id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17284v1
|
Common Ground Tracking in Multimodal Dialogue
| 2024-03-26T00:25:01 | 2024-03-26T00:25:01 |
Ibrahim Khebour, Kenneth Lai, Mariah Bradford, Yifan Zhu, Richard Brutti, Christopher Tam, Jingxuan Tu, Benjamin Ibarra, Nathaniel Blanchard, Nikhil Krishnaswamy, James Pustejovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Within Dialogue Modeling research in AI and NLP, considerable attention has
been spent on ``dialogue state tracking'' (DST), which is the ability to update
the representations of the speaker's needs at each turn in the dialogue by
taking into account the past dialogue moves and history. Less studied but just
as important to dialogue modeling, however, is ``common ground tracking''
(CGT), which identifies the shared belief space held by all of the participants
in a task-oriented dialogue: the task-relevant propositions all participants
accept as true. In this paper we present a method for automatically identifying
the current set of shared beliefs and ``questions under discussion'' (QUDs) of
a group with a shared goal. We annotate a dataset of multimodal interactions in
a shared physical space with speech transcriptions, prosodic features,
gestures, actions, and facets of collaboration, and operationalize these
features for use in a deep neural model to predict moves toward construction of
common ground. Model outputs cascade into a set of formal closure rules derived
from situated evidence and belief axioms and update operations. We empirically
assess the contribution of each feature type toward successful construction of
common ground relative to ground truth, establishing a benchmark in this novel,
challenging task.
|
[
-0.7799398899,
-0.7239146829,
0.8592916727,
-0.1217118949,
-0.2972736955,
0.1109343469,
-0.1409789622,
-0.1514249742,
0.288666755,
0.3555142581,
-0.67665869,
-0.96498698,
-0.7631351948,
-0.41753456,
-0.1080955192,
0.7818679214,
-0.1434598565,
-0.1630292684,
-0.4137091637,
-0.6060269475,
-0.7647548318,
-0.9833322763,
-0.061377123,
-0.312658906,
0.5206383467,
0.2244251221,
0.6842301488,
0.0846168101,
0.2999682426,
0.283170104,
-0.1587260216,
0.2718318403,
-0.2873615921,
0.2331731468,
-0.005796107,
-0.2891471088,
-0.2817321122,
0.183265388,
0.5851952434,
0.7904425859,
-0.0806678012,
-0.0063377353,
0.03422492,
0.0293271448,
-0.34178707,
0.2631894052,
-0.471617043,
0.1578207612,
0.1430557519,
-0.3824672997,
-0.0208635852,
-0.5036073327,
0.218415007,
-0.6098920107,
0.4141453207,
-0.1252586544,
0.5433683395,
0.3552825451,
-0.7189173102,
-0.4370076954,
-0.3958928883,
0.7136483192,
-0.5076155663,
0.4171301425,
0.314691782,
0.1219607443,
-0.1453087032,
-0.4226731956,
-0.6346701384,
-0.3237133324,
-0.1519609839,
0.0400601104,
-0.0128697865,
0.3472856283,
0.4578998685,
0.2692588866,
-0.2786067128,
-0.3347593844,
-0.2018174678,
-0.2646493018,
0.2802296281,
0.1894422472,
0.3604986966,
-0.0466213301,
-0.4452695549,
0.1521831453,
-0.3375220299,
0.0275388267,
-0.2231642455,
0.1409546286,
-0.1771813482,
0.460618794,
-0.5367621183,
0.5555934906,
0.1191535741,
0.0480175912,
0.251955688,
-0.5445739031,
0.0253882725,
-0.0060113729,
0.5188147426,
0.9107640386,
0.0328980759,
-0.1599754095,
-0.0815331638,
0.4512334168,
0.1315393895,
-0.3630021513,
-0.0298597664,
-0.0968765616,
-0.2969359159,
0.0847467259,
-0.1835501194,
-0.4171670377,
-0.5633384585,
-0.7007106543,
0.220165506,
-0.4597729445,
-0.4124651253,
0.1817140281,
-0.0693264306,
0.0682055354,
0.7599029541,
-0.6330145597,
0.5460874438,
0.9239035249,
1.0727857351,
-0.066894263,
-0.3259710073,
-0.5132550001,
0.0840321407,
-0.1066405997,
0.6942144632,
-0.5624467731,
-0.2374378443,
-0.0705850124,
-0.0344366431,
-0.2467918694,
-0.0966119245,
0.4304918647,
-0.2115921825,
0.2719049454,
-0.6790390611,
-0.7435883284,
-0.4606652856,
0.8225710392,
-0.4296791553,
0.7199532986,
-0.301158756,
-0.8301087618,
0.5112648606,
-0.6416243911,
0.0231800545,
-0.0359785594,
-0.597949028,
-0.0816478133,
0.2351387143,
0.1546056122,
0.3173790872,
-0.0567522831,
0.7657756805,
-0.5350602269,
-0.4281893671,
0.1373145431,
-0.615753293,
0.4592393041,
0.0601416118,
-0.2414643168,
0.141430214,
-0.5036970377,
-0.0455260612,
-0.3784013093,
0.0085563902,
-0.3243523538,
0.1849497557,
-0.2966597676,
0.2724063694,
0.3426257074,
-0.4653852284,
0.3858502209,
0.210482344,
0.1300168782,
0.640371263,
0.4483427107,
0.2633942664,
-0.397377193,
0.3761644363,
0.1002397463,
0.1447697729,
-0.1200778261,
-0.6778855324,
-0.5914487243,
-0.1855159402,
-0.0304619651,
0.2031496465,
-0.1556767374,
0.3117909729,
-0.2269313186,
-0.4158793688,
-0.3067311049,
-0.2255910635,
0.3355963528,
0.2517704666,
0.3764383793,
-0.3932483494,
-0.2206813395,
-0.6203294396,
0.0471416488,
-0.2663373649,
0.0347643644,
0.3304681778,
0.3044245243,
-0.0501917377,
1.0702265501,
-0.6941680312,
-0.1662375331,
-0.0135584883,
0.7392013669,
0.020329535,
0.5475603342,
0.4688963592,
-0.9959852695,
-0.4608384669,
0.0257864259,
-0.8550001979,
-0.234558776,
-0.1083717719,
-0.0186417941,
-0.2431011349,
0.511449337,
-0.8807904124,
0.6680006981,
0.5561571121,
-0.4145199656,
0.236773476,
0.077314876,
0.7794668674,
-1.0055838823,
-0.051129628,
-0.0150578702,
-0.0493891761,
-0.5038498044,
-0.0721502081,
-0.4253693223,
-0.0422519147,
-0.332282573,
0.2581083179,
-0.3606943786,
-0.363479048,
0.0143614644,
0.3576542437,
-0.1184311584,
1.0023239851,
0.4230612218,
0.7580679059,
0.5219121575,
-0.5268087387,
0.3531992137,
0.4476968944,
-0.1968770623,
0.8155548573,
-0.3872755468,
0.4944416881,
0.047464218,
0.4933016002,
-0.9770799875,
-0.0117058931,
0.3387030661,
-0.6246820092,
-0.4239576459,
-0.5716920495,
-0.4933916032,
0.1378978044,
0.2120813727,
0.4586637616,
0.2347363681,
-0.241942212,
0.8016886711,
0.3965294957,
-0.1891415417,
-0.3575816453,
-0.0795348138,
0.1927060932,
-0.397688508,
-0.7472829223,
0.2165933102,
-0.1281415671,
-0.3957687616,
-0.1250074208,
-0.248565346,
-0.2509535849,
0.2443590313,
0.510886848,
-0.1642487794,
-0.0802312568,
0.1692467034,
-0.1416538209,
-0.04832647,
0.090795964,
-0.1774346232,
0.7008038759,
-0.3319253922,
-0.6799285412,
-0.4809766412,
0.7292147875,
0.8027732372,
-0.241718933,
0.5537399054,
0.460902065,
-0.4883254766,
0.2160200179,
-0.5210540891,
0.0807637572,
-0.3636237979,
0.2686595023,
-0.4517872632,
-0.9108995795,
0.6292666197,
-0.3597924411,
0.0823130086,
0.1522282809,
0.3626380265,
-0.2894308865,
1.1212626696,
0.5548380613,
0.0258403979,
0.2670131624,
0.1308827996,
0.1136167869,
-0.7668834329,
-0.2941988409,
-0.4393098354,
-0.3255258799,
-0.3219003081,
-0.7475836277,
0.4625850022,
0.3075556457,
-0.0106982933,
0.351841718,
-0.2383849472,
0.2467970997,
0.8897473216,
-0.0678065345,
0.3663745821,
-0.395496279,
-0.3688105643,
-0.1881595105,
-0.4679474533,
-0.3970789611,
0.6957422495,
0.1624800861,
0.4754088521,
0.2003551573,
0.8079195619,
0.5338270664,
0.2272941172,
-0.5774086118,
0.7813911438,
0.1307748705,
-0.4285887778,
-0.0753892362,
-0.1684989333,
-0.369844377,
0.3105812073,
-0.2663863301,
-0.8599497676,
-0.0421405584,
0.1999609619,
-0.3220898807,
0.1799965799,
-0.5296707153,
0.9288264513,
-0.1473450363,
-0.1220316365,
-0.7062854171,
-0.7167344093,
0.102349773,
0.0253136959,
-0.0840497836,
-0.2563945353,
0.5076550841,
0.6129190922,
-0.0846474469,
1.1797077656,
-0.603992641,
-0.0270415712,
0.4197194278,
-0.0486521423,
0.3536443412,
0.0905212313,
0.3761819303,
0.3687571287,
0.083127968,
-0.1282125711,
-0.7173911333,
0.5833408237,
-0.6181483865,
-0.6593911648,
-0.5911386013,
-0.5211305618,
-0.2819072902,
0.1008821055,
0.0432936624,
0.4043466449,
-0.6697356701,
0.2753574848,
0.7188040614,
-0.244116351,
0.2080887258,
0.3848596811,
-0.1559949815,
-0.4741670489,
0.4178253412,
-0.0396494754,
0.3325091302,
0.2067227811,
0.0061303577,
-0.4795441926,
-0.5103570819,
-0.0493676141,
-0.0189522728,
-0.8972944617,
0.0593405105,
-0.8709262013,
-0.1501636356,
-0.2573680878,
-0.2602134347,
-0.1466015279,
-0.3299418986,
-0.1809247583,
-0.1265817583,
0.0552195013,
0.5013298392,
0.0129135521,
0.4007583261,
-0.955673337,
0.6016668677,
0.4406667054,
0.3424077332,
-0.4895056188,
-0.1053512171,
-0.2219470143,
0.5219373703,
-0.3814296722,
-0.743994832,
0.1316445619,
-0.0244601518,
0.7263832688,
-0.0666404888,
0.1087940559,
0.75138098,
-0.3187628984,
0.9649847746,
0.5172083974,
-1.157084465,
0.609195292,
-0.4796304107,
0.3624296188,
0.5831404924,
0.1872178167,
-1.1205949783,
-0.4148774445,
-0.5810207725,
-0.2298569977,
0.4350754619,
0.1158632934,
-0.1988876462,
-0.1040886417,
-0.2099135965,
-0.134096995,
0.4281427562,
-0.6409947872,
0.0488250554,
-0.2425099611,
-0.246194765,
0.0143842502,
0.0467153117,
-0.5987083316,
-0.1112912595,
0.1260157973,
-0.4618199468,
0.3020594716,
0.1714530736,
-0.2451253235,
-0.0592724048,
0.379057169,
0.767000556,
0.5127664804,
-0.4279758036,
0.1180620268,
0.201323241,
-0.0540953353,
0.0791051909,
0.0893766433,
-0.1237899363,
0.1646793336,
0.236441344,
0.9217631221,
0.1760612279,
-0.1851683855,
0.6911624074,
-0.2138654739,
-0.2853766978,
-0.3864945471,
0.0420919769,
0.0536264591,
0.6086597443,
0.138655141,
0.650357306,
0.1205663159,
-0.5685059428,
0.5598905087,
0.4139347672,
-0.6558962464,
-0.5526050925,
0.3759837747,
0.3871441483,
-0.4030704796,
0.4357974231,
-0.0637750849,
-0.9230521321,
0.4491857588,
0.0827124342,
1.0175455809,
0.1006971896,
0.2480256259,
0.2627377212,
-0.0282339659,
-0.0270858407,
0.0300736036,
-0.3876394331,
-0.926540494,
-0.5333434343,
-0.3397583663,
-0.5220497251,
-0.1696021259,
-0.7658756971,
0.2787679732,
-0.3199543655,
-0.2537722886,
-0.2438015044,
0.0459315032,
-0.6657646894,
0.3935611546,
0.7102195621,
0.5783407688,
-1.0759593248,
0.7399349809,
0.4484012425,
-0.3966176808,
-0.4586687386,
0.390832454,
0.2958581746,
-0.5671634078,
0.6198920608,
0.3107672334,
-0.4573442042,
-0.2745803297,
-0.7074534297,
-0.8259771466,
1.083851099,
0.0216329191,
-0.5854411721,
-0.1929146945,
0.1055492237,
0.6711893678,
-0.4653614759,
0.1762129068,
0.260443747,
0.312645942,
0.2665635943,
-1.0652648211,
-0.1049251482,
-0.1074264944,
-0.5568066239,
0.3173086345,
-0.8917838931,
0.6508945823,
0.1501212567,
-0.2086345851,
-0.0910122842,
0.6060749888,
0.4452095926,
0.75857687,
0.8112090826,
0.6333886385,
0.8178653717,
-0.2061230838,
0.2869234383,
-0.3082668781,
0.4722675383,
1.3155646324,
-0.381621927,
0.5169301033,
0.3632874191,
0.1984214783,
0.3106571138,
0.2998291254,
0.0077217999,
0.7441108227,
0.142426163,
-0.4220435917,
-0.4260009229,
-0.3373916149,
-0.4699870646,
0.5122004747,
0.4947831631,
-0.0590612032,
-0.1571946293,
-0.2851688862,
-0.119953908,
0.0814732984,
-0.1585395783,
0.8793264627,
0.0014421104,
-1.2333928347,
0.3968955278,
-0.4231739044,
0.4322221875,
-0.3979419172,
-0.5151963234,
-0.2825279236,
-0.065930739,
0.1998251826,
-0.8819260597,
0.2346064448,
-0.0371881202,
-0.0345978551,
-0.3586129248,
0.2922509611,
-0.6439284682,
-0.0230279695,
0.4753864706,
0.3196297586,
-0.0207127333,
-0.1145589054,
-0.6548908353,
0.2203749716,
0.254871428,
0.0524331145,
0.1523646414,
0.7438930273,
-0.1966438144,
0.6068793535,
0.500706315,
-0.0518743768,
0.2259064168,
0.2178742886,
0.965025425,
-0.9284282923,
-0.5709784031,
-0.3285401762,
0.6410648227,
-0.2669984996,
-0.5169941783,
0.4730225801,
0.2999670208,
0.7081722021,
0.3892451227,
0.9104046822,
-0.140850395,
0.7052818537,
-0.6972091794,
0.3189622462,
-0.3236691654,
0.2499975264,
-0.443715632,
-1.0217167139,
-0.0663504973,
0.651394546,
-0.179402411,
-0.3356824219,
0.8857706785,
0.5130070448,
-0.2044728249,
0.2529090941,
0.3375768661,
0.0194204599,
0.462007314,
0.6475179195,
1.35755229,
-0.2307929993,
0.3691525459,
-0.091653198,
-0.139429301,
0.0147884572,
-0.7426656485,
-0.7563682795,
-0.7068116069,
-0.6088181138,
-0.0803474635,
0.0169102736,
0.990975678,
0.7484355569,
-0.6326252222,
-0.0538584068,
-0.2672710717,
-0.1764611602,
-0.2574851513,
-0.1447816491,
0.1382019967,
-0.0893960968,
-0.6129325032,
0.4661677778,
0.2285189033,
-0.035592176,
-0.0320648551,
-0.2389764935,
-0.4879713953,
-0.047824692,
0.0720036775,
0.0532592162,
-1.0125286579,
-0.767365694,
-0.0721326098,
-0.0393972397,
0.2271197587,
0.8130366206,
-0.6433833838,
0.4766071141,
0.2807694674,
0.3080512583,
0.7481449842,
0.3778650463,
0.8129316568,
-0.9380401969,
0.0311212856,
0.4295129776,
0.3564920127,
0.2836449742,
-0.0648268163,
0.457644552,
0.5293498635,
-0.6103075147,
-0.5972718596,
0.3564021289,
-1.102311492,
0.0610340573,
0.9271627665,
-0.4890827835,
0.2802399099,
-0.3266525269,
-0.3725253344,
0.4011838138,
-0.4168199003,
0.6500726342,
1.0991892815,
0.1071718857,
-0.3683568537,
-0.1768848449,
0.4147540331,
0.3508217931,
-0.5314808488,
0.1928193718,
1.0889444351,
0.1686418951,
0.4968385398,
0.8905909061,
0.3516442478,
0.0534260273,
0.1732438058,
-0.0913047493,
0.351161778,
-0.526810348,
-0.1046487316,
0.2768262625,
-0.2009291053,
-0.4476036727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17281v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17281v1
|
Automate Knowledge Concept Tagging on Math Questions with LLMs
| 2024-03-26T00:09:38 | 2024-03-26T00:09:38 |
Hang Li, Tianlong Xu, Jiliang Tang, Qingsong Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge concept tagging for questions plays a crucial role in contemporary
intelligent educational applications, including learning progress diagnosis,
practice question recommendations, and course content organization.
Traditionally, these annotations have been conducted manually with help from
pedagogical experts, as the task requires not only a strong semantic
understanding of both question stems and knowledge definitions but also deep
insights into connecting question-solving logic with corresponding knowledge
concepts. In this paper, we explore automating the tagging task using Large
Language Models (LLMs), in response to the inability of prior manual methods to
meet the rapidly growing demand for concept tagging in questions posed by
advanced educational applications. Moreover, the zero/few-shot learning
capability of LLMs makes them well-suited for application in educational
scenarios, which often face challenges in collecting large-scale,
expertise-annotated datasets. By conducting extensive experiments with a
variety of representative LLMs, we demonstrate that LLMs are a promising tool
for concept tagging in math questions. Furthermore, through case studies
examining the results from different LLMs, we draw some empirical conclusions
about the key factors for success in applying LLMs to the automatic concept
tagging task.
|
[
-0.604057014,
-0.9044753909,
0.6709459424,
-0.2717854679,
-0.311691761,
0.2785254419,
-0.1080093756,
-0.3470514715,
0.2075173259,
0.4146410823,
-0.4187653363,
-0.6899828315,
-0.5679419041,
-0.031179877,
-0.369156599,
0.5837441683,
-0.3957286477,
0.0350956731,
-0.7236687541,
0.2223170251,
-0.5375978947,
-0.4745752811,
-0.6213020682,
-0.3746863008,
0.3992927372,
0.4575579464,
0.329883635,
0.8243675828,
0.9137992859,
0.2306884676,
0.248837918,
0.3278458118,
0.0601389334,
0.2312636524,
-0.1230089813,
-0.6194844842,
-0.5273085237,
0.0903036594,
0.774664104,
1.1037611961,
-0.0774826258,
0.3713386655,
-0.2324393541,
0.3084747493,
-0.3725527525,
0.3972848356,
-0.8390467763,
0.0876085535,
-0.0677421317,
-0.1787029207,
-0.0018381098,
-0.3592765033,
0.1372828484,
-0.5807512999,
0.0261655822,
-0.1093191952,
0.647369206,
0.6155096292,
-0.1714157909,
-0.5109499097,
-0.604516089,
0.7388344407,
-0.5298807025,
0.1580144763,
0.5311874151,
0.3553288877,
-0.0951952264,
-0.4560173452,
-0.6262302399,
-0.0722062066,
-0.0540821217,
-0.027078256,
-0.0471534207,
-0.0823665634,
0.4844676256,
0.1654944718,
-0.3523074687,
0.2515632212,
-0.1545976847,
-0.1444367766,
0.6678450108,
0.3966654837,
0.247813791,
-0.1666325629,
-0.3179275692,
0.0660172477,
-0.6854168177,
-0.1134996191,
0.2116711885,
0.2333668321,
0.2229103744,
0.8698275685,
-0.0964280665,
1.0682368279,
-0.405603826,
-0.3392537832,
0.04954651,
-0.2120925188,
-0.1078490913,
-0.1648563594,
0.5278736353,
0.282078743,
0.6074178815,
-0.0105234245,
-0.2070686072,
0.3669748008,
-0.1024619788,
-0.6789941788,
-0.3072483838,
0.027338678,
0.2501668036,
-0.0173906442,
-0.2196482271,
-0.4429296851,
-0.2114642411,
-0.5597536564,
0.6712970734,
-0.3819773793,
-0.1749329418,
0.2434834689,
-0.022704158,
0.3742517531,
0.6091760993,
-0.6287515163,
0.1925400943,
0.7393780947,
0.5526557565,
-0.2086932808,
-0.0217361934,
-0.4210402668,
0.1642479897,
-0.4921298325,
0.9523724318,
-0.8105409741,
-0.4528605044,
-0.1598233581,
-0.4185290635,
-0.161454007,
-0.5453022122,
0.0238446482,
-0.6979789734,
-0.0376744382,
-0.2273795605,
-1.2039973736,
-0.0594934449,
0.5496408343,
-0.3175569773,
0.9062168598,
-0.1125005633,
-0.3866014779,
0.1351796538,
-0.6922641397,
-0.2972529531,
0.3961493373,
-0.3602561653,
-0.1251041591,
-0.0044107786,
0.0232074875,
0.8122737408,
-0.3886195123,
0.3573591113,
-0.2045966387,
-0.1802307814,
0.450388819,
-0.2017635256,
0.4535155296,
-0.0490489565,
0.0073604886,
-0.3178178966,
-0.5217726827,
-0.0713717043,
0.4685130417,
-0.0579429902,
-0.5899199843,
0.0026841648,
-0.6001266241,
0.1017369777,
0.352741152,
-0.438916564,
0.5695817471,
-0.3663165271,
0.1030859202,
0.5826634169,
0.0971330479,
0.4128913581,
-0.3889809251,
0.6551331282,
-0.0462609902,
-0.2957675755,
-0.4687370062,
-0.5719711185,
-0.8212206364,
-0.3170649111,
0.6037024856,
0.6199294329,
-0.7711384296,
0.5334468484,
-0.1177859828,
-0.5098397136,
-0.4554316998,
0.3838724792,
0.1013773084,
0.8706780672,
0.3052827716,
-0.1574022919,
-0.1422853321,
-0.7902132869,
-0.2387159169,
-0.1119528785,
-0.0301421117,
0.4326940179,
0.6774231195,
-0.0510607325,
1.3761160374,
-0.9977840185,
-0.5962385535,
-0.0838867426,
0.2625894845,
-0.0656106099,
0.3846864998,
0.3481457531,
-0.6066125035,
-0.3969808221,
-0.3768535554,
-0.6382949352,
-0.2482642233,
-0.004586149,
-0.1537846774,
0.1277720779,
0.4982416332,
-0.5795090199,
0.3457629085,
0.078693375,
0.0329972655,
0.376268357,
0.0581279956,
-0.3927492499,
-1.1657651663,
-0.0402672105,
0.3371019661,
-0.1519471109,
-0.3946897984,
0.1187507808,
0.0314023271,
0.0214158986,
-0.3946343064,
0.7799890041,
-0.424939245,
-0.1831358373,
-0.0599221028,
0.5252257586,
-0.091969721,
0.3207722902,
0.2624009848,
0.5447631478,
0.6423740983,
-0.6809873581,
0.7283229232,
0.088094525,
-0.3336130083,
0.5312585831,
-0.5293433666,
0.0443846583,
-0.1780696958,
0.2083498985,
-1.1375664473,
-0.3175775111,
0.2781749368,
-0.6057450771,
0.1756027192,
-0.3006281853,
-0.9880758524,
-0.2850019336,
-0.1942498386,
0.3326029181,
0.6065388322,
-0.2643563449,
0.7508160472,
0.5980010629,
-0.1887737811,
-0.3219916523,
-0.4632765055,
0.0573928878,
-0.269110918,
-0.2321098596,
0.1817178875,
-0.2981732488,
-0.3985703588,
0.0650424585,
-0.1353923529,
-0.0585148744,
0.4620859921,
0.0463389456,
0.6841323972,
-0.0392530151,
0.531060636,
0.0409323014,
-0.3254168034,
0.4090459645,
-0.4680533409,
0.6116200686,
0.0658677295,
-0.7382878065,
-0.1434064955,
0.2085231394,
0.2744575739,
-0.5008819103,
0.4093687534,
0.3878350258,
-0.8363325596,
-0.3943208754,
-0.656709075,
-0.0810473338,
-0.4246110916,
0.2431498021,
-0.2421445847,
-0.9085430503,
0.44481951,
-0.336209476,
0.2421718836,
0.4406489134,
0.5216283798,
-0.4608594179,
0.894184351,
0.5454710722,
-0.0035718279,
0.203987509,
-0.5625516772,
0.060895931,
-0.6833080649,
-0.1831969768,
-0.4511919022,
-0.2613991201,
-0.2811778784,
-0.7922156453,
0.4815923572,
0.0321215689,
-0.0459997989,
0.0591922589,
-0.318985343,
0.6954219937,
0.3601628244,
-0.2735848427,
0.524963975,
0.0537330396,
-0.1595702618,
-0.0154272011,
-0.5918132067,
-0.3894736469,
1.0111657381,
0.3302066028,
0.9719945192,
-0.1574291438,
0.9466433525,
-0.0661945269,
0.4548514485,
-1.3364161253,
0.8364569545,
-0.0600111224,
-0.6043050289,
-0.4123956263,
-0.4013967216,
-0.5200898051,
-0.0008337988,
-0.0263520386,
-0.4281202257,
-0.1848077923,
0.1313789785,
-0.5773869157,
0.3945837915,
-0.5288257003,
0.5021901727,
-0.214257881,
0.0236581806,
0.0702746883,
-0.4472075999,
0.2768896818,
-0.5575301647,
0.2026626617,
-0.4083917737,
-0.3964162767,
0.9592657089,
-0.2374340296,
1.0462481976,
-0.1128544733,
-0.4585676193,
0.4683602154,
0.2570455074,
0.2265674621,
0.0639395863,
0.3064962924,
0.0609663501,
-0.1044660658,
-0.1587775499,
-0.7299131751,
0.5894107819,
-0.5920976996,
-0.8049994111,
-0.4671834707,
-0.8756315708,
-0.5114539862,
0.0682921186,
-0.2517705262,
0.3944117427,
0.2672407329,
-0.1777227819,
1.0495023727,
-0.0165515691,
0.5203757882,
0.6733391881,
-0.3099349141,
-0.1528424025,
1.1296103001,
0.5022778511,
0.2055443674,
0.3637025952,
0.091629833,
-0.4231604636,
-0.3241036832,
-0.4888395071,
0.5809873343,
-0.9196891189,
-0.5985857844,
-0.8227254748,
-0.3506226838,
-0.3277594745,
-0.26039204,
-0.2292899638,
-0.5419096351,
-0.3480792046,
-0.0379166268,
0.534901619,
0.5599538088,
0.0687172189,
0.1658405662,
-0.6571118236,
0.427503556,
0.668741405,
0.380076468,
-0.1133957952,
-0.6146064997,
-0.114589341,
0.0478113629,
0.0019095133,
-0.6818438768,
0.158758387,
0.1498298496,
0.386123538,
0.1590252966,
0.1074502096,
0.6553182006,
-0.4798099101,
0.4978938401,
0.0798028633,
-0.9160135984,
0.6138628721,
-0.2673001587,
0.2876076698,
0.2368798256,
0.7878634334,
-0.4477632642,
-0.2823413908,
-0.4862703681,
-0.6914055347,
0.5056952238,
-0.219007358,
0.3840737939,
-0.0202714056,
0.5413310528,
0.005449133,
0.2839785218,
-0.2465790212,
-0.4414389431,
0.236135304,
-0.4012778401,
-0.0919959173,
-0.0286523402,
-0.1595358253,
-0.4165262878,
0.5199630857,
-0.3569903374,
0.135266304,
-0.0147970216,
-0.3544792235,
-0.1695501506,
0.1277870536,
0.4000062346,
0.6608731151,
-0.0820470825,
0.1293597519,
0.3729174435,
-0.274074316,
0.0920203626,
0.3541823626,
-0.1494788378,
-0.0716403276,
0.2830274403,
0.3519437611,
0.0140959676,
-0.7497276068,
0.4159478247,
-0.0174152683,
-0.286193192,
-0.5919371843,
0.2939374447,
0.3870510757,
0.025766626,
0.5036365986,
-0.2515995502,
-0.2303122729,
-0.3174416721,
0.1400306523,
0.7837344408,
-0.0233649816,
-0.1127057672,
0.3121313751,
0.0591628999,
-0.3181577027,
0.3954858184,
-0.1739663333,
-0.6632201672,
0.9156637788,
0.4880340397,
0.5920309424,
-0.2305818349,
0.1241976172,
0.2759847045,
0.2961342931,
0.0955163091,
0.160727486,
-0.2271029353,
-0.9280418158,
-0.6703982353,
-0.7672377229,
-0.7574849725,
-0.1138305068,
-0.5855778456,
0.3774260283,
-0.5942687392,
-0.1268524379,
0.1806644201,
0.0997765288,
-0.8092258573,
0.4468408525,
0.5535721779,
1.0034669638,
-0.8322013021,
0.9080284238,
1.2223218679,
-0.3560377657,
-0.8693578839,
-0.2017369419,
-0.1456002593,
-1.0255442858,
0.8634341955,
0.0147020351,
-0.0916280001,
0.5399836302,
-0.6650085449,
-1.0148237944,
1.0398658514,
0.0433670059,
-0.5700383186,
-0.2363630086,
0.434268266,
0.4325497448,
-0.5314183831,
0.1865517795,
0.608830452,
0.3603290617,
0.4495490193,
-0.7119418979,
-0.2149288356,
-0.088208884,
-0.1904396862,
0.3377479315,
-0.3519083261,
0.6167317033,
-0.219470039,
0.0676582754,
-0.3049503267,
0.7456330657,
0.1436727345,
0.3290873766,
0.5457135439,
0.8134216666,
0.6351183057,
-0.2273238003,
0.61400038,
-0.3146249354,
0.4148391187,
0.9713737369,
-0.3281304538,
0.6834155321,
0.2338487804,
-0.2047291398,
0.2249044031,
0.6532803774,
-0.326995343,
-0.0496804714,
0.4430522025,
-0.1653332561,
-0.7213608623,
-0.3036193848,
-0.4157426059,
0.5278809071,
0.8487167954,
0.0523932241,
-0.3888827264,
-0.0096023222,
0.146383211,
-0.0990982056,
-0.4462266266,
0.8481241465,
0.1981767863,
-0.5273211002,
0.4126110971,
-0.0393567942,
0.6934885383,
-0.6661816239,
-0.2151785344,
-0.3097856343,
-0.1799848974,
-0.0516127795,
-0.8824228048,
0.2601289451,
0.1814413518,
0.0702886283,
-0.0613061562,
0.7810803652,
-0.5487163663,
-0.7376029491,
0.0547335222,
0.9104442596,
0.1908781379,
0.167788893,
-0.6217260361,
-0.0612841137,
-0.5146830678,
0.0364950895,
0.3990011215,
0.3181105554,
0.0418423153,
0.8997379541,
0.6649204493,
0.0898329541,
-0.0091530802,
-0.0738027394,
1.0275895596,
-0.7115484476,
-0.1543208361,
-0.8560113311,
0.4304505587,
0.216901511,
-0.0048257494,
0.8726089001,
0.375495404,
1.0442034006,
0.1398430616,
0.7838419676,
0.1384669095,
0.596950531,
-0.3093403578,
0.5879485011,
-0.6459998488,
0.4085704684,
-0.3270022869,
-1.009359479,
-0.6190183163,
0.5768415928,
-0.5296646357,
-0.0083582075,
0.462343961,
0.491528511,
0.1333746463,
-0.2079164535,
0.3880066276,
-0.0849698707,
0.2727621198,
0.5188381672,
0.9444758892,
-0.0392190591,
0.3346887827,
-0.4417405427,
-0.1633244157,
-0.1099724323,
-0.8547801375,
-1.1348361969,
-0.572036922,
-0.6681655049,
0.1039327383,
-0.3302194476,
1.27835989,
0.3183087707,
-0.6427810788,
-0.1984071732,
0.2980794907,
0.2628565729,
0.3372697532,
-0.2415752113,
0.3593981266,
-0.4774014354,
-0.7469545007,
0.1457163692,
0.2386642694,
0.2827916443,
-0.4735738635,
0.5254127979,
-0.1541172564,
0.2089848071,
0.4022028744,
-0.0014346046,
-0.5588471889,
-0.121681422,
0.2026319802,
-0.0916709676,
-0.223761335,
0.8001559377,
-1.0477485657,
0.3635933995,
0.2796807587,
0.9057374597,
0.1037522405,
0.0668486357,
0.1399502009,
-0.6251963377,
-0.2834312022,
0.4662970603,
0.2951057553,
0.3132292926,
-0.1260121465,
0.4199334681,
0.5997475386,
-0.2226318866,
-1.0175938606,
0.2046084702,
-0.6932607293,
-0.1185980812,
1.1436357498,
-0.2265944332,
-0.1214276925,
-0.0612265617,
0.0897303373,
0.1878252029,
-0.0316951051,
0.6222207546,
0.8603565693,
-0.0385955609,
0.0609037168,
-0.6730502248,
0.2639710307,
0.4386307299,
-0.8311374187,
-0.1219873354,
0.4220123291,
0.4282491207,
0.2556481063,
0.3394110501,
0.0851740018,
0.1322735846,
-0.4290760756,
0.179714337,
-0.2549182773,
-0.2954268754,
-0.2683063149,
0.165248692,
0.0731042251,
-0.0990732089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17254v1
|
A Hybrid Approach To Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis Using Transfer Learning
| 2024-03-25T23:02:33 | 2024-03-25T23:02:33 |
Gaurav Negi, Rajdeep Sarkar, Omnia Zayed, Paul Buitelaar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) aims to identify terms or multiword
expressions (MWEs) on which sentiments are expressed and the sentiment
polarities associated with them. The development of supervised models has been
at the forefront of research in this area. However, training these models
requires the availability of manually annotated datasets which is both
expensive and time-consuming. Furthermore, the available annotated datasets are
tailored to a specific domain, language, and text type. In this work, we
address this notable challenge in current state-of-the-art ABSA research. We
propose a hybrid approach for Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis using transfer
learning. The approach focuses on generating weakly-supervised annotations by
exploiting the strengths of both large language models (LLM) and traditional
syntactic dependencies. We utilise syntactic dependency structures of sentences
to complement the annotations generated by LLMs, as they may overlook
domain-specific aspect terms. Extensive experimentation on multiple datasets is
performed to demonstrate the efficacy of our hybrid method for the tasks of
aspect term extraction and aspect sentiment classification.
Keywords: Aspect Based Sentiment Analysis, Syntactic Parsing, large language
model (LLM)
|
[
-0.4470206201,
-0.8383524418,
0.5264614224,
0.2190727741,
-0.4368705153,
0.3685113788,
-0.1569689661,
-0.6943812966,
0.6709794998,
0.6757990718,
-0.5641924739,
-0.5173215866,
-0.442609489,
0.1122907028,
-0.0973960385,
1.3108522892,
-0.3506140709,
0.0455154218,
-0.3335534334,
-0.5080307126,
-0.3987083733,
-0.8043323755,
-0.3494872153,
-0.3598102331,
0.2410073131,
0.1829167753,
0.3621807694,
-0.109149389,
0.5104086995,
0.2152449936,
-0.2367330939,
0.1896525025,
0.0285640992,
0.0250358526,
-0.5624473691,
-0.4451875687,
-0.4712556899,
-0.1116826385,
0.3547381759,
0.9451036453,
0.2734305561,
-0.0154543752,
0.0973955467,
0.7178135514,
-0.5366461873,
0.3649304509,
-0.5515171885,
0.0133237513,
-0.0453265309,
0.1166552752,
-0.2595828176,
-0.2363270819,
0.1624395549,
-0.3241525292,
0.0647858605,
-0.1072852984,
0.6540342569,
-0.2317907512,
-0.4520219266,
-0.1078469828,
-0.814512372,
0.9009854794,
-0.6935045719,
0.1372730434,
0.0901860669,
-0.1925656199,
0.1572189778,
-0.3351646662,
-0.7024485469,
0.0863203853,
-0.2728564441,
0.1160298586,
-0.0139308823,
0.173857078,
-0.1778808981,
0.960617125,
-0.0474029668,
0.1675411463,
-0.2171948999,
-0.3064950705,
0.5700722933,
0.1172576174,
0.1085431874,
-0.6200171709,
-0.5092516541,
0.0288451724,
-0.6285117269,
0.2478322685,
0.2805995643,
0.7236958146,
-0.4489217103,
0.5975613594,
-0.2741114199,
0.5047343373,
0.1585785002,
-0.1797192097,
0.3923903406,
-0.5880329013,
0.0553108938,
-0.1927016824,
0.9603469968,
0.1014489606,
-0.266148597,
-0.0760889351,
-0.4023575783,
0.127963677,
0.209842816,
-0.2933726609,
-0.1778525412,
0.2870700061,
-0.4166006148,
-0.3892583549,
0.2196191251,
-1.0706070662,
-0.4514776766,
-0.5020707846,
0.5063508749,
-0.4581921995,
-0.3734593391,
-0.2757575214,
0.3159266412,
0.3454261422,
0.2276800424,
-0.6261388063,
0.144997403,
0.8104996681,
0.9533017278,
-0.4490711987,
-0.1142610684,
-0.3402597904,
-0.1037803143,
-0.1135216802,
1.061218977,
-0.5473757386,
-0.4780068696,
0.2216433585,
0.0590324178,
-0.0100571429,
-0.5044214129,
0.520850122,
-0.2371749431,
0.2491104007,
-0.0510428958,
-0.2943006158,
-0.8339021206,
0.3006488383,
-0.647936821,
1.0857871771,
0.4146407545,
-0.6906021833,
0.127151683,
-0.5261898637,
-1.0712052584,
-0.204484418,
-0.0900063515,
-0.6588864326,
0.3974268436,
0.3387592733,
0.5217227936,
-0.1188168973,
0.2471509129,
-0.420281589,
0.3234810829,
0.365011245,
0.0494067445,
0.3849839866,
-0.0867563635,
-0.2870298922,
0.3799955547,
-0.5695870519,
-0.3753907084,
-0.1680323631,
-0.0465317853,
-0.6511942744,
-0.2314715236,
0.106561631,
0.3676781654,
0.6183997393,
-0.6198618412,
0.2115262896,
-0.467757076,
0.2359422445,
0.5982680917,
0.2681412697,
0.5775316358,
-0.192274794,
0.5467981696,
0.5143464208,
0.217346549,
-0.0935041979,
-0.2309286147,
-0.9786860347,
-0.2122141272,
0.1626021713,
0.4466280937,
-1.0675289631,
0.8945352435,
-0.0447531678,
-0.357005626,
-0.6257670522,
0.4446324408,
0.2145902067,
0.2593974471,
0.3614355326,
-0.6129271984,
-0.4746564031,
-1.2215166092,
0.0260501467,
-0.3632425666,
0.5563352108,
0.1496335417,
0.4132505655,
0.1015282869,
1.0094263554,
-0.3006880879,
-0.6905106306,
-0.997399509,
0.4465836585,
0.1351086944,
0.2918173373,
0.4206487536,
-0.8913174272,
-0.1371619552,
0.3089517951,
-0.7520988584,
-0.0157560483,
-0.2437221706,
-0.0647134706,
0.2748568654,
0.0515605323,
-0.5030059814,
0.1922665685,
0.7446842194,
-0.063615717,
0.3740077019,
0.2012199908,
0.0026721954,
-1.5764442682,
-0.0638818443,
0.4758348763,
-0.3701915145,
-0.2796433568,
0.085970737,
-0.154326424,
-0.0697046965,
-0.6436659694,
0.3611338437,
-0.4432668984,
-0.131991744,
-0.6135393977,
-0.2040013373,
0.247568652,
0.6366048455,
0.3577456474,
0.5915005803,
0.6764228344,
-0.1936074644,
0.2808506787,
0.034295544,
0.1518715024,
0.6535772681,
-0.2058008611,
0.2978759408,
0.138657555,
0.3543019593,
-0.6601464748,
0.0869276002,
0.3081227541,
0.0965067446,
0.3848377168,
-0.160440281,
-0.3227338493,
-0.0521628149,
-0.6691448092,
0.2725105286,
0.2285842597,
-0.3890467286,
1.2132008076,
0.5310065746,
-0.3438783884,
-0.305665493,
-0.323820591,
-0.0325203016,
-0.2882378995,
-0.2300705463,
0.3524073958,
0.4431054592,
-0.3582325578,
0.1725032628,
0.0341189988,
0.0342106968,
-0.08314877,
0.3761214912,
0.498352617,
-0.3740928769,
-0.2967241406,
0.3093201518,
0.0058670947,
0.0513723977,
0.0281476602,
0.4417083561,
-0.2977102995,
-0.0555346757,
-0.5990749598,
0.5152490735,
0.390717715,
-0.2090595663,
0.8858096004,
0.3263135254,
-0.2420383841,
-0.4838856757,
-0.3481860757,
-0.133050859,
-0.3707549572,
0.490305692,
-0.2127856314,
-0.7565567493,
0.5236745477,
-0.193699643,
0.0513897911,
0.5475373268,
0.4429882467,
0.0028642167,
0.3496237695,
1.0958887339,
-0.5451169014,
0.7215622067,
-0.3401091695,
0.2550773621,
-1.0189187527,
-0.2101720124,
-0.2564224005,
-0.2994636297,
-0.4934459925,
-0.2785669565,
0.2847452164,
0.1947440058,
0.3261268437,
0.3310722113,
-0.1122797653,
0.1187772453,
0.2948848307,
0.3089503646,
0.4121743441,
-0.0765791461,
0.4097510278,
0.0291840676,
-0.2109396905,
-0.3438151479,
1.0393568277,
0.315644294,
0.6387033463,
0.0333636664,
0.6536477208,
0.4605301917,
0.4968290031,
-1.1819167137,
0.5762517452,
-0.5560419559,
-0.1203209832,
0.2603287399,
-0.3729976714,
-0.4276225269,
0.2223319113,
-0.4470502436,
-0.642173171,
0.1990199834,
-0.149485454,
-0.1524116993,
0.5558304787,
-0.5993733406,
0.601562798,
-0.2176456749,
-0.3644060194,
-0.1428296566,
-0.4933612645,
0.4598686695,
-0.3166677952,
0.3154627383,
-0.0304586012,
0.0622473843,
0.8391276002,
-0.2391919792,
1.257968545,
-0.1096246168,
-0.063660346,
0.3717129827,
0.2074647099,
0.4442445636,
-0.0624565221,
0.1376875788,
0.5037828088,
-0.2414446473,
-0.2013357878,
-0.5904512405,
0.791697979,
-0.7055229545,
-0.4621426761,
-0.4905304313,
-0.4771261513,
-0.6224111915,
-0.0915732533,
-0.0138517078,
0.2049351484,
0.0181542989,
-0.2147379816,
0.3510932922,
-0.134334594,
0.3991802633,
0.3708759546,
-0.3530365527,
-0.3694383204,
1.0283505917,
-0.1565732062,
0.2268767506,
0.5125848055,
0.1856428236,
-0.2766594887,
-0.8112783432,
-0.3209026754,
0.4543452859,
-0.5262390375,
-0.3866603673,
-0.4664437771,
-0.2517928481,
-0.3201951683,
-0.1697156876,
-0.7081615329,
-0.3211097121,
-0.2449780107,
-0.2324960679,
0.7000339031,
0.9015014172,
0.1194889471,
0.3033772707,
-0.7600869536,
0.3045134544,
-0.0545059554,
0.0470373034,
-0.1688536406,
-0.5166959763,
-0.0440910906,
-0.2577068508,
-0.5537720323,
-0.8140339851,
0.3288604915,
0.1465583891,
0.2805935144,
0.2364265621,
0.1811187714,
0.1624427438,
0.2089214027,
1.0869954824,
0.34373191,
-1.0155037642,
0.7412503362,
-0.074471496,
-0.2261928469,
0.8139264584,
0.3239343166,
-0.2265438586,
-0.5850789547,
-0.5194045901,
-1.1391183138,
0.6504002213,
-0.1400199682,
0.2110194266,
0.3127088249,
0.3770855367,
0.7953672409,
0.0174881592,
-0.9128622413,
-0.2981734276,
0.0014902597,
-0.5168363452,
0.1745742112,
0.0849905759,
0.0713572055,
-0.1474585086,
0.9029577971,
-0.285295099,
-0.0938439965,
0.0170039367,
-0.1667328924,
0.0612422265,
0.4547965229,
0.0210369453,
0.5667406321,
-0.0493880026,
0.1114269495,
0.0120158559,
-0.2099313736,
0.0533769168,
0.2604022026,
-0.2670435607,
0.0048444667,
0.4655609727,
0.7837324142,
0.0688138083,
-0.3524308205,
0.7127861977,
0.3407083452,
-0.0433862358,
-0.2181426138,
-0.2861317694,
-0.1401914656,
0.1914945692,
0.2242080569,
0.0334827006,
0.1188194007,
-0.8346871138,
0.1030942425,
0.3744982481,
-0.6047941446,
-0.8341144323,
0.162653476,
0.4933598936,
0.0380824208,
0.2797904611,
-0.0892738402,
-0.6267760992,
0.3059528172,
0.281817764,
1.0637433529,
0.1553202569,
0.4580565393,
-0.034932293,
0.0663768649,
-0.0651192367,
0.234860003,
0.1865347326,
-0.7240393758,
-0.6949884892,
-0.9808994532,
-0.6277804375,
0.3135456443,
-0.8652032018,
0.2635959387,
-0.575599134,
-0.0247597061,
0.1422118545,
-0.1383557469,
-0.4304513037,
0.031740468,
0.2856359184,
0.409109354,
-1.3179689646,
0.8034629226,
1.1789175272,
-0.7980687618,
-0.6985598207,
0.1146560609,
-0.0888479352,
-0.5965198874,
0.3011632264,
0.1791941226,
-0.074912861,
-0.5382669568,
-0.2045992762,
-0.243464902,
0.6174083948,
0.09651158,
-0.3798636794,
0.2319628447,
0.1852920055,
0.6827417016,
-0.4411371052,
-0.1159350052,
0.4813878238,
0.0764534473,
-0.0423799269,
-0.8728126287,
0.1445819438,
0.0204358362,
-0.1093974113,
0.533129096,
-0.809289217,
0.6752790213,
0.1435467154,
0.0769718587,
-0.0016554594,
1.2380803823,
-0.0710903555,
0.4360393882,
0.5630463958,
0.4894585907,
0.1467471868,
0.0338846929,
0.8566145897,
-0.2221986353,
0.5580521822,
0.917270124,
-0.5027929544,
1.1241098642,
0.7752321362,
-0.4405294955,
0.80769521,
0.5307533145,
0.3308941424,
0.539922893,
-0.2625283003,
-0.4934037626,
-0.2122575343,
-0.5278936625,
-0.0747404099,
0.4190284908,
0.3870381713,
-0.530326128,
-0.2951286435,
0.2869546115,
-0.030661149,
0.2417496145,
-0.5129266381,
1.1532101631,
0.4386983216,
-0.4575371742,
-0.2764376998,
-0.005986331,
1.1040443182,
-0.6830402613,
-0.0392340496,
-0.5956203938,
0.0845288187,
-0.3977428079,
-1.1244570017,
0.5846623778,
-0.1235008687,
-0.1124235392,
-0.0747996271,
0.6500316858,
-0.2742461562,
-0.8519565463,
0.3778136373,
0.684615612,
-0.0666364804,
-0.1126266494,
-0.6605061889,
-0.1983463913,
0.1022833586,
-0.277310282,
0.6754923463,
0.5765771866,
-0.2124144733,
0.1765537113,
0.4878354073,
0.4809879959,
-0.4429076612,
0.0406717025,
1.0382397175,
-0.8086602092,
-0.6882070899,
-0.7269312739,
0.1770617962,
0.170197323,
-0.4459768534,
0.4497156441,
0.5382351279,
0.5922453403,
0.1279754639,
1.0283272266,
-0.2831188142,
0.5528296232,
-0.7892897725,
0.1811757535,
-0.4882441461,
0.3147494495,
-0.2160153687,
-1.1746821404,
-0.1420977861,
0.218086943,
-0.6383083463,
-0.1103978232,
0.781873107,
0.562486887,
-0.2557358742,
0.3176590502,
-0.1012553349,
0.0484667532,
0.1978050023,
0.5624610782,
0.9219251871,
-0.0817479342,
0.1990218908,
-0.9135909677,
-0.2620051205,
0.0125895254,
-0.795368731,
-0.7899024487,
-0.5592848063,
-0.6155727506,
-0.4705431759,
-0.1572696418,
0.9670132995,
0.3850437999,
-0.965688467,
0.0193762761,
0.0946477577,
0.0329005979,
-0.3771897852,
-0.4066741765,
0.7000675797,
-0.1962922066,
-0.5199918747,
0.2136397213,
0.3545853198,
-0.0663905442,
-0.5987184048,
0.4229813218,
-0.1684332639,
-0.1837193966,
0.6038823724,
0.3241446316,
-0.5688010454,
-0.4806188047,
-0.56845963,
0.1334631145,
0.3807086945,
0.9893407822,
-0.627194047,
0.0850561485,
0.3463692665,
0.7121601701,
0.278836906,
0.2858866453,
0.5028498173,
-0.7757169604,
0.2319435626,
0.2784893215,
0.4471877515,
0.6959199905,
-0.5338394046,
0.1095115021,
0.5156488419,
0.0391125344,
-0.2974131703,
0.1999434829,
-1.5496079922,
-0.3857171535,
1.3813076019,
-0.2926591039,
-0.4704699516,
-0.1548707932,
-0.163008973,
0.0142012918,
-0.5305947661,
0.6847751737,
0.4742057621,
-0.5955411792,
-0.1082765833,
-0.0673294663,
0.0655747652,
0.4400636256,
-1.1867531538,
0.1115244254,
0.4298205376,
0.2689488828,
0.2758834362,
0.2968786657,
-0.1308374107,
-0.1766787469,
-0.2254403681,
0.3226222396,
-0.0565369986,
-0.190656513,
-0.5127918124,
0.3929139376,
0.0254839603,
-0.3519957364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17246v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17246v1
|
TwoStep: Multi-agent Task Planning using Classical Planners and Large Language Models
| 2024-03-25T22:47:13 | 2024-03-25T22:47:13 |
Ishika Singh, David Traum, Jesse Thomason
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA, cs.RO
|
Classical planning formulations like the Planning Domain Definition Language
(PDDL) admit action sequences guaranteed to achieve a goal state given an
initial state if any are possible. However, reasoning problems defined in PDDL
do not capture temporal aspects of action taking, for example that two agents
in the domain can execute an action simultaneously if postconditions of each do
not interfere with preconditions of the other. A human expert can decompose a
goal into largely independent constituent parts and assign each agent to one of
these subgoals to take advantage of simultaneous actions for faster execution
of plan steps, each using only single agent planning. By contrast, large
language models (LLMs) used for directly inferring plan steps do not guarantee
execution success, but do leverage commonsense reasoning to assemble action
sequences. We combine the strengths of classical planning and LLMs by
approximating human intuitions for two-agent planning goal decomposition. We
demonstrate that LLM-based goal decomposition leads to faster planning times
than solving multi-agent PDDL problems directly while simultaneously achieving
fewer plan execution steps than a single agent plan alone and preserving
execution success. Additionally, we find that LLM-based approximations of
subgoals can achieve similar multi-agent execution steps than those specified
by human experts. Website and resources at https://glamor-usc.github.io/twostep
|
[
-0.3699465394,
-0.6721914411,
0.8556475639,
0.2337999344,
-0.0196363125,
0.1165779307,
-0.2871811092,
-0.3219575584,
0.1008648425,
0.6572290659,
-0.8508090973,
-0.2686083615,
-0.3761185706,
-0.3573916256,
0.0827378631,
0.5612649322,
-0.0834549144,
0.0079645598,
-0.0383994952,
0.0597779378,
-0.2259824872,
-0.2514546514,
-0.9202209115,
-0.6565393806,
0.434553206,
0.4877442122,
0.7317210436,
0.4854255915,
0.4264255464,
0.2168721259,
0.0539179668,
0.4497624338,
-0.4029072523,
0.2227520198,
-0.3365962505,
-0.1864113063,
-0.8286525011,
-0.1299115121,
0.3263165057,
0.6047184467,
-0.2649729252,
0.0693296865,
-0.1535220891,
0.6377657056,
-0.8015959859,
0.4690602422,
-0.3588257432,
-0.0301517323,
0.2538532019,
-0.2268646359,
-0.3557778299,
0.1945964694,
0.2079668492,
-0.4528357089,
0.0604397431,
-0.2498410046,
0.260152638,
0.3558501303,
-0.4122709036,
-0.3058749139,
-0.870387435,
0.7918760777,
-0.5143862367,
0.1234125718,
0.4087052345,
0.3475373685,
-0.4541478455,
-0.5635265112,
-0.5649319887,
-0.0212127604,
0.0347648785,
-0.1280984282,
-0.0098841432,
0.2448554337,
0.3686292768,
-0.3813589215,
-0.7367880344,
0.1701772064,
-0.313439697,
0.0064833565,
0.8526784182,
0.3712334931,
-0.0076946467,
0.1253986955,
-0.7956047654,
0.0055116257,
-0.661214292,
0.1280607134,
0.1116672605,
0.3192780316,
0.0648742318,
0.5346806645,
-0.2010097206,
0.435649395,
-0.0737377927,
-0.3888712525,
-0.3956031501,
-0.3606180251,
-0.168092072,
-0.3210411966,
0.4615383148,
0.5231612325,
0.4131356776,
-0.3671097159,
-0.3854156137,
0.2282788306,
0.1532643139,
-0.6022961736,
-0.1980282217,
0.3983899951,
-0.2823502719,
0.2978729904,
-0.2620378435,
-0.6022612453,
-0.4516720474,
-0.5836423635,
0.2618737519,
-0.2855336666,
-0.3687462807,
0.1284108758,
-0.1405562609,
0.455670923,
0.629891336,
-0.7031750679,
0.8186402917,
1.1013666391,
0.6272755861,
0.1161504164,
-0.7826724052,
-0.6424881816,
0.3578464091,
-0.6081111431,
0.9078119397,
-0.3449106514,
-0.3294666409,
0.0083302846,
-0.3616299331,
-0.1023012251,
-0.126933381,
0.2818543017,
-0.5832160711,
-0.2006326169,
-0.7244403958,
-0.3736903667,
-0.4008444548,
0.3272972405,
-0.4085407853,
0.7447780967,
-0.0452105775,
-0.3470730186,
0.5245934725,
-0.8770860434,
-0.6379908323,
-0.0939345136,
-0.0784766451,
0.1017076597,
-0.1506662816,
0.0103495149,
0.7509695888,
-0.6111411452,
0.3083237112,
-0.2696156502,
-0.0624766015,
-0.145978421,
0.0904901326,
0.7961568832,
0.2091305554,
-0.4233118296,
0.2819792032,
-0.0457188189,
0.1281706095,
0.0241592787,
-0.2351249307,
-0.0476726294,
0.4856616557,
0.1193182021,
0.6112578511,
0.3319448233,
-0.1587010473,
0.511239171,
-0.3237396777,
0.3349166214,
0.6700939536,
-0.1075213104,
0.7814441919,
-0.6054347157,
0.5112972856,
-0.4502164125,
0.0377106704,
0.1053637341,
-0.5051681399,
-0.5834343433,
-0.0199724659,
-0.2443162501,
0.6595214009,
-0.7524941564,
0.1832586974,
-0.2418678552,
-0.4641176164,
-0.0334737487,
0.0083809067,
0.6049751043,
0.0507609621,
0.3403097093,
-0.3886242211,
-0.2895905674,
-0.6621055007,
-0.1485431045,
-0.3239557445,
0.1757484227,
-0.1156729013,
0.6868041754,
0.2089689374,
0.8308575749,
-0.5262194872,
-0.4038293064,
-0.7060724497,
0.3081516922,
-0.1315259039,
0.2509333193,
0.574557364,
-0.8616937399,
-0.4509530365,
-0.1948667318,
-0.5077648759,
0.2210289091,
-0.2586102188,
-0.0847660676,
0.1690569669,
0.2213739753,
-0.8727400899,
0.4336868525,
0.1956236362,
-0.4452566504,
0.7786800861,
-0.4402234256,
0.0367533229,
-0.92969203,
0.0240676682,
0.0938579366,
-0.2177853435,
-0.9844266176,
0.4538910687,
0.0238354728,
-0.022358913,
-0.4700579047,
0.7916486859,
-0.7679072618,
-0.6650320888,
-0.5747385621,
-0.100259833,
-0.2995023131,
0.8892506957,
0.2961476445,
0.6433085203,
0.4752568007,
-0.7297412753,
0.3769872189,
0.1472506672,
-0.0038872373,
0.4875764847,
-0.6186969876,
0.2246008217,
-0.2295400351,
0.4495936632,
-0.6809987426,
-0.346075058,
0.3682815135,
-0.1846683174,
0.4506350458,
-0.220887661,
-0.5482301116,
-0.3351518512,
-0.4277586639,
0.2582554221,
0.3999086022,
-0.1776538491,
0.5524263978,
0.5223746896,
-0.2305469364,
-0.6484225988,
-0.7915350199,
0.1267586052,
0.0240904223,
-0.6143381596,
0.2550069392,
-0.0197759308,
-0.5869585872,
0.0571387038,
-0.1177973002,
-0.3163567483,
-0.0078670327,
0.3484692574,
0.0522235818,
0.2403727025,
-0.0647495165,
0.0224071182,
-0.392457962,
0.0887519047,
-0.2239153087,
0.6011431813,
0.2747476697,
-0.4469866753,
-0.504562974,
0.7701479793,
0.9732254148,
-0.4616420567,
0.583676815,
0.3972878456,
-0.5429508686,
-0.2884439528,
-0.4852947295,
-0.1519511491,
-0.3245256543,
0.1541604102,
-0.6543595195,
-0.3597196043,
0.1946146786,
-0.2669874728,
0.662468195,
0.2377837747,
0.6769536138,
0.0742193758,
0.8704858422,
0.536241293,
0.1869343221,
0.0865058303,
-0.5710986853,
0.0414988175,
-0.7835037708,
-0.2853423655,
-0.5012285709,
-0.4355317056,
-0.0703166872,
-0.907559514,
0.3126590252,
0.0008059828,
-0.1198503003,
0.5246654153,
-0.2892519534,
0.3605662286,
0.6057795286,
-0.0801469535,
0.2231910229,
-0.0921139717,
0.1765191257,
0.1609006822,
-0.6493090987,
-0.7134314179,
1.0008751154,
0.0844184235,
0.5907013416,
0.1751763374,
0.7438813448,
0.3829305768,
-0.2036010176,
-0.8592426777,
0.8489077091,
-0.0596731044,
-0.7517294884,
-0.5846127272,
-0.1342906505,
-0.8630732298,
0.3604203165,
-0.1978120208,
-1.0112206936,
0.3256626427,
0.0032985711,
-0.2823099792,
0.3294286132,
-0.6191346049,
0.8269636035,
-0.1614595801,
-0.3579606712,
-0.8997728825,
-0.8116552234,
0.3218669593,
0.1305563301,
0.27798599,
-0.67255193,
-0.3084235191,
0.8127093315,
-0.5160105228,
0.725420773,
-0.3455986083,
0.1067018956,
0.3417906165,
0.1761211902,
0.8728064299,
-0.1804199219,
-0.1226077229,
-0.3970438242,
-0.0417186357,
-0.8281652331,
-0.4560040832,
0.7081844211,
-0.5218737125,
-0.5906896591,
-0.3690624237,
-0.7232195735,
-0.0748672187,
0.0246396866,
-0.0586192422,
0.6225770712,
-0.2462567389,
-0.505864799,
0.2264347523,
0.2671113014,
1.0027959347,
0.5326706171,
0.0543339252,
-0.117451556,
0.3486906886,
0.1885396391,
0.432756573,
0.5302866101,
-0.1338733882,
-0.478081733,
-0.6844035983,
-0.2365999669,
0.2813347876,
-0.6796266437,
0.0934537128,
-0.5563105345,
0.1836697906,
-0.4392554164,
-0.4760503173,
-0.4899813235,
-0.5610042214,
0.1117433161,
0.3332743347,
-0.0452716574,
0.8707640171,
-0.4046843052,
0.097161822,
-0.3927871287,
0.5880612731,
0.5230056643,
-0.2843236327,
-0.039744962,
0.1136960015,
-0.0321187563,
0.0718630403,
-0.287540406,
-1.0320967436,
0.4004813731,
0.1533297598,
0.5400640368,
0.4559923708,
0.346042186,
0.6082726717,
-0.4044965804,
0.5366677046,
0.2691096663,
-0.6975067854,
0.5461173058,
-0.2852825224,
0.3482695818,
0.3357213736,
0.4764036536,
-0.3873996735,
-0.0887457728,
-0.45478338,
-0.5361725688,
0.9056348205,
0.0258187633,
-0.3363243341,
0.2166905701,
0.1262674779,
0.0504744053,
0.1184131801,
-0.2745652199,
-0.3134548664,
0.3162185252,
0.3822817206,
-0.4086822271,
-0.521287024,
-0.4188918471,
0.0563629009,
0.5323072076,
-0.1924703419,
0.4165323377,
0.096475862,
-0.1570653021,
-0.325024724,
0.5716863871,
0.918073535,
1.1600726843,
0.0582367703,
0.3497880697,
0.1386087239,
-0.0914267525,
0.3718955815,
0.2706269026,
0.021871686,
-0.4494253099,
0.7024367452,
0.3098916411,
0.223909691,
-0.5859161019,
0.3292676806,
0.0364396907,
-0.3312323391,
-0.234014526,
0.014245104,
0.1314736754,
0.7506471276,
0.4996270239,
0.2914022207,
0.0324707814,
-0.683855176,
-0.0045008291,
0.3042975962,
-0.1644659936,
-0.4797568023,
0.5243389606,
0.2444219887,
-0.5575195551,
0.214310497,
-0.7286958694,
-0.5068641901,
0.7393481135,
0.4902470708,
1.0194225311,
-0.2652954757,
0.4591340423,
0.1344110072,
0.4514787495,
-0.3553689718,
0.6960545778,
0.0055715321,
-0.6351369023,
-0.8147009015,
-0.4890473187,
-0.2867975235,
-0.2686437368,
-0.3318329453,
0.0118316161,
-0.5420938134,
-0.1002610549,
0.0457119197,
0.3478082716,
-0.7494348288,
-0.0658918023,
-0.1777653843,
0.7734707594,
-0.7081736326,
0.8102401495,
1.201394558,
-0.190333724,
-0.901271224,
0.0343379192,
0.3309454322,
-0.717359066,
0.5299767852,
-0.0841230527,
-0.1415962428,
-0.0489149764,
-0.0325194187,
-0.6206476688,
1.1407741308,
0.2975217104,
-0.5046632886,
-0.4589886665,
-0.0973968506,
0.2212459445,
-0.2041223198,
0.0010441158,
0.6294699311,
0.7812491059,
0.3911293149,
-1.1858531237,
0.2288549989,
0.2218231559,
-0.2847048342,
0.662894249,
-0.3497844636,
0.9459416866,
-0.7284722328,
-0.2272985131,
0.1270102113,
0.4283090234,
0.0907059833,
0.6635416746,
0.570681572,
0.6420210004,
0.5072363615,
0.0242534764,
0.9641369581,
-0.1409816146,
0.4766141176,
0.9897475243,
-0.3985460997,
0.797065556,
0.3367869556,
-0.4332455695,
0.0993209928,
0.364536792,
0.5432010293,
0.6699387431,
-0.0812985748,
-0.3765007257,
-0.5667490363,
-0.1488212943,
-0.1101006493,
0.6486008167,
0.3774858117,
0.1730594039,
-0.5991768837,
-0.1527852118,
0.3036831319,
0.1028260514,
-0.4011963606,
0.6320028901,
0.0116811572,
-1.1012077332,
0.341644913,
0.1509028375,
0.1996876001,
-0.3790253997,
0.0430982374,
0.1080379859,
0.2477417439,
-0.0959761292,
-0.8565888405,
0.2782590389,
-0.256726414,
-0.1385369599,
-0.4347573221,
0.9038980007,
-0.4423326254,
-0.0750460923,
0.3030706346,
0.8318756819,
0.1116037816,
-0.1565690935,
-0.7401534915,
-0.4324978292,
-0.3113527894,
-0.1783598959,
0.2086297423,
0.184518218,
-0.1176288128,
0.8311809301,
0.3887884617,
0.1211939678,
-0.1676964313,
-0.36459288,
0.7805479765,
-0.6145006418,
-0.4738472998,
-0.8095707297,
0.4804503024,
0.0303343479,
-0.110360153,
0.2777147293,
0.3886488676,
0.6145516038,
-0.0197708998,
0.5406451225,
-0.1564881802,
0.2651779354,
-0.5667367578,
0.3010522425,
-0.5197102427,
0.1777018458,
-0.1472527236,
-0.8901136518,
-0.1779610664,
0.3609004319,
-0.4741173089,
-0.1113947406,
0.8126367331,
0.7623912096,
0.1040272862,
-0.3498776257,
0.4216595888,
-0.3218483031,
0.3286544085,
1.0320048332,
0.8264739513,
0.13672629,
0.31816715,
-0.2873250544,
-0.3226802349,
-0.2836050093,
-0.5693557858,
-1.1356836557,
-0.722430408,
-0.1373313516,
0.2062772512,
0.4363796711,
1.2733659744,
0.9826613069,
-0.4240694642,
-0.5390383601,
-0.0986760035,
0.281208992,
-0.5679818392,
-0.1279447675,
0.339572072,
-0.3601049185,
-0.5855848789,
0.7292548418,
0.4163262546,
-0.1968697608,
-0.4065938294,
-0.5208683014,
-0.4793478549,
-0.0308973733,
0.5797216296,
0.5994548798,
-1.064247489,
-0.0703585744,
-0.114866294,
-0.0871725157,
-0.3620145619,
1.1353088617,
-0.6039449573,
0.340926975,
0.5569497347,
0.2260704786,
0.7063742876,
-0.1222750917,
0.6002035141,
-0.5718194246,
0.292706579,
0.2524179816,
0.2871624827,
-0.2393727601,
-0.0261980202,
0.7243446708,
0.0668748543,
-0.6919206381,
-0.4570837915,
0.5610681772,
-1.0432610512,
-0.5920989513,
1.1698704958,
-0.2000066936,
-0.0017619164,
-0.2919848561,
-0.3069077432,
0.3007826507,
-0.582003355,
0.4498046339,
0.3827269375,
-0.4715988934,
-0.1611241549,
-0.4492157698,
0.5957812071,
0.1933721453,
-0.8590598106,
0.1325633675,
0.7297245264,
-0.096686393,
0.2244367152,
1.0834724903,
0.5293936729,
0.658509016,
0.1971831322,
0.0814441592,
-0.2093771994,
-0.7842568159,
0.1402541995,
0.4821221232,
0.3333105445,
-0.1427108198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17245v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17245v1
|
SPLICE: A Singleton-Enhanced PipeLIne for Coreference REsolution
| 2024-03-25T22:46:16 | 2024-03-25T22:46:16 |
Yilun Zhu, Siyao Peng, Sameer Pradhan, Amir Zeldes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Singleton mentions, i.e.~entities mentioned only once in a text, are
important to how humans understand discourse from a theoretical perspective.
