id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17534v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17534v2
|
Retrieval-style In-Context Learning for Few-shot Hierarchical Text Classification
| 2024-06-25T13:19:41 | 2024-06-29T09:24:33 |
Huiyao Chen, Yu Zhao, Zulong Chen, Mengjia Wang, Liangyue Li, Meishan Zhang, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hierarchical text classification (HTC) is an important task with broad
applications, while few-shot HTC has gained increasing interest recently. While
in-context learning (ICL) with large language models (LLMs) has achieved
significant success in few-shot learning, it is not as effective for HTC
because of the expansive hierarchical label sets and extremely-ambiguous
labels. In this work, we introduce the first ICL-based framework with LLM for
few-shot HTC. We exploit a retrieval database to identify relevant
demonstrations, and an iterative policy to manage multi-layer hierarchical
labels. Particularly, we equip the retrieval database with HTC label-aware
representations for the input texts, which is achieved by continual training on
a pretrained language model with masked language modeling (MLM), layer-wise
classification (CLS, specifically for HTC), and a novel divergent contrastive
learning (DCL, mainly for adjacent semantically-similar labels) objective.
Experimental results on three benchmark datasets demonstrate superior
performance of our method, and we can achieve state-of-the-art results in
few-shot HTC.
|
[
-0.1017645597,
-0.7027394772,
0.3446479142,
0.0183757301,
-0.2453028858,
0.3354944587,
-0.0414707512,
-0.4164981246,
-0.187772572,
0.1944071651,
-0.4752038121,
-0.908847332,
-0.4681904018,
0.0702077374,
-0.2657705843,
1.0394514799,
-0.0074864719,
-0.2906448543,
0.0753881484,
-0.2331633121,
-0.0194724295,
-0.5585541129,
-0.3831333518,
-0.620629847,
0.5523211956,
0.777636528,
0.2600437701,
0.6038555503,
0.466010958,
0.1651454568,
-0.2934107184,
0.1185743287,
-0.6724775434,
-0.1121907532,
0.064730376,
-0.1305076331,
-0.052330479,
-0.1968302578,
0.8101167679,
0.5190103054,
0.018933082,
-0.0132312905,
0.4082299769,
0.3553587794,
-0.9622534513,
0.0620910451,
-0.8242038488,
0.2999513745,
-0.4361402094,
-0.4799883366,
-0.7350976467,
-0.0038978336,
0.4398765266,
-0.5142766833,
-0.3126790226,
0.3086580038,
0.8420255184,
0.1085780263,
-0.5349319577,
-0.1631591022,
-0.4824513197,
0.9212974906,
-0.5850268602,
0.3639832437,
0.6048589349,
0.5267260671,
0.072986275,
-0.8272328377,
-0.3607757986,
-0.1561422348,
-0.28203246,
0.1313169301,
-0.093158029,
0.0599568933,
0.0151133556,
0.0383178815,
-0.463753134,
0.5044488907,
0.0984262004,
-0.0486437343,
0.0749768913,
0.2104997039,
-0.0667052567,
-0.3114290535,
-0.7579646111,
0.0600451082,
-0.9288846254,
-0.0969503596,
-0.2431415021,
0.5152326226,
-0.2896725535,
0.2952477336,
-0.1808909923,
0.5808001757,
0.2028435022,
-0.5841786861,
0.1924691796,
-0.2392015159,
-0.4528586566,
0.3173037469,
0.6562080383,
-0.0636032224,
-0.3605326712,
-0.1317242384,
-0.2743418217,
-0.5545813441,
-0.0614030883,
-1.0797468424,
0.0219867695,
-0.1321994513,
-0.4337689579,
-0.2716900408,
-0.0581815206,
-0.5338441133,
-0.3287204504,
-0.04369165,
0.7070528269,
-0.3080779612,
0.1829520911,
-0.1030822098,
0.1831154972,
0.3025305271,
0.2063551694,
-0.8569490314,
0.330409497,
0.4379222989,
0.9378291965,
-0.4400157332,
-0.3128842413,
-0.6321137547,
0.3786191642,
-0.2506990135,
0.6369376183,
-0.5748357177,
-0.2638409734,
0.2210820019,
-0.280780226,
0.0888832211,
-0.6541543007,
0.2239698023,
-0.7117000818,
0.1581282169,
0.0547522008,
-0.5072559118,
0.0842880681,
0.8146675825,
-0.2301447242,
1.0932146311,
-0.005868874,
-1.0747861862,
0.5194784403,
-0.3054883778,
-0.3449287713,
0.3149769902,
-0.4149757624,
-0.726349473,
-0.4860488772,
0.0307708383,
0.5739697814,
-0.0772270411,
-0.0307412576,
-0.1814465225,
-0.7987498045,
-0.2078187615,
-0.4085201919,
0.6731556654,
0.0432489626,
-0.3753657639,
-0.0344126225,
-0.698009491,
-0.0439682975,
-0.2855480909,
-0.6246108413,
-0.4793525934,
-0.2798672318,
0.2487364709,
0.404551208,
0.125644207,
-0.520152688,
0.2658760548,
-0.414572686,
0.0731760785,
0.426491946,
0.1985639483,
0.6498847008,
-0.2824457884,
0.3211387396,
0.3628409207,
-0.0030241671,
-0.3599741459,
-0.119289428,
-0.4890963733,
-0.513479352,
0.1410134733,
0.6024388075,
-1.0869508982,
0.3128005266,
-0.0558009446,
-0.3307330608,
-0.1692529023,
0.2546464801,
0.5484549403,
0.773598969,
0.5705546141,
0.0277585145,
-0.4267476499,
-0.8899980783,
0.0105543025,
-0.2671169937,
0.1127968282,
0.6175696254,
0.7126827836,
-0.4784318209,
0.9227502942,
-0.3224317133,
-0.6776190996,
-0.3248414397,
0.4275743961,
0.0468340814,
0.4302006662,
0.4216319323,
-0.6101722121,
-0.7172950506,
0.2120507956,
-0.7602458596,
0.0469678231,
-0.0708291307,
-0.2425811887,
0.2811098993,
0.6356248856,
-0.1678488553,
0.4110909402,
0.1703808308,
0.2460710704,
0.4109780788,
-0.0228021238,
-0.004637762,
-1.0185648203,
-0.1709543169,
0.2146366388,
-0.3120346963,
-0.5174728632,
-0.0038324902,
0.2934654057,
0.2849060595,
-0.8895583153,
0.8158160448,
-0.2397512943,
0.0066184048,
-0.3824371397,
0.2145256698,
-0.0359509438,
0.5405414104,
0.2144958675,
0.4581215084,
0.7371906042,
-0.6830871105,
-0.1964997649,
0.1729503572,
-0.5230038762,
0.584510088,
-0.1613493562,
0.1768642068,
-0.3429047167,
0.4456652105,
-0.8401517272,
-0.210883975,
0.2200309038,
-0.0123913856,
0.4895173311,
-0.36067608,
-0.7285684943,
-0.1116296574,
-0.2938203812,
0.5789242387,
0.4246192873,
-1.0374041796,
0.3065083027,
0.0371890366,
0.1595523506,
-0.850389421,
-0.8537976742,
0.0388673618,
-0.3599618077,
-0.0751078129,
0.8161370158,
-0.0595754683,
-0.0565103702,
-0.3046734333,
-0.2444987595,
-0.5215528607,
-0.045797918,
0.0271382518,
0.1031221971,
-0.2047836483,
0.309361428,
0.2247492969,
0.0631122068,
-0.5213342309,
-0.3468360007,
0.226845026,
-0.2222724408,
-0.1059236377,
-0.6862961054,
0.2159769684,
0.1361622512,
0.1558782458,
0.5374448895,
0.5289316773,
-0.5275869966,
-0.3344761431,
-0.2046976984,
-0.1870905012,
-0.4670879245,
0.34393996,
-0.5461001396,
-1.091574192,
0.156341657,
-0.1340238601,
-0.0225052182,
0.0909117758,
0.5092183352,
-0.4021511376,
0.8447054625,
0.8349616528,
-0.2162893713,
0.7688354254,
-0.3330570757,
-0.2572056949,
-0.6070072055,
-0.3348891735,
-0.4454725981,
-0.2381270081,
-0.6209062934,
-0.068672061,
0.5646296144,
0.2402746677,
-0.6365043521,
0.2247363776,
-0.1573753655,
0.796580255,
0.3333424032,
0.418839097,
0.5679217577,
0.1323202401,
-0.3058688045,
-0.059403114,
-0.8114978671,
-0.4052139521,
0.5746327043,
0.3981847465,
1.0391274691,
0.1373726726,
1.1795860529,
-0.0641641244,
0.5226811171,
-0.9749956131,
0.2693457901,
-0.2009655386,
-0.4913425744,
-0.1142987236,
-0.4146133065,
-0.695268333,
0.4309175611,
-0.1654708087,
-0.8280527592,
0.3206677437,
0.0787053406,
-0.4143787026,
0.259136349,
-0.397593677,
0.6444758773,
-0.1475864798,
-0.6171020865,
0.0927133709,
-0.9494333267,
0.3707261384,
-0.0878638625,
-0.0355819426,
0.2164491415,
-0.2397368103,
0.4613224566,
-0.1838407964,
1.0438116789,
0.0150327487,
0.0422489941,
0.3124722242,
0.1897262633,
0.459433794,
-0.1315112561,
-0.1700771749,
-0.1602007896,
-0.0238975212,
-0.3723592162,
-0.5061305165,
0.6137971282,
-0.5150271654,
-0.2728685737,
-0.4027722478,
-0.2554120421,
-0.2365799695,
0.3802284002,
0.5544114113,
0.5598907471,
-0.1639964581,
0.4710747004,
0.6513489485,
-0.1596075892,
0.6197634935,
0.4873968661,
-0.2137959898,
-0.0917972401,
0.7758539319,
-0.0191610586,
0.1599649489,
0.9226223826,
0.3672566414,
-0.249953866,
-0.481518358,
-0.4489529431,
-0.1702174842,
-0.9294925928,
-0.5106487274,
-0.5828406811,
-0.3321695328,
0.0367600694,
-0.2095044851,
-0.146356836,
-0.0328652672,
-0.5624430776,
0.0089803133,
0.0090219909,
0.6467349529,
0.3304080665,
0.6680400372,
-0.5931425691,
0.3346231282,
0.2557765841,
0.435280323,
0.0007653349,
-0.7795799375,
-0.3841514885,
-0.3290393353,
-0.4352348745,
-0.695531249,
0.3165441155,
0.4674844444,
0.4165506959,
0.37400195,
0.0305898152,
0.7346847653,
-0.5653299093,
0.4863185883,
0.1002044901,
-0.7162114978,
0.4814165235,
-0.1865095049,
0.6112768054,
0.874637723,
0.7257503271,
-0.3722207844,
-0.1787362546,
-0.2421069592,
-0.6848434806,
0.8022014499,
0.0962264463,
0.0632736981,
-0.078239195,
0.3775772154,
0.2080034316,
0.1525394917,
-0.8765977025,
-0.3431826234,
-0.1328038722,
-0.3181551695,
0.4214695692,
-0.0697365776,
0.1262748837,
-0.2556079924,
0.5144318938,
-0.4737539887,
-0.1462143064,
0.1214879006,
-0.4821703136,
0.1102481112,
0.572003603,
0.2675857842,
0.5015989542,
-0.3903251886,
0.3775469661,
0.1822591424,
-0.1839953065,
0.2919150591,
-0.0545733161,
-0.3430099189,
-0.158132568,
0.3430318236,
0.6643750072,
0.6520265341,
-0.5912622809,
0.6247466803,
0.2559736073,
-0.0904408172,
0.0899830684,
-0.2976798713,
-0.3537779748,
0.2295558155,
0.5745532513,
-0.231564343,
0.4375348091,
-0.6526778936,
0.4756768048,
0.3066408038,
-0.6429792643,
0.066303201,
0.2525515854,
-0.0689567626,
-0.0549906269,
0.5422942042,
-0.422606647,
-0.4556184411,
0.3581483066,
0.8555750251,
0.7692719102,
0.1286575794,
0.3280029595,
0.3929364383,
0.13976264,
-0.117280446,
-0.1243041083,
-0.4772046208,
-0.6309884787,
-0.158332482,
-0.3923792243,
-0.6032953858,
0.0189154893,
-0.4239780605,
0.3800507188,
-0.5853210092,
-0.0074474867,
-0.2113153487,
0.0921355635,
-0.5120584369,
0.0839155391,
0.2526942492,
0.9348856211,
-0.513989687,
1.1071307659,
0.5629839897,
-0.4043990374,
-0.375528276,
0.3361290693,
0.3280873895,
-0.4353427887,
1.1428364515,
0.352722168,
-0.4692094028,
0.2397457063,
-0.8237144351,
-0.6168396473,
1.1934081316,
0.0633990094,
-0.6518247128,
-0.0708597153,
-0.0915234238,
0.6304484606,
-0.6645550132,
0.3073301911,
0.5900176764,
0.2119741589,
0.4340550005,
-0.7568407655,
-0.3327950239,
0.1412011683,
0.091226384,
-0.1983025968,
-0.5786820054,
0.4437345862,
-0.1926831007,
-0.3790557683,
0.1765674651,
0.6156660914,
0.6173959374,
0.6348210573,
0.287604183,
0.1952350736,
0.6409834027,
0.1248262376,
1.1315290928,
0.0770699531,
0.480083853,
1.3851406574,
-0.3839188218,
1.1182293892,
0.3549114168,
0.1721025705,
0.6857056022,
0.8176719546,
0.3942941725,
0.7407702804,
0.1414608508,
-0.4067798853,
-0.2588278353,
-0.3709187806,
0.0273047891,
0.4303156435,
0.3123438656,
-0.1725138724,
-0.5425408483,
0.1853393167,
-0.058386866,
-0.0512459241,
-0.3541654944,
1.0067595243,
0.3219203949,
-0.0113388635,
0.6819753647,
0.0964187831,
1.1421679258,
-0.3695299327,
-0.05477966,
-0.2729482651,
0.1256156117,
-0.2920791209,
-0.7157454491,
-0.1265843511,
-0.0364572592,
-0.1678277701,
-0.2372072935,
0.6616028547,
-0.7398982048,
-0.177094996,
0.2348064035,
0.375107497,
0.0337948538,
0.1301835924,
-0.738581121,
-0.0774895251,
-0.47044909,
-0.0967108309,
0.5055614114,
0.3618519604,
-0.2188261747,
0.6777581573,
-0.0797723308,
-0.3619291782,
0.0653709471,
0.3172268569,
0.6604227424,
-0.6456861496,
-0.4908418953,
-0.8891156912,
0.2195174992,
0.1202021539,
-0.2996093929,
0.5866922736,
0.6683655381,
0.927056849,
0.1561606526,
0.5761666894,
0.2564956844,
0.1762153506,
-0.607753098,
0.5544108152,
-0.7372544408,
0.3355667591,
-0.3339661062,
-0.7635580897,
-0.6774838567,
0.4694370031,
-0.0367117487,
0.2240391821,
0.8328428268,
0.7235108614,
-0.2387601733,
-0.268462956,
0.4685360193,
0.2959608436,
0.2292391509,
0.6685300469,
0.9319713712,
-0.622364223,
0.7078137398,
-0.4740604162,
-0.1851584315,
-0.4291245043,
-0.9316904545,
-0.9159234166,
-0.4534562826,
-0.4252207279,
-0.1174603105,
0.1271446198,
1.2099741697,
0.9805040956,
-0.5945833921,
-0.2552689314,
0.2448509187,
0.3242355883,
-0.0787492841,
-0.2018141001,
0.4538412094,
-0.3987402022,
-0.6924219728,
0.4624154866,
0.5524569154,
0.2239165902,
-0.0516228341,
-0.1237321049,
-0.375148356,
-0.3537606597,
1.0720543861,
0.3374752104,
-0.5824043155,
-0.2622386515,
-0.1301151961,
-0.6546517611,
0.3831470013,
0.7410411239,
-0.9821395278,
0.3459881246,
0.5238565803,
0.9032998085,
0.8159563541,
-0.012788279,
-0.1462693959,
-1.3564362526,
0.2135856301,
0.4111797512,
0.1224169806,
0.2849602997,
-0.2030620873,
0.1099131405,
-0.0482676439,
-0.2534018457,
-0.6361061335,
0.2175883949,
-0.8615851402,
-0.2376727611,
1.1207360029,
-0.0169798508,
-0.0959059224,
-0.183057487,
-0.2466946989,
-0.1065486223,
-0.4278024435,
0.5986158252,
0.4673776031,
-0.2403590828,
-0.5326154232,
-0.2210482359,
0.5272886157,
0.1140896156,
-0.9098923206,
-0.1808186173,
0.4206114113,
0.0790235773,
-0.0855751708,
0.7562656403,
-0.1844763756,
0.1502965838,
-0.264932394,
-0.3009317517,
0.1598953456,
-0.8197078109,
-0.4136288464,
0.2130935192,
0.0932052806,
0.0127440784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17532v1
|
Can Large Language Models Understand DL-Lite Ontologies? An Empirical Study
| 2024-06-25T13:16:34 | 2024-06-25T13:16:34 |
Keyu Wang, Guilin Qi, Jiaqi Li, Songlin Zhai
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LO
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown significant achievements in solving a
wide range of tasks. Recently, LLMs' capability to store, retrieve and infer
with symbolic knowledge has drawn a great deal of attention, showing their
potential to understand structured information. However, it is not yet known
whether LLMs can understand Description Logic (DL) ontologies. In this work, we
empirically analyze the LLMs' capability of understanding DL-Lite ontologies
covering 6 representative tasks from syntactic and semantic aspects. With
extensive experiments, we demonstrate both the effectiveness and limitations of
LLMs in understanding DL-Lite ontologies. We find that LLMs can understand
formal syntax and model-theoretic semantics of concepts and roles. However,
LLMs struggle with understanding TBox NI transitivity and handling ontologies
with large ABoxes. We hope that our experiments and analyses provide more
insights into LLMs and inspire to build more faithful knowledge engineering
solutions.
|
[
-0.0621412918,
-0.5917665958,
1.3321582079,
-0.0585751832,
-0.0106353918,
0.0655234605,
-0.3156148195,
-0.7326474786,
-0.109399572,
0.914659977,
-0.7496601343,
-0.501162827,
-0.707680285,
0.3645544946,
-0.561576426,
0.5911508799,
0.0020564382,
0.0047404394,
0.0067841681,
0.0048559587,
-0.3701625168,
-0.383633256,
-0.3952499926,
-0.3954823315,
0.5578947663,
-0.0092288936,
0.6555226445,
0.5818918943,
0.3943150342,
0.3000510335,
-0.3901168406,
0.0577980727,
-0.4628188908,
0.00920338,
-0.3935830295,
-0.8531663418,
-0.4051983953,
-0.1309814155,
0.7133694291,
0.9830833673,
-0.0449513979,
0.042486228,
-0.063676849,
0.3525066674,
-0.4898338914,
0.4739179313,
-0.9734745622,
0.0936179832,
0.0747743249,
-0.1100700647,
-0.6266602278,
0.1128779948,
0.3441672325,
-0.7840758562,
-0.2221755236,
0.3336270154,
0.6933806539,
0.1457383633,
-0.642362833,
-0.3945799172,
-0.7288793921,
0.9901376367,
-0.8877017498,
0.5424479246,
0.0727919117,
0.3217434287,
-0.23849307,
-0.6744105816,
-0.754335463,
-0.1334705502,
-0.3270080686,
-0.0178566575,
0.051592771,
0.2377260774,
0.5362406969,
0.2439660132,
-0.3992019594,
0.4392069876,
-0.1356960982,
-0.1738714129,
0.5411685109,
0.3616752326,
0.3613920808,
-0.4237870574,
-0.6980212331,
0.1912876815,
-0.7298868299,
-0.141416654,
-0.1071631238,
0.2174835056,
-0.0309727658,
0.7443285584,
-0.0241518803,
0.7117468715,
-0.6098447442,
-0.2552717924,
-0.0458651632,
-0.5080810189,
-0.3759445548,
-0.1462012976,
0.6244964004,
-0.0014609516,
0.3757540882,
-0.6983813047,
-0.4796491563,
-0.1643734276,
0.0121060275,
-0.5551751256,
0.3243774176,
0.3134118319,
-0.5125158429,
0.0466652922,
-0.0532603152,
-0.2616347671,
-0.6350259185,
-0.362735182,
0.7290725112,
-0.3869445324,
-0.2676854432,
0.4200695455,
-0.2932783663,
0.4657236338,
0.4462193549,
-0.7273666859,
0.3264980912,
0.8338577747,
0.6309052706,
-0.0816458762,
-0.1764738113,
-0.1911443174,
0.3159681559,
-0.087896049,
0.5846010447,
-0.4930081367,
-0.0459456705,
0.0503499173,
-0.0221714135,
-0.3118332326,
-0.6052219272,
0.3817089498,
-0.8360105157,
-0.1733251661,
-0.355596453,
-0.9646052718,
-0.3067681193,
0.3967389166,
-0.7181889415,
0.3245982528,
0.0711114928,
-0.6551334858,
0.2176318914,
-0.5245582461,
-0.0547625571,
-0.0244018193,
-0.386677593,
0.1738395095,
0.4928361773,
-0.2582414746,
0.6026568413,
-0.6460384727,
0.1187384278,
-0.2682017684,
-0.2374910265,
0.7372989058,
-0.1655959934,
0.9532883763,
0.0350509435,
-0.1103789359,
-0.0085656205,
-0.7711516023,
0.0081922999,
0.2329145521,
-0.0661146045,
-0.3420703113,
0.0884739235,
-0.0160025097,
0.4565364718,
0.2362165898,
-0.6320026517,
0.3585612476,
-0.5232353806,
0.6542246938,
0.7636936307,
-0.3948814869,
0.3430984914,
0.0095057478,
0.5511197448,
-0.1253251284,
-0.0956673473,
-0.0562502705,
-0.2056311667,
-0.5814262033,
-0.0868321285,
0.3858483434,
0.5243970752,
-0.9020880461,
0.4878379107,
-0.3901571929,
-0.0336674824,
-0.1926798224,
0.2698680162,
0.3261164129,
0.2538170516,
0.2335786074,
0.0647242814,
-0.2837432325,
-0.8669254184,
-0.0912934095,
-0.1427797377,
-0.0500693358,
0.3716591597,
0.731139183,
-0.3272376657,
0.9645031095,
-0.4824300408,
-0.3870683014,
-0.6084583402,
-0.1315030158,
0.2389087826,
-0.1977903545,
0.4873623252,
-0.7781995535,
-0.0810178444,
0.0551585928,
-0.9854342937,
-0.3609184623,
-0.0459118709,
0.1377115548,
0.1305323392,
0.4918013215,
-0.7383224964,
0.3191106021,
0.5831080079,
-0.5343589783,
0.4732775986,
-0.2076291591,
-0.2104903162,
-0.8250738978,
-0.0532594398,
-0.2149031162,
-0.2808361351,
-0.6686681509,
0.1430632025,
0.045171313,
0.3097296953,
-0.4154373109,
0.7944034338,
-0.4310958683,
-0.6194474697,
-0.3289060891,
0.6153350472,
0.1941148043,
0.1466658562,
0.2608598173,
0.3890377879,
0.5237764716,
-0.4628185034,
0.3618761301,
0.1824196726,
-0.6539310217,
0.0172160026,
-0.6131653786,
-0.2725688815,
-0.0137075605,
0.274146229,
-0.9576228261,
-0.1320653558,
-0.1425832659,
-0.0001285121,
0.0577483699,
-0.0787065551,
-1.0637973547,
-0.0517772287,
-0.0390496217,
0.2289338112,
0.4650161564,
-0.4799846709,
0.927161634,
0.1957194954,
0.1176803857,
-0.3462201953,
-0.6741939783,
0.0383065045,
-0.2406562716,
-0.7407031059,
0.2245485634,
0.1185739785,
-0.6946334243,
0.0723428056,
-0.1330880672,
-0.1011105776,
0.2580532432,
0.0011415177,
0.226319313,
-0.1579428464,
0.4538783133,
-0.2508025467,
-0.0219761636,
0.4053812325,
-0.26140064,
0.6971091032,
0.1174036562,
-0.1704290658,
-0.2553912103,
0.0041931984,
0.5352190137,
-0.1648633182,
1.1751350164,
0.3573005199,
-0.2950263023,
-0.5482480526,
-0.4411346018,
-0.3600179553,
-0.447601974,
0.4456736445,
-0.3596051931,
-0.9291928411,
0.7526975274,
-0.142533645,
0.1375078857,
0.6162551045,
0.2607868314,
-0.1550442278,
0.8195828199,
0.6778900623,
0.2512909174,
0.1203766763,
-0.3443528712,
0.169717595,
-0.8196505904,
-0.2165052295,
-0.4210529923,
-0.1451538354,
-0.4847579896,
-0.1443326771,
0.387282759,
0.0834771842,
-0.0614536516,
0.0345310271,
0.1411439031,
0.3251922727,
-0.2088359147,
-0.0111776078,
0.7008603811,
-0.006104453,
0.0799623206,
0.0850243345,
-0.6646568179,
-0.642649889,
0.8566735387,
0.4841204584,
0.9786149859,
0.295204103,
0.4569365978,
-0.0126903784,
-0.0420619808,
-0.7988373637,
0.8082032204,
-0.4458737969,
-0.6916460991,
-0.1969183236,
-0.6472616196,
-0.8198096752,
0.2304280847,
-0.3704695106,
-0.856018424,
-0.1055296138,
-0.01257159,
-0.1630485356,
0.4128319323,
-0.5984981656,
0.877671957,
-0.3942809701,
-0.102444008,
-0.3103468418,
-0.751778543,
0.454406023,
-0.2954791486,
0.5800575018,
-0.2632654309,
-0.2751029432,
0.7241082191,
-0.4516421556,
0.8593508601,
0.0314406753,
-0.6989478469,
0.0794711486,
0.0219520424,
0.3579303324,
-0.0494919717,
-0.3159631789,
0.0607013963,
0.1324168593,
-0.2997991443,
-1.0084531307,
0.5620002747,
-0.7129461765,
-0.6707712412,
-0.3076279759,
-0.7040343285,
-0.2382365614,
0.1208479106,
0.033160314,
0.4445223808,
0.2078597397,
0.110507004,
0.8457173109,
-0.3803090453,
0.3484906256,
0.7577941418,
-0.618260026,
0.3770176768,
0.5323420763,
0.3256081045,
0.8084890246,
0.5919665098,
0.3844147921,
-0.4343339205,
-0.6062549949,
-0.2048437148,
0.361071229,
-0.948159337,
0.0779225081,
-0.7435008287,
-0.4002484381,
-0.1526376456,
-0.0022297155,
-0.167083472,
-0.5767872334,
-0.0356676765,
0.027965039,
0.5174055696,
1.1000835896,
0.457390666,
0.4730681777,
-0.8941833377,
0.2642918229,
0.104892984,
0.2942880988,
0.0763221458,
-0.8475371599,
-0.1177823022,
-0.0098466221,
0.1836930215,
-0.7951913476,
0.1147237271,
-0.0372815467,
0.4916213453,
0.3659420609,
0.0657427609,
0.3452296555,
-0.3466770053,
0.6916494966,
-0.1732138693,
-1.0185213089,
0.4004054368,
-0.209927097,
0.0921307802,
0.0911416337,
0.2756591439,
-0.1098116264,
-0.3660809994,
-0.4428184927,
-0.6209573746,
0.8232471347,
0.2200853229,
0.0893774331,
0.2472653538,
0.7853508592,
0.1868160367,
0.1770147234,
-1.0366879702,
-0.1886823326,
0.3806961179,
-0.1488197893,
0.0007590784,
-0.3321067393,
0.0124971336,
0.2709387243,
0.4110302627,
0.1522013694,
0.0382284522,
-0.1243258119,
-0.2555762231,
0.2623556554,
0.6888209581,
0.283426404,
0.8177134395,
-0.2308855951,
0.4446407259,
0.2292271852,
-0.192890048,
-0.0238138922,
-0.0539654195,
-0.0583473258,
-0.2973994315,
0.8812357187,
0.6667999625,
0.0657500774,
-1.0569536686,
0.3752785027,
-0.0048954231,
-0.1042059287,
-0.4060438871,
0.3159638941,
0.11052192,
0.3206402063,
0.2193247825,
-0.4631329477,
0.1051957309,
-0.9165030122,
-0.1668813676,
0.6111878157,
-0.0530927479,
-0.3713746965,
0.3978227079,
-0.0627931803,
0.1027572602,
0.4455473125,
-0.2370727211,
-0.6072588563,
0.7240664959,
0.7048720121,
0.5194862485,
0.1838262677,
-0.074204579,
-0.207973063,
0.3674333096,
-0.0885623619,
0.4013098776,
0.3127732873,
-1.1144144535,
-0.7184771299,
-0.7485392094,
-0.357611984,
0.0952972844,
-0.3625468016,
0.0466234758,
-0.3449137807,
0.0475063026,
0.2168692052,
0.0529587008,
-0.6970917583,
0.1529700607,
0.026591152,
0.8956251144,
-0.9495910406,
0.8555967212,
0.7246058583,
-0.4310652018,
-1.0220718384,
-0.0084198602,
-0.0399483107,
-0.9281211495,
1.3583503962,
0.1319376081,
-0.2107157409,
0.0325344279,
-0.4131836295,
-0.6922457814,
1.2273157835,
0.4194513261,
-0.5459668636,
-0.1543809772,
0.3753660023,
0.5999366045,
-0.4037427902,
0.3756953478,
0.5455952883,
0.6936488152,
0.0127454987,
-1.0307193995,
0.0841102079,
0.1857753992,
-0.0213280153,
0.0791408569,
-0.5915178657,
0.7985375524,
-0.1599394977,
-0.1930435002,
0.1103937626,
0.4292773306,
0.1025194302,
0.092952311,
0.7215546966,
0.3797514737,
0.4103039503,
-0.0672098771,
1.2913845778,
-0.1842345148,
0.2649427652,
0.8014143109,
-0.7594285011,
0.8073930144,
0.3088504374,
-0.2142310143,
0.4993530512,
0.2140431404,
0.1926554143,
0.1695576906,
0.1820678562,
-0.2737091482,
-0.5172780752,
-0.4043233395,
-0.0032045376,
0.6943181753,
0.6087837219,
-0.4713353217,
-0.1096384674,
0.087111339,
-0.1749388278,
0.0414539203,
-0.5124068856,
0.7853642106,
0.3289071023,
-0.2568787932,
0.2742821872,
-0.0081276326,
0.3259825408,
-0.6717655659,
0.0467724651,
0.2096328735,
0.2868427336,
-0.3864468038,
-1.0842812061,
0.3784929514,
-0.1769744754,
-0.1516895741,
-0.2505971491,
0.7537359595,
-0.2859966457,
-0.4842720926,
0.7356496453,
0.710909903,
0.0657163262,
0.0971966386,
-0.269898802,
0.3213622868,
-0.1471986771,
-0.2183473557,
0.3837732673,
0.8217020035,
0.0313011147,
0.7915337682,
0.1089996174,
0.1987647116,
0.0625779256,
0.0371799394,
0.6482636333,
-0.7880414724,
-0.1409543604,
-0.9247934222,
0.1634202898,
0.0943517461,
0.1411392093,
0.7960188389,
0.3884946406,
0.7635298967,
-0.1276876926,
0.8057330251,
-0.0398382209,
0.3975867927,
-1.0834709406,
0.4669935703,
-0.8242604136,
0.7236385345,
-0.0094979275,
-0.9157871604,
-0.3049075902,
0.5085766912,
-0.4451477528,
0.1091932431,
0.67894876,
0.5859463811,
-0.0542371161,
0.0289580207,
0.4703826904,
0.656525135,
0.282691747,
0.5925792456,
1.1039600372,
-0.1181842759,
0.5433515906,
0.1377962381,
-0.0904725492,
0.0639617071,
-0.7828499079,
-1.1039680243,
-0.2670290172,
-0.0733270422,
-0.2000276595,
-0.0647777095,
0.9317191839,
0.295163542,
-0.5270479918,
-0.3238138556,
0.0180831235,
0.3215128779,
0.1721138954,
-0.2033704966,
0.3895552456,
-0.4202781022,
-0.4515312612,
0.2233278602,
0.4219239354,
-0.1162151694,
-0.4056808054,
-0.002892253,
-0.0622814745,
0.1352798641,
0.8585249186,
-0.0771914124,
-1.1544442177,
-0.4073599279,
0.1290008128,
-0.0853244513,
-0.2791653872,
0.8366573453,
-0.7234511375,
0.1588329822,
0.5917092562,
0.6600817442,
0.1719043404,
-0.340121299,
0.4468481839,
-0.5167594552,
-0.1033679917,
-0.1771125644,
0.7722086906,
-0.0859367698,
-0.1006599739,
0.5775806904,
0.0949319229,
-0.5378105044,
-0.5591382384,
0.4125949144,
-1.1740695238,
-0.461319685,
1.4622511864,
-0.2643977404,
-0.1319759935,
-0.2291643769,
-0.0636486337,
-0.030040985,
0.102461271,
0.4854160249,
0.6715283394,
-0.19928734,
-0.3677358329,
-0.9260451198,
0.1181349978,
0.3909053802,
-0.9024150372,
0.3288595974,
0.3953555226,
0.3188916147,
0.1534697413,
0.466124326,
0.0459255464,
-0.0355017111,
-0.3965643346,
-0.1926081628,
0.113067627,
-0.1531253159,
-0.2191542536,
0.097840026,
0.3819797635,
0.4647767842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17526v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17526v1
|
LumberChunker: Long-Form Narrative Document Segmentation
| 2024-06-25T13:08:35 | 2024-06-25T13:08:35 |
André V. Duarte, João Marques, Miguel Graça, Miguel Freire, Lei Li, Arlindo L. Oliveira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2
|
Modern NLP tasks increasingly rely on dense retrieval methods to access
up-to-date and relevant contextual information. We are motivated by the premise
that retrieval benefits from segments that can vary in size such that a
content's semantic independence is better captured. We propose LumberChunker, a
method leveraging an LLM to dynamically segment documents, which iteratively
prompts the LLM to identify the point within a group of sequential passages
where the content begins to shift. To evaluate our method, we introduce
GutenQA, a benchmark with 3000 "needle in a haystack" type of question-answer
pairs derived from 100 public domain narrative books available on Project
Gutenberg. Our experiments show that LumberChunker not only outperforms the
most competitive baseline by 7.37% in retrieval performance (DCG@20) but also
that, when integrated into a RAG pipeline, LumberChunker proves to be more
effective than other chunking methods and competitive baselines, such as the
Gemini 1.5M Pro. Our Code and Data are available at
https://github.com/joaodsmarques/LumberChunker
|
[
0.0980826765,
-0.8896211386,
0.6774217486,
0.4624841511,
-0.6381552219,
0.6339853406,
0.1604460031,
-0.6818856001,
0.4094946682,
0.4584080577,
-0.4707190096,
-0.4669761658,
-0.6088887453,
-0.03503884,
-0.7970277071,
0.7380572557,
-0.1488364637,
-0.3009756804,
-0.1817326993,
-0.1064090282,
-0.5869845152,
-0.2201659381,
-0.4758036733,
-0.2279978544,
0.8613640666,
0.1585513204,
0.4508030117,
1.1065382957,
0.5556484461,
0.3176959753,
-0.3178756833,
-0.1536082029,
-0.4189696312,
0.5745964646,
-0.1950831264,
-0.6198143363,
-0.0867884681,
-0.162388429,
0.7399753928,
0.513721168,
-0.1372094899,
0.1115728095,
-0.0787987635,
0.652582705,
-0.4251183867,
-0.1947802156,
-0.7410091162,
-0.0537760518,
-0.770309329,
-0.2518847883,
-0.3188405931,
-0.4756150842,
0.2805345654,
-0.4887856841,
0.3907119632,
0.303593725,
0.9704135656,
0.175831899,
-0.4313556254,
-0.5350911021,
-0.317299515,
0.8351965547,
-0.4440330863,
0.3648327589,
0.3372136652,
0.1168009415,
0.0071030855,
-0.9884017706,
-0.2154007554,
0.0835386962,
-0.0695211589,
0.0779243708,
-0.2220348418,
-0.2312345654,
0.1381960958,
0.533270061,
-0.7718512416,
0.2292584926,
-0.5139234662,
-0.0450445265,
0.6301762462,
0.2251526117,
0.1185472161,
-0.863967061,
-0.5061798096,
-0.1547414958,
-0.2738561332,
0.2374434769,
0.4485017061,
-0.1698217243,
0.2710750401,
0.5560147762,
0.2363622487,
0.5287255645,
0.3495208025,
-0.5516408086,
0.1814397275,
0.0282889083,
-0.1970654875,
0.2907223403,
0.5152924061,
0.4419180751,
-0.3131605387,
-0.0316837318,
-0.2889903486,
-0.3987615108,
0.4671773016,
-0.785589397,
-0.2662798464,
0.333588928,
-0.5880866051,
-0.1725677848,
-0.0526686683,
-0.7911878824,
-0.510237813,
-0.2236868739,
0.0010985306,
-0.72679317,
0.1315307617,
0.0417760052,
-0.771535933,
0.5107441545,
0.5145885348,
-0.9765018821,
0.0700958371,
1.0533055067,
1.2181142569,
-0.6442635059,
0.0272778831,
-0.5115745664,
0.3264231682,
-0.2919582129,
1.1917586327,
-0.417828083,
-0.5427030921,
-0.2320053428,
0.1411426663,
-0.033421088,
-0.7853358388,
0.5760130882,
-0.3885416389,
0.3266471922,
0.0370079316,
-0.4330828786,
-0.0512080081,
0.5989238024,
-0.8137263656,
1.3973017931,
0.3036207259,
-0.7368934155,
0.320985049,
-0.0273126606,
-0.3055659235,
0.300383538,
-0.1715225279,
-0.2501760125,
0.3633563221,
0.2073226273,
0.1959467679,
-0.1993065178,
0.4620243907,
0.008324814,
-0.0910287723,
0.0662788227,
-0.5449723601,
0.6675477028,
-0.1193292961,
-0.0878183916,
0.2196602523,
-0.7938392162,
-0.0292158816,
0.0717018843,
-0.5892714262,
-0.5982100368,
0.0674246252,
0.2781963646,
-0.1648150831,
0.164641425,
-0.5601093173,
0.2661306858,
-0.4574640095,
-0.0410254411,
0.8335831165,
0.1113326177,
0.3478091955,
-0.5616835952,
0.6176558733,
-0.3982413709,
-0.0791615248,
-0.4937286377,
-0.1716579199,
-0.6560313106,
-0.5354821086,
0.4941554964,
0.4928172231,
-0.4585374296,
0.631267786,
-0.1776268184,
-0.5896295309,
-0.2884368598,
-0.1250065565,
-0.0366903096,
0.5004613996,
0.359331876,
-0.5056244135,
-0.5345512033,
-0.9118662477,
-0.164544642,
-0.1397428066,
-0.5811828375,
-0.0638952404,
0.2741274834,
0.0973719433,
0.9716287851,
-0.8030468225,
-0.2701900899,
-0.0485704057,
0.331738323,
0.4650472105,
0.3066107929,
0.3531982303,
-0.935274899,
-0.6873373985,
-0.1555441022,
-0.5272164345,
-0.0905348212,
-0.4505651295,
-0.2133931667,
-0.065765366,
0.6026390791,
-0.5187135339,
0.4362911582,
0.4254904985,
-0.3125784099,
0.749342978,
-0.1482846439,
-0.2461123765,
-0.9494590163,
0.1842261702,
-0.1725148112,
-0.2700826228,
-0.1523032784,
-0.0763884783,
0.0598358065,
0.2087082416,
-0.1771125495,
0.6504849792,
-0.5932795405,
0.0982548073,
-0.2261174768,
0.4747104049,
0.2569094598,
0.3275281787,
0.0971306264,
0.2984754443,
0.1538366824,
-0.0924230143,
0.2954663932,
0.4186970294,
-0.5878240466,
0.953610003,
-0.6706089377,
0.0958273187,
-0.2789796889,
0.5632460117,
-0.8175427318,
-0.1606484056,
0.1416953504,
-0.0598507971,
0.3852969408,
-0.1975030452,
-0.3681785166,
-0.2093726546,
-0.7112548351,
0.2636937797,
0.2058163732,
-0.4771963358,
0.7629855275,
0.5084558725,
-0.4521565437,
-0.5272129774,
-0.4352668524,
0.1798751801,
-0.396898061,
-0.723362565,
0.7328372002,
-0.2449190766,
-0.2987530529,
-0.154654488,
-0.6831838489,
-0.1477797627,
-0.057051979,
0.3575305939,
0.2253046781,
-0.2228074968,
0.2124281824,
0.1531597972,
-0.2960981429,
-0.00283764,
-0.373721838,
0.3846536577,
0.2164526135,
-0.2473817319,
0.3944730163,
0.5355675817,
0.1298569888,
-0.3557882607,
0.2856386602,
0.5033085346,
-0.2706624568,
-0.317440331,
-0.7053460479,
0.2923691273,
-0.4816072583,
0.3494203985,
-0.1934333146,
-1.03350389,
0.2031203359,
-0.2064035833,
0.1913490891,
0.4883081317,
0.2693873048,
-0.3335674107,
0.5891820788,
0.4756686389,
0.0456237569,
0.5462543368,
-0.1516239196,
0.0574882776,
-0.9711806178,
-0.5761376619,
-0.6320279241,
-0.7932411432,
-0.2862966657,
-0.876886487,
0.248950541,
0.4707374573,
0.3093055189,
0.3188548684,
-0.6471802592,
0.8338781595,
0.4342208803,
-0.1647924632,
0.4372361302,
-0.1055163965,
-0.3366567791,
-0.1029587016,
-0.5833295584,
-0.5247700214,
0.4952687919,
0.4354566336,
0.7692351341,
-0.0906145945,
0.7460331917,
0.0783103183,
0.3510396481,
-1.1766273975,
0.4472078681,
-0.1568199694,
-0.6696022749,
-0.5638908148,
0.0363288522,
-1.3883856535,
0.4001316428,
0.0004397271,
-1.0873054266,
0.307418257,
-0.303729862,
-0.1756686866,
0.2390096933,
-0.2091284841,
0.6707710624,
-0.7441433072,
-0.2577369511,
-0.1567154229,
-0.7267147899,
0.0010062011,
-0.5599618554,
0.0235301089,
-0.4840310514,
-0.2372171283,
0.9477398396,
-0.0995898247,
0.5765733123,
0.0275494251,
-0.0686884522,
0.3057666421,
0.1972008646,
0.4524919391,
0.0904669017,
-0.18802692,
0.0358918272,
0.2924815416,
-0.2759349346,
-0.5675524473,
0.4225941896,
-0.2891195118,
-0.6728659272,
-0.6158659458,
-0.421361357,
0.0587462597,
0.5921518803,
0.1124264374,
0.4889176488,
-0.4755959213,
0.9526949525,
0.4327655733,
-0.0223521162,
0.5647920966,
0.395548135,
-0.4342033565,
-0.4087921381,
0.4915448725,
0.148029685,
-0.3912326992,
0.8196179271,
0.3312062025,
-0.3721143603,
-1.0035769939,
-0.2631462812,
0.352506727,
-0.6280367374,
-0.3371414542,
-0.5956870317,
-0.2023065686,
0.2131450921,
-0.5519640446,
-0.244796738,
-0.351714313,
-0.1118856147,
-0.3324236572,
-0.0617723241,
0.6386768818,
0.3465791643,
0.3652772307,
-0.9689462781,
0.2270326018,
0.1611470878,
0.3413362801,
-0.0421209186,
-0.328663677,
-0.3627631962,
-0.5924353004,
-0.494215399,
-0.7805472612,
0.4767515957,
-0.1118721068,
0.7561628222,
0.2186529636,
0.0451874807,
0.7103094459,
-0.6057716012,
0.5937057137,
0.3140480816,
-0.7793464065,
0.3907275796,
-0.5604652166,
0.8563479185,
0.7789652944,
0.7630224228,
-0.9514164925,
-0.4205508232,
-0.5883648396,
-1.2079770565,
0.555832088,
0.0276867505,
-0.0840787813,
-0.1064617112,
0.03332223,
0.3042916656,
0.0298897512,
-0.5069032907,
0.3231088817,
-0.1038742885,
-0.2106779218,
0.2756929994,
-0.3775562346,
-0.0505481698,
-0.0313532464,
0.3820670545,
-0.3229919076,
-0.1811664402,
0.2454663515,
-0.2635415196,
-0.1136321574,
0.1390435398,
0.0578927398,
1.1199431419,
-0.4161460102,
0.1414652914,
0.0796942636,
-0.5731118321,
0.0836828128,
0.2359189689,
-0.1982244551,
0.3060919642,
0.7709097266,
0.6825188994,
0.4829739034,
-0.7158905268,
0.3462306261,
0.0087831253,
-0.4726034999,
-0.2742964625,
-0.0774377808,
0.3477189243,
0.5795449018,
0.8243649006,
-0.155709669,
-0.0380217209,
-0.3502582908,
0.3171775341,
0.2848504782,
-0.4309364259,
-0.1496267319,
0.3156277239,
0.2880397141,
-0.6973260641,
0.8247548938,
0.2503903508,
-0.4261060953,
0.4794868529,
0.3827590048,
0.9193774462,
-0.112805292,
0.3252234757,
0.2283412963,
0.1465473473,
-0.1034929976,
-0.2449071407,
-0.2178322673,
-0.3275793195,
-0.3312260509,
-0.9057465792,
-0.3199475706,
0.059688665,
-0.4541909993,
0.4503684342,
-0.4168452024,
-0.0946372673,
-0.0074390098,
-0.0736258328,
-0.252206713,
0.155585885,
0.1449601948,
1.1295439005,
-0.0607102625,
0.7935931683,
0.2494917661,
0.0890425146,
-0.6934683919,
0.3503703475,
0.2120951116,
-0.5189098716,
0.3697952926,
0.3896643519,
0.0281239282,
-0.2412413359,
-0.268256247,
-0.9942172766,
1.4475756884,
0.1295669526,
-0.7400840521,
-0.627517581,
-0.1114459783,
0.5362938643,
-0.0633819029,
0.3501342237,
0.5146918297,
0.6006264091,
0.4680069387,
-0.7945470214,
-0.2019565254,
-0.1099834889,
-0.0805609971,
0.5647527575,
-0.6225177646,
0.5301865935,
0.3515220881,
-0.3827497065,
0.1370181888,
0.569288373,
0.3258534372,
0.4651142061,
0.757842958,
0.2051577419,
1.1477468014,
0.0038091938,
0.7907495499,
-0.0868314728,
0.1736809015,
1.2021940947,
-0.0599522702,
1.054707408,
0.5865235925,
-0.1174317226,
0.8549815416,
0.5230107307,
-0.2675006092,
0.2623556554,
0.3996998072,
-0.0897226706,
0.0044149444,
-0.0858912691,
-0.0886871293,
0.6890158057,
0.1731220633,
-0.3346109092,
-0.4684856832,
-0.2887097895,
0.0702531636,
-0.0156482253,
0.0307033136,
0.6591048241,
0.2678612471,
-0.8103840947,
0.3898915946,
0.2080462575,
0.6358326077,
-1.1934661865,
0.0812786296,
-0.2842932045,
0.1119135916,
-0.1855351925,
-0.878058672,
0.5678162575,
-0.0229347274,
-0.1862727255,
-0.6177761555,
0.9935738444,
-0.3436207771,
-0.4829524457,
0.2997553349,
0.4585511386,
-0.0334358327,
-0.1864700615,
-0.7004005313,
0.2642249465,
0.0790199265,
-0.4156059325,
0.3967741132,
0.6356785893,
-0.2649310529,
0.4031096995,
0.6757854223,
-0.1454938948,
-0.147543788,
-0.2989501655,
0.8349121213,
-0.8137676716,
-0.6579669714,
-0.8015084863,
0.7462228537,
-0.4084407389,
-0.3962154388,
1.0802224874,
1.0427416563,
0.6594384313,
0.0506597124,
0.3855656087,
-0.0801745504,
0.5254632831,
-0.5012004375,
0.4260534644,
-0.3564376533,
0.1472405642,
-0.1371524036,
-1.1999204159,
-0.2768349349,
0.4463294148,
-0.2946841717,
-0.4982308745,
1.1502506733,
0.4867232144,
-0.0384571888,
0.0512138158,
0.106906794,
-0.0246720277,
0.4652568996,
0.1998302341,
0.904499948,
-0.0250340272,
0.7690031528,
-0.0018617085,
-0.1107488722,
-0.0545824431,
-1.109112978,
-0.7657131553,
-0.5267173052,
-0.1886213422,
-0.0303017795,
0.0285328254,
0.6491815448,
0.7994859219,
-0.3267685771,
-0.6438587904,
0.3786967993,
0.3228571713,
-0.0159726217,
-0.210099712,
0.4345733821,
-0.0995277539,
-0.6055521369,
0.7089922428,
0.7245978713,
-0.2784845233,
-0.1098356098,
0.0937599465,
-0.4309287667,
0.1734881699,
0.5723173618,
-0.0071687545,
-0.4746105969,
-0.2950483561,
0.1317488849,
0.0519295037,
0.5241938233,
1.2120082378,
-0.8214386106,
0.3992868066,
0.7134861946,
0.6363147497,
1.2469670773,
0.3234433234,
0.3802684247,
-0.9159761667,
-0.0579241589,
0.5909941196,
0.0655994043,
0.306538105,
-0.238377288,
0.6213233471,
0.3263475299,
-0.5628815889,
-0.5692957044,
-0.0917189941,
-1.1363735199,
-0.538498044,
0.8739135861,
0.0267108455,
-0.5575762391,
-0.21431382,
-0.5599904656,
-0.1917223036,
-0.3128422499,
0.6362327337,
0.8208808303,
-0.1808578223,
-0.276417315,
-0.1978960335,
0.1533914953,
0.0315135606,
-0.9276126027,
-0.0344576091,
0.7460566759,
0.1436681002,
0.3657172024,
0.8542132378,
-0.0320604555,
-0.1644030958,
0.2237436473,
-0.4491560161,
0.0824781284,
-0.2713601589,
-0.1587506384,
0.6266416311,
-0.0696757734,
0.2342197299
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17519v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17519v1
|
Entropy-Based Decoding for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-06-25T12:59:38 | 2024-06-25T12:59:38 |
Zexuan Qiu, Zijing Ou, Bin Wu, Jingjing Li, Aiwei Liu, Irwin King
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Augmenting Large Language Models (LLMs) with retrieved external knowledge has
proven effective for improving the factual accuracy of generated responses.
Despite their success, retrieval-augmented LLMs still face the distractibility
issue, where the generated responses are negatively influenced by noise from
both external and internal knowledge sources. In this paper, we introduce a
novel, training-free decoding method guided by entropy considerations to
mitigate this issue. Our approach utilizes entropy-based document-parallel
ensemble decoding to prioritize low-entropy distributions from retrieved
documents, thereby enhancing the extraction of relevant information of context.
Additionally, it incorporates a contrastive decoding mechanism that contrasts
the obtained low-entropy ensemble distribution with the high-entropy
distribution derived from the model's internal knowledge across layers, which
ensures a greater emphasis on reliable external information. Extensive
experiments on open-domain question answering datasets demonstrate the
superiority of our method.
|
[
-0.0774330646,
-0.3565717638,
0.6133310795,
0.1528579295,
-0.4419097006,
-0.0497056954,
-0.4794231653,
-0.4607563317,
0.2280145586,
0.3807986379,
-0.2985894978,
-0.3606176972,
-0.5784282684,
0.074966915,
-0.302831769,
0.7806087732,
0.0093742618,
0.1691699922,
-0.6278509498,
0.1454079598,
-0.0268162228,
-0.4469233155,
-0.6420034766,
-0.3635037839,
0.4554686248,
0.1359778345,
0.1467285007,
0.4824104905,
0.5222251415,
0.2729610205,
-0.1510132253,
0.3235273957,
-0.6432292461,
0.374048382,
-0.2543777227,
-0.5873927474,
0.0400191396,
-0.4317863882,
0.6863254309,
0.4074707031,
-0.1434586942,
-0.0058194236,
0.3182399869,
0.5046699047,
-1.1047730446,
0.3352387846,
-0.8752319217,
-0.2474483401,
-0.0435650982,
-0.6019749641,
-0.6561814547,
-0.0451389998,
-0.1016413495,
-0.592253387,
0.2179960608,
0.0329307392,
0.4764623642,
0.3023864925,
-0.1438317001,
-0.4050824046,
-0.5545445681,
0.8702841997,
-0.56349051,
0.4990436137,
0.8711333871,
-0.2205031216,
0.1896976531,
-0.4121280313,
-0.3378814161,
0.0917343497,
-0.0453045294,
0.1668831557,
0.0310279932,
0.0051097129,
-0.0970208794,
0.4057566524,
-0.4274380803,
0.061379157,
-0.3016915321,
-0.2435891777,
0.4224103987,
0.0375517756,
0.1405317932,
0.0373483934,
-0.2059020251,
-0.2466569245,
-0.4018676281,
-0.1432128698,
0.260299772,
0.3994333148,
-0.1268023551,
0.3543843031,
-0.4335540831,
0.4617215395,
0.2200838625,
-0.0898521543,
0.4022231102,
-0.1802586615,
-0.407891959,
0.1881752908,
0.5251576304,
0.1504597515,
-0.2057306916,
-0.6497585773,
-0.3498689234,
-0.3895269036,
0.1778670996,
-0.8614429832,
-0.1186547801,
0.3866009414,
-0.3881546259,
-0.2696961462,
-0.0023299826,
-0.6224134564,
-0.5192096829,
-0.2461486608,
0.4068056643,
-0.6563948393,
-0.169337973,
0.0707518682,
-0.3590269089,
0.2086779475,
0.4851815999,
-1.0087660551,
0.0299065262,
0.6308806539,
0.6923527718,
-0.1041824818,
-0.0997436866,
-0.7283921838,
0.4538788795,
-0.3065343797,
0.719741106,
-0.6031191945,
-0.1598828733,
-0.0266318228,
-0.2102749795,
-0.1665187031,
-0.6660049558,
0.5230197906,
-0.9826187491,
0.0966798067,
-0.3508574665,
-0.6396006942,
0.0345314443,
0.4117854536,
-0.4791933,
0.6520878077,
-0.0750301555,
-1.1305522919,
0.0625414103,
-0.2947650552,
-0.2920522988,
0.1188137829,
-0.0113592502,
-0.0451917797,
0.1750422418,
0.4164201021,
0.2328304201,
-0.4299937189,
-0.0192916803,
-0.2763736546,
-0.4258134663,
-0.0218464565,
-0.57601583,
0.6414989829,
0.3674387336,
0.1183225587,
-0.0313519649,
-0.8690622449,
0.1781463176,
0.0365710184,
-0.7430339456,
-0.7751420736,
-0.0538913496,
-0.2731122673,
-0.0510735698,
0.3666940629,
-0.4916161001,
-0.1327395588,
-0.4867396057,
0.0649933517,
0.7586304545,
0.2073969245,
0.5705763102,
-0.371986568,
0.2108008265,
0.3774192929,
-0.4282647073,
-0.1281792074,
-0.0840980038,
-0.6255578995,
-0.7434443831,
0.0685192123,
0.7915925384,
-1.1120252609,
0.4631557465,
-0.3413540721,
-0.226902768,
-0.6153956056,
0.4354602098,
0.3978474438,
0.637932241,
0.4943323135,
-0.1378590018,
-0.5458942652,
-0.4593914449,
-0.1676834375,
-0.171727404,
-0.2676294446,
0.2581814229,
0.3566709459,
-0.1140435487,
0.4408176541,
-0.4757059216,
-0.0318058096,
-0.0297899786,
0.1331971735,
0.0496700257,
0.5786914229,
0.0443790555,
-0.5488340259,
-0.3753693104,
-0.0464661382,
-0.8575545549,
0.1192367673,
-0.0284758769,
-0.3752268553,
0.2138807774,
0.7246454954,
-0.7942644954,
0.1418518275,
-0.0080254879,
-0.0406917743,
0.3740099669,
-0.3144934475,
0.1408116072,
-1.0063972473,
0.1528236121,
-0.1055976003,
0.0623707473,
-0.4131837785,
0.3198261559,
0.2265863121,
0.1565387994,
-0.3114163578,
0.6604042649,
-0.5295366645,
0.2928050756,
-0.2127201855,
-0.1024685651,
0.0805497915,
0.3850881457,
0.289719671,
0.763515234,
0.5196937323,
-0.6214405894,
0.211406514,
0.2209371179,
-0.6135401726,
0.6106486917,
-0.1891601533,
0.3630261123,
-0.6612468362,
0.072243847,
-0.7947812676,
-0.4873933494,
0.2143373787,
-0.2973873317,
0.4850013554,
-0.1951856017,
-0.5698361993,
-0.1527670473,
-0.4624962211,
0.468533814,
0.3653148413,
-0.6701537967,
0.2648186982,
0.0604321398,
-0.210534811,
-0.7299853563,
-0.806766808,
-0.0746605918,
-0.3071537614,
-0.5457923412,
0.1745430827,
-0.2595239878,
-0.4430981576,
-0.1257144958,
-0.1492246538,
-0.2871598303,
0.0714260638,
-0.1680270135,
-0.0152773438,
-0.2344613969,
0.3871210515,
-0.0658314899,
0.3285644054,
0.0130477222,
-0.439149797,
0.4763185382,
0.2067682445,
-0.2645330727,
-0.2344459742,
0.3955544829,
0.4615210593,
-0.3632349074,
1.1367075443,
0.6361732483,
-0.3599367142,
-0.2715625167,
-0.5451236367,
-0.3084254265,
-0.5125488639,
0.2853049338,
-0.3846651614,
-0.733818233,
0.6596146822,
0.2970537543,
-0.2441190928,
0.2677852511,
0.568104744,
-0.0905701518,
0.5351265669,
0.4508061409,
-0.2229001522,
0.6072192788,
-0.018616626,
0.0420334414,
-0.8713929653,
-0.4414868057,
-0.4953353107,
-0.0352197066,
-0.1479658335,
-0.6478999853,
0.1819203049,
0.2691388726,
-0.3092343211,
-0.1420381963,
-0.4538820386,
0.4831237495,
0.8139926791,
0.4405447841,
0.2553342879,
0.4304683208,
-0.237802133,
0.2034619898,
-0.6003851891,
0.0227546282,
1.0573388338,
0.0762623027,
1.0761324167,
0.141077444,
1.0916478634,
0.167849198,
0.0754237175,
-0.5755187869,
0.3546789289,
0.0333345644,
-0.444316119,
-0.4796815813,
-0.7727108002,
-0.9240559936,
0.4655773342,
-0.0359166078,
-0.91988343,
0.3995357454,
-0.0438829474,
-0.2768312395,
0.4206622839,
-0.7600387335,
0.3675089478,
0.06832809,
-0.6105821729,
-0.0921135321,
-0.5624320507,
0.4899301231,
-0.1149280295,
0.159675017,
0.2024715096,
0.0341646187,
0.5350993872,
-0.2716273963,
0.7521333098,
-0.1566147655,
-0.3838948607,
0.4379188716,
0.0470267311,
0.7955679297,
-0.0047405977,
-0.5932810903,
-0.2402749956,
0.04399902,
-0.3939558268,
-0.4615163207,
0.7995685339,
-0.7470079064,
-0.6893270016,
-0.2193548679,
-0.9631325006,
-0.3787367344,
0.2360362262,
0.4079482257,
0.3542392552,
0.0164128821,
0.4879045784,
0.9251030684,
-0.2727220058,
0.4568073153,
0.5501070619,
0.4115531743,
-0.6649085283,
1.1335250139,
0.0288310312,
0.0830120221,
0.8345995545,
-0.0592450872,
-0.3445931077,
-0.6381908655,
-0.0851059929,
0.1001364887,
-0.9387893081,
-0.3928971589,
-0.6072205901,
-0.29469347,
-0.6943009496,
0.0388353132,
0.0640207157,
-0.1490754187,
-0.6786830425,
-0.1008148193,
0.157475695,
0.3162328899,
-0.1140421778,
0.1183651388,
-0.8641783595,
0.2526128292,
0.244124338,
0.4926152825,
0.1962454319,
-0.6502657533,
-0.583052516,
-0.024656659,
-0.0607157685,
-0.6820415258,
0.4614428878,
0.0558690391,
0.589264214,
0.2846031487,
0.5204723477,
0.5443629622,
-0.3658322692,
0.5165029764,
0.0398066565,
-0.6726346612,
0.3751399517,
-0.4081854522,
0.4882939458,
0.5656309128,
0.1860089749,
-0.1275024414,
-0.5050570965,
-0.3835386336,
-1.056692481,
0.9064241052,
0.0610219054,
0.1666256636,
-0.3418570459,
0.2166066468,
0.0112491511,
0.2958431244,
-0.6044161916,
0.2117708027,
-0.0501338057,
-0.5405039787,
-0.0298142452,
-0.3997438252,
-0.1940082163,
-0.0733989254,
0.7966898084,
-0.044472836,
0.4318279028,
0.3410466909,
-0.428483963,
-0.1963700652,
0.4862399101,
0.5759676099,
0.3654124141,
-0.5904787183,
0.4252292216,
0.1392985433,
-0.4094246924,
0.0352710485,
0.1474244595,
-0.2072137743,
-0.1963876635,
0.4323492646,
0.7413458824,
-0.1442961693,
-0.5949231982,
0.285307318,
0.1664554924,
-0.162470296,
0.0005770577,
-0.0380239971,
0.1312568635,
0.3975713551,
0.5985527039,
0.0503530167,
0.1786025614,
-0.342520237,
0.228151083,
0.6045008898,
-0.0977264717,
-0.1367154121,
0.4697245359,
0.1403072178,
0.0223658662,
0.6369213462,
-0.1767240167,
-0.0000469001,
0.505378902,
0.7127625942,
0.7724667192,
-0.0808062032,
-0.0637313649,
0.4137251079,
0.3903280795,
-0.3230162561,
0.3346319795,
-0.3397616148,
-0.7023047209,
-0.2937721312,
-0.7155314684,
-0.218158856,
0.3801622689,
-0.7497903109,
-0.1726775914,
-0.2843001187,
0.2557246685,
-0.4260372519,
-0.1635630578,
-0.5700709224,
0.2963367105,
0.3664034605,
0.97808218,
-0.330449909,
1.0231912136,
0.3081460297,
-0.39459759,
-0.3939141333,
0.5430364609,
-0.2398121655,
-0.8613393307,
0.556925416,
0.0295752492,
-0.2655373514,
0.0945496559,
-0.5999481082,
-1.0575091839,
1.0437746048,
0.7475506663,
-0.2757169902,
-0.135331437,
-0.2111332864,
0.4895353615,
-0.1254794896,
0.2823428512,
0.1558643579,
0.1767293513,
0.1673536748,
-0.6558323503,
0.1652136147,
-0.3098802269,
-0.1707171947,
-0.0605435148,
-0.5760806203,
0.5814106464,
-0.1599680185,
-0.2662681937,
0.2193137556,
0.6324987411,
0.1649217755,
0.3604683578,
0.2118879259,
0.6290496588,
1.1464517117,
0.3165365756,
1.2094610929,
-0.6070104837,
0.201913029,
1.2993901968,
-0.2220699936,
1.1566979885,
0.6316100955,
0.0739526451,
0.4035598338,
0.439391613,
0.2839223146,
1.0393687487,
0.223480612,
-0.6358676553,
-0.3506008983,
-0.0821955055,
-0.4492546022,
0.131705001,
0.5070171356,
-0.5864945054,
-0.2809178829,
-0.0852191076,
-0.3036527634,
-0.0925570875,
-0.5237432718,
0.9167478085,
0.0811466724,
-0.7081302404,
0.9114313126,
0.1339692473,
0.7787847519,
-0.568952322,
0.3629634976,
-0.3020429909,
0.2196957767,
-0.1609982997,
-0.7208551168,
0.2114359438,
-0.1445672065,
-0.5063075423,
-0.1839668304,
0.9027764797,
-0.8173450828,
-0.3950204253,
0.2313893139,
0.5174844265,
0.1902854592,
-0.2431793213,
-0.2792636156,
0.0133339139,
-0.079769291,
-0.1651851088,
0.539460063,
0.5470972061,
0.2221343517,
0.5707532167,
0.5037780404,
-0.1322951019,
0.0405294299,
-0.0098504862,
0.8280196786,
-0.3627074659,
-0.6777384281,
-0.7923534513,
0.2912604511,
0.0124151334,
0.2362162918,
0.688167274,
0.509636879,
0.6694580913,
-0.2970567048,
0.830933392,
0.253223896,
0.4356735051,
-0.7566747665,
0.6883926988,
-0.5769098997,
0.505577445,
-0.0077079148,
-0.5848509669,
-0.201256305,
0.3416849375,
-0.4221844077,
0.0253226422,
0.5777803063,
0.9504945874,
-0.1739833206,
-0.2807650864,
0.3799429238,
0.0996767208,
-0.13697128,
0.5821906328,
0.7195283771,
-0.1910623014,
0.8401574492,
-0.1060220003,
0.0632979721,
-0.1991778761,
-0.526332438,
-0.8538697362,
-0.4727630317,
-0.1801495999,
-0.4576820433,
0.2220535725,
0.8448462486,
0.5973966718,
-0.7970607281,
-0.0448198803,
-0.0425876379,
0.3125655949,
-0.0792756751,
-0.2281456739,
0.4261854291,
-0.8263652325,
-0.5837836266,
0.6750943661,
0.0528896451,
-0.0356501639,
0.2174206525,
-0.1608837694,
-0.2763666809,
0.4042318463,
0.6382703185,
0.2494283319,
-0.4949202836,
-0.203601405,
-0.093941316,
-0.3173784316,
0.3038556278,
0.5717929006,
-0.6602708697,
0.3777568936,
0.9150168896,
0.8860116005,
0.4585295618,
0.076504983,
0.4806085527,
-1.0918507576,
0.3234906197,
0.0755833089,
0.2414183468,
0.5012254715,
-0.719222784,
0.3269779682,
0.2786715031,
-0.2448893487,
-0.9134725332,
-0.0507110544,
-0.6843131781,
-0.4759444892,
1.2761290073,
-0.2822292447,
-0.230902791,
-0.0204958972,
0.0606754459,
0.1327481419,
-0.5322156549,
0.8628874421,
0.7743595243,
0.1808302402,
-0.4415732026,
-0.2209920734,
0.4950826466,
0.4637932181,
-0.7924736738,
0.1932233423,
0.4734437168,
0.3773374557,
0.1802843511,
0.6945907474,
0.0298084375,
0.1415652186,
0.2053860873,
0.0006955717,
-0.010416274,
-0.1671530604,
-0.4694646895,
0.4808552861,
0.1101320162,
-0.2541078925
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17513v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17513v2
|
Benchmarking Mental State Representations in Language Models
| 2024-06-25T12:51:06 | 2024-07-01T06:48:34 |
Matteo Bortoletto, Constantin Ruhdorfer, Lei Shi, Andreas Bulling
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While numerous works have assessed the generative performance of language
models (LMs) on tasks requiring Theory of Mind reasoning, research into the
models' internal representation of mental states remains limited. Recent work
has used probing to demonstrate that LMs can represent beliefs of themselves
and others. However, these claims are accompanied by limited evaluation, making
it difficult to assess how mental state representations are affected by model
design and training choices. We report an extensive benchmark with various LM
types with different model sizes, fine-tuning approaches, and prompt designs to
study the robustness of mental state representations and memorisation issues
within the probes. Our results show that the quality of models' internal
representations of the beliefs of others increases with model size and, more
crucially, with fine-tuning. We are the first to study how prompt variations
impact probing performance on theory of mind tasks. We demonstrate that models'
representations are sensitive to prompt variations, even when such variations
should be beneficial. Finally, we complement previous activation editing
experiments on Theory of Mind tasks and show that it is possible to improve
models' reasoning performance by steering their activations without the need to
train any probe.
|
[
-0.6371397972,
-0.5667370558,
0.8887410164,
-0.0114953583,
-0.1454135776,
-0.193797648,
-0.4874104261,
-0.3310255408,
0.0805307478,
0.1780973971,
-0.5050362945,
-0.0756773725,
-0.5661297441,
0.2526632249,
-0.1277328134,
0.5045830607,
-0.2017818689,
0.2028857619,
-0.3037798107,
-0.3243076801,
-0.5630857348,
-0.5892973542,
-0.6101737022,
-0.5689937472,
0.4546632469,
0.003738302,
0.6814753413,
0.4451577961,
0.4247105718,
0.1917907149,
-0.163830936,
0.2547429204,
-0.4876859784,
0.3431359231,
-0.4253937602,
-0.7411902547,
-0.1619192064,
0.2471515983,
0.9104872942,
0.6136858463,
-0.1611212194,
0.2287407368,
0.1193883345,
0.422509253,
-0.7756177187,
0.3052013814,
-0.7634724379,
-0.0788842887,
-0.0872292668,
-0.0000310732,
-0.6332941651,
-0.2759608328,
0.1058113277,
-0.3973375857,
0.2784445286,
0.2305296361,
0.734503448,
0.2877093852,
-0.3788763583,
-0.0072453087,
-0.7083547115,
0.7147372365,
-0.8678610325,
0.5461342335,
0.4303497374,
0.2092221975,
-0.177035898,
-0.4144742191,
-0.5022674203,
-0.5237910151,
-0.1792678535,
-0.1063988954,
-0.1688252687,
0.1669595838,
0.8352310061,
0.4477489889,
-0.242924124,
-0.0450905338,
0.0840720087,
-0.1973003745,
0.4307615459,
0.4826802909,
0.0882991105,
0.1099731103,
0.0925970227,
-0.5055521727,
-0.6153330207,
0.1739914566,
0.1015112773,
0.3239504397,
0.1155903637,
0.6237232089,
-0.3366009891,
0.6158245206,
0.2490567863,
0.1762845963,
-0.1514721513,
-0.0422659256,
-0.3714296222,
-0.347294867,
0.6109498739,
0.485317111,
0.2033893466,
-0.0256995354,
-0.4109455347,
0.4224079251,
0.350383848,
-0.7667374015,
-0.2382728457,
-0.0644658878,
-0.3447613716,
0.2254999578,
-0.0875830054,
-0.3501596451,
-0.6578163505,
-0.2897943258,
0.5647680759,
-0.6487240195,
-0.3818183243,
0.2582172453,
-0.1174822301,
0.1094965413,
0.3591381609,
-1.0327528715,
0.490142405,
0.6058760881,
0.6410039067,
-0.0441689305,
-0.3566346467,
-0.2888391912,
-0.044538632,
-0.7707361579,
0.7872447968,
-0.6252934933,
-0.4999896288,
-0.047976356,
-0.1366960555,
-0.2494129688,
-0.575396657,
0.3528544009,
-0.3889911473,
0.0799604431,
-0.9415302873,
-1.1237221956,
-0.1930423677,
0.2598010302,
-0.765065372,
1.0225690603,
0.0694758445,
-0.718826592,
0.4124970734,
-0.4011993408,
-0.1521496177,
-0.1488171071,
-0.500880003,
-0.0403609648,
0.6615395546,
0.1532990783,
0.5056356788,
-0.4932861328,
0.1127733737,
-0.3428600729,
-0.5032880902,
0.6293459535,
-0.2395200878,
0.5659157634,
0.0737835839,
-0.2501922846,
0.1521335244,
-0.4707655311,
0.1505140364,
0.2982460558,
-0.1893036515,
-0.4017109275,
0.1795984656,
-0.418152988,
-0.0095709143,
0.1550973058,
-0.4961757064,
0.3010180891,
-0.3218067884,
0.1504961103,
0.5287953019,
0.1544923186,
0.3882957399,
-0.452203244,
0.436106056,
0.1332287788,
-0.0920418277,
-0.2823800147,
-0.4691358805,
-0.9227807522,
-0.0073791407,
0.2564788163,
0.2306223065,
-0.3094300032,
0.1188502312,
-0.0808745101,
-0.517226398,
-0.6858959198,
-0.0812571123,
0.3357634246,
0.3202677369,
0.291310519,
-0.3109412491,
-0.1718436033,
-1.1293119192,
-0.6965962052,
-0.2072043568,
-0.0562414117,
0.1683379412,
0.5237854719,
0.054160744,
0.9032306075,
-0.5620493293,
0.1046018526,
-0.176085934,
0.2549575567,
0.0990789384,
0.3876937628,
0.5858363509,
-0.3114298284,
-0.2232259512,
-0.2628287077,
-0.5743190646,
0.1946390867,
-0.1341259778,
0.0186177194,
0.1030176058,
0.4523343444,
-0.8140949011,
0.3416269124,
0.242529586,
-0.3540214002,
0.5239773393,
-0.2807749212,
0.3096382618,
-0.7572970986,
-0.0201255102,
0.2541053891,
-0.1927455068,
-0.6321191788,
0.3472164869,
0.6312437654,
-0.0894737989,
-0.0721670836,
0.6038745642,
-0.5587004423,
0.1147210449,
-0.2727984786,
-0.058331728,
-0.097846441,
0.541811645,
-0.001723813,
0.8585652709,
0.5319797397,
-0.6190196276,
0.0334392115,
-0.1604028344,
-0.6714631915,
0.4851364493,
-0.5874378085,
0.4473646283,
-0.1758137345,
0.0591657721,
-0.8734047413,
-0.0646694303,
0.0423204117,
-0.2402085215,
0.3226195276,
0.0035116735,
-0.7651905417,
-0.1590610743,
-0.0773226023,
0.2812457085,
0.5734708905,
-0.2772571743,
0.5692488551,
0.1944154948,
0.1981147975,
-0.1343444884,
-0.4108431041,
-0.1340153664,
-0.405202657,
-0.2100426257,
0.3477336168,
-0.2046112716,
-0.5350885391,
-0.0961700678,
-0.3527038395,
0.0651556402,
0.1777371913,
0.1439039707,
0.0954001471,
-0.3018567264,
0.1749508381,
0.0891950428,
0.0459215529,
0.4650260508,
-0.0893252641,
0.4875226915,
-0.2314733565,
-0.4682650268,
-0.3541076183,
0.4723829627,
0.4723742604,
-0.4400144815,
0.7782649398,
0.2074207962,
-0.7583848238,
-0.4269972146,
-0.7398662567,
-0.490539521,
-0.4871796966,
0.1896075159,
-0.6880508065,
-0.9449648261,
0.58057338,
-0.0926706716,
-0.0062283836,
0.4770966172,
0.4446418583,
-0.1473301202,
1.3051612377,
0.6706724763,
-0.1361733824,
0.4202696383,
-0.048960913,
-0.0088138739,
-0.8711531758,
0.0695966929,
-0.454595089,
-0.2082873136,
-0.364351511,
-0.5439395905,
0.2223594189,
0.2210351676,
-0.2762567699,
0.2173018008,
-0.3180690408,
0.531802237,
0.5234798789,
0.169943735,
0.1206587926,
-0.2277946621,
-0.5304676294,
-0.2974436879,
-0.5714328289,
-0.6276625395,
1.024862051,
0.3316472769,
0.7915530205,
0.0368818268,
0.4950704575,
0.1606736928,
0.2770177722,
-0.6868411303,
0.7892846465,
0.1055423841,
-0.8029851317,
-0.171919331,
-0.2562529445,
-0.6237307191,
0.3416582346,
-0.1516593993,
-0.9416717291,
0.2119384557,
0.2212315649,
-0.3772327006,
0.3406858742,
-0.6510130763,
0.7380555272,
0.0098537188,
-0.060077861,
-0.6002416611,
-0.1782687157,
0.1536183208,
0.1597367525,
-0.3072282076,
-0.2733424008,
0.1254859716,
0.644862473,
-0.0795049742,
0.8974983096,
-0.2418513298,
-0.3577982485,
0.2188483328,
0.5402439833,
0.6059722304,
0.0612465926,
-0.2058725208,
-0.1178842485,
0.1467577219,
-0.2769039869,
-0.8887675405,
0.5094550252,
-0.5359082818,
-0.9398017526,
-0.2831674516,
-0.7339031696,
-0.6597169638,
0.1898667663,
0.1715371758,
0.4912656844,
-0.3614017367,
-0.0165177248,
0.9690726399,
0.086054787,
0.1945174187,
0.4796588719,
-0.2845925391,
-0.0237968415,
0.6258542538,
0.1633285582,
0.3914302289,
0.357622236,
-0.0347881131,
-0.237813741,
-0.5318258405,
-0.2751305103,
0.3180109859,
-1.0163034201,
0.0415328965,
-0.3396606743,
0.027313849,
-0.3363526762,
0.3194076717,
-0.5596801639,
-0.2381213754,
-0.3523586988,
-0.0454180501,
0.3973829746,
0.8368860483,
0.1832374483,
0.0460376926,
-0.1810113341,
0.2408867627,
0.3780258,
0.6028606892,
0.1154030859,
-0.5167720318,
-0.4775128067,
0.0455679446,
-0.1597786695,
-1.104391098,
-0.0675468519,
-0.0074355914,
0.8055630326,
0.4647320509,
0.0329058841,
0.7279161811,
-0.4993562698,
0.7094144821,
-0.0965118408,
-1.0362907648,
0.6193768978,
-0.4194022715,
0.4479145408,
0.5502379537,
0.4507577419,
-0.6089389324,
-0.5671599507,
-0.4036683142,
-0.1747808754,
0.5343449712,
-0.0779369324,
0.1036355346,
-0.1719813198,
0.5908672214,
0.0738869682,
-0.0271466728,
-0.462744385,
-0.3917846084,
-0.0650570467,
-0.0272756089,
-0.2751076519,
-0.3325894177,
-0.281971395,
-0.4189804196,
0.4184636772,
-0.2664137185,
0.5168044567,
0.27207762,
-0.1823158413,
-0.0730876923,
0.2247453481,
0.6702108383,
0.6916734576,
-0.1954056472,
0.210436359,
0.436948806,
-0.08987239,
0.1315242052,
0.0650670975,
-0.1299868077,
0.0373277739,
0.232553035,
1.0073481798,
0.2455602437,
-0.5245611668,
0.017801363,
-0.1755208224,
0.0130932936,
0.0200376548,
0.5216536522,
0.2036571056,
0.4352446795,
0.2185187787,
0.0977950096,
0.0123349056,
-0.5021035075,
-0.2384999841,
0.4985488057,
-0.3190860152,
-0.4485148489,
0.6670632958,
-0.2840166092,
-0.337751478,
0.5058099031,
-0.3748015165,
-0.3099786937,
0.4378257692,
0.6122903824,
0.778311193,
-0.3518487215,
-0.0271308273,
0.4909855425,
0.4703437984,
-0.4300088584,
0.4385548532,
-0.0833138749,
-1.0432995558,
-0.1934247762,
-0.0813176185,
-0.6693426371,
0.3355104923,
-1.0120776892,
-0.0489526466,
-0.5294344425,
-0.5934119821,
-0.1926078647,
0.0588119626,
-0.9357992411,
0.2923020422,
0.359523356,
1.0861039162,
-0.7038382888,
0.9345260262,
0.9769889712,
-0.2676248252,
-0.8661800027,
0.1350853294,
-0.0170601495,
-0.5417361856,
0.2540084422,
0.1694846898,
-0.2863830626,
-0.003427559,
-0.3674717546,
-0.983286202,
0.8121764064,
0.7003697753,
-0.5602989793,
0.0568206087,
-0.0367840901,
0.6145985126,
-0.4051141739,
0.2915935814,
0.6899352074,
0.3293001354,
-0.6537026167,
-0.9354224205,
0.3255949914,
-0.3245619833,
0.1988571882,
0.0729596913,
-0.5277158022,
0.9781346321,
-0.1633045226,
-0.5516846776,
0.1614044309,
0.7984824181,
0.3520084321,
-0.0153450929,
0.5442822576,
0.5555551052,
1.0231206417,
-0.2008894384,
1.2286239862,
-0.3298392892,
0.3909988701,
1.2009234428,
-0.3355506957,
0.8407754898,
0.4447264373,
-0.2696875036,
0.430986315,
0.6917436719,
-0.0154077783,
0.4774220288,
0.3618194163,
-0.1661076397,
-0.4230360985,
-0.0077995174,
-0.3607277572,
0.1678374559,
0.6111305952,
-0.2863606215,
0.0483947769,
-0.039951317,
-0.1371358186,
0.1210740656,
-0.2476238906,
0.5661767125,
0.1005666852,
-0.9720733166,
0.6391942501,
0.0658963397,
0.5215001702,
-0.5261054039,
0.1696301848,
-0.4688796699,
0.1819015145,
0.3394007385,
-0.7266824245,
-0.1032676846,
-0.0644846484,
-0.2852790058,
-0.2546933591,
0.6777995825,
-0.2158198506,
-0.3290848136,
0.3232836723,
0.5007123947,
0.101561971,
-0.249926731,
-0.4763402939,
0.2759491801,
-0.1614603251,
-0.4704796076,
0.360213995,
0.484605372,
-0.0679418296,
0.757979095,
0.1521174908,
0.2529694736,
0.1624475569,
0.2205051482,
0.8198494315,
-1.0015611649,
-0.2696507573,
-0.9079255462,
0.2843362689,
0.0118776187,
-0.4963877201,
0.8478197455,
0.4030990303,
0.965408504,
-0.1700110286,
0.5733246803,
0.2547250986,
0.4249384105,
-0.5967791677,
0.7349741459,
-0.4073182642,
-0.0131793236,
-0.2324706763,
-0.872568965,
0.0463889539,
0.7142216563,
-0.2717570364,
0.024908023,
0.865375042,
0.7822976112,
-0.0880795494,
0.2650074363,
0.3561117947,
0.2983675599,
0.1978829652,
0.4397007823,
1.1367185116,
-0.2618742287,
-0.0164411273,
-0.4709877968,
0.0181686096,
-0.0557303242,
-0.8005027175,
-1.1735473871,
-0.8787268996,
-0.3458347619,
-0.1252373904,
-0.1187656671,
0.9282028675,
0.7447690368,
-0.7040174603,
-0.3558375239,
0.1234024018,
-0.151250124,
-0.50900352,
-0.1661634296,
0.2026170641,
-0.4008028805,
-0.562825501,
0.7564734817,
0.1023947001,
0.0440686084,
-0.518374145,
0.1096176282,
0.1071738452,
0.2955183983,
0.468103528,
0.1930146664,
-1.0196636915,
-0.4850417376,
0.1034516692,
-0.161164239,
0.0505503975,
1.1361497641,
-0.8424782157,
0.4778521955,
0.3267383873,
0.5475088954,
0.5165546536,
-0.3331936002,
0.7282604575,
-0.517790556,
-0.1060873792,
0.2212329358,
0.679675281,
0.2941562533,
-0.1926555932,
0.2429311275,
-0.0494093262,
-0.4065297544,
-0.9259980321,
0.3522152603,
-0.7874650955,
-0.245136708,
0.8814262748,
-0.2054785788,
0.0210329872,
0.2623291314,
-0.1159214452,
0.3430845439,
-0.3621794581,
0.8490948081,
1.1445015669,
-0.2664676011,
-0.2922071815,
-0.65909338,
0.4699463844,
0.8917871714,
-0.5309949517,
0.2754351199,
0.3892612457,
0.371155858,
0.0572464764,
0.6442540288,
0.1377148032,
0.2074939609,
0.0789134577,
-0.1534251273,
0.1149736941,
-0.2050104141,
-0.4830212593,
-0.0440612882,
0.3542788029,
0.0873713717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17825v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17825v1
|
Automatic speech recognition for the Nepali language using CNN, bidirectional LSTM and ResNet
| 2024-06-25T12:14:01 | 2024-06-25T12:14:01 |
Manish Dhakal, Arman Chhetri, Aman Kumar Gupta, Prabin Lamichhane, Suraj Pandey, Subarna Shakya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This paper presents an end-to-end deep learning model for Automatic Speech
Recognition (ASR) that transcribes Nepali speech to text. The model was trained
and tested on the OpenSLR (audio, text) dataset. The majority of the audio
dataset have silent gaps at both ends which are clipped during dataset
preprocessing for a more uniform mapping of audio frames and their
corresponding texts. Mel Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCCs) are used as
audio features to feed into the model. The model having Bidirectional LSTM
paired with ResNet and one-dimensional CNN produces the best results for this
dataset out of all the models (neural networks with variations of LSTM, GRU,
CNN, and ResNet) that have been trained so far. This novel model uses
Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) function for loss calculation
during training and CTC beam search decoding for predicting characters as the
most likely sequence of Nepali text. On the test dataset, the character error
rate (CER) of 17.06 percent has been achieved. The source code is available at:
https://github.com/manishdhakal/ASR-Nepali-using-CNN-BiLSTM-ResNet.
|
[
0.1691287458,
-0.5059071183,
-0.1608497947,
0.4413930774,
-0.5537584424,
0.3359059095,
-0.3142622113,
-0.432747066,
-0.1402387172,
0.4504579902,
-0.0602150224,
-0.456183821,
-0.5776648521,
0.5657000542,
-0.8797402382,
0.585581243,
0.0230385568,
0.3038355112,
0.2610511184,
-0.1645869166,
-0.4429241419,
-0.6397856474,
-0.7888900042,
-0.1924128234,
0.2325434834,
0.3791729808,
0.1651595533,
0.4993970394,
0.3789050579,
0.3544602394,
-0.4041408598,
0.1299979836,
-0.1010196209,
0.0420511216,
0.2661632001,
-0.2949472964,
-0.1933652461,
-0.1711812913,
1.1037890911,
0.3690711856,
-0.5635100603,
0.0716557652,
0.1279402673,
0.691768527,
-0.2087381631,
0.163591519,
-0.5406895876,
0.2185701728,
-0.2398391962,
-0.2791069746,
-0.4722897708,
-0.4113224745,
0.0265733991,
-0.2105343342,
0.117881842,
0.0720259622,
0.7203071713,
0.5055107474,
-0.5821818709,
-0.3269544542,
-0.6859318018,
0.4736574292,
-0.7074711919,
0.6375029087,
0.7418738604,
0.6470381021,
0.1916190237,
-0.5800853968,
-0.6801971793,
-0.2885893285,
-0.0558150597,
0.108138971,
0.0880399048,
-0.1087751389,
-0.1098222733,
0.4695127904,
-0.8048548698,
0.2484368086,
-0.8889508247,
-0.1595680118,
0.5081464648,
0.289731741,
0.0999452844,
-0.0126397489,
-0.2842403948,
0.1825939715,
-0.5366340876,
0.2405764461,
0.4657795131,
0.4786839485,
-0.4875710905,
0.7322353721,
-0.3068872094,
1.0663844347,
-0.1322467625,
0.2166219801,
0.3020199537,
-0.366591543,
-0.290383935,
0.7840989828,
0.8351979852,
-0.0762077719,
0.6251717806,
0.0990055799,
-0.0558680482,
-0.0739406869,
0.0383463576,
-0.6951152086,
-0.2373356372,
-0.1135581061,
-0.475728929,
-0.2968768179,
-0.3433327973,
-0.2851293087,
-0.3216082752,
-0.6344410777,
-0.1360321343,
-0.3147263825,
-0.2279639542,
0.165740788,
0.3118956983,
0.2819384336,
0.3658238053,
-0.4390390217,
0.5430742502,
0.1978206038,
1.0119642019,
-0.2025286555,
-0.2889601588,
-0.6722857356,
0.0819714814,
-0.202655986,
0.8835334778,
-0.3241050839,
-0.4067417681,
-0.1243826896,
0.0501020551,
-0.1569661796,
-0.3440854251,
0.4311846793,
-0.720225215,
0.1963838339,
0.4190296829,
-0.2845665514,
-0.3139614761,
0.1838987917,
-0.7867712379,
0.6911560893,
-0.1344739199,
-0.6357170343,
-0.0783091933,
-0.5090383291,
-0.8872855306,
0.0637864992,
0.0102393283,
-0.4184083641,
-0.1746631414,
-0.0832117349,
0.4003393948,
-0.5340689421,
0.4151132107,
0.1767661273,
-0.3772399426,
0.4813333154,
-0.9085205197,
1.1363617182,
0.264008671,
0.022917904,
0.2906079292,
-1.1726024151,
-0.0853387937,
0.0553529523,
-1.0587968826,
0.2408204228,
-0.03040036,
0.620572269,
0.2050435394,
0.107597962,
-0.6468009949,
-0.3075060248,
-0.5710964203,
0.6455748677,
0.7038032413,
-0.3468519449,
0.1640396714,
0.1163741425,
0.1345345527,
0.1220661923,
-0.0320246071,
0.0922321156,
-0.4550392032,
-0.6161782742,
-0.0715536252,
0.7830747366,
0.8538067937,
-0.3506426811,
0.6261872649,
-0.1374679953,
-0.3206612468,
-0.6558212638,
-0.1275486201,
0.4344274104,
0.6819390655,
0.3843814731,
-0.4300543368,
-0.757240057,
-0.7038272023,
0.0565119907,
-0.3063232005,
0.2135761529,
0.0282172579,
0.0451740585,
-0.0650628656,
0.6838375926,
-0.3266479373,
-0.5551297665,
-0.1126613542,
0.0893066451,
0.2472488731,
0.6033399701,
-0.1010034531,
-1.1200006008,
-0.9426347613,
0.2234632522,
-0.4524237812,
0.0902839974,
0.2877787948,
0.4123536646,
0.5446767807,
0.5759204626,
-0.1852723211,
0.7157205939,
0.4258004129,
-0.2209703475,
0.6657101512,
-0.2141157985,
0.0732836649,
-0.9993041754,
0.2845275998,
-0.1211472899,
-0.4382743835,
-0.6209440827,
-0.4864453673,
-0.0329225063,
-0.2945675552,
-0.392573297,
0.437595427,
-0.5434951782,
-0.0528281294,
-0.2999446392,
-0.0714580864,
-0.2936386764,
0.3098666966,
0.3698793948,
0.8033388257,
0.4028237462,
-0.4926214516,
0.6180158854,
0.4678611457,
-0.4444479048,
0.3825631738,
-0.8931112885,
0.0754567981,
0.0861544758,
0.1079490706,
-1.0501083136,
0.1131214872,
0.25626719,
-0.6428932548,
0.7575194836,
0.0231105443,
-0.6526243091,
-0.2265644819,
0.3299070001,
0.5103077888,
0.4337967038,
-0.3465459049,
0.2554993927,
0.3970603049,
-0.1768172085,
-0.5061596036,
-0.919927001,
0.4120069146,
-0.0340311192,
-0.2307793796,
0.0925227776,
-0.1889707595,
0.3089576066,
-0.0948239267,
0.2623510361,
-0.4014142752,
-0.1662352681,
0.1519583613,
-0.047809694,
-0.1829303354,
-0.0484224148,
-0.1442416757,
-0.4801034033,
-0.245581612,
-0.0615903772,
0.6631116271,
-0.4694392681,
-0.2013471723,
-0.9034457803,
0.5278141499,
0.4350657761,
-0.4582289457,
0.4096632302,
0.7051166296,
-0.5120505691,
0.1809848845,
-0.4785811007,
0.1227955073,
-0.3922801316,
0.5005115867,
-0.2646779418,
-0.682461381,
0.4271403253,
0.0941687077,
-0.3954252005,
0.2792957127,
0.3951722085,
0.0605505556,
0.9143819213,
0.6583294868,
-0.153136462,
0.3504690528,
-0.2200922668,
0.1458922327,
-1.1717932224,
-0.3036170304,
-0.7163673639,
-0.0587445721,
-0.4154647887,
-0.2360964119,
0.1777529866,
-0.0761331245,
-0.4583920538,
0.472250104,
-0.7969568372,
0.1438465416,
0.5767943263,
0.0915164202,
0.4358501136,
0.1153286472,
-0.1109373644,
0.1860573441,
-0.6677533388,
-0.2827187479,
0.7671988606,
0.143071115,
0.6808202863,
-0.0302070547,
0.2586558759,
0.3983160853,
0.0810565352,
-0.7066427469,
0.4528801143,
-0.4295105636,
-0.4308545887,
-0.4637960792,
-0.2801262438,
-0.6858900785,
-0.0757663473,
0.1929153204,
-0.3806222081,
0.3585966527,
-0.0534159355,
-0.2731771767,
0.2135253847,
-0.4595048428,
0.4953039289,
-0.2896657884,
0.1416856498,
-0.316965431,
-1.3386794329,
0.1081838086,
0.0397835784,
-0.2843647599,
-0.0115585038,
0.0573671572,
0.8785802722,
-0.18181476,
1.1080981493,
0.0854285136,
0.2031726241,
0.4150494635,
-0.1220283881,
0.3593263328,
-0.3203339279,
-0.5094818473,
0.4414934516,
-0.1728880554,
-0.086029157,
-0.0480549447,
0.3733207881,
-0.7691316605,
-0.1272830665,
-0.6395574808,
-0.2084155977,
0.1163378954,
0.2389239371,
0.2502638996,
0.6249634027,
-0.2874404192,
0.4525818825,
0.3567415476,
-0.1137376726,
0.540022552,
0.6401631832,
0.2069376707,
-0.8267524838,
0.8855028749,
0.391887933,
0.0758182332,
0.3392140567,
0.2420672476,
-0.4858585894,
-0.7130138874,
-0.7847458124,
0.1010355428,
-0.7452139258,
-0.5526843667,
-0.5361540914,
-0.8460665345,
-0.2068960965,
0.0203110892,
-0.2691086531,
-0.3916515708,
-0.8723470569,
-0.0010375885,
0.5310172439,
0.6115572453,
-0.0097444234,
0.5546178222,
-0.634773314,
0.3135075271,
0.1401380897,
0.2872097194,
0.1660337746,
-0.7095208168,
-0.4241398871,
0.0280747861,
-0.1342953742,
-0.809776783,
0.6499177814,
0.5354768038,
0.1678621471,
0.1839071214,
-0.0462311953,
0.4834589362,
-0.8551607132,
0.6006526351,
0.5460125804,
-0.8311043978,
0.4544447958,
-0.1343820095,
0.2136727571,
0.4350803196,
0.1960893124,
-0.6522472501,
0.0458912849,
-0.2521075904,
-0.4870294333,
0.6735463738,
0.0794389993,
-0.2995159626,
0.1410757899,
0.1413244903,
0.0769930109,
0.44541502,
-0.5939391255,
-0.0692915693,
-0.3267676234,
-0.5322270989,
-0.1829311699,
-0.2704625726,
0.1244374588,
-0.5232692361,
0.6335304379,
-0.1888891011,
0.1989058703,
0.3379049897,
-0.0240493231,
-0.2666640282,
0.2058779299,
0.8114247322,
0.2176338583,
0.0038723294,
0.2640200555,
0.3461182714,
-0.527353704,
0.375213027,
0.3601867557,
-0.0425965674,
-0.0270694885,
0.1328314394,
0.7672679424,
0.0176364556,
-0.4718257487,
0.4501386285,
-0.2164284736,
0.1120569035,
-0.599339962,
-0.2959170938,
0.0630032048,
0.1936880499,
0.3303050101,
0.2855706513,
0.3160562515,
-0.2840965986,
0.0760821477,
0.1719487458,
-0.7209044695,
-0.3945478797,
0.6623105407,
0.1411080956,
-0.859523356,
1.0478744507,
0.0856226832,
-0.8107309937,
0.740765214,
0.8366355896,
1.0184767246,
-0.7314995527,
0.0682257041,
0.3289916515,
0.1692408919,
0.0421842523,
0.3044420779,
-0.315112859,
-0.2545319498,
-0.3187362552,
-0.9462914467,
-0.1376560181,
-0.126003474,
-0.4629425704,
0.5560795069,
-0.291944921,
0.1452128291,
-0.3702423871,
-0.0054341033,
-0.5516059995,
0.479539454,
-0.1505273581,
0.835078001,
-0.6365395188,
1.02434659,
0.3491149545,
-0.4441536963,
-0.5197161436,
-0.181991905,
-0.2039157003,
-0.9283171296,
0.97134763,
0.1635804176,
-0.2980016768,
0.2878742218,
-0.3261899948,
-0.7611344457,
0.8788893223,
0.102802299,
-0.5927844644,
-0.0117584551,
0.2508704066,
0.6940532923,
-0.4109632671,
-0.0002150494,
0.2215727717,
0.4067482948,
0.1937777847,
-1.1545573473,
0.0385215022,
-0.4814210534,
-0.0227100272,
0.0115908254,
-0.7620227337,
0.536932528,
-0.232886523,
-0.2364743948,
0.2575853765,
0.7630404234,
0.1108575538,
0.3255492747,
0.4633434713,
0.4438024163,
0.4621210992,
0.2461578399,
0.6234914064,
-0.0905703604,
-0.0615641549,
1.0722585917,
-0.363196671,
1.1887806654,
0.3166112602,
-0.2116702199,
0.3142409623,
0.8544988632,
0.0934894457,
0.7281401157,
0.4835826755,
-0.2432468086,
0.0036464757,
-0.2928213775,
-0.4773118496,
0.6181690693,
0.3609793186,
-0.2475495785,
-0.1254973561,
0.1562286913,
-0.5356109738,
0.072702989,
-0.0661958009,
0.9244949222,
0.3290148675,
-0.094456479,
0.8489977121,
-0.0174996946,
0.5727710128,
-0.5599110126,
-0.1862622648,
0.3180043101,
0.0882187858,
-0.244973883,
-0.725730896,
0.6235766411,
0.0189462788,
-0.3823519349,
-0.006308048,
0.713049531,
-0.7858619094,
-0.6142192483,
0.2313741595,
-0.0697975978,
0.4251909852,
-0.0242496524,
-0.5878379345,
0.0667320937,
-0.1673453301,
-0.0026098411,
0.1110965759,
0.1951751262,
-0.019996224,
0.6954401135,
0.7919570804,
0.4235964715,
0.1432511955,
0.1807507724,
0.7075158358,
-0.5577045679,
-0.8521666527,
-0.6326567531,
0.5798549652,
-0.0265491605,
-0.3045576811,
0.3236583471,
0.7150489092,
0.4808367789,
0.03507201,
0.5633822083,
0.2869289517,
0.5366612673,
-0.3335037529,
1.1162314415,
-0.5131844282,
0.0613418296,
0.2239232063,
-0.5375502706,
-0.4624876976,
0.606646955,
0.0255435277,
0.0062441309,
0.5708003044,
0.515411377,
-0.0993652046,
0.325001955,
0.3114302158,
0.1823682934,
0.2037824541,
0.3490639627,
0.7919266224,
-0.7670668364,
0.5713171959,
-0.0919369981,
-0.0922959968,
-0.4018896818,
-0.6959849,
-0.6854841113,
-1.1241298914,
-0.3460192084,
-0.2800789475,
0.2369871438,
0.6230934262,
0.7364267707,
-0.7839595079,
-0.5088214278,
-0.2619164288,
0.0474683605,
-0.160274893,
-0.1717081219,
0.7968132496,
0.0452057533,
-0.4992308617,
0.5487331748,
0.1691552103,
0.2173734158,
-0.1580393165,
-0.2799319625,
-0.66059798,
-0.2570486665,
0.4669654667,
0.41256392,
-0.6355235577,
-0.0739878863,
-0.0432218984,
-0.1017794833,
0.3169619739,
0.5339133739,
-0.7477585673,
0.4816192687,
0.5750244856,
0.5811181068,
0.5657122135,
-0.1224385872,
0.4986702502,
-0.5395125747,
0.0466849506,
0.4471352696,
0.2081353962,
0.7954370379,
-0.5508911014,
0.4377471507,
0.1794962436,
-0.709885776,
-1.1247816086,
0.0907715037,
-0.9994235039,
0.0364011899,
0.9199474454,
0.1099842489,
-0.3157286048,
-0.3087474108,
-0.4266286492,
0.7479615808,
-0.3066481352,
0.5455793142,
0.3278856277,
-0.0350012742,
-0.2612452805,
-0.3909156621,
0.3186231554,
0.0998112559,
-0.5109091401,
0.2366719544,
0.2143390924,
0.2871128619,
0.0574799106,
0.5637288094,
-0.1726687998,
0.3177450001,
-0.0959040895,
0.086074762,
-0.4386791289,
-0.6505408287,
-0.8922718763,
0.1098548844,
-0.1340107769,
-0.4011254013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17484v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17484v1
|
MedCare: Advancing Medical LLMs through Decoupling Clinical Alignment and Knowledge Aggregation
| 2024-06-25T12:05:56 | 2024-06-25T12:05:56 |
Yusheng Liao, Shuyang Jiang, Yanfeng Wang, Yu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown substantial progress in natural
language understanding and generation, proving valuable especially in the
medical field. Despite advancements, challenges persist due to the complexity
and diversity inherent in medical tasks, which can be categorized as
knowledge-intensive tasks and alignment-required tasks. Previous approaches
either ignore the latter task or focus on a minority of tasks and hence lose
generalization. To address these drawbacks, we propose a progressive
fine-tuning pipeline. This pipeline employs a Knowledge Aggregator and a Noise
aggregator to encode diverse knowledge in the first stage and filter out
detrimental information. In the second stage, we drop the Noise Aggregator to
avoid the interference of suboptimal representation and leverage an additional
alignment module optimized towards an orthogonal direction to the knowledge
space to mitigate knowledge forgetting. Based on this two-stage paradigm, we
proposed a Medical LLM through decoupling Clinical Alignment and Knowledge
Aggregation (MedCare), which is designed to achieve state-of-the-art (SOTA)
performance on over 20 medical tasks, as well as SOTA results on specific
medical alignment tasks. Various model sizes of MedCare (1.8B, 7B, 14B) all
demonstrate significant improvements over existing models with similar model
sizes.
|
[
-0.0165916495,
-0.5601758957,
0.7401205301,
-0.2885427177,
-0.2405544519,
0.0499851815,
-0.0778114125,
-0.3828034401,
0.0944308862,
0.5857364535,
-0.9291049242,
-0.7027904391,
-0.7947979569,
0.0071375356,
-0.2233174294,
1.0208194256,
0.007058891,
0.2185275853,
-0.3436056077,
-0.2538002431,
-0.4592042267,
-0.0400923453,
-0.9840403199,
-0.4813153744,
0.5900111198,
0.1614515036,
0.7026548386,
0.9951078892,
0.7565360069,
0.3164489567,
-0.2052334249,
0.7101380229,
-0.4880983829,
0.1972113252,
-0.2226417512,
-0.4681937397,
-0.9345004559,
-0.3035121262,
0.6647067666,
0.9304584861,
-0.5663032532,
0.0202778056,
0.0091005703,
0.9084395766,
-0.4222459495,
0.2433802783,
-0.4969994426,
-0.0382600427,
-0.0416992046,
-0.1381066591,
0.0252804141,
-0.2539292574,
0.0014124039,
-0.6455563307,
-0.0309604462,
-0.0545475259,
0.7967389822,
0.7722014189,
-0.2693793476,
-0.2710213661,
-0.5513064265,
0.8402664065,
-0.8978435397,
0.3760379851,
0.2126298696,
0.2100404203,
-0.2729147971,
-0.9669364095,
-0.2250450552,
0.2441735417,
0.1261476576,
0.4105783701,
-0.3466672897,
0.2734172642,
-0.1531893611,
0.5375580192,
-0.3913673162,
0.6589818001,
-0.5392097235,
-0.0701449588,
0.4559209645,
0.6430418491,
0.3730996549,
0.2362663001,
-0.2705241442,
0.5278935432,
-0.8681742549,
-0.3278940916,
-0.2768341303,
0.1841150373,
-0.2214405388,
0.5193234682,
-0.2277198136,
0.8046841025,
-0.0276863575,
-0.5961842537,
0.2448520362,
-0.2939635813,
-0.5795418024,
0.0391700156,
0.6713485122,
0.4885905683,
-0.0284693241,
-0.2240189761,
-0.0608850755,
0.5273708105,
0.3595616221,
-0.5426506996,
-0.0857868344,
0.56228441,
-0.7215005159,
-0.4013881385,
-0.4991880953,
-0.325620085,
-0.6411989331,
-0.7213942409,
0.1594931781,
-0.5644331574,
-0.1943023503,
0.5948809981,
0.3165166676,
0.0437472016,
0.3924040198,
-0.7275417447,
0.3490639031,
1.028042078,
0.7333393097,
-0.2768538892,
-0.0142981401,
-0.4713039696,
0.2260315269,
-0.1569756269,
0.8108713627,
-0.3526059091,
-0.1008113995,
0.0335844755,
0.0111715784,
-0.2599536777,
-0.8318753839,
0.4677105546,
-0.3411424756,
0.3262573481,
0.1167201102,
-0.8923811316,
-0.0767141655,
0.3933390379,
-0.3871974647,
0.6346393228,
0.3537412286,
-0.6083774567,
0.4665965438,
-0.6099656224,
-0.3118140399,
0.1828418225,
-0.3813593388,
-0.5681578517,
0.2586921453,
0.28326267,
0.3969973922,
-0.6017181277,
0.6174507737,
0.0421626456,
-0.3077870607,
-0.0524182096,
-0.1519998461,
0.5157089233,
0.3126177192,
0.0352378897,
0.2280900627,
-0.872017324,
-0.2577626109,
-0.1357345283,
-0.5292856693,
-0.2630267739,
0.1403254718,
-0.3944551349,
0.3053999543,
0.2738605738,
-0.4052190781,
0.3111464977,
-0.7151249051,
0.5265291929,
0.4771849215,
0.0871093124,
0.3702760339,
-0.7738605738,
0.6551021338,
0.3848331273,
0.4060961902,
-0.0346727334,
-0.5512797832,
-0.5471791625,
-0.6716893315,
0.1574324369,
0.5249410868,
-0.4593879879,
0.3775088191,
-0.4565401673,
-0.2830595076,
-1.19176054,
0.313156575,
0.3363488615,
0.9622343183,
0.5614489913,
-0.3840158284,
-0.4881628752,
-0.8771473169,
-0.2921799123,
0.0714245886,
-0.1156106591,
0.2625080049,
-0.0731910989,
-0.909750998,
0.7048885226,
-0.4213353097,
-0.7825841904,
-0.2857544124,
-0.2276478559,
0.519487977,
0.4498383403,
0.0770578682,
-0.4592677653,
-0.0123140663,
0.110237658,
-0.7162305713,
-0.189765498,
0.1537149549,
-0.0906877071,
0.0573793128,
0.658536613,
-0.5620890856,
0.1230900511,
0.8695798516,
-0.4535220563,
0.1849610806,
-0.3468924463,
-0.1730413437,
-1.4520763159,
0.0029299862,
-0.2456491143,
-0.2961917818,
-0.6428983808,
-0.0586597025,
0.0043465872,
0.2304232419,
-0.3776704669,
0.4543146193,
-0.3591066003,
0.4501176775,
-0.2751482129,
0.0508509539,
0.0270898622,
0.1085600629,
-0.2019781917,
0.3310241103,
0.5906866789,
-0.6974428892,
0.0911226273,
0.3235360384,
-0.2919606566,
0.591147244,
-0.3826956153,
-0.2560140491,
-0.282954812,
0.0455114953,
-0.6576684713,
-0.2916892469,
0.0312672555,
-0.1797472984,
0.4975501001,
-0.1629322916,
-0.2703652382,
-0.1182804331,
0.0620473288,
0.4823269546,
0.6478557587,
-0.1756731868,
0.6777781844,
0.6182298064,
-0.386084944,
-0.4084542692,
-0.6847597957,
-0.0036524776,
-0.2125180513,
-0.5899249911,
0.3505080342,
0.2656109333,
-0.2089624405,
-0.0005993468,
-0.1923321486,
0.008129484,
-0.1387569308,
0.2090231031,
0.4409833252,
-0.3690122068,
0.4263454378,
0.4983996749,
-0.3339457214,
-0.0111549385,
-0.595413208,
0.4490063488,
0.3157833815,
-0.4282376468,
-0.4695906341,
0.3597148955,
0.7710630298,
-0.2158795595,
0.8979136944,
0.5802419782,
-0.5383554697,
0.1352921873,
-0.7833955288,
-0.1322505027,
-0.4188935161,
0.5969831944,
0.1752541661,
-1.2674982548,
0.4557515681,
-0.6372013092,
0.4368037879,
0.525446713,
0.7570075989,
-0.2797212005,
0.9922447205,
0.5234822035,
-0.1196710095,
0.0620025508,
-0.1629028916,
0.1142608002,
-0.9370219111,
-0.4077631235,
-0.201724872,
-0.4850030243,
-0.4242991209,
-0.5299019814,
0.5425249338,
0.0207765047,
-0.3668668568,
-0.1586844772,
-0.5602886677,
0.1038973108,
0.4130210578,
0.4432682693,
0.6078268886,
0.0436945073,
-0.2149517089,
-0.0385588743,
-0.9607910514,
-0.2240975052,
1.0839982033,
0.5174723864,
0.750670135,
0.0960783064,
0.8295646906,
-0.156357795,
0.4915868044,
-0.8678478003,
0.2583255768,
-0.710622251,
-0.2622058988,
-0.1550131738,
-0.4428600967,
-1.1460007429,
0.0659159943,
-0.163686797,
-0.5090962648,
0.0347189046,
0.3507578075,
-0.6760249734,
0.2104711831,
-0.2912783325,
0.6761190891,
0.042750109,
-0.1974403113,
-0.2442965657,
-0.7879910469,
0.4063099623,
-0.108857967,
0.6220362186,
-0.2684343457,
-0.3596084714,
0.573848784,
-0.4872488081,
0.9191140532,
-0.1055316702,
-0.2954494357,
0.0185296889,
-0.022714192,
0.3708687723,
-0.1296367347,
0.0867901444,
0.118904449,
-0.0096778795,
-0.2413147241,
-0.3642849326,
0.6110349298,
-0.5525940657,
-0.3882572651,
-0.0329865254,
-1.0045163631,
-0.482383877,
0.3584471643,
0.2729589939,
0.5742781162,
0.0755119324,
0.0219359733,
0.7443991899,
-0.1935281157,
0.0379942991,
0.6878489256,
-0.0580686107,
-0.4111880958,
0.6964312792,
-0.0709844455,
0.3592914939,
0.3579282165,
0.2166188806,
-0.337762922,
-0.8323637843,
-0.081970565,
0.4056351483,
-0.4789641201,
-0.5239832401,
-0.7151305079,
-0.3387992084,
-0.2932578921,
-0.0611071885,
-0.4922482073,
-0.257850945,
-0.485627681,
0.1198023856,
0.2736706436,
0.6929175854,
0.1721471995,
0.3168379366,
-1.0795106888,
0.4525032341,
0.0737675577,
0.4525013864,
-0.2566144466,
-0.4842886329,
-0.3408631384,
-0.0915314853,
-0.2191827446,
-0.4197754264,
0.4300275445,
0.2080119103,
0.3446041048,
0.6767838597,
-0.1011786088,
0.9329434037,
-0.674263835,
0.5085073113,
0.5395509005,
-0.4292707443,
0.4909680188,
-0.3506136239,
0.6104445457,
0.60397017,
-0.016099263,
-0.4632565081,
-0.7382696271,
-0.5535953641,
-0.9039543271,
0.2989185154,
-0.1513660699,
-0.1169308349,
0.009586338,
0.403865993,
0.0537189953,
0.2541752756,
-0.1446828246,
-0.0721344128,
0.5188657045,
-0.8889974952,
-0.0157942679,
-0.1905402094,
-0.646338582,
-0.3709662557,
0.3611003757,
-0.1564413011,
0.1224891767,
0.2754424214,
0.0261417888,
-0.2018821687,
0.3648852706,
0.5316510797,
0.6088610888,
0.1103927866,
-0.0749798343,
0.0867640674,
-0.7946697474,
-0.0603207387,
0.2118485123,
-0.0634678006,
-0.1597039849,
0.5064191818,
0.6610045433,
0.5103198886,
-0.7845586538,
0.3595520556,
0.0595161468,
-0.3920424879,
-0.0073633962,
0.2222327739,
0.488955766,
0.4107893705,
-0.0720079169,
0.3418992758,
0.1618424803,
-0.3310369253,
0.2411103249,
0.3228476346,
-0.5832622051,
0.0499723367,
0.809130013,
0.0867778659,
-0.076361455,
0.6281998158,
0.2612958848,
-0.0973953381,
0.3825624883,
0.5146028996,
0.625617981,
-0.2633270025,
-0.2435993552,
0.0891954601,
0.1755854785,
-0.3265841305,
0.5333603621,
0.2520525753,
-0.686806798,
-0.724676311,
-0.7633565068,
-0.1141215339,
0.0599245429,
-0.7484462261,
0.1519108564,
-0.1983302683,
-0.2591833472,
-0.2804584801,
-0.1611393839,
-0.8076746464,
0.3859044313,
-0.0418325439,
0.9197115898,
-0.590487957,
0.798741281,
0.8668907285,
-0.0296696629,
-0.9010288119,
-0.2781051099,
0.2135392278,
-1.0861523151,
0.129355371,
-0.1015289277,
0.0130974716,
0.0871555209,
-0.2677500248,
-0.7112905979,
1.4490344524,
0.4286086857,
-1.0471625328,
-0.2891479135,
0.0569547378,
0.527741611,
-0.5737880468,
-0.2917680144,
0.9176537395,
0.1699536443,
0.0754567236,
-1.0077559948,
0.1453896761,
0.0621839948,
-0.2359548509,
0.2950352728,
-0.4795618355,
0.7008957267,
-0.3083951473,
-0.1424460411,
0.2430962622,
0.1574106216,
0.4815158546,
0.3728366196,
0.3111129999,
0.9984960556,
0.9284033179,
-0.1664213091,
0.9735531211,
-0.4481178224,
0.2703632712,
1.1122667789,
-0.1116478667,
0.5845735073,
0.6289255619,
-0.2243691683,
0.4071285725,
0.4159947038,
0.2492984086,
0.4356402755,
-0.0076341946,
-0.462218672,
-0.3831577897,
-0.1602758318,
-0.3939830661,
0.4303662777,
0.6326678395,
-0.8428612947,
-0.2812562585,
-0.197832197,
0.1691248566,
0.0291360337,
-0.6364598274,
1.2806859016,
0.3789668679,
-0.7051035166,
0.5244485736,
-0.1994311661,
0.4551307857,
-0.721658349,
-0.0562121496,
-0.314324975,
0.524864316,
-0.397326529,
-0.4132269621,
0.2982477248,
-0.2736410201,
-0.2512403131,
-0.0704248473,
0.760214448,
-0.6283297539,
-0.6654289961,
0.1524759233,
0.6111550927,
0.014651346,
0.2353612334,
-0.6107568145,
0.1203944981,
-0.1014011353,
0.1532557011,
0.403790772,
0.4839805067,
0.240094021,
0.8338999748,
0.5498088002,
0.663738966,
0.022274971,
0.3896189928,
1.1262431145,
-0.4045082629,
-0.4257707,
-0.894369781,
0.6325358152,
0.0086247269,
-0.2838429213,
0.1867246777,
0.4701390564,
0.2326550782,
0.0244118981,
0.6635460258,
0.3126861453,
0.786585629,
-0.6482106447,
0.8324944973,
-0.7350322008,
0.3762026131,
-0.079018496,
-0.4356889129,
-0.7319526672,
0.3157351017,
0.0625944436,
-0.2742707431,
0.5614953637,
0.6959558129,
-0.1079317629,
-0.1260372549,
0.4250560403,
0.4404524863,
0.3407433033,
0.7767296433,
0.5009651184,
-0.314319402,
0.2878797948,
0.1077533886,
-0.535225153,
-0.0366063565,
-0.6991358995,
-0.6082395315,
-0.1582981795,
-0.4751112461,
-0.3331409991,
0.1052071527,
0.803314805,
0.7173556685,
-0.7763938904,
0.1273125857,
-0.294008404,
-0.102103956,
-0.4602523744,
-0.1254924387,
0.4261390269,
-0.631177187,
-0.5127698183,
0.4455501139,
0.8406376839,
-0.254791379,
-0.181115672,
-0.1411840469,
0.0644361824,
-0.0971126333,
0.533430934,
0.1288684905,
-0.8021905422,
0.1347422302,
-0.1111295372,
-0.1212249473,
0.0807999447,
0.7782441974,
-0.8036884665,
0.4777706861,
0.020496361,
0.7650413513,
0.1213068292,
0.0991936252,
0.6851008534,
-0.4672873616,
0.0527626015,
0.4914472997,
0.4735366106,
0.0758430138,
-0.3187356889,
0.3985821009,
0.0414343439,
-0.6463983655,
-0.6924574971,
0.3315511048,
-0.9420599937,
-0.1978659332,
0.9695365429,
-0.1431487203,
0.094600372,
-0.2827000916,
-0.2164844722,
0.4543227255,
-0.0434451215,
0.9348372817,
0.3136571944,
-0.3374259174,
-0.1664046347,
-0.46140939,
0.5915799141,
0.4909251034,
-0.7857093811,
-0.139925018,
0.3705684841,
0.450945735,
-0.1490071863,
0.8951819539,
-0.711225152,
0.2452548593,
-0.4287623167,
-0.2298652679,
-0.0531095304,
-0.1124937013,
-0.3785777688,
0.1140890941,
0.038105756,
-0.2927054465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17474v1
|
Transformer-based Named Entity Recognition with Combined Data Representation
| 2024-06-25T11:41:16 | 2024-06-25T11:41:16 |
Michał Marcińczuk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study examines transformer-based models and their effectiveness in named
entity recognition tasks. The study investigates data representation
strategies, including single, merged, and context, which respectively use one
sentence, multiple sentences, and sentences joined with attention to context
per vector. Analysis shows that training models with a single strategy may lead
to poor performance on different data representations. To address this
limitation, the study proposes a combined training procedure that utilizes all
three strategies to improve model stability and adaptability. The results of
this approach are presented and discussed for four languages (English, Polish,
Czech, and German) across various datasets, demonstrating the effectiveness of
the combined strategy.
|
[
-0.5203963518,
-0.1981220394,
0.5108299255,
0.1414624453,
-0.3839023709,
0.0461880825,
-0.3861650527,
-0.5159025788,
0.3001939356,
0.5775630474,
-0.4574243426,
-0.2894756496,
-0.718462348,
0.4761374593,
-0.4413664341,
0.9523199797,
-0.3595531285,
0.5896833539,
-0.2199660838,
-0.5511638522,
-0.8830853701,
-0.6870535016,
-0.6664430499,
-0.4861547947,
0.5280359983,
0.3352335095,
0.4136340022,
0.5760314465,
0.8376418352,
0.1979244053,
0.1721303761,
0.0414901637,
-0.4250160754,
0.2047185749,
-0.1557993591,
-0.5276571512,
-0.0353626199,
-0.0688439533,
0.8115932345,
0.7595749497,
0.0142303109,
-0.0662341267,
-0.1368493587,
0.3271842301,
-0.4560787976,
0.2057183683,
-0.6177604795,
0.2212858498,
-0.2653335631,
-0.1866912246,
-0.6793948412,
0.0410558246,
0.2762593925,
-0.5697051883,
0.3553700447,
0.0288283061,
0.8723236918,
0.326587975,
-0.6107147932,
-0.2929283679,
-1.2944161892,
0.8344762325,
-0.3198440075,
0.7951103449,
-0.0642521009,
0.4551131129,
-0.0411108248,
-0.7911841869,
-0.6131616235,
0.0816137567,
-0.426161468,
0.0850477964,
-0.2828688323,
-0.1592582911,
0.442004025,
0.1644855142,
-0.278581351,
0.1236274689,
-0.4203975201,
-0.1458013356,
0.5784804821,
0.0132086193,
0.3126893342,
-0.0645682961,
-0.6933586001,
-0.2721495926,
-0.6954525709,
0.1667963415,
0.1133056805,
0.6949121952,
0.1439830214,
0.5375227332,
0.0284596868,
0.5777952671,
0.1450843215,
-0.1732546836,
0.2736450136,
0.0135886502,
-0.319368124,
0.2203060836,
0.5854538083,
0.1072297096,
0.10037902,
-0.8151195645,
-0.3338966072,
0.167705819,
0.5898504257,
-0.4660326838,
-0.2148443758,
0.1188497618,
-0.4663906693,
-0.1713741571,
0.4559746981,
-0.7741872072,
-0.1742810309,
-0.4931976199,
0.5308578014,
-0.4725530148,
-0.221425131,
0.0751995221,
-0.360612005,
0.3140167296,
0.1990680993,
-0.8818384409,
0.563824594,
0.3483797908,
0.4833619297,
-0.4872276485,
-0.220539853,
-0.3658262193,
0.323900193,
-0.0207065642,
1.0058301687,
-0.5657377839,
-0.4280315042,
-0.3385586143,
0.3045957088,
-0.4571288526,
-0.4945523441,
0.7185883522,
-0.6765163541,
0.3602935076,
-0.1315322369,
-0.7800995708,
-0.4456534684,
0.0861452147,
-1.3926339149,
0.9302000999,
0.0300064683,
-1.1448457241,
0.6110229492,
-0.7917852998,
-0.4336862266,
0.2538684011,
-0.3194145858,
-0.6564614177,
0.0680884495,
0.3334717453,
0.6642715335,
-0.0807716921,
0.3158024848,
0.196447432,
-0.3329468071,
0.0610261783,
-0.339233309,
0.5688340664,
-0.2657229602,
-0.1844979078,
-0.0390164517,
-0.983235538,
-0.1054084376,
0.5740506053,
-0.5947304368,
-0.5158265829,
0.151201576,
0.4301868081,
-0.0039624525,
-0.1901781261,
-0.4903264642,
0.3986833096,
-0.2415986657,
0.2632604837,
0.1444946229,
0.0537530258,
0.5260493755,
0.0085365605,
0.4808265567,
0.3860591352,
-0.3674752414,
-0.0507920012,
-0.3062018156,
-1.0332325697,
-0.100103274,
0.8177245855,
0.6784293056,
-1.0080122948,
0.1590346694,
-0.656031251,
-0.4768832624,
-0.3690459728,
-0.3108654618,
-0.0283034388,
0.4105259478,
0.7112574577,
-0.1249890551,
-0.8888985515,
-1.0413649082,
-0.2529082298,
0.1338274479,
0.1254046857,
0.1813707501,
0.6964277625,
-0.2803562582,
1.0069357157,
-0.2804212272,
-0.1091340035,
-0.5338098407,
0.1109939441,
0.1786524504,
0.3443912268,
0.5555606484,
-1.2687754631,
-0.1963802278,
-0.0983812436,
-0.4948994517,
0.6415176988,
-0.1736381203,
0.1762438565,
-0.0773532093,
0.2318452746,
-0.5644468069,
0.426063776,
0.3351584077,
-0.0707964897,
0.1869915873,
-0.0112454221,
0.1065746471,
-1.1999346018,
-0.0832929388,
0.1078283936,
-0.3648992181,
-1.0079661608,
-0.1233699024,
0.3423818648,
-0.2558816373,
-0.4966023266,
0.4195556343,
-0.6889506578,
0.0844434574,
-0.1483421475,
-0.1345560551,
-0.1788575202,
0.45863837,
0.4602623284,
0.7220958471,
0.7378485203,
-0.6689497232,
0.6419926286,
0.3428716362,
-0.0840339437,
0.6505798697,
-0.5646935701,
0.2223799676,
-0.4911503196,
0.2767150104,
-0.7337387204,
-0.4058202207,
0.1694399267,
-0.2646094859,
0.7258482575,
-0.0022141563,
-0.3760987818,
-0.6414924264,
0.0473536141,
0.378783226,
-0.0528942496,
-0.8659768105,
1.053896904,
0.4484226704,
0.185588792,
-0.5077971816,
-0.852137804,
0.1851070821,
-0.7706961036,
-0.4388712943,
0.8604069948,
0.3323043287,
0.2251653224,
-0.0152300568,
-0.1357313246,
-0.2623375058,
-0.049665913,
0.1684913039,
0.4098491669,
-0.1555304825,
0.4151634872,
-0.2296775579,
-0.2853655517,
-0.2596324086,
-0.0763415471,
0.4648058712,
0.2219013572,
-0.0878593475,
-0.4296891689,
0.5686042309,
0.5178912282,
-0.3269991875,
1.0087815523,
0.4394479394,
-0.7275767922,
-0.2238569558,
-0.3795312345,
-0.0597415604,
-0.3189812899,
0.0646971539,
-0.6534902453,
-0.6766058803,
0.5883321166,
-0.3361018896,
-0.1092769653,
0.5329887271,
0.3313960731,
-0.0604632013,
0.8003930449,
0.8721442819,
-0.1945542693,
0.260062784,
-0.2180796862,
0.6740909815,
-0.8264116049,
-0.437663883,
-0.5544173717,
-0.4277220666,
-0.6106581092,
-0.2358078063,
0.104521893,
0.0784603879,
0.0983390734,
1.130289197,
-0.6230704188,
0.2352578193,
0.4931235015,
0.2161493301,
0.3081255555,
0.0289197266,
-0.1226066351,
-0.1549184322,
-0.6614310145,
-0.7237814665,
1.1034773588,
0.4590118527,
0.6111887693,
0.0012721481,
0.8150126338,
-0.0600442812,
0.0765432119,
-0.9270185828,
0.3646408021,
-0.0604044497,
-0.5018328428,
-0.2271070331,
-0.363686949,
-1.053045392,
0.1758665442,
-0.3863019645,
-0.7470391393,
0.3135014176,
-0.1473078579,
-0.2261240184,
0.2595845759,
-0.7360019088,
0.8053021431,
-0.3053419888,
0.3688679338,
0.241691649,
-0.523041904,
-0.0294287317,
-0.1943538338,
-0.047321178,
0.2261073738,
0.0257796459,
1.0584732294,
0.1342184097,
0.3891260624,
-0.1147886887,
0.1517500579,
-0.0572131388,
-0.4596904814,
0.6343639493,
0.0764725357,
0.2054944783,
0.3680123687,
-0.0879305825,
-0.0835361183,
-0.5966230631,
0.4056349099,
-0.5789657235,
-0.2573378086,
-0.2622954249,
-0.5920777321,
-0.2947332561,
0.448089391,
0.5038957,
0.3003336787,
-0.4045560062,
0.3232925832,
0.8212214112,
0.1161280498,
0.5479177833,
0.4500379264,
0.0112705026,
-0.4475574493,
0.4918285608,
0.2733661532,
-0.1872285008,
0.5409911275,
-0.3506973386,
-0.1107626408,
-0.4717487097,
-0.407553792,
0.1740659922,
-0.7366671562,
-0.4856928289,
-0.8352311254,
-0.3875099421,
-0.2018079609,
0.2840105295,
-0.3907624483,
-0.4436786473,
-0.3139099181,
-0.0972173065,
0.2879990041,
0.64403373,
0.48080948,
0.2987835705,
-0.6071158648,
0.4178107083,
0.1772028357,
0.5276954174,
-0.1982288808,
-0.100430809,
-0.2309830785,
-0.1635967344,
-0.1671182811,
-1.3824490309,
0.1382844597,
0.0428069681,
0.9023111463,
0.1413002312,
-0.1438403577,
0.448669225,
-0.7531481385,
0.4998283684,
0.1110110432,
-0.7818520069,
0.6958354115,
-0.0267999582,
-0.0440469384,
0.476385504,
0.6802480221,
-0.4810613692,
-0.1031922027,
-0.5933300257,
-0.6845472455,
0.955527246,
0.4356358647,
0.1318744272,
0.1416266859,
0.1921842843,
0.0819130838,
-0.0157096758,
-1.0034550428,
-0.5788058639,
-0.0320563242,
-0.3209277391,
0.2635054886,
0.0073417909,
-0.1094423309,
-0.2736397684,
0.7217260003,
-0.0060841264,
0.632060945,
0.0285967756,
-0.2019277215,
0.0632740334,
0.2783415318,
0.2300855964,
0.2697342038,
0.0457524545,
0.0414255783,
0.3551108539,
-0.5265231133,
0.1919822395,
0.4422930479,
-0.2173388451,
0.3998191059,
0.4058569074,
1.1460187435,
0.5521591902,
-0.2931837142,
0.3819977045,
-0.3796925545,
0.0544998497,
-0.2175374329,
0.1357051134,
0.1939313412,
0.2934304476,
0.4392680824,
0.1919141859,
0.1099668667,
-0.2170997113,
0.2640179992,
0.4296440482,
-0.2051303834,
-0.0707925633,
0.5849673748,
-0.088349767,
-0.3206769824,
0.5433247685,
0.0777306929,
-0.6465401053,
0.7122561336,
0.6192522645,
0.6908105612,
-0.5243977308,
0.0856636167,
0.4768010676,
0.1274900436,
-0.5238164663,
0.1017582044,
-0.0836468264,
-1.0584141016,
0.0346159525,
-0.372721225,
-0.3890759647,
0.1400071681,
-0.9610723257,
0.8879960775,
0.0556904636,
-0.4343197942,
0.5279027224,
-0.0924176052,
-1.1572343111,
0.3744449615,
0.340649873,
0.8604164124,
-0.8207804561,
0.7805097103,
1.2118473053,
-0.5950299501,
-1.0707648993,
-0.0206107628,
-0.3952675462,
-0.4353486896,
0.5903573632,
0.4522002041,
0.1808601618,
0.0963842198,
-0.2692755461,
-1.3148841858,
1.3390808105,
0.3097784221,
-0.709333539,
-0.3463334143,
0.126716271,
0.512560904,
-0.6870883107,
-0.0393903404,
0.6479594111,
0.4931729138,
0.1650657952,
-0.998447299,
-0.1940047145,
-0.0860851035,
0.2486069053,
0.3395889401,
-0.3527158499,
0.5666165352,
-0.0082237963,
-0.9542583823,
-0.2126511335,
0.7381467819,
0.0299109165,
0.2334380001,
0.5257870555,
0.7907595038,
0.9111344814,
-0.4075447917,
0.8710603118,
-0.3590620458,
0.8461171389,
1.0889856815,
-0.2598588765,
0.8488132954,
0.5649676323,
-0.2343288511,
0.476085484,
0.3929447532,
-0.5097722411,
0.7898270488,
-0.1263653487,
-0.0224357415,
0.0543444417,
0.0381510966,
-0.169566229,
0.7593089938,
0.1383564323,
-0.590069592,
-0.4924759567,
0.596758306,
-0.0902847648,
-0.2542861104,
-0.2319629043,
0.849745214,
-0.1861710548,
-0.4901069403,
0.2599869967,
0.1181318611,
0.5682972074,
-0.2395422608,
-0.078117229,
0.1639309824,
0.0576633923,
-0.2672073245,
-0.6662980914,
0.3337405026,
0.0509417616,
-0.5845019221,
-0.1240241453,
0.918786943,
-0.6460496187,
-0.8108292222,
0.4187461138,
0.2995303571,
0.0149406567,
0.0889850557,
-0.3961132765,
0.1212842986,
-0.0902310312,
-0.1604836583,
-0.0863706842,
0.2896046937,
-0.0297542214,
0.492823422,
0.1570748985,
0.0542042106,
0.0615492836,
0.2300375551,
1.0152131319,
-0.758751452,
-0.3507499397,
-0.6205500364,
0.5621030331,
-0.0731605813,
0.0779879764,
0.6030645967,
0.5479359627,
1.012673378,
-0.1633737832,
0.7347553372,
0.0870727524,
0.708322525,
-0.4896159172,
0.4575889707,
-0.2254068255,
0.0524425283,
-0.0636372343,
-1.2435145378,
-0.4489894509,
0.5527114272,
-0.1858220845,
0.0480961949,
0.7506420016,
0.309351176,
-0.3389906585,
0.1362740099,
0.1815386862,
-0.2079239041,
0.2152960002,
0.7075456977,
0.5244172215,
-0.8585140705,
0.2779932916,
-0.2779419422,
0.1620560735,
-0.0218831375,
-0.6967145205,
-0.9620792866,
-0.6797267795,
-0.356862396,
0.0175742526,
-0.2728526294,
0.7384001017,
0.713049829,
-0.9693499207,
0.3800602555,
-0.0520982333,
-0.1350654811,
-0.1537399888,
-0.246139586,
0.403285563,
-0.1722459495,
-0.7683780789,
0.4991433918,
0.3237250745,
0.2069158405,
-0.2180153728,
0.2762175202,
-0.0355399624,
0.016268868,
0.4036533237,
0.0743446648,
-0.7438035011,
-0.2457813621,
0.0619202442,
-0.1799260974,
0.3874617219,
1.0877672434,
-0.9624034762,
0.6215341687,
0.236882627,
0.7468820214,
0.3941298425,
0.1196807474,
0.424693197,
-0.6682593226,
0.1193456426,
0.2725565732,
0.5803349614,
0.7610839605,
-0.7345787287,
0.5248578191,
0.1663364172,
-0.3184640706,
-0.5727119446,
-0.0038254778,
-1.0998773575,
-0.0234626047,
0.8744492531,
-0.1191302091,
0.0497893095,
0.0011253126,
-0.1219934374,
0.4544271529,
-0.2235684097,
0.4853723943,
1.008223772,
-0.319406569,
-0.2987609804,
-0.4625756741,
0.210381642,
-0.1201939657,
-0.7265398502,
-0.2141511589,
0.1738759577,
0.3363354802,
0.4777029157,
0.1291508228,
-0.0297408234,
0.0173175354,
-0.1248555407,
0.0598377213,
0.1429458559,
-0.6458079815,
-0.5784564018,
0.1674081981,
-0.3565369844,
-0.1640788168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17465v1
|
Enhancing Tool Retrieval with Iterative Feedback from Large Language Models
| 2024-06-25T11:12:01 | 2024-06-25T11:12:01 |
Qiancheng Xu, Yongqi Li, Heming Xia, Wenjie Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Tool learning aims to enhance and expand large language models' (LLMs)
capabilities with external tools, which has gained significant attention
recently. Current methods have shown that LLMs can effectively handle a certain
amount of tools through in-context learning or fine-tuning. However, in
real-world scenarios, the number of tools is typically extensive and
irregularly updated, emphasizing the necessity for a dedicated tool retrieval
component. Tool retrieval is nontrivial due to the following challenges: 1)
complex user instructions and tool descriptions; 2) misalignment between tool
retrieval and tool usage models. To address the above issues, we propose to
enhance tool retrieval with iterative feedback from the large language model.
Specifically, we prompt the tool usage model, i.e., the LLM, to provide
feedback for the tool retriever model in multi-round, which could progressively
improve the tool retriever's understanding of instructions and tools and reduce
the gap between the two standalone components. We build a unified and
comprehensive benchmark to evaluate tool retrieval models. The extensive
experiments indicate that our proposed approach achieves advanced performance
in both in-domain evaluation and out-of-domain evaluation.
|
[
-0.1824499816,
-0.7264737487,
0.6172845364,
0.0658593103,
-0.4820213318,
0.2175848931,
-0.4756203294,
-0.444406122,
0.0090246815,
0.414660573,
-0.4623666108,
-0.6140263677,
-0.5537368059,
0.0060224668,
-0.5346330404,
0.7010889053,
0.0652648062,
0.2477359027,
-0.1706020385,
-0.1052429676,
-0.7084802985,
-0.638002038,
-0.5122093558,
-0.5035206676,
0.4676811993,
0.4656352103,
0.3909701407,
0.3312399685,
0.5136840343,
0.3504544199,
-0.0914420336,
0.1151809394,
-0.5606992245,
0.1055274904,
-0.2953375876,
-0.3207212687,
-0.2290352583,
-0.2157712877,
0.6316708326,
0.803776741,
-0.3895056546,
0.2645584643,
0.1837467104,
0.212455526,
-0.5664023757,
0.080893293,
-0.8402643204,
-0.2226767689,
-0.2055096477,
-0.3273434341,
-0.7900400162,
-0.3405644596,
0.1974301189,
-0.629422009,
0.2653862536,
0.0640637502,
0.4489428997,
0.0230861995,
-0.3235227764,
-0.2474928349,
-0.7167167068,
0.8705063462,
-0.8528690934,
0.6565516591,
0.4432348311,
0.4452136159,
-0.3385759592,
-0.7561222911,
-0.245581463,
-0.6407796741,
0.0995734856,
-0.129354775,
0.2208601385,
-0.3096163571,
0.3759978712,
0.2653516531,
-0.0852079093,
0.3288450539,
-0.4563101828,
-0.2654746473,
0.6644303203,
0.2361087054,
-0.1126812696,
0.1319788545,
-0.3106623888,
-0.198210448,
-0.8482635021,
-0.12171866,
0.3124756813,
0.5203983784,
0.1315678358,
0.6470918655,
-0.064909704,
0.6786540747,
-0.005367178,
-0.2026339173,
0.4149174392,
-0.3660711646,
-0.047853373,
-0.3170617819,
0.4938154817,
0.3169053197,
-0.0878505856,
-0.5200388432,
-0.533372879,
-0.4666747749,
0.5556162596,
-0.9541834593,
-0.0864252001,
-0.112490654,
-0.3765248358,
0.0122920005,
0.2054751962,
-0.5638953447,
-0.7054309249,
-0.3674035072,
0.6014326215,
-0.3035790324,
-0.3730413318,
0.0784501657,
-0.1313519776,
0.1842992157,
0.6699873805,
-0.3504336476,
0.1543644965,
0.6005573869,
0.9788743854,
-0.2818207443,
-0.1504386961,
-1.074126482,
0.0707530826,
-0.1454428434,
0.7547249794,
-0.9339127541,
-0.7370265126,
0.037556611,
0.218249917,
0.1762034893,
-0.833244741,
0.2074896246,
-0.7661572099,
0.1589500457,
-0.2850598991,
-0.5636231899,
-0.4566418529,
0.227625668,
-0.6825587749,
1.2968018055,
0.1250561029,
-0.5363616943,
0.3454262018,
-0.5653586984,
-0.3698135614,
0.1916671693,
-0.1200750843,
-0.4583800733,
0.3611237407,
0.1111092716,
0.3545286953,
-0.5387835503,
0.3238332272,
-0.8686057329,
-0.6052790284,
0.019046111,
-0.302541703,
0.4743469656,
0.0138140582,
-0.25034374,
0.4635588825,
-0.5585740805,
-0.0638921857,
0.0869772658,
-0.5232508779,
-0.2119321227,
-0.1234828159,
0.1094779447,
0.2762765586,
0.209424898,
-0.6497166753,
0.4861839116,
-0.4974968731,
0.217492342,
0.8353801966,
0.0513310544,
0.4106556773,
-0.0975548849,
0.4672594666,
0.0071820091,
-0.0170210656,
-0.1241312996,
0.0071795685,
-0.6021297574,
-0.0847810581,
0.4127705991,
0.2992677093,
-0.8554767966,
0.3112167418,
-0.1572466791,
-0.4559737444,
-0.5328534842,
0.5190527439,
0.3373310566,
0.2996175885,
0.430059135,
-0.7936800122,
-0.3259829879,
-0.5621213317,
-0.1165207773,
0.0125659145,
-0.3200792968,
0.463835448,
0.4326563776,
-0.1382500231,
0.5905529857,
-0.2513426542,
-0.3411664069,
-0.3288789093,
0.1307797432,
0.0984154269,
0.2265405059,
0.0587738343,
-0.5097855926,
-0.3943649828,
0.0551874898,
-0.4080924094,
-0.0616713241,
0.1823817194,
0.0318974108,
0.0495887473,
0.7470492125,
-0.3697152138,
0.414890945,
0.1002398804,
-0.0787948817,
0.5696761608,
-0.2959733009,
-0.175083667,
-0.9330777526,
0.4286665618,
-0.0780868679,
-0.3497745693,
-0.2509819269,
0.1991025209,
0.2040468752,
0.1495344639,
-0.5532938242,
0.8872981071,
-0.5669958591,
-0.2511914372,
-0.3917637765,
0.3994946778,
-0.1553096324,
0.3094597459,
-0.1481811553,
0.9271349311,
0.4847724438,
-0.647819221,
0.3746806085,
-0.0449554883,
-0.2975396216,
0.5147024393,
-0.6764197946,
0.5041257739,
-0.0039604302,
0.2170760185,
-0.7783615589,
-0.0727783665,
-0.1291251034,
-0.1411312819,
0.4531943202,
-0.2136367559,
-0.9939537644,
-0.3723435998,
-0.5413956046,
0.0161839835,
0.2051905692,
-0.7512175441,
0.7727392316,
0.3943882585,
-0.1211413369,
-0.5592476726,
0.1500378102,
-0.0417433195,
-0.1669484526,
-0.2264745384,
-0.0004339952,
-0.3057474196,
-0.102525495,
-0.3466483653,
-0.4921321571,
0.0574711114,
0.2662119269,
0.0917026699,
0.2001525909,
0.0879061446,
0.5031526089,
-0.2871992588,
-0.075663574,
-0.0289509706,
-0.1783655435,
0.641323626,
-0.0161975343,
-0.6897400022,
-0.0312369149,
0.2846688032,
0.3678624928,
-0.4365347922,
0.4272207022,
0.8584448099,
-0.1683838218,
-0.204738006,
-0.9141383171,
-0.5962464213,
-0.5215396881,
0.5235540867,
-0.5270195603,
-0.9507412314,
0.3835802078,
-0.5956737995,
0.3253642619,
0.2012191862,
0.790802598,
0.1305425763,
1.3799253702,
0.9767541289,
-0.2536085546,
0.5697047114,
-0.3669261634,
-0.0160197262,
-1.10577631,
-0.3579164445,
-0.5918287635,
-0.186719358,
-0.1303848326,
-0.4078319073,
0.2537952363,
0.3017987013,
-0.1485765129,
0.371455133,
-0.3026813865,
0.4728975892,
0.6169893742,
0.2412404865,
0.4914905429,
0.0525435098,
-0.5435587168,
0.1334336847,
-0.6982450485,
-0.5140706897,
1.1390622854,
0.308469981,
0.8427516222,
0.2861454487,
0.5729598403,
0.0974470451,
0.5822652578,
-0.9485897422,
0.4974423051,
-0.0776274279,
-0.412940979,
-0.1257224232,
-0.392351985,
-0.930270493,
0.4172107279,
0.0968271792,
-1.1086761951,
-0.1490496844,
0.0172885526,
-0.3122782707,
0.1765289903,
-0.6808223724,
0.6883082986,
-0.1378972381,
-0.5203568935,
-0.4291648567,
-0.6083243489,
-0.0108175324,
-0.201072678,
0.204223603,
-0.0433471911,
0.0479055494,
0.4478738904,
-0.3796089888,
0.9724904895,
-0.3613613546,
-0.4243258536,
0.0227653105,
0.2690957785,
0.7945227623,
0.164669618,
-0.4396698177,
-0.2193730474,
-0.0492297374,
-0.091023162,
-0.6596150398,
0.7998710871,
-0.6161955595,
-0.8410579562,
-0.0228195991,
-0.6024852395,
-0.3508219719,
0.4340221584,
-0.0854134038,
0.6443463564,
0.0400397182,
0.4261084497,
0.478557229,
-0.2674710155,
0.3951988518,
0.7618812323,
-0.464646101,
0.0445781574,
0.8193145394,
0.0361394659,
0.201226145,
0.1884191334,
0.0384180397,
-0.5629981756,
-0.5320913196,
-0.5515217185,
0.3302765489,
-0.9644809365,
-0.4017169774,
-0.5135408044,
0.1349171251,
-0.0097359242,
0.1388736367,
-0.3390191197,
-0.1883131117,
-0.3304611742,
-0.020925479,
0.4422717988,
0.9176525474,
0.2898992896,
0.3222641349,
-0.8076472282,
0.0290974304,
-0.0161912721,
0.7835974097,
0.3667232692,
-0.814850688,
-0.2884932756,
-0.1107876748,
-0.4916505218,
-0.7036249638,
0.1412160844,
0.0838833749,
0.6441323161,
0.1650976241,
0.0861160904,
0.7965875268,
-0.6176335216,
0.5916863084,
-0.1208812073,
-0.8371019363,
0.3213913143,
-0.0132976733,
0.5942453742,
0.4780012071,
0.2397421449,
-0.3556158543,
-0.5035490394,
-0.4415051639,
-1.0641357899,
0.8011270761,
-0.1888834983,
0.2101673633,
0.2157841474,
0.3514460623,
0.3788345754,
0.2968529761,
-0.6466213465,
0.14985241,
0.0632493272,
0.0505813397,
0.053007789,
-0.0013492451,
-0.1759013385,
-0.1715712398,
0.8135225773,
-0.4113985896,
0.1716106534,
-0.1770286411,
-0.4851314127,
-0.2470858991,
0.3722501099,
0.3210240602,
1.023067832,
-0.1023103669,
0.1066975817,
0.5766342282,
-0.2067518681,
0.0018110607,
0.2061652541,
0.1021080017,
0.1086019352,
0.215632081,
0.6000962257,
0.3208619654,
-0.7873035669,
0.4773950875,
0.0257429313,
0.1308998317,
-0.2695188224,
0.0289701782,
0.2542254627,
0.5123773813,
0.4258452356,
-0.3886945844,
0.3475044072,
-0.3994452357,
0.3683328927,
0.7100210786,
-0.510011375,
-0.3036006987,
0.427016288,
0.1665554494,
-0.3941906691,
0.6150649786,
-0.2761451006,
-0.4008497298,
0.3111411631,
0.6040915251,
0.6752253175,
-0.0332897939,
0.0174393691,
0.4638254941,
0.2103230357,
-0.239838928,
0.2701618373,
-0.2099238187,
-0.2421579212,
-0.6505249739,
-0.4844766259,
-0.3252511322,
0.2506368756,
-0.6027418375,
0.5197545886,
-0.3676524758,
-0.2287346274,
-0.24267672,
0.0751640052,
-0.7903602123,
-0.2075178325,
-0.2004433274,
1.0608259439,
-0.2599205971,
1.032351017,
0.7495584488,
-0.4802082479,
-0.9773489833,
-0.0301344171,
0.1363842338,
-0.7052913904,
0.6408655047,
0.5122169852,
-0.3820364177,
0.0722372159,
-0.5392120481,
-0.8930736184,
1.1256257296,
0.4000613391,
-0.742883265,
0.0179570485,
-0.2720970511,
0.4988798797,
-0.1961264908,
0.5893880129,
0.3438129127,
0.258151561,
0.3638098836,
-1.4091281891,
0.1990415603,
-0.2644786239,
0.2914859653,
0.446374625,
-0.4172489941,
0.4610711634,
-0.3174481392,
-0.3019408286,
0.157915622,
0.3913862407,
0.3023919463,
-0.0195921175,
0.5149273276,
0.441888988,
0.4831843972,
0.1530657709,
1.0773620605,
-0.0705632567,
0.4510546625,
1.3881161213,
-0.4987305403,
1.0340723991,
0.4656533301,
0.0283799674,
0.2997112572,
0.5200077891,
0.0036704012,
0.4123445153,
0.3724270463,
-0.2058131993,
-0.3907173872,
-0.2696018815,
-0.3480681777,
0.3547767997,
0.2854022086,
-0.3622928858,
-0.4955671728,
0.0985920131,
-0.0595329925,
-0.1534069777,
-0.2311534286,
1.1479833126,
0.16355066,
-0.5196148753,
0.5187823772,
0.2099374682,
0.6417628527,
-0.562995255,
-0.3583595753,
-0.0011692304,
0.4788794219,
0.0265439376,
-0.5290329456,
0.1592930704,
-0.1224833056,
0.0621837042,
-0.0004446526,
0.6600065827,
-0.475832969,
-0.458827436,
0.6385147572,
0.4566965997,
0.0070861452,
-0.1262801141,
-0.744382441,
0.2721494734,
-0.1530556381,
-0.2116751969,
0.402794987,
0.2924055755,
-0.1708532125,
0.8933622837,
0.6050981879,
-0.0209280364,
-0.0148464944,
0.5209864974,
1.0338779688,
-0.5219903588,
-0.2223555297,
-0.7830310464,
0.433933109,
-0.2014758289,
0.0242234878,
0.9175782204,
0.4356085956,
1.1798304319,
0.0474809259,
0.5613159537,
0.0401536562,
0.8057924509,
-0.3910810947,
0.3064470887,
-0.7405792475,
0.7444993854,
-0.2488202155,
-1.0486543179,
-0.2550870478,
0.5480324626,
-0.3362742066,
0.3023715317,
0.4818374515,
0.8360564113,
-0.3266580105,
-0.1483190358,
0.144595027,
0.2002652287,
0.3660983443,
0.2256757766,
0.7203713059,
-0.1458752453,
0.5959230065,
-0.1598335057,
-0.0191293508,
-0.4241785407,
-0.8038821816,
-0.8677690029,
-0.507124722,
-0.1437091827,
-0.3194074035,
-0.0762231499,
1.2719472647,
0.8435621858,
-0.6738806367,
-0.592734158,
0.290856272,
0.045548141,
-0.1097603738,
-0.220626846,
0.146103248,
-0.518304944,
-0.5832081437,
0.4887637198,
0.3632713258,
-0.3344087303,
-0.4512583613,
-0.0671850368,
-0.242273584,
-0.1764778197,
0.9068219662,
-0.0111995386,
-0.8764815927,
-0.4459554553,
0.2538692057,
0.2464769781,
0.0794458464,
0.9886146784,
-0.8504396677,
0.7458553314,
0.2349817306,
0.7624441981,
0.6115551591,
-0.1772696525,
0.7829582095,
-1.1411069632,
-0.0264566969,
0.1258294284,
0.3692625463,
0.616948247,
-0.2102450579,
0.5345453024,
-0.0933782458,
-0.281979084,
-0.9575343132,
0.3102231324,
-0.446328938,
-0.2778576016,
1.1498382092,
-0.1690590978,
0.2627981603,
-0.3409278691,
-0.4987712502,
0.329087764,
-0.6075082421,
1.0299288034,
0.7170088887,
0.0824964941,
-0.2764982879,
-0.6668345928,
0.0823232457,
0.3398088813,
-0.70625633,
0.3194600642,
0.5058930516,
0.4076185524,
0.1436046809,
0.476513803,
-0.3288215697,
0.2945274711,
-0.526253581,
0.0047073839,
-0.0358132869,
-0.4539032578,
-0.4127040505,
0.1047109365,
0.5615113378,
0.2569437921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00875v1
|
MoE-CT: A Novel Approach For Large Language Models Training With Resistance To Catastrophic Forgetting
| 2024-06-25T11:03:45 | 2024-06-25T11:03:45 |
Tianhao Li, Shangjie Li, Binbin Xie, Deyi Xiong, Baosong Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of large language models (LLMs) has predominantly catered to
high-resource languages, leaving a disparity in performance for low-resource
languages. Conventional Continual Training (CT) approaches to bridge this gap
often undermine a model's original linguistic proficiency when expanding to
multilingual contexts. Addressing this issue, we introduce a novel MoE-CT
architecture, a paradigm that innovatively separates the base model's learning
from the multilingual expansion process. Our design freezes the original LLM
parameters, thus safeguarding its performance in high-resource languages, while
an appended MoE module, trained on diverse language datasets, augments
low-resource language proficiency. Our approach significantly outperforms
conventional CT methods, as evidenced by our experiments, which show marked
improvements in multilingual benchmarks without sacrificing the model's
original language performance. Moreover, our MoE-CT framework demonstrates
enhanced resistance to forgetting and superior transfer learning capabilities.
By preserving the base model's integrity and focusing on strategic parameter
expansion, our methodology advances multilingual language modeling and
represents a significant step forward for low-resource language inclusion in
LLMs, indicating a fruitful direction for future research in language
technologies.
|
[
-0.3146820664,
-0.753475368,
0.3413057327,
0.1434392929,
-0.1795579195,
0.2438375652,
-0.5699662566,
-0.1571723223,
-0.1287366301,
0.3494779468,
-0.534533143,
-0.3670362234,
-0.672127068,
-0.0065994961,
0.1316412836,
0.6914941669,
-0.0646359846,
0.2268192023,
-0.1177717,
-0.477273047,
-0.8408304453,
-0.6871557236,
-0.7909492254,
-0.3998821378,
0.6185871363,
0.3325755298,
0.3997209966,
0.592114985,
0.3081045151,
0.2171247154,
0.0423650183,
0.0955844223,
-0.7762959599,
0.0986323804,
-0.1836534441,
-0.5662593842,
-0.6226828694,
-0.3777308762,
0.9991787672,
0.805090785,
-0.2877325118,
-0.1300776005,
0.2877191007,
0.720277369,
-0.8723301888,
0.2150309831,
-0.9574964643,
0.0103925746,
-0.3678669035,
-0.0716297999,
-0.8072988987,
0.0339570493,
0.0239045788,
-0.4683283865,
-0.0457429104,
-0.2658376396,
0.6092653871,
0.0202763211,
-0.3987743258,
-0.207632497,
-0.7349995971,
1.0560920238,
-0.3015165031,
0.6224149466,
0.2407254726,
0.1591639668,
0.1092216074,
-0.2762108743,
-0.1455461532,
-0.4487270415,
0.3982600272,
0.2049834281,
0.0556294061,
-0.1930544078,
-0.0775561333,
0.2093060315,
-0.6237987876,
0.2831062376,
-0.4682101011,
-0.217824921,
0.3381924033,
0.1505680531,
0.2976589203,
0.3461365104,
-0.6838973165,
0.0585676059,
-1.1537430286,
-0.2294791043,
0.1090505496,
0.4543084204,
-0.1788522005,
0.1740469038,
0.0916166157,
0.2880669236,
-0.1540086716,
-0.0478415452,
0.1801006049,
0.058605466,
0.0126429554,
0.0823406577,
0.7199314833,
-0.0934074372,
0.305216223,
-0.2850149572,
-0.2585517466,
-0.1327064186,
0.1985036731,
-0.5234891176,
-0.1742897332,
-0.1865808815,
-0.2712962925,
0.0143089006,
-0.2632514238,
-0.5532782078,
-0.0915935189,
-0.0870099068,
0.41602543,
-0.9433034062,
-0.5275344253,
-0.0523977317,
0.2119857222,
-0.1131107584,
0.2808414996,
-0.9593169689,
0.0813256949,
0.5860791802,
1.0681993961,
-0.3228197694,
-0.602933526,
-0.3933265507,
0.5720728636,
-0.471993804,
0.5505974889,
-0.716175139,
-0.6021553278,
0.1057849675,
-0.2177747041,
-0.1460587978,
-0.6569039226,
0.1810370982,
-0.7442200184,
-0.0331983194,
-0.1252072006,
-0.3712056577,
-0.2404128611,
0.5990905166,
-0.6996483803,
0.8900001645,
0.1106955037,
-0.3363919854,
0.1861583591,
-0.7485583425,
-0.3044257164,
0.0468592383,
0.0880878642,
-0.3348419666,
0.2349312901,
0.1155181825,
0.3313142955,
-0.2757773995,
0.307844013,
-0.5624973774,
-0.2911156416,
0.10725227,
-1.0004473925,
0.8332099319,
0.1552614123,
0.109548904,
-0.099442862,
-0.6889508367,
-0.0414886065,
0.3783550262,
-0.7817075253,
-0.5221508145,
-0.2799393237,
0.0025082028,
0.3009402454,
0.4982271194,
-0.3605778813,
0.3712945879,
-0.4265647233,
0.4265649319,
0.9999679923,
-0.2768387198,
0.6095543504,
-0.4365064502,
0.5332604051,
0.2600946426,
0.1125518829,
-0.666749239,
-0.2402644455,
-0.8532213569,
-0.3054369688,
0.1872977465,
0.4905079901,
-0.8517866731,
0.0084095486,
-0.7117533684,
-0.4652780294,
-0.3111494482,
0.4642251134,
0.6118867397,
0.227966547,
0.409624964,
-0.4576376379,
-0.4458318055,
-0.7795827389,
-0.0550891347,
-0.2424513102,
0.0918251276,
-0.0506243967,
0.3219430149,
-0.0760548562,
0.6461017728,
-0.0851617083,
-0.2528832853,
-0.5145515203,
0.0062080552,
0.033441592,
0.68700248,
0.5228707194,
-0.6350468397,
-0.5346530676,
0.1186146885,
-0.722741127,
0.2647174001,
-0.1752019078,
-0.1137199029,
0.4248953164,
0.4435353577,
-0.4462288916,
0.0082703838,
0.6303883195,
0.2676977813,
0.4932106435,
-0.3384270072,
-0.1888637692,
-1.2522798777,
0.0574083626,
-0.3584276438,
0.1383166462,
-0.5427120328,
0.2056947798,
0.2298415601,
-0.1362558752,
-0.5478398204,
0.8982131481,
-0.7036660314,
0.3043394089,
-0.2235898674,
-0.1303137988,
-0.2724975646,
0.6405909657,
0.050824482,
0.7410461903,
0.681075871,
-0.7645998001,
0.2512767613,
0.0741437897,
-0.0407023616,
0.6145674586,
-0.2227574438,
0.2440479547,
-0.0665367097,
0.1831978709,
-0.8449243307,
-0.0352475494,
0.1551511139,
-0.2994988859,
0.6178592443,
-0.3979159296,
-0.331440717,
-0.2227271199,
-0.1007489935,
0.6893486977,
0.4409027696,
-0.3424386084,
0.8494958878,
0.1555185318,
-0.4417128563,
-0.5161603093,
-0.8218151927,
0.4098945558,
-0.3032864928,
-0.4565556943,
0.1817538291,
-0.2713118792,
-0.0521164648,
-0.2161047012,
0.1195339561,
-0.5051550865,
0.2373259068,
0.0114748562,
0.2264390588,
-0.6565769911,
0.3857554793,
0.0193394572,
-0.3369060457,
-0.0809193775,
-0.5272384882,
0.8836061358,
-0.1197867692,
-0.4728049934,
-0.5326761007,
0.5672214031,
0.7990058661,
-0.3458780944,
0.8075853586,
0.4438882768,
-0.3945860267,
-0.1826765388,
-0.6568247676,
-0.0915492773,
-0.4644837677,
0.6875898242,
-0.4981010258,
-0.6834877133,
0.4333385527,
-0.160863921,
0.2286638319,
0.253361702,
0.7613993287,
0.0827523246,
0.6948025227,
0.8811488152,
-0.3258203566,
0.7231429219,
0.0047459817,
0.0165049601,
-0.8418139815,
-0.053189531,
-0.0671130791,
-0.2039421052,
-0.2296733111,
-0.29678455,
0.2992975414,
0.108523719,
-0.360440582,
0.1898864806,
0.0921654478,
0.3168824613,
0.5899749994,
0.0695708245,
0.3145996928,
0.0216131918,
-0.3324146271,
-0.0318438448,
-1.0904603004,
-0.4667347968,
1.3950794935,
0.3178752363,
0.6297540665,
0.2383590043,
0.7704639435,
0.1264774799,
0.7072828412,
-0.6678358912,
0.4919529259,
-0.0728985295,
-0.6766095757,
-0.3254929781,
-0.4124528766,
-0.7980659604,
0.2617197931,
0.0722420365,
-0.5536308289,
-0.1534054875,
0.4087936282,
-0.4180184007,
0.5969004035,
-0.8164801598,
0.6250451803,
-0.4352608919,
-0.5659030676,
-0.3475810587,
-0.2828487754,
0.4111118317,
-0.3936317861,
0.2460948378,
-0.0545654707,
-0.1172011346,
0.422011584,
-0.0796434134,
0.9644227028,
-0.0174347665,
-0.3299500346,
0.2298151851,
0.3545385003,
0.4767410457,
0.0292528514,
-0.265614152,
0.4259319007,
-0.4648464024,
-0.666108191,
-0.2564749718,
0.7251625061,
-0.3993215263,
-0.6525310874,
-0.168178007,
-0.7777553797,
-0.4987416565,
0.418573916,
0.23636657,
0.3059010208,
-0.4278998375,
0.3923123777,
0.7883359194,
-0.1951019764,
0.5517940521,
0.4666567445,
0.1089932472,
-0.5158935785,
1.0209858418,
0.3280287385,
0.6459518075,
0.5575766563,
0.222550571,
-0.0571717918,
-0.5991617441,
-0.4017568529,
0.1460371166,
-0.5506119132,
-0.0715821162,
-0.592336297,
-0.1980496347,
-0.2074773759,
-0.3027197421,
-0.8562712669,
-0.0607662573,
-0.0835548788,
0.1962409914,
-0.0561852045,
0.5224494934,
-0.0429990105,
0.3034443855,
-1.1048318148,
0.0005005347,
0.231513381,
0.4305137396,
0.431145519,
-0.6026896834,
-0.5350468755,
0.2353123277,
-0.6822528243,
-0.4595738947,
0.332531184,
0.4044982195,
0.6054236293,
0.5702106357,
0.0058216304,
0.7618598938,
-0.7680210471,
0.6941233873,
0.4610805511,
-0.8021193743,
0.3929859698,
-0.5059902668,
0.5824465752,
0.2689400017,
0.2436251789,
-0.549811542,
-0.4515740275,
-0.4549915791,
-0.8849224448,
0.6213995814,
-0.022182228,
0.4816898108,
-0.1604490727,
0.1936609447,
0.318079561,
-0.0008393607,
-0.9399737716,
0.0294399653,
0.0092559531,
-0.1091746017,
0.0035288518,
-0.4821498692,
-0.073438406,
0.1939190626,
0.7133216858,
-0.1587678641,
0.2427667081,
-0.2539080679,
-0.458027482,
0.1054407284,
0.2394281626,
0.6268255711,
0.7136346698,
0.0796312913,
0.0443697125,
0.5871102214,
-0.4627285302,
0.1016539186,
-0.4740309119,
0.0865155011,
-0.1059829891,
0.6758604646,
0.5361284614,
0.5442457795,
-0.6308463216,
0.218978256,
0.267303139,
-0.132239908,
-0.3777240217,
0.0801598132,
0.2740685642,
0.0702096373,
0.2963825464,
0.1573639363,
-0.363929987,
-0.6619027257,
0.2704261541,
0.3398410678,
-0.5214571953,
-0.424992919,
0.7008054256,
0.287149936,
-0.2038113326,
0.7371878028,
0.1419971734,
-0.4016856849,
0.4593859911,
0.648643136,
0.8846654892,
-0.6337837577,
-0.1694090366,
0.4266932309,
0.4842974544,
-0.2867608368,
0.0262068901,
-0.040459808,
-0.6120604873,
-0.1487096995,
-0.3777076304,
-0.1524827182,
0.0988456458,
-0.7977664471,
0.3333651423,
-0.6812965274,
0.0465499796,
-0.6718420982,
-0.4448076487,
-0.5332921743,
-0.005359584,
0.3737921417,
1.0274378061,
-0.6073618531,
1.1564013958,
0.4936053157,
-0.3365639746,
-0.3302251995,
0.2039388567,
0.1695028841,
-1.0327349901,
0.6418423057,
0.2449619323,
-0.1823249161,
-0.0429011062,
-0.2015334964,
-0.9354089499,
1.0413762331,
0.7360206842,
-0.6357665062,
-0.0047598965,
0.0632860363,
0.2831224799,
-0.2338505387,
-0.1198609695,
0.1927742213,
0.2216750085,
0.0837947577,
-0.8905973434,
-0.2024449557,
-0.1204020977,
0.2218139619,
0.1890033185,
-0.8966991901,
0.7922519445,
-0.2128718495,
-0.2776951194,
0.3994699419,
0.6159324646,
0.2580133379,
0.1579249054,
0.3300704062,
0.403545469,
0.652410388,
-0.1628828943,
0.8403571248,
-0.3246737421,
0.4653758705,
1.2712385654,
-0.4187998772,
1.0518937111,
0.5185987353,
0.1122721508,
0.2342131436,
0.4231755435,
0.248060897,
0.559671402,
-0.0325782858,
-0.39550668,
-0.5568166375,
-0.02369144,
-0.4946524203,
0.428709805,
0.4872747362,
-0.1322425604,
-0.3519694209,
0.3109821379,
0.2025759667,
0.1416582763,
-0.3679811954,
0.6490113735,
0.1863592267,
-0.3542052805,
0.8096880913,
-0.1237579137,
0.6923488975,
-0.934671998,
0.0694331154,
-0.3905321956,
0.378518194,
0.4246502221,
-0.5113906264,
0.3668900728,
-0.093989864,
-0.2875830829,
-0.4746195376,
0.0383049957,
-0.5266980529,
-0.5499195457,
0.479555279,
0.398270905,
-0.2758978605,
-0.0006148757,
-0.6805207729,
0.2110446841,
-0.2095907927,
-0.2191797495,
0.328522861,
0.7443304062,
-0.250967145,
1.089525938,
0.6162904501,
0.0254154708,
0.1941301525,
-0.0616559051,
0.7958711386,
-0.5556852818,
-0.7082811594,
-1.0056496859,
0.4355090261,
0.0979914144,
-0.4851288199,
0.4258708954,
0.6183653474,
1.1752130985,
-0.1981550455,
0.9085593224,
0.2750531137,
0.1309874356,
-0.884681344,
0.983828187,
-0.7493059039,
0.3431255221,
-0.0511771515,
-0.8024227619,
-0.4763270319,
0.2438450307,
-0.256963402,
0.27482149,
0.7645465732,
0.7003561258,
-0.161565572,
-0.5189775825,
0.6234685779,
0.4595849812,
0.3839504719,
1.0888189077,
0.8863969445,
-0.1957998425,
0.8377637267,
-0.0001869955,
-0.1707541049,
-0.429009527,
-0.6614487767,
-0.959374249,
-0.5284905434,
-0.1703668833,
-0.034763705,
0.2163440734,
0.8960903287,
0.7688630223,
-0.7850960493,
-0.3214367032,
-0.0138764344,
0.1379010379,
-0.37991786,
-0.148359254,
0.2090770155,
-0.5294189453,
-0.9231219888,
0.4947483242,
0.6807350516,
-0.0387605652,
-0.2982499599,
-0.2969253361,
-0.1938276291,
0.0447177887,
0.5498201251,
0.4093845487,
-0.874242425,
-0.0857300162,
-0.1579033285,
-0.1295656413,
0.3040107191,
0.7627388835,
-0.5047775507,
0.6726306081,
0.094649002,
0.876303196,
-0.1197069213,
-0.5831106305,
0.9054551721,
-0.6885249615,
0.4658373594,
0.2190419286,
0.4989132881,
0.2214702815,
-0.2713628709,
0.1831187159,
0.4035836756,
0.0674337819,
-0.8129218817,
0.424412936,
-0.8081851006,
-0.281134814,
0.9524149895,
-0.2559435368,
-0.0379699543,
-0.1761035621,
-0.1933807433,
0.0432309993,
-0.3089314997,
1.1191833019,
1.0266379118,
0.3863761723,
-0.3168098032,
-0.4766874313,
-0.1086340025,
0.4213923216,
-0.3766345382,
0.3211238682,
0.2395280451,
0.4053739607,
0.1003835723,
0.577870965,
-0.3000866175,
0.3993656337,
-0.0109652681,
0.114379406,
-0.3241212666,
-0.6292765141,
-0.4138170183,
0.39285025,
0.1050210819,
-0.2009310573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17456v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17456v1
|
Improving Grammatical Error Correction via Contextual Data Augmentation
| 2024-06-25T10:49:56 | 2024-06-25T10:49:56 |
Yixuan Wang, Baoxin Wang, Yijun Liu, Qingfu Zhu, Dayong Wu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Nowadays, data augmentation through synthetic data has been widely used in
the field of Grammatical Error Correction (GEC) to alleviate the problem of
data scarcity. However, these synthetic data are mainly used in the
pre-training phase rather than the data-limited fine-tuning phase due to
inconsistent error distribution and noisy labels. In this paper, we propose a
synthetic data construction method based on contextual augmentation, which can
ensure an efficient augmentation of the original data with a more consistent
error distribution. Specifically, we combine rule-based substitution with
model-based generation, using the generative model to generate a richer context
for the extracted error patterns. Besides, we also propose a relabeling-based
data cleaning method to mitigate the effects of noisy labels in synthetic data.
Experiments on CoNLL14 and BEA19-Test show that our proposed augmentation
method consistently and substantially outperforms strong baselines and achieves
the state-of-the-art level with only a few synthetic data.
|
[
-0.1880768239,
-1.2080072165,
0.4130469859,
0.15232265,
-0.138324365,
-0.1272694319,
-0.3532695174,
-0.3022788167,
0.2049840838,
0.2282628715,
-0.8688496947,
-0.6411320567,
-0.2124172747,
0.3481722176,
-0.3929808736,
0.7458349466,
-0.0854484588,
0.2666894495,
-0.4057687521,
0.1165350676,
-0.8116007447,
-0.6344915628,
-0.4175447524,
0.1046910435,
0.2475463003,
0.5125048161,
0.5694309473,
0.7212070227,
0.0521406196,
0.3530960381,
-0.200120002,
1.0053751469,
-0.3499459624,
0.1102846786,
-0.33122316,
-0.1749019325,
-0.7519798875,
-0.147478953,
0.755243361,
0.9061386585,
-0.1175113544,
-0.2172372341,
0.1385773271,
0.3892630637,
-0.5505821109,
0.2429495752,
-0.6192464232,
0.0224839076,
-0.1907212734,
-0.2533699274,
-0.4989283085,
-0.443521142,
-0.3310416341,
-0.9821437597,
0.5598964691,
-0.1052290946,
0.7066521049,
0.2567343414,
-0.2426369041,
-0.0518812202,
-0.6593929529,
0.5997873545,
-1.0312247276,
0.3225020468,
0.2779918015,
-0.116082482,
-0.4985109866,
-0.5645700693,
-0.7894535661,
-0.0533034019,
-0.2308947742,
0.088003993,
0.0230942462,
-0.0278869458,
0.2586584091,
0.4317733049,
-0.3272726536,
-0.1048184335,
-0.3471603692,
-0.2049137652,
0.6966826916,
0.0261104908,
0.4339559674,
-0.2176301777,
0.0719655603,
-0.2593311071,
-0.737082243,
-0.2477160394,
0.4573533833,
0.606348455,
0.1401720941,
0.5023467541,
-0.4505755305,
0.8243566751,
0.2174479961,
0.1048004776,
0.6877952218,
-0.7111257315,
-0.307074666,
0.1074515432,
0.4405241311,
0.4120720327,
0.1742608249,
-0.0964932144,
-0.2474144846,
0.2707761526,
0.3159236908,
-0.3657338321,
-0.206703186,
-0.1119689941,
0.0890005827,
-0.3677818477,
0.3430824876,
-0.8919175863,
-0.0414026529,
-0.8444918394,
0.3173313141,
-0.4857718349,
0.118105948,
0.0130998176,
0.2238019556,
-0.1953019649,
0.4400632977,
-0.8793247938,
0.1263844818,
0.5213010907,
0.5230967402,
0.1176335588,
-0.1638718098,
-0.653932035,
0.0963063762,
-0.617284596,
0.6935698986,
-0.3828724623,
-0.5936048031,
0.0701215789,
0.1970589757,
-0.1175932288,
-0.6903343797,
0.8071938753,
-0.1870136857,
0.4195477962,
-0.1823583692,
-0.6404221654,
0.0754214749,
0.1767869443,
-0.5920165777,
1.2618479729,
0.2604705095,
-0.3426428139,
0.43619138,
-0.4788869321,
-0.742785275,
-0.0199614409,
0.0423412509,
-0.4587216973,
0.101101473,
0.7050775886,
0.2111342698,
0.0805089772,
0.5756836534,
-0.0788275972,
-0.3681897819,
0.1729099602,
-0.472943902,
0.4675125182,
0.0692333877,
-0.24151133,
0.0003812221,
-1.0874915123,
0.206596002,
-0.2316244841,
-0.4621083438,
-0.3316782713,
0.0376288369,
0.0366696157,
0.0205373242,
-0.0915073231,
-0.5432117581,
0.3395047784,
-0.6110381484,
0.1948596835,
0.7800361514,
0.0010554658,
0.550098896,
-0.2999631464,
0.3943359852,
-0.0557162352,
-0.0203325003,
-0.3023871481,
-0.1978255212,
-0.8227019906,
-0.0974134207,
0.483597219,
0.6329863071,
-0.869492054,
0.7466796637,
-0.5190376639,
-0.2603498399,
-0.4072767496,
0.3946960568,
0.3444400728,
0.8751262426,
0.6082932353,
0.0484746881,
-1.171235919,
-0.6210914254,
-0.0961855054,
0.0595567264,
0.1552539468,
0.1946983486,
0.1169124544,
-0.5852020979,
1.0146788359,
-0.5669469237,
-0.219100982,
-0.1607010663,
0.01632859,
0.1215399653,
0.9629211426,
0.2109045833,
-0.5525680184,
-0.2697575986,
0.0575575642,
-0.6260393858,
-0.5300488472,
-0.2059106976,
-0.2681707144,
0.2472305298,
0.7150020003,
-0.4903901815,
0.259236306,
0.2985633314,
-0.3140460849,
0.5992913842,
-0.3993038535,
0.1416607499,
-1.1520096064,
-0.1661074311,
-0.0173172783,
-0.3445783556,
-0.7400118709,
-0.0100623798,
0.1812996566,
0.0906124562,
-0.3440594673,
0.2738830447,
-0.2693710327,
0.3951323032,
-0.1181542575,
-0.0996375307,
0.0507383086,
0.1977084875,
-0.2162835002,
0.8763693571,
0.3104887307,
-0.4936496615,
0.4663889706,
0.4121574163,
-0.1489925683,
0.5502464175,
-0.418872118,
0.0258304346,
-0.2866210639,
0.4265654981,
-0.7994535565,
-0.7217075825,
0.4169286788,
-0.308044225,
0.3430947065,
0.1040796489,
-0.4879150391,
0.0039648102,
-0.0465543568,
0.3878739178,
0.5593425632,
-0.8305430412,
0.5176952481,
0.0534702018,
-0.2382113487,
-0.3693881035,
-0.7821742892,
0.1517044753,
-0.2221167535,
-0.8180276752,
0.6986146569,
0.0988266766,
-0.1934069842,
-0.1265591979,
-0.0679305568,
0.146364361,
-0.1582996547,
0.0473543555,
0.3843025565,
-0.1204717904,
0.38564533,
0.2539880276,
0.0116368607,
-0.0094514154,
-0.1426621675,
0.302931428,
0.2058328539,
-0.1994791478,
-0.2781293392,
0.2502142489,
0.2758675516,
0.2043090016,
0.5313084722,
0.2797127664,
-0.5316619873,
-0.5115195513,
-0.561370492,
-0.1765522957,
-0.4704103172,
0.1576519161,
-0.2220922559,
-0.3817322254,
0.3545178771,
-0.0217704475,
-0.3163864613,
0.3439937532,
0.1327522993,
-0.2173351049,
0.7915900946,
0.1570945084,
0.154790476,
0.57048136,
-0.1650611907,
0.1756217033,
-0.6667520404,
-0.2368021309,
-0.2031441927,
-0.0909128264,
-0.4419996142,
-0.4719230831,
0.342572242,
0.1085636616,
0.0300966911,
0.3451271653,
-0.2221066803,
0.3761520088,
0.6791656017,
0.3837075233,
0.2788520455,
0.4118126929,
-0.0865604803,
-0.3315672576,
-0.639549315,
-0.3434369564,
0.9528228045,
-0.1653237045,
0.6568347812,
0.0516638644,
0.5398582816,
0.2723449767,
0.1013686359,
-0.3180813193,
0.4382356107,
-0.3458691537,
-0.3012942076,
-0.2741164863,
-0.4074810743,
-0.508852005,
0.2886027694,
-0.509802103,
-0.4025380015,
0.4196132421,
0.4986323714,
-0.3128284812,
0.0558487959,
-0.9736391902,
0.8126547337,
0.151651755,
-0.5969355106,
0.1784445643,
-0.4085214436,
0.2808401883,
-0.2974714935,
0.283257544,
0.3449262381,
0.3043955564,
0.3601329625,
-1.0381116867,
0.8195834756,
-0.1569970548,
-0.2407134026,
0.364726007,
-0.2539910972,
0.9756428003,
0.1048590317,
-0.0248947311,
-0.1633589715,
-0.5197798014,
-0.246577248,
-0.8460399508,
0.617159903,
-0.3758995831,
-0.5201024413,
-0.2212291807,
-0.6503326297,
-0.4509017766,
-0.2035406083,
0.3351502717,
0.5966489911,
-0.210453555,
0.3467767835,
0.320420891,
-0.0901239738,
0.2399274111,
0.1835764498,
0.1852223724,
-0.4823936224,
0.8182945848,
0.110726513,
0.1735244691,
0.1560517401,
-0.0585222468,
-0.4625568688,
-0.4226047993,
-0.6279799938,
-0.0613372996,
-0.6225550175,
-0.3000869155,
-0.6576645374,
-0.1207903698,
-0.753585875,
-0.3005755544,
-0.2456977218,
-0.4359923601,
-0.4277143478,
-0.3954735696,
0.4551501274,
0.1438438743,
-0.3438664675,
0.6089981794,
-0.5983532071,
0.0917686522,
0.1209829003,
0.0383436643,
-0.28792274,
-0.5273801684,
-0.1489427388,
0.4194749892,
-0.1574792713,
-0.7477259636,
0.7373737097,
0.432728976,
0.3182088733,
0.0116116097,
-0.2469821423,
1.2100236416,
-0.5084962249,
0.677228272,
-0.111947231,
-1.1704509258,
0.7303666472,
-0.5894722939,
0.0746413246,
0.4949935675,
-0.4645905793,
-0.5677476525,
-0.2655772865,
-0.8227016926,
-1.0156859159,
0.5770468116,
0.3653204143,
0.3746321201,
-0.0144299157,
0.5956426859,
0.0693624318,
0.1001771241,
-0.6843523979,
-0.0420786478,
-0.2280900329,
-0.4515648782,
-0.2232594937,
-0.2105341852,
0.1243560389,
-0.4791480303,
1.1066374779,
-0.1544224322,
-0.2317778915,
0.4204069376,
-0.2246906012,
-0.0998927355,
0.4695115685,
0.5114847422,
0.5028173923,
-0.0560080409,
0.10804791,
0.5838474035,
-0.4267017543,
0.3768554926,
0.2419226319,
-0.5946560502,
0.2341069579,
0.3342891634,
0.6355202794,
0.2385991663,
-0.7223715186,
0.1788392365,
0.4729432762,
-0.094997853,
-0.3652697206,
0.246037066,
-0.1187136024,
-0.1124263331,
0.2718238235,
0.240410164,
0.1243096516,
-0.4449961782,
0.3874187171,
0.1998406947,
0.1311055571,
-0.175424993,
0.5838190317,
0.1377084255,
-0.0001327679,
0.550735116,
-0.4040802419,
-0.2763767242,
0.536277473,
0.7452751398,
0.4291445613,
-0.432617873,
0.2931670249,
0.595744431,
0.0673281178,
-0.2722683251,
0.2606232464,
0.2341302931,
-0.8309614658,
-0.7523142099,
-0.395229578,
-0.0396918729,
0.1978987306,
-0.4568817019,
0.3275330067,
-0.3427309394,
0.0550933778,
-0.0819578096,
-0.3459613919,
-0.3196145892,
0.7014999986,
-0.1601259559,
0.4668127,
-0.9053584933,
0.5718707442,
0.7011438012,
-0.3375414312,
-0.7696294785,
-0.2022004575,
0.0658622235,
-0.3239542544,
0.587936461,
-0.0552255809,
0.1362742335,
-0.0559285842,
-0.4131122828,
-0.7427334189,
0.833630681,
0.3776072264,
-0.7566113472,
-0.0409432314,
0.2593003213,
0.7601985335,
-0.4525434375,
-0.20982261,
0.6262803674,
0.5603213906,
0.2336675376,
-0.4579765499,
0.1423753798,
-0.6176640391,
0.1842464656,
-0.0345900469,
0.0299375672,
0.8379386663,
0.0629593804,
-0.3980134428,
0.1963732988,
0.6218169332,
0.1952354759,
0.2007187307,
0.4320123494,
0.7085398436,
0.8147792816,
-0.3455183506,
0.874273181,
0.0593169667,
0.3034054935,
1.3794759512,
-0.0941531509,
0.5302672386,
0.5312405229,
-0.0691505298,
0.5457755923,
0.5702729225,
-0.1725407988,
0.4673165381,
0.1662162393,
-0.4258746803,
-0.1337758899,
-0.0732703507,
-0.3933103681,
0.3069724441,
0.3736824691,
-0.4922471941,
-0.1517890245,
0.0116487639,
0.1035910398,
0.4042822421,
-0.2198524028,
0.6802565455,
-0.3496414721,
-0.7186437249,
0.6131039858,
0.1529840976,
0.6390467882,
-0.0886276737,
-0.1747161597,
-0.4623073637,
0.393209815,
-0.3799791336,
-0.2651571929,
0.3802814484,
0.1676502079,
-0.313846916,
-0.2450032979,
0.6620959044,
-0.7903979421,
-0.7752299309,
-0.1748412251,
0.4017560482,
-0.2213950306,
0.0312279407,
-0.1638765335,
0.013070683,
0.0589416809,
0.2427044213,
-0.1727771014,
0.1643198282,
-0.1155940443,
0.2447096258,
1.0237722397,
0.2281631231,
0.2725013196,
0.2252613306,
0.7857652307,
-0.4738624394,
-0.6261251569,
-0.7896311283,
0.7543715239,
-0.3986321092,
-0.2135934979,
0.9017966986,
0.4913105369,
1.1280810833,
-0.4403029978,
0.8569270968,
-0.0294437818,
0.524386704,
-0.8109680414,
0.2561596632,
-0.3390489817,
0.3358515501,
-0.4345897138,
-1.0450072289,
-0.5555594563,
0.6512194872,
-0.3221857548,
0.1099181175,
0.4939187169,
1.2873241901,
-0.3378309906,
0.0714491159,
0.0975863934,
0.1244980246,
0.1761658341,
0.2467177212,
0.7359421849,
-0.7220575213,
0.0957708508,
-0.3036953211,
0.0483866744,
-0.2849722207,
-0.6309945583,
-0.3810841739,
-0.5010873675,
-0.488604337,
-0.4969718456,
0.4540189505,
1.1620675325,
0.6662108898,
-1.0360527039,
0.2982141078,
-0.6528883576,
-0.1131501719,
-0.2450104505,
-0.2884760499,
0.380702585,
-0.6460933089,
-1.1436411142,
0.8614866734,
-0.274558872,
0.4662995636,
0.1919606477,
-0.1261513084,
-0.1468322724,
-0.0708417892,
0.5836629272,
0.1398166567,
-0.6677877307,
-0.2920289636,
0.0056372294,
0.0127664618,
0.2005080879,
0.7081417441,
-0.7287676334,
0.7134770155,
0.5790225863,
0.5829536915,
0.1535992175,
0.5916700959,
0.8284423351,
-1.3186583519,
0.2052792162,
-0.1709064394,
0.5032712817,
0.6394905448,
-0.5527157187,
0.6743921638,
0.5285892487,
-0.0870185643,
-0.8477733731,
-0.1459586471,
-0.8019970059,
-0.1985272318,
1.2419537306,
0.0751247182,
-0.0980600566,
0.1435305327,
-0.4533166885,
0.3259307742,
-0.3284497559,
0.7978258729,
0.7962113023,
0.1669145525,
0.1424153745,
-0.283542037,
0.693867743,
0.6141541004,
-1.1409958601,
0.0246816054,
1.0909904242,
0.2661800385,
0.1382513046,
0.1620463878,
-0.1281669885,
0.2966421843,
0.0664197057,
-0.0370505415,
-0.1834397167,
-0.2700881958,
-0.3487108946,
-0.0309914872,
-0.5789818168,
-0.1157354116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17453v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17453v1
|
Learning to Ask Informative Questions: Enhancing LLMs with Preference Optimization and Expected Information Gain
| 2024-06-25T10:44:01 | 2024-06-25T10:44:01 |
Davide Mazzaccara, Alberto Testoni, Raffaella Bernardi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Questions are essential tools for acquiring the necessary information to
complete information-seeking tasks. However, large language models (LLMs),
especially open-source models, often perform poorly in generating informative
questions, as measured by expected information gain (EIG). In this paper, we
propose a method to enhance the informativeness of LLM-generated questions in
20-question game dialogues. We sample multiple questions from the same model
(LLAMA 2-CHAT 7B) for each game and create pairs of low-EIG and high-EIG
questions to apply a Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) algorithm. Our
results show that this method produces more effective questions (in terms of
EIG), even in domains different from those used to train the DPO model.
|
[
-0.5069375038,
-0.9007977247,
0.675273478,
-0.0494824946,
-0.3142213225,
-0.1730021834,
-0.4546491504,
-0.3906772435,
0.089636296,
0.6250289083,
-0.605789125,
-0.4528302252,
-0.374096334,
0.113511771,
0.23137559,
0.8205347657,
-0.0157480985,
0.1405019015,
-0.4347626865,
0.1792899966,
-0.208854422,
-0.3881059289,
-0.9004261494,
-0.0746104047,
0.5015587807,
0.6895833015,
0.4196292758,
0.4616440237,
0.5358575583,
0.2546174526,
-0.1204966307,
0.6630541682,
-0.9994099736,
0.5324590206,
-0.0132774608,
-1.0239986181,
0.0336064138,
-0.1353969276,
0.4227195382,
0.5042698383,
-0.0759619176,
0.2278313786,
0.0189754013,
0.5642859936,
-0.5076779127,
0.2967381775,
-0.7791137695,
0.0136901373,
0.1697587222,
-0.779289484,
-0.4599793851,
-0.5118818879,
0.1542679667,
-0.8762645125,
-0.4365724325,
0.091104269,
0.8012799025,
0.2050587237,
-0.0713201612,
-0.5645222068,
-0.8890975714,
0.7744768858,
-0.6818642616,
0.1649853289,
0.269226402,
0.0475288443,
-0.3762708902,
-0.2065037489,
-0.4532358348,
-0.2464431971,
0.2259867787,
0.2369126827,
-0.5181236863,
0.0108912019,
0.3626919687,
0.1024583206,
-0.2559838891,
0.0052988273,
-0.2913731337,
0.2343766838,
0.6758246422,
0.1948828846,
0.0839342922,
-0.1206845641,
-0.2641001046,
-0.2456002533,
-0.8070774674,
0.3731041551,
0.9346573949,
-0.0411686413,
0.1914281249,
0.6217304468,
-0.2552581429,
0.8605219126,
0.4165019691,
-0.3086744547,
0.0405385382,
-0.3525398374,
0.2250301093,
-0.2377628237,
0.4685352445,
0.9201332331,
0.2877576053,
-0.0196322668,
-0.058069136,
-0.3448747098,
0.0585338026,
-0.9619308114,
-0.1542172879,
0.4916149378,
-0.4049317241,
-0.5528858304,
0.0595506802,
-0.7564892173,
-0.2491039187,
-0.2512818575,
0.371509701,
-0.3636744022,
-0.2762567401,
0.1925188005,
-0.3405446708,
0.4735616148,
0.58018893,
-0.8232047558,
-0.0394952111,
0.3406963944,
0.2808935642,
-0.1993279308,
0.2308670282,
-0.6177099943,
0.277874887,
-0.4772912264,
0.7222704887,
-0.6591861844,
-0.4398043454,
-0.0116930483,
-0.3022230864,
0.260668993,
-0.754409194,
0.3389059901,
-0.580281198,
0.3966677785,
-0.4757950008,
-0.6542013288,
0.0739941224,
0.6306200624,
-0.3066477478,
0.869181335,
-0.2765856087,
-0.7289525867,
0.4207429588,
-0.7123975754,
0.0029140348,
0.2190400213,
-0.3265729547,
-0.03979351,
0.1238418818,
0.5123294592,
0.3958958685,
-0.3273454309,
0.2945331037,
-0.097883977,
-0.3324419856,
0.2655507624,
-0.2227093726,
0.3149603605,
0.1805931926,
-0.3094054163,
0.0192066915,
-0.5862978101,
0.3771416545,
0.3850044608,
-0.7361533046,
-0.5551304221,
0.1797363311,
-0.6887556911,
-0.0915620476,
0.4194886386,
-0.6012140512,
0.154910475,
-0.4891133308,
0.0019439822,
0.7951766849,
0.2891381979,
0.297133714,
-0.5192756653,
0.4764440358,
0.2472193688,
0.3464026451,
0.0214041825,
-0.5912927389,
-0.9376081824,
0.1922338605,
-0.0432412997,
0.5424580574,
-1.0147082806,
0.3575012684,
-0.0302616134,
-0.5457283258,
-0.5149745345,
0.1287591308,
0.0781959668,
0.5456501842,
0.1936444789,
0.0597622208,
-0.6167327762,
-0.7240683436,
-0.1529190242,
-0.5404807329,
0.0573375523,
1.1701413393,
0.1188310981,
0.1683810353,
0.7211717367,
-0.8108153939,
0.2890661955,
-0.4421264231,
-0.0108642094,
0.2812727094,
0.0945160463,
0.3989227712,
-0.9424036741,
-0.4285061955,
-0.2702126503,
-0.6343365312,
-0.0792047307,
0.0246557966,
-0.3348380625,
-0.2376567423,
0.168393299,
-0.4503253698,
0.0704168975,
0.3589364588,
0.1435510516,
0.276317656,
-0.2236439288,
0.4467788935,
-1.0914677382,
-0.0450197905,
-0.150490582,
-0.0405100547,
-0.8522177935,
0.0868006125,
-0.2643233538,
-0.1063046455,
-0.4394694269,
0.6845303774,
-0.4706196189,
0.2274890244,
-0.1975533217,
0.4336191714,
0.1058274582,
0.5169192553,
0.0661572739,
0.8988919258,
0.3875081241,
-0.9957489967,
0.3965863883,
0.3261427283,
-0.5453036427,
0.3165147007,
-0.6381967664,
0.4081974328,
-0.6523492932,
-0.0924420133,
-1.1589645147,
-0.2908074856,
0.2243635803,
-0.465351522,
0.1498030573,
-0.0237421487,
-0.2587984502,
-0.3078684509,
-0.5196962357,
0.3284808993,
0.5422108769,
-0.7544522285,
0.0938302055,
0.5845063925,
-0.2101007253,
-0.7363051772,
-0.2056432664,
-0.161346212,
-0.2513963282,
-0.6912285686,
0.0801953897,
-0.3942964077,
-0.4600123167,
-0.2084371746,
0.1168573275,
0.1426694095,
0.200920552,
0.0735645071,
0.2527797222,
-0.2052495033,
0.4221246243,
0.0642900318,
0.4043639302,
0.0741758421,
-0.2759026885,
0.8610486388,
0.0673886389,
-0.1716577709,
0.0052233981,
0.497464031,
-0.146719113,
-0.2921798229,
0.4506658316,
0.0602983609,
0.0310037211,
-0.3964504898,
-0.6750389934,
-0.349994123,
-0.4944115877,
0.4002660513,
-0.5333167315,
-1.0848199129,
0.3104203343,
-0.288562268,
0.0117461234,
0.3343068659,
0.4885468483,
-0.1342678219,
1.3259915113,
0.4156501889,
0.2160135061,
0.5441788435,
-0.2097194046,
-0.0906139761,
-0.6601662636,
-0.3727096617,
-0.4091193378,
-0.2242534459,
-0.2988387048,
-0.6475092769,
0.5143082738,
0.2157297581,
-0.0385544002,
0.1314513236,
-0.5619230866,
0.5245739222,
0.6704109311,
0.3928756416,
0.2938025594,
0.1323500872,
-0.1808521003,
-0.0800315291,
-0.8033608198,
-0.5499989986,
1.2375972271,
0.275674969,
0.994857192,
0.1667006761,
1.0793076754,
-0.2563228905,
0.0328554399,
-0.8792310953,
0.5534784794,
0.1989117265,
-0.624535501,
-0.4744895399,
-0.6716278195,
-0.8356541395,
-0.0189235248,
-0.2052908391,
-0.6755612493,
0.3588117957,
0.1216853261,
-0.5041895509,
0.3270550668,
-0.4669434726,
0.2889044583,
-0.472946763,
-0.3656663597,
0.100500904,
-0.4300513864,
0.3061513603,
0.1616336405,
-0.0332971625,
-0.115941599,
-0.1972022653,
0.7159799933,
-0.0893765241,
0.3445329368,
-0.3009886742,
-0.1367441118,
0.6272583604,
-0.1111859679,
0.6502623558,
0.1453016102,
-0.2391930223,
-0.1747222245,
-0.2484971136,
-0.0952407941,
-0.8713270426,
0.452932328,
-0.9197648764,
-1.1096161604,
0.1262413114,
-0.4888923764,
-0.3993635476,
-0.0080911545,
0.1641548872,
0.2852998674,
-0.2278985232,
0.1539979428,
0.8913170099,
-0.5425651073,
0.1117853895,
0.3762301803,
-0.1482362002,
-0.3138596714,
0.5916295648,
-0.2264425009,
0.5997501612,
0.6442381144,
0.4852718711,
-0.2623716295,
-0.6607187986,
-0.4656628072,
0.3058280051,
-0.7427862883,
-0.2239614427,
-0.751639843,
-0.10248667,
-0.2249758244,
0.3775495887,
0.0037237196,
-0.2631557584,
-0.4426113367,
-0.2448994517,
0.4083768725,
0.754355073,
0.0030614913,
0.1548012942,
-0.6724736094,
-0.1251172274,
0.4448207617,
0.0921778381,
-0.1830822378,
-0.4861595929,
-0.0228478685,
0.3119036257,
-0.2916150689,
-0.8683966398,
0.2221112698,
0.0867132917,
0.8313931227,
0.5244817138,
0.1586395055,
0.5872063637,
-0.3654877543,
0.7087090611,
0.1452833414,
-0.3782142699,
0.9136292338,
-0.3823369741,
0.1937086284,
0.6370432973,
0.7667578459,
-0.1631843895,
-0.214262262,
-0.4598947167,
-0.6255570054,
0.7238910198,
0.0241523255,
0.4951263368,
-0.4837855995,
0.4705069661,
0.1705266386,
0.4844691455,
-0.5772100091,
-0.2980882823,
0.291628927,
0.0197394639,
0.1667442769,
-0.4697600603,
-0.317270577,
-0.016419841,
0.7067314982,
-0.1983985007,
0.4285522401,
0.2792705894,
0.2783380151,
-0.2928914726,
0.3034006357,
0.5617530346,
0.5887821913,
-0.4259275496,
-0.0055915872,
0.1079533026,
-0.2216068059,
0.2043273449,
-0.1590882391,
-0.38711676,
-0.1019627228,
-0.1385459453,
1.135008812,
-0.0996646881,
-0.8098400831,
0.5496529937,
-0.1971286386,
-0.3292666972,
0.0377639718,
0.3360087574,
0.1565332413,
0.3321898282,
0.2051851451,
-0.3364121318,
0.0841857791,
-0.8213649392,
0.1639964432,
0.6177176833,
-0.3869363368,
0.1571273953,
0.5697928071,
0.255102843,
-0.2416139394,
0.2853883207,
-0.1060510874,
-0.4746546447,
0.4213104248,
0.5152298212,
0.3356890082,
-0.1999378055,
0.4383071065,
0.5301271677,
0.1156846359,
-0.0196420569,
0.7463004589,
-0.2149345875,
-0.816532135,
-0.3107940555,
-0.350743264,
-0.7341134548,
0.2824310958,
-0.3157115579,
0.4019264281,
-0.412450552,
-0.3617698252,
-0.1843407899,
0.1547370553,
-0.624070704,
0.2233551443,
-0.0768831149,
0.5367302895,
-0.1001201794,
0.2849230468,
0.6495832205,
-0.5489313602,
-1.0795100927,
-0.0892328992,
-0.6521975398,
-0.9983024001,
0.9054139853,
-0.0082990676,
0.0187284779,
0.0467284583,
-0.9243091941,
-1.0802773237,
1.0360933542,
0.4045391977,
-0.589381218,
-0.2764363885,
0.2122569978,
0.2818875909,
-0.6128773689,
0.5769689679,
0.0573255792,
0.4839506447,
0.3445916176,
-0.5081189871,
-0.1474500746,
-0.2896688879,
-0.3017316759,
0.162077859,
-0.631005764,
0.7123167515,
-0.5907456279,
-0.1239843443,
-0.0162128359,
0.4790399373,
0.3705399632,
0.0619151592,
0.6902727485,
0.2449631393,
0.9799380302,
-0.1309631616,
1.1450482607,
-0.5251090527,
0.0825705081,
1.0011870861,
-0.1366039068,
0.813601017,
0.541234076,
0.0512485616,
0.2066818476,
0.7284481525,
-0.1055689901,
0.6175129414,
0.8232137561,
-0.1555878818,
-0.5363599658,
-0.2666191757,
-0.2613441348,
0.5383211374,
0.1241000444,
-0.4970000088,
0.0290813986,
-0.1234052852,
0.1009950712,
0.0291994251,
-0.1624672413,
1.1265902519,
-0.1065075472,
-1.0103082657,
0.381739378,
-0.0986837074,
0.6114351153,
-0.6716992855,
-0.248680681,
-0.3688321412,
-0.0071658739,
0.0484614111,
-0.6030968428,
-0.2907526195,
0.2201668471,
-0.0916996449,
0.1817979813,
0.800378859,
-0.6252779961,
-0.3453284204,
0.2423309982,
0.853905797,
0.5407409668,
-0.0478907824,
-0.5832446218,
-0.1384421736,
0.1748365462,
-0.3321282268,
0.1832084805,
0.3695896864,
0.2798438072,
0.6447572708,
0.6739197373,
0.3163637221,
0.1019554362,
-0.1004085615,
1.0254172087,
-0.3001843989,
-0.2642688751,
-0.7291197777,
0.3832634389,
-0.4876924455,
-0.2741983533,
0.7969985604,
0.7032094002,
0.8937752247,
-0.1101939753,
0.8543069959,
0.2079337239,
0.5359220505,
-0.4914362431,
0.4592651427,
-0.6582016349,
0.3405591547,
-0.2288282365,
-1.0545237064,
0.2287012786,
0.5236567259,
-0.3144059777,
0.0317334384,
0.3379733562,
0.8447441459,
0.2606659234,
0.0171071608,
0.6084604263,
-0.1155077219,
0.3130835295,
0.8221536279,
1.2232484818,
-0.331238687,
0.7023605108,
-0.2131070942,
-0.3609101176,
-0.0278879851,
-0.7500472665,
-1.1645668745,
-0.4141726792,
-0.1278643459,
-0.1841736287,
0.1959252656,
1.1690257788,
0.5982551575,
-0.4458439648,
-0.3696312308,
0.1788638383,
0.0636307672,
0.3121221364,
-0.1670798212,
0.0623806901,
-0.3676725924,
-0.935867846,
0.556258142,
0.1991119385,
0.1151740327,
-0.2603866756,
-0.0089293551,
-0.2608998716,
0.556263268,
0.3660734892,
-0.1516615003,
-0.3779149354,
-0.4541974366,
0.4829494655,
0.050197348,
0.2623462975,
0.6686602831,
-0.2735993266,
0.6881591678,
0.5645065904,
0.6696228385,
0.5694056153,
0.370985657,
0.8117232919,
-0.6186887026,
-0.1349078417,
0.3467812836,
-0.0105047794,
0.3851739168,
-0.6834927797,
0.500923872,
-0.1272279173,
-0.4309085608,
-0.5929720402,
0.3097410798,
-0.6025400162,
-0.1011155099,
1.5981527567,
-0.1731738001,
-0.0546906516,
0.2697676122,
-0.4188636839,
0.173980996,
-0.5122868419,
0.4299102724,
0.875292778,
-0.3575575948,
-0.1186872274,
-0.4511530101,
0.7159764171,
0.3912500143,
-1.1393691301,
-0.1893611401,
0.3735910058,
0.1151149422,
0.117630206,
0.6185759902,
-0.0889541581,
0.1226020604,
-0.0693397149,
-0.0862369537,
-0.2719524801,
-0.2537743449,
0.0922662988,
0.1901523173,
0.2961327434,
-0.1969200671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17430v1
|
Towards Probing Speech-Specific Risks in Large Multimodal Models: A Taxonomy, Benchmark, and Insights
| 2024-06-25T10:08:45 | 2024-06-25T10:08:45 |
Hao Yang, Lizhen Qu, Ehsan Shareghi, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) have achieved great success recently,
demonstrating a strong capability to understand multimodal information and to
interact with human users. Despite the progress made, the challenge of
detecting high-risk interactions in multimodal settings, and in particular in
speech modality, remains largely unexplored. Conventional research on risk for
speech modality primarily emphasises the content (e.g., what is captured as
transcription). However, in speech-based interactions, paralinguistic cues in
audio can significantly alter the intended meaning behind utterances. In this
work, we propose a speech-specific risk taxonomy, covering 8 risk categories
under hostility (malicious sarcasm and threats), malicious imitation (age,
gender, ethnicity), and stereotypical biases (age, gender, ethnicity). Based on
the taxonomy, we create a small-scale dataset for evaluating current LMMs
capability in detecting these categories of risk. We observe even the latest
models remain ineffective to detect various paralinguistic-specific risks in
speech (e.g., Gemini 1.5 Pro is performing only slightly above random
baseline). Warning: this paper contains biased and offensive examples.
|
[
-0.2521469891,
-0.8280630708,
0.3340565264,
0.0576840639,
0.1390873343,
-0.3457246721,
-0.1840122789,
-0.4173864126,
0.1345010996,
0.5306856632,
-0.5178519487,
-0.3397087455,
-0.7462775111,
-0.3324322999,
-0.2729890049,
1.0233479738,
0.3041206598,
-0.0625492483,
-0.1433380842,
-0.2630800903,
-0.4352125823,
-0.7404616475,
-0.5065621734,
0.2008394301,
1.0436785221,
0.1265793145,
0.7647425532,
0.162004292,
0.6218209267,
0.2712426186,
-0.2169697881,
-0.1556652337,
-0.2889406681,
0.4251363873,
-0.2391546667,
-0.2310498804,
-0.5839199424,
0.1591367871,
0.7716599703,
0.779145062,
-0.2785132229,
0.3986802697,
-0.0305479001,
0.0242701098,
-0.8767177463,
0.2067536414,
-0.7631366849,
-0.0368221514,
-0.6848160625,
-0.3171781301,
-0.5479179025,
0.0475822799,
0.205487147,
-0.2028185576,
-0.3492403328,
-0.0708019361,
0.318059653,
0.1875427365,
-0.9490742683,
-0.2548495233,
-0.7535234094,
0.7042189837,
-0.6567573547,
0.4557521045,
0.4072698653,
0.6058714986,
0.0524951816,
-0.6569240093,
-0.4427657723,
-0.310485214,
0.1323594302,
-0.1148628294,
-0.5678448081,
0.1903337985,
0.264074862,
0.0049007153,
-0.5735616088,
0.1701235771,
-0.2205737084,
-0.6028254628,
0.4894507229,
0.2027514875,
0.3497253954,
-0.3826966882,
-0.3523994684,
-0.1929954588,
-0.5696820617,
0.368168503,
0.678884387,
0.4649540782,
-0.1489474177,
0.5398230553,
-0.0231498554,
0.5194575191,
-0.321769774,
-0.3990774155,
0.4858942628,
-0.4444271922,
-0.0486645773,
0.0295323357,
0.816565454,
0.3296159804,
0.1354365945,
-0.022778593,
-0.0804755911,
-0.0432031155,
0.0662308112,
-0.3632274568,
0.1413125396,
0.0706510991,
-0.3870439529,
-0.4022615254,
-0.2313373685,
-0.8702374101,
-0.7265405059,
-0.0624834038,
0.7373608351,
-0.5323965549,
-0.4968561828,
0.0700355843,
-0.0960256979,
0.2205418497,
0.0235043801,
-0.4521666765,
-0.1741130352,
0.4305041432,
0.5317351222,
0.0233576167,
-0.1815336049,
-0.7410182357,
0.3135633469,
-0.0948448703,
0.5517998934,
-0.6984018087,
-0.3715277016,
0.0074858717,
-0.2515506744,
-0.1555807739,
-0.3681855798,
1.0337494612,
-0.078880921,
0.0757533014,
-0.1162524149,
-0.0910163596,
-0.2758600414,
0.2982309163,
-0.6049789786,
0.7520567775,
-0.1783409715,
-0.975840807,
0.269762516,
-0.3103943467,
-0.3648506403,
-0.1257631481,
-0.3214515746,
-0.3843752742,
0.0684382319,
-0.0105841765,
0.5057815909,
-0.2678075731,
0.5831413865,
-0.4288726747,
0.0929167569,
0.595826447,
-0.9553470016,
0.5062311888,
0.1800338179,
-0.2324783802,
0.4949330688,
-0.719941318,
-0.0971887633,
-0.1727560014,
-0.0510033332,
-0.5372571945,
0.0257928967,
0.2657182515,
0.6538425684,
0.0308236219,
-0.4268572927,
-0.2978971899,
0.1280028522,
0.6186156869,
0.7191651464,
0.050639607,
0.1368769705,
-0.4769175649,
0.6151845455,
0.2620384097,
0.4438308179,
-0.3916431665,
-0.5630965233,
-0.3075058162,
-0.5736025572,
0.2713157535,
0.5709552169,
-0.7875525355,
0.1573269665,
-0.3860646188,
-0.7527471185,
-0.4268737435,
-0.2667120099,
0.5372394323,
0.4400452971,
0.1428803056,
-0.2806974351,
-0.4530233443,
-1.1018670797,
-0.4848967493,
-0.327560991,
0.0913432762,
0.5179425478,
0.1886024773,
-0.4289936125,
0.6808293462,
-0.1422778517,
-0.3614302576,
0.0357364975,
0.3881177306,
-0.0738684312,
0.435629636,
0.4984672964,
-0.9807149172,
-0.0710758865,
-0.2089686394,
-0.4433035254,
-0.1455739141,
-0.1827528924,
0.3037363887,
-0.1694588959,
0.5773851275,
-0.7052758336,
0.1944661438,
0.8462732434,
-0.176528424,
0.6785449386,
0.1864435822,
0.1245471761,
-0.8490505815,
0.1170591712,
0.2581338882,
-0.0330944061,
-0.9552120566,
0.014670033,
-0.0500472859,
-0.3011058569,
-0.8418976665,
0.3014173508,
-0.124715507,
0.0166629367,
0.1705666482,
0.0016950369,
-0.3706409931,
0.2669341266,
-0.2182542384,
0.6710245013,
0.7205157876,
-0.4938472807,
0.1972468793,
-0.0249936786,
-0.4672907293,
0.6155654192,
-0.514388442,
0.1829472929,
-0.2224297822,
0.3448369503,
-1.1079419851,
-0.2146520168,
0.2039192319,
-0.5833104849,
0.2578694224,
0.0482817069,
-0.4073251188,
-0.1473804861,
-0.4100929499,
0.8238849044,
0.2598794401,
-0.0291954223,
0.9955046773,
0.6566810012,
-0.6368503571,
-0.6286171079,
-0.5736789703,
0.3386133313,
-0.6961448789,
-0.8191227317,
0.2398753315,
-0.0397747308,
-0.4092408121,
-0.3396279812,
-0.1445301473,
0.1022920236,
0.0014307641,
0.4644505084,
-0.0154262744,
-0.042175889,
0.1321517229,
-0.052793093,
0.0033334601,
0.1401581764,
0.1427753717,
0.6517233849,
-0.0367285945,
-0.3201907575,
-0.5200099945,
0.4345316887,
0.8462159038,
-0.4742376506,
0.5481264591,
0.9303646088,
-0.3097446561,
0.1767405719,
-0.6122470498,
-0.1795356423,
-0.4763581753,
0.4392906427,
-0.4872204363,
-0.7829005122,
0.6073753834,
0.0723606125,
-0.2478287518,
0.3824149668,
0.6803789735,
-0.0459415503,
1.0215829611,
0.3451966047,
-0.2006680965,
0.3925780058,
0.1891134679,
0.0415315516,
-0.6332255602,
-0.4961738586,
-0.6511371732,
-0.1245886683,
-0.6611742377,
-0.7126354575,
0.7164550424,
-0.6488554478,
-0.1847172976,
0.3079257607,
0.0722298324,
-0.0471526124,
0.568659246,
-0.0004640115,
0.1744735837,
-0.4169951975,
0.0699205026,
-0.0317377187,
-0.5946184397,
-0.299482137,
1.1497530937,
0.7749142647,
0.9307089448,
0.4246360362,
0.3429297209,
0.401717931,
-0.0604230538,
-0.6020281315,
0.5154200196,
-0.0386809111,
-0.9451055527,
-0.2711277902,
-0.7482579947,
-0.7614418268,
0.2182980329,
-0.2935444415,
-0.713751018,
0.3875645995,
0.1725895852,
-0.4442147315,
0.179699868,
-0.4884550273,
0.7916574478,
-0.2428640127,
-0.2319616675,
-0.1147951633,
-0.9093776941,
0.5949681401,
-0.2017489821,
0.7582416534,
-0.3319799304,
-0.0397061892,
0.6880213022,
0.4299477339,
1.0731765032,
-0.1781512946,
-0.5306740403,
0.1342597157,
0.2342282236,
0.3880216181,
-0.0200349372,
-0.0171736479,
0.1917169392,
0.1852264851,
-0.2176341265,
-0.2244925499,
0.6090971828,
-0.5147647262,
-0.4532688558,
-0.5588883758,
-0.9877214432,
-0.6161279082,
-0.0631566718,
0.1824507415,
0.5857945085,
-0.2516017258,
0.4211974144,
0.7145444155,
-0.5041128397,
0.2806474566,
0.4020082951,
0.0127795627,
-0.4111478329,
1.0019203424,
0.0309485756,
0.4682664275,
0.2622326016,
0.2986164987,
-0.3202063739,
-0.4821986854,
-0.0342217349,
-0.0227843747,
-0.8149631619,
-0.0499691553,
-0.4515296519,
0.0080006262,
-0.6253672242,
0.4275166988,
-0.1493337005,
-0.3384800553,
-0.0838117748,
0.0362870768,
-0.0323418677,
0.1311546862,
-0.0965237245,
0.1698323935,
-0.80616045,
0.158144623,
0.5263781548,
0.077833347,
-0.1820661873,
-0.6743486524,
0.1756303161,
0.0213451236,
-0.2397982478,
-0.8906471133,
0.2841792703,
0.5054978132,
0.8803033829,
0.714197278,
0.0942474157,
0.404014498,
-0.6319309473,
0.8679914474,
0.4073866308,
-0.9567506909,
0.3884221613,
-0.8110921383,
0.0157330763,
0.4227579534,
0.6663155556,
-1.0317274332,
-0.2372018546,
-0.6161749959,
-0.8558705449,
0.2686624527,
0.184359774,
0.5132921338,
0.0097186444,
0.0134415021,
0.0712416694,
0.2958970666,
-0.7407082915,
-0.1211179793,
-0.0642836243,
-0.1834287196,
-0.3422009051,
-0.3086898625,
-0.5937337279,
-0.0828507319,
0.3879278898,
-0.0864373073,
0.2170185745,
-0.0940880328,
-0.1598135829,
-0.0184660163,
0.5227805972,
0.8330606818,
0.3323438764,
-0.2554809749,
0.590532124,
0.0456496477,
-0.2872650325,
0.2074796259,
0.1804103553,
0.1857167184,
-0.1100518256,
0.6849119067,
0.8720000386,
0.4687629342,
-1.1890773773,
0.6999341249,
0.2238636315,
-0.0227174386,
-0.0854009241,
-0.1625955254,
-0.0810294822,
0.1681822538,
0.2076581717,
0.0397646241,
0.3599677086,
-1.0285781622,
0.365270108,
0.5458083749,
-0.5924856663,
-0.3586420119,
0.5056375861,
0.3391399682,
-0.0060879276,
0.004260031,
-0.0506671555,
-0.3727594018,
0.4672358036,
0.2670975327,
0.6555474401,
-0.4822622836,
0.1794720739,
-0.0642433017,
0.4553489089,
0.2535454333,
0.2840758264,
0.306204468,
-0.6675698161,
-0.2244691849,
-0.3131574094,
-0.5045824051,
0.1572830081,
-0.8351653218,
0.2336234152,
-0.2711248398,
-0.5649811029,
0.4583437443,
-0.6980316639,
-0.3461840153,
0.0630403385,
0.5989024043,
0.8051174879,
-0.9234732389,
0.6831790209,
0.571782887,
-0.2848038673,
-0.5289504528,
0.1041922718,
0.5412719846,
-0.6537435651,
0.6384651065,
0.1509624869,
-0.2204808742,
-0.2890120447,
-0.0687122643,
-0.8079527617,
0.9461143613,
0.4366369247,
-0.6069424748,
-0.318084389,
0.4347028136,
0.2488702238,
-0.1603473723,
0.1209081411,
0.5598396659,
0.5134754181,
-0.0451441295,
-1.3115956783,
-0.1700110137,
0.0066111782,
-0.0153588932,
0.2066227645,
-0.456594497,
1.0958586931,
0.1051720008,
0.0055925688,
-0.0300247669,
0.3691647649,
-0.0020143008,
0.6028781533,
0.7412289977,
0.5280281901,
0.5591459274,
-0.0339687057,
0.9601970911,
-0.0829894394,
0.1807760894,
1.0796456337,
-0.3163788617,
0.8422608972,
0.4696445465,
-0.0557863042,
0.1505637169,
0.516443193,
0.3298228681,
0.4508882165,
0.2878982425,
-0.5143911839,
-0.3583801687,
-0.3367245793,
-0.3678356409,
0.9256162643,
0.579227984,
-0.4550761282,
-0.1520914584,
0.6484902501,
0.1508954614,
-0.0617247261,
-0.5042135715,
0.6335298419,
0.0799781978,
-0.283051908,
0.3304270804,
-0.0459027663,
0.908416152,
-0.7696400881,
0.3904916346,
0.1332260519,
0.0731471553,
0.021916084,
-0.6464008689,
0.283236444,
-0.2043793499,
0.1010481566,
0.025747491,
0.5734428763,
-0.474290818,
-0.4255653918,
0.2693871558,
0.4192946255,
-0.0556726456,
-0.2974859178,
-0.5295062661,
0.2801111937,
-0.3074446321,
-0.1077644676,
0.5621884465,
0.4456662238,
-0.1122562438,
0.8285460472,
0.4736143947,
-0.0476749353,
0.1823217571,
0.0871119499,
0.7579129338,
-0.5791010857,
-0.3081061244,
-0.6898301244,
0.5245500803,
0.2243289948,
-0.517324388,
0.8744550347,
0.4033977687,
0.5166535378,
0.0608710833,
0.5799280405,
-0.0316804126,
0.2629462183,
-0.5742512345,
0.7371603847,
-0.5040889382,
-0.0066158869,
-0.643663764,
-0.4709135592,
-0.2844341397,
0.2578893006,
-0.3629370928,
-0.0799777135,
0.4548064172,
0.8456876278,
0.0745442957,
-0.1083592251,
0.5887961388,
0.1735225171,
0.3804946244,
0.4765853882,
1.0351829529,
-0.0460370705,
0.8319539428,
-0.1528717428,
-0.3369833231,
-0.1172490492,
-1.0582501888,
-0.689083159,
-0.8952237964,
-0.372084409,
-0.3222519457,
-0.083570458,
0.7436369658,
0.7202385664,
-0.526353538,
-0.0122870617,
0.4787343144,
-0.3336928189,
-0.2556835711,
-0.1552069932,
0.1321434975,
0.0171689615,
-0.538761735,
0.4625812471,
0.1329128295,
-0.0804358646,
-0.3112105727,
0.1627290696,
-0.1474421769,
0.4009810388,
0.7741751671,
0.1633345187,
-0.8244885206,
-0.6702871919,
-0.1195933074,
0.0391297825,
-0.3592374325,
0.9172522426,
-0.2733142972,
0.2893037796,
0.3505478501,
0.5532351136,
0.1806387603,
-0.4039327204,
0.2521518171,
-0.9419332147,
0.3205852211,
0.5473018885,
0.3960792124,
0.230853036,
-0.2419412285,
0.1714314073,
0.2484006435,
-0.3883656263,
-1.0633405447,
0.5881704092,
-1.4331738949,
-0.2105922103,
1.3896546364,
-0.113653779,
0.2450707853,
-0.016406754,
-0.3918400705,
0.1530054063,
-0.2868539095,
0.745372057,
0.6642341018,
-0.0150473407,
-0.2900372446,
-0.8285697699,
0.5203956366,
0.3478166461,
-0.7421025634,
0.276398927,
0.5150737762,
0.2133741379,
0.4121252298,
0.1905756444,
-0.2888122201,
0.431327939,
-0.0161430966,
-0.0652918071,
-0.0796388909,
-0.4890524447,
-0.5698724985,
0.4261609614,
-0.068464838,
-0.0974910632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17419v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17419v1
|
Leave No Document Behind: Benchmarking Long-Context LLMs with Extended Multi-Doc QA
| 2024-06-25T09:42:56 | 2024-06-25T09:42:56 |
Minzheng Wang, Longze Chen, Cheng Fu, Shengyi Liao, Xinghua Zhang, Bingli Wu, Haiyang Yu, Nan Xu, Lei Zhang, Run Luo, Yunshui Li, Min Yang, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Long-context modeling capabilities have garnered widespread attention,
leading to the emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) with ultra-context
windows. Meanwhile, benchmarks for evaluating long-context LLMs are gradually
catching up. However, existing benchmarks employ irrelevant noise texts to
artificially extend the length of test cases, diverging from the real-world
scenarios of long-context applications. To bridge this gap, we propose a novel
long-context benchmark, Loong, aligning with realistic scenarios through
extended multi-document question answering (QA). Unlike typical document QA, in
Loong's test cases, each document is relevant to the final answer, ignoring any
document will lead to the failure of the answer. Furthermore, Loong introduces
four types of tasks with a range of context lengths: Spotlight Locating,
Comparison, Clustering, and Chain of Reasoning, to facilitate a more realistic
and comprehensive evaluation of long-context understanding. Extensive
experiments indicate that existing long-context language models still exhibit
considerable potential for enhancement. Retrieval augmented generation (RAG)
achieves poor performance, demonstrating that Loong can reliably assess the
model's long-context modeling capabilities.
|
[
-0.4958092272,
-0.9656375051,
0.8033941388,
0.2340328842,
-0.3401067853,
0.0258457232,
-0.3977980316,
-0.647480309,
0.0361373834,
0.7577364445,
-0.5414948463,
-0.4891133308,
-0.3612702489,
0.044497788,
-0.7175783515,
0.7869349718,
-0.2575102448,
-0.4032163024,
-0.5387117863,
-0.4691877961,
-0.3004592061,
-0.3676093519,
-0.5800079107,
-0.1704751104,
0.608232677,
0.1534273326,
0.3250599205,
0.4291806817,
0.2584858239,
0.2250737548,
-0.2311660349,
0.2402284294,
-0.4794223011,
0.2575336099,
0.0960969627,
-0.2264359295,
-0.5489786267,
0.0878530294,
0.8142179251,
0.6789785624,
-0.117763944,
0.2397846729,
-0.0129590621,
0.5758762956,
-0.6013019085,
0.134796977,
-0.5854911804,
-0.1352271289,
-0.0429702252,
-0.2220461071,
-0.2774311304,
-0.3875793815,
-0.0251077116,
-0.6511740088,
0.1413387954,
-0.1887984574,
0.6846622229,
0.2687616348,
-0.6807745099,
-0.2747195363,
-0.4503256977,
0.7393774986,
-0.7529045939,
0.4253005981,
0.4372987747,
0.3858321309,
-0.1050317287,
-0.7255460024,
-0.6379330754,
-0.2558748722,
0.2294517756,
0.484282434,
0.2677101195,
-0.1574934125,
0.2624339759,
0.3116567135,
-0.2397656441,
0.0546422303,
-0.3436477184,
0.0959726945,
0.3884589374,
-0.2403595299,
-0.0309500992,
0.0147187179,
-0.6239886284,
0.0007519053,
-0.7701175213,
0.0950407013,
0.1283971965,
0.1137607247,
0.0317445323,
0.4732940495,
-0.1829540879,
0.5856208205,
-0.1835777313,
-0.1942507029,
0.3335329294,
-0.3101697564,
-0.2506385744,
-0.1452298462,
0.5466729999,
0.4327749014,
-0.0583376326,
-0.327542901,
-0.3198574185,
-0.1095465422,
0.1774439216,
-0.7551578283,
0.4813900888,
0.3603650331,
-0.2589216828,
-0.2144026905,
-0.4530058503,
-0.7805911899,
-0.5309806466,
-0.1096693277,
0.3460111618,
-0.4561220109,
-0.148787722,
-0.1096746922,
-0.1863601059,
0.5190837979,
0.4197497666,
-0.4811633229,
0.5382332206,
0.9876185656,
0.677077949,
-0.308478862,
-0.6550548673,
-0.993819952,
0.2416099161,
-0.4833013713,
0.8240081668,
-0.5007365346,
-0.5330842137,
0.1153305173,
0.0909422785,
-0.1124565452,
-0.6256091595,
0.8782641888,
-0.561403513,
0.5256969929,
-0.2840346098,
-0.7186355591,
-0.0451512747,
0.5742074847,
-0.6210448742,
1.3737891912,
0.4887775183,
-0.4650121033,
0.1539195627,
-0.6347070932,
-0.5122896433,
-0.1101525053,
-0.285166502,
-0.3240269125,
0.1419232339,
0.0896913484,
0.1151789874,
-0.5129802823,
0.1683504581,
-0.3886283636,
-0.7842462063,
0.0004391776,
-0.4795331061,
0.4234375358,
0.0028622085,
-0.4741007984,
-0.0091400137,
-0.927500546,
0.3041544259,
0.0459280461,
-0.6133202314,
-0.3307725489,
-0.1827381551,
0.1888999045,
0.3683729768,
0.3674255311,
-0.6720006466,
0.0958765,
-0.2348010093,
0.3709149957,
0.6432546377,
-0.1204887182,
0.34526214,
-0.5296620131,
0.6963567138,
-0.1242875904,
0.0735907033,
-0.3193442225,
-0.368213892,
-0.5488672256,
-0.3233343959,
0.233989656,
0.3469504714,
-0.5101486444,
0.1485141218,
-0.4756711721,
-0.3262037635,
-0.599642694,
0.2733311951,
0.5072966218,
0.6043339372,
0.3915162385,
-0.1615053266,
-0.2482169569,
-0.6489943266,
-0.2727065086,
-0.1469486505,
0.0246037375,
0.5203846693,
0.3439849615,
-0.3009883463,
0.7783838511,
-0.3145001829,
-0.2780779302,
-0.0379666239,
-0.0591079742,
0.2806593776,
0.1052673757,
0.371825397,
-0.8508161306,
-0.3632876873,
-0.1273236275,
-0.7064292431,
-0.2198197693,
-0.0149344644,
-0.0055670892,
0.4992724955,
0.7448525429,
-0.9553236365,
0.2612993121,
0.7172845602,
-0.0847485885,
0.6867978573,
-0.3149942756,
0.1651973128,
-1.0973426104,
0.2590061128,
-0.2958377004,
-0.142584011,
-0.4030821621,
0.4632399976,
0.3962099552,
-0.5014035106,
-0.4080956578,
1.1441509724,
-0.5721527338,
-0.3414221406,
-0.3516433835,
0.5825870633,
0.6009546518,
0.322191149,
-0.1455502957,
0.9956921935,
0.1986012608,
-0.3556863666,
0.1373335868,
0.1824401468,
-0.284244895,
0.6980087757,
-0.6632786989,
0.1362461597,
-0.0422977731,
0.5557019114,
-0.8610514402,
0.0269951839,
-0.245702371,
-0.300432086,
0.2958027124,
-0.1596230567,
-0.6188118458,
-0.4862645566,
-0.497376889,
0.3605844975,
0.5304599404,
-0.6257417202,
0.6516722441,
0.07854186,
-0.0438998304,
-0.6896486282,
-0.4366925359,
0.1790098697,
-0.4539125562,
-0.5046290755,
0.4792673588,
-0.3381337821,
-0.1895846575,
-0.2620283365,
-0.2905238569,
-0.335760206,
0.1640278846,
0.3659210205,
-0.1057198718,
-0.3020127416,
0.3923468888,
-0.0425923653,
0.0361102857,
0.073467426,
-0.0484007038,
0.4680502713,
-0.1541121304,
-0.4576589167,
0.0282689836,
0.776494205,
0.84410882,
-0.4814200997,
0.4384703934,
0.7206140161,
-0.2350306511,
-0.240783304,
-0.7127387524,
0.1242863014,
-0.5128618479,
0.336935997,
-0.6495710015,
-0.6773356795,
0.5952108502,
-0.2136231065,
0.1948031187,
0.1131416187,
0.1386980265,
-0.1726566404,
0.4738598168,
0.5185354352,
-0.108503826,
0.324949652,
0.0373162739,
0.1612502933,
-1.1051871777,
0.1530968547,
-0.4477702081,
0.2241378278,
-0.5278532505,
-0.6343933344,
0.4118147194,
0.4640679657,
-0.1705793291,
0.3148791194,
-0.1994143128,
0.4899834991,
0.6354897618,
-0.0051003182,
0.273909241,
-0.3746908009,
-0.0576263778,
0.3902553916,
-0.3646672666,
-0.3207473159,
1.1407271624,
0.1752555817,
0.5048905611,
0.1536304504,
1.088329792,
0.115954645,
0.3012501597,
-0.6515550017,
0.7023586631,
-0.0385506377,
-0.4727642238,
-0.5837933421,
-0.4109691679,
-1.0798779726,
0.4075807929,
0.2280460596,
-0.6111758947,
-0.2558709383,
-0.2375954837,
-0.2760147154,
0.1631026268,
-0.5868247151,
0.8111566305,
-0.1661603451,
-0.4376079142,
-0.0328907967,
-0.4651882946,
0.2993435562,
-0.4301408529,
0.3897117674,
-0.2323237062,
-0.2020094693,
0.50715065,
-0.2516418993,
0.6007653475,
-0.070622988,
-0.5540034175,
0.433652252,
-0.0443049707,
0.7319259644,
-0.1038483977,
-0.4177712202,
-0.1470329165,
0.3443656862,
-0.5150972009,
-0.5635034442,
1.1609363556,
-0.4888980091,
-0.7529420853,
-0.1950412095,
-0.5562403798,
-0.5465403199,
0.6204485297,
0.0599145554,
0.4875380397,
-0.2559962869,
0.1420464963,
0.6911094189,
-0.3707490861,
0.5464237928,
0.6069298387,
-0.2530451715,
-0.2787569463,
0.6600096822,
0.1069012433,
0.3055232465,
0.3005305827,
0.1817473322,
-0.5547348261,
-0.5100186467,
-0.4125850499,
0.206543237,
-0.9231877327,
0.1364157796,
-0.7213264704,
-0.0911559314,
-0.5585544705,
-0.0921050236,
-0.3264505863,
-0.2775803208,
-0.0732260197,
0.1020570025,
0.007213363,
0.3613233268,
0.333026737,
0.0801195949,
-0.8663012981,
0.5981884003,
0.41874066,
0.6587327123,
-0.077014856,
-0.4915481806,
-0.149871856,
-0.1829722822,
-0.202817291,
-0.5254935026,
-0.0262959041,
0.1807633489,
0.618211925,
0.1203291118,
0.3135991395,
0.6751502156,
-0.6223738194,
0.7249289751,
0.025837129,
-0.7999467254,
0.263240993,
-0.7620865107,
0.6596619487,
0.7094292045,
0.0233657043,
-0.6057738066,
-0.3487880528,
-0.5182793736,
-1.0155007839,
0.1713419557,
-0.0437753312,
0.15879713,
-0.3158480227,
0.2512588501,
0.1784889847,
0.2929917872,
-0.7177684307,
0.0325968228,
-0.0766235515,
0.091282703,
-0.1922260523,
-0.2479331344,
-0.3520533741,
0.1370085478,
0.5260850787,
-0.4328325391,
0.1721732318,
0.2551811039,
-0.1203731522,
0.0311727449,
0.6666841507,
0.6494192481,
0.8947573304,
-0.535754621,
0.0423932746,
0.2482252866,
-0.0581197664,
0.0121877976,
0.4180910587,
0.0120113231,
0.1056889743,
0.4209940434,
0.2883265615,
0.3532084525,
-0.9079090357,
0.6443807483,
-0.0766237825,
-0.140862003,
-0.6523082852,
-0.1083545536,
0.3468408585,
0.0935476199,
0.5825256109,
-0.372454077,
-0.0978632867,
-0.783488512,
0.2560893893,
0.4122624099,
-0.5358863473,
0.0243931711,
0.6385024786,
0.2572603524,
-0.1341404915,
0.4379169047,
-0.0064803008,
-0.2357551605,
0.8140568137,
0.5627990961,
0.7290992141,
0.2277629226,
0.1557584554,
0.0335678905,
0.1524769664,
-0.0331753753,
0.252094388,
-0.2349793017,
-0.2656276524,
-0.3870229721,
-0.5512081385,
-0.5411090255,
0.4371192157,
-0.8501846194,
-0.0117389308,
-0.3407135606,
-0.0566495247,
0.0539321713,
0.3788238168,
-0.5599075556,
0.3830633759,
0.2141941935,
1.1784943342,
-0.3269139826,
1.0378552675,
0.3950985372,
-0.0847466812,
-0.2867642939,
0.1372745186,
-0.1085851416,
-0.6438668966,
0.2956436574,
0.6319076419,
-0.1141670495,
-0.1963088065,
-0.2704771161,
-0.8356226087,
1.226172924,
0.2253558189,
-0.5265901089,
-0.0901028886,
-0.0747607946,
0.6902986169,
-0.2440949231,
0.2319859862,
0.4818840325,
0.4631818533,
-0.1022683755,
-0.9514616728,
0.1947539598,
-0.2531812787,
-0.2612128258,
0.222556293,
-1.0175783634,
0.7950053811,
-0.1889186502,
-0.2086770386,
0.4577162564,
0.3984832764,
0.4271583557,
0.6381145716,
0.5281606913,
0.5059365034,
0.7656997442,
0.0606879741,
1.2703925371,
-0.4683662653,
0.1814890951,
1.6942753792,
-0.9010131955,
0.9852162004,
0.6370038986,
0.0134629747,
0.2861952484,
0.4821406901,
0.2304332107,
0.4005529881,
0.2496575564,
-0.465287596,
-0.0886478499,
-0.1708254963,
-0.7056353092,
0.3834212124,
0.0041733603,
-0.2098713219,
-0.3004812896,
-0.2351450771,
-0.0730959401,
0.2738854587,
-0.0873445645,
0.6101990342,
0.1954092234,
-1.0718890429,
0.8426069021,
-0.0418644138,
0.4615900517,
-0.7335303426,
0.1058889702,
-0.6705586314,
0.1268983781,
0.2177033424,
-0.6834369302,
0.0807019919,
-0.3119912744,
-0.3154095709,
-0.1602999121,
0.530421555,
-0.4067210853,
-0.2512904406,
0.6905889511,
0.6954465508,
0.0845394805,
-0.2879454195,
-0.5309996605,
-0.0983599499,
-0.347101599,
-0.4201042056,
0.5973716378,
0.6308280826,
-0.1839099824,
0.8379310966,
0.6778275967,
-0.098173216,
-0.0005774145,
0.3513025641,
0.9132084846,
-0.9246766567,
-0.4504350424,
-0.4100458622,
-0.1784857363,
-0.204295814,
-0.5103353858,
0.9004273415,
0.6778692603,
0.5378015637,
0.1714547127,
0.6879546642,
0.2640075088,
0.7954615951,
-0.3964751959,
0.5815962553,
-0.7181491852,
0.3418598771,
-0.3136097789,
-0.9519297481,
0.0969268456,
-0.2107533216,
-0.2144723088,
0.0789252892,
0.8253790736,
0.5439144373,
-0.0820243433,
-0.1130962744,
0.6332246065,
0.0221435297,
0.4162986875,
0.6281433105,
0.8435539007,
-0.6406258345,
0.7585867047,
-0.0566410758,
-0.080181621,
-0.1446743011,
-0.8943713903,
-0.8458857536,
-0.3948399425,
-0.1340564787,
-0.3891916573,
0.0784785673,
0.4574943483,
0.7312217355,
-0.414224416,
-0.0586522259,
0.2387477905,
0.1388563663,
-0.3545701802,
-0.2324572355,
0.5826804638,
-0.319545269,
-0.6479266882,
0.860301137,
0.2653229833,
0.0763571337,
-0.0611682832,
-0.0230488479,
-0.1925024837,
0.2993821502,
0.732306242,
0.4437117577,
-0.6517876387,
-0.3203820288,
-0.0281051006,
-0.2639327347,
0.0997497737,
0.6669399738,
-0.8077477217,
0.3306001425,
0.1763238758,
0.8046229482,
0.6483868957,
0.2376449108,
0.44789958,
-0.8324525952,
0.076957114,
0.1080598459,
0.262712419,
0.2978503406,
-0.1712230146,
0.751927197,
-0.1387542188,
-0.5435422659,
-0.9880176187,
0.0885681286,
-0.9874345064,
-0.4847086072,
1.3561145067,
-0.4663150907,
-0.4325083494,
0.020436503,
0.0355797485,
0.0038905209,
-0.2550839484,
0.9071717262,
0.6782536507,
0.1347986758,
-0.351939857,
-0.7058896422,
0.3539842069,
0.5874814987,
-1.0646115541,
0.2816128135,
0.5294057727,
0.304681927,
0.2223768085,
0.9084578156,
-0.2093938887,
0.3913906515,
0.0181149915,
-0.3001157641,
-0.0960312486,
-0.2745600939,
-0.231633842,
0.3651303053,
0.0020891593,
-0.1820638776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17415v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17415v2
|
Layer-Wise Quantization: A Pragmatic and Effective Method for Quantizing LLMs Beyond Integer Bit-Levels
| 2024-06-25T09:37:15 | 2024-06-26T08:00:18 |
Razvan-Gabriel Dumitru, Vikas Yadav, Rishabh Maheshwary, Paul-Ioan Clotan, Sathwik Tejaswi Madhusudhan, Mihai Surdeanu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7; I.2.0
|
We present a simple variable quantization approach that quantizes different
layers of a large language model (LLM) at different bit levels. Specifically,
we quantize the most important layers to higher bit precision and less
important layers to lower bits to achieve floating point quantization levels.
