155628,
0.1282141507,
0.1235083416,
-0.1234142929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19758v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19758v2
|
Quantum Natural Language Processing
| 2024-03-28T18:15:07 | 2024-04-26T18:45:02 |
Dominic Widdows, Willie Aboumrad, Dohun Kim, Sayonee Ray, Jonathan Mei
|
quant-ph
|
quant-ph, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Language processing is at the heart of current developments in artificial
intelligence, and quantum computers are becoming available at the same time.
This has led to great interest in quantum natural language processing, and
several early proposals and experiments.
This paper surveys the state of this area, showing how NLP-related techniques
have been used in quantum language processing. We examine the art of word
embeddings and sequential models, proposing some avenues for future
investigation and discussing the tradeoffs present in these directions. We also
highlight some recent methods to compute attention in transformer models, and
perform grammatical parsing. We also introduce a new quantum design for the
basic task of text encoding (representing a string of characters in memory),
which has not been addressed in detail before.
Quantum theory has contributed toward quantifying uncertainty and explaining
"What is intelligence?" In this context, we argue that "hallucinations" in
modern artificial intelligence systems are a misunderstanding of the way facts
are conceptualized: language can express many plausible hypotheses, of which
only a few become actual.
|
[
-0.3670493364,
-1.2620521784,
0.8549854755,
-0.0678745285,
-0.2169015706,
0.2786384523,
-0.2064274251,
-0.6606245637,
0.2318955362,
0.5312579274,
-0.2947609723,
-0.05325054,
-0.5021391511,
0.2661972642,
-0.6321440339,
0.4135603011,
0.2874315679,
-0.0387810506,
0.0791685432,
-0.020949889,
-0.4633737504,
-0.6465991735,
-0.8382210732,
-0.2854092717,
0.1324129999,
-0.0032759369,
1.3130033016,
0.3026205599,
0.5343462229,
0.4019652605,
-0.1803036779,
0.0536572635,
0.0815800577,
0.2366385609,
-0.0972919017,
-0.6671823859,
-0.1198269576,
-0.0259562582,
1.042063117,
0.8358362317,
-0.1269652247,
-0.1742373407,
-0.2045076936,
1.0475075245,
-0.5705384016,
-0.0185791142,
-0.4138466716,
0.6685582995,
-0.0333714299,
-0.2564008236,
-0.4218573272,
-0.4174347222,
0.3254069984,
-0.4727254808,
0.0791458711,
0.4013510644,
0.4454951882,
0.3237803578,
-0.4616215825,
-0.4315283,
-1.1099302769,
0.918982327,
-0.5784907937,
0.9390001297,
0.5198524594,
0.1444821805,
-0.1180082038,
-0.6421249509,
-0.8260115385,
-0.5001616478,
-0.1403141916,
-0.128838554,
-0.6232334971,
0.1716921777,
0.2820056975,
0.6244235039,
-0.6997575164,
-0.3220357597,
-0.2009074837,
-0.1128461286,
0.4971146584,
-0.0891974568,
0.4654271603,
-0.2577511668,
0.0619297288,
-0.0117994072,
-0.2288007885,
0.0299860686,
0.0161984991,
-0.0188361984,
0.326873064,
0.7934529185,
-0.4528447688,
0.7527088523,
-0.0198303424,
0.2561790943,
-0.2129566818,
-0.330432266,
-0.2523161769,
0.4380317926,
0.7697541118,
-0.025215365,
0.2936240435,
-0.4883203804,
-0.029161714,
0.2691186666,
0.5607680678,
-0.268773973,
-0.3158174753,
0.3641370833,
-0.3002383709,
0.1011286974,
-0.1960413158,
-0.5673781037,
-0.3790126443,
-0.4813729823,
0.3651576638,
-0.7141859531,
-0.1190824956,
0.4084253013,
-0.4103578031,
0.2116029263,
0.004903439,
-1.0190070868,
0.7122519612,
0.7664172053,
0.5910099149,
0.1878411174,
0.0167565662,
-0.2371052802,
0.0934421048,
-0.5525364876,
0.9520879984,
-0.6456859112,
-0.2548652887,
-0.0035084249,
-0.3375565708,
0.1281039119,
-0.4022981822,
0.4110579789,
-0.6857641339,
0.2617711425,
-0.1227628291,
-0.7003193498,
-0.4340929985,
-0.0066991192,
-0.6700800657,
0.5915583372,
-0.0645249188,
-0.583596468,
-0.1149728,
-0.7575119138,
-0.6075162888,
0.2744059265,
-0.2535649836,
-0.0007363818,
0.4506489635,
0.0930725336,
0.1342293024,
-0.3298422992,
0.2236673236,
0.1389699727,
-0.4089499712,
0.7874525189,
-0.2898540199,
0.5810053349,
0.245560661,
-0.23178114,
0.0863481313,
-0.6915296912,
0.1628972888,
0.1833842248,
-0.0543699786,
-0.321398586,
0.3890617788,
-0.2053856999,
-0.1548689902,
0.3817356527,
-0.4480162263,
-0.0616628118,
-0.6752192974,
0.9223526716,
0.3774549365,
0.0110643059,
0.8776658773,
-0.1656220853,
0.2813771665,
-0.212531805,
0.1765994728,
0.1533904672,
-0.6821767688,
-0.8759253621,
0.3179230392,
0.1947042495,
0.6575163603,
-0.6044861078,
0.5593847632,
-0.134758383,
-0.2119850367,
-0.6463721395,
-0.1522922218,
0.132858783,
0.1729656607,
0.3410972655,
-0.0942012966,
-0.5442720056,
-1.1827156544,
-0.8044039607,
-0.1634183377,
-0.0066823331,
-0.3033909202,
0.1437442452,
-0.1668292582,
1.0187501907,
-0.5160440803,
-0.0221302062,
-0.0599974804,
0.2022069693,
-0.0014922727,
0.6175949574,
-0.0897317529,
-0.9787873626,
0.0326932557,
-0.0644321442,
-0.9082844257,
0.7183249593,
-0.0866316035,
-0.2565596104,
0.1992916763,
0.442009598,
-0.9090961814,
0.2833411396,
0.1638869196,
-0.4070732594,
0.0908337682,
-0.0332030281,
0.1917834431,
-0.6547335386,
-0.2960344553,
0.0727405548,
-0.1712999493,
-0.9220781922,
0.2685777545,
0.0319173262,
-0.1061972156,
-0.2176671177,
0.3240986764,
-0.2049775273,
-0.102196224,
-0.3834050298,
0.3229430318,
-0.1232431158,
0.4744272828,
0.1798754483,
0.2895050645,
0.3913912773,
-0.6352139711,
0.4811279774,
0.0653363466,
-0.1131360158,
0.4428604543,
-0.5040906668,
0.3832308948,
-0.2298191041,
-0.1380072683,
-0.7182013988,
-0.0379123576,
0.4383678734,
-0.5864900351,
0.0956326947,
0.3428881168,
-0.8409004807,
-0.386349082,
-0.2631094456,
0.2230817676,
0.7752181888,
0.0243127178,
0.6347850561,
0.5647664666,
0.0695407987,
-0.019016223,
-0.8925355673,
0.2698771358,
-0.0857078582,
-0.4357641339,
0.4052193165,
0.0082798135,
-0.6526611447,
0.3459395766,
-0.0000508135,
-0.2749974132,
0.3312848806,
0.0738578439,
-0.0125280572,
-0.2369194478,
0.3359267116,
0.0868168026,
-0.0974556059,
0.3871315718,
-0.3615194559,
0.4792560339,
-0.3664410114,
-0.0025393767,
-0.6874361634,
0.4352205396,
0.195231244,
-0.1561946869,
0.6039446592,
0.3781236708,
-0.8953971863,
-0.053273011,
-0.4235167205,
-0.306991756,
-0.4800698161,
0.2458257228,
-0.2130639553,
-1.1869732141,
0.0250119101,
0.1134224087,
-0.0177657343,
0.5633642673,
0.3548516035,
-0.1672809273,
1.4316196442,
0.6645467877,
0.0305896197,
0.6112228632,
0.0521876775,
0.8750236034,
-0.7636727691,
0.1202470586,
-0.4730780423,
-0.1175140813,
-0.848746717,
-0.1402239501,
0.2047676593,
0.3812665641,
-0.2988316417,
0.1830893606,
-0.685973227,
0.4926086664,
0.9527922273,
-0.145073846,
0.5195374489,
0.0009806216,
0.2772139609,
0.1358032525,
-0.6620919704,
-0.6944451332,
0.7508923411,
0.283582598,
0.3696805835,
0.0355024934,
0.4837118685,
0.3987542689,
-0.2383612394,
-0.8454480767,
0.6706296206,
0.0075524915,
-0.4946071208,
-0.5822686553,
-0.2151598483,
-0.9410379529,
0.3020975292,
-0.3607413471,
-0.8601151705,
-0.0387508161,
0.0032067585,
-0.6551126838,
0.1491831392,
-0.7212554812,
0.5697372556,
0.0358947739,
-0.0297251008,
-0.6452460289,
-0.4893266857,
0.6512848139,
-0.0175282042,
0.4012718499,
-0.0707157478,
0.1919847429,
0.9537046552,
-0.0956258923,
0.4540709853,
0.1827390492,
-0.2354912162,
0.4277843833,
0.2149617076,
0.0769300312,
0.3135986924,
0.0314905979,
0.0028482056,
0.3539727032,
-0.2974520624,
-0.67126894,
0.4623853564,
-0.6279287338,
-0.6954293251,
-0.6151199937,
-0.5833861828,
-0.3379034698,
0.1732472181,
0.0754523724,
0.2934684157,
-0.0898834243,
-0.0633670837,
0.6841017008,
-0.2058765888,
0.4720743299,
0.3456905484,
-0.3975838423,
-0.3346427083,
1.0007126331,
0.1722251475,
-0.1544792205,
0.6440358758,
0.2557505965,
-0.2226617783,
-0.3868384063,
-0.1137503535,
0.2290971577,
-0.7243004441,
0.0851389617,
-0.6973636746,
-0.4265425801,
-0.4487686455,
-0.0834810957,
-0.3213006556,
-0.5787836909,
-0.1321099997,
0.1264220029,
0.4080512226,
0.9405260682,
0.0603283793,
0.2118017077,
-0.9702290893,
0.7660837173,
0.6891483665,
0.2680931687,
0.1863444299,
-0.1346387118,
-0.4451032579,
0.2133072764,
-0.3143734038,
-0.8518782854,
0.2697556317,
0.1821517497,
0.4531388581,
0.0719687343,
0.1198566183,
0.4360690713,
-0.626432538,
0.938105762,
-0.0188370235,
-1.208039403,
0.8367043138,
0.0744708404,
0.4788070321,
0.2726320624,
0.4209982753,
-0.8211485147,
-0.7430912256,
-0.6865837574,
-0.331884861,
0.3850595653,
0.2430080473,
0.097329922,
-0.31671229,
0.3102319539,
-0.2720161378,
0.3146650791,
-0.5737404823,
-0.2347107679,
0.0936968923,
-0.198099643,
-0.0790331289,
-0.2140824795,
-0.0217553023,
-0.3576982617,
0.3135528266,
0.0516857468,
0.581197381,
0.327506125,
-0.411521107,
-0.3077049255,
0.3514944017,
0.4132349193,
0.6534925699,
-0.0220409315,
0.4346840978,
-0.0349074975,
-0.3576802015,
-0.1264767349,
0.0448671989,
-0.2141127288,
-0.0686825812,
0.3868924081,
0.6824849844,
0.4248701334,
-0.759436965,
-0.0605891906,
-0.2505498528,
-0.1133528277,
-0.5090225935,
0.1520263851,
0.0328371748,
0.6441231966,
0.4918625653,
-0.0063199955,
0.7470741868,
-0.9486909509,
-0.0022040936,
0.5715269446,
-0.3691872656,
-0.4946700931,
0.5989202857,
-0.2813441455,
-0.7298815846,
0.8962702751,
-0.4548409879,
-0.6638256907,
0.2745999694,
0.4469015002,
0.9858220816,
-0.0554574542,
0.0339501798,
0.2270409167,
0.3563422561,
-0.0251434781,
0.5793382525,
-0.2807341516,
-0.8493118286,
-0.3764781356,
-0.7855128646,
-0.48571679,
-0.3314298689,
-0.5141247511,
-0.153268069,
-0.6379519105,
-0.3474577367,
0.1146228537,
0.1654164046,
-0.6023924351,
0.0803362504,
0.6924342513,
0.3863290846,
-0.4621312618,
0.7474785447,
0.6514079571,
-0.1501210779,
-0.2747660875,
-0.1327112913,
-0.2344967723,
-0.5066587329,
0.4619890451,
0.1093313918,
-0.0476508327,
0.4492298961,
-0.5180516243,
-1.0879863501,
0.5609701872,
0.1008975655,
-0.4852664173,
-0.1489339471,
0.2143812627,
0.5163399577,
0.2404451668,
-0.0811678767,
0.9393548965,
0.3955962062,
-0.4938212931,
-0.5185087919,
0.0408267416,
-0.2205193788,
0.2124457657,
0.487916708,
-0.3918809593,
0.8549596667,
0.1347536594,
-0.5763731599,
-0.0534634069,
0.9910863638,
0.1638687104,
0.0579855479,
0.2540494502,
0.621789813,
0.8539181948,
-0.0425509252,
1.0908334255,
-0.4383281469,
0.0785448179,
0.633628428,
-0.0481537879,
1.01009202,
0.6183678508,
-0.6431083083,
0.5432277918,
0.424402833,
0.1647185236,
0.4291481078,
0.2182522863,
-0.1805495471,
-0.1235044822,
-0.1206808686,
-0.0546560213,
0.2206092626,
0.4451952875,
0.0016207061,
0.09874437,
0.3201849461,
-0.3315341175,
0.0748872906,
-0.3203724325,
0.8504863977,
0.3322906196,
-0.6484109163,
0.3344725966,
0.0821960121,
0.5914850831,
-0.3295944929,
-0.278463006,
0.1225169301,
-0.0987714827,
0.0026012789,
-0.8038113713,
0.4536227882,
-0.2599748373,
-0.1586227417,
-0.189399004,
0.6709381342,
-0.0708154812,
-0.4581717849,
0.0041689803,
0.4642162919,
0.1487777233,
-0.3807199895,
-0.5451032519,
0.1351145953,
-0.2439629585,
-0.247632429,
0.1293826848,
0.5355881453,
-0.000143968,
0.5771521926,
0.484880209,
-0.0427613519,
0.454228282,
-0.252876699,
0.4373440742,
-1.3253335953,
-0.5195381641,
-0.9702313542,
0.1444186866,
0.2458992004,
-0.1632496715,
0.8123617172,
0.3043729365,
0.6873482466,
0.0748707876,
0.581528306,
0.0883418173,
0.3162620664,
-0.701123476,
0.5145697594,
-0.2872305214,
-0.1268405169,
-0.0343402773,
-0.915253818,
-0.3491039872,
0.8721345663,
-0.1843346804,
-0.284525007,
0.9954427481,
0.2282533795,
0.4872025251,
0.799478054,
0.1920589805,
0.0108043505,
0.0854911283,
0.6223860979,
1.2061371803,
-0.6463320851,
-0.1073918939,
-0.7117455006,
0.2255144417,
-0.1843220294,
-0.3867764175,
-0.5704706907,
-0.7870166898,
-0.4897987247,
0.0305749997,
0.0139901098,
0.7655848265,
0.4498638809,
-0.6638547778,
-0.235281229,
-0.5307739973,
0.427113086,
-0.365716666,
-0.2095629573,
0.281630218,
-0.6497421265,
-0.7927926779,
0.4520613849,
0.3873426914,
0.1159309372,
-0.3550779819,
0.1461115032,
-0.2450519204,
0.1066496074,
0.9376158714,
0.2808819711,
-0.9486541748,
-0.2755152881,
0.0719177276,
-0.0324245803,
0.1510329694,
0.5862592459,
-1.1631621122,
0.3518061638,
0.4928197265,
0.6878525019,
0.0373088941,
-0.315746367,
0.5421437621,
-0.1551742107,
-0.0049585062,
0.6428664327,
0.1822441071,
0.1699867994,
-0.3541867435,
0.3191592097,
0.1517915577,
-0.4879468381,
-0.9104962349,
0.0605588704,
-0.7440648675,
-0.5747476816,
0.5589222312,
0.6820760369,
-0.5363137126,
-0.0727536827,
-0.0907099992,
0.5100898147,
-0.2000557929,
0.580170691,
0.8134813905,
-0.4342904091,
-0.3479432166,
-0.8779046535,
0.5445395112,
0.6175103784,
-0.5432710052,
-0.1411607713,
0.2681694627,
-0.3833173513,
0.5727380514,
0.4855949879,
0.1683994979,
0.2737750113,
0.0700950846,
-0.0172743443,
0.6867774129,
-0.1715673059,
-0.7034985423,
0.1974137574,
0.3100344539,
0.0144233992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19754v1
|
GOLD: Generalized Knowledge Distillation via Out-of-Distribution-Guided Language Data Generation
| 2024-03-28T18:08:22 | 2024-03-28T18:08:22 |
Mohsen Gholami, Mohammad Akbari, Cindy Hu, Vaden Masrani, Z. Jane Wang, Yong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge distillation from LLMs is essential for the efficient deployment of
language models. Prior works have proposed data generation using LLMs for
preparing distilled models. We argue that generating data with LLMs is prone to
sampling mainly from the center of original content distribution. This
limitation hinders the distilled model from learning the true underlying data
distribution and to forget the tails of the distributions (samples with lower
probability). To this end, we propose GOLD, a task-agnostic data generation and
knowledge distillation framework, which employs an iterative
out-of-distribution-guided feedback mechanism for the LLM. As a result, the
generated data improves the generalizability of distilled models. An
energy-based OOD evaluation approach is also introduced to deal with noisy
generated data. Our extensive experiments on 10 different classification and
sequence-to-sequence tasks in NLP show that GOLD respectively outperforms prior
arts and the LLM with an average improvement of 5% and 14%. We will also show
that the proposed method is applicable to less explored and novel tasks. The
code is available.
|
[
0.0462114476,
-0.7365704179,
0.5835940838,
-0.0104911039,
-0.1902217716,
-0.063566722,
-0.4121589065,
0.0312223472,
-0.164685145,
0.8508815765,
-0.5694446564,
-0.6489424109,
-0.652651906,
0.2263275385,
-0.4716077745,
1.1949648857,
0.1137210429,
-0.3181068003,
-0.2569516599,
0.1527799964,
-0.1820559651,
-0.6123198271,
-0.4175485075,
-0.6805861592,
0.1333609223,
0.2320238799,
0.4556852579,
0.6222772598,
0.4872390032,
0.298247695,
-0.0912090689,
0.4707621038,
-0.5042341352,
0.1221614182,
-0.2598325908,
-0.6859938502,
-0.3989228606,
-0.1676699817,
0.260445267,
0.7614940405,
-0.4729272425,
0.3161666393,
0.2679906785,
1.2531688213,
-0.8025644422,
0.2544978857,
-0.9359948635,
0.1090621576,
-0.3591220081,
-0.3962351382,
-0.293397069,
-0.166651383,
0.0072314413,
-0.47416991,
0.4512409866,
0.0093733789,
0.338874042,
0.5342386365,
-0.2244690955,
-0.7154804468,
-1.0716460943,
1.0006886721,
-0.7644883394,
0.0179057028,
0.460042119,
0.3194218278,
-0.2794724703,
-0.9469898343,
-0.6157777905,
-0.1124004424,
0.2064765245,
0.0956219882,
-0.2449544668,
0.0437621213,
0.1614534259,
0.7219144106,
-0.4651208222,
-0.3969098628,
-0.1205401048,
0.4264318049,
0.6368370652,
0.0431632921,
-0.1109135002,
0.0025390512,
-0.0594654195,
-0.0199174844,
-0.7071253061,
-0.4645290077,
0.6460157633,
0.4943521917,
0.1857586056,
0.7459310889,
-0.3057622612,
0.891043365,
0.2574951351,
-0.4140840769,
0.3096855581,
-0.2758343518,
-0.3638440073,
0.0951241404,
0.6864354014,
0.1957681179,
0.17217125,
-0.3053662777,
-0.1017501801,
0.0812092721,
0.0700490847,
-0.6336753368,
-0.5261820555,
0.1863375753,
-0.3430416882,
-0.2404522747,
-0.0103826663,
-0.5282988548,
-0.4612033665,
-0.1958620995,
0.1454761028,
-0.0531855486,
-0.4321730733,
0.4766269922,
-0.3314581513,
-0.5618673563,
-0.0728153512,
-1.2481132746,
0.499291271,
0.4317044616,
0.8260124922,
-0.2077507973,
0.1614508927,
-0.5027542114,
0.4388011396,
-0.1203294098,
0.5135159492,
-0.1322178394,
-0.4084031582,
-0.1425511986,
-0.2353579253,
0.1449355334,
-0.9886471033,
0.3373692334,
-0.4170003831,
0.0215513017,
-0.3148159981,
-0.6440545321,
-0.1360925883,
0.1205027327,
-0.6478407979,
1.021476984,
0.2292726189,
-0.8844391108,
0.5434100628,
-0.7620747089,
-0.2041928321,
0.1191310138,
-0.2587859929,
-0.351644218,
0.2149736285,
0.1681583673,
0.2443865985,
-0.3759085536,
0.3946850896,
-0.2483205348,
-0.1475254446,
-0.0460677221,
-0.561968565,
0.5999224782,
0.4865733683,
-0.4750167429,
-0.3688696027,
-0.8857269883,
-0.1329377145,
0.1561095864,
-0.501003325,
-0.581186235,
0.2915172279,
-0.2792921662,
-0.0245166402,
0.2017282099,
-0.3846310973,
0.351770103,
-0.3182010949,
0.4040679634,
0.418512702,
0.1630634069,
0.5830967426,
-0.3167479932,
0.3379147351,
-0.0239833128,
0.0583661161,
0.1255366802,
-0.4392597377,
-0.5032839775,
-0.2308968604,
0.170156166,
0.6526546478,
-0.7464450598,
0.7399140596,
-0.1892602146,
-0.4050477743,
-0.3887768388,
0.7835844755,
0.0963658243,
0.6786548495,
0.2432803363,
-0.2191446573,
-0.5273919106,
-0.3483122587,
-0.011770322,
-0.3257659078,
-0.1103015766,
0.0892928392,
0.3300999701,
-0.4223524034,
1.196269989,
-0.6651456356,
-0.5573008657,
-0.4961284399,
0.2437674999,
0.3911614716,
0.2625959516,
0.5843856931,
-0.7420917153,
-0.4486594796,
0.0200338867,
-0.8362908959,
-0.3729819953,
0.152727142,
-0.2328886986,
0.2238710672,
0.3615020812,
-0.3769769967,
0.2313715965,
0.7634470463,
0.0138417911,
0.2872284055,
-0.506714344,
0.0434493385,
-1.2124603987,
0.2918879986,
-0.0703083724,
-0.1065388173,
-0.6064184308,
-0.35254848,
-0.144424215,
0.069633171,
-0.2643281817,
0.3020949364,
-0.4329118133,
0.0821132809,
-0.5063300729,
0.1121159121,
0.1654689163,
0.238168925,
0.2188002616,
0.366304487,
0.4159795046,
-0.7506073117,
0.6005149484,
0.26474154,
-0.4382078052,
0.3871922493,
-0.4813333452,
0.0751103312,
-0.176794216,
0.0308255814,
-0.8963230848,
-0.0119003104,
0.1659910381,
-0.0496165864,
0.3266430497,
-0.3034678996,
-0.6811443567,
-0.2765897512,
0.0706731677,
0.2223841399,
0.707983017,
-0.5847584605,
0.3333000839,
0.3214452565,
-0.2628597021,
-0.6642565131,
-1.0984098911,
-0.0707171261,
-0.5864331126,
-0.4848609269,
0.2894244492,
-0.2371535599,
-0.6529383063,
0.1682907343,
-0.0419914536,
0.0314750411,
-0.0244483016,
0.1315061003,
-0.1285772026,
0.219088614,
0.2011271119,
0.0904738754,
0.0078528477,
0.0018447201,
-0.6257868409,
0.3948082626,
0.227571398,
-0.6509197354,
-0.025886938,
0.2810163498,
0.0488221832,
0.2208058089,
0.429042846,
0.2656776607,
-0.0978319421,
-0.4012375474,
-0.31111902,
0.0086813848,
-0.5329213738,
0.3478607237,
-0.0717627257,
-0.6036410332,
0.4292335212,
-0.4073147178,
0.4289107323,
0.3849513233,
0.6723849773,
0.0592372119,
1.1015882492,
0.9758008718,
-0.1682129502,
0.4636496603,
-0.4651401341,
0.2260852903,
-0.3461331427,
0.079375878,
-0.5005948544,
-0.210988149,
-0.2067702711,
-0.2488768846,
0.4404269159,
0.3484346569,
0.1653890908,
-0.1147032157,
-0.5171319842,
0.2588212192,
0.5514929295,
-0.0774914622,
0.6857326031,
0.2877486348,
0.1472889185,
0.0831599534,
-0.8886399865,
-0.5450607538,
1.408688426,
-0.0352828689,
0.9892567396,
-0.0855710804,
1.0785381794,
0.5643233657,
0.2475514263,
-0.4457209408,
0.2068204731,
-0.4299321473,
-0.5685759783,
-0.0890943259,
-0.6902008057,
-0.8072367311,
-0.0264774188,
0.0258631315,
-0.4321647584,
-0.2047083527,
0.5188827515,
-0.4380149543,
0.3790840209,
-0.7640673518,
0.5395721197,
-0.2545906305,
-0.0949610099,
0.073533237,
-0.4010711312,
0.5756005645,
-0.1758319288,
0.4762382209,
-0.0086094402,
0.3246242106,
0.6773973107,
-0.7084055543,
0.73111099,
-0.3933607638,
-0.4227925837,
0.7204554081,
-0.24370341,
0.5478053093,
0.0846634805,
-0.162875101,
-0.0662138835,
-0.2907574773,
-0.0857892558,
-0.7579541206,
0.6698756814,
-0.5138306022,
-0.4481414855,
-0.1767008454,
-0.7906606197,
-0.1566076577,
-0.1168502197,
0.5230090618,
0.2161729634,
0.1086166948,
-0.0700406805,
0.7350203395,
-0.0412687846,
0.4244522154,
0.3408851326,
-0.1338581592,
-0.3936654329,
0.9649711251,
0.2398220599,
0.4587126374,
0.2288849801,
0.0720708743,
-0.5824002028,
-0.711623013,
-0.5819992423,
0.1007293314,
-0.7156826258,
-0.1064107642,
-0.4231548905,
0.0299188886,
-0.3341682851,
-0.0364150926,
-0.4298876524,
-0.4064671695,
-0.4792572856,
-0.0414989442,
0.7137213349,
0.8658105731,
-0.3691727221,
0.3850207925,
-0.8335607648,
0.388304919,
0.402636081,
0.1038695201,
-0.2367954403,
-0.3839333355,
-0.3676064014,
0.3698048592,
-0.4274032712,
-0.5949064493,
0.5254246593,
0.5263163447,
0.603113234,
0.4038644731,
0.3790437579,
0.7522518635,
-0.4388396144,
0.9645185471,
0.2677668631,
-0.7026688457,
0.6887533665,
-0.0592774153,
0.2967311442,
0.69390589,
0.0829491317,
-0.1378682405,
-0.673663497,
-0.6908968687,
-1.0306555033,
0.3866999447,
0.1247379482,
0.0706285462,
-0.154996857,
0.4317948222,
0.4049559534,
0.7027301788,
-0.5083572268,
-0.4328220785,
-0.0125247957,
-0.3747442067,
-0.2573700249,
-0.0908037052,
-0.2185437828,
0.1360482126,
0.7911084294,
-0.2226538658,
-0.076679714,
0.0795195624,
-0.2624690533,
-0.2739396691,
0.1448937058,
0.2786270678,
0.5410103202,
-0.3097248375,
0.2786621153,
-0.00889902,
-0.7157897353,
0.1237859577,
-0.0165335834,
-0.2753372788,
0.2702209949,
-0.0537549444,
0.6460495591,
-0.4361593425,
-0.6314730048,
0.1415011287,
-0.0781718791,
-0.4707321525,
-0.2061129063,
0.3015282154,
0.0435041338,
0.4397599697,
0.5655195713,
0.0029994491,
0.2566593587,
-0.4308116734,
0.1564967781,
0.3721192777,
-0.0033989944,
-0.2629507482,
0.5658909678,
0.0420177467,
0.2137133479,
0.4773148298,
-0.4696312249,
0.0810425356,
0.1914350092,
0.4476476014,
0.7627416253,
0.0068286425,
0.1206192225,
0.0654177293,
0.0412769057,
-0.462030232,
0.6962999701,
-0.3667886555,
-0.5215674639,
-0.5672241449,
-0.8048778176,
-0.3133140504,
0.3380234241,
-0.6521909237,
0.027157465,
-0.04584473,
-0.4431218505,
-0.4821340144,
0.2494967729,
-0.3786439896,
0.1239703894,
0.0726561174,
0.7298203111,
-0.9826569557,
0.7998000383,
0.5090392828,
-0.0645697489,
-0.5020065308,
-0.136056006,
-0.1293783337,
-0.4295349121,
0.5799332261,
-0.3487731814,
0.0114928549,
0.1659522355,
-0.4871592522,
-0.7459082603,
1.2068309784,
0.8830598593,
-0.6040193439,
-0.0071403254,
0.4263885617,
0.4319966733,
-0.1728812605,
-0.0679650009,
0.6900436878,
0.3721652627,
0.375389576,
-0.8868298531,
-0.3923437297,
-0.4009516835,
0.0568167418,
0.0282041114,
-0.1341518909,
0.7721689343,
-0.1671963185,
-0.1510276943,
-0.1015320942,
0.7117674351,
0.6785791516,
0.2543103397,
0.4681636095,
0.7413785458,
0.9023682475,
-0.0172145031,
0.7457048893,
-0.2510431409,
0.3571205735,
1.0097748041,
-0.4900735319,
0.4985425472,
0.7020085454,
-0.1464069337,
0.3668139279,
0.3021990657,
0.194425419,
1.0921082497,
0.4658244252,
-0.4433557987,
0.1424174756,
-0.0443105064,
-0.4920735657,
0.1386315823,
0.3362859786,
-0.4613745511,
-0.6165524125,
0.1052749008,
-0.1293645054,
0.1084319055,
-0.375477165,
0.8892065287,
0.1745954007,
-0.5308530927,
0.7879971266,
-0.1382603943,
0.8164722919,
-0.8318832517,
-0.1146057397,
-0.0612013601,
0.4678294063,
-0.2744902372,
-0.4848911464,
0.5328908563,
0.2486145198,
-0.4356166422,
-0.4762754738,
0.7671636939,
-0.7818758488,
-0.2889397442,
0.0094325375,
0.6291989088,
0.1878043115,
-0.2577631772,
-0.4344250262,
-0.0687416941,
-0.041480802,
-0.5013670921,
0.5124123693,
0.6982580423,
0.1020517573,
0.4935486913,
0.4747924805,
0.4548213482,
0.2615711987,
0.150603354,
0.7380962968,
-0.0755350813,
-0.5843004584,
-0.9197286963,
0.4779335558,
0.1275057495,
0.0052943151,
0.80664891,
0.3801140189,
0.8430148363,
-0.1389224678,
1.4038553238,
-0.231705904,
0.403362602,
-0.5263867974,
0.7041756511,
-0.5499150753,
0.2094857395,
-0.3571737111,
-0.9226108789,
-0.1158401966,
0.4708993435,
-0.1550941765,
-0.0199053641,
0.3751575947,
0.572424233,
-0.0229671951,
-0.1651684493,
0.2515294254,
-0.2937761247,
0.3704121411,
0.5993363857,
0.6344089508,
-0.3208461106,
0.4916950762,
-0.3182420731,
-0.2391734272,
-0.0617836528,
-1.1336672306,
-0.7634241581,
-0.5960605145,
-0.3390602171,
-0.1536083966,
-0.0079460302,
0.7259849906,
0.5812083483,
-0.6720021367,
-0.38993752,
-0.7344806194,
-0.1994604468,
-0.4988645315,
-0.1556832641,
0.278760761,
-0.5238810182,
-0.7449419498,
0.3838343918,
0.2069329619,
0.0945964307,
-0.2803422213,
-0.31894207,
0.1333050281,
-0.0859056637,
0.4080283344,
0.1819652319,
-0.2670982778,
0.1309002936,
-0.0413070396,
0.1008696482,
-0.2475789785,
0.685251832,
-0.7213634849,
0.4266579449,
0.3982304037,
0.3889293075,
0.4651498795,
0.1099399179,
0.6644580364,
-1.2653437853,
0.257209599,
0.0885939971,
0.2802748084,
0.3051005304,
-0.3334934413,
0.4114792645,
0.380344063,
-0.593863368,
-0.8389659524,
0.2038929909,
-0.746363759,
-0.0831212252,
1.4060555696,
-0.3083195686,
-0.3024327457,
-0.1762667,
-0.1841737032,
0.4694456458,
-0.2639455497,
1.0963724852,
0.4940849841,
-0.1898942143,
0.1636443287,
-0.49910748,
0.7936227918,
0.1433689296,
-0.8037447929,
0.4215058088,
0.4551248252,
0.2256757319,
0.3024056852,
0.8845532537,
-0.052756954,
-0.1932025999,
-0.0410750583,
0.1347871125,
-0.3392277658,
-0.3195609152,
-0.0891632661,
0.326665014,
0.1013534516,
-0.0941587463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19651v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19651v2
|
MagicLens: Self-Supervised Image Retrieval with Open-Ended Instructions
| 2024-03-28T17:59:20 | 2024-06-24T23:41:29 |
Kai Zhang, Yi Luan, Hexiang Hu, Kenton Lee, Siyuan Qiao, Wenhu Chen, Yu Su, Ming-Wei Chang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.MM
|
Image retrieval, i.e., finding desired images given a reference image,
inherently encompasses rich, multi-faceted search intents that are difficult to
capture solely using image-based measures. Recent works leverage text
instructions to allow users to more freely express their search intents.
However, they primarily focus on image pairs that are visually similar and/or
can be characterized by a small set of pre-defined relations. The core thesis
of this paper is that text instructions can enable retrieving images with
richer relations beyond visual similarity. To show this, we introduce
MagicLens, a series of self-supervised image retrieval models that support
open-ended instructions. MagicLens is built on a key novel insight: image pairs
that naturally occur on the same web pages contain a wide range of implicit
relations (e.g., inside view of), and we can bring those implicit relations
explicit by synthesizing instructions via foundation models. Trained on 36.7M
(query image, instruction, target image) triplets with rich semantic relations
mined from the web, MagicLens achieves results comparable with or better than
prior best on eight benchmarks of various image retrieval tasks, while
maintaining high parameter efficiency with a significantly smaller model size.