However previous attempts to incorporate their detection in end-to-end neural
coreference resolution for English have been hampered by the lack of singleton
mention spans in the OntoNotes benchmark. This paper addresses this limitation
by combining predicted mentions from existing nested NER systems and features
derived from OntoNotes syntax trees. With this approach, we create a near
approximation of the OntoNotes dataset with all singleton mentions, achieving
~94% recall on a sample of gold singletons. We then propose a two-step neural
mention and coreference resolution system, named SPLICE, and compare its
performance to the end-to-end approach in two scenarios: the OntoNotes test set
and the out-of-domain (OOD) OntoGUM corpus. Results indicate that reconstructed
singleton training yields results comparable to end-to-end systems for
OntoNotes, while improving OOD stability (+1.1 avg. F1). We conduct error
analysis for mention detection and delve into its impact on coreference
clustering, revealing that precision improvements deliver more substantial
benefits than increases in recall for resolving coreference chains.
|
[
-0.5390238762,
-0.6385977864,
0.3942076564,
-0.1124135032,
-0.5108795762,
0.0215956829,
-0.7538136244,
-0.6170275807,
0.5925009251,
0.4519428611,
-0.2132891268,
-0.312456131,
-0.7726585865,
0.3914472461,
-0.469543159,
1.2777329683,
0.3671906888,
-0.3611807227,
-0.4511599541,
-0.287258774,
-0.1561907828,
-0.6648277044,
-0.5689529777,
-0.2550035715,
0.7190718055,
0.67160815,
0.1779186279,
0.6977121234,
0.4475285709,
0.2901749015,
-0.5019640923,
0.5334989429,
-0.1661376059,
0.1165433452,
-0.3129320145,
-0.4074611962,
-0.7164692879,
-0.1376580894,
0.6010048389,
0.6539875865,
0.2593481541,
0.1577287912,
0.0047830301,
0.3420699537,
-0.5332794785,
-0.0877195969,
-0.8524211049,
-0.021469295,
-0.2963487804,
-0.1941028535,
-0.4073859453,
-0.275080502,
0.5069246292,
-0.4414543211,
0.3860733807,
0.0323185511,
1.0316417217,
0.0912109241,
-0.1819129735,
-0.4244123101,
-0.3236751854,
0.7029417157,
-0.755102098,
-0.261365056,
0.2891209126,
0.0158461109,
0.2988102138,
-0.8224938512,
-0.3305733204,
-0.3790952861,
-0.5449845791,
0.0945088044,
-0.0014349874,
0.0764271393,
0.1347980201,
0.5132092834,
-0.1859143674,
-0.0629858673,
-0.5241791606,
-0.0712111667,
0.4426524937,
-0.3511644304,
0.0410653763,
-0.353059262,
-0.3333314061,
0.502496779,
-0.5452833772,
-0.2196703404,
-0.1244185716,
0.5240541101,
0.4466727674,
0.2520616055,
0.4336411655,
0.438200593,
0.6754294634,
-0.2101536542,
0.0974819511,
-0.342476517,
0.0688819662,
0.496801883,
0.4628978372,
0.4026789963,
0.3657847345,
-0.5044873357,
0.1203653142,
0.2728140652,
0.3422134817,
-0.4698495567,
-0.1398162246,
0.1555268317,
-0.0452233255,
0.0151447244,
-0.1109037995,
-0.3101516664,
-0.3497818708,
-0.1576072574,
0.2543698251,
-0.5550603271,
-0.2418450713,
0.0138158975,
-0.3373174071,
-0.2679637372,
0.3314679563,
-0.7144532204,
0.6129878163,
0.6817798018,
0.8495965004,
-0.1845318377,
-0.5755718946,
-0.2633498311,
0.1666324288,
-0.1088221744,
1.3787807226,
-0.1012962088,
-0.4275883138,
-0.3660667837,
-0.1489268839,
-0.2265481204,
-0.710826695,
0.4946861267,
0.1294610202,
-0.0089325616,
-0.1543006897,
-0.7559989095,
-0.2632449865,
0.4975130558,
-0.5869352818,
1.0477676392,
-0.1807177514,
-0.872780025,
0.2291453481,
-0.3381378651,
-0.3903819621,
0.1370769441,
-0.3191724718,
-0.2911590338,
0.2082416862,
0.1240543872,
0.6428043246,
-0.4071390033,
0.4112470448,
0.1858558208,
-0.3070798516,
0.1491925865,
0.2199144512,
0.3747715652,
-0.37396878,
-0.2907000482,
0.175343886,
-0.7149835825,
-0.2204201519,
-0.2160692811,
0.0193469562,
-0.652762711,
-0.2317315489,
-0.1627647132,
0.0945818648,
0.2277222872,
-0.8954076171,
0.1505715698,
-0.3155575991,
0.4341286719,
0.5282158852,
0.1664023399,
0.6225253344,
-0.264015615,
0.085005559,
0.2590865791,
-0.0906160027,
-0.6716330647,
-0.5065970421,
-0.8711709976,
-0.2690374553,
0.1446919292,
0.3077020645,
-0.1366627812,
0.6667478085,
-0.536337316,
-0.4957744181,
-0.2689865828,
-0.0159308985,
0.8299432993,
0.4917578399,
0.4587608874,
-0.5308833122,
-0.9895635843,
-0.8655921221,
-0.3280574083,
-0.291782558,
0.1340590566,
0.5242699981,
0.6115274429,
0.1924589872,
1.2925518751,
-0.4159154296,
-0.6085813046,
-0.2125090212,
0.1249764189,
0.3014778197,
0.4664734602,
0.4621677995,
-0.6069056392,
-0.4534139037,
0.2707342505,
-0.6780068278,
0.1409142613,
-0.1686577946,
0.1192369461,
-0.0702251345,
0.6174609661,
-0.5204786658,
0.3044783771,
0.1714389771,
-0.3794623017,
0.8004288077,
-0.1620653272,
-0.1558766216,
-1.0918643475,
0.2300105095,
0.0817292035,
-0.3541070223,
-0.4685015082,
-0.2081363946,
0.1196579933,
0.2854404747,
-0.2353555858,
0.3863635361,
-0.6676262021,
-0.069903709,
-0.2274600118,
0.5451772809,
0.0525452383,
0.4667771459,
0.1665622294,
0.7337521315,
0.2914568484,
-0.6121612787,
0.2107762247,
0.4298994541,
-0.267349869,
0.8595193028,
-0.4758993983,
0.3706859052,
-0.2049704194,
0.3720637858,
-0.8018760681,
0.1785218418,
-0.271620065,
-0.7407066822,
0.3221668303,
-0.1000763252,
-0.2438908964,
-0.1091870889,
-0.2145426422,
0.1849723756,
0.0815869048,
-0.509991467,
0.6922940016,
0.6555560827,
-0.211141482,
-0.4230946004,
-0.9549065828,
0.3700277507,
-0.2116587013,
-0.3598063886,
0.7346619964,
0.0915589705,
-0.0433767624,
0.0830596164,
-0.3699904978,
-0.2400561869,
-0.1264059991,
0.387329489,
0.2318667918,
-0.2640723884,
0.2204879671,
-0.1767194122,
-0.4436559379,
-0.0761336535,
-0.5830442905,
-0.0164607186,
-0.3701145947,
0.3231013119,
-0.113373667,
0.4610701799,
0.4010160565,
-0.2042932212,
0.4864458144,
0.1920051128,
-0.4938941896,
-0.1562002301,
-0.7722554803,
-0.2926361263,
-0.3933231831,
0.2423189878,
-0.4163593054,
-1.0421144962,
0.4711791873,
-0.3530820012,
0.3898344338,
0.2769987881,
0.101911366,
-0.1970429868,
0.1156266257,
0.401285708,
0.1939465553,
0.1367064863,
-0.3043669164,
0.3664166927,
-1.249519825,
-0.1424391121,
-0.640900135,
-0.1662135273,
-0.026420841,
-0.5863422751,
0.1855127811,
0.3153191209,
0.0697286278,
0.887550354,
-0.6409353018,
0.5643662214,
0.340952605,
0.1254677027,
0.5558553338,
0.0127838189,
-0.3507329226,
-0.2235826254,
-0.7386127114,
-0.4205362201,
0.6184741855,
0.0103894668,
0.0130020576,
-0.1028048843,
0.6685154438,
0.2057170868,
0.5124937296,
-0.8743545413,
0.8500365615,
-0.4888367951,
-0.7162946463,
-0.134352088,
-0.1728058308,
-0.6204620004,
0.1569947004,
0.1427684724,
-1.0376865864,
0.2709362805,
0.1668855995,
-0.6880974174,
0.5019133091,
-0.368254751,
0.3990871608,
0.1569394022,
-0.2247630656,
-0.0513797961,
-0.7013517618,
0.2372348458,
0.1109233946,
0.1070577055,
-0.2205117196,
0.0201026611,
0.834457159,
-0.3682082891,
0.9459968805,
0.2363111377,
0.0822708681,
0.4657247961,
-0.1205771118,
0.2076693326,
-0.0428905636,
-0.0434715413,
0.3012603521,
-0.2048735172,
-0.1598002017,
-0.5353691578,
0.8526929021,
-0.4676657021,
-0.3161467016,
-0.4800178707,
-0.4353625178,
0.0686110184,
0.0110603962,
0.5033851266,
0.5639074445,
-0.1398538798,
0.187826246,
0.5981592536,
0.2550251484,
0.4314227402,
0.2771415114,
-0.096188657,
-0.7221179605,
0.5149977207,
0.5258640051,
0.0352463126,
0.1201757789,
0.1414209902,
-0.1586258262,
-0.2637394667,
-0.469776988,
0.5562583804,
-0.8054055572,
-0.3673498034,
-0.881319344,
-0.1312551349,
-0.3772897422,
-0.4795509279,
-0.7069185972,
-0.7354750633,
-0.1976501048,
-0.3860156536,
0.7227090001,
0.5207636952,
-0.1615508497,
0.3248792291,
-0.797418654,
0.0806273371,
0.0642761812,
0.1523024291,
0.0249156747,
-0.7097294927,
-0.5369669795,
-0.7063996196,
0.135680601,
-0.6896766424,
0.0481634028,
0.6979968548,
0.200326249,
0.5293760896,
0.0126117328,
1.0149412155,
-0.6119863987,
0.8956568241,
0.2886701524,
-1.024012208,
0.5130072832,
-0.1442071944,
0.4238657355,
0.8716762066,
0.1973504871,
-0.8567919731,
-0.2915226817,
-0.7624686956,
-1.1932387352,
0.5184117556,
0.0949086323,
-0.1181246638,
-0.4262435734,
0.7344804406,
0.2369518429,
0.1784034371,
-0.3858063817,
-0.5853021741,
0.3246283829,
0.3219481111,
-0.2472676337,
-0.3823938072,
-0.0078414539,
-0.311624378,
0.6528633237,
-0.1302912235,
0.2396759242,
0.4463294148,
-0.273878336,
0.1333269775,
0.1429432184,
0.1844484508,
0.5744618177,
-0.2978922129,
0.4892362058,
0.2558341622,
-0.6152091026,
0.071193628,
-0.1460867524,
-0.2810426652,
0.6149575114,
0.3558526039,
0.4512989521,
0.9076356292,
-0.3495545089,
0.1763373017,
0.1338530928,
-0.1455902606,
-0.5164434314,
-0.2558189034,
0.2929627895,
-0.1797669828,
0.5092786551,
0.4237415195,
-0.0308542065,
-0.5425026417,
0.6170579195,
-0.1840955317,
-0.4597007334,
-0.4447882771,
-0.0241115652,
0.3907846808,
-0.265897423,
0.3903467953,
-0.1184671,
-0.7680827379,
0.543632865,
0.7606374025,
0.8817410469,
-0.3104691505,
0.0697732493,
0.9036064744,
0.249281168,
-0.1803509593,
-0.0038226356,
-0.5003076792,
-0.8072550297,
-0.4280467629,
-0.2796417177,
-0.4591008723,
-0.3639751077,
-1.093654871,
0.0834393203,
-0.7437825799,
-0.4664114118,
0.234281376,
-0.032313358,
-0.1760693789,
0.2506328225,
0.0991152376,
0.914783895,
-0.5568038225,
0.7478473186,
0.9347353578,
-0.2827281952,
-0.5149372816,
-0.3411253095,
-0.0777145773,
0.1297225356,
0.2510259449,
0.5235663652,
-0.3210529685,
0.2988344133,
-0.249747768,
-0.8963137269,
0.9024280906,
0.176007092,
-0.3563670218,
-0.1797018349,
-0.2789207101,
0.2415787876,
-0.3868140876,
0.6792567968,
1.071321249,
0.3597186506,
0.0359444618,
-1.0799509287,
-0.0231266189,
-0.4881779552,
-0.0971379727,
0.274815619,
-0.5343770981,
0.8009544611,
-0.0558499098,
-0.5139949322,
0.051663667,
0.8061339259,
0.3721096516,
0.3571973145,
0.5113463998,
0.591073215,
0.7273821235,
-0.133699894,
0.7446064353,
-0.1305117011,
0.4999189377,
1.7007899284,
-0.2582730353,
0.8340060115,
0.7538415194,
-0.0466409773,
0.5484477282,
0.2845339775,
0.2496027499,
0.1527457833,
0.0757739842,
-0.4447817802,
-0.1023507714,
-0.5663935542,
-0.2636496425,
0.1223122329,
0.6617362499,
-0.2036118805,
-0.4502285421,
0.0587295555,
0.2763643563,
0.4545252919,
-0.4511592686,
0.9027403593,
0.3324276805,
-0.8786846399,
0.4532316923,
-0.2401361167,
1.0682704449,
-0.6305157542,
0.1006162986,
-0.2853890359,
0.4062209129,
-0.4553595185,
-0.4558094442,
0.5244913101,
0.1637973338,
-0.2497028857,
-0.1557479203,
0.834944725,
-0.4078087211,
-0.2379488647,
0.5163133144,
0.2497946173,
0.4024968445,
-0.1205903739,
-0.4543212652,
-0.3343574107,
-0.1094345078,
0.0614985898,
0.0846976563,
0.4225554168,
0.1956412196,
0.2518568635,
0.4660648108,
0.2268890291,
0.1820021719,
-0.1925347,
0.9160103202,
-0.7163596749,
-0.6187545061,
-0.6870060563,
0.6045565009,
-0.3657930195,
-0.7427631021,
1.0480780602,
0.5400674939,
0.7721108198,
-0.0027509627,
0.7267943621,
-0.2309127301,
0.7821085453,
0.047574196,
0.3730299473,
-0.2332413048,
0.0706639066,
-0.3361492753,
-0.6551327109,
-0.6856715083,
0.7330046892,
-0.2588810325,
-0.3902380168,
1.1052685976,
0.662206769,
-0.097580649,
0.2171272188,
0.4447743595,
0.3638591766,
-0.0827358291,
0.447751075,
0.6613042951,
-0.6313704848,
0.3499863446,
-0.2649742365,
-0.0763195977,
-0.2414890081,
-0.8929061294,
-0.7098993659,
-0.6605953574,
-0.5157614946,
-0.5182213187,
0.3342430294,
1.0922780037,
0.6299005747,
-0.7490152121,
-0.3807668388,
-0.057378035,
-0.2852946222,
-0.4619158804,
-0.084378846,
0.5522856116,
-0.3286135197,
-0.5618562698,
0.503903389,
0.7606241703,
-0.5637912154,
-0.0858299136,
0.188363269,
-0.6505789161,
0.0513641462,
0.5217678547,
0.2754795253,
-0.6323213577,
-0.2209009826,
-0.1311087012,
-0.0960804969,
0.3369368911,
1.251480937,
-0.918771565,
0.3438544571,
0.2681431174,
0.5069058537,
0.5628665686,
0.0753709972,
0.4479634762,
-0.908336401,
0.3997185528,
0.5195077062,
0.338586241,
0.4076455832,
-0.4014216661,
0.4431881905,
0.218302682,
-0.4813838005,
-0.6679793596,
0.119462043,
-0.9691451192,
-0.2119542807,
0.8454498649,
-0.7994052172,
-0.5425975323,
-0.4536769092,
-0.2569038868,
0.2877351046,
-0.3819229901,
0.6837601662,
0.505351603,
0.1061159298,
-0.3184984624,
-0.0396507606,
0.3164676428,
0.6666053534,
-0.5836587548,
0.141912967,
0.3448222876,
0.1593614072,
0.8011244535,
0.7502778769,
-0.0538883135,
0.5377877951,
0.0332322456,
0.2369134724,
-0.1088497117,
-0.579985261,
-0.2840158641,
0.2994745374,
-0.0784705803,
-0.0849839374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17240v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17240v2
|
The Role of $n$-gram Smoothing in the Age of Neural Networks
| 2024-03-25T22:42:19 | 2024-04-30T20:58:40 |
Luca Malagutti, Andrius Buinovskij, Anej Svete, Clara Meister, Afra Amini, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For nearly three decades, language models derived from the $n$-gram
assumption held the state of the art on the task. The key to their success lay
in the application of various smoothing techniques that served to combat
overfitting. However, when neural language models toppled $n$-gram models as
the best performers, $n$-gram smoothing techniques became less relevant.
Indeed, it would hardly be an understatement to suggest that the line of
inquiry into $n$-gram smoothing techniques became dormant. This paper re-opens
the role classical $n$-gram smoothing techniques may play in the age of neural
language models. First, we draw a formal equivalence between label smoothing, a
popular regularization technique for neural language models, and add-$\lambda$
smoothing. Second, we derive a generalized framework for converting any
$n$-gram smoothing technique into a regularizer compatible with neural language
models. Our empirical results find that our novel regularizers are comparable
to and, indeed, sometimes outperform label smoothing on language modeling and
machine translation.
|
[
-0.6772233844,
-0.6432980299,
0.4833137989,
0.1766387969,
-0.0309014022,
-0.2402204424,
-0.4052819312,
-0.3155909777,
0.3813539445,
0.2630207539,
-0.0176855903,
-0.1784869134,
-0.8291641474,
-0.0865552202,
-0.5975010395,
0.933863163,
0.3724698722,
0.0126440255,
-0.0967696682,
0.2505845129,
0.1051474065,
-0.4172629714,
-1.1654882431,
-0.8461967707,
0.9657767415,
-0.1645769775,
0.9883200526,
0.7749478221,
0.2356164306,
0.3501220047,
-0.3165413737,
0.191609934,
-0.3511344194,
0.0146451611,
0.396089077,
-0.5034124255,
-0.9068807364,
0.2019470632,
0.8917437792,
0.8874715567,
-0.0136193233,
-0.2440972626,
0.0781909525,
1.14077878,
-0.6712760329,
0.0711895674,
-0.4653486609,
-0.1292744428,
-0.2602275908,
-0.4331128299,
-0.3920003474,
-0.6311149001,
-0.1956817657,
-0.6963086128,
0.1686380208,
-0.2794551849,
1.0577840805,
0.2326121181,
-0.3019690514,
0.1093387455,
-0.7344461679,
0.7054536939,
-1.1655675173,
0.3154964447,
0.7796148062,
0.4703465998,
-0.6970829368,
-0.7271687984,
-0.4470670521,
-0.2254998386,
0.0661825165,
-0.0438944325,
-0.2090764791,
0.1577453911,
0.2096388042,
0.4381752312,
-0.1071752682,
0.3933283985,
-0.3757076561,
-0.1047249585,
0.4177310765,
-0.3805819154,
0.2171161771,
0.2914955318,
-0.0667236,
0.1991004497,
-0.6779943705,
-0.2052683383,
0.5100118518,
0.4645015001,
0.3467679322,
0.0449342765,
-0.4654154778,
1.0482548475,
-0.044380866,
-0.0736634359,
-0.1066777036,
-0.1040706038,
-0.3185048997,
0.1013071761,
0.4877584875,
0.5720030069,
0.8510779738,
-0.4733645916,
-0.2756169438,
0.1349442899,
0.303937614,
-0.7119881511,
-0.311553359,
-0.3073262274,
-0.4454212487,
-0.1811728776,
-0.1430586725,
-0.8691398501,
-0.4385626614,
-0.3655293584,
0.1854213625,
-0.2001868039,
-0.212704286,
0.3528500199,
-0.2518263161,
0.226362437,
0.1881159544,
-1.052090168,
0.8623236418,
1.1139961481,
0.7236766815,
0.1748806834,
0.0368302129,
-0.3627525866,
-0.3997493088,
-0.730229795,
0.5782443285,
-0.7087850571,
-0.0567993298,
0.0454789437,
-0.2554164231,
-0.1444607973,
-0.3342858553,
0.486458689,
-0.8037437201,
0.0916787982,
-0.1089515761,
-0.6604841948,
-0.476066947,
0.3650388122,
-0.2354248911,
0.8973371387,
-0.1695882231,
-0.3726644814,
0.4401068389,
-0.2746404111,
-0.2392615527,
-0.2473262399,
0.0437422432,
-0.2262172848,
0.4840369821,
0.2237482667,
0.3061155379,
-0.4454820752,
0.4060603082,
-0.3644656241,
-0.7559219599,
0.4218650758,
-0.7779262066,
0.6100574136,
-0.07965523,
-0.0254666768,
-0.323954314,
-0.8606414795,
0.2182226181,
-0.2480467707,
-0.5137409568,
-0.5350444913,
-0.0468481258,
0.0187116582,
0.2955980301,
0.0002768344,
-0.7503523231,
0.33902812,
-0.5245871544,
0.7374421954,
0.3759560585,
-0.2253232449,
0.5739232898,
-0.4614326954,
0.3044015765,
-0.4160385728,
0.1007993966,
-0.0327825174,
-0.9631334543,
-1.1563053131,
-0.0472660549,
0.8845966458,
0.0639711469,
-0.4353265464,
0.1208146736,
-0.4536613822,
-0.6406284571,
-0.594068408,
0.0207878388,
0.3043417633,
0.4057683945,
0.5178752542,
-0.3886423409,
-0.2816001475,
-1.0529631376,
-0.3472275138,
0.0409528129,
-0.0359899141,
-0.0148891695,
-0.1444664299,
-0.0225028507,
0.7011452317,
-0.2343639284,
-0.1538307071,
0.302477777,
0.3149986863,
0.1869072765,
0.8575429916,
0.629742682,
-0.5727950931,
-0.1712112427,
0.052590318,
-0.4196835458,
-0.2105436027,
-0.1601043046,
0.1033321023,
0.3851372898,
0.9167433977,
-0.1683577895,
0.662007153,
0.7111204863,
-0.0176826157,
0.2797297835,
-0.6266304255,
-0.0005863311,
-0.6241057515,
-0.042018,
0.3185925484,
-0.1970951259,
-1.0320199728,
0.1352430582,
0.2074214518,
0.202079609,
-0.0745710805,
0.4877279401,
-0.4755543768,
-0.1456981748,
-0.8104740977,
0.2650345564,
0.1537366509,
0.4774293303,
-0.3907285631,
0.4643850625,
0.7604497671,
-0.8966220021,
-0.1566827446,
-0.250877887,
0.0579220615,
0.1729072481,
-0.5745596886,
0.2002907395,
-0.4009382725,
0.2914782465,
-1.0400671959,
0.2734421194,
0.2030667663,
-0.4819764495,
0.8416158557,
-0.519972086,
-0.4167581797,
-0.1723679304,
-0.1030197218,
0.3651058674,
0.7913549542,
-0.2616790831,
0.5892637968,
0.0873171985,
0.0021554988,
-0.3355637193,
-1.0133444071,
0.4544211626,
-0.1257937998,
-0.4460141659,
0.4703791738,
0.3394822776,
-0.0987618491,
-0.1651447415,
-0.3288101554,
-0.4719101489,
0.2332224846,
0.0783382729,
0.1594784558,
-0.4692533314,
0.0275351591,
-0.1442309469,
-0.7820039988,
-0.1481832266,
-0.8066456318,
0.4707789719,
-0.0183394663,
-0.0641313493,
-0.3093304336,
0.0573660806,
0.3826751113,
-0.1725354791,
0.5559979081,
0.6235285401,
-0.4993001223,
0.1746156365,
-0.8521318436,
-0.2263323367,
-0.4752187431,
-0.0076077217,
-0.0269038249,
-0.5661735535,
0.210518837,
-0.0479396917,
0.0230850242,
0.3603150845,
0.1199903414,
0.1499696672,
0.8653382659,
0.7532697916,
0.0205590781,
0.6577736735,
-0.0970069617,
0.489785701,
-1.0533758402,
0.0520766191,
-0.6892843246,
-0.8269019127,
-1.0048846006,
-0.2824149132,
-0.0432622992,
0.19201307,
-0.1063265055,
0.364318043,
-0.1739604175,
0.2116778046,
0.6397343278,
-0.0715581849,
0.0321757607,
0.0668709576,
0.1643422395,
-0.0808431879,
-0.8127295375,
-0.383405745,
0.7650533319,
0.3420458734,
0.5450669527,
-0.1270212084,
0.6912211776,
-0.1411664337,
0.2569229901,
-0.807649672,
0.6048828363,
-0.6750745177,
-0.2987191379,
-0.041199185,
-0.354529649,
-0.9912598729,
0.2460140437,
-0.3050707281,
-0.736123085,
0.8306452036,
0.2715014517,
-0.4565131962,
0.3661316335,
-0.7498993278,
0.5219481587,
0.0312460624,
-0.2941292524,
0.1129803285,
-0.5322586298,
0.2734860778,
-0.1211853176,
0.3379904926,
-0.2792362869,
-0.1893063486,
0.5977777839,
-0.2402986437,
0.6872422099,
-0.249435842,
-0.0209300406,
-0.074803181,
0.247499913,
0.1065907255,
-0.2637864053,
-0.212366268,
0.1238621324,
-0.2751517296,
-0.5856843591,
-1.0749710798,
1.0478049517,
-0.3885592818,
-0.4237459302,
-0.214459911,
-0.5191377401,
-0.1817987859,
0.3492380977,
-0.0965512618,
0.9720469117,
0.2398500741,
0.1514427066,
0.5342957973,
-0.0467386618,
0.7682878375,
0.2989310026,
-0.4427469969,
-0.0949553326,
1.1694886684,
0.5725596547,
0.4805004597,
0.2214723676,
0.3685631752,
-0.0101686921,
-0.6843095422,
-0.0862248242,
0.1000519916,
-0.5178674459,
-0.0200904142,
-0.6997862458,
-0.3089210093,
-0.3408555388,
-0.1230921894,
-0.2002616376,
-0.9103540778,
-0.0187427849,
0.1747249812,
0.4418908954,
0.5713464022,
-0.2521300018,
0.4921807051,
-0.6089656949,
0.2423135042,
0.2502939701,
0.5603388548,
0.1361171603,
-0.4965011775,
-0.2375773489,
0.0804707929,
0.0666519701,
-0.5053744316,
0.3476992249,
0.6636760235,
0.4858979583,
0.56807971,
-0.4753383696,
0.6737906337,
-0.6297619343,
0.5210921764,
-0.1725699455,
-0.5212273598,
-0.156440407,
-0.3862252235,
0.4034227729,
0.4048113227,
0.2517188787,
-0.9112339616,
-0.2840398848,
-0.6333132386,
-1.1958427429,
0.304012686,
0.152750507,
0.1834657937,
-0.0897303596,
0.5807857513,
-0.035029795,
0.2831063271,
-0.3608016372,
-0.5888701081,
-0.2785636187,
0.275492996,
-0.5431027412,
-0.2997067273,
0.2589536607,
-0.2181227952,
0.746280551,
-0.1020501778,
0.2764149904,
0.0019394885,
0.2498701662,
0.1273311377,
0.3775304854,
0.7078579664,
0.3504579067,
-0.2855606377,
0.2906519175,
-0.3349219859,
-0.3425148726,
0.0206478126,
0.3269917965,
-0.7716203332,
-0.0854748711,
0.0135025345,
0.8696451783,
0.5670408607,
0.0396711379,
0.0040260619,
-0.1235954762,
-0.2979223728,
-0.0433073491,
0.0607596934,
0.1163205057,
-0.1818597615,
0.136184752,
0.7640984654,
0.3361017108,
-0.4627119899,
0.3807134032,
0.2220999897,
-0.8215714693,
-0.1237806901,
0.5777143836,
-0.2896440327,
-0.5534619093,
0.4319047034,
-0.1413464397,
-0.3996950984,
0.5097120404,
0.5585619211,
0.9561725855,
0.0651110411,
0.0862154216,
0.331669867,
0.4594194591,
-0.3496278226,
0.0118742092,
0.0882108584,
-0.6081852317,
-0.5949012041,
-0.5497379303,
0.2634546459,
-0.1571652442,
-0.7360239625,
-0.3164092004,
-0.6480791569,
-0.6552513838,
0.240975529,
-0.3260628879,
-0.5233370662,
0.2452744842,
0.4537434578,
1.16639781,
-0.6785430312,
0.9069586396,
0.484420836,
-0.2221446633,
-0.3780905902,
0.123000741,
0.0349335447,
-0.740994215,
0.7237154245,
0.2856636941,
-0.0269440152,
0.2120559663,
-0.2282517254,
-1.0021998882,
0.4045880139,
0.2616182566,
-0.3414959013,
-0.1193318516,
-0.144342795,
0.9133710861,
-0.1423183084,
0.2829625905,
1.0603538752,
0.7159468532,
-0.0353125073,
-0.7273332477,
-0.1032976434,
-0.5498844981,
0.2352622598,
0.6512422562,
-0.3400169015,
0.9517403841,
0.2694226503,
0.0584329143,
0.1137775034,
0.5809727311,
-0.262326479,
0.0185813475,
0.2992494702,
0.5650625825,
0.4304367304,
-0.5041078329,
1.2359000444,
-0.2986396253,
-0.1361495554,
0.9845178723,
0.1623973548,
0.7551911473,
0.6056983471,
0.0964366198,
0.3555183709,
0.5028167963,
0.0631006584,
0.4109732509,
0.6153185368,
0.0268761627,
-0.2895750701,
-0.1820259839,
-0.289560169,
0.3044823408,
0.5304985642,
-0.0819309652,
-0.6204847097,
-0.1833087057,
0.1030789316,
0.4007788002,
-0.52645576,
0.6980497241,
0.2544567287,
-0.5672417283,
0.7331449389,
0.1486502439,
0.9476136565,
-0.5495945215,
-0.1058226377,
-0.2683481872,
0.1113133058,
-0.1049842834,
-0.2217434943,
0.1652398556,
-0.3723428249,
-0.0134973051,
-0.3246259391,
0.8244299889,
-0.6223251224,
-0.6533636451,
0.4479577243,
0.2866668701,
0.2508308887,
-0.079398483,
-0.5401627421,
-0.088739939,
-0.457079947,
-0.0647234991,
0.4591592252,
0.3793318272,
0.0465798266,
0.7202107906,
0.5609943271,
0.3761419058,
0.6110680103,
0.1293670237,
0.8247355223,
-0.3137387633,
-0.2932115495,
-0.7847713232,
0.2047223002,
-0.0066740015,
-0.3520492017,
0.9102615714,
0.2578928769,
0.6419702172,
0.3488919735,
0.4362866282,
0.1749237776,
0.0827367231,
-0.6579249501,
0.8080871701,
-0.6859115362,
-0.1738310009,
-0.2338287979,
-0.8652561307,
-0.649707377,
0.4315884113,
-0.5048558116,
0.5654243827,
0.4477017522,
0.9071417451,
0.1162991971,
-0.0088678906,
0.4963801503,
0.0598282516,
0.2798877358,
0.2239978015,
0.4898428917,
-0.8522710204,
0.1400205791,
-0.1778225899,
-0.0775785968,
-0.203104049,
-1.1620730162,
-0.5376921296,
-0.3748164177,
-0.3047620058,
-0.2441892624,
0.1933733076,
0.7257663012,
0.7483128905,
-0.7550446987,
-0.1531299949,
-0.2591722608,
-0.1254474521,
-0.5830449462,
-0.1327340603,
0.1362201422,
-0.5775633454,
-0.710919857,
0.7559939027,
0.3007529378,
0.3350975513,
-0.2006765306,
0.1598005295,
-0.3967399299,
0.2100240439,
0.177611649,
0.5641806722,
-0.6126722097,
-0.0195313208,
-0.0283581689,
-0.0444026478,
0.3679376543,
0.9359520078,
-0.8478732109,
0.7304261923,
0.477701813,
0.8917717934,
0.368521452,
-0.0882205218,
0.9463456273,
-0.6313588619,
0.3747989833,
-0.0559774414,
0.4710880816,
0.5151612163,
-0.1159690544,
0.2387175262,
-0.0160440858,
-0.6709423065,
-0.4931991398,
0.1497326195,
-0.5441963077,
-0.1215093061,
0.8545745611,
-0.0886959061,
-0.4364728034,
-0.245039776,
-0.1353570819,
0.2998696268,
-0.5186591148,
0.7562046647,
0.6128097177,
0.3211781383,
-0.0372201204,
-0.964746654,
0.7879318595,
0.4161982834,
-0.3451299667,
-0.0698874071,
0.3112772703,
-0.0838482454,
0.3847656548,
0.6567125916,
-0.0911611989,
-0.0005665804,
0.0679457635,
-0.0132771023,
-0.3393581212,
-0.554561913,
-0.5903843641,
0.0181081779,
0.1684519351,
-0.1574903727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17220v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17220v1
|
Making Sentence Embeddings Robust to User-Generated Content
| 2024-03-25T21:48:36 | 2024-03-25T21:48:36 |
Lydia Nishimwe, Benoît Sagot, Rachel Bawden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
NLP models have been known to perform poorly on user-generated content (UGC),
mainly because it presents a lot of lexical variations and deviates from the
standard texts on which most of these models were trained. In this work, we
focus on the robustness of LASER, a sentence embedding model, to UGC data. We
evaluate this robustness by LASER's ability to represent non-standard sentences
and their standard counterparts close to each other in the embedding space.
Inspired by previous works extending LASER to other languages and modalities,
we propose RoLASER, a robust English encoder trained using a teacher-student
approach to reduce the distances between the representations of standard and
UGC sentences. We show that with training only on standard and synthetic
UGC-like data, RoLASER significantly improves LASER's robustness to both
natural and artificial UGC data by achieving up to 2x and 11x better scores. We
also perform a fine-grained analysis on artificial UGC data and find that our
model greatly outperforms LASER on its most challenging UGC phenomena such as
keyboard typos and social media abbreviations. Evaluation on downstream tasks
shows that RoLASER performs comparably to or better than LASER on standard
data, while consistently outperforming it on UGC data.
|
[
-0.1585889906,
-0.8591715693,
0.2814749479,
-0.1449058354,
-0.2997950315,
0.0804655701,
-0.2208650112,
-0.4216405451,
0.0255828518,
0.4289310575,
-0.1815180182,
-0.6346123815,
-0.5352188945,
0.3466991484,
-0.4726772606,
0.8988348842,
0.190826565,
0.275477916,
-0.2936235964,
-0.0989085212,
-0.4634685516,
-0.4912866056,
-0.3226114213,
-0.233026728,
0.206289053,
0.1018106565,
1.1143580675,
0.791258812,
0.6864383221,
0.1571521908,
-0.1344007999,
0.4515222013,
-0.4666784406,
0.3414741457,
-0.1340151429,
-0.2992730737,
0.0815621987,
-0.4300569892,
0.5942714214,
0.5875115991,
-0.3544975519,
-0.3554536104,
0.4244171977,
0.3698940277,
-0.5510460734,
-0.2019862235,
-0.7378760576,
0.3883869946,
-0.1119450927,
0.0151017765,
-0.7734865546,
-0.2753725052,
0.0075005083,
-0.5607274175,
0.4323506057,
-0.0373035632,
1.1946810484,
0.4349004626,
-0.31194368,
-0.5124857426,
-0.737528801,
0.6126679182,
-0.7430541515,
0.7984612584,
0.1992496997,
0.1606711447,
-0.2946184576,
-0.8171957731,
-0.3431316018,
-0.2504202425,
-0.169635728,
0.2732970119,
-0.1632362902,
0.0378460251,
0.0904604644,
0.1430500448,
-0.7235460877,
0.113477841,
-0.0600592531,
-0.2294955254,
0.4552455544,
0.2880626023,
0.4988970459,
-0.4848471284,
-0.4738394022,
-0.304097265,
-0.8661339283,
0.1193024665,
0.5427170992,
0.4192516804,
0.325622946,
0.8262596726,
0.0277241822,
0.8497293591,
-0.0743075907,
-0.0729442388,
-0.1735578328,
-0.4314540923,
-0.0194766577,
-0.0126605444,
0.9781720638,
0.4301460385,
0.3262653351,
-0.2641459405,
-0.2465397269,
0.1033947617,
0.4688351452,
-0.8431988955,
-0.5077292919,
-0.0934133753,
-0.3632498384,
-0.0652772859,
0.4068733156,
-0.7990813255,
-0.3200124204,
0.2671464384,
0.1410480887,
-0.5136419535,
0.3873832822,
0.1417904496,
-0.0117754769,
-0.1387041211,
0.0543124564,
-1.0779769421,
0.109088935,
0.47507599,
0.787379384,
-0.0432522818,
-0.2218161374,
-0.4177533686,
0.1665525585,
-0.3826386631,
0.810424149,
-0.594822526,
-0.5714286566,
0.3463341892,
-0.1978222579,
-0.0596889742,
-0.6487854123,
0.8580914736,
-0.4450692534,
0.453807056,
-0.0095938453,
-0.9840684533,
0.2021440864,
-0.1212748662,
-0.5869103074,
1.0011752844,
-0.0437906049,
-0.7823708653,
0.6477515101,
-0.4087509215,
-0.5323389769,
0.1087610498,
-0.3122142851,
-0.6763525605,
0.2157559544,
0.3812909424,
0.4315757453,
0.1962814778,
0.2802319229,
-0.326901108,
-0.450142175,
0.3642159402,
-0.4679571688,
0.7719427943,
0.2807570696,
-0.0879247189,
-0.0979522392,
-0.6253538728,
0.0832597464,
0.0127776498,
-0.5571603179,
-0.2048537284,
0.2942381799,
0.2660212517,
-0.1391332895,
0.0958839357,
-0.6857679486,
0.2368838191,
-0.6377453804,
0.6306810975,
0.5580511689,
0.0154955555,
0.4955061376,
-0.0114801824,
0.4583578706,
-0.2849587798,
-0.0976554006,
-0.104387857,
-0.671895802,
-0.4955706894,
-0.1315796524,
0.3750496805,
0.7486101985,
-0.8197686076,
0.724825561,
-0.1973401308,
-0.3339155018,
-0.6732882261,
0.5109046698,
0.3987276852,
0.5822506547,
0.3230808675,
-0.3893396258,
-0.5996795297,
-0.8014569283,
-0.3526337147,
-0.1278201491,
-0.4542222321,
0.2488291264,
0.3004323244,
-0.185753271,
1.1080236435,
-0.5161721706,
-0.4324547946,
-0.3046824932,
0.1733727306,
-0.0432626233,
0.5077866912,
0.0771143213,
-0.6717991829,
-0.7131136656,
-0.239566505,
-1.034822464,
-0.0098713506,
-0.6077566147,
0.1370838881,
0.2795934677,
0.3993798196,
-0.5783020258,
0.5980788469,
0.4073055387,
-0.6147936583,
0.1130959541,
-0.4089044333,
-0.0248180777,
-1.2390811443,
-0.291100502,
0.0121474294,
-0.3795450032,
-0.5644215345,
0.1522841454,
-0.061570514,
-0.2838421166,
-0.5517619252,
0.1078119278,
-0.2463312149,
-0.1617173404,
-0.1558383405,
0.3447371721,
0.2276404053,
0.1080578864,
0.2243198305,
1.0259954929,
0.3095523715,
-0.174188301,
0.3570573032,
0.5623247623,
-0.5940821171,
0.3659155667,
-1.0530846119,
0.2627203763,
0.0788714141,
0.1846106201,
-0.7917686701,
-0.2311864197,
-0.0750751644,
-0.6932016611,
0.0780910701,
0.1984347254,
-0.9185118675,
-0.0603482425,
-0.1257726997,
-0.1370199174,
0.62170434,
-0.6291477084,
0.4854868054,
0.2052481472,
0.1849850565,
-0.2716939449,
-0.9046218991,
0.3304521739,
-0.1220465824,
-0.9085859656,
0.4436145425,
0.2006259263,
-0.108574979,
0.3482275903,
0.1508528739,
-0.2902643383,
0.1991849542,
0.2418286502,
0.1967569292,
-0.0909572244,
0.1126532108,
-0.1083525866,
-0.0723076835,
-0.2408583313,
-0.0477439649,
0.3752625883,
0.0129021164,
-0.4607152343,
-0.6708725691,
0.4979610741,
0.0765532032,
-0.0222787466,
1.0492683649,
0.839343667,
-0.3456389606,
-0.5475536585,
0.0882437602,
-0.609598875,
-0.477157712,
0.4018244147,
-0.1028523296,
-1.0872727633,
0.4309646487,
0.352288574,
0.0914530978,
0.0826918185,
0.3797599971,
-0.4009064436,
1.2656360865,
0.7137919664,
0.2233253568,
0.3907122314,
0.1040301174,
0.5102824569,
-0.6417028308,
-0.2433806211,
-0.4998048246,
-0.081591256,
-0.4754401743,
-0.0374017581,
0.146426186,
0.3862846494,
0.1857602298,
0.6778928041,
-0.6503263712,
0.5772625208,
0.6253083348,
0.0800383613,
0.1414148808,
-0.0019697377,
0.0026172174,
-0.5819392204,
-0.871303618,
-0.8080140352,
0.9132152796,
0.3155201674,
0.9808383584,
0.2969594002,
0.6654850841,
0.49953264,
-0.2392885387,
-0.5360662937,
0.3921609521,
-0.6051852107,
-0.626961112,
-0.1202829778,
-0.5295767784,
-0.8946412802,
0.1038361862,
-0.5224143863,
-0.6048704386,
-0.1000844389,
0.1093225256,
-0.5287277102,
0.3622242808,
-0.7202538848,
0.7728735209,
0.0272100866,
-0.3907241225,
0.2746731937,
-0.5050958395,
-0.1289259642,
0.1670464128,
-0.0199554171,
0.2326310724,
-0.0388735346,
0.7070721388,
-0.4246163964,
0.8503026366,
-0.1407451332,
0.0056368015,
0.4504550397,
0.000626369,
0.5429888368,
0.2905043364,
0.140089795,
-0.0550918244,
-0.4314965904,
-0.318420738,
-0.8186193109,
0.565181613,
-0.6367575526,
-0.5008244514,
-0.153482914,
-0.5437356234,
-0.253460288,
-0.0195945892,
0.6791744828,
0.6288731098,
-0.1252906322,
0.6941536069,
0.8129626513,
-0.2270352542,
0.5334307551,
0.0056055528,
-0.0925820023,
-0.528011322,
0.7828264832,
0.0333945118,
0.2698945701,
0.3330860138,
0.048357822,
-0.5005714893,
-0.5441089869,
-0.8736510277,
-0.203210637,
-0.7819721699,
-0.2230383009,
-0.4704570174,
-0.2383549809,
-0.4688516855,
-0.721036315,
-0.399385184,
-0.2199187279,
-0.7071654201,
-0.2389695197,
0.0480581224,
0.8258031607,
0.0758252144,
0.3362938464,
-0.8688558936,
0.0215789285,
0.2511361539,
0.0832308903,
-0.4318321347,
-0.6281225085,
-0.2795060575,
-0.0634991899,
-0.1858468801,
-0.8722677231,
0.5828259587,
0.6854979992,
0.5442156792,
0.5746873021,
0.0996241421,
0.4455451071,
-0.5217617154,
1.1471269131,
0.0553555302,
-0.910902977,
0.5578674078,
-0.3531251848,
0.320861429,
0.759727478,
0.2633740008,
-0.1583185494,
-0.6535993218,
-0.3399989605,
-0.6871325374,
0.2419222593,
0.2807579339,
0.5569939017,
-0.0235924423,
0.3871890008,
-0.0876705498,
-0.1417685896,
-0.9778715372,
-0.0524467602,
-0.5300539732,
-0.5443816185,
0.0268326178,
-0.2199907303,
0.1423700303,
0.1708387434,
0.3744092286,
0.0160212331,
0.1804421097,
0.3927140534,
-0.2610728443,
0.1533255279,
0.2114886045,
0.4933609366,
0.2835845947,
-0.3550862074,
0.4067668915,
0.2070624381,
-0.5585204363,
0.0263316464,
-0.1437377334,
-0.6105888486,
0.2434508353,
0.743047297,
0.5411894321,
0.2522335351,
-0.9537468553,
0.4312149286,
-0.1089434177,
-0.1434972286,
0.1054779664,
0.166810438,
0.0466516055,
0.0000385788,
0.1443691105,
0.1187996194,
0.1145483181,
-0.4045767188,
0.6198769808,
0.3306494653,
-0.7152110338,
-0.2512375712,
0.8877511024,
0.2660933137,
-0.4364573658,
0.6789454222,
-0.1619790345,
-0.6223111153,
0.2661930919,
0.9728963375,
0.6276424527,
-0.0529648103,
0.231781438,
0.2655602396,
0.4195924103,
0.1391679347,
-0.0279156845,
0.1497897655,
-0.8257905245,
-0.185875237,
-0.4939255714,
-0.3795281351,
-0.4517464936,
-0.8351255059,
0.0729979426,
-0.7045778036,
-0.1516702622,
-0.1929942071,
-0.0575466566,
-0.3361797333,
0.0294250175,
-0.0082572075,
0.7567212582,
-0.9488264918,
1.071988821,
0.6505562067,
-0.3633564115,
-0.6877630353,
-0.1339897662,
0.0396142155,
-0.6502092481,
0.504237175,
0.1282364279,
-0.1863423288,
-0.1822488457,
-0.1901741624,
-0.5057018399,
1.0615212917,
0.3983857036,
-0.509562254,
0.1167207584,
0.3536856472,
0.7110333443,
-0.4310774505,
-0.1207205206,
-0.2014953792,
0.0646949708,
0.0991540626,
-0.4757812619,
-0.0808430016,
-0.0390482172,
0.2538890839,
0.161247313,
-0.2048000693,
0.8833201528,
-0.0713011101,
-0.6019359827,
0.0439600386,
0.9655911326,
0.0176954884,
-0.016044125,
0.2624891102,
0.8745576143,
0.7383150458,
-0.1934709549,
1.0756584406,
-0.1414507031,
0.4178618789,
1.153365612,
-0.3873416781,
1.190705657,
0.3420739472,
-0.1077097803,
0.6755545139,
0.3380862176,
-0.4178019762,
0.8359581232,
0.000298315,
-0.2225594819,
-0.3609367907,
-0.2907344997,
-0.2363161147,
0.5743532777,
-0.0826255009,
-0.4391293824,
-0.2097167522,
0.1875298768,
0.1374060512,
0.7176846862,
0.0038528426,
0.8987563252,
-0.0284059625,
-0.4261571765,
0.4317420721,
0.0804867074,
0.9294474125,
-0.4584246576,
-0.0057974369,
-0.2586350739,
0.3523024917,
-0.257044971,
-0.8696579337,
0.6769518256,
0.321416527,
0.0288929213,
-0.3131982982,
0.8968091607,
-0.4361472428,
-0.5936539769,
0.1956574172,
0.2698053718,
-0.0408432037,
0.3343884945,
-0.5166602731,
0.1676217765,
0.3278459907,
-0.02937386,
0.2740817964,
0.140585497,
0.5155310035,
0.6032707691,
0.6164265871,
-0.0718283802,
0.1143367887,
-0.0348249227,
0.5129468441,
-0.5561692119,
-0.2701481581,
-1.0344861746,
0.4729623199,
-0.0240043402,
-0.5077061653,
1.2682899237,
0.5833702087,
0.8910893798,
0.0073257852,
0.4849136472,
0.1030171812,
0.3144976199,
-0.7975497842,
0.9394369125,
-0.4102748632,
0.2137525976,
-0.0521093644,
-0.9492582083,
-0.738066256,
0.9934545159,
0.2329335213,
-0.2248530835,
0.3716436327,
0.8723527789,
0.1477402151,
0.1231055334,
0.4512926638,
-0.2041340023,
0.4928660989,
0.6123351455,
0.888366282,
-0.2826495469,
0.6891523004,
-0.2668983638,
0.1036188751,
-0.2342010438,
-0.7701814175,
-1.0916785002,
-0.5637643933,
-0.1406354308,
-0.3872663677,
0.12605685,
0.7565074563,
0.8631065488,
-0.7800029516,
-0.0392956734,
-0.4256671965,
0.0150214909,
0.0297310632,
-0.2114113271,
0.3512858152,
-0.3233880103,
-0.6468414068,
0.6025223136,
0.0291401893,
0.1279909313,
-0.4179297388,
-0.1178270355,
-0.0651455298,
0.2121285945,
0.3423241079,
0.0297406204,
-0.7195323706,
-0.6476891637,
0.3644996583,
-0.3158502281,
0.051056236,
0.4326032698,
-0.6760471463,
0.5165035129,
0.348094523,
0.8719066978,
-0.0304396711,
0.0909047127,
0.5100501776,
-0.8748916984,
-0.1152126193,
0.3073877394,
0.5357851386,
0.6551184654,
-0.4601041377,
0.4859130383,
0.1291347742,
-0.7409840822,
-0.8622275591,
0.3164356053,
-0.8335009217,
-0.398414284,
0.9995757341,
-0.535161674,
-0.0576095581,
-0.0444041938,
-0.0631851107,
0.0179698784,
-0.5809271932,
0.863124311,
0.7978369594,
-0.1671699286,
-0.1874328852,
-0.3154951632,
0.5153313279,
0.5816712379,
-0.745293498,
0.0135887638,
0.5268075466,
0.1329490542,
0.3331317902,
0.0592565611,
0.0811349824,
0.1170937195,
0.5139246583,
-0.1659816653,
-0.3468848467,
-0.4966490567,
-0.3735212386,
0.5415348411,
0.0269420985,
-0.1088092774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17216v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17216v1
|
Ontology Completion with Natural Language Inference and Concept Embeddings: An Analysis
| 2024-03-25T21:46:35 | 2024-03-25T21:46:35 |
Na Li, Thomas Bailleux, Zied Bouraoui, Steven Schockaert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We consider the problem of finding plausible knowledge that is missing from a
given ontology, as a generalisation of the well-studied taxonomy expansion
task. One line of work treats this task as a Natural Language Inference (NLI)
problem, thus relying on the knowledge captured by language models to identify
the missing knowledge. Another line of work uses concept embeddings to identify
what different concepts have in common, taking inspiration from cognitive
models for category based induction. These two approaches are intuitively
complementary, but their effectiveness has not yet been compared. In this
paper, we introduce a benchmark for evaluating ontology completion methods and
thoroughly analyse the strengths and weaknesses of both approaches. We find
that both approaches are indeed complementary, with hybrid strategies achieving
the best overall results. We also find that the task is highly challenging for
Large Language Models, even after fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.5240966082,
-0.4580739141,
0.6976439953,
-0.2751149535,
0.0273676347,
0.4122953415,
-0.1666119099,
-0.5008108616,
0.2408036739,
0.5508750677,
-0.6784106493,
-0.4440938532,
-0.6826510429,
0.254521817,
-0.3280549049,
0.6078901291,
0.059240222,
-0.2571014762,
-0.5538172126,
-0.0844504014,
-0.5365110636,
-0.166344896,
-0.4104438722,
-0.6101703048,
0.1106493473,
0.255215317,
0.6417316198,
0.7186943293,
0.5992456675,
0.175183028,
-0.2428233474,
0.4365537465,
-0.1779229939,
-0.1775672585,
-0.3740709126,
-0.4688463807,
-0.2145415395,
0.1100522578,
0.5025351644,
1.3265348673,
-0.4010209739,
0.0154473623,
0.0881779343,
0.4039235115,
-0.958294034,
-0.0024462333,
-0.5321822166,
0.4191962183,
0.0420762114,
-0.1552383006,
-0.1373246312,
-0.3114183545,
0.7927649021,
-0.8575083613,
0.1372159421,
0.1680978537,
0.6619717479,
0.3594076037,
-0.5080435276,
-0.7011210322,
-0.7079378963,
1.2141979933,
-0.6416471601,
0.3692145348,
0.5651410222,
0.0005792074,
-0.0867738202,
-0.6174253821,
-0.6564530134,
-0.1740018576,
-0.3253448009,
0.3160669506,
-0.0219441745,
0.2792071104,
0.33342731,
0.5630499125,
-0.404617995,
0.1633327156,
-0.0993423238,
-0.0954013988,
0.2957717776,
0.0360955931,
0.4918918014,
-0.5954329967,
-0.316254735,
0.0084809652,
-0.544329226,
-0.3382596076,
0.2378413677,
0.2566039264,
0.0525872633,
0.6932113767,
-0.2544032633,
0.9964964986,
-0.3664221764,
-0.1171477884,
0.3936988115,
-0.8405812383,
-0.0540371127,
-0.0619262084,
0.5158712864,
0.2412277907,
0.2146603465,
-0.8779219985,
-0.0127754929,
0.2586055994,
0.4547904134,
0.1530253291,
0.225309208,
0.5917194486,
-0.1414609253,
0.0712507889,
0.1300971955,
-0.3299057186,
-0.1603241414,
-0.3873486221,
0.4061997235,
-0.6544995904,
-0.4106948972,
0.1444185674,
-0.7353024483,
0.6466824412,
0.2554609179,
-0.91745013,
0.413218379,
1.2469332218,
0.8236193061,
-0.1182812527,
-0.0058620977,
-0.1536056101,
0.3827694058,
-0.4114575982,
0.8412312865,
-0.6520882845,
-0.3046168089,
0.0273561087,
-0.3103018105,
-0.1137419716,
-0.5128744841,
0.6347830296,
-0.4401383996,
0.2969858944,
-0.568166256,
-1.1214287281,
-0.2733064294,
0.502730608,
-0.5257716775,
1.0069510937,
0.0812929198,
-0.8809765577,
0.5804886222,
-0.6290575862,
-0.1942754537,
0.1773581654,
-0.1149306595,
0.1069522724,
0.0409018099,
-0.3933911622,
0.4502064288,
-0.7812122107,
0.2683905065,
-0.3576222956,
-0.263460964,
0.0359339155,
0.3655758798,
0.551027298,
0.0582693629,
-0.1840064526,
-0.4244491756,
-0.9210726619,
0.1393436342,
-0.0009239363,
0.0181133989,
-0.8210670352,
0.0980145335,
-0.2156424224,
-0.02536311,
0.2030829787,
-0.866235137,
0.2139774114,
-0.6774405241,
0.3956780434,
0.2057224661,
-0.0010084723,
0.7215495706,
-0.3707179725,
0.3187059462,
-0.2919308841,
-0.123780936,
0.0472231358,
-0.7572031021,
-0.7248968482,
-0.1277688295,
0.7139551044,
0.6548781991,
-0.7047050595,
0.9021084905,
-0.4058393836,
-0.5224354267,
-0.5245854259,
0.1848880053,
0.5826735497,
0.2621916234,
0.2663957775,
-0.6209290028,
-0.8012429476,
-0.6921899319,
-0.1932828426,
-0.0456924438,
-0.2525730729,
0.1456320882,
0.5528339744,
-0.3061210215,
1.2576429844,
-0.5056626797,
-0.4557707012,
-0.1961705536,
0.0975987315,
0.0875557214,
0.4493243098,
0.333892107,
-0.8832061291,
-0.1310233325,
0.1754176021,
-1.2171740532,
0.2722436488,
0.1408984512,
-0.0555243269,
-0.0705631897,
0.2155757695,
-0.4870899916,
0.5057344437,
0.3548299372,
-0.009225538,
0.103994377,
-0.237013191,
-0.0847298428,
-1.0683344603,
0.0709202811,
-0.0450354032,
-0.0355902202,
-0.9745067358,
0.2477266043,
-0.0654982552,
0.4094188511,
-0.0944480672,
0.3718497753,
-0.5536433458,
-0.1083411947,
-0.2042957693,
0.6409999132,
-0.0300580356,
0.1413996816,
0.2118923217,
0.0697265863,
0.5081515312,
-0.5686155558,
0.2729860544,
0.4793038964,
-0.2461952716,
0.2083425373,
-0.5335006118,
0.056206964,
-0.1757446378,
0.1285627335,
-1.1812338829,
-0.2226799428,
0.3260722458,
-0.2260233462,
0.1198264584,
-0.1059062928,
-0.5528594851,
-0.4789570272,
-0.3117189109,
0.1839945465,
0.6020537615,
-0.4623836875,
0.8060373664,
0.2970358133,
0.2055364996,
-0.7306637168,
-0.7335981727,
0.1522236913,
0.0125918081,
-0.305801481,
0.5704423189,
0.3474288285,
-0.2361287922,
0.3842097521,
-0.0437569991,
0.0847654194,
0.2131672353,
0.2707691491,
0.1114604026,
-0.2088705599,
0.2029654086,
-0.0186459012,
-0.2071662843,
0.0741113424,
-0.3958427012,
0.4451828301,
0.18019104,
-0.6052207947,
-0.3361440003,
0.4567629993,
0.2024371326,
-0.099328272,
0.7762346864,
0.2986418903,
-0.5372787118,
-0.0816461816,
-0.790941,
-0.1225723326,
-0.3797530234,
0.0660077631,
-0.3049471676,
-0.6498718858,
0.3860329688,
-0.0479426943,
0.155993849,
0.5183815956,
0.1072969362,
0.0874199048,
0.4547922313,
0.7347227931,
0.3410975933,
0.1644708812,
-0.6757028103,
0.2848488092,
-0.9412018061,
-0.3850656748,
-0.5865302682,
0.0581723154,
-0.8108680844,
-0.2630123794,
-0.0932711661,
-0.0291661024,
0.2996127009,
0.4560934007,
-0.3051370084,
0.1551591605,
0.8451374173,
0.0190569628,
0.7328696847,
-0.0294701792,
-0.1686021835,
0.1198256314,
-0.9360833764,
-0.5742524862,
1.3756582737,
-0.0967480764,
0.2540189624,
0.283213079,
0.8332590461,
0.1380548626,
0.2483153343,
-0.8791620731,
0.3100879788,
-0.2574124634,
-0.5887345076,
-0.2484072745,
-0.36561957,
-0.9412076473,
0.1611243188,
-0.5829365849,
-0.7919469476,
0.1062711328,
-0.0519104749,
-0.5502045751,
0.3009143472,
-0.7537173033,
0.6157387495,
0.3160674274,
-0.0031969189,
-0.3498697281,
-0.6594303846,
0.5004078746,
-0.3782626987,
0.2415369004,
-0.1480659992,
-0.2653646171,
0.896620214,
-0.4800443649,
0.8081957698,
0.1120967492,
-0.2191487402,
0.4294754267,
-0.5700780153,
0.0680502728,
-0.1974422932,
-0.1733939648,
0.0923324972,
0.2026120722,
-0.4878863692,
-0.9867196083,
0.4113663733,
-0.6280664802,
-0.6972308159,
-0.3449344635,
-0.2417844087,
-0.4360125363,
-0.0397385918,
0.2908813357,
0.517939806,
-0.1974990368,
-0.0761979595,
0.6251249313,
-0.0895882025,
0.394937396,
0.3220137954,
-0.0671528131,
-0.0988760218,
0.7895773649,
0.4360219836,
0.4401552677,
0.4545668364,
0.0222437475,
-0.3939974308,
-0.2942649126,
-0.2269463837,
0.2492530346,
-0.654370904,
0.0467603318,
-1.0640076399,
-0.4341511428,
-0.416149646,
0.0283451155,
-0.4165093601,
-0.5055211186,
-0.066744782,
0.1044912487,
0.4482577741,
0.8930100203,
-0.073876977,
0.1921499372,
-0.8593430519,
0.3726816177,
0.3938264847,
0.3790251911,
0.5164477825,
-0.3532695174,
0.028698612,
0.1828861982,
-0.2617779374,
-0.5939757228,
-0.1970199794,
0.2828958631,
0.6718953848,
0.5883064866,
0.1240913793,
0.6216473579,
-0.3758049905,
0.5446636081,
0.3287171423,
-0.8243852258,
0.6506012082,
0.0133603383,
0.1488122195,
0.3771817684,
0.794952333,
-0.5596596599,
-0.4885148406,
-0.8680824041,
-0.7202975154,
0.4424509704,
0.3175296783,
0.0047741751,
-0.1658154875,
0.4855368137,
0.2107226253,
0.124221012,
-0.11868947,
-0.3852485716,
0.1734932959,
-0.1234043315,
-0.1570543945,
-0.181650117,
-0.0225135554,
-0.1609974951,
0.4123597741,
-0.0852400437,
0.211493656,
0.1801373214,
-0.1118052974,
0.1892748624,
0.286547333,
0.0217023399,
0.6921238303,
-0.3591816127,
-0.0835662186,
0.2527051568,
-0.2835352719,
0.0684401244,
-0.1911909431,
-0.1717746705,
-0.0450265631,
0.7896929383,
0.5007071495,
0.2116742283,
-0.820422411,
0.4420350194,
0.1081842706,
-0.2530721426,
-0.3538894653,
0.2142580599,
0.028551273,
-0.0653355047,
0.6183596253,
0.0909295827,
0.3516218066,
-0.8506476879,
0.1731068939,
0.6162343621,
-0.5030565262,
-0.2305237949,
0.2342901528,
-0.1212651357,
-0.0962336808,
0.4891836941,
-0.4554611742,
-0.6208794713,
0.5861007571,
0.3437743485,
0.6473572254,
0.215612933,
0.1917522848,
0.2619738877,
0.3213513792,
-0.2207181305,
0.4851078093,
-0.078612335,
-1.1240776777,
-0.8050761819,
-0.655760169,
-0.6946737766,
-0.4195034802,
-0.8846549392,
-0.0385823101,
-0.3699978888,
-0.2726045847,
0.2112043053,
0.0657505319,
-0.6932377815,
0.2649460435,
0.0448047817,
0.9395938516,
-1.0420401096,
0.6199279428,
0.846662581,
-0.3736695945,
-0.637691617,
0.0450438038,
-0.0089043006,
-0.5735154748,
0.4642548561,
-0.0128085874,
-0.0055438546,
0.1294606328,
-0.0345387571,
-1.1171101332,
0.949913919,
-0.1434534639,
-0.2136806697,
-0.0730313063,
0.1652875394,
0.6055770516,
-0.4581778347,
0.2347913682,
0.872918427,
0.5340074301,
0.3777419925,
-0.8793957829,
0.2142160833,
0.0404461138,
0.2672767043,
0.176967442,
-0.216117382,
0.3724863827,
-0.2665400803,
-0.2584631443,
0.3600319624,
0.6625828743,
-0.0261324197,
0.2474276274,
0.6072440743,
0.9131065011,
0.8915275335,
-0.172640115,
1.1125435829,
-0.1213863343,
0.4618973136,
0.9327709079,
-0.3978167176,
1.0370240211,
0.4450953305,
-0.3559092879,
0.5431538224,
0.6268742085,
-0.0257651173,
0.6645433307,
0.0328558758,
-0.0223938227,
-0.3367276788,
-0.64057374,
-0.5327166915,
0.6608391404,
0.5499053597,
0.049437087,
-0.1745206863,
0.1486545354,
-0.4381629229,
0.0037049605,
-0.0838004202,
1.0638127327,
0.1689627022,
-0.8687288165,
0.4916689396,
-0.1284530014,
0.6890900135,
-0.4326815009,
0.0298011955,
-0.0799701065,
-0.1443482339,
-0.2177402675,
-0.6730576754,
0.6040588617,
-0.3075949252,
-0.2539631128,
0.0528067686,
0.5224784613,
-0.2607421577,
-0.2986927032,
0.6687479019,
0.8264557123,
-0.1821016967,
0.2297704369,
-0.2429888844,
-0.3469709456,
-0.1625652462,
0.0483426712,
0.0147582777,
0.408331126,
0.068366617,
0.8399563432,
0.4801489413,
-0.0567788519,
-0.0329189263,
-0.1036472842,
0.5500094295,
-0.7277168036,
-0.1284811944,
-0.8017711639,
0.1266963333,
-0.2384698093,
-0.266063273,
0.833569169,
0.4268601835,
0.8012062311,
0.0203622654,
0.9080706239,
-0.3156883121,
0.6697206497,
-0.5824055672,
0.3770024478,
-0.8382865787,
0.2758277655,
-0.5659759045,
-0.8944285512,
-0.4445999265,
0.2858391702,
-0.2834979892,
-0.0798328891,
0.918376863,
0.5505031943,
-0.1473257393,
0.3864713013,
0.1872322559,
-0.1280279756,
-0.4013932049,
0.4220709205,
1.1357750893,
-0.5129486918,
0.1527037472,
-0.1535180062,
-0.3523392677,
0.0234851148,
-0.7087671757,
-0.7833775282,
-0.5206410289,
-0.5357904434,
-0.3485450447,
-0.0224092826,
0.9846307635,
0.5081409812,
-0.9134107232,
-0.0497566201,
-0.0995812267,
0.3946146071,
-0.218973726,
-0.1140554771,
0.2109275758,
-0.456522882,
-0.6078158021,
0.0735021755,
0.3383899033,
-0.1439852864,
-0.2002681643,
0.0918527097,
-0.59831357,
0.0615772568,
0.4405721426,
0.2343308777,
-1.1147141457,
-0.2781843543,
-0.0872841999,
0.0410883278,
-0.0599104837,
0.612205565,
-0.7820027471,
0.3673607111,
0.3330234289,
0.846830368,
0.2010231614,
-0.1778570563,
0.7348678708,
-0.6599702835,
0.0263609719,
-0.1430246681,
0.3809982836,
0.2977485955,
0.0809485018,
0.8835551739,
0.3754166961,
0.190395534,
-0.8002358675,
0.1456926912,
-0.8786090612,
-0.2102174908,
0.976238966,
-0.1447900534,
-0.269928962,
-0.4050787389,
0.2252893448,
0.2948208749,
0.1584133655,
0.5772414207,
0.7595020533,
0.1542427242,
0.2545118332,
-0.5173191428,
0.4087384939,
0.5284772515,
-0.4504530132,
-0.3749575913,
-0.0751105025,
0.204989925,
0.7569725513,
0.3924674392,
0.2771095037,
0.2280045152,
-0.0085395258,
0.1902648807,
0.6137635112,
0.0285252184,
0.0208976474,
0.2615386248,
0.0193496961,
0.0116940867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17199v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17199v1
|
Extracting Social Support and Social Isolation Information from Clinical Psychiatry Notes: Comparing a Rule-based NLP System and a Large Language Model
| 2024-03-25T21:19:50 | 2024-03-25T21:19:50 |
Braja Gopal Patra, Lauren A. Lepow, Praneet Kasi Reddy Jagadeesh Kumar, Veer Vekaria, Mohit Manoj Sharma, Prakash Adekkanattu, Brian Fennessy, Gavin Hynes, Isotta Landi, Jorge A. Sanchez-Ruiz, Euijung Ryu, Joanna M. Biernacka, Girish N. Nadkarni, Ardesheer Talati, Myrna Weissman, Mark Olfson, J. John Mann, Alexander W. Charney, Jyotishman Pathak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Background: Social support (SS) and social isolation (SI) are social
determinants of health (SDOH) associated with psychiatric outcomes. In
electronic health records (EHRs), individual-level SS/SI is typically
documented as narrative clinical notes rather than structured coded data.
Natural language processing (NLP) algorithms can automate the otherwise
labor-intensive process of data extraction.
Data and Methods: Psychiatric encounter notes from Mount Sinai Health System
(MSHS, n=300) and Weill Cornell Medicine (WCM, n=225) were annotated and
established a gold standard corpus. A rule-based system (RBS) involving
lexicons and a large language model (LLM) using FLAN-T5-XL were developed to
identify mentions of SS and SI and their subcategories (e.g., social network,
instrumental support, and loneliness).
Results: For extracting SS/SI, the RBS obtained higher macro-averaged
f-scores than the LLM at both MSHS (0.89 vs. 0.65) and WCM (0.85 vs. 0.82). For
extracting subcategories, the RBS also outperformed the LLM at both MSHS (0.90
vs. 0.62) and WCM (0.82 vs. 0.81).