We propose two effective strategies to measure the importance of layers within
LLMs: the first measures the importance of a layer based on how different its
output embeddings are from the input embeddings (the higher the better); the
second estimates the importance of a layer using the number of layer weights
that are much larger than average (the smaller the better). We show that
quantizing different layers at varying bits according to our importance scores
results in minimal performance drop with a far more compressed model size.
Finally, we present several practical key takeaways from our variable
layer-wise quantization experiments: (a) LLM performance under variable
quantization remains close to the original model until 25-50% of layers are
moved in lower quantization using our proposed ordering but only until 5-10% if
moved using no specific ordering; (b) Quantizing LLMs to lower bits performs
substantially better than pruning unless extreme quantization (2-bit) is used;
and (c) Layer-wise quantization to lower bits works better in the case of
larger LLMs with more layers compared to smaller LLMs with fewer layers. The
code used to run the experiments is available at:
https://github.com/RazvanDu/LayerwiseQuant.
|
[
-0.3291794062,
-0.8789079785,
0.631284833,
0.2883446813,
-0.3883214891,
0.1403520107,
-0.1902679503,
-0.3128809929,
-0.0536938794,
0.3463981152,
-0.1496923566,
-0.5059934258,
-0.362295121,
-0.3817189038,
-0.3046633899,
0.7455747128,
0.1992523223,
0.1686712056,
-0.3676397204,
0.0633515865,
-0.0050065392,
-0.6307972074,
-0.7216794491,
-0.3250563741,
0.5780288577,
0.2645322084,
0.773625493,
0.8381412625,
0.7722555995,
0.2653063536,
-0.276730746,
-0.0636705682,
-0.2436418682,
-0.1124557331,
0.0761153847,
-0.51270926,
-0.7396321297,
0.047324799,
0.7915213704,
0.6871237159,
-0.2573293149,
0.3854869902,
-0.3398242295,
0.8957832456,
-0.6804134846,
-0.1271553636,
-0.2548080385,
0.2304143757,
-0.2006893158,
-0.2685703635,
-0.2415079027,
-0.484267205,
-0.0897521675,
-0.2647816241,
0.0657023937,
-0.027378628,
0.6189495921,
0.2594048083,
-0.5129270554,
0.2410809845,
-0.894035697,
0.9614088535,
-1.0340520144,
0.4377744496,
0.3619474471,
0.1950645149,
0.3948177099,
-0.7388799787,
-0.3504203856,
-0.2410297841,
0.2718405724,
0.1629659832,
0.0090129469,
0.3721409142,
0.2273188382,
0.7075187564,
-0.2745990455,
0.031006556,
-0.2052042186,
-0.277613759,
0.4436861277,
0.0738721713,
0.1889316738,
-0.0493925065,
-0.5401072502,
-0.2460991293,
-0.831975162,
0.4208010733,
0.5527815819,
0.0879009366,
0.0990531221,
0.5011780262,
-0.0993674025,
0.6043025851,
0.0353381224,
-0.3206603229,
0.1222567707,
-0.3615964949,
-0.2736295164,
-0.0408688411,
0.597776711,
0.0061402982,
0.0795710906,
-0.0557918288,
-0.6484575272,
-0.1954585016,
0.316560775,
-0.9562856555,
-0.2298309654,
0.4843661189,
-0.4304893911,
-0.4960627556,
-0.033972498,
-0.1429673284,
-0.1636303812,
-0.2855189145,
0.7153189778,
-0.5693985224,
-0.3024205267,
0.2015034705,
0.1159921512,
0.2708063722,
0.3521145582,
-0.8032175303,
0.438387841,
0.9184580445,
0.829020679,
0.0740210414,
-0.0140061192,
-0.5778386593,
0.0983716473,
-0.7502985001,
0.4576604366,
-0.4903154969,
-0.0609692261,
-0.191169247,
-0.5445919037,
0.2545723021,
-0.5681564808,
0.4291903377,
-0.7018533349,
0.0482339263,
-0.1807857901,
-0.569536984,
-0.0705457553,
0.109194845,
-0.7359272242,
0.9818050861,
0.1128312871,
-0.6635382771,
-0.0436849892,
-0.1928219199,
-0.3220911622,
0.1499005854,
-0.0982478186,
-0.5917107463,
0.6748321056,
0.0420971699,
0.442687124,
-0.3576489687,
0.2742213905,
-0.2008769959,
-0.4914438725,
0.425372839,
-0.4886266589,
0.8774735332,
0.07674063,
-0.174995929,
0.1027886868,
-0.8502770066,
0.6530210972,
-0.0238087624,
-0.6081030369,
-0.3011731207,
-0.0006530031,
-0.0595975928,
0.1049387082,
0.3178584874,
-0.3250719905,
0.1385627389,
-0.3630630672,
0.9740819335,
0.76153934,
0.1975282133,
0.5580591559,
-0.0915482044,
0.6264951229,
0.0774323195,
0.3912975788,
0.2471637875,
-0.2332594246,
-0.8682560325,
-0.4740740061,
0.6712658405,
0.5090531707,
-0.6966844797,
0.5017809868,
-0.2017966509,
-0.1992542744,
-0.4443763793,
-0.1349020749,
0.6047824621,
0.1320154518,
0.092726551,
-0.5588490367,
-0.1058947966,
-1.0053908825,
-0.0790046901,
-0.425722152,
-0.1346815377,
-0.0436213836,
0.2308477908,
0.1862787455,
0.7493800521,
-0.3100056052,
-0.0495938733,
0.0536621176,
0.0927419588,
0.0819823518,
0.5379101038,
0.2604984641,
-0.8193666339,
-0.3348817229,
0.1955417693,
-0.312795639,
-0.043013107,
0.0779409036,
-0.194708854,
0.0691830143,
0.4779365063,
-0.6617667079,
0.1849734485,
0.542440474,
0.0443633944,
0.3666269481,
-0.1612062901,
-0.0644134507,
-0.7853557467,
-0.1841864735,
0.1054837406,
-0.6378724575,
-0.9437271357,
0.2241288871,
0.4487484694,
0.0357694626,
-0.5262323618,
0.0870721713,
-0.4297670722,
-0.2089722604,
-0.05082101,
-0.0231019687,
0.2607052922,
0.5934121013,
-0.1235685125,
0.6837334633,
0.478426367,
-0.3925503492,
0.2684921026,
-0.4696264565,
-0.6337598562,
0.5983697176,
-0.7792758346,
0.4038372338,
-0.0008920261,
0.0024332253,
-0.8306093216,
0.1730764955,
0.0653785765,
-0.3197382689,
0.4044119418,
-0.2582959831,
-0.5994383693,
-0.0160302334,
-0.6429463625,
0.6224550009,
0.4234365225,
-0.1314209104,
0.5408353209,
0.3844581842,
0.0388728715,
-0.360799402,
-0.8754113317,
-0.0911795571,
-0.5724582076,
-0.7879744768,
0.5651318431,
-0.3718689084,
-0.252908498,
-0.0972475111,
-0.4767149985,
-0.2573412061,
0.1499141902,
-0.0544720776,
-0.0752182975,
-0.4355891049,
0.2172451913,
-0.0654137954,
-0.1193392873,
0.2364960164,
-0.7631198168,
0.4289876819,
-0.4890428782,
-0.1949326694,
-0.2020595074,
0.2957586348,
0.1776966751,
-0.3865688443,
0.6643205881,
0.9653756022,
-0.4505999088,
-0.3487176001,
-0.5078476071,
0.1242967471,
-0.5262109041,
0.3523685634,
-0.4781481326,
-1.0423167944,
0.7184084654,
-0.0098632472,
-0.2997846901,
0.2261583358,
0.4483729899,
-0.2273720205,
1.0937582254,
0.8111240864,
0.0172102917,
0.706230402,
-0.4507519305,
0.494099766,
-0.9101191759,
0.1453034878,
-0.2645273507,
-0.2624815702,
-0.7586909533,
-0.6484552622,
0.4749850631,
0.7107746601,
-0.3932295442,
0.0538029596,
-0.4139279425,
0.8376526237,
0.5529615879,
0.3363291621,
0.2337708473,
0.1394632161,
0.0904933736,
-0.0098686218,
-0.7089925408,
-0.369864583,
0.6708202958,
0.5733901262,
0.613576293,
0.4726267159,
0.8142713308,
0.2314923853,
-0.1409704983,
-0.934317112,
0.480039537,
-0.2498084903,
-0.3407434523,
-0.5224394202,
-0.681829989,
-0.4825882614,
0.3104377985,
0.1618787646,
-0.638055861,
0.2579876482,
0.1175313592,
-0.6400153041,
0.1751980782,
-0.9725548625,
0.6579558849,
-0.2123365253,
-0.1829150915,
-0.1880779117,
-0.7196663618,
0.3003881276,
-0.0399265774,
0.2448628694,
-0.0129908007,
-0.4886584878,
0.5756857395,
-0.5487812757,
0.8490579128,
-0.0118858702,
-0.4321792424,
0.3388498724,
0.3414510787,
0.5121700764,
0.1535385549,
0.0758497268,
0.2653413117,
0.0957362801,
-0.5594564676,
-0.6886627078,
0.8391004801,
-0.9923769236,
-0.7822905779,
-0.0358158275,
-0.5979940891,
-0.1471818984,
0.0623364151,
0.0265041366,
0.6856880188,
0.2815305889,
0.2837108076,
0.9065024257,
-0.1194264069,
0.3506747782,
0.3013253808,
-0.0350542068,
-0.5277428627,
1.4469753504,
0.3289417922,
0.7046200037,
0.9370743036,
0.6389691234,
0.0986271054,
-0.7939517498,
-0.0481646024,
-0.0557794422,
-0.9485837221,
-0.3514398932,
-0.4271932244,
-0.5261902213,
-0.3080206513,
0.1011629924,
-0.5674574971,
-0.9074356556,
-0.0696182922,
-0.1753641963,
0.225618571,
0.4489690959,
-0.2321619689,
0.3142083287,
-0.5669251084,
0.240675658,
0.565563798,
0.4172538519,
0.054099407,
-0.5166462064,
-0.6378481984,
-0.1761851162,
-0.1254736334,
-0.5744431019,
0.3623822331,
0.2878977358,
0.3961827159,
0.2799340189,
-0.1015818119,
0.7018862367,
-0.3754080832,
0.7191293836,
0.1142649278,
-1.3739591837,
0.5509182215,
-0.2342094332,
0.4116357863,
0.3765069842,
0.2383659035,
-0.3725692332,
-0.2654717267,
-0.5844957829,
-1.3125844002,
0.747651577,
0.3594238162,
0.0382551365,
0.1803102195,
0.3989013433,
-0.2375810146,
0.4756929576,
-0.9315301776,
-0.4236597121,
-0.0105313053,
-0.121185109,
0.0887295604,
-0.4073735476,
-0.201947704,
-0.1103989854,
0.4382309616,
-0.0206794012,
0.3762325943,
0.0511322245,
-0.1983977854,
-0.2795780599,
0.1186799332,
0.5243142843,
0.9695132971,
-0.4837808013,
0.6384689212,
-0.0082922373,
-0.5379986763,
0.0764991045,
-0.2978203297,
-0.2738788426,
-0.2759291232,
0.5045771599,
0.9376088977,
0.075500533,
-0.1696820706,
0.5557473302,
0.0232842602,
-0.0969286785,
-0.2042780071,
0.0985800251,
0.1687089354,
0.5835348964,
0.1949325502,
-0.0993550867,
0.1322281212,
-0.4530924261,
-0.1019082591,
0.4142462909,
-0.2823810875,
-0.4181067944,
0.2676223814,
0.054888621,
-0.5369618535,
0.3022535443,
-0.0429401174,
-0.489169687,
0.8518356085,
0.338086158,
0.8183985353,
-0.1968694031,
0.3598949909,
0.1307669282,
0.5185395479,
-0.1313432753,
0.1193646342,
-0.2563767731,
-0.661493957,
-0.6995543838,
-0.4481692612,
-0.419108659,
0.0927522406,
-0.7681974769,
-0.0055060233,
-0.7090544105,
-0.2556655109,
0.1291254014,
0.3673636913,
-0.6026849151,
0.2220014036,
0.2765398622,
0.6690372229,
-0.6067035794,
1.0581642389,
0.6268099546,
-0.4069094956,
-0.7585630417,
0.0210199039,
-0.2357242852,
-0.847684443,
0.5096071959,
-0.1010782123,
-0.0903454125,
0.2965364158,
-0.7710703015,
-1.1789479256,
1.3229759932,
0.4736592174,
-0.6387594938,
0.222648263,
0.3167665303,
0.602016747,
-0.2492188513,
0.4513283074,
0.5163834691,
0.2026101351,
-0.0227666982,
-0.5277062058,
-0.0589301214,
-0.0990993381,
0.6893984675,
0.4393543005,
-0.905923605,
0.9682126641,
-0.1047735363,
-0.335860759,
-0.1163094342,
0.5923933983,
0.1968187243,
0.041011285,
0.5674193501,
0.5077558756,
0.6548094153,
0.0841062218,
1.1425510645,
-0.2638518214,
0.5324530602,
0.7489506006,
0.0763104185,
0.8330298662,
0.7111257315,
-0.4585169554,
0.1374774575,
0.6742401719,
0.5355769396,
0.6817790866,
0.5835158229,
-0.2117085457,
-0.5299518704,
-0.0833587199,
-0.2651424408,
-0.1008309945,
0.246455878,
-0.0388152078,
0.2246416509,
-0.1376231462,
-0.1835946441,
-0.2482559681,
-0.287419647,
0.6161221266,
0.3152989745,
-0.1649189144,
0.6516640782,
0.2864075899,
0.4562445879,
-0.6644647121,
0.1226868331,
-0.5828467011,
0.1251154095,
-0.2263955921,
-0.7203755379,
-0.0167091936,
-0.097149834,
-0.4026268423,
-0.4844568968,
0.6408421993,
-0.5457271934,
-0.7943876982,
0.0526692048,
0.5326625109,
0.1357036233,
-0.1664706916,
-0.576700151,
0.3503461778,
-0.0583065264,
-0.6833385825,
0.5801728964,
1.0161750317,
-0.2465314716,
0.6030670404,
0.4498370588,
0.3049801886,
0.171482563,
0.5695261955,
0.8899002671,
-0.9102271795,
-0.3459514976,
-0.7604663968,
0.4256850779,
0.2708045542,
-0.1401706338,
0.5205749869,
0.253207624,
1.0366430283,
0.2062317878,
0.3666051328,
0.1102242172,
0.006407286,
-0.7730334997,
0.1503602564,
-0.5128746629,
0.7025232911,
-0.1151040867,
-1.2911274433,
-0.409163028,
0.8377813697,
-0.1631205231,
0.1961265206,
0.733156085,
0.6128030419,
0.0688709617,
-0.3130483031,
0.5996275544,
0.2443193942,
0.4252591133,
0.6459384561,
1.0467356443,
-0.5460431576,
0.462823689,
-0.8582189083,
-0.1676719338,
0.1545777023,
-1.0089508295,
-0.6764982939,
-0.4599832594,
-0.7748013139,
-0.0608950481,
-0.006387766,
0.6476083994,
0.8459348083,
-0.5590865612,
-0.3302952647,
-0.0600787587,
0.1769552976,
-0.3622050881,
-0.310382247,
0.4687210917,
-0.0683068633,
-0.5346231461,
0.1740733832,
0.4487491846,
-0.0584300235,
-0.6529282928,
-0.0523232855,
0.0177596696,
0.1915070713,
0.7957122326,
-0.2380858362,
-0.7051679492,
-0.4465103447,
-0.1161627173,
-0.3935620785,
0.0205047932,
0.9804788232,
-0.6159324646,
0.2499218285,
0.7443699837,
0.4553443193,
0.6750819683,
0.103515178,
0.3469298482,
-1.2109630108,
0.0443421453,
0.3591129184,
-0.0533240251,
0.4770487249,
-0.4847495556,
0.5709553361,
-0.0197125524,
-0.6118911505,
-0.803802073,
0.1698067486,
-1.1306302547,
-0.2464005947,
1.1408679485,
-0.2596045136,
-0.4804924428,
0.4773123562,
0.1843834519,
0.0028223407,
-0.2879999876,
0.6207155585,
0.6533977985,
0.0112546058,
-0.4723097086,
-0.670332253,
0.3513426483,
0.4382027686,
-0.6110354066,
-0.0954098776,
0.30137676,
0.0998643488,
0.2001645416,
0.7124534845,
-0.0935026184,
-0.0677651986,
-0.2446190268,
0.0659960881,
-0.0070346412,
-0.3736583889,
-0.5672805905,
0.1360155493,
0.2280173153,
-0.1524851173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17404v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17404v1
|
Make Some Noise: Unlocking Language Model Parallel Inference Capability through Noisy Training
| 2024-06-25T09:25:39 | 2024-06-25T09:25:39 |
Yixuan Wang, Xianzhen Luo, Fuxuan Wei, Yijun Liu, Qingfu Zhu, Xuanyu Zhang, Qing Yang, Dongliang Xu, Wanxiang Che
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Existing speculative decoding methods typically require additional model
structure and training processes to assist the model for draft token
generation. This makes the migration of acceleration methods to the new model
more costly and more demanding on device memory. To address this problem, we
propose the Make Some Noise (MSN) training framework as a replacement for the
supervised fine-tuning stage of the large language model. The training method
simply introduces some noise at the input for the model to learn the denoising
task. It significantly enhances the parallel decoding capability of the model
without affecting the original task capability. In addition, we propose a
tree-based retrieval-augmented Jacobi (TR-Jacobi) decoding strategy to further
improve the inference speed of MSN models. Experiments in both the general and
code domains have shown that MSN can improve inference speed by 2.3-2.7x times
without compromising model performance. The MSN model also achieves comparable
acceleration ratios to the SOTA model with additional model structure on
Spec-Bench.
|
[
-0.2866463959,
-0.734490633,
0.4528976381,
0.0880975872,
-0.0460738949,
0.0701534301,
-0.2013898045,
-0.6112000942,
0.2526448369,
0.4970184863,
-0.6157696247,
-0.2812083662,
-0.6522810459,
-0.0080077881,
-0.4421633482,
0.7841030359,
0.2903657854,
0.2861244977,
0.1772738397,
0.2631481588,
-0.1152534708,
-0.5145211816,
-1.0465167761,
0.0034000489,
0.4042526484,
0.1265318096,
0.6780622602,
0.8458111286,
0.2814743221,
0.3147522807,
-0.4147695601,
0.2073079944,
-0.5070823431,
0.1371282041,
0.0861567259,
-0.7384037971,
-0.4806625247,
-0.2331882566,
0.6604632139,
0.6609377265,
0.0139234746,
0.0259352718,
-0.1430223733,
0.674315989,
-0.7705414295,
0.3714516759,
-0.6964222193,
-0.0609958135,
-0.2776221633,
0.0440635718,
-0.5684975982,
-0.0946552008,
-0.0436215661,
-0.5755437613,
0.2886323035,
0.2249548584,
0.9277037978,
0.2678378522,
0.0385179035,
-0.0002151386,
-0.8371866941,
0.9360896945,
-1.029771328,
0.4411751032,
0.5210604668,
0.2338471562,
-0.0332061537,
-0.797853291,
-0.4606662393,
-0.1213080212,
-0.0111980429,
0.052684363,
-0.2902084291,
0.2642892897,
0.5639787912,
0.2280306071,
-0.3906904161,
-0.0037858374,
-0.498071909,
-0.1323189884,
0.4167640805,
0.1143390015,
0.195571512,
0.0559645332,
0.3110588193,
-0.0164089669,
-0.5803815126,
-0.0737111568,
0.4978669286,
0.6552672982,
0.0074753119,
0.191701591,
-0.3611212075,
0.6635426879,
-0.074880816,
-0.0756344795,
0.2454161197,
-0.2823657095,
-0.3252887428,
0.2404592484,
0.5067830086,
0.2328475714,
0.1587170959,
-0.1841256469,
-0.3650722504,
0.2470876724,
0.2104858607,
-1.1754461527,
-0.3565495908,
0.0663359538,
-0.7683888078,
-0.412863344,
-0.2450974882,
-0.4856280386,
-0.2486127317,
-0.6352091432,
0.1331755519,
-0.4518007636,
-0.647346437,
0.2952897549,
-0.1143334657,
-0.1663604677,
0.1666330099,
-1.1308870316,
0.444773376,
0.6194378734,
0.9218885899,
0.0042154402,
-0.278614819,
-0.5804384351,
-0.0832901746,
-0.6100962162,
0.7506181598,
-0.7952484488,
-0.1900989711,
-0.1546755731,
0.0827995464,
-0.3601748943,
-0.5371049643,
0.20824036,
-0.4981890321,
-0.3101335168,
-0.418595612,
-0.3464901447,
-0.1857469231,
0.1206116304,
-0.4948547781,
1.029317379,
0.1514637023,
-0.8092802167,
0.2946663201,
-0.6349509358,
-0.3783732951,
-0.3189709485,
-0.0804142132,
-0.4934257269,
0.287116915,
0.3443040252,
0.2527502775,
-0.2591993809,
0.2768495977,
-0.3313857913,
-0.5716287494,
-0.0328547508,
-0.418364048,
0.8304700851,
0.6008773446,
-0.1874392033,
0.146357581,
-0.8482838273,
-0.1292379051,
-0.1258284897,
-0.1040292159,
-0.2999416888,
0.0456252769,
-0.160989359,
0.0983485952,
-0.2118211389,
-0.5514561534,
0.0329499394,
-0.7239190936,
0.4755862057,
0.4060611725,
0.0351103023,
0.4322155416,
-0.5233722925,
0.5052143335,
0.3572559357,
0.0026463233,
-0.2153523266,
-0.4874725044,
-0.8715943694,
-0.2978952229,
0.6115953326,
0.2269075066,
-0.7264330387,
-0.1159210131,
-0.2731936276,
-0.2679589093,
-0.8091915846,
0.1574838012,
0.3387893438,
0.2786754072,
0.1244492456,
-0.2222238034,
-1.1069527864,
-0.6949084401,
-0.235944435,
-0.2079215348,
-0.1579706371,
0.1349785328,
0.3291890323,
0.1968173534,
0.7119967341,
-0.0991980731,
-0.0540545434,
-0.3082342744,
0.3331237137,
0.1235691458,
0.7105636001,
0.6375658512,
-0.5242244005,
-0.4518137574,
-0.0499123037,
-0.6783303022,
-0.0810054913,
-0.18882218,
-0.0598697998,
0.0444430187,
0.9334138632,
-0.4123798013,
0.3722326159,
0.4361643493,
0.0247113053,
0.3626540601,
-0.0864362195,
0.1109667346,
-1.1816978455,
-0.2276874036,
-0.3625596464,
-0.1580179036,
-0.6024458408,
-0.0189646538,
-0.169450447,
-0.1475439072,
-0.4365324378,
0.1068117768,
-0.5483976007,
-0.1102855727,
-0.4309450984,
-0.1194568649,
-0.1095401123,
0.3908053637,
0.0943897814,
1.0746036768,
1.1274305582,
-0.5912022591,
-0.2799169719,
-0.0268567875,
-0.2479107976,
0.038381394,
-0.4340164661,
-0.0048328782,
-0.3655629456,
-0.0057648416,
-0.7800467014,
-0.008666018,
0.0418076143,
-0.2241587639,
0.4078246057,
-0.4546267986,
-0.5853998661,
-0.2504012585,
-0.096723631,
0.3607621193,
0.630553782,
-0.4863836169,
0.519626379,
0.4544018209,
0.0170832463,
-0.3270243406,
-1.0504211187,
0.2374590039,
0.1906767637,
-0.5877603292,
0.2975425422,
0.0344281346,
-0.1081222743,
0.0178493541,
-0.1618077457,
-0.1476700604,
0.0568357818,
0.3554173708,
-0.0199283548,
-0.7556819916,
-0.0012341872,
0.2311201245,
-0.3115838468,
0.0724488646,
-0.4451214671,
0.2307051867,
-0.3492079377,
-0.1999132931,
-0.5145754814,
0.2282542586,
0.6634177566,
-0.2196124643,
0.825539887,
0.5981228948,
-0.2637269497,
-0.3318836689,
-0.452458322,
-0.5548506975,
-0.4823599458,
0.4821328521,
-0.6559493542,
-0.9060194492,
0.4411743581,
-0.4835948944,
0.0216041431,
0.0395094827,
0.5182446837,
0.2211318761,
1.2850033045,
0.5966339111,
-0.0210774317,
0.6663451791,
-0.2851836979,
0.2490768433,
-0.5371146202,
0.1005474329,
-0.6528223157,
-0.4754697382,
-0.5490791798,
-0.449632287,
-0.09700609,
0.2029569149,
-0.2294412106,
0.4995721281,
-0.4623146653,
0.6667335629,
0.6685657501,
0.1513175517,
0.2822269499,
0.3059447408,
-0.1737473011,
-0.1345278919,
-0.9463698268,
-0.1442623883,
1.0192323923,
0.318203032,
0.6832323074,
-0.0060913237,
0.627510488,
-0.0563229918,
0.3119932413,
-0.5295360088,
0.4184123576,
-0.3624808192,
-0.6100703478,
-0.1840189844,
-0.4722814858,
-0.7122576833,
0.188448146,
-0.2203329057,
-1.0304521322,
0.4314278364,
0.147469759,
-0.3561805785,
0.688054502,
-0.7820302248,
0.6338049769,
0.493388623,
-0.1938589364,
-0.2471997142,
-0.4316212535,
0.6095010638,
0.0666204616,
0.1402938366,
-0.0994415656,
0.401771307,
0.7782226205,
-0.4486500323,
1.169831872,
-0.2002574056,
0.1996652931,
0.5421831012,
0.3290826082,
0.8190908432,
-0.2382881492,
-0.5343735218,
0.3638946414,
0.1233107373,
-0.4196149409,
-0.6139070392,
0.5492110252,
-0.5985759497,
-0.464740783,
0.0245634895,
-0.9559150934,
-0.1835471392,
0.0667099506,
0.1750134379,
0.2040370107,
0.0554729439,
0.167875573,
0.4324981868,
0.2355561852,
0.7913994789,
0.5294789076,
-0.1914455146,
-0.0617167726,
1.1422702074,
0.277536124,
0.1079635248,
0.2015862912,
0.1699757576,
-0.0562332869,
-0.7975680232,
-0.4539610744,
-0.0452765189,
-0.3688360751,
-0.0744631365,
-0.8309255242,
-0.5245106816,
-0.329926163,
0.0820500925,
-0.6903579235,
-0.5698207021,
0.0346165337,
-0.1043210253,
0.4124034345,
0.75264889,
-0.1214056686,
0.9260050654,
-0.7508510947,
0.2931543589,
0.0836503431,
0.3002660871,
0.1843255609,
-0.7513144016,
-0.4280668199,
0.009934633,
-0.0468944535,
-0.5675722361,
0.3458844423,
0.1913501471,
0.2953427136,
0.5488892198,
0.3132352233,
0.8238974214,
-0.3500422239,
0.5056188703,
0.1132242233,
-0.8743979335,
0.3317230642,
-0.2154153436,
0.2632811964,
0.5304111242,
-0.014611938,
-0.0391529724,
-0.8135198355,
-0.6183585525,
-0.3862650096,
1.1569898129,
0.4999813139,
0.1804644167,
-0.0045536109,
0.2004879117,
-0.1213176548,
0.219611451,
-0.6101405621,
-0.2875551879,
-0.0671911463,
-0.1208716482,
0.3293985128,
-0.5668118596,
0.0415006578,
-0.4015608728,
0.6348273158,
-0.0338645987,
0.1263161749,
0.0285532605,
-0.0303852484,
-0.2941762209,
0.1938512027,
0.5095751882,
0.5719567537,
-0.2848482728,
0.285186559,
0.2999520302,
-0.3910503983,
-0.115746066,
0.0027930688,
-0.5971705914,
0.2570513189,
0.1790004373,
1.0938769579,
0.2457383573,
-0.3569618762,
0.3811319768,
-0.1070175543,
-0.5528242588,
0.228987962,
0.1938656867,
0.2143966258,
0.2700339258,
-0.0772792995,
0.7781734467,
0.2409757674,
-0.1384132802,
0.3398931921,
0.1218047217,
-0.5428834558,
-0.4453068972,
0.729865849,
-0.0728320628,
-0.2255990803,
0.2689288557,
-0.5036132932,
-0.3183244765,
0.5003398061,
0.8550115228,
0.9069799781,
-0.1305064112,
0.1111445427,
0.6164188981,
0.534553647,
-0.435793519,
0.5515274405,
-0.0696108788,
-0.7618409991,
-0.877140224,
-0.7827609777,
-0.1545880735,
0.2080754191,
-0.5721030831,
-0.0195739623,
-0.6943609118,
-0.1032977849,
0.0841082558,
-0.4393553436,
-0.3475133181,
0.1220971197,
0.0860992968,
0.6679852009,
-0.8530945182,
1.0506844521,
0.4333996475,
-0.301751554,
-0.784784019,
-0.033977598,
0.0111051714,
-0.7308929563,
0.8828257918,
0.1802089959,
-0.1537971348,
0.1378973722,
-0.5641033649,
-0.777451992,
0.4563930929,
0.8016899228,
-0.9131478071,
0.0315577313,
0.1080901399,
0.4171568751,
-0.5429478288,
0.4460093379,
0.6956804991,
0.4259088039,
0.131615445,
-0.6866362095,
0.2252518833,
-0.1100414321,
0.2182281762,
-0.0178144798,
-0.4291023612,
0.9586758018,
-0.3182829916,
-0.2699339092,
0.1143058315,
0.6687407494,
0.1686727703,
0.3259860575,
0.7088699937,
0.4502496719,
0.8504205942,
0.074574694,
0.8534920812,
-0.6542568207,
0.1056771353,
1.2463685274,
-0.0949572921,
0.8523055911,
0.4709730744,
-0.2266981453,
0.3176447749,
0.5577021837,
-0.0147300484,
0.402941376,
0.3863656223,
-0.3145235777,
-0.6909250617,
-0.283059299,
-0.4087219834,
0.2371869832,
0.3517201543,
-0.4093877077,
-0.4921267927,
0.0674742684,
-0.1369991302,
0.0383671187,
-0.1775822788,
0.6553444862,
0.2478570491,
-0.2778164148,
0.7894106507,
0.0131500615,
0.5545544624,
-0.5871676207,
-0.0998665094,
-0.1254441887,
0.1345523596,
-0.0691813529,
-0.0794675201,
0.6669203639,
-0.2042240798,
-0.4506998062,
-0.1781147569,
0.510529995,
-0.47536847,
-0.7919790745,
0.4087069333,
0.5118435025,
0.5875889659,
-0.3801399469,
-0.7323848009,
0.1872639358,
0.0833710209,
-0.2208851129,
0.4809830785,
0.5314437747,
-0.0790027305,
0.6389195919,
1.016767025,
0.2244630605,
0.1259435266,
0.5136771798,
0.9626955986,
-0.4877510369,
-0.507948041,
-0.7440091372,
0.1993899941,
0.0106712682,
-0.1443147808,
0.5925334692,
0.5858954787,
0.7361497879,
-0.1839825213,
0.6721789241,
-0.0844276473,
0.3871783614,
-0.6630996466,
0.9033013582,
-0.4749666154,
0.6639453769,
-0.0664414316,
-0.6819692254,
-0.3376889825,
0.2954538465,
-0.273234576,
0.0068447851,
0.7918393016,
1.5410490036,
-0.3007727563,
0.2465022653,
0.8116830587,
0.6209180951,
-0.0215270501,
0.3203763962,
0.6398074031,
-0.8300082684,
0.8439448476,
-0.374333322,
0.0322803967,
0.0318611786,
-0.6577088237,
-1.0516031981,
-0.2294304967,
-0.4784801006,
-0.6847859621,
0.387783587,
0.5649044514,
1.2303148508,
-1.36381495,
-0.2569713891,
-0.606869638,
0.1897778064,
-0.5721139908,
-0.2129967213,
0.46929878,
-0.8507323861,
-1.063718915,
0.7804175019,
0.1500132084,
0.0059754518,
0.2798771858,
-0.151246652,
-0.0909181312,
-0.0104224095,
0.3915766478,
0.3496206403,
-0.6230086088,
-0.013288008,
-0.0883201137,
0.0116257276,
0.0379131474,
1.0158178806,
-0.6828674674,
0.6441420913,
0.5205700397,
0.8647796512,
0.864299953,
-0.2265170664,
0.7298229337,
-0.8925445676,
0.6328178644,
-0.1722024083,
0.3800432682,
-0.0332158171,
-0.2809199989,
0.3276070952,
0.3679876029,
-0.1837724149,
-0.9297063947,
0.0512555502,
-0.7097940445,
-0.5564880371,
1.025957346,
-0.1611543,
-0.4862004817,
-0.4751344323,
-0.237777859,
0.269200325,
-0.5078366399,
0.6279371977,
0.3509519398,
0.1492579132,
-0.4141418338,
-0.70420748,
0.6657658815,
0.7441859245,
-0.312166214,
0.2574393451,
0.0088501815,
0.0964803994,
0.1483842582,
0.5014281273,
-0.0645685419,
0.2391244471,
0.8427027464,
0.1710874885,
-0.4531315267,
-0.3161579072,
-0.1397828013,
0.1576767713,
0.0658378229,
-0.4162678123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17385v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17385v1
|
Native Design Bias: Studying the Impact of English Nativeness on Language Model Performance
| 2024-06-25T09:04:21 | 2024-06-25T09:04:21 |
Manon Reusens, Philipp Borchert, Jochen De Weerdt, Bart Baesens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) excel at providing information acquired during
pretraining on large-scale corpora and following instructions through user
prompts. This study investigates whether the quality of LLM responses varies
depending on the demographic profile of users. Considering English as the
global lingua franca, along with the diversity of its dialects among speakers
of different native languages, we explore whether non-native English speakers
receive lower-quality or even factually incorrect responses from LLMs more
frequently. Our results show that performance discrepancies occur when LLMs are
prompted by native versus non-native English speakers and persist when
comparing native speakers from Western countries with others. Additionally, we
find a strong anchoring effect when the model recognizes or is made aware of
the user's nativeness, which further degrades the response quality when
interacting with non-native speakers. Our analysis is based on a newly
collected dataset with over 12,000 unique annotations from 124 annotators,
including information on their native language and English proficiency.
|
[
-0.4084541202,
-0.6137174964,
0.2172968537,
0.2484735101,
-0.0496033095,
0.3207935691,
-0.3693419695,
-0.9635788798,
0.1660336256,
0.2033113837,
-0.2615919411,
-0.4420207143,
-0.4328589737,
0.4070043862,
-0.0115259541,
0.6280292273,
0.0385607444,
0.1716980934,
-0.5905120373,
-0.1111730114,
-0.6888558865,
-0.6796354651,
-0.5121889114,
-0.3004585505,
0.4538373649,
0.39006266,
0.6992519498,
0.2812418938,
0.362359643,
0.2339929193,
-0.2630914748,
-0.0112535907,
-0.6273255944,
0.0912113041,
-0.3376169801,
-0.7287100554,
-0.5719919205,
0.1092230007,
0.3803637922,
0.7107102871,
0.1848192513,
0.3166745007,
0.2644581199,
0.4053165913,
-0.5747070909,
0.0822026581,
-0.5676372051,
-0.0702054575,
-0.3189097643,
-0.1961126626,
-0.6309010386,
-0.2902916074,
0.1942280978,
-0.6746709347,
0.373575598,
0.179959625,
0.8076508641,
0.0712293684,
-0.663277626,
-0.0737887323,
-0.7640442252,
0.8038283587,
-0.9633321762,
0.5413472056,
0.4708595574,
-0.0904455557,
-0.1604477316,
-0.0359219275,
-0.3019409776,
-0.4645089209,
-0.2999572754,
-0.0319047384,
-0.0782161653,
0.0185586009,
0.4332379401,
0.4395436049,
-0.7883172631,
0.7343527675,
-0.5384235978,
-0.3259103894,
0.9057893753,
0.0809441656,
0.2140578926,
-0.0905188024,
-0.0518837385,
0.1566259712,
-0.8722474575,
0.3413696587,
0.6058213115,
0.4665688574,
-0.426394701,
0.3713168204,
-0.0735288635,
0.7628226876,
-0.1507228613,
-0.4983797371,
0.5585121512,
-0.1135717556,
0.121578984,
-0.1313244253,
0.7531204224,
0.5483130813,
0.7756966949,
-0.1604585201,
-0.4395220578,
0.1329679936,
-0.0405750535,
-0.6264491677,
0.0223172978,
-0.1035220847,
-0.5443676114,
-0.022087045,
0.0527062751,
-0.720436573,
-0.3287705481,
-0.3748908937,
0.2035399526,
0.1766143739,
-0.4179342091,
0.0938528776,
0.1509331912,
0.0345905907,
0.1008875519,
-0.9499168992,
0.3366048932,
0.4065530896,
0.602625072,
-0.5837829113,
-0.11333327,
-0.2621352673,
-0.1197145879,
-0.3794333637,
0.6041358113,
-0.6129617095,
-0.8049123287,
0.1726133674,
-0.0186391715,
0.0075149862,
-0.773608923,
0.4966270328,
-0.6050436497,
0.2282504588,
-0.5075488687,
-0.2174596936,
0.0101359338,
-0.0510813892,
-0.7458948493,
0.8761241436,
-0.2559129894,
-0.8280350566,
0.6353977919,
-0.4547589123,
-0.6989442706,
0.0559112318,
-0.3245155513,
-0.0191308409,
0.4998939931,
0.284940511,
0.2922030389,
-0.1584674567,
0.0108938953,
-0.3162789941,
-0.4943445921,
0.1136539057,
-0.3371764719,
0.4342617691,
0.3048019707,
-0.2764905393,
-0.0786475614,
-0.8855844736,
-0.3893158436,
0.3951939046,
-0.6033824682,
-0.574842751,
0.0918247625,
0.1414818913,
0.3737453222,
0.264703691,
-0.7517752647,
0.0631419569,
-0.4544628561,
0.247369349,
0.8093757033,
-0.0553925857,
0.3769807518,
-0.3731102049,
0.7004101276,
-0.1441890001,
-0.0543924384,
-0.232557252,
-0.6474624276,
-0.4274874032,
0.0880526975,
0.1647832394,
0.3749560118,
-0.2273658812,
-0.0293922685,
-0.231670782,
-0.2097542733,
-0.5240311027,
0.4637695551,
0.2993822396,
0.4832192063,
0.0823577493,
-0.4123552144,
-0.5220739841,
-1.2099641562,
-0.2506892383,
-0.4457979798,
-0.3383312523,
0.4414060414,
0.3059746325,
0.0736853033,
0.9878573418,
-0.2380245179,
-0.0699693635,
-0.2803248465,
-0.0219225287,
0.1243842319,
0.1303572804,
0.6776664257,
-0.5338151455,
-0.3392938375,
-0.0866320729,
-0.5118032098,
-0.3363444805,
-0.0412936658,
0.0560039654,
0.5597434044,
0.3776980937,
-0.4362263978,
0.2747583687,
0.825245142,
-0.1559622884,
0.5725054741,
-0.0887942761,
0.1259588599,
-1.1353360415,
0.1252839863,
0.3444953561,
0.1825296134,
-0.3148623407,
-0.1522181332,
0.1053856984,
0.1223087981,
-0.3812398612,
0.6853196621,
-0.5977147818,
-0.131398648,
-0.23305583,
0.1147703603,
0.1907449812,
0.1558464915,
0.2579528391,
1.0686181784,
0.0291589759,
-0.5180928111,
-0.0842149705,
0.1951142401,
-0.4654689133,
0.4931438863,
-0.9426085949,
0.1913042516,
-0.3597672582,
0.1590991616,
-1.2847774029,
-0.1249563023,
-0.4161788821,
-0.5817201734,
0.389439106,
-0.0344161019,
-0.4971910119,
-0.5766457915,
-0.0823664218,
0.3757771254,
0.4094820023,
-0.4054785967,
0.3916528523,
0.2888385355,
-0.300381124,
-0.3784472048,
-0.7411714792,
0.0844283327,
-0.0549729466,
-0.8638863564,
0.1988819838,
-0.1864054203,
-0.5785841942,
-0.3141857684,
0.0589133836,
0.229400456,
0.3415504098,
0.1900172979,
0.3046543896,
-0.3755905628,
0.2067999691,
-0.3843864202,
0.2262345999,
0.4628289938,
-0.032469444,
0.4194090962,
0.2475995719,
-0.3947134316,
-0.3387240469,
0.3024574518,
0.6381932497,
-0.630505681,
0.7923227549,
0.0814243108,
-0.3471995592,
-0.066741921,
-0.7831736207,
-0.2112334073,
-0.4767403305,
0.4769900739,
-0.4759112895,
-0.970841825,
0.7537506819,
0.4752301276,
0.4969678521,
0.3257995248,
0.5469382405,
-0.1440166086,
1.0674080849,
0.7429904938,
-0.247361213,
0.3831987083,
0.0455153584,
0.1387791932,
-0.4912465811,
-0.3959113061,
-0.5659310818,
-0.5494302511,
-0.7223564982,
-0.0299393218,
-0.0470044985,
-0.3521423936,
-0.1479222775,
-0.0119696334,
-0.2011942416,
0.306632936,
0.5392415524,
-0.1562878489,
0.4011638165,
0.1564768851,
-0.2014630437,
-0.4413963854,
-0.4880844057,
-0.6484003067,
1.1459937096,
0.5818700194,
1.1906971931,
0.2528976798,
0.4081830978,
0.2143128663,
0.2723425031,
-0.5980859399,
0.2965972424,
0.1032275483,
-0.8247430325,
0.1278664768,
-0.4910775125,
-0.9547014236,
0.0476530902,
-0.3234477043,
-0.7383344769,
0.1002809256,
0.2657262981,
-0.3304711282,
0.3405605555,
-0.8561444283,
0.5586616993,
-0.5558255315,
-0.5438052416,
0.0712461546,
-0.4590138197,
0.4588104784,
-0.3153758049,
0.5059802532,
-0.1159379482,
-0.0082777794,
0.8357436061,
0.0158862472,
1.0033199787,
-0.148358807,
-0.3827008307,
-0.0314371511,
0.1212192923,
0.5089673996,
0.035444621,
-0.2494528145,
0.1585486382,
-0.3240273297,
-0.5236765146,
-0.2665476799,
0.8498337269,
-1.0644904375,
-0.9308356643,
-0.125190571,
-0.6193447709,
-0.5049886703,
-0.1235725582,
0.4463599622,
0.3293218017,
-0.1292267889,
0.049545601,
0.5860663056,
-0.5063721538,
0.3276038468,
0.815748632,
-0.1872089356,
-0.035253156,
0.5416527987,
0.416056484,
0.5353924036,
0.3666036129,
0.1824709773,
-0.3741399646,
-0.5793989301,
-0.296094507,
0.3958304822,
-0.5375958085,
0.1501778662,
-0.4487858713,
0.0266422722,
-0.4509975612,
-0.0503664427,
-0.3400560319,
-0.0608379543,
-0.1359710842,
-0.3665946126,
0.2654635906,
1.110486269,
0.1755274087,
0.1637496054,
-0.4337073565,
-0.073857896,
0.2406453341,
0.2989204526,
0.1564962715,
-0.9634649754,
-0.3360711932,
-0.0153340083,
-0.1560287923,
-0.6875195503,
0.0848573744,
0.0768273771,
0.9689789414,
0.5380880833,
-0.0312577263,
0.2380396426,
-0.3728547096,
0.970184803,
-0.0962508023,
-0.4649269879,
0.4886492789,
-0.4676416218,
0.5558950305,
0.5454114676,
0.4674468338,
-0.6563958526,
-0.3575926125,
-0.2553794384,
-0.8440937996,
0.32934618,
-0.2478016913,
0.5367093682,
-0.1318256408,
0.2108196467,
0.2048742175,
0.129299894,
-0.7871293426,
-0.3853525817,
0.1787369698,
0.2079704404,
-0.2364071757,
-0.6633330584,
0.1308659464,
-0.034946911,
0.4444222152,
-0.0183845498,
-0.074227348,
-0.0814569741,
-0.2799633741,
-0.2676814198,
0.1384456158,
0.893717885,
1.0314882994,
-0.2008843571,
0.1701545715,
0.326675266,
-0.3721825182,
0.2193067074,
-0.2547807992,
-0.1542984992,
0.2434021831,
0.6219124794,
0.5993114114,
0.3039875627,
-0.4535908103,
0.4800409675,
-0.186199978,
-0.0932999551,
-0.1127831787,
-0.1435655206,
0.2174948752,
-0.3770219386,
0.5897945762,
0.0047263252,
-0.178023383,
-0.3805737197,
0.0783213675,
0.5204501748,
0.000106696,
-0.6124537587,
0.9792897701,
0.5891823769,
-0.5649898052,
0.4511006176,
-0.0288495012,
-0.3700993061,
0.3477313221,
0.5563665032,
0.4465443194,
-0.4058430195,
-0.1084892154,
0.5432657003,
0.5142146349,
0.228217721,
0.1447852701,
0.2938963771,
-0.6771912575,
-0.9104784131,
-0.5164637566,
-0.3172406554,
0.3255821764,
-0.5925792456,
0.2514629066,
-0.4477391243,
-0.3611103892,
-0.3395727277,
-0.0646867976,
-0.9410136938,
0.2066381127,
0.5644493699,
1.1424735785,
-1.1553122997,
0.4297444224,
0.9113168716,
-0.4508458376,
-0.7278367281,
-0.0016767177,
0.2599695921,
-0.7873734236,
0.9364221096,
0.1917091608,
0.0171867311,
-0.3829447031,
-0.1486380994,
-1.0113066435,
0.6327352524,
0.554967165,
-0.6228461266,
0.0000651178,
0.5300312638,
0.589804709,
-0.1255606413,
0.5323204994,
0.4256929457,
0.1181209385,
-0.0253630448,
-1.3442405462,
-0.2428962886,
-0.3541073203,
0.2202884853,
-0.0913512632,
-0.7527880669,
0.7480697036,
-0.2308861613,
-0.166701287,
-0.2454229891,
0.6938405037,
0.3456275761,
0.0304547157,
0.3676244318,
0.4212550819,
0.7869594693,
0.0309450533,
0.8674355745,
-0.5108491182,
-0.1386302859,
1.0223782063,
-0.2477462441,
1.0686826706,
0.5182763934,
-0.3358443975,
0.5155883431,
0.8493170738,
0.4076921642,
0.144473657,
0.4137699604,
-0.3283406496,
-0.1147869974,
-0.2600027323,
-0.5417995453,
0.463773489,
0.0930304751,
-0.4504626691,
0.0175128635,
-0.0292934906,
0.2135136873,
0.3396150172,
-0.2333173603,
0.4853363037,
0.1239202023,
-0.6143162847,
0.7003139853,
-0.001377004,
1.3264237642,
-0.4490236342,
0.2068617791,
-0.7585762739,
-0.0597747862,
-0.5356231332,
-0.6419500709,
0.0003457206,
0.0673829764,
-0.5243651867,
-0.0840351954,
0.2959661484,
-0.0388163589,
-0.6076486111,
0.5707287788,
0.5894770622,
0.1039699316,
0.1189130545,
-0.2654537857,
0.3069632947,
-0.110956043,
-0.5197572708,
0.365989089,
0.0300132576,
-0.3092109859,
0.6270629168,
0.6328074336,
0.1526324451,
0.216559723,
0.1535459608,
0.5202423334,
-0.2740579844,
-0.371067822,
-0.8535807133,
0.5500925779,
-0.1002930775,
-0.5149760842,
0.9550285935,
0.8492028117,
1.2703573704,
-0.0197471119,
0.8625990748,
0.4585706592,
0.4971591532,
-0.3122890294,
0.6300325394,
-0.5523306727,
0.4383001328,
-0.3532577753,
-1.0638999939,
-0.1351461112,
0.5832445025,
-0.65433079,
0.3297459483,
0.285769254,
0.8839660883,
-0.0085040499,
-0.1225458682,
0.5310068727,
0.0628670156,
0.5003377199,
0.456063658,
0.8166890144,
0.0092672687,
0.4097593427,
-0.0299256705,
-0.1433347464,
-0.1474539638,
-0.6914359331,
-0.9470518827,
-0.2608117759,
-0.2070209533,
-0.2160817385,
-0.159254998,
1.0970807076,
0.7603527308,
-0.8482297659,
-0.4812737107,
0.4975057244,
-0.0943505615,
0.3733590245,
-0.2399130017,
0.0465515517,
-0.2865791619,
-0.7190772295,
0.3416197896,
-0.1024725214,
0.0449760742,
-0.5532420874,
-0.2172435671,
0.069947049,
0.0577686653,
0.6095181108,
0.3554267883,
-0.7689086199,
-0.1797263175,
0.3977699876,
-0.252197504,
0.2215565741,
0.5602948666,
-0.7236588597,
0.4549151957,
0.402910769,
0.5416876674,
0.2154560536,
-0.0636017919,
0.7979639173,
-0.8324757814,
0.2754749954,
0.0769610181,
0.4213194251,
0.6370250583,
-0.2682264149,
0.183524549,
0.3337413371,
-0.5399220586,
-0.7192260623,
0.1122798249,
-0.3992784321,
-0.0693799406,
1.4486253262,
-0.0495857298,
-0.163932085,
-0.1093215272,
-0.2085092962,
-0.3315163553,
-0.4522096813,
0.6125163436,
0.9112579823,
0.0031449927,
-0.2011249214,
-0.9506636262,
0.4539017677,
0.4513659775,
-0.5119115114,
-0.0563446246,
0.5155373812,
0.6367701888,
0.1266745627,
0.5088097453,
0.1074008122,
0.1810798347,
-0.2656884193,
0.2529110014,
0.0122975288,
-0.0020130789,
-0.3066016138,
-0.0129308309,
0.856623292,
-0.1256946921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17378v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17378v1
|
A Text is Worth Several Tokens: Text Embedding from LLMs Secretly Aligns Well with The Key Tokens
| 2024-06-25T08:55:12 | 2024-06-25T08:55:12 |
Zhijie Nie, Richong Zhang, Zhanyu Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Text embeddings from large language models (LLMs) have achieved excellent
results in tasks such as information retrieval, semantic textual similarity,
etc. In this work, we show an interesting finding: when feeding a text into the
embedding LLMs, the obtained text embedding will be able to be aligned with the
key tokens in the input text. We first fully analyze this phenomenon on eight
embedding LLMs and show that this phenomenon is universal and is not affected
by model architecture, training strategy, and embedding method. With a deeper
analysis, we then find that the main change in embedding space between the
embedding LLMs and their original generative LLMs is in the first principal
component. By adjusting the first principal component, we can align text
embedding with the key tokens. Finally, we give several examples to demonstrate
the vast application potential of this finding: (1) we propose a simple and
practical sparse retrieval method based on the aligned tokens, which can
achieve 80\% of the dense retrieval effect of the same model while reducing the
computation significantly; (2) we show that our findings provide a fresh
perspective to help understand fuzzy concepts (e.g., semantic relatedness vs.
semantic similarity) and emerging technologies (e.g., instruction-following
embedding) in this field.
|
[
0.062682353,
-0.766872406,
1.0247539282,
-0.0727444291,
-0.5462213755,
0.121684514,
-0.1924221367,
-0.2283369005,
0.4066964388,
0.308490485,
-0.3076345026,
-0.4986140132,
-0.6779909134,
-0.1090686396,
-0.587895453,
0.7118816972,
0.04366754,
0.2643280029,
-0.4450436831,
-0.2270654887,
-0.5386909246,
-0.6555250287,
-0.2838562429,
-0.1973117292,
0.4182059169,
0.2801306844,
0.9427399635,
1.1553230286,
0.7538554072,
0.3190781474,
-0.1917292476,
-0.0776077956,
-0.5546064377,
0.2128438354,
0.0037920845,
-0.6659271717,
-0.1603905261,
-0.0577433743,
0.9922510386,
0.6166753769,
0.125969708,
-0.1265871227,
0.4856396616,
0.5308572054,
-0.4280020893,
0.0034747478,
-0.8491271138,
0.030410273,
-0.3030624688,
-0.02759807,
-0.34311831,
-0.0440517925,
-0.0555654578,
-0.60027349,
0.0450608358,
0.277582705,
1.069568634,
0.3729245961,
-0.3887510896,
-0.294536531,
-0.1808239818,
0.7648019195,
-0.6720749736,
0.3732866347,
-0.0281132832,
-0.0531978495,
-0.1381300837,
-0.578037858,
-0.7869236469,
0.0620904155,
-0.1660212129,
-0.2556924224,
0.1241250336,
0.1935526282,
-0.0540910028,
0.3512096703,
-0.3254930377,
0.2754960656,
0.1027381197,
-0.1307965964,
0.3583763838,
0.0819674581,
0.4031139314,
-0.3360260129,
-0.7669919133,
-0.1641225219,
-0.8044989705,
-0.3365686238,
0.1996062398,
0.5396470428,
-0.0554021783,
0.9194690585,
0.4403871894,
0.5888726711,
0.0329682939,
-0.1579530388,
0.2217294425,
-0.7326201797,
-0.225343585,
0.1563133746,
0.680837214,
0.3220973909,
0.3756328225,
-0.2170676589,
-0.2006195635,
-0.0770289153,
0.243910715,
-0.5117537975,
0.1696124971,
-0.0961091816,
-0.6211630702,
-0.359033078,
0.3729142845,
-0.3941629231,
-0.4602986574,
-0.2381722778,
0.6987050176,
-0.4336794019,
0.020113742,
0.0407945067,
-0.2563651204,
0.5183770061,
0.170804888,
-1.0707278252,
0.3899796307,
1.3552008867,
1.0353219509,
-0.2299813777,
-0.121490933,
-0.2399540544,
0.1932728887,
-0.3743200898,
0.7314993143,
-0.8223398328,
-0.1384158283,
0.2675118446,
-0.1814274043,
0.0009926768,
-0.4473711848,
0.4024171829,
-0.5415839553,
-0.0597078167,
-0.3868356347,
-0.9439998269,
0.050378181,
0.1592932791,
-0.6521328688,
1.0373082161,
-0.2723357975,
-0.7244068384,
0.3536626995,
-0.0224963687,
-0.1938441247,
-0.0986767411,
-0.4661240876,
-0.4168245792,
0.3764441609,
0.0167351365,
0.5048798919,
-0.2228445709,
0.2059295475,
-0.4005056322,
-0.6197413802,
0.6122985482,
-0.4556683302,
0.4793931842,
0.0676560551,
-0.2172638476,
-0.1094348803,
-0.3809803426,
-0.0605785958,
0.0126364408,
-0.2476390451,
-0.7063519359,
0.0822406709,
-0.0292959306,
-0.0556234978,
0.4037664235,
-0.6845114231,
0.4696737826,
-0.4817724526,
0.4839739501,
0.9527098536,
-0.0350888334,
0.7343375087,
-0.4289085567,
0.1548590511,
0.0172413997,
-0.2023847997,
-0.3215463459,
-0.4537363648,
-0.6340828538,
-0.4992206395,
0.6550374627,
0.3360013366,
-0.2985948324,
0.5488880277,
-0.4920798242,
-0.0073783989,
-0.6956373453,
0.2852340043,
0.246990338,
0.123313196,
-0.0182367843,
-0.0981589556,
-0.2697354257,
-0.8913780451,
-0.5549070835,
-0.0244126972,
0.117163986,
0.1350673884,
0.2997329235,
0.0034591975,
0.9804716706,
-0.6421331167,
-0.4319598079,
0.0566880181,
-0.2136379033,
0.0781303868,
0.6634613872,
0.4336337447,
-0.7693791389,
-0.5428195,
-0.0655365288,
-0.5844553113,
0.090883404,
-0.2282057703,
-0.3729073703,
0.0161960963,
0.7836648226,
-0.5918081403,
0.1290998757,
0.4034437835,
-0.4587779939,
-0.2040868551,
-0.1814155132,
-0.0441274531,
-1.3013100624,
-0.1189270914,
-0.2042628676,
-0.319378376,
-0.3746035397,
0.1686778814,
0.2327991128,
-0.0379096679,
-0.2434483916,
0.6236407161,
-0.4939564764,
-0.1051913947,
-0.317078948,
0.6544100046,
0.0727278069,
0.3103464842,
-0.4073240459,
0.8137527108,
0.2734877467,
-0.2555087209,
0.1098608524,
0.3073236048,
-0.4074661434,
0.4611057043,
-0.3878338635,
0.1739336997,
-0.2968739569,
-0.0092078233,
-1.4393392801,
0.0800315663,
0.1127815768,
-0.4820516407,
0.5962552428,
0.0881601498,
-0.8492570519,
0.091679737,
-0.7195866108,
0.5020992756,
0.4480551481,
-0.6162828207,
0.458615005,
0.449585855,
-0.1809933633,
-0.5863547921,
-0.7398623228,
0.2189613581,
-0.241210103,
-0.3742392361,
0.6580631137,
0.1386875957,
-0.2398565263,
0.5366769433,
-0.1633036137,
0.0295932163,
0.3472097814,
0.1406914294,
0.2833628058,
-0.3290979564,
0.604740262,
0.0762551799,
-0.1022617221,
-0.1418368965,
-0.4481851161,
0.527551055,
0.1347850263,
-0.6355622411,
-0.329603076,
0.3559974134,
0.4147128761,
-0.009286792,
1.0109190941,
0.393973738,
-0.6014854908,
0.0559885129,
-0.5875613689,
-0.0544616729,
-0.5337573886,
0.5087709427,
-0.241057992,
-1.1039762497,
0.3172835112,
0.0010934395,
-0.0104698744,
0.6132056117,
0.3566093445,
-0.1745821089,
1.2266609669,
0.8765220642,
-0.1861964017,
0.5820889473,
0.0192331113,
0.4476626515,
-0.8936602473,
-0.5027045608,
-0.6996559501,
-0.5433195233,
-0.7755184174,
-0.5639408827,
0.1241226718,
0.2643615901,
-0.3263438344,
0.0010508405,
-0.4270800054,
0.5253669024,
0.3357134461,
0.0411059968,
0.2194672674,
0.1632102728,
-0.4964692295,
-0.3052696884,
-0.5910708904,
-0.6216279864,
0.9532412291,
0.3924625814,
0.8748134971,
0.2589660883,
0.8658374548,
0.2105157822,
0.1985228956,
-0.9814647436,
0.349416554,
-0.3662899137,
-0.3203992248,
-0.178749606,
-0.1650476307,
-0.826946795,
0.1950042844,
-0.3604127765,
-0.7415243387,
0.0118292719,
-0.163743645,
-0.288238585,
0.2647030652,
-0.6467267871,
0.703070879,
-0.3473579586,
-0.2810064256,
-0.2776912153,
-0.3619763255,
-0.0102416025,
-0.1666579545,
0.0917944387,
-0.0368582457,
-0.6363056898,
0.8318558335,
-0.468842268,
0.9186751842,
0.0945143253,
-0.2644348145,
0.2063333243,
-0.2119722813,
0.4098104835,
-0.0983730257,
-0.0682137683,
-0.086247839,
-0.0963019282,
-0.4992514551,
-0.9424889684,
1.118442893,
-0.7428022623,
-1.0173727274,
-0.5832750201,
-0.3504092693,
-0.1302355826,
0.3516477942,
-0.0726633221,
0.3896082938,
-0.1677505672,
0.4022748172,
0.8207224011,
-0.1062281653,
0.3540204167,
0.0796075836,
-0.1881738901,
-0.3802520931,
0.7850375772,
0.0737202615,
0.2100072354,
0.8763520122,
0.1640675664,
-0.4174123704,
-0.2181303799,
-0.3062509,
0.5601526499,
-0.712080121,
-0.4916530848,
-0.5750277042,
-0.1797749549,
-0.4033069015,
-0.4465728402,
-0.2216206342,
-0.5864484906,
-0.6403495073,
-0.2852917016,
0.4053505957,
1.0486416817,
0.0535990708,
0.460232228,
-0.9397271872,
-0.0456004553,
0.3022520244,
0.5123302937,
0.3091732264,
-0.4452694952,
-0.2804448009,
0.0334161855,
-0.3470381796,
-0.8712210655,
0.0857850909,
0.23968485,
0.5784872174,
0.7302945256,
-0.1768515855,
0.7332074046,
-0.6902633905,
0.9180474877,
0.0837249383,
-1.1844183207,
-0.0285983197,
-0.0889240056,
0.156937331,
0.6142537594,
0.3158253729,
-0.4959074855,
-0.2387625277,
-0.5205529332,
-0.6771956682,
0.5317831039,
0.020569263,
0.7988778353,
-0.2294494361,
0.6501746774,
-0.0396788642,
0.2437641621,
-0.5952649117,
-0.3311645389,
0.0752762631,
-0.7753576636,
-0.1089388505,
-0.6089401841,
0.0476441495,
-0.0150936432,
0.4462304413,
0.0452024303,
0.7367216349,
0.0880343467,
-0.1159733683,
0.0845427066,
0.1353197694,
0.4461545944,
0.230576396,
0.1006694436,
0.4347765446,
0.0720294416,
-0.3545251191,
0.2291211933,
-0.0906750932,
0.0276462249,
-0.006355864,
0.4267205596,
0.543833673,
0.6858465075,
-0.5350928903,
0.7974982262,
0.138018921,
0.0104446542,
0.0666948184,
-0.0512417667,
0.2671253085,
0.2609151602,
0.4459758699,
-0.2493791729,
-0.1026981026,
-0.5636430979,
0.3008103073,
0.8781293035,
-0.4438545406,
-0.223521769,
0.4829353392,
0.0707582161,
-0.4639852345,
0.5585125685,
0.0676368251,
-0.9242892861,
0.4229251742,
0.8804514408,
0.7430288792,
0.168270275,
0.1305059195,
0.1326411068,
0.275655359,
-0.0322720036,
0.1733905077,
-0.1772624701,
-0.7438125014,
-0.3285424113,
-0.5436020494,
0.0360496938,
-0.2495208383,
-0.4552710652,
0.2975176573,
-0.3495540917,
-0.1235405356,
-0.1775793135,
0.0969040766,
-0.5905493498,
-0.2497525066,
0.2116983235,
0.9052399993,
-0.783896029,
0.7236871719,
0.5480183959,
-0.1405158937,
-0.8289300799,
0.2962851524,
0.042099867,
-1.1252992153,
0.683891058,
0.2430264801,
0.1476753503,
0.0684683993,
-0.6012541056,
-1.2548897266,
0.94810462,
0.292504847,
-0.4676693976,
-0.1691864133,
0.3738788664,
0.4352516234,
-0.340344429,
-0.1586783379,
0.1318293661,
0.3748130202,
-0.067434296,
-0.6019123197,
0.3331900239,
-0.1231074855,
0.1638509482,
0.5379002094,
-0.8202722073,
0.8141061664,
-0.0594265833,
-0.5190212131,
0.4364187419,
0.6663382053,
-0.1196112186,
-0.0432509594,
0.244166255,
0.8229578733,
0.7378396988,
-0.0591313839,
0.9379734993,
-0.4042083323,
0.4100024104,
0.6016555429,
-0.2555653155,
0.9334490895,
0.7281630039,
0.0893382803,
0.4530166388,
0.3154657483,
0.0200576317,
0.7674465179,
0.1868740171,
-0.2022981048,
-0.2220308483,
-0.2820397317,
-0.2871843874,
0.3182051182,
0.4629913568,
-0.4898076355,
-0.102418229,
0.0059320256,
0.1995675564,
0.2488670498,
-0.119169265,
0.9762778878,
0.3346785009,
-0.5029553175,
0.2934384942,
0.1211031005,
0.789993763,
-0.4417515099,
-0.1358927786,
0.0476384126,
0.3149645329,
-0.0303949043,
-0.776309371,
0.1161625534,
-0.1451565921,
0.0089312978,
-0.3021206558,
0.7023925781,
-0.4562569261,
-0.4567355514,
0.1754528582,
0.4275943637,
-0.1831377596,
0.2322188318,
-0.4847434163,
0.2875246406,
-0.072983183,
0.0985391885,
0.6005741954,
0.7062363029,
0.1604490131,
0.2974113822,
0.5062049627,
-0.0015356415,
0.0660994276,
-0.2006758451,
0.8807932138,
-0.7592190504,
-0.424983263,
-1.1883901358,
0.1565217078,
-0.0666184649,
-0.1159585416,
0.8708586693,
0.5924743414,
0.7206133008,
0.2690940201,
0.479139179,
0.2995153368,
0.1658824831,
-0.7674973011,
0.5720775127,
-0.5921415091,
0.2926377654,
-0.3435885906,
-0.9753639698,
-0.4352884889,
0.7139881253,
-0.0307846032,
-0.1056636646,
0.7474642396,
0.7281417847,
0.0626535043,
-0.1342503577,
0.244865045,
0.1449504197,
0.1218647957,
0.2538600564,
0.7595956922,
-0.4474704862,
0.258531034,
0.0431878753,
-0.0677464679,
-0.2166370302,
-0.919133842,
-0.6541736126,
-0.7123529315,
-0.0692598075,
-0.1809017509,
0.2273271531,
0.9058642387,
0.2618811131,
-0.4705142677,
-0.032921467,
-0.0039306371,
0.480035156,
0.0267488398,
-0.2411213517,
0.5413050056,
-0.491627723,
-0.7114963531,
-0.0761747211,
0.2951104343,
0.2546275854,
-0.1738318801,
0.0516516007,
-0.4830694795,
0.1692512929,
0.4228390753,
-0.2691497505,
-0.6759437323,
-0.7252637148,
0.3145736158,
-0.4546435177,
0.125346452,
0.9645475149,
-0.7776446939,
0.2524207234,
0.6320269108,
1.0885170698,
0.1263756901,
0.1303811967,
0.5815476179,
-0.7808442116,
0.0532570705,
0.0492787324,
0.4187638462,
0.3752781451,
-0.4781925082,
0.0125629706,
0.0700081214,
-0.3870992661,
-0.8746339679,
-0.0253226478,
-0.8415077329,
-0.2885577381,
1.1906099319,
0.037603654,
-0.2545523643,
0.2669562995,
-0.1885882914,
0.3326422572,
-0.2544569373,
0.6432252526,
0.9943413734,
0.1595728844,
0.1672956795,
-0.0851717815,
0.2788774967,
0.6450222731,
-0.3238329887,
-0.1705849469,
0.0644240081,
0.1439979672,
0.1743885726,
0.3581131101,
-0.1998694837,
-0.1508074999,
-0.0388590693,
-0.3982623816,
0.1064913645,
-0.134434998,
-0.5205910206,
0.0409638248,
0.3400215805,
-0.4349814355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17377v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17377v1
|
A Three-Pronged Approach to Cross-Lingual Adaptation with Multilingual LLMs
| 2024-06-25T08:53:46 | 2024-06-25T08:53:46 |
Vaibhav Singh, Amrith Krishna, Karthika NJ, Ganesh Ramakrishnan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Low-resource languages, by its very definition, tend to be under represented
in the pre-training corpora of Large Language Models. In this work, we
investigate three low-resource cross-lingual approaches that enable an LLM
adapt to tasks in previously unseen languages. Llama-2 is an LLM where Indic
languages, among many other language families, contribute to less than
$0.005\%$ of the total $2$ trillion token pre-training corpora. In this work,
we experiment with the English-dominated Llama-2 for cross-lingual transfer to
three Indic languages, Bengali, Hindi, and Tamil as target languages. We study
three approaches for cross-lingual transfer, under ICL and fine-tuning. One, we
find that adding additional supervisory signals via a dominant language in the
LLM, leads to improvements, both under in-context learning and fine-tuning.
Two, adapting the target languages to word reordering may be beneficial under
ICL, but its impact diminishes with fine tuning. Finally, continued
pre-training in one low-resource language can improve model performance for
other related low-resource languages.
|
[
-0.2536784112,
-0.3369269371,
0.1889187843,
0.5293281078,
-0.3906202614,
0.5343949795,
-0.5302186608,
-0.6770160198,
0.1336628199,
0.4605659842,
-0.433981657,
-0.0763782784,
-0.5891411304,
0.3152166009,
0.1349453181,
1.0335556269,
-0.4418259263,
0.0651234686,
0.2924716473,
-0.3565247655,
-0.7061880231,
-0.3694485128,
-0.5816516876,
-0.3353299797,
0.6320171356,
0.8246952891,
0.5486910343,
0.2841201127,
0.3447085321,
0.1278886199,
0.1617827564,
0.2682909966,
-0.6865136623,
-0.4262446463,
-0.47688061,
-0.9287370443,
-0.45228827,
-0.0953329876,
0.7098488212,
0.6988764405,
0.0758449212,
0.271340847,
0.3771748245,
0.515093565,
-0.8284711838,
0.0706048235,
-0.8825408816,
0.224925369,
-0.3365115821,
-0.3913154304,
-0.3874448538,
0.0583395734,
-0.1358915269,
-0.9183886647,
-0.3270097673,
0.3675114214,
0.4652861357,
0.3460332155,
-0.3097665906,
-0.3872436285,
-0.6525288224,
1.023794055,
-0.5624309182,
0.4564193487,
0.511695087,
-0.0161025804,
0.103679508,
-0.2449572384,
-0.3807787597,
-0.0618333146,
-0.2848000526,
0.158192426,
-0.2977602482,
-0.2375799268,
-0.0460489132,
0.0510582067,
-0.3040712178,
0.7916948795,
-0.343945682,
-0.1613653004,
0.3869132996,
0.0561344251,
0.2382211983,
0.1038337722,
-0.6791923046,
-0.1649569273,
-1.1224943399,
0.0453392006,
0.2925484776,
0.6057314277,
-0.557703197,
0.4172616303,
0.1867274642,
0.5378778577,
0.1359790713,
-0.4315649867,
0.0616073012,
-0.7594498992,
-0.1697036922,
0.3461608887,
0.4104499519,
0.2154537588,
0.502448976,
-0.1713781953,
-0.0314833932,
-0.1366372108,
-0.1501217633,
-0.5383993387,
0.1849232912,
-0.321297884,
-0.4002040327,
0.1856772453,
-0.6561553478,
-0.6524589658,
-0.4048702419,
-0.4986047745,
0.4251920581,
-0.3323389888,
-0.4173356593,
0.0237195976,
0.2570713758,
0.4522940516,
0.3692315221,
-1.2167412043,
0.4444757104,
0.5048766732,
0.9746202826,
-0.4731143415,
-0.6395516396,
-0.6618670821,
0.5289789438,
-0.598880887,
0.7208147645,
-0.4554688632,
-0.3813921511,
-0.0281182975,
0.1419922262,
-0.3503220379,
-0.6282288432,
0.1989803761,
-0.5060486794,
0.1131812111,
-0.3709703386,
0.1249871776,
-0.1944773495,
0.2279750407,
-0.4846057594,
0.9831228256,
0.2576678693,
-0.6543853879,
0.3726820052,
-0.6696487069,
-0.7334419489,
-0.1422222108,
0.1333675534,
0.1703068018,
0.0985846967,
0.1860725731,
0.3486234546,
-0.5652682781,
-0.3666850626,
-0.1997265816,
-0.5537733436,
0.0703922138,
-0.313662678,
0.9295998216,
0.1275344044,
-0.2574750483,
-0.0759562105,
-0.7255729437,
-0.0909919068,
-0.0076222746,
-0.6095901728,
-0.5537204146,
-0.3861147761,
0.176158756,
0.1788028628,
0.310205847,
-0.2465873063,
0.1288375258,
-0.3056292534,
0.2359340638,
0.7866168022,
-0.2996829152,
0.7417831421,
-0.1933168173,
0.7797247171,
0.2595196068,
0.0051712785,
0.2021616101,
-0.0208063573,
-1.18501544,
-0.3171435297,
0.2312725484,
0.9356373549,
-1.1173392534,
-0.2446799576,
-0.1444801092,
-0.2518123984,
-0.8356297612,
0.6888725758,
0.509901166,
0.3000580966,
0.4761651456,
-0.4396772981,
-0.5298626423,
-0.923208952,
-0.3113807738,
-0.3746165633,
0.0885721967,
0.0734407827,
0.2687143683,
-0.2148194909,
0.4331932664,
0.0515497848,
-0.4325935245,
-0.4441893101,
0.0089110518,
0.1922975034,
0.3017478287,
0.797657311,
-0.4263336062,
-0.674025476,
0.4918637574,
-0.4492488503,
-0.2855240405,
-0.2927048206,
-0.2453711927,
0.5870708227,
0.5716090798,
-0.1842454225,
0.0863748491,
0.9207023382,
0.0007419124,
0.30912292,
-0.318734169,
-0.1882663965,
-1.0431040525,
-0.2210998088,
-0.2779336274,
-0.1079665348,
-0.6588362455,
-0.1753054261,
0.0501892529,
0.2080367059,
-0.662905097,
0.841758728,
-0.7929349542,
-0.5759021044,
-0.3665068746,
0.1125008762,
-0.2138847709,
0.7344278097,
0.1296416968,
0.9521813393,
0.5534638166,
-0.5874985456,
-0.0201507434,
0.0671649352,
-0.3129217923,
0.7631514668,
-0.2869254947,
0.1608851254,
-0.018906692,
0.0489041135,
-0.7499344945,
0.1683327854,
0.5507664084,
0.1120725647,
0.4693593085,
-0.1597947627,
-0.4788003862,
0.2606144845,
-0.2668251395,
0.614467442,
0.1240131259,
-0.6680722833,
0.5097186565,
0.2733210027,
-0.4904439449,
-0.6084614396,
-1.0315496922,
0.2029503882,
-0.3334614038,
-0.1524439752,
0.4235116839,
-0.1251285672,
-0.3839847744,
0.0050003119,
0.172159642,
0.1174411997,
0.2426733226,
0.0455834307,
0.3380948007,
-0.385779649,
-0.1348637342,
0.0755996481,
-0.1047500521,
-0.205306828,
-0.2200790793,
0.379452467,
-0.3085305989,
-0.4740476012,
-0.1485636532,
0.2991360724,
0.5017592311,
-0.26560691,
0.5450360775,
0.9020972848,
-0.2633434236,
-0.2053862065,
-0.3318083286,
0.1991552114,
-0.4052708447,
0.5384213924,
-0.4300493598,
-0.9009783268,
0.4819715321,
-0.2327515483,
0.0083474685,
0.2107243985,
0.9224080443,
0.1762198657,
0.4487326145,
1.0573729277,
-0.3698222935,
0.5831236243,
0.0014073658,
0.4016647637,
-1.0521713495,
-0.1741079986,
-0.2371511459,
-0.4051455557,
-0.8673689961,
-0.674400866,
0.3482347131,
0.4026038349,
-0.1992349625,
0.5453695059,
0.1132420823,
0.24097161,
0.6009637713,
-0.2165707499,
0.3890425861,
0.2724663913,
-0.1062646583,
0.0655820295,
-1.0646092892,
-0.3586187065,
0.8397156,
0.29698506,
0.9997378588,
0.2999301255,
0.5152536035,
0.0129844639,
0.6183479428,
-0.606500864,
0.3945110738,
-0.3522814512,
-0.3320044577,
-0.2403582782,
0.0200541019,
-0.7095246315,
0.5179519653,
-0.2621981502,
-0.6744852662,
0.3912778497,
-0.1675795913,
-0.3985176384,
0.2920498848,
-0.7841281891,
0.5957579017,
-0.8363987207,
-0.6144050956,
-0.4613667428,
-0.4886324406,
0.4044440687,
-0.6495060921,
0.602825582,
-0.1861954033,
-0.3706875741,
0.6838629842,
0.1440716982,
1.1123367548,
0.0209964998,
-0.3631371856,
0.1817899644,
0.2485324591,
0.4769739509,
0.1094537303,
-0.0919299722,
0.3743308187,
0.0217104349,
-0.4404924214,
-0.2563784122,
0.595797956,
-1.069650054,
-0.7028771639,
-0.2776914239,
-0.988312602,
-0.4363239706,
0.1420960426,
-0.0606182665,
-0.1156065613,
0.0194890462,
-0.0759441257,
0.1568441391,
-0.4951225221,
0.6797608733,
0.8708407879,
-0.0620040037,
-0.316477567,
0.7605300546,
0.0939886123,
0.4377115369,
0.5110781789,
0.0250576474,
-0.1725388914,
-0.479242146,
-0.6984091997,
0.3706958592,
-0.7391018271,
-0.0731612369,
-0.274214983,
0.085271962,
-0.3195146918,
-0.3495800197,
-0.2416531742,
-0.3110835552,
-0.6804441214,
0.0342894718,
0.4051698744,
0.5270690918,
-0.41268152,
0.4246989191,
-0.6599807143,
0.3198549747,
0.2277718335,
0.2653764188,
-0.0838169158,
-0.9146619439,
-0.5452442169,
-0.0512605235,
0.1304895729,
-0.463424176,
0.2496433556,
0.4491052628,
0.5912460685,
0.0943102464,
-0.1267596036,
1.0526649952,
-0.5058342814,
0.4785300493,
0.3283888102,
-0.828320682,
0.1341251284,
0.0650913268,
0.1508228481,
0.5808925033,
0.4843294621,
-0.5637250543,
-0.0493688174,
0.0769996643,
-0.6032280922,
0.8834002018,
-0.2050640136,
0.1212233156,
0.3314702213,
0.0752927214,
0.2831292748,
-0.0818306506,
-0.8870990276,
0.090629071,
-0.2055167407,
0.081077449,
-0.2952476442,
-0.2982788682,
-0.2053766102,
-0.0911738425,
0.5650279522,
-0.4680595398,
-0.1543442458,
-0.1146285385,
-0.5414563417,
-0.224023968,
0.4616931081,
0.5326111317,
0.6409465075,
0.1077897549,
0.3061014116,
0.8375327587,
-0.2357867211,
0.2689451575,
0.086120069,
0.0970616415,
-0.2859666049,
0.8212498426,
1.013518095,
0.6272234917,
-0.5084255338,
0.0853218213,
0.2734776735,
0.1312076598,
-0.0771076083,
-0.0662338659,
0.2420108914,
0.4713763297,
0.2917239964,
-0.139763549,
-0.4212854207,
-0.8749614954,
-0.3002072871,
0.3392713964,
-0.1353725493,
-0.5228739977,
0.4930118322,
0.0888493806,
-0.1634338498,
0.2381308973,
-0.0431959406,
-0.4392291903,
0.3514882326,
0.9987428784,
0.5374211669,
-0.1358119696,
0.0608816557,
0.1099171489,
0.6245108843,
0.0175339878,
0.1695212871,
-0.027972158,
-0.8221102357,
-0.5492064953,
-0.6639231443,
-0.4824028909,
-0.0612170584,
-0.5523386002,
0.3782857358,
-0.4818524122,
0.2462973297,
-0.2349167466,
0.2270553112,
-0.8949706554,
-0.1300856769,
0.3178721964,
0.8421253562,
-0.9968679547,
0.9747699499,
0.7319449782,
-0.2914891839,
-0.6200399399,
-0.0779431015,
-0.1057446003,
-1.357506156,
0.9465348125,
-0.2338845134,
-0.3915885091,
0.0518038496,
-0.0907213315,
-1.1242529154,
1.1588212252,
0.6736117005,
-0.7614660859,
0.153895244,
0.4605611265,
0.600992322,
-0.4022443891,
0.0267722234,
0.6379085779,
0.5820356607,
-0.2857521474,
-1.2343740463,
0.1050283387,
0.0788281858,
0.0998432189,
-0.1768376529,
-0.8586645126,
0.8888326883,
-0.4049589634,
-0.1743980348,
-0.0578756444,
0.5536879301,
0.3554760814,
0.1117677838,
0.7476608753,
0.2099864334,
0.6869749427,
0.4108282924,
0.8819125295,
-0.448913753,
-0.1517366469,
1.1197965145,
-0.7969917059,
0.8814141154,
0.9139063954,
-0.2194924355,
0.4422337413,
0.7690688372,
0.2474758625,
0.6388319135,
0.1011579707,
-0.1217424795,
-0.1944944412,
-0.6902215481,
-0.3501658142,
0.7067379355,
0.4639923871,
0.1121471599,
-0.1986355186,
0.1799117625,
0.0756533965,
-0.2091520578,
-0.6060240865,
0.6552189589,
0.342721343,
-0.6698214412,
0.8687624335,
0.0377665237,
0.8282216787,
-0.4909059405,
0.0130351884,
-0.521225512,
0.2838038504,
-0.2241103947,
-0.6204765439,
0.2092893124,
0.204533726,
-0.0824733451,
-0.5160229206,
0.8552567959,
-0.7105734944,
-0.6939367056,
0.8323761225,
0.7151058912,
0.1760938168,
0.3114356697,
-0.4759247601,
0.2010203898,
-0.0771483704,
-0.0598666258,
0.6772897243,
0.5665374994,
-0.5368571281,
0.505095005,
0.6536741257,
0.3870967925,
0.1022900119,
0.0567698739,
0.787817657,
-0.3819797933,
-0.3520750999,
-0.6608276367,
-0.0258502569,
0.6236257553,
-0.2807142735,
0.6919465065,
0.3811256289,
1.3334583044,
-0.1018125862,
0.7040008307,
0.1066640839,
0.2202267647,
-0.7901873589,
0.4146545231,
-0.8196177483,
0.2089791298,
-0.1052887365,
-0.8807502389,
-0.1622109711,
0.3409360647,
-0.1479159147,
-0.3186015487,
0.5861071944,
0.860650599,
-0.0894818678,
-0.3688905537,
0.2554182708,
0.1138858423,
-0.0734420046,
0.8255598545,
0.88082093,
-0.2141219527,
0.7426415682,
-0.2556524277,
-0.115238376,
-0.3754463196,
-0.9898284674,
-0.7650116086,
-0.2608345449,
-0.0676963478,
0.0513462685,
0.0858909041,
0.9098178744,
0.6033050418,
-0.7845092416,
-0.5472614765,
0.4304933548,
0.2902613878,
-0.2574424744,
-0.1031143218,
0.2802271843,
-0.3321478367,
-0.6300248504,
0.7212839723,
0.4807999432,
0.0383211859,
-0.3320270777,
-0.2587133944,
-0.3296696842,
-0.2329734862,
0.835424602,
0.3859268725,
-0.761331439,
-0.3375566602,
-0.0120469909,
-0.147383526,
0.0651621073,
0.8205985427,
-0.5827971101,
0.0409598388,
0.1879150569,
0.8637108803,
0.4477539659,
-0.3226419985,
0.4184652567,
-0.6739872098,
0.6749229431,
-0.0429104045,
0.2958878279,
0.4653070569,
-0.2775452435,
0.6371928453,
0.1633950174,
0.0304130483,
-0.8022090793,
0.1474588215,
-0.8640853763,
-0.2947213948,
1.3392312527,
-0.0587415583,
-0.1651491821,
-0.1027557775,
-0.1358179301,
0.3803535104,
0.148472622,
0.4677263498,
0.6921651363,
-0.0963203982,
-0.2359031588,
-0.6365410089,
0.2613489926,
0.6939325929,
-0.8577930927,
0.0835819617,
0.0257756226,
0.3038678169,
0.1410287023,
0.7253141403,
0.0217243601,
0.1462067813,
-0.2098775953,
-0.0059012258,
0.06648992,
-0.4196451306,
-0.4886808693,
-0.2198542655,
0.3115713596,
-0.1776303798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17375v1
|
An Empirical Study on the Characteristics of Bias upon Context Length Variation for Bangla
| 2024-06-25T08:49:11 | 2024-06-25T08:49:11 |
Jayanta Sadhu, Ayan Antik Khan, Abhik Bhattacharjee, Rifat Shahriyar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pretrained language models inherently exhibit various social biases,
prompting a crucial examination of their social impact across various
linguistic contexts due to their widespread usage. Previous studies have
provided numerous methods for intrinsic bias measurements, predominantly
focused on high-resource languages. In this work, we aim to extend these
investigations to Bangla, a low-resource language. Specifically, in this study,
we (1) create a dataset for intrinsic gender bias measurement in Bangla, (2)
discuss necessary adaptations to apply existing bias measurement methods for
Bangla, and (3) examine the impact of context length variation on bias
measurement, a factor that has been overlooked in previous studies. Through our
experiments, we demonstrate a clear dependency of bias metrics on context
length, highlighting the need for nuanced considerations in Bangla bias
analysis. We consider our work as a stepping stone for bias measurement in the
Bangla Language and make all of our resources publicly available to support
future research.
|
[
-0.3282511234,
-0.8651457429,
0.3359962106,
0.6147141457,
-0.1035411358,
-0.1234412715,
-0.3065738082,
-0.4738914669,
0.0647557005,
0.1744624525,
-0.5294033289,
0.0481527783,
-0.6962637305,
0.1322720945,
-0.1760356277,
1.010858655,
-0.0350408815,
0.2012235522,
0.1135371849,
-0.2547949255,
-0.9604206085,
-0.2306272835,
0.1767880768,
-0.3520794809,
0.4999783635,
0.2865831852,
0.4502967596,
0.3774660528,
0.184022516,
0.1160556525,
-0.4029603601,
-0.0933966041,
-0.6216857433,
-0.066753909,
-0.4620696008,
-0.441095084,
-0.25089854,
0.147445932,
0.9725519419,
1.0820538998,
0.1900353134,
0.5199508071,
0.1595244557,
0.9670627117,
-1.1475590467,
-0.017340064,
-0.4795598686,
-0.0515849218,
-0.577360332,
-0.1498399526,
-0.1626288593,
-0.5936268568,
0.4142023325,
-0.0148321148,
0.1537642628,
-0.0539995432,
0.8104819059,
0.2510886192,
-0.6483259797,
-0.3310239613,
-0.6573272943,
1.0306252241,
-0.668356359,
0.4424353242,
0.5299865603,
0.3124579787,
0.1999579221,
0.0317696705,
-0.3181316853,
-0.0823384225,
-0.1717732102,
-0.3246331215,
0.3429247141,
-0.3751327395,
0.3820860088,
0.3606616557,
-0.0072293249,
-0.212721616,
-0.6491746902,
0.0975581184,
0.5955085754,
0.0959541574,
0.3086592555,
-0.3310441673,
0.0910083055,
0.1692985445,
-1.2019590139,
0.1947225481,
0.9661670923,
0.4987283647,
-0.5051289797,
0.3755820692,
-0.3353673816,
0.8669176102,
0.0578441434,
-0.1298754215,
0.2017858773,
-0.7264179587,
-0.0060423277,
0.3453555405,
0.3625826836,
0.0070775305,
0.0504904911,
0.0784042478,
0.1030192524,
-0.187335223,
0.1228372902,
-0.9279484749,
0.1933427751,
-0.2952051163,
-0.4517872036,
0.0239104815,
-0.1532395333,
-0.8480294943,
-0.5061064959,
-0.1365887076,
0.1354337186,
-0.2402329594,
-0.3335060775,
-0.1315485686,
0.0233047362,
0.477240026,
0.165609926,
-0.9953640103,
-0.0385503322,
0.3378267586,
0.8710598946,
-0.019824693,
-0.1770346165,
-0.2188079208,
-0.0613515936,
-0.5435610414,
0.4614934623,
-0.8545066714,
-0.6534426212,
0.0112842945,
-0.1620103717,
0.0489584208,
-0.2802477777,
0.5074961782,
-0.2133488357,
0.0543665588,
-0.7395557761,
-0.2372324467,
-0.1487564892,
-0.1701148152,
-0.3182361424,
0.6715111732,
0.2537824214,
-1.1861807108,
0.9431680441,
-0.5807450414,
-0.5812692642,
-0.0150960237,
-0.4838039875,
-0.1795524061,
0.2860990167,
0.1094091684,
0.0846259519,
-0.416367799,
0.2800208628,
-0.3265986741,
-0.749853611,
0.3572930098,
-0.5491420031,
0.9311834574,
0.1181574613,
-0.6553293467,
0.0120895263,
-0.7002435923,
-0.1559905857,
-0.0137784705,
-0.306966722,
-0.611784935,
0.0234499909,
0.1556038558,
0.0616251267,
0.3642189801,
-0.591789782,
0.0717522725,
-0.3949910402,
0.0958080217,
0.9516177773,
-0.2561553717,
0.6054568291,
-0.0015038201,
0.4172186553,
-0.2145088911,
0.0979970768,
-0.0377880409,
-0.1588872075,
-0.4709540606,
-0.3214077055,
0.518294394,
-0.0222048145,
-0.1317109913,
0.3530743718,
-0.2039028406,
-0.3154115677,
-0.794862926,
0.2088430077,
0.5906777978,
0.3180387318,
-0.060140878,
-0.3902718127,
-0.5763059258,
-1.2817559242,
-0.3730695844,
-0.1019052044,
0.0950963721,
0.6846553683,
0.5658246875,
-0.5429706573,
1.5080052614,
-0.4070084691,
-0.0315453447,
-0.2334839404,
0.0724298209,
0.3394275606,
0.3729809821,
0.7388840914,
-0.5468803644,
-0.4322009087,
-0.0075339163,
-0.6374287009,
-0.7271792293,
0.3123246431,
-0.3692251742,
0.1371052712,
0.0040558372,
-0.014294683,
0.7954372168,
0.621434629,
-0.6232967973,
0.8100616932,
0.1913537532,
0.1706214696,
-0.6249185801,
0.0813241005,
-0.0987081677,
0.0648642406,
-0.4641191363,
-0.2366536558,
0.0011023822,
0.4404810369,
-0.5768901706,
0.880710721,
-0.5082865953,
-0.4362277687,
-0.4742312431,
-0.2540459037,
-0.210427776,
0.1045210361,
0.0690810606,
1.0467456579,
0.278770268,
-0.6464695334,
-0.3160955012,
0.2387474328,
-0.586535275,
0.7030016184,
-0.8151894808,
0.0931564048,
-0.1145525202,
0.2940666676,
-0.741777122,
-0.4035545588,
0.1992232352,
-0.226638779,
0.2132771611,
-0.3495814502,
-0.1637845933,
-0.0185170788,
-0.1695857048,
0.7779103518,
0.4096685052,
-0.3429976106,
0.0907227248,
0.5172589421,
-0.0674843937,
-0.9183363914,
-0.6029725671,
-0.3690066934,
-0.3842314482,
-0.5537081957,
0.0456944704,
-0.2424184829,
-0.4534942508,
-0.3631081283,
-0.1621158868,
-0.179081291,
0.0805073529,
0.5232863426,
-0.0572459772,
-0.079396084,
-0.175587967,
0.3871883452,
0.4886955619,
0.0989716724,
0.1443687081,
0.7655467391,
-0.3949224949,
-0.2941047847,
-0.1855607927,
0.1650733799,
0.308747679,
0.1674457788,
0.9097284079,
0.5792770982,
-0.2860730886,
0.0191076882,
-0.6356744766,
-0.1767143309,
-0.4383586645,
0.3650249839,
-0.1782774329,
-0.9411239028,
0.6561472416,
0.1678088605,
-0.3215329051,
-0.0399916172,
0.7744525075,
0.2696097195,
0.6871436238,
0.8174292445,
0.0112265022,
0.5755540133,
0.1945652515,
0.3105171621,
-1.2517958879,
0.062556237,
-0.4508045018,
-0.2047430426,
-0.66679883,
-0.0703493878,
0.141306743,
0.0745312646,
-0.4376648068,
-0.1350620836,
-0.0584872738,
0.4908826947,
0.3875466585,
0.1542121172,
-0.2103034258,
-0.3327580988,
0.258762449,
-0.3181784451,
-0.5007624626,
-0.6374390125,
1.2046494484,
0.3927408457,
0.7732102871,
0.1068942323,
0.4530744851,
0.4434265792,
0.1952183694,
-0.1700073332,
0.3005410731,
0.4686677754,
-1.1840318441,
-0.5213744044,
-0.4123533666,
-0.866376698,
0.2625644803,
0.1473192871,
-0.7064961195,
0.4124980271,
0.2337088883,
-0.0992563441,
-0.0497528538,
-0.6816443801,
0.7397298217,
-0.1939032972,
-0.8981449604,
0.1393375695,
-0.6731584668,
0.6340712309,
-0.3154955208,
0.2003747225,
-0.3709045649,
0.3589969277,
0.8757675886,
-0.3601459563,
0.9739368558,
-0.2763005495,
-0.3003456891,
0.2262477428,
-0.0625381842,
0.0847478583,
0.2603233755,
0.0167267546,
0.4606475234,
-0.1276276261,
-0.9104710221,
-0.1540815532,
0.5488182902,
-0.8149454594,
-0.3907335401,
-0.4856263697,
-0.7907202244,
-0.3256922662,
0.2332824767,
0.2600361705,
0.1355963945,
-0.3051100671,
0.3419074118,
0.3898698092,
-0.6168322563,
0.4833353758,
0.5590830445,
-0.2766378224,
0.3838184476,
0.4458816946,
0.4517299533,
0.187757045,
0.021568954,
0.5364993811,
-0.2703532577,
-0.1029724404,
-0.4270427525,
0.0740903988,
-0.5107467175,
0.2467953712,
-0.5613666773,
0.018499326,
-0.6226270199,
-0.3931039274,
-0.5755574107,
-0.1117124856,
0.1641079038,
-0.0939552188,
0.1754198074,
0.8619707227,
-0.0565637425,
0.5611802936,
-0.279956311,
-0.0706005916,
0.4699960649,
0.3048392236,
0.1845385134,
-0.8206970692,
-0.3355798721,
0.1735127866,
-0.0935288742,
-1.0045518875,
0.3814609051,
0.0392129943,
0.3495178819,
0.4736636877,
-0.0271174572,
0.3360564113,
-0.5173648596,
0.9110805988,
0.0384274982,
-1.1643589735,
0.881513834,
-0.6890787482,
0.4026380777,
0.6682645082,
0.2585495412,
-0.2331297994,
-0.0481166281,
-0.3003697693,
-0.953201592,
0.7289070487,
0.4106537998,
0.2481018752,
-0.0249211509,
0.1725055575,
0.522436142,
0.4724392593,
-0.7730560899,
-0.4817264676,
-0.164928928,
0.2394225299,
0.1776313782,
-0.6516480446,
-0.04882586,
-0.355961144,
0.5450782776,
0.0264374223,
0.2729604244,
-0.09639474,
-0.4939473271,
0.1282593906,
0.6425010562,
0.7630453706,
1.3839159012,
-0.5901203156,
0.0017022754,
0.3108905256,
-0.701567173,
0.3466269076,
-0.2266757488,
-0.5425521135,
0.0551529564,
0.3004133701,
0.8870710731,
0.0413065031,
-0.6686344743,
0.4823506773,
0.1272773892,
0.3994591832,
-0.1705940813,
-0.1704447567,
-0.1702802032,
-0.0077448045,
0.4709858894,
-0.149592638,
0.2480318844,
-0.5767670274,
-0.021744905,
0.1612295359,
-0.759232223,
-0.4968897104,
0.3149623275,
0.3031217158,
-0.0474420115,
0.1798721999,
-0.444019109,
-0.4462149739,
0.4221267998,
0.6209920645,
0.6468928456,
-0.4529954493,
0.1483583897,
0.2988706231,
0.5451618433,
0.1677035242,
0.1402023435,
-0.0570099913,
-0.6004324555,
-0.4163116515,
-0.8755455613,
-0.1859727055,
-0.0933014005,
-0.6109011173,
0.0985320285,
-0.3548002541,
-0.1566605419,
-0.3517606556,
-0.0800752044,
-0.7453655005,
0.1843680292,
-0.0879091769,
0.2528654039,
-0.9795746207,
0.5143504143,
0.546487093,
-0.3753921688,
-0.4161767364,
0.0725574195,
-0.0261593014,
-0.7153137326,
1.2909010649,
0.3831276298,
-0.2051190585,
-0.6345875859,
-0.4802805781,
-0.8343605399,
0.5879241824,
0.4148964286,
-0.4309809208,
0.1957069188,
0.2175423205,
0.4224774241,
-0.2799229622,
0.5716814995,
0.8886147738,
0.5119654536,
-0.4523158371,
-0.9392512441,
-0.0009103401,
-0.2036386877,
0.2399293035,
-0.059928406,
-0.6462490559,
0.9118943214,
0.0665711015,
-0.051317133,
-0.4907702804,
0.6944286227,
0.2968483567,
0.4542760849,
0.3008544743,
0.0799029917,
0.6316607594,
-0.0327892564,
1.0770697594,
-0.3447841406,
0.1455287635,
1.1617805958,
-0.6894109845,
0.2308432013,
0.4770228565,
-0.4225122035,
0.4368381202,
0.6548753977,
0.6296910048,
0.4561113119,
0.4864259958,
-0.2350554317,
0.1190004051,
-0.6768069863,
-0.8099252582,
0.3672222197,
0.2799220979,
-0.2363017648,
0.2978075147,
-0.0563543774,
0.3070835173,
0.0934558362,
-0.3257217109,
0.2114883214,
0.0790942386,
-0.378960222,
0.4204576612,
-0.1829074621,
1.1443521976,
-0.6058132648,
0.2602195442,
-0.4617238641,
0.0634003803,
-0.1844927222,
-0.4322807789,
0.3925830424,
0.1285998076,
-0.4328956902,
0.1104453579,
0.6191510558,
-0.2271782756,
-0.448931694,
0.2554336488,
0.4987513721,
-0.0185373891,
0.0399906449,
-0.1492797732,
0.3867920041,
-0.0507400446,
-0.0128194084,
0.4984571934,
0.2884036899,
-0.1483668238,
0.4817216694,
0.3701060414,
0.2912734747,
0.5736286044,
0.028302649,
0.4193368852,
-0.5565505028,
-0.6623704433,
-0.9288577437,
0.0590068139,
-0.2336736917,
-0.5431735516,
1.0377362967,
0.4145519137,
0.908377111,
-0.0893428698,
0.9519008398,
-0.1738505363,
0.4805350006,
-0.3661461473,
0.8734770417,
-0.4283903837,
0.2062066495,
-0.825525105,
-1.3212150335,
0.286812067,
0.915384233,
-0.7034432888,
0.2800867558,
0.584982872,
0.4655553401,
0.0209370442,
-0.051154051,
0.0984254479,
0.0936917737,
0.1699901074,
0.1920593828,
0.9858311415,
-0.356937021,
0.0035467916,
-0.0327532738,
-0.4481277764,
-0.4111086726,
-0.9566619992,
-1.0680702925,
-0.5009924173,
-0.272839129,
-0.1773722321,
0.4390270412,
0.8550893664,
1.0512231588,
-0.5260028839,
-0.5425044298,
0.2896108925,
0.4148586392,
0.0746648461,
-0.2305539697,
0.3499415517,
-0.1765985042,
-0.6510977149,
0.2067281157,
0.1995240748,
-0.2692717314,
-0.3404602706,
-0.1765412539,
-0.458545953,
0.4383393824,
0.6793217063,
0.3105613291,
-0.601346612,
-0.4737499058,
-0.3013051152,
-0.0750038102,
-0.0424282104,
0.7556139231,
-0.2373984456,
0.442832768,
0.7912403941,
0.6499560475,
0.3274911046,
-0.0992129445,
0.6835153699,
-1.1762733459,
0.5003723502,
-0.0674915612,
0.4883205891,
0.4688811898,
-0.246519044,
0.7683824301,
0.2010737807,
-0.592264533,
-1.1392315626,
0.4301693141,
-0.7016985416,
-0.277495265,
1.4629867077,
0.1112775132,
-0.2161225826,
-0.0981796607,
-0.3636805713,
0.1769025922,
-0.4439733028,
0.9693772793,
0.8918138146,
0.180359304,
0.1073262691,
-0.5627593398,
0.3661161959,
0.4658345282,
-0.4794175625,
0.0806988329,
0.5372581482,
0.1068769693,
0.2152609378,
0.7952702045,
-0.0743682534,
0.1340987086,
-0.0591069907,
0.1418608576,
0.2898229361,
-0.169568643,
-0.1832002401,
-0.1239585355,
-0.1748854667,
0.1978957951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17363v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17363v2
|
Leveraging Synthetic Audio Data for End-to-End Low-Resource Speech Translation
| 2024-06-25T08:26:41 | 2024-06-27T09:08:03 |
Yasmin Moslem
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This paper describes our system submission to the International Conference on
Spoken Language Translation (IWSLT 2024) for Irish-to-English speech
translation. We built end-to-end systems based on Whisper, and employed a
number of data augmentation techniques, such as speech back-translation and
noise augmentation. We investigate the effect of using synthetic audio data and
discuss several methods for enriching signal diversity.
|
[
-0.3048842251,
-0.499674499,
0.1880719811,
0.3851032555,
-0.2966699004,
0.6604106426,
-0.1240398064,
-0.8938575387,
0.5228815675,
0.4594975114,
-0.7965094447,
-0.4415133297,
-0.5743902326,
0.3421916366,
-0.9124583006,
0.80556494,
0.2178833634,
0.2367954552,
0.1813649833,
-0.298933804,
-0.3349920511,
-0.5227071047,
-0.6001835465,
-0.2277464271,
0.1778331101,
0.6165030599,
0.5304774046,
0.28958413,
0.3859908283,
0.1825951189,
-0.0837062672,
0.3347615898,
-0.568182826,
0.0495763943,
-0.3048444986,
-0.3819279969,
-0.5422160625,
-0.003436856,
0.8096598387,
0.7792022228,
0.0078917891,
0.3738137484,
-0.0628177971,
0.3940214813,
-0.3141867518,
0.0044225981,
-0.792630136,
0.1604246795,
-0.3887958527,
-0.4651589692,
-0.3910910487,
0.0629813001,
0.1489459574,
-0.6442022324,
0.1254014671,
0.3469131291,
0.4008350372,
0.4559919536,
-0.473113656,
-0.2556236982,
-1.0113745928,
0.8265744448,
-0.837218225,
0.7479639053,
0.3022396266,
0.1303568482,
-0.3585985005,
-0.9746784568,
-0.7081359625,
0.0170843285,
0.1111038253,
0.5930140018,
-0.4014670551,
0.2494549453,
0.0023844242,
0.4396992326,
-0.535954833,
0.1612903774,
-1.0425177813,
-0.297352016,
0.9096889496,
0.0224890299,
0.4033687413,
0.1595763415,
-0.2778761685,
-0.1649151742,
-0.6126558781,
-0.1011247635,
0.882932663,
0.49961555,
-0.3321936727,
0.7251243591,
-0.5551367998,
0.6206868887,
-0.2056834996,
-0.3199016452,
0.4379497766,
-0.6279462576,
0.1875240207,
0.7969970107,
0.6100506186,
0.5291736126,
-0.0706846416,
-0.2362557203,
-0.3196389973,
0.0781071708,
-0.0712066069,
-0.558706522,
0.2052865028,
0.2385509163,
-0.3221821487,
-0.2513367236,
-0.2473939508,
-0.665135026,
0.4062997103,
-0.437011987,
0.4733373225,
-0.2893460393,
-0.1464899182,
0.2863636315,
-0.4423530996,
0.2855718136,
0.1903063655,
-0.6823783517,
0.7158549428,
0.3528954685,
1.003133893,
-0.490236938,
-0.0503063463,
-0.7893657684,
0.3721760213,
-0.4761297405,
0.6455677748,
-0.2443403602,
-0.7776172161,
-0.1429589838,
-0.0796465874,
0.3219256103,
-0.7460276484,
1.0048302412,
-0.0905840695,
0.3257097006,
0.1909588724,
-0.4273901582,
0.1159278899,
-0.2693242729,
-0.4695772827,
0.8855381608,
0.119263649,
-0.2704116702,
0.0680350289,
-0.641207099,
-0.6912062764,
0.0553647354,
0.0700164214,
-0.1885443777,
0.2214819044,
0.2011330873,
-0.0364749581,
-0.2345982194,
-0.0167067982,
0.1065235659,
-0.3505425751,
0.3341554403,
-0.7805893421,
0.6570438743,
0.5908663273,
-0.050732892,
-0.0808125809,
-0.928681314,
-0.0430200659,
-0.1569769233,
-0.3131036758,
-0.0149046415,
-0.0418253951,
0.4259630442,
0.0888198093,
0.1576619893,
-1.0160775185,
-0.1564394832,
-0.5578010082,
0.77211833,
0.3594298661,
-0.1811217517,
0.3703097701,
-0.320543468,
0.5606268644,
-0.0156405158,
0.0620380268,
-0.2506899238,
-0.8890277147,
-0.3880150914,
-0.1726439297,
0.3269497156,
0.8844056726,
-0.4592685699,
0.1767884046,
-0.2260749489,
-0.2316813767,
-1.1256783009,
-0.0039042521,
0.1125184745,
0.6191021204,
0.6780448556,
-0.2510530651,
-0.8919414878,
-1.0227799416,
-0.0828161165,
-0.3356667161,
-0.0165738426,
-0.0122735715,
0.0147821587,
-0.3843285739,
0.8635860085,
-0.2043012232,
-0.3980374634,
-0.1113426685,
-0.00199835,
0.2311237454,
0.7657737732,
0.3401899934,
-0.7282396555,
-0.3524628878,
0.2290440351,
-0.3762645125,
-0.3827876449,
-0.035631597,
-0.0817454159,
-0.1229063123,
0.6712451577,
-0.4926130176,
0.5477175117,
0.9353995919,
-0.095547609,
0.4767200053,
0.100111641,
0.3406181335,
-1.0388598442,
-0.2755199671,
-0.3754190207,
-0.4856157005,
-0.7709594369,
-0.0696526021,
-0.2629189789,
-0.3204402328,
-0.5344215035,
0.6875040531,
-0.1941264272,
-0.29323259,
-0.1577105224,
0.1002907082,
-0.0097873621,
0.1217910051,
-0.0303106997,
1.3145009279,
0.1784865707,
-0.1916213036,
0.4957158864,
0.5912736058,
-0.2032396942,
0.5475046635,
-0.508159101,
0.1863969713,
0.1177282035,
0.309723556,
-1.1712939739,
-0.3539477885,
-0.0579755306,
-0.9753195047,
0.1747840792,
-0.1762520671,
-0.3513423204,
-0.1247528419,
-0.0255487096,
0.3916608393,
0.7889074087,
-0.6569823623,
0.117463991,
0.4699879289,
-0.4320755601,
-0.1418873966,
-0.9926298857,
0.6605085135,
-0.1920180321,
-0.75993222,
0.8610035777,
-0.2647278309,
-0.3717519939,
-0.0210544933,
0.0031242201,
-0.0090239076,
-0.3021619618,
-0.0866094381,
0.0144515866,
-0.2510024309,
0.0004967474,
0.3907486796,
-0.0373806842,
-0.0320314504,
-0.854806006,
0.3922459483,
0.1530749649,
-0.380613029,
-0.4523124099,
1.0075581074,
0.4840954244,
0.0513645485,
0.3549856544,
0.6193453074,
-0.2295847684,
-0.2126787305,
-0.4692781866,
-0.2651075423,
-0.4798514247,
0.2983592153,
-0.2292225212,
-0.8431084156,
0.6129317284,
-0.3565360308,
0.0508324578,
0.3676368296,
0.4106850326,
-0.5530951023,
1.3408731222,
0.3951326609,
0.1652041376,
0.4202022851,
-0.1972375214,
0.3361252248,
-0.9512763619,
-0.0847400129,
-0.35043782,
-0.535728097,
-0.7872160673,
-0.2944036722,
0.4733451009,
0.0763481334,
0.3021467924,
0.326426357,
-0.6868184209,
0.0365048982,
0.6529567242,
-0.0150372256,
0.5702329874,
0.2223244756,
0.1702709198,
-0.1796994209,
-0.5592724681,
-0.2042377144,
0.9056902528,
0.3256835639,
0.614911139,
0.1212504059,
0.7005670071,
0.4467177093,
-0.1820294708,
-0.7586784959,
0.360873431,
-0.3002402484,
-0.4861036539,
-0.4310925603,
-0.1464866251,
-0.7468321323,
0.0929856673,
-0.1132151559,
-0.4718812704,
0.3642722666,
0.0184675734,
0.0722042695,
0.1533623636,
-0.7064760923,
0.017588092,
-0.095063895,
-0.0551331602,
-0.2449627668,
-0.4776097834,
0.1754069328,
-0.2113562673,
0.4121024907,
-0.0010899031,
-0.1132938564,
0.8389844298,
-0.4646270573,
0.6080849767,
0.1056244895,
-0.2801781297,
0.4562212229,
-0.228196919,
0.6536998153,
0.0633104965,
-0.1719646752,
0.3832547963,
0.0671439692,
-0.4103933871,
-0.4496233165,
0.4583572149,
-0.876783967,
-0.5588787198,
-0.0863090828,
-0.5520093441,
-0.4794721603,
-0.0933360755,
0.6811908484,
0.5632580519,
-0.0766286626,
0.3286027312,
0.407004416,
-0.1737537086,
0.3776982725,
0.4339184463,
-0.2367231548,
-0.794439733,
1.004852891,
0.495627284,
0.6261649728,
0.1513293982,
0.0756192207,
-0.3829488158,
-0.9406826496,
-0.7157754898,
-0.0526980795,
-0.562687993,
-0.0995386392,
-0.7764389515,
-0.5159261227,
-0.6257286668,
-0.3538667858,
-0.5537645817,
-0.8747302294,
-0.194893837,
-0.4181456268,
0.582428813,
0.5557277799,
-0.3836425543,
0.8313981295,
-0.6998488307,
0.3449910581,
0.1085925102,
-0.0447827764,
-0.6392367482,
-0.7944633961,
-0.4585955441,
0.1926555634,
-0.0032075495,
-0.8858748674,
0.8117179275,
0.516332984,
0.6662144065,
-0.2247402966,
0.2033996284,
0.7845350504,
-0.5617516041,
0.9247900248,
0.445145756,
-0.8959271908,
0.6700094938,
-0.4100652933,
0.3533465564,
0.3068300784,
-0.045748353,
-0.5468985438,
-0.6077848673,
-0.4947447479,
-0.9481081367,
0.3837001622,
0.3889550865,
0.3044182956,
0.1658580452,
0.1538014412,
0.2431728989,
0.2109401375,
-0.1484015137,
-0.1451231688,
-0.2721337974,
-0.3094525635,
0.0004991138,
0.1077897921,
-0.0595349707,
-0.3187454641,
0.6128963232,
-0.2800419927,
0.281598419,
0.4936645329,
0.0505760238,
-0.3063721657,
0.3577890694,
0.5100396872,
0.2320396751,
-0.1280955672,
-0.1362073123,
0.611879468,
-0.7747180462,
0.253775537,
-0.0178477895,
-0.3670940399,
0.2255341262,
0.6983708739,
0.8864697814,
0.1126303747,
-0.6709729433,
0.2515978515,
0.0340399779,
-0.4638553858,
-0.4596260488,
-0.0365876593,
0.0419458821,
0.1622937322,
0.628954649,
0.1214323416,
0.6081628799,
-0.7890190482,
0.4071822464,
0.2411186993,
-0.5496988893,
-0.4921234548,
0.7886904478,
0.365639478,
-0.4793884456,
0.4371315837,
0.1207517534,
-0.15977332,
0.2040432096,
0.8633958101,
0.9616572857,
-0.365444988,
-0.0845603943,
0.1788215637,
0.266290158,
0.2833064198,
0.6088292599,
-0.1565872133,
-0.2323765457,
-0.9425271749,
-0.7890717983,
-0.6752536297,
0.0876689628,
-0.7347437739,
0.3490294814,
-0.0306773558,
-0.3594821692,
-0.2885783017,
-0.2420474887,
-0.6330232024,
0.205473125,
0.1451360285,
0.9879125357,
-0.6248406768,
0.849285841,
0.3742837906,
-0.0653686374,
-0.4345666766,
-0.1412971616,
0.0127022201,
-0.6443703175,
0.6987281442,
-0.4176094234,
-0.4961484075,
0.4028538167,
-0.8450959921,
-1.0979510546,
0.8497502208,
0.453702122,
-0.7765880227,
0.0147478217,
0.6499058604,
0.4528951943,
-0.2441984266,
-0.004771133,
0.5783743858,
0.4840607345,
0.4436248243,
-1.3517781496,
-0.6388209462,
-0.2736962736,
-0.2957640886,
-0.1644259095,
-0.5234928727,
0.71832937,
0.0285119452,
-0.2348894477,
0.0084870458,
0.8293678761,
0.0743273348,
0.2783929408,
0.3574151993,
0.3164128661,
0.5187997222,
-0.0303206909,
0.6222648025,
-0.2405822873,
-0.1978263855,
1.0687304735,
-0.1235703379,
0.9109555483,
0.7280282378,
-0.2889862359,
0.0329168998,
0.4458468258,
0.5440970659,
0.6869062185,
0.0035062204,
-0.5271465778,
0.0225155167,
-0.5503853559,
-0.4580739439,
0.7124405503,
0.8490390778,
0.0411199108,
-0.0228879564,
0.3887245953,
-0.5691731572,
0.0743100345,
-0.0551067032,
0.9753338695,
0.3389574289,
-0.4016510248,
0.5814780593,
-0.228202194,
0.8920016885,
-0.5720870495,
-0.3213659525,
-0.195193857,
-0.1134409457,
-0.3592538834,
-1.1119010448,
0.5611569285,
-0.0855687782,
-0.1218823045,
-0.3595939279,
0.5630153418,
-0.6021875143,
-0.3799459636,
0.6547329426,
0.4063160717,
0.2024106979,
0.3137365878,
-0.2461018711,
0.3787750006,
0.1608778834,
0.0352992043,
0.277997911,
0.3207785189,
-0.1856258512,
0.5051912665,
1.1179182529,
0.7028192878,
0.5317081809,
0.0379141606,
0.655202508,
-0.5031785369,
-0.8345990777,
-0.4483774006,
0.5319479704,
-0.1333090514,
-0.2988066673,
0.5836905837,
0.702747345,
1.0831604004,
0.2007470727,
1.1124942303,
0.339059025,
0.7774766684,
-0.5870164633,
0.2536501884,
-0.3504532576,
0.0313803256,
-0.0496907309,
-0.8332694173,
0.0429642573,
0.2009646297,
0.0656615347,
-0.6353027821,
0.1980936676,
0.7958342433,
-0.1788147092,
0.3273784816,
0.7211574316,
0.0977414399,
0.4734224975,
-0.0030673211,
0.888635695,
-0.6970341206,
0.6391878724,
-0.1956247687,
-0.1187263802,
-0.254709512,
-0.5005594492,
-0.1410140842,
-0.9620599747,
-0.2618957758,
-0.3022977412,
0.2942759693,
0.8902409673,
1.0028712749,
-0.9252206087,
-0.3507215679,
0.1111588478,
-0.3675562143,
-0.09251035,
-0.1516246796,
0.0151039502,
-0.2598606944,
-1.0120278597,
1.2075244188,
0.515640676,
0.2490144074,
-0.3399251103,
-0.3535203934,
0.0253415629,
0.3173208237,
0.9001743793,
0.237117216,
-0.7865694761,
-0.2979032397,
0.0347979739,
0.2483197749,
0.1374506056,
0.4848382175,
-0.901184082,
0.5197560191,
0.5517949462,
0.5205765367,
0.728757441,
-0.0868396461,
0.8712074757,
-0.8894553781,
0.5706440806,
0.3802422881,
0.2663111687,
0.4317930043,
-0.5443036556,
0.6452538371,
0.2024628371,
-0.457901299,
-1.0632833242,
0.1121622249,
-1.0788565874,
0.1020669937,
1.0161170959,
0.3614042401,
-0.0282715596,
-0.3558305204,
-0.4899345636,
0.4249639213,
-0.5594184399,
0.1838758737,
0.4941071272,
-0.3603060544,
-0.1920714378,
-1.0817430019,
0.4669464529,
0.0931201354,
-0.5788644552,
-0.226618275,
0.2345791906,
-0.0465678908,
0.2885003686,
0.5629931688,
-0.2130899429,
0.0444824062,
0.1575107276,
-0.283428818,
0.1469042003,
-0.066000469,
-0.056187585,
-0.2861388624,
-0.1187691838,
-0.3653858304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17328v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17328v1
|
Dual-Space Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-25T07:25:15 | 2024-06-25T07:25:15 |
Songming Zhang, Xue Zhang, Zengkui Sun, Yufeng Chen, Jinan Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge distillation (KD) is known as a promising solution to compress
large language models (LLMs) via transferring their knowledge to smaller
models. During this process, white-box KD methods usually minimize the distance
between the output distributions of the two models so that more knowledge can
be transferred. However, in the current white-box KD framework, the output
distributions are from the respective output spaces of the two models, using
their own prediction heads. We argue that the space discrepancy will lead to
low similarity between the teacher model and the student model on both
representation and distribution levels. Furthermore, this discrepancy also
hinders the KD process between models with different vocabularies, which is
common for current LLMs. To address these issues, we propose a dual-space
knowledge distillation (DSKD) framework that unifies the output spaces of the
two models for KD. On the basis of DSKD, we further develop a cross-model
attention mechanism, which can automatically align the representations of the
two models with different vocabularies. Thus, our framework is not only
compatible with various distance functions for KD (e.g., KL divergence) like
the current framework, but also supports KD between any two LLMs regardless of
their vocabularies. Experiments on task-agnostic instruction-following
benchmarks show that DSKD significantly outperforms the current white-box KD
framework with various distance functions, and also surpasses existing KD
methods for LLMs with different vocabularies.
|
[
-0.4094466865,
-0.6288223267,
0.884226203,
-0.0382891744,
-0.2995305657,
0.2856823802,
-0.469204396,
-0.138753891,
-0.062647976,
0.2667281032,
-0.4930406511,
-0.5560665131,
-0.8903970718,
-0.3838897049,
-0.2961044014,
0.7249740362,
-0.114655219,
0.0411501899,
-0.6660028696,
-0.1402436644,
-0.5743018389,
-0.5237135291,
-0.3382670879,
-0.4717447162,
0.4836908281,
0.2862278223,
0.550265789,
0.42782709,
0.3549730778,
0.2441469282,
-0.2070184052,
0.0101386821,
-0.3726204038,
0.2313875705,
-0.2804305553,
-0.376526475,
0.075389728,
-0.246165365,
0.4968080223,
0.9522017241,
-0.2257519364,
0.0847876817,
0.4642646313,
0.8973388672,
-0.7711760402,
0.2206044346,
-0.305261761,
0.2322363853,
0.0223107561,
0.1631061882,
-0.2130947113,
-0.2379962355,
0.3205491602,
-0.4786965847,
0.138474524,
-0.3832528591,
0.5142861605,
0.6493394375,
-0.6825042963,
-0.3484765887,
-1.0154027939,
0.6501301527,
-0.6858999133,
0.6604080796,
0.1177464947,
0.6225653291,
0.0347000137,
-0.5209487677,
-0.721008122,
-0.0824211463,
-0.1301705688,
-0.0481758229,
-0.0675139874,
-0.0887091309,
0.2948701978,
0.2893123031,
-0.3469142914,
0.1967244744,
-0.5540559292,
0.0731368363,
0.3863208592,
-0.0792724788,
0.0704826191,
0.1142400205,
-0.4964975417,
-0.4330887794,
-0.6730624437,
0.0010610464,
0.2761439085,
0.1872920841,
-0.0571762584,
0.3888662755,
-0.3325046301,
0.4877496362,
0.2194630057,
-0.3011189699,
0.104675971,
-0.1976359785,
-0.1677305251,
0.0585865043,
0.6799767613,
0.5108968616,
0.170587793,
-0.2213394493,
0.1344948113,
0.315749526,
0.1138604954,
-0.7330623865,
-0.5515671372,
-0.0068242108,
-0.3024505675,
-0.2272824943,
-0.1670541167,
-0.8317788243,
-0.502609551,
-0.5264649391,
0.3457498848,
-0.2307548374,
-0.4637842774,
0.114304468,
-0.0540650971,
-0.3124747574,
0.1654809713,
-0.9151457548,
0.421430558,
0.5168663859,
0.7324736118,
-0.3249571621,
-0.2001606077,
-0.1800701469,
0.2858849466,
-0.0824635699,
0.5829457641,
-0.5303409696,
-0.3142365217,
-0.0956457108,
-0.2461528927,
0.1445531547,
-0.645378828,
0.0969214216,
-0.5772585273,
-0.0166659132,
-0.4815366864,
-0.6420099735,
-0.2667355239,
0.0924626142,
-0.5881320834,
1.1667832136,
0.1591587812,
-0.710398674,
0.594547987,
-0.5494385958,
-0.3680085838,
-0.0383401476,
-0.3191042542,
-0.2166613936,
0.0995430723,
0.2262149304,
0.5709996819,
-0.2452709526,
0.3417999446,
-0.7061814666,
-0.0554372631,
0.019364275,
-0.3519470394,
0.6740109324,
0.2327711135,
-0.1813557446,
-0.341986835,
-0.6767755151,
0.0156208901,
0.0463741086,
-0.3437585831,
-0.9084991813,
-0.0748220459,
-0.1850186288,
0.466599822,
0.374453485,
-0.3805745542,
0.3689188957,
-0.2129526883,
0.3228851557,
0.7205438018,
-0.0115669277,
0.7572541833,
-0.0087670144,
0.5327607393,
0.4416763186,
-0.2713475823,
0.1726350635,
-0.1605997533,
-0.4280642569,
-0.2236893177,
0.212690711,
0.2399144769,
-0.7643402815,
0.3898366392,
-0.3260390162,
-0.4948947728,
-0.5347149372,
0.3270942271,
0.4035848081,
0.432169944,
0.2333596796,
0.0282405335,
-0.3397155702,
-0.8592559099,
-0.0732768551,
-0.1051453799,
0.104482241,
0.2057676017,
0.3323723376,
-0.0794281065,
0.8796738982,
-0.9346948862,
-0.3732782304,
-0.0544174425,
-0.1937193722,
0.0575794727,
0.2594790459,
0.7251141667,
-0.8625760078,
-1.0110268593,
0.1933936775,
-0.4713905454,
-0.307552278,
0.2864377797,
-0.2534029484,
0.181901738,
0.6788643003,
-0.703181386,
0.3629341722,
0.5616058111,
-0.37576738,
0.4630683362,
-0.1849751472,
0.2308980823,
-1.4352738857,
-0.0349565893,
-0.0490201302,
-0.154562667,
-0.4425070882,
0.0630519465,
0.1896804273,
0.1117906794,
-0.2617101073,
0.6128757596,
-0.3623923063,
-0.1626915783,
-0.382517457,
0.3223874867,
0.0706221312,
0.5811350942,
0.2548251152,
0.3982555568,
0.6196457148,
-0.6102114916,
0.6242086291,
0.0356577225,
-0.4480265081,
0.6540964842,
-0.4433063567,
0.0159813594,
-0.0730451122,
0.1966992915,
-1.3459224701,
0.0919241682,
0.0562947243,
-0.2202619016,
0.3481458426,
-0.194683373,
-0.4905542135,
-0.5605323315,
-0.1215583533,
0.5821965933,
0.8143973947,
-0.7038386464,
0.2050392777,
0.3389948308,
-0.3374908864,
-0.7052220702,
-0.7286928892,
-0.2777641416,
-0.3799518645,
-0.6099557877,
0.2379951626,
-0.2281393707,
-0.2120262086,
0.3968756199,
-0.3680585921,
-0.1237939447,
-0.069115825,
0.1404721886,
0.2144681066,
-0.218885079,
0.321551919,
0.3983502686,
0.1197949499,
0.0017076172,
-0.5550079346,
0.475456357,
0.4869330823,
-0.5282475948,
-0.2450680286,
0.369408071,
0.8158524036,
0.1258694679,
0.8735558391,
0.4798018336,
-0.3655053377,
-0.5261823535,
-0.566570878,
-0.2827101648,
-0.4725039005,
0.6483644247,
-0.4481843114,
-0.8970855474,
0.4818380773,
-0.2097448409,
-0.0296202209,
0.212847501,
0.6930634379,
-0.0368383601,
0.8624759316,
0.9127512574,
-0.1437713653,
0.3207647204,
-0.2599214017,
0.4662656486,
-0.8296154737,
-0.1892821938,
-0.4727229476,
-0.6641656756,
-0.1620645374,
-0.4723634422,
0.3631095886,
0.3573036194,
0.1474058181,
0.279872328,
-0.5638594031,
0.6668077111,
0.5842379928,
-0.374679327,
0.3170264661,
0.2768597901,
-0.4413692057,
-0.3210446537,
-0.7372917533,
-0.2723897398,
1.1920657158,
0.1537305862,
0.7768951058,
0.1634667367,
0.9374526739,
0.2090276927,
0.0996592715,
-0.5596488118,
0.3963711858,
-0.4382485449,
-0.288095355,
-0.310089469,
-0.4936265647,
-0.628262043,
0.5426614881,
0.2653882802,
-0.8503770828,
0.1418718249,
0.1248485595,
-0.4868758619,
0.3713465333,
-1.0983035564,
0.8995380402,
0.121939756,
-0.1708222479,
-0.3201722205,
-0.4178721011,
0.5915991664,
-0.2187274545,
0.2148204595,
-0.0539800152,
0.1999116093,
0.6678285003,
-0.4581787288,
0.7194792032,
-0.5461059213,
-0.4664371908,
0.103194423,
0.1722928137,
0.3104884624,
0.0687153935,
0.2989076972,
-0.0158278607,
0.4954691827,
-0.1153768152,
-0.851893425,
1.0060235262,
-0.8800509572,
-0.6664828062,
-0.2019073069,
-0.7946726084,
-0.2579752207,
0.161847651,
0.0995112509,
0.1548036337,
0.0373270474,
0.1826897711,
0.6430683136,
-0.0793655887,
0.3015687764,
0.6202740073,
-0.2597295642,
-0.0490190499,
0.5809680223,
0.3086443543,
0.5751575232,
0.4215940833,
0.1015340984,
-0.7289195657,
-0.2614805996,
-0.2900592685,
0.0383993797,
-0.9033640623,
-0.1898468584,
-0.6641937494,
-0.2825636864,
-0.7248653769,
-0.165724948,
-0.5997519493,
-0.468285948,
-0.0686857849,
-0.0376096219,
0.2111864537,
0.6602409482,
-0.0171671491,
-0.0295839161,
-0.6526151896,
0.568246603,
0.4314605892,
0.2861976624,
0.2999742329,
-0.5496842265,
-0.2705686986,
0.3760308027,
-0.4160515368,
-0.6736493111,
0.2585280538,
0.0402713567,
0.3217316568,
0.3634343445,
0.3654149175,
0.8359671831,
-0.5720621943,
0.6135177612,
0.4700986743,
-0.6426923871,
0.3121588826,
0.169521004,
0.6520313025,
0.3669851422,
0.3271328211,
-0.8597186804,
-0.6026601195,
-0.3800885081,
-0.6739920378,
0.9675076008,
-0.1979895383,
0.003379059,
0.2684900761,
0.1414219588,
0.4079988301,
0.1406972408,
-0.6966584325,
-0.3163778782,
0.1762859523,
-0.4866888821,
-0.0500654727,
-0.1116824299,
-0.0379157849,
-0.1174647436,
0.661080122,
-0.0004388632,
-0.0044355504,
-0.0473998189,
-0.0573100038,
-0.1837394685,
0.1996455491,
0.2416541576,
0.5684392452,
0.1008638814,
0.4344153702,
0.0860709101,
-0.6486495137,
0.4988106787,
0.1301717609,
-0.0060113552,
-0.1132840738,
0.1211172491,
0.5778918266,
0.1502010971,
-0.4888069928,
0.4267288148,
0.055837132,
-0.3102493584,
-0.0275017172,
0.1118636429,
0.6002465487,
0.6850751638,
0.2426409423,
0.1651463956,
0.0692468807,
-0.3322297931,
0.1069827825,
0.3166629374,
-0.087801151,
-0.2863075137,
0.6625526547,
-0.0181317888,
-0.0441483408,
0.3874293864,
-0.3693005145,
-0.4483596087,
0.6690403819,
0.4113380611,
0.84343189,
-0.2288050056,
0.2378933877,
0.2265616506,
-0.1038096696,
-0.1622059643,
0.0315201692,
-0.5095515251,
-0.7491173148,
-0.4081433117,
-0.8251650929,
0.1277860403,
0.3131095767,
-0.6857008934,
0.3445005715,
-0.2331195921,
-0.0081355972,
0.2350221872,
0.1415382922,
-0.5903164744,
-0.2233058959,
0.367040813,
0.4924117327,
-0.9039703012,
1.1489661932,
0.7367075086,
-0.0078883572,
-0.7313424349,
0.0951775759,
0.0374156833,
-0.4750273824,
0.9407132864,
-0.1138460934,
-0.0967429951,
-0.1558808833,
-0.0808994249,
-0.9592146277,
1.3112404346,
0.5223501921,
-1.1411842108,
-0.0832796395,
0.2135874033,
0.572840333,
-0.2517977059,
-0.2955550551,
0.529609859,
0.2151633501,
0.40740183,
-0.9431068897,
0.0369563997,
-0.0168852434,
0.2446326464,
0.4341376722,
-0.5859856606,
0.6585903764,
-0.2322579622,
-0.4208569229,
-0.196366936,
0.4426421523,
0.3401904106,
0.2879189551,
0.492944628,
0.931861341,
0.6073565483,
0.0172037724,
0.5835061073,
-0.323579222,
0.5510199666,
1.221061945,
-0.667634964,
0.6604699492,
0.8514276743,
-0.6319180131,
0.2643310726,
0.2259602249,
0.063567102,
1.0183376074,
0.1317117363,
-0.1685930043,
0.0688146651,
0.2430854291,
-0.4525338113,
-0.0140134357,
0.1568319798,
-0.1433411539,
-0.4613541365,
0.2177299112,
-0.1926840544,
0.4303316474,
-0.0181213599,
0.8056976199,
0.2022897303,
-0.8643875122,
0.6438031793,
0.0371938497,
0.5928009748,
-0.5213759542,
0.0019784158,
-0.1441173702,
0.495005995,
0.092382215,
-0.7361762524,
0.3426429033,
-0.103054449,
-0.5198715329,
-0.2824151516,
0.6882269382,
-1.0885626078,
-0.4236221611,
0.5475359559,
0.3746272624,
-0.074976027,
0.1120332256,
-0.4894411862,
0.1054438278,
0.1004491746,
-0.1036786363,
0.5468482971,
0.7038910985,
0.0475677401,
0.5085389018,
0.4420805573,
0.2211035043,
0.3028473854,
0.0369909592,
0.8789997101,
-0.1904804409,
-0.8562222123,
-1.0194090605,
0.2903779447,
-0.0329162925,
-0.0255568512,
0.6618980169,
0.3227078617,
1.0431417227,
-0.3099293709,
0.9183756709,
-0.2357255667,
0.6043275595,
-0.5301080942,
0.7733627558,
-0.6442825794,
0.3484878242,
-0.2351559848,
-1.3628306389,
0.0645335168,
0.4138035178,
-0.3719044328,
0.0388023667,
0.8904469609,
0.7895026803,
-0.4135279953,
-0.314614594,
0.492624253,
0.2085464597,
0.258312881,
0.9405024052,
0.8481450081,
-0.2200786471,
0.5643229485,
-0.4765175879,
0.0279749129,
-0.1730989516,
-0.5951539278,
-1.0274759531,
-1.0030920506,
-0.6376463771,
-0.0178092327,
-0.0785188451,
0.5392186642,
0.8746368289,
-0.5482634306,
-0.0296581965,
-0.0963706151,
0.1542128921,
-0.2723590434,
-0.3018538356,
0.5298147798,
-0.2508326173,
-0.873886764,
0.0081700198,
0.2918066084,
0.0425851718,
-0.5186860561,
-0.2718590498,
-0.2045117021,
-0.0889870152,
0.3918782771,
-0.0460671186,
-0.8279325962,
-0.2162937373,
-0.2312146574,
-0.2071535438,
-0.2362811267,
0.643460989,
-0.8109208345,
0.355493784,
0.4334399998,
0.6798560023,
0.5694133639,
-0.3130240738,
0.4777688086,
-1.1373250484,
0.334825635,
0.0031740617,
0.094932735,
0.2174584419,
-0.4863420725,
0.2142252028,
0.1571549922,
-0.4304492176,
-0.9597691894,
0.2718383968,
-0.6472862959,
-0.5171965361,
1.2621605396,
-0.3248461187,
-0.0856860802,
0.1166925132,
-0.2430856526,
0.3274944723,
-0.3221666515,
0.9938530922,
1.2507591248,
0.3151876926,
-0.0472818799,
-0.5155739784,
0.6021556854,
0.4196766019,
-0.492318064,
0.4185951352,
0.4741601646,
0.5044966936,
0.2749204934,
0.5106689334,
-0.0979309082,
0.2907051742,
0.0201521702,
0.1379187703,
-0.1012261286,
-0.3625144064,
-0.2820950449,
0.1155237779,
-0.0867900327,
-0.2007655352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00087v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00087v1
|
ARES: Alternating Reinforcement Learning and Supervised Fine-Tuning for Enhanced Multi-Modal Chain-of-Thought Reasoning Through Diverse AI Feedback
| 2024-06-25T07:20:11 | 2024-06-25T07:20:11 |
Ju-Seung Byun, Jiyun Chun, Jihyung Kil, Andrew Perrault
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) excel at comprehending human instructions and
demonstrate remarkable results across a broad spectrum of tasks. Reinforcement
Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) and AI Feedback (RLAIF) further refine LLMs
by aligning them with specific preferences. These methods primarily use
ranking-based feedback for entire generations. With advanced AI models
(Teacher), such as GPT-4 and Claude 3 Opus, we can request various types of
detailed feedback that are expensive for humans to provide. We propose a
two-stage algorithm ARES that Alternates REinforcement Learning (RL) and
Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT). First, we request the Teacher to score how much
each sentence contributes to solving the problem in a Chain-of-Thought (CoT).
This sentence-level feedback allows us to consider individual valuable
segments, providing more granular rewards for the RL procedure. Second, we ask
the Teacher to correct the wrong reasoning after the RL stage. The RL procedure
requires massive efforts for hyperparameter tuning and often generates errors
like repetitive words and incomplete sentences. With the correction feedback,
we stabilize the RL fine-tuned model through SFT. We conduct experiments on
multi-model dataset ScienceQA and A-OKVQA to demonstrate the effectiveness of
our proposal. ARES rationale reasoning achieves around 70% win rate against
baseline models judged by GPT-4o. Additionally, we observe that the improved
rationale reasoning leads to a 2.5% increase in inference answer accuracy on
average for the multi-modal datasets.
|
[
-0.6942693591,
-1.1449296474,
0.7140746117,
-0.0677006096,
-0.1717002094,
0.1136119291,
-0.29441154,
-0.3034332991,
-0.0621761605,
0.5495904088,
-0.8722526431,
-0.2967412472,
-0.5409696102,
0.135400787,
-0.0227031428,
1.0349968672,
-0.1439857334,
0.1828666031,
0.2099937052,
-0.2961250246,
-0.4685800374,
-0.2618620396,
-1.0506323576,
-0.3123716712,
0.6512222886,
0.770216465,
0.5276107788,
0.6124541759,
0.2196602076,
0.3474294543,
0.1901325583,
0.9539045095,
-0.1910540015,
0.3604183197,
-0.5008555055,
-0.353286624,
-0.4138754308,
0.0725141615,
0.372189343,
0.3142876625,
-0.2934756279,
0.0035862159,
0.0384229571,
0.8815643787,
-0.698965013,
0.0032710757,
-0.5496647358,
0.0130553255,
0.0623348877,
-0.5023364425,
-0.6976989508,
-0.2354264259,
-0.0660598502,
-0.855441153,
-0.1132772267,
0.4701147377,
0.6535310745,
0.6627812982,
-0.5972470641,
-0.3938058019,
-0.9587792158,
0.8053085804,
-0.4981234372,
0.5303203464,
0.486833185,
0.3334055841,
-0.1164311767,
-0.6490468979,
-0.5774036646,
-0.4714427292,
0.2921684682,
0.2732600272,
-0.0952111185,
0.4013181627,
0.1909926236,
0.1717138439,
-0.1024149507,
0.0168371554,
-0.3848388195,
0.0429133587,
0.6140982509,
0.2090086639,
-0.1588724554,
0.2091702521,
-0.4425929785,
-0.2964887023,
-0.5168978572,
0.2704307735,
0.359716326,
0.2174943686,
0.1980848014,
0.5485889316,
-0.4498516619,
0.6475361586,
0.5180625916,
0.0513924435,
-0.0284785125,
-0.2412577569,
-0.2978783548,
-0.2483662516,
0.5981720686,
0.134965688,
0.0725972354,
-0.0471036099,
-0.4236938655,
0.1161591932,
0.5023869276,
-0.3595984876,
-0.2502560914,
-0.0466607735,
-0.413983345,
-0.202249065,
-0.0250467509,
-0.5413148403,
-0.4450372458,
-0.7391244769,
0.9164091349,
-0.5313263535,
0.2078755349,
0.0830370933,
0.0180135146,
-0.233487606,
0.621363163,
-0.8165866137,
0.4403090477,
0.4281488359,
0.3505177796,
0.1065030172,
-0.5324452519,
-0.8817790747,
-0.0042135282,
-0.3860529363,
0.9244346023,
-0.6416142583,
0.1313825995,
-0.3881063163,
-0.2008415908,
-0.1472920626,
-0.266883105,
0.6610338688,
-0.6586461663,
0.3594400883,
-0.3059370816,
-0.5329976082,
-0.529065311,
0.4121548533,
-0.4024800956,
1.0042587519,
-0.1603272557,
-0.4378534257,
0.4340261817,
-0.637134254,
-0.2610273659,
-0.4448536038,
-0.1369156241,
-0.361923784,
0.0492593087,
0.8024182916,
0.3345595002,
-0.2431640178,
0.2510514259,
-0.4306284487,
-0.4325230122,
0.2662328482,
-0.7844413519,
0.0330432057,
0.3312076926,
-0.5690524578,
0.7772942185,
-0.6409198642,
0.0777308568,
-0.3547011018,
-0.3556636274,
-0.1696122587,
0.2599891126,
-0.0561615713,
0.4210479856,
-0.1746254265,
-0.2484763861,
0.3783698976,
-0.2250940651,
0.4025073051,
1.038543582,
0.2014915347,
0.3466916978,
-0.5938435793,
0.5663794279,
-0.1284393072,
0.3018565476,
-0.1211971492,
-0.3950922489,
-1.0135647058,
-0.3011132479,
0.2424578816,
0.4123363495,
-0.8222792745,
0.280418992,
0.1997844875,
-0.1656175852,
-0.7676491737,
0.1302701682,
0.4392439127,
0.4164425731,
0.6929811239,
-0.263582617,
-0.6130117178,
-0.9768430591,
-0.1499105841,
0.0144153219,
0.2698256075,
0.5993908048,
0.5249227285,
-0.2211828679,
0.6384465098,
-0.2207823396,
-0.2064496428,
-0.2242281437,
0.4439228773,
-0.1473832577,
0.2839069366,
-0.013855055,
-0.4726849496,
-0.1995948106,
-0.0243439116,
-0.3609829843,
0.038592618,
-0.3310850859,
-0.1116108745,
0.065582931,
0.4146799445,
-0.3659724891,
0.1527094543,
0.3731291294,
-0.3878341615,
0.4897612631,
-0.424392134,
0.560736239,
-0.8451185226,
-0.0762225166,
-0.0764417127,
-0.3573882878,
-0.1102833077,
0.2342575938,
-0.0080643129,
0.137093246,
-0.1423741132,
0.4210252166,
-0.2187580615,
-0.0638935864,
-0.538097322,
0.0386595204,
-0.0932843685,
0.9426817894,
-0.0657369196,
0.9738458991,
0.3648710251,
-0.7695302367,
0.4509153664,
0.0371890739,
-0.1847064048,
0.4277923405,
-0.4747537374,
0.2277574688,
-0.1006498784,
0.715295136,
-0.7452999353,
-0.2516679466,
0.3173091412,
-0.3164787889,
0.0156436134,
0.1070504338,
-0.2330172211,
-0.2138054669,
-0.3300452828,
0.3293403089,
0.2090934515,
-0.6316255331,
0.6400194168,
0.1306391805,
-0.0196511894,
-0.7643216252,
-0.1574242711,
-0.1407892853,
-0.0963132828,
-0.4165926874,
0.1457001418,
0.0062921406,
-0.1122489944,
0.2160713673,
-0.2957445979,
0.0528829321,
0.0752431154,
0.2235446274,
0.1011725366,
-0.058035735,
0.3438268304,
0.4217574298,
-0.1448888183,
-0.2355931997,
-0.4620174468,
0.457038939,
-0.3868134618,
-0.5631790757,
-0.6234361529,
0.2300246209,
0.7223728895,
-0.364582777,
0.5070083141,
0.6542547941,
-0.153498143,
-0.4957203269,
-0.5044822693,
-0.5551548004,
-0.4152683318,
0.3098588288,
-0.4284968078,
-0.9291512966,
0.3039673865,
-0.3048456609,
0.1446810216,
0.4531188607,
0.6695203185,
-0.2583525777,
1.4446792603,
0.498028636,
0.0661815628,
0.5477634668,
-0.3611858785,
-0.015972117,
-0.9223396182,
-0.274900645,
-0.1231905073,
-0.5904280543,
-0.3805075288,
-0.3672312498,
0.6187972426,
0.2507788837,
-0.5443435311,
-0.1035619006,
-0.3535489738,
0.4480932653,
0.8548734188,
0.5107155442,
0.3458218277,
-0.2097492963,
-0.4379402995,
0.2655599117,
-0.6609580517,
-0.3296721578,
1.2479739189,
0.389988035,
0.8353040814,
-0.0058560208,
0.608087182,
0.4958710968,
0.2357505858,
-0.6900935769,
0.3425512612,
0.0723643303,
-0.6819181442,
-0.3657236099,
-0.2970406711,
-0.7277787328,
0.5196312666,
-0.510039866,
-0.4490669072,
-0.0032691204,
0.4006515443,
-0.6590077281,
0.2182556242,
-0.5047292113,
0.536429882,
-0.2682579756,
-0.6083153486,
-0.9312987328,
-0.7019612789,
0.4991789758,
0.2222010791,
0.2867262661,
0.0667664185,
0.0904259384,
0.6080721021,
-0.4218302965,
0.6860833764,
0.0163900293,
0.1794214696,
0.1211105734,
-0.1619723886,
0.7709578872,
0.3788637519,
0.1739366055,
-0.5227172971,
-0.2520534396,
-0.2879882455,
-0.7599598765,
0.6857447028,
-0.9694728851,
-0.5484165549,
-0.4768793583,
-0.6933966875,
-0.5728241801,
-0.0545636788,
0.1921226382,
0.5205734968,
0.1889520735,
0.1132265255,
0.6945712566,
-0.0153030744,
0.1057889611,
0.5163328052,
-0.1431400329,
-0.8095139265,
0.6816093922,
-0.3868704736,
0.1449154168,
0.3049470484,
0.0316154175,
-0.3535120785,
-0.4312227666,
-0.7563100457,
-0.0623524487,
-0.5756896138,
-0.1909861565,
-0.521609962,
0.0718558729,
0.0888517797,
-0.1524268687,
-0.5264790058,
-0.5577763915,
0.108240962,
-0.0950252786,
0.3058783412,
0.7667660713,
-0.2577230334,
0.1707008332,
-0.6504489183,
0.516667068,
0.5834760666,
0.2370803505,
0.1175429076,
-0.4408913553,
-0.25426507,
0.211338982,
-0.7058649659,
-0.9046439528,
0.0592468269,
0.2046720237,
0.4388207197,
0.4376283288,
-0.0955967009,
0.8741675615,
-0.4416404366,
0.4734465182,
0.0391257107,
-0.9352660775,
0.6541234255,
-0.2402350903,
0.0011772278,
0.6600763798,
0.0070732585,
-0.4625626206,
-0.5328634977,
-0.5502699018,
-0.9006583095,
1.0030853748,
0.1259120405,
-0.2625996172,
0.0947062001,
0.3101696372,
0.2334040403,
0.1171559915,
-0.6273614168,
-0.2960770726,
0.0493144169,
-0.1623572707,
-0.0486592427,
0.137098074,
-0.3712333143,
-0.4871632457,
1.0313317776,
-0.1007509232,
0.0900786966,
0.2906610072,
-0.0251221135,
-0.3591242135,
0.6504491568,
0.8148959279,
0.4364362955,
-0.1461973488,
0.2220147252,
0.3889869153,
-0.0817347765,
0.3504263461,
0.2177089155,
-0.0490861237,
-0.4674576819,
0.3186890483,
1.1696962118,
0.392123431,
-0.6092962623,
0.1351950169,
-0.1108706221,
-0.2145823687,
-0.1648266315,
0.3237766623,
-0.2147441506,
0.6565189362,
0.3390569985,
0.8037393093,
0.2664992809,
-0.6437184811,
0.4313176274,
0.334428817,
-0.4259009957,
-0.1944523007,
0.7836230993,
0.3978530765,
-0.1042575017,
0.5523017645,
-0.1856432408,
-0.4191373289,
0.4657866061,
0.3973015249,
0.7832311392,
-0.0510572903,
0.2692315578,
0.2948388755,
0.2343756855,
-0.4253090024,
0.3314117789,
-0.4115996063,
-0.6609783173,
-0.6271358132,
-0.3846475184,
-0.5703219175,
0.2339551002,
-0.6662532687,
0.1710940897,
-0.560893476,
-0.1957402229,
-0.1171906888,
0.1146426126,
-0.4774755239,
0.2738898695,
0.1784531772,
0.6132414341,
-0.8823773265,
0.8953174353,
0.9847721457,
-0.5048162341,
-1.1092904806,
0.0671449825,
0.033544682,
-0.6382950544,
0.4156502485,
-0.0327314548,
-0.3736362159,
0.1029364839,
-0.337326318,
-0.8242515326,
1.0498554707,
0.1046881229,
-0.6047595143,
0.0313876867,
-0.5347386599,
0.4605378211,
-0.3132816851,
0.549249053,
0.394506216,
0.5089972019,
0.0131378658,
-0.9412884116,
-0.1287728101,
-0.2092003077,
-0.3171390593,
0.3438914716,
-0.6004177928,
0.8323675394,
-0.4456997514,
0.1089664847,
-0.0428351872,
0.6644024253,
0.7040671706,
0.5482688546,
0.6689819694,
0.8264540434,
0.8133198023,
0.1478781551,
0.926525414,
-0.2256887257,
0.3307070732,
1.0611701012,
0.0862496346,
0.8754915595,
0.4783023596,
-0.0160810277,
0.5458893776,
0.6593924761,
0.1510569006,
0.7902460098,
-0.0766823143,
-0.245971635,
-0.6068268418,
0.1729360223,
-0.2789434195,
0.3830632865,
0.4139873385,
-0.3398923278,
-0.1608883291,
0.3009048402,
-0.2929656506,
0.1688099653,
-0.3387463689,
0.6715986729,
-0.0494501814,
-1.04294312,
0.3709325194,
0.3859145641,
0.6324855089,
-0.4722673893,
-0.156510219,
-0.1903340667,
0.533236146,
-0.0468671322,
-0.4541144073,
0.0269411486,
-0.0642764419,
-0.2552921176,
-0.2179543972,
0.3150915802,
-0.4772413075,
-0.2742560804,
-0.0032987082,
0.4670059681,
-0.3240932524,
0.1211374402,
-0.7873279452,
-0.0755445808,
-0.0019972499,
-0.4389252365,
0.1525139958,
0.3671269119,
-0.2799053788,
0.9068450332,
0.6776812673,
-0.0306528695,
0.0248577297,
0.0665361062,
0.9616224766,
-0.5048184395,
-0.5762357712,
-0.6484383941,
0.3755366802,
0.087600328,
-0.6790140867,
0.5120544434,
0.4463756084,
0.628744185,
0.0128147835,
0.6870207191,
0.0372898169,
0.3780122399,
-0.826772213,
0.2727974653,
-0.721945107,
0.4376435578,
-0.0628416687,
-0.7685704231,
-0.0242933705,
0.7347313762,
-0.2770283818,
0.0655583814,
0.898960948,
0.5733665228,
-0.3154100776,
0.177842468,
0.0460740849,
0.1305426955,
0.2432068139,
0.7151378393,
1.0947577953,
-0.4360625148,
0.3823437691,
-0.2340758145,
-0.2432938665,
-0.2075711191,
-0.3018468618,
-0.6796796322,
-0.6353865862,
-0.1056524813,
-0.153312102,
0.4504925907,
1.2654947042,
0.8230358958,
-0.8833167553,
0.006017535,
-0.5336261988,
0.1307746917,
-0.7586076856,
-0.1869660467,
0.2992845774,
-0.6909383535,
-0.5985228419,
0.7415921688,
0.2349620461,
-0.5243467689,
-0.0864648819,
-0.458956629,
-0.2432547957,
0.4421586394,
0.48649472,
0.129272759,
-1.1186025143,
-0.4291291535,
0.0131305698,
-0.0708139166,
-0.2033559829,
0.8279205561,
-0.9724504948,
0.4673933983,
0.3332355618,
0.4472058117,
0.6255714297,
0.2491867244,
0.5864952207,
-0.6384167671,
0.0659118444,
0.3615654409,
0.2822208405,
-0.1325252205,
-0.1487693936,
0.3084334135,
0.0543247685,
-0.8029819727,
-0.5753091574,
0.4742101431,
-1.0101357698,
-0.4523491859,
1.0256102085,
0.0632856637,
0.2813459039,
-0.1192138493,
-0.637394309,
0.3609950542,
-0.6880752444,
1.0250953436,
0.6454952955,
-0.6343933344,
-0.4630264044,
-0.4578033388,
0.5836306214,
0.756980598,
-0.8190360069,
-0.17664361,
0.7704036236,
0.1588021666,
-0.1884865016,
0.5762239099,
0.2100630999,
0.5886613131,
-0.1188510954,
-0.095494464,
-0.4611238539,
-0.704680264,
-0.2920052111,
0.1938000172,
0.198419407,
-0.3201732934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17324v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17324v1
|
Delving into the Utilisation of ChatGPT in Scientific Publications in Astronomy
| 2024-06-25T07:15:10 | 2024-06-25T07:15:10 |
Simone Astarita, Sandor Kruk, Jan Reerink, Pablo Gómez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, astro-ph.IM, cs.DL
|
Rapid progress in the capabilities of machine learning approaches in natural
language processing has culminated in the rise of large language models over
the last two years. Recent works have shown unprecedented adoption of these for
academic writing, especially in some fields, but their pervasiveness in
astronomy has not been studied sufficiently. To remedy this, we extract words
that ChatGPT uses more often than humans when generating academic text and
search a total of 1 million articles for them. This way, we assess the
frequency of word occurrence in published works in astronomy tracked by the
NASA Astrophysics Data System since 2000. We then perform a statistical
analysis of the occurrences. We identify a list of words favoured by ChatGPT
and find a statistically significant increase for these words against a control
group in 2024, which matches the trend in other disciplines. These results
suggest a widespread adoption of these models in the writing of astronomy
papers. We encourage organisations, publishers, and researchers to work
together to identify ethical and pragmatic guidelines to maximise the benefits
of these systems while maintaining scientific rigour.
|
[
-0.2780776322,
-0.5243905187,
0.4851318598,
0.2993209064,
-0.3010266423,
0.0080370838,
-0.2261927724,
-0.7749962211,
0.0765085295,
0.6579829454,
-0.2900322676,
-0.3417975903,
-0.9611102343,
0.4101521969,
-0.6496400833,
1.076338172,
0.0327830277,
0.0215203054,
-0.1684769541,
0.194466725,
-0.1541856378,
-0.3914265931,
-0.3919262588,
-0.2013512701,
0.715144217,
0.2041271925,
0.6452852488,
0.4998450279,
1.1691203117,
0.2288249433,
-0.2819467485,
0.3532634974,
-0.5467197299,
-0.1233793423,
0.1465237141,
-0.4065857232,
-0.1524726003,
0.1922868192,
0.697722733,
0.7824422717,
-0.2374278009,
-0.0095867943,
0.1684880257,
0.5360547304,
-0.4013828337,
0.6669746041,
-0.6691605449,
0.0302440468,
-0.5389134884,
-0.2561508417,
-0.3654725254,
-0.4046934247,
0.3375477195,
-0.9392846823,
0.0870705396,
0.288623184,
0.7194590569,
0.0337159298,
-0.0627532303,
-0.9021062255,
-0.5583802462,
0.7615907788,
-0.3996048868,
0.406770438,
0.374796927,
0.0285859574,
-0.3720093668,
-1.0444381237,
-0.5890477896,
-0.6270756125,
-0.1206709892,
0.1947470307,
-0.2085058987,
0.0396355726,
0.0852651373,
0.1096742973,
-0.6716620326,
-0.2122336328,
-0.6546801925,
0.0117232408,
0.3297666311,
0.0001640088,
0.1691272557,
-0.2822771072,
-0.0147833899,
-0.1345020682,
-0.7924546599,
-0.2422230989,
0.3049890399,
0.2868576348,
0.3931643069,
0.9150743484,
0.177399382,
0.4612933397,
-0.2627380192,
0.3773647845,
-0.2707812786,
-0.4375918806,
-0.0480731688,
-0.1514476389,
0.9350941777,
0.272511065,
0.2822961807,
-0.2993224263,
0.3118103743,
0.4418307841,
0.3680720329,
-0.6047692299,
-0.5182179809,
-0.1199944615,
-0.0132398447,
-0.2832511067,
0.0596476458,
-0.6347184777,
-0.5041639209,
-0.1850367486,
0.0047492702,
-0.5611649156,
0.020000821,
0.2863012552,
-0.3293413222,
0.1086784527,
0.0787867755,
-0.861884892,
0.081678018,
1.0715596676,
0.834143579,
0.2405478209,
-0.3261486292,
0.0182881653,
-0.1058821082,
-0.5070655942,
0.9958869815,
-0.8412929773,
-0.9048985243,
-0.1504070759,
-0.0344051234,
-0.2215262055,
-0.3333177567,
0.8481310606,
-0.5551921725,
0.5446747541,
-0.251842618,
-0.6496690512,
-0.429577291,
-0.1553970426,
-0.3046447039,
1.0624289513,
-0.1260520965,
-0.6171022654,
0.9565458298,
-0.9717193842,
-0.0387276448,
0.3975857496,
0.0836288631,
-0.5939939618,
-0.0141096525,
0.067694515,
0.3260591626,
0.0122790728,
0.162464276,
-0.0924322531,
-0.152757898,
0.2963873148,
-0.19550699,
0.2470914871,
0.6323595643,
0.0850887224,
-0.4004798532,
-0.4466655254,
-0.2166359276,
-0.1772236377,
-0.2208887339,
-0.5094763041,
0.483646065,
0.3257678449,
-0.2984254658,
0.1398545653,
-0.6992701292,
0.3114858568,
-0.5001831055,
0.5149060488,
0.1838217378,
0.0588169917,
0.3205443919,
-0.3341374993,
0.2083636522,
-0.2216319591,
-0.0517362766,
-0.0750980228,
-0.7179474831,
-0.4175032377,
-0.2235454917,
0.0609476827,
0.2243285626,
-0.1456495821,
0.2344845235,
-0.0506653637,
-1.0295505524,
-0.5451691151,
0.046174515,
0.2024898231,
0.3459441066,
0.0864505321,
-0.2001852095,
-0.5934385061,
-0.509215951,
-0.6564585567,
-0.1599975824,
0.1165348738,
0.5579572916,
0.6017959118,
-0.3505128026,
0.890427053,
-0.4201016724,
0.0676992759,
0.2384942025,
0.6556817889,
0.2057601064,
0.1933307499,
0.2012332678,
-1.0155018568,
-0.5336051583,
0.2754086554,
-0.855097115,
-0.1601373851,
0.0316181555,
-0.1832068264,
0.059827283,
0.3849692643,
-0.5352271795,
0.1571618319,
0.4284341931,
-0.5517639518,
0.4922061861,
-0.0838950649,
0.2263770103,
-0.8507892489,
0.47974509,
0.2678674161,
-0.1520242095,
-0.3894434571,
0.1353464276,
-0.0003309451,
-0.1387607455,
-0.1474560797,
0.2535327077,
-0.5781609416,
0.1387688369,
-0.3999023438,
0.3986581564,
-0.1781751961,
-0.3273438811,
0.1829954088,
0.8866578341,
0.4142632484,
-0.543223381,
0.1902686059,
0.5555714369,
-0.4747262895,
0.2349379063,
-0.5423311591,
-0.0823579133,
-0.4996903837,
0.246775791,
-0.9430828094,
-0.2590413988,
0.1286713481,
-0.4463684857,
0.0874007568,
-0.2119752616,
-0.317440927,
-0.4171341956,
0.199206844,
-0.2221155465,
0.3979061544,
-0.2418686897,
0.2475496083,
0.5661866665,
-0.3770347834,
-0.5727718472,
-0.2454193234,
0.4847798645,
-0.4088762403,
-0.6779395342,
0.0630699098,
0.1486947984,
-0.3892487884,
0.0461514741,
0.0193030685,
0.2842724621,
0.0937239602,
0.2635826766,
0.3062331378,
-0.0723701715,
0.148563534,
-0.6680744886,
-0.1712235361,
0.0352346711,
-0.4664030671,
0.6426512599,
-0.1770200133,
-0.0585917197,
-0.1436802,
0.3454551995,
0.4260909557,
-0.0176406838,
0.5779749751,
0.6479498744,
-0.0313676409,
0.0665167719,
-0.4570173323,
-0.3217941225,
-0.4365572631,
0.6142704487,
0.2254656553,
-0.7621418834,
0.324496448,
0.0293480866,
0.4968771636,
0.5096195936,
0.3798254132,
-0.3495993316,
0.6655912399,
0.6818969846,
-0.0065722661,
0.5335586071,
-0.1896605045,
0.2515655756,
-0.6667978764,
-0.1628660113,
-0.8804463148,
0.1723121107,
-0.9475907683,
-0.4706771076,
0.4975055456,
-0.1943410635,
0.0785292983,
0.5460379124,
-0.8352416158,
0.5843408704,
0.3458022773,
-0.1801392138,
0.4120608866,
0.0625694171,
0.3224001527,
-0.1732793748,
-0.4347825348,
-0.8176281452,
1.1508882046,
0.0747478977,
0.803987205,
-0.1760670096,
0.5905287862,
0.1567472667,
0.6173933148,
-0.7775635719,
0.4513535202,
-0.4972337186,
-0.5694309473,
-0.1021252126,
-0.4991953671,
-1.2690299749,
0.0903681666,
-0.0818899721,
-0.6471043825,
0.0502076261,
-0.1497628987,
-0.1105670854,
0.0531380624,
-0.7554414868,
0.5012120605,
0.1458202004,
-0.215886429,
-0.3759063482,
-0.3204241693,
0.1696760505,
-0.1216832623,
0.3011426926,
-0.1264071912,
0.0733587146,
1.0232827663,
0.013220991,
0.7624440789,
0.1288126856,
0.0366276652,
0.4629846811,
0.0782878026,
0.5323804617,
0.0388656966,
-0.0174782816,
0.2160788924,
0.4144633114,
-0.250087887,
0.0361888856,
0.6592933536,
-0.6709275246,
-0.3721300662,
-0.8028280139,
-0.5277508497,
-0.012715511,
0.0371403731,
0.4109734893,
0.367898047,
-0.4284409285,
0.3918206394,
0.2510530353,
-0.0275214147,
0.3768260777,
0.4748335779,
-0.4097901583,
-0.0430971831,
0.7821924686,
0.2340661287,
0.0522974804,
0.1507223547,
0.2850117981,
-0.4087868035,
-0.4548839033,
0.0008609826,
0.3845984638,
-0.2104074657,
0.2973067462,
-0.8663768768,
-0.1863102317,
-0.3214217424,
-0.3505685031,
-0.1915102303,
-0.3857743442,
-0.335177511,
0.1976948082,
0.493026793,
0.8013718128,
0.0009401051,
0.6812096238,
-0.7338191271,
-0.0431706198,
-0.1841198653,
0.3002932966,
-0.541223526,
-0.2863130569,
-0.2634468973,
-0.1351615191,
-0.6076549292,
-0.6626392603,
0.7850952148,
0.3679188788,
0.4342314303,
0.1103733703,
-0.5128902793,
0.3979152143,
-0.2919414043,
0.8642279506,
0.0189885497,
-0.3797528446,
0.2537998259,
-0.8341017365,
0.1612847447,
0.3319776654,
0.7197477221,
-1.1697191,
-0.6033427119,
-0.7485026717,
-0.8712810874,
0.3846827447,
0.2797266245,
0.1325344741,
-0.0699242204,
0.297736764,
0.2301763445,
0.3670897186,
-0.6093664169,
0.2156461179,
0.1475191861,
-0.1647185832,
-0.1550118476,
-0.0757569298,
-0.189969629,
0.3072963357,
0.7549214959,
-0.1015379876,
0.2913223803,
0.3000929058,
0.0933490247,
-0.0694733411,
0.2258158475,
0.0994347557,
0.7360603809,
-0.2553081214,
-0.215826571,
-0.311470449,
-1.1852488518,
-0.6474283338,
0.3267466426,
-0.3959224522,
0.0702658519,
0.0598604679,
0.3156212568,
0.2868900597,
-0.458462745,
-0.0848247707,
0.1060897186,
-0.3438338935,
-0.5402972102,
0.0849671662,
0.1453001946,
-0.0246083476,
0.30295825,
0.4060285091,
0.3786426783,
-0.5737580657,
0.1600965708,
0.6534230709,
-0.339754045,
-0.2291486263,
0.6452898383,
-0.006341747,
-0.0676170141,
0.2033466101,
-0.0224900972,
-0.4828550518,
0.5657265782,
0.2713618279,
0.6326383352,
0.26214239,
0.3937858939,
0.3360220492,
0.2286482006,
-0.3286688328,
0.3929267526,
0.213730365,
-0.5414327383,
-0.5307929516,
-0.8257484436,
-0.7619211674,
-0.279029429,
-0.046431087,
0.4889322817,
-0.2672519386,
-0.3198090196,
0.6259364486,
0.2573449314,
-0.5312697887,
-0.1715227962,
0.3631386161,
0.5667089224,
-0.5806425214,
0.2491856664,
0.6304633617,
-0.3837634325,
-0.6191981435,
-0.4500269592,
0.3611314893,
-0.6853313446,
0.5120632052,
0.0117519898,
0.0893567801,
0.0335853994,
-0.7856411338,
-0.7617357373,
0.7336996794,
-0.2632553279,
-0.6104359627,
-0.0251434818,
0.1060448512,
0.7486266494,
-0.1103745848,
0.4574127197,
0.5229961276,
0.7252684832,
0.3663913608,
-1.0422691107,
-0.5790269375,
-0.1299432963,
-0.4509725869,
0.6239714026,
-0.7085897326,
0.6186295748,
0.1517117321,
-0.3543683589,
0.0507959984,
0.398283124,
0.1818298697,
0.5621334314,
0.0021542883,
0.1430038214,
0.9881013036,
-0.2613455951,
0.8067137003,
-0.2646118999,
0.4198635817,
0.3838860989,
-0.2445112169,
0.7352949381,
0.6073433757,
-0.5058104396,
0.2374073267,
0.4973717928,
-0.3582367599,
0.2312414497,
0.1265342087,
-0.4274785519,
0.0859055966,
-0.3502216339,
-0.2151848078,
0.8240697384,
0.7579278946,
-0.3590890467,
-0.2122644186,
-0.0440948196,
0.494848609,
0.1109647304,
-0.0907743052,
0.9229729772,
0.3568692207,
-1.0554145575,
0.3023155034,
-0.35142079,
0.6896924973,
-0.8503369093,
0.1542778909,
-0.0779070035,
0.2010457814,
-0.2420400381,
-0.9723567963,
0.5980367064,
0.2671175599,
0.0930017233,
-0.2055435628,
0.5753929019,
-0.270863086,
-0.7649116516,
-0.1079669073,
0.4670513272,
0.3717325628,
-0.056643758,
-0.1413766295,
-0.4745232165,
0.0581394285,
-0.3784012198,
0.273781538,
0.4746050239,
0.1126940846,
0.7130073905,
0.9343003035,
0.6495996714,
0.1989456415,
-0.3169979751,
0.7861772776,
-0.6843212843,
-0.4791065156,
-0.6135417223,
0.2140717208,
-0.1615556031,
-0.5949856043,
0.9170833826,
0.4261807203,
0.210936904,
0.1112438217,
0.8866522312,
-0.3148702383,
0.6386654973,
-0.3284212053,
0.8537364602,
-0.2505390048,
0.2957470417,
-0.3956337869,
-0.9391290545,
-0.4771277905,
0.3821709454,
-0.6893314719,
-0.1175275296,
0.5709168911,
0.9503065944,
-0.0083333487,
0.724745214,
0.1645818055,
0.1281072348,
0.5596317649,
0.1507653892,
0.7903619409,
-0.2558219731,
0.7507338524,
0.05032859,
-0.3001836836,
-0.4346438944,
-1.0687106848,
-0.4055524468,
-0.7212213278,
-0.2302256227,
-0.1379389167,
0.203582868,
0.7678251863,
0.6064932942,
-0.7280856967,
-0.0842229202,
-0.2470549941,
-0.3895200789,
-0.0995717049,
-0.1992629021,
0.4026744962,
-0.5457379818,
-0.6911688447,
0.3646820784,
0.1298930347,
-0.3353130817,
-0.1440763921,
0.2719882727,
-0.0971375182,
0.1785351187,
0.455083549,
0.4533002377,
-0.2032586932,
-0.1620584279,
0.4025579989,
-0.1472635269,
-0.0096938359,
0.6274065375,
-0.4459472597,
0.5959749222,
0.4356614947,
0.3630048335,
0.5485823154,
-0.0548985824,
0.4700323641,
-0.4225558043,
0.005116777,
0.5524252653,
0.2929326892,
0.3605333865,
-0.361763835,
0.7586910129,
0.4260740876,
-1.3022736311,
-0.6189360023,
-0.165173322,
-1.0218715668,
-0.0313257761,
1.0990610123,
0.128885448,
-0.2753223181,
-0.176275,
-0.5534098744,
-0.0257029645,
-0.6121694446,
1.2317998409,
1.0296925306,
-0.2556572258,
-0.0596911944,
-0.9128313661,
0.5730476379,
0.3467966616,
-0.5895683765,
0.320417136,
0.534511745,
0.0366582572,
0.4353443682,
0.2492889762,
-0.4117807448,
0.1362509131,
0.3231915832,
-0.0758992434,
0.0564748161,
0.044249367,
0.2643800974,
0.1192860156,
0.12612243,
0.2417743504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17312v1
|
Not All Preference Pairs Are Created Equal: A Recipe for Annotation-Efficient Iterative Preference Learning
| 2024-06-25T06:49:16 | 2024-06-25T06:49:16 |
Sen Yang, Leyang Cui, Deng Cai, Xinting Huang, Shuming Shi, Wai Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Iterative preference learning, though yielding superior performances,
requires online annotated preference labels. In this work, we study strategies
to select worth-annotating response pairs for cost-efficient annotation while
achieving competitive or even better performances compared with the random
selection baseline for iterative preference learning. Built on assumptions
regarding uncertainty and distribution shifts, we propose a comparative view to
rank the implicit reward margins as predicted by DPO to select the response
pairs that yield more benefits. Through extensive experiments, we show that
annotating those response pairs with small margins is generally better than
large or random, under both single- and multi-iteration scenarios. Besides, our
empirical results suggest allocating more annotation budgets in the earlier
iterations rather than later across multiple iterations.
|
[
-0.4896274507,
0.2124975026,
0.4203811288,
0.240173921,
-0.363827914,
-0.0037777559,
-0.4179185629,
-0.5660482645,
0.3505028784,
0.166624561,
-0.2566563487,
-0.0922731534,
-0.7784228325,
0.0075063999,
0.3535318375,
1.1515309811,
0.1488303095,
-0.0379344523,
-0.4295871556,
-0.496072799,
-0.2026200444,
-0.6252636909,
-0.8779338002,
-0.3925060332,
0.8845086098,
0.5955999494,
0.5580849051,
0.753518939,
0.5916681886,
0.2188974619,
0.0409321934,
0.1327786148,
-0.5584579706,
0.2363345474,
0.0400256626,
-0.1635062397,
-0.1857629865,
0.5094560385,
0.1174580306,
0.6713246703,
0.0960578173,
0.3875919282,
-0.1011705697,
1.0928333998,
-0.9966725707,
0.1989109963,
-0.5606977344,
0.0435198657,
-0.148451522,
-0.3568359315,
-0.5952167511,
-0.806581676,
0.470918119,
-1.0889576674,
-0.2271923125,
0.2893974185,
0.7237000465,
0.4161049128,
0.0692454055,
-0.3669066131,
-0.5039699674,
0.6841999888,
-0.190512836,
0.3317520022,
0.5877331495,
0.3569144011,
0.2743836641,
-0.5913560987,
-0.0879020467,
-0.4285365045,
-0.0799710974,
0.3489920795,
0.2878881395,
0.110641472,
0.1695583016,
0.3732963204,
0.0459733866,
0.3271285295,
-0.3255128264,
0.0581505373,
0.9348105192,
-0.258726269,
-0.3145559132,
-0.0507175997,
-0.4990283251,
-0.4493471086,
-0.4300119579,
0.636826992,
0.5406293869,
0.3742650151,
0.1070291996,
0.5038163066,
-0.3467777073,
0.6846607327,
0.3349682093,
-0.3446003199,
0.372307092,
0.0298472494,
0.0137202041,
0.2023981959,
0.6494761109,
0.7022794485,
0.576151669,
-0.4338439703,
-0.1680927277,
-0.1655894965,
0.2264744192,
-0.5755647421,
-0.4067553282,
0.2253088802,
-0.4897636175,
-0.4984307885,
-0.1358327717,
-0.694082737,
-0.4928260148,
-0.5072304606,
0.6101431847,
-0.1267055124,
-0.1539783627,
-0.0677408129,
-0.6903259754,
-0.1632026434,
0.3183834553,
-1.1847900152,
0.312017858,
0.5806863904,
0.7974378467,
-0.2659834921,
0.0056720451,
-0.7594645619,
-0.0499859862,
-0.3612713218,
0.9528100491,
-0.7470477819,
-0.5168074965,
-0.1622504592,
-0.6651264429,
0.1277876645,
-0.5680226684,
0.505156517,
-0.6062632203,
-0.0682928711,
-0.9126579165,
-0.6032041907,
0.1473940462,
0.048409801,
-0.997042954,
1.0171964169,
0.0772651732,
-1.0983405113,
1.0770068169,
-0.5539405942,
-0.2235956937,
0.0475999266,
0.0024130233,
-0.3317867517,
0.1335702538,
0.1419418454,
0.393582195,
-0.0985180289,
-0.1713680029,
-0.7056996822,
-0.3241688013,
0.4762551785,
0.1104148924,
0.514690876,
0.2344313562,
-0.53485322,
0.1683065593,
-0.9178437591,
0.0476178862,
0.1317328811,
-0.495708257,
-0.6679192185,
-0.0152693065,
-0.1911861598,
-0.0579384565,
-0.0871235728,
-0.5901665688,
0.3763507605,
-0.0806392059,
0.286167413,
1.4131928682,
-0.2765749395,
0.8337592483,
-0.3494196236,
-0.0072912294,
-0.3823452294,
0.329353869,
0.4385650158,
-0.3836653233,
-0.7330048084,
-0.6016784906,
0.5984725356,
0.0649613291,
-0.5644378066,
0.0085454164,
-0.252595365,
-0.2650020123,
-0.8344215751,
-0.0657325834,
0.3012193739,
0.6462888122,
0.4886594713,
0.0027906252,
-0.2748309374,
-0.9591219425,
-0.2298036218,
-0.3974972963,
0.1981014013,
0.5135883093,
0.1060140505,
0.3554806709,
0.8601481318,
-0.5001187921,
-0.2457205355,
0.0138222706,
0.0684009418,
-0.3503493965,
0.1643480062,
0.8248320222,
-0.917653203,
-0.5733942389,
-0.2165993899,
-0.3014977574,
-0.0832877159,
0.0130352266,
-0.2074945569,
0.2833761871,
-0.2212346047,
0.1017801613,
0.198820442,
0.3574291468,
0.1480721831,
-0.1242808029,
-0.2271197736,
0.3316670656,
-0.6264578104,
0.1517764479,
0.2480413616,
-0.1019310057,
-0.2323558927,
-0.3318742514,
0.0570725314,
0.4800294936,
-0.0768850148,
0.5248618722,
-0.3223364651,
-0.3316988051,
-0.0231503025,
0.2543001175,
-0.2281258404,
0.442935288,
0.5024531484,
0.7482579947,
0.1386704296,
-0.562597394,
0.195740521,
0.2833666503,
0.0260227285,
0.6392480135,
-0.4557765126,
0.3619224131,
-0.1991396248,
0.2071064711,
-1.1779710054,
-0.2204725742,
0.3546842337,
-0.4671892822,
0.150550738,
-0.2299948484,
-0.2290712893,
-0.2280629575,
-0.9215384722,
0.2224462628,
0.5087141991,
-1.1967396736,
0.0082482751,
0.4379603267,
0.1011165455,
-0.8962629437,
-0.3936649561,
-0.4351446927,
-0.4030297101,
-0.1321612448,
0.1285993904,
-0.1837223768,
-0.5295757055,
-0.1155014709,
-0.218754977,
0.2607414722,
0.379709065,
0.5850486159,
0.2042451501,
0.3084922433,
0.4142950773,
-0.1736601293,
-0.6890667081,
-0.1898629218,
-0.3819178045,
0.1291561723,
0.0658113733,
-0.0473900586,
0.0363914631,
0.5109223127,
0.0494901799,
-0.34143278,
0.5727181435,
0.3171236813,
-0.1060071364,
-0.0698069707,
-0.7255483866,
-0.1169152856,
-0.4541593492,
-0.3925396204,
-0.6008743644,
-0.8148457408,
0.2034666985,
0.05196229,
0.445373714,
0.5585302114,
0.2630588114,
-0.2359071821,
0.8334259987,
0.5050250888,
-0.0499237254,
0.5414413214,
-0.2278465331,
-0.0025030342,
-0.7177816629,
-0.3042064309,
-0.5769915581,
-0.5556493402,
-0.7002382874,
0.0420293696,
0.5327966809,
-0.0133387763,
-0.2915171087,
-0.1275287718,
-0.8894864321,
0.3511304557,
1.1585502625,
0.2791212797,
0.365837127,
0.1661206931,
-0.043605648,
-0.2171285748,
-0.4541534781,
-0.2931490541,
1.4122897387,
0.054557886,
0.4807084203,
-0.0457130298,
0.8952661753,
0.0593667626,
0.4616856873,
-0.7287754416,
0.1378757358,
-0.0919306874,
-0.3295845389,
-0.1822885871,
-0.2513544858,
-0.7133107781,
0.1443273574,
-0.5453875065,
-0.8745213151,
0.2469820529,
0.5588569045,
-0.7427126169,
0.3212910891,
-0.615907371,
0.4596138299,
-0.3621811569,
-0.5710884929,
-0.1211424395,
-0.8964931369,
-0.2259978801,
0.256444782,
-0.1931566745,
-0.250743866,
-0.1385237724,
0.8550136685,
-0.0725515038,
0.2668505013,
-0.2636443973,
0.3920273483,
0.0262669101,
-0.3041083515,
0.2445569485,
0.3540305793,
-0.4578561783,
-0.0567147173,
-0.3265376389,
-0.3291009068,
-0.2155082822,
0.7953745127,
-0.835573256,
-0.569214046,
-0.5244787335,
-0.3113087118,
-0.2464063466,
-0.1720128357,
0.500336647,
0.3434846401,
0.3173021376,
0.0760779455,
0.5986993909,
0.0532613881,
0.6998822689,
-0.0621926151,
0.1996909082,
-0.7959240079,
0.7010442615,
0.4239223301,
0.5145770311,
0.4761502445,
0.4233049452,
-0.4954165816,
-0.5373708606,
-0.5699328184,
0.0390428416,
-0.7901536822,
-0.0362804607,
-0.7271636128,
0.4074701965,
-0.3124405146,
-0.5310800076,
-0.5609001517,
-0.8575650454,
0.0743993074,
-0.5252107978,
0.8613166213,
0.5197348595,
-0.7165068984,
0.020007303,
-0.1819893122,
0.216977939,
0.6968972087,
0.5519562364,
-0.0791591331,
0.0572188571,
0.0674536303,
-0.1174558699,
-0.1112349033,
-0.7869616747,
-0.0805370957,
-0.1423817575,
0.7150296569,
0.2580810189,
0.4784392416,
0.8188576102,
-0.0737086013,
0.5787402987,
0.0438514762,
-0.5959278345,
0.461886704,
0.046054855,
-0.2594920099,
1.0366955996,
0.8333193064,
-0.2252354622,
0.2559775114,
-0.7044928074,
-1.2295218706,
0.7550275326,
0.1301840991,
-0.2311457992,
0.0618060343,
0.599478662,
0.5754714608,
0.4703487754,
-0.6919968724,
-0.6606663465,
-0.241162926,
0.0795629025,
-0.2594370544,
-0.2562515736,
-0.4670514762,
-0.1938359737,
0.6061990261,
-0.2917177081,
0.3306037784,
0.3101023138,
0.0199788902,
-0.1510965377,
0.046763055,
0.3105067015,
0.4883955121,
-0.5374544263,
0.1860454381,
0.0365223251,
0.1227577701,
0.1691438556,
0.1672832221,
-0.0129129887,
-0.161168471,
0.0673254281,
1.1732692719,
0.0652308613,
-0.3471763134,
0.5716317892,
-0.0986197367,
-0.0446945801,
-0.1579406112,
-0.1633108854,
0.0362508595,
0.1968108118,
0.2996397316,
0.0891805217,
0.4742338061,
-0.4255409241,
-0.0138681876,
0.4707088768,
-0.3705206811,
0.0940447301,
0.6500342488,
0.4091208279,
-0.2207652032,
0.4022405446,
-0.1983300149,
-0.5506286025,
0.3883167207,
0.1980718821,
0.681126833,
0.2030650824,
0.467761606,
0.65163517,
-0.0916519165,
-0.3414283395,
-0.0805012062,
-0.7248895168,
-0.3392820358,
0.1424558908,
-0.2672771215,
-0.6887645125,
-0.2292438447,
-0.9732067585,
0.1545909494,
-0.5755296946,
-0.2292475253,
0.2933804691,
-0.0222726781,
-0.7113725543,
0.2721843421,
0.2269795388,
0.544382751,
-0.6553072333,
0.353584379,
0.8529425859,
-0.5944616199,
-0.8477865458,
-0.1699563861,
-0.0997734293,
-0.9561684132,
0.9898513556,
0.3744559586,
-0.0190038383,
-0.1570927352,
-0.2262544334,
-0.749786377,
0.9284094572,
0.2618914545,
-0.3946720958,
0.1324295253,
-0.0173041578,
0.2561126351,
-0.2572597861,
0.8537603021,
0.5489974618,
0.4742073417,
0.332691133,
-0.9878214002,
-0.1138492301,
-0.1059726328,
-0.0054582129,
0.2485332638,
-1.0984416008,
0.5966794491,
-0.5089427829,
0.0404504612,
-0.2028311789,
0.2354488224,
0.2928000093,
0.5424641967,
0.6737335324,
0.5658638477,
0.7405076027,
-0.2677370012,
1.0683714151,
0.0780349895,
0.2463956624,
1.0361812115,
-0.0263338163,
0.9465021491,
0.6975527406,
-0.0941104442,
0.0887289047,
1.2041113377,
0.3740193248,
1.0372450352,
0.2788076103,
-0.0433929376,
-0.5438137054,
-0.1536609828,
-0.4675377905,
-0.0733758807,
-0.0259237476,
-0.2039206475,
0.0209264979,
-0.1350108981,
0.0485127531,
0.1545060426,
-0.2547053099,
1.1362073421,
-0.0138941249,
-0.9552669525,
0.3309005201,
-0.4931944013,
0.8104199171,
-0.2515205443,
0.1124111488,
-0.3347271681,
0.2520580888,
-0.242767036,
-0.7433025837,
-0.2181643844,
-0.2447541207,
-0.0843967497,
-0.3138481677,
0.4741390049,
-0.154721126,
-0.0433808267,
0.5132056475,
-0.1289538294,
-0.3687330186,
-0.0010336691,
-0.4979851246,
0.1075063199,
-0.0547179431,
-0.553224802,
0.2837159336,
-0.001521142,
-0.1216139197,
0.7103674412,
0.5792841315,
0.1531418115,
0.2005833834,
-0.1472135335,
0.7754999995,
-0.2513951957,
-0.6333256364,
-0.7250141501,
0.8384723663,
-0.7592929602,
-0.4732093513,
0.53595227,
0.3595769107,
1.0744782686,
0.1328906864,
0.8616660237,
0.1551268548,
0.3481575549,
-0.3343800604,
0.0310962014,
-0.6197884679,
0.1730792224,
-0.2042063624,
-0.7087708712,
-0.1545027941,
0.9135867953,
-0.4753609896,
0.0183467213,
0.4791272581,
0.0428054631,
0.2871712148,
0.1777044088,
-0.0861619636,
-0.4745768309,
0.2862349749,
0.6931132674,
0.6272794604,
-0.2672162354,
0.2050015479,
-0.8614817262,
-0.5054309964,
-0.3160821795,
-0.9934848547,
-0.9642394185,
-0.7362821698,
-0.438618511,
-0.3771602213,
0.3884634674,
1.5049864054,
0.8838803768,
-0.5535861254,
-0.0426186658,
0.3911759555,
-0.1705230176,
-0.3518183827,
-0.1189747378,
0.2920866609,
-0.5750591159,
-0.7395566702,
-0.2149259001,
0.3754037619,
-0.036751058,
0.098300755,
-0.1090212613,
0.021019537,
-0.0114204325,
0.3027640879,
0.3112766743,
-0.5382018089,
-0.5595144033,
-0.0686054677,
-0.0600489229,
0.3421946466,
0.7411008477,
-0.7293332815,
0.7216091156,
0.5432639122,
1.0113227367,
0.73793751,
0.0079514934,
0.4479296505,
-0.5038256049,
0.2656742334,
0.0849064887,
0.2310602665,
0.4770911038,
-0.3796418905,
0.9325194359,
0.2122021317,
-0.6267809272,
-0.815436542,
0.0344726965,
-1.3152195215,
-0.0162457675,
1.5008049011,
-0.2377041429,
0.2204692662,
0.3345462382,
-0.3563888967,
0.0993999541,
-0.7190877795,
1.115031004,
0.5126239657,
-0.3630638123,
0.1409959942,
-0.2700670362,
0.9099085331,
0.5242363811,
-0.6690902114,
-0.049060531,
0.3181295991,
0.1652110517,
0.3472352326,
0.8194280267,
0.3264984488,
0.2638005912,
-0.1028775498,
-0.1060136929,
-0.2565715313,
-0.3457314968,
-0.0791442171,
0.3993073404,
0.6137422919,
-0.7260231972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17305v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17305v1
|
Retrieval Augmented Instruction Tuning for Open NER with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-25T06:24:50 | 2024-06-25T06:24:50 |
Tingyu Xie, Jian Zhang, Yan Zhang, Yuanyuan Liang, Qi Li, Hongwei Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The strong capability of large language models (LLMs) has been applied to
information extraction (IE) through either retrieval augmented prompting or
instruction tuning (IT). However, the best way to incorporate information with
LLMs for IE remains an open question. In this paper, we explore Retrieval
Augmented Instruction Tuning (RA-IT) for IE, focusing on the task of open named
entity recognition (NER). Specifically, for each training sample, we retrieve
semantically similar examples from the training dataset as the context and
prepend them to the input of the original instruction. To evaluate our RA-IT
approach more thoroughly, we construct a Chinese IT dataset for open NER and
evaluate RA-IT in both English and Chinese scenarios. Experimental results
verify the effectiveness of RA-IT across various data sizes and in both English
and Chinese scenarios. We also conduct thorough studies to explore the impacts
of various retrieval strategies in the proposed RA-IT framework. Code and data
are available at: https://github.com/Emma1066/Retrieval-Augmented-IT-OpenNER
|
[
-0.2956942022,
-0.7168934345,
0.2648950517,
0.0150594013,
-0.2323044986,
-0.2311175764,
-0.8021829724,
-0.5874453783,
0.2758099139,
0.5801876783,
-0.2907164991,
-0.5214645863,
-0.4681680202,
0.2987272441,
-0.2915545404,
0.9810972214,
-0.0731361732,
0.2462578416,
0.1610192209,
-0.0012089676,
-0.568556428,
-0.1775062382,
-0.8447383642,
-0.1977585405,
0.5208704472,
0.7683933377,
0.3208445311,
0.9632895589,
0.6265624166,
0.1916958094,
0.1289481819,
0.437559247,
-0.3806567192,
0.0357793346,
-0.3696202338,
-0.3376023471,
-0.2376916409,
-0.1110448092,
0.9706714749,
0.3675788343,
-0.1930501461,
0.28465119,
0.0196855776,
0.4997057021,
-0.8627019525,
0.1482282281,
-0.8822945952,
-0.0107703935,
-0.3897581697,
-0.5228248239,
-0.8602056503,
-0.2441722453,
0.1417639256,
-0.7234437466,
0.2174868733,
0.4401132166,
1.3505066633,
0.0930716842,
-0.153648749,
-0.2876759171,
-0.8468592763,
0.8738210201,
-0.6321036816,
0.4570207596,
0.5324139595,
0.2406361252,
-0.143577233,
-0.6150761247,
-0.4787005186,
-0.173509866,
-0.1193295345,
0.0633546486,
-0.0684807003,
0.060921859,
0.4397008121,
0.6589398384,
-0.3561921716,
0.4140952528,
-0.3322647214,
-0.08239232,
0.4722516239,
-0.0323927626,
0.5032548308,
0.0053569227,
-0.358378768,
-0.1540737152,
-0.8553791642,
-0.1042760611,
0.1803836077,
0.6981986165,
0.1844540983,
0.7568890452,
-0.1399538368,
0.8696023226,
0.2306360453,
-0.000645315,
0.2125098705,
-0.102441147,
-0.21036686,
0.4331213832,
0.613027513,
0.0594935678,
0.4152886271,
-0.3046918511,
-0.5606667399,
-0.5626658797,
0.2168714404,
-0.9154307842,
-0.2251073718,
-0.2162562907,
-0.286547929,
0.2197983265,
0.5319015384,
-0.712431252,
-0.0619955175,
-0.4786425829,
0.6763102412,
-0.6468333602,
-0.2788780332,
0.1373072863,
0.0476380438,
0.5949236155,
0.3178634644,
-0.999156177,
0.1315350682,
0.6851372123,
0.6113649607,
-0.3005446792,
-0.0388520546,
-1.1390951872,
0.3366002142,
-0.2017473727,
0.730275929,
-0.9846672416,
-0.1383361071,
-0.113910675,
0.1871276796,
-0.4651170969,
-0.7761158943,
0.3978833258,
-1.0292943716,
0.2779046595,
-0.1503590643,
-0.6955302358,
-0.1545947939,
0.2892607749,
-0.9798597097,
1.0944443941,
-0.1044746488,
-0.7265619636,
0.3446374834,
-0.7450042367,
-0.5662166476,
0.1759059131,
-0.2408399731,
-0.3326636851,
0.1573385596,
0.46096614,
0.2500590384,
-0.3536339402,
-0.1361941397,
-0.0187542662,
-0.6305409074,
-0.1551583409,
-0.3207386434,
0.5336824059,
0.1339020431,
-0.2756274045,
-0.1141704321,
-0.8244503736,
0.3473405242,
0.0544985272,
-0.6015694737,
-0.7417143583,
-0.1821502596,
-0.2237583101,
-0.261818409,
0.2580577135,
-0.7121697068,
0.4223102927,
-0.5224315524,
0.2380395979,
0.7290104628,
0.2155805528,
0.4419670999,
0.1527438313,
0.3987924755,
-0.0908941925,
-0.1587936878,
-0.1780601889,
-0.1559768915,
-0.7630143166,
-0.4559999704,
0.8568612933,
0.6537587643,
-0.9940184951,
0.3339295089,
-0.4144358933,
-0.0728117451,
-0.7921357751,
-0.0295364,
0.4224582314,
0.5334457159,
0.4859548509,
0.0735592023,
-0.5716460943,
-0.7200853825,
-0.2479288876,
0.1281482875,
-0.0731125176,
0.4946842492,
0.3640657067,
0.053689044,
0.7130730748,
-0.3901818097,
-0.3837983012,
-0.1230216548,
0.119403474,
0.2053119689,
0.365922302,
0.123148635,
-0.77451545,
-0.5157824159,
0.3482713699,
-0.6781318188,
0.0824772045,
0.111630775,
-0.1967835724,
0.117079936,
0.5032836199,
-0.3597103059,
0.4782994986,
0.1306672841,
0.1528917998,
0.3414210081,
-0.2503609657,
0.383869648,
-1.1876955032,
0.1290963143,
0.0831529647,
0.1048068181,
-0.2832764387,
0.264380157,
0.3143615127,
0.0355700217,
-0.255995959,
0.6876404881,
-1.0171858072,
-0.1817950457,
-0.3103786409,
0.3002423048,
-0.0632434413,
0.1554246247,
0.2308460772,
1.1632652283,
0.4805343151,
-0.8566355705,
0.0937849507,
0.1465771943,
-0.6952208281,
0.3196192682,
-0.546751976,
0.3814432919,
-0.195425272,
-0.3019355834,
-0.450604409,
-0.3429232836,
0.0799979046,
-0.2930893898,
0.7608979344,
-0.0747679919,
-0.6353698969,
-0.2227206975,
-0.082348004,
0.2944414914,
0.1689423323,
-1.0594522953,
0.7307701707,
0.2204912752,
0.0874481872,
-0.850364089,
-0.4133265615,
0.0017521753,
-0.2423779368,
-0.4329990447,
0.6749490499,
0.110779427,
-0.1923828721,
0.1466692388,
-0.2189479172,
-0.197000131,
-0.0104632098,
-0.0829202533,
0.3517298698,
-0.6404987574,
0.3484987319,
0.0313745998,
-0.0968843624,
-0.2987112999,
-0.1289795488,
0.3552355766,
-0.0194262769,
-0.311378628,
-0.3449554443,
0.1859889925,
0.0034525106,
-0.7370064855,
0.8788790107,
0.7477113008,
-0.510835588,
-0.3923424482,
-0.4905878305,
-0.3086114824,
-0.4690703154,
0.3780076802,
-0.5866192579,
-0.8845396638,
0.2751790285,
-0.1548099816,
0.2378562689,
0.2457146943,
0.1825575382,
0.1304857284,
1.0707247257,
0.8005891442,
-0.2549553514,
0.8824009299,
-0.2204749882,
0.2534862757,
-1.0901882648,
-0.1311748028,
-0.6433879733,
-0.2558641136,
-0.3210882545,
-0.1120166928,
0.3694026768,
0.3509489,
-0.110932149,
0.4140382409,
-0.417247057,
0.8125807643,
0.614698112,
0.3171059787,
0.3667762876,
0.3363802135,
-0.0121068461,
-0.1463643163,
-0.4934159815,
-0.3976663649,
0.8427960277,
-0.0272831954,
0.7994197011,
0.1382108033,
0.8184143901,
0.002267048,
0.1933799684,
-0.844709456,
0.5233956575,
-0.3672598302,
-0.3729816973,
-0.2032990903,
-0.4777825177,
-1.1102420092,
-0.097110495,
-0.2561556101,
-0.8910697699,
-0.1101771146,
-0.0077288421,
-0.3233219087,
0.3632375896,
-0.6718910933,
0.5513135195,
-0.1903662533,
-0.306548804,
-0.0995099619,
-0.3469973803,
0.2740636468,
0.1450578421,
-0.1481546313,
0.2604788542,
-0.0839890093,
0.6337225437,
-0.1475260705,
0.2953827977,
-0.1025815755,
-0.0486356393,
0.1205874532,
-0.2289690524,
0.6753463745,
0.0007926582,
-0.5069969296,
0.1031805947,
-0.2948033214,
-0.1194510832,
-0.7460999489,
0.84373945,
-0.7707112432,
-0.6441109776,
-0.1185977235,
-0.4042001069,
0.0177534129,
0.4898819327,
0.4187251329,
0.5256869197,
-0.0163667202,
0.3587726653,
1.1274151802,
-0.3357664049,
0.4125930071,
0.8998509645,
-0.1463040113,
-0.3659528494,
1.1863750219,
0.2265710682,
0.0612459667,
0.8257809281,
0.0002169871,
-0.0462880693,
-0.5450595021,
-0.7028489113,
0.3535753787,
-0.5574092865,
-0.3353697658,
-0.3858521581,
-0.5154265761,
-0.1999990195,
0.3960095346,
-0.2666300833,
-0.1165652499,
-0.662194252,
-0.095910497,
0.5110334158,
0.6377717257,
0.1726861894,
0.1124239564,
-0.8950485587,
0.218532294,
-0.1923335195,
0.5665627718,
-0.0458775572,
-0.6607761383,
-0.5372136235,
0.0003212263,
0.089169018,
-0.7797358036,
0.265950948,
0.5608397126,
0.7147375941,
0.4227473736,
0.2508587837,
0.8525565267,
-0.6928972006,
0.4782379568,
-0.4326997399,
-0.5813778639,
0.7126783729,
-0.0050361226,
0.0802842826,
0.6861457229,
0.5228671432,
-0.058070574,
0.0529182479,
-0.1311185062,
-0.8935275078,
0.9666846395,
-0.1614762694,
-0.0360638723,
-0.3119542599,
0.6971826553,
0.1246111616,
-0.0383714139,
-0.5920908451,
-0.2700588703,
0.3795567751,
-0.2531305552,
0.278327018,
-0.1591870189,
0.1737651676,
-0.1331565678,
0.941742599,
0.0017611693,
0.2579012811,
0.078621313,
-0.346814394,
-0.2296378613,
0.331320554,
0.183659181,
0.3174178898,
-0.1318936646,
-0.0763687268,
0.0129451873,
-0.5075517893,
-0.3084022999,
0.2322250158,
-0.3016881645,
0.0259987935,
0.2306749821,
0.9448064566,
0.238014549,
-0.6309685111,
0.2959081531,
-0.2230852693,
0.0670756102,
-0.3581004739,
0.3049131036,
-0.3938901722,
0.23668015,
0.3251926005,
-0.2995916307,
0.1266717315,
-0.3040356636,
0.2408007085,
0.5884646177,
-0.2795790136,
-0.1492188871,
0.3517680466,
-0.1509278268,
-0.5373412967,
1.1682329178,
-0.1832967252,
-0.2055062503,
0.4626266062,
0.7947826385,
0.8784457445,
-0.2884710729,
-0.0905581862,
0.8038341999,
0.4422223568,
-0.1499614269,
0.3600057662,
-0.1727765799,
-0.6936126351,
-0.5757239461,
-0.573425293,
-0.3283432126,
0.3192059696,
-1.2307436466,
0.656609118,
-0.2898626924,
0.1271480024,
-0.015800897,
-0.0456139557,
-0.6069651842,
0.0184033774,
0.0387470014,
1.0798442364,
-0.380656749,
0.9531259537,
0.9354776144,
-0.4825180471,
-1.0683284998,
0.1366595626,
-0.332067281,
-0.9240186214,
0.7849681377,
0.3585173786,
0.0077896938,
0.3357072473,
-0.5239095688,
-1.0917239189,
1.1898204088,
0.3611237109,
-0.765760839,
-0.2594032586,
-0.1421457529,
0.3129010797,
-0.3344967067,
0.4931151569,
0.4791505337,
0.4473898709,
0.0458156727,
-0.9686137438,
-0.19761087,
-0.3944861293,
-0.1613616645,
0.5362234116,
-0.4529804885,
0.8030696511,
-0.4180914462,
-0.6612198949,
0.2039774805,
0.6852043867,
0.0536606014,
0.1325525343,
0.4209780097,
0.6632710695,
0.7609895468,
-0.0485461242,
0.8572816849,
-0.4192492366,
0.0210357402,
1.3989813328,
-0.3673489094,
1.1806656122,
0.2357138544,
0.2689543664,
0.512384057,
0.5804437995,
-0.0931961536,
0.526639998,
0.0235388875,
-0.263386935,
-0.1710608751,
-0.2460252196,
-0.3766273856,
0.5967677832,
0.4872024655,
-0.5158183575,
-0.2965046465,
0.3840358257,
-0.1274699122,
0.1032132506,
-0.5728914142,
1.1585829258,
-0.0474087894,
-0.713566184,
0.4899828136,
0.1772607714,
0.4883399308,
-0.5762232542,
-0.5523915291,
0.0684944391,
0.2367717773,
-0.2063403428,
-0.6067276597,
0.0295352265,
0.1118535399,
-0.4126548469,
-0.0503224432,
0.7196308374,
-0.5737655759,
-0.1967834085,
0.2918325067,
0.1645907909,
0.3102320433,
-0.016675774,
-0.5104573369,
0.0762070566,
0.1252906322,
-0.4342186153,
0.5784511566,
0.6373426914,
-0.0759217441,
0.4209262729,
0.3607794344,
0.1812929362,
0.1277824342,
0.1410377324,
0.8051674962,
-0.7992964983,
-0.2055927217,
-0.812345624,
0.2274858952,
-0.0873546004,
-0.1771820486,
0.9427126646,
0.6061268449,
1.031696558,
0.1717474014,
0.4564010203,
-0.0525633357,
0.6288041472,
-0.8936932087,
0.3706246912,
-0.5323815942,
0.5572838187,
-0.1413390189,
-1.0514820814,
-0.0057545067,
0.6031499505,
-0.556258738,
-0.0391042717,
0.4879315495,
0.9197400212,
-0.1064524725,
0.3588947356,
0.0757704973,
0.0738378987,
0.0979927257,
0.5297825336,
0.5882449746,
-0.4913692176,
0.4270905852,
-0.2692127526,
-0.2075389922,
-0.0839799792,
-0.8839278817,
-0.7940315604,
-0.3389104903,
-0.2938347757,
-0.2211728394,
0.0872109234,
1.092900753,
0.4509385526,
-0.8638283014,
0.0804642439,
0.1273716688,
0.0926295146,
-0.2338697016,
-0.3484022915,
0.4925273657,
-0.3289969265,
-0.8948036432,
0.6440435648,
0.2630461156,
-0.2826740146,
0.2088210136,
0.1174082607,
-0.366684407,
-0.2291444689,
0.4466538131,
0.486027956,
-0.5994313955,
-0.5613335371,
0.3455412686,
0.0060144234,
0.0567739569,
0.6683337092,
-0.6791517735,
0.7503239512,
0.1813315302,
1.0598547459,
0.3687595129,
0.0406538248,
0.5475228429,
-0.9024367332,
-0.1717818528,
0.1279957592,
0.3159670234,
0.264367342,
-0.5148225427,
0.5515242815,
-0.19100447,
-0.5549093485,
-0.9586643577,
-0.1094856858,
-0.7773020267,
0.0690193474,
1.108119607,
-0.2572795451,
-0.2866888344,
0.2638764977,
-0.2500896752,
0.3072894514,
-0.4363103807,
0.5815262198,
0.5904382467,
-0.0468734019,
-0.2389001697,
-0.6150050759,
0.1002909765,
0.2276229858,
-0.6039611101,
-0.0224338509,
0.3857486248,
0.2106030434,
0.061114002,
0.3366574645,
-0.1115527004,
0.3157106638,
-0.2829535604,
0.1597328484,
-0.2767999172,
-0.4948837459,
-0.3402597904,
-0.0477432422,
0.1702927202,
-0.3462327421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17304v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17304v1
|
Leveraging LLMs for Dialogue Quality Measurement
| 2024-06-25T06:19:47 | 2024-06-25T06:19:47 |
Jinghan Jia, Abi Komma, Timothy Leffel, Xujun Peng, Ajay Nagesh, Tamer Soliman, Aram Galstyan, Anoop Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In task-oriented conversational AI evaluation, unsupervised methods poorly
correlate with human judgments, and supervised approaches lack generalization.
Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) show robust zeroshot and
few-shot capabilities across NLP tasks. This paper explores using LLMs for
automated dialogue quality evaluation, experimenting with various
configurations on public and proprietary datasets. Manipulating factors such as
model size, in-context examples, and selection techniques, we examine
"chain-of-thought" (CoT) reasoning and label extraction procedures. Our results
show that (1) larger models yield more accurate dialogue labels; (2)
algorithmic selection of in-context examples outperforms random selection; (3)
CoT reasoning where an LLM is asked to provide justifications before outputting
final labels improves performance; and (4) fine-tuned LLMs outperform
out-of-the-box ones. Our results indicate that LLMs that are suitably
fine-tuned and have sufficient reasoning capabilities can be leveraged for
automated dialogue evaluation.
|
[
-0.602266252,
-0.7505124807,
0.83637321,
-0.0792433992,
-0.3518742025,
0.3267619014,
-0.238157019,
-0.4416935146,
-0.0342900865,
0.7567679882,
-0.3822303414,
-0.632828474,
-0.6338345408,
0.2286413312,
-0.4523302019,
0.9575237632,
0.0206972975,
0.1759812981,
-0.3694354296,
-0.1652244627,
-0.3521696031,
-0.5195369124,
-0.5557931662,
-0.538598001,
0.3825132251,
0.2874204218,
0.9140478969,
0.4841037989,
0.4182312191,
0.3750525415,
-0.1443741024,
0.4524658322,
-0.4001350999,
0.1485652924,
-0.1617149413,
-0.4473987818,
-0.5946093798,
0.2584698796,
0.5466492772,
0.8157975078,
0.1239322126,
0.3112739921,
0.2127352059,
0.354067415,
-0.6166380644,
0.2113217562,
-0.6870076656,
0.0498921722,
0.3657435775,
-0.262760371,
-0.3637360334,
-0.3423790038,
0.3715500534,
-0.3028823733,
-0.1417200416,
0.1827066839,
0.8597078323,
0.4699088335,
-0.3706405461,
-0.5058783293,
-0.8560109735,
0.95771873,
-1.0616407394,
0.1499803662,
0.506722331,
0.3096283376,
-0.2685424089,
-0.5415907502,
-0.4819782078,
-0.5797902346,
-0.0427899286,
0.0809919611,
-0.2697820663,
0.3341178,
0.1808829755,
0.4917702377,
-0.2119863331,
0.3821971416,
-0.0643124208,
-0.2448173761,
0.6748360991,
0.375403136,
0.1709593683,
-0.2093225121,
-0.2607628703,
-0.0411471762,
-0.5358168483,
0.0732451603,
0.3129061162,
0.1390281171,
0.167855829,
0.6041702628,
-0.097358942,
0.9133635759,
0.006781138,
-0.2987542748,
-0.1247373074,
-0.5017330647,
-0.5291935802,
-0.2190814763,
0.9981468916,
0.5202686191,
0.1391460449,
-0.1217032596,
-0.370167613,
-0.071776852,
0.1621043086,
-0.6005375981,
-0.0794466659,
0.3501529396,
-0.371818006,
-0.2936581075,
-0.1998909265,
-0.5365080833,
-0.2070055306,
-0.6063294411,
0.3119605184,
-0.1667209268,
0.1264332235,
-0.0923480466,
-0.0565823056,
0.0600397214,
0.5344766378,
-0.5404698253,
0.2902913988,
0.7864867449,
0.6585980058,
-0.5145563483,
0.0788144991,
-0.7777277827,
-0.2339739799,
-0.6339513659,
0.8412730694,
-0.4100088179,
-0.353969872,
-0.0496148393,
-0.2770809531,
-0.0569241233,
-0.7421194315,
0.5161077976,
-0.3517189026,
0.2885537744,
0.1145138666,
-0.7276332974,
-0.0795208812,
0.5788313746,
-0.4294647872,
0.8468337059,
0.2071721852,
-0.3418680131,
0.3374330103,
-0.336602062,
-0.0770774111,
0.1385054141,
-0.2265093029,
-0.2178127766,
0.1575604379,
0.4389627278,
0.4921420515,
-0.5099675059,
0.4574075937,
-0.269638598,
-0.4705091119,
0.6352530718,
-0.8106657863,
0.5425274372,
0.3167270124,
-0.1760992259,
0.2901436388,
-0.6182107329,
0.3615852892,
-0.3499262035,
-0.2541008294,
-0.025605062,
-0.1300225407,
-0.345092833,
0.1895029247,
0.045809906,
-0.4403971434,
-0.1010022461,
-0.6044823527,
0.4417899549,
0.6039423347,
0.2106212825,
0.3500535786,
-0.3731856644,
0.5059230924,
-0.1569476128,
0.2113172114,
-0.0951531306,
-0.4686912596,
-1.1182597876,
-0.4900555313,
0.3331125379,
0.3767935038,
-0.715883255,
0.8274483085,
-0.0389396995,
-0.4123830199,
-0.5719614029,
0.3316700757,
0.4007481933,
0.3135251105,
0.1607767642,
-0.653819561,
-0.0761001185,
-0.723377049,
-0.1265824288,
-0.382545054,
-0.3795165718,
0.5672627687,
0.3703170717,
-0.319511354,
1.1502559185,
-0.3693672419,
-0.2259920239,
-0.4508783221,
0.3891067505,
0.3178407252,
0.0603333563,
0.0365097597,
-0.1352141351,
-0.1897578686,
-0.1963816285,
-0.7819894552,
-0.2359251529,
-0.3065892458,
-0.0569322966,
0.1653159559,
0.3523890376,
-0.4862824082,
0.4094866514,
0.5562508106,
-0.0442192703,
0.6302409172,
-0.1337777972,
0.1964408755,
-0.7506714463,
-0.1088654175,
0.1833785921,
-0.4747801125,
-0.5552318096,
-0.1909792572,
-0.4303772748,
-0.0529399179,
-0.5149653554,
0.4813223779,
-0.369597733,
-0.4734735191,
-0.4131702781,
0.5037616491,
0.2554817796,
0.5670235157,
-0.0030507757,
0.801600337,
0.3158664405,
-0.525698781,
0.6411777139,
0.1634996682,
-0.8576259613,
0.6005249023,
-0.6817371845,
0.3803136945,
0.0824603215,
0.5410935879,
-1.0673919916,
-0.1554476917,
0.14044258,
-0.2337576449,
0.0392966643,
-0.1379333138,
-0.5834527016,
-0.2569468915,
-0.1292883307,
0.2292947173,
0.3973602951,
-0.6023387909,
0.4082100093,
0.4597412646,
-0.221181035,
-0.2187132388,
-0.4020368755,
0.289620012,
-0.2150902152,
-0.3899756968,
-0.0627420843,
0.0229896102,
-0.4148011208,
-0.3436652124,
-0.2436289191,
-0.1540645808,
0.0510799736,
0.297458142,
0.3614150584,
-0.1283145696,
0.0779603943,
-0.0466499329,
-0.1111927181,
0.1525171697,
-0.1109564602,
0.438626796,
-0.2849926651,
-0.6519163847,
-0.799323082,
0.0346201621,
0.5669551492,
-0.0671221092,
0.2672488391,
0.5095543861,
0.0108700106,
-0.1748332828,
-0.7615696788,
-0.1810876578,
-0.4461253881,
0.2154524475,
-0.0536157899,
-0.95534724,
0.2527738512,
-0.3747791946,
0.0407993272,
0.1636695862,
0.4933526516,
-0.3789218366,
1.1579012871,
0.2122310549,
-0.1462869197,
0.3254781961,
-0.2836384773,
0.5050296783,
-0.9789654016,
-0.1183374003,
-0.4606925249,
-0.0981025547,
-0.4538215399,
-0.6737722158,
0.6001617908,
0.1917212903,
-0.2077720761,
0.2955759466,
-0.4108372927,
0.4718160033,
0.4758968055,
0.084652029,
0.6000548601,
-0.1015474275,
0.0790128633,
0.1312333643,
-0.5935394168,
-1.0357199907,
0.8386222124,
0.6089013219,
0.8462548852,
-0.2475011647,
0.4839738607,
0.2343071848,
0.3280250132,
-0.9811563492,
0.70525527,
0.0263489038,
-0.3695272803,
-0.5314109325,
-0.4825148582,
-0.7735783458,
0.3403618038,
-0.0860179961,
-1.0007586479,
-0.0592309982,
0.0989844203,
-0.5138901472,
0.1516786367,
-0.4480312169,
0.5682830215,
-0.4183705449,
-0.0436053574,
-0.2210992426,
-0.4470243752,
0.2005100101,
0.0640460402,
0.0020736877,
-0.5463472009,
0.2437405884,
0.6551095843,
-0.5132762194,
0.8650317192,
0.2436349988,
-0.3062921166,
0.7204549313,
0.1789063364,
0.3281133175,
0.0234015584,
-0.0846998468,
0.4373115897,
0.1710365117,
-0.1516899914,
-0.8765786886,
0.6491776109,
-0.8480095267,
-0.6697860956,
-0.1807499826,
-0.5086991787,
-0.6247329116,
-0.139508605,
0.0695587024,
0.4154531658,
-0.2357376218,
0.2422036082,
0.3189905882,
-0.4793023169,
0.3367376029,
0.3463771045,
-0.0917566791,
-0.4528011084,
0.8143411875,
-0.081647858,
0.6136867404,
0.2441862673,
0.1899633557,
-0.4256937206,
-0.4028741717,
-0.4933515489,
0.0109329876,
-0.7900290489,
-0.335973829,
-0.5122313499,
-0.3607937396,
-0.1745980978,
0.0839510113,
-0.4052181542,
-0.4194453955,
-0.2944396138,
-0.1279945672,
-0.013082928,
0.6530877948,
0.2103114873,
0.3343040943,
-0.7449582815,
0.273893714,
0.4533019364,
0.3151957691,
-0.0100009441,
-0.6618360877,
-0.1025743261,
0.2571904957,
-0.5404573083,
-0.5889325142,
0.5284839272,
0.0147083178,
0.5915956497,
0.2791011035,
0.0388688333,
0.5386971831,
-0.1000929624,
0.9936801195,
0.2397536933,
-1.0201611519,
0.6039240956,
-0.1663773656,
0.4910672009,
0.6528166533,
0.1256488562,
-0.2725304067,
-0.7694373131,
-0.3170544505,
-0.6641376019,
0.521350503,
0.3449707031,
0.0260469485,
-0.1797257513,
0.0679519549,
0.0226289332,
0.2544955909,
-0.3865198195,
-0.074023433,
-0.0207202882,
-0.0875407681,
-0.2177701592,
-0.1831289679,
-0.2304869592,
-0.2358365208,
0.4469105005,
-0.2913303673,
0.2229983956,
0.1559042782,
-0.118173331,
-0.0464954153,
0.4537705183,
0.2751118243,
0.8415523767,
-0.2004011422,
-0.0188104194,
0.3685289919,
0.171150133,
0.1750046313,
-0.3050435185,
0.0813333765,
0.1692312807,
0.4394131005,
0.9409028888,
0.1213580072,
-0.8919223547,
0.5202282071,
-0.0867888331,
-0.0504762754,
-0.2026868314,
0.2881643176,
-0.2366235405,
0.3249889016,
0.1449544132,
-0.1352845281,
0.261112839,
-0.7021467686,
0.0368107557,
0.5638224483,
-0.5152335167,
0.0500794426,
0.1677290648,
0.5117861032,
-0.4468083382,
0.8422285318,
0.011043705,
-0.2804986835,
0.5465338826,
0.2384495735,
0.8679552078,
0.087849915,
0.3216122389,
0.2298891842,
0.1518993527,
0.0010018961,
-0.2724759877,
-0.2619485855,
-0.817281425,
-0.7370798588,
-0.6046575308,
-1.0064003468,
0.3027025163,
-0.6980116367,
0.1595017761,
-0.5318123102,
-0.4586833715,
-0.1111661121,
-0.0333032645,
-0.7814131379,
0.2980432212,
0.2976007462,
0.6639589071,
-0.5685960054,
0.5328269005,
0.1845396757,
-0.1968298107,
-0.725631237,
-0.0441016294,
0.008333928,
-0.7600739598,
0.5336774588,
0.1215186194,
-0.3669616282,
-0.324950695,
-0.5717993379,
-0.7568611503,
0.9533312917,
0.3398447037,
-0.7411906719,
0.1026885957,
0.3019099236,
0.903627038,
-0.5519502163,
0.7167348266,
0.9041757584,
0.2305752784,
0.2397997826,
-1.111384511,
-0.257260859,
0.1544727534,
0.0836957321,
-0.0344131105,
-0.2977233529,
0.2365948856,
-0.0641991273,
-0.0920813605,
0.2984003723,
0.5217546821,
0.3385420144,
0.4473363757,
0.5604017973,
0.3431882858,
0.6264718175,
-0.1432516873,
1.0113501549,
-0.2476998121,
0.2480894476,
1.3419942856,
-0.4243745506,
0.8463311791,
0.2896542251,
-0.0960659608,
0.3460893929,
0.5184652805,
-0.0352957696,
0.2416976988,
0.4569534659,
-0.2962638438,
-0.4377306998,
-0.4213615358,
0.1284959614,
0.7544273734,
0.5369603634,
-0.5119740367,
-0.1925841123,
0.0209991615,
-0.1551331729,
-0.0027551656,
-0.1694910377,
1.2201346159,
0.2731741369,
-1.0526131392,
0.748277843,
-0.1940110177,
0.4377603531,
-0.096453689,
-0.0534845963,
-0.256868422,
-0.0097448817,
-0.0544865392,
-1.0255386829,
0.2654535174,
0.2507115602,
0.2531558573,
-0.3543778062,
0.5058118701,
-0.3752950728,
-0.3878248632,
0.3013716936,
0.6190806031,
0.5891634226,
-0.0156940911,
-0.655348599,
0.2711224854,
-0.1254330575,
-0.0640389994,
0.3472482562,
0.2691898048,
0.0362379178,
0.7877965569,
0.5414912701,
0.0689454526,
-0.3043357134,
0.4839029908,
0.8550972939,
-0.4964268804,
-0.0398898721,
-0.7531449199,
0.3119481206,
-0.2253420353,
-0.3089575171,
0.5607289076,
0.3254057169,
0.8065575361,
0.3283731341,
0.6470440626,
0.4911026657,
0.4322761595,
-0.4962401688,
0.4784589708,
-0.2100083828,
0.4142922461,
-0.3430488408,
-1.1183462143,
-0.2141524553,
0.6896414757,
-0.4365647435,
-0.1179207563,
0.5639989376,
0.8299885988,
0.1581409723,
0.085188143,
0.6742843986,
0.1198092923,
0.5522353053,
0.4331205785,
1.1737582684,
-0.2820112109,
0.546462059,
-0.0171474963,
-0.3264959455,
-0.1577882618,
-0.9093008637,
-1.0971465111,
-0.3301104605,
-0.5195959806,
-0.2165530622,
0.1206286997,
1.1224365234,
0.8358849883,
-0.7169851065,
-0.3760974705,
-0.0114217475,
0.1574503779,
0.0422778316,
-0.1977398694,
0.0331157818,
-0.5320612788,
-0.7913075089,
0.6102084517,
0.4987508357,
-0.0551727191,
-0.3721224368,
-0.0752129182,
0.1189355031,
0.3210086524,
0.7427458167,
-0.0475478396,
-1.0307403803,
-0.3313983381,
-0.3891133368,
-0.253477633,
0.1114151701,
0.6843343973,
-0.7103220224,
0.621045053,
0.4025444686,
0.5855306387,
0.4252494872,
0.3309966922,
0.7812629342,
-0.6246959567,
-0.194400683,
0.5057843328,
0.314258337,
0.3824496567,
-0.1250503361,
0.4278360605,
-0.3417788148,
-0.8164215684,
-0.777118206,
0.0952271223,
-0.8797982335,
-0.1196828261,
1.3663725853,
-0.3995286524,
-0.0571318418,
-0.1441087574,
-0.3755088151,
0.1167765558,
-0.3959826827,
0.7705426216,
0.8038678169,
-0.4708990455,
-0.1851296574,
-0.5413403511,
0.3572685719,
0.4056967199,
-1.0096714497,
-0.2178685367,
0.5742453337,
0.0906732753,
0.251493305,
0.6135578156,
-0.0001417673,
0.0480155982,
-0.3195920885,
-0.2515718937,
0.115151681,
-0.3131878674,
-0.34631598,
-0.072813876,
0.3665749431,
-0.1930260807
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17300v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17300v1
|
CausalScore: An Automatic Reference-Free Metric for Assessing Response Relevance in Open-Domain Dialogue Systems
| 2024-06-25T06:08:16 | 2024-06-25T06:08:16 |
Tao Feng, Lizhen Qu, Xiaoxi Kang, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatically evaluating the quality of responses in open-domain dialogue
systems is a challenging but crucial task. Current evaluation metrics often
fail to align with human judgments, especially when assessing responses that
are grammatically correct. To address this issue, we propose a novel metric,
called CausalScore, which assesses the relevance of responses by measuring the
causal strength between dialogue histories and responses. The causal strength
is estimated by utilizing both unconditional dependence and conditional
dependencies from the dialogue history to responses. We compare our metric with
the existing competitive metrics in terms of their alignment with human
judgements. Our experimental results demonstrate that CausalScore significantly
surpasses existing state-of-the-art metrics by aligning better with human
judgements. Additionally, we collect a new dialogue dataset CGDIALOG+ with
human-annotated causal relations and a set of pairwise human judgements to
facilitate the development of future automatic metrics.
|
[
-0.3550668061,
-0.4249512851,
0.6184849143,
0.3201988041,
-0.0582708083,
-0.1083567962,
-0.1841223687,
-0.3199641705,
0.0716850236,
0.3241943717,
-0.323962003,
-0.2075101584,
-0.5252574086,
0.0832756236,
-0.0755821317,
0.9513455033,
0.0921297818,
0.2436244339,
-0.6729477644,
-0.5972386599,
-0.8834303021,
-0.4066322446,
-0.4538049102,
-0.158746779,
0.6935659647,
0.2678028941,
0.7786411047,
0.1005953252,
0.7156674266,
0.3093824387,
0.2239102572,
0.1870030463,
-0.4964575171,
0.074507229,
-0.5959025025,
-0.1197170764,
-0.6132717729,
0.2796159089,
0.5303151608,
0.8065422773,
0.0249871574,
0.4972785711,
0.2815071642,
0.3319664896,
-0.8363557458,
0.3099574447,
-0.3518123031,
-0.2480111569,
0.2020900548,
-0.6638847589,
-0.4805663526,
-0.7192897797,
0.4236653149,
-0.6811724305,
0.1443175077,
0.3028972745,
0.862875402,
0.2827095985,
-0.7305892706,
-0.0935376063,
-0.9081842303,
0.603631258,
-0.9084773064,
0.3412951231,
0.339066118,
0.6295397878,
-0.2551124394,
-0.555544734,
-0.4458556473,
-0.3717804551,
-0.4865555465,
0.3600452542,
-0.3369862139,
0.0297714788,
0.1382682621,
0.271527797,
-0.5196303725,
-0.1179591939,
-0.2636888623,
-0.3547763824,
0.4937532842,
0.5908358693,
0.3343353868,
-0.1237951592,
-0.3665869236,
0.098965995,
-0.39080441,
0.2473587245,
0.1955835819,
0.4532909393,
0.0991415456,
0.3846494257,
-0.2802964747,
0.7138493657,
0.2087101042,
-0.1891797632,
-0.1974146366,
-0.6530870795,
-0.3681733012,
0.0768220723,
1.127125144,
0.5886346102,
-0.0486101694,
-0.2868391573,
0.3108227551,
0.1794853956,
0.4742321968,
-0.7275319695,
-0.0665407255,
-0.0631606877,
-0.2301937491,
-0.0914331377,
0.321290344,
-0.6546553373,
-0.2639431357,
-0.3268111348,
0.5750849247,
0.1272081733,
-0.0186546613,
0.114651747,
-0.0805066973,
-0.157767728,
0.7274983525,
-0.4734945595,
0.3964320719,
0.5921829343,
0.6038698554,
-0.0154833347,
0.016109135,
-0.8757023215,
-0.0444798432,
-0.3972528279,
0.7977137566,
-0.3081274629,
-0.2212207466,
-0.1310746372,
0.0397751778,
-0.0577337556,
-0.4618448019,
1.0752027035,
-0.5964779854,
0.6075627208,
-0.1282954812,
-0.4240549505,
-0.3036065996,
-0.0039621987,
-0.5061358213,
0.8085469604,
0.2322032154,
-0.8404837847,
0.6515911818,
-0.1205449551,
-0.2178699374,
0.0062960424,
-0.1503053457,
-0.2798478603,
0.0420267805,
-0.0905523673,
0.0713713095,
-1.0866868496,
0.7208263278,
-0.6875889897,
-0.1979149133,
0.2560870945,
-0.5640089512,
0.7046066523,
-0.0231358428,
-0.4216123819,
0.2142140567,
-0.9211508036,
0.0787853003,
-0.2511112988,
-0.0532720499,
-0.6141808629,
0.1433973312,
-0.4982711077,
0.5165251493,
0.0587429963,
-0.6910641193,
-0.1675770134,
-0.2578032017,
-0.130883798,
0.6904079914,
0.2357674837,
0.2902370393,
-0.2318318337,
0.2081409544,
-0.0598410666,
0.318305552,
-0.0332756117,
-0.5937979817,
-0.8070905209,
-0.296808809,
0.0708957762,
0.5856199861,
-0.1219907627,
0.9360933304,
-0.4940259755,
-0.4660188854,
-0.3848483562,
-0.0991324633,
0.5325275064,
0.9582148194,
0.3008898497,
-0.9254643321,
-0.3770498931,
-0.9046418667,
-0.4726021588,
-0.844352901,
-0.2983463705,
0.7152729034,
0.0541476384,
0.1299343407,
1.3511039019,
-0.6011449695,
-0.3551995456,
0.3233741224,
0.4323962629,
0.1942873299,
0.1520970464,
0.3078201413,
-0.307025969,
-0.2322003245,
-0.1250983924,
-0.9689821005,
-0.6293617487,
-0.0366031453,
-0.3208125234,
-0.1822874099,
0.1949548423,
-0.4685453176,
0.5269119143,
0.2618843019,
-0.7939707637,
0.7137001753,
0.0349093936,
0.7689779401,
-0.7401309013,
0.588383913,
0.029811617,
-0.1241067722,
-0.4399968982,
-0.4195370674,
0.0111501478,
-0.0518347323,
-0.5254734159,
0.778883934,
-0.0416609533,
-0.0095252767,
0.2282390445,
0.4189631641,
-0.0113855973,
0.6900213957,
-0.2894292772,
0.6825507283,
-0.0658823624,
-0.6331496239,
0.4441480935,
0.5429209471,
-0.4799085557,
1.1295039654,
-0.7255197167,
-0.014721958,
0.2093520612,
0.442559123,
-1.3644589186,
-0.1990493834,
0.270000428,
-0.6166424751,
-0.2259500474,
-0.0732741281,
-0.3652568758,
-0.4663686752,
-0.005652701,
0.6520097256,
0.1057036296,
-0.4639344513,
0.3484374285,
0.1530317515,
-0.2276939005,
-0.2526528835,
-0.0749432519,
0.0684876218,
-0.3113085628,
-0.7136299014,
-0.2218869925,
-0.2008170485,
-0.3464022279,
-0.1547335535,
-0.3839808404,
-0.0231607687,
0.0724519417,
0.370988518,
0.3785316348,
-0.3040815592,
-0.0150602376,
-0.1078763083,
-0.2568227351,
0.3614301383,
-0.3075419366,
0.0294045098,
0.1226351261,
-0.4868266582,
-0.5612999201,
0.1517896354,
0.9014037251,
-0.0682381913,
0.4075844288,
0.1121091694,
-0.0894814804,
0.4186139107,
-0.5737848282,
0.0360679738,
-0.404324919,
-0.0241349805,
-0.0240662582,
-0.9332917929,
0.3016221225,
-0.071020402,
-0.0824279785,
0.6077660322,
0.4528074265,
0.1496039331,
1.331807971,
0.2410602123,
-0.2440134734,
0.1499791443,
0.5341560245,
0.4996163845,
-0.7946926355,
-0.3105790317,
-0.8560643196,
-0.0225776881,
-0.2805161774,
-0.1734770238,
0.4896654189,
0.2211955041,
-0.6873072982,
0.4661076367,
-0.060600616,
0.0524917431,
0.4305047989,
-0.1177537963,
0.5921518207,
-0.3969030678,
-0.2512852252,
-0.2014194727,
-0.3893946707,
-0.5845460296,
0.8904308677,
0.0276246052,
0.7811028361,
0.4209601879,
0.1582502425,
0.4391315579,
0.4473951161,
-0.670229435,
0.5574371815,
0.2688597739,
-0.4677092433,
-0.2711231709,
-0.6448481679,
-0.8857834339,
0.3288854361,
-0.037759874,
-1.0444604158,
0.1767441332,
0.030392589,
-0.5382345319,
-0.0319911577,
-0.5191483498,
0.8043230176,
-0.1880062968,
-0.5424565673,
-0.1075275764,
-0.7290335894,
0.3548877239,
-0.0492127575,
-0.0149903996,
-0.3756456077,
0.2722614408,
0.806040585,
-0.6701890826,
0.8457117677,
0.0046757488,
-0.2135700583,
0.1906415969,
0.2642342746,
0.1994269788,
0.2480627745,
0.2651270032,
0.1021055132,
-0.1590906084,
-0.1771064848,
-1.057043314,
0.6927087903,
-0.6140429974,
-0.8714780211,
-0.407838881,
-0.1727294624,
-0.600607872,
0.2570011914,
-0.1673747748,
0.5438916087,
-0.8933581114,
0.047594253,
0.3148400486,
-0.2587771416,
0.09710031,
1.0732575655,
0.0035046614,
-0.7394541502,
0.5003068447,
-0.1698201895,
0.388733834,
0.4974026978,
0.2358264476,
-0.197906211,
0.2981340885,
-0.5085546374,
0.0703403503,
-0.4923382998,
-0.585506916,
-0.6845035553,
-0.0127076032,
-0.2699812055,
-0.0053672837,
-0.0528335981,
-0.5958634615,
-0.1835111231,
0.0158420522,
0.1184421629,
0.3505041897,
-0.054643292,
-0.0682863966,
-0.7478892207,
0.2220406681,
0.6553632617,
0.4296852052,
0.1174776331,
-0.6621813178,
-0.2884431481,
-0.0259120334,
-0.5277656913,
-0.607611835,
0.1385066658,
0.1791593134,
0.5482808352,
0.5261796117,
0.3281385303,
0.7017487288,
-0.5584375262,
1.0805785656,
0.4676455259,
-0.8631415367,
0.6328646541,
-0.5344700217,
0.3751863241,
0.7183479667,
0.2578380406,
-0.6560662389,
-0.9150155783,
-0.6214333177,
-0.7513126731,
0.7500613928,
0.1625108272,
-0.1444810927,
-0.0497226901,
-0.0626550242,
-0.0127286334,
0.1630874127,
0.0691061169,
-0.1534028351,
0.0252848025,
-0.0329849795,
-0.3616736829,
0.1309267282,
-0.4585079253,
-0.4042200744,
0.4576288462,
-0.1089484021,
0.4837259948,
0.2945363224,
-0.2118865252,
-0.4066176414,
0.3080276251,
0.5935622454,
0.6501224637,
-0.4214642346,
0.0730392039,
0.1623028517,
-0.2826411724,
0.3984342813,
-0.0292586517,
0.0949761122,
0.0064286767,
0.4329843223,
0.7819692492,
0.6670393348,
-0.5385660529,
0.8578711748,
-0.4026816189,
0.0752336085,
-0.0239297617,
0.0665153265,
-0.3593654037,
0.2212176323,
0.2624069452,
0.2321573496,
0.3861007988,
-0.3504539132,
0.414579004,
0.2459232062,
-0.8663182259,
-0.4086737931,
0.9163675308,
0.4085407555,
-0.2621718645,
0.473849684,
0.1205173582,
-0.3094723821,
0.526614666,
0.4349404275,
1.2017823458,
-0.2601812184,
0.2165869772,
0.7965250015,
-0.0019236954,
0.1991983354,
-0.3707251251,
-0.2746574283,
-0.5077201724,
-0.1182692051,
-0.4638182521,
-0.5234754682,
-0.1813782752,
-0.9199148417,
0.1761917472,
-0.4171853662,
-0.4660210907,
-0.0258805696,
-0.0818543956,
-0.7289057374,
0.3183388412,
-0.3457280993,
0.748020947,
-0.8242784739,
0.3275003135,
0.2452030629,
-0.7140718102,
-0.7213887572,
0.0721777081,
0.4277065098,
-0.4865061939,
0.9363459349,
-0.018467335,
-0.5864077806,
-0.3106137812,
-0.1224672124,
-0.7761836648,
1.0747718811,
0.3200264871,
-0.1682594866,
0.2624114156,
0.0899850652,
0.7430363894,
-0.2473821491,
0.7655206919,
0.6844603419,
0.3602080345,
-0.1644030958,
-1.4079190493,
0.2815087438,
-0.4933087826,
-0.1576277316,
0.4904530048,
-0.821765542,
0.1526033282,
-0.0279284846,
-0.4156832397,
0.4072648287,
0.5850867033,
-0.2297206372,
0.4095815718,
0.3905392587,
0.672257781,
0.5861968994,
-0.2167546153,
0.71911937,
-0.2058928907,
0.489412725,
1.2965979576,
-0.3376219273,
0.709030211,
0.2770257592,
-0.122522682,
0.6120297313,
0.2527076602,
0.2698410451,
0.5251566768,
0.2161785513,
-0.5722538233,
-0.2128411233,
-0.2980903387,
-0.1204100922,
0.2527917624,
0.1410983503,
-0.1222486869,
-0.4013819396,
-0.3022722304,
0.136803478,
0.0244586505,
0.0051248483,
1.0949721336,
0.0370620601,
-1.1129574776,
0.6504427791,
-0.3518733978,
0.1820196658,
-0.6385295987,
0.0523949377,
-0.3721312881,
0.2275734544,
-0.1351055056,
-0.7036736012,
0.1523530781,
0.1240004078,
-0.1335265338,
0.0757891759,
0.3666215241,
-0.2982885838,
0.0061034942,
0.5848708749,
0.3836747408,
-0.1886464506,
0.3746165931,
-0.3247745037,
-0.3095965385,
-0.3719390631,
-0.0012668154,
0.3609267175,
0.4309766889,
-0.265961647,
0.5374726057,
0.5572734475,
-0.2301501781,
-0.3182539344,
0.2194493413,
0.7491620779,
-0.6834414005,
-0.4174074829,
-0.4951312542,
0.5732702017,
-0.2407632321,
-0.5684629083,
0.9527549148,
0.5059222579,
0.6321472526,
0.2252574861,
0.5953907967,
0.0176177248,
0.6396328807,
-0.1694222093,
0.5443694592,
-0.4962605238,
0.0981359556,
-0.8128240705,
-0.9567257762,
-0.4582608342,
0.1896113306,
-0.3776319027,
-0.229001537,
0.920743227,
0.8249391317,
-0.2079850286,
0.139357388,
0.3900673389,
0.1478973031,
0.4172422886,
0.5164973736,
1.0144438744,
-0.3876229227,
0.5489640236,
0.4420245588,
-0.6583393812,
-0.324493438,
-0.8254824281,
-0.7093481421,
-0.6538206935,
-0.185014531,
-0.4115630984,
0.2079445422,
0.8069156408,
0.4823991656,
-0.8780516386,
-0.4784581959,
0.1585641652,
-0.0971327946,
-0.2816534936,
-0.2721749544,
0.3169303834,
-0.5129146576,
-0.2495607585,
0.3024788201,
0.6314062476,
-0.337133348,
-0.0875563845,
-0.2084734887,
0.0609892905,
0.5598765612,
0.7359151244,
0.5583758354,
-0.7490344048,
-0.7623695135,
-0.2383788228,
-0.3975860178,
-0.0147896055,
1.271463275,
-0.7565457821,
0.7609192729,
0.655393362,
0.4820622802,
0.0940271318,
0.1614051014,
1.0163104534,
-0.4925615191,
-0.0323270597,
0.1493580937,
0.2184565216,
0.1220032573,
-0.1694629937,
0.521502614,
0.3412424028,
-0.7726081014,
-0.5978358388,
0.1661684811,
-1.1415308714,
0.2107144892,
0.8722243309,
-0.3763924241,
0.2209200859,
-0.2973417342,
-0.3551823795,
0.2335297018,
-0.5518211126,
0.8076355457,
0.6745918393,
-0.1761240661,
0.3484472036,
-0.3654924929,
0.4522846341,
0.4899845123,
-0.8277650476,
0.1987055987,
0.9329131842,
0.0048507899,
0.2918969691,
0.7930299044,
-0.2373463511,
0.4599115849,
-0.1934828013,
-0.3892148733,
0.4505794048,
-0.3458494842,
-0.0509183854,
-0.0070728627,
0.0001433052,
0.0389237665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17294v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17294v2
|
Math-LLaVA: Bootstrapping Mathematical Reasoning for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-06-25T05:43:21 | 2024-06-26T16:43:27 |
Wenhao Shi, Zhiqiang Hu, Yi Bin, Junhua Liu, Yang Yang, See-Kiong Ng, Lidong Bing, Roy Ka-Wei Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive reasoning
capabilities, particularly in textual mathematical problem-solving. However,
existing open-source image instruction fine-tuning datasets, containing limited
question-answer pairs per image, do not fully exploit visual information to
enhance the multimodal mathematical reasoning capabilities of Multimodal LLMs
(MLLMs). To bridge this gap, we address the lack of high-quality, diverse
multimodal mathematical datasets by collecting 40K high-quality images with
question-answer pairs from 24 existing datasets and synthesizing 320K new
pairs, creating the MathV360K dataset, which enhances both the breadth and
depth of multimodal mathematical questions. We introduce Math-LLaVA, a
LLaVA-1.5-based model fine-tuned with MathV360K. This novel approach
significantly improves the multimodal mathematical reasoning capabilities of
LLaVA-1.5, achieving a 19-point increase and comparable performance to GPT-4V
on MathVista's minitest split. Furthermore, Math-LLaVA demonstrates enhanced
generalizability, showing substantial improvements on the MMMU benchmark. Our
research highlights the importance of dataset diversity and synthesis in
advancing MLLMs' mathematical reasoning abilities. The code and data are
available at: \url{https://github.com/HZQ950419/Math-LLaVA}.
|
[
-0.4220002592,
-0.6951004267,
0.5330112576,
0.3528177142,
-0.1739011705,
0.2850601971,
-0.2327237576,
-0.2241320461,
0.0735358596,
0.2734696567,
-0.7763646841,
-0.5039398074,
-0.3223746717,
0.00872235,
-0.0445442125,
0.7328959703,
-0.1846553981,
0.2501048744,
-0.8166275024,
-0.2710312605,
-0.4877249897,
-0.1825070977,
-0.1299125254,
-0.1596994996,
0.6477407813,
0.5383719802,
0.7049946785,
0.3110658526,
0.6055304408,
0.3568549752,
0.3207701743,
0.5448625684,
-0.39489007,
0.493852973,
0.0345435515,
-0.6338144541,
-0.4154243469,
-0.2371659577,
0.6106967926,
0.5037395358,
-0.1081761047,
0.36337623,
-0.3567364514,
0.7350940108,
-0.7267190218,
0.5223762393,
-0.6707544327,
-0.1468972117,
-0.2345748544,
-0.0606734082,
-0.3201922774,
-0.3694726229,
-0.2540249527,
-0.9440365434,
-0.1730542034,
-0.0113087827,
0.671628356,
0.3492790461,
-0.3920237124,
-0.0935906693,
-0.4680370688,
1.026021719,
-0.3988301158,
0.4850231409,
0.5989894271,
0.6421148777,
0.1416510195,
-0.4897442162,
-0.3495620191,
0.0450345874,
0.2760797441,
0.0023879176,
-0.2274742275,
-0.2947231233,
0.3507957458,
0.252140969,
-0.5457009077,
-0.1143486202,
-0.4403876066,
-0.3142611682,
0.6051092148,
0.3266818523,
0.0702371001,
-0.0333252139,
-0.1221070066,
-0.1014818996,
-0.809337914,
0.0383687243,
0.3638223708,
-0.0074492898,
-0.1151843742,
0.8102858663,
-0.055103153,
0.7335865498,
-0.4364009798,
-0.5184933543,
0.3694686294,
-0.400909543,
-0.3798873723,
-0.4164860845,
0.4833768308,
0.3218795359,
0.4513328373,
0.1998163015,
-0.317792654,
0.336160332,
-0.1389100403,
-0.8369040489,
-0.1518927664,
0.102533564,
-0.074090153,
-0.2758125067,
-0.4292645752,
-0.8724105358,
-0.2231580764,
-0.6436736584,
0.3533577323,
-0.4625749588,
-0.0700199977,
0.1022407487,
0.2373791039,
0.2444229871,
0.7936042547,
-0.850410521,
0.1137813255,
0.6624487042,
0.5095232129,
0.100303635,
-0.0506577715,
-0.7288503647,
-0.0911592767,
-0.4312575161,
0.7487760186,
-0.8127582669,
0.0034414195,
-0.0152739547,
-0.1820474863,
0.1183134988,
-0.4422759414,
0.2771560252,
-0.649404645,
0.2340716124,
-0.2904819548,
-0.3942949474,
-0.1052281484,
0.5177143216,
-0.5436995625,
0.96196872,
-0.0430945866,
-0.3994217515,
0.0784908757,
-0.4108949304,
-0.2965388894,
0.0564657375,
-0.3472822607,
-0.4386909604,
0.0407476053,
0.7998262644,
0.2489337623,
-0.6042340994,
0.2205647677,
-0.442563504,
-0.0814190358,
0.4369699359,
-0.5963667035,
0.731908977,
0.3231013417,
0.1515812427,
0.0614892505,
-0.9377297163,
0.0907282904,
0.2962707579,
-0.2111789882,
-0.2713353634,
-0.3734883368,
0.048805438,
0.2043794394,
0.2413320988,
-0.4199535847,
0.3667805791,
-0.0802909583,
0.2698466182,
0.9521425366,
-0.3231374323,
0.2947171926,
-0.4092735052,
0.8042613864,
-0.0553943031,
0.1872448921,
-0.6151170731,
-0.8269268274,
-0.7396249771,
-0.6517011523,
0.4392694533,
0.5892315507,
-1.0369637012,
-0.3085184693,
-0.2036727518,
-0.3148210645,
-0.6576681733,
0.4274838865,
0.4020184577,
0.48811239,
0.3199988902,
0.0921486616,
-0.4993465245,
-0.9965331554,
-0.1206612363,
0.2092895061,
-0.0999933332,
0.3669424057,
0.6190988421,
-0.0509613045,
0.7104110718,
-0.5757446289,
-0.2280894667,
0.0038716665,
-0.0902177617,
0.0962619409,
0.2725065649,
0.4497366846,
-0.8484678864,
-0.3728605509,
-0.1206487194,
-0.8862002492,
-0.1123743057,
-0.1120319813,
-0.3242268264,
-0.0184715874,
0.2379173785,
-0.6386893988,
0.3896827698,
0.5830324292,
-0.2280775011,
0.6282734871,
-0.0298543833,
0.277490586,
-1.0911251307,
-0.218824774,
0.0946806148,
-0.3199103773,
-0.3021081388,
0.2040402144,
0.1163401827,
-0.1222907975,
-0.407253325,
0.383400619,
-0.3722898364,
-0.2148051411,
0.1107556447,
0.0889992043,
0.1395529807,
0.5854734778,
-0.4047065079,
0.8971765637,
0.721419096,
-0.2617931068,
0.8418355584,
0.2585810721,
-0.5376499295,
0.7745625973,
-0.5445716381,
0.0598652251,
-0.172699675,
0.1231737584,
-1.1163468361,
-0.403198868,
0.0198538769,
-0.4530425966,
0.1245092377,
-0.3458435237,
-0.7538737059,
0.0777173862,
-0.2468818128,
0.9161741138,
0.5083342791,
-0.4738288224,
0.7411437035,
0.3456179202,
-0.3069084287,
-0.6405929327,
-0.6527173519,
0.0706682876,
-0.0220557973,
-0.8967341185,
-0.0059552155,
-0.3451677263,
-0.6359865069,
-0.1110143811,
0.0141324829,
-0.0960786492,
-0.210459426,
0.2121478319,
0.6744554639,
-0.3808401823,
0.5077795982,
0.3047036827,
-0.1734213978,
0.0816344395,
-0.2439746559,
0.4201530218,
-0.4577397108,
-0.6403923631,
-0.1704895347,
0.193989709,
0.7079660296,
-0.5144723654,
0.5088897347,
0.4266209304,
-0.4347529411,
0.0350765884,
-0.5867672563,
0.0209802929,
-0.4651072919,
0.1114275604,
-0.5438798666,
-0.820763886,
0.3672499061,
-0.0883130059,
0.2952969074,
0.2953161895,
0.8398765922,
-0.242247954,
0.8636075854,
0.1680144817,
0.3097050488,
0.1668113917,
-0.1807066947,
-0.2061390728,
-0.5122466087,
-0.4301988482,
-0.1045370698,
-0.4293849766,
-0.283478111,
-0.8152558208,
0.4701654911,
-0.3667599559,
-0.1019238234,
-0.1177548394,
-0.1758420169,
0.797021687,
0.3501437306,
0.1281672567,
0.4674031734,
0.4577282369,
-0.3145986795,
-0.4371650815,
-0.425693363,
-0.1184249073,
1.2591776848,
0.2635723948,
1.0258871317,
0.2801254094,
0.3813951612,
0.0651905313,
0.3010528684,
-0.7128309608,
0.5725306869,
0.1021578684,
-0.6324809194,
-0.2044724226,
-0.626480937,
-0.8498885632,
0.4884251356,
-0.314846009,
-0.3934234381,
-0.1295449734,
0.1086300835,
-0.1520255357,
0.2437992096,
-0.6454133391,
0.6495116949,
-0.3471745253,
-0.6960272789,
-0.2589093745,
-0.4042000175,
0.6913817525,
-0.1461028755,
0.6585241556,
-0.3794117868,
-0.0793958455,
0.4421229661,
-0.3932215571,
0.7784935236,
0.019822998,
-0.5211425424,
0.2289405167,
0.3547346294,
0.2986854017,
0.2869270742,
0.2795290649,
0.1019476503,
-0.0217317864,
-0.5398872495,
-0.8823266029,
0.851118207,
-0.6138758063,
-0.4985050261,
-0.2271550596,
-1.0869334936,
-0.4334417284,
0.0403093062,
-0.1733080447,
0.7382588983,
0.4223059416,
0.4344873726,
0.7414545417,
-0.1507081538,
0.1493148506,
0.0963851213,
-0.6437764168,
-0.809707582,
0.9682358503,
-0.0830959603,
0.3271157444,
0.5621542931,
0.130760029,
-0.3334608674,
-0.0891702548,
-0.6129549146,
0.3382724226,
-1.0935381651,
-0.4654347897,
-0.1430672705,
0.0285623558,
-0.2198325098,
-0.0472615659,
-0.489913702,
-0.7501624823,
-0.0165435802,
0.1107098162,
0.6143061519,
0.4236992598,
0.1071423516,
-0.1327852011,
-0.5641623139,
0.5041205287,
0.655095458,
0.2962072492,
-0.2743248641,
-0.5017609,
-0.0345445573,
0.1540594697,
-0.1438468993,
-0.647031188,
0.2781565785,
0.0894413888,
0.2200167477,
0.1577346921,
-0.2790821493,
0.9143861532,
-0.4923151433,
0.4304586351,
0.4541873336,
-0.8533436656,
0.5676119328,
-0.3868363202,
0.4341424406,
0.258004427,
0.2316405922,
-0.1292258203,
-0.0024695343,
-0.2782688737,
-0.5169107914,
0.2625054717,
0.5536842346,
0.0483804867,
0.4656318724,
0.1168140173,
0.2794611454,
0.2631123066,
-0.6135776639,
-0.2744472325,
-0.3254476488,
-0.3948518038,
-0.0163278542,
-0.0274187047,
-0.4123051763,
-0.647988081,
0.3756057322,
-0.3351337314,
0.0986211225,
-0.2821155488,
-0.3704634905,
-0.0333133042,
0.3553657234,
0.9227942824,
0.9784457088,
0.0500284173,
0.3134438694,
0.1435300112,
-0.4378153384,
0.237240091,
0.2185074985,
0.0204070862,
-0.1051396728,
0.435279727,
0.723356545,
0.3781535029,
-0.9849797487,
0.4732331932,
-0.1640806794,
-0.5377826095,
-0.2082577795,
-0.1754599661,
0.156882301,
0.3914380372,
0.4047918916,
0.2096272707,
-0.2452328354,
-0.2609020472,
0.1041328833,
0.4635256231,
0.1726861894,
-0.2395279408,
0.5790893435,
-0.0276414808,
-0.1204454452,
0.674508214,
0.0643874183,
-0.1259595156,
0.567655623,
0.469560653,
0.3309260607,
-0.0203659795,
0.2326763421,
0.272249639,
0.3696433008,
0.3072598577,
0.4146345258,
-0.139302969,
-0.5817357302,
-0.7652924061,
-0.5444580913,
-0.379080832,
0.0192472171,
-0.4878511727,
0.2863107324,
-0.5285226703,
0.1001055762,
0.0177318659,
-0.2953875661,
-0.7963995337,
0.1029698551,
0.3240582049,
0.6711806059,
-0.6167657971,
0.7210154533,
0.6661925316,
-0.4989606142,
-0.4681462049,
-0.3873223066,
-0.0422415249,
-1.3086810112,
0.8408018351,
0.0797095522,
-0.1155156121,
-0.1827289611,
-0.867043972,
-0.8284906149,
1.1353462934,
0.8132923245,
-0.7289649248,
0.0027997685,
0.2749323845,
0.3089441359,
-0.3300505579,
0.2690919936,
0.1913025081,
0.4499520361,
0.6090862751,
-0.8763909936,
-0.1237554923,
-0.4060964584,
-0.0269898139,
0.220176667,
-0.4862514436,
0.8726352453,
-0.413474381,
0.1923329979,
-0.0162868295,
0.6252639294,
0.6998220682,
0.4585234225,
0.4276027381,
0.7661873102,
0.6819623709,
-0.083711043,
0.8458955884,
0.0288145505,
0.3306622505,
0.7676423788,
-0.0139298122,
0.7694138885,
0.5838332176,
-0.3131873608,
0.6557731628,
0.4268829226,
-0.0539735258,
0.3822080791,
0.1976788342,
-0.2661559284,
-0.8808438778,
0.1075724065,
-0.4061751366,
0.5045948625,
0.6000294089,
-0.1033904776,
-0.4203568101,
0.0943748206,
-0.12704584,
0.0474058278,
-0.2787892222,
0.2917982638,
0.0657069311,
-0.5351660252,
0.8213327527,
-0.1208903342,
0.3362335563,
-0.6184538603,
-0.3689144254,
-0.3979516923,
0.1758840084,
-0.1980788112,
-0.8415277004,
-0.0511809103,
0.0676796585,
-0.012140057,
-0.1955073923,
0.5791599751,
-0.4577043653,
-0.9233850837,
-0.2540008128,
0.5970366001,
0.0562060326,
0.0629064068,
-0.7699782252,
0.3374822438,
-0.0924382359,
0.0145678325,
0.4627275467,
0.5380954742,
-0.1342847943,
0.9602410793,
0.9883543253,
-0.2890266776,
0.1585789323,
0.2189838886,
1.1661015749,
-0.3295698166,
-0.2075283378,
-0.8975823522,
0.5914396048,
0.0729157329,
-0.3540837169,
0.8351033926,
0.6008704305,
0.6298488975,
-0.2171762735,
0.5539745092,
0.3313036561,
0.0778417736,
-0.7549432516,
0.2161774039,
-0.8794257045,
0.4227308333,
-0.2526499033,
-0.7928624153,
-0.5979091525,
0.6758008599,
-0.3306089938,
0.0107234549,
0.5355021358,
0.7005678415,
-0.3076547682,
-0.0740489587,
0.4302761853,
-0.0369734466,
0.3596110642,
0.7794284821,
0.976365149,
-0.4789627492,
0.9262421727,
-0.1548925042,
-0.3472956717,
-0.0309764799,
-0.7956581116,
-0.9439864755,
-0.4804146588,
-0.3588188589,
-0.3041281104,
-0.186405316,
0.8941387534,
0.4630205333,
-0.6597619653,
-0.1057083756,
0.1512722224,
0.280321002,
-0.0168562364,
-0.1685659587,
0.0813924968,
-0.3913235962,
-0.5729694366,
0.3187710643,
0.4765301049,
-0.1965891868,
-0.5326682329,
-0.0641962662,
-0.2200826108,
0.0925101265,
0.7786141634,
0.1707075685,
-0.7747671604,
0.2590420544,
0.2487064749,
0.1048395932,
0.2327201962,
0.790689528,
-0.7161713839,
0.6047400832,
0.3660684228,
0.8552962542,
0.6717280746,
-0.2878371775,
0.3308024108,
-0.7942143083,
0.2257983536,
0.2367862314,
0.5389015079,
0.3836222291,
-0.0118276989,
0.3110200167,
0.5257316828,
-0.3853251338,
-0.8863230944,
0.3785936236,
-0.854871273,
-0.1337023228,
1.1878483295,
-0.0266605224,
-0.2553052306,
0.1868306845,
-0.2773033679,
-0.289195776,
-0.3576897383,
0.5219271183,
0.804058373,
-0.0584623776,
-0.6072586775,
-0.6092844009,
0.1145978346,
0.4385264218,
-1.0876402855,
-0.0652824566,
0.7502695322,
0.2533424199,
0.1375671178,
0.3268134296,
-0.2494167536,
0.4005984366,
0.1228317618,
-0.1534250975,
-0.3696501851,
-0.3854471147,
-0.0850126743,
0.2583560944,
-0.2079587877,
-0.2800792754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17287v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17287v1
|
Predicting the Big Five Personality Traits in Chinese Counselling Dialogues Using Large Language Models
| 2024-06-25T05:30:55 | 2024-06-25T05:30:55 |
Yang Yan, Lizhi Ma, Anqi Li, Jingsong Ma, Zhenzhong Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Accurate assessment of personality traits is crucial for effective
psycho-counseling, yet traditional methods like self-report questionnaires are
time-consuming and biased. This study exams whether Large Language Models
(LLMs) can predict the Big Five personality traits directly from counseling
dialogues and introduces an innovative framework to perform the task. Our
framework applies role-play and questionnaire-based prompting to condition LLMs
on counseling sessions, simulating client responses to the Big Five Inventory.
We evaluated our framework on 853 real-world counseling sessions, finding a
significant correlation between LLM-predicted and actual Big Five traits,
proving the validity of framework. Moreover, ablation studies highlight the
importance of role-play simulations and task simplification via questionnaires
in enhancing prediction accuracy. Meanwhile, our fine-tuned Llama3-8B model,
utilizing Direct Preference Optimization with Supervised Fine-Tuning, achieves
a 130.95\% improvement, surpassing the state-of-the-art Qwen1.5-110B by 36.94\%
in personality prediction validity. In conclusion, LLMs can predict personality
based on counseling dialogues. Our code and model are publicly available at
\url{https://github.com/kuri-leo/BigFive-LLM-Predictor}, providing a valuable
tool for future research in computational psychometrics.
|
[
-0.3629542589,
-0.6000155807,
0.7008507848,
0.6568456292,
-0.1411921531,
-0.118382439,
-0.5096470714,
-0.5927568674,
0.1199052855,
0.5035410523,
-0.6697847247,
-0.5141997337,
-0.4977023304,
0.2136840373,
0.0576788001,
0.7750697136,
0.3400463164,
0.7908267379,
-0.0010874721,
0.1436703801,
-0.6936330795,
-0.5331833363,
-0.7946998477,
-0.480820179,
0.6759234667,
0.3794063926,
0.4651839137,
0.389343679,
0.4106636941,
0.2882151008,
-0.3620389104,
0.0147826616,
-0.4760075212,
-0.0100795068,
0.0736337155,
-0.3661880791,
-0.7918155789,
0.1313402653,
0.484933883,
0.4946650863,
-0.235297665,
0.261908263,
-0.0095052803,
0.501160264,
-0.2908946574,
0.3708723783,
-0.5869245529,
0.1643195897,
-0.0043171858,
0.0702300146,
-0.4527333081,
-0.3629927337,
0.1539941877,
-0.1905662715,
0.1206653193,
0.0922715515,
0.4729527831,
0.1321922094,
-0.6821801066,
0.0679855123,
-1.023436904,
0.8203911185,
-0.8727920651,
0.0985404924,
0.6804461479,
0.6165866852,
-0.2751249075,
-0.2999733984,
-0.5298159719,
-0.4225158691,
-0.0861234516,
0.182380572,
0.2686066031,
0.2621384859,
0.6219395995,
0.5951156616,
-0.4270571172,
0.3732105494,
-0.4144588709,
-0.0901565328,
1.0509477854,
0.3497351408,
0.0609519258,
0.1246522367,
-0.1512927115,
0.1425216347,
-0.7899395227,
0.051162824,
0.3087841868,
0.0670721009,
-0.0673144832,
0.2165669203,
-0.0227738786,
0.3630937934,
0.4945209622,
-0.6906048656,
-0.0005302173,
-0.152006343,
-0.1231706887,
0.2758800983,
0.7298532724,
0.5372529626,
0.4218580127,
0.1249546111,
0.1448121667,
-0.223794654,
0.1022254601,
-1.0606831312,
-0.2225569934,
0.5941727161,
-0.3875479102,
-0.3653607368,
-0.1497505009,
-0.7163857818,
-0.774455905,
-0.1105419472,
-0.2028394192,
-0.5370341539,
-0.3023016751,
-0.0439021774,
0.2755487263,
0.4287744462,
0.4305993319,
-0.9981268048,
-0.0321990103,
0.6396821141,
0.6537062526,
-0.1880544871,
-0.356321454,
-0.6022865772,
0.0946075991,
-0.4303327501,
0.4684138894,
-0.5629094243,
-0.6217210293,
0.0808742419,
-0.0133865168,
0.2688685954,
-0.4331918955,
0.7724637985,
-0.1290304214,
0.0994632095,
-0.5534220934,
-0.5431572199,
0.0342960954,
0.4195414484,
-0.641010344,
0.6474562287,
0.0073405509,
-0.5607851744,
0.5102238059,
-0.5647904277,
-0.2386153042,
0.065059334,
0.0675869882,
-0.6540905237,
-0.1627958715,
0.281883657,
0.8104900122,
-0.2701832652,
0.5598763824,
-0.8459827304,
-0.5864822268,
0.7235246897,
-0.0719897449,
0.5082309246,
0.052628167,
-0.1230400652,
0.2797983587,
-0.564091444,
-0.0363482013,
0.070142962,
-0.2405799776,
-0.0123831928,
-0.0098221358,
-0.1344015151,
0.3045582473,
0.2270932496,
-0.8449269533,
0.4974750578,
-0.4166540504,
0.1944519579,
0.7364683747,
-0.0097068343,
0.0370381325,
-0.2123677284,
0.5677694678,
0.1411577612,
0.1384863853,
-0.0523883663,
-0.375213623,
-0.4197990298,
-0.5130339861,
0.2519561946,
0.2882175744,
-0.2425739318,
0.8236551285,
-0.1260217875,
-0.957922101,
-0.238122344,
0.2155011892,
0.4891142249,
0.0396962203,
0.2399693727,
-0.0893256515,
-0.5868728757,
-0.5875678658,
-0.1799605936,
-0.1028114632,
-0.0533567518,
0.3009301424,
0.4529677927,
-0.0406514518,
0.5745841265,
-0.6497851014,
-0.2673484981,
-0.6520649791,
-0.1313289106,
0.3242917061,
0.3406994343,
0.7896886468,
-0.7481476068,
-0.6003802419,
-0.1461504549,
-0.3775189817,
0.003783429,
0.1570459455,
0.1063631624,
0.1180266663,
0.3282809258,
-0.3870234489,
0.2766506374,
0.7018984556,
-0.451094389,
0.9160678387,
-0.0733514503,
-0.2333482653,
-1.0297482014,
0.1770535558,
0.1290308684,
0.0981914476,
-0.5434085131,
-0.1819225997,
-0.0827681795,
-0.0985453427,
-0.0736111626,
0.7714689374,
-0.2114177346,
-0.1839396209,
-0.1101528406,
-0.1270384341,
-0.2658264935,
0.7203164697,
0.003165449,
0.6821935773,
0.3841259778,
-0.4948252738,
0.6692665219,
0.3703381717,
-0.3485299349,
0.6901195049,
-0.6850163341,
0.1211642921,
0.1125109792,
0.7624223828,
-1.0745213032,
-0.5015839338,
-0.1402872056,
-0.4042236507,
0.1214368418,
-0.092077747,
-0.2543430924,
-0.5045592189,
-0.3314815164,
-0.0840424672,
0.4407423735,
-0.4213767648,
0.487623632,
-0.0913485363,
-0.4090145826,
-0.5908186436,
-0.3561013341,
-0.1443651468,
-0.4050460458,
-0.3617969453,
0.3260893524,
-0.4365496337,
-0.0546317175,
-0.5256063938,
0.140482083,
0.0293219909,
0.2293531597,
0.3753300309,
0.5603933334,
-0.0580506884,
0.1212109104,
-0.0697478876,
-0.1847122461,
0.1597584635,
-0.0411710925,
0.5497214794,
-0.2700592577,
-0.3961676955,
-0.2684019506,
0.0396393612,
0.8002493978,
-0.465611577,
0.7544981241,
1.0089119673,
0.0102888271,
-0.0485831685,
-0.6872270703,
-0.238248542,
-0.4374589026,
0.4994911551,
-0.3082464337,
-0.8729839921,
0.6729403138,
-0.0214855056,
0.1842527837,
0.0479629487,
0.7415635586,
0.0222528037,
1.5639972687,
0.6556470394,
-0.2427988797,
0.5333298445,
-0.1642358154,
0.4754243493,
-0.9290834069,
0.051055789,
-0.1914418489,
-0.4652997553,
-0.7812783122,
0.1160212532,
0.4761024117,
-0.0950095877,
-0.5656244159,
-0.2810719013,
-0.2485530376,
0.3274130821,
0.2798003852,
-0.098479256,
0.3371048272,
-0.2766450346,
-0.2244753838,
-0.2106453776,
-0.0626024231,
-0.3935445249,
1.1223578453,
0.4834403992,
0.5359389782,
0.2125990689,
0.4179791808,
-0.0386421047,
0.5238921046,
-1.146160841,
0.6483944654,
-0.026420407,
-0.6837171316,
-0.5211360455,
-0.2384083271,
-0.6726243496,
0.2206085473,
-0.2852734327,
-0.8968932033,
-0.0622224919,
0.25343889,
-0.4228955507,
0.0652298704,
-0.5124045014,
0.8061497211,
-0.2906514704,
-0.3134556115,
-0.2239581794,
-0.5863953829,
0.6005678773,
-0.1528878957,
-0.1883337945,
-0.2604726255,
0.356780231,
0.3631556034,
-0.1744937301,
0.7978977561,
-0.2514263093,
-0.2157752365,
-0.2212131917,
0.2115068287,
0.4102688134,
-0.0007553217,
-0.4006356597,
-0.0319929458,
0.4604025781,
-0.3609443307,
-0.9161176682,
0.596737206,
-0.9821289182,
-0.5172570348,
-0.3136174381,
-0.2867414653,
-0.6793599129,
0.2095807195,
0.1236887723,
0.266508311,
-0.5472959876,
0.2523633838,
0.3484745622,
-0.2475580871,
0.2307232171,
0.645986855,
-0.6312980056,
-0.3260825872,
0.8656007051,
0.0477283858,
0.234717831,
-0.1696732342,
0.5254146457,
-0.1302133948,
-0.4846262932,
-0.1829557866,
0.5067210793,
-0.4398845732,
0.0620802604,
-0.2806680202,
-0.3321799338,
-0.6104229689,
-0.0383887663,
-0.2481198013,
0.1778972596,
0.2278743237,
-0.2852143049,
0.2158322632,
0.5738816857,
0.2835259736,
0.3709765971,
-0.7514769435,
-0.1202296987,
0.3074839711,
0.3865704834,
0.2761398852,
-0.3092569709,
-0.2275996655,
0.0777578503,
-0.594630003,
-0.5567945242,
0.6364587545,
0.0413335524,
0.2780495584,
0.947791934,
-0.0035273265,
0.5750477314,
-0.0889891237,
0.9742637277,
0.0665370598,
-0.6427229643,
0.2873673439,
-0.612116456,
0.1671576649,
0.3271064758,
0.3960181475,
-0.7688297629,
-0.167588979,
-0.6680095196,
-0.4163835645,
0.7399223447,
-0.1290778667,
0.017796766,
0.2681880891,
0.3610654771,
-0.0610605031,
0.3139553368,
-0.7193232179,
-0.067958422,
-0.1253747344,
-0.2282270491,
-0.2720099986,
-0.4479493797,
-0.1098990887,
-0.4631271064,
0.7218695879,
-0.489194423,
0.3924535215,
0.0181594994,
0.4705426395,
-0.2188986391,
0.3688545227,
0.6095779538,
0.6486313939,
-0.4408609867,
-0.2995397449,
0.486933738,
-0.6206229925,
-0.0033979698,
-0.1469747424,
0.3467307091,
-0.2605363727,
0.4439250231,
0.8690648079,
-0.0475887842,
-0.6536836624,
0.7226029038,
-0.1238069087,
-0.2496310622,
-1.0499010086,
0.2300094664,
0.2564692795,
0.2315352708,
0.0250615384,
-0.5093095899,
-0.0023476428,
-0.6340740919,
-0.4385236204,
0.304423362,
-0.5209781528,
-0.3821237087,
0.2391732782,
0.3644138873,
-0.1040817574,
0.6196997762,
-0.1206017211,
-0.4856540263,
0.6193417311,
0.5864107609,
0.8117544055,
-0.5462802649,
0.1520111114,
0.454305023,
-0.3814201653,
-0.1305498779,
0.3132790923,
0.1230909526,
-0.9296138287,
-0.6825525165,
-0.8119010329,
-0.6940652132,
0.4995982349,
-0.5544975996,
0.4394045174,
-0.6933866739,
-0.0862931162,
-0.0756845325,
0.4952886701,
-0.3177935779,
0.2491776496,
0.4369001687,
0.591319859,
-0.6447326541,
0.939438045,
0.8028019667,
-0.2155619711,
-1.1166496277,
0.0234208126,
0.2709956169,
-0.712284565,
0.6505903006,
0.2910175323,
0.0100204507,
-0.0754200742,
-0.7806149721,
-0.7716680169,
1.1723338366,
0.4182637036,
-0.3457147479,
-0.2965344787,
0.0377548821,
0.6907408237,
-0.4502785802,
0.5475580096,
0.7105258703,
0.7284208536,
0.6387640834,
-1.0980548859,
0.0051574497,
-0.3084667027,
0.1777107418,
-0.0760584697,
-0.8495926261,
0.6281039119,
-0.33236745,
0.2348777652,
0.2983988225,
0.5953555107,
0.4317469299,
0.0931593627,
0.4796580374,
0.0947142243,
0.7871357799,
0.0520098545,
0.839584589,
-0.6566365361,
0.2271835655,
0.8608168364,
-0.5178012848,
0.6595140696,
0.0990174413,
-0.1771692932,
0.5947158933,
0.6112024784,
-0.4456951618,
-0.0312868915,
0.1853635609,
-0.0517979041,
-0.4218687117,
-0.2370869517,
-0.1470314115,
0.8780412674,
0.5147063136,
-0.3621276915,
0.3651482761,
-0.0213840473,
0.3240016699,
-0.2233843058,
-0.2269279212,
0.6307643056,
0.14806813,
-0.8588044047,
0.4454884231,
0.0983265415,
0.6170447469,
-0.6485576034,
-0.1868636608,
-0.3130547106,
0.4407927692,
-0.3024454713,
-0.7874401808,
-0.0042309319,
-0.2374592721,
0.1475220025,
-0.2752729654,
0.7354026437,
-0.4884242415,
-0.3642696142,
0.1093607321,
0.3693900406,
0.097176224,
-0.1351913661,
-0.4520434141,
-0.3158628047,
-0.1602121145,
-0.2961710095,
0.6350867152,
0.2363259345,
-0.0914460495,
0.8633474112,
0.735160172,
0.3480405509,
-0.5523747802,
0.0084728906,
0.6459819078,
-0.9296374321,
-0.7152907252,
-0.890137136,
0.2786270678,
-0.2463365346,
-0.4964770079,
0.6409653425,
0.1107380167,
0.4775321782,
0.0340204649,
0.7264923453,
0.1798805743,
0.7510349154,
-0.4564541876,
0.6627444625,
-0.2602853477,
0.0045234007,
-0.4099054933,
-0.9686549306,
-0.001474936,
0.4526123703,
-0.8178600073,
0.2613581121,
0.6517633796,
0.7323446274,
0.1703509986,
0.1169404835,
0.5648753643,
0.5559889674,
0.4819810688,
0.5292373896,
0.6723601818,
0.2461252958,
0.3839918077,
-0.2286110371,
0.0470516495,
-0.5658499599,
-0.6226599216,
-1.0708912611,
-0.4412904382,
0.0459017269,
-0.2651186883,
-0.4249818921,
1.0511449575,
0.4893205464,
-0.5695106983,
-0.3173211813,
0.3442038596,
0.073918134,
-0.3783567846,
-0.2125040442,
0.1691929698,
0.0835077986,
-0.6942418814,
-0.0293652602,
0.1121380627,
-0.0608151816,
-0.8188570142,
-0.0174426325,
0.2029249966,
-0.0400811508,
0.6146191955,
0.0025975467,
-0.8556005955,
-0.505386889,
0.0817924291,
-0.1898945272,
0.061036095,
0.6795543432,
-0.2887430191,
0.1601412743,
0.0956348926,
0.2319125235,
0.4110588431,
0.0501934476,
0.928753376,
-0.3903492987,
0.0115799699,
0.1779053807,
0.4510023296,
0.2850289345,
-0.6220061779,
0.4811677635,
-0.0274146069,
-0.6481801271,
-0.5872385502,
0.2954866588,
-0.9572638869,
-0.0486047454,
1.2634660006,
-0.4951896369,
-0.2308196276,
-0.0731378198,
-0.7011938095,
0.0840887874,
-0.3691397607,
0.8610469103,
0.869187057,
-0.3180048764,
-0.2038067579,
-0.420135349,
0.6345649958,
0.500556767,
-0.4716008306,
0.191813767,
0.6079286337,
0.3060280085,
0.136466369,
0.4289144874,
0.0472215265,
0.2490638644,
-0.4007613957,
0.2078624368,
-0.1914574057,
0.0011964117,
-0.1653443575,
-0.1282512546,
0.3980565965,
0.432056576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17283v1
|
A Recursive Encoding for Cuneiform Signs
| 2024-06-25T05:18:12 | 2024-06-25T05:18:12 |
Daniel M. Stelzer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
One of the most significant problems in cuneiform pedagogy is the process of
looking up unknown signs, which often involves a tedious page-by-page search
through a sign list. This paper proposes a new "recursive encoding" for signs,
which represents the arrangement of strokes in a way a computer can process. A
series of new algorithms then offers students a new way to look up signs by any
distinctive component, as well as providing new ways to render signs and
tablets electronically.
|
[
-0.2514272928,
-0.2748840749,
0.6797149777,
0.0301579814,
-0.124010779,
0.4395826459,
0.0802567601,
-0.2763136029,
0.2746503055,
0.2358500212,
-0.9437733889,
-0.4468118846,
-1.0225473642,
0.3393047154,
-0.37884444,
0.3421880603,
-0.2571676075,
-0.2564805746,
0.4789883196,
-0.0166940577,
-0.2053729147,
-0.6078244448,
-0.8698689938,
-0.4422914684,
0.5378651619,
0.4429101646,
0.8751869798,
0.5831051469,
0.4598666131,
0.3592693806,
0.0090271058,
0.3424776793,
-0.2953420877,
0.2185316533,
0.0078090448,
-0.3276127577,
-0.0541988015,
0.2227026671,
0.5964611173,
0.9768934846,
0.0339276493,
-0.0329662412,
-0.4646565914,
0.884388566,
-0.5324191451,
0.1887448579,
-0.189634487,
0.2483381927,
-0.2651945949,
-0.3624794185,
-0.7127591968,
-0.6019833088,
-0.099951148,
-0.8166248202,
0.2231700569,
0.0745316818,
0.6543877721,
-0.2079572231,
-0.204938218,
-0.5456254482,
-0.5831667185,
0.573882997,
-0.3358120024,
0.8657360673,
0.1739645898,
0.2573995292,
-0.8026483059,
-0.9682425857,
-0.60822016,
0.0249268152,
-0.0362806246,
-0.0338977128,
-0.1589913666,
0.1230703518,
0.5203492641,
0.4942887425,
-0.3987419009,
-0.0509196408,
-0.4210474193,
-0.1807840765,
0.5704069734,
0.380323112,
0.908542037,
0.1597332507,
0.0735353827,
-0.2541961968,
-0.7544675469,
0.352632165,
0.4961554408,
0.2726539373,
0.1360298395,
0.6206642389,
-0.1833712161,
1.0003890991,
0.6759356856,
0.0118992953,
0.1938901544,
0.0735129118,
-0.0023151217,
0.1549749672,
0.3916220665,
0.3773315251,
0.3354682326,
-0.0344253145,
-0.2436409146,
0.0350393206,
0.0532716885,
-0.6183095574,
-0.6649631858,
0.1108421758,
-0.5600609779,
-0.24121131,
0.1164546311,
-0.1727538705,
-0.7610099912,
-0.2314322889,
0.4345943928,
-0.4873663783,
-0.281981647,
0.4268178642,
-0.351356566,
0.178489998,
0.4670208693,
-1.3047511578,
0.3109720051,
0.602327466,
0.6970075369,
0.1975629479,
-0.115743272,
-0.5683495998,
-0.184083119,
-0.0625047609,
0.7843977809,
-1.0311980247,
-0.3865720928,
0.0111207962,
0.2783688009,
-0.1947075427,
-0.1072439179,
0.1531936228,
-0.3847742975,
0.1939324439,
-0.1241711229,
-0.6500959992,
-0.4562034607,
0.0461237207,
-1.2027831078,
1.0237799883,
0.4162684977,
-0.6385611892,
0.0677721798,
-0.4740230143,
-0.763297081,
0.1877570897,
-0.4993695915,
-0.2724483311,
0.2713159919,
0.2975524664,
0.3473013639,
0.213140592,
-0.4777150154,
0.3811302185,
-0.7234622836,
0.4969411492,
-0.1443903893,
1.3133392334,
0.0063727666,
-0.6463171244,
-0.101234898,
-0.6622712016,
0.0312640406,
0.2034058124,
-0.5395134091,
-0.3167335689,
0.056296926,
-0.1963561773,
0.051527258,
0.3595637977,
-0.6629222631,
0.4407795966,
-0.6060739756,
0.5903288126,
0.6261031628,
0.1147707924,
0.348882854,
-0.2300577313,
0.3188343048,
0.0478313453,
0.2190859616,
-0.3982611001,
-1.0130023956,
-0.776209712,
0.5503186584,
-0.2404796481,
0.3125177622,
-0.6810544729,
-0.1681722552,
0.2087905854,
-0.4911239743,
-0.4274302721,
-0.0525714904,
0.3987490535,
0.2080047727,
0.0428119116,
-0.3592155278,
-0.6180989742,
-0.3766742945,
-0.1068854406,
-0.0221604723,
0.1818370223,
-0.0951076746,
0.2665967941,
-0.024230333,
-0.0832207128,
-0.46811077,
0.1550945044,
-0.1928127408,
0.4579016566,
0.5789565444,
0.3626430631,
0.0902428403,
-0.9421005249,
-0.5604287982,
0.252079308,
-0.2158968449,
0.1154522151,
-0.5043042302,
-0.0492583402,
0.2399831712,
0.5503255725,
-0.4764425159,
0.556545496,
0.4185741544,
-0.6041030884,
0.6547092795,
-0.2672455907,
0.3232530951,
-0.36458534,
-0.2916625142,
-0.1580942869,
0.0337639973,
-0.7725448608,
0.2825150192,
0.1519448757,
-0.2307302356,
-0.4618690908,
0.2277457267,
-1.071977973,
0.0420499109,
-0.1591825485,
0.3607930839,
0.0662532002,
0.4071099162,
0.4019801617,
0.7066332102,
0.5165758133,
-0.5624598265,
0.6657754779,
0.0985749066,
-0.1969181001,
0.5087895989,
-0.0364643373,
0.2943935096,
-0.368968606,
-0.1701244861,
-1.0368765593,
-0.1502994299,
0.532305479,
-0.5831800103,
0.6080448627,
0.0388636552,
0.0204311647,
-0.6762080789,
-0.3616672754,
0.6783158183,
0.28671965,
-0.6454914808,
0.6699123979,
0.2925957143,
0.2744016945,
-0.6229333878,
-0.3235298097,
-0.1273814887,
0.2553916872,
-0.724324286,
0.3614948392,
0.0401493423,
0.000375252,
-0.0886714831,
-0.2653636038,
-0.0132421749,
0.0057650646,
0.4946209192,
0.1129624918,
-0.1243481115,
-0.1545442343,
-0.0618933849,
-0.341391772,
0.1618525237,
-0.4150171578,
0.5367523432,
-0.1275078058,
-0.3375852108,
-0.7394681573,
0.5579840541,
0.6079412103,
0.004089457,
0.0919601023,
0.2652712166,
-0.8567299843,
-0.1993145794,
-0.3047496676,
-0.0073664095,
-0.5891879797,
0.1643564701,
-0.4002682865,
-0.4578590691,
0.3516719341,
-0.3139781654,
0.0687939972,
0.0871243253,
0.4186939299,
-0.2211180925,
1.0531402826,
0.5888214111,
0.4823692143,
0.4443858266,
-0.3280204535,
0.5163555741,
-0.765062809,
-0.8031167984,
-0.4268292785,
-0.4277713895,
-0.7659159899,
-0.1866711378,
-0.1420133114,
-0.3716860414,
-0.3644560575,
0.8542796373,
-1.3080637455,
0.7158929706,
0.7500248551,
0.1966194361,
0.3980302513,
0.1782440543,
-0.0993028581,
-0.0630602166,
-0.393974334,
-0.3710177839,
0.95089221,
-0.093772836,
0.7844234109,
0.0055267634,
0.9692719579,
0.3300169706,
0.3012106419,
-0.8821060658,
0.4791851044,
-0.4684723318,
-0.4639806151,
-0.413420558,
-0.0142405834,
-1.2595857382,
-0.2908430994,
-0.3957212269,
-1.044085741,
0.2515824735,
0.0137704182,
-0.3408881724,
0.7600093484,
-0.6211004257,
0.6861687303,
-0.3981478214,
0.1028897613,
0.1316484809,
-0.1745405793,
0.0943548158,
0.4177420735,
0.0825441107,
-0.0159473401,
0.3866275847,
0.7762332559,
-0.5012750626,
0.6122906208,
-0.2120707929,
-0.0532108247,
0.3687106371,
0.4674546123,
0.7696961761,
-0.4495335817,
0.1130912527,
-0.19617185,
0.1090348363,
-0.2410326153,
-0.5782858729,
0.6972466111,
-0.7743141651,
-0.8365284204,
-0.715647459,
-0.4209975004,
0.1934283227,
0.5966081619,
0.543823421,
0.4936107695,
0.1563577503,
-0.5539246798,
0.6608775854,
-0.2504608333,
0.3535304964,
0.169694528,
-0.2560652792,
-0.1133118272,
1.1150220633,
0.2532927096,
-0.0962323621,
0.4798607528,
0.0729632378,
-0.3500272036,
-0.8240433931,
-0.3395107985,
0.3493716717,
-0.9390960932,
0.0437355749,
-0.0056069316,
-0.4743352234,
-0.1997880936,
-0.5340076685,
-0.0728471801,
-0.7130594254,
-0.26243186,
-0.0668005049,
0.173728615,
1.0538805723,
-0.055576209,
0.3985135257,
-0.4526790679,
0.5292273164,
0.4295468032,
0.6146118641,
0.1407922953,
-0.2249476761,
-0.0779246315,
-0.0637616813,
-0.4256554842,
-0.999001503,
0.0261663254,
0.0339550078,
0.4552812874,
0.5560352206,
0.0270343609,
0.5360575318,
-0.4432659447,
0.332911253,
0.6757197976,
-0.7791087627,
0.4936473668,
-0.0788631737,
0.1571357399,
0.2874984443,
0.6067830324,
-1.1188768148,
-0.3341856897,
-0.42447263,
-0.7327818871,
0.5587804317,
0.4910724163,
0.2224252373,
-0.3084307611,
0.5036783814,
0.3452626169,
-0.2183365077,
-0.5260441899,
-0.6462404728,
-0.5716072321,
-0.226831466,
0.675804019,
-0.1329210848,
0.2423480153,
-0.4483855069,
0.4927784204,
0.5192922354,
0.4669306576,
0.0521010906,
-0.0988842994,
-0.2553026974,
0.0537781715,
0.5463902354,
0.5482208729,
-0.1651315242,
0.4856376052,
-0.2987002134,
-1.1916478872,
0.4353838265,
-0.0653708652,
-0.4185043275,
0.1382405907,
0.1189532876,
0.5937223434,
0.2380814254,
-0.3511110842,
0.3698376119,
-0.1276957244,
-0.1216358542,
-0.6641356945,
0.2952888906,
-0.0555663556,
0.1720038354,
0.4784533978,
-0.3459812105,
0.194064185,
-0.4056625366,
0.2439152598,
0.1317399442,
-0.0952840596,
-0.2440664321,
0.7135474086,
0.5158862472,
-0.9765093327,
1.2386479378,
-0.3442329168,
-0.5445479155,
0.7081663013,
0.7824354172,
0.754347682,
-0.2786335647,
0.5485231876,
0.7981508374,
0.3955586851,
-0.1183982491,
0.8331027031,
-0.0514111593,
-0.4653064311,
-0.3392677605,
-0.2596581876,
-0.8790019751,
-0.0130001456,
-0.4548433423,
0.2735168636,
-0.8906351924,
-0.2562570274,
0.4536224604,
-0.0691211969,
-0.7302911282,
0.3923740685,
0.7027550936,
0.9393334389,
-0.5607559085,
0.5153077841,
0.6978441477,
-0.4035962522,
-0.8565050364,
-0.5904606581,
-0.065889284,
-1.102327466,
0.7863265872,
0.5857033134,
-0.4810756743,
0.1463598013,
-0.3010922372,
-0.9158760309,
0.9646618366,
0.0661156029,
-0.8380090594,
-0.4301144779,
0.4222370684,
0.0957918316,
-0.4306217432,
0.1132438704,
0.7542911768,
0.7618145943,
-0.1739190817,
-0.2974799275,
0.6333066821,
-0.4899887741,
-0.1161328629,
0.6860553026,
-0.0948833823,
0.8278405666,
-0.494343549,
-0.9779504538,
0.0740928352,
0.4755423367,
0.055321902,
0.6061677337,
-0.121902667,
0.3910108507,
1.0858392715,
-0.5015593767,
0.8770364523,
-0.276448071,
0.1533612609,
0.8951007724,
0.4230233133,
0.3564808369,
0.5344541073,
-0.3499910831,
1.0062355995,
0.6849860549,
-0.2636906505,
0.157573238,
0.4097091258,
-0.3706306219,
-0.4405756593,
0.3597788215,
-0.0569763519,
-0.0268423799,
0.6434604526,
-0.4628484547,
-0.3439530134,
-0.1153013185,
-0.0392896906,
0.5234535336,
-0.7392933965,
0.0807748511,
0.0564309992,
-0.412070483,
0.5621877313,
-0.0322355665,
0.4083712399,
-0.2548652887,
-0.4506573677,
-0.2346734107,
-0.247458443,
-0.6736206412,
-1.2671802044,
0.0726517364,
-0.413996309,
-0.0032480077,
-0.0758729652,
0.6675263643,
-0.0239217449,
-0.7491612434,
0.0420620032,
-0.0062312488,
0.4446251392,
0.099847123,
-0.4538445771,
0.1997743249,
-0.1540016681,
-0.1782068163,
-0.2121658921,
0.4942857623,
-0.3015398979,
0.6676070094,
0.5144491196,
0.0311079416,
0.4285482466,
0.106256254,
0.541621089,
-1.0997775793,
-0.3312035203,
-0.4516011178,
0.5008763671,
-0.0368902236,
-0.1684565842,
0.6361246109,
0.2011758089,
1.0138016939,
-0.1073666811,
0.701412797,
-0.0457882844,
-0.1613419503,
-0.2920764983,
0.764672935,
-0.0200351086,
-0.0994891822,
-0.2313713878,
-0.7943795919,
-0.6500060558,
0.8618573546,
-0.2549661994,
-0.0483744778,
0.8015334606,
0.544839561,
-0.0433036871,
0.1054139957,
0.3275779784,
-0.211835146,
-0.0549230613,
1.1435153484,
0.7826618552,
-0.6894963384,
0.5822706819,
-0.6071478724,
-0.149071306,
-0.2212029994,
-0.6955963373,
-0.9365720749,
-0.8976825476,
-0.4860092998,
-0.421243161,
0.026831774,
0.5636325479,
0.1030260548,
-0.904546082,
-0.0636494905,
-0.2617318332,
0.5294229984,
-0.6103977561,
-0.0740534216,
0.7824904919,
0.0284576025,
-0.8074328899,
-0.0044109509,
0.3955931365,
0.330973506,
-0.1731078029,
-0.3341121972,
-0.0868780538,
0.0515797958,
0.534712553,
0.9312257171,
-0.5329989195,
-0.5204482079,
0.1496790797,
-0.0211028066,
0.2807230651,
1.186347127,
-0.6051717401,
0.7800102234,
0.5949139595,
0.3123130202,
0.5914262533,
-0.3220296502,
0.1533667594,
-0.2526926398,
-0.1928517222,
-0.0583381802,
0.4867777526,
0.4295897186,
-0.6681129336,
0.2881880105,
0.1283617616,
-0.0740646198,
-0.5521833897,
0.5835213661,
-1.0672755241,
-0.0948559791,
0.682962656,
-0.0724186972,
-0.4603432715,
-0.4629952312,
-0.4200436175,
0.343379885,
-0.299354434,
1.0306973457,
0.6969571114,
-0.737588048,
-0.4221492708,
0.0922541395,
0.4127653241,
-0.2276729494,
-0.2349246889,
0.137382254,
0.4277011752,
0.3113358617,
0.2755068243,
0.6189935207,
-0.2821709514,
0.9502514601,
0.3965100646,
-0.0617723875,
-0.672983408,
-0.3602882922,
-0.0467232242,
0.1508632153,
0.3294580579,
-0.2181342393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17282v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17282v2
|
SetBERT: Enhancing Retrieval Performance for Boolean Logic and Set Operation Queries
| 2024-06-25T05:14:54 | 2024-06-26T14:38:31 |
Quan Mai, Susan Gauch, Douglas Adams
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce SetBERT, a fine-tuned BERT-based model designed to enhance query
embeddings for set operations and Boolean logic queries, such as Intersection
(AND), Difference (NOT), and Union (OR). SetBERT significantly improves
retrieval performance for logic-structured queries, an area where both
traditional and neural retrieval methods typically underperform. We propose an
innovative use of inversed-contrastive loss, focusing on identifying the
negative sentence, and fine-tuning BERT with a dataset generated via prompt
GPT. Furthermore, we demonstrate that, unlike other BERT-based models,
fine-tuning with triplet loss actually degrades performance for this specific
task. Our experiments reveal that SetBERT-base not only significantly
outperforms BERT-base (up to a 63% improvement in Recall) but also achieves
performance comparable to the much larger BERT-large model, despite being only
one-third the size.
|
[
-0.2739040256,
-0.7309309244,
0.4460560083,
0.2460640669,
-0.0927942544,
-0.0818252414,
-0.1671050191,
-0.3498789072,
0.1963166147,
0.8729149699,
-0.4341360331,
-0.454097867,
-0.3457579017,
-0.3020102084,
-0.3915746808,
0.9951568842,
0.256121546,
0.1385649592,
0.1889542043,
-0.3885166645,
-0.5775011778,
-0.4983215928,
-0.4616767168,
-0.3612286747,
0.36864537,
0.1349119395,
0.9430549145,
0.1405933201,
0.6978040338,
0.0818747357,
-0.1526755393,
0.3397466242,
-0.6940898895,
0.1812845021,
-0.4003058374,
-0.6031541824,
0.0494617112,
0.0252591856,
0.4716679454,
0.8392416239,
0.0365285799,
-0.166409567,
-0.1557443887,
1.0287292004,
-1.0808087587,
-0.0956209302,
-0.87123698,
0.3010182679,
0.2015229613,
-0.2764877379,
-0.4831523597,
-0.8975461721,
0.1711735278,
-0.5330942273,
0.4722421467,
0.1916926503,
0.8574185371,
0.5060206652,
-0.4592647254,
-0.1209102422,
-0.5441947579,
0.5871186852,
-0.6680433154,
0.5703524947,
0.2797906399,
0.0705933496,
-0.195312202,
-0.7363473773,
-0.6058996916,
-0.2117040157,
-0.2238571942,
0.3351231217,
-0.0119531453,
0.1949204952,
0.3750821054,
0.3251388967,
-0.5080965161,
-0.2440282553,
-0.5565663576,
-0.0345487408,
0.3052079678,
0.1050645038,
0.0090056332,
0.0370518379,
-0.1747441292,
0.1907202154,
-1.0945688486,
0.0901656896,
0.3829735518,
0.531033814,
0.5876583457,
0.6060804129,
-0.2902832031,
1.1543720961,
-0.0588111803,
0.6780466437,
0.054313004,
-0.1318747997,
-0.2464310229,
0.1032530069,
0.2805988789,
0.2593396604,
0.2041457742,
-0.1901369691,
-0.5161134005,
-0.0213382076,
0.2118129581,
-0.8490756154,
-1.1224735975,
0.0172353815,
-0.5137517452,
-0.3309316635,
0.1362195015,
-0.0282448661,
-0.3999145031,
-0.5314372182,
1.1416273117,
-0.9014792442,
0.2682152987,
0.2823532522,
-0.4222167134,
0.2620841861,
0.4231271744,
-0.6621873379,
0.3915143609,
0.7863813043,
0.5591542125,
0.2808664739,
0.1855429709,
-1.0787708759,
-0.0481426232,
-0.7825810313,
0.384416014,
-1.1239266396,
-0.0462292247,
0.1142934263,
-0.1435713619,
0.018220868,
-0.6959750056,
0.5854917169,
-1.0034179688,
0.2693476379,
-0.6617525816,
-0.6330122352,
-0.1172933429,
0.3677999675,
-0.7232507467,
0.9600676298,
-0.1293071806,
-0.5434505939,
0.4910037816,
-0.6485341191,
-0.9331097007,
-0.0496627912,
-0.115834862,
-0.2331579328,
0.2915381789,
0.532710135,
0.3337589204,
0.0506796576,
-0.2760253549,
-0.2391605079,
-0.9153108001,
0.0028607757,
0.1648711562,
1.1158714294,
-0.1656464338,
-0.1183829159,
0.1174652278,
-0.4840735197,
0.4294973612,
-0.2726114988,
-0.2240485996,
-0.5193586349,
0.3597884476,
-0.3937870562,
0.1918001026,
0.2030821294,
-0.8065446615,
0.2993114889,
-0.5479815602,
0.4555807114,
0.6400688291,
-0.0710449293,
0.1092259809,
-0.278183192,
-0.0163856428,
0.0400011204,
-0.0260199141,
0.159885928,
-0.290917635,
-0.8986983299,
-0.3021633029,
0.5980302095,
0.7015755177,
-0.8481892943,
0.5581908226,
0.0703149214,
-0.250838846,
-0.99541682,
-0.2039457411,
0.3824480474,
0.8956230283,
0.550714016,
0.1827901602,
-0.4337648153,
-1.3688592911,
-0.1069528162,
0.0567233264,
0.1007584333,
0.3415551782,
0.3945319653,
0.0955002084,
0.7404527664,
-0.9448031187,
-0.24718301,
0.1758903116,
0.1578370184,
0.5285518765,
0.4500341415,
0.318610996,
-0.9322122335,
-0.3970547915,
-0.2263123691,
-0.7204457521,
-0.0267528649,
0.3533822298,
-0.3596851528,
0.2959505618,
0.511346519,
-0.4120466709,
0.8048689365,
0.1470825523,
-0.1881196201,
0.6515409946,
-0.3709926009,
0.3666760325,
-0.5832439661,
0.0342869908,
-0.4251604378,
-0.2404868007,
-0.3544121087,
0.1053437442,
0.6213707328,
-0.2802054584,
-0.2760988176,
0.0269147381,
-0.1293535978,
-0.17238383,
-0.0268005561,
0.3421203196,
0.3430433273,
0.3872188032,
-0.0699827671,
1.1323522329,
0.4464874268,
-0.7848827839,
0.2851645052,
0.5657988787,
-0.2627812028,
0.5852844119,
-0.9449859858,
-0.0720743537,
-0.1607455164,
0.2648504674,
-0.9648806453,
0.3024021685,
-0.000266793,
-0.41037184,
0.1101686582,
-0.1467691809,
-0.7616125345,
-0.1180575341,
-0.7531320453,
0.1075439006,
0.6447474957,
-1.1962932348,
0.1624198854,
-0.1681150943,
0.2071087658,
-0.7979639769,
-0.5925973654,
-0.1357433647,
0.2169443518,
-0.8505976796,
0.5939303041,
0.0235124324,
-0.1397849917,
0.0583609641,
-0.1801290661,
0.0385304131,
-0.0384509936,
-0.1626569182,
0.2698370218,
-0.1587475389,
0.9981848001,
0.1969133168,
0.2532648146,
-0.0894600451,
-0.4817585647,
0.5338655114,
-0.4176466465,
-0.0849836916,
-0.1223911718,
0.2941426933,
-0.0334234983,
-0.782497108,
0.9334436059,
0.6871346831,
-0.5141651034,
-0.2318553776,
-0.5861349106,
-0.4834133983,
-0.4440923929,
0.1796443462,
-0.5144454837,
-0.8273713589,
0.6409143209,
0.3698292971,
0.0861210972,
0.4441900849,
0.3889232874,
-0.5075998306,
0.8263984323,
0.3580335379,
0.1445823163,
0.458230406,
-0.1898912489,
0.4407468438,
-1.1394891739,
-0.1703593284,
-0.4458058774,
-0.5011481643,
-0.6901142001,
0.013506853,
0.5343588591,
0.1783149838,
-0.5258870721,
0.3086287379,
-0.7741850615,
0.537065804,
1.0350131989,
0.7375956774,
0.4189768434,
-0.3408004045,
0.0672488213,
-0.15756239,
-0.5373392105,
-0.3458978534,
1.2519533634,
-0.4043176174,
0.9287115335,
0.5231387019,
0.8919026852,
0.5925853848,
0.0335898697,
-0.4523555338,
0.5402626395,
-0.42286098,
-0.8307720423,
-0.195710659,
-0.5159242153,
-0.9144487381,
0.4595434666,
-0.2635760307,
-1.0069956779,
0.182832554,
0.4340648949,
-0.4083203375,
0.1770532131,
-0.9113653302,
0.6321276426,
-0.1634544432,
-0.4896804094,
-0.2982210517,
-0.7987486124,
0.3521312475,
0.0611013323,
-0.7581162453,
-0.2123269737,
-0.2009638101,
0.6156283617,
-0.3900197446,
0.3018200397,
-0.1262432486,
0.0887430161,
0.0689256787,
0.3370915353,
0.6126270294,
0.3359005153,
-0.4522692859,
-0.2574201226,
0.1887043566,
-0.4030433297,
-0.9273032546,
1.0352655649,
-0.6023584008,
-0.5578094721,
-0.0196612645,
-0.602137208,
-0.3406526744,
0.1951325238,
0.2171931863,
0.6849805117,
-0.0794638917,
0.3649589121,
1.0640764236,
-0.2602486312,
0.2526744902,
0.4542387128,
-0.1204951182,
0.0308934711,
1.0853800774,
0.0778705627,
0.1953861117,
0.7541082501,
-0.0237904526,
-0.1972119212,
-0.3013461828,
-0.0499722436,
0.1119161546,
-0.7763273716,
-0.314398855,
-0.5098428726,
-0.1460868418,
-0.4822058976,
-0.152718842,
-0.3036726415,
-0.9351510406,
-0.2522844672,
0.0956633314,
0.2144162059,
0.2986026108,
-0.089766182,
0.1781735718,
-0.4389749169,
0.3788407743,
0.222239539,
0.7015603185,
-0.4275128543,
-0.3358739316,
-0.0393520407,
-0.0639361143,
-0.4306623042,
-0.7173432708,
0.2366310656,
0.3081303835,
0.2808739543,
0.0966914967,
0.3879480958,
0.4963597357,
-0.4289658666,
0.4513910115,
-0.1539655775,
-0.8279886842,
0.8026490211,
-0.4300935268,
0.2049201429,
0.7264710665,
0.0945741683,
-0.2733566165,
0.0672799572,
-0.7033746839,
-0.7883327603,
0.8839606643,
0.7845281959,
-0.1238346994,
0.040294081,
0.1535458714,
0.0103091868,
0.5042693615,
-0.4130040705,
-0.0770677328,
-0.1140007898,
-0.2047010511,
0.3063248694,
-0.0143233845,
-0.5134462118,
-0.406360656,
0.8703396916,
0.0084188897,
0.7106519341,
0.3134983182,
-0.2145285308,
0.214180842,
0.2018852085,
0.275617063,
0.7290156484,
-0.9415171146,
-0.0301644076,
0.080279775,
0.0719538629,
-0.3911891282,
0.6803398728,
-0.0745379254,
-0.0591007955,
0.2873907089,
0.5115942359,
-0.1300131232,
-0.8369272351,
0.3853754699,
0.0322452188,
-0.2362488508,
-0.269749403,
0.3528316021,
-0.123311013,
0.4553627372,
0.2078439593,
-0.1513831764,
0.6388862729,
-0.5742890835,
0.1808014959,
0.5850101113,
-0.5567244887,
0.2710956335,
0.4421073794,
0.2897001803,
-0.3701019287,
1.2203015089,
-0.1423788965,
-0.7008256912,
0.6743695736,
0.4997800589,
0.4861653745,
0.370577246,
-0.1283070445,
0.078015551,
0.569442153,
0.2065996975,
0.7522702217,
-0.179293111,
-0.7992208004,
-0.0149626834,
-0.134362191,
-0.3931324184,
0.0169954374,
-0.7520568967,
-0.05511133,
-0.6378343701,
0.0059870947,
0.1405771524,
0.0833056942,
-0.6969161034,
0.2684408426,
-0.2896220684,
0.9263410568,
-0.4681155384,
0.5349986553,
0.6274552941,
-0.5402929187,
-0.4610917568,
0.044956699,
-0.4566148221,
-0.6528120637,
0.8460161686,
0.2387025952,
-0.1695019305,
-0.1802228093,
-0.7371656299,
-0.5654863119,
0.7509061098,
0.2456567734,
-0.4487994313,
0.2148813903,
-0.4561223686,
0.5938522816,
-0.2450112998,
0.0625368655,
0.8569406867,
0.2759723961,
-0.2571510971,
-0.6702805161,
-0.0124373138,
-0.0249044448,
0.0027491904,
0.9124866128,
-0.7090095282,
0.8550633788,
-0.2844220698,
0.2530157864,
-0.0946335867,
0.5705570579,
0.1272545457,
0.1376143992,
0.1158178896,
0.5826838017,
0.95509094,
-0.4328505993,
1.0580207109,
-0.2410319597,
0.3588861227,
1.4477882385,
-0.2739061117,
0.9565569162,
0.3443580568,
0.0136481486,
0.1762120128,
0.3747458458,
0.1111872047,
0.8132010102,
0.3196401,
-0.337826103,
-0.4853819609,
0.1474930346,
-0.299636215,
0.0791219994,
0.613019526,
-0.6237617135,
-0.0636440217,
-0.115327999,
-0.1745785177,
0.1451980472,
-0.3120079339,
0.3428387642,
-0.2170791626,
-0.7286528349,
0.6212311983,
-0.1103915051,
0.3965520263,
-0.2314440757,
-0.3558102548,
-0.2248030007,
0.5449522138,
-0.2936766744,
-1.0025442839,
0.152215302,
-0.6577522159,
-0.2030204087,
0.3394035101,
0.8247608542,
-0.3739631772,
-0.5884365439,
0.1649106145,
0.3230705261,
-0.0820650831,
-0.2784431875,
-0.6818758249,
-0.1177914739,
0.183976382,
-0.0719018951,
-0.1992817223,
0.3969352245,
-0.0524675362,
0.7619495392,
0.3775963187,
-0.2437297851,
-0.0640397593,
0.2357648611,
1.1258091927,
-0.8294417858,
-0.1555833071,
-0.5313696861,
0.0767267346,
-0.3319574296,
-0.1596255153,
0.3575906157,
0.6781383753,
0.6557201743,
-0.0770266429,
0.7906097174,
-0.2401449531,
0.5920306444,
-0.6716276407,
0.5179371238,
-0.6101408601,
0.3328126669,
-0.2078030556,
-0.9764470458,
-0.4308477938,
0.721647203,
-0.5825413465,
0.1559470594,
0.5140032768,
1.0967077017,
-0.1924955249,
0.1224385425,
0.3150244653,
0.0538744591,
0.6564618945,
0.6320217848,
0.6794718504,
-0.6431186199,
0.7081069946,
-0.0958555788,
-0.1449567825,
-0.5673586726,
-0.4842186272,
-1.1629003286,
-0.4424110353,
-0.0588974729,
-0.4263999164,
0.7125108838,
0.7469415069,
0.7278668284,
-0.5889025927,
0.2053228319,
0.0618722998,
0.1656879634,
-0.1823970228,
-0.2046819776,
0.6815862656,
-0.6588711739,
-0.4620703161,
0.355122149,
0.1507241279,
-0.4629018605,
0.2695007622,
0.1185221821,
-0.667368114,
0.1400687397,
0.7465611696,
0.1788673401,
-0.456636399,
-0.6217167377,
-0.1648081094,
0.0145537704,
0.0185733177,
0.675442636,
-1.2104364634,
0.532872498,
0.5497220755,
0.6635345221,
0.7583189607,
0.1491981,
0.6900239587,
-0.9761468768,
-0.064478077,
0.6809456944,
0.3892802596,
0.2998421192,
-0.3095041215,
1.0069161654,
-0.0542794056,
-0.5264118314,
-0.4675138295,
0.2435002029,
-0.9350976944,
-0.2957977951,
0.7242660522,
0.1508692801,
0.2055801451,
0.118823953,
-0.3731390238,
0.0734287649,
-0.6489843726,
0.7350183129,
0.5414962769,
-0.6435580254,
-0.0452124774,
-0.3659307659,
0.2197823972,
0.7612196207,
-0.5490874648,
-0.0299990103,
0.8037545085,
0.2119216919,
0.0380637273,
0.3088142276,
-0.0482117236,
0.5055803657,
-0.2973782122,
-0.0206343941,
-0.2097176313,
-0.2839255631,
0.0536437891,
0.1098793224,
-0.1240602955,
-0.5102289319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17276v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17276v1
|
OPT-Tree: Speculative Decoding with Adaptive Draft Tree Structure
| 2024-06-25T04:45:53 | 2024-06-25T04:45:53 |
Jikai Wang, Yi Su, Juntao Li, Qinrong Xia, Zi Ye, Xinyu Duan, Zhefeng Wang, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Autoregressive language models demonstrate excellent performance in various
scenarios. However, the inference efficiency is limited by its
one-step-one-word generation mode, which has become a pressing problem recently
as the models become increasingly larger. Speculative decoding employs a "draft
and then verify" mechanism to allow multiple tokens to be generated in one
step, realizing lossless acceleration. Existing methods mainly adopt fixed
heuristic draft structures, which fail to adapt to different situations to
maximize the acceptance length during verification. To alleviate this dilemma,
we proposed OPT-Tree, an algorithm to construct adaptive and scalable draft
trees. It searches the optimal tree structure that maximizes the mathematical
expectation of the acceptance length in each decoding step. Experimental
results reveal that OPT-Tree outperforms the existing draft structures and
achieves a speed-up ratio of up to 3.2 compared with autoregressive decoding.
If the draft model is powerful enough and the node budget is sufficient, it can
generate more than ten tokens in a single step. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Jikai0Wang/OPT-Tree.
|
[
-0.1214637011,
-0.8320065737,
0.3179235756,
0.4210575521,
-0.5836909413,
0.524769783,
0.2099406719,
-0.5030094981,
0.3694064021,
0.229315415,
-0.5679528713,
-0.2355904281,
-0.4663170576,
0.2738871574,
-0.6354901791,
0.5575474501,
-0.2306566089,
-0.371681571,
0.1435539275,
0.0031359519,
-0.0008826723,
-0.2281915098,
-0.9012598395,
0.2032213956,
-0.0436252132,
0.3235358596,
0.7103261948,
1.0463246107,
0.3417880237,
0.322842598,
-0.129954204,
0.1691351384,
-0.3596370816,
0.1372829527,
0.2580988705,
-0.4443438947,
-0.6056540012,
-0.3478415608,
0.9946175814,
0.2900350988,
-0.2355029732,
0.090585202,
-0.3059508801,
0.8053247929,
-0.6877521873,
0.0445929989,
-1.1240800619,
-0.0053881789,
-0.3462108672,
-0.731277585,
-0.6085469723,
-0.4358267188,
-0.1226259023,
-0.6734272838,
0.286847651,
0.290599227,
0.6303798556,
0.2176592499,
-0.2276507914,
-0.189717263,
-0.4481361806,
0.2357877195,
-0.6683804989,
0.3654813468,
0.4631156623,
0.2997560799,
-0.1777022928,
-0.5681036115,
-0.3823322058,
-0.1519230306,
0.1179746315,
0.2055980712,
-0.199047491,
0.2252710611,
0.2052015364,
0.3504468501,
-0.6943331957,
0.0099633159,
-0.2735657096,
-0.4011388421,
0.4149753451,
0.3198300898,
0.163644731,
-0.191696465,
-0.0388324186,
-0.2295596749,
-0.3436465561,
0.1275430769,
0.5985133648,
0.1828481853,
-0.0011709194,
0.3431715369,
-0.559479177,
0.7613376379,
0.201386109,
0.0905396938,
0.1365802586,
-0.5218608975,
-0.2356945276,
0.2790174186,
0.6043760777,
0.0848529115,
-0.1462894231,
-0.066483885,
-0.2287209779,
0.2891621292,
0.1867571175,
-0.9252612591,
-0.2621606588,
0.3920973539,
-0.6445646286,
-0.4874916375,
-0.2856145501,
-0.6191538572,
0.0670723021,
0.3885466456,
0.0571543202,
-0.8039266467,
-0.5885145664,
0.6387732625,
-0.2580859959,
0.1382498145,
0.290022999,
-0.8455716968,
0.3744048774,
0.3278729916,
0.8919139504,
-0.1323919743,
-0.3372826874,
-0.5323255658,
-0.0666509569,
-0.7231574655,
0.9451234341,
-0.5299702287,
-0.2821654081,
-0.1020073518,
-0.3203705549,
-0.1445502341,
-0.0217354316,
0.8983511329,
-0.7373782992,
-0.0588622801,
-0.0181151889,
-0.5091894269,
-0.0082137333,
0.2528938949,
-0.5122971535,
0.7176206708,
0.2800379992,
-1.1202050447,
0.5356858969,
-0.8351001143,
-0.610231936,
0.2683794498,
0.1408421695,
-0.3412803411,
0.406763941,
0.3923811018,
0.1351907402,
-0.1023632064,
0.0250531211,
-0.2275028378,
-0.3306906819,
-0.0992741138,
-0.7248626947,
0.8906100392,
0.5828088522,
-0.0796491876,
0.0696264654,
-0.8512955308,
0.4048437476,
0.4331948161,
-0.4672579467,
-0.2278404236,
0.3699057698,
-0.0436281972,
-0.2806810141,
0.0285378508,
-0.5440829396,
0.3044800758,
-0.7326368093,
0.6073191762,
0.6042726636,
0.0085007418,
0.3118197024,
-0.1567022502,
0.646707356,
0.1526964605,
0.1645864397,
-0.6361010075,
0.0221545063,
-0.6818546057,
0.0531160422,
0.4059714973,
0.1900482625,
-0.950037837,
0.3804157078,
-0.1559132338,
-0.3823919594,
-0.4726127684,
-0.4919619262,
0.064238064,
0.1571585387,
0.1956877112,
-0.1626012623,
-0.8146205544,
-0.5717653632,
-0.3023055494,
-0.6871143579,
0.4828611314,
0.1052604243,
0.2381037027,
-0.064135775,
0.786646843,
-0.4698858559,
0.2946490347,
-0.0285720285,
0.0605551451,
0.2230155915,
0.5814288855,
0.6875199676,
-0.4919970036,
-0.6052636504,
0.2268088907,
-0.2320443094,
0.0466386341,
-0.3550668955,
-0.1677347571,
0.2930872738,
0.4104793072,
-0.5084217787,
0.1362576932,
0.62369138,
-0.6629094481,
0.6263780594,
-0.3878004253,
0.1375312358,
-1.0292699337,
-0.0207539909,
-0.5037593842,
-0.4204149544,
-0.2235326469,
0.2937036753,
0.1409790665,
0.2294605523,
-0.1220136732,
0.1637613475,
-0.5871592164,
-0.0397882983,
-0.4498857856,
-0.1673324853,
-0.0954499692,
0.1636619866,
-0.0033860765,
0.9317509532,
0.8291401267,
-0.4746904373,
0.0120457625,
-0.0898544043,
-0.2808482647,
0.1439656019,
-0.2946485579,
0.2148533612,
-0.3350824714,
0.4553796947,
-0.9450247288,
-0.2733606696,
0.2374461293,
-0.5027913451,
0.1007962823,
-0.1247076839,
-0.2899623513,
-0.7122418284,
-0.2699356377,
0.634038806,
0.4376227558,
-0.6039571762,
0.6366016865,
0.2553289831,
0.1858506054,
-0.4871792197,
-0.3098952174,
0.2278563082,
-0.0133406809,
-0.4639805555,
0.4351875484,
-0.262265116,
0.2431466728,
0.2490817904,
-0.3954224288,
-0.1803013235,
0.1709232181,
-0.088583678,
0.0305862725,
-0.3809047937,
-0.2088658661,
0.4154244661,
-0.2042033225,
0.1372083575,
-0.9017825723,
0.2434134781,
-0.1430868059,
-0.2174319476,
-0.2902213633,
0.3738646209,
1.0374711752,
-0.1807816774,
0.3051089346,
0.3991563618,
-0.4311130047,
-0.4842096567,
-0.4223569036,
0.036337167,
-0.5051763654,
0.5382265449,
-0.8123385906,
-0.8165094852,
0.4427980781,
-0.1555331051,
0.3633026183,
0.562199831,
0.34072873,
0.2660448551,
1.2530058622,
0.5404236913,
-0.1000077203,
0.4666116834,
-0.1285255551,
-0.0603587441,
-0.5824913979,
-0.0125695821,
-0.793610096,
0.1131422445,
-0.2663538754,
-0.4733503461,
0.0225044955,
0.2883557081,
0.0455473401,
0.4629798532,
-0.8090327382,
0.6489878893,
0.2553254962,
-0.0756682307,
0.3532134891,
0.3006692529,
-0.5540661812,
0.1746433377,
-1.1065522432,
-0.1960588694,
0.8376862407,
0.4765253663,
0.6613150239,
-0.106059812,
0.6665800214,
0.2594752312,
0.193946749,
-0.786714375,
0.5291906595,
-0.1602277458,
-0.412945509,
-0.2159332931,
-0.4664621055,
-0.7128186226,
0.231453225,
-0.1568586677,
-0.5225834846,
0.0276775304,
0.489122659,
-0.3067634404,
0.3774199784,
-0.6635231972,
0.5842030048,
-0.308637023,
-0.1181346402,
-0.4167600274,
-0.1909084618,
0.4503604174,
-0.1764988452,
-0.1180203184,
0.0302688014,
0.0690963864,
0.7397844791,
-0.5084234476,
0.4775837362,
-0.2681206763,
0.2194888592,
0.5299098492,
0.4072074294,
1.0277739763,
0.1693664193,
-0.3078115284,
-0.279868722,
0.3502751887,
-0.453538835,
-0.3395805061,
0.2986050546,
-0.7550315261,
-0.4242887497,
-0.3865081072,
-0.4376744926,
-0.1853239387,
0.4608460665,
0.44135198,
0.2633043826,
-0.3009340763,
0.0637314022,
0.2202315331,
0.1400499046,
0.6783240438,
0.5472564697,
-0.2643939853,
-0.4701249897,
0.7593083382,
-0.0282297935,
0.1801122576,
0.4795467854,
0.2932365835,
-0.4754737318,
-1.3134948015,
-0.6639713049,
-0.2069275826,
-0.4937720299,
-0.392609179,
-0.9792280197,
-0.3058741689,
-0.1106152311,
-0.2469154149,
-0.5507988334,
-0.4255991876,
0.0496730357,
-0.2067920566,
0.5451087356,
0.4651227891,
-0.0595934354,
0.3440786004,
-0.7752802372,
0.2925911844,
0.0436625853,
0.557621479,
0.20828484,
-0.448516041,
-0.2085509002,
-0.1374603063,
0.0697139278,
-0.8438239098,
0.2128321379,
0.0659650564,
0.4048115909,
0.5524018407,
0.3045493066,
0.9844654799,
-0.4918210506,
0.41310817,
0.1760931164,
-1.0065085888,
0.440449208,
-0.419757247,
0.5437947512,
0.7147452235,
-0.0291553959,
-0.3111642897,
-0.4790768027,
-0.632840693,
-0.7493874431,
1.0378984213,
0.2526126802,
0.062994279,
-0.0567832105,
0.5068323612,
0.1104098856,
-0.1828304082,
-0.4581867754,
-0.0483418815,
-0.4049794972,
-0.0554632097,
0.3011868298,
-0.5364390016,
0.3074717522,
-0.0934361741,
0.5961805582,
-0.454418689,
0.3210688233,
0.2984780371,
0.2420033365,
-0.6612387896,
0.2081299424,
0.3898661137,
0.3679564893,
-0.3651292622,
0.1929856837,
0.1944347769,
-0.5873295665,
0.1599105597,
0.0467713997,
-0.3866202831,
0.043866884,
0.26083377,
1.0955004692,
-0.1904463172,
-0.4204901159,
0.0966016576,
-0.4339394569,
-0.5338955522,
0.0086837113,
0.077516675,
0.0172640346,
0.0049647903,
0.5069638491,
0.5186198354,
0.2227158397,
-0.2055225223,
0.2438352555,
0.5790318847,
-0.0051628225,
-0.4355091751,
0.6779103279,
0.279360801,
-0.3958803415,
0.5642420053,
-0.5219715238,
-0.5667209625,
0.6065766215,
0.9551058412,
1.2967447042,
-0.1080336869,
0.3940938711,
0.6203178763,
0.5643862486,
-0.2145669907,
0.4753661454,
-0.2301425934,
-0.7892075181,
-0.5356539488,
-0.939684093,
-0.2367427349,
-0.0476821698,
-0.2319552302,
-0.1037404463,
-0.3707442582,
-0.1279823482,
-0.1979978979,
-0.089539431,
-0.4282725751,
0.0175615326,
-0.1998554021,
1.3529362679,
-0.6693969965,
0.8896386027,
0.630426228,
0.3515868783,
-0.9978747964,
0.2580432296,
-0.2498533279,
-0.6074981689,
0.2257919908,
0.0138697224,
-0.2515888512,
0.4106677771,
-0.0831470639,
-1.0998871326,
0.7260070443,
0.3115996122,
-0.5424947739,
-0.2073817402,
-0.2002211362,
0.3924529552,
-0.566879034,
0.3405075073,
0.4438423514,
0.4077884257,
0.3952610791,
-0.5957988501,
0.1431704462,
-0.2530197203,
0.0604189336,
0.2629023492,
-0.3717842996,
0.6312755346,
-0.2774291635,
-0.6420814395,
0.1243398711,
0.5666000843,
0.1069662422,
0.0139664989,
0.8197159767,
0.3489750624,
0.7007067204,
0.1370957345,
0.9192597866,
-0.7336697578,
0.2835301459,
0.7476937175,
-0.0621945187,
0.817034781,
0.1872788072,
-0.4012567997,
0.195178315,
0.82275635,
0.3993237019,
0.4157685637,
-0.0033805333,
-0.0831344351,
-0.4872488379,
-0.0064786547,
-0.3323081732,
0.4799336493,
0.4056651592,
-0.2066988647,
-0.3725637794,
-0.2716040611,
-0.3342314959,
-0.1786809713,
-0.3009961545,
0.4034713209,
-0.2686397731,
-0.9371122122,
0.841704905,
0.2803127468,
0.5747042298,
-0.854906261,
0.1639392972,
0.0342364199,
0.0385999456,
-0.1596291512,
-0.4338816404,
0.411711961,
-0.1725248992,
-0.1192425638,
-0.2747012377,
0.7635214925,
-0.2757332623,
-0.6819329858,
0.1363978237,
0.5995137691,
-0.0366185158,
0.0800820589,
-0.8580933809,
0.5253210068,
0.1660003066,
-0.2687502801,
-0.0660303235,
0.4717425704,
-0.0998412296,
0.3966912925,
0.9612833261,
0.297083348,
0.1656271666,
-0.1685925573,
0.8455617428,
-0.5105816126,
-0.9785926938,
-0.855887711,
0.2498043776,
0.0755966827,
-0.2481323481,
0.5875414014,
0.580308795,
0.7025453448,
0.0519957356,
0.7590647936,
-0.2209934443,
0.026818851,
-0.6049189568,
0.4326888025,
-0.3564241529,
0.074797757,
-0.2938738465,
-0.7633034587,
-0.2037012577,
0.5824922919,
0.1732941568,
-0.0944427475,
0.9752485752,
0.6656729579,
-0.0392159559,
0.2649097145,
0.2205170542,
0.3969455361,
0.2251990288,
0.776619494,
0.7182920575,
-0.4907014668,
0.6070994735,
-0.0859839469,
-0.2393156737,
-0.1253614426,
-0.9064643979,
-0.7270674109,
-0.5707350373,
-0.3596918583,
-0.3779233098,
0.2445845455,
0.867243886,
0.8240789175,
-0.4983916879,
-0.1604742706,
-0.8377754092,
0.13707605,
-0.4624568522,
-0.2298804373,
0.601491034,
-0.4330633581,
-0.5733143091,
0.6203936338,
0.5511173606,
0.1716290116,
-0.1591528505,
-0.1845901459,
0.0164746139,
0.2140208781,
0.5103174448,
0.3053539693,
-0.5710201263,
-0.0843229815,
0.1019131392,
0.0641059726,
0.0049109254,
1.1026799679,
-0.990004003,
0.6934687495,
0.8106452227,
0.8673855662,
0.4921256602,
0.049052313,
0.4178986847,
-0.2947452366,
0.0975767747,
0.2965963185,
0.3899503946,
-0.1477846354,
-0.4836104214,
0.2448360026,
0.2826144993,
-0.1722688377,
-0.8885142803,
0.2262538821,
-0.8549386263,
-0.3766512573,
0.7503526211,
0.1135114729,
-0.3556951284,
-0.1059021577,
-0.3837406039,
-0.0379085839,
-0.5579281449,
0.6520207524,
0.474306047,
-0.0519749671,
-0.2356864065,
-0.0585155413,
0.6157209277,
0.3826074302,
-0.7933846116,
0.5049564242,
0.4212768674,
0.1271394938,
0.173923105,
1.2183721066,
-0.1315166801,
0.5545662045,
0.6796167493,
-0.5107452869,
-0.3835887015,
-0.2964210212,
-0.2186453789,
0.5257682204,
0.4926854968,
-0.1880133301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17274v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17274v1
|
Can We Trust the Performance Evaluation of Uncertainty Estimation Methods in Text Summarization?
| 2024-06-25T04:41:17 | 2024-06-25T04:41:17 |
Jianfeng He, Runing Yang, Linlin Yu, Changbin Li, Ruoxi Jia, Feng Chen, Ming Jin, Chang-Tien Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Text summarization, a key natural language generation (NLG) task, is vital in
various domains. However, the high cost of inaccurate summaries in
risk-critical applications, particularly those involving human-in-the-loop
decision-making, raises concerns about the reliability of uncertainty
estimation on text summarization (UE-TS) evaluation methods. This concern stems
from the dependency of uncertainty model metrics on diverse and potentially
conflicting NLG metrics. To address this issue, we introduce a comprehensive
UE-TS benchmark incorporating 31 NLG metrics across four dimensions. The
benchmark evaluates the uncertainty estimation capabilities of two large
language models and one pre-trained language model on three datasets, with
human-annotation analysis incorporated where applicable. We also assess the
performance of 14 common uncertainty estimation methods within this benchmark.
Our findings emphasize the importance of considering multiple uncorrelated NLG
metrics and diverse uncertainty estimation methods to ensure reliable and
efficient evaluation of UE-TS techniques.
|
[
-0.2286499292,
-0.3912580609,
0.598780334,
0.241354689,
-0.4092671275,
0.3591955304,
-0.263923049,
-0.4588379264,
-0.1967145205,
0.1143874526,
-0.1467905045,
-0.5368813276,
-0.7999377847,
0.3044413328,
-0.3032398522,
0.8320885301,
-0.0318301544,
-0.1009841785,
-0.1816436946,
-0.0413356684,
-0.3000943661,
-0.2524555027,
-0.3884307444,
-0.2208281457,
0.0619086288,
0.1429753304,
0.7407851815,
0.4395796955,
0.653491497,
0.267883569,
-0.1109328941,
0.2113185823,
-0.0353791378,
0.2611859739,
-0.0559391044,
-0.2479082644,
-0.4981279373,
0.0141256601,
0.7564640045,
0.6309124827,
-0.33502087,
0.4121712446,
0.2080673724,
0.6611884832,
-0.9108385444,
-0.3300566077,
-0.6456730366,
0.1479098648,
-0.0870385095,
0.1295265108,
-0.2637019455,
-0.5379366875,
0.6027654409,
-0.6231550574,
0.1285273582,
0.105253309,
0.8513348699,
0.4315274358,
-0.4390659332,
-0.2048355341,
-0.7618653774,
1.0347430706,
-1.0586515665,
0.246440798,
0.4736791253,
0.3393830657,
-0.0241095424,
-0.7277681231,
-0.1111354604,
0.0938137397,
-0.0230900869,
0.4452296197,
-0.2407658994,
0.0991422832,
-0.0810810775,
0.2779887617,
-0.5456080437,
0.150262922,
-0.1425336152,
-0.5560898185,
0.6372666955,
0.0216929186,
0.0296929348,
-0.3459682465,
-0.5300353765,
-0.0338790305,
-0.0779732764,
-0.1292053163,
0.4607920945,
0.1404257417,
-0.1566270888,
0.3848823309,
-0.2379327565,
0.6191053987,
-0.3051019609,
-0.3302998543,
0.1171479225,
-0.5353574157,
-0.3316042721,
-0.1179940626,
1.2532418966,
0.7174541354,
0.3323845863,
-0.5003934503,
-0.0612716861,
-0.0563154481,
0.438451916,
-0.5602261424,
0.0587626584,
0.3063643575,
-0.1234361455,
-0.2939389646,
0.2701712847,
-1.018032074,
-0.2953305542,
0.1632512957,
0.3431503773,
-0.4527125955,
-0.1185515448,
0.0677531287,
-0.4020465016,
-0.2342981994,
0.1887969077,
-0.5708156824,
0.3530274928,
0.3838858008,
0.735434711,
-0.3803918958,
-0.4619248807,
-0.1690187156,
0.1056425199,
-0.3936493993,
0.8233101964,
-0.1698057204,
-0.4756407142,
-0.1365735233,
-0.723601222,
-0.257807672,
-0.2125095874,
0.9987172484,
-0.0566298813,
0.1884329766,
-0.2396518141,
-0.6502712369,
-0.1299356073,
0.0939080045,
-0.5847688317,
1.3023425341,
0.146329239,
-1.078625083,
0.5771406293,
-0.3018840849,
-0.2996835709,
-0.3029930294,
-0.0602578446,
-0.7212534547,
0.3910591602,
0.4800717533,
0.4527884126,
-0.5673773289,
0.3195978999,
-0.1801825464,
-0.4084182978,
0.4558604956,
-0.7439991832,
0.3789725304,
0.2264058143,
-0.2135244459,
-0.0681070238,
-0.7565208673,
0.2683385015,
-0.2570983469,
-0.1132564768,
-0.3222509623,
-0.0620209612,
0.0174358096,
-0.0176082551,
0.2572186291,
-0.2799146473,
-0.3428739905,
-0.1725074351,
0.1405443996,
0.4246634841,
0.2934951186,
0.3765113056,
-0.2780872881,
0.6785091162,
-0.1687739342,
-0.007042361,
-0.0230635274,
-0.4290347397,
-0.1935175806,
-0.0190143753,
0.6328856349,
0.445620507,
-0.3428964615,
0.3860251009,
-0.2966284752,
-0.8211222291,
-0.1747353971,
-0.1102602631,
0.697670877,
0.360886693,
0.3206011355,
-0.0760084465,
-0.6371718049,
-0.5617361665,
-0.8956212401,
-0.4429841042,
-0.4221237898,
-0.1661719084,
0.452096194,
0.0225077569,
1.0434041023,
-0.2576790154,
-0.0159618855,
-0.2175644636,
0.9727908373,
-0.2395633012,
0.2621686757,
0.6500890851,
-0.3093596995,
-0.3721092343,
-0.2454510033,
-0.8968048692,
-0.0645655543,
-0.2844617367,
0.0560523309,
0.3331072927,
0.2072298527,
-0.3469131887,
0.5067566037,
0.7087572813,
-0.0867586285,
0.69409132,
-0.4899407029,
0.4042002261,
-1.1923099756,
0.011512069,
0.2875079811,
-0.1434125453,
-0.4507117569,
-0.0294721536,
0.0861431658,
0.4032377601,
-0.0721067339,
0.2099518329,
-0.5992190838,
-0.3291024268,
0.0364467464,
0.4908094406,
0.1545602083,
0.0810597092,
-0.1152285188,
0.860383451,
0.4757359028,
-0.5312995315,
-0.2257814258,
0.0016122515,
-0.4588572085,
0.6434857249,
-0.7917799354,
-0.0679749325,
0.2188431323,
0.1805779785,
-0.8830120564,
-0.3459269702,
-0.2436414212,
-0.5999004245,
0.1713805944,
0.3482884169,
-0.4784678519,
-0.279761076,
-0.5755000114,
0.2020204216,
0.2081193775,
-0.0655153096,
0.6717997193,
0.3806711733,
-0.0985663831,
-0.9013129473,
-0.8280671835,
0.2596486509,
-0.3317928016,
-0.3223885,
0.0468748622,
0.1471634209,
-0.3867119551,
-0.1997388601,
-0.6478843093,
-0.3060162365,
0.3776476681,
0.2166909873,
-0.115534395,
-0.0146644395,
0.0190990493,
0.3168149292,
-0.0615246743,
0.0273226257,
-0.0829946175,
0.0320938714,
-0.1670790613,
-0.267896384,
-0.2225736231,
0.1058302522,
0.4526075423,
-0.2942742109,
0.3929227889,
0.7302291989,
-0.5170281529,
-0.011034091,
-0.5975974798,
0.0767226219,
-0.3602804542,
0.4492053092,
-0.0579161011,
-0.5732606053,
0.7102429867,
-0.0570848733,
0.1129315421,
0.6313358545,
0.0953781605,
-0.4365350604,
0.539041996,
0.4998740554,
-0.0793631375,
0.0602393039,
0.1327186823,
-0.0908212587,
-0.7794269919,
0.1480360031,
-0.7844001651,
-0.1702270508,
-0.5746037364,
-0.2742604911,
0.5501918793,
0.3726341426,
0.050403893,
0.3940894306,
-0.2807414532,
0.3499236703,
0.5547128916,
-0.1996205896,
0.5166935325,
-0.09154208,
-0.108299695,
-0.231313765,
-0.5340073705,
-0.7390803695,
1.4416646957,
0.3625385463,
0.516109705,
0.0950287804,
0.737216115,
0.2987325788,
0.1237703934,
-0.268620342,
0.2168574184,
-0.0518542379,
-0.6948041916,
-0.7464401126,
-0.6411018372,
-0.6940892339,
0.3682823777,
-0.4089077115,
-1.0962121487,
-0.1451647133,
0.0356280543,
-0.698497355,
0.3725538552,
-0.7232228518,
0.6337531805,
-0.0448263697,
0.2114990503,
0.0612771697,
-0.8057265878,
0.3651100397,
-0.2222388536,
0.3018793464,
-0.1434764564,
-0.2591004372,
0.9713717699,
-0.2501048148,
0.5790145993,
0.22277309,
-0.0890446454,
0.4250659049,
0.0647977889,
0.4159686267,
0.2944469452,
-0.3157303929,
0.4834410548,
-0.120271638,
-0.1722636968,
-0.3984781206,
0.234991774,
-0.7167260051,
-0.05641618,
-0.6914356351,
-0.6080886722,
-0.5959918499,
0.2500499487,
0.9022842646,
0.4634150565,
-0.3831319809,
0.1409834772,
0.3884969056,
-0.0663548857,
0.8333263397,
0.1141759902,
0.0909681022,
-0.6857255697,
0.5414590836,
0.1595695913,
0.5717383623,
0.4147193134,
0.3019795716,
-0.2688613236,
-0.9281842113,
-0.3969686925,
-0.0856233314,
-0.324834466,
-0.4608673155,
-0.6398756504,
-0.0430805534,
-0.2242034376,
-0.1964971274,
-0.6495743394,
-0.445931077,
-0.1092403457,
-0.3893186152,
0.3349290192,
0.662291348,
-0.0223811753,
0.6612289548,
-0.9076142907,
0.2901364267,
0.130522266,
0.6185360551,
-0.3500695825,
-0.5365775824,
-0.3180599213,
0.180653289,
-0.2839580178,
-0.8579577208,
0.0390608013,
0.2316524088,
0.6018343568,
0.245199427,
0.2303083241,
0.3710429966,
-0.1245705932,
1.011100173,
0.1900753677,
-1.1352757215,
0.3026393652,
-0.565479219,
0.4728012979,
0.9717997313,
0.2222961932,
-0.2237959206,
-0.8026590943,
-0.7344456911,
-0.8380793929,
0.4010232389,
0.616681695,
-0.4565989077,
0.1062509716,
0.2145136595,
-0.0403855368,
0.388856262,
-0.3816982508,
-0.3471090198,
-0.0240141489,
-0.1380366087,
-0.0461821742,
-0.4787330925,
0.1196754202,
0.1994579881,
0.5517885089,
-0.0723841637,
-0.0643025562,
0.0961071327,
-0.0820165202,
-0.1468160748,
0.4097926319,
0.6989894509,
0.8876930475,
-0.6313302517,
-0.0192684829,
0.4296232462,
-0.7435473204,
-0.0192561857,
0.0454092249,
-0.1758263856,
0.3427253664,
0.5691507459,
0.3561374247,
0.524246037,
-0.4856958687,
0.4134083092,
-0.4746544659,
-0.2152888477,
-0.2419418693,
-0.3212696314,
-0.0656571165,
-0.2015070617,
0.4114920199,
0.4685823917,
0.4211178124,
0.0016623809,
0.2996048331,
0.109833844,
-0.4870918095,
-0.1764130592,
0.7495163679,
0.1451283544,
0.0172158461,
0.1479566395,
-0.2629004419,
-0.2749758065,
0.4575306773,
0.1244169697,
1.1641943455,
-0.3191473186,
0.5497788191,
0.5798367858,
0.7537578344,
-0.4277560115,
0.1548057646,
0.3089988232,
-0.5823111534,
-0.5417522788,
-0.530526042,
-0.6851421595,
-0.2909360826,
-0.8704093695,
-0.2163707912,
-0.1404356211,
-0.5567293167,
-0.2984898686,
0.0004836116,
-0.4292427897,
0.4138418138,
-0.1047525853,
0.7292969823,
-0.7757222056,
0.2162995189,
0.5244697332,
-0.1109138206,
-0.8428325057,
0.3361994922,
0.1946454942,
-0.1509601474,
-0.1196099818,
-0.0701686516,
-0.3889584839,
-0.427955538,
0.0292755961,
-0.8993719816,
1.2811386585,
0.3780360818,
-0.3724330366,
-0.0346578844,
0.3056443632,
0.6241466999,
0.0088177212,
0.6651878953,
0.7729851007,
0.4798165262,
-0.1631177366,
-1.1828784943,
-0.0293885861,
0.1776440293,
0.2334977835,
0.1357999742,
-0.4643261731,
0.562732935,
-0.3311676979,
-0.3868176937,
0.1438803971,
0.7852156758,
0.1963938773,
0.2627164423,
0.4181416631,
0.430639565,
0.9073653221,
-0.331305027,
1.0763560534,
-0.2479514033,
0.372569114,
1.4683231115,
-0.0036933434,
0.7523649931,
0.3341627419,
-0.4853854477,
0.0865974799,
0.4622044861,
0.3540912867,
0.126762107,
-0.0341418087,
0.1167936474,
-0.0793837979,
0.0052275723,
-0.2695299685,
0.4948496521,
0.2832162976,
-0.1920877099,
-0.4306332171,
-0.5508597493,
0.1146787852,
0.4635368288,
0.0976409018,
0.7520602345,
0.0910201669,
-0.5635725856,
0.1797282845,
-0.117950961,
0.6931192875,
-0.5950141549,
0.3623496592,
-0.0883974731,
-0.0697332397,
-0.0016520029,
-0.6775439978,
0.3486569524,
0.1686430275,
0.2487782389,
-0.0294856541,
0.4496168494,
-0.090166539,
-0.6373768449,
0.0492068306,
0.6171910167,
-0.0009613152,
-0.253611356,
-0.2837380469,
-0.1272762865,
-0.082874015,
-0.2848918736,
0.1325635463,
0.6520934105,
0.1198473051,
0.5612987876,
0.1809160411,
0.1532713026,
0.0473292172,
0.041969467,
0.2078562677,
-0.3571147621,
-0.3124064207,
-0.8465936184,
0.7886754274,
-0.370921731,
-0.8942645192,
0.9938905835,
0.4927442074,
0.6211573482,
0.1457302868,
1.0350254774,
0.2217069715,
0.5629275441,
-0.3200779855,
0.765103519,
-0.1702504158,
0.1534946263,
-0.8791828156,
-0.9333306551,
-0.3668028414,
0.3319808543,
-0.0087791178,
0.2216074318,
0.9159360528,
0.235144496,
0.3121132851,
0.287068218,
0.3231895864,
-0.1354727149,
0.1808307469,
0.1462986618,
0.4182352126,
-0.8711310029,
0.596671164,
-0.4610752463,
-0.1848385036,
0.0381538831,
-1.2784456015,
-0.8088029623,
-0.4802725613,
-0.3588880599,
0.0059809266,
-0.0804093406,
0.6627333164,
0.4760168195,
-0.7448455095,
-0.2590680122,
-0.0152025865,
0.1625745445,
-0.5640774965,
-0.1321005672,
0.398052901,
-0.1654716879,
-0.5931484699,
0.0302461982,
0.3222253025,
0.196409449,
-0.1151724011,
0.1084144637,
-0.0944419801,
0.2080788165,
0.1577872336,
0.113994576,
-0.6142061949,
-0.3892773986,
-0.1197903305,
-0.13570638,
-0.3296545148,
0.5579687953,
-0.2727199793,
0.3694842458,
0.2746400833,
0.6972833872,
0.1643801481,
0.2948000729,
0.9324418902,
-1.0838694572,
-0.2192611396,
0.0694408044,
0.4590810835,
0.347799778,
-0.1747546792,
0.7053794265,
-0.2591210902,
-0.6055554152,
-0.9143325686,
0.0040175207,
-0.9158960581,
0.1055807993,
0.9383591413,
-0.3057032526,
0.0960474536,
-0.0818913355,
0.2884083688,
0.3646717966,
-0.5183300376,
0.9112657905,
0.8218608499,
0.0850646421,
0.0829321221,
-0.5302735567,
0.5519214869,
0.3216645122,
-0.9406407475,
0.2132537067,
0.252934128,
-0.0223744884,
0.4336192012,
0.3945778906,
-0.0805331916,
0.2362370491,
0.1358236969,
0.1267771721,
0.1309138238,
-0.3209499121,
-0.1130613387,
-0.0339583009,
-0.0279181674,
-0.1124950498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17271v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17271v1
|
DARG: Dynamic Evaluation of Large Language Models via Adaptive Reasoning Graph
| 2024-06-25T04:27:53 | 2024-06-25T04:27:53 |
Zhehao Zhang, Jiaao Chen, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The current paradigm of evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) through
static benchmarks comes with significant limitations, such as vulnerability to
data contamination and a lack of adaptability to the evolving capabilities of
LLMs. Therefore, evaluation methods that can adapt and generate evaluation data
with controlled complexity are urgently needed. In this work, we introduce
Dynamic Evaluation of LLMs via Adaptive Reasoning Graph Evolvement (DARG) to
dynamically extend current benchmarks with controlled complexity and diversity.
Specifically, we first extract the reasoning graphs of data points in current
benchmarks and then perturb the reasoning graphs to generate novel testing
data. Such newly generated test samples can have different levels of complexity
while maintaining linguistic diversity similar to the original benchmarks. We
further use a code-augmented LLM to ensure the label correctness of newly
generated data. We apply our DARG framework to diverse reasoning tasks in four
domains with 15 state-of-the-art LLMs. Experimental results show that almost
all LLMs experience a performance decrease with increased complexity and
certain LLMs exhibit significant drops. Additionally, we find that LLMs exhibit
more biases when being evaluated via the data generated by DARG with higher
complexity levels. These observations provide useful insights into how to
dynamically and adaptively evaluate LLMs. The code is available at
https://github.com/SALT-NLP/DARG.
|
[
-0.3884399235,
-1.0992560387,
0.4040178955,
0.2416630983,
-0.2018381655,
0.6323527098,
-0.5946469307,
-0.2990328074,
-0.278856039,
0.2793622017,
-0.4224851131,
-0.7260399461,
-0.8422750235,
0.1886889338,
-0.1417897046,
1.0001301765,
-0.1229865924,
-0.1267345995,
-0.2713799477,
-0.4033105671,
-0.5407429934,
-0.1917069107,
-0.5457239747,
-0.4439550936,
0.2840301991,
0.213532567,
0.8366085887,
0.6935660243,
0.3981497586,
0.4034404457,
-0.3727067709,
0.4663104117,
-0.6371728778,
0.513694644,
-0.2769538164,
-0.2918484509,
-0.5716696978,
-0.2544721365,
0.8956583142,
0.8822031617,
-0.0153622916,
0.1571781933,
-0.0305307936,
0.5320907831,
-0.5010602474,
0.3379018307,
-0.9552828074,
-0.1697348058,
-0.0683973432,
-0.0655312836,
-0.3839710057,
-0.4400057495,
0.3262162507,
-0.3688470125,
-0.2429762036,
0.0013397316,
0.6522516608,
0.4579391479,
-0.3990387022,
-0.4301716387,
-0.5586581826,
0.7707579732,
-0.6461576819,
0.2655271292,
-0.1054320186,
0.5091904998,
-0.4888122976,
-0.9509038329,
-0.401090771,
-0.5884953737,
0.1591829807,
-0.0534178875,
-0.2553334236,
-0.0335585661,
0.4392265379,
0.415618062,
-0.4439634979,
0.2123168707,
0.2260611206,
0.1860416532,
0.6167944074,
0.2582556307,
0.4369390011,
-0.0647714436,
-0.2631371915,
-0.0743504465,
-0.393175751,
-0.1814976633,
0.4214551747,
0.3270891011,
-0.1474255621,
0.1681794077,
-0.1605707854,
0.8516147137,
0.0875023529,
-0.0382016562,
0.6183955669,
-0.1567435265,
-0.1053842455,
-0.2530950606,
0.5451701283,
0.1560258716,
0.3067985773,
-0.1598341614,
-0.2740293443,
-0.2748208046,
0.2254002839,
-0.5736467242,
-0.2827475965,
0.1367702931,
-0.370690465,
-0.3199771643,
-0.2806865573,
-1.0892437696,
-0.7677747011,
-0.2266898155,
0.2564140558,
-0.4390013218,
-0.2781608105,
0.264829427,
-0.0921398327,
-0.0983437598,
0.5397943258,
-0.5674305558,
0.4426060915,
0.6032139659,
0.6604226232,
-0.5897621512,
-0.2856727839,
-0.6769860983,
0.04508733,
-0.1589603275,
0.7577521205,
-0.8728577495,
-0.2138656974,
-0.0498048253,
-0.1716138422,
-0.1040742993,
-0.9450914264,
0.6036230922,
-0.5689386725,
-0.2330004126,
-0.1857526153,
-0.5695291162,
-0.1279457062,
0.3745892942,
-0.5723409057,
1.197142601,
0.4303594232,
-0.7261595726,
0.3020566106,
-0.833330214,
-0.4276931882,
0.3631612957,
-0.1549265385,
-0.5154749155,
-0.0005207905,
0.2972820997,
0.0447335877,
-0.4261530936,
0.4039990306,
-0.6059738398,
-0.2303402424,
0.3710031807,
-0.3518052995,
0.7894209027,
0.1953990459,
-0.5135720372,
0.3112734258,
-1.1297943592,
0.2851334512,
0.0720913187,
-0.5631081462,
-0.1866473705,
0.2122697979,
-0.4000119865,
-0.0539249294,
0.1809054166,
-0.2405900508,
0.3380354345,
-0.2115896791,
0.319241941,
0.9048062563,
-0.0422526076,
0.3088653386,
-0.3258102834,
0.7087577581,
-0.1409934759,
-0.0493374206,
-0.013288198,
-0.3437203169,
-0.9644513726,
-0.361946404,
0.3985924721,
0.5510557294,
-0.799081862,
0.501011312,
-0.5421818495,
-0.5567575097,
-0.2759544849,
0.1615724415,
0.1929380149,
0.2036209553,
0.2335336655,
-0.1347288042,
-0.5253254175,
-0.6036657095,
-0.3870772421,
-0.1654243916,
0.0138205672,
0.7582368255,
0.4160302281,
-0.4179967642,
0.6572712064,
-0.4258190691,
0.3455812037,
-0.3799271286,
0.2172042131,
0.3232654631,
0.3141356111,
0.6667058468,
-0.4482449889,
-0.4979501963,
0.2800208926,
-0.5728822351,
-0.7525913119,
-0.2302518785,
-0.1397474408,
0.0290630758,
0.3228366375,
-0.4527853131,
0.0608126633,
0.6355625987,
-0.2145173401,
0.8806564212,
-0.1667536795,
0.023218127,
-0.5456428528,
-0.0927103534,
-0.2531144619,
-0.2936712503,
-0.5197591186,
0.3350256383,
-0.1739851981,
0.0252043474,
-0.0673213005,
0.8190472126,
-0.5531414151,
-0.1913271099,
-0.4125567973,
0.2778600454,
-0.1189719215,
0.2127767056,
-0.3944269121,
0.5872508883,
0.8150086403,
-0.6407396793,
0.7801722884,
0.061887119,
-0.7292941213,
0.2429533452,
-0.4694744945,
0.1912749708,
0.0654757917,
0.2926397026,
-0.851508081,
0.0013473135,
0.0894662142,
-0.179982841,
0.2602399886,
-0.2034921944,
-0.606054008,
-0.3715245426,
-0.0625170097,
0.5118153691,
0.5271000266,
-0.8277225494,
0.7550529838,
0.2793674469,
-0.3995987475,
-0.4054243267,
-0.3664301634,
0.1788308769,
-0.3454630375,
-0.6774883866,
0.3203183115,
-0.2777557969,
-0.4129398465,
-0.1168045625,
-0.2715661824,
0.158765167,
0.2419361472,
0.0206884332,
-0.0659441724,
-0.1023280323,
0.2659713328,
0.1246557534,
-0.0063648694,
0.017470967,
-0.339817822,
0.7665618062,
-0.2729054093,
-0.2701535821,
-0.0199260265,
-0.0630376637,
0.5212501884,
-0.2561103702,
0.4075543582,
0.6671985388,
-0.239547208,
-0.89604491,
-0.3213227987,
0.2249616235,
-0.5451318622,
0.6380819678,
-0.5593833327,
-0.9113399982,
0.7870258093,
-0.6815883517,
-0.010341594,
0.1182945892,
1.0017921925,
0.3076417446,
0.7802098989,
0.2229667753,
0.3487522304,
0.3427805603,
-0.0544480421,
0.2046056092,
-0.6443108916,
-0.1999267042,
-0.3724446595,
-0.3571135402,
-0.7819685936,
-0.6601803303,
0.2918316722,
0.1805139631,
-0.2888344228,
0.0204416327,
-0.3605065942,
0.4621472061,
0.218518734,
0.0607393235,
0.2757710814,
-0.1131850779,
-0.3273047805,
0.2078729272,
-0.6304872036,
-0.4477966726,
1.0216448307,
0.3898335695,
0.9091755152,
0.120715417,
0.3707189262,
0.5703476667,
0.3184176981,
-0.5907612443,
0.723302424,
-0.4345610738,
-0.1329161972,
-0.2102960199,
-0.6676229835,
-0.8687648773,
0.3672833145,
-0.1361946464,
-0.6720544696,
0.0392851159,
-0.0274833534,
-0.0756850466,
0.2960288525,
-0.5352395773,
0.5972933769,
-0.5418550372,
-0.2957351208,
-0.1715335399,
-0.3106999397,
0.3040314317,
-0.3221596181,
0.2644610107,
-0.3208748996,
-0.0066836206,
0.5906413794,
-0.3709560931,
0.6673916578,
-0.1737636477,
-0.1774016172,
0.2459087223,
0.1665138751,
0.617708981,
0.1815666705,
-0.5099827647,
0.0764537454,
-0.2596512735,
-0.4369490147,
-0.9012476206,
0.8665861487,
-0.7432415485,
-0.8153098822,
-0.410409838,
-1.1035550833,
-0.3806306422,
0.2665294111,
-0.4364856482,
0.1047521681,
0.080559656,
0.1778060943,
0.3292586207,
-0.7789149284,
0.1881073862,
0.415635258,
-0.3333052397,
-0.5731484294,
0.6805214286,
-0.0207839198,
0.5260084271,
0.0338480435,
0.3860263824,
-0.1647612154,
-0.9968169332,
-0.3041872978,
0.0832184777,
-0.862996161,
-0.1673586816,
-0.5446445942,
-0.2039357871,
-0.3172916174,
0.0184923839,
-0.1585023254,
-0.4360341132,
0.0566261299,
-0.0869360268,
0.4411747754,
0.6349664927,
-0.0121372091,
0.3287120759,
-0.5303126574,
0.2440788597,
0.3210753798,
0.6400800347,
0.0267392918,
-0.5686112642,
-0.1461486518,
-0.0695943907,
-0.2270691544,
-0.5877739787,
0.1937599182,
0.2790772319,
0.9117655754,
0.1477588415,
0.1457138509,
0.7255905271,
-0.5588202477,
0.636423111,
-0.1757078171,
-1.1636422873,
0.3366101384,
-0.540451467,
0.4701732099,
0.2923711538,
-0.005909936,
-0.191697523,
-0.3610739708,
-0.4186391234,
-0.8306609988,
0.6224925518,
0.0844987258,
0.1743827462,
0.0625609979,
0.6056689024,
0.3063714802,
0.1001744419,
-0.7193802595,
-0.2665400505,
-0.0422233939,
-0.1186194643,
0.2646184266,
-0.2200376093,
-0.1818497032,
-0.2738598585,
0.4018382728,
-0.2267831862,
0.1171344072,
-0.387278229,
-0.07454326,
0.0911702663,
0.2320406884,
0.3115314245,
0.8701788783,
-0.1959099174,
0.2595967054,
0.5388584137,
-0.2255636752,
0.0962000489,
0.2585480213,
-0.1523988992,
-0.0793265626,
0.4206234813,
1.2017930746,
0.0685728416,
-1.0366241932,
0.2481413633,
0.0115643339,
-0.0778634772,
-0.0201313756,
0.3531232178,
-0.0084567377,
0.3977583945,
0.1460612118,
-0.067379646,
-0.1367502511,
-0.3878445923,
0.3786952198,
0.4263623953,
0.094960168,
-0.0923522115,
0.4465966821,
0.2223798037,
-0.2708666623,
0.4643978179,
-0.4148476124,
-0.6081908345,
0.6500712633,
0.7396447062,
0.8284966946,
-0.1403758228,
0.2164482623,
0.2586965859,
0.1770994067,
0.2662942708,
0.2150256634,
0.0277975537,
-0.7552704811,
-0.524178803,
-0.8456104398,
-0.4816431701,
0.2918072939,
-0.3227089047,
0.442953676,
-0.6153882146,
-0.1735401005,
-0.0232779477,
0.0246441159,
-0.3148264587,
0.2921448946,
0.1467456073,
0.8875649571,
-0.4974186718,
0.7469763756,
0.7386677861,
0.0967090875,
-0.325923115,
0.0870857015,
-0.1634002328,
-0.9215270877,
0.7961684465,
-0.0688768402,
-0.0372391567,
-0.0722488612,
-0.4083358347,
-1.0370354652,
0.9081571698,
0.6280481219,
-0.331448108,
0.2052902877,
0.2942726314,
0.6657380462,
-0.4684790671,
0.3249396384,
0.7546094656,
0.6751872301,
0.1993891448,
-0.83200562,
0.1122832373,
-0.4032852054,
0.0345352516,
0.0310069565,
-0.4808540046,
0.8318668008,
-0.1642620265,
-0.2730056942,
0.0853435248,
0.4311425388,
0.5448409915,
0.119103089,
0.7230865359,
0.6482429504,
0.9106715322,
-0.329264611,
0.9644088149,
-0.3585571349,
0.333545208,
1.2498311996,
-0.4925093353,
0.4833109975,
-0.0272101779,
-0.3155103326,
0.7736245394,
0.5612958074,
-0.3386491537,
0.2383159399,
0.8676934242,
-0.3544755876,
-0.2969254553,
-0.0737459213,
-0.1444261521,
0.4991191328,
0.3560829163,
-0.230685696,
-0.4071686268,
-0.0123742921,
-0.0001567797,
0.1662066281,
-0.1564441919,
0.6081123352,
-0.145993039,
-0.602238059,
1.0247309208,
0.0518809669,
0.4472229183,
-0.5709884763,
0.0665874109,
-0.1614455134,
0.2060070485,
-0.1375662833,
-0.732721746,
0.1396245062,
0.1048529223,
-0.0310314726,
-0.175334096,
0.7583737373,
-0.3410725594,
-0.4273236394,
0.6072311401,
0.544419229,
0.0702472702,
0.3686642647,
-0.8381755352,
0.4979254901,
0.0348712057,
-0.2020687163,
0.3347137272,
0.6255207062,
-0.144379437,
0.9991620183,
0.6274759769,
0.3150784671,
0.4332668185,
0.4673474431,
1.0386228561,
-0.390612781,
-0.3510596752,
-0.867164433,
0.3712030053,
-0.1727733165,
-0.0847645029,
0.6445410848,
0.3686456382,
0.7023534775,
0.0447827652,
1.0079984665,
-0.0854492038,
0.4107894003,
-0.4184575975,
0.6552605033,
-0.4534178376,
0.5687971711,
-0.3933260739,
-0.9194380641,
-0.4364747405,
0.4054630399,
-0.4827786386,
0.3360413313,
0.6762972474,
0.5960960984,
0.1327594668,
-0.1596587151,
0.158671841,
0.6319409609,
0.7033972144,
0.4826025963,
0.8519355059,
-0.0815967098,
0.5191987753,
0.0525877513,
-0.5531690717,
0.143391192,
-1.18524611,
-0.8689392209,
-0.2173903435,
-0.6988312006,
-0.4229995906,
0.2115155011,
0.6929568052,
0.4524950385,
-0.7729317546,
-0.2484657168,
-0.2096543908,
0.3036535978,
-0.1909355372,
-0.2530418634,
0.5215550661,
-0.6015411019,
-0.958301127,
0.4088827372,
0.4228021502,
-0.1154651791,
-0.14660649,
-0.2025218159,
-0.2048412859,
0.1267915815,
0.6649193764,
-0.0212787427,
-0.7066049576,
-0.4366360605,
-0.2900002897,
0.2698570788,
-0.0256205257,
0.616666913,
-0.741093576,
0.6484695673,
0.6022622585,
1.0466396809,
0.2879438996,
0.0869167969,
0.5443866849,
-0.5216580629,
-0.1554019898,
0.203080982,
0.2589366436,
0.3004897833,
0.0352379084,
0.441624701,
0.3478720784,
-0.6852346659,
-1.1450920105,
0.3954550326,
-1.0825217962,
-0.3314197659,
1.4347434044,
-0.3456531763,
0.0404337086,
-0.0328152589,
-0.051276572,
0.209754318,
-0.18031165,
0.9789700508,
0.7993248105,
-0.272875458,
-0.3473389447,
-0.2806218266,
0.4870880544,
0.390163213,
-1.2012704611,
0.3466575742,
0.4032737315,
0.3943216205,
-0.0009293633,
0.2588032782,
-0.1555691957,
0.108415246,
-0.0300595555,
-0.2103998363,
-0.0142891472,
-0.0617432445,
-0.3006489277,
0.1856135875,
0.2378278524,
0.1268892884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17266v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17266v1
|
AG-LSEC: Audio Grounded Lexical Speaker Error Correction
| 2024-06-25T04:20:49 | 2024-06-25T04:20:49 |
Rohit Paturi, Xiang Li, Sundararajan Srinivasan
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Speaker Diarization (SD) systems are typically audio-based and operate
independently of the ASR system in traditional speech transcription pipelines
and can have speaker errors due to SD and/or ASR reconciliation, especially
around speaker turns and regions of speech overlap. To reduce these errors, a
Lexical Speaker Error Correction (LSEC), in which an external language model
provides lexical information to correct the speaker errors, was recently
proposed. Though the approach achieves good Word Diarization error rate (WDER)
improvements, it does not use any additional acoustic information and is prone
to miscorrections. In this paper, we propose to enhance and acoustically ground
the LSEC system with speaker scores directly derived from the existing SD
pipeline. This approach achieves significant relative WDER reductions in the
range of 25-40% over the audio-based SD, ASR system and beats the LSEC system
by 15-25% relative on RT03-CTS, Callhome American English and Fisher datasets.
|
[
-0.3565456867,
-0.5168460608,
0.5698301196,
-0.0680713728,
-0.0533476286,
0.3009509146,
-0.1978222281,
-0.2210719138,
0.7894973159,
0.2645777762,
-0.3435828388,
-0.5375872254,
-0.4667936265,
0.1157077551,
-0.3682108521,
0.3729276657,
0.3297285438,
0.1775670648,
0.1045777127,
-0.1023865566,
-0.5152173638,
-0.4010654092,
-0.660369575,
-0.1363942623,
0.0577974916,
0.5136497617,
0.7306867838,
0.5153805614,
0.5108229518,
0.3568748534,
-0.6494018435,
0.3038846254,
-0.2561460435,
0.0047246846,
-0.3246320188,
-0.0654693469,
-0.9062337875,
-0.1661768407,
0.8376218677,
0.9291625023,
-0.5554080009,
-0.3538394272,
0.0616437458,
0.6787205935,
-0.6973227859,
-0.0370232947,
-0.7010845542,
-0.1232440546,
-0.0382731631,
-0.4143093526,
-0.6460062861,
-0.2064101994,
-0.4264573753,
-0.1821293533,
0.446878463,
-0.3127658963,
0.6738898158,
0.4057508707,
-0.1180512384,
-0.154501006,
-0.944778502,
0.4044944346,
-0.9009866118,
0.8586550355,
0.6351435184,
0.2035586536,
0.0089308629,
-0.3345033824,
-0.1864776164,
-0.1980535537,
0.0696141869,
0.3620912135,
0.1254024208,
0.3383159935,
0.3491176367,
0.4040867686,
-0.0676565617,
0.1480804384,
-0.7241635919,
-0.4125060737,
0.5884075165,
-0.0491043106,
0.0619760379,
0.0236882828,
-0.0651550964,
-0.238176167,
-0.8243281245,
0.1716759205,
0.4105291367,
0.8235394359,
0.002073386,
0.6971800327,
-0.063624315,
0.5878256559,
0.2332140058,
-0.1064134985,
0.4703990221,
-0.2358671427,
-0.0226482004,
0.8976812363,
0.3991753161,
0.6601432562,
0.065178588,
-0.0051663038,
-0.5062663555,
0.5775694251,
0.347322315,
-0.4969570935,
-0.1436984241,
0.1129728705,
-0.1023510769,
0.1336952895,
0.2905110717,
-0.5788047314,
-0.5092745423,
-0.5660547018,
0.2802112699,
-0.4220100343,
-0.0056422367,
0.0862948895,
-0.1894374192,
0.0463367328,
0.4736080468,
-0.6085019112,
0.6730772853,
0.3604842424,
0.9162080884,
0.0690736026,
-0.0214203596,
-0.935366869,
0.3803854287,
-0.5746409297,
0.6922587156,
-0.3602047265,
-0.6619819999,
-0.1772392541,
-0.0307153147,
-0.0730848014,
-0.4776493013,
0.8789032698,
-0.3213663995,
-0.0369278193,
-0.4378054142,
-0.7746537328,
0.3695479929,
-0.2108760625,
-0.4585642815,
0.8359083533,
-0.0631573722,
-0.8270326257,
0.0433895551,
-0.3192010522,
-0.2888551056,
0.0758269578,
-0.2021122873,
-0.0021924567,
0.0243527256,
0.4987154007,
0.3945380449,
0.1987240613,
0.2077772468,
0.0321983434,
-0.9091778398,
-0.2463396192,
-0.1244308501,
0.270634979,
0.2049373388,
-0.527718842,
0.0031479585,
-1.2360272408,
0.0167358406,
-0.1560562253,
-0.295645684,
-0.6797745228,
0.2873707116,
-0.3013814986,
-0.2404050976,
-0.2271548659,
-0.719457984,
-0.386988163,
-0.639944315,
0.4324528575,
0.9276803136,
-0.1935897619,
0.4701714218,
0.0874002874,
0.0713198781,
-0.0420965068,
-0.5457750559,
-0.4652326703,
-0.2440559268,
-0.7787437439,
-0.382705003,
0.3931867182,
0.8447525501,
-0.5940644145,
0.9418392181,
-0.5006200671,
-0.5890917182,
-0.7720145583,
-0.2661634684,
0.3709939122,
0.682308197,
0.5482292175,
-0.4874923229,
-0.6465341449,
-0.7048210502,
-0.0762326643,
-0.3386077583,
-0.1180890352,
0.3929472566,
-0.288790822,
-0.3413798213,
1.0710728168,
-0.3058107197,
-0.480584234,
-0.0299649909,
-0.288300097,
0.5436362028,
0.3617460728,
0.2038994581,
-0.3597678244,
-0.2761279941,
0.079255186,
-0.2724014223,
-0.5740087032,
-0.0141099822,
0.4202368259,
-0.0367859975,
0.9549341202,
-0.6311663389,
0.605773747,
0.429682076,
-0.4945299923,
0.5580523014,
-0.2378385067,
0.3682830036,
-0.7647006512,
-0.2628884614,
-0.0857037604,
-0.3473809063,
-0.7135428786,
-0.0656349063,
0.1467635483,
-0.1705384701,
-0.4426954687,
0.2257080823,
-0.1922044605,
-0.2352116853,
-0.1111967266,
0.4395448864,
0.024119243,
0.1147256419,
-0.0055894651,
1.2716064453,
0.4134988189,
-0.7714204788,
0.4974567294,
0.552974999,
-0.2506180704,
0.666575253,
-0.8572995067,
0.2587403655,
-0.3314044178,
0.3770350516,
-1.0756816864,
0.0488294549,
-0.0327569954,
-0.5281612873,
0.3519190252,
0.1320367903,
0.0131243942,
-0.1358112693,
-0.223874703,
0.1876879036,
0.3787456453,
-0.6602945924,
0.4573194683,
0.2653283477,
-0.4736256897,
-0.2699661255,
-0.6792802215,
0.2694519758,
0.0056768055,
-0.5209254026,
0.3994889855,
0.0331167616,
-0.552331686,
-0.1366219223,
-0.2145673484,
0.4691724181,
-0.3405940831,
0.0990392864,
-0.0193683058,
-0.3694291115,
0.1779059917,
-0.1356426775,
-0.2967036963,
-0.1657136232,
0.1664791703,
0.4799019396,
-0.2500268817,
-0.7568181753,
-0.5526766777,
0.397110194,
0.4208137393,
0.039354004,
0.6977704763,
0.1300171465,
-0.2979258299,
0.1958686113,
-0.7732076049,
-0.1527090967,
-0.5011187792,
0.313747704,
-0.5598549843,
-0.8205661178,
0.5592957139,
0.0254700556,
-0.1371283382,
0.5958915353,
0.3079659939,
-0.1923504919,
0.8222801089,
0.040545743,
-0.1527929306,
0.030248668,
0.2050397396,
0.4156732559,
-0.768725276,
-0.0293901395,
-0.7426896691,
-0.088441208,
-0.4559469819,
-0.4294664264,
0.2184445709,
-0.0401021093,
-0.3877088726,
0.5979146361,
-0.2900466919,
0.4927579761,
0.4996445775,
0.1372614652,
0.1115509942,
0.0145920487,
-0.4795160592,
-0.4295183718,
-0.228840977,
-0.3635115027,
0.4990259111,
0.8072370291,
0.8884105086,
0.0512574762,
0.7718755603,
0.6405075192,
-0.5189989805,
-0.6130021214,
0.6262063384,
-0.3373860717,
0.0093068909,
-0.4538038373,
-0.5312767625,
-0.217277199,
0.2565449476,
0.1602762491,
-0.7222006321,
0.4865877926,
0.0187923424,
-0.4341032207,
0.3962473571,
-0.8697295189,
0.0988053828,
-0.0321458988,
-0.1342645735,
-0.0880817845,
-0.6866124272,
-0.1320356131,
0.0485231951,
0.6522960663,
0.0162715055,
0.1706158519,
0.7357371449,
-0.5238082409,
0.7535069585,
-0.6415881515,
-0.4875958562,
0.2135624141,
0.0209334586,
1.0035681725,
-0.2375779152,
-0.2840468884,
0.1102296934,
-0.2394842207,
0.1068849042,
-0.3541389406,
0.5287314653,
-0.8998782039,
-0.5939262509,
-0.1621621996,
-0.0871844143,
-0.7407628298,
-0.1938648075,
0.1299097687,
0.4536726773,
-0.3064382672,
0.4634359479,
0.6963840127,
-0.0520751402,
0.1733101755,
0.2690163851,
0.1245939657,
-0.9129657745,
0.6259297729,
-0.1323349923,
0.3254686892,
0.1234571487,
0.0035644886,
-0.339271158,
-0.511182189,
-0.2037137896,
0.1822784543,
-1.0186923742,
-0.2614686787,
-0.7024662495,
-0.6162332892,
-0.8137021065,
-0.3202709556,
-0.8325634599,
-0.5549863577,
-0.3611588478,
-0.5967063904,
0.2822530866,
0.15576078,
-0.2315767556,
0.9726683497,
-1.0846130848,
0.5623194575,
0.0789808631,
0.5045983195,
-0.4941385686,
-1.0553270578,
-0.1405349821,
0.3340176642,
0.0423723981,
-0.7611451149,
0.2655697763,
0.7427486777,
0.4192483127,
0.5432162285,
-0.0986737758,
1.3799519539,
-1.1201716661,
0.9520562291,
0.5329287648,
-1.2995800972,
0.7792019248,
-0.2654604912,
0.0868396163,
0.6211419106,
-0.2505077124,
-0.7768579125,
-0.44852072,
-0.7110320926,
-1.0634713173,
0.8302645683,
0.4705821872,
0.0331709385,
-0.1071965024,
0.1950336397,
-0.1716554165,
-0.0677262098,
-0.3257649541,
-0.04977924,
-0.3718413711,
0.0692879111,
-0.5533536673,
-0.4884797633,
-0.2084472328,
-0.3938067257,
1.1682515144,
-0.108410731,
0.1780585498,
0.4371628463,
0.0752846524,
-0.3640912771,
0.5192545056,
0.6198601723,
0.3822092116,
-0.4863905609,
0.3692418337,
0.4752423167,
-0.614646554,
0.3689517975,
-0.2053189427,
-0.0471066907,
0.2547267079,
0.3163114488,
1.1480036974,
0.2505002618,
-0.6640605927,
0.4043414295,
0.1268061996,
-0.1521615535,
-0.4134356081,
0.0093232729,
0.1624105871,
0.1456683725,
0.352812022,
0.1680836678,
0.0207633879,
-0.1451748312,
0.5197324157,
0.2164036781,
-0.5727504492,
-0.1803488135,
0.5075221062,
0.3780748844,
-0.365329653,
0.6166792512,
-0.0626384839,
-0.4159405529,
0.419403553,
0.6861581802,
0.7386505008,
-0.9923460484,
-0.0162199587,
0.514998734,
0.604857862,
-0.1130125746,
0.1784879267,
0.0003207535,
-0.9274784327,
-0.442149967,
-0.6162548661,
-0.5183097124,
-0.0424252376,
-0.6976013184,
0.6264686584,
-0.4019073844,
-0.2425151467,
-0.3200079799,
-0.3678447902,
-0.1033607349,
0.4684863985,
0.4894647896,
0.9883161783,
-1.2520310879,
0.517079711,
0.7071959376,
0.2988247275,
-0.8462888598,
-0.2892875075,
-0.0783060715,
-0.5566238165,
0.3900518119,
0.1140281707,
-0.4079907537,
-0.1046093553,
-0.1770705879,
-0.8721837997,
0.8688982725,
0.2975000441,
-0.9632138014,
0.0347184204,
0.414039284,
0.6070088744,
-0.2832160592,
0.4231820405,
0.8326532245,
0.4132042527,
0.6498050094,
-1.2217553854,
-0.3457342386,
-0.3059689105,
0.1055054367,
0.1743163019,
-0.148499012,
0.634521544,
-0.07782498,
-0.2088601738,
-0.1951457858,
0.8450273275,
0.478194952,
0.2650980651,
0.8154680133,
0.9175797701,
0.7400524616,
-0.1295598,
0.3385306895,
-0.0315049402,
0.2842945755,
1.1927634478,
-0.7500737906,
0.7785318494,
0.7819221616,
-0.5548229814,
0.1897469014,
0.5229154825,
0.1741517484,
0.7717719078,
0.0719371513,
-0.057840094,
-0.2563533187,
-0.1627965271,
-0.7023274302,
0.7403082848,
0.7034620643,
-0.1413327605,
-0.2652947009,
-0.0166895129,
-0.3509652317,
0.3230901062,
-0.556879878,
0.7198818922,
0.1132765859,
-0.1482071579,
0.6950871944,
0.1032906771,
0.5621960163,
-0.5951231122,
-0.0034851355,
-0.2403660119,
0.5450718403,
-0.370762527,
-0.3705627918,
0.5492973328,
0.0390360095,
-0.0041150358,
-0.2946857512,
0.908203125,
-0.3875867724,
-0.4347142875,
0.4723789692,
0.3386960924,
0.1041476578,
0.0412471183,
-0.0953475609,
0.2562199533,
0.020886533,
0.0875584036,
-0.0422267392,
0.1805749387,
0.0504251197,
0.3479087353,
0.6328991652,
0.6415798068,
0.0713893026,
0.457321316,
0.8032720685,
-0.8471074104,
-0.996737659,
-0.6655332446,
0.4547008574,
-0.1108047217,
0.3800053596,
0.5130596161,
0.471080482,
0.4783980548,
-0.119603917,
0.4607275426,
-0.0457411781,
1.1949239969,
-0.6350407004,
0.5645517707,
-0.359379679,
0.6840410233,
-0.6520765424,
-1.2507845163,
-0.1386422664,
0.7006589174,
0.2278370857,
-0.0992487073,
0.7184484601,
0.9016054273,
-0.1779444814,
0.3300489783,
0.5420954823,
0.251249671,
0.4121761024,
0.058304891,
0.8221169114,
-0.5968547463,
-0.0751689598,
-0.2496713698,
-0.3529247344,
-0.0006294948,
-0.7579234242,
-0.4263899624,
-0.4713534117,
-0.5146674514,
-0.4783544242,
0.3805605769,
0.9943885803,
0.0706360191,
-1.2960063219,
-0.2938103676,
0.0160670988,
-0.3287820518,
-0.274212271,
-0.2201326936,
0.5048965216,
-0.2475090325,
-0.447254777,
1.1575444937,
0.2683199644,
-0.1150267571,
0.2462290823,
-0.3177416921,
0.0009825865,
0.1731196046,
0.4962072074,
0.0289139561,
-0.7230215073,
-0.8134431839,
-0.0114194304,
-0.0442198105,
0.1831377894,
0.708229959,
-0.8994500041,
0.290586561,
0.2454743385,
0.6307453513,
-0.0527315363,
0.2686098516,
0.2813260257,
-1.1294533014,
0.3672372103,
0.3394007683,
0.6080379486,
0.5073235631,
-0.3506161273,
0.63197577,
0.5036537051,
-0.4100509286,
-0.9035462737,
-0.1569705009,
-0.9696248174,
0.1955482662,
1.4857490063,
0.0423986465,
0.1536924839,
-0.0494861193,
-0.365110755,
0.1780617982,
-0.4112241864,
0.4849365652,
0.7614016533,
0.3003607094,
-0.1589067876,
-0.1785158217,
0.2323316932,
0.4176079035,
-0.4812402427,
0.1852007508,
0.6586741805,
-0.0665362701,
0.5387784839,
0.7780083418,
-0.1098470762,
0.1802946776,
-0.1123489663,
0.2151302248,
0.1447938234,
-0.4848706126,
-0.4060063958,
-0.0553117208,
-0.1248304546,
-0.2967704237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17262v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17262v1
|
D2LLM: Decomposed and Distilled Large Language Models for Semantic Search
| 2024-06-25T04:03:04 | 2024-06-25T04:03:04 |
Zihan Liao, Hang Yu, Jianguo Li, Jun Wang, Wei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The key challenge in semantic search is to create models that are both
accurate and efficient in pinpointing relevant sentences for queries. While
BERT-style bi-encoders excel in efficiency with pre-computed embeddings, they
often miss subtle nuances in search tasks. Conversely, GPT-style LLMs with
cross-encoder designs capture these nuances but are computationally intensive,
hindering real-time applications. In this paper, we present D2LLMs-Decomposed
and Distilled LLMs for semantic search-that combines the best of both worlds.
We decompose a cross-encoder into an efficient bi-encoder integrated with
Pooling by Multihead Attention and an Interaction Emulation Module, achieving
nuanced understanding and pre-computability. Knowledge from the LLM is
distilled into this model using contrastive, rank, and feature imitation
techniques. Our experiments show that D2LLM surpasses five leading baselines in
terms of all metrics across three tasks, particularly improving NLI task
performance by at least 6.45%. The source code is available at
https://github.com/codefuse-ai/D2LLM.
|
[
-0.2273409516,
-0.7636749148,
0.7633332014,
0.2621820569,
-0.2339496911,
0.1632942408,
-0.2019969523,
-0.3494951427,
-0.0868672505,
0.3902698755,
-0.5730063915,
-0.4073038697,
-0.7703465223,
0.0428736992,
-0.419242084,
0.4712367356,
-0.0386493988,
0.0725800395,
-0.406283766,
0.1648834348,
-0.4940611124,
-0.2595048845,
-0.3937274516,
-0.5254853964,
0.6863880157,
0.0707633495,
0.7348682284,
0.5565353632,
0.4492541254,
0.2977195382,
-0.3626609445,
0.3794732988,
-0.8294048309,
0.3257168829,
-0.3681657016,
-0.5433339477,
-0.3106227815,
0.1878162622,
0.4266428351,
0.7070766687,
-0.049533464,
0.03830171,
0.1878597736,
0.7227169275,
-0.4825775623,
0.5741487145,
-0.8845972419,
-0.0092453538,
0.0155899143,
-0.1502326727,
-0.3418844342,
-0.036069084,
0.2053727359,
-0.5053464174,
0.0360174589,
0.0167365726,
0.4887754321,
0.6123210788,
-0.2553320527,
-0.4377064705,
-0.5860443711,
0.911264658,
-0.5352649689,
0.5644401908,
0.2458987087,
0.1282910556,
-0.4433889091,
-0.7384550571,
-0.5621307492,
0.1238924488,
-0.2450625896,
0.146299392,
-0.2351341844,
0.0304567926,
0.0301638413,
0.4473899901,
-0.783090651,
0.3788049221,
-0.1639143378,
0.1913627088,
0.543443501,
0.1534394324,
0.2714406848,
0.1871079355,
-0.4351709187,
-0.0808684826,
-0.6014873385,
-0.3254358172,
0.1403643489,
0.0541255698,
0.1807246059,
0.6684037447,
-0.2199936211,
0.731505394,
-0.0245871563,
-0.0809423178,
0.0074574561,
-0.5184245706,
0.0344498605,
-0.0024986786,
0.3315389454,
0.3473590612,
0.1165790111,
-0.5407009721,
-0.276904732,
0.0671446696,
0.165450424,
-0.9048154354,
-0.3363128901,
0.4100798965,
-0.4500636458,
-0.1934192479,
-0.1502084881,
-0.5866136551,
-0.1706404686,
-0.4272109866,
0.3450153172,
-0.2944642901,
-0.2026366144,
0.4097086787,
-0.3062962592,
0.4253434837,
0.2368418872,
-0.6446023583,
0.2838557661,
0.7742831707,
0.6874319911,
-0.1770148277,
-0.1988917142,
-0.5673963428,
0.1199101433,
-0.168880105,
0.5059937239,
-0.5386057496,
-0.274207294,
-0.0968570188,
-0.2120964229,
0.0342991017,
-0.6553157568,
0.2008634061,
-1.0211882591,
0.0717919171,
-0.1398172677,
-0.7696620822,
-0.361569494,
0.3158624172,
-0.8382343054,
1.1805461645,
0.199408561,
-0.6676044464,
0.2140203416,
-0.6273494363,
-0.3260033131,
0.17019324,
-0.041019883,
-0.2253739387,
0.2755972743,
0.1529464126,
0.4127438962,
-0.5804463029,
0.2848134935,
-0.3968158364,
-0.6455874443,
0.2433340102,
-0.1820638478,
0.7542430758,
0.067130208,
-0.360978514,
-0.3783262968,
-0.5140752792,
0.0227856226,
0.4495523572,
-0.5053465366,
-0.5060043335,
0.1615558565,
-0.0322217941,
0.312525481,
0.4234092832,
-0.5691143274,
-0.0358377993,
-0.5349650383,
0.5124710798,
0.3285580873,
-0.479773134,
0.499723345,
-0.0594735965,
-0.1033035666,
0.0991771221,
-0.0320422947,
0.1312994361,
-0.3224588335,
-0.6953861117,
-0.4096754789,
0.2559227049,
0.6186663508,
-0.60065341,
0.8551830053,
-0.4783345163,
-0.323623538,
-0.7691532373,
0.4601016939,
0.2328963876,
0.243583709,
0.5590251088,
0.0406538248,
-0.3596536517,
-0.7171398997,
-0.112755999,
-0.0497021861,
-0.2011321038,
0.279363066,
0.3156139851,
-0.6980594397,
1.0275752544,
-0.5929906368,
-0.4616264701,
-0.486338526,
0.0418182313,
0.0476086102,
0.1382631063,
0.3070038855,
-0.9899333715,
-0.3503113091,
-0.2571361959,
-0.7898478508,
-0.1539948881,
0.3053080738,
-0.1182883754,
0.0037440874,
0.3347156346,
-0.6472297311,
0.4058715105,
0.3972002268,
-0.04032401,
-0.0787985027,
-0.3571259379,
-0.2016139925,
-0.8149908185,
0.2086017728,
-0.2458036393,
-0.1525179893,
-0.4826880097,
0.1117840484,
0.0447968729,
-0.0354635492,
-0.4104937613,
0.5520483255,
-0.6579545736,
-0.2261788696,
-0.4948048294,
0.6743770838,
0.30289644,
0.4075939059,
0.221767813,
0.5033748746,
0.3643326759,
-0.6183609962,
0.7124670148,
0.3362703621,
-0.391399771,
0.0663355589,
-0.7500531673,
0.227448687,
-0.2699392438,
0.3485731184,
-0.9809163213,
0.0924355313,
-0.2237295061,
-0.1063359976,
0.4756874442,
-0.0418335907,
-0.8314878941,
-0.3026077449,
-0.5680871606,
0.5956447124,
0.618511796,
-0.8049488664,
0.4723453224,
0.4049545527,
-0.1205011457,
-0.4596292973,
-0.8295983672,
0.1316389292,
-0.0251409132,
-0.6677690744,
0.6361483335,
0.0077422531,
-0.2237758338,
0.1670648009,
-0.0470771752,
0.0004386392,
0.3851819932,
-0.1103610545,
0.2969973087,
0.1801968515,
0.0374498777,
-0.0574203916,
-0.2034006268,
-0.1078833044,
-0.3634293079,
0.7141506076,
0.2304293662,
-0.396430701,
-0.172925964,
0.5603321195,
0.455039382,
-0.3100132048,
0.4687419832,
0.7343122959,
-0.4243699312,
-0.2584277689,
-0.6528437138,
-0.3496213257,
-0.4351640344,
0.6923650503,
-0.3778180778,
-0.9790209532,
0.2211702317,
-0.352425158,
-0.0752613544,
0.2940674126,
0.6570514441,
-0.2007594258,
0.9646024704,
0.4888134301,
-0.0255861245,
0.1985280365,
-0.4165810049,
0.4383946359,
-0.8543163538,
-0.5278505087,
-0.2757698298,
-0.6725767851,
-0.6122666597,
-0.7611352801,
0.2348188013,
0.1672515273,
0.1095510423,
0.1973728985,
-0.5240995884,
0.49774912,
0.5096578598,
0.2337971032,
0.2305985391,
-0.0043620099,
0.0339469686,
-0.0300236717,
-0.7741329074,
-0.2340548486,
0.7633837461,
0.3250457048,
1.0541549921,
0.1385772526,
0.7324004769,
0.1022164002,
-0.2816156447,
-0.9465846419,
0.5017586946,
-0.4163791239,
-0.5746977329,
-0.3577465117,
-0.4179551005,
-0.9173919559,
0.3236554861,
0.0413225703,
-0.4219353497,
0.0767361596,
-0.1701136827,
-0.0855008811,
0.1721688658,
-0.3157259524,
0.7804598212,
-0.4806856811,
-0.4528593123,
-0.4405095875,
-0.656575799,
0.2873186171,
-0.0538355149,
0.0581941865,
-0.4071168005,
-0.258266449,
0.4103170335,
-0.1622944027,
0.6500947475,
-0.1764483005,
-0.0924345478,
0.1809585541,
0.1461620182,
0.6404132247,
0.1762043536,
-0.0140460012,
0.2807427943,
-0.1851756126,
-0.415220499,
-0.6163744926,
1.009755373,
-0.5671995282,
-0.5725304484,
-0.2366881967,
-0.5284434557,
0.0382249057,
0.072037071,
-0.04619167,
0.3135314286,
-0.1684408337,
0.265326798,
0.9950852394,
-0.2142034918,
0.3835493326,
0.462890327,
-0.1091109142,
-0.0457719341,
0.7148526907,
-0.0686506033,
0.0253251232,
0.8452788591,
0.04680923,
-0.7644942999,
-0.6004644036,
-0.3641727269,
0.1819657385,
-0.5846845508,
-0.2123167366,
-0.8107152581,
-0.2199147195,
-0.3155123591,
0.0441499464,
-0.4837313592,
-0.164058581,
-0.3775427341,
-0.0276315324,
0.372035712,
0.5917514563,
0.0020339049,
-0.1739790291,
-0.7902810574,
0.4157586694,
0.470309943,
0.3997536302,
-0.1959824711,
-0.3063057363,
-0.3128351867,
0.220988974,
0.0743418559,
-0.4799923599,
0.303951025,
0.1567816138,
0.7077540755,
-0.2137299329,
0.1409642398,
0.6533697248,
-0.3560824692,
0.6076228023,
-0.0110269263,
-0.7340956926,
0.453956455,
0.2300143093,
0.2798770368,
0.5405181646,
0.388840884,
-0.2776418626,
-0.1286352128,
-0.0087482547,
-0.9784715176,
0.8054349422,
0.2198366821,
-0.0998267308,
-0.0211488195,
0.3452262282,
0.0754445195,
-0.0432055257,
-0.2952880859,
-0.1798453331,
-0.0922527313,
-0.5185619593,
-0.0304759797,
-0.6424508691,
0.0213251114,
-0.1265795529,
0.4690996706,
0.0723459497,
0.1651129425,
0.2313086689,
-0.6387918591,
0.5306347013,
0.0013048662,
0.1637198627,
0.3696791232,
-0.2385053188,
0.5141204596,
0.1376814395,
-0.3340345621,
0.1013975441,
0.3564173877,
0.0962803587,
0.1059033871,
0.243203178,
0.6790756583,
0.4192590714,
-0.760459125,
0.4141135812,
-0.1125139594,
-0.0408929102,
-0.1781667918,
-0.123391293,
0.4018210769,
0.3510839641,
0.2778834105,
-0.5800174475,
0.581864059,
-0.5442544818,
0.1831641197,
0.3994012773,
-0.15464136,
-0.2367835045,
0.5962685347,
0.3590600193,
0.075767003,
0.8263697624,
-0.1349475086,
-0.4730842113,
0.2187600881,
0.3694758415,
0.9504452944,
0.0364077315,
-0.1507854164,
0.0259776674,
0.1762176156,
-0.0991370529,
0.1966437399,
-0.1729222089,
-0.6470110416,
-0.4378796518,
-0.7606312037,
-0.1789194494,
0.0139754005,
-0.4463338554,
0.2268438488,
0.0835534558,
0.037106432,
-0.0235689562,
0.1665849537,
-0.8911899328,
0.0247223023,
0.2700723708,
0.764993012,
-0.2833196819,
0.8547847867,
0.6388853788,
-0.1864174902,
-0.3731279373,
-0.2642176449,
-0.1524720192,
-0.8464206457,
0.8079959154,
0.1886279136,
-0.2022143155,
0.12073531,
-0.1124566272,
-0.811502099,
1.3889033794,
0.3705256879,
-0.6662599444,
-0.2402444929,
0.4352996349,
0.3072896898,
-0.2927272022,
0.3579372168,
0.7069283724,
0.4615009129,
0.1397604495,
-0.830073595,
0.0235438589,
-0.0159033202,
0.4471726418,
0.0482037254,
-0.514949739,
0.6527665257,
-0.0689801574,
-0.1609532088,
-0.1292793155,
0.1826037616,
0.2070780993,
0.2261037678,
0.3336487114,
0.6788346767,
0.472640872,
-0.1768997014,
0.8295619488,
-0.4635748267,
0.3884396851,
1.0079852343,
-0.6895449162,
0.7852043509,
0.4440120459,
-0.107425347,
0.1747169495,
0.5689467788,
0.1408261359,
0.8171655536,
0.3528468311,
-0.2612657845,
-0.3203727603,
0.1024347395,
-0.0986026227,
0.7979114652,
0.3088957667,
-0.2873081565,
-0.5465980172,
-0.1031787097,
-0.1582986265,
0.2091387063,
-0.0330269895,
1.2276742458,
0.1449949592,
-0.2884519398,
0.5812246203,
0.096306324,
0.7819203734,
-0.3938244283,
-0.1133369878,
-0.3802368343,
0.4749319553,
-0.0867616683,
-0.8576883078,
0.3445266485,
-0.1298641413,
-0.4095202386,
-0.2572455704,
0.9066181779,
-0.8583303094,
-0.4000439048,
0.9240599871,
0.5151126981,
0.2567626238,
-0.225593701,
-0.7002900243,
0.3623297215,
-0.1571430862,
-0.2641735971,
0.4853403866,
0.5008929968,
0.2265185565,
0.4944318235,
0.4362829924,
-0.2031526566,
0.1052768603,
-0.0306882337,
0.998506844,
-0.6897713542,
-0.0458284616,
-1.024490118,
0.3103615046,
-0.1490311772,
0.3612179756,
0.4892499745,
0.8413021564,
0.8656759858,
0.0004352988,
0.7095496058,
0.1374944597,
0.4166819155,
-0.5652770996,
0.7445117831,
-0.5932809114,
0.2544766665,
0.3123896122,
-1.0315324068,
-0.1894457638,
0.4697880447,
0.1077677086,
0.0209373645,
0.3112260699,
0.8823812604,
-0.1406181157,
-0.272762686,
0.4072761536,
0.0884502903,
0.269385457,
0.7425554991,
0.7108467221,
-0.4551873207,
0.5120270252,
-0.1887956709,
-0.2912774086,
-0.5125491619,
-0.5965251327,
-0.838719666,
-0.3250184953,
-0.3777404726,
0.0756318718,
0.0477898791,
0.6946754456,
0.5735374093,
-0.3838271201,
-0.0657062382,
-0.0247325823,
0.2149068415,
-0.0133051882,
-0.1741508543,
0.2470407933,
-0.5430850983,
-0.9590342641,
0.6439670324,
0.5313431621,
-0.0873891413,
-0.4286976159,
-0.139260754,
-0.2736871839,
0.1028713137,
0.9296757579,
-0.4152668118,
-0.7948543429,
-0.0954279602,
0.1419673115,
-0.2953048348,
-0.2366054952,
0.5604711771,
-0.77794379,
0.5083198547,
0.6116401553,
0.8366440535,
0.8841038942,
-0.1595086008,
0.4216032624,
-0.6262244582,
0.1755682677,
0.3302051425,
0.3368385732,
0.2478510886,
-0.344121784,
0.6336727142,
0.1966999918,
-0.3398982882,
-0.7036980987,
0.1788974702,
-1.0712531805,
-0.4923781157,
1.2565256357,
-0.1935970187,
-0.2216215581,
-0.146727249,
-0.0793940946,
0.3019758165,
-0.1092219278,
0.6667644382,
0.4933456182,
0.0222486071,
0.0294070933,
-0.3247242868,
0.2830505371,
0.2397220731,
-0.3709032834,
0.1768573225,
0.4006210864,
0.3329780996,
-0.0014379888,
0.11774005,
-0.4447215199,
0.036818482,
0.1455907971,
0.1097019091,
-0.3337568045,
-0.1218559295,
-0.140928179,
0.0103497067,
0.0572164357,
-0.2870932221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17261v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17261v1
|
TRAWL: Tensor Reduced and Approximated Weights for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-25T04:01:32 | 2024-06-25T04:01:32 |
Yiran Luo, Het Patel, Yu Fu, Dawon Ahn, Jia Chen, Yue Dong, Evangelos E. Papalexakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50 (Primary), 65F55 (Secondary), I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) have fundamentally transformed artificial
intelligence, catalyzing recent advancements while imposing substantial
environmental and computational burdens. We introduce TRAWL (Tensor Reduced and
Approximated Weights for Large Language Models), a novel methodology for
optimizing LLMs through tensor decomposition. TRAWL leverages diverse
strategies to exploit matrices within transformer-based architectures,
realizing notable performance enhancements without necessitating retraining.