Additional human analyses on a 1.4M-image unseen corpus further demonstrate the
diversity of search intents supported by MagicLens. Code and models are
publicly available at https://open-vision-language.github.io/MagicLens/.
|
[
-0.3626936078,
-0.380664885,
0.7323607206,
0.0459780432,
-0.2815220058,
-0.5130776167,
-0.2299766243,
-0.404622376,
-0.0903280973,
0.7685254216,
-0.5065232515,
-0.568903923,
-0.3533091247,
0.0502768643,
-0.3581641912,
0.9555928707,
-0.1288203299,
0.0997229069,
-0.3103916943,
-0.1914449781,
-0.1575386822,
-0.1023167074,
-0.1320298761,
0.2363115847,
0.7141797543,
0.3860452771,
1.1474626064,
0.8079067469,
0.9445686936,
0.3109351695,
0.1157176122,
0.6366397142,
-0.5724142194,
0.1942107379,
-0.4123129547,
-0.3687322736,
0.0958470628,
0.3565372527,
0.3851073384,
0.4286945462,
0.239012748,
0.2552229464,
-0.0575367995,
0.997471571,
-1.1843038797,
0.2025133222,
-0.557456553,
0.3527217507,
-0.2706664205,
-0.5722844005,
-0.3913695514,
-0.3609475195,
0.2832521796,
-0.9218966365,
0.3750341535,
0.1542259902,
0.6878231168,
-0.0522704683,
-0.2818053365,
-0.7120167613,
-0.5584471822,
0.6846215725,
-0.1983518451,
0.3999359906,
0.5825312138,
0.6407895088,
-0.1292737722,
-0.8311200738,
-0.3516090214,
-0.291756779,
-0.4842312634,
0.1439664364,
-0.0667485148,
0.0285410639,
0.029154392,
0.7448801994,
-0.437399447,
-0.4494156837,
-0.5398135185,
0.1429997087,
0.6057098508,
-0.0437647775,
0.4918861985,
-0.0145571809,
-0.2719188035,
-0.2107091397,
-0.5257743001,
-0.3101278245,
0.3640715182,
0.1941644996,
0.22136724,
0.8294505477,
-0.1723280549,
0.8233494759,
-0.0737927631,
0.0420948565,
0.0822948143,
-0.2518760264,
0.0081237499,
-0.2663743794,
0.7766812444,
0.4955484271,
0.4741832316,
-0.5806918144,
-0.2562112212,
-0.2666932344,
0.3324457109,
-0.9126005173,
-0.3964693248,
-0.2268930525,
-0.9314669967,
-0.0945126191,
0.3672543764,
-0.6927185655,
-0.1483827978,
-0.4257084727,
0.6658572555,
-0.5696359873,
0.077093251,
-0.0036219028,
-0.2459117621,
0.3266754746,
0.2956308424,
-0.859208107,
0.5347166657,
0.5403521061,
0.897241056,
-0.1146813482,
-0.2834865451,
-0.6579326391,
0.297016263,
-0.6184196472,
0.7014080286,
-0.8577623367,
-0.3351809084,
-0.0876306221,
0.0674322844,
-0.0546320789,
-0.3965649307,
0.4630393386,
-0.9366495013,
0.5372501016,
-0.090127036,
-0.4973255396,
-0.1142307892,
0.1139724329,
-0.8261749148,
0.8426964879,
-0.1958716065,
-0.6810696721,
-0.1726846397,
-0.9523866773,
-0.3056631982,
-0.0894989073,
-0.3076229692,
-0.2891205549,
0.2523124516,
0.1736285985,
0.4252911806,
-0.0788021833,
-0.3625047505,
-0.5550284982,
-0.6266304851,
0.0204142835,
-0.3910419643,
0.4872538447,
0.1717815995,
-0.1646257043,
-0.1171660796,
-0.5036517382,
0.2066218704,
0.604413867,
0.1185056046,
-0.8029386997,
-0.1316816956,
-0.2973890603,
0.097163111,
0.4660820961,
-0.4783321321,
0.3559634387,
-0.056501057,
-0.0484491847,
0.7312380672,
-0.2385464311,
0.55962044,
0.1190086529,
0.1184956357,
-0.3114051223,
0.5578612089,
-0.7295699716,
-0.4362417758,
-0.662296772,
-0.200497359,
0.1130172089,
0.4232197702,
-0.5614477396,
0.1599037647,
-0.3532986939,
-0.3788143396,
-0.5259180665,
0.2821400464,
0.9271484613,
0.3125383854,
0.7586231232,
-0.2777115703,
-0.112776123,
-1.1550638676,
-0.3736539781,
0.3613117635,
-0.0788558051,
0.656321466,
0.5663779378,
-0.1311247051,
0.8156561852,
-0.7364181876,
-0.6130341887,
0.572322309,
-0.1185324565,
0.1523960382,
0.217792362,
0.6515587568,
-1.2882419825,
-0.6469357014,
0.1941391677,
-0.9143143892,
0.0831405297,
0.3100104928,
-0.4372202158,
-0.026860388,
0.3968379796,
-0.62744838,
0.8633758426,
0.3129934371,
-0.2258055061,
0.6120462418,
-0.4143809378,
0.4958463907,
-0.5297138095,
0.0818757713,
0.0503346212,
-0.0150865261,
-0.2900887132,
0.2728881836,
0.2607339025,
0.131943956,
-0.3468517065,
0.5686286092,
-0.9436158538,
-0.4611419439,
-0.2363284081,
-0.0743553415,
0.2829182446,
0.5495513678,
0.059038043,
0.9679284096,
0.5871009827,
-0.527505219,
0.4787775874,
0.1805063039,
0.036291834,
0.7444022894,
-0.4165794551,
0.4463009238,
-0.1781429201,
-0.0857361108,
-0.7432057858,
-0.1310838312,
0.229625985,
-0.2717648745,
0.2871876955,
-0.3817074597,
-0.7433879972,
-0.58942312,
-0.4463758767,
0.4468865395,
0.3194624484,
-0.9274322987,
0.5924956799,
0.0229899567,
0.226691246,
-0.5882014632,
-0.5689422488,
0.0583163314,
0.1461500973,
-0.5795755982,
0.6245422363,
-0.116846852,
-0.239416793,
0.53338027,
-0.1826413125,
-0.3467018008,
-0.365201354,
0.2036699504,
0.3027256429,
-0.0227233917,
0.1992063373,
-0.2973922491,
-0.0072807111,
-0.2016145736,
-0.5988368988,
0.0488192365,
-0.3990774751,
-0.6442350745,
-0.3366036713,
0.5179322362,
0.4726175964,
-0.4018222988,
0.5723697543,
0.6216207743,
-0.2430040836,
0.1346403807,
-0.522000432,
-0.1009205654,
-0.5221579671,
-0.2003033161,
-0.6400133967,
-0.6022885442,
0.2950075865,
0.1983751655,
0.0377577543,
0.2974200547,
0.209933117,
-0.4763166904,
1.1217068434,
0.5066853166,
0.476706028,
0.3648384511,
-0.4508571327,
-0.0137868673,
-0.7242446542,
-0.500465095,
-0.1376824826,
-0.2138650119,
-0.4339060485,
-0.4075200856,
0.5057592988,
0.0585476942,
0.0853488967,
0.2192758173,
-0.8381850719,
0.8985804319,
0.9930455685,
0.5939527154,
0.2688561082,
0.2576014698,
-0.4042105675,
-0.0648505315,
-0.390678823,
-0.3728480637,
1.0904949903,
-0.1732256711,
0.8551807404,
0.0023451184,
0.6171050072,
0.3838770986,
0.2160896212,
-0.6043940783,
0.5838686824,
-0.4243445396,
-0.4393070638,
-0.120446682,
-0.5103392005,
-1.2838008404,
0.3492328823,
0.0469272397,
-0.3783477843,
-0.0554067828,
0.2312842458,
-0.1275613755,
0.4526256919,
-0.7090035677,
0.8148162365,
-0.6043252945,
-0.7772328854,
-0.2730301619,
-0.7814200521,
0.4605594277,
0.1481145769,
0.2799842954,
0.0076763569,
-0.0958614647,
0.4704908431,
-0.5183146,
0.5777330995,
-0.013105114,
0.0382106155,
0.292142272,
0.2774246335,
0.2723951042,
-0.5344486237,
0.144428283,
0.0659561008,
0.0458305329,
-0.3503813148,
-1.0225753784,
0.7866973281,
-0.5296966434,
-0.4829292893,
-0.0998982266,
-0.3828134239,
0.1436863691,
0.4571916163,
0.1175979152,
0.5088624358,
-0.0436059199,
0.0877678394,
0.9868546724,
-0.0809556022,
0.4534787834,
0.4272984564,
-0.4776408374,
-0.437438786,
0.9803237319,
0.1854591817,
-0.0352579951,
0.4550969899,
0.2564412355,
-0.3028602302,
-0.2434902787,
-0.5501721501,
0.2736881375,
-0.8120790124,
-0.3825080395,
-0.4726736844,
-0.0599098094,
-0.3367465138,
-0.0545210168,
-0.4619064927,
-0.2603518069,
-0.5331523418,
0.3223676383,
0.5758700371,
0.7567890286,
-0.194752261,
0.0940061882,
-0.9097263217,
0.8265613914,
0.7467023134,
0.8837497234,
-0.0738840476,
-0.2537219226,
-0.3133422732,
0.0122513138,
-0.3041686714,
-1.1721374989,
0.3390511572,
0.2709189355,
0.689858973,
0.4811199009,
0.0280209128,
0.8918469548,
-0.7639138103,
0.398581028,
0.274825424,
-0.6263763309,
0.8325849175,
-0.3015800118,
-0.04463844,
0.432064563,
0.4715245366,
-0.1633247286,
0.2453356385,
-0.5426940918,
-0.407674998,
0.5002366304,
0.6032722592,
0.2245505154,
0.0387725122,
0.4934066832,
0.0423288681,
0.0370422564,
-0.4812772274,
-0.3900022805,
-0.290386498,
-0.2904020846,
0.5136431456,
-0.05191347,
-0.3742809594,
-0.1851532906,
0.4369384944,
-0.2496560067,
0.4220980108,
0.5413390994,
-0.1729020476,
-0.1323875338,
0.0311027262,
0.1671543717,
0.2939130962,
-0.0766531378,
0.3795450628,
-0.262911886,
-0.3767973483,
-0.0795672163,
0.3899051845,
-0.0426814258,
-0.041791141,
0.1733098775,
0.6258437634,
0.1654480845,
-0.6099227667,
0.8197749257,
-0.1977864653,
-0.1236064658,
-0.2978777289,
0.1718404591,
-0.3009492457,
0.2239965647,
0.7913810015,
0.0977883637,
0.6092104912,
-0.5311229825,
0.357160598,
0.8622729182,
-0.438745141,
-0.2008262277,
0.4167369604,
-0.0283848122,
-0.2711392641,
0.5238469243,
-0.4999249279,
-0.4507631063,
0.4034454525,
0.3588257432,
0.6670558453,
-0.058659099,
0.0427743942,
-0.0630833805,
0.2510356605,
-0.1793061495,
0.2752292454,
-0.2797293663,
-0.4276327193,
-0.2011096478,
-0.3652878404,
-0.3757023215,
-0.2348348945,
-0.6246178746,
0.2134507895,
-0.1883747727,
0.0883390084,
-0.2569996119,
-0.1199895963,
-0.83238554,
0.1277846992,
0.2573402822,
0.9037458301,
-0.198124975,
0.5228769779,
0.4593056738,
-0.4664670527,
-0.4397091568,
-0.3112891018,
-0.2406566888,
-0.8710674047,
0.6810702682,
0.5572161078,
-0.2516227663,
0.1586170346,
-0.9315092564,
-0.7793457508,
1.0900905132,
0.3838602006,
-0.2016910464,
-0.2206560224,
-0.0707746446,
0.3670525551,
-0.3395372331,
0.5448220372,
0.2577755451,
0.5603280663,
0.2759329081,
-0.9089307785,
-0.1288415194,
-0.5563804507,
-0.0698448345,
0.1051977277,
-0.5003590584,
0.6486260891,
-0.6209326982,
-0.4527337551,
0.2699743509,
0.7261074185,
0.2820686698,
0.5423521399,
0.3578258455,
0.6886014938,
0.3867943585,
0.1957050562,
1.1431031227,
-0.2135685533,
0.1949195713,
0.9530083537,
0.1041625142,
0.694380939,
0.3888559043,
-0.0498479567,
0.6613733172,
0.4624750316,
-0.2274966687,
0.7516277432,
-0.1434224099,
-0.0781835988,
-0.2140774429,
-0.1563331932,
-0.3589769006,
0.218985185,
0.5596951246,
-0.8488492966,
-0.371447891,
-0.0373732895,
-0.3903981447,
0.2771836817,
-0.4999336004,
0.6193980575,
-0.0363165885,
-0.4621821344,
0.3685540557,
-0.3062713742,
0.6935718656,
-0.4492066205,
-0.4072374105,
0.0590060577,
-0.0159072857,
-0.3171952069,
-1.1005634069,
0.0129870949,
-0.294462204,
-0.227728188,
-0.0728134513,
1.078707695,
-0.390917629,
-0.5474148393,
0.2855286598,
0.4509167075,
0.2921365798,
-0.2430892885,
-0.7446529865,
-0.0593218543,
-0.1989303976,
-0.4615451097,
0.0398157202,
0.4508853257,
0.018766826,
0.5971823931,
0.808355689,
-0.1727256328,
0.3669363856,
-0.2788560987,
0.8331131339,
-0.5236129165,
-0.1857204735,
-0.7414107323,
0.0780596957,
-0.2590363622,
0.1064129248,
0.8216516972,
0.6229039431,
0.728089571,
-0.228637889,
0.6534175277,
0.3014983535,
0.1229925081,
-0.5418358445,
0.2727360129,
-0.6663567424,
-0.2245586663,
-0.1780652553,
-0.8536204696,
-0.4977328479,
0.6224742532,
-0.4956510067,
0.1381887048,
0.4284579754,
0.9184733033,
-0.6569592953,
0.1014478803,
0.1944690496,
-0.3801153004,
-0.0320833884,
0.269148767,
0.8639314771,
-0.4428495765,
0.9133368731,
-0.4162050784,
-0.1379341483,
-0.2638575733,
-0.7394928336,
-0.8539205194,
-0.4444304705,
-0.0864748731,
-0.1157448813,
0.3352611959,
0.6514246464,
0.9663051963,
-0.3215108216,
0.2019542158,
-0.1992925853,
0.0695094615,
-0.1007676795,
-0.253809005,
0.5717822909,
-0.4042732716,
-0.6758530736,
0.310400635,
0.4934154451,
0.3985193372,
-0.4380327165,
-0.2015892118,
-0.0576724522,
0.0669722334,
0.4557690918,
0.3846571743,
-0.5782322288,
0.0560958534,
0.3009830713,
-0.3886907399,
0.115873903,
0.9009467363,
-0.8047773242,
0.5598533154,
0.4451243579,
0.3520593941,
0.5678031445,
-0.2214620411,
0.2721513212,
-0.710544467,
-0.0992367491,
0.0491758771,
0.3392885327,
0.5828617215,
-0.4513829947,
0.7834221721,
0.304043442,
-0.3726854324,
-0.518925488,
0.0844321847,
-0.6488780379,
-0.6040642858,
1.0895658731,
-0.227652505,
-0.3882799745,
0.305475235,
-0.2724691927,
0.2382042855,
-0.2050400227,
0.5558614135,
0.1003895849,
-0.2260600328,
-0.3439160585,
-0.5246059299,
0.1487879902,
0.1275789291,
-0.4644801915,
-0.1573471576,
0.5805152655,
-0.0313389339,
0.5126277804,
0.4357278049,
-0.3014151752,
0.4150729775,
-0.3007877767,
0.1290971488,
-0.3167533278,
-0.5200709701,
0.1659035683,
0.4317632616,
-0.4903944433,
-0.4475076795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19647v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19647v2
|
Sparse Feature Circuits: Discovering and Editing Interpretable Causal Graphs in Language Models
| 2024-03-28T17:56:07 | 2024-03-31T16:54:50 |
Samuel Marks, Can Rager, Eric J. Michaud, Yonatan Belinkov, David Bau, Aaron Mueller
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce methods for discovering and applying sparse feature circuits.
These are causally implicated subnetworks of human-interpretable features for
explaining language model behaviors. Circuits identified in prior work consist
of polysemantic and difficult-to-interpret units like attention heads or
neurons, rendering them unsuitable for many downstream applications. In
contrast, sparse feature circuits enable detailed understanding of
unanticipated mechanisms. Because they are based on fine-grained units, sparse
feature circuits are useful for downstream tasks: We introduce SHIFT, where we
improve the generalization of a classifier by ablating features that a human
judges to be task-irrelevant. Finally, we demonstrate an entirely unsupervised
and scalable interpretability pipeline by discovering thousands of sparse
feature circuits for automatically discovered model behaviors.
|
[
-0.2561280727,
-0.7856760025,
0.8749679923,
0.1911019087,
0.1536448896,
-0.0503703952,
-0.1705611646,
-0.3767156899,
0.3339654207,
0.6588600278,
-0.7581843138,
-0.182736367,
-0.659876287,
-0.2186810374,
-0.8022651076,
0.9075671434,
0.0580976419,
-0.3607957363,
0.0765354559,
-0.1501947045,
-0.537388742,
-0.2739962339,
-0.4988204539,
-0.4020011723,
0.6778797507,
0.3041976392,
0.8818027973,
0.5839890838,
0.121487543,
0.4355269074,
-0.1686502397,
0.0035324371,
-0.4829965532,
-0.1035904586,
-0.3552641869,
-0.2210631669,
-0.4849315584,
-0.2344959825,
0.4682980776,
1.4451943636,
0.2176343054,
0.2633813918,
0.2831941247,
0.5275453925,
-0.499348402,
0.5799836516,
-0.7130411863,
-0.3667717576,
-0.2357368469,
-0.2324907631,
-0.5362145901,
-0.0031401403,
-0.0608597472,
-0.6175203323,
0.7062842846,
0.0246289466,
0.6893178225,
0.2686779797,
-0.3401685059,
-0.1355056167,
-0.7199568152,
0.6177545786,
-0.0446115695,
0.4249980748,
0.4820268154,
-0.0316260159,
-0.3158805072,
-1.0005184412,
-0.1870820373,
-0.0641236529,
-0.3892879486,
-0.4135653377,
-0.4591742754,
0.358022213,
0.4222082496,
0.0698626712,
-0.4965880811,
0.1146574616,
-0.3374792635,
-0.4208464622,
0.5296143293,
0.3832058311,
0.4473670423,
-0.1462349445,
0.241939649,
0.2636162341,
-0.7529341578,
0.0539455973,
0.3687000871,
0.4871870577,
0.1035077199,
0.4503266215,
-0.259896338,
0.7371243834,
0.0787613615,
0.2972165048,
0.052817449,
-0.09501075,
-0.2780883908,
0.0065556644,
0.6860199571,
-0.41206038,
0.3684617281,
-0.2572922409,
-0.0188879762,
-0.2353336662,
0.4460101426,
-0.374147892,
-0.6563886404,
-0.044458013,
-0.6868894696,
-0.3135845363,
-0.1191205606,
-0.6273936033,
-0.5147610307,
-0.3483779132,
0.3304561675,
-0.2741040885,
-0.1292172074,
-0.0141076753,
-0.0755213499,
-0.3296100199,
0.4386262,
-1.471395731,
0.5334669948,
0.4955888987,
0.8667855263,
0.0695929751,
-0.5405222178,
-0.3553799093,
0.0317219011,
-0.1979153454,
0.8913800716,
-0.5102721453,
0.0572108403,
-0.1755365431,
0.4893664122,
-0.3031328917,
-0.3509143889,
0.5944950581,
-0.5726566911,
-0.4380879998,
-0.3420764506,
-0.1326959878,
-0.1609775573,
-0.5967670679,
-0.9018042088,
0.890886426,
0.3564201593,
-0.9305967689,
0.2037484944,
-0.6520907283,
-0.7263505459,
-0.1663778722,
0.1082045287,
-0.2570434213,
0.3398294151,
0.1932938546,
0.2908512354,
-0.05788178,
0.2953943014,
-0.4834481478,
-0.5502896309,
0.4196603,
-0.5748969316,
1.0418854952,
0.224827528,
-0.4531580806,
0.4155197442,
-0.8746057153,
-0.3407944739,
0.0276019666,
0.1674771607,
-0.3968378603,
0.5329741836,
0.1986460239,
0.0143098263,
0.0266891588,
-0.3684000969,
-0.0870974958,
-0.2682771385,
0.9550415277,
0.8560794592,
0.0696081892,
0.4167464674,
0.1642458886,
0.1652551889,
-0.0692986324,
0.1500634849,
-0.2003322691,
-0.5134150982,
-0.9710874557,
-0.1976207197,
0.2333746403,
0.3563618958,
-0.559572041,
0.5921213031,
-0.1580721587,
-0.0333549865,
-0.3324680924,
0.3091755509,
0.0410439149,
0.5146671534,
0.4756325483,
-0.1951156855,
-0.3637582064,
-0.8682284355,
-0.2158784419,
-0.2261863053,
-0.156611979,
0.0937054008,
0.2671539783,
-0.2444897443,
0.7416466475,
-0.8371647596,
0.1496382207,
-0.3771066666,
0.4042683542,
-0.0845224187,
0.3798125386,
0.2679881155,
-0.4357921779,
0.1156460345,
-0.0055176266,
-0.5989955068,
-0.3754197955,
-0.4031072259,
-0.1499376297,
-0.113255091,
0.7754070759,
-0.4795233905,
0.5114685893,
0.1581075788,
-0.2998617887,
0.0627913699,
-0.1103441194,
-0.0076716533,
-0.3671043217,
0.0722841844,
-0.000504303,
-0.2602467239,
-0.4929703176,
-0.2161118835,
0.0503659621,
-0.1393982917,
-0.0152031295,
0.3057692051,
-0.454166621,
-0.5578474998,
-0.167777136,
0.0193911586,
-0.0023613474,
0.6578753591,
-0.0779046118,
0.4670287073,
0.5036281943,
-0.3520145416,
0.1870118976,
0.0799409449,
-0.4084438086,
0.0016626903,
-0.4900880158,
-0.0074723307,
-0.1150280088,
-0.219268173,
-1.0932022333,
-0.3137138486,
0.0529890805,
-0.2559695542,
0.5201569796,
-0.2650579512,
-0.5056955218,
-0.1644281596,
0.0092209904,
0.3841691315,
0.3072582483,
-0.5333679318,
0.1234155744,
0.5670647025,
-0.1686307937,
-0.2208068818,
-0.6610904336,
-0.0691468343,
0.0424629934,
-0.5086418986,
-0.0449148379,
0.3850851953,
-0.0662143081,
0.2197722495,
-0.0151294405,
-0.4347716272,
0.4129010737,
0.5559019446,
0.1218733117,
-0.1635139734,
0.2990235388,
0.3547123969,
-0.3369157612,
0.0843528882,
-0.2884195745,
0.275295496,
-0.0444746353,
-0.4447035491,
-0.3896031976,
0.2663947642,
0.7003932595,
-0.0879972279,
0.3436099589,
0.580726862,
-0.5080581903,
-0.1840707362,
-0.1279006153,
-0.1365394741,
-0.4505163133,
0.5998159647,
-0.1718533188,
-1.3600643873,
0.53639853,
-0.3444801867,
-0.5042422414,
0.6231695414,
0.4982408285,
0.0791263506,
1.3024208546,
0.9708310962,
-0.0578731857,
0.5530679822,
0.0348416306,
0.6325399876,
-0.6278503537,
-0.1503228247,
-0.6318116784,
-0.2755847275,
-0.7812201977,
-0.2175185531,
0.4872322679,
0.2168413848,
-0.3365190625,
0.4887138009,
-0.4606095254,
0.4889981151,
0.2883343101,
0.1732791811,
0.1935357302,
0.0236895345,
-0.1516729891,
-0.1415285021,
-0.7862326503,
-0.2466344386,
0.7230585217,
0.3637462556,
1.0533511639,
-0.1515657008,
0.2605462968,
0.2653160393,
0.1645479947,
-0.7576451898,
0.3006308377,
-0.1642379761,
-0.4199246764,
-0.612113893,
-0.4414150119,
-0.9603198171,
-0.0762586892,
-0.2396032214,
-1.3533864021,
0.5704445839,
0.2001411468,
-0.2617689669,
0.2809063196,
-1.0198518038,
1.2322412729,
-0.0816855207,
-0.3219271004,
-0.3379891217,
-0.4953198135,
0.5541704297,
0.008741837,
0.2385127097,
0.1036848649,
0.2103799433,
0.2758132517,
-0.6586819291,
1.1893390417,
0.1273692548,
0.2723366916,
0.3567189872,
0.4042474926,
0.3143981993,
0.1331077814,
0.1474262178,
0.2247175425,
-0.2450321317,
-0.2512027621,
-0.8405096531,
0.9434717894,
-0.7487294078,
-0.3474474549,
-0.0941447914,
-0.7848909497,
-0.1843694896,
0.2628266811,
0.0797859281,
0.6419132948,
-0.1285576075,
-0.2845209539,
0.7623106241,
-0.2010508478,
0.3960048258,
0.0640321225,
0.1034734026,
0.0349486284,
1.1656485796,
0.1942682266,
0.1534622014,
0.4739242196,
0.0112413028,
-0.1726945788,
-0.5353606939,
-0.4095422029,
0.0380463898,
-0.6960039139,
0.0272736326,
-0.862699151,
-0.4172282219,
-0.3425397277,
-0.2201718092,
-0.3107816875,
-0.9642605186,
-0.3660500646,
-0.1397794187,
0.4552405775,
0.9797167778,
-0.1675611287,
0.253436029,
-0.6157057285,
0.3760955036,
0.609621346,
0.5310662985,
0.238997519,
-0.4536927938,
-0.4905527234,
-0.3038568199,
-0.2760886252,
-0.881416738,
0.2469426692,
-0.0101200351,
0.512526691,
0.4478104115,
-0.2136203945,
0.9220737815,
-0.5569608212,
0.54046911,
0.0133948894,
-1.5047256947,
0.6813278794,
-0.110780865,
0.0415606685,
0.2031633258,
0.4204183221,
-0.2623293102,
-0.4487966597,
-0.6179607511,
-0.7895675302,
0.9803139567,
0.3038466871,
-0.010618587,
-0.0921285823,
0.4549258947,
-0.19364205,
0.0690220073,
-0.5515046716,
-0.2455596477,
-0.3528130054,
-0.1431484967,
-0.026042778,
-0.4536273777,
0.0885701552,
-0.4358725548,
0.1947500557,
-0.202216059,
0.1423748285,
0.1101892963,
-0.2683700621,
-0.4627031982,
0.3393096626,
0.5665140152,
0.8509594798,
-0.2784090638,
0.5019438267,
0.0485153086,
-0.4908675253,
-0.0432527065,
0.1745792925,
-0.396857053,
-0.0302245524,
0.7997403145,
0.9427233934,
0.6238654256,
-0.5620833635,
0.4330474734,
-0.0363987163,
0.0479438305,
0.0350625813,
0.1774865538,
0.1197036281,
0.1825972795,
-0.1279597431,
0.316912353,
0.65972507,
-0.6833307743,
0.1442463249,
0.2211417556,
-0.7955993414,
-0.5563797355,
0.7020930052,
-0.021018412,
0.0340362489,
0.5315058231,
-0.120865196,
-0.3238731623,
0.5595541,
0.385132134,
1.1304504871,
-0.0575068593,
0.3149776757,
0.369132638,
0.7249566913,
-0.0124877626,
-0.1347386986,
-0.291626662,
-0.6971382499,
-0.6356508732,
-0.5017290115,
-0.1101336032,
0.1987843513,
-0.7070464492,
0.2984808087,
-0.5297433734,
0.2118780911,
0.6425968409,
-0.5182048082,
-0.3374576271,
-0.1518902481,
-0.1128010452,
0.6001675129,
-1.2688119411,
1.0319764614,
0.5533178449,
-0.3961693048,
-0.7739247084,
-0.1048172638,
0.1528249085,
-0.8386375308,
0.9218543172,
-0.213143751,
-0.1202139184,
-0.1126493588,
-0.6201717854,
-0.8738951683,
0.8163559437,
0.5998111367,
-0.4126010537,
0.2151087523,
-0.0184235685,
0.5826122761,
-0.1381575018,
0.4624437988,
0.8059826493,
0.2458702326,
0.1638597697,
-0.8081834316,
0.3466233313,
-0.018039031,
0.1432172358,
0.5915135145,
-0.3805182278,
1.0767056942,
-0.2819959819,
-0.2522279918,
-0.1127469987,
0.3514140844,
-0.2299131155,
0.2589929998,
0.469561249,
0.3671563268,
0.7074427009,
-0.0504132286,
0.8999841213,
-0.127714172,
0.5757341385,
1.0689425468,
-0.1923574358,
0.4620000422,
0.3603651524,
-0.2084447742,
0.6059677601,
0.554269433,
0.2462207973,
0.4851867259,
0.2463632673,
-0.1939061582,
-0.6763365865,
0.0548233092,
0.1751110405,
0.3410122991,
0.6355790496,
-0.4634210169,
-0.4422558546,
-0.1943390518,
-0.1062458381,
-0.0880912095,
-0.4292049706,
0.5317782164,
0.1068170145,
-0.3905552924,
0.4688420892,
0.1219701469,
-0.0046117227,
-0.4393696785,
-0.4748570323,
-0.0481230989,
0.1072880775,
-0.5022833943,
-0.8914142847,
0.6268096566,
0.015478896,
-0.4757629335,
-0.2757575214,
1.0440068245,
-0.1269283444,
-0.4694966376,
0.3308667541,
0.2872071266,
-0.0068040821,
-0.0576009639,
-0.5511024594,
0.1026797295,
-0.0576848388,
-0.0480556376,
0.4856387377,
0.8373844028,
-0.6138784289,
0.6694226861,
0.4738286138,
0.0504115522,
0.0704045668,
0.3363853097,
1.0971002579,
-0.8562377691,
-0.2673365474,
-0.588781476,
0.3922326565,
0.1187448576,
-0.0727028251,
0.4600001872,
0.2199982405,
0.6784579754,
0.032107152,
0.7307308316,
-0.1576159298,
0.3419628143,
-0.6750451922,
0.622574985,
-0.2575435936,
0.4663109183,
-0.3221527934,
-0.5262299776,
-0.371206224,
0.6035205126,
-0.1635285616,
-0.0761075914,
0.9842348695,
0.9267061949,
-0.337398082,
0.1245922968,
0.3994059563,
0.5746631026,
-0.0235004649,
0.5467124581,
0.7687724233,
-0.2939207256,
0.426330477,
-0.2408540994,
-0.3365132511,
-0.033581987,
-0.7038969398,
-1.0249531269,
-0.7108457685,
-0.3288130462,
-0.26116696,
-0.0699175075,
0.5488640666,
0.7013196945,
-1.0517238379,
-0.3040508032,
-0.4931522906,
0.986530602,
-0.3206897676,
-0.2839157283,
0.5423521399,
-0.7620736361,
-0.3751262426,
0.2625564039,
0.6898229122,
-0.3620759845,
-0.3174573481,
0.1979639083,
-0.0716887861,
-0.2558467686,
0.653441608,
0.5371080637,
-0.65150249,
-0.6509817243,
-0.1416014284,
0.2286195159,
-0.3007106781,
1.4236769676,
-0.6585350633,
0.53079319,
0.6598576903,
0.420389235,
0.5366464853,
-0.4346524477,
0.3060793579,
-0.7062008381,
0.4537628293,
-0.1467226893,
0.5919716358,
0.1446521282,
-0.4737863541,
0.3756239414,
0.6620550156,
-0.5965868831,
-0.6337676644,
0.2374390513,
-1.1971775293,
-0.318075031,
0.7213442326,
-0.1408811063,
-0.3299078047,
-0.6590636969,
0.0587314479,
0.0555458181,
-0.0243230797,
0.6514083147,
0.47039029,
-0.594597578,
-0.4680356681,
-0.8203852773,
0.5727186203,
0.0826397687,
-0.675566256,
0.2713528872,
0.6615122557,
0.3477394879,
0.1420119852,
0.5207039714,
-0.2744258344,
0.1746705472,
0.14689897,
0.0436149016,
0.1097767502,
-0.5163906217,
-0.4896224439,
0.0190593228,
0.2911981046,
0.1550315768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19634v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19634v1
|
Asymmetric and trial-dependent modeling: the contribution of LIA to SdSV Challenge Task 2
| 2024-03-28T17:49:31 | 2024-03-28T17:49:31 |
Pierre-Michel Bousquet, Mickael Rouvier
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
The SdSv challenge Task 2 provided an opportunity to assess efficiency and
robustness of modern text-independent speaker verification systems. But it also
made it possible to test new approaches, capable of taking into account the
main issues of this challenge (duration, language, ...). This paper describes
the contributions of our laboratory to the speaker recognition field. These
contributions highlight two other challenges in addition to short-duration and
language: the mismatch between enrollment and test data and the one between
subsets of the evaluation trial dataset. The proposed approaches experimentally
show their relevance and efficiency on the SdSv evaluation, and could be of
interest in many real-life applications.