Discussion and Conclusion: Unexpectedly, the RBS outperformed the LLMs across
all metrics. Intensive review demonstrates that this finding is due to the
divergent approach taken by the RBS and LLM. The RBS were designed and refined
to follow the same specific rules as the gold standard annotations. Conversely,
the LLM were more inclusive with categorization and conformed to common
English-language understanding. Both approaches offer advantages and are made
available open-source for future testing.
|
[
-0.4106216729,
-0.7185572386,
0.7918847203,
0.447401166,
-0.2488301843,
0.022909794,
-0.2790074646,
-0.6884269714,
0.718252182,
0.4443362355,
-0.4852535427,
-0.966307044,
-0.8794122338,
0.2902219296,
-0.219971329,
1.3056496382,
-0.0172416214,
-0.0035978009,
0.0283061173,
-0.1172026321,
-0.0542397387,
-0.5878287554,
-0.6877166629,
-0.1813608259,
0.642070055,
0.2625944316,
0.569405973,
0.4073754251,
0.8657228947,
0.180960238,
-0.320394516,
0.233907342,
-0.2544434667,
-0.0091460506,
-0.2004384249,
0.0030905427,
-0.7523870468,
-0.2616113424,
0.2675247192,
0.6298517585,
-0.390532881,
0.3436586559,
0.2835167944,
0.670681715,
-0.5572777987,
0.36864236,
-0.1690970957,
0.0818607807,
-0.3927212656,
-0.0438569263,
-0.3401706517,
-0.4673687816,
0.2710780203,
-0.5341661572,
0.3081852198,
-0.0692580715,
0.7729369402,
-0.1523443758,
-0.1022909954,
-0.335049361,
-0.7178803086,
0.4848770201,
-0.7940231562,
0.0928399935,
0.5733438134,
0.1873224825,
-0.2293051034,
-0.418705821,
-0.2656087875,
-0.0809563994,
-0.3169071972,
0.0436867774,
-0.1415418535,
0.241468817,
0.4959727228,
0.4045191705,
-0.4979444146,
-0.0588826351,
-0.7877110243,
-0.0292351563,
0.9541312456,
0.2774449587,
0.3964858949,
-0.5630398393,
0.0330155194,
0.1717457026,
-0.3109116256,
0.1463800967,
-0.1025806442,
0.2706358135,
-0.3989781141,
0.7557603121,
-0.2050710917,
0.0427218564,
-0.224580124,
-0.2637621164,
0.3849384487,
-0.1790250391,
0.0963470116,
0.1839343607,
1.0845263004,
0.556065619,
0.3058293164,
-0.3066972494,
-0.2215458155,
0.3499554396,
0.0940327048,
-0.2586806715,
-0.2106145322,
0.0828751475,
-0.9297019243,
-0.0801786482,
0.1594165862,
-1.0486807823,
-0.5811698437,
-0.2892329991,
0.1912564188,
-0.4617000818,
-0.5069637895,
0.0539978668,
-0.3787307441,
0.2553264797,
0.4475993216,
-0.8983547091,
0.9165740013,
0.7596026659,
1.2968928814,
-0.5078133345,
0.0336550288,
-0.5819118619,
0.0841697976,
-0.0947341025,
0.6387799382,
-0.3193007708,
-0.4387646914,
0.0548897795,
0.3853685558,
-0.2370598465,
-0.5858153105,
0.5673938394,
-0.0258279573,
0.1803518832,
-0.4188493788,
-0.3853500485,
0.2071104497,
-0.156608507,
-0.6324243546,
0.9427163005,
0.3584848642,
-0.8023830652,
0.1455315053,
-0.6190639138,
-0.4423538446,
0.2376026362,
-0.3100320995,
-0.1896074861,
0.0840872526,
0.1356678903,
0.4718883932,
-0.2801660001,
0.2613795996,
-0.7360007763,
-0.4128035307,
0.0516353883,
-0.1131314337,
0.8076139688,
0.0587815903,
-0.5312386155,
-0.1833087504,
-0.955668211,
-0.3616596162,
0.2432849556,
-0.2622188628,
-0.7066677213,
0.2208819091,
0.106475234,
0.4071995318,
-0.0933558941,
-0.7105078697,
-0.2314798832,
-0.349858582,
0.1694205254,
0.6240407825,
0.2137278616,
0.138022393,
-0.3498774171,
0.6227745414,
-0.1007252038,
0.1774631739,
0.1701432317,
-0.5619140863,
-0.2431252897,
-0.3916814327,
0.0740952864,
0.7035746574,
-0.313791573,
0.5702013969,
-0.1073421165,
-0.2116160542,
-0.7381466627,
0.0790964887,
0.2550780177,
0.2575594187,
0.6180602908,
-0.5160624981,
-0.6948564649,
-0.7800140977,
-0.0396297723,
-0.0092858896,
-0.0547613576,
0.2563793957,
0.3588892519,
-0.305062294,
0.699965179,
-0.5571793914,
-0.4750442207,
-0.5310115814,
-0.0897050649,
0.1433868408,
0.2477073073,
0.2418443412,
-0.260738045,
-0.4562798738,
0.0949529707,
-0.8515673876,
-0.3517300189,
0.2689276338,
-0.0188136976,
0.2940182984,
0.4232035577,
-0.7273876667,
0.7551053762,
0.3269048929,
-0.3392382264,
0.5151557922,
-0.159430176,
-0.1763756722,
-1.0769116879,
0.0152192926,
0.5307348371,
-0.1095957905,
-0.5162491798,
-0.4265596569,
-0.1821136326,
-0.0058223545,
-0.0214083996,
0.239876464,
-0.3728785217,
0.0562095083,
0.0355854742,
0.4045377374,
-0.0130222598,
0.2538430989,
0.2379673272,
0.0992411673,
0.3620235026,
-0.3968849778,
0.1572921574,
0.1142824814,
-0.1973029226,
0.3938547969,
-0.7186216116,
-0.1503942311,
-0.313783884,
0.0914839208,
-1.0448803902,
-0.1889137477,
0.3748114705,
-0.2441621721,
-0.0105698705,
0.0906061679,
-0.3101054728,
-0.1188569441,
-0.4142584801,
-0.0842395574,
0.4510456026,
-0.0065361098,
0.3571212888,
0.6552630067,
-0.7400827408,
-0.2048126459,
-0.3957471251,
0.0089530786,
-0.3761631548,
-0.2234135717,
0.3547842205,
0.0695539117,
-0.7302978039,
0.0122722378,
-0.0478082225,
0.132234484,
0.1292754859,
0.4045649767,
0.5166854262,
-0.3238715529,
-0.0077963434,
0.2003863454,
-0.0003769863,
0.5157112479,
0.4832959771,
0.5516711473,
-0.1250947118,
-0.1794520169,
-0.6155891418,
0.7553435564,
0.6716248989,
-0.056745898,
0.9147971272,
0.4156673849,
-0.4862745404,
-0.1348898262,
-0.5067321658,
-0.117943868,
-0.3696628511,
0.1122834086,
-0.0409850664,
-0.6535549164,
0.4741577804,
0.2016079724,
0.1195012778,
0.4343295097,
0.1296603084,
-0.0719803348,
1.3098011017,
0.6040750146,
-0.2677020431,
0.4397804141,
0.0608232468,
0.2894797027,
-0.8679683208,
-0.2717821896,
-0.5346695781,
-0.0423116721,
-0.8025929332,
0.0903140828,
0.3602561355,
-0.0587568693,
0.0786786526,
0.059085492,
-0.424094528,
0.0290781092,
0.1453026682,
0.5872710943,
0.2065777481,
0.1443430036,
-0.071863398,
-0.296751678,
-0.4754770696,
-0.5290686488,
1.0545845032,
0.558724165,
0.5108023882,
0.3080773652,
0.877237916,
0.5773742795,
0.5222547054,
-0.5274336338,
0.6914305091,
-0.4451937079,
-0.2787068188,
-0.1887919307,
-0.4224557281,
-0.7941334844,
0.2296339273,
-0.3221253157,
-1.1645387411,
0.2366000265,
-0.2802337408,
-0.6165565848,
0.051125057,
-0.82698071,
0.6372300982,
-0.0175367184,
-0.2446160316,
-0.0758261159,
-0.7988744378,
0.3882196844,
-0.0661609545,
0.461617142,
-0.2512144744,
0.2361829132,
0.9344444275,
-0.4221371412,
0.7006458044,
-0.1455736607,
0.0091931904,
-0.0160472132,
0.0548127927,
0.2870551944,
0.0824012607,
-0.250159055,
0.1760860533,
0.5937238932,
-0.0593568087,
-0.5589367151,
0.5459563732,
-0.8017829657,
-0.6560744643,
-0.5515412688,
-0.3907910883,
0.0796497464,
0.0923992097,
0.0644266605,
0.6515234113,
0.0268080588,
0.2907954752,
0.5681447983,
-0.3229872286,
0.3212708533,
0.6003769636,
-0.2355667502,
-0.750697732,
0.6043270826,
0.2894203067,
0.2702057958,
0.0741749853,
0.459181875,
-0.1836494207,
-0.2291200161,
-0.1859129369,
0.9028539658,
-0.4708350599,
0.2272399515,
-0.9579552412,
-0.4824137688,
-0.9378635287,
0.0484215356,
0.037202768,
-0.4352653623,
-0.1211215779,
-0.2333973199,
0.4387295544,
0.967389822,
-0.1238260865,
-0.0211571213,
-0.9359194636,
0.4656310678,
-0.3966606259,
0.3608347774,
-0.033224158,
-0.2492884547,
-0.2045800686,
-0.2593746185,
-0.0586126372,
-1.2354909182,
0.4110234082,
0.0983698592,
0.5225397348,
0.6128599048,
0.3042438328,
0.9122061133,
-0.3294149339,
0.8171575665,
0.1135079935,
-0.7997445464,
0.6456940174,
-0.33837834,
0.0993230715,
0.6765857935,
0.6026632786,
-0.7583303452,
-0.6344080567,
-0.7859818339,
-1.0818736553,
1.013442874,
-0.0508824587,
-0.4694772959,
-0.3354903162,
0.6391367912,
-0.0959272459,
0.2389232367,
-0.7390086651,
-0.4049023986,
0.3148065209,
-0.5669503808,
-0.4280512035,
-0.4500266612,
-0.2258593291,
-0.3395919204,
0.3931682706,
0.1342626959,
0.2140912563,
0.6307614446,
0.190708667,
-0.2751118541,
0.2604729235,
0.4104967415,
0.6349343061,
-0.3733213246,
0.3311288953,
0.1024362892,
-0.7238721848,
-0.1284133345,
0.2647051811,
-0.2342844158,
0.391461879,
0.3700194061,
0.5087291598,
0.0509483479,
-0.7144604325,
0.49165833,
-0.2869052887,
-0.2617315054,
-0.5378519893,
0.1195495576,
-0.0713261142,
0.1648053378,
0.0443813242,
-0.2868593037,
0.1640227139,
-0.4667329788,
0.2151006162,
0.4291793108,
-0.5419495106,
-0.5247764587,
0.2880794108,
-0.2549660206,
-0.7217563391,
0.2441124916,
-0.1007042229,
-0.1016020402,
0.4510017335,
0.6758130789,
0.809997797,
-0.1925764531,
0.4515421689,
0.3154509068,
0.443159163,
-0.3422898054,
0.3901706636,
-0.2754801214,
-0.4088529944,
-0.0547429621,
-0.479080081,
-0.4062866271,
0.3257239759,
-1.1161159277,
0.3069581091,
-0.6569748521,
-0.1763024479,
-0.0372965597,
0.1012821272,
-0.3003530502,
0.0362804234,
0.2246782631,
0.7617793679,
-1.0139107704,
0.4264032245,
0.9389187694,
-0.3565527797,
-0.8918130994,
0.0328926258,
0.3262072206,
-0.0813407525,
0.1392366886,
0.2660405934,
-0.0326415934,
-0.3817360997,
-0.2121255696,
-0.8935785294,
0.961376965,
0.0835094526,
-0.4040064514,
-0.0524366572,
0.238880679,
0.8282198906,
-0.3957425654,
0.3903025687,
0.8319579959,
0.1238237694,
-0.1963557899,
-0.9002569914,
0.1785834283,
-0.5964714289,
-0.3130219877,
0.2655422688,
-0.5154367089,
0.5641480088,
0.0354703814,
-0.2825341225,
-0.2022916079,
0.2430632412,
0.6211246848,
0.8331941366,
0.5825020671,
0.412089318,
0.8384351134,
0.1535736322,
0.7324506044,
-0.2177691013,
0.088712886,
0.9887735248,
-0.8190178275,
0.8201750517,
0.5259053111,
-0.1278361976,
0.7950878143,
0.5531013012,
0.4082315564,
0.4316752255,
-0.0054155355,
-0.4335738122,
0.2253147364,
-0.1829679608,
-0.2676459253,
0.046279043,
0.6447041035,
-0.664026022,
-0.1514919698,
-0.2389989644,
0.1927003264,
-0.049896352,
-0.1166939512,
1.08411479,
0.4124338925,
-0.6809309721,
0.2152668536,
0.0023662271,
0.3061148524,
-0.8842670918,
-0.1305014491,
-0.1816983521,
0.4153678417,
-0.5100294948,
-0.4288433194,
0.493032068,
0.3173284531,
-0.2443776131,
-0.1379410028,
0.7706308961,
-0.243886441,
-0.5443255901,
0.7008938193,
0.4946993887,
0.2542387545,
0.3221058846,
-0.5522662401,
-0.0759545788,
-0.0493958741,
-0.18382442,
0.5332120657,
0.6317616701,
-0.2632361054,
0.4504976869,
0.5765229464,
0.8530974388,
0.0189105049,
0.2818054259,
0.7748350501,
-0.7540124655,
-0.5453320742,
-1.0289194584,
0.146676138,
-0.3644282222,
-0.3331800997,
0.9585878849,
0.4281505346,
0.3821994364,
0.2937926054,
0.8286962509,
-0.207933411,
0.8281348348,
-0.2230706215,
0.4622182846,
-0.546361208,
0.4393671155,
-0.859169364,
-0.6374240518,
-0.3665544093,
0.5453644991,
-0.5819929838,
-0.4241057336,
0.8944550157,
0.884021759,
0.0448032394,
0.2559563518,
-0.0693257153,
0.0209762696,
0.4007997811,
0.3925602734,
0.6887052059,
-0.1806477606,
0.1749520153,
-0.4534105957,
-0.4259365201,
0.1286982745,
-0.4480746388,
-0.6549379826,
-0.1865767688,
-0.3468348682,
-0.7401897907,
0.1206845716,
1.4410495758,
0.1991089582,
-0.7953181863,
-0.4737884402,
0.1092017964,
0.1695629358,
-0.5723153353,
-0.3430383801,
0.4479876757,
-0.0866274387,
-0.1503893733,
0.1364354938,
0.3657130897,
-0.2926619351,
-0.3511884809,
0.0277051926,
-0.2166672647,
-0.2076992989,
0.5968189836,
0.0765276924,
-0.4488852918,
-0.1303983778,
0.1455014646,
-0.2952262759,
-0.0090125594,
0.6112870574,
-0.2866031229,
0.1651448309,
0.4407050014,
0.346650213,
0.113020137,
0.2833868861,
0.4797427356,
-0.2120159864,
-0.1257314086,
0.0335839391,
0.4738717675,
0.1370372623,
-0.6446230412,
0.3827275038,
0.5273439288,
-0.465198338,
-0.8629698157,
-0.1974001974,
-0.8968855739,
0.002909455,
1.441262126,
-0.2830108702,
-0.5519628525,
-0.665768981,
-0.3128941357,
0.1142912433,
-0.5986511707,
1.0914020538,
0.7391171455,
-0.2518565655,
-0.3552356362,
-0.7343946695,
0.467107892,
0.2645408809,
-0.6222168803,
0.0028032626,
0.4640770257,
0.275513947,
0.1701016128,
1.0716359615,
-0.4833186567,
0.2628022432,
-0.3976719677,
0.0835239664,
0.4094467759,
-0.151511535,
-0.6204941869,
0.4289121032,
-0.1249507591,
-0.0402692854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17196v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17196v1
|
GPT-4 Understands Discourse at Least as Well as Humans Do
| 2024-03-25T21:17:14 | 2024-03-25T21:17:14 |
Thomas Shultz, Jamie Wise, Ardavan Salehi Nobandegani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We test whether a leading AI system GPT-4 understands discourse as well as
humans do, using a standardized test of discourse comprehension. Participants
are presented with brief stories and then answer eight yes/no questions probing
their comprehension of the story. The questions are formatted to assess the
separate impacts of directness (stated vs. implied) and salience (main idea vs.
details). GPT-4 performs slightly, but not statistically significantly, better
than humans given the very high level of human performance. Both GPT-4 and
humans exhibit a strong ability to make inferences about information that is
not explicitly stated in a story, a critical test of understanding.
|
[
-0.5580849648,
-0.873948276,
1.0196796656,
0.1389181316,
-0.2796314359,
0.2425211668,
0.0399586745,
-0.7636096478,
-0.2137571424,
0.0214937571,
-0.3352552354,
-0.2505562603,
-0.5419757962,
0.5182828307,
-0.0565057956,
1.2764850855,
-0.071689643,
0.0959257185,
-0.1141944751,
0.0587670989,
-0.3785959184,
-0.6713043451,
-0.7612130642,
-0.5528343916,
0.489356637,
0.2808651328,
0.725790143,
0.2278362066,
0.5388688445,
0.3367479742,
-0.0504863001,
-0.3441975713,
-0.3178048432,
0.0082886918,
-0.3356898725,
-0.5429368615,
-0.2878762186,
0.2841611505,
0.6104648709,
0.5614984035,
0.1158710495,
0.1981490552,
0.24541004,
0.1674340516,
-0.1884364784,
0.4093354344,
-0.2971615493,
0.1612339467,
-0.1308348328,
-0.0548644774,
-0.2798234522,
-0.4703201354,
0.4813377857,
-0.8880085945,
0.3885750175,
0.0289257821,
1.1057027578,
0.293245852,
-0.755404532,
-0.1200979128,
-0.4469697475,
0.3760877252,
-0.4353122413,
0.2309355885,
0.5988150239,
0.1773158312,
0.1825263947,
-0.9281385541,
-0.742425859,
-0.2792645991,
-0.3734201193,
0.448574096,
0.0950835273,
0.4244176745,
0.5523869395,
0.4984109104,
-1.0164963007,
-0.1979813278,
-0.6070508957,
-0.2698743343,
0.4459481239,
-0.0451331027,
0.3455562592,
-0.3259755075,
-0.4227797389,
0.2215663046,
-0.3454253078,
0.1927977502,
0.2943398058,
-0.2212118506,
0.1216643602,
0.2634150982,
0.0136501556,
0.503382504,
0.1762470901,
0.0680858269,
0.2478175163,
-0.7246527076,
-0.3079695702,
-0.0489110425,
0.6554200649,
0.2918056548,
0.245822683,
-0.1823159903,
-0.034323696,
0.3321192861,
0.3574829102,
-0.7395102382,
-0.328538537,
-0.1253828853,
-0.2858225703,
-0.1350106895,
-0.1783837378,
-0.4988407791,
-0.268317759,
-0.358641386,
0.4999037981,
-0.6619783044,
-0.1129121482,
0.1694199592,
-0.6232987642,
0.9296901226,
0.4435598552,
-1.0784369707,
0.7066559196,
0.7182273269,
0.9422314167,
-0.3650769889,
-0.4304198623,
-0.3921851814,
-0.0161492843,
-0.3129359782,
1.163892746,
-0.4565156996,
-0.3859218955,
-0.5003733039,
-0.1660126001,
-0.2563893795,
-0.3664588034,
0.8966345191,
-0.4449100196,
0.4552840292,
-0.7707484365,
-0.5172955394,
-0.4437767565,
0.7155640125,
-0.4557904303,
0.8481433392,
0.3089317083,
-1.0108987093,
0.4926138222,
-1.0140451193,
-0.5322553515,
0.2679894567,
-0.5337187648,
-0.1495892107,
-0.1226009354,
0.3156596422,
0.1757193655,
-0.1967298687,
0.279866159,
0.1586026251,
-0.6774699092,
0.208006978,
-0.4377663732,
0.4785105586,
-0.093265906,
-0.6479908228,
0.0739561915,
-0.3093051612,
0.1354437023,
0.1019810662,
-0.3605667353,
0.0198301077,
-0.3363542259,
-0.3887621164,
0.1113607883,
0.0787726417,
-0.6394597888,
0.3639146984,
-0.459292084,
0.6242839694,
0.7034358978,
0.4115331173,
0.3874320686,
-0.467872858,
0.8217350841,
-0.1291300058,
0.0388808995,
-0.2193104327,
-1.0208525658,
-0.512157321,
0.0053902124,
0.2515721023,
0.8337287903,
-1.0329521894,
-0.0518159233,
-0.0183822718,
-0.1544166207,
-0.4200239182,
-0.3133742511,
0.4452877343,
0.7728000879,
0.2730825543,
-0.4306570888,
-0.3937695622,
-0.8985951543,
-0.3226181567,
-0.4847019017,
-0.2491529286,
0.2975040078,
0.7220992446,
0.0662770048,
0.7161871195,
-0.4687180817,
0.1506399512,
-0.2867937982,
0.5795755386,
0.0853953436,
0.0850109085,
0.3966100216,
-0.8769654632,
-0.4461856782,
0.070825614,
-0.9149213433,
-0.0281945672,
-0.091524981,
0.1087429821,
-0.1004258543,
-0.0652912259,
-0.7537452579,
0.6227695346,
0.3404460549,
-0.7094758749,
0.7387368083,
-0.288443774,
0.3601717055,
-0.522865653,
0.1138024256,
-0.1418568045,
-0.3561534882,
-0.6382812262,
-0.1488293558,
-0.0136583503,
-0.2113582343,
-0.1963921338,
0.2899754643,
-0.4887537658,
-0.6576625705,
0.1335599571,
0.2584115565,
0.289535284,
0.5927013159,
-0.0152530326,
1.3033940792,
0.472153306,
-0.5223170519,
0.1884962916,
0.3906506598,
-0.2672672272,
0.8727661371,
-0.958078146,
0.6313375235,
-0.2104773223,
0.2750861049,
-1.1846709251,
-0.3983095884,
0.2622613609,
-0.6262997985,
-0.0356123187,
0.150971666,
-0.3037151694,
-0.4765118361,
-0.2108001113,
0.2949367762,
0.404825896,
-0.1328433603,
0.6269521117,
0.2566818893,
-0.4653903246,
-0.4264249504,
-0.7193128467,
0.2986763716,
-0.299179703,
-0.6496575475,
0.3013555408,
-0.2444593459,
-0.318104744,
-0.2259094566,
0.1353782564,
-0.4997156262,
0.0017793704,
0.1912368089,
0.0818174854,
-0.3446979523,
0.0830371827,
-0.0639725104,
-0.208385393,
0.153436929,
-0.0788721964,
0.3590398729,
-0.5887723565,
-0.3254231215,
-0.7810463905,
0.2841747999,
0.4537271559,
-0.250824064,
0.1437186152,
0.5863763094,
-0.0584645793,
0.4856497049,
-0.2878801823,
-0.3664911091,
-0.4812330902,
0.2505409718,
-0.8199338317,
-0.8414004445,
0.5118675828,
0.0422189534,
0.0285752807,
0.4576150775,
0.3741029799,
-0.0579238161,
0.9472737312,
0.2211401761,
-0.0153422067,
-0.1012524292,
-0.1746694297,
0.1658239514,
-0.6643496156,
-0.0000975337,
-0.4952827096,
-0.4342721999,
-0.3991876841,
-0.3894577026,
0.369014442,
-0.2447592616,
-0.5971754193,
-0.0389479883,
-0.7146891356,
0.6916553974,
0.5927864909,
-0.0000095454,
0.6851710677,
-0.5436439514,
0.0090804491,
-0.237716347,
-0.1867618561,
-0.7910370231,
0.8429197669,
0.400885582,
0.3309182823,
0.283785224,
0.5733143091,
0.2171848416,
0.4104322791,
-0.7952076197,
0.4915150106,
0.3309465051,
-0.7950201035,
-0.3532980084,
-0.2042336762,
-1.1117862463,
0.3829171956,
0.1343920082,
-0.6398552656,
-0.0536582507,
-0.0164031181,
-0.632393539,
0.1106105819,
-1.0519809723,
0.9018059373,
-0.3546645939,
-0.0393241979,
0.100372605,
-0.901196599,
0.3575409651,
-0.0125973029,
0.1425403506,
0.0589476191,
-0.3580327034,
0.7942045331,
0.1970989853,
0.745013833,
-0.2639368176,
0.1795880944,
0.4206829071,
-0.0540324971,
0.1741873771,
0.2737683356,
-0.195375964,
0.1140222326,
-0.0678402036,
-0.4048937261,
-0.708434999,
0.2297867239,
-1.1048254967,
-0.7550347447,
-0.721316874,
-0.4644574225,
-0.1567777395,
0.2407183051,
0.3713796139,
-0.016832903,
-0.5992571712,
-0.3110062182,
0.5605167747,
-0.1962529868,
0.2332181633,
0.4924310446,
-0.1485633552,
-0.2239329368,
0.4031747878,
0.073215805,
0.2745579481,
0.1634300947,
0.3784202337,
-0.4000020325,
-0.6332842112,
-0.7010409236,
0.3634455204,
-0.6233771443,
0.1285753101,
-0.7197768688,
-0.2767587006,
-0.2210670114,
-0.0435747318,
0.0755094215,
-0.2017641515,
-0.1673807353,
-0.6677545905,
0.1843298674,
1.4038732052,
-0.0122514972,
0.1256531775,
-0.4954427779,
0.4046530426,
0.7305837274,
0.0661168396,
-0.4324969351,
-0.561737895,
0.3093677163,
-0.1192186102,
-0.7678824663,
-1.0208883286,
0.0313243419,
0.1783059537,
0.3776625395,
0.3456793725,
-0.1650523096,
0.5943388343,
-0.8589836359,
1.3160452843,
-0.0830751956,
-1.2071596384,
0.4286658168,
-0.5892723799,
0.4308145344,
0.6094306111,
0.5585317016,
-0.5047688484,
-0.3487820327,
-0.7481376529,
-0.2680742145,
0.6313098669,
0.5441076159,
0.1133771464,
-0.0093599064,
0.6667153239,
0.2431026995,
0.1231189221,
-0.7964264154,
0.09031564,
-0.4094218016,
0.1711823493,
-0.1425765902,
-0.1241885647,
-0.0220279433,
-0.5031248927,
0.1544634402,
-0.0720676407,
0.6483486295,
0.3541066349,
0.2269578427,
0.1168776751,
0.389859736,
0.6808345318,
0.9671033621,
-0.1356838048,
0.4311522543,
0.426268518,
-0.8252591491,
0.4821211398,
0.1949745566,
0.0350466035,
-0.0893353,
0.4532894194,
0.7328426242,
0.1259862632,
-0.3303906322,
0.7064213753,
-0.6561220884,
-0.694803834,
-0.1268328428,
0.1354542971,
0.2084371746,
0.1113712713,
0.4014924467,
0.0009679329,
0.5030196905,
-0.8097214103,
0.5241571665,
-0.0259065162,
-0.1997244954,
-0.6924068332,
0.5956876874,
0.3219975829,
-0.5173299909,
0.5370043516,
-0.5872423053,
-0.9409317374,
0.5813976526,
0.6170520186,
0.4982009232,
-0.3687183261,
0.4828347862,
0.2364366055,
0.4771232903,
-0.0131807998,
0.6575829983,
-0.1256677955,
-0.7420939207,
-0.7413321137,
-0.1177399382,
-0.7736263275,
0.1318002343,
-0.6806527376,
-0.1333801895,
-0.341055721,
-0.2800082862,
0.1986827999,
0.140846476,
-0.8016160131,
0.2766699493,
-0.0712801665,
0.5503906608,
-0.803052485,
0.6049000025,
0.6757570505,
-0.5859794021,
-1.0863262415,
0.4003829062,
-0.0901087299,
-0.7802314758,
0.8507900834,
0.383305192,
0.1078953743,
0.2652434409,
-0.4301749766,
-0.8731020689,
1.1240589619,
0.5334858894,
-0.2543503344,
-0.2421897799,
0.0154787926,
0.6062930226,
0.1313446462,
0.518298924,
0.8256248236,
0.8588832617,
0.0990658477,
-1.3789584637,
-0.0205798596,
-0.0052699931,
-0.232387796,
0.0207904223,
-0.4599709511,
0.9678578973,
-0.2666790783,
-0.2587739229,
-0.2277826667,
0.548099041,
0.0919688866,
0.681132555,
0.5312519073,
0.4227128625,
1.2342305183,
-0.1973039806,
1.3738921881,
0.077689983,
0.1435765177,
1.051173687,
-0.5182094574,
0.5221460462,
0.1219050437,
-0.3281480968,
0.6983219385,
0.7969438434,
0.5054133534,
0.4096936882,
0.2848308384,
-0.3297400177,
0.0304854941,
0.2110304385,
-0.3471693397,
0.6937883496,
0.2225077748,
-0.0357637666,
-0.1034323871,
0.1318051368,
0.0053131334,
0.0050387043,
-0.1774138361,
1.0493404865,
0.1093364134,
-1.1862845421,
0.6184795499,
-0.2510708869,
0.3324838579,
-0.3325627446,
-0.0568324849,
-0.1269296855,
-0.0176743791,
0.0361622311,
-1.2441960573,
0.509462893,
0.0409795195,
-0.0128612136,
-0.1968373358,
0.7641087174,
-0.0668268427,
-0.0063950424,
0.0861296505,
0.5371408463,
0.6169986129,
-0.226939097,
-0.7116765976,
-0.0805268437,
0.0723132342,
-0.2403998971,
0.1586549431,
0.6086649299,
0.0351524651,
0.4143892527,
0.2519784272,
-0.1361745,
-0.2136296183,
0.1117381528,
0.9638990164,
-0.7458780408,
-0.670345962,
-0.9780187607,
0.4094228745,
-0.4722127318,
-0.3556663692,
0.7994533181,
0.5724626184,
0.3741497099,
0.2481753677,
1.0086541176,
0.2529566288,
0.4921721518,
-0.2480591536,
0.3916759789,
0.1227440834,
-0.27260077,
-0.3371496499,
-0.6711061597,
-0.2043656558,
1.0009317398,
-0.7252444029,
0.1480210423,
1.1946214437,
0.2270952463,
-0.0155475363,
0.6678238511,
0.4475185573,
0.2536529005,
0.4541073143,
0.6906602979,
1.1129071712,
-0.1506734937,
0.4863893688,
0.2430726588,
-0.5194919109,
0.4538369477,
-0.5951319933,
-1.0782897472,
-0.4467158914,
-0.0570455082,
0.0094990712,
0.2278650552,
0.1963940114,
0.6565868855,
-0.3203976452,
0.0632984862,
-0.1519150138,
-0.0791344568,
-0.1109970286,
-0.254647851,
0.4079889953,
-0.2786864638,
-0.5272045732,
0.2413766086,
0.436427325,
-0.029963892,
-0.1859696507,
-0.1433242857,
-0.1770859957,
0.1621800363,
0.5228345394,
-0.0568753444,
-0.5758620501,
-0.7691639066,
0.0527065806,
0.0119116288,
0.293156147,
0.9196677208,
-0.8029578924,
0.3774711192,
0.3703878224,
0.7088205814,
0.7177137136,
0.4288889766,
0.7285064459,
-0.5961540937,
0.1601549089,
0.6762635708,
0.1720156074,
0.4148797095,
-0.6783376336,
0.7160402536,
0.304173559,
-1.2230503559,
-0.3349688053,
0.2611443698,
-0.780626893,
-0.1415457726,
0.9110584259,
-0.376226753,
-0.0521373153,
-0.7791749835,
-0.76581949,
0.1276741326,
-0.4748413861,
0.6303021908,
0.8768977523,
-0.5338847041,
-0.2029025853,
-1.0172539949,
0.7090178132,
0.2347615659,
-1.0575144291,
-0.3604720533,
0.3013271987,
0.3499285877,
0.0709116086,
1.3179885149,
0.1709565073,
0.3615233004,
-0.143848896,
-0.2210807502,
0.3258154094,
0.0339991599,
-0.0861508548,
0.1522411257,
0.1714814603,
-0.2383071631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.11619v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.11619v1
|
Advancing Speech Translation: A Corpus of Mandarin-English Conversational Telephone Speech
| 2024-03-25T21:08:06 | 2024-03-25T21:08:06 |
Shannon Wotherspoon, William Hartmann, Matthew Snover
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
This paper introduces a set of English translations for a 123-hour subset of
the CallHome Mandarin Chinese data and the HKUST Mandarin Telephone Speech data
for the task of speech translation. Paired source-language speech and
target-language text is essential for training end-to-end speech translation
systems and can provide substantial performance improvements for cascaded
systems as well, relative to training on more widely available text data sets.
We demonstrate that fine-tuning a general-purpose translation model to our
Mandarin-English conversational telephone speech training set improves
target-domain BLEU by more than 8 points, highlighting the importance of
matched training data.
|
[
0.3577288389,
-0.5665749311,
-0.046481207,
0.2647070885,
-0.5078439713,
0.1767769605,
-0.5126038194,
-0.5386841893,
-0.3043791354,
0.5681222677,
-0.2101679593,
-0.2887249887,
-0.2949714363,
0.035495162,
-0.5574758053,
0.8714960814,
0.27328825,
0.5800306797,
0.2469145209,
-0.1975117028,
-0.8822827935,
-0.3069700897,
-0.9283824563,
-0.3634656668,
0.3547588587,
0.5584679842,
1.0422576666,
0.6608589292,
0.4950521886,
0.1126759872,
-0.029967308,
-0.0251069162,
-0.3518582582,
0.1332297325,
-0.2960014641,
-0.5988072157,
-0.6037223935,
-0.084441632,
0.8018263578,
0.798484087,
-0.0773130283,
0.2302845865,
0.0772201642,
0.6197373271,
-0.1698355079,
0.2010209709,
-0.8393256068,
-0.1022514999,
-0.3215259016,
-0.3596321344,
-0.6910969615,
-0.1566812992,
0.2151625156,
-0.3978674114,
0.3148611188,
0.1948759109,
0.6939356923,
0.3672146797,
-0.4432676136,
-0.0226352941,
-0.7481665015,
0.846359849,
-0.5935303569,
0.709213078,
0.4090670645,
0.2834345102,
0.0620709248,
-0.6251494288,
-0.1663284898,
-0.3209469616,
-0.1464077532,
0.3055835962,
-0.0886736065,
0.220459938,
0.1000917181,
0.2755949795,
-0.6941112876,
-0.0361099504,
-0.603120327,
0.0697215274,
0.9450832009,
-0.0814532116,
0.4494911432,
-0.0812993348,
0.0940063894,
-0.1036044732,
-0.608137548,
0.0985572636,
-0.032888595,
0.8327563405,
-0.322702527,
0.5039588213,
-0.0183956325,
1.0058661699,
-0.2089328468,
0.0289701018,
0.3625978231,
-0.5482052565,
-0.2453780174,
0.6838180423,
0.4102759957,
0.328777343,
0.4356476068,
-0.3510145545,
-0.07562159,
-0.238356933,
0.1445260644,
-0.5479738712,
0.0221431125,
0.2932545245,
-0.3045342267,
-0.1247079372,
-0.100240618,
-0.2097802758,
0.2452628314,
-0.5253260136,
0.2102576047,
-0.3148170114,
-0.0330846459,
0.0441851765,
-0.270673126,
0.5820925236,
0.2719554603,
-0.8860756159,
0.1825546473,
0.6577835083,
1.0606085062,
-0.2277735919,
-0.108591795,
-0.8440273404,
0.4303787947,
-0.8703846931,
0.3962994218,
-0.5982355475,
-0.4703591764,
0.2010781169,
0.1702930629,
-0.2324581891,
-0.619235754,
0.8323565722,
-0.3435505629,
0.3218525648,
0.0424342901,
-0.4099797904,
0.0132874697,
-0.2769016027,
-0.4186486304,
0.8977708817,
0.195990324,
-0.3045020998,
0.2653919458,
-0.6017475128,
-0.8581390381,
0.2695867419,
0.1061285585,
-0.1941271573,
-0.1082364097,
0.3389771581,
0.5737834573,
-0.3015199304,
0.2139380425,
0.2155412585,
-0.3617909551,
0.1291577667,
-0.2482746989,
0.9413588047,
0.477047801,
-0.2304129899,
-0.0370705575,
-0.5797868371,
-0.0632199347,
-0.0188161153,
-0.3760206699,
-0.2991997004,
0.0864894092,
0.3451220989,
0.0091122882,
0.5115687847,
-0.5225108862,
-0.1450446844,
-0.4039001167,
0.5301780701,
0.3468623757,
-0.2825421095,
0.4795768559,
-0.3735411167,
0.3568802774,
0.1361891031,
-0.1754272729,
-0.4434022307,
-0.6953113079,
-0.4933947027,
0.3120879531,
0.4944270551,
1.1003642082,
-0.4452012479,
0.3450803757,
-0.6071074009,
-0.3504873514,
-0.8825064301,
0.0576062724,
0.4714006782,
0.5789570212,
0.6296431422,
-0.0264866557,
-0.4803862572,
-0.9082000256,
-0.1988726258,
-0.1111026257,
-0.1782715917,
0.2841129005,
-0.2224248797,
0.177798599,
0.6301667094,
-0.168891564,
-0.380867064,
-0.3285981119,
-0.2856999338,
0.3080846965,
0.5352680683,
0.4387958944,
-1.1174025536,
-0.9455606937,
0.5504339337,
-0.4229150116,
-0.2265991569,
-0.1443350613,
-0.0760852993,
0.0683962777,
0.5423123837,
-0.0911385119,
0.1918811351,
0.6900060177,
-0.072261557,
0.242069453,
-0.035946101,
0.3804057837,
-1.6069403887,
0.0861072689,
-0.1135195643,
-0.5277590752,
-0.9884397984,
-0.1548713744,
0.0173354633,
-0.4243240356,
-0.4307852983,
0.4539123178,
-0.3400741816,
-0.2299477309,
-0.3112958372,
0.4049533308,
-0.2252416015,
0.1178129092,
0.3469747305,
1.1967779398,
0.6508737803,
-0.478687495,
0.4770749807,
0.6309829354,
-0.0773845613,
0.5477963686,
-0.6733625531,
0.2239442617,
0.317073822,
0.1188774109,
-0.9180874228,
-0.1030748188,
-0.0082381153,
-0.7869805098,
0.305308938,
-0.076063782,
0.049032826,
-0.0230466817,
0.1228836253,
0.3273183107,
0.5797840953,
-0.5318934321,
-0.1186318696,
0.3169680536,
-0.5228207707,
-0.5911074281,
-0.7446625233,
0.4264173508,
-0.0067265132,
-0.6126682758,
0.7934951782,
0.1763234884,
-0.1734185517,
-0.0998916104,
0.1725829393,
-0.2422192842,
-0.315325439,
-0.0703526363,
0.0700628236,
-0.465026319,
0.2886625528,
0.1247683093,
0.1844463497,
0.0220040753,
-0.3484497666,
0.544326663,
0.3331931233,
0.1243751049,
-0.3588078916,
0.4929796457,
0.2008987218,
-0.0326334499,
0.3928935826,
0.5660009384,
-0.3567440808,
-0.0485834032,
-0.3158279061,
0.0662961677,
-0.4081487656,
0.5395643115,
-0.6424703598,
-0.6821292043,
0.2976848185,
0.297834456,
0.4361762404,
0.2557820082,
0.3884745538,
0.0662625358,
1.0217859745,
0.4461782277,
-0.6337974072,
0.7360527515,
0.0758423954,
0.0673876852,
-0.7470475435,
0.13572523,
-0.5620744228,
-0.132750228,
-0.4639663696,
-0.4717897773,
0.153139919,
0.1618454605,
0.0852682069,
0.8052724004,
-0.5117223859,
0.236141786,
0.5598390102,
0.1974435598,
0.3461125195,
0.060563311,
0.261615634,
-0.0503026098,
-0.6374484301,
-0.3722728193,
0.9054268599,
0.3392074704,
0.3644803762,
0.0723958313,
0.4462966323,
0.3225054145,
-0.068125926,
-0.6657975316,
0.3437181711,
-0.4669463933,
-0.5119797587,
-0.5384721756,
-0.4338380098,
-1.1643352509,
0.0996420607,
0.1256687045,
-0.5316349268,
0.0894285589,
0.1884582192,
-0.118636094,
-0.0147721404,
-0.6689915657,
0.6756001711,
-0.1822641492,
-0.1199983656,
-0.7094928026,
-0.719697535,
0.0528651886,
-0.0817076787,
0.0828118473,
-0.1008423045,
0.0048923097,
0.8151352406,
-0.1000119895,
0.4353853464,
-0.1293348968,
-0.2220362574,
0.2040309906,
-0.2757190466,
0.2764703631,
-0.052780617,
-0.107114546,
0.2734380364,
-0.1212920994,
-0.5821679235,
-0.4091182947,
0.1737551391,
-0.6695153713,
-0.5122306347,
-0.0741855055,
-0.6820065379,
-0.2562030256,
0.0478749871,
0.3213213682,
0.4744954705,
-0.3840309083,
0.3707872033,
0.3544901311,
-0.0420228615,
0.4645352364,
0.436183244,
-0.0195965786,
-0.4362004399,
0.7423038483,
0.1380961686,
0.5260356665,
0.725559473,
-0.0381128639,
-0.3821093738,
-0.6633175611,
-0.7257163525,
0.0992548764,
-0.3974151015,
-0.0635474846,
-0.4241760075,
-0.5514645576,
-0.9170358181,
-0.2523436546,
-0.1213272437,
-0.5032619834,
-0.2242482454,
-0.1190264747,
0.3422371149,
0.4927698374,
-0.157500878,
0.6063265204,
-0.9352302551,
0.338945657,
0.2001646608,
-0.2991929054,
-0.4093066454,
-1.1884125471,
-0.80605793,
0.3791100085,
-0.0069180164,
-0.8939572573,
0.4592563808,
0.505194068,
0.4881836474,
0.0516420789,
-0.2164261937,
0.8410729766,
-0.9660043716,
0.880115211,
0.1012766361,
-0.90797019,
0.9051424861,
-0.5337312222,
0.3203337491,
0.3079180121,
0.2900207043,
-0.9905516505,
-0.259659797,
-0.5703271031,
-0.6824197173,
0.7253656387,
0.2099528909,
0.1659279466,
0.1965023875,
0.3135657012,
-0.4001535773,
0.1957075149,
-0.4101654291,
-0.1130404845,
-0.080251202,
-0.1871112287,
-0.4384623766,
0.0749568939,
-0.1202026978,
-0.4712558389,
0.6955004334,
-0.1503932774,
0.2407185733,
0.248535797,
-0.1873304546,
-0.2715860009,
0.4264827967,
0.591375649,
0.3787543476,
-0.4311348796,
-0.3479015231,
0.3875851333,
-0.616335988,
0.2579383254,
0.37066257,
-0.0389954261,
0.2306856811,
0.4802576303,
0.949061811,
0.2227082551,
-0.5116526484,
0.4264542162,
0.2304129004,
-0.0805498585,
-0.3016597331,
0.1185254902,
0.0858000815,
-0.018484924,
0.6122766137,
-0.1537427902,
0.1583125889,
-0.5646935701,
0.5458772182,
0.1328937858,
-0.6500189304,
-0.2216878235,
0.6944006085,
0.5017068386,
-0.6831966043,
0.3544815779,
0.1002079174,
-0.3798806369,
0.3842758238,
0.8029929399,
1.0105874538,
-0.7613081336,
0.1559411585,
0.3346817195,
0.1396775544,
-0.0096445838,
0.2076600641,
-0.1282076836,
-0.7108640075,
-0.7255923152,
-0.4764059484,
-0.6490335464,
-0.0217248108,
-0.8800034523,
0.4239470065,
0.1198872998,
0.0985375717,
-0.0833291635,
-0.1664566398,
-0.2150102258,
0.3595815897,
0.2091582417,
0.9167308807,
-0.6190213561,
1.0989044905,
0.6837772131,
-0.0651722327,
-0.8462212086,
-0.1235221326,
-0.4279486239,
-0.7735907435,
0.679056704,
-0.024301514,
-0.0472071432,
0.3933894336,
-0.4475599527,
-0.7405783534,
0.9545949101,
0.4259390235,
-0.8954216838,
-0.1420346349,
0.5187851191,
0.4066839516,
-0.5179278255,
0.0162863582,
0.7921417952,
0.2001695335,
-0.1707547009,
-1.4914511442,
-0.3288488388,
-0.0787799954,
-0.0665397346,
0.0585271642,
-0.7667233348,
0.6495783329,
0.0499544218,
-0.2483736724,
-0.1090269759,
0.7954095602,
-0.181102246,
0.0472858325,
0.4569752514,
0.3334935009,
0.5362651944,
-0.0746299326,
0.6430628896,
-0.5378623009,
0.0284777712,
1.2636663914,
-0.2795005441,
1.2341262102,
0.0935490802,
-0.3091543913,
0.0955215171,
0.7562449574,
0.2556065321,
0.447558254,
-0.0926918387,
-0.4227240682,
-0.1218481436,
-0.3515568972,
-0.4782417119,
0.5373337269,
0.6078804731,
-0.3596363962,
-0.1055394411,
0.0610145144,
-0.1642951071,
0.1449877024,
-0.2897918224,
0.7309550643,
0.2794469595,
-0.671923399,
0.8196667433,
-0.100633949,
0.5352083445,
-0.4108906388,
-0.131221205,
-0.1150555089,
-0.0056214929,
-0.2381228358,
-0.5447309613,
0.3480316401,
-0.0786338747,
0.0683942884,
-0.239554137,
0.5367639065,
-0.8754359484,
-0.2811836898,
0.3563659489,
0.4179269075,
0.3870778084,
-0.0131262802,
-1.0096863508,
-0.303155601,
0.2913373411,
-0.0179612562,
0.0324988365,
0.2443454564,
-0.0239657443,
0.4705131948,
0.6389089823,
0.4670017064,
0.2932859957,
0.2260507494,
0.5276953578,
-0.7350690961,
-0.4284547269,
-0.5829812288,
0.3669913709,
-0.246089831,
-0.4322959781,
0.5283380151,
0.8939931393,
0.9718950987,
0.083537899,
0.9641967416,
0.0010295353,
0.7940574288,
-0.5540220737,
0.4748390019,
-0.231591627,
-0.2909689546,
-0.1758294404,
-1.0855922699,
-0.2177289128,
0.6389499903,
-0.2838943005,
-0.3637046814,
0.6242750287,
0.8706891537,
-0.088108249,
0.0629836321,
0.6749045849,
-0.0520568937,
0.3612671196,
0.4927082658,
0.4740405679,
-0.8258205056,
0.5764681697,
-0.1125725657,
-0.091711536,
-0.0795998424,
-0.3926284611,
-0.7489378452,
-0.8119574189,
-0.3263243437,
-0.2762076557,
0.4486667812,
0.8040325642,
0.8002718091,
-1.036990881,
-0.7268356085,
0.034002576,
-0.2349555194,
-0.4475582838,
-0.2254264653,
0.2815838456,
-0.828933835,
-1.149969697,
0.8801282644,
0.1345798671,
0.2350735366,
0.0005665488,
-0.2485016733,
-0.2094762921,
-0.0340808481,
0.6232202053,
0.2774039805,
-0.4983597994,
-0.3302416205,
0.0188755337,
-0.1065812409,
0.3227346838,
0.8277184367,
-0.433971256,
0.1769334227,
0.2862003148,
0.7836957574,
0.356000185,
0.2257525176,
1.0290589333,
-1.0449692011,
0.5810258389,
0.2688777149,
0.3401747942,
0.5249782801,
-0.4405997992,
0.7731795907,
0.0491201356,
-0.7439299226,
-0.836478889,
0.0750748292,
-1.0859181881,
-0.0293613598,
1.140815258,
-0.1297607124,
-0.130089283,
-0.3473802805,
-0.4190194905,
0.5287826657,
-0.5918486118,
0.2035702318,
0.6682861447,
-0.0401571579,
-0.3132996261,
-0.7488882542,
0.6833054423,
0.6789655685,
-0.4557631314,
0.1965403855,
0.4521690011,
-0.1190696433,
0.2610328496,
0.6860272884,
0.0295143258,
0.3920433819,
0.026454363,
-0.2223555297,
0.4127560556,
-0.2701505721,
-0.4191520512,
-0.2735934258,
0.1602999717,
-0.5631062388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17169v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17169v3
|
QuanTemp: A real-world open-domain benchmark for fact-checking numerical claims
| 2024-03-25T20:36:03 | 2024-05-01T06:27:24 |
Venktesh V, Abhijit Anand, Avishek Anand, Vinay Setty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automated fact checking has gained immense interest to tackle the growing
misinformation in the digital era. Existing systems primarily focus on
synthetic claims on Wikipedia, and noteworthy progress has also been made on
real-world claims. In this work, we release QuanTemp, a diverse, multi-domain
dataset focused exclusively on numerical claims, encompassing temporal,
statistical and diverse aspects with fine-grained metadata and an evidence
collection without leakage. This addresses the challenge of verifying
real-world numerical claims, which are complex and often lack precise
information, not addressed by existing works that mainly focus on synthetic
claims. We evaluate and quantify the limitations of existing solutions for the
task of verifying numerical claims. We also evaluate claim decomposition based
methods, numerical understanding based models and our best baselines achieves a
macro-F1 of 58.32. This demonstrates that QuanTemp serves as a challenging
evaluation set for numerical claim verification.
|
[
-0.7088304162,
-0.4498952031,
0.4160152078,
0.4468955994,
-0.0900452882,
0.1671046317,
-0.0474310741,
-0.5794478059,
-0.0409443937,
0.181249395,
-0.3821811378,
-0.4749991,
-0.4686688185,
0.2967546284,
-0.2185097337,
0.9702326059,
-0.0139222033,
-0.1775740087,
-0.6445883512,
-0.3381584287,
-0.1068911701,
-0.6392425895,
-0.3692424595,
-0.018637266,
0.293407917,
0.2148307711,
0.3502211571,
0.2670646012,
0.6447937489,
0.2953613997,
0.1909650713,
0.5809993148,
-0.0452523604,
0.0161164068,
-0.1559454501,
-0.2611381114,
-0.499979645,
0.0454526581,
0.7256309986,
0.2669830024,
-0.3414855301,
0.7049182057,
-0.3731960952,
0.3121822178,
-1.2891390324,
0.2512462139,
-0.7008631229,
0.3980823755,
-0.1059361026,
0.052329924,
-0.3869509399,
-0.7337955832,
-0.0360893607,
-0.5975841284,
0.4701044261,
-0.0242982712,
0.9191199541,
0.5292286277,
-0.7967534661,
0.0577745996,
-0.8190628886,
0.5921618342,
-0.6132265329,
0.2820935845,
0.2224344462,
0.7210267782,
0.278770864,
-1.0086678267,
-0.6558308005,
0.0885376185,
0.0250345282,
0.1151908115,
-0.4611255527,
-0.098156698,
0.7941643596,
0.3558668494,
-0.7554237843,
-0.2625980079,
-0.3671696782,
-0.6463826895,
0.5878745317,
-0.0355092809,
0.2645830512,
-0.1113797873,
-0.3931408226,
-0.2257508934,
-0.77522403,
-0.1304647326,
0.11048197,
-0.0353776366,
-0.3679700196,
0.6140690446,
-0.3440761864,
0.6365565062,
-0.5201290846,
-0.0194699746,
-0.0402441882,
-0.2347123027,
-0.30310601,
0.1773521602,
0.7178736329,
0.3030591309,
0.2205261439,
-0.0631272271,
0.0225952454,
0.173320353,
0.2583913505,
-1.1382838488,
0.1170247793,
0.2059254646,
-0.1519352794,
-0.2192240357,
0.5252519846,
-0.6370325685,
-0.2032351196,
-0.1031998843,
0.1993613988,
-0.2338557541,
-0.2769587934,
0.1387733519,
-0.3327926397,
-0.3203287125,
0.2267682552,
-0.3088923991,
0.4514412582,
0.9520995617,
0.9775381684,
0.123598896,
0.1279522032,
-0.5708970428,
-0.0630230829,
-0.4340759516,
1.2731379271,
-0.1930004805,
-0.1132678837,
-0.0511071458,
-0.3115444183,
0.1614167094,
-1.0117509365,
0.9100005627,
-0.5716362,
-0.0975666419,
-0.2996557951,
-0.4296139181,
-0.1007606462,
0.4497015178,
-0.9461603761,
1.077043891,
0.2258397639,
-0.761577189,
0.4392221868,
-0.5333151221,
0.0224267431,
-0.0490445718,
-0.2124314606,
-0.5735840201,
0.3923053145,
-0.0233119912,
-0.1072125137,
-0.6424761415,
0.3767035902,
-0.6517812014,
0.0197677836,
0.3925285041,
-0.5471409559,
0.9188791513,
0.228666082,
-0.3555446863,
-0.3986179531,
-1.094304204,
0.3963386714,
-0.0142790508,
-0.0283794999,
-0.5115860701,
-0.19924362,
-0.282354027,
0.4267694354,
0.1064219102,
-0.9798195362,
0.4227659404,
-0.0310172625,
0.1783327311,
0.4629625976,
0.1615538299,
-0.3840170503,
-0.4487409592,
0.4829656482,
0.1404103935,
-0.0334296897,
0.125961408,
-0.2132766098,
-0.3052988648,
-0.2763895988,
1.1087219715,
0.6199980378,
-0.7760700583,
0.0114786113,
-0.4504863918,
-0.4008677602,
-0.1870318502,
-0.5527943969,
0.2683778703,
0.6764908433,
0.3979671597,
0.0235443916,
-0.6967068911,
-0.9917017221,
-0.5469321012,
-0.3585887253,
-0.4417371154,
0.1663728654,
0.6057834625,
0.1076377183,
1.1536523104,
-0.9876613617,
-0.0759360492,
0.6296420693,
0.5851454139,
-0.0550148934,
0.2824671566,
0.7252455354,
-0.822227478,
-0.5146095753,
-0.225467205,
-0.9551243186,
-0.2851797342,
-0.0603034422,
0.2160479873,
-0.0186047591,
0.2108179629,
-0.8636336923,
0.4514077902,
0.5157283545,
-0.332942307,
0.8190400004,
-0.1773506254,
0.4366167784,
-0.4800446928,
0.1147079393,
0.3743587136,
-0.3617630303,
-0.1640548408,
0.1570332199,
0.3200927079,
-0.1550993621,
-0.5671197176,
0.5607308149,
-0.0145417117,
-0.1352367252,
-0.0312426817,
-0.1824306697,
0.0046301703,
0.4013963044,
-0.0540431365,
0.7941525578,
0.1469081044,
-0.657006979,
0.4893888831,
0.0681975707,
-0.3891973794,
1.0426585674,
-0.7736006379,
-0.1407158971,
0.1184470579,
0.5561577082,
-0.6167197824,
-0.1090840176,
0.0137469824,
-0.5142017007,
-0.2096104771,
-0.2857367396,
-0.6993585825,
-0.3283523023,
-0.3448116183,
0.655049026,
0.215525791,
-0.6057174802,
0.6342483163,
0.494064182,
-0.3972548842,
-0.5766227841,
-0.3804319203,
0.3387676775,
-0.1205687374,
-0.4672838449,
0.7043039799,
-0.0387167893,
-0.8826723695,
-0.0739929378,
-0.5292435884,
-0.5037118196,
-0.0930017605,
0.2331299484,
-0.0655156523,
-0.3640998006,
-0.0165803414,
0.173099786,
-0.3288493454,
0.5061201453,
-0.3583961129,
0.0187912099,
-0.0869488567,
-0.5175193548,
-0.1296229959,
0.2848309278,
0.6416283846,
-0.2508007586,
0.4024977982,
0.4241474271,
-0.8965489864,
-0.3711795211,
-0.5602255464,
0.0105189243,
-0.365655005,
-0.0849007443,
-0.4842099547,
-0.4853225946,
0.410077095,
-0.6061748862,
0.438048631,
1.0493522882,
0.1019511223,
0.0212875046,
0.9529348612,
0.3326637149,
0.4242173731,
-0.1111718789,
-0.2925184667,
-0.0190571062,
-0.3951593935,
-0.269977361,
-0.9850537181,
-0.0672905147,
-0.3899614513,
-0.3497718275,
0.6581343412,
-0.1934704185,
-0.3880640268,
0.1584826261,
-0.2820473611,
0.4793409109,
0.5067648292,
0.1709753424,
0.6389297843,
0.1216623262,
-0.0142003605,
-0.4371761084,
-0.5713657737,
-0.275098294,
0.8719397187,
0.0465562716,
0.2586137354,
0.3859762847,
0.3347509205,
0.9803647995,
0.3981159031,
-0.3234398663,
0.4781594574,
-0.231357336,
-0.6366215944,
-0.1276787072,
-0.8493642211,
-0.5240740776,
0.49331218,
-0.2655133605,
-0.2003240883,
0.2581419647,
0.237764284,
-0.5676409006,
0.5052734017,
-0.1869080067,
0.7876405716,
-0.1668122858,
-0.2098128051,
-0.5081701279,
-0.4111188054,
0.6928877234,
-0.2077154368,
0.3142670095,
-0.2862704992,
-0.1176329926,
0.5256979465,
-1.0091820955,
0.7217110991,
-0.4698651135,
-0.5267326832,
0.616733849,
0.2609514892,
0.3215793073,
0.3000703454,
-0.1464139819,
0.4109687507,
0.4907685518,
-0.2980356812,
-0.5892241597,
0.4059777558,
-0.5472130775,
-0.004703226,
-0.8621776104,
-0.1072883084,
-0.3125660121,
0.1317488998,
0.1963263601,
0.7722358704,
-0.583552599,
0.2282908112,
0.8725669384,
-0.2718687356,
0.2490384877,
0.6708393097,
0.1469454467,
-0.7434132099,
1.0252035856,
0.1638479233,
-0.0717748851,
0.3778623044,
0.2111210227,
-0.438791275,
-0.1313956678,
-0.5022066832,
0.0817628279,
-0.5708237886,
-0.6968974471,
-0.5533837676,
-0.2265522182,
-0.2962210476,
0.3529582322,
-0.3098332286,
-1.0869244337,
0.3056031764,
0.0460070558,
0.1795760244,
0.4617021382,
-0.4455991983,
-0.0829030722,
-0.9356101155,
1.0445080996,
0.5316735506,
0.513269186,
-0.264885217,
-0.2641972303,
-0.2902787924,
0.3265733421,
-0.3746033311,
-0.3625935018,
0.1478331834,
0.40032354,
0.347401768,
0.2097535431,
0.7139270306,
0.5402585268,
-0.4682561755,
0.7065470815,
-0.0765412599,
-0.8278990388,
0.3400289714,
-0.0002123461,
0.145882681,
0.45217067,
0.6836392283,
-0.4814892411,
-0.1587241292,
-1.1878260374,
-0.4323858023,
0.2953122258,
-0.0311078988,
-0.4843272567,
0.0412575975,
0.3019761741,
0.0098001109,
0.1555058807,
-0.4219481349,
-0.0833539814,
-0.1384036392,
-0.0621471144,
0.439491868,
-0.0655034706,
-0.5164632201,
-0.0136161931,
0.5948294997,
-0.374473393,
0.1501602829,
0.1941601187,
-0.2853572369,
-0.0063937316,
0.0876660645,
0.9900345206,
0.8299931884,
-0.1800495237,
0.561419189,
0.3384341002,
-0.6617594361,
0.3561018407,
0.1566870511,
-0.2800055146,
0.4231260717,
0.4094207585,
0.2553072274,
0.3587533236,
-0.7148987651,
0.5173555613,
-0.4974552989,
-0.3884165883,
-0.4589138031,
-0.0988416523,
-0.3837122619,
0.0246281326,
0.4980410933,
0.4028972983,
0.1674599349,
-0.2214431167,
0.4411064982,
0.218998462,
0.0229147952,
-0.3500525355,
0.7858927846,
-0.0179717876,
0.0648057237,
0.5956649184,
-0.0639036074,
-0.2987807691,
0.9956795573,
0.2845495343,
0.8268669844,
0.0709400997,
0.4557129741,
0.6243543029,
0.1508817077,
-0.0790021047,
0.1388062388,
-0.2737089992,
-0.3593436778,
-0.508053124,
-0.4136096537,
-0.8277457952,
0.0128180636,
-0.6338860989,
0.1463790983,
-0.7320097685,
-0.5213894844,
0.2019679397,
0.1412652284,
-0.4414074123,
0.4037115872,
0.0233301595,
1.1190187931,
-0.9247432947,
0.3098395467,
0.3727921844,
-0.2601254582,
-0.05932533,
-0.0331679545,
0.286331296,
-0.6082903743,
0.7456097007,
-0.2024878114,
-0.270932883,
-0.0352792218,
-0.8126196265,
-0.580193162,
0.5521092415,
0.7110564709,
-0.2154871076,
-0.0157017019,
0.3638286591,
0.4324432611,
0.1835601181,
0.1433597356,
0.0668566152,
0.5616393685,
0.1401946247,
-0.7683970928,
0.125017032,
-0.0525864996,
-0.3066235185,
0.1702023298,
-0.7938356996,
0.7638508677,
-0.2213704437,
-0.296328038,
-0.1915022731,
0.8967602253,
0.4999771118,
0.5197026134,
0.6555632353,
0.8577625751,
0.668954432,
-0.3523850739,
0.9174450636,
-0.4632941782,
0.3625623286,
0.9968901277,
-0.292188108,
0.7247090936,
-0.1272200793,
-0.5928395987,
0.5756588578,
0.6747826934,
-0.166642487,
0.1367552429,
0.3629261553,
-0.6940560937,
-0.3056467474,
-0.3699879944,
-0.4774841964,
0.1997915804,
0.4234420359,
0.4354418218,
-0.5742954612,
-0.313043803,
-0.0650106817,
-0.1107248738,
-0.055112645,
0.7359374166,
0.0568754934,
-0.8529855013,
0.6918201447,
0.2534736395,
0.3267863989,
-0.6979214549,
-0.496263206,
-0.1201687753,
0.2063189596,
-0.4725905061,
-0.5076085925,
0.4747510552,
0.2565329671,
-0.092556186,
-0.180237323,
0.6625397205,
-0.1887130886,
-0.2413387597,
-0.5272223353,
0.3305308223,
-0.013473317,
-0.6104797721,
-0.5001450777,
-0.0758378878,
-0.2950315475,
0.196467936,
0.2147052884,
0.9648956656,
-0.3889380097,
0.5237228274,
0.6042609215,
0.1897216141,
-0.2116650045,
0.0613744669,
0.5009248257,
-0.6065445542,
-0.3007036448,
-0.7134475112,
0.3558553457,
-0.311817348,
-0.170237273,
0.7582070827,
0.9448156953,
0.632014215,
-0.1063953638,
0.8962913156,
-0.1363563091,
0.479929179,
-0.4173810184,
0.4149396718,
-0.2573875487,
-0.1154974625,
-0.075473167,
-0.7967969179,
-0.5719992518,
0.3788870275,
0.2647648156,
-0.2780269384,
0.6560971141,
0.1814014018,
-0.2534977198,
0.1946168095,
0.1571128517,
0.0581002235,
0.2881758511,
0.2242084593,
0.7619664669,
-0.4803034663,
0.576176703,
-0.2669036686,
-0.2551056147,
-0.1645447612,
-1.2329750061,
-0.3323863149,
-0.3818860352,
-0.7978846431,
-0.5772557855,
-0.450591892,
0.735676229,
0.665315032,
-1.0069460869,
-0.0211217701,
0.2207197845,
0.121287033,
-0.4615467489,
-0.1739517301,
0.3110920787,
0.0709709823,
-0.3580724895,
0.1236100048,
0.2855830491,
0.3531640172,
-0.2799141109,
0.3417037129,
0.0795515701,
0.1314167231,
0.8237286806,
0.9001897573,
-0.2020532191,
-0.1419789642,
-0.1367304325,
-0.1513573974,
0.0749839395,
1.2281358242,
-0.9001865387,
0.0352071747,
0.5863949656,
0.8076568246,
0.7249631286,
0.2333800197,
0.5838313103,
-0.9864487052,
-0.0196069442,
0.3031631112,
0.253439784,
0.0057496531,
0.0337029882,
0.7456842065,
0.6087375283,
-0.2934499681,
-1.1490389109,
0.0407739617,
-0.8338683844,
-0.2502230406,
0.4685811996,
-0.2055926621,
-0.0357339084,
-0.0084810769,
0.0762192756,
0.0665617287,
0.0192614719,
1.0577036142,
0.6926499605,
-0.0297431219,
0.2139531672,
-0.6172579527,
0.4701889753,
-0.0015722049,
-1.0902209282,
0.3949721456,
0.8513234258,
0.1903867871,
0.3274297714,
0.4629650116,
-0.2400163263,
0.3290157914,
0.3222830892,
0.1626318842,
-0.1497094333,
-0.5141263604,
-0.0512036905,
0.5799738169,
-0.2703079879,
-0.0532244891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17158v1
|
Reflecting the Male Gaze: Quantifying Female Objectification in 19th and 20th Century Novels
| 2024-03-25T20:16:14 | 2024-03-25T20:16:14 |
Kexin Luo, Yue Mao, Bei Zhang, Sophie Hao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Inspired by the concept of the male gaze (Mulvey, 1975) in literature and
media studies, this paper proposes a framework for analyzing gender bias in
terms of female objectification: the extent to which a text portrays female
individuals as objects of visual pleasure. Our framework measures female
objectification along two axes. First, we compute an agency bias score that
indicates whether male entities are more likely to appear in the text as
grammatical agents than female entities. Next, by analyzing the word embedding
space induced by a text (Caliskan et al., 2017), we compute an appearance bias
score that indicates whether female entities are more closely associated with
appearance-related words than male entities. Applying our framework to 19th and
20th century novels reveals evidence of female objectification in literature:
we find that novels written from a male perspective systematically objectify
female characters, while novels written from a female perspective do not
exhibit statistically significant objectification of any gender.
|
[
-0.043073047,
-0.6312282085,
0.5431157947,
0.2080530524,
0.2028684914,
-0.3271983266,
0.2135847211,
-0.4356940687,
0.214908272,
0.6398048401,
-0.7293521762,
-0.2276174873,
-0.3349812627,
0.3062645793,
-0.4232036769,
0.5327493548,
0.0721099526,
0.1491336524,
-0.6460900903,
0.027757898,
-0.3601720631,
-0.3648997545,
-0.024182938,
-0.2353669256,
0.4589143693,
-0.3535602689,
0.6669605374,
0.2498217374,
0.4968578517,
0.2787992358,
0.0701606423,
0.2693742812,
-0.8037877083,
0.0938551649,
-0.073485136,
-0.7939215899,
-0.1032991707,
0.4160682261,
0.5211751461,
0.600705266,
0.3802694976,
0.0923360884,
0.2201590389,
0.8445842266,
-0.6909785867,
0.0978587195,
-0.1295553446,
0.1810691059,
-0.1396597326,
-0.295383364,
-0.6979938745,
-0.3083922863,
0.3246549666,
-0.2825676203,
0.4907668531,
0.2896420956,
0.9693105817,
-0.1005552933,
-0.5044585466,
-0.2005927116,
-0.6941390634,
1.18138659,
-0.1808820367,
0.3072875738,
0.2717816532,
-0.0151686054,
0.1287342012,
-0.1010100096,
-0.257729739,
-0.4707984328,
-0.465148598,
-0.1217917129,
-0.1535730213,
-0.3777992427,
0.4126491845,
0.4324945509,
-0.3879389167,
-0.8735650778,
-0.2991122901,
0.0767358691,
0.6762909889,
0.0776574388,
0.5172094703,
-0.2708090246,
-0.528044343,
0.2136847377,
-0.5362834334,
0.1197906435,
0.8245435953,
0.385563612,
0.2670360506,
0.5661919713,
0.2327414453,
0.3714489043,
0.3326616287,
0.0627934113,
0.1227413267,
-0.1976075023,
-0.0792740285,
0.0005745374,
0.547529757,
0.7997378707,
0.2357100397,
-0.1827419847,
0.0498163588,
0.1742938012,
1.0900412798,
-0.5970392227,
0.0964961648,
-0.2489078045,
-0.8221283555,
-0.5503486395,
0.2899199128,
-0.682538271,
-0.8678432107,
-0.0881171823,
0.1589411646,
-0.1905305982,
-0.2806238532,
-0.2932212055,
-0.5980547071,
0.3416760266,
0.2369022071,
-1.2151846886,
0.0805379823,
0.6066007018,
0.4901196063,
-0.0390333943,
-0.1976435333,
0.085446544,
0.1566756517,
-0.8872916698,
0.6305617094,
-0.5853553414,
-0.2774035335,
0.3175017834,
0.3103591502,
-0.2190726399,
-0.1697376072,
0.5274565816,
-0.0701908544,
0.3440983593,
-0.4965085685,
-0.2386962026,
-0.3910495043,
0.3744882643,
-0.7197304964,
1.2484720945,
0.294716686,
-0.7874083519,
0.5860276818,
-0.0555139892,
-0.1152655184,
-0.2924137115,
-0.516346693,
-0.3785375059,
0.1836542487,
0.0740004778,
0.248472333,
-0.3815038204,
0.0562481992,
-0.3014008999,
-0.2780896127,
0.2737820446,
0.0330737196,
0.5284306407,
-0.2433776557,
-0.4440775812,
-0.0978372246,
-0.0410944037,
-0.3909240365,
0.039955169,
0.014448042,
-0.9242306352,
0.0485498831,
0.3938006461,
-0.3208369017,
0.2300818861,
-0.6346380711,
0.0453727059,
-0.143579945,
0.2660456598,
0.3716765344,
-0.1248293892,
0.7924919724,
-0.443882525,
0.4054274857,
-0.1520398706,
0.1023663506,
-0.3147969246,
-0.366312027,
-0.5609757304,
0.1649519503,
0.0154010355,
0.1299650222,
-0.4797868133,
0.2245038897,
0.0553801209,
-0.2707683742,
-0.1299792528,
-0.1021900102,
0.6114331484,
0.1503166705,
-0.0532527342,
-0.1284241527,
-0.3854900599,
-1.2971711159,
-0.8499783278,
-0.2877200842,
0.0526983701,
0.5523298383,
0.4835850894,
-0.2981636226,
0.7722717524,
-0.8599652648,
-0.7907654047,
-0.190730989,
-0.0238348152,
-0.1052902564,
0.557107091,
1.1503791809,
-0.8839963675,
-0.0515286773,
-0.0404759794,
-0.9649668932,
0.1437730044,
0.1105379015,
-0.6336291432,
0.0013486876,
0.6673774719,
-0.3121909499,
0.6409097314,
0.1084810942,
-0.7820898294,
0.7520876527,
0.1614847928,
0.6805123687,
-0.6273593903,
0.1483076811,
0.5610084534,
-0.1641334742,
-0.6627666354,
0.2662154138,
0.0916006044,
0.0113557465,
-0.2894374132,
0.7035509944,
-0.7306178808,
0.0442508869,
0.0722569525,
0.2443506271,
0.5530632734,
0.3081023693,
0.1888812482,
0.4387638867,
0.032620687,
-0.4112327397,
-0.0971811116,
0.3703072667,
-0.2170630395,
0.7943309546,
-0.3483921289,
0.0063770697,
-0.5038512945,
-0.0299692433,
-1.3582429886,
-0.1908643097,
0.3502263129,
-0.2560023665,
0.190884456,
-0.0641551837,
0.2293685675,
-0.264464885,
-0.606760323,
0.5888986588,
0.0717713535,
-0.2748398483,
1.026997447,
0.2868591249,
0.172293365,
-0.7871011496,
-0.9108486176,
-0.2305596024,
-0.1959015578,
-0.2551113963,
0.2472964078,
0.0771980658,
-0.6269875765,
-0.1894130856,
-0.0612975024,
-0.1358910352,
-0.3582622707,
0.3157663345,
0.3352912664,
0.035191875,
-0.0147350328,
0.1025981531,
0.2859041691,
0.2021648884,
0.108329609,
0.1356386095,
0.1793189347,
-0.0831032991,
-0.2599513829,
0.5068106055,
0.467862457,
-0.0035785132,
0.4661648273,
0.5040487647,
-0.505548954,
-0.2108163387,
-0.3914632201,
-0.3027043045,
-0.3646475971,
0.4856951237,
-0.7483431101,
-0.4218691289,
0.3885909915,
0.3689212501,
0.0076711522,
0.4733402133,
0.2335535139,
-0.148263976,
0.9912916422,
1.0313590765,
-0.0819160119,
0.7788571715,
-0.4263463914,
0.1105775908,
-1.186621666,
-0.2446876317,
-0.6976403594,
-0.3561496735,
-0.2516029775,
-0.4113692045,
-0.1155589595,
-0.2787400484,
-0.0637988895,
0.3131705821,
-0.6366481185,
0.4765999019,
0.5260514617,
0.4920620918,
0.2733610868,
-0.2286309004,
0.1885904968,
-0.3535785377,
-0.3086925745,
-0.8688455224,
1.2443448305,
0.4813912213,
0.6643111706,
0.4493543208,
0.3008258641,
0.8851374984,
0.3563787043,
-0.6502626538,
0.6007674336,
-0.238478601,
-1.0530065298,
-0.2324008197,
-0.0812937766,
-0.7775401473,
0.4436743855,
0.0657109544,
-0.828995347,
1.0080975294,
0.0327471457,
-0.0886893943,
-0.0639977604,
-0.3086975217,
1.0243766308,
0.1207427979,
-0.9582618475,
-0.1907946914,
0.0176365413,
0.7280669212,
0.604583025,
0.0225971863,
-0.254337728,
-0.3550092578,
0.6598408222,
-0.2098606378,
0.9731624126,
-0.2826189399,
-0.5484691262,
0.060936328,
0.404094547,
0.1082338095,
-0.0121291159,
-0.0736808926,
0.0195957962,
0.1346869022,
-0.5460341573,
-0.3917459548,
0.4909941554,
-0.5062938333,
-0.5606758595,
-0.5820704699,
-0.7934791446,
-0.0216976572,
0.2609873116,
0.1407733411,
0.9441508055,
-0.7942538261,
-0.2147041112,
0.5795632601,
0.050027214,
0.3561080992,
-0.0327712446,
-0.845290184,
-0.0146277053,
0.593621552,
0.0049778335,
0.2922384143,
0.6907176375,
-0.0249972232,
-0.4887461364,
-0.1535920352,
-0.5676847696,
0.441156745,
-0.6757034659,
0.3070704341,
-0.4642755687,
0.20454593,
-0.2763396204,
-0.1372339725,
-0.133095175,
0.0531555414,
-0.4650264978,
0.2260351628,
0.0764589459,
0.6122347713,
0.8755515814,
0.1696799397,
-0.340737015,
0.3359539807,
0.2952805161,
0.2294212431,
0.0842942297,
-0.4334630072,
-0.2434853315,
-0.1733966172,
-0.270844847,
-0.8586646914,
0.5587776899,
0.2362881005,
0.3516127467,
0.9419780374,
0.1088740602,
0.3519757092,
-0.4107644558,
0.9239400625,
0.1280764937,
-0.7726213336,
0.3087804019,
-0.8782796264,
0.1863802075,
0.6646080017,
0.3449874222,
-0.4973688424,
-0.6117767692,
-0.3341587186,
-0.2743080556,
0.786233604,
0.0744866654,
0.4528432488,
0.1123633906,
0.3580510318,
0.3464061022,
0.6283748746,
-0.9152017832,
-0.4012916982,
-0.0712297633,
-0.343656987,
-0.4230644405,
-0.3645921946,
-0.3319469988,
-0.0176394712,
0.4337997437,
-0.3587563038,
0.7731590867,
0.5588584542,
-0.428507179,
-0.0589312427,
-0.1118218377,
0.4599384367,
0.8212213516,
-0.3645337224,
0.0720183775,
-0.5320287943,
-0.8341025114,
0.136073783,
-0.1919628382,
-0.7506012321,
0.4804569483,
0.5385711193,
0.8396389484,
0.4373025894,
-0.5717436671,
0.470575273,
0.079631947,
-0.3273784816,
-0.3704998195,
0.0990769863,
-0.076253891,
0.6058548689,
0.6923468113,
0.1869732141,
0.5141201019,
-1.083701849,
-0.3229798377,
0.6626899242,
-0.8510325551,
-0.1197823957,
0.7584973574,
0.2602618337,
-0.215727672,
-0.0129124885,
-0.0553399473,
-0.5236799121,
0.6617116928,
0.3037941158,
1.1380044222,
-0.1605554223,
0.3822654486,
0.5008749366,
0.5141897202,
-0.053975299,
0.2575351894,
0.1040141061,
-0.6763477921,
0.3550248742,
-0.5080797672,
-0.1811903119,
-0.3978767097,
-0.4428843558,
0.1018345878,
-0.1496913582,
-0.3298368752,
0.2519020438,
-0.2328082919,
-0.1014649794,
0.0842518955,
0.1751124263,
0.6290307641,
-0.8785494566,
0.1196682081,
0.847215414,
-0.529714942,
-0.2724697888,
0.3671849072,
0.2379034758,
-0.1050796807,
0.4200136364,
0.5858485103,
-0.2215234041,
-0.1214455515,
-0.2306794077,
-0.7544519305,
0.830652833,
0.1934025735,
-0.4067811072,
-0.3599942923,
0.106064409,
0.3815728724,
-0.7962571383,
0.6843232512,
0.6408486962,
0.6092235446,
-0.5887379646,
-0.5815793872,
-0.0000165181,
-0.4745455086,
0.3538785577,
0.3852183223,
-0.8530947566,
0.6888711452,
-0.1116183698,
-0.0970551446,
0.2724705637,
0.7590410113,
-0.0698179007,
0.6049516201,
0.4333167374,
0.2455714643,
0.4089406431,
-0.5068321228,
0.9681497812,
0.2711357474,
0.2487293631,
0.5173487663,
-0.1609418839,
0.4122284353,
0.6217472553,
-0.7240405083,
0.6606818438,
0.5555121303,
-0.0801608562,
0.4825109541,
0.0479145721,
-0.211120069,
0.0137877259,
-0.2909520864,
-0.1745339632,
0.3959605992,
-0.1441226304,
-0.9518930316,
0.2755337358,
0.444191277,
-0.0761873499,
0.5597700477,
-0.6055927277,
0.6131427884,
0.2266838104,
-0.6801435351,
0.2465206534,
-0.1930103451,
0.4983874559,
-0.4575649798,
0.0200432912,
-0.1561778933,
0.4958064854,
-0.3289993703,
-0.2150747329,
0.0760189593,
-0.2127407342,
-1.0291671753,
-0.0554212593,
0.7707305551,
-0.6345313787,
-0.8200730681,
0.1859218329,
0.2355330437,
0.3166051805,
-0.1880312711,
-0.3876911402,
0.1291883737,
0.2479063869,
-0.4857529998,
0.3584784269,
0.2730665505,
-0.1065953523,
0.6077662706,
0.1028925553,
-0.2824611366,
-0.049706053,
0.3704301119,
0.2671987116,
-0.703786552,
-0.5163763762,
-0.6729139686,
0.5109456182,
-0.1653329879,
-0.4003381133,
0.9383516908,
0.5871289372,
0.1407245547,
-0.5860691667,
0.5801755786,
-0.271086812,
0.5211794376,
-0.0758388191,
0.9661210775,
-0.6489395499,
-0.0335938632,
-0.7778024077,
-1.2530964613,
0.1110825539,
0.5713092685,
-0.6095737815,
0.3240680397,
0.7485321164,
0.7844906449,
0.1267244518,
0.2730099261,
0.2403588146,
-0.1130053997,
-0.2549028099,
0.0623025484,
1.0139605999,
-0.7906975746,
0.1694902182,
0.0969806686,
-0.2900413573,
-0.5539354682,
-0.6845309138,
-1.1724395752,
-0.6920065284,
-0.4832639992,
-0.0731615499,
0.1600905359,
0.3364857435,
0.7265552878,
-0.2669822276,
-0.333717376,
0.0831382498,
0.1013606712,
-0.7258256078,
-0.3042948544,
0.3207002878,
-0.2542251647,
-1.2845522165,
0.0043742023,
-0.0060568228,
-0.4011780024,
-0.9829458594,
0.1331104934,
-0.2713627815,
0.3237605393,
0.6198447943,
-0.4714923501,
-0.8396453261,
-0.1220462546,
0.0782703534,
-0.1183979437,
0.1211741194,
0.9677439928,
-0.64798069,
0.5183642507,
0.4560654759,
0.1193427742,
0.3565353751,
0.2420944273,
0.8733489513,
-0.7737583518,
0.1229439154,
0.1110403836,
0.1853747368,
0.3026540577,
-0.8294097781,
0.5085766315,
0.4141054451,
-0.4535647631,
-1.1131312847,
0.3639782369,
-0.8941192627,
-0.4197652042,
0.8557552099,
-0.1196727604,
-0.5915669203,
-0.177584812,
-0.5739578605,
-0.1551864296,
-0.5876696706,
0.591894567,
0.9196527004,
-0.1756141633,
-0.4355681837,
-0.8420953155,
0.5538163185,
0.3918450177,
-0.7488630414,
0.4367539883,
0.7073011398,
-0.2039129138,
0.4390048385,
0.2597786486,
-0.105466418,
0.2634499371,
0.4553485811,
0.3046275377,
0.10084299,
-0.3532099128,
0.0693089887,
0.3512373567,
-0.3015499711,
-0.098196961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17155v1
|
Task-Agnostic Detector for Insertion-Based Backdoor Attacks
| 2024-03-25T20:12:02 | 2024-03-25T20:12:02 |
Weimin Lyu, Xiao Lin, Songzhu Zheng, Lu Pang, Haibin Ling, Susmit Jha, Chao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Textual backdoor attacks pose significant security threats. Current detection
approaches, typically relying on intermediate feature representation or
reconstructing potential triggers, are task-specific and less effective beyond
sentence classification, struggling with tasks like question answering and
named entity recognition. We introduce TABDet (Task-Agnostic Backdoor
Detector), a pioneering task-agnostic method for backdoor detection. TABDet
leverages final layer logits combined with an efficient pooling technique,
enabling unified logit representation across three prominent NLP tasks. TABDet
can jointly learn from diverse task-specific models, demonstrating superior
detection efficacy over traditional task-specific methods.