The most significant improvements were observed through a layer-by-layer
intervention strategy, particularly when applied to fully connected weights of
the final layers, yielding up to 16% enhancement in accuracy without the need
for additional data or fine-tuning. These results underscore the importance of
targeted and adaptive techniques in increasing the efficiency and effectiveness
of large language model optimization, thereby promoting the development of more
sustainable and accessible AI systems.
|
[
-0.2626253068,
-0.8164444566,
0.2836337984,
0.1619605422,
-0.1943874955,
0.635270834,
-0.4317685664,
-0.2073689103,
0.133244127,
0.3170195222,
-0.5958554149,
-0.4543528557,
-0.5606148243,
-0.2041541189,
-0.5287823081,
0.5970228314,
0.0711847991,
0.0337359235,
-0.012049078,
-0.3192902803,
-0.3599680066,
-0.3563100398,
-0.8768713474,
-0.5172610879,
0.5277249813,
0.0578365624,
0.7902462482,
0.910721004,
0.7162442803,
0.4086548388,
-0.144324109,
0.2730820179,
-0.7459519506,
0.1494389623,
0.0381631441,
-0.7435824871,
-0.5372676849,
-0.0481322929,
0.8734843731,
0.921374023,
-0.1856461912,
0.5602926016,
0.0879244953,
0.8089700937,
-0.8746940494,
0.2458181679,
-0.3177678585,
0.2901150882,
-0.1880051196,
-0.349109441,
-0.6838049889,
-0.3099879622,
0.1263208538,
-0.4919750392,
0.0990806744,
-0.0644846931,
0.3039341271,
0.4720412493,
-0.3090578914,
0.0130803557,
-0.9998673797,
1.1828600168,
-0.8333023787,
0.5726856589,
-0.1544041187,
0.1939743459,
-0.2128689885,
-1.0962673426,
-0.3166922629,
-0.2599852085,
0.0234834775,
-0.0097207259,
-0.5668293238,
0.3067016304,
0.1890723854,
0.0313867629,
-0.5267157555,
0.0678746551,
-0.3929599822,
-0.0046544839,
0.7027803063,
0.1648013741,
0.3740305901,
0.3069972694,
-0.0156657286,
-0.4493387043,
-0.6987394094,
-0.0649011135,
0.1387037337,
0.1747293919,
-0.0499582328,
0.5424751639,
0.2558889985,
0.4783539176,
-0.2401582003,
-0.2181188613,
0.1850017905,
0.2716086805,
-0.3510668576,
0.0481911041,
0.5090450048,
0.3305548728,
0.2918477654,
-0.2150763422,
-0.3055225909,
0.246174261,
0.3410464525,
-0.5779423714,
-0.219768241,
0.2389555275,
-0.5412489772,
-0.5183736682,
-0.3641269207,
-0.6478087306,
-0.2639654875,
-0.2111693472,
0.3976850808,
-0.2403419316,
-0.2318131626,
0.026960751,
-0.1670178622,
0.3830441535,
0.2303511351,
-0.446916163,
0.3503345251,
0.8433537483,
1.1013371944,
-0.201853022,
-0.1811394542,
-0.6259843707,
0.4431495965,
-0.6273685694,
0.3937777877,
-0.6833443046,
-0.2906403244,
-0.0688064098,
-0.4910677075,
-0.1058977321,
-0.504311204,
0.4472088516,
-0.6909598708,
0.169425264,
0.2656854987,
-0.3585980833,
-0.3352084458,
0.2077745348,
-0.9957577586,
1.081638217,
0.3539758921,
-0.5015217662,
-0.1655852199,
-1.201746583,
-0.6801165342,
0.008417123,
0.6276553273,
-0.5133220553,
0.4765919745,
0.2679585814,
0.4214531481,
-0.4896473885,
0.2294109911,
-0.391880244,
-0.4828672707,
0.0212333873,
-0.286360234,
0.6546790004,
0.3457810581,
-0.4000432193,
0.2975028455,
-0.644533813,
0.2789675593,
0.1974379122,
-0.4708040655,
-0.4078402817,
0.2671777904,
0.0295244828,
-0.0407058857,
0.1210362464,
-0.2306078076,
0.1205403581,
-0.5934031606,
1.0432521105,
0.8645185828,
-0.3843311369,
0.573538959,
-0.2653572559,
0.7023798823,
-0.160782665,
0.0581354648,
0.2533131242,
0.0895939171,
-0.9241437316,
-0.3880896866,
0.2541196644,
0.3098075688,
-0.8365868926,
0.1223909706,
-0.7589843869,
-0.6011449099,
-0.7615973353,
-0.0196566749,
0.3923069239,
0.3145952523,
0.4229900837,
-0.044500079,
-0.8519310951,
-0.8085422516,
-0.444879353,
-0.3133467138,
-0.143072933,
-0.0079190815,
0.2528462708,
-0.1804628223,
0.672630012,
-0.5081510544,
-0.1343046129,
-0.5487468839,
0.1807209402,
0.0587011948,
0.4291927814,
0.5527046323,
-0.6810721159,
-0.3295515478,
-0.0482770726,
-0.6810731292,
0.0022027707,
-0.014146571,
-0.0427043997,
0.1807831675,
0.5813536048,
-0.8444136977,
0.247079581,
0.5931738615,
0.0824731514,
0.3029949665,
-0.222959131,
-0.3095876575,
-0.8454729319,
0.0717411116,
0.0233713109,
-0.4241527319,
-0.9545516372,
0.5968950987,
-0.0601876304,
-0.084824197,
-0.433155179,
0.4179422557,
-0.5299907923,
-0.1830214858,
-0.1299879402,
-0.0295128319,
-0.12394315,
0.5559548736,
-0.1212975234,
0.9776028991,
0.4077152014,
-0.4468453228,
0.4522697031,
0.0688194931,
-0.2082253546,
0.3713047504,
-0.7573081851,
0.3607081473,
-0.4151107371,
0.241290316,
-0.7909495234,
0.2057656199,
-0.0391192324,
-0.1353309304,
0.2870116234,
0.0074800453,
-0.1759451181,
-0.5504925251,
-0.8432117701,
0.5495108962,
0.5910635591,
-0.5254821181,
1.2316964865,
0.4909412265,
0.061829973,
-0.6441470385,
-0.8514614701,
0.3160355687,
-0.523271203,
-0.603363812,
0.3514720798,
-0.1949750334,
-0.4079560041,
-0.1180391014,
0.0323527083,
0.1945035905,
0.2759647965,
-0.1682067215,
0.0713850707,
-0.6125280261,
0.0240858905,
-0.1455068737,
-0.0530449115,
0.1279952824,
-0.676040709,
0.9983841777,
-0.2236814797,
-0.0247727837,
-0.2568311989,
0.2416342497,
0.8221997619,
-0.4432652593,
0.6928672194,
0.8368827701,
-0.2010496259,
-0.4835039675,
-0.4559774697,
0.1161082536,
-0.5679554343,
0.7805344462,
-0.3386514783,
-0.8615033627,
0.3989624679,
-0.1700162441,
0.178757593,
0.3407959342,
0.6659039259,
-0.1651304513,
1.33656919,
0.6537767053,
-0.4463770092,
0.5277051926,
-0.4908212721,
0.3906263709,
-0.9627430439,
-0.1226323396,
-0.3654251993,
-0.8437997103,
-0.6987172365,
-0.438539207,
0.4576580226,
-0.3430325985,
-0.4147646725,
0.2746291757,
-0.4962036014,
0.4459478259,
0.7421789169,
0.282538414,
0.0784583762,
-0.0444566794,
0.1065985262,
0.1531726867,
-0.7736371756,
-0.3047070205,
1.125638485,
0.4732320607,
0.6428150535,
0.2220643759,
0.4995163679,
0.7055151463,
0.2694174051,
-0.949429214,
0.7244613767,
-0.1459715813,
-0.1484598517,
-0.4047494233,
-0.6861255169,
-0.9686765075,
0.3251460791,
-0.0897221193,
-0.481785506,
-0.342661798,
-0.0589866452,
0.0433924533,
0.5629998446,
-0.8751586676,
0.3640131056,
-0.1405735463,
-0.2462646812,
-0.662705183,
-0.4677470028,
0.3089939356,
-0.1608408988,
0.1943500787,
0.0686741546,
-0.2847239077,
0.9176205397,
-0.5691110492,
0.5088129044,
-0.3695018291,
-0.0951801315,
-0.0306740608,
0.3259063065,
0.8374909163,
-0.2751686871,
-0.2232222706,
0.0223617461,
-0.1098877937,
-0.4849583805,
-0.7749005556,
0.5535943508,
-1.0426214933,
-0.7405138612,
-0.0318571962,
-1.0140866041,
-0.217466861,
0.2042640448,
-0.2880782783,
0.4879974723,
-0.1409495473,
0.3645685613,
0.5321497321,
-0.2244955003,
0.7803219557,
0.207776159,
0.1303235292,
-0.4593631625,
0.6789019108,
0.0369320847,
0.0651067421,
0.6030447483,
0.1529705524,
-0.3781421185,
-0.8564186692,
-0.0311719812,
0.2330970764,
-0.7108647227,
-0.2966753244,
-0.5014143586,
-0.2543636262,
-0.2352059484,
-0.2836822569,
-0.4447554052,
-0.5167732835,
-0.1598564088,
-0.1651335508,
0.1231461465,
0.724203229,
0.2158271819,
0.6571050286,
-0.656750083,
0.1904238313,
-0.0112378299,
0.3779585958,
0.3334908187,
-0.3819094896,
-0.2791538537,
0.2081532776,
0.0515867136,
-0.1830456853,
0.6775348783,
0.5485599637,
0.4508283436,
0.1386491209,
0.0586208999,
0.9596402049,
-0.524787128,
0.5551330447,
0.0552627109,
-1.1704170704,
0.246268943,
-0.115531221,
0.4512886107,
0.1790027618,
0.1373573244,
-0.4504148066,
-0.4700163603,
-0.4737004042,
-0.8423045278,
0.6018317342,
0.1807751507,
0.3378953636,
0.4374764264,
0.2365499437,
-0.401913017,
0.1379545331,
-0.6750237942,
-0.3146033883,
0.1197356805,
-0.5656015873,
-0.1073376983,
-0.3274644315,
-0.0061465665,
-0.3213447034,
0.7844728827,
-0.22437796,
0.2990453839,
-0.2421244979,
-0.6393119097,
-0.1606504321,
-0.0636742711,
0.8147109151,
0.7736654282,
-0.0029483908,
0.409319073,
0.4965691268,
-0.7512680888,
0.3049087226,
-0.3408245742,
-0.0986968204,
-0.2322740406,
0.7571864724,
0.6798551679,
0.2481955439,
-0.6284887791,
0.1608639061,
-0.1428093612,
-0.0479215756,
-0.2852014303,
0.132157132,
0.077338241,
0.6214364171,
0.5358887315,
0.0998454913,
-0.1316150725,
-0.1846757233,
0.2200731635,
0.6254361868,
-0.2453989685,
-0.4033770859,
0.640562892,
0.0041638613,
-0.4162019491,
0.6132072806,
0.3538615108,
-0.5983059406,
0.3229204118,
0.6441268921,
0.8897631168,
-0.4156520665,
0.1630318314,
0.121285893,
0.4554125071,
-0.0500296056,
-0.0596834682,
0.1175688803,
-0.7135843635,
-0.6225056052,
-0.6168236732,
-0.1828902662,
0.1002650186,
-0.435156703,
0.3194414675,
-0.836838305,
-0.1079826131,
0.0036582132,
0.2409425229,
-0.501305759,
0.0216288362,
0.2217897475,
0.8740418553,
-0.5971034765,
0.8720400333,
0.7152783871,
-0.1183127016,
-0.908139348,
-0.2602562904,
-0.1356498301,
-1.0112971067,
0.5725401044,
-0.0900112167,
-0.3613773584,
0.4896329343,
-0.5713559389,
-1.0586292744,
1.1412824392,
0.8495016098,
-0.2270649225,
-0.3198886812,
0.6723268628,
0.5293974876,
-0.3132883906,
0.5496169925,
0.8140383363,
0.5969356894,
0.1437094063,
-0.697432518,
-0.0475409143,
-0.3826828003,
0.4964720011,
0.4599368572,
-0.654407084,
0.7500698566,
-0.0332519934,
-0.1692965627,
-0.1766046584,
0.850148797,
0.0196569953,
-0.1178039461,
0.5476370454,
0.4678354859,
0.9069682956,
0.015362706,
0.8103806376,
-0.2969414294,
0.3983086348,
0.5594648719,
-0.3625745773,
0.8072405457,
0.5299232006,
-0.2938645482,
0.5035138726,
0.3228690028,
-0.0375418104,
0.4330002367,
0.1393105537,
-0.2091332674,
-0.1569003314,
-0.1635476053,
-0.0178543068,
0.7002396584,
0.2905825675,
-0.1407803446,
-0.3285883367,
0.1560565382,
0.1165877879,
-0.0539716817,
-0.5633648038,
0.6883348823,
0.0545723364,
-0.3655416369,
0.9010205865,
0.3263919652,
0.6794825792,
-0.4927468002,
0.0738426894,
-0.275085777,
0.4677083194,
-0.2120196968,
-0.5294032097,
0.3528060019,
-0.0573695973,
0.0853520408,
-0.2583680451,
0.8029990792,
-0.4526198208,
-0.6179065704,
0.4025184214,
0.3739666641,
-0.2131797522,
-0.0048488565,
-0.6066034436,
0.1107037887,
-0.0216228962,
-0.4513544142,
0.0685563609,
0.128155008,
-0.1940445006,
1.2600332499,
0.8070755601,
0.2614977658,
0.0843067989,
-0.1143406108,
1.0633950233,
-0.5865854621,
-0.3863185346,
-1.0546233654,
0.4249257147,
0.1189100444,
0.1782588214,
0.502024591,
0.6373653412,
0.8019931316,
-0.180184111,
0.6921741962,
0.0792075694,
0.2873776257,
-0.6006758809,
0.9024854302,
-0.5202693939,
0.4191019833,
-0.1892666519,
-1.1932924986,
-0.6855813861,
0.4377464652,
-0.2001731545,
0.0875018686,
0.6812803745,
0.8595452309,
-0.1838514656,
-0.0621462055,
0.4152517319,
0.3504029214,
0.5665776134,
0.650474906,
0.8600644469,
-0.3925586045,
0.5344302058,
-0.184820801,
0.0568576343,
-0.0700433105,
-0.8348213434,
-1.0354837179,
-0.4637283981,
-0.3234722614,
-0.077964969,
0.1744908541,
1.1998013258,
0.6865409613,
-0.8211692572,
-0.5471417904,
0.0412623212,
0.1258633882,
-0.2241437882,
-0.2113204151,
0.5147669911,
-0.2765825093,
-0.7056855559,
0.4942598045,
0.3094598055,
-0.337112397,
-0.3769563437,
-0.1941787153,
-0.1917074472,
0.0696216673,
0.9134934545,
-0.0674372837,
-0.4451369345,
-0.5356556773,
0.0594022945,
0.0259490814,
0.1964434981,
0.8071138263,
-0.9268244505,
0.0117478091,
0.4821031392,
0.7407742143,
0.6805083156,
-0.1154541597,
0.8827565908,
-0.8610733151,
0.3377587199,
0.4445700347,
0.2987160385,
0.2082720697,
-0.1218744814,
0.7170802951,
0.0872625038,
-0.0870080963,
-1.1236120462,
0.011357571,
-0.7463422418,
-0.1312877983,
0.8996919394,
-0.0771569014,
-0.6699390411,
0.1734663248,
0.1329616159,
0.3985218108,
-0.088289164,
0.7392256856,
0.3217433095,
0.3121412396,
-0.5970519185,
-0.3413801789,
0.2660381794,
0.5472735167,
-0.6528459787,
0.1502745152,
0.1744269133,
0.0790175572,
0.0150194271,
0.0649804845,
0.0793080702,
-0.0093228864,
-0.3815280199,
0.0885216072,
-0.244006753,
-0.246095255,
-0.2937532961,
0.369795382,
0.12598373,
0.1268765628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17260v1
|
Mitigating Hallucination in Fictional Character Role-Play
| 2024-06-25T03:56:33 | 2024-06-25T03:56:33 |
Nafis Sadeq, Zhouhang Xie, Byungkyu Kang, Prarit Lamba, Xiang Gao, Julian McAuley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Role-playing has wide-ranging applications in customer support, embodied
agents, computational social science, etc. The influence of parametric world
knowledge of large language models (LLMs) often causes role-playing characters
to act out of character and hallucinate about things outside the scope of their
knowledge. In this work, we focus on the evaluation and mitigation of
hallucination in fictional character role-play. We introduce a dataset with
more than 2,000 characters and 72,000 interviews, including 18,000 adversarial
questions. We propose RoleFact, a role-playing method that mitigates
hallucination by modulating the influence of parametric knowledge using a
pre-calibrated confidence threshold. Experiments show that the proposed method
improves the factual precision of generated responses by 18% for adversarial
questions with a 44% reduction in temporal hallucination for time-sensitive
interviews. The code and the dataset will be available at
https://github.com/NafisSadeq/rolefact.git.
|
[
-0.466630578,
-0.9775477052,
0.4490711689,
0.3240996599,
0.0949814469,
-0.0628015772,
-0.0956919268,
-0.4747749269,
0.5067769289,
0.8393573165,
-0.6359069943,
-0.341225028,
-0.2743469477,
0.0111357486,
-0.1393951625,
0.8570693731,
0.2269957811,
0.1357613206,
-0.4657302499,
0.0883951262,
-0.4477058351,
-0.7093302011,
-0.8057904243,
-0.2913811505,
0.5856332183,
0.1907660067,
0.937712729,
0.0987802222,
0.2975877523,
0.2237150818,
0.2830348313,
0.3915863335,
-0.8450881243,
0.586632669,
-0.0351515859,
-0.6809669733,
-0.3093311787,
0.0103373239,
0.5340173841,
0.4992322922,
-0.0549120978,
-0.0286053158,
0.0272464007,
0.2511250675,
-0.5945566297,
0.3904211223,
-0.4780953825,
0.2227229923,
0.0807763785,
-0.5460479259,
-0.4141578078,
-0.3249656558,
-0.1944334656,
-0.8219299316,
0.5236507058,
0.0164689962,
0.6280671954,
0.4830920398,
-0.1491092443,
-0.2307577878,
-0.8973293304,
0.5066881776,
-0.5735223889,
0.0912756845,
0.9159209728,
0.3751782775,
-0.154875651,
-0.0742468163,
-0.5829162598,
-0.4883805811,
-0.1940121502,
-0.0201506186,
0.2233812362,
0.0550300442,
0.7393541932,
0.0812407956,
-0.6559516788,
-0.1330964714,
-0.2506394684,
-0.3257322311,
0.5552316308,
0.1227392554,
0.263727963,
-0.1253579706,
-0.036898382,
-0.2250636667,
-0.6546022296,
-0.0294802655,
0.4668743908,
0.0281506516,
0.4524034858,
0.6544131041,
-0.0462404825,
0.1321750432,
0.1511705816,
0.1175914705,
-0.0668384582,
0.086098738,
-0.0769350156,
0.2875374556,
0.3519756496,
0.3561164439,
0.4448929131,
-0.3576516211,
-0.0451253727,
0.3837305605,
0.5890343785,
-0.7859403491,
-0.1239573285,
0.1545358002,
-0.1773620546,
-0.3574374616,
0.0689930841,
-0.8811212778,
-1.0927124023,
-0.0977293476,
0.7258309722,
-0.587685883,
-0.1099799275,
-0.0105175013,
-0.0949632674,
0.1828844696,
0.2561674714,
-0.6303243041,
0.3766396642,
0.5741933584,
0.6570258141,
-0.0057564359,
-0.393515408,
-0.9629442096,
0.1832463741,
-0.6077136993,
0.5666470528,
-0.4002268612,
-0.4519490898,
-0.18801561,
0.0838330239,
-0.1469410509,
-0.6631521583,
0.4110900164,
-0.4628126323,
-0.0339352116,
-0.4680614769,
-0.3096962571,
-0.0367577858,
0.425283581,
-0.9281976223,
0.7695156932,
-0.1763233989,
-0.455326587,
0.3265445232,
-0.4208860695,
-0.654376328,
0.1022116244,
-0.3740515113,
-0.3175994158,
0.1618861407,
0.3421832025,
0.437594682,
-0.1974453479,
0.2687510848,
-0.3970738947,
-0.8229340911,
0.5282495022,
-0.4598549008,
0.5176192522,
-0.0413364433,
-0.5691633224,
-0.1388615221,
-0.4298970699,
-0.232432887,
0.0114156557,
0.3458121419,
-0.4404123127,
-0.0130189387,
-0.1224759966,
0.2455878705,
-0.1494175345,
-0.2470053434,
-0.0630150959,
-0.3359832168,
-0.083727397,
0.5138660669,
0.3779004812,
0.123964794,
-0.7445037365,
0.7714813948,
-0.2729642391,
0.1744886935,
0.1633859575,
-0.2856379151,
-0.7126765847,
-0.2747320831,
0.1041984335,
0.4321594834,
-1.1983454227,
0.5573630333,
0.0918113962,
-0.476259023,
-0.2823434472,
-0.2347802669,
0.4153303206,
0.4969293475,
0.4976415336,
-0.07586357,
-0.4933991134,
-0.7479481697,
-0.3419884145,
-0.4260065556,
-0.2493764609,
0.333788991,
0.3718816936,
-0.1123118475,
0.6282181144,
-0.5787717104,
-0.5633111,
-0.0674446896,
0.2880190611,
-0.2567143738,
0.5554404855,
0.3575728536,
-0.8582189083,
-0.1239383146,
-0.4847132266,
-0.8224720955,
-0.1212697029,
-0.6098009944,
-0.1158567816,
0.2968305945,
0.7354128957,
-0.9929565191,
0.6743128896,
0.4025544524,
-0.5850641727,
0.7056188583,
-0.196583733,
0.8423880339,
-0.8173183203,
0.3942925334,
-0.2423330098,
-0.1325536072,
-0.5781731606,
0.0695342049,
-0.2448808402,
-0.1447550058,
-0.0947758779,
0.4206237793,
-0.3457775414,
-0.0406992175,
-0.0454833806,
0.1793225557,
0.1061485633,
0.4817878306,
0.1386507452,
0.899505496,
0.2233895063,
-0.7237679958,
0.1560692489,
0.2963580191,
-0.4473447502,
0.48958233,
-0.5202227235,
0.0581082962,
-0.0992388651,
0.2553499043,
-1.0151090622,
-0.2248743623,
0.3567228615,
-0.4055149853,
0.1598149985,
-0.0196729563,
-0.6828401089,
-0.037647482,
-0.313972801,
0.3971202374,
0.3764256239,
-0.3656248152,
0.629937768,
0.29726547,
-0.1043262109,
-0.4464193285,
-0.7109421492,
0.2050742507,
-0.4004936516,
-0.5379704833,
0.7109797597,
-0.6103611588,
-0.2716298997,
-0.3112824261,
-0.3086643815,
0.0004333871,
0.0870444551,
0.197751388,
0.1107258871,
0.0547325462,
0.1598336101,
0.1256026179,
0.0512811281,
0.2057889551,
0.3158444762,
0.7818447948,
0.0039060228,
-0.4773759842,
-0.2260194868,
0.3439005315,
0.6858077049,
0.1423147023,
0.7988193631,
0.5304476619,
-0.5518965721,
-0.2538228333,
-0.9065381885,
-0.5755663514,
-0.4335882962,
0.3787500262,
-0.4206257164,
-0.6289215684,
0.8583670259,
0.2899735272,
-0.3416163623,
0.2250402868,
0.2946109772,
0.1259340048,
0.9215582609,
0.085040994,
0.1983577162,
0.2334388345,
0.0018842195,
0.1639832556,
-0.5243771076,
-0.2831892967,
-0.3036750853,
-0.233009547,
-0.4245839417,
-0.8012908101,
0.3564089239,
0.0930823013,
-0.0353507362,
0.3496034741,
0.0530192368,
0.5418525934,
0.2483918816,
0.4696674049,
0.2545982599,
-0.0450585037,
0.0865211859,
-0.2322967052,
-0.5355568528,
-0.3392086327,
0.8667201996,
0.2273561805,
0.7547798157,
0.3423940539,
0.6762390733,
0.5710514784,
-0.1501805186,
-0.4890070558,
0.7497001886,
0.0767648146,
-0.8060708046,
-0.7797509432,
-0.5476017594,
-0.5873489976,
0.0613169484,
-0.3816727698,
-0.6465929151,
0.2997312546,
0.1388083994,
-0.6072276235,
0.0896893144,
-0.4644048214,
0.6500613093,
0.0455322117,
-0.5785815716,
-0.3033037186,
-0.4582116008,
0.3867273331,
-0.1457600445,
-0.0888314322,
0.214781791,
0.1813824922,
0.5378965735,
-0.1229460165,
1.1278686523,
-0.2903599441,
-0.0926918089,
0.1679728776,
0.6891630888,
0.742433846,
0.5852045417,
-0.2082016915,
0.1417526603,
0.2967977524,
-0.2605533004,
-0.9103536606,
0.7151161432,
-0.4953646362,
-0.7780679464,
-0.5592551827,
-0.809110105,
-0.6248221397,
-0.1873060167,
0.2926801443,
0.2657342851,
-0.781437397,
0.4184258282,
1.0868905783,
-0.4128364623,
0.2399813086,
0.2362354994,
-0.2121421993,
-0.3239590824,
0.7911165357,
0.2079022378,
0.2260547131,
0.2546229661,
0.127395317,
-0.2835798264,
-0.0510292649,
-0.1041552126,
0.2938389182,
-0.5798854232,
-0.1231731325,
-0.6859594584,
-0.3692184985,
-0.7187579274,
-0.0439758562,
-0.2370803356,
-0.6010459065,
-0.3879511654,
-0.0046214028,
0.170513466,
0.4091203511,
-0.0095364898,
0.0735910609,
-0.2711515129,
0.5593678951,
0.260727495,
0.2647921443,
-0.1170227081,
-0.4147645235,
-0.0418337397,
-0.0298913717,
0.0945952088,
-0.6999338865,
0.4454208612,
0.1286329776,
0.7961884141,
0.5047982931,
0.490318507,
0.9528028369,
-0.2885710001,
0.7658704519,
-0.0752584264,
-0.964093864,
0.1493234187,
-0.2937234044,
0.0928007439,
0.7821349502,
0.3189187646,
-0.726773262,
-0.4355250001,
-0.5731317997,
-0.4192358255,
0.6309459209,
0.586412549,
-0.0260986779,
-0.0114210146,
0.3487958014,
0.2804590464,
0.3167824149,
-0.5870500207,
0.0607078224,
-0.1621187478,
0.0587511845,
-0.6197463274,
-0.3207345009,
-0.3848609626,
-0.1377877444,
0.6859223247,
-0.1293158531,
0.2607762218,
0.4059354067,
-0.4293881059,
-0.1185823455,
-0.0820323676,
0.9727826715,
0.5721646547,
-0.2479100972,
0.2557111681,
0.1781564057,
-0.4987403452,
-0.1492393464,
0.1664623171,
-0.1763615459,
-0.1433702558,
0.4316526949,
0.4312165082,
0.3143160641,
-0.5958183408,
0.3783791959,
-0.1290743351,
-0.2785891294,
-0.3965744078,
0.1826200783,
-0.1632443815,
0.4693624377,
0.2516090572,
0.020791851,
0.2173157781,
-0.5439876914,
0.49169752,
0.3267597854,
-0.3284656405,
-0.0928666219,
0.5769643188,
-0.064453505,
-0.4371626973,
0.3938136995,
-0.1220977083,
-0.5019177198,
0.8916485906,
0.6643935442,
0.8408676982,
-0.4393215179,
0.6322793961,
0.1713920683,
0.5158626437,
-0.1805085242,
0.1755036414,
0.1078342497,
-0.5969726443,
-0.1177186668,
-0.3297802806,
-0.308575958,
0.3650456071,
-0.4467703402,
0.3091128767,
-0.528106451,
-0.0577019788,
-0.4442877471,
0.1544305384,
-0.5403838158,
0.0468114689,
0.0265406501,
0.3883517087,
-0.8867545128,
0.5595088601,
0.0942154154,
-0.5628432035,
-0.3073802292,
0.7635880709,
-0.1846240163,
-0.5170807242,
0.5082010627,
0.2541989982,
-0.2474722713,
0.000109495,
-0.2257911861,
-0.5648617744,
1.0724527836,
0.3821501434,
-0.2831863761,
-0.1898244917,
0.3284394145,
0.6248846054,
-0.461892128,
0.2551813126,
0.4254012704,
0.4252147079,
0.1687543392,
-0.5128627419,
0.4255225062,
-0.2726773918,
0.0180580579,
-0.2652161419,
-0.4881590307,
0.5881889462,
-0.0212632325,
-0.0082728714,
0.1381772012,
0.5524728298,
0.5375449657,
0.3208153844,
0.8866321445,
-0.0645449832,
0.8522785306,
0.2889503539,
0.6024338603,
-0.3403143585,
0.0442119054,
1.0480360985,
-0.4493055642,
0.3263069093,
0.7216117978,
0.3528850675,
0.2359109074,
0.5123374462,
-0.1204361096,
0.4349741638,
0.4084269702,
-0.2896266878,
-0.5832879543,
0.038216345,
-0.3232213855,
0.3466212451,
0.4119850397,
-0.0852202401,
-0.0059230844,
0.2134448439,
-0.0362720191,
0.2292560935,
0.0579270311,
0.3666014969,
-0.082223855,
-0.8754962087,
0.4544548392,
-0.2934551537,
0.3080424666,
-0.6327201724,
-0.4436989725,
-0.3720203936,
0.1324675828,
0.0144861704,
-0.218905881,
0.2672986388,
-0.2101911604,
-0.1539604962,
-0.1090219766,
0.5780270696,
-0.5289693475,
-0.5115297437,
0.3457309008,
0.2807772458,
0.2351291031,
-0.5198321342,
-0.4882434309,
-0.0295904689,
-0.2334672809,
-0.2535356581,
0.2008742243,
0.4019675255,
-0.2116604447,
0.4754018784,
0.5178125501,
0.0954085812,
-0.2311210185,
0.2086991817,
0.7227156758,
-0.6310683489,
-0.70795995,
-0.5936298966,
0.2918740511,
-0.265057683,
-0.2254938334,
0.7417471409,
0.5392388701,
0.4847916067,
-0.2441247702,
0.5381408334,
-0.0545140691,
0.233587563,
-0.6952672005,
1.2449270487,
-0.4593664408,
0.6042116284,
-0.5496476889,
-0.8977716565,
-0.470589757,
0.6750065684,
-0.2561581135,
0.1886779517,
0.8482952714,
1.2410566807,
0.0809722915,
0.055817388,
0.9325026274,
0.1535272896,
0.3468078971,
0.385414958,
0.8736746311,
-0.4312285185,
0.544675827,
-0.2626050711,
-0.3093858361,
-0.3424522579,
-0.7706954479,
-1.3989391327,
-0.647916615,
-0.3403254747,
-0.8296670318,
0.3060445487,
0.802228868,
0.5240170956,
-0.689812243,
-0.2336462736,
-0.0824596137,
-0.0397057123,
-0.552893579,
-0.2548273504,
0.264341414,
-0.3789014816,
-0.5232637525,
0.6270141006,
-0.2226885259,
-0.1993282586,
-0.4882082641,
-0.2177403569,
-0.2783362865,
0.4847382307,
0.4851819873,
0.1322759241,
-0.6298822761,
-0.4042544663,
0.3737013042,
-0.0097055472,
-0.0970621333,
1.1001380682,
-0.743277967,
0.3450709581,
0.3619247675,
0.4169371724,
0.5616827607,
0.0714967176,
0.707292676,
-0.7413308024,
0.0568434931,
0.433650583,
-0.0433298014,
0.1083101332,
-1.0588421822,
0.5460159779,
0.3914124966,
-0.4280613661,
-0.8106851578,
0.1656377316,
-0.7432108521,
-0.5346446633,
1.1633410454,
0.0108517967,
-0.1206958592,
-0.1469712108,
-0.187315762,
0.3868983686,
-0.2446438074,
1.3077529669,
0.9352759719,
-0.1777953506,
-0.0580699965,
-0.4961005747,
0.8612904549,
0.512984395,
-0.8173825145,
0.4079683423,
0.6044800878,
-0.0564578027,
0.1433036476,
0.4424666166,
-0.0809835196,
0.1799556613,
0.1268010437,
0.1742611527,
-0.0758510828,
-0.8056840897,
-0.2520899475,
0.2190623134,
-0.3291870654,
0.1713575274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17257v1
|
Leveraging Parameter-Efficient Transfer Learning for Multi-Lingual Text-to-Speech Adaptation
| 2024-06-25T03:50:54 | 2024-06-25T03:50:54 |
Yingting Li, Ambuj Mehrish, Bryan Chew, Bo Cheng, Soujanya Poria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Different languages have distinct phonetic systems and vary in their prosodic
features making it challenging to develop a Text-to-Speech (TTS) model that can
effectively synthesise speech in multilingual settings. Furthermore, TTS
architecture needs to be both efficient enough to capture nuances in multiple
languages and efficient enough to be practical for deployment. The standard
approach is to build transformer based model such as SpeechT5 and train it on
large multilingual dataset. As the size of these models grow the conventional
fine-tuning for adapting these model becomes impractical due to heavy
computational cost. In this paper, we proposes to integrate parameter-efficient
transfer learning (PETL) methods such as adapters and hypernetwork with TTS
architecture for multilingual speech synthesis. Notably, in our experiments
PETL methods able to achieve comparable or even better performance compared to
full fine-tuning with only $\sim$2.5\% tunable parameters.The code and samples
are available at: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/multilingualTTS-BA4C.
|
[
-0.3929549158,
-0.3670730889,
0.2358624488,
0.4472318888,
-0.3193473518,
0.0190789308,
-0.3975327611,
-0.360771656,
-0.0793402046,
0.2589664757,
-0.3770567179,
-0.3150194287,
-0.3380928934,
0.2984729409,
0.1284502447,
0.9762643576,
0.1076301709,
-0.0152995586,
0.5086987615,
-0.2780027092,
-0.3622192144,
-0.524864316,
-0.686373353,
-0.1379255503,
0.5072634816,
0.4889121056,
0.2670821846,
0.4673607647,
0.2594803274,
0.241111353,
-0.1134997606,
0.4126570821,
-0.3708566725,
0.0624739528,
-0.2693039179,
-0.2736822665,
-0.4029662609,
-0.3289350569,
0.9286118746,
0.5432776213,
-0.0276650656,
0.0448215045,
0.1396834999,
0.4314171672,
-0.6181430817,
0.2006826103,
-0.7758892775,
0.1224313751,
-0.0743038803,
-0.20586887,
-0.6714829803,
-0.2419229746,
0.3384039402,
-0.792001009,
-0.0459734127,
-0.0740507245,
0.411534965,
0.0050498466,
-0.4220540226,
-0.1560090482,
-0.8975129724,
0.8045282364,
-0.6263760328,
0.9921404123,
0.2807142138,
0.2504325509,
0.0584355704,
-0.7307305932,
-0.350987792,
-0.2539309263,
-0.0091752391,
0.1266082078,
-0.0039584502,
-0.0602977164,
-0.0298732501,
-0.1059281826,
-0.7290531397,
0.1287969053,
-0.3313804269,
-0.448836714,
0.2699390352,
-0.2169973701,
0.0432898663,
-0.0382097512,
-0.433832556,
-0.3698046505,
-0.4089529812,
-0.0262872595,
0.2833200097,
0.8079204559,
-0.3152950108,
-0.1588066965,
0.2830339074,
0.6724880338,
0.1820296943,
-0.2178802192,
0.3620301485,
-0.5325351954,
0.0731755123,
0.2608703077,
0.7639446855,
-0.10750328,
0.484803915,
-0.2392403036,
0.0671836361,
-0.4971656203,
0.1005428508,
-1.10341084,
-0.0670103729,
0.033969216,
-0.2800785005,
0.0460953414,
-0.1347106695,
-0.7415245771,
-0.0676773414,
-0.2898992598,
0.4096239805,
-0.5594239235,
-0.3967905641,
0.1382383555,
0.0229108948,
0.2099297941,
0.0863573626,
-0.9954464436,
0.1236640215,
0.3026327789,
0.9912468195,
-0.2609001398,
-0.7991988063,
-0.8815504313,
0.4460154772,
-0.4647199214,
0.5183503032,
-0.3437871337,
-0.4528095722,
-0.1758780777,
0.1952698678,
-0.3495282531,
-0.4639612734,
0.6107677221,
-0.4184170663,
0.0630410537,
-0.0338306725,
-0.1791145504,
-0.1728806943,
-0.1075734869,
-0.6712948084,
0.9092237949,
-0.1210338697,
-0.4811094701,
0.0582637377,
-0.716966033,
-0.714984417,
-0.0813674778,
0.2706613839,
-0.471318692,
0.0246915817,
0.2541992664,
0.5495352149,
-0.2307100445,
0.2907084227,
-0.1251271367,
-0.2532674372,
0.2713514864,
-0.636105597,
0.6309292912,
0.3761771023,
-0.2822435796,
0.1660024971,
-0.9132853746,
0.1104688421,
-0.238293916,
-0.5531929135,
-0.3274964988,
-0.3032038808,
0.6389496326,
0.1401715279,
0.0687281117,
-0.3002105057,
-0.1144161075,
-0.4448167086,
0.5708650351,
0.6261470318,
-0.1041991487,
0.4647803903,
-0.2460143417,
0.3233518302,
0.0767117292,
0.1006583869,
-0.0029512006,
-0.1278711259,
-0.4126207232,
-0.4220862091,
0.6110009551,
0.4190824628,
-0.7553052902,
0.217828542,
-0.3148994744,
-0.6551354527,
-0.5802862644,
-0.1415835321,
0.42278561,
0.5004341006,
0.4705786407,
-0.1297217757,
-0.503595233,
-0.6366322637,
-0.293705374,
-0.2548160255,
-0.0900537595,
0.1282854378,
0.2292981595,
0.1714796871,
0.4933174551,
-0.0821781307,
-0.1318477988,
-0.1263526529,
0.144315958,
0.0212464258,
0.503479898,
0.7150039077,
-0.8456217647,
-0.730638206,
0.4201288819,
-0.2861615419,
-0.1288495958,
-0.2306932211,
-0.1019234434,
0.1524269879,
0.5533511639,
-0.1988204271,
-0.2380397469,
0.8052176833,
-0.1230849773,
0.7433445454,
-0.4958359003,
0.157834664,
-1.4046145678,
0.410977453,
-0.0582537875,
-0.3482034802,
-1.0728379488,
-0.1103532836,
0.1763980538,
-0.2744937539,
-0.8330375552,
0.6231411695,
-0.4300828576,
-0.1001130342,
-0.2274449021,
-0.0432068743,
-0.1331005991,
0.6394193172,
0.2292639911,
1.0979391336,
0.6315983534,
-0.699020803,
0.0892920792,
0.1937299371,
0.0732854605,
0.6103215218,
-0.4404915273,
0.2384283543,
0.0688647106,
0.2860857844,
-0.6658874154,
0.1040088981,
0.1923540086,
-0.294885993,
0.1459783614,
-0.1849052608,
-0.1720019579,
0.1845443547,
-0.3072654307,
0.5723335147,
0.3844026923,
-0.6221497655,
0.8444627523,
0.1524092257,
-0.2928852141,
-0.4159159958,
-0.7277021408,
0.0049828161,
-0.4221973419,
-0.2399816513,
0.7380966544,
-0.2990095317,
0.3256652355,
-0.1420028508,
0.0720469281,
-0.2755313814,
-0.1329906583,
-0.3063158095,
-0.0894463584,
-0.4181961417,
0.0830618218,
0.0541372225,
-0.2213715464,
-0.2401133925,
-0.5058683157,
0.4479201138,
-0.2179573476,
-0.2008893043,
-0.5930314064,
0.4153183103,
1.0996420383,
-0.4452333152,
0.5023613572,
0.9353548884,
-0.2000003457,
-0.27391541,
-0.1419461221,
-0.2742197216,
-0.4721196592,
0.7190649509,
-0.833104074,
-0.6689924002,
0.6094802618,
-0.3962065876,
0.0053749029,
0.1689018905,
0.7305732965,
0.3766199946,
0.8025394082,
0.5536547303,
-0.1244124547,
0.6544917822,
0.0974101573,
0.0984985381,
-0.8995317817,
0.0211887546,
-0.6072756052,
-0.0882165805,
-0.9530235529,
-0.4483129978,
0.6893880367,
-0.212520197,
-0.220976308,
0.4863650203,
-0.3749467432,
0.2295984477,
0.6573355198,
0.1133230478,
0.2318231463,
0.141824618,
-0.2180671394,
-0.0201118886,
-0.8398091793,
-0.1230749115,
0.945184052,
0.1395355612,
0.4454292655,
0.22169213,
0.3300057352,
0.0392692275,
-0.3031162322,
-0.7491955757,
0.3869248927,
-0.5642011762,
-0.2322520167,
-0.3886550665,
-0.4303171337,
-0.9388151169,
0.5022699237,
-0.2137837261,
-0.5227724314,
0.4124734104,
0.0351378508,
-0.2680222988,
0.2542062998,
-0.7225972414,
0.6647323966,
-0.2597112656,
-0.4949494004,
-0.3023891747,
-0.7933569551,
-0.2342810631,
-0.4827543497,
0.2444450259,
0.1049395651,
0.0206593648,
0.7391555309,
-0.0301311426,
0.7646567822,
-0.24347426,
-0.087975271,
-0.0560628138,
-0.0092406794,
0.402100116,
-0.1426448375,
-0.3756940961,
0.1214859039,
0.127346769,
-0.2492921203,
-0.5801967382,
0.5134937167,
-0.7947635651,
-0.1243499741,
-0.0759712309,
-0.7645065188,
-0.6027643681,
0.1902092099,
0.074360542,
0.5552957654,
-0.1855982393,
0.2908136249,
0.6001580954,
-0.200223729,
0.6453716159,
0.6563652158,
0.0294528045,
-0.5291473866,
1.1810898781,
0.1772574633,
0.320869118,
0.508109808,
0.5860889554,
-0.4065195322,
-0.6346799731,
-0.8152236342,
0.3184009492,
-0.4522171915,
-0.0430074073,
-0.2841814756,
-0.3219222724,
-0.252732873,
-0.1199035645,
-0.6520280838,
-0.2001875788,
-0.3764032423,
0.1766505837,
0.4942425489,
0.2427596748,
-0.2655294538,
0.358984828,
-0.8651183844,
0.3886224627,
0.3128550947,
0.4193098545,
-0.0084126461,
-0.7880191803,
-0.4260234535,
-0.0974164307,
-0.1687746495,
-0.8125112653,
0.2229460627,
0.6611698866,
0.4111418128,
0.0443625301,
0.1190667748,
0.7471056581,
-0.6625860929,
0.5534722209,
0.1823241413,
-1.0493680239,
0.2331388593,
-0.1669595838,
0.437183857,
0.406006217,
0.5707464814,
-0.6761661768,
-0.1168712229,
-0.2494354695,
-0.7565121055,
0.8303883672,
0.0977795795,
0.1023048535,
0.5610378981,
0.2923671603,
0.2585497499,
-0.1661238223,
-0.5490876436,
-0.1197384521,
-0.1368112564,
-0.3659224212,
-0.0695381984,
0.0201962236,
0.1728267372,
-0.2635174692,
0.8797765374,
-0.4257123172,
0.0712458044,
0.0515156575,
-0.1515280902,
0.2456029356,
0.3951865137,
0.7506949902,
0.5046702623,
-0.0053282036,
0.2509322762,
0.404646039,
-0.5403276086,
0.3935745358,
0.2790935636,
0.10610158,
0.0435417667,
0.2324511558,
1.1695162058,
0.2812201083,
-0.4146620333,
0.2369537055,
-0.0004860351,
-0.4616602063,
0.2132519931,
-0.2239892185,
0.3059152365,
0.2109531015,
0.2502774,
0.0277402233,
0.1403312832,
-0.3529068828,
0.2945837379,
0.0572308786,
-0.2575030029,
-0.6433933377,
0.6035666466,
0.2491624355,
-0.4336163998,
0.3263779581,
0.0927456692,
-0.4378093183,
0.2389277667,
0.9453288317,
0.8971657753,
-0.8155823946,
0.219504565,
0.2466403842,
0.0347840451,
0.0326897539,
0.1098074466,
-0.041056376,
-0.4763434529,
-0.652972281,
-0.6646219492,
-0.6098618507,
0.2147290558,
-0.345993489,
0.421308279,
-0.0960756764,
0.0842416063,
0.1139166728,
-0.4072917998,
-0.3898881376,
0.1250943691,
0.0973564982,
0.6037678123,
-0.9470168948,
0.9350605607,
0.7780578136,
0.0067322049,
-0.9261366725,
0.1139376163,
-0.3900321722,
-0.6333189607,
0.4302027225,
-0.2217004746,
-0.5014413595,
0.2153704762,
0.2725408375,
-0.8259488344,
0.5748226643,
0.8971719742,
-0.5912739038,
-0.0156506039,
0.4721392989,
0.5700513124,
-0.097919926,
0.3219334185,
0.4345880449,
0.6211737394,
0.1037478819,
-1.3514376879,
-0.042240601,
0.0088039776,
0.1976372749,
0.0417778082,
-0.77361691,
0.5910978913,
0.1020787507,
0.1793926507,
-0.3094042242,
0.4514143169,
0.1681756079,
-0.0432266109,
0.6221814156,
0.0465555117,
0.6994652152,
0.3193686903,
0.4522096515,
-0.5653167367,
0.2081367075,
0.8433468938,
-0.1051735207,
0.9237043262,
0.4696370363,
-0.0921781957,
0.2530164123,
0.5234651566,
0.3312488198,
0.821870327,
-0.0187038518,
-0.2690403759,
-0.1720244437,
-0.1329764575,
-0.3382536173,
0.8603515029,
0.2763895988,
-0.1851187497,
-0.2694453895,
0.4068108201,
-0.0799939185,
-0.1242363751,
-0.1274132878,
0.9316813946,
-0.0616187602,
-0.5121436119,
0.9847143292,
0.0296620987,
0.6544572711,
-0.7591617107,
-0.0230729524,
-0.1417654306,
0.1881915331,
0.0039976719,
-0.4634483159,
0.3139135242,
-0.0739056692,
-0.240853861,
-0.2622963786,
0.616710186,
-0.6122811437,
-0.3925895393,
0.3399412334,
0.6750603318,
0.1827995032,
-0.0240499564,
-0.7087087035,
-0.0161465742,
0.0218110494,
-0.2217038423,
0.388767451,
0.4449716806,
-0.2174994648,
0.5005676746,
0.7131469846,
0.4108993709,
0.0023105622,
0.1786796153,
0.4748488963,
-0.3649539649,
-0.8117642999,
-0.7795649171,
0.3581837714,
0.3669500351,
-0.3929845095,
0.4599710405,
0.6097049713,
0.8449425697,
-0.2867957652,
0.8863709569,
0.2559783161,
0.3717050254,
-0.5759096742,
0.6372455955,
-0.6129093766,
-0.0745786354,
-0.2280745357,
-0.7821260691,
-0.2984241247,
0.4402954578,
-0.0088312728,
0.0345399678,
0.6794644594,
0.8426804543,
-0.3580994308,
0.0438870788,
0.4605066478,
0.0241365042,
0.2878500223,
0.5770301819,
0.4472639561,
-0.336773783,
0.7447094917,
-0.1505317539,
-0.1359727085,
-0.2690747082,
-0.9261060953,
-0.4061764777,
-0.9054197073,
-0.2893371284,
-0.0523990095,
0.4813539386,
0.853993535,
1.0519539118,
-0.8700712323,
-0.5422503352,
-0.0874392837,
-0.0597267598,
-0.4663701952,
-0.1588265449,
0.7210957408,
-0.3755429387,
-0.9854539037,
0.5444342494,
0.104959622,
-0.000543743,
-0.0274379216,
-0.1560760736,
-0.1162688136,
-0.0106213987,
0.6769382358,
0.3135225773,
-0.4232261777,
-0.3660151362,
0.030666532,
0.2032434195,
0.2245077044,
0.7483110428,
-0.5754830837,
0.5425357819,
0.40656811,
1.0017582178,
0.6385018826,
-0.2171113193,
0.6010372639,
-0.9130232334,
0.2305433154,
0.1375995278,
0.0499714762,
0.4061652422,
-0.1160297021,
0.2059605718,
0.2183409482,
-0.5872374177,
-0.6846684217,
0.1635280997,
-0.9961901307,
-0.4194837511,
1.1347945929,
-0.0728441179,
-0.0617245436,
0.0285190288,
-0.3740843534,
0.5288819075,
-0.3079497814,
0.4017435908,
0.3774602115,
-0.2888146341,
-0.1763407141,
-0.4027736187,
0.5084419847,
0.5256263614,
-0.7997755408,
0.2857016027,
0.1796291769,
0.3457179368,
-0.0117637962,
0.3996918499,
0.1302494258,
0.3728049099,
-0.0819102004,
-0.0026641688,
-0.0923163593,
-0.4121926427,
-0.4127129316,
0.2703130543,
0.1804538667,
-0.4519714713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17255v1
|
MPCODER: Multi-user Personalized Code Generator with Explicit and Implicit Style Representation Learning
| 2024-06-25T03:45:28 | 2024-06-25T03:45:28 |
Zhenlong Dai, Chang Yao, WenKang Han, Ying Yuan, Zhipeng Gao, Jingyuan Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated great potential for assisting
developers in their daily development. However, most research focuses on
generating correct code, how to use LLMs to generate personalized code has
seldom been investigated. To bridge this gap, we proposed MPCoder (Multi-user
Personalized Code Generator) to generate personalized code for multiple users.
To better learn coding style features, we utilize explicit coding style
residual learning to capture the syntax code style standards and implicit style
learning to capture the semantic code style conventions. We train a multi-user
style adapter to better differentiate the implicit feature representations of
different users through contrastive learning, ultimately enabling personalized
code generation for multiple users. We further propose a novel evaluation
metric for estimating similarities between codes of different coding styles.
The experimental results show the effectiveness of our approach for this novel
task.
|
[
-0.5543696284,
-0.0874708518,
0.3375792801,
0.3650450706,
0.0411782861,
0.2624849379,
-0.3808322847,
0.0637136102,
0.1516396403,
0.2996575832,
-0.4356286824,
-0.6342957616,
-0.4670253694,
0.3706575334,
-0.1502632052,
0.8583334088,
0.0956436321,
0.0306199491,
-0.2646404803,
-0.1099011078,
-0.488052398,
-0.8737310767,
-0.3444426954,
-0.1121885851,
0.6103322506,
0.5385081172,
0.1829984933,
0.3586628139,
0.3687544763,
0.3402888775,
0.3550939858,
0.165408656,
-0.4580419958,
0.0473602712,
0.1687622517,
-0.0506884791,
-0.1040257588,
-0.3823703229,
0.2928859293,
0.1576592028,
-0.2090933919,
0.4394538701,
0.0828647539,
0.4177371562,
-0.5809875131,
0.0991673693,
-0.6120322347,
0.2116241604,
0.133362636,
-0.4586069584,
-0.4257154763,
-0.7046782374,
-0.2864094675,
-0.212793842,
0.1625985056,
-0.1706434041,
0.4757991731,
-0.0137134502,
-0.560174644,
-0.4376422465,
-0.7796962261,
0.674238503,
-0.6786039472,
0.3589737415,
-0.0156919826,
0.4952574074,
0.2934644222,
-0.9045872688,
-0.7634592056,
-0.3531647027,
-0.2792288363,
-0.1050410867,
-0.0607649982,
-0.3213199377,
0.1663919538,
0.210678339,
-0.3695703447,
-0.089913331,
-0.3820572197,
-0.1075883806,
0.5340906382,
0.2222864628,
0.5091258883,
-0.0841130689,
-0.4625273645,
-0.0078996541,
-0.5362100601,
0.0810289308,
0.6390919089,
0.009871182,
-0.1922052652,
0.257832408,
-0.1676226109,
0.3887021542,
-0.051915478,
-0.4559755623,
0.6026884317,
-0.3072220087,
0.1636130214,
-0.0799971744,
0.7880323529,
0.5097723603,
0.4132289886,
-0.2082915157,
-0.3147766888,
-0.0587644465,
0.3149762452,
-0.9089753032,
-0.3546280563,
-0.1127518192,
-0.541905582,
-0.3623763621,
0.3534736931,
-0.8793370724,
-0.4345352352,
-0.416698128,
0.0167493951,
-0.2654931843,
-0.2352339029,
-0.0496063642,
-0.1122523174,
0.1662277877,
0.0812397376,
-0.9487021565,
0.229938969,
0.2737338543,
0.5402687192,
-0.0708800331,
-0.5607220531,
-0.4055760801,
0.284337163,
-0.0527235121,
0.4326971471,
-0.7426031232,
-0.4468218386,
0.1039656922,
-0.400154233,
0.2886305749,
-0.3688766956,
0.1038420424,
-0.3524862826,
-0.0159108024,
-0.1667450666,
-0.2440990061,
0.0671006143,
-0.0078543564,
-0.431333065,
0.6233739853,
0.3979123533,
-0.6360130906,
0.46885553,
-0.537828505,
-0.18502675,
0.2141837627,
-0.5230763555,
-0.7066698074,
0.2072827071,
0.1553922743,
0.6170548201,
0.1004464105,
0.2537040412,
-0.4818302393,
-0.6321623921,
0.4480559528,
-0.1372051984,
0.2428171188,
0.3945138454,
-0.106841512,
0.4759011269,
-0.8457593918,
0.0278437417,
0.1685848981,
-0.7116873264,
0.0505213924,
-0.0160212088,
0.2948284149,
0.5136247277,
0.38001737,
-0.4685046673,
0.3222468197,
0.2448339462,
0.4030472338,
0.9112020135,
0.0811432377,
0.1030148566,
-0.2400309294,
0.5114166141,
-0.2284218073,
-0.1575974822,
-0.4979479313,
-0.0162884723,
-0.6322922707,
-0.2996648252,
0.0978115201,
0.3055516481,
-0.5825760961,
0.4990506172,
-0.3500477076,
-0.1018091664,
-0.2015625238,
0.6418940425,
0.7854289412,
0.1600936204,
0.2801011503,
-0.4299612939,
-0.7036883235,
-0.6963558197,
-0.1473105401,
0.1595141441,
-0.2273249626,
0.6848838925,
0.4010209143,
-0.7003769875,
1.0244003534,
-0.7878434062,
-0.2344243973,
-0.4120766222,
0.058268901,
-0.2241408378,
0.5896102786,
0.694583118,
-0.9202415347,
-0.5611363649,
0.1332791746,
-0.5286778808,
-0.1222618818,
-0.1323809475,
0.0859469995,
0.1524857134,
0.5475010276,
0.1400291622,
0.0038425392,
0.681435585,
-0.342653513,
0.5648824573,
-0.3755362928,
0.2607859969,
-1.2070937157,
0.2788283825,
0.2393181771,
-0.1423994154,
-0.3596233428,
0.2926612794,
0.107087411,
-0.4453173578,
-0.3796114922,
0.4107935429,
-0.4226040542,
-0.2177295685,
-0.0179230142,
-0.4147456884,
-0.1043328643,
0.8972287178,
0.0345463417,
1.0231643915,
0.2146935463,
-0.4153803885,
0.3723622859,
0.0176523197,
-0.3799978793,
0.2971586883,
-0.6559273601,
0.6515433192,
-0.0553455688,
0.0671831518,
-1.0515688658,
-0.4103454053,
-0.0468917936,
-0.3279896677,
0.2247730047,
-0.4300053418,
-0.5730574131,
-0.3033511341,
-0.3476040661,
0.1290768236,
0.9534823895,
-0.7264344096,
0.3820151091,
0.1621344835,
-0.1776587963,
-0.3169666529,
-0.3926478624,
-0.0760222152,
-0.2780003548,
-0.5283702016,
0.252825886,
-0.1714896709,
-0.0410847366,
-0.1180806085,
-0.2814139426,
-0.183413431,
0.0486503355,
0.3160010278,
0.0415684171,
-0.250870496,
0.034604881,
0.0889514759,
-0.2443347722,
-0.0414225794,
-0.0540583096,
0.7805054784,
-0.2161105424,
-0.4551249444,
-0.1582352668,
0.4794968665,
0.2802974582,
-0.6677692533,
0.6233019829,
0.9295170903,
0.0111690499,
-0.2903541028,
-0.6455131769,
0.1237085834,
-0.5407691598,
0.4524480104,
-0.6799767613,
-1.1233285666,
0.4041699469,
-0.4103944302,
-0.2048780173,
0.0797755048,
0.7089834213,
0.070677422,
1.1265922785,
1.0686333179,
0.0880669132,
0.5273456573,
-0.1120068207,
-0.080439806,
-0.7840046883,
-0.5439730287,
-0.5765277743,
-0.2757636011,
-0.2981381118,
-0.1095986962,
0.2110583782,
0.245391205,
-0.4561724663,
0.2998286784,
-0.6693191528,
0.7501472831,
0.5640578866,
0.2033781409,
0.1614690572,
0.2179310322,
-0.2245201021,
-0.1158049703,
-0.2234046459,
-0.4818120897,
0.909213841,
0.2161281109,
1.0375000238,
0.4067032039,
1.0551338196,
0.3269439638,
0.1421618462,
-0.4464052618,
0.1582479328,
-0.3061579764,
0.1414392143,
0.2354412228,
-0.59422189,
-0.4291899204,
0.0481144376,
-0.0999797359,
-0.7363646626,
0.2499391288,
0.3622398674,
-0.2505782247,
0.0205773637,
-1.0626140833,
0.9849134088,
-0.2035053223,
-0.1574790031,
0.0946320966,
-0.54555583,
0.4578262866,
-0.3115737736,
0.0146199288,
-0.0413867049,
-0.2136120051,
0.368131727,
-0.1896895021,
0.9406561255,
-0.1780869812,
0.1041591987,
-0.0705584511,
0.2551958263,
0.2613555491,
0.3112933934,
0.0174206588,
-0.0272922572,
-0.3785563409,
-0.1158501878,
-0.5803183913,
0.9835889935,
-0.6494602561,
-0.3336298168,
-0.1278232187,
-0.2335394174,
-0.0988340452,
0.1767714471,
0.2210638076,
0.5740897655,
-0.1913937926,
0.1248753965,
0.5382947326,
-0.4071332216,
0.6759337783,
0.3083764613,
-0.2262536287,
-0.6121470928,
1.1945153475,
-0.4558542669,
0.0047190916,
0.337056607,
0.2426689118,
-0.0438925438,
-0.4456116259,
-0.3949976861,
-0.0510719828,
-0.7107334137,
-0.196953848,
-0.6148343086,
-0.0342616923,
-0.2956123352,
-0.5392193198,
0.0408171713,
0.1697818041,
-0.1436018497,
0.3018604517,
0.3909419477,
0.7737386823,
0.418295294,
0.288908273,
-0.9413534999,
0.4913038909,
0.4941279888,
0.4475598633,
-0.1718343347,
-0.1874673367,
-0.0676966906,
-0.380751133,
-0.2772923708,
-0.8319471478,
0.4688281715,
0.2714959681,
0.6115764976,
0.278303057,
-0.1436553597,
0.5153112411,
-0.7145018578,
0.6470154524,
0.5148404241,
-1.0618542433,
0.3859083951,
0.0376244001,
0.5074712634,
0.5921824574,
0.5126304626,
-0.7510271072,
-0.0630899966,
-0.2126820087,
-0.5569577217,
0.523614347,
0.0556183867,
0.6064389348,
0.0764231086,
0.3688745499,
0.2892794311,
0.2482444048,
-0.7445418239,
-0.2111641616,
-0.4016894102,
-0.3805780709,
-0.1315023154,
-0.4044031203,
0.0528327711,
-0.185208559,
0.0860792175,
-0.6226041317,
0.5145322084,
-0.1232022718,
-0.0889566541,
0.2608938515,
0.5891285539,
0.6907402873,
0.9190061092,
-0.1162292585,
0.0825801641,
0.0893184319,
-0.2462317795,
0.1201894656,
0.1623854637,
0.0907068551,
-0.1071554422,
0.1618827134,
0.6809765697,
0.1791844964,
-0.5853926539,
0.7483336329,
-0.3779541552,
0.0688394234,
-0.4647183418,
0.2284222096,
0.2306967974,
-0.0439246334,
0.1188291088,
0.5905222297,
0.1219954714,
-0.3912151158,
0.4062822759,
0.1482902169,
-0.4240953922,
-0.2384761721,
0.5625133514,
0.6203833222,
-0.3228338957,
0.4217337668,
-0.4399320185,
-0.538810432,
0.5258389115,
0.6834687591,
0.9705296159,
-0.1114683226,
0.0742573962,
0.2828449607,
-0.1427896321,
0.3350292146,
0.3427399397,
-0.3243698776,
-0.5793578029,
-0.4612839222,
-0.9368419647,
-0.1076833233,
-0.1628426164,
-0.4963156283,
0.5899372697,
-0.6243349314,
0.260491401,
-0.1990214437,
-0.2688634694,
-0.5475007892,
-0.1839131564,
0.3358984292,
0.6674341559,
-0.5107125044,
1.0493425131,
0.7169615626,
-0.6846871376,
-0.7140162587,
0.1773672253,
0.2311679125,
-0.5416807532,
0.8128449321,
0.2321351767,
-0.3629379272,
-0.0188007001,
-0.4212104082,
-0.4467467964,
0.9557554126,
0.5863943696,
-0.6759006977,
0.0935469642,
-0.2244818956,
0.4148391187,
-0.8057444692,
0.1889200956,
0.3862390518,
0.0103840576,
0.1160899773,
-0.5935332775,
0.0196552351,
-0.4879565239,
0.4808884561,
0.2996611893,
-0.5659214258,
0.7345190048,
-0.4271608293,
-0.0709287375,
0.0099654449,
0.3937619627,
0.3102628291,
0.0675588995,
0.0796688572,
0.1830164641,
0.4230197966,
0.050757166,
1.3115144968,
-0.5128371119,
0.3659254611,
1.0877068043,
-0.2263057232,
0.6553961635,
0.130968079,
-0.0567666031,
0.6771719456,
0.0623216294,
-0.2660188973,
0.4450392723,
0.3998738229,
-0.3508974612,
-0.0802214667,
0.1729183644,
-0.5331367254,
0.3218924701,
0.0912705585,
-0.6114301682,
0.0814180896,
-0.0622123666,
0.1630863845,
0.3275858462,
-0.1264024228,
1.066647172,
-0.021138072,
-0.1694563478,
0.4568761885,
0.3232387006,
1.1822272539,
-0.852953732,
-0.4286982119,
-0.4159845412,
0.3591369689,
-0.4496635497,
-0.66774863,
0.1224956214,
0.1708899736,
-0.116345048,
-0.3673219383,
0.7673349977,
-0.4264885187,
-0.4545616806,
0.1403028369,
0.1958329827,
-0.2262219638,
0.165112868,
-0.527048409,
0.2455809712,
0.195115909,
0.1115967631,
0.3862210512,
0.1735825986,
0.3625265062,
0.6886088252,
0.6487719417,
-0.1223086119,
0.3591653109,
0.2921518981,
0.9628885388,
-0.6176518798,
-0.370990634,
-0.8681094646,
0.3683867455,
-0.0870516077,
-0.6228290796,
0.9179366231,
0.6852174401,
1.0913295746,
-0.6549888253,
0.7357091904,
-0.0913638845,
0.0992426649,
-0.5591788888,
0.7291230559,
-0.2542724609,
0.4173607826,
-0.519646585,
-1.1374824047,
-0.2612531185,
0.3646597564,
0.1720106006,
0.3995014727,
0.4739007056,
0.6273291707,
-0.3005026579,
-0.3914188445,
0.2192379832,
-0.3477303982,
0.3915453851,
0.7103540301,
0.8726198077,
-0.0662653521,
0.7851825356,
-0.5493916273,
-0.1548998356,
-0.1301564574,
-0.8555119634,
-0.8240763545,
-0.5582641959,
-0.2993935645,
-0.2873538435,
-0.0272841547,
1.1551553011,
0.8951733708,
-0.6596428752,
-0.449422121,
0.0950606838,
-0.0197296124,
-0.2018238157,
-0.1939442307,
0.087170206,
-0.4519058764,
-0.7339949608,
0.0770800337,
0.0581413619,
-0.0437745936,
-0.3844054937,
-0.6039104462,
0.3191764057,
-0.2499637008,
0.5890129209,
0.3200289309,
-0.5977110863,
-0.2176775336,
-0.2517588437,
-0.3412795961,
0.2393278331,
1.3000879288,
-0.766197741,
0.40744403,
0.6352698803,
0.6608467698,
0.4067691863,
0.0780385658,
0.4477737248,
-1.2718631029,
-0.1099376082,
-0.0661224648,
0.4513958395,
0.3137857318,
-0.492336303,
0.3346065581,
0.0824182928,
-0.3649528921,
-0.551482141,
0.3398814201,
-0.9197001457,
-0.2664803863,
1.1692777872,
-0.3701816499,
0.1243587658,
0.0544079244,
-0.5329799652,
-0.1778084487,
-0.7623520494,
0.3563528359,
0.2142685205,
-0.251860261,
-0.4714133441,
-0.1776319146,
0.4869128168,
-0.1981367916,
-0.8702138066,
-0.2073438019,
0.5947201848,
0.5207872391,
0.2497055084,
0.5942396522,
-0.0492463671,
0.4332715571,
0.1875459701,
0.5060718656,
-0.6787004471,
-0.4032113552,
-0.7203238606,
0.437843889,
0.2637217939,
0.1133124903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17253v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17253v1
|
How Well Can Knowledge Edit Methods Edit Perplexing Knowledge?
| 2024-06-25T03:41:02 | 2024-06-25T03:41:02 |
Huaizhi Ge, Frank Rudzicz, Zining Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As large language models (LLMs) are widely deployed, targeted editing of
their knowledge has become a critical challenge. Recently, advancements in
model editing techniques, such as Rank-One Model Editing (ROME), have paved the
way for updating LLMs with new knowledge. However, the efficacy of these
methods varies across different types of knowledge. This study investigates the
capability of knowledge editing methods to incorporate new knowledge with
varying degrees of "perplexingness", a term we use to describe the initial
difficulty LLMs have in understanding new concepts. We begin by quantifying the
"perplexingness" of target knowledge using pre-edit conditional probabilities,
and assess the efficacy of edits through post-edit conditional probabilities.
Utilizing the widely-used CounterFact dataset, we find significant negative
correlations between the "perplexingness" of the new knowledge and the edit
efficacy across all 12 scenarios. To dive deeper into this phenomenon, we
introduce a novel dataset, HierarchyData, consisting of 99 hyponym-hypernym
pairs across diverse categories. Our analysis reveal that more abstract
concepts (hypernyms) tend to be more perplexing than their specific
counterparts (hyponyms). Further exploration into the influence of knowledge
hierarchy on editing outcomes indicates that knowledge positioned at higher
hierarchical levels is more challenging to modify in some scenarios. Our
research highlights a previously overlooked aspect of LLM editing: the variable
efficacy of editing methods in handling perplexing knowledge. By revealing how
hierarchical relationships can influence editing outcomes, our findings offer
new insights into the challenges of updating LLMs and pave the way for more
nuanced approaches to model editing in the future.
|
[
-0.1234210059,
-0.8664048314,
0.7870479822,
-0.038926065,
0.0059943418,
0.404910624,
-0.064804852,
-0.3105111718,
0.0419497117,
0.2782655954,
-0.4892040789,
-0.6837147474,
-0.8301148415,
0.2040691525,
-0.4087211788,
0.9758647084,
-0.0771486163,
-0.2762694061,
-0.2737655938,
-0.1228923947,
-0.368720144,
-0.9626889229,
-0.1567538381,
-0.2951271236,
0.7020292878,
0.4786585867,
1.247810483,
0.6927185059,
0.7193356156,
0.3269785643,
-0.7554444671,
0.0454397388,
-0.7365924716,
-0.0233315025,
-0.3204895258,
-0.7059156299,
-0.7978322506,
0.0500396602,
0.6803137064,
0.8353212476,
-0.0241145622,
0.0457317531,
0.0148309153,
0.514325738,
-0.80098629,
-0.2135693729,
-0.9574287534,
0.2078214735,
-0.3354019523,
-0.3025183082,
-0.0070342487,
0.0086023994,
0.4469871819,
-0.9618221521,
-0.0020463604,
-0.0508524664,
0.7969943881,
0.3899711967,
-0.2033709437,
-0.4344941378,
-0.6854045391,
0.3178935945,
-0.8496472836,
0.2937837839,
0.2543104291,
-0.147726059,
-0.298566848,
-0.5465732813,
-0.757861495,
0.117723614,
-0.0669590309,
-0.11513675,
-0.3559990227,
0.1357482821,
0.8317096829,
0.2384918481,
-0.0622471049,
0.278752625,
-0.019920392,
0.0461476333,
0.3542274535,
0.2725393474,
0.3448898196,
-0.5915563107,
-0.2529327571,
0.1702410281,
-0.8688168526,
0.0317980871,
0.52059412,
-0.1289134324,
0.180128172,
0.8915771246,
-0.1921016872,
0.4719258547,
0.2025716007,
-0.3896544874,
0.1315408498,
-0.1351436973,
-0.4814602733,
-0.0946874246,
0.3572352827,
0.361513406,
0.0146796331,
-0.1803724021,
-0.2532370985,
-0.3364675343,
0.1218490824,
-0.2675595582,
-0.2500408292,
0.131812498,
-0.0972389057,
-0.3914237618,
-0.2811379731,
-0.3569281399,
-0.800940156,
-0.1882112175,
0.6088297367,
-0.4093197584,
-0.0706899539,
0.3034419417,
-0.1145332679,
-0.0966373608,
0.7127560973,
-0.5743396282,
0.0071581029,
0.7488892674,
0.5402507782,
-0.0550999828,
-0.5019322634,
-0.0999426618,
0.2802023888,
-0.4253793955,
0.6517724395,
-0.727335453,
-0.2666823566,
-0.1635170579,
-0.2967558205,
-0.0469608158,
-0.5830985904,
0.2003457844,
-0.7868224978,
-0.0458084606,
-0.4286260307,
-0.8455538154,
0.1050697714,
0.2262652963,
-0.4730378389,
0.6355931163,
0.0718264058,
-1.1190621853,
0.3614869416,
-0.5725012422,
-0.2918874919,
-0.1318864375,
0.1325541139,
-0.1539877355,
0.2659868002,
0.0610166937,
0.1351157725,
-0.0968478248,
0.2683552206,
-0.1432985067,
-0.0936457142,
0.513151288,
-0.0909033641,
0.5587551594,
-0.0305686649,
-0.0180767979,
0.1367365122,
-0.6269988418,
-0.4355923235,
-0.1074519381,
-0.2974501252,
-0.6382004023,
-0.1029556543,
-0.5579308271,
0.2687946558,
0.3629908562,
-0.3000073433,
0.4929536879,
-0.0578859188,
0.242181778,
0.7520446181,
0.2050519735,
0.3564743996,
-0.4815481305,
0.7843580246,
0.1614345163,
0.2223126143,
-0.0429345034,
-0.4310723841,
-0.6354678869,
0.1149694026,
0.5617726445,
0.7517147064,
-0.8260469437,
0.0592388138,
-0.2135169953,
-0.2956911325,
-0.5922296047,
0.4646368623,
0.530489862,
0.7530812025,
0.4136927724,
-0.1056693122,
-0.4659466743,
-0.8654914498,
-0.5784210563,
-0.2044097632,
0.114418216,
0.198189348,
0.5532268882,
-0.2587144971,
0.7351983786,
-0.5362013578,
-0.0244267527,
-0.016730262,
0.277534306,
0.1136916205,
0.4778259099,
0.2344357967,
-0.6387320161,
-0.1528474092,
-0.1163375676,
-0.907073915,
-0.1860559881,
-0.2325303108,
-0.1629111618,
0.0791601092,
0.6807070971,
-0.5744680762,
0.4389252961,
0.311934948,
-0.1546080559,
0.8617635965,
-0.2221100479,
0.3015595078,
-0.8872381449,
-0.2705245018,
-0.106396541,
0.27766487,
-0.6908464432,
0.2189331651,
0.0495378263,
0.3318874836,
-0.496594727,
0.1813020706,
-0.4353359342,
0.1435305625,
0.1300533116,
0.1308661103,
-0.2670730352,
0.324680984,
-0.2194374651,
0.4807202518,
0.2631213069,
-0.291785866,
0.2027276456,
0.5422210693,
-0.6242518425,
0.4620513916,
-0.3804967701,
0.2699100673,
-0.2639886439,
-0.0455907881,
-0.8892684579,
-0.2623622417,
0.0505059771,
-0.2995715141,
0.1007421315,
-0.2285820395,
-0.6458687186,
-0.0330689922,
-0.1562664211,
0.4296613634,
0.2384728938,
-0.2458188534,
0.4242018163,
0.365226984,
-0.4447207749,
-0.9251461625,
-0.7339348197,
0.5673243999,
-0.303964287,
-0.6471134424,
0.4651670754,
-0.019445831,
-0.5119869113,
0.2717483044,
-0.4260849953,
0.0235695038,
0.2378039807,
0.035265144,
0.2270306498,
-0.0729287043,
0.1667436957,
0.27199471,
-0.049249623,
0.0870277584,
0.0163065642,
0.0160070676,
0.391651541,
-0.3011584878,
-0.5679547787,
-0.0317335837,
0.6677513123,
-0.1443555355,
0.5593799949,
-0.1470122635,
-0.4968200326,
0.0937600657,
-0.758190155,
0.1664994508,
-0.4153223336,
0.6246641278,
-0.8421141505,
-1.0069042444,
0.6466175318,
-0.1825222522,
-0.0275879223,
0.4436356723,
0.2473739982,
-0.2940852046,
0.848295331,
0.6211230159,
0.1139800251,
0.3735417426,
-0.2233279347,
0.2202471197,
-1.0846937895,
-0.2366381586,
-0.4903427064,
-0.4100280404,
-0.7026498914,
-0.5293962955,
0.5308161378,
0.3716630042,
-0.0055991933,
0.1712374687,
0.068445161,
0.5489815474,
0.1956577301,
0.1638702899,
0.921066761,
-0.0892096087,
-0.1418743134,
-0.2203309387,
-0.9763570428,
-0.5293227434,
1.2424556017,
0.3935874701,
0.8613387346,
0.3420098126,
0.5758064389,
0.1556022167,
0.3197890222,
-0.6437314153,
0.3528895974,
-0.3439974487,
-0.5640005469,
-0.6204598546,
-0.3665837049,
-0.6277253032,
0.0572451949,
-0.7039901614,
-0.6956154108,
0.5096617937,
0.3499993682,
-0.4660286009,
0.7184699774,
-0.6162883043,
0.6913224459,
-0.0513520092,
-0.3164856434,
-0.1671326011,
-0.6957867146,
0.3615416586,
-0.2606206238,
0.5159223676,
0.257111311,
-0.0758333355,
0.7352092266,
-0.3403492868,
0.5664937496,
0.0139900446,
-0.5090096593,
-0.1616315395,
0.3571332097,
0.539203763,
0.0373025946,
-0.2953610718,
-0.0471581593,
-0.039469108,
-0.3913983703,
-1.0828721523,
0.5466656685,
-0.7569600344,
-1.2092652321,
-0.2404416353,
-0.9414997101,
-0.522511363,
-0.060192775,
0.2588221729,
0.3380246162,
-0.017537469,
0.1173363253,
0.8716626763,
-0.4073835313,
-0.1128095761,
0.4442404807,
-0.1969503462,
-0.1052076146,
0.7047855258,
0.6965608597,
0.5655171275,
0.5588830709,
0.1941066086,
-0.0371923409,
-0.9962713122,
-0.1831864715,
0.0437373519,
-0.7144995928,
0.0765253454,
-0.8626950979,
-0.2218413353,
-0.3522481322,
-0.2960323691,
-0.0427645855,
-0.6323809624,
-0.0108631467,
-0.166137144,
0.1730978191,
1.0639885664,
-0.1072903275,
0.3492672741,
-0.4375675917,
0.5044218302,
0.5364267826,
0.1697918773,
0.0048266654,
-0.749917686,
-0.1392971426,
0.0083365273,
-0.0073324535,
-1.0237156153,
-0.0761426985,
-0.2520266473,
0.4379693568,
0.1886980832,
-0.0218451899,
0.9838507175,
-0.2259153277,
0.4662088752,
-0.0630678982,
-1.1175692081,
0.3475168645,
-0.372992605,
0.3476319909,
0.3438510001,
0.5491344929,
-0.6877353787,
-0.6673642993,
-0.7113919258,
-0.6662214994,
0.5628468394,
0.0822537467,
0.0649291053,
0.3598838747,
0.7913402319,
0.0283187963,
0.3598461747,
-0.4103320837,
-0.287886411,
-0.0236734487,
0.2049089074,
-0.1256089211,
-0.6500117779,
-0.1165380999,
-0.6196522713,
0.5633891821,
0.3680538535,
-0.2228103727,
0.3970819414,
-0.4480981231,
-0.3118891418,
0.5500630736,
0.5308918357,
1.0122323036,
-0.216593191,
0.2105611861,
0.5022131205,
-0.2903464139,
0.1190483272,
-0.0370445549,
-0.3273707628,
-0.3040444851,
0.7347524762,
0.8550552726,
0.4225330055,
-0.2375812829,
0.1850494146,
0.1272232234,
-0.4631836116,
0.2404424101,
0.1266044676,
0.1988714337,
0.1955321729,
0.406603545,
0.1113575622,
-0.0072917542,
-0.6548007131,
-0.1277320832,
0.1781107932,
0.0212293845,
-0.196747914,
0.4235312641,
-0.0689947456,
-0.4259753227,
0.3862447143,
-0.231096372,
-0.7076579332,
0.4884385169,
0.4548217952,
0.4932846129,
-0.2799834907,
0.1360703707,
0.0505886711,
0.4846401513,
0.2545215189,
-0.149633944,
0.2296234667,
-0.9493221641,
-0.5003563166,
-0.4122427404,
-0.7618180513,
0.3785218,
-0.4449422657,
0.0757836252,
-0.5012430549,
-0.1443097591,
0.3196706772,
-0.1360270083,
-0.5545681119,
0.1779085249,
-0.3148424625,
0.9452866316,
-0.7405743599,
0.7343248725,
1.0775065422,
-0.120741643,
-0.7660293579,
0.3291624784,
0.3403903246,
-0.4777302444,
0.4480308294,
-0.5433234572,
-0.123506099,
0.1190967634,
-0.6253252029,
-0.780654788,
0.7615244389,
0.4609367847,
-0.6785858274,
-0.4383552969,
0.1476115733,
0.594497323,
-0.2615349293,
-0.1329280287,
0.8465566635,
0.6768823862,
0.1788164079,
-0.8928486705,
0.0148593727,
-0.2763050199,
-0.1624108553,
-0.063619107,
-0.2562835813,
1.0118587017,
-0.4646614492,
-0.0323105454,
0.0811781064,
0.2858867347,
-0.0226225518,
0.1576689631,
0.5750183463,
0.8161346912,
0.8527006507,
0.1031536609,
0.8179706931,
-0.1127369031,
0.1215309352,
1.2834903002,
-0.2496287823,
0.6257721186,
0.4700126648,
-0.2242878526,
0.7234783173,
0.3223696947,
0.2313971967,
0.0125191938,
0.3930169642,
-0.2427505553,
-0.3827364147,
0.0214069113,
-0.3139498234,
0.3988366723,
0.4411839545,
-0.0183474757,
-0.0938885808,
-0.0385396406,
0.3844623864,
0.14368622,
-0.1598173231,
0.8345121741,
-0.1419773549,
-0.5067690611,
0.4967787564,
0.0427912883,
0.6285250187,
-0.3857474327,
-0.0181697849,
-0.1313791573,
-0.3299339116,
-0.4878590107,
-0.9696491361,
0.1359533668,
0.2715076506,
-0.2396489233,
-0.0623513833,
0.48008582,
-0.2299040109,
-0.3156653047,
0.2390595078,
0.8890237808,
-0.071408987,
-0.1131772473,
-0.4957378805,
0.058928065,
-0.0839938149,
-0.2020337582,
0.3346932232,
0.8864799738,
-0.1008230597,
0.6174666882,
0.6231269836,
0.3055965602,
-0.0405846946,
-0.0400257595,
0.8079719543,
-0.7162843943,
-0.2751079798,
-0.7325289845,
0.5140937567,
0.0711486563,
-0.5772150755,
0.7472640276,
0.297133714,
0.9169745445,
0.1182902083,
0.8532256484,
0.0167581327,
0.3779695332,
-0.5787258744,
0.7419623733,
-0.5794072747,
0.6710807681,
-0.8355127573,
-0.6158033609,
-0.3775054812,
0.2495790124,
-0.7816516161,
-0.2381455749,
0.9341395497,
0.8430169821,
0.1688905358,
0.0496018156,
0.4470297694,
0.9798690081,
-0.038049262,
0.56494385,
1.1308567524,
-0.1104678512,
0.2334693968,
-0.5863018036,
-0.3767155111,
-0.0049310243,
-0.904191792,
-0.7732508779,
-0.5021778345,
-0.3251164854,
-0.220333159,
0.6222509146,
0.7760635018,
0.3797534406,
-0.5537627339,
-0.1752065271,
0.1418031603,
0.7817278504,
-0.042159602,
-0.13059856,
0.341245085,
-0.2323667258,
-0.4721872509,
0.1941046864,
0.1072786897,
0.0313933305,
0.0059746411,
0.0688794479,
-0.4627624452,
0.0710831508,
0.6619223356,
0.075641498,
-0.6098946929,
-0.2915075719,
-0.0807046369,
0.0128481155,
0.0795158222,
0.7645847201,
-0.6220318079,
0.4579695463,
0.3580292761,
0.6529814601,
0.2684747279,
0.1940618455,
0.3886592686,
-0.3149093688,
-0.2572898865,
-0.0400221869,
0.1904999763,
0.3338488638,
-0.4637015164,
0.1636201739,
0.4908479154,
-0.3879499137,
-0.8256486058,
0.0705391467,
-0.6298570037,
-0.3593316674,
1.0107626915,
-0.2580822706,
-0.026274126,
-0.2395244688,
-0.2301104814,
0.2872733772,
0.0024571957,
1.0382195711,
1.1175860167,
-0.2597859204,
0.0056775124,
-0.502161622,
0.6060114503,
0.7032234669,
-0.6948345304,
0.0764733106,
0.4682239592,
0.4117071033,
0.0362357721,
0.2600439489,
-0.1395306587,
0.4252524376,
-0.2011063248,
-0.1401794553,
-0.1630156934,
-0.4662255645,
-0.4275858998,
0.3708323836,
0.3217180371,
0.5004757643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17245v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17245v1
|
Unlocking Continual Learning Abilities in Language Models
| 2024-06-25T03:24:06 | 2024-06-25T03:24:06 |
Wenyu Du, Shuang Cheng, Tongxu Luo, Zihan Qiu, Zeyu Huang, Ka Chun Cheung, Reynold Cheng, Jie Fu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) exhibit impressive performance and generalization
capabilities. However, LMs struggle with the persistent challenge of
catastrophic forgetting, which undermines their long-term sustainability in
continual learning (CL). Existing approaches usually address the issue by
incorporating old task data or task-wise inductive bias into LMs. However, old
data and accurate task information are often unavailable or costly to collect,
hindering the availability of current CL approaches for LMs. To address this
limitation, we introduce $\textbf{MIGU}$ ($\textbf{M}$agn$\textbf{I}$tude-based
$\textbf{G}$radient $\textbf{U}$pdating for continual learning), a
rehearsal-free and task-label-free method that only updates the model
parameters with large magnitudes of output in LMs' linear layers. MIGU is based
on our observation that the L1-normalized magnitude distribution of the output
in LMs' linear layers is different when the LM models deal with different task
data. By imposing this simple constraint on the gradient update process, we can
leverage the inherent behaviors of LMs, thereby unlocking their innate CL
abilities. Our experiments demonstrate that MIGU is universally applicable to
all three LM architectures (T5, RoBERTa, and Llama2), delivering
state-of-the-art or on-par performance across continual finetuning and
continual pre-training settings on four CL benchmarks. For example, MIGU brings
a 15.2% average accuracy improvement over conventional parameter-efficient
finetuning baselines in a 15-task CL benchmark. MIGU can also seamlessly
integrate with all three existing CL types to further enhance performance. Code
is available at \href{https://github.com/wenyudu/MIGU}{this https URL}.
|
[
-0.0835886225,
-0.7363947034,
0.4055440426,
0.2747772932,
-0.1025960669,
0.220980823,
-0.634167552,
-0.3457766175,
-0.248253718,
0.2665747404,
-0.4494221509,
-0.5022714734,
-0.3730753362,
-0.2275721878,
-0.1343726814,
0.8968148232,
0.0789580345,
0.1749492735,
-0.1664513499,
-0.4917124808,
-0.8171311021,
-0.3499563634,
-1.0641167164,
-0.6595262289,
0.8788596988,
0.4577421248,
0.4128400087,
0.4587504566,
0.0781052932,
0.1761722863,
-0.0510209948,
0.1818737984,
-0.7231091261,
0.0579939038,
-0.2286898941,
-0.363882333,
-0.3013878763,
-0.1010338217,
1.0394995213,
0.7355591655,
-0.2470644414,
-0.1606349647,
0.6048983932,
0.8622832298,
-0.567632854,
0.2214899212,
-0.9220587015,
-0.1807767153,
-0.2442945242,
0.0669839904,
-0.4774944484,
-0.1983118057,
0.0577468313,
-0.3795664907,
-0.0128680002,
-0.2818019688,
1.2006483078,
0.2958987653,
-0.0594801232,
-0.1962047815,
-0.9880484939,
0.9379326701,
-0.6302232146,
0.6073117852,
0.1901819706,
0.3022657335,
-0.3110496402,
-0.5543532968,
-0.1237918586,
-0.588593483,
0.0509596877,
0.2343236953,
-0.0737684667,
0.1681416333,
-0.0879461393,
0.5346528292,
-0.3817158043,
0.3307549953,
-0.0177721661,
-0.0093204873,
0.270737946,
-0.0216389224,
0.2478322089,
0.2099413872,
-0.279219538,
0.1313767433,
-0.698302865,
0.0450773649,
0.0451901592,
0.108084619,
-0.0793915391,
0.0096098864,
-0.0351604596,
0.7303289175,
0.032749448,
-0.0623134822,
0.1452217251,
0.0119720623,
-0.1543484628,
-0.4892444909,
0.5958862901,
-0.1083355844,
0.2602383196,
-0.7392730117,
-0.3932543397,
0.0169319138,
0.2428413033,
-0.3187963665,
-0.3097498119,
0.1834443808,
0.0367841013,
-0.0712679625,
-0.013636441,
-0.5508824587,
0.0950825587,
-0.4979242384,
0.5656458139,
-0.6156674623,
-0.3783033192,
0.1231506318,
0.1712159514,
0.1544979662,
0.1270997822,
-0.8092250228,
0.279260993,
0.5230728388,
0.9676883817,
-0.533769846,
-0.5055900216,
-0.6424151659,
0.3496235609,
-0.3129024506,
0.5652478337,
-0.4512408674,
-0.2784256935,
-0.1045940667,
0.1474210471,
-0.3940696716,
-0.739867866,
0.3036691248,
-0.3916493356,
-0.1283392906,
-0.1800693572,
-0.5035693049,
-0.043821495,
0.1083993018,
-0.5582042336,
1.1392657757,
0.305765748,
-0.3128140569,
0.3034402132,
-0.6535406113,
-0.270260781,
0.1651964337,
-0.0581323765,
-0.679267168,
0.1461326182,
-0.0560150146,
0.4290755987,
-0.119806923,
0.7214805484,
-0.249504894,
-0.2980467379,
0.0456591174,
-0.4833089709,
0.5384406447,
0.2349984199,
-0.3638038635,
0.1432659328,
-0.6631672382,
-0.2831451893,
0.2050799876,
-0.5198810697,
-0.2296688408,
0.0434036665,
-0.2048864365,
0.0469093882,
0.2219098657,
-0.374137938,
0.2220865935,
-0.1865582317,
0.3887359798,
0.9628086686,
-0.044582583,
0.5159135461,
-0.7127609253,
0.4522557855,
0.1317539066,
0.1598819345,
-0.0934657827,
-0.2407845706,
-1.1591444016,
-0.2007679045,
0.2516014576,
0.6636351943,
-0.6121163964,
0.198679775,
-0.4363333881,
-0.8148477077,
-0.2082701772,
0.6172773838,
0.5858855844,
0.5645637512,
0.4841884971,
-0.1637922078,
-0.3098359108,
-0.5956261754,
-0.3280384839,
-0.0745220855,
-0.1181582063,
0.4804928899,
0.2585532963,
-0.2597553432,
0.7731038332,
-0.1131428927,
-0.2643254399,
-0.4185919166,
0.1395377964,
0.1681645811,
0.9278925657,
0.5317421556,
-0.3667096496,
-0.3422690332,
0.1876678616,
-1.0279359818,
-0.1230583116,
-0.6493199468,
-0.2837549448,
0.4249552786,
0.515137732,
-0.50127244,
0.1294018477,
0.5830837488,
-0.1099381894,
0.6642177105,
-0.1956425011,
-0.2486926019,
-0.8137026429,
0.2567922473,
0.106309481,
-0.2710613906,
-0.6923884153,
0.2428524941,
0.1443767101,
-0.0736468285,
-0.383292973,
0.6716817021,
-0.6250109076,
0.1819449216,
-0.1106645465,
0.0045245849,
-0.0748730823,
0.8116138577,
-0.2185507715,
0.6121196151,
0.8673484325,
-1.1081448793,
-0.0422077514,
-0.2212865055,
-0.1952806711,
0.3414139152,
-0.665143311,
0.3309602141,
-0.2411971241,
0.0944992155,
-0.6111565828,
-0.0290784985,
0.3211694956,
-0.3110337555,
0.6578562856,
-0.438272506,
-0.4374911189,
-0.1941682845,
0.1807842404,
0.1669756025,
0.5313765407,
-0.5137791634,
1.0081213713,
0.3287683129,
-0.0525060445,
-0.4673668146,
-0.4783997536,
0.2900757194,
-0.3122916818,
-0.3554154336,
0.3447336257,
-0.3524799645,
-0.0679868683,
-0.0159889646,
-0.2929911613,
0.1564788818,
0.3533121943,
0.0773492754,
0.3939456344,
-0.1481538415,
0.4222000539,
0.1114194542,
-0.1968144178,
-0.0631869957,
-0.7889768481,
0.7150565386,
-0.3013688922,
-0.0379806943,
-0.3197842538,
0.1227351874,
0.6263116598,
-0.2751492858,
0.8213979602,
0.6608982086,
-0.4964717031,
-0.2466458976,
-0.864023149,
-0.0088048559,
-0.4757759869,
0.2370052785,
-0.4362472892,
-0.904858768,
0.6233138442,
-0.1668596715,
0.3718899786,
0.3130503595,
0.2366574854,
-0.2161931992,
0.5580253005,
0.6817731857,
-0.4177674353,
0.6900331378,
-0.4492470324,
-0.2137216926,
-0.7662394047,
-0.4372560978,
-0.3173215389,
-0.2297355086,
-0.0912207365,
-0.085260056,
0.358435899,
0.6925494075,
-0.0295863673,
0.340483427,
-0.2740704119,
0.4415639043,
0.4857470989,
0.3627020121,
0.0895423144,
-0.0281260777,
-0.3734694421,
0.1865947098,
-0.959730804,
-0.1723347157,
0.9985554218,
0.29634583,
0.6788948178,
0.0693753436,
0.6929408312,
0.2913639843,
0.4446536303,
-0.6157544851,
0.5933383703,
-0.106148012,
-0.0887588561,
-0.2385659963,
-0.5355067253,
-1.0128309727,
-0.080113329,
-0.0677728504,
-0.7186571956,
-0.0276957266,
0.5367478728,
-0.0560192801,
0.5741470456,
-0.6689540148,
0.7781608105,
-0.2503566146,
-0.6379835606,
-0.3291200697,
-0.3949705064,
0.100073576,
-0.1655761003,
0.0068742055,
-0.0947852731,
0.1670232862,
0.5911262631,
-0.1616120934,
0.8225165606,
-0.3985109925,
-0.1934071034,
0.3464938104,
0.2343214601,
0.6031603813,
0.2213764191,
0.0666077957,
0.4047321379,
-0.338514179,
-0.7130357623,
-0.5158932209,
1.0768194199,
-0.5769726634,
-0.8060756326,
-0.2790798247,
-0.6749646068,
-0.3200888634,
0.1740523577,
0.0701068491,
0.6115777493,
-0.0299231689,
0.1015431359,
0.7781076431,
-0.156315431,
0.5483217239,
0.3867688477,
-0.080708012,
-0.3419158757,
1.2883927822,
0.1362246126,
0.5292513371,
0.1505791992,
0.3873918355,
-0.119875595,
-0.6034404635,
-0.4226065278,
0.4287422895,
-0.6258068681,
-0.1985888034,
-0.7953528762,
-0.3764081299,
-0.0891322792,
-0.201585114,
-0.2303512543,
-0.0583293177,
-0.4263235927,
-0.0140960701,
0.223546952,
0.5452201366,
-0.3304439485,
0.04361232,
-0.778599143,
0.3057042062,
0.3900345862,
0.4633204937,
0.2877037525,
-0.5491053462,
-0.4639829695,
0.0744965672,
-0.3009949625,
-0.5570255518,
0.1253342628,
0.5598025322,
0.7286807299,
0.3614067733,
-0.2658229172,
0.7966410518,
-0.4668304622,
0.7317647338,
-0.0532204062,
-0.8078469038,
0.6999877691,
-0.5483090281,
0.6938952804,
0.4701324701,
0.3762178123,
-0.5889354348,
-0.8583477736,
-0.4994570315,
-0.7227887511,
0.4164618552,
0.1536726207,
0.2066912204,
-0.1327667683,
0.4950358272,
0.1642748117,
-0.2105653137,
-0.8247832656,
-0.3579567969,
-0.2917345762,
-0.0508509837,
0.0141632855,
-0.2019708008,
0.1578588337,
-0.3947387934,
0.877953589,
-0.0032971771,
0.2264097631,
0.0974964648,
-0.4065354466,
0.1116243005,
0.2314131409,
0.5208181739,
0.743714273,
-0.145546928,
-0.1477922797,
0.3617270291,
-0.4851383865,
0.0532306321,
-0.0427363925,
-0.3371858597,
0.2344810814,
0.0376449339,
0.6753631234,
0.3844586611,
-0.5852170587,
-0.0210683346,
0.2486238033,
-0.0302909315,
-0.6765118837,
0.3268330693,
0.1251627803,
-0.0112645952,
0.5100795627,
0.2515654564,
-0.2677995265,
-0.3791383803,
0.3745438159,
0.3620688617,
-0.643427968,
-0.3448595107,
0.8156936765,
0.0849481076,
-0.0739272758,
0.5306819677,
-0.3477148712,
-0.2379202098,
0.3648796678,
0.7098807096,
0.9414829612,
-0.3079327941,
0.0131686982,
0.5641949177,
0.1165144444,
-0.2000367939,
0.0811048597,
-0.0113069899,
-0.7126145363,
-0.3972311914,
-0.6358426809,
-0.1297179908,
0.4711854458,
-0.6356835365,
0.1109967455,
-0.6527950168,
-0.0449736938,
-0.4809904099,
-0.3056907952,
-0.5844871998,
0.1467214525,
0.0299955439,
0.6742507219,
-0.5023191571,
1.1783854961,
0.3432429731,
-0.3157697618,
-0.6392940879,
-0.1222757623,
0.1082124338,
-0.62497437,
0.3874802589,
0.186123848,
-0.3887102008,
0.3879935443,
-0.4764389694,
-0.6484224796,
1.2034947872,
0.4155445099,
-0.7851412296,
-0.2483543307,
-0.0859276429,
0.2418042719,
-0.1526373625,
-0.2482523322,
0.6719828248,
0.3082278669,
-0.0551017597,
-0.6027383804,
-0.2061543018,
-0.3050669432,
-0.0691910833,
0.2569039464,
-0.631480515,
0.5441990495,
-0.2213794589,
-0.5268889666,
0.2530542016,
0.844370544,
0.3580208421,
0.1263245791,
0.5491572022,
0.8642284274,
0.7265589833,
-0.3674709201,
0.8883719444,
-0.4983246028,
0.3701684773,
1.1738290787,
0.1348183155,
0.5222081542,
0.2526775301,
0.1697505265,
0.6030874252,
0.2861286402,
-0.1049393788,
0.3710384369,
0.2027205676,
-0.5927029252,
-0.3301265538,
-0.2777199447,
-0.1401155144,
0.1537385434,
0.5055097342,
0.0071574147,
-0.1295896769,
0.2368481755,
0.4538773,
0.1600235999,
-0.5926035047,
0.7106859088,
0.1829836965,
-0.7013912797,
0.9689136147,
-0.1185579672,
0.7737691402,
-0.861610651,
-0.0561292768,
-0.5311476588,
0.0834976211,
0.0317106657,
-0.3220292926,
0.2014452368,
0.0033043714,
0.0787840709,
-0.0902068689,
0.6049827337,
-0.6211547256,
-0.4732404351,
0.4015556276,
0.3093571365,
-0.1090248525,
0.0721798539,
-0.6110607386,
0.0491612777,
-0.1752384156,
0.0731452107,
0.2955618799,
0.1953681558,
0.1073503792,
1.1825469732,
0.6352494359,
0.2177268714,
0.0898052454,
0.2677179575,
0.8653146029,
-0.5472120643,
-0.2480739504,
-0.7822728753,
0.6176243424,
0.1373310387,
-0.3003509045,
0.5025015473,
0.3713255823,
1.104796648,
-0.236992538,
0.6692608595,
0.0715985596,
0.2034644186,
-0.9633635879,
0.8972710967,
-0.6242415309,
0.2424596399,
-0.1827740669,
-0.8963595033,
-0.3590251207,
0.2426965535,
-0.0230183527,
0.0511016846,
0.7786211371,
0.720821321,
-0.0848504901,
-0.4728186727,
0.4715187848,
0.2479265481,
0.328705132,
0.929895103,
0.584989965,
-0.2918041945,
0.5915144086,
-0.1835636199,
-0.1275627017,
0.1853400022,
-0.547903657,
-1.0064547062,
-0.6263666749,
-0.4350959659,
-0.3623118997,
0.377668947,
0.6268168092,
0.4761120081,
-0.8080214858,
-0.3204542398,
-0.408557117,
-0.0536195822,
-0.4603906572,
-0.2481371462,
0.2726319432,
-0.7652415633,
-0.781714499,
0.5370260477,
0.3873423338,
0.1522110254,
-0.2275758833,
-0.4308697283,
-0.2618216574,
0.0200103596,
0.3950410783,
0.6601507068,
-0.8291280866,
-0.5645837784,
-0.0060986038,
0.0154811274,
0.2437408566,
0.5336365104,
-0.9843071699,
0.2983987331,
-0.089389123,
1.0353790522,
0.2616581619,
-0.360450983,
0.5826993585,
-0.7292125225,
-0.0128317373,
0.1955672503,
0.4863742888,
0.2742509842,
-0.1894936562,
0.5130527616,
0.3758567274,
-0.620459497,
-0.5270760059,
0.433973968,
-1.0918132067,
-0.1226608008,
1.1004604101,
-0.4033769667,
-0.0173789598,
-0.2333535999,
0.1012158617,
0.368899852,
-0.3616329134,
0.815939188,
0.6015057564,
0.4291402102,
-0.4043669701,
-0.4477160871,
0.4044346511,
0.6393574476,
-0.6724781394,
0.0049245241,
0.377214551,
0.5060549378,
-0.2521029711,
0.4071858823,
-0.2521077693,
0.3506715894,
-0.3843322396,
-0.0138837034,
-0.2240144759,
-0.7742800117,
-0.4382091463,
-0.1730989665,
0.2685931921,
-0.0599671565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17241v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17241v1
|
What Do the Circuits Mean? A Knowledge Edit View
| 2024-06-25T03:09:53 | 2024-06-25T03:09:53 |
Huaizhi Ge, Frank Rudzicz, Zining Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the field of language model interpretability, circuit discovery is gaining
popularity. Despite this, the true meaning of these circuits remain largely
unanswered. We introduce a novel method to learn their meanings as a holistic
object through the lens of knowledge editing. We extract circuits in the
GPT2-XL model using diverse text classification datasets, and use hierarchical
relations datasets to explore knowledge editing in the circuits. Our findings
indicate that these circuits contain entity knowledge but resist new knowledge
more than complementary circuits during knowledge editing. Additionally, we
examine the impact of circuit size, discovering that an ideal "theoretical
circuit" where essential knowledge is concentrated likely incorporates more
than 5% but less than 50% of the model's parameters. We also assess the overlap
between circuits from different datasets, finding moderate similarities. What
constitutes these circuits, then? We find that up to 60% of the circuits
consist of layer normalization modules rather than attention or MLP modules,
adding evidence to the ongoing debates regarding knowledge localization. In
summary, our findings offer new insights into the functions of the circuits,
and introduce research directions for further interpretability and safety
research of language models.
|
[
-0.242013678,
-0.7690325975,
0.970723331,
-0.4171016812,
-0.0840786248,
0.2203379422,
-0.069706209,
-0.454631269,
-0.0875131935,
0.4821714461,
-0.310007304,
-0.2519313991,
-0.6537154317,
-0.2781736553,
-0.4220369756,
0.9953048229,
-0.2928889692,
-0.3490853608,
-0.0367418975,
0.0748060718,
-0.4069252908,
-0.3753872216,
-0.1516902,
-0.3516931236,
0.7650135756,
0.1837733388,
0.9380113482,
0.806273818,
0.4060764909,
0.2685660422,
-0.447735101,
0.0590255819,
0.0332520902,
-0.1788351238,
-0.4400560558,
-0.5710267425,
-0.4994524121,
0.0360075496,
0.3796068132,
1.0161916018,
0.143443808,
0.0634126738,
-0.1234320253,
0.7168531418,
-0.6155388355,
0.2987175286,
-0.9423266649,
0.0788579434,
-0.2752175927,
-0.0007240944,
-0.5481387973,
-0.0645822436,
0.2152067572,
-0.7381098866,
0.1266057193,
0.2055470347,
0.8319801092,
-0.1229015514,
-0.7049567699,
-0.3115353286,
-0.7851825953,
0.4994220436,
-0.3277332783,
0.4426789582,
0.2015702724,
0.2833870351,
0.128093183,
-1.0006343126,
-0.7234342098,
0.2111370862,
-0.280844003,
-0.0189509932,
-0.399887681,
0.4085644484,
0.4828059077,
0.3505187631,
-0.199386254,
-0.3146935105,
-0.6049588919,
-0.1856123805,
0.2749787569,
-0.0139260693,
0.8151707649,
-0.446189791,
0.0726788566,
0.4014417231,
-0.856859386,
-0.0836448371,
0.4447387457,
0.0468392484,
0.1071314067,
0.5681740046,
-0.0816646442,
0.8220199943,
-0.0589027181,
0.1152969599,
-0.042526681,
-0.169356212,
-0.5215778947,
0.1640923768,
0.5749756098,
0.1816548854,
0.5932688713,
-0.4619599879,
0.0275507085,
-0.2895579934,
0.402657479,
-0.4665547609,
-0.8098802567,
-0.1041979417,
-0.4704980254,
-0.3723810613,
0.0853754953,
-0.3149385452,
-0.2406146824,
-0.6318131089,
0.4797350764,
-0.2778734267,
-0.354087919,
0.2336766273,
-0.2827733755,
-0.0471989214,
0.2161327153,
-1.2578165531,
0.5346065164,
0.4331106544,
0.7113637328,
0.1185222641,
-0.2202675343,
-0.0132451346,
0.2761603594,
-0.2968638837,
0.8180693388,
-0.4770971537,
-0.3737501204,
-0.4545948505,
0.2721385062,
-0.3122660518,
-0.3610459566,
0.368929565,
-1.0303353071,
0.1412215382,
-0.5185039043,
-0.5165518522,
-0.2142136842,
-0.1485583633,
-0.7445512414,
0.8278024793,
0.1432107836,
-1.1958998442,
0.163765654,
-0.5704949498,
-0.7308764458,
-0.2193846107,
0.032843262,
0.0506394878,
0.258770138,
0.028761331,
0.0720483065,
-0.0366224647,
0.2193005234,
-0.2045898885,
-0.0062550418,
0.2858502865,
-0.263063252,
0.7614639997,
0.1152001396,
-0.3513655365,
0.1778875291,
-0.7378838062,
-0.0018573022,
-0.1621675342,
0.1557992697,
-0.5618128777,
0.3135761917,
0.0061337426,
0.4711892307,
-0.0997122824,
-0.6135867238,
0.1394281685,
-0.7705488205,
0.9803818464,
0.8291807771,
0.3087922335,
0.6899685264,
0.0309113469,
0.2836889029,
0.0518512651,
0.2871959805,
-0.1444338858,
-0.7371597886,
-0.762408793,
0.4499231279,
0.3106354177,
0.4955820441,
-0.6444035769,
0.5560141206,
-0.0950204656,
-0.4174782634,
-0.3424363136,
0.1660386175,
0.110722743,
0.7090060711,
0.4884155989,
-0.057940878,
-0.3626401424,
-1.1066571474,
-0.530005753,
-0.2908017635,
-0.1220972463,
0.0912391245,
0.6105676293,
-0.0391108766,
0.9632282853,
-0.7125429511,
0.0199075583,
-0.2584233582,
-0.0867091939,
-0.0568788424,
0.193216756,
0.211167872,
-0.5462653041,
-0.2914486229,
0.4889219105,
-0.8675124049,
0.2538392842,
-0.1866014898,
-0.2666209042,
-0.2941705883,
0.4235584438,
-0.5688146353,
0.498739928,
0.0406465009,
-0.1491396278,
0.3062756062,
-0.2452123314,
0.0167044476,
-0.9056609869,
-0.1877343059,
-0.2262800038,
0.0393519364,
-0.7123895288,
0.0546283498,
0.3592174947,
0.1842542142,
-0.3784690797,
0.565656364,
-0.5767426491,
-0.1385805309,
-0.3447429836,
0.5295052528,
0.3565682173,
0.3507053852,
-0.0473060384,
0.4956254065,
0.443256259,
-0.3665601015,
0.4318170547,
0.2907985747,
-0.6492177844,
0.2282836586,
-0.6755105257,
0.3369495571,
0.0447852537,
-0.2177201509,
-0.6823812723,
-0.4312704504,
0.0126378415,
-0.196162194,
0.0655834824,
-0.0243428685,
-0.7791194916,
-0.2418604642,
0.045189254,
0.5474972725,
0.3890252113,
-0.5318774581,
0.5925931931,
0.8107833266,
-0.1732494533,
-0.122621581,
-0.8009855747,
0.0965415016,
0.054389406,
-0.7009081841,
0.2981730402,
0.2553974986,
-0.5544131994,
0.1912944317,
-0.0915210322,
-0.2960963249,
0.2655380368,
0.2835570574,
0.3629790246,
-0.0580329821,
0.7058178782,
0.677649498,
0.0112840757,
0.4413683712,
-0.4896499515,
0.0070434706,
-0.007076168,
-0.3288970292,
-0.5287304521,
0.0993721038,
0.4050372243,
-0.3701951802,
0.4911360443,
-0.0122143822,
-0.6843631268,
-0.020035753,
-0.1478530914,
0.1309117377,
-0.4860794544,
0.3374072909,
-0.4800280035,
-0.9244624376,
0.4208281934,
-0.0478298552,
-0.2251624167,
0.7669936419,
0.4011918008,
0.0268987473,
1.0059562922,
0.5340949893,
-0.0201182738,
0.2011518925,
0.0669929907,
0.7461754084,
-1.0295858383,
-0.392814219,
-0.3286649585,
-0.2852039933,
-0.5169574618,
-0.285929352,
0.2858431935,
0.2494050264,
-0.3874941468,
0.3002615869,
-0.5553426147,
0.7941845059,
0.289003849,
0.3249785304,
0.5315486193,
0.0249140169,
-0.1859432459,
-0.1912282705,
-0.7011771202,
-0.5210974216,
1.1462560892,
0.325335443,
0.6062759161,
-0.004389551,
0.1873723119,
0.1376387626,
0.3801112175,
-0.8157681823,
0.1836066246,
0.1811365783,
-0.7901438475,
-0.0839607269,
-0.2455011755,
-0.5966740847,
-0.1096752435,
0.0588845275,
-0.9815238714,
0.2076127827,
0.1516032666,
-0.3485043943,
0.8707224131,
-0.8518089056,
0.9607242346,
-0.3474705815,
-0.2014443725,
-0.131897226,
-0.7427236438,
0.5151093602,
0.1006969064,
0.6046570539,
0.3384860754,
0.3218719959,
0.7415628433,
-0.2940000892,
0.6522396207,
0.0367805175,
-0.1533038318,
0.5550045371,
0.2173349708,
0.320358187,
0.0411551483,
0.1387302279,
-0.0702625215,
0.0455817431,
-0.287907064,
-0.8398272991,
0.7097170353,
-0.7857989073,
-0.5402287841,
-0.1382942349,
-0.6296688914,
-0.3014053404,
0.4212574065,
0.2839781642,
0.5489335656,
-0.0978563577,
-0.1427289546,
0.9852045774,
-0.294886291,
0.0858526751,
-0.0522642806,
-0.4481505156,
-0.1557549685,
0.9267352223,
0.2043411136,
0.5522420406,
0.6235902905,
-0.0783094168,
-0.2090943158,
-0.3520533741,
-0.4598973989,
0.0200501475,
-1.0199875832,
0.2128903717,
-0.9689360261,
-0.4164811075,
-0.1305640638,
-0.036669638,
-0.1143933833,
-0.801903069,
-0.192563355,
-0.6646862626,
0.2533687651,
1.0755479336,
0.1640932113,
0.4183189869,
-0.6621333361,
0.3403830826,
0.6557885408,
0.4747075737,
0.106190674,
-0.4851478934,
-0.4527496994,
-0.1645985991,
-0.4506586194,
-1.1592583656,
-0.0497636944,
-0.093738772,
0.3812490702,
0.2707011104,
-0.2319300473,
0.5028364658,
-0.6210465431,
0.7256086469,
0.067830503,
-1.4730596542,
0.8566852808,
-0.172806859,
0.20430924,
0.2569791377,
-0.0060653114,
-0.6264818907,
-0.3911904991,
-0.8060246706,
-0.6318417788,
0.5044434071,
0.2753560841,
0.3244131207,
-0.1741445363,
0.6201879382,
-0.1907080263,
0.1984637976,
-0.7539104819,
-0.3696719706,
-0.2815583348,
-0.2019360214,
0.3988905251,
-0.2789354324,
-0.1608949304,
-0.4642961323,
0.4499310851,
0.0741184726,
0.2700561881,
0.0577063635,
-0.315323174,
-0.2248944342,
0.5405293107,
0.2658705413,
0.8352683187,
-0.0456894375,
0.6275792122,
0.1227313504,
-0.4599714577,
0.0252020769,
-0.2182032764,
-0.3336064517,
-0.0320715867,
0.5873936415,
0.940105319,
0.3485443294,
-0.4481682181,
0.2014787644,
0.0530039221,
-0.1905634701,
0.1827422678,
0.1902693808,
0.2247492522,
-0.0386336781,
-0.0648179352,
0.4711853266,
0.5400534272,
-0.6381642818,
0.2911168933,
0.1307590008,
-0.78207165,
-0.7092115879,
0.727830708,
0.1534772664,
-0.1159809753,
0.573533237,
-0.1902207136,
-0.6254988909,
0.6884668469,
0.045768287,
0.9205228686,
0.0645636916,
0.3154419661,
0.3920994997,
0.7895986438,
0.0509762503,
-0.1532079428,
-0.1225069314,
-0.8488480449,
-0.4101523161,
-0.407466799,
-0.2822631299,
0.0137634184,
-0.9551706314,
0.1100461558,
-0.5648958683,
0.114079833,
0.3476146758,
-0.3774221539,
-0.42309618,
0.3671192229,
-0.2600759268,
1.0769616365,
-0.7885747552,
1.2415112257,
0.6026419401,
-0.1620304585,
-1.0428581238,
0.0972266421,
-0.0583572835,
-0.4302171767,
0.7678542733,
-0.0350872613,
0.0485624224,
0.0331561752,
-0.2566174269,
-0.6175710559,
0.8897775412,
0.2177775204,
-0.6086530685,
-0.3338491917,
0.0027471276,
0.5169135928,
-0.1955766976,
0.310700804,
0.9076177478,
0.4451484978,
-0.2666452825,
-0.7139057517,
-0.0650504231,
-0.3937960267,
-0.0137131447,
0.4032700062,
-0.1905268431,
0.8399958611,
-0.3589039445,
-0.1871718168,
-0.1696625203,
0.2987380624,
-0.1323994696,
0.2700304389,
0.2248082906,
0.2912165523,
0.8094681501,
-0.1515066475,
1.1387680769,
-0.4582488835,
0.5645937324,
1.3335715532,
-0.1985114515,
0.5286742449,
0.5529742241,
-0.3888444304,
0.7181079388,
0.6520721316,
0.251044184,
0.6015217304,
0.2547513545,
-0.2947912216,
-0.4215810597,
0.213640362,
-0.1994352788,
-0.0528801791,
0.2543136775,
-0.6432634592,
-0.1693203449,
0.0784684345,
0.0080034006,
0.1553571522,
-0.3678588271,
0.5786207914,
0.1707465947,
-0.3663143516,
-0.1397078484,
0.1268209666,
-0.1710651368,
-0.194858402,
0.0128824143,
0.0466209911,
0.072404176,
-0.28547436,
-1.1111072302,
0.5999975204,
0.0090377266,
-0.5873514414,
-0.1969414353,
0.8927702904,
-0.0248769429,
-0.7180354595,
0.4121320844,
0.464104861,
-0.2188707143,
-0.2525423765,
-0.4150648117,
-0.2332618386,
0.038118735,
-0.2023586631,
0.320091933,
0.7762253284,
-0.1268957704,
0.3720642626,
0.1909746379,
0.1492292434,
0.1432248056,
-0.0943000019,
1.0142045021,
-0.7242851853,
-0.2717280984,
-0.7662730217,
0.6344272494,
-0.0298413578,
-0.345622927,
0.5375737548,
0.5089919567,
0.9539647102,
0.0330956727,
1.2147376537,
-0.1125907823,
0.3108665645,
-0.6770019531,
0.6890330315,
-0.2622589171,
0.6157409549,
-0.21186997,
-0.5870547295,
-0.2893003821,
0.5494840741,
-0.735311687,
-0.0541412719,
0.9204455614,
0.5785495043,
-0.2542142868,
0.4184180796,
0.2410177588,
0.5157955289,
0.2679049075,
0.5803578496,
0.8364337087,
-0.7694798708,
0.2456284463,
-0.4719138741,
-0.1624845415,
0.4424169362,
-0.374612689,
-0.982853651,
-0.5730933547,
-0.2308333218,
-0.230733335,
0.0848651752,
0.4639357924,
0.4285396636,
-0.8194264174,
-0.1439408809,
-0.5894134641,
0.7379978299,
-0.0415903777,
-0.1917576939,
0.6117992997,
-0.3239884675,
-0.3836324215,
0.0862745494,
0.7111715078,
-0.3500036895,
-0.0535696335,
0.1101304293,
-0.0794780403,
0.0612917021,
0.8336529136,
0.0447377786,
-0.8725882769,
-0.6266438365,
0.2695863545,
0.1301899701,
-0.0455465391,
0.9327812791,
-0.6349765658,
0.8256092668,
0.2630095184,
0.4252402782,
0.314746052,
-0.4281325936,
0.4372524917,
-0.5391160846,
0.0634503365,
-0.2344076484,
0.4332953393,
0.1398826241,
-0.3254028857,
0.2179261148,
0.6279703379,
-0.5184988976,
-0.689925909,
0.5101285577,
-0.9988616705,
-0.2430787385,
0.9523926377,
-0.1285843104,
-0.2154835463,
-0.3478380144,
-0.3010670841,
0.1928257346,
0.1927249432,
0.8353516459,
0.8291406035,
-0.2634473145,
-0.3685465753,
-0.8569014668,
0.5110679865,
-0.0309764314,
-1.0591007471,
0.0908013359,
0.2845309973,
0.4623329043,
0.2034665495,
0.2843401432,
-0.1810874641,
0.3742161691,
-0.1648774892,
0.0646790788,
0.1334640682,
-0.4294599593,
0.0394004397,
0.1990574747,
0.1516133547,
0.287699759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17233v1
|
Self-Constructed Context Decompilation with Fined-grained Alignment Enhancement
| 2024-06-25T02:37:53 | 2024-06-25T02:37:53 |
Yunlong Feng, Yang Xu, Dechuan Teng, Honglin Mu, Xiao Xu, Libo Qin, Wanxiang Che, Qingfu Zhu
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Decompilation transforms compiled code back into a high-level programming
language for analysis when source code is unavailable. Previous work has
primarily focused on enhancing decompilation performance by increasing the
scale of model parameters or training data for pre-training. Based on the
characteristics of the decompilation task, we propose two methods: (1) Without
fine-tuning, the Self-Constructed Context Decompilation (sc$^2$dec) method
recompiles the LLM's decompilation results to construct pairs for in-context
learning, helping the model improve decompilation performance. (2) Fine-grained
Alignment Enhancement (FAE), which meticulously aligns assembly code with
source code at the statement level by leveraging debugging information, is
employed during the fine-tuning phase to achieve further improvements in
decompilation. By integrating these two methods, we achieved a Re-Executability
performance improvement of approximately 7.35\% on the Decompile-Eval
benchmark, establishing a new state-of-the-art performance of 55.03\%.
|
[
-0.3678283989,
-0.748950839,
0.306951791,
0.0967453271,
-0.2621460557,
0.131489411,
-0.170934245,
-0.5284221172,
0.0359450802,
0.6546640396,
-0.4060225487,
-0.4053671062,
-0.2139657885,
0.0296450872,
-0.4304434657,
0.7363244891,
-0.1148676723,
-0.2496827692,
-0.3542802036,
0.0575887039,
-0.3776237071,
-0.5595209599,
-0.2996892333,
0.051926747,
-0.079908587,
0.5369932055,
0.4401701093,
1.2419297695,
0.7370904088,
0.3889501691,
0.0277159959,
0.1018023565,
-0.6963207722,
0.0926582739,
-0.2205548584,
-0.036559578,
-0.8207871914,
-0.1723197699,
0.6322495341,
0.37498492,
-0.0567777827,
0.3714923561,
0.4188052714,
1.0229194164,
-0.9893910885,
0.0730329305,
-0.4390497804,
0.0004887679,
-0.1472573876,
-0.5255032778,
-0.4715899229,
-0.1574592441,
-0.3967003524,
-0.4099509418,
0.3396622241,
-0.1831180602,
0.7016621828,
0.7934110761,
-0.3424378633,
-0.0224014763,
-0.6276674271,
0.7843390703,
-0.7722399235,
0.5958570838,
0.195272103,
0.0645756274,
-0.2630241513,
-0.8287088871,
-0.0994069204,
0.1536718905,
-0.1764552742,
-0.0442997441,
-0.0860781074,
0.3650813699,
0.1483639628,
0.7226330042,
-0.4578169882,
0.1536609083,
-0.4530602694,
-0.4410681725,
0.7818353772,
0.183317706,
0.2319159508,
-0.1993413568,
-0.7061881423,
-0.0196049735,
-0.7213699222,
-0.1636511385,
0.2101200223,
0.1760664433,
-0.0033268419,
0.4112899303,
-0.3767527938,
0.5364331007,
0.1992067099,
-0.0909923092,
0.4050697386,
-0.5366723537,
-0.5648097992,
0.2139457911,
0.4190939367,
0.3774391115,
-0.2558774352,
-0.1586187333,
-0.3992298841,
-0.0604368784,
0.5257113576,
-1.0785186291,
-0.3748018444,
0.3715192378,
-0.6912397146,
-0.1884829402,
-0.1471135467,
-0.6303984523,
0.1575225145,
-0.5896817446,
0.3394231498,
-0.3687689006,
-0.0955196023,
-0.0181514155,
-0.0342306681,
0.4513347149,
0.2406868339,
-0.8126247525,
0.0960193872,
0.8193140626,
0.5257239342,
-0.2749814093,
-0.1877570748,
-0.7488987446,
0.2441741675,
-0.4861066937,
0.7580612302,
-0.3819981217,
-0.3680358529,
-0.3232388794,
0.1053462029,
0.1764757633,
-0.7307314873,
0.4659437239,
-0.516486764,
-0.0950898379,
-0.2346240431,
-0.8046647906,
-0.0980507806,
0.2517100275,
-0.3829598129,
1.0940639973,
0.3352201879,
-0.5407904983,
0.0548316129,
-0.5450482368,
-0.362311542,
-0.1600227952,
-0.1719591171,
-0.1668955535,
0.3094934821,
0.1531386226,
0.4261224866,
0.009445237,
0.319129467,
-0.3177788854,
-0.5466225743,
-0.2670823038,
-0.4214368165,
0.6709691286,
0.5690282583,
-0.3536254466,
0.1158602834,
-0.9887740016,
0.2342686504,
-0.118805021,
-0.6176355481,
-0.2625892162,
-0.0584000871,
-0.2803408802,
0.1862572134,
0.6989155412,
-0.4282683134,
0.1721570939,
-0.77770257,
0.1041133851,
0.7879152894,
0.0664657503,
0.638594687,
-0.0733507946,
0.4051711559,
-0.2439082861,
-0.1076249182,
-0.1927517951,
0.1797482222,
-0.752614975,
-0.3270541131,
0.1098967791,
0.4662374556,
-0.3896632791,
0.5707059503,
-0.0788666233,
-0.199991107,
-0.3228109777,
0.3559572101,
0.9656538963,
0.7791986465,
0.6244431734,
-0.2026299536,
-0.7151401639,
-1.0900496244,
-0.1141014025,
0.1589403003,
-0.0708874092,
0.009401706,
0.2181319445,
-0.4613001645,
0.8448663354,
-0.656527698,
-0.0291507579,
-0.015408651,
0.0400117524,
-0.3892599046,
0.9364686608,
0.4539399445,
-0.4799540937,
-0.3046228886,
-0.0338337906,
-0.6022292376,
-0.3653416038,
0.1487240642,
-0.3666289747,
0.4785924852,
0.9355245233,
0.2438536435,
0.5296000242,
0.6860983372,
-0.2763769329,
0.7367592454,
-0.3392000794,
0.22897695,
-1.2363848686,
0.0987883657,
-0.4457799196,
-0.2105009258,
-0.471226573,
0.4781100452,
0.3304382265,
-0.1219159141,
-0.5866912007,
0.4685782492,
-0.6343384981,
-0.4918352664,
-0.5557377934,
0.0809655488,
0.2589142025,
0.5595704317,
0.0467043221,
0.976708591,
0.3586747348,
-0.6416392326,
-0.1068188995,
0.1823100746,
-0.307271868,
0.288769722,
-0.5143079162,
0.1873808801,
-0.1028821021,
0.005853768,
-1.1297670603,
-0.3319085538,
0.0133663369,
-0.1085683405,
0.6033299565,
-0.1208754778,
-0.0287715122,
0.0695278645,
-0.3434574902,
0.5978060961,
0.2636326849,
-0.8014016151,
0.3871980608,
0.2162383497,
-0.0384975113,
-0.6385420561,
-0.8006288409,
-0.18961896,
-0.1776151955,
-0.5637546182,
0.7106139064,
-0.3571077883,
-0.1992862821,
-0.1234269142,
-0.5045726895,
-0.1599443555,
0.2779598236,
0.1124422178,
0.2092980295,
-0.3739068806,
0.0677755103,
0.4657699466,
-0.3700891435,
0.0994515941,
0.1654248983,
0.4472073615,
-0.2416483313,
-0.2671865523,
-0.5079228282,
0.4211314023,
0.4002687931,
-0.3332428038,
0.356533587,
0.5851917863,
-0.2867230773,
-0.0380326584,
-0.493555516,
-0.0791166648,
-0.5735576749,
0.3185599744,
-0.5386637449,
-0.8395947218,
0.599006176,
-0.2190632969,
0.0743418634,
0.2800340652,
0.2312312573,
-0.0188774597,
0.8214627504,
0.5752203465,
0.0636138469,
0.5597351789,
-0.4063560069,
0.12506634,
-1.2196811438,
0.009897138,
-0.616951108,
-0.4190386832,
-0.4836955667,
-0.3569277823,
0.0548325852,
0.4497106373,
-0.4158229232,
0.577842772,
-0.7737805843,
0.642419517,
0.3480605185,
0.1662353724,
0.252081424,
-0.1594407558,
0.1613393724,
0.0666436255,
-0.4544782937,
-0.3932436407,
0.7029038072,
0.2165374756,
0.6775105596,
0.0530058071,
1.3025791645,
0.2242202759,
0.0561932772,
-0.7738339305,
0.4749279916,
-0.1168285608,
-0.4246637821,
-0.3444007039,
-0.4330117702,
-0.784422636,
0.2706686258,
0.195585683,
-0.8207272887,
0.4377460182,
0.2454483956,
-0.5018997788,
-0.1169578508,
-0.8831486702,
1.0958306789,
-0.0875330195,
-0.2582533956,
-0.2703838944,
-0.6389474273,
0.4548321068,
-0.0477585122,
0.176237762,
-0.0875895768,
-0.123362273,
0.7077289224,
-0.5213452578,
0.6155416965,
-0.0350516923,
-0.5529062748,
0.3083843589,
0.4582657218,
0.5963299274,
-0.0766442791,
-0.1709596366,
0.1621393561,
0.2556352019,
-0.4248666763,
-0.7128605247,
0.8139282465,
-0.4370892644,
-0.70674932,
0.0972694457,
-0.4539243579,
0.012675846,
0.323479712,
0.2811850905,
0.8679405451,
-0.1236210838,
0.4287921786,
0.3189336061,
-0.1103579924,
0.7907479405,
0.3648412824,
-0.0325689167,
-0.4016511142,
0.7892499566,
-0.0976183042,
0.4456564188,
0.5880101919,
0.2059221715,
-0.2746454179,
-0.4449646175,
-0.1689694971,
-0.1789382845,
-0.7353235483,
-0.6298000216,
-0.5021036267,
-0.2435526848,
-0.4902975559,
-0.7049279213,
-0.8133523464,
-0.3101902604,
-0.3989595771,
-0.0907175317,
-0.19290784,
0.3180472255,
-0.1721686572,
0.1979932636,
-1.0788921118,
0.4310416281,
0.0481795482,
0.2796474397,
-0.1181811094,
-0.6118853688,
-0.3188378513,
0.130812183,
-0.3370127082,
-0.654867053,
0.3338298202,
0.1045613885,
0.3993741572,
0.4983956218,
0.3881731331,
1.1147134304,
-0.25586918,
0.6404227018,
-0.1849169284,
-1.1050256491,
0.6380682588,
-0.1630345732,
0.3688980639,
0.6908245087,
-0.07657893,
0.2179843932,
-0.2903843522,
-0.4416515529,
-0.8960076571,
0.7323701978,
-0.0038449666,
-0.0109545765,
-0.2213831097,
0.3636265695,
0.0253798626,
-0.0294109583,
-0.3840184808,
-0.0940025374,
0.0851791948,
-0.0218633395,
0.0002865119,
-0.6316199899,
-0.0180447176,
-0.4508385062,
0.6228771806,
-0.3253079057,
0.4086123109,
0.3786525726,
-0.2351949513,
-0.0425412953,
0.2805898786,
0.6084062457,
0.7185492516,
-0.3640660942,
0.1719773263,
0.1148720011,
-0.2483808547,
0.1665881127,
-0.1654963642,
0.1224514395,
-0.5787034631,
0.3389870226,
0.4148787558,
0.5650777817,
-0.4966082573,
0.2384728044,
0.1785837561,
-0.0135368304,
-0.0934686512,
0.3129416406,
-0.1131515652,
0.3123799562,
0.2153789699,
0.0781917647,
0.5030972958,
-0.4955643415,
0.5488668084,
0.4005982876,
-0.0377614014,
-0.044099953,
0.5438527465,
0.2870374024,
-0.1782908291,
0.6419448256,
-0.3328216076,
-0.2952976227,
0.7245216966,
0.8665309548,
1.0204924345,
-0.3013132215,
-0.0452920943,
0.5623263121,
0.0421228297,
0.0794855282,
0.1709443778,
-0.5573461056,
-0.7601228952,
-0.6386921406,
-0.8203923702,
0.0084275212,
-0.0618259385,
-0.8930624127,
0.0958073288,
-0.2266992182,
0.3700648248,
-0.4289583564,
0.0305654295,
-0.3233619928,
0.3142180145,
-0.2014424801,
0.8244761825,
-0.5108833313,
0.8310236335,
0.4036078751,
-0.1791727096,
-0.8123853207,
0.2435091287,
0.0051363818,
-0.5120846629,
0.4831785858,
0.3381145597,
-0.3108290434,
0.2786195874,
-0.3634462655,
-1.2871774435,
1.1464408636,
0.6570420861,
-0.6004446149,
0.0564894006,
-0.274374038,
0.4340405762,
-0.2795135677,
-0.0282464605,
0.8643532395,
0.3555256426,
0.1513889432,
-0.7919576168,
0.2640422583,
-0.0911255181,
0.0889499485,
0.4571958482,
-0.6437073946,
0.4338999093,
-0.1703792363,
-0.5741091967,
0.0453442931,
0.8560135961,
-0.0166941881,
0.2978735268,
0.1778784841,
0.6123985052,
0.5964249969,
0.111853756,
0.908408463,
-0.7823653221,
0.4729650021,
1.4186058044,
-0.0093295816,
0.9479922652,
0.5053275824,
-0.0447155051,
0.5359206796,
0.5138594508,
0.4940153658,
0.5419551134,
-0.2654181421,
-0.0111031877,
-0.2655800283,
0.2963228524,
-0.4432036579,
0.8308542371,
0.2922652364,
-0.3547829688,
-0.4761972725,
-0.1433223784,
-0.0928649604,
0.1544004232,
-0.1699739099,
0.8453620672,
-0.1730161309,
-0.5528129935,
0.9727216959,
-0.0579673238,
0.5012560487,
-0.2105616629,
-0.1155956239,
-0.5017700791,
0.2391325086,
-0.4489129186,
-0.5831340551,
0.9829591513,
-0.2768198252,
-0.1407970488,
-0.2612268329,
0.8632631302,
-0.374289304,
-0.1650719941,
0.3263333142,
0.1200862527,
0.289700985,
-0.0893979073,
-0.4836259484,
0.3454326689,
0.1970704645,
-0.4212088883,
0.530651927,
0.1088598594,
0.2239110768,
0.5901634097,
0.465383023,
-0.436063081,
-0.0572348163,
-0.2961249948,
0.9452171326,
-0.6818386912,
-0.3714376092,
-0.8035411835,
0.6670289636,
0.1868389249,
-0.0554372072,
0.8149610162,
0.9318048358,
1.0009390116,
-0.1127028316,
0.3048283458,
-0.236166954,
0.1470755786,
-0.7358565331,
0.2693575621,
-0.7720504403,
0.3994414508,
-0.3898415267,
-1.0596290827,
-0.1764779985,
0.5038042068,
-0.1832925975,
0.0063408655,
0.6409785151,
1.0172313452,
-0.1515119821,
-0.3340096176,
0.4101406038,
-0.0657444149,
0.2095604837,
0.3633283973,
0.3265051246,
-0.4595830739,
0.3027696013,
-0.5537044406,
-0.2016460001,
-0.3912671804,
-1.0040103197,
-0.4516168237,
-0.6639236212,
-0.4398139417,
-0.3463795781,
-0.1717687845,
0.7462704778,
0.6875735521,
-0.6558337808,
-0.0354695693,
-0.2409916669,
-0.0037299891,
-0.2394467145,
-0.3740324676,
0.509236753,
-0.7339867949,
-0.7136257887,
0.9891290069,
0.4677791297,
-0.0307084341,
-0.2099019289,
-0.1963910013,
0.0937063918,
-0.0597993992,
0.7482907772,
0.363514781,
-0.5451901555,
-0.4745348394,
-0.1084703654,
-0.1222531274,
0.35580042,
0.6547476053,
-0.6840468049,
0.5189866424,
0.9017144442,
0.7950770855,
0.3700938821,
0.7406167388,
0.4882031679,
-1.0191597939,
0.1955737323,
0.0133704944,
0.3935546875,
-0.0523526371,
-0.8131589293,
0.6430565119,
-0.120996356,
-0.781129241,
-0.7109647989,
0.232659936,
-0.9127768278,
-0.3615113497,
1.0678167343,
-0.0873947144,
-0.5105593801,
0.1240404546,
-0.3451119363,
0.3279227316,
-0.2782584131,
0.7974204421,
0.3543516695,
-0.4771472216,
0.0181633141,
-0.0023394779,
0.4973038435,
0.2456380576,
-0.8282566071,
0.370873332,
0.8669956326,
0.4190716445,
0.2182734162,
0.5779342055,
-0.3439336717,
0.2228349298,
0.0911751464,
0.3280952275,
-0.2720413506,
-0.463334769,
-0.4784533381,
0.1579419672,
-0.1556370109,
-0.5181452036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17232v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17232v1
|
Beyond Demographics: Aligning Role-playing LLM-based Agents Using Human Belief Networks
| 2024-06-25T02:37:29 | 2024-06-25T02:37:29 |
Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Zach Studdiford, Krirk Nirunwiroj, Agam Goyal, Vincent V. Frigo, Sijia Yang, Dhavan Shah, Junjie Hu, Timothy T. Rogers
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Creating human-like large language model (LLM) agents is crucial for faithful
social simulation. Having LLMs role-play based on demographic information
sometimes improves human likeness but often does not. This study assessed
whether LLM alignment with human behavior can be improved by integrating
information from empirically-derived human belief networks. Using data from a
human survey, we estimated a belief network encompassing 18 topics loading on
two non-overlapping latent factors. We then seeded LLM-based agents with an
opinion on one topic, and assessed the alignment of its expressed opinions on
remaining test topics with corresponding human data. Role-playing based on
demographic information alone did not align LLM and human opinions, but seeding
the agent with a single belief greatly improved alignment for topics related in
the belief network, and not for topics outside the network. These results
suggest a novel path for human-LLM belief alignment in work seeking to simulate
and understand patterns of belief distributions in society.
|
[
-0.3938154578,
-0.363807559,
0.5656949282,
0.2150020301,
0.1138036624,
0.4149583876,
-0.1777390838,
-0.3535203636,
0.4860310853,
0.5684918761,
-0.5135481358,
-0.3076202869,
-0.2044815719,
-0.0194547512,
0.2427020818,
0.4841601849,
0.2386027575,
0.1457568258,
-0.5484701991,
0.2305752933,
-0.3987929523,
-0.5188643336,
-0.7641435862,
-0.8610041738,
0.6629576683,
0.2344704419,
0.9745103121,
0.7158577442,
0.2395594269,
0.3364785016,
0.1824145019,
0.5922535658,
-0.6044304967,
0.1236986667,
-0.4264988303,
-0.664534688,
-0.6574314833,
0.2817957699,
0.6956333518,
0.7092450261,
-0.3017209172,
-0.031489186,
0.2303473204,
0.3025632799,
-0.1752374619,
0.1296748668,
-0.4897202551,
0.0591505691,
-0.0412358083,
-0.4981386364,
-0.3750364184,
-0.4295795262,
0.1135701984,
-0.6326729655,
0.3236151636,
0.1659659296,
0.6428131461,
0.0627561435,
-0.7204183936,
0.1192003265,
-0.7737535238,
0.7497696877,
-0.721824944,
0.1284784526,
0.4561370313,
0.141790837,
-0.715015173,
0.1350456029,
-0.6215921044,
0.0430774391,
0.0646789521,
0.0090377554,
0.2084828168,
0.1417481899,
0.1956300586,
-0.40177086,
-0.5267491341,
0.3162316084,
-0.2136068493,
-0.1655244529,
0.9977993965,
0.3514561057,
0.3702178001,
-0.0829626471,
-0.1793623716,
-0.2687250674,
-0.863746047,
0.1935375929,
0.642924428,
0.5664188862,
-0.1390607059,
0.6656227708,
0.0053122966,
0.3623501062,
0.3249075413,
-0.3422042429,
0.2683824599,
0.1174132153,
-0.0212060846,
0.359896034,
0.5779742002,
0.7114337683,
0.6040171385,
-0.1258182824,
0.0332530029,
0.3556288183,
0.5134117007,
-0.6014816165,
0.1793491393,
-0.1222622618,
-0.6513577104,
-0.5781966448,
0.3245404065,
-0.7088556886,
-1.0656144619,
-0.4491964877,
0.1241806149,
-0.2865659595,
-0.5057861209,
-0.1425494254,
-0.1627821773,
0.3651620448,
0.6806859374,
-0.9066372514,
0.3410957754,
0.937353611,
0.6170876622,
-0.2719789743,
-0.2389347553,
-0.170841977,
0.2899300754,
-0.6766112447,
0.5223099589,
-0.7196928859,
-0.2653723955,
-0.0027170654,
0.0395746864,
-0.1252424419,
-0.5747616887,
0.0608873293,
-0.7381010056,
-0.0457349978,
-0.4681410789,
-0.7535521984,
0.2067191154,
0.420589447,
-0.4443758428,
0.8641628027,
-0.439507395,
-0.5213885903,
0.5213961005,
-0.5695987344,
-0.0820261762,
-0.0346551798,
-0.5556793213,
-0.0049782908,
0.1189419031,
-0.1056353003,
0.4078004956,
-0.32821697,
0.3322772384,
-0.7052285075,
-0.4820381105,
0.6374985576,
-0.5407006145,
0.682480216,
0.1128129363,
-0.3654366732,
0.0356172472,
-0.1839272082,
-0.1980981231,
0.0447345152,
-0.0735320076,
-0.2900740504,
0.4189388454,
-0.4987844527,
0.3048655391,
0.0860359594,
-0.6228660941,
0.5299168229,
-0.4223278761,
0.0871592537,
0.9759141207,
0.0130066127,
0.7974621654,
-0.8059214354,
0.6036230326,
-0.096244283,
0.0460704751,
0.3236937523,
-0.7027320266,
-0.306699872,
0.0723075792,
0.0312223528,
0.5096411109,
-0.5153891444,
0.5640910268,
-0.3791915476,
-0.3850498497,
-0.2551797032,
0.1176214591,
0.1099910587,
0.3975502253,
0.046216622,
-0.2618850172,
-0.5880332589,
-0.8154109716,
-0.1437505782,
-0.7548378706,
0.0003146015,
0.3979739547,
0.2976563573,
-0.2449267805,
1.204788208,
-0.4243965745,
-0.1152475998,
0.0232512318,
0.025012508,
0.1090906635,
0.4332795739,
0.3288360834,
-0.8171213269,
-0.4316197634,
0.1979904026,
-0.8022963405,
-0.0534878559,
-0.1023724452,
-0.3026414514,
0.0924163163,
0.3077652156,
-0.6401132345,
0.5303797722,
0.4326715171,
-0.4384503663,
0.3831138015,
-0.2013528794,
0.294919908,
-1.3636226654,
-0.2787560523,
0.3810360134,
-0.3157410622,
-0.4956542552,
-0.3387363255,
-0.1426968426,
0.0845952109,
-0.20269081,
0.580081284,
-0.4278891087,
-0.2571433187,
-0.3309615254,
0.1901069731,
-0.0783849284,
0.1324735135,
0.0965854153,
0.9754548669,
0.3096745908,
-0.3246750832,
0.2896238565,
0.2743946016,
-0.1216204688,
0.6104251742,
-0.3945336342,
0.1238821968,
-0.5489653945,
0.4933925271,
-0.9521820545,
-0.4324973524,
0.2037394196,
-0.3463321626,
0.2305316031,
-0.3591812551,
-0.4051603377,
-0.1130494699,
-0.1563579291,
0.2481921166,
0.7127293944,
-0.1842853129,
0.7995854616,
0.40566203,
-0.1558475494,
-0.662977159,
-0.4437741041,
0.3187549412,
-0.6064366698,
-0.7994127274,
0.6243870854,
0.1569457203,
-0.5283972621,
-0.0299871955,
-0.0094148936,
0.158143118,
-0.0559727363,
0.4011996984,
0.3663654625,
-0.2703851163,
0.4244322479,
-0.1321152896,
0.1581877023,
0.0112521984,
-0.3915801644,
0.5604382753,
0.1709427238,
-0.4868634045,
-0.3106530607,
0.2056902945,
0.3608359694,
0.1071359366,
0.8834763169,
0.1096927524,
-0.3757417798,
-0.1388871074,
-0.7381129861,
-0.1992910802,
-0.5199660659,
0.1555486023,
0.0923375562,
-0.9145379663,
0.5129818916,
-0.2453309745,
0.0222224891,
0.1394485384,
0.3924492598,
-0.7322910428,
1.0312811136,
0.3872424364,
0.2071143836,
0.4761944115,
0.1265939027,
-0.170726344,
-0.7237682939,
-0.237430498,
-0.1842694879,
-0.5035740137,
-0.6022627354,
-0.9179894924,
0.1456276625,
-0.0972196013,
-0.5639204383,
0.1469042152,
-0.1324160844,
0.2767396271,
-0.042385865,
0.2972967923,
-0.1097962335,
0.1923360974,
-0.1784836054,
-0.1711801142,
-0.4053308666,
-1.0347993374,
1.0183320045,
0.3512528539,
0.8471472263,
0.398619324,
0.9696654677,
0.6359559298,
0.651684761,
-0.43134287,
0.5477220416,
-0.1068135127,
-0.7660009861,
-0.5926672816,
-0.5439063907,
-0.973849237,
0.3923852444,
-0.4910354614,
-1.0594213009,
0.5446497798,
0.2963149846,
-0.2574161291,
0.2341833115,
-0.4529366493,
0.6789249778,
-0.2662546635,
-0.2943672538,
-0.2537361085,
-0.6408669949,
0.095435217,
-0.107831873,
0.1764968187,
-0.3491359949,
-0.0526202172,
0.6391320825,
-0.516982317,
1.558475852,
-0.3674212098,
-0.3908603191,
0.2755117416,
-0.113283895,
0.604981482,
-0.108828254,
-0.4992333055,
-0.1240229979,
-0.1340341866,
-0.3383971155,
-1.0471490622,
0.5528436899,
-1.1895809174,
-1.0152540207,
-0.2384715825,
-0.5035729408,
-0.3781251609,
-0.0553741083,
-0.2782350183,
0.2568988502,
-0.5825102329,
0.19646433,
0.8511176109,
-0.0887078345,
0.0256990883,
0.1280548871,
-0.2826450765,
-0.2809469104,
0.6487895846,
0.1195066571,
0.4132313132,
0.4098798633,
0.2851999104,
-0.4736314118,
-0.0193686225,
-0.1221841574,
0.2928681374,
-0.4625041187,
-0.0707964972,
-0.5848611593,
-0.0094349664,
-0.5188026428,
-0.10261406,
-0.2012661397,
-0.0807115734,
-0.2676932812,
-0.1199498475,
0.2342589647,
0.6138125658,
0.0186115094,
0.5619007945,
-0.5853213668,
0.1943827718,
0.3911884129,
0.1659402698,
0.1630153358,
-0.3875179589,
0.0179491621,
0.6549162865,
-0.1429447532,
-1.1096343994,
0.1462458372,
0.0714929476,
0.6199455857,
0.6867477298,
0.0522979125,
0.9907960892,
-0.476455152,
0.634775281,
0.3134940565,
-0.6321824193,
0.1835637391,
-0.4347114861,
-0.3293897212,
0.368863374,
0.173729524,
-0.7042322159,
-0.072223343,
-0.4022713304,
-0.2773013115,
0.8094356656,
0.3331460059,
0.3469170332,
-0.0442804135,
0.5205075741,
-0.0923168808,
0.0701470524,
-0.3074358106,
-0.1868246049,
-0.2146603167,
-0.3881983459,
-0.3159581423,
0.0494208708,
-0.3389346004,
-0.1072437093,
0.4863830209,
-0.3310030699,
0.190626055,
0.1140051186,
0.1680224389,
-0.4482837319,
0.092977263,
0.594737947,
0.6327592134,
-0.1621925384,
0.2790693641,
0.1925910413,
-0.2995765507,
0.7100573182,
0.0206057373,
-0.0637093037,
-0.6176462173,
0.3591223955,
0.5352326035,
-0.0127389412,
-0.3358418345,
0.5203052163,
-0.1333652139,
-0.1406376958,
-0.4027156532,
0.4004673362,
0.6206901073,
0.5685516596,
0.3900488317,
0.1935853213,
-0.4184043407,
-0.7943659425,
0.221253559,
0.5581182241,
-0.3478581309,
-0.3119667768,
0.5269228816,
0.2042785883,
-0.708315134,
0.5650110245,
-0.0860958621,
-0.2654295266,
0.9635869265,
0.7312348485,
0.6512339115,
-0.313929081,
0.6231799126,
0.0242095459,
0.2971234024,
-0.3095914721,
0.1279106736,
0.1849296987,
-1.4528782368,
-0.6926814914,
-0.374079138,
-0.2278551906,
-0.4862154126,
-0.3481114209,
0.1747196615,
-0.1669815779,
-0.5757239461,
-0.1382129639,
0.1296985447,
-0.8055189848,
0.1406554133,
0.2287854552,
0.6162188649,
-0.9736696482,
0.8543738127,
0.9745114446,
-0.2032788843,
-1.01463449,
0.3705420494,
0.1613295823,
-0.7892718315,
0.6795473695,
0.033779636,
-0.1950795501,
-0.1777492017,
-0.6030439734,
-1.0734064579,
1.3409826756,
0.4838760197,
-0.4080890715,
-0.2792694867,
0.3148168027,
0.6786336899,
-0.9210307002,
0.166821599,
0.0698603913,
0.4685090482,
0.3086107969,
-0.6263384819,
0.2188329101,
-0.253993541,
0.1630817652,
0.1099359691,
-0.6546967626,
0.5587151051,
-0.0632375255,
-0.0762331337,
-0.1006892249,
0.9396772385,
0.7733524442,
0.3697598279,
0.9246191382,
0.0315535739,
1.0011510849,
0.3685422242,
0.7284286618,
-0.0691503137,
0.1177032366,
0.9242719412,
-0.9369090199,
0.3830705285,
0.400562942,
-0.1710749269,
0.5131875277,
0.7685440183,
0.1078726575,
0.0943300202,
0.3217264116,
-0.0146833975,
-0.7586062551,
-0.3015528917,
-0.200738892,
0.5470897555,
0.3650417924,
-0.1825085878,
0.0049828729,
-0.4836797118,
-0.2239558399,
0.1806502789,
0.0169352293,
0.6956669688,
0.1252031028,
-0.6707541943,
-0.0024723511,
-0.1007325873,
0.6752406955,
-0.4864226878,
-0.4621295631,
-0.0340990722,
-0.2409587353,
-0.3286590278,
-0.7500835061,
-0.0165154506,
-0.0364267007,
-0.215194881,
-0.2644489706,
0.8135102987,
-0.4438737035,
-0.3043802977,
0.2762085497,
0.6480373144,
0.2639043629,
0.2248765677,
-0.4295242727,
-0.2705504894,
-0.0785623193,
-0.1437241137,
0.5316773057,
0.6412228942,
-0.5229417086,
0.5010033846,
0.8663781285,
0.3486352563,
-0.1882448345,
0.1423025429,
0.7682045698,
-0.6331624985,
-0.5484445691,
-0.9350240231,
0.4062000513,
-0.5482386351,
0.0973347053,
0.5548966527,
0.2856186628,
0.3744573891,
0.2611705959,
0.6757049561,
0.1413304806,
0.161662519,
-0.1862732321,
0.7771993876,
-0.4432510436,
0.2647832334,
-0.4060953856,
-1.1857802868,
-0.0202114545,
0.599978447,
-0.2415596396,
0.2068021595,
0.1205333397,
1.0231958628,
-0.0059459871,
-0.1079709828,
0.4714462757,
-0.0609991252,
0.5660325289,
-0.0401454344,
1.1151756048,
0.1421609968,
0.1866857409,
0.1008036658,
-0.360898912,
-0.1349385679,
-0.9656777978,
-0.9369578958,
-0.2035003006,
-0.2316219807,
-0.4092044532,
-0.019593941,
1.5919604301,
0.7554556727,
-0.3806859851,
-0.5344535708,
0.1668593436,
0.1378878653,
-0.3867211342,
-0.2956255674,
0.178238377,
0.0352441743,
-0.4696206152,
0.3554622829,
0.123811461,
-0.072694689,
-0.3819074035,
-0.4756808281,
-0.138255924,
0.4689010084,
0.4059654176,
0.1354452074,
-0.8043305278,
-0.5322358608,
0.160372138,
-0.2958807051,
0.0745752677,
0.8347827196,
-0.5047685504,
0.3921989501,
0.3218338788,
0.5268771052,
0.1148282886,
0.6211945415,
1.0370838642,
-0.7777459025,
-0.036174532,
0.1873605102,
0.2515460253,
0.2892007232,
-0.7263410091,
0.3890565932,
0.154068917,
-0.5262627006,
-0.5643700957,
0.2998366058,
-0.7689031363,
-0.0082831662,
1.2565078735,
-0.0569023192,
-0.3044578135,
-0.253703177,
-0.1548983604,
0.3698273003,
-0.7397397161,
0.7093839645,
0.5726522207,
-0.3175122738,
-0.0864605308,
-0.2040585279,
0.2373881191,
0.2444970906,
-0.7697989345,
0.0831495672,
0.4418892264,
0.17494151,
0.2874801159,
0.8154139519,
0.0899149179,
-0.0660380647,
-0.2296060473,
0.2530753613,
0.1466653794,
-0.0891902819,
0.0198543482,
0.1010877118,
0.1042066813,
0.2010469288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17231v1
|
CogMG: Collaborative Augmentation Between Large Language Model and Knowledge Graph
| 2024-06-25T02:37:12 | 2024-06-25T02:37:12 |
Tong Zhou, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have become integral to question-answering applications
despite their propensity for generating hallucinations and factually inaccurate
content. Querying knowledge graphs to reduce hallucinations in LLM meets the
challenge of incomplete knowledge coverage in knowledge graphs. On the other
hand, updating knowledge graphs by information extraction and knowledge graph
completion faces the knowledge update misalignment issue. In this work, we
introduce a collaborative augmentation framework, CogMG, leveraging knowledge
graphs to address the limitations of LLMs in QA scenarios, explicitly targeting
the problems of incomplete knowledge coverage and knowledge update
misalignment. The LLMs identify and decompose required knowledge triples that
are not present in the KG, enriching them and aligning updates with real-world
demands. We demonstrate the efficacy of this approach through a supervised
fine-tuned LLM within an agent framework, showing significant improvements in
reducing hallucinations and enhancing factual accuracy in QA responses. Our
code and video are publicly available.
|
[
-0.588465631,
-1.0153710842,
0.6239165664,
-0.040447358,
0.034520898,
0.4443216324,
0.0199054983,
-0.6578733325,
0.3598181605,
0.6370947957,
-0.763414681,
-0.6417133808,
-0.3224006891,
0.1688925326,
-0.0094949231,
0.7011371255,
0.0748214573,
-0.0581690595,
-0.7420114279,
-0.2243672311,
-0.5439603925,
-0.4311137795,
-0.7183527946,
-0.5958445668,
0.3190729022,
0.3780003488,
1.1743190289,
0.2637033463,
0.4260016978,
0.3015308678,
0.0694514886,
0.8822365999,
-0.621481061,
0.1195880473,
-0.0527204834,
-0.3880355358,
-0.902982831,
-0.1843266189,
0.2125778198,
1.0427957773,
-0.1247094572,
-0.0418944582,
0.1090463549,
0.4519251585,
-0.3615965843,
0.4286696911,
-0.3461446762,
-0.0157319438,
0.4513401985,
-0.1798989922,
-0.3219296634,
-0.4907392561,
0.3209135234,
-1.0905332565,
0.1955867261,
0.3706038594,
0.7461323738,
0.6768413186,
-0.2460468709,
-0.1917099208,
-0.4483153224,
0.3714800179,
-0.6160241365,
0.341127336,
0.3845359087,
0.2749192417,
-0.5632283092,
-0.776333034,
-0.615229249,
-0.1331918836,
-0.2782431841,
0.1213497445,
-0.2512216568,
0.5685874224,
0.2682616413,
0.4308624864,
-0.5246587396,
0.0539155081,
-0.2510597408,
-0.5021190047,
0.737631321,
0.0767421797,
0.580395937,
0.048540704,
-0.3329904377,
-0.0810559392,
-0.6144314408,
-0.2309804559,
0.1601786166,
0.0143237608,
-0.0272115376,
0.5958724618,
-0.1996529996,
0.9277953506,
0.3282616735,
0.0331077911,
0.3601807952,
-0.2948123515,
-0.2918866873,
0.1601891667,
0.5698055029,
0.5483893752,
0.0849066004,
-0.6209614873,
0.2455229908,
-0.2576214075,
0.2648485303,
-0.5387461185,
-0.2927718759,
0.3291831613,
0.1294977218,
-0.1256439835,
-0.0859466046,
-0.5397952795,
-0.7041154504,
-0.2513331771,
0.5217609406,
-0.2841085792,
-0.1646133959,
0.3118184209,
-0.206613183,
-0.0055078729,
0.4716404378,
-0.479260236,
0.2416381091,
0.6019932032,
0.4887162745,
-0.2043542117,
-0.2936026752,
-0.5870625377,
0.4898291826,
-0.39901492,
0.6233342886,
-0.3600107133,
-0.1447681785,
-0.0821451321,
0.1322542727,
-0.0281125959,
-0.6867690682,
0.1152737662,
-0.9074177742,
0.5901283622,
-0.3692726493,
-0.8390526175,
-0.5739093423,
0.6763903499,
-0.7166324854,
0.9145935178,
0.6200932264,
-0.5962756872,
0.1181062162,
-0.5753490925,
-0.1045989022,
0.2727361321,
-0.2258052826,
-0.3217857182,
-0.3417078555,
0.5493858457,
0.3226488531,
-0.1060955599,
0.3378433287,
-0.5003240108,
-0.524029851,
-0.0164167099,
0.2321022451,
0.6441192031,
-0.0101993214,
0.0524655171,
0.3539220989,
-0.7062578201,
0.1188585982,
-0.1140739545,
-0.163452968,
-0.2837430537,
-0.1449317932,
-0.637008369,
0.0694106072,
0.5048624873,
-0.1742917448,
0.2444076836,
-0.6209498644,
-0.0046999808,
0.4152781069,
0.3728151321,
0.6137632132,
-0.4977637529,
0.7441484332,
-0.061347574,
0.1822964102,
0.2734101117,
-0.4636063874,
-0.7568275332,
-0.2888422012,
0.0194327794,
0.5525550842,
-1.3223752975,
0.6170447469,
-0.2501292527,
-0.1412918717,
-0.6407173872,
0.2821803689,
0.1164886206,
0.5813198686,
0.5893158317,
-0.2176307589,
-0.7005764246,
-0.7432946563,
-0.1134781688,
-0.3792411089,
-0.1615921706,
0.3348627985,
-0.0656164512,
-0.5134189725,
1.0270969868,
-0.7194116116,
-0.4523018897,
-0.1564529985,
-0.0144886244,
-0.0709620118,
0.1311104894,
0.3061952889,
-0.57265836,
-0.2073872536,
-0.0032266309,
-1.0014413595,
-0.2739623189,
0.1616022885,
-0.057252828,
0.1024099439,
0.6773525476,
-0.4300427437,
-0.0115551287,
0.8204012513,
-0.3113042414,
0.4064616859,
-0.3213632405,
0.2163164914,
-1.2768518925,
-0.4608487189,
-0.3550468981,
-0.5967648625,
-0.5399340987,
0.3993620872,
-0.2665521204,
-0.1189285666,
-0.1494494975,
0.3700771928,
-0.4756473303,
-0.0415129438,
-0.2940668464,
0.622081697,
0.3307458758,
0.6226526499,
-0.1562827528,
0.8314712644,
0.4975953102,
-0.5046935678,
0.6722272038,
0.3554953039,
-0.0756928399,
0.3659112155,
-0.3448809981,
0.4793676138,
0.0384813175,
0.1391860843,
-0.729813993,
-0.4832942784,
0.6157194376,
-0.441704154,
0.0516815484,
-0.0421076342,
-0.6280149221,
-0.3173215091,
-0.1212577447,
0.2199028134,
0.4247610271,
-0.6727692485,
0.762580514,
0.4949498475,
-0.0999809206,
-0.3902389109,
-0.5186499953,
0.1165426299,
0.0881553143,
-1.0050486326,
0.2758831084,
-0.025341697,
-0.3658951223,
0.1807469279,
-0.0537850633,
-0.1336176991,
0.0156530663,
0.1256290227,
0.1673728824,
-0.1433619857,
0.4437202513,
0.1119645834,
0.0424250253,
0.1314937919,
-0.3517502248,
0.6308908463,
-0.0059743347,
-0.4974097311,
-0.1004964709,
0.1050382629,
0.2860500515,
-0.0451723821,
0.7184815407,
0.7972583175,
-0.5028884411,
-0.0739944726,
-0.7129577994,
-0.2987558544,
-0.5294737816,
0.4518065453,
-0.2148534358,
-1.4072628021,
0.6738294959,
-0.0667926371,
-0.5182422996,
0.2792854607,
0.3019829094,
-0.0167794675,
1.0191559792,
0.6475545764,
0.0276353527,
0.1665223241,
-0.1426781267,
0.2682001889,
-0.7867885828,
-0.4063842595,
-0.0897288248,
0.0319029465,
-0.4838555455,
-0.6848335862,
0.6770676374,
0.3398717344,
0.1348844469,
0.0692953989,
-0.6045499444,
0.4284600914,
0.3096842766,
0.4017894268,
0.5203438997,
0.0416215956,
0.0245345253,
0.1898633242,
-0.9313265085,
-0.3287710845,
0.7228983045,
0.1782348454,
0.6497987509,
0.1080146134,
0.5811583996,
0.3417269289,
0.0702832788,
-0.6011513472,
0.6231176257,
0.3052256107,
-0.5053236485,
-0.5550268888,
-0.4367904961,
-0.8069946766,
0.275595665,
-0.2764165103,
-0.5936120749,
0.1186853722,
0.1989930421,
-0.5451203585,
0.1540348977,
-0.8184040785,
0.7418530583,
0.1134142205,
-0.3393739462,
-0.3951025307,
-0.4514010251,
0.3292597234,
-0.0566706322,
0.134983629,
0.1145597324,
0.0010220059,
0.5012850165,
-0.6345904469,
0.7758722901,
-0.1558836848,
-0.3515800834,
0.5252740383,
0.1015325487,
0.8783326149,
0.0241800211,
-0.0204808395,
-0.1287758052,
-0.009725295,
-0.5279524922,
-0.8609933257,
0.5247867703,
-0.8201544285,
-0.9168544412,
-0.1088913381,
-1.0653793812,
-0.6388043761,
0.0801739395,
-0.0949445665,
0.2151793689,
-0.0972483531,
-0.0407427959,
0.6525524259,
-0.3233627379,
0.110745661,
0.3831723928,
-0.4594776034,
-0.5397057533,
0.8272565603,
0.0410551094,
0.3640663922,
0.0619104393,
0.0720820948,
-0.3596061468,
-0.7188643813,
-0.1995709389,
0.1560613662,
-0.6861820817,
0.0339246988,
-0.7547987103,
-0.2600583732,
-0.7700309157,
-0.1036241353,
0.2071391493,
-0.2417181134,
-0.3540426791,
-0.2137466669,
0.536039114,
0.689306736,
-0.1085937917,
0.4473185241,
-0.9085630178,
0.4321908355,
0.6405113339,
0.1824519932,
-0.1674271822,
-0.1507439166,
-0.4082628787,
0.2049512714,
-0.1120966524,
-0.911678493,
0.2813949883,
-0.1404093802,
0.4608086944,
0.1569004506,
0.2452237606,
1.0401631594,
-0.0015779892,
0.8237298727,
0.0851108134,
-0.7918762565,
0.2047465891,
-0.4972220659,
0.2525841892,
0.5463416576,
0.0478573777,
-0.5391480327,
-0.7223726511,
-0.623821497,
-0.6416275501,
0.6065859199,
0.1094022989,
-0.1876284778,
0.0724333748,
0.4606130123,
0.0109301787,
0.3448930383,
-0.5106548667,
0.0042912327,
0.0496214107,
-0.2830944657,
0.0226759911,
-0.0720037892,
-0.4198822081,
-0.2608499527,
0.7323831916,
-0.5205478668,
0.0452645272,
0.4148190618,
-0.4028087854,
-0.2907892168,
0.1174604595,
0.40725106,
0.7715835571,
-0.3343483806,
0.1116934344,
0.591721952,
-0.2884338796,
-0.0424054936,
0.3240280747,
-0.1139368191,
-0.2535983324,
0.3893203139,
0.752666831,
-0.1064690575,
-0.5221150517,
0.5269206762,
0.043993827,
-0.1905968636,
-0.2940694988,
0.2680414617,
0.1055788919,
0.6274338365,
0.3318839073,
0.0895017534,
0.109925054,
-0.3975370228,
0.2236581743,
0.4123055637,
-0.7731407285,
-0.0898313001,
0.428797096,
0.1873373836,
-0.3336605132,
0.3860853612,
-0.6591053605,
-0.5842573047,
0.6173602939,
0.3732649088,
0.606765449,
0.196072489,
0.3930195868,
0.1094294712,
0.4025788903,
-0.0691845492,
0.1887079477,
0.0288809147,
-0.9045590162,
-0.7254375815,
-0.0418739133,
-0.640663445,
0.0974951982,
-0.4449751973,
0.1413676292,
-0.204898715,
0.0417820625,
-0.5922636986,
0.2423833907,
-0.459989965,
0.2715477943,
0.0336447544,
0.5050807595,
-0.5433222651,
0.7578507662,
0.7242928147,
-0.5396547318,
-1.0551992655,
0.0748929828,
-0.3158581853,
-0.8479871154,
0.1143186837,
-0.1056545526,
-0.2302319258,
0.2783615291,
-0.687887907,
-0.7242746949,
1.30426085,
0.6040320992,
-0.4143621624,
-0.297269851,
0.3570854962,
0.8356927633,
-0.3483676016,
-0.0001581198,
0.3529379964,
0.4458900988,
0.2777814865,
-0.7405695319,
0.3476709127,
0.1581588387,
-0.4366576076,
-0.040383406,
-0.7239766121,
0.3733866215,
-0.3275993764,
-0.0647479296,
-0.1309606433,
0.6018481851,
0.4190705419,
0.4524078071,
0.5260713696,
0.7560663819,
1.1842148304,
-0.145629108,
0.9857841134,
-0.349342078,
0.258839488,
1.2466658354,
-0.2719195485,
0.2120580375,
0.3968549967,
-0.0338303372,
0.4759519994,
0.7509053349,
0.0132607864,
0.2570616305,
-0.0104167806,
-0.3104050756,
-0.5606384873,
-0.2731030881,
-0.527102232,
0.1069853082,
0.2550199628,
-0.0798207521,
-0.2239848226,
-0.0375913791,
-0.0276553314,
-0.0216382109,
-0.3643881977,
0.940464437,
-0.0315334462,
-0.8393797874,
0.6219832897,
-0.2485282123,
0.2974010706,
-0.2361400127,
-0.1333274096,
-0.19863002,
-0.0059138043,
-0.4482864439,
-0.5596899986,
0.3376168013,
-0.5092357993,
-0.0020329899,
-0.0888143629,
0.9768334627,
-0.7458707094,
-0.2362990528,
0.5542874336,
0.7965225577,
-0.0762716308,
-0.2450371832,
-0.4161287546,
-0.2618008852,
-0.0920556411,
0.22622329,
-0.0477064587,
0.4135646224,
-0.0414362811,
0.7277191877,
0.5264965296,
0.1025091112,
0.2049465328,
0.3701945245,
0.9206705689,
-0.3410169482,
-0.4028984308,
-0.6243021488,
0.2333736718,
-0.2945423722,
0.4068235457,
0.8427951336,
0.597825706,
0.8306394815,
0.0200494584,
0.7607174516,
0.0978842229,
0.364720583,
-0.4397215247,
0.7594570518,
-0.5491045117,
0.3188608587,
-0.2004958689,
-0.8061494827,
-0.4535357058,
0.3251913488,
-0.4165830612,
-0.1945576668,
0.7195258141,
1.1242032051,
0.2133926153,
-0.0475672744,
0.5532724857,
0.3744404316,
0.2208282948,
0.5189884305,
0.9546552896,
-0.4583382905,
0.6505822539,
-0.0774279013,
0.0356681198,
-0.1654365808,
-0.5888752341,
-1.0535424948,
-0.4228277802,
-0.6104713082,
-0.6643844247,
0.2144916654,
1.1110069752,
0.6476626992,
-0.6871998906,
0.0851283371,
-0.1422670931,
0.5605940223,
-0.224460572,
-0.2450879216,
0.3022527397,
-0.3718372285,
-0.5454019904,
0.4497781694,
0.306899935,
0.1429029405,
-0.4072849751,
-0.299795419,
-0.1433679461,
0.0037970329,
0.5038423538,
0.0436005704,
-0.562977612,
-0.6559659839,
0.263174504,
-0.0622433573,
0.2730476856,
0.4105372429,
-0.9194639325,
0.6562898159,
0.617797792,
0.7202733755,
0.4773858786,
0.2078829408,
0.6813315749,
-0.9642766714,
0.0423490256,
0.1323777735,
0.1426198483,
0.4100079536,
-0.5351298451,
0.5867016912,
0.3786373734,
-0.4236830175,
-0.7316047549,
0.2227206975,
-1.0576344728,
-0.1441347301,
1.1947106123,
-0.0034859949,
-0.2874289751,
-0.4857607782,
-0.4103957713,
0.5987517238,
-0.182656303,
1.0251553059,
0.8852443099,
-0.1813940257,
-0.3091406524,
-0.1315941215,
0.5598890781,
0.2349199206,
-1.0933899879,
-0.3077782989,
0.8202372789,
0.1229556799,
0.3053313792,
0.7406121492,
0.0394236632,
0.2797729969,
-0.2099199891,
0.3347706199,
-0.4455752075,
-0.0010433563,
-0.2505542338,
0.541739583,
0.2918402851,
-0.2142893076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17224v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17224v1
|
Large Language Models are Interpretable Learners
| 2024-06-25T02:18:15 | 2024-06-25T02:18:15 |
Ruochen Wang, Si Si, Felix Yu, Dorothea Wiesmann, Cho-Jui Hsieh, Inderjit Dhillon
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.SC, 68T05
|
The trade-off between expressiveness and interpretability remains a core
challenge when building human-centric predictive models for classification and
decision-making. While symbolic rules offer interpretability, they often lack
expressiveness, whereas neural networks excel in performance but are known for
being black boxes. In this paper, we show a combination of Large Language
Models (LLMs) and symbolic programs can bridge this gap. In the proposed
LLM-based Symbolic Programs (LSPs), the pretrained LLM with natural language
prompts provides a massive set of interpretable modules that can transform raw
input into natural language concepts. Symbolic programs then integrate these
modules into an interpretable decision rule. To train LSPs, we develop a
divide-and-conquer approach to incrementally build the program from scratch,
where the learning process of each step is guided by LLMs. To evaluate the
effectiveness of LSPs in extracting interpretable and accurate knowledge from
data, we introduce IL-Bench, a collection of diverse tasks, including both
synthetic and real-world scenarios across different modalities. Empirical
results demonstrate LSP's superior performance compared to traditional
neurosymbolic programs and vanilla automatic prompt tuning methods. Moreover,
as the knowledge learned by LSP is a combination of natural language
descriptions and symbolic rules, it is easily transferable to humans
(interpretable), and other LLMs, and generalizes well to out-of-distribution
samples.
|
[
0.0393605269,
-0.5057174563,
0.7613774538,
0.329788506,
-0.1889270395,
0.2062179744,
-0.5616047978,
-0.5985457301,
0.0312731862,
0.4023937285,
-0.498986125,
-0.39839378,
-0.7989889979,
0.1587752551,
-0.4515968263,
0.7127149105,
-0.0313128494,
0.1574065089,
-0.0294724759,
-0.0923455432,
-0.4364368618,
-0.477827996,
-0.7931490541,
-0.661111474,
0.4166840613,
-0.0272850562,
0.6480620503,
0.6008256674,
0.2472512424,
0.3368393183,
0.0173236895,
0.1506965756,
-0.2790105641,
0.1042877138,
-0.3650242984,
-0.6661556959,
-0.1136576086,
-0.1218297482,
0.5435553789,
0.6765476465,
-0.2165052146,
0.0744977593,
0.1534633934,
0.3951651752,
-0.4274522364,
0.6983681321,
-0.5693405271,
0.0389115065,
0.0477856956,
-0.0386988223,
-0.6797934771,
-0.3929108679,
-0.1012983546,
-0.4244610667,
-0.3174315691,
-0.0138188591,
0.5425956845,
0.4373882413,
-0.2809028924,
-0.1128902584,
-0.6175279021,
0.9474378824,
-0.7987394929,
0.439599216,
0.3008939326,
0.6311389804,
-0.333083719,
-0.6788541675,
-0.507430315,
-0.4280645847,
-0.2612952292,
-0.1808469743,
-0.1733781844,
0.0510007367,
0.435998559,
-0.0905520022,
-0.4124580026,
0.4037995636,
-0.2292815596,
-0.0109893233,
0.7514796853,
0.251241684,
0.4135479033,
-0.0844099894,
-0.0719488189,
-0.1500116438,
-0.7801778316,
-0.0029535706,
-0.063831389,
0.6251160502,
-0.1670200676,
0.6099092364,
-0.1037167013,
0.9175271392,
-0.2332592607,
-0.1853877753,
-0.0610562302,
0.0989769027,
-0.2518282533,
0.1338510811,
0.6480087638,
-0.0247013569,
0.6612144709,
-0.3512158394,
-0.404458344,
0.1204017848,
0.2579956055,
-0.6169157624,
-0.0024101103,
0.0762682557,
-0.4342296422,
-0.1749728322,
-0.1092540547,
-0.382671684,
-0.6006351709,
-1.1247415543,
0.5033135414,
-0.585141778,
-0.2306271046,
0.1555188894,
0.0286678746,
0.1303328425,
0.5757245421,
-0.7017937899,
0.4534035623,
0.9115642309,
0.8096647263,
-0.1377944499,
-0.2427734435,
-0.5058861375,
0.2011149526,
-0.2418921292,
0.3976639211,
-0.5928919315,
-0.0077788411,
0.0247156397,
-0.1350078732,
-0.1841006428,
-0.5089151263,
0.3463279009,
-0.4128117859,
-0.0963515192,
-0.1225613356,
-0.4432363212,
-0.1570125818,
0.2405713946,
-0.6261552572,
0.8315102458,
0.1576736867,
-0.4508148432,
0.3103556335,
-0.6200903058,
-0.5544875264,
-0.0111839902,
-0.3566177487,
0.0261074882,
0.2591799796,
0.0851031169,
0.6938435435,
-0.4219899774,
0.5140945315,
-0.3108890951,
-0.466345787,
0.3203632832,
-0.1786111295,
0.6654748321,
0.1980392337,
-0.5437965393,
0.3028140664,
-0.7876756191,
0.181335479,
0.2148548216,
-0.296533972,
-0.3938919902,
0.2319960445,
-0.1194565073,
0.4941441119,
-0.0451904275,
-0.2516030669,
0.0605044886,
-0.5479972959,
0.4921514988,
1.0627820492,
-0.5718563795,
0.3721977174,
-0.1483215839,
0.4698083997,
-0.1350124329,
-0.1030217931,
0.0659557581,
-0.0761936456,
-0.8154161572,
-0.3198224008,
0.0769553185,
0.5072830319,
-0.8693954349,
0.6501067877,
-0.4199426174,
-0.4374447465,
-0.2735662162,
0.1573151648,
0.2295403033,
0.2760028839,
0.2693527639,
0.0102955671,
-0.4772538245,
-0.8841388226,
-0.4357074499,
-0.1794471145,
0.0375776365,
0.0477240533,
0.4437083304,
0.1521841288,
0.7236744165,
-0.3994112313,
-0.185408473,
-0.6921595335,
0.0530902892,
0.5298059583,
0.2646353245,
0.2964932919,
-0.3407765329,
-0.4688034654,
-0.030534301,
-0.8811126947,
-0.0887069479,
-0.2355373055,
-0.0469971709,
-0.0535109527,
0.5599757433,
-0.9379588366,
0.1934386343,
0.1655502319,
-0.27617535,
0.5928319693,
-0.0408703834,
-0.2885333002,
-0.8609300256,
0.0444526933,
0.2338183075,
-0.2761552036,
-0.4723976552,
0.1228574142,
-0.0136857545,
-0.0991169512,
-0.4459567666,
0.8343837857,
-0.38994807,
-0.2349512726,
-0.2440875918,
-0.1072056368,
-0.184733972,
0.4606133699,
0.1395110637,
0.564776063,
0.5667256117,
-0.4939636588,
0.1474582255,
0.0400742665,
-0.532749474,
0.574862361,
-0.6317166686,
-0.1369823366,
-0.3623896837,
0.3764589131,
-0.4831525087,
-0.1651432365,
0.3181598783,
0.0169015992,
0.4745335877,
0.183782652,
-0.6393985748,
-0.2047243118,
0.0106127523,
0.1269288659,
0.5432325602,
-0.6966506839,
0.8674907684,
0.0721959397,
-0.1735900491,
-0.6499429345,
-0.5402684808,
0.1531867534,
-0.1194157824,
-0.313621819,
-0.0097603081,
0.2320987433,
-0.5034826398,
-0.0883745551,
-0.0086730123,
0.1022523344,
0.1832130551,
0.474068135,
0.2446978688,
-0.1135868654,
0.4086953402,
-0.0719759986,
-0.0741549507,
0.3300273716,
-0.2813896239,
0.5335868597,
-0.1325621754,
-0.4824549258,
-0.5817907453,
0.151393339,
0.6614237428,
-0.2275846452,
0.9266321659,
0.3829117715,
-0.3191120625,
-0.6140797734,
-0.292889446,
-0.3439225852,
-0.4124234915,
0.3519677818,
-0.4474542141,
-0.6674832702,
0.0886180848,
-0.3071811795,
0.2399953753,
0.2942514718,
0.4363833666,
-0.0430245362,
1.2206989527,
0.5506990552,
-0.1872691512,
0.4281051159,
-0.0433642641,
0.209905833,
-0.4244789779,
-0.2680802047,
-0.510115087,
-0.6646393538,
-0.1535555571,
-0.3095026314,
0.147744149,
-0.0877500996,
-0.5781303644,
0.2888894081,
-0.4782012701,
0.585611701,
0.4298738837,
0.1925062984,
0.167230621,
0.1073475033,
-0.0238368846,
-0.0342956185,
-0.5136218667,
-0.4684031904,
1.0245372057,
0.3387066126,
0.8806602955,
-0.0245942827,
0.6675512791,
0.2553813457,
0.6031751633,
-0.7884936929,
0.7480979562,
-0.3464914858,
-0.2361336052,
-0.1672518104,
-0.5333322883,
-0.7533284426,
0.3768327832,
-0.3285811543,
-1.0585491657,
-0.0689765364,
0.0628078431,
-0.1318873316,
0.3637419641,
-0.7259497643,
0.7252087593,
-0.7376533747,
-0.2372006625,
-0.4812759161,
-0.6577868462,
0.4416694343,
-0.2380730361,
0.2574062347,
-0.1441520751,
0.144524321,
0.5239265561,
-0.3069762588,
1.1398522854,
-0.1893732995,
0.0323257446,
-0.1316103041,
0.1718828827,
0.7134104967,
-0.3052219152,
-0.3855400085,
0.1966836154,
0.0666120201,
-0.2138606012,
-0.8703306317,
0.568644762,
-0.8438006639,
-0.6313316822,
-0.4837425053,
-0.7553197145,
-0.2268479317,
0.1536082327,
-0.2723837197,
0.3195545971,
-0.1265172213,
0.0871994272,
0.3697516918,
-0.3153452575,
0.2432771027,
0.4786836803,
-0.3992938399,
-0.0291312039,
0.8902028203,
-0.0276233982,
0.2299087644,
0.4504938126,
0.2218608707,
-0.5011381507,
-0.490477711,
-0.3306478858,
0.4158663154,
-0.8210847378,
-0.0213263668,
-0.4642314017,
-0.3241012692,
-0.1585433781,
-0.0923187286,
-0.0798817277,
-0.4793364108,
-0.1975830942,
-0.033661928,
0.1788971573,
0.7334380746,
0.0178666674,
0.4084371328,
-0.6418641806,
0.1466302723,
0.0180479661,
0.2783741057,
0.115963757,
-0.4022316635,
-0.1512606889,
0.0597362891,
0.035528414,
-0.6883615851,
0.4690601528,
0.179938063,
0.6839880943,
0.2985794544,
-0.0058141807,
0.5286939144,
-0.3420290053,
0.330699563,
0.4912413657,
-0.8363832831,
0.5079604983,
-0.0438664816,
0.3545273542,
0.3876164258,
0.4212258458,
-0.430036664,
-0.3744095862,
-0.3390419185,
-0.5608249307,
1.004663825,
0.0402823165,
0.0780935511,
0.210356921,
0.2720800638,
0.1076642945,
0.2730843127,
-0.8543018103,
0.0832949802,
-0.0936055407,
-0.6560831666,
-0.4037139416,
0.086873278,
-0.2304076105,
-0.3925461471,
0.5010740757,
-0.2551204264,
-0.0942784771,
-0.3419721127,
-0.3308935761,
0.0875302777,
0.3680085838,
0.2238291502,
0.8374906778,
-0.1455764323,
0.4019765854,
0.022382522,
-0.0396385975,
0.1939893961,
0.1659054011,
-0.1571814865,
-0.2608584166,
0.4521482885,
0.9518327713,
0.2167608291,
-1.0731327534,
0.2377225161,
-0.0095083741,
0.0203962326,
-0.3824774027,
0.2920793891,
0.1818121076,
0.4889193773,
-0.0034243795,
0.0062535894,
-0.2092758119,
-0.5946062207,
0.0342333689,
0.4377254546,
-0.3420998752,
-0.3038981855,
0.5285289288,
0.0423394665,
-0.1880455464,
0.8124895096,
0.0331867971,
-0.4446504414,
0.6212264895,
0.627740562,
0.7527989149,
-0.0914724544,
0.3041228354,
0.3031936884,
0.3760508597,
-0.2516426444,
0.2974074185,
-0.0632750541,
-0.6425010562,
-0.6621864438,
-0.9379124641,
-0.1224759445,
0.2190970927,
-0.4027784169,
0.2363799363,
-0.6747013927,
0.029414868,
0.1682888567,
-0.3518307507,
-0.6688486338,
0.1757879853,
0.0820594281,
1.022552371,
-0.9439054728,
0.9130215049,
0.8098710179,
-0.3455338776,
-1.1163618565,
-0.3437601924,
0.1092332974,
-0.912972033,
1.1431943178,
0.3253432512,
0.2238755077,
-0.133420378,
-0.5499703288,
-0.6412728429,
0.7970492244,
0.6414819956,
-0.5302253366,
-0.1207334474,
0.3815693855,
0.5921068192,
-0.1838505268,
0.3143553436,
0.850597918,
0.6413461566,
0.2705646455,
-0.795575738,
0.2738522291,
-0.1668085605,
-0.3064931333,
0.4198469818,
-0.1952756941,
0.6531926394,
-0.0787594765,
-0.1475508213,
-0.066477567,
0.4789980352,
0.4485025406,
0.1253273934,
0.5981456637,
0.6439059377,
0.5856015086,
-0.2625025213,
1.1594810486,
-0.2766093016,
-0.224481672,
1.1626646519,
-0.4234735966,
0.935785234,
0.4566757977,
-0.2506985366,
0.4586157799,
0.5188133121,
0.0594163723,
0.2410157174,
0.5097927451,
-0.3155033588,
-0.6748936176,
-0.3401829302,
-0.0937539786,
0.474558264,
0.5210020542,
-0.4842564166,
-0.5038212538,
-0.1861230582,
-0.0500640087,
0.1185432374,
-0.2853321731,
0.47290048,
0.4504999816,
-0.7698948979,
0.4600838423,
0.0203516465,
0.4668030143,
-0.8831003308,
-0.2401927859,
0.1109811589,
0.4421843886,
-0.2339726388,
-0.8235498667,
0.2566896677,
-0.2187228203,
0.0583512411,
-0.4028720856,
0.9158024788,
-0.3359188735,
-0.5299381614,
0.3269790411,
0.6827840209,
0.1775209159,
-0.1227511242,
-0.8126916289,
0.0559869036,
-0.1296904981,
-0.1147755533,
0.594493866,
0.2270462662,
-0.366406858,
0.9324697852,
0.7675688267,
0.3039082587,
-0.1709426939,
0.2182733864,
0.8356102705,
-0.5902061462,
-0.4815602899,
-0.8573261499,
0.3214444816,
-0.1142146885,
0.1815170795,
0.4064373076,
0.2949599326,
0.4050720036,
-0.0264731105,
0.761490941,
-0.0500864871,
0.3831250966,
-0.6020033956,
0.6480196714,
-0.591142118,
0.3239353299,
0.0356240943,
-0.9685236216,
-0.3739727139,
0.6003982425,
-0.4820595682,
0.0433957912,
0.4684348106,
0.6842978597,
-0.1231636256,
0.0331262499,
0.2478896976,
0.290068239,
0.2827159464,
0.7249403596,
1.1201658249,
0.2343616337,
0.2476375997,
-0.1239565089,
-0.2370479107,
-0.0397848934,
-0.7982275486,
-0.9062571526,
-0.2400276363,
-0.0227290597,
-0.1910874099,
0.136168927,
1.1201575994,
0.7394914031,
-0.6908333898,
-0.4382487833,
-0.033121746,
0.2076597065,
-0.3446148038,
-0.2084612697,
0.4989917278,
-0.4235726595,
-0.656650722,
0.4665523469,
0.1726622283,
-0.0277457014,
-0.230398789,
-0.3568678796,
-0.1138343439,
0.0138796829,
0.8860312104,
0.4163343608,
-0.7831171751,
-0.2787393928,
-0.0615094677,
0.0078368625,
-0.2672908604,
0.7791012526,
-0.9190406799,
0.3092388213,
0.4197313786,
0.736581862,
0.3262393475,
-0.1463264078,
0.7383650541,
-0.6312855482,
0.2090096027,
0.2258922309,
0.5123496056,
0.1164213717,
-0.1112000048,
0.6554786563,
-0.0341764241,
-0.2277742773,
-0.7922399044,
0.1731046736,
-0.9444258809,
-0.5872545838,
1.1580240726,
-0.0882787853,
-0.1186847165,
-0.0934958979,
-0.1291920245,
0.1578378826,
-0.2927555144,
0.8181243539,
0.5842536688,
-0.2444409132,
-0.3115970492,
-0.5042716861,
0.3524414301,
0.4817592204,
-1.025031209,
0.047519654,
0.661198616,
0.0517149791,
0.0758571103,
0.3007822335,
0.0376065075,
0.1103953719,
-0.3498892486,
0.1737312675,
-0.2496591657,
-0.3386618495,
-0.3030860424,
0.1370033473,
0.3180910945,
0.1999708414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17213v1
|
Detecting Frames in News Headlines and Lead Images in U.S. Gun Violence Coverage
| 2024-06-25T01:56:47 | 2024-06-25T01:56:47 |
Isidora Chara Tourni, Lei Guo, Hengchang Hu, Edward Halim, Prakash Ishwar, Taufiq Daryanto, Mona Jalal, Boqi Chen, Margrit Betke, Fabian Zhafransyah, Sha Lai, Derry Tanti Wijaya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
News media structure their reporting of events or issues using certain
perspectives.
When describing an incident involving gun violence, for example, some
journalists may focus on mental health or gun regulation, while others may
emphasize the discussion of gun rights. Such perspectives are called
\say{frames} in communication research. We study, for the first time, the value
of combining lead images and their contextual information with text to identify
the frame of a given news article. We observe that using multiple modes of
information(article- and image-derived features) improves prediction of news
frames over any single mode of information when the images are relevant to the
frames of the headlines. We also observe that frame image relevance is related
to the ease of conveying frames via images, which we call frame concreteness.
Additionally, we release the first multimodal news framing dataset related to
gun violence in the U.S., curated and annotated by communication researchers.
The dataset will allow researchers to further examine the use of multiple
information modalities for studying media framing.
|
[
-0.4110592306,
-0.9581707716,
0.5346367359,
0.2346652448,
-0.5422757268,
0.049988348,
-0.0388720222,
-0.4025113881,
0.204873085,
0.2816699445,
-0.2178915143,
-0.4647929966,
-0.9336807728,
-0.0820272267,
-0.5743488073,
0.9166181087,
-0.0885175467,
0.1848815382,
0.2651509047,
-0.1539071053,
-0.4090473652,
-0.3956288099,
-0.4584876299,
-0.0347019546,
0.4342567027,
0.0191304032,
1.0497738123,
0.6546735764,
0.9957703352,
0.1836025715,
-0.2489574403,
-0.2334247082,
-0.2614732981,
-0.0354366079,
-0.0559596308,
-0.1875113398,
-0.3139463067,
0.4394383132,
0.5844013691,
0.2965007126,
0.656688869,
0.0457207672,
-0.1677193642,
0.6172440052,
-0.7290933728,
0.0111280633,
-0.3408997059,
0.2278064936,
-0.5494681001,
-0.5544292927,
-0.4028006792,
-0.3336699307,
-0.081129849,
-0.4013280869,
0.3167304397,
-0.0672786906,
0.9977042675,
0.0273781475,
-0.6831915975,
-0.3595232666,
-0.5242832899,
0.1661983579,
-0.3316809237,
0.4175327122,
0.5002378225,
0.0886299163,
-0.2467106283,
-0.1624898016,
-0.4176162183,
-0.0380812064,
-0.2543246746,
0.0255672596,
-0.3311742842,
-0.0828646347,
0.4435134828,
0.4676668346,
-0.6582456231,
-0.3221637309,
-0.8259245157,
-0.2984477282,
0.7045588493,
0.0636919439,
0.460678637,
-0.170351848,
-0.4625862539,
-0.1521035731,
-0.4230829775,
0.395737499,
0.316831857,
0.0779005662,
-0.2116570026,
0.8073104024,
-0.1496559232,
0.7915942669,
0.2261000127,
-0.3821543455,
0.3643229902,
-0.6850633621,
0.0790118054,
0.237879023,
0.619024694,
1.0240232944,
0.0475591794,
0.2120090127,
-0.0201100428,
0.1704068184,
0.1605762392,
-0.8566109538,
0.1467440575,
-0.1556672901,
-0.7995559573,
-0.218605876,
0.2636086345,
-0.5665614605,
-0.5423180461,
-0.0679832622,
0.3151570261,
-0.0875944644,
-0.3740860522,
0.0011889174,
-0.6449922323,
0.3340210319,
0.0047194283,
-0.5896314383,
-0.2442255169,
0.4755472243,
1.0687627792,
-0.122201398,
-0.0364595316,
-0.3201492429,
0.0442348719,
-0.7067227364,
0.839617312,
-0.6945086718,
-0.3120040596,
-0.1565104425,
0.2380021662,
0.4003495276,
-0.2741992176,
0.4995088875,
-0.7781746387,
0.1187583581,
-0.1592099071,
-0.3648889959,
-0.1774621159,
0.2940433323,
-0.8210760355,
0.5671770573,
-0.0512582138,
-0.8838183284,
0.7964561582,
-0.1762933582,
-0.5947747231,
-0.4371070564,
-0.243416056,
-0.6988685131,
0.2977332771,
0.1933795363,
0.3795205057,
0.2332665324,
0.3178040087,
-0.3039049804,
-0.3625990748,
0.102366142,
-0.4536713958,
0.4235265851,
0.2875255644,
-0.0513186567,
0.0948577449,
-0.5743505359,
-0.526581049,
0.099447608,
-0.309812814,
-0.3251304924,
0.0752571076,
0.056049522,
0.014610311,
-0.1660035998,
-0.6719561815,
-0.2288819849,
0.1523917317,
0.0559837893,
0.3338226676,
0.1700095981,
0.6316705346,
-0.5284568667,
0.2029039413,
0.2665912807,
0.1523817778,
-0.7235150933,
-0.6359302998,
-0.0808117911,
-0.0685158297,
0.0353827998,
0.604631722,
-0.2895967662,
0.1460068822,
0.2168091387,
-0.1859350652,
0.1694919765,
-0.3826033771,
0.0923468992,
0.5206918716,
0.2671132684,
-0.6704161763,
-0.6464229226,
-0.7745103836,
-0.4070240557,
0.1388754845,
0.2342521995,
-0.2682787478,
0.1940487474,
0.3499650061,
1.1407865286,
-0.484169364,
-0.3656528294,
0.018867543,
0.5778672099,
0.2472603917,
0.3180807531,
0.673740685,
-1.2479549646,
-0.2924570739,
-0.4901017249,
-0.8579180241,
-0.0096994843,
-0.2127311379,
-0.017963184,
-0.0736585334,
0.7235218287,
-0.2081233412,
0.8960883021,
0.3730146289,
-0.4737525582,
0.3732175529,
0.3550006449,
0.6562922001,
-0.8543522358,
-0.3081580102,
0.3386529088,
-0.2171764523,
-0.449408859,
-0.4058620334,
-0.0052078916,
-0.7137089968,
-0.2893882394,
0.2253103256,
-0.4520538747,
-0.3847377598,
-0.7197351456,
0.0644467771,
0.2595877349,
0.1046153754,
0.3147905469,
0.9330847859,
0.6087611914,
-0.1475108713,
0.3766694367,
0.1832468361,
-0.5505836606,
0.7160946131,
-0.3488258421,
-0.1985736787,
-0.8461779356,
0.6265311837,
-0.9082978368,
-0.439196378,
0.2951179147,
-0.5659291744,
0.1514791995,
-0.1462015659,
-0.078272298,
-0.2039156258,
-0.2523365021,
0.0985946655,
-0.1319854707,
0.1207789108,
0.1486308277,
0.6959517598,
-0.0529693291,
-0.5544368625,
-0.8124212623,
0.2202463746,
-0.1604720205,
-0.6355981827,
0.3921528757,
-0.0307414941,
-0.2872850299,
0.4208573997,
-0.395182699,
-0.5422390103,
0.0922832564,
0.3152239621,
0.2164443135,
-0.4451738298,
0.5060123801,
-0.0993816331,
-0.3585621119,
-0.0039510424,
0.4246307015,
0.2139511704,
-0.0915359631,
-0.1479369551,
-0.6244448423,
0.8984175324,
0.6329881549,
-0.424354583,
0.5899128318,
0.7229896784,
-0.2991409004,
0.4696248174,
-0.3403120935,
-0.4845118523,
-0.3311887383,
0.3304266036,
-0.2724235952,
-0.6821599603,
0.1568218023,
0.1746073961,
0.0176223945,
0.145452559,
0.3968751132,
-0.0253595281,
0.9184194803,
0.6036634445,
-0.1150220484,
0.9631988406,
0.1199154556,
0.2170914412,
-0.4687517881,
-0.0152020482,
-0.1680975854,
-0.5593866706,
-0.0714624599,
-0.3035998642,
0.3484783471,
0.3505030274,
-0.1742835343,
0.5087196231,
-0.5700637102,
0.7758313417,
0.3700493574,
0.324682951,
0.7174705267,
-0.0532686561,
0.4596869349,
0.1476927847,
-0.1524200439,
-0.4504146278,
1.2696954012,
0.1284174025,
0.8217735291,
-0.0315079801,
0.4324799478,
0.4373091757,
0.428964287,
-0.9152081609,
0.2664251626,
0.0481574349,
-1.0143589973,
0.0031239281,
-0.0790295228,
-0.9061040878,
0.2352613062,
-0.6350629926,
-0.3979261518,
0.2542014122,
-0.0585624203,
-0.589182198,
0.1125838086,
-0.5487366915,
0.5718342066,
-0.1770031452,
0.0086241774,
-0.2917485833,
-0.5635095835,
0.2583518326,
-0.0437231809,
0.432597667,
-0.7787451744,
0.0376399681,
0.5512637496,
0.1417072862,
0.4742023647,
0.2670277059,
0.1946012378,
0.2573617101,
-0.4583608508,
0.1937784553,
0.2772783041,
0.2035111338,
-0.0596495531,
-0.1084174439,
-0.2247925103,
-0.3758745193,
0.2261240631,
-0.2876657546,
-0.6222954392,
-0.5673314929,
-0.7617402077,
0.0122230826,
0.2947793901,
0.6996396184,
0.7760664225,
-0.0196102522,
0.4843326211,
0.7104970813,
0.3306153417,
0.9039945006,
0.4557656348,
-0.248188749,
-0.3258297741,
0.1776908934,
0.4115555286,
-0.1183850616,
0.2785463929,
0.0577626713,
-0.0015384188,
-0.4703645706,
-0.4017450213,
-0.356859833,
-0.4488379061,
-0.3315031826,
-0.2993879616,
-0.2153791636,
-0.2238653302,
-0.3403052092,
-0.4027991295,
-0.1672522128,
-0.3489569128,
-0.1849338412,
0.3212927282,
0.4046992064,
-0.1718556732,
0.4528721273,
-1.0079245567,
0.6731448174,
0.3909326196,
0.4379616082,
-0.5807847977,
-0.2074624002,
-0.2540806532,
-0.1327409744,
-0.6791323423,
-1.5105311871,
0.0489309579,
-0.049151957,
0.5935654044,
0.455562681,
0.3507903516,
0.1984636784,
-0.5998812318,
0.6056523323,
0.4200047553,
-0.6657562852,
0.7904481292,
-0.4143934846,
0.1323711425,
0.4149138033,
0.635230422,
-0.1096948981,
-0.3906257451,
-0.2609944642,
-0.4260492325,
0.3233704865,
0.0236573946,
0.5029078722,
-0.182682991,
0.0504692271,
-0.2648853362,
0.144478634,
-0.8113074303,
-0.2288923264,
-0.136188373,
-0.0487792902,
0.1509420723,
-0.3958814442,
-0.58657372,
0.0028863889,
0.2804418802,
-0.0768919885,
0.0951211229,
0.4008515775,
-0.2940097451,
-0.326891005,
0.3432379365,
0.6999642253,
0.9301002026,
-0.2657167614,
0.316740334,
-0.4111020863,
-0.6163352728,
0.3871755898,
0.1034581363,
-0.1695150584,
0.3122299314,
0.2127934396,
0.9177631736,
0.3653234541,
-0.4508283138,
0.887090981,
0.0719755664,
0.0311594959,
-0.1189816222,
-0.0107704233,
-0.253441602,
0.8604584336,
0.8815132976,
0.4663282931,
0.456853956,
-0.8811787963,
0.745737493,
0.5177949071,
-0.355186224,
-0.2045432031,
0.6970824003,
0.3607358932,
-0.1687784791,
0.1720777303,
0.0284753535,
-0.2510923743,
0.6277035475,
0.6388016343,
0.558159709,
0.1255427152,
0.3114558756,
0.3739538789,
0.3803780377,
-0.201132983,
0.0161558855,
0.0708772838,
-0.9969334602,
-0.3618194461,
-0.2815322578,
-0.3800557852,
-0.0892512426,
-0.8280225992,
0.2421017736,
-0.4264204204,
-0.847900033,
0.297465831,
-0.1047148779,
0.0169811416,
0.1236820966,
0.842425406,
1.0263403654,
-1.169880867,
0.7236179709,
0.5384160876,
-0.3728137314,
-0.3247058094,
0.2086355835,
0.5209786892,
-0.3583177924,
0.4774464369,
0.5679529905,
0.0491750464,
-0.130091995,
-0.4618726969,
-0.8035187721,
0.8887439966,
0.4777545631,
0.0097466204,
0.054281339,
-0.3705000877,
-0.2074432671,
-0.6771042347,
-0.012755448,
0.3865972459,
0.5597651601,
0.2674190998,
-0.8239148259,
-0.3242757916,
-0.2748351991,
-0.0550609604,
0.4901679158,
-0.7271658182,
0.92172122,
-0.2644089162,
-0.396945864,
-0.3605369925,
0.7316457629,
0.22172831,
0.8979876041,
0.1804586649,
0.641286552,
0.4554124177,
-0.2800593674,
0.7399998307,
-0.34812361,
0.3224371374,
1.0300837755,
0.1861619204,
0.7495145202,
0.2920745909,
-0.0335878581,
0.4324092865,
0.5811299682,
-0.1676750034,
0.6452397704,
-0.2453283966,
-0.21875076,
-0.1605487466,
-0.1176022962,
-0.582367897,
0.7058024406,
0.2884209454,
-0.5827261806,
-0.8017376065,
0.6100311875,
0.3454499841,
0.1738886535,
-0.4378030896,
0.5944214463,
-0.0658092275,
-0.2464145124,
0.0223430246,
-0.0093765426,
0.6685256362,
-0.4813842177,
0.0884564891,
-0.2021104246,
-0.2238366455,
-0.1552618444,
-1.2137051821,
1.0486859083,
-0.1257793158,
-0.7092426419,
-0.405205816,
0.8154996634,
-0.3891234398,
-0.2089029551,
0.046070125,
0.0930424482,
0.0086706923,
-0.4246838093,
-0.5137324333,
0.5570811033,
-0.3717979491,
-0.5670782924,
0.3217390776,
-0.0618225411,
-0.0921194553,
0.1570670158,
0.6271912456,
-0.1447070092,
0.1557878852,
-0.6317374706,
0.8364388347,
-0.6121504307,
-0.3049808741,
-0.6125365496,
0.5098712444,
-0.4752271771,
-0.5636170506,
0.5158576965,
0.6678189039,
0.5023071766,
0.1050262973,
0.4600041509,
-0.2110407203,
0.130589366,
-0.6068562269,
0.5745594501,
-0.2174160182,
-0.2948984504,
0.1152300611,
-0.6907861829,
-0.5328317285,
0.7410615087,
-0.3832208216,
-0.5040100217,
0.5931261778,
0.7800252438,
0.0401637889,
0.2903745472,
0.2994342148,
-0.3760057092,
-0.2444147766,
0.2981968522,
0.5400815606,
-0.3725921512,
0.6678981781,
-0.3220333457,
-0.4923633337,
-0.0655061826,
-0.8424826264,
-0.8546585441,
-0.5988452435,
-0.35320279,
-0.1655800194,
0.1431949884,
0.6378732324,
1.0193301439,
-0.6462737322,
0.1854193807,
0.1565071642,
0.3638189137,
-0.1001936644,
-0.2292464077,
0.3369714916,
-0.4571917057,
-0.7414221764,
0.5122953057,
0.5451495647,
0.0767493322,
0.1821116656,
0.456343472,
-0.2014425993,
0.0614071228,
0.5770199895,
0.2163833827,
-0.2983438373,
-0.4537779689,
-0.040278852,
-0.4455818236,
0.3358252048,
1.046351552,
-0.7189158201,
0.6135758162,
0.6592013836,
0.5685928464,
0.3536151052,
0.1732682735,
0.5556322932,
-0.67141819,
0.6541752815,
0.0043046153,
0.2323940843,
0.1108996123,
-0.4900006354,
0.3607519567,
0.4354872406,
-0.4740816951,
-0.5801935196,
0.4024398327,
-1.0593146086,
-0.3460103273,
0.8933666945,
-0.1531778723,
-0.1400060356,
-0.2562349141,
-0.23390387,
0.2021657974,
-0.4120853245,
0.314226836,
0.8490956426,
-0.1477605402,
-0.8164415359,
-0.7530750632,
0.325504154,
-0.2652503848,
-0.6148001552,
-0.355016619,
0.7492762804,
0.0663089082,
0.2625201643,
0.6678221822,
-0.1806828827,
0.3713608384,
0.1062649414,
-0.4461709261,
-0.2657375932,
-0.3983869255,
-0.046189554,
0.4640770257,
-0.6177836061,
-0.4717092812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17186v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17186v2
|
CLERC: A Dataset for Legal Case Retrieval and Retrieval-Augmented Analysis Generation
| 2024-06-24T23:57:57 | 2024-06-27T15:55:57 |
Abe Bohan Hou, Orion Weller, Guanghui Qin, Eugene Yang, Dawn Lawrie, Nils Holzenberger, Andrew Blair-Stanek, Benjamin Van Durme
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Legal professionals need to write analyses that rely on citations to relevant
precedents, i.e., previous case decisions. Intelligent systems assisting legal
professionals in writing such documents provide great benefits but are
challenging to design. Such systems need to help locate, summarize, and reason
over salient precedents in order to be useful. To enable systems for such
tasks, we work with legal professionals to transform a large open-source legal
corpus into a dataset supporting two important backbone tasks: information
retrieval (IR) and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). This dataset CLERC
(Case Law Evaluation Retrieval Corpus), is constructed for training and
evaluating models on their ability to (1) find corresponding citations for a
given piece of legal analysis and to (2) compile the text of these citations
(as well as previous context) into a cogent analysis that supports a reasoning
goal. We benchmark state-of-the-art models on CLERC, showing that current
approaches still struggle: GPT-4o generates analyses with the highest ROUGE
F-scores but hallucinates the most, while zero-shot IR models only achieve
48.3% recall@1000.
|
[
-0.4112641513,
-0.3726234138,
0.7661631107,
-0.1644276381,
-0.2879695594,
-0.2243241966,
-0.0946278423,
-0.3780589104,
0.0275448449,
0.7375338674,
-0.2315808982,
-0.54678303,
-0.4359367192,
-0.0507070161,
-0.7194603682,
1.1398723125,
0.1593462229,
0.1828591079,
-0.3074586987,
-0.5575001836,
-0.7332769632,
-0.9023607969,
-0.306638658,
-0.1365167499,
0.4656489491,
0.5284340382,
0.4342053533,
0.2337746769,
0.5754264593,
0.1348374039,
0.1549452245,
-0.1640660912,
-0.7419156432,
0.283352524,
-0.4414677322,
-0.1370110214,
-0.4046544135,
0.0164748169,
0.1598149836,
0.4924608767,
-0.3025869131,
0.3494303226,
-0.4466593862,
0.8431155682,
-0.9198331237,
0.0528015196,
-0.884118855,
0.0263522845,
-0.3322451711,
-0.2795555592,
-0.6856648326,
-0.3942582905,
0.3360892534,
-0.6262776256,
0.5959026217,
0.1554559022,
0.6765282154,
0.2700352669,
-0.3726678789,
-0.6578251123,
-0.5890480876,
0.4807633758,
-0.4816773534,
0.4070792198,
-0.0055575268,
0.4054429233,
-0.2945716977,
-1.099247098,
-0.4137272835,
-0.3877838552,
-0.1597198099,
0.3415470719,
-0.0793934986,
0.0286167469,
0.4334075153,
0.1535083055,
-0.5551232696,
-0.2457794994,
-0.5558745265,
-0.2125023603,
0.6208788753,
0.0417472161,
0.0285274517,
-0.0501148775,
-0.1883162409,
-0.1797596961,
-0.6288061142,
-0.1954803616,
0.4261116982,
0.2461040318,
0.3440470994,
0.5104355812,
-0.0074380925,
0.7466062903,
0.0665154681,
0.2483252436,
0.0586879067,
-0.2362312526,
-0.0927478224,
0.4092133045,
0.5352153778,
0.2893823981,
0.2259356081,
-0.026507495,
-0.3119860888,
-0.267249465,
0.475603044,
-0.7673823833,
-0.2747383416,
0.4006418288,
-0.4761378467,
-0.0922548026,
0.5282557607,
-0.7787642479,
-0.4806005359,
-0.626760006,
0.0069436664,
-0.2144892663,
0.0371370204,
0.1885519326,
-0.5051501393,
0.2414770424,
0.2540585101,
-0.3930410147,
0.4273103178,
0.5633292794,
0.5827146769,
-0.0154067492,
0.1100626886,
-0.871280849,
0.1691855937,
-0.2610008419,
0.8220717311,
-0.7323873639,
-0.5488751531,
0.1257264167,
-0.1041027531,
0.0187640898,
-0.6336948872,
0.8382688165,
-0.7444929481,
-0.058091972,
-0.3737131357,
-0.5601513982,
-0.0052589229,
0.1317014992,
-0.9280326366,
0.6848573685,
0.1753407866,
-0.9363204241,
0.6791789532,
-0.7352677584,
-0.5358042717,
0.2735489905,
-0.3305517435,
-0.4857615232,
0.1598732322,
0.0388310403,
0.2960897386,
-0.3341457844,
0.5807844996,
-0.2743674815,
-0.3554979265,
-0.0577211641,
0.1646387428,
0.5932878852,
0.4817315042,
-0.2089444548,
0.1135490313,
-0.5841602683,
-0.0658006668,
0.0932904929,
-0.1948718876,
-0.3439231515,
0.0045852596,
-0.3118455708,
0.2200610191,
0.1599175483,
-0.335963726,
-0.0132419318,
-0.0171927456,
0.3268525898,
0.5092571974,
0.2124765217,
0.3131860495,
-0.2607560158,
0.4332670569,
-0.1476128846,
0.0165281016,
-0.016773792,
-0.2080546767,
-0.6921460629,
-0.0762028173,
0.6345357895,
0.5292077065,
-0.5594575405,
0.2347390354,
-0.5079953074,
-0.3194324672,
-0.4067460001,
-0.1820862591,
0.2188334465,
0.4701734185,
0.5041023493,
-0.2521724999,
-0.8826107979,
-0.892854929,
-0.582401216,
-0.0154454773,
0.2133500725,
0.4253916442,
0.8749561906,
-0.0446877852,
0.985927999,
-0.1521694809,
-0.2200800031,
-0.3522017896,
0.2628501952,
0.3871733248,
0.2186685652,
0.4407498837,
-0.9361268878,
-0.4699903131,
0.0407358706,
-0.7457039952,
-0.1604888439,
-0.4000680745,
-0.1906693727,
0.0207327548,
0.6777323484,
-0.3246595562,
0.7649862766,
-0.256778568,
-0.3137521148,
0.7824365497,
-0.2379605472,
0.2825654149,
-0.5305121541,
0.6174730659,
-0.0632292181,
-0.3281591237,
-0.6570750475,
0.1219832078,
-0.0697040856,
0.0128353834,
-0.3067831695,
0.5859423876,
-0.494756043,
-0.3000593185,
-0.2090593427,
0.2588109374,
0.0508969203,
0.2507740855,
0.0275498983,
0.6624245644,
-0.0608796887,
-0.5337289572,
0.1333166063,
0.3236804008,
-0.3138961196,
0.7046958804,
-0.5592756271,
0.319821775,
-0.0451795831,
0.227401793,
0.0095818825,
-0.4548866451,
0.075538516,
-0.1264441013,
0.238099888,
-0.4633052945,
-0.6321187019,
-0.5549610853,
-0.1306046098,
0.3033211529,
0.1962639987,
-0.6055149436,
0.5859702229,
0.5615732074,
-0.0511740074,
-0.7729178667,
-0.3193065524,
0.0023821634,
-0.1396696121,
-0.2887804806,
0.3734893799,
0.0621902347,
-0.5068127513,
0.1062847748,
-0.0908452347,
-0.0200157259,
-0.1294952929,
0.3117823005,
0.1545976847,
-0.0094123548,
0.206496194,
0.004077571,
0.1210425198,
0.0296186544,
-0.2690551579,
0.5225176215,
-0.2124363929,
-0.3756957054,
-0.0884397775,
0.3516727984,
0.5367250443,
-0.28742823,
0.2749316692,
-0.0239888784,
-0.1007321328,
-0.1617667675,
-0.7288877964,
0.0418306254,
-0.362913698,
0.0197527371,
-0.5737445354,
-0.8543604612,
0.4794947207,
-0.004887071,
0.2438421845,
0.5980429649,
0.6196030974,
0.1537923366,
0.5092997551,
0.2632287741,
-0.1235249043,
0.4224674404,
-0.1668176055,
0.2272899449,
-0.576814115,
-0.1802870482,
-0.4911657572,
-0.0198032279,
-0.1997834444,
-0.2169640064,
0.481195569,
0.0267250668,
-0.4494578242,
0.2967936397,
-0.6411647797,
0.5451495051,
0.7926080823,
0.0350405648,
0.3719884753,
-0.0856985599,
-0.3038158715,
0.4173421562,
-0.6233753562,
-0.4336859584,
1.2662787437,
-0.0017731261,
0.2667243481,
-0.0314138308,
0.7441507578,
0.6122190356,
0.2669760287,
-0.5857858658,
0.634614706,
-0.3084250093,
-0.8894332647,
0.0487946011,
-0.2563830614,
-0.8807974458,
0.10485401,
-0.2614783943,
-0.5400878191,
0.4785082936,
0.0766198114,
-0.4930279851,
0.0697408915,
-0.5104062557,
0.7052260637,
-0.1436911523,
-0.7131108642,
-0.2425555289,
-0.8120328784,
0.4261395335,
-0.0001068405,
0.1738476455,
0.1083003506,
0.433034271,
0.5737109184,
-0.7144477367,
0.3972309828,
-0.3953677416,
0.3199580014,
0.956351757,
0.2087450624,
0.5781925917,
0.124368377,
-0.2922668755,
-0.2529534698,
0.3272530735,
-0.2046841681,
-0.5242549777,
0.5533802509,
-0.2068766952,
-0.682098031,
-0.6259579659,
-0.5473331809,
0.1539756656,
0.2391323596,
0.0734648257,
0.4154067636,
-0.3629513979,
0.208251521,
0.4349955618,
0.1482260823,
0.1254150867,
0.5991410017,
0.099506557,
-0.3456785679,
0.7894553542,
0.2259686738,
-0.3319827318,
0.0537142232,
0.0468656905,
-0.2539044619,
-0.6400337815,
-0.2303501815,
0.1356471926,
-0.8733133674,
-0.2515401244,
-0.4601167738,
-0.2307955027,
-0.4065565169,
-0.0872294605,
-0.2015478462,
-0.3427511752,
-0.1750442088,
-0.079446964,
0.3363499045,
0.7159216404,
-0.0705935955,
-0.0102187581,
-0.6693477631,
0.1748226285,
0.058705911,
0.2857385278,
-0.2687178552,
-0.509762466,
-0.1400909275,
-0.285994947,
-0.2131883204,
-0.5883693695,
0.3342831433,
0.0070874859,
0.5348002315,
0.0824017897,
0.237390399,
0.6707668304,
-0.6282538176,
0.5152670741,
0.0148172202,
-0.7461942434,
0.6979777813,
-0.2465494573,
-0.0906092525,
1.0673794746,
0.2239251137,
-0.2469187826,
-0.0229992364,
-0.8251448274,
-0.7344976664,
0.5700873137,
0.26902017,
-0.3231751323,
0.0116749657,
0.8879826665,
0.2625996768,
0.2220540643,
-0.3806970716,
0.2921414673,
-0.3171860874,
-0.4053612649,
0.4804287553,
-0.1590233594,
-0.3058593273,
-0.2763112783,
0.64998281,
-0.1844444126,
0.0857918039,
0.4926328957,
-0.2786913216,
0.3626440465,
0.2315245271,
0.5636270046,
0.6215472817,
-0.3128146529,
0.0946402848,
0.1131480932,
-0.4096540809,
-0.1319879144,
0.1963227689,
-0.0805413947,
-0.0082014473,
0.29003793,
0.6304581165,
0.0144751845,
-0.9409177303,
0.5723572969,
-0.2197615355,
-0.3795442581,
-0.7388967872,
0.1417099237,
-0.291094631,
0.2681157887,
0.3058658838,
0.0482680239,
0.4862971008,
-0.5638226271,
0.5802870393,
0.3307163417,
-0.3836927414,
-0.0520559773,
0.6473574638,
0.2049638778,
0.1106797457,
0.6077691317,
-0.2123005986,
-0.3531751037,
0.5879470706,
0.1845707893,
0.5821462274,
0.3246845007,
-0.0061104465,
0.6424479485,
-0.1072234064,
-0.5110016465,
0.2170637548,
-0.0606750734,
-0.3612526655,
-0.0730263516,
-0.4198379219,
-0.3935574591,
0.0647970363,
-0.7528300881,
0.4995512962,
-0.2935838699,
-0.2502463162,
-0.1701491624,
-0.0629582107,
-0.7185879946,
0.0207729284,
-0.1958876699,
0.868424356,
-0.4198575318,
0.763902545,
0.2272271514,
-0.6380446553,
-0.4115773439,
-0.1802058816,
-0.0962437466,
-0.3308400512,
0.7564026713,
0.0835416317,
-0.1411965042,
0.0114844143,
-0.803968966,
-0.4878762662,
1.2795091867,
0.3000295758,
-0.7882055044,
-0.0694629475,
0.1187404692,
0.6838356853,
-0.6845273376,
0.2624521255,
1.0967081785,
0.4906665683,
0.253485322,
-0.6160524487,
0.0406889319,
-0.3301669657,
-0.2337399721,
0.0529157557,
-0.3998425901,
0.5779302716,
-0.3540665209,
-0.4460635483,
0.1575219184,
0.4372731149,
0.5504202247,
0.5169161558,
0.3489578366,
0.5991539359,
0.8762817383,
-0.1384850591,
1.2748775482,
-0.5266575217,
0.2578267753,
1.664005518,
-0.4764745235,
0.8063480854,
0.4988589585,
0.2572344542,
0.6365573406,
0.2677533329,
-0.3126186132,
0.4599558711,
0.3532024622,
-0.2002850324,
-0.3198598027,
-0.2178061306,
-0.0431081876,
0.1103148684,
0.4817698002,
-0.4819531143,
-0.0719982162,
-0.3037980199,
-0.1385250688,
0.2437109351,
-0.2318813205,
0.809134841,
0.0358127169,
-0.8252444863,
0.1953568161,
-0.397195667,
-0.0098297978,
-0.2392378002,
-0.2976010442,
-0.2011090368,
0.1567877382,
-0.2721068561,
-0.8635732532,
0.2659889162,
0.1554698497,
-0.266058594,
0.1063705161,
0.867685318,
-0.0873102769,
-0.2963860035,
0.4017779529,
0.4055552781,
0.2737460732,
0.0412696935,
-0.7198938727,
-0.0525238439,
-0.1141694188,
-0.1348881871,
0.0852494463,
0.3516677916,
-0.3357714415,
0.5613864064,
0.5995842218,
0.0402017087,
0.120502919,
0.4963837266,
0.9824541807,
-0.6333121657,
-0.1025157198,
-0.5514656901,
0.6502639651,
-0.5217749476,
-0.13069354,
0.1308009028,
0.732722044,
0.6659581661,
-0.0561385863,
0.9476274848,
-0.3236646652,
0.703969419,
-0.628133893,
0.4596470296,
-0.2535913587,
0.3493300676,
0.1257947534,
-0.6775020361,
-0.3777395785,
0.3771594465,
-0.4261851609,
-0.1039606035,
0.6186353564,
0.6730853319,
-0.0714435205,
0.0299529396,
0.1796805412,
0.013319239,
0.4935237765,
0.4123503864,
0.7233097553,
-0.4687740505,
0.6480789185,
0.0272870176,
0.0418773219,
-0.4798498452,
-0.7405134439,
-0.9804129004,
-0.4451099336,
-0.0937523097,
-0.3553812504,
0.2908707559,
0.786775589,
0.4747151136,
-1.0717988014,
-0.2213308215,
-0.5086944103,
-0.0582602359,
0.1537971944,
-0.2059051394,
0.4358905554,
-0.5891028047,
-0.4418926537,
0.393825978,
0.1035906523,
-0.2328836769,
0.1127774715,
-0.0511817038,
-0.3913661838,
0.0625802055,
0.4034699798,
0.4941571355,
-0.5990140438,
-0.5777354836,
-0.133469522,
-0.0612916127,
0.2297612727,
1.3853110075,
-0.80414325,
0.7198165655,
0.519841969,
0.4335507154,
0.6387596726,
0.243900463,
0.7901164293,
-0.6490296125,
0.1508788764,
0.4674069285,
0.6254523396,
0.0895491764,
-0.1027421877,
0.8915241361,
0.1934634745,
-0.7925055623,
-0.7394387126,
-0.0220115203,
-0.8086692095,
-0.4819509685,
0.86577636,
-0.0773305893,
-0.2202288508,
-0.3493022919,
-0.2398876846,
0.3058029115,
-0.5267385244,
0.5898852348,
0.6471507549,
-0.2252312005,
0.032195881,
-0.9037377834,
0.4956127107,
0.0653847605,
-0.6560639143,
0.1103866771,
0.7287661433,
0.2963915467,
0.349153012,
0.5478239655,
-0.3147631884,
0.4032048583,
0.0006051192,
0.3589285612,
0.0444188192,
-0.4437516332,
-0.1523594111,
0.4365501106,
-0.1898178458,
0.3416640162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17185v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17185v1
|
Vaporetto: Efficient Japanese Tokenization Based on Improved Pointwise Linear Classification
| 2024-06-24T23:47:20 | 2024-06-24T23:47:20 |
Koichi Akabe, Shunsuke Kanda, Yusuke Oda, Shinsuke Mori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper proposes an approach to improve the runtime efficiency of Japanese
tokenization based on the pointwise linear classification (PLC) framework,
which formulates the whole tokenization process as a sequence of linear
classification problems. Our approach optimizes tokenization by leveraging the
characteristics of the PLC framework and the task definition. Our approach
involves (1) composing multiple classifications into array-based operations,
(2) efficient feature lookup with memory-optimized automata, and (3) three
orthogonal pre-processing methods for reducing actual score calculation. Thus,
our approach makes the tokenization speed 5.7 times faster than the current
approach based on the same model without decreasing tokenization accuracy. Our
implementation is available at https://github.com/daac-tools/vaporetto under
the MIT or Apache-2.0 license.
|
[
-0.2316069603,
-0.3731926382,
0.4224423766,
0.1288167089,
-0.5315132737,
0.1116066948,
-0.057678733,
-0.40481776,
0.2496346384,
0.2694624364,
-0.1215761453,
-0.5763511658,
-0.5781239271,
-0.3559113443,
-0.3450412452,
0.6105194688,
-0.2790131271,
0.2566766143,
0.2476943582,
-0.0821234062,
-0.4339361787,
-0.7914245725,
-0.8912772536,
-0.0112299928,
0.3945941031,
0.3726020455,
0.3976371884,
0.8210788965,
0.5711377859,
0.3779300451,
0.0191248879,
-0.1644156724,
-0.5450388789,
0.0545896292,
0.0872822031,
-0.6199628115,
-0.4921919107,
-0.445012778,
0.4318865836,
0.3706045747,
-0.1070443019,
0.2269029468,
0.0021942616,
0.2492970526,
-1.0772885084,
0.132197991,
-0.517450273,
0.1924440712,
-0.3282805681,
-0.4169275761,
-0.3202948868,
-0.594481349,
-0.2527730465,
-0.7834217548,
0.1275051981,
-0.011557674,
0.6834538579,
-0.0243893825,
-0.2671581209,
-0.0725916773,
-0.6444464326,
0.6453070641,
-0.7375975251,
0.1889731139,
-0.1375500262,
0.57616359,
0.0472972766,
-1.028090477,
-0.4385690689,
0.1170616969,
0.174360618,
-0.0888226032,
-0.145742476,
0.4902060926,
0.361805886,
0.1416761577,
-0.4262019992,
0.4623228312,
-0.3196643889,
-0.3552114666,
0.3154891431,
0.3098894358,
0.3284589946,
-0.5160660744,
-0.5636513829,
-0.1140183806,
-0.5864227414,
0.4076725543,
0.3103130162,
0.3143310249,
0.3095625043,
0.2882348001,
-0.2590737641,
0.6777918935,
-0.0201428011,
-0.3613350987,
0.2830325663,
-0.3959662318,
-0.0836065859,
0.313213557,
0.7965250015,
0.5010746717,
-0.0568413921,
0.1934069991,
-0.2588166893,
-0.2946299613,
0.1846531779,
-1.2908657789,
-0.2606035769,
0.1088306457,
-0.8984122872,
-0.4038033783,
0.507586658,
-0.6914432049,
-0.0780192018,
-0.1375340521,
0.5144764185,
-0.6452528238,
-0.1415694356,
-0.1187956259,
-0.5260409117,
0.2392600179,
0.4264658093,
-0.7726628184,
0.2291971743,
1.2089099884,
1.3081852198,
-0.232220158,
-0.1387715936,
-0.3836417794,
0.3051399291,
-0.2783117294,
0.6207427979,
-0.4011884928,
-0.7984665632,
-0.3338390291,
-0.4548900127,
0.0778667182,
-0.3900974989,
0.1941695809,
-0.0224646851,
0.1598491669,
-0.3157387376,
-0.4746236801,
-0.2931302488,
0.0703138635,
-0.3687051833,
1.0880081654,
0.1371845603,
-0.6409047246,
0.5445910692,
-0.7193850279,
-0.3273382187,
0.3661513031,
-0.0159282349,
-0.1243641675,
0.3469679058,
0.261407882,
0.4272740483,
-0.1125336066,
0.5156276226,
-0.243009761,
-0.8289115429,
0.0126252705,
-0.5824933648,
0.8865767717,
0.2340348959,
-0.7104170322,
0.2612810433,
-0.9342640638,
0.4015919864,
-0.380548507,
0.0284033064,
-0.525223732,
0.0181234982,
0.1353773922,
0.0993878096,
0.557646811,
-0.3196111321,
0.4002546668,
-0.6193172932,
0.3034850061,
1.0115013123,
0.1778972894,
0.1519914865,
0.1187841743,
0.7367378473,
-0.0375389121,
0.7682372928,
-0.191254884,
-0.5343059897,
-1.1734435558,
-0.4819414914,
0.3085274398,
0.4811411798,
-0.922670722,
0.86122787,
-0.1691459268,
-0.8252661228,
-0.2054014951,
-0.2859305441,
0.5418865681,
0.6478427649,
0.2509468198,
-0.6760892272,
-0.7092093825,
-0.8941125274,
-0.0986530036,
-0.3535319567,
0.0162902158,
0.0488266349,
0.2682080865,
-0.0490280241,
0.7194988132,
-0.6343415976,
0.1182416528,
0.0314186662,
0.384368062,
0.3876378238,
0.7187922597,
0.7486075759,
-0.4402891397,
-0.6250975728,
0.2122715563,
-0.4480423629,
-0.1207182854,
0.0786996558,
-0.2354488373,
-0.0629324391,
0.3823741674,
-0.1520220935,
0.7802810073,
-0.0044443263,
-0.2441551983,
0.1892743558,
-0.1926948577,
0.4933810234,
-1.1279972792,
0.4150299132,
-0.3483480811,
-0.3475316167,
-0.7225568295,
-0.0022442227,
-0.0169772748,
-0.2842674255,
-0.5248803496,
0.118309997,
-0.2076674402,
-0.0760959759,
-0.418408215,
0.0211466756,
-0.0807310715,
0.5117205381,
-0.1125434786,
0.8077515364,
0.8104290366,
-0.7263745666,
0.4202114344,
-0.3338628113,
-0.2323207259,
0.8392552137,
-0.5784521699,
0.0807913765,
-0.1877135485,
0.1301695406,
-0.7665649652,
0.2810561359,
0.4305794239,
-0.3289276659,
0.097177282,
0.0266480651,
-0.1266672611,
-0.4726216495,
-0.7495406866,
0.3649018109,
0.451377064,
-0.6785151362,
0.5716324449,
0.3015457094,
0.0557630435,
-0.6612862945,
-0.4507531524,
-0.0200456437,
-0.3116202652,
0.0389751904,
0.4644297659,
0.1986041814,
0.1186951101,
-0.1565457135,
-0.1658467501,
-0.1966089755,
0.2077046633,
0.2573970854,
0.2580692172,
-0.1211587116,
0.0976605266,
0.1986906081,
-0.5569190383,
-0.2494000047,
-0.6099749207,
0.7553742528,
0.0994559228,
-0.1860103458,
-0.9416716099,
0.2163447738,
0.4240692854,
0.0382166356,
0.6342929602,
0.6305016875,
-0.3444957137,
-0.2475785166,
-0.2351355255,
0.1877503842,
-0.5528952479,
0.5487665534,
-0.6731106043,
-0.5642613173,
0.4811464548,
-0.0021717385,
-0.1136636809,
0.5069932938,
0.4457209408,
0.2105123401,
1.0829485655,
0.5054388642,
-0.2997453809,
0.7891284227,
-0.4981062114,
0.4874997139,
-0.6785440445,
-0.5553301573,
-0.9519206882,
-0.3730925322,
-0.5528947711,
-0.5678533316,
0.5323286057,
0.3482113183,
-0.381714344,
0.6031842828,
-0.8600537777,
0.5053489804,
0.5736815333,
-0.0120666716,
0.1103350669,
-0.4481015801,
-0.0815724432,
0.0012200275,
-0.9073988795,
-0.2648155093,
1.1560336351,
0.1927361935,
0.4664695263,
0.0960340798,
0.9125598073,
0.1260147393,
0.253156513,
-0.9236884713,
0.6596086025,
-0.1559548378,
-0.2223958075,
-0.0858863145,
-0.5364521742,
-0.758279264,
0.3212543726,
0.0186477751,
-0.8654619455,
0.3471518159,
0.1701388061,
-0.1710003465,
0.3459480703,
-0.5877223611,
0.8931165338,
-0.7877141237,
0.0623071827,
-0.2856110334,
-0.1393673271,
0.3174006343,
-0.0967891216,
0.0220839195,
0.0082940431,
-0.4824308753,
1.0623660088,
-1.2190573215,
0.6307182908,
-0.9640848041,
0.1556272954,
0.1659892201,
-0.1070298478,
0.2836304605,
-0.0016488446,
-0.1331769377,
0.2379728258,
0.2644792795,
-0.3509055674,
-0.9447104335,
0.7364723682,
-0.8376551867,
-0.3407753408,
-0.4464995563,
0.1275823563,
-0.0267675575,
0.4919043183,
0.5926440358,
0.5488981009,
-0.1820914447,
0.0503124148,
0.1186923981,
0.0867326409,
0.5442372561,
0.2422665805,
-0.5380179286,
-0.699770689,
0.9958266616,
0.3295091987,
-0.1484542489,
0.5569837689,
0.2482304275,
-0.2860561609,
-0.9029178023,
-0.2460281402,
-0.2644023597,
-0.8130981326,
-0.5066777468,
-0.222317338,
0.0121519575,
-0.4940930009,
-0.2935661972,
-0.5192641616,
-0.7955537438,
-0.4737698138,
0.0373148024,
0.2658485472,
0.6292713284,
0.2054751366,
0.7161235809,
-0.5298385024,
0.3579359651,
0.1218750924,
0.5395405293,
0.3012471199,
-0.3560684919,
-0.2470098585,
-0.1849521846,
-0.1908304095,
-0.7880545259,
0.1627535224,
0.1732751578,
0.6966608167,
0.7236696482,
-0.159941107,
1.3326519728,
-0.2637884915,
0.8421929479,
0.7180587053,
-1.6257115602,
0.7034467459,
0.1114739999,
0.0750263259,
1.0590715408,
0.5935656428,
-0.5548685789,
-0.0933606997,
-0.5223745108,
-1.1519397497,
0.4965346456,
-0.1248026416,
-0.0467909724,
0.1643065661,
0.5635172129,
0.1457803994,
0.3815213144,
-0.4525854886,
-0.2064648122,
-0.5572267771,
-0.3715147376,
-0.0579145625,
-0.1381976306,
0.4448378682,
-0.6190823317,
0.7847779989,
-0.2285975665,
0.1542354375,
-0.0396657474,
0.0934567526,
0.2019566745,
-0.2389134467,
0.3583367467,
0.755186379,
-0.0089346012,
-0.1054260656,
0.1191010922,
-0.4558650255,
0.3452472091,
-0.1920695603,
-0.4939249158,
0.0100474786,
0.286950469,
1.2120945454,
0.3777706027,
-0.5104294419,
0.7398647666,
-0.1727656722,
-0.0693450719,
-0.2916828096,
0.5574494004,
-0.4373878837,
-0.0170938913,
0.1739629656,
0.1015664116,
0.5709993243,
-0.4804115593,
0.1265594512,
0.4056348205,
-0.2737208009,
-0.0162449535,
0.5846797228,
0.4335951507,
-0.6338061094,
0.3888424039,
0.0050178254,
-0.7094696164,
0.4893357456,
0.4449493289,
1.1338287592,
-0.353203088,
0.1107410342,
0.5797311068,
-0.0450957753,
-0.103674233,
0.1690547913,
-0.4915452302,
-0.4428525567,
-0.1675545871,
-0.5245093703,
-0.6340245008,
-0.3644037247,
-0.7156150937,
0.5875229836,
-1.0666632652,
-0.2973871827,
-0.2168373466,
-0.1061443165,
-0.2424608767,
0.0012858917,
-0.0900187641,
0.8685349226,
-0.5313808918,
1.088263154,
0.0629593283,
-0.1228441745,
-0.9182989597,
-0.0596189611,
-0.2225630879,
-0.5901835561,
0.5349289179,
0.4336760342,
-0.3674860597,
-0.0897926539,
-0.0651146844,
-0.9578804374,
1.2666628361,
0.1572207808,
-0.8979073167,
0.0414841175,
-0.0085955048,
0.5885618329,
-0.2793108523,
0.4887940288,
0.662507534,
0.5567714572,
0.0680449232,
-0.8763088584,
-0.1806024462,
-0.491538614,
0.6697114706,
0.3816518784,
-0.704102695,
0.6969975233,
0.4550777972,
-0.041951783,
0.2320388556,
0.6042455435,
0.0796230882,
0.1892013997,
0.4487770498,
0.4831860065,
1.2195856571,
-0.2125725746,
0.7859940529,
-0.56254071,
0.5049760938,
0.6898002028,
-0.1924929917,
0.9557892084,
0.4668267071,
-0.2905869782,
0.724502027,
0.3167667091,
-0.0489926189,
0.2905223668,
0.3601083457,
-0.2024143189,
0.1594808698,
0.1469960511,
-0.2895369232,
0.9481265545,
0.0127491588,
-0.1500033587,
0.0867865682,
0.3728174269,
0.1988537461,
-0.03451626,
-0.7476231456,
0.7110773325,
-0.3097288907,
-0.6611056924,
0.8035875559,
0.4535695016,
1.0733237267,
-0.7986623645,
0.2083930224,
0.0838799551,
0.1803174317,
-0.1907168329,
-0.3043168485,
0.2315347791,
0.2916971445,
0.1545042992,
-0.3057173491,
0.6390487552,
-0.0221007895,
-0.6503516436,
0.1276318729,
-0.06520731,
0.1042501926,
0.2165404111,
-0.7662975192,
0.1938299686,
0.0726052895,
-0.2277340889,
0.0172182433,
0.1771710813,
-0.0308607351,
0.5057162642,
0.572480619,
0.3474902511,
0.0891873837,
0.1136608124,
0.7271517515,
-0.8933845758,
-0.9026350975,
-0.9146455526,
0.3463504314,
-0.4376936257,
-0.422322154,
0.8305177093,
0.9463879466,
0.6446979642,
0.101090543,
0.7907348871,
-0.2084764987,
0.2536291778,
-0.7325536013,
0.5112145543,
-0.3346261382,
0.2466554791,
-0.2860921323,
-0.9422875643,
-0.4891982973,
0.6706390977,
-0.1924509108,
0.2867948711,
0.7173938751,
0.7309191823,
0.1168274954,
-0.2499942929,
0.131635502,
-0.064415589,
0.7244702578,
0.9283074737,
0.5194931626,
-0.4910369217,
0.2080328315,
-0.6356087327,
-0.3451767862,
-0.302531302,
-0.9330796003,
-0.5952964425,
-0.3919475377,
-0.2279356122,
-0.1276813298,
-0.1309236437,
0.7570794225,
0.7600254416,
-0.964206636,
-0.3827335238,
-0.3352683187,
0.0819311813,
-0.0752120838,
-0.2843771875,
0.4182348847,
-0.3317681253,
-0.8659390211,
0.2008562833,
0.6549690366,
-0.155559212,
-0.4024500847,
-0.184650898,
0.2597759664,
-0.087198548,
0.3682080805,
0.1859840006,
-0.3931106925,
-0.5244899392,
-0.3959391415,
0.130720824,
0.2697837353,
1.295150876,
-0.7996656895,
0.6079381704,
0.7793343067,
0.2035609633,
0.766254127,
0.1796642691,
0.4846951962,
-0.4067590535,
0.6536586285,
0.2666707337,
0.3961695731,
0.0832277238,
-0.3662877083,
0.1197168231,
0.5486671329,
-0.1034587994,
-0.6921592951,
0.0405219421,
-1.0249190331,
-0.4594556987,
0.5933932662,
-0.2638454437,
-0.6005911827,
-0.0387972146,
-0.3972357512,
0.2311176509,
-0.1018484384,
0.4583549201,
0.2406714559,
-0.2881154418,
-0.0398837179,
0.0611447804,
0.3356380761,
0.0465148538,
-0.863512516,
-0.1903342009,
0.3399251699,
0.2801243067,
0.1074803621,
0.9790843725,
-0.117045261,
0.3938087821,
0.0627990887,
0.2692767978,
-0.2642713785,
-0.4336952567,
-0.515550375,
0.4411054552,
0.37252599,
-0.2571464181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17169v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17169v1
|
Multi-LogiEval: Towards Evaluating Multi-Step Logical Reasoning Ability of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-24T23:02:56 | 2024-06-24T23:02:56 |
Nisarg Patel, Mohith Kulkarni, Mihir Parmar, Aashna Budhiraja, Mutsumi Nakamura, Neeraj Varshney, Chitta Baral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) continue to exhibit remarkable performance in
natural language understanding tasks, there is a crucial need to measure their
ability for human-like multi-step logical reasoning. Existing logical reasoning
evaluation benchmarks often focus primarily on simplistic single-step or
multi-step reasoning with a limited set of inference rules. Furthermore, the
lack of datasets for evaluating non-monotonic reasoning represents a crucial
gap since it aligns more closely with human-like reasoning. To address these
limitations, we propose Multi-LogiEval, a comprehensive evaluation dataset
encompassing multi-step logical reasoning with various inference rules and
depths. Multi-LogiEval covers three logic types--propositional, first-order,
and non-monotonic--consisting of more than 30 inference rules and more than 60
of their combinations with various depths. Leveraging this dataset, we conduct
evaluations on a range of LLMs including GPT-4, ChatGPT, Gemini-Pro, Yi, Orca,
and Mistral, employing a zero-shot chain-of-thought. Experimental results show
that there is a significant drop in the performance of LLMs as the reasoning
steps/depth increases (average accuracy of ~68% at depth-1 to ~43% at depth-5).