|
[
0.0877704844,
-0.3943541348,
0.6047762632,
0.2453679591,
0.0853131786,
-0.1921440661,
-0.0947934464,
-0.2872103751,
-0.0511668548,
0.4564500451,
-0.4897665977,
0.0134656532,
-0.5897405744,
0.220604226,
-0.6310578585,
0.5647839308,
-0.1939205825,
0.3652230501,
-0.5097603798,
-0.4047031403,
-0.8100056648,
-0.0998133868,
-0.7680331469,
-0.2926876247,
0.1672933698,
0.2574193478,
0.1711096168,
0.567792058,
0.4769804478,
0.2920649648,
-0.2486523092,
-0.1383959949,
-0.0775596425,
0.2295272797,
-0.419465065,
-0.4851055145,
0.0861010104,
0.1734509915,
1.0357478857,
0.8022569418,
-0.3587037623,
0.0552128777,
-0.0097924117,
0.7025424838,
-0.5587437749,
-0.1287923604,
-0.6511474848,
-0.1955121756,
-0.4570895135,
-0.1852513254,
-0.626485467,
-0.0751839355,
0.2620874941,
-0.3013948798,
0.4271388948,
-0.1745658219,
0.9603387117,
0.2720042169,
-0.709954083,
-0.5294676423,
-0.9977481961,
0.8625673056,
-0.2916386425,
0.5733901858,
0.2264990807,
0.4819731712,
-0.3782249689,
-0.3249620497,
-0.381301403,
-0.5218642354,
0.1244911402,
0.1138625294,
-0.2104437053,
-0.1940094233,
0.4991438389,
0.1797769368,
-0.5368620157,
0.3484208584,
-0.6702798009,
-0.3289003968,
0.724917531,
0.2027224004,
0.1006163359,
-0.2367541343,
-0.3313569427,
-0.0979987085,
-0.7497240305,
0.3756734431,
0.3935858607,
0.6627638936,
-0.1765609235,
0.8128628731,
-0.27185601,
0.5761086345,
-0.5278226137,
-0.1707855761,
0.3555676043,
-0.5229584575,
-0.0378633067,
-0.0935598165,
0.6305729747,
-0.0669656768,
-0.0660921782,
0.0565977208,
-0.3741568923,
0.262178719,
-0.0679752007,
-0.5329101682,
-0.1825125217,
0.0939781368,
-0.4070647359,
-0.0364804305,
0.1962847412,
-0.5367594361,
-0.5216935277,
-0.2387109995,
0.7163125277,
-0.3075347841,
-0.3471975923,
-0.0615462065,
-0.5344680548,
-0.1064802855,
0.6308689117,
-0.6224609613,
0.5482017398,
0.2954021394,
0.6562930346,
-0.5510915518,
-0.1159349903,
-0.9661704898,
0.0327154361,
-0.2493543923,
0.459801048,
-0.1974696666,
-0.5887878537,
-0.0228963476,
-0.0567924976,
0.1086287946,
-0.606657505,
0.452480793,
-0.1895116717,
0.1369080395,
-0.6680228114,
-0.6193782091,
0.3269694448,
-0.1032659858,
-0.4576878548,
1.1118757725,
0.196693942,
-0.7384358644,
0.3221058846,
-0.4623345435,
-0.334335506,
0.4063812196,
-0.5406652093,
-0.3420000374,
0.0838254765,
-0.3071790338,
0.2141735107,
-0.5703175664,
-0.143468827,
-0.0148099512,
-0.3490375876,
0.4074472487,
-0.2979485095,
1.1376584768,
0.009604061,
-0.2812965512,
-0.1311937869,
-1.3293190002,
-0.4813385904,
0.4463035464,
-0.2852477431,
-0.5505934954,
0.3106103837,
0.142121166,
-0.1136526614,
-0.0336917564,
-0.8027558327,
-0.0718437731,
-0.3168402612,
0.1416312456,
0.7695366144,
0.0061235912,
0.1565010399,
-0.0936715826,
0.3703711629,
0.0826454014,
0.0363336317,
-0.1338874549,
-0.528899312,
-0.8111914396,
-0.4323901534,
0.6966722608,
0.7782289982,
-1.0770413876,
0.0439523123,
-0.0465884432,
-0.6501739621,
-0.1662622392,
-0.0210975986,
0.5301607251,
0.3069589436,
0.1848966628,
-0.5705509186,
-0.4918715358,
-1.0039260387,
-0.1028717533,
-0.5347730517,
-0.272669822,
0.5706807375,
0.704446137,
-0.2839271426,
1.0298821926,
-0.4891574979,
-0.3082220852,
-0.0407988764,
0.0523458607,
0.057185106,
0.4135161936,
0.6124128103,
-0.9425061345,
-0.4769444466,
-0.047835812,
-0.4852871001,
-0.4463953376,
0.0168453902,
0.6824842095,
0.2094407529,
0.7361882925,
-0.3972689211,
0.6184623837,
0.4000918865,
-0.456309557,
0.9986106157,
-0.3196781576,
0.1171609908,
-0.6437534094,
-0.1773879975,
0.06778723,
-0.2540780306,
-0.9003075361,
-0.2484107465,
0.0537996367,
0.0175468624,
-0.5807175636,
0.4948710501,
-0.3191067576,
-0.5506284237,
-0.0842590556,
0.3083508909,
-0.2504971623,
0.0297756884,
-0.1815634072,
0.8047962189,
0.5654398203,
-0.7881172299,
0.5395172834,
0.2431417257,
-0.5963009,
0.5826573372,
-0.7794491053,
0.0616508834,
-0.1060435548,
0.1131308451,
-1.0462471247,
-0.1552908421,
0.1354659349,
-0.279615283,
0.2502216399,
0.0217661466,
-0.5025008917,
-0.3029562533,
-0.0167461596,
0.4841415286,
0.3715442121,
-0.2792228162,
0.4771363735,
0.3280555308,
-0.2233141363,
-0.4310968816,
-0.5640571713,
-0.1670296192,
-0.235627383,
-0.2715469599,
0.5432137251,
0.0309330579,
-0.4910366535,
-0.207005769,
-0.0290461984,
0.0881963223,
0.1168884858,
0.3960853219,
0.3123677373,
-0.0262955036,
0.2282261401,
-0.1365662366,
-0.0321202353,
-0.1177437678,
0.3386693895,
0.1607412994,
0.1191335693,
-0.6901677847,
-0.7648719549,
0.5296939611,
0.3541318476,
-0.0169591345,
0.5213961601,
0.3853169382,
-0.5456768274,
-0.14523682,
-0.7077301741,
0.077842094,
-0.4855654836,
0.4569533765,
-0.6014207602,
-0.998290658,
0.4788891673,
0.0426930115,
-0.2966745496,
0.6073741317,
0.6929332018,
-0.0657324642,
0.621096909,
0.7737396955,
0.2907635272,
0.6998077035,
0.2415307015,
-0.0834036097,
-0.6974833608,
-0.2474748343,
-0.8443952799,
0.2522899508,
-0.5807284713,
-0.3662390113,
0.3253870606,
-0.0167895518,
0.0060774661,
0.7695220113,
-0.2919069827,
0.2660817504,
0.3583449423,
0.0126545178,
-0.0397665612,
-0.4969069362,
-0.1683409214,
-0.330696553,
-0.5375721455,
-0.2140630186,
1.0769367218,
0.6275861859,
0.4238474965,
0.3239824176,
0.5512232184,
0.484473139,
-0.0303224325,
-0.5491696596,
0.7434566617,
-0.4151338637,
-0.4400729239,
-0.6807336807,
-0.6759880185,
-0.8145411611,
-0.0313635953,
0.0461775623,
-1.2284724712,
0.5057625771,
-0.1131920815,
-0.3975071013,
-0.3589099348,
-0.573061645,
0.7485513687,
-0.0535373092,
-0.1387950927,
-0.1440581977,
-0.6025542021,
0.0935383588,
-0.004501489,
0.1837230772,
-0.3162104487,
0.3509505391,
1.107098937,
-0.138893038,
0.4596500397,
-0.4192534089,
0.0286442433,
0.409235388,
-0.0158408526,
0.6289728284,
0.0896926373,
0.0727974251,
-0.2350279838,
0.3439134657,
-0.260312587,
-0.4280246794,
0.4731696546,
-0.8388969302,
-0.5512858629,
-0.5216459036,
-0.49498263,
-0.3077572286,
0.1288805902,
0.1374803036,
0.4793755412,
-0.5521792173,
0.3908824325,
0.6783443689,
-0.2774440646,
0.2922856808,
0.7147174478,
-0.3397991061,
-0.2433710098,
0.9857192039,
0.2095635682,
0.5023584366,
0.196271807,
-0.0161217246,
-0.2115499526,
-0.6189271212,
-0.2908945084,
0.2202372551,
-0.8830391169,
-0.0636027902,
-0.5338047147,
-0.3392133117,
-0.4655747414,
0.2181750089,
-0.7935326099,
-0.5359814167,
-0.4882012308,
0.3012274206,
-0.0531407222,
0.8531345129,
-0.0423261449,
0.3652051985,
-0.4361824989,
0.3461842537,
0.6332212687,
0.0554694757,
-0.5015006065,
-0.6978462934,
-0.2725983262,
-0.0276828706,
-0.2549479604,
-1.036265254,
-0.0511329062,
0.1882239729,
0.7295994759,
0.4448594153,
-0.2662572265,
0.4558268189,
-0.5616601706,
1.0180996656,
0.2819394171,
-1.186418891,
0.7995204329,
-0.2427195609,
-0.260366559,
0.5432053208,
0.1874677092,
-0.317083925,
-0.020237077,
-0.5626192093,
-0.6026957631,
0.8615329862,
0.7341160774,
-0.2387457341,
0.4912771285,
0.5067523122,
0.0988019258,
0.0536261983,
-0.5793963671,
-0.3404394984,
0.1366635859,
0.243740201,
-0.1169692054,
-0.6015859842,
-0.3078763485,
-0.1431355029,
0.8447589874,
0.1020884365,
0.2383582592,
0.1200307161,
-0.0226108246,
-0.0042288629,
0.2834941447,
0.8309241533,
0.4365668297,
-0.367788285,
-0.1174957156,
0.6011598706,
-0.2456117123,
0.3217895627,
0.2208549082,
-0.1386093795,
0.4370757937,
0.1994288713,
0.9588342905,
-0.0821697935,
-0.7422517538,
0.9712370038,
-0.1710831374,
-0.2734644413,
-0.5051404834,
0.1147341281,
-0.1929665059,
0.5318595171,
0.521490097,
0.190557152,
0.2287204713,
-0.5222513676,
0.251627624,
0.5001074076,
-0.5834568739,
-0.2656208873,
0.6322306991,
0.0253545009,
-0.7067455053,
0.4157868326,
-0.5617986917,
-0.507666707,
0.7210438251,
0.7202013731,
0.6633170247,
-0.7284176946,
0.1989074796,
0.0600256436,
0.1825788766,
-0.4915579855,
0.245172143,
-0.0382869616,
-0.8659793735,
-0.0031942041,
-0.4748975635,
-0.6459223628,
0.0560290404,
-0.9795446396,
0.9081543088,
-0.0012884103,
-0.2352859974,
0.4588637352,
-0.0722747892,
-0.6995004416,
0.2138998508,
0.2482465208,
1.0012226105,
-1.4083328247,
0.8896482587,
0.5974618793,
0.1238671914,
-0.4022150934,
-0.2340752184,
0.1795893908,
-0.2360283434,
0.8052856326,
0.0697222054,
-0.0161581803,
-0.4495568275,
-0.1086398587,
-0.8136273623,
1.2273465395,
0.2890984118,
-0.4245501161,
0.069764547,
0.0822473541,
0.5510376692,
-0.4517549574,
0.0701882467,
0.6354962587,
0.0199596249,
0.3457100987,
-1.3167026043,
-0.1249746308,
-0.2785853446,
0.563611567,
-0.1345266402,
-0.5847122669,
0.8888478279,
-0.0176301487,
-0.297316432,
0.367778331,
1.0941245556,
0.6349730492,
0.507273972,
0.8249912262,
0.2290412188,
0.5403240919,
-0.1713304222,
0.7509176135,
0.2731905878,
0.4137745798,
1.0484473705,
-0.6177393198,
0.7799215913,
0.605381608,
-0.8085161448,
0.2670356631,
0.4418655038,
-0.1919474602,
0.7363494039,
0.4164327085,
-0.2163396329,
-0.0085918037,
-0.4272146225,
-0.4289174676,
0.7592774034,
0.6140941978,
-0.1087764055,
0.0374600105,
0.3411902785,
-0.5230646133,
-0.0052525848,
-0.0145887341,
0.2641851902,
0.0962872803,
-0.3523099124,
0.0715894476,
0.2891586125,
0.3178958595,
-0.6110978127,
0.0816525593,
0.302775681,
0.3398441672,
0.0452641472,
-0.3295684755,
0.3297053874,
-0.1214371324,
-0.0104992148,
-0.2084037364,
0.7661786079,
-0.3625170588,
-0.3481660485,
0.2059298456,
0.3595705628,
0.19377473,
0.1367369145,
-0.4602155685,
0.4409986138,
0.0571089908,
-0.1757333279,
0.1646166146,
0.3937085569,
-0.1124624237,
0.7486038208,
0.3276791871,
0.2572514415,
-0.1841741502,
0.1979915202,
0.6288381815,
-0.3280835152,
-0.5449522734,
-0.7735875845,
0.4332082868,
0.0750759542,
-0.3874389529,
0.8747699857,
0.6926809549,
0.7130069733,
0.0112526212,
0.606369257,
-0.0741902217,
0.9285175204,
-0.3429841101,
0.4990462363,
-0.7350462675,
0.4543791711,
-0.5427998304,
-0.6689845324,
-0.0659246668,
0.3959682584,
-0.0260772593,
-0.1461750716,
0.7320370674,
0.7463271022,
0.2588505149,
-0.1116475835,
0.2586163878,
0.0653572828,
0.5122981071,
0.5460699797,
0.8600664139,
-0.8302853703,
0.2799862027,
-0.1556631029,
-0.407664299,
-0.3540636897,
-0.7296196222,
-0.9954000711,
-1.1978406906,
-0.6891079545,
-0.6222864985,
0.1796361208,
0.9797945023,
0.1586540192,
-1.1199294329,
-0.4552385807,
-0.1331190765,
-0.0292791184,
-0.3248218298,
-0.1566509008,
0.4033250213,
0.3491780758,
-0.5789136887,
0.693520546,
0.5334992409,
0.5552500486,
-0.2533376217,
-0.0551046729,
-0.122180447,
0.1300088912,
0.3660925627,
0.2989469171,
-0.762152493,
-0.5247934461,
-0.1400882751,
-0.2139049023,
-0.1336918175,
0.7674708366,
-0.6090200543,
0.5151171684,
0.4508373141,
0.5539739728,
0.6622522473,
-0.2106806785,
0.453766644,
-0.8318639994,
0.5078830123,
0.2074638307,
0.549736917,
0.392970562,
-0.1080221683,
0.5681425929,
0.7259851694,
-0.5317115784,
-1.5135360956,
0.5064179301,
-1.2380398512,
0.0436793491,
1.3977998495,
-0.2157862186,
0.1004726887,
-0.2606367767,
-0.0202811081,
0.3507365286,
0.0275936462,
0.7369463444,
0.9531451464,
-0.1828887165,
-0.2114956826,
-0.7299250364,
0.5247260928,
0.4584002495,
-0.6773290634,
-0.2169783562,
0.1280554384,
0.2959018648,
0.3874898553,
0.8777548075,
0.1090027317,
0.4387070537,
0.3115659058,
-0.2008777857,
0.0936118215,
-0.56925565,
-0.33951509,
-0.0441375077,
0.035021238,
-0.3732182086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19631v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19631v1
|
Retrieval-Enhanced Knowledge Editing for Multi-Hop Question Answering in Language Models
| 2024-03-28T17:47:19 | 2024-03-28T17:47:19 |
Yucheng Shi, Qiaoyu Tan, Xuansheng Wu, Shaochen Zhong, Kaixiong Zhou, Ninghao Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown proficiency in question-answering
tasks but often struggle to integrate real-time knowledge updates, leading to
potentially outdated or inaccurate responses. This problem becomes even more
challenging when dealing with multi-hop questions since they require LLMs to
update and integrate multiple knowledge pieces relevant to the questions. To
tackle the problem, we propose the Retrieval-Augmented model Editing (RAE)
framework tailored for multi-hop question answering. RAE first retrieves edited
facts and then refines the language model through in-context learning.
Specifically, our retrieval approach, based on mutual information maximization,
leverages the reasoning abilities of LLMs to identify chain facts that na\"ive
similarity-based searches might miss. Additionally, our framework incorporates
a pruning strategy to eliminate redundant information from the retrieved facts,
which enhances the editing accuracy and mitigates the hallucination problem.
Our framework is supported by theoretical justification for its fact retrieval
efficacy. Finally, comprehensive evaluation across various LLMs validates RAE's
ability in providing accurate answers with updated knowledge.
|
[
-0.1544551998,
-1.1957226992,
0.905637145,
0.0538857393,
-0.0074729817,
0.2955648005,
-0.1055157408,
-0.5504732132,
0.4489424825,
0.3949038684,
-0.3975824714,
-0.26839903,
-0.5212097764,
0.2633214891,
-0.3086258471,
0.6261458993,
0.046617683,
-0.1339655221,
-0.4115585983,
-0.2278937995,
-0.7081024051,
-0.593390584,
-0.4870174527,
-0.0019567872,
0.6548765898,
0.4912841618,
0.8489133716,
0.621081531,
0.6394960284,
0.2551595569,
-0.5252683163,
0.5439136028,
-0.3612980545,
0.4414060116,
-0.2465830594,
-0.3186568916,
-0.731345892,
-0.2882402837,
0.8738449812,
0.7750587463,
0.1128828973,
0.1383459419,
-0.1380465627,
0.590632081,
-0.7505319118,
-0.094745554,
-0.8487517238,
-0.2240952104,
-0.0490348376,
-0.4256166816,
-0.4711974859,
-0.5082784891,
0.0510998145,
-0.7003793716,
-0.1100019589,
0.1319229901,
0.7058324218,
0.246643424,
-0.4865652025,
-0.1800447553,
-0.5160052776,
0.5676164627,
-0.5620756149,
0.6416988969,
0.4054684341,
0.0461414605,
-0.2025136203,
-0.6486340761,
-0.4996905327,
-0.089079015,
-0.2379021198,
-0.1584623903,
-0.0558989495,
0.2136913985,
0.4353970885,
0.1035024524,
-0.4597875774,
-0.4158218205,
-0.2543963194,
-0.2933104634,
0.4082537889,
-0.0668540299,
0.3559324145,
-0.1887996495,
-0.2580807507,
0.0412756391,
-0.661388278,
-0.1162952408,
0.0790817142,
0.284853369,
0.4696153998,
0.8205156326,
-0.3689740002,
0.9440429211,
0.0869183391,
-0.1193275154,
0.3358539939,
-0.3952097893,
-0.0909288079,
-0.153005451,
0.4861169159,
0.3928675056,
0.1078244969,
-0.3245173097,
-0.1565681398,
-0.4425134063,
0.071324937,
-0.60841012,
0.0521522351,
0.2655922472,
-0.1117251664,
-0.0622428097,
0.0773019493,
-0.7454980016,
-0.3147503734,
-0.166976586,
0.7618958354,
-0.4363152683,
-0.2766118944,
0.3629400134,
-0.2496135682,
0.0977288336,
0.4420813024,
-0.3419564664,
0.0073912493,
0.6149281263,
0.9170867801,
0.1579293907,
-0.3980800509,
-1.0932313204,
0.3810281456,
-0.3104525506,
0.7318819761,
-0.8142447472,
-0.1958409846,
-0.2061772794,
-0.1759600639,
-0.2125352919,
-0.4543863833,
0.3576506078,
-1.2910810709,
-0.0331857987,
-0.6437754035,
-0.8255183697,
-0.286683172,
0.5923563242,
-0.6784078479,
1.0221982002,
-0.119140923,
-0.9774488211,
-0.0909244567,
-0.6955664754,
-0.4182940125,
-0.1323695034,
0.2055592984,
-0.108134076,
0.0028589959,
0.3605135083,
0.3691720963,
0.0220285021,
0.5598325133,
-0.3077062964,
-0.2900916636,
0.3756396174,
-0.1367741823,
0.5766344666,
0.0533104613,
0.3117109537,
0.224400714,
-0.6526294351,
-0.055475045,
-0.0617885627,
-0.4126521945,
-0.5641946793,
-0.2458567023,
-0.3744503558,
0.2023133039,
0.288277328,
-0.6956708431,
0.4281591177,
-0.097719714,
0.0506550074,
0.6768959761,
0.3986458778,
0.3646137416,
-0.7339634299,
0.6529618502,
-0.0981748253,
0.1370747834,
-0.1971157044,
-0.5587037802,
-0.537602365,
-0.1430682689,
0.2857859135,
0.5389140844,
-0.8037194014,
0.1165141463,
-0.3248283267,
-0.242080003,
-0.6492376924,
0.116095759,
0.1540786475,
0.7772454023,
0.7536363006,
0.0325372517,
-0.6646765471,
-0.5224637985,
-0.6753540039,
-0.1331318468,
0.2797781527,
0.265666455,
0.3734888434,
-0.3739781976,
1.2294790745,
-0.6284033656,
-0.0887951031,
-0.3114407659,
0.017257547,
0.0715152249,
0.3413532376,
0.3408747911,
-0.7587451935,
-0.4253237844,
-0.1772277057,
-0.6563076377,
-0.168367669,
-0.2189135402,
-0.3198132217,
-0.2772707939,
0.5469143391,
-0.7744374871,
0.2393234521,
0.3105886281,
-0.3101348877,
0.7884718776,
-0.1282960176,
0.4724042416,
-1.0771871805,
0.060949672,
-0.2483619601,
-0.3228985369,
-0.7228794098,
0.3301939666,
0.2257109433,
0.1721226722,
-0.3200284541,
0.8722467422,
-0.4098418951,
-0.1257042885,
-0.0842236057,
0.3934544325,
0.3080584705,
0.2581532896,
0.1083218306,
0.8145593405,
0.4708034396,
-0.7804780006,
0.3862407506,
0.5334602594,
-0.2331800312,
0.280423671,
-0.5272851586,
0.4167124331,
-0.3611254394,
0.1760949194,
-0.6638813615,
-0.2579033673,
0.0650041997,
-0.5050988197,
0.1307001859,
-0.3860044777,
-0.4517865479,
0.1410849243,
-0.3978235424,
0.4869437218,
-0.0378785767,
-0.6546729207,
0.8131099343,
0.3356973231,
-0.2727899849,
-0.9591683745,
-0.4863483608,
0.1052693948,
-0.0766452849,
-0.6702985764,
0.2978074253,
-0.4129594266,
-0.4272422194,
0.1605821997,
-0.1820890903,
-0.1398274899,
0.1246414781,
-0.4199053049,
0.3100480139,
-0.0416976772,
0.3680794835,
0.1762887388,
-0.0255125687,
-0.1038414612,
0.0554883555,
0.3613633215,
-0.018663954,
-0.4374415278,
-0.3616470993,
0.2361041158,
0.6383876801,
-0.6094281673,
0.7043087482,
0.4628465772,
-0.4181331992,
0.1395051777,
-0.7436377406,
-0.3347011805,
-0.4073147774,
0.5586282611,
-0.7334791422,
-1.0808979273,
0.4975832701,
-0.1946072876,
0.1854826361,
0.2454516739,
-0.0425662138,
-0.085927695,
0.736428082,
0.3921563923,
-0.0032560988,
0.4678374827,
-0.1536578089,
0.2251793146,
-1.2559558153,
-0.2909470201,
-0.5060108304,
-0.2494539768,
-0.0959857777,
-0.6862601042,
0.5367431045,
0.3734866381,
-0.1951268464,
0.2082031667,
-0.0205693301,
0.5688549876,
0.4490778148,
0.2108708173,
0.7544868588,
-0.2142361104,
-0.1283568293,
-0.021320248,
-0.8341109157,
-0.1254055351,
1.1029667854,
0.1660176814,
0.782816112,
0.4572125673,
0.5155255795,
0.1614653319,
0.0707827061,
-0.7429437637,
0.5081307292,
0.3293262422,
-0.7563765645,
-0.2552304566,
-0.7366420627,
-0.44212237,
0.3802826703,
-0.4511241615,
-0.6083996296,
0.1973487884,
0.2312521338,
-0.5350311399,
0.5465284586,
-0.4867607057,
0.7370067239,
-0.2175381333,
-0.333415091,
-0.2672077715,
-0.634393394,
0.4661890864,
-0.1652944982,
0.4685425758,
0.1552866697,
0.0454075672,
0.6467204094,
-0.2073297501,
0.4685938954,
-0.197410807,
0.1867010742,
0.2057818025,
0.5169756413,
0.6968570352,
0.1875109226,
-0.2771096826,
-0.232255891,
0.1453302801,
-0.1415516287,
-0.9095031619,
0.4833886921,
-0.5083175898,
-0.5383578539,
-0.5142877698,
-0.7809360623,
-0.5699004531,
0.023181228,
-0.2321775407,
0.6905645728,
0.0402641855,
0.2880929112,
0.7861354947,
-0.3692038953,
0.1881952882,
0.4124925435,
-0.6054011583,
-0.355189085,
0.6252420545,
0.0642776638,
0.4323936999,
0.6507314444,
0.2648315132,
-0.5789903998,
-0.4681125879,
-0.3556591272,
0.4911022782,
-0.8134865165,
-0.4147047997,
-1.169490099,
-0.2798625529,
-0.41452685,
-0.1075271666,
-0.3054119945,
-0.5490983129,
-0.0750415027,
-0.2428432256,
0.7409754395,
0.7296851277,
-0.3053509295,
0.3053256869,
-1.0686298609,
0.539711833,
0.3751482666,
0.4771230221,
0.0075471606,
-0.843071878,
-0.2649297714,
0.0906965286,
0.0022975446,
-1.1125940084,
0.0763723329,
0.3473150134,
0.3960207105,
-0.0510101728,
0.1998356879,
1.1108515263,
-0.3570305109,
0.422190845,
-0.1624143869,
-0.9141017795,
0.5735836029,
-0.0096309977,
0.2333520651,
0.5676004887,
0.3508144021,
-0.9678547382,
-0.2947809398,
-0.4483678043,
-0.6559336782,
0.5655411482,
-0.1852456331,
0.0398326591,
-0.0828497857,
0.6827372909,
-0.0546953417,
0.2383311987,
-0.6411299109,
-0.1206191331,
0.2379905581,
-0.0501001552,
0.2886873782,
-0.5208269358,
0.1306376904,
-0.4435747564,
0.9814898968,
-0.0765266418,
0.0048183291,
0.3874476552,
-0.655182004,
-0.1618044674,
0.400701344,
0.2936802804,
0.8965776563,
-0.4936242402,
0.1259879768,
0.2408622056,
-0.3237224817,
0.0248041227,
-0.1345535368,
-0.401766181,
0.0809622183,
0.4837045372,
0.5775175691,
0.1767510623,
-0.7073205113,
0.5078445673,
-0.1776600033,
0.0393965431,
0.0779242963,
-0.0214896463,
0.0671849549,
0.2662034333,
0.3631055653,
0.3446334302,
0.0620257258,
-0.45144099,
0.4520566165,
0.4944713116,
-0.1132387072,
-0.1661788523,
0.5632781386,
-0.0528663881,
-0.2906338871,
0.6291963458,
-0.2238077819,
-0.6611372828,
0.204061985,
0.5293421149,
0.6461351514,
-0.2448279262,
0.2142839581,
0.6283549666,
0.3327337801,
-0.1252598464,
0.3510379791,
0.1875607222,
-0.9797841311,
-0.8178623915,
-0.6340469718,
-0.4456015527,
0.1512774974,
-0.6450206637,
0.1784228235,
-0.3448646665,
-0.1264077425,
-0.4371826947,
-0.095553197,
-0.363676846,
0.0769869238,
-0.4293159842,
0.9042800069,
-0.7108653188,
0.7750017643,
0.7825951576,
-0.4363236725,
-0.7270141244,
0.1018259749,
-0.0724745691,
-0.3624126911,
0.4240362346,
-0.1045588478,
-0.3092388809,
0.29341048,
-0.3349524438,
-1.1575733423,
0.9949804544,
0.4527358711,
-0.497733146,
-0.1211706325,
-0.1388019621,
0.1834801584,
-0.1776938736,
0.4484402239,
0.5200428367,
0.5062787533,
0.3871073723,
-0.8607887626,
-0.1704982221,
-0.0431102142,
-0.2006866783,
-0.07485836,
-0.412552923,
0.6540722251,
-0.4693669677,
0.0728741586,
-0.0630809441,
0.6696157455,
0.3872817457,
0.0221085083,
0.5329353213,
0.5303344131,
1.0648963451,
0.1631070524,
0.7888770103,
-0.3708998859,
0.3342134655,
1.4278001785,
-0.1947012693,
0.9057157636,
0.4139466882,
0.0881568491,
0.3348038197,
0.4975306988,
0.6450745463,
0.3769825995,
-0.1791412681,
-0.2581273317,
-0.3550100327,
-0.1354262233,
-0.3257217109,
0.4758646488,
0.2020286173,
0.1013907418,
-0.1060121059,
-0.0552402064,
0.1865662038,
0.1000214517,
-0.223858282,
0.750289619,
-0.189215064,
-0.4752320647,
0.2902025878,
0.1894495189,
0.5582914352,
-0.612126708,
-0.1837242097,
-0.3909906745,
-0.0964657888,
-0.1443794519,
-0.7686080337,
0.4901415706,
0.3500348628,
-0.2061399221,
-0.2242056429,
0.6745372415,
-0.6888779998,
-0.4238541126,
0.4827493727,
0.8438633084,
-0.0373377465,
-0.3677953482,
-0.6482843757,
0.2545948923,
-0.0833379477,
-0.1722508967,
0.1480820775,
0.3834748566,
0.1508840173,
0.915628612,
0.6357204318,
0.3534050286,
0.2867585719,
0.1442876458,
0.8359168172,
-0.6800330281,
-0.3863764107,
-0.7146366835,
0.5322402716,
-0.1304041743,
0.0394559428,
0.6615519524,
0.6768419743,
0.8409518003,
0.0429742523,
0.7819344997,
-0.1470719725,
0.8593146205,
-0.6375316978,
0.5305281878,
-0.6161218882,
0.4667030275,
-0.5127261877,
-1.0449635983,
-0.4857581258,
0.7565087676,
-0.2474902272,
0.051024884,
0.7970666289,
1.1063287258,
-0.1395685226,
-0.0378223732,
0.2882976234,
0.4429043829,
0.2864691317,
0.3050068319,
0.9330684543,
-0.5397818685,
0.4497056007,
-0.3577703834,
-0.1471464038,
-0.1210857779,
-0.8327807784,
-0.6489172578,
-0.5325616598,
-0.422114104,
-0.2709566951,
0.19833453,
1.2189978361,
0.471783489,
-0.6014429331,
-0.1689267457,
0.3929784596,
0.4367858171,
-0.3098979294,
-0.2309271991,
0.5622941256,
-0.4889244139,
-0.4350736439,
0.7480638623,
0.278013289,
-0.3387037218,
0.312009722,
-0.0869045034,
-0.9297550321,
0.0148728443,
0.7131432891,
0.0742216632,
-0.402076304,
-0.6593157649,
0.3784928322,
0.2374907583,
0.1685146391,
0.6291230917,
-0.7227641344,
0.7683393359,
0.479806602,
1.1416664124,
0.2022740841,
0.4141082764,
0.3015446365,
-0.8624957204,
-0.1427380443,
0.2562503219,
0.3098635674,
0.5136926174,
-0.340218991,
0.2471944094,
0.4735136926,
-0.5494675636,
-0.7057557702,
0.2170902044,
-0.7857016325,
-0.2065209001,
1.2735322714,
-0.0643324628,
-0.1035824046,
-0.2229484618,
-0.2342740446,
0.2570811212,
-0.1495072097,
0.5075028539,
0.7143104076,
-0.0933965445,
-0.2220922709,
-0.5868560672,
0.4699079096,
0.2493674755,
-0.666674614,
0.2369888872,
0.8182479739,
0.4285309315,
-0.1148576215,
0.7580541372,
-0.0862674788,
0.2525230646,
-0.4206715822,
-0.0079463059,
-0.241314441,
-0.7351645231,
-0.2985697389,
0.0838045925,
0.3961577713,
-0.0203672778
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19603v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19603v1
|
Semantic Map-based Generation of Navigation Instructions
| 2024-03-28T17:27:44 | 2024-03-28T17:27:44 |
Chengzu Li, Chao Zhang, Simone Teufel, Rama Sanand Doddipatla, Svetlana Stoyanchev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
We are interested in the generation of navigation instructions, either in
their own right or as training material for robotic navigation task. In this
paper, we propose a new approach to navigation instruction generation by
framing the problem as an image captioning task using semantic maps as visual
input. Conventional approaches employ a sequence of panorama images to generate
navigation instructions. Semantic maps abstract away from visual details and
fuse the information in multiple panorama images into a single top-down
representation, thereby reducing computational complexity to process the input.
We present a benchmark dataset for instruction generation using semantic maps,
propose an initial model and ask human subjects to manually assess the quality
of generated instructions. Our initial investigations show promise in using
semantic maps for instruction generation instead of a sequence of panorama
images, but there is vast scope for improvement. We release the code for data
preparation and model training at https://github.com/chengzu-li/VLGen.