|
[
-0.043603871,
-0.669490695,
0.550922811,
0.1197207943,
-0.0542260259,
0.2739509642,
0.0993425027,
-0.3868790269,
0.1466119289,
0.6949189901,
-0.5718966126,
-0.8218670487,
-0.3858038187,
-0.0256604552,
-0.6153406501,
1.0627486706,
0.1283484548,
-0.5099308491,
0.1604302675,
0.0952746794,
-0.9493070841,
-0.6402499676,
-0.5851610303,
-0.0935696587,
0.4569575191,
0.2058160454,
0.3369963765,
0.1673826277,
0.4798767567,
0.1671971381,
0.4714568853,
-0.1544762403,
0.0380962007,
0.3452457488,
-0.4250478745,
-0.7389618158,
-0.4129438698,
-0.2058217973,
0.3598817885,
-0.0360994972,
-0.2668262124,
0.3076230586,
-0.1492811292,
0.3136054873,
-0.8428742886,
-0.162473321,
-1.0244432688,
0.1647290289,
-0.4469327331,
-0.3413583636,
-0.6534210443,
0.0216492973,
-0.248217836,
-0.0140779205,
0.6007397771,
0.1325067878,
0.5747949481,
0.1481301636,
-0.324606359,
-0.2367295772,
-0.4276511371,
0.2685483396,
-0.509539187,
0.8759715557,
0.2483818978,
0.3114499152,
-0.4050964117,
-0.8142145276,
-0.6640332341,
-0.4351037443,
-0.2442089766,
-0.2466887683,
-0.2981752157,
0.2281247377,
0.1007099897,
0.5097568035,
-1.1723048687,
0.2422905713,
0.1444529891,
-0.2904187143,
0.2980301976,
0.210959509,
0.6184358597,
-0.2868970335,
-0.4672005475,
-0.0878284499,
-0.5984324813,
0.3064160943,
0.3690392375,
0.3247653544,
0.245858416,
0.5035567284,
0.1606501341,
0.6408422589,
0.4348751009,
0.1263285428,
0.2118883133,
-0.1311742812,
-0.2693914771,
0.0673257262,
0.4935880005,
-0.0658547208,
-0.4597983062,
-0.6566394567,
-0.4679597914,
0.4436005652,
0.6944128871,
-0.661798358,
-0.3849062026,
0.565058589,
-0.2433664352,
-0.4371692538,
0.2067559808,
-0.5274950862,
-0.3731202781,
0.4251476824,
0.4305489063,
-0.327798754,
-0.0954127386,
0.0307231545,
-0.3415045142,
0.4360405505,
0.1372825801,
-0.6412701607,
0.6739735603,
0.9057576656,
0.8700528741,
-0.4506784678,
-0.2762687504,
-1.0333092213,
0.3246990144,
-0.1386869997,
0.8749435544,
-0.2820911109,
-0.2501268685,
-0.2658543587,
0.2904648781,
-0.1636432111,
-0.3863385618,
0.4919684231,
-0.8194050193,
0.1592246443,
0.1709627658,
-0.3287543356,
-0.4624220431,
0.5815470219,
-0.7158953547,
1.3380528688,
0.2665373385,
-0.7202404737,
0.4042411447,
-0.7899721861,
-0.6238507628,
0.2888807952,
-0.1222171932,
-0.4913704693,
0.1325386018,
0.1363096982,
0.6125206351,
0.1652454287,
0.1656207144,
-0.0379530713,
-0.1931352168,
0.2020746768,
-0.3510684967,
0.88463521,
-0.1403764337,
-0.6929081082,
-0.0893005058,
-0.5235272646,
-0.0676819459,
-0.1433290541,
-0.0363640934,
-0.4370934665,
-0.3311662078,
0.1362145394,
0.1158192009,
0.3941417634,
-1.2098770142,
0.0747166947,
-0.3804648221,
-0.1262614429,
0.7902925014,
0.0430380739,
0.1610158235,
-0.0978105441,
0.6167740226,
0.0140639516,
0.1238577813,
-0.317026943,
-0.516569972,
-0.2172706723,
-0.5503591299,
0.1257988214,
1.2164200544,
-0.7243666649,
0.575750649,
-0.0436743014,
-0.504622817,
0.0386110097,
0.2575665414,
0.5877735615,
0.3259862661,
0.3570980132,
-0.3691215217,
-0.3781718612,
-0.8316272497,
-0.5636080503,
-0.1419234127,
-0.1731792539,
0.1111911461,
0.7355161309,
-0.394628793,
0.6905926466,
-0.7360227108,
-0.3987120986,
-0.1694686264,
0.1192555055,
0.4372744262,
0.5568452477,
0.5526269078,
-0.9689182639,
-0.7574349642,
0.3407849967,
-0.6572618484,
0.0118144071,
-0.0814987123,
0.204926908,
0.0926455408,
0.4314931035,
-0.7536738515,
0.7647656202,
0.6388586164,
-0.4616295397,
0.4389664233,
-0.0589778461,
0.1820787787,
-1.0270708799,
0.0906195715,
-0.1378979236,
-0.6466178894,
-0.9410944581,
0.411374718,
0.3188911378,
-0.3101636171,
-0.2042920738,
0.614751339,
-0.5248296261,
-0.3016615212,
-0.1751156002,
-0.018555833,
0.0228488725,
0.7643902898,
-0.1592906117,
0.8075510859,
0.360727191,
-0.2981096208,
0.7019230723,
0.2973122299,
0.1109838709,
0.6386223435,
-0.4833224714,
0.459179312,
0.2489885688,
0.6972178221,
-1.293466568,
-0.1066239625,
0.7568683028,
-0.664639771,
0.5517554283,
-0.0307503883,
-0.5181502104,
-0.6288951635,
-0.6798314452,
0.346256882,
0.2360860109,
-0.5533979535,
0.8486044407,
0.2220513523,
-0.1266282946,
-0.8134225607,
-0.7878518105,
0.2216583043,
0.0377039351,
-0.4831646979,
0.4877765477,
0.2619888783,
0.2060733736,
0.0429331437,
-0.6391009092,
-0.3909039199,
0.2322034836,
0.4968338609,
0.1472254694,
-0.2814500928,
-0.0743086189,
0.0292582978,
-0.1878731102,
-0.103468515,
-0.7076052427,
0.5421608686,
-0.2182675302,
-0.6073461771,
-0.52215451,
0.615766108,
0.3978865445,
-0.4335725605,
0.410417676,
0.7506126761,
-0.5311675668,
-0.3990114927,
-0.7752306461,
-0.3797805309,
-0.5070185065,
0.2291014344,
-0.5005393028,
-0.876968801,
0.6283919215,
0.213407144,
0.3823597133,
0.0038799176,
0.3127509654,
0.0196282528,
0.503798604,
0.6506738663,
0.1937609315,
0.3346301019,
-0.0843505785,
0.4177076519,
-0.8655636907,
-0.0923532769,
-0.4011593163,
-0.2287646681,
-0.4537321925,
-0.3063561022,
0.1762072295,
-0.4320254028,
0.2493408769,
0.8643555641,
-0.7185694575,
0.1785538644,
0.4236134291,
0.8249174356,
0.3347415924,
-0.3827281594,
0.0681310371,
0.3651868999,
-0.554055512,
-0.1365528256,
1.2968041897,
0.3766939342,
0.7307790518,
0.072755523,
0.9754322767,
0.7811225057,
0.3498583138,
-0.5152463913,
0.6836333275,
-0.4236621857,
-1.0210233927,
-0.5564714074,
0.1613065004,
-1.0613200665,
0.0623437576,
0.1406583488,
-1.3360255957,
0.4481475353,
0.254607439,
-0.5037154555,
0.660174787,
-0.6842309833,
0.9787595272,
-0.0134833949,
-0.0595763959,
0.0153377941,
-0.5567429662,
0.4608125091,
-0.229177326,
-0.0568724871,
-0.0621217377,
-0.0906276405,
0.5807842016,
-0.3243350983,
0.9914591312,
-0.3302844465,
-0.2583270371,
0.2311298996,
0.3671641946,
0.7800993323,
0.3090701699,
0.3836403787,
0.056873627,
-0.1179433689,
-0.3555441201,
-0.7696196437,
0.4584881961,
0.0471929535,
-1.0705018044,
-0.4281802475,
-0.6183714867,
-0.0863965452,
0.0165727697,
0.3053417504,
0.5529077053,
-0.0114302123,
0.2552648783,
0.833866179,
-0.1740918159,
0.3560171723,
0.2378362417,
-0.2147915512,
-0.2015962303,
0.9485934377,
-0.2597374618,
-0.0387676954,
0.8563936949,
0.0207005031,
-0.371157825,
-0.475094676,
-0.3948233426,
-0.0248505361,
-0.5254091024,
-0.5255106688,
-0.9670369625,
-0.379460752,
-0.1921620369,
-0.3724195957,
-0.3406351805,
-0.2489012629,
0.2461178601,
-0.12459822,
0.4404349923,
0.173755303,
-0.1807099432,
0.5361706018,
-0.8601757288,
0.8627070785,
0.6159765124,
0.3178526759,
-0.0893116593,
-0.2541071177,
-0.1863651425,
-0.2455917299,
-0.2437806576,
-1.2673089504,
0.165085122,
-0.0242335666,
0.6431732774,
0.0041430611,
0.1087883264,
0.0803509951,
-0.5957186818,
0.8011061549,
0.1593195796,
-1.0528370142,
0.6108099818,
-0.2651846707,
0.0388626978,
0.4844568372,
0.0687036514,
-0.4412149489,
-0.7043755651,
-0.5831155777,
-0.5307200551,
0.4962164462,
0.203158617,
0.0822614059,
0.3071060181,
0.2575961053,
0.5220319033,
0.4456610382,
-0.9226846695,
0.0005194066,
-0.3030103445,
-0.0519295484,
0.1333087534,
0.0690055862,
0.0731695369,
0.0259835795,
0.2935205102,
0.2102961242,
0.5791599154,
0.261225462,
-0.5454086065,
0.0803251415,
0.4107634127,
0.3534692526,
0.2551187873,
-0.3525580168,
0.0688003972,
0.3410769701,
-1.1035293341,
0.5698593855,
0.3643890619,
-0.1705916226,
0.3415621221,
0.3151899278,
0.4687241912,
0.2535527647,
-0.1987291574,
0.9315646291,
0.0840014145,
-0.0655344576,
-0.2348184139,
0.1909419745,
-0.604211688,
0.6564632058,
0.6567077041,
0.025661286,
0.5697776675,
-0.4891462922,
0.7900047898,
0.6734833717,
-0.382925421,
-0.4473010898,
0.494620055,
0.1600548029,
-0.5380982161,
0.3221485019,
-0.0823385715,
-0.9177945852,
0.4485841691,
0.6057205796,
1.5331567526,
-0.9122291803,
0.4148432016,
-0.2738182247,
0.7617514133,
0.2039718926,
0.3471925557,
-0.4001194835,
-0.8202058077,
-0.1583326608,
-0.3273940682,
-0.3764227331,
0.1819144487,
-0.5630128384,
0.1673686206,
-0.5329885483,
-0.1539367884,
-0.1420258582,
-0.2486433536,
-0.6381006837,
0.1218753234,
-0.1383596212,
0.8387722373,
-0.7984835505,
0.6395724416,
0.6471053958,
0.0333167501,
-0.4616422951,
0.3641643524,
-0.1781098098,
-0.8771371841,
0.6907440424,
0.3856315911,
-0.1411198825,
0.0607441068,
-0.3346568346,
-0.3512910306,
0.8577228189,
0.0636185333,
-0.2286571115,
-0.5714338422,
-0.2704325318,
0.1515971422,
-0.0824176967,
-0.2071979493,
0.2074814886,
0.5780361295,
-0.3038486242,
-0.9593763947,
0.5325749516,
-0.1300907582,
-0.0721012577,
0.4735041261,
-0.1753762364,
0.9714235663,
0.1310878843,
-0.4145351648,
-0.2294101864,
0.5831260681,
0.3270505071,
0.6979768276,
0.5973387957,
0.5494083762,
0.4788008332,
0.1002438888,
0.6898345351,
-0.2480625659,
-0.0277678799,
1.0617012978,
-0.2751010954,
0.5624935627,
0.2859707177,
-0.0509843081,
0.7506931424,
0.3118540645,
-0.3873790503,
0.5949602127,
0.0990646854,
-0.3385403752,
-0.0280481894,
0.2448325008,
-0.4341265261,
0.5625311136,
0.4975617826,
-0.0641198978,
-0.5852601528,
0.4785143435,
0.0108305076,
-0.0212254524,
-0.4988065064,
0.4212487638,
-0.0774150342,
-0.3775726855,
0.4349117875,
-0.1110935062,
0.715377748,
-0.6558967233,
-0.0551800355,
0.1234134212,
0.1749102324,
-0.366502732,
-1.0298304558,
0.3666057885,
0.128302753,
0.0796571597,
-0.1381314397,
1.2209225893,
-0.1648398787,
0.0314831585,
0.1269101053,
0.4528065324,
-0.1766495556,
-0.4408717752,
-0.3680972159,
-0.1914075017,
0.0191501435,
-0.3254963756,
0.0043209181,
0.6378493309,
-0.0310515556,
0.5977889299,
0.9136092067,
-0.1809845567,
0.1870176345,
-0.5379747748,
0.9986673594,
-0.6459956765,
-0.8240079284,
-0.9564247131,
0.702109158,
-0.1509592831,
-0.1378111243,
0.9095258117,
0.6016857624,
0.6016117334,
-0.189767614,
0.6876315475,
0.0336417444,
0.4342410862,
-0.406319797,
0.373464644,
-0.2901458144,
0.123621963,
-0.6180086732,
-0.9034749269,
-0.3824650645,
0.229012385,
-0.2295346856,
-0.3077205718,
0.9886929393,
0.7417783141,
-0.2156725526,
0.02555486,
0.5066568851,
0.0369822085,
0.4163306653,
0.6127812266,
0.6622092724,
-0.4456934333,
0.5363550186,
0.0303209219,
-0.4443435073,
-0.3784179688,
-0.772656858,
-1.2806460857,
-0.6099459529,
0.0605533458,
-0.2427828014,
0.4702725708,
0.4414857328,
0.4746708274,
-0.9104393125,
-0.0913081393,
-0.2087155581,
0.2969768643,
-0.3470775485,
-0.2630732059,
0.2475166619,
-0.143708244,
-0.0198907256,
0.1928946227,
0.643944025,
-0.2163358033,
-0.2059339732,
0.4634062648,
-0.3088937998,
-0.0090426262,
0.4260465801,
0.6198469996,
-0.7808667421,
-0.4041332304,
0.1480640322,
-0.1211715117,
-0.072324276,
0.7905507684,
-0.8289132118,
-0.1079256088,
0.4344646037,
0.9950800538,
0.5077915788,
-0.2882642448,
0.5974934101,
-1.0118530989,
0.3994106948,
0.4099164307,
-0.0257927217,
-0.0023105894,
-0.8699631095,
0.4710520506,
0.4054848254,
-0.3132714629,
-1.2290196419,
0.5163494349,
-0.9505582452,
-0.3356002569,
0.5473434329,
-0.3672382236,
-0.4512348771,
-0.4456585348,
-0.0289949942,
-0.0639979318,
-0.6621183157,
0.5380917788,
0.4536102414,
-0.1615388244,
-0.2666339874,
-0.5019990206,
0.3591636419,
-0.0824685246,
-0.7958580256,
0.0809396207,
0.0560660213,
0.0605139099,
0.3879753053,
0.6305099726,
0.1090241,
0.6959450841,
0.229014039,
0.0264236964,
-0.1816361696,
-0.5714748502,
-0.0545742922,
0.2719838619,
-0.3361876011,
-0.6139165759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17146v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17146v1
|
Outcome-Constrained Large Language Models for Countering Hate Speech
| 2024-03-25T19:44:06 | 2024-03-25T19:44:06 |
Lingzi Hong, Pengcheng Luo, Eduardo Blanco, Xiaoying Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Counterspeech that challenges or responds to hate speech has been seen as an
alternative to mitigate the negative impact of hate speech and foster
productive online communications. Research endeavors have been directed to
using language models for the automatic generation of counterspeech to assist
efforts in combating online hate. Existing research focuses on the generation
of counterspeech with certain linguistic attributes, such as being polite,
informative, and intent-driven. However, it remains unclear what impact the
counterspeech might have in an online environment. We first explore methods
that utilize large language models (LLM) to generate counterspeech constrained
by potential conversation outcomes. We build two conversation outcome
classifiers that predict the incivility level and the hater reentry behavior
following replies to hate with Reddit data, then propose four methods to
incorporate the desired outcomes, i.e., low conversation incivility and
non-hateful hater reentry, into the text generation process, including Prompt
with Instructions, Prompt and Select, LLM finetune, and LLM transformer
reinforcement learning (TRL). Evaluation results show effective strategies to
generate outcome-constrained counterspeech and the linguistic characteristics
of texts generated by different methods.
|
[
-0.5600147247,
-1.0906230211,
0.380539149,
0.1093119532,
-0.1005340442,
0.0180818923,
-0.273145467,
-0.5343511105,
0.5190860629,
0.5489940643,
-0.7042755485,
-0.0829025581,
-0.5466046333,
0.1720881015,
-0.5190370083,
1.2468802929,
0.1965732127,
0.0804738998,
-0.0443346836,
0.0036687118,
-0.4513239264,
-0.8569663167,
-0.7622141242,
-0.4293048382,
0.6264790297,
0.4284796417,
0.5090742111,
0.33309865,
0.4974326491,
0.2758693695,
0.1149680093,
-0.1492297947,
-0.8801622987,
0.3475978971,
-0.1304985881,
-0.1576649994,
-0.045474045,
0.0086795753,
0.3925507069,
0.2015222311,
-0.3641014099,
0.037169911,
-0.0699547827,
0.0478142723,
-0.4661512077,
-0.1895410419,
-0.8719223738,
0.1885891855,
-0.1387344748,
0.0946473777,
-0.4959142804,
-0.4784634411,
-0.1093113795,
-0.3454978466,
0.0931402966,
0.0028550993,
0.4120549858,
0.1197485998,
-0.2764386535,
-0.5918867588,
-0.7911574244,
0.9523079395,
-1.0717923641,
0.4918533862,
0.4583469033,
0.2231772393,
-0.2444018424,
-0.4282874763,
-0.822619319,
-0.4080344439,
-0.1126295477,
0.1255783439,
-0.2817097306,
0.0124057829,
0.3645905256,
0.1347022951,
-0.4405630827,
0.4554175138,
-0.2024724931,
-0.0119711878,
0.6939414144,
0.4880263209,
0.0811828226,
-0.1860472858,
-0.2851606011,
0.1476605386,
-0.5502408743,
-0.1248049513,
0.6803920865,
0.5141963959,
-0.0541553311,
0.63342309,
-0.2475886345,
0.551708281,
0.1344140023,
-0.296073705,
-0.0115076397,
0.0022024564,
0.1270440072,
-0.0487328991,
0.8076184988,
0.2399034351,
0.49961707,
0.0133651393,
-0.2153428644,
0.4815692008,
0.6297459006,
-1.0231271982,
-0.0051947981,
0.1040480658,
-0.3398109674,
-0.5431280732,
-0.3849555254,
-1.0126837492,
-0.522016108,
-0.1646756679,
0.24271743,
-0.2664808631,
-0.2415390611,
-0.4603745341,
-0.1462468356,
-0.019629173,
0.288428396,
-0.7973576188,
0.6285020113,
0.4867427647,
0.6274010539,
-0.4688881338,
-0.107615605,
-0.7884286046,
-0.1426307708,
-0.2661845386,
0.5298025012,
-0.736163795,
-0.4865349233,
0.2639875114,
-0.4068029523,
0.325735122,
-0.3716275096,
0.5827732086,
-0.5927403569,
0.2203255147,
0.0774594098,
-0.6347019076,
0.017711129,
0.4088310301,
-0.4896613657,
0.6539666057,
0.0307681113,
-0.7985426784,
0.0548965745,
-0.3897587657,
-0.74991256,
0.1638268977,
-0.1864020675,
-0.6684970856,
0.3081509173,
-0.2686398327,
0.2407255024,
-0.266579628,
0.2070719749,
-0.3288680017,
0.0071144984,
0.4816707969,
-0.2998616397,
0.467207402,
0.4180974662,
-0.5366179943,
0.1328474134,
-0.5413703322,
-0.0795177296,
0.3912024498,
-0.3314575255,
-0.2389678806,
0.2697651982,
0.2063174993,
0.2546275258,
-0.1882374138,
-0.8652429581,
-0.3019687831,
-0.3895264566,
0.3085123599,
0.8305855393,
0.0189732853,
-0.0430494584,
-0.4127050042,
0.6076129079,
-0.2286607027,
0.1373442709,
0.2562273741,
-0.5431703329,
-0.6612633467,
0.0546010472,
-0.1666903496,
0.4283433557,
-0.7606573701,
0.0151635259,
0.0339142345,
-0.5702485442,
-0.2420207411,
-0.2166005969,
0.7582584023,
0.6376708746,
0.3424528539,
-0.4057807624,
-0.8692291379,
-0.832026124,
-0.2882008553,
-0.2480768114,
0.0901502371,
0.3301028907,
0.2771213353,
-0.0711129531,
0.7475503683,
-0.4828752577,
0.0251965802,
-0.398396194,
0.3476282656,
-0.0960090607,
0.2084426582,
0.2763338089,
-0.8424353004,
-0.7061521411,
-0.4808261693,
-0.2058130205,
-0.3087535203,
0.0199377928,
0.188574791,
0.3278111517,
0.3534635305,
-0.4509208202,
0.5789530277,
0.6242265701,
-0.2460600436,
0.7475770116,
0.4879277349,
0.4422445893,
-0.8628894687,
-0.1937098801,
-0.0307481624,
-0.3447265625,
-1.1859920025,
0.1609660089,
-0.4798879027,
-0.3113075197,
-0.6750104427,
0.5610600114,
0.1255497038,
0.2235652655,
-0.4638653398,
0.1031531692,
-0.450624913,
0.4004605114,
0.5372146368,
0.5408769846,
-0.2367301881,
-0.7196153402,
0.2522023618,
0.4034045041,
-0.2997722328,
0.803094089,
-0.5292474627,
0.0909446999,
0.0441289991,
0.2170542479,
-0.7901350856,
-0.0545525551,
0.2830936313,
-0.6484767795,
-0.0102545246,
-0.0894546807,
-0.1372049451,
-0.4181981981,
-0.2330178767,
0.4846126139,
0.6231752634,
-0.3236357272,
0.4793001711,
0.6549162269,
-0.3419851363,
-0.3388572037,
-0.7661502361,
0.0793404281,
-0.3181505501,
-0.1423116326,
0.2999057472,
-0.4502699077,
-0.6676149964,
-0.3945764899,
0.4633915126,
0.0464592464,
-0.0103316065,
0.3369777799,
-0.0180041026,
0.1170954332,
0.0703693777,
-0.3827154934,
0.1294825971,
0.1882901639,
0.0204815976,
0.9005217552,
0.2392995059,
-0.1485383958,
-0.0977880135,
0.6509509683,
0.2700273693,
0.0643264204,
0.8547141552,
0.4676652849,
-0.3026565313,
-0.3273868263,
-0.7450245619,
-0.4648014307,
-0.4266915619,
0.4282671809,
-0.2068922222,
-1.1003938913,
0.3975354135,
0.2963601351,
0.280647397,
0.3208045363,
0.8557674885,
0.0052098734,
0.9686846137,
0.4669117332,
0.2472999245,
0.5450384617,
0.5425870419,
0.3072392941,
-0.4222588837,
0.0662105009,
-0.6437882781,
-0.1657009125,
-0.5783100128,
-0.2411865294,
0.1973794699,
-0.2887432277,
-0.4135165215,
0.3946259618,
-0.4389139712,
0.1170858592,
0.516589582,
-0.0634091347,
0.1382475942,
0.2299973518,
0.0525299087,
-0.5365690589,
-0.6703010201,
-0.0410747081,
0.9286598563,
0.2631557286,
0.6371571422,
0.3713095188,
0.4978688061,
0.4703836441,
0.6592344046,
-0.7257727981,
0.5995957255,
-0.0850994363,
-0.6168991327,
-0.2674782276,
-0.8128333688,
-0.7212510109,
-0.090399459,
-0.4150085747,
-0.7035530806,
-0.3413624167,
0.350276649,
-0.1488302052,
0.3685731292,
-0.3819958866,
0.614985764,
-0.279987216,
-0.3162172735,
-0.5260226727,
-0.3671492934,
0.4597949684,
-0.2393876314,
0.507950902,
0.0528498553,
0.2133221328,
0.6825076938,
-0.3912332356,
1.048979044,
-0.1004995704,
-0.1424991339,
0.4183188379,
0.4427057803,
0.8206520081,
-0.3602032065,
-0.2131746411,
0.2755283117,
-0.4093929529,
-0.0245893691,
-0.2390509695,
0.6996992826,
-0.5264416933,
-0.5946614742,
-0.0843432322,
-0.452342242,
-0.2756085992,
0.1280786395,
0.305883795,
0.2119610757,
-0.5416092277,
-0.1356953233,
0.6460265517,
-0.5732163787,
0.2664852738,
0.8502781987,
-0.4686598182,
-0.501998961,
1.1110943556,
0.1852091998,
0.4607645571,
0.3360825181,
0.5122671723,
-0.2538796067,
-0.4317130744,
-0.2039763331,
0.0133479293,
-0.566003859,
-0.3453761041,
-0.7696547508,
-0.3644596934,
-0.5581512451,
-0.2838728428,
-0.3275960684,
-0.4169779718,
-0.0607828274,
0.0296778604,
0.5333051085,
1.0671256781,
-0.2892268896,
0.5000324249,
-0.399014771,
0.5157888532,
0.4100723565,
0.3578273356,
0.1189488322,
-0.8715914488,
-0.1802199483,
0.0033157307,
-0.1034758985,
-1.0799535513,
0.4658820629,
-0.1293141544,
0.3514887989,
0.0572966561,
0.4165067077,
0.4507403672,
-0.8008593321,
0.6234429479,
0.4396209121,
-0.5964214802,
0.5613462925,
-0.3401798606,
0.1374718547,
0.1889710277,
0.456503123,
-0.8536147475,
-0.8040151,
-0.7990217209,
-0.6704176664,
0.4787690341,
0.2846601605,
0.3875558674,
-0.4389460087,
0.0043208203,
0.1378363669,
0.3829687238,
-1.063685298,
-0.1769187599,
-0.3306027949,
-0.2262253165,
0.0683694556,
-0.5188320279,
-0.1709628999,
0.0264720805,
0.8210496902,
0.1964597553,
0.0597587936,
-0.2063800544,
-0.0246480424,
-0.2363013327,
0.3970103264,
0.7038298249,
0.3101340234,
0.13651371,
0.1229951233,
0.3616194725,
-0.3446752429,
0.0599694401,
-0.0517875515,
-0.5032009482,
0.0096594682,
0.1031708345,
0.650126636,
0.1038016006,
-0.7571885586,
0.4457385242,
-0.0936721191,
-0.1311457157,
-0.6220666766,
-0.0627285913,
0.0218928698,
0.1548552215,
0.0452172868,
-0.46869573,
-0.0417069718,
-0.2825519741,
0.3901848197,
0.6335660815,
-0.3634426892,
-0.0633284077,
0.6143921018,
0.3119111061,
-0.7638845444,
0.6165408492,
-0.3674097061,
-0.7198057771,
0.3973051012,
0.8185916543,
0.6529846191,
-0.4747488201,
0.3900821507,
0.6119186282,
0.2169582695,
0.3074070811,
0.0445416234,
0.147262454,
-0.7494333982,
-0.2766370773,
-0.8937243223,
-0.4984432459,
0.4227446914,
-0.1619115323,
0.1432029158,
-0.6795865893,
-0.1515497714,
-0.0510185733,
-0.1387886107,
-0.5622829199,
0.197711736,
0.3769251406,
0.5344064832,
-0.777276814,
0.4021370411,
0.2492366135,
-0.375629425,
-0.5916678905,
-0.1346290261,
0.378885746,
-0.8159495592,
0.59417665,
0.0589962117,
-0.3914031386,
0.0439108685,
-0.5705394149,
-0.5980972052,
0.1400913,
-0.0144557757,
-0.7358074784,
0.4638722241,
0.4911102951,
0.642732501,
-0.4565546513,
0.3223938048,
0.312530458,
0.3103015721,
0.0711665377,
-0.7829841971,
0.1686144918,
-0.0866794437,
-0.094362393,
0.3117062449,
-0.6543954611,
0.8670548797,
-0.0492089801,
-0.3170401454,
-0.0500249341,
0.4981248081,
0.1520886421,
-0.1077902541,
0.5709941983,
0.9301389456,
0.1556535214,
0.2001565248,
0.9142101407,
0.047646068,
0.0261822306,
1.2421219349,
-0.2321131527,
0.9204736352,
0.362303555,
-0.1423157156,
0.5869502425,
0.1741021723,
0.0983028486,
0.1706109196,
0.6824362874,
-0.4968487024,
-0.2241979837,
-0.6663717628,
-0.111316286,
0.532461822,
0.4162901044,
-0.1507978886,
-0.1796837002,
0.1397687495,
0.1911714077,
0.5692492127,
-0.2605015337,
0.973897934,
-0.0595973209,
-0.7598598599,
0.3873135149,
0.2275062799,
0.8365553021,
-0.5977416635,
-0.1256589144,
-0.1417488158,
0.1564888954,
-0.1607193947,
-0.7284665704,
0.4611107409,
0.3639699221,
-0.2263329774,
-0.1938242167,
0.7003216147,
-0.5487557054,
-0.4525016248,
0.2703590095,
0.2338115573,
0.1668460965,
0.0146754421,
-0.6816863418,
0.2965022922,
0.045480039,
-0.2837558091,
0.5419490337,
0.0052965898,
-0.0460154153,
0.6480086446,
0.5564887524,
0.1881000847,
-0.1287230402,
0.1651972681,
0.7602139115,
-0.4828619659,
-0.5559610128,
-0.7802141309,
0.3882755935,
-0.1635515988,
-0.2125093937,
0.6517709494,
0.4621883035,
1.0004627705,
0.0835054889,
0.8875638247,
-0.3518701494,
1.1040703058,
-0.2345935702,
0.4883911014,
-0.3913877904,
-0.0483863242,
-0.3560718298,
-0.6209753752,
-0.2064541727,
0.5928692222,
-0.3850111663,
-0.0884609073,
0.3491347134,
0.7989317775,
0.1180161387,
-0.0347560942,
0.440843612,
0.3032345176,
0.5212281346,
0.4817794859,
0.8566963077,
-0.1780916601,
0.8177579641,
-0.1474263072,
-0.1733630449,
-0.0925347283,
-0.6701120138,
-0.886202395,
-0.3582772017,
-0.1493474841,
-0.5409590006,
0.1033347026,
0.8236324787,
0.3761918843,
-0.883916676,
-0.4202548265,
-0.0392996147,
0.1776270568,
0.1209604517,
-0.2993676364,
-0.3365797102,
-0.3041425347,
-0.6266418099,
0.2537946403,
0.0107845664,
-0.1207838804,
-0.2392837852,
-0.3346943855,
-0.33369717,
0.3875025213,
0.754663527,
0.5441990495,
-0.737596035,
-0.3846197128,
-0.2483692467,
-0.1790215969,
-0.1356682628,
1.0053768158,
-0.7403416634,
0.3568840027,
0.3051844537,
0.6518222094,
0.3819988668,
0.0496391281,
0.673895061,
-0.82158494,
0.0879773796,
0.6160361767,
0.0081694433,
0.290138483,
-0.2018327415,
0.3376299739,
0.1914620996,
-0.5471300483,
-0.7940955758,
0.8202832937,
-0.2378724664,
-0.4848915637,
1.1543015242,
0.2032554299,
0.278786689,
-0.2437797338,
0.019138366,
0.3069459796,
-0.4282950461,
0.8731574416,
0.5457404256,
-0.1859393716,
-0.4851631224,
-0.4046346247,
0.6668050885,
0.4177955687,
-0.939044416,
0.3032197952,
0.7919059396,
-0.0784295946,
0.1995243281,
0.6383347511,
0.0992172435,
0.1334880292,
0.0988373458,
0.1958883256,
0.1541821957,
-0.2172194719,
-0.0499710999,
0.1844963729,
0.0002848992,
0.4505806565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17143v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17143v2
|
Guided Distant Supervision for Multilingual Relation Extraction Data: Adapting to a New Language
| 2024-03-25T19:40:26 | 2024-03-27T15:15:16 |
Alistair Plum, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Christoph Purschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Relation extraction is essential for extracting and understanding
biographical information in the context of digital humanities and related
subjects. There is a growing interest in the community to build datasets
capable of training machine learning models to extract relationships. However,
annotating such datasets can be expensive and time-consuming, in addition to
being limited to English. This paper applies guided distant supervision to
create a large biographical relationship extraction dataset for German. Our
dataset, composed of more than 80,000 instances for nine relationship types, is
the largest biographical German relationship extraction dataset. We also create
a manually annotated dataset with 2000 instances to evaluate the models and
release it together with the dataset compiled using guided distant supervision.
We train several state-of-the-art machine learning models on the automatically
created dataset and release them as well. Furthermore, we experiment with
multilingual and cross-lingual experiments that could benefit many low-resource
languages.
|
[
-0.506355226,
-0.7866435647,
0.5478164554,
0.2524995208,
-0.0298488494,
-0.3283772767,
-0.4444678426,
-0.6895711422,
0.1813152283,
0.6413542032,
-0.854934752,
-0.5890797973,
-0.6446772814,
0.2369882762,
0.0233931616,
1.1582075357,
-0.0567231551,
0.2896685004,
-0.2483432144,
-0.3722053468,
-0.3349481225,
-0.7178029418,
-0.5802190304,
-0.0887850299,
0.8864982128,
0.3133925796,
0.5258184671,
0.659953773,
0.5893555284,
0.2457604706,
-0.0166896321,
0.3608029783,
-0.4485783875,
0.3104873598,
-0.2900448442,
-0.1750227362,
-0.4820645154,
0.0223952737,
0.7668972611,
1.1491055489,
0.3142296076,
0.4252100587,
-0.2462890595,
0.9540054202,
-0.4533767104,
0.6104947329,
-0.2844583094,
0.0768750086,
-0.4500037134,
0.0264551081,
-0.3749292195,
-0.5869705677,
0.2808986306,
-0.5328862667,
0.2353249788,
-0.1977025867,
0.7244859934,
-0.0118375206,
-0.8026559353,
-0.1876465827,
-1.0539972782,
0.5835638046,
-0.1836385876,
0.7987248898,
0.6548147202,
0.5699129701,
-0.192328468,
-0.635335803,
-0.0428582728,
-0.3270883262,
-0.2881897092,
-0.0212421324,
-0.0718333423,
-0.3499971032,
0.4033603072,
0.2205334455,
-0.3150203526,
-0.001192897,
-0.555295527,
-0.062719807,
0.8177452087,
0.0490452796,
0.0083954427,
-0.0844858438,
0.0764894485,
0.1048244163,
-0.8668845296,
-0.3826743662,
0.4294163585,
0.4018348157,
-0.0611560605,
0.3826384544,
-0.3811263442,
0.7953351736,
0.1244668514,
-0.0531504154,
0.3376492262,
-0.370588541,
0.2230795622,
-0.0142219616,
0.8904238939,
0.2434411347,
0.8726845384,
-0.4386332631,
0.2790903449,
-0.4888167381,
0.0214841794,
-0.7626596093,
-0.5909017324,
-0.0450546518,
-0.5256338716,
-0.0755669475,
0.2538233697,
-0.8581178784,
-0.2555009723,
-0.4102298021,
-0.1691055298,
-0.4664757252,
-0.4342120886,
-0.3380800188,
0.0177266523,
0.0201558806,
0.169745177,
-1.026724577,
-0.109340094,
0.5745625496,
0.7324444652,
-0.1824909598,
-0.5500054359,
-1.0799098015,
0.5557916164,
-0.198404029,
0.5980475545,
-0.5687251091,
-0.3789515197,
0.2671631575,
0.4935612977,
0.1080053672,
-0.5380022526,
0.285841316,
-0.7472345829,
0.5541111827,
-0.1315707862,
-0.5311999321,
-0.1115899011,
-0.063333638,
-0.9626410007,
0.8711471558,
0.4310618043,
-0.6338967085,
0.3299372792,
-0.5015282631,
-0.6389566064,
0.054791756,
-0.0735090822,
-0.3991187513,
-0.182957828,
0.3504409194,
0.8836422563,
-0.0444803052,
0.6161327958,
-0.7035764456,
0.0569540225,
-0.1236641705,
-0.0301731676,
1.0869971514,
0.1457066685,
-0.0717496574,
-0.1727306247,
-1.0205892324,
-0.4153211117,
0.0549832843,
-0.2504552305,
-0.7756670117,
-0.1283947229,
0.0503725931,
0.2893092632,
0.2822705805,
-0.3445395827,
0.2584553361,
-0.2448898852,
-0.1025168523,
0.5415215492,
0.4349179566,
0.567363441,
0.1275950968,
0.6147912741,
-0.1916116625,
-0.0024383366,
-0.2222343981,
-0.2113990784,
-0.4184370935,
-0.2122235745,
0.2957895696,
0.6586123705,
-0.7204149365,
0.7985712886,
-0.5143755674,
-0.5127686262,
-0.2226419449,
0.4232701659,
0.2997418642,
0.6330907345,
0.3033342659,
-0.065976046,
-0.5107254982,
-0.9747259021,
-0.1650014371,
0.0275986865,
-0.1623626351,
0.3361391723,
0.3952095211,
-0.4421400726,
0.9380533695,
-0.8224799633,
-0.5104669333,
0.1300058365,
-0.0806306973,
0.043134924,
0.5019232631,
0.7893050313,
-0.9462582469,
-0.6227343678,
0.3620179296,
-1.3700742722,
-0.0172004029,
-0.1227289066,
-0.6896010637,
-0.1144940555,
0.5499172807,
-0.3974178731,
-0.0479113124,
0.4474622607,
-0.2509984076,
0.6271198392,
-0.1733747572,
-0.2211817205,
-1.3868229389,
0.2206851691,
0.2714572847,
-0.4520838857,
-0.630895555,
0.0388801172,
0.1439877748,
0.11530108,
-0.3635046482,
0.5791214705,
-0.8481948972,
0.0754785538,
0.0588587113,
0.1373804361,
-0.213393122,
0.4763985276,
0.2510005236,
0.3416795433,
0.6035345793,
-0.5336922407,
0.8495175242,
0.6715584397,
-0.0203429218,
0.8456933498,
0.0009881809,
0.0880302563,
-0.1698596179,
0.1918803304,
-0.3821252286,
-0.5104454756,
0.3748531044,
-0.1178153753,
0.4277151525,
-0.3172318339,
-0.4422909617,
-0.0538526475,
-0.1590379924,
0.0537529364,
0.2016089112,
-0.7914958,
0.7635966539,
0.5106999278,
-0.5508080125,
-0.3087587059,
-0.5341047049,
0.0474779792,
-0.5518737435,
-0.5820810795,
0.1944242865,
0.1628179699,
-0.5493337512,
0.102853179,
0.1846612841,
-0.5765509605,
-0.0006300848,
0.4893822074,
0.3759090602,
-0.0994362384,
0.2148701251,
0.2236948311,
-0.192410782,
0.3341124058,
0.0826796442,
0.0540574864,
0.2594308257,
-0.0411496162,
-0.1667396128,
0.6691441536,
0.2747835517,
-0.2210457325,
0.7412611246,
0.8271003366,
-0.3727925718,
-0.0232980158,
-0.5261573195,
-0.2048238963,
-0.3958131969,
0.4619383812,
-0.6423599124,
-0.8297352195,
0.475499928,
-0.422078073,
0.1300709546,
0.5922114253,
0.4039621055,
0.0467660278,
0.5775506496,
0.9986311793,
-0.4577309191,
0.6431703568,
-0.0459420159,
-0.2081541717,
-0.5949957967,
-0.1973282248,
-0.235454753,
0.2761065364,
-0.8727527261,
0.0490037017,
0.2897824943,
0.0750001967,
-0.0268318392,
0.5436434746,
-0.2095687687,
0.316321224,
0.5813740492,
0.0686704963,
0.5514403582,
0.2395358235,
0.3384886682,
-0.2082506418,
-0.2159964293,
-0.5095663071,
1.0113455057,
0.099199906,
0.2509476244,
0.1244971976,
0.9400380254,
0.1390687227,
0.4864388108,
-0.6673084497,
0.2296577841,
-0.1708102971,
-0.7408850193,
-0.3081741929,
-0.7326021194,
-1.0703139305,
0.0353495777,
-0.0691577941,
-0.6746465564,
0.0796655416,
0.0977754593,
-0.1380620301,
-0.0574714653,
-0.679777205,
0.8559437394,
-0.2301185727,
-0.466280818,
-0.044748757,
-1.1916130781,
0.5511236191,
-0.5839198828,
0.2750613689,
0.0261713509,
0.3933953345,
0.7711161375,
-0.1535300463,
0.6616770029,
-0.2641748786,
-0.2730844915,
-0.1559535265,
0.1836176068,
0.5753329992,
-0.0204483829,
-0.2548060715,
0.3471650183,
0.1571498364,
-0.1641203612,
-0.4803884923,
0.7431079149,
-0.3053751886,
-0.4359885156,
-0.2043092102,
-0.5984633565,
-0.5020897388,
0.343327105,
-0.1080159992,
0.2480330616,
-0.479616046,
-0.0152751934,
0.2341257334,
-0.1922293752,
0.3163895607,
0.4520251453,
-0.3934115767,
-0.5133283734,
0.9640720487,
0.1747781336,
0.1329087466,
0.1910071969,
-0.0210564435,
-0.2211277038,
0.1042945236,
-0.6508157253,
0.632989049,
-0.6375159025,
0.162582323,
-0.6585761309,
-0.0302798524,
-0.3161190748,
0.0607310683,
-0.0927416235,
-0.4059064388,
-0.3159067631,
-0.2120928913,
0.5721584558,
0.8823165894,
-0.2071501911,
0.1857263297,
-1.1697672606,
0.5021918416,
0.1133188009,
0.2637941837,
-0.155733481,
-0.1312575191,
-0.4502255917,
-0.2293931097,
-0.1408281773,
-1.1018128395,
0.3059151769,
0.3626480699,
0.3663874269,
0.6151497364,
-0.1264994144,
0.9152241349,
-0.7634568214,
0.4143229723,
-0.1129700765,
-0.4422319829,
0.5408759713,
-0.6806596518,
0.0314004384,
0.6637505293,
0.7643247843,
-0.5538899302,
-0.3740476072,
-0.6274735928,
-0.6917849779,
0.887357533,
-0.0084504578,
0.212218225,
0.2008674145,
0.630779326,
0.4872838855,
0.1067322493,
-0.6658234596,
-0.545907557,
0.4113855958,
-0.1481050402,
-0.1696497053,
-0.128959015,
-0.0396009833,
-0.3588688076,
0.7770360708,
0.1353132427,
-0.0230638757,
-0.1052260473,
-0.075116083,
-0.0326630361,
-0.2749744654,
0.1358103305,
0.7531336546,
-0.2194847614,
-0.0790805668,
0.1581172645,
-0.2331259251,
-0.0149180004,
0.7130169868,
-0.0784373581,
0.3502197862,
0.6822144389,
0.4393187165,
-0.1958171427,
-0.3102353513,
0.4060131013,
0.1421620101,
-0.1804483235,
-0.682590425,
-0.1449706852,
0.3441636562,
0.3158991039,
0.3913284838,
-0.4248273969,
-0.0725675821,
-0.3637888134,
0.5801379085,
0.4368742704,
-0.3867882788,
-0.3318387568,
0.6888590455,
0.1351588666,
-0.277749598,
0.6639615893,
-0.1566233784,
-0.2458954901,
0.2423841059,
0.2373699397,
0.7437565923,
-0.2541210949,
0.1814766824,
0.4815696776,
-0.1067897901,
-0.0152835846,
-0.2057480365,
-0.2964547873,
-0.4131785333,
-0.5929264426,
-0.4321360588,
-0.3653124571,
0.0731809884,
-0.912794888,
0.3127652705,
-0.0341167934,
0.0757934302,
0.1490545124,
-0.1501386613,
-0.5699931383,
0.0572390929,
0.0954161063,
0.4760466516,
-1.0300118923,
1.117320776,
0.4770697951,
-0.4105827808,
-0.6230921745,
0.0237520393,
-0.1473720819,
-0.4617363811,
1.1000730991,
0.2207459211,
-0.0669939741,
0.200737685,
-0.2147170752,
-0.7616102099,
0.8935207129,
0.7503826022,
-0.6041345596,
-0.1958130896,
0.0446570367,
0.5415296555,
-0.3131771684,
-0.0277515631,
0.6341139078,
0.5221684575,
-0.2660439909,
-0.7303059697,
0.0023412248,
-0.1340609342,
-0.2768433094,
0.4621374607,
-0.5413094163,
0.3636876941,
0.0883255079,
-0.2058666497,
-0.0313694291,
0.8154453039,
0.0671272129,
0.2364721447,
0.308331877,
0.0993365869,
0.727024138,
0.0478639156,
0.9055410624,
-0.4023836851,
0.2455790192,
1.4616575241,
-0.4998802245,
0.5293874145,
0.5539498925,
-0.2209282815,
0.6577358842,
0.7557990551,
-0.4038088322,
0.4395972788,
-0.1818376184,
-0.4319808781,
0.0011562548,
-0.257362932,
-0.375515908,
0.3239200115,
0.0152831329,
-0.9053826332,
-0.2776299715,
0.062912643,
0.3225399256,
0.0781771913,
0.0086606396,
0.8942342997,
0.0987678021,
-0.6930592656,
0.1383260936,
-0.1412158161,
0.2729193866,
-0.6977322698,
-0.2150087208,
-0.1798070818,
0.1643843055,
-0.3323513269,
-0.4179887176,
0.4218773246,
0.1115756482,
-0.2211331427,
-0.1373352408,
0.4752964377,
-0.748067975,
-0.7872887254,
0.5966084599,
1.0308344364,
0.4536232054,
-0.2088868469,
-0.4040737152,
-0.488695085,
0.1383420229,
-0.4177017212,
0.3434510231,
0.610314846,
-0.276248008,
0.4165346324,
0.8099867105,
0.5270478725,
0.0215805732,
0.103663817,
0.8602336645,
-0.8146448731,
-0.2719070911,
-1.2302917242,
0.2740368843,
-0.2640783489,
-0.153861165,
1.1493952274,
0.6969854832,
0.9079909921,
-0.1376226097,
0.8892030716,
-0.0815420896,
0.460611552,
-0.2770746648,
0.4771147966,
-0.3427557051,
-0.2037038952,
-0.4586630166,
-1.1448116302,
-0.5952875018,
0.481728673,
-0.4746742845,
0.0194238983,
0.6140369177,
0.6047537327,
-0.2617253959,
-0.1343236119,
0.1271603405,
-0.2170083821,
0.2916814983,
0.4436834455,
0.6422337294,
-0.0795151368,
0.4999248683,
-0.740758419,
-0.1952089667,
0.1781934351,
-0.9759209156,
-1.1219278574,
-0.6678580046,
-0.3911382854,
-0.2561249733,
-0.0992343202,
0.829844296,
0.7248315811,
-0.648794055,
-0.1935309172,
0.0720495433,
-0.0582303703,
-0.201174587,
-0.2632398903,
0.7228530049,
0.039152272,
-0.9706124067,
0.4222233593,
0.0671865642,
-0.0079990281,
-0.4178557098,
-0.0226717498,
-0.2456994206,
-0.8611207008,
0.6205694079,
0.2249352783,
-0.3924522698,
-0.1690288037,
-0.3444237709,
0.0155334761,
0.1308953017,
0.5308896899,
-0.4313471019,
0.5812217593,
0.09155415,
0.6810958982,
0.774072051,
0.3182296455,
0.8644912839,
-1.066647768,
0.2636559904,
-0.1198059544,
0.3578340709,
0.5249903202,
-0.8376021385,
0.8409045935,
0.1486048549,
-0.5214658976,
-0.6702933908,
0.3466358483,
-0.7579054236,
-0.0972897336,
1.3661687374,
-0.4355305731,
-0.0626812875,
-0.3180917799,
-0.2940406203,
0.6150557399,
-0.2910793424,
0.6626782417,
0.8529707789,
-0.215727821,
0.1176078022,
-0.7745274305,
0.4326021075,
0.1359557807,
-0.8734235168,
0.4228771925,
0.9079749584,
0.2622607946,
0.2230525613,
0.3058899641,
-0.0054344917,
0.1151892096,
-0.3359650373,
0.0305218622,
-0.2496086359,
-0.215002656,
-0.3983127773,
0.2565119565,
-0.0419587456,
-0.1642636657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17141v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17141v2
|
MetaAligner: Towards Generalizable Multi-Objective Alignment of Language Models
| 2024-03-25T19:28:10 | 2024-05-06T14:17:41 |
Kailai Yang, Zhiwei Liu, Qianqian Xie, Jimin Huang, Tianlin Zhang, Sophia Ananiadou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) aim to tackle
heterogeneous human expectations and values via multi-objective preference
alignment. However, existing methods are parameter-adherent to the policy
model, leading to two key limitations: (1) the high-cost repetition of their
alignment algorithms for each new target model; (2) they cannot expand to
unseen objectives due to their static alignment objectives. In this work, we
propose Meta-Objective Aligner (MetaAligner), a model that performs conditional
weak-to-strong correction for weak responses to approach strong responses.
MetaAligner is the first policy-agnostic and generalizable method for
multi-objective preference alignment, which enables plug-and-play alignment by
decoupling parameter updates from the policy models and facilitates zero-shot
preference alignment for unseen objectives via in-context learning.
Experimental results show that MetaAligner achieves significant and balanced
improvements in multi-objective alignments on 10 state-of-the-art policy
models, and outperforms previous alignment methods with down to 15.71x less GPU
training hours. The model also effectively aligns unseen objectives, marking
the first step towards generalizable multi-objective preference alignment.
|
[
-0.2210683674,
-0.4430502653,
0.4944571853,
-0.0167881642,
0.0208974294,
-0.0890448764,
-0.5614308715,
0.081117183,
0.0817713514,
0.5058030486,
-0.6551897526,
-0.4465077519,
-0.6003896594,
-0.047733441,
0.0896332711,
1.2624527216,
-0.162188217,
-0.0637907013,
0.0272102561,
-0.4245509803,
-0.5344303846,
-0.2044325173,
-0.3347360194,
-0.5897346139,
0.6326289177,
0.4708736241,
1.1073422432,
0.4459885657,
0.7531206608,
0.2875110805,
0.1099624708,
0.1887554973,
-0.3559797108,
-0.1531057805,
-0.587400496,
-0.0412838981,
-0.8053845763,
0.0530298539,
0.5689407587,
0.4235877991,
-0.341036588,
0.2375814319,
0.3555970192,
0.4379889071,
-1.0453199148,
-0.2113663852,
-0.6004933715,
-0.1525465697,
-0.009565264,
0.0921714827,
-0.2838443816,
-0.1687523723,
0.1790672392,
-0.4401188791,
0.0476613007,
-0.0750928819,
1.0826177597,
0.4250184894,
-0.5408741832,
-0.0882157162,
-0.8449785709,
1.1866275072,
-0.616722703,
0.4203166366,
0.0767195895,
0.3732750714,
0.0920639932,
-0.19412525,
-0.6375448108,
0.1664502025,
-0.2730798423,
0.1317982376,
-0.080238007,
0.3307872415,
-0.1699260771,
0.117526792,
-0.7319399118,
-0.0922268927,
-0.1626102179,
-0.223336339,
0.4522624612,
0.2421090603,
0.1819528639,
-0.1248097718,
-0.2017949075,
0.0488596,
-0.3527546525,
-0.0792142898,
0.2350728214,
0.604978323,
-0.175973773,
0.8086830378,
-0.3003786206,
0.8627684116,
0.6406118274,
-0.4785398245,
0.3582977653,
-0.4095242918,
-0.1264181435,
0.0887561515,
0.9236344099,
0.5828029513,
0.0487444438,
-0.2390766144,
-0.1378950626,
0.090594478,
0.2384301722,
-0.7064579725,
0.2184806764,
0.242920205,
-0.3212950528,
-0.1743753552,
-0.1554187834,
-0.7393525243,
-0.1212548688,
-0.6376512051,
0.5256316662,
-0.0641384125,
-0.1676639616,
0.4179120958,
0.1865399182,
0.465276897,
0.1336030513,
-1.0496342182,
0.0832568929,
0.7669728994,
0.6875983477,
-0.0706228763,
-0.5507008433,
-0.4760923982,
0.4998940229,
-0.0881874636,
0.519104898,
-0.869476676,
-0.0047456529,
-0.1442977637,
0.0575196557,
-0.312088728,
-0.0148070287,
0.6351533532,
-0.2830120325,
0.6200318933,
-0.095882155,
-0.0933039784,
-0.0363977402,
0.58692801,
-0.348146826,
0.7983070612,
0.1575836539,
-0.6224889159,
0.4684411585,
-0.6180225015,
-0.2723444104,
-0.4196922183,
-0.051150389,
-0.5617995858,
0.1444318146,
0.2547882199,
0.2224470526,
-0.4424262643,
0.8324888945,
-0.4784217775,
-0.2997865379,
0.0154297128,
-0.3860805929,
0.4529128969,
0.1833251715,
-0.5284047723,
0.3267556131,
-0.5382003188,
0.0733614266,
-0.1596573442,
-0.3357850611,
-0.2658886611,
0.2204036266,
-0.1835752577,
0.3978660107,
0.5075783134,
-0.3936083615,
0.3874571919,
-0.2364878356,
0.2212844044,
0.7957615852,
-0.6211409569,
0.9099665284,
-0.1948564798,
0.3948833346,
-0.3072248995,
0.2931952477,
0.1713007092,
-0.0052145142,
-0.7356610894,
-0.6351801753,
0.4375425279,
0.6431227922,
-0.1550836563,
0.5214864016,
-0.6512318254,
-0.1567545384,
-0.8827412128,
0.3932191133,
0.6844949722,
0.6816117167,
0.5733593106,
0.10117881,
-0.3961320221,
-1.0256385803,
-0.431204021,
-0.1460818797,
0.108518526,
0.5027003288,
0.185981825,
-0.5442331433,
1.0142308474,
-0.6524636745,
-0.5576500297,
-0.3189150393,
0.1175842285,
0.4061025679,
0.3862531185,
0.4719525576,
-0.5627669096,
-0.6645035744,
0.1376194209,
-0.6754868627,
-0.2484742105,
0.1822260916,
-0.2252728939,
-0.0184672158,
0.2205098271,
-0.5310103893,
-0.0765574425,
0.9084216952,
-0.1441722512,
0.2124825716,
0.0135266986,
0.2816213965,
-1.150804162,
0.2350087762,
-0.1871234626,
-0.1206768081,
-0.7336665392,
-0.018411871,
0.2018379718,
-0.2140864134,
-0.48877123,
0.768434763,
-0.369984746,
0.3051450849,
-0.3492982388,
-0.0701609328,
0.0747817606,
0.4187232852,
0.1242230237,
0.8217875957,
0.5696097016,
-0.5626242161,
-0.0637536272,
0.26071769,
0.3142239153,
0.9304220676,
-0.7279471159,
0.1021085307,
-0.4380661845,
0.100505501,
-0.6897195578,
-0.2223433852,
0.5565069318,
-0.1263050139,
0.3555664718,
-0.3243202269,
0.1012065262,
-0.2512715161,
-0.3186210096,
0.5538195372,
0.0968991071,
-0.4993105829,
1.239441514,
0.1718006879,
-0.0386013277,
-1.1693409681,
-0.4062436521,
0.0380656086,
-0.3477722406,
-0.4494101703,
0.5079059601,
-0.0692949444,
-0.0622381158,
0.1837520748,
0.0022744355,
0.1712776273,
-0.0669456795,
0.0583616234,
0.3822566569,
-0.2505241334,
0.0883398578,
0.0975071117,
-0.4211208522,
-0.4965062439,
-0.3551639616,
0.4783765376,
-0.3314177394,
-0.4419977367,
-0.284581095,
0.2028650939,
0.5571045876,
-0.5395953655,
0.6972694993,
0.4531010091,
-0.2574007809,
0.2315541208,
-0.7508299351,
0.0085123591,
-0.5172671676,
0.347168088,
-0.5021061897,
-0.8572182059,
0.0312405899,
-0.0070163603,
0.1452913582,
0.4421877563,
0.2253249437,
0.0561663024,
1.3041577339,
0.6488981843,
-0.5198442936,
0.2772735059,
0.1892761588,
0.4260888398,
-1.0550400019,
0.0463426188,
-0.4024153054,
-0.5366460085,
-0.3383824229,
-0.1809362173,
0.2670834363,
0.1563952118,
-0.4587827921,
0.4331092834,
-0.6560867429,
0.6974329948,
0.2875041366,
-0.0043745125,
0.0558812954,
-0.2446087748,
-0.0335899591,
-0.0757510215,
-0.4132533371,
-0.6409181356,
1.3263192177,
-0.0123135876,
0.9802325964,
0.3438877761,
0.7468754053,
-0.028288288,
0.5055861473,
-0.5467767715,
0.3624196649,
-0.380071193,
-0.8682107925,
-0.3618751168,
-0.3016002178,
-0.6769208908,
0.5368358493,
-0.4773024023,
-0.6756298542,
0.2800514102,
0.5640989542,
-0.2835311592,
0.1910355687,
-0.5323045254,
1.1244239807,
-0.6473363042,
-0.6077666879,
0.079079479,
-0.6256936789,
0.5199149251,
-0.0807061717,
0.2212737501,
-0.4168738723,
-0.0344450288,
0.1880864501,
0.0015508266,
0.7267715335,
-0.2114072591,
0.0207878742,
-0.039953623,
-0.2093613446,
0.5825312138,
-0.156798929,
-0.2515042722,
0.0544887632,
-0.4139780998,
-0.2412726134,
-0.417532146,
0.6119497418,
-0.6757977009,
-0.6892023087,
-0.5839432478,
-0.6965648532,
-0.0850448757,
0.4474057257,
0.021579409,
0.180421561,
-0.5950587988,
0.0313701332,
0.4822110236,
-0.0359678157,
0.2935754359,
0.8820531368,
-0.1881592572,
-0.7278439403,
1.0221269131,
-0.2736043632,
0.3335411251,
0.567543149,
0.2852747738,
-0.2986552119,
-0.200569883,
-0.377759546,
0.343020618,
-0.300680995,
-0.3433384001,
-0.7160210013,
0.0162984598,
-0.3947594464,
-0.5930843949,
-0.577126503,
-0.1306434423,
-0.3480651975,
0.1047854796,
-0.1255919635,
0.0647951365,
-0.2788327336,
0.5959759355,
-0.4788571596,
0.4851541519,
0.4722663462,
0.4106774926,
-0.5517601967,
-0.3538480997,
0.0674513131,
0.2340245545,
-0.584282577,
-0.4515420198,
0.0996379182,
0.6002069712,
0.4224438965,
0.8445161581,
-0.0550481118,
0.9438169003,
-0.7203664184,
0.3477743566,
0.3921242356,
-1.1651360989,
0.3329669237,
-0.2636321187,
0.4220803082,
1.0201143026,
0.1342350692,
-0.5229095221,
-0.3063174784,
-0.1421005428,
-0.5544062257,
0.619682312,
-0.2076753825,
0.354397893,
-0.0126221925,
0.2829612494,
-0.1161913499,
0.2863442302,
-0.7566812038,
-0.1548342258,
-0.3542223573,
-0.6036612988,
-0.6144572496,
-0.1438043416,
-0.2317848653,
-0.0975921899,
0.7178103924,
-0.546254456,
-0.0018211299,
-0.1225433797,
-0.48935467,
-0.0521370023,
0.8290970325,
0.8941489458,
0.6186783314,
-0.4572912753,
0.3421185613,
0.2965497077,
-0.0956198797,
0.5242863894,
0.2570540011,
-0.4012292922,
-0.2338515818,
0.0013538687,
0.768004477,
0.4341485798,
-0.453216821,
0.8146173954,
-0.0851289853,
-0.2740977407,
0.1986877322,
0.132611379,
0.1190179661,
0.200522393,
-0.0130595304,
0.1401160806,
0.1690885574,
-0.3963015974,
0.0024394486,
1.0081676245,
-0.6211547852,
-0.3815208077,
1.0148950815,
0.1697037518,
0.0158197302,
0.3711234927,
-0.2192768157,
-0.6529580355,
0.0035302257,
0.6728861332,
0.9003152847,
-0.5890034437,
0.3987536132,
0.3970254064,
0.5237218142,
-0.2815965712,
0.2052365392,
0.3082090914,
-0.8992230892,
-0.311401993,
-0.5299855471,
-0.3941659331,
-0.0362565555,
-0.6815942526,
0.4552825093,
-0.2286326587,
-0.4411927462,
-0.2254173607,
-0.3477754295,
-0.7058197856,
0.1687536985,
-0.1648188233,
0.2029520273,
-0.9151408672,
0.4359823763,
0.4606984854,
-0.274828583,
-0.5175178051,
-0.0645038262,
0.2490545809,
-0.7410364747,
0.2683774829,
0.1638393402,
-0.4082190692,
-0.0934320018,
-0.3500294089,
-1.0938527584,
1.0168112516,
0.7411240935,
-0.6229742169,
-0.0820421129,
0.3394826055,
0.2573398948,
-0.4973558486,
0.2823240757,
0.4488214254,
0.7346368432,
-0.110693574,
-0.9177343845,
0.0137462374,
0.0632682294,
-0.202388525,
0.6807453632,
-0.8452581763,
0.7862654924,
-0.3754207194,
-0.086509876,
-0.1643923968,
0.5767704248,
0.0981038958,
0.1910110116,
0.4278476238,
0.8499416709,
0.722581923,
-0.0650644004,
0.6881515384,
-0.5459601283,
0.4278277755,
1.3721381426,
-0.7044106722,
0.5792283416,
0.4623887539,
0.1765498817,
0.3505515456,
0.1819439083,
-0.0745478868,
0.7878696918,
-0.1224753186,
-0.2160904408,
-0.3044095337,
-0.2046539634,
-0.3686076999,
0.4208228886,
-0.0651102141,
-0.2486086339,
-0.2222927213,
0.0123917339,
0.1944303066,
-0.1972870529,
-0.2824201286,
0.8753839135,
-0.230127871,
-0.9184310436,
0.5281455517,
0.2550672889,
0.8523865342,
-0.6584657431,
0.2023513615,
0.055565156,
0.6074894667,
-0.2427107245,
-0.4490303099,
0.2096990198,
-0.0178235527,
-0.482383132,
-0.1777432412,
0.707547009,
-0.8924945593,
-0.6356767416,
0.2467218637,
0.229557246,
-0.3040347993,
0.0044529312,
-0.7759406567,
0.0473212786,
-0.0937856436,
0.003979018,
0.2919453979,
0.0325774923,
0.0927521512,
0.5021356344,
0.321524471,
-0.1544721872,
-0.0906733423,
-0.0888366029,
0.6993600726,
-0.512747705,
-0.0514847934,
-0.9392793775,
0.6888616085,
0.108653456,
-0.436426878,
0.5016614795,
0.7143812776,
0.6478549242,
0.0451997779,
0.7569084167,
0.0679382086,
0.3240189552,
-0.4758555293,
0.4032386839,
-0.6699844003,
-0.0363952443,
-0.3685699701,
-1.227342248,
-0.3764397502,
0.5740597844,
-0.4782100022,
-0.137286976,
0.6687949896,
1.1003149748,
-0.5737825036,
-0.5660334826,
0.0293382443,
-0.4155763388,
0.2666349709,
0.4987480342,
0.551681757,
-0.2412119508,
0.6210689545,
-0.0291190278,
-0.2555257678,
-0.2213806361,
-0.9694826603,
-0.9118779302,
-0.166942969,
-0.3379206657,
-0.1913164705,
0.4124924541,
1.0442501307,
0.5715463758,
-0.9252824783,
-0.2552860081,
0.2795521319,
0.2866668701,
-0.2975592017,
-0.1820957363,
0.3631107509,
-0.4950267673,
-0.8057282567,
0.2573182881,
0.2830356658,
-0.0806892216,
0.2105034739,
-0.5637453198,
-0.1477231234,
0.3134531081,
0.3073460758,
0.42289868,
-0.7847133279,
-0.3464318514,
0.0860612988,
-0.3328595161,
0.2277803719,
0.6381956339,
-0.2748517692,
0.3582377434,
0.212438494,
0.5619571209,
0.2373430282,
0.2229062915,
0.7001659274,
-0.4434251487,
-0.1477733999,
-0.1310081631,
0.3436367214,
0.309468329,
-0.0817387849,
0.332493186,
-0.313133657,
-0.4988662899,
-0.7439763546,
0.2089106143,
-0.7184848189,
-0.0602071285,
1.1204625368,
0.2901222706,
-0.0146579007,
0.1811035275,
-0.3117763698,
0.1009213179,
-0.442573756,
0.6135456562,
0.6053629518,
0.1195422113,
-0.1665648669,
-0.1234937683,
0.2963157594,
0.4331794679,
-0.6590878963,
0.0260957908,
0.5322600603,
0.4187399149,
0.1479200423,
0.6855882406,
-0.0200363286,
0.0719155222,
-0.6137248278,
0.4080792069,
0.1601509899,
-0.5815041065,
-0.405229032,
0.0528073199,
0.0024166191,
-0.1682879627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17135v1
|
Exploring the Generalization of Cancer Clinical Trial Eligibility Classifiers Across Diseases
| 2024-03-25T19:17:59 | 2024-03-25T19:17:59 |
Yumeng Yang, Ashley Gilliam, Ethan B Ludmir, Kirk Roberts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.QM
|
Clinical trials are pivotal in medical research, and NLP can enhance their
success, with application in recruitment. This study aims to evaluate the
generalizability of eligibility classification across a broad spectrum of
clinical trials. Starting with phase 3 cancer trials, annotated with seven
eligibility exclusions, then to determine how well models can generalize to
non-cancer and non-phase 3 trials. To assess this, we have compiled eligibility
criteria data for five types of trials: (1) additional phase 3 cancer trials,
(2) phase 1 and 2 cancer trials, (3) heart disease trials, (4) type 2 diabetes
trials, and (5) observational trials for any disease, comprising 2,490
annotated eligibility criteria across seven exclusion types. Our results show
that models trained on the extensive cancer dataset can effectively handle
criteria commonly found in non-cancer trials, such as autoimmune diseases.