We further conduct a thorough investigation of reasoning chains generated by
LLMs which reveals several important findings. We believe that Multi-LogiEval
facilitates future research for evaluating and enhancing the logical reasoning
ability of LLMs. Data is available at
https://github.com/Mihir3009/Multi-LogiEval.
|
[
-0.3429858983,
-0.8251213431,
0.6384547353,
0.2784062326,
-0.2689681053,
0.0942905024,
-0.1901396215,
-0.3995067775,
-0.1271924227,
0.5381228924,
-0.5782901645,
-0.7055991888,
-0.5995634198,
0.1285091788,
-0.2819342017,
0.9094436765,
0.142903015,
0.1037546396,
-0.2772643864,
-0.3895508051,
-0.5910328627,
-0.428153336,
-0.6342505217,
-0.4059358239,
0.4951097667,
0.3811357617,
0.5859256983,
0.0579277091,
0.3295490146,
0.2693042159,
-0.2014352977,
0.2739415467,
-0.33100757,
0.0656732768,
-0.1478970051,
-0.4897319674,
-0.5670961738,
-0.1051191539,
0.8975008726,
0.4489757419,
-0.1814168692,
0.2813488543,
-0.1991929263,
0.82700634,
-0.6522477269,
0.2380625904,
-0.6714570522,
0.0160838999,
-0.0324511118,
-0.0484882817,
-0.6424732804,
-0.4043040276,
-0.0112126982,
-0.3000942469,
-0.0837062374,
0.0743570253,
0.3342144787,
0.1415764689,
-0.781281352,
-0.2323643714,
-0.4365030825,
0.8841903806,
-0.7919801474,
0.6771786213,
0.0136686759,
0.220861882,
-0.2440179884,
-0.4661362767,
-0.4747108519,
-0.4205488265,
-0.2169153243,
0.0130289979,
-0.0305586029,
0.1487784833,
0.4069282413,
0.2518261075,
-0.7009706497,
-0.0714365393,
-0.1097443178,
-0.2275671661,
0.7018944025,
0.3658151031,
0.0697659031,
-0.1176134348,
-0.4505178034,
-0.2152134925,
-0.5020653009,
0.3354634941,
0.2587149143,
0.2610065341,
0.1778207272,
0.4846235812,
-0.2257472575,
1.0833183527,
-0.3422835767,
-0.7257378101,
0.411344409,
-0.7536215782,
-0.338984549,
0.0965029374,
0.7172050476,
0.2113123387,
0.2883259356,
0.1683746576,
-0.2734043896,
0.1865773648,
-0.0872100443,
-0.7806369662,
-0.1123909056,
0.218480885,
-0.3388758004,
-0.0712459162,
-0.1796047986,
-0.9118179679,
-0.4868945479,
-0.2309701294,
0.5649535656,
-0.5324019194,
-0.2587560415,
0.6812110543,
-0.1545609981,
0.2953318059,
0.6223755479,
-0.55426687,
0.4473816752,
0.6303635836,
0.5720584393,
0.1827858686,
-0.590212822,
-0.7973120809,
-0.1302070618,
-0.3633772731,
0.9409762621,
-0.8052151203,
-0.124293223,
-0.3466754258,
-0.1883555055,
-0.3524116576,
-0.416824311,
0.931429565,
-0.4924590588,
-0.0489794798,
0.0291081332,
-0.6159417033,
-0.4069296718,
0.41173473,
-0.755300045,
0.8341593742,
-0.3326611817,
-0.7079093456,
0.5138878822,
-0.7777515054,
-0.7522186637,
-0.0609761477,
-0.289180696,
-0.2205171734,
0.1171003655,
0.3858615756,
0.2888964117,
-0.615445137,
0.1870565861,
-0.4093095064,
-0.2475356609,
0.0880217403,
-0.7206693292,
0.9167137146,
-0.0924758166,
-0.2481592894,
0.0843251199,
-0.8700663447,
0.2039681971,
-0.0945205241,
-0.4214705229,
-0.3747848272,
-0.0366907641,
-0.4155115187,
0.4876408875,
0.1059784293,
-0.4712663293,
0.2733100951,
-0.1548843235,
0.2192746252,
0.661861062,
0.1935947239,
-0.0189974103,
-0.0948723406,
0.454192251,
0.1622845531,
0.3728176951,
-0.4565366209,
-0.7463728786,
-0.6964511871,
-0.6064684391,
0.2011757493,
0.6896197796,
-0.4013159871,
0.264108181,
-0.0837897211,
-0.5041450262,
-0.5296325088,
0.3035807312,
0.4860984385,
0.4113897979,
0.489176333,
-0.2168227732,
-0.1308821291,
-0.9132440686,
-0.5241482854,
-0.4024930298,
0.062177293,
0.1956321299,
0.6005134583,
-0.1909965277,
0.4675156772,
-0.3252739608,
0.0590655282,
0.0142551521,
0.423843801,
0.6097458005,
0.1366118044,
-0.0471221246,
-0.5253484249,
0.0041910443,
-0.0232478771,
-0.7193830013,
0.1949374676,
-0.3057198524,
-0.1829526275,
0.2034257352,
0.1334720999,
-1.0631732941,
0.5175917149,
0.45160079,
-0.6142117977,
0.7602021694,
-0.1194892377,
0.4683072269,
-0.5197776556,
-0.0655938908,
0.2108671069,
-0.2183685303,
-0.659968853,
0.1077237427,
0.1130582839,
0.2454056591,
-0.2766207755,
0.5589148998,
-0.4049275815,
-0.1222392172,
0.1797687113,
0.3025497198,
0.3168561161,
0.3454224169,
0.1234678701,
0.3930248618,
0.6379137039,
-0.5919007659,
0.5803975463,
0.1776880324,
-0.8134770989,
0.614054203,
-0.4392664731,
0.2665602565,
-0.1483350396,
0.4495589137,
-1.0782608986,
0.1633815914,
0.0660372153,
-0.2171039283,
0.0331110843,
-0.1633933634,
-0.8826654553,
-0.3152052164,
-0.2992240787,
0.4717293978,
0.195233196,
-0.4586339295,
0.7321448326,
0.0697507933,
-0.0898654982,
-0.7182592154,
-0.4608395696,
0.2052609324,
-0.3055109978,
-0.9308668375,
-0.1783971936,
-0.2561046183,
-0.4404129088,
-0.0721800551,
-0.3272699416,
-0.0054327436,
-0.0475736298,
-0.1417320967,
0.3597455323,
-0.3232302368,
0.3145806193,
0.0012562982,
-0.0727787986,
0.1350669265,
-0.5309221745,
0.2179097682,
-0.6386498213,
-0.6281815767,
-0.1975428313,
0.0636226609,
0.8230425119,
-0.5601686835,
0.7187701464,
0.5024536848,
-0.448094517,
-0.0562627651,
-0.7121139169,
-0.1134051308,
-0.2787776291,
0.1695953161,
-0.7164891958,
-0.9166012406,
0.1843201369,
-0.0873217657,
0.2200291902,
0.4246660173,
0.6516657472,
0.1940613687,
0.9059609175,
0.096077852,
-0.0224336311,
-0.2266619802,
0.0663834363,
0.5093762279,
-0.5323976278,
-0.4494746029,
-0.4744536877,
0.0050234678,
-0.5462717414,
-0.6710537076,
0.2917949855,
0.391333282,
-0.2120636404,
0.1526869237,
-0.0348687135,
0.4847019911,
0.2215477079,
0.0487754941,
0.8710483909,
-0.2040710449,
-0.4127286375,
0.3193095922,
-0.6375901103,
-0.5361867547,
0.9539551139,
0.4516090453,
0.9218887687,
0.24886702,
0.56729877,
0.2475252151,
0.1611188203,
-0.9133532047,
0.680870533,
0.062675111,
-0.9345562458,
-0.7315148115,
-0.5852199197,
-0.7044335604,
0.678635478,
-0.0917021111,
-0.9325492382,
0.0849161819,
0.0898422822,
-0.309124589,
0.3170524538,
-0.75170362,
1.0724585056,
-0.5063050985,
-0.2700373828,
-0.4945700169,
-0.6617075801,
0.8426746726,
-0.3546318412,
0.5266646743,
-0.2733525634,
0.0323765725,
0.3954129815,
-0.2900134921,
0.6325718164,
-0.2327850312,
-0.3234141469,
0.5328856707,
0.2079799175,
0.487044096,
0.3408729136,
-0.1863359958,
0.1668117493,
0.2934102118,
-0.3704716861,
-0.7654007077,
0.5416305661,
-0.2673642337,
-0.5615242124,
-0.3460969627,
-0.3494796455,
-0.3924103081,
0.101382874,
-0.2912744284,
0.5196387172,
-0.0456031114,
0.1365943998,
0.6245601177,
-0.1883437186,
0.2277028114,
0.3186040819,
-0.3903239071,
-0.4018156528,
0.7639195323,
-0.2025301903,
0.3717577755,
0.5192283392,
0.2168862522,
-0.6670534015,
-0.3305293024,
-0.6448730826,
0.1964587122,
-1.0613725185,
-0.1086569652,
-0.4638445079,
-0.0385822803,
-0.1143866479,
0.3837407827,
-0.2733640373,
-0.4501498938,
0.2664701939,
-0.1661441773,
0.3469679058,
0.7232391238,
0.0997527838,
-0.3644332588,
-1.0143238306,
0.3842329085,
0.4900556207,
0.3766074181,
0.0419996269,
-0.4846304655,
-0.0373487733,
-0.2328456491,
0.0183754228,
-0.7016250491,
-0.0708335936,
0.1340127885,
0.6892619729,
0.3196111023,
-0.2205087245,
0.9016101956,
-0.5881942511,
0.4977680445,
0.4100990891,
-1.086006403,
0.4555538595,
-0.027121786,
0.3988976479,
0.6940391064,
0.3091879785,
-0.5851509571,
-0.1629176587,
-0.4072750509,
-0.627014637,
0.4625636041,
0.2553768158,
-0.2052404135,
0.0657826662,
0.0790148675,
0.1986993849,
0.4341789782,
-0.6983128786,
-0.1568839699,
-0.0310482178,
0.115055494,
-0.2691531181,
-0.0191665981,
-0.0311018173,
-0.4645528495,
0.5509161949,
-0.1422662884,
0.1259497553,
0.0491815992,
-0.2274311781,
0.1229987741,
0.5663403273,
0.5780196786,
0.9437557459,
-0.2142483741,
0.3171413541,
0.4128267169,
-0.0850370899,
0.3180189729,
0.0629220456,
0.2479820848,
-0.0537674353,
0.8321069479,
0.8269487619,
0.1930226535,
-0.9043151736,
0.4635182917,
-0.2481229156,
-0.1849714816,
-0.0988945365,
-0.0063733682,
0.2386012077,
0.3871687651,
0.112186864,
0.0865109414,
0.1712807417,
-0.6995071769,
0.3143713474,
0.3411875665,
-0.1195893362,
-0.1345549971,
0.1799777597,
-0.0168004539,
-0.1523587406,
0.7626358271,
-0.4157207012,
-0.2268959582,
0.3796531558,
0.3482653499,
0.6799187064,
-0.2267059535,
0.1997224987,
0.4696165621,
0.6953415871,
0.0469737723,
0.3089728951,
0.0341132954,
-0.8369861245,
-0.8788653612,
-0.8072892427,
-0.2466726303,
0.3660221398,
-0.5338599086,
0.3193572462,
-0.4251182675,
-0.0378085338,
0.0364781767,
-0.1827144027,
-0.7738856077,
0.2453126609,
0.1067314669,
1.2341811657,
-0.8207597733,
0.7386370897,
0.6821309924,
-0.2287923098,
-0.4884053767,
0.1325308084,
0.137831673,
-0.721029222,
0.6068155766,
0.3438537419,
-0.6438169479,
-0.1938107312,
-0.2484448552,
-0.5101887584,
0.9878014922,
0.2786225975,
-0.6888798475,
0.1917258203,
-0.0143752182,
0.5793294311,
-0.4794931412,
0.5820702314,
0.945012331,
0.8340466022,
0.1576489657,
-0.9064918756,
-0.0052192467,
-0.1549604833,
-0.1387070417,
0.3874527216,
-0.685099721,
0.6844449639,
-0.2595561147,
-0.0420143753,
-0.2179080993,
0.2327304929,
0.6628776789,
0.2752307951,
0.8690927625,
0.8809410334,
1.0078955889,
0.1782612801,
0.9765086174,
-0.2662850618,
0.2997220159,
1.0955715179,
-0.5088561177,
0.851246655,
0.3051471114,
-0.212728098,
0.7323608994,
0.6018619537,
0.2597620785,
0.2170196772,
0.4185371995,
-0.6313027143,
-0.6878665686,
0.0135922423,
-0.0047828611,
0.5560032129,
0.4740101397,
-0.0111177666,
-0.1790301353,
-0.3368288577,
-0.0804811493,
-0.2931489348,
-0.2964899242,
0.584015131,
0.1048098952,
-0.6473654509,
0.708458364,
0.0603986792,
0.2507136166,
-0.5346257091,
-0.3219776154,
-0.1531464159,
0.024882542,
-0.2382252514,
-0.9314938784,
-0.1136910841,
0.1309797466,
0.1393319815,
0.1117035598,
0.8531689644,
-0.133075878,
-0.7280507088,
0.7617232203,
0.6218188405,
0.4052810371,
0.0211609639,
-0.7816436887,
0.0361529142,
-0.0576329529,
-0.3611560166,
0.1408884078,
0.6196529269,
-0.1063843817,
0.7339025736,
0.4895308316,
-0.1081414521,
0.1211471558,
0.4521668851,
0.7186630368,
-0.8469839096,
0.051330816,
-1.1918110847,
0.7178640366,
0.0811501816,
-0.2683533132,
0.6004918814,
0.6524879932,
0.8534933925,
0.0378809124,
0.8048149347,
0.1119170934,
0.1742368788,
-0.8206936121,
0.0364325903,
-0.5556318164,
0.2362928241,
-0.430637151,
-0.8811945319,
-0.3110640049,
0.6270393729,
-0.1864379346,
0.1406085938,
1.0455087423,
0.6745560765,
-0.0054187067,
0.2923043668,
0.5360538363,
0.2451614588,
0.090676859,
0.8066960573,
1.0906351805,
-0.1757810712,
0.5545043349,
0.1167659014,
-0.4518763721,
0.074016571,
-1.0846819878,
-1.0487644672,
-0.2925688624,
-0.1805590987,
-0.1873916984,
0.0265743714,
0.8632817864,
0.5455297828,
-0.7286745906,
-0.4691983759,
-0.0127750533,
0.3057820499,
-0.2759473026,
-0.1629833728,
0.072121866,
-0.4223251343,
-0.3345368505,
0.682074964,
0.712161243,
-0.4405078888,
-0.3888031244,
-0.1714210808,
-0.6187713146,
0.1481032223,
1.0653297901,
-0.0721907467,
-0.8515899777,
-0.2780436575,
-0.240266785,
0.300822258,
0.2145590037,
0.8199642301,
-0.6474352479,
0.5395801663,
0.5022523403,
0.7462202311,
0.7599253058,
-0.0082848649,
0.1554586142,
-0.3938825727,
-0.0458774045,
0.1386709213,
0.4311625063,
0.0984244049,
-0.0995043963,
0.4521199465,
0.2494032234,
-0.4615903497,
-0.5634558797,
0.3851106167,
-0.4713961184,
-0.2362833768,
0.9703782201,
-0.3146049082,
0.0574258715,
-0.0066887559,
0.0045348974,
-0.0531751141,
-0.3935678899,
0.3205784857,
1.0702829361,
-0.6306137443,
-0.3462176323,
-0.9434105754,
0.0710046068,
0.4657890201,
-1.1154390574,
0.1515373141,
0.7261555195,
0.2301591635,
0.2363868505,
0.6655666828,
-0.2115031481,
0.0268400274,
0.0573393516,
-0.0711818635,
0.4353853166,
-0.9051623344,
-0.5439924002,
0.0290527456,
0.3622670472,
0.0179069899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17163v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17163v1
|
Paraphrase and Aggregate with Large Language Models for Minimizing Intent Classification Errors
| 2024-06-24T22:30:26 | 2024-06-24T22:30:26 |
Vikas Yadav, Zheng Tang, Vijay Srinivasan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLM) have achieved remarkable success in natural
language generation but lesser focus has been given to their applicability in
decision making tasks such as classification. We show that LLMs like LLaMa can
achieve high performance on large multi-class classification tasks but still
make classification errors and worse, generate out-of-vocabulary class labels.
To address these critical issues, we introduce Paraphrase and AGgregate
(PAG)-LLM approach wherein an LLM generates multiple paraphrases of the input
query (parallel queries), performs multi-class classification for the original
query and each paraphrase, and at the end aggregate all the classification
labels based on their confidence scores. We evaluate PAG-LLM on two large
multi-class classication datasets: CLINC, and Banking and show 22.7% and 15.1%
error reduction. We show that PAG-LLM is especially effective for hard examples
where LLM is uncertain, and reduces the critical misclassification and
hallucinated label generation errors
|
[
-0.1017630547,
-0.9892476201,
0.7700838447,
0.3748196065,
-0.2697588503,
-0.0254241265,
-0.2919465303,
-0.1125400364,
-0.0145824607,
0.8127089739,
0.1127858832,
-0.6669849157,
-0.7580641508,
0.1088539734,
-0.4695056677,
0.9957818985,
0.0408745892,
-0.0981604308,
-0.4522527456,
-0.2760770023,
-0.1348216385,
-0.9374630451,
-0.9372668862,
-0.1029185206,
0.3644852638,
0.5348801017,
0.7368622422,
0.4488131702,
0.5905331969,
0.2731074989,
-0.2484229803,
0.3964605927,
-0.4097745717,
0.2112967223,
-0.0457622297,
-0.4422560632,
-0.6210885048,
-0.191504389,
0.8049030304,
0.775498569,
-0.3727978766,
0.0916936472,
0.3347520232,
0.6263136268,
-0.7811166644,
0.4525215328,
-0.6305367947,
-0.3467646539,
-0.1035834923,
-0.1881410927,
-0.596277535,
-0.4558623135,
0.0272723865,
-0.3615538776,
0.0681477636,
0.1991413385,
0.419882983,
0.2299969494,
-0.3773798347,
-0.5437451601,
-0.4946195185,
0.9607948661,
-0.7942481041,
0.0793348029,
0.4003456235,
0.1376065314,
-0.2003115565,
-0.8898492455,
-0.5401328206,
-0.2108089775,
-0.1335944384,
-0.142008245,
-0.0415528007,
0.2211877406,
-0.0277265348,
0.3901882768,
-0.4333429337,
0.1198347211,
-0.1970904469,
-0.1009301841,
0.5347175002,
0.2152553648,
0.0011254227,
-0.1071437821,
-0.3563629389,
-0.1135778651,
-0.7156191468,
-0.0877080634,
0.1021342576,
0.4006105959,
0.2461679876,
0.6525580883,
-0.2448912859,
0.7161251903,
-0.2051721215,
-0.5555596948,
0.0590563715,
-0.3166504502,
-0.3386917412,
0.1298717856,
0.8999569416,
0.545345366,
0.1894527674,
-0.2864556313,
-0.1834169775,
0.0721272752,
-0.0875950605,
-0.5874259472,
0.0041619535,
0.1331070364,
-0.5010921359,
-0.3899278045,
-0.1579478383,
-0.9739141464,
-0.349362433,
-0.3226599991,
0.3617915809,
-0.2346700877,
0.2119044363,
0.2588810921,
-0.0787949786,
0.4133626819,
0.3179855943,
-0.5659371614,
0.5431701541,
0.701605916,
0.8948076367,
-0.2971867919,
-0.4965494275,
-0.6781377792,
0.5417144299,
-0.2168433368,
0.7825866342,
-0.5243245363,
-0.3834979534,
-0.055968143,
-0.4199397862,
-0.3292379081,
-0.6173611283,
0.9487024546,
-0.4504197538,
0.1103624403,
0.0004519567,
-0.7900263071,
-0.3083790541,
0.2953966856,
-0.4378982484,
0.7947548628,
-0.1822809577,
-0.6660861969,
0.1909609288,
-0.4042329788,
-0.5607831478,
-0.0468072109,
-0.0337599404,
-0.3800052702,
0.1935726553,
0.3954429924,
0.6656752825,
-0.6520929933,
0.4444723129,
-0.3705816865,
-0.1661233753,
0.3027271032,
-0.6130443811,
0.4132550955,
0.3112869859,
-0.137544781,
-0.0556902923,
-0.5738407969,
-0.1664227992,
0.0658596903,
-0.5159699917,
-0.5559058189,
0.1886096299,
0.0602011792,
0.2749520242,
0.4639125764,
-0.1877226532,
0.1458573043,
-0.0579307638,
0.3117587566,
0.7128750682,
0.1835419089,
0.4268577099,
-0.5686226487,
0.3500644565,
-0.1439189464,
0.1170919761,
0.1206982806,
-0.5551441908,
-0.7749746442,
-0.1817997396,
0.176060006,
0.5904368162,
-0.7246308327,
0.3861245811,
-0.4215480685,
-0.5166823268,
-0.1185411289,
0.3829488754,
0.3650923967,
0.5106447339,
0.5301760435,
-0.0573665723,
-0.2230425328,
-0.8081593513,
-0.4942364991,
-0.2432079762,
0.1348283291,
0.3364171386,
0.1155806854,
-0.0618453473,
0.6564279795,
-0.6948959231,
-0.3438269794,
-0.5951632261,
0.1813289076,
0.2127645165,
0.3167735636,
0.5904865861,
-0.8478076458,
-0.5388873816,
-0.177458629,
-0.7427389026,
-0.1021153703,
-0.2081875503,
-0.0523474291,
0.1828387529,
0.4888314307,
-0.7040777802,
0.1261274964,
0.4480879903,
0.0035762154,
0.311914891,
-0.330321461,
0.1764145941,
-1.1220612526,
-0.2526114583,
0.0324532241,
-0.0843044892,
-0.6365159154,
0.1243753955,
-0.0078697661,
0.0999640748,
-0.453771919,
0.3780965209,
-0.257697165,
0.1106681898,
-0.311491251,
-0.0447661094,
-0.1716912091,
0.4628376365,
0.0818286911,
0.6322143674,
0.8643707633,
-1.0518198013,
0.218058899,
0.248762995,
-0.4027588069,
0.4863861799,
-0.4770841002,
0.0743170753,
-0.2394844741,
0.3245269358,
-1.0903918743,
-0.5332300663,
0.1650096774,
-0.1750622243,
0.2481463701,
-0.0263902228,
-0.5777930617,
-0.1677936167,
-0.3368244767,
0.2843973935,
0.569668889,
-0.6855177879,
0.6886326075,
0.3890530765,
-0.4957591295,
-0.5743708014,
-0.5590473413,
0.3403078616,
-0.6622293591,
-0.4892496467,
0.0549166538,
0.0461844504,
-0.4100700915,
-0.3267460167,
0.0281683244,
-0.260445863,
0.0950465873,
-0.1267690659,
0.1455542147,
-0.054589659,
0.1492137611,
0.1756520122,
0.2362392247,
0.0410156585,
-0.2228592932,
0.6628229618,
-0.1390648335,
-0.3086343408,
-0.2294234037,
0.3767722249,
0.905443728,
-0.1813989729,
0.9695456624,
0.1933050454,
-0.0700893924,
0.0394859575,
-0.7348561883,
0.1149162352,
-0.4443868995,
0.2758112848,
-0.2278964818,
-0.5978143811,
0.3147133291,
-0.0858134925,
0.2498965114,
0.4895488024,
0.5234601498,
0.0728601441,
0.8622079492,
0.2546513379,
-0.2296909839,
0.2256347239,
0.0633800775,
0.1274940968,
-0.5619161725,
-0.1670197397,
-0.5801594853,
-0.1922186017,
-0.4932096303,
-0.5617567897,
0.4949910045,
0.2032672465,
0.1635277867,
0.0613919795,
-0.2010421753,
0.4674973488,
0.6067016125,
0.2311955541,
0.4102944732,
0.1563192904,
0.2320145518,
0.1456039995,
-0.7700172663,
-0.6963008642,
1.4034899473,
-0.025959624,
0.9009328485,
0.21694763,
0.9914104342,
0.0550602153,
0.3979531527,
-0.7902420759,
0.6922294497,
-0.4051157534,
-0.4339319766,
-0.300601393,
-0.621537745,
-0.8082566261,
0.4228724241,
-0.0159384515,
-0.4175130129,
0.1161280349,
0.2709215879,
-0.1713158935,
0.4228012562,
-0.7121736407,
0.7862969041,
-0.1766823977,
-0.20771873,
-0.145606339,
-0.5972907543,
0.6170981526,
-0.4049847424,
0.5458727479,
-0.0153865162,
-0.2657873929,
0.838075161,
-0.3815522194,
0.7754465938,
-0.0524795651,
-0.0006242504,
0.7143950462,
-0.0550164916,
0.8485895991,
-0.098980017,
-0.2843685448,
0.0507138111,
-0.3273205161,
-0.4159993231,
-0.4498923123,
0.634791553,
-0.4705492854,
-0.5968978405,
-0.263635993,
-0.616415143,
-0.2654160857,
-0.1301178783,
0.3868797719,
0.2748547792,
-0.0352059752,
0.6163783073,
0.5473051667,
-0.0761638284,
0.5401995778,
0.1102409884,
0.0404702388,
-0.4176424146,
0.9242653251,
0.1040364206,
0.4892565608,
0.3690599501,
0.5048992634,
-0.4499657452,
-0.8809368014,
-0.0726519376,
0.1962850392,
-0.9409188628,
-0.2037868053,
-0.8711665273,
0.0528095141,
-0.7015661597,
0.0428499281,
-0.0396581739,
-0.4522585273,
-0.1710352451,
0.0952609181,
0.2712268829,
0.6084246039,
0.0778346434,
0.715441525,
-0.9747187495,
0.3114855587,
0.4786269665,
-0.0082648704,
-0.0352315158,
-0.7013198733,
-0.0329727419,
-0.225995034,
-0.2969249785,
-0.8654470444,
0.5135518312,
0.5393084288,
0.7662737966,
0.2007238716,
0.2418089062,
0.5840237141,
-0.376493603,
0.732722044,
0.169304058,
-0.8891596198,
0.3587461114,
-0.1666910946,
-0.030202318,
0.685765624,
0.4694588482,
-0.497250706,
-0.7134670019,
-0.6085538864,
-1.2489269972,
0.5684832931,
0.2039934397,
0.0827502161,
-0.2494411618,
0.3174919784,
0.0988395885,
0.3226692975,
-0.855457902,
-0.370411545,
0.1888687462,
-0.4373848736,
-0.401501894,
-0.4371805787,
-0.0023707377,
-0.0582535453,
0.6198951006,
-0.1459052265,
-0.1331885457,
-0.0493772812,
-0.3071617782,
0.3237417936,
0.4991136193,
0.4512182474,
0.6994659305,
-0.0254439767,
0.2905258238,
0.4198349416,
-0.3428692818,
0.2137879729,
-0.0666245744,
-0.0735042691,
-0.0343795195,
0.3591420949,
0.4978070557,
0.2521242201,
-0.7075160742,
0.4920899868,
-0.0469149314,
-0.2892628908,
-0.1305354387,
-0.0434421748,
0.0931509137,
0.1078044102,
0.3527289033,
0.0134658916,
0.3975531459,
-0.3656321466,
0.0590245463,
0.2089155763,
0.1797174215,
0.1460992098,
0.4925359488,
-0.0528754443,
0.038183976,
0.4893789291,
-0.1752628088,
-0.3647395968,
0.448595345,
0.5431534052,
0.8978037834,
-0.2954441905,
-0.017092457,
0.2589410245,
0.1782047153,
-0.649235785,
-0.0541410334,
-0.1243300736,
-0.6346978545,
-0.5648478866,
-0.9227467775,
-0.7219341993,
0.1671557128,
-0.6632237434,
0.1819844097,
-0.3623838723,
0.1311435997,
-0.0635497645,
-0.6588028073,
-0.3678064048,
0.1320352405,
0.0667973831,
0.3925041556,
-0.8710061312,
0.7598946095,
0.8717963696,
-0.229121685,
-0.8298184872,
0.1322451979,
-0.3633632958,
-0.6792362332,
0.6912901998,
0.1098604798,
-0.0266623497,
-0.0427570306,
-0.4278353453,
-0.8353454471,
0.8505530357,
0.2410528064,
-0.5137888193,
-0.1082862541,
0.1098351851,
0.3130122423,
-0.2306831479,
-0.0807759985,
0.7676804066,
0.5143454671,
0.3983612955,
-0.8405150175,
-0.1479471922,
0.3335273266,
-0.1939374357,
0.2312553823,
-0.5741720796,
1.1505628824,
-0.0102557484,
0.177325666,
0.0087820366,
0.5400936604,
0.3735312819,
0.5010442138,
0.5637463331,
0.5569409728,
0.8086759448,
0.0094374251,
1.2382751703,
-0.23720406,
0.3756392896,
1.2370921373,
-0.2447612137,
0.9397621155,
0.4699243307,
-0.2896041572,
0.0534606241,
0.5345951915,
0.3772778809,
0.4170610607,
0.0167909879,
-0.5897200704,
-0.452345252,
0.1616275162,
-0.1726499945,
0.5959553719,
0.5442414284,
-0.5063159466,
-0.3526574671,
-0.0585034676,
0.020324409,
0.0580481105,
-0.59047544,
0.976388216,
0.1800086647,
-0.7758191824,
0.5465825796,
0.050873138,
0.7602499723,
-0.3918269873,
0.1479014158,
-0.383381933,
0.358833909,
-0.0840450227,
-0.6549220085,
0.3049571216,
0.060741514,
0.0324001238,
-0.2531678379,
0.6292133927,
-0.4885140061,
-0.6775431633,
0.1491282284,
0.4293135107,
0.5287725329,
-0.385758698,
-0.486733079,
-0.2806934416,
-0.0974492952,
-0.2756342888,
0.361895591,
0.5063285232,
-0.0723877773,
0.6513472795,
0.5716762543,
0.0649318919,
0.2995970547,
-0.0639456362,
0.6852810383,
-0.5763527751,
-0.4504160881,
-1.1964404583,
-0.0570068285,
-0.2061724663,
-0.1333402097,
0.9014993906,
0.7336765528,
0.5454841256,
-0.1397184432,
0.7425788641,
0.0839705542,
0.4146555066,
-0.6124875546,
0.4200770557,
-0.5033612251,
0.2028795332,
-0.3679380715,
-1.1779568195,
-0.4265510142,
0.5205389261,
-0.3398457766,
-0.1157416999,
0.6891015768,
0.6407217979,
0.0925177708,
-0.236783728,
0.3877314627,
-0.0370801799,
0.4261591136,
0.6188922524,
0.8834255934,
-0.2927127481,
1.0460056067,
-0.2949554622,
-0.1919334829,
-0.3467329443,
-0.7129249573,
-0.8243794441,
-0.0921138301,
-0.3990131617,
-0.2659944892,
-0.196717903,
0.8296208978,
0.2560663521,
-0.7891200185,
-0.4173703492,
-0.3417125344,
0.3061657548,
-0.1719047278,
-0.2081878334,
0.4551256001,
-0.8562020659,
-0.9447606802,
0.3747867644,
0.1822857559,
0.1608984917,
0.2021876276,
-0.1129407287,
-0.2592713535,
0.073039487,
0.7393215895,
0.0445136838,
-0.6411030293,
-0.111961171,
-0.1620175242,
-0.1699515432,
0.0256968513,
0.7091470361,
-0.3912034631,
0.0423796847,
0.5119088888,
0.7781811953,
0.43942523,
0.1791513264,
0.3132056892,
-0.7117807269,
0.1143004373,
0.3097918928,
0.4814075232,
0.228773132,
-0.1767566204,
0.3607544005,
0.1921657473,
-0.7026104331,
-0.7634042501,
0.0339281633,
-0.9399693012,
-0.4630226791,
1.4102330208,
-0.2101515681,
-0.3296083212,
-0.23804003,
-0.2351333201,
0.1850134134,
-0.273168385,
0.6188753247,
0.7192360759,
-0.1557906419,
0.1221097335,
-0.4383666813,
0.3604109585,
0.5651547909,
-0.9330570102,
0.2933256626,
0.6843954325,
0.2869374156,
0.1482769847,
0.4019880891,
-0.0409285352,
0.195479691,
-0.023936864,
-0.0160900522,
0.1564903706,
-0.2206475735,
-0.1571096182,
0.5553454161,
0.4659047723,
-0.3578563333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17158v1
|
DEXTER: A Benchmark for open-domain Complex Question Answering using LLMs
| 2024-06-24T22:09:50 | 2024-06-24T22:09:50 |
Venktesh V. Deepali Prabhu, Avishek Anand
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Open-domain complex Question Answering (QA) is a difficult task with
challenges in evidence retrieval and reasoning. The complexity of such
questions could stem from questions being compositional, hybrid evidence, or
ambiguity in questions. While retrieval performance for classical QA tasks is
well explored, their capabilities for heterogeneous complex retrieval tasks,
especially in an open-domain setting, and the impact on downstream QA
performance, are relatively unexplored. To address this, in this work, we
propose a benchmark composing diverse complex QA tasks and provide a toolkit to
evaluate state-of-the-art pre-trained dense and sparse retrieval models in an
open-domain setting. We observe that late interaction models and surprisingly
lexical models like BM25 perform well compared to other pre-trained dense
retrieval models. In addition, since context-based reasoning is critical for
solving complex QA tasks, we also evaluate the reasoning capabilities of LLMs
and the impact of retrieval performance on their reasoning capabilities.
Through experiments, we observe that much progress is to be made in retrieval
for complex QA to improve downstream QA performance. Our software and related
data can be accessed at https://github.com/VenkteshV/DEXTER
|
[
-0.4097898304,
-1.021574378,
0.7998150587,
0.2113096565,
-0.077778779,
0.2925960124,
-0.0808268636,
-0.5318992138,
0.1559053808,
0.3837476373,
-0.5493821502,
-0.5289098024,
-0.2449000776,
0.2243306786,
-0.0717089027,
0.4434295297,
-0.3624532521,
0.3494846523,
-0.4166676402,
-0.2391139865,
-0.502423048,
-0.3960626423,
-0.271856159,
0.1741944253,
0.4365404844,
0.2837066948,
0.5857403874,
0.4585694075,
0.638795495,
0.2082258612,
-0.0250840597,
0.4255833626,
-0.7452568412,
0.5297732949,
-0.4178095758,
-0.5034929514,
-0.6008661985,
-0.0154244807,
0.7632645369,
1.0158671141,
0.0800424591,
0.3982595801,
-0.2642645836,
0.235437125,
-1.0797445774,
-0.202415809,
-0.7874170542,
-0.0583432019,
-0.3470491767,
-0.3678125441,
-0.2654914558,
-0.3867840171,
0.3921982944,
-0.681402564,
0.0933767855,
0.3179422617,
0.6943947673,
0.1887389719,
-0.4002805054,
0.0330023952,
-0.6237570643,
0.7201144099,
-0.702036798,
0.446926266,
0.0919172168,
0.5039914846,
-0.2669773102,
-0.9565274119,
-0.5180131793,
-0.0118532423,
0.2761780024,
0.412977457,
0.0044656694,
0.194196552,
0.4842105806,
0.4392878115,
-0.5878110528,
-0.0483061373,
-0.2057040781,
-0.1625667959,
0.4104830027,
0.5311663151,
0.2652736306,
0.3013750315,
-0.4573554993,
0.059112478,
-0.7172660232,
0.454307586,
0.2432000488,
0.0600104444,
0.1476077884,
0.952301383,
-0.4831513166,
0.7121937275,
-0.2026261836,
0.0867403597,
0.2304838151,
-0.2939745486,
-0.2243933827,
-0.3079454005,
0.4296145141,
0.2854503691,
0.1255778968,
-0.3717526793,
-0.3902260363,
-0.2281040549,
0.4455248415,
-0.761384666,
-0.0662560835,
0.366155982,
-0.3145549297,
0.3463640511,
0.2439431101,
-0.4684316516,
-0.1474516988,
-0.2821529806,
0.6967435479,
-0.1864737272,
-0.0362201221,
0.3643017709,
-0.1753991842,
0.2998758554,
0.5952116251,
-0.4894729555,
0.7362356782,
0.7289457917,
0.6835311055,
-0.5362789631,
-0.2338778824,
-1.1957550049,
0.0053362637,
-0.1703370661,
0.7027395368,
-0.393307507,
0.0120199015,
0.0556646958,
0.1424861848,
-0.3615932167,
-0.8686434627,
0.5252263546,
-0.8879280686,
-0.0988547876,
-0.3002473712,
-0.5385833979,
-0.1608407348,
0.6132467389,
-0.7823413014,
0.9065272212,
0.3353490233,
-0.6235412359,
0.0299502648,
-0.2749969661,
-0.3574971259,
0.3204069436,
-0.033157263,
-0.1236714721,
-0.0278600529,
0.0137982117,
0.6097617149,
-0.5947219729,
0.2634778023,
-0.6748504043,
-0.6487163901,
0.2846351862,
-0.1831055433,
0.4039813578,
0.018566737,
-0.1706087142,
0.2738589048,
-0.617213428,
0.2247468382,
0.0293648709,
-0.451941669,
-0.4415753484,
-0.0376383029,
-0.2031823397,
0.1033637822,
0.3520065844,
-0.8793578148,
0.2057451457,
-0.3312169015,
0.1958548278,
0.5465943813,
-0.0475571752,
0.1442938596,
-0.5941173434,
0.5311743021,
0.2527782917,
0.1996308267,
0.1337194145,
-0.4126991332,
-0.3442529142,
-0.568951726,
0.2653618455,
0.5467602611,
-0.7801367044,
-0.000573738,
-0.340534091,
-0.3439992964,
-0.8519631624,
0.1850341856,
0.4688766897,
0.5507972836,
0.6722272635,
-0.4768313468,
-0.2399035841,
-0.8754236698,
-0.4116504788,
0.1750812829,
-0.1539862156,
0.632842958,
0.3364448249,
-0.2041850984,
0.9404981732,
-0.6031184793,
0.0026239443,
-0.0646846965,
-0.1394803673,
0.1902206689,
0.3124737144,
0.3059718311,
-0.7589149475,
-0.2815464437,
-0.2341285497,
-0.6255261302,
-0.1526109725,
0.1405593157,
-0.4107602537,
-0.2108611763,
0.3681000471,
-0.7647899389,
0.1981388628,
0.3840548098,
-0.3474512398,
0.8907455206,
-0.0203672852,
0.1989966631,
-0.8337218165,
0.3944867551,
-0.0789531171,
-0.3944075406,
-0.4516925812,
0.1731005013,
0.3282038271,
0.2157348692,
-0.685939312,
0.7210409641,
-0.4295527935,
-0.4044250846,
0.4228028059,
0.3904080987,
0.1738504171,
0.5881242752,
-0.0981651917,
0.9965356588,
0.2874412835,
-0.5498194098,
0.3674153686,
0.1875026375,
-0.4775655866,
0.4322706759,
-0.8848488331,
-0.1577743143,
0.0292763691,
-0.0224350058,
-1.0662608147,
-0.203635633,
0.0394647047,
-0.1289535761,
0.2222721875,
-0.0591872223,
-0.674803555,
-0.3411360085,
-0.540864408,
0.6299576759,
0.25061813,
-0.4466420412,
0.6903477907,
0.2000254989,
-0.1848571599,
-0.6249177456,
-0.1124890968,
-0.30710572,
0.1717461944,
-0.7075837851,
0.4642942548,
-0.3668539226,
-0.4338774681,
-0.0925494283,
-0.4650650322,
-0.1186304018,
0.5184925795,
0.0770777166,
0.3454565108,
-0.4640230536,
-0.0812000409,
0.4477600455,
0.2547228038,
0.2646790743,
0.1254179627,
0.5082636476,
-0.1970745176,
-0.497853756,
-0.1168482006,
0.3319333196,
0.7353199124,
-0.4566099942,
0.5270770788,
0.3103604615,
-0.2413595319,
-0.3448401392,
-0.6676071286,
-0.2659268081,
-0.3966302574,
0.123011969,
-0.6427133679,
-1.0931504965,
0.7672271132,
-0.5182782412,
0.0849099383,
0.2846924365,
0.5714861751,
-0.2876445353,
1.0571871996,
-0.0189100504,
0.2721362114,
0.1549292505,
-0.3168953955,
-0.1219780594,
-1.1338127851,
-0.3008565009,
-0.369550705,
-0.2502756119,
0.0011953687,
-0.4019850791,
0.5594634414,
0.4099489748,
-0.3750288486,
0.0626005754,
-0.05449659,
0.2049841583,
0.7592185736,
0.2747963071,
0.3692941964,
-0.5135295391,
-0.3561966121,
0.2768236697,
-0.6370466948,
-0.4321769476,
1.099460721,
0.2464443892,
0.6988247633,
0.4114667475,
0.2913692296,
0.2306343615,
0.251612097,
-0.6503515244,
0.516772449,
0.1158166453,
-0.5110980272,
-0.2852372825,
-0.5242869854,
-0.9328558445,
0.5090456009,
-0.2498425096,
-0.6003439426,
-0.0316653512,
-0.221789822,
-0.5033320189,
0.3123551905,
-0.4462415874,
0.9759861827,
-0.0449416712,
-0.5695419312,
-0.0221290272,
-0.9821938276,
0.4665829837,
-0.0094186617,
-0.2227839679,
-0.3173983395,
-0.010223588,
0.5838168263,
-0.3502064943,
0.5712841749,
-0.0019587388,
0.003476328,
0.0512963757,
0.3778122962,
0.4726478159,
0.2403157353,
-0.1513189822,
-0.0147484681,
0.4811745286,
-0.4878122211,
-0.5757552385,
0.6356441975,
-0.8748252392,
-0.7213270068,
-0.1015553847,
-0.8242592812,
-0.6963054538,
0.3186298311,
-0.0767798349,
0.6869707704,
-0.1579426825,
0.2550339997,
1.0740103722,
0.0075680437,
0.112566717,
0.5958359241,
0.0950184613,
-0.4124335051,
0.6097486019,
0.0383228622,
0.4622440338,
0.498688519,
-0.0951221511,
-0.2589993179,
-0.7370557785,
-0.6907185316,
0.3706257641,
-0.6475022435,
-0.3911508918,
-0.9641306996,
-0.1242181584,
-0.3332522213,
-0.0958624855,
-0.1365838349,
-0.419796437,
-0.4314878881,
0.2371253222,
-0.0620717742,
0.215349555,
0.5132279396,
-0.0524433888,
-0.9839724302,
0.6538556814,
0.4531369805,
0.582033813,
-0.0367333107,
-0.327351898,
-0.1607879996,
0.1238688529,
-0.2738257647,
-0.461938858,
0.1161746606,
-0.0487920679,
0.8970932364,
0.112384364,
0.5663658977,
0.5766912103,
-0.1331557333,
0.6767963767,
-0.1935483068,
-0.8536529541,
0.2947446406,
-0.3387082517,
0.2559995651,
0.7840886712,
0.6566243172,
-0.1241752654,
-0.3821196556,
-0.4191950262,
-0.7556751966,
0.675136447,
0.0076722912,
-0.2457335144,
-0.0545455627,
0.3848513961,
0.1907209158,
0.4291861355,
-0.1922555566,
-0.0331436358,
0.0261270721,
-0.3006286621,
0.1524392664,
-0.2970502675,
-0.3006116152,
-0.1756658703,
0.5118436217,
-0.3362526596,
0.0635909662,
0.4696926177,
-0.4294745326,
-0.2266257852,
0.1869286597,
0.629360497,
0.5598940253,
-0.5364901423,
0.1449449211,
0.1476916969,
-0.5960657597,
-0.1803258806,
0.2330858111,
-0.1036489308,
-0.3255512118,
0.4728096128,
0.5307503939,
0.1726254374,
-1.3160700798,
0.8302946687,
-0.1583456099,
-0.215540424,
-0.0214491524,
0.1646171659,
-0.1519386917,
0.5472844243,
0.4137496054,
-0.0880294293,
0.4306833148,
-0.5954342484,
-0.0536379702,
0.5638265014,
-0.3567575514,
-0.2995551229,
0.752177,
0.0723268688,
-0.0283584762,
0.7004801631,
0.0358916931,
-0.4946875274,
0.5965313911,
0.464626193,
0.742541194,
0.1123367175,
-0.1147426888,
0.078715764,
0.0565410554,
-0.089431569,
0.8874314427,
-0.2410482168,
-0.6856438518,
-0.3826909661,
-0.4985750318,
-0.7388039231,
-0.2135085166,
-0.7201515436,
-0.186281994,
-0.4729764462,
-0.0945601612,
-0.139542833,
0.2628825605,
-0.6888998747,
0.1847062409,
-0.2762031555,
1.2318768501,
-0.2722021639,
0.5518822074,
0.8110305667,
-0.3369664252,
-0.790674746,
-0.0960361436,
-0.2044149637,
-0.6120548844,
0.6280657053,
0.2063829452,
-0.3911713362,
0.2449963242,
-0.615475297,
-0.6433636546,
1.3537627459,
0.2438826859,
-0.3537062705,
0.1364710629,
-0.0485079363,
0.4974839985,
-0.3819224536,
0.3572742343,
0.343080014,
0.358784914,
0.0913096294,
-0.9230587482,
0.3223799169,
-0.473939836,
-0.1437615752,
0.1213557571,
-0.4886890054,
1.0847100019,
-0.2458054125,
-0.2637009323,
0.4168685675,
0.4159541428,
0.4521018863,
0.6630597711,
0.3110638261,
0.4684048295,
0.6829548478,
-0.133843407,
0.8717089295,
-0.3099504113,
0.053860072,
1.0988351107,
-0.7058196068,
0.9485315084,
0.3937135935,
0.0640193224,
0.3444654644,
0.5778944492,
0.1937462389,
0.4536577165,
0.5739706159,
-0.3582657278,
-0.4510789216,
-0.1799320281,
-0.221366778,
0.0301146768,
0.4103831649,
0.013662355,
-0.1618709713,
-0.0153108332,
-0.3081066608,
0.0386270881,
-0.4513039589,
0.8158656955,
-0.0940796137,
-0.8171845078,
0.558414638,
-0.0556886047,
0.5258367062,
-0.5958576202,
-0.015763469,
-0.2281281054,
0.1455602199,
-0.0934779048,
-0.9177010059,
-0.010451803,
-0.4466962218,
-0.129597947,
0.1618158519,
0.561499238,
-0.4019626379,
0.2680691779,
0.3161638379,
0.9094629288,
0.0362249352,
-0.2805454731,
-0.3826833963,
0.057905741,
-0.5469934344,
-0.3482192159,
0.2903141677,
0.6301620603,
-0.2191911638,
0.9413737655,
0.7873271704,
-0.07410831,
0.2092586309,
0.1970880479,
1.1686820984,
-0.6864120364,
-0.0479826555,
-0.4386808276,
0.2898960412,
-0.0225227531,
-0.4170463681,
0.8196508288,
0.7974203825,
0.9238392711,
-0.1560875475,
0.4447820783,
0.2651011348,
0.6815609932,
-0.5797124505,
0.4391746819,
-0.6065083742,
0.2260217071,
-0.2664943039,
-0.916464746,
-0.4424282014,
0.0278908256,
-0.1773567647,
-0.1947579533,
0.5409952402,
0.706500411,
-0.263218224,
0.0484761819,
0.4438447952,
0.2378819287,
0.2888109982,
0.4921416044,
1.0435380936,
-0.3123453856,
0.2111063004,
-0.0615164749,
-0.1067897603,
-0.4660205543,
-0.4193975031,
-0.9103640318,
-0.4382084012,
-0.0595287308,
-0.4438260198,
0.0209076833,
1.0250036716,
0.4724293947,
-0.6289189458,
-0.1025310755,
0.2245708406,
0.2588660121,
-0.5023649335,
-0.2112472951,
0.2474165857,
-0.3616394997,
-0.5347507,
0.4993766844,
0.3701810241,
0.0592197403,
-0.2342882305,
-0.0270761773,
-0.4584410191,
0.1786910892,
0.8610449433,
0.2993619144,
-0.5899341106,
-0.2989191711,
0.4749239981,
-0.3188452423,
-0.0168853924,
0.9126107097,
-0.8567345142,
0.4497926831,
0.6694889069,
1.0209929943,
0.5018470883,
0.2128027827,
0.5194847584,
-0.3763963878,
-0.6486203671,
0.5915876031,
0.441519618,
-0.0883028433,
-0.1636323035,
0.6756353974,
0.3479214609,
-0.4417380095,
-1.0102719069,
0.0659488961,
-1.5549762249,
-0.3264443874,
0.982221663,
-0.4177490771,
-0.2118788362,
-0.6092295647,
-0.1669203341,
0.0503363386,
-0.1879103631,
0.4644708931,
0.3095457554,
0.0645289272,
0.0881662816,
-0.3803329766,
0.0848230869,
0.3161855042,
-0.932423234,
-0.0326748416,
0.5472127199,
0.3436968029,
-0.1517478973,
0.698806107,
-0.1237624884,
0.5341311693,
-0.3228216171,
-0.0079129478,
-0.2827709913,
-0.5008394718,
-0.0318430439,
0.5373653173,
-0.0310226176,
-0.0515961051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17135v1
|
Testing network clustering algorithms with Natural Language Processing
| 2024-06-24T20:54:32 | 2024-06-24T20:54:32 |
Ixandra Achitouv, David Chavalarias, Bruno Gaume
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY, physics.soc-ph
|
The advent of online social networks has led to the development of an
abundant literature on the study of online social groups and their relationship
to individuals' personalities as revealed by their textual productions. Social
structures are inferred from a wide range of social interactions. Those
interactions form complex -- sometimes multi-layered -- networks, on which
community detection algorithms are applied to extract higher order structures.
The choice of the community detection algorithm is however hardily questioned
in relation with the cultural production of the individual they classify. In
this work, we assume the entangled nature of social networks and their cultural
production to propose a definition of cultural based online social groups as
sets of individuals whose online production can be categorized as social
group-related. We take advantage of this apparently self-referential
description of online social groups with a hybrid methodology that combines a
community detection algorithm and a natural language processing classification
algorithm. A key result of this analysis is the possibility to score community
detection algorithms using their agreement with the natural language processing
classification. A second result is that we can assign the opinion of a random
user at >85% accuracy.
|
[
-0.7342403531,
-1.0150697231,
0.1158065274,
0.426489085,
-0.149571836,
0.5566374063,
-0.4146883488,
-0.7677148581,
1.0343389511,
0.4329493344,
-0.4850302637,
-0.4058612585,
-0.4924331903,
0.4448386133,
-0.4114648104,
0.7405225039,
0.0434751622,
-0.010197632,
-0.1562793851,
-0.3198407292,
-0.0898831412,
-0.5481074452,
-0.8748468161,
-0.3023586869,
0.3609936833,
0.1449679434,
0.4294970632,
0.6484579444,
0.4502883852,
0.439653039,
-0.1679092646,
0.1598042995,
-0.3991601765,
0.0051195449,
-0.1432925016,
-0.4661315978,
-0.1677297503,
0.0475097373,
0.4308105707,
0.7082953453,
-0.1160087883,
0.4340785742,
-0.0664383993,
0.5402659178,
-0.4908359945,
-0.2090721279,
-0.6078503132,
0.3584460616,
-0.1399841011,
-0.2758584023,
-0.2306767702,
-0.786490798,
-0.1101388633,
-0.2813057303,
0.5013911724,
0.2345934659,
0.4307217896,
-0.1588686109,
-0.5898336768,
-0.3097302616,
-0.9283803105,
0.6397261024,
-0.4893798828,
0.0427446738,
0.580771029,
0.5489556789,
-0.1660290211,
-0.5070728064,
-0.8001235127,
0.0506849103,
-0.0909428,
0.1959480643,
0.0594486482,
0.0694657043,
0.048971545,
0.8847358823,
-0.6313335299,
0.1270672679,
-0.6552836299,
-0.1821554899,
0.667519331,
-0.1191501394,
0.3834171593,
-0.1121144295,
-0.1202590019,
0.1878007203,
-0.3524899483,
0.0197548009,
0.5885335803,
0.2849666178,
-0.016022779,
0.5860080719,
-0.554764092,
0.3565578759,
0.2273239195,
0.0852165297,
0.4197743237,
-0.243782267,
-0.2897245884,
0.1735242009,
0.8241148591,
0.4036513865,
0.6176742911,
-0.0234440286,
0.183873415,
0.5838051438,
0.1525775641,
-0.3837880492,
-0.1587872207,
-0.0533015616,
-0.8751448393,
-0.5284347534,
0.3457071185,
-0.5499178767,
-0.4777562916,
-0.0652695596,
0.1113419235,
0.1216352507,
-0.6994822621,
-0.1025307924,
-0.2821004987,
0.0422091112,
-0.0652466193,
-0.5333445072,
0.7130398154,
0.5574808121,
1.0647933483,
-0.3810165524,
-0.0751026794,
-0.3193961084,
-0.0387835689,
-0.1736849993,
0.8845319748,
-0.5555924177,
-0.2599757612,
0.0134791052,
0.1112855077,
-0.021787148,
-0.5134926438,
0.239813596,
-0.6000512838,
0.2514291108,
-0.3177053034,
-0.7274398208,
-0.1576642692,
0.5587780476,
-0.6386362314,
0.9181507826,
-0.045134902,
-0.637953639,
0.3850947618,
-0.797786057,
-0.7065666914,
0.2264134586,
-0.0885448679,
0.1400319934,
-0.002760048,
-0.0840305611,
0.4847348034,
-0.1127652526,
0.0078816898,
-0.7491517663,
-0.32478562,
0.4912901521,
-0.0203209594,
0.7486152053,
0.3079509139,
-0.4633111954,
0.0893299282,
-0.6453977823,
0.162073344,
0.1412279159,
-0.4264046848,
-0.5705990791,
0.2617537081,
-0.0579751953,
0.1950118393,
0.0311974734,
-0.6835544705,
-0.1183644235,
-0.4520552456,
0.5339477062,
0.7321910262,
0.2154314369,
0.4577904046,
0.0314716436,
0.3719204366,
0.0219894778,
0.2788575888,
0.3089013398,
-0.7129777074,
-0.9515869021,
0.2241428941,
-0.0731507465,
0.4926306307,
-0.9481034875,
0.8116829395,
-0.0447797962,
-0.6311129928,
-0.1800569594,
0.0838492215,
0.0348967798,
0.1312527955,
0.220627293,
-0.8357571363,
-0.4351853132,
-0.9085731506,
-0.3159247339,
-0.2268818468,
0.0317435116,
0.0021226816,
0.1920746565,
-0.3633404374,
1.0267766714,
-0.5776546597,
-0.2826987207,
-0.3263947964,
0.2981820703,
0.2461693436,
0.3360337615,
0.2041674405,
-0.8791524172,
-0.779055357,
0.2564653754,
-0.6914055347,
0.0587647222,
0.5429599285,
0.100346528,
0.1375504136,
0.342520535,
-0.1557519883,
0.4662306905,
0.4986514747,
-0.2574262917,
0.3379748464,
-0.0435841605,
0.2672040761,
-1.2001576424,
-0.262902528,
0.290872246,
-0.1949852258,
-0.7830789089,
0.2146776319,
-0.4375489056,
0.1856828332,
-0.0542524867,
0.1491434574,
-0.4898522496,
-0.3149106205,
-0.5355699658,
-0.0281083751,
-0.1481958181,
0.4077777863,
0.0069437344,
0.1100964472,
0.4950523973,
-0.7354565859,
0.5747387409,
-0.1450675726,
-0.4735829532,
0.844303906,
-0.5091650486,
0.3610856831,
-0.2213875502,
0.4585762322,
-1.0719765425,
-0.356985718,
0.273065418,
-0.3983129859,
-0.4459196329,
-0.2297251523,
-0.6671488285,
-0.4942620397,
-0.1687100828,
0.5756378174,
0.2779653668,
-0.3086664677,
0.5263882875,
0.7246599197,
0.1931044012,
-0.0636782944,
-0.7991309166,
-0.0672119856,
-0.5743265152,
-0.771897316,
0.1421907097,
-0.1711016297,
-0.3850902319,
0.1095749661,
0.1871214807,
-0.5660418868,
0.2425793111,
0.2721746862,
-0.2013252825,
-0.329646498,
0.1379106641,
-0.0308586489,
0.1108599454,
-0.0119743738,
-0.0704201981,
0.6366025805,
-0.3615264595,
-0.4033409357,
-0.0396935791,
0.4886889458,
0.3669643402,
-0.3764169812,
0.8390873671,
0.8405560851,
-0.6706413031,
-0.301687479,
-0.7602826953,
-0.1897988319,
-0.547097981,
0.1191227809,
0.0192460045,
-1.2143559456,
0.8078671098,
0.0622709468,
-0.2238094211,
0.4130592942,
0.4143953025,
-0.0805928037,
0.8515812159,
0.5394448638,
-0.203174457,
0.056364812,
-0.0366332531,
0.6184911132,
-0.386464268,
0.2198226303,
-0.5818363428,
-0.7164204121,
-0.9313520789,
-0.2859644294,
0.4563576877,
-0.1008808762,
-0.0166138876,
0.3787678778,
-0.4978759587,
0.8363486528,
0.5482288003,
0.0399192721,
0.5581207871,
0.2723358572,
0.0413188003,
0.177800864,
-0.4238259494,
-0.339826405,
0.5083019733,
0.228305161,
0.3834513724,
0.2550402284,
0.5989102125,
0.6249037385,
0.5393304229,
-0.805701375,
0.5503413677,
-0.1857613176,
-0.7263604403,
-0.2692744732,
-0.4649924636,
-0.8881847858,
0.196772173,
-0.4043534994,
-0.8426355124,
0.1508692205,
0.0786577761,
-0.1736598313,
0.4163145125,
-0.6552678347,
0.7616776824,
0.0496783406,
0.0354013816,
-0.4865597188,
-0.5825281739,
0.4030639231,
0.0011853409,
0.5350708961,
-0.1712861657,
0.5474944711,
0.6628335714,
-0.2115029544,
1.0786168575,
0.0400695689,
0.376352191,
0.5295778513,
0.3109589219,
0.1460055113,
-0.2509438694,
-0.0127674434,
0.1958031356,
0.1584713012,
-0.0946861953,
-0.5349652171,
0.7849233747,
-0.6853474379,
-0.23839131,
-0.1669931263,
0.0802334994,
-0.0319604836,
0.1330590099,
0.2744201124,
0.4188117683,
-0.2409425229,
0.0953641832,
0.3540218472,
-0.0310627595,
0.3366118371,
0.3065484464,
-0.4137825966,
-0.4086586535,
1.1263399124,
0.2562977672,
0.2600087821,
0.2325896919,
0.487516135,
-0.1209763438,
-0.4967090786,
-0.1193362772,
0.1453521103,
-0.8560138941,
0.1840824634,
-0.4439066947,
-0.2303945869,
-0.4252074063,
-0.1224095225,
-0.0299558043,
-0.171331659,
-0.0325559899,
-0.2430233657,
-0.004517863,
0.9679891467,
0.1487231404,
0.3795878589,
-0.7259375453,
0.0621482134,
0.309948504,
0.625995934,
0.1841862798,
0.0857871696,
-0.2368738055,
-0.1311069876,
-0.1620443016,
-1.1682293415,
0.125271067,
0.240234077,
0.4615046978,
0.5671718121,
-0.0003001772,
0.605858922,
-0.0749607459,
0.6878176332,
0.0682629868,
-0.7154759765,
0.3766038716,
-0.3890092075,
-0.09107963,
0.7607263327,
0.4140966833,
-1.0078030825,
-0.4250579178,
-0.5679862499,
-0.6514831781,
0.3526169062,
0.3122724593,
-0.0601930134,
-0.4437176287,
0.2867262363,
-0.0378384329,
0.3305223286,
-1.0661934614,
-0.3744309247,
-0.0367068462,
-0.1601676643,
-0.0147331711,
0.0598684475,
-0.0670175925,
-0.1807216853,
0.4115117192,
-0.3763387799,
0.1202903762,
0.2173728496,
-0.0460781083,
-0.4458192885,
0.0152119324,
0.2970645428,
0.8739926815,
0.05513978,
0.3447606266,
0.0049971063,
-0.2680835128,
0.1070596948,
-0.4470883608,
-0.1143989861,
-0.1499311477,
0.3069042265,
0.4574551582,
-0.1720831692,
-0.3090128005,
0.5149341822,
-0.2483918518,
-0.0260984916,
-0.7097593546,
0.0749263018,
0.1225661337,
0.016942909,
0.5034818649,
0.2497667372,
0.367811501,
-0.6888248324,
-0.0207603332,
0.3444672525,
-0.6155785918,
-0.4065895379,
-0.0488932393,
0.3443467319,
-0.5504502654,
0.3690367043,
-0.5664372444,
-0.6599146128,
0.7949048281,
0.3926593661,
1.0589799881,
-0.1945380718,
0.5301330686,
0.3740501702,
0.4816910923,
-0.0458875187,
-0.0210464392,
0.130778566,
-1.339381218,
-0.6643174887,
-0.8967548609,
-0.1047457606,
-0.1660680473,
-0.682787776,
-0.0411919281,
-0.6294646263,
-0.2867501676,
-0.1398458183,
-0.2762397528,
-0.4101932049,
0.2478220165,
0.1076743305,
0.7598944902,
-1.169154048,
0.4944777191,
0.8220733404,
0.0521450602,
-0.578166008,
0.1019362584,
0.17561014,
-0.4230621755,
0.4179725945,
0.4847767949,
-0.0105689894,
0.0196906794,
-0.3801491559,
-0.8340976834,
0.7709350586,
-0.2043664902,
0.0157087427,
0.414981395,
0.1394816786,
0.8439749479,
-0.4436663985,
0.2612304389,
0.3864883482,
0.4010373652,
0.0914283395,
-0.9315550327,
0.0071395189,
-0.5697344542,
-0.1182495654,
0.2581268847,
-0.5797439814,
0.6340279579,
0.4617301822,
-0.3583341837,
-0.3606152833,
0.7832180858,
0.2222824395,
0.4632256031,
1.1345796585,
0.2907039523,
0.7835177183,
0.0568885393,
0.9076113701,
0.0325731263,
0.2582133114,
0.6223328114,
-0.3023329079,
0.6836518645,
0.3345967531,
-0.3517887294,
0.8666735291,
0.9610428214,
0.0107765337,
0.1677241474,
0.4242989719,
-0.2782689333,
-0.2410642058,
-0.3567840159,
-0.180291146,
0.388579011,
0.1464845985,
-0.2987119555,
0.00155653,
-0.2250573337,
-0.349960655,
0.3500317335,
-0.5945840478,
0.7176015973,
0.1182476208,
-0.7290021181,
-0.0737744123,
0.4239820838,
0.8637905121,
-0.4573208392,
0.2233051509,
-0.1095104739,
0.025027737,
-0.4451850951,
-0.4849954247,
0.5836915374,
-0.2475348115,
-0.1921456456,
0.1612464041,
1.0671098232,
-0.2293593138,
-0.749576807,
0.5606222153,
0.5437634587,
0.2071422786,
-0.1766416728,
-0.380058378,
-0.2728529871,
-0.1496707648,
0.0816399828,
0.3118861914,
0.0727848858,
-0.335937798,
0.4045386612,
0.8107357621,
0.1381946355,
0.458571285,
0.128466174,
0.513389647,
-0.5004175305,
-0.991026938,
-0.9758608341,
0.1252408177,
-0.4639981985,
-0.2556191087,
0.8885393143,
0.3442002833,
1.0290697813,
0.1059337929,
0.8120210767,
-0.4069925547,
0.3455618918,
-0.1970544606,
0.5988241434,
-0.2650543451,
-0.1817752719,
-0.3079549074,
-1.0407762527,
-0.1243503392,
0.5722993016,
-0.2294621319,
0.0883452594,
0.7743545771,
0.7193894386,
-0.197561115,
0.6487836838,
-0.0389248207,
0.1954982877,
0.2229803801,
0.0829275027,
0.8910818696,
-0.0335980207,
0.2058879584,
-0.5289214253,
-0.4587003589,
0.0698167309,
-0.8219724298,
-1.1515479088,
-0.594142139,
-0.2727680802,
-0.3485501707,
-0.6050127149,
1.1700389385,
0.497581929,
-0.884693861,
-0.6109130383,
-0.0162439253,
0.2068503499,
-0.4857729673,
-0.3591741323,
0.0044035441,
0.2362125218,
-0.4463031888,
0.5436302423,
0.3703295887,
-0.2258275896,
-0.6932225227,
-0.02337569,
-0.2299963236,
-0.1717305332,
0.6484315991,
0.1753295809,
-0.5743806958,
-0.3641044497,
0.0612884313,
0.2184924185,
-0.0137659283,
0.8343795538,
-0.3092913628,
0.458081305,
0.6535030007,
0.5863270164,
0.4157454073,
0.0999141261,
0.538336575,
-0.7983745337,
-0.3058587015,
0.0242426861,
0.2684012651,
0.4205381274,
-0.4555498958,
0.4439101219,
0.7716304064,
-0.4333361983,
-0.6000871658,
0.3454031646,
-0.8551303148,
-0.1216022149,
0.9696011543,
0.0948983356,
-0.3242388666,
-0.4257035851,
0.0886208862,
0.3379265964,
0.0066378135,
0.8945497274,
0.6325502396,
-0.0298571717,
0.2031583041,
-0.280703485,
0.0448462069,
0.0082212789,
-0.8384763002,
-0.5493208766,
0.2007445097,
0.3626976311,
0.6141674519,
0.8549194336,
0.1999287754,
-0.0492693037,
-0.7909692526,
0.0345482491,
0.1769213229,
0.0486078747,
-0.1884833723,
0.7014272809,
-0.2220107764,
0.1138939112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17104v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17104v1
|
Automated Adversarial Discovery for Safety Classifiers
| 2024-06-24T19:45:12 | 2024-06-24T19:45:12 |
Yash Kumar Lal, Preethi Lahoti, Aradhana Sinha, Yao Qin, Ananth Balashankar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Safety classifiers are critical in mitigating toxicity on online forums such
as social media and in chatbots. Still, they continue to be vulnerable to
emergent, and often innumerable, adversarial attacks. Traditional automated
adversarial data generation methods, however, tend to produce attacks that are
not diverse, but variations of previously observed harm types. We formalize the
task of automated adversarial discovery for safety classifiers - to find new
attacks along previously unseen harm dimensions that expose new weaknesses in
the classifier. We measure progress on this task along two key axes (1)
adversarial success: does the attack fool the classifier? and (2) dimensional
diversity: does the attack represent a previously unseen harm type? Our
evaluation of existing attack generation methods on the CivilComments toxicity
task reveals their limitations: Word perturbation attacks fail to fool
classifiers, while prompt-based LLM attacks have more adversarial success, but
lack dimensional diversity. Even our best-performing prompt-based method finds
new successful attacks on unseen harm dimensions of attacks only 5\% of the
time. Automatically finding new harmful dimensions of attack is crucial and
there is substantial headroom for future research on our new task.
|
[
-0.4010512531,
-0.7975341678,
0.5069861412,
0.0417327322,
0.1941904724,
0.2165133357,
0.1671458781,
-0.2949511111,
0.0138927912,
0.2429205328,
-0.4342617691,
-0.8107260466,
-1.0221601725,
-0.0912413225,
-0.3096238375,
1.1126031876,
0.2131308764,
-0.1164077744,
-0.0488984175,
-0.0297257137,
-0.3868460357,
-0.7450447083,
-0.8762315512,
0.0919149071,
0.9741901755,
0.4287303686,
0.8602351546,
0.6286793947,
0.8453853726,
0.3833814561,
-0.3853531182,
-0.0089947907,
-0.3910732865,
0.2180945873,
-0.0670511425,
-0.4075393677,
-0.2501169443,
0.110659264,
0.1645958573,
0.5982978344,
0.1695571095,
-0.1015941352,
0.0646534264,
0.729156971,
-0.8972521424,
0.0385255851,
-0.7579878569,
0.3819882274,
-0.2006260753,
-0.2280685008,
-0.4771069586,
-0.5660531521,
0.1055267751,
-0.3645446301,
0.3790221512,
-0.0870091021,
0.4242554009,
0.507379353,
-0.8602201939,
-0.4547341466,
-0.7347974777,
0.5924891233,
-0.2404986769,
-0.0303131472,
0.0648400784,
0.5584017634,
-0.6248782277,
-0.5301733613,
-0.1423866004,
-0.5052488446,
0.0373535715,
-0.1176410168,
-0.2801109552,
0.1278496236,
0.3931920528,
0.1716455817,
-0.5364948511,
0.1417284161,
-0.2572096586,
-0.3651892245,
1.0845217705,
0.3495195508,
0.433175534,
-0.0300671048,
-0.435056299,
-0.3585407138,
-0.5755818486,
0.0872382522,
0.749440968,
0.274618268,
0.0649917871,
0.267637521,
0.0290514603,
0.1573956311,
-0.073718071,
0.0095753754,
0.1513833851,
-0.2852987647,
0.0878187716,
0.2115917355,
1.0192705393,
0.2192467749,
-0.1972601116,
-0.0782402158,
-0.0784181133,
0.2989522219,
0.5816654563,
-0.5844417214,
-0.8493897319,
0.0171823781,
-0.2616954148,
-1.0127339363,
0.0007194681,
-0.7714191079,
-1.1663452387,
0.3370958567,
0.6102394462,
-0.3635369241,
-0.0467706956,
-0.1220333204,
-0.5494099855,
-0.1161229461,
0.291215837,
-0.4685449898,
0.0243702903,
0.3224665225,
0.7413004041,
-0.1732482314,
-0.1158047095,
-0.6255962849,
-0.2357827127,
-0.4391306639,
0.8405085802,
-0.2936815321,
-0.6344242692,
-0.1493266225,
-0.0740315691,
-0.0061791674,
-0.5343176723,
0.838139832,
-0.4223176539,
0.1450609863,
-0.5163208246,
-0.2716997564,
-0.3815027177,
0.3244650662,
-0.7975728512,
0.5291736722,
-0.0683686361,
-1.0133976936,
0.3633458614,
-0.8960422873,
-0.6047008634,
-0.1432088017,
0.0377504677,
-0.785797298,
-0.0230143983,
0.0621331483,
0.320174247,
-0.1422194093,
-0.1087225303,
-0.7113263011,
-0.2323645949,
0.2776623964,
-0.5944378376,
1.1187186241,
0.2446288466,
-0.5772978663,
0.3403350115,
-0.7521612644,
-0.0398331396,
0.3771561384,
-0.3768159747,
-0.2057970166,
0.3102266788,
-0.0742665157,
0.1990679204,
0.2017516494,
-0.6363744736,
-0.1042727008,
-0.1378842592,
0.1327868551,
0.9383708239,
0.2480172217,
0.1366394013,
-0.458738178,
0.5042872429,
0.1645121723,
0.5539060235,
0.1068228483,
-0.4477905929,
-0.720331192,
-0.0744926259,
0.1549666673,
0.7152011991,
-0.6026764512,
0.6372654438,
0.1112651601,
-0.9248104692,
-0.0190378521,
-0.060110569,
0.4753377736,
0.2945488691,
0.425447017,
-0.2777594328,
-0.4095493257,
-0.8110278845,
-0.2981184423,
-0.3689229786,
-0.0607609861,
0.3176426589,
0.3987943828,
-0.6114605665,
0.4657816291,
-0.5522748828,
-0.2661638558,
0.1663642824,
0.2611667812,
-0.4834387898,
0.4004784226,
0.6889181137,
-0.7556801438,
-0.3670643866,
-0.16474244,
-0.9451647401,
0.0905417129,
-0.0047482871,
0.0640750751,
0.1056949422,
0.3437289894,
-0.1878908873,
0.2093758285,
0.3168936968,
-0.2652049959,
0.3418007791,
0.0400819965,
0.1359531879,
-0.7162060738,
-0.1565022618,
-0.0910241306,
0.1182438284,
-0.9915635586,
0.0815324858,
0.0389256515,
-0.1192089915,
-0.6097827554,
0.0931137055,
-0.1264065653,
0.2376120239,
-0.2348626405,
-0.0370359831,
-0.221949771,
0.3203598261,
-0.5313491821,
0.3193061054,
0.7585314512,
-0.6566546559,
0.5188111663,
-0.0647826567,
0.2338842601,
0.436181128,
-0.5083550215,
0.1602350324,
-0.2268852443,
0.358622998,
-0.8971552849,
-0.4169313908,
0.4410165548,
-0.5226130486,
0.3728982508,
-0.0381624177,
-0.2476190478,
-0.4591378868,
-0.684471488,
0.2378847301,
0.2379909754,
-0.7338504195,
0.410720259,
0.6383653283,
-0.1029425487,
-0.7403238416,
-0.3618150353,
0.2737412453,
-0.4675628543,
-0.6765303612,
0.0120592369,
-0.2030420303,
-0.3195972443,
-0.2259473354,
-0.1918887198,
0.0908903852,
0.6774641871,
0.5587605834,
0.0087150075,
0.1056886688,
-0.0334628895,
-0.1968152225,
-0.1361295581,
0.6887976527,
-0.0485212728,
0.2914506197,
-0.2822578847,
-0.429816097,
-0.3752045929,
0.4024289548,
0.5783955455,
0.0283943154,
0.5169979334,
0.5339738727,
-0.3799264133,
-0.1014445648,
-0.2310215831,
0.0344635136,
-0.5541505218,
0.4558004737,
0.1256367266,
-0.727837503,
0.393145293,
0.0423772149,
0.3046429157,
0.8566148281,
0.1523400396,
0.0227879733,
1.5092946291,
0.5385167599,
-0.2154403627,
0.2990731895,
-0.1104661971,
0.2172463387,
-0.2625796795,
-0.3648028672,
-0.5061603785,
-0.3587945104,
-0.9574962854,
0.0666737035,
0.765363574,
-0.1520441324,
-0.4684584737,
0.2219928205,
-0.5327779651,
0.2825753391,
0.7632685304,
0.3355492353,
0.0504541807,
-0.1488127857,
0.1541241407,
0.2112789303,
-0.6119003892,
-0.3718977571,
1.2459111214,
0.5110346079,
0.7406867743,
0.2530436516,
1.0258764029,
0.3537360132,
0.538782239,
-0.7255498767,
0.6359388232,
-0.2868688703,
-0.6572332978,
-0.3221675456,
-0.5563200712,
-0.9815021753,
-0.0148501508,
-0.2628838122,
-0.1307348311,
-0.0660198405,
0.4172740579,
-0.3598608971,
0.4585118592,
-0.6668727398,
0.7077818513,
-0.5049909353,
0.0115095153,
-0.0752381235,
-0.8201525211,
0.464264065,
-0.2647899091,
0.1021377966,
0.1621123403,
0.3423049748,
0.6926220655,
-0.3134464324,
0.9343700409,
-0.4997063279,
-0.2281111628,
0.2753897011,
0.0928123668,
0.6342892051,
-0.1358593106,
0.2109482735,
0.0011663387,
-0.3664990664,
-0.3328583241,
-0.3958576024,
0.6485328674,
-0.6003362536,
-0.721350193,
-0.7409945726,
-0.5622124672,
-0.0686332956,
0.103996329,
0.3979799151,
0.0212698672,
-0.3530305922,
0.2366323322,
0.9619494081,
-0.5842751861,
0.4265436828,
0.376101613,
0.4141342938,
-0.3917325437,
1.1932941675,
0.1450164467,
0.1086441875,
0.2486490458,
0.2502208352,
-0.1552888155,
-0.7017349601,
-0.1414175183,
-0.3587217927,
-0.73607409,
-0.3081757128,
-0.6795946956,
-0.4821159542,
-0.4296147525,
-0.1849699169,
-0.2324762195,
-0.2642202377,
-0.1234758347,
-0.1411778182,
0.3589763045,
0.8625468016,
-0.2270214409,
0.1295015961,
-0.7986243963,
0.1159165427,
0.6501950622,
0.0631534681,
-0.3462125659,
-0.0974384248,
0.0338252522,
0.2000572979,
-0.8132776618,
-0.8794089556,
0.2791678309,
-0.1304444522,
0.4264512062,
0.5830709338,
0.4588846862,
0.157216385,
-0.289506495,
0.7886471152,
0.2148890942,
-0.5064097047,
0.6628630757,
-0.3752388358,
-0.0908114314,
0.3664905727,
0.65599823,
-0.221940577,
-0.5583602786,
-0.9368398786,
-0.7077739239,
0.2124612182,
0.3164238036,
-0.0885551274,
-0.2008421868,
-0.0874297917,
-0.0464427583,
-0.0395888574,
-0.5568005443,
-0.5700697303,
-0.2367249727,
-0.0578286275,
-0.0932705998,
-0.1674213409,
-0.4378903508,
0.2456997633,
0.6367906332,
0.1250538379,
0.1649051011,
-0.0519669168,
0.1521607935,
-0.2338783145,
0.3875358105,
0.3619498909,
-0.0886711851,
-0.0700542107,
0.4558823109,
0.4057715237,
-0.6073223948,
0.3229308426,
0.5837153792,
-0.1517022252,
-0.2449543476,
0.3677814305,
0.4391873479,
-0.1525460333,
-0.4981316328,
0.5939350724,
-0.3014602065,
-0.3961618245,
-0.5811052322,
0.6756911278,
-0.3696524799,
0.3323097527,
0.191310063,
0.5145691633,
0.5026822686,
-0.4889276326,
0.3836091161,
0.8040198088,
-0.428368032,
-0.0940416604,
0.8137837648,
0.2436733544,
-0.3317949474,
0.1174536496,
-0.3789449334,
-0.7000755668,
0.8455799222,
0.1607015878,
1.0116285086,
-0.5035023689,
0.221424818,
0.2548673749,
0.4578712285,
0.0447461866,
0.1303165406,
0.1866633892,
-0.3596530557,
0.4108343124,
-0.3099863827,
-0.4755892158,
0.3440069854,
-0.5584211946,
0.0288064834,
-0.7733534575,
-0.1243386343,
0.187585637,
0.0836451575,
-0.3650409579,
0.5022797585,
0.0164482109,
0.4588034749,
-0.963871181,
0.1785790175,
0.5588809252,
-0.1817195714,
-0.4403404891,
0.0990243852,
0.6007433534,
-0.3459699452,
0.4636266232,
0.3377410173,
-0.1217273101,
-0.2839406133,
-0.5293858647,
-0.8280053735,
0.9779176116,
0.2361718863,
-0.3713642061,
0.1115649566,
0.1764484644,
0.6502704024,
0.1107095107,
-0.0998916775,
0.2262288481,
0.4391979873,
-0.0192608777,
-0.4756168127,
0.2503032982,
-0.4402111769,
-0.0793751255,
0.3445344567,
-0.5802468061,
0.7669324875,
-0.4022848308,
-0.3571027815,
-0.2365960479,
0.4959262609,
0.1014465839,
0.611133635,
0.8467585444,
0.6245812774,
0.7481196523,
-0.0853575915,
0.9106347561,
-0.077321656,
0.0364726335,
0.8564746976,
-0.0341501199,
0.4438320696,
-0.0888887048,
-0.0410194322,
0.2748662233,
0.7143242359,
-0.273137331,
0.4006131291,
0.3309770525,
-0.5548455119,
-0.0701272935,
-0.0473863631,
-0.3040560484,
0.1687777191,
0.261585027,
-0.5022985339,
-0.2419756651,
0.2141177505,
0.1431100816,
-0.0983075127,
-0.087094292,
0.7861459851,
-0.2799550891,
-0.4946071506,
0.5737389922,
0.0317575373,
0.6344527006,
-0.3038150966,
0.066739291,
-0.0465597622,
0.2353373319,
-0.1992538422,
-0.6972919703,
0.3146446347,
-0.0537431575,
-0.0161075033,
0.092812404,
0.6477813125,
-0.117725201,
-0.313477248,
0.3621240556,
0.0112130633,
0.0104644056,
-0.1955817491,
-0.4174177051,
-0.292999953,
-0.0359410644,
-0.1516916454,
0.4473361671,
0.3314655423,
-0.0214526523,
0.8017941117,
0.5956643224,
-0.0959023684,
0.1449739784,
-0.0343929306,
0.992860496,
-0.6080915332,
-0.3471266925,
-0.711899817,
0.3470466435,
-0.197437793,
-0.1834006757,
0.8201804161,
0.4430880547,
0.7582594752,
0.1186075211,
1.0866886377,
-0.1485691816,
0.3916472197,
-0.2364376038,
0.8153288364,
-0.4063574374,
0.4655554593,
-0.3006076515,
-0.4770045578,
-0.559535563,
0.2646463215,
-0.1448658258,
-0.100500837,
0.7064278126,
0.9702124,
0.2120772749,
0.0581467152,
-0.0022938596,
0.2366932482,
0.7453045845,
0.5641469359,
0.8969455361,
-0.5096274614,
1.0209401846,
-0.4185968935,
-0.511115551,
-0.0797196925,
-0.7482650876,
-1.1137006283,
-0.3640272021,
-0.4658600092,
-0.4655146301,
0.308704108,
0.5859348178,
0.2601417899,
-0.9046791196,
0.4179172814,
-0.353641212,
0.1734570265,
-0.0518129654,
-0.2878125608,
0.2882656455,
-0.4192868471,
-0.424829334,
0.4847656786,
0.0745896846,
0.2009285241,
-0.3377144635,
0.0202563982,
0.1726351976,
0.0408684984,
0.5791574121,
0.3955614567,
-0.3992057443,
-0.5601211786,
-0.2145794481,
-0.2964084744,
-0.3330618143,
0.4430383146,
-0.2929973602,
0.3354330361,
0.5543394089,
0.7330967784,
-0.2880656421,
-0.2532411516,
0.4010107815,
-0.7075463533,
-0.1633914262,
0.3328177333,
0.2447269112,
0.2445180863,
-0.7864739299,
0.5173432827,
0.3021366298,
-0.6346110106,
-0.8308304548,
0.422732681,
-0.5285609961,
-0.3413713574,
0.9476006627,
-0.1254547983,
0.0714114383,
-0.1534885019,
-0.2197417021,
0.2931594551,
-0.166610837,
1.3186169863,
0.2962820828,
-0.0618044361,
0.3172508776,
-0.2453505546,
0.8157114387,
0.2013839483,
-1.0278023481,
0.0200623516,
0.5314336419,
0.1069653332,
0.5808247328,
0.1322185844,
-0.1888782829,
0.4563556015,
0.2395795286,
-0.2108124048,
0.0530015081,
-0.7025131583,
-0.2428892851,
0.4142093658,
-0.2023128569,
-0.3114183247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17095v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17095v1
|
Attention Instruction: Amplifying Attention in the Middle via Prompting
| 2024-06-24T19:35:11 | 2024-06-24T19:35:11 |
Meiru Zhang, Zaiqiao Meng, Nigel Collier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The context window of large language models has been extended to 128k tokens
or more. However, language models still suffer from position bias and have
difficulty in accessing and using the middle part of the context due to the
lack of attention. We examine the relative position awareness of LLMs and the
feasibility of mitigating disproportional attention through prompting. We
augment the original task instruction with $\texttt{attention instructions}$
that direct language models to allocate more attention towards a selected
segment of the context. We conduct a comprehensive investigation on
multi-document question answering task with both position-based and index-based
instructions. We find that language models do not have relative position
awareness of the context. Nevertheless, they demonstrate the capacity to adapt
attention to a specific segment using matching indexes. Our analysis
contributes to a deeper understanding of position bias in LLMs and provides a
pathway to mitigate this bias by instruction, thus benefiting LLMs in locating
and utilizing relevant information from retrieved documents in RAG
applications.
|
[
-0.2408182323,
-0.9147644043,
0.9186295271,
0.1290726215,
0.0509451255,
-0.1142828092,
-0.0880263895,
-0.1845091432,
-0.1344916224,
0.3130465746,
-0.7421017289,
-0.3806592226,
-0.7183951735,
-0.0225521512,
-0.3844552934,
0.8126444817,
0.0592300743,
0.0562088862,
-0.4703475237,
-0.0227946509,
-0.8392193913,
-0.6132414341,
-0.5902466178,
-0.0919947848,
0.5988208652,
0.7147333622,
0.3206036985,
0.5914590359,
0.3212248683,
0.4042828679,
-0.1872947216,
0.0423990302,
-0.5914544463,
0.2147722989,
-0.299348712,
-0.8431338668,
-0.2878175378,
0.1494895369,
0.9563145638,
0.7380460501,
-0.0823202282,
0.1501897126,
0.05334628,
0.9361568093,
-0.687754333,
-0.1840616167,
-0.6662381291,
-0.136159122,
-0.2878800333,
-0.4083079994,
-0.5637738109,
-0.0010156299,
0.333468765,
-0.3539049327,
0.3760342896,
0.2869896889,
0.6191424727,
0.5276682973,
-0.3148342371,
-0.3019595444,
-0.5158769488,
0.9681221247,
-0.2181728631,
0.3291612864,
0.4348543286,
0.1634146869,
-0.0978399068,
-0.279428333,
-0.4241317809,
0.0889472067,
0.002854693,
0.1142544076,
-0.026624795,
0.1257421225,
0.4774365127,
0.0525849611,
-0.3880561888,
0.0181489121,
-0.2740405202,
0.0444967113,
0.0921411961,
0.1656636894,
0.3219045699,
0.0535474345,
-0.4526794851,
-0.1091260687,
-0.6394541264,
0.0710659102,
0.1863438785,
0.0471945852,
-0.1110074669,
0.5223678946,
0.068113111,
1.036488533,
0.5023084283,
-0.2133552283,
-0.1807726026,
-0.1674336791,
-0.343652457,
0.1569446921,
0.0652009398,
0.4171954095,
0.0801785737,
-0.0423624963,
0.0073667266,
-0.348112613,
0.5368853807,
-0.3842802346,
0.4511063099,
0.221593678,
-0.3390509784,
0.128634572,
-0.099991776,
-0.6503689289,
-0.3412756026,
-0.4272470474,
0.1910704225,
-0.1155155078,
0.3220894039,
0.01250936,
-0.1431334764,
0.5497068167,
0.4451456368,
-1.2468781471,
0.113336958,
0.8317058682,
0.7146933079,
-0.1727511436,
-0.3019668758,
-0.4445374906,
0.5826248527,
-0.2176245451,
0.8773286939,
-0.725515008,
-0.4081557691,
-0.1319741905,
0.2166322917,
-0.4546280503,
-0.3409728408,
0.348826021,
-0.6544168591,
0.5483699441,
-0.4637845755,
-0.5508075356,
-0.1893789917,
0.4870129824,
-0.5022750497,
1.0750069618,
0.1904014498,
-0.8937610388,
-0.1604295969,
-0.7755653262,
-0.3984089494,
-0.2848179638,
-0.1325575262,
-0.0350330546,
0.1656913608,
0.4444228113,
0.4011297822,
-0.2215404958,
-0.1527076066,
-0.0263256729,
-0.6155264974,
0.3952476084,
-0.4992887676,
0.5332250595,
-0.0686383024,
-0.2896347046,
0.1327711195,
-0.3478185534,
-0.3603676558,
0.0657435954,
-0.3893468976,
-0.6680446267,
-0.2582954168,
-0.4762834311,
0.0965695605,
0.3770236373,
-0.1904158145,
0.2537820935,
-0.4957599044,
0.1714990735,
0.9695256948,
0.1335015446,
0.9237701297,
-0.292237699,
0.7717384696,
-0.0876639113,
0.2566684783,
-0.3163237274,
-0.2369718105,
-0.8751520514,
0.0605105981,
0.0595276542,
0.6507197022,
-0.5641354322,
0.0196411423,
-0.0640087277,
0.0451193042,
-0.5986276865,
0.0743787065,
0.6303957701,
0.8530198932,
0.0986451134,
0.0310770106,
-0.3930578828,
-0.9726188779,
-0.0281397235,
0.0681308508,
0.1279518902,
0.3665681481,
-0.0013768482,
0.0022637532,
0.6067543626,
-0.6131022573,
-0.1303563416,
-0.2769839764,
-0.2436655462,
0.2340595871,
0.103004016,
0.4042795002,
-0.7621603012,
-0.639923811,
-0.4217630625,
-0.4127241969,
-0.2411308587,
-0.125422433,
-0.5339108109,
0.222753793,
0.8587683439,
-0.5515046716,
0.1117355227,
0.4209648371,
-0.0645881444,
0.415255338,
-0.2773516476,
0.0978367254,
-1.2064665556,
0.0857887268,
0.0333314128,
-0.183284238,
-0.7077899575,
-0.118713893,
0.121098347,
0.028798962,
-0.5687514544,
0.8352924585,
-0.8762018681,
-0.2813960016,
-0.6161217093,
0.4874592721,
0.2707140148,
0.5213375092,
-0.0523186512,
0.970662415,
0.4625233412,
-0.6173294783,
-0.0525799058,
0.2785220444,
-0.21173805,
0.8889524341,
-0.5028024912,
0.3766456842,
-0.4479735792,
0.1466570646,
-1.1381804943,
-0.1849534661,
0.2587762177,
-0.3231086433,
0.7740116119,
-0.1897267252,
-0.0833215117,
-0.3558322787,
-0.46275267,
0.1543638259,
0.1707298309,
-0.3391141891,
0.296351254,
0.5853752494,
-0.4184478819,
-1.1276506186,
-0.5540151,
-0.1734450459,
-0.3095525205,
-0.4437685907,
0.3370928764,
-0.1046010777,
-0.3789272606,
-0.1147216558,
-0.2769002616,
0.1169174612,
0.1780395806,
0.1995684952,
0.4276147187,
0.0433374792,
0.328261584,
-0.0640914813,
-0.2675944567,
0.0241888072,
-0.2553313673,
0.370015949,
0.174477607,
-0.5088819265,
-0.3833097816,
0.558496058,
0.5391764045,
0.0210016705,
0.6502500176,
0.3438068032,
-0.2624944746,
-0.1730938405,
-0.7498892546,
-0.385795325,
-0.5005794764,
0.4068713188,
-0.164468646,
-0.9984439015,
0.2562867999,
0.0922517329,
-0.0122416327,
0.0882158875,
0.6751654148,
-0.29788661,
1.077119112,
0.7934116125,
-0.3891017437,
0.8554013371,
0.0502703153,
0.2197595835,
-1.2999490499,
-0.0066834092,
-0.7452629209,
-0.5203793049,
-0.1566966921,
-0.6213526726,
0.5148671269,
-0.0516061857,
0.1562764943,
-0.1867276281,
-0.7689931393,
0.8011738658,
0.6725662351,
0.0797030032,
-0.1496663839,
0.0652947724,
-0.1754125059,
-0.0576976947,
-0.8010123968,
-0.5330459476,
0.7233177423,
0.3330720663,
0.6723616719,
0.0094908085,
0.4506888986,
0.029364638,
0.2889049649,
-0.7549133301,
0.54888767,
-0.0978401303,
-0.7430871725,
-0.5143677592,
-0.0087195234,
-0.9762313366,
0.1987318844,
0.3101350963,
-0.9413850307,
0.1432916522,
-0.0022283373,
-0.5344289541,
-0.1046592817,
-0.9863396883,
0.7570312619,
-0.1666576862,
-0.6093327999,
-0.0872030184,
-0.7337598205,
0.2030864209,
0.2605801523,
0.3336284161,
-0.1514429152,
-0.1438454688,
0.681851685,
-0.2396608293,
1.1064432859,
-0.4297937751,
-0.1700036228,
0.3847540915,
-0.2660488486,
0.6478952169,
-0.2003786713,
-0.1291052699,
-0.4718541801,
-0.2595170438,
-0.4104599953,
-0.6582788229,
0.7806072235,
-0.4971555471,
-1.28066957,
-0.3026700616,
-0.9883344769,
-0.4048169553,
0.1261595935,
-0.016200399,
0.2115000784,
0.0925195366,
0.076755017,
1.09370327,
-0.1498618126,
0.5161207914,
0.647708714,
0.2882882953,
0.0896131694,
0.6025685072,
-0.0158929639,
0.1412564069,
0.7348592281,
0.2869656682,
-0.7240813375,
-0.5234386921,
-0.372618258,
0.2711710334,
-1.0485371351,
0.0757156387,
-0.7165568471,
0.0095761269,
-0.3787053227,
-0.4505620301,
0.0438843593,
-0.3623729348,
-0.2543830872,
-0.1325645149,
0.2042129338,
0.5448769331,
0.306529969,
0.529086709,
-0.9013501406,
0.1392527521,
0.4497154951,
0.006619459,
0.3133513331,
-0.6886375546,
-0.3627298772,
-0.1474282593,
-0.277964741,
-0.9095704556,
0.1882921159,
-0.0979026929,
0.9566799998,
0.2781004906,
-0.0711622238,
0.649985671,
-0.6314584613,
0.6919736862,
-0.0558778271,
-0.8321318626,
0.5656796098,
-0.1667460948,
0.8149292469,
0.49414289,
0.4164238572,
-0.6578575969,
-0.4159162641,
-0.4184548259,
-0.6543203592,
1.1735919714,
-0.3252852559,
0.292006582,
-0.0720113516,
0.5882040262,
-0.1574708223,
0.0546783917,
-0.5197100043,
-0.0710468441,
0.3062627316,
-0.4349414706,
0.121988073,
-0.5842549801,
-0.3516684473,
-0.0148114022,
0.6213622093,
-0.127508536,
0.3529916704,
0.3241457939,
-0.1275458783,
-0.063004598,
0.3765322566,
0.9393265843,
0.7023027539,
0.0338773504,
0.2574441135,
0.2535029352,
-0.5005696416,
0.1982195079,
-0.0364215448,
-0.4006694853,
-0.1258214712,
0.1586379111,
0.8412589431,
0.4846796393,
-0.3424507976,
0.4839933813,
-0.0337969698,
0.1935040951,
0.0696723983,
0.1295801848,
0.4008671641,
0.3227005899,
0.4105693996,
-0.472589463,
0.0638967827,
-0.3723504841,
0.047381144,
0.5660890341,
-0.5300344229,
0.0094739879,
0.6107851267,
0.2088512033,
-0.208416909,
0.3386977017,
0.2345262468,
-0.5392078757,
0.7301857471,
0.6163387299,
0.7092797756,
-0.4433724284,
0.0292032603,
0.1876698434,
0.2823091149,
-0.0393746942,
0.2867503464,
-0.1742902547,
-0.6195957661,
-0.413621515,
-0.3409726918,
-0.557448864,
-0.1422731578,
-0.4304926991,
0.0948061123,
-0.3459299505,
-0.0807484984,
0.0818381757,
-0.1299831569,
-0.3825468421,
0.0441647246,
0.1037186831,
0.7464455366,
-0.4821407497,
0.8653454185,
0.8510140777,
-0.0719188377,
-0.6510608196,
0.1774657518,
0.2070715129,
-0.9901491404,
0.3846128285,
0.3895836473,
-0.2265253365,
0.0995795354,
-0.6516869068,
-0.8403276205,
1.0380034447,
0.2555080652,
-0.638666153,
-0.1982435584,
-0.0661260933,
0.3078765869,
-0.2993994951,
0.204289794,
0.34924227,
0.4829801619,
0.1057301834,
-0.4954795539,
0.0972581953,
0.0565121286,
0.055914104,
0.1370636821,
-0.8091214299,
0.6509248018,
-0.3088014424,
-0.2629103363,
-0.3617339134,
0.2989284694,
0.4131685495,
0.4280902445,
0.5215046406,
0.2777038813,
0.8396982551,
0.0118334601,
1.3110672235,
-0.330703944,
-0.1051817909,
1.2238169909,
-0.4394963682,
0.63432163,
0.8813953996,
-0.1250017881,
0.3197522461,
0.6082883477,
0.3424390852,
0.5866183043,
0.0608783402,
-0.299041599,
0.0994998068,
-0.2711975276,
-0.1474131346,
0.1709745228,
0.6225994229,
-0.3600012958,
-0.1878184527,
0.0468448959,
-0.0807559416,
0.1504411995,
-0.4062623978,
0.8135949373,
0.2076663226,
-0.9422029257,
0.518014431,
0.0372157656,
0.4337096214,
-0.5884556174,
-0.0330459327,
-0.3246769905,
0.1310586631,
0.0469324104,
-0.7277188897,
0.301990062,
-0.0588968247,
-0.7382856607,
-0.4067934155,
0.8899941444,
-0.5085933208,
-0.2216091603,
0.0857939348,
0.4585162401,
0.1563117504,
0.0024487874,
-0.7874027491,
0.0386453234,
0.1242258921,
-0.3522817791,
0.4961622059,
0.628600955,
-0.3439106941,
0.609102428,
0.6394692063,
-0.3280702829,
0.1993222088,
0.2839612067,
0.6587045193,
-0.5365470052,
-0.549172163,
-0.8337608576,
0.4202514589,
-0.1902183741,
0.0735187307,
0.9123407602,
0.1433732957,
0.6690786481,
-0.1976885051,
0.684319973,
0.2310495526,
0.7170220613,
-0.6173758507,
0.4183993042,
-0.4703305364,
0.3764854968,
-0.097198315,
-0.9560061693,
-0.1737495065,
0.4644849002,
-0.6868132949,
0.0365914218,
0.770388782,
0.9108693004,
0.0510923713,
-0.2948984504,
0.3584846556,
0.1112583429,
-0.0616169088,
0.685431242,
0.8704047203,
0.0070080962,
0.4511198103,
-0.0754150376,
-0.3141055107,
-0.5093535781,
-0.7286862135,
-0.7910814285,
-0.344668597,
-0.0368864983,
-0.0450589731,
0.1462909132,
0.6272420287,
0.6591340899,
-0.5569852591,
-0.0751280934,
0.0974823907,
0.6167836785,
-0.1522524059,
-0.200130567,
0.5400022864,
-0.4397825897,
-1.1316730976,
0.6111831665,
0.6047846675,
0.2451981902,
-0.357951045,
0.0581296198,
-0.6753898859,
0.1854058206,
0.5767342448,
0.2483262718,
-0.6370508075,
-0.2045204192,
0.4094660878,
-0.5352965593,
0.1240272671,
0.7889287472,
-0.212648958,
0.4010018408,
0.6387942433,
0.7048738599,
0.3250519335,
0.3786236048,
0.6076635122,
-1.2338529825,
0.4647816122,
0.0167776532,
0.2393580973,
0.4816382527,
-0.7039784789,
0.4324771762,
-0.0544069223,
-0.6025980115,
-0.6068967581,
0.0056307814,
-0.8373473287,
-0.4244051874,
1.1492114067,
-0.0184799619,
-0.7118377686,
-0.268843025,
-0.6257616878,
0.2545680702,
-0.3013031483,
0.8875598907,
1.0389977694,
-0.1469148993,
-0.4881843328,
-0.8206623793,
0.3073097169,
0.8504785895,
-0.7334353328,
0.1500658244,
0.4975431859,
0.0951651186,
0.0706019849,
0.8125023842,
-0.1641141921,
0.2131386846,
-0.2861433923,
-0.0167124402,
0.1427048147,
-0.393994987,
-0.4573529959,
0.2061806619,
0.1240644306,
-0.350858748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17055v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17055v2
|
Large Language Models Assume People are More Rational than We Really are
| 2024-06-24T18:15:27 | 2024-07-01T17:29:54 |
Ryan Liu, Jiayi Geng, Joshua C. Peterson, Ilia Sucholutsky, Thomas L. Griffiths
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
In order for AI systems to communicate effectively with people, they must
understand how we make decisions. However, people's decisions are not always
rational, so the implicit internal models of human decision-making in Large
Language Models (LLMs) must account for this. Previous empirical evidence seems
to suggest that these implicit models are accurate -- LLMs offer believable
proxies of human behavior, acting how we expect humans would in everyday
interactions. However, by comparing LLM behavior and predictions to a large
dataset of human decisions, we find that this is actually not the case: when
both simulating and predicting people's choices, a suite of cutting-edge LLMs
(GPT-4o & 4-Turbo, Llama-3-8B & 70B, Claude 3 Opus) assume that people are more
rational than we really are. Specifically, these models deviate from human
behavior and align more closely with a classic model of rational choice --
expected value theory. Interestingly, people also tend to assume that other
people are rational when interpreting their behavior. As a consequence, when we
compare the inferences that LLMs and people draw from the decisions of others
using another psychological dataset, we find that these inferences are highly
correlated. Thus, the implicit decision-making models of LLMs appear to be
aligned with the human expectation that other people will act rationally,
rather than with how people actually act.
|
[
-0.3500930071,
-0.7134812474,
1.1009253263,
0.2799384892,
0.1362010092,
0.0174703803,
-0.3610475063,
-0.7395749688,
-0.0302827861,
0.1551766396,
-0.465693146,
-0.1380718499,
-0.4899778366,
-0.0228424221,
-0.1839525998,
0.6692607999,
0.1111780629,
0.3407619298,
-0.3282105923,
-0.0963490531,
-0.2587254941,
-0.7422490716,
-0.8964016438,
-0.742256403,
0.4892758727,
-0.0011476196,
1.0798025131,
0.4406031966,
0.1410734355,
0.2573040426,
-0.0011225032,
-0.1132414788,
-0.594225347,
-0.0693863109,
-0.2926213443,
-0.6786918044,
-0.333291471,
0.3622855842,
0.5160454512,
0.6500586271,
0.0004580275,
-0.0382736884,
-0.1575094014,
0.6815881729,
-0.4296526313,
0.2375571281,
-0.493216455,
-0.1083434299,
0.1362413466,
0.017588703,
-0.5673199296,
-0.2719458342,
0.3449403942,
-0.5187197328,
-0.0761343241,
0.3909447789,
0.7021496296,
0.3880432248,
-0.6337421536,
-0.216071263,
-0.9801205397,
0.8486804366,
-0.6616211534,
0.3018710911,
0.6290141344,
0.1698444337,
-0.5155191422,
-0.3981586397,
-0.7610372305,
-0.5505416989,
-0.1634702235,
0.0262300968,
-0.0174496919,
0.3088679016,
0.6120648384,
-0.1059502289,
-0.3018191457,
0.2323689461,
-0.2907419503,
0.1078216434,
0.7816396952,
0.2507374883,
0.2135321498,
0.0623743162,
-0.4017364085,
-0.0361875109,
-0.8016508222,
0.147065416,
0.2551718056,
0.041995395,
-0.0362442471,
0.6262640953,
-0.0099423127,
0.4869942069,
0.1787692457,
-0.194464758,
0.0831451043,
0.0239978507,
-0.3458608687,
0.3236597776,
0.7433687449,
0.5759963989,
1.0214232206,
0.0376671478,
-0.1679998934,
0.3288080394,
0.1611998081,
-0.5473874211,
0.0035838697,
0.4476357996,
-0.3722318411,
-0.0253529996,
0.010476158,
-0.5742869973,
-0.5155367255,
-0.6787554622,
0.3781986535,
-0.1542787701,
-0.2349970788,
0.1123215854,
0.0906387791,
0.2909168601,
0.6196275949,
-0.8671174645,
0.4336948097,
1.0334146023,
0.6243226528,
-0.2793933749,
-0.7201296687,
-0.3019435704,
0.3229608238,
-0.716404736,
0.839771688,
-0.7216736078,
-0.3665244281,
-0.1300071627,
-0.2244518548,
-0.090040639,
-0.3558761477,
0.4942984283,
-0.4736477137,
0.077021189,
-0.6377881765,
-0.6336519718,
-0.282055825,
0.1619828343,
-0.5325651169,
0.6995031238,
-0.0069029168,
-0.4899801314,
0.6898031831,
-0.4971348643,
-0.2367039472,
-0.0839289576,
-0.4744068086,
-0.0930407941,
0.2945123613,
-0.0461555645,
0.3936065137,
-0.651755929,
0.515783906,
-0.6943830848,
-0.458663702,
0.7786579132,
-0.5414549112,
0.7539319396,
0.1658867002,
-0.355959326,
0.2392188907,
-0.2223255038,
-0.0215692818,
0.0433230214,
-0.3062105179,
-0.5314954519,
0.3993428349,
-0.2180459499,
0.5108853579,
0.1075081751,
-0.3388653994,
0.4018599093,
-0.1645819992,
0.531971693,
1.1642632484,
-0.4177418649,
0.6894818544,
-0.6130260825,
0.263004154,
-0.2395867556,
0.1917665601,
0.2676079571,
-0.5302120447,
-0.7424199581,
-0.419791013,
0.072103411,
0.4421382248,
0.0218099579,
0.080233328,
-0.4440087378,
-0.2329038233,
-0.3750537336,
-0.1436821073,
0.1719876677,
0.2621896565,
0.0846026614,
0.1903739423,
-0.5003798008,
-0.9419018626,
-0.4263590872,
-0.5586872697,
0.0368976295,
0.3506355286,
0.4894155562,
-0.2851982713,
1.0991082191,
-0.2475843579,
0.0607975125,
-0.2158622146,
0.2523321509,
0.1490944773,
0.4708720148,
0.3807822764,
-0.7675486803,
-0.3263342381,
-0.0441143177,
-0.7063328624,
0.0254431665,
-0.2729829848,
-0.2147129774,
0.4383058548,
0.3547386229,
-0.8533706665,
0.252466023,
0.4186595976,
-0.4848830402,
0.3874375522,
-0.3426664174,
0.0938071683,
-0.7616561055,
-0.238161236,
0.1736374944,
-0.1539026499,
-0.448807478,
-0.3075895607,
-0.0250022318,
0.4915717542,
-0.3166530132,
0.7655104995,
-0.398966521,
-0.5503914356,
-0.0851508155,
-0.1456001103,
-0.1952189207,
0.4525327086,
0.0999492481,
0.8827082515,
0.4082701206,
-0.5407275558,
0.1529928446,
-0.0776778013,
-0.4898239374,
0.6723220348,
-0.6714202166,
-0.0106107565,
-0.3848591745,
0.5121697187,
-0.8396524191,
-0.5314130783,
-0.0085900882,
-0.3498571217,
0.186914131,
-0.1323670298,
-0.553067863,
-0.2154283077,
-0.1373369098,
0.344399482,
0.8216878772,
-0.5734018087,
0.9642783999,
0.5214400291,
-0.2262073904,
-0.4989236891,
-0.7786370516,
0.0485222787,
-0.2996754348,
-0.6644173861,
0.018000653,
-0.2185697258,
-0.9506652951,
-0.1071759462,
0.091594547,
-0.1982264221,
0.0104400041,
0.3480995595,
0.6531352401,
-0.1632699519,
0.0867087618,
-0.2705431879,
-0.0677903593,
0.3452810943,
-0.2105629295,
0.4464213252,
-0.2372409552,
-0.590482533,
-0.3730190098,
0.1546173394,
0.8774898052,
0.1437604576,
0.7984765768,
0.1955634505,
-0.4087459743,
-0.0152328052,
-0.8060532212,
-0.1517575085,
-0.4097186625,
0.2338341624,
-0.3462112546,
-0.8614656329,
0.4941122532,
-0.0134613067,
0.0164020006,
0.4099410176,
0.5716316104,
-0.3244505823,
1.6528710127,
0.3671331108,
0.0130675547,
0.2180591822,
0.1195751727,
0.0911517888,
-0.8395223618,
-0.2232332826,
-0.472396493,
-0.3643566072,
-0.7922392488,
-0.2589308321,
0.1131138429,
0.0109257009,
-0.7077141404,
-0.1705421805,
-0.1316851974,
0.6989542842,
0.4444883168,
-0.2548593879,
0.2497145534,
0.0233090352,
0.0430767983,
-0.1054305509,
-0.5829973817,
-0.7519631982,
0.9708860517,
0.3893999755,
1.0180994272,
0.1632691473,
0.2077749521,
0.2401680052,
0.77648139,
-0.8493553996,
0.4504505992,
0.1464195698,
-0.6963711381,
-0.2660093307,
-0.4970963299,
-0.9153692722,
0.4020596147,
-0.3092459738,
-0.8917619586,
0.2416125387,
0.1119282693,
-0.3940335512,
0.1526064575,
-0.8918919563,
0.5370646715,
-0.5081317425,
-0.4815400541,
-0.3646670878,
-0.4680295885,
0.6272335649,
-0.1633818597,
0.3376118541,
-0.4235458672,
-0.1725245565,
0.5743220448,
-0.1826461852,
0.8660806417,
0.0331965312,
-0.1025172621,
0.2047998905,
0.2066885084,
0.738489151,
0.0453644171,
-0.323585242,
0.301850915,
-0.0588234775,
-0.3872680068,
-0.5973195434,
0.8292473555,
-1.0729964972,
-0.7619698644,
-0.7025967836,
-0.5162675977,
-0.1522305161,
-0.062005233,
0.1273299903,
0.3290591836,
-0.2960456908,
-0.0867116675,
0.5323724747,
-0.074175097,
0.1776349992,
0.5104656219,
-0.3274824023,
-0.2438470572,
0.6501102448,
0.229925409,
0.3933663666,
0.2270150036,
0.3023580015,
-0.4734534621,
-0.3188022971,
-0.1430297643,
0.4818878174,
-0.7478030324,
0.3612034321,
-0.6039779186,
0.1478489041,
-0.3106520474,
-0.3821145594,
-0.2286781967,
-0.1551303864,
-0.1198992655,
-0.2498223782,
0.2582752109,
1.1674128771,
-0.0260604639,
0.0739314631,
-0.6050075889,
0.0707770139,
0.5713759065,
0.211294651,
0.1547182798,
-0.3845417798,
0.0977614895,
0.2436604947,
0.1407503635,
-0.5640679002,
0.3824979365,
-0.1341720223,
0.8186794519,
0.3204504848,
0.0140577862,
0.720582068,
-0.4661211967,
0.697815001,
-0.018014567,
-0.831181705,
-0.0119513366,
-0.3915415704,
0.017102493,
0.4159572423,
0.4321315587,
-0.5935793519,
-0.0507270023,
-0.6105378866,
-0.5641466379,
0.9124111533,
0.0299753472,
0.1091493443,
-0.145042792,
0.2326354682,
0.0116825029,
0.161269635,
-0.8450258374,
-0.210050866,
0.0548390076,
-0.2543825805,
-0.2491959184,
-0.3230501413,
-0.0403194241,
-0.1852763295,
0.4765700102,
-0.0778076053,
0.4058375061,
0.1448807716,
0.0703493655,
-0.4555296302,
0.2487657964,
0.8672836423,
0.8769161105,
-0.2612560689,
0.186014995,
0.3213317394,
-0.1281579137,
0.2561267018,
-0.1835408509,
0.0167193227,
-0.4895127118,
0.3382730186,
0.8534386754,
0.2118680328,
-0.946856916,
0.5240844488,
-0.2726663947,
-0.1166340411,
-0.7984603047,
0.1797025353,
0.2193395644,
0.416801542,
0.4189712405,
0.300023973,
-0.1275638342,
-0.6998003125,
-0.1499291807,
0.6090186834,
-0.3153382242,
-0.3921294808,
0.5356853604,
0.2242673337,
-0.555321455,
0.7211161256,
-0.1540112197,
-0.5721638799,
0.7168456316,
0.4052199721,
1.0002421141,
-0.0195074044,
0.0365133584,
0.359280616,
0.4222996533,
-0.6013335586,
0.030497225,
0.1515806913,
-0.915596664,
-0.8304662704,
-0.3832927644,
-0.3745066226,
0.3153904974,
-0.410146445,
0.1670286059,
-0.4014471769,
-0.0914128795,
-0.2661871314,
-0.1569541842,
-0.5578784347,
0.0779843628,
0.273119837,
0.8637101054,
-0.7163094282,
0.8462191224,
0.5053189397,
-0.2809225619,
-0.8260139823,
0.245679915,
-0.0795289427,
-0.8671178818,
1.069960475,
0.2666697204,
-0.0591258518,
-0.1000810266,
-0.7058495879,
-1.1007175446,
0.8993268013,
0.5865473747,
-0.4964472651,
-0.1618699431,
0.0712382719,
0.5292332172,
-0.5953236818,
0.4855212569,
0.589003861,
0.7567489743,
0.2033954263,
-0.8914933205,
-0.0453851148,
0.0399567671,
-0.0254341643,
0.2471603155,
-0.7388027906,
1.1683527231,
-0.4974274039,
-0.2295849919,
-0.1125761196,
0.447586596,
0.3561265171,
0.1782821417,
0.5929943919,
0.3739715219,
0.7635155916,
-0.1039939225,
1.4662519693,
-0.0966841578,
0.1798244566,
1.2065266371,
-0.6770225763,
0.850428462,
0.3641373813,
-0.3188500404,
0.3351280689,
0.7830768228,
0.2181054354,
0.2528035045,
-0.0549552739,
-0.2061227262,
-0.7044578791,
0.0488578416,
-0.0753200874,
0.4068350494,
0.7227779031,
-0.3493864834,
0.1286544651,
-0.5498850346,
0.0238858704,
-0.1527626216,
-0.2787908912,
0.8833039999,
0.0158544853,
-1.1187740564,
0.5216143727,
-0.1609801054,
0.5983247757,
-0.4483408332,
-0.0021644859,
0.0737553537,
0.0374601334,
-0.1730106473,
-0.9593203664,
-0.0056305211,
-0.0388173386,
-0.2550082803,
-0.120832175,
0.514266789,
-0.2278715074,
-0.3166431785,
0.4644352198,
0.5586748123,
0.2105564773,
0.0133969747,
-0.8163532019,
0.0385223366,
0.056318026,
-0.5012385249,
0.4690678716,
0.2418187857,
-0.3114341199,
0.8301536441,
0.9298383594,
0.1622969508,
0.0369373262,
-0.0037712285,
0.4533261061,
-0.6264263988,
-0.348639667,
-1.1475422382,
0.2628106773,
-0.1418688595,
-0.1718709171,
0.4053620994,
0.2551186085,
0.8362050653,
0.1994724721,
1.0561188459,
0.4012562037,
0.2131605595,
-0.5689197183,
0.3381636143,
-0.3013992608,
0.2913074791,
-0.1274605393,
-1.0565222502,
0.0376334786,
0.9250536561,
-0.7277061343,
0.4179475307,
0.675257802,
0.7032926083,
0.163416326,
0.1455698311,
0.4661675096,
0.5537968874,
0.2848193944,
0.522249639,
1.2192796469,
0.1661589295,
0.2179391831,
0.0991235673,
-0.2924207151,
-0.3798906803,
-0.9710078835,
-0.8903910518,
-0.4246641695,
0.0262932796,
-0.1545207649,
-0.1089856252,
1.5261325836,
0.7024137974,
-0.6159394979,
-0.4009692967,
-0.254707247,
0.1570178866,
-0.0347361155,
-0.2151214033,
0.0403749011,
-0.1563311666,
-0.9591238499,
0.1762572527,
0.3227218091,
0.3632289469,
-0.4409343898,
-0.4101299047,
-0.139914453,
0.4792557061,
0.6105266213,
0.2263951004,
-0.9814973474,
-0.3267333508,
-0.1555676758,
-0.5138374567,
0.1352439821,
0.6251178384,
-0.8093209863,
0.0873451754,
0.4821392,
0.4531109929,
0.1898236126,
-0.071760945,
0.8019036651,
-0.0491368324,
-0.0382506363,
0.0894615576,
0.5529721975,
0.3418016136,
-0.4227600694,
0.4763674438,
0.04105483,
-0.7957003117,
-0.6330432892,
0.3567259312,
-0.79214257,
-0.4559694529,
1.3738992214,
0.0480521061,
-0.4845167696,
-0.1766268164,
-0.3518913984,
-0.0021700235,
-0.7926091552,
0.8381341696,
0.818359375,
-0.2715879381,
0.1498776227,
-0.7697528005,
0.5513709784,
0.3652684391,
-0.7810253501,
0.2912327349,
0.7025852203,
0.141937837,
0.0915085599,
0.6300330758,
0.3151441216,
0.2106278241,
-0.2115749717,
-0.1964947879,
0.1674299538,
-0.0213696659,
-0.2364867479,
-0.0410927609,
0.3847353756,
0.3977165222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.17038v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.17038v1
|
modeLing: A Novel Dataset for Testing Linguistic Reasoning in Language Models
| 2024-06-24T18:00:59 | 2024-06-24T18:00:59 |
Nathan A. Chi, Teodor Malchev, Riley Kong, Ryan A. Chi, Lucas Huang, Ethan A. Chi, R. Thomas McCoy, Dragomir Radev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce modeLing, a novel benchmark of Linguistics Olympiad-style
puzzles which tests few-shot reasoning in AI systems. Solving these puzzles
necessitates inferring aspects of a language's grammatical structure from a
small number of examples. Such puzzles provide a natural testbed for language
models, as they require compositional generalization and few-shot inductive
reasoning. Consisting solely of new puzzles written specifically for this work,
modeLing has no risk of appearing in the training data of existing AI systems:
this ameliorates the risk of data leakage, a potential confounder for many
prior evaluations of reasoning. Evaluating several large open source language
models and GPT on our benchmark, we observe non-negligible accuracy,
demonstrating few-shot emergent reasoning ability which cannot merely be
attributed to shallow memorization. However, imperfect model performance
suggests that modeLing can be used to measure further progress in linguistic
reasoning.
|
[
-0.0655646473,
-1.1367893219,
0.6885880232,
-0.003740961,
-0.0392253436,
-0.2103859335,
-0.1454177946,
-0.2063474059,
-0.4196834564,
0.3540947139,
-0.5960211158,
-0.4376446605,
-0.4069262147,
0.0398124047,
-0.6224344373,
0.6802484989,
0.0649273098,
0.0297876205,
-0.6263082027,
0.087496914,
-0.4320171475,
-0.330865711,
-0.5363907814,
-0.6036769748,
0.2246143818,
0.3374392986,
0.7797827721,
0.7371784449,
0.4552371502,
0.2269338369,
-0.0458067916,
-0.1550463885,
-0.3040823042,
0.0671683997,
-0.2226112187,
-0.9316533208,
-0.1481394917,
0.2086350918,
0.633795023,
0.8939249516,
-0.097868301,
0.2063348442,
-0.3444106281,
0.4408169687,
-0.4598310888,
0.3684203923,
-0.8963691592,
-0.0303816888,
-0.4190027714,
0.3069760799,
-0.5106060505,
-0.2687957883,
-0.0198615212,
-0.5058265924,
0.2126476765,
0.0851131901,
0.8285159469,
0.3825707436,
-0.287176162,
-0.0880023763,
-0.6862258911,
0.5715212226,
-0.9575685859,
0.2305628657,
0.473418504,
0.7216889858,
-0.1537673175,
-0.5612702966,
-0.660890758,
-0.6766638756,
-0.0137239061,
-0.0515600927,
-0.1155643463,
-0.1871587187,
0.456078887,
0.2497452348,
-0.9009361267,
0.0273715649,
-0.2330942303,
0.1507779956,
0.7688379288,
0.3447145224,
0.4542856812,
-0.008504563,
0.0231467504,
-0.0037311146,
-0.9746023417,
-0.0944296122,
0.540830195,
0.474018693,
-0.1019558832,
0.8576979041,
-0.3012636006,
0.8012122512,
-0.3432955146,
0.249239713,
0.0910465792,
-0.2661046684,
-0.2286680639,
-0.3172519803,
0.7209683657,
-0.1194016859,
0.4152952433,
-0.1865975112,
-0.2423517406,
0.3879979551,
-0.0249889754,
-0.4491744339,
-0.7039401531,
-0.0699691176,
-0.3063310087,
-0.2871474624,
-0.1287229806,
-0.5815472603,
-0.2287885249,
-0.2030807734,
0.3990971446,
-0.5559946895,
-0.4061172307,
0.1433077306,
-0.1147141159,
0.0794269964,
0.1407496631,
-0.8838143349,
0.410664171,
1.0779206753,
0.6564207673,
-0.1180487275,
-0.455552429,
-0.2274520695,
-0.3300936222,
-0.6073886752,
0.9325991869,
-0.7834321856,
-0.1967428178,
-0.0998611748,
-0.2679648399,
-0.1883368641,
-0.6472405195,
0.4449788928,
-0.3132757843,
0.1165238619,
0.0185563136,
-0.980923593,
-0.0494149625,
0.4325219691,
-0.6373190284,
1.1279220581,
0.1010673195,
-0.3929537237,
0.2105369717,
-0.743093431,
-0.2132045478,
0.2067738771,
-0.3779439628,
-0.4146967828,
0.2964749932,
0.0045785131,
0.043156717,
-0.4164661765,
0.2987904847,
-0.5451322198,
-0.3697201312,
0.2989860773,
-0.3023456633,
0.9004642963,
0.1048994288,
-0.2279413044,
-0.2531539202,
-0.8297113776,
0.2846445441,
0.3543647826,
-0.1332780123,
-0.2174518257,
0.1481961906,
-0.1375714988,
0.2436379939,
0.035128478,
-0.4688403308,
0.5143913031,
-0.5655623078,
0.3150395453,
0.5181729794,
-0.1886963248,
0.3786911666,
-0.5468090177,
0.5911610723,
-0.0584098399,
-0.00162841,
-0.318590194,
-0.884893477,
-0.831628561,
-0.1342806369,
0.4696104825,
0.5787355304,
-0.5000188947,
0.061245501,
-0.1958068758,
-0.6476781368,
-0.4979805946,
-0.0139118573,
0.3652638197,
0.3590771556,
0.0833756402,
0.0807225257,
-0.3899338543,
-1.0257977247,
-0.6374641061,
-0.3984659314,
-0.0553549305,
0.2859859169,
0.9333717227,
0.0532296225,
1.0280774832,
-0.3125427365,
0.1070772037,
-0.2985415459,
0.5815031528,
0.3464883268,
0.5409587622,
0.516254127,
-0.5384576917,
-0.3449579775,
-0.0869771391,
-0.8190529943,
-0.2225433439,
0.0467774719,
0.0520544797,
-0.0256531816,
0.417335242,
-0.7698085904,
0.4770211279,
0.3040089011,
-0.337107718,
0.77108711,
0.0228983108,
-0.0964783281,
-0.5468383431,
0.1264122427,
-0.2444892526,
-0.041600097,
-0.5594339371,
0.3802692592,
-0.0154948132,
-0.2580641508,
-0.473811537,
0.7549253106,
-0.37152946,
-0.0647554696,
-0.2659721673,
-0.0960124582,
-0.1470007598,
0.227758497,
0.0124818301,
0.5967469215,
0.6528279781,
-0.4351139367,
0.4244325161,
0.1075682715,
-0.6538760662,
0.4689598382,
-0.76001513,
0.4542918205,
-0.2196126431,
-0.2504431307,
-0.7299113274,
-0.2741675675,
-0.1096068397,
-0.4953987896,
0.0496361405,
-0.4516181052,
-0.6650850177,
-0.350615412,
0.1981299222,
0.4057107866,
0.5337043405,
-0.2933695614,
0.4168262184,
0.1395331621,
-0.1875864714,
-0.1669641435,
-0.7887191176,
-0.0709005594,
-0.1196794957,
-0.7334478498,
0.0086113606,
-0.22481668,
-0.566229105,
0.2527295053,
0.1142308116,
-0.3826408088,
0.4358343184,
0.0886870772,
0.2571671903,
-0.6616281271,
0.3069632351,
-0.2146609426,
-0.0221063104,
0.1671982706,
-0.1980946511,
0.3358285129,
-0.2989470661,
-0.616743505,
-0.278772831,
0.5038964748,
0.2991754413,
-0.2704074085,
0.5574819446,
0.0666310713,
-0.7261123657,
-0.5312376022,
-0.4114788175,
-0.2552906871,
-0.3639261723,
0.4291762412,
-0.6733158827,
-0.6492608786,
0.5116565228,
0.0049743466,
-0.1030075699,
0.4356181324,
0.5902557373,
0.0187269915,
1.1648507118,
0.5127894282,
-0.0617148094,
0.1638337821,
-0.1959275454,
0.2401003391,
-0.340357244,
-0.0559368916,
-0.7941426039,
-0.2120648921,
-0.3271252811,
-0.3387067318,
0.1144815907,
0.158229664,
-0.4189406633,
0.2785439193,
-0.156592235,
0.9671285748,
0.6937968731,
-0.2518438995,
0.4606307447,
-0.4319877326,
-0.3230926692,
-0.0976222903,
-0.6518102884,
-0.660505116,
1.1766742468,
0.0268169027,
0.9899932742,
0.0332920067,
0.5426360965,
0.046410691,
0.2901711166,
-0.614217937,
0.4189442992,
-0.0481172763,
-1.04776752,
-0.2194629312,
-0.5430710912,
-0.76876086,
0.2997916639,
-0.2135412544,
-0.9309408069,
-0.0327458568,
0.2977143824,
-0.2984527946,
0.2143309861,
-0.6212391853,
1.1931673288,
-0.2495183796,
-0.145331189,
0.0049577318,
-0.4026996493,
0.7483333349,
0.1898914278,
0.1321353018,
-0.4663814902,
0.2658593655,
0.4268583059,
-0.3886982501,
0.6935831904,
0.1265530437,
0.3242240548,
0.2949154079,
0.5584278703,
0.491174221,
0.0642712489,
-0.196917966,
-0.0651008114,
0.0318560228,
-0.4357699156,
-0.8573581576,
0.5169398189,
-0.5419288278,
-0.4876324534,
-0.5001461506,
-0.7575310469,
-0.2675979435,
0.1817344278,
0.2507244349,
0.27368325,
-0.4044233263,
0.059262529,
0.5081876516,
0.1593564004,
0.2354047298,
0.5583456159,
-0.175334692,
0.0201785192,
0.6942045689,
-0.0809499398,
0.3843506575,
0.3329520226,
0.3559106588,
-0.1990162134,
-0.7888363004,
-0.3009185493,
0.2145349979,
-0.7030517459,
-0.0270595793,
-0.3267084658,
-0.25564605,
-0.419593811,
0.2117637247,
-0.711288929,
-0.6584913135,
-0.0289113261,
0.0258314721,
0.0529082194,
1.0045231581,
0.0596528538,
0.1995744109,
-0.445289731,
0.1742486805,
0.3946920633,
0.2751586735,
-0.245687291,
-0.3689123392,
-0.1089352593,
0.1853139102,
-0.2301597595,
-0.844154954,
0.3158171475,
0.3385900557,
0.7335076332,
0.2244354635,
-0.2879458666,
0.4580769241,
-0.6837025285,
0.8798672557,
-0.2454790175,
-1.0117666721,
0.8027044535,
-0.513497591,
0.4246601164,
0.5779387355,
0.204319939,
-0.5566138625,
-0.4627764821,
-0.7776788473,
-0.2911440432,
0.5553461909,
0.2244385183,
-0.1210052818,
-0.1094433814,
0.3462459743,
0.0663007274,
0.185339272,
-0.7078438401,
-0.2254147977,
-0.0282820575,
-0.3213042319,
-0.1688743532,
-0.0998385176,
-0.111175403,
-0.3059224784,
0.7338872552,
-0.2726769447,
0.1569150686,
-0.2081754655,
-0.397867918,
0.0800389126,
0.1426779628,
0.618176043,
0.6306393147,
-0.010634142,
0.241129607,
-0.1487905234,
-0.1217787489,
0.1799991131,
0.2005059868,
-0.4480991364,
0.048807174,
0.4987797141,
0.6944915056,
0.2924832702,
-0.6687666774,
0.6126514673,
0.0686879829,
-0.2061953843,
-0.17710118,
0.0570933111,
0.2769266069,
0.273702085,
0.0611713976,
0.0694017857,
0.1881836951,
-0.6992592216,
0.2613944411,
0.4887925684,
-0.1477268785,
-0.5303426385,
0.8184310198,
-0.1159301475,
-0.4111834466,
0.819414854,
-0.4276890755,
-0.3938877583,
0.7574829459,
0.6267869473,
0.7761923075,
-0.1846255064,
0.2467939854,
0.3566121161,
0.5241211653,
-0.3830817342,
0.2844859362,
0.1784030646,
-0.7261410952,
-0.2810277641,
-0.2723068595,
-0.4170338511,
0.2946150899,
-0.3571248651,
0.3311550021,
-0.2653707564,
0.066444166,
0.227065593,
-0.1274206191,
-0.6951555014,
-0.0553669743,
0.3660878837,
1.1392914057,
-1.1450853348,
0.824313283,
0.6226686239,
-0.5304851532,
-0.5118205547,
-0.45136711,
0.4655468762,
-0.7050763369,
0.7469379306,
0.0460854732,
0.2571266294,
-0.2205990106,
-0.7030971646,
-0.8966152668,
0.718557477,
0.7160461545,
-0.391302675,
-0.1501493752,
0.3335430622,
0.4750635624,
-0.5711554885,
0.43321082,
0.8753629327,
0.3629639447,
-0.0451134704,
-0.9384419918,
-0.2429635972,
-0.6346194744,
0.0892572179,
0.100960806,
-0.1540663242,
1.2975656986,
-0.1411118805,
-0.2416325063,
0.5407868028,
0.4822950959,
0.3127110004,
0.2209907919,
0.2734207213,
0.9652485847,
0.773755908,
-0.3852920532,
1.2238301039,
0.182703808,
0.4077243507,
1.5836163759,
-0.4314819276,
0.8988054991,
0.1682797968,
-0.2204513103,
0.5132969022,
0.4903235734,
-0.0414793827,
0.5199124813,
0.6307655573,
-0.1657960564,
-0.5217217803,
0.1379716396,
-0.3831648231,
0.6055047512,
0.3021164238,
-0.1457476765,
-0.4744750857,
-0.0900957659,
-0.0291095618,
0.3547260165,
-0.0276544522,
0.7320539951,
0.0750620589,
-0.7455608845,
0.473398596,
-0.1527261287,
0.3402826786,
-0.3812500834,
-0.1696428657,
-0.3210277259,
0.278775245,
0.1271627992,
-0.5568158031,
0.3853045106,
-0.0030804358,
-0.0754727349,
0.0484535098,
0.5497485995,
-0.5792324543,
-0.7874975204,
-0.0959651396,
0.7317948341,
0.4166465104,
-0.2142108232,
-0.8134751916,
0.0079042185,
-0.476682663,
-0.1306153387,
0.0576532558,
0.4464343488,
-0.0769616961,
0.8020200729,
0.4352191985,
0.2220438719,
0.5332410336,
0.2329771072,
0.5591477752,
-0.6902530193,
-0.4894237816,
-1.0220257044,
0.3712695241,
-0.0728226081,
-0.4613946378,
0.6026719213,
0.8156812787,
0.8721609116,
-0.1808125526,
0.8130454421,
0.1102792397,
0.4968147576,
-0.4882558286,
0.8143705726,
-0.3152923882,
-0.0343095213,
-0.0471939109,
-0.6883980036,
-0.4030079544,
0.6221328974,
-0.3300488293,
-0.0097951237,
0.8337402344,
0.9366326332,
-0.139328748,
0.2508023977,
0.4556774199,
0.3299918771,
0.2730089128,
0.848092258,
1.170732379,
-0.4322547913,
0.3085824549,
-0.4345024824,
-0.0811847448,
-0.1039787456,
-0.9367036819,
-1.104465723,
-0.5727443099,
-0.4766584635,
0.0650324151,
0.1877798885,
0.6852381825,
0.916323483,
-0.7981305718,
-0.2726299465,
-0.408103615,
0.2729414105,
-0.3544638455,
-0.2348284274,
-0.017803574,
-0.5485312343,
-0.7845191956,
0.6870524883,
0.1401170045,
0.1378222406,
-0.2889710069,
0.1207531542,
-0.4547139406,
0.0914092287,
0.2715591788,
0.3518711925,
-0.8319138288,
-0.2875050306,
0.0708264485,
0.0957264081,
-0.0417238139,
0.8955357671,
-0.807933867,
0.5392720103,
0.6427673697,
0.6356501579,
0.5823076963,
-0.2563112378,
0.6639475822,
-0.6369391084,
0.2282435298,
0.5440378189,
0.5073085427,
0.2743493915,
-0.0619138815,
0.5506664515,
0.4257657528,
-0.4413550198,
-1.0654989481,
0.3069142997,
-0.493686378,
-0.137098074,
0.7669187188,
-0.2596418858,
-0.3669916689,
-0.0006832632,
0.289172858,
-0.0947284997,
-0.0345016979,
0.7329967618,
1.0331388712,
-0.0385304652,
-0.3371351361,
-0.7817400098,
0.5665151477,
0.4281219542,
-1.0489537716,
-0.0020028879,
0.3785533011,
0.3226521909,
0.0789378211,
0.5343273878,
-0.1722265184,
0.5081486106,
0.3674901426,
-0.1847784072,
-0.1075352058,
-0.4172215164,
-0.3424316049,
0.115760535,
0.1475549787,
-0.0579203255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16858v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16858v2
|
EAGLE-2: Faster Inference of Language Models with Dynamic Draft Trees
| 2024-06-24T17:59:11 | 2024-06-30T15:03:25 |
Yuhui Li, Fangyun Wei, Chao Zhang, Hongyang Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Inference with modern Large Language Models (LLMs) is expensive and
time-consuming, and speculative sampling has proven to be an effective
solution. Most speculative sampling methods such as EAGLE use a static draft
tree, implicitly assuming that the acceptance rate of draft tokens depends only
on their position. Interestingly, we found that the acceptance rate of draft
tokens is also context-dependent. In this paper, building upon EAGLE, we
propose EAGLE-2, which introduces a new technique of context-aware dynamic
draft tree into drafting modeling. This improvement leverages the fact that the
draft model of EAGLE is well-calibrated: the confidence scores from the draft
model approximate acceptance rates with small errors. We conducted extensive
evaluations on three series of LLMs and six tasks, with EAGLE-2 achieving
speedup ratios 3.05x-4.26x, which is 20%-40% faster than EAGLE-1. EAGLE-2 also
ensures that the distribution of the generated text remains unchanged, making
it a lossless acceleration algorithm.
|
[
-0.2041601837,
-1.031780839,
0.5349504948,
0.6399607062,
-0.2146898806,
0.3140423894,
-0.0006720521,
-1.1171051264,
0.3644466698,
0.3403875828,
-0.6955131888,
-0.1837035418,
-0.6378022432,
0.0022083367,
-0.6486136317,
0.2198378742,
-0.151514858,
-0.4761854112,
0.3547448516,
0.1407411695,
-0.0449422598,
-0.0617080517,
-0.8785961866,
-0.3114819229,
0.2632530332,
0.4166086912,
0.6671795249,
1.0245629549,
0.2729960382,
0.2137673795,
-0.396029532,
0.0827410966,
-0.23185803,
0.3254519999,
0.1592172086,
-0.4757892191,
-0.6349571943,
0.085938029,
0.7950024009,
0.4822040498,
0.0124281328,
0.2575536072,
-0.235714972,
0.6942877173,
-0.68071419,
0.1219117939,
-1.0068545341,
0.1340404898,
-0.3730612397,
-0.3865883946,
-0.543456912,
-0.0218419991,
0.3506343365,
-0.9136176705,
0.1694651246,
0.1540947855,
0.5667728782,
0.1320560127,
-0.5486859083,
-0.4098944962,
-0.5203443766,
0.7803530693,
-0.6338986754,
0.4352841377,
0.411029458,
0.5520314574,
-0.1755769551,
-1.0329692364,
-0.7511268258,
-0.0940842256,
0.2539057732,
0.0155543834,
0.1007670015,
0.0300947148,
-0.0589129888,
0.2182281464,
-0.4025017619,
0.3515243232,
-0.0857456326,
-0.1428486407,
0.6484772563,
-0.0874836594,
0.1121451855,
0.0228214003,
-0.2091391385,
-0.313896209,
-0.828173697,
0.3240345716,
0.4475824535,
0.5612872243,
-0.0520219915,
0.4545173347,
-0.3576088846,
0.678068161,
0.4132574201,
-0.2271933556,
0.3330029249,
-0.294783771,
-0.3208954632,
0.1453322023,
0.3787093461,
0.2174270004,
0.0750978366,
-0.0586686358,
-0.1762787104,
-0.1468839794,
-0.1596705317,
-0.9655613899,
0.2018211037,
0.5620527864,
-0.6157506704,
-0.3897644281,
-0.0908398405,
-0.4818584621,
-0.3959513307,
-0.0950826332,
-0.3653874397,
-0.2930251956,
-0.6442970037,
0.1181132495,
-0.1459842324,
0.278437674,
0.5111982822,
-0.9848499298,
0.2057280988,
0.9209688902,
0.7910824418,
-0.0711922124,
-0.3071867824,
-0.9815844297,
0.0828494951,
-0.7631767988,
1.2624672651,
-0.8503841162,
-0.2353823632,
0.1287723482,
-0.2318889201,
0.1473764032,
-0.5011712909,
0.6387747526,
-0.8448556662,
-0.2053459883,
-0.5887242556,
-0.4561054409,
-0.1974117011,
0.1974880248,
-0.7703727484,
1.2625257969,
0.2291418463,
-0.7671924233,
0.6934411526,
-0.5846349001,
-0.4294147491,
0.1344161481,
-0.1872891933,
-0.0573122613,
-0.0519190207,
0.128369242,
0.2324115038,
-0.2578755319,
0.0753392056,
-0.6663233042,
-0.7731217742,
-0.2374954224,
-0.2492824942,
0.8907485604,
0.6574693322,
-0.4034881592,
-0.1596223414,
-0.3716672063,
0.2367389053,
-0.2094690502,
-0.7016120553,
-0.2030908912,
0.2830115557,
0.2946591079,
0.0881593153,
-0.091742605,
-0.4125939906,
0.2766028047,
-0.7952570915,
0.1905768663,
0.4616097212,
-0.0799515098,
0.4794105589,
-0.1771782041,
0.4321633577,
-0.171431303,
-0.2654791772,
-0.1134062633,
-0.2962065935,
-0.6384851336,
-0.4739904404,
0.1856744587,
0.6522439718,
-0.7499251366,
0.3912921846,
-0.1345968097,
-0.4502639771,
-0.1475173831,
0.1518782526,
0.329374522,
0.1391429305,
0.0300574172,
0.0883249938,
-0.6908416152,
-0.6188476682,
-0.5947352648,
-0.7288060188,
0.1219298616,
0.2060407102,
0.2191398442,
0.0101286825,
0.7575234771,
-0.0443083122,
0.0018374941,
-0.2575461268,
0.5627864599,
-0.11539343,
0.3800016344,
0.9144287705,
-0.624196291,
-0.7359648347,
-0.1754848063,
-0.6128894091,
-0.2703083158,
-0.15249376,
-0.1873203367,
0.346706301,
0.6342499256,
-0.6321619749,
0.0893521458,
0.6694875956,
-0.58933568,
0.2633903027,
0.0056644171,
-0.0060892273,
-1.0728998184,
0.0936859623,
-0.0450577959,
-0.1032185629,
-0.5154619813,
0.3958304524,
0.1434121132,
0.2776008546,
-0.7504995465,
0.947408855,
-0.7920743227,
-0.1733707488,
-0.4479928315,
0.0121794688,
-0.196393013,
-0.0153758302,
0.1159807667,
1.0981014967,
0.5748838782,
-0.3955413401,
0.0307795461,
0.0470953323,
-0.5417576432,
0.1954700053,
-0.4079210758,
0.1374980211,
-0.1514923126,
0.8344233036,
-0.8864443898,
-0.1865722835,
0.200267747,
-0.2468626499,
0.2716002464,
0.0982557014,
-0.6358402371,
-0.2785196006,
-0.4603198469,
0.3923342526,
0.3448506892,
-0.5073949695,
0.6860727668,
0.3749918044,
-0.1035667509,
-0.9419310093,
-0.9795371294,
0.1322657019,
0.0676114559,
-0.5227931142,
0.3920849562,
-0.0046528066,
-0.4112775326,
0.0544097237,
-0.1272989064,
-0.29030931,
0.1364090294,
0.1222748086,
-0.3011849523,
-0.3448402882,
0.0364855453,
0.4179840684,
-0.0927407667,
-0.1196371764,
-0.4402809739,
0.2216273397,
-0.1387411058,
-0.3790613711,
-0.6655023098,
0.2678361237,
0.8074114919,
-0.2777399123,
0.4672445357,
0.2460796386,
-0.4713941813,
-0.3233790994,
-0.7593485117,
-0.193677485,
-0.4531942308,
0.4627695084,
-0.4719143808,
-0.9111963511,
0.3945759833,
-0.161007151,
0.4920346141,
0.3721389472,
0.5219087601,
0.0798971057,
0.978309691,
0.6866025925,
0.0127458023,
0.6841965318,
-0.2648926079,
0.1198963597,
-0.7273939848,
-0.0164316911,
-0.5691819191,
-0.2964527011,
-0.3101694882,
-0.6234549284,
-0.1255790442,
0.2999118268,
-0.0581399836,
-0.0020904965,
-0.1963497251,
0.5017359853,
0.4347547889,
-0.1835219264,
0.3331798017,
0.2877295613,
-0.0971152261,
0.2526256442,
-0.5689359307,
-0.6756998897,
1.1389220953,
0.4432348311,
0.2277788222,
0.2115778923,
0.3432906568,
0.1645403206,
0.6715699434,
-0.641935885,
0.5414866209,
-0.3143663108,
-0.9851354957,
-0.3039688468,
-0.0002144074,
-0.6301594973,
0.2636192441,
-0.3020865321,
-0.8414688706,
0.1491404623,
0.6255428195,
-0.5644044876,
0.3158431053,
-0.6373738647,
0.4143705368,
-0.0260288268,
-0.3361691236,
-0.3237437606,
-0.3337952197,
0.8150515556,
-0.4905668795,
0.0289988518,
-0.3577824533,
-0.1772611141,
0.6241942644,
-0.570938468,
0.6762117743,
-0.3603830636,
0.0220242292,
0.8496917486,
0.3670926094,
0.9759838581,
0.0906664506,
-0.7075885534,
-0.3131195307,
0.2292148024,
-0.3174915016,
-0.6943412423,
0.748724103,
-0.6349842548,
-0.3713211715,
-0.4880461991,
-0.7618364096,
-0.1283980608,
0.1189783737,
-0.0425665528,
0.2564566433,
0.0181814618,
0.2649480402,
0.1805990785,
-0.1139990091,
0.5376808643,
0.7693014741,
-0.2671495974,
0.0908889845,
0.3836967349,
0.3918019831,
0.0501218811,
0.4399122596,
-0.0345368683,
-0.6474938989,
-0.6328204274,
-0.4877072573,
0.2016208619,
-0.5192942023,
0.1337390244,
-0.8525131345,
0.0414345637,
-0.3190050125,
-0.216964066,
-0.5312748551,
-0.6396836638,
-0.0575513542,
-0.3190544248,
0.4094780684,
0.3045492172,
0.1113105193,
0.5645424128,
-0.4372429848,
0.128213197,
0.1109127179,
0.4395602345,
0.2640819252,
-0.5327796936,
0.1837689579,
-0.0052614287,
-0.202011466,
-0.6360194087,
0.0026183934,
0.3084288836,
0.5101025105,
0.5469817519,
0.1281322241,
0.7956523299,
-0.358541131,
0.7776572108,
-0.1046261564,
-0.7946155667,
0.1556123197,
-0.2584216297,
0.3190498054,
0.8192753792,
-0.1930621117,
-0.3973402679,
-0.6120911837,
-0.3998608589,
-0.697108686,
0.8262215853,
0.1529568881,
0.1136042625,
-0.0535888337,
0.6699762344,
-0.0732234865,
0.0030557592,
-0.2455660999,
-0.1352656782,
-0.0983281061,
-0.1607629061,
-0.0702065155,
-0.633205235,
0.396697104,
-0.1176815182,
0.7367188334,
-0.1891259104,
0.1742401123,
0.1072441265,
0.0915579125,
-0.5081751347,
0.00308163,
0.7077746391,
0.6228683591,
-0.464542836,
0.4558670521,
0.2745643556,
-0.4589221776,
0.2322473526,
0.1645817757,
-0.4518471956,
0.0352377966,
0.6661301851,
0.6508572698,
0.0297475196,
-0.78908813,
0.28739658,
-0.0586973578,
-0.486317724,
-0.3414972126,
0.0368227698,
0.2851708531,
0.3875478208,
0.4892372191,
0.0290200152,
0.2074080408,
-0.5116069913,
0.2969676852,
0.6537847519,
-0.151833117,
-0.3258322477,
0.7492868304,
0.3504860699,
-0.4871741533,
0.5011507273,
-0.3811556399,
-0.230425179,
0.6587878466,
0.6592146158,
0.9585104585,
-0.1329585612,
0.1403196603,
0.3741703331,
0.2549423277,
-0.3862640262,
0.571282506,
0.0207298789,
-0.5907996893,
-0.6738882065,
-0.6289442778,
-0.2644488811,
0.3980869651,
-0.1594106853,
0.0814511031,
-0.4696758687,
-0.180289343,
-0.0883027837,
0.3305253685,
-0.4791715145,
0.0619269535,
-0.0263693891,
1.822939992,
-0.9516031146,
1.0375338793,
0.7585135698,
-0.0348390266,
-1.1492116451,
0.2783194482,
0.3807181418,
-0.6472216249,
0.8719722629,
0.2642338574,
-0.388094008,
0.2110823095,
-0.1596412808,
-1.0579224825,
1.1912950277,
0.3133985102,
-0.4729423821,
-0.0369287953,
-0.0476741828,
0.474055618,
-0.4178680778,
0.5767319202,
0.5365375876,
0.7533012033,
0.3237735331,
-0.744437933,
0.0442242399,
-0.3851734102,
0.2102712393,
-0.1236839741,
-0.6495469213,
0.9364308119,
0.0887146965,
-0.3056077659,
0.2134088129,
0.9790247083,
0.8237349987,
0.2882900536,
0.895644784,
0.2583780885,
0.9182258844,
0.2036486417,
0.9825489521,
-0.7578722239,
0.0829762444,
0.9316183925,
-0.6092089415,
1.2053248882,
0.7656621933,
0.0670543835,
0.4109642208,
0.9071740508,
0.5869980454,
0.4268793464,
-0.0318200737,
-0.4572705626,
-0.2741104066,
-0.0622068644,
-0.4059569538,
0.4069970846,
0.010661562,
-0.2917723358,
-0.3013900518,
-0.5151907206,
0.1557480991,
-0.0268245097,
0.1661928147,
0.2609111071,
0.0448211581,
-1.0577263832,
0.6008001566,
0.4087243378,
0.5272343159,
-0.62349087,
-0.0495904796,
-0.2895819545,
0.2608757615,
0.0333583355,
-0.6255888939,
0.3921553493,
0.1410765052,
-0.1982723624,
-0.2681807876,
0.3686020374,
-0.3016284108,
-0.8892849684,
0.2970939577,
0.5266817808,
0.3066658676,
-0.1373969167,
-0.625010252,
0.5645387769,
-0.4074619412,
-0.7409622073,
0.1237998679,
0.3769818246,
-0.3204357624,
0.644400835,
0.8094195127,
0.2336569875,
0.0345780179,
-0.2210133821,
0.5229209661,
-0.179614976,
-0.6934942007,
-0.6975579262,
0.2610471547,
0.0456232205,
-0.2431555837,
0.4420620501,
0.7442013621,
0.5921213031,
0.2339862883,
0.8488567472,
-0.0484932959,
0.7829181552,
-0.6112785935,
0.737113595,
-0.7072498202,
0.4881028831,
-0.1358485967,
-0.8884183764,
-0.3532730043,
0.6101837754,
-0.1341199577,
0.0004509094,
0.8162286282,
0.9932993054,
-0.2751188278,
-0.0295116492,
-0.254039228,
0.0970750451,
0.6137332916,
0.5896609426,
0.6416438818,
-0.3991609812,
0.4358177483,
-0.1890657842,
-0.3171733618,
-0.5061112642,
-1.3341606855,
-0.7403140664,
-0.4193741977,
-0.0257869326,
-0.2585970759,
0.2331758589,
1.1305158138,
1.15647614,
-0.6168079972,
-0.3955759704,
-0.319573611,
-0.1767100692,
-0.5546117425,
-0.168769598,
0.4528064728,
-0.296197474,
-0.73883605,
0.6353715062,
0.1302895695,
0.0514213406,
-0.0771067739,
-0.4586744606,
-0.2681001723,
0.3643707335,
0.5670566559,
0.4592499137,
-1.203017354,
-0.4294113517,
0.031674318,
-0.1670279205,
-0.328316927,
0.8435072303,
-0.8731248379,
0.5254709721,
0.6350420713,
0.8423436284,
0.5518417954,
0.2598747909,
0.3934730291,
-0.4222860336,
0.6954451203,
-0.1932596564,
0.0126699312,
0.065991722,
-0.2818255424,
0.2656359673,
0.2289366871,
-0.0208958685,
-1.0950415134,
0.2493350208,
-0.7972669601,
-0.4217603803,
1.1229152679,
0.086571686,
-0.1463931203,
0.023350656,
-0.2700566947,
0.318195045,
-0.326979816,
0.6687375307,
0.5519862175,
-0.120395869,
-0.2352204919,
-0.6264057159,
0.574703753,
0.4497936666,
-0.7441007495,
0.247077167,
0.2546968162,
0.2454091758,
-0.1708807647,
1.2068763971,
0.2596366405,
0.3106596172,
0.2315966338,
-0.1631087512,
-0.4740169346,
-0.394353956,
0.0646937266,
0.2472338825,
0.6170318127,
0.2020912915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16851v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16851v2
|
Losing Visual Needles in Image Haystacks: Vision Language Models are Easily Distracted in Short and Long Contexts
| 2024-06-24T17:58:03 | 2024-07-03T03:55:59 |
Aditya Sharma, Michael Saxon, William Yang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
We present LoCoVQA, a dynamic benchmark generator for evaluating long-context
extractive reasoning in vision language models (VLMs). LoCoVQA augments test
examples for mathematical reasoning, VQA, and character recognition tasks with
increasingly long visual contexts composed of both in-distribution and
out-of-distribution distractor images.
Across these tasks, a diverse set of VLMs rapidly lose performance as the
visual context length grows, often exhibiting a striking logarithmic decay
trend. This test assesses how well VLMs can ignore irrelevant information when
answering queries -- a task that is quite easy for language models (LMs) in the
text domain -- demonstrating that current state-of-the-art VLMs lack this
essential capability for many long-context applications.
|
[
-0.2164822966,
-0.7377222776,
0.7320033908,
0.2976604998,
-0.577298224,
-0.2855196893,
-0.0425183661,
-0.6240410805,
-0.2374147922,
0.6560373306,
-0.488054812,
-0.4101602137,
-0.4060080945,
-0.004102712,
-0.6308421493,
0.4252097011,
-0.05384342,
-0.2123737186,
-0.7743573189,
-0.2925794125,
-0.7182677388,
-0.383690089,
-0.4435203671,
0.2155217379,
0.6379648447,
-0.0129135959,
0.5267928839,
0.787645936,
0.7358310819,
0.2548030615,
-0.1981571168,
0.2121803015,
-0.4500313401,
0.42102018,
-0.3440851271,
-0.2250047773,
0.0129844425,
-0.2629723549,
0.7234933972,
0.5622218251,
-0.0228139628,
0.1267944574,
-0.1078851521,
0.5675125122,
-1.1451737881,
0.1394999623,
-0.744343698,
-0.1991488039,
-0.3691319525,
0.0267563015,
-0.356382221,
-0.1797873825,
0.1928310543,
-0.4304706454,
-0.0252147336,
0.0560658462,
1.0862551928,
0.6662688255,
-0.6084143519,
-0.1288917363,
-0.5750864148,
0.8566219211,
-0.2565548122,
0.5867060423,
0.3933912814,
0.6095041037,
0.0378023386,
-0.9892535806,
-0.508901298,
-0.1547384262,
0.0803854987,
0.1700109392,
-0.0911506861,
-0.1573505253,
0.4444879591,
-0.0407327637,
-0.3355250061,
-0.1189362705,
-0.4201929867,
-0.0353111252,
0.4534654915,
0.5968383551,
-0.0931114852,
-0.1526810527,
-0.5256775618,
-0.1719398052,
-0.8129506707,
0.2239858508,
-0.2001670152,
-0.1393675059,
0.2560877502,
0.4342300892,
-0.3542440534,
1.0745437145,
-0.2757492065,
0.1206984147,
0.1422074139,
-0.4378939569,
-0.4460501969,
-0.5474894047,
0.6828330159,
0.5536141992,
-0.0403633788,
0.0397004932,
-0.3350364268,
-0.1173910424,
0.2018550634,
-0.7215793729,
-0.2575035989,
-0.0116002467,
-0.3068314493,
-0.1761145145,
-0.2612107098,
-0.9725358486,
-0.484157294,
0.0534583069,
0.5331920385,
-0.2965078056,
0.246697098,
0.0217946749,
-0.3328244984,
0.5252314806,
0.5372728109,
-0.5574144721,
0.0971192047,
0.5341895223,
0.6632006764,
-0.3721035421,
-0.2845766544,
-1.0651497841,
-0.2378348708,
-0.474339962,
0.678180933,
-0.473944962,
-0.3819920719,
0.1287405491,
0.2958419323,
0.0133444015,
-0.8203984499,
0.608630538,
-0.4851402938,
0.1379235685,
-0.4519415796,
-0.2886091173,
-0.0204701032,
0.2837290168,
-0.6818883419,
1.2398322821,
0.2097116411,
-0.4499062598,
0.5362482667,
-0.2611816525,
-0.2117939293,
0.4167642593,
-0.3472327292,
-0.4229746163,
0.0568426065,
0.0234103482,
0.3977656662,
-0.50723207,
0.1089960635,
-0.4214265943,
-0.6341593266,
0.2578309774,
-0.4769738317,
0.7107934356,
0.0194927473,
-0.5694666505,
0.0767738223,
-0.8637205362,
0.1357717812,
0.1132251546,
-0.3226032257,
-0.8962675333,
0.4750778675,
0.0646114796,
0.4751310647,
0.1526731402,
-0.2622551024,
-0.0303065535,
-0.1269744486,
0.3277526796,
0.7081085443,
-0.1095294431,
0.0033735919,
0.085815154,
0.2961946726,
0.2018160373,
0.264778018,
-0.3229177594,
-0.3852718771,
-1.1448460817,
-0.5203368068,
0.0422168784,
0.4841644168,
-1.2530068159,
0.1152913049,
-0.3438126147,
-0.3780933321,
-0.2702966928,
0.0724909231,
0.5244248509,
0.6186489463,
0.2678166926,
-0.3497664034,
-0.3380258381,
-1.1215251684,
-0.502941072,
-0.1260238588,
-0.0626947135,
0.3852576315,
0.6798839569,
-0.2863533497,
0.7905337811,
-0.3161648512,
-0.0406345017,
0.2517268062,
-0.1580371261,
-0.0469373204,
0.1948632896,
0.459284842,
-1.0823552608,
-0.2774522007,
-0.14078255,
-0.8691483736,
-0.0717562363,
-0.1644333899,
-0.1627832353,
0.3069655895,
0.7286393642,
-0.6913034916,
1.0086995363,
0.354446739,
-0.7076422572,
0.7077206969,
0.0596715659,
0.0238830075,
-0.5261085629,
0.2876406014,
0.0629134327,
-0.4546173811,
-0.4016825557,
0.2851835787,
0.4350285232,
0.1163461208,
-0.6591566205,
0.8654913902,
-0.6088521481,
-0.0578846149,
-0.0510358401,
0.1736121923,
0.2816987634,
0.3036735058,
0.3318286836,
0.8194472194,
0.647331357,
-0.8171181083,
0.4581747949,
0.0640274733,
-0.6567935348,
0.388233453,
-0.7771672606,
-0.0368448794,
-0.1457594931,
-0.1996574998,
-0.8596081138,
-0.1887601316,
0.1650074124,
-0.0206973609,
-0.1113798171,
-0.0052351025,
-0.2746942341,
-0.5150247216,
-0.1312818229,
0.6174942851,
0.8719393611,
-0.6442349553,
0.5567657948,
0.1994667202,
0.0954749361,
-0.7888991833,
-0.6364998817,
0.1346574724,
-0.342712909,
-0.3252254128,
0.086291194,
-0.058541324,
-0.5378912091,
-0.030240126,
0.0405848995,
-0.4214763343,
0.092890352,
0.3342904747,
0.236890763,
-0.1117819473,
0.393774122,
-0.3006626368,
0.3084953725,
0.381385684,
-0.1472270191,
0.2152617574,
-0.3229908645,
-0.4486299157,
-0.0964167863,
0.3947893679,
0.8077723384,
-0.3504997492,
0.6429561377,
0.3521371782,
-0.3095532954,
-0.1819589585,
-0.4836363196,
0.1475730091,
-0.4874977171,
0.7553351521,
-0.4733189642,
-0.5876339674,
0.5558151007,
0.0883444101,
0.0307479389,
0.488851279,
0.6009908319,
-0.0543060452,
0.7155071497,
0.5863555074,
0.4727067351,
0.5721842051,
-0.0380772054,
-0.0611688159,
-0.7607022524,
-0.4713291824,
-0.2665879428,
0.2015309483,
-0.2856801152,
-0.8072761893,
0.2872076631,
0.0552274249,
0.0738145038,
0.2380423099,
-0.473755002,
0.7001204491,
0.5963329673,
0.03081364,
-0.0682141334,
-0.3498111069,
-0.0789510384,
-0.1343601495,
-0.6050470471,
-0.2737621665,
0.7153843045,
0.1384614408,
0.6993892193,
-0.0051981243,
0.4328457713,
0.0022156534,
0.2112845778,
-0.9611402154,
0.6967415214,
-0.0023586235,
-0.4545052052,
-0.4185580611,
-0.3802666664,
-0.9050754905,
0.5257685184,
-0.0456088185,
-0.6757215261,
0.5133509636,
0.1952360421,
-0.2655008137,
0.0524496846,
-0.3632940054,
1.0982177258,
-0.2256790996,
-0.9771072268,
0.2694893181,
-0.6032068729,
0.5477787852,
-0.267536968,
0.0792530552,
-0.0592113398,
-0.2555465698,
0.5602966547,
-0.3276014328,
0.5761681199,
0.0243654326,
0.0292445123,
0.4978491366,
0.1075894088,
0.5738955736,
-0.1251284778,
0.064342387,
0.1178582087,
0.1845899224,
-0.4604006112,
-0.6328234076,
0.4026831985,
-0.1034556404,
-0.6589129567,
-0.4206364751,
-0.3119172454,
-0.1024601385,
0.2430116534,
0.3148179054,
0.458062917,
-0.1856382489,
0.5398070216,
0.8410921693,
-0.2796346247,
0.5965663195,
0.0845754966,
-0.2807098031,
-0.1400425434,
0.7360201478,
-0.1055949554,
0.3448682725,
0.1408678144,
-0.0439238586,
-0.4736069143,
-0.4031664133,
-0.4645371735,
0.0253327582,
-1.1609852314,
-0.0395390876,
-0.3946919143,
-0.1823964268,
-0.1491226256,
0.1370801777,
-0.384847194,
-0.1530940533,
-0.2281212509,
0.4235117733,
-0.0287338868,
0.5711306334,
0.415441066,
-0.1518877447,
-0.760727644,
0.1708292365,
0.717120707,
0.2653601468,
-0.1961196065,
-0.5114337802,
-0.4329795241,
-0.1996033341,
-0.1637437791,
-0.7507835031,
0.5050147176,
0.1565012336,
0.5956398845,
0.2959005833,
0.0278696753,
1.0239508152,
-0.5803138614,
0.9697266221,
0.2388641089,
-0.9483648539,
0.3289425075,
-0.2624070942,
0.6787096858,
0.4208650887,
0.1758138239,
-0.5398802757,
-0.2894689739,
-0.3250049949,
-0.9374464154,
0.1812349111,
0.2659645677,
-0.1133611724,
-0.1523553431,
0.3034285307,
-0.0640589222,
0.1444154829,
-0.7458799481,
0.0212047976,
-0.1906066835,
-0.1778663844,
-0.0466501303,
-0.3670283258,
-0.0989717245,
-0.3697543144,
0.2046261728,
-0.157246083,
0.1945299357,
0.3802257776,
-0.048164852,
0.1941606104,
-0.1108593792,
0.7780660391,
0.7982302308,
-0.045600377,
0.3961791992,
0.1480984986,
-0.4475308061,
-0.236172691,
-0.1609713733,
-0.1890428215,
0.2502597868,
0.4035062194,
0.8414016366,
0.0800421983,
-1.2336266041,
0.7361102104,
-0.3127467036,
-0.3152816892,
-0.5093168616,
0.010154889,
0.07989005,
0.1828497797,
0.4179778099,
0.1459962726,
0.2429947257,
-0.5183250904,
0.2742503583,
0.5825724006,
-0.6523808837,
-0.097157225,
0.8076558113,
0.2037740797,
-0.3221592605,
0.573351562,
-0.0096626598,
-0.4565721154,
0.8071537614,
0.0414915234,
0.8167196512,
0.0629536808,
-0.2628279924,
0.205359444,
0.3867734373,
-0.1389764249,
0.1326141804,
-0.1111084595,
-0.2502572834,
-0.362154901,
-0.4195364416,
-0.2136270851,
0.2628164589,
-0.6765323281,
0.3810197115,
-0.1381780058,
-0.0166331455,
0.0796810165,
-0.4243151546,
-0.7843852043,
0.3635978997,
0.0934241414,
0.969408989,
-0.4692970812,
0.9336109161,
0.4526477158,
-0.1512365341,
-0.2728080451,
-0.0176080931,
-0.1347627193,
-0.5692003965,
1.0306370258,
0.2967385054,
-0.3286425173,
-0.4499819279,
-0.7209711671,
-0.8343417048,
0.9851627946,
0.2115838081,
-0.6172028184,
0.0137243709,
-0.2118715793,
0.5492386222,
-0.2551570833,
0.0991984978,
0.331543535,
0.2033055425,
0.2696492672,
-0.8429108262,
0.0795092732,
-0.2904394269,
0.0954962671,
0.3245308399,
-0.6591038704,
1.126968503,
-0.1723798066,
-0.364405334,
0.4004184902,
0.5016467571,
0.2507058978,
0.5918539762,
0.5282865763,
0.1746572107,
0.5159514546,
-0.1592741311,
1.0190553665,
0.0471843705,
0.3165732324,
1.1013394594,
-0.3824329972,
1.0925052166,
0.8056796789,
0.332166642,
0.4110807776,
0.6543467641,
0.1451696903,
0.7618495822,
0.2188435495,
-0.2728893757,
-0.7368026972,
0.1525654346,
-0.1771309078,
0.5509375334,
0.4052798748,
-0.4207573235,
0.0085412543,
-0.0435918607,
-0.3582289517,
0.0006272896,
-0.1559976339,
0.4349114597,
0.1114987954,
-0.9481031299,
1.0085135698,
-0.2942294478,
0.3071360886,
-0.4052907526,
-0.2079467773,
-0.1915865242,
0.3470341861,
0.3270382285,
-0.6698684692,
0.3860702217,
-0.1541743279,
-0.0382996798,
0.0304704066,
0.73947227,
-0.4574955404,
-0.3926709294,
0.2936207056,
0.4536477625,
0.2687364519,
-0.030076284,
-0.6333453059,
0.2318091989,
-0.1634249985,
-0.4333544672,
0.2538761795,
0.6568785906,
-0.4478011727,
1.0771085024,
0.3551310897,
-0.1133327186,
0.1968915015,
-0.3000109494,
0.9791223407,
-0.9512167573,
-0.249945417,
-0.9895539284,
0.4454754889,
-0.4093831778,
-0.5017525554,
0.9235643744,
0.4393583536,
0.5940400362,
-0.2531665862,
0.4643033445,
0.0436991528,
0.2192563862,
-0.7062281966,
0.527754426,
-0.960496664,
0.1440344155,
-0.0968448669,
-0.731058836,
-0.3720960915,
0.4403497577,
-0.230226934,
-0.0608166866,
0.9155486226,
0.5370590091,
0.0328116864,
-0.5774273872,
0.8538293839,
-0.0410743132,
0.1601235569,
0.8533086777,
1.2212620974,
-0.56297189,
0.6784858108,
-0.1200682744,
-0.0246574767,
-0.3760152161,
-1.0394330025,
-1.1176477671,
-0.7551794648,
-0.3297508359,
-0.2809877098,
0.296900928,
0.3111770153,
0.7547622323,
-0.3044111133,
-0.0315336734,
0.0227338541,
0.1883784682,
-0.3604621589,
-0.2507284582,
0.2527420819,
-0.1472030282,
-0.6955349445,
0.2185824364,
0.4841048419,
0.0506935269,
-0.2966559827,
-0.024940148,
-0.0420112573,
0.150482282,
0.8005205393,
0.3671401441,
-0.9276176095,
-0.4371504486,
0.2222417891,
-0.321074605,
-0.0856209025,
0.4944707155,
-1.0857621431,
0.6519414783,
0.5036365986,
0.4940904081,
0.3295497894,
0.0082496861,
0.2893117666,
-0.5948108435,
0.3871486485,
0.4222952425,
0.3257803619,
0.1810174435,
-0.2501403689,
0.4591895342,
0.4294223189,
-0.5799803734,
-1.1182487011,
0.1615247279,
-0.9777294397,
-0.3628802299,
1.1942927837,
-0.1955984235,
-0.771163702,
-0.134362489,
-0.044432871,
-0.2664881945,
0.0141315069,
0.7481100559,
0.685636282,
0.1703677028,
-0.4847874939,
-0.5301188827,
0.7736253738,
0.4648976028,
-0.8385928869,
0.31153211,
0.7468704581,
0.2609696686,
0.1940077245,
0.5975087881,
0.036786925,
0.6343626976,
0.2792064846,
0.0758735165,
0.029179981,
-0.4550892115,
-0.3252757788,
0.1957140565,
-0.096371524,
-0.3716248274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16845v1
|
RaTEScore: A Metric for Radiology Report Generation
| 2024-06-24T17:49:28 | 2024-06-24T17:49:28 |
Weike Zhao, Chaoyi Wu, Xiaoman Zhang, Ya Zhang, Yanfeng Wang, Weidi Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces a novel, entity-aware metric, termed as Radiological
Report (Text) Evaluation (RaTEScore), to assess the quality of medical reports
generated by AI models. RaTEScore emphasizes crucial medical entities such as
diagnostic outcomes and anatomical details, and is robust against complex
medical synonyms and sensitive to negation expressions. Technically, we
developed a comprehensive medical NER dataset, RaTE-NER, and trained an NER
model specifically for this purpose. This model enables the decomposition of
complex radiological reports into constituent medical entities. The metric
itself is derived by comparing the similarity of entity embeddings, obtained
from a language model, based on their types and relevance to clinical
significance. Our evaluations demonstrate that RaTEScore aligns more closely
with human preference than existing metrics, validated both on established
public benchmarks and our newly proposed RaTE-Eval benchmark.
|
[
-0.2318145782,
-0.4188628197,
0.5740057826,
0.0350553207,
-0.0292321909,
-0.0027757138,
-0.0983794704,
-0.6275430918,
0.0977921486,
0.2420738488,
0.0579799004,
-0.8213300705,
-0.6411219239,
0.0591187775,
-0.2942188084,
1.2704703808,
0.0574144013,
0.5238882899,
-0.6352236867,
-0.2083009034,
-0.4153198302,
-0.2577474117,
-0.8979648948,
-0.5032485127,
0.4221771657,
0.3157089651,
0.8259379268,
0.734117806,
1.2157162428,
0.0988874957,
0.0256689414,
0.095619075,
-0.0950542018,
0.1916445941,
0.0127431164,
-0.1469993144,
-1.1092997789,
0.0163397547,
0.650924623,
0.5650420785,
-0.2322332114,
0.3946432173,
-0.3677954972,
0.8478637338,
-0.5670846105,
0.3134779334,
-0.1871533543,
0.1644544601,
-0.1219941974,
-0.4755681455,
-0.4574977458,
-0.6061730385,
0.0881385803,
-0.3443036377,
0.3583602011,
0.0024763246,
0.8944716454,
0.020600507,
-0.3715558052,
-0.5512519479,
-0.5614437461,
0.4331916571,
-0.4697324932,
0.280349046,
0.1807659864,
0.482080549,
0.2153504342,
-0.9256398678,
-0.1747441143,
-0.5754809976,
-0.2009509802,
0.2571789324,
-0.5827560425,
0.028455453,
0.2302866727,
0.5379381776,
-0.7463954091,
0.0798473731,
-0.3268839419,
-0.3814601004,
0.7309154868,
0.593678534,
0.7817572951,
-0.4755426943,
-0.3479840457,
-0.0177825168,
-0.6137859225,
-0.1095010564,
0.1184579432,
0.1552049071,
-0.1241422072,
0.670879066,
-0.4366991818,
0.4009478092,
-0.0895405933,
-0.4004870355,
0.6034182906,
-0.1659185886,
0.0806306675,
0.4921307564,
0.7846264839,
0.8265649676,
-0.0527646728,
-0.0778703094,
-0.3869639933,
0.617620647,
0.4672403336,
-0.9326683879,
-0.0421095043,
0.2366568595,
-0.8178350329,
-0.6266176701,
-0.2944268882,
-0.2459424287,
-0.117059201,
0.0137022911,
0.3914338648,
-0.7498849034,
-0.4200068414,
0.1336846054,
-0.0050231046,
-0.1339262426,
0.2004841119,
-0.2591586411,
0.4159405231,
0.6071890593,
0.7809553146,
-0.0028115909,
0.0824601576,
-0.5233118534,
-0.0819746852,
-0.4630008638,
1.2232984304,
-0.4222367704,
-0.70064044,
-0.243151173,
-0.3898602426,
0.246706292,
-0.5517110229,
0.7638399005,
-0.3950881064,
0.1988126636,
0.1952943057,
-0.64525491,
-0.1465782821,
0.3999583721,
-0.7009840012,
0.8602695465,
0.3344462812,
-0.8632344604,
0.6778330207,
-0.8357403874,
-0.5101719499,
0.4325638711,
-0.2481017858,
-0.4976020157,
0.2600444257,
0.1179073825,
0.2661352456,
-0.8017905354,
0.5820426941,
0.1181150451,
0.1100227237,
0.2724041045,
-0.2450798303,
0.2056284398,
0.5304492712,
0.1156732962,
0.0568371825,
-0.6724970341,
0.3441115916,
0.0556953885,
-0.053155601,
-0.4174673557,
0.0824581906,
0.0830537826,
0.0694191158,
0.2194806486,
-0.7474284768,
-0.1665252894,
-0.3044286966,
0.2530906498,
0.1976426393,
0.2776709497,
0.3859104216,
-0.7396141887,
0.7862915993,
0.1980527192,
0.3752108514,
-0.0994424298,
-0.3540129662,
-0.3908957541,
-0.2852012217,
0.250275135,
0.15622437,
-0.1176194325,
0.1591680497,
-0.6157638431,
-1.1402705908,
-0.7112700343,
-0.5272377133,
0.7239890099,
1.0436702967,
0.2571922839,
-0.9471638799,
-0.3093874753,
-1.2762399912,
-0.3555406332,
-0.3373930454,
0.1835283637,
0.4062315226,
0.259560734,
0.0763164386,
0.7656007409,
-0.6737456918,
-0.5344996452,
-0.2744803727,
0.1767091006,
0.2085067034,
0.4514330328,
0.4056565762,
-0.6469649673,
-0.4515430927,
-0.2161193639,
-0.9017886519,
-0.0382777378,
0.1519378126,
0.0274866764,
0.065699406,
0.3014551401,
-0.2179518491,
0.4264653921,
0.4809405804,
-0.3522150218,
0.3212731183,
-0.4719490111,
0.5257403851,
-1.0918831825,
0.2796888053,
0.2592487037,
-0.3510600328,
-0.4422005415,
-0.0734435916,
0.1893560439,
-0.4304150641,
-0.5018365383,
0.5538539886,
-0.6202397346,
-0.3392789364,
-0.0387012027,
0.0394364595,
0.1234852597,
-0.2748930156,
0.1221813485,
0.6776521802,
0.6667010188,
-0.5942713618,
0.0098422663,
0.3650524318,
-0.5871338248,
0.8426837921,
-0.7721287608,
0.2848319411,
-0.3210210502,
0.2026305944,
-0.4645524919,
0.0246214997,
-0.2845050395,
-0.8436313272,
0.2553066909,
-0.3414157927,
-0.2755917609,
-0.3137103021,
-0.0395218879,
0.4323351383,
0.6322948337,
0.080713369,
0.3800201416,
0.7798328996,
-0.1033654585,
-0.4791921675,
-0.6124883294,
0.066771619,
0.0617859215,
-0.6777677536,
0.3829450309,
-0.100068219,
-0.3474135399,
0.516381681,
0.0579328537,
-0.2193860561,
0.1151866317,
0.6880934834,
0.4642731845,
-0.675293982,
0.1336308122,
-0.0579007715,
-0.5018618703,
0.2237775773,
0.0609935708,
0.56121099,
-0.2742910385,
-0.2902955115,
-0.5359332561,
0.3364272118,
0.448450923,
-0.3893195391,
0.4365595579,
0.3846126497,
-0.6179174185,
0.2306588143,
-0.5057378411,
0.0173477996,
-0.3018535376,
0.5322756767,
-0.3881191313,
-0.7345698476,
0.3127986789,
0.1557359993,
-0.0254492462,
0.865557909,
0.7475366592,
0.0542171113,
1.2562845945,
0.3054189384,
0.1483919173,
0.0137196453,
-0.1474210471,
0.2096272707,
-1.0383082628,
-0.4361949861,
-0.677513361,
-0.0979053155,
-0.5428359509,
-0.262214154,
0.7650461197,
-0.2150298357,
-0.0270662662,
0.0596784651,
-0.8943088055,
0.4491335154,
0.05810396,
0.1512072831,
0.4954315126,
0.0145080201,
0.4233263433,
-0.2386030704,
-0.6399843097,
-0.6761934161,
1.2432895899,
0.2623890042,
0.610250771,
-0.0093367351,
0.6146556735,
0.7163824439,
0.874815464,
-0.9355967045,
0.3935388625,
-0.5596669316,
-1.0132924318,
0.0347198583,
-0.4392631948,
-0.8521810174,
-0.1745870709,
-0.3555347919,
-0.1618571281,
-0.2431431264,
0.0486397594,
-0.4047478735,
0.1107175648,
-0.359970659,
0.6504389644,
-0.2385276556,
0.2600197792,
-0.6442672014,
-0.2132868171,
0.2179711014,
0.0613456778,
0.3160920143,
-0.740937233,
-0.1403499693,
0.8673117757,
-0.176883325,
0.3044654429,
-0.0350054912,
0.5159151554,
0.2119020969,
0.466688484,
-0.0493202619,
0.4787448943,
-0.1177719161,
0.3520350456,
-0.1344233751,
-0.23923482,
-0.1908433288,
0.7228469849,
-0.7782378793,
-0.0639411509,
-0.6837515831,
-0.5926924944,
-0.0861810446,
0.3040753901,
0.4910075665,
1.2145943642,
-0.638365984,
-0.2661149204,
0.2946024835,
-0.3964185417,
-0.0298847053,
0.7880850434,
-0.0871237144,
-0.4815365076,
0.8160297275,
0.0431355126,
0.1433272809,
0.4809576571,
0.1049695387,
-0.0947512165,
-0.7518982887,
-0.2754410803,
0.2044078857,
-0.700715363,
-0.5974177718,
-0.9215686917,
-0.5315801501,
-0.2477373332,
-0.1577666551,
-0.7162644267,
-0.2688837945,
-0.0236474369,
0.0908684209,
0.4895715714,
0.7534324527,
-0.1216565743,
-0.0059255115,
-0.9233209491,
0.074680917,
-0.3191598356,
0.3727146685,
-0.1846971363,
-0.5280359387,
-0.2571481466,
-0.3388392627,
0.006377554,
-0.6339247227,
0.6521834135,
0.2388304025,
0.4946975708,
0.0814498588,
0.0470944308,
0.4573858976,
-0.4651199281,
0.6845023036,
0.6006673574,
-0.9043912292,
0.8505554199,
-0.0697593018,
0.0762787685,
0.6465806365,
0.5475757718,
-0.7422248721,
-0.51072824,
-0.9461091161,
-0.8687531352,
0.393465966,
-0.1625485122,
0.1720564961,
-0.4220259488,
0.294410497,
0.0888809338,
-0.125612855,
-0.249719575,
-0.2695378661,
0.2092993259,
-0.1820619106,
-0.0708288476,
-0.4179507792,
-0.2402371764,
0.0518914051,
0.3805588186,
-0.0869137123,
0.3511799574,
0.6239103675,
-0.4935798645,
-0.1985624284,
0.3517229557,
0.4612892568,
0.9068012834,
-0.2912019491,
0.2376399487,
0.0024319629,
-0.7043130994,
0.2393782139,
-0.2088413984,
-0.1415655613,
0.32132411,
0.4722286463,
0.5721284747,
0.036150407,
-0.5086558461,
0.7091703415,
-0.4336502552,
-0.0621469431,
-0.5370739102,
0.0311831031,
-0.0877484977,
-0.2322495729,
0.1765564233,
0.4074510634,
0.3823809922,
-0.2536495924,
0.4372884333,
0.0842060223,
-0.9568210244,
-0.3830796778,
0.6114185452,
0.2278222293,
-0.3023074269,
0.97870332,
-0.1814881414,
-0.1822077036,
0.8104869723,
0.4864454567,
0.7478878498,
-0.100478448,
0.4985508919,
0.9340408444,
0.2603540123,
-0.0064774528,
0.3619487584,
0.617167294,
-0.7187390924,
-0.3922787607,
-0.5518092513,
-0.1823779941,
-0.1867396832,
-1.2339129448,
0.35843876,
-0.6268139482,
-0.6935203671,
0.3628970385,
-0.0882672668,
-0.7756643295,
0.5937283635,
0.1535855979,
1.0616127253,
-0.6492567062,
0.6169369817,
0.83279562,
-0.7600331306,
-0.9710276723,
-0.3654391766,
-0.0628276765,
-0.8486992717,
0.8644172549,
0.1304969341,
0.073485218,
-0.0976636484,
-0.0328226089,
-0.7457479835,
1.0928095579,
0.1470118016,
-0.3337989748,
-0.0284223091,
-0.3164320588,
0.6807820201,
-0.8257152438,
0.8161664009,
0.4038601816,
0.1261989325,
-0.568743825,
-1.0822461843,
0.2096572667,
-0.2484065294,
0.051475931,
0.4047498405,
-0.495312959,
0.765011847,
-0.4301669598,
-0.4167365134,
-0.2052979469,
0.4902895987,
-0.0301335454,
0.6449658275,
0.5623472333,
0.6292554736,
0.5343103409,
-0.0464625657,
1.5379209518,
-0.5309076905,
0.3221553266,
0.8130909801,
-0.3459976614,
0.591398716,
0.0166382845,
-0.0974493101,
0.5459823012,
0.4043568075,
0.014339109,
0.3808857203,
-0.0000148974,
-0.1815674752,
-0.3375733793,
-0.7138848305,
-0.7268872261,
0.5192220211,
0.2584810555,
-0.498516947,
-0.2895731032,
-0.2542190552,
0.1730872542,
0.0876048431,
-0.2334544212,
0.8938727379,
0.1263692826,
-0.5390779376,
0.2718856633,
-0.0229860395,
0.3649347723,
-0.6621310115,
0.174861744,
-0.378085047,
0.0683606192,
-0.5645803809,
-0.8948696256,
0.483607769,
0.2858499587,
-0.5373021364,
-0.0227376577,
0.579623878,
-0.0178911369,
-0.3894458711,
0.1406037956,
0.4602359235,
0.301042676,
0.2173290998,
-0.6211083531,
-0.0913750008,
-0.1635088027,
-0.1403963566,
0.4882283211,
0.1269186884,
-0.1094799116,
0.6433336735,
0.605709374,
0.6061102748,
-0.6126635671,
0.3032853901,
0.7145872116,
-0.5864316821,
-0.4520383179,
-0.5550878048,
0.4279203117,
-0.0644980669,
-0.6838219762,
0.3098648489,
1.0199452639,
0.5421823263,
0.1507460475,
0.5741422772,
-0.2232211828,
0.5685551167,
-0.3167714477,
1.1042494774,
-0.5919126868,
0.114850007,
-0.1218033135,
-0.7064234614,
-0.2361638546,
0.2636916339,
-0.2556631267,
-0.2432806641,
0.9931253791,
0.7939875126,
0.1181381568,
-0.2002528459,
0.334794879,
0.0073079118,
0.3048987389,
0.5852769017,
0.8656161427,
-0.3592274189,
0.5326157808,
-0.2790115178,
-0.2418728471,
-0.0440199226,
-0.7273499966,
-0.2776855528,
-0.5511103272,
-0.6521729827,
-0.6949104667,
0.1534486264,
0.6281625628,
0.7296118736,
-0.4893235862,
-0.1243832931,
0.433405906,
-0.3072983921,
-0.0785424113,
-0.2588009238,
0.4936845303,
-0.3696542084,
-0.3935762346,
0.1862872094,
0.6067792177,
-0.2444916964,
-0.0896097794,
-0.0227297693,
0.4616755545,
-0.1487234086,
0.2750260532,
-0.1004303172,
-0.278249532,
-0.1565009952,
-0.013604763,
-0.8252379894,
0.3740845919,
1.0097783804,
-0.6389833093,
0.5607119203,
0.4884254038,
0.3309040368,
0.4250451028,
-0.3833893538,
0.5205338597,
-0.2863977551,
0.1311750263,
0.7353054881,
0.2208262831,
0.4702512026,
-0.4369524717,
0.5343996882,
-0.032538183,
-0.4822417498,
-1.0607231855,
0.2832678258,
-1.0365729332,
0.0384987928,
0.7797614932,
-0.0766393021,
-0.2909246385,
0.1362924427,
0.1891918629,
0.3400733471,
-0.5943384171,
0.5982411504,
0.1906225234,
-0.3831154406,
0.1804340631,
-0.5295590758,
0.5483164787,
0.4228388965,
-0.926199913,
-0.4080341756,
0.5824289918,
0.6067934036,
0.205172345,
1.101246953,
-0.8127992749,
0.7229935527,
0.0575256087,
0.576038897,
-0.2068197727,
-0.0377448127,
-0.1903181076,
0.1982476711,
0.4093017876,
0.1230796278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16842v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16842v1
|
Exploring Factual Entailment with NLI: A News Media Study
| 2024-06-24T17:47:55 | 2024-06-24T17:47:55 |
Guy Mor-Lan, Effi Levi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explore the relationship between factuality and Natural Language Inference
(NLI) by introducing FactRel -- a novel annotation scheme that models
\textit{factual} rather than \textit{textual} entailment, and use it to
annotate a dataset of naturally occurring sentences from news articles. Our
analysis shows that 84\% of factually supporting pairs and 63\% of factually
undermining pairs do not amount to NLI entailment or contradiction,
respectively, suggesting that factual relationships are more apt for analyzing
media discourse. We experiment with models for pairwise classification on the
new dataset, and find that in some cases, generating synthetic data with GPT-4
on the basis of the annotated dataset can improve performance. Surprisingly,
few-shot learning with GPT-4 yields strong results on par with medium LMs
(DeBERTa) trained on the labelled dataset. We hypothesize that these results
indicate the fundamental dependence of this task on both world knowledge and
advanced reasoning abilities.
|
[
-0.4707498848,
-1.1193916798,
0.7609236836,
0.0680736899,
-0.1832626462,
-0.0786274374,
-0.1416017562,
-0.6284224987,
0.20179075,
0.340786159,
-0.4537791312,
-0.4175565541,
-0.5067546964,
0.2215599418,
-0.2609749734,
1.1904019117,
0.1275364459,
-0.1137487292,
-0.4243409932,
-0.3911089003,
-0.3318296671,
-0.353856355,
-0.5329419374,
-0.1902053505,
0.5679892302,
0.3185106218,
0.7222551703,
0.4835020602,
0.6294091344,
0.2772070467,
0.058647804,
0.3265407383,
-0.4778569043,
-0.0149117447,
-0.1586252898,
-0.7196524143,
-0.0607550256,
0.5026813149,
0.5928456783,
0.5808314681,
0.1734055579,
0.3647125363,
-0.216283977,
0.6887912154,
-0.6744448543,
0.0149275735,
-0.6593013406,
0.1364780366,
-0.0841110051,
-0.4933115542,
-0.3299983442,
-0.6218706369,
0.2775602043,
-0.807076335,
0.4831527472,
0.4701623917,
1.1531970501,
0.4249783754,
-0.700245142,
-0.3593911529,
-0.9041785002,
0.7162219286,
-0.7231822014,
0.4675123096,
0.5126289129,
0.2997665405,
0.0395261012,
-0.5548796654,
-0.8328885436,
-0.1948529184,
-0.4546020925,
0.451529175,
-0.1614685953,
-0.0205453653,
0.5271880627,
0.3408293426,
-0.5846898556,
-0.1468891948,
-0.4955080152,
-0.1113023758,
0.6204912066,
-0.1762001365,
0.2976153791,
-0.3538503349,
-0.3384029269,
0.3494107127,
-0.8115980029,
-0.2195990533,
0.4541124105,
0.1135251224,
-0.1656846702,
0.718591392,
-0.1917814165,
0.606456995,
-0.0899282172,
-0.261703223,
0.1846170574,
-0.6365334988,
-0.1810080856,
0.4381347299,
0.6486834884,
0.3098334968,
0.1099199429,
-0.2978058159,
0.0661411136,
0.3784420788,
0.0254360512,
-0.6084254384,
-0.0994046926,
0.1701514572,
-0.2219421118,
-0.3272007108,
0.2592305243,
-0.5423787832,
-0.2866559625,
-0.6904740334,
0.5071889162,
-0.4382452965,
-0.1996997148,
0.1597273499,
-0.2815087438,
0.469640255,
0.1464150697,
-0.5801669955,
0.3475848138,
0.8290379643,
0.9175562859,
0.062160939,
-0.0204969011,
-0.583409071,
0.2524561882,
-0.4586963356,
0.8553932309,
-0.5563024879,
0.0416355729,
-0.0403055474,
-0.2617446482,
-0.1128363088,
-0.3125384748,
1.0997955799,
-0.5199032426,
0.548558414,
-0.3932295442,
-0.7878090143,
-0.493532002,
0.6056831479,
-0.8519338369,
0.9028269649,
-0.3249837458,
-1.2404121161,
0.5043156147,
-0.6824790239,
-0.4932830334,
-0.2279937416,
-0.1960877627,
-0.3882370889,
0.0882641524,
0.2258172631,
0.1234846562,
-0.2577068508,
0.578740418,
-0.2940583229,
-0.4000006616,
0.4515333176,
-0.664963603,
0.5844739676,
0.0563275479,
-0.3346351981,
-0.2322524637,
-0.8802214265,
-0.3243824244,
-0.0896443054,
-0.3892252445,
-0.4356478155,
0.0111783398,
-0.1517365128,
0.138688758,
-0.1463374943,
-0.8116803169,
-0.0229242593,
-0.4029071629,
0.2013190985,
0.1861178577,
0.3337015212,
0.4541215897,
-0.3738025725,
-0.0262000952,
-0.0939495265,
0.0058753351,
0.062800914,
-0.5039928555,
-0.8841276169,
-0.1335746795,
0.6003781557,
0.6705586314,
-0.806769073,
0.2315704674,
-0.2672139704,
-0.1663313508,
-0.5174518228,
-0.0353376791,
0.2340462357,
0.6572751999,
0.27540344,
0.0684887022,
-0.861769557,
-1.0803990364,
-0.3726851642,
-0.1180683374,
0.1269505024,
0.0870103613,
0.5704810023,
-0.0241133291,
1.2362027168,
-0.5526410937,
-0.2537313998,
-0.2266233414,
0.5958153605,
0.3043738306,
0.2838022709,
0.6175913215,
-1.1305968761,
-0.1717257649,
-0.1339185536,
-1.145075202,
-0.0035486771,
-0.3446728587,
-0.1661644578,
0.4174812734,
0.3518509567,
-0.7301195264,
0.6421952248,
0.2551595271,
-0.2229146212,
0.4683068991,
-0.0543530434,
0.3012848198,
-0.7378752232,
0.0365967117,
0.479503423,
-0.1798135787,
-0.6879646778,
-0.0858569443,
-0.2734463513,
0.0429485478,
-0.4163404405,
0.2104968578,
-0.2520570457,
-0.1809749156,
-0.2639796138,
0.2218904942,
0.2547764182,
0.3215603232,
0.2040455639,
0.5062868595,
0.4623093307,
-0.5479889512,
0.2967600226,
0.2660064399,
-0.23547557,
0.48077631,
-0.6186231971,
-0.0422753543,
-0.3537092805,
0.4821364284,
-0.7956444621,
-0.2560818195,
0.2838973403,
-0.426014185,
0.0451155081,
-0.2118738592,
-0.6483829618,
-0.0817296728,
-0.2246249169,
0.0914152563,
0.271412164,
-0.4680653512,
0.5958895683,
0.1746185571,
0.0784228817,
-0.4056348801,
-0.8037526011,
0.1637225151,
-0.449593097,
-0.4835087657,
0.2271530181,
0.1311783195,
-0.5693772435,
0.1855044216,
-0.2105747759,
-0.2274093628,
-0.1290924102,
0.1260683537,
0.3011025488,
-0.513364315,
0.2624451518,
-0.0789959133,
0.0011158471,
0.2402784526,
0.026743345,
-0.0058379588,
-0.2914772332,
-0.3259554803,
-0.5047730207,
0.2543642223,
0.1755830497,
-0.3096340597,
0.7775985003,
0.8076635003,
-0.3612156808,
0.1289533377,
-0.7119011879,
-0.3132089972,
-0.37870875,
0.0104685137,
-0.1862573922,
-0.6270935535,
0.268617928,
0.0163283553,
0.1168224737,
0.3056560159,
0.0061184452,
-0.1381105036,
0.7282579541,
0.4160992801,
0.0249308702,
0.070069477,
-0.4651881456,
0.2856456637,
-0.4265934229,
-0.0641825721,
-0.1471578479,
-0.383667618,
-0.7993897796,
-0.2321622074,
0.34360677,
-0.1195414513,
-0.1713754833,
0.0390802473,
-0.0478433706,
0.8032883406,
0.6569305658,
0.1700731367,
0.5775113702,
-0.208530724,
0.3866565228,
-0.1212685108,
-0.7403445244,
-0.4003386796,
0.9653757215,
0.2835849822,
0.5496587157,
0.3937752545,
0.6532241106,
0.1487743855,
0.343746841,
-0.7487934828,
0.4382075369,
-0.0608464256,
-0.8423469663,
-0.1158453226,
-0.4797353446,
-0.5477968454,
0.2127691358,
-0.6523225307,
-0.3209591508,
0.2213656902,
0.0495461337,
-0.3517138362,
0.2224173099,
-0.7213917375,
0.4837088287,
-0.2770490348,
-0.5817322731,
-0.1914371699,
-0.768324554,
0.8065672517,
-0.0502275229,
0.3078770638,
-0.1656344682,
0.118358165,
0.663875401,
0.1318062991,
1.0263990164,
-0.0570255369,
0.0083115352,
0.5817317963,
-0.1051405445,
0.1941446811,
0.4765128195,
-0.1126367822,
-0.0302738268,
-0.2187892199,
-0.3006293774,
-1.0878874063,
0.6063950062,
-0.5012094378,
-0.7281175852,
-0.6586706638,
-0.5429312587,
-0.2204141021,
0.0853950605,
0.1135907471,
0.8151679635,
-0.2770400941,
0.2578821778,
0.804587543,
0.040687684,
0.3962819874,
0.5736631751,
-0.0145794665,
-0.1884128004,
0.9926565289,
0.1914970279,
0.1421120316,
0.3949994147,
0.4417182505,
-0.5106270313,
-0.3762522042,
-0.3289373517,
0.4533454478,
-0.7654854059,
-0.0541120172,
-0.5413272381,
-0.263861686,
-0.2000567615,
0.0897974744,
-0.1695815325,
-0.5576406717,
0.0162039008,
-0.4193649292,
0.4136380851,
0.7692912221,
-0.1294294149,
0.0304895379,
-0.6588226557,
0.4708113372,
0.3443148136,
0.0783933029,
-0.5303940177,
-0.4404189289,
-0.0955623314,
0.1999090165,
-0.4255276024,
-0.8617645502,
0.0649207309,
0.500960052,
0.5141501427,
0.4031555057,
0.359988004,
0.5237110853,
-0.5249942541,
0.5625025034,
-0.0884118006,
-0.7141728401,
0.5936111212,
-0.3987415433,
-0.0470928177,
0.6338955164,
0.8097583652,
-0.2531128824,
-0.557280302,
-0.7875153422,
-0.370080173,
0.3243164122,
0.4128859043,
0.0011871519,
-0.0298035145,
0.3224548995,
0.0724340677,
0.1846448481,
-0.6622398496,
-0.2296055406,
-0.3155607581,
-0.2803168893,
0.0612147786,
-0.1844478101,
-0.4741938114,
-0.4675014317,
0.6318680644,
-0.2487750649,
0.2925672233,
0.4318066835,
-0.1213692948,
0.1820562333,
0.3481346667,
0.6370255947,
0.752820015,
-0.3561185002,
0.481475234,
0.2896767557,
-0.2093648016,
0.0524432212,
0.2181126177,
-0.2626668513,
0.2416465133,
0.5451835394,
0.9093665481,
0.3864009678,
-0.3423452675,
0.5990499854,
0.0526336096,
-0.3782785833,
-0.3153669834,
-0.0685953647,
0.1039249077,
0.1030209512,
0.365386039,
0.1365003884,
0.5768796206,
-0.8530536294,
0.3589273989,
0.2729623914,
-0.3314626217,
-0.5070821643,
0.4497778416,
0.2180553228,
0.1842031628,
0.4168475568,
-0.3550306261,
-0.5070801377,
0.486469835,
0.7005831003,
0.4704188406,
0.3763202429,
0.4625049531,
0.4661618173,
0.3016198575,
-0.1225124821,
0.087315321,
0.2067429274,
-0.8623949289,
-0.8225072026,
-0.3896337152,
-0.4577305019,
0.1117020473,
-0.5729104877,
0.3241733015,
-0.2749345899,
0.0424575396,
0.3297085166,
-0.0439496264,
-0.5900840163,
0.3468291163,
0.2185945064,
0.7525225878,
-1.2198309898,
0.6352572441,
0.6949689984,
-0.6271443367,
-0.6391580105,
0.3374383152,
0.1899816692,
-0.3198227882,
0.7886595726,
0.2888795137,
-0.0260958411,
0.0515468419,
-0.6767775416,
-0.7935428619,
0.9107663631,
0.4049708843,
-0.1733768582,
0.0748058632,
0.2489786297,
0.4457903802,
-0.2404063195,
0.2435655743,
0.7845384479,
0.5935797095,
0.2349998206,
-0.500585258,
0.0380863026,
-0.1040138304,
-0.386222899,
0.1334715337,
-0.5879847407,
0.4192069471,
-0.333370477,
-0.4366123378,
-0.4794343114,
0.9537060261,
0.245376572,
0.7490273118,
0.446036309,
0.6971729994,
0.6398991942,
-0.1380643249,
0.9297730923,
-0.006851384,
0.2241220027,
1.060281992,
-0.2811941803,
0.7451916337,
0.376647234,
-0.0865906104,
0.594181776,
0.4768050909,
0.0218976475,
0.3088810742,
-0.1049825773,
-0.4431379139,
-0.2626900077,
-0.3239320219,
-0.0724976882,
0.7430633307,
0.346057266,
0.0338847935,
-0.2914700508,
-0.0294617433,
0.158394739,
0.3007913232,
-0.048317302,
0.7814278007,
0.0555661172,
-0.6623309851,
0.4312002957,
-0.2306380421,
0.7475269437,
-0.4425466657,
-0.1626765728,
-0.1787078083,
-0.2453021407,
-0.3986356854,
-0.8055173159,
0.6893825531,
-0.0748803541,
-0.1711714268,
0.295555234,
0.8170638084,
-0.5756618381,
-0.5866552591,
-0.2170923352,
0.5461013317,
0.0368233956,
0.1372638643,
-0.4850384891,
-0.0341705307,
-0.1638648212,
-0.2290902734,
0.0625663698,
0.5590360165,
0.0518199615,
0.4582149684,
0.7506887913,
-0.0064432221,
-0.0388587713,
0.0474856235,
0.6914426088,
-0.5033923388,
-0.2743840516,
-0.8847215772,
0.2975015342,
-0.4206599593,
-0.2413423955,
0.9246813059,
0.8424643874,
0.5391686559,
0.0749536455,
0.9396319389,
-0.0693209767,
0.4986840189,
-0.8420509696,
0.4515994489,
-0.2041271776,
-0.0427861959,
0.0623132028,
-0.943985343,
-0.5402956009,
0.3643467426,
-0.63437289,
-0.3593101203,
0.8932383657,
0.7261481881,
-0.2750335634,
0.5400001407,
0.1215407476,
-0.0120733799,
0.2287605256,
0.2473922223,
0.9019260406,
-0.3595166802,
0.3832266629,
-0.3680956662,
-0.1000206992,
0.0869412124,
-0.9755880833,
-0.8723982573,
-0.3625790179,
-0.570128262,
-0.1294656396,
0.2833543718,
0.7540101409,
0.4783373773,
-0.7041251063,
0.1621691287,
-0.2728103101,
0.0964571908,
-0.0717306286,
-0.2649045587,
0.3503026068,
-0.442783922,
-0.6513232589,
0.4907808602,
-0.0513759553,
0.1126724929,
-0.1180988774,
0.095779106,
-0.6180747747,
0.2387606353,
0.5114397407,
0.2418618202,
-0.6690917015,
-0.6218655705,
-0.12742275,
0.1922541857,
0.0016499893,
0.8342529535,
-0.7827208042,
0.2315885425,
0.4444252253,
0.7588397861,
0.3448173106,
0.343603909,
0.5102664232,
-1.0651218891,
0.3460540175,
0.0528242998,
0.1978143454,
0.5623174906,
-0.3393939435,
0.790379107,
0.5169577599,
-0.5406155586,
-0.7860680819,
0.347235173,
-0.8778412342,
-0.0929058716,
1.287565589,
0.0816217884,
-0.3038482368,
-0.3132490516,
-0.1966597885,
0.3443439007,
-0.1796609312,
0.5703625083,
0.5020871758,
-0.1970783621,
-0.2034551501,
-1.0622293949,
0.6082901955,
0.1887085587,
-0.8210858703,
-0.2869009972,
0.4580905437,
0.2239602059,
0.3704473376,
0.3356536329,
0.2673391998,
0.1444205344,
0.076871261,
-0.1791723818,
-0.043987643,
-0.2883703411,
0.1022882015,
-0.1208198518,
-0.1548104733,
-0.2651486397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16838v1
|
From Decoding to Meta-Generation: Inference-time Algorithms for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-24T17:45:59 | 2024-06-24T17:45:59 |
Sean Welleck, Amanda Bertsch, Matthew Finlayson, Hailey Schoelkopf, Alex Xie, Graham Neubig, Ilia Kulikov, Zaid Harchaoui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
One of the most striking findings in modern research on large language models
(LLMs) is that scaling up compute during training leads to better results.