|
[
-0.4523725212,
-0.5466809273,
0.5793396831,
-0.1205181181,
-0.4424420297,
-0.4239418805,
-0.1189197525,
-0.0341678932,
0.0511208065,
0.9704524875,
-1.0162920952,
-1.1518560648,
-0.6267092228,
-0.038424138,
-0.2057717144,
0.7200685143,
-0.0410109907,
0.2314610481,
-0.3962419927,
-0.0130496453,
-0.7724693418,
-0.0047173696,
-0.1320821643,
-0.1449471116,
0.2877946794,
0.7795832157,
0.7625543475,
0.6772280931,
0.5941339731,
0.3562082052,
0.4525883496,
0.4917634726,
-0.3699269593,
0.119034633,
-0.2348647714,
-0.2441073209,
-0.1646572649,
-0.0160410609,
0.5839582682,
0.6524865031,
0.0743997768,
0.2334890366,
-0.3063631356,
0.8225648403,
-0.6605053544,
0.6558205485,
-0.3946684301,
0.1801853329,
0.1723155975,
-0.6018261909,
-0.4293111563,
-0.4614704251,
0.4163345397,
-1.0634557009,
0.2084268183,
0.2926017344,
0.9155981541,
0.4273192286,
-0.5279595852,
-0.3927011192,
-0.487318635,
0.8349470496,
-0.3051375151,
0.0878629014,
0.253698349,
0.6572610736,
-0.5008403063,
-0.4395838082,
-0.4276631474,
-0.2445827127,
0.1940647364,
0.5269457698,
0.2083159238,
-0.1853279471,
-0.0583484173,
-0.0313332565,
-0.6455352902,
0.0684495345,
-0.6091442108,
-0.0712482482,
0.6953443885,
0.3997634053,
0.5442957878,
-0.1896520555,
-0.9306111932,
-0.4068914354,
-1.0627907515,
-0.1928041428,
-0.0478482731,
0.3654499054,
-0.1026947126,
0.779422164,
-0.5322830677,
1.197634697,
-0.1586860418,
-0.1805918068,
0.2042706311,
-0.2001306117,
0.1386113763,
0.1825078577,
0.5758702755,
1.0674897432,
0.361579299,
-0.2415054142,
-0.226099506,
0.0486854613,
0.6443181038,
-0.5476257801,
-0.3249002099,
-0.0556411445,
-0.2479072958,
-0.0419127457,
0.3261945844,
-0.6039972901,
-0.2638964653,
-0.5008968711,
0.4721617103,
-0.4047949314,
0.0845478997,
0.2373025566,
-0.1107048988,
0.95733428,
0.5555530787,
-0.4108898938,
0.1699981242,
0.4943754673,
0.5917471051,
-0.1436441541,
-0.3954296112,
-0.5688790679,
0.3543841839,
-0.3370453715,
0.7155926228,
-0.4306697845,
-0.7100628614,
0.1431547552,
-0.0749592856,
-0.0425797068,
-0.4229918718,
0.1215408519,
-0.6258140802,
0.2207362056,
-0.1367429197,
-0.4935846627,
-0.6384701729,
0.1994659752,
-0.6908319592,
0.6179742813,
0.3472616673,
-0.3824586868,
0.2850931883,
-0.8168825507,
-0.5767076612,
0.2356435657,
-0.2240683585,
-0.2705172002,
-0.2593816817,
0.4068804085,
0.2662132382,
-0.5265933871,
-0.190723151,
0.3281717002,
-0.4080363512,
0.003746991,
0.1577601433,
0.6099626422,
0.0993085504,
-0.6615322232,
0.0405736156,
-0.5413861871,
0.0843497664,
0.1990291923,
-0.3698609173,
-0.1456347704,
0.1486958563,
-0.0455201492,
0.211561799,
0.2969611883,
-0.5860835314,
0.1938627213,
-0.4377536476,
-0.147761941,
0.5055857301,
0.1760821939,
0.7058719397,
-0.1926115006,
0.4514870048,
0.3292946517,
0.1619846672,
-0.4594651163,
-0.9181886911,
-1.0693643093,
0.038866505,
0.3554861546,
0.6522914171,
-1.1421695948,
0.5902571678,
-0.6581242085,
-0.4919446707,
-0.3232138157,
0.1056000888,
0.6349920034,
0.6997321844,
0.6425554156,
-0.5466976762,
-0.2011985332,
-0.4842457175,
0.4475570023,
0.058422178,
-0.0573470891,
0.18314071,
0.5311592221,
-0.2226172239,
0.8449420929,
-0.5329360962,
-0.2972085178,
-0.0611466505,
0.1047604978,
-0.4494822621,
0.6496957541,
0.4434603751,
-0.8656686544,
0.1215791702,
-0.0765759647,
-0.9179496765,
0.1050139219,
-0.1561447084,
-0.5370491147,
0.3044042587,
0.4058388174,
-0.4110106528,
0.5766346455,
0.2070050389,
-0.1441200674,
0.0354779102,
-0.3971547782,
0.2445785552,
-0.878005445,
-0.3934762478,
0.0276873093,
0.0156112965,
-0.359857738,
0.6009030342,
-0.1869108528,
-0.2954334319,
-0.5768582821,
0.2157206088,
-0.6435304284,
-0.0766871125,
-0.2764599025,
0.4571803212,
0.0428397134,
0.6326330304,
0.5090367794,
0.1314661801,
0.7334055305,
-0.6087082028,
0.6145512462,
0.3672898114,
-0.3402971923,
0.3806543648,
-0.3406552076,
0.0031776894,
-0.1215166673,
0.3188060224,
-1.1283717155,
-0.2512553632,
0.4719638824,
-0.2531329393,
0.1685462147,
-0.1673154682,
-0.4634007215,
-0.3047762811,
-0.0600717701,
0.1624227464,
0.77224195,
-0.5950300097,
0.556923151,
0.3194927871,
0.201116547,
-0.0846386701,
-0.5903902054,
-0.1612286121,
-0.0487858765,
-0.9683416486,
0.0953211561,
0.275262028,
0.2300849408,
-0.042552039,
-0.0436091088,
-0.0547954179,
-0.0717002079,
0.7299385667,
0.6240668297,
-0.2521355748,
-0.0498445146,
0.1298984885,
-0.330434382,
0.174947381,
-0.6657249928,
0.3413569629,
-0.2022220194,
-0.4353218973,
-0.6880106926,
0.5181714892,
0.3484009504,
-0.4776982963,
0.4254382253,
0.4877576828,
-0.0712589622,
-0.2094964981,
-0.1919946223,
-0.1403976679,
-0.4724074304,
0.0246053692,
-0.2670868635,
-0.3369153738,
0.1705023944,
-0.7184990644,
0.1380704343,
0.4871134162,
0.4709223807,
-0.2915847898,
0.4254507124,
0.4082378149,
0.331368953,
0.0045137606,
-0.749319911,
0.0425608829,
-0.4573462009,
-0.5636962056,
-0.2813985348,
-0.3919379413,
-0.8836755157,
-0.8363960385,
0.6713836789,
-0.4347114563,
-0.1766215712,
0.2873921692,
-0.8022736311,
0.3466724455,
1.0137417316,
0.2979914546,
0.0154376365,
-0.0555027425,
-0.0308311656,
0.2351469845,
-1.0649006367,
-0.492413789,
1.0819131136,
-0.3391222656,
0.8868203163,
-0.2507353425,
1.1955834627,
0.2228488922,
-0.1581281126,
-0.6305323243,
0.906062007,
0.2404882461,
-0.1376480013,
-0.4755905867,
-0.425807178,
-1.1619161367,
-0.0491355956,
-0.5105021,
-0.2568879724,
-0.1934925914,
0.0197559744,
-0.3214841783,
-0.0778385699,
-0.9247483611,
0.9874897003,
-0.2538411021,
-0.0918635204,
0.0820061415,
-1.2412678003,
0.1849553436,
0.3193200827,
0.0837769732,
0.2850975096,
-0.0929698199,
0.6256812811,
-0.6395489573,
0.7673436999,
-0.5325561762,
-0.0317057595,
0.7290363908,
0.1594931483,
0.2136377394,
-0.2553364635,
0.2878907919,
0.1622979343,
-0.3229091763,
-0.3726830184,
-0.7060266137,
0.630913496,
-0.7147691846,
-0.4563339651,
-0.1572085619,
-0.62317729,
0.1974405348,
0.0290176217,
0.3519175649,
0.5878705382,
0.0891631246,
-0.285815984,
0.5310732126,
-0.5897085071,
0.0984102041,
0.3447827995,
0.0679577366,
-0.0021877552,
1.4149520397,
0.1954167932,
0.0364802703,
0.5276299119,
-0.0045790998,
-0.1738614589,
-0.5398063064,
-0.8507900238,
-0.0920046493,
-0.6472360492,
-0.2235831767,
0.173400104,
-0.199760139,
-0.2014501542,
-0.450173378,
-0.5150808096,
-0.5740021467,
-0.0561210141,
0.2835419774,
0.2756302357,
0.862360239,
0.0846694782,
0.3872956038,
-0.7430615425,
0.4538961649,
0.2381199598,
-0.2682664394,
-0.223361209,
0.037935473,
-0.2454013377,
0.1695170999,
-0.4469626248,
-0.6136212349,
0.0737906471,
-0.0720307603,
0.3216617703,
0.248037681,
0.3494975269,
0.3020667136,
-0.7030977011,
0.9477187991,
0.2925913632,
-0.5812997222,
1.1028827429,
-0.192673251,
0.7244854569,
0.1390396506,
0.3303124905,
-0.0297628753,
-0.6307255626,
-0.6369223595,
-0.955708921,
0.5177209377,
0.2956782281,
-0.0399661958,
-0.0215406101,
0.3968518972,
0.0823307782,
-0.1094843298,
-0.096658431,
-0.178611666,
-0.4774996042,
-0.1477747113,
0.1332799941,
0.2120473832,
-0.2917355001,
-0.0159241483,
0.399427563,
-0.0274644587,
0.3592024148,
0.1781848073,
-0.3250110745,
0.2424959242,
-0.2449616641,
0.8042039275,
0.5141043663,
0.007750934,
-0.0719050914,
-0.1664797217,
-0.2668645382,
0.0266403779,
-0.0734343603,
-0.3996973336,
0.1410346627,
0.2365855575,
0.6010561585,
0.3634298444,
-0.5511417389,
0.7197317481,
0.2845185101,
-0.1643172503,
-0.2899641395,
0.4547583759,
0.0749502108,
0.0880054086,
-0.0607727319,
-0.1417607814,
0.2823775411,
-0.1429778188,
0.1433381438,
0.3565517068,
-0.0516151413,
0.1861723512,
0.527977407,
0.6030092835,
-0.214621976,
0.9812369347,
-0.2304137945,
-0.3197736442,
0.5854867697,
0.1256495863,
0.4637678564,
-0.0201402642,
0.4214584827,
0.50394243,
0.3576820493,
0.2560296953,
0.2405926138,
-0.5593662262,
-0.4000069499,
-0.1828814745,
-0.4128244817,
-0.6220155358,
-0.5526568294,
-0.8881828189,
0.1428311169,
-0.2111584842,
0.0149013568,
-0.4141884148,
-0.3244236708,
-0.7756857276,
0.5988947153,
0.4894514382,
0.80938375,
-0.4515371025,
0.545707345,
0.7007411718,
-0.5998405814,
-0.454372704,
-0.1282052994,
-0.0624544062,
-0.9522737265,
0.7092826962,
0.1819271147,
-0.5231403112,
-0.2003547251,
-0.6582195759,
-0.3408682346,
1.1064088345,
0.13190943,
-0.1899508089,
-0.2494631559,
0.5544515252,
0.2017226368,
-0.7618411183,
-0.0986725911,
0.2479915172,
0.4928967953,
0.3302590251,
-0.3119421899,
-0.0319923162,
-0.2260872722,
0.5274255872,
-0.0847203508,
-0.4780371487,
0.2538999319,
-0.5279018879,
-0.1376763284,
0.3996915519,
0.7386581302,
0.0581091307,
0.0825072825,
0.4353227317,
0.5631703138,
0.4362654984,
-0.5114064217,
1.2608165741,
-0.4358303547,
-0.0952730179,
1.3875415325,
0.0276883338,
0.6880851984,
0.5744786859,
0.6623338461,
0.7686473727,
0.6493573189,
-0.2050929666,
0.8893998861,
0.6482427716,
0.0797879696,
-0.4132350981,
0.2056726068,
-0.3830496073,
0.9440686107,
0.2415285856,
-0.3628540933,
-0.7121297717,
0.269852668,
-0.2934155762,
0.132096976,
-0.2696120441,
0.8389317989,
-0.3947432637,
-0.7859488726,
0.6610723138,
0.0968478322,
0.0439296253,
-0.451139003,
-0.4789733887,
-0.0770243257,
-0.3050432205,
0.0039146962,
-0.8557158709,
-0.1158226952,
-0.1085140258,
0.0669803694,
-0.1439663917,
0.3438423276,
-0.356233716,
-0.5053764582,
-0.090388149,
0.5594284534,
0.37403211,
0.2901626527,
-0.2332551926,
0.0264657959,
-0.1098153889,
-0.2586473525,
0.006918875,
0.4833281636,
-0.0855092779,
0.6890617609,
0.3008615971,
-0.1844779551,
0.6328581572,
-0.0826776624,
0.7503323555,
-0.6594990492,
-0.4371228814,
-0.2184228152,
0.8162747025,
0.0575673431,
-0.4538340271,
0.5590019822,
0.5751577616,
1.1253507137,
-0.5183140635,
0.5816295147,
0.1968077272,
-0.2061398625,
-0.8760896921,
0.7155317068,
-0.4562875032,
0.007498024,
-0.0584438331,
-0.6979663968,
-0.3745618463,
0.6829667687,
-0.3925458193,
-0.1663316339,
0.4064132571,
1.1442893744,
-0.0076550483,
0.2010408789,
0.1127342209,
-0.3718746305,
-0.1027068496,
0.8569940329,
0.9070603848,
-0.6411988735,
0.44890517,
-0.3204013705,
-0.2320064157,
-0.1236626059,
-0.4992185533,
-0.5613954663,
-0.8966956139,
-0.504607439,
-0.2569566667,
0.1017464548,
0.4962210953,
0.8096844554,
-0.3299310207,
-0.2943668365,
-0.2298128456,
0.3051260114,
-0.2637891173,
-0.1334077418,
0.3935924768,
-0.5459150672,
-0.7629696727,
0.3444404602,
0.3172950745,
-0.0261271875,
-0.3864476681,
-0.445802927,
-0.1211812422,
-0.0653068349,
0.4996358454,
0.0741026849,
-0.7414836287,
-0.2599496543,
-0.1912652552,
-0.1384721249,
0.1970980614,
0.6647043824,
-0.8326622248,
0.8506478667,
0.1746024191,
0.6105886102,
0.5967333317,
-0.1821773201,
0.6012847424,
-0.4674505889,
0.1017905623,
-0.1394365281,
0.1931219846,
0.5463960767,
-0.0588885397,
0.6786743402,
-0.0365794189,
-0.2317025512,
-0.2681164443,
0.1769853085,
-1.5307738781,
0.0759038851,
1.036298871,
-0.3672871292,
-0.7451177835,
0.3019206524,
-0.4044958353,
0.3242372274,
-0.2004698217,
0.7465133071,
0.3629950583,
-0.1110927984,
0.1483839154,
-0.3615016937,
0.0344003141,
-0.0179347917,
-0.6831057072,
-0.3676522076,
0.8243008256,
0.0358432643,
0.474839896,
0.0603651106,
-0.3481936753,
0.8800520301,
0.2677313983,
0.163366124,
-0.1075489521,
-0.507517755,
0.2402804494,
0.2925377786,
-0.3031422496,
-0.9745973349
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11848v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11848v1
|
Model Of Information System Towards Harmonized Industry And Computer Science
| 2024-03-28T16:53:08 | 2024-03-28T16:53:08 |
Edafetanure-Ibeh Faith, Evah Patrick Tamarauefiye, Mark Uwuoruya Uyi
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
The aim of attending an educational institution is learning, which in turn is
sought after for the reason of independence of thoughts, ideologies as well as
physical and material independence. This physical and material independence is
gotten from working in the industry, that is, being a part of the independent
working population of the country. There needs to be a way by which students
upon graduation can easily adapt to the real world with necessary skills and
knowledge required. This problem has been a challenge in some computer science
departments, which after effects known after the student begins to work in an
industry. The objectives of this project include: Designing a web based chat
application for the industry and computer science department, Develop a web
based chat application for the industry and computer science and Evaluate the
web based chat application for the industry and computer science department.
Waterfall system development lifecycle is used in establishing a system project
plan, because it gives an overall list of processes and sub-processes required
in developing a system. The descriptive research method applied in this project
is documentary analysis of previous articles. The result of the project is the
design, software a web-based chat application that aids communication between
the industry and the computer science department and the evaluation of the
system. The application is able to store this information which can be decided
to be used later. Awareness of the software to companies and universities,
implementation of the suggestions made by the industry in the computer science
curriculum, use of this software in universities across Nigeria and use of this
not just in the computer science field but in other field of study
|
[
-0.1957814991,
-0.7835717797,
-0.0380997844,
0.8025060892,
-0.2360074073,
-0.0139336204,
0.2553433776,
-0.5096157193,
0.3516227901,
0.3632406294,
-0.6196454763,
-0.262093097,
-0.0964775831,
-0.2060559243,
-0.6639197469,
0.9870882034,
-0.0420030318,
0.0413445607,
-0.0687518716,
0.0905589461,
-0.7908864021,
-0.4070519805,
-0.9424375892,
-0.4164268076,
0.0796455443,
0.4975247979,
0.4359694719,
0.1463261247,
0.9044978023,
0.4067291915,
0.0824236274,
-0.5717949867,
-0.4706451297,
0.2012239099,
-0.3447306156,
-0.5872064233,
-0.3426552415,
-0.2468828261,
0.5090475082,
0.611574769,
-0.596894145,
0.416320473,
0.6037989259,
0.6264978051,
-0.6225633621,
0.2815293968,
-0.0880921707,
-0.0557266325,
-0.0247874949,
-0.3869649172,
-0.1005309075,
-0.1795030087,
0.0648225173,
-0.5665000677,
-0.0873135775,
-0.0971991345,
0.8404188156,
-0.1558994949,
-0.122943677,
-0.5486922264,
-1.21496737,
0.9536809325,
-0.535173595,
0.2538835406,
-0.051978372,
0.5574212074,
-0.515206635,
-0.5081330538,
-0.0790638998,
0.2234053016,
0.3797951043,
0.2270997018,
0.1813868433,
-0.0986675024,
-0.0520454831,
0.4246310592,
-0.2482685596,
-0.2028619051,
-0.8799224496,
-0.1197938845,
0.6068854332,
0.4888042808,
0.4381087422,
-0.0418128483,
-0.5498707294,
-0.0111295944,
-0.2614403367,
0.2522383928,
0.4623823464,
0.3571858704,
-0.2132878751,
0.3491653204,
-0.6484547257,
0.442851752,
-0.3223443329,
-0.6322938204,
0.0866751447,
-0.0941984132,
-0.5016731024,
0.0635136068,
0.4857282937,
0.0960455015,
-0.0600402318,
0.4156197011,
-0.0641518235,
0.3993403316,
0.5120661259,
-0.6289625168,
0.2389738411,
0.2773353755,
-0.7090526819,
-0.4731869102,
0.0838763937,
-0.5704034567,
0.0281151962,
-0.6502246857,
0.5458322763,
-0.2595371008,
-0.4082692862,
-0.3318442702,
-0.3492108881,
0.1620633602,
0.7341531515,
-0.5450897217,
0.3704468608,
0.6525475383,
0.8726535439,
0.0664762557,
0.0190398768,
0.5733507276,
0.2978333235,
-0.2830248177,
0.5595988631,
-0.2380788326,
-0.5312626362,
-0.0518580116,
-0.0847994611,
0.1777302027,
-0.2951793671,
0.4905139506,
-0.5670514107,
0.1094572917,
0.2060891837,
-0.4559892416,
-0.3563655615,
0.2925167084,
-0.210866943,
0.4793475568,
-0.0437812731,
-0.8604878783,
0.2453190535,
-0.7910604477,
-0.0964954048,
0.2443724424,
-0.3705501854,
-0.1681078523,
-0.3090360761,
-0.5545458794,
0.2309714407,
-0.2679881155,
0.5216694474,
-0.398509562,
-0.6839508414,
0.0310537703,
-0.1744790375,
1.0965795517,
0.7403306961,
-0.1387655586,
-0.1459434479,
-0.6805596948,
0.0776680782,
-0.3614320457,
-0.6922412515,
-0.269893229,
0.2515593171,
0.2236091197,
0.0482384004,
0.3108755648,
-0.5705286264,
0.204872489,
0.0053883838,
0.1931071132,
0.5557194352,
0.1185883209,
0.2590192258,
-0.3316077888,
0.5166082382,
0.1687735617,
0.638939321,
0.1222513095,
-0.2229900658,
-0.7361037731,
-0.1639278531,
0.4604851902,
0.8700301647,
-0.5142607093,
0.2150159031,
0.1483683288,
-0.4459860623,
-0.326962918,
-0.0781659931,
-0.0274453424,
0.3690539896,
-0.1651819795,
-0.8639770746,
-0.9099716544,
-0.822290659,
0.1796720177,
-0.3493283689,
-0.0704257786,
-0.0347559899,
0.3006741405,
-0.4181528389,
1.0978959799,
-0.3997587264,
-0.5738230348,
-0.0088488283,
0.2611113787,
0.464915216,
0.5369542241,
0.1207470372,
-1.0025821924,
-0.3675067425,
-0.2028285712,
-1.2089209557,
0.064053081,
0.1308220625,
-0.2108841389,
0.014489254,
0.2520211637,
-0.0453634895,
1.0167793036,
0.0769406557,
-0.0362881795,
0.5841939449,
-0.1130473316,
0.5331491828,
-1.188611269,
0.3619503975,
0.1288465112,
0.1275630444,
-0.5111567974,
-0.0473275036,
-0.3913965523,
-0.4248996079,
-0.1058411822,
0.2326844931,
-0.3184197545,
0.0356711186,
-0.8129823804,
0.2186746299,
-0.0979426876,
0.2171366662,
-0.2208544314,
0.5439828038,
0.7298161387,
-0.9267348051,
0.5222625732,
0.1785045564,
-0.3778783679,
1.1797392368,
-0.4788321853,
-0.462236017,
-0.0014298969,
0.2136588693,
-0.5630883574,
-0.1828813106,
0.2729505599,
-0.5360484123,
0.2304915488,
0.1384242326,
-0.0943846405,
-0.5549594164,
-0.0938005522,
-0.1013936102,
0.5062045455,
0.0222191401,
0.3320371211,
0.5731787086,
-0.3441262245,
-0.7613110542,
-0.7854632139,
0.2022538334,
-0.2147025168,
-0.9575508237,
0.297362119,
-0.0651734024,
-0.4786035419,
0.0011077201,
0.0234987922,
-0.584079206,
0.0973152518,
0.6500582695,
0.6154635549,
-0.2563615739,
-0.0096961176,
-0.2286365628,
0.1235399917,
-0.0010719331,
-0.1250477731,
0.1345400512,
0.0213654805,
-0.3889609277,
-1.030136466,
0.4379734099,
0.3836165965,
0.6380218863,
0.9629346728,
0.3185639381,
-0.5458280444,
-0.031098295,
-0.5372602344,
-0.1517207772,
-0.5438302755,
0.1306157261,
-0.283851862,
-0.4305453598,
0.5462896228,
-0.5539246798,
-0.0335669555,
0.2552632391,
0.4137698412,
-0.1625063866,
0.7155181766,
1.1903796196,
-0.2994908392,
0.7169958353,
-0.1197389513,
0.3087562919,
-0.8868154883,
-0.408216387,
-0.7210838795,
-0.1874324232,
-0.5363250971,
0.3784759343,
0.3211006522,
0.5709049702,
-0.3274276555,
0.3534092009,
-0.6379801035,
0.0722679123,
0.5849362016,
0.32550174,
0.3472312689,
0.0666382685,
-0.169470787,
0.2697667181,
-0.5147868991,
-0.7197297812,
0.7343648672,
0.3549031019,
1.1830813885,
0.0185442083,
0.6652625203,
0.5002132058,
0.3513981104,
-0.5784426928,
0.4571100175,
0.1502169371,
-0.74373734,
-0.4277534187,
-0.3239832819,
-0.8288126588,
-0.0482863002,
0.0200497136,
-1.0681831837,
0.3978055418,
0.0823935866,
-0.0416352451,
0.0296885632,
-0.6517145634,
0.4028941095,
0.0435082205,
-0.5914120674,
-0.6127320528,
-0.6020435095,
0.3347622156,
-0.0495321751,
0.7491341829,
0.0841679946,
0.3962022662,
0.9790782928,
-0.4306162894,
0.8186338544,
-0.0699239373,
0.1952616721,
0.8870851398,
0.0291985106,
-0.1231101379,
-0.2135214955,
-0.3337358236,
-0.0192246977,
0.3793530762,
-0.239045471,
-0.2629110813,
0.7863298655,
-0.8851976991,
-0.5443503857,
-0.5107992291,
-0.4306976199,
-0.0097981282,
0.0294223242,
0.0173102673,
0.4687620401,
-0.5994724035,
0.4524926543,
0.3987733722,
-0.1646306366,
0.4191748202,
0.4920924008,
-0.388184011,
-0.2714838982,
0.5613314509,
0.2816622853,
0.1121747494,
0.1670689732,
-0.0981838182,
0.181336686,
-0.0813511238,
-0.4011063576,
-0.0445650294,
-0.8251826167,
-0.279215008,
-0.2820702195,
-0.5477368832,
-0.5728674531,
-0.1091807336,
0.1387939155,
-0.2852106094,
-0.3612287045,
0.6089311838,
0.0409835801,
1.0072801113,
-0.2602188289,
0.4235495329,
-0.627445519,
0.1557481438,
0.0665896311,
0.5163556933,
0.1350753307,
-0.4424090683,
-0.5074702501,
0.1069212705,
-0.967669189,
-0.8473992348,
0.099674128,
-0.1432833672,
0.6826258302,
0.6589232087,
-0.2052660584,
0.4536695778,
0.016995592,
0.5350112319,
0.2983053327,
-0.9395763278,
0.7892028689,
-0.4494658709,
0.0836493894,
0.4468127787,
0.590423584,
-0.8987739682,
-0.3313912153,
-0.8846162558,
-0.6320943832,
0.870182991,
0.2417498827,
0.0595268421,
0.5398759842,
0.2765207291,
-0.2197371721,
0.3501767218,
-0.6961095929,
0.071501039,
0.1470222473,
-0.3407818675,
0.6479784846,
-0.0774674192,
0.018492911,
0.0835998729,
1.0735405684,
0.3301117718,
0.2007885128,
0.1350916773,
0.3107244968,
-0.1581486315,
0.6188058853,
0.1469551325,
0.8230856061,
-0.1345860213,
-0.3110468686,
-0.0315165222,
-0.5878697038,
0.1467649192,
-0.4762479067,
-0.3324654698,
-0.284853816,
-0.0308062639,
0.4346064627,
-0.1513422579,
-0.3111211061,
0.4508489668,
0.2450717837,
0.0295475665,
-0.4148481786,
0.4801112115,
0.3711368144,
0.2580411136,
0.6222813129,
0.0999795198,
0.5346109271,
-0.9918153882,
0.2017689794,
0.4402273297,
-0.5012194514,
0.1995361,
0.3688943088,
0.2964038849,
-0.735712111,
0.4556875825,
0.2291802168,
-0.2208743393,
0.6902748346,
0.7414728999,
0.337131083,
-0.8564360142,
0.1642281562,
0.45266065,
0.1871464998,
-0.3233425021,
0.6496238112,
0.0587928854,
-0.3505465686,
0.0981958434,
-0.7011556029,
-0.6110597253,
-0.0851563662,
-0.4213149846,
0.9727962613,
-0.5098062754,
-0.3555124998,
-0.314835012,
-0.3070016801,
-0.3251223862,
0.7626290321,
-0.2023139596,
0.7676845193,
-0.7310550213,
0.5175153017,
0.5121356249,
-0.4404692948,
-0.8488969803,
-0.6859359145,
-0.1015168801,
-0.2014334798,
0.863279283,
-0.1164375246,
-0.1646727324,
-0.2986332774,
-0.6514457464,
-1.0988430977,
1.2451348305,
-0.1572215408,
-0.7521289587,
0.2661222517,
0.0274530072,
0.613509059,
-0.4867988825,
0.4258119166,
0.0500485897,
0.163394317,
0.5668047071,
-1.0307883024,
-0.3570795357,
-0.3712161481,
0.061033994,
0.3655994833,
-0.7755661607,
0.88275069,
0.2092276216,
-0.4165801108,
-0.1046083346,
0.5673256516,
0.1087237746,
0.473783493,
0.3778754771,
0.3682760298,
0.4596936703,
0.0851288661,
0.3654035628,
-0.3007408977,
0.3199174702,
0.9421623945,
-0.0541427583,
0.8858382702,
0.3945492208,
-0.3922871351,
0.8339214325,
0.7176187634,
-0.0055263829,
0.2306257188,
0.2940040827,
-0.4334651828,
0.299354881,
-0.2843302488,
-0.4458056688,
0.5373896956,
0.6804953814,
-0.2689327896,
-0.1206365302,
0.4167222679,
-0.0906493515,
-0.2762617171,
-0.3120674491,
0.7580688,
0.169696033,
-0.5289063454,
0.0498536974,
0.4152892232,
0.5006213188,
-0.8613838553,
-0.1903135478,
0.1515560299,
0.3350426257,
-0.4128189683,
-0.5103794932,
0.6048431396,
0.0138319544,
-0.076587081,
0.175558418,
0.9975165129,
-0.0754645094,
-0.4087851346,
0.1081289575,
0.1705570221,
0.4561666548,
0.3199530542,
-0.563952446,
0.202283591,
-0.1168743372,
0.1037785411,
0.1684762686,
0.34847489,
-0.345882982,
0.7721588612,
0.1401326656,
0.1637117565,
-0.2918052971,
-0.0038212072,
0.5915661454,
-0.7402048707,
-0.8599551916,
-0.450581044,
0.316717118,
-0.2459718734,
-0.0370039195,
0.5413248539,
0.6777051687,
0.5954324603,
0.2496754378,
0.9392361045,
-0.3937770426,
0.4454982579,
-0.0605784468,
0.5305680037,
-0.3058400452,
0.3412281275,
-0.4607750177,
-1.0277177095,
0.0728094354,
0.533233583,
-0.0777329355,
0.0952772945,
0.5135138035,
0.6234222054,
0.0475926623,
0.6547259092,
0.1052098349,
-0.1722506583,
0.003871857,
0.0867718533,
0.8304682374,
-0.726097703,
0.4255758822,
-0.1867873222,
-0.948600173,
-0.5012094975,
-0.6990195513,
-0.3725833893,
-0.5141365528,
-0.4583921134,
-0.2320948094,
0.0118261343,
0.5671838522,
0.7090696692,
-0.8609039187,
-1.1370904446,
-0.0266734231,
-0.1345994622,
-0.1345360726,
-0.365960449,
-0.1214236245,
-0.2810516655,
-0.2533307374,
-0.0580664687,
0.505153954,
0.0758640766,
-0.625054121,
0.4616446197,
-0.4449932873,
0.1633856893,
0.4388282597,
0.2947800457,
-0.3351110816,
-0.1899417341,
-0.2824055552,
-0.3812704086,
0.0937031433,
0.774177134,
-0.5091395974,
0.2471231967,
0.5881589055,
0.1213716567,
0.4418326914,
0.042889297,
0.443434149,
-0.2932820916,
0.1319404542,
-0.1298588514,
0.2528981268,
0.2915886343,
-0.8689582944,
0.5498119593,
0.2099048793,
-0.9707306027,
-0.3457226455,
0.1065322235,
-0.8750433922,
-0.4787645936,
0.5000456572,
0.1122013479,
-0.3947452903,
-0.4672666788,
-0.5662243962,
0.6675078869,
-0.2751663029,
1.1531306505,
0.8631622195,
-0.6095830202,
0.4204237163,
-0.4655843079,
0.0733462051,
-0.0262638833,
-0.9489827752,
-0.4104108512,
0.390434891,
0.3884072304,
0.5843192935,
0.9486239552,
-0.1603708863,
0.0104741165,
0.3484785259,
0.5001291037,
0.6004635692,
-0.5391699672,
0.1281652004,
0.5129429698,
0.0668549091,
-0.2805968523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19559v1
|
Improving Adversarial Data Collection by Supporting Annotators: Lessons from GAHD, a German Hate Speech Dataset
| 2024-03-28T16:44:14 | 2024-03-28T16:44:14 |
Janis Goldzycher, Paul Röttger, Gerold Schneider
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hate speech detection models are only as good as the data they are trained
on. Datasets sourced from social media suffer from systematic gaps and biases,
leading to unreliable models with simplistic decision boundaries. Adversarial
datasets, collected by exploiting model weaknesses, promise to fix this
problem. However, adversarial data collection can be slow and costly, and
individual annotators have limited creativity. In this paper, we introduce
GAHD, a new German Adversarial Hate speech Dataset comprising ca.\ 11k
examples. During data collection, we explore new strategies for supporting
annotators, to create more diverse adversarial examples more efficiently and
provide a manual analysis of annotator disagreements for each strategy. Our
experiments show that the resulting dataset is challenging even for
state-of-the-art hate speech detection models, and that training on GAHD
clearly improves model robustness. Further, we find that mixing multiple
support strategies is most advantageous. We make GAHD publicly available at
https://github.com/jagol/gahd.