However, they struggle with criteria disproportionately prevalent in cancer
trials, like prior malignancy. We also experiment with few-shot learning,
demonstrating that a limited number of disease-specific examples can partially
overcome this performance gap. We are releasing this new dataset of annotated
eligibility statements to promote the development of cross-disease
generalization in clinical trial classification.
|
[
0.2419308573,
-0.1839911491,
0.6331624389,
0.1024442464,
-0.1063578129,
-0.1733794212,
0.0016113357,
-0.5044011474,
0.1142461598,
0.5484450459,
-0.0826426521,
-0.8869870305,
-1.0691411495,
0.3095205128,
-0.4885756373,
1.2124451399,
-0.0215856545,
0.2738442123,
-0.0781767145,
-0.2255169302,
-0.4106945992,
-0.4255781472,
-0.5372269154,
-0.276827395,
0.8356929421,
0.3887165785,
0.3112623394,
0.5047478676,
0.8577662706,
0.1458933204,
0.133188203,
-0.0211730208,
-0.4913887978,
0.0769976154,
-0.124851115,
-0.8081770539,
-0.2655618489,
0.4802762866,
0.0217989534,
0.8273274899,
-0.2877431512,
-0.0211750958,
0.0068921838,
0.308522135,
-0.6177766919,
0.0595366843,
-0.6061282158,
0.5102294683,
-0.3436180353,
-0.262888521,
-0.320877105,
-0.7446097136,
0.2824243605,
-0.8821625113,
0.8599097133,
-0.0729776919,
0.7884491682,
-0.1461473256,
-0.8099009991,
-0.7536889911,
-0.544796586,
0.4781775177,
-0.4039911032,
-0.1153180376,
0.6570948958,
0.8639703989,
-0.2101436853,
-0.911932528,
0.1238291487,
-0.2649364173,
-0.1404127479,
0.3463690579,
0.0050776871,
0.6311202645,
0.2845595479,
0.7975823879,
-0.884721458,
0.2547676265,
-0.6393145323,
-0.4089883268,
0.7246927619,
0.2369028032,
0.5326371789,
-0.1072655618,
-0.0982245281,
0.2659294009,
-0.6762005687,
0.3297888637,
-0.1544800401,
0.4393294156,
-0.0271412544,
0.9108541608,
-0.4323446155,
0.6739057899,
-0.0917313099,
0.2547696531,
0.0883873403,
-0.4555333257,
-0.159129262,
0.0569755733,
0.6249846816,
0.4527747929,
0.0521076359,
-0.3847270012,
0.114723675,
0.0985387787,
0.3975481093,
-0.4837281704,
-0.2980785966,
0.4438713193,
-0.8827004433,
-0.2122366428,
0.0348437391,
-0.4078070521,
-0.5853819847,
0.2798774242,
0.5721947551,
-0.3517977595,
-0.0216008984,
0.4233829081,
-0.5875276923,
0.2211541981,
0.3110007942,
-0.8422157764,
0.1205020994,
0.6510027647,
0.6229708791,
0.1198449284,
-0.0857457593,
-0.735575974,
0.2216603011,
-0.1052521244,
0.4406745434,
-0.9078979492,
-0.4630803466,
0.0029477139,
0.1792520881,
-0.6934731007,
-0.3627299368,
0.715644598,
-0.3744621575,
0.5359002352,
-0.251069665,
-0.6787167788,
-0.2706929147,
0.1593576968,
-0.460370779,
0.117303662,
0.3529521525,
-0.4998333156,
1.0564819574,
-0.6598332524,
-0.1666587293,
0.3842599392,
-0.2130123079,
-0.558447659,
0.5197429061,
-0.0699309632,
0.4272227585,
-0.5146625638,
0.2509092391,
-0.420915246,
-0.1684906036,
-0.2167314738,
0.2519795001,
0.3439931571,
0.3560983539,
-0.3168042004,
-0.1423621923,
-0.5695259571,
0.0035976116,
-0.0650998354,
-0.2275739163,
-0.3917234242,
0.0228152946,
-0.1274108291,
0.2187464237,
-0.1641497016,
-0.7300710082,
0.3731809556,
-0.5003219247,
0.2055312097,
0.2182917148,
-0.0240087714,
0.0439817011,
-0.2555921674,
0.7727362514,
0.0082540372,
0.597309649,
0.2914377749,
-1.0232315063,
-0.5367152095,
-0.3032377362,
0.7341727018,
0.4753496647,
-0.5890063047,
0.4129619896,
-0.1429830641,
-0.1911710799,
-0.3986286521,
-0.1880054474,
0.5557696223,
0.2759928703,
0.3160312772,
-0.6125632524,
-0.5174813271,
-0.9667267799,
-0.0811096057,
-0.1525838226,
-0.2105185241,
0.3808884621,
0.5604576468,
-0.0859326944,
0.7690893412,
-0.2740887105,
-0.7747561932,
-0.3014543951,
0.1164996848,
0.1951288283,
0.4063899219,
0.5644749403,
-0.7733274698,
-0.2540584505,
0.3042807877,
-0.7978356481,
-0.2369475067,
-0.0905113444,
0.1807409376,
-0.4717481136,
0.0818024203,
-0.1767135859,
0.9663978219,
0.5748282075,
-0.4040782154,
-0.2846490741,
-0.1087354422,
0.3453921676,
-0.5385769606,
0.3120714426,
0.1449857801,
-0.3110615015,
-0.619915545,
-0.2780767679,
0.0232767444,
0.0295297876,
-0.1040277556,
0.1107732579,
-0.205183208,
0.048642695,
-0.1957796216,
-0.2083320916,
-0.0293578003,
-0.21889548,
0.0692680404,
0.0360600352,
0.4448432922,
-0.8048722744,
0.063947618,
0.0874050409,
-0.2437201887,
0.2171957642,
-0.6350082159,
-0.2895147502,
-0.2327078283,
0.4339945912,
-0.8248063922,
-0.4377320707,
0.2404878289,
-0.5689128041,
-0.148341462,
-0.3391951323,
0.0717018321,
-0.6887654066,
0.1270305961,
0.4821963012,
0.3754149675,
-0.0220833384,
0.5598781109,
0.1849626154,
-0.0443763845,
-0.548101306,
-0.8270694017,
-0.2657364905,
-0.4678773284,
-0.0695517808,
0.1674301475,
0.341183424,
0.2052346021,
-0.1136108413,
0.1934134662,
-0.2358077615,
-0.0499466583,
0.3962295353,
-0.176401183,
0.0783869103,
-0.0760606825,
0.0532297269,
0.0779507458,
-0.1408986151,
0.0337392874,
0.3447810411,
0.5626175404,
-0.7289891243,
-0.4627701938,
0.5742810965,
0.035168305,
0.0316992588,
0.2045805305,
0.3836127818,
-0.4895252585,
0.0262347236,
-0.5051956177,
0.0300090183,
-0.3420613706,
0.2542664111,
-0.3790669143,
-1.148675561,
0.6343873143,
0.2567206025,
0.4685045779,
0.8199563026,
0.6744110584,
0.2269656509,
1.0067372322,
0.4708681107,
0.2752218843,
-0.2114965618,
-0.0032658812,
-0.0643094853,
-0.7068867087,
-0.3825288117,
-0.500759542,
-0.4148004055,
-0.4668408334,
-0.4743796587,
0.5180042386,
-0.0423090085,
0.161194697,
0.2373759151,
-0.8743479848,
0.4932435453,
0.1929063499,
0.3267972469,
0.2338436991,
-0.2521354556,
-0.2378804684,
-0.1634164453,
-0.8748533726,
-0.0395107195,
1.8842054605,
0.4327502251,
0.0522049926,
0.2601400912,
1.0380789042,
0.6528486609,
0.708376348,
-0.480925411,
-0.0941988155,
-0.6731277108,
-0.9451320171,
-0.0420056283,
-0.7031593919,
-1.5066697598,
0.1457681954,
-0.1204404831,
-0.4889042675,
0.5688798428,
0.0325123258,
-0.8747401237,
0.0370041952,
-0.5845834017,
0.8321806192,
-0.213360101,
0.349140197,
-0.0678522438,
-0.7478997707,
0.6856999993,
-0.0107253296,
0.1305498034,
-0.3875585198,
0.0302847233,
0.5764430761,
-0.2288810611,
0.7452816367,
-0.3208963275,
0.4354322851,
-0.0225341879,
-0.2232888341,
0.0773844495,
0.2105926275,
-0.0813990161,
0.142056495,
0.1266303807,
-0.5863931775,
-0.3102459311,
0.2611680627,
-0.611630857,
-0.203716293,
-0.6794773936,
-0.3694828749,
-0.2886409461,
0.1917101294,
0.417006433,
0.1651107967,
-0.5007064939,
0.1621383429,
0.4368802905,
-0.4245049059,
-0.0751500055,
0.7366299033,
-0.4100354016,
-0.3854415417,
0.6865679622,
-0.0662723631,
0.3769996166,
0.4774873257,
0.1554802805,
-0.2437280566,
-1.1636853218,
-0.0272802506,
-0.1417373419,
-0.4654383361,
-0.1262233555,
-0.7017143369,
-0.2679949403,
-0.5810505152,
0.0360515602,
0.0178914759,
-0.3634997904,
-0.1673768461,
0.2425854355,
0.0679292306,
0.7613614798,
-0.1850935966,
0.290915966,
-0.6963307261,
0.6258663535,
0.3743207157,
0.212859273,
-0.3458307087,
-0.8271563649,
-0.1534669548,
-0.1589540392,
-0.1150505692,
-0.5195743442,
0.1180599481,
0.6120536923,
0.8936117887,
0.4362377822,
-0.0564948544,
0.5693923831,
-0.1746714711,
0.5907869339,
0.5123716593,
-0.5652673244,
0.6748437881,
-0.4336453676,
-0.1344486922,
0.9417396188,
0.624736011,
-0.7325599194,
-0.4257388413,
-0.5786798,
-0.5405527949,
0.8210876584,
0.5393564105,
-0.2725236714,
-0.0427300893,
0.7317489386,
0.3605442941,
0.0584593751,
-0.5679807067,
0.0161950048,
-0.0658452511,
-0.2645898163,
-0.1540793031,
-0.1645677537,
-0.7789213061,
-0.1232293472,
0.1678796858,
-0.0630972311,
0.1880597323,
0.4673226774,
-0.1348599941,
0.1735901386,
0.2004875392,
0.3833430409,
0.5339370966,
-0.4660663307,
-0.1094145179,
0.0487155691,
-0.6915294528,
-0.017380612,
0.2297424078,
-0.0447962582,
-0.0810738504,
0.4653839171,
0.4437817633,
0.0080638789,
-0.4641599655,
0.6150133014,
-0.4410436749,
-0.5117009282,
0.1563696414,
0.370814532,
-0.3644869924,
0.0786856636,
0.087838456,
-0.3040383458,
0.7126723528,
-0.3880256712,
0.3590544164,
0.6503372192,
-0.5576516986,
-0.1164722815,
0.8782083988,
0.5257151127,
0.1021961197,
0.4865442812,
-0.0670872778,
0.1457446367,
0.7659273148,
0.3723948896,
0.8138517141,
-0.1777649522,
0.3883083165,
0.3447943628,
0.3311803639,
-0.1870989203,
0.1870641857,
0.3319504261,
-0.4072496891,
-0.2249453515,
-0.5599094629,
-0.6405665278,
-0.0011399343,
-0.5710714459,
0.3450325727,
-0.6538489461,
-0.4627123773,
0.4254662693,
-0.2599103451,
-0.537065506,
0.4317410886,
0.412623316,
0.6341534257,
-1.0656663179,
0.7364336252,
0.4647907615,
-0.333522588,
-0.3681878448,
-0.404022783,
0.2415397465,
-0.8046749234,
0.3239992857,
0.3381735086,
0.5969044566,
-0.3395165503,
-0.2235497385,
-0.7543729544,
1.2261638641,
0.1200274676,
-0.6405418515,
-0.2672934234,
0.4132067263,
0.4459201396,
-0.7605798841,
0.3674456179,
0.6020655632,
0.3852590919,
0.3380932808,
-1.3628137112,
-0.3154816926,
-0.1162588596,
0.1666184813,
-0.147265926,
-0.4706191719,
0.5667721033,
-0.0778868347,
-0.0740251243,
0.3996445239,
0.204161942,
0.3760736287,
1.0163217783,
0.4894570112,
0.674847424,
0.7250931263,
-0.4567565322,
1.1181578636,
-0.0740735456,
0.4011021554,
0.5576695204,
-0.3138985634,
-0.0865330175,
-0.1335484982,
-0.4039789736,
0.0973354876,
0.7947239876,
0.0835047141,
0.4542257786,
0.2090471685,
-0.0125437686,
-0.5931735039,
-0.0433426797,
-0.6986938119,
0.4314920604,
0.4469272196,
-0.8383047581,
-0.333539933,
0.1844688654,
-0.3439005911,
-0.2636708617,
-0.179133445,
0.5712844729,
0.1325274557,
-0.3695365489,
0.4177209735,
0.0138231916,
0.4387029707,
-1.0241007805,
0.0239243004,
0.1138581634,
0.1979658157,
-0.5648267269,
-0.5311941504,
0.1746670604,
-0.1488149166,
-0.1998935491,
0.468241781,
0.563071847,
-0.1834519356,
-0.7194315195,
0.1671664864,
0.1931999177,
0.3399389982,
0.2025420517,
-0.8256589174,
-0.0283849929,
0.1006219238,
0.0057404866,
0.4857920706,
0.4216235578,
-0.0693566203,
0.4852674901,
0.5261951089,
0.3654048145,
-0.0461298563,
0.0645617992,
0.5130032301,
-0.7947246432,
-0.1100675836,
-0.605713129,
0.2355280519,
-0.0619457327,
-0.8545635939,
0.80912292,
0.7935910821,
-0.0413358808,
0.3393056095,
0.8475310802,
-0.2319091856,
0.6266607046,
-0.469504565,
0.5800276399,
-0.701833427,
0.0715253502,
-0.0048669758,
-0.4494670331,
-0.7478781343,
0.1670118272,
-0.6677758694,
0.2386508733,
0.5398107171,
0.3465393782,
-0.0991151333,
0.1668028086,
0.3145969212,
-0.0229619648,
0.550137341,
1.1537669897,
0.3801927269,
-0.6121348143,
0.1458747387,
-0.107665211,
-0.5620737076,
-0.385292083,
-0.4588332474,
-0.7205792665,
-0.3153299689,
-0.2936276197,
-0.4046938717,
0.4540981054,
0.5648032427,
0.8884818554,
-0.9290955663,
-0.0351085365,
0.0863447636,
0.0104493359,
-0.1771958619,
-0.1191346645,
0.2046407759,
-0.3709920049,
-0.5914658904,
0.2915876806,
0.3483677804,
-0.1833697408,
0.2973344624,
0.006566775,
-0.2207634002,
-0.1667610407,
0.3547925651,
0.8043603897,
-0.4173983335,
-0.0428532213,
-0.2940786481,
-0.1751078814,
-0.0217622221,
0.9552907348,
-0.590895474,
0.7649191022,
0.1569322348,
0.4007759988,
0.3272798657,
0.0825130343,
0.6148933768,
-0.1327137053,
0.1093319058,
0.6586276293,
0.151721552,
-0.1649751514,
-0.2430574745,
0.5829409957,
0.2988211513,
-0.9490519762,
-0.7818682194,
0.1615466475,
-1.0166817904,
0.0368496217,
1.1191928387,
-0.172364682,
0.1287187785,
-0.8081908226,
0.1817310601,
0.0076480336,
-0.2128682286,
0.9779003263,
0.4138098061,
-0.657553792,
0.0901239738,
-0.6972908974,
0.8694849014,
0.4659605622,
-0.725962162,
0.0137037262,
0.6130552888,
0.3599205017,
-0.1386487633,
1.0926619768,
-0.4272510409,
0.7634430528,
-0.4978741109,
0.2843852341,
0.3426355422,
-0.0530318357,
-0.3276938498,
0.2250125557,
0.0312980488,
-0.1430654824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17125v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17125v1
|
The Strong Pull of Prior Knowledge in Large Language Models and Its Impact on Emotion Recognition
| 2024-03-25T19:07:32 | 2024-03-25T19:07:32 |
Georgios Chochlakis, Alexandros Potamianos, Kristina Lerman, Shrikanth Narayanan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In-context Learning (ICL) has emerged as a powerful paradigm for performing
natural language tasks with Large Language Models (LLM) without updating the
models' parameters, in contrast to the traditional gradient-based finetuning.
The promise of ICL is that the LLM can adapt to perform the present task at a
competitive or state-of-the-art level at a fraction of the cost. The ability of
LLMs to perform tasks in this few-shot manner relies on their background
knowledge of the task (or task priors). However, recent work has found that,
unlike traditional learning, LLMs are unable to fully integrate information
from demonstrations that contrast task priors. This can lead to performance
saturation at suboptimal levels, especially for subjective tasks such as
emotion recognition, where the mapping from text to emotions can differ widely
due to variability in human annotations. In this work, we design experiments
and propose measurements to explicitly quantify the consistency of proxies of
LLM priors and their pull on the posteriors. We show that LLMs have strong yet
inconsistent priors in emotion recognition that ossify their predictions. We
also find that the larger the model, the stronger these effects become. Our
results suggest that caution is needed when using ICL with larger LLMs for
affect-centered tasks outside their pre-training domain and when interpreting
ICL results.
|
[
-0.4978307486,
-0.3175767362,
0.7198228836,
0.0461576805,
-0.2299502045,
-0.2770735919,
-0.4343093038,
-0.592500627,
-0.2430117577,
0.2491006404,
-0.3650621474,
-0.5083627105,
-0.6897867322,
0.1468524486,
-0.1464560479,
1.0450246334,
-0.3111231327,
-0.1331234723,
-0.2870480418,
-0.1398807466,
-0.1606619805,
-0.8175147772,
-0.3519027233,
-0.6102722883,
0.4535434842,
0.4464551508,
0.3562746048,
-0.1074026003,
0.5290803313,
0.2212603539,
-0.1589975953,
-0.0330661908,
-0.5488947034,
0.0934057832,
-0.136096552,
-0.5479761362,
-0.1396446377,
0.2027944922,
0.6669812202,
0.3635386825,
0.0422775783,
-0.2644063234,
0.1962446272,
0.8279670477,
-0.9871320724,
0.0666767135,
-0.6941487789,
0.2622744441,
-0.188224867,
0.0299353674,
-0.4054607153,
-0.1847191006,
0.567370832,
-0.2031268477,
-0.2249396741,
-0.0307778269,
0.9091166258,
0.3980601132,
-0.6097043753,
-0.382273823,
-0.6285555363,
0.6539061069,
-1.0143675804,
0.4439038634,
0.5126097798,
-0.0004724933,
-0.1135350466,
-0.4871902764,
-0.7818273902,
-0.4928779304,
-0.189265281,
0.1449752152,
-0.2923249602,
0.132340461,
0.5804829597,
0.3818499446,
-0.1379184127,
0.3005880713,
0.0480119698,
0.1689099371,
0.4779325724,
0.152765438,
0.1959633976,
0.1270446032,
-0.5393748879,
-0.0111165345,
-0.9928711653,
0.4897548556,
0.165781647,
0.1138871983,
-0.3484456241,
0.3228650987,
-0.1349876076,
0.2404568046,
0.3585267067,
-0.0329948068,
0.2562110424,
0.2734261751,
-0.4227545857,
0.1470898986,
0.7983668447,
0.1423759311,
0.3365217447,
0.0914494172,
-0.2339659333,
-0.0664813295,
0.1905442178,
-0.8364951015,
-0.0396155789,
0.1672229022,
-0.2962433994,
0.3027210832,
0.1308294237,
-0.6509469151,
-0.7024551034,
-0.5469975471,
0.5186560154,
-0.4332700372,
-0.3360429406,
-0.1717184782,
0.2171510458,
0.0800712556,
0.3347448409,
-0.7444128394,
0.344843775,
0.4973372519,
0.7454000711,
-0.3616194427,
-0.3177341819,
-0.4428372979,
-0.193056792,
-0.3347204328,
0.4271770418,
-0.422522366,
-0.1523741335,
0.2032888383,
-0.0066296747,
-0.0571599007,
-0.5925477147,
0.6140466332,
-0.43436867,
-0.2651607096,
-0.4024053514,
-0.6307592392,
-0.1318522245,
0.1987653971,
-0.3803395927,
0.7920206189,
0.0216168538,
-0.8259096146,
0.3981488645,
-0.2316567749,
-0.5240255594,
-0.1213059723,
-0.1214965731,
-0.3443321884,
0.6193045378,
-0.0854270458,
0.732372582,
-0.2053002119,
0.2029533535,
-0.5302169323,
-0.5961766243,
0.4598071277,
-0.2671501637,
0.383729279,
0.0244674534,
-0.6743089557,
-0.0137409139,
-0.5965290666,
-0.4054712951,
-0.1968326122,
-0.3348317444,
-0.6093976498,
0.1451320052,
-0.3844060302,
0.5931788087,
0.1212754473,
-0.5090691447,
0.0724296793,
-0.4706812799,
-0.0150760766,
0.9243930578,
-0.4697248042,
0.5078194141,
0.1436088681,
0.3466632664,
0.3266277313,
-0.2582737803,
-0.1311308742,
0.1401170045,
-0.8546956182,
-0.1619250029,
-0.1452111602,
0.31580019,
-0.3391103745,
0.2860364318,
-0.0438148119,
-0.5083433986,
-0.3380613327,
0.2163691819,
0.4213882089,
0.6993770003,
0.2276712507,
-0.3140436113,
-0.4426479638,
-0.7424875498,
-0.1834773421,
-0.1444763839,
0.1136676818,
0.4599086046,
0.5059747696,
-0.1718139648,
0.80048877,
-0.2103102505,
-0.2788488269,
-0.0846020952,
0.495752722,
0.1756985039,
0.4217303693,
0.334751457,
-0.7375764251,
-0.6386592984,
0.107754007,
-0.7721210122,
-0.1534271985,
0.0534549244,
-0.0274214633,
0.4459232092,
0.590452373,
-0.5743627548,
0.5295907855,
0.6467044353,
-0.1822617352,
0.5046892166,
-0.2300601304,
0.1624372602,
-0.5327519774,
-0.0760302842,
0.4850749373,
0.1023544744,
-0.6353228688,
-0.3246518672,
0.3481056392,
0.1972945929,
-0.6505058408,
0.6812109351,
-0.4849978387,
-0.0990803093,
-0.3730461299,
0.0448324345,
-0.3170324266,
0.501698792,
0.390630126,
0.6143410206,
0.5948049426,
-0.6642943025,
-0.0072543053,
-0.0988704413,
-0.4222498834,
0.9134289622,
-0.3930915892,
0.3012404144,
-0.3075346947,
0.2456746399,
-0.9764502048,
-0.2265173346,
-0.0021948973,
0.0302869584,
0.6296307445,
-0.0180059709,
-0.2735150456,
-0.1566937268,
-0.0540398434,
0.2490773648,
0.6839382052,
-0.6649913788,
0.7806956768,
0.0488765985,
-0.1745448411,
-0.4618048966,
-0.6508231163,
-0.0358921178,
-0.4314529002,
-0.250033021,
0.1841651201,
-0.1678806692,
-0.4864389598,
-0.3666624129,
-0.2011797875,
-0.0957539231,
0.1155914739,
0.6797229648,
0.0332645774,
-0.1821247041,
0.4346390963,
-0.0430719703,
0.0498305075,
0.1149541363,
0.0288020149,
0.1610053778,
-0.2904592454,
-0.348843962,
-0.6697205305,
0.2370628119,
0.7539253831,
-0.1760343462,
0.7204984426,
0.5324062705,
-0.4863954484,
-0.1101348698,
-0.5934979916,
-0.0996476263,
-0.4265480638,
0.2705990672,
-0.3444173038,
-0.9692400694,
0.437913686,
-0.2266542614,
-0.3373676836,
0.3956749141,
0.4874135554,
-0.327806443,
1.0350241661,
0.6719055176,
-0.2143961042,
0.7350474,
0.2439849675,
0.1383451521,
-1.0718255043,
-0.0575774163,
-0.4826853573,
-0.4114439785,
-0.1017048806,
0.173574537,
0.2067263573,
0.2618190646,
-0.5045785308,
-0.1876868159,
-0.0172053333,
0.2924823761,
0.3780732155,
0.1240690276,
-0.0177773833,
-0.179367736,
0.0928780884,
-0.3018241525,
-0.2158633173,
-0.4159092307,
0.8135699034,
0.2619301975,
0.7768990993,
-0.1411634833,
0.4967309833,
-0.0566170327,
0.8041677475,
-0.6429925561,
0.2841151655,
-0.1648588628,
-0.2322381139,
0.0022166837,
-0.2867245972,
-0.702350378,
0.2171142399,
-0.2298175395,
-1.1677672863,
0.2290260941,
0.305711925,
-0.215334177,
0.1900007874,
-0.7305511236,
0.8901790977,
-0.3446063399,
-0.4330228865,
-0.0395518057,
-0.7115393281,
0.3775868416,
-0.1221823096,
0.153995961,
-0.1752608567,
0.1906919032,
0.4188884795,
-0.3591662049,
1.0446068048,
-0.156231299,
-0.2227597386,
0.1458574384,
0.1610935777,
0.7812362313,
-0.2394429594,
-0.1861567199,
0.011855742,
-0.3802710772,
-0.0609381534,
-0.6105052829,
0.7522249818,
-0.6785048842,
-0.6722199321,
-0.2944255769,
-0.5972422957,
-0.3379549384,
0.0506830066,
0.413192749,
0.2884296775,
0.0339679942,
0.3611654043,
0.7658281922,
-0.0796406418,
0.318044275,
0.5515351295,
0.1604582518,
-0.0750074759,
0.6387693882,
0.178477183,
0.3906135559,
0.3693398237,
0.2360806167,
-0.1950230151,
-0.5703123212,
0.1074713171,
0.0761362687,
-0.8513611555,
-0.1623019725,
-0.5936591625,
0.1782197356,
-0.2590842545,
-0.3834719062,
-0.2901120186,
0.3002108335,
-0.5671519041,
-0.2274044007,
0.1975753307,
0.7240085006,
0.0179286133,
0.2992777824,
-0.6390011907,
-0.0214175712,
0.356174618,
0.3516486585,
0.2051062882,
-0.5370320082,
-0.402484417,
0.0269578621,
-0.2432866544,
-0.8755216002,
0.3866569698,
0.288824439,
0.3550492227,
0.5928592682,
0.1845721006,
0.606100738,
-0.3605589271,
0.7937045693,
0.1643234044,
-1.342132926,
0.4826392233,
-0.11713548,
0.4487078488,
0.543721199,
0.7317636013,
-0.3728291094,
-0.4839025438,
-0.5779114366,
-0.8417782784,
0.8095067739,
-0.0713430047,
0.1805244237,
0.0205446612,
0.4261409044,
0.0039926856,
0.2553375959,
-0.8040866852,
-0.0100803236,
0.0274410117,
-0.4818207026,
-0.3314621449,
-0.3827712536,
0.1347560138,
-0.2372176647,
0.4262855947,
-0.1107420847,
-0.0786219835,
0.4585991204,
-0.287609905,
-0.3230268657,
0.2365401834,
0.6136248708,
0.351582557,
-0.3266379535,
0.5114514232,
0.4467406273,
-0.2124583423,
0.0455573499,
0.0499697514,
0.1777848154,
-0.2285129875,
0.4705098569,
1.0609186888,
0.4328732193,
-0.8993317485,
0.6669843197,
0.1313471347,
0.0969085693,
-0.1529334784,
-0.0805550665,
-0.106178157,
0.5032055378,
0.37509197,
-0.0346627049,
0.0248150937,
-0.6575247645,
0.1164404973,
0.4572637081,
-0.9496747851,
-0.5028270483,
0.3448171616,
-0.1956860572,
-0.1443903744,
0.5139853358,
-0.0718931556,
-0.7399778366,
0.6210512519,
0.5641030073,
0.8318996429,
-0.346621424,
-0.2095083147,
0.2087652534,
-0.0018245726,
-0.3473432064,
0.012195576,
-0.1207761988,
-0.7180339098,
-0.245584771,
-0.3815808296,
-0.4687556922,
-0.0704161972,
-0.5375215411,
0.2613377869,
-0.3807865679,
-0.0759464428,
-0.4446024299,
-0.1756847799,
-0.9141622186,
0.5165439248,
0.5078263879,
0.7205588222,
-0.8103926778,
0.6988964677,
0.7166284919,
-0.2802526355,
-0.900970161,
0.1503781229,
0.1418324411,
-0.2555249333,
1.0075320005,
0.3862411082,
-0.0649813414,
-0.1403131634,
-0.6929565072,
-0.7788516283,
0.8922314644,
0.512055099,
-0.6595353484,
0.1886959374,
-0.2389797866,
0.8343105912,
-0.570512712,
0.4660000801,
0.3357430995,
0.2800998986,
0.1979251504,
-0.8122152686,
0.0618701838,
-0.0442275293,
-0.3231359422,
0.2297070622,
-0.4857180119,
1.0153621435,
-0.1795082241,
-0.2627259195,
-0.2673282325,
0.8141077757,
0.25263533,
0.4211881459,
0.4919454753,
0.4711433649,
0.7307380438,
-0.1266963631,
1.3114173412,
-0.0656770244,
0.3559094071,
1.1235283613,
-0.6921194792,
1.1244401932,
0.5175514221,
-0.0593018308,
0.5311469436,
0.5821803212,
0.4357060194,
0.5231733322,
0.2099121362,
-0.1984518021,
-0.3045179844,
-0.2267874777,
-0.2049686611,
0.1987567693,
0.3436361253,
-0.4358299077,
0.081787549,
0.157461971,
0.2169064283,
-0.0548735783,
-0.5097083449,
0.745313406,
0.4486175776,
-0.6780789495,
0.5843868256,
-0.6228179932,
0.9201327562,
-0.624322474,
0.0331353322,
-0.1667009145,
0.2609367371,
-0.3381925821,
-0.7910205722,
0.1007685065,
0.0162987411,
-0.0089809783,
-0.0983094573,
0.7573035955,
-0.5536623001,
-0.1434699893,
0.4472501278,
0.1763485521,
0.0164688472,
-0.269612968,
-0.1935374439,
0.182846576,
-0.3417567015,
-0.516079545,
0.5888619423,
0.7005130053,
0.2010538578,
0.5197692513,
0.3173936307,
0.0100612249,
-0.1911774129,
-0.0912407711,
0.7096818686,
-0.4540711343,
-0.323574096,
-1.0694749355,
0.8122988343,
0.0760887414,
-0.565792501,
0.5443204045,
0.0152504873,
0.8414624929,
0.0872475654,
0.6167247295,
0.2928373516,
0.0733500421,
-0.623565793,
0.4481717944,
-0.9188659191,
-0.088435851,
-0.7634466887,
-0.633620739,
-0.2980585992,
0.5769726038,
-0.6019663811,
-0.1477917582,
0.7079946995,
0.3358849883,
0.0467290692,
0.0370248146,
0.3219806552,
0.4589394629,
0.2068949342,
0.8086712956,
0.9840242863,
0.0524754338,
0.1221776307,
-0.2010253966,
-0.220634982,
-0.3087616861,
-1.1248714924,
-0.8925849795,
-0.5946780443,
-0.3273309469,
-0.1694284379,
0.0462482199,
1.120577693,
0.5903089643,
-0.6715254188,
-0.0847104713,
-0.034450803,
0.1476257443,
-0.1865858585,
-0.1781247854,
0.3476461172,
-0.3187824488,
-0.7628381252,
0.1609577537,
0.4989053309,
0.2179860324,
0.082615383,
-0.259988457,
0.019891683,
-0.0571755841,
0.6436288953,
0.3889046013,
-0.7731162906,
-0.3843374848,
-0.3587314188,
-0.3223708272,
0.2642119825,
0.7807677984,
-0.7059869766,
0.3152829707,
0.441426605,
0.6574562192,
0.4456300735,
-0.1576783061,
0.6419020295,
-0.625618279,
0.1005040258,
0.166603595,
0.7209890485,
0.3538652658,
-0.4688176215,
0.2994419932,
-0.1223075762,
-0.5660958886,
-0.6981562972,
0.3474594057,
-0.7696248293,
-0.0598934926,
1.1352357864,
-0.5657886863,
0.0072229984,
0.2249697,
-0.3774222732,
0.1245980486,
-0.5074082613,
0.6516110301,
0.9544036984,
-0.2202711254,
-0.4176023602,
-0.2493300289,
0.6445908546,
0.5343223214,
-0.7291423082,
0.1565674841,
0.4901485145,
-0.0707677454,
0.0563004762,
0.5598583221,
0.1375190765,
0.0507615209,
-0.4457205534,
0.1836663783,
0.2173175365,
-0.2207233757,
-0.6422432661,
0.3397288918,
0.1451774985,
0.4360455275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17124v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17124v2
|
Grounding Language Plans in Demonstrations Through Counterfactual Perturbations
| 2024-03-25T19:04:59 | 2024-04-29T04:34:52 |
Yanwei Wang, Tsun-Hsuan Wang, Jiayuan Mao, Michael Hagenow, Julie Shah
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Grounding the common-sense reasoning of Large Language Models (LLMs) in
physical domains remains a pivotal yet unsolved problem for embodied AI.
Whereas prior works have focused on leveraging LLMs directly for planning in
symbolic spaces, this work uses LLMs to guide the search of task structures and
constraints implicit in multi-step demonstrations. Specifically, we borrow from
manipulation planning literature the concept of mode families, which group
robot configurations by specific motion constraints, to serve as an abstraction
layer between the high-level language representations of an LLM and the
low-level physical trajectories of a robot. By replaying a few human
demonstrations with synthetic perturbations, we generate coverage over the
demonstrations' state space with additional successful executions as well as
counterfactuals that fail the task. Our explanation-based learning framework
trains an end-to-end differentiable neural network to predict successful
trajectories from failures and as a by-product learns classifiers that ground
low-level states and images in mode families without dense labeling. The
learned grounding classifiers can further be used to translate language plans
into reactive policies in the physical domain in an interpretable manner. We
show our approach improves the interpretability and reactivity of imitation
learning through 2D navigation and simulated and real robot manipulation tasks.
Website: https://yanweiw.github.io/glide
|
[
-0.193103686,
-0.8532914519,
0.7897862792,
0.1075204462,
-0.1491303146,
-0.1417848915,
0.011113245,
0.1927470863,
0.3109655082,
0.6044011712,
-0.8691771626,
-0.5075117946,
-0.551250875,
-0.3063854575,
-0.3758574426,
0.6784031987,
-0.4138659537,
-0.2022452503,
-0.0948117971,
-0.0026388799,
-0.3508377075,
-0.4942705631,
-0.3076811433,
-0.8370853662,
0.3636945784,
0.4389759302,
0.7459001541,
0.4864068031,
-0.260025233,
0.3454484642,
0.0554447249,
0.4715826213,
-0.525837183,
0.1191634014,
-0.1080762073,
-0.5003971457,
-0.1420588344,
0.0132152615,
0.4393357635,
0.7666349411,
-0.0560647137,
-0.4777176678,
-0.1894313395,
0.5408521891,
-0.5036256909,
0.4009123743,
-0.4666399062,
0.3813532889,
0.4752692878,
-0.4114567041,
-0.5155618787,
0.1796668172,
-0.1758750826,
-0.736507833,
0.0220594704,
-0.1132504791,
0.850425601,
0.5064658523,
-0.3004813492,
0.0388942957,
-0.9284424782,
0.7210144997,
-0.3007705808,
0.4864835739,
0.3817269206,
0.3216643035,
-0.6939272881,
-0.5520918965,
-0.7916249633,
-0.2903581858,
-0.2344061881,
0.2088850141,
-0.1640940309,
0.3520611823,
0.4264684618,
-0.0615321249,
-0.463118434,
0.0427609049,
-0.0544290319,
-0.1584301144,
0.3539334536,
0.1889306754,
0.4181794226,
0.094503738,
-0.3510905504,
-0.1945894361,
-0.9192152023,
0.129489705,
0.221889019,
0.1113861501,
-0.3338135183,
0.6052079797,
-0.3301453292,
0.6197313666,
0.2739936411,
0.0866637304,
-0.0222233292,
0.0180927198,
-0.3604759574,
-0.1198051721,
0.5431257486,
0.374343127,
0.1507471949,
-0.332321614,
-0.2665058672,
0.137226522,
0.3614028394,
-0.6055686474,
-0.0578942113,
0.1929821223,
-0.399635464,
-0.0568575002,
-0.1247824207,
-0.6385272145,
-0.5010221004,
-0.6786231399,
0.5629289746,
-0.3875244558,
-0.0809923783,
0.4364961982,
-0.1602907032,
0.2447340339,
0.5056390166,
-0.7042831182,
0.3185683489,
0.6918182373,
0.6744904518,
0.2668454349,
-0.5831544995,
-0.679089427,
0.4089908302,
-0.4652382433,
0.6586236358,
-0.5066413879,
-0.4789546132,
0.104915686,
0.075955078,
-0.2270559818,
-0.3373585939,
0.1433603764,
-0.3699391782,
0.1432351023,
-0.1413055658,
-0.3721675873,
-0.5659019947,
0.4138805866,
-0.4319429398,
0.5891953111,
0.0240824334,
-0.350074172,
0.3408899307,
-0.5597734451,
-0.7895845771,
-0.3309274018,
-0.5520544052,
-0.2764290273,
0.0140606612,
0.1812250912,
0.7147548199,
0.0442593694,
0.3401456177,
-0.022819614,
-0.5503942966,
-0.0775727555,
-0.350055933,
0.4910651743,
-0.1491744071,
-0.8462448716,
0.697684586,
-0.6290877461,
-0.3094529808,
0.1098115742,
-0.163703382,
-0.0894694403,
0.4123252332,
-0.38875705,
0.4432161748,
0.0621074103,
-0.0783375353,
0.2372380197,
-0.5888212919,
0.340620935,
0.6702004075,
0.0682578385,
0.5627686977,
-0.4929094017,
0.6871401072,
0.0303314812,
0.1142924875,
-0.3434705436,
-0.273091495,
-0.7698228955,
-0.0440073572,
-0.48608163,
0.4050707221,
-0.8689917922,
0.4230828881,
-0.2313126326,
-0.2754488289,
0.0554730035,
0.0543733314,
0.5480614305,
0.6382270455,
0.5739879012,
0.1307682991,
-0.5105164051,
-0.9263932109,
0.0635459945,
-0.2257611603,
-0.0279291365,
0.2460086495,
0.3851887286,
-0.3437958062,
0.7227618098,
-0.1192016825,
-0.0840605125,
-0.4621704519,
0.4109060764,
0.0919232294,
0.3499726653,
0.5002748966,
-0.9796532393,
-0.1192148253,
-0.0258239415,
-0.6695199609,
0.0990768224,
-0.5702365041,
-0.1704759896,
0.2227215916,
0.5557676554,
-0.7480484843,
0.5104362965,
0.4730156362,
-0.3086654842,
0.5296651125,
-0.2325184494,
0.0712758824,
-0.7709497213,
-0.1977592409,
-0.0875427723,
-0.137088865,
-0.5215799212,
0.324432224,
-0.2664743364,
0.0963257253,
-0.496855557,
0.5505472422,
-0.3523262143,
-0.2001485676,
-0.3035086989,
0.1721905172,
-0.0112846717,
0.8092600107,
0.4245060384,
0.6482114196,
0.653098166,
-0.74816221,
0.0308975801,
0.0866300836,
0.1283110529,
0.209299475,
-0.5654078722,
0.1659764647,
-0.1636963636,
0.6425204277,
-0.9561306238,
-0.2179148197,
0.3925617039,
-0.1664371192,
0.1998472363,
-0.5255557895,
-0.3635786176,
-0.0087402435,
-0.1631523371,
-0.0688296556,
0.6046679616,
-0.6425623298,
1.1285517216,
0.2359722704,
0.5624316335,
-0.6002961993,
-0.499022305,
-0.0406261273,
-0.2437312901,
-0.4496838748,
0.3420388103,
-0.0215815734,
-0.396849066,
-0.3405666649,
-0.308409214,
0.1006310657,
0.3011395931,
0.8003490567,
0.0156416371,
-0.1556322873,
-0.1436399817,
0.4282311797,
-0.1802705526,
0.3378099799,
-0.2303030491,
0.8533377051,
-0.1006165296,
-0.424957484,
-0.4609898031,
0.1788844466,
0.6896867752,
0.205622524,
0.5610948801,
0.2200476378,
-0.3745324314,
-0.2824725509,
-0.0804835781,
-0.2540066242,
-0.484262675,
0.215971753,
-0.6138417125,
-0.3953186274,
0.4609487355,
-0.450384587,
0.2307763994,
0.2098493576,
0.4516036212,
-0.1692163795,
0.9287360311,
0.5576197505,
-0.0002950139,
0.3372344673,
-0.5817545056,
-0.0759144053,
-0.4672918916,
-0.2938885093,
-0.2470313162,
-0.6586064696,
-0.1797955483,
-0.8056911826,
0.291867733,
0.2532807887,
-0.4214426577,
0.3404279351,
-0.1105178371,
0.4860506654,
0.3401269913,
0.2468973398,
0.079503417,
0.2329196483,
-0.3690977693,
0.0726581812,
-0.612443924,
-0.7446343899,
0.634352386,
0.1292938143,
0.649828732,
-0.1014939398,
0.796315968,
-0.0853073224,
0.3148795962,
-0.8999221325,
0.7828236222,
-0.3726371825,
-0.2027952373,
-0.4403874874,
-0.1601115763,
-0.8221769333,
0.2919078469,
-0.1777502298,
-0.6269150376,
0.0960141793,
0.4008071423,
-0.0716585889,
0.3769476116,
-0.4549272358,
0.7248973846,
-0.3607215881,
-0.4667435884,
-0.6498716474,
-0.7745607495,
0.1966843009,
0.3786072433,
0.3300352097,
0.1602396965,
0.1097231805,
0.3241585493,
-0.2112147957,
1.2356888056,
-0.4436698556,
-0.1933124065,
0.1731380671,
0.6611617208,
0.5739191771,
-0.1178110689,
-0.0186371077,
0.1632446796,
-0.5560602546,
-0.1913205385,
-0.8771821856,
0.6354682446,
-0.7184119821,
-0.6963644624,
0.1393597722,
-0.5569996834,
-0.3843531907,
0.1258240491,
0.1188285202,
0.4627195597,
-0.082361646,
0.1042549461,
0.7901365161,
-0.2695993185,
0.3251669407,
0.429076165,
-0.3488702476,
0.1329202503,
0.7865234017,
-0.1851192266,
0.2364745438,
0.8979179859,
0.4800349772,
-0.2046534568,
-0.4647680223,
-0.6747629642,
-0.0245497245,
-0.7846440673,
0.2087755054,
-0.7101949453,
-0.006845329,
-0.1206582859,
-0.5602147579,
-0.2549668252,
-0.5180494785,
-0.2244240195,
-0.3437030911,
0.0483095609,
0.7659853697,
0.0364070572,
0.4099124074,
-0.4034623504,
0.6311203241,
0.217081964,
0.0196095034,
-0.1383214295,
-0.5135751963,
0.0962162837,
0.2562341988,
-0.3095529974,
-0.6817910671,
0.3064931631,
0.0431940965,
0.767260313,
0.428106755,
-0.0083727697,
0.9182538986,
-0.6199688315,
0.7816361189,
0.147108078,
-0.8901293874,
0.7740588784,
-0.3450519145,
-0.0023054669,
0.1044797599,
0.6967263222,
-0.498505652,
-0.3679478765,
-0.6129549742,
-0.9087780714,
0.3831528425,
-0.1061503813,
0.3380890787,
0.1638783813,
0.4826941788,
0.1939727515,
0.1387818009,
-0.7170522809,
-0.4236337543,
-0.4352333248,
-0.0656448305,
-0.138581425,
-0.043127425,
-0.4499049485,
-0.0642374679,
0.5117225051,
-0.3795959651,
0.126340583,
0.1725628972,
-0.29413113,
-0.3504568636,
0.0811060071,
1.0080984831,
0.4727362096,
0.2094798386,
0.3465905488,
-0.1362554729,
-0.0405981354,
0.2199673802,
-0.0037840039,
-0.289631784,
-0.1225624979,
0.4631657004,
0.8849924207,
0.4362006187,
-0.6876773834,
0.2206114382,
0.160322994,
-0.4802850187,
-0.2807324529,
0.2759840488,
-0.0918384418,
0.2778223753,
0.1727408618,
-0.0010668848,
0.0025830225,
-0.5666725636,
0.3106401861,
0.3417622149,
-0.4429361522,
-0.5824250579,
0.6323068738,
-0.0461857058,
-0.4298725426,
0.4199432135,
-0.0678595603,
-0.7769007683,
0.6643090844,
0.4788495898,
0.7681558728,
0.0993964076,
0.404761672,
0.2276111692,
0.3188685179,
-0.1175510287,
0.378026247,
-0.1375342458,
-0.9682862163,
-0.5256685019,
-0.2185407132,
-0.3201231956,
0.2249115109,
-0.1686079651,
0.3390364349,
-0.7620114684,
0.4732411504,
-0.415173471,
-0.3286859095,
-0.3548747599,
0.1285667866,
0.1149419546,
0.665512383,
-1.0428879261,
0.6471530795,
0.9214038849,
-0.5297700763,
-0.9362774491,
0.2442838699,
-0.0043650363,
-0.9062127471,
0.9798075557,
0.1342803538,
-0.6935982108,
-0.2507946491,
-0.7388767004,
-0.4153942764,
0.7743366957,
0.4965535402,
-0.5504202247,
-0.0300916042,
-0.1542920768,
0.5713829398,
-0.2255167067,
0.0223835129,
0.1756790131,
0.5855385065,
0.1573096365,
-0.6392775178,
0.1729125381,
0.0422109142,
-0.5111821294,
0.152296111,
-0.6299811602,
0.5432690382,
-0.2861783206,
-0.1121402979,
-0.028880246,
0.524138391,
0.567710042,
0.4778611958,
0.8359884024,
0.5116513371,
0.2546855509,
0.0767648593,
1.0869444609,
-0.1705162525,
-0.0204966012,
1.0656088591,
-0.3128342032,
0.6854100227,
0.6868713498,
0.0022245971,
0.8163803816,
0.3507156074,
0.5317363143,
0.4196601808,
0.3534504473,
-0.0602734908,
-0.5783597827,
0.1294658482,
0.1008823514,
0.3922918439,
0.6516750455,
-0.1257753223,
-0.3723745048,
0.0293396022,
0.0206550937,
0.5541537404,
-0.2073766887,
0.5042142868,
-0.1286527961,
-0.6047180295,
0.5581044555,
-0.1476483792,
0.4066832662,
-0.4731146693,
-0.6121099591,
-0.2790413201,
-0.0630113482,
-0.1153489426,
-0.5839654803,
0.2730033696,
-0.4912509024,
-0.1088026688,
-0.7401756048,
0.5456883907,
-0.2475359142,
0.0181656592,
0.3803162873,
0.3309285939,
0.2696861327,
0.0604179353,
-0.6356680989,
-0.114009358,
-0.126219511,
-0.3124064207,
0.391543746,
0.4092122614,
-0.3062048554,
0.8603140116,
0.3486408889,
-0.1223402768,
0.0894557238,
0.2018413544,
0.9309610724,
-0.4501932263,
-0.4158459604,
-0.60313344,
0.5529063344,
0.2793895602,
-0.0445978455,
0.3920835853,
0.4029892087,
0.8481812477,
-0.097470209,
0.4577236474,
0.0289181676,
0.1361383051,
-0.9399735332,
0.5242971778,
-0.608595252,
0.217760548,
0.0603985861,
-0.5035737753,
-0.3467905521,
1.0060095787,
-0.3434408009,
-0.0220686235,
0.4275339842,
0.7282735109,
-0.1830129921,
-0.3247718811,
0.6496922374,
0.3513477147,
0.5074193478,
0.3785318136,
0.9438582659,
-0.1741263866,
0.2758261263,
-0.5319871306,
-0.0690649524,
-0.1173498109,
-0.9396276474,
-0.8084036112,
-0.6046561003,
-0.2915273011,
-0.2372494191,
0.1887951493,
1.1131694317,
0.9684022665,
-0.6117058396,
-0.3905907869,
-0.5371415019,
0.4238310456,
-0.4360885322,
-0.2212851048,
0.1379711926,
-0.3727777898,
-0.7216941714,
1.059579134,
0.1924662739,
0.0619110428,
-0.3554463089,
-0.4521954358,
-0.2066540718,
-0.1575659961,
0.6678677797,
0.4471097291,
-0.9143164158,
-0.3351447284,
-0.0805549994,
0.1475300342,
-0.049325496,
1.1230875254,
-0.9933726788,
0.2524609566,
0.2750757933,
0.4914170206,
0.4505032301,
-0.1420265883,
0.7641138434,
-0.8898332715,
0.4364781678,
0.1327848136,
0.5541542172,
-0.1535425931,
-0.375208348,
0.4622723162,
0.2332582772,
-0.1964343339,
-0.5436173081,
0.4743674695,
-0.9184604883,
-0.4335920215,
1.3111679554,
-0.2541327775,
-0.1479791254,
-0.1691825837,
-0.3388436735,
0.2910700142,
-0.2281138003,
0.8713293076,
0.4695213735,
-0.3717213571,
-0.2920544147,
-0.372564435,
0.2768290341,
0.3846209943,
-0.6721445918,
0.1147562489,
0.7803243399,
0.0453078076,
0.2499404699,
0.3402841091,
0.0417390727,
0.2810065746,
-0.1582989693,
0.1335832924,
-0.1719026119,
-0.6932113767,
-0.4743180871,
0.0683637559,
-0.1119857803,
-0.1190438941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.17104v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.17104v2
|
Attribute First, then Generate: Locally-attributable Grounded Text Generation
| 2024-03-25T18:41:47 | 2024-04-01T17:57:40 |
Aviv Slobodkin, Eran Hirsch, Arie Cattan, Tal Schuster, Ido Dagan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent efforts to address hallucinations in Large Language Models (LLMs) have
focused on attributed text generation, which supplements generated texts with
citations of supporting sources for post-generation fact-checking and
corrections. Yet, these citations often point to entire documents or
paragraphs, burdening users with extensive verification work. In this paper, we
introduce a locally-attributable text generation approach, prioritizing concise
attributions. Our method, named ``Attribute First, then Generate'', breaks down
the conventional end-to-end generation process into three intuitive steps:
content selection, sentence planning, and sequential sentence generation. By
initially identifying relevant source segments (``select first'') and then
conditioning the generation process on them (``then generate''), we ensure
these segments also act as the output's fine-grained attributions (``select''
becomes ``attribute''). Tested on Multi-document Summarization and Long-form
Question-answering, our method not only yields more concise citations than the
baselines but also maintains - and in some cases enhances - both generation
quality and attribution accuracy. Furthermore, it significantly reduces the
time required for fact verification by human assessors.
|
[
-0.2259206921,
-0.7188631892,
0.928604424,
0.0871758014,
-0.236843124,
-0.0154648237,
-0.1468576044,
-0.2494354844,
0.1553810686,
0.6342613101,
-0.6710750461,
-0.1304568797,
-0.211480543,
0.1580850482,
-0.3444614112,
1.1558235884,
0.0115469899,
-0.5799704194,
-0.6881492734,
0.0388048068,
-0.1530701816,
-0.6730680466,
-0.7403300405,
-0.4486303031,
0.799895227,
0.685333252,
0.6642345786,
0.5617292523,
0.4068057239,
0.3247206509,
0.0792784691,
0.5244060159,
-0.3961609602,
0.3506111801,
-0.1157272011,
-0.2296801656,
-0.343116492,
-0.0794158652,
0.5043722391,
0.4220691919,
0.1512024254,
0.4055448771,
-0.0440424606,
0.4495277405,
-0.7781579494,
-0.3508420587,
-0.9504904747,
-0.2855885029,
-0.3123987913,
-0.5258290172,
-0.5359845161,
-0.7346514463,
-0.0517134666,
-0.3071334958,
0.4768252671,
0.0974860862,
0.8630803823,
0.1676181853,
-0.5666747689,
-0.1537101567,
-0.34741956,
0.7989269495,
-0.4736189842,
0.0516499355,
0.3755604625,
-0.0892057121,
-0.1695971936,
-0.9390485883,
-0.5857254863,
-0.3412171602,
-0.4533080161,
-0.1399620026,
-0.0435143821,
-0.3298410773,
0.2403166741,
0.3271001279,
-0.3857658207,
-0.0900873393,
-0.2587970793,
-0.3928761482,
0.7409845591,
0.0469847061,
-0.1881357133,
-0.4884308577,
-0.2088763565,
-0.123919107,
-1.2338020802,
-0.1471826136,
0.2754483223,
0.3120631576,
0.3098495007,
0.7948147058,
-0.2680572569,
0.3114233613,
0.299043864,
-0.2237885147,
0.0999385267,
-0.6127253175,
-0.0129835848,
0.4834725261,
0.8967579603,
0.1907561123,
0.0969883725,
-0.1816981286,
-0.1502773613,
-0.0861879513,
0.3949531615,
-0.9999043941,
-0.2104417533,
0.1873491406,
-0.2783574164,
-0.8020929098,
-0.1157427207,
-0.2335993946,
-0.5649189353,
-0.4437376857,
0.1347349882,
-0.3189168572,
-0.0382324941,
-0.4937108457,
0.4525502324,
0.0669131503,
0.0416884683,
-0.5618798733,
-0.0377085358,
0.4024042785,
0.8232433796,
-0.2668719888,
-0.2206912041,
-0.9145840406,
0.4028722644,
-0.2364981771,
1.0416585207,
-0.1551418751,
-0.0685917661,
0.118466869,
-0.3613068461,
0.620415628,
-0.4431031048,
0.6442266703,
-0.321916759,
0.2348446101,
-0.4478676915,
-0.2713471055,
0.3079099655,
0.0184555259,
-0.4876294732,
1.3182410002,
0.1253138334,
-0.951779604,
0.5883411765,
-0.3362458646,
-0.9341259003,
-0.1158375815,
-0.2290490866,
-0.5744654536,
0.4078664482,
0.2749048769,
0.7703505158,
-0.4482899904,
0.6215013862,
0.0729439557,
0.3685746193,
0.3119837344,
-0.1986026913,
0.4138121009,
0.3606871367,
-0.2719617486,
0.406064868,
-1.2134073973,
0.1734342277,
0.1873218417,
-0.2089479268,
-0.3325019181,
0.3592331111,
0.0508912392,
0.1280980855,
0.10410247,
-0.3909789324,
-0.0672656819,
-0.2419075221,
0.3638869226,
0.826135993,
0.3212195039,
0.5536278486,
-0.2601451278,
0.1414594203,
0.005954416,
-0.2675442398,
-0.4928775728,
-0.0512352809,
-0.8356029391,
-0.2371639907,
-0.2248434573,
0.3349240422,
-0.8107408881,
0.675927043,
-0.467217505,
-0.6402406096,
-0.1524416357,
0.0408252999,
0.4437483251,
0.6130607724,
0.1952244937,
0.0340056568,
-0.5583667755,
-0.8465522528,
-0.2096407264,
-0.4390621781,
-0.2757470012,
0.0809202343,
0.4105999172,
0.0198329482,
1.1958495378,
-0.8933932781,
-0.2322743535,
-0.3053969443,
0.608366549,
-0.147841379,
0.4796238542,
0.4336324632,
-0.579339087,
-0.3462851048,
-0.0885467902,
-0.5571678877,
-0.5502038002,
-0.518340826,
-0.4224565923,
0.2200645953,
0.5727713108,
-0.685020566,
0.0418892726,
-0.0399112776,
-0.4198947251,
0.3416488171,
-0.0281876344,
0.1249534115,
-1.2532765865,
0.1275215745,
-0.3060920835,
-0.5000472665,
-0.4339895844,
0.2054434866,
-0.1396018267,
-0.1676155776,
-0.2929169834,
0.4095334411,
-0.6251402497,
0.0336486511,
-0.2067069262,
0.1903067529,
0.1677697599,
0.2532251179,
-0.0069663837,
0.8430356383,
0.2172035575,
-0.6745723486,
0.2220290005,
0.2257695794,
-0.4114699364,
0.6359496713,
-0.4688231647,
0.2788664103,
-0.1966045946,
0.1085947677,
-0.7833734751,
-0.3448636532,
-0.155842647,
-0.3887114227,
0.2112715095,
0.4718134999,
-0.6267512441,
-0.1253172606,
-0.4559469819,
0.3564450443,
0.2884016037,
-0.4626547396,
0.6557438374,
0.2728362083,
-0.3933087587,
0.0047292383,
-0.5134281516,
0.0160414912,
-0.2002181858,
-0.727627337,
0.4430911839,
0.0547809787,
-0.3207263649,
-0.1977672279,
0.0284885913,
-0.0058357776,
0.2570246756,
0.0416635722,
-0.1088834852,
-0.3037588,
-0.0711878464,
0.1297886074,
-0.0963981748,
0.0781157166,
0.0055498113,
0.3119752109,
0.1934418827,
-0.2157989591,
-0.0585499965,
0.6696174741,
0.4540345073,
-0.4673896432,
0.5878165364,
0.4387176037,
-0.1953055859,
-0.1630934775,
-0.586171329,
-0.4458126128,
-0.4577532113,
0.3412654698,
-0.3770283163,
-0.6684137583,
0.5520118475,
0.0736816078,
0.3088609278,
0.4678936303,
0.7486989498,
0.0959280953,
0.6762558818,
0.5674440861,
0.0058229151,
0.4520024657,
0.2224308997,
0.4946647584,
-0.3943273723,
-0.1169439405,
-0.6558900476,
0.0017287706,
-0.2647294104,
-0.3584721684,
0.2793688178,
0.0252660196,
-0.2939632237,
0.2044059634,
-0.5053304434,
0.5268450975,
0.6050972939,
0.0809650645,
0.2576590478,
0.3424707949,
0.0734673813,
-0.327124387,
-0.4321441054,
-0.5429216623,
1.0474646091,
-0.0539931767,
0.5825327635,
0.1907666773,
0.8595081568,
0.2864157856,
0.7280198336,
-0.4936174154,
0.6099281907,
0.1873001158,
-0.3405166268,
-0.1020194218,
-0.3590413034,
-0.6477614045,
0.0715082586,
-0.338396579,
-0.6865343451,
-0.194017157,
0.2408460975,
-0.5443378687,
-0.0483051054,
-0.5760306716,
0.54034096,
-0.1716179401,
-0.7766244411,
-0.0029844532,
-0.5175646544,
0.5527194142,
-0.3890970945,
0.1448541582,
0.1325160563,
0.2550540864,
0.3994563818,
-0.4361201227,
0.4606198072,
0.0237123575,
-0.3815692067,
0.5225477815,
0.2736967802,
0.8590307236,
0.0991214812,
-0.0761301666,
-0.3777591288,
-0.5596780181,
0.0682394207,
-0.516937077,
0.6705895066,
-0.4405179322,
-0.5307919979,
-0.433206439,
-0.3181931376,
-0.0174669437,
0.2911989987,
0.6046857834,
0.5519772768,
-0.090561986,
0.3931232691,
0.695887506,
-0.151134938,
0.1973028332,
0.2702536881,
-0.2197936326,
-0.6699163914,
0.9654039741,
-0.0624682084,
0.3575996459,
0.3305044472,
0.0691214353,
-0.2532978058,
-0.3904406726,
-0.0692924634,
0.068574287,
-0.7709105611,
-0.6182118058,
-0.7375786901,
-0.1814984083,
-0.5507404208,
-0.6587502956,
-0.3897550404,
-0.2912669778,
-0.3676582575,
-0.2295671999,
0.3608011305,
0.4327004254,
0.051305104,
0.4991556406,
-0.5464866161,
0.6839905381,
0.1231829226,
-0.1454920024,
-0.12512815,
-0.396422416,
-0.1608539075,
-0.2380009145,
-0.6486696005,
-0.8201107383,
0.0942254215,
0.4706977904,
0.4089991152,
0.4236125648,
0.3458736837,
0.7249724865,
-0.7250875831,
0.9655212164,
0.205024302,
-0.8170474172,
0.8177490234,
-0.1358860433,
0.0666479692,
0.7131233811,
0.0041620792,
0.0649928302,
-0.8915831447,
-0.6752233505,
-1.3453009129,
0.6435116529,
0.6533409953,
0.1553600132,
-0.1986355335,
0.4427878857,
-0.0098779993,
0.3170652986,
-0.9242052436,
-0.289018482,
-0.1363240033,
-0.2171819806,
-0.1026704013,
-0.5766792893,
-0.0795674399,
-0.2228997797,
0.7798714042,
-0.3641201556,
0.2406172156,
0.4084777534,
-0.3559720814,
-0.1613643616,
0.2608804107,
0.742850244,
0.6808332801,
-0.0610618591,
0.4683089852,
-0.0533908494,
-0.1904550195,
0.2502024472,
-0.1785957813,
-0.5844355226,
0.1604690105,
0.5376338363,
0.6537204385,
0.2890772223,
-0.2724048495,
0.4718468189,
0.321660459,
-0.1295303106,
-0.290525794,
-0.05550896,
-0.3203521669,
0.1395990849,
0.5733318925,
-0.0928238258,
0.0013964521,
-0.573591888,
0.4697569609,
0.3818000853,
0.3190839887,
-0.1814835966,
0.9214766026,
0.210629344,
0.1553351134,
0.367567718,
-0.1984917819,
-0.5220227838,
0.2472235858,
0.6771799326,
1.1977032423,
-0.0344783813,
0.3149169385,
0.7040786147,
0.3234449029,
0.0547737479,
0.1302143335,
-0.1495598108,
-0.5652891397,
-0.4693314433,
-0.7716896534,
-0.067101419,
0.1651899517,
-0.4752176404,
0.3470014036,
-0.3151632547,
-0.1900515556,
0.1220899746,
0.0107770478,
-0.2527089417,
0.2200485468,
0.2610530555,
0.6056500673,
-0.8370753527,
0.6739642024,
0.637781024,
-0.5900630951,
-0.8029708862,
0.1825012863,
-0.1684275866,
-0.4153089225,
0.5541288853,
0.1696129739,
-0.2254101932,
0.2394349128,
-0.7158067822,
-0.9829309583,
1.1234635115,
0.5850984454,
0.0280426145,
0.0593476407,
0.0141021125,
0.3256684542,
-0.4087952375,
0.2223678231,
0.4847827554,
0.3725531697,
0.3551745713,
-0.3727758527,
0.5333101153,
-0.0304807331,
0.0294708405,
0.0711389706,
-0.3874259889,
0.8623126149,
-0.356864512,
-0.3213696182,
0.0271705482,
1.2236651182,
0.5488221645,
-0.0269436166,
0.33298859,
0.250659436,
0.9684894681,
-0.0712691471,
0.9695634246,
-0.1908722222,
-0.0468339808,
1.3726961613,
-0.386475265,
0.7702414393,
0.7891456485,
-0.0975804552,
0.5792288184,
0.5060673952,
0.0576042831,
0.8343179822,
0.2607343793,
-0.2924513817,
-0.2788577676,
-0.3553940058,
-0.3764656186,
0.1569683701,
-0.2371751517,
-0.3896301985,
-0.2947673798,
-0.1355838925,
0.3280414045,
0.2523522675,
-0.2364372164,
0.8796383142,
-0.0541389734,
-1.0522191525,
0.5057597756,
0.1125865057,
0.4041235149,
-0.7156664729,
0.1196244434,
-0.5241687298,
0.2393938452,
-0.4205360413,
-0.7142763138,
0.3729707003,
0.3937126696,
-0.5421705842,
-0.6506604552,
0.8811479211,
-0.5367800593,
-0.6430613399,
-0.3153690398,
0.1784347892,
0.0442186892,
-0.4132932127,
-0.0317226164,
-0.1702835709,
0.1201469079,
-0.6746961474,
0.1595000327,
0.7057068944,
-0.3753911853,
0.4588603079,
0.8794284463,
0.1288405061,
0.1467930973,
-0.0423266292,
1.0404874086,
-0.4617855549,
-0.5267484784,
-0.9408535361,
0.9281294346,
-0.2184352279,
-0.2398418933,
0.6509330273,
0.7080884576,
0.5919555426,
0.1048042327,
0.6878700852,
-0.4599977434,
0.2623629272,
-0.7034370899,
0.7881993055,
-0.7123500109,
0.01701352,
-0.4006159306,
-1.0113331079,
-0.4632897675,
0.8617126942,
0.1155101657,
-0.3277444541,
0.9527813792,
0.7695603371,
0.0358864181,
-0.4290060997,
-0.0538855046,
0.1844824851,
0.4876337051,
0.3945674896,
0.6336315274,
-0.34264189,
0.4020934999,
-0.1845106483,
0.0368369557,
0.0588146374,
-1.3497976065,
-0.7496530414,
-0.5120761395,
-0.4726108611,
-0.4400233626,
-0.6222702861,
0.8983045816,
0.3468956649,
-0.82705158,
0.1987264901,
-0.2300065607,
0.2693820298,
0.1104296818,
-0.1939021647,
0.3594187796,
-0.5291693211,
-0.2793596387,
0.1726578325,
-0.0840913057,
-0.1496700197,
-0.3520739973,
-0.1297683567,
-0.0811999962,
0.0820700675,
0.9142246842,
-0.1239746585,
-0.6985827684,
-0.4715387821,
-0.1434994489,
-0.3719811738,
0.0737313256,
1.1799323559,
-0.8903754354,
0.0544305928,
0.3948329687,
0.5129347444,
0.1496562511,
0.1326413155,
0.7157292366,
-1.2745176554,
0.1830360442,
0.0737255812,
0.0792610198,
0.4730688334,
-0.5432037711,
0.3784734011,
0.1034547091,
-0.4966990352,
-1.1874012947,
0.3036962152,
-0.7702014446,
0.0544689782,
1.2031693459,
-0.1101632491,
-0.0089857178,
0.2056795061,
-0.3684278131,
0.3687923253,
-0.2288243324,
0.593788743,
0.5615525842,
0.1740834117,
-0.1791567355,
-0.1527406126,
0.7685898542,
0.3145689666,
-1.0335206985,
0.5283822417,
0.9012717009,
-0.0874281898,
0.4069760144,
0.8641273975,
0.2079353631,
-0.0652336404,
-0.0830489025,
0.0908569321,
-0.1328875422,
-0.4307594299,
0.2635820508,
0.3067421615,
0.1394843906,
0.2181210518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19710v1
|
STRUM-LLM: Attributed and Structured Contrastive Summarization
| 2024-03-25T18:32:44 | 2024-03-25T18:32:44 |
Beliz Gunel, James B. Wendt, Jing Xie, Yichao Zhou, Nguyen Vo, Zachary Fisher, Sandeep Tata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Users often struggle with decision-making between two options (A vs B), as it
usually requires time-consuming research across multiple web pages. We propose
STRUM-LLM that addresses this challenge by generating attributed, structured,
and helpful contrastive summaries that highlight key differences between the
two options. STRUM-LLM identifies helpful contrast: the specific attributes
along which the two options differ significantly and which are most likely to
influence the user's decision. Our technique is domain-agnostic, and does not
require any human-labeled data or fixed attribute list as supervision.