However, less attention has been given to the benefits of scaling compute
during inference. This survey focuses on these inference-time approaches. We
explore three areas under a unified mathematical formalism: token-level
generation algorithms, meta-generation algorithms, and efficient generation.
Token-level generation algorithms, often called decoding algorithms, operate by
sampling a single token at a time or constructing a token-level search space
and then selecting an output. These methods typically assume access to a
language model's logits, next-token distributions, or probability scores.
Meta-generation algorithms work on partial or full sequences, incorporating
domain knowledge, enabling backtracking, and integrating external information.
Efficient generation methods aim to reduce token costs and improve the speed of
generation. Our survey unifies perspectives from three research communities:
traditional natural language processing, modern LLMs, and machine learning
systems.
|
[
-0.2993516922,
-0.758898735,
0.6225365996,
0.3947195709,
-0.0821097121,
0.0190147702,
-0.2743254602,
-0.4391301572,
0.135245651,
0.4234269261,
-0.5693733096,
-0.123163037,
-0.5451883674,
0.1762584299,
-0.4494004846,
0.6732481122,
0.2705023587,
0.1883776784,
-0.0623783767,
0.1203757972,
-0.2875401378,
-0.5967976451,
-0.8968764544,
-0.2548339963,
0.2892805338,
0.2267498672,
0.4978292286,
0.9195615649,
0.2677927613,
0.276930362,
-0.1243028566,
0.1650973856,
-0.2578422725,
0.128066361,
-0.195703879,
-0.6305593252,
-0.3875196874,
-0.2232772261,
0.9104575515,
0.9738734961,
-0.1339969486,
0.5615350604,
-0.0832441375,
0.5277347565,
-1.1199994087,
0.1579177082,
-0.7273802757,
0.05602438,
-0.3660393655,
-0.2922047675,
-0.7323057055,
-0.2929518521,
-0.1322084665,
-0.3151049316,
0.4764477909,
0.0941410512,
0.2508322001,
0.063312389,
-0.6309403181,
-0.391628921,
-0.8570614457,
1.3133779764,
-0.9046926498,
0.2482258976,
0.1897051185,
0.2181951106,
-0.1869426221,
-1.007474184,
-0.4137811065,
0.1206920967,
-0.1713681966,
-0.20347628,
-0.2789872289,
0.3133364022,
0.4500754178,
0.4226063192,
-0.1703183502,
0.2179441005,
-0.0388974063,
-0.2095975578,
0.5251732469,
0.2517296076,
0.2186181992,
-0.3548255861,
0.2460517883,
-0.0674562678,
-0.868573308,
-0.2717038095,
0.2100836635,
0.2107437402,
0.3458124995,
0.5299876332,
-0.0350492522,
0.8363258243,
-0.0007787164,
-0.137791127,
-0.0711060017,
-0.7026286125,
-0.2451292723,
-0.1196260676,
0.7805255055,
0.0135674365,
0.1337065846,
-0.2277161926,
-0.0898493826,
0.0283190515,
-0.1071393043,
-0.8605175614,
0.1422079057,
0.13934654,
-0.5792934895,
-0.2829603553,
0.039265465,
-0.9560291767,
-0.1464720666,
-0.2690117657,
0.022136407,
-0.112902157,
-0.4009171128,
0.112722151,
-0.1238849089,
0.3351758122,
0.0490855984,
-1.2124761343,
0.5084041357,
0.8692082763,
0.8075580597,
0.0812566355,
-0.1053071246,
-0.9130217433,
0.2051393539,
-0.5727975368,
0.4441749752,
-0.4972514212,
-0.1507081687,
0.2172387987,
-0.2635448873,
-0.1285631955,
-0.3069889545,
0.5738219619,
-0.7012062669,
0.2089045793,
-0.2673918009,
-0.6251226068,
0.1020716876,
-0.0667276531,
-0.7463899851,
1.0298658609,
-0.1626762748,
-0.9704420567,
0.395150125,
-0.860915184,
-0.6770495772,
-0.108224012,
0.0116391834,
-0.1994160563,
0.6077128053,
0.5125857592,
0.5492127538,
-0.5762858391,
0.1854085177,
-0.1278007925,
-0.1237110049,
0.1841545403,
-0.5674318671,
0.8508550525,
0.6154737473,
-0.5154367685,
-0.179079324,
-0.8133612871,
0.2202718705,
0.2282451093,
-0.3782083988,
-0.1940969229,
0.4892641306,
-0.2095845491,
-0.0846649036,
0.1386204064,
-0.5602450371,
0.1589215398,
-0.4578156471,
0.9759525061,
0.5920240283,
0.0423994176,
0.626899004,
0.1043250933,
0.4057638347,
-0.1580086499,
-0.002600743,
-0.6008640528,
-0.1618148834,
-0.7069663405,
-0.2684419453,
0.5798147321,
0.3005260825,
-0.6656165123,
0.3233931959,
-0.4474153221,
-0.1337647885,
-0.4747447073,
0.0305732787,
0.3145938814,
0.1832266748,
0.2638407946,
0.186001122,
-0.5538124442,
-0.6610673666,
-0.5270824432,
-0.1131287888,
-0.1990966499,
0.3252705336,
0.2313778847,
-0.2277717292,
0.8781418204,
-0.5486729741,
0.4451247752,
-0.3757231832,
0.2481721342,
0.157454446,
0.3119605184,
0.5172386765,
-0.6390286088,
-0.2687276602,
-0.1654026061,
-0.4918921292,
-0.1919150501,
0.0225888416,
0.1277509928,
0.4147979319,
0.7608522773,
-0.5403551459,
0.2461796254,
0.6238396168,
-0.1730652004,
0.4334748983,
-0.2027857006,
0.1046874002,
-1.1523995399,
-0.0092509631,
-0.4582605362,
-0.3781933784,
-0.8184276819,
0.3276323676,
-0.023459658,
0.0791652575,
-0.1639058441,
0.6205224991,
-0.9016494155,
-0.4848146737,
-0.2581605017,
0.0976103693,
-0.1292088479,
0.2371235043,
0.0160279982,
0.5493900776,
0.5130221844,
-0.7110793591,
0.1308895051,
-0.3494647741,
-0.2900691032,
0.1086207554,
-0.4660640955,
0.2468843609,
-0.0411335453,
0.371845603,
-0.9879042506,
-0.2868510783,
-0.1175244823,
-0.3160862923,
0.2243858427,
-0.1333864629,
-0.9041685462,
-0.4637009501,
-0.2307330966,
0.8532486558,
0.5366200209,
-0.7037317157,
0.714379549,
0.1904401183,
0.0427616425,
-0.7812693119,
-0.8187137842,
0.1692642868,
-0.1191957146,
-0.5223306417,
0.0973558873,
0.1206364185,
-0.5262352228,
0.0646327585,
0.1069975868,
0.0596828908,
0.1906939298,
-0.1133796275,
-0.1397156119,
-0.3233384192,
0.1237087101,
0.1111648306,
-0.0770671591,
0.0779279843,
-0.6645414829,
0.7340765595,
-0.012671777,
-0.4383055568,
-0.1620097011,
0.3639058173,
0.5584573746,
-0.3259196281,
0.8607612252,
0.5501185656,
-0.2628623843,
-0.3488248885,
-0.639498651,
-0.1569437981,
-0.4228284061,
0.1556359529,
-0.3770076632,
-0.7614371777,
0.4975250661,
-0.2302566022,
0.5405544043,
0.8205432892,
0.7952415347,
0.1074073538,
1.1435936689,
0.55179286,
-0.1168627888,
0.7596655488,
-0.223371461,
0.1504205465,
-0.6125198007,
0.1646909565,
-0.7154781818,
-0.2317449898,
-0.4554522038,
-0.669705689,
0.1001133844,
0.0998115391,
-0.1732417643,
0.1214747205,
-0.2083549649,
0.515234828,
0.6685727835,
-0.3309720755,
0.4587409198,
0.2273527831,
-0.1148972958,
0.1951905042,
-0.9427707195,
-0.1718672514,
1.3378256559,
0.2736847699,
0.6556432247,
0.1103402749,
0.6979415417,
0.3035951555,
0.2973398864,
-0.6147025228,
0.4590792954,
-0.1474773139,
-0.737306416,
-0.5502299666,
-0.799554646,
-1.0228402615,
0.2715159953,
-0.1559432894,
-0.4918423891,
-0.0133240521,
0.2833471,
-0.0244797375,
0.6593997478,
-0.6408173442,
0.4251516461,
-0.0690127313,
-0.2285969704,
-0.4985119104,
-0.651481986,
0.5861570239,
-0.141392976,
0.4309284687,
0.2840691507,
-0.10060817,
0.5745139718,
-0.5066619515,
0.7014129758,
-0.1606951803,
-0.1396891624,
0.4993955493,
0.1637038887,
0.6368655562,
-0.0182187296,
-0.1848089844,
0.1094184071,
0.1688770652,
-0.5702161193,
-0.5633063316,
0.3262063861,
-0.4534366727,
-0.3047527671,
-0.0941125751,
-0.5091166496,
-0.2189405262,
0.2905099094,
0.5541598797,
0.6032304764,
-0.2797451317,
0.1590085477,
0.677013576,
-0.2215718776,
0.6852821112,
0.2899998128,
-0.2714578807,
-0.4096950591,
0.8799189925,
0.1415549219,
0.5241841078,
0.7658712268,
0.2593069375,
-0.3254679739,
-0.5340528488,
-0.4150920808,
0.3748874366,
-0.4965150058,
-0.1079297438,
-0.5379610658,
-0.151129961,
-0.68447119,
-0.0378716178,
-0.3983980417,
-0.6254953146,
-0.3118082881,
-0.2470793128,
0.0170542244,
0.7339432836,
-0.2926287353,
0.4636690021,
-0.7929691076,
0.3517506123,
0.2539501786,
-0.001826703,
0.2947615087,
-0.1780306697,
-0.3123470545,
0.0132984007,
-0.0344883949,
-0.6230375767,
-0.0701054558,
0.2382382601,
0.5061794519,
0.5564103723,
-0.1929740906,
0.5185776353,
-0.6685400605,
0.8895491362,
0.2566671371,
-1.1310060024,
0.2703915536,
-0.2291479558,
0.1909922659,
0.2139813751,
0.0028784983,
-0.6436796188,
-0.1651240885,
-0.6810724139,
-0.6263795495,
0.4839030206,
0.1542181522,
0.2548928559,
-0.1881088465,
0.5190806985,
-0.0342854187,
0.2131012976,
-0.6443942189,
-0.2266755998,
-0.0569796823,
-0.3046251535,
-0.353820771,
-0.4141020775,
-0.1051464155,
0.0158982296,
0.2027768344,
-0.3880500495,
0.3128957748,
-0.1083509699,
-0.312433362,
-0.0908052027,
0.4940463305,
0.5973264575,
0.8304713964,
0.1108250692,
0.2938546836,
0.2459854633,
-0.2602803707,
0.1946079731,
-0.1547163427,
-0.171790272,
-0.0134638874,
0.9417757392,
0.8700770736,
0.1999705434,
-0.5145820975,
0.5137248635,
-0.1084337384,
-0.4143738151,
-0.0582809635,
0.0120564289,
0.1097012609,
0.1492561996,
0.4310064316,
-0.3062869906,
0.1992878914,
-0.6566048265,
0.0314961672,
0.6410081387,
0.1192072183,
-0.5112358332,
0.6058281064,
0.083767727,
-0.2095702887,
0.6542204618,
0.0703524649,
-0.2121951431,
0.4640230536,
0.7408215404,
1.0616184473,
-0.1012446433,
0.1185879409,
0.3943282068,
0.217881918,
-0.269549638,
0.1109728739,
-0.3829320073,
-0.561188221,
-0.8887465596,
-0.8529601693,
-0.17387335,
-0.0465357788,
-0.6968694329,
-0.0816190392,
-0.4175130427,
-0.2401780337,
-0.1314025074,
0.0144287208,
-0.6826556325,
-0.0606762879,
0.139283821,
1.1477944851,
-0.7875455022,
0.3659631908,
0.4116366208,
0.1163033545,
-0.760409236,
0.0233083591,
-0.2145842612,
-0.6950876117,
0.5794761777,
-0.2806177735,
-0.2776506245,
0.1925736219,
-0.6225324869,
-0.8350825906,
0.9948043227,
0.5471966267,
-0.450610429,
-0.4696290791,
0.1888558865,
0.5426861048,
-0.3640863299,
0.2381875664,
0.9926241636,
0.366756022,
0.0956196114,
-0.6073876619,
-0.0174534507,
0.2178393751,
0.0570455156,
0.548417449,
-0.5791104436,
0.8732640147,
-0.1974059492,
-0.4333817661,
0.1399027258,
0.8183125257,
0.2258183807,
0.1330512911,
0.605512917,
0.6275069714,
0.8106569648,
0.0174095463,
1.1237508059,
-0.3397603035,
0.3815050423,
0.8352339268,
0.0911022499,
0.6418409348,
0.4479241669,
-0.333927989,
0.5331554413,
0.7000524998,
0.1933990717,
0.2377833128,
0.3442739546,
-0.3124430776,
-0.1780489832,
0.1873988211,
-0.222511813,
0.1439510584,
0.3890449107,
-0.45357427,
-0.4027329087,
-0.1111073568,
0.042444136,
-0.3827528954,
-0.484985441,
0.9293203354,
0.0893032998,
-0.8005019426,
0.2661741674,
0.2532119155,
0.4040468335,
-0.6287769079,
0.0363796577,
-0.3211128712,
0.1463457346,
-0.1836624891,
-0.4697272182,
0.0094753429,
0.1089124456,
-0.3583967984,
-0.2166237086,
0.5848636031,
-0.2082951814,
-0.7079697847,
0.2129883319,
0.5313310623,
0.2458992004,
0.0876315832,
-0.3596785963,
-0.0770040601,
-0.1671230495,
-0.4218552113,
0.1128175184,
0.6325518489,
-0.1261317432,
0.6021091938,
0.6583346128,
0.3011898696,
0.6660904288,
0.1664259285,
0.6060410738,
-0.7095537186,
-0.3450849056,
-1.1171627045,
0.1918323338,
0.2199965417,
0.0351560041,
0.7679283619,
0.4133320749,
0.6195524931,
0.0611385554,
0.7404434681,
-0.119939819,
0.4088376164,
-0.8026940227,
0.161314711,
-0.5235925913,
0.0208866578,
-0.3577836752,
-0.9779004455,
-0.3522231877,
0.0641164556,
-0.2010975033,
0.0987918451,
0.6213380098,
0.4623096287,
-0.0490742512,
-0.2378489524,
0.1340825558,
0.0735912994,
0.6223578453,
0.4128066301,
0.7439863682,
-0.253672272,
0.550327003,
0.1503165662,
-0.2732371986,
-0.3196828365,
-1.0321621895,
-0.7657808661,
-0.3812687099,
0.1431407481,
-0.202519089,
-0.3638440669,
0.6749497056,
0.7838032842,
-0.6904948354,
-0.3292603493,
-0.4041158855,
0.308175534,
-0.4283679128,
-0.2095006257,
0.5022115707,
-0.7963356972,
-1.0107218027,
0.3273271322,
0.0192290358,
-0.2637855113,
-0.5254443884,
-0.0216127168,
0.0278022401,
0.4589240253,
0.8325971961,
0.4329165816,
-0.5959962606,
0.0048380229,
0.122878857,
-0.0831741467,
-0.148734495,
1.4266120195,
-0.4823056757,
0.2715231776,
0.8086571097,
0.9190187454,
0.7879242897,
0.1737832129,
0.8027752042,
-0.663351953,
-0.0266240146,
0.0295629408,
0.421774894,
0.1101324782,
-0.1917167157,
0.5537040234,
0.3360015452,
-0.5197650194,
-1.1050583124,
0.5109679103,
-0.4140839875,
-0.4625963867,
1.0366102457,
0.1744780988,
-0.3927199244,
0.2227776349,
0.1762506813,
0.1891044378,
0.0837020352,
0.2860190272,
0.8753788471,
-0.2118451297,
-0.0492554717,
-0.5872215033,
0.503105104,
0.4340951741,
-0.7215109468,
0.4419763386,
0.5484276414,
0.3911567926,
0.2841846645,
0.755888164,
-0.1642706543,
0.0577801503,
0.1573630869,
-0.0180837549,
0.0586144291,
-0.4752783179,
-0.4566492438,
0.2754201889,
0.0708706453,
-0.0263724979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16833v1
|
USDC: A Dataset of $\underline{U}$ser $\underline{S}$tance and $\underline{D}$ogmatism in Long $\underline{C}$onversations
| 2024-06-24T17:41:53 | 2024-06-24T17:41:53 |
Mounika Marreddy, Subba Reddy Oota, Venkata Charan Chinni, Manish Gupta, Lucie Flek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Identifying user's opinions and stances in long conversation threads on
various topics can be extremely critical for enhanced personalization, market
research, political campaigns, customer service, conflict resolution, targeted
advertising, and content moderation. Hence, training language models to
automate this task is critical. However, to train such models, gathering manual
annotations has multiple challenges: 1) It is time-consuming and costly; 2)
Conversation threads could be very long, increasing chances of noisy
annotations; and 3) Interpreting instances where a user changes their opinion
within a conversation is difficult because often such transitions are subtle
and not expressed explicitly. Inspired by the recent success of large language
models (LLMs) for complex natural language processing (NLP) tasks, we leverage
Mistral Large and GPT-4 to automate the human annotation process on the
following two tasks while also providing reasoning: i) User Stance
classification, which involves labeling a user's stance of a post in a
conversation on a five-point scale; ii) User Dogmatism classification, which
deals with labeling a user's overall opinion in the conversation on a
four-point scale. The majority voting on zero-shot, one-shot, and few-shot
annotations from these two LLMs on 764 multi-user Reddit conversations helps us
curate the USDC dataset. USDC is then used to finetune and instruction-tune
multiple deployable small language models for the 5-class stance and 4-class
dogmatism classification tasks. We make the code and dataset publicly available
[https://anonymous.4open.science/r/USDC-0F7F].
|
[
-0.664665401,
-0.6826114655,
0.6687437892,
0.1015931293,
-0.1797625721,
-0.0982235074,
-0.4555013478,
-0.5564361811,
-0.1982134134,
0.5407211781,
-0.4206049442,
-0.7104927897,
-0.5768114924,
0.3794558644,
-0.115813069,
1.317511797,
-0.1030241773,
-0.1447520107,
-0.0561063848,
-0.3895583749,
-0.06881468,
-0.6942981482,
-0.7360986471,
-0.3983361721,
0.6919353008,
0.4304103851,
0.7665509582,
0.4642401934,
0.2069880217,
0.349427253,
0.0547939576,
0.0535372682,
-0.2558522522,
0.0838622153,
-0.2932668626,
-0.4343267381,
-0.4397120178,
0.5520957112,
0.3589145243,
0.573266983,
-0.1294647455,
0.3040463924,
-0.112314418,
0.3111329675,
-0.2840904593,
0.437194705,
-0.5786429048,
-0.1712014973,
-0.1876938939,
0.2090287358,
-0.2703291476,
-0.2287956476,
0.100318931,
-0.4207116961,
0.2013483793,
-0.0472509786,
0.9780573249,
0.2139091045,
-0.4022611678,
-0.2117570043,
-0.5268196464,
0.9629526734,
-0.7620260715,
0.2460063398,
0.8170140982,
0.194245249,
-0.0418889932,
-0.625487566,
-0.7579618692,
-0.3995373249,
-0.1440133005,
-0.0412042625,
0.0258581005,
0.1442930996,
0.5422433615,
0.307418704,
-0.1289644241,
0.3189045489,
-0.0260080546,
-0.1339393556,
0.7910172939,
0.1524399668,
0.0477200001,
-0.4132326841,
-0.348811537,
0.0183951873,
-0.4180249572,
0.2385897934,
0.4757906199,
0.2618155181,
-0.1753362119,
0.4927535355,
-0.4079070687,
0.6439765692,
0.2068895549,
-0.1202752367,
0.2148267478,
-0.362077564,
-0.1768023372,
-0.3521859348,
1.0441799164,
0.1534034312,
0.1936391294,
0.0034313505,
-0.1632407457,
0.1480693668,
0.2587396502,
-0.7680969238,
-0.1117873266,
0.1174075231,
-0.1603474319,
-0.4634065926,
0.2452051044,
-0.7757816315,
-0.4865231216,
-0.860386014,
0.0782793388,
0.0231086835,
-0.0546053313,
0.0347801335,
0.1357603818,
0.2282943577,
0.5106913447,
-1.032523632,
0.3673359156,
0.7247716188,
0.6602750421,
0.0186905768,
-0.0871975496,
-0.2326056659,
-0.1440109909,
-0.1297457665,
0.8574732542,
-0.6860044599,
-0.1925544739,
-0.0775258839,
0.265122354,
-0.0260642599,
-0.1617570668,
0.5622379184,
-0.407215476,
0.3202310801,
-0.4107064009,
-0.4731422961,
-0.162879765,
0.45679757,
-0.4921449423,
1.061288476,
0.2236422002,
-0.9372392893,
0.2740043402,
-0.7666279674,
-0.324665159,
-0.103092216,
-0.4276207685,
-0.3852841258,
-0.0403251797,
0.4282323122,
0.7523659468,
-0.5135564208,
0.2809575796,
-0.467025578,
-0.0868494883,
0.4753220975,
-0.1912715435,
0.6872615218,
0.2305299044,
-0.7041355371,
0.0788832083,
-0.7561913133,
-0.0442121029,
0.100177221,
-0.4850243032,
-0.3813194335,
-0.1219281405,
0.0216246061,
0.3689586818,
0.1327092499,
-0.5179843903,
0.4152145684,
-0.4044283032,
0.5464064479,
0.9607453346,
0.0155215384,
0.2916318476,
0.0227760915,
0.3588453233,
-0.0107781142,
0.1021864638,
-0.1420927346,
-0.4901752174,
-0.8901026845,
-0.1875412464,
0.3680332601,
0.5162069798,
-0.5394896865,
0.5724202991,
-0.2171861827,
-0.4456983507,
-0.5800529718,
0.2466395646,
0.3439105153,
0.3634063601,
0.3167963028,
-0.2320453674,
-0.4163216352,
-0.8586810827,
-0.0887589082,
-0.2400263548,
-0.1638174802,
0.3209572434,
0.4993555546,
-0.5227746367,
0.9550810456,
-0.346016109,
-0.3593097329,
-0.1587808281,
0.7506069541,
-0.1043329313,
0.2064262629,
0.3448446691,
-0.5453489423,
-0.423199445,
0.2004234344,
-0.6786273718,
-0.2748041451,
-0.3490846753,
-0.150171265,
0.4826344252,
0.5644065142,
-0.6101248264,
0.4897386432,
0.4817718863,
-0.2101054788,
0.3442622721,
-0.0237908531,
0.2988665104,
-1.1570055485,
0.1508522928,
0.3444020748,
-0.2568230927,
-0.354131192,
-0.1606884897,
-0.2457144707,
-0.019035764,
-0.1211014837,
0.515275836,
-0.4537833929,
0.1736434698,
-0.2491523772,
0.1812729388,
-0.2222144306,
0.7068779469,
0.0448078066,
0.6614200473,
0.2372934222,
-0.3043958545,
0.4749582112,
0.2409299463,
-0.0994367525,
0.6514801979,
-0.4810522199,
0.4035986364,
-0.0729296431,
0.3603186607,
-0.8000908494,
-0.3754696548,
0.4261735976,
-0.2980059981,
0.2130342573,
-0.249484539,
-0.6747869253,
-0.297647804,
-0.2500415444,
0.0665344819,
0.3169125617,
-0.4523093104,
0.515527904,
0.668307662,
-0.1459834427,
-0.4576771855,
-0.4104407132,
0.2835589051,
-0.0259212963,
-0.2654650807,
-0.0943132415,
0.1170547456,
-0.2779462934,
-0.1686252654,
0.0904825106,
0.1867758185,
0.0101570273,
0.5616110563,
0.0354403518,
-0.0000555563,
0.2497632056,
-0.1284547448,
-0.3916538954,
0.1103953868,
-0.252378583,
0.4269036055,
-0.4956687391,
-0.4068789184,
-0.676717937,
0.3141176105,
0.5363806486,
-0.1023852155,
0.4764444828,
0.7267868519,
-0.286529243,
-0.1911203265,
-0.8137947917,
-0.1323993951,
-0.4267463088,
0.2842506468,
-0.263094753,
-0.8498148918,
0.3664922416,
-0.110127762,
0.3690976202,
0.5345463753,
0.7078132033,
-0.2117745131,
1.2506498098,
0.5455771089,
-0.6018573046,
0.4311250448,
-0.2551147342,
0.0350351147,
-0.4536288977,
0.0571659505,
-0.6682761312,
-0.3689390719,
-0.478769958,
-0.4946745038,
-0.051430244,
-0.2552663088,
-0.2856989801,
0.2526103556,
-0.3875295222,
0.3760514259,
0.5064482093,
-0.087652564,
0.2225156873,
0.179503724,
-0.0176000036,
-0.2316579968,
-0.2890658677,
-0.6814039946,
1.0590803623,
0.4397269785,
0.8579819798,
-0.2854151428,
0.5480183959,
0.3340038657,
0.5853295922,
-0.8147665858,
0.7070832253,
0.0314737745,
-0.4996883869,
-0.2661892176,
-0.4905168116,
-0.7963144183,
-0.0257954672,
-0.2640386522,
-0.6222736835,
-0.0816915482,
0.1567556858,
-0.2967987955,
0.353091687,
-0.4666604698,
0.9872436523,
-0.2430894971,
-0.0817536116,
-0.1684843153,
-0.9129483104,
0.1410205662,
-0.0644883364,
0.2393857837,
-0.2117010951,
-0.0334271081,
0.6306370497,
-0.3863962591,
1.2781367302,
-0.2383333296,
-0.0444948263,
0.3434077203,
-0.283577919,
0.585036397,
0.1588186175,
0.1216823608,
0.4254361391,
-0.2685859501,
-0.1860179156,
-0.5047214031,
0.5650345087,
-0.9764980078,
-0.5434613228,
-0.6448836327,
-0.2155293375,
-0.2459755838,
0.0031500091,
0.068419829,
0.2833906114,
-0.1743079722,
0.1111170873,
0.4554833174,
0.1313491166,
0.2306113839,
0.2455753684,
-0.0623007715,
-0.4892181754,
0.6317578554,
0.0123027461,
0.1812609732,
0.0592186525,
0.2170434743,
-0.2899745703,
-0.3692443073,
-0.5192988515,
0.4470784962,
-0.7822040319,
-0.1923775971,
-0.8290680647,
-0.1591425687,
-0.2908111215,
-0.1222065836,
-0.3095084131,
-0.4056586325,
-0.4605195224,
-0.2310884148,
0.4360912144,
0.7119781375,
0.0884199515,
0.4010035694,
-0.6416081786,
0.3811691105,
0.5479918718,
0.2636290193,
-0.3290677071,
-0.4995365143,
-0.2454364002,
0.2255594432,
-0.3305985034,
-0.718357265,
0.0169363618,
0.2207669616,
0.5037155747,
0.584764719,
0.1278464943,
0.759221375,
-0.3228678107,
0.7634118795,
0.1326484531,
-0.9137037396,
0.5345489979,
-0.3565183878,
0.2160314471,
0.8560988903,
0.5838933587,
-0.8061760664,
-0.6696825027,
-0.6830275655,
-0.7403534651,
0.8984761238,
0.1422262937,
0.1212170795,
-0.0943465531,
0.4591688514,
0.1369214058,
0.2318589091,
-0.8207060695,
-0.1085558534,
-0.19843629,
-0.4860573411,
-0.123200573,
-0.249297604,
-0.3591457605,
-0.4380081296,
0.7091889381,
-0.4181066155,
-0.0363586359,
0.0301295426,
-0.0559887998,
-0.0962264314,
0.3488467336,
0.359276861,
0.5233590007,
0.0370033197,
0.2442617714,
0.245602861,
-0.3997453451,
0.1261517853,
0.3147122562,
-0.2152362168,
-0.1456690729,
0.0654059947,
0.8259485364,
0.4194198549,
-0.4743328094,
0.5587881804,
-0.1679204404,
-0.1941676289,
-0.4559626877,
-0.1723819971,
0.1520331651,
0.1138968915,
-0.0274368655,
0.1693035811,
-0.1220259443,
-0.5472952127,
0.1591150463,
0.3656503856,
-0.4336228967,
-0.6956447959,
0.5468924046,
0.3019309938,
0.0228758678,
0.5805969834,
-0.3299787641,
-0.5951964259,
0.1850304157,
0.0684375465,
0.9391223192,
-0.0928502902,
0.2871889174,
0.5637538433,
0.193718031,
-0.269903779,
0.024569191,
-0.2776739895,
-0.5262051821,
-0.3069226742,
-0.8052231669,
-0.3480781019,
0.0706103444,
-0.4850740433,
0.4227486551,
-0.7053278089,
-0.5211874247,
0.2504510581,
0.0832782909,
-0.774559319,
0.0353514478,
0.3153646588,
0.3524594009,
-1.0049604177,
0.7737876773,
0.801753521,
-0.6529784203,
-0.8124882579,
-0.1407102793,
0.2253723592,
-0.63480407,
0.6374728084,
0.2830445468,
-0.1162342504,
-0.069461599,
-0.8276404142,
-0.5364587307,
0.7921196222,
0.0334873535,
-0.4310986698,
0.0428843684,
0.3530154228,
0.7003579736,
-0.3783372641,
0.0689055547,
0.7384595871,
0.5881383419,
-0.0262838826,
-0.9251760244,
0.1265823543,
-0.0958441272,
-0.1189593375,
0.1842272133,
-0.4872536957,
0.8526473045,
-0.1788914353,
-0.344030261,
-0.107561253,
0.5544975996,
-0.0221100505,
0.1674145609,
0.866098702,
0.7710502148,
0.5042812228,
-0.2033560276,
0.8510397077,
-0.0611214004,
0.5172738433,
1.0412470102,
-0.1040550023,
0.8266716599,
0.3682949543,
-0.3650147021,
0.4789063036,
0.7288520932,
-0.1464490592,
0.0690722167,
0.2469008118,
-0.2853204906,
-0.4487214983,
0.1232655793,
-0.1655919403,
0.478284508,
0.3651660085,
-0.1933697909,
-0.2987521291,
-0.0204633586,
0.4585958123,
0.071871765,
-0.1165654957,
1.1435074806,
0.2197032869,
-0.6920521855,
0.4615554512,
0.1615301371,
0.6493401527,
-0.5798475742,
-0.0130112171,
-0.0910780281,
0.1940827668,
-0.1780290455,
-0.6022889614,
0.1073685437,
0.2001158595,
-0.0398365259,
-0.1961635351,
0.5694663525,
-0.5273842216,
-0.6057683229,
0.1193105429,
0.2126976252,
0.1909195781,
-0.2158859819,
-0.9254501462,
-0.1331931204,
-0.0055163186,
-0.5551447272,
0.2957825661,
0.4919256568,
-0.3354783654,
0.4305154383,
0.9360544086,
0.0815153271,
-0.0589493513,
0.3231754899,
0.9719355106,
-0.8053820729,
-0.4133653939,
-0.7392706275,
0.4383485615,
-0.41602844,
-0.2910323143,
0.570130825,
0.2439833432,
0.9140350223,
0.0078044683,
0.8700967431,
-0.1220212355,
0.5964816809,
-0.2707167566,
0.7769830823,
-0.4722266197,
0.1735265553,
-0.153422147,
-0.6419692039,
-0.4151975811,
0.7804600596,
-0.318947047,
0.0266499016,
0.5544276237,
0.5965063572,
0.0456457585,
0.1962517649,
0.0157157741,
0.1465959847,
0.5318779349,
0.2317968011,
0.8217157722,
-0.2932757735,
0.5439655781,
-0.3825834692,
-0.2456459999,
-0.2583856285,
-0.809923768,
-1.1232907772,
-0.5600440502,
-0.483671993,
-0.2466850132,
-0.253013581,
1.3153660297,
0.693476975,
-0.9504252076,
-0.1743671298,
0.0154593,
-0.1596688926,
-0.0491005294,
-0.1982594728,
0.3095762432,
-0.6317692995,
-0.771707952,
-0.0379141457,
0.2042120993,
0.1745197475,
-0.4241944849,
0.0602668002,
-0.2224404663,
0.0042536929,
0.507420361,
0.5903673768,
-1.0935260057,
-0.5870072246,
-0.1936957389,
-0.3929926753,
0.0665456429,
0.9155626297,
-0.568857789,
0.5972405672,
0.1838367432,
0.7867016196,
0.4285140932,
0.3339937925,
0.4602285028,
-0.846380353,
0.2995099425,
0.2756131291,
0.2934951186,
0.3432869017,
-0.1684584618,
0.4844337702,
0.3719497621,
-0.7792800665,
-0.6408035755,
0.1640272141,
-1.1775346994,
-0.0810431167,
1.2453404665,
-0.30610618,
-0.1744726002,
-0.3594022095,
-0.5806472898,
0.1422882676,
-0.4500190318,
0.9115903974,
0.8143348694,
0.087440446,
0.0098124398,
-0.6874157786,
0.7456983328,
0.0926443338,
-1.0452201366,
0.3587706983,
0.6851351261,
0.3167496622,
0.1362990141,
0.745331347,
-0.0615898892,
-0.1009459943,
-0.1630441695,
0.239492178,
-0.1462732106,
-0.157342568,
-0.2938505709,
0.0762175247,
0.0217785239,
-0.1570214182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16829v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16829v1
|
Understanding and Mitigating Tokenization Bias in Language Models
| 2024-06-24T17:38:02 | 2024-06-24T17:38:02 |
Buu Phan, Marton Havasi, Matthew Muckley, Karen Ullrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
State-of-the-art language models are autoregressive and operate on subword
units known as tokens. Specifically, one must encode the conditioning string
into a list of tokens before passing to the language models for next-token
prediction. We show that, for encoding schemes such as maximum prefix matching,
tokenization induces a sampling bias that cannot be mitigated with more
training or data. To counter this universal problem, we propose a novel
algorithm to obtain unbiased estimates from a model that was trained on
tokenized data. Our method does not require finetuning the model, and its
complexity, defined as the number of model runs, scales linearly with the
sequence length. As a consequence, we show that one can simulate token-free
behavior from a tokenized language model. We empirically verify the correctness
of our method through a Markov-chain setup, where it accurately recovers the
transition probabilities, as opposed to the conventional method of directly
prompting tokens into the language model.
|
[
-0.1373619735,
-0.5870605111,
0.2657859027,
0.0265393537,
-0.4597689211,
0.040614035,
-0.2815645039,
-0.1552059948,
0.1698441654,
0.4918941855,
-0.3857710063,
-0.3440157771,
-0.6471527219,
-0.2275754362,
-0.4844678342,
1.1111114025,
0.1438042372,
0.5206676722,
-0.1089610904,
-0.1388511211,
-0.5535617471,
-0.8740134835,
-0.5773388147,
-0.4148994982,
0.0907138437,
0.0335577056,
0.6467584968,
0.7339090705,
0.2988522351,
0.1338755637,
-0.2174070179,
-0.0779498816,
-0.3154831529,
0.0440276861,
-0.1498686969,
-0.6351355314,
-0.1457665712,
0.1936382502,
0.5245434642,
0.9208624959,
-0.231137827,
0.3050526977,
-0.1982495487,
0.3652292788,
-0.6251668334,
0.1040850729,
-1.0076678991,
0.1298633665,
-0.3128041923,
-0.1277249902,
-0.782453537,
0.030778056,
-0.1324178427,
-0.4157348275,
0.2722570002,
0.2889185548,
0.527143836,
0.1085930318,
-0.4671795964,
-0.064671278,
-0.6231385469,
0.8781489134,
-0.7916892171,
0.5133870244,
0.5544204116,
-0.033542309,
-0.2422255129,
-0.4251917899,
-0.4960904717,
-0.2046565115,
0.036603488,
-0.2541563213,
-0.2455691248,
0.2489489317,
0.3586545289,
0.2816295326,
-0.2393506765,
0.1885642558,
-0.2866072059,
-0.3577927947,
0.2575100362,
-0.0379422568,
0.3394731879,
-0.1060226485,
-0.4063633382,
-0.0155419949,
-0.5426837802,
-0.0282119475,
0.5789294243,
0.4566304386,
0.2254654318,
0.5889866948,
0.0128162187,
0.5591042638,
0.2462509573,
0.3262805343,
0.2211962491,
-0.4523844421,
-0.2999787927,
0.012594996,
0.5410217047,
0.3904118538,
0.502073586,
-0.3922848701,
-0.342885226,
0.1559531987,
0.1056810543,
-0.651835382,
-0.1169930845,
0.1311351359,
-0.485630244,
-0.2723780572,
-0.0308548473,
-0.6185437441,
-0.2833955884,
-0.1379628032,
0.2722712159,
-0.1631802768,
-0.3499229252,
0.0727338344,
-0.2762842774,
-0.0175022092,
-0.2210338414,
-1.0648878813,
0.5846648812,
0.5237200856,
0.7599160075,
-0.104739584,
-0.1268285364,
-0.6875942945,
0.0064376369,
-0.5987529755,
0.4130639136,
-0.7256766558,
-0.4116768837,
-0.0055428124,
-0.2040003091,
-0.0401432477,
-0.3672762513,
0.3602166176,
-0.6569363475,
0.0073655588,
-0.2298996747,
-0.7530280352,
0.2488839626,
-0.019592749,
-0.6361077428,
1.0100786686,
-0.0174699035,
-1.0524470806,
0.5803713202,
-0.4866183698,
-0.2352374643,
-0.3369858563,
0.0624203011,
-0.158960253,
0.6061646342,
0.5126318932,
0.114204593,
-0.1344745606,
0.4485124946,
-0.3138549626,
-0.3082192838,
0.3189989626,
-0.6163876653,
0.7149373889,
0.2353515178,
-0.3262564838,
0.1442105621,
-0.4707159996,
-0.1253271848,
-0.0616544411,
-0.2130274773,
-0.6062145233,
0.0245809462,
0.0789905861,
0.0719896406,
-0.0176794603,
-0.6812690496,
0.2789945304,
-0.6006020308,
0.4147789776,
1.0968002081,
-0.0741936713,
0.7428740263,
0.0571693592,
0.5243171453,
0.3488900959,
0.2602106035,
-0.3978612125,
-0.3231756985,
-0.9109021425,
-0.0409208797,
0.7817572355,
0.2951484323,
-0.5878155828,
0.2770997584,
-0.1535734236,
-0.0927369222,
-0.5307578444,
-0.0460159704,
0.5055584908,
0.3808671534,
0.3232161105,
-0.6624728441,
-0.8328259587,
-0.8126531243,
-0.6624961495,
-0.2647028267,
0.0409971252,
0.068815589,
0.4317620099,
-0.0663041621,
1.1029469967,
-0.1870028228,
0.0585797839,
-0.1676614732,
0.2032295465,
0.2225337327,
0.833699882,
0.3713101745,
-0.3846848309,
-0.1419021189,
-0.200627923,
-0.150331825,
-0.206072703,
-0.0340943635,
-0.1864048094,
0.4093463719,
0.6776608825,
-0.4608667493,
0.6833110452,
0.4392096698,
-0.5696427822,
0.3629611135,
-0.2718889117,
-0.2612282932,
-0.9164448977,
0.2194327861,
-0.0835609213,
-0.3032087386,
-0.7317461371,
-0.040993236,
-0.1304261386,
0.1344071031,
-0.2026320398,
0.8819938302,
-0.5670720339,
-0.139022544,
-0.391641289,
-0.147384271,
-0.1343998313,
0.4808964133,
-0.0128202941,
0.6847521067,
0.5233569741,
-0.5936937332,
0.01666734,
0.0254216995,
-0.2991233766,
0.2021224499,
-0.594405055,
0.2543517053,
-0.3822441101,
0.4511761069,
-0.8785873055,
0.2053940594,
0.026688993,
-0.6253275871,
0.2034934014,
-0.4338683486,
-0.4768910408,
-0.2793055177,
-0.0470446423,
0.7735564113,
0.6543633342,
-0.476474911,
0.4873656929,
0.6280399561,
0.3221824467,
-0.9003415704,
-0.7134023905,
0.0382065438,
-0.0671610087,
0.0965241268,
0.1219868287,
-0.0944840088,
-0.2029095441,
-0.1008323058,
-0.2826535106,
0.0622906461,
0.2632007301,
0.0070986152,
0.1950608641,
0.1689266264,
0.171251744,
-0.0284608211,
-0.1489988863,
0.124679938,
-1.0081905127,
0.8307221532,
0.3431019783,
-0.5708935857,
-0.255549401,
0.2168531716,
0.5553179979,
-0.2338393927,
0.7375760078,
0.5136821866,
-0.6062784195,
-0.2842944264,
-0.6585227251,
-0.3071849048,
-0.3797215521,
0.4475156665,
-0.3281521201,
-0.6016076207,
0.6983343363,
0.2982125282,
0.1607786864,
0.2674693465,
0.6527687907,
0.4449428916,
1.3461693525,
0.6662694216,
-0.4496942163,
0.5882830024,
-0.0772325024,
0.2341258824,
-0.8499340415,
-0.2240614146,
-0.4926951826,
-0.1079239994,
-0.5339664221,
-0.624876976,
0.019536091,
0.0976815894,
-0.1207791567,
0.2041733563,
-0.2996712625,
0.6758856177,
0.8606914282,
-0.2233110666,
0.1182503849,
0.0809898004,
-0.7650117874,
0.1152281687,
-0.7517319322,
-0.1826953143,
1.2441738844,
0.3157592416,
0.7346004844,
-0.1141431853,
0.4070320129,
0.427976191,
0.280169934,
-0.6243957877,
0.2378724962,
-0.1356764138,
-0.8597119451,
-0.2752184868,
-0.3883577883,
-0.8229681849,
0.356990546,
-0.1018365622,
-0.9752922058,
0.297993809,
0.3610185981,
-0.074793376,
0.5694669485,
-0.4727565348,
0.643471539,
0.058715146,
-0.0948296413,
-0.1014322639,
-0.4454035163,
0.294521749,
-0.0562800467,
0.4624156952,
-0.1663313806,
0.0521141626,
0.8785597682,
-0.5458946824,
0.8644288182,
-0.3979539275,
0.1102008969,
0.1382559836,
0.1804291159,
0.5676108599,
-0.0855874345,
-0.0939373747,
0.0042794212,
0.0628068,
-0.7197068334,
-0.4990535378,
0.4198521078,
-0.6201655269,
-0.4211992621,
-0.3850619793,
-0.5133733749,
-0.3864928782,
0.1793191433,
0.3216888011,
0.4275118709,
-0.4211324155,
-0.2014206648,
0.3996590078,
-0.0495720729,
0.5414244533,
0.2677364945,
-0.4600744843,
-0.4905268848,
0.5684632063,
0.1534199417,
0.2820116878,
0.1221831888,
0.2889307439,
-0.4707481861,
-0.5725287199,
-0.4818122685,
0.0587531067,
-0.7066039443,
-0.0697542876,
-0.595983088,
0.0600044206,
-0.5243435502,
0.2914249301,
-0.2973088622,
-0.557051003,
-0.1083527654,
-0.3402549922,
0.1405137777,
0.7024990916,
-0.1048855409,
0.3020837605,
-0.5712088943,
-0.181665197,
0.1264419705,
0.5006864667,
0.2835742533,
-0.7451558709,
-0.3394940794,
0.0476503409,
0.2756786048,
-0.7553030849,
0.3498778939,
0.1098273247,
0.6253999472,
0.4188182652,
0.0478158034,
0.6743504405,
-0.716365993,
0.7775368094,
0.1815972179,
-1.416514039,
0.3434249461,
-0.1885689348,
0.2151248157,
0.5236076713,
0.0855297893,
-0.895357132,
-0.3042194247,
-0.7442196608,
-0.8906430006,
0.656042397,
0.2058152705,
0.4880642295,
-0.424952805,
0.4752624631,
-0.0175139997,
0.4081337452,
-0.6693874002,
-0.1764030755,
-0.1837798804,
-0.25678882,
-0.1566276848,
-0.4247935414,
0.0733828917,
-0.1950022876,
0.8050414324,
-0.2388997227,
0.1425787508,
-0.0161684044,
-0.3264976144,
-0.0737165064,
0.1073100194,
0.4402530193,
0.5172095299,
0.0064494931,
0.297447145,
0.2839875817,
-0.4202863872,
0.1218595356,
-0.1852031499,
-0.3962894976,
0.2827846706,
0.1426405311,
1.0485249758,
0.0355011486,
-0.6356070638,
0.7047434449,
-0.1154548004,
0.1552502364,
-0.1326100379,
-0.3369803429,
-0.1505811214,
-0.088007845,
0.3479453921,
0.0732712671,
0.0334352963,
-0.4869459569,
0.2673898041,
0.7747398615,
-0.661742866,
-0.5426752567,
0.8359903693,
0.2086578161,
-0.2034331113,
0.6041178703,
-0.0276786555,
-0.5655882955,
0.5981402397,
0.7003372908,
0.8976675868,
-0.2121177912,
-0.0105201593,
0.4000640512,
0.3333746493,
-0.3557570279,
0.1049067304,
-0.0808214173,
-0.8549393415,
-0.3887459934,
-0.8039054871,
-0.2320816517,
0.0421669744,
-0.7587814927,
-0.0367619991,
-0.420089215,
-0.5684580207,
-0.2199785262,
-0.279618293,
-0.6624232531,
0.1630715877,
0.2197728455,
1.0848356485,
-0.9959048033,
0.9146872759,
0.3938997686,
-0.4346308708,
-0.689776361,
0.053219106,
-0.1808036417,
-0.9318519235,
0.6736591458,
0.0997438803,
0.070896849,
0.0040026507,
-0.4574051201,
-0.9883256555,
0.4819410741,
0.361022979,
-0.3159526885,
-0.2046258301,
0.1144496724,
0.3939873278,
-0.4204611182,
0.4398080409,
0.7326973677,
0.2990965247,
-0.1306399405,
-0.9803853631,
0.0245977063,
-0.303378284,
0.3966657221,
0.1773570329,
-0.3565143049,
0.8563459516,
-0.07749594,
-0.2158743441,
0.1066553816,
0.7061787248,
-0.0327140763,
-0.1019807681,
0.7009144425,
0.5191383958,
0.8825338483,
0.0451324508,
0.7880688906,
-0.6737282872,
0.4735191762,
1.0467084646,
-0.0496958233,
0.6112052202,
0.844119072,
-0.0561966114,
0.3682599664,
0.6118616462,
0.0904293433,
0.3759024143,
0.7761477828,
-0.1190314367,
-0.2218967676,
-0.4582563341,
-0.0410458781,
0.3654311001,
0.0333909765,
-0.6012411118,
-0.0468057916,
0.1159510761,
0.1975958645,
-0.0063045197,
-0.3589562476,
0.7406907082,
-0.0583339743,
-0.8409796953,
0.4801518023,
0.2439188212,
0.8040603995,
-0.3692531884,
0.2513480186,
-0.4280828536,
0.0829189569,
0.0164407529,
-0.1451509148,
0.1979738772,
0.1492402256,
-0.2131688893,
-0.0616385341,
0.328854084,
-0.5437136889,
-0.637008965,
0.1414702237,
0.6150270104,
0.1226205677,
0.1711560637,
-0.3947323263,
-0.0288480613,
-0.116853632,
-0.1999630183,
0.3643150926,
0.239435941,
-0.4112050831,
0.5774344802,
0.7892834544,
0.2747170031,
0.3007421196,
0.3805723786,
0.7030087113,
-0.478520602,
-0.6444741488,
-1.1094311476,
0.214694649,
-0.0812148228,
-0.1384746134,
0.5712079406,
0.5862316489,
1.0023605824,
0.0137068201,
0.7703000307,
0.332362324,
0.2296570688,
-0.6019638777,
0.5430536866,
-0.2231700271,
0.3499988019,
-0.0324831419,
-0.6251035333,
-0.3002665937,
0.3854804635,
-0.109993197,
0.138647899,
0.5515298247,
0.7570952177,
-0.0456494428,
-0.2654155195,
0.2111006528,
-0.0350281969,
0.200071618,
0.2589157522,
0.531611979,
-0.4111922085,
0.2825913727,
-0.0622943975,
-0.1057205871,
0.0318840593,
-0.8971749544,
-1.0796990395,
-0.5424056649,
-0.0466804802,
-0.4992945492,
0.2582712471,
1.2507487535,
0.933339417,
-0.9322978258,
-0.3617538512,
-0.3163039386,
0.191106081,
-0.1632077992,
-0.1355686933,
0.2846493423,
-0.6504238844,
-0.9406100512,
0.1498059481,
-0.0685595199,
0.1343572289,
-0.511526227,
0.0940016732,
-0.0671578273,
0.6151753664,
0.2402367443,
0.0393620096,
-0.7980768085,
-0.2882427871,
-0.0368472598,
0.1432858855,
0.1272486597,
1.1413751841,
-0.8597917557,
0.57265836,
0.4613788426,
0.6146779656,
0.3595291674,
0.0358473398,
0.8863589168,
-0.9914447069,
0.2288733572,
0.009305845,
0.5022185445,
0.3187349737,
-0.2377846539,
0.3837351203,
0.3187951148,
-0.2361671627,
-1.1496511698,
0.5021321177,
-0.4224070907,
-0.2945982814,
1.1088783741,
-0.0354206786,
-0.3395676017,
-0.1326780766,
0.0224763565,
0.3865555227,
-0.414568156,
0.6443058848,
0.7755159736,
0.1824773103,
0.0962603688,
-0.2308561504,
0.7118625045,
0.5459646583,
-0.2571789324,
0.3784879744,
0.1944982708,
0.3862349093,
-0.1158247441,
0.7908329368,
-0.0811366439,
-0.0666004121,
0.0914862305,
0.2100457847,
-0.0324951075,
-0.039329417,
-0.6081494689,
-0.087229982,
0.2914240956,
-0.3105944991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16828v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16828v1
|
Ragnarök: A Reusable RAG Framework and Baselines for TREC 2024 Retrieval-Augmented Generation Track
| 2024-06-24T17:37:52 | 2024-06-24T17:37:52 |
Ronak Pradeep, Nandan Thakur, Sahel Sharifymoghaddam, Eric Zhang, Ryan Nguyen, Daniel Campos, Nick Craswell, Jimmy Lin
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Did you try out the new Bing Search? Or maybe you fiddled around with Google
AI~Overviews? These might sound familiar because the modern-day search stack
has recently evolved to include retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems.
They allow searching and incorporating real-time data into large language
models (LLMs) to provide a well-informed, attributed, concise summary in
contrast to the traditional search paradigm that relies on displaying a ranked
list of documents. Therefore, given these recent advancements, it is crucial to
have an arena to build, test, visualize, and systematically evaluate RAG-based
search systems. With this in mind, we propose the TREC 2024 RAG Track to foster
innovation in evaluating RAG systems. In our work, we lay out the steps we've
made towards making this track a reality -- we describe the details of our
reusable framework, Ragnar\"ok, explain the curation of the new MS MARCO V2.1
collection choice, release the development topics for the track, and
standardize the I/O definitions which assist the end user. Next, using
Ragnar\"ok, we identify and provide key industrial baselines such as OpenAI's
GPT-4o or Cohere's Command R+. Further, we introduce a web-based user interface
for an interactive arena allowing benchmarking pairwise RAG systems by
crowdsourcing. We open-source our Ragnar\"ok framework and baselines to achieve
a unified standard for future RAG systems.
|
[
-0.7642362714,
-0.3428736329,
0.4861020446,
0.0367216393,
-0.1681909859,
0.5373899341,
0.1040788218,
-0.5668849349,
0.4588381946,
0.7418422103,
-0.4242911339,
-0.3466083407,
-0.1681105644,
0.1015467569,
-0.4285639524,
1.2519577742,
-0.2516925037,
-0.3786206245,
-0.2643065453,
-0.3802400529,
-0.6439622641,
-0.1939498186,
-0.6978539228,
-0.4312125742,
0.7726893425,
0.549534142,
0.4433104396,
0.7134926319,
0.673209846,
0.243105188,
-0.189785257,
0.1664965153,
-0.5027308464,
0.5259290934,
-0.447496146,
-0.2817008495,
-0.8659681678,
0.3585586548,
0.6047398448,
0.3318524361,
-0.1317978203,
0.6058740616,
-0.0676788092,
0.5458769202,
-0.7062162757,
-0.2374018431,
-0.7844664454,
0.1208242923,
-0.4980653822,
-0.5106432438,
-0.3716153204,
-0.0403167382,
-0.1453775316,
-0.9282791615,
0.4397068918,
0.3923454583,
1.0171399117,
0.1856811643,
-0.350612849,
-0.33371526,
-0.6695335507,
0.9097463489,
-0.2391280234,
0.4916424155,
0.2425608635,
0.6897804141,
-0.2019386292,
-1.3272647858,
-0.1958190352,
-0.342120707,
0.18920739,
0.4110875726,
0.179010123,
-0.1845685244,
0.1335394084,
0.4833180904,
-0.6739476919,
-0.0526098944,
-0.2022647262,
0.1085140854,
0.4125262499,
0.3373795152,
0.0800034702,
-0.0883777291,
-0.6338811517,
-0.0369742624,
-0.8398070931,
-0.361505419,
0.0944128186,
0.1603584588,
0.0115214484,
0.4833321571,
-0.1048421487,
0.5120274425,
0.2588453591,
0.0800126344,
0.2703754902,
-0.2781297266,
-0.0718085468,
-0.34399423,
0.3419824541,
0.2370409966,
-0.2805438042,
-0.3928588629,
-0.4843707681,
-0.1546118855,
0.8139139414,
-0.4667905569,
-0.025898505,
0.2228654027,
-0.3855724335,
-0.4134379625,
-0.1211167499,
-0.9940229654,
-0.4847609699,
-0.4747872055,
0.2967763543,
-0.017451182,
-0.2878800035,
-0.3498883545,
-0.438878715,
0.4574315548,
0.187621519,
-0.4716255665,
0.3034439981,
0.9406231642,
0.82382828,
-0.3369668126,
-0.222857058,
-0.7892972231,
0.2692237794,
-0.475096941,
1.0442484617,
-0.3699181378,
-0.5498682261,
-0.1952259094,
-0.1124877706,
0.2748797834,
-0.7156594992,
0.7282771468,
-0.9273825288,
0.2254479378,
-0.1984335035,
-0.3595036268,
0.1731858104,
0.495513767,
-0.8128188848,
1.0161247253,
-0.0041120728,
-0.8070387244,
0.4557318985,
-0.920383513,
-0.1725099683,
0.4506206512,
-0.0701056793,
-0.5786761045,
0.2478435636,
-0.012726699,
-0.081043072,
-0.5568298697,
0.4687597454,
-0.2652032971,
-0.5358456969,
-0.0842576846,
-0.2062232494,
0.7191588879,
0.6557604074,
-0.5531133413,
-0.0341198258,
-0.5313352942,
0.323581934,
-0.0273150243,
-0.4097093642,
-0.125070706,
-0.1513785124,
0.2287301272,
-0.141180858,
0.4441942871,
-0.234719649,
0.0424168408,
-0.248211816,
0.0067804889,
0.6628879905,
0.0000161483,
0.4454172254,
-0.453856796,
0.8826506734,
-0.4960264862,
0.2767014802,
-0.1585370153,
-0.154749766,
-0.6178479791,
-0.1467626244,
0.6415592432,
0.4851519763,
-0.8319771886,
0.0247359369,
-0.1899724007,
-0.5795962811,
-0.3440022767,
-0.1802979559,
0.4183731079,
0.5400075316,
0.2906163633,
-0.294796139,
-1.0141505003,
-0.8099193573,
-0.4818424881,
-0.0354145356,
-0.2136442214,
0.3586954474,
0.2570545375,
-0.2090862244,
0.9912910461,
-0.130903542,
-0.1692416817,
-0.3875137568,
0.3139616549,
0.1066362709,
0.4471895993,
0.3917495906,
-1.1209022999,
-0.4170547724,
0.1576508135,
-0.9324415922,
-0.2406944484,
0.3160509169,
-0.2889667451,
0.1348992735,
0.6839144826,
-0.2848778367,
0.3921371102,
0.5257763267,
-0.2345790565,
0.5424390435,
-0.0285388734,
0.3169227242,
-1.2828483582,
0.6680699587,
-0.3665819764,
-0.253198266,
-0.4017920792,
0.5626639128,
-0.1274560541,
-0.3900412023,
-0.165658012,
0.8964397907,
-0.4737349153,
-0.484996289,
-0.3117284775,
0.5187352896,
0.2915347517,
0.0548012853,
-0.5267065167,
1.0129351616,
-0.0590728223,
-0.4415745437,
0.211116448,
0.057516098,
-0.03729463,
0.8523003459,
-0.6495351791,
0.2695330679,
0.1210897565,
0.4492098987,
-0.6308812499,
-0.2304729074,
0.0054068989,
-0.7542706728,
0.4453473389,
-0.1663529575,
-0.2986763716,
-0.3295865059,
-0.2520866096,
0.3644661903,
0.3850864768,
-0.6898682714,
0.8634194732,
0.8452000618,
0.0593626499,
-0.7946122885,
-0.4279336035,
0.6407178044,
-0.4444018602,
-0.3823444843,
0.5520328283,
-0.1452350318,
-0.2947147191,
0.135424301,
-0.2776315808,
-0.1753272861,
0.1743014604,
0.189886108,
0.3584368825,
-0.2038879842,
0.0359198228,
-0.1676521003,
-0.4698444903,
-0.2290384173,
-0.4599192142,
0.3800986111,
-0.2460157573,
-0.150503695,
-0.0693396926,
0.3660232127,
0.5369406343,
-0.4944851696,
0.0205786787,
0.664059639,
-0.3202572465,
-0.0219759978,
-0.6545372009,
0.1001100019,
-0.4975656271,
0.1466907114,
-0.4743483365,
-0.9728437662,
0.4858042598,
-0.4991303086,
0.4732685387,
0.5567774773,
0.394259572,
-0.4583180547,
0.8529554605,
0.8312686682,
0.1788733453,
0.4287714362,
-0.4004797935,
0.0790138096,
-1.2309656143,
-0.135715276,
-0.7301755548,
-0.5066162944,
-0.8476669192,
-0.4661608934,
0.6514977813,
0.0127882166,
-0.2930229604,
0.3308881819,
-0.4512003958,
0.6231606603,
0.529543519,
-0.2800295651,
0.2858169973,
-0.0318276808,
-0.2728503644,
-0.0962516293,
-0.6478626132,
-0.4377399981,
1.1579264402,
0.1396550238,
0.5469248891,
-0.2951515615,
1.1371189356,
0.4512419403,
0.7901226878,
-0.4482909441,
0.5472946167,
-0.3778948188,
-1.120349884,
-0.1653129011,
-0.3125286996,
-1.0212665796,
0.0668133646,
0.0879208148,
-0.3910922408,
0.1432372034,
0.2817139626,
0.0794095099,
0.3796418309,
-0.4814989865,
0.8693047762,
-0.2203695476,
-0.5511951447,
-0.1741607487,
-0.5868410468,
0.2840320766,
0.0250145756,
0.2756058276,
0.0210985765,
-0.3971382082,
0.7185291052,
-0.1225349754,
0.3851433098,
-0.2417210937,
0.1610335261,
0.5043373108,
0.1157300472,
0.5170610547,
0.0147014735,
-0.165729329,
-0.0871976614,
-0.3086364567,
-0.2800447047,
-0.4871958792,
0.8049222231,
-0.36141482,
-0.4299049079,
-0.4447421432,
-0.473793745,
-0.2788212895,
0.3427117169,
0.3329814076,
0.4844289124,
-0.4094904065,
0.379652679,
0.5020115972,
0.0070739752,
0.0522393398,
0.3510502577,
-0.442288518,
-0.710739851,
1.0682706833,
0.0041252058,
0.0191449337,
0.3697761595,
0.1032740474,
-0.3253636956,
-0.4434190094,
-0.3770909905,
0.098636128,
-0.444783777,
-0.4310672879,
-0.4467977881,
-0.1145480871,
-0.2018899471,
-0.4080722034,
-0.4755753279,
-0.3435101807,
0.0220387075,
0.1336645335,
0.1700734496,
1.0102310181,
-0.3713791966,
0.0374068357,
-0.5300642252,
0.5428361893,
0.1241690293,
0.7629140019,
-0.194653973,
-0.5764762163,
-0.5775937438,
-0.1074122787,
-0.536000967,
-0.418191582,
0.2087396532,
-0.0573466085,
0.6277133822,
-0.2449637204,
-0.0191013943,
0.7790811062,
-0.5492470264,
0.6165688634,
-0.0085552018,
-0.7312050462,
0.4193442166,
-0.5247650743,
0.1772162616,
0.8382357359,
0.151863277,
-0.6502078176,
-0.5195387006,
-0.8181340098,
-1.0128525496,
0.5694214106,
0.0721081868,
-0.3262254298,
0.2242070735,
0.3263010681,
-0.0196822304,
0.2315308601,
-0.2884806693,
-0.0159521606,
-0.2001419067,
-0.067763336,
-0.0000855993,
-0.1416476816,
-0.1647642702,
0.1383659542,
0.6309391856,
-0.0466810949,
0.1604627967,
0.016787637,
0.120395489,
-0.0223497897,
0.1512572318,
0.268645972,
0.68819803,
-0.31776613,
0.1059308797,
0.2379262745,
-0.6899988055,
0.0888160467,
0.0305997804,
-0.2471455634,
0.1277676225,
0.0486477688,
0.4844070077,
0.3146796227,
-0.6027758718,
-0.0434400067,
-0.0308887213,
-0.0641679838,
-0.5642752647,
-0.1875192523,
0.1296098232,
0.3698447049,
0.3683591187,
0.0269943271,
0.4374216199,
-0.374476403,
0.5310218334,
0.2524104416,
-0.287122786,
-0.0354259014,
0.8363062143,
0.2566046715,
-0.4562591314,
0.2360249311,
-0.4753871262,
-0.4734677672,
0.5119120479,
0.403213948,
1.3095318079,
-0.1804771274,
0.1562916189,
0.3253040612,
0.3490923345,
0.0573458374,
0.0315215476,
-0.0659243762,
-0.1987390965,
-0.4694927037,
-0.7068824768,
-0.7073534131,
0.1377771944,
-0.6134866476,
0.3914911449,
-0.4145613313,
-0.312377274,
-0.2137028575,
0.3027740717,
-0.6259858012,
0.175999403,
-0.2131301165,
1.0165338516,
-0.3202277422,
0.3057260811,
0.7677419186,
-0.2655799091,
-0.6417149305,
0.1125459373,
0.0646101236,
-0.6774531603,
0.5567905307,
-0.1322877109,
-0.1835429221,
-0.0884032249,
-0.6665106416,
-0.9532307386,
1.3167091608,
0.0478807837,
-0.2474913746,
-0.1871206611,
-0.2210961729,
0.5997980833,
-0.4416279197,
0.0737334266,
0.4493305385,
0.5936780572,
0.3064371943,
-0.793140769,
-0.3207403421,
-0.2533921599,
0.0937969014,
0.309007585,
-0.4132225513,
0.7484163642,
-0.023225002,
-0.359645009,
0.3459843397,
0.4552177489,
0.6329828501,
0.8745328188,
0.4281207621,
0.8601074219,
0.5088891983,
-0.0808417201,
1.0833027363,
-0.1981128454,
0.3251477182,
1.4409062862,
-0.3470272422,
1.0227798223,
0.3299070299,
-0.044356484,
0.3668465316,
0.3645479083,
0.1519351304,
0.2279727161,
0.0777411088,
-0.2044821978,
-0.0832127482,
-0.2720302045,
-0.2032865733,
0.4940187335,
0.3248349428,
-0.0578612164,
-0.4840126336,
-0.0764885619,
0.0698572993,
0.1358559281,
-0.1228205189,
0.7630100846,
-0.055515036,
-0.7827385068,
0.6793911457,
-0.0872599781,
0.5609307885,
-0.4078811407,
-0.1604865938,
-0.5195156336,
0.1070718914,
-0.1381446421,
-0.7913833857,
0.4181205332,
0.3761585653,
-0.1285223365,
-0.3717713356,
0.7478658557,
-0.1388952434,
-0.345026195,
0.2059561759,
0.4966098368,
0.2638261318,
0.2176285684,
-0.6978632212,
0.3724808991,
-0.0171334725,
-0.1951767802,
0.3841637075,
0.5765506029,
-0.1644954532,
0.5786659718,
0.515250802,
0.0580083579,
0.0301785637,
-0.0042326776,
0.8190363646,
-0.7204523087,
-0.2808938622,
-0.0019816463,
0.5256927609,
-0.290971756,
-0.3001180887,
0.5775858164,
0.7860407829,
0.7456803918,
0.2201109827,
0.7282623649,
-0.3865389526,
1.1220808029,
-0.1590180397,
0.805927515,
-1.0350915194,
0.2463321835,
-0.0832486898,
-0.9179295897,
-0.1867449284,
0.1701799035,
0.0963853002,
0.2743620872,
0.5342262983,
0.7061989903,
-0.1215343922,
-0.0754015967,
0.2167436928,
0.112643607,
0.5669870377,
0.2040604204,
0.6863794923,
-0.4779957533,
0.8449041843,
0.035154555,
-0.3662300408,
-0.4082639217,
-0.8373172879,
-0.3875063062,
-0.7514024377,
0.0182037503,
-0.256786406,
0.3508100212,
0.4423195124,
0.4316266775,
-0.6075178385,
-0.4800507128,
-0.1282864213,
0.1859467179,
-0.0438306406,
-0.2524099052,
0.0306137744,
-0.7276194692,
-0.6749095321,
0.4560210109,
0.4528167546,
-0.1456821412,
-0.1930924803,
-0.0405423492,
-0.2528681755,
-0.2328208089,
0.4796565175,
0.6528123617,
-0.5881265998,
-0.3174071014,
0.3410463929,
0.0194118489,
0.0114780217,
0.9962981343,
-1.0169032812,
0.5402989388,
0.489656806,
0.7678852677,
0.5570141673,
-0.0516244099,
0.6705162525,
-0.6283231378,
-0.0894511938,
0.6334577203,
0.0867791176,
0.2659132779,
0.1387891769,
0.8620262146,
0.1723077744,
-0.9116667509,
-1.1221741438,
0.1906054616,
-0.8612046838,
0.0417419709,
0.6311272383,
0.064322859,
-0.2470331639,
-0.3133650422,
-0.1119844317,
0.2383995354,
-0.1411295533,
0.7819759846,
0.2885875404,
-0.0726988092,
0.163107425,
-0.7670231462,
0.4503216743,
0.2624698579,
-0.8579170108,
0.1521167159,
0.4546997249,
0.2278802693,
0.4171724916,
0.5463821292,
-0.5357043147,
0.4369643629,
0.2381190956,
0.16335769,
0.0068293875,
-0.6172642112,
-0.098283723,
0.1929080486,
0.0246616025,
-0.1498329341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16810v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16810v1
|
PISTOL: Dataset Compilation Pipeline for Structural Unlearning of LLMs
| 2024-06-24T17:22:36 | 2024-06-24T17:22:36 |
Xinchi Qiu, William F. Shen, Yihong Chen, Nicola Cancedda, Pontus Stenetorp, Nicholas D. Lane
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, machine unlearning, which seeks to erase specific data stored in
the pre-trained or fine-tuned models, has emerged as a crucial protective
measure for LLMs. However, unlearning approaches for LLMs that have been
considered thus far have focused on the removal of independent data points and
have not taken into account that the stored facts are logically connected to
one another and form an implicit knowledge graph. To facilitate the development
of structural unlearning methods, which are essential for the practical
application of unlearning, we propose PISTOL, a pipeline for compiling
multi-scenario datasets for benchmarking structural LLM unlearning.
Additionally, leveraging sample datasets synthesized using PISTOL, we conducted
benchmarks with four distinct unlearning methods on both Llama2-7B and
Mistral-7B models. This analysis helps to illustrate the prevailing challenges
in effectively and robustly removing highly inter-connected data, batched data,
or data skewed towards a specific domain. It also highlights the choice of
pre-trained model can impact unlearning performance. This work not only
advances our understandings on the limitation of current LLMs unlearning
methods and proposes future research directions, but also provides a replicable
framework for ongoing exploration and validation in the field.
|
[
-0.1098896265,
-0.6269176006,
0.1749024391,
-0.2531363368,
-0.4070916772,
0.4853619635,
-0.1513744742,
-0.0255543292,
-0.438593477,
0.4691937268,
-0.6935705543,
-0.9272348881,
-0.6521695256,
-0.1564313322,
-0.5695183277,
1.0148712397,
-0.0948217064,
0.3469597399,
-0.0164208524,
-0.0090482887,
-0.4642564058,
-0.4759962857,
-0.2293994725,
-0.5348590612,
0.1829813272,
0.3500745296,
0.3163321018,
0.8564138412,
0.3157747984,
0.3026659191,
-0.3107866049,
0.2155107409,
-0.734264791,
0.2479093373,
-0.1364112049,
-0.4423336983,
-0.2399768531,
-0.026724495,
0.775372088,
0.8509560823,
-0.2252026945,
0.3415731788,
0.5071420074,
0.7479801178,
-0.713944912,
0.4938466549,
-0.8132263422,
0.3786748648,
-0.4186399281,
-0.1298289299,
-0.3614911735,
0.0442885235,
-0.0355320834,
-0.4640113711,
0.4057578743,
-0.0095004784,
0.2964769602,
0.4255155623,
-0.6368529201,
-0.2068564147,
-0.5215578079,
0.5035127997,
-0.4638292193,
0.3926497698,
0.0258905534,
0.2799656391,
-0.6508141756,
-0.9352983236,
-0.0149473967,
0.4184523821,
0.0833468288,
0.1514587998,
0.0316810124,
0.0846167803,
0.1574860215,
0.2349627018,
-0.5538449287,
0.2281044275,
-1.0212790966,
-0.3033126891,
0.4336572587,
0.1805025786,
-0.1321729571,
-0.2116049379,
-0.5935713053,
-0.0267762486,
-1.3263609409,
0.065711908,
0.5102985501,
0.497289896,
-0.1032590866,
0.7571740746,
-0.1646612287,
0.4035983086,
-0.319209218,
-0.1564769894,
0.4087659121,
0.1051081717,
-0.2071746737,
0.1243283227,
0.66453439,
0.2923642397,
0.2416083068,
-0.4357915819,
-0.175614655,
0.0457193926,
0.3382950425,
-0.6229733825,
-0.3679548204,
0.2207940221,
-0.5756560564,
-0.2873075008,
-0.010963711,
-0.7293909192,
-0.541772902,
-0.3691037893,
0.2567961812,
-0.2399230748,
0.0013150797,
-0.0548568964,
-0.3582791388,
-0.0298386812,
0.0200054254,
-0.4717304409,
-0.0415867269,
0.5548990965,
0.7396950126,
-0.2558395565,
-0.3712709844,
-0.606782794,
0.3968650401,
-0.2910478711,
0.6122081876,
-0.56717062,
-0.6446323395,
-0.0974143371,
0.035410963,
0.1991008818,
-0.7730247974,
0.4336150587,
-0.260229826,
0.1228319705,
-0.1716837287,
-0.8506490588,
-0.2423122674,
-0.0164455213,
-0.3329758346,
1.0814028978,
0.0590186454,
-0.3874628842,
0.6846602559,
-0.3050120175,
-0.1926859766,
-0.1437767297,
-0.2683835924,
-0.7158989906,
0.1150114834,
0.0629497021,
0.7174972892,
-0.3430882096,
0.7474811077,
-0.8085548878,
-0.4990862608,
-0.1893691123,
-0.4021787643,
0.6446663141,
0.3935065866,
-0.4442167282,
0.0601434149,
-0.8446115255,
0.0110331476,
-0.0861987248,
-0.4673067033,
0.1456881911,
0.1673794985,
-0.3726318777,
0.2315271199,
-0.0086340634,
-0.3871040046,
0.336330384,
-0.3497290611,
0.5139279366,
0.9633537531,
0.0663331673,
0.4224065542,
-0.2525370717,
0.2029182613,
0.3942680359,
0.1011711806,
-0.2172355503,
-0.1670844555,
-0.6903749108,
-0.4173627496,
0.1528561264,
0.4295535982,
-0.5420424342,
0.1999039054,
0.1443635821,
-0.6563150287,
-0.1884479374,
0.6722778678,
0.8842341304,
0.7197062969,
0.5319621563,
-0.3905465901,
-0.8193356991,
-0.6481918693,
-0.3649423718,
-0.0466544479,
-0.1054874733,
-0.3097914159,
0.4924859107,
-0.0107073355,
0.8182998896,
-0.5392060876,
-0.4366262853,
-0.1866882145,
0.2102249116,
0.0976225436,
0.270942986,
0.2025578171,
-0.5697819591,
-0.02916844,
-0.3987986445,
-1.3337967396,
0.0728514642,
0.1042146087,
0.0162352547,
0.0251225717,
0.6757807732,
-0.4397080243,
0.7940719128,
0.2134911865,
0.1464958191,
0.5360304713,
-0.0037330491,
-0.0568489805,
-1.0755717754,
-0.0504246093,
-0.081327498,
0.1717606485,
-0.5181355476,
-0.0621677041,
-0.0220708158,
-0.3246352971,
-0.7961878181,
0.5474882126,
-0.8359667063,
-0.4482656717,
-0.0668346807,
-0.0101817865,
-0.0753027871,
0.7636646032,
0.1062453613,
0.6576538086,
0.6951093078,
-0.5850166082,
0.2899312973,
0.3012956083,
-0.4322414994,
0.1657242626,
-0.6332018375,
-0.0985261798,
-0.1565040797,
0.3195002079,
-0.8088060021,
0.1018619239,
0.2386644036,
-0.0973458886,
0.332919389,
-0.5817260742,
-0.4278869331,
-0.1237608939,
-0.4350485504,
0.1173276305,
0.3436984718,
-0.5754776001,
0.4384925663,
0.4476236999,
-0.0338051766,
-0.920624733,
-0.4747428596,
-0.2533558309,
-0.5666068196,
-0.3137379587,
0.3091607392,
-0.0306902993,
-0.155006513,
-0.1443313509,
-0.5054822564,
-0.1720162034,
0.0642097071,
0.7882003784,
0.3197136819,
0.0289540105,
0.3347136378,
0.1533264071,
-0.3295429647,
0.0614105426,
-0.0313244835,
0.4582702219,
-0.0026642822,
-0.6071255803,
0.0115568088,
0.0720606521,
0.228361845,
-0.1441695094,
0.6644841433,
0.5193164945,
-0.339476645,
-0.4335007071,
-0.2196918577,
-0.12140394,
-0.555259943,
0.1819032282,
-0.2327217907,
-0.8089851737,
0.6085198522,
-0.7097263336,
0.5347256064,
0.1530708373,
0.591878891,
-0.2522475719,
0.5378750563,
0.4423483312,
-0.1762650013,
0.188483879,
-0.482539922,
0.1441478282,
-0.8786953688,
-0.5788716674,
-0.3935118318,
-0.3910645545,
-0.2593685389,
-0.2754899859,
0.6473429799,
0.5225117207,
-0.5746941566,
0.3200469613,
-0.4300199151,
0.600614965,
0.3603550494,
0.3955910504,
0.4640901983,
0.006873779,
-0.3591122329,
0.1756906807,
-0.5765906572,
-0.5982585549,
1.8098351955,
0.0280908402,
0.7041597962,
-0.0000109528,
0.8292867541,
0.3405103385,
0.2407150567,
-0.4248195887,
0.448566258,
-0.1360500306,
-0.7322842479,
-0.1924482584,
-0.5130819082,
-0.9116945863,
0.1842518896,
-0.2541489601,
-0.6216697693,
-0.024651356,
0.2590371072,
-0.1170295551,
0.6367520094,
-0.6707445979,
0.7845609188,
-0.0471597202,
-0.3190943301,
-0.0961998776,
-0.8157752156,
0.576133728,
-0.2201048136,
0.1043536142,
-0.3006031811,
0.1778069139,
0.4750029445,
-0.4985847473,
1.1090860367,
-0.2467979193,
-0.0339640751,
0.3490633667,
0.0189707335,
0.4054668844,
0.1365118325,
-0.2080627233,
0.4767563641,
-0.1366873831,
-0.1666671634,
-0.4397179782,
0.2854861319,
-0.6228760481,
-0.34126544,
-0.2004667968,
-0.4747465551,
-0.3725284338,
0.1388979256,
0.5993391275,
0.7304959893,
-0.3100853562,
0.2968256474,
0.5653139949,
-0.007986811,
0.634583056,
0.5069544315,
0.0745080486,
-0.0906830505,
0.7086265087,
0.2819011509,
-0.0462455414,
0.279414624,
-0.2522481382,
-0.3513141274,
-0.911511302,
-0.3527511358,
-0.112318255,
-0.7375653982,
-0.5717899203,
-0.224456504,
-0.2665790319,
-0.2530126274,
-0.3234930634,
-0.4744408429,
-0.3762559593,
-0.311868608,
-0.2692876458,
0.2119095623,
0.6910560131,
-0.0853473023,
0.449623704,
-0.8789041638,
0.4117870033,
-0.0142338453,
0.3295072019,
-0.0678980574,
-0.5684243441,
-0.1528442204,
0.1250017881,
-0.6063553095,
-0.6158044934,
0.3743623793,
0.2627161741,
0.7610408068,
0.3804424107,
0.3189663887,
0.7155228853,
-0.4137786925,
0.4070390761,
0.1153110489,
-0.8697009087,
0.5804648995,
-0.4483805299,
0.0222249571,
0.4817367494,
0.5677407384,
-0.0634177551,
-0.3352316618,
-0.4843473434,
-0.846749723,
0.4225626886,
-0.0956924036,
-0.3851780891,
0.2453791201,
0.5798942447,
0.1236823052,
0.5336789489,
-0.3492414355,
-0.3447514772,
0.0374257676,
-0.1688923836,
-0.1436903477,
-0.0456717312,
-0.3231105506,
-0.1413080543,
0.676923275,
-0.1801614165,
0.0074139666,
-0.3615178168,
-0.4434819818,
0.1296809912,
0.277498126,
0.027058186,
0.6394082308,
-0.2059083283,
-0.0647207052,
0.4082792699,
-0.3956850171,
0.3724502027,
-0.2508607209,
-0.1403221786,
-0.4374610186,
0.4344257414,
0.3928253055,
0.5844213367,
-0.7667469978,
0.247863248,
0.2312616259,
-0.211509496,
-0.3292503357,
0.2769215703,
0.011778879,
0.4767737389,
0.2681384981,
0.0194092784,
0.1917428672,
-0.6928041577,
0.5158057213,
0.4051294029,
-0.2901530564,
-0.1483005732,
0.4901946187,
0.0987276733,
0.1142182946,
0.8131752014,
0.01531839,
-0.2937321663,
0.4801709652,
0.1874321103,
0.5071653128,
-0.0637957081,
0.1387353688,
0.1688205451,
0.2805228531,
-0.1716933995,
-0.0061734407,
-0.0240733549,
-0.638538003,
-0.1550388187,
-0.5798606873,
-0.3892470002,
0.1648378223,
-0.8393027186,
0.3912782371,
-0.6727284789,
0.1523352712,
-0.2160247415,
0.1857724786,
-0.5599367023,
0.1746465564,
-0.2279853374,
0.6421548128,
-0.8006079197,
0.7808164358,
0.2468292862,
-0.2387799323,
-0.8274533749,
-0.4428842962,
1.072868228,
-0.9171819687,
0.4913768172,
0.057821624,
-0.1534604132,
-0.2691038549,
-0.3174423873,
-0.5229841471,
1.1933703423,
0.7874442935,
-0.5206532478,
-0.0878552645,
0.2257604897,
0.2270570397,
-0.2671239376,
0.1595777422,
0.5774919391,
0.2387267947,
0.1616751701,
-0.5536462665,
-0.2316405922,
-0.3743607104,
-0.4714546204,
0.3651540577,
-0.6154499054,
0.8636461496,
-0.2642587721,
-0.1958476901,
0.0246862955,
0.5058867335,
0.4697336257,
0.4294771552,
0.1940687746,
0.6882600784,
0.7330449224,
-0.2007879168,
0.3015015423,
-0.3107166588,
0.2377075702,
1.4965349436,
-0.4585308433,
0.8193768859,
0.1561662406,
-0.0218176953,
0.2583639324,
0.7314825058,
-0.0888147652,
0.4860667586,
0.2140500546,
-0.3442645669,
-0.2001463622,
0.3039384782,
-0.4988670349,
0.8986421227,
0.2701846957,
-0.3106245399,
-0.5859784484,
-0.1470655054,
0.1004543006,
-0.1753843278,
-0.1991066039,
0.7518507838,
0.0659137815,
-0.2237241566,
0.4111713469,
-0.0354361758,
0.5266594887,
-0.8169357777,
-0.0497328937,
-0.4722830653,
0.3556040227,
-0.3182219863,
-0.6851429939,
0.4558519423,
0.2134485245,
-0.2233866453,
-0.3666435182,
0.6397332549,
-0.5150916576,
-0.1226261482,
0.3933274746,
0.6144373417,
0.2989857793,
0.0367893651,
-0.7558645606,
0.0785793439,
-0.0984773189,
-0.3435088694,
0.8272222877,
0.485049963,
0.0347761512,
1.1098452806,
0.8158937693,
-0.0954992175,
0.0964025185,
-0.0526725464,
1.1519526243,
-0.4437776506,
0.0667363703,
-0.6685228944,
0.6517948508,
0.1372573823,
-0.4702475667,
0.8056311607,
0.9696123004,
0.9286414385,
0.1948278099,
0.5487344861,
0.4407705963,
0.5186508894,
-0.8833419681,
0.7373723984,
-0.4430472255,
0.7896695137,
-0.2887129486,
-1.0090420246,
-0.0696027577,
0.2187946141,
0.2070601285,
0.0972573385,
0.5185549259,
1.0056134462,
-0.09886875,
0.0875133649,
0.2491593957,
0.0350362249,
0.1857256889,
0.5530441999,
0.6787418723,
-0.4281328022,
0.6745564938,
-0.2092492431,
0.0166259147,
0.2605723441,
-0.967689395,
-0.8993118405,
-0.584400773,
-0.0726720318,
0.0219912771,
0.287317574,
0.5952414274,
0.6522772312,
-0.5315520167,
-0.4294453263,
-0.0157100838,
0.1984347552,
-0.0146045359,
-0.0904042199,
0.3795892,
-0.3122557998,
-0.3100973368,
0.9480233788,
0.4035805166,
0.0075613256,
-0.2071045935,
-0.0973109826,
0.0672992095,
-0.359123677,
0.4468131959,
0.4429109991,
-0.387444824,
-0.1554486603,
-0.2933319211,
0.3605448604,
0.0259350166,
1.0562628508,
-1.0344237089,
0.2422992736,
0.1844433546,
0.4178254008,
0.6006762385,
-0.2148375213,
0.7040290833,
-1.2748205662,
0.4172371626,
-0.2559169233,
0.6376337409,
0.030258812,
-0.2520836294,
0.8653252721,
0.2398796976,
-0.3640062213,
-1.0831679106,
0.1269314736,
-0.5164778829,
-0.5478879809,
0.6997793913,
-0.4110655189,
-0.0376339369,
-0.4772238433,
0.1723840684,
0.6471950412,
-0.2172014117,
0.7592760921,
0.5317720771,
0.0202552453,
-0.085955441,
-0.3440250158,
0.4225986898,
0.2548312247,
-1.0031911135,
0.4416455925,
0.6769240499,
0.4245287776,
-0.3925022483,
0.3734590709,
-0.3851972818,
0.0970957503,
0.0734380707,
0.0876462907,
-0.4786533117,
-0.9275314212,
-0.2526646554,
0.4290727377,
-0.453111589,
0.045103848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16807v1
|
Beyond Thumbs Up/Down: Untangling Challenges of Fine-Grained Feedback for Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-06-24T17:19:34 | 2024-06-24T17:19:34 |
Katherine M. Collins, Najoung Kim, Yonatan Bitton, Verena Rieser, Shayegan Omidshafiei, Yushi Hu, Sherol Chen, Senjuti Dutta, Minsuk Chang, Kimin Lee, Youwei Liang, Georgina Evans, Sahil Singla, Gang Li, Adrian Weller, Junfeng He, Deepak Ramachandran, Krishnamurthy Dj Dvijotham
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Human feedback plays a critical role in learning and refining reward models
for text-to-image generation, but the optimal form the feedback should take for
learning an accurate reward function has not been conclusively established.
This paper investigates the effectiveness of fine-grained feedback which
captures nuanced distinctions in image quality and prompt-alignment, compared
to traditional coarse-grained feedback (for example, thumbs up/down or ranking
between a set of options). While fine-grained feedback holds promise,
particularly for systems catering to diverse societal preferences, we show that
demonstrating its superiority to coarse-grained feedback is not automatic.
Through experiments on real and synthetic preference data, we surface the
complexities of building effective models due to the interplay of model choice,
feedback type, and the alignment between human judgment and computational
interpretation. We identify key challenges in eliciting and utilizing
fine-grained feedback, prompting a reassessment of its assumed benefits and
practicality. Our findings -- e.g., that fine-grained feedback can lead to
worse models for a fixed budget, in some settings; however, in controlled
settings with known attributes, fine grained rewards can indeed be more helpful
-- call for careful consideration of feedback attributes and potentially beckon
novel modeling approaches to appropriately unlock the potential value of
fine-grained feedback in-the-wild.
|
[
-0.5468578339,
-0.5102263093,
0.7475861907,
-0.2090534121,
-0.1613925695,
0.0413386673,
-0.4219896197,
-0.5404345989,
-0.1699531674,
0.2660206854,
-0.5121253729,
-0.2235433459,
-0.7560861111,
-0.0364185199,
-0.2239442319,
1.2503089905,
0.03896657,
0.0763912126,
-0.4288606048,
0.1864634752,
-0.3669653237,
-0.486323148,
-0.8568161726,
-0.6040011644,
0.8166889548,
0.7296994925,
0.9984759092,
0.521756947,
0.6846596003,
0.233815968,
0.0614688545,
0.342232883,
-0.5407619476,
-0.2820583582,
-0.3094813228,
-0.4520093501,
-0.2400798202,
0.1795006692,
0.2264149487,
0.5539176464,
0.150387466,
0.2127922177,
0.5040969849,
0.9758192301,
-0.8221819997,
-0.0509228297,
-0.3978447914,
0.1409559697,
-0.167244643,
-0.4951998293,
-0.3404276073,
-0.4636569917,
0.0632744133,
-0.4982337058,
0.2351190299,
-0.2908501029,
1.0304763317,
0.299695611,
-0.1630640328,
-0.5666999817,
-0.9223806262,
0.8882049322,
-0.4490678608,
-0.0190516766,
0.3159052432,
0.3030492067,
0.0192631185,
-0.6241742373,
-0.2311864346,
-0.3830485046,
0.0602931231,
0.1161505282,
-0.024807319,
0.0039915997,
-0.0786130652,
0.5110976696,
0.2882923186,
0.3129267395,
-0.109167695,
-0.0857941508,
0.6161696315,
0.1179777831,
0.1791443974,
-0.3948783576,
-0.2908700407,
-0.3962534666,
-0.4850136638,
0.855720818,
0.365876019,
0.5323637724,
-0.0282802712,
0.6266932487,
-0.2812967002,
0.6013171673,
0.5533205271,
0.032639116,
-0.2646045983,
-0.1858376861,
0.0922843665,
-0.1812452972,
0.7051514387,
0.9873381257,
0.1646563411,
-0.1426596195,
-0.5432060361,
0.3157014549,
0.4187699258,
-0.8413327932,
-0.1603731811,
0.062193729,
-0.7043167949,
-0.8947200179,
0.1705698669,
-0.9038571119,
-0.6110163331,
-0.5844591856,
0.6563868523,
-0.1419104934,
0.1079778373,
-0.0081285313,
-0.3627355397,
0.169857204,
0.6568520069,
-1.2197152376,
0.1567287594,
0.6308178306,
0.778182447,
-0.1005622447,
-0.1236237139,
-0.5570449829,
-0.3511807323,
-0.3449503183,
1.25867486,
-0.7810229063,
-0.4172571599,
-0.1946763247,
-0.1626290679,
0.3759019673,
-0.5608680844,
0.4285597205,
-0.1816775054,
-0.0168655589,
-0.6414402127,
-0.32534495,
0.1970553249,
0.3362818956,
-0.485172987,
0.8491529226,
0.0494599752,
-0.7037324905,
0.5788184404,
-0.4884934723,
-0.0786489621,
-0.0279158633,
-0.4164678454,
-0.1482602358,
0.5348925591,
0.2259418219,
0.5548011661,
-0.4702589512,
0.3662862778,
-0.5469065905,
-0.1851062775,
0.3200181723,
-0.5842353106,
0.1844733506,
0.2868304849,
-0.5278981328,
0.0930192024,
-0.7067455053,
0.0580246411,
0.2567251325,
-0.3760821521,
-0.1573320776,
0.1810112894,
0.2256493419,
0.1152055413,
0.206207782,
-0.566814363,
0.2831661105,
0.0107260281,
0.644755125,
0.9471369982,
-0.3161966205,
0.6805002689,
-0.6154107451,
0.272837013,
-0.1411581933,
0.1557280719,
-0.2929295599,
-0.198993817,
-0.5499464273,
0.1897637397,
0.6521893144,
0.2268677801,
-0.6317889094,
-0.0671768486,
-0.0469102971,
-0.4754715264,
-0.5579692125,
-0.0164010152,
0.5238729119,
0.4313207865,
0.1653331965,
-0.748370707,
0.08154919,
-0.6563521624,
-0.1196193397,
-0.0309441164,
-0.3116549253,
0.5283287764,
0.2480319738,
-0.0115975747,
0.9803396463,
-0.6375675797,
-0.2858014703,
0.0653467551,
0.5193909407,
-0.3389467299,
0.5495496988,
0.4888667762,
-0.6961438656,
-0.0368540958,
0.2547830641,
-0.2310952097,
-0.0327289626,
-0.3913803697,
0.0577369593,
0.1577868611,
0.2209224403,
-0.3741001487,
0.4208913743,
0.4431048632,
-0.3791896701,
0.7322934866,
-0.3379549384,
0.6331077218,
-0.8248009682,
0.1138366237,
0.1998015344,
-0.3002010584,
-0.2389432639,
0.2382877916,
-0.0083838142,
-0.0399858095,
-0.3466940522,
0.3859829605,
-0.0620004125,
-0.0984137654,
-0.486106962,
-0.1809053123,
0.1984073222,
0.5543593764,
0.2168855518,
0.6570050716,
0.3767382801,
-0.6364874244,
0.3135768175,
-0.0008748012,
-0.2010606378,
1.015088439,
-0.7101348042,
0.1790171415,
-0.1272221357,
0.1782143563,
-0.9997525215,
-0.6117911935,
-0.0184172485,
-0.6704616547,
0.4085838497,
0.0732018724,
-0.3519377112,
-0.3562355936,
-0.5681971312,
0.349146992,
0.4399944842,
-0.7340152264,
0.2042642087,
0.4533664584,
-0.0754257813,
-0.245848,
-0.6012810469,
0.1175221354,
0.0194340982,
-0.5617706776,
0.4662669003,
-0.0135763455,
-0.0939475968,
-0.1231333688,
-0.0664164573,
0.0820708424,
0.026337428,
0.1549856514,
0.1893884391,
0.1599635929,
0.1311147809,
-0.0355040915,
-0.271412462,
-0.042681206,
-0.2885037363,
0.4084754288,
-0.3368487358,
-0.3112286329,
-0.3794130087,
0.3823120296,
0.4256654382,
-0.0303099863,
-0.0477638692,
0.5267179012,
-0.2103761733,
0.0837702155,
-0.2652467787,
-0.4665217102,
-0.4812773168,
0.1522568315,
-0.073131524,
-1.0179909468,
0.4480882287,
-0.3786951303,
0.199761644,
0.3636553288,
0.5320491195,
-0.399196893,
1.3981026411,
0.5671795011,
0.2417271733,
0.4048845172,
-0.2976194918,
-0.1610543877,
-0.6272185445,
-0.3779658377,
-0.6206761599,
-0.6174873114,
-0.6038726568,
-0.2449712902,
0.0958170593,
0.0777829438,
-0.1162070855,
-0.0527110174,
-0.8327579498,
0.5872003436,
0.6476060748,
0.448246479,
0.2814834118,
-0.0445555262,
0.0705171227,
-0.0337258428,
-0.5068172812,
-0.7300137281,
0.7134022713,
0.3236200213,
1.1663818359,
-0.4042756259,
0.682387352,
0.4189641178,
0.0722824335,
-1.0131251812,
0.3414434195,
-0.613078475,
-0.2971205115,
-0.1548451632,
-0.3098897338,
-0.9005836248,
-0.2117178887,
-0.4014924765,
-0.7245440483,
0.3857145905,
0.7234309912,
-0.8966219425,
0.4040184021,
-0.885885179,
0.8352084756,
-0.3265086114,
-0.6539919972,
-0.0334037542,
-0.8069303632,
0.0632047355,
0.1599960625,
0.2307628542,
0.0954723433,
0.3599315882,
0.4154761732,
-0.4491558373,
1.0395556688,
-0.0978767201,
-0.2426653504,
0.1449387372,
0.047388088,
0.2971646786,
0.0859155729,
0.2972893119,
0.0222181156,
0.1952529699,
-0.3743074536,
-0.6436775923,
0.7483793497,
-0.8630779982,
-0.4182025194,
0.0355419554,
-0.4338750541,
-0.1457507759,
0.0871337354,
0.6982654333,
0.9529429078,
0.0065327943,
0.2045760006,
0.4813570976,
-0.1349205524,
0.5107543468,
-0.1137548164,
-0.274617672,
-0.4216363728,
1.2175072432,
0.018728666,
0.4568993151,
0.3484944701,
0.3489973545,
-0.1788993627,
-0.3106316626,
-0.6908661127,
-0.2684815824,
-0.6175139546,
-0.3671330512,
-0.1746946126,
0.0367380269,
-0.0651728958,
-0.6741307378,
-0.8051491976,
-0.5002049804,
-0.6101895571,
0.1866788268,
0.0541157126,
0.9913527369,
-0.0678664669,
0.2346210033,
-0.9684206247,
0.2470994741,
0.5326383114,
0.6896839142,
0.3279670775,
-0.3032482862,
-0.2297725379,
0.3043938577,
-0.8431296945,
-0.562790215,
0.1521388143,
-0.0821674094,
-0.1017726213,
0.5261013508,
0.1036737636,
0.6990488768,
-0.3541772664,
0.9948351979,
0.3623069525,
-0.8964820504,
0.4965645969,
-0.3391477764,
0.561470747,
0.7024561167,
0.1255251467,
-0.3522966504,
-0.4238724411,
-0.5478034019,
-0.829665184,
0.7773367763,
0.0861789808,
0.2320942581,
0.103008464,
0.4831908941,
0.4549324214,
0.1805588305,
-0.710070312,
0.144277066,
-0.4194094241,
0.0836222321,
-0.0216682255,
-0.1484371424,
-0.112555474,
-0.318857789,
0.2390854061,
-0.2345002443,
0.2025334239,
0.3949868083,
0.1913489848,
-0.4709301889,
0.5395106077,
0.4848778248,
0.266556561,
-0.2170234472,
0.3070842326,
-0.3521388471,
-0.1996021867,
0.2608708441,
-0.1281802952,
-0.3054091036,
-0.2936103344,
0.0040235426,
1.0595109463,
0.4528720379,
-0.2735067904,
0.3255957663,
-0.057682842,
-0.368966639,
0.2459453642,
0.0919998735,
-0.2518770695,
0.1052568853,
0.2327513695,
0.6937536597,
0.2987068594,
-0.5951880813,
0.0189027078,
0.6744765043,
-0.6666731834,
-0.459204644,
0.623781383,
0.513291955,
-0.394357115,
0.212863937,
-0.1444791108,
-0.2452002317,
0.6256546378,
0.4184812307,
0.7169220448,
0.236232698,
0.7071582079,
0.2000629753,
-0.0385222733,
-0.3230716288,
-0.0445861742,
-0.3390832245,
-0.6462231874,
-0.3214344382,
-0.4835955799,
-0.6420919299,
-0.0397365801,
-0.9234925508,
0.2975363731,
-0.3743302226,
-0.6883241534,
0.4578733444,
-0.0736108199,
-0.6048877239,
0.2800866663,
0.4588325024,
0.6620944738,
-0.6496508718,
0.4181135297,
0.9376922846,
-0.4133082628,
-1.0920684338,
-0.0056102034,
0.0540146641,
-0.5554961562,
0.4006021917,
0.5180490613,
-0.3380974233,
0.1982038319,
-0.9185873866,
-0.5850159526,
0.8205780983,
0.3643400967,
-0.3932974935,
-0.1635920256,
0.167451039,
0.4214570224,
-0.2736301124,
0.4557008743,
0.6441054344,
0.4935668409,
0.4859805405,
-0.7714579105,
-0.1141549051,
-0.2509360909,
0.3656821251,
0.4055573046,
-0.8049539924,
0.5498159528,
-0.4828319848,
-0.2336004227,
0.1923499852,
0.3029190004,
0.0797667205,
0.6229589581,
0.4798074365,
0.6642446518,
0.4708166718,
-0.2207563072,
1.3833355904,
0.0754299611,
0.480902195,
0.7437611222,
0.073837027,
0.719130218,
0.7506822348,
-0.2049975544,
0.3795095384,
0.9753936529,
0.0201107878,
0.6917920709,
-0.0677077696,
0.1902376413,
-0.4545236826,
-0.3783074915,
-0.2151038796,
0.3752887547,
-0.0183271784,
-0.1601990014,
-0.5352079272,
0.0688867196,
-0.3471308649,
0.1796590537,
-0.6810868979,
0.8251525164,
-0.0103302784,
-1.0120626688,
0.3666687906,
-0.1473798603,
0.9971857071,
-0.3422218561,
-0.0831683278,
-0.1661500782,
0.169746995,
-0.4560984969,
-1.0259544849,
0.1605699211,
0.1841258258,
-0.5842101574,
-0.173103556,
0.7533735633,
-0.2262594104,
-0.3522602618,
-0.0480044037,
-0.1292976886,
-0.2580130398,
-0.1148123816,
-0.4925666451,
0.0618797652,
0.0596827269,
-0.2114530951,
0.5706989169,
0.3407893777,
-0.0336573906,
0.3756075501,
0.6632136106,
-0.0583283901,
-0.3312896192,
0.0184224267,
0.8708472848,
-0.6487001181,
-0.5191767812,
-0.9380505085,
0.6739861965,
0.0108257104,
-0.3349559605,
0.3534291089,
0.0721812695,
1.0445172787,
-0.2835663259,
0.6499508619,
-0.0627698898,
0.0298922155,
-0.5654557943,
0.5655167103,
-0.7565503716,
0.1327455938,
-0.4357913136,
-0.6462652683,
-0.2081488967,
0.3892026544,
-0.2674673498,
0.0512134023,
0.5231255293,
0.5550751686,
0.0608525798,
0.1941805631,
0.1357658505,
-0.2498010546,
0.2779535651,
0.522004962,
1.1412043571,
-0.0667498708,
0.4606121778,
-0.508577764,
-0.4755262733,
-0.21011509,
-1.0499969721,
-0.4894380569,
-0.6129170656,
-0.204788968,
-0.2078054249,
-0.2732709944,
1.0609368086,
0.7623762488,
-0.7880316377,
-0.1541631967,
-0.4163645208,
-0.1084403619,
-0.0973943174,
-0.2846876681,
0.1749381423,
-0.6327189207,
-0.7561389804,
-0.3590535522,
0.4300482869,
0.2248051763,
-0.1025140435,
-0.1385532469,
0.3860881031,
0.2786721885,
0.6189343333,
0.4161186218,
-0.705956459,
-0.37578246,
-0.0102945389,
-0.3186876774,
0.2683481276,
1.0345544815,
-0.6934159994,
0.5108203292,
0.3717621863,
0.718767643,
0.1995891035,
0.1703189909,
0.6275803447,
-0.6520783305,
-0.0421625748,
-0.0074184122,
0.101350002,
0.5616839528,
-0.5566812158,
0.1131957173,
0.0363283791,
-0.9851595163,
-0.7140186429,
0.2929914594,
-0.9986690283,
-0.2919962704,
1.0380154848,
0.1005247235,
-0.1745243967,
0.4550857842,
-0.7588861585,
0.0878492221,
-0.5989524126,
1.2744128704,
0.7935287356,
-0.1681302488,
-0.0830710158,
-0.0724822134,
0.7163169384,
0.5987386107,
-0.892308116,
0.0863316879,
0.767428875,
-0.1635371447,
0.3035971522,
0.5068214536,
-0.2937318981,
0.5371747613,
-0.3165981174,
-0.0004542842,
-0.0743307024,
-0.4203917086,
-0.5502995253,
0.2343770713,
0.4245301187,
-0.1714611202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16801v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16801v2
|
RES-Q: Evaluating Code-Editing Large Language Model Systems at the Repository Scale
| 2024-06-24T17:08:17 | 2024-06-25T18:04:23 |
Beck LaBash, August Rosedale, Alex Reents, Lucas Negritto, Colin Wiel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The instruction-following ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) has
cultivated a class of LLM-based systems capable of approaching complex tasks
such as making edits to large code repositories. Due to the high sensitivity
and unpredictability of LLM behavior in response to changes in prompting,
robust evaluation tools are needed to drive future iteration of these systems.
We propose RES-Q, a natural language instruction-based benchmark for evaluating
$\textbf{R}$epository $\textbf{E}$diting $\textbf{S}$ystems, which consists of
100 handcrafted repository editing tasks derived from real GitHub commits.
Given an edit instruction and a code repository, RES-Q evaluates an LLM
system's ability to interpret the instruction, navigate the repository to
gather relevant information, and construct an appropriate edit that satisfies
the specified criteria. We argue that evaluating LLMs in this way addresses
issues with traditional benchmarks and provides a more holistic assessment of a
model's abilities. We evaluate various state-of-the-art LLMs as language agents
in a repository-editing system built on Qurrent OS, our language agent
development software. Despite their 1% pass@1 performance difference on
HumanEval, we find Claude Sonnet 3.5 outperforms GPT-4o by 12% pass@1 on RES-Q,
indicating RES-Q's capacity to differentiate model capability as traditional
benchmarks approach saturation. We further investigate token efficiency,
performance relationships with existing benchmarks, and interesting disparities
between closed and open-source LLMs. Code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/Qurrent-AI/RES-Q.
|
[
-0.1948750019,
-0.5765340924,
0.3894820809,
-0.0675147846,
0.1152303517,
0.2557177842,
-0.5971317887,
-0.2464982122,
-0.0596518181,
0.4214032292,
-0.2625732422,
-0.5001470447,
-0.3967084885,
0.4832214117,
-0.3140445352,
0.6648202538,
-0.1276766062,
0.1267125607,
-0.2696673274,
-0.2713719904,
-0.4492915869,
-0.4072969556,
-0.3232572973,
-0.1443506926,
0.4003790915,
0.3026026785,
0.7036584616,
0.6055415869,
0.6260142326,
0.3707966506,
-0.1519608796,
0.0893403292,
-0.6751042604,
0.3698478937,
-0.381093502,
-0.4249348342,
-0.6090237498,
-0.1518803537,
0.8340723515,
0.1412669122,
-0.0125786737,
0.4323823452,
-0.0322614089,
1.0127606392,
-0.8437097669,
0.1007886454,
-0.536177516,
-0.1871448159,
-0.0058274874,
-0.0716753677,
-0.5727968812,
-0.6391715407,
-0.0018700515,
-0.4535464048,
-0.2097130865,
-0.0169654321,
0.6819517016,
0.4167346656,
-0.0184653401,
-0.2714034021,
-0.575475812,
0.7156015038,
-0.5586592555,
0.7318279147,
0.2014408708,
0.3951781988,
-0.2371958345,
-0.888264358,
-0.3654071093,
-0.3882583976,
0.1808926165,
-0.029646121,
-0.4974222779,
0.1246149093,
0.4300473332,
0.4178686738,
-0.4064450264,
-0.0422547609,
-0.225412339,
-0.217665419,
0.2833434939,
0.2103645951,
0.350281924,
-0.1402050257,
-0.2164089978,
-0.1774354875,
-0.7421011329,
-0.0289284084,
0.2537668943,
0.2528867126,
0.0808267668,
0.6141593456,
-0.3555204272,
0.7569596171,
-0.1607128382,
0.0891044214,
0.1130852178,
-0.2591972947,
-0.3399415612,
-0.2395603061,
0.6623943448,
0.4111842215,
0.3858475685,
-0.3084692359,
-0.7649797201,
-0.0905360356,
0.450509429,
-0.8800752163,
-0.1871491522,
0.1025293618,
-0.3582640588,
-0.0942235216,
0.0017430563,
-0.612564683,
-0.561226666,
-0.3480134904,
0.5399338007,
-0.4652118087,
0.0061345659,
0.0906217545,
-0.0832118392,
0.2548598647,
0.3729960918,
-0.4448710382,
0.3732378185,
0.8900817037,
0.8221020103,
0.1025547385,
-0.4362721145,
-0.7242541909,
-0.2084556371,
-0.2759063542,
0.8312674165,
-0.8088574409,
-0.2240346074,
-0.1278382689,
0.0182047449,
-0.0580967218,
-0.6272958517,
0.4638880491,
-0.8572886586,
-0.1320538521,
-0.222519204,
-0.7510166168,
0.0039344523,
0.389724344,
-0.7619249225,
0.8702302575,
0.6271455288,
-0.695561111,
0.0957650691,
-0.5931485295,
-0.0104712918,
0.0631156564,
0.0455058627,
-0.1363295317,
0.028861139,
0.0431032367,
0.0463870056,
-0.5674751401,
0.130249545,
-0.0902133659,
-0.801502943,
0.4768964052,
-0.3353360891,
0.5252712965,
0.1498446912,
-0.1693921685,
0.2951570749,
-0.5308294296,
0.2042558938,
-0.0356434062,
-0.4735019207,
-0.2989053428,
-0.242223382,
-0.2607307434,
-0.1973052174,
0.3667034507,
-0.3875524998,
0.4272741973,
-0.1946758032,
0.5811493397,
0.7767127156,
0.101124458,
0.3845738769,
-0.5346409082,
0.9034776092,
-0.6213108301,
0.2831403017,
-0.2710162699,
-0.1628418267,
-0.6103998423,
-0.496118784,
0.7674925923,
0.4884291887,
-0.7723307014,
0.1195580065,
-0.4791065156,
-0.5532407761,
-0.7566533685,
0.0499149337,
0.7829232812,
0.1460586041,
0.3577505052,
-0.2224694788,
-0.4810018539,
-0.9725143909,
-0.6596890688,
-0.3444373012,
-0.0212241001,
0.2574564517,
0.5080178976,
-0.2735739052,
0.7921482921,
-0.1917289346,
0.248111397,
-0.0273745637,
-0.031418521,
-0.0108320657,
0.2373064309,
0.2784473598,
-0.3426662385,
-0.2945570946,
-0.0845727995,
-0.5210175514,
-0.3865818977,
0.0441782884,
-0.1716724634,
0.2424064428,
0.396677494,
-0.4235946238,
0.2394405603,
0.4559758008,
-0.2188813984,
0.687284708,
-0.3227696419,
0.58599931,
-0.6754809022,
0.0946824849,
-0.0433749296,
-0.1699272543,
-0.5456289649,
0.5246036649,
0.5254124403,
-0.0184318703,
-0.4495925307,
0.412772119,
-0.5752205253,
-0.5888934731,
-0.1114431992,
0.3040824831,
0.2109337002,
0.407610476,
-0.2692945004,
1.0305132866,
0.1427128166,
-0.3349804878,
0.4599989951,
0.029242212,
-0.6131613255,
0.3672628701,
-0.7204049826,
0.4728872478,
0.362462908,
0.1850413084,
-0.7097768188,
0.0468887351,
0.2076061219,
-0.3815358877,
0.1488785595,
-0.374741286,
-0.6932333112,
-0.1327267289,
-0.4418787062,
0.4051261246,
0.4436537325,
-0.3232477307,
0.3747680485,
0.1779999435,
-0.1595299244,
-0.6100885272,
-0.4819175005,
0.3271238804,
0.0804642811,
-0.4946484566,
0.1636687815,
0.0430495329,
-0.5297814012,
0.1733016223,
-0.0325431451,
-0.0675655529,
0.139447853,
0.1502278596,
0.3111436963,
-0.3250133693,
0.1904336512,
-0.0553351529,
-0.0581831448,
0.1075457111,
0.0199613813,
0.3370932341,
-0.5563831925,
-0.5375599265,
-0.5538085699,
-0.3297002614,
1.0193969011,
-0.4793369174,
0.4401651621,
0.0178150088,
-0.3487949371,
-0.0510186367,
-0.487914443,
-0.0975974798,
-0.3845997453,
0.4132294059,
-0.4403884411,
-0.8313088417,
0.5344743729,
-0.1389401108,
0.2297768146,
0.1983152926,
0.413336575,
0.3819912374,
0.5311330557,
0.2808426619,
0.1163188517,
0.5209131241,
-0.2079907954,
0.0015315255,
-1.10752213,
0.0411139578,
-0.8097822666,
-0.3558295965,
-0.6733400226,
-0.8372371793,
0.1882859617,
0.2482509613,
-0.5159719586,
0.5546550155,
-0.5320141912,
0.5770936608,
0.3696136177,
0.0032136897,
0.515319109,
-0.3900429904,
0.0236019827,
0.0269085113,
-0.635463953,
-0.847622931,
1.108022809,
0.6245353222,
0.8544788957,
0.1545121521,
0.6786806583,
0.5703182817,
0.7207930684,
-0.7274978757,
0.6082941294,
0.0653180853,
-0.2846566439,
-0.5575943589,
-0.4236050248,
-0.6223759651,
0.353972584,
-0.1543733627,
-0.4403012097,
0.1382884085,
-0.0921835601,
-0.2456256151,
0.3847461641,
-0.8901407123,
0.9310756326,
-0.0497731119,
-0.3993323147,
-0.2744393647,
-0.1445833296,
0.23368828,
-0.087266095,
0.2444667518,
0.0943607539,
-0.4116530418,
0.400223732,
-0.3417801261,
0.4596508443,
-0.2038489729,
-0.0815366805,
0.4152094722,
0.4957411885,
0.5798675418,
0.0210210923,
-0.4754933417,
-0.0529713854,
0.2182168365,
-0.353821367,
-0.82307446,
0.6530939341,
-0.717657268,
-0.5885403752,
-0.1372558177,
-0.3662678897,
-0.1422825009,
-0.0006428222,
-0.1833603382,
0.76978755,
-0.3631115258,
0.3993239403,
0.4440738261,
-0.5486949086,
0.0863321349,
0.7339317203,
-0.4377186,
-0.4585953653,
0.8488003612,
0.139315933,
0.4669078588,
0.3490982354,
0.2271223068,
-0.3161831796,
-0.5708902478,
-0.7364399433,
0.1127401665,
-0.7330147624,
-0.427151531,
-0.4603687227,
-0.1352156848,
-0.1861245334,
-0.1396946311,
-0.424294889,
-0.245387122,
0.0779199749,
0.224491626,
0.4338620901,
0.9849509001,
0.2788216472,
-0.2117928118,
-1.1034712791,
0.1508553326,
0.2889767289,
0.5941258073,
0.0519230515,
-0.9999101162,
-0.3322542906,
0.0111613898,
-0.118731685,
-0.7898625135,
0.1386974305,
-0.0168728847,
0.5079731941,
-0.1039850041,
0.3895007372,
0.496946305,
-0.3958077729,
0.593091011,
-0.2565978169,
-1.1406878233,
0.414180398,
-0.2062278241,
0.4977070093,
0.6009219289,
0.015790116,
-0.6439136863,
-0.7295327187,
-0.3171607554,
-0.3633683026,
0.7028722167,
0.0935639217,
-0.0122924969,
-0.100892134,
0.4474226236,
-0.0271934047,
0.1201596186,
-0.4279221594,
0.0710077137,
0.0349746495,
0.1962350905,
0.3229629099,
-0.3358010948,
0.1907947809,
-0.0026979246,
0.4839324951,
0.0004994988,
0.047258582,
0.2560446858,
-0.3579008579,
-0.2872655392,
0.6913231015,
0.6751875877,
0.9771353602,
-0.3160337806,
-0.0766824707,
0.2915660739,
-0.3786916137,
0.0260646325,
-0.1381131113,
-0.0640566871,
-0.265573144,
0.6094284058,
0.6730889678,
0.4908457994,
-1.1283284426,
0.4223898053,
-0.3733533323,
-0.1076543182,
0.0505905747,
0.1795973629,
0.0897538885,
0.5188792348,
0.1955325305,
-0.0652235448,
0.0760847777,
-0.5304869413,
0.1192164049,
0.039103061,
-0.4833119214,
-0.2764200866,
0.1338309199,
0.289737463,
-0.7741223574,
0.7362645268,
-0.2997918129,
-0.5985509753,
0.6992385983,
0.2536702752,
1.092543602,
-0.1119388193,
0.0040342752,
0.3541990221,
0.4606819153,
0.0068853679,
0.1712648869,
0.1021630764,
-0.5663549304,
-0.560654223,
-0.4326935709,
-0.7262305021,
0.0232419614,
-0.8312804103,
0.2209415436,
-0.4615682364,
-0.1905254871,
-0.2261907458,
0.0894543082,
-0.4832175076,
-0.1848848015,
-0.2734667957,
1.1632652283,
-0.4904907048,
0.7868978381,
0.9980993271,
-0.170007199,
-0.5784544349,
0.0988681838,
-0.1088386178,
-0.6324118972,
0.6375501752,
0.0450051725,
-0.2205438018,
-0.0821764767,
-0.3304612637,
-0.5403226018,
1.1645052433,
0.5583078265,
-0.94648242,
0.2455198467,
-0.3000113666,
0.8142071962,
-0.3201271594,
0.5338231921,
0.7523411512,
0.4217377007,
-0.2877475917,
-0.962862432,
0.0914349705,
-0.2304331511,
0.0644662604,
0.3992885351,
-0.6719580889,
0.7422004938,
-0.2960980833,
-0.2676653862,
0.1966933012,
0.3997170627,
0.4322291017,
0.0880937651,
0.5636399388,
0.5754448175,
0.6242364049,
0.0099160234,
1.1423678398,
-0.7131652236,
0.3550831974,
1.125639677,
-0.4359823763,
1.0845627785,
0.312235117,
-0.438885957,
0.4171555042,
0.4020993412,
0.2218137681,
0.1595139056,
0.6331466436,
-0.2136346251,
-0.0988452137,
-0.1139043272,
-0.3147710264,
0.2845440209,
0.1851539463,
-0.1895907819,
-0.0656296536,
-0.1837202311,
-0.2574585974,
0.4308559895,
-0.1779713929,
0.623939693,
-0.1187926382,
-0.5652870536,
0.7039776444,
0.0750014633,
0.2824814618,
-0.2283386439,
-0.2680034339,
-0.3443930447,
-0.0488660932,
0.0555603355,
-0.9095864296,
0.1182144433,
0.5643537641,
-0.1425464898,
-0.2855043113,
0.5916948915,
-0.0480657667,
-0.033937633,
0.4140935242,
0.5494886041,
0.1919474006,
-0.0275558308,
-0.8926402926,
0.5902833343,
-0.0161122289,
-0.5154826045,
0.4875342846,
0.73351717,
-0.0532056093,
0.8798272014,
0.3640381694,
0.1145961806,
-0.3568095267,
0.3203337193,
0.914078176,
-0.6891591549,
-0.1060251966,
-0.7228863835,
0.1679287851,
0.1701976806,
-0.3208160698,
0.4275032878,
0.528175354,
0.8683280945,
0.0839728341,
0.5711916685,
0.0174680948,
0.6044856906,
-0.5162093043,
0.5363940001,
-0.3309657872,
0.575145185,
-0.171122238,
-1.11898458,
0.0920255482,
0.4033218324,
-0.5273989439,
0.0651022568,
0.6066868901,
1.0921953917,
0.3695625365,
0.0651517287,
0.4274667203,
0.185144946,
0.1367812604,
0.441642195,
1.3089137077,
-0.5054269433,
0.4368838072,
-0.1415397078,
-0.2019437402,
-0.2861532271,
-0.732355237,
-0.6880527735,
-0.3854868412,
-0.2619353533,
-0.3311259449,
0.3681031168,
1.1678309441,
0.2391374111,
-0.7128629088,
-0.2078340203,
0.1018409654,
0.2949372828,
-0.1422310621,
-0.2043801099,
0.2887791097,
-0.383992523,
-0.7869693041,
0.434145391,
0.504612565,
-0.2499879599,
-0.4852978885,
-0.2673491538,
0.0085224407,
-0.0159683675,
0.4349220991,
0.2915319502,
-0.7948876023,
-0.4871416092,
0.2734376788,
-0.6205653548,
-0.1243755817,
0.8197740912,
-0.7447342277,
0.6413567662,
0.642757237,
0.9668921828,
-0.1608525515,
0.1714928895,
0.6195908785,
-0.1769763827,
-0.3190053105,
0.3583876789,
0.2419868708,
0.2959923446,
-0.0618243366,
0.5649974346,
-0.019660065,
-0.9336884022,
-1.0260640383,
-0.1726979315,
-0.4948068857,
-0.1894491762,
1.0317332745,
-0.4355254173,
-0.3060846329,
0.0175921582,
-0.1936989129,
0.256629765,
-0.4608976543,
0.6228829026,
0.7199103236,
0.0805680752,
-0.307985127,
-0.7641676664,
0.2117510885,
0.2272081822,
-0.6611892581,
0.417090863,
0.6805853844,
0.1305452138,
-0.1355685294,
0.4851568937,
-0.1984978467,
0.5648459792,
-0.0151564181,
0.4585421383,
-0.1840597987,
-0.2881323695,
-0.636824429,
-0.111230284,
0.5640315413,
0.0320340544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16797v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16797v2
|
Lottery Ticket Adaptation: Mitigating Destructive Interference in LLMs
| 2024-06-24T16:58:23 | 2024-06-25T13:46:41 |
Ashwinee Panda, Berivan Isik, Xiangyu Qi, Sanmi Koyejo, Tsachy Weissman, Prateek Mittal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Existing methods for adapting large language models (LLMs) to new tasks are
not suited to multi-task adaptation because they modify all the model weights
-- causing destructive interference between tasks. The resulting effects, such
as catastrophic forgetting of earlier tasks, make it challenging to obtain good
performance on multiple tasks at the same time. To mitigate this, we propose
Lottery Ticket Adaptation (LoTA), a sparse adaptation method that identifies
and optimizes only a sparse subnetwork of the model. We evaluate LoTA on a wide
range of challenging tasks such as instruction following, reasoning, math, and
summarization. LoTA obtains better performance than full fine-tuning and
low-rank adaptation (LoRA), and maintains good performance even after training
on other tasks -- thus, avoiding catastrophic forgetting. By extracting and
fine-tuning over lottery tickets (or sparse task vectors), LoTA also enables
model merging over highly dissimilar tasks. Our code is made publicly available
at https://github.com/kiddyboots216/lottery-ticket-adaptation.
|
[
-0.1192591041,
-0.6123428941,
0.0818960145,
0.6122119427,
-0.4184988439,
0.0449315608,
-0.1135568991,
-0.4481160939,
0.3026957512,
0.7938585877,
-0.5166290998,
-0.0640139803,
-0.7088145614,
-0.0831298158,
-0.3169138134,
1.0765917301,
-0.0097662518,
0.1700284034,
-0.3736456931,
0.0374101065,
-0.693734169,
-0.3909570575,
-0.9483088255,
-0.2438138723,
0.6135796309,
0.3133734763,
0.3202407956,
0.2518863976,
0.6944242716,
0.4130398333,
0.0747175664,
0.3541107774,
-0.9637644887,
0.0943055078,
-0.4024999738,
-0.7050399184,
-0.3538883626,
-0.2307130545,
0.5832071304,
0.6606298089,
-0.0835826471,
0.16042988,
0.4740834236,
0.6740801334,
-0.7474286556,
0.2245336622,
-0.9662810564,
0.0967127085,
-0.0355889276,
-0.7719753981,
-0.3494203091,
-0.27502653,
-0.2844670415,
-0.8833045959,
-0.0226034634,
-0.0019305907,
0.672876358,
0.5696268082,
-0.1439981461,
-0.3558523953,
-0.9516474009,
0.6704694033,
-0.3521393239,
-0.0084856041,
0.4109006822,
0.0926568285,
-0.6278999448,
-0.0131522296,
-0.462556839,
-0.0670121908,
0.454952091,
0.2625598013,
-0.291215837,
0.1102291271,
0.2221377045,
-0.1305874586,
-0.4093151689,
0.1185476854,
-0.3954077065,
-0.0922600478,
0.5783862472,
0.1821145862,
0.1772115827,
-0.1139262542,
-0.2926953733,
0.0198903419,
-0.709168613,
0.0056500179,
0.3929403722,
0.3552697599,
-0.0816515237,
0.4335331023,
-0.1285354495,
0.7101830244,
0.3196756542,
-0.3898281455,
0.0622774065,
-0.360966295,
-0.1847529113,
-0.1077266783,
0.4186262488,
0.2170238793,
0.3560811579,
-0.4779989123,
-0.2468516082,
-0.2686550617,
0.1342568547,
-0.5381684303,
-0.059275303,
0.0677455142,
-0.4872008264,
-0.212947011,
-0.2285476923,
-0.6286287904,
-0.8747442961,
-0.3404610753,
0.9426856637,
-0.2401814163,
-0.0157400742,
0.2077261358,
-0.1095885932,
0.2323723286,
0.4969216883,
-0.9491753578,
0.3650387824,
0.7694082856,
0.7045210004,
-0.2325059772,
-0.6940021515,
-0.8961693645,
0.2275115848,
-0.456507057,
0.9138114452,
-0.0162430275,
-0.1647219658,
-0.2350603938,
0.046082709,
-0.3869358897,
-0.8642804027,
0.3440588713,
-0.7558646798,
-0.1012670919,
-0.0428111479,
-0.2665438354,
-0.0702067763,
0.0436101928,
-0.7634737492,
0.6926051974,
0.2113241106,
-0.2711375356,
0.455391407,
-0.5411301255,
-0.6068214178,
-0.0265468452,
0.3003021479,
-0.428470552,
0.5014662743,
-0.0025913187,
0.3386431038,
-0.2178033441,
0.1436385959,
-0.5327596664,
-0.7309581637,
0.3033626676,
-0.4480982721,
0.7837561965,
0.067778565,
-0.0893081501,
0.1648767442,
-0.8716252446,
-0.4698618054,
0.0359089673,
-0.5212692618,
-0.5210799575,
0.298091799,
0.168625012,
0.2502315044,
0.2820966542,
-0.1361032575,
0.3141268194,
-0.4316946268,
0.0249100607,
1.1508047581,
-0.1144920066,
0.5964030623,
-0.6247198582,
0.4311006367,
0.3994926512,
0.2266642749,
0.2937201858,
-0.3117814958,
-0.8249571919,
0.0565792955,
0.5011297464,
0.827285707,
-1.0896898508,
0.4118774235,
-0.3884931803,
-0.1634801626,
-0.4460726976,
0.5836527944,
-0.0406325348,
0.0426127575,
-0.0852100104,
-0.6784125566,
-0.8360306621,
-0.5026956797,
-0.1843898594,
0.0384991616,
0.0990664139,
0.3333649039,
0.5683454275,
0.1918441355,
0.7102865577,
-0.2077857256,
-0.676510036,
-0.1201739758,
-0.0939293951,
0.2984084785,
0.6522449851,
0.6652667522,
-0.6442831755,
-0.3406296968,
0.0987377688,
-0.4416925311,
-0.1639641672,
-0.6829238534,
-0.1117616966,
0.2755100727,
0.1739826053,
-0.3935942054,
0.3138647079,
0.8353655934,
-0.5773124695,
0.2537489235,
-0.3222210705,
0.1395722777,
-1.2655582428,
-0.2783239484,
-0.2711985409,
-0.2119163275,
-0.4141684175,
-0.2276001573,
-0.2283162177,
-0.0273058806,
-0.1993782818,
0.3701787293,
-0.4634448588,
-0.2856970131,
-0.7758992314,
0.2204304338,
-0.2284743786,
0.4276098013,
-0.2357307673,
0.8802895546,
0.6800724268,
-0.4647074342,
0.362865746,
0.0465954505,
-0.4242120087,
0.6846647859,
-0.0601214468,
0.0071457652,
-0.2491289973,
0.037018124,
-0.9047210217,
-0.0682340488,
0.5296882987,
-0.2206046134,
0.3524897695,
-0.14608787,
-0.2959097922,
-0.0170189161,
-0.2850709558,
0.351154089,
0.3324767053,
-0.5250306726,
0.9310229421,
0.4280671179,
-0.2922374904,
-0.5520398617,
-0.3405330181,
0.5316939354,
-0.1624451429,
-0.311458528,
0.2067866027,
-0.1821105927,
-0.0313232876,
0.1589211822,
-0.0032811156,
-0.2520521879,
0.4311492741,
0.3253399134,
0.3272444308,
-0.186915651,
0.0272457693,
0.1504246294,
-0.2407910377,
-0.1153293923,
-0.3489769995,
0.3161313236,
0.6077413559,
-0.261172384,
-0.2456032485,
0.308113575,
0.609246552,
0.231523335,
0.8052582741,
0.5485511422,
-0.4680495858,
-0.3997270167,
-0.62468642,
-0.1180363148,
-0.4422222972,
0.831700027,
-0.5531466603,
-0.912471652,
0.6418311,
-0.2548034191,
-0.2367752194,
0.077182658,
0.6354337931,
0.1001370475,
0.4972721934,
0.8328577876,
-0.4142430425,
0.7749902606,
0.1412566304,
0.1990608573,
-0.6631780267,
-0.0250646584,
-0.5742647052,
-0.3729534149,
-0.3767710924,
-0.8501421809,
0.165534243,
0.2480972409,
0.2013012916,
0.2040009499,
-0.2470366061,
0.8111820221,
0.506934166,
0.1167181805,
0.3127192557,
0.0288364217,
0.6437210441,
0.2288584411,
-0.9757266045,
-0.0600415058,
1.3131949902,
0.0542510562,
0.7596848011,
0.1203367189,
0.8432896733,
0.1472430825,
0.6177033782,
-0.5372693539,
0.5373906493,
-0.3997288346,
-0.5498508215,
-0.4559698403,
-0.7206315994,
-1.0608038902,
0.3347064853,
-0.4061805904,
-0.9607247114,
0.3908310533,
-0.068724826,
-0.5547181368,
0.3019366264,
-0.6909492612,
0.6428815126,
-0.1213920936,
-0.5805912018,
-0.4320956767,
0.0747868046,
0.5212510824,
-0.6926764846,
0.3915878236,
-0.1326154023,
-0.1694007516,
0.8934682608,
-0.0569011904,
1.1609908342,
-0.0670504943,
-0.134580031,
0.2076491863,
0.0386413448,
0.8803901672,
-0.2618873119,
-0.1272648424,
0.1397050023,
0.0818807334,
-0.5543377399,
-0.5266125798,
0.9299301505,
-0.9327932,
-0.621009469,
-0.3092828989,
-1.0555692911,
-0.1765114069,
-0.0356679484,
-0.2070361227,
0.1490377635,
0.0623701625,
0.0277127866,
0.5080741048,
-0.1601135284,
0.4787888825,
0.4095392525,
-0.0361147076,
-0.4934915304,
1.2765994072,
0.2035398185,
0.0788414478,
0.4782190025,
0.0212180391,
-0.048091542,
-1.0706467628,
-0.2584348619,
0.0831511095,
-0.6404093504,
-0.2571234107,
-0.1885462701,
-0.0445888676,
-0.4907392859,
-0.0501902848,
-0.1197377592,
-0.5310825706,
-0.5769903064,
0.3336429894,
0.208707571,
0.8982178569,
-0.3207464218,
0.2535997033,
-0.6150433421,
0.385653317,
0.3229230344,
0.5821737647,
0.2130732238,
-0.8478237391,
-0.4221217632,
-0.4931681752,
-0.319719404,
-0.8595938683,
0.0580617748,
0.2240308523,
0.4526565075,
0.1861057431,
-0.0987031534,
0.9101367593,
-0.4765722752,
0.4089859128,
0.3979400396,
-0.9777249694,
0.0027486689,
-0.2159806788,
0.020478338,
0.3145367503,
-0.0195605941,
-0.2512005568,
-0.2602765262,
-0.1330091059,
-0.6451302171,
0.9972593188,
0.0525333546,
0.2510068119,
0.4243914485,
0.4155721664,
0.087293677,
0.1429114938,
-0.9779466391,
-0.0438376144,
-0.0246640891,
-0.2693242729,
-0.3411745131,
-0.4721783698,
-0.202609241,
-0.2605400085,
0.6737058759,
-0.3201048076,
-0.0742566884,
-0.1418190747,
-0.0411356762,
-0.4518177211,
0.12227007,
0.8434776664,
0.7322165966,
0.0745262578,
-0.0725781843,
0.5873152614,
-0.5686479807,
0.1593624055,
0.3664015532,
-0.152358979,
-0.3485273123,
0.4827410281,
0.6995382309,
0.6384817362,
-0.5768101215,
0.3566224277,
0.1775832623,
-0.3992238045,
-0.0484514497,
0.2466683984,
0.2115481198,
0.5369287133,
0.5004613996,
0.1148204282,
-0.05418754,
-0.4801605344,
0.1690277457,
0.5975879431,
-0.3068341315,
-0.0875191018,
0.555452764,
0.335686475,
-0.5231269002,
0.036507152,
-0.3229614198,
-0.3744266927,
0.6303079128,
0.7157697082,
1.0196816921,
-0.1639383882,
0.0744659901,
0.1272713393,
0.513358295,
0.0292916838,
0.4020139277,
0.0181878824,
-0.7914538383,
-0.9906917214,
-0.640832603,
-0.2241308242,
0.1030145884,
-0.1976789534,
-0.011516206,
-0.2900097072,
0.1158182994,
-0.1216005012,
0.0521829501,
-0.3139566779,
-0.1880767494,
0.243422851,
0.8063781261,
-0.740722239,
0.8392875195,
0.5306743979,
-0.2340424806,
-0.7089111209,
-0.189937219,
-0.1691719294,
-0.6167984605,
0.6404463649,
-0.5146817565,
0.1289143711,
0.013037676,
-0.2485864162,
-1.121021986,
0.9528973103,
0.3248263597,
-0.771658659,
0.2260168195,
0.2656842172,
0.187395364,
-0.3080016077,
-0.047593113,
0.3710011244,
0.3284195662,
0.1930907518,
-1.2014652491,
0.0650458187,
0.1558189243,
-0.1247627735,
0.2713847756,
-0.5898429751,
0.6307225823,
-0.2032662779,
0.1541740596,
0.4058368206,
0.3967301548,
0.2233105898,
0.4179837406,
0.7157627344,
0.2385928631,
0.7171819806,
-0.2359094024,
0.608207643,
-0.3823251724,
0.4809475243,
0.9187902212,
-0.5136886239,
0.6952157021,
0.8691188693,
-0.3488480449,
0.139611423,
0.3935826421,
0.082284525,
0.4506469965,
0.5926220417,
-0.1672649831,
-0.560968399,
0.041206222,
-0.1384958178,
0.5598673224,
0.0643282086,
0.1673747599,
-0.395526737,
0.2918579578,
-0.4979310632,
-0.1451680064,
-0.5001823306,
0.8954076767,
0.045960784,
-0.7166957855,
0.5670211911,
-0.1955203563,
0.6808440685,
-0.6305404902,
-0.072555922,
-0.1393474042,
0.4807911515,
-0.0259637069,
-0.2592187226,
0.2220212817,
-0.2560293972,
-0.3460642993,
0.0495312102,
0.9841580987,
-0.3861996531,
-0.475792408,
0.3666939437,
0.5482586622,
0.0525096916,
-0.0050467425,
-1.0172169209,
0.4703012109,
0.0807864144,
-0.2535122633,
0.8288257122,
0.581025064,
-0.003165724,
0.7456402779,
0.8775749803,
0.4400742054,
0.0442779399,
0.1827117205,
0.8128271103,
-0.7444295287,
-0.4224892557,
-0.5872411132,
0.2267333418,
0.0342624523,
-0.3011195064,
0.6867246628,
0.641800642,
0.7010518312,
-0.2589227259,
0.5744326115,
0.2637520134,
0.0077997679,
-0.6116137505,
0.5699887872,
-0.6711677313,
0.401742667,
-0.3810613155,
-0.8546062112,
-0.3703209162,
0.404128015,
-0.2980407476,
-0.0636492223,
0.5891003609,
0.9090620875,
-0.0161782391,
-0.2011954337,
0.5857046247,
0.1553119719,
0.0368012302,
1.1608319283,
0.9629225731,
-0.6067122221,
0.9040186405,
-0.2360289544,
-0.5011657476,
-0.3711493611,
-0.9198084474,
-0.8281633258,
-0.538069725,
-0.4507744312,
-0.5606760979,
0.3618531525,
0.8016184568,
0.750680089,
-0.90443331,
-0.6022500992,
0.117822431,
0.6574186087,
-0.5983870029,
-0.2052940428,
0.3375155628,
-0.4248242378,
-0.9212557077,
0.2672431469,
0.5902455449,
0.0186081938,
-0.2158343494,
-0.1527240127,
-0.0439816155,
0.2594868839,
0.6452747583,
0.1186254248,
-0.4244244993,
-0.3200604618,
-0.2737304866,
0.0174535736,
-0.2133190781,
0.8952625394,
-0.6030643582,
0.1551682353,
0.3350294232,
0.8108541965,
0.1366335452,
-0.1817004979,
0.2868045866,
-0.2208869755,
0.2654793561,
0.090963915,
0.2622439265,
0.0267833248,
-0.3805736899,
0.3224745989,
0.4731028378,
-0.5417938828,
-0.9762381911,
-0.0559127554,
-1.2670966387,
-0.5684942007,
1.1770017147,
0.2292704582,
-0.4950014949,
-0.5643007755,
-0.1745508909,
-0.0402599573,
-0.0568455644,
1.2209703922,
0.839941442,
0.0324428305,
-0.047876101,
-0.4086235166,
0.4390025735,
0.4820254743,
-0.8525081277,
0.0639856905,
0.1964500844,
0.4285223484,
0.1345158368,
0.7383078337,
0.2183770835,
0.5747171044,
0.1388275027,
0.0689317062,
-0.0593486093,
-0.2109708637,
-0.5757353902,
0.5034629107,
0.2563877106,
-0.3764536977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16783v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16783v2
|
M2Lingual: Enhancing Multilingual, Multi-Turn Instruction Alignment in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-24T16:45:13 | 2024-06-28T10:14:53 |
Rishabh Maheshwary, Vikas Yadav, Hoang Nguyen, Khyati Mahajan, Sathwik Tejaswi Madhusudhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Instruction finetuning (IFT) is critical for aligning Large Language Models
(LLMs) to follow instructions. While many effective IFT datasets have been
introduced recently, they predominantly focus on high-resource languages like
English. To better align LLMs across a broad spectrum of languages and tasks,
we propose a fully synthetic, novel taxonomy (Evol) guided Multilingual,
Multi-turn instruction finetuning dataset, called M2Lingual. It is constructed
by first selecting a diverse set of seed examples and then utilizing the
proposed Evol taxonomy to convert these seeds into complex and challenging
multi-turn instructions. We demonstrate the effectiveness of M2Lingual by
training LLMs of varying sizes and showcasing the enhanced performance across a
diverse set of languages. We contribute the 2 step Evol taxonomy with the
guided generation code: https://github.com/ServiceNow/M2Lingual, as well as the
first fully synthetic, general and task-oriented, multi-turn, multilingual
dataset built with Evol - M2Lingual:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/ServiceNow-AI/ M2Lingual - containing 182K
total IFT pairs, covering 70 languages and 17+ NLP tasks.
|
[
-0.1844801009,
-0.619151473,
0.1137691364,
0.2899267673,
0.1177360341,
0.2127880305,
-0.5221675038,
-0.1847667694,
0.05392351,
0.3118577003,
-0.7366570234,
-0.5509127975,
-0.4720942974,
0.1435397118,
-0.1775693893,
1.0321817398,
-0.1160108969,
0.3502157629,
-0.2287769467,
-0.2879095078,
-0.5484800339,
-0.4116737545,
-0.6944392323,
-0.27590096,
0.536948204,
0.7422300577,
0.4537371695,
0.7017179132,
0.2931161821,
0.3438635767,
0.3381541669,
0.7518340349,
-0.3591051102,
-0.0406761058,
-0.1786670536,
-0.3734071851,
-0.5166560411,
-0.203210175,
0.6115611792,
0.6094625592,
-0.3745436072,
0.2164755464,
0.302239567,
0.5928164721,
-0.2413370162,
0.3183034956,
-0.3585572541,
-0.0347875729,
-0.3189056814,
-0.1945787668,
-0.6014040112,
-0.0615660027,
-0.0844338462,
-0.8316075206,
-0.0244948845,
0.1320411563,
0.4726464748,
0.1137739941,
-0.5263238549,
-0.3971420527,
-0.651640296,
0.7854813337,
-0.7233324051,
0.7104608417,
0.2053125203,
0.3190155029,
0.1151277572,
-0.4240919054,
-0.5389528275,
-0.1120557562,
0.0535525791,
0.1235932037,
-0.0395904891,
-0.0035527432,
-0.0317820236,
0.2506433427,
-0.7438291907,
0.6018406749,
-0.3237853646,
-0.2553703487,
0.6322821379,
0.1273667514,
0.2708978653,
0.1223969758,
-0.3522776365,
-0.1301936209,
-0.8118767738,
-0.0827225819,
0.526698947,
0.6200070977,
-0.2408128381,
0.8328777552,
0.0397822224,
0.8256569505,
0.1970808953,
-0.3547797501,
0.2230387628,
-0.3485167027,
-0.0166401546,
0.1881336272,
0.7771575451,
0.5044189095,
0.1584500968,
-0.0685501918,
-0.3175264299,
-0.1733285189,
0.1073861867,
-0.7813677788,
-0.0661070049,
0.1540872008,
-0.0098650297,
-0.1021004543,
-0.1508805454,
-0.6802864075,
-0.2349712998,
-0.8704953194,
0.3718903065,
-0.7031864524,
-0.1959692836,
0.0715977922,
0.4390706122,
0.4021993876,
0.1903825551,
-1.1888153553,
0.1312765926,
1.0626784563,
0.7670473456,
-0.142304942,
-0.6017659307,
-0.6157037616,
0.1958881766,
-0.3423582613,
0.5922611356,
-0.5703337789,
-0.0531992242,
0.2370946854,
0.3035764694,
-0.1513657123,
-0.3556601703,
0.3085836768,
-0.3362976611,
0.6149564385,
0.101840727,
-0.723267138,
-0.1981737763,
0.489969939,
-0.393494159,
0.9934393764,
-0.0209148191,
-0.3998171985,
0.1421580911,
-0.6145488024,
-0.692877233,
-0.0372589082,
-0.4251244664,
-0.3289008141,
-0.2055239826,
0.1258535534,
0.3781998158,
-0.2459270507,
0.1832711697,
0.1068022549,
-0.0429378897,
-0.0968552455,
-0.5914875269,
0.7788778543,
0.0703345388,
-0.4625234306,
0.3056456149,
-0.7158786058,
0.1205091253,
-0.0307364222,
-0.3993856311,
-0.2769778669,
-0.2192185968,
0.1120527908,
0.2270287424,
0.3623778224,
-0.5111619234,
0.6377834082,
-0.2942976356,
0.4001658559,
0.8479970694,
-0.4282383025,
0.5230814815,
-0.0919374451,
0.6935299039,
-0.0059266658,
0.1335966289,
-0.1711020917,
-0.6054470539,
-0.706792891,
-0.2309865654,
0.4055253863,
0.820338726,
-0.9487946033,
0.1474957466,
-0.4926032722,
-0.3074707091,
-0.9189965129,
0.2659413218,
0.7713805437,
0.2506614029,
0.4020812809,
0.13880907,
-0.5906825662,
-0.8923078179,
0.0738090798,
0.3803512454,
0.1034326926,
0.0628276765,
0.1444420367,
-0.5758506656,
0.3829876482,
-0.3548211157,
-0.3918988407,
-0.1423633844,
0.0921181589,
0.2007870525,
0.6825989485,
0.2839886248,
-0.6304239631,
-0.7053584456,
0.5215610266,
-0.4620825052,
0.0642213374,
-0.1128482893,
-0.3581968248,
0.4419867694,
0.4521439373,
-0.609131813,
-0.2903152406,
0.8332883716,
-0.2346386313,
0.541179657,
-0.4329770207,
0.0484862886,
-1.4041229486,
-0.2323056757,
-0.0047513442,
-0.1533150822,
-0.6069571972,
0.2597161829,
0.2436681837,
-0.1052981764,
-0.3691515625,
0.6341570616,
-0.6789858937,
-0.0455345213,
-0.1571025401,
0.0525217205,
-0.0169196017,
0.4366674125,
-0.1194945648,
0.9920625687,
0.4661288261,
-0.4553668201,
0.3689361811,
0.3692389727,
-0.2025070935,
0.666323781,
-0.1746896207,
0.1442580074,
0.0483015738,
-0.0607054457,
-0.6974144578,
-0.3429164588,
0.0814706832,
-0.287096262,
1.0243968964,
-0.2965590656,
-0.4519624412,
-0.1707926691,
-0.1383307427,
0.2698693573,
0.3643836081,
-0.6711101532,
0.6792490482,
0.1686546057,
-0.0587110259,
-0.764385879,
-0.6126405001,
0.0900539458,
-0.1505021304,
-0.5106548667,
0.4182850122,
-0.1737509221,
-0.0876412988,
-0.2299661189,
-0.1654207408,
0.1045947522,
-0.1659609526,
-0.0986637026,
0.321744889,
-0.4872285128,
0.1015179381,
0.2916343808,
-0.2912876308,
-0.2158960551,
-0.7330216765,
0.656981647,
-0.1610139757,
-0.4101518095,
-0.3763794303,
0.5131015778,
0.6175065041,
-0.3701559305,
0.8019165397,
0.8098503351,
-0.2178460509,
-0.2633099854,
-0.357667774,
-0.1354993582,
-0.4840102196,
0.4170348346,
-0.4124389887,
-0.8068833351,
0.0469206125,
0.1041822657,
0.5295582414,
0.4135620892,
0.6312945485,
-0.2735943794,
1.1947438717,
0.7039387822,
-0.0609798208,
0.3032374084,
-0.3099657297,
0.2416937351,
-0.7843196988,
-0.2974018753,
-0.2277955562,
-0.3870206177,
-0.8664649725,
-0.5664045215,
0.1300142854,
-0.079539977,
-0.2437622249,
0.2947954237,
-0.5644634962,
0.4561357498,
0.6574761868,
-0.0442497283,
0.0159534719,
0.1787338704,
-0.2134386301,
-0.1392218471,
-0.8385174274,
-0.6592196226,
1.0780035257,
-0.0017429149,
0.6102964878,
0.3894816339,
0.7422043085,
0.0859610364,
0.359624505,
-0.8545438647,
0.3662651479,
-0.690061748,
-0.4675315917,
-0.2881470025,
-0.3416107595,
-0.9270943999,
0.1927592605,
-0.1254423857,
-0.3764417171,
-0.2245895267,
0.2966653109,
-0.3115518093,
0.1544749588,
-1.0015147924,
0.97341609,
-0.7514114976,
-0.5003536344,
-0.054433167,
-0.513541162,
0.232302025,
-0.0071846023,
0.4186403751,
0.0118910084,
-0.0959418491,
0.5634104609,
-0.4253128767,
0.8730764985,
-0.1400232613,
-0.4293096662,
0.0537198335,
0.0573328398,
0.5027752519,
-0.2524041831,
0.0033937127,
0.0087564476,
0.0094132181,
-0.4059406519,
-0.4847412109,
0.9357064962,
-0.7680322528,
-0.5702543855,
-0.2090165913,
-0.6616380811,
-0.3326232135,
0.3389882147,
0.179245159,
0.6436377168,
-0.0064517832,
0.1551295519,
0.6764647961,
-0.1121238023,
0.0845472515,
0.6115869284,
-0.3759599328,
-0.4505647719,
1.3607803583,
0.3060180843,
0.3714980185,
0.6900941133,
0.229107514,
-0.2617349029,
-0.4824281335,
-0.8475906253,
0.1317471266,
-0.53294909,
-0.3532505333,
-0.5851774812,
-0.0931153074,
-0.4478794932,
-0.1163268089,
-0.371733129,
-0.4640246034,
-0.266918093,
-0.1775420606,
0.4245895147,
0.5673236847,
-0.0879976675,
0.3931786716,
-0.7955904603,
0.1177842543,
0.2998209894,
0.2869335115,
-0.2042653412,
-0.5389372706,
-0.4024223089,
0.2893178761,
-0.3173906207,
-0.5647756457,
0.3596785665,
0.6467115283,
0.5029830933,
0.4257133007,
-0.3505247831,
0.7423681021,
-1.0250909328,
0.4793671668,
0.2643735111,
-0.6593638659,
0.1129612029,
-0.3742364943,
0.2421156466,
0.3032645285,
0.5682572722,
-0.7076476216,
-0.1365915984,
-0.3034927845,
-0.9313413501,
0.6606888771,
-0.0769390389,
0.2561511397,
0.0886762217,
0.2133708745,
0.469786942,
0.1684413999,
-0.5714585781,
-0.3154873848,
-0.1325649321,
-0.8414009213,
-0.3097200692,
-0.3244134784,
-0.3317654431,
-0.1586150378,
0.9304067492,
-0.432939589,
0.2564299405,
-0.3948610127,
-0.1478186399,
0.1709830761,
0.2540165782,
0.8928893209,
0.4862916172,
0.1722795665,
0.1496122628,
-0.1002969816,
-0.3723416328,
0.2292546779,
0.3304472268,
-0.0665909499,
-0.2505403459,
0.5032907128,
0.7012240291,
0.4842546284,
-0.5952709317,
0.2900986075,
0.1762830615,
-0.1071291044,
-0.2533706427,
-0.0894702822,
0.3016137183,
0.3815480471,
0.0811608508,
-0.0819678307,
-0.0686762407,
-0.4650397599,
0.2203588337,
0.3923430443,
-0.1860478669,
-0.4410073757,
0.504262805,
0.2645997107,
-0.4574385583,
0.7580879927,
-0.3233565688,
-0.4657199681,
0.3517647982,
0.810464859,
0.6977702379,
-0.4385297894,
0.1475050896,
0.4868846834,
0.5220898986,
0.1827984154,
0.3590863645,
0.1457137764,
-0.7250804901,
-0.5898044705,
-0.5580676198,
-0.3390392661,
-0.0668638796,
-0.5011110306,
0.263923496,
-0.1741759032,
0.1242074519,
0.0193806272,
-0.1316895783,
-0.6149231195,
0.001398891,
0.4323622584,
0.7689372301,
-0.8469882607,
0.9383606315,
0.8528173566,
-0.2936789989,
-0.7972291112,
-0.2530480921,
0.3250095248,
-0.9319115281,
0.4658626914,
0.3532140255,
-0.0559525155,
0.1122815609,
-0.2773371637,
-0.771927774,
1.042478919,
0.3585186005,
-0.9034545422,
-0.1270021647,
0.3938961327,
0.4666080475,
-0.522413969,
0.010352917,
0.4671073854,
0.5423039794,
-0.0420184173,
-0.6706946492,
-0.3394701183,
-0.1752645671,
-0.1675085872,
0.4427593946,
-0.6581437588,
0.59892869,
-0.1916421801,
-0.0326269567,
0.0246322397,
0.6968343854,
0.2391507775,
0.3029651642,
0.2631886303,
0.5960335732,
0.8564184308,
-0.2608478367,
0.9018667936,
-0.3666410148,
0.1253127754,
1.3788950443,
-0.1921020895,
0.780872345,
0.5145757794,
-0.0922171399,
0.2226959616,
0.7328824401,
0.1286738217,
0.40872702,
-0.0629276037,
-0.1400318891,
-0.1044705063,
0.0851331949,
-0.2247212678,
0.4973538518,
0.4218810499,
-0.055036895,
0.0531380959,
0.3024613559,
0.2458541095,
0.0578299612,
-0.3424117863,
0.7617109418,
-0.0662377179,
-0.6185997725,
0.6335747242,
-0.0025219608,
0.8452002406,
-0.6377675533,
-0.1088749468,
-0.3983671963,
0.3301664591,
-0.3660022914,
-0.7976157665,
0.1025831774,
0.0762057751,
-0.1159777492,
-0.385733366,
0.1172296256,
-1.0307085514,
-0.6690535545,
0.1385804415,
0.3307976425,
-0.0311533902,
0.3728680015,
-0.7921258211,
-0.1513798088,
0.3677912951,
-0.0554823279,
0.3620011508,
0.6263750196,
-0.1323799044,
0.6553890705,
0.6304917336,
-0.1948824227,
0.4411458075,
0.0635802075,
0.5278595686,
-0.2836291492,
-0.1786506921,
-0.6743844748,
0.6670870185,
0.0584335737,
-0.3809243143,
0.9720377922,
0.8529604673,
1.1273467541,
-0.2055666298,
0.4763721526,
-0.0799590051,
0.2488354146,
-0.7639412284,
0.4984523356,
-0.6693597436,
-0.0108053461,
0.1000985056,
-1.0314341784,
-0.0859369934,
0.3296299875,
-0.2002595663,
-0.0481184684,
0.4343359768,
0.8180982471,
-0.3674786389,
-0.140902102,
0.3646662235,
0.1765792668,
0.362101078,
0.2117506564,
0.6483879089,
-0.287694037,
0.4058185816,
-0.4646941721,
-0.2429834604,
-0.1986068636,
-0.7518165708,
-0.5432001352,
-0.7560371161,
-0.3277669549,
-0.0781408921,
0.0068690968,
1.2454704046,
0.6224197149,
-0.947558701,
-0.4120366275,
0.0909457132,
-0.0838669166,
-0.5276325345,
-0.1975428909,
0.3302187026,
-0.5106194615,
-0.8222461939,
0.5961062312,
0.2045222074,
0.0854805559,
-0.2754067481,
-0.2122114152,
-0.4203075767,
-0.1272595674,
0.9126592278,
0.2651063502,
-0.6584570408,
-0.1096167937,
0.1414562315,
-0.1060394272,
0.0606379136,
0.6602306366,
-0.0784051344,
0.660030663,
0.1012296006,
0.8955379128,
0.2735678554,
-0.2658092082,
0.6893314719,
-0.9483231902,
0.2291745692,
0.134661153,
0.3711178005,
0.5079500675,
-0.312929064,
0.5101273656,
-0.1521102637,
-0.5313196778,
-0.6109948158,
0.1154045388,
-0.7733659148,
0.0422204025,
1.2680608034,
0.0134931039,
-0.1204214841,
0.3190190196,
-0.4369097352,
0.3027175367,
-0.1715655476,
0.5358535051,
0.69101578,
-0.0152777527,
-0.1935476661,
-0.6469734311,
0.2870976031,
0.3184964955,
-0.7376067638,
0.1520201266,
0.6183258891,
0.1488403976,
0.1328250319,
0.0463745929,
0.0467504524,
0.1350682527,
-0.2722338736,
0.2773586214,
-0.2509307861,
-0.4390454888,
-0.2832278907,
-0.2170824558,
0.0955444276,
-0.2381769568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16779v1
|
It Is Not About What You Say, It Is About How You Say It: A Surprisingly Simple Approach for Improving Reading Comprehension
| 2024-06-24T16:43:11 | 2024-06-24T16:43:11 |
Sagi Shaier, Lawrence E Hunter, Katharina von der Wense
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural language processing has seen rapid progress over the past decade. Due
to the speed of developments, some practices get established without proper
evaluation. Considering one such case and focusing on reading comprehension, we
ask our first research question: 1) How does the order of inputs -- i.e.,
question and context -- affect model performance? Additionally, given recent
advancements in input emphasis, we ask a second research question: 2) Does
emphasizing either the question, the context, or both enhance performance?
Experimenting with 9 large language models across 3 datasets, we find that
presenting the context before the question improves model performance, with an
accuracy increase of up to $31\%$. Furthermore, emphasizing the context yields
superior results compared to question emphasis, and in general, emphasizing
parts of the input is particularly effective for addressing questions that
models lack the parametric knowledge to answer. Experimenting with both
prompt-based and attention-based emphasis methods, we additionally find that
the best method is surprisingly simple: it only requires concatenating a few
tokens to the input and results in an accuracy improvement of up to $36\%$,
allowing smaller models to outperform their significantly larger counterparts.
|
[
-0.4388554692,
-1.1004743576,
0.7599397898,
0.263266027,
-0.4433468878,
-0.129414618,
-0.2255583107,
-0.6099666357,
-0.3717054129,
0.3869424164,
-0.2548672855,
-0.1638109982,
-0.5669058561,
0.3520518541,
-0.3521048427,
0.6817710996,
0.2726103365,
0.2464578003,
-0.3024045825,
-0.2861675918,
-0.5785318017,
-0.389632225,
-0.8086885214,
-0.3767682016,
0.6255235672,
0.4779301286,
0.6102895141,
0.921038866,
0.5158051252,
0.3337257504,
-0.5236725807,
0.1219860241,
-0.2813163102,
0.2152510583,
-0.1559147388,
-0.5340998173,
0.0833969638,
-0.1983383,
0.5482314229,
1.0318284035,
0.0413556024,
0.1083148718,
0.2186776549,
0.6230186224,
-0.7030436397,
0.0066707283,
-0.1971031725,
-0.272390604,
0.0041640876,
-0.5382844806,
-0.6022889018,
-0.0364012234,
0.581946671,
-0.3775032759,
0.1618620455,
0.1602111012,
0.7029399872,
0.3762601018,
-0.5937806368,
-0.2762905955,
-0.7021948695,
0.7618387938,
-0.7439273596,
0.5111779571,
0.6094048619,
0.0773132741,
0.2777762711,
-0.6876416206,
-0.4287832379,
-0.0868784487,
-0.2397065014,
0.0372464806,
0.1230395883,
0.2064538598,
0.4305517375,
0.3379016519,
-0.5311439037,
-0.2918887734,
-0.4729220569,
0.0846989676,
0.4461857975,
-0.0219284985,
0.3841209114,
-0.2248473018,
-0.1508244872,
-0.134441644,
-0.2455686033,
0.6155506968,
0.0317334048,
0.4758730233,
0.2242276222,
0.7488164902,
-0.5019560456,
0.8929351568,
0.2673573792,
-0.0742785037,
-0.0842124969,
-0.7029377818,
-0.3143969476,
-0.1525846273,
0.3258889616,
0.5077165961,
0.2409478724,
-0.2151469141,
-0.0078646578,
-0.2145590484,
0.3315138221,
-0.6032202244,
-0.0837638453,
0.2716788352,
-0.1513673514,
-0.053319294,
-0.0212805327,
-0.570489347,
-0.3976235688,
-0.391315192,
0.3889252543,
-0.3223166764,
0.2076595873,
0.137585327,
-0.2335290462,
0.5852078199,
0.310575366,
-1.1687738895,
0.4314897656,
0.7089591026,
0.5326272845,
-0.043774303,
-0.1814773232,
-0.5634359717,
-0.0496537164,
-0.293939203,
1.0362830162,
-0.6404256225,
-0.3310600519,
-0.0854114518,
-0.0423400551,
-0.2869253159,
-0.4257635772,
0.6698274612,
-0.7946141958,
0.4238180816,
-0.513582468,
-0.7533332705,
-0.2627824247,
0.1872439682,
-0.6268339157,
1.2174432278,
-0.291965127,
-0.801998198,
0.4290853143,
-0.5688078403,
-0.746127665,
-0.1878986806,
0.198961556,
0.1081971675,
0.1867746115,
0.6290730834,
0.1893360019,
-0.1139326245,
0.0481580496,
-0.0622486398,
-0.5979273319,
0.483590275,
-0.4263605177,
0.495125711,
-0.0746321306,
-0.2752218843,
-0.0545951314,
-0.4857258797,
0.2606231868,
-0.1132843122,
-0.4722361565,
-0.4394163191,
-0.131966114,
-0.0412934311,
-0.0674614757,
0.0347127132,
-0.4408804178,
-0.0855122283,
-0.9625471234,
0.4879562259,
0.2307216972,
0.2578240633,
0.9939538836,
-0.3122813404,
0.5548365116,
-0.2201553285,
0.087256819,
-0.4754448533,
-0.4266284108,
-0.7447681427,
0.2474089861,
0.5565376282,
0.5918813944,
-0.6668843627,
0.0370784476,
0.2406002134,
-0.2399555147,
-0.4725171626,
0.1086926833,
0.437695235,
0.9510215521,
0.4923481941,
-0.1774311364,
-0.3179646134,
-0.7654955387,
-0.5376468897,
-0.3934159577,
0.1385530531,
0.1924671829,
0.102617301,
0.4044470191,
0.8239250183,
-0.6760132313,
0.37240237,
-0.5750893354,
0.2471076399,
0.0426301956,
0.2808462977,
0.1811677516,
-0.7419957519,
-0.4784589112,
-0.2002757788,
-0.2995454669,
-0.0838310048,
0.1461967528,
-0.2783795297,
0.1364403665,
0.50181216,
-0.5487481952,
0.2814100981,
0.0942018479,
-0.3532509208,
0.4000553787,
-0.1826234609,
0.153740868,
-0.7887333035,
0.1603469253,
0.0663000196,
-0.1660724729,
-1.0046801567,
0.2430605739,
0.2306901962,
-0.0460790358,
-0.5671812892,
0.8487283587,
-0.2907339633,
0.2497123182,
-0.2782597244,
0.1011107042,
0.3735793531,
0.5096887946,
-0.0540205874,
0.7887117863,
0.5054504871,
-0.6904138327,
-0.1836596876,
0.185421288,
-0.3940095603,
0.6400184631,
-0.8657444119,
0.3716314733,
-0.3859598339,
0.0707860738,
-1.3417303562,
-0.1924403608,
0.2550086379,
-0.5227611065,
0.4386020899,
-0.0445351601,
-0.3278967738,
-0.2745976746,
-0.0855476335,
0.3800392449,
0.398167938,
-0.3793988526,
0.5212984085,
0.0738375336,
-0.3855628967,
-0.7117202878,
-0.9657915235,
-0.161971435,
-0.2660823166,
-0.650162816,
0.229234919,
-0.2687697709,
-0.4018077254,
-0.2421881258,
-0.2972131968,
-0.6994262338,
0.3402772546,
-0.1594528407,
0.0776357949,
-0.3418758214,
0.5041429996,
0.1276693195,
-0.0051701227,
-0.0505123287,
0.0435429588,
0.3363868296,
0.0698567703,
0.0796941742,
-0.5298058987,
0.4361473322,
0.3873913884,
-0.394375205,
0.6219922304,
0.1465140432,
-0.0764673576,
-0.3888016343,
-0.4678154588,
-0.5771726966,
-0.4754878581,
0.2814434171,
-0.2453036904,
-0.7538623214,
0.1478396207,
0.2897295058,
0.1611209065,
0.0438786373,
0.2502803206,
-0.616396904,
1.2364959717,
0.6956867576,
0.2230954915,
0.6190869808,
0.0057090665,
0.3606714904,
-0.8151563406,
0.0967955589,
-0.5674032569,
-0.2857886851,
-0.024233928,
-0.5132347345,
0.0700245127,
0.2495987266,
0.212685883,
0.1412604451,
-0.3694641888,
0.6797772646,
0.4950124621,
0.1746866554,
0.5661332011,
-0.078819029,
-0.0604730211,
-0.0705136284,
-0.5956596732,
-0.7043067813,
1.0064858198,
0.3345588148,
0.4656560421,
-0.0805519298,
0.459623307,
-0.0431194715,
0.1813085228,
-0.9797241688,
0.3702760935,
0.2355749309,
-0.8460808396,
-0.7009842992,
-0.1191529334,
-1.1218947172,
0.6379420161,
0.0603545792,
-0.6031663418,
0.2886006236,
0.2918222547,
-0.8832624555,
-0.3032148778,
-0.9870870709,
0.764344573,
-0.1183044016,
-0.4167081118,
0.057212729,
-0.6994999647,
0.1982630491,
0.3431401253,
0.1520988345,
-0.0408518463,
-0.0989798978,
0.6348670721,
-0.3507288396,
0.5779480338,
-0.0989070162,
0.17237629,
0.5083016157,
-0.2486561984,
0.2135831863,
0.0894335508,
-0.2650972903,
-0.4913083315,
0.2546991408,
-0.4674706161,
-1.1104075909,
0.0950833112,
-0.4366566241,
-0.6340502501,
-0.234814465,
-0.6678103209,
-0.5216698647,
0.1939685941,
0.1791281402,
0.8198934197,
-0.2335944474,
0.2290059775,
0.9478916526,
0.1418270916,
0.632517457,
0.4396798313,
0.0323941894,
-0.1570810974,
0.466881007,
0.2889152467,
0.3563497961,
0.5560512543,
0.2855045497,
-0.6712982655,
-0.4050784707,
-0.5670084953,
0.5383226871,
-0.9617109895,
0.1994018853,
-0.9883754253,
0.0977218896,
-0.5573052764,
-0.1037150249,
-0.0183627829,
-0.4593872726,
-0.3451919854,
-0.2102101892,
0.217032209,
0.5964784622,
0.3499194384,
0.5051301122,
-0.3634963334,
0.2212987542,
0.5285663009,
0.0872251615,
0.1927532703,
-0.6426745653,
-0.1553649902,
-0.1211618781,
-0.3452913165,
-0.9789453745,
0.2390678972,
-0.0234304518,
0.5346088409,
0.1479725689,
0.144879967,
0.6535895467,
-0.4221612811,
0.6901423931,
-0.3079150915,
-0.9067601562,
0.4115361869,
-0.038453944,
0.7756807804,
1.1720004082,
0.1011087522,
-0.5565806627,
-0.4670524001,
-0.5324130654,
-0.7741995454,
0.7770699859,
-0.0148793263,
0.2181115448,
0.0611680485,
0.3679660261,
-0.118989937,
0.1974316239,
-0.5022250414,
-0.3058955073,
0.0829785392,
-0.2166727632,
-0.2080853432,
-0.2967536747,
-0.1303227991,
-0.4682581425,
0.5481265783,
-0.2442713678,
0.2439668477,
0.54282552,
-0.3837703466,
0.1645763218,
0.3979825675,
0.7083681226,
0.8857116103,
0.0035210631,
0.3769040108,
0.3428834379,
-0.2624288201,
-0.0749148354,
0.0552046187,
-0.4315194786,
-0.0035555982,
0.4893278778,
0.7447991371,
0.5736123323,
-0.6099225283,
0.3386277556,
-0.1677726656,
-0.1182300523,
0.3945471048,
0.1054014787,
0.3397274017,
0.2101551592,
0.3150264919,
-0.1406072229,
0.4296439886,
-0.6786356568,
0.1308009177,
0.0767313018,
-0.4374841154,
-0.1532279551,
0.3676388264,
0.3177713156,
-0.3090625703,
0.2966939509,
0.0867744088,
-0.5111427903,
0.7846572995,
0.480301857,
0.6700764298,
-0.2244926095,
0.3375401497,
0.4873623252,
0.2746692598,
-0.1818003803,
0.6300362945,
-0.6455065608,
-0.543865025,
-0.5773525238,
-0.4713359773,
-0.4568063021,
-0.2106737196,
-0.7446044683,
0.0742813349,
-0.4203012586,
-0.2408680171,
0.0882309601,
0.1914883256,
-0.4481732249,
0.4503134191,
-0.0097060241,
0.9747129679,
-0.7134236097,
0.5646641254,
0.8469896913,
-0.3059366643,
-1.0282753706,
0.3552367985,
-0.4213693142,
-0.4647243321,
0.1088500023,
0.3352351487,
0.249052763,
0.2902148366,
-0.527692914,
-1.2281044722,
0.6875689626,
-0.0389602371,
-0.2775290012,
-0.1452939063,
-0.0403095074,
0.7151861191,
-0.0247866381,
0.4975354373,
0.7443962097,
0.7139782906,
0.1993361712,
-0.6479356289,
-0.1747855693,
-0.2605783641,
-0.0071511469,
-0.0357208885,
-0.4879433513,
0.4519714415,
-0.3514352143,
-0.4862731099,
0.0974464789,
0.802877903,
0.0541223064,
0.5800356269,
0.4329378009,
0.2870758474,
1.0605031252,
-0.1042680517,
1.4820357561,
-0.0608232915,
0.054458946,
1.1577094793,
-0.1242332309,
0.7537365556,
0.6237375736,
-0.0671672747,
0.2802574933,
0.8636256456,
0.3350970447,
0.69775635,
-0.0690158159,
0.0579773486,
-0.1043498665,
-0.1477289796,
-0.1492870897,
0.147372365,
0.0152707901,
-0.4047893584,
-0.1768260449,
0.2257277519,
-0.1725745052,
0.3061367869,
-0.0934946164,
0.8986991048,
0.1139118075,
-1.1361689568,
0.4911838174,
0.0820150524,
0.3804195821,
-0.2949258983,
0.215331018,
-0.3664177656,
-0.087400116,
0.1114286408,
-0.8189226985,
0.2372111827,
-0.0011228154,
-0.6275327206,
-0.1965188384,
0.3755629957,
-0.5299115777,
-0.5648156404,
0.0301671475,
0.4746505022,
0.030294057,
0.0134435156,
-0.609945178,
0.0680090785,
-0.3148887455,
-0.3591259718,
-0.107677415,
0.2907791436,
0.0361551195,
0.4345565438,
0.5173454285,
-0.1811405122,
0.2389059514,
0.2111350745,
0.5188195705,
-0.6963421702,
-0.5370905399,
-0.7205644846,
0.7000282407,
-0.1473713368,
-0.6252576709,
0.7520046234,
0.138779074,
0.5461186767,
0.1834653765,
0.4751611352,
0.1795043051,
0.6412009597,
-0.3684195876,
0.3450208604,
-0.506821394,
-0.0434014313,
-0.2720061839,
-0.9537628293,
-0.4558198452,
0.4094014168,
-0.6701587439,
0.0753614306,
1.1084578037,
0.6710143685,
0.24219504,
0.3029192388,
0.4628278613,
0.0493956506,
-0.0324883573,
0.2428632528,
0.9635797143,
-0.4616086483,
0.3408872783,
-0.4808181822,
-0.1013463587,
-0.1638274789,
-0.4081739783,
-0.7916973233,
-0.2770994902,
-0.2449910939,
-0.1037990153,
0.1156141981,
0.5159283876,
0.7479476333,
-0.6163066626,
-0.1748703122,
-0.03292007,
0.4047417641,
-0.354038626,
-0.1708660424,
0.1927821189,
-0.5415356755,
-1.023547411,
0.5475281477,
0.1986711025,
-0.1170628071,
-0.0180869009,
0.1153302193,
-0.4153164327,
0.5457838774,
0.5592418909,
0.3231550753,
-0.7356624007,
-0.1547486484,
0.3568946421,
-0.5204262137,
0.2522694468,
0.7391541004,
-0.5309968591,
0.7454753518,
0.8106413484,
0.9206933379,
0.3613134921,
0.6455150843,
0.596061945,
-0.4636235237,
-0.126397565,
0.2113266885,
0.1266046166,
0.4161252975,
-0.5781889558,
0.3765573502,
-0.1020152047,
-0.5269367099,
-0.8676426411,
-0.1120623201,
-0.9732714891,
-0.4585682154,
0.9309238195,
0.3022533655,
-0.437522471,
-0.3801435232,
-0.4720050991,
0.1458593011,
-0.3435813487,
0.5276905894,
1.0450376272,
-0.2787403762,
-0.321351856,
-0.5891976357,
0.4537757635,
1.18027246,
-0.5109914541,
0.0486400463,
0.2526182234,
0.0981526002,
0.0769208968,
0.5972810984,
0.0415892377,
0.5114458799,
-0.3741235137,
-0.3371576369,
0.2550911307,
-0.4267498255,
-0.6729124784,
0.4294180274,
0.1707325429,
0.0390839502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16778v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16778v1
|
Finding Transformer Circuits with Edge Pruning
| 2024-06-24T16:40:54 | 2024-06-24T16:40:54 |
Adithya Bhaskar, Alexander Wettig, Dan Friedman, Danqi Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The path to interpreting a language model often proceeds via analysis of
circuits -- sparse computational subgraphs of the model that capture specific
aspects of its behavior. Recent work has automated the task of discovering
circuits. Yet, these methods have practical limitations, as they rely either on
inefficient search algorithms or inaccurate approximations. In this paper, we
frame automated circuit discovery as an optimization problem and propose *Edge
Pruning* as an effective and scalable solution. Edge Pruning leverages
gradient-based pruning techniques, but instead of removing neurons or
components, it prunes the \emph{edges} between components. Our method finds
circuits in GPT-2 that use less than half the number of edges compared to
circuits found by previous methods while being equally faithful to the full
model predictions on standard circuit-finding tasks. Edge Pruning is efficient
even with as many as 100K examples, outperforming previous methods in speed and
producing substantially better circuits. It also perfectly recovers the
ground-truth circuits in two models compiled with Tracr. Thanks to its
efficiency, we scale Edge Pruning to CodeLlama-13B, a model over 100x the scale
that prior methods operate on. We use this setting for a case study comparing
the mechanisms behind instruction prompting and in-context learning. We find
two circuits with more than 99.96% sparsity that match the performance of the
full model and reveal that the mechanisms in the two settings overlap
substantially. Our case study shows that Edge Pruning is a practical and
scalable tool for interpretability and sheds light on behaviors that only
emerge in large models.
|
[
-0.6509225965,
-0.8984325528,
0.7265786529,
0.015298035,
-0.1454023272,
-0.1179706752,
-0.2114927024,
0.0595508106,
-0.0602324717,
0.2761956453,
-0.9626249671,
-0.2506965697,
-0.4519224167,
-0.3098420203,
-0.4830561578,
0.6967753172,
-0.0231956188,
-0.2693047822,
0.0060024229,
0.0588863157,
-0.4441617131,
-0.2674788237,
-0.5759016871,
-0.6340421438,
0.2378349155,
0.4687018394,
0.7953299284,
0.7195079327,
0.5179156065,
0.2914566398,
-0.3964502513,
0.1544674039,
-0.3512352407,
-0.008521759,
0.0246846788,
-0.3079072237,
-0.1518967897,
-0.0925630704,
0.4069051743,
0.7543797493,
-0.1276783198,
0.1313940138,
0.0392469727,
0.7371621728,
-0.4339911938,
-0.0768733621,
-0.5578503013,
0.1169472709,
-0.2246682942,
-0.3045613468,
-0.6220197678,
-0.3116013706,
-0.0743835941,
-0.5235053897,
0.489518255,
-0.2222514749,
1.0650638342,
0.3416366279,
-0.4216216803,
-0.3257612586,
-1.0287611485,
0.548535645,
-0.2089906037,
0.6121096015,
0.1935333312,
0.409712106,
-0.1571588516,
-1.1356810331,
-0.3756560087,
-0.1394671202,
-0.1816218495,
0.0341520831,
-0.4993844628,
0.3426133394,
0.5900434852,
0.386407584,
-0.5173428059,
-0.1052322462,
-0.5226620436,
-0.3804731965,
0.2085824609,
-0.0238652956,
0.5539598465,
-0.0376719236,
-0.156712234,
-0.3319740891,
-1.0181429386,
0.2693292499,
0.6426516771,
0.0501493961,
0.4778058529,
0.2660060227,
0.2271700352,
0.7460497618,
-0.0369402319,
-0.008509852,
-0.0213582646,
-0.2044427991,
0.0158490464,
-0.2511592209,
0.4796767533,
0.3596669137,
0.5483609438,
-0.0066451011,
-0.3620471358,
0.0373446271,
0.4997321963,
-0.7857095003,
-0.7945349216,
-0.1718114316,
-0.4963136911,
0.0821570382,
0.0645605177,
-0.6110708714,
0.0661379099,
-0.3263323903,
0.4384175539,
-0.4930028915,
-0.2336210161,
-0.2306704968,
-0.4108102322,
0.2192135006,
-0.0212623812,
-0.9327113032,
0.5914976597,
0.6966008544,
1.066044569,
0.1621593982,
0.0313991643,
-0.6313390136,
-0.3320066333,
-0.4378272891,
0.6859240532,
-0.6531147957,
-0.6062586308,
-0.1736628562,
0.0954043269,
-0.233237192,
-0.6655555367,
0.9039916992,
-0.5872061849,
-0.289517194,
-0.3600134552,
-0.2975873053,
-0.1602592617,
-0.1654835641,
-0.8637125492,
1.0411765575,
0.099989742,
-0.5417386293,
0.0650303513,
-0.5629122853,
-0.6928266287,
-0.0924225301,
-0.1140556633,
-0.5950517058,
0.3499035835,
0.4737704396,
0.0151654668,
-0.0400643721,
0.3872160912,
0.1038031206,
-0.6482447386,
-0.1982467175,
-0.5258239508,
0.8254044652,
0.1130110323,
-0.4946965277,
0.1717832685,
-0.3723784685,
0.0861776695,
0.1284739971,
0.2285630256,
-0.2346388996,
0.1028369591,
-0.0267032385,
0.2891296148,
-0.1838787049,
-0.425722599,
0.0891332626,
-0.5630781651,
0.903819859,
0.8822941184,
0.1529156268,
0.5260010362,
-0.2203544974,
0.4785642624,
-0.2345126867,
0.3455153704,
-0.4608382583,
-0.3841154873,
-0.9953266978,
0.1304387301,
0.1131558567,
0.3125540912,
-0.58858639,
0.4713267684,
-0.1743755788,
-0.4733777344,
-0.4541144967,
-0.095775485,
0.1542646885,
0.5697885156,
0.6018390059,
-0.2139130533,
-0.2038272619,
-1.1994153261,
-0.3578145504,
0.1007348001,
-0.3208550811,
0.284568876,
0.4276080728,
-0.1836527884,
1.1191866398,
-0.5855249166,
-0.2643567622,
-0.3801750541,
0.1332251579,
0.1767105311,
0.5809227824,
0.1751734316,
-0.9079532623,
-0.3956374526,
0.0402157195,
-0.3295388222,
-0.0177330468,
-0.2062816322,
0.1533987522,
-0.4231734574,
0.4923687279,
-0.4386695921,
0.6415530443,
0.0984454975,
0.2597535253,
0.1819825768,
-0.1761447936,
-0.2321230322,
-0.4355737865,
-0.0427025557,
0.2408993393,
-0.0311041009,
-0.7989004254,
0.0684436709,
0.3523177505,
-0.1942739338,
-0.1417733729,
0.3909777403,
-0.5510940552,
-0.0695016161,
-0.3328224123,
0.0509151891,
0.0556267947,
0.7902511954,
0.0806282237,
0.8941674232,
0.4333910346,
-0.5260331035,
0.0029979693,
0.0515433699,
-0.0873264596,
0.236788705,
-0.8047825098,
0.3131871819,
-0.2132221907,
0.3153809607,
-0.6724738479,
0.0109474985,
0.0948941559,
-0.3183278441,
0.1577221155,
-0.3895088732,
-0.2344957888,
-0.5694684982,
-0.2085357308,
0.3320003748,
0.8535773754,
-0.9550830722,
0.7772960067,
0.4320914745,
-0.195233047,
-0.2337115258,
-0.3657884598,
-0.1628959775,
0.0032314903,
-0.8034563065,
0.5657204986,
0.1400290281,
-0.1465462446,
-0.1010987759,
-0.6574905515,
-0.1802442968,
0.145422712,
0.3944594562,
0.1521720141,
-0.0152027188,
0.1715774089,
0.3461533785,
-0.3793312609,
0.3118567169,
-0.4845245183,
0.6175983548,
-0.3634509742,
-0.6045036316,
-0.450430572,
0.2111373842,
0.3930030763,
-0.4678504467,
-0.0163704082,
0.574778676,
-0.4972674549,
-0.5627323389,
-0.4347163439,
-0.5315246582,
-0.6123211384,
0.2152822912,
-0.4703848362,
-0.541249454,
0.3846653104,
-0.4848570228,
0.0331564434,
0.5681140423,
0.1537532508,
0.2138305753,
1.1720076799,
0.814627409,
0.1790492088,
0.5379393101,
-0.5452260971,
0.7966908216,
-0.8313071728,
-0.3835720122,
-0.5089239478,
-0.4444240034,
-0.4647598565,
-0.0630414858,
0.6751637459,
-0.1437798589,
-0.0866687372,
0.442229569,
-1.0209964514,
0.6894983053,
0.8563249111,
0.215259999,
0.2305596918,
0.1580238789,
-0.2171888798,
-0.1724536419,
-0.9030976295,
-0.4461378753,
0.7543227673,
0.4666247964,
0.5581073761,
-0.368449837,
0.552295506,
-0.1170009896,
0.3598622382,
-0.8848488927,
0.3989355862,
0.040793702,
-0.3622879088,
-0.225522548,
-0.4968164861,
-0.7874963284,
-0.0372272171,
0.2602372169,
-0.8403629661,
0.2472004294,
0.177463755,
-0.2506841719,
0.486066848,
-0.7442421913,
0.9245169163,
-0.1038074419,
-0.2174126804,
-0.098497048,
-0.708091259,
0.2508116663,
0.2975057065,
0.2422193438,
0.2817421556,
0.3822312653,
0.7617085576,
-0.6537382007,
0.4040756822,
-0.2570384145,
0.1775454134,
0.6041123271,
0.2536730468,
0.7093126774,
-0.2259859443,
0.3269660473,
-0.172683239,
-0.3608642817,
-0.16083619,
-0.7984452248,
0.7409592271,
-0.6066489816,
-0.6753367186,
-0.149810642,
-0.3762403727,
-0.142015636,
0.0917575881,
0.5971621871,
0.820856452,
0.0741174445,
0.0371672697,
0.8578691483,
0.0500894636,
0.6210191846,
-0.1079869121,
0.1569040567,
-0.0414526835,
1.2242646217,
0.3242118061,
0.0940229669,
0.1948109865,
0.0597306304,
-0.1993022561,
-0.5539539456,
-0.4235133529,
0.0541688651,
-0.8128956556,
-0.0683324635,
-0.7618294954,
-0.5018651485,
0.1733830273,
-0.2708698511,
-0.437148869,
-0.4876875579,
0.0629402548,
-0.2951724231,
0.172697857,
0.6797189713,
0.0166693851,
0.7386242151,
-0.6928139329,
0.1859006882,
0.3896403611,
0.3125376999,
0.3263256252,
-0.3824947476,
-0.0372940041,
-0.0341490172,
-0.7005974054,
-0.8341374993,
0.341016531,
0.0273379236,
0.5211708546,
0.2946971655,
0.0567947067,
0.6759310961,
-0.5839883685,
0.5192950964,
0.1029339582,
-1.2234069109,
0.6008939147,
0.0771183595,
0.1664936543,
0.4979872108,
0.3934451938,
-0.5425871015,
-0.2509790361,
-0.9623582959,
-1.2003729343,
0.3456287682,
0.4438884258,
0.027502846,
0.0318794288,
0.1831898093,
-0.0736376718,
-0.0848876312,
-0.7353872657,
-0.290127188,
-0.2306653559,
-0.2025478035,
0.3603923619,
0.0363861695,
-0.283967644,
-0.1409655809,
0.5551070571,
-0.0786853954,
0.2451570928,
0.2226292044,
-0.3212990463,
-0.1599921584,
0.0788674578,
0.3063924909,
0.8569896817,
0.0817295164,
0.3342086971,
0.1188729778,
-0.5634643435,
0.2511909306,
0.115209043,
-0.3456326723,
0.3408358991,
0.4312412143,
0.7069767118,
-0.0857751593,
-0.6129273176,
0.6523476243,
-0.1132950112,
-0.0827187896,
-0.268031925,
0.1745285988,
0.030869415,
0.0217113681,
0.7121679783,
0.21882765,
0.3842989802,
-0.2227353305,
0.5992173553,
0.5754882693,
-0.6685948372,
-0.275595814,
0.4634054601,
0.2370929122,
-0.7246773243,
1.0734807253,
-0.2335973233,
-0.8414469957,
0.9733746648,
0.2579168677,
0.8614040017,
-0.0795261338,
0.200809136,
0.502512753,
0.7109864354,
-0.2077849805,
-0.4361928403,
-0.2146515846,
-0.3492367566,
-0.370095104,
-0.1144701838,
-0.3908385336,
-0.0279099904,
-0.7603207231,
0.2836488485,
-0.3756334782,
-0.0168962181,
0.0494067781,
-0.0580086075,
-0.5334870815,
0.1862213016,
-0.3109422326,
1.0336140394,
-1.1093811989,
0.739590764,
0.2306987792,
-0.1641357243,
-1.0366309881,
0.088149786,
-0.0787797421,
-0.6413792968,
0.4593320191,
0.5139122605,
-0.1770118624,
0.0816907063,
-0.2370535731,
-0.5121474862,
1.0650652647,
0.0957207605,
-0.7860147953,
-0.2006397545,
-0.451271683,
0.3095774055,
-0.0481015742,
0.7471339703,
0.81075418,
0.5979981422,
0.2783442438,
-0.7263956666,
0.1130442992,
-0.4542050362,
-0.0461662561,
0.6982415318,
-0.4213691354,
0.9098507166,
-0.1978265047,
-0.5309438705,
-0.273381263,
0.5423206687,
0.0424812175,
0.4982242584,
0.6693829894,
0.4059810936,
0.7625285387,
-0.3296256959,
0.740301311,
-0.385591656,
0.5434031487,
0.6698806882,
0.0395705961,
0.2550080121,
0.530454874,
-0.1265655011,
0.3895229399,
0.8016142249,
-0.0296368413,
0.5749760866,
0.3896144032,
0.049756702,
-0.2781885564,
0.1004953161,
-0.2699353099,
-0.2554409802,
0.3862321973,
-0.1533491313,
-0.3999271393,
-0.0522822738,
0.0826509669,
0.213796854,
-0.3106155694,
0.5644847155,
0.0867855549,
-0.8452122211,
0.4224420488,
0.0614821129,
0.308002919,
-0.3878580928,
-0.3329269588,
-0.3265063167,
0.0814746171,
-0.2664421499,
-0.5531924963,
0.4802409112,
-0.2978629172,
0.0738412738,
-0.4228332341,
0.9306052327,
-0.0942561924,
-0.4703304172,
0.2890787125,
0.5160043836,
-0.1505642533,
-0.1805910468,
-0.1819625348,
0.1107795909,
0.1659287214,
-0.3966277242,
0.1897889525,
0.2697272301,
-0.1964609474,
0.7943148613,
0.499861449,
-0.0963766798,
-0.1275533885,
-0.1818861514,
1.2342017889,
-0.5536942482,
-0.3303129077,
-0.9163054824,
0.4251430929,
-0.2025460899,
-0.2755514681,
0.3996969759,
0.5538919568,
0.8549482822,
0.2931798995,
0.7430346012,
0.1253930926,
0.1025060937,
-0.4929951131,
0.1990047097,
-0.2581146061,
0.3329847753,
-0.0215724446,
-1.0197554827,
-0.1164045632,
0.9133422375,
-0.5003756881,
0.0754117072,
0.8593423963,
1.0135989189,
-0.478156358,
0.3609212935,
-0.0836781859,
-0.0812268332,
0.3860967457,
0.5626154542,
0.7884395123,
-0.2376070023,
0.7625025511,
-0.4599961936,
-0.5040636659,
-0.0453993715,
-0.6045235991,
-0.7603318095,
-0.5937583447,
-0.0543089211,
-0.1823335439,
0.0595797338,
0.7325085998,
0.6990171075,
-0.3800790608,
-0.167477116,
-0.662588954,
0.5969676971,
-0.5334814191,
-0.2500770092,
0.4354203641,
-0.3384510279,
-0.5844934583,
0.5014211535,
0.2882202566,
-0.1897376329,
-0.1422257423,
-0.0305186994,
0.2140059173,
-0.0518115573,
0.1645516008,
0.2650337219,
-0.5548829436,
-0.2012216151,
0.4083554149,
0.1864574552,
0.17095761,
1.2149879932,
-0.7285980582,
0.2823795974,
0.2542116046,
0.5799590349,
0.9491117001,
0.0455954447,
0.7203698158,
-0.6458583474,
-0.0152141172,
0.3970113099,
0.2008661926,
0.1052290648,
-0.1752902418,
0.5020548105,
0.1701590121,
-0.6178680062,
-0.8925030231,
0.5455368161,
-0.6003630161,
-0.3020298183,
0.8128291965,
-0.0641661957,
-0.2485912442,
0.1315953583,
-0.2411049902,
0.049776461,
-0.2299399525,
0.3748466969,
0.5255736709,
-0.2373482138,
-0.2465845793,
-0.603074193,
0.5618029237,
0.2514002919,
-0.3800789416,
-0.0216946322,
0.1912667602,
0.0131044099,
0.3587399721,
0.3756651878,
0.2591106296,
0.3671294451,
0.0431635641,
-0.1045444086,
-0.2943591774,
-0.806871295,
-0.2487788945,
0.3162995279,
-0.0594836697,
-0.0107851224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16777v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16777v1
|
Blending LLMs into Cascaded Speech Translation: KIT's Offline Speech Translation System for IWSLT 2024
| 2024-06-24T16:38:17 | 2024-06-24T16:38:17 |
Sai Koneru, Thai-Binh Nguyen, Ngoc-Quan Pham, Danni Liu, Zhaolin Li, Alexander Waibel, Jan Niehues
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are currently under exploration for various
tasks, including Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR), Machine Translation (MT),
and even End-to-End Speech Translation (ST). In this paper, we present KIT's
offline submission in the constrained + LLM track by incorporating recently
proposed techniques that can be added to any cascaded speech translation.