|
[
-0.7749944925,
-0.975481987,
0.0976770669,
-0.3377844095,
-0.1723393649,
0.0855812728,
-0.1746569425,
-0.520411551,
0.2183142006,
0.3435661793,
-0.4209550619,
-0.2766243517,
-0.937712431,
-0.3513428867,
-0.4818433523,
1.6317669153,
0.2340275049,
0.1527032703,
-0.0847625583,
-0.5724804997,
-0.0466827527,
-0.730237782,
-0.7261578441,
-0.4213321507,
0.8111385107,
0.1394088864,
1.1651290655,
0.8302155137,
0.3927955925,
0.1597860008,
-0.2089334577,
0.089234136,
-0.5772856474,
0.4518565238,
-0.0089217359,
-0.1119761616,
-0.1647069603,
0.0164666735,
0.2362890244,
0.2114960849,
0.0458604656,
0.1510721296,
-0.1294915378,
0.0895311683,
-0.5229828954,
-0.0537300706,
-0.552541852,
0.0333420746,
-0.715673089,
0.3257774413,
-0.1507422477,
-0.4550615251,
0.2204804868,
-0.5643487573,
0.6560333371,
-0.3581238389,
0.6812466383,
0.3255280256,
-0.1222055629,
-0.4397979677,
-0.7800164223,
0.494787097,
-0.539529562,
0.1452057511,
0.3686410785,
0.6455162764,
-0.0632676408,
-0.5180267692,
-0.5571752191,
-0.1615461558,
0.2050516456,
-0.1914681345,
-0.5852662325,
-0.118735753,
0.4762931466,
0.262807548,
-0.5186988115,
0.2790071368,
-0.3733667731,
-0.3740093708,
0.8837252259,
-0.1260869056,
0.2988176942,
0.0549391657,
-0.1136103719,
-0.2838798165,
-0.497652024,
-0.2080424279,
0.9407715201,
0.451833427,
0.1010041833,
0.319919765,
0.0816265494,
0.3957151473,
-0.0274146069,
0.2631389499,
0.315988332,
0.1938930005,
0.0090339575,
0.0773442313,
0.6421328187,
0.1776809394,
0.3714047968,
-0.2739393413,
-0.1499439031,
0.5852722526,
0.5249708295,
-0.6755753756,
-0.778341651,
0.1908668876,
-0.1671562642,
-0.5829091668,
-0.2105921656,
-0.9899175763,
-1.2434383631,
-0.0711151212,
0.2843782604,
-0.4193751216,
-0.1487853974,
-0.3843604624,
-0.3962159157,
-0.0220618695,
0.3706982732,
-0.9487500787,
0.1665381044,
0.5643701553,
0.8646080494,
-0.1772722751,
-0.071841307,
-0.8975387216,
-0.1066011712,
-0.1572428197,
0.6820572615,
-0.4370629191,
-0.3196492791,
0.1607538909,
-0.3340978026,
0.2613684535,
-0.5026401877,
0.7246044278,
-0.606654048,
0.2822679281,
-0.1663562059,
-0.4740275145,
-0.279638797,
0.0629841164,
-0.8383843303,
0.7095969319,
0.0622578673,
-0.7931162715,
0.4114257395,
-0.7501974702,
-0.6143643856,
0.2746326029,
-0.286370635,
-0.7297646999,
0.1505136043,
0.4343087971,
0.4537043869,
-0.0016392606,
0.2592017651,
-0.8603612185,
-0.2143247128,
0.1077305973,
-0.4426805675,
1.1451261044,
0.3574174643,
-0.492724508,
0.2818529308,
-0.7416796088,
-0.4168695211,
0.3218681514,
0.016414348,
-0.3717807233,
0.1368086338,
0.3788320422,
0.2518743277,
-0.2423165292,
-0.6540362239,
-0.0599201247,
-0.0719353929,
0.2259742916,
1.0733726025,
-0.091583088,
0.1159288585,
-0.4464552999,
0.651646018,
-0.0788802058,
0.1314423233,
0.1584886312,
-0.377145946,
-0.7009150982,
-0.2379009873,
0.1205667034,
0.4380586743,
-0.7473883033,
0.0236142427,
0.0858292878,
-0.7031664848,
-0.7513294816,
0.1755059212,
0.1049092785,
0.4054424465,
0.4847961366,
0.0292291474,
-0.8012278676,
-0.7782379389,
-0.0893722028,
-0.1821869016,
-0.1149318814,
0.2824805975,
0.6109651923,
-0.1481506824,
0.5961943269,
-0.167691797,
-0.1864150316,
-0.2248483896,
0.2356620878,
-0.3392156065,
0.2122450024,
0.6877949834,
-1.0217504501,
-0.3310584128,
-0.1498265713,
-0.7118207216,
-0.0642446205,
0.0606340691,
-0.0401860811,
0.116660431,
0.162366271,
-0.0923645496,
0.3354803324,
0.5517289639,
-0.2526227236,
0.3939341605,
0.2098940313,
-0.150658831,
-0.9316911697,
-0.1101499349,
0.1140273139,
-0.257883966,
-0.9946549535,
0.0443157889,
-0.3259007633,
-0.0811684802,
-0.5461273789,
0.279872179,
0.0300326329,
0.3668122888,
-0.4591231942,
0.1130457968,
-0.4505852759,
0.2401371598,
-0.258248955,
0.6120952368,
0.6743104458,
-0.3953487575,
0.8764947057,
0.2961833775,
-0.1192421168,
0.7302150726,
-0.5829038024,
0.2604127526,
-0.3074472547,
0.1464253962,
-0.7964820862,
-0.4411622286,
0.5689247251,
-0.5510185361,
0.1717469096,
-0.1844096482,
-0.453620702,
-0.2970977426,
-0.442446053,
-0.1273486167,
0.3202365041,
-0.7248055339,
0.4458923638,
0.9354760051,
-0.219949469,
-0.5262305737,
-0.6322712302,
0.1326461583,
-0.6951881647,
-0.3916517496,
0.228948608,
-0.009854937,
-0.3335396945,
0.0659110844,
-0.0213969368,
0.0680168197,
0.3820022047,
0.3858052492,
0.1430592239,
0.0637107641,
0.1779800057,
-0.4117380381,
0.0785708055,
0.2180908322,
-0.1080046222,
0.4855633974,
0.0954925939,
-0.2493029386,
-0.2401667535,
0.3547543883,
0.465034157,
-0.0460187122,
0.5363797545,
1.0648597479,
-0.5558245182,
-0.353448391,
-0.5143330097,
-0.1075172126,
-0.3764481246,
0.3182838559,
-0.0081492057,
-0.8514781594,
0.6046432257,
0.5257956982,
0.2749960124,
0.4026458561,
0.5863125324,
0.1800390482,
1.340012908,
0.4576135278,
-0.5707754493,
0.649338603,
-0.2192016393,
-0.056048438,
-0.3140719533,
0.0306542031,
-0.3649198711,
-0.3348947465,
-0.4538716972,
-0.2091918141,
0.1027968153,
-0.3376964331,
-0.2502868772,
0.1664755344,
-0.4706285894,
0.2548388541,
0.6979362965,
0.0251708385,
-0.1898109764,
0.4390802979,
0.332873553,
-0.1442571282,
-0.438721627,
-0.4530428648,
1.1644074917,
0.5195009112,
0.5319030881,
0.1822962314,
0.6082510352,
0.5741701126,
0.378002584,
-0.542370677,
0.2650190592,
-0.1916017532,
-0.8775894046,
-0.1678372025,
-0.3859786093,
-0.4607354105,
0.187451452,
-0.1471039504,
-0.7766201496,
0.0951794162,
0.2365511954,
-0.4036475718,
0.4298618138,
-0.3799986243,
0.8558884263,
-0.1129978523,
-0.331853807,
-0.084681958,
-0.4843470454,
0.1217843741,
-0.1443282068,
0.0791680589,
-0.1454929262,
0.3302090764,
1.1820906401,
-0.2444493622,
0.6846213937,
-0.6933607459,
-0.0570823774,
0.2966516614,
-0.1388883293,
0.5792813897,
-0.2342686355,
-0.2056223005,
0.0262119118,
-0.4701508582,
-0.3409459591,
-0.5191252828,
0.5460644364,
-0.6942347884,
-0.520917058,
-0.4046473205,
-0.7608280182,
-0.2966721654,
0.0548541471,
0.3475479782,
0.3553395569,
-0.3005880713,
0.3371673226,
0.6526964903,
0.149535954,
0.2573361993,
0.0370608121,
0.0517668277,
-0.631084919,
1.0390202999,
0.4716748595,
0.0808474422,
-0.213786602,
0.0209147241,
-0.4191870987,
-0.6992815733,
-0.6551202536,
-0.2425631136,
-0.6956829429,
-0.1724466681,
-0.7270483971,
-0.2001367807,
-0.5274865627,
-0.2399440408,
0.0738278404,
-0.4388720393,
-0.1469486505,
-0.3355683982,
0.6771838069,
0.6904045343,
-0.379925698,
0.5394944549,
-0.1104400381,
0.3891483545,
0.3645116091,
0.0925508365,
0.0130817443,
-0.5661169291,
-0.3922545612,
0.296741277,
-0.5148797035,
-0.9255836606,
0.2959457934,
-0.0478107259,
0.5852733254,
0.4291324615,
0.0999428332,
0.7561112046,
-0.2333874553,
0.6670960188,
-0.2045332789,
-0.6568279266,
0.5578776598,
-0.5200906396,
-0.0882457048,
0.4878144264,
0.5401784778,
-0.5606071949,
-0.6260727048,
-0.9094516635,
-0.7813726068,
0.8501861095,
0.2054211497,
0.0693615451,
0.1966518909,
-0.1707731038,
0.0703697056,
0.0854899138,
-0.4824570417,
-0.5900201797,
-0.4995934069,
-0.2568207085,
-0.3575531244,
-0.14763017,
-0.5038443208,
-0.0764273405,
0.9780912995,
0.0172923058,
-0.1122870147,
-0.3328736722,
-0.1859223098,
-0.0029219771,
0.0616429187,
0.2212394923,
0.2386149168,
-0.1185058504,
0.1218205765,
0.2334021628,
-0.4662235677,
0.1873005182,
0.7427304983,
-0.501470387,
0.1379879117,
0.1395711154,
0.8833855391,
-0.4843935072,
-0.562135458,
0.4253812134,
0.0427506939,
-0.1389780641,
-0.2973638773,
0.182735011,
-0.1016339362,
0.3753924966,
0.3829424679,
-0.0077031744,
0.1968863904,
-0.0606660619,
0.5435016751,
0.5503211021,
-0.4663637578,
-0.1911419332,
0.9097800255,
-0.1431966573,
-0.2971307337,
0.3831573725,
-0.3095313013,
-0.6555776596,
0.4033655524,
0.4138834476,
0.7521796823,
-0.3354195654,
0.5304998755,
-0.1008738503,
0.0542583764,
0.2373530716,
-0.0192698855,
-0.0759288147,
-0.6008912921,
0.0188738331,
-0.3607170582,
-0.6772509217,
0.4681235254,
-0.6487746835,
0.1642333418,
-0.630297184,
-0.1353329569,
0.5295746326,
0.1794601679,
-0.5572935343,
0.0464501567,
0.5597529411,
0.4847185016,
-0.9986661077,
0.5980232358,
0.7514759302,
-0.4459924102,
-0.3039229214,
-0.1741995513,
0.6242491603,
-0.7745489478,
0.2221402973,
0.2425585538,
0.1343029886,
-0.1736804396,
-0.5895709991,
-0.4405522943,
0.5876737833,
0.3450242281,
-0.193709299,
0.1266869456,
0.1241997853,
0.6920119524,
-0.2154348642,
0.0187257938,
0.5270768404,
0.2407611012,
0.0137219978,
-0.1875021905,
-0.0147702647,
-0.3151177764,
-0.1355789751,
0.2176548243,
-0.3592042029,
0.7614518404,
0.0001746638,
-0.3063450456,
-0.1946247965,
0.6313186288,
0.0955486521,
0.3001334071,
0.6557580829,
0.7694097757,
1.0215990543,
-0.0091407876,
0.8586597443,
0.2098416686,
0.1321097761,
1.1330059767,
-0.1823310405,
0.4725152552,
0.1326225698,
0.0973294154,
0.1951204985,
0.4718385935,
-0.5999414325,
0.3743882477,
0.3108056784,
-0.5953387022,
-0.1139756292,
-0.5315580964,
-0.2983742654,
0.3559372425,
0.32546556,
-0.3348228335,
-0.4566310942,
0.4794740379,
0.4442905188,
0.1212551519,
-0.1714295745,
0.7369405031,
-0.3209762573,
-0.2017725706,
0.4216620922,
-0.2460329831,
0.6579141021,
-0.4519857764,
0.1488654763,
-0.0200007837,
0.4152268767,
-0.1926333159,
-0.5472897887,
0.3838347495,
0.4067554176,
-0.1592844278,
-0.1087316349,
0.7174087763,
-0.4337609112,
-0.2864670455,
0.2491625994,
0.2097392976,
0.0201670192,
-0.2280230522,
-0.6125667095,
0.1714691073,
0.0606272854,
-0.1228140742,
0.3356410563,
0.0899747387,
-0.1263160855,
0.4859292805,
0.8286355138,
0.4587743878,
-0.0491511114,
0.1435685605,
0.902880311,
-0.4164283574,
-0.3236592114,
-1.0727523565,
0.2483004481,
-0.3873821795,
-0.3505696952,
1.0559878349,
0.4624096453,
1.1637057066,
0.2806721032,
1.2193233967,
-0.2010589987,
0.7271022797,
0.1156761646,
0.8414068222,
-0.2947623432,
-0.1184308976,
-0.2076816857,
-0.3909581602,
-0.6230297089,
0.7256782055,
-0.3292424977,
-0.1979658306,
0.0271572638,
0.8827511072,
-0.1565677524,
0.3296987712,
0.1787160337,
0.1416113377,
0.9015775323,
0.4119025767,
0.8137613535,
-0.4807254076,
0.8099681735,
-0.5702914,
-0.0542829521,
-0.2361310869,
-0.553265214,
-0.8982920647,
-0.3178080618,
-0.4221313894,
-0.5626794696,
0.4329444468,
0.9656110406,
0.6100155115,
-1.1017807722,
-0.0135306148,
0.0866941661,
0.2086955458,
-0.1808313727,
-0.2154801786,
0.3326940835,
-0.2017950118,
-0.739549458,
0.2476084679,
-0.2216678411,
0.1569741666,
-0.2104605585,
0.0463716611,
-0.0349427238,
-0.1237836406,
0.346322149,
0.4554900527,
-0.5267150998,
-0.4043404162,
-0.4159092307,
0.0150365336,
-0.1287134588,
0.5575588346,
-0.6589587331,
0.6160219312,
0.3007259965,
1.2158943415,
0.2204568088,
-0.0661269054,
0.5063360333,
-0.5928159952,
0.1396734565,
0.3810890317,
0.3021537066,
0.5771261454,
-0.1988148689,
0.4177006483,
0.3111030757,
-0.4379500747,
-1.0998886824,
0.13144131,
-0.4231236875,
-0.0531089157,
1.0816962719,
-0.1560185999,
0.096199587,
-0.1670747846,
-0.2528280318,
0.4385597408,
-0.5348035693,
0.833037138,
0.953758657,
0.1449022889,
0.0678667724,
-0.6137571931,
0.7446957231,
0.2267731726,
-0.5856871009,
0.3781249225,
0.8037052751,
-0.0250560921,
0.2346884757,
0.3718690574,
0.1212947145,
0.3483844399,
0.1719648987,
-0.1809486747,
-0.4046262801,
-0.4825634956,
-0.8030954003,
0.3251343369,
-0.2584093511,
-0.3806984723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19548v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19548v1
|
WaterJudge: Quality-Detection Trade-off when Watermarking Large Language Models
| 2024-03-28T16:28:38 | 2024-03-28T16:28:38 |
Piotr Molenda, Adian Liusie, Mark J. F. Gales
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Watermarking generative-AI systems, such as LLMs, has gained considerable
interest, driven by their enhanced capabilities across a wide range of tasks.
Although current approaches have demonstrated that small, context-dependent
shifts in the word distributions can be used to apply and detect watermarks,
there has been little work in analyzing the impact that these perturbations
have on the quality of generated texts. Balancing high detectability with
minimal performance degradation is crucial in terms of selecting the
appropriate watermarking setting; therefore this paper proposes a simple
analysis framework where comparative assessment, a flexible NLG evaluation
framework, is used to assess the quality degradation caused by a particular
watermark setting. We demonstrate that our framework provides easy
visualization of the quality-detection trade-off of watermark settings,
enabling a simple solution to find an LLM watermark operating point that
provides a well-balanced performance. This approach is applied to two different
summarization systems and a translation system, enabling cross-model analysis
for a task, and cross-task analysis.
|
[
-0.3926723301,
-0.5723441839,
0.1925011277,
0.1863975674,
-0.6898345351,
0.0226688758,
0.0678982437,
-0.3728262484,
0.2660551369,
0.5869830251,
-0.4818482995,
-0.446847707,
-0.9082551599,
0.0552514754,
-0.6738951802,
0.9718887806,
-0.0872311369,
-0.22486341,
-0.5965139866,
-0.5140450597,
-0.4694145918,
-0.4209105074,
-0.8189826608,
-0.616512239,
0.1272859275,
-0.1480024755,
0.9101688862,
0.5385097265,
0.7047180533,
0.2514888346,
-0.6125069857,
0.2014345229,
-0.4250723124,
0.3354033828,
-0.2397224009,
-0.4920172691,
-0.3543178439,
0.0222020671,
0.5087266564,
0.4255477488,
0.1147288531,
0.381162554,
0.2794126868,
0.6652413607,
-0.8852058053,
0.3484214544,
-0.440834552,
0.2217109054,
-0.2095318139,
-0.2693153918,
-0.1379144937,
-0.119577758,
-0.0569165982,
-0.5650443435,
0.0071288329,
0.0846124142,
1.0194505453,
0.646604836,
-0.0386200584,
-0.1859671921,
-0.4549418092,
0.8477756381,
-1.0336630344,
0.043385759,
0.3402216136,
0.2815559506,
-0.0160776805,
-0.6131622195,
-0.5329760313,
0.0831522644,
-0.0303742569,
0.4263720214,
-0.4797978699,
-0.2501915693,
0.1798588932,
0.6052341461,
-0.5480944514,
0.0259396937,
0.2466312796,
-0.1496002227,
0.7127370834,
0.3621077836,
0.3071492612,
0.0536842383,
-0.2647413313,
-0.1753430814,
-0.8769815564,
0.1158429682,
0.2877823412,
0.2985833287,
-0.0687134713,
0.4755280316,
-0.106588006,
0.7801629901,
-0.1366232187,
-0.2859189808,
-0.0447554551,
-0.2788213491,
-0.3926955163,
-0.1819310486,
0.8468610048,
0.4832131267,
0.1725918651,
-0.0281648748,
-0.5854067206,
-0.0815604255,
0.1376833469,
-0.9093304276,
-0.1426578164,
0.0095588602,
-0.6534230113,
-0.3180421591,
-0.1124960482,
-0.585991621,
-0.6586363912,
-0.1672655195,
0.5826010704,
-0.0388531163,
-0.2422932386,
0.2023325264,
-0.3657900095,
0.0207235124,
0.2456089407,
-0.6077702045,
0.2610115707,
0.5792477727,
0.907967627,
-0.6567619443,
0.1147126555,
-0.5598554611,
0.273681879,
-0.3016717136,
0.9909152389,
-0.4523035288,
-0.4624454677,
0.0041876109,
-0.26254493,
0.1439484805,
-0.972124815,
0.3799933493,
-0.6636380553,
0.3219228685,
-0.3072031438,
-0.9484205842,
-0.0260137748,
0.3714726269,
-0.989030242,
1.1010204554,
0.17452766,
-1.0270212889,
0.5601553321,
-0.5084266663,
-0.577873528,
0.2867163122,
0.0552711822,
-0.8086156249,
-0.0064565819,
0.1971409172,
0.4479285479,
-0.4419552386,
0.1945287436,
-0.2114057988,
-0.6240142584,
0.1963183135,
-0.4380099177,
0.7627034187,
-0.0880516618,
-0.495778352,
0.2704597116,
-0.6405360699,
0.1069489345,
0.2062785029,
-0.6795194745,
-0.5962420702,
0.0672191903,
0.0127593437,
-0.0144135039,
0.2126436532,
-0.023172643,
0.0735666975,
-0.0662181601,
0.1403099746,
0.4646840394,
0.0708402619,
0.2089329958,
-0.3524359763,
0.9139342308,
-0.018391313,
0.293502152,
0.0373117216,
-0.6562289596,
-0.8170520663,
-0.4098291397,
0.6341621876,
0.4984675646,
-1.2152371407,
0.4714977145,
-0.4787796438,
-0.2272894233,
-0.5532194376,
0.2803658545,
0.573438108,
0.0423795208,
0.5360913873,
-0.3606199622,
0.0279933512,
-0.946816504,
-0.609642446,
-0.1986038834,
-0.1373823881,
0.0372517817,
0.5081385374,
-0.0285321064,
0.9491547942,
-0.3594136834,
-0.3948644698,
-0.4735580385,
0.1431235671,
0.1169492528,
0.2693189979,
0.6680845618,
-0.7698899508,
-0.3307185471,
-0.2193493545,
-0.5214012265,
-0.56549263,
-0.0249423906,
-0.1094410568,
-0.0402079634,
0.5535054207,
-0.3667121828,
0.6529702544,
0.989092052,
-0.4003078938,
0.5903162956,
-0.0146091124,
0.2326464802,
-0.7876027226,
0.2278933078,
-0.053466823,
-0.3601534665,
-0.485137254,
0.1622390747,
0.0661365092,
0.2235203236,
-0.278640151,
0.8226650357,
-0.2531882823,
-0.1463553011,
-0.5774816275,
0.0424737483,
0.3841831982,
0.1059273109,
-0.1509024203,
0.9494248033,
0.1560153812,
-0.4381561279,
0.2072645575,
0.1155817658,
-0.4198791683,
0.7872807384,
-0.8394976854,
-0.1277853251,
0.084353067,
-0.0533276573,
-0.9114148021,
0.2446508259,
0.2199748605,
-0.3412567973,
0.3460254669,
-0.3537860513,
-0.5904307365,
0.1764829159,
-0.4827597737,
0.2396609038,
0.3230720162,
-0.6785966158,
0.5538010001,
0.3648191094,
-0.1874781847,
-0.4323182106,
-0.8039851785,
0.2084438354,
-0.4097352624,
-0.5281170011,
0.667547226,
0.0509447902,
-0.4593144059,
0.1972304732,
-0.1792294979,
-0.123111181,
0.3006763756,
0.2501810491,
0.0126169538,
-0.0666450113,
-0.1370426416,
0.4366464317,
-0.2716096938,
-0.0038316604,
0.0991768837,
0.2608186901,
0.1350118816,
-0.3405174315,
-0.2143511325,
0.2228377014,
0.3624165058,
-0.2985024154,
0.751647532,
0.5083079934,
-0.3699841499,
-0.3236874342,
-0.2497421801,
0.1783695817,
-0.4578530788,
0.0561456978,
-0.1353550106,
-0.747079134,
0.6014741659,
-0.0671846196,
0.1844851077,
0.5485152602,
0.3519486487,
-0.1411399692,
0.7060145736,
0.5575020313,
-0.3202245533,
0.6301857233,
-0.327236563,
0.1904826611,
-0.7449728847,
0.0648176596,
-0.43163234,
-0.1603565514,
-0.1105745286,
-0.2970098555,
0.2792384923,
0.4616319537,
0.0435311757,
0.3043486774,
-0.283256501,
0.5602601171,
0.4116148353,
-0.2182710022,
0.5427154303,
0.0064533213,
-0.0097415419,
-0.0798194483,
-0.7099742889,
-0.7031939626,
0.7648204565,
-0.0685174391,
0.5718877912,
0.1706525385,
0.6307222247,
0.84333992,
0.7601786256,
-0.5867944956,
0.5860210061,
-0.2254308015,
-0.511134088,
-0.3840897381,
-0.5802497268,
-1.0275858641,
0.5098888874,
-0.381610781,
-0.1731898934,
-0.1729271114,
0.041899763,
-0.2811154723,
0.2559187114,
-0.3955957592,
0.8192257881,
-0.1473418176,
-0.5019055605,
-0.0908879638,
-0.2119919509,
0.1586904526,
-0.0127374576,
0.2220271528,
-0.299313575,
-0.1469855309,
0.8787147403,
-0.2302542925,
0.5103060603,
-0.3127817512,
-0.3524670899,
0.2301613092,
0.3421887457,
0.2750349045,
-0.0605763607,
-0.2001905888,
0.1641674787,
-0.104294233,
-0.2576647997,
-0.6671136618,
0.4992636144,
-0.4035821557,
-0.4999041259,
-0.2590443492,
-0.3754472435,
-0.2189984769,
0.1688397676,
0.2766842246,
0.2168132812,
-0.0506852716,
-0.0611872226,
0.4105947912,
-0.5016405582,
0.573844254,
0.2795125544,
-0.2614670694,
-0.4172879159,
0.876360178,
0.0448322706,
0.2781437933,
0.186552763,
0.2337617427,
-0.3831540346,
-0.9274362326,
-0.5451406837,
-0.0086152228,
-0.8875926137,
-0.4633575976,
-0.0282889698,
-0.0738778561,
0.0784609318,
0.0404987261,
-0.4097349942,
-0.2529249787,
-0.3569688499,
0.142979607,
0.1489816904,
0.5699722171,
0.3225004971,
0.4398970604,
-0.6365770102,
0.358617872,
0.2942869067,
0.4500804245,
-0.2237760425,
-0.8930904865,
-0.3231104016,
-0.0643659309,
-0.3945565224,
-0.5274118185,
0.4558108151,
0.2551114559,
0.6422729492,
0.4993545115,
0.1370203048,
0.6517072916,
-0.1517493874,
0.9789089561,
0.1789650768,
-1.2881010771,
0.4580912888,
-0.0853795782,
0.420080483,
0.4635494947,
0.0765919387,
-0.4234689176,
-0.5130952001,
-0.5627613068,
-1.0874160528,
0.2113607079,
0.5376548171,
0.010871754,
0.2415242195,
0.347489655,
0.1498101056,
0.2072480023,
-0.7901505232,
-0.3396317959,
-0.1472346932,
-0.0953366458,
0.0430657826,
-0.2385422587,
-0.1208889261,
-0.1382350475,
0.7711417675,
-0.259051621,
0.2016327977,
-0.1591859311,
-0.3997135162,
0.1974665374,
0.1814035475,
0.5808904171,
0.5702373385,
0.0973943844,
0.1609063148,
0.1089101434,
-0.2473129928,
0.0701403022,
-0.0748791918,
-0.4290005267,
0.3030771017,
1.0122033358,
0.8263553977,
0.1118811592,
-0.7522906661,
0.6606998444,
-0.1196403354,
-0.0416207463,
0.2297166884,
0.2128653079,
0.2828312218,
0.2324600071,
0.2232790142,
-0.2660747766,
0.2212207019,
-0.1643022448,
-0.0251752343,
0.5197581053,
-0.2120791823,
-0.1001406312,
0.6221366525,
0.2312198579,
-0.2602981627,
0.3298078775,
-0.2601601481,
-0.6435198784,
0.6374652982,
0.203905195,
0.8578594923,
-0.0476359501,
-0.0450931266,
0.0302835368,
0.354593575,
-0.1468815655,
0.2482478768,
0.028273182,
-0.8482764363,
-0.5321107507,
-0.4881888032,
-0.5767370462,
0.3021176159,
-0.935459435,
-0.0699619949,
-0.2738372386,
-0.5347388983,
0.0339341313,
-0.1375513971,
-0.4471060038,
0.2829098701,
0.1649343222,
0.5448538065,
-0.8907427788,
0.5462765694,
0.558142662,
-0.0919004157,
-0.221927315,
0.2157195657,
-0.0261672661,
-0.6644071937,
0.4061224759,
0.1360698491,
-0.3246949911,
-0.3461246192,
-0.4757604599,
-0.7051023841,
1.0391091108,
0.6367592812,
-0.4793972373,
0.6469160318,
0.3404329717,
0.7850308418,
-0.0317024253,
0.0836723372,
0.7523091435,
0.4789551795,
-0.3516774476,
-0.8126120567,
0.201102972,
-0.4766723216,
0.2310093045,
0.1895943582,
-0.4497380257,
0.414870888,
0.1674367785,
-0.3899107277,
-0.0335130431,
0.3592979014,
0.1925887465,
0.196776107,
0.6046063304,
0.6082127094,
0.3602057099,
-0.3114931881,
1.2025697231,
-0.2581692636,
0.5425501466,
0.9776206613,
-0.2631539702,
0.8424427509,
0.6274947524,
-0.480345726,
0.0251836758,
0.5795318484,
-0.0737660155,
0.6854298115,
0.5341143608,
-0.3056176901,
-0.3033325076,
-0.180045262,
-0.3357611895,
0.2027406693,
0.2501502931,
-0.3373086452,
-0.1595311165,
-0.1671642363,
-0.1680318415,
-0.0591025203,
-0.3092795312,
0.7616014481,
0.0999603942,
-0.4564856887,
0.6482160091,
0.1615115404,
1.0023025274,
-0.2528856099,
-0.016705839,
-0.6778467298,
0.129514873,
-0.1681562215,
-0.8568204641,
0.4699840844,
0.0533181205,
-0.1601659954,
-0.3623703122,
0.7496570349,
-0.413536191,
-0.2598691881,
0.584415257,
0.5795508623,
0.0767027065,
-0.2992186844,
-0.9159470797,
0.2763612866,
-0.2036644518,
-0.5475414991,
0.3092160523,
0.2158412188,
-0.200463742,
0.8542244434,
0.523404479,
0.1812072545,
0.0286519062,
0.3899402618,
0.6187154055,
-0.4242665768,
-0.3930496275,
-1.0091397762,
0.2879166901,
-0.3149294853,
-0.329662621,
0.7275283933,
0.4852380455,
0.7118964791,
-0.0030722253,
0.845944941,
0.2327711582,
0.0678072944,
-0.6216753125,
0.9757634997,
-0.7083348632,
0.5208339095,
-0.4819181263,
-0.8892741799,
-0.5928917527,
0.5249056816,
-0.0517881922,
-0.082711041,
0.5045452118,
0.5951273441,
0.0563736968,
-0.1214559451,
0.4411024749,
-0.4516868293,
0.5874878168,
0.2336981446,
0.9765566587,
-0.4420184791,
0.5351648331,
-0.0859636664,
-0.003326999,
-0.1373089254,
-1.1186695099,
-0.9594120979,
-0.3836243749,
-0.7407671809,
-0.3196583092,
0.1946884543,
0.4549911916,
0.5435936451,
-0.9056457877,
-0.0126838945,
0.3120894134,
0.140701279,
-0.4463764429,
-0.2154629976,
0.5935358405,
0.2519074082,
-0.4830023646,
0.1944365054,
0.4649198353,
0.2881358862,
-0.0763047561,
-0.1091777086,
0.303391248,
0.1537050754,
0.7013641596,
-0.0254948214,
-0.4868127406,
-0.1462833434,
-0.4742332697,
-0.1063349023,
-0.0526857972,
0.8007649779,
-0.4041901529,
0.2981417179,
0.5408447981,
0.8786227703,
0.5457708836,
-0.1366771013,
0.2346052825,
-0.8259078264,
0.085712336,
0.1935296208,
0.540707767,
0.4801861048,
-0.0972594246,
0.5380424261,
0.239659518,
-0.1115018427,
-0.70915097,
-0.1936214119,
-0.7622865438,
-0.3457835317,
1.3234093189,
-0.5929868817,
0.0989805162,
-0.1404746175,
-0.048041191,
0.1183610633,
-0.068547219,
1.0139901638,
0.9842778444,
-0.0601270571,
-0.0224957876,
-0.3676426411,
0.5439137816,
0.5863105655,
-1.2753084898,
-0.0636811852,
0.2503034472,
0.528311491,
0.0722834989,
0.3730757236,
-0.1125827655,
0.1615192443,
-0.1501329541,
0.3186946213,
-0.1840018034,
0.0020591193,
-0.4840638936,
0.1563010365,
-0.0008424515,
-0.2073597461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19521v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19521v4
|
Interpreting Key Mechanisms of Factual Recall in Transformer-Based Language Models
| 2024-03-28T15:54:59 | 2024-05-24T15:06:45 |
Ang Lv, Yuhan Chen, Kaiyi Zhang, Yulong Wang, Lifeng Liu, Ji-Rong Wen, Jian Xie, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we delve into several mechanisms employed by Transformer-based
language models (LLMs) for factual recall tasks. We outline a pipeline
consisting of three major steps: (1) Given a prompt ``The capital of France
is,'' task-specific attention heads extract the topic token, such as
``France,'' from the context and pass it to subsequent MLPs. (2) As attention
heads' outputs are aggregated with equal weight and added to the residual
stream, the subsequent MLP acts as an ``activation,'' which either erases or
amplifies the information originating from individual heads. As a result, the
topic token ``France'' stands out in the residual stream. (3) A deep MLP takes
``France'' and generates a component that redirects the residual stream towards
the direction of the correct answer, i.e., ``Paris.'' This procedure is akin to
applying an implicit function such as ``get\_capital($X$),'' and the argument
$X$ is the topic token information passed by attention heads. To achieve the
above quantitative and qualitative analysis for MLPs, we proposed a novel
analytic method aimed at decomposing the outputs of the MLP into components
understandable by humans. Additionally, we observed a universal
anti-overconfidence mechanism in the final layer of models, which suppresses
correct predictions. We mitigate this suppression by leveraging our
interpretation to improve factual recall confidence. The above interpretations
are evaluated across diverse tasks spanning various domains of factual
knowledge, using various language models from the GPT-2 families, 1.3B OPT, up
to 7B Llama-2, and in both zero- and few-shot setups.
|
[
-0.3709462583,
-0.7316145897,
0.8725821972,
-0.1780602187,
-0.0516366959,
0.0375057012,
-0.1188060641,
-0.1164984927,
-0.1181600168,
0.6903784275,
-0.6338753104,
-0.4252735078,
-0.7372694016,
0.1157814041,
-0.5148918033,
1.2525428534,
-0.1683348417,
-0.3647885621,
-0.2095353603,
0.0626624599,
-0.5858698487,
-0.6654279828,
-0.5681610703,
-0.3971820176,
0.6698215604,
0.3743693829,
0.3857318163,
0.4098208845,
0.4227798879,
0.238816604,
-0.0653898343,
-0.1209155098,
-0.9610319138,
-0.0092288796,
-0.4123867452,
-0.8698534369,
-0.1520729512,
0.0253868997,
0.6599869132,
0.467823118,
-0.0794909522,
0.2787581384,
0.0763569996,
0.6567454338,
-0.7201703191,
0.3779624403,
-0.9815473557,
0.0583414249,
0.2288381606,
-0.5906894207,
-0.5652859211,
-0.1269198209,
0.1106284484,
-0.2595321834,
0.6624951959,
0.0984585509,
0.90000844,
0.4398070276,
-0.5377941728,
-0.2869537771,
-0.9428480268,
0.5785433054,
-0.2679184973,
0.3834130764,
0.3685368598,
0.0920478106,
0.0273147672,
-0.8398297429,
-0.7203354836,
-0.1335896403,
-0.5436566472,
0.2657958567,
-0.3431863785,
-0.0058527612,
0.5465909839,
0.382873863,
-0.4694721401,
-0.1732004285,
-0.5447730422,
-0.4461310804,
0.2208896726,
0.1215656772,
0.1378450841,
-0.1535759121,
-0.5147816539,
0.1449509114,
-1.0066524744,
0.0831848159,
-0.0452395864,
0.4094100893,
-0.1489895731,
0.6162104011,
-0.079075262,
0.3893562853,
0.2142288685,
-0.048619736,
0.0060011097,
-0.3809363842,
-0.294089973,
0.1628310978,
0.3215127885,
0.1471878737,
0.3081482649,
-0.2697682679,
-0.3235456944,
0.205325231,
0.522875011,
-0.6036472917,
-0.1016051769,
0.2530689538,
-0.2547944784,
-0.238427639,
-0.0574456155,
-0.5339583755,
-0.1376327276,
-0.4238518178,
0.5064163208,
-0.165861249,
-0.0459896773,
0.0327030607,
-0.0766938403,
0.4515277445,
0.0448888279,
-0.9411551356,
0.5504274964,
0.8121270537,
0.6792821288,
-0.2736728191,
-0.1614415497,
-0.6291140914,
0.0406781919,
-0.2876176238,
0.75277704,
-0.3425697088,
-0.3303628266,
0.2071726769,
0.2251972407,
-0.3740520477,
-0.4556522667,
0.8122209907,
-0.754080534,
0.3175501227,
-0.9258160591,
-0.5630791187,
-0.5894947648,
0.3972047567,
-0.8336175084,
1.0293568373,
-0.2322552651,
-0.7500324845,
0.4504909217,
-0.2658467591,
-0.3048359454,
-0.3069979846,
-0.2054083198,
-0.3102089167,
0.1312580407,
0.2732887864,
0.6177681088,
-0.3136425912,
0.3987476826,
0.1256877482,
-0.4379986525,
0.3151874244,
-0.8420508504,
0.5238463879,
-0.2053924352,
-0.5056118965,
-0.044981882,
-0.8049366474,
-0.6337347627,
0.1518630981,
-0.0610958338,
-0.0230484232,
-0.0222668517,
-0.2953939438,
0.5003395677,
0.0094752265,
-0.5308359265,
-0.1447058171,
-0.289963156,
0.2308918834,
0.6501478553,
0.5391018391,
0.3547692001,
-0.22948502,
0.2938686311,
0.2496798635,
-0.2012893558,
-0.5446451902,
-0.4189999998,
-0.9479627609,
-0.4629663229,
0.0794446245,
0.8549809456,
-0.4488657415,
0.1770009547,
-0.2747049928,
-0.045489829,
-0.2722968161,
-0.0644731224,
0.3511142731,
0.8640033603,
0.3040614426,
-0.0440097041,
-0.3613528311,
-0.9640104771,
-0.0971260369,
-0.1295328736,
0.0611094423,
0.0390344486,
0.7766158581,
0.001603622,
1.1557184458,
-0.5387034416,
-0.1437162161,
-0.2785911858,
0.2919584811,
0.3303925693,
0.1780246496,
0.5298406482,
-0.9504836202,
-0.1314682811,
-0.2345346659,
-0.6313577294,
0.1401417404,
-0.4398500919,
0.0034053393,
0.3984459937,
0.5890888572,
-1.026576519,
0.5990113616,
0.0716260299,
-0.3462058604,
0.6257295012,
-0.0274888426,
0.175876379,
-0.781167686,
0.308163017,
-0.1018274799,
-0.2464025021,
-0.7597228885,
-0.1060050651,
-0.0531433634,
0.0011768354,
-0.2908143103,
0.5309565663,
-0.3342081606,
-0.0852549747,
-0.1122613326,
0.3510979116,
0.2133083791,
0.9024477005,
0.143798992,
0.6833249927,
0.395948261,
-0.4914925396,
0.1616227478,
0.1506353468,
-0.019063564,
0.5017750263,
-0.534008503,
-0.0268288944,
-0.5318956971,
0.2151716501,
-1.6556768417,
0.0729170963,
0.5057813525,
-0.3477424085,
0.6175703406,
-0.1672367901,
-0.3787580729,
-0.3437998593,
-0.0751625225,
-0.0168228075,
0.4068144858,
-0.3989634514,
0.7917282581,
0.0648076013,
-0.4900499284,
-0.7217028737,
-0.6730875969,
0.1109854504,
-0.2353738546,
-0.0363474302,
0.1926409453,
0.2167612165,
-0.1674143821,
0.1341273487,
-0.4088778794,
0.0013440689,
0.0471578948,
0.323638469,
0.5852541327,
-0.1876151115,
0.1397506297,
-0.0699810684,
-0.3620912135,
0.4561040401,
-0.3532629311,
0.1825461388,
-0.1797782928,
-0.4724155366,
-0.5355730057,
0.1855974942,
0.6849403381,
-0.2707881033,
0.9565098882,
0.7092177272,
-0.386157304,
0.1394623667,
-0.8347449899,
-0.5194104314,
-0.3632529676,
0.4188872278,
-0.5369617343,
-0.8497895598,
0.7804557681,
0.0774972662,
0.1238981709,
0.6603344679,
0.917140007,
-0.0022738583,
0.5576526523,
0.5764351487,
-0.2512473166,
0.0913414136,
-0.4078954756,
0.453328222,
-0.6341559887,
-0.2883867025,
-0.4469846189,
-0.0667253509,
-0.3956066668,
-0.4742643833,
0.1652413756,
-0.1763890982,
-0.1012129411,
0.1535233706,
-0.0622841157,
0.459155798,
0.5357889533,
0.0014530979,
0.3325830996,
0.0952963829,
-0.3193236887,
-0.1713354588,
-0.9016019702,
-0.5428897738,
1.1158493757,
0.4079476893,
0.3364865482,
-0.2206260115,
0.5473517776,
0.269836992,
0.3736608028,
-0.7080981135,
0.4813102782,
0.0972894505,
-0.7863914371,
-0.2259093076,
-0.1802043468,
-0.5906555057,
0.367963165,
-0.3586001396,
-0.8030492663,
0.3285791576,
0.2044991702,
-0.6218921542,
0.4027575552,
-0.5709859729,
0.8759034276,
0.2308825403,
-0.4653208554,
-0.4206022322,
-0.6955936551,
0.5385686755,
-0.0924584642,
0.0843802318,
0.0594764166,
0.1669242382,
0.3706906736,
0.3047846258,
1.2253562212,
-0.107210435,
-0.1271446794,
0.5205672383,
0.1777111739,
0.8025982976,
-0.0957657024,
0.1734899879,
0.1613691449,
-0.1899068803,
-0.2484691143,
-0.7567644715,
0.4312018454,
-0.6358211637,
-0.7198988795,
-0.3261458576,
-0.4678471982,
-0.0194922742,
-0.0785233378,
0.2843902111,
0.6722283959,
-0.4286951125,
0.1621687114,
0.8571207523,
-0.1365207136,
0.3154796958,
0.5830206871,
0.0366928168,
0.0395687334,
0.9630675316,
0.1501184106,
0.3589859903,
0.7986238599,
-0.0548588969,
-0.4970149696,
-0.3589389324,
0.0096064517,
0.4267398119,
-0.9962086082,
-0.0141189322,
-0.8345211148,
-0.2651708722,
-0.1830921173,
0.0217467044,
-0.2689978182,
-0.5954437852,
-0.3475217819,
-0.5420286059,
0.0026172523,
0.4992849529,
-0.1247187257,
0.0343489051,
-0.7139882445,
0.7555767894,
0.4779542983,
-0.0182060935,
0.0776554719,
-0.6810946465,
-0.232514739,
-0.1762037128,
-0.2026707381,
-0.7453229427,
0.18678765,
-0.0949264765,
0.728813827,
0.4238358438,
0.1027372181,
0.3008301556,
-0.6646640897,
0.7511795163,
-0.1498862654,
-0.8553758264,
0.2494389266,
-0.0190320704,
0.1870118231,
0.4258723259,
0.5665399432,
-0.6913487315,
-0.577286303,
-0.5732035041,
-0.7931652069,
0.6165354252,
0.4178880453,
0.0234316811,
-0.176550746,
0.6362954974,
0.0557629056,
0.3422974348,
-0.566052258,
-0.3159137368,
-0.1621111333,
-0.1015272141,
-0.0264159888,
-0.7246980667,
-0.4280733168,
0.0260905419,
0.6758055687,
0.0028857801,
0.4323906898,
0.4298123419,
-0.1939199716,
0.0493576974,
0.2280248553,
0.7829936147,
0.7482008934,
-0.2467021346,
0.1767435074,
0.2700117826,
-0.4242632687,
-0.0433987081,
-0.0520573147,
-0.3211976588,
-0.0534593277,
0.7306990027,
1.0892976522,
0.4610747099,
-0.4033413827,
0.4761089385,
0.0206550118,
-0.0181341767,
-0.3214017153,
-0.0708517507,
-0.0123824375,
0.2866190076,
0.5602514148,
0.2510982752,
0.199314937,
-0.7446136475,
0.5520965457,
0.3357481956,
-0.5483412743,
-0.628405273,
0.6626124978,
0.0456877016,
0.0239762217,
0.5906456113,
-0.1912722737,
-0.7601537704,
0.538387835,
0.4406985939,
1.1617289782,
0.0037637393,
0.3311128318,
0.5168572068,
0.5915049911,
-0.0249195602,
0.0796654299,
-0.1218564734,
-0.9691438675,
-0.8320760131,
-0.3655955791,
-0.2093326598,
-0.0276955683,
-0.7719776034,
-0.0309564229,
-0.1379035115,
-0.059527915,
-0.2898568213,
-0.2073899955,
-0.8244823813,
0.4021278918,
0.584595263,
0.8367393613,
-1.1229200363,
0.5884849429,
0.1204880252,
-0.2580586374,
-0.5450170636,
0.2595361769,
0.3035349548,
-0.9686263204,
0.7691919804,
0.0541977845,
-0.2665176094,
0.0114366664,
-0.3717008531,
-0.9230152965,
0.868640244,
0.2249608487,
-0.5979545712,
-0.1212769747,
0.2846483886,
0.4600410461,
-0.385489136,
0.0452517755,
1.0572730303,
0.4241708219,
0.357987076,
-0.6123666167,
0.309523344,
0.15913634,
-0.3340016901,
-0.047218781,
-0.3700501025,
0.6343767047,
-0.4332338274,
-0.3639516532,
-0.2052052021,
0.5710547566,
0.1844263822,
0.1126020029,
0.3762264252,
0.4435424805,
0.8191862106,
-0.1206867471,
1.1792615652,
-0.4996057451,
0.5485786796,
1.1074539423,
-0.2245336771,
0.7541545033,
0.5669981837,
-0.0700938627,
0.4576694965,
0.2193046361,
0.0460199416,
0.6169976592,
-0.2145959884,
-0.1227095723,
-0.2634644806,
0.0068900478,
0.0659951344,
0.4141963422,
0.4115525186,
-0.2543942928,
-0.2318190485,
-0.0664996579,
0.1792097688,
-0.1450627297,
-0.2979509234,
0.6559764743,
0.1435132027,
-0.6982703209,
0.6510452628,
-0.2263370305,
0.00804877,
-0.523401618,
-0.0929368138,
-0.2415321618,
0.0079840859,
0.0811517984,
-0.7942354679,
0.4434179962,
-0.1083401367,
-0.4044013023,
-0.172147885,
0.74291116,
-0.5568649173,
-0.486158222,
0.1391616613,
0.4323179722,
-0.1294045448,
-0.3714416921,
-0.6030042768,
0.051860854,
0.0692403093,
-0.6013143063,
-0.0849141553,
0.5882267356,
-0.0019676748,
0.6624371409,
0.5044500828,
0.0164273679,
-0.003183774,
0.0932778493,
0.7674402595,
-0.7973859906,
-0.3604449332,
-0.9853007793,
0.6953582764,
0.1506607234,
0.0869027972,
0.6336432695,
0.4930373728,
0.5660964847,
-0.0902892128,
0.7895729542,
0.1974376291,
0.4697346389,
-0.7256503701,
0.4475986958,
-0.2822778523,
0.1631491631,
-0.1225765124,
-0.9087905884,
-0.2616402805,
0.2852168083,
-0.483430773,
-0.2898395956,
0.8874824643,
0.7606515288,
0.0162413884,
-0.0595195256,
0.4270997047,
0.7325385213,
0.1834010631,
0.3731105626,
0.6415838003,
-0.3867726028,
0.5483500361,
-0.0493448041,
-0.0516007803,
-0.2982743084,
-0.7325344682,
-0.9402780533,
-0.6578344703,
-0.2897118628,
-0.1806707382,
-0.0343895368,
0.6148176789,
0.3984808922,
-1.0524718761,
0.0683724284,
-0.0320707224,
0.3418194354,
-0.2142711878,
-0.2300180942,
0.4791577756,
-0.5450501442,
-0.5290611386,
0.1099781767,
0.5617896914,
-0.0253072679,
-0.3297849596,
0.3229766786,
-0.0948678255,
0.2296224385,
0.7644837499,
0.2514154911,
-0.9556515813,
-0.6373897195,
0.1101905927,
-0.0501218177,
0.1331219226,
1.0195070505,
-0.9730865359,
0.224350214,
0.3818419278,
0.5157521367,
0.6935896873,
0.132056132,
0.6430028081,
-0.7744436264,
0.359308809,
-0.0157296415,
0.3971093893,
0.3359064758,
-0.4015418589,
0.3321682811,
0.5709574223,
-0.3261336088,
-0.6425330639,
0.190392673,
-0.6692469716,
-0.1874612123,
0.9768941402,
-0.203633666,
-0.1258545071,
-0.2011139542,
-0.3532409668,
0.3318069875,
-0.0856286287,
0.8952940106,
0.8851222992,
0.179352209,
-0.2508045733,
-0.7088310122,
0.5323510766,
0.1855439693,
-0.3063575625,
0.2200580686,
0.3682507575,
0.259963423,
0.3270700872,
0.5754372478,
0.0614290349,
0.1958830804,
0.0758038089,
-0.0152923418,
0.2608120739,
-0.7125254273,
-0.267306,
0.3124454021,
-0.3434950411,
-0.0944829211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.01322v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.01322v1
|
A Review of Multi-Modal Large Language and Vision Models
| 2024-03-28T15:53:45 | 2024-03-28T15:53:45 |
Kilian Carolan, Laura Fennelly, Alan F. Smeaton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently emerged as a focal point of
research and application, driven by their unprecedented ability to understand
and generate text with human-like quality. Even more recently, LLMs have been
extended into multi-modal large language models (MM-LLMs) which extends their
capabilities to deal with image, video and audio information, in addition to
text. This opens up applications like text-to-video generation, image
captioning, text-to-speech, and more and is achieved either by retro-fitting an
LLM with multi-modal capabilities, or building a MM-LLM from scratch. This
paper provides an extensive review of the current state of those LLMs with
multi-modal capabilities as well as the very recent MM-LLMs. It covers the
historical development of LLMs especially the advances enabled by
transformer-based architectures like OpenAI's GPT series and Google's BERT, as
well as the role of attention mechanisms in enhancing model performance. The
paper includes coverage of the major and most important of the LLMs and MM-LLMs
and also covers the techniques of model tuning, including fine-tuning and
prompt engineering, which tailor pre-trained models to specific tasks or
domains. Ethical considerations and challenges, such as data bias and model
misuse, are also analysed to underscore the importance of responsible AI
development and deployment. Finally, we discuss the implications of open-source
versus proprietary models in AI research. Through this review, we provide
insights into the transformative potential of MM-LLMs in various applications.