STRUM-LLM attributes all extractions back to the input sources along with
textual evidence, and it does not have a limit on the length of input sources
that it can process. STRUM-LLM Distilled has 100x more throughput than the
models with comparable performance while being 10x smaller. In this paper, we
provide extensive evaluations for our method and lay out future directions for
our currently deployed system.
|
[
-0.1743264794,
-0.5247267485,
0.5202279687,
0.8016545773,
-0.5461831689,
0.3208462894,
-0.1647108197,
-0.6182530522,
0.4532387853,
0.0619066581,
-0.6339443922,
-0.5647084117,
-0.5323316455,
0.3248007894,
-0.3203400075,
1.2824668884,
-0.2040275335,
0.0306040812,
-0.4989067614,
-0.1187556013,
-0.2782683074,
-0.1304591745,
-0.8082467318,
-0.6246289611,
0.722482264,
0.542419076,
0.6197223663,
0.6489031315,
0.8880186677,
0.2988343537,
-0.1937654614,
0.2674185336,
-0.5698960423,
0.3626381755,
-0.4690821767,
-0.3774719536,
-0.7648628354,
0.2777187526,
0.2200387865,
0.4887119532,
-0.3696805835,
0.5896293521,
0.2995965183,
0.515350461,
-0.535595715,
-0.1246907935,
-0.5197421908,
0.055744309,
-0.1801066399,
-0.2945057154,
-0.3158609271,
-0.3861146867,
-0.0234914292,
-0.7741515636,
0.2303929925,
0.1215320975,
0.7101286054,
0.3337339461,
-0.5281074047,
-0.3911969662,
-0.7217001319,
0.8647586703,
-0.8249061704,
-0.0804292858,
0.364982903,
0.4207903147,
0.1532859951,
-0.9170078039,
-0.3358527124,
-0.2153824717,
-0.5051183701,
0.6498072147,
-0.038644515,
-0.0754199997,
0.1279169172,
0.608404696,
-0.5911892056,
0.4230673313,
-0.4588369727,
0.1270005107,
0.9502701163,
0.4521795511,
-0.0248923358,
-0.2353432477,
-0.4896683097,
0.234085083,
-0.6561340094,
-0.1460346878,
0.3846374154,
0.2713941932,
-0.3234257698,
0.5714852214,
-0.2257899791,
0.5085682273,
0.16287449,
-0.6984204054,
0.1299983859,
-0.4511885941,
-0.326790899,
-0.0325855501,
0.5907787085,
0.9998180866,
-0.2134188116,
-0.0878215656,
-0.1262746155,
0.0021343059,
0.0917619243,
-0.8525391817,
-0.3627668023,
0.3032895327,
-0.7963318825,
-0.4590938091,
0.0231239703,
-0.715705514,
-0.631005466,
-0.4408248067,
0.2063143104,
-0.1336687654,
-0.2025044411,
-0.3061971664,
-0.7459620833,
0.1113170609,
0.7276249528,
-0.573294878,
0.4298784137,
0.5316590667,
1.0351220369,
-0.7186698318,
-0.0266610794,
-0.359521836,
0.3160363138,
0.1977439225,
0.9137093425,
-0.5446874499,
-0.5229602456,
-0.1938993037,
-0.3432453573,
0.2803362012,
-0.710783422,
0.2791779637,
-0.2942675352,
0.0979194269,
-0.1179047152,
-0.4142787457,
-0.0743102059,
0.2551046312,
-0.865395546,
1.1407883167,
0.1537835598,
-0.7828359008,
0.3159515262,
-0.3292191327,
-0.7909684181,
0.0173921436,
-0.0835768059,
-0.6172837019,
0.3211297691,
-0.104166992,
0.0987840593,
-0.538908422,
0.0650458187,
-0.3296344876,
-0.2834993303,
0.2300934941,
0.1290617436,
0.7380227447,
0.4495378435,
-0.1993270218,
0.1829602122,
-0.9244996309,
-0.1816678047,
0.0840151161,
-0.4447183609,
-0.4167640209,
0.2161082029,
-0.0532702766,
0.2146939635,
0.2456522286,
-0.0848570243,
0.1360902786,
-0.1188520044,
0.4055030346,
0.647033155,
-0.1423374414,
0.4877221286,
-0.5158792138,
0.6245610118,
0.0807249546,
-0.0308387391,
-0.0564456098,
-0.020869419,
-0.7022879124,
-0.4785728753,
0.3153555393,
0.5894961357,
-0.8053402901,
-0.0321853273,
0.0250172727,
-0.5239800215,
-0.5500965118,
0.2173005193,
0.5534135699,
0.8435978293,
0.6744533777,
-0.2179898173,
-0.742616117,
-1.1093581915,
-0.3955686688,
-0.143505007,
-0.4851840734,
0.4839313924,
0.4130037129,
0.1071890742,
0.8664731383,
-0.9743692875,
-0.3487209082,
-0.6544773579,
0.4457806349,
0.0841880813,
0.2074819654,
0.3535821736,
-0.9333673716,
-0.7177244425,
-0.183611393,
-0.6721314192,
-0.5411789417,
-0.1520913541,
0.0844653174,
-0.0420881324,
0.3197435141,
-0.5567228794,
0.5646030903,
0.2202156782,
0.0372797027,
0.6903545856,
-0.0833940208,
0.2445758432,
-1.2015883923,
0.2466035336,
0.1435062289,
-0.2253284901,
-0.4806393385,
0.0871116668,
-0.0748519748,
0.2799822688,
-0.3753193319,
0.1237649769,
-0.4767829478,
-0.1918638796,
-0.1326113194,
0.5314258337,
0.1830807179,
0.2935902178,
0.1514803469,
0.6798172593,
-0.0352035314,
-0.7203307748,
0.475091517,
0.359469831,
-0.0544733778,
0.8509294987,
-0.8281269073,
0.0341703333,
0.0300527047,
0.328779012,
-1.1167184114,
-0.1172892079,
0.1159381345,
-0.2660420835,
0.1370858848,
-0.0252629947,
-0.1552494317,
-0.2821042538,
-0.929238975,
0.4208031595,
0.2632725239,
-0.3117131591,
0.6630458236,
0.4521181285,
-0.6734666824,
-0.2913964987,
-0.7665390968,
0.1177159622,
-0.6329270601,
-0.50284338,
0.8049252629,
-0.1504187286,
-0.7611710429,
-0.1432806104,
-0.3340920806,
-0.195623368,
0.3009446859,
0.2923947573,
0.3451782465,
-0.0687378123,
0.0413216539,
0.037876565,
-0.1176490113,
-0.2725095451,
0.1524089128,
0.0815047473,
0.2753867805,
0.1140319481,
-0.2494448423,
0.6561198235,
-0.1803435981,
-0.0944501087,
0.2249074429,
0.0963558629,
0.0277365465,
-0.4113694131,
-0.4468502998,
-0.0232266057,
-0.4400567114,
0.1646419168,
-0.1448972672,
-0.6579357982,
0.5800625086,
-0.2793851495,
0.2409386486,
0.4252849519,
0.3635025918,
-0.7282363176,
0.7119313478,
0.5347085595,
0.1239791736,
0.4788319468,
0.1750909239,
-0.1200780943,
-0.5735428929,
-0.1820805967,
-0.664403379,
-0.8863365054,
-0.3773566484,
-0.0745546967,
0.2666757107,
0.0689300075,
0.0146790314,
0.268067956,
-0.4252840579,
0.5756579638,
0.6428388953,
0.2495853901,
0.6219065189,
-0.2245625556,
0.1871735603,
-0.0601844564,
-0.3193750978,
-0.3926095963,
0.9248227477,
-0.1479367316,
0.8007978201,
0.299181968,
0.7602246404,
0.5048219562,
0.5524545312,
-0.7578287721,
0.5783016682,
-0.2211104631,
-0.3257191181,
-0.1748314351,
-0.50021106,
-0.7598031163,
0.4244151115,
-0.3481715918,
-0.3555101752,
-0.2425521612,
0.475199908,
-0.4549884796,
-0.0548327938,
-0.5287068486,
0.4182053506,
-0.2427333295,
-0.5675896406,
-0.2924017012,
-1.0089613199,
0.4631882608,
0.2469935715,
0.1834574193,
0.0551846661,
-0.1134438515,
0.6649231911,
-0.4825432003,
0.6283255219,
-0.0202388056,
0.0000033875,
0.1461956799,
-0.009757868,
0.5159660578,
-0.0975641534,
-0.0770107657,
-0.1382876337,
-0.3842483461,
-0.0014365723,
-0.4803558588,
0.4627483189,
-0.3133915663,
-0.8158456683,
-0.4105417132,
-0.5734077692,
-0.0958643258,
0.0687923357,
0.2221328914,
0.1588728428,
-0.3649843335,
0.0993547365,
0.3662239909,
-0.0633035004,
0.6914851069,
0.6777670383,
-0.1281798035,
-0.5736172795,
0.6766672134,
0.1247207224,
0.1627828032,
0.45140329,
0.2047516555,
-0.2992791235,
-0.9109399319,
-0.2866946459,
0.1912032664,
-0.4457101822,
-0.7022252679,
-0.1248288229,
0.0335037597,
-0.3296585977,
-0.3440529704,
0.0334218256,
-0.8454765677,
-0.3457963467,
-0.6954863071,
0.2513655424,
0.700132668,
-0.1705504209,
0.5825514793,
-0.5561903119,
0.7092875242,
0.2265707552,
0.0879534483,
-0.0383986309,
-0.4780487418,
-0.2293933481,
-0.1166987717,
-0.6135271788,
-0.8667808175,
0.3434903622,
0.3211785555,
0.436693728,
0.4568600059,
0.335187465,
1.208491087,
-0.4190189242,
0.8523731232,
0.4836613536,
-0.8166893125,
0.66144979,
-0.0105370255,
-0.0354686119,
0.9194748998,
0.4220301211,
-0.1916863918,
-0.6247420907,
-0.389420867,
-1.1492543221,
0.7550045848,
0.1213370934,
-0.3619163334,
0.2498217672,
0.1645331085,
0.3719193935,
0.4822885394,
-0.7816640139,
-0.4003929794,
-0.2844662666,
-0.2736170292,
-0.1641109884,
-0.3499021828,
-0.316768527,
-0.2141761333,
0.4146361947,
0.0857738703,
-0.3757650852,
0.2203378826,
-0.5698388219,
0.1996856928,
0.2580536306,
0.6082766652,
1.0044977665,
-0.1957554519,
0.7696421146,
0.4166161418,
-0.2216261029,
-0.0615859888,
0.2060941756,
-0.3715057969,
-0.0414204448,
0.5562583804,
0.3984438181,
0.5384133458,
-0.3844512999,
0.4317827225,
0.1728281975,
-0.3908868432,
-0.182899937,
-0.0552124344,
0.4085540771,
0.3682911992,
0.3295774758,
-0.3898174167,
0.5054565668,
-0.4415303469,
0.0913103968,
0.2394329309,
0.0037985377,
-0.3119414747,
0.5707426667,
0.6304408908,
-0.3212928474,
0.519282937,
-0.0293314885,
-0.2107352912,
0.5769578815,
0.6986335516,
0.7313643694,
-0.4315396845,
0.356010735,
0.2356425524,
0.0573975928,
0.0280630235,
0.1565717459,
-0.3274642527,
-0.2361815274,
-0.0153998891,
-0.4922487438,
-0.506419003,
-0.0818356201,
-1.0584101677,
0.1542081237,
-0.3621997535,
-0.1919954866,
0.2089437246,
0.1101826802,
-0.2597125769,
0.2209259272,
-0.2718816996,
1.0155091286,
-0.7640275955,
0.4479095936,
0.4561258852,
-0.6227793694,
-0.3932864964,
-0.2439239323,
0.2730833292,
-0.5030212402,
0.5665056109,
0.076085031,
-0.4712324739,
-0.2557628751,
-0.5606581569,
-0.2298311442,
1.6545984745,
0.3317768872,
-0.3543538451,
-0.1641966999,
0.0677713677,
0.4552104473,
-0.3670201302,
0.3607879877,
0.604441762,
0.6010876298,
0.3929516673,
-0.8394412398,
0.0886041597,
-0.2319608331,
-0.0544733107,
0.0108722933,
-0.7467540503,
0.9989061952,
-0.1923275888,
-0.6041138172,
-0.0916265994,
0.6960479617,
0.3119998574,
0.7867096066,
0.3576588333,
0.5442438126,
0.6923735142,
0.073828049,
0.6213949323,
0.0251140818,
0.1036449745,
1.6783698797,
-0.6480239034,
0.8631325364,
0.7668041587,
-0.3506380022,
0.5626770258,
0.5582960844,
-0.1126767993,
0.5462610722,
0.3305841982,
-0.2812948227,
-0.2985403538,
-0.1796025038,
-0.3963367641,
0.3323654532,
0.0456538573,
-0.4619793892,
-0.386873126,
-0.6303757429,
0.1771841943,
0.2934219539,
-0.5661295056,
1.1702986956,
0.4299909472,
-0.7984762788,
-0.0497546494,
0.1099450812,
0.6331484914,
-0.8843711615,
-0.1592430472,
-0.5895041823,
0.0316613242,
-0.6864571571,
-0.5663687587,
0.4792120457,
0.2568174303,
-0.2975169122,
-0.5719101429,
0.814981997,
-0.4920129478,
-0.2593357563,
0.2926370502,
0.4629967809,
-0.0573109314,
0.2030255347,
-0.3599777222,
-0.0640848503,
-0.061337661,
-0.2134828418,
0.3949767947,
0.1612541378,
0.0721316263,
0.4782092273,
0.3953397274,
0.1150629222,
-0.4980371296,
-0.0692932457,
0.9507706165,
-0.8794319034,
-0.689899385,
-1.1162064075,
0.6923416853,
-0.6915546656,
-0.3072840869,
1.1465334892,
0.9683179259,
0.5652680993,
0.0182794295,
0.8139762282,
0.0480906963,
0.5894312859,
-0.515429914,
0.4631362259,
-0.6584498882,
0.327059567,
-0.1795360148,
-0.4991790652,
-0.42582798,
0.6335852146,
-0.0001859913,
-0.1901344359,
0.8084643483,
0.5781942606,
0.0224115532,
0.061035201,
-0.244247973,
0.1554896832,
0.0725482777,
0.5883159637,
0.917637825,
0.0966575593,
0.7442346811,
0.0324632525,
-0.4547755122,
-0.4175983965,
-1.20230937,
-0.7751538157,
-0.2762167752,
-0.4006966352,
-0.1897640973,
-0.1446956843,
0.7546494603,
0.3442525864,
-0.6810236573,
-0.4875516593,
0.2484250814,
0.5215479732,
-0.4586630464,
-0.1605920196,
0.1932096928,
-0.1024186462,
-0.4029047489,
0.3370826542,
0.4423042536,
-0.0329130255,
0.1699465513,
-0.0399516858,
-0.0511583686,
0.1678387374,
0.7492074966,
0.0380312614,
-0.3161467612,
-0.1322500855,
-0.2215344757,
-0.1778647602,
0.222694084,
1.0700486898,
-0.4045910835,
-0.1149044111,
0.6475081444,
0.1750340164,
0.9002489448,
0.4760380089,
0.6635842919,
-0.8723509908,
-0.1239682212,
0.2297616452,
0.2261298746,
0.1241060644,
-0.0140763447,
0.6946790814,
0.1210519895,
-0.200119257,
-0.861202538,
0.4721080959,
-1.1844354868,
-0.3986363709,
1.1583491564,
-0.3183222413,
0.2332555801,
-0.20627442,
-0.3230956197,
0.1754528135,
-0.1651445627,
1.05433321,
0.6511462331,
-0.3708772361,
0.0648315251,
0.1245879233,
0.6781930923,
0.0057214731,
-0.9400858283,
0.1823313236,
0.8089386225,
0.1894208491,
-0.0322020426,
0.7624517679,
0.1667202711,
0.1199618429,
0.1554341763,
-0.2210475802,
-0.5270916224,
-0.2735137045,
-0.1831789166,
0.5712684989,
-0.0947880447,
-0.0020267849
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16995v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16995v1
|
Language Rectified Flow: Advancing Diffusion Language Generation with Probabilistic Flows
| 2024-03-25T17:58:22 | 2024-03-25T17:58:22 |
Shujian Zhang, Lemeng Wu, Chengyue Gong, Xingchao Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Recent works have demonstrated success in controlling sentence attributes
($e.g.$, sentiment) and structure ($e.g.$, syntactic structure) based on the
diffusion language model. A key component that drives theimpressive performance
for generating high-quality samples from noise is iteratively denoise for
thousands of steps. While beneficial, the complexity of starting from the noise
and the learning steps has limited its implementation to many NLP real-world
applications. This paper proposes Language Rectified Flow ({\ours}). Our method
is based on the reformulation of the standard probabilistic flow models.
Language rectified flow learns (neural) ordinary differential equation models
to transport between the source distribution and the target distribution, hence
providing a unified and effective solution to generative modeling and domain
transfer. From the source distribution, our language rectified flow yields fast
simulation and effectively decreases the inference time. Experiments on three
challenging fine-grained control tasks and multiple high-quality text editing
show that our method consistently outperforms its baselines. Extensive
experiments and ablation studies demonstrate that our method can be general,
effective, and beneficial for many NLP tasks.
|
[
-0.1046842486,
-0.9847506881,
0.3708857894,
0.182378903,
-0.1782845706,
0.1767459959,
-0.2901313901,
-0.1187240779,
0.106765233,
0.8183407187,
-0.6223495603,
-0.464469403,
-0.6191602945,
-0.0191800464,
-0.8257071376,
1.0638718605,
-0.0019772253,
-0.1824668348,
0.0307294186,
0.1840263158,
-0.1320636421,
-0.2244026959,
-1.1381314993,
-0.6281631589,
0.4925447106,
-0.0150942914,
0.6973858476,
0.3099526465,
0.361027956,
0.3429899812,
-0.4083499312,
-0.0513361767,
-0.3748212159,
0.4421252012,
-0.1139996126,
-0.2326424718,
-0.1761159003,
-0.1421469152,
0.7001847029,
0.8760043979,
-0.7346051335,
-0.1919358522,
0.1331525594,
1.0048452616,
-0.6206582785,
0.0872298628,
-0.4410587549,
0.0303300079,
-0.2432418466,
-0.0600620061,
-0.4065646529,
-0.5689699054,
-0.0360355861,
-0.3380176127,
0.4228976369,
-0.3997839093,
0.5411698222,
0.3859234154,
-0.1108219177,
-0.2279506922,
-1.1047918797,
0.6110306382,
-0.7488451004,
0.3283388019,
0.0681132749,
0.2786100507,
-0.3608137369,
-1.1661980152,
-0.5610348582,
0.0589665361,
0.2580414712,
0.1132187247,
-0.441736728,
-0.0384806767,
-0.1739118546,
0.2321308106,
-0.5069459677,
-0.1132215112,
-0.4008348286,
-0.2159217447,
0.708570838,
0.0023591053,
0.2206757665,
0.2040100247,
0.0866224915,
-0.0646156967,
-0.6792831421,
-0.1169360057,
0.3813835084,
0.3470796049,
0.114902027,
0.2829350829,
-0.3797056377,
0.8144785166,
-0.0882903188,
-0.1942504495,
0.3758043349,
-0.086845167,
-0.3137293756,
-0.1630447954,
0.6197065115,
0.0076453108,
0.3587906063,
-0.1881505996,
-0.1657725275,
-0.3214670718,
0.3941147625,
-0.812838912,
-0.4874985218,
0.3723976314,
-0.2980380952,
-0.3323069513,
-0.3340859115,
-0.6295436025,
-0.3235550821,
-0.2213411182,
0.0861298293,
-0.5308313966,
-0.7573244572,
0.2571882904,
-0.0716001317,
-0.1600455493,
0.4624020457,
-0.6798000932,
0.128989324,
0.6185033321,
0.8145678043,
-0.0491257459,
-0.0236376766,
-0.5778995156,
-0.0327384137,
-0.3369847536,
0.8944225311,
-0.5279223919,
-0.1101252958,
0.1370685399,
-0.2585482001,
0.1360580623,
-0.7983856201,
0.4756398201,
-0.5839853287,
0.1093636602,
0.2330898643,
-0.583597362,
-0.278509438,
0.0173370242,
-0.6766674519,
0.6058599949,
0.1576401889,
-0.5828555822,
0.068839781,
-0.5075159669,
-0.5102824569,
0.1396770477,
0.281509012,
-0.4174496531,
0.0415543243,
-0.1532570571,
0.3572779298,
-0.0974102244,
0.3578417599,
0.0749024823,
0.0125577766,
0.2305570543,
-0.7042728662,
0.7462896705,
0.5978082418,
-0.0053511853,
0.0924994498,
-0.9515316486,
-0.069605127,
0.0020251563,
-0.4641001821,
-0.1007713303,
0.100896813,
-0.0052914061,
0.0222246461,
-0.1566388607,
-0.5230911374,
-0.0410583355,
-0.6176886559,
0.6844668388,
0.5134598613,
0.2661188245,
0.6236510277,
-0.0502239391,
0.6592301726,
0.3077351451,
-0.1643596143,
0.0899048448,
-0.6102337241,
-0.5639160872,
-0.3182405233,
0.3182907999,
0.4516224563,
-0.8367392421,
0.2071614861,
0.1127937809,
-0.3751661479,
-0.6767383814,
0.3649175167,
0.1517080963,
0.6333539486,
0.3077562153,
-0.1603506953,
-0.301571846,
-0.5704881549,
0.0233917721,
-0.2522392869,
-0.1751774549,
-0.290319562,
0.0501278974,
-0.2154280692,
0.7763518691,
-0.7018415332,
-0.1163274497,
-0.5773794055,
0.6571770906,
0.0127943493,
0.558021605,
0.2819599509,
-0.6801614165,
-0.2973555624,
-0.2672251463,
-0.1971811056,
-0.5316122174,
-0.2315927893,
-0.2966033816,
0.4400936365,
0.6921201944,
-0.4724321365,
0.1908730865,
0.8172704577,
-0.2777440846,
0.3485914171,
-0.3652515709,
-0.0562098697,
-1.1297962666,
-0.0072340472,
0.0949303731,
-0.381690979,
-0.7595932484,
0.1099412069,
-0.2343628407,
-0.1307648122,
-0.5470794439,
0.3317287266,
-0.338429302,
0.3251957893,
-0.561753571,
0.223440066,
0.0012113865,
0.2744831443,
0.2004357576,
0.4883980751,
0.5309637785,
-0.8027679324,
0.4928646088,
-0.1351300478,
-0.1570387185,
0.4750989676,
-0.4626460075,
-0.1201301366,
-0.4577720463,
0.2136250734,
-1.1313471794,
0.1419269592,
0.1408750713,
-0.2432795763,
0.454292506,
-0.1215477139,
-0.3537998796,
-0.0724132136,
0.0965027809,
0.1471225619,
0.8398209214,
-0.457775712,
0.4498699009,
0.3599081635,
-0.3989626765,
-0.4821936786,
-0.6859192848,
0.0949365944,
0.004781282,
-0.4888775945,
0.362934202,
-0.0969385281,
-0.3400132954,
0.1233542114,
0.1717757285,
-0.3497413993,
0.1399832219,
0.0443647616,
-0.239030242,
0.0284453835,
0.309642911,
0.2675125301,
-0.070668973,
-0.0905380994,
-0.1751050055,
0.6290414929,
0.2215917706,
-0.1182535216,
-0.5271204114,
0.3278242052,
0.2519327998,
-0.1600574255,
0.667901516,
0.7998070121,
-0.3192968965,
-0.4045189917,
-0.2024727911,
-0.1753946394,
-0.4294459224,
0.4180254936,
-0.3825988173,
-0.9872866869,
0.3597976565,
-0.2239864767,
0.2432845682,
0.3605543077,
0.4904946387,
-0.1915789843,
0.7916274071,
0.6211832166,
0.1272798777,
0.5286127329,
-0.3316688836,
0.2490534931,
-0.6205694675,
0.0258199181,
-0.599118948,
-0.4019992352,
-0.5600975156,
-0.455733031,
-0.1475182027,
0.4316869974,
0.0646210015,
0.3176280558,
-0.4473873079,
0.2010583282,
0.5154006481,
-0.1144047156,
0.3429133892,
0.046555493,
-0.0505318567,
-0.1078971475,
-0.5857481956,
-0.2926870883,
0.772407949,
0.3288016617,
0.7604094148,
0.2015229464,
0.9375017285,
0.3117669225,
0.5993569493,
-0.52665025,
0.5630502701,
-0.351526618,
-0.2348653823,
-0.2723749578,
-0.6480850577,
-1.1361733675,
0.1472684294,
-0.2035753876,
-0.4113102257,
-0.0334255472,
0.2460867316,
-0.2668081224,
0.3964311779,
-0.6822941303,
0.6414994001,
0.5298218131,
-0.3051234484,
-0.3747928143,
-0.2418058813,
0.4177630246,
0.0290001184,
0.2056369931,
-0.0346372388,
0.1693051159,
0.3984584808,
-0.5804604888,
0.7883953452,
-0.2902348638,
-0.5346791148,
0.6141632795,
0.2570589185,
0.3770046234,
-0.0442129001,
0.0667993352,
0.0818673894,
-0.315274626,
-0.1659799367,
-0.7775732875,
0.7163393497,
-0.3549183309,
-0.5351127386,
-0.0330035202,
-0.3718971312,
0.0832894444,
0.0771341622,
0.2297221273,
0.3528831005,
-0.1252218336,
0.0484363027,
0.5595892668,
-0.2041536719,
0.7118825912,
0.4876228273,
-0.2243276685,
-0.4240165353,
0.7527914643,
0.0418022051,
0.3774597049,
0.4599206448,
0.0373886451,
-0.3651692569,
-0.753965199,
-0.3138231933,
0.2814260423,
-0.4242786467,
-0.296792835,
-0.6388713121,
-0.5418252349,
-0.51982373,
-0.1342923045,
-0.565515101,
-0.6741484404,
-0.2667233348,
-0.0344398245,
0.3437394202,
0.5897192359,
-0.3264299929,
0.3565829992,
-0.8364523053,
0.2959051728,
0.3687726855,
0.3128714859,
-0.1242411211,
-0.6661630869,
-0.0909222737,
0.0045073507,
-0.478140831,
-0.7696188688,
0.7371625304,
0.3892690539,
0.3039083481,
0.2670009732,
-0.0222824216,
0.5232673287,
-0.6764550805,
0.7879661918,
0.157548666,
-0.7975233793,
0.6563552022,
0.2433051914,
0.3031301498,
0.185715124,
0.0560752004,
-0.5247756839,
-1.024971962,
-0.6936272979,
-0.8725268245,
0.2397592515,
0.3801393509,
0.3098804057,
-0.3531475663,
0.7064595819,
-0.1447354853,
0.3388918042,
-0.5192579031,
-0.1572121829,
-0.0771775395,
-0.395635426,
-0.1120218039,
-0.1879991144,
0.0835135877,
0.0636988506,
0.6259542704,
0.1626125127,
0.1537620574,
0.2508994937,
0.0073643555,
-0.1946657896,
0.4465592802,
0.7322938442,
0.3033165336,
-0.2280630618,
0.1604926437,
-0.4192992449,
-0.6819259524,
0.21472992,
-0.0068347785,
-0.5643995404,
0.2990108132,
0.2589140236,
0.6150396466,
-0.1008310392,
-0.628819108,
0.2659119368,
-0.0667618364,
-0.3599179983,
-0.2492004037,
0.3845706582,
0.3335428536,
0.3863252997,
0.1607929319,
0.3887917697,
0.4428563416,
-0.3702062368,
0.2657865882,
0.4599613547,
-0.2414158732,
-0.3808766603,
0.71767205,
0.4581282437,
-0.4215014279,
0.6939446926,
-0.5041322112,
-0.155295074,
0.2045749873,
0.6099771261,
1.1812137365,
-0.1220510677,
0.5889566541,
0.6737489104,
0.0728916898,
-0.3978850842,
0.2772103548,
0.0585496277,
-1.0308082104,
-0.9787703156,
-0.70705688,
-0.1516776532,
0.1801672876,
-0.4967515767,
-0.1878721863,
-0.3821544051,
-0.2891198993,
-0.1454276592,
-0.2163108587,
-0.1408223063,
0.222427696,
0.137257129,
0.8482046723,
-0.8981631994,
0.9083704352,
0.6386255622,
-0.4583805799,
-0.4290079772,
0.1770298332,
-0.1660072953,
-0.4065757096,
0.8254094124,
-0.2464856207,
-0.2912953794,
0.3960343301,
-0.568595767,
-0.6526568532,
0.7974914312,
0.5099551678,
-0.4719830751,
0.2600736618,
-0.1945787668,
0.7672964334,
-0.2775561512,
-0.200337559,
0.5908768177,
0.1741070449,
0.3940607905,
-0.5333383083,
-0.1194943413,
-0.1780064255,
0.2564303279,
0.3489871025,
-0.255580008,
0.6644041538,
-0.3909908533,
-0.473893255,
0.030554885,
0.893473208,
0.2895001471,
0.0454149432,
0.4752822518,
0.79798913,
0.7267125249,
-0.1229667366,
0.7375483513,
-0.1161482781,
0.0688663349,
1.1156390905,
-0.1932514012,
1.2070446014,
0.5316671729,
-0.2993708849,
0.8087755442,
0.21598728,
0.5473541617,
0.7343299985,
0.5108304024,
-0.4913351238,
-0.0909673348,
0.0408775955,
0.0018383319,
0.2649209797,
0.2167627662,
-0.2995747626,
-0.3583885431,
0.073034808,
0.0360070802,
0.4421964884,
-0.2525761127,
0.7976438999,
-0.13367486,
-0.595131278,
0.5982739329,
0.085462518,
0.7509768009,
-0.4110223055,
-0.1665167212,
-0.5521242023,
0.1174510345,
-0.0376027077,
-0.9965343475,
0.7196132541,
0.0188114233,
-0.0860904828,
-0.6397733092,
0.5808802247,
-0.8176091909,
-0.3782857656,
0.0941140577,
0.3502145708,
0.3942881525,
-0.154041335,
-0.6151483059,
-0.2128209472,
0.1541658044,
-0.3690276742,
0.189057678,
0.5889057517,
0.3895636797,
0.8877342343,
0.4928447902,
0.6665855646,
0.0526769981,
0.6215570569,
0.4298227131,
-0.3981671929,
-0.2357697189,
-0.7070695758,
0.6854782104,
-0.0557419434,
-0.235368818,
0.1572694629,
0.1993786097,
0.7422227263,
-0.0574399419,
0.5610682964,
0.0668573752,
0.7916646004,
-0.7928198576,
0.8043840528,
-0.4168840945,
0.2031674385,
-0.2096578926,
-0.6822471619,
-0.5094575286,
0.7172856927,
0.2538405061,
-0.067933321,
0.5716537237,
0.795535028,
0.3111437261,
-0.3610646129,
0.345510155,
0.1748342216,
0.4083313346,
0.4915824831,
0.5171066523,
-0.412699312,
0.5227000713,
-0.3388094604,
-0.2138368934,
-0.0285840351,
-0.9875560999,
-0.3136405349,
-0.7137852907,
-0.9014987946,
-0.4016914666,
-0.063248165,
0.5654796362,
0.5221216083,
-0.7526757121,
-0.088186726,
-0.7029288411,
0.2637273371,
-0.6339905858,
-0.2722737491,
0.0580709428,
-0.7639972568,
-0.9604369998,
0.2438663989,
0.3485245407,
0.1119622067,
-0.4172382653,
-0.0681366473,
-0.0489515848,
0.0394816548,
0.6500824094,
0.3057615161,
-0.4638923705,
-0.0886944607,
-0.2540656328,
-0.2067829072,
-0.2072900385,
0.8144190907,
-0.5632719398,
0.3626955152,
0.7962139249,
0.6158249378,
0.2097151279,
-0.0129023883,
0.7514152527,
-1.0466516018,
0.2026890367,
0.1978401393,
0.3224729598,
0.3877249658,
-0.1234420836,
0.4626470208,
0.3209167719,
-0.4904226363,
-0.5887902379,
0.3413712978,
-0.6914361119,
-0.5300450921,
1.2008945942,
-0.1940275133,
-0.1480781734,
-0.1423056424,
-0.2001610249,
0.4158621132,
-0.3575991988,
0.8157843947,
0.5835495591,
-0.2025222182,
-0.604850769,
-0.2402535379,
0.7275105119,
0.2438976318,
-0.6795430183,
0.318957299,
0.703155756,
0.4080180228,
0.2830270231,
0.930277586,
-0.2084599286,
-0.020307092,
-0.1433772594,
0.4306571484,
0.2195089757,
-0.2801241875,
-0.4332447946,
0.3626353145,
0.1525588483,
-0.1018548459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16984v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16984v2
|
Modelling Commonsense Commonalities with Multi-Facet Concept Embeddings
| 2024-03-25T17:44:45 | 2024-06-04T21:36:42 |
Hanane Kteich, Na Li, Usashi Chatterjee, Zied Bouraoui, Steven Schockaert
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Concept embeddings offer a practical and efficient mechanism for injecting
commonsense knowledge into downstream tasks. Their core purpose is often not to
predict the commonsense properties of concepts themselves, but rather to
identify commonalities, i.e.\ sets of concepts which share some property of
interest. Such commonalities are the basis for inductive generalisation, hence
high-quality concept embeddings can make learning easier and more robust.
Unfortunately, standard embeddings primarily reflect basic taxonomic
categories, making them unsuitable for finding commonalities that refer to more
specific aspects (e.g.\ the colour of objects or the materials they are made
of). In this paper, we address this limitation by explicitly modelling the
different facets of interest when learning concept embeddings. We show that
this leads to embeddings which capture a more diverse range of commonsense
properties, and consistently improves results in downstream tasks such as
ultra-fine entity typing and ontology completion.
|
[
-0.5464339852,
-0.3845296204,
0.4908829033,
-0.0690939501,
-0.4135054052,
-0.0151314568,
-0.0590266138,
-0.2641094625,
0.3539539278,
0.3390985131,
-0.2230522186,
-0.4767695963,
-0.5771721005,
-0.0560811609,
0.0411037207,
0.9673355222,
0.150212124,
-0.0944605842,
-0.5504994988,
-0.5180896521,
-0.3514457941,
-0.5537127852,
-0.1509092897,
-0.2866493165,
0.6566912532,
0.3433465064,
0.6428878903,
0.4837121964,
0.3041846156,
0.2242000997,
-0.2842282355,
0.3395795822,
-0.3917773962,
0.0490820184,
-0.5701135993,
-0.3696837127,
-0.1367540956,
0.390348047,
0.1662274897,
1.1865512133,
-0.2723510861,
-0.1033235565,
0.3012891114,
0.3340685666,
-0.7939352989,
0.3945976794,
-0.5367515087,
0.1723704487,
-0.0481435321,
-0.3159322739,
-0.1607435793,
0.0344261229,
0.2910194397,
-0.9765806198,
0.3669370711,
-0.0824747309,
0.8190335035,
0.3076831996,
-0.4443800747,
-0.4875356257,
-0.4681945741,
0.9448586702,
-0.4085840881,
0.4623197615,
0.0951285511,
0.2289084941,
0.1447965652,
-0.6834076047,
-0.6243457198,
0.0169023387,
-0.4309345186,
0.2861253917,
0.0104784854,
0.1754086167,
0.086626038,
0.4022415578,
-0.1307718307,
-0.0287503246,
-0.1213101745,
-0.0293819383,
0.3322399259,
0.0428965539,
0.2817957699,
-0.4781249762,
-0.5591463447,
0.0494252183,
-0.8724520802,
-0.1290679127,
0.2973063588,
0.6355619431,
-0.08626315,
0.5309578776,
-0.3343446851,
0.5833784342,
-0.0160631295,
-0.1074359119,
0.4643459022,
-0.4096960723,
0.1043211818,
-0.2622317374,
0.2354669422,
0.2412691414,
0.3232290447,
-0.2189783007,
-0.1881996393,
0.1741846502,
0.1889567226,
-0.5498031974,
-0.4331897497,
0.4606176913,
-0.1398796737,
-0.414530158,
-0.0177100655,
-0.5718665123,
-0.3896945715,
-0.5823922157,
0.5424256921,
-0.343506068,
-0.5221523643,
0.0924589112,
-0.387817353,
0.2521842718,
0.5728982687,
-0.8244938254,
0.2285711169,
0.8875113726,
0.821241498,
0.0409366153,
-0.3537783325,
-0.4604025483,
0.3986490071,
-0.0203653686,
0.8643680215,
-0.9826148152,
-0.2315619886,
-0.0729994029,
-0.2384316772,
-0.1754607409,
-0.6866931319,
0.0796162635,
-0.4123482704,
-0.2874620557,
-0.5376247168,
-0.6547707319,
-0.2492879927,
0.1943327487,
-0.9080797434,
0.5305739045,
0.0633758828,
-0.9326529503,
0.6199613214,
-0.9919450283,
-0.3323158622,
0.119769834,
-0.3739722371,
-0.1746657193,
0.1831555367,
0.1476058513,
1.0332596302,
-0.0372460298,
0.3560826182,
-0.6179801226,
-0.0663110986,
0.1459240317,
-0.1438241899,
0.5231110454,
0.3292345405,
-0.012443278,
-0.199538514,
-0.2248197049,
-0.5059611201,
-0.2059597373,
0.0674609542,
-0.866748035,
-0.0276126023,
0.1015598625,
0.2631213069,
-0.0627419725,
-0.6645681858,
0.0824619085,
0.0229819603,
0.6895645857,
0.5883254409,
-0.0024049841,
0.6473479271,
-0.3931426704,
0.0894096494,
0.6491142511,
-0.1126691252,
0.0702024475,
-0.6576689482,
-0.2757488489,
-0.7590373158,
0.542887032,
0.3708814681,
-0.6203713417,
0.2775293589,
-0.3061118722,
-0.3491185308,
-0.3794713616,
0.1603190303,
0.3066850305,
0.177348882,
0.2114125043,
-0.5334697962,
-0.0707887784,
-0.7175828815,
-0.2188349217,
0.1216672286,
0.0273920875,
0.5332954526,
0.6735747457,
-0.0740500763,
1.2397463322,
-0.6596493125,
-0.4066771865,
-0.2029702812,
0.3836263716,
-0.0438722521,
0.6527300477,
0.4305655062,
-1.387808919,
-0.148047775,
-0.0060163373,
-0.9111179113,
0.2519611716,
-0.2051881999,
0.0018774658,
-0.0928377584,
0.5111418962,
-0.7509179115,
0.2759772241,
0.2729206979,
-0.1288468987,
0.1093868241,
-0.0144488439,
-0.2551086247,
-1.0892734528,
0.0056850887,
0.187108025,
-0.0288030393,
-0.5052198172,
0.629347682,
0.0814598352,
-0.2766010761,
-0.7925980091,
0.7304179072,
-0.4463151395,
-0.2838718295,
0.294395417,
0.3184625804,
0.2510297298,
0.6445274949,
0.2284350246,
0.5218631029,
0.4196482599,
-0.8434599638,
0.0983881131,
0.1753513515,
-0.0162498225,
1.0944013596,
-0.6297175288,
-0.2534749806,
-0.254068464,
0.2576019168,
-0.7961599827,
-0.303761065,
0.0298917294,
-0.3065600991,
0.4152720571,
-0.3576918542,
-0.5091049671,
-0.0546574295,
-0.3400346935,
0.4032888412,
0.0852060243,
-0.8752168417,
0.9658432007,
0.4987508357,
-0.2399823964,
-0.5977644324,
-0.5542078018,
-0.2957534194,
-0.3907924891,
-0.4674530625,
0.4726541638,
0.0867199823,
-0.0468551777,
0.3558002412,
-0.1819580346,
-0.0130267283,
0.3747426569,
0.1964145303,
0.0161927547,
0.0610515848,
0.4802953601,
0.2124830037,
-0.0773887485,
-0.316477865,
-0.3676670492,
0.5339692831,
-0.1797157526,
-0.6575067043,
-0.2201251835,
0.6454969645,
0.5924367309,
-0.3814464211,
0.6553882957,
0.5449256301,
-0.6167222857,
-0.3471646309,
-0.3683368564,
-0.2205044925,
-0.4689131677,
0.5097355843,
-0.6687693,
-0.930162251,
0.7058016062,
-0.2989888191,
0.1225319356,
0.4555320442,
0.1537857056,
-0.3472714424,
0.6264064312,
0.6747586131,
0.3306542933,
0.0986380875,
-0.5587494373,
0.3777710497,
-1.2551170588,
-0.402574569,
-0.3364320099,
-0.1792860627,
-1.0541564226,
-0.502772212,
0.1676589549,
0.2574685514,
-0.0361587405,
0.2143345028,
-0.499694407,
0.5390853882,
0.6069105864,
0.2407157868,
0.3445041776,
0.096808441,
-0.361389637,
0.0911124721,
-0.7533130646,
-0.6046226025,
1.1976667643,
0.327082932,
0.7669048309,
0.2051147819,
1.1830505133,
0.134305194,
0.5196304917,
-0.8874726295,
0.2207164466,
-0.7132569551,
-0.7475363016,
-0.2676014006,
-0.4381213486,
-0.7261807323,
0.4261403084,
-0.0253959876,
-0.4021805823,
0.6734936237,
0.2823658288,
-0.5250495672,
0.686553359,
-0.6740745902,
0.7519404292,
0.2892875969,
-0.2595522106,
-0.3183199167,
-0.2036691755,
0.2998195887,
-0.0860889181,
0.2054000944,
-0.1331473738,
-0.18513906,
0.7158970237,
-0.1554092765,
1.3124037981,
-0.2547837496,
-0.0314101353,
0.2993774116,
-0.2852263153,
0.0903257802,
0.282512188,
0.2086835653,
0.1648482382,
-0.0738332048,
-0.8505697846,
-0.6882892847,
0.649974227,
-0.8677895069,
-0.6019211411,
-0.5514305234,
-0.4077380002,
-0.2312940955,
-0.2345954925,
0.1502247304,
0.6503480077,
-0.2734053135,
0.1155422479,
1.0645087957,
-0.2003242522,
0.286147505,
0.0820086077,
0.3165936172,
-0.1919509023,
1.2258806229,
0.2865409553,
0.3831484914,
0.4072249234,
0.1156047136,
-0.4063675702,
-0.3476223052,
-0.292548418,
0.1598040462,
-0.918027997,
-0.3599027395,
-1.0574643612,
-0.2618090212,
-0.2888697684,
-0.3925181329,
-0.3286983073,
-0.802235961,
-0.3832847774,
-0.0827025697,
0.5308065414,
0.9443357587,
-0.5121669769,
0.0806203112,
-0.6939221621,
0.4053380787,
1.078327775,
0.473608762,
0.187195003,
-0.3538894057,
0.0066608521,
0.1027992889,
-0.4001397491,
-0.6679933071,
0.0820272863,
0.3554791212,
0.9358725548,
0.3855652809,
0.1105360091,
0.430516094,
-0.273118794,
0.5973689556,
0.1108206064,
-0.926453352,
0.4802937806,
-0.3023345172,
-0.1986279935,
0.4490321875,
0.7886535525,
-0.6076853871,
-0.1944906861,
-0.8211454153,
-0.9108943343,
0.2175678164,
0.0640990138,
0.4103296697,
-0.1140569225,
0.1550753862,
0.3060077429,
0.2431620061,
-0.5619550943,
-0.1573614329,
-0.6135726571,
-0.2521974742,
0.0631183386,
-0.0674627721,
-0.3516404331,
-0.1141896918,
0.3566987216,
-0.3021254241,
0.413821429,
0.052948758,
-0.4240963161,
0.4044795036,
0.3457366526,
0.4394140542,
0.3771806955,
-0.333753705,
0.2669574022,
0.0106282989,
-0.4777595699,
0.0018257429,
0.3358507454,
-0.0273301173,
0.0022714869,
0.3211123347,
0.4804380238,
0.4124987125,
-0.1988510936,
0.5845615864,
0.3100841641,
0.0765391365,
-0.0429022573,
0.0712060705,
0.4175806046,
0.1777483225,
0.1815502048,
0.2059406191,
0.2155282199,
-0.7970027924,
0.4959463179,
0.4640723169,
-0.2129962295,
-0.2615793645,
0.2257439941,
0.7037503123,
0.2056435049,
0.5024245381,
-0.5079459548,
-0.6197420359,
0.5865266323,
0.2931438684,
0.8504961729,
-0.0797762647,
0.4275788963,
0.3387404382,
-0.0225991178,
0.0899417102,
0.243587181,
-0.2380362153,
-1.0342011452,
-0.2263263017,
-0.8346549273,
-0.734329164,
-0.1466618478,
-0.7259940505,
0.0125127481,
-0.5049256086,
0.1195124686,
0.3195743859,
-0.0436357558,
-1.0672066212,
0.2453750521,
0.1406859457,
0.8061589003,
-1.3759551048,
0.6327579021,
0.8058584332,
-0.7716347575,
-0.6911684275,
-0.131441012,
0.0236846786,
-0.6390093565,
0.7629618645,
0.2409292012,
0.1267929077,
-0.0540942885,
-0.6581662297,
-0.9541048408,
1.2162791491,
-0.2342290133,
-0.4599975348,
-0.073582828,
0.3031014204,
0.2258386314,
-0.8195329309,
0.1274701059,
0.3425595164,
0.2212181091,
0.2936618626,
-0.6183856726,
0.1251870096,
-0.2214714885,
0.1570317447,
-0.002664455,
-0.5165745616,
1.00230515,
-0.3428816795,
-0.2091135085,
-0.2508189976,
0.6033993959,
0.6350974441,
0.3505239487,
0.5113130808,
1.1136351824,
0.9063174725,
-0.2466959506,
0.9517731667,
-0.0203863084,
0.3968248665,
1.0582419634,
-0.2505775392,
0.9406186938,
0.4941394627,
-0.0299982503,
0.4750665128,
0.6064456701,
-0.0347417369,
0.8566296101,
0.2146347016,
-0.2247308642,
-0.3315436542,
-0.3245443404,
-0.4249829948,
0.4342123866,
0.8052176833,
0.0203483105,
-0.2970031798,
0.0131727159,
-0.0633962676,
0.0984484553,
-0.2986551225,
0.6907048821,
0.3076962233,
-0.2359024286,
0.274858743,
-0.2165399641,
1.2116883993,
-0.1090962365,
-0.214480564,
-0.409295857,
-0.1538625658,
-0.1976430714,
-1.0253709555,
0.2739614248,
-0.3772927225,
-0.0542879775,
-0.1738623679,
0.4821619689,
-0.3972630799,
-0.3196352422,
0.2144735456,
0.6506940126,
0.0326764397,
-0.0740965605,
-0.5104224086,
-0.4242955744,
-0.2897354364,
-0.0354335792,
0.2413735539,
0.891482532,
0.0353822298,
0.5522428155,
0.6558733582,
-0.0154374475,
-0.180144459,
0.0888446867,
0.9823337793,
-0.8746602535,
-0.5338237286,
-0.2930513322,
0.6614630222,
-0.156097725,
-0.4624440074,
0.2172978222,
0.278506875,
1.2103981972,
-0.0302312281,
0.8098284602,
0.0119155059,
0.3735768795,
-0.5852195024,
0.8198522329,
-0.7358806729,
0.3280616701,
-0.4466011524,
-0.8751726747,
-0.3872193396,
0.6609855294,
-0.0652436465,
0.2110111862,
0.5211957693,
0.7755225897,
-0.4992742538,
0.1743462682,
0.4282930195,
-0.1620490253,
0.1756717712,
0.427144438,
0.9933217168,
-0.0919543579,
0.1435841024,
-0.5304530859,
-0.1969614774,
-0.1832703501,
-0.8665729761,
-0.8497278094,
-0.6408423781,
-0.4280281067,
0.1210132465,
-0.0244735572,
0.8340415359,
0.807651937,
-0.9015575647,
0.1445174068,
-0.0328976102,
0.1539648622,
-0.0725825205,
-0.2172810286,
0.3724884093,
-0.4589906335,
-0.5382378697,
-0.4195024669,
0.2897334099,
0.1517489702,
-0.2418292463,
-0.0257555433,
-0.261662364,
0.2163338214,
0.720641017,
0.1106483415,
-0.919652462,
-0.3120387197,
-0.1300773621,
-0.0878740773,
0.0508869663,
0.6889648438,
-0.9182503223,
0.1021633297,
0.2586686611,
0.6023984551,
0.3126173317,
-0.3569194078,
0.3668648899,
-0.8721116781,
0.063453339,
0.26970613,
0.4105404913,
0.7227522135,
-0.2554979026,
0.6532712579,
0.4102729857,
0.0465605855,
-0.6331406832,
0.4846220016,
-0.9373890162,
-0.4236250818,
0.8895223737,
-0.3415518403,
-0.0359670632,
-0.2561326623,
0.38773036,
0.3460136056,
-0.3653600216,
0.6291252375,
0.5017739534,
0.0381562784,
-0.0466857515,
-0.2392590046,
0.4930074811,
0.3899092674,
-0.7555229664,
0.053985741,
0.1384778023,
0.53325212,
0.6371042132,
0.148757726,
-0.1657271683,
0.392906785,
0.0172748957,
-0.1557842344,
0.0531734787,
-0.5040730834,
-0.2104681581,
0.1583322734,
-0.0064272354,
-0.1898588985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16977v1
|
A comparison of Human, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4 Performance in a University-Level Coding Course
| 2024-03-25T17:41:02 | 2024-03-25T17:41:02 |
Will Yeadon, Alex Peach, Craig P. Testrow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study evaluates the performance of ChatGPT variants, GPT-3.5 and GPT-4,
both with and without prompt engineering, against solely student work and a
mixed category containing both student and GPT-4 contributions in
university-level physics coding assignments using the Python language.
Comparing 50 student submissions to 50 AI-generated submissions across
different categories, and marked blindly by three independent markers, we
amassed $n = 300$ data points. Students averaged 91.9% (SE:0.4), surpassing the
highest performing AI submission category, GPT-4 with prompt engineering, which
scored 81.1% (SE:0.8) - a statistically significant difference (p = $2.482
\times 10^{-10}$). Prompt engineering significantly improved scores for both
GPT-4 (p = $1.661 \times 10^{-4}$) and GPT-3.5 (p = $4.967 \times 10^{-9}$).
Additionally, the blinded markers were tasked with guessing the authorship of
the submissions on a four-point Likert scale from `Definitely AI' to
`Definitely Human'. They accurately identified the authorship, with 92.1% of
the work categorized as 'Definitely Human' being human-authored. Simplifying
this to a binary `AI' or `Human' categorization resulted in an average accuracy
rate of 85.3%. These findings suggest that while AI-generated work closely
approaches the quality of university students' work, it often remains
detectable by human evaluators.
|
[
-0.119880408,
-0.6059993505,
0.5579147935,
0.1839528233,
0.3534574807,
0.5597490668,
-0.0453062803,
-0.535799861,
-0.2559635043,
-0.229725644,
-0.0635210276,
-0.270671159,
-0.2506025136,
0.7165111303,
-0.2916415334,
0.9818052649,
-0.0791232511,
0.0623637587,
-0.3706491292,
0.4090385437,
-0.5930485129,
-0.6076782942,
-0.6720315218,
-0.5020244122,
0.4617244601,
0.248458147,
0.6382126808,
0.2998838723,
0.7019812465,
0.2879247069,
0.1331267953,
-0.5268981457,
-0.2234569788,
-0.5445946455,
-0.2017417699,
-0.3818536997,
-0.4699386954,
0.567104876,
0.4712150693,
0.419421047,
-0.1687617898,
0.1215684265,
0.160993889,
0.6956697702,
-0.2777460515,
0.1995735168,
-0.1384195983,
0.1169298813,
-0.1782571524,
-0.4285270572,
-0.6006482244,
-0.4417086244,
-0.0293178689,
-0.7782267928,
0.5348864198,
0.0450427048,
0.8065790534,
0.1113960445,
-0.1930240244,
-0.2253410518,
-0.4210986793,
0.6217290759,
-0.4768648744,
0.3380648792,
0.3289698958,
0.0092161624,
-0.1853784323,
-0.6378336549,
-0.4896685183,
-0.4395643473,
0.0406720638,
0.4574283659,
-0.1780050844,
0.4396386445,
0.5515735149,
0.6092972755,
-1.129614234,
0.2219875604,
-0.8454207778,
-0.5367699265,
0.7931108475,
-0.1260688156,
0.5617009401,
-0.2330030799,
0.067003876,
-0.2100138813,
-0.7973438501,
0.2735132873,
0.8845674992,
0.004786334,
-0.094668597,
0.7536948323,
-0.4778621197,
0.5119181871,
-0.0025927424,
0.0360821299,
0.3270540535,
-0.3474523723,
0.042487625,
-0.0087175015,
1.1165224314,
0.3574925363,
0.4067417085,
-0.2478729635,
-0.0872203857,
0.4134265482,
0.3247655332,
-0.6628007293,
-0.8394661546,
-0.0158238579,
-0.3199681044,
-0.1584421843,
0.0948980749,
-0.4175940156,
-0.2583476901,
-0.2722577155,
0.5915827751,
-0.2878853679,
-0.0732508376,
0.1235620901,
-0.2942351997,
0.2606159449,
0.3980416954,
-0.8020629883,
0.2244538665,
0.6244071722,
0.9856405258,
-0.2378140539,
-0.7431525588,
-0.3147032857,
-0.2627530694,
-0.2588069141,
0.6948871017,
-0.4149732888,
-0.4339782,
-0.4353495836,
-0.5409477949,
-0.054701969,
-0.3212834597,
0.5161495805,
-0.3966263533,
0.568695426,
-0.0157234855,
-0.6289302707,
0.025309734,
-0.1751718074,
-0.4346770346,
1.1175134182,
0.4770952761,
-0.5302679539,
0.505058527,
-0.9843702316,
-0.1715283543,
0.3189631701,
-0.4562199116,
-0.2421983033,
-0.2695778608,
-0.1176239848,
0.4287073314,
0.0126927402,
0.2067803293,
0.0445771813,
-0.8826528192,
0.4797445834,
-0.2717980444,
0.7301510572,
0.1909614503,
-0.5733882189,
0.0205477793,
-0.6435177922,
0.0646516979,
-0.0893604457,
-0.6106454134,
0.2266064584,
-0.1881005615,
-0.2560245991,
0.2135564536,
-0.0516283475,
-0.797527492,
0.5220043063,
-0.2391529083,
0.5319665074,
0.8236777186,
-0.1342281997,
0.3923566937,
-0.4042115808,
0.6978914738,
-0.4392196238,
-0.0872992799,
0.1956386417,
-1.1662815809,
-0.4226339161,
-0.1380840242,
0.2541683912,
0.624794364,
-0.7833426595,
0.1245380789,
0.0248114616,
-0.5220198035,
-0.5236133933,
0.1579039842,
0.6219789386,
0.5056517124,
0.4337460101,
-0.1712472737,
-0.3112570345,
-0.7780062556,
-0.7202881575,
-0.6501280069,
-0.6565176845,
0.0782990232,
0.6261438727,
-0.1289512366,
0.9776080847,
-0.4903414845,
-0.0638013706,
-0.0454691984,
0.5060324073,
0.4635860026,
0.8778100014,
0.4311254621,
-0.4523623288,
-0.5767120123,
-0.03536129,
-0.7329466343,
-0.1768807471,
-0.1611333042,
0.0228009541,
0.2515357435,
0.2182952315,
-0.594062686,
0.5874817371,
0.2652576864,
-0.7218706012,
0.9684666991,
-0.4189661145,
0.5713601708,
-0.5741688013,
0.0639670044,
0.3279919922,
-0.0751659945,
-0.4451605976,
0.1090434417,
0.2935536206,
-0.303455025,
-0.3774263263,
0.1500869691,
-0.4106268287,
-0.042625878,
0.0345060565,
-0.0636528879,
-0.2006456852,
0.6448235512,
-0.144355461,
1.1303380728,
0.5213996768,
-0.3696497679,
0.4971444905,
0.020321466,
-0.2300735712,
0.4504683316,
-0.8816783428,
0.5562376976,
0.3082963228,
0.2281557322,
-0.7725898027,
-0.4414229393,
0.2000169605,
-1.0261114836,
0.0784027129,
0.0490940213,
-0.5924870372,
-0.6630903482,
-0.4519214928,
0.6510047913,
0.8419426084,
-0.1505830288,
0.1280993074,
-0.1848340929,
-0.2871434689,
-0.2278603464,
-0.6954069138,
0.0894217044,
-0.0275209751,
-0.476659745,
0.1703320891,
-0.3139070868,
-0.0698112622,
-0.0705331266,
0.0564398989,
0.0136307394,
0.272616148,
0.1478145868,
0.3387388885,
-0.2035036087,
-0.4264191091,
-0.3767898977,
-0.2575120032,
0.2697716057,
-0.0370855778,
0.2942783237,
-0.4608971179,
-0.4431215823,
-0.9008877277,
0.1731138974,
0.1027377471,
0.144372493,
0.230411768,
0.5331664085,
-0.2422529012,
0.2363306284,
-0.4391593039,
-0.1126785949,
-0.5776994824,
0.3223211169,
-0.5530652404,
-1.0545128584,
0.3208476603,
0.4909996986,
-0.0636704788,
0.6127002239,
0.3070169985,
-0.2634879649,
1.0762940645,
0.5596971512,
-0.3062529564,
0.3003681898,
-0.2788568735,
0.3254300952,
-0.6964123845,
-0.2523341477,
-0.8170694113,
-0.2085874975,
-0.7720045447,
-0.1475847811,
0.3816064298,
0.2476755828,
-0.4636538923,
0.5131032467,
-1.0408564806,
0.8312548995,
0.828668952,
0.0454447046,
0.4072168469,
-0.146478951,
0.2598352134,
-0.0623522475,
-0.826140523,
-0.561306417,
1.3445625305,
0.3164607286,
0.7269076109,
0.3954355121,
0.6849626303,
0.6648889184,
0.3692973256,
-0.5256050825,
0.457221657,
0.2884215713,
-0.4315654337,
-0.3212994933,
-0.8383405209,
-1.0418649912,
-0.0310671721,
0.0307004508,
-1.0088015795,
-0.2490925193,
0.0551728867,
-0.4403179288,
0.2752785385,
-1.0684775114,
0.9627742171,
-0.0172816813,
-0.2601551116,
-0.178469345,
-0.5379799604,
0.132234171,
-0.1857758462,
0.2185319662,
0.058880426,
0.2080786824,
1.1496862173,
-0.2075875849,
0.621972084,
-0.050922934,
-0.0179295111,
0.4593886435,
0.1293243617,
0.1173586771,
0.3480479717,
-0.2288042456,
0.2048890442,
0.0296449475,
-0.7121907473,
-0.4373326898,
0.5983844995,
-1.3155114651,
-0.4772566855,
-0.7955348492,
-0.5006846786,
0.0198405851,
0.1416499615,
0.5609803796,
0.6851736903,
0.1296267956,
0.0452917106,
0.294323653,
-0.3066658378,
0.6022636294,
0.434053123,
0.0266505238,
-0.3183817863,
1.1674284935,
-0.0373479798,
0.1587482393,
0.2627597451,
0.1911393553,
-0.2961152494,
-0.429425478,
-0.6670307517,
0.1399044544,
-0.4976150393,
-0.2544085085,
-0.5602141619,
-0.2219312936,
-0.6547755599,
-0.6337171197,
-0.1639244854,
-0.1951983571,
-0.3683833182,
0.0884027779,
0.0867776796,
1.0647406578,
-0.0585444458,
0.0789347515,
-0.6036348939,
0.27332443,
0.269098103,
0.5957242846,
-0.3510419726,
-0.4601120055,
-0.1555577517,
0.1005578116,
-0.7011241317,
-0.7822816372,
-0.1380643398,
0.2240094095,
0.6426866055,
0.0893442556,
-0.0706526637,
0.4635623097,
-0.2286599725,
1.3307626247,
0.4779340923,
-1.19255054,
0.6240049005,
-0.4612196088,
0.3486967385,
0.4459643364,
0.391148895,
-0.4888983071,
-0.7054161429,
-0.7751205564,
-0.421222508,
0.9569951296,
0.7776155472,
-0.1180094928,
0.2121622264,
0.5315182209,
0.0693349764,
0.0613679998,
-0.9480255246,
-0.1656290144,
-0.2832131386,
-0.135752812,
-0.3050141335,
0.0887082592,
0.2499172688,
-0.4335612953,
0.5164724588,
-0.1707260609,
0.5911088586,
0.4202720225,
-0.0135590471,
0.1341720968,
0.2920841575,
0.6744174361,
0.9511306882,
-0.2821078002,
0.098611176,
-0.0811749473,
-0.8628541827,
0.2910303473,
-0.0123572042,
-0.0744022205,
-0.1515200436,
0.5788908601,
0.1993177235,
-0.1933728904,
-0.5824875236,
0.6626061201,
-0.1855277419,
-0.4433029294,
-0.0736398026,
0.3783653378,
-0.4493743777,
0.0054395446,
0.4978294373,
0.3251712918,
0.5187078118,
-0.5605946183,
0.0949482471,
-0.1081660166,
0.0427052639,
-0.7354544997,
1.0504765511,
0.3936632276,
-0.5169974566,
0.6628004909,
-0.524977088,
-0.6008091569,
0.7945149541,
0.5570409298,
0.8729221821,
-0.1715607047,
0.3557291627,
0.7415210009,
0.1962260306,
-0.2259005159,
0.3334313631,
-0.2146223634,
-0.3510040641,
-0.5724081993,
-0.3707765043,
-0.7691265345,
-0.1763436049,
-0.55206424,
0.1838676482,
-0.2817392945,
0.0645132586,
-0.1207137033,
0.3004104495,
-0.7409527898,
0.0582075343,
0.0612756722,
0.6805734634,
-0.7493334413,
0.5543861389,
1.0917037725,
-0.4576859772,
-1.1924422979,
-0.2393570989,
0.1115887985,
-0.2661497295,
0.4390384257,
0.2827936113,
0.0056470348,
0.2900848389,
-0.493162781,
-0.6791888475,
0.9866678715,
0.2046881765,
-0.226030007,
-0.0038553611,
0.3231723905,
0.6673694849,
0.2694468498,
0.8024510741,
0.4672465026,
0.1382043511,
-0.2001598775,
-1.4055937529,
-0.1240183488,
-0.4317807555,
-0.2682822049,
0.0752823278,
-0.6837738752,
0.9517647028,
-0.0981881022,
-0.218626976,
0.2114910483,
0.6080998778,
0.5739092827,
0.6370598078,
0.137597084,
0.2480838001,
0.8468437791,
-0.2737477422,
1.132140398,
-0.2525344491,
0.6433306336,
0.4902061522,
-0.0575477742,
0.5152397752,
0.3498516381,
-0.8277598023,
0.3982153535,
0.7530034184,
-0.0748448074,
0.2837718427,
0.4531413615,
-0.0562822185,
0.0570223927,
0.3712899983,
-0.7024805546,
0.2114928514,
-0.1827735901,
0.3550877571,
0.1399628967,
0.0640408695,
0.0659403279,
-0.056677714,
-0.3191490471,
0.5729819536,
0.0141658001,
-0.866535604,
0.4856159687,
0.0040538157,
0.893170476,
-0.236237973,
-0.1340623647,
-0.2261318266,
-0.0216736048,
-0.5795218349,
-1.1630275249,
-0.0071656941,
0.5390325189,
-0.0182618778,
-0.4798496664,
0.4075520039,
-0.0834062248,
-0.2701328993,
-0.3021779656,
0.1561714113,
0.6335591078,
-0.0314225256,
-0.4016494751,
-0.2342696786,
0.1215971857,
-0.2475598603,
0.194038555,
0.307343632,
0.083572261,
0.6643795371,
0.6649132371,
-0.0509380288,
0.1377866268,
-0.0598908253,
0.7633683085,
-0.81346488,
-0.7389621139,
-0.8833158612,
0.3811226785,
0.0346650183,
-0.6614605784,
0.9148454666,
1.0354982615,
1.2472858429,
-0.14258416,
0.7202682495,
-0.3020982146,
0.1403774619,
-0.5861279368,
0.5932531357,
-0.2624840736,
0.2834104002,
-0.8121495843,
-1.0438086987,
-0.279353112,
0.6106023192,
-0.1736575067,
0.1908045262,
0.7951999903,
0.4825177491,
0.130523622,
0.0302270669,
0.2847732902,
-0.2381511629,
0.796731472,
0.860717833,
1.2790936232,
-0.4084493816,
0.3868729174,
-0.551276803,
-0.4645091295,
-0.1279853582,
-0.588137567,
-0.9123264551,
-0.3724009991,
-0.7138517499,
-0.360598743,
-0.1956190765,
0.6878286004,
0.5414542556,
-0.6705761552,
-0.1495707035,
-0.2570869923,
-0.1010702997,
-0.2206933349,
-0.2649585605,
0.4228789508,
-0.2399113476,
-0.5519564152,
0.3852394819,
-0.055664666,
0.0525007024,
-0.0331240445,
-0.5276389718,
0.1499346197,
-0.2830622494,
0.5363203883,
0.2699889839,
-0.7175273299,
-0.5352162719,
0.1152048558,
-0.378349483,
0.1597268879,
0.6945453286,
-0.8834770322,
0.2580690384,
0.6227907538,
0.5627321601,
0.166859135,
0.3454776406,
0.4128755331,
-0.5730515122,
0.0229998436,
0.3859157264,
0.3191085756,
0.2374695688,
-0.6636009216,
0.762742281,
0.6311855912,
-1.2534765005,
-0.7307305336,
-0.2262105346,
-1.1542944908,
-0.0565550365,
1.0615627766,
-0.1304140836,
0.1560104638,
-0.154552415,
-0.5209637284,
0.1223200932,
-0.6090755463,
0.918030858,
0.6530783772,
-0.726229012,
0.1285681427,
-0.7973857522,
0.5701611042,
0.5029312968,
-0.777104497,
-0.5283385515,
0.5811964869,
0.2111857682,
0.1700411737,
0.9750989079,
0.1079196483,
0.7721210122,
0.1919801533,
0.46132496,
-0.1179285273,
-0.0992807299,
-0.2650360167,
0.1586294323,
0.1558813751,
-0.1716730297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16973v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16973v3
|
VoiceCraft: Zero-Shot Speech Editing and Text-to-Speech in the Wild
| 2024-03-25T17:38:32 | 2024-06-14T00:29:46 |
Puyuan Peng, Po-Yao Huang, Shang-Wen Li, Abdelrahman Mohamed, David Harwath
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
We introduce VoiceCraft, a token infilling neural codec language model, that
achieves state-of-the-art performance on both speech editing and zero-shot
text-to-speech (TTS) on audiobooks, internet videos, and podcasts. VoiceCraft
employs a Transformer decoder architecture and introduces a token rearrangement
procedure that combines causal masking and delayed stacking to enable
generation within an existing sequence. On speech editing tasks, VoiceCraft
produces edited speech that is nearly indistinguishable from unedited
recordings in terms of naturalness, as evaluated by humans; for zero-shot TTS,
our model outperforms prior SotA models including VALLE and the popular
commercial model XTTS-v2. Crucially, the models are evaluated on challenging
and realistic datasets, that consist of diverse accents, speaking styles,
recording conditions, and background noise and music, and our model performs
consistently well compared to other models and real recordings. In particular,
for speech editing evaluation, we introduce a high quality, challenging, and
realistic dataset named RealEdit. We encourage readers to listen to the demos
at https://jasonppy.github.io/VoiceCraft_web.