Specifically, we integrate
Mistral-7B\footnote{mistralai/Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.1} into our system to
enhance it in two ways. Firstly, we refine the ASR outputs by utilizing the
N-best lists generated by our system and fine-tuning the LLM to predict the
transcript accurately. Secondly, we refine the MT outputs at the document level
by fine-tuning the LLM, leveraging both ASR and MT predictions to improve
translation quality. We find that integrating the LLM into the ASR and MT
systems results in an absolute improvement of $0.3\%$ in Word Error Rate and
$0.65\%$ in COMET for tst2019 test set. In challenging test sets with
overlapping speakers and background noise, we find that integrating LLM is not
beneficial due to poor ASR performance. Here, we use ASR with chunked long-form
decoding to improve context usage that may be unavailable when transcribing
with Voice Activity Detection segmentation alone.
|
[
-0.30157727,
-0.4933283925,
0.2789641619,
0.3888251185,
-0.4451873004,
0.6084045172,
-0.3577302694,
-0.6347687244,
0.1713663042,
0.5411080122,
-0.7472604513,
-0.2555857599,
-0.5172070861,
0.3226663768,
-0.6635176539,
0.7873882651,
-0.1806687564,
0.4168692529,
-0.1329756379,
-0.0780480057,
-0.6024794579,
-0.3689987957,
-0.6094035506,
-0.6559516191,
0.3855315149,
0.2479332834,
0.3431571722,
0.7739704847,
0.4058547914,
0.2839413881,
-0.261428237,
0.216884926,
-0.3914708793,
0.331127584,
-0.1114195511,
-0.3082488775,
-0.7630620003,
-0.3129609823,
0.8833096623,
0.60857445,
-0.0647480413,
0.2066382468,
0.2566366494,
0.376221329,
-0.3401225209,
-0.036600668,
-0.691652596,
0.0156735964,
-0.4375781417,
-0.499375999,
-0.2742437422,
0.0294448454,
0.0284647532,
-0.4609194398,
-0.1471777707,
0.0935255215,
0.5074486732,
0.6223484278,
-0.5284977555,
-0.3844089508,
-0.8897806406,
0.8306929469,
-0.8544661999,
0.510160923,
0.2973659635,
0.2695563138,
-0.4141399264,
-0.8605974317,
-0.3626318872,
-0.0628892258,
0.2612432241,
0.3778226972,
-0.2481064349,
0.3577046692,
0.0380394608,
0.5006579161,
-0.4258514643,
0.3322601616,
-0.2058781981,
-0.216933012,
0.6485490203,
0.1518285871,
0.0762161091,
0.0892895386,
-0.3162649274,
0.0255067088,
-0.7072304487,
0.0030835448,
0.0888829529,
0.5934460759,
-0.1391079575,
0.6130824685,
-0.1692946553,
0.6421607733,
0.230118081,
-0.4060064256,
0.2080578059,
-0.5223575234,
-0.1364507377,
0.3887886703,
0.7352153063,
0.0507354811,
-0.177921176,
-0.1572909653,
-0.4483371377,
-0.3789546788,
0.0871489719,
-0.6604684591,
0.1896240711,
0.3594284654,
-0.2597930133,
-0.2232533395,
-0.1441730708,
-0.3697400391,
-0.242317006,
-0.5119189024,
0.6703467965,
-0.062844947,
0.0337329693,
-0.0990724638,
-0.0899024308,
0.0630789101,
0.5495709777,
-0.3508215845,
0.4799300432,
0.5235548019,
0.8918116689,
-0.4155173898,
-0.1840638965,
-1.1121872663,
0.178348124,
-0.3402870595,
0.5439296961,
-0.1496372074,
-0.5032632947,
0.039950639,
-0.0708706528,
0.1747465879,
-0.6440340281,
0.5039174557,
-0.4759419262,
0.068813853,
-0.2809398472,
-0.6756185293,
0.091962941,
0.2342024446,
-0.4513499439,
1.2956066132,
-0.0814195201,
-0.4064954221,
-0.0051425532,
-0.6265969872,
-0.472927928,
0.2426219434,
0.0324067138,
-0.250192374,
0.1074476764,
-0.018064931,
0.3571566045,
-0.3627990484,
0.4785044491,
-0.0789290145,
-0.2915565073,
0.3867282867,
-0.4096875489,
0.552963078,
0.113268666,
-0.6142920256,
0.3874697983,
-0.7347431779,
0.1227970943,
-0.3094601631,
-0.7088310719,
0.0096963253,
0.0771762878,
0.3815461993,
0.3369126916,
0.1564371139,
-0.5756926537,
0.0835226923,
-0.3940307796,
0.6577795744,
0.5816714168,
-0.3119399846,
0.5565136671,
-0.3541993201,
0.4880315661,
-0.1887966394,
0.0027007598,
0.0470619723,
-0.6695424914,
-0.9155102968,
-0.385769397,
0.4369280338,
0.7480732203,
-0.8526852131,
0.6176515818,
-0.4962849021,
-0.2614027262,
-0.5763335824,
0.1256832182,
0.469771117,
0.4311901629,
0.6013946533,
-0.2900834084,
-0.6804918647,
-0.4795475006,
-0.087678656,
-0.0974305943,
-0.0518819429,
0.0059660356,
0.2635307908,
-0.434989512,
0.9763721824,
-0.0006688667,
-0.3795016408,
-0.4011780024,
0.1306147575,
0.0303674154,
0.3933696747,
-0.172456488,
-0.6271933317,
-0.5881323218,
0.2138364315,
-0.3381167054,
-0.5095822215,
-0.0398867913,
0.0475751087,
0.1903726757,
0.7733009458,
-0.5075423717,
0.5411732197,
0.6453558207,
0.0208477415,
0.3919007778,
-0.2532373667,
0.0574096851,
-1.2363718748,
-0.092754446,
-0.3575491905,
-0.8545283675,
-0.8901427984,
-0.0224825032,
0.1493712664,
-0.0073848646,
-0.6668488383,
0.6153231263,
-0.5610974431,
-0.3772493303,
-0.5477513075,
0.3934643567,
-0.0839366466,
0.0583993606,
-0.1531462073,
0.7732424736,
0.2986922264,
-0.4738588929,
0.3315136433,
0.2378712595,
-0.143273592,
0.4033556581,
-0.3258742392,
0.0729149729,
0.1171819195,
0.8303704262,
-0.8044709563,
-0.3541987836,
0.2223148644,
-0.4047740102,
0.582749486,
0.0946108624,
-0.582898736,
-0.1724050045,
-0.2841426432,
0.3995199203,
0.4902173281,
-0.6058318615,
0.6759605408,
0.2975248992,
-0.3357636929,
-0.4026293159,
-1.0061193705,
0.4970833361,
-0.2471773326,
-0.4635891318,
0.9425198436,
-0.3668966293,
-0.196782887,
-0.1801967025,
-0.1522156298,
-0.039058499,
-0.2430149764,
0.1790416837,
0.0127000613,
-0.3133451641,
-0.0453825705,
0.2418652922,
-0.0352317207,
-0.2226126492,
-0.5297832489,
0.5849916935,
0.165686205,
-0.3755156398,
-0.5047254562,
0.43437621,
0.5810072422,
0.0292145684,
0.2972047627,
0.7516975999,
-0.4189230502,
-0.1553147137,
-0.7778511643,
0.0383491144,
-0.4695456326,
0.3183044493,
-0.4288994074,
-1.1362565756,
0.5955308676,
-0.1184786931,
0.0561720692,
0.3412329853,
0.5629921556,
-0.236405015,
0.8540802002,
0.3928169608,
-0.108358182,
0.5703282356,
-0.0254633464,
0.1322490871,
-1.1643662453,
-0.3302750885,
-0.356921792,
-0.4479064941,
-0.5909050703,
-0.8282658458,
0.3858703673,
0.2697969079,
0.1678583324,
0.3637554049,
-0.3397755623,
0.3167775273,
0.5894297957,
0.0746227801,
0.5683723688,
-0.1246444136,
0.12643601,
0.0631988943,
-0.729665041,
-0.2267735153,
0.9164218307,
0.3393379748,
0.5732910633,
0.0708884373,
0.6667227149,
0.247582525,
0.2301699966,
-0.9795019627,
0.5087711215,
-0.3199951649,
-0.5423022509,
-0.2875325382,
-0.4918791056,
-0.6726965904,
0.2411209792,
0.0705055445,
-0.5109746456,
-0.0206317287,
0.1309408098,
-0.2584900558,
0.1913988739,
-0.1593812406,
0.301227808,
-0.2728152871,
-0.0547680296,
-0.1336138248,
-0.911018312,
0.2068852037,
-0.4169686735,
0.4616261721,
0.009382871,
-0.2264987677,
0.5846198201,
-0.5949222445,
0.8424729109,
0.1435809433,
-0.2969837189,
0.1844549179,
-0.1826556176,
0.6425857544,
-0.1983419508,
-0.0850295797,
0.1756719947,
0.0726450458,
-0.1278697848,
-0.3386016786,
0.8226906061,
-0.6733837128,
-0.4581679702,
-0.4524653256,
-0.7899999619,
-0.276298821,
0.2043673992,
0.5468161702,
0.7360858917,
-0.0634407103,
0.34129408,
0.6542175412,
-0.0739616603,
0.6512455344,
0.4249491394,
-0.3171764314,
-0.8398117423,
0.8677421212,
0.43655774,
0.6419368386,
0.563336134,
0.4023345113,
-0.449260205,
-0.6921460629,
-0.7449743748,
-0.0049376213,
-0.8726198077,
-0.4137634933,
-0.6815443039,
-0.3686912358,
-0.433273077,
-0.2444346696,
-0.3792204857,
-0.5845565796,
-0.5444466472,
0.2940322161,
0.2138774693,
0.884696722,
-0.0597254187,
0.5905531049,
-0.8385853171,
0.2354323119,
0.0547809526,
-0.1838630587,
-0.221243009,
-0.991892755,
-0.2962683439,
0.1935939789,
-0.3222149312,
-0.5925137401,
0.4451748729,
0.537397325,
0.3644776046,
0.0794007629,
0.1465214938,
1.2512872219,
-0.6919836998,
0.7423892617,
0.237649858,
-1.1811269522,
0.4160418808,
-0.4699308574,
0.6680290103,
0.5407665968,
0.0450801961,
-0.4017626345,
-0.6478986144,
-0.2230519801,
-0.9518648982,
0.8396881223,
0.4251191914,
0.0794845149,
0.3613985181,
0.2552517951,
0.0271341577,
0.2111412138,
-0.6340171695,
-0.1848500818,
-0.0268081855,
-0.3606287241,
-0.139781341,
-0.0413760692,
-0.0414773859,
-0.3467452824,
0.8880524039,
-0.0687213689,
0.0233995393,
0.1184243113,
-0.2136691511,
-0.3366990685,
0.2200519741,
0.8136105537,
0.340955168,
-0.120066531,
0.1085073799,
0.5297042131,
-0.5991443992,
0.2166748494,
0.1722899228,
-0.0561805107,
0.2034414709,
0.4340772927,
0.7364061475,
0.5288162827,
-0.6248860955,
0.4359458387,
0.0895332471,
-0.260061413,
-0.2927738428,
-0.3389398456,
0.081016317,
0.3381525874,
0.4623523951,
0.2598824203,
0.2162577212,
-0.5427650809,
0.1135060117,
0.3809348047,
-0.4818263054,
-0.3899592757,
0.6282684207,
0.3799615502,
-0.4852149785,
0.1687179059,
-0.2159860432,
-0.6106133461,
0.2116630971,
0.8100663424,
0.9969577193,
-0.3858671486,
-0.2074986398,
0.1314546913,
0.2876203656,
-0.3945700824,
0.0730099902,
-0.1626758575,
-0.3011488914,
-0.7644181252,
-0.7410659194,
-0.5725144148,
0.2387673557,
-0.6809405088,
0.5131798983,
-0.1017233431,
-0.2210554332,
-0.394446671,
-0.2106907964,
-0.3399110436,
0.2956147492,
0.1602136791,
0.8146451116,
-0.4760887325,
1.0634816885,
0.5623780489,
-0.0271723736,
-0.6776736379,
0.3635665774,
0.2262338698,
-0.5808438063,
0.4949587584,
0.1347412914,
-0.3427034914,
0.323533535,
-0.1342803091,
-1.2596535683,
1.3135670424,
0.380931735,
-0.7195410132,
-0.0688884035,
0.3617387414,
0.3035496771,
-0.2600224614,
0.0565810129,
0.3724603355,
0.3235207796,
0.4971348047,
-1.4806399345,
-0.0628222376,
-0.0063200374,
0.0894139484,
0.1626833826,
-0.3510423601,
0.5966793299,
0.2649970353,
-0.1478825957,
0.3390486538,
0.5862383842,
0.2924734652,
0.4012105763,
0.4312935472,
0.3415508866,
0.5840120316,
-0.0651362166,
0.8396307826,
-0.1070683151,
0.0391809084,
1.3591029644,
-0.2113153636,
1.2186368704,
0.6753913164,
-0.1196701303,
0.1772772819,
0.7200188041,
0.5615721345,
0.5990651846,
0.3403197825,
-0.5284695029,
-0.2129019946,
-0.3016191125,
-0.4572013617,
0.4327659011,
0.3263106346,
-0.027655974,
-0.0871835053,
0.3329946995,
-0.1161681265,
-0.2235845476,
-0.4397601485,
0.8479596972,
0.453966707,
-0.5528780818,
0.5126712322,
0.097148262,
0.8825161457,
-0.6884427071,
0.27055493,
-0.074355036,
0.178281635,
-0.3188373148,
-0.5565688014,
0.3502252698,
0.1183471233,
-0.1065603346,
-0.6019009948,
0.764089644,
-0.7449699044,
-0.5547776222,
0.4405429363,
0.4003769755,
0.2203454375,
-0.1876862496,
-0.4814220071,
0.4808131754,
-0.0029673961,
-0.1180165708,
0.4412510991,
0.436272949,
-0.2525155246,
0.7072309256,
0.6637054086,
0.2597516775,
0.3414264619,
0.2928803563,
1.0309391022,
-0.3885646462,
-0.4737169147,
-0.8903169632,
0.9145982862,
0.0864654705,
-0.1452448517,
0.7597601414,
0.6230661273,
0.768324554,
0.1371924281,
0.7110698819,
0.0151937027,
0.3914030492,
-0.5829443932,
0.5412663221,
-0.6882292032,
0.219963789,
-0.3046630025,
-1.0373651981,
-0.4113968909,
0.3186527789,
0.0321768411,
-0.3121038377,
0.6854487062,
0.6878900528,
-0.0422000363,
-0.1034218445,
0.4958509803,
0.0638969392,
0.3842412531,
0.0141544342,
0.9447286725,
-0.7322227359,
0.8251335025,
-0.1286795288,
-0.3176446855,
-0.3070658445,
-0.956992507,
-0.7557050586,
-0.6904679537,
-0.4937107265,
-0.3009953797,
-0.0372853167,
1.0793964863,
0.7486432195,
-0.8315415382,
-0.5561721325,
-0.2407934368,
-0.3106869161,
0.0895715058,
-0.1196266785,
-0.1708940715,
-0.2476540059,
-0.7372923493,
1.0871562958,
0.5060794353,
0.0776778385,
-0.2351030409,
-0.4259451628,
-0.1434727907,
0.0943420082,
0.7891495824,
-0.1136068851,
-1.2112221718,
-0.1140443459,
0.0544925258,
0.0283914153,
0.0781449825,
0.7135055065,
-0.5312029719,
0.5875807405,
0.516143918,
0.7399922013,
0.770562768,
0.074170962,
0.6338834167,
-0.9158047438,
-0.0818731934,
0.2411714345,
0.1785233468,
0.4749405086,
-0.2304302305,
0.2263742834,
0.0466312394,
-0.6638186574,
-1.1046090126,
0.0950077698,
-1.0933798552,
0.0559157394,
1.2177960873,
-0.0154400123,
0.047276143,
-0.3068924546,
-0.1870314926,
0.4870187938,
-0.3865725696,
0.3139651716,
0.6502876282,
-0.2625259161,
-0.0304131117,
-0.7014521956,
0.4371444881,
0.3027696609,
-0.8464050293,
-0.1206338555,
0.2897258699,
0.1699474603,
0.1355459094,
0.8476358056,
-0.001510368,
0.0514933467,
-0.3326609135,
-0.0894358456,
0.0556790605,
-0.107501626,
-0.536021471,
-0.2654815614,
0.0894623473,
-0.2194239646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16772v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16772v2
|
OlympicArena Medal Ranks: Who Is the Most Intelligent AI So Far?
| 2024-06-24T16:31:12 | 2024-06-26T15:00:04 |
Zhen Huang, Zengzhi Wang, Shijie Xia, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this report, we pose the following question: Who is the most intelligent
AI model to date, as measured by the OlympicArena (an Olympic-level,
multi-discipline, multi-modal benchmark for superintelligent AI)? We
specifically focus on the most recently released models: Claude-3.5-Sonnet,
Gemini-1.5-Pro, and GPT-4o. For the first time, we propose using an Olympic
medal Table approach to rank AI models based on their comprehensive performance
across various disciplines. Empirical results reveal: (1) Claude-3.5-Sonnet
shows highly competitive overall performance over GPT-4o, even surpassing
GPT-4o on a few subjects (i.e., Physics, Chemistry, and Biology). (2)
Gemini-1.5-Pro and GPT-4V are ranked consecutively just behind GPT-4o and
Claude-3.5-Sonnet, but with a clear performance gap between them. (3) The
performance of AI models from the open-source community significantly lags
behind these proprietary models. (4) The performance of these models on this
benchmark has been less than satisfactory, indicating that we still have a long
way to go before achieving superintelligence. We remain committed to
continuously tracking and evaluating the performance of the latest powerful
models on this benchmark (available at
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/OlympicArena).
|
[
-0.5716109276,
-0.248867631,
0.899862051,
-0.1307576746,
-0.1290557534,
-0.0371179432,
0.1127173603,
-1.0117424726,
0.0072961496,
0.2667766809,
-0.2185249925,
-0.4455054402,
-1.0142554045,
0.0662126988,
-0.7137215734,
1.1394190788,
0.2355536669,
0.3278621137,
-0.3543568552,
-0.4335612357,
-0.387151897,
-0.4326459765,
-0.7481566072,
-0.679612577,
0.6882977486,
0.3450768292,
0.4519108236,
0.7364271879,
0.7313476205,
0.3529790342,
0.0200970918,
0.0006536136,
-0.2856768072,
-0.076084286,
-0.221288234,
-0.6576545835,
-0.7086883783,
0.34556216,
0.1201000884,
0.4637268782,
0.3116396368,
0.4659781158,
-0.2569014728,
0.6255115271,
-0.1831047684,
0.1916731149,
-0.6058582664,
-0.1062967256,
-0.2571723163,
0.1603403836,
-0.1130373627,
-0.322643131,
0.1245082915,
-0.6842125654,
0.0015664884,
0.3071986735,
0.5038545728,
0.4689691365,
-0.2687041163,
-0.0069417544,
-0.6813166738,
0.7308963537,
-0.5668722391,
0.0684949234,
0.2694796026,
0.3680921197,
0.1873943806,
-0.9799750447,
-0.4878621697,
-0.6570261121,
0.6058636904,
0.5225070715,
-0.1746808887,
-0.3037843406,
0.0115310457,
-0.1064022109,
-0.7914649844,
0.3260827065,
-0.625315547,
0.2870777845,
0.992551744,
0.2103838474,
0.2160508335,
0.4118248224,
-0.083304286,
0.0702413768,
-0.4735756516,
-0.2167553157,
0.4044454992,
-0.0547526702,
0.0026410136,
0.6078233123,
-0.2118294686,
0.2419528514,
-0.2069596648,
0.4231491685,
0.1220953912,
-0.0305434298,
0.2174676955,
0.3863121867,
0.9669326544,
0.3849211037,
0.412216872,
-0.4678607881,
-0.2738208175,
0.1871802956,
0.3439521492,
-0.5440158844,
-0.5843588114,
0.351238668,
-0.4682520926,
-0.1861423999,
0.2486895621,
-0.3463209569,
-0.4578683972,
-0.1434776187,
0.7566928267,
-0.3437199891,
-0.0972136408,
-0.2898536921,
-0.0301693585,
-0.143780008,
0.408572495,
-0.6239331961,
0.1404076368,
1.1194941998,
0.8208479285,
-0.135035947,
-0.5811502337,
-0.2365274727,
-0.2299753428,
-0.6213156581,
0.8995630145,
-0.6147388816,
-0.0854491964,
-0.4313360453,
-0.4567854404,
-0.0976930633,
-0.5700564981,
0.4820837975,
-0.7352433801,
0.0595367849,
-0.205838263,
-0.6678754091,
-0.2268718034,
0.3003126085,
-0.743307054,
0.7236237526,
-0.2099052221,
-0.6774225235,
0.3439678848,
-0.9838908911,
0.022477217,
0.1690963507,
-0.060082484,
-0.3201864958,
0.0091434922,
0.0935618281,
0.3682196736,
-0.7653543353,
0.2232959569,
-0.5089166164,
-0.4995625913,
0.4459667504,
-0.1838004887,
0.4746668637,
0.2524543405,
-0.5826884508,
0.2600454986,
-0.791380465,
-0.0170180537,
-0.0663468912,
0.0550568476,
0.1251631081,
0.049378898,
-0.1447789669,
0.3514303863,
0.367588222,
-0.7604472041,
0.0179501213,
-0.1139274612,
0.7205305099,
0.8577447534,
-0.1306353658,
0.1618997157,
-0.631809175,
0.3763899803,
-0.2409594506,
0.4220626652,
0.3261356056,
-0.9718812704,
-0.546649456,
-0.304309845,
0.5222241879,
0.7182235718,
-0.3730866611,
0.3940939307,
-0.3825798929,
-0.9799317718,
-0.5998620391,
-0.2135468423,
0.3112714589,
0.5387966633,
0.2463818938,
-0.1218060032,
-0.0106039178,
-0.990327239,
-0.5023776293,
-0.379914254,
0.1843993813,
0.078022249,
1.0783289671,
0.0233170316,
0.593018651,
0.0046924925,
-0.0414237864,
-0.3082480729,
0.5533342957,
0.3471984863,
0.7128078938,
0.4589525461,
-0.8229637146,
-0.3874459863,
0.2579371929,
-1.1292665005,
0.0537930951,
0.2427191585,
-0.0792766213,
-0.2063267827,
0.2489931732,
-0.4479114413,
0.4123743773,
0.3241591454,
-0.2365496755,
0.6288817525,
-0.2139025182,
0.4389621019,
-0.8104593158,
0.5382444859,
-0.0599434189,
-0.1513410956,
-0.7038671374,
-0.0261076074,
-0.1729173362,
-0.0557362549,
-0.2396889329,
0.6098378301,
-0.0292785093,
-0.0734097809,
-0.1915544271,
0.1863335371,
-0.4171263874,
0.1831684858,
-0.3048285246,
0.5748078227,
0.8062037826,
-0.5113340616,
0.6888070107,
0.1037906334,
-0.5038641095,
0.4345390499,
-0.8013452888,
0.1887055188,
-0.2594434619,
0.0751217529,
-0.6780796647,
-0.109332785,
0.1696072519,
-0.6771181226,
-0.0781007856,
0.0803194568,
-0.4254594743,
-0.482534945,
-0.2402291,
0.6560609341,
0.3288187385,
-0.4121763408,
0.3019172549,
0.4671327472,
-0.3604363501,
-0.5245264769,
-0.8665909767,
0.1018302292,
-0.2373096794,
-0.5321172476,
0.0572687089,
-0.3321872354,
-0.2862893343,
0.1575282663,
-0.0010778685,
-0.0263273548,
0.2613119483,
0.1824224591,
0.2175061554,
-0.1889639646,
-0.1122535244,
-0.4101592302,
-0.4801826477,
0.0247086491,
-0.3425777853,
0.2824885249,
-0.4979495406,
-0.4490967691,
-0.8617241979,
0.2780647576,
0.9871051311,
-0.5811854601,
0.9512760043,
0.3404979706,
-0.2944660783,
0.2344562858,
-0.3955056071,
-0.0417292491,
-0.3295188248,
0.4632141888,
-0.140327096,
-0.6148195267,
0.8720902205,
0.0798453614,
0.1131260991,
0.5737426281,
0.2594576478,
0.0448508337,
1.6514440775,
0.5619383454,
-0.4302451611,
0.4583314657,
-0.6364879608,
0.2247428745,
-0.9216928482,
-0.4427475333,
-0.6860851645,
-0.7270308137,
-0.7038454413,
0.1616985053,
0.8542200327,
-0.2000284046,
-0.688722074,
0.0039475947,
-0.6228485703,
0.2823438644,
0.9638195634,
0.1062807888,
0.184376806,
-0.4988602102,
0.0357804373,
0.222026512,
-0.9652368426,
-0.5500326157,
1.3949056864,
0.13277556,
0.5114462376,
-0.0448674411,
0.8856745958,
0.3705508411,
0.6015740633,
-0.2765265703,
0.568639636,
-0.1655943096,
-0.9065086246,
-0.1814745814,
-0.6034337878,
-1.0156970024,
0.0703876838,
-0.2411124855,
-1.0190330744,
0.006554212,
0.1563110054,
-0.4970115125,
0.4674253464,
-0.2405688763,
0.9032636881,
-0.4519222081,
-0.4316040277,
-0.3243014514,
-0.7645418644,
0.4617925584,
-0.1053601652,
0.2924840748,
-0.2294646502,
-0.0171608515,
0.9615780711,
-0.4446391463,
0.1954889148,
0.036774911,
0.5035099387,
0.2216169536,
-0.2178432494,
0.3160219193,
0.1909009069,
-0.4863882363,
0.1613308042,
-0.0895468369,
-0.5726300478,
-0.2399496436,
0.9331975579,
-1.2426797152,
-0.357170254,
-0.636351347,
-0.2232702821,
-0.13844423,
0.38980335,
0.7081059813,
0.8145090342,
-0.0116153751,
0.124242045,
0.586582303,
0.1095612049,
0.3235777915,
0.1083193794,
0.1163620055,
-0.5105178356,
1.1066814661,
0.4863254726,
-0.3010935783,
0.4029781222,
0.1301703453,
-0.3146312237,
-0.896371007,
-0.5526601076,
0.2877847254,
-0.5045560598,
-0.0359827206,
-0.4908572733,
-0.1917875111,
-0.3501207829,
0.0234883912,
-0.7557019591,
-0.5804317594,
-0.0263964273,
0.098725453,
0.0372801311,
1.2780007124,
0.0761822909,
0.0626976117,
-0.6244935989,
0.1449081302,
0.4461051524,
0.3386289775,
-0.1005883142,
-0.3815226853,
-0.354809016,
-0.2231419235,
-0.1153535545,
-0.6181699634,
-0.0762722492,
-0.060763821,
0.8262913227,
0.3454214334,
0.0261550453,
0.2849062681,
-0.3354719579,
1.1758890152,
0.2101934105,
-0.5876170993,
0.3054818511,
-0.282900095,
0.3552749455,
0.597882688,
0.1904516667,
-0.317301482,
-0.6495203376,
-0.8390915394,
-0.8418672681,
0.9222350717,
0.0187730473,
-0.156873256,
0.0416135751,
0.3783323169,
0.2548081577,
0.4342311621,
-0.6696118712,
-0.2493415326,
-0.2257982045,
-0.41954723,
-0.0084122224,
0.2064212263,
-0.1484069228,
-0.0007648479,
1.0802556276,
0.0113417385,
0.378262043,
0.1686885357,
0.0178063419,
0.0179619659,
-0.1890908331,
0.5143722892,
1.0816680193,
0.1380808651,
0.0523276851,
0.0613151565,
-0.2607253492,
-0.1598055959,
0.3845212162,
-0.3092316389,
-0.4721103013,
0.8683956265,
0.6576408148,
-0.1921819597,
-0.6184488535,
0.3348694742,
-0.2247924805,
-0.2304809242,
-0.3100569546,
0.3678021729,
-0.1732134521,
0.7743632793,
0.3455998003,
0.4285044968,
0.2430119365,
-0.6875977516,
-0.0340568088,
0.3336644173,
-0.4002938867,
-0.4983823895,
1.414003849,
0.2541129589,
-0.2417444289,
0.5370149016,
-0.1067198664,
-0.7192457914,
0.7349487543,
0.1194507256,
0.8794824481,
-0.0083068637,
0.1804329902,
0.2013564259,
0.3083274961,
-0.4229040146,
0.3108325303,
0.1088204309,
-0.3524490595,
0.0550858155,
-0.2470522821,
-0.420275569,
0.1555207819,
-0.2989955544,
-0.2171689421,
-0.4000661671,
-0.3514416516,
0.0327210501,
0.3603297174,
-0.6632329822,
0.2703828812,
0.3630293608,
0.9678480029,
-0.7407983541,
0.4466424286,
1.0845149755,
-0.3366725743,
-0.5409522057,
-0.2596451044,
-0.1536089629,
-0.4738085568,
0.3817851245,
0.179131642,
-0.1703281999,
0.1952591836,
-0.7461004257,
-0.8544880152,
1.2260839939,
0.3953665197,
-0.1838828921,
0.4885761738,
0.0521211587,
0.5486280322,
-0.369508177,
0.6488881707,
0.470300138,
0.7328281403,
-0.2579555809,
-0.7906327248,
-0.4197434485,
-0.6106496453,
-0.1505006403,
-0.0346863195,
-1.1711105108,
0.8018329144,
0.0037189273,
0.3144317269,
0.7466512918,
0.9118096232,
0.2598676682,
0.8505818248,
0.228992939,
0.8105965257,
0.8505765796,
-0.1227561757,
1.0483629704,
-0.5671150684,
-0.0093918471,
0.715362072,
-0.2997327447,
0.6225582957,
-0.0706661567,
0.1065342277,
0.1946208775,
0.6037954092,
0.018088365,
0.461845994,
-0.0990475044,
-0.0267468113,
-0.3253747821,
0.0911049023,
-0.3343665302,
0.4350388646,
-0.1554462761,
-0.2307244092,
0.0512681529,
0.1006276682,
0.1865691096,
0.040934965,
-0.5215266943,
0.5487728119,
-0.1142267585,
-1.1175328493,
0.2850261033,
-0.0029213699,
0.2128440738,
-0.5879510045,
0.0979748145,
-0.323361814,
0.3522399962,
0.0968182012,
-0.6205095053,
-0.3702467382,
0.3393250108,
-0.0303957853,
0.0864892602,
0.2546651661,
-0.1115690246,
-0.5333504677,
0.1909056902,
0.4505027831,
0.4156101644,
-0.057913281,
-0.9957233667,
0.0128610125,
-0.469558239,
-0.3497174382,
0.2220681608,
0.5071134567,
-0.2388654053,
0.9532274008,
0.4353701174,
0.1601482183,
0.2929879725,
0.1030196697,
0.7221671939,
-0.4670542777,
-0.6771059632,
-0.6569911242,
0.3556843698,
-0.1837853491,
-0.9059504271,
0.4260694385,
0.76733464,
0.4903487861,
0.3122402132,
0.9034166336,
-0.0248954501,
0.2139222026,
-0.2918902338,
1.0219703913,
-0.7542417645,
0.1730664968,
-0.2054870576,
-1.0137661695,
-0.3516927958,
0.3982416093,
-0.5363529921,
0.3287034035,
0.5271883011,
0.5452976227,
0.0388245322,
0.2481039613,
0.3631954491,
0.438811332,
0.5148346424,
0.514885962,
0.9993713498,
-0.2598776221,
0.5148064494,
-0.1794433743,
-0.65006423,
-0.5002088547,
-0.5658419728,
-0.6812998652,
-0.4629651904,
-0.3250396848,
0.276871264,
0.349491924,
0.7730295062,
0.9744559526,
-0.8279611468,
-0.0112361712,
-0.1760368198,
0.00878595,
-0.4721689522,
-0.0916140676,
0.2582370043,
-0.0870516971,
-0.96319592,
0.3840624988,
0.3595652878,
-0.4939058125,
0.0391963869,
-0.0960953906,
-0.2047945112,
0.2183754891,
0.2513379753,
0.3524806201,
-0.3880291283,
-0.5704929233,
-0.2238166183,
-0.1137711182,
-0.1902626306,
0.354798615,
-0.6796919703,
0.3604879379,
0.5315944552,
0.4348162115,
0.5240079761,
0.0355168879,
0.2983692288,
0.1822509766,
-0.2197578251,
0.5302739143,
0.3787135482,
0.142336756,
-0.1358339489,
0.7829015851,
0.2881095409,
-1.2445422411,
-0.655174017,
0.0718681291,
-0.7683904171,
-0.291493088,
0.4088883102,
0.001629911,
-0.4567902684,
0.0581421591,
0.0485651605,
0.4012630284,
-0.2959440649,
1.1536015272,
0.6063213944,
-0.93944031,
0.0306917038,
-1.0203919411,
0.0286429934,
0.547326684,
-0.7337811589,
-0.3029095531,
0.095692955,
0.1059007198,
0.2859362662,
0.3706235886,
-0.1709542871,
0.5707039237,
0.166667223,
-0.0817923248,
-0.3502809107,
-0.8053222895,
0.0737543255,
0.173337847,
0.1366861016,
-0.2525525689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16767v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16767v1
|
The GPT-WritingPrompts Dataset: A Comparative Analysis of Character Portrayal in Short Stories
| 2024-06-24T16:24:18 | 2024-06-24T16:24:18 |
Xi Yu Huang, Krishnapriya Vishnubhotla, Frank Rudzicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The improved generative capabilities of large language models have made them
a powerful tool for creative writing and storytelling. It is therefore
important to quantitatively understand the nature of generated stories, and how
they differ from human storytelling. We augment the Reddit WritingPrompts
dataset with short stories generated by GPT-3.5, given the same prompts. We
quantify and compare the emotional and descriptive features of storytelling
from both generative processes, human and machine, along a set of six
dimensions. We find that generated stories differ significantly from human
stories along all six dimensions, and that human and machine generations
display similar biases when grouped according to the narrative point-of-view
and gender of the main protagonist. We release our dataset and code at
https://github.com/KristinHuangg/gpt-writing-prompts.
|
[
-0.5336284637,
-0.5992535949,
0.8577410579,
0.1964495033,
-0.1584115177,
0.1211508438,
-0.2055767775,
-0.5170540214,
0.3791831434,
0.2603718638,
-0.8914166093,
-0.479200542,
-0.4113574326,
0.5689894557,
-0.1935109645,
1.1970516443,
-0.1023470834,
-0.2607863545,
-0.4081636369,
0.0386940464,
-0.4761526287,
-0.4782238305,
-0.5332792401,
-0.071612671,
0.8968546987,
0.2041592598,
0.6899012327,
0.3765546978,
0.5602958202,
0.2169467956,
0.2872183323,
-0.1431851536,
-0.3903711736,
0.2586442828,
0.0451496914,
-0.1155014634,
-0.0599560663,
0.3351297379,
0.598000288,
0.4561319649,
0.1672608256,
0.1890916228,
0.2074394375,
0.6669474244,
-0.2202054858,
0.0270773508,
0.0780732781,
0.14016518,
-0.2702099085,
-0.0976984352,
-0.0417210646,
-0.7371718287,
0.1894474179,
-0.5274692178,
1.1807491779,
0.0884045139,
0.7138442397,
-0.0892209113,
-0.2143591493,
-0.4882116318,
-0.6546065211,
0.5316254497,
-0.2560705543,
-0.1422753781,
0.0579569153,
0.4493571222,
0.2935713828,
-0.6394152045,
-0.7307549119,
-0.4420652092,
-0.4461320341,
-0.0839553028,
-0.3669366539,
-0.2272868305,
0.5384878516,
0.6064929366,
-1.2314130068,
0.0880157053,
-0.4683699608,
-0.278241843,
0.7879288793,
0.5170006752,
0.5536504984,
-0.4219377935,
-0.0982945338,
-0.2935521305,
-0.7523444295,
-0.0927481055,
0.876462996,
0.1330242902,
-0.330155611,
0.5992267132,
-0.0569780134,
0.3677632213,
-0.0590256937,
-0.1414166689,
0.3912535608,
-0.2142787576,
0.0899805427,
0.0966092944,
1.1436936855,
0.8284853101,
0.3542904854,
0.0418385118,
-0.0948179588,
0.2566210926,
0.2348544598,
-0.7203813791,
-0.3703834116,
-0.0387710221,
-0.6391243935,
-0.3100009561,
0.1572310627,
-0.7111209631,
-0.9911031127,
-0.2788125575,
0.1751377732,
-0.3455931246,
-0.1421403885,
-0.1013120115,
-0.5998325944,
0.0055123321,
0.0927454084,
-1.0079568624,
0.0289707799,
0.6248043776,
0.8935036063,
-0.172435984,
-0.4307711124,
-0.0526074022,
-0.3246901333,
-0.1407705098,
0.8932065964,
-0.3193047643,
-0.3961749077,
-0.2868683636,
-0.223721832,
0.0434790216,
-0.6937016845,
0.6343076229,
0.0564506873,
0.5585919023,
-0.6919627786,
-0.2889938056,
0.0020001342,
0.0209433306,
-0.855458498,
0.7913373113,
0.3960782588,
-0.8924124837,
0.6746462584,
-0.7019800544,
-0.2984983921,
0.0448256657,
-0.2654233873,
-0.3885922432,
0.2643297613,
0.4256598055,
0.569472909,
-0.4771114588,
0.0937528163,
-0.1745915115,
-0.4428064227,
0.3029714823,
-0.3143889606,
0.5235427022,
0.2147004455,
-0.1538432091,
0.0351856425,
-0.6522781253,
-0.1919647455,
0.4461739659,
0.0399639569,
-0.000640596,
-0.1874342114,
-0.0951211825,
0.0450258963,
-0.060685996,
-0.6205160022,
0.3520148098,
-0.0428861305,
0.6117607355,
0.2868773043,
0.4124073386,
0.1048703417,
-0.568349421,
0.8327085376,
-0.0703377351,
0.0182216708,
-0.1081784591,
-0.597099781,
-0.2244736552,
-0.3320150673,
-0.018983772,
0.3529472947,
-0.6320774555,
0.2934435606,
-0.1444771588,
-0.5079693794,
-0.5369746685,
-0.2896434665,
0.4008064568,
0.5452793241,
0.2339865118,
-0.1203631312,
-0.5183279514,
-1.0182620287,
-0.5452703834,
-0.3118291795,
-0.6454955339,
-0.0606387816,
0.3784296513,
0.0145908687,
0.8841099739,
-0.7119708061,
-0.0176407732,
-0.6288068295,
0.5887916684,
0.2189984024,
0.3289460242,
0.868970871,
-0.440888375,
-0.7596322298,
-0.2532726228,
-0.8440881371,
-0.4096494615,
-0.3050047755,
0.0877062753,
0.0374665521,
-0.0106871082,
-1.0283610821,
0.4217399955,
0.2735235691,
-0.6666334867,
1.0500862598,
-0.0342420228,
0.4628151655,
-0.8717962503,
-0.0645342469,
0.2964548767,
-0.0157448202,
-0.3673249781,
-0.3415057957,
-0.1794278473,
-0.346126914,
-0.2006336451,
0.3611604273,
-0.5251342654,
-0.4568741322,
0.0513941236,
0.2388675064,
0.4095169902,
0.3129278719,
-0.027610464,
0.959117949,
0.3403365612,
-0.1603606343,
0.7154177427,
0.2062723786,
-0.5485264659,
0.7537860274,
-0.7514163852,
0.2124708593,
-0.2690216899,
0.2174607217,
-0.6951010823,
-0.3796586394,
0.3537565768,
-0.6611612439,
0.0008424221,
0.1102490798,
-0.7827852964,
-0.5458254218,
-0.4496768117,
0.1238799915,
0.8015535474,
-0.2754422128,
0.3070606291,
-0.1423877478,
-0.6757394671,
0.0118323071,
-0.5071149468,
0.1509787142,
-0.7994663715,
-0.5798922777,
0.3211715519,
-0.1039909497,
-0.4930103123,
-0.0168091152,
0.3579210341,
0.1664918661,
-0.4187328517,
0.2455529571,
-0.0411804244,
-0.2850601077,
0.0638657734,
-0.0417641401,
-0.2877072692,
0.3029786348,
0.0968022346,
0.3817338049,
-0.0747256875,
-0.2290614098,
-0.5787501335,
0.6372109652,
0.424028784,
0.0166354794,
0.5817012787,
0.7885431051,
0.0657295734,
0.0023980357,
-0.2849510014,
-0.1143514737,
-0.3629263043,
0.183518067,
-0.3638957441,
-0.7938746214,
0.67373842,
0.634704113,
-0.1255538017,
0.8137552142,
0.5416777134,
-0.2501042485,
1.0943832397,
0.5835718513,
0.1014500931,
0.254126966,
-0.0518361479,
0.2300052196,
-0.6080379486,
-0.0395983942,
-0.4559770226,
-0.5335304737,
-0.4725587666,
0.0256153848,
0.3831323683,
-0.0190632716,
-0.4692896307,
0.1346560419,
-0.5435174704,
0.885471642,
0.6338763237,
-0.0779389963,
0.2379985005,
-0.0327789411,
0.1515368074,
-0.4675453603,
-0.4992661476,
-0.7542203069,
0.7913069129,
0.3412512839,
0.4064229429,
0.0436803438,
0.6375225782,
0.5876101851,
0.1678779572,
-0.3650045693,
0.365096122,
-0.3097446263,
-0.3449913561,
-0.0766653493,
-0.6388402581,
-0.7248313427,
0.0945339203,
-0.0988338888,
-0.8349334598,
0.0990073234,
0.008853239,
-0.7220156789,
0.1978607923,
-1.1355046034,
0.9538033009,
-0.1449456513,
-0.0035146254,
0.1064537838,
-0.6675786972,
0.2368748337,
0.1437149197,
-0.3232848346,
-0.2874201536,
0.4027504325,
0.7753667235,
-0.5589537024,
0.9294928312,
-0.2883065343,
-0.0224483944,
0.7444096208,
0.1740091592,
0.2326999456,
0.2150004953,
0.0358810052,
-0.0843038484,
-0.0790590793,
-0.2897652984,
-0.673949182,
0.6003706455,
-0.8714516759,
-0.3744654059,
-0.4294216633,
-0.6355509758,
-0.0965673625,
-0.1869881451,
0.7363190651,
0.5268987417,
-0.4622572958,
-0.1100252047,
0.1961780339,
-0.4075162113,
0.5757656693,
0.0513147786,
-0.1110832766,
-0.2830230892,
0.899836123,
-0.0339548886,
0.2067569792,
0.2113230675,
0.3497263789,
-0.5053317547,
-0.2386294752,
-0.3385653794,
0.395776093,
-0.6394010782,
-0.1120808944,
-0.4933454394,
-0.1366614848,
-0.1959969252,
-0.3746420741,
0.0513137467,
-0.3090316951,
-0.4486835301,
-0.4720733464,
0.5761882663,
0.9789299965,
-0.1102476344,
0.2282734066,
-0.8006173968,
0.4770334065,
0.3746572435,
0.0932152718,
-0.186206162,
-0.2461155504,
0.0256008152,
-0.0712175742,
-0.4257445335,
-0.7391136885,
0.4947384894,
0.1336594522,
0.2031188607,
0.3175881207,
0.0169835519,
0.4406486452,
-0.2079422921,
1.2478638887,
0.3174413741,
-0.8079641461,
0.4994325042,
-0.6777118444,
0.3676544726,
0.4255039096,
0.45761621,
-0.7076354623,
-0.2245207876,
-0.7526180744,
-0.4893617034,
0.3872079551,
0.4414176643,
0.0085015837,
-0.0614094846,
0.429112047,
0.6417879462,
0.1233288944,
-0.6265100837,
0.1568942964,
-0.3300053477,
-0.4260214865,
-0.3328204453,
-0.343059063,
-0.0042281304,
-0.2415226698,
0.1221278384,
-0.046369087,
0.610573411,
0.0962286741,
-0.0092561822,
-0.055378858,
0.0665642992,
0.6001892686,
0.7418724895,
-0.0964407772,
0.188422665,
-0.01427182,
-0.610852778,
-0.0142329661,
-0.0454837866,
0.005386468,
0.1431821436,
0.9764832258,
1.1089730263,
-0.2617257535,
-0.5559462905,
0.3788437247,
-0.2863363624,
-0.5041496754,
-0.0501077697,
0.1962729245,
-0.0626982078,
0.4998235404,
0.2215669304,
-0.1894216835,
0.0756236017,
-0.6002675295,
-0.1539914757,
-0.2124585062,
-0.1529790759,
-0.6868053079,
0.4413114488,
0.2634458244,
-0.201356858,
1.0075725317,
-0.4528535604,
-0.2711482644,
0.7869663239,
0.4193666577,
1.1374961138,
0.1907871962,
0.6430150867,
0.4340743721,
0.072786063,
0.1364652365,
0.2979061604,
0.2305101901,
-0.4817466438,
-0.2223429531,
-0.6233837008,
-0.1439059526,
0.2544974685,
-0.6237034798,
0.2005810142,
-0.15001297,
-0.0758404955,
0.1240005717,
0.0704367831,
-0.5820376277,
0.1390265822,
-0.0180368926,
0.3001993597,
-1.0455161333,
0.2376035005,
0.4833592176,
-0.506868422,
-0.5762545466,
0.2851313949,
0.1190323532,
-0.298323065,
0.5018213391,
0.3357846439,
0.1661206037,
-0.0751013234,
-0.3501684964,
-0.3560699821,
1.1056821346,
0.4893502891,
-0.4647586346,
-0.1024405137,
0.4890699983,
0.9200685024,
-0.5444319844,
0.0263992101,
0.6445813179,
0.3978971243,
-0.1720125973,
-0.7231280208,
-0.0289995354,
-0.2561523318,
0.0528147556,
0.1194077656,
-0.3077996373,
1.0166962147,
-0.4404357076,
-0.5265448093,
0.1239129454,
0.5224586129,
0.521237731,
0.3383448124,
0.2714444399,
0.4161707163,
0.5755341053,
-0.2483202666,
1.3492299318,
0.065420039,
0.2492512017,
0.8727975488,
-0.3257431984,
0.1599954516,
0.1495450288,
-0.366427213,
0.4824285209,
0.9038789868,
-0.0802783519,
0.4284880757,
0.2718072236,
-0.342746377,
0.0192236807,
0.1817009002,
-0.500482738,
0.0787838474,
-0.0186987929,
-0.5081673265,
-0.2524336576,
0.2497575134,
-0.00763248,
0.1054154783,
-0.1477705836,
0.8510611653,
0.1236814409,
-0.4109697342,
0.3074841201,
-0.2443240434,
0.3243024349,
-0.3692122102,
-0.0105114793,
-0.3503817022,
-0.1132092699,
0.0041528107,
-1.2036137581,
0.5010457039,
0.4358265996,
-0.5499335527,
-0.4389875829,
0.6525076628,
-0.2095379829,
-0.4093902111,
-0.2846131325,
0.6027115583,
0.225234583,
-0.4345681667,
-0.4701514244,
0.0127871865,
-0.1677429974,
-0.1995017231,
0.2158253789,
0.8008253574,
-0.2629795372,
0.3115345538,
0.3006258905,
-0.0820165053,
-0.1616813242,
0.4465980828,
0.6001204848,
-0.895681262,
-0.8371237516,
-0.8621255755,
0.653540194,
-0.1027562246,
-0.6598470211,
0.6877233386,
0.493253231,
0.4000031352,
-0.5223503709,
0.9364225864,
-0.324116081,
0.8669233322,
-0.5950806737,
0.806846559,
-0.0764102638,
0.1520707756,
-0.1247748956,
-1.1851409674,
-0.1260303557,
0.3294011056,
-0.4160242379,
0.3302721083,
0.956628561,
0.5757963657,
0.0974666551,
0.108493425,
0.0336719081,
-0.0385198742,
0.2227211595,
0.4165036678,
1.235023737,
0.0709222555,
0.1110414267,
-0.1727761179,
0.0055045676,
-0.0112915384,
-0.8698301315,
-0.9405294657,
-0.7789908648,
-0.351585567,
-0.0259196647,
0.0775620267,
0.4291332066,
0.2745063007,
-0.4763038754,
0.0954471305,
-0.079883337,
-0.1026696414,
-0.2177675962,
-0.2928646505,
0.2782607675,
0.0106809633,
-0.4483709633,
0.114384234,
0.0135704214,
0.239420563,
-0.3711063266,
-0.0521433949,
0.4826776981,
-0.0931361988,
0.5584283471,
0.1909248382,
-0.446505338,
-0.5568885803,
-0.2295814008,
-0.0750135854,
0.1814061403,
1.2195919752,
-0.6602066159,
0.0349969827,
0.7069000602,
-0.0039522746,
0.3099346459,
0.2128520906,
0.6400141716,
-1.1306787729,
-0.1013903692,
0.2502967715,
0.2152082026,
0.5352889299,
-0.6777265668,
0.4042629004,
0.4403582215,
-0.5768933296,
-0.4879004657,
0.4199317694,
-0.8117830753,
-0.1585613787,
0.9420832396,
-0.0571383983,
0.0446332023,
0.1082718596,
-0.4784130454,
0.0343115069,
-0.2579246163,
0.8589739799,
0.7946295142,
-0.5639142394,
-0.4005950391,
-0.6629123688,
0.6670208573,
-0.1089261919,
-0.8909714222,
0.202654317,
0.7235916257,
0.1930802315,
0.0252652615,
0.5918875337,
-0.0396982022,
0.133886978,
0.3521997035,
0.2066061199,
-0.093866989,
-0.400706917,
-0.074989222,
0.3807778955,
-0.2441068441,
0.0937769935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16758v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16758v1
|
Towards Fast Multilingual LLM Inference: Speculative Decoding and Specialized Drafters
| 2024-06-24T16:06:50 | 2024-06-24T16:06:50 |
Euiin Yi, Taehyeon Kim, Hongseok Jeung, Du-Seong Chang, Se-Young Yun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
and broadened their applicability across diverse commercial applications.
However, the deployment of these models is constrained by high inference time
in multilingual settings. To mitigate this challenge, this paper explores a
training recipe of an assistant model in speculative decoding, which are
leveraged to draft and-then its future tokens are verified by the target LLM.
We show that language-specific draft models, optimized through a targeted
pretrain-and-finetune strategy, substantially brings a speedup of inference
time compared to the previous methods. We validate these models across various
languages in inference time, out-of-domain speedup, and GPT-4o evaluation.
|
[
-0.1945654452,
-0.7260662913,
0.6463073492,
0.4003056884,
-0.1648001075,
0.2264549285,
-0.2701801062,
-0.6289482117,
0.2312846333,
0.7325904369,
-0.7222998738,
-0.2000476271,
-0.5699359179,
0.3669771254,
-0.2908104956,
0.7469434738,
-0.1823789924,
0.0029362412,
0.1592286527,
0.1481169909,
0.0535428748,
-0.7900106907,
-0.9014365673,
-0.1921392977,
0.3973103464,
0.1785773337,
0.5547618866,
0.694150269,
0.0283616055,
0.2985039055,
-0.03125678,
0.3308403492,
-0.4734892845,
0.0796974301,
0.0695450902,
-0.7318922281,
-0.4792263508,
0.0015578585,
0.5942937732,
0.6093705893,
-0.0628990903,
0.0618680008,
-0.2495794147,
0.3408508003,
-0.8315518498,
0.0520191081,
-0.9734825492,
0.0151770618,
-0.3850610554,
-0.2469877154,
-0.8131811619,
-0.2382440716,
0.01673913,
-0.9216127396,
0.5474278927,
0.0865197405,
0.6841028929,
0.0553907789,
-0.4653557241,
-0.1674496233,
-0.6486501694,
0.6395670176,
-0.8339169621,
0.7057504654,
0.4279690087,
0.3428171873,
-0.132753849,
-0.8462536931,
-0.6648592949,
-0.2358160466,
0.0780528933,
0.011704836,
0.2590798438,
0.1204860508,
0.1475780904,
0.184664309,
-0.5490287542,
0.2463873029,
-0.0027755818,
-0.5005200505,
0.6044065952,
0.0945448428,
0.0001269324,
0.1663746238,
-0.199154228,
0.0970167816,
-0.6075261235,
-0.2524791658,
0.7436133027,
0.1866876632,
-0.2060557455,
0.4328370988,
-0.3169992268,
0.6441770196,
0.1445297897,
-0.2515664101,
0.1808642,
-0.5235877633,
-0.1748198569,
-0.0949377939,
0.6838931441,
0.0324662104,
0.3396756053,
-0.414545536,
-0.20626764,
0.2267260849,
-0.1463183314,
-0.7597541809,
-0.2056261152,
0.2108423114,
-0.2573268712,
-0.0405211411,
-0.2797121406,
-0.5613577366,
-0.1342647672,
-0.1081862748,
-0.0529189445,
-0.4623545706,
-0.3979871869,
0.4836888015,
-0.2326304615,
0.1789113134,
0.3271397054,
-1.3487013578,
0.0823777243,
0.5471441746,
0.6031332016,
-0.2458265424,
-0.6603291631,
-0.7018754482,
0.4019613564,
-0.7041621804,
1.124723196,
-0.632817626,
-0.3697085381,
-0.0194472689,
-0.0927596912,
-0.2735551,
-0.1427888721,
0.7194991708,
-0.8212170005,
-0.0894936472,
-0.1699717492,
-0.63495785,
0.196565643,
0.5975228548,
-0.7363059521,
0.7887628078,
-0.0248295683,
-0.769903481,
0.6616942883,
-0.3210815489,
-0.5371708274,
-0.0443377495,
-0.0576392896,
0.0089908829,
0.0300764032,
0.6771657467,
0.6962916851,
-0.3926411867,
0.1538429111,
-0.4184922576,
-0.551273942,
0.0386033989,
-0.768806994,
0.46642676,
0.4192915261,
0.1104279533,
0.1453369558,
-0.7647083402,
0.0677433014,
0.1686335951,
-0.6520690918,
-0.1667959541,
-0.2986166477,
0.11035835,
0.0299035441,
0.030849779,
-0.3136499524,
0.2531799376,
-0.5533065796,
0.4642722011,
0.6082100868,
-0.0357223675,
0.4967671633,
0.0015937249,
0.7723085284,
-0.0232708678,
0.0754646063,
-0.4536425471,
-0.0652907267,
-0.8174042106,
-0.3816491067,
0.5211361647,
0.4513094723,
-1.2991913557,
0.0189632569,
-0.2102463692,
-0.3111116588,
-0.6441076398,
0.1034466475,
0.4824109077,
0.1065910012,
0.191622749,
0.2439866662,
-0.4407854676,
-0.75495857,
-0.591802001,
0.0114386361,
0.2147156894,
-0.0694461316,
0.2425607592,
-0.3221657872,
0.3156110644,
-0.3197695911,
0.2212973535,
-0.8485478163,
0.3111964464,
0.2116774619,
0.362131834,
0.6440889835,
-0.5875543356,
-0.518686235,
-0.0285994262,
-0.6125993729,
0.0636135861,
-0.3561910689,
-0.2674898207,
0.3054942787,
0.8623284698,
-0.7315489054,
0.0220709145,
0.6380488276,
-0.3129769564,
0.7273647189,
-0.4737159312,
0.2035516053,
-1.0375192165,
-0.0973808393,
-0.0221032985,
-0.1629225165,
-0.6558442116,
0.3508628607,
0.2152148187,
-0.02306577,
-0.5338546634,
0.8992603421,
-0.8527648449,
0.2037726045,
-0.1299600154,
-0.0993897617,
0.110085234,
0.3922412694,
0.3873499632,
0.8255493045,
0.5434826612,
-0.5085140467,
-0.029341856,
-0.1331570596,
-0.2819818556,
0.1478905082,
-0.4753225148,
0.3955516517,
-0.0355490372,
0.4957746863,
-0.7384238243,
-0.3900868297,
0.0121680051,
-0.000942714,
0.4102602601,
-0.2594817877,
-0.7714907527,
-0.4375248849,
-0.2170579582,
0.6489142776,
0.0206978712,
-0.5174742341,
0.863645494,
0.2205411345,
0.0452438593,
-0.8052079082,
-0.7403644919,
-0.0206401758,
-0.1227663532,
-0.5714136958,
0.2770895064,
-0.0518040396,
-0.2245807201,
-0.3171963692,
0.1305070072,
-0.2100599408,
0.1550269276,
-0.2534880638,
0.1455587596,
-0.2045866996,
-0.162236616,
0.4254942536,
-0.3265329301,
-0.1005160958,
-0.3620753288,
0.4975762963,
0.1507784575,
-0.4669683278,
-0.275701642,
0.4865684509,
0.4770027995,
-0.3988315761,
0.6006443501,
0.6864667535,
-0.069577083,
-0.4493422508,
-0.9926205277,
-0.2340022177,
-0.4419911504,
0.3851994276,
-0.8076145053,
-0.783077836,
0.5821543932,
-0.2243966907,
0.1156731769,
0.3793932498,
0.5021591783,
0.5513780117,
0.8422500491,
0.7604886293,
0.0334770195,
0.2628712654,
-0.3674628139,
0.0923007056,
-0.59824121,
-0.0964951292,
-0.5224436522,
0.1720903367,
-0.3468129933,
-0.7549306154,
0.1619119644,
0.0163825862,
0.1470372677,
-0.021243738,
0.0747109875,
0.8550752401,
0.5411859751,
-0.0454351529,
0.3785162568,
-0.169931069,
-0.539185226,
0.1196754575,
-0.9833149314,
-0.4445088506,
1.1750968695,
0.3027434349,
0.7804080248,
-0.0605614036,
0.5856081843,
-0.1290448904,
0.2269863933,
-0.6234824657,
0.4819868207,
-0.2718617618,
-0.8355505466,
-0.2313605398,
-0.295035243,
-0.5798715949,
0.3693738878,
-0.259695977,
-0.4913323522,
0.0586044416,
0.4394522905,
-0.4394927919,
0.2912713289,
-0.9996009469,
0.8483299613,
-0.2153540105,
-0.5041905642,
-0.3405359089,
-0.4830600917,
0.5678632259,
-0.3455609977,
0.1671790481,
-0.2141929269,
0.0951530337,
0.3825256526,
-0.248693645,
0.7044641376,
-0.0147933429,
-0.1024192423,
0.1979272813,
0.2892326415,
0.7380612493,
0.2508251369,
-0.6704244614,
0.2482425123,
-0.0450248532,
-0.4627522826,
-0.4105154574,
0.614854753,
-0.7028138638,
-0.5777536631,
-0.2567870021,
-0.774502039,
-0.581405282,
0.2151143104,
0.5415071845,
0.3439157307,
-0.3756886721,
-0.3602996767,
0.5106746554,
-0.1183237955,
0.4151266813,
0.6579346061,
-0.0387937799,
-0.074542582,
0.6097681522,
-0.0199990347,
0.38367787,
0.5824218392,
0.0887397081,
-0.4597456753,
-1.0251188278,
-0.6569815278,
0.3460430801,
-0.8081331253,
0.1082482636,
-0.8089850545,
-0.0029703313,
-0.4844619334,
-0.2372644991,
-0.4818768203,
-0.3230389059,
-0.1359529197,
-0.221890226,
0.2014933079,
0.5258544683,
0.1882754713,
0.3932119906,
-0.7581738234,
0.4501782656,
0.017314598,
0.2070141733,
0.1007389501,
-0.5234500766,
-0.3880183995,
-0.0856629387,
0.0367747173,
-0.5161998868,
0.2787377536,
0.1494493335,
0.8479582071,
0.4394013584,
-0.0727671832,
0.7425954342,
-0.7615563869,
0.7586868405,
-0.0102008507,
-0.9088821411,
0.2427748144,
-0.3608241379,
0.4482622743,
0.490054965,
0.4702333808,
-0.358399123,
-0.5726642609,
-0.3145447671,
-0.8629233837,
0.6231383681,
-0.1106030643,
0.2535467446,
-0.278699249,
0.412835598,
0.4948677123,
-0.0140031772,
-0.4775083661,
-0.0235665701,
-0.0407400504,
0.12267638,
-0.3161361516,
-0.632106781,
0.1875109822,
-0.1124807149,
0.6570723057,
-0.4706498086,
0.0842204615,
0.01327175,
-0.1602077037,
0.1296483427,
0.3090859652,
0.5026664138,
0.6461353898,
-0.0323150828,
0.1119384095,
0.4090605378,
-0.3046221733,
0.1843982488,
0.3586120903,
0.1611809582,
0.0409775376,
0.8146224022,
0.8942308426,
0.318135649,
-0.4896759689,
0.1221116111,
-0.4413878322,
-0.3892392516,
-0.0589717478,
0.0411242209,
0.2489114404,
0.2432770431,
0.2199451029,
0.1046809852,
0.0912228376,
-0.420507133,
-0.0542789958,
0.3266039789,
0.2596278489,
-0.4794391394,
0.8204391599,
0.2926540077,
0.0813179091,
0.4873595536,
-0.377612263,
-0.3342161477,
0.3678762019,
0.6546410918,
0.8717220426,
-0.2020093352,
0.0383567102,
0.1526356041,
0.1987144947,
-0.4051403105,
0.390976876,
0.0565577112,
-0.9448859692,
-0.7367902398,
-0.7041202188,
-0.2777170539,
0.1124953255,
-0.326331079,
0.1355891079,
-0.2969793677,
-0.1210294217,
0.0106027359,
-0.1630863398,
-0.8782701492,
-0.0126491813,
0.0890759006,
1.2330709696,
-0.7886485457,
1.1860166788,
0.5229799151,
0.0948408023,
-1.0315397978,
0.3048149943,
-0.0350914672,
-0.7722732425,
0.7174267173,
0.0794890448,
-0.3462808132,
0.0664175153,
0.0438462198,
-0.7151139975,
0.7090594769,
0.9258539677,
-0.8416740894,
-0.3205632865,
-0.0112110348,
0.4978654683,
-0.2319010645,
0.4299106896,
0.7686781883,
0.4036623538,
0.1468770057,
-0.9301661849,
-0.0721982494,
-0.2734099329,
0.0276574641,
0.0559592135,
-0.5477829576,
0.9344366193,
-0.390214175,
0.0088257426,
0.1495804191,
0.7425307631,
0.3149971962,
0.1088457033,
0.439930886,
0.3734286427,
0.8119584918,
0.106171973,
1.4862915277,
-0.5610342622,
-0.1088605225,
1.1031457186,
-0.4588534236,
0.8043779135,
0.5147304535,
0.1454583257,
0.2175611258,
0.7960837483,
0.3780389726,
0.5139389634,
-0.0403359793,
-0.3593554795,
-0.4553427696,
-0.1332446188,
-0.322460562,
0.4272387326,
0.4229153395,
-0.313305527,
-0.0809285715,
-0.0709290653,
0.0990227535,
0.1036319807,
-0.2898117006,
0.5748447776,
0.0757064819,
-0.9173848629,
0.6968675256,
0.2384421825,
0.7481641769,
-0.8157504797,
0.2276026011,
-0.2837843895,
0.4340443611,
0.2254690975,
-0.3636658788,
0.1856025904,
-0.0207054894,
-0.0702921823,
-0.3059882224,
0.4252462983,
-0.4406781793,
-0.8216388822,
0.4550217092,
0.7895273566,
0.0254451893,
-0.1301038563,
-0.6688086987,
0.3220214546,
-0.1881174445,
-0.476315707,
0.1090390533,
0.9051001668,
-0.2931823134,
0.6163342595,
0.8169211745,
0.3450267613,
0.0903322622,
0.4864424765,
0.8373329639,
-0.3334217966,
-0.7789452076,
-1.0301408768,
0.2774648964,
0.2532721758,
-0.3728283644,
0.8759503961,
0.4938504994,
0.8732706308,
-0.3344212472,
0.846991241,
0.5159968734,
0.2518107891,
-1.0536247492,
0.5931379795,
-0.2981523573,
0.311185658,
-0.087282978,
-0.6517546177,
-0.2060524672,
0.2903179824,
-0.3498727977,
0.049193304,
0.7680664659,
0.8220533133,
-0.26917696,
-0.1050400734,
0.3169728518,
0.027909318,
0.3672417998,
0.601867497,
0.9111168385,
-0.1851148754,
0.4405654967,
-0.2834570706,
0.013702997,
-0.1276797801,
-1.1727849245,
-1.3589226007,
-0.3245725036,
-0.0467377752,
-0.1059484929,
0.2245856673,
0.9308340549,
1.0688912868,
-0.6007145047,
-0.269818157,
-0.0874000117,
-0.006506681,
-0.2873145044,
-0.1221562549,
0.2766697407,
-0.3713297248,
-0.784270525,
0.6147297025,
0.0726526529,
0.1756692529,
-0.213350296,
-0.1447028518,
-0.2890540957,
0.3287668824,
0.6226559281,
0.0175744146,
-0.7944847941,
0.2050609589,
0.0381740108,
-0.0055171251,
-0.3049347997,
1.1661669016,
-0.6268625259,
0.3611314893,
0.4198940694,
0.6462197304,
0.6490256786,
-0.2090929598,
0.9585301876,
-0.8046419024,
0.8862737417,
0.1395373493,
0.5062593222,
0.2044556886,
-0.5674672127,
0.3469948769,
0.1518651098,
-0.1751604676,
-0.7872747183,
0.1829227805,
-0.4156019986,
-0.3979177177,
1.2010428905,
-0.3764664829,
-0.1764777154,
-0.1826791912,
-0.1411955804,
0.2385536432,
-0.4179276824,
0.5934221745,
0.6501521468,
0.0607944317,
-0.1402986497,
-0.559297502,
0.5384939909,
0.2520513833,
-0.9046872258,
0.2637053728,
0.2071315795,
0.1045763344,
-0.0417878143,
1.0144097805,
0.252615273,
0.2150140852,
0.3812111318,
-0.1163411364,
-0.2809286714,
-0.5540719628,
-0.0739298761,
0.0749476701,
0.3703048229,
0.2723126411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16751v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16751v2
|
Towards Zero-Shot Text-To-Speech for Arabic Dialects
| 2024-06-24T15:58:15 | 2024-06-25T14:18:21 |
Khai Duy Doan, Abdul Waheed, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Zero-shot multi-speaker text-to-speech (ZS-TTS) systems have advanced for
English, however, it still lags behind due to insufficient resources. We
address this gap for Arabic, a language of more than 450 million native
speakers, by first adapting a sizeable existing dataset to suit the needs of
speech synthesis. Additionally, we employ a set of Arabic dialect
identification models to explore the impact of pre-defined dialect labels on
improving the ZS-TTS model in a multi-dialect setting. Subsequently, we
fine-tune the
XTTS\footnote{https://docs.coqui.ai/en/latest/models/xtts.html}\footnote{https://medium.com/machine-learns/xtts-v2-new-version-of-the-open-source-text-to-speech-model-af73914db81f}\footnote{https://medium.com/@erogol/xtts-v1-techincal-notes-eb83ff05bdc}
model, an open-source architecture. We then evaluate our models on a dataset
comprising 31 unseen speakers and an in-house dialectal dataset. Our automated
and human evaluation results show convincing performance while capable of
generating dialectal speech. Our study highlights significant potential for
improvements in this emerging area of research in Arabic.
|
[
-0.4349300563,
-0.4882435501,
0.4683559835,
-0.058769647,
-0.3519266248,
0.2975769043,
-0.2037878335,
-0.4820172191,
0.2720321119,
0.4010781348,
-0.4625681639,
-0.7772814035,
-0.4793202877,
0.1922088265,
-0.5744937658,
0.9125154614,
0.3453757465,
-0.0659043789,
0.4406785071,
-0.1930772811,
-0.3593020737,
-0.5669623017,
-0.6380445957,
-0.0015524717,
0.462672472,
0.9412092566,
0.975346446,
0.6819857955,
-0.3319928646,
0.1916587353,
-0.04882567,
-0.0764673725,
-0.1127368361,
0.4008919001,
0.0315880217,
-0.0327315591,
-0.4583702087,
-0.4535442293,
0.678694129,
0.657974422,
-0.0991462469,
0.0776156932,
-0.2347233444,
0.5841551423,
-0.6430030465,
-0.0596617386,
-0.6245975494,
-0.0376617201,
-0.4731472731,
0.1437994987,
-0.4348221421,
-0.1072309688,
0.2835479081,
-0.0924896747,
0.3230497539,
-0.1078773811,
0.598249197,
-0.1591200978,
-0.6566268802,
-0.1303335577,
-0.860401988,
0.6774349213,
-0.7526002526,
0.6071431041,
0.128567785,
0.4459876418,
0.0725427493,
-0.5834504366,
-0.5584181547,
-0.4211327136,
0.3661277294,
0.1007341668,
-0.1984215677,
0.1468557566,
-0.1962932944,
0.2051394731,
-0.5926138759,
0.0056824177,
-0.1082142442,
-0.2262314111,
0.6000219584,
0.0784029886,
0.3094033301,
-0.0031693554,
-0.1271160841,
0.0328099765,
-0.8140317798,
-0.0297637675,
0.2105497271,
0.8670153022,
-0.3524513841,
0.400723964,
-0.365895927,
0.7760962248,
-0.0526340082,
0.1108116955,
0.1391979009,
-0.4624451399,
-0.0972497091,
0.4028701186,
0.8015971184,
-0.1287823766,
0.3016768992,
-0.3406268656,
-0.2772095501,
-0.2094443589,
0.112651512,
-0.9361695647,
-0.0221848395,
0.3729650378,
0.031581942,
-0.1314649135,
-0.0891449973,
-0.73911798,
-0.2533529401,
-0.0691547617,
0.5833176374,
-0.5924799442,
-0.3075531721,
0.1236102432,
-0.1807310581,
-0.1127781942,
0.3081173599,
-0.9039283395,
0.2964340746,
0.2329258472,
1.1276576519,
0.2479093522,
-0.1707340926,
-0.3606969416,
0.3965280354,
-0.6279675961,
0.5490922332,
-0.3856381178,
-0.5486536026,
0.2171764672,
-0.5955026746,
0.2027487457,
-0.5540502667,
0.4995033145,
-0.2399807274,
0.0169232413,
-0.1730902493,
-0.3181034625,
0.061154563,
-0.1157352105,
-0.652133286,
0.9653337598,
0.2678854167,
-0.2867794633,
-0.0002255485,
-0.6580958366,
-0.5802851915,
-0.0320783369,
-0.277564466,
-0.5633764267,
0.2832854688,
0.2843173146,
0.2100986987,
-0.3754623532,
0.1708827615,
0.0053032232,
-0.3623571694,
0.1208221912,
-0.5921316743,
0.7321693301,
0.3869929314,
-0.6287292838,
0.1569535434,
-0.8232527971,
0.3027059436,
-0.0335771479,
0.2046438605,
0.0310048945,
0.0956471637,
0.3644489348,
0.2144403309,
-0.055376064,
-0.642559588,
-0.14056319,
-0.686289072,
0.4146773517,
0.519274056,
-0.1587052196,
0.1957985312,
-0.5288699269,
0.4084485769,
0.1326517761,
-0.1401031315,
-0.5415803194,
-0.4107589722,
-1.005531311,
-0.5542622805,
0.4149857461,
0.3064812124,
-0.8795835376,
0.4100500047,
-0.3645628095,
-0.7199093699,
-0.4360322058,
-0.3218950927,
0.4069200754,
0.3106325865,
0.510781467,
-0.4886553884,
-0.5715337992,
-0.8232716322,
-0.1208855957,
-0.3330595195,
-0.1804676801,
0.1977432072,
0.267634064,
0.131170243,
1.2263212204,
-0.0864795372,
-0.2365725487,
-0.2828861773,
0.2256496698,
-0.1442849636,
0.1385937333,
0.7298070192,
-0.3610118628,
-0.8151643276,
0.2527529895,
-0.2662214041,
-0.3392349482,
0.0661626011,
0.1756804585,
0.5283699632,
0.2487142086,
-0.475667268,
0.5262721777,
0.4426005781,
-0.45784536,
0.6622208953,
0.2078645974,
0.1092932224,
-1.1960961819,
-0.0519994348,
-0.0253279563,
-0.3478653431,
-0.9924386144,
-0.0683057383,
-0.2618923485,
-0.3983362317,
-0.5541012883,
0.7049017549,
-0.4516598582,
-0.0347842611,
-0.2607820928,
0.1643735915,
-0.0350061879,
0.3337582946,
0.155786559,
1.1937497854,
0.5440265536,
-0.3775521517,
0.2212103903,
0.1579273939,
-0.4568423629,
0.3712049127,
-0.6315077543,
0.3948070705,
0.042950321,
0.1109104007,
-1.1486548185,
-0.0648990944,
0.3311901689,
-0.7023406625,
0.1577126682,
-0.100363113,
-0.2565157712,
0.1244233027,
-0.3406421244,
0.5283250213,
0.3499694467,
-0.2544139028,
0.4855206609,
0.2853555083,
-0.7108851671,
-0.3777828217,
-0.3614672124,
0.5720064044,
0.0612861402,
-0.6098405123,
0.423351109,
0.2674938142,
-0.2598257065,
-0.0732124075,
-0.0277131088,
-0.4374034107,
-0.0736164525,
0.2089974582,
-0.0106929718,
-0.4891088009,
0.2773727179,
0.2448827028,
0.0192934088,
-0.1710762084,
-0.5000500679,
0.6274605393,
0.0596538857,
-0.3481463194,
-0.6655187607,
0.7654674053,
0.759101212,
-0.2031471431,
0.6500372291,
0.3973458111,
-0.2213847488,
-0.2180779129,
-0.3289960921,
0.0344955847,
-0.4627743065,
0.7159216404,
-0.4583705366,
-0.7846613526,
0.2195064425,
0.0846852809,
-0.0710571632,
0.3688963056,
0.6001799107,
0.0613399446,
0.8905225396,
0.6775417328,
-0.4561509788,
0.5646083951,
0.044941131,
0.293841213,
-0.1603648067,
-0.0416909866,
-0.9322192073,
0.067629151,
-0.4273701012,
-0.2835374177,
0.7411242127,
-0.2894221544,
-0.5305361152,
0.2099428028,
-0.1198948249,
0.2217149436,
0.7319734693,
-0.0128407767,
0.0973600075,
0.361397922,
-0.1430021822,
0.0046358318,
-0.764241159,
-0.5784628391,
1.0755553246,
0.0528933927,
0.2474723458,
0.5140579939,
0.7641798258,
0.6550739408,
0.1213704571,
-0.7904103398,
0.480651468,
-0.0847526863,
-0.4611289203,
-0.53803128,
-0.2351548225,
-0.8809764385,
0.0979083851,
-0.0111709125,
-0.667289257,
-0.1157460064,
0.0802760571,
-0.6318221688,
0.3303725719,
-0.7485069036,
0.5394649506,
-0.0765324607,
-0.4074253738,
-0.3012807071,
-0.7033569813,
-0.1407818198,
-0.1153603941,
0.1955978125,
-0.0774842128,
0.060410697,
0.5517796278,
-0.6679238081,
0.8125982881,
-0.1771849394,
-0.2062006146,
0.5522220731,
-0.0496340171,
0.1147692129,
-0.244281143,
-0.4768679738,
0.4989848435,
0.1951171607,
-0.6463087797,
-0.4585519135,
0.3288062513,
-0.9934939742,
-0.5579176545,
-0.5352064967,
-0.5496278405,
-0.4768668115,
0.0539987907,
0.1771258414,
0.731803,
-0.4346391559,
0.0251714308,
0.2761620283,
-0.2168425024,
0.5356270671,
0.639503479,
-0.339494735,
-0.747860074,
0.855245769,
0.3241998553,
0.3644574583,
0.2613787949,
-0.037872918,
-0.3932884336,
-0.6982318759,
-1.11142838,
0.1146998331,
-0.3056337535,
-0.2322788239,
-0.0984228328,
-0.4375581443,
-0.7085248828,
-0.0066894838,
-0.4145025015,
-0.5976436138,
-0.2559637725,
0.0435233749,
0.3081354499,
0.8458938599,
0.0477851778,
0.6330475807,
-1.0998458862,
0.2679813504,
0.1068883762,
0.1524651647,
0.1163623556,
-0.9617110491,
-0.6306343675,
0.3582626283,
-0.381665349,
-1.1953235865,
0.5384423733,
0.4539917707,
0.0009965551,
0.4593945146,
0.2811824083,
0.6658986807,
-0.9053338766,
0.9481243491,
0.16862683,
-1.4569451809,
0.4081529081,
-0.3864913583,
0.4347138703,
0.2669431269,
0.1814344674,
-0.9976243377,
-0.39135921,
-0.271289885,
-0.913125217,
0.7462575436,
0.4587517381,
0.4114296734,
-0.0083157634,
0.3594467938,
0.1718931496,
0.3413821757,
-0.4132360518,
-0.5462840796,
-0.1737314761,
-0.4654015601,
-0.1507274806,
-0.4376839399,
0.096220836,
-0.1744279861,
0.8447996974,
-0.0205762442,
0.3100701571,
0.1380723864,
0.0345630944,
-0.2537309825,
0.6600404382,
0.7289155126,
0.4661774337,
-0.1627676338,
0.0966256633,
-0.1033083498,
-0.2897145748,
0.5349975824,
0.2429838032,
-0.4318586886,
0.5338537693,
0.2884248197,
0.9167631865,
-0.0818677992,
-0.71832335,
0.35907498,
0.2318452746,
-0.1415120661,
-0.3869133294,
-0.047519803,
-0.2296629995,
0.1854281425,
0.5270118117,
0.0843575969,
-0.0360910036,
-0.7445345521,
0.3252064586,
0.5129901171,
-0.4287810922,
-0.5912005305,
0.4880787432,
0.5244798064,
-0.747133255,
0.3489821851,
-0.1303007305,
-0.5023500323,
0.5269178748,
0.5293532014,
0.9461500049,
-0.6018638611,
0.4596391618,
0.1810031086,
0.122573778,
0.2588112652,
0.3933956921,
-0.2889734209,
-0.6720495224,
-0.2876825035,
-0.2716322839,
-0.770511508,
0.0686349049,
-0.5475158691,
0.4414364398,
-0.3027740717,
-0.2894782424,
0.0488984622,
-0.1123228446,
-0.1674521267,
0.3578130603,
0.3318687975,
0.7518393993,
-0.9837138653,
1.1342145205,
0.4103187025,
-0.2663716674,
-0.5769312382,
0.2391788661,
-0.0286042094,
-0.6197705865,
0.2660768032,
0.170391202,
-0.5498683453,
0.271797806,
-0.3409020007,
-0.9399616122,
0.7306269407,
0.6348125339,
-0.7143403292,
0.1663453281,
0.7031879425,
0.4624000788,
-0.0502042137,
0.4219808578,
0.383131355,
0.1726649106,
0.1845757365,
-1.1813756227,
-0.3449972272,
-0.0604380518,
-0.1395377219,
0.3483754992,
-0.7078362107,
0.9338450432,
-0.2817261517,
-0.3221314251,
0.6145893931,
0.7241843343,
-0.1215488091,
0.4807557166,
0.2738496065,
0.5324531198,
0.5244671106,
-0.0702685192,
0.691524744,
-0.4287751019,
0.0981656089,
1.2316387892,
-0.6832324266,
0.9750660658,
0.3538419604,
-0.2798316181,
0.5924057961,
0.3149040937,
0.5245666504,
0.6402228475,
0.0911366865,
-0.9984727502,
-0.1597595662,
-0.4452355802,
-0.5349935293,
0.6262982488,
0.2684161961,
-0.2735873759,
-0.3548609912,
-0.2137509584,
0.0643497333,
0.0796460956,
-0.2176813483,
0.5867106915,
-0.2061446905,
-0.485316664,
0.7131671309,
0.4595034122,
0.2739489973,
-0.8168572783,
-0.036526721,
-0.2499289662,
-0.0329895206,
0.1149430126,
-0.4602295458,
0.3476815224,
0.246035561,
-0.1446207464,
-0.0905441567,
0.4324247241,
-0.6191362739,
-0.4509394169,
0.0807219371,
0.9004796743,
0.0958282426,
-0.2691912651,
-0.2476639599,
-0.0004539354,
0.1863891631,
0.1784826368,
0.2896144092,
0.5463941693,
-0.1518830955,
0.4669690132,
0.3037475348,
0.2471049279,
-0.0397533886,
0.1804302782,
0.6311749816,
-0.910255909,
-0.4225121439,
-1.048682332,
0.3851081133,
0.2579312027,
-0.1435807347,
0.8259330392,
0.6619169712,
0.8636499643,
0.0659455433,
1.1386779547,
0.0841203183,
0.5831890106,
-0.3573782742,
0.7200562954,
-0.4659114182,
0.0273029804,
-0.3093266189,
-0.4087635577,
-0.2498905808,
0.3748681247,
0.0683107525,
0.1614529192,
0.4471600652,
0.9343238473,
0.2753475606,
0.1640797555,
0.7928119898,
0.2806337476,
0.1887795627,
0.3856320381,
0.8356574178,
-0.4509294629,
0.5777860284,
-0.2293255925,
0.0474203117,
-0.0339222066,
-0.7367956042,
-0.5176304579,
-0.5479018688,
-0.2909393311,
-0.2657004297,
0.5220785737,
1.2045969963,
0.7854306102,
-1.0696487427,
-0.7442134619,
0.1320425123,
-0.0008350724,
-0.2115968168,
-0.1181547344,
0.2516295612,
-0.1152810901,
-0.885042727,
0.5151080489,
0.5253797174,
0.19667992,
0.0013914146,
-0.0624749921,
-0.1153097302,
0.3702158928,
0.650206089,
0.3434863389,
-0.7523651123,
-0.4231838882,
-0.1476774663,
0.1123333126,
0.3320578933,
0.6877003908,
-0.9652415514,
0.5255390406,
-0.0909829959,
0.5556570888,
0.2205997854,
-0.1439899504,
0.5061296225,
-1.0744298697,
0.3313744366,
0.3176080287,
0.11547748,
0.4039078355,
0.2025020272,
0.2010258734,
0.2279641777,
-0.2768896222,
-0.7293992639,
0.39590922,
-0.7452129722,
-0.1591399759,
1.0715744495,
-0.1046549007,
0.2030459344,
-0.478603214,
-0.3990510404,
0.5223419666,
-0.6522780061,
0.9526472688,
0.6244958639,
-0.0417825915,
-0.1013799235,
-0.2801734805,
0.2791664898,
0.7891507745,
-0.6414507627,
-0.0013223951,
0.7032589316,
0.1099753305,
-0.0056773135,
0.7070092559,
0.2785908282,
0.3650124371,
-0.0525168106,
0.1177192181,
-0.0765710995,
-0.4826845229,
-0.4895454049,
0.2431939095,
0.3985238969,
-0.4644856453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16748v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16748v1
|
OCALM: Object-Centric Assessment with Language Models
| 2024-06-24T15:57:48 | 2024-06-24T15:57:48 |
Timo Kaufmann, Jannis Blüml, Antonia Wüst, Quentin Delfosse, Kristian Kersting, Eyke Hüllermeier
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Properly defining a reward signal to efficiently train a reinforcement
learning (RL) agent is a challenging task. Designing balanced objective
functions from which a desired behavior can emerge requires expert knowledge,
especially for complex environments. Learning rewards from human feedback or
using large language models (LLMs) to directly provide rewards are promising
alternatives, allowing non-experts to specify goals for the agent. However,
black-box reward models make it difficult to debug the reward. In this work, we
propose Object-Centric Assessment with Language Models (OCALM) to derive
inherently interpretable reward functions for RL agents from natural language
task descriptions. OCALM uses the extensive world-knowledge of LLMs while
leveraging the object-centric nature common to many environments to derive
reward functions focused on relational concepts, providing RL agents with the
ability to derive policies from task descriptions.
|
[
-0.2770780027,
-0.8238787055,
0.4797635078,
0.0928312838,
0.1774145812,
0.0296473838,
-0.4276450276,
-0.613745451,
-0.1611771882,
0.5053392649,
-0.5768687725,
-0.2550057471,
-0.5665155649,
-0.0427184999,
0.2338121533,
0.981343329,
-0.2334025353,
-0.0564826168,
-0.5136788487,
-0.1292380542,
-0.5739235878,
-0.4138213396,
-0.7812402844,
-0.8381819725,
0.7263098359,
0.5377891064,
0.4803295434,
0.4661509395,
0.3350330293,
0.2888045609,
0.2195324153,
0.16014947,
-0.4811315536,
0.0155611066,
-0.7365477681,
-0.3900381327,
-0.6548482776,
0.0684474334,
0.2011577785,
0.4261729121,
-0.2809080482,
0.1478332281,
-0.1112327799,
0.4819943905,
-0.8849912286,
1.0204242468,
-0.4864377975,
0.3390930891,
0.4830330312,
-0.2299871594,
-0.6023085117,
-0.1986270696,
0.2524823248,
-0.5700299144,
-0.2908951938,
-0.0102698486,
0.7473827004,
0.3017076552,
-0.0975571498,
-0.4590653181,
-0.6380250454,
1.1165597439,
-0.3824081421,
0.0238051973,
0.3638716042,
0.6137371063,
0.0285346229,
-0.4282847345,
-0.3908003271,
-0.783503294,
-0.2233386338,
0.1338733137,
0.2929573059,
-0.0533340201,
0.1098749861,
0.2968630791,
-0.2448922545,
0.2208646685,
-0.0644450635,
-0.146276772,
0.9469403625,
0.511210084,
0.2474938035,
-0.0149391722,
-0.7459478974,
-0.4533439279,
-0.4807119966,
0.5961265564,
0.2553064227,
0.5949200988,
-0.0496498607,
0.6474454403,
-0.3278394938,
0.7879196405,
-0.2285448164,
-0.3199024498,
-0.0190963019,
-0.0858440474,
-0.1540805846,
0.2318351418,
0.7503331304,
0.4374845028,
0.368781209,
-0.4115357995,
-0.5295459628,
0.1377003044,
0.6890887618,
-0.9789674282,
0.1633698046,
0.3613482714,
-0.2509474456,
-0.5386058092,
0.2021400779,
-0.7624083161,
-0.5266038775,
-0.517644465,
0.5650125742,
-0.1919943094,
-0.4467408955,
0.5060014129,
-0.0458275862,
0.3731385171,
0.3395725191,
-0.7651635408,
0.4751287401,
0.6704853773,
0.2562717497,
-0.4285155833,
-0.5528773665,
-0.8061426878,
-0.1824151427,
-0.0652401522,
0.7894670367,
-0.4751245677,
-0.4070703089,
0.2125449777,
0.115304254,
-0.2716287673,
-0.5496183634,
0.2787786722,
-0.5381022096,
-0.073942706,
-0.0565229319,
-0.4109601378,
-0.3919962049,
0.8429719806,
-0.3923812509,
0.9801231623,
0.4494439363,
-0.2996156514,
0.2637014985,
-1.0195008516,
-0.3963766694,
0.0668463781,
-0.2210803926,
-0.3273073137,
-0.0504425764,
0.1224538684,
0.483248651,
-0.32030195,
0.2251200676,
-0.3515048325,
-0.142306596,
0.5961183906,
-0.0443583988,
0.2185582966,
0.1317258775,
-0.5437088013,
0.2678910196,
-0.4243328571,
0.2147808671,
0.396051228,
-0.2398699671,
-0.1361927986,
0.2975319922,
-0.0446137674,
0.1139334515,
0.5415665507,
-0.638532877,
0.2788794637,
-0.2895618975,
0.2987591326,
0.507447958,
-0.0946512744,
0.4464999437,
-0.3418416083,
0.7978019118,
-0.1939495355,
0.3067379594,
-0.07035584,
-0.0978779122,
-0.4704353809,
-0.2456252277,
-0.0326496474,
0.6183244586,
-0.5290362239,
0.3720974028,
-0.1329548955,
-0.4893554747,
-0.3089059591,
-0.0229863245,
0.5273208618,
0.5088359714,
0.382314086,
-0.4072958827,
-0.059155982,
-0.7218526602,
-0.1668097377,
-0.3449315429,
0.2923794985,
0.5947233438,
0.5214566588,
-0.1279158592,
1.0486559868,
-0.7212876081,
-0.6754273176,
-0.5438145399,
0.1477180868,
-0.1232515052,
0.2231071442,
0.3005292118,
-0.7344352603,
-0.3614408076,
0.3443350494,
-0.8702561259,
0.0199707486,
0.0397833884,
0.0477491915,
-0.0485376343,
0.5541644692,
-0.3478193581,
0.3922849894,
-0.0741010234,
-0.4250521064,
0.5808830857,
-0.2929757833,
0.1134143621,
-0.3726808727,
0.112547867,
-0.1332858652,
-0.4887731373,
-0.2214231044,
0.4328241348,
0.0041447086,
0.0635116994,
-0.8213868141,
1.0539293289,
-0.2439778447,
-0.2018931806,
-0.5662344098,
0.3153721988,
-0.0169858113,
0.8403327465,
0.444504261,
0.3655182719,
0.5442401171,
-0.6497139931,
0.3756187558,
0.0855390877,
-0.0482390039,
0.9483523965,
-0.6973582506,
0.0351055861,
-0.1669643819,
-0.1287291944,
-0.5955839157,
-0.0289750043,
0.2044266164,
-0.3742823005,
0.0662971884,
0.0198576879,
-0.2382832915,
-0.1670589,
-0.2079037875,
0.4208147824,
0.211830765,
-0.533829689,
0.743635416,
0.4791743755,
-0.0685314238,
-0.6898621917,
-0.3258495629,
-0.4734458029,
-0.1212280467,
-0.1383615732,
0.1486606449,
0.0033037795,
-0.2167994827,
0.1919748038,
-0.0139492825,
-0.0095090354,
0.4220835567,
0.430876106,
0.4765161574,
-0.1058620661,
0.2065393925,
-0.4423268437,
-0.1182038784,
0.4424233735,
-0.1811288148,
0.5187877417,
-0.4339722395,
-0.4607947171,
0.037019942,
0.0647990406,
0.3645333648,
-0.5524752736,
0.5063900352,
0.7251121402,
-0.1876990497,
-0.5415909886,
-0.2162209302,
-0.2900093794,
-0.3808074594,
0.7126723528,
-0.45638901,
-0.7168161273,
0.2610254884,
0.0516765676,
0.2026512474,
0.2697396576,
0.6907289028,
0.5025779605,
1.0253911018,
0.4058355093,
-0.0683166608,
0.4500506818,
-0.3171955645,
-0.0984734073,
-0.7250017524,
-0.6620773673,
-0.4756123722,
-0.1389358193,
0.0281637087,
-0.4334821105,
0.0612813905,
-0.0529873185,
-0.3202750385,
0.2636010349,
-0.5713726878,
0.5104448199,
0.1766053885,
0.1245035082,
0.1943086982,
-0.0695426017,
0.0260476768,
0.3127583265,
-0.3014370203,
-0.5656240582,
1.0148791075,
0.5095704794,
1.067361474,
-0.159236744,
0.537830174,
0.4215532839,
0.6045101881,
-1.2894001007,
0.5203749537,
0.2410895675,
-0.3006152511,
-0.4678049684,
-0.4417990148,
-1.0808298588,
0.4258181155,
0.026471179,
-0.9244893789,
-0.1466977447,
-0.0100025525,
-0.2450165451,
0.0296186339,
-0.5561346412,
1.2991575003,
-0.5021921992,
-0.4530543685,
-0.2312944531,
-0.2724970877,
0.2382215858,
0.3053788841,
0.2943952382,
-0.3452525139,
-0.0639627948,
0.6696970463,
-0.4239111543,
0.7554822564,
-0.4532364011,
-0.070961237,
0.5246650577,
0.3715660572,
0.4989322126,
0.3076350689,
-0.1073849499,
-0.4305335581,
0.1088716015,
-0.4574968517,
-0.7847994566,
0.6037114263,
-0.8114475608,
-0.4451138079,
-0.4271194041,
-0.8431329727,
-0.3806532323,
0.0566438586,
-0.3935754001,
0.3929632604,
-0.335608542,
-0.2053323835,
0.4821985364,
-0.2220167518,
0.2774440944,
0.8929033875,
-0.6359286904,
-0.0287430622,
1.1747363806,
-0.5111403465,
0.4510542154,
0.4560092986,
0.3835451603,
-0.6292433143,
-0.2008949667,
-0.4512855113,
0.1015625224,
-0.6330369115,
-0.0369736627,
-0.331851989,
-0.1174098849,
-0.0419879705,
-0.0914220139,
-0.6015087962,
-0.0105945347,
-0.0218004081,
-0.2149849385,
0.2410444915,
0.9863773584,
0.26426512,
0.1178246364,
-0.5354979038,
0.1715638787,
0.5775786638,
0.1899831742,
0.2050426155,
-0.2964814901,
-0.3051000237,
0.0914165303,
-0.4548121393,
-0.538911283,
0.5002331138,
-0.0818222985,
0.7878887057,
0.1835665256,
0.2473364174,
0.3506636024,
-0.2249121815,
0.6897817254,
0.2401966155,
-0.7402399778,
0.3572775126,
-0.0385296009,
0.1084668785,
0.4009625018,
0.2191701829,
-0.4307347238,
-0.3855479062,
-0.4650135338,
-0.6911018491,
1.1009173393,
-0.2468163371,
-0.075883396,
-0.0584735312,
0.1938589364,
0.1841021031,
0.2762148082,
-1.0336478949,
-0.0420132242,
-0.304556638,
-0.3358440399,
-0.2396777123,
0.1107959226,
-0.2041181922,
0.2272394747,
0.4688811004,
-0.4415728152,
0.3709214926,
0.4167438447,
-0.5076476336,
-0.1781405807,
0.4308781326,
0.6329056025,
0.6114891171,
-0.4006983042,
0.3190708458,
0.0389062688,
-0.0302546807,
0.3248802722,
-0.0059629241,
0.2967233062,
-0.54036659,
0.2930900156,
1.0049268007,
0.2843889594,
-1.2921535969,
0.704312861,
-0.1252819598,
-0.1390342712,
-0.3715770841,
0.298352778,
0.1384290755,
0.2749477327,
0.1296720207,
-0.3180356622,
-0.0729941353,
-0.8413724303,
0.2079115957,
0.5157214403,
-1.0998376608,
-0.2767626941,
0.4543579221,
-0.1578753293,
-0.424885124,
0.3968061805,
-0.5705984831,
-0.6131637692,
0.9299657941,
0.325397104,
0.8200901747,
-0.1242057309,
0.5497357249,
0.356223017,
0.0758669227,
-0.1523499191,
0.1753301173,
-0.0329256877,
-0.7095782757,
-0.2619983554,
-0.6788410544,
-0.5398980379,
0.0208498947,
-0.9510164857,
0.1075718924,
-0.2720734179,
0.0549356155,
-0.090131782,
-0.1384929121,
-0.7360354066,
0.2306170613,
0.0794976875,
0.7034844756,
-0.7207692266,
0.5884321332,
1.0416828394,
-0.7161334157,
-1.0477511883,
-0.508300066,
-0.4125023782,
-1.1156203747,
1.1787325144,
0.1285213083,
-0.0728776827,
-0.2884145975,
-0.1465327591,
-0.3113591969,
1.0027674437,
0.1780743599,
-0.0378434695,
-0.075575009,
0.5310512185,
0.5952103734,
-0.8344935179,
0.8166807294,
0.3533222377,
0.6478000879,
-0.0261264853,
-0.76073879,
0.1277654767,
-0.004930858,
-0.1319197863,
0.1816131175,
-0.3618684113,
0.8639569879,
-0.1971632689,
0.1356070638,
-0.1266682446,
0.456456542,
0.3758234978,
0.325150609,
0.8107466698,
0.3158848286,
0.2341761291,
0.1083184108,
1.302827239,
-0.0742187724,
0.6638296247,
1.088277936,
-0.3419983983,
1.0052068233,
0.5203862786,
-0.1726833582,
0.5367854238,
0.52985394,
0.1571580172,
0.3785848618,
0.4847417772,
0.078561388,
-0.5509569049,
-0.4059411287,
-0.0687611252,
0.4044397473,
0.3119923174,
-0.1319079995,
-0.5501903296,
0.1712396294,
-0.2087108344,
0.3798397779,
-0.607875824,
0.7483432293,
0.1344719529,
-1.1692993641,
0.4999710023,
0.0818956047,
0.3605034947,
-0.5757040977,
-0.2025075853,
0.0018226228,
0.5672627687,
-0.1449805647,
-0.8425357342,
0.1269171536,
-0.2579986155,
0.0137669062,
-0.2462743223,
0.5331144333,
-0.6603865623,
-0.1959389746,
0.6550744176,
0.4564436972,
0.0494990908,
-0.3106587827,
-0.9419705868,
-0.0897265822,
-0.2304974645,
-0.2616340816,
0.6079699993,
0.1477241516,
-0.1049676985,
0.8342469931,
0.2755092978,
0.0897662044,
-0.1389671862,
-0.1960674524,
0.4725843668,
-0.599114418,
-0.5765706301,
-0.7405290008,
0.4617003202,
0.1409475803,
0.0779747441,
0.3990525007,
0.4441986978,
0.8109050393,
-0.4668282866,
0.4993578792,
-0.1672805399,
0.4428103864,
-0.5039782524,
0.4060549736,
-0.8947014809,
0.1955866218,
0.0371549353,
-0.6847540736,
0.2309521139,
0.5831373334,
-0.5107384324,
-0.019441098,
0.816889286,
0.8723332286,
-0.0032989827,
-0.1919303536,
0.4412193,
-0.1703234166,
0.4415484071,
0.8517681956,
1.2808388472,
-0.136919871,
0.5818313956,
-0.3124952614,
-0.0520665385,
-0.4361031651,
-0.7733607888,
-1.0389436483,
-0.2792895138,
-0.6342868209,
-0.1168083027,
-0.1410046369,
1.01963377,
0.8005163074,
-0.741085887,
-0.7129973769,
-0.1056446284,
0.4426704347,
-0.6570815444,
-0.3290351033,
0.3532914817,
-0.7532635927,
-0.8847075105,
0.3884298503,
0.3035087287,
-0.472560972,
-0.5237677097,
-0.5965173244,
0.1123892441,
0.0553727746,
0.6999853849,
0.4826893508,
-0.7915889025,
-0.4386260211,
0.0333256759,
-0.3493549824,
0.0187342316,
0.8436886668,
-0.8133882284,
0.5454965234,
0.3271008432,
0.7573001385,
0.3542107046,
-0.0213157907,
0.6109611988,
-0.4426586032,
0.2175811827,
0.2604121864,
0.2756677568,
0.1579291373,
-0.2943198085,
0.5188264251,
-0.0294000283,
-0.4803397655,
-0.9697742462,
0.3491044641,
-1.2804777622,
-0.2610203922,
1.1250363588,
-0.6316890121,
-0.6649387479,
0.0355376229,
-0.4277729988,
-0.0821426958,
-0.4534652233,
0.7060988545,
0.3431605399,
0.053411644,
-0.0561023504,
-0.4393380284,
0.549302578,
0.5323675871,
-1.1519942284,
0.0823822394,
0.079445377,
0.2539914548,
0.1759920567,
0.3536565006,
-0.2772875428,
0.4280737936,
-0.2861984372,
0.468816936,
-0.6331959963,
-0.1789016575,
-0.1217295006,
0.4734658599,
0.6077668667,
-0.3316861093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16747v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16747v1
|
Sparser is Faster and Less is More: Efficient Sparse Attention for Long-Range Transformers
| 2024-06-24T15:55:59 | 2024-06-24T15:55:59 |
Chao Lou, Zixia Jia, Zilong Zheng, Kewei Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Accommodating long sequences efficiently in autoregressive Transformers,
especially within an extended context window, poses significant challenges due
to the quadratic computational complexity and substantial KV memory
requirements inherent in self-attention mechanisms. In this work, we introduce
SPARSEK Attention, a novel sparse attention mechanism designed to overcome
these computational and memory obstacles while maintaining performance. Our
approach integrates a scoring network and a differentiable top-k mask operator,
SPARSEK, to select a constant number of KV pairs for each query, thereby
enabling gradient-based optimization. As a result, SPARSEK Attention offers
linear time complexity and constant memory footprint during generation.
Experimental results reveal that SPARSEK Attention outperforms previous sparse
attention methods and provides significant speed improvements during both
training and inference, particularly in language modeling and downstream tasks.
Furthermore, our method can be seamlessly integrated into pre-trained Large
Language Models (LLMs) with minimal fine-tuning, offering a practical solution
for effectively managing long-range dependencies in diverse applications.
|
[
-0.6320146918,
-0.5622351766,
0.277572453,
0.8088313341,
-0.2953214049,
-0.117514655,
-0.4857725501,
-0.3150952458,
0.5512613654,
0.3392968178,
-1.0093390942,
-0.0285963137,
-0.6579197049,
0.0135877421,
-0.3313864172,
0.9753072858,
0.1426802725,
-0.5162646174,
-0.0746228173,
-0.2529767752,
-0.5648268461,
-0.2030131966,
-0.6551749706,
-0.003731888,
0.9639599323,
0.154792279,
0.6633036733,
0.8653352261,
0.3475497663,
0.3871852756,
0.0561893173,
-0.0517030545,
-1.0295802355,
0.3896958232,
0.0894009694,
-0.0137419747,
-0.3947946131,
-0.0999356434,
0.6679867506,
0.7573929429,
0.0497832745,
0.369574815,
0.3762090802,
0.8498522043,
-0.9102936387,
0.2279184461,
-0.626337111,
0.0840509832,
0.036056798,
-0.0992394015,
-0.3254953027,
-0.0036122696,
0.087632224,
-0.8351544142,
0.4288413823,
-0.1171602979,
0.7433199883,
0.9985371828,
0.0085821869,
0.204429701,
-0.6037893295,
1.0372247696,
0.1462214589,
0.7859781981,
0.4553155005,
0.3460544944,
0.0334755927,
-0.6075801849,
-0.1237511113,
-0.2493679374,
-0.1804101765,
0.3370272517,
-0.0897264779,
0.2533174455,
0.4955589473,
0.1544639319,
-0.4647323489,
-0.088207297,
-0.1181361675,
-0.2601261437,
0.2726855278,
0.1895404011,
-0.3171218932,
-0.160722509,
-0.2637222707,
0.2059895992,
-0.4170966446,
-0.1239300892,
0.2426036447,
0.147508055,
-0.0922980607,
0.2658804655,
-0.4710655808,
0.6804943681,
0.5612443089,
0.2119541019,
-0.2021161467,
-0.3411489129,
-0.1005395055,
-0.0886118263,
0.6492297649,
0.0067943237,
0.1654308885,
-0.4467870593,
-0.0898196995,
-0.1188956127,
0.5291665792,
-0.6767519116,
-0.3320631981,
-0.0016815114,
-0.4201358259,
-0.0488454923,
-0.5310181975,
-1.0787787437,
0.1185927615,
-0.317011714,
0.3980024457,
0.1680366248,
0.0289230756,
-0.1707583219,
0.3129271865,
0.2292955816,
0.3804802299,
-1.2859642506,
0.3996001482,
0.5670349598,
0.8291479945,
-0.2514330745,
-0.201051563,
-0.9061107039,
0.1421961784,
-0.3869744241,
0.7458007932,
-0.2635468841,
-0.056342829,
-0.245264262,
0.0596920736,
-0.1213301793,
-0.4312953651,
0.2554985583,
-0.5803982019,
-0.2065053135,
0.0030574226,
0.1357404888,
0.3477289975,
0.0897786766,
-0.896361649,
1.5627835989,
0.5809904933,
-0.5488392115,
0.3606612682,
-0.4372124672,
-0.5454370379,
0.3674673438,
0.0203482341,
-0.4618964791,
0.0549821034,
0.2878239751,
0.5341481566,
-0.2097266167,
-0.0444625393,
-0.3337757885,
-0.4750218093,
-0.0234378371,
-0.359860003,
0.2977538407,
0.1239008084,
-0.4399864376,
0.1134796292,
-0.7511048317,
-0.1824147105,
0.1384542882,
-0.4153927267,
-0.3050667942,
-0.0881216899,
0.1544433534,
0.2045775652,
0.3110131621,
-0.5379508138,
0.1623232365,
-0.5881089568,
0.3987162709,
0.8930915594,
-0.2160359472,
0.6544485092,
-0.0012759152,
0.5746062994,
-0.4714889526,
0.304977566,
-0.2631727159,
-0.1439003646,
-1.0294172764,
-0.6967605352,
0.3349695504,
0.1996479183,
-0.3075035214,
0.5190647244,
-0.4934979379,
0.0760909915,
-0.639778316,
0.4124746323,
0.0511543453,
0.4596856534,
0.2608206272,
-0.224759981,
-0.4985282421,
-0.913626492,
-0.0289671011,
0.1448953897,
-0.1605987549,
0.692491591,
0.1016607955,
-0.2422508001,
0.7198469639,
-0.7305644155,
-0.345002383,
-0.2576145232,
-0.1715250015,
0.1428739578,
0.3107974827,
0.2411639094,
-0.5429864526,
-0.8603332043,
-0.0675061643,
-0.1647323519,
-0.1419323385,
-0.3671913445,
-0.502414465,
0.1599654704,
0.6030135155,
-0.870252192,
0.3172401786,
0.1516221464,
0.1712517738,
0.0625500903,
0.1536422521,
-0.0597137921,
-0.8509429693,
0.1542736739,
-0.0628750101,
-0.4261509478,
-0.3561151624,
-0.1672483534,
0.1241401732,
-0.318590045,
-0.1740057319,
0.4877013564,
-0.323432833,
-0.0473749079,
-0.1972020566,
-0.0270379223,
-0.0461049005,
1.020870924,
-0.0376162045,
0.6162057519,
0.3755056262,
-0.4101321995,
0.5072390437,
0.1164190471,
-0.2616742849,
0.3144519329,
-0.4630942941,
0.2075656801,
-0.2389253825,
0.0584397353,
-1.4089142084,
-0.2586043179,
0.2429402769,
-0.3958686888,
0.7213299274,
-0.3384945989,
-0.4162275493,
-0.4135681093,
-0.3011473119,
0.5855925679,
0.5774872899,
-0.6876308918,
0.7265859246,
0.075067766,
-0.4377667904,
-0.9159758091,
-0.437356174,
0.034355823,
-0.1228605136,
-0.602928102,
0.0904561207,
0.0419279374,
0.2387921959,
-0.0847755075,
-0.3419834673,
-0.0703428015,
0.2179363966,
0.1283658743,
0.1430595964,
-0.2909376323,
0.1580989808,
0.0573090725,
-0.5691694021,
-0.0229787659,
-0.3356459737,
0.4813274443,
0.3697267473,
-0.0180671532,
-0.2997823954,
0.8310649991,
0.6383407116,
-0.2371861786,
0.4694737792,
0.5607190728,
-0.2689715326,
-0.5712214708,
-0.7815915942,
-0.3570560813,
-0.540874362,
0.8556498885,
-0.2339520305,
-1.1048990488,
0.3384431005,
-0.045657292,
-0.1423996538,
0.4302962124,
0.762067914,
-0.0858519003,
1.1001046896,
0.7099682093,
-0.5144884586,
0.4807869196,
-0.1104717329,
0.4555099308,
-0.7660247684,
0.0067030122,
-0.3575183451,
-0.3973000348,
-0.3886122704,
-0.3460797369,
0.2746698558,
-0.1204371825,
-0.0897160247,
0.3665657341,
-0.6930654645,
0.5847842693,
0.1946677268,
-0.1046632007,
-0.1507288814,
0.1584105194,
0.1475310177,
-0.1637032032,
-0.8412487507,
0.3174304962,
0.8509088755,
0.4732482433,
0.9816632867,
-0.2487147003,
0.4174196422,
0.2067938596,
0.4068288207,
-0.9455624819,
0.5056333542,
-0.1546239853,
-0.3474832177,
-0.4466239214,
-0.4228540361,
-0.9913402796,
0.0473095104,
0.3020017445,
-0.7182529569,
0.038597405,
0.2784003913,
-0.7023767233,
-0.3182995021,
-0.6588013768,
0.9705069661,
0.0826911926,
-0.7087355852,
-0.3573087454,
-0.7347967029,
0.1594047695,
-0.2907617092,
-0.2184321284,
-0.1650899053,
-0.2400332242,
0.4161053002,
-0.0738212317,
0.8012672067,
0.0546081625,
-0.0446709953,
0.1519809067,
0.0897589028,
0.6392948031,
0.0974531099,
0.4290762544,
0.0476551242,
-0.5488122106,
-0.4230790138,
-0.6597043872,
1.0629607439,
-0.5122948885,
-0.5210418701,
-0.1461417824,
-0.7787513733,
-0.1888393462,
-0.0383515544,
0.1239290908,
0.2414464504,
0.1567217261,
0.2644743323,
0.8795835376,
-0.1398416758,
0.4476544261,
0.2913342118,
0.4366496205,
-0.3702957034,
0.9562106729,
0.2429230213,
0.3052165508,
0.6011679173,
-0.0651060492,
-0.410315603,
-0.1978518516,
-0.4310341179,
0.2826347649,
-0.6423601508,
-0.4013894796,
-1.0733491182,
-0.3334388435,
-0.3925138116,
-0.2544425726,
-0.586728096,
-0.4544168115,
-0.1196226701,
0.1155846119,
0.3637979329,
0.335434705,
-0.0330220051,
0.2882401049,
-0.4659206569,
0.7872823477,
0.6377379894,
0.7863843441,
0.2297420353,
-0.4804904163,
-0.6663438082,
-0.5333710909,
-0.1901155859,
-0.3113056421,
0.3287515342,
0.2913174927,
0.5298624635,
0.2168696523,
-0.2073978335,
0.7967646718,
-0.6543127298,
0.3886335194,
0.0001972224,
-0.6677002907,
0.302980572,
-0.4305928946,
0.5233277678,
0.3345082998,
0.3889696598,
-0.462815702,
-0.4008969367,
-0.1554543823,
-1.0299209356,
0.9459114671,
0.2340507656,
0.2361365706,
-0.0772599876,
0.4370626807,
-0.0473722965,
-0.0233503133,
-0.6570031047,
-0.3753610849,
-0.3739939332,
-0.4240292311,
-0.110636048,
-0.4498866796,
0.0899305642,
-0.2237439901,
0.4762766957,
-0.2617661655,
0.5364155173,
0.1908348054,
-0.1591393203,
-0.5800637007,
0.0119457077,
0.5666482449,
0.0949508101,
-0.1378030479,
0.0146768447,
0.2982388735,
-0.737214148,
0.03536864,
0.4395416975,
0.0107230553,
-0.1877162904,
0.1768011302,
0.5257654786,
0.5627034903,
-0.3745903075,
0.393660754,
-0.1698860675,
-0.1582898051,
-0.147818327,
-0.1715966165,
0.1732716858,
0.1020716503,
0.3500398099,
0.026660556,
0.2319272608,
0.2696601748,
0.4159129858,
0.3986858726,
-0.4402123392,
-0.1183625758,
0.8355069757,
0.1501081288,
-0.0437710211,
0.513692379,
0.2099727392,
-0.4292736053,
0.6322214007,
0.2285769284,
1.0798250437,
-0.4665626585,
-0.2646766603,
0.5535104871,
0.304032892,
0.1270458698,
-0.1717212498,
-0.6821494102,
-0.1137333885,
-0.9791076183,
-0.7709050775,
0.2490481883,
0.3766088188,
-0.3515042067,
0.081677407,
-0.6204331517,
0.0136728389,
0.1582577229,
-0.0887684077,
-0.5488895774,
-0.0273445249,
0.0846979618,
0.5180277228,
-0.4891484678,
0.7221320271,
0.0720491707,
0.0458456986,
-0.5233979225,
-0.1261806041,
-0.4008028209,
-0.7310402393,
0.9356591105,
0.4180209637,
-0.3083008826,
0.142618373,
-0.5059598684,
-1.2376321554,
0.6193329096,
0.3104394376,
-0.6231104136,
0.1826360673,
0.2454808056,
0.3796658814,
-0.0873729959,
0.1051096842,
0.4689362645,
0.2047257423,
0.0349883474,
-0.7596147656,
-0.0949058458,
-0.1361014396,
-0.0164423306,
0.7888806462,
-1.1050204039,
0.4987520278,
0.0860417187,
-0.1553227007,
0.3098243177,
0.8659897447,
-0.3035287261,
-0.1247165799,
0.5456551313,
0.7381474972,
0.0525307767,
0.0173356999,
0.782056272,
-0.3274971247,
0.353569746,
0.9110009074,
-0.15338552,
0.3237317204,
0.5454930663,
-0.14884305,
0.0753131136,
0.5647513866,
-0.0085321032,
0.8540930152,
0.3387553692,
-0.4766913652,
-0.5089222193,
-0.1315434873,
-0.1204934195,
0.2361145914,
0.4539381564,
-0.2222530544,
-0.3715393245,
-0.0240992904,
-0.4157523811,
-0.0659740418,
-0.4857751429,
0.8216612935,
0.0425353721,
-0.8880835772,
0.8446651697,
-0.1486866772,
0.5275142789,
-0.7536444664,
-0.1923933029,
-0.2109725177,
0.3469529152,
0.1078896895,
-0.2512622774,
0.2626731992,
-0.2222468555,
-0.4559508264,
-0.2668987811,
0.843456924,
-0.5505343676,
-0.2931275666,
0.3636991084,
-0.1032545418,
-0.1472978741,
-0.136934191,
-0.7175802588,
0.0215082131,
-0.1692820042,
-0.2541131675,
0.5971319675,
0.3996859789,
0.0549495965,
0.7620058656,
0.55771631,
-0.2303001434,
0.4143460989,
0.0423705466,
1.0105348825,
-0.5295660496,
-0.7494305372,
-0.5906738043,
0.1816458553,
0.1182545349,
-0.2047115713,
0.635538578,
0.531719327,
0.5572496653,
-0.1649610698,
0.4762431383,
0.3061967194,
0.5311026573,
-0.1983962059,
0.6472818851,
-0.4245039821,
-0.0932332575,
-0.1302425116,
-1.0536551476,
-0.2972861528,
0.6778856516,
-0.0480000712,
0.2372052372,
0.5628239512,
0.6956912875,
-0.344949156,
-0.4619835913,
0.5064287186,
0.2733379304,
-0.1201397479,
0.8894893527,
0.8541744351,
-0.3815992475,
0.7189046144,
-0.4893581867,
-0.0444311425,
-0.1150995269,
-0.6269049048,
-0.9960718751,
-0.3948342502,
-0.3441665769,
-0.2595327199,
0.002435487,
0.7325539589,
0.8697912097,
-0.5685480833,
0.0517458543,
0.0468863808,
-0.0508652329,
-0.0500483923,
-0.2694804072,
0.5180978775,
-0.6945236921,
-0.6477591395,
0.2529681027,
0.6615596414,
-0.1722567827,
-0.4001743793,
-0.0516308695,
-0.0350585058,
-0.0476618223,
0.6732415557,
0.2877611816,
-0.5793786049,
-0.2495875061,
0.3674574494,
-0.1615566015,
0.2243904471,
0.8792248368,
-0.892486155,
0.4509876966,
0.3982006013,
0.9486289024,
0.6333777308,
-0.0383134708,
0.2970033586,
-0.9636732936,
0.463953048,
0.4876866341,
0.1251952499,
0.2330957204,
-0.8192697167,
0.3239633739,
0.301882416,
-0.7075374126,
-0.6567763686,
0.1311075985,
-1.2647680044,
0.0435754955,
0.990257442,
0.0586693212,
-0.4368939102,
-0.4661666155,
-0.0787778795,
0.0558641814,
-0.5469225049,
0.8278659582,
0.6866908073,
0.1682016999,
-0.4098059833,
-0.6017771959,
0.7520586848,
0.8381096721,
-0.3906960487,
0.4877580106,
0.249955222,
0.1662989259,
-0.0192958135,
0.557002604,
0.07559558,
0.5741087198,
-0.0967235714,
-0.1706327498,
0.21024324,
-0.480740428,
-0.422983259,
0.2106867284,
-0.2263827771,
-0.1073568687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16746v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16746v2
|
The Responsible Foundation Model Development Cheatsheet: A Review of Tools & Resources
| 2024-06-24T15:55:49 | 2024-06-26T02:19:01 |
Shayne Longpre, Stella Biderman, Alon Albalak, Hailey Schoelkopf, Daniel McDuff, Sayash Kapoor, Kevin Klyman, Kyle Lo, Gabriel Ilharco, Nay San, Maribeth Rauh, Aviya Skowron, Bertie Vidgen, Laura Weidinger, Arvind Narayanan, Victor Sanh, David Adelani, Percy Liang, Rishi Bommasani, Peter Henderson, Sasha Luccioni, Yacine Jernite, Luca Soldaini
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Foundation model development attracts a rapidly expanding body of
contributors, scientists, and applications. To help shape responsible
development practices, we introduce the Foundation Model Development
Cheatsheet: a growing collection of 250+ tools and resources spanning text,
vision, and speech modalities. We draw on a large body of prior work to survey
resources (e.g. software, documentation, frameworks, guides, and practical
tools) that support informed data selection, processing, and understanding,
precise and limitation-aware artifact documentation, efficient model training,
advance awareness of the environmental impact from training, careful model
evaluation of capabilities, risks, and claims, as well as responsible model
release, licensing and deployment practices. We hope this curated collection of
resources helps guide more responsible development. The process of curating
this list, enabled us to review the AI development ecosystem, revealing what
tools are critically missing, misused, or over-used in existing practices. We
find that (i) tools for data sourcing, model evaluation, and monitoring are
critically under-serving ethical and real-world needs, (ii) evaluations for
model safety, capabilities, and environmental impact all lack reproducibility
and transparency, (iii) text and particularly English-centric analyses continue
to dominate over multilingual and multi-modal analyses, and (iv) evaluation of
systems, rather than just models, is needed so that capabilities and impact are
assessed in context.
|
[
-0.2561678886,
-0.4291836023,
0.1972852647,
0.3604350388,
-0.0578345694,
-0.0777073056,
0.2936491668,
-0.4868105352,
-0.2719798982,
0.9553797245,
-0.672983706,
-0.1011923403,
-0.4533241093,
-0.0718971044,
-0.5640221238,
1.1666697264,
-0.0144880647,
0.187278524,
-0.5983349681,
0.07358744,
-0.6557838917,
0.0130271353,
-0.3217429221,
-0.1953939348,
0.2354597747,
0.2950514853,
0.7324795127,
0.8228260279,
0.8089735508,
0.264131844,
-0.151477322,
-0.1822181493,
-0.5942969322,
-0.1553088129,
-0.3340203762,
0.0638346374,
-0.7482900023,
0.5475190878,
0.1608859748,
0.8398791552,
-0.1783124208,
0.6345619559,
0.0421140566,
0.4035137296,
-0.8973380923,
0.4056813121,
-0.0686613247,
-0.1074103713,
-0.2425783128,
-0.0109570753,
-0.340692997,
-0.1146962196,
0.0912522674,
-0.6368188858,
0.2696545124,
-0.3327903748,
0.3015955091,
0.5173600316,
-0.5527660251,
-0.4148473144,
-0.773892045,
0.9154227972,
-0.4847800136,
0.657679081,
0.6029918194,
0.2964945138,
-0.2027466893,
-1.0283504725,
-0.2229334563,
-0.3609975576,
0.1138943806,
0.0125817191,
-0.0185173228,
-0.0000755483,
0.1364199966,
0.1810069382,
-0.2349485457,
-0.0720749721,
-0.8351602554,
-0.6280174255,
0.9749698043,
0.0225769859,
0.2483231574,
-0.332275629,
-0.3236710727,
-0.2613917291,
-0.8692638874,
0.1082105413,
0.4820765555,
0.167218253,
-0.2434676886,
0.663633287,
0.1677938402,
0.7733967304,
-0.2221482694,
-0.0904685259,
-0.0751915574,
-0.7705404162,
-0.1755816191,
-0.0389277413,
0.2464714348,
0.3318366706,
0.0823194832,
-0.1734172553,
-0.3687077463,
0.1209372133,
0.6722809076,
-0.8570510745,
-0.4265993536,
0.3276351988,
-0.4564574361,
-0.319906652,
0.0262146126,
-0.7719377279,
-0.6408218145,
-0.4684027731,
-0.0202507358,
0.0192828588,
-0.3463832736,
-0.0574844442,
-0.4156451523,
0.083906889,
0.2940124869,
-0.5769981742,
0.280831784,
0.6646156311,
0.4215004146,
0.0700260401,
-0.2126634419,
-0.532789588,
0.1904465854,
-0.5403279662,
0.4746697247,
-0.5221742392,
-0.8280391097,
-0.200833708,
-0.0202522893,
0.4216348529,
-0.3551807404,
0.3864397109,
-0.1995518506,
-0.0793853924,
-0.3711959422,
-0.2997943163,
-0.2776459157,
0.1350056082,
-1.0486629009,
0.7676790357,
0.2465249598,
-0.4364696741,
0.5772166252,
-0.8142597675,
-0.4547593892,
0.0022304358,
-0.1188128218,
-0.2770049274,
-0.1121178642,
0.0115383714,
0.4782125354,
-0.4939504862,
0.6447089911,
-0.2540924549,
-0.2977614701,
-0.2311133593,
-0.2858509719,
1.2809964418,
0.2430794686,
-0.5354509354,
0.2568727732,
-0.6965423822,
0.0922337174,
-0.1478340477,
-0.3169527352,
0.0116609149,
0.0828605071,
0.4990506768,
0.1127914339,
0.20552136,
-0.2474541813,
-0.2552986145,
0.1749560833,
0.6405018568,
0.9238916636,
-0.0314672813,
0.478682071,
-0.1653754115,
0.8276759982,
-0.0504155122,
0.4915317595,
-0.3215440214,
-0.3629791141,
-0.5315436125,
-0.1638513356,
0.1091103554,
0.3133441806,
0.0109255696,
0.284314543,
-0.1303407252,
-0.865269959,
-0.5950270295,
0.2539932132,
0.5265696049,
0.7039327025,
0.3328230381,
-0.3178038895,
-0.4449191689,
-1.0108405352,
-0.0934791192,
-0.3385277987,
0.4447658658,
0.3785853684,
0.8500506878,
-0.4291249216,
1.0752049685,
-0.0855313316,
-0.2466624677,
-0.0363229103,
-0.0283490978,
-0.4093010724,
0.78810817,
0.7716719508,
-1.3174369335,
0.102338478,
-0.2162308097,
-0.5066267848,
0.0600913689,
-0.0184978526,
-0.1107712388,
-0.0986271873,
0.4951575696,
-0.6554584503,
0.3468608856,
0.5175099969,
-0.5677964091,
0.4874911308,
0.1873494387,
0.0110461805,
-0.8537221551,
0.7367855906,
0.0129990699,
-0.1448249668,
-0.327126801,
0.4932573736,
0.3181218803,
-0.3203864694,
-0.3991048038,
0.8226343393,
-0.5779172778,
-0.2779932022,
0.1462823898,
0.1108946428,
0.2651961744,
-0.253541708,
-0.2157966942,
1.0630482435,
0.2810759544,
-0.6647430062,
0.4692889452,
0.4572989345,
-0.1840848923,
0.5489300489,
-0.7137468457,
0.0036910882,
-0.1503260732,
0.4247789681,
-0.043305371,
-0.4074320495,
0.2232401222,
-0.2781247795,
0.2737042904,
-0.0366255865,
-0.3999872506,
-0.2653823495,
-0.1092085242,
0.1993130147,
0.2635327876,
-0.242613852,
0.5504173636,
0.859442234,
-0.0105334446,
-0.8584275842,
-0.9604504108,
-0.0933264717,
0.0256891008,
-0.5716819167,
0.3218783736,
-0.2058070153,
-0.5417627096,
0.3504826725,
-0.3094910979,
-0.450383395,
0.4491175115,
0.3599585891,
0.0032122871,
-0.0262985602,
0.0067872535,
-0.3054181933,
-0.0998204052,
0.4858734906,
0.0475760922,
-0.0143467104,
-0.1083906069,
-0.4230362177,
-0.0031181222,
0.4315787852,
0.7062823176,
-0.6749323606,
0.1918866336,
0.4117978811,
-0.6644479632,
-0.2071559578,
-0.3403262794,
-0.4159433544,
-0.4037596881,
0.4445820749,
0.0274444781,
-0.6078962088,
0.4871470034,
0.159127906,
0.2721094489,
0.421959579,
0.2187184542,
0.2281111181,
0.9092363119,
1.2202204466,
-0.0641719326,
0.1782236993,
-0.5064482689,
0.4105300903,
-0.7324928045,
-0.5424204469,
-0.5223814249,
-0.0699955523,
-0.3932141364,
-0.3322178423,
-0.0531872287,
0.2931841314,
-0.2705856264,
0.2517951131,
-0.6206898689,
0.4508027732,
0.4093758464,
-0.0299449936,
0.1981142759,
-0.5243400335,
0.3043580055,
-0.11180906,
-0.557294488,
-0.7208246589,
1.0897977352,
0.2419789135,
0.6143419147,
0.0528751947,
0.5735935569,
0.4784865081,
0.6346723437,
-0.6401750445,
0.4129975736,
0.173176378,
-1.2075991631,
-0.1474062651,
-0.2271637321,
-0.5297820568,
-0.365319103,
0.2257343084,
-0.343795985,
0.3074259758,
0.1906395257,
-0.4067658186,
-0.0688631833,
-0.6108952761,
1.1951489449,
-0.103532739,
-0.2860092819,
-0.4700685441,
-0.4367437065,
0.4749437273,
-0.2039176077,
0.1986505836,
0.0988041312,
0.0701458529,
0.6577545404,
-0.3613958657,
0.9004594684,
-0.1717669964,
0.0205356367,
0.7031922936,
0.012077054,
0.3553239405,
0.1578250229,
-0.1801279634,
-0.1668234169,
0.054573752,
-0.4470345974,
-0.1835193485,
0.7563138604,
-0.7059306502,
-0.5391325355,
-0.5258336663,
-0.519974649,
-0.0762165189,
0.6235810518,
-0.0253940243,
0.28037256,
-0.6526723504,
0.4138503075,
0.57032758,
0.1612354666,
0.2895611525,
0.3878428638,
-0.0225227121,
-0.0591088384,
0.5735209584,
0.3019127548,
0.0422869995,
-0.2316998541,
-0.0276394021,
-0.0392643064,
-0.4039555192,
-0.3812698126,
-0.1351823807,
-0.8646574616,
-0.3800218999,
-0.4585760236,
-0.2798027396,
-0.5321133733,
-0.3226734102,
-0.5190115571,
-0.2715947628,
-0.3856572807,
-0.4903776348,
0.4385257363,
0.8205696344,
-0.2178070694,
0.0833162889,
-0.6725367308,
0.2190898359,
0.1515768021,
0.3221259117,
-0.1303258836,
0.2100031227,
-0.1780056059,
0.2217010856,
-0.3975844681,
-0.7489829659,
0.1207083315,
0.0486484841,
0.6839362383,
0.2584335208,
0.1194690168,
0.7119085193,
-0.1653848737,
0.8390187025,
-0.1164956912,
-0.9028182626,
0.5907459855,
-0.5274609327,
-0.0433455631,
0.5181899667,
0.3186327815,
-0.1893188655,
-0.0164998509,
-0.8199455142,
-0.7852098942,
0.7491933107,
0.2567104399,
0.2535172403,
0.1464778334,
0.2286614329,
0.025104763,
0.3757009804,
-0.6576470137,
0.066601865,
-0.3211517632,
0.022314433,
-0.0358526334,
-0.0763239488,
-0.6530816555,
-0.0162007287,
0.8101145029,
-0.1099121273,
0.0073186336,
0.1689835787,
-0.1841170788,
-0.2070301622,
-0.0491020009,
0.392732203,
1.0690939426,
-0.1591158807,
-0.2218766809,
-0.359316498,
-0.8020991087,
-0.0662821755,
0.529161036,
-0.3787975907,
-0.3839814961,
0.3033493459,
0.4492145479,
0.3761391938,
-0.8083600998,
0.5104202628,
0.2752486169,
0.2817038298,
-0.4203320146,
0.1372065395,
0.266373992,
0.1700168699,
0.1184296235,
0.3848327994,
0.3846085966,
-0.481364429,
0.3832972944,
0.326665014,
-0.5596616864,
-0.1292448342,
0.6522731185,
0.6250979304,
-0.2808404267,
0.8593956232,
-0.1284890175,
-0.1533789784,
1.1150871515,
0.4071708918,
0.7997250557,
-0.1710808873,
0.5187807679,
0.119583413,
0.68383497,
-0.2610149086,
0.4577391744,
-0.0338166468,
-0.4151373506,
-0.2959799767,
-0.3703711927,
-0.3908180594,
0.3036539555,
-0.6791737676,
0.3767289221,
-0.6668803692,
-0.1385726184,
0.070070751,
0.2021774352,
-0.8939924836,
0.4609194398,
-0.2880771756,
1.1448949575,
-0.6486740112,
0.3742882609,
0.787694037,
-0.6810495853,
-0.7867771387,
-0.2982772589,
0.3750436306,
-0.3901736736,
0.3448148072,
0.3034065068,
-0.2552601397,
0.1473430246,
-0.8452186584,
-0.8892551064,
1.3099406958,
0.5228542686,
-0.233338207,
0.0848060399,
-0.1462051719,
0.3511115611,
-0.3588936031,
0.0680812299,
0.5344334841,
0.7348807454,
-0.4727346301,
-0.828704834,
-0.0063335281,
-0.442366451,
-0.2324337959,
0.1398720294,
-0.553555727,
0.7123421431,
-0.428420186,
-0.1013970003,
0.0825198516,
0.2849930823,
0.4464051127,
0.3551619649,
0.0987444371,
0.2717303038,
0.5885264277,
0.053807538,
1.0694380999,
-0.4520778358,
0.1498640776,
0.7681928873,
-0.1159739494,
0.6340177059,
0.6626286507,
0.1911248565,
0.0007947177,
0.7531254888,
-0.1594724506,
0.3841076493,
0.061832875,
0.1413304061,
-0.2574696839,
-0.552500844,
-0.3917707503,
0.4733344316,
0.3057587147,
-0.4316248596,
-0.2912509441,
-0.1517683566,
0.0646330938,
0.1032756642,
-0.264416337,
0.1517567635,
0.225370273,
-0.5687940121,
-0.1069510058,
0.1707762182,
-0.0523186959,
-0.511808455,
-0.3223465681,
-0.1435043216,
0.214796409,
-0.2550229132,
-0.8051374555,
0.4957951605,
0.1028489769,
-0.3879230022,
-0.6012178063,
0.6045737863,
0.0997514576,
-0.6193732619,
0.4479492903,
0.5801342726,
-0.1232071444,
0.1442734152,
-0.7497153878,
0.1087627038,
-0.2117473334,
-0.4033547342,
-0.0297434125,
0.2515366971,
-0.4520195723,
0.9162067175,
0.7738908529,
-0.0136861987,
-0.082558535,
-0.1298327297,
0.8124451637,
-0.5773777962,
-0.4974335432,
-0.3878718019,
0.8554775119,
-0.0888362303,
-0.8023600578,
0.5048499703,
0.3706994057,
1.008218646,
0.0543633923,
0.8286784887,
-0.329127878,
0.0099926079,
-0.2236949503,
1.0256521702,
-0.3391940594,
0.0819574222,
-0.2218027264,
-1.030490756,
-0.2799808383,
0.7660017014,
0.0968151316,
0.3781918287,
0.130514577,
0.6231495738,
-0.1865584701,
0.0967234597,
-0.1952881217,
0.1970610321,
0.4789534509,
-0.1246669739,
0.3491654694,
-0.4792633057,
0.4882993996,
-0.5084201097,
-0.2991001904,
-0.1590157747,
-1.2318495512,
-0.5902152061,
-0.5860810876,
-0.4066132903,
-0.1636694819,
0.234494105,
0.5764703751,
1.0326662064,
-0.7697674036,
-0.213357091,
-0.4490038157,
0.002325485,
-0.3430439234,
-0.2326116115,
0.0456974171,
0.1581189781,
-0.3518832922,
0.4996697903,
0.0256563574,
-0.038686052,
-0.931214571,
-0.1467038393,
-0.0097005134,
0.003339095,
0.2891997695,
0.445371598,
-0.6028001308,
-0.1810924113,
0.2429417074,
-0.1800234914,
-0.480605036,
0.6770331264,
-0.63611269,
0.5766091943,
0.4373536408,
0.547469914,
0.0662202016,
-0.3338940144,
1.0090682507,
-0.3948376775,
0.2906766832,
0.7062135339,
0.3294143379,
0.6126339436,
-0.5591722727,
0.848212719,
-0.1752701402,
-0.6542761326,
-1.1328361034,
0.3357490599,
-0.6105534434,
-0.0824703798,
0.7102962136,
-0.1552818567,
-0.0720729828,
0.0688679144,
-0.104229182,
0.1577188075,
-0.3030872345,
0.8163092136,
0.8472830653,
0.0610965043,
-0.1266471744,
-0.6918917298,
0.7065327168,
0.1088925526,
-0.9119935036,
0.184352681,
0.9114764929,
0.1126456931,
0.4086060524,
0.508179605,
-0.2608255744,
0.5788270235,
0.175097689,
0.1351461112,
-0.1125297546,
-0.716803968,
-0.1730270982,
-0.2656756639,
-0.0471193157,
0.2919127941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16743v1
|
Adversarial Contrastive Decoding: Boosting Safety Alignment of Large Language Models via Opposite Prompt Optimization
| 2024-06-24T15:51:30 | 2024-06-24T15:51:30 |
Zhengyue Zhao, Xiaoyun Zhang, Kaidi Xu, Xing Hu, Rui Zhang, Zidong Du, Qi Guo, Yunji Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the widespread application of Large Language Models (LLMs), it has
become a significant concern to ensure their safety and prevent harmful
responses. While current safe-alignment methods based on instruction
fine-tuning and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) can
effectively reduce harmful responses from LLMs, they often require high-quality
datasets and heavy computational overhead during model training. Another way to
align language models is to modify the logit of tokens in model outputs without
heavy training. Recent studies have shown that contrastive decoding can enhance
the performance of language models by reducing the likelihood of confused
tokens. However, these methods require the manual selection of contrastive
models or instruction templates. To this end, we propose Adversarial
Contrastive Decoding (ACD), an optimization-based framework to generate two
opposite system prompts for prompt-based contrastive decoding. ACD only needs
to apply a lightweight prompt tuning on a rather small anchor dataset (< 3 min
for each model) without training the target model. Experiments conducted on
extensive models and benchmarks demonstrate that the proposed method achieves
much better safety performance than previous model training-free decoding
methods without sacrificing its original generation ability.
|
[
-0.3128252327,
-0.8159874082,
0.1058980748,
-0.1313621104,
-0.4710131884,
-0.1958388239,
-0.048614841,
-0.2835598588,
-0.0348852202,
0.4386303127,
-0.6339607239,
-0.4305277467,
-0.4485245049,
0.0567834191,
-0.2816339433,
1.0041568279,
0.1329084933,
0.4754154682,
-0.0537057966,
-0.2586915195,
-0.412799418,
-0.5509450436,
-1.1457873583,
-0.1865505129,
0.4294538498,
0.2466955632,
0.9807397723,
1.1382060051,
0.3161719739,
0.2982500196,
-0.1612151861,
0.1871512383,
-0.4354649484,
0.1673313528,
-0.1405064762,
-0.3754564822,
-0.2002992779,
-0.1701540351,
0.3973621428,
0.4887283146,
0.032436952,
-0.3276072145,
0.2584528625,
0.5936290622,
-0.804797709,
-0.0771447867,
-0.3667794764,
0.0224273261,
0.1920052767,
-0.493224889,
-0.4003333449,
-0.5373954773,
-0.0594747774,
-0.6512745023,
0.2302773446,
0.2701429427,
0.7737137079,
0.4095660448,
-0.4190153778,
-0.3127557635,
-0.2356526256,
0.6884309649,
-0.7714906931,
0.1078760624,
0.1920374036,
0.0861074701,
-0.252732724,
-0.1600524038,
-0.5045208335,
-0.042293001,
-0.0761222318,
0.0531524532,
-0.2256432921,
0.4100889862,
0.1129430309,
0.0887847245,
-0.7467911243,
0.5697692633,
0.0952476338,
-0.2759782374,
0.4834915996,
0.4927260578,
0.3938658535,
0.1762427837,
-0.3903077245,
-0.4907850921,
-1.058591485,
0.1132488027,
0.694588542,
0.5601838231,
-0.2054933012,
0.3443260789,
-0.0533703268,
0.6241540313,
0.2798644602,
0.2030448765,
-0.0396827348,
-0.1682346761,
-0.0889399275,
0.2810862064,
0.895123601,
0.6086286306,
0.042643141,
-0.202052474,
-0.3814779222,
0.4567641914,
0.213215366,
-0.9147931933,
-0.3877193332,
0.13715446,
-0.4372861087,
-0.749358356,
-0.2434165776,
-0.8714434505,
-0.7703694105,
-0.2692397535,
0.446626842,
-0.4928171635,
0.072673656,
-0.0295047481,
0.0075559556,
0.1785982549,
0.1842455566,
-0.9938543439,
0.1560490876,
0.6937549114,
0.6286956072,
-0.1378980428,
-0.241162613,
-1.0757631063,
-0.1450334638,
-0.6441527009,
0.544549346,
-0.4371702373,
-0.5102930665,
0.0981739983,
0.0249511506,
0.0258305352,
-0.2975955904,
0.5800343752,
-0.8151310086,
0.2610091865,
-0.4877682626,
-0.4052347243,
-0.1585734785,
0.282975018,
-0.5752236247,
0.4266402423,
-0.2117429376,
-0.9584502578,
0.0020876932,
-0.3325960338,
-0.7266854644,
-0.1764903367,
-0.2514313161,
-0.5699261427,
0.0126130963,
0.6594400406,
0.0946188346,
-0.4195996523,
0.0754331201,
-0.3545123339,
-0.5203088522,
0.1384447664,
-0.6527777314,
0.9617236257,
0.4620017409,
-0.4854525626,
0.4365753531,
-0.6147722006,
-0.0916495994,
0.2705190778,
-0.2853425443,
-0.2750369012,
-0.0837928057,
-0.0988133624,
0.2204534411,
0.1734673977,
-0.3668242991,
-0.0628375486,
-0.6368559003,
0.1732484549,
0.952262938,
-0.0262071062,
0.5236289501,
-0.3617857099,
0.9085937738,
0.087566942,
0.0412355028,
-0.3643417656,
-0.2158662677,
-0.7366390228,
-0.1837824285,
0.254252255,
0.7631321549,
-0.9862982631,
0.6572578549,
0.0663278028,
-0.0523409359,
-0.7842279077,
0.0298026372,
0.8961220384,
0.9313057065,
0.4617960453,
-0.0325769149,
-0.5227117538,
-0.7180533409,
-0.150720045,
-0.2637489438,
0.1825975329,
0.3690103292,
0.0441343635,
-0.1237187907,
0.5158433914,
-0.4725463986,
-0.033756461,
-0.19371517,
0.0879025385,
0.0438048542,
0.5896146894,
0.4657340348,
-0.7091827989,
-0.390234381,
-0.0813971609,
-0.6451773643,
-0.2698867619,
-0.1214941442,
-0.18344374,
0.3598035574,
0.8486477137,
-0.383659333,
0.1857810616,
0.5697939396,
-0.4233415723,
0.5114974976,
-0.3185307682,
0.2313958853,
-0.9899831414,
0.3301244378,
-0.2329122126,
-0.037850529,
-0.6020337939,
0.3225086033,
0.1362850517,
-0.296331495,
-0.3229890466,
0.66636163,
-0.4299207628,
0.2286548913,
-0.5253081918,
0.116885379,
0.0876274258,
0.4521132708,
-0.0380710885,
0.8597302437,
0.6920769811,
-0.5800167322,
0.4894727767,
0.1842647046,
0.0073517072,
0.5554454327,
-0.5874009132,
0.1293129921,
-0.3401375711,
0.2482126355,
-1.0713437796,
0.0071351086,
0.4534500539,
-0.3596978784,
0.540225625,
-0.1606740505,
-0.1616535187,
-0.1515528411,
-0.3847639561,
0.6554554105,
0.613717556,
-0.8983000517,
0.3012873232,
0.2560685277,
-0.2165048271,
-0.9490212202,
-0.5911415815,
0.1420872062,
-0.4416816831,
-0.4607294202,
0.0645670667,
-0.0954073966,
-0.0386357009,
-0.033316236,
-0.0732112676,
0.2997322083,
0.3922514319,
0.0741759539,
0.5105655789,
-0.345202893,
-0.0691996217,
0.0170991905,
-0.327488929,
0.092842944,
-0.2094853073,
0.4325116575,
0.0117026465,
-0.3827247918,
-0.590474844,
0.4918337762,
0.2947617471,
-0.0966772586,
0.826026082,
0.4895945489,
-0.1872474253,
-0.0990683958,
-0.2701981068,
-0.4255219102,
-0.5208377242,
0.3685440719,
-0.1965619028,
-0.579793632,
0.4477160275,
0.2967858613,
0.0387226045,
0.2208237052,
0.2712804079,
0.1069330797,
1.5132642984,
0.4746886194,
-0.3663614094,
0.6349785328,
0.1015918627,
0.1766596735,
-0.5457871556,
-0.082262516,
-0.7368798852,
-0.2492629141,
-0.4478625357,
-0.067234993,
0.3079121113,
0.2221821696,
-0.3372378945,
0.1752004176,
-0.423042506,
0.6918604374,
0.5531841516,
0.2359554768,
0.0646733046,
-0.0830426589,
-0.351025939,
0.1020734534,
-0.8124815226,
-0.3113104105,
0.9047855735,
0.1707765609,
1.189922452,
0.0126364203,
0.6330657601,
0.0129306633,
0.0307342764,
-0.6932670474,
0.628256619,
-0.4066380858,
-0.1832582653,
-0.2093500793,
-0.6965695024,
-1.0097308159,
0.2688699961,
-0.2849512398,
-0.3817985058,
0.2743541598,
0.4966503978,
-0.5347627401,
0.1921694577,
-0.8082578182,
0.8603460193,
-0.3089641631,
-0.1616980284,
-0.1380406469,
-0.9180995822,
0.2732607424,
0.2437375784,
0.1019839346,
0.3644777238,
-0.1008539647,
0.5155703425,
-0.3801490068,
0.7968255877,
-0.3119002581,
-0.3028001785,
0.0542448834,
0.1841271669,
1.0672210455,
-0.1827869415,
-0.0290002376,
-0.3705671132,
-0.2722647786,
-0.4090336859,
-0.5911493301,
0.882574439,
-0.7088894844,
-0.6785600185,
-0.2544391751,
-0.5857556462,
-0.2819500864,
0.1920461804,
0.5829750299,
0.6829253435,
-0.2657882869,
0.0558001772,
0.9161957502,
-0.4291935563,
0.3808515966,
0.4244069457,
0.1799737513,
-0.5710263848,
1.0063422918,
-0.399523437,
0.2832602262,
0.5408953428,
0.1264094859,
-0.5281531811,
-0.8023059964,
-0.5532804132,
-0.0365885943,
-0.9238211513,
-0.4465555549,
-0.6059436202,
-0.0642242506,
-0.4984353781,
-0.4309121966,
-0.1888774037,
-0.2953084707,
-0.6728747487,
0.073215358,
0.0449853353,
0.3951053321,
-0.1258425415,
0.2458619028,
-0.70873487,
0.4512766898,
0.2141015977,
0.0701907799,
0.0670367703,
-0.4969550073,
-0.190776825,
0.1244186386,
-0.144093737,
-0.708393991,
0.3336855173,
-0.0865636766,
0.4798870981,
0.6997948885,
0.5889946818,
0.6207920313,
-0.4053421617,
0.5246514082,
0.4410041273,
-0.7187483311,
0.3018454611,
-0.2574167252,
0.3139042854,
0.467705369,
0.2312295884,
-0.4296126068,
-0.2084049582,
-0.3017564714,
-0.9127147198,
0.9297456741,
-0.1947086155,
-0.0182841569,
-0.1947619915,
0.073732838,
-0.0512835272,
-0.0333205983,
-0.4433312714,
-0.2356013656,
-0.3325698674,
-0.5553545356,
-0.2161991894,
-0.173371613,
-0.4924216568,
0.4271731377,
0.906014204,
-0.3287802935,
0.0916484371,
-0.0506724678,
-0.0766355097,
-0.2750173509,
0.3663667142,
0.6257755756,
-0.0418002307,
0.0059223138,
0.2977320552,
0.1718208939,
-0.1968747824,
0.3207296431,
0.3414902687,
-0.1228368431,
-0.4154027104,
0.2139066607,
0.7353333831,
0.0768319219,
-0.6851966381,
0.7078066468,
-0.2230335176,
0.1531575918,
0.3176809847,
0.3102073073,
-0.1496455669,
0.3570416272,
0.1641517282,
0.144464314,
0.1071257815,
-0.1528331339,
0.1420845389,
0.8569081426,
-0.3669145703,
-0.153932035,
0.8105382919,
0.42911461,
-0.2162469029,
0.5019083023,
-0.225035727,
-0.4639786184,
0.7703087926,
0.6954358816,
1.0341008902,
-0.2792606056,
-0.0891419202,
0.2917548418,
0.2017597258,
-0.1287422031,
0.0445262715,
0.0899000019,
-0.6717295051,
-0.115798831,
-0.4164635241,
-0.3517810106,
0.2757525444,
-0.7730184793,
0.3667992949,
-0.4935261607,
0.1368245929,
-0.3337970674,
-0.1033321917,
-0.2360887229,
0.4273919463,
0.0840145051,
0.7031918168,
-0.805877924,
0.6450146437,
0.5758632421,
-0.0354517139,
-0.5001956224,
0.1432893872,
0.1934633851,
-0.880633831,
0.2721494436,
0.2660358846,
-0.4985166192,
0.0515923686,
-0.4021306038,
-0.5040630698,
0.8080006242,
0.6524899602,
-0.6269251108,
-0.2269560099,
-0.2676824629,
0.4529514015,
-0.4339961708,
0.0291919429,
0.3254420161,
0.0675634593,
0.126782909,
-0.4015287757,
0.503038466,
-0.2839612663,
0.0689499676,
0.2162238657,
-0.4678071737,
0.6049305797,
-0.5221962929,
-0.5663903952,
0.4784429371,
0.5024257898,
0.2628862858,
0.0269280784,
0.4972872138,
0.6735438704,
0.5074547529,
0.0730459243,
1.066519022,
-0.4784775674,
0.0333454534,
1.0992816687,
0.0075387331,
0.5279142857,
0.3383597732,
0.1818799227,
0.1176220402,
0.5298871398,
0.1210485026,
0.8949829936,
0.0180432238,
-0.3125933409,
-0.3029952049,
-0.1660929769,
-0.6234309673,
0.0540380664,
0.2931405902,
-0.4571369886,
-0.3203022778,
-0.1427339464,
0.0763987303,
0.2256752253,
-0.3077839315,
0.8152768612,
-0.0887524709,
-0.8907091618,
0.8565653563,
0.0732785612,
0.7852196097,
-0.467219919,
0.1081867293,
-0.317230016,
0.3145709932,
-0.0471754372,
-0.4825991988,
0.0685591698,
-0.027775256,
-0.0768865123,
-0.0589764677,
0.4074130356,
-0.57580477,
-0.0553128347,
0.2499750108,
0.0025402191,
-0.2473982126,
0.2409290075,
-0.8178756237,
-0.0113544222,
0.0622835606,
-0.1059635431,
0.5531572104,
0.3047222793,
0.1625244915,
0.6379081607,
0.701846838,
0.0665513203,
-0.2132625282,
-0.0214957464,
1.0018132925,
-0.6575224996,
-1.0079039335,
-0.8750603795,
0.2268204242,
0.2530720234,
-0.1594288796,
0.5720446706,
0.3465256989,
0.4837788939,
0.0677046627,
0.7307076454,
0.2933195233,
0.212328136,
-0.8576823473,
0.5648853779,
-0.4400743544,
0.4581789374,
-0.1832240671,
-0.5515555143,
-0.327596575,
0.4296159148,
-0.1438893825,
0.0390284024,
0.525652945,
1.2190978527,
0.0594352596,
0.08728645,
0.2555995584,
0.0825533196,
0.3810604811,
0.6698366404,
0.805185318,
-0.3722713888,
0.9024547338,
-0.048447866,
-0.197020337,
-0.4385842681,
-0.9040605426,
-1.037103653,
-0.2336769253,
-0.2941823006,
-0.6655703783,
0.4054370821,
0.9607393146,
0.5531115532,
-1.0938347578,
0.1523474902,
-0.3904464841,
0.0801007599,
-0.1521113217,
-0.2333645672,
0.5249940157,
-0.6018035412,
-0.6702893376,
0.7119396329,
0.1318620741,
0.47654742,
0.0155694596,
-0.4460310042,
0.0155389141,
0.134344846,
0.0414321534,
0.5617301464,
-0.6256827712,
-0.0813785866,
-0.1587857008,
-0.4403982162,
-0.0680583939,
0.682205081,
-0.7049478292,
0.4999864697,
0.63570261,
1.0305150747,
-0.0492404625,
0.3494124413,
0.8029721975,
-0.7374622226,
0.2241245806,
0.2282293439,
0.3647803366,
0.5499987602,
-0.6749145389,
0.1131717861,
-0.0298791993,
-0.5110089779,
-0.8849011064,
0.3968634009,
-0.5715035796,
-0.4850530326,
1.1612797976,
-0.3789467514,
-0.0470735021,
-0.1915195286,
-0.3365384638,
0.3213919401,
-0.5902983546,
0.819648087,
0.441519469,
-0.0545216985,
-0.0949363932,
0.2327020317,
0.7923888564,
0.6713413,
-0.6334503293,
0.2222844958,
0.5924447179,
0.059726119,
-0.0269475281,
0.2411449701,
-0.0881016403,
0.5408481359,
0.2168125957,
-0.3103477955,
-0.3483885229,
-0.2987377942,
-1.0413305759,
0.1906332672,
0.0150962221,
-0.4464771152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16732v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16732v2
|
CLIMATELI: Evaluating Entity Linking on Climate Change Data
| 2024-06-24T15:36:00 | 2024-06-27T14:44:51 |
Shijia Zhou, Siyao Peng, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Climate Change (CC) is a pressing topic of global importance, attracting
increasing attention across research fields, from social sciences to Natural
Language Processing (NLP). CC is also discussed in various settings and
communication platforms, from academic publications to social media forums.
Understanding who and what is mentioned in such data is a first critical step
to gaining new insights into CC. We present CLIMATELI (CLIMATe Entity LInking),
the first manually annotated CC dataset that links 3,087 entity spans to
Wikipedia. Using CLIMATELI (CLIMATe Entity LInking), we evaluate existing
entity linking (EL) systems on the CC topic across various genres and propose
automated filtering methods for CC entities. We find that the performance of EL
models notably lags behind humans at both token and entity levels. Testing
within the scope of retaining or excluding non-nominal and/or non-CC entities
particularly impacts the models' performances.
|
[
-0.7034521103,
-0.655408144,
0.2692344487,
0.0321634226,
-0.2338208854,
0.0878996775,
-0.4399217367,
-0.9445847273,
-0.0036915534,
0.4437921345,
-0.614697516,
-0.5531138182,
-0.4557775855,
0.4191920757,
-0.5387936234,
0.9491567612,
0.2358623445,
-0.2001727223,
-0.3793898821,
-0.0361945033,
-0.1448410004,
0.0114029609,
-0.9563596845,
-0.2736480236,
0.6968031526,
0.5295730233,
0.9178641438,
0.4067968726,
0.4172534347,
0.2966608405,
-0.1978837997,
0.1661503613,
-0.6225342751,
0.3031465709,
-0.4559174478,
-0.0348942615,
-0.1120076552,
-0.1496870369,
0.5627884269,
0.4366560876,
0.1266192049,
0.6177483201,
0.0473819524,
0.4290319085,
-0.7524251342,
0.2735160291,
-1.2053261995,
-0.3553894758,
-0.3486048877,
0.0508911274,
-0.3994126916,
0.0429120176,
0.2067347616,
-0.8885508776,
0.7658201456,
0.7182296515,
0.6633388996,
0.573092103,
-0.4193536937,
-0.3061551452,
-0.6425332427,
0.4232710302,
-0.4092671871,
0.6476198435,
0.2274215966,
-0.1238555834,
-0.0980530158,
-0.5039397478,
-1.0230457783,
-0.3779509962,
-0.1721598059,
-0.180951193,
-0.0768398494,
-0.2128963023,
0.3002887964,
0.2453785986,
-0.42409271,
0.0523913465,
-0.5500029922,
-0.2552953959,
0.7966532707,
0.0541163385,
0.4008936584,
-0.5696922541,
-0.392087996,
-0.1678222567,
-0.8668036461,
-0.3278849423,
0.5612303615,
0.4447074234,
-0.1139347255,
0.4741839767,
0.0256104711,
0.413092941,
-0.02383033,
0.2806539237,
-0.1569186151,
-0.4569594264,
-0.2326543331,
0.3191231787,
0.634285152,
0.3519499004,
0.0279152077,
-0.2296621352,
0.1394669563,
-0.2296157777,
-0.0751752108,
-0.6988299489,
-0.6918829083,
-0.2120868266,
-0.1349136531,
-0.118612051,
0.080314979,
-1.1628642082,
-0.6678434014,
-0.3811264336,
-0.0860132203,
0.1105735153,
-0.4724724293,
-0.2733714581,
0.1050096005,
-0.0475974828,
0.2888977528,
-0.6582698822,
0.3474886715,
0.5776221752,
0.6390148401,
-0.3642810881,
-0.152471453,
-0.2770747542,
0.0850550085,
-0.1865088493,
0.8928166032,
-0.8498920798,
-0.6334559321,
-0.3084966838,
0.1879380792,
0.0323927067,
-0.2131575346,
0.3769897819,
-0.7683609128,
0.0142170871,
-0.5862995982,
-0.5969920754,
0.1500722617,
-0.1746038496,
-1.1683369875,
1.2374640703,
-0.2384946793,
-1.0570052862,
0.8141089082,
-0.8113533854,
-0.1445899308,
0.1342356801,
0.3215649128,
-0.5330877304,
-0.3952649832,
0.1065277979,
0.0547243804,
-0.7273583412,
0.4532130063,
-0.5778838992,
-0.1315852702,
-0.0371867903,
-0.3242725134,
0.7292337418,
0.338024348,
-0.3558343649,
0.1823206693,
-0.6259281635,
-0.3341917992,
-0.080590114,
0.0400943123,
-0.6230110526,
0.2036954314,
0.5689537525,
-0.0164283775,
0.1993324459,
-0.4562236369,
0.2695741057,
-0.0462966412,
0.4506605864,
0.6829153895,
0.2530884445,
0.3321548104,
0.0313046314,
0.1961957365,
0.0762328207,
0.091595009,
0.1055428833,
-0.7627983689,
-0.8498156071,
0.2108087391,
0.2995180488,
0.4665238261,
-0.9343252778,
0.0303134248,
-0.2283337414,
-0.8994238377,
-0.430290699,
0.2893676758,
0.0257544294,
0.5812200308,
0.6297079921,
0.2286738902,
-0.4711677432,
-0.7311509848,
-0.4089019299,
-0.6411142945,
0.1013023555,
0.2891842425,
0.9593448639,
-0.137684986,
1.0026950836,
-0.518635869,
0.2593404949,
0.1311974972,
0.1162986532,
-0.2045139074,
0.3170238733,
0.5447850227,
-1.2226263285,
-0.3635034859,
-0.1316885054,
-0.234443903,
-0.2175101489,
-0.1198355108,
-0.2088627517,
0.1403645724,
0.3778848648,
-0.4027267098,
0.5839335918,
0.4273697436,
-0.6823462844,
0.3548707068,
-0.0840522647,
0.6087552309,
-0.7808506489,
0.272705555,
0.3941965103,
-0.1476098746,
-0.5411575437,
-0.0897191018,
-0.1760383695,
-0.1041711047,
-0.5376929641,
0.8070626855,
-0.5108927488,
-0.1583318263,
0.0172287356,
0.2828435898,
0.0707801357,
0.0975623056,
0.011795124,
0.7938037515,
0.4741639495,
-0.6937134862,
0.3470764458,
0.133774966,
-0.1961184591,
0.4321433902,
-0.3460731208,
0.4358180761,
-0.2443128973,
0.2856281996,
-0.729665041,
-0.1118905172,
0.3186921775,
-0.1317090094,
-0.0191219337,
-0.0681208,
-0.6582922339,
-0.355553627,
-0.0015681288,
0.4661921859,
-0.0042819167,
-0.4605683684,
0.3646611571,
0.4161906242,
0.1789581776,
-0.1177044287,
-0.3166226149,
0.303597033,
-0.5219963193,
-0.3450798094,
0.4192707837,
-0.3913560808,
-0.454521656,
0.498440057,
-0.1781688929,
-0.3495269418,
0.5253872275,
0.3498959839,
0.3953815997,
-0.0993037075,
0.4437554777,
-0.1311316788,
0.1657404155,
0.2089139372,
-0.2910132706,
0.1637660116,
-0.0372314937,
-0.0765618384,
-0.3559982479,
0.1144248173,
0.5858982801,
-0.1103922576,
1.1994119883,
0.6086885333,
-0.7600107789,
0.1401235908,
-0.5711134076,
0.0702290684,
-0.3665385544,
0.0628409088,
-0.1495397091,
-0.8277299404,
0.4457355738,
-0.0418283045,
0.0183425285,
1.0435422659,
0.3414927125,
0.3032372594,
0.4392306209,
0.8560394645,
-0.3613137305,
0.3526686728,
-0.0247768108,
0.3950932324,
-0.6679034829,
-0.5981752276,
-0.868745625,
0.0539152287,
-0.8997458816,
-0.4062318206,
0.1516521126,
0.1519315094,
-0.3595911264,
0.6568257213,
-0.5480342507,
0.4726722836,
0.1572135091,
0.1481791288,
0.6112000942,
-0.2830598652,
0.3634482622,
-0.0144030694,
-0.4183137119,
-0.4914317131,
0.666780293,
-0.0718313381,
0.564219892,
0.1206724048,
0.1574068218,
0.8793333173,
0.7304166555,
-0.2650125623,
0.4189759493,
0.0783615634,
-0.7494066358,
-0.6428908706,
-0.3211968541,
-0.7452532649,
0.0649340674,
-0.5218954682,
-0.4900154769,
0.3713714778,
0.2520181239,
0.1141058356,
0.6857370734,
-0.4507848918,
0.7016249299,
0.0019017733,
-0.4882401526,
-0.3581472933,
-0.2324457914,
0.2802458405,
-0.2860157788,
0.4154562354,
-0.4523768723,
-0.1917275488,
0.5697469115,
-0.3080377579,
0.6637920737,
-0.2069823742,
0.1060088351,
0.4224641919,
-0.1306214929,
0.2005729675,
0.5114465356,
-0.4542274773,
0.3417595625,
0.0716556087,
-0.4354936182,
-0.2045249194,
1.0458453894,
-0.6566880345,
-0.539943397,
-0.3371798992,
-0.038890373,
0.0216845982,
0.0869173259,
0.3008834124,
-0.0232201628,
-0.4277525544,
-0.0276523456,
0.6871007681,
-0.1369795501,
0.2501000464,
0.4699950814,
-0.0587522723,
-0.2116404921,
0.6029676795,
0.0795974955,
0.0417944416,
0.0940968022,
0.0460897833,
-0.1065752506,
-0.2986425459,
-0.56791538,
0.0081400815,
-0.6645952463,
-0.2984196842,
-0.5471637249,
-0.0229780134,
-0.4797286987,
0.004667534,
-0.1115085334,
0.106453687,
-0.5563133359,
-0.0537308417,
0.6321947575,
0.9315726757,
0.1695961654,
-0.1781388074,
-0.2662037611,
0.2074248791,
0.0261811037,
0.1500076056,
-0.0175305735,
0.0501557142,
-0.228139028,
0.0784548,
0.022310596,
-1.2172470093,
0.2198766321,
0.6379974484,
0.3150321245,
0.147798866,
0.3282053173,
0.893933773,
-0.507481277,
1.0229626894,
-0.0368324369,
-1.3646038771,
0.7795905471,
0.0874181613,
0.1114010364,
0.553445816,
0.4644120932,
-0.5888119936,
-0.3119623959,
-0.5825917721,
-1.005081296,
0.1805932671,
0.3506238461,
-0.0576969422,
-0.2318639904,
0.7220596075,
0.0236631762,
0.1555638313,
-0.412966609,
-0.5242255926,
-0.1953291595,
0.2188569903,
-0.1015832424,
0.028984433,
0.2377961129,
-0.3699269295,
0.8909417391,
-0.12634027,
-0.0407460183,
0.5097228885,
-0.2734081745,
-0.3452503681,
0.1905992627,
0.3899447322,
0.5286703706,
0.2870272994,
-0.0927390531,
0.6521903872,
-0.2670828402,
-0.1280045509,
-0.0717879161,
-0.267375946,
0.2097560018,
0.3469726741,
0.9556801319,
0.7050375342,
-0.4152549803,
0.1276237667,
-0.1290765554,
0.313593477,
-0.4334036708,
0.1305069029,
-0.0015658865,
0.0739476904,
0.3902371228,
0.0935774967,
0.4329554737,
-0.5171450973,
0.2102232873,
0.0561074875,
-0.3346985579,
-0.4285578132,
1.201302886,
0.2397478223,
0.0416294374,
0.8356670141,
-0.007771411,
-0.4642132521,
0.6950154901,
0.2881655991,
0.5845225453,
-0.254711777,
0.2384635657,
0.7607330084,
0.4570057988,
0.1408388019,
-0.2182253748,
-0.4349357486,
-0.5621672273,
-0.2765620947,
-0.5833147764,
-0.6779543757,
-0.06319464,
-0.7526577711,
0.5874982476,
-0.2083384097,
-0.1407732815,
0.1254479587,
0.1769337356,
-1.1032028198,
0.2414282113,
0.3457386792,
1.1613030434,
-1.0874314308,
0.8638601899,
0.6520844698,
-0.2363364697,
-0.563090086,
0.0686072707,
0.1876947284,
-0.247974351,
0.6939110756,
-0.0292579997,
-0.4060901403,
0.0542919822,
-0.8892583847,
-0.8955853581,
1.2425686121,
0.2960057855,
-0.5990578532,
-0.0704555437,
-0.133867532,
0.6405204535,
-0.4125885069,
0.2289116234,
0.6561945081,
0.9586375952,
0.0478584357,
-0.772464931,
0.0519961976,
-0.3880265355,
0.0046141357,
0.3098373711,
-0.7379428744,
0.3555860519,
-0.182345435,
-0.5223422647,
0.0049323137,
1.031935811,
-0.0205661543,
0.7021369338,
1.0583311319,
0.3228391111,
1.1214731932,
-0.2639315426,
0.8563037515,
-0.5776836872,
0.798971355,
1.0480591059,
-0.5415076017,
0.8821514845,
0.1519839019,
0.068464458,
0.5817247033,
1.0045639277,
-0.2964270413,
0.4171003103,
0.2492655367,
-0.3916553557,
-0.3850237727,
-0.3805611134,
-0.1055801436,
0.1139203459,
0.5339294672,
0.0489844717,
-0.1039880216,
0.0501845255,
0.2131787986,
-0.0316411257,
-0.3710039556,
0.6090046763,
-0.128258571,
-0.6008866429,
-0.072112307,
-0.1302702725,
0.3565635979,
-0.0382717475,
-0.1129816025,
0.0448715277,
-0.5987325311,
-0.5203272104,
-0.5799564123,
0.5635815859,
0.3717254698,
-0.254273057,
-0.0194961131,
0.5747684836,
-0.6847258806,
-0.4123049974,
0.4713326991,
0.0280405376,
0.166236192,
0.0135038178,
-0.8621321917,
0.1436219215,
0.0333555378,
-0.3301874101,
-0.0575417802,
0.1683618426,
-0.2470991015,
0.6910705566,
0.9200442433,
0.0037550069,
0.0338699147,
-0.1676791608,
0.9907433987,
-0.6039318442,
-0.1626108736,
-0.7473064065,
0.4385834038,
-0.32791996,
-0.5154632926,
0.51918751,
0.5734117031,
0.8549532294,
0.2737175822,
0.4732603431,
-0.2483494133,
-0.0720196366,
-0.6455835104,
0.6908909082,
-0.4024348259,
0.4621963799,
-0.1807355136,
-1.2128967047,
-0.0798421279,
0.0672863126,
-0.3306283355,
-0.0827832744,
0.6898033023,
0.599660635,
0.268097192,
0.138055414,
0.2705902457,
0.3364311755,
0.2667761445,
0.1363264322,
0.3695232272,
-0.2845832705,
0.3790792823,
-0.3255648613,
0.2977021635,
0.0599675514,
-1.0971997976,
-0.7905649543,
-0.9230434895,
-0.7949922085,
-0.2770359516,
0.1499813944,
0.8465045094,
0.6578957438,
-1.0064944029,
0.289621681,
0.0808510855,
0.4063791931,
0.2849585414,
-0.2628926933,
0.3991421461,
0.1954308003,
-0.8697209358,
0.3802182376,
0.237370953,
-0.428827107,
-0.6785590053,
0.082031779,
-0.1330396682,
0.0448732339,
0.1177942529,
0.227366358,
-0.9889894724,
-0.5443536639,
-0.1606410742,
0.0631146207,
-0.2171597034,
0.8903082013,
-0.8221535683,
0.3747093081,
0.4417719245,
0.538367033,
0.4592515528,
-0.1109743416,
-0.0263589118,
-0.1562402546,
-0.1264862865,
-0.1887062639,
0.4398005009,
0.6460953355,
-0.8901489973,
0.4854136705,
0.4182400405,
-0.7851619124,
-0.5637351871,
0.0195194408,
-0.6703784466,
-0.0720489174,
0.7499960661,
-0.2136287838,
-0.2890534699,
-0.2146707177,
0.1005875468,
0.2554457188,
-0.5845149755,
0.7185931802,
0.9687330127,
-0.004402881,
-0.2208974808,
-0.6108647585,
0.5355188251,
-0.1173425242,
-0.8708461523,
-0.0609315112,
0.517883718,
0.5243386626,
0.1595927328,
0.3043723106,
0.2979816198,
-0.0305880178,
-0.2334120572,
0.1437978446,
0.2400626391,
-0.3737485707,
-0.064302735,
-0.0162297543,
0.0039352104,
0.470587939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16722v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16722v1
|
Venturing into Uncharted Waters: The Navigation Compass from Transformer to Mamba
| 2024-06-24T15:27:21 | 2024-06-24T15:27:21 |
Yuchen Zou, Yineng Chen, Zuchao Li, Lefei Zhang, Hai Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transformer, a deep neural network architecture, has long dominated the field
of natural language processing and beyond. Nevertheless, the recent
introduction of Mamba challenges its supremacy, sparks considerable interest
among researchers, and gives rise to a series of Mamba-based models that have
exhibited notable potential. This survey paper orchestrates a comprehensive
discussion, diving into essential research dimensions, covering: (i) the
functioning of the Mamba mechanism and its foundation on the principles of
structured state space models; (ii) the proposed improvements and the
integration of Mamba with various networks, exploring its potential as a
substitute for Transformers; (iii) the combination of Transformers and Mamba to
compensate for each other's shortcomings. We have also made efforts to
interpret Mamba and Transformer in the framework of kernel functions, allowing
for a comparison of their mathematical nature within a unified context. Our
paper encompasses the vast majority of improvements related to Mamba to date.
|
[
-0.5948001146,
-0.3839035332,
0.785885334,
0.083443135,
-0.1467959285,
0.2723415792,
-0.2363412976,
-0.2014528364,
0.1507838666,
0.4486786425,
-0.4505818486,
-0.1799920201,
-0.7292429805,
0.03097439,
-0.4512423575,
0.7052648664,
0.276932627,
-0.0230671186,
0.0637449995,
-0.1974299848,
-0.7249546051,
-0.5136823654,
-0.4265694022,
-0.7786189318,
0.5240972638,
0.1773768812,
0.9642761946,
0.2329401672,
0.3682903051,
0.3323979676,
-0.3271842897,
0.1307525784,
-0.3794846237,
0.2825421095,
-0.2223643959,
-0.3773943484,
-0.2091199458,
-0.1639613807,
0.6995615959,
1.1994006634,
-0.0676121861,
-0.1156637743,
0.2831054628,
0.8902463913,
-0.5556717515,
0.3081024885,
-0.4801178575,
0.0285723228,
-0.0072075408,
0.0762275234,
-0.3206996024,
-0.274666369,
0.428209722,
-0.6313275695,
-0.0246979147,
-0.0433207713,
0.7553446889,
0.3479506969,
-0.9065444469,
-0.3541828394,
-1.0493649244,
0.7459056973,
-0.547604084,
0.4437728226,
-0.091514498,
0.5628539324,
-0.4554039538,
-0.8677448034,
-0.4650246203,
-0.1741618812,
-0.076844126,
0.1804795712,
-0.4436384141,
0.0177357253,
-0.226910755,
0.5512789488,
-0.1639831811,
0.1675177813,
-0.6097878218,
-0.2133068442,
0.514341414,
0.3109969795,
0.1339152604,
-0.3950284719,
-0.1665949672,
-0.1328558624,
-0.7302271128,
0.3273979425,
0.3110427558,
0.5152189136,
0.0820484012,
0.5388108492,
-0.1482349634,
0.8524612188,
-0.1269343346,
0.2769593596,
0.0505693257,
-0.1674167663,
-0.3847092688,
0.1659967303,
0.9193741679,
0.2534882128,
0.1565954387,
-0.2228133231,
-0.0731084198,
-0.0909979641,
0.8302541971,
-0.3662385941,
-0.3828000128,
-0.067562595,
-0.3914114833,
-0.3733798563,
0.0838045254,
-0.7293952107,
-0.6687324643,
-0.4049429893,
0.2161688209,
-0.369684875,
-0.4695835412,
0.2386967838,
0.1972043663,
0.2972568572,
0.1656639278,
-0.8237335086,
0.3479483426,
0.9827364087,
0.9407325387,
-0.037743073,
0.0630061701,
0.1411434561,
-0.2334840745,
-0.3871027529,
0.835046351,
-0.8136944771,
-0.9419765472,
0.0982423052,
-0.1174055561,
-0.1057805121,
-0.1992634982,
0.7199190259,
-0.4828562438,
0.1997456551,
-0.386095047,
-0.2677298784,
-0.8392120004,
0.3420819342,
-0.9361183047,
0.8859972358,
0.0211029351,
-0.2721109986,
0.0615511537,
-1.0909405947,
-0.7527217865,
-0.3087159395,
0.1045810357,
-0.2436586171,
0.1854904592,
0.3183139563,
0.3669477403,
-0.6355977654,
0.4920430779,
0.114936091,
-0.472691983,
0.3537466824,
-0.3368341923,
0.8973939419,
0.3228845596,
-0.052890636,
-0.0886992291,
-0.9669783711,
-0.1383426487,
0.0067639672,
-0.4832438827,
-0.2977696061,
0.1732728183,
-0.315346539,
-0.0197662991,
-0.0376546122,
-0.471755296,
0.4403428435,
-0.7312452793,
0.8073759675,
0.4781323373,
0.1636650115,
1.2653357983,
0.2494651824,
0.4952459633,
0.2597971261,
0.2144931108,
-0.5471420288,
-0.7179324031,
-0.9687140584,
0.268561393,
0.3450692892,
0.4035547376,
-0.7389340997,
0.4272570908,
-0.3516269028,
-0.736092627,
-0.6040433049,
-0.3567495346,
0.0463072658,
0.6991285086,
0.699187696,
0.0115532456,
-0.5427546501,
-0.8876625896,
-0.3387610614,
-0.0863547102,
-0.0984710455,
0.2447549701,
0.0941313133,
-0.2317533344,
1.0593833923,
-0.4591339231,
-0.3471916318,
-0.3428197205,
0.0317593999,
0.4613600373,
0.4852378964,
0.3955467641,
-0.9081480503,
-0.0614355728,
0.0474070944,
-0.6388179064,
0.1243548691,
-0.2951867282,
0.0195974223,
-0.3227717876,
0.4579865634,
-0.5791526437,
0.3766766191,
0.4827535748,
-0.0190645382,
-0.0771081522,
-0.0491381139,
-0.0363156572,
-1.0991446972,
0.0652457774,
-0.0730736032,
0.3806010783,
-1.0154548883,
-0.06691733,
-0.0008464658,
-0.1000473723,
-0.2251758873,
0.1779044122,
-0.5844660997,
-0.0286656618,
-0.2980349362,
0.2685078979,
0.0599958077,
0.4849435985,
-0.4618878067,
0.5332624316,
0.8311563134,
-1.030579567,
0.379245311,
0.3017221987,
-0.2317563891,
0.2944912314,
-0.650343895,
0.1126859039,
-0.2223483771,
0.2208165228,
-1.1742811203,
0.3260428607,
0.4861991107,
-0.5881115198,
0.2708981931,
-0.2470462173,
-0.1450367272,
-0.4039905369,
0.0600746386,
0.3913588226,
0.5754021406,
-0.4498510063,
1.1411734819,
0.4751290381,
0.2110542357,
-0.6750870347,
-0.7246028781,
0.504453361,
-0.0224676672,
-0.4465076625,
0.2436587363,
0.5269065499,
-0.2533700168,
-0.1334620863,
-0.0970674455,
-0.0670437515,
0.2787230909,
0.592859149,
0.2499571443,
-0.5142194629,
0.3080635965,
0.1463135928,
-0.4754880369,
0.3078332543,
-0.6652393341,
0.4725065231,
-0.4669999778,
-0.2039601505,
0.0496997908,
0.1027799621,
0.3851866722,
-0.5255925059,
0.6922287941,
0.2485571504,
-0.0978479534,
-0.0371939465,
-0.1520124227,
-0.0393269993,
-0.5463722348,
0.1094795316,
-0.3726952374,
-0.9190375209,
0.483056426,
-0.5071650743,
0.1572801918,
0.6290309429,
0.2325808257,
-0.0705845654,
0.7546467185,
0.9377600551,
0.0076611196,
0.0824966058,
-0.338417083,
0.9788736105,
-1.1167519093,
-0.6360396147,
-0.7047179937,
-0.7419192195,
-0.7442666292,
-0.1150703579,
0.402502954,
-0.1609744579,
-0.2352991849,
0.5757944584,
-0.5959618092,
0.2910303473,
0.3856213689,
-0.3250474632,
0.2585964203,
-0.3458938897,
-0.4869152606,
-0.0847822279,
-1.018455267,
-0.5627728701,
0.9244965911,
0.2802295685,
0.7483195066,
0.0488789938,
0.2641145885,
-0.0649434477,
0.3281430006,
-0.9788838029,
0.6492696404,
0.069302775,
-0.5705449581,
-0.4220364988,
-0.147020027,
-1.194853425,
0.455789566,
-0.3553088009,
-0.65159899,
0.4171798527,
-0.025931878,
-0.5678806901,
0.6378452778,
-0.4637010992,
0.5498785973,
-0.157665506,
0.0920847878,
0.0988295451,
-0.8993752003,
0.4438643157,
0.0134045128,
0.1806120425,
0.0293020997,
0.0096637802,
0.4295224249,
-0.2065672874,
0.6850904226,
-0.2022992671,
-0.2768552899,
0.4054780006,
0.362410903,
-0.0463409163,
-0.0035645186,
-0.0783101767,
0.4618188143,
-0.3823367655,
-0.0276403558,
-0.8286928535,
0.6470181942,
-0.5777151585,
-0.4771272242,
-0.3553870618,
-0.3962810338,
-0.2887550592,
0.4035320282,
0.2909342349,
0.451687932,
-0.2182208747,
0.3721574545,
0.57213521,
-0.2892579138,
0.7184869051,
0.191835314,
-0.3966098428,
-0.1367197931,
0.6040532589,
0.0687190369,
-0.0664901808,
0.5415474772,
0.0437483341,
-0.4351725578,
-0.3819120526,
-0.5020327568,
-0.0644335374,
-0.8495271802,
-0.3100475371,
-0.602833271,
-0.3515219688,
-0.0282593966,
-0.2143245488,
-0.7652935386,
-0.4582337141,
-0.5159672499,
-0.191620633,
0.1103972271,
1.1715618372,
0.0253705289,
0.5469548702,
-0.8019905686,
0.0304612834,
0.0435469598,
0.2534350157,
0.4623651206,
-0.3827044368,
-0.2053366452,
0.21677953,
-0.3026087284,
-0.7847803831,
0.124655515,
-0.1027784273,
0.5564629436,
0.3718721569,
-0.0124441246,
0.5755799413,
-0.7343457937,
1.002471447,
0.3715826273,
-0.9886537194,
0.4151235223,
-0.06917236,
0.2839685678,
0.4380464554,
0.4042250216,
-0.6086958647,
-0.154589057,
-0.390599221,
-0.7905263305,
0.172576502,
0.4073891044,
0.3576000631,
0.4002449811,
0.4643832743,
-0.1101614833,
0.1391554326,
-0.6004116535,
-0.387101233,
-0.6322350502,
0.100488618,
-0.2304366827,
0.06477198,
0.1217448413,
-0.2934441566,
0.3798469007,
-0.1228651181,
0.2549932003,
0.1694057435,
-0.1348121464,
0.0984704494,
0.3146935701,
0.5424450636,
0.5635430217,
0.4554752111,
0.236989066,
0.255571425,
-0.4447598159,
0.3801401556,
-0.1293223202,
-0.2978976667,
0.1061503738,
0.1537364721,
0.7755975127,
0.7796860337,
-0.131902054,
0.2875146866,
-0.022821486,
-0.2413588166,
-0.1563879997,
0.3008385599,
0.2001366913,
0.3802370727,
0.5680631995,
0.5578232408,
0.3048776388,
-0.3820155263,
-0.1315755993,
0.3910502791,
-0.753338635,
-0.3089736104,
0.739018321,
0.2887249589,
-0.613453567,
0.7084502578,
0.097923167,
-0.7100229859,
0.4662955999,
0.1446746886,
0.756688118,
-0.33626616,
0.2347852886,
0.3489013314,
0.7781110406,
0.0835681185,
-0.1117622256,
-0.2457593381,
-0.8229609132,
-0.3862657249,
-0.5748183727,
-0.2847958505,
-0.1033268273,
-0.810080111,
-0.041666247,
-0.4908820391,
-0.4266459644,
-0.0151368184,
-0.1849043667,
-0.3802113831,
0.2336498797,
0.18497549,
0.9046192765,
-0.5091910362,
0.7022508979,
0.7097461224,
-0.3544405699,
-0.779881537,
0.064863503,
-0.0266390517,
-0.5456742048,
0.4801204205,
0.1607445776,
-0.5864548683,
-0.0673425794,
-0.4044620097,
-0.9655081034,
1.1750378609,
-0.129046604,
-0.53727597,
-0.0602319725,
0.2807911336,
0.6919057965,
-0.2670195401,
-0.1274753809,
0.8698731661,
0.6641842127,
0.081182681,
-0.6658701897,
-0.0691613629,
-0.1809982061,
0.3509283364,
0.4181712866,
-0.5727957487,
0.8358775377,
-0.3349248767,
-0.3829837739,
0.1460022032,
0.9358523488,
-0.3146873116,
0.0406400859,
0.4183030427,
0.2348837256,
0.7176960707,
-0.4469862878,
0.8431289792,
-0.2076461315,
0.3409031034,
0.7386863232,
-0.3784606159,
0.5323697329,
0.4333825409,
-0.1997512877,
0.6726918221,
0.385076493,
-0.2443230301,
0.4500264525,
0.1514948606,
-0.1680033207,
-0.1020203158,
0.2553845644,
-0.315860182,
0.6196922064,
0.4177135825,
-0.2115596384,
-0.4326209426,
0.2168346643,
0.0842270032,
0.1753435582,
-0.4535483122,
0.6632170081,
0.4206273556,
-0.7574232817,
0.3371040225,
0.1623018831,
0.3924921453,
-0.4980537295,
-0.0154893063,
-0.221867606,
0.1737558395,
-0.1046276465,
-1.0117173195,
0.393686831,
-0.2817030549,
0.1540570259,
-0.1022228599,
0.9104338288,
-0.0522856377,
-0.4046621323,
0.3938907385,
0.3951062262,
-0.1414350122,
-0.0715117604,
-0.5595468879,
0.0612258166,
-0.0752124116,
-0.3266490698,
-0.0701030418,
0.4347064495,
0.479524523,
0.821886301,
0.7770628333,
-0.2687807679,
0.2310173362,
0.0881664455,
1.0663200617,
-0.7933757901,
-0.6678125858,
-0.8769521713,
0.6332041025,
0.0162157174,
-0.3460016549,
0.6934790611,
0.4264825284,
0.5348629951,
0.1163776219,
0.6351191401,
0.2196969241,
0.2802554071,
-0.5981805325,
1.0085254908,
-0.4349658489,
0.3021458387,
-0.0920399055,
-1.0419845581,
-0.5525260568,
0.729788661,
-0.2679769397,
0.1024896055,
0.7003445625,
0.6290687919,
-0.2355378121,
0.4493026733,
0.2373646349,
0.1648231447,
0.4571750164,
0.6050108671,
0.9972268343,
-0.757301569,
0.6847638488,
-0.1022679061,
0.1692505926,
-0.2029504329,
-0.9068972468,
-0.7472497225,
-0.8898643851,
0.1306480914,
-0.2765210271,
-0.3272639513,
0.3625945449,
0.5844756961,
-0.6499739885,
-0.2374944389,
-0.1274003536,
0.2003654987,
0.0031259833,
-0.1221592128,
-0.1130162627,
-0.1788036823,
-0.4443377256,
0.7418843508,
0.6814679503,
0.0083720423,
-0.6367944479,
-0.1500710249,
-0.1058460772,
0.1254253834,
0.7319395542,
0.3721412122,
-0.5957515836,
-0.1007989049,
0.2755282223,
0.0310728494,
0.3945859373,
1.1778827906,
-0.9892639518,
0.2597077191,
0.1794959307,
0.9713281989,
0.3809080124,
-0.2816724777,
0.7488968372,
-0.3856457472,
0.0356164649,
0.324369669,
0.4533908665,
0.5038904548,
-0.1971757263,
0.5113912821,
-0.0534882396,
-0.3855687678,
-0.7068240643,
0.3460003734,
-0.9749972224,
-0.3235455155,
0.8515007496,
0.1969739944,
-0.2547853291,
-0.1434800029,
-0.2077003568,
0.2921343446,
-0.1562503874,
0.5127007365,
0.6865081191,
-0.005718844,
-0.138820529,
-0.3261838555,
0.2621210515,
0.2796574831,
-0.3940950632,
-0.2367338687,
0.2588582337,
-0.0425859876,
0.5812584758,
0.08120507,
-0.1226209253,
-0.0975091755,
-0.1224543378,
-0.2504262328,
-0.1621781439,
-0.6618044376,
-0.6782875657,
0.2317881286,
-0.3407946229,
-0.0509617105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16714v1
|
AutoDetect: Towards a Unified Framework for Automated Weakness Detection in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-24T15:16:45 | 2024-06-24T15:16:45 |
Jiale Cheng, Yida Lu, Xiaotao Gu, Pei Ke, Xiao Liu, Yuxiao Dong, Hongning Wang, Jie Tang, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming increasingly powerful,
they still exhibit significant but subtle weaknesses, such as mistakes in
instruction-following or coding tasks. As these unexpected errors could lead to
severe consequences in practical deployments, it is crucial to investigate the
limitations within LLMs systematically. Traditional benchmarking approaches
cannot thoroughly pinpoint specific model deficiencies, while manual
inspections are costly and not scalable. In this paper, we introduce a unified
framework, AutoDetect, to automatically expose weaknesses in LLMs across
various tasks. Inspired by the educational assessment process that measures
students' learning outcomes, AutoDetect consists of three LLM-powered agents:
Examiner, Questioner, and Assessor. The collaboration among these three agents
is designed to realize comprehensive and in-depth weakness identification. Our
framework demonstrates significant success in uncovering flaws, with an
identification success rate exceeding 30% in prominent models such as ChatGPT
and Claude. More importantly, these identified weaknesses can guide specific
model improvements, proving more effective than untargeted data augmentation
methods like Self-Instruct. Our approach has led to substantial enhancements in
popular LLMs, including the Llama series and Mistral-7b, boosting their
performance by over 10% across several benchmarks. Code and data are publicly
available at https://github.com/thu-coai/AutoDetect.
|
[
-0.3441599309,
-0.5959596634,
0.6599911451,
0.1737314016,
0.2456365526,
0.2302655578,
-0.0629815832,
-0.3518725336,
-0.0593323708,
0.3685584664,
-0.4593287706,
-0.4219394624,
-0.7144600153,
0.0785650164,
-0.661755383,
0.6746355891,
-0.3378716409,
-0.1794797629,
-0.2248180956,
-0.0127085866,
-0.5913712978,
-0.4169607759,
-0.388695091,
-0.1872876734,
0.0704553723,
0.6093294024,
0.5274150968,
0.6031501889,
0.63557899,
0.4591831267,
0.4914177954,
0.0710170791,
-0.1562778205,
0.3357943594,
-0.2908869386,
-0.2104373425,
-0.6999546289,
-0.3388941884,
0.5589300394,
0.5137792826,
0.0822169781,
0.1288191527,
0.405970484,
0.471159786,
-0.8026677966,
0.3517262936,
-0.7128213644,
-0.0009234674,
-0.3099811971,
0.170827657,
-0.1105109006,
-0.0045192088,
-0.164026767,
-0.1332608014,
0.2631952763,
-0.2260432541,
0.7735854387,
0.8139519095,
-0.4634210467,
-0.0959345549,
-0.463891387,
0.695345819,
-0.7378389239,
0.2515591085,
0.2082366943,
0.4083387256,
-0.3087821305,
-0.4766246378,
-0.4795585871,
-0.3276017308,
0.021872608,
0.0517461747,
-0.3737076223,
-0.0206813142,
0.0483150817,
0.4277431667,
-0.8323948979,
0.4065974355,
0.2502031326,
-0.4276835918,
0.6787697673,
0.3719626665,
0.5044488907,
0.0231352374,
-0.2229076475,
-0.2682778537,
-0.6738137007,
-0.2340336889,
0.4161483943,
0.1244668588,
0.1176529676,
0.3968965411,
-0.1477145702,
0.5010794997,
-0.0842682049,
0.089759998,
0.1287322491,
-0.1973652095,
-0.1892634779,
-0.1972362846,
0.8439387679,
-0.0367562473,
0.1297875345,
0.0743303522,
-0.7098072767,
0.1869887859,
0.0738412961,
-0.6900085807,
-0.4210650027,
0.150027439,
-0.1207945123,
-0.5367844105,
0.1117373556,
-0.7056154013,
-0.5859385133,
-0.2033516914,
0.5320520997,
-0.2883276343,
-0.3668524027,
0.1244628578,
0.2315705866,
0.0792203546,
0.069770664,
-0.9235799313,
0.3533364534,
0.5913959146,
0.5311912894,
-0.3113185167,
-0.6242214441,
-0.397367835,
0.0767698735,
-0.2820154727,
1.0584754944,
-0.1459541619,
-0.1828404069,
-0.2934838235,
0.0890368,
-0.2845013142,
-0.592356205,
0.3328999281,
-0.0375301614,
-0.2927122116,
0.1076305509,
-0.4952118099,
0.2150476575,
0.3772420883,
-0.7004385591,
1.1015570164,
0.3654920459,
-0.7350661159,
-0.0000565479,
-0.5335428715,
-0.3109802604,
-0.0196978226,
-0.2588791251,
-0.6968666315,
-0.0613181442,
0.4204022884,
0.5117986798,
-0.4932123125,
0.3061648011,
-0.5051589608,
-0.2092983723,
0.1845224053,
-0.7435088158,
0.7665263414,
-0.0829335228,
-0.7394658923,
0.1573192328,
-0.9771122932,
0.0630650297,
0.3581612408,
-0.1467643082,
-0.2699180245,
0.0565691218,
0.0075518331,
0.0072610509,
0.2871870995,
-0.3516321778,
0.1558223516,
-0.4331833124,
0.127441749,
0.9500210285,
-0.0664898083,
0.2086801976,
-0.1945454925,
0.6761886477,
0.0252289884,
0.4104007781,
-0.1369518638,
-0.0480993129,
-0.9242172241,
-0.2322833538,
0.1105494276,
0.6558759212,
-0.60568434,
0.6938033104,
-0.0418067947,
-0.5075785518,
-0.4522988498,
0.5526337028,
0.5831323862,
0.4202868044,
0.2034277618,
-0.4606717825,
-0.4611486495,
-0.926440537,
-0.2523220778,
-0.4565401375,
-0.1623256803,
0.0061817323,
0.599511981,
-0.674700439,
0.7218109369,
-0.3450655341,
-0.4885497093,
-0.3358986676,
-0.0198545698,
-0.1505342424,
0.4486443698,
0.5428040624,
-0.4660992324,
-0.5813454986,
-0.0689152554,
-0.7617224455,
-0.6010439992,
0.0204979461,
0.2150976062,
0.4460886717,
0.474521488,
-0.1480952203,
0.4081801474,
0.6976088881,
-0.4405385852,
0.6911919117,
-0.1147296429,
-0.2204445153,
-0.9164498448,
-0.1691001654,
-0.1450453699,
-0.0040291324,
-0.2828997076,
0.0006994083,
0.15800412,
0.1702650785,
-0.0024839093,
0.5651840568,
-0.5450598001,
-0.1919062436,
-0.3046825826,
-0.0399044603,
0.0952632949,
0.1848324239,
-0.3433608115,
0.7622723579,
0.734140873,
-0.3499496281,
0.5628231764,
0.021495359,
-0.1071212739,
0.6964797378,
-0.6451917887,
0.09578228,
0.2169317901,
0.1148647591,
-0.9804315567,
-0.524730444,
0.2304618359,
-0.3547370136,
0.3269051313,
-0.2482860386,
-0.6157571077,
-0.3881305158,
-0.3078255057,
0.2441668212,
-0.0002596114,
-0.791644752,
0.6551008821,
0.4084468782,
-0.1648658812,
-0.7066079974,
-0.3834583759,
0.3449194729,
-0.2072236985,
-0.6519538164,
0.0307257064,
-0.2964963615,
-0.2983196676,
-0.1960108727,
-0.1511032432,
-0.2703287303,
0.5988735557,
0.476598382,
0.3555032015,
-0.2265251279,
0.2310928702,
-0.0935720354,
-0.3119897544,
0.1127812415,
-0.2579163313,
0.4205611944,
-0.6365837455,
-0.946485877,
-0.2455167174,
0.1195768788,
0.6870404482,
-0.3072758913,
0.106905736,
0.526124835,
-0.1798726618,
-0.6617247462,
-0.6092948318,
-0.2339452207,
-0.5203462243,
0.4983930588,
-0.4323480427,
-0.5665286183,
0.5128256083,
-0.0221661627,
-0.103715837,
0.3449397981,
0.4218246043,
0.2168718278,
1.1453310251,
0.7950004339,
-0.6716444492,
0.2083624452,
-0.1789536923,
0.1013147309,
-0.5311591029,
0.058514908,
-0.3880657852,
0.1338899285,
-0.315317899,
-0.1026259288,
0.3028332293,
-0.1297276318,
-0.207468316,
0.548038125,
-0.4487071931,
0.63050735,
0.2073347718,
-0.3183590472,
0.3598255515,
-0.2325021029,
-0.2017254829,
0.0063285623,
-0.6390098333,
-0.5919638872,
1.1935422421,
0.6277195811,
0.9256009459,
0.1331535131,
0.9842286706,
0.1561377645,
0.4751555622,
-0.7070158124,
0.4664489925,
0.1256323606,
-0.3813976645,
-0.4748666286,
-0.4188946784,
-0.8443356752,
0.1602178961,
0.1395752728,
-0.4673515558,
0.3111002147,
0.2330722362,
-0.1804093719,
0.3699115813,
-0.7659526467,
1.0586279631,
-0.5392309427,
-0.3358806968,
0.2211495042,
-0.36190781,
0.4004276395,
-0.5602343678,
0.1864003986,
-0.1451596618,
0.1118884534,
0.4497235715,
-0.5384278297,
1.082185626,
0.0263907351,
-0.5398891568,
0.1223677844,
0.3009460568,
0.6107510924,
0.0563564375,
0.1005977914,
-0.0813232809,
0.0950248688,
-0.3108552992,
-0.5028817654,
0.7024771571,
-0.4991351664,
-0.4708141088,
-0.4387948513,
-0.5532386899,
-0.2950429022,
0.2763606906,
0.0935482755,
0.3121169508,
-0.5482956767,
-0.2134513408,
0.5536862016,
-0.1629632562,
0.6805055141,
0.9284462929,
-0.0402384885,
-0.0687214509,
1.1339182854,
0.0300550237,
0.3417226374,
-0.1011334583,
-0.0059111631,
0.002102521,
-0.7259272933,
-0.387720108,
0.0055942149,
-0.8527154326,
-0.4831940532,
-0.3702133,
-0.2394678146,
-0.5834701061,
0.0115598403,
-0.785204947,
-0.2355537564,
-0.0594563298,
-0.1047769859,
0.0717126355,
0.8461565971,
-0.3281383812,
0.2955243289,
-0.5947516561,
0.1643262058,
0.5908228755,
0.3721036017,
0.0272241812,
-0.4682492018,
-0.0866375715,
-0.4382138252,
-0.4801754057,
-0.5645968914,
0.6794665456,
0.1532801837,
0.4787752628,
0.4864409864,
0.1951069981,
0.4174509943,
-0.3748692572,
0.3206789494,
-0.0706796572,
-0.9678490758,
0.5048242211,
-0.1912445426,
0.1163569018,
0.6277328134,
0.030662179,
-0.2344766408,
-0.8895822167,
-0.7226073146,
-1.0518269539,
0.3607886136,
0.075621374,
-0.0959759355,
-0.0486515947,
0.025961753,
-0.1098165959,
-0.190463081,
-0.810156405,
-0.0648614466,
-0.1791405231,
-0.3597124815,
0.0153680295,
-0.1043606997,
-0.1520322412,
-0.1116847172,
0.6876981258,
-0.383438468,
0.0535962097,
0.146502912,
-0.6207315922,
-0.0558064058,
0.323708266,
0.1356567144,
0.6233487725,
-0.1381050944,
0.4026171267,
0.2487908751,
-0.4506168962,
0.3207181394,
0.3081556857,
0.0237356573,
0.074418515,
0.6829280257,
0.3248673379,
0.2427201718,
-0.8701984882,
0.7981229424,
-0.0355594009,
0.1417068243,
-0.6610427499,
0.2507222295,
-0.1432491988,
0.4222555161,
0.2297048867,
-0.3095850348,
0.2323317826,
-0.5192195773,
0.4527265728,
0.5165546536,
-0.4927045703,
-0.2578553557,
0.4325161874,
-0.0321358554,
-0.1529777944,
0.3324458599,
-0.1821067482,
-0.7738958597,
1.0849933624,
0.4760425687,
1.0912024975,
-0.7815669775,
0.1477177292,
0.1276237369,
0.5868840218,
-0.2142203003,
0.0718761459,
0.1414003521,
-0.8330721855,
-0.145007357,
-0.4724691808,
-0.4445072711,
0.0770574883,
-0.4670017958,
0.1839773357,
-0.4313186407,
0.1534877867,
-0.0162924062,
-0.1473615766,
-0.3918925822,
0.0896370485,
0.0160076078,
0.5068747997,
-1.0052247047,
0.9372674823,
0.3475700021,
-0.5328737497,
-0.8813166618,
0.1689838469,
0.3433511257,
-0.852909863,
0.7432545424,
0.1029294282,
-0.2129496783,
0.0553928949,
-0.4467790425,
-0.733643353,
1.1285700798,
0.3881303072,
-0.6888228059,
0.1350152642,
0.2757467031,
0.4496165812,
-0.4127286375,
0.3397373855,
0.8415869474,
0.6425612569,
-0.3389844596,
-1.0622454882,
0.1770420074,
-0.2084451467,
-0.2028352022,
0.2620033622,
-0.5046284795,
0.6904319525,
-0.1244821548,
-0.1586475372,
0.0611000061,
0.2199047506,
0.1105988324,
0.3854296207,
0.7180012465,
0.5544103384,
0.6155923605,
0.0265445095,
0.889035821,
-0.2037401795,
0.2939036787,
1.1043543816,
-0.4185602069,
0.5631931424,
0.2016351819,
-0.0783495754,
0.2847121656,
0.3081375659,
-0.3385449052,
0.1977318823,
0.3439057469,
-0.3000058234,
-0.292745918,
0.2205670178,
-0.209192574,
0.4898187518,
0.3011183739,
-0.2062990069,
-0.4600192308,
0.1454763561,
0.0317949243,
0.0659482107,
-0.1651067138,
0.7078649998,
0.1224041656,
-0.4759697318,
0.8748562336,
-0.0334804282,
0.5064682961,
-0.4926861227,
-0.0362007245,
-0.4687788188,
0.556951344,
-0.164304778,
-0.5568572283,
0.316885978,
-0.0239864513,
0.0771680921,
-0.1633889526,
0.98231709,
-0.1793603748,
-0.4145002365,
0.694848299,
0.4528644681,
0.0907709822,
-0.3073209226,
-0.7215176821,
0.2035223991,
-0.1849872023,
-0.1747447699,
0.4936017394,
0.5602760911,
-0.2307768017,
0.8884482384,
0.381090641,
-0.048427891,
-0.1792632788,
0.1821914762,
0.9393073916,
-0.4721596539,
0.0027315419,
-0.933358252,
0.2877495885,
-0.0877309889,
-0.0529899336,
0.900570035,
0.4532820582,
0.67232126,
0.0526698977,
0.8670907617,
0.1739406586,
0.5777909756,
-0.2381180078,
0.8056215048,
-0.4425093532,
0.7952726483,
-0.4519934654,
-0.963978529,
-0.3841136098,
0.4883112609,
-0.1397292912,
-0.1857910901,
0.7404946089,
1.1306509972,
-0.1837803274,
-0.6299064755,
0.3622995913,
0.3674520254,
0.3819909096,
0.8599381447,
0.8971048594,
-0.462025404,
0.8132014275,
-0.2007652223,
-0.3213142753,
-0.2226554006,
-0.7197777033,
-1.0185121298,
-0.3970753551,
-0.4720109999,
-0.3294470012,
0.168738991,
0.6796361804,
0.3348031342,
-0.8785461783,
-0.2893272638,
-0.3264953792,
0.3053780198,
-0.0537124723,
-0.2238407135,
0.5075243115,
-0.5796014667,
-0.4891244173,
0.6987159848,
0.3133332729,
0.2835444212,
-0.5328801274,
-0.0108354595,
0.3061518967,
0.1493847072,
0.3101584017,
0.6034634113,
-0.4399265051,
-0.3580055237,
-0.1961058527,
-0.2404004782,
-0.1864647418,
0.6047711372,
-0.5353411436,
0.3293538392,
0.2288172245,
0.7623839378,
0.1455098838,
-0.3839901388,
0.6472875476,
-0.5458526611,
0.0634194836,
0.2963068485,
0.4189532101,
0.3520240784,
-0.1973406076,
0.629765451,
0.2824345827,
-0.5962064862,
-1.1515616179,
0.3476892114,
-0.6398970485,
-0.4004907608,
0.9020555019,
-0.2251309603,
-0.1517837793,
-0.3666683137,
-0.0127277086,
-0.0397286937,
0.1020990685,
1.1790388823,
0.5692754984,
0.2757126093,
-0.0596284755,
-0.7040509582,
0.4703871012,
0.5663648248,
-0.9962351322,
0.2754279375,
0.5119171739,
0.5302160978,
-0.1137819216,
0.4434110224,
-0.2122668773,
0.2230524868,
-0.1415954381,
0.3758585751,
-0.1780927777,
-0.4470554888,
-0.6170213223,
-0.124977462,
0.189434275,
0.1051499695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16694v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16694v1
|
Task Oriented In-Domain Data Augmentation
| 2024-06-24T14:58:11 | 2024-06-24T14:58:11 |
Xiao Liang, Xinyu Hu, Simiao Zuo, Yeyun Gong, Qiang Lou, Yi Liu, Shao-Lun Huang, Jian Jiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown superior performance in various
applications and fields. To achieve better performance on specialized domains
such as law and advertisement, LLMs are often continue pre-trained on in-domain
data. However, existing approaches suffer from two major issues. First,
in-domain data are scarce compared with general domain-agnostic data. Second,
data used for continual pre-training are not task-aware, such that they may not
be helpful to downstream applications. We propose TRAIT, a task-oriented
in-domain data augmentation framework. Our framework is divided into two parts:
in-domain data selection and task-oriented synthetic passage generation. The
data selection strategy identifies and selects a large amount of in-domain data
from general corpora, and thus significantly enriches domain knowledge in the
continual pre-training data. The synthetic passages contain guidance on how to
use domain knowledge to answer questions about downstream tasks. By training on
such passages, the model aligns with the need of downstream applications. We
adapt LLMs to two domains: advertisement and math. On average, TRAIT improves
LLM performance by 8% in the advertisement domain and 7.5% in the math domain.
|
[
-0.1779554486,
-0.7891326547,
0.6187710166,
0.3739878237,
-0.0897087604,
0.2569854558,
-0.3667806089,
-0.57878685,
0.1135792732,
0.6655727029,
-0.7152912021,
-0.3387955725,
-0.5068498254,
0.0915022343,
-0.1426703632,
0.9047672153,
0.0177593008,
0.1812826395,
-0.8234322071,
-0.1227178648,
-0.3955226839,
-0.8901718259,
-0.727273643,
-0.301805824,
0.2252162546,
0.3900781274,
0.4511907697,
0.4285276532,
0.3219351172,
0.3030461967,
0.2515656352,
0.5270567536,
-0.6523164511,
0.3366569281,
-0.349242568,
-0.3564727306,
-0.7526407838,
-0.0731040314,
0.5518833399,
1.0095106363,
0.5145871639,
-0.0825001448,
0.2154506892,
0.6790350676,
-0.3504313231,
0.3211053014,
-0.5766804218,
-0.271471858,
-0.36246261,
-0.3238494396,
-0.2334925383,
-0.3416146636,
0.2584181726,
-0.7309343219,
0.2996287346,
0.1082765013,
0.7081037164,
0.0967266336,
-0.4342134595,
-0.0975864306,
-0.519712925,
0.9633971453,
-0.5838265419,
0.3755609989,
0.6381297708,
-0.0120295454,
-0.4001947045,
-0.5153650641,
-0.5992535949,
-0.1284062415,
-0.136668101,
-0.1520006359,
0.0805454478,
-0.0057439748,
0.1739619225,
0.4873910248,
-0.6988189816,
0.1184847057,
-0.0910676494,
-0.201540634,
0.6879149675,
0.3192196786,
0.0800738633,
0.0777993873,
-0.2782616019,
-0.2376524806,
-1.0256677866,
0.1767858416,
0.4112333953,
0.4956825972,
0.0793838352,
0.6110264659,
-0.2260417789,
0.8914292455,
0.2204894572,
-0.095623672,
0.3652377427,
-0.2005770952,
-0.2497869432,
-0.3718169034,
0.4744583368,
-0.0342985354,
0.0358639956,
-0.2970431149,
-0.3799413443,
0.1929822713,
0.3745202422,
-0.8843328953,
0.0745604932,
0.4092670977,
-0.1476393789,
-0.1697945297,
-0.156130597,
-0.4516953528,
-0.2203731388,
-0.6728115678,
0.3747421503,
-0.6749098897,
-0.0486614555,
0.0682940856,
0.1570182294,
0.1248966902,
0.3419084251,
-0.9234346747,
0.2909764647,
0.8598911166,
0.4539282918,
-0.6128292084,
-0.1095186248,
-0.7842384577,
0.1674078554,
-0.149685815,
0.7168869972,
-0.9248123765,
-0.4177755415,
0.062463887,
0.232716471,
-0.3119640946,
-0.673391521,
0.5798439384,
-0.7959396243,
0.0342327207,
-0.1772675514,
-0.9275147319,
-0.2240756154,
0.242124483,
-0.6625569463,
1.2075579166,
0.6807519197,
-0.3132879436,
0.5793178082,
-0.7109673023,
-0.8456529975,
0.2242063135,
-0.2200925499,
-0.4733223915,
0.0685122162,
0.3956674933,
0.5267891884,
-0.3015982211,
0.3199287057,
-0.3242521286,
-0.3681993186,
0.3758699894,
-0.0550215058,
0.5705829859,
0.1412252635,
-0.1693785787,
-0.044455342,
-0.6660717726,
0.0088243233,
-0.0575818382,
-0.4017852247,
-0.4805256426,
0.0531180948,
0.1460188478,
0.2059574872,
0.3145378828,
-0.7530595064,
0.3290892243,
-0.3970226347,
0.1754724681,
0.7734631896,
-0.2347694188,
0.5676759481,
-0.4376012385,
0.5835058093,
0.0848803967,
0.0614491552,
0.1275094301,
-0.3834412396,
-0.775501132,
-0.4175313711,
0.1010396779,
0.3755514622,
-0.9527548552,
0.5356396437,
-0.5055570006,
-0.0492049418,
-0.3238300383,
0.339494735,
0.215824306,
0.4501826763,
0.3330169618,
-0.4126789272,
-0.4936052561,
-0.6074040532,
-0.1559297144,
0.0157501567,
-0.035438206,
0.4552236497,
0.2164746672,
-0.4060096145,
1.0577806234,
-0.6017949581,
-0.3775366545,
-0.5348283648,
0.0495481975,
0.3718124032,
0.4791100025,
0.6093485355,
-0.8631751537,
-0.4892237484,
0.0237809271,
-0.6430264115,
-0.0985602885,
-0.0215294883,
-0.3917479813,
0.0727507696,
0.1878310889,
-0.4590489864,
0.169951573,
0.4771033525,
-0.4018330872,
0.4792472124,
-0.0329097137,
0.1832643896,
-0.8532306552,
-0.0781007856,
0.1727454811,
-0.5304015875,
-0.8821160793,
0.0491769165,
0.0353961736,
-0.2290874422,
-0.2312726229,
0.7660034895,
-0.2014911175,
-0.0262918659,
-0.5337737203,
-0.2476117611,
0.2194017619,
0.7013614178,
0.2830519676,
0.984059155,
0.8451036811,
-0.9350311756,
0.3135589957,
0.5056505203,
-0.3476451337,
0.8202003837,
-0.2789194286,
0.2713473439,
-0.0869840682,
0.0973733217,
-0.5051665902,
-0.3082575202,
-0.0045998902,
-0.3278181851,
0.4696878493,
-0.0172871444,
-0.4550182223,
-0.2516911924,
-0.1275250316,
0.445135504,
0.3592200875,
-0.7091298103,
0.7244313955,
0.4254864156,
-0.3572957218,
-0.277222693,
-0.5003946424,
-0.0518219322,
-0.1605747044,
-0.7752657533,
0.5701365471,
-0.0244877823,
0.0494994149,
0.0048197433,
-0.0279401708,
-0.2125477046,
-0.2948966324,
0.2004080117,
0.5125771761,
-0.0952359587,
0.2129851282,
0.0529394038,
0.1694174558,
0.0547097661,
-0.599905014,
0.2960321307,
0.2940564454,
-0.318909198,
-0.0499280915,
0.4925132096,
0.3454216421,
-0.1373602003,
0.5486108661,
0.3167033792,
-0.0056537832,
-0.6108825803,
-0.4497934878,
-0.1800433993,
-0.5224841237,
0.4122965634,
-0.4365486205,
-1.1681423187,
0.0659543499,
-0.1841948032,
0.0300559364,
0.18699269,
0.3376041651,
-0.2284535468,
0.7875558734,
0.9767893553,
-0.2791183293,
0.5393003225,
-0.4429555535,
0.3176553845,
-0.8942038417,
-0.0724940002,
-0.1674610376,
-0.2414643168,
-0.275346905,
-0.7369372845,
0.5473207235,
-0.2685233653,
-0.1377972066,
0.4991252124,
-0.0904142186,
-0.0358865187,
0.3367079794,
0.342674762,
0.1504183561,
0.3360439539,
0.2243136615,
-0.1711844057,
-0.5718206167,
-0.30033499,
1.4129811525,
0.1761070639,
0.8580405116,
0.0272484384,
0.3005191088,
0.4218976796,
0.4179531038,
-0.738237977,
0.6407489777,
-0.577919662,
-0.4252665341,
-0.3587134182,
-0.503213644,
-0.5577166677,
0.095190376,
-0.1761357635,
-0.4082191586,
0.329477489,
0.2675729096,
-0.1566846669,
0.0871154815,
-0.3230129182,
0.5645312667,
-0.3203036785,
-0.7045692205,
-0.2559148073,
-0.2371672392,
0.2497494519,
-0.4765170217,
0.0310571641,
0.007980017,
0.2085602731,
0.4094053507,
-0.6676498055,
0.7848950028,
-0.1760586053,
-0.0584839694,
0.2440649867,
-0.180503875,
1.0196340084,
-0.1243755594,
-0.285767585,
-0.2783320844,
-0.490824908,
-0.4513787925,
-0.7496473193,
0.6776129007,
-0.5143758059,
-0.5791144967,
-0.195005089,
-0.8032402992,
-0.9347683787,
-0.2777312696,
-0.0222590845,
0.6397051811,
-0.2402317971,
-0.0065573519,
0.7626796961,
-0.2185061276,
0.1608281881,
0.6432918906,
0.1163323671,
-0.0905682221,
1.1832695007,
-0.5134379268,
0.3908980489,
0.5214412212,
-0.1533896774,
-0.6025931835,
-0.40896824,
-0.3976771235,
0.1719560921,
-0.6253856421,
-0.1622930914,
-0.7274535298,
-0.1754716933,
-0.4932035208,
-0.1298233271,
-0.0758651868,
-0.2999807894,
-0.269405514,
-0.0165892858,
0.7056159973,
0.4315398633,
0.2375447303,
0.3331617117,
-0.6355893016,
0.3308739364,
0.3601360917,
0.2689368427,
-0.3545262516,
-0.6157315373,
-0.5146132112,
0.0751570761,
-0.2771831453,
-0.3268343508,
0.4762090743,
0.513677001,
0.5553360581,
0.2603809536,
-0.1733071506,
0.6354302764,
-0.3368290663,
0.5553320646,
-0.0624192767,
-0.744555831,
0.2598845363,
-0.2546375096,
0.0193784926,
0.4734348059,
0.3502561152,
-0.1473369151,
-0.6897277832,
-0.2180171311,
-0.7970733047,
0.6842469573,
0.2030247897,
0.3310861588,
0.1952958256,
0.2703942657,
0.4223853648,
0.3661411107,
-0.4676396251,
-0.1155893281,
-0.1747069806,
-0.1186812893,
-0.1420581341,
0.0427127555,
0.0544166043,
-0.546977818,
0.7956048846,
-0.4803033769,
0.2757760286,
-0.0253188647,
-0.4194145799,
-0.0213056859,
0.256657511,
0.1920650452,
0.7897289991,
-0.1388859898,
-0.1854180992,
-0.141025275,
-0.7343709469,
0.2509275079,
0.2734244168,
-0.1877736896,
-0.101606898,
0.2155833989,
1.0090278387,
0.0829756856,
-0.7279559374,
0.533487916,
0.3843487203,
-0.2177314162,
-0.1415993124,
0.1321261674,
-0.2310360223,
0.2254233807,
0.4121856689,
-0.0435966328,
0.0198765472,
-0.641757071,
0.2931429744,
0.5379995704,
-0.1288326234,
-0.340500176,
0.6912523508,
0.220958367,
0.406419009,
0.4385698736,
-0.2563254535,
-0.5318800807,
0.4422104061,
0.6548687816,
0.8626074791,
-0.0441065989,
0.3028597236,
0.1720412523,
-0.165767014,
0.0699884817,
0.6024284959,
-0.0003349183,
-0.7850295901,
-0.859241128,
-0.8473178148,
-0.2709321976,
0.4230623245,
-0.3117248714,
0.0481769629,
-0.1472823322,
-0.2564507723,
-0.1763427258,
-0.0010882207,
-0.9418256879,
0.5361297131,
-0.2328258604,
0.7235329747,
-0.7437950969,
1.1947864294,
0.7779380679,
-0.1955493093,
-0.5837525725,
0.0810410753,
-0.3290780783,
-0.6927764416,
1.0035581589,
-0.1507071108,
-0.0516533256,
-0.1388198137,
-0.3831675351,
-0.708765626,
0.8378955722,
0.3531695306,
-0.4312489927,
0.1045684367,
0.5723903179,
0.4725959897,
-0.7841132879,
-0.2187227756,
0.5889549255,
0.4705072641,
0.2002769858,
-0.5287220478,
0.0643837675,
-0.2160504907,
0.1218735501,
-0.0014409439,
-0.3232566714,
0.8486536145,
0.0056348988,
-0.0604616925,
-0.0346651971,
0.7354547381,
0.205381453,
0.1512586176,
0.5160352588,
0.5873243809,
0.487967521,
-0.1062731892,
1.0790897608,
-0.234011516,
0.0238709114,
0.9426372647,
-0.5895139575,
0.5629063249,
0.3929646313,
-0.3099742234,
0.449475348,
0.5619431138,
0.0988633633,
0.6108303666,
0.0440297835,
-0.6244972348,
-0.355078727,
-0.1533546597,
-0.0489807911,
0.4145466387,
0.535445869,
-0.2511270344,
0.0641383603,
0.2174341679,
-0.1476902217,
0.1152022332,
-0.387581557,
0.5108969212,
0.0494415686,
-0.7457072139,
0.5125066042,
-0.0360833704,
0.5976777077,
-0.7727241516,
-0.0555460639,
-0.3796859384,
0.1704668105,
-0.145322606,
-0.6341280937,
0.2058369368,
0.1022168249,
-0.2618727088,
-0.4522322416,
0.7371380925,
-0.5733558536,
-0.4979993105,
0.1785854846,
0.5596648455,
-0.0698735416,
-0.2307545692,
-0.367322892,
0.0624540523,
-0.2211254984,
-0.12354891,
0.559410274,
0.363571763,
-0.2926284969,
0.6135437489,
0.7130721211,
0.3255317807,
-0.129741624,
0.2292742282,
1.3255677223,
-0.4449704587,
-0.5857909918,
-0.3631505072,
0.3735439777,
-0.2132853568,
-0.0308524705,
0.6943582892,
0.733746469,
0.7242267728,
-0.2618654668,
1.0639531612,
-0.1825589687,
0.6985085607,
-0.6856633425,
0.3471345603,
-0.6080275774,
0.2188760638,
-0.1603311002,
-1.0676734447,
0.0922635868,
0.2403806895,
-0.4473037422,
0.0874996856,
0.6820582747,
0.9914988279,
-0.3572882414,
-0.0564367548,
0.3701078594,
-0.0739709362,
0.2378975153,
0.7005798221,
0.6817809939,
-0.1540896595,
0.0941365585,
0.0041898447,
-0.2378439605,
-0.1352946609,
-0.6807638407,
-0.9778549075,
-0.7256866097,
-0.1982577294,
-0.16770567,
0.1357570589,
0.8129587173,
0.8487259746,
-0.8550437093,
-0.317258805,
-0.0390884541,
-0.2346699685,
-0.4328572154,
-0.2544986904,
0.3882763982,
-0.6474606991,
-0.8845499158,
0.8836726546,
0.3459065855,
-0.1458567232,
-0.2876285315,
-0.1686780751,
0.0648867562,
0.1359781176,
0.8418316841,
0.3115462363,
-0.2747291028,
-0.2127815038,
0.054825712,
-0.123035118,
0.0903658569,
1.286483407,
-0.8177034259,
0.3448199928,
0.3745822906,
0.8655161858,
0.590783298,
0.1894547641,
0.9925014377,
-0.9475495815,
0.2758065462,
0.357378006,
0.2187636048,
0.5534843802,
-0.693107307,
0.4441489875,
0.2430690825,
-0.4249830246,
-0.3548619151,
0.3582090437,
-0.8829063177,
-0.2667523623,
1.1813665628,
-0.2170813531,
-0.1223280355,
-0.414699167,
0.1958545446,
-0.1242302358,
-0.3398433626,
0.4532112479,
0.3927798271,
-0.2743865252,
0.1854628623,
-0.6438673735,
0.9190903902,
0.3274713755,
-0.9728711843,
0.0578606613,
0.6113936305,
0.2608789802,
-0.3477715254,
0.7695609331,
-0.150990054,
0.088664338,
-0.4110891819,
-0.1537318528,
-0.129730463,
-0.2832095325,
-0.058405675,
-0.072166577,
0.0517990291,
-0.1809760034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16690v1
|
Scaling Laws for Linear Complexity Language Models
| 2024-06-24T14:51:31 | 2024-06-24T14:51:31 |
Xuyang Shen, Dong Li, Ruitao Leng, Zhen Qin, Weigao Sun, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The interest in linear complexity models for large language models is on the
rise, although their scaling capacity remains uncertain. In this study, we
present the scaling laws for linear complexity language models to establish a
foundation for their scalability. Specifically, we examine the scaling
behaviors of three efficient linear architectures. These include TNL, a linear
attention model with data-independent decay; HGRN2, a linear RNN with
data-dependent decay; and cosFormer2, a linear attention model without decay.