|
[
-0.4021812975,
-0.6336151361,
0.6588095427,
0.0035734016,
0.0639115497,
-0.0733736381,
-0.4471459687,
-0.7065145373,
-0.1784601063,
0.6239014864,
-0.353381604,
-0.078566879,
-0.6835625172,
0.1160691008,
-0.4188549817,
0.5211983323,
0.0600056015,
0.3633536696,
-0.1791240871,
-0.1291588545,
-0.3964337111,
-0.6404476166,
-0.454274714,
-0.2636443377,
0.5067362189,
0.0483220592,
0.8694149256,
0.5341122746,
0.685764432,
0.3794222772,
-0.0696996152,
0.342949152,
-0.2885485888,
0.0020143888,
0.0555922911,
-0.5049524903,
-0.5932607055,
0.1372339427,
0.8331375122,
0.6781213284,
0.0836578608,
0.082511209,
-0.027902646,
0.3639598191,
-0.572706759,
0.4109875858,
-0.6267584562,
-0.2036556453,
-0.1134422943,
-0.0158831794,
-0.5000970364,
0.1050879955,
0.1002870202,
-0.3404640853,
-0.0838095173,
0.1852065027,
0.5416681767,
0.4928553998,
-0.642608881,
-0.2813707888,
-0.9747443795,
1.0551269054,
-0.8659427166,
0.7351472974,
0.1225437596,
0.3380499184,
-0.0831878707,
-0.5264636874,
-0.5710870028,
-0.5433160663,
0.1909810305,
0.0199757852,
-0.0079313638,
0.1809263974,
0.1629208028,
0.5114002824,
-0.2808096707,
0.4087567031,
-0.291082859,
-0.0467921495,
0.4931232333,
0.3214586973,
0.2584681809,
-0.1731064022,
-0.318734169,
0.0224211738,
-0.7596670985,
-0.1700828075,
0.2146873474,
0.2275709212,
-0.1807551235,
0.879727006,
0.0767337158,
0.926019311,
-0.2530322373,
-0.5428825021,
0.0649305135,
-0.6042444706,
-0.4570287466,
-0.4333957434,
0.8708991408,
0.1812566966,
0.5465218425,
-0.0431340262,
-0.2724030316,
0.076968953,
0.2712988853,
-0.5194483399,
0.2010016888,
0.0318543948,
-0.6743717194,
-0.1652234197,
-0.1319474876,
-0.6354609728,
-0.4447751343,
-0.7790500522,
0.28725034,
-0.3114646375,
-0.3075156808,
0.1802368164,
0.2421727329,
0.466517508,
0.5902743936,
-0.7842220664,
-0.0899689868,
0.6759303212,
0.6621676087,
-0.0995774344,
-0.5176478028,
-0.2008416951,
0.3661120236,
-0.3548696935,
0.3828407228,
-0.660788238,
-0.2713483572,
0.2263539881,
-0.0030968743,
-0.0832805037,
-0.3913555741,
0.2299009413,
-0.534871161,
0.2088229954,
-0.1011281163,
-0.2045259625,
-0.376298666,
0.4780874848,
-0.8063819408,
0.5363332629,
-0.1724655181,
-0.5372043848,
0.1763377488,
-0.8674334288,
-0.4376322627,
-0.137583226,
-0.286424309,
-0.1418061852,
0.3184763789,
0.2064700425,
0.6938746572,
-0.7836318016,
0.3779488504,
-0.1206806526,
0.1068138108,
0.3114041388,
-0.8140668273,
0.5769745111,
0.2159618139,
-0.1695540696,
0.4854706824,
-0.7316868305,
-0.270663619,
0.0684011355,
-0.5361704826,
-0.0182622876,
0.4058770239,
0.3052221835,
0.306375742,
0.2217945307,
-0.2799762487,
-0.0378811173,
-0.1631687731,
0.8614205718,
0.7273251414,
-0.4658653736,
0.4374872148,
-0.2983004749,
0.371693939,
0.1117000207,
0.4734584093,
-0.7102968097,
-0.4701326191,
-0.8365778327,
-0.4755690694,
0.0363061242,
0.5378863811,
-0.7571622729,
0.0699976608,
-0.308504492,
-0.3369706869,
-0.6031150222,
0.1510649323,
0.0080230394,
0.1446869522,
0.1984689832,
-0.0536641516,
-0.198653996,
-0.9748561978,
0.091623418,
-0.1884779036,
0.0028871223,
0.6003320813,
0.369949013,
-0.5679464936,
0.5362771749,
-0.2060282826,
-0.283077538,
-0.3196821809,
-0.0980994701,
-0.0447131507,
0.214201048,
0.5827869177,
-1.1058366299,
-0.12989223,
0.1335539371,
-0.7380366325,
0.2576900125,
-0.2096908987,
0.4803806841,
0.3048906326,
0.5401983261,
-0.7582851648,
0.0832913443,
0.8443511724,
-0.0465920568,
0.5180817246,
-0.230101645,
0.3516165316,
-1.2563743591,
0.1463939399,
0.1259294152,
-0.3428967595,
-0.5969053507,
0.3769887686,
-0.0271597896,
-0.2873429358,
-0.5346072316,
0.3970885277,
-0.7251164913,
-0.2427127659,
-0.4688672721,
-0.0391332246,
-0.2148026377,
0.2648447156,
-0.0896846652,
0.85966295,
0.6412255764,
-0.4540368915,
0.6700149775,
0.0129731875,
-0.4791888595,
0.4256919026,
-0.5453631878,
-0.0289709941,
-0.2148143053,
-0.0461326279,
-0.840700686,
-0.3238840103,
0.0496583171,
-0.1791765392,
0.3885687292,
0.1270535439,
-0.7379323244,
-0.304338932,
-0.2105476409,
0.6103056669,
0.3341856301,
-0.4295256734,
0.9730153084,
0.4625741541,
-0.1544433832,
-0.3902968466,
-0.7002180815,
0.4495423138,
-0.1309759468,
-0.6797574759,
0.2032381892,
-0.2103886306,
-0.4237882197,
-0.190564096,
0.3958070278,
-0.0333984271,
0.0305057578,
0.2959589362,
0.3891801834,
-0.3611032963,
0.0742940083,
-0.4660456181,
-0.0509690791,
0.0019696285,
-0.1231646165,
0.5478885174,
-0.2358559519,
-0.5799162984,
-0.3511120081,
0.5069572926,
1.0990914106,
-0.6257468462,
0.6490943432,
0.6044800878,
-0.3055255711,
0.1259903461,
-0.8783012629,
-0.137970373,
-0.4145913422,
0.5918907523,
-0.3091892898,
-1.0945767164,
0.2394615412,
-0.2291118652,
0.0956193805,
0.3680664003,
0.9793896079,
0.0594262108,
1.0872740746,
1.1778457165,
-0.3902991414,
0.7502197027,
0.0660366267,
0.358222574,
-0.8991000652,
-0.3442828953,
-0.2850356698,
-0.2186063677,
-0.5440642238,
-0.6554112434,
0.4977055788,
-0.2286470979,
-0.1254246831,
-0.0619770214,
-0.1973614395,
0.3255650997,
0.5444992185,
-0.2020059526,
0.4986524582,
-0.1550430655,
0.1773755848,
0.0718932673,
-0.6847456694,
-0.6473965645,
1.0957175493,
0.6069133282,
1.1470688581,
0.0532409437,
-0.0212487448,
0.0991397277,
0.1954598129,
-0.9182032943,
0.5453488231,
-0.2277543843,
-0.7453622222,
-0.3609272838,
-0.1877434254,
-0.5938417315,
0.3280848265,
-0.2331820279,
-0.4752396643,
-0.0894077495,
-0.0177976321,
-0.1611914188,
0.6018798351,
-0.6015527844,
0.6589560509,
-0.556032896,
-0.1428453177,
-0.4243269563,
-0.6881040931,
0.5871843696,
-0.2667163908,
0.3081539273,
0.0095557366,
-0.1737962365,
0.2914041281,
0.1357008815,
0.985214889,
0.1854327768,
-0.389211446,
0.2885128856,
-0.1278685033,
0.2594828606,
-0.1470303237,
0.1425988972,
0.3666662872,
-0.0599326193,
-0.062212348,
-0.1764489114,
0.6988661885,
-0.7695897818,
-0.6779726148,
-0.1633766294,
-0.916523993,
-0.1047646329,
0.2797933221,
-0.1960769147,
0.5134209991,
-0.1142885312,
0.3652961552,
0.7613741755,
-0.4840505123,
0.7157453299,
0.3985286951,
-0.2988490462,
-0.3433439732,
0.6864958405,
-0.0057008616,
0.3670967221,
0.5050801039,
-0.0016560225,
-0.1517209709,
-0.6259304285,
-0.5187491179,
0.3506275713,
-0.6468512416,
-0.1246570349,
-0.458874464,
-0.2812871635,
-0.5030734539,
-0.026103342,
-0.5329194665,
-0.0089476528,
-0.4028717875,
0.2085229158,
0.1633560061,
0.9100322127,
0.0298332851,
0.2716744244,
-0.7485906482,
0.5696932673,
0.3166674078,
0.3743598163,
0.0689267218,
-0.2257811129,
-0.1676212251,
0.0866901428,
-0.2880812585,
-0.6444139481,
0.3221219778,
0.1083155051,
0.6065980196,
0.4541560411,
-0.4076844156,
0.3574227393,
-0.7970329523,
0.9771994948,
0.3537644446,
-0.7600907087,
0.1890412271,
-0.4941629767,
0.3210007548,
-0.0686845332,
0.3084430099,
-0.5908602476,
-0.1725738198,
-0.073075898,
-0.6299480796,
0.5434470177,
-0.2037268281,
0.3492362499,
0.2463379353,
0.3536605239,
0.0431567132,
0.3068557382,
-0.9960330725,
-0.1136224046,
-0.119298555,
-0.2674462795,
-0.3592442572,
-0.3391398787,
-0.114944607,
-0.0493857265,
0.2951266468,
-0.3603755236,
0.195876807,
-0.0844764858,
-0.2399004996,
0.005484682,
0.4453649521,
0.8636543751,
0.759906888,
0.274138093,
0.1497283727,
0.0618704744,
-0.2000300884,
0.0211650562,
-0.0018852738,
-0.0810395777,
-0.3270082176,
0.3466709852,
0.833142817,
0.2375467569,
-0.8371997476,
0.5727988482,
0.2604293823,
-0.1099911556,
-0.3198341727,
-0.1736707389,
0.1098499969,
0.7011752725,
0.2509506643,
0.0764690489,
-0.0679719821,
-0.844067812,
-0.2859581113,
0.8209913969,
-0.2284456193,
-0.4294430912,
0.832464695,
0.1829408258,
-0.3220814764,
0.4701928496,
0.374039948,
-0.3854712844,
0.3374365568,
0.4450882971,
0.7594766021,
-0.2269014269,
-0.0783031285,
-0.0881402642,
0.6564903855,
-0.0792434439,
0.1128015146,
0.0726048127,
-0.7362446189,
-0.7073122859,
-0.533233583,
-0.4239855111,
0.4737243056,
-0.23562406,
0.1626136303,
-0.3107441366,
-0.2532547116,
-0.0432707295,
-0.3322848678,
-0.7073718905,
0.152652964,
0.5610220432,
0.7906009555,
-0.5830857158,
0.7515349388,
0.8015711308,
-0.3141231239,
-0.4428142309,
-0.2140070498,
-0.0956906676,
-0.8220865726,
0.5894448757,
0.0296718311,
-0.1832787246,
-0.0762199312,
-0.6029169559,
-0.9011610746,
1.0755734444,
0.4153580964,
-0.5476438403,
-0.3949529231,
0.4687327743,
0.3981604576,
-0.3670276403,
0.2063199729,
0.4111000001,
0.5613607764,
-0.1355476826,
-1.232000947,
-0.2242447287,
0.1250220388,
0.1852818877,
0.1684483439,
-0.9281720519,
0.9463642836,
-0.3970398307,
0.043668557,
0.1069401652,
0.5210853815,
-0.1033893451,
0.0566034019,
0.2971881628,
0.3328865767,
0.2668710947,
-0.0430877842,
1.1326588392,
-0.3074254692,
0.0435418673,
0.6831054688,
-0.3623448908,
0.8493977189,
0.659386158,
0.0002442178,
0.0115279704,
0.3526783586,
-0.2536539733,
0.3186534941,
-0.0654523373,
-0.0399761982,
-0.3812916577,
-0.2369161248,
-0.2256064862,
0.6827500463,
0.3584665954,
-0.519467473,
-0.1365428865,
0.3140086532,
-0.2586409748,
-0.0815295726,
-0.5050243735,
0.7307282686,
0.2607809305,
-0.3639426827,
0.1333201081,
0.2651283741,
0.853100121,
-0.566280067,
0.1502481252,
0.1661840379,
0.2552138865,
0.089426361,
-0.6123617887,
0.1433070302,
-0.0264770221,
-0.5663231611,
-0.3251013458,
0.7032916546,
-0.3848904669,
-0.5548494458,
0.2811338902,
0.8219298124,
-0.0914599672,
-0.0809704065,
-0.6412597895,
0.3857839108,
-0.2479582429,
-0.3049862683,
0.2468593419,
0.3099019527,
-0.052229438,
0.9605558515,
0.526517868,
0.0633450449,
0.3408541977,
0.1221591532,
0.8166882396,
-0.7667685747,
-0.1323472857,
-0.9101068974,
0.3871798813,
0.3042448461,
-0.0759821832,
0.5979291797,
0.4739291966,
0.7256558537,
-0.1509843916,
0.7635735869,
0.2144826949,
0.2733120322,
-0.616633594,
0.7563935518,
-0.7377431989,
-0.1028211042,
-0.1856644303,
-1.0562340021,
-0.4609810412,
0.3840567768,
-0.321860224,
0.2270967811,
0.4124851525,
0.6893469095,
-0.1184402332,
-0.0560736321,
0.7262508869,
0.2017078698,
0.5530340672,
0.4412381649,
1.0895605087,
-0.2853814363,
0.4647708535,
0.2539995611,
-0.1415390074,
-0.2682006359,
-0.8885655403,
-0.8954445124,
-0.6706618071,
-0.1026302576,
0.2281368226,
-0.3543333709,
0.7669301629,
0.9210308194,
-0.5556101799,
-0.3884598613,
0.2438306063,
-0.1031330302,
0.1427560598,
-0.1570718139,
0.0391019359,
-0.3136634231,
-0.9474554658,
0.5514088273,
0.5247872472,
0.2861943841,
-0.7702974081,
-0.0822043717,
-0.1656115949,
0.1959246397,
1.0826966763,
0.0610786565,
-1.1802302599,
-0.2285930365,
0.0658823848,
-0.1816305518,
0.1244672686,
0.8664288521,
-0.5001305938,
0.3321606219,
0.3062903881,
0.8469491601,
0.2762120962,
-0.3343418837,
0.6014817357,
-0.1527646929,
0.1696602553,
0.2482608557,
0.5827269554,
0.53021878,
0.0724995211,
0.2305492163,
0.0724638849,
-0.6601173282,
-0.7960819006,
0.4412848055,
-1.0050065517,
-0.3070326746,
1.2318410873,
0.2089435756,
-0.159096688,
0.175817892,
-0.340398401,
0.1107119694,
0.0349329039,
0.7120169401,
0.7452872396,
0.0246833526,
-0.5437922478,
-0.8223188519,
0.2248751074,
0.210872069,
-0.8744024038,
0.1173557267,
0.7750735879,
0.1263937056,
0.2492596358,
0.1989377141,
-0.2512593865,
-0.0213609952,
-0.2015582323,
-0.0190140251,
-0.2673835754,
-0.7122281194,
-0.464468658,
0.2648351192,
0.2574346066,
-0.0237289593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19511v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19511v1
|
Improving Clinical NLP Performance through Language Model-Generated Synthetic Clinical Data
| 2024-03-28T15:44:18 | 2024-03-28T15:44:18 |
Shan Chen, Jack Gallifant, Marco Guevara, Yanjun Gao, Majid Afshar, Timothy Miller, Dmitriy Dligach, Danielle S. Bitterman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generative models have been showing potential for producing data in mass.
This study explores the enhancement of clinical natural language processing
performance by utilizing synthetic data generated from advanced language
models. Promising results show feasible applications in such a high-stakes
domain.
|
[
0.0355511829,
-0.9270305037,
0.7424038053,
0.1799458712,
-0.0536508337,
0.1159329563,
-0.1233694181,
-0.6577269435,
0.2720517814,
0.9037954211,
-0.3247921467,
-0.6383616328,
-0.5403145552,
0.2356957197,
-0.6251984835,
0.8064918518,
0.3245571852,
0.6740170717,
-0.2715385556,
-0.0631122291,
-0.3215974271,
-0.9138818383,
-1.1285808086,
-0.5170769095,
0.2294611633,
0.0181135442,
1.0490169525,
0.7784427404,
0.8037444949,
0.3017070591,
0.1107416078,
0.2575893402,
-0.2708167732,
0.4472141564,
0.0246045999,
-0.6169210672,
-0.8745221496,
-0.3102043569,
0.578771174,
0.9784992337,
-0.5936290026,
-0.4459070265,
-0.5184307694,
0.6663473248,
-0.2374733835,
0.1383603364,
-0.683560729,
0.1529831588,
-0.2831166983,
-0.4910643399,
-0.5755687356,
-0.4546736777,
0.3593121469,
-0.6988183856,
0.9056834579,
-0.086946778,
0.6880717278,
-0.1231805235,
-0.1578853428,
-0.5634414554,
-1.0205987692,
0.5159251094,
-1.1314226389,
0.4366824925,
0.5326789021,
0.4556151628,
-0.3235974312,
-1.2067798376,
-0.4330783784,
-0.5013173819,
-0.0512299985,
0.2467948198,
-0.1950871646,
0.4305049479,
0.3351097107,
0.7663036585,
-0.7573132515,
0.066623427,
-0.5879576206,
0.0418988019,
0.8681787252,
0.6639769077,
0.6914148331,
-0.062740922,
0.1866132617,
-0.0358477384,
-0.7764092088,
-0.3735340536,
-0.0089946855,
0.4923228323,
0.129642278,
0.8872182965,
-0.3118697405,
0.8137347102,
-0.420714736,
-0.2622354329,
0.1461202204,
-0.3097404242,
-0.3350303173,
0.29890275,
0.5847117901,
0.437420547,
0.1145562232,
-0.3022136986,
-0.1904528737,
0.4931081235,
0.6156431437,
-0.6938263774,
-0.4489109218,
0.3745024204,
-0.4877935052,
-0.3988519013,
-0.2315282226,
-0.6365517378,
-0.5409393311,
-0.6334110498,
-0.046980314,
-0.7783293724,
-0.1574123651,
0.5091866851,
-0.1493400633,
-0.2485876828,
0.2364099026,
-1.0663763285,
0.6741903424,
0.4174837172,
0.8312141299,
-0.2377612144,
0.3360599875,
-0.3557682931,
0.2930753529,
-0.5212244987,
0.7512727976,
-0.5619369745,
-0.5818864107,
0.2800880671,
-0.2190402448,
-0.1322079301,
-1.0461279154,
0.5690349936,
-0.3210414946,
0.2050818503,
0.1070635468,
-0.7738896012,
0.2415304929,
-0.0277395975,
-0.8289887309,
0.9024516344,
0.3669216931,
-0.3978205621,
0.3682840765,
-0.8233103156,
-0.6588375568,
0.5176208019,
-0.2439585477,
-0.4049453437,
0.2676644921,
0.2788213789,
0.2785754204,
-0.4027884901,
0.5755276084,
-0.0582050271,
0.0677621812,
0.4321319461,
-0.3489359915,
0.3877850771,
0.4165869951,
0.0917934999,
0.0704739466,
-1.2810636759,
0.1120369658,
0.0855557993,
-0.2902776301,
-0.4041931331,
0.1236673892,
0.3292603791,
0.0651681572,
-0.2790844738,
-0.5183790326,
0.1436118484,
-0.7753515244,
0.4014038742,
0.0826816857,
0.1521351486,
0.1409098059,
-0.477291882,
0.9223331213,
-0.1126471758,
-0.029575238,
0.0307195522,
-0.6484311223,
-0.6693785191,
-0.2555064261,
0.3904108107,
0.4673711061,
-0.8742657304,
0.0625859797,
-0.2254286855,
-0.4526067376,
-0.9459986687,
-0.1665079892,
0.2591203451,
0.6332349181,
0.647605896,
-0.3071569502,
-0.8519924283,
-1.0529735088,
-0.1924283803,
-0.0375855602,
-0.3147899806,
0.1988639683,
0.0839553624,
-0.389649123,
0.7776890397,
-0.8491007686,
-0.28501302,
-0.5806922913,
0.3066184223,
0.1559850276,
0.5960007906,
0.4741326869,
-0.6073540449,
-0.3956326246,
0.0327368155,
-0.8592269421,
-0.2752861679,
-0.2251908481,
-0.1505935937,
0.0751393512,
0.4721590281,
-0.7520791888,
0.6436527967,
0.5092673302,
-0.1343091279,
0.6274108291,
-0.6178552508,
0.0807543099,
-1.077824831,
0.066761665,
-0.1456613839,
-0.3810935915,
-1.1596515179,
-0.0271290075,
-0.1333588511,
-0.3231267631,
-0.411880672,
0.4132258594,
-0.2205515802,
0.2508872747,
-0.3321829438,
-0.0889921039,
0.0146825276,
-0.261325568,
0.54649055,
0.7136868834,
0.4792425931,
-0.6356669664,
0.402534008,
0.5078542233,
-0.3360353708,
0.3033449054,
-0.9754487872,
-0.0986548513,
-0.0648766458,
0.0951139703,
-0.7261046171,
-0.6944156289,
-0.3818543851,
-0.3676808476,
0.2015997171,
0.0149301291,
-0.5397283435,
-0.4153569639,
0.1835806072,
0.2932315469,
0.6212821603,
-0.1953280866,
0.2410497516,
0.3820719719,
-0.4882297218,
0.1196973026,
-0.8411948681,
0.2739751339,
0.0230228733,
-0.5671489239,
0.7976678014,
0.1208873093,
-0.3061019778,
-0.1579599679,
0.4668034315,
-0.1507739425,
-0.2500595748,
0.0956815705,
0.299182862,
-0.3710989058,
0.5005660653,
0.1466720551,
-0.0620244592,
0.1566367745,
0.2316187918,
0.8287024498,
0.2449104488,
-0.2426164448,
-0.5238346457,
0.6579239368,
0.5278864503,
0.0925710946,
1.103936553,
0.294392556,
-0.6893845797,
-0.1795815974,
-0.3868064284,
-0.2393379509,
-0.4413267374,
0.3163098991,
-0.1631180942,
-0.5105843544,
0.3868290484,
0.0752212554,
-0.2802547216,
0.359128058,
0.850091815,
0.1406495273,
1.5529751778,
0.4332986772,
0.4599682987,
0.2153752595,
-0.2087314725,
0.3601023853,
-0.6020230651,
-0.1932626218,
-0.3456703424,
0.2536042631,
-0.6830121279,
-0.3973395526,
0.6371666193,
0.0618380755,
0.3068594635,
0.2034672648,
-0.6235488653,
0.0148019316,
0.4813788533,
0.2805384696,
0.4015191197,
-0.0185354315,
-0.2377810776,
-0.3795276284,
-0.8531703353,
-0.7432807088,
1.3181239367,
0.3703041077,
0.6113135815,
0.0167337526,
0.2960689068,
0.2666358948,
0.5960111618,
-0.4432934225,
0.3384816945,
-0.3665611148,
-0.6451719999,
0.052694086,
-0.2352624387,
-1.0719588995,
0.1584689766,
-0.5756539702,
-0.2934528589,
-0.2161377966,
0.166212827,
-0.4582886994,
-0.000699522,
-0.6097667813,
0.4443683326,
0.055950541,
-0.1461154521,
-0.295085907,
-0.320846945,
0.3985320926,
-0.0752085671,
-0.1153675392,
-0.0518424585,
0.3664230406,
0.6189416647,
-0.753790617,
0.6420450211,
0.0765019655,
0.0325261541,
0.2526343465,
0.0445255153,
0.3886694014,
0.2959155738,
-0.2300039232,
-0.0800586268,
0.0118724471,
-0.4254220128,
-0.5798372626,
0.4832821786,
-0.3770070076,
-0.4671443701,
-0.331989944,
-0.7986697555,
-0.557575345,
-0.0461633094,
0.3571296632,
0.7649944425,
-0.3896541297,
0.1103312448,
0.2280396074,
-0.5207845569,
0.1979155242,
0.4533458352,
-0.1889335066,
-0.502028048,
0.5257984996,
-0.0201882664,
0.6237975955,
0.3301689625,
0.1581069082,
-0.494055599,
-0.9607690573,
-0.3359423578,
0.3295309842,
-0.5030549169,
-0.0457029417,
-0.8952423334,
-0.5706568956,
-0.8106865883,
-0.2833653688,
-0.4747962058,
-0.730499804,
-0.2572336793,
-0.2329650521,
0.5002037883,
0.7635551095,
0.1619528383,
0.5907570124,
-1.0452469587,
0.5334156156,
-0.0173934232,
0.1741192937,
-0.1863917708,
-0.1009312272,
-0.055907879,
0.1738202572,
-0.3658630252,
-0.7402538061,
1.1925470829,
0.2949370444,
0.5146859884,
0.3074455857,
-0.193870604,
0.754463017,
-0.5924603939,
0.8955614567,
0.2813391387,
-0.6639968753,
0.869304359,
-0.6473383904,
0.3167565167,
0.341389209,
0.3304813504,
-0.5249785185,
-0.6366246939,
-0.8384671211,
-0.7330394983,
0.4630696774,
0.5279965401,
0.0133299846,
-0.2244655639,
0.4939244092,
0.2281258553,
0.2915507853,
-0.4455560148,
-0.0970905274,
0.1736557335,
-0.4508269727,
-0.0382963941,
-0.173160404,
-0.2223009318,
-0.4678222835,
0.4345749617,
-0.216557458,
0.4280001223,
0.4555953145,
0.2138307989,
-0.121131137,
0.0641667023,
0.7333905697,
0.8794364929,
-0.1402790695,
-0.0241840295,
0.0946791992,
-0.6849042177,
-0.1531288773,
0.0451703109,
-0.1797370762,
0.2735687792,
0.7519901991,
0.6708394289,
-0.1620990336,
-1.0434777737,
0.0982502848,
-0.1731345803,
-0.1822115481,
-0.4040111303,
0.2953185439,
0.1335030794,
-0.1798073202,
0.0201706011,
0.0678098723,
0.3878281713,
-0.6254550815,
0.3879344165,
0.2643842995,
-0.1622443497,
-0.4242119193,
0.9278351068,
-0.0566338487,
-0.4577743113,
0.9680861235,
0.3690049946,
-0.2892144918,
0.5925782919,
1.1049365997,
0.5909538269,
-0.4233300388,
0.3836635947,
0.418741852,
-0.2611202002,
-0.0622953475,
0.4553458393,
0.3363005221,
-0.6826441288,
-0.4949544668,
-0.649713695,
-0.3830418587,
0.4953626692,
-0.8365412951,
0.3322587907,
-0.3624995947,
-0.4900331795,
0.3544751406,
-0.2941696048,
-0.6106862426,
0.628436923,
0.0410032049,
0.6855811477,
-0.6630327702,
0.9420433044,
0.5255550742,
-0.3242913187,
-0.4490868151,
-0.4583315849,
-0.297070086,
-0.8094368577,
0.643345654,
-0.1991705298,
0.2169364989,
-0.196463421,
-0.2869755924,
-0.5907782912,
0.7161059976,
0.1924508065,
-0.5282753706,
-0.178538844,
0.9263579249,
1.2867558002,
-0.6083859801,
0.2299831659,
0.7633344531,
0.0754968375,
0.1520848125,
-0.8896196485,
-0.0235639829,
-0.4321164191,
0.2554428875,
0.0667053387,
0.0865980983,
0.7691549063,
-0.1685954183,
-0.1605220437,
0.3069265485,
0.3547725379,
0.4170714021,
0.4279030561,
0.0524076372,
0.5652328134,
0.7476371527,
-0.0853006244,
1.5032253265,
-0.2166170031,
0.0186255965,
0.8882930279,
-0.4143988192,
0.7041239738,
0.2299348116,
-0.3383506536,
0.3922312856,
0.304228723,
0.23265405,
0.4180199504,
0.2214146107,
-0.5915792584,
-0.1550580263,
-0.3193453252,
-0.4387881458,
0.4378602803,
0.7478302121,
-0.9039698839,
0.1171169654,
0.0834079534,
-0.0672011822,
0.3147810698,
-0.1066347882,
0.7536728978,
0.1928765774,
-0.7419050932,
0.7378069162,
0.059343908,
0.0468538962,
-0.6502906084,
-0.3694837689,
0.052675195,
0.3495202065,
-0.0986123905,
-0.3998107314,
0.7370722294,
-0.1470643878,
-0.1477000862,
-0.234527871,
0.7668877244,
-0.587249279,
-0.7384238839,
0.0729988366,
0.4367266595,
0.0384711176,
0.1035797298,
-0.5171076059,
-0.1735615581,
-0.2729830146,
0.0402070545,
0.1936285794,
0.0918735489,
-0.1229939386,
0.853168726,
0.9833253026,
0.8020858169,
0.245697394,
0.500874579,
0.6717242599,
-0.7510035634,
-0.4948149621,
-0.6205016971,
0.2638839185,
-0.2619458735,
-0.4410201907,
0.4566471279,
0.7192314863,
0.4451546669,
-0.3074415028,
0.817217648,
0.1136084422,
0.8330728412,
-0.8160572648,
0.6430366635,
-0.2134022862,
0.0481645055,
-0.1756869704,
-0.4471000135,
-0.7812970877,
0.3781895638,
-0.1868528873,
-0.2208985835,
0.7085160613,
0.8887209296,
0.0419742167,
0.3832306564,
0.4822513461,
0.2045183033,
0.752601862,
0.5302336812,
0.728990972,
-0.539953053,
-0.237157926,
-0.4258957505,
0.0440063253,
-0.0456632413,
-0.6434964538,
-0.8122944832,
-0.6154286265,
-0.3980833888,
-0.5196820498,
0.0901264474,
0.7819475532,
0.8688815832,
-1.0244698524,
-0.0092757083,
-0.6972601414,
-0.5557493567,
-0.2336709946,
-0.3093467951,
0.5400564075,
-0.4554139972,
-0.7739697695,
0.6570050716,
0.1130901203,
0.4488953352,
-0.1256071329,
-0.0669786856,
0.0487857498,
0.2860424519,
0.7731955051,
-0.0030466195,
-0.5528265834,
0.1587992907,
-0.0689088702,
-0.1661468744,
0.0978735462,
1.1578066349,
-0.7413163185,
0.7219845653,
0.4129463732,
0.4950205386,
0.4731556773,
0.1722219288,
1.1597667933,
-0.560538888,
0.0950114653,
0.7242888212,
0.2736454606,
0.46023646,
-0.5637847781,
0.6237626672,
0.3032034039,
-0.3617314994,
-0.8878603578,
0.0369385295,
-0.8051349521,
-0.0599675439,
1.1590294838,
0.1522444785,
0.1606228203,
-0.335845083,
-0.3146340549,
0.2721769214,
-0.0081138443,
0.9212312102,
0.5317897201,
-0.7192908525,
0.1623836756,
-1.0530834198,
0.9943680167,
0.4794226885,
-1.0491223335,
-0.0992242023,
0.4538059831,
-0.0130140614,
0.0182153415,
0.7908366323,
-0.5557552576,
0.2711300254,
0.1032814085,
0.0141989961,
0.2543280423,
-0.1332402676,
-0.1352511942,
0.2659616172,
-0.0740734264,
0.1488215476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19509v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19509v1
|
Phonetic Segmentation of the UCLA Phonetics Lab Archive
| 2024-03-28T15:42:07 | 2024-03-28T15:42:07 |
Eleanor Chodroff, Blaž Pažon, Annie Baker, Steven Moran
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Research in speech technologies and comparative linguistics depends on access
to diverse and accessible speech data. The UCLA Phonetics Lab Archive is one of
the earliest multilingual speech corpora, with long-form audio recordings and
phonetic transcriptions for 314 languages (Ladefoged et al., 2009). Recently,
95 of these languages were time-aligned with word-level phonetic transcriptions
(Li et al., 2021). Here we present VoxAngeles, a corpus of audited phonetic
transcriptions and phone-level alignments of the UCLA Phonetics Lab Archive,
which uses the 95-language CMU re-release as our starting point. VoxAngeles
also includes word- and phone-level segmentations from the original UCLA
corpus, as well as phonetic measurements of word and phone durations, vowel
formants, and vowel f0. This corpus enhances the usability of the original
data, particularly for quantitative phonetic typology, as demonstrated through
a case study of vowel intrinsic f0. We also discuss the utility of the
VoxAngeles corpus for general research and pedagogy in crosslinguistic
phonetics, as well as for low-resource and multilingual speech technologies.