|
[
-0.0438518152,
-0.8982341886,
0.282377094,
0.1347303092,
-0.0853601769,
0.4322480261,
-0.3099856377,
-0.5034201145,
0.1794706285,
0.6584146619,
-0.7077278495,
-0.6005122662,
-0.3607893288,
0.0373671204,
-0.6771053672,
0.9489868879,
0.4280274808,
0.0578165501,
-0.1864859313,
-0.0620398186,
-0.6868910193,
-0.6483594179,
-0.6995227933,
-0.2464481741,
0.4024123251,
0.2821418941,
0.8337230086,
0.8114763498,
0.0458846726,
0.2494746596,
-0.4622234404,
0.0220752116,
-0.4250681102,
0.2261223793,
-0.1732662916,
-0.4425802231,
-0.7142454982,
0.0544563457,
0.3955109417,
0.4301924407,
-0.1557928473,
0.4753025472,
-0.2387223542,
0.0884646848,
-0.4119469523,
-0.2805292606,
-0.937823534,
0.2191084325,
-0.2049160749,
-0.0846630111,
-0.4036345482,
-0.133916676,
0.1383912861,
-0.6598742604,
0.5349986553,
-0.0620317906,
0.4136473238,
0.3386126161,
-0.0260416754,
0.0087208468,
-0.8742660284,
0.5722135305,
-0.863448441,
0.3977100253,
0.2354244143,
0.2306934893,
-0.1962068528,
-0.9783157706,
-1.0077109337,
0.125232324,
0.4419876635,
0.1552348286,
-0.4193432629,
0.3760779798,
0.4138645828,
0.3206709325,
-0.6829949617,
0.2359699011,
-0.2150417268,
-0.1156249717,
0.5379786491,
0.1052784473,
0.4906478822,
-0.2404455096,
0.113330029,
-0.1632245332,
-0.5278162956,
0.0629793629,
0.6425597668,
0.5877748728,
-0.0112291267,
0.6414073706,
0.0512129068,
0.9888014793,
-0.0133269709,
-0.1259523481,
0.0529366322,
0.0341932625,
-0.5702887177,
0.5293033123,
0.5789522529,
0.3198711872,
0.1451419443,
-0.3102055192,
0.0198523141,
-0.0203774739,
0.3399775028,
-0.7638031244,
-0.0922395363,
0.4628054798,
-0.5812997222,
-0.7478399873,
-0.2399363518,
-0.5983408093,
-0.6311267614,
-0.2397300452,
0.5373803377,
-0.1023753509,
-0.5432222486,
0.242085278,
-0.5234439969,
-0.0741975829,
0.1829867065,
-0.8433563113,
0.4478554726,
0.78451401,
1.023724556,
-0.3777314723,
-0.3436978459,
-0.6854205728,
-0.1407179981,
-0.3924325109,
0.7640959024,
-0.6370251775,
-0.8169957399,
-0.0947845951,
-0.1034071669,
0.2487418503,
-0.6857202649,
0.5447232127,
-0.2652435303,
0.1687350422,
0.2059068382,
-0.5920869708,
-0.0412469767,
0.1268800944,
-0.5594471097,
1.0435813665,
-0.0801948458,
-0.2439604253,
0.2087877691,
-0.8773347735,
-0.3076148927,
-0.0786309466,
0.217885077,
-0.2751049101,
0.3589396477,
-0.0045734108,
0.3210507333,
-0.2303211689,
0.424462676,
-0.1251307279,
-0.4642399251,
0.3898716569,
-0.8675799966,
0.6519644856,
0.252992332,
-0.2692964077,
0.4503077269,
-0.9943947196,
0.2616812885,
-0.0246985722,
-0.0301434305,
0.087832652,
-0.012464121,
0.4547589123,
0.2782921791,
-0.3506005108,
-0.9746391177,
0.3235881925,
-0.6148656011,
0.7755986452,
0.5110199451,
-0.0474246591,
0.2434786856,
-0.2638519108,
0.6051481366,
-0.1226580814,
0.2591564953,
-0.4104572833,
-0.7323887348,
-0.3895059526,
-0.1197432652,
0.5136908889,
0.7171179056,
-0.5369055867,
0.1121920794,
-0.2914893627,
-0.7215679288,
-0.8330128789,
-0.3240809739,
0.366681546,
0.6376674175,
0.5067312717,
-0.2046781778,
-0.6400886178,
-0.4470760822,
-0.680570364,
-0.0897796005,
-0.2494543791,
0.1552515626,
0.0387171134,
0.0289381985,
1.1477051973,
-0.1972562373,
-0.0742286816,
-0.3252466917,
0.2438485771,
0.2556720972,
0.5870866776,
0.4100218415,
-0.5182308555,
-0.4181439579,
-0.0689489543,
-0.3569437265,
-0.1907061338,
-0.2848041654,
0.1524183005,
-0.0544947423,
0.4290033281,
-0.6979969144,
0.711391747,
0.6655550599,
-0.3885545135,
0.5957556963,
-0.0665741935,
0.1471272558,
-1.0394468307,
-0.0553848781,
-0.3968897462,
-0.4960113168,
-0.9428511858,
-0.2027962059,
-0.2701027393,
-0.6019442677,
-0.8391472697,
0.5332026482,
-0.0460314639,
-0.1501226425,
-0.3019428253,
0.0880542621,
-0.0275799241,
0.4506603777,
0.0860034451,
1.0389195681,
0.5513060689,
-0.0887574255,
0.5774112344,
0.3614243865,
-0.100379467,
0.4809915721,
-0.8803200722,
0.4910908937,
0.033720389,
0.2180544585,
-0.7546143532,
0.0437762141,
-0.0120319705,
-0.8273492455,
0.2981848419,
-0.2850157619,
-0.472966224,
-0.1195174381,
-0.2331789732,
0.2622582912,
0.5303943157,
-0.6414223909,
0.5780870914,
0.3604741693,
-0.2354500443,
-0.3783590496,
-0.9750970006,
0.6546047926,
0.0343761593,
-0.4027973115,
0.7907028794,
-0.1689666957,
-0.1554460973,
0.1711494327,
-0.1649406701,
-0.2490277439,
-0.2562093735,
0.5428960919,
0.2212373763,
-0.1681997627,
0.0128679341,
0.111976549,
-0.0817539617,
-0.1712393016,
-0.5855804682,
0.3573369086,
0.1565472037,
-0.2604666948,
-0.657042563,
0.3737850785,
0.7084760666,
-0.1072277874,
0.2653985023,
0.3694377244,
-0.3838663995,
-0.1161312833,
-0.6291304827,
0.0329855159,
-0.4469206035,
0.3693889976,
-0.3091373146,
-1.0107944012,
0.4933879077,
-0.1666498631,
0.1957453489,
0.2928669155,
0.2859740555,
-0.0617411472,
1.126713872,
0.4539856613,
0.0891612768,
0.5929749012,
-0.3234450817,
0.0052915602,
-0.5116734505,
-0.0942429304,
-0.5350837111,
-0.4489924312,
-0.5116378069,
-0.537789762,
0.1649593264,
-0.2694047093,
-0.0287785362,
0.4256618619,
-0.7966828346,
0.8846960664,
0.5191236734,
-0.0145476386,
0.2509974241,
0.0361005776,
-0.0223283041,
-0.2222885042,
-0.8266080618,
-0.3784283698,
1.2185306549,
0.2121495754,
0.3296098113,
-0.0765481144,
0.4289490283,
0.5597527623,
0.1545505375,
-0.7792928219,
0.2949308753,
-0.3116199076,
-0.8091759086,
-0.3956731856,
-0.037430048,
-0.5321198702,
0.0894382969,
-0.3757461607,
-0.7106247544,
0.0891696587,
0.2276733667,
-0.6552035213,
0.7576355338,
-0.6095201373,
0.9234671593,
-0.0725734383,
-0.4249838889,
-0.2102329731,
-0.6579809189,
0.088201113,
0.2592720985,
0.00872894,
0.0474760607,
0.2805175185,
0.5247008801,
-0.4806699753,
0.8478370309,
-0.363596946,
0.2918758392,
0.5760934949,
0.3801876605,
0.2570669949,
0.0193305556,
-0.2351913452,
0.5326248407,
0.390534848,
-0.0384202152,
-0.8514917493,
0.6346214414,
-0.7784210443,
-0.3963805735,
-0.354305476,
-0.2026644945,
-0.3036420643,
0.2662540674,
0.2776994109,
0.7768387198,
-0.482277602,
0.2778507471,
0.6289553046,
-0.5033470988,
0.6597989798,
0.2691722512,
-0.3055811822,
-0.6745248437,
0.9073066115,
0.1191561371,
0.1826291978,
0.0783145353,
0.1490355432,
-0.2115154415,
-0.5761195421,
-0.8291943669,
-0.0938462988,
-0.4335927963,
-0.276216507,
-0.6733459234,
-0.3458339274,
-0.3789975345,
-0.1115847528,
-0.70503968,
-0.7298322916,
-0.4462841749,
-0.2731459141,
0.3790523708,
0.8456266522,
-0.069225885,
0.588473022,
-0.7320736051,
0.549934268,
0.4353874624,
0.4720517099,
-0.1114001721,
-0.6910331249,
0.0356624015,
0.1060426906,
-0.1988614798,
-0.8570898771,
0.4644390345,
0.3156905472,
0.1678462327,
-0.0963606536,
-0.1451317072,
1.0984927416,
-0.6950882673,
1.3266750574,
0.1993998736,
-1.2755903006,
0.3343491256,
-0.2295242697,
0.3999199569,
0.417005688,
-0.3260263205,
-1.0573210716,
-0.215791136,
-0.7322046161,
-0.5039320588,
0.7294172645,
0.2963820398,
0.4909037054,
0.0577086397,
0.4592352509,
0.1883358806,
0.3690397143,
-0.3141729832,
-0.2301193625,
-0.7276765108,
-0.2016280144,
0.1135227755,
-0.4185814559,
0.1835461557,
-0.4639238715,
0.5718587637,
0.0324340425,
0.2985903025,
0.3884500265,
0.0075646564,
-0.2528870702,
0.2470451295,
0.844070673,
0.3019269407,
-0.1381256431,
0.0172882788,
0.3547070622,
-0.752291441,
-0.0268531106,
-0.1864042133,
-0.1047957689,
0.3434775472,
0.2902300358,
1.1281797886,
0.2238339931,
-0.6459608078,
0.5501730442,
-0.3206522167,
-0.4061811268,
-0.2700151205,
0.0840143859,
-0.0423795767,
0.1053748652,
0.0670614317,
0.4567828178,
0.1510716081,
-0.317032814,
0.0367194228,
0.1542940885,
-0.4716231823,
-0.5441935062,
1.0799936056,
0.2607504725,
-0.896934092,
0.6250408292,
0.03230929,
-0.2950523794,
0.4052458405,
0.8185801506,
1.4690746069,
-0.0492778756,
0.1990410686,
0.1981205791,
0.1610389352,
0.0719473436,
0.3046712279,
-0.2870096862,
-0.4668264389,
-0.6583077312,
-0.5470763445,
-0.6547361016,
0.2182584554,
-0.3865275383,
0.3891840577,
-0.5742419362,
-0.3658883274,
0.1339566857,
-0.4271858931,
-0.5531215668,
0.2573436201,
0.1364453435,
1.0758917332,
-0.5078140497,
0.8472910523,
0.2936303914,
-0.0905851349,
-0.8383803964,
0.0060566147,
0.2175075859,
-0.4002078474,
0.3218890727,
-0.0017765437,
-0.2736425996,
0.4520608485,
-0.704862535,
-0.7453882694,
0.9309315681,
0.4846904576,
-0.5375450253,
-0.0262523293,
0.3024534583,
0.5990040898,
-0.1127141118,
0.3087563813,
0.5797652602,
0.2113100886,
0.2468620241,
-1.1504317522,
-0.6220365167,
-0.3024981022,
0.0788989887,
-0.2438225448,
-0.3765312433,
0.5549442768,
0.0773943365,
-0.1084032059,
0.1117163002,
0.4571075439,
-0.0521337017,
0.3634969592,
0.3996424675,
0.5864265561,
0.6084411144,
-0.0713098198,
0.7165056467,
-0.2940270901,
-0.0050467127,
1.2726897001,
-0.1887961328,
0.8980183005,
0.3331893981,
-0.1630729735,
0.3627304137,
0.4631464183,
0.1331549287,
0.2961406112,
0.2048468441,
-0.4548653364,
-0.1144456342,
-0.2872267663,
-0.1758824885,
0.8535781503,
0.129266113,
0.0374721773,
0.1871295869,
0.2112285197,
0.1113162711,
0.1242247522,
-0.1391118616,
0.9095851183,
-0.2788087428,
-0.4917910397,
0.3746140301,
0.1576342881,
0.711820066,
-0.536429584,
-0.2891237736,
-0.0056826631,
-0.2151878625,
-0.3477170169,
-0.7101758122,
0.5903710723,
0.6221510172,
-0.2884253561,
-0.6208578348,
0.7683544755,
-0.3895382583,
-0.3306136429,
-0.025674399,
0.2486215085,
0.1414877325,
-0.3600546122,
-0.6633014679,
0.2920634449,
-0.1340948641,
-0.2724009752,
-0.0170591269,
0.2607380152,
0.0980245695,
0.1998045295,
1.125951767,
0.4565548301,
0.1770301908,
0.3180335462,
0.595317781,
-0.6645838022,
-0.62697047,
-0.8627462983,
0.7530983686,
-0.2576554418,
-0.4830655456,
0.5728117824,
0.6607421041,
0.8665822148,
-0.1661978215,
0.877643168,
0.0621362701,
0.6543087363,
-0.2360557616,
0.8483628631,
-0.3394846618,
-0.1522803009,
-0.3679057956,
-0.7989398837,
-0.6939564347,
0.2741542757,
0.0962749496,
-0.318118602,
0.3444822431,
0.9345013499,
0.0253802277,
0.3462084532,
0.7588434815,
0.1418274194,
0.4224240184,
-0.0472593047,
0.7629643679,
-0.5479856133,
0.5428291559,
-0.2504173517,
-0.1180294454,
0.1508159041,
-0.9736730456,
-0.8048996329,
-0.4108323753,
-0.255032748,
-0.2143531442,
0.1617001295,
1.1980023384,
0.8782263398,
-0.7918565869,
-0.3709540963,
-0.2486132979,
0.0241634063,
-0.3755635023,
-0.1744523644,
-0.0489194989,
0.060151305,
-0.8546920419,
0.8747621775,
0.6180459261,
0.0964231119,
-0.1764151752,
0.0345637798,
0.1325397938,
0.2576166689,
0.6019117236,
0.4210996032,
-0.8288692236,
-0.1978552192,
0.2789246142,
0.2257234901,
0.0110436864,
1.037307024,
-0.9311440587,
1.0660574436,
0.4178802073,
0.6387589574,
0.596014142,
0.0143071692,
0.4282855392,
-0.9152076244,
0.403709054,
0.3799340725,
-0.217411831,
0.325429827,
-0.3132594824,
0.2300353944,
0.3331664205,
-0.5642104149,
-1.0936574936,
-0.0272841305,
-0.8359382749,
-0.0916012228,
0.8662772179,
0.0823645368,
-0.2328360677,
0.0108620999,
-0.5183114409,
0.6147038341,
-0.0964071006,
0.6116420627,
0.5706138611,
-0.113221921,
-0.169965297,
-0.7717528939,
0.666767776,
0.2602128685,
-0.5150091052,
0.2265967131,
0.4932079911,
0.2289662808,
-0.1219783649,
0.4116474092,
-0.1290944815,
0.3387916088,
0.2296308875,
0.3811057508,
-0.5983086824,
-0.3964676559,
-0.7238746881,
0.1179352775,
-0.1177213341,
-0.326658994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16971v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16971v2
|
AIOS: LLM Agent Operating System
| 2024-03-25T17:32:23 | 2024-03-26T02:35:07 |
Kai Mei, Zelong Li, Shuyuan Xu, Ruosong Ye, Yingqiang Ge, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.OS
|
cs.OS, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The integration and deployment of large language model (LLM)-based
intelligent agents have been fraught with challenges that compromise their
efficiency and efficacy. Among these issues are sub-optimal scheduling and
resource allocation of agent requests over the LLM, the difficulties in
maintaining context during interactions between agent and LLM, and the
complexities inherent in integrating heterogeneous agents with different
capabilities and specializations. The rapid increase of agent quantity and
complexity further exacerbates these issues, often leading to bottlenecks and
sub-optimal utilization of resources. Inspired by these challenges, this paper
presents AIOS, an LLM agent operating system, which embeds large language model
into operating systems (OS) as the brain of the OS, enabling an operating
system "with soul" -- an important step towards AGI. Specifically, AIOS is
designed to optimize resource allocation, facilitate context switch across
agents, enable concurrent execution of agents, provide tool service for agents,
and maintain access control for agents. We present the architecture of such an
operating system, outline the core challenges it aims to resolve, and provide
the basic design and implementation of the AIOS. Our experiments on concurrent
execution of multiple agents demonstrate the reliability and efficiency of our
AIOS modules. Through this, we aim to not only improve the performance and
efficiency of LLM agents but also to pioneer for better development and
deployment of the AIOS ecosystem in the future. The project is open-source at
https://github.com/agiresearch/AIOS.
|
[
-0.3003983796,
-0.334464699,
0.6798551679,
0.1901364028,
-0.0240082983,
0.4042682946,
-0.1078629196,
-0.5634438992,
0.1752850562,
0.5289849043,
-0.5105900168,
-0.1870709509,
-0.6322755218,
0.1372449398,
-0.1505660564,
0.8321101069,
0.1629451066,
-0.0111901639,
-0.3732453883,
-0.1095879748,
-0.4144377112,
-0.1392378211,
-0.9267001748,
-0.4924112558,
-0.0684795976,
0.3591267467,
0.9317688346,
0.952365756,
0.5485699773,
0.5406830907,
0.2784319222,
0.0871103257,
-0.0719492137,
0.3098227084,
-0.278814584,
-0.3625718057,
-0.7736759186,
-0.0507434309,
0.7831575871,
0.1812395155,
-0.2215013653,
-0.142126292,
-0.1531723589,
0.4153776169,
-0.5347085595,
0.0188960694,
-0.7266752124,
0.1142712831,
-0.1484820396,
-0.2763372958,
-0.0773669854,
-0.1081113443,
0.1805859506,
-0.7992739081,
-0.5204219818,
0.0855854228,
0.3898893893,
0.6170796752,
-0.2894419432,
-0.5417993069,
-0.5078394413,
1.000492692,
-0.5621801019,
0.2593356669,
-0.0130903898,
0.2718198001,
-0.1294484586,
-0.4133840501,
-0.636793375,
-0.4064875543,
0.0772233531,
-0.0618519783,
0.0786785781,
0.2493189573,
-0.2240275145,
0.2692048252,
-0.2968659103,
0.1782587469,
0.0214510858,
-0.2600384057,
0.5754600763,
0.3922581673,
0.6217854023,
0.3924209774,
-0.4126802087,
0.1712817401,
-0.408545047,
-0.0743136853,
0.5214633942,
0.2657060027,
-0.0730163902,
0.463165015,
-0.2352000177,
0.5538879037,
-0.2818441093,
-0.4190275371,
0.2262773812,
0.0909807011,
-0.0631439984,
-0.0748602226,
0.7128117681,
0.2532014251,
0.3214881718,
-0.5848755836,
-0.512757957,
0.3035974503,
0.5089010596,
-0.6285480261,
0.5025418401,
0.4255404174,
-0.2021197826,
-0.2412121892,
-0.2831890583,
-0.2777689397,
-0.2313765734,
-0.2112386525,
0.1314783096,
-0.5718761683,
-0.0844026282,
-0.2207426131,
-0.1021501645,
0.1332875937,
0.5774108768,
-0.7843096852,
0.6300247908,
0.8453403115,
0.885368824,
-0.3908542693,
-0.5304530859,
-0.577819705,
0.4542901814,
-0.1380506456,
0.6591723561,
-0.654387176,
-0.5049181581,
-0.2728573382,
0.0121038705,
0.1037313789,
-0.4112946689,
0.1371104121,
-0.5821093917,
-0.0564177819,
-0.0549912862,
-0.4596523345,
0.0244245306,
0.4204621613,
-0.1636761278,
0.6324939728,
0.0560026169,
-0.095571138,
-0.1911312193,
-1.0581350327,
-0.4704937935,
0.400993824,
-0.3471162021,
0.083622314,
0.0315086208,
-0.3856256902,
0.1450747252,
-0.6994540095,
0.1043320894,
-0.1816984862,
-0.4071533382,
0.1386489123,
-0.1188897491,
0.6701421738,
0.6909678578,
-0.2050528377,
0.02787962,
-0.3409510851,
0.0889545977,
0.3142006397,
-0.1589973718,
-0.3413295448,
0.382877171,
-0.1109233648,
-0.2168194056,
0.6976106763,
-0.5424392223,
0.7353066206,
-0.1879605949,
0.4487590492,
0.8978638649,
-0.5333771706,
0.7167451382,
-0.1146110967,
0.4324920177,
-0.1165571362,
0.6268156767,
0.0292769838,
-0.3265449107,
-0.3509619236,
-0.3085887432,
-0.4969625175,
0.9587833881,
-0.7348043323,
0.278355062,
-0.0950297415,
-0.2223288268,
-0.3582137823,
0.3304249048,
0.4979367554,
0.452440232,
0.0318568647,
-0.2986171246,
-0.0541881286,
-1.1133908033,
0.1021651849,
-0.2689953446,
0.0524267033,
0.4412968159,
0.4712228775,
-0.6790748835,
1.0315477848,
-0.3093695045,
-0.2896319628,
0.1479739696,
-0.269525975,
-0.0018963431,
0.518234551,
0.6636025906,
-0.7378306985,
-0.4244654179,
0.3904403448,
-1.0655082464,
-0.2954704762,
0.3450874984,
-0.0654953569,
0.2690740526,
0.3632979691,
-0.5595197082,
-0.1498220414,
0.5515590906,
-0.3472755253,
0.3260971308,
-0.3337974846,
0.1557690054,
-0.9643409848,
0.0974505097,
-0.4458020627,
-0.1503291726,
-0.4501710236,
0.3788239956,
-0.2455869168,
-0.2229546607,
-0.3805107474,
0.8974752426,
-0.3814465404,
-0.4629147053,
-0.6665805578,
0.0510959439,
-0.031831149,
0.1474224329,
-0.2053694129,
1.2540847063,
0.7654389739,
-0.6685853601,
0.7404791713,
0.046653349,
0.1521319449,
0.7594136596,
-0.6264088154,
0.2562138438,
-0.0216900557,
0.1096480563,
-0.5166609287,
-0.2295534611,
0.4094460011,
-0.1717952043,
0.1049607247,
0.1024399772,
-0.3405843377,
-0.2221001089,
-0.2694170475,
0.4345172942,
0.3295274079,
-0.2956715822,
0.9243447781,
0.6946572661,
-0.1529530138,
-1.011903882,
-0.4579416811,
0.3770641983,
-0.094698973,
-0.727211833,
0.3560782075,
-0.1891266406,
-0.6507666111,
0.5389730334,
0.2255132049,
0.1733543575,
0.3289620578,
0.2244759053,
0.0260240063,
-0.1585044861,
0.2666192651,
0.1622381359,
-0.2378048152,
-0.2291601002,
-0.5491213202,
0.3532143533,
-0.6288468838,
-0.3728834689,
-0.557287395,
0.6030864716,
1.0884495974,
-0.2282524109,
0.5383046865,
0.064365916,
-0.2428780049,
-0.215513438,
-0.6288481951,
-0.066711843,
-0.5248241425,
0.4004963636,
-0.4893414676,
-0.6857550144,
0.7672924399,
-0.2585431933,
0.2811844945,
0.2339143157,
0.4503077269,
-0.1681851447,
0.8359960914,
0.716563642,
-0.2929522395,
0.6751813293,
-0.2063868195,
-0.0721552074,
-0.9585708976,
-0.1280581653,
-0.184742406,
-0.2705338597,
-0.225043118,
-0.3221974373,
0.5160831213,
-0.2003528476,
-0.3451637626,
-0.0666735172,
-0.7310294509,
0.464828223,
0.485137552,
-0.3666230142,
0.3166857064,
-0.2074486315,
0.1686407924,
0.585919857,
-0.3545250893,
-0.7761538029,
0.7349683046,
0.4537639022,
0.799433887,
0.2432155907,
0.5640730858,
0.8877313137,
0.3161249161,
-0.8819799423,
0.7886988521,
-0.3385955989,
-0.5145848393,
-0.7136030793,
-0.1083674282,
-0.8112438917,
0.3051751256,
0.1375321448,
-1.0031501055,
0.0857404172,
0.1182346791,
-0.2599696517,
0.2256325185,
-0.8377406001,
0.5272189975,
-0.5537952781,
-0.4229212701,
-0.3607608974,
-0.6528269649,
0.0740749836,
0.1702586561,
0.209008202,
-0.3312927186,
-0.4495575428,
0.3756021857,
-0.812042594,
0.4647926092,
-0.196995616,
-0.1558483243,
0.5947959423,
-0.1464493573,
0.8473040462,
0.0193549842,
-0.3237124383,
0.1271966249,
-0.2210009992,
-0.2540594041,
-0.4691283703,
0.8960294127,
-1.0449861288,
-0.6308506131,
-0.4487469494,
-0.8479086757,
0.0444560237,
0.0800390914,
-0.0478216335,
0.1791336387,
-0.1578063369,
-0.0391049683,
0.4993662536,
-0.2942431569,
0.5323399901,
0.6044591069,
-0.1573506594,
-0.3224867582,
0.9816425443,
0.1478469074,
0.273891598,
0.1410118788,
-0.0311358087,
-0.1055633724,
-0.5445230007,
-0.6552776694,
0.0884334445,
-0.5181288719,
-0.102520369,
-0.7247196436,
-0.1792266667,
-0.6184000969,
-0.4322133362,
-0.6870221496,
0.0918109715,
-0.2430095673,
0.4500321746,
0.3677701652,
0.6900209188,
-0.0492344387,
0.757704556,
-0.4385201335,
0.3901202679,
0.4204198718,
0.5693161488,
0.021589173,
-0.1033895016,
-0.3689321876,
-0.1320961118,
-0.2776054442,
-0.8972888589,
0.3050474226,
0.0974626392,
0.6869291067,
0.5253014565,
-0.2486703247,
0.2085424662,
-0.4445229173,
0.4169645011,
-0.0848914981,
-1.0365210772,
0.5162963867,
-0.4332195222,
0.191947192,
0.576038897,
0.0197358653,
-0.5476899147,
-0.4923072755,
-0.2090526819,
-0.8212991357,
1.0289047956,
0.0742922649,
-0.039564617,
0.1386578828,
0.5212835073,
-0.0489162989,
0.4495683014,
-0.5606136322,
-0.0775723755,
-0.0564110652,
-0.1478674561,
0.0251510646,
0.0582512058,
-0.1889815629,
0.1552345306,
0.9649918079,
-0.4964455366,
0.3521407843,
0.1293621063,
-0.1447211802,
-0.2414868027,
0.2184072435,
0.5202918053,
0.3051787019,
-0.1749074906,
0.1004744247,
0.2438932806,
-0.6129934192,
0.2525756657,
-0.0497929268,
-0.4380151331,
-0.6241146326,
0.1252555549,
0.8786417842,
-0.5083311796,
-0.9262226224,
0.1938902587,
0.0374426581,
0.3648360074,
-0.5136280656,
0.3590581119,
-0.0009261888,
0.8598781824,
0.8031437397,
-0.1819051802,
0.4438261688,
-0.9830836654,
-0.1619527787,
0.88384372,
-0.0307773184,
-0.0850946307,
0.4558564126,
0.4853112102,
-0.5894383788,
0.6082035303,
-0.3715336323,
-0.6188999414,
0.9129033089,
0.4016748071,
1.0998414755,
-0.3956993818,
0.0170320645,
-0.3998968005,
0.6712630987,
-0.0362453572,
0.4059200585,
-0.095560059,
-0.7541350126,
-0.1901861131,
-0.8091730475,
-0.6484939456,
-0.0424781963,
0.0091392174,
0.0385717154,
-0.4396800399,
-0.3039735854,
-0.5627310276,
0.0945626348,
-0.2794012129,
0.3938825727,
0.444662869,
0.6165403724,
-0.6804376841,
0.8372796178,
1.037719965,
0.0992871299,
-0.2123273611,
-0.1081984118,
0.0004951271,
-1.0586138964,
0.5682277083,
-0.0728529319,
-0.4957504869,
0.1260875165,
-0.3966276348,
-1.104991436,
1.2447617054,
0.5580355525,
-0.4531086683,
-0.004193496,
0.195847258,
0.4235647619,
-0.6503762007,
0.3049371541,
0.1196915656,
0.6554284096,
-0.0010543237,
-0.8629929423,
0.0569528416,
-0.3924320638,
0.0310066715,
0.1568118781,
-1.0690034628,
0.87868011,
-0.3719675839,
-0.0949191451,
0.1389024854,
0.5131123066,
0.192056939,
0.5113327503,
0.7969896197,
0.6316084266,
0.6417008638,
-0.0747216493,
1.1968128681,
-0.5993075371,
0.0155416811,
0.7892261744,
-0.5204336643,
0.3000794053,
0.5373015404,
-0.0483809412,
0.2341219336,
0.3607288897,
0.1804698855,
0.4799990654,
0.0371916145,
-0.4924488366,
-0.1120404378,
-0.539573431,
-0.4316414595,
0.4005916119,
0.5068355799,
-0.0269623213,
-0.0188584421,
0.2438668609,
-0.2019269019,
-0.2588362098,
-0.1914298981,
0.6852394342,
0.0819898397,
-0.6506842375,
-0.0976074263,
-0.0110348091,
0.7078986168,
-0.9755290747,
0.2047022432,
-0.1369252652,
0.2498729825,
-0.0633748397,
-0.597928226,
0.3566008508,
-0.0593063757,
-0.2307792455,
-0.4081068039,
0.794054389,
-0.084115915,
-0.1069151685,
0.6582605839,
0.3154338598,
0.1835243255,
0.0156270042,
-0.700350821,
0.4843588471,
-0.4938797057,
-0.4317035377,
0.341591686,
0.5582384467,
-0.1402050108,
1.0242226124,
0.4069150388,
0.0032338153,
-0.1568418741,
-0.3824948668,
0.6723085046,
-0.4386488497,
-0.6406908631,
-0.9303517342,
0.2292093337,
-0.019246906,
-0.2078401595,
0.389803648,
0.5559212565,
0.3558018208,
0.0185405891,
0.8456868529,
-0.26468876,
-0.0303306263,
-0.2343904227,
0.7368245721,
-1.0575188398,
0.2805161774,
-0.1487500519,
-0.8151994944,
0.1663312316,
0.3577131927,
-0.1296308786,
0.104611963,
0.4005304873,
0.6116204262,
0.0747706294,
-0.2720134258,
0.3339052498,
0.2793509364,
0.1753868759,
0.4669279754,
0.8046841025,
-0.1965086609,
0.0988389477,
-0.1556091309,
-0.3434455097,
-0.4527342916,
-0.7054601312,
-0.2920162976,
-0.5764440894,
-0.2696869075,
0.012236611,
0.4414865971,
1.0019943714,
0.6513666511,
-0.5496905446,
-0.7422596812,
-0.0387800895,
0.4330812693,
-0.0648691282,
-0.1985258907,
-0.1516728848,
-0.4434429109,
-1.1076655388,
0.600918591,
0.7981503606,
0.0430191495,
-0.3272306621,
-0.4940172732,
-0.1712956131,
0.2051971406,
0.6624528766,
0.4720535874,
-0.6948359013,
-0.1697247177,
0.1001877263,
-0.5329615474,
-0.319454968,
0.5773682594,
-0.6078052521,
0.2331478,
0.3416989446,
0.8945565224,
-0.1393028498,
-0.2993032932,
0.5390121937,
-0.4504861832,
0.2609623075,
0.3352970481,
0.2638527453,
0.1186645851,
-0.756734252,
0.6020144224,
0.4040845633,
-0.4259314239,
-0.8554078341,
0.3100104332,
-1.1640149355,
-0.4903410971,
0.8479536772,
0.2153557241,
-0.3143669963,
-0.0146698272,
-0.0352813751,
0.3229802549,
-0.6738120914,
0.7316045761,
0.6024647355,
-0.4143457413,
0.2009471357,
-0.4318845272,
0.0846084803,
0.4142853022,
-1.0720750093,
-0.1176184639,
0.4257721007,
0.0626528263,
0.4656282663,
1.0303241014,
0.0891036317,
-0.0148181589,
-0.0469983555,
0.52393049,
-0.1759506762,
-0.5450353026,
0.0561347082,
0.2690469325,
-0.0311255157,
-0.2845537961
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16968v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16968v1
|
Evaluating Shortest Edit Script Methods for Contextual Lemmatization
| 2024-03-25T17:28:24 | 2024-03-25T17:28:24 |
Olia Toporkov, Rodrigo Agerri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern contextual lemmatizers often rely on automatically induced Shortest
Edit Scripts (SES), namely, the number of edit operations to transform a word
form into its lemma. In fact, different methods of computing SES have been
proposed as an integral component in the architecture of several
state-of-the-art contextual lemmatizers currently available. However, previous
work has not investigated the direct impact of SES in the final lemmatization
performance. In this paper we address this issue by focusing on lemmatization
as a token classification task where the only input that the model receives is
the word-label pairs in context, where the labels correspond to previously
induced SES. Thus, by modifying in our lemmatization system only the SES labels
that the model needs to learn, we may then objectively conclude which SES
representation produces the best lemmatization results. We experiment with
seven languages of different morphological complexity, namely, English,
Spanish, Basque, Russian, Czech, Turkish and Polish, using multilingual and
language-specific pre-trained masked language encoder-only models as a backbone
to build our lemmatizers. Comprehensive experimental results, both in- and
out-of-domain, indicate that computing the casing and edit operations
separately is beneficial overall, but much more clearly for languages with
high-inflected morphology. Notably, multilingual pre-trained language models
consistently outperform their language-specific counterparts in every
evaluation setting.
|
[
-0.3791698217,
-0.7511945367,
0.5489453673,
0.1443258971,
-0.4427398443,
-0.1689744443,
-0.4266823232,
-0.2996512949,
0.1899978966,
0.2607079744,
-0.4352896214,
-0.6572083831,
-0.7254992127,
0.5107015967,
-0.163965404,
0.7315442562,
-0.0300916955,
0.273635,
-0.1347738653,
-0.1800134778,
-0.1838360131,
-0.6394978166,
-0.3783270717,
0.1147328317,
0.4871273935,
0.2331014425,
0.6436599493,
0.7675461769,
0.2810792923,
0.3909929097,
-0.3869060874,
0.0777918026,
0.0520957224,
0.0197617244,
-0.2972248495,
-0.2741553187,
-0.3567878008,
-0.2337374985,
0.572712481,
1.0293232203,
0.2081152648,
0.1520718187,
0.0752060637,
0.3872163594,
-0.9699375033,
-0.1032558456,
-0.5743842721,
0.1353714913,
-0.4606856704,
-0.0132061848,
-0.4934411049,
-0.1069019362,
0.1465079337,
-0.4111371338,
0.1276828647,
-0.1254032403,
0.3741288781,
0.3429583013,
-0.4391522706,
-0.4278925657,
-0.3460238874,
0.5966340303,
-0.7374982238,
0.696528852,
0.29161641,
0.1287865341,
-0.0510184281,
-0.7376387715,
-0.5175843835,
-0.1090818495,
-0.242504105,
0.1153236702,
-0.120689407,
0.3788233101,
0.4123399258,
0.0577604473,
-0.3340290487,
0.4685038626,
-0.3704455197,
-0.505151391,
0.2807016373,
-0.0169978421,
0.2934657335,
-0.3534322381,
0.0154815624,
0.1986546516,
-0.5860643983,
0.0530472808,
0.3170625269,
0.2755748928,
0.1702223867,
0.739084661,
-0.2494306266,
0.7900807261,
-0.0292104743,
-0.2150543779,
0.1117650345,
-0.3460319936,
-0.3270209134,
0.1244417131,
0.4924870729,
0.2266665548,
-0.0251794886,
-0.1179459244,
-0.3027406633,
0.0737125203,
-0.0605715923,
-0.9479339719,
0.1375699639,
-0.0184416529,
-0.2439897656,
0.0175073147,
-0.1891805381,
-0.5755478144,
-0.2297385186,
-0.2774840593,
0.5872538686,
-0.4696111083,
0.2059341818,
0.16568923,
-0.0343435965,
0.0302147735,
0.5293879509,
-0.7528259754,
0.3620561957,
0.5857708454,
0.980388701,
-0.2584601045,
-0.288207382,
-0.812299192,
0.0155594135,
-0.4841130674,
0.625700295,
-0.5950283408,
-0.5200227499,
0.1138872504,
0.1622489989,
-0.4040611982,
-0.4541086853,
0.4133027494,
-0.435161829,
0.1980045289,
-0.0753084198,
-0.8636588454,
0.1830121875,
-0.0821819752,
-0.4962994754,
0.8040876985,
-0.0154458089,
-0.7209125161,
0.3536547124,
-0.8165916204,
-0.5766745806,
-0.0880988315,
0.1853946,
-0.2634293139,
0.2865743339,
0.3715732396,
0.5150673985,
0.1515875906,
0.0333788693,
-0.1554578692,
-0.424511075,
0.2298720926,
-0.3772979677,
0.5231136084,
0.0572964959,
-0.4420383871,
0.1902795732,
-0.5525683165,
-0.1561528742,
-0.138725996,
-0.2981062531,
-0.5660174489,
-0.2653660774,
-0.0612238422,
0.2192180604,
0.1456130147,
-0.6143983006,
0.0678617954,
-0.5167173743,
0.3320508897,
0.9570133686,
0.1062359065,
0.6072502732,
0.2184926867,
0.4048775733,
-0.0141705414,
0.1853655279,
-0.4571729898,
-0.2958055437,
-1.0195331573,
-0.4345967472,
0.7555652261,
0.3124856353,
-0.743596375,
0.3261858523,
-0.1547984034,
-0.354624331,
-0.3563388884,
0.1166812032,
0.6345606446,
0.474938184,
0.2507149279,
-0.4369644821,
-0.5050593019,
-0.97244066,
-0.4192952812,
0.0588121489,
0.1916244626,
0.0262055229,
0.7004921436,
-0.3617912233,
0.9483963251,
-0.3401058018,
-0.2150589228,
-0.2111774981,
-0.0646358654,
-0.0632143319,
0.4236298203,
0.6593943238,
-0.3537459671,
-0.4575572312,
-0.0573986284,
-0.3285999,
-0.4417035282,
0.1602015793,
-0.0461599678,
0.5745698214,
0.7152282,
-0.5111367106,
0.7156539559,
0.2669824064,
-0.1523973048,
0.6888095737,
-0.2765009105,
-0.0022106445,
-0.8497496247,
-0.057071086,
-0.1538117975,
-0.2365255356,
-0.7260259986,
-0.0226744842,
0.1460137665,
0.0980840102,
-0.8964704871,
0.8913946152,
-0.4393876791,
-0.4720722735,
-0.0798595548,
0.165374577,
-0.0450652763,
0.6600325704,
0.0488180257,
0.8762323856,
0.4203574955,
-0.6622334123,
-0.096920155,
0.0738115981,
-0.5159044862,
0.523449719,
-0.4319186211,
0.3445269465,
-0.1780216545,
0.1838532686,
-0.6374836564,
-0.3238181174,
0.0407368205,
-0.1840648204,
0.099284865,
-0.4429525733,
-0.7088774443,
-0.0465015434,
-0.268032074,
0.2482004613,
0.3807327747,
-0.6521421075,
0.3998956382,
0.2730239928,
-0.2162780315,
-0.5966718793,
-0.5091918111,
-0.0995970964,
-0.3107791543,
-0.3634064794,
0.4551181495,
-0.1580454558,
-0.3555159271,
-0.056722708,
-0.3279350996,
-0.1122364253,
0.1045057625,
0.0615019649,
-0.0379644111,
-0.0165513884,
0.081465371,
0.5362139344,
-0.1038700491,
-0.272715956,
-0.2728894651,
0.5646081567,
-0.1702552438,
-0.603392601,
-0.445813179,
0.1543794125,
0.5130765438,
-0.2331320494,
0.5799055099,
0.631067872,
-0.4656842649,
-0.0973887891,
-0.5072674155,
0.1298244447,
-0.4578710198,
0.4831826687,
-0.6382305622,
-1.0270142555,
0.6824920774,
-0.3127679229,
-0.0641922057,
0.4484261572,
0.48857373,
0.0979347453,
1.0951962471,
0.4525401294,
0.2982950211,
0.638483882,
-0.2526606321,
-0.0729247332,
-0.9288907051,
-0.0958464891,
-0.4908382595,
-0.0321041346,
-0.368058145,
-0.5388605595,
0.5961474776,
0.3094987273,
0.1176052541,
0.3739433587,
-0.1738243401,
0.7540972233,
0.2680684924,
-0.0494907983,
0.0764441043,
-0.0622212403,
-0.5344251394,
-0.1604498923,
-0.708584547,
-0.5397703648,
0.9039667845,
0.1699486524,
0.4381409287,
0.1273372173,
0.855761826,
0.2350255251,
0.1565934271,
-0.8333801031,
0.6157428026,
-0.2398131639,
-0.0873202831,
-0.3671617806,
-0.0157902408,
-0.9269856215,
0.7407231331,
0.0485283807,
-0.8777732849,
0.2489607185,
0.0157426074,
-0.3334026337,
0.1622220874,
-0.8530777097,
0.9692837,
-0.1367339343,
-0.4435618818,
-0.2223090529,
-0.5393391252,
0.142140761,
-0.2609128952,
0.5403086543,
0.0905168205,
-0.1962223649,
0.9909234643,
-0.8204526305,
0.9035152197,
-0.2641938925,
0.0416645482,
0.2008384168,
0.2608376741,
0.3492870331,
0.0788808614,
-0.0269570332,
0.2521480322,
0.1732915491,
-0.2904199958,
-0.6769351959,
0.5435667634,
-0.5244941115,
-0.6945181489,
-0.377486378,
-0.0635979101,
-0.159059003,
0.4066654444,
0.4095547497,
0.6148985624,
-0.3198727667,
0.0060904152,
0.3392314911,
-0.2505767643,
0.7671598792,
0.3670651317,
-0.2174477577,
-0.4490193427,
0.6023535728,
0.3627701998,
0.2360708416,
0.1784573197,
0.2444421351,
-0.3074863851,
-0.6595337987,
-0.7275194526,
0.1624735445,
-1.1168413162,
-0.1879782081,
-0.8191984892,
-0.124360323,
-0.4575949311,
-0.3885800242,
-0.3848534226,
-0.6628311276,
-0.2095361203,
-0.1872797161,
0.0710435882,
0.6455264688,
-0.2079899609,
0.4455927312,
-0.6233205795,
0.0542004444,
0.4025019407,
0.2603264451,
-0.2774372399,
-0.4356462359,
-0.4850361049,
-0.1624497175,
-0.0200212784,
-1.0105162859,
0.2957785428,
0.3968424499,
0.5159227252,
0.2213142812,
-0.1478668153,
1.0608383417,
-0.700640142,
0.7659615874,
-0.0785464868,
-1.5179342031,
0.5241479874,
-0.0331949852,
0.3140674531,
0.5428419113,
-0.0100306505,
-0.6321750283,
-0.2447133809,
-0.4703885317,
-0.7085074782,
0.9010627866,
0.2441419512,
0.1691245735,
-0.190002054,
0.3149836659,
0.3122928441,
0.2118231058,
-0.2985312343,
-0.0591751449,
-0.0589312427,
-0.0596761853,
0.0070843888,
-0.3209982514,
0.2988363206,
-0.3005572259,
0.4285335839,
-0.2245858461,
0.0935484767,
0.2678157389,
-0.7711986899,
0.1098347381,
0.4714123607,
0.8759126067,
0.6186368465,
-0.0306057371,
0.3873547316,
0.5719218254,
-0.3310913742,
-0.1040511802,
-0.2131349146,
-0.1525936872,
0.4120914042,
0.6025441289,
1.0514034033,
0.4060372412,
-0.7233064175,
0.7322170734,
0.0319224745,
0.0389754586,
-0.1707119793,
-0.079723984,
-0.2755135894,
-0.0605880991,
0.0785994604,
0.2786827087,
0.3670605421,
-0.3264669478,
0.1947223544,
0.3521557748,
-0.2040760815,
-0.5555125475,
0.2867737412,
0.0591517761,
-0.4130994976,
0.1541521847,
-0.154691413,
-0.8985046148,
0.5502038002,
0.5927146077,
0.938626945,
-0.400903821,
0.0497766808,
0.3544744551,
0.2908047736,
0.171074912,
-0.1701898426,
-0.3116728365,
-0.5386170745,
-0.5292240381,
-0.7517594695,
-0.5100335479,
-0.0315852612,
-0.4148470759,
0.4650578499,
-0.4719648063,
-0.1574560553,
0.0750687942,
-0.3320435286,
-0.7571602464,
0.1753431857,
-0.009235994,
0.873295784,
-0.6869470477,
0.7181628346,
0.6974138618,
-0.0546461046,
-0.3461514711,
0.0072676823,
0.0033663255,
-0.6130300164,
0.7743741274,
0.3472627401,
-0.3214729726,
0.0908220857,
-0.3249934316,
-0.8742554188,
0.7542043924,
0.4011569023,
-0.2442744821,
0.1086898297,
0.1794854105,
0.6711975336,
-0.3943923116,
0.3253232241,
0.6906859875,
0.4013747871,
-0.0267006941,
-1.208438158,
-0.2056561112,
-0.2952237725,
0.1253576726,
-0.0099066934,
-0.3113644719,
0.6506261826,
-0.157880038,
-0.4443066418,
0.1285724789,
0.473003149,
-0.0045807799,
0.2498195618,
0.5622391105,
0.3803229034,
0.50912714,
-0.0444592945,
0.9200765491,
-0.2287384719,
0.1689338535,
0.8076044321,
-0.1143700182,
0.7388745546,
0.5525556207,
-0.0625438243,
0.4098671377,
0.8051946163,
0.505808413,
0.5244944096,
0.1079253703,
-0.0893433094,
-0.1491518617,
-0.2603985965,
-0.1615286022,
0.5057192445,
0.4455557764,
-0.1330805272,
-0.1132117808,
0.2910386324,
0.2680346668,
-0.0388334878,
-0.321475774,
0.975073874,
-0.0707874447,
-0.6003249884,
0.4941239953,
0.4328833818,
0.7807043195,
-0.4603122175,
0.1837344021,
-0.3697911799,
-0.0091917058,
-0.1558085829,
-0.5043389201,
0.4514344633,
0.1868343949,
0.1411354095,
-0.120932132,
0.6006553173,
-0.3667345047,
-0.3973820508,
0.1951120943,
0.5203416348,
0.1707733572,
0.2246594578,
-0.488994956,
0.2002532631,
-0.3049874306,
-0.2667922378,
0.3662334979,
0.3165106177,
-0.363409847,
0.422185272,
0.8015566468,
0.0316262878,
0.3625732958,
0.2429005951,
0.6883197427,
-0.4630188644,
-0.7394103408,
-1.0597485304,
0.4084499776,
-0.0433554947,
-0.1688635498,
0.7632121444,
0.7300134301,
1.0505005121,
-0.257953167,
0.6549645662,
0.1683181226,
0.1230136007,
-0.8655245304,
0.3134706616,
-0.5921827555,
0.1505016685,
-0.6183203459,
-1.0930585861,
-0.6438672543,
0.5152083039,
-0.4729735553,
-0.1137881204,
0.8786702156,
0.7026605606,
0.0205786806,
-0.3415489197,
0.5012699366,
-0.0118570793,
0.0363820866,
0.2584989965,
0.870356977,
-0.3307995796,
0.1498545557,
-0.4741374552,
-0.0355023928,
-0.3072974682,
-0.6769043207,
-0.9735989571,
-0.6525257826,
-0.3205238581,
-0.1628371924,
0.0485845506,
1.0641776323,
0.5677027106,
-0.6736142039,
-0.1026973426,
0.1414167881,
0.3696088791,
-0.0953461975,
-0.146271944,
0.7287166715,
-0.4526945651,
-1.1330324411,
0.5309826732,
0.6377710104,
0.1702773869,
-0.0339474194,
-0.1916531771,
0.1956771463,
0.2962652445,
0.8114328384,
0.0368939415,
-0.9485881329,
-0.3616569638,
0.1585042626,
-0.1861176789,
-0.0854080692,
0.9125329852,
-0.5830014348,
0.7108439207,
0.4044490755,
0.5690875053,
0.4522412121,
-0.2412016243,
0.1800644994,
-1.0183473825,
0.4653657675,
-0.0718244389,
0.6893015504,
0.4145722687,
-0.1552068591,
0.4818978608,
0.3329150379,
-0.1672667414,
-1.0807468891,
0.2978993952,
-0.6787061691,
-0.3366464674,
1.1380496025,
-0.1530042291,
-0.415412873,
-0.1530546546,
-0.4607384205,
0.3286358416,
-0.0347986072,
0.3119245768,
0.5538566113,
-0.1160935014,
-0.1161667332,
-0.2041118741,
0.6184772253,
0.44257918,
-0.5451679826,
-0.0986199751,
0.5374541879,
0.3208170235,
0.1484963149,
0.7053650618,
-0.0560980588,
0.1852089167,
-0.2524454892,
0.0234208293,
-0.1154352948,
-0.2819876969,
-0.6137157083,
0.0648760796,
-0.0181221515,
-0.0709498003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.00051v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.00051v1
|
Deja vu: Contrastive Historical Modeling with Prefix-tuning for Temporal Knowledge Graph Reasoning
| 2024-03-25T17:25:40 | 2024-03-25T17:25:40 |
Miao Peng, Ben Liu, Wenjie Xu, Zihao Jiang, Jiahui Zhu, Min Peng
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Temporal Knowledge Graph Reasoning (TKGR) is the task of inferring missing
facts for incomplete TKGs in complex scenarios (e.g., transductive and
inductive settings), which has been gaining increasing attention. Recently, to
mitigate dependence on structured connections in TKGs, text-based methods have
been developed to utilize rich linguistic information from entity descriptions.
However, suffering from the enormous parameters and inflexibility of
pre-trained language models, existing text-based methods struggle to balance
the textual knowledge and temporal information with computationally expensive
purpose-built training strategies. To tap the potential of text-based models
for TKGR in various complex scenarios, we propose ChapTER, a Contrastive
historical modeling framework with prefix-tuning for TEmporal Reasoning.
ChapTER feeds history-contextualized text into the pseudo-Siamese encoders to
strike a textual-temporal balance via contrastive estimation between queries
and candidates. By introducing virtual time prefix tokens, it applies a
prefix-based tuning method to facilitate the frozen PLM capable for TKGR tasks
under different settings. We evaluate ChapTER on four transductive and three
few-shot inductive TKGR benchmarks, and experimental results demonstrate that
ChapTER achieves superior performance compared to competitive baselines with
only 0.17% tuned parameters. We conduct thorough analysis to verify the
effectiveness, flexibility and efficiency of ChapTER.
|
[
-0.3110563457,
-0.7557814121,
0.5025966167,
-0.2048299611,
-0.6210836172,
0.2777234018,
0.0124097168,
-0.300668031,
-0.0598974191,
0.4164585173,
-0.6946268082,
-0.7284597158,
-0.2561863661,
0.1039886698,
0.1128337309,
0.7136536837,
-0.210366711,
-0.1707531363,
-0.1264201403,
-0.1217783317,
-0.5505433679,
-0.3588870466,
-0.5657777786,
-0.9913012981,
0.1641339362,
0.3694763184,
0.7304891348,
0.863011539,
0.0032010134,
0.1825333089,
-0.3257131577,
0.2678226531,
-0.5085061193,
0.155022189,
-0.2468690723,
-0.2451165766,
-0.4409180582,
-0.3119532168,
0.4753607213,
0.7642771602,
0.0795647651,
-0.1729403287,
0.0270831771,
0.4040753245,
-0.5218945742,
0.4797607064,
-0.734389782,
0.1636676788,
-0.1376118362,
-0.4826170206,
-0.2121224701,
-0.2385152727,
0.1439000815,
-0.851988554,
0.421169132,
0.0694361925,
1.0427620411,
0.4498250782,
-0.767198503,
0.0142276771,
-0.7763305902,
0.8358015418,
-0.87197119,
0.5916872025,
0.573857367,
0.3433605433,
-0.1205562279,
-1.0526254177,
-0.6019986868,
-0.1979994625,
-0.3878070712,
0.1627143025,
0.1754539311,
0.1397449821,
0.3798829019,
0.339512229,
-0.7316589355,
0.2260280699,
0.0222508591,
-0.074155204,
0.1956883222,
0.6313069463,
0.0232903734,
-0.2199771553,
-0.2291249633,
-0.1117404625,
-0.5217188597,
-0.1747054011,
0.345126152,
0.2039604634,
-0.1706817746,
0.4067544043,
-0.3707977533,
0.9960115552,
0.023192415,
-0.2227067351,
0.076954715,
-0.5047826171,
-0.1445050389,
0.1295125186,
0.4775474668,
0.6514773369,
0.2660783529,
-0.4827877879,
0.0347209424,
0.1286251992,
0.2559051514,
-0.8809430003,
-0.3599537313,
-0.1169307455,
-0.3711560965,
-0.1644672751,
-0.4592200518,
-0.9145576358,
-0.1658017188,
-0.4998753071,
0.2495108843,
-0.6113551259,
-0.2460806519,
0.1141101867,
-0.2132698745,
0.1401823759,
0.2671904564,
-0.736335814,
0.1937280595,
0.6966556311,
0.7329885364,
0.0754518956,
-0.0593479089,
-0.3047284484,
0.4638123512,
-0.3486796916,
0.5212377906,
-0.8847079277,
-0.753372848,
-0.1570136249,
-0.0086421445,
-0.0027820293,
-0.4044629633,
0.5636239052,
-0.6846754551,
0.0214284435,
-0.1486412287,
-0.7745006084,
-0.1580840498,
0.4475404918,
-0.5459417701,
1.0566686392,
0.1453430504,
-0.8648394346,
0.5310756564,
-0.1570661366,
-0.3590521812,
0.1887852401,
-0.0664947405,
-0.5703700185,
-0.3871048391,
0.3144564629,
0.0559244268,
-0.3138921857,
0.4790829718,
-0.4784342349,
-0.2267117649,
-0.2686092257,
-0.0399520621,
0.6805036664,
0.3213531077,
-0.3490184844,
-0.1752412915,
-0.7292678356,
-0.0107406825,
0.0750399753,
-0.0677327588,
-0.7341228127,
0.0277421158,
-0.2532822192,
-0.0203509536,
-0.0536731184,
-0.3213689327,
0.4429381788,
-0.5722252131,
0.4922769964,
0.2672306597,
0.2030852139,
0.374632746,
-0.2222519964,
0.4084820747,
0.1854114532,
0.0395722166,
-0.4581250548,
-0.1965271533,
-0.6595067382,
0.094675459,
0.4643331468,
0.4593940079,
-1.2413076162,
0.2566274405,
-0.4639531076,
-0.3837079704,
-0.035878256,
-0.2761267424,
0.327713877,
1.2457251549,
0.4458864331,
0.0539722368,
-0.540518105,
-0.8686275482,
-0.326620847,
-0.4070003927,
-0.0205205157,
0.4637012184,
0.4603495002,
0.0682387277,
0.9913636446,
-0.736836791,
0.0120062055,
0.1179972738,
0.5393101573,
0.060569752,
0.384370923,
0.5356769562,
-0.9378626943,
-0.2387616038,
0.0816613212,
-0.7165733576,
-0.2726785839,
0.1116013229,
-0.0904819593,
0.2712609172,
0.7861232758,
-0.2929259837,
0.3940482438,
0.0887172297,
-0.550780654,
0.4186886251,
-0.0563613847,
0.3670776188,
-1.1881188154,
0.1406962872,
-0.0859620348,
-0.2888765335,
-0.5211393237,
-0.1624991,
0.1864336282,
-0.1780589372,
-0.1147169322,
1.0889083147,
-0.2137793601,
0.406619221,
-0.1727707833,
-0.0222523436,
-0.0546264015,
0.5269934535,
0.1765346676,
0.3861430287,
0.0587540604,
-0.6502787471,
0.1035833806,
0.1587133408,
-0.1864663512,
0.5033636093,
-0.4424263835,
0.1786027849,
-0.0922021046,
0.1750818491,
-0.9356989861,
-0.0446422882,
0.3222474456,
-0.2575148642,
0.7837014794,
-0.5467178822,
-0.5769394636,
-0.2367223799,
0.0367385745,
0.6704505682,
0.5597688556,
-0.5059412718,
0.8868792653,
0.0558477975,
-0.1396605521,
-0.677767694,
-0.462864697,
0.0868752003,
-0.3874803782,
-0.3669787645,
0.7446916103,
0.069921121,
-0.314715296,
0.3801506162,
-0.4786220789,
-0.1723844409,
0.0495989881,
0.0846753195,
0.1677650213,
-0.2492968589,
0.4502423406,
0.208800897,
-0.2480478287,
-0.4395100176,
-0.7158721685,
0.4575929642,
-0.028868001,
-0.1060764194,
0.1596547961,
0.0104999784,
0.1953073144,
0.0578842796,
0.6685420871,
0.2889147699,
-0.3144564033,
-0.1784839481,
-0.6594327092,
-0.1809544265,
-0.4038788974,
0.1592407078,
-0.3315045238,
-0.9420450926,
0.5223388672,
-0.3908916414,
-0.0401185155,
0.5449512005,
0.4023125768,
-0.0268276948,
0.4601596594,
0.3854858875,
0.1623380184,
0.522254467,
-0.0697564259,
-0.1710983664,
-0.2948899567,
-0.5824278593,
-0.6918638349,
-0.272379905,
-0.711299479,
-0.0509165525,
0.5469557643,
0.3838216066,
-0.645175457,
-0.0014901492,
-0.1536327153,
0.496894002,
0.3011399806,
0.2055602819,
0.5714554191,
-0.1737410277,
-0.3296587467,
-0.3003643751,
-0.7560762763,
-0.3942467272,
0.7617605329,
-0.1828156412,
0.8037427664,
-0.2519943714,
0.3769053221,
0.2625280321,
-0.0443625636,
-0.6929244399,
0.43585518,
-0.2816122472,
-0.3976071179,
-0.2307887375,
-0.6202375293,
-0.9206613302,
0.0706937686,
-0.0276118871,
-0.5545533299,
0.0255899522,
0.3613120317,
0.0824728981,
0.4881600738,
-0.6214812398,
1.0958731174,
-0.0013911527,
-0.3055544794,
-0.1219017729,
-0.947904706,
0.17405577,
0.0785732344,
-0.178771168,
0.0380307436,
-0.2301485389,
0.3837873042,
-0.4667053223,
1.0007581711,
-0.0650170073,
0.2764264047,
0.0735700652,
0.4366106987,
0.57721138,
-0.0834392905,
-0.1055232882,
0.3093995154,
-0.0192694608,
-0.3990190327,
-0.7146043777,
0.6982277036,
-0.6153116226,
-0.6523314118,
-0.1102577075,
-0.6288596392,
-0.2790383399,
0.2739934623,
0.2725140154,
0.6779481173,
-0.2655113339,
0.0688666701,
0.6206655502,
-0.1455860436,
0.6012437344,
0.6325045824,
0.0443738885,
-0.3488205373,
0.5441902876,
0.2230155617,
0.0039006465,
0.9440370202,
0.249715969,
-0.3970220983,
-0.4013329446,
-0.4000062346,
0.3025157154,
-0.7295274138,
-0.3400152624,
-0.8059492111,
-0.0726385862,
-0.1879437119,
-0.1508178264,
-0.1696397662,
-0.7423920035,
-0.4272941351,
-0.0223039184,
0.4505990446,
0.4060305655,
0.2628464401,
0.2245225608,
-0.7029560208,
0.4203394651,
0.2010520399,
0.5436246991,
0.1225881055,
-0.393930614,
-0.1908132434,
-0.3445240259,
-0.5038077235,
-0.811342299,
0.2386539578,
0.121125713,
0.5857587457,
0.0570723973,
0.3689001501,
0.6698750854,
-0.5060520768,
0.8620744348,
-0.1377841234,
-0.9150868058,
0.5249686241,
-0.4421589077,
0.4812535346,
0.2645681798,
0.471324712,
-0.5325018764,
-0.3073753119,
-0.7014548182,
-0.9989705682,
0.8257853389,
0.2075806707,
-0.3418841362,
0.0560360029,
0.6668604016,
0.4664275348,
0.2324234098,
-0.4388488233,
-0.3571880162,
-0.5942126513,
-0.2139877975,
-0.1117988154,
-0.2383953631,
0.1033738926,
-0.0251237657,
0.6010975838,
-0.1432699561,
-0.2641444206,
0.0319510959,
-0.0518072397,
0.0322936326,
0.4285381436,
0.4556459188,
0.8179183602,
-0.1615244001,
0.3454530537,
0.3267362416,
-0.1600089222,
0.0782959685,
0.4267823994,
-0.32983163,
0.1820148677,
0.5785653591,
0.989859879,
0.3029192984,
-0.1862202585,
-0.0607616641,
0.1687904894,
-0.0932393968,
0.0700047314,
-0.1244206056,
0.1477815807,
0.5022216439,
0.2215276808,
-0.416878581,
-0.0622161701,
-0.1454100013,
-0.1020219997,
0.2214033157,
-0.2238992155,
-0.2153056413,
0.7638822794,
0.1619385332,
-0.2524947822,
0.8343484998,
-0.1888769418,
-0.5241239071,
0.7437143922,
0.4045149386,
0.8678367138,
-0.2057949305,
-0.0864124,
0.4983629286,
0.2187632769,
-0.055748716,
0.0992430076,
-0.2868113518,
-0.4635451436,
-0.3679992855,
-0.4720673561,
-0.3163699508,
0.3517739177,
-0.4156297445,
0.3442741334,
0.026940912,
-0.315132767,
-0.0686380118,
0.0760027021,
-0.786793232,
0.1520940214,
-0.0902368426,
0.8642074466,
-0.831810832,
0.6898989677,
0.5574163795,
-0.1882148683,
-0.5156702995,
0.2609014511,
-0.0663508698,
-0.5085077286,
0.9829546809,
-0.3569336832,
-0.1897379458,
0.0366768651,
-0.4288915396,
-0.2978954613,
1.1591829062,
0.5691289902,
-0.5559888482,
-0.2579232454,
0.0188935418,
0.7323282957,
-0.0428110808,
0.0942006633,
0.5040487647,
0.3982007504,
0.3778982162,
-0.9916887283,
0.0271202251,
-0.0926085338,
0.1380706429,
0.6495829225,
-0.4791612327,
0.7246297002,
0.0695907325,
-0.3694131672,
0.0481471084,
0.4353309274,
0.1091994643,
0.8394167423,
0.3864993453,
0.8537089825,
0.5246216655,
-0.2641471326,
1.1557540894,
-0.1925060898,
0.2863507271,
1.2843959332,
-0.2381092161,
0.0891650394,
0.3381842673,
0.0070103421,
0.3390537202,
0.7737073302,
0.0388630852,
0.7215180397,
-0.0985408425,
-0.1855250895,
-0.5376497507,
-0.3817048073,
-0.5599152446,
0.0930481181,
0.2876838744,
-0.3018494546,
-0.6071810722,
-0.1641504765,
0.1020844281,
0.0078338524,
-0.4698937535,
0.8688694835,
0.2220441401,
-0.6694555283,
0.5148236156,
-0.1277811229,
0.1208452806,
-0.7854916453,
-0.3777493536,
-0.4977252781,
0.1199489161,
0.0429645479,
-0.7885954976,
0.2205464393,
-0.0947727114,
-0.2534269691,
-0.1757021546,
0.7316386104,
-0.4467250705,
-0.2463225573,
0.2286279052,
0.4801975191,
-0.1609096974,
0.3724307716,
-0.3736355603,
-0.2313618213,
-0.2962459028,
-0.2247488648,
0.0924972594,
0.789707303,
-0.3810505569,
0.63446486,
0.0019572014,
-0.1043722555,
-0.3467466235,
0.2264618576,
0.8995603323,
-0.9306573272,
-0.9320602417,
-1.1331620216,
0.1924151033,
0.1152984574,
-0.2068369836,
0.4880409837,
0.6720141768,
1.0060235262,
0.0307370108,
0.5186511874,
0.2402782887,
0.5251660347,
-0.9604752064,
0.5257381797,
-0.7717189193,
0.2887997329,
-0.1345508397,
-0.549328804,
-0.2570507824,
-0.1441283971,
-0.3416655064,
0.3134715259,
0.7347078919,
0.6884532571,
-0.1440596133,
0.2308378816,
0.299631834,
0.301890552,
0.2277952433,
0.6138911247,
0.8995844722,
-0.0890853703,
0.7784336805,
-0.0702610686,
0.2017794102,
-0.2711268663,
-1.3157720566,
-1.1053991318,
-0.7667563558,
-0.3619894385,
-0.4763305485,
0.4100436568,
0.8246370554,
0.5103267431,
-0.5153606534,
0.0147078326,
0.1034369245,
0.2417793423,
-0.0868635029,
-0.2059299499,
0.4995940626,
-0.2620898187,
-0.5648828745,
0.2306912094,
0.101726912,
0.2916300595,
0.3532337546,
-0.0243096352,
0.165767476,
-0.3371159732,
0.3017332256,
0.3063924313,
-0.6709833145,
-0.2540051937,
-0.2387657017,
-0.0672601983,
0.2173400968,
1.2956231833,
-1.0373985767,
0.899704814,
0.6500727534,
0.5454232097,
1.2989321947,
-0.0010933003,
0.6252878904,
-0.9331342578,
0.19744201,
0.4295296669,
0.1990109533,
0.3181198239,
-0.2122392505,
0.7835513353,
0.515614748,
-0.3382754624,
-0.6345239282,
0.3069530129,
-0.8620222807,
-0.6470986605,
0.9695815444,
0.0266215857,
0.0970263407,
-0.4338847697,
0.0532855801,
0.903996706,
-0.2744103968,
0.9362908006,
0.8366920352,
-0.1386687011,
-0.131096065,
-0.4597882032,
0.5616902113,
0.1479881257,
-0.7467424273,
-0.0398380607,
0.513087213,
0.1658498496,
-0.1903458387,
0.3993223608,
-0.1000933722,
-0.015288285,
0.2682755589,
-0.2253595442,
-0.6793358922,
-0.1662979573,
-0.2929923832,
0.218440488,
-0.1749847531,
0.0767832994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.19709v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.19709v1
|
Hierarchical Recurrent Adapters for Efficient Multi-Task Adaptation of Large Speech Models
| 2024-03-25T17:21:56 | 2024-03-25T17:21:56 |
Tsendsuren Munkhdalai, Youzheng Chen, Khe Chai Sim, Fadi Biadsy, Tara Sainath, Pedro Moreno Mengibar
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
Parameter efficient adaptation methods have become a key mechanism to train
large pre-trained models for downstream tasks. However, their per-task
parameter overhead is considered still high when the number of downstream tasks
to adapt for is large. We introduce an adapter module that has a better
efficiency in large scale multi-task adaptation scenario. Our adapter is
hierarchical in terms of how the adapter parameters are allocated. The adapter
consists of a single shared controller network and multiple task-level adapter
heads to reduce the per-task parameter overhead without performance regression
on downstream tasks. The adapter is also recurrent so the entire adapter
parameters are reused across different layers of the pre-trained model. Our
Hierarchical Recurrent Adapter (HRA) outperforms the previous adapter-based
approaches as well as full model fine-tuning baseline in both single and
multi-task adaptation settings when evaluated on automatic speech recognition
tasks.
|
[
-0.21218808,
-0.5270183682,
0.2710209787,
0.3835141063,
-0.3472118676,
-0.3058294952,
-0.1005917713,
-0.1573512256,
-0.1967751086,
0.2318163514,
-0.5709621906,
-0.150979355,
-0.6156370044,
-0.1610207856,
0.0047335941,
0.8439071178,
0.1349408478,
-0.25404796,
0.0027082663,
-0.2066138238,
-0.7530683279,
-0.4893250465,
-1.1000336409,
-0.4017778933,
0.751696229,
0.3089942634,
0.1734666675,
0.6436299086,
0.5036233068,
0.3646923602,
0.0125587387,
0.0276928227,
-0.4934379756,
0.2201354206,
-0.2864731252,
-0.214168787,
-0.7651865482,
-0.4746454358,
1.0133517981,
0.4644885659,
-0.5491183996,
0.5001214147,
0.2962776124,
0.8196834922,
-0.8203006983,
0.250918746,
-0.7301522493,
-0.0979105532,
-0.0529251844,
-0.4585335553,
-0.3088474572,
0.0142692197,
0.3001376092,
-0.8546232581,
-0.081950143,
-0.09796343,
0.2711517811,
0.5182629824,
-0.1687207669,
0.2304617763,
-1.0032417774,
0.728071034,
-0.6970213056,
0.4778562784,
-0.0258778483,
0.35568434,
-0.1726728529,
-0.6859494448,
-0.3765495718,
-0.180682838,
0.202963993,
0.2072169483,
-0.674051106,
0.1922495812,
0.2294445038,
0.0040232874,
-0.4881814718,
0.2353633791,
-0.1570951641,
-0.1221626773,
0.1645077616,
-0.0311509911,
0.0529074334,
0.1218565777,
-0.1142325103,
0.0915218964,
-0.3608216047,
0.0126929693,
0.0771263987,
0.6509796977,
-0.0758718848,
-0.0531130768,
-0.1437160075,
0.9866889119,
0.5086898208,
-0.3816523552,
0.2476370037,
-0.4168101251,
-0.3017101586,
0.1070327163,
0.3447851837,
-0.0004028182,
0.2412518412,
-0.0301746242,
-0.0000248109,
-0.2682858706,
0.5754462481,
-0.829744041,
-0.2554604411,
0.0213424657,
-0.4845351875,
0.1922420114,
-0.3285933435,
-0.6410259604,
-0.1847982556,
-0.5013816953,
0.7102590799,
-0.0124381119,
-0.2558935583,
0.1016810387,
-0.0988559499,
0.1974671632,
0.4301257133,
-0.8973858356,
0.5231393576,
0.4927328825,
1.0172231197,
-0.3249470294,
-0.5991183519,
-0.9359029531,
0.2914937437,
-0.2309513241,
0.7062501311,
-0.2834366858,
-0.0974289179,
-0.3123018146,
0.2051939517,
-0.5574226975,
-0.6705848575,
0.4258458316,
-0.2364780009,
-0.141568765,
0.0085077137,
-0.0571070984,
-0.1775867045,
-0.1623865217,
-0.6185427308,
0.6607589126,
-0.0352014266,
-0.4832119048,
0.3576564491,
-0.8813287616,
-0.5294033885,
0.0061897533,
0.2230743021,
-0.4345917404,
0.1953884512,
0.3261727691,
0.482778877,
-0.2940567732,
0.2004251033,
-0.187775597,
-0.3462029696,
-0.2324676067,
-0.4599913061,
0.4297277927,
0.065818049,
-0.168442145,
0.644898057,
-0.7749642134,
-0.2742614448,
-0.2676002383,
-0.6477661729,
-0.3393261731,
0.0486280099,
0.3025843799,
0.3134132326,
0.1418579966,
-0.3903627992,
-0.1256097704,
0.0565481856,
0.5918757915,
0.844043076,
-0.0343773142,
0.4082468748,
-0.6754094362,
0.3695707023,
0.2752850354,
0.0537073985,
0.0109039592,
-0.2704925835,
-0.6208752394,
-0.6000548005,
0.1063086614,
0.4248815775,
-0.3363873959,
0.6755142808,
-0.4966991246,
-0.7071467638,
-0.5540083051,
0.0932893679,
0.2709296346,
0.493994385,
0.318277657,
-0.2453860343,
-0.6199111938,
-0.785124898,
-0.2985553145,
-0.0189885292,
-0.2543703318,
0.3551934063,
0.4823700488,
-0.1495654881,
0.5511888862,
-0.1471427828,
-0.432728529,
-0.1782803684,
0.0452680439,
0.4520153999,
0.7218217254,
0.588432014,
-0.5183874369,
-0.2145690322,
0.2099548578,
-0.1282003075,
0.0927600637,
-0.3968396187,
-0.1856279969,
0.0489680469,
0.2364710867,
-0.2906561792,
0.0100246323,
0.8830698133,
-0.0984605625,
0.3372263312,
-0.4782867432,
0.0566821434,
-1.2103891373,
0.3443531096,
0.1090986207,
-0.2707310021,
-0.9105154276,
-0.2192301452,
-0.1312695444,
-0.101385504,
-0.2244379371,
0.2331555486,
-0.1959618628,
-0.1818423122,
-0.3836585283,
-0.0989259407,
-0.2725589871,
0.8039626479,
-0.0358777009,
0.8189832568,
0.8354079723,
-0.7432280183,
0.3739227355,
0.0277662612,
-0.3193539679,
0.5725507736,
-0.701752305,
0.2326099724,
-0.0728568435,
0.5100912452,
-1.0068639517,
0.0409329496,
0.0283438824,
-0.0559639782,
0.1277222931,
-0.2055040896,
-0.0903889909,
-0.1374233812,
-0.1267305762,
0.6345295906,
0.3213825822,
-0.7466686964,
1.0195735693,
0.4817414284,
-0.4175643921,
-0.4094412029,
-0.6549196243,
-0.0938321128,
-0.3232598007,
-0.2101772428,
0.4818829596,
-0.072722666,
0.3450556099,
-0.2877627015,
-0.5739676952,
-0.3160660863,
0.0096547222,
0.4007588327,
0.0699246749,
-0.5475914478,
0.0628838465,
0.1200250462,
-0.0465747379,
-0.1171431392,
-0.5752664208,
0.4725548327,
0.0100470912,
-0.0834088176,
-1.0949394703,
0.4182035625,
1.0929112434,
0.0758177191,
0.6312915087,
0.5602161884,
-0.5216483474,
-0.0019875588,
-0.5431060195,
0.0762312934,
-0.4146302044,
0.9646970034,
-0.5187680721,
-0.7618445158,
0.3887780011,
-0.1410206854,
0.2498893589,
0.2802216411,
0.4560263157,
0.1555035412,
0.6517249346,
0.4288307726,
-0.6222540736,
0.8066126704,
0.1840719432,
0.0132268518,
-1.0208209753,
0.1227876842,
-0.7266412377,
-0.4033118188,
-0.5512816906,
-0.4843875766,
0.3685218096,
-0.1456010938,
-0.5884339213,
0.3934439421,
-0.4313563704,
0.0813899115,
0.6685458422,
0.3559337258,
0.1303693354,
-0.0237458199,
0.5852288008,
0.3110632896,
-1.0419403315,
-0.0468670949,
0.672744751,
0.4129021466,
0.5759971142,
0.1436534822,
0.3307685554,
0.1921947151,
0.0126478421,
-0.7978003621,
0.2783863842,
-0.6027070284,
-0.3963173628,
-0.5464265943,
-0.4840297997,
-0.925162971,
0.3940648139,
-0.2987071574,
-0.6571381092,
0.5222120285,
0.5623021722,
-0.7545411587,
0.2861018479,
-0.575786531,
0.7992885113,
0.1139954478,
-0.1003271416,
-0.5572838187,
-0.3312093914,
-0.1699731499,
-0.42152071,
0.0717160925,
0.0638300627,
0.0779246241,
1.1244931221,
0.2646290362,
0.8085212111,
-0.5311645865,
0.0524521805,
0.120969072,
-0.3057079613,
0.6053717732,
-0.3673664033,
-0.2902496159,
0.152767688,
0.0686269403,
-0.5130809546,
-0.5961247683,
0.6853820682,
-0.8535469174,
-0.5835105777,
-0.1845131516,
-1.1272799969,
-0.314019233,
0.1177247316,
-0.1123838797,
0.7974240184,
-0.0458780155,
0.4947947562,
0.1987574995,
-0.2238904685,
0.3370736837,
0.277214855,
0.2851838171,
-0.4670034647,
0.8183429241,
0.0623701401,
0.4978782237,
0.4832055867,
0.3192654848,
-0.11450167,
-0.8376345634,
-0.2744865417,
0.0435628183,
-0.2523437738,
-0.1490011811,
-0.3322073221,
-0.3672575653,
-0.4886312187,
0.1106219739,
-0.3623535335,
-0.2779273689,
-0.3484078646,
0.1919368207,
0.2625134289,
0.4365595579,
0.0185155571,
0.7465001941,
-0.6294737458,
0.8625584841,
0.775346458,
0.275786221,
0.2432568967,
-1.1563770771,
-0.2608121336,
-0.1319724321,
-0.1297182143,
-0.3916363418,
0.1585048437,
0.6766177416,
0.5753158927,
0.2222607434,
-0.0803204328,
1.3339768648,
-0.851143539,
0.2937350571,
0.1909624934,
-0.9636185169,
0.2145674229,
-0.4392056465,
0.9366123676,
0.3811631203,
0.143539384,
-0.2961039245,
-0.024300741,
0.0305181108,
-0.7963657975,
0.8676704764,
-0.0367319882,
0.1860717237,
0.5718097091,
0.5787189007,
0.0429711305,
-0.026835857,
-0.4550563693,
-0.2324440777,
-0.3059466481,
-0.0409676395,
-0.250659436,
-0.2836322784,
-0.0325446166,
-0.4530060887,
0.6501446962,
-0.2050624937,
0.2584099472,
0.0557964146,
0.079856202,
-0.3151831925,
0.5770685673,
0.7070227861,
0.8714214563,
-0.2173896581,
0.0080830706,
0.6268594861,
-0.5379061699,
0.1329876781,
0.2594126463,
0.3366043568,
-0.0816954747,
0.4560648501,
1.1708748341,
0.4894296527,
-0.2013878971,
0.0884035677,
0.1045844555,
-0.3615289927,
-0.1431451589,
0.1288686842,
0.2530553341,
0.4235751927,
0.348940134,
0.5373935699,
0.1459483206,
-0.6122843027,
0.2709511518,
0.1513096541,
-0.282351464,
-0.2534836531,
0.2805235088,
0.4145337939,
-0.4244308472,
0.2759055793,
0.4802248478,
-0.1458132267,
0.3433658183,
0.8766967654,
0.9277364016,
-0.8749451041,
-0.2862708569,
0.5046409965,
0.0446642525,
-0.0839569792,
0.0520825423,
-0.2125397325,
-0.5234281421,
-0.6518791914,
-0.638566196,
-0.1392170489,
0.2245898545,
-0.9778004289,
-0.1035706326,
-0.2899389267,
-0.2267918289,
0.2438252717,
-0.3300842941,
-0.415478617,
0.0613330789,
0.1940989047,
0.8420743942,
-0.6548236012,
1.2386626005,
0.5811393261,
0.3436129689,
-0.5903379917,
0.1355872005,
-0.142981559,
-0.642790854,
0.3748250604,
-0.0291644372,
-0.6270231605,
0.1846118569,
0.2259831131,
-0.8629005551,
1.1810947657,
0.5163394809,
-1.2056306601,
-0.2210315615,
-0.2131014466,
0.4076307714,
-0.4855285585,
-0.1700941622,
0.7220389247,
0.4271672666,
0.0734506622,
-1.4411542416,
0.1257969439,
-0.1179327518,
0.2734411657,
0.08739236,
-0.1839818358,
0.6301688552,
-0.152395308,
0.0460865088,
0.1946226209,
0.6904107332,
0.4258017242,
0.1600628346,
1.1225827932,
0.1245614737,
0.6574361324,
0.2142071873,
0.7110885978,
-0.1827402413,
0.1447150409,
1.4371814728,
-0.1217679381,
1.1607581377,
0.5371155143,
-0.0827246457,
0.4928616881,
0.1523390859,
0.2762817442,
0.631785512,
0.408724606,
-0.1681803465,
-0.4524386525,
-0.1533302367,
-0.318338573,
0.5093159676,
0.1676675081,
-0.1371615231,
-0.1078475937,
0.1637548357,
-0.2862464488,
-0.1783756167,
-0.7294436693,
0.9995840788,
0.0174732674,
-0.6710863709,
0.5250158906,
-0.4062617719,
0.6291078329,
-0.6917837858,
-0.0031720877,
0.2948181629,
0.5821092725,
-0.2451933473,
-0.3838549554,
0.27592206,
-0.045334816,
-0.4442811608,
-0.0436953939,
0.5038387179,
-0.5148200989,
-0.3433900476,
0.4087507129,
0.3992234766,
-0.1447668076,
-0.3847883642,
-0.6492038965,
-0.1237595081,
-0.2159285545,
-0.1311537027,
0.4214445055,
0.2585146427,
0.3062051833,
0.5156205893,
0.7432180047,
0.3424577713,
0.134247601,
0.3377909064,
0.8540818691,
-0.628454566,
-0.5280976295,
-0.6423394084,
0.352453202,
0.1980089843,
-0.2781767249,
0.5073049664,
0.3144907057,
0.5002425313,
-0.1566463113,
0.6713106632,
0.2794316411,
0.4472511113,
-0.3375276625,
0.769382298,
-0.5935505033,
-0.0403428748,
-0.3999331594,
-0.7616605759,
-0.459682703,
0.642747283,
-0.0609895438,
0.2398337722,
0.4897218347,
0.6647998095,
-0.188269347,
-0.1832836568,
0.4604465663,
0.3308596611,
0.1684684902,
0.7192925215,
0.6221126914,
-0.3606721461,
0.5289750695,
-0.2538344562,
-0.4024215639,
0.0114735849,
-0.8008019328,
-0.7249571681,
-0.7277380228,
-0.3686531484,
0.0156717598,
0.4940942824,
0.9954553246,
1.3087627888,
-1.0683279037,
-0.6269293427,
-0.1146901771,
-0.2474825382,
-0.6450856924,
-0.1527545601,
0.434151262,
-0.2711749673,
-0.7116894722,
0.4481334984,
0.3022914827,
-0.4084393978,
0.2952540517,
-0.0773249492,
-0.1932840198,
-0.0413341373,
0.6653555632,
0.127876237,
-0.7154855132,
-0.5211653709,
-0.3654156923,
0.3018901944,
0.118758902,
0.9630651474,
-0.6619005203,
0.416015774,
0.3509111404,
0.7377488017,
0.3543041348,
0.0708340257,
0.7306591272,
-0.4487099648,
0.098297216,
0.0194149222,
0.3726969659,
0.0265521985,
-0.0998007357,
-0.0875764713,
-0.0688717216,
-0.8917097449,
-0.6866243482,
-0.0206126925,
-1.4489557743,
-0.2404721379,
0.9839357138,
-0.2575047314,
-0.0598825328,
-0.3237114847,
-0.2894316614,
0.4660331309,
-0.5344873071,
0.6787575483,
0.3150945306,
-0.1972254366,
-0.1912860274,
-0.5147981048,
0.2615708709,
0.3414586782,
-1.0303394794,
0.2995226383,
0.1886457056,
0.3959661722,
0.226689741,
0.4767815471,
0.2518655658,
0.5773646235,
-0.1493081748,
-0.0871192217,
-0.0490983203,
-0.5195226669,
-0.714248836,
0.2274211794,
0.1323946267,
-0.7655428052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16952v1
|
Data Mixing Laws: Optimizing Data Mixtures by Predicting Language Modeling Performance
| 2024-03-25T17:14:00 | 2024-03-25T17:14:00 |
Jiasheng Ye, Peiju Liu, Tianxiang Sun, Yunhua Zhou, Jun Zhan, Xipeng Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pretraining data of large language models composes multiple domains (e.g.,
web texts, academic papers, codes), whose mixture proportions crucially impact
the competence of outcome models. While existing endeavors rely on heuristics
or qualitative strategies to tune the proportions, we discover the quantitative
predictability of model performance regarding the mixture proportions in
function forms, which we refer to as the data mixing laws. Fitting such
functions on sample mixtures unveils model performance on unseen mixtures
before actual runs, thus guiding the selection of an ideal data mixture.