We also include LLaMA as a baseline architecture for softmax attention for
comparison. These models were trained with six variants, ranging from 70M to 7B
parameters on a 300B-token corpus, and evaluated with a total of 1,376
intermediate checkpoints on various downstream tasks. These tasks include
validation loss, commonsense reasoning, and information retrieval and
generation. The study reveals that existing linear complexity language models
exhibit similar scaling capabilities as conventional transformer-based models
while also demonstrating superior linguistic proficiency and knowledge
retention.
|
[
-0.047166653,
-0.5154843926,
0.6275664568,
0.4572969079,
0.2477837205,
-0.376290679,
-0.2701337039,
-0.37974298,
-0.2434311211,
0.6166867018,
-0.3036256433,
0.129082948,
-0.6214447618,
-0.12021029,
-0.3467589617,
1.0469595194,
0.0340000093,
0.0797822848,
-0.1693613678,
-0.4713653624,
-0.3285547197,
-0.4066003263,
-0.6997487545,
-0.3970881999,
0.6968809366,
0.2660761774,
0.8895609379,
1.0018166304,
0.7558355331,
0.2853389084,
-0.4392302334,
-0.4655435681,
-0.8672425151,
-0.042227827,
-0.2709920406,
-0.4313186705,
-0.7302057147,
-0.2768396139,
0.5867901444,
0.9226149917,
-0.0556606613,
0.2550657988,
0.0472552255,
0.5327891707,
-0.3504567742,
0.1279858053,
-0.5176050663,
-0.1128664613,
0.0194400549,
0.2920987904,
-0.5719504356,
-0.4046677053,
0.1744090319,
-0.395803988,
-0.035896983,
0.1070469022,
0.6421940327,
0.2091782093,
-0.4377616048,
-0.6797856688,
-0.7288953662,
1.0246764421,
-0.9830557108,
0.3685445786,
0.1657946557,
0.0850371793,
0.2299682647,
-0.9623762369,
-0.2214013934,
-0.4517160654,
-0.0332281478,
-0.4431406558,
-0.5462583303,
0.1973093599,
0.3908945322,
0.50440377,
-0.5275632739,
0.2061780542,
-0.5041804314,
-0.1309239417,
0.1954979897,
0.3191218078,
0.2392448187,
0.0409609713,
-0.3801406324,
0.1448913664,
-0.5309358835,
-0.0473611094,
0.0670772344,
0.3637600243,
-0.0853375569,
0.5490816236,
0.0139543228,
0.5243750811,
0.1900002658,
-0.2898378372,
0.1053543612,
-0.5884085894,
-0.1622813642,
-0.4051002562,
0.3700120747,
0.020550387,
0.2498547733,
-0.3523545265,
-0.4326488972,
-0.408711493,
0.4351960421,
-0.8131994605,
0.0324183665,
0.262529254,
-0.5710782409,
-0.2295823842,
-0.5866562724,
-0.3786915243,
-0.3407472074,
-0.3881046772,
0.9306280613,
-0.2432589382,
-0.4004593194,
0.224482283,
0.2294529825,
0.3891120553,
0.1714631915,
-0.9761067033,
0.5347961783,
0.881803751,
0.7662732005,
-0.077225551,
0.0338240974,
-0.5081140399,
-0.3597604036,
-0.260805279,
0.1460035443,
-0.3721576333,
0.3769114912,
0.1182951778,
-0.221220836,
-0.0510465205,
-0.3986004293,
0.6720570326,
-0.7414351106,
-0.0587702021,
-0.2350187898,
-0.6257963181,
-0.1846106499,
0.1066979244,
-0.8127148747,
0.7742763758,
0.166543141,
-0.6356405616,
-0.002336445,
-0.491234988,
-0.4081964493,
0.1621270627,
0.1818173826,
-0.4659129083,
0.2913203239,
-0.203503862,
0.5438295603,
-0.4440684021,
0.1739078015,
-0.3586158454,
-0.1011870429,
-0.1096158549,
-0.3355075419,
0.775917232,
0.3436020911,
-0.4075914025,
0.0948211029,
-0.7505500317,
0.0918815807,
0.1407920122,
-0.5617867112,
-0.1951831281,
0.0257644411,
0.1804379225,
0.1367004514,
0.4997891784,
-0.2424238026,
0.0475531071,
-0.3171344399,
0.6354202628,
0.5134723783,
-0.0716817155,
0.6573624611,
-0.0770422071,
0.5162532926,
-0.0518069379,
0.2406177223,
-0.235230267,
-0.3358347714,
-1.0824791193,
0.0606047958,
0.1294952929,
0.3606229722,
-0.3341129124,
0.0657196641,
-0.4754938781,
-0.3913829327,
-0.1694659293,
0.3168401718,
0.6022707224,
0.3452111483,
0.2248712033,
-0.1637997031,
-0.4381960332,
-0.8965799809,
-0.1023693755,
-0.0484712794,
-0.058677569,
0.5548272729,
0.5128375888,
-0.1438911408,
0.6447671056,
-0.1388895363,
-0.010931571,
-0.5579525828,
0.0470998548,
0.4879256487,
0.2654087842,
0.4859777987,
-0.569711864,
-0.2350642085,
0.1615926325,
-0.4810966253,
-0.1518054157,
-0.0121755796,
0.370102942,
-0.0139014376,
0.7097645998,
-0.3547402918,
0.1533942968,
0.510260582,
-0.291560024,
0.2009091526,
-0.4269481599,
-0.4484289587,
-0.8683792353,
0.2568561435,
-0.1601904631,
-0.357093215,
-1.2723858356,
0.2897388041,
0.2943384945,
0.0521067008,
-0.4291528761,
0.3432052433,
-0.4418569803,
-0.3396401107,
-0.2881612778,
-0.1152768135,
-0.0558989421,
0.7862962484,
-0.138642922,
0.5386936665,
0.2955744267,
-0.8021712899,
0.1632510722,
-0.3404647112,
-0.1089952365,
0.2537934184,
-1.1191661358,
0.1690096557,
-0.1524583995,
-0.0112677719,
-1.0996603966,
0.0121004069,
-0.2301533818,
-0.1641781032,
0.16096057,
-0.1409724057,
-0.4368847311,
-0.3301149607,
-0.0307867508,
0.6799466014,
0.4268350303,
-0.3169097304,
0.6942948699,
0.1976783872,
-0.1526314765,
-0.4461472631,
-0.542863071,
0.0755908489,
-0.2269724309,
-0.5662468672,
-0.2143102139,
-0.205379948,
-0.4941996336,
-0.1576534808,
0.1089708507,
-0.1739993691,
-0.0237871241,
0.0605043247,
-0.1190566942,
-0.7625257373,
0.1882249564,
-0.3771147132,
0.1243637353,
0.0776498318,
-0.7231277823,
0.7917492986,
-0.4980044067,
0.0102481702,
-0.1590759754,
0.085696958,
0.9755592942,
-0.329549551,
0.6675801277,
0.4469923675,
-0.4214935005,
0.2325977236,
-0.6405142546,
0.0978818834,
-0.4206036925,
0.5736136436,
-0.3337806761,
-0.7522562146,
0.8232088685,
0.1662966609,
0.3214088082,
0.6167529225,
1.003821373,
0.1154262871,
0.687833488,
0.7285342813,
-0.230502218,
0.3844029009,
-0.0978429914,
-0.0912314355,
-0.6319898367,
0.0361301601,
-0.5124240518,
-0.3655003011,
-0.4704129398,
-0.7907979488,
0.1631742865,
-0.0672673434,
-0.4475145936,
0.6171727777,
-0.0728906021,
0.6065123081,
0.1908421367,
-0.1102479473,
0.2102262378,
0.0210194085,
-0.162874639,
0.0075756824,
-0.6512811184,
-0.2023208439,
1.2940409184,
0.8896225095,
0.8388992548,
0.4310823083,
0.1981093287,
0.3850909472,
0.2113474011,
-0.8216575384,
0.3706295788,
-0.2759196162,
-0.7068583369,
-0.6032338142,
-0.6447750926,
-0.9128745794,
0.1642123312,
0.2035562247,
-0.4823405743,
0.2779950202,
-0.0254638288,
-0.2586892545,
0.4224742651,
-0.5682713985,
0.5419703126,
-0.2395515591,
-0.5585486889,
-0.3877085447,
-0.6655042171,
0.2012747079,
-0.0925752744,
0.1440617293,
0.1742085069,
-0.3337053657,
0.5844420791,
-0.4053781331,
0.7283800244,
-0.0697470084,
-0.4089009464,
0.1599175483,
0.1294331849,
0.6968352199,
-0.1048029289,
-0.0605802499,
-0.0154820262,
-0.5960066915,
-0.5887073278,
-0.3107371628,
0.5312946439,
-0.7691313028,
-0.344288826,
-0.0064139185,
-0.8305210471,
-0.0407699011,
0.4980869889,
0.0870705321,
0.6769608855,
0.0591787621,
0.5614134073,
1.1657636166,
0.0146635845,
0.5654864311,
0.5111789703,
-0.1949842721,
-0.2677924931,
0.776848793,
0.1884487569,
0.7960522771,
0.4783580303,
0.1976762116,
-0.2482452244,
-0.6341350675,
-0.2598752975,
0.3037312329,
-0.7164956331,
-0.0441349037,
-0.7449692488,
-0.4335542321,
-0.3415677547,
0.0761247948,
-0.6050618291,
-0.6450932026,
-0.1208522096,
0.0715068579,
0.2854920626,
1.1430341005,
-0.0342350043,
0.0217982568,
-0.1516643614,
0.3078507483,
0.4660767615,
0.5688828826,
0.1855695397,
-1.1177096367,
-0.4578029811,
-0.3235150874,
0.0134479161,
-0.4534446597,
0.0899106413,
0.4009517431,
0.3566107452,
0.5108884573,
-0.2193810493,
0.290992111,
-0.6789065599,
0.3078518212,
0.201141715,
-0.8233610392,
0.1784280837,
-0.4467154741,
0.4864896536,
0.2392767668,
0.1496072561,
-0.4222514629,
-0.4427320063,
-0.4049656689,
-0.7410369515,
0.6593651772,
0.2973383069,
0.5997407436,
0.4882378578,
0.7397406101,
-0.0941732973,
-0.1939568073,
-1.1098743677,
-0.1181245446,
-0.1017728075,
-0.2398274988,
-0.0457944795,
-0.5888331532,
0.1250727475,
0.0697571263,
0.2347723097,
0.1335550547,
0.0506232791,
-0.0358605087,
-0.1971660256,
-0.0474760383,
0.3293232024,
1.033970952,
0.6656236649,
-0.1618284285,
0.0614797175,
0.3291276395,
-0.7042661309,
0.3392911851,
-0.2586996257,
-0.1863227934,
-0.2872307003,
0.3931507468,
1.0007088184,
0.4744183719,
-0.5442420244,
0.404743284,
-0.2129277885,
-0.3091059327,
-0.1752919555,
-0.046865955,
0.4463211894,
0.3201061189,
0.2339262366,
0.006627765,
0.1074691489,
-0.2213463485,
0.211622864,
0.0718339756,
-0.5757458806,
-0.3130313158,
0.8389002085,
0.1271679997,
-0.296620369,
0.5361486077,
-0.1954845488,
-0.286390394,
0.601883471,
0.5654737949,
0.5980731845,
-0.1940230578,
-0.1449199021,
0.4511334002,
0.7290198207,
-0.0921617523,
-0.0450303704,
0.0561637953,
-0.4726065993,
-0.3800033629,
-0.6220725179,
-0.3439673483,
0.3112946153,
-0.6791197658,
0.0566662326,
-0.6948523521,
-0.151025027,
0.0123743154,
0.1140415668,
-0.57934618,
0.2332374156,
0.2858858705,
0.7907349467,
-0.6190149188,
0.7560341358,
0.337107569,
-0.2534164488,
-0.6652138829,
-0.1641069353,
-0.0010299551,
-0.9189332724,
0.7443727851,
0.0541551299,
-0.0796606019,
0.0243814886,
-0.3051122725,
-1.2030569315,
0.9952602386,
0.4178312421,
-0.670158565,
-0.0691199377,
0.3300147653,
0.8526528478,
-0.5083137155,
0.2614688575,
0.4327822924,
0.0746947676,
0.2440621108,
-0.9052963853,
-0.1082405373,
-0.1409089267,
0.2229003906,
0.0504578464,
-0.7494488358,
1.2394156456,
-0.4915067554,
0.0174547676,
0.0143534848,
0.9512122273,
-0.0012483993,
0.0960917175,
0.67616117,
0.7286538482,
0.5974837542,
0.1864312142,
0.8740429878,
-0.3194668591,
0.4314417243,
1.1540602446,
-0.2402347922,
0.9731760621,
0.207978189,
-0.1750086099,
0.3627498746,
0.145122394,
0.0619297922,
0.0100400429,
0.4541618228,
0.0346988104,
-0.0972056314,
-0.2109898478,
-0.163406387,
0.3636841178,
0.4042797983,
-0.5647946,
-0.0816215798,
-0.0346036032,
0.335093528,
-0.1052857712,
-0.575294435,
0.7315739989,
-0.0626483634,
-0.5219017863,
0.7261533141,
0.0282513183,
0.3336433768,
-0.4745218754,
0.4158242941,
-0.5250498652,
0.5278943181,
0.0558631569,
-0.602802515,
0.0765362605,
0.169012472,
-0.5106306672,
-0.3924830854,
0.5793708563,
-0.3759501874,
-0.6953142285,
0.371430248,
0.1461331546,
0.1916456223,
0.1370062828,
-0.5048406124,
0.107637763,
-0.0067157769,
-0.3965021074,
0.168715626,
0.382959187,
-0.0247569922,
0.9707884789,
0.1401212066,
0.0382564031,
0.604670167,
0.2653944194,
0.7364812493,
-0.3972814083,
-0.198165834,
-0.5624815226,
0.1876969784,
0.0359375142,
-0.1189855114,
0.6185669899,
0.5427145362,
0.168166101,
0.068590425,
0.374050647,
0.0280189347,
0.338075906,
-0.3020586967,
0.5759611726,
-0.6627806425,
0.3144290447,
0.1483727396,
-0.7904848456,
-0.2312314063,
0.1145101786,
-0.1852436811,
0.192473501,
0.3481207788,
0.716401875,
-0.1265488267,
-0.3731561601,
0.4907642901,
0.5707349181,
0.3171595335,
0.979288578,
0.1225484014,
-0.5547803044,
1.0356624126,
0.1702367514,
-0.2445052564,
-0.4065580368,
-0.6310555339,
-0.8009467125,
-0.4561337233,
-0.2036053687,
-0.4635807276,
-0.2492761612,
0.4819811881,
0.7020213008,
-0.8937067389,
-0.4204941988,
-0.2254980654,
-0.0209202841,
-0.1283455193,
-0.1835722029,
0.2831531167,
-0.7362088561,
-0.4554116428,
0.0435484685,
0.6319611669,
0.0220390242,
-0.6474377513,
-0.2503979504,
-0.0272683613,
0.6097807884,
0.5816380382,
0.4790633321,
-0.8796790242,
-0.1166451201,
0.2406080812,
-0.602089107,
-0.0003310381,
0.9598919749,
-0.2321829796,
0.4883535504,
0.6583710313,
0.633726716,
0.3328157663,
-0.3559182882,
0.5524166226,
-0.6785547733,
0.0927498117,
0.2121578753,
0.3610588908,
0.1221134886,
-0.0981687009,
0.3738171756,
-0.0040846826,
-0.7263214588,
-0.643065691,
0.2259062976,
-0.8163882494,
0.0882310122,
1.2341510057,
-0.174264878,
-0.1766783297,
-0.1868520677,
0.0778244287,
-0.219890818,
0.0122604612,
0.3572399616,
0.8166520596,
0.0465661958,
-0.4029196203,
-0.7333562374,
0.3057878315,
0.628575623,
-0.5963706374,
0.4026875794,
0.1427081376,
0.2811276615,
0.2971173823,
0.555172205,
-0.1614623517,
0.1900935769,
-0.0053513404,
-0.0176265445,
0.3980210125,
-0.0886403695,
-0.5985568762,
0.3617434204,
0.0712066069,
0.4473387599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16678v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16678v1
|
Segment Any Text: A Universal Approach for Robust, Efficient and Adaptable Sentence Segmentation
| 2024-06-24T14:36:11 | 2024-06-24T14:36:11 |
Markus Frohmann, Igor Sterner, Ivan Vulić, Benjamin Minixhofer, Markus Schedl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Segmenting text into sentences plays an early and crucial role in many NLP
systems. This is commonly achieved by using rule-based or statistical methods
relying on lexical features such as punctuation. Although some recent works no
longer exclusively rely on punctuation, we find that no prior method achieves
all of (i) robustness to missing punctuation, (ii) effective adaptability to
new domains, and (iii) high efficiency. We introduce a new model - Segment any
Text (SaT) - to solve this problem. To enhance robustness, we propose a new
pretraining scheme that ensures less reliance on punctuation. To address
adaptability, we introduce an extra stage of parameter-efficient fine-tuning,
establishing state-of-the-art performance in distinct domains such as verses
from lyrics and legal documents. Along the way, we introduce architectural
modifications that result in a threefold gain in speed over the previous state
of the art and solve spurious reliance on context far in the future. Finally,
we introduce a variant of our model with fine-tuning on a diverse, multilingual
mixture of sentence-segmented data, acting as a drop-in replacement and
enhancement for existing segmentation tools. Overall, our contributions provide
a universal approach for segmenting any text. Our method outperforms all
baselines - including strong LLMs - across 8 corpora spanning diverse domains
and languages, especially in practically relevant situations where text is
poorly formatted. Our models and code, including documentation, are available
at https://huggingface.co/segment-any-text under the MIT license.
|
[
0.0896594152,
-0.9446004629,
0.7707349658,
0.4796232581,
-0.5808874369,
-0.1694358587,
-0.0473013073,
-0.450665921,
0.1588370502,
0.6675159931,
-0.7048758864,
-0.700502336,
-0.4126452208,
0.2706599832,
-0.5381875634,
0.874322474,
0.241862148,
-0.1025754511,
-0.2712626755,
-0.3598870635,
-0.4813486934,
-0.7072588205,
-0.3230058849,
-0.0017401346,
0.2478393763,
0.3920745552,
0.3993127048,
1.1266387701,
0.382933706,
0.2815700471,
-0.2733935714,
0.2655991912,
-0.120218657,
0.431289643,
-0.0927166417,
-0.3834284544,
-0.0254904218,
-0.0028410559,
0.7205474973,
0.9701768756,
-0.1237042248,
-0.3315186501,
-0.2502893806,
0.5334801674,
-0.7322729826,
-0.3756226003,
-0.9583698511,
0.0102647319,
-0.2647432387,
-0.1834138632,
-0.5382239223,
-0.459644407,
0.2416163683,
-0.8967059851,
-0.1096343324,
0.3966500759,
1.1254823208,
0.4245998859,
-0.2548226416,
-0.2740164995,
-0.2911040783,
0.7649895549,
-0.2601045966,
0.4410858452,
0.0028068032,
-0.1843599677,
0.0483337902,
-0.8826771975,
-0.0859569386,
-0.1205134764,
0.1431535482,
-0.0167118981,
-0.1459620893,
-0.1522138268,
0.1005984768,
0.2346623093,
-0.6095202565,
0.0652956888,
0.1160785928,
-0.222006917,
0.2386742234,
0.2262590677,
0.7088007331,
-0.2860504687,
-0.616995573,
0.1931336671,
-0.7174962163,
0.0851176381,
0.2327536345,
0.4167224169,
-0.0834051222,
0.447088033,
0.2138894349,
0.9249327183,
-0.2347835153,
-0.2058812678,
-0.1228854805,
-0.3394174874,
-0.3000862002,
-0.0687904581,
0.75043118,
-0.0897016078,
0.5043829679,
-0.1298276335,
0.1333236098,
0.0662296265,
0.3685275614,
-0.6901415586,
-0.4068461955,
-0.2412256747,
-0.3456614316,
-0.0956942961,
0.0876229107,
-0.503700614,
-0.3730515838,
-0.2977970839,
0.0426979586,
-1.0652563572,
0.2708203793,
0.4049286544,
0.011835847,
0.2177162468,
0.2013615817,
-0.7192519307,
0.2579391599,
0.6930755973,
1.0008159876,
-0.4642904997,
-0.4435832202,
-0.6222816706,
0.1548796147,
-0.0892508402,
1.2164360285,
-0.8435983658,
-0.333327055,
0.1297984719,
0.0221806914,
-0.686668396,
-0.4709877372,
1.072445035,
-0.26531142,
0.2631483078,
-0.1144239902,
-0.892726779,
-0.0259543229,
0.3096239269,
-0.4831073284,
0.6891046762,
-0.0331127271,
-0.8099947572,
0.3624465764,
-0.9158489704,
-0.7033938169,
0.0204598941,
0.0243081916,
-0.5919329524,
0.0310544446,
0.5947332382,
0.125902012,
0.02156673,
-0.0262653381,
-0.3206683993,
-0.2213330269,
0.292137742,
-0.231562525,
1.0776677132,
0.1498949677,
0.1622044444,
0.4466487467,
-1.1694225073,
0.1918924302,
0.0710943565,
-0.2584000826,
-0.4522604644,
0.1105133519,
0.614574194,
-0.328371793,
0.0506551154,
-0.5118327141,
0.1865692586,
-0.5047283769,
0.6410790682,
0.6484927535,
0.2624512613,
0.625513494,
-0.0931653008,
0.6188728809,
-0.2036679387,
0.1602457315,
-0.7550829053,
-0.1304554343,
-0.7931944132,
-0.8048378825,
0.5903188586,
0.5559270382,
-0.36692518,
0.8652538061,
-0.1531923413,
-0.0689846873,
-0.3764175475,
-0.0496438369,
0.1408278495,
0.3713352978,
0.2666632533,
-0.0920027271,
-0.9749106765,
-0.626526773,
-0.5054704547,
-0.127517432,
0.0571076311,
-0.0365117081,
0.3568126261,
0.0064418754,
1.0506715775,
-0.7786764503,
-0.4244657457,
-0.5231369734,
-0.1328710467,
-0.1040821448,
0.4751887321,
0.3806014061,
-0.6958639026,
-0.4474610984,
-0.2181478292,
-0.5381976366,
-0.305254519,
-0.2542643845,
-0.3149554729,
-0.1235885173,
0.6287781596,
-0.4708368182,
0.2614433169,
0.138507098,
-0.6395998597,
0.520394206,
-0.1592275798,
-0.27017501,
-1.0341992378,
0.1278933883,
-0.0493858792,
-0.5072761178,
-0.596876502,
0.1703732014,
-0.0458160266,
-0.2249133289,
-0.3480801582,
0.2779374123,
-0.2776772082,
0.1399959326,
-0.3016133904,
0.2470662892,
0.2867996097,
0.0359500349,
-0.0129343746,
0.8022812605,
0.3729588687,
-0.4709357321,
-0.2746018171,
0.7847643495,
-0.6041291952,
0.8663779497,
-0.6077638865,
-0.0127048027,
0.0434834957,
0.1336560994,
-0.5443042517,
-0.193631798,
0.2884917855,
-0.3134973049,
-0.1544886976,
0.1002502888,
-0.1600466222,
0.2860444188,
-0.0800539032,
0.1778603047,
0.3159308434,
-0.452024579,
0.5083454847,
0.3887521029,
-0.1619455963,
-0.2148672342,
-0.4530456364,
0.1196885854,
-0.1670109183,
-0.7852604985,
0.5149489641,
-0.1247379556,
-0.1224017665,
-0.0888692215,
-0.2757835984,
-0.5383168459,
0.3503555655,
0.1833193302,
0.1868777275,
-0.1538078934,
-0.127445966,
-0.015839139,
-0.1526845098,
-0.1817903668,
-0.4879478216,
0.5265738368,
0.0483372919,
-0.2171387374,
-0.3951283395,
0.5689701438,
0.3141065538,
-0.3994957209,
0.3812220991,
0.3430890441,
-0.1981492341,
-0.5016821623,
-0.3010093868,
0.2994826138,
-0.383500576,
0.2777189612,
-0.3554766476,
-1.1956814528,
0.1769148111,
-0.0229629856,
-0.1697829217,
0.2103397399,
0.1630214006,
-0.0892077759,
0.6476582289,
1.2292886972,
0.017129248,
0.6574918628,
0.3364718854,
0.3625843823,
-0.6875298023,
-0.1135127321,
-0.9004381299,
0.1553460509,
-0.2517572045,
-0.0900415406,
0.1923581362,
0.165978983,
-0.1698859632,
0.3710370064,
-0.5455977917,
0.8515437841,
0.4816961288,
-0.1353135705,
0.3800865114,
0.0252206735,
-0.2795810997,
-0.1866410673,
-0.7055718899,
-0.4494577646,
0.6214309931,
0.0384814516,
0.3673150837,
-0.5268262625,
0.4833732545,
0.2598211765,
0.0489266291,
-0.7174394131,
0.4625619352,
-0.4681874216,
-0.5200980306,
-0.1053765416,
-0.3869842291,
-0.9978513718,
0.4550028741,
-0.1280898899,
-1.0291156769,
0.0431234688,
-0.3130102754,
-0.6222687364,
0.3671385646,
-0.5901390314,
1.0855808258,
0.0120136635,
0.2231801152,
0.4826728404,
-0.6699619293,
0.0769525841,
-0.1693305224,
0.1664154083,
-0.4003905356,
-0.1641774178,
0.8016650081,
-0.4730304182,
0.4771125615,
0.0358207114,
0.1549107432,
0.3201279938,
-0.1406794488,
0.1232380271,
-0.0154058617,
0.1385141164,
-0.2061367482,
0.2907135189,
-0.3899659514,
-0.3929051161,
0.4742477238,
-0.6263456345,
-0.1323254257,
-0.4305719733,
-0.690413177,
-0.2838765085,
0.3571796119,
0.3282037079,
0.1143140942,
-0.5961937904,
0.3577614725,
0.4588910639,
-0.083320573,
0.6423988938,
0.5449445248,
-0.0882166475,
-0.6868846416,
0.7182552218,
-0.3177242875,
-0.3566128314,
0.5742070079,
0.0256734155,
-0.4324016273,
-0.5826622248,
-0.2308030874,
0.0690067038,
-0.539718926,
-0.1006121188,
-0.7827262878,
-0.1454345882,
-0.2243016809,
-0.4470971525,
-0.3271617591,
-0.3638459146,
-0.5153346658,
-0.0064795781,
0.0454657823,
0.4203127027,
0.1735700071,
0.745262444,
-0.741279304,
0.1742102653,
-0.1922441125,
0.2235863358,
-0.6199358702,
-0.4580357969,
-0.1113779694,
-0.5117480159,
-0.4474472404,
-0.7187789679,
0.2425976992,
0.5427199602,
0.1514862478,
0.5509452224,
0.0469645858,
0.6091332436,
-0.674064219,
0.7687112689,
0.4637158215,
-1.2397023439,
0.4313732386,
-0.3553276062,
0.3945597112,
0.955856204,
0.177617088,
-0.6854485273,
-0.0952060148,
-0.3643914759,
-0.8723390102,
0.6064084768,
0.3899366558,
-0.0552380681,
0.0082036043,
0.5152955651,
0.3202514648,
-0.0291428026,
-0.9398006201,
-0.1199529842,
-0.0715449974,
-0.2680862248,
0.1524039507,
-0.0975753292,
-0.0118464753,
-0.0457567349,
0.5444910526,
-0.0358404256,
-0.1873129606,
0.2269611508,
-0.4681327939,
0.2665258944,
0.5732454658,
0.3311591446,
0.7662308216,
-0.10513933,
-0.0167330895,
-0.232984215,
-0.5430858731,
0.4237428606,
0.238460198,
-0.76425457,
0.1582993716,
0.3866806328,
0.7446472645,
0.2822992206,
-0.5551633835,
0.5192222595,
-0.0820008442,
-0.344625622,
-0.1252782047,
0.0034785839,
-0.2720837891,
0.0323584825,
0.1678845137,
0.3456871808,
-0.1131633967,
-0.5073673725,
0.3919168711,
0.1477256268,
-0.6086678505,
-0.3000108004,
0.7536752224,
0.3081343174,
-0.4037080407,
0.4485227466,
-0.0986320153,
-0.5899720788,
0.2565115988,
0.6339496374,
1.0730942488,
-0.0767915472,
0.5137040615,
-0.0242510475,
0.3937688768,
0.0993531868,
0.2406988442,
0.0713325962,
-0.7359516025,
-0.7502154708,
-0.8268861771,
-0.2972998917,
0.0002780897,
-0.5311214328,
-0.0904342085,
-0.6677965522,
0.0313489363,
0.1256089807,
-0.2719915509,
-0.3750215173,
0.5306637883,
0.1189083457,
0.9843098521,
-0.9129155874,
0.7174018025,
0.9961513877,
-0.3927515149,
-0.4424337149,
0.2107529044,
-0.3690878153,
-0.7282280326,
-0.0322847553,
0.3722046614,
0.1216863617,
-0.1964326054,
-0.7590862513,
-0.7226369977,
0.5279990435,
0.4998041391,
-0.3302168846,
-0.2488704175,
0.317401439,
0.3994558156,
-0.7527714372,
-0.0447434522,
0.9438912272,
0.4752714932,
-0.0306446105,
-0.3146184385,
0.0741553977,
-0.1447076052,
0.3035055697,
0.1270529032,
-0.3954533935,
0.4581190348,
0.0833475739,
-0.3546207845,
0.6953100562,
0.7081441283,
0.0261775944,
0.2558031976,
0.8133239746,
0.7361531258,
1.0128513575,
-0.4719530046,
0.9525690675,
-0.3755192459,
-0.0592112392,
0.9685814381,
-0.364092499,
0.6719451547,
0.4641302228,
-0.112289384,
0.5939660072,
0.5291064978,
-0.0955114588,
0.5147755146,
0.1172900721,
-0.1011339948,
-0.6504471302,
-0.4414819777,
-0.1952418834,
0.7696731091,
-0.0817007497,
-0.1247607097,
-0.109959662,
0.0655265227,
0.1956874281,
0.5429774523,
-0.1027247012,
0.7493317723,
0.1662111282,
-0.7015393376,
0.258095324,
0.1825167239,
0.6059361696,
-0.8759662509,
0.3817681372,
-0.2065017819,
0.0915971026,
-0.1589133143,
-0.2662626207,
0.3548623025,
0.1729698926,
-0.2255709469,
-0.0139008621,
0.7526068687,
-0.2719188929,
-0.4541488588,
0.116061002,
0.5992456079,
-0.0885692313,
-0.4093160033,
-0.7617830038,
0.4299805164,
0.3931953013,
0.116181165,
0.2823726237,
0.5624677539,
0.3463389575,
0.5322619677,
0.6285219193,
0.0667538419,
-0.0200036187,
0.269412905,
0.7982491851,
-0.8010423779,
-0.8054451346,
-0.7484308481,
0.55930233,
-0.2485172302,
-0.6913787127,
0.6877837777,
0.68663764,
0.550263226,
0.1683680415,
0.7395128012,
0.0795971975,
0.4246051908,
-0.4901744723,
0.5197399855,
-0.5296605825,
0.083632879,
-0.3296147287,
-1.2112835646,
-0.7239360213,
0.6364668012,
-0.2533204257,
-0.2983731329,
1.1149954796,
0.1761360317,
-0.0488550141,
0.3599595726,
0.3690985143,
0.0110596959,
0.2529972494,
0.2058692425,
0.8198367357,
-0.2015174031,
0.9814534187,
0.0156789385,
-0.0720301867,
0.1869675815,
-0.8647919297,
-0.7027247548,
-0.2787804306,
-0.4003772438,
-0.0542134121,
0.2950212359,
0.7963487506,
0.856934309,
-0.7121564746,
-0.1285681129,
-0.1820061654,
0.1860753745,
0.0184330102,
-0.1834207177,
0.4439971745,
-0.8499119878,
-0.5209303498,
0.8661631942,
0.6401996613,
-0.175889805,
0.3074943125,
0.229404673,
-0.4098287225,
0.3594614565,
0.5566348433,
0.3381994367,
-0.3957564235,
-0.2438810766,
0.0794705823,
0.1957956702,
0.5073772073,
1.0735878944,
-0.1663792282,
0.2227573544,
0.0504048727,
0.8612328172,
0.3254585862,
0.3559553921,
0.4196677804,
-0.9248225093,
0.183693409,
0.3720391095,
0.5845241547,
0.5590983629,
0.1616123021,
0.4596424401,
0.4080252647,
-0.6668314934,
-0.7236680388,
0.4240043163,
-1.1465262175,
-0.4893104434,
0.9741651416,
-0.4588201642,
-0.4154640436,
-0.1389878988,
-0.4173159003,
-0.0732210129,
-0.3192334771,
0.5165342093,
0.4940902591,
0.0615352318,
0.0085739559,
0.2738997638,
0.4368331134,
0.7998093963,
-1.1641762257,
-0.0098069841,
0.67555511,
0.3588399887,
0.0064282962,
0.6124376059,
-0.116153203,
-0.0096817827,
0.0446804166,
-0.1389109194,
0.0766409859,
-0.5412762761,
-0.360340029,
0.6912853718,
-0.1958498806,
-0.2068994343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16674v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16674v1
|
Computational Approaches to the Detection of Lesser-Known Rhetorical Figures: A Systematic Survey and Research Challenges
| 2024-06-24T14:31:34 | 2024-06-24T14:31:34 |
Ramona Kühn, Jelena Mitrović, Michael Granitzer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rhetorical figures play a major role in our everyday communication as they
make text more interesting, more memorable, or more persuasive. Therefore, it
is important to computationally detect rhetorical figures to fully understand
the meaning of a text. We provide a comprehensive overview of computational
approaches to lesser-known rhetorical figures. We explore the linguistic and
computational perspectives on rhetorical figures, emphasizing their
significance for the domain of Natural Language Processing. We present
different figures in detail, delving into datasets, definitions, rhetorical
functions, and detection approaches. We identified challenges such as dataset
scarcity, language limitations, and reliance on rule-based methods.
|
[
-0.714353919,
-0.9011458755,
0.628674984,
0.0325738862,
-0.3842193484,
0.2640109062,
-0.11488159,
-0.7757940292,
0.3354051113,
0.4146398604,
-0.6889025569,
-0.2530455887,
-0.7638847232,
0.3321447968,
-0.24654603,
0.3083221018,
0.2690881193,
0.0210480746,
-0.2761715949,
-0.0895891264,
-0.3138006032,
-0.5873166919,
-0.7001848817,
-0.2796487808,
0.5147234797,
0.2790009975,
0.6252046227,
0.7006216645,
0.627125144,
0.3143473864,
-0.2482260466,
-0.0086700879,
-0.4256432354,
0.3804193437,
-0.2819762826,
-0.3948964775,
0.2206139416,
-0.0533140004,
0.6668372154,
0.9675944448,
0.1547686607,
-0.1104806736,
-0.2408118397,
0.7364272475,
-0.5509620905,
0.2128344625,
-0.5655415654,
0.118680723,
-0.7807630301,
-0.2781454325,
-0.5737969279,
-0.6489120126,
0.0917452872,
-0.5555092096,
0.2870431542,
0.1406994611,
0.5375132561,
0.081145443,
-0.4849324524,
-0.5255528688,
-0.7204958797,
0.8933188915,
-0.4287593663,
0.0616402663,
0.3773463964,
0.4803425968,
-0.2673479915,
-0.7621269226,
-0.3624012172,
-0.1772294641,
-0.3637232482,
-0.2273712158,
-0.8045811057,
-0.0075402143,
0.4471652508,
0.2939266264,
-0.7150890827,
0.064747937,
-0.2616047561,
-0.3965483606,
0.5039483309,
0.1446491927,
0.5413222909,
-0.4414671957,
0.0924451128,
-0.102857016,
-0.7774445415,
-0.147153765,
0.3350614905,
0.2700495422,
-0.0789578632,
0.5027116537,
-0.2208201736,
0.7909536362,
-0.0252618175,
0.2584536672,
-0.2101050168,
-0.1776058078,
0.0898597836,
0.0975757316,
0.6701521277,
-0.3011397719,
0.5232622623,
0.3270991743,
0.1248341128,
0.0239204504,
0.1176498905,
-0.6408339143,
-0.397922039,
-0.2363955081,
-0.5411090255,
-0.1784387827,
-0.2786003351,
-0.6540820003,
-0.9817530513,
-0.3879462779,
-0.289311558,
-0.4107615948,
-0.2041276246,
-0.2366999984,
-0.2628077269,
0.1732649207,
0.430255264,
-0.6203490496,
0.3578761816,
0.8853312135,
0.6975954175,
-0.0259654876,
0.1047427729,
-0.3466727436,
-0.0783304125,
-0.535718143,
1.5125660896,
-1.1288913488,
-0.2901367545,
0.1549967527,
-0.1045219451,
-0.1355200857,
-0.5691694617,
0.9711347222,
-0.3623850942,
0.207848385,
-0.6320358515,
-0.7026430964,
-0.2756182253,
0.2606657445,
-1.0113816261,
0.820769906,
0.1317009032,
-1.0113832951,
-0.0675747693,
-0.7023109794,
-0.5939448476,
0.2737287879,
-0.4839583933,
0.0145880915,
0.5360577106,
0.1031374484,
0.3823480904,
-0.6018231511,
0.0746199787,
-0.0527994037,
-0.2661657929,
0.5518693328,
-0.4958662391,
0.7696380615,
0.3080030382,
-0.2354370058,
-0.0505275019,
-0.6484267712,
-0.0586010963,
0.2845200002,
0.2867482007,
-0.4757130742,
0.1716669351,
0.2843738794,
-0.1306259632,
0.093483083,
-0.3348176181,
0.0580385886,
-0.5832958221,
0.5055912137,
0.4176321626,
0.2853289843,
0.1748643368,
-0.4896247089,
0.8205782771,
-0.3939534724,
-0.2481588721,
-0.3249558508,
-0.9026615024,
-0.2530574799,
-0.4027204514,
0.5086715221,
0.465425998,
-0.83839643,
0.0022422022,
-0.100221239,
-0.6185336709,
-0.0318229795,
-0.360262394,
0.2569952309,
0.4909681678,
-0.0213906989,
0.0100694168,
-0.6674292684,
-1.1310356855,
-0.5017204285,
-0.1143091172,
0.0138202049,
0.1641904712,
0.5874003768,
0.4076377153,
0.9500200748,
-0.6907891035,
-0.1239303872,
-0.1804779768,
0.7029091716,
0.0518717542,
0.3010696471,
0.8825260997,
-0.8322529197,
-0.57725811,
0.0396177843,
-0.5752327442,
-0.2108369917,
-0.1107293442,
0.1508346349,
-0.117711246,
0.611255765,
-0.7193374038,
0.5233942866,
0.0394298807,
0.059798751,
0.5143621564,
0.122801654,
0.4292160571,
-0.5657118559,
0.0269837864,
0.1458091587,
-0.0045465883,
-0.9524687529,
0.0823380277,
-0.1773462147,
-0.046933867,
-0.418615818,
0.3825813532,
-0.4455667436,
-0.0349959061,
-0.4608294666,
0.2817741632,
-0.0455009677,
0.173553437,
0.2890680432,
0.6456477046,
0.5623786449,
-0.430749625,
0.2427256703,
-0.0929292515,
-0.403251946,
1.1469038725,
-0.6592901349,
0.2848569453,
-0.3137535155,
0.3213773668,
-1.2892733812,
-0.402538836,
0.6901625395,
-0.4999917448,
0.1919778883,
-0.373478502,
-0.5528219938,
-0.1555932015,
-0.4813670516,
0.7054675221,
0.2160979658,
-0.2520213723,
0.4146891534,
0.7345632315,
-0.4264257252,
-0.29873088,
-0.643337369,
0.2122113556,
-0.2334282845,
-0.4884056747,
0.3734463453,
0.047219824,
-0.6137216687,
-0.1808855385,
0.1146917045,
-0.2367080748,
-0.2270276695,
0.1299339235,
-0.083034046,
-0.2750554681,
0.1121605188,
0.0231296495,
-0.1442279518,
0.1002310291,
-0.1734284908,
0.4592168033,
0.0333121866,
-0.5114159584,
-0.5126412511,
0.6434344649,
0.4145362079,
0.14503555,
0.2990227044,
0.4126071036,
-1.0032125711,
0.1014881879,
-0.384360522,
-0.0985645056,
-0.4812361598,
0.0390624739,
-0.2168477029,
-0.6807533503,
0.4251175523,
-0.1382844597,
-0.2522135973,
0.6781256795,
0.3927344978,
-0.2005020231,
0.8376925588,
0.3493449688,
-0.0389316604,
0.3534242809,
0.0103290817,
0.2605491281,
-0.390622586,
-0.1083797067,
-1.222247839,
-0.3135301769,
-0.5413401127,
-0.5724414587,
0.0412248187,
-0.4035102725,
0.0013917499,
0.2344013155,
-0.9434078932,
0.6559230685,
0.1301558763,
-0.3917472064,
0.2723075747,
0.3122009635,
-0.0489245243,
-0.5289999843,
-0.434463948,
-0.6052138805,
0.5729691982,
0.1982985139,
0.4105677903,
0.049580548,
0.3775993288,
0.6342418194,
0.1443274468,
-1.0541975498,
0.6046248674,
0.0578460954,
-0.6657212973,
-0.1347274482,
-0.4718488157,
-1.3686548471,
0.2041002959,
0.0093255891,
-1.0082689524,
0.2721546292,
0.0573774651,
-0.0303164627,
0.1598324627,
-0.4524710774,
0.6062500477,
-0.1807193011,
-0.0317934453,
-0.268602699,
-0.4103167057,
0.1916305125,
0.2024345547,
0.6856445074,
-0.0609191693,
-0.0443490259,
0.8563476801,
-0.0306799375,
0.8950592875,
-0.1208328977,
-0.1994287074,
0.7494650483,
0.1535417885,
0.5793568492,
-0.2085319757,
0.0483708829,
0.0802073553,
0.1143363565,
-0.5121452808,
-0.4621564448,
0.6859912872,
-0.2918706834,
-0.2767769396,
-0.7399952412,
-0.3237346113,
-0.2464638054,
0.0683619678,
0.4785766006,
0.3642280698,
-0.5409807563,
0.0697869807,
0.6581436396,
-0.0540162846,
0.3336806595,
0.102634728,
-0.0397826955,
-0.4424931705,
1.0770932436,
0.1574515849,
-0.1450213492,
0.7356883287,
0.278883487,
-0.4222877324,
-0.8732864857,
-0.2000511736,
0.290920198,
-0.9012641907,
0.0751252919,
-0.2085748017,
-0.0334963985,
-0.3175592721,
-0.1910658032,
-0.1706851274,
-0.7196882367,
-0.6080388427,
0.1443561465,
0.4995195866,
1.0909721851,
-0.0791373625,
0.3660112023,
-0.3004343212,
0.3818071783,
0.1472553313,
0.1967803389,
-0.0561773255,
-0.2971359789,
0.2317330092,
0.15794985,
-0.1609981358,
-1.1559200287,
0.2861160338,
0.1225670129,
0.5106045008,
0.386700511,
0.0991206169,
0.5359914303,
-0.3173547387,
0.8268556595,
0.1568610519,
-0.7330316305,
0.5856792927,
-0.6813161373,
0.3522134125,
0.6047682166,
0.5830554366,
-0.6125661731,
0.0297556408,
-0.5346257687,
-0.4708494246,
0.601513207,
0.5366637111,
-0.0828071311,
0.0604525954,
0.2805685699,
0.0003185749,
0.1132059172,
-0.3639338315,
-0.2743156552,
-0.0016692039,
-0.1825328171,
0.0316708721,
0.09992823,
-0.1785566062,
-0.2894311845,
0.4084654152,
-0.2830083072,
0.2215079218,
0.0333833322,
-0.1795894951,
-0.0458352491,
0.405777216,
1.1472452879,
0.6418683529,
0.1032001525,
0.2944204509,
-0.0288209822,
-0.6888200045,
-0.1212651506,
0.1814399064,
-0.1563269347,
0.256462723,
0.3914579749,
0.4265550673,
0.5120612979,
-0.7564681172,
0.2300876677,
-0.2746071219,
-0.1237867177,
-0.4883892536,
-0.4420247674,
0.287076056,
0.0678881034,
0.654958427,
0.3714745343,
0.4130794406,
-0.6245946288,
0.1505170316,
0.6578779221,
-0.3543023169,
-0.4158983231,
0.2012219578,
-0.0647586063,
-0.5354380012,
-0.0039107194,
-0.3774518371,
-0.6038511992,
0.8765996099,
0.419736743,
0.5813059807,
0.2117984444,
0.6547582746,
0.0839560628,
0.2823949456,
0.0307920147,
0.1261136234,
-0.0617035404,
-0.310770154,
-0.1563845426,
-0.1433471441,
-0.8561668992,
0.2884138823,
-0.4612130523,
0.1494022757,
-0.5980507135,
-0.1871380508,
0.6432539225,
0.0140412068,
-0.4163708687,
-0.1938108951,
0.5033108592,
0.6127970219,
-0.5038571954,
0.3527544141,
0.807687223,
-0.0625526458,
-0.3820495605,
-0.1734210551,
0.5213139057,
-0.4352224171,
0.4277506173,
-0.0463060923,
-0.5192286968,
-0.1929128766,
-0.7740399241,
-0.7537348866,
0.4376009107,
0.7336685061,
-0.3172666132,
0.1878955811,
0.3901444376,
0.6972394586,
-0.5400518775,
0.5645709038,
0.5610696673,
0.7858194709,
0.4716305733,
-0.5814321041,
0.0580585301,
-0.3113065064,
-0.0965544432,
0.2342718989,
-0.2812989652,
0.9449439049,
0.2179755419,
-0.5008031726,
0.1957386434,
0.6099829078,
0.5835665464,
0.7095504999,
0.2313411385,
0.0515391417,
0.9575986862,
-0.2481598854,
0.8088645935,
0.0130953621,
0.3082177937,
0.9385507107,
-0.2650562227,
0.6417005062,
0.2513917387,
-0.3296526074,
0.5869705081,
0.7805374861,
0.0768322051,
0.1193805784,
0.5114819407,
-0.2105579525,
-0.2874638438,
-0.400742054,
-0.5579397082,
0.4573889077,
0.7676695585,
-0.1326771677,
-0.4381349683,
0.0208064225,
-0.0554282404,
0.5892270803,
-0.2350483537,
0.4661278427,
0.1022355333,
-0.5844599605,
0.7374233007,
-0.0732398555,
0.6035655141,
-0.3939231038,
-0.4039123058,
0.2049099356,
-0.1896038353,
-0.108468309,
-0.684533596,
0.4258372188,
0.0153225651,
0.0552387312,
-0.2683213651,
1.4459135532,
0.0937682465,
-0.538683176,
-0.147575438,
0.4652196169,
0.2623515725,
-0.3615701497,
-0.6207029223,
0.2274362594,
-0.162012741,
-0.0203067213,
0.3267069757,
0.4775945246,
-0.040448498,
0.5877890587,
0.4381029606,
-0.0714208633,
0.0749361068,
0.0396200679,
0.6647337079,
-0.7451957464,
-0.4213416278,
-0.6517112255,
0.0803546533,
-0.3247904181,
-0.273016274,
0.555708468,
0.4165196717,
0.453223139,
-0.2844709456,
0.8002601862,
-0.0787471458,
0.5486995578,
-0.3644090593,
0.8736826181,
-0.2094056606,
0.2864469588,
-0.3854780197,
-0.4891756177,
-0.3171642721,
0.7654776573,
-0.5085477233,
-0.0708120167,
0.6999504566,
0.4418893158,
0.0720877424,
0.7727037072,
0.1346220374,
-0.0697839931,
0.1484934837,
0.3423800468,
1.3219671249,
-0.2786752582,
0.5913347602,
-0.3846619129,
0.0919235945,
-0.184083119,
-0.9958157539,
-0.9353350997,
-0.8714945912,
-0.6591275334,
0.3174134195,
-0.314548403,
0.7083315849,
0.6908730865,
-0.9504094124,
-0.2143429369,
-0.2666998208,
0.653842926,
-0.1704107225,
-0.2775150537,
0.1908152401,
-0.0194082223,
-0.6169245839,
0.5654569864,
0.3786258399,
0.063732557,
-0.1038571969,
0.2582737207,
-0.4217179716,
0.5781015754,
0.5574628711,
0.7534834146,
-0.6544524431,
-0.3711530566,
-0.0666745678,
-0.0442617163,
0.2058620751,
1.513202548,
-0.941898644,
0.0628150031,
0.8306961656,
0.419339776,
0.3719957471,
0.0026463263,
0.0934547335,
-0.7402373552,
0.0928956494,
0.681258142,
0.29694435,
0.41123873,
-0.4733668268,
0.4263114631,
0.4254156351,
-0.2312190086,
-1.0341044664,
0.5419562459,
-1.2193938494,
-0.3951841891,
0.5967285037,
0.129591465,
-0.2448636442,
-0.5371193886,
-0.4392699301,
-0.1076138169,
-0.2958170772,
0.3723631501,
0.7735210061,
-0.4954133034,
-0.3816034496,
-0.470043689,
0.6505832672,
0.1622400284,
-1.0625349283,
0.0997861773,
0.6799581051,
0.0051175277,
0.5103632808,
0.6529423594,
0.0031704626,
0.3417238295,
0.0583562665,
-0.6247548461,
0.3104904294,
-0.2058146,
-0.2970169187,
0.7134712338,
0.090925701,
0.194258526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16672v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16672v1
|
CAVE: Controllable Authorship Verification Explanations
| 2024-06-24T14:27:54 | 2024-06-24T14:27:54 |
Sahana Ramnath, Kartik Pandey, Elizabeth Boschee, Xiang Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Authorship Verification (AV) (do two documents have the same author?) is
essential for many sensitive real-life applications. AV is often used in
proprietary domains that require a private, offline model, making SOTA online
models like ChatGPT undesirable. Other SOTA systems use methods, e.g. Siamese
Networks, that are uninterpretable, and hence cannot be trusted in high-stakes
applications. In this work, we take the first step to address the above
challenges with our model CAVE (Controllable Authorship Verification
Explanations): CAVE generates free-text AV explanations that are controlled to
be 1) structured (can be decomposed into sub-explanations with respect to
relevant linguistic features), and 2) easily verified for explanation-label
consistency (via intermediate labels in sub-explanations). In this work, we
train a Llama-3-8B as CAVE; since there are no human-written corpora for AV
explanations, we sample silver-standard explanations from GPT-4-TURBO and
distill them into a pretrained Llama-3-8B. Results on three difficult AV
datasets IMdB2, Blog-Auth, and FanFiction show that CAVE generates high quality
explanations (as measured by automatic and human evaluation) as well as
competitive task accuracies.
|
[
0.0293163471,
-0.5170358419,
0.6193861365,
0.265779078,
-0.3082043529,
-0.0293473806,
-0.1102603003,
-0.5494328141,
0.0587610379,
0.6452355385,
-0.6316516399,
-0.3955898285,
-0.8812742829,
0.406288445,
-0.1823851615,
1.2061191797,
-0.4776749611,
-0.1383750737,
-0.3655866086,
-0.1652614772,
-0.4170581698,
-0.2766575217,
-0.6883023977,
-0.3475129008,
0.5422244072,
0.1164195463,
0.4649634361,
0.7627081871,
0.3412622511,
0.227156058,
0.0029594656,
0.264329493,
-0.7271429896,
0.1282014102,
-0.1567521095,
-0.4645544291,
-0.4744807184,
-0.0774861872,
0.2150014043,
0.2168556899,
0.0439612791,
0.1228108257,
-0.1356328577,
0.3571434915,
-0.5883216858,
0.3248816431,
-0.4561268985,
-0.0352593064,
-0.1153474972,
-0.4167305529,
-0.5931286812,
-0.5529836416,
0.0032720349,
-0.9045182467,
0.2481721938,
0.042646274,
0.8610826135,
0.5913978219,
-0.4603588283,
-0.5641970634,
-0.7228862047,
0.6235860586,
-0.4076594412,
-0.0362327918,
0.5187886953,
0.408264637,
-0.0246309619,
-0.7118560672,
-0.6210880876,
-0.0767630786,
-0.3366945386,
0.1097313017,
-0.0836557299,
-0.0659194216,
-0.0573507436,
0.1940224618,
-0.5608345866,
0.1022345498,
-0.4126295149,
-0.3663905859,
0.8145756125,
-0.1410856545,
0.1906488538,
0.0961848423,
-0.5322434306,
0.054461278,
-1.1881130934,
0.303842783,
0.4185704291,
0.0855435729,
-0.0139315175,
0.7669314742,
0.1013636589,
0.4021508992,
0.1127772033,
0.0215224437,
-0.139601782,
-0.1667508185,
-0.0617200024,
0.3353603184,
0.7080269456,
-0.0025981404,
0.3450427055,
-0.3229317069,
-0.1055848897,
-0.00477533,
0.1270350218,
-0.6457625628,
-0.2258665711,
0.4183422923,
-0.2131468952,
-0.408867538,
0.0400731638,
-0.5054678321,
-0.8242510557,
-0.1535240561,
0.7977606654,
-0.0298196152,
-0.3976871669,
0.0496727005,
0.0153987901,
0.1348236799,
0.553026855,
-0.630032897,
0.2585893571,
0.6295092702,
0.6153270006,
-0.1729961187,
-0.2675439417,
-0.9248501062,
0.2003787458,
-0.4503014386,
0.3532284498,
-0.3581745625,
-0.0179613121,
-0.1455748528,
-0.1312876195,
-0.0277141463,
-0.2066452652,
-0.0269084256,
-0.7072736621,
0.2800987065,
-0.2704296708,
-0.4207912087,
-0.2533175647,
0.1499058306,
-0.5298429132,
0.706302166,
-0.0946394727,
-0.8716387153,
0.3159152269,
-0.7144418955,
-0.1265883744,
0.0894492641,
-0.386788398,
-0.3297995925,
-0.2867935896,
0.3727598786,
0.5371398926,
-0.063694872,
0.3746915162,
0.2237305641,
-0.4227153957,
0.1596963853,
0.1497271061,
1.0343332291,
0.0786530748,
-0.8189404607,
0.1768175066,
-0.6414306164,
-0.3762279451,
0.1926764697,
-0.3058787882,
-0.2817622721,
-0.0945775658,
-0.5314840674,
-0.2138275802,
0.4462003708,
-0.5851731896,
0.0712008625,
0.1459487826,
0.3226230741,
0.9157881737,
0.0495308526,
0.1198011115,
-0.1965454519,
0.8236235976,
-0.1154579967,
0.0552999303,
-0.198928535,
-0.6973041296,
-0.3423582613,
-0.7407479882,
0.3508576155,
0.6575254798,
-0.6090295911,
0.1450059265,
-0.2002171427,
-0.45331949,
-0.5534305573,
0.1769324392,
0.7409818769,
0.4265222847,
0.3204612732,
-0.188326031,
-0.367972672,
-0.6175056696,
-0.4699026048,
-0.088505961,
-0.3022710979,
0.7177832127,
0.5081573129,
-0.2692605853,
1.0728350878,
-0.2437630147,
-0.3078892529,
-0.0704282373,
0.3383722007,
0.1500964612,
0.4660442472,
0.3417780995,
-0.9710710645,
-0.303080529,
-0.0225369632,
-1.0054298639,
-0.2776637673,
-0.2226461321,
-0.1468556225,
-0.1518811733,
0.7446790934,
-0.7131945491,
0.5195102692,
0.533206284,
-0.5304315686,
0.6362430453,
-0.2576408982,
0.0969917625,
-0.7759977579,
0.1014557183,
-0.201068446,
-0.5668303967,
-0.313564539,
0.3657156527,
-0.1881688684,
0.0923905373,
-0.3806279004,
0.4860903621,
-0.4556783736,
0.1119249314,
0.1413530409,
0.290482074,
-0.0029790681,
0.7737679482,
-0.1231131181,
0.6087787747,
0.7125219703,
-0.6106638908,
0.3452720642,
0.3823156655,
-0.2143494636,
0.3305762708,
-0.9184439778,
0.3918577433,
-0.3336421251,
0.5999364853,
-1.2045154572,
-0.4892275631,
0.2402370274,
-0.5443359017,
0.2624239028,
-0.3694961369,
-0.3930614591,
0.195422098,
-0.0311722532,
0.4482192099,
0.4375497401,
-0.6647797823,
0.77810359,
0.2111033797,
-0.3693714738,
-0.844468832,
-0.6600115299,
-0.0560331456,
-0.1783338636,
-0.5255814791,
0.1223866269,
-0.1366910189,
-0.4532489181,
0.0883555636,
-0.2203191966,
-0.3033742309,
0.1046689302,
0.5828123093,
0.2422321141,
-0.209889859,
0.0073342989,
0.2332732826,
-0.0704998299,
-0.0269766543,
-0.0772294328,
-0.0432046242,
-0.1882662624,
-0.1288127154,
-0.5651109219,
0.3806490004,
0.614880383,
-0.3616105914,
0.8490874171,
0.3449118435,
-0.3703091741,
0.0141504249,
-0.3626332879,
-0.1136850491,
-0.4137404263,
-0.3118678927,
-0.4458198547,
-1.2786282301,
0.6779530048,
-0.0767860487,
0.2616541982,
0.5891965032,
0.5857740641,
0.134325102,
0.9311630726,
0.5881783366,
0.2985241115,
-0.0142209353,
-0.236947909,
0.2948418558,
-0.6201314926,
-0.46348387,
-0.5179098248,
-0.1446429789,
-0.5044522882,
-0.2248597592,
0.2750644982,
0.0522704758,
-0.2421295494,
0.6352886558,
-0.6182513833,
0.8275750875,
0.5623122454,
0.0576365404,
0.5249893665,
-0.3559791148,
-0.0347680226,
0.1612319201,
-0.3652448058,
-0.7560001612,
0.987596333,
0.3262298405,
0.8075497746,
0.4210972786,
0.8480527401,
0.6063860655,
0.2614888549,
-0.3065409362,
0.438500315,
0.0257087331,
-0.9823106527,
-0.5380104184,
-0.4183156192,
-0.9764240384,
0.1990441531,
-0.1424558759,
-1.0363429785,
0.2062748969,
0.3975740373,
-0.5812094808,
0.0810926259,
-0.7069058418,
0.6393277049,
0.1055879593,
-0.4358323812,
-0.0121250954,
-0.9458175898,
0.5756617785,
-0.2373188585,
0.3587809801,
0.0810181201,
0.1539374888,
0.719358623,
-0.5035600066,
0.9099699259,
-0.3927346468,
-0.1114831194,
0.2297206372,
0.5266386867,
0.744197309,
0.3206670284,
-0.0886413231,
0.3128558099,
-0.0359740108,
-0.3114711046,
-0.3367596269,
0.7188267112,
-0.9779735208,
-0.5157412291,
-0.3100230396,
-0.2907203138,
0.0898355916,
0.3772626519,
0.5838972926,
0.3960752189,
0.0314639434,
0.4023762941,
0.8787922859,
-0.2040767521,
-0.1524007767,
0.1901891083,
0.0922907516,
-0.1030103341,
0.7115284204,
-0.1388260424,
-0.0383455269,
0.6113005877,
0.357023865,
-0.2592943609,
-0.4473924935,
-0.564427495,
0.2590079904,
-0.6917918324,
0.0251786932,
-0.7574605346,
-0.0933625624,
-0.2492272258,
-0.4455328286,
-0.2535375655,
-0.5379135609,
-0.2725118101,
-0.2695055306,
0.3122168779,
1.0288761854,
-0.033226233,
0.4942212403,
-0.3110040724,
0.6168151498,
0.6450394988,
0.2565956712,
-0.2563337386,
-0.3860696852,
-0.026087014,
0.0681095496,
0.0024391459,
-0.9065802693,
-0.0535647832,
0.3071193099,
0.4731308222,
0.4151574373,
0.1398029923,
0.251876086,
-0.360290736,
0.984911561,
-0.1258853376,
-0.9978116751,
0.5841293335,
-0.5014328957,
-0.2202810496,
0.5640303493,
0.4749403298,
-0.1141165122,
-0.6804044843,
-0.6871961951,
-0.7793180346,
0.8615359068,
0.5616551638,
-0.0627762303,
0.4376191199,
0.5005754828,
0.6510302424,
0.3059846163,
-1.0338383913,
0.0856472403,
-0.3388203084,
0.0048660715,
-0.1962655038,
-0.1687626839,
-0.6448399425,
0.2501572669,
0.7718624473,
0.0519388728,
0.1902164072,
0.4154134095,
-0.2882491648,
-0.1510090083,
-0.0713101476,
0.8035158515,
0.9734292626,
-0.2310717404,
0.4646385908,
-0.2144643068,
-0.3128598928,
0.0744458213,
-0.1213876531,
0.0042604571,
0.0482517257,
0.7064922452,
0.7513757348,
-0.2351963967,
-0.4741748869,
0.8878068328,
-0.3158853352,
-0.4579785764,
-0.2535037696,
0.185115993,
0.1104297861,
0.246705696,
0.2729488611,
0.1167966202,
-0.1441857964,
-0.1527525783,
-0.0906491801,
0.0440259576,
-0.3229142427,
-0.3433268964,
1.0881903172,
0.1802087426,
-0.3511339128,
0.4351423681,
-0.2016867399,
-0.3360034525,
0.7337486744,
0.3327765465,
0.8215869069,
-0.0950862616,
0.2872716784,
0.2720191181,
0.4944666922,
-0.0606627129,
0.092116721,
-0.4898090363,
-0.5325477719,
-0.47914958,
-0.2856996059,
-0.8341934681,
0.0186054669,
-0.5724125504,
0.0016979715,
-0.55532974,
0.3640267551,
0.1086884364,
-0.2589695156,
-0.6079852581,
0.2879279256,
-0.1709581017,
0.7585629821,
-1.134835124,
0.3025134206,
0.4275535047,
-0.2761621475,
-0.9999160767,
-0.2370875627,
0.2126642615,
-0.986941874,
0.4416163266,
0.2894419134,
-0.4475956857,
0.1381806433,
-1.0386588573,
-0.4972138703,
1.2620817423,
0.5393497348,
-0.1974470764,
0.249592483,
-0.3899805546,
0.6325699687,
-0.2932900786,
-0.0127682257,
0.1372726709,
0.5136309266,
0.2567566931,
-0.7840326428,
0.2696400881,
-0.3088239133,
-0.44933635,
-0.1794755012,
-0.4413483739,
0.7636714578,
-0.3506831229,
-0.0454488322,
-0.0260308925,
0.4638287425,
0.6345197558,
0.4649915397,
0.7164795995,
0.2402852774,
0.9258034825,
-0.0595700257,
1.1159361601,
-0.0641139373,
0.1611050665,
1.1163518429,
-0.129765898,
0.5083594918,
0.4861630499,
0.0384757631,
0.7385345101,
0.8582604527,
0.2710904181,
0.5490326285,
0.2966490686,
-0.1502433568,
-0.403986603,
-0.0630669668,
-0.3649918437,
0.6257495284,
0.0253836177,
-0.2531168163,
0.0788284168,
-0.1521776915,
0.1913655251,
-0.1116416603,
-0.1354992986,
0.7269442081,
-0.0050438144,
-0.9715934396,
0.4612847865,
-0.1370050311,
0.3133873343,
-0.7585331202,
-0.0426123664,
-0.2197909355,
0.2397944778,
-0.3211379647,
-0.4567281902,
0.0671452358,
0.4269680381,
0.0590606928,
-0.4229611158,
0.4364760518,
-0.4573145211,
-0.1045547649,
-0.0988938957,
0.2569459677,
0.7610353231,
-0.0551379807,
-0.1587214321,
-0.1868789643,
-0.034591157,
-0.4460959136,
-0.1569598466,
0.5896049142,
-0.3736525774,
0.7226327658,
0.5493494868,
0.1990962625,
0.2060643882,
-0.1415662467,
0.6225845218,
-0.1258937716,
-0.8098761439,
-0.7909415364,
0.5239694118,
0.1142745614,
-0.364520669,
0.493439585,
0.4528849125,
0.6533702016,
-0.1244067401,
0.8865750432,
-0.2176001668,
0.3217952549,
-0.5657768846,
0.8366554976,
-0.7432275414,
0.1697741002,
-0.2302877754,
-0.7499544621,
-0.440948993,
0.5091186762,
0.0894067883,
-0.0247803703,
0.7199100852,
0.8502539396,
-0.0906885862,
-0.1005156934,
-0.0423866101,
0.3575093746,
0.5384936333,
0.4435495436,
0.5825865269,
-0.2716431618,
0.6762184501,
0.0336388312,
-0.6981090307,
-0.4622215629,
-1.2676355839,
-0.8811047673,
-0.5905257463,
-0.5125131607,
-0.3058435619,
0.0364767946,
0.4773864746,
0.8464810252,
-0.7941390276,
0.0152495131,
-0.224961251,
0.4156786203,
-0.5011839867,
-0.1380430311,
0.564268887,
0.3083066046,
-0.448313117,
0.4127490222,
0.234518975,
-0.0419617444,
-0.2970188558,
-0.3439077437,
0.0199399386,
0.3341296911,
0.1897122562,
0.4566676915,
-0.8070634007,
-0.2992596626,
0.0437369607,
-0.1487965584,
-0.083818987,
0.933807373,
-0.4703455269,
0.8095796704,
0.5159900188,
0.5554910898,
0.6689504385,
0.1982733756,
0.5765370727,
-0.8359669447,
-0.1150297523,
0.1607035249,
0.2315734774,
0.3756541312,
-0.9007722735,
0.6862574816,
0.0683758259,
-0.8109041452,
-0.8720952868,
0.093422763,
-1.1375596523,
0.0046890504,
1.1071749926,
-0.5913060308,
-0.1059122384,
-0.14514561,
-0.2920009494,
0.499944061,
-0.1369369924,
1.0932465792,
0.7971770763,
-0.2659558356,
-0.0689691454,
-0.292003572,
0.5241624713,
0.1186707392,
-0.6614257693,
0.148104459,
0.2045615911,
0.2115785331,
0.221146211,
1.0070428848,
-0.1515369415,
0.4818148315,
0.0507888123,
0.129670158,
-0.5610269904,
-0.6516601443,
-0.1415026039,
0.0074591753,
-0.0379544646,
-0.4044108689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16655v1
|
Large Language Models Are Cross-Lingual Knowledge-Free Reasoners
| 2024-06-24T14:03:04 | 2024-06-24T14:03:04 |
Peng Hu, Sizhe Liu, Changjiang Gao, Xin Huang, Xue Han, Junlan Feng, Chao Deng, Shujian Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models have demonstrated impressive reasoning capabilities
across multiple languages. However, the relationship between capabilities in
different languages is less explored. In this work, we decompose the process of
reasoning tasks into two separated parts: knowledge retrieval and
knowledge-free reasoning, and analyze the cross-lingual transferability of
them. With adapted and constructed knowledge-free reasoning datasets, we show
that the knowledge-free reasoning capability can be nearly perfectly
transferred across various source-target language directions despite the
secondary impact of resource in some specific target languages, while
cross-lingual knowledge retrieval significantly hinders the transfer. Moreover,
by analyzing the hidden states and feed-forward network neuron activation
during the reasoning tasks, we show that higher similarity of hidden
representations and larger overlap of activated neurons could explain the
better cross-lingual transferability of knowledge-free reasoning than knowledge
retrieval. Thus, we hypothesize that knowledge-free reasoning embeds in some
language-shared mechanism, while knowledge is stored separately in different
languages.
|
[
-0.2025901973,
-0.3338487744,
0.8143795729,
0.187034741,
0.1159375012,
-0.1692903638,
-0.4928600192,
-0.7128592134,
0.1258907616,
0.3675933778,
-0.173040092,
0.0808508173,
-0.6070686579,
-0.0749157742,
-0.3609692752,
0.6182360053,
-0.3237800598,
0.0000136366,
-0.3493868113,
-0.2744897604,
-0.2929328084,
-0.4552111328,
-0.5069358945,
-0.6840025187,
0.704867661,
0.0539776906,
0.7186074257,
0.2489501387,
0.0534830093,
0.2090814561,
-0.1403509974,
-0.0385037772,
-0.1845697612,
0.0624195896,
-1.0230371952,
-0.6884744763,
-0.100795038,
-0.3620027304,
0.5548316836,
0.7996971607,
0.1683339477,
-0.0898314044,
0.0679416582,
0.4389725327,
-0.5930127501,
0.374110043,
-0.6167476177,
-0.145657599,
0.1506132036,
-0.0357137211,
-0.471150279,
-0.1930543482,
0.2964259982,
-0.78908813,
0.0378756225,
-0.1111673489,
0.8265398145,
0.0066610659,
-0.4509161115,
-0.2408276498,
-0.5354422331,
0.7163895369,
-0.3807910979,
0.5519637465,
0.4998035729,
0.2882809639,
0.2764062285,
-0.3696250916,
-0.5916451812,
-0.263741225,
-0.3659439087,
-0.3703688681,
-0.5208120942,
-0.1880383939,
0.3003788292,
0.0968552977,
-0.4334466755,
0.0214643739,
-0.4129982591,
-0.3759815097,
0.6573033929,
-0.3861481249,
0.6896293759,
-0.1458750665,
-0.3185248077,
-0.1002024561,
-0.6220697165,
0.0275747124,
0.1285816729,
0.4018295705,
-0.1072732732,
0.4802596867,
-0.2475567013,
0.5164417624,
-0.2706434131,
0.1977889538,
0.0549559332,
-0.4550617933,
-0.0470862612,
0.0539869368,
0.8087625504,
0.1332875788,
0.6851478815,
-0.5633279085,
-0.148172155,
-0.2570043206,
-0.0591629148,
-0.4625776112,
-0.1127117053,
-0.1884348094,
-0.4541801214,
0.2971409857,
-0.3663460314,
-0.3961735368,
-0.1983309537,
-0.279835999,
0.6715149879,
-0.5583714247,
-0.6722331643,
0.264220655,
-0.2066320181,
0.3362804651,
0.2290971875,
-1.0584305525,
0.1573467702,
0.7641559243,
0.6667259932,
-0.2997127175,
-0.4574863911,
-0.2342720032,
0.2494391948,
-0.5001369715,
0.6435142159,
-0.3749678433,
-0.0161971357,
-0.0763191208,
0.361830771,
-0.5788619518,
-0.4634596705,
0.1108046621,
-0.7990025878,
0.0214906689,
-0.8334627748,
-0.3231975734,
-0.7751618624,
0.2244431078,
-0.779840827,
0.5437880754,
-0.0598148853,
-0.7045978904,
0.2511672974,
-0.3847005665,
-0.7007504702,
-0.0978977084,
-0.096558027,
0.4268752038,
0.1049584225,
0.2325982898,
0.4308772683,
-0.4938622415,
0.2838688791,
-0.2939074337,
-0.1574303508,
0.3765423,
-0.322960794,
1.1812900305,
0.0121760927,
-0.4263114333,
0.0963575616,
-0.4788708389,
0.1911232024,
0.0487595648,
-0.2282175571,
-0.7473160625,
-0.1930909902,
-0.4121715724,
0.4874841571,
0.2085892558,
-0.5636911392,
0.1017759666,
-0.1726195514,
0.4590927064,
0.3484567106,
-0.1126755178,
0.806032896,
-0.2384411991,
0.2225117683,
0.1397709399,
-0.1966274232,
0.2516847253,
-0.5419830084,
-0.7612404823,
0.0402157381,
0.2505196035,
0.7990252972,
-1.0739063025,
-0.1571478397,
-0.4990333617,
-0.2596257329,
-0.3077305853,
-0.0183925033,
0.5158830285,
0.2046676427,
0.500559032,
0.0028102419,
-0.0374070518,
-1.0986235142,
-0.3969368935,
-0.0450192802,
0.0840051174,
0.2161627114,
0.5819420815,
0.1482211202,
0.3833773434,
-0.1008482873,
0.0576437749,
-0.563226819,
-0.0840239748,
0.0635139048,
0.5600831509,
0.6213360429,
-0.5265961885,
-0.3660096824,
0.5498110652,
-0.9053512216,
0.0343659967,
-0.3414111435,
-0.424746573,
0.2512103617,
0.4284943044,
-0.8566355705,
0.2739365101,
0.4253614545,
-0.4172905684,
0.4600680172,
-0.2893970311,
0.1713359654,
-0.7949334383,
0.1961977035,
-0.2822716534,
0.172535494,
-0.5102074146,
0.1634732038,
0.1133222654,
0.0737876371,
-0.3843329847,
0.9487951994,
-0.6680624485,
-0.3889679015,
-0.1752275229,
0.137469396,
0.1762054414,
0.5581470132,
0.1928146929,
0.5117648244,
0.9432471991,
-0.6428833604,
0.3993763626,
0.1103575751,
-0.5342882276,
0.4118454754,
-0.6363703012,
-0.1165251955,
0.0417973474,
-0.1598388702,
-0.6144794226,
0.0567787029,
0.1004942358,
-0.4339261353,
0.1752651036,
-0.18003048,
-0.5313636065,
0.0945643187,
0.3968711495,
0.6220262051,
0.2593087256,
-0.5473505259,
0.5944583416,
0.00702783,
-0.1209504604,
-0.6582030058,
-1.1241241693,
-0.1810923964,
0.081211336,
-0.7406027317,
0.2313856184,
0.3127444088,
-0.4587317705,
0.4596492052,
-0.0458780453,
-0.1970989108,
-0.1475538164,
-0.0238932632,
0.1379595399,
-0.3136282563,
0.3926135302,
0.2092524469,
-0.0545289665,
0.2075843364,
-0.5233413577,
0.3245965838,
0.031740088,
-0.6176452637,
-0.1702505052,
0.648244679,
0.7744575739,
-0.442866385,
1.0598289967,
0.3568351567,
-0.3402832448,
-0.3659127653,
-0.2780152559,
-0.0790071562,
-0.3280408382,
0.2338430583,
-0.72330302,
-0.9187853932,
0.7817400694,
0.2787026465,
-0.0043730955,
0.4628456831,
0.3442602754,
0.4191420376,
0.8079693317,
0.458412528,
0.1513120532,
0.1599960774,
-0.2483172268,
0.3761741817,
-0.6370327473,
-0.5366893411,
-0.3678337932,
-0.2777695954,
-0.3878032863,
-0.6758172512,
-0.1868683398,
0.3083080053,
-0.3649107814,
0.4148832858,
-0.1980288178,
0.4711016119,
0.7047458887,
-0.147432819,
0.3158679903,
0.1499708295,
-0.6213701963,
0.1235347614,
-0.8766716123,
0.0690793768,
0.6384000778,
0.0638167262,
0.621712327,
0.1851620078,
0.2739026546,
-0.1732347608,
-0.1263802648,
-0.8737163544,
0.7135498524,
-0.4355393946,
-0.6739264131,
-0.1844704747,
-0.606153965,
-0.806497097,
0.5965794921,
-0.1672189832,
-0.9435034394,
0.3951638341,
-0.3103352487,
-0.0659741759,
0.9260442257,
-0.6995657086,
0.7297710776,
-0.4703316092,
-0.4917857647,
-0.41690135,
-0.4309384525,
0.3532232046,
0.1591612697,
0.2100212127,
-0.148697868,
0.228182584,
0.6427490711,
0.0324181467,
0.5158478618,
-0.1401790828,
-0.2907107174,
0.2774400413,
0.6092649102,
0.0778910816,
-0.2151866704,
-0.1672209203,
0.3634083271,
0.0355301127,
-0.3638227284,
-0.8869131207,
0.7049303651,
-0.6943172812,
-0.8555998206,
-0.1865980178,
-0.9424857497,
-0.167427659,
0.4138784409,
0.1565516591,
0.1882211864,
0.3023823202,
0.2273551524,
0.6539119482,
-0.3908008933,
0.4101341069,
0.3408558965,
-0.5036685467,
-0.055879388,
0.969289124,
0.359700799,
0.4907846451,
0.7459246516,
0.0445331521,
-0.2885899246,
-0.3019315004,
-0.3835480213,
0.4540367424,
-0.8621233702,
0.2810839117,
-0.5228209496,
-0.2786658406,
-0.2820110321,
-0.2659484148,
-0.3745719194,
-0.7311986685,
-0.1105160415,
-0.1551921219,
0.2089139968,
0.4382377863,
-0.4435344636,
-0.2669023871,
-0.911192596,
0.3357224464,
0.5861285925,
0.398756206,
0.5003667474,
-0.3445787132,
-0.1507252008,
0.1135921627,
0.337118715,
-0.9604073167,
0.351791352,
-0.0582896471,
1.0042681694,
0.1658070385,
-0.0526120029,
0.3029225767,
-0.1834152192,
0.6908376813,
0.2891554236,
-0.9682093263,
0.2562949955,
-0.2174502164,
0.3109682798,
0.1517282724,
0.6435548067,
-0.5333488584,
0.0740201771,
-0.3834134042,
-0.6206147075,
0.7654879689,
-0.0518443324,
-0.0246623103,
0.0398244001,
0.0829957351,
0.1696777344,
-0.227172181,
-0.6811800599,
0.1762804985,
-0.157177642,
0.3967152536,
0.1182263345,
0.0371519923,
-0.327106297,
-0.3747875392,
0.5647054315,
-0.1822810769,
0.3711683452,
0.1800406575,
-0.2529782951,
0.1155250743,
0.5856004953,
0.2154557109,
0.534271121,
0.3765731752,
0.3619578481,
0.25195539,
-0.0234686881,
0.1798410863,
0.166014865,
-0.1900554001,
-0.1169368625,
0.5598367453,
1.0676921606,
0.262547493,
-0.4849979877,
0.4423007369,
0.0115698222,
-0.6197371483,
0.1248278469,
0.0357703231,
0.4699770212,
0.6747294664,
0.2264334857,
0.0605017096,
-0.0851228982,
-0.5401643515,
0.0744628757,
0.3882946968,
-0.3142771125,
-0.4141155183,
0.5524566174,
-0.2258838564,
0.0626073554,
0.8028264642,
-0.2948116958,
-0.6150696278,
0.4982984364,
0.6356837749,
0.7667704225,
-0.00818979,
0.3835982382,
0.4661098123,
0.3499943018,
-0.3127643764,
0.3709698915,
-0.3446830213,
-1.0401492119,
-0.763266325,
-0.4333634675,
-0.0712478161,
-0.03017487,
-0.652657032,
-0.3186002076,
-0.1238395423,
0.1442908943,
-0.028358601,
-0.2916572392,
-0.6082891226,
-0.050409846,
0.1646372825,
0.9373357892,
-0.6767635942,
0.9288913012,
0.6797827482,
-0.3877311349,
-1.2687641382,
-0.1319868118,
-0.2938770056,
-0.8692701459,
1.0341128111,
0.0353969522,
-0.234995693,
-0.3631289005,
-0.1602935046,
-1.0686700344,
0.8351587653,
0.6448398829,
-0.4157208204,
-0.2854942381,
0.1690633446,
0.5320190787,
-0.101600267,
-0.0916449577,
0.4035708308,
0.401162535,
0.2405115962,
-1.4209034443,
0.5225346684,
-0.2733251154,
-0.1987692863,
0.2003934979,
-0.4709396958,
1.0644614697,
-0.4197843373,
-0.2949032485,
-0.2457285523,
0.2821910977,
0.0912370458,
0.0204870757,
0.3194426,
0.7594623566,
0.6294618249,
-0.1101076379,
1.0770299435,
-0.2415650189,
0.059824612,
0.7971255779,
-0.2397240996,
0.8513297439,
0.3576447368,
0.1648677737,
0.846536696,
0.0658397824,
0.1596043855,
0.5138334036,
0.1665103883,
-0.2636685967,
-0.5875913501,
-0.1007467881,
-0.3389261961,
0.4930422008,
0.4356839359,
-0.4737887084,
-0.3075227439,
0.0891441628,
0.1462959945,
-0.1791869551,
-0.5491114259,
0.5063952804,
0.2553695738,
-1.1431792974,
0.8224551082,
-0.3571934998,
0.4862042665,
-0.4623266459,
-0.0050245463,
-0.0619468503,
0.1842315197,
-0.3018116951,
-1.1839962006,
0.5818144083,
-0.228054598,
-0.2889235318,
-0.3780865967,
1.0698342323,
-0.5196620822,
0.0046960423,
1.0048223734,
1.0602293015,
0.2115322798,
-0.081086956,
-0.5820636749,
-0.4136760831,
0.135576427,
-0.3038363457,
0.6172710061,
0.6654215455,
-0.5222423077,
0.7239233255,
0.712503612,
0.4119709134,
0.206054762,
0.207044825,
0.6477717757,
-0.6477705836,
-0.4476737082,
-0.528006196,
0.1984306872,
0.1724886447,
0.0818168893,
0.6617580652,
0.1756056398,
0.98806566,
-0.1246845499,
0.8679151535,
-0.3101176322,
0.2464571744,
-0.4932361245,
1.0492072105,
-0.7853993773,
-0.0287436824,
0.1914920956,
-0.6750108004,
-0.2480907589,
0.6279996634,
-0.6613714099,
-0.1190580353,
0.9151476622,
0.65827775,
-0.1385573298,
0.1070922464,
0.4330370128,
0.0609114952,
0.0169917699,
1.0898160934,
0.8034282923,
-0.0347129256,
0.6864737868,
-0.2816813886,
-0.0792769715,
0.1966176033,
-0.776910603,
-0.7984184623,
-0.6846948862,
-0.1382489353,
-0.2725759745,
0.0162621774,
0.410230279,
0.7203063965,
-0.7281748056,
-0.1685847044,
-0.020069398,
0.456756562,
-0.5283226967,
-0.2376616746,
0.4115486443,
-0.133737132,
-0.4018289447,
0.4810706675,
0.0491287746,
-0.1663167477,
-0.1280669123,
0.0700878352,
-0.3608811498,
0.0458341725,
0.6340436339,
0.5562449694,
-0.6657067537,
-0.4381878972,
0.3189166784,
-0.0156613123,
-0.245397225,
0.9281966686,
-0.6599595547,
0.3553634584,
1.0786602497,
0.7143805027,
0.5093074441,
-0.6154626608,
0.5429666042,
-0.4849947095,
0.0454708785,
-0.0322807841,
0.6341210008,
0.3705904186,
-0.1443432122,
0.2450752556,
0.2668504715,
-0.4985772967,
-0.4479658008,
0.3639478683,
-0.9022634625,
-0.6884017587,
1.4708590508,
-0.4529890418,
-0.1626992822,
-0.1602366716,
0.2173466682,
0.5618161559,
-0.0645707175,
0.3157314062,
0.8590620756,
-0.3911521733,
-0.2969695032,
-0.6059268117,
0.3510997891,
0.4561098814,
-0.6811511517,
0.0665293932,
0.3159067929,
0.4923578501,
0.572860539,
0.4726856053,
-0.287393868,
0.3255056441,
0.3472622037,
-0.0434760787,
-0.0424899682,
-0.4649148285,
-0.1670012772,
0.4416853786,
-0.1696675271,
-0.0764529407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16635v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16635v1
|
ShadowLLM: Predictor-based Contextual Sparsity for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-24T13:41:08 | 2024-06-24T13:41:08 |
Yash Akhauri, Ahmed F AbouElhamayed, Jordan Dotzel, Zhiru Zhang, Alexander M Rush, Safeen Huda, Mohamed S Abdelfattah
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The high power consumption and latency-sensitive deployments of large
language models (LLMs) have motivated techniques like quantization and
sparsity. Contextual sparsity, where the sparsity pattern is input-dependent,
is crucial in LLMs because the permanent removal of attention heads or neurons
from LLMs can significantly degrade accuracy. Prior work has attempted to model
contextual sparsity using neural networks trained to predict activation
magnitudes, which can be used to dynamically prune structures with low
predicted activation magnitude. In this paper, we look beyond magnitude-based
pruning criteria to assess attention head and neuron importance in LLMs. We
developed a novel predictor called ShadowLLM, which can shadow the LLM behavior
and enforce better sparsity patterns, resulting in over 15% improvement in
end-to-end accuracy without increasing latency compared to previous methods.
ShadowLLM achieves up to a 20\% speed-up over the state-of-the-art DejaVu
framework. These enhancements are validated on models with up to 30 billion
parameters. Our code is available at
\href{https://github.com/abdelfattah-lab/shadow_llm/}{ShadowLLM}.
|
[
-0.2391712368,
-1.05344522,
0.4988912046,
0.4580138326,
-0.1804149747,
-0.1056352034,
-0.3089870811,
-0.2374720573,
0.2468519956,
0.6643690467,
-0.441124022,
-0.3882739246,
-0.5065452456,
-0.2483365834,
-0.4769772291,
0.6256254911,
0.2002453357,
0.0883882418,
-0.4338145852,
-0.0423849896,
-0.5002244711,
-0.6671435833,
-0.5948491096,
-0.412758708,
0.6448886395,
0.0082623558,
0.6137393117,
0.4347032309,
0.4020935893,
0.2709248662,
-0.412558049,
-0.0588922836,
-0.5535346866,
0.2077523321,
0.0797663778,
-0.1686706543,
-0.8097212315,
-0.2296964079,
0.7175678611,
1.0431293249,
-0.3691091835,
0.1047865823,
0.2802673578,
0.5347121954,
-0.8439933062,
-0.029099511,
-0.6013374329,
-0.1090766639,
-0.0885748416,
-0.2817462385,
-0.3832490444,
-0.0537327044,
-0.0509173833,
-0.2847755849,
0.1497973651,
0.0851422027,
0.4885029793,
0.5284742117,
-0.1772496998,
0.3890970051,
-0.7699811459,
0.8585203886,
-0.7746106982,
0.6519036889,
0.4063108563,
0.100160189,
-0.2506358325,
-0.6165016294,
-0.3967084289,
-0.2944167852,
-0.178026408,
0.0735012516,
-0.3487211466,
0.2223381847,
0.364720583,
0.1805597842,
-0.6868727803,
0.0891640112,
-0.0380131155,
-0.0476574525,
0.2429146022,
0.2374140173,
0.0127184829,
0.0006079758,
-0.3128508031,
0.1682284921,
-0.8078768253,
-0.1547996104,
0.2545278072,
0.0087779034,
-0.0309881419,
0.1876661777,
-0.1091321036,
1.0949690342,
0.3448479772,
-0.0134946145,
0.0120825805,
-0.1071822718,
-0.3085137904,
0.0622206144,
0.5876139402,
0.2043824047,
0.0051172082,
-0.3939182758,
-0.1916298121,
-0.1962068379,
0.1720872223,
-1.0066792965,
-0.1470449269,
0.3385224044,
-0.3105638921,
-0.400988847,
-0.1591486037,
-0.603641212,
-0.4253408313,
-0.2309297323,
0.1785698235,
-0.4629847705,
-0.4839470983,
0.269015789,
0.3136071265,
0.0245888419,
0.4070693254,
-0.7697552443,
0.4333497584,
0.668508172,
0.7785747051,
-0.5696811676,
-0.342364341,
-0.761045754,
0.2746784687,
-0.2575927079,
0.4452370703,
-0.4980607331,
0.0823147595,
-0.1650669277,
-0.0301429462,
-0.1802264452,
-0.5994955897,
0.1229429096,
-0.6578187943,
-0.0217466652,
0.0466273166,
-0.3388860226,
-0.3171221912,
0.3119618595,
-0.7350542545,
0.9470201731,
0.1873636395,
-0.5574564338,
0.1648367494,
-0.3582133949,
-0.588778615,
0.3806863129,
0.0645596161,
-0.3941074014,
0.473223716,
0.0594127402,
0.7614830732,
-0.2074701041,
0.8100007772,
-0.3545713127,
-0.5897970796,
0.4789767861,
-0.5626018047,
0.5271778703,
-0.0809426755,
-0.425612092,
0.1312680393,
-0.967797637,
0.1281940043,
-0.1681744009,
-0.1831998676,
-0.5096169114,
0.0701343194,
0.3942120969,
0.2443793714,
0.1518552899,
-0.0591180362,
0.042480275,
-0.6615527868,
0.4011497498,
0.7577577829,
-0.1500666738,
0.3085979819,
-0.0512056015,
0.7244791389,
-0.0942818522,
0.0280227363,
-0.0858555064,
0.0018524167,
-0.7675780654,
-0.3544926047,
0.3100757301,
0.3323784173,
-0.4923230112,
0.7285252213,
-0.4416612983,
-0.2024948299,
0.0639444813,
0.0232490078,
0.4975752532,
0.2590798438,
0.2866856456,
-0.2923209369,
-0.6913498044,
-0.8115736246,
-0.0359339975,
-0.0325578637,
0.1574090868,
0.369482249,
0.2669210434,
-0.2093873918,
0.9929482937,
-0.3132824898,
-0.298037529,
-0.4111108482,
-0.0904094279,
0.1451791078,
0.4650877714,
0.3779325187,
-0.8239726424,
-0.2370976657,
-0.2082684338,
-0.5745130181,
-0.3685441315,
-0.0265500993,
0.0913419873,
0.0527124703,
0.5783466697,
-0.657943964,
0.2717009485,
0.8848994374,
-0.252479285,
0.3761296272,
0.0969096869,
-0.0279412903,
-1.0967409611,
0.3974375725,
0.0076753381,
-0.3094615042,
-0.7946315408,
-0.1989008039,
0.0392348655,
0.0539660119,
-0.5121861696,
0.798070848,
-0.6166553497,
-0.1744825691,
-0.3497457504,
-0.0620539971,
-0.1538789272,
0.7170827389,
0.1167656109,
0.7761696577,
0.4125138521,
-0.7405711412,
0.1694325507,
-0.2903041244,
-0.2868478894,
0.4289351404,
-0.7162416577,
0.0373704545,
0.1951258183,
0.1664060354,
-0.7878282666,
-0.0459045097,
0.0216522701,
-0.3285154402,
0.3376318216,
-0.0700503439,
-0.4401223063,
-0.0709045976,
-0.2149492651,
0.5249528289,
0.4267652333,
-0.3969128728,
0.8224562407,
0.4200088084,
-0.0722900182,
-0.8466499448,
-0.5568114519,
0.1775014699,
-0.2329351455,
-0.5232311487,
0.5905123353,
-0.1786431372,
-0.2695594132,
-0.0585938022,
-0.0670801923,
0.1223213822,
0.4042446017,
0.7245321274,
0.0959360525,
-0.0586751141,
0.0094788186,
-0.205625996,
-0.2613838315,
0.0974425822,
-0.4158710539,
0.910570085,
0.0046709157,
-0.2935043871,
-0.1358366162,
-0.0519272313,
0.5982456207,
-0.0471558608,
0.6715480089,
0.5951128602,
-0.5277641416,
-0.418679893,
-0.9326217175,
-0.3884592056,
-0.5121331811,
0.8281874061,
-0.1437864304,
-0.8685981035,
0.4254050553,
-0.115299724,
-0.5189909339,
0.0375868715,
0.5727487803,
0.0892018452,
1.0297654867,
0.8995999098,
-0.2220158428,
0.7726696134,
-0.3070445657,
0.0471410267,
-1.0723421574,
-0.0445049144,
-0.016754875,
-0.2412229925,
-0.0500782132,
-0.4165378213,
0.1814968139,
0.3906502128,
0.2224866003,
0.3419711292,
-0.4573245049,
0.5145034194,
0.2302517742,
-0.0730525106,
0.2228266746,
0.314198941,
-0.0217644591,
-0.113269724,
-0.6806287766,
-0.4051176906,
0.7611740828,
0.215484187,
0.8531299233,
-0.0922112018,
0.1694945991,
0.1672476232,
0.3295392692,
-0.7462043166,
0.8342831135,
-0.0327472202,
-0.2756824195,
-0.2178851664,
-0.4518851638,
-1.0066357851,
0.3267997205,
-0.0035981718,
-0.7667267323,
0.0103960978,
0.3930594623,
-0.4624407589,
0.2582400143,
-0.2635617256,
0.7919646502,
-0.3997604549,
-0.7678660154,
-0.3119445145,
-0.3180603981,
0.2218663096,
-0.0041023125,
-0.0659638643,
-0.1093530282,
-0.1772166491,
0.7389762998,
-0.1520959586,
1.0610123873,
-0.1217079163,
-0.1439847201,
-0.0248464942,
0.2403176874,
0.5886207223,
0.0851924792,
0.0453564897,
0.561547935,
-0.2563025951,
0.0284032077,
-0.5971816182,
0.9222607613,
-0.4543135166,
-0.612770021,
-0.426737994,
-0.59023875,
-0.2945046127,
0.2047663033,
0.1649855822,
0.3031959832,
-0.3683509827,
0.4207345545,
0.7669183016,
-0.1044932455,
0.5574320555,
0.7117190361,
-0.310308367,
-0.6002925038,
0.928003788,
0.2183413953,
0.1111450866,
0.4149116874,
0.04116074,
0.0692831129,
-0.9322155118,
-0.280423075,
0.0859549716,
-0.3423371613,
-0.2880010009,
-0.7837151289,
-0.4026844203,
-0.3257101774,
-0.1358689815,
-0.2603988647,
-0.366356343,
-0.2242656201,
-0.0694578961,
0.2143893093,
0.3756774664,
0.1635202318,
0.560310483,
-0.445217818,
0.0847075656,
0.1636660993,
0.3729504347,
0.0413676053,
-0.4513574541,
-0.3662225604,
-0.1917088032,
-0.2085319608,
-0.6880372167,
0.7256772518,
0.0384073444,
0.5527330637,
0.2297558635,
-0.2212540209,
0.730448246,
-0.4030955136,
0.6857785583,
0.3004942834,
-0.9511821866,
0.5336862206,
-0.2316346169,
0.3526571393,
0.1896688342,
-0.0050239353,
-0.7096760869,
-0.3353678882,
-0.672965765,
-0.9935871363,
0.8512906432,
0.1076717749,
-0.0035563943,
0.2834436595,
0.4649738669,
0.0824399963,
0.2888141274,
-0.7442379594,
-0.2044495046,
0.2106594145,
-0.1988979727,
-0.2121897489,
-0.5564411283,
0.051599659,
-0.0472009033,
0.5678989291,
-0.2771861553,
-0.0745249987,
-0.1339637637,
-0.463031292,
-0.3150642812,
0.1577467322,
0.5642050505,
0.7714618444,
-0.2454030812,
0.2020227164,
0.4887102246,
-0.7422475815,
0.0905685425,
0.1937026232,
-0.5128337145,
-0.0360880196,
0.4252168238,
0.8837752938,
0.3622972667,
-0.6205049157,
0.6743962765,
0.05857265,
-0.0204273332,
-0.6601192951,
0.1281327456,
-0.0343263447,
0.0517626218,
0.4446849525,
0.1426456571,
0.0604571477,
-0.0483972169,
0.1272543669,
0.7001166344,
-0.5423931479,
-0.5395472646,
0.5925203562,
0.2258452326,
-0.1282209009,
0.1874391586,
0.0660147592,
-0.4005082846,
0.7308328748,
0.4609259367,
1.0340846777,
-0.3089265823,
-0.258559078,
0.3192415833,
0.1726879478,
-0.1572466195,
-0.0930129439,
-0.0525802895,
-0.6524384022,
-0.6516012549,
-0.7798068523,
-0.1985349655,
0.6602329612,
-0.4150525928,
0.3220736682,
-0.4774350524,
-0.3074665964,
-0.1339960843,
-0.1267448515,
-0.349491179,
0.1545338184,
0.2570530772,
0.5115413666,
-0.6473864317,
1.0717128515,
0.5500112772,
-0.0942635909,
-0.3402064741,
0.0850362852,
-0.1724064052,
-0.559366703,
0.8255434632,
0.4842254221,
-0.4315915108,
0.1040922776,
-0.5814756751,
-1.1628113985,
1.1415038109,
0.6812528372,
-0.8091321588,
-0.0262319334,
-0.0222516935,
0.3435594738,
-0.2653861642,
0.256724149,
0.3584055007,
0.2774817646,
-0.0161238723,
-0.6511685252,
0.2590813339,
-0.1036430448,
0.3592405319,
0.2170540243,
-0.5771917105,
0.7920126319,
-0.1674173623,
-0.3678779006,
0.0008499622,
0.549457252,
0.3219930828,
0.1830573827,
0.5562747717,
0.5271029472,
0.4430705011,
-0.2548053265,
0.8422588706,
-0.6626839638,
0.1993553489,
1.0342655182,
-0.3606351614,
0.7218385935,
0.7556596994,
-0.0418759584,
0.2882037759,
0.4363686442,
-0.0543766357,
0.5475029349,
0.3057548702,
-0.0775429085,
-0.3833763599,
-0.1429577917,
-0.373721242,
0.0937772021,
0.456250459,
-0.2960547507,
0.2747597098,
0.2226078659,
-0.0640306845,
-0.0275765266,
-0.2549013793,
0.7400277257,
0.1015853509,
-0.6660606265,
0.786654532,
0.0356261134,
1.025328517,
-0.5671542287,
-0.0673536286,
-0.3205873668,
0.6473842263,
-0.229193002,
-0.3702492118,
0.1544426978,
-0.2660118937,
-0.3365557492,
-0.3174116015,
0.8678932786,
-0.5300630927,
-0.4693732858,
0.6047093868,
0.5812305808,
-0.1403618157,
-0.3480984867,
-0.6875029802,
0.224886328,
-0.276455164,
-0.638014257,
0.4975797534,
0.1472790837,
-0.1176213026,
0.7638194561,
0.7332746387,
0.4621222615,
-0.1440923959,
0.2356956303,
0.8038515449,
-0.7187460661,
-0.2697483003,
-1.0878373384,
0.2233186662,
-0.1008367389,
-0.119867377,
0.8524035215,
0.5838242769,
0.6369303465,
0.0993446037,
0.5183635354,
0.0530676469,
0.1816094071,
-0.5990569592,
0.781058073,
-0.5937797427,
0.3824228048,
-0.1795255691,
-0.9355997443,
-0.434980154,
0.5694819689,
-0.3186798692,
0.3310947716,
0.7580443621,
1.063557744,
-0.0830831155,
-0.3831167519,
0.6288465858,
0.2717072368,
0.0177102257,
0.6807664633,
0.9795293808,
-0.2295024544,
0.6039321423,
-0.5071305633,
-0.0993451625,
-0.4841708243,
-0.8900176287,
-0.8994590044,
-0.428912729,
-0.6043223143,
-0.4750426412,
0.2693487704,
0.6359667778,
1.1532571316,
-0.8193106651,
-0.2311506718,
-0.3233661354,
0.001446221,
-0.6072924733,
-0.2616205215,
0.4472730756,
-0.0913723037,
-0.5233056545,
0.3027355969,
0.4721176922,
0.1024810374,
-0.4928266108,
-0.2079901248,
0.0757481754,
-0.1385724545,
0.6300667524,
-0.0153446579,
-1.0602476597,
0.0579261258,
0.0540169142,
-0.379543364,
-0.115158312,
0.8733496666,
-0.9538065791,
-0.0593624711,
0.2732172608,
0.3692734838,
0.5104714632,
0.0105674909,
0.5762451291,
-0.9338548779,
0.3929263353,
0.4535076618,
0.4176426828,
0.4131256342,
-0.6414116025,
0.5384367108,
0.2629886866,
-0.3420494795,
-0.9788194895,
0.0150889764,
-1.0471249819,
-0.3420053422,
1.504929781,
0.0920447335,
-0.5035607815,
0.1465430111,
-0.1353468299,
0.0036263627,
-0.3042843938,
0.6115662456,
0.5375941396,
0.1896595955,
-0.4495834708,
-0.6097169518,
0.5614975691,
0.871530354,
-0.6291863918,
0.5512672663,
0.6684286594,
0.2580545843,
0.1538226455,
0.5892079473,
0.0081942799,
0.310331434,
-0.2621403635,
0.3732358813,
-0.347638309,
-0.3345909119,
-0.6853199005,
0.3761644065,
-0.0908407569,
0.1286641359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16620v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16620v2
|
OmAgent: A Multi-modal Agent Framework for Complex Video Understanding with Task Divide-and-Conquer
| 2024-06-24T13:05:39 | 2024-06-25T02:43:41 |
Lu Zhang, Tiancheng Zhao, Heting Ying, Yibo Ma, Kyusong Lee
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have expanded their
capabilities to multimodal contexts, including comprehensive video
understanding. However, processing extensive videos such as 24-hour CCTV
footage or full-length films presents significant challenges due to the vast
data and processing demands. Traditional methods, like extracting key frames or
converting frames to text, often result in substantial information loss. To
address these shortcomings, we develop OmAgent, efficiently stores and
retrieves relevant video frames for specific queries, preserving the detailed
content of videos. Additionally, it features an Divide-and-Conquer Loop capable
of autonomous reasoning, dynamically invoking APIs and tools to enhance query
processing and accuracy. This approach ensures robust video understanding,
significantly reducing information loss. Experimental results affirm OmAgent's
efficacy in handling various types of videos and complex tasks. Moreover, we
have endowed it with greater autonomy and a robust tool-calling system,
enabling it to accomplish even more intricate tasks.
|
[
-0.4236159623,
-0.9529421926,
0.6738885045,
0.2395969331,
-0.0818114728,
0.2677802145,
-0.2578249276,
-0.1787323654,
-0.1706164777,
0.3281032741,
-0.5294374824,
-0.2990846634,
-0.6766006351,
-0.19141078,
-0.204156369,
0.507951498,
-0.3487066925,
0.3007599711,
0.0581397675,
-0.4781146646,
-0.397488445,
-0.3800125122,
-0.5206198096,
-0.320631355,
0.3500480056,
0.5455730557,
0.8620672226,
0.796645999,
0.5637925267,
0.5344856977,
0.3311071992,
0.5649524331,
-0.3606496155,
0.4375566542,
-0.3475015163,
-0.3309178948,
-0.4679579735,
-0.4046793282,
0.5219311118,
0.4852707684,
-0.1168613955,
0.0627877265,
-0.446472466,
0.2704389989,
-1.1061745882,
0.2029135078,
-0.2924384475,
0.2822613716,
0.0333080404,
-0.467931211,
-0.1867254078,
0.2281423956,
0.1631657779,
-0.5775150061,
0.1938245445,
-0.2079189271,
0.4422489703,
0.5488778949,
-0.5356276631,
0.1014619619,
-1.0838282108,
0.4346677661,
-0.0558067858,
0.5255018473,
0.4388659,
0.6814027429,
-0.034695603,
-0.4859092534,
-0.6058586836,
-0.0783984438,
0.5810451508,
0.1687476188,
-0.0913370997,
0.2463499308,
0.0058072763,
0.3331553936,
-0.4697890282,
0.0006448813,
-0.1573232263,
-0.3204321563,
0.3862380087,
0.4862030447,
0.4804367423,
-0.1314166337,
-0.4375894666,
-0.1714254767,
-0.0028413844,
0.2660056651,
0.0832909867,
-0.1292357296,
0.064417474,
0.8731697202,
-0.2048207968,
0.6224818826,
-0.0872891918,
-0.4463984668,
0.0945565775,
-0.2122720033,
-0.8509788513,
0.0232776292,
0.6714304686,
0.3535791934,
-0.1299761832,
0.0618089363,
-0.0060135173,
0.0401264429,
0.2268889248,
-0.928008616,
-0.3245334029,
0.1493565887,
-0.2715796232,
0.1592311114,
0.3682747483,
-0.696733892,
-0.5065043569,
-0.6036048532,
0.6053681374,
-0.7009090781,
-0.1968259811,
0.2501035035,
-0.0942920372,
0.2127406597,
0.8922819495,
-0.2341298014,
0.0960326195,
0.2727718353,
0.7431245446,
-0.2204570919,
-0.6600245237,
-1.0837585926,
0.3821919262,
-0.1090624183,
0.4987535179,
-0.4721309841,
0.139351666,
0.2368215621,
0.1775317341,
-0.0925483182,
-0.2829902768,
0.422654897,
-0.8693856597,
-0.0482309833,
-0.0479621291,
-0.1962783784,
-0.452827245,
0.7191861272,
-0.7946757078,
0.4893978238,
-0.3186317384,
-0.1904539168,
0.2509547174,
-0.8321851492,
-0.3799149096,
-0.1185928732,
-0.2680716217,
-0.0338003561,
-0.1694153547,
0.2693870366,
0.3578901291,
-0.2346809953,
0.0674768761,
-0.1995258778,
0.1949067414,
0.285997659,
-0.80800879,
0.0512322523,
0.2901114821,
-0.1826952398,
0.3450396359,
-0.6209679842,
-0.2402551174,
-0.0014395,
-0.36274001,
0.0384828113,
0.0518192574,
0.0927995071,
0.1637319177,
0.0795890167,
-0.6820103526,
0.124338232,
0.247735709,
0.6073356271,
0.6786569953,
-0.2461749762,
0.6383942962,
0.0893867835,
0.743289113,
0.1343943328,
0.3064715564,
-0.5206583142,
-0.1321979314,
-0.5805388093,
-0.4753156304,
-0.3281133473,
0.3745873272,
-0.8538498282,
-0.0628292188,
-0.1837151796,
-0.2202501297,
-0.3454801738,
0.1402307898,
0.2970167696,
0.1323182285,
0.3475721776,
-0.1803877354,
-0.3028161228,
-0.5870822072,
0.0557846166,
0.2621310353,
-0.0530381575,
0.3223170936,
0.4278392792,
-0.48477,
1.1138923168,
-0.7924553752,
-0.7074616551,
-0.2345878184,
0.2145433575,
-0.1287776232,
0.2814065218,
0.2142356783,
-1.3912831545,
-0.1900664121,
0.3357124031,
-0.9345015287,
0.3752944767,
-0.1557150632,
-0.0311221872,
-0.0962293521,
0.6795222163,
-0.6035460234,
0.5073114634,
0.3024426997,
-0.3153576553,
0.4998742938,
-0.6263783574,
0.6270418167,
-0.7779563665,
-0.3045157492,
-0.1798336357,
-0.6452031732,
-0.4808415473,
0.0786544234,
-0.2259776145,
-0.1514804065,
-0.5747635961,
-0.0296840761,
-0.4266234934,
-0.1738007814,
-0.1999409199,
0.281547457,
0.0158660244,
0.5946583152,
0.0220824014,
0.6685100794,
0.6410998106,
-0.56793648,
0.8133887649,
0.1926775277,
-0.1305282563,
0.9138488173,
-0.301210165,
-0.0572677143,
-0.5308619142,
-0.013859869,
-0.9704167247,
-0.906874001,
0.127213046,
-0.4467943609,
0.1429799348,
-0.2382682562,
-0.4753780067,
-0.0287242532,
-0.2235195935,
0.6937810183,
-0.040747907,
-0.6153584719,
1.0775156021,
0.2998070419,
0.1370878518,
-0.6562379599,
-0.4834833443,
0.2278992236,
-0.1590378284,
-0.8925096393,
0.2481143177,
-0.2061097324,
-0.2059957236,
0.0981674045,
-0.5017328858,
-0.6297412515,
-0.3867145181,
0.4751974642,
-0.0534163527,
-0.1425426751,
0.1722952574,
-0.2141416371,
0.1439653635,
0.0239441395,
-0.1826034784,
0.5122747421,
-0.2464834601,
-0.7195891142,
-0.0704475269,
0.6425457001,
1.034306407,
-0.5750021338,
0.3593132496,
0.9979256392,
-0.3146199584,
-0.2831423283,
-0.7212062478,
0.2157332897,
-0.4889700115,
0.8061742783,
-0.6496716142,
-0.9721857905,
0.6266117096,
-0.0138392756,
-0.2584669292,
0.0880876407,
0.6827200055,
-0.0849672109,
1.1614162922,
0.6477146745,
-0.0469144247,
0.6857128739,
-0.3764915764,
0.02087803,
-0.3593817651,
-0.666926682,
-0.0657543465,
-0.1356262118,
0.0937588364,
-0.760242939,
0.7232837677,
-0.0576279648,
-0.5198814869,
0.1750672609,
-0.2929299474,
0.8083429337,
0.2035353184,
0.3708437979,
0.4948691726,
0.0357124805,
0.3214944303,
0.0772178695,
-0.5289114118,
-0.3112597466,
0.5588120222,
0.4228746295,
1.197750926,
0.6609330773,
-0.0949803218,
0.726070106,
-0.3379607201,
-0.9124845862,
0.5850347281,
0.1661293656,
-0.4572462738,
-0.3576252162,
-0.2066520751,
-0.957377255,
0.5103649497,
0.2048226148,
-0.6445054412,
0.1492160708,
-0.0909491926,
-0.3106187284,
0.6349374056,
-0.4904857576,
1.0676518679,
-0.4628564715,
-0.6882275939,
-0.4186902046,
-0.8890632391,
0.4206510484,
0.1616293639,
0.2890769541,
0.13708435,
-0.2676813006,
0.3149375021,
-0.7614198327,
0.5780991912,
0.0355369374,
0.154736951,
0.4557190239,
0.4296749532,
0.0576429106,
0.2109689713,
0.4052217305,
-0.4949894547,
-0.1199793145,
-0.2625372112,
-0.6121219993,
0.5711157918,
-0.976857841,
-0.4051478207,
-0.288172394,
-0.60397017,
0.261217922,
0.1617693454,
0.0838043168,
0.5940040946,
-0.0808326527,
0.3832755089,
0.7788365483,
-0.0390492976,
0.6649843454,
0.4317203164,
0.014477375,
-0.5958396792,
0.9155611396,
-0.10828311,
0.4323260486,
0.4796023071,
-0.0894457921,
-0.0867628232,
-0.1856763065,
-0.5224530101,
-0.2410378754,
-1.0308505297,
-0.3618525863,
-0.6137593985,
0.0080180196,
-0.0735395029,
-0.2136766911,
-0.4208350778,
0.3454914987,
-0.1296067536,
-0.290490061,
0.3549411297,
0.6557908654,
-0.0943720192,
0.3619832993,
-0.9119992852,
0.5589904189,
0.7658935189,
0.3214728832,
-0.1855489463,
-0.3866043389,
-0.3227229118,
-0.2212308794,
-0.5299729109,
-1.1309177876,
0.46122244,
0.3403240144,
0.4635241032,
0.6713598967,
-0.0415533707,
0.9063805342,
-0.294624418,
0.8547796607,
0.1815443039,
-1.0391944647,
0.2749322653,
-0.5091344118,
0.2214979827,
0.4422145486,
0.2744626105,
-0.2676444948,
0.1074947938,
-0.3951737285,
-0.8359542489,
0.958907783,
0.3893093467,
-0.240702033,
0.4500126839,
-0.0619143583,
-0.1285425127,
0.3913502991,
-0.5418044329,
0.0659553856,
-0.4594345093,
0.1526624858,
0.0051070107,
0.0952994078,
-0.2632076442,
-0.0344549455,
0.1245897636,
-0.3230041862,
0.1583873481,
0.8094412684,
-0.7315748334,
-0.3247731626,
0.4337510169,
0.6345322728,
0.5635036826,
-0.3129211962,
0.4670902789,
0.2037027031,
-0.5855585933,
0.5295646191,
0.0743893981,
0.4691144526,
-0.1006337255,
0.4255623519,
0.5979126692,
-0.0652780756,
-1.1897623539,
0.7324739099,
0.241372332,
-0.0862044692,
-0.5062983632,
-0.102430962,
-0.3353543282,
0.591272831,
0.33529526,
0.3830336034,
0.3262374103,
-0.8747310638,
0.2184623033,
0.1147985309,
-0.4726808965,
-0.4821057916,
0.7604960203,
-0.0020978265,
-0.4561268389,
0.2753091753,
-0.3378313184,
-0.7464844584,
0.8047383428,
0.0072121779,
0.7413650155,
-0.2975851595,
0.3443058431,
-0.1159059182,
0.2695347667,
-0.1870275289,
0.2628928721,
-0.3732943535,
-0.7561753392,
-0.7808781862,
-0.1787026376,
-0.3798677921,
0.0564958677,
-0.5785776973,
0.0006123643,
-0.3285556138,
-0.0713845566,
0.0766018108,
-0.6264840364,
-0.8812752962,
0.3421280384,
0.2408214957,
0.7241487503,
-0.6515707374,
0.6556877494,
1.0645003319,
-0.741345942,
-0.8254339099,
-0.4584221542,
0.1053267047,
-0.5634667277,
0.7259601951,
0.1196224019,
-0.4394256771,
-0.5034784675,
-0.5222588778,
-0.5195040107,
1.0668460131,
0.4452877641,
-0.1519825459,
-0.0288817082,
0.3149819076,
0.3904545903,
-0.4419645965,
0.5233591199,
0.6226719618,
0.5897963643,
0.4811202884,
-0.8467025757,
-0.3776982129,
-0.1469447166,
-0.54675138,
0.2686676383,
-0.4555825889,
1.1044285297,
-0.2789954841,
0.2096419036,
-0.1401923448,
0.3293488324,
-0.1388154924,
0.5884484053,
0.6178207397,
0.3934011459,
0.233235389,
0.1522177309,
0.6406061053,
0.3114331067,
0.2146390378,
1.3056977987,
-0.08076749,
0.4894383252,
0.3373120725,
-0.0082543334,
0.2211374342,
0.406607151,
0.0758968145,
0.3151450157,
-0.0860059336,
-0.3844022751,
-0.9507748485,
-0.2576350272,
0.0597937368,
0.9267137647,
0.3301077485,
-0.1840192825,
-0.5711932778,
0.5319137573,
-0.0792893991,
0.2487042695,
-0.5423685908,
0.8292089105,
-0.2907630503,
-0.6158363223,
0.1438589096,
-0.0641635358,
0.2581902146,
-0.6727608442,
-0.0260205306,
0.1873510629,
0.5371302366,
-0.4366602004,
-0.8661741614,
0.047066085,
0.0467529558,
-0.2931576669,
-0.0387322232,
0.6470279694,
-0.7461560369,
0.0691563338,
0.3121087849,
0.4605130553,
0.0823765993,
-0.6373025775,
-0.4039060473,
0.3139276803,
-0.0155130131,
-0.1732409745,
0.163687259,
0.729178369,
-0.0472433046,
0.8110833168,
0.39297387,
-0.3760075569,
0.1198164597,
0.0205082018,
0.9496648908,
-0.4945915639,
-0.3294248581,
-0.9310231805,
0.6968610883,
-0.1388512552,
-0.0455742069,
0.7195135951,
0.5726029277,
0.6457706094,
-0.2226625681,
0.7146086097,
-0.1590124071,
-0.2051410526,
-0.268614471,
0.2193679363,
-0.751490593,
-0.1139711291,
-0.3422910273,
-0.8097227216,
-0.2189046592,
0.428080827,
-0.068740271,
-0.3595899045,
0.4999503195,
0.5676556826,
-0.4097898304,
-0.0200685561,
0.3486430347,
0.1932091862,
0.8620610833,
0.5001306534,
1.0335919857,
-0.2587844729,
1.0235050917,
0.1789666414,
-0.2492984086,
-0.3787562549,
-0.6382433176,
-0.8284221888,
-0.4556222856,
-0.1542482525,
-0.0011403114,
-0.1080650464,
1.1262774467,
1.0280945301,
-0.2973930538,
-0.3768647015,
-0.0094207851,
0.0534108281,
-0.0779244751,
-0.1713145971,
0.2507298589,
-0.1015154049,
-0.7761689425,
0.6661621928,
0.5693693757,
-0.255982697,
-0.4925346673,
-0.2189040631,
-0.1368067265,
0.0322786383,
1.034247756,
0.4760681689,
-0.6678070426,
-0.3065336049,
0.1899179369,
0.0972812846,
0.2457064837,
0.9421580434,
-0.5140346289,
1.0358453989,
0.7313218713,
0.7307186127,
0.6947072148,
0.1097869501,
0.5927790403,
-0.4698407054,
0.2300135195,
0.1904830933,
0.544665575,
0.1883127391,
-0.1672353297,
0.4780898988,
0.1254916638,
-0.7005481124,
-0.6798294783,
0.4127487242,
-1.5048007965,
-0.2763267756,
0.8958110809,
-0.1319027394,
-0.277351141,
-0.2253706157,
-0.7010220289,
0.1821313947,
-0.8008522391,
0.1601365358,
0.2579979599,
-0.1791463941,
-0.3676161468,
-0.5612042546,
0.211398676,
0.3433068097,
-0.6696274877,
-0.1445683688,
0.6487777829,
0.1765364259,
0.4477462173,
0.2736130059,
0.1448940933,
0.3640131652,
-0.3316856921,
-0.0180649254,
-0.4324130714,
-0.757340014,
-0.3243560195,
0.8076509833,
-0.2271909714,
-0.7529129982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16611v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16611v1
|
Evaluation of Language Models in the Medical Context Under Resource-Constrained Settings
| 2024-06-24T12:52:02 | 2024-06-24T12:52:02 |
Andrea Posada, Daniel Rueckert, Felix Meissen, Philip Müller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Since the emergence of the Transformer architecture, language model
development has increased, driven by their promising potential. However,
releasing these models into production requires properly understanding their
behavior, particularly in sensitive domains such as medicine. Despite this
need, the medical literature still lacks technical assessments of pre-trained
language models, which are especially valuable in resource-constrained settings
in terms of computational power or limited budget. To address this gap, we
provide a comprehensive survey of language models in the medical domain. In
addition, we selected a subset of these models for thorough evaluation,
focusing on classification and text generation tasks. Our subset encompasses 53
models, ranging from 110 million to 13 billion parameters, spanning the three
families of Transformer-based models and from diverse knowledge domains. This
study employs a series of approaches for text classification together with
zero-shot prompting instead of model training or fine-tuning, which closely
resembles the limited resource setting in which many users of language models
find themselves. Encouragingly, our findings reveal remarkable performance
across various tasks and datasets, underscoring the latent potential of certain
models to contain medical knowledge, even without domain specialization.
Consequently, our study advocates for further exploration of model applications
in medical contexts, particularly in resource-constrained settings. The code is
available on https://github.com/anpoc/Language-models-in-medicine.
|
[
-0.0779233426,
-0.4131337404,
0.6571696997,
-0.1055460647,
-0.0446268655,
-0.022848485,
-0.3808933496,
-0.3017143309,
-0.2681459486,
0.5918359756,
-0.5014884472,
-0.2787549794,
-0.7505135536,
0.2831014991,
-0.3007794619,
1.1332206726,
-0.0949304923,
0.2726317048,
-0.3923195004,
-0.2550000846,
-0.5317828655,
-0.6342583299,
-0.3527849913,
-0.4855644405,
0.2672700882,
0.1174055934,
0.4970336854,
0.6406701207,
0.7512655854,
0.2788428664,
-0.1958170086,
-0.0897595659,
-0.2596468329,
0.1838159412,
-0.1801814735,
-0.2012897134,
-0.3058332801,
0.0875571892,
0.4250476658,
0.953091979,
-0.0632926077,
0.2270260453,
-0.1455096155,
0.3231242001,
-0.6147584319,
0.1328173131,
-0.4704810381,
0.0869411081,
-0.139230147,
0.1090338379,
-0.4634409845,
-0.2275140584,
0.5433135033,
-0.286935091,
0.3656924367,
0.0330171213,
0.9321069717,
0.3864533007,
-0.4644450247,
-0.2478799224,
-0.9468377233,
0.8257296085,
-0.6048361659,
0.386287272,
0.4327168465,
0.3900228143,
0.2409510612,
-0.8886734247,
-0.4007459879,
-0.4357188344,
-0.1787740588,
0.008009728,
-0.4578070343,
0.2088157982,
0.1666408181,
0.4213579893,
-0.4906832576,
0.246899277,
-0.5157559514,
-0.132637307,
0.2480221391,
0.3456026316,
0.5374551415,
-0.4142090976,
0.0601387471,
-0.0063018212,
-0.4256910682,
-0.2189620286,
-0.2304756194,
0.1783947647,
-0.2180225402,
0.5545378327,
0.0802480429,
0.8794645667,
-0.2484531403,
-0.2237867117,
0.0718412697,
-0.5304319859,
-0.3861519694,
-0.4288933277,
0.9614387155,
0.1765957475,
0.150018245,
-0.2109250873,
-0.2443057001,
0.2018052787,
0.7264990807,
-0.9462907314,
-0.1437437683,
0.1513157636,
-0.6506119967,
-0.3577638865,
-0.5158853531,
-0.6153752804,
-0.4486192763,
0.0146548208,
0.0798404142,
-0.5140703917,
-0.2577265501,
0.1823793501,
0.1822289675,
-0.2360983044,
0.0358126834,
-0.9077823758,
0.4990519583,
0.3668406308,
0.8097758889,
-0.1732683182,
0.0390759446,
-0.0106441127,
-0.2824686766,
-0.3182329535,
0.783528626,
-0.5880196691,
-0.5855275989,
0.0417528637,
-0.1494349688,
-0.3798774183,
-0.6948570013,
0.7563318014,
-0.3035874963,
0.321950376,
0.106230475,
-0.5662429929,
-0.1375137419,
0.1805836409,
-0.7150601745,
0.4206275344,
0.4534215629,
-0.6312294006,
0.3127523363,
-0.7948297858,
-0.5147684813,
0.2673196197,
-0.4192313552,
-0.5699286461,
0.395557344,
0.0934371129,
0.6015042663,
-0.8263789415,
0.5619464517,
0.0548135601,
-0.076483421,
0.436679095,
-0.4887194633,
0.6282734275,
0.3952268958,
-0.0719843805,
0.1116107553,
-0.7006446123,
-0.0251897946,
0.2866648138,
-0.2134285122,
-0.3336687088,
0.0630751699,
0.3188856244,
0.2455841452,
-0.023726603,
-0.473878324,
0.0331452787,
-0.5438553095,
0.5640317202,
0.0922279656,
-0.0194316972,
0.4882587194,
-0.2986018062,
0.8566514254,
-0.2367043644,
0.3608594537,
-0.2412985712,
-0.2975839078,
-0.613694191,
-0.2873424292,
0.5235669613,
0.4954484999,
-0.6878085732,
0.2458060235,
-0.4544557929,
-0.6354435682,
-0.8483706117,
-0.2232066691,
0.5855045319,
0.6842906475,
0.4005827308,
-0.1131711602,
-0.2064464986,
-0.9545130134,
-0.0839417577,
-0.2172625661,
-0.2485361546,
0.7733383775,
0.4282344282,
-0.4172750115,
0.6933551431,
-0.3671465814,
-0.0886991322,
-0.5037712455,
-0.0499660596,
0.0229272209,
0.3077537715,
0.6477819085,
-0.7128997445,
-0.1286506355,
0.1822776198,
-0.6441751719,
-0.3511485755,
0.0075834696,
0.2203655243,
0.0018664048,
0.1783626229,
-0.330257833,
0.3808594942,
0.8701559901,
-0.3160758317,
0.3727307916,
-0.2851688862,
0.124789536,
-0.9517323971,
0.4532517791,
0.1001731306,
-0.158790946,
-1.0349647999,
-0.0327173993,
0.1633480191,
-0.3591852486,
-0.2767096758,
0.7269430161,
-0.3301307857,
0.3943952918,
-0.385476619,
-0.247503981,
-0.0379079916,
0.1594837904,
0.2591151297,
0.5424699783,
0.5393679142,
-0.5518132448,
-0.1114947572,
0.2454044372,
-0.4446952641,
0.2517288327,
-0.7619295716,
-0.1282874197,
0.0438712984,
-0.0541088693,
-0.5536886454,
-0.2935109735,
0.1177566051,
-0.2088929862,
0.4219610691,
-0.1525892168,
-0.3530565202,
-0.451482892,
0.2292720824,
0.6585021615,
0.6965444088,
-0.1261116862,
0.4018581212,
0.5943030715,
-0.2449001968,
-0.2125996351,
-0.4542614222,
-0.1569454223,
0.0004647203,
-0.2382514179,
0.4217788875,
-0.0417665839,
-0.169252187,
0.019100083,
-0.177523762,
-0.3828444183,
0.1378381252,
0.3283107281,
0.4983362556,
-0.1154680923,
0.3503762782,
0.1208779588,
-0.1004273891,
-0.0606147684,
-0.0592887625,
0.5009028912,
0.0064625815,
-0.3518066704,
-0.3233786225,
0.1857303977,
0.7850979567,
-0.3734969199,
0.6683603525,
0.2267403603,
-0.6037436724,
-0.0230119396,
-0.555745244,
-0.1511886716,
-0.3735151291,
0.633967638,
-0.0751339868,
-0.9588167667,
0.2640034854,
-0.1874912232,
-0.0681253672,
0.531435132,
0.7139576077,
0.2840728164,
0.8919557333,
0.7554206848,
0.1789498031,
0.2739757597,
-0.0722659007,
0.2711262703,
-0.6583610773,
-0.2373424172,
-0.6539261937,
0.167165041,
-0.4869960546,
-0.4105455577,
0.5756962299,
-0.3107846379,
0.0325791463,
0.2271625102,
-0.7335059643,
0.2675008774,
0.0825516433,
-0.0361388475,
0.1001066193,
-0.2030466795,
-0.2663396001,
-0.0524240918,
-0.9507591724,
-0.6761790514,
1.0909096003,
0.5189971328,
0.610648334,
-0.402274698,
0.3032574356,
-0.1474265158,
0.5723894835,
-0.9138038158,
0.2576410472,
-0.5281735659,
-0.6788832545,
-0.0961546302,
-0.6052848101,
-0.9356814623,
-0.0258517172,
-0.3768950105,
-0.4666653872,
-0.0228138212,
0.1314024031,
-0.80678159,
0.249813363,
-0.6819875836,
1.0489650965,
-0.2429618239,
0.0315402448,
-0.1054781303,
-0.546895802,
0.2985039949,
-0.577265799,
0.1720368117,
-0.1795303673,
-0.0593588576,
0.6392756104,
-0.3694329858,
0.7574808002,
0.0429564491,
0.0676144958,
0.0791603923,
0.1530455798,
-0.1293441057,
-0.1686585248,
-0.1207399219,
0.4302608073,
0.1697394997,
-0.1313353777,
-0.4381203055,
0.3590065539,
-0.5996278524,
-0.2823041677,
-0.216168344,
-0.5754616857,
-0.3701339364,
0.2759378254,
0.5988313556,
0.4760110378,
-0.3679309487,
0.0821123645,
0.4435311854,
-0.6440483928,
0.3124273717,
0.582798183,
-0.0589502268,
-0.1810170561,
0.6536468863,
0.1778933704,
0.1421532482,
0.2960833609,
0.2932236195,
-0.1756128669,
-0.8758097291,
-0.416637361,
0.2945243418,
-0.1809586585,
-0.3699164391,
-0.7524471283,
-0.6062450409,
-0.274920851,
-0.0074985982,
-0.4324986339,
-0.2618280649,
-0.2186810076,
0.1573150903,
0.1085478216,
0.9539294243,
0.483766526,
0.4135245681,
-0.9776483774,
0.1992097944,
0.0595941134,
0.6786184311,
-0.0588514395,
-0.4984009564,
-0.3502722085,
-0.313285768,
-0.2706611753,
-0.9237022996,
0.525416255,
0.1198022142,
0.5380183458,
0.2584350109,
0.0329620279,
0.3142240047,
-0.9495563507,
0.6254317164,
0.2110571563,
-0.8995586038,
0.6960531473,
-0.1182052121,
0.4706661403,
0.4724218845,
0.4631181359,
-0.5689986944,
-0.4834129214,
-0.5696186423,
-0.6725082994,
0.7744487524,
0.3996854424,
0.2932074368,
-0.1108230725,
0.4212810695,
0.1448943317,
0.1190203205,
-0.6709883213,
-0.1032658666,
-0.0268171504,
-0.3621835709,
0.093055144,
-0.2860465348,
0.0074041919,
-0.0987638086,
0.4011318684,
-0.0407097638,
0.2011097968,
0.1361401379,
-0.0979737043,
-0.1191857755,
0.4128558934,
0.5340243578,
0.4766695201,
0.1079060733,
-0.1503635943,
0.2346430719,
-0.6297050118,
0.1133404821,
0.252679646,
-0.1476074904,
0.0327891856,
0.4971535504,
0.920093894,
0.2017282844,
-0.9485911727,
0.6570575833,
-0.3633367717,
0.0204169061,
0.1853013039,
0.0372407027,
-0.1887070686,
0.0735045075,
-0.0825370327,
0.3147818744,
0.190779224,
-0.010361068,
0.0531847849,
0.2910471857,
-0.3830683529,
-0.4569694698,
0.7327374816,
0.1982292235,
-0.3105611503,
0.6597183943,
-0.039203532,
-0.3610644937,
0.4229280055,
0.5423805714,
0.8706620932,
-0.3864649236,
0.1726064086,
0.3042780161,
0.2271881849,
-0.0314293839,
0.0180443097,
0.1265632361,
-0.7608938217,
-0.5496131778,
-0.7494506836,
-0.3071438372,
0.3667152226,
-0.5266894102,
0.1878617555,
-0.3835472763,
-0.6275749207,
0.2119797021,
-0.1354543418,
-0.8084177971,
0.202958703,
0.2526139021,
0.8318259716,
-0.7244319916,
0.8547052741,
0.8527264595,
-0.3162891865,
-0.5704749823,
0.0619226471,
-0.2195326686,
-0.7656951547,
0.4979654551,
0.064636521,
0.0118398797,
-0.2974148095,
-0.2118006051,
-0.3981350958,
0.7347800732,
0.5074759722,
-0.5136865973,
-0.3900173008,
0.1674822569,
0.9167177677,
-0.3529545069,
0.3199526072,
0.5469480753,
0.0729116797,
-0.1532405764,
-1.3969103098,
0.0265892819,
-0.4202435613,
0.2549776137,
0.1242256463,
-0.3554511666,
0.7247912288,
-0.2913556695,
-0.3763383329,
0.2130694091,
0.1150381565,
0.0780131742,
0.0786204338,
0.4226536751,
0.1990825683,
0.6113554239,
-0.1026348546,
1.2952600718,
-0.5859466195,
0.3276775777,
0.6251710057,
-0.300173521,
0.6845954061,
0.1832339913,
-0.0831960812,
0.252812624,
0.377545774,
-0.0356966257,
0.3830385506,
0.2000243068,
-0.3412513435,
-0.2311124951,
-0.5642954111,
-0.1988306791,
0.5832723379,
0.4499974847,
-0.6906633973,
-0.0951622874,
0.2481795996,
0.0311918333,
0.1268974543,
-0.2486391515,
0.8344422579,
0.1517589539,
-0.6036462784,
0.5634768009,
0.0552378222,
0.4077243507,
-0.5621283054,
0.1344853491,
-0.0825503543,
0.0074707884,
0.0486591235,
-0.4258258641,
0.3760529757,
0.4156480134,
-0.265602529,
-0.3837904334,
0.8954076767,
-0.2506841421,
-0.6000801921,
0.2369332314,
0.7620758414,
0.0077329385,
0.176050216,
-0.4675657749,
0.0272087213,
-0.0862607285,
-0.0918769017,
0.1901900619,
0.4242814779,
-0.0439561829,
0.6563131213,
0.2237027884,
0.3710012436,
-0.2666403353,
0.1532548517,
0.7222592831,
-0.5447583199,
-0.2616504133,
-0.9428579211,
0.2977961302,
0.1768631786,
-0.3099929094,
0.2771229148,
0.4181536436,
0.5560507774,
-0.2328893095,
0.8828678727,
0.1206376031,
0.6079651713,
-0.2699856758,
1.1403131485,
-0.5901994109,
0.154749617,
-0.1118218899,
-0.2770121992,
-0.634319663,
0.5289083719,
-0.4159847796,
0.1510332376,
0.628500402,
0.4521047473,
-0.0146101797,
-0.0230494961,
0.5563797355,
0.1378338784,
0.0666874647,
0.5804368258,
0.7655075192,
-0.2454660982,
0.5184684396,
-0.3001028001,
-0.3207924664,
-0.0527399331,
-0.7124091387,
-0.9648011327,
-0.628133297,
-0.2825321257,
-0.1158747748,
-0.1044141576,
0.9260034561,
0.9413284659,
-0.8134445548,
-0.201752305,
0.1101947054,
-0.1769735068,
0.0535161644,
-0.0835289881,
0.3230167329,
-0.3988066316,
-0.6886057258,
0.3204005659,
0.344938606,
0.271725446,
-0.1528567523,
0.1093389019,
0.2867797315,
0.1202806607,
0.5618106127,
0.1998266429,
-0.6815078855,
0.1403138638,
0.3495491147,
-0.2478386909,
-0.1144829839,
1.0309590101,
-0.8468241096,
0.5590353608,
0.2435355037,
0.7964153886,
0.0590613112,
-0.4255666733,
0.6412138939,
-0.6385654211,
-0.1521016359,
0.6314386129,
0.4664772749,
0.381550312,
-0.1789706349,
0.4307872951,
0.0527184047,
-0.6207167506,
-0.9397753477,
0.187352851,
-0.596363306,
-0.393091768,
1.002084136,
-0.0179833397,
0.0149464374,
-0.0093661789,
-0.1840349883,
0.4655548632,
-0.0176061802,
0.7813634872,
0.5789055228,
-0.2397327125,
0.0197517667,
-0.8159956932,
0.6406072378,
0.3990565538,
-0.8973079324,
0.1353200823,
0.3923297524,
0.1789828986,
0.2781573236,
0.7695846558,
-0.3279006779,
0.1619732231,
-0.2388927788,
0.1716902703,
0.1852159947,
-0.3643715084,
-0.6038694978,
0.1495786458,
0.1415767074,
-0.0199138653
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16605v1
|
CLEAR: Can Language Models Really Understand Causal Graphs?
| 2024-06-24T12:46:15 | 2024-06-24T12:46:15 |
Sirui Chen, Mengying Xu, Kun Wang, Xingyu Zeng, Rui Zhao, Shengjie Zhao, Chaochao Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ME
|
Causal reasoning is a cornerstone of how humans interpret the world. To model
and reason about causality, causal graphs offer a concise yet effective
solution. Given the impressive advancements in language models, a crucial
question arises: can they really understand causal graphs? To this end, we
pioneer an investigation into language models' understanding of causal graphs.
Specifically, we develop a framework to define causal graph understanding, by
assessing language models' behaviors through four practical criteria derived
from diverse disciplines (e.g., philosophy and psychology). We then develop
CLEAR, a novel benchmark that defines three complexity levels and encompasses
20 causal graph-based tasks across these levels. Finally, based on our
framework and benchmark, we conduct extensive experiments on six leading
language models and summarize five empirical findings. Our results indicate
that while language models demonstrate a preliminary understanding of causal
graphs, significant potential for improvement remains. Our project website is
at https://github.com/OpenCausaLab/CLEAR.
|
[
-0.1056879908,
-0.908395648,
0.9628021121,
0.2840873301,
-0.0007178605,
-0.1759125143,
-0.0581472293,
-0.7641521692,
-0.5222905278,
0.5306814313,
-0.5245410204,
-0.4835758805,
-0.6461663842,
0.02554808,
-0.6179146171,
0.6890062094,
-0.1031276435,
0.0825222507,
0.0161081478,
-0.1555004716,
-0.567792058,
0.0621067472,
-0.9178317785,
-0.6749207973,
0.6678087711,
0.2541293502,
0.7560886741,
0.8413372636,
0.3800650537,
0.3638829291,
-0.1775329858,
-0.0616347231,
-0.7445865273,
-0.1325320005,
-0.6722855568,
-0.3703762591,
-0.233767435,
0.0810273811,
0.5954523683,
1.4780249596,
0.0775889903,
0.1714629829,
-0.0023680383,
0.4306717515,
-0.6082640886,
0.6129263043,
-0.3147862554,
-0.1705125272,
0.0283296723,
0.172671631,
-0.8650246263,
-0.3337965906,
0.0113043012,
-0.716244638,
0.3516203165,
0.2255738378,
1.0814681053,
0.1693192422,
-0.999550283,
0.0334500447,
-1.0483219624,
0.2871136963,
-0.6557961106,
0.6021316648,
0.237714231,
0.4855186641,
-0.3150078654,
-1.1104928255,
-0.6318888664,
-0.1118316799,
-0.223843053,
-0.0352477655,
-0.3549295664,
0.2271681875,
0.5207089186,
0.1242648363,
-0.6281586289,
0.1214168221,
-0.4651921391,
-0.2036602646,
0.3983929455,
0.217772454,
0.7424618602,
0.0088892141,
-0.1537501067,
0.3317804039,
-0.6140884161,
-0.0056507122,
0.1911862791,
0.3841167688,
-0.2854495049,
0.2357999086,
-0.442165494,
1.0312197208,
-0.3487300575,
0.2341671735,
-0.2591282129,
-0.3392849565,
-0.431755811,
-0.0373018049,
0.634578824,
0.0815739781,
0.5472207665,
-0.4035544693,
0.2342375815,
0.0974545851,
0.0424416251,
-0.6911591887,
-0.4505749643,
0.1021365523,
-0.4271369278,
-0.0122075323,
-0.0896946713,
0.0476871431,
-0.754288733,
-0.4941671789,
0.1696070731,
-0.3151825666,
-0.4472445846,
0.6700737476,
-0.2263042182,
0.013133212,
0.5295987725,
-0.5359501243,
0.4589940012,
0.9061125517,
0.5278013945,
0.4016093314,
-0.4319964945,
-0.2761660814,
0.2040487975,
-0.4603090286,
0.8593044281,
-0.3608191013,
0.0903045014,
-0.0257231537,
-0.0259375274,
-0.2188203037,
-0.1464479864,
0.8111286759,
-0.6627459526,
0.1066222042,
-0.4042925835,
-0.7003541589,
-0.5837836862,
0.0773044154,
-0.8112579584,
0.374837786,
-0.3270556033,
-0.7074690461,
0.6353243589,
-0.2289773822,
-0.4105626047,
0.0910253599,
-0.0076017305,
0.0248664208,
0.0988447741,
-0.0286128316,
0.2644300163,
-0.6766129136,
0.8080599904,
-0.5745687485,
-0.2880007029,
0.3115705252,
-0.4030351341,
1.1053618193,
0.2373427302,
-0.3610918522,
0.2776650488,
-0.7145204544,
-0.1450958997,
0.0997365043,
0.1300459206,
-0.2480500787,
0.3579607308,
-0.1850696802,
0.3577331603,
0.0612350665,
-0.4892969429,
-0.0952612013,
-0.3475487828,
0.4361574352,
0.6428237557,
-0.0857797414,
0.1375117153,
0.069931291,
0.0428256132,
-0.2508694828,
0.2519437075,
-0.1563230157,
-0.5884152055,
-0.7049896121,
-0.1779494286,
-0.0635778233,
0.2321720272,
-0.2000891715,
0.2791951597,
-0.2611455023,
-0.4618727863,
-0.1817490011,
-0.1616578847,
0.6241450906,
1.0182514191,
0.2395235896,
-0.1314622611,
-0.334841162,
-0.8430001736,
-0.676163137,
-0.4917471409,
0.1070397124,
0.277128756,
0.6926831603,
-0.0513836779,
0.9190579653,
-0.8460191488,
0.3866006732,
-0.2507102787,
0.3912585974,
0.3895157874,
0.2328342944,
0.1603218913,
-0.6949685812,
-0.1629704386,
-0.0139784124,
-1.0470707417,
-0.3087863326,
-0.026519658,
-0.149716273,
-0.5535058975,
0.8733426332,
-0.2336176932,
0.4091963768,
0.242301017,
-1.0433204174,
0.5593237281,
-0.2474128008,
0.1074614823,
-0.2936413288,
0.4596713185,
-0.0811813921,
-0.3313560486,
-0.9587588906,
-0.0129026342,
0.088996172,
-0.3025710583,
-0.3162692189,
0.7384095192,
-0.1960605383,
0.071996592,
-0.0967478529,
0.2638069391,
0.1567458063,
0.3982324302,
-0.1042189226,
0.0868498832,
0.5229891539,
-0.5494064093,
0.0265584402,
0.0167703964,
-0.5836926699,
0.4802927077,
-0.8780081272,
-0.1585676074,
-0.3769498467,
0.2487935573,
-1.1902405024,
-0.3396162987,
0.2579294443,
-0.2674435675,
0.0720622614,
-0.1382646859,
-0.6547219753,
-0.3037881553,
0.4806134999,
0.4109947085,
0.1863591224,
-0.4188675284,
0.3094568551,
0.3280951977,
0.2324135303,
-0.4267264307,
-0.425691992,
0.0231253449,
0.1195209473,
-0.7986773252,
-0.0041276729,
-0.0515506677,
-0.5231569409,
0.1063701063,
-0.2330753505,
-0.3718355894,
0.392111659,
0.2272058874,
-0.2540857792,
-0.1160983145,
0.3274638951,
-0.0901358351,
-0.3363875747,
0.1555169076,
-0.363966912,
0.3940913081,
-0.2236555219,
-0.4663821757,
-0.6320518255,
-0.0674037635,
0.4993433952,
-0.3244344294,
0.8123805523,
0.3763286769,
-0.5774233937,
-0.0040342435,
-0.349761188,
-0.0105865933,
-0.4265762269,
0.1586893052,
-0.3565213978,
-0.8298865557,
0.7574359775,
-0.3184479475,
-0.2689881325,
0.5441255569,
0.1880560368,
0.1065308377,
1.4048216343,
0.6817455888,
0.1233518422,
0.3174390793,
0.0187114887,
0.3610008359,
-0.3327246606,
-0.3936855495,
-0.8302328587,
0.1096529365,
-0.3827012777,
-0.0524101704,
0.0291541405,
0.6011021137,
-0.851446569,
0.0784647912,
-0.186814636,
0.5911512971,
0.0703970492,
0.1032129973,
0.418697536,
-0.3603549898,
-0.0885666832,
0.2914559543,
-0.4923447371,
-0.64242661,
0.5509231687,
0.3501430154,
0.606951654,
0.2174449414,
0.2697559893,
0.0631532222,
0.4184288085,
-0.2487921715,
0.6161457896,
0.0504220612,
-0.8182790279,
-0.3207868636,
-0.5249396563,
-1.1248284578,
0.3235254586,
0.0041941395,
-0.9853730798,
0.1942760944,
0.1955470443,
0.1660239846,
0.2974332571,
-0.749733448,
1.4749513865,
-0.0116833383,
-0.3723520935,
-0.3301032484,
-0.7445855737,
0.7640151381,
0.2361011654,
0.5824614763,
-0.4791805446,
0.2972276211,
0.7205053568,
-0.5653889179,
1.0133836269,
-0.1980574727,
-0.1744326949,
0.294220686,
0.1962572932,
0.1909689158,
-0.1180124208,
-0.1880911142,
0.2484340519,
-0.299426347,
-0.5728597641,
-0.7615514994,
0.4697381854,
-0.6640371084,
-0.4348429739,
0.0007908545,
-0.4890633821,
0.0244926419,
0.7016444802,
-0.1497680396,
0.6006131768,
-0.2977938652,
-0.3516983688,
0.5282186866,
-0.2501548827,
0.0543356761,
0.8695583344,
-0.2698507607,
0.0410871319,
0.7700205445,
-0.1916799098,
0.3778786361,
0.3408189118,
0.5721160173,
-0.2018669695,
-0.4988316,
-0.1531568468,
0.5418329239,
-1.0917283297,
0.2652188838,
-0.4645889103,
0.1621117294,
-0.4158990085,
-0.1149524152,
0.0027482277,
-0.3769184649,
-0.0451079272,
-0.208195731,
0.0697011799,
1.0672307014,
-0.0873834118,
0.3386698961,
-0.4680438042,
0.3920007944,
0.2602468133,
0.5046446323,
0.2254759371,
-0.2737907469,
-0.0706148222,
-0.0478825644,
0.0514182337,
-1.124774456,
0.113865383,
-0.1373383254,
0.6025081277,
0.6794701815,
-0.1401155144,
0.6973211169,
-0.7007032633,
0.5743469596,
0.1847933829,
-1.2214052677,
0.591383934,
-0.4932559431,
0.3942432702,
0.4151734114,
0.3531673253,
-0.6731345057,
-0.7507041693,
-0.6230747104,
-0.6070509553,
0.6541707516,
0.2101812959,
-0.2862766087,
-0.0032878034,
0.5536088347,
-0.1524690539,
-0.0276379399,
-0.7800009847,
-0.3197211623,
-0.0063289274,
-0.2264393121,
-0.2208607793,
-0.0041438485,
-0.1401425004,
-0.2056627423,
0.2189408243,
0.0554803424,
-0.0118807284,
0.0493437275,
-0.3147263527,
-0.1106236055,
0.2302073836,
0.5229149461,
0.9977239966,
-0.1419377774,
0.5433692336,
-0.0409708321,
-0.2116098553,
-0.0098274611,
0.1109077409,
-0.1729108989,
-0.2779308856,
0.9798512459,
0.8429557085,
0.4863930047,
-0.6498416066,
0.36929968,
-0.2607161999,
0.1482311636,
0.2833772004,
0.1125987098,
0.1815233976,
0.0707191229,
0.0091655897,
-0.1051021144,
0.4134190381,
-0.5714352131,
0.0846398249,
0.1518167853,
-0.6207995415,
-0.453815788,
0.9340965748,
0.1141142994,
-0.1296859235,
0.6228030324,
-0.2290460169,
-0.5239837766,
0.8551920056,
0.7207972407,
0.7587792277,
-0.1197153777,
0.1484838277,
0.5224749446,
0.5637925863,
-0.1157449037,
0.3533239365,
0.01017839,
-0.8084164262,
-0.5778965354,
-0.353564322,
-0.3701115847,
-0.2217571735,
-0.4699692726,
0.1869987845,
-0.252361536,
0.1581217647,
0.3680095375,
-0.1934239715,
-0.6689397693,
0.4147454798,
-0.0428339429,
0.8772367835,
-1.2483751774,
0.4803746045,
0.2840099037,
-0.7324331403,
-0.9387370944,
-0.3377600014,
0.0454603583,
-0.6343921423,
1.1247526407,
0.325797528,
-0.3855315447,
-0.0461894833,
-0.6957367659,
-0.7292631865,
0.6562348604,
0.6323860884,
-0.2819856405,
0.1629878581,
0.118229188,
0.5783981681,
0.0733117685,
0.4006052911,
0.5874398351,
0.6708461046,
-0.1650553942,
-0.788154304,
0.3929629326,
-0.1713516861,
-0.3579312861,
0.3179076016,
-0.2141177505,
0.832147181,
-0.3409373164,
-0.6276459098,
-0.2782556415,
0.73270154,
-0.0176256262,
0.503465116,
0.5282638669,
0.3797183037,
1.0646047592,
-0.0885639787,
1.2494854927,
-0.4069774449,
0.4411201477,
1.1475923061,
-0.3083396554,
0.2712759078,
-0.1223414764,
0.0139036058,
0.7591408491,
0.3732945025,
0.441340059,
0.2879034281,
0.4554052055,
-0.1680342704,
-0.5923393369,
-0.3217790425,
-0.064933978,
0.1943415403,
0.4187702537,
-0.1356226355,
-0.4608533382,
-0.1891332567,
0.2751403451,
0.2165701389,
-0.4087894559,
0.4399072528,
0.0512317307,
-0.7001331449,
0.3959662616,
0.1130478606,
-0.2395825833,
-0.5704820752,
-0.0190009885,
0.0080730217,
0.2979973853,
-0.2531045079,
-0.8859760761,
0.2818265855,
-0.0754156411,
-0.0748918131,
-0.26019454,
0.8312814236,
-0.2973290384,
-0.2866782248,
0.3394508362,
0.4286123216,
0.1795694232,
0.1182477772,
-0.4933012128,
0.0293023996,
-0.2909606099,
0.2150184661,
-0.2162347734,
0.5083916783,
-0.2424889654,
0.8216527104,
0.5344612598,
0.0103514325,
-0.0436535329,
0.4523202181,
0.4987297058,
-0.68402946,
-0.3722659051,
-0.9626128078,
0.5126869082,
-0.1778949201,
-0.2072612047,
0.8399079442,
0.3965028524,
0.6793931723,
0.195092991,
0.4854010046,
0.1285590231,
0.1063222587,
-0.3683406115,
0.7170684934,
-0.4661882222,
-0.0052916589,
-0.3969913423,
-0.1942450553,
-0.7041379213,
0.4378628135,
-0.6011167169,
-0.0309730284,
0.7952635288,
0.52596277,
-0.0521897785,
0.176079154,
0.1235231757,
0.5442852378,
0.7404455543,
0.4814514816,
0.9238030314,
-0.1063170061,
0.4010056257,
0.0135570327,
-0.3492848873,
0.0691851452,
-0.913087368,
-0.7667728066,
-0.4531204998,
-0.4423029423,
-0.2232282758,
0.0190476999,
0.011789483,
0.5334170461,
-0.5219243765,
-0.3502006531,
-0.6694899797,
0.7753052711,
-0.395519793,
-0.1928721964,
0.5737592578,
-0.5177562237,
-0.3956135511,
0.294011265,
0.3400790393,
-0.3403686881,
-0.0788186491,
0.0200330783,
-0.2674226165,
0.1912616193,
0.5686584711,
0.5349005461,
-0.6699259877,
-0.5212781429,
-0.2565430403,
-0.2506455779,
-0.457529366,
1.1305817366,
-0.49358055,
0.8374894857,
0.8594038486,
0.0192363393,
0.4638497829,
-0.3333426416,
0.6592739224,
-0.3005601466,
0.1015596837,
-0.1818098575,
0.7067402005,
0.1735165715,
-0.0458070636,
0.5624916553,
0.2368765324,
-0.4311603904,
-0.954685092,
0.6604306102,
-0.7644987106,
-0.6660073996,
0.7830502391,
-0.1252443939,
-0.0397756174,
-0.5846663713,
-0.0795529634,
0.6501410604,
0.1809987426,
0.4284739494,
0.4458499849,
-0.3678774834,
0.1877523363,
-0.6174359918,
0.3158534169,
0.2001804858,
-0.8653786182,
0.3393965364,
0.7508327961,
0.2047461569,
0.0396197252,
0.7623439431,
0.0746280625,
0.2768018544,
-0.010360498,
-0.0726610944,
0.0329223871,
-0.4593233466,
-0.3350913823,
0.2398786098,
0.2684344053,
0.3437296748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16567v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16567v1
|
Data Augmentation of Multi-turn Psychological Dialogue via Knowledge-driven Progressive Thought Prompting
| 2024-06-24T12:02:56 | 2024-06-24T12:02:56 |
Jiyue Jiang, Liheng Chen, Sheng Wang, Lingpeng Kong, Yu Li, Chuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing dialogue data augmentation (DA) techniques predominantly focus on
augmenting utterance-level dialogues, which makes it difficult to take dialogue
contextual information into account. The advent of large language models (LLMs)
has simplified the implementation of multi-turn dialogues. Due to absence of
professional understanding and knowledge, it remains challenging to deliver
satisfactory performance in low-resource domain, like psychological dialogue
dialogue. DA involves creating new training or prompting data based on the
existing data, which help the model better understand and generate
psychology-related responses. In this paper, we aim to address the issue of
multi-turn dialogue data augmentation for boosted performance in the psychology
domain. We propose a knowledge-driven progressive thought prompting method to
guide LLM to generate multi-turn psychology-related dialogue. This method
integrates a progressive thought generator, a psychology knowledge generator,
and a multi-turn dialogue generator. The thought generated by the progressive
thought generator serves as a prompt to prevent the generated dialogue from
having significant semantic deviations, while the psychology knowledge
generator produces psychological knowledge to serve as the dialogue history for
the LLM, guiding the dialogue generator to create multi-turn psychological
dialogue. To ensure the precision of multi-turn psychological dialogue
generation by LLM, a meticulous professional evaluation is required. Extensive
experiments conducted on three datasets related to psychological dialogue
verify the effectiveness of the proposed method.
|
[
-0.739266634,
-1.0417497158,
0.8207656741,
0.4139866233,
-0.1601814628,
0.2150668055,
-0.3935629427,
-0.1078487188,
0.1376259178,
0.4651226103,
-1.3940556049,
-0.3905854225,
-0.1637308151,
0.1057576388,
0.0685806647,
0.8364737034,
0.2358677983,
0.2908292115,
-0.2117378712,
0.0684155971,
-0.8771621585,
-0.4231214523,
-0.6953387856,
-0.5226374269,
0.117742382,
0.337172389,
0.6019037962,
-0.1228427216,
0.0560258366,
0.2989608943,
0.0289324261,
0.5740125179,
-0.4180081785,
0.4867430031,
-0.0143118408,
-0.374982655,
-0.8059262633,
-0.1166931763,
0.6145871878,
0.5741745234,
-0.3277858794,
-0.0016032765,
-0.1156174168,
0.8246258497,
-0.4966726601,
0.1917171329,
-0.5717873573,
0.081496805,
0.0879954398,
-0.3796207309,
-0.379648447,
-0.6319858432,
0.1624996513,
-0.5521347523,
0.2895858586,
-0.4464705586,
0.206613183,
0.1640796065,
-0.1466899812,
-0.3090907931,
-0.9462306499,
0.5552865267,
-0.7858013511,
0.3133199811,
0.3088060915,
0.3014565706,
-0.3478785753,
-0.3473255932,
-1.0398520231,
-0.1699929237,
0.2524838746,
0.2441020757,
0.0687019452,
0.1674922109,
0.4030124843,
0.2805991769,
-0.269333899,
-0.1580908895,
0.0786581859,
-0.1104031578,
0.619971633,
0.5301680565,
-0.1247370914,
0.0575167462,
-0.0519584566,
-0.2339382768,
-0.569940865,
-0.0411569215,
0.5147294402,
0.2664557695,
0.1332780421,
0.4342578351,
-0.5324395895,
0.7901058793,
0.5313549042,
-0.4224139452,
0.4412965477,
-0.6317796707,
0.0482426547,
0.0061661587,
0.8254748583,
0.5462235808,
0.5045809746,
0.0418214463,
-0.0560376868,
0.0865271464,
0.3073760271,
-0.6489164829,
-0.0985407531,
0.3130677044,
-0.1783130169,
-0.1980841756,
-0.2926253974,
-1.1305698156,
-0.5386383533,
-0.5099053979,
0.1504573077,
-0.7665053606,
-0.5290131569,
0.1641932875,
0.0103955017,
0.1389615834,
0.4349349439,
-0.6835930347,
-0.1407293677,
0.480560571,
0.6299860477,
0.0204323251,
-0.0357975625,
-0.3785858154,
0.1255194396,
-0.2530190647,
0.730494082,
-0.7894685268,
-0.5701587796,
0.2409380525,
-0.3071900308,
0.047198724,
-0.3621889055,
0.4246515036,
-0.4590828121,
0.5259680152,
-0.0718682408,
-0.4921475053,
0.0371762775,
0.4164561629,
-0.3712693453,
0.9833530188,
-0.0687569305,
-0.7010580897,
0.4810513258,
-0.9308029413,
-0.4657660723,
0.2129907906,
-0.373726517,
-0.263733685,
-0.0993132964,
0.6829372644,
0.2700133324,
-0.1215994209,
0.5391498804,
-0.349206537,
-0.1563485712,
0.6311613321,
-0.7922452688,
0.4125521779,
-0.016709229,
-0.2631245255,
0.0684288815,
-0.8910397887,
0.2964528203,
-0.1948611587,
-0.1825644225,
-0.0016838902,
-0.1647269577,
-0.3780561984,
0.4006667137,
0.1765163541,
-0.6280186176,
0.3972172439,
-0.3722457886,
0.0507690199,
0.9147456288,
0.391801089,
0.2555953562,
-0.1464450806,
0.6206341982,
-0.007278475,
0.2797697484,
-0.2400621176,
-0.6574705243,
-0.5831632018,
-0.2518351972,
0.0142541016,
0.5363090038,
-1.0430256128,
0.6133090258,
-0.144984737,
-0.4047679901,
-0.8251006007,
-0.0103552388,
0.0741160959,
0.6928268671,
0.3355636597,
-0.0933713913,
-0.5511142015,
-0.6474139094,
-0.1863527298,
-0.1886603534,
-0.1311737299,
0.384242028,
-0.0184482094,
-0.3070599139,
1.2213033438,
-0.8407490253,
-0.1795851588,
-0.372623682,
0.363225311,
0.3455100656,
0.3421409726,
-0.0115553187,
-0.5591722131,
-0.2719567418,
-0.5174683332,
-0.6682242751,
-0.08296711,
-0.4103266299,
-0.3020043373,
0.0228975732,
0.1487820297,
-0.8075410724,
0.3064463437,
0.1849254966,
-0.1195305735,
0.9822872281,
-0.1060470864,
0.2988480031,
-1.068048954,
-0.1374909431,
0.0131687652,
0.1182158366,
-0.8962755203,
-0.3990414143,
-0.1306492239,
-0.0647122711,
-0.1653883606,
0.1829467416,
-0.1551212519,
0.3749599159,
-0.3920617998,
0.2295947969,
-0.0797313452,
0.5890923738,
0.400772959,
0.8776803613,
0.7261571884,
-0.8055495024,
0.5069681406,
0.4398139119,
-0.4032453001,
0.7860393524,
-0.1004274711,
0.4837712348,
-0.1079610884,
0.5425060391,
-0.8923698664,
-0.1839583367,
0.1119871438,
-0.3207663,
0.2461442351,
0.1305520087,
-0.5405161977,
-0.5117369294,
-0.3214022219,
0.3211155236,
0.4631607831,
-0.3775233328,
0.5057173371,
0.1898771971,
-0.5440979004,
-0.4864574373,
-0.3728129864,
0.1076288819,
-0.242471993,
-0.8826626539,
0.3367325068,
-0.3363055885,
-0.0390391573,
-0.5439269543,
0.060165152,
0.3027412593,
-0.4627887309,
0.067074351,
0.5221569538,
0.0925404727,
0.3234679699,
0.123659052,
-0.0669794679,
0.3723760843,
-0.2635945678,
0.8926949501,
0.0790711716,
-0.5031635761,
-0.431575954,
0.3744721711,
0.4831353426,
-0.1272766739,
0.7200552821,
0.8662967086,
-0.0567243658,
0.0810539201,
-0.8828774691,
-0.5717769861,
-0.5261279345,
0.2264719158,
-0.3900062442,
-0.7037388086,
0.2872139513,
-0.4828398824,
0.0254901107,
-0.1077083424,
0.8762818575,
-0.1376457214,
1.5298418999,
0.3908108771,
0.077635847,
0.6801329255,
-0.2288201898,
0.3830663562,
-1.1079195738,
-0.45154351,
-0.0271668993,
-0.1587759852,
-0.3680934906,
-0.3852614164,
0.6259580851,
-0.1616048217,
-0.120076783,
-0.2217140645,
-0.5006696582,
0.0334741101,
0.2637003958,
0.4029602408,
0.4517276287,
0.0549200438,
-0.1345875859,
-0.2327607125,
-0.550376296,
-0.2379835248,
1.1127302647,
0.2255619913,
0.950083971,
0.0006178899,
0.624103725,
0.2109293938,
0.2273275107,
-0.7889145613,
0.6441283822,
0.6010264158,
-0.3507508039,
-0.3195828795,
-0.4736567438,
-0.6789304018,
0.0454549678,
-0.2967072427,
-0.7127823234,
0.2013111711,
0.063456513,
-0.390602529,
-0.1004889831,
-0.486086607,
0.2099755406,
-0.2204146832,
-0.2536028624,
-0.4703255594,
-0.4603762329,
0.4777258039,
-0.1326761544,
0.1935772449,
0.1918685436,
0.3592765629,
0.7423818111,
-0.4130768776,
0.7900864482,
-0.5237441659,
-0.4182108045,
0.3817447424,
-0.0395205505,
0.7892770171,
0.2672595084,
-0.0609062165,
-0.3855134547,
-0.4053634405,
-0.1269894838,
-0.7875334024,
0.4094128907,
-0.5443452001,
-0.8758874536,
0.0210906845,
-0.7648694515,
-0.9812855124,
-0.0373679772,
0.2527533472,
0.3716325164,
-0.0891472101,
-0.2141391337,
0.7388235331,
-0.1194254979,
0.2962763309,
0.7170492411,
-0.1250266284,
-0.6212525368,
0.7839152813,
-0.1984306127,
0.3567878902,
-0.0566115081,
0.0895681158,
-0.705837667,
-0.3692320883,
-0.3876107931,
0.1791844666,
-0.6287226081,
-0.256757021,
-0.6551219821,
0.0656607524,
-0.592776835,
0.1806426793,
-0.1634929776,
-0.356184423,
0.1147247925,
-0.2099359334,
0.7319718599,
0.4446353316,
0.023683561,
0.3298538029,
-0.6573907137,
0.3722915947,
0.3659353256,
0.25624156,
0.2550218403,
-0.3750063777,
-0.2311230302,
0.3990724683,
-0.7040736675,
-1.0443953276,
0.2616244555,
0.1229559183,
0.485822916,
0.5922731161,
0.1535143107,
0.8896912336,
-0.3931989074,
0.9096575975,
0.4109528363,
-0.6440765858,
0.933114171,
-0.2588434517,
0.5129497051,
0.5468240976,
0.1415085196,
-0.4420480728,
-0.6501235962,
-0.6371025443,
-0.6795045137,
0.7128311396,
0.2619584501,
0.1619214118,
-0.0346035436,
0.2112186849,
0.1937807947,
0.4654851258,
-0.4318083227,
-0.2417461127,
-0.2216153592,
-0.0946059078,
0.1771687269,
0.1662033498,
-0.3700916469,
-0.274871856,
0.6629168987,
-0.4179799557,
0.4570816755,
0.2125713974,
0.168700844,
-0.1438118517,
0.4942545295,
0.3961519599,
0.60198313,
-0.1723751426,
-0.3829425275,
0.2162486166,
-0.5610243678,
0.2614843547,
0.0109239919,
-0.1196075752,
-0.071902588,
0.0939212218,
0.8591604829,
-0.3975952268,
-0.5540142655,
0.1550517231,
0.0094149476,
-0.0384828448,
-0.2362865359,
0.1453942955,
0.1117711589,
0.3058299124,
0.5130107403,
0.1614256352,
0.0951170176,
-0.6256311536,
0.0559646897,
0.558724463,
-0.0973385423,
-0.0382296406,
0.0613981746,
0.2571433187,
-0.3955198228,
0.8604602218,
-0.1618468463,
-0.5739386082,
0.0205404852,
0.6281786561,
0.8449832797,
-0.1937354952,
0.4538310468,
0.2466824055,
-0.2760772705,
0.0230137557,
0.578501761,
-0.3498586416,
-0.9026557207,
-0.9757668376,
-0.4373185635,
-0.5285557508,
0.5851862431,
-0.8382135034,
0.1053798348,
-0.180424884,
-0.6255067587,
-0.3272603154,
-0.1219254062,
-0.6909911036,
0.1288657635,
0.2613495886,
0.9798026085,
-0.6422604918,
0.7293789387,
0.6068388224,
-0.2790118456,
-0.6218343377,
0.378901124,
-0.1977107227,
-0.6643238068,
0.3213069439,
-0.0012827957,
-0.4097019732,
0.008225034,
-0.4088081717,
-0.3667928874,
1.0024601221,
0.2739048302,
-0.5516936779,
-0.0257736538,
0.2556491494,
0.7130793929,
-0.6120741963,
0.4260275662,
0.6230753064,
0.6621779203,
0.1719010621,
-0.6353469491,
0.1556889713,
-0.2441847324,
-0.1734603345,
0.0823076814,
-0.573030889,
0.4544174969,
-0.2293958217,
0.0138277607,
-0.0840128362,
0.6736129522,
0.7617459893,
0.3041844666,
0.521974206,
0.3836984634,
0.8966379762,
0.0530847237,
0.7384189367,
-0.3887131214,
0.0430432409,
1.0149956942,
-0.421866715,
0.495740205,
0.4750844836,
-0.2828664184,
0.9020900726,
0.4919692278,
0.0668056756,
0.6743742824,
-0.0990216583,
-0.7187661529,
-0.4336931705,
-0.0138881849,
-0.4295395315,
0.1696226001,
0.7905203104,
-0.1458280534,
0.0638091788,
0.2386930287,
-0.209117189,
-0.0980698466,
-0.1765714586,
1.1130549908,
-0.0913289636,
-1.1848590374,
0.7046815157,
-0.2726989985,
0.6251959801,
-0.5811082721,
-0.0809885263,
-0.204732731,
0.2108965814,
-0.2147009671,
-1.0962197781,
-0.0863983184,
0.1577982008,
-0.2273738235,
-0.2681332231,
0.6900839806,
-0.599116385,
-0.431722641,
0.0586381331,
0.710762918,
-0.0206169039,
-0.2891964912,
-0.759288013,
-0.2336994261,
0.1806313694,
-0.1297485232,
0.369292438,
0.5705798864,
0.1273282468,
0.8000790477,
0.7645874023,
0.2751165032,
-0.1498772949,
0.6774527431,
1.1409327984,
-0.5143241882,
-0.6921274066,
-0.8109397888,
0.547139883,
-0.3586336672,
-0.0567125641,
0.5700458288,
0.2583098114,
0.305944562,
-0.1644887626,
1.0041509867,
0.0113146119,
0.341070503,
-0.5673086047,
0.3395001888,
0.0068673361,
0.304271251,
-0.5173942447,
-0.9617128372,
0.3745379746,
0.6082437038,
-0.5384914279,
0.107130155,
0.5091432929,
1.0078488588,
0.1888473034,
0.4924319386,
0.0515079238,
0.0310369227,
0.5283173919,
0.5797240734,
1.1138827801,
0.0043849316,
0.6741399765,
0.0097599793,
-0.5236891508,
0.0563111156,
-0.7231837511,
-0.8161127567,
-0.4474353492,
-0.3379999697,
-0.6035279036,
-0.1023839861,
0.8061868548,
0.5963176489,
-0.6029484868,
-0.0162088256,
-0.4189355969,
-0.1157713458,
-0.4418559074,
-0.3750478327,
0.1375130266,
-0.5395687819,
-0.5842687488,
0.7540132403,
0.1511540413,
-0.1072598472,
-0.6380349398,
-0.326298207,
-0.1938919425,
0.1252549589,
0.4569036961,
-0.1691761911,
-0.5637887716,
-0.0558620133,
-0.0052944329,
0.3797816932,
0.1709120423,
1.069283247,
-1.1685667038,
0.7492240071,
0.3129832745,
0.3127089143,
0.6583396196,
0.1559073329,
1.1273373365,
-1.0695656538,
-0.0619703718,
0.3166529238,
-0.0316496007,
0.5201081038,
-0.6292395592,
0.2535863817,
0.1922252327,
-0.3727560639,
-0.7455541492,
0.5728643537,
-0.6483407021,
0.0158109572,
1.0156105757,
-0.0378668532,
0.3064930439,
-0.1832223088,
-0.5092376471,
0.4084771872,
-0.7494384646,
0.9315086007,
0.8732798696,
-0.8184085488,
-0.1879272014,
-0.2079567909,
0.7514330745,
0.533077538,
-0.7147254348,
0.345892787,
0.416467309,
-0.1064733192,
0.4368663728,
0.6743488312,
-0.1036667675,
0.2688974738,
-0.1194510385,
-0.1015124395,
0.011978698,
-0.0395289883,
-0.1249914095,
0.1374849826,
-0.2270071805,
-0.0294944607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16563v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16563v2
|
Are there identifiable structural parts in the sentence embedding whole?
| 2024-06-24T11:58:33 | 2024-07-02T14:14:48 |
Vivi Nastase, Paola Merlo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Sentence embeddings from transformer models encode in a fixed length vector
much linguistic information. We explore the hypothesis that these embeddings
consist of overlapping layers of information that can be separated, and on
which specific types of information -- such as information about chunks and
their structural and semantic properties -- can be detected. We show that this
is the case using a dataset consisting of sentences with known chunk structure,
and two linguistic intelligence datasets, solving which relies on detecting
chunks and their grammatical number, and respectively, their semantic roles,
and through analyses of the performance on the tasks and of the internal
representations built during learning.
|
[
-0.1872832477,
-1.0703066587,
0.8349320889,
0.166401431,
-0.2063913941,
0.2027469724,
-0.09238749,
-0.3495458066,
0.4820877612,
0.3516670763,
-0.4133434892,
-0.0893936679,
-0.7147188187,
-0.069927834,
-0.7928732634,
0.6629337668,
0.0337566845,
-0.069280453,
-0.52079916,
-0.0316483378,
-0.5488595963,
-0.4286232591,
0.0535848252,
-0.150522545,
0.2915152907,
0.2937285006,
0.8617726564,
1.1593519449,
0.3122070432,
0.340433687,
-0.0741971061,
0.0398506969,
-0.0645938963,
0.3227927387,
-0.2816496491,
-0.8913524151,
0.1402647048,
-0.2157534957,
0.8709858656,
0.7854120731,
0.1338155866,
0.1179836318,
-0.0319530405,
0.4483540058,
-0.4603568316,
0.3669688106,
-0.3784666359,
0.2083240449,
-0.4572239816,
0.0967151597,
-0.4076060057,
0.0029687113,
0.0291207004,
-0.1912963539,
0.1451349705,
0.0210738983,
0.9887146354,
0.3366851807,
-0.5302463174,
-0.4786427617,
-0.6588489413,
0.6322450638,
-0.2671704292,
0.3977329433,
0.4228778183,
-0.1132584661,
-0.2079173625,
-0.4123498201,
-0.4453157485,
-0.0003509726,
-0.6134335995,
-0.0694391951,
-0.2629736364,
0.0007776782,
0.0807280615,
0.4262845218,
-0.3930489123,
0.0810384005,
-0.4640620053,
-0.2772247493,
0.4835231304,
0.0665605739,
0.7979201078,
-0.5507948995,
-0.1788662225,
-0.1126794666,
-0.5859544277,
0.1334542036,
0.4132269323,
0.1167149246,
-0.118741639,
1.0483224392,
0.0506373569,
0.6539229155,
-0.0185606778,
0.2187516391,
0.3380275369,
-0.1777340621,
-0.1501119882,
0.3174767196,
0.5896258354,
-0.2939673066,
0.4022703171,
-0.443949908,
-0.1592880636,
0.2596308589,
0.4803928733,
-0.3526453078,
-0.1593800187,
0.3855801523,
-0.3409675062,
-0.0869525,
0.5171711445,
-0.3578110337,
-0.0734632537,
-0.205485329,
0.2925013304,
-0.6483542323,
-0.3114825189,
0.0377844386,
-0.5044239163,
0.4318603277,
-0.3390719295,
-0.8298367262,
0.3644317091,
0.9602916241,
0.7527318597,
0.2062156647,
-0.4247766733,
-0.504840374,
0.0368019678,
-0.2355926484,
0.8810243011,
-1.0050264597,
-0.0175267421,
0.1422174871,
0.2403234392,
-0.1829865873,
-0.4223237336,
0.2495571822,
-0.4290745556,
0.1804891825,
-0.1868104041,
-1.0455203056,
-0.2364807725,
0.0591625832,
-0.9236952066,
1.012812376,
0.1927130669,
-0.8647649884,
0.2297756821,
-0.3556285501,
-0.5330753326,
0.1392540336,
-0.558169961,
-0.3668875098,
0.6622377038,
-0.0001126854,
0.6141290665,
0.0282483958,
0.2783447504,
0.1134373397,
-0.2848555148,
0.7085413933,
-0.0982788652,
0.299484849,
-0.0175513923,
-0.3376325965,
0.1732474566,
-0.7587051392,
-0.1163036674,
0.2159887552,
-0.4061388671,
-0.5666463971,
0.3223589659,
-0.0607020743,
-0.0067552957,
0.1174610853,
-0.8943224549,
0.0997004732,
-0.2095006853,
0.7405104637,
0.5100750923,
0.0416639894,
0.4502429664,
-0.3353149295,
0.2859545946,
0.6161990762,
-0.2211689949,
-0.3457904756,
-0.5629003644,
-0.9898506999,
-0.3526023626,
0.481675595,
0.4956353605,
-0.6050912738,
0.751203835,
-0.4304836094,
-0.0919271186,
-0.744461298,
-0.1771519184,
0.3672281802,
-0.0693012252,
0.3397655785,
-0.0380303115,
-0.6357033253,
-1.1126759052,
-0.4148057401,
0.0451651923,
-0.1911464036,
-0.204400748,
0.7768266797,
0.1362395883,
1.1614367962,
-0.5886077881,
0.0764022171,
-0.2805955708,
-0.1084179506,
-0.1246785074,
0.4197294116,
0.3255968094,
-0.9238661528,
-0.1389132142,
-0.2898721695,
-0.78964746,
0.2361742854,
-0.2681874931,
-0.1352404505,
-0.5433254242,
0.577229321,
-0.5446083546,
0.3343600929,
0.2585028112,
-0.7634205222,
-0.0168393701,
-0.2522366643,
-0.2063830197,
-0.9224629998,
-0.5672743917,
0.0036125358,
-0.3927557468,
-0.7580824494,
0.033076752,
0.2883615196,
0.2649396062,
-0.2075906545,
0.0823616236,
-0.6517481804,
-0.1329337806,
-0.1235640794,
0.2884778082,
-0.0557813719,
0.429397583,
-0.0089828968,
0.2739107609,
0.4570814669,
-0.2077961564,
0.1732419133,
0.3009573817,
-0.7843986154,
0.538528204,
-0.6624016166,
-0.0480980165,
-0.6472026706,
-0.0610273182,
-0.8668889999,
-0.5342978835,
-0.0052458048,
-0.1410984695,
0.174929142,
-0.1724655181,
-0.5353855491,
-0.1889348328,
-0.0627467036,
0.4003902972,
0.4721724689,
-0.2933866382,
0.6107956171,
0.5960317254,
-0.0004897567,
-0.3809529841,
-0.9205152988,
-0.2254790664,
-0.1304994375,
-0.5996887088,
0.5001516938,
0.377063632,
-0.3208070993,
0.6376478672,
-0.0101612508,
-0.3188849092,
-0.0056242719,
0.5921153426,
0.1012466401,
-0.4091678858,
0.5043930411,
0.0654583648,
0.2542761564,
0.0327233039,
-0.2555042803,
0.5740481615,
-0.0913709253,
-0.3662347794,
-0.1170137748,
0.4914296865,
0.5468401909,
-0.3617447317,
0.9250847697,
0.2913216352,
-0.5232568383,
-0.2987510264,
-0.431308955,
0.0870965794,
-0.3778478503,
0.5235599279,
-0.5481093526,
-1.0545510054,
0.4761400223,
0.2851654291,
-0.2569352388,
0.6587310433,
0.3242497742,
-0.1158241928,
0.5473243594,
0.5794683695,
-0.1094871163,
0.5735800862,
-0.1346640587,
0.168122232,
-0.8283154368,
-0.5602455735,
-0.3689068258,
-0.5639297366,
-0.3940421045,
-0.5423320532,
0.0116051231,
0.1241204217,
-0.3768498003,
0.4407829344,
-0.5301643014,
0.7464774251,
0.5143056512,
0.27782318,
-0.0286004897,
-0.225641191,
-0.2016222328,
0.1293364018,
-0.5696189404,
-0.3052430749,
0.6921585202,
0.455855757,
0.4778949916,
0.0348149911,
0.2949800193,
0.3552457392,
-0.359757781,
-0.8509934545,
0.2756620049,
-0.2245639712,
-0.4707993865,
-0.0719718635,
-0.4239586592,
-0.980697751,
0.3046523333,
-0.2460861802,
-0.5931614041,
0.2668593228,
-0.5133419037,
-0.166320771,
0.343927145,
-0.724781692,
0.6851102114,
-0.2464563847,
0.2945402563,
-0.0838250145,
-0.6052528024,
0.0147165097,
0.1834741682,
0.2720841765,
-0.2510232329,
0.0611080192,
0.9924026132,
-0.3365837634,
0.8471568227,
-0.0449435562,
0.4214152396,
0.4664501548,
-0.1040236577,
0.2769941092,
-0.3244625628,
0.2917506099,
-0.0589674786,
0.0897658393,
-0.5511261225,
-0.7376359105,
0.4060080945,
-0.7535505891,
-0.3324193954,
-0.2938251495,
-0.6319209337,
0.0693347231,
0.0404527485,
0.117697075,
0.721056819,
-0.1323043853,
0.6848109961,
0.5265225172,
0.0028910579,
0.6073079109,
0.2223110944,
0.0646599084,
-0.0196608584,
0.6035916805,
0.28199929,
0.0639975592,
0.7394812703,
0.156513989,
0.0379377492,
-0.279038161,
-0.3156477213,
0.4310668707,
-0.6337952018,
-0.0622618161,
-0.6279557347,
-0.5232790709,
0.0250853617,
0.0577093214,
-0.4209380746,
-0.5331850648,
-0.1220556423,
-0.5972556472,
0.3623176515,
1.3932753801,
0.3594551384,
0.4182530046,
-0.8788164854,
0.0161202047,
0.0699609146,
0.3018939495,
0.1244605854,
-0.2402212322,
-0.4731751084,
0.0768490061,
0.1344048083,
-0.8799217939,
0.0605124645,
0.1889186203,
0.5860369205,
0.3466862738,
-0.1933885962,
0.4364057481,
-0.620379746,
0.9557932019,
-0.2610557973,
-0.9693636894,
0.4673790038,
0.1482259929,
0.422709167,
0.1786236465,
0.6687490344,
-0.4734293222,
-0.5785649419,
-0.556676805,
-0.6053144336,
0.4120052159,
0.2585127354,
0.2059382349,
-0.4142059386,
0.4235839546,
-0.0963463709,
-0.000281752,
-0.5828852057,
-0.0257925279,
-0.2111279219,
-0.5426803231,
0.2949234843,
-0.6297702789,
-0.1373270154,
0.050728783,
0.0755117089,
0.1811570525,
0.4041705728,
0.226420626,
-0.5538653135,
0.3809623718,
0.4059711993,
0.3606533408,
0.3400588334,
0.1324444562,
0.4439077377,
-0.2462412119,
-0.5744346976,
0.1215404347,
-0.2718340755,
-0.013997186,
-0.0082057249,
0.8722907305,
0.8096260428,
0.512904942,
-0.6157747507,
0.6321427822,
0.0777197927,
0.0397319123,
-0.3604756594,
0.0737176463,
0.0820408687,
0.538005054,
0.2315174192,
-0.178775996,
-0.1895167232,
-0.8489449024,
0.4593349099,
0.1561848372,
-0.7827756405,
-0.6664101481,
0.3182111084,
-0.1907957047,
-0.2697460651,
1.0001991987,
0.0038971133,
-0.7908724546,
0.5982062221,
0.4856970906,
0.6844823956,
-0.0994495153,
0.3840428889,
-0.1382716745,
0.3424927294,
-0.1473400444,
0.3368034065,
0.0257236753,
-1.0617594719,
-0.414329052,
-0.6298196912,
0.0539500155,
-0.3494145274,
-0.8089630604,
-0.039001558,
-0.1415740699,
0.1591245234,
0.3207341135,
-0.5265869498,
-0.6678430438,
0.1422087252,
0.2462159246,
0.7019689679,
-1.0927805901,
0.8468693495,
0.5766322613,
-0.5865027308,
-0.6606764793,
-0.0879505351,
-0.1167108044,
-0.637568891,
0.7069811821,
0.1649808735,
0.2174365819,
-0.4593087435,
-0.2731811702,
-0.8572528958,
0.8066622615,
0.1491628885,
-0.239553526,
-0.5586432815,
0.5137045979,
0.3903430402,
-0.6038831472,
0.2644609809,
0.6257102489,
0.339025408,
-0.0424977392,
-0.531509161,
0.1785028726,
-0.2269797623,
-0.078234069,
0.4640217721,
-0.4477797151,
1.0633989573,
0.3276458085,
-0.3732132316,
-0.2137550414,
0.7375267744,
-0.3998144865,
-0.3444185555,
0.5311200023,
0.6469680071,
0.9288549423,
-0.4184993207,
1.1106770039,
-0.2566480041,
0.1353422403,
1.0244259834,
0.3632190228,
0.9681902528,
0.1721886694,
-0.0765045509,
0.9714635611,
0.4730927944,
-0.1889115721,
0.6206555367,
0.3057336807,
-0.0117332349,
-0.0444021672,
-0.0325848125,
-0.0546421334,
0.7596457601,
0.6595847011,
-0.4835984707,
0.0197613202,
0.2974151075,
0.2387981117,
0.0046216561,
-0.1941586584,
0.7054020166,
-0.0424110852,
-0.573844254,
0.0829458013,
0.0274353623,
0.4875851572,
-0.5666098595,
0.0314437039,
-0.0321441367,
0.2003309131,
-0.4382404089,
-1.0652097464,
0.7407603264,
-0.1673791111,
-0.4221554995,
-0.2763955593,
0.5569325089,
-0.6163578629,
-0.4362506568,
0.1508843154,
0.4501622319,
0.1335725188,
-0.3182695508,
0.0298792627,
0.0335637778,
-0.0028219256,
-0.1816461682,
0.316714555,
0.7050997019,
-0.018706236,
0.3101637959,
0.2370193154,
0.0096326685,
0.4776523113,
-0.076015763,
0.8822171688,
-0.9504308701,
-0.5118079782,
-1.055236578,
0.5965270996,
-0.2786601782,
-0.2393942028,
0.751216948,
0.6993017793,
0.8751941919,
0.0298540685,
0.6043698192,
-0.1146104634,
0.2568161786,
-0.6498271227,
0.3825522661,
-0.1199796125,
0.0213610511,
0.1069418192,
-0.8027023077,
-0.2111208886,
0.557954669,
-0.2898100019,
-0.4316502512,
0.9104643464,
0.3742061853,
-0.2121012509,
0.370565176,
0.2242625505,
0.3998140991,
0.2531033754,
0.3377382159,
0.9566796422,
-0.3356196284,
0.2476667166,
-0.2168364823,
-0.0753631592,
0.0248052869,
-0.4026782513,
-0.8409748673,
-0.9845044017,
-0.1623762846,
-0.1128970906,
-0.2162098885,
0.5966752768,
0.5491928458,
-0.6859738827,
-0.1334693581,
-0.0330512263,
0.2205728441,
-0.1948633194,
-0.238256827,
0.4827629924,
-0.2582479417,
-0.415722847,
0.6582314372,
0.4064787328,
-0.0321750566,
-0.2281288803,
0.5990470052,
-0.3646350503,
0.4514756501,
0.5428695679,
-0.078296043,
-0.6873677373,
-0.8085793257,
0.0065598995,
-0.0033500963,
0.2353085577,
1.0444190502,
-0.6078622341,
0.3603380322,
0.6779980659,
0.754801929,
0.5474812388,
0.1132782325,
0.5333789587,
-1.1193970442,
0.4359628558,
0.1059652641,
0.6455987692,
0.2305066288,
-0.4301055372,
0.4286940992,
-0.049331218,
-0.4044850171,
-0.491678834,
0.3209245801,
-0.743016839,
-0.4560521841,
0.8257936239,
-0.3438112438,
-0.5425364971,
-0.2426934689,
0.1662538648,
0.1070588008,
0.082847774,
0.3370624185,
1.0743033886,
-0.2310463041,
-0.1043134034,
-0.3440713882,
0.1261659414,
0.1203161553,
-0.5909987092,
-0.2846410573,
0.3651581705,
0.3068310022,
0.524061203,
0.0487594604,
-0.1970335245,
-0.3205687404,
0.3100642264,
-0.2927397788,
-0.0509978533,
-0.5465908051,
-0.0569587685,
0.5660282373,
-0.343318671,
-0.5235314369
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16562v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16562v2
|
EVALALIGN: Supervised Fine-Tuning Multimodal LLMs with Human-Aligned Data for Evaluating Text-to-Image Models
| 2024-06-24T11:56:15 | 2024-06-27T03:57:05 |
Zhiyu Tan, Xiaomeng Yang, Luozheng Qin, Mengping Yang, Cheng Zhang, Hao Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
The recent advancements in text-to-image generative models have been
remarkable. Yet, the field suffers from a lack of evaluation metrics that
accurately reflect the performance of these models, particularly lacking
fine-grained metrics that can guide the optimization of the models. In this
paper, we propose EvalAlign, a metric characterized by its accuracy, stability,
and fine granularity. Our approach leverages the capabilities of Multimodal
Large Language Models (MLLMs) pre-trained on extensive datasets. We develop
evaluation protocols that focus on two key dimensions: image faithfulness and
text-image alignment. Each protocol comprises a set of detailed, fine-grained
instructions linked to specific scoring options, enabling precise manual
scoring of the generated images. We Supervised Fine-Tune (SFT) the MLLM to
align closely with human evaluative judgments, resulting in a robust evaluation
model. Our comprehensive tests across 24 text-to-image generation models
demonstrate that EvalAlign not only provides superior metric stability but also
aligns more closely with human preferences than existing metrics, confirming
its effectiveness and utility in model assessment.
|
[
-0.5051145554,
-0.7978248,
0.4677233696,
0.1999436617,
-0.2753751576,
0.1648230106,
-0.3828242719,
-0.287723273,
-0.0044034105,
0.4094406068,
-0.4513808787,
-0.7419440746,
-0.4967341423,
0.1459013075,
-0.4313369095,
0.8997958302,
-0.3550592959,
0.1499675363,
-0.6243401766,
-0.2809806764,
-0.3507218063,
-0.2079159766,
-0.5753329396,
-0.0777535513,
0.5595939755,
0.2943763137,
0.88056916,
0.4736606479,
0.7119013071,
0.3368700147,
0.3178876638,
0.8368587494,
-0.5217676163,
0.3063519895,
-0.1328861713,
-0.081246689,
-0.4876143932,
-0.0670319349,
0.5132114291,
0.4189577401,
0.0819843262,
0.6570012569,
0.1028075069,
0.7879293561,
-0.8014971614,
-0.0885647088,
-0.7436350584,
-0.1305744946,
0.015460033,
-0.6453877091,
-0.5953086615,
-0.3710702956,
-0.3224101961,
-0.5114849806,
0.0690045133,
0.4577105939,
1.0895975828,
0.3860450685,
-0.4064435661,
-0.1479783505,
-0.6767130494,
0.8510323763,
-0.302567631,
0.482003808,
0.3816279769,
0.2558660209,
0.0350649878,
-0.6091226339,
-0.3664495349,
-0.3770682514,
-0.1152960882,
0.2062993646,
-0.1390040666,
0.0895327032,
-0.1469713449,
0.1680478752,
-0.5964182019,
0.3940572739,
-0.3533809781,
-0.2077742517,
0.6564862132,
0.4692963362,
0.3255330622,
0.0184012186,
-0.7884685397,
-0.0070195678,
-0.7628461123,
0.0955796987,
0.4032236338,
0.167266354,
-0.1233340129,
0.7333171964,
0.0453953631,
0.5897099972,
0.2725284696,
-0.0335723124,
-0.0239939466,
-0.4491277337,
-0.2463084608,
-0.0861799344,
0.9825313091,
0.9680678844,
-0.0157550834,
-0.1282907426,
-0.5679942966,
0.1878912896,
0.4920016527,
-1.0019317865,
-0.0925531313,
0.3215146959,
-0.6522833109,
-0.4291420579,
0.0420319326,
-0.7468692064,
-0.2095962912,
-0.8135488033,
0.5743851066,
-0.3722694814,
0.1669162512,
-0.0799902529,
0.2379380465,
0.0221316237,
0.5718169212,
-0.9778054357,
0.1842214167,
0.6362977624,
0.9671981931,
-0.2917667925,
-0.4264315963,
-0.6305603385,
-0.0517326221,
-0.7332082391,
0.9431492686,
-0.5182505846,
-0.097972028,
0.0692780688,
-0.008009769,
0.0425824448,
-0.394300431,
0.6607444286,
-0.4594452083,
-0.0063458937,
0.2800142765,
-0.3654153049,
0.1159673557,
0.4034501016,
-0.5822787881,
1.1258214712,
0.2034444958,
-0.4226357639,
0.4550589323,
-0.509995997,
-0.1859051436,
-0.0949350595,
-0.1328996122,
-0.7406839132,
0.4306535125,
0.5632449389,
0.7913575768,
-0.315441072,
0.2803990543,
-0.2543586791,
-0.3839442432,
0.5092545748,
-0.8044552207,
0.3495333791,
0.2256253064,
0.0514564961,
0.446152389,
-0.6703761816,
0.3331503868,
-0.1503928006,
-0.2088585347,
-0.3049621284,
-0.1384602785,
0.4850826263,
0.1110742316,
0.3114005327,
-0.329072237,
0.1560584456,
-0.0977379233,
0.2478315979,
0.8357353806,
-0.132307291,
0.6206231713,
-0.3729112744,
0.6033818126,
-0.3192465901,
0.3395466506,
-0.4422151148,
-0.1551543325,
-0.8893683553,
-0.5213851929,
0.4588432312,
0.1327902079,
-0.5582928658,
0.5258885026,
-0.6714130044,
-0.5954306722,
-0.9444792271,
0.3186418712,
0.4472975433,
0.1574681252,
0.3851615191,
-0.5176981688,
-0.2263952047,
-1.1486308575,
0.1539656371,
0.0487751253,
0.0238178764,
0.4053344727,
0.4244972169,
-0.4638483822,
0.7573898435,
-0.164947927,
-0.4451517761,
0.2101829201,
0.604209125,
-0.3308259249,
0.4218076468,
0.6436905265,
-0.5726316571,
-0.5125342607,
0.3220680356,
-0.5563639402,
-0.2177468687,
-0.4989905059,
-0.3739266098,
0.3345051706,
0.3598264456,
-0.565330267,
0.3783022463,
0.9656538367,
-0.2434398234,
0.7050301433,
-0.3455018997,
0.6263552904,
-0.9182646275,
0.0298335087,
0.1491403431,
-0.4660517871,
-0.4858066738,
0.1832442731,
0.4456040859,
-0.0701435357,
-0.4860553443,
0.6633527279,
-0.5342812538,
0.1757712066,
-0.1869500577,
0.0793538764,
0.4333266914,
0.293918401,
0.0081550293,
0.8827345967,
0.5215270519,
-0.3824742734,
0.4433270097,
0.1564287096,
-0.596370399,
1.0732321739,
-0.4992910326,
0.2457993031,
-0.1287716329,
0.0229576081,
-0.9816643596,
-0.1830119789,
-0.1276555657,
-0.4271276593,
0.4823144972,
0.0873732865,
-0.5669397712,
-0.0749145895,
-0.5128564835,
0.6252425909,
0.2105266005,
-0.7326609492,
0.6777361035,
0.1690146178,
-0.0854225904,
-0.4711005092,
-0.3532830477,
0.1816527247,
-0.1631784141,
-0.6545854211,
0.3965384662,
-0.0169623122,
-0.1835945249,
-0.1653598249,
0.1276942343,
0.027804831,
-0.1693186164,
0.706938684,
0.4863212705,
-0.2046482563,
0.2208509594,
0.1858502179,
-0.2384227365,
-0.2071971893,
0.0733289272,
0.5303202271,
-0.2382767498,
-0.6910367608,
-0.6810287237,
0.2436537296,
0.7999427319,
-0.3417129219,
0.6105101705,
0.8209789395,
-0.1348956823,
0.0422051772,
-0.6649742723,
-0.1674332172,
-0.4787798524,
0.5406304598,
-0.3135792017,
-0.617449522,
0.1696895212,
-0.3279413283,
0.1100056916,
0.3341279626,
0.8827803135,
-0.4778516293,
1.1366152763,
0.4971769452,
0.1202934682,
0.2328904569,
-0.1051738262,
0.0309585594,
-0.8924002051,
-0.2920072079,
-0.2640299499,
-0.505749464,
-0.2319591641,
-0.5398063064,
0.2718847096,
0.1030217037,
-0.2388633788,
0.2292665243,
-0.5264719725,
0.5454016328,
0.2515742481,
0.256026268,
0.2951153517,
0.2220064253,
0.1288860887,
-0.2751761079,
-0.2356592119,
-1.0174044371,
1.1604244709,
0.4580549598,
1.1520826817,
-0.0195934568,
0.4913158417,
0.2692923546,
0.6118493676,
-0.7034808397,
0.3474344015,
-0.1018468589,
-0.4523645043,
-0.220591858,
-0.2094686031,
-0.9576683044,
0.1196569651,
-0.5589547753,
-0.6765048504,
-0.0141899372,
0.2632327974,
-0.460893482,
0.0363957323,
-0.8727762103,
0.8822197318,
-0.9178692102,
-0.6961510777,
-0.1608774662,
-0.4120826721,
0.2465838045,
-0.2987040579,
0.1583873928,
-0.3818835616,
-0.294894129,
0.3225174844,
-0.1855469048,
0.7829341292,
0.2176180631,
-0.1996529698,
-0.0226876326,
0.3118068874,
0.4568629563,
0.0345792584,
0.0240787584,
0.2561548054,
0.1087690368,
-0.1323312521,
-0.8045491576,
0.7997063994,
-0.7465274334,
-0.1761457175,
0.1039173901,
-0.4450809062,
-0.0384802148,
-0.1659156382,
0.1925912201,
0.5384849906,
-0.4351899028,
0.3166542053,
0.2243804932,
-0.0727399513,
0.1963033378,
0.2186829746,
-0.508233726,
-0.6139822006,
1.0779474974,
-0.3556298316,
0.4577021003,
0.5276107788,
-0.1787899137,
-0.4428977072,
-0.4011975527,
-0.7313269973,
-0.0598451085,
-0.7099131942,
-0.6395685673,
-0.3055129349,
-0.1021474153,
-0.0719395652,
-0.5402165055,
-0.7300093174,
-0.2211571783,
-0.5926446319,
0.1037396342,
0.2400485873,
0.3981488645,
0.3065286279,
0.2437057793,
-0.801417172,
0.3572298586,
0.1879754066,
0.3373807371,
-0.2171263695,
-0.7168468833,
-0.2171713263,
-0.0361867584,
-0.6300367117,
-0.4377338886,
0.4663659334,
0.4594106078,
0.3055000305,
0.7491348982,
-0.0566448756,
0.9875166416,
-0.6008146405,
0.7432240844,
0.588531971,
-0.8550108075,
0.5173633695,
-0.0814484432,
0.0588687994,
0.7648503184,
0.2792327702,
-0.3482591808,
-0.3984597027,
-0.3925636113,
-0.9694304466,
0.2105728984,
0.2259634882,
0.6239347458,
0.3504738808,
0.1437693983,
0.4044517875,
0.0072641573,
-0.7347374558,
-0.1113810837,
-0.11691311,
-0.5206146836,
0.0764521137,
-0.2282134145,
-0.3502036333,
-0.3836826682,
0.5180658102,
-0.2963202,
0.0958637893,
-0.2396980226,
-0.2931966782,
-0.2461423278,
0.2185960114,
0.8786382675,
0.7034811974,
-0.0769305378,
0.3119115531,
0.0186512582,
-0.3096990883,
0.3962582648,
-0.087809369,
-0.0861491486,
-0.0753288269,
0.3826355636,
0.9940629601,
0.261204809,
-0.7901696563,
0.680015564,
-0.1372200549,
-0.3214395344,
-0.1508384794,
-0.0033182269,
-0.2855149806,
0.2540383637,
0.2150530964,
0.5278509855,
-0.2079984695,
-0.1914801002,
0.0997368023,
0.7464446425,
-0.5388906002,
-0.2945435643,
0.7014541626,
0.3937901556,
-0.3610451519,
0.4882908762,
-0.0791812614,
-0.2505919635,
0.4779488146,
0.4017907083,
0.8255608082,
0.0591468737,
0.3362048566,
0.3699859977,
0.4561669827,
-0.0169645157,
-0.0948884711,
-0.0006735785,
-0.6963364482,
-0.2528848052,
-0.7789083719,
-0.2751767635,
0.1266586185,
-0.5555245876,
0.5254665613,
-0.3666072488,
-0.5040203929,
-0.0667029694,
-0.3088160455,
-0.7677081227,
0.0951857716,
0.2290681303,
0.5097647905,
-0.9057099223,
0.5085989237,
0.678417325,
-0.3099975288,
-0.5310798287,
-0.2110471129,
-0.1060010865,
-0.8187259436,
0.7141838074,
0.4523534477,
-0.1925348639,
-0.0247213524,
-0.6121612787,
-0.714535296,
1.2221240997,
0.5231463313,
-0.7300704718,
0.435788542,
0.0519844927,
0.5825235248,
-0.5591938496,
0.5157235861,
0.4360307753,
0.608009696,
-0.083640866,
-0.9206136465,
-0.1783864945,
-0.2760225832,
0.2221616954,
0.1574149728,
-0.5348445773,
0.3965279162,
-0.3253889978,
-0.3634350002,
0.4984959066,
0.597443223,
0.2231732458,
0.3663086295,
0.2043538839,
0.577434063,
0.536474824,
-0.2236218899,
0.8691937327,
-0.4984139204,
0.5800480843,
0.9624648094,
-0.1088259295,
1.0393987894,
0.7268592119,
-0.1650716066,
0.159541294,
0.8230298758,
-0.2793276906,
0.5541282892,
-0.1278162897,
-0.2168165892,
-0.4704202712,
-0.2905457616,
0.0357016847,
0.5728906989,
0.3537595272,
-0.7104414105,
-0.1269905716,
0.0466100127,
-0.3987485766,
0.3055862486,
-0.4044126868,
0.6213228106,
-0.1511511654,
-0.4684613943,
0.7719498277,
0.0524205193,
0.7263751626,
-0.286162436,
0.0806741193,
-0.14886415,
0.0839746818,
-0.3749670088,
-0.7868093848,
-0.0128277875,
-0.0429526977,
-0.1101770252,
-0.339715302,
0.6082955003,
-0.6012713313,
-0.8076705933,
-0.112409614,
0.2523382306,
0.0174013115,
0.0173526611,
-0.6772819757,
0.3616727293,
-0.2689047456,
-0.1362876743,
0.2535680234,
0.4070821106,
-0.0773700476,
0.6261282563,
0.5908504128,
0.1015052646,
-0.1178469509,
0.3027604222,
0.6082409024,
-0.1789313108,
0.1973161697,
-1.1506145,
0.639049232,
-0.0416344739,
-0.4322787821,
0.5329189897,
0.8474442959,
0.524414897,
-0.2173874676,
0.5219986439,
0.3522828519,
-0.1041235179,
-0.8353500366,
0.8695469499,
-0.7464925051,
0.0233955067,
-0.2539068758,
-1.0547395945,
-0.4820875525,
0.5478872657,
-0.0624279939,
-0.0897890702,
0.5833087564,
1.2658098936,
-0.2055945992,
-0.414088577,
0.5687537789,
-0.274828881,
0.2006378174,
0.2953356504,
1.0732812881,
-0.4364159107,
0.3727714419,
-0.2006112337,
-0.2485059351,
-0.3008583188,
-1.00391078,
-0.9770810604,
-0.7619010806,
-0.3740558624,
0.0392710939,
-0.1268006563,
1.0793937445,
0.8599177003,
-0.603418529,
0.0540313646,
0.2640820742,
-0.2353637367,
-0.194395259,
-0.2069384903,
0.6220487356,
-0.3559823632,
-0.9136353135,
-0.1059379056,
0.7846003175,
0.2149119973,
-0.5573738813,
-0.2533505857,
0.3413389921,
0.0651838258,
0.8015792966,
-0.0580605045,
-0.9348371625,
-0.1735060662,
-0.1142387614,
-0.4665666521,
0.1705820113,
0.6536028385,
-0.4646632075,
0.616876781,
0.0752049088,
0.7082579732,
0.2247725427,
0.437156409,
0.3913678527,
-0.9380909204,
0.1682426631,
0.0000038285,
0.3207505345,
0.5647030473,
-0.2870745063,
0.244973883,
-0.292216152,
-0.6919714808,
-0.7593969107,
-0.1496840268,
-1.0584685802,
-0.0097175492,
1.261302948,
0.0675207749,
-0.1407417357,
0.1138452813,
-0.5820031166,
-0.1370897293,
-0.4209697843,
1.0117886066,
0.5517104268,
-0.0200121049,
-0.4527177215,
-0.6015262008,
0.2274233401,
0.2966452837,
-0.9132005572,
0.1276442409,
0.6722580791,
-0.1314981729,
0.2672773302,
0.4572385252,
0.065546371,
0.2901345491,
-0.2965768874,
0.2137864977,
-0.1619440019,
-0.4017102122,
-0.0715799928,
0.0306922141,
0.2845754623,
-0.1801324487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16554v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16554v1
|
LLaMA-MoE: Building Mixture-of-Experts from LLaMA with Continual Pre-training
| 2024-06-24T11:43:07 | 2024-06-24T11:43:07 |
Tong Zhu, Xiaoye Qu, Daize Dong, Jiacheng Ruan, Jingqi Tong, Conghui He, Yu Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) has gained increasing popularity as a promising
framework for scaling up large language models (LLMs). However, training MoE
from scratch in a large-scale setting still suffers from data-hungry and
instability problems. Motivated by this limit, we investigate building MoE
models from existing dense large language models. Specifically, based on the
well-known LLaMA-2 7B model, we obtain an MoE model by: (1) Expert
Construction, which partitions the parameters of original Feed-Forward Networks
(FFNs) into multiple experts; (2) Continual Pre-training, which further trains
the transformed MoE model and additional gate networks. In this paper, we
comprehensively explore different methods for expert construction and various
data sampling strategies for continual pre-training. After these stages, our
LLaMA-MoE models could maintain language abilities and route the input tokens
to specific experts with part of the parameters activated. Empirically, by
training 200B tokens, LLaMA-MoE-3.5B models significantly outperform dense
models that contain similar activation parameters. The source codes and models
are available at https://github.com/pjlab-sys4nlp/llama-moe .
|
[
-0.4827428162,
-0.8473672271,
0.564158082,
0.4500172734,
-0.2292319536,
0.2566486597,
-0.4068215787,
-0.4329150319,
0.3859452009,
0.74725914,
-0.2202786207,
-0.0217937175,
-0.8214055896,
0.1645061374,
-0.4750739038,
0.8063444495,
0.044065915,
0.0254503489,
-0.0456077717,
0.1585630924,
-0.7178676724,
-0.310048908,
-0.5056704879,
-0.2285951972,
0.4021981657,
0.4775546491,
0.6204336882,
0.5610098839,
0.1172382161,
0.3780793846,
0.058469668,
0.1800516099,
-0.8596790433,
0.2159902304,
-0.0215833243,
-0.5845732093,
-0.5061385632,
0.025136508,
0.7444722056,
0.7499651909,
-0.4584439993,
-0.0133571643,
0.0613970682,
0.1461434066,
-0.4729174674,
0.0163544659,
-1.2357397079,
-0.2151750028,
-0.351002872,
0.0232372563,
-0.4824498892,
-0.0812466964,
0.0520052351,
-0.5995613337,
-0.0795429721,
0.0849832743,
0.6899673939,
0.4206760228,
-0.4144355357,
-0.1903962642,
-0.5212070942,
1.0278198719,
-0.842700243,
0.2365118414,
0.541097939,
0.1574302465,
-0.5677450299,
-0.4509930313,
-0.6394223571,
-0.3709463179,
0.2974896729,
0.0148366578,
0.1704352498,
-0.125123173,
-0.1606798172,
0.210672304,
-0.1358330399,
0.5103467703,
-0.4201741219,
0.0250853244,
0.8161207438,
0.0451305658,
0.1133070961,
0.1816841513,
-0.4102082551,
0.1554824412,
-0.917517364,
-0.3603790104,
0.3328727484,
-0.0132612996,
0.064158462,
0.544017911,
-0.2472864836,
0.6938515902,
0.3779421151,
-0.5586262345,
0.1202464029,
-0.0547199324,
0.0568001047,
-0.0363152549,
0.8012160659,
0.0172374789,
0.5338190794,
-0.4278918803,
-0.4445886314,
-0.2245267332,
0.2842127681,
-0.649017334,
-0.4230566025,
0.1203029826,
-0.225334838,
-0.4475743771,
-0.2613600791,
-0.3894606233,
-0.2344575673,
-0.4557005465,
0.4930782914,
-0.2483244687,
-0.63069278,
0.1513292044,
0.2318644822,
-0.0205843039,
0.3577578366,
-0.7729715109,
0.0750473142,
0.4712901711,
0.5396059155,
-0.1868071705,
-0.5115891099,
-0.5624286532,
0.4187747538,
-0.5436095595,
0.9045008421,
-0.7528442144,
-0.5301733613,
-0.077879861,
-0.3840254247,
0.0391791463,
-0.7284603715,
0.0312884748,
-0.7434576154,
-0.0184630305,
-0.1055561975,
-0.4243670106,
-0.1817429215,
0.3464317024,
-0.4727380276,
1.2111897469,
0.0778637826,
-0.4551867545,
0.2523834705,
-0.3468720019,
-0.4087441266,
0.092125617,
-0.202665329,
-0.0020405196,
0.2608631253,
0.4466254711,
0.9044273496,
-0.2710215747,
0.6662991643,
-0.5446467996,
-0.165482074,
0.3325691521,
-0.3310979605,
0.6941741705,
0.0985464901,
-0.1322756708,
-0.1467302889,
-0.7809236646,
-0.4414040446,
0.2097229511,
-0.5848332047,
-0.2323428988,
0.1953172088,
-0.3486764729,
0.1808832139,
0.5094666481,
-0.2778863013,
0.3920980692,
-0.1464823484,
0.4288472235,
0.9014362097,
0.0045729759,
0.3986634314,
-0.2945261598,
0.4704716802,
0.3030566573,
-0.0679301694,
-0.3439813852,
-0.6545187235,
-0.9723774791,
-0.4608025551,
0.2323063761,
0.4892492592,
-0.9353869557,
0.5889286399,
-0.6100157499,
-0.6383586526,
-0.5382573605,
0.6603384018,
0.1099836975,
0.5246803164,
0.367451489,
-0.3305228055,
-0.2791084051,
-0.7486159205,
0.2539200783,
-0.2580355108,
0.0208076481,
0.0452786684,
0.4483536184,
-0.4039524794,
1.102027297,
-0.3653769791,
-0.0092201559,
-0.2871581316,
-0.023794625,
0.2721900046,
0.5398533344,
0.6517192125,
-0.3395729661,
-0.3152055144,
0.0487309955,
-0.6664764285,
-0.2106370628,
-0.0767460093,
-0.274034977,
-0.3355455399,
0.3712538183,
-0.6267827749,
0.0006347318,
0.5892754793,
0.3324503303,
0.642611742,
0.0162099898,
-0.2209606171,
-1.3098911047,
-0.1152618453,
-0.1180277169,
-0.2523624599,
-0.6126528382,
0.2454978824,
-0.2296053171,
-0.0128335292,
-0.2836103737,
0.7062658072,
-0.505199492,
0.0592886209,
-0.4006360769,
-0.0726045817,
-0.3112174869,
0.684591949,
0.0095564146,
0.6590331197,
0.7916077971,
-0.7246861458,
0.4571364522,
0.1112772822,
-0.3916700184,
0.4150952101,
-0.7954161763,
0.3048796654,
0.0354459509,
0.386385262,
-0.8097912669,
-0.4532677531,
0.3354549408,
-0.1607489586,
0.4103111923,
-0.1879707873,
-0.6547108889,
-0.273747623,
-0.0600966699,
0.4856311083,
0.5841693282,
-0.3842379451,
0.9657581449,
0.5732724667,
-0.6657274365,
-0.6207824945,
-0.6168109775,
0.2690884173,
-0.1265167445,
-0.6910073161,
0.129080683,
-0.0491535626,
-0.229861483,
0.0053823045,
0.0996232182,
-0.2244975418,
0.241820544,
0.140313834,
-0.0410398245,
-0.2709204555,
-0.0059667835,
0.4133335948,
-0.0109941261,
0.0280943625,
-0.2103133351,
0.7008364797,
0.1472501606,
-0.3803150356,
-0.2932626009,
0.4360134602,
0.4021478295,
-0.406134814,
0.6738978028,
0.3735954165,
-0.0867291093,
-0.2442079782,
-1.1299619675,
-0.1777807921,
-0.4778239429,
0.5389911532,
-0.4435965717,
-0.8644120693,
0.6548079252,
-0.1493398994,
0.2950478494,
0.3829426169,
0.8673523068,
-0.0893087611,
0.6815732718,
0.5621497035,
-0.4884915352,
0.5424802303,
-0.042500779,
-0.1592989564,
-0.6806492209,
-0.1473360658,
-0.2075416744,
-0.3547848761,
0.058631856,
-0.5964609385,
0.3157109618,
0.3261055648,
-0.2150643468,
0.1653294563,
-0.06223974,
0.4235039055,
0.4069750905,
0.24771671,
0.0907627046,
0.1475656331,
0.0847777501,
0.5905029178,
-0.9275376201,
-0.4034733772,
1.5087789297,
0.5282837749,
0.7477123737,
-0.1291771829,
0.7898731828,
-0.0623419136,
0.7467848659,
-0.598923564,
0.7442396283,
0.1115046814,
-0.7185376883,
-0.1611044258,
-0.3991657197,
-0.7519125938,
0.2403844595,
-0.2601304352,
-0.4124142826,
0.1806253642,
0.2504247129,
-0.2580218613,
0.2188286036,
-0.6907534003,
0.1806038171,
-0.4338878393,
-0.1393401027,
-0.4309464395,
-0.5933785439,
0.5817215443,
-0.5744473338,
0.1486109793,
-0.2115700394,
-0.1672536433,
0.6859161854,
-0.4912928343,
0.9893425703,
-0.0357181951,
-0.449262917,
0.4522333443,
-0.0115904184,
0.5823387504,
0.1659089625,
-0.2227791995,
0.3915784657,
-0.5811032653,
-0.6894210577,
-0.4156173468,
0.4720263779,
-1.052564621,
-0.7746049762,
0.174257338,
-0.5394097567,
-0.317815721,
0.2043904811,
0.0263864305,
0.5028089285,
0.198398754,
0.3844542503,
0.6569972038,
0.0642386004,
0.2709277868,
0.2368691117,
-0.3266243041,
-0.5339852571,
0.7991184592,
0.3215667605,
0.1817377657,
0.259852767,
0.0461446494,
0.0674405172,
-0.7863125801,
-0.4376292825,
0.2416701466,
-0.5116701722,
-0.2537550926,
-0.6052518487,
-0.0897217467,
-0.2553194761,
-0.1611013412,
-0.5212944746,
0.0260465983,
-0.3769666255,
-0.0061570895,
0.3321993649,
0.8384269476,
0.0804760084,
0.8448324203,
-0.8884339333,
0.203372255,
0.602109015,
0.2085990757,
0.3748580813,
-0.6114180684,
-0.4585088491,
0.2583999336,
-0.1881913096,
-0.9587622285,
0.1287397593,
0.2666957378,
0.8784276247,
0.7219746709,
-0.2093397081,
0.7203922868,
-0.5914320946,
0.7747923136,
0.1506042182,
-0.6802219748,
0.1891478896,
-0.6178586483,
0.0094851935,
0.5555440187,
0.4066476226,
0.0962914228,
-0.5642635226,
-0.323788166,
-0.8268905282,
0.4855735004,
0.0457465872,
0.4225514829,
-0.0918338597,
0.4805782735,
0.4564005435,
0.3026240766,
-0.6314223409,
0.1623064429,
-0.2536560893,
-0.2703888416,
-0.0487885959,
-0.4090477824,
-0.0958131105,
-0.0667757988,
0.5540342927,
0.0071286168,
0.0561898164,
-0.3470124602,
-0.4523725808,
0.230183959,
-0.1318641305,
0.4894863665,
0.7637016177,
-0.0478166193,
-0.1077167615,
0.3582360744,
-0.5852108002,
0.1955613494,
0.0710142106,
0.1066033244,
-0.2876327932,
0.4916371405,
0.751976192,
0.4933157563,
-0.6056492925,
0.3467000723,
0.2925282419,
-0.1864054203,
-0.2490504533,
0.2381263077,
0.2117276341,
0.1702874452,
0.6648058891,
-0.05637585,
-0.3751297593,
-0.3869665265,
0.0666453689,
0.1610371321,
0.2138960809,
-0.4231539071,
0.5229526758,
0.6800094247,
0.0546438545,
0.7106156945,
-0.247631833,
-0.5190441012,
0.4102283716,
0.4643006623,
0.5544928908,
-0.4059540927,
-0.0941952541,
-0.0427461118,
0.2840430439,
-0.4243783951,
0.0822024047,
-0.2055656314,
-0.9681711793,
-0.7387628555,
-0.5429887176,
-0.3120499551,
-0.0994100496,
-0.3933854401,
0.1848098487,
-0.5057388544,
-0.1510848999,
-0.5249794722,
-0.099501431,
-0.7376971841,
0.2436647713,
0.0777971148,
0.6354593039,
-0.780426681,
0.9310032129,
0.7033409476,
-0.242074281,
-0.9208651185,
-0.0800417513,
-0.3095383048,
-1.0995337963,
0.69160074,
0.0552612655,
0.0281328149,
0.252615422,
-0.8372172117,
-0.9937566519,
1.0009678602,
0.3996927738,
-0.7962682843,
-0.0501580052,
-0.056435395,
0.2218080759,
-0.3829295337,
0.2039485723,
0.3610879779,
0.2374702245,
0.0459010527,
-0.8466132879,
-0.1673885882,
-0.3199169934,
-0.0142386509,
-0.0425585397,
-0.6892760396,
0.9241185188,
0.0334466435,
0.1953500062,
0.1363355815,
1.1535137892,
0.6598429084,
-0.1856386214,
0.7401735187,
0.7427155375,
0.7544103265,
0.1745819449,
0.7505494356,
-0.5979568958,
-0.0294094812,
0.9895780683,
-0.3674009442,
1.1143425703,
0.3387980163,
-0.1153629199,
0.5891808867,
0.6638765335,
-0.0385846868,
0.4177288115,
0.1072021723,
-0.1454804838,
-0.5394744277,
0.1193554401,
-0.675560832,
0.36689803,
0.5048811436,
0.0202724915,
-0.022826286,
0.0571572334,
0.2155834734,
-0.3970915079,
-0.4128475487,
0.5960270762,
0.240300104,
-0.5907761455,
0.3826431632,
-0.0996183604,
0.9378189445,
-0.6778290868,
0.3534828722,
-0.4435075223,
-0.2830330729,
0.0020616075,
-0.6370690465,
-0.2278496176,
0.0972284228,
-0.1322707981,
-0.0158106666,
0.5302326083,
-0.5855760574,
-0.7133777738,
-0.0163892824,
0.4602897465,
0.2687058449,
-0.0262488853,
-0.431335628,
-0.0060040159,
-0.2296319753,
-0.5450030565,
0.3795137107,
0.5640437603,
0.0049510957,
0.8397062421,
0.6967397332,
0.1989597976,
0.5588278174,
-0.1337249726,
1.091242075,
-0.1833640635,
-0.4591124952,
-0.5844240785,
0.6812876463,
0.0286956448,
-0.4537777901,
0.5184122324,
0.2204417437,
0.8873767257,
-0.1693490595,
0.6691158414,
0.1756956577,
0.205350101,
-0.6687296629,
0.7659161687,
-0.6646850705,
0.1546304673,
-0.2048564255,
-1.1503129005,
-0.0161147993,
0.4415948987,
-0.3207394183,
0.3232138455,
0.1241081506,
0.7890958786,
-0.1449404806,
-0.3558560908,
0.1700432003,
0.4427915215,
0.4549515545,
0.4494249821,
0.9712744355,
0.0049034241,
0.4654287398,
-0.1067729741,
-0.230438903,
-0.5061321259,
-0.8461111784,
-0.9231204391,
-0.3351435363,
-0.2618746459,
0.1650143266,
-0.257571429,
0.9812511206,
0.8843953609,
-0.5764369965,
-0.241566658,
0.178238377,
-0.0211642012,
0.0828627199,
-0.0966986492,
0.1192431524,
-0.3834455013,
-0.689396739,
0.6411312222,
0.2637034059,
-0.0438833199,
-0.5559564829,
-0.1447778642,
-0.0799296051,
0.1790402383,
0.6256433725,
0.0873861164,
-0.7526963353,
-0.0972635448,
-0.184493944,
0.0962640941,
-0.1337622553,
0.3634492457,
-0.7343907356,
0.4029571712,
0.4469245672,
1.0909174681,
0.169994086,
0.0459885299,
0.8526451588,
-0.6630802751,
0.2831356525,
0.0612100028,
0.487205267,
0.2275913656,
-0.035300266,
0.2965606153,
0.2182960361,
-0.5972887278,
-0.9438257813,
0.1508872807,
-1.0099256039,
-0.1841254085,
1.231290102,
-0.1653105617,
0.034134753,
-0.1678753048,
-0.2586608231,
0.0672056079,
-0.4634156823,
0.7815244794,
0.8128072023,
0.2321896404,
-0.0655270442,
-0.5339081883,
-0.179959774,
0.4910106361,
-0.6268740296,
-0.452090174,
0.2636214793,
0.4550962746,
0.0505190268,
0.7111848593,
0.2207071036,
-0.0368425734,
0.1268196106,
0.0611406788,
-0.3067974746,
-0.5456100702,
0.1029025093,
0.1834179759,
0.1518542171,
0.0453932658
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.