VoxAngeles is free to download and use under a CC-BY-NC 4.0 license.
|
[
-0.2571107745,
-0.6178779006,
0.2647349536,
0.2185635418,
-0.194867745,
0.4466888011,
-0.1037202477,
-0.3472139537,
0.4698074162,
0.4377670288,
-0.3157399297,
-0.632883966,
0.0499831773,
0.2495639473,
-0.4575681388,
0.478921473,
0.37794438,
0.3439764977,
0.0487870798,
-0.3272927403,
-0.1542738825,
-0.7225105762,
-0.6768735647,
0.0318315066,
0.96165663,
0.3005394638,
0.490301609,
0.6687325835,
0.0964459181,
0.2676665485,
-0.2170633227,
-0.225570932,
-0.3764164746,
0.002729638,
-0.00191852,
-0.3444213867,
-0.4410920441,
-0.0332800634,
0.9211299419,
1.0598151684,
-0.3063577414,
0.1010352373,
-0.1235499382,
0.4594919086,
-0.3423797786,
-0.22225748,
-0.554496944,
0.1521742493,
-0.6940096021,
-0.2440155894,
-0.3458721042,
-0.4328047931,
0.2447804213,
-0.7128975987,
0.4139835238,
0.0564702079,
0.4684508741,
0.0272274334,
-0.2333447337,
-0.0382369608,
-0.6592846513,
0.8651036024,
-0.2527635396,
1.1395561695,
0.2453375906,
0.3376813233,
-0.1707653999,
-0.6366351247,
-0.372228235,
0.0436825678,
0.2482367605,
-0.0058732135,
-0.4952523112,
-0.0370729454,
0.0658313259,
0.3999881446,
-0.8802481294,
0.4147347212,
-0.9697445631,
-0.6701060534,
0.4312131703,
-0.1259639859,
0.462949127,
-0.2797440588,
-0.1090792492,
-0.4009134173,
-0.7355054617,
0.0069637345,
0.6488262415,
0.3778883815,
-0.1759483069,
0.7505930662,
-0.0242010076,
0.5218529105,
-0.2251012176,
-0.2621839643,
0.6562637091,
-0.2913934886,
-0.2020374686,
0.5051551461,
0.6771470904,
-0.1599654406,
0.0629759431,
-0.2846307456,
0.2553586066,
-0.1624241322,
0.2482642233,
-0.587405324,
-0.2577607334,
0.4237115979,
-0.3372569978,
-0.1210171804,
-0.1515705884,
-0.5705242753,
-0.0118162036,
-0.4704872966,
-0.0293925311,
-0.7721682191,
-0.2860565186,
-0.0387742445,
-0.3268523514,
0.1072010174,
0.2486079037,
-0.650216043,
0.2090159059,
0.604141593,
0.8735272288,
-0.1646817625,
-0.4172180593,
-0.6448742747,
0.0539600737,
-0.3235009015,
0.6911605597,
-0.4950258434,
-0.8976401687,
0.1377950162,
0.2453265637,
-0.1400504112,
-0.7116962075,
0.7034807801,
-0.2478404194,
0.4535513818,
-0.2511078119,
-0.5687711239,
-0.1655158401,
-0.1145015433,
-0.6523959041,
0.9599516988,
0.1421554089,
-0.3706091344,
0.30184111,
-0.4031496048,
-0.3449143469,
0.0892133117,
-0.2547139823,
-0.2276348174,
0.1311544031,
0.143881768,
0.0855413973,
0.1676333249,
-0.0713000968,
-0.2044111639,
-0.060486909,
0.37725088,
-0.4625505507,
1.2954549789,
0.3523735106,
0.093173638,
0.3570613861,
-1.0467628241,
0.0647058934,
-0.0996152461,
-0.500406146,
-0.2103074938,
-0.010693768,
-0.0261970405,
-0.2478913814,
-0.003639566,
-0.9361028075,
0.0694560707,
-0.0855353624,
0.3424005806,
0.2956430316,
-0.206337437,
0.4501362443,
-0.3409185112,
0.6364177465,
0.0091125797,
0.1012821719,
0.0445380025,
-0.5719206929,
-0.3377296329,
-0.5353602171,
0.446246177,
0.519243598,
-0.3701187968,
0.1738466471,
-0.3267359138,
-0.5423028469,
-0.741925478,
0.0068698768,
0.1974840611,
0.5268204212,
0.5792869925,
-0.2420250326,
-0.5078367591,
-0.7327885032,
0.143217355,
-0.2422466129,
-0.2276633829,
0.0926063508,
-0.2393883318,
-0.0167596284,
0.6624041796,
-0.0895894617,
-0.1672381908,
-0.1533344686,
0.1330114305,
-0.02055059,
0.3557822704,
0.6334282756,
-0.5584142804,
-0.0169576928,
-0.1315395236,
-0.3602986932,
-0.2185586542,
0.3624781966,
-0.1073527709,
0.1469836682,
0.6215958595,
-0.3170805573,
0.1860169917,
0.6032625437,
-0.106457673,
0.5652062893,
-0.0515554696,
-0.0077548558,
-0.8790242672,
0.1181810796,
-0.1329798251,
-0.1736858338,
-0.59723562,
-0.5199580193,
0.0807573348,
-0.277757287,
-0.8700729012,
0.4578225017,
-0.6286334395,
-0.3223998249,
0.0887908116,
0.2629530132,
0.0693791956,
0.1257901639,
0.1838454902,
0.7354432344,
0.4041992426,
-0.3771497309,
0.1300472766,
0.138530761,
-0.2924485207,
0.5966601372,
-0.5467888713,
0.0928823352,
0.0541172028,
0.3191010356,
-0.670199275,
-0.0724240988,
0.1167469993,
-0.4817759693,
0.2887849212,
-0.4000425041,
-0.0702031478,
-0.2340147644,
-0.3871711493,
0.8024938703,
0.3974859118,
-0.4153880477,
0.1058349088,
0.8689160347,
-0.3273164034,
-0.4549874365,
-0.4768463671,
0.066366151,
-0.2801248729,
-0.4970355034,
0.2971154451,
-0.0324602164,
-0.3736403584,
-0.0168839153,
0.1085908115,
-0.2329959422,
-0.140939936,
0.1756912023,
0.2265160829,
-0.5410471559,
-0.0256649293,
0.0906859636,
0.2092580944,
0.0321992263,
-0.4053624272,
0.6084386706,
0.1233869344,
-0.2885911763,
-0.4441586435,
0.3455767334,
0.5480909944,
-0.1196074188,
0.2615152895,
0.7586029768,
-0.4348343313,
0.0531126894,
-0.7241483331,
0.0150820287,
-0.3746148944,
0.1320631057,
-0.3527350426,
-0.9191395044,
0.3401845992,
0.3853132427,
0.0708091855,
0.427097708,
0.2759716213,
-0.1388105005,
0.6320433617,
0.1807252616,
-0.3300746679,
0.5978772044,
-0.2102372199,
-0.0492179394,
-1.0592790842,
-0.3579342663,
-0.7990778685,
-0.1883726269,
-0.4749719501,
-0.5643796921,
0.1593678743,
-0.1192113459,
0.3544160724,
0.1830265671,
-0.5673367381,
0.3531861901,
0.579033792,
-0.1649262458,
0.1793343276,
0.3265692592,
-0.1964648962,
-0.0776762813,
-0.5961999297,
-0.3760356605,
0.9860826731,
0.3622610569,
0.4332492948,
0.2755894363,
0.9964635968,
0.2466321737,
-0.1429946274,
-0.8903259635,
0.4495949447,
-0.2907294333,
-0.5062823296,
-0.5255651474,
-0.4251892269,
-1.4279354811,
0.3757024109,
0.0952489898,
-0.9679414034,
0.5346994996,
0.0139523689,
-0.4120489955,
0.1375115216,
-0.6480118036,
0.7792457342,
-0.2785016,
-0.0650152564,
-0.2442654967,
-0.4741936028,
0.1574361473,
0.0975909084,
0.3183338642,
-0.2473089695,
0.1674625725,
1.0985310078,
-0.496752739,
0.6719178557,
-0.0507312939,
-0.180817917,
0.4926478863,
0.1456273794,
-0.3578787744,
-0.0710487142,
0.0213987939,
0.449893266,
0.4338956475,
-0.2785084248,
-0.0374027453,
0.7762654424,
-0.7199636698,
-0.3785405457,
-0.2988107204,
-0.413551569,
-0.1469388008,
0.4169622958,
0.2996278107,
0.8453850746,
-0.6993982792,
0.4107590914,
0.5436199307,
-0.187414214,
0.3924493194,
0.2526990473,
-0.4609125257,
-0.4886997044,
1.1405535936,
0.2603515387,
-0.0611564703,
0.4687763453,
0.4366897047,
-0.6792353392,
-0.8263271451,
-0.6013125181,
0.3579673469,
-0.2506160438,
0.098318167,
-0.6558927298,
-0.2301309705,
-0.7991843224,
-0.0279215481,
-0.4443047643,
-0.9065204859,
-0.3891921639,
-0.1270143688,
0.0758933872,
0.6244192719,
-0.510133028,
0.0137031134,
-0.9658269286,
0.4255972803,
0.22200571,
-0.2662649751,
-0.3177021444,
-0.4073907435,
0.0003348769,
0.2283437103,
-0.253207922,
-0.7208533883,
0.3249020576,
0.1926784068,
0.6341154575,
0.296443224,
-0.2498048246,
0.4941858947,
-0.4697435796,
0.8566021919,
0.199206084,
-0.742353797,
0.3580635786,
-0.5230533481,
0.3923234046,
0.4917512536,
0.22402215,
-0.6816506982,
-0.5025894642,
-0.6446583867,
-0.8005331755,
0.5492709875,
0.1774223447,
-0.1586105525,
-0.1781030446,
-0.1038667858,
0.2516000271,
0.0574632883,
-0.0935793594,
-0.0476033054,
-0.3775625527,
-0.2980918586,
0.0445710048,
-0.1952051073,
-0.3984484375,
-0.2125453055,
0.6154369116,
0.0530620366,
0.0609262437,
0.3007457256,
-0.3592021167,
0.0551277138,
0.4975188673,
0.850728631,
0.9126620889,
-0.3316537142,
0.2401119769,
0.0621037856,
-0.9141730666,
0.0819500759,
0.2081143856,
-0.0116490908,
0.3499792516,
0.3146218061,
0.4788666964,
0.3183164597,
-0.422355473,
0.1633760035,
-0.2035291344,
-0.225282222,
-0.3719073534,
-0.0352256633,
0.2985103726,
0.0776932463,
0.2949880958,
-0.4682086408,
0.181841895,
-0.7095050216,
0.1370752454,
0.2345431447,
-0.2789616883,
-0.5607732534,
0.5921989679,
0.268224746,
-0.5254696608,
0.7080030441,
0.0131320572,
-0.3449862897,
0.3526376188,
0.271976918,
0.8915429711,
-0.4906205535,
0.3850443661,
0.4329121113,
0.0173361395,
0.1989561319,
0.4188558161,
-0.1351778805,
-0.6377916932,
-0.0753718838,
-0.743226409,
-0.5795014501,
0.1161990538,
-0.6431849599,
0.1360704601,
-0.3871834576,
-0.2117946297,
0.295931071,
-0.3014072478,
-0.6822258234,
0.2234837562,
0.4804516733,
0.8621176481,
-0.3577442169,
1.0466136932,
0.4595591724,
0.0004945238,
-0.7014911175,
-0.4302278161,
0.4363537729,
-0.8236601949,
0.5403364301,
-0.0671115965,
-0.3068782091,
-0.0201969333,
0.0081939101,
-0.7989627123,
0.8319122791,
0.271230042,
-0.7573338747,
0.0136552677,
0.4590143859,
0.4716745913,
-0.1706118435,
0.0230204333,
0.5652044415,
0.2542580962,
-0.0514947362,
-1.056994319,
-0.2927028835,
-0.0113448482,
-0.4429163337,
0.2363408655,
-0.3379238844,
0.6009687185,
-0.0442650467,
-0.4171801209,
0.0878256634,
0.791164279,
0.327450037,
0.2969634235,
0.5450322032,
0.6905382276,
1.1653953791,
-0.1536562294,
0.6971095204,
-0.0647400767,
-0.1167516932,
1.0516091585,
-0.1446311027,
0.9347260594,
0.5867853165,
-0.3838030696,
0.3150509596,
0.6262412667,
0.1630976796,
0.1371643841,
0.2350948453,
-0.2516647577,
0.1752722412,
-0.3909786642,
-0.5797036886,
0.5616338849,
0.47995314,
0.0151943322,
-0.0302584432,
-0.24921453,
0.1204343736,
-0.4012064636,
-0.024188526,
0.5352703333,
0.1109088957,
-0.4308792353,
0.5269551277,
-0.5049251318,
0.144112736,
-0.5246322155,
0.227379784,
-0.0843876526,
-0.0777683109,
-0.1914100945,
-0.8390657902,
0.2363532037,
-0.133730799,
0.0562026054,
-0.053755939,
0.3458585143,
-0.5550448298,
-0.6056755781,
0.2834991217,
0.6680032611,
0.4258411229,
0.171196416,
-0.4371108413,
0.3195410669,
-0.0351490751,
0.0308680255,
0.1904246211,
0.3926237226,
-0.1270607114,
0.3052787185,
0.7950379252,
0.383479327,
0.6024099588,
0.64287889,
0.4088218212,
-0.6352424026,
-0.4768736064,
-0.4233075082,
0.3110238612,
-0.175570935,
-0.508108139,
0.7414055467,
1.0924106836,
1.049690485,
0.1321004629,
0.7638489604,
0.1378608793,
0.7541942,
-0.8220800757,
0.526171267,
-0.4597201347,
0.0678725019,
-0.133833304,
-1.1975768805,
-0.2446932048,
0.3745150864,
-0.078207776,
-0.429728359,
0.7608341575,
0.5538141727,
-0.2780009806,
0.170740366,
0.383544296,
-0.0183948614,
0.3396918178,
-0.0013505692,
0.8525784612,
0.0544570796,
0.595397532,
-0.7603753805,
-0.0314162113,
-0.1473959237,
-0.5212544799,
-0.5604713559,
-0.7280519009,
-0.3872433007,
-0.148034811,
-0.0378809497,
0.6856504679,
0.6218905449,
-0.7842395306,
-0.695884645,
0.3260163963,
0.1911361963,
0.1770517379,
-0.2452473789,
0.3734915257,
-0.1335584968,
-0.8437587619,
1.171041131,
0.2672287226,
0.332480818,
-0.162471056,
0.1169858128,
-0.0204048045,
-0.1157222986,
0.4570468962,
0.8577303886,
-0.6488873959,
-0.3497451544,
0.2667703927,
0.114791356,
0.3631908,
1.1104593277,
-0.518743813,
0.44336465,
0.5859546065,
0.2990409136,
0.3217258453,
-0.0643217266,
0.609366715,
-0.5894001722,
0.3546235263,
0.3542863131,
0.7752344012,
0.5882652998,
-0.0249231625,
0.4181030989,
0.2922091186,
-0.5110117793,
-0.9114807844,
-0.1099473462,
-1.5042406321,
-0.1565959007,
1.0922403336,
0.1283484548,
-0.4970502257,
-0.3085868657,
-0.3477836847,
0.3431159258,
-0.5922073126,
0.5510648489,
0.5621635318,
-0.2430816144,
-0.1018257588,
-0.2506202757,
0.4598810375,
0.3321928084,
-0.6002670527,
-0.1488792151,
0.7888373733,
0.3127453625,
0.4929336011,
0.7124311328,
-0.2546836734,
0.1285531819,
0.0204703473,
-0.0066227647,
0.1220563948,
-0.5126959682,
-0.2525316477,
0.2184347361,
-0.035760656,
-0.5395635962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19454v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19454v1
|
JDocQA: Japanese Document Question Answering Dataset for Generative Language Models
| 2024-03-28T14:22:54 | 2024-03-28T14:22:54 |
Eri Onami, Shuhei Kurita, Taiki Miyanishi, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Document question answering is a task of question answering on given
documents such as reports, slides, pamphlets, and websites, and it is a truly
demanding task as paper and electronic forms of documents are so common in our
society. This is known as a quite challenging task because it requires not only
text understanding but also understanding of figures and tables, and hence
visual question answering (VQA) methods are often examined in addition to
textual approaches. We introduce Japanese Document Question Answering (JDocQA),
a large-scale document-based QA dataset, essentially requiring both visual and
textual information to answer questions, which comprises 5,504 documents in PDF
format and annotated 11,600 question-and-answer instances in Japanese. Each QA
instance includes references to the document pages and bounding boxes for the
answer clues. We incorporate multiple categories of questions and unanswerable
questions from the document for realistic question-answering applications. We
empirically evaluate the effectiveness of our dataset with text-based large
language models (LLMs) and multimodal models. Incorporating unanswerable
questions in finetuning may contribute to harnessing the so-called
hallucination generation.
|
[
-0.5495346189,
-1.3288894892,
0.834410131,
-0.1606406868,
-0.4372946918,
-0.035255786,
0.0076913759,
-0.2776282132,
-0.0699495599,
1.0110163689,
-0.8240481615,
-0.7817178965,
-0.2518559992,
0.2788475454,
-0.352165252,
0.6491814256,
-0.3331148624,
0.1717100441,
-0.7426236868,
-0.1340108216,
-0.6193209887,
-0.1959658712,
-0.5381528139,
-0.0053966795,
0.2410603017,
0.5331619978,
0.6511879563,
0.2920332253,
0.4943313599,
0.3148124516,
0.2022417188,
0.1953122467,
-0.1914400905,
0.2815721929,
0.1152097955,
-0.8821042776,
-0.0447813906,
-0.2106630653,
0.6655685306,
0.9038289785,
-0.0131384023,
0.3056215942,
-0.1616366059,
0.4649651051,
-0.5803411603,
0.1936480552,
-0.6217115521,
0.2574751675,
-0.1469951272,
-0.2811456323,
-0.3278256357,
-0.3758819699,
-0.1471779197,
-1.1719142199,
0.3001053035,
-0.0559729859,
0.801995039,
0.3037161529,
-0.3761313558,
-0.643361032,
-0.5267400742,
0.4737918973,
-0.5503498316,
0.2331931889,
0.7037227154,
0.3099731803,
-0.1986325681,
-0.5880014896,
-0.8766574264,
-0.1543528289,
0.0583892241,
0.5194492936,
0.2602957487,
0.1429701149,
0.549392879,
0.533816576,
-0.9280973673,
-0.1487561911,
-0.193807438,
-0.1783947051,
0.3869404495,
0.3574953675,
0.7694128752,
-0.4321252108,
-0.1647106707,
-0.2885695398,
-0.2668568492,
0.0709008351,
0.1359958053,
0.1962148249,
0.0891165212,
0.8791392446,
-0.3924044967,
0.7157205939,
-0.1278970391,
-0.2972387671,
-0.0311271045,
-0.3476531506,
-0.1198298708,
-0.0741027668,
0.813300252,
0.3615647256,
0.0958370715,
0.0206148103,
0.0451815054,
-0.0603754073,
0.3226203918,
-0.6678618789,
-0.0220867079,
0.341943711,
-0.336383909,
-0.1238600388,
-0.0468441397,
-1.1871315241,
-0.4215938151,
-0.2125461102,
0.5290019512,
-0.4167416096,
-0.0265323184,
-0.0833118185,
-0.2445736229,
0.5768905282,
0.5752833486,
-0.783844471,
0.2113945633,
0.4459020197,
0.6718667746,
0.0651601106,
-0.2258583754,
-0.4309640527,
-0.0431770384,
-0.5993776321,
0.6181287766,
-0.5734974742,
-0.7005170584,
0.1007150039,
0.2698002756,
-0.0925442204,
-0.4844533801,
0.5288643837,
-0.6826792955,
0.5546272993,
-0.4573141932,
-0.581585288,
-0.2249063551,
0.4733389914,
-0.7892736197,
0.9997320175,
0.1369903237,
-0.6776986122,
0.1615963578,
-0.4918629229,
-0.2636462748,
0.3053277433,
-0.3531508446,
-0.392475158,
0.0675773621,
0.6396910548,
0.3460761011,
-0.5642260909,
0.2070176899,
-0.2693837285,
-0.3816854358,
0.4931148589,
-0.7237792015,
0.7045412064,
0.2648783922,
-0.2273773551,
-0.3034066558,
-0.8975912333,
0.1523471624,
0.4951261878,
-0.2260922045,
-0.6751218438,
-0.4028110802,
0.0469044484,
0.1820355356,
0.2815390229,
-0.5424655676,
0.2977052629,
-0.1101369634,
-0.0113093378,
0.4365311861,
0.3452028632,
0.0934463292,
-0.2447794825,
0.9966770411,
-0.0230777245,
0.1808957607,
-0.391166985,
-0.6387192607,
-0.7610934973,
0.1116033569,
0.0787499771,
0.4976247549,
-1.4962060452,
0.0312523171,
-0.019099772,
-0.6064627767,
-0.8242612481,
-0.0137422523,
0.4413627982,
0.839564085,
0.3344896436,
-0.3816479146,
-0.1792773902,
-0.6739107966,
0.2390472442,
-0.4803235531,
-0.0921363533,
0.3863136172,
0.5043851733,
0.0521033742,
0.6358969808,
-0.59278965,
-0.0864036977,
-0.0314554498,
0.3045505583,
0.0002709854,
-0.0340105034,
0.1820082515,
-1.0488379002,
-0.1998749822,
0.0286586136,
-1.1608332396,
-0.0654996559,
-0.4957128763,
-0.1232211068,
0.1084343344,
0.5502215028,
-0.6271669269,
0.1214450151,
0.4516275227,
-0.0525055379,
0.5748950243,
-0.1430687457,
0.4657598436,
-1.4217939377,
0.3379799128,
-0.2052681148,
0.009285301,
-0.6640211344,
0.4985821247,
0.1216482967,
-0.5680946708,
-0.4445346594,
0.5259414911,
-0.4601388872,
-0.2766545117,
-0.1931287646,
0.4416823089,
0.3027881086,
0.6107137799,
0.19795084,
1.1206531525,
0.3759395778,
-0.3896170855,
0.3976755738,
0.647503674,
-0.4461289942,
0.5937449932,
-0.5411953926,
0.2069989443,
-0.4197444022,
0.0436867885,
-1.1923145056,
-0.3947765231,
0.3058859408,
-0.5088812113,
0.1569002867,
-0.0667439997,
-0.4434740543,
-0.5583286285,
-0.2012381256,
0.358196795,
0.2131493986,
-0.4920885861,
0.6413801312,
0.3446023464,
-0.3152270615,
-0.8086493015,
-0.5300640464,
0.0298338532,
-0.0955715254,
-0.2423353344,
-0.1640848219,
-0.2591179907,
0.0406382903,
0.0788663998,
0.0088441698,
-0.2661213577,
0.1657720953,
0.4218015075,
0.5710169673,
-0.3401300907,
0.1137285084,
0.2185273767,
0.0634080768,
0.1133917272,
0.0095104408,
0.693580091,
0.0625445992,
-0.4046756625,
-0.430727005,
0.5964285135,
0.7683415413,
-0.2558274269,
0.5814068913,
0.5346115828,
-0.4297177792,
0.0677826256,
-0.3995437026,
0.1505149156,
-0.4407786727,
0.5203146338,
-0.7487393618,
-0.8706202507,
0.6801755428,
0.0564668626,
-0.0108950259,
0.5269163847,
0.6499987841,
-0.2699182332,
0.983286202,
0.3332450688,
0.0399216451,
0.1014095768,
-0.047860872,
-0.1428255737,
-0.7750814557,
-0.339081794,
-0.6292749643,
0.3408875763,
-0.6666107178,
-0.4838868976,
0.3552163243,
0.1457294822,
0.1533144414,
0.240153566,
-0.3771928251,
0.5792793036,
0.3588540256,
-0.068837136,
0.5003686547,
-0.1919133812,
-0.0898857266,
0.2107284963,
-0.6624452472,
-0.4706493616,
1.1896934509,
0.2352405936,
0.7300387621,
-0.0673281625,
0.5202999115,
-0.0433775596,
0.1357371062,
-0.8212710619,
0.6729986072,
-0.0809687823,
-0.8160023689,
-0.6625932455,
-0.5721775889,
-0.9049386978,
0.2304995358,
-0.2275271565,
-0.469235301,
0.1956725419,
-0.058725182,
-0.096392706,
0.144201681,
-0.4516422153,
0.8793778419,
-0.112491861,
-0.0510088243,
0.2692545652,
-0.5902410746,
0.4939443171,
-0.2533296347,
0.1271894276,
-0.0104466174,
0.0791700035,
0.8195284605,
-0.3631139994,
0.6734862924,
-0.075020127,
-0.2513444424,
0.4976567924,
-0.0189978052,
0.4234198928,
0.1866984367,
0.043396648,
0.0574678592,
0.3950409293,
-0.358263135,
-0.7599737644,
0.6391872168,
-0.895817697,
-0.5543370843,
-0.3384708762,
-0.5566108823,
-0.3871531785,
0.3727695644,
0.4810831845,
0.4329947531,
-0.3599035442,
0.1148843318,
0.8892844915,
-0.4333887398,
0.0751310438,
0.3971201181,
-0.286773622,
-0.3136123121,
0.8663967848,
0.1286963671,
0.4066583216,
0.6026365161,
-0.1768407524,
-0.5070479512,
-0.4526970088,
-0.841964066,
0.3646399677,
-0.9869557023,
-0.0067276657,
-0.6360273957,
-0.3011703789,
-0.192299217,
-0.1006038487,
-0.2286900729,
-0.2585511804,
-0.2647968829,
0.0433973595,
-0.0667921826,
0.3532366455,
0.5635989308,
0.0076779616,
-0.7246446013,
0.8553843498,
0.6168418527,
0.221218124,
-0.0735313594,
-0.3129223287,
-0.0190900248,
0.1275820881,
-0.1269031465,
-1.0453464985,
0.2084937245,
-0.0621523373,
0.4716910422,
0.2155218124,
0.1968770027,
0.6485140324,
-0.281512022,
0.8389294147,
0.1433586478,
-0.674811542,
0.5720092654,
-0.4188842177,
0.6076040864,
0.9680857658,
0.7614116073,
-0.8917743564,
-0.563011229,
-0.4568543434,
-0.6874588132,
0.5210030675,
0.2082314044,
0.2196406871,
-0.0131520741,
0.5572491884,
0.2835512757,
0.2994438112,
-0.5952621698,
-0.1947497576,
-0.4135560393,
-0.4329465926,
-0.1458826512,
-0.0245315153,
-0.062212985,
0.0691312179,
0.5762283206,
-0.4117823243,
0.3297717571,
0.253485173,
-0.2598277926,
-0.2242411226,
0.393109262,
0.3011176586,
0.4577555954,
-0.2797450125,
-0.0025656349,
0.2147399634,
-0.6889171004,
0.2066195905,
0.1358100176,
-0.5834123492,
0.0479102768,
0.2933243811,
0.9040239453,
-0.3876996338,
-0.9441354275,
0.4801833928,
-0.5009255409,
-0.4378617704,
-0.5408425927,
0.152806595,
-0.131821081,
-0.1181969568,
0.2566649914,
-0.5719389319,
0.3018432558,
-0.8872386217,
0.0684451088,
0.3876372576,
-0.5611165762,
0.1356571019,
0.7260434628,
-0.0530239567,
0.0531041101,
0.8302663565,
0.0487246625,
-0.2435109019,
0.8775808215,
0.5675656796,
0.5776238441,
-0.0501486398,
0.6290910244,
0.458150655,
0.3287248313,
0.1633248031,
0.3092808723,
-0.1928969026,
-0.7358478904,
-0.3002532125,
-0.7275499701,
-0.7701234221,
0.4791494906,
-0.9086042643,
0.0279045943,
-0.4940529466,
0.0552134514,
0.1792255491,
0.0999180302,
-0.577174902,
0.5646750331,
0.2492527068,
0.5695663691,
-0.968888998,
0.6287879348,
0.665899992,
-0.7673841119,
-0.6539325714,
0.2800281346,
-0.1194684803,
-0.8689783812,
0.0926355049,
0.1015329733,
0.1652477533,
0.0457892157,
-0.5553023815,
-0.7771500945,
1.1784753799,
0.1213120297,
-0.5398702025,
-0.0183349606,
0.6085543633,
0.6185156703,
-0.1107461452,
0.3691366613,
0.457283169,
0.4009971321,
0.1397760808,
-0.418621093,
0.1829184145,
-0.625062108,
0.1764422208,
0.1902377009,
-0.5973630548,
0.3136450946,
-0.0229708944,
-0.3151595891,
0.4693780541,
0.5428164005,
0.3876364529,
0.5437458754,
0.5060572624,
0.4331252277,
0.9146903753,
-0.1688061953,
1.216078043,
0.0971738845,
0.0348101668,
1.1423596144,
-0.1768976599,
0.7669177651,
0.4203680754,
-0.1130009815,
0.3278577626,
0.6905122995,
-0.0891113505,
0.3228561282,
0.0056429878,
-0.1700754464,
-0.3282927871,
-0.3522538245,
-0.4190606475,
0.5392612219,
0.4032752514,
-0.0516047031,
0.0521686785,
0.3903850615,
-0.089818351,
0.0926489606,
-0.1898500919,
0.9231129289,
-0.0351675153,
-0.8168592453,
0.4750131369,
-0.0596679188,
0.0374338776,
-0.5906026363,
-0.0452976227,
-0.5102741122,
-0.4603210092,
0.2257075757,
-1.0973063707,
0.0015853592,
0.0776091963,
-0.1598610729,
0.2735487521,
0.540459156,
-0.5845840573,
-0.6454369426,
-0.0956065431,
0.4860762656,
0.2055862099,
0.0531744547,
-0.7694450617,
-0.2888774574,
-0.1118095368,
-0.218347773,
0.2895037532,
0.5287077427,
-0.2257835418,
0.7403833866,
0.6994721293,
-0.2294917405,
-0.0462875441,
0.3124758899,
0.8650419712,
-0.5167414546,
-0.3935803473,
-0.1974337399,
0.404938519,
-0.0213402137,
-0.4708374441,
0.6919853687,
0.4384734035,
0.8290655017,
-0.1915456206,
0.8212158084,
0.06751398,
0.2694502771,
-0.959916532,
0.6304744482,
-0.8795394301,
-0.0546195507,
-0.5624827147,
-1.0294194221,
-0.3556120694,
0.187067613,
-0.191360414,
-0.0987029448,
0.6946435571,
0.8506146669,
0.1659858972,
0.1501533091,
0.5835441947,
0.123656936,
0.1356367469,
0.6548346877,
1.0033789873,
-0.7161942124,
0.5727761388,
-0.3808027804,
0.0329517126,
-0.0944112092,
-0.2103125453,
-0.8975790739,
-1.0293670893,
-0.3194491565,
-0.1592114121,
0.085923098,
0.5917471647,
0.1690094322,
-0.7875050902,
0.0073170727,
-0.0555451103,
-0.0232668743,
-0.0168470722,
-0.2294366807,
0.5682426691,
-0.1483377665,
-0.7842714787,
0.1597147286,
0.2125960439,
0.23838301,
-0.1186563596,
0.0664912239,
-0.1222191453,
0.1612549722,
0.3487029672,
0.4996750057,
-0.5415725708,
-0.0356840566,
0.210264504,
-0.1495693922,
0.0798669904,
0.6018562317,
-0.3251411915,
0.9295843244,
0.4849731028,
0.8545203209,
0.6219793558,
0.209629938,
0.2862330079,
-0.6408896446,
0.1204494536,
0.1217638329,
0.3007055521,
0.3406513929,
-0.4273924232,
0.325648278,
0.1486828923,
-0.3769922256,
-0.5091507435,
0.0182978828,
-1.1868505478,
-0.5944288969,
0.8523371816,
-0.0729367435,
-0.4832905531,
-0.2892952263,
-0.4377349317,
0.3840002418,
-0.0367754512,
0.9080610871,
0.8886483908,
0.3215630054,
-0.6518381834,
-0.7228380442,
0.222063303,
0.4815874994,
-1.3951354027,
0.1549865752,
0.6352177262,
-0.0620514639,
0.2344235778,
0.8643074632,
-0.3095751703,
0.6181089878,
0.1321883947,
0.149208039,
0.0127104707,
-0.366008997,
-0.3305926621,
0.4466556311,
0.1776916236,
-0.1967449784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19443v1
|
Mixed Preference Optimization: Reinforcement Learning with Data Selection and Better Reference Model
| 2024-03-28T14:15:10 | 2024-03-28T14:15:10 |
Qi Gou, Cam-Tu Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become increasingly popular due to their
ability to process and generate natural language. However, as they are trained
on massive datasets of text, LLMs can inherit harmful biases and produce
outputs that are not aligned with human values. This paper studies two main
approaches to LLM alignment: Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF)
and contrastive learning-based methods like Direct Preference Optimization
(DPO). By analyzing the stability and robustness of RLHF and DPO, we propose
MPO (Mixed Preference Optimization), a novel method that mitigates the
weaknesses of both approaches. Specifically, we propose a two-stage training
procedure: first train DPO on an easy dataset, and then perform RLHF on a
difficult set with DPO model being the reference model. Here, the easy and
difficult sets are constructed by a well-trained reward model that splits
response pairs into those with large gaps of reward (easy), and those with
small gaps (difficult). The first stage allows us to obtain a relatively
optimal policy (LLM) model quickly, whereas the second stage refines LLM with
online RLHF, thus mitigating the distribution shift issue associated with DPO.
Experiments are conducted on two public alignment datasets, namely HH-RLHF and
TLDR, demonstrating the effectiveness of MPO, both in terms of GPT4 and human
evaluation.
|
[
-0.3283776343,
-0.4038096666,
0.5554580688,
0.0104609812,
-0.3409825563,
0.1411052346,
-0.3554010093,
-0.1552331895,
-0.1590254754,
0.5887574553,
-0.7668014765,
-0.1734611392,
-0.4448999465,
0.1719822437,
0.3659569323,
1.1036425829,
-0.2111302167,
0.1996020377,
-0.2671153247,
-0.1162990481,
-0.3551370502,
-0.5417964458,
-0.6342030764,
-0.877831161,
0.6136931181,
0.5167856216,
0.8341454864,
0.9473791718,
0.3846462071,
0.223944962,
-0.1253249794,
0.4081438184,
-0.711591661,
0.1576668173,
-0.1917108893,
-0.3300101459,
-0.0557981916,
0.0094258431,
0.4998022616,
0.3826209903,
-0.4691262543,
-0.3575651944,
0.0633166581,
0.9308642745,
-0.7688838243,
-0.0387835167,
-0.634160161,
0.1259129643,
0.1758517474,
-0.155259192,
-0.3449404836,
-0.5253347158,
0.3035902083,
-0.7029672861,
-0.3013068736,
0.1470525712,
0.8955023885,
0.5129616857,
-0.4624651074,
-0.2203044891,
-0.7399843335,
1.2284579277,
-0.6030543447,
0.391508311,
0.2944477499,
0.2329642326,
-0.3647952974,
-0.1343068928,
-0.6525810957,
-0.3871010542,
0.0005718717,
0.230233103,
0.3859112263,
0.1398258954,
-0.078763105,
0.3119901717,
-0.2607808113,
0.4870121777,
0.0386448987,
-0.1346854866,
0.6081910133,
0.0276338365,
-0.010368607,
-0.0710501447,
-0.6159248948,
-0.4458320141,
-0.6263997555,
0.1063411534,
0.6314699054,
0.3695641458,
-0.0236868095,
0.3998356462,
-0.13923949,
0.5647915006,
0.2430886328,
-0.6635822058,
0.2184160501,
-0.0513207577,
0.0287623759,
-0.0081250053,
0.829608202,
0.3724613786,
0.3522082567,
-0.1368042976,
-0.393488884,
0.124148272,
0.1766112745,
-0.53169626,
0.1245780662,
0.2854477167,
-0.3696736097,
-0.5769768953,
-0.1157328188,
-0.7908295989,
-0.4915129244,
-0.6458871365,
0.1390458494,
-0.1495075226,
-0.1411945671,
0.0543210059,
0.2717326283,
0.2011331469,
0.3183921874,
-1.1947568655,
0.3669485152,
0.7981566191,
0.4866027236,
-0.6575778723,
-0.4119438827,
-0.64785254,
0.2040255368,
-0.2226854712,
0.5201782584,
-0.602265656,
-0.3448490798,
0.1394275725,
-0.3545287549,
-0.0183667261,
-0.7705811858,
0.8822233677,
-0.6873959899,
0.4906803966,
-0.1579902768,
-0.4280908704,
0.0683742464,
0.3245546818,
-0.6248300076,
1.1402696371,
-0.0005149373,
-0.8795662522,
0.4311385751,
-0.4102802575,
-0.2275424451,
-0.505389154,
-0.2754439712,
-0.7303430438,
-0.2076512873,
0.2935685217,
0.2383969426,
-0.1493472755,
0.4757723212,
-0.5077387094,
-0.3948194087,
0.3017990589,
-0.1253248602,
0.3877610862,
0.3065054715,
-0.2052305192,
0.4487011135,
-0.7242245078,
-0.2115118802,
0.1669469476,
-0.7209022045,
-0.2500707507,
0.4216195643,
-0.187048614,
0.4593758881,
0.194631502,
-0.4027059674,
0.326490432,
-0.4305949211,
0.4470160306,
1.0752923489,
-0.1073929742,
0.6404191256,
-0.4246845543,
0.4285300672,
0.1088637337,
0.2806904316,
0.4780512452,
-0.1129632518,
-0.7068344355,
-0.0708026066,
0.3128722608,
0.7245892286,
-0.879966259,
0.5657507777,
-0.1134771854,
0.1179060414,
-0.4584692419,
0.2146281451,
0.4267872274,
0.657235086,
0.2479105145,
-0.1123571992,
-0.3115002513,
-0.9692077637,
0.0803480297,
-0.1685875505,
0.1478932947,
0.516027689,
0.2480154634,
-0.3282565475,
0.8340163231,
-0.6667521,
0.0338062085,
-0.1781729609,
-0.0265328605,
0.1678298563,
0.2862084806,
0.1916495264,
-0.8317992687,
-0.4265782237,
0.133411631,
-0.2478622794,
-0.0784421116,
0.022174187,
-0.2669147551,
0.2082654685,
0.0225466602,
-0.2043460906,
-0.2300825715,
0.6487078071,
0.1276521832,
0.3328533173,
-0.2772979438,
0.0862383321,
-0.9647400379,
-0.1429615021,
0.0862781629,
-0.2812526524,
-0.4213724136,
-0.2055646181,
-0.0076643396,
-0.1038741618,
-0.345173955,
0.5093685985,
-0.2838159204,
0.0557324365,
-0.4332898855,
0.0697396547,
-0.2364085764,
0.7845584154,
0.3411125541,
0.7683891058,
0.1874510199,
-0.6639690399,
0.310988456,
0.2170989662,
-0.0420390069,
0.4049588442,
-0.384382695,
0.4329686761,
-0.1943572015,
0.1177439988,
-0.7809342742,
-0.1345278174,
0.4795413911,
-0.0708566159,
0.4083530009,
-0.0167420842,
-0.3177458346,
-0.126192525,
-0.5368788242,
0.2768516243,
0.3389157653,
-0.7005659938,
0.1260081232,
0.4309312701,
-0.117870912,
-0.9429277778,
-0.2095266879,
-0.3943428695,
-0.4057766497,
-0.3503070474,
0.4172556996,
-0.1069880128,
-0.2597932518,
-0.2483138591,
-0.1685957015,
-0.0706766844,
0.0082968706,
-0.0611110143,
0.4436147213,
0.2816389501,
0.1349235475,
-0.0432540439,
-0.3569953144,
-0.3247267604,
-0.0920615643,
0.4659639299,
0.1174962744,
-0.0409284458,
-0.227845788,
0.2417657524,
0.3128996193,
-0.1062528491,
0.5954875946,
0.2612615824,
0.0247934926,
-0.3211370111,
-0.3857912123,
-0.2362536192,
-0.4632267952,
0.2706985474,
-0.2288327962,
-0.8599044085,
0.0798650607,
-0.2158398181,
0.0864161775,
0.0290421266,
0.5245265365,
0.0701664835,
1.0418894291,
0.5560478568,
-0.3740746677,
0.7803694606,
0.2005636543,
-0.0269067623,
-0.6729334593,
-0.1139413118,
-0.4227478504,
-0.3381831646,
-0.8531143665,
-0.3126625419,
0.1811369956,
0.2071162909,
-0.3610243201,
0.0227114391,
-0.4782355726,
0.5359802246,
0.6245706081,
0.3795951307,
0.2896923721,
0.1389150769,
-0.3939419389,
-0.2465043366,
-0.6878266931,
-0.4890813231,
1.226926446,
0.3607536256,
0.8437666297,
-0.1164464802,
0.9130290747,
0.1202763692,
0.2793571353,
-0.8873534203,
0.2907426953,
-0.1360988021,
-0.2566359937,
-0.4117058516,
-0.6703802347,
-0.8122336268,
0.4955258369,
-0.5287042856,
-0.502417624,
0.2055496573,
0.3415957689,
-0.0684559345,
0.1076850891,
-0.555038929,
0.5995289087,
-0.5336233377,
-0.6758310199,
-0.2410238683,
-0.7345656753,
0.3762900531,
0.1327141076,
0.1903789192,
-0.1128500476,
-0.2605158985,
0.6149992347,
-0.2390437126,
0.4188537598,
-0.0038431846,
-0.0521682985,
-0.0694768056,
-0.1973689944,
0.8767495751,
-0.1077995673,
-0.2396449298,
-0.2849329412,
-0.263804704,
-0.3776673973,
-0.5820218921,
0.7830578089,
-1.1683850288,
-0.4281797707,
-0.5610753894,
-0.4241289496,
-0.5704727173,
0.0722534806,
0.0213251654,
-0.1028338224,
-0.1508657187,
-0.0260947421,
0.755036056,
-0.1547757685,
0.326261729,
0.3626835644,
-0.0893384814,
-1.0149484873,
0.7652121186,
-0.3026610613,
0.4180757403,
0.6730690598,
0.6007453799,
-0.3761278987,
-0.7422742248,
-0.2669542134,
0.4107571244,
-0.5477138758,
0.0841144249,
-0.1206525266,
0.1422972381,
-0.1451845318,
-0.0681776851,
-0.4059718251,
-0.0950509235,
-0.2903577089,
-0.0145694967,
0.0365275666,
0.5758482218,
0.0856136531,
0.2481035441,
-0.4008291066,
0.337659806,
0.4156692028,
0.4483963251,
-0.1588207036,
-0.2196539193,
-0.1187422052,
0.0009268519,
-0.51557827,
-0.7919396758,
0.3150435686,
-0.2021649331,
0.595723331,
0.5058053732,
0.1227936298,
0.4715721011,
-0.5036611557,
0.2971165478,
0.3574655652,
-0.5826383233,
0.4780803621,
-0.418291539,
0.0212932527,
0.8804707527,
0.5797941685,
-0.4664697647,
0.2140044272,
-0.3398301899,
-0.7809935808,
0.84169662,
0.1416860223,
-0.1914403588,
0.1729644537,
0.4418085814,
0.2182161808,
0.4310400784,
-1.0075546503,
-0.3405955434,
-0.0370220542,
-0.2278931588,
-0.1313640624,
-0.3346267939,
-0.3720416427,
-0.0251701698,
0.8619933128,
-0.2039249241,
-0.0899226144,
0.0272028409,
0.0299743153,
-0.1964173466,
0.5180301666,
0.6216078401,
0.5958985686,
-0.4949845076,
-0.1224307269,
-0.1273172498,
-0.2174515277,
0.4284238219,
0.029302815,
-0.3747863173,
-0.4513358474,
-0.0016795299,
1.0405302048,
0.2777918577,
-0.5601742864,
0.3561071157,
0.1331901252,
-0.2213457823,
0.1054584682,
0.0968951508,
0.0571671017,
0.0462345183,
0.0288282372,
-0.3219922185,
-0.0921527073,
-0.5976534486,
0.1063662395,
0.3311659992,
-0.3654077947,
0.0697719753,
0.3351655006,
0.4971354902,
-0.3013257682,
0.5050365329,
-0.0425115563,
-0.5220149159,
0.3380878866,
0.6007641554,
0.7205560207,
-0.0713492259,
0.3119233549,
0.2184570432,
0.074816823,
-0.3430397809,
0.0169634186,
-0.1531879902,
-1.0867195129,
-0.3572508991,
-0.5735353827,
-0.8545194268,
0.2442233413,
-0.7157028317,
0.2369098216,
-0.5749528408,
-0.0636641532,
-0.2953062356,
0.3851357996,
-0.3223668039,
0.1653467268,
0.1609960943,
0.3372894228,
-0.8346787691,
0.8814293742,
0.7200987339,
-0.224955976,
-0.5808616281,
0.2744439244,
-0.0037819939,
-0.9186739326,
0.5028461218,
-0.1065784916,
-0.0773967803,
-0.1647317559,
-0.3267670274,
-0.7936318517,
1.0424119234,
0.4296354353,
-0.8093044162,
0.0524090193,
-0.0198283345,
0.3745132089,
-0.4578467309,
0.1261579096,
0.6200584769,
0.4562655091,
0.2829591334,
-0.8017781973,
-0.0547433309,
0.2875481248,
0.1523481756,
0.4923344254,
-0.8969637752,
0.5348799229,
-0.0688109249,
-0.0349544957,
-0.149040848,
0.4783789814,
0.6767003536,
0.1338079274,
0.6813827157,
0.7993338108,
0.7475320101,
0.0010366507,
1.0699145794,
-0.0572797395,
0.403799504,
1.1903334856,
-0.6216086149,
1.0348151922,
0.819932878,
-0.474768132,
0.3887390494,
0.8792844415,
0.1623611748,
0.9062767625,
0.3462197781,
-0.2428481728,
-0.268509388,
-0.0574121699,
-0.1055662781,
0.0393551737,
-0.1491212994,
-0.1922823936,
-0.1554129571,
-0.1959601045,
0.0513364561,
0.423814714,
-0.2087197602,
0.9939953089,
-0.0593038313,
-0.9205477834,
0.4757500291,
0.0278219879,
0.8454102278,
-0.6794300079,
0.036210373,
-0.3175557852,
0.3168671727,
-0.1121420711,
-0.5851893425,
-0.0656285211,
-0.188162908,
-0.2882349193,
-0.321824342,
0.5891034603,
-0.5696452856,
-0.2559680045,
0.4198444188,
0.1258959174,
-0.2589549422,
0.2400695533,
-0.9576532841,
0.0703083128,
0.1856452525,
-0.3051430285,
0.6122300625,
0.0775325894,
-0.0134681445,
0.6654563546,
0.6838226318,
0.2809135616,
-0.2833684683,
0.0932657868,
0.7499917746,
-0.6077774763,
-0.6028876901,
-0.7636049986,
0.2502058446,
-0.1928457022,
-0.3140711486,
0.3122541308,
0.4524197578,
0.8816180825,
0.0544100963,
0.6238902807,
0.4983625412,
0.5226774216,
-0.7431485653,
0.103929311,
-0.4113329649,
0.2863026261,
-0.1011433452,
-1.171992898,
-0.1020061672,
0.513651669,
-0.5198792815,
-0.0906749666,
0.6735908389,
0.7162351012,
-0.0055221408,
-0.3606289923,
0.2013370693,
-0.2518067658,
0.1119581759,
0.705999434,
0.9181375504,
0.0018716108,
0.5910588503,
-0.437951684,
-0.3083462119,
-0.2728256583,
-1.0096920729,
-0.7574741244,
-0.1784666628,
-0.2295155078,
-0.3180890679,
0.2659808993,
1.1854723692,
0.7976115346,
-0.8435027599,
-0.514492631,
-0.1549514085,
0.4973271191,
-0.123013556,
-0.2309475839,
0.2554221749,
-0.2586268783,
-0.8581517935,
0.303504616,
0.2522052824,
0.1413005143,
-0.1536580622,
-0.5986847878,
-0.3526886404,
0.0603916422,
0.3420549333,
0.2950837612,
-0.7521355152,
-0.2852927446,
-0.22764498,
-0.2610426843,
0.3890898228,
0.9512529969,
-0.491740793,
0.4828183055,
0.6584742069,
0.8129019141,
0.5827764869,
0.2810543776,
0.795663476,
-0.5209608078,
0.1620279402,
0.3177434802,
0.2486922294,
0.3366823792,
-0.4224999845,
0.4319234788,
0.1956165433,
-0.740198195,
-0.6465018988,
0.499760896,
-1.0597664118,
-0.3769555986,
1.2924669981,
0.0657935366,
-0.0459372588,
0.1475936472,
-0.3230112493,
0.2110069394,
-0.7460646033,
0.9636434317,
0.9126554132,
-0.3882929981,
-0.2176238447,
-0.3026737273,
0.6808879375,
0.5409745574,
-0.8364299536,
-0.093569912,
0.5765786171,
0.3227961063,
-0.1879326701,
0.5401608348,
0.0927173123,
-0.0026567024,
-0.3358554244,
0.009963084,
-0.1303526014,
-0.2237639129,
-0.5851815343,
0.0619857274,
0.3820472658,
-0.3515235782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19432v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19432v2
|
Uncovering Misattributed Suicide Causes through Annotation Inconsistency Detection in Death Investigation Notes
| 2024-03-28T14:03:12 | 2024-03-29T17:21:02 |
Song Wang, Yiliang Zhou, Ziqiang Han, Cui Tao, Yunyu Xiao, Ying Ding, Joydeep Ghosh, Yifan Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Data accuracy is essential for scientific research and policy development.
The National Violent Death Reporting System (NVDRS) data is widely used for
discovering the patterns and causes of death. Recent studies suggested the
annotation inconsistencies within the NVDRS and the potential impact on
erroneous suicide-cause attributions. We present an empirical Natural Language
Processing (NLP) approach to detect annotation inconsistencies and adopt a
cross-validation-like paradigm to identify problematic instances. We analyzed
267,804 suicide death incidents between 2003 and 2020 from the NVDRS. Our
results showed that incorporating the target state's data into training the
suicide-crisis classifier brought an increase of 5.4% to the F-1 score on the
target state's test set and a decrease of 1.1% on other states' test set. To
conclude, we demonstrated the annotation inconsistencies in NVDRS's death
investigation notes, identified problematic instances, evaluated the
effectiveness of correcting problematic instances, and eventually proposed an
NLP improvement solution.
|
[
-0.1680815369,
-0.859890461,
0.5985965133,
0.3490317464,
0.1705301255,
0.0297338236,
0.1126983762,
-0.4737077951,
0.0496115312,
0.3904523253,
-0.6306203604,
-0.3697393239,
-0.6277348399,
0.4660069346,
-0.3073864281,
0.9078453183,
-0.1710584015,
0.1122337803,
-0.1757917851,
-0.3833940625,
-0.3822711408,
-0.4813742042,
-1.0919115543,
-0.0927120969,
0.5768143535,
0.0800931901,
0.5532737374,
0.4005942643,
0.5570188761,
0.1308258474,
-0.1645201743,
0.3128269315,
-0.1502476335,
-0.1015789509,
0.3453246951,
-0.5608945489,
-0.3734441698,
-0.0483035855,
0.3281867206,
0.287306726,
-0.1563333273,
0.1315051913,
0.0070188507,
0.6651240587,
-0.6647601128,
-0.2534886301,
-0.205640614,
0.504442811,
-0.2236885726,
-0.376773715,
-0.5285146236,
-0.8728173971,
0.1609061658,
-0.5753847361,
0.5493406057,
-0.2807545662,
0.5615355372,
0.5695165992,
-0.1660785824,
-0.4282853603,
-0.8065236807,
0.7200853825,
-0.7593733668,
0.1678029299,
0.4155351222,
0.2486865669,
-0.3177093267,
-0.118024528,
-0.5465162396,
-0.0692745671,
-0.1601879448,
-0.1111661196,
-0.201654911,
0.0717500374,
0.5889573693,
0.4778048694,
-0.65971452,
0.1711862534,
-0.1087381318,
-0.467686981,
0.8606358767,
0.3101980984,
0.4928554296,
-0.4169347286,
-0.2266613245,
-0.0209327452,
-0.4919175506,
0.0360610522,
0.6932892203,
0.3039504588,
-0.1741408408,
0.5550233126,
-0.1613115221,
0.8043593168,
-0.029366076,
-0.3289881647,
0.5188922286,
-0.2959260941,
-0.1076396108,
0.502292335,
0.7655985951,
0.6380495429,
0.3059248328,
-0.0039672307,
0.1042424068,
-0.0184168145,
0.2161496133,
-0.4159356356,
-0.2855627537,
0.392403543,
-0.4639384151,
-0.3570118845,
-0.3468492925,
-0.6232072115,
-0.6443206668,
-0.3497324586,
0.4061897695,
-0.611245811,
-0.2418563366,
-0.1609732807,
-0.5134347677,
0.0625799745,
0.4934636652,
-0.2489119321,
-0.0390886031,
0.4409670234,
1.0064508915,
-0.1456591785,
-0.0749896616,
-0.5628171563,
-0.2155686468,
-0.0864469111,
1.0041538477,
-0.3419418633,
0.1652858555,
0.2079893053,
-0.0234727487,
0.0994327068,
-0.5778543949,
0.9893006682,
0.0743864253,
0.1739010215,
-0.3401723206,
-0.5357857347,
-0.1122228727,
0.3357022405,
-0.6971899867,
1.1409378052,
-0.1195723563,
-0.9831010699,
0.7782564163,
-0.4920651615,
-0.3427313566,
-0.0115654804,
-0.1858663708,
-0.7283527255,
0.0351470262,
0.2509397566,
0.6018602848,
-0.1307159364,
0.2719299793,
-0.2143922299,
-0.2188212574,
0.1930689216,
-0.5163602233,
0.9591979384,
-0.1478075087,
0.0396149121,
-0.2170296758,
-1.2076218128,
-0.0549148582,
0.1890908629,
-0.6165660024,
-0.6659553051,
0.0676737651,
0.3302819729,
0.1751579195,
-0.1115053594,
-0.8012670875,
-0.0855228305,
-0.175410524,
-0.0544002652,
0.383726418,
0.5550550222,
0.0866509452,
-0.5459142327,
0.2442731112,
0.0895683989,
0.4452834725,
0.076544635,
-0.6015440822,
-0.3929221928,
-0.0778597295,
-0.0420915261,
0.849150598,
-0.5675798655,
0.3731938303,
0.3340862393,
-0.4719845653,
-0.4217736125,
-0.2018692642,
0.1619323492,
0.9140172601,
0.8754706383,
-0.0285775028,
-1.048363328,
-0.9082766175,
-0.6292913556,
-0.1795437485,
-0.0312477536,
-0.4187479317,
0.3146924376,
-0.0313766897,
1.0929284096,
-0.327604413,
-0.6842640042,
-0.1180360317,
0.5762660503,
-0.0632203966,
0.3587348759,
0.3316711485,
-0.7651084661,
-0.3151311874,
-0.3370060921,
-0.9644654393,
-0.1996850073,
-0.481811136,
0.2259644121,
0.2933887541,
0.4376429021,
-0.0748944357,
0.8490242362,
0.0894413963,
0.1737204939,
0.5903420448,
-0.2063425332,
-0.0219338983,
-0.6013452411,
-0.1508232504,
0.2644281685,
0.1506246775,
-0.7629354,
-0.7376749516,
0.054784406,
0.3678801954,
-0.1964843124,
-0.0756416768,
-0.2113807499,
0.2960349023,
-0.1495369822,
0.1483126134,
-0.0417820476,
0.080156602,
-0.0214923713,
0.2766569853,
0.169398129,
-0.4990488589,
0.3260346353,
0.5094065666,
-0.0702670589,
0.8915679455,
-0.4000901282,
-0.3587140441,
-0.6452479959,
0.2078108937,
-0.8112010956,
-0.2131102085,
0.3459087312,
-0.3202677965,
-0.0395729505,
-0.2862939239,
-0.3802080452,
0.0082019772,
-0.2912967801,
0.092749998,
0.0356649421,
-0.0498510115,
0.6546949744,
0.3065029979,
0.0389530957,
-0.537949264,
-0.8650050163,
0.0848701447,
-0.3681428134,
-0.2785778642,
-0.1429779679,
0.1645854712,
-0.237558499,
-0.1477977633,
-0.0023336252,
-0.1601123512,
0.2541997731,
0.4769694805,
-0.0595479496,
-0.1851919442,
0.3729263544,
0.0400649309,
-0.2098328471,
0.3694443703,
0.3998726904,
0.1712363213,
0.3297908902,
-0.2930355668,
-0.6587439775,
0.37207371,
0.1890619695,
-0.1279602051,
0.7362576723,
0.3904644847,
-0.5536514521,
-0.187227264,
-0.7101883888,
0.2555936873,
-0.2714090049,
0.0095852856,
0.2482867837,
-0.6758502126,
0.6529706717,
-0.0216989089,
0.2080392838,
0.6455646753,
0.0570369847,
-0.0008080609,
0.7513160706,
0.4497299492,
0.082390137,
0.5130599737,
-0.0843436345,
0.4170421362,
-1.0254689455,
-0.371999681,
-0.4581607878,
-0.1056011915,
-0.5420113802,
-0.2588385344,
0.5137549043,
0.0973322168,
-0.269726783,
0.2596563399,
-0.5980737805,
0.5726236701,
0.0952867866,
-0.0618309602,
0.6619049311,
0.1042564362,
0.0936991647,
-0.2853730917,
-0.3395188153,
-0.520986557,
0.9807345867,
0.2699103355,
0.5689114928,
0.131570667,
0.9279921055,
0.372895509,
0.4855388403,
-0.3189045489,
0.1002806649,
-0.0655896217,
-0.5782725215,
-0.5000812411,
-0.4764528573,
-0.5603809357,
-0.0897981972,
-0.3167440891,
-0.8289909363,
0.4049975574,
0.0341015309,
-0.617677629,
0.0364927873,
-0.4027733505,
0.9008398652,
-0.3243486583,
0.2230290473,
0.2203316242,
-0.5350635648,
0.3320531845,
-0.1230260059,
0.2711382508,
-0.4201903641,
0.4220329821,
0.9442310929,
-0.5491828322,
0.8172553182,
-0.4052346051,
-0.1400738209,
0.2703416944,
-0.016531067,
0.4718589485,
0.065136604,
-0.2481396645,
0.0741654858,
-0.2677341402,
-0.0125464024,
-0.4489738047,
0.1476206928,
-0.4483623803,
-0.0078397132,
-0.5424952507,
-0.3838388622,
-0.0526535921,
-0.0038684385,
0.6220288277,
0.4940340519,
-0.3286715746,
-0.335727334,
0.7196629047,
-0.2791977227,
0.5354268551,
0.5306609273,
-0.0881332532,
-0.4772339165,
0.8167535663,
0.5636914372,
0.2984687686,
0.1861923337,
0.0511561185,
-0.044061739,
-0.5217391253,
-0.5466685891,
0.2621375918,
-0.8017109036,
-0.4003985822,
-0.8905203938,
-0.2105171084,
-0.1248878762,
-0.0458927117,
-0.3344593942,
-0.1827556789,
-0.4179148972,
-0.2352472395,
0.8458353281,
0.7898005843,
-0.4063651562,
0.1732555479,
-0.6359671354,
0.4411349893,
-0.023792237,
0.1151539907,
0.0268206298,
-0.413870424,
-0.149114728,
0.1367332637,
-0.2919839323,
-0.9964008927,
0.0645850748,
0.3100451529,
0.4926975071,
0.3476144671,
0.2840429246,
0.9762171507,
-0.2854848802,
0.5667637587,
0.0633786619,
-0.7602003813,
0.8671316504,
-0.1903861761,
-0.1678148061,
0.8731592298,
0.7243363857,
-0.8700832725,
-0.6933451295,
-0.7234977484,
-0.790991962,
0.6173931956,
0.1754710972,
-0.2947956026,
-0.0626382008,
0.3989611268,
0.040532846,
-0.0729553774,
-0.5595452189,
-0.6534215212,
0.0673779771,
-0.1876942366,
0.1491786391,
-0.1409900486,
-0.0405870974,
-0.1677089334,
0.7428824306,
-0.1829879582,
0.0537224039,
0.6620931625,
-0.0561225004,
-0.5915594101,
-0.0946640894,
0.619058311,
0.668466866,
-0.238033399,
-0.0558144674,
0.3646082282,
-0.4929944277,
0.3684387207,
0.2358049154,
-0.4054550827,
0.2432455719,
0.6436404586,
0.5366460681,
-0.0119370343,
-0.5225946307,
0.8359134197,
-0.4058935642,
0.0585040227,
-0.8419815302,
0.0445420593,
-0.2074596733,
0.1208061054,
0.6758072972,
0.2238632888,
0.3717161715,
-0.3327589333,
0.2963224351,
0.3668560088,
-0.3169028759,
-0.0756771415,
0.3794490099,
-0.1155194417,
-0.3065048456,
0.3356631994,
-0.2431760281,
-0.5084980726,
0.5427748561,
0.1482834965,
0.843262732,
-0.4818627238,
0.6641319394,
0.4337501824,
0.70713377,
-0.4053210318,
0.4362912178,
0.1729527265,
-0.6367948651,
-0.6898687482,
-0.7328500152,
-0.4951611459,
0.2832941711,
-0.9831208587,
0.2571263313,
-0.6528169513,
-0.0001577607,
0.2171892524,
-0.4411684871,
-0.4652267098,
0.2766706944,
0.4370287955,
0.624378562,
-1.521355629,
0.1085454971,
0.4672324061,
-0.674798131,
-0.6871026754,
0.330927074,
0.1263021678,
-0.3657104671,
0.7307399511,
0.361842066,
0.3102361262,
-0.3798330128,
-0.5214865804,
-0.9500160217,
0.5920678377,
0.2138196975,
-0.3195391893,
0.214382723,
0.539881289,
0.6996599436,
-0.1723299176,
0.2540622652,
0.7061803937,
0.4777593017,
-0.2620773613,
-0.8501089215,
0.2654747367,
0.1464429498,
-0.1397965401,
0.6714497209,
-0.4161609113,
0.8149121404,
-0.0516214781,
-0.2987683117,
-0.3596306741,
0.5147334933,
0.1849691123,
0.8575760126,
0.2709887922,
0.9637403488,
0.9472911954,
-0.0566946827,
0.8520721793,
0.6947357059,
0.4326992631,
1.0190665722,
-0.3002284467,
0.7227489948,
0.5975046754,
-0.3182150126,
0.654360652,
0.2020817697,
-0.0067932154,
0.3953491151,
0.1594033539,
-0.1776276976,
-0.4024251699,
-0.2101369053,
-0.1707119942,
0.3431250155,
0.3282503486,
-0.4274098575,
-0.5919121504,
0.3940844834,
0.0069110449,
-0.2933783829,
0.0567737445,
0.8710176349,
-0.0173634347,
-0.159832418,
0.461230576,
-0.2001736611,
0.4529187977,
-0.1832479537,
-0.4544746578,
-0.0440399684,
0.0946393758,
-0.6300264001,
-0.7388548851,
0.8252069354,
0.1268029809,
-0.3073080778,
0.0513430648,
0.5420916677,
-0.1362697482,
-0.6033060551,
0.1337591559,
0.2052452862,
0.2046588063,
-0.472027123,
-0.4585490525,
0.227557689,
0.1011017859,
0.0208138041,
0.1176541746,
0.6425243616,
-0.180922702,
0.4428585768,
0.6721407771,
0.0965347439,
0.1852669716,
-0.2608538866,
0.5142427683,
-0.5953723788,
-0.3162882626,
-0.7750487328,
0.7790153623,
-0.3234273195,
-0.7123538852,
0.8178903461,
0.5209683776,
0.8632547259,
0.1180506945,
0.9961559176,
-0.216883868,
0.913651228,
-0.5051158071,
0.5340101123,
-0.400755167,
0.0953705832,
-0.3212008178,
-0.7856664062,
-0.749368012,
0.878395319,
-0.6668912768,
-0.2846235633,
0.5470439196,
0.4902873039,
0.3001849353,
0.2756607831,
-0.0283593908,
0.2396102697,
0.1876810938,
0.3690390885,
0.9194532633,
-1.0324735641,
0.3296518028,
-0.3892566562,
0.0458660275,
-0.443062216,
-0.9275233746,
-0.8206681013,
-0.5444549322,
-0.8291375041,
-0.1800152212,
-0.0877539292,
0.7630357146,
-0.152448073,
-0.7961525321,
0.2690697908,
-0.2834481895,
0.2095462531,
-0.1338992566,
-0.2401462495,
0.2874987423,
-0.0839297324,
0.005438183,
0.362585485,
0.3061138093,
0.0885236636,
-0.0187861416,
0.1317438334,
-0.3004104197,
-0.3393674493,
0.3083124757,
0.3300874829,
-0.7659108639,
-0.46616292,
-0.6568259001,
0.0472908244,
0.1064805388,
0.8002710342,
-0.7716705799,
0.1982954741,
0.372535795,
0.5515120029,
-0.1869276464,
0.0151167037,
0.1673520952,
-0.9647715092,
-0.233398512,
0.1873712093,
0.0980811939,
0.6464083791,
-0.8253951669,
0.4020712674,
0.2701027691,
-0.6336467862,
-1.1059542894,
-0.031106161,
-0.658153832,
0.1871066093,
0.6887789369,
0.0704682022,
-0.321226269,
-0.7099025249,
-0.1672514826,
0.3924160302,
-0.3609960675,
0.5452324748,
0.5051730871,
-0.6099398732,
-0.1076881438,
-0.7056566477,
0.8488925099,
0.2922089696,
-0.8030746579,
0.33630687,
0.5915386677,
0.2845725715,
0.5617819428,
0.3486168087,
0.2149242163,
0.4128858447,
-0.1954967231,
0.1706868559,
0.0241557956,
-0.2060389519,
-0.5857172012,
0.2237176001,
-0.2339317203,
0.0553187318
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.