Furthermore, we propose nested use of the scaling laws of training steps, model
sizes, and our data mixing law to enable predicting the performance of large
models trained on massive data under various mixtures with only small-scale
training. Moreover, experimental results verify that our method effectively
optimizes the training mixture of a 1B model trained for 100B tokens in
RedPajama, reaching a performance comparable to the one trained for 48% more
steps on the default mixture. Extending the application of data mixing laws to
continual training accurately predicts the critical mixture proportion that
avoids catastrophic forgetting and outlooks the potential for dynamic data
schedules
|
[
-0.3499067724,
-0.634187758,
0.3840688169,
0.6203657985,
-0.2139192522,
0.2511877716,
-0.1708733588,
-0.436054796,
-0.0042641312,
0.685059309,
-0.479665786,
-0.2058770955,
-0.7494704723,
-0.288015604,
-0.7725286484,
0.5980116725,
0.0785226673,
0.3751699626,
-0.5702858567,
0.0548893437,
-0.508182168,
-0.7236691117,
-0.2640005052,
-0.4959059656,
0.2715236843,
0.2881618738,
0.5669993758,
0.7480059266,
0.2758677304,
0.1993920803,
0.0299734566,
-0.1326102912,
-0.7210677266,
0.1165357307,
0.0188246258,
-0.7769473791,
-0.0587857328,
-0.1112812534,
0.6790223122,
0.8422932029,
-0.6217556596,
-0.19674474,
-0.0363379121,
0.6419093013,
-0.6957656741,
0.2849876583,
-0.7725045681,
0.135500595,
-0.2575284839,
-0.3095437586,
-0.3766416907,
-0.3149782419,
0.0358497351,
-0.5570318699,
0.1142314076,
0.3947230279,
0.5483692884,
0.2831944227,
-0.2747407258,
-0.201107949,
-0.7391804457,
0.9685308337,
-0.8336758614,
0.5280287862,
0.4793474674,
0.5013535619,
-0.2441197485,
-0.5843292475,
-0.8463381529,
0.0078543657,
0.0768868029,
-0.0706660226,
-0.1233796701,
0.035385251,
0.0864009783,
0.3535791934,
-0.6595636606,
0.1078189015,
-0.3570536077,
0.0900171325,
0.5350656509,
0.4774689674,
0.3928691447,
0.6166523695,
0.2404384166,
-0.2411129475,
-0.5900632739,
-0.3205743432,
0.3277601302,
0.4842053652,
-0.2129409015,
0.6039968133,
-0.1219970062,
0.6912002563,
0.0081041502,
-0.3685326576,
0.1794314086,
-0.5437585115,
-0.152919203,
-0.0744478405,
0.5778212547,
0.1678713113,
0.6976208091,
-0.2961467206,
-0.3086301684,
0.0415423475,
0.4133363366,
-0.8986895084,
-0.4157141745,
0.1087561995,
-0.2200798243,
-0.3274056613,
-0.0765457749,
-0.5415585637,
-0.4652259946,
-0.8383198977,
0.4151871502,
-0.4332408905,
-0.4500161111,
0.5336130857,
0.0515521392,
-0.0859957039,
0.0829993337,
-1.0779186487,
0.7078056335,
0.9340956211,
0.6343886256,
-0.0872146413,
-0.4522221684,
-0.273349613,
-0.0181775428,
-0.4474729002,
0.2765604556,
-0.5039080381,
-0.4157592952,
0.1261705905,
-0.3512438536,
-0.3379537761,
-0.8629596233,
-0.0706214681,
-0.5994065404,
-0.0064702495,
0.113776274,
-0.7859377265,
-0.0030132663,
-0.0989188328,
-0.7871162891,
0.9753141999,
0.2264409959,
-0.7679110765,
0.7320758104,
-0.2493694872,
-0.8561326861,
-0.1707960367,
0.0250804927,
-0.4704294801,
0.2743444443,
-0.1349513382,
0.5449942946,
-0.2342391163,
0.3371796906,
-0.467317611,
-0.2821223438,
0.1947088242,
-0.0254318248,
0.7354819775,
0.2774353921,
-0.0838729963,
0.0877180323,
-0.6949932575,
-0.1360228807,
0.2014822364,
-0.1847532541,
-0.3079938591,
0.1797965467,
0.2134578228,
0.2015632093,
0.0327202678,
-0.1719896048,
-0.2040445358,
-0.044914186,
0.0918451697,
0.5261614323,
-0.0044567902,
0.4770353436,
-0.4326368868,
0.731415987,
0.3291835189,
0.1036138386,
0.1411865354,
-0.500679791,
-0.6160901785,
-0.1384906322,
0.5006338358,
0.3989459872,
-0.5991664529,
0.6003938317,
-0.3113176227,
-0.6769236326,
-0.4085760117,
0.2280075103,
0.0292319208,
0.2283876687,
0.2212481946,
-0.4441440403,
-0.9799983501,
-0.4181106985,
-0.1807323694,
-0.223998189,
0.3068724275,
0.2118685693,
0.5193269849,
-0.3177239001,
1.0307945013,
-0.3585673869,
0.2883119285,
-0.4687050283,
0.1972435117,
0.2474569976,
0.5969896913,
0.69627285,
-0.7667422891,
-0.7046570778,
0.1413431913,
-0.4884832501,
-0.0633497909,
0.0753443539,
0.0052126064,
-0.0944372341,
0.4305768907,
-0.3020532429,
0.0568184219,
0.705142796,
-0.1308485568,
0.6114343405,
-0.1880726367,
-0.0919212997,
-0.8015775681,
-0.0961520746,
0.2125075459,
-0.3585226834,
-0.6916764379,
-0.1383285373,
0.0686612129,
0.1149931252,
-0.3610670567,
0.4595979154,
-0.1408422589,
-0.0189080723,
-0.3561405838,
-0.4999530315,
-0.218121931,
0.0624560565,
0.0180462096,
0.9613733888,
0.7167807817,
-0.7530639172,
0.2308789343,
-0.1787439734,
-0.6026283503,
0.1890832931,
-0.6125810742,
-0.3171472549,
-0.0282398555,
0.1350724548,
-0.7977804542,
-0.2683165073,
-0.2583417594,
-0.2943630219,
0.4224317074,
-0.1392854005,
-0.771287322,
-0.2629894912,
0.1666897088,
0.485324651,
0.7303173542,
-0.3758616447,
0.6417578459,
0.6580225229,
-0.0737349242,
-0.5351241231,
-0.6880166531,
-0.1375287175,
-0.4280273318,
-0.5796419382,
0.1807944179,
-0.3214938045,
-0.3837991357,
-0.2477791458,
-0.0287826378,
-0.5263922811,
0.2823648453,
0.1288759261,
0.1440476626,
-0.2429490536,
-0.4463303685,
-0.0383362137,
0.1302721053,
0.1904722601,
-0.4433414042,
0.8516606688,
0.2231416702,
-0.1531647146,
-0.1644745916,
0.0695003867,
0.6959708333,
0.1394676417,
1.0739474297,
0.4513296187,
-0.4830088019,
-0.1844177544,
-0.4653010368,
-0.1369257122,
-0.4075671732,
0.3694332242,
-0.3274513781,
-0.5919041634,
0.5837510228,
0.207506761,
-0.0813468993,
0.1554808766,
0.7113110423,
0.0470471419,
1.0163061619,
0.7768588662,
-0.5193886161,
0.836904943,
-0.0145284645,
0.2225363702,
-0.1355030984,
-0.0984654278,
-0.5252991915,
-0.0772087723,
-0.6094985008,
-0.4899608791,
0.1100047156,
0.0142410882,
-0.0439070091,
0.3102929294,
0.1240658313,
0.8893936276,
0.4208435118,
-0.1327826083,
0.1966843903,
0.2289252877,
-0.0449361429,
-0.0950793922,
-0.8792611361,
0.00772068,
1.3049795628,
0.3985749483,
0.9205504656,
-0.1399665177,
0.7874668241,
0.2229839563,
0.1773354858,
-0.6729910374,
0.3239171207,
-0.1349157244,
-0.5957152247,
0.0622327067,
-0.8612756133,
-0.9573170543,
0.2876077592,
-0.1805491447,
-0.3757359982,
-0.0520858467,
0.0704806745,
-0.1536253393,
0.129311502,
-0.6841731071,
0.594738543,
-0.2103493214,
-0.0852889791,
-0.4684844911,
-0.6570382714,
0.2359949052,
-0.5267958045,
0.3737379611,
0.0374066085,
0.1863869727,
0.7171643972,
-0.2778256238,
0.7859659195,
-0.0436497703,
-0.0655373409,
0.1630070657,
0.0615208857,
0.2815885544,
-0.3058240414,
0.0970529392,
0.22140266,
0.0778773353,
-0.6120581627,
-0.4869119525,
0.4223364294,
-0.7942136526,
-0.0657736734,
-0.0505415983,
-0.6197860241,
-0.3713057935,
0.2797099352,
0.2753372788,
0.1190360785,
-0.0453026779,
0.4346423447,
0.7957578897,
0.2186061591,
0.1442471743,
0.4313750267,
-0.35601601,
-0.3087273538,
1.2786223888,
0.1903210282,
0.2936496139,
0.2810866237,
0.2743448019,
-0.2965629697,
-0.9242230654,
-0.0859477893,
0.1675439328,
-0.4418283403,
0.0887582302,
-0.663793385,
-0.0392015316,
-0.3963316977,
-0.0983150676,
-0.5084166527,
-0.4259383976,
-0.135247007,
0.1090049893,
0.0129311625,
0.6818082333,
0.028598275,
0.4947740436,
-0.6150155067,
0.1092798412,
0.0630075857,
0.4685626626,
-0.0368909277,
-0.5073658824,
-0.4919488728,
0.0825394019,
0.0604570881,
-0.4247319698,
0.4677396715,
0.0355265215,
0.6625452638,
0.2019595653,
-0.3620878756,
0.6504789591,
-0.3384793103,
0.4873888493,
0.3510416448,
-0.7426261306,
0.2615905702,
-0.3861411214,
-0.1401924342,
0.6571286321,
0.2613867521,
-0.4039118886,
-0.4752213955,
-0.7082705498,
-0.9319216609,
0.5904318094,
0.2701556087,
0.2238438874,
0.2977324724,
0.2032335252,
0.3062466085,
0.5734450221,
-0.7024615407,
-0.2906761765,
0.0606160015,
-0.6382629275,
-0.1348027289,
0.02770059,
-0.0157356896,
-0.5179112554,
0.7502644062,
0.016556086,
-0.0766309276,
-0.7778270841,
-0.1038011909,
-0.112899676,
-0.2754443288,
0.6368692517,
0.979224205,
-0.1906611472,
-0.1619781256,
-0.1640586406,
-0.7421607375,
0.212249428,
0.0669193789,
-0.0218607355,
-0.0761772469,
0.2128557265,
0.6605665684,
0.0713585094,
-0.9242679477,
0.4353911579,
-0.3031696081,
-0.287668556,
-0.2303486615,
0.5361087918,
0.1235143095,
0.1425649375,
0.2672369778,
-0.0642494187,
0.0458860472,
-0.4256861806,
0.3282249868,
0.0321833715,
-0.0797914788,
-0.1782499254,
0.5566657782,
-0.1284812987,
0.0956983492,
0.475928247,
0.0489295088,
-0.3118471801,
0.7776462436,
0.6674773097,
0.5266553164,
-0.3517293334,
-0.2383202314,
0.1887001842,
0.1309494078,
-0.4935179055,
0.169919163,
0.1682679057,
-0.8679105639,
-0.4182786644,
-0.6117635369,
-0.5508327484,
0.1067183241,
-0.6065832376,
0.1447488964,
-0.5447355509,
0.0278037172,
0.0196636561,
0.0042674285,
-0.6835578084,
0.586689949,
0.1906766742,
0.7923223972,
-1.0621041059,
0.7551564574,
0.4885981381,
-0.1960320622,
-0.6072797179,
0.0396857075,
0.0164773129,
-0.7404383421,
0.1755935997,
-0.0036890069,
0.1200914904,
0.001519133,
-0.4888571203,
-0.7669990063,
0.729755342,
0.4301836789,
-0.5083899498,
0.3003567755,
0.2912609577,
0.4467317462,
-0.6738157272,
0.0121563338,
0.9451490045,
0.247874245,
0.3542547822,
-0.8445760012,
-0.310133934,
-0.3229708374,
-0.2129444778,
0.2262013257,
-0.2245929241,
0.853376627,
0.0128983986,
-0.0911989436,
-0.1658617705,
0.6872580647,
0.4175858498,
0.3767734468,
0.5198050737,
0.6689692736,
0.8267816305,
-0.1883331686,
1.2711545229,
-0.4603495002,
0.2882579863,
1.1642735004,
-0.3705870211,
0.738933444,
0.4414225817,
-0.5714305043,
0.4081939757,
0.7023419738,
0.1323159486,
0.7408920527,
0.3080839217,
-0.2789392471,
-0.0854571313,
-0.0640812069,
-0.3453105092,
0.2190621495,
0.3356204927,
-0.2605231404,
0.0968070626,
-0.1979691684,
-0.051262524,
-0.0561135821,
0.0075411261,
0.7642459273,
-0.1252606362,
-0.5032013059,
0.6728100181,
-0.0475615375,
0.6331840158,
-0.4932291508,
0.2908464074,
-0.2268725187,
0.1733282954,
0.0224683564,
-0.886213541,
0.2901527286,
-0.3127673864,
-0.2658239305,
-0.0587704293,
0.4020375013,
-0.6047387123,
-0.3618933558,
0.2872948349,
0.4275850356,
0.0021729867,
-0.1657769829,
-0.6886423826,
0.0853461996,
-0.0125656705,
-0.0952715427,
0.615832448,
0.4963216782,
0.2561374605,
0.783921957,
0.6048777699,
0.4103042781,
0.458535552,
0.2734861672,
0.877420783,
-0.4919233024,
-0.8844301105,
-0.8202315569,
0.4233537614,
-0.0988126844,
-0.070152387,
0.3830517828,
0.8188913465,
0.9332313538,
0.032403484,
0.9467611313,
0.2111272365,
0.2544158697,
-0.5254046917,
0.5688662529,
-0.6360512376,
-0.0253043361,
-0.0147670489,
-1.0430061817,
-0.2822772563,
0.5033108592,
-0.1961563528,
0.2631290853,
0.4099655747,
0.7692983747,
-0.3829793036,
0.2628820837,
0.3106762171,
-0.0391047187,
0.273871541,
0.2782437205,
0.5062438846,
-0.2433348298,
0.0680314898,
-0.3706379831,
-0.047217261,
-0.4380321503,
-0.6321918964,
-0.6596756577,
-0.4818073213,
-0.358409971,
-0.3271116018,
-0.2044425011,
0.6935517788,
1.1364748478,
-0.8830673099,
-0.645475924,
-0.4659466743,
-0.0534839071,
-0.1844285131,
-0.2556575537,
-0.3337055743,
-0.3809072673,
-0.6228511333,
0.392118454,
0.0310460981,
0.5630894899,
-0.1862263978,
-0.2960677743,
-0.0433193333,
0.4190561473,
0.4827594161,
0.1664681733,
-0.3589543402,
0.4518084526,
-0.3522288501,
-0.3634345531,
-0.0316181965,
1.0434900522,
-0.3093754649,
0.5673164725,
0.5376495123,
0.8571278453,
0.7157758474,
-0.052517768,
0.8738163114,
-0.9018260241,
0.2293348014,
0.3463779986,
0.5592480898,
0.291439563,
-0.2316944748,
0.6347411275,
0.220271945,
-0.376522243,
-0.766279459,
-0.1361633092,
-0.815572083,
-0.3533470035,
0.9757227898,
0.0268330723,
-0.2747421861,
-0.1657980531,
0.084219113,
0.1640353799,
-0.2496832907,
0.7704796791,
0.9038088918,
-0.0063352757,
-0.2071672976,
-0.9423487186,
0.4261319041,
0.6825789213,
-0.9152713418,
0.2328229547,
0.4508002698,
0.357609719,
-0.0535231344,
0.4339331388,
-0.1095186546,
0.0732636675,
0.1591482013,
-0.1055662036,
0.2594692111,
-0.5144221187,
-0.142436862,
0.0196162518,
0.0955112278,
0.1335693747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16950v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16950v2
|
Aligning with Human Judgement: The Role of Pairwise Preference in Large Language Model Evaluators
| 2024-03-25T17:11:28 | 2024-03-26T02:28:42 |
Yinhong Liu, Han Zhou, Zhijiang Guo, Ehsan Shareghi, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen, Nigel Collier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated promising capabilities as
automatic evaluators in assessing the quality of generated natural language.
However, LLMs still exhibit biases in evaluation and often struggle to generate
coherent evaluations that align with human assessments. In this work, we first
conduct a systematic study of the misalignment between LLM evaluators and human
judgement, revealing that existing calibration methods aimed at mitigating
biases are insufficient for effectively aligning LLM evaluators. Inspired by
the use of preference data in RLHF, we formulate the evaluation as a ranking
problem and introduce Pairwise-preference Search (PairS), an uncertainty-guided
search method that employs LLMs to conduct pairwise comparisons and efficiently
ranks candidate texts. PairS achieves state-of-the-art performance on
representative evaluation tasks and demonstrates significant improvements over
direct scoring. Furthermore, we provide insights into the role of pairwise
preference in quantifying the transitivity of LLMs and demonstrate how PairS
benefits from calibration.
|
[
-0.2863383591,
-0.4454571009,
0.7902291417,
0.0736457705,
-0.1580769271,
0.1600601524,
-0.5040729046,
-0.4196567833,
0.0772572383,
0.4708976746,
-0.0647198185,
-0.3131920397,
-0.601822257,
0.0029032435,
-0.1182168201,
0.7925207019,
-0.1250596792,
0.2867699265,
-0.5625667572,
-0.2686120272,
-0.5012520552,
-0.5992187262,
-0.5974349976,
-0.7993174791,
0.6546722651,
0.3723328412,
1.1363689899,
0.5207290053,
0.666400969,
0.2087359577,
0.1370570511,
0.0822308138,
-0.5483629107,
0.2946067154,
-0.1397245973,
-0.2671749592,
-0.3000533581,
0.1928002536,
0.7396341562,
0.74938941,
-0.2042803317,
0.1013653576,
-0.0005625918,
1.0025789738,
-0.5789046884,
-0.0467483662,
-0.3530480862,
-0.0450198203,
-0.2668057382,
-0.2644093335,
-0.4044374824,
-0.6287529469,
0.4463633895,
-0.322958827,
0.0693415627,
0.5136727691,
0.6827372909,
0.2812696695,
-0.5325884819,
-0.0516574681,
-0.5003322363,
1.0242141485,
-0.7611026764,
0.65957582,
0.3389867842,
0.1685866266,
-0.2072213292,
-0.2105677426,
-0.2757388055,
-0.1665064692,
-0.0981160179,
-0.0870298371,
0.1666439623,
0.1811267883,
-0.1453258544,
0.3649736941,
-0.7571741939,
0.4874079823,
-0.1445248425,
-0.3578239679,
0.9755980372,
0.1110761687,
0.1695022881,
-0.3392957449,
-0.4009667635,
-0.2817827463,
-0.5738748908,
0.1173567995,
0.7574735284,
0.3468967974,
0.1239595115,
0.5124894977,
0.0311256927,
0.9023547173,
-0.006957192,
0.028717611,
0.0636598542,
-0.2207415253,
-0.1451066732,
0.1980716139,
1.1103897095,
0.7592193484,
0.2828930914,
-0.2284495234,
-0.4884006381,
0.1275117546,
0.4037258029,
-0.5806631446,
-0.1730538905,
0.1777573973,
-0.5012136102,
-0.5322620869,
0.1466302276,
-0.8524881601,
-0.4893771112,
-0.5289440155,
0.4861914515,
0.0098015834,
-0.1865974367,
0.1783515662,
-0.0943884999,
0.1876050383,
0.1454266608,
-1.0343497992,
0.4639597237,
0.8881979585,
0.4541364312,
-0.3805299401,
-0.296631068,
-0.5785357952,
-0.1235253364,
-0.5258564353,
0.7796313763,
-0.5711022615,
-0.4196094573,
-0.0105192522,
-0.4961770773,
0.0988828391,
-0.525175035,
0.9466004372,
-0.6975804567,
0.4122031033,
-0.4629497826,
-0.581307888,
-0.043898236,
0.1005595773,
-0.5905324221,
1.3488137722,
0.0378847048,
-0.8049263954,
0.4061617255,
-0.2742683887,
-0.2729995549,
0.0138885314,
-0.3092118204,
-0.3215997517,
0.0443442948,
0.2452072948,
0.4135701954,
-0.6006768942,
0.6027078032,
-0.4101307988,
-0.54475528,
0.2320606112,
-0.4244478047,
0.5832048655,
0.0912853405,
-0.1369787902,
0.3410585225,
-0.2861066461,
0.0543190725,
0.1020064503,
-0.3955354393,
-0.6691265702,
0.20197846,
0.2179524601,
-0.0561261922,
0.3578333557,
-0.2420338541,
0.1192689613,
-0.6040815115,
0.3364702761,
1.0605361462,
-0.2049827874,
0.7603835464,
-0.5086713433,
0.4284872413,
-0.3686696291,
0.1958296895,
0.4425573647,
-0.4427805543,
-0.6511664987,
0.3234888911,
0.4964562356,
0.3750359416,
-0.2513504624,
0.6793369651,
-0.4119817913,
-0.4586969912,
-0.7594860196,
0.4436352849,
0.5249938369,
0.4051913619,
0.0593351647,
-0.3086541593,
-0.5580172539,
-1.1479415894,
-0.3884806037,
-0.3903263211,
0.1475941539,
0.2743676007,
0.1217125729,
-0.0305686444,
1.0865024328,
-0.4346948862,
0.014784894,
-0.1767923683,
0.0034354406,
0.078312166,
0.3111778498,
0.3533371091,
-0.9002697468,
-0.303069979,
-0.1698623002,
-0.5353806615,
-0.2622013688,
0.2831974626,
-0.417442441,
0.2687778473,
0.2810109258,
-0.3305075169,
0.098770082,
0.8423138857,
-0.1803927571,
0.4594644308,
-0.1713045537,
0.2226521671,
-0.8279450536,
0.0585652478,
0.2474716157,
-0.4376477897,
-0.3626962602,
0.1429138631,
0.0796543658,
0.3040246964,
-0.1279771626,
0.7954722047,
-0.4175904393,
-0.2372578979,
-0.0330356397,
0.6543061733,
0.26720801,
0.0831592008,
-0.0270267166,
0.799141109,
0.1856624633,
-0.3943363726,
0.4211882651,
0.2049610466,
-0.4756377041,
0.5517399907,
-0.4347452521,
0.451880753,
-0.0476522185,
0.2207072973,
-1.0608887672,
-0.0912915543,
0.1105426401,
-0.3375559747,
0.37663275,
0.0243940763,
-0.4456348419,
-0.4047219455,
-0.6172908545,
0.6556044221,
0.359655261,
-0.5299182534,
0.2626618147,
0.5465365648,
-0.0310892854,
-0.652081728,
-0.5611154437,
0.0905775502,
-0.3005910814,
-0.6608536839,
0.4332427382,
-0.0923113301,
-0.6278990507,
-0.1171857268,
-0.3169670105,
0.3469788134,
0.0824384093,
0.2523680925,
0.6401181817,
-0.1380051523,
0.2467743456,
-0.2380231619,
-0.231894508,
0.042655509,
-0.1243518442,
0.5758751035,
-0.0947006494,
-0.4098353982,
-0.0739068165,
0.187397927,
0.3741134107,
-0.2391741574,
0.3667106926,
0.3493056595,
-0.238210842,
-0.0137998359,
-1.0591683388,
-0.1975563169,
-0.4406634569,
0.1464164555,
-0.0686070919,
-0.8855381608,
0.1383161545,
0.3449591398,
-0.0429059379,
0.4300746918,
0.4460255206,
-0.0262982231,
1.0447429419,
0.5235062242,
-0.4718526006,
0.2656356692,
0.2742127478,
0.4573767185,
-1.056314826,
-0.0348339565,
-0.6118671298,
-0.5020782351,
-0.551633358,
-0.2746568918,
0.4453769028,
0.1074708626,
-0.2466189265,
0.1146479174,
-0.5442370772,
0.5560533404,
0.5730614066,
0.2519066632,
0.2476959825,
-0.2369557619,
-0.2241757512,
-0.1918559521,
-0.5669677854,
-0.8270792961,
1.3416442871,
0.3187283874,
0.7026793361,
0.1017034128,
0.8165746331,
0.2286660969,
0.2377415746,
-0.9338921905,
0.4765464664,
-0.0372732989,
-0.4876919389,
-0.4734565616,
-0.4672386646,
-0.7831255198,
0.1836442798,
-0.2349711806,
-0.7720289826,
-0.1258887649,
0.0404327027,
-0.4693241715,
0.1182405353,
-0.7760135531,
0.883482039,
-0.5375830531,
-0.5353829861,
-0.3306003213,
-0.7616224885,
0.4041574299,
-0.0880850255,
0.2433007509,
-0.1106615886,
0.0342600383,
1.0083893538,
-0.0852260441,
0.4881077707,
0.0623188876,
-0.2376996726,
-0.0792578384,
0.2002250403,
0.3510164917,
0.0221163705,
-0.5964019895,
0.0633405745,
0.0062078978,
-0.2377787232,
-0.5647163391,
0.9707819223,
-0.7082636356,
-0.9450573325,
-0.4465887547,
-0.4645657837,
-0.3669820428,
0.1714384109,
0.0342113301,
0.2538606524,
-0.3041347265,
-0.0192795675,
0.5225898623,
-0.0622529238,
0.3443341553,
0.1333752722,
-0.6217096448,
-0.3959617913,
0.7578880191,
-0.1800374985,
0.4301919341,
0.5928438306,
0.5385377407,
-0.5209981799,
-0.4364041984,
-0.4195842445,
0.3173253238,
-0.6954200864,
-0.1881678998,
-0.2272769958,
-0.0739757046,
-0.4824467897,
-0.2225665897,
-0.1989605874,
-0.2101521343,
-0.1121929437,
-0.1179221347,
0.186891973,
0.8349614739,
0.1781691462,
0.0590018965,
-0.6562854648,
0.1345199496,
0.4984934032,
0.4696156085,
-0.0211946908,
-0.4962777495,
-0.0759924874,
-0.0519026294,
-0.2140899152,
-0.7149191499,
0.2283817232,
-0.2123105973,
0.6030133367,
0.3441391587,
0.1651038677,
0.6565244794,
-0.2294227034,
0.7177943587,
0.0601264872,
-0.9934151173,
0.3177186847,
-0.2702566087,
-0.0118007073,
0.7669923902,
0.1594131142,
-0.6613712907,
0.0111577539,
-0.3281334937,
-0.6033038497,
0.7960711718,
0.0578349195,
-0.1190979034,
0.4260780811,
0.2602245212,
0.0004411653,
0.1568487585,
-0.4875263572,
-0.2525348067,
0.1858492941,
-0.369679153,
-0.4585981369,
-0.3273123801,
-0.2951927781,
-0.2061944157,
0.6944383979,
-0.0631305873,
0.0255506374,
0.1333892643,
0.017143786,
-0.494528085,
0.3120960295,
0.40593642,
0.5888422132,
-0.4071986079,
0.2369218022,
-0.0669195727,
-0.1142293662,
0.1465702057,
0.0877595916,
-0.1815515608,
-0.2350494117,
0.1663209647,
0.7782052159,
0.6073185205,
-0.5797601342,
0.74683249,
-0.0505443737,
0.0660409331,
-0.0855654329,
-0.021080222,
0.2584762573,
0.1565240324,
0.224098146,
0.0356558859,
0.0851920769,
-0.3593218327,
-0.0707141832,
0.7064549923,
-0.3574296236,
-0.0805206969,
0.4583216608,
0.2696796358,
-0.6843218207,
0.5657850504,
-0.048084069,
-0.7957777977,
0.4555823505,
0.2714132965,
0.7675449848,
-0.2462192029,
0.0478280745,
0.1680936217,
0.2258963883,
-0.3995394409,
-0.0241990481,
-0.1329358816,
-1.0235005617,
-0.1417416185,
-0.7671844363,
-0.6420179009,
-0.1930866241,
-0.7089750767,
0.5478520393,
-0.1458878666,
-0.2080764472,
-0.0547307841,
0.1187112406,
-0.627845645,
0.0079325316,
0.2526496947,
0.6396892071,
-0.6546546817,
0.8276320696,
0.6553352475,
-0.2255066782,
-0.9287122488,
0.0716707259,
0.0951026529,
-0.8936479688,
0.6137248874,
0.2350306213,
-0.2076562047,
-0.0657318458,
-0.2527051568,
-0.7580328584,
0.9404413104,
0.3844277263,
-0.7317866087,
-0.1976024359,
0.0043165428,
0.4367058277,
-0.1295951307,
0.4007384181,
0.6999876499,
0.7818595171,
-0.2861594558,
-1.192661643,
0.0201312229,
-0.006103084,
0.0906555876,
0.5506910086,
-0.8023244143,
0.4679977894,
-0.086691536,
-0.0388504975,
-0.1077635288,
0.2247199416,
0.2633727789,
0.2923390865,
0.5742716789,
0.5634305477,
0.737334311,
-0.0963903144,
0.9627765417,
-0.2557942271,
0.3074275255,
0.9456369281,
-0.5777662396,
1.0764073133,
0.8058319688,
-0.4176923633,
0.3580201268,
0.7317814231,
0.2499325424,
0.229374662,
0.2665143311,
-0.2095540017,
-0.6219248772,
-0.1051480994,
-0.1383794546,
0.3885450065,
0.0836074501,
-0.2789642215,
-0.0533266626,
-0.4271166921,
-0.1728954911,
0.4085995555,
-0.092784062,
0.5506455302,
0.2042558789,
-1.0193310976,
0.3746604323,
0.0721945465,
0.8249666691,
-0.3711552322,
0.1909699887,
-0.0708691552,
0.0083274785,
-0.3579289019,
-1.0027457476,
0.0804422125,
-0.2448698878,
-0.1257813275,
-0.4525512755,
0.6651512384,
-0.314606756,
-0.3889397681,
0.5537635088,
0.4200549722,
0.0019632361,
-0.0487403795,
-0.5555827618,
0.2479627877,
-0.0020015435,
-0.2812534571,
0.4461767375,
-0.0501695909,
-0.1722770333,
0.5735428929,
0.652916491,
0.1587549746,
-0.1815595031,
0.2434350699,
0.578263998,
-0.6217260957,
-0.2161461413,
-1.0092316866,
0.0941099003,
0.0801840127,
-0.2913710177,
0.6293380857,
0.7389833331,
0.7310656905,
0.3048899472,
0.6452979445,
0.3306493759,
0.4199416339,
-0.6082491279,
0.7149575353,
-0.410254389,
0.3776549995,
-0.2938928306,
-1.1793175936,
-0.3491857052,
0.6430740356,
-0.5386525393,
0.0262316093,
0.5799644589,
0.9103195071,
0.0451101102,
0.0972798616,
0.2860623598,
-0.1686074883,
0.3358100057,
0.5744303465,
0.780860424,
-0.5257160068,
0.2218292803,
-0.2461816669,
-0.0886728168,
-0.2629429102,
-1.0939161777,
-0.7602191567,
-0.5417897105,
-0.0481794514,
-0.1651872993,
0.0172609091,
1.3786969185,
0.6851636767,
-0.6105632186,
-0.6132509112,
-0.0033384429,
0.4002679586,
0.0869958624,
-0.2686386704,
0.3375329375,
-0.1938304603,
-0.7960460186,
0.3875264227,
0.3301895261,
-0.1269112676,
-0.6557810307,
-0.4302195907,
-0.1853278279,
-0.1246098876,
0.3044016957,
-0.1208463013,
-0.9344433546,
-0.4268802106,
-0.1407368779,
-0.3810726702,
0.2523646057,
0.7850483656,
-0.8193053007,
0.4966610074,
0.6015810966,
0.6970114112,
0.2263650298,
0.1259966493,
0.9341738224,
-0.4547069073,
-0.1674455106,
0.2812061906,
0.3292411268,
0.6006685495,
-0.2995323241,
0.4551840127,
0.0013924122,
-1.0327737331,
-0.9479817748,
-0.0105745587,
-1.1255387068,
0.0190346893,
1.3064495325,
0.2556527555,
-0.0328566507,
0.0937836096,
-0.3519290686,
0.2163523287,
-0.6017612219,
0.7127174735,
0.9915979505,
-0.0068601924,
0.0303854868,
-0.4157537222,
0.3581509292,
0.6784870625,
-0.4983601272,
0.0301283319,
0.3872105777,
0.1999043077,
0.1108978242,
0.4570653141,
0.0635010228,
-0.1016338021,
-0.4832979441,
-0.0017869683,
0.2279860526,
0.0073173214,
-0.5527063608,
-0.0739170238,
0.4997542202,
0.0863237232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16941v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16941v1
|
SPACE-IDEAS: A Dataset for Salient Information Detection in Space Innovation
| 2024-03-25T17:04:02 | 2024-03-25T17:04:02 |
Andrés García-Silva, Cristian Berrío, José Manuel Gómez-Pérez
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DL
|
Detecting salient parts in text using natural language processing has been
widely used to mitigate the effects of information overflow. Nevertheless, most
of the datasets available for this task are derived mainly from academic
publications. We introduce SPACE-IDEAS, a dataset for salient information
detection from innovation ideas related to the Space domain. The text in
SPACE-IDEAS varies greatly and includes informal, technical, academic and
business-oriented writing styles. In addition to a manually annotated dataset
we release an extended version that is annotated using a large generative
language model. We train different sentence and sequential sentence
classifiers, and show that the automatically annotated dataset can be leveraged
using multitask learning to train better classifiers.
|
[
-0.4287801087,
-0.6364591718,
0.9535545707,
0.134436816,
-0.3709128201,
0.113787815,
-0.2174903154,
-0.566372931,
0.4908558428,
0.2956542671,
-0.6336690784,
-0.5767015219,
-0.3622674644,
-0.0766408816,
-0.4602016509,
1.0334649086,
0.0266941227,
-0.426342845,
-0.5065715313,
0.1064970344,
-0.6346576214,
-0.3401254117,
-0.2153834105,
0.2789813578,
0.5185679197,
0.6423865557,
0.328289777,
0.4310719371,
0.7365336418,
0.1979407966,
0.1188599393,
0.251595974,
-0.0444103889,
0.006092736,
0.0084543396,
-0.3792192936,
0.1329131871,
-0.1493304819,
0.6178817153,
0.5634709597,
0.1529897451,
0.1218057796,
-0.2919696271,
0.6915062666,
-0.655346036,
0.385723412,
-0.2936249375,
0.2246985286,
-0.5582021475,
-0.1157389954,
-0.117186442,
-0.5127296448,
-0.0137450937,
-0.7075872421,
0.2949435115,
0.3666373789,
0.8251297474,
0.3732378781,
0.277541697,
-0.7032293677,
-0.6178818941,
0.7161954641,
-0.3234256208,
0.1867622733,
0.0177214947,
0.1931569427,
0.0235749483,
-0.4811335504,
-0.9354159832,
-0.1094064564,
-0.0553342365,
0.0774624422,
-0.2649759054,
-0.2737925947,
0.1898884922,
0.2105971575,
-0.6595694423,
-0.217805624,
-0.442320466,
0.325725317,
0.5384659767,
-0.1688732356,
-0.050304953,
-0.3896658719,
-0.4378305376,
-0.0266937241,
-0.5369145274,
-0.0040680333,
0.4044338465,
0.2665573657,
0.1174990386,
0.6742071509,
-0.3654657006,
0.5803571343,
-0.0159260705,
0.5179355145,
0.4144873917,
-0.5121572018,
-0.0121123577,
0.0333376601,
0.6108211279,
0.1888568103,
-0.0623239353,
-0.3505610526,
0.0059896293,
0.1712507457,
0.2568596601,
-0.5604797602,
-0.3232732117,
0.3023994863,
-0.2495346069,
-0.1299291551,
0.6687293053,
-0.5730851889,
-0.6562477946,
-0.1930995882,
0.0294840354,
-0.4984415174,
-0.0863509551,
0.2959049046,
-0.6788601279,
-0.2577341795,
0.2261076719,
-0.8980460167,
0.0572771654,
0.8119952679,
0.8515962958,
-0.0920710787,
-0.2177883089,
0.0542250685,
0.0535744205,
-0.1923072189,
1.4053009748,
-0.7021351457,
-0.2543498576,
-0.2620795071,
-0.0959605947,
0.0406382307,
-0.3635930419,
0.7591073513,
-0.3816285431,
0.3109049499,
-0.4242002368,
-0.6569473743,
-0.114665091,
0.0337486081,
-0.8283736706,
0.9675053954,
0.1308496743,
-0.9384541512,
1.0037178993,
-1.4486649036,
-0.6038782597,
0.4477618635,
-0.3248390853,
-0.6651853323,
0.1857453436,
0.1260297894,
0.3315460086,
0.0066039916,
0.3449246883,
-0.0088741174,
-0.2438425869,
0.590300858,
0.1524732262,
0.1066525951,
0.2913506925,
-0.4189895391,
0.2550318837,
-0.769433558,
0.0293682534,
0.1819317639,
-0.2898588479,
-0.5798871517,
-0.1847837418,
0.1781366318,
0.0461324416,
0.1336749792,
-0.7984287739,
0.3000479341,
-0.1353623569,
0.186266616,
0.3516042531,
0.4567207396,
0.2803671956,
-0.29428792,
0.3012886047,
0.0286652856,
0.2266984582,
-0.2406858206,
-0.7177584767,
-0.7008367777,
-0.3198381364,
0.0080620283,
0.1784749776,
-0.6972926855,
0.7849210501,
-0.0390252545,
-0.4405224025,
-0.6637507081,
-0.1325916946,
0.0931239799,
0.2902430892,
0.2987724543,
-0.1201215014,
-0.6942515373,
-0.9420936108,
-0.6974927783,
0.0807531327,
0.0551542751,
0.2938150465,
0.7006146312,
-0.1985117942,
1.0720695257,
-0.9439117908,
-0.1280734688,
-0.1482959539,
0.5480968356,
0.2498539388,
0.4200691879,
0.4597054124,
-1.3216166496,
-0.1933081597,
-0.2847737968,
-0.5298310518,
-0.002780786,
-0.1804860979,
-0.1383907199,
-0.1927694678,
0.4657841027,
-0.7689475417,
0.2309811115,
-0.0552887991,
-0.5301037431,
0.3893234432,
0.3353433907,
0.4343757331,
-1.1704852581,
0.3128036857,
0.3090365231,
0.2486711591,
-0.526212275,
-0.3775197864,
0.0715803504,
-0.1242031455,
-0.2878734767,
0.5530554652,
-0.2655778229,
0.1087524146,
-0.5903269649,
0.2781490982,
0.2943412662,
0.2334997803,
0.388184458,
0.5395249128,
0.1133632064,
-0.3935675025,
0.6236808896,
0.3974995315,
-0.6535535455,
0.4302847981,
-0.135458529,
0.1731290668,
-0.5018433332,
0.140203014,
-1.0348607302,
-0.5780613422,
0.1678331345,
-0.2927111089,
-0.2336912453,
0.0767154843,
-0.8876562119,
-0.7309682965,
-0.5013504624,
-0.0058585163,
-0.0863380805,
-0.6250026822,
-0.1720819026,
0.5964550376,
-0.58210361,
-0.5883983374,
-0.5509212017,
0.1746595055,
-0.4225454926,
-0.3186345398,
0.5342413783,
-0.0396627672,
-0.089433454,
0.5459500551,
0.4146647155,
-0.2125174999,
0.0685869455,
0.6060090661,
0.3707034886,
0.051937215,
0.507373333,
-0.1943371743,
-0.038267117,
-0.0722126514,
-0.5791330934,
0.3303873241,
-0.3056684732,
-0.2838103473,
-0.2922380567,
0.3388679922,
0.3908926249,
0.1916695088,
0.5059608221,
0.7775331736,
-0.5525973439,
-0.2583327293,
-0.4876941442,
-0.0064364714,
-0.3995685875,
0.6545912623,
-0.0971203893,
-0.6612208486,
0.0620085485,
-0.2479946464,
0.24193573,
0.4712051749,
0.2468401045,
-0.381190449,
0.3337558508,
1.278169632,
-0.0022415856,
0.896666944,
-0.3469474316,
0.471268028,
-0.78185004,
-0.4095484614,
-0.4675847292,
-0.3441901207,
-0.0253564958,
-0.47147879,
0.0345145985,
-0.1018883064,
0.2402508557,
0.53374964,
-0.6382516026,
0.748046577,
0.6841444969,
-0.2157242745,
0.1228392124,
-0.0172709767,
0.2499775141,
-0.1144742146,
-0.8198240399,
-0.7174871564,
0.8166373968,
0.24518089,
0.75796175,
-0.1534371078,
0.4096968472,
0.4545561075,
0.4407498538,
-0.8417941928,
0.2863008678,
-0.2449548244,
-0.3801760674,
-0.2051537037,
-0.3870848119,
-0.5308820605,
-0.2448834032,
-0.1599634588,
-0.4531148076,
0.4462551177,
-0.0335643664,
-0.8064369559,
0.1823488474,
-0.9970664382,
0.6916214228,
-0.2817258835,
-0.1502571106,
-0.0352154113,
-0.4622189701,
0.0495436005,
-0.2255568206,
0.1597639471,
-0.0507945344,
0.3048924208,
1.0133873224,
0.2045544684,
0.8095453978,
-0.2869373858,
0.1154217497,
0.4422649741,
-0.4749742746,
0.1373843551,
0.0870543718,
0.0287320577,
-0.088092722,
-0.5689735413,
-0.099867329,
-0.47122401,
0.5511260629,
-0.4144226611,
-0.2743239403,
-0.28796646,
-0.8215740323,
-0.1435525268,
0.0951955765,
0.4305685461,
-0.1037604287,
-0.3674910963,
0.1643504351,
0.2847292423,
-0.0622109063,
0.4990565181,
0.2278506011,
0.1943295747,
-0.2214397043,
0.7898254395,
0.0724910498,
-0.0644602329,
0.4532141984,
-0.0359863527,
-0.5840789676,
-0.2564581037,
-0.4542909861,
0.0643818453,
-0.8359178305,
-0.11035382,
-0.7230259776,
-0.1863398254,
-0.2507650554,
-0.3169492781,
-0.2466840148,
-0.8494240046,
-0.2760112584,
-0.1308835447,
0.4371746778,
0.9941624999,
0.1064561233,
0.1620791554,
-0.4664263725,
0.2711069584,
-0.0463538915,
0.1885417551,
-0.2398767918,
-0.094385244,
-0.7182245851,
-0.2272016108,
-0.4338814914,
-0.2722596526,
0.2737540305,
0.1210078821,
0.4677273929,
0.474257648,
-0.3608869612,
0.2838254869,
-0.3011271954,
0.8113201261,
0.3852458596,
-0.6239489317,
0.9452036023,
0.0644477904,
0.5214431882,
0.5106055737,
0.4584531486,
-0.8059043288,
-0.3310332,
-0.7044586539,
-0.8340096474,
0.4044123888,
0.1566552371,
-0.2077649534,
0.0636591837,
0.2808214426,
0.4985238612,
0.8377079964,
-0.7673748136,
0.2078263611,
-0.248269707,
-0.5600400567,
0.3564654589,
0.0228857864,
-0.2122936845,
0.2126146406,
0.6079270244,
-0.0850621387,
0.420904994,
-0.0057053673,
0.0516701192,
-0.1247665808,
0.6087563038,
0.5082498789,
0.4829028845,
-0.1300463676,
0.2731449604,
-0.2197565883,
-0.6528721452,
-0.0189525075,
0.3263512254,
-0.3062671125,
0.3234544098,
0.1179733947,
0.8209824562,
0.1722646356,
-0.5941179395,
0.4367471337,
-0.1148848236,
-0.0092886901,
-0.1884919852,
0.2541840374,
0.0546876937,
0.4102990925,
0.5057544708,
0.6393299103,
0.3467267454,
-0.6300382018,
0.2152796388,
0.1807543039,
-0.3128430843,
-0.5058636069,
0.4503014982,
0.1882180423,
-0.0104051875,
0.1171795651,
-0.4135032892,
-0.5216477513,
0.7136141062,
0.4515888393,
0.8676648736,
0.3156576157,
0.2939631343,
0.0445929095,
0.1609708816,
0.005766666,
0.5357841849,
-0.1516997516,
-0.654009819,
-0.0866619796,
-0.4381510615,
-0.3557862639,
0.3154552877,
-0.055641558,
0.3852930069,
-0.4871835113,
-0.5339584947,
0.4673152268,
0.0256906264,
-0.6802821159,
0.1057007611,
0.3306481242,
0.4965242147,
-0.9432573318,
0.4485359788,
0.9485372305,
-0.4215116203,
-0.0244774222,
0.2176984102,
-0.1830646396,
-0.2823024392,
1.0620342493,
0.2863221169,
-0.260348618,
-0.2998651862,
-0.6550372243,
-0.9015222192,
0.7931303382,
0.0137095507,
-0.687210381,
-0.0533917286,
0.0770784169,
0.2642303109,
-0.7449391484,
-0.2590613961,
0.2905562222,
0.6189016104,
-0.0332816616,
-0.4780286849,
-0.1829461306,
-0.4891988933,
-0.2139320821,
0.2499890774,
-0.6823750138,
0.8276489973,
-0.6154693961,
-0.4403169155,
0.0444137715,
0.513994813,
0.4454216659,
0.4413704872,
0.5541416407,
0.5589542389,
1.0612311363,
-0.257001549,
0.656904757,
-0.1713714153,
0.1850526035,
0.8849274516,
-0.2859243453,
0.6434522271,
0.5123438239,
0.2394964844,
0.5651272535,
0.4280068278,
-0.5796429515,
0.9305607677,
0.1393830776,
-0.2750481069,
0.5357855558,
-0.4661195874,
-0.2815202773,
0.0490346812,
0.6737667918,
-0.2496005893,
0.0762291774,
0.3006419241,
-0.0157565102,
-0.0497687235,
0.1426611245,
0.7232409716,
-0.0473127775,
-0.4744961858,
0.0204542149,
0.0044983588,
0.7881608009,
-0.2597525418,
-0.2346763313,
0.2064468563,
0.0910265297,
-0.4238167405,
-1.1651062965,
0.2081574649,
0.2819454372,
-0.4423829913,
-0.0899970904,
0.9222606421,
-0.4759920239,
-0.4287439287,
-0.1063368097,
0.2095995992,
0.1057615355,
-0.2397873551,
-0.5497307181,
-0.2433637828,
-0.2243851423,
0.0765787587,
-0.3588268161,
0.7008296847,
0.0598416254,
0.3505911231,
0.6570314765,
0.3652291298,
-0.0980663747,
0.310379833,
1.0629527569,
-0.9460232258,
-1.1353096962,
-0.6197387576,
0.3996139169,
-0.6660403609,
-0.5318979025,
0.7792107463,
0.8533281684,
0.6617873311,
-0.4455156624,
1.3270273209,
-0.2675682902,
0.6687883735,
-0.476126045,
0.5928835869,
-0.0342189185,
0.2373087108,
-0.3754234016,
-0.8122311234,
-0.3067390025,
0.5738124251,
-0.4901641607,
0.0604913458,
0.9301224947,
0.3891948164,
-0.1422051489,
0.3964901567,
-0.0325240232,
-0.1068387479,
0.368111074,
0.495153904,
1.2098740339,
-0.2531448603,
0.233093977,
-0.1365827471,
-0.3331258297,
-0.5576213598,
-0.6688855886,
-0.6980215907,
-0.9058070183,
-0.5148044825,
0.1198872924,
0.038749408,
0.7451474667,
0.9100276828,
-0.8200469613,
0.1035548076,
-0.2979137003,
-0.0381518044,
-0.0613304339,
-0.3108592629,
0.5161885619,
-0.4011142552,
-0.2528593838,
0.6040609479,
0.6802497506,
0.11352662,
-0.1139720455,
0.4831310511,
-0.381207794,
0.016109772,
0.5221436024,
0.2968827784,
-0.3249466717,
-0.3657231033,
0.1423008889,
-0.0229498502,
0.1463743299,
1.0483694077,
-0.6359117031,
0.2743897736,
0.1611623317,
0.6698408723,
0.2533848882,
0.1437163204,
0.1315205395,
-1.3503926992,
0.5458700061,
0.5087122917,
0.3004910648,
0.7590632439,
-0.7647594213,
0.4278171659,
0.4105946124,
-0.3687295616,
-0.4468706548,
0.0496436134,
-0.5257745981,
-0.5274413228,
0.7917135358,
-0.0446241722,
-0.4264710546,
-0.4192376733,
-0.4049557447,
-0.0769845173,
-0.6783728004,
1.2771440744,
0.7806871533,
-0.387919575,
0.2432650775,
-0.4619579315,
0.8183541298,
0.2122358084,
-1.436679244,
0.2479130626,
0.4083643258,
-0.0830367357,
0.9125570059,
0.5292332172,
-0.0195268225,
0.3193268776,
0.044060193,
0.2432871461,
0.0916958675,
-0.6585164666,
0.1754473895,
0.2725296617,
0.0104744183,
-0.4239520431
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16915v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16915v3
|
Coarse-Tuning for Ad-hoc Document Retrieval Using Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-03-25T16:32:50 | 2024-03-27T01:53:36 |
Atsushi Keyaki, Ribeka Keyaki
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning in information retrieval systems using pre-trained language
models (PLM-based IR) requires learning query representations and
query-document relations, in addition to downstream task-specific learning.
This study introduces coarse-tuning as an intermediate learning stage that
bridges pre-training and fine-tuning. By learning query representations and
query-document relations in coarse-tuning, we aim to reduce the load of
fine-tuning and improve the learning effect of downstream IR tasks. We propose
Query-Document Pair Prediction (QDPP) for coarse-tuning, which predicts the
appropriateness of query-document pairs. Evaluation experiments show that the
proposed method significantly improves MRR and/or nDCG@5 in four ad-hoc
document retrieval datasets. Furthermore, the results of the query prediction
task suggested that coarse-tuning facilitated learning of query representation
and query-document relations.
|
[
-0.5915689468,
-0.6304323673,
0.4576208293,
-0.4910285771,
-0.5355522037,
-0.1477493197,
-0.3364874721,
-0.3702370822,
0.0463633277,
0.488405019,
-0.5054631829,
-0.5454589128,
-0.5919910073,
-0.0992561951,
-0.1493457258,
0.8503576517,
0.2296199948,
0.2029296309,
-0.2379047275,
-0.1714706868,
-0.2007737458,
-0.2754508555,
-0.7096577287,
-0.2989070714,
0.5501952767,
0.4777582884,
0.6623471379,
0.9502434731,
0.5945413709,
0.2525714636,
0.267107904,
0.5220828056,
-0.6031090617,
0.305803448,
-0.3551306427,
-0.5588955283,
-0.2543579042,
0.3166869283,
0.5984811783,
0.7060168386,
-0.2954510748,
0.0997845605,
0.1772060394,
0.846416235,
-0.6088603735,
0.3192911446,
-1.1695618629,
-0.3251159489,
-0.3846332133,
-0.8222557306,
-0.3439968526,
-0.2410117239,
-0.188582629,
-0.7710088491,
0.6162193418,
0.5588471293,
1.1376250982,
0.1392506808,
-0.3816952705,
-0.3279433846,
-0.5155043602,
0.5253298879,
-0.5531602502,
0.4906309545,
1.0669471025,
0.1048228592,
-0.2799079716,
-0.7158765793,
-0.3812123537,
-0.1853346974,
-0.2538953125,
-0.0662235469,
0.4335366189,
0.4224127531,
0.0851507783,
0.4771053493,
-0.6439350247,
0.1180285439,
-0.3407242,
0.0259939022,
0.4515273571,
0.0577159524,
-0.1653453708,
0.0907214805,
-0.0835892409,
-0.1073792502,
-0.5056004524,
-0.1884760559,
0.3781198263,
0.7129940391,
0.1742791533,
0.2249321491,
-0.4597748816,
0.9218776226,
0.3581020534,
0.1713447571,
0.0231814645,
-0.511086762,
-0.0315130651,
-0.2009754181,
0.6304510236,
0.1430332065,
0.1869056523,
-0.4554243982,
-0.4104052186,
-0.148161307,
0.3249180913,
-0.6955762506,
-0.4031166434,
-0.1835988164,
-0.4270276129,
-0.1673091799,
0.2983702421,
-0.3116754889,
-0.1794325411,
-0.8052380085,
0.6263982058,
-0.6448413134,
0.0685274303,
0.1419978589,
0.154019475,
0.2307408154,
0.3381477296,
-0.8298072219,
0.6714606881,
0.5729438066,
0.6143689752,
0.1632142365,
-0.4010382593,
-0.977660954,
0.2303456515,
-0.0733999312,
1.1465460062,
-0.779630065,
-0.4597468972,
-0.0787937194,
-0.0479500741,
-0.3615859747,
-0.5851255655,
0.7520217896,
-0.9138005376,
0.0160144232,
-0.1352462023,
-0.5692324042,
0.0965695158,
0.1397145092,
-0.6419783831,
1.1766711473,
0.0977309495,
-0.7784891129,
0.3076262176,
-0.1623319387,
-0.7747228146,
-0.0446661264,
-0.196592465,
-0.3565872312,
0.1682182252,
0.1808117777,
0.4505108297,
-0.3570221066,
0.0032926956,
-0.3500112295,
-0.5642938614,
-0.4623397887,
0.117794767,
-0.0119821439,
0.2470851094,
0.0652168691,
-0.1102858931,
-0.8473183513,
0.1588855535,
-0.1029726565,
-0.5499333143,
-0.5668097734,
0.1723977476,
-0.1459350437,
0.2812522948,
0.2969738543,
-0.281778723,
0.1657698303,
-0.6416649818,
0.2311646193,
0.6896745563,
-0.1052263379,
0.8357464671,
-0.5815357566,
0.3037688136,
-0.0636735484,
-0.0551086217,
-0.34364748,
-0.0561055541,
-0.6416997313,
0.3021006584,
0.4140303433,
0.2529253662,
-0.7254420519,
0.1546030492,
-0.1570923328,
-0.3749625683,
-0.5663470626,
0.3328118324,
0.5757308602,
0.6301490664,
0.4868016243,
-0.2001096308,
-0.3417128623,
-0.4167531133,
-0.4992704988,
-0.183603093,
0.0007773698,
0.7776062489,
0.187051326,
0.0283832252,
0.636166513,
-0.6994278431,
-0.7303881049,
0.2466122508,
0.6962749958,
-0.0528502092,
0.5593050122,
0.2471698672,
-1.0756597519,
-0.5531944633,
-0.0821558833,
-0.0055976463,
0.0498905629,
0.2630799413,
-0.203890875,
0.144287616,
0.759334147,
-0.4439556301,
0.1445321441,
0.0640532151,
-0.1577239186,
0.5932939649,
-0.6314830184,
0.3384773731,
-0.783359766,
0.0628300756,
0.0924445763,
-0.344083935,
-0.1753234267,
0.1304319948,
0.3599006236,
-0.2771015167,
-0.1107067466,
0.5538840294,
-0.5513784289,
0.0436095409,
-0.2207252383,
0.1940254718,
0.313863039,
0.4129396975,
0.0528504215,
0.8300167918,
0.4542742372,
-0.8298764825,
-0.1270578355,
0.006056082,
-0.2055163085,
0.4802520275,
-0.4784321785,
0.3715921938,
-0.270994097,
0.0087931044,
-0.87281394,
-0.1392572373,
-0.3467417657,
-0.6138878465,
0.8122927547,
-0.4159648716,
-0.7921221256,
-0.1770318747,
-0.4057008922,
0.238638863,
0.0620263629,
-0.3193102777,
0.4694682658,
0.3089318275,
-0.1313402206,
-0.1912110746,
0.0427890942,
-0.3785040379,
0.1113617346,
-0.4301835001,
0.7255644798,
0.1516760737,
0.1834192127,
-0.0950435326,
-0.3838163018,
-0.2677547336,
-0.0396466404,
0.0694570914,
-0.0855290666,
-0.170623228,
0.2946523428,
0.0153418556,
-0.1033818647,
-0.2379032671,
-0.467944175,
0.5282969475,
-0.1558212489,
-0.1988320649,
0.0454457253,
0.1407200843,
0.359719038,
-0.6578164101,
0.6769559979,
0.6910049915,
-0.1552122831,
-0.1306382418,
-0.7785968184,
-0.4598609805,
-0.5044521093,
0.1246296763,
-0.5432063341,
-0.7911394238,
0.4316389263,
-0.339048177,
-0.3216521144,
0.2232932448,
0.0295570213,
-0.4046691656,
1.1724154949,
0.8462186456,
-0.0408184156,
0.6094349027,
-0.3052485287,
-0.1661618501,
-0.8057423234,
-0.2691318095,
-0.9664518237,
-0.2764393091,
-0.577070117,
-0.4485277534,
0.3254734874,
0.4177099466,
-0.4206530452,
0.1946468353,
-0.1851733327,
0.4369439781,
0.7430709004,
0.387911588,
0.4171814322,
-0.0350631773,
-0.2310338914,
0.0457674488,
-0.5865849853,
-0.2054777294,
0.999301672,
-0.2784851491,
1.0101191998,
-0.3217720389,
0.5789493918,
0.0831918344,
-0.3537645936,
-0.6620567441,
0.3256214261,
-0.5247673988,
-0.2161235064,
-0.1816277057,
-0.4586048424,
-0.944024682,
0.2028674334,
-0.3062913418,
-0.4255204201,
0.1567544043,
0.1495937705,
-0.2507386804,
-0.0220501032,
-0.4911323786,
0.6059901714,
-0.0344029404,
-0.4218898714,
-0.5302826166,
-0.895584166,
-0.0412154868,
-0.0789320543,
0.3386920989,
-0.2089361846,
0.0393891819,
0.5972486734,
-0.1484354585,
0.3739949465,
-0.1628565192,
0.2504402399,
-0.0566156656,
0.2125144452,
0.8233141899,
0.2385463715,
-0.6290835738,
-0.3150319755,
-0.0286097284,
-0.3815643787,
-0.5054258704,
0.837038517,
-0.7077721357,
-0.6201441884,
-0.231772095,
-0.5400923491,
-0.4277730584,
0.531786561,
0.2928163707,
0.7197387815,
-0.0647196695,
0.3652361631,
1.0313899517,
0.1775021702,
0.0774881318,
1.1891967058,
0.2075828016,
0.0171187483,
0.7631030679,
0.1461117566,
0.0122376457,
0.7435157895,
-0.0037965945,
-0.4962978065,
-0.8739773631,
0.093153283,
0.3501885831,
-0.3968308568,
-0.479772985,
-0.6066837907,
-0.0089534372,
-0.5749447346,
-0.0161350239,
-0.258548975,
-0.1628728658,
-0.6502417922,
0.2359268218,
0.2627837062,
0.3764179349,
0.051942464,
0.4345294535,
-0.8672527671,
0.4964167476,
-0.0224781092,
0.8740798235,
-0.2250882387,
-0.8379392028,
-0.6209108233,
-0.0672063753,
-0.3873101771,
-0.2500721216,
0.2059777975,
0.9825593829,
0.425966531,
0.4156000614,
0.5783987045,
0.7929516435,
-0.7693588734,
0.2227366567,
-0.3090068698,
-0.345895052,
1.0872240067,
-0.6554329395,
0.2187622637,
1.0910536051,
0.615765214,
0.0423201881,
-0.482671082,
-0.4435842335,
-0.8870582581,
1.0632842779,
-0.0627546981,
0.0978706703,
0.0291247945,
0.6558145881,
0.2318015248,
0.2480248213,
-0.1750437021,
-0.2035254687,
0.0274749175,
0.0866051689,
-0.1583087146,
-0.1864749342,
0.0820890516,
-0.3161782324,
0.6396822333,
-0.2948821187,
-0.0249024332,
0.0335306823,
-0.1933240741,
-0.4639270604,
0.0422289558,
0.0780957341,
0.6887618303,
-0.7395924926,
0.2077489644,
-0.2269688994,
-0.4623137414,
-0.0686055273,
0.6119201183,
0.2228918225,
-0.0278934818,
0.0036670614,
0.6926295757,
0.5467574596,
-0.4253398478,
0.3964047432,
-0.2983960807,
-0.0713015199,
0.1840463728,
0.1795812696,
-0.0848323703,
0.0290427506,
0.4378434718,
0.1152893379,
0.3384654522,
-0.4410765171,
0.4426244497,
0.5984344482,
-0.2597938776,
-0.2559522092,
0.8921717405,
0.1764274389,
-0.2171172649,
0.6501322389,
-0.2961857319,
0.0130475536,
0.3812910616,
0.4759417176,
0.3115718365,
-0.2772241533,
-0.0154842362,
0.3388855159,
-0.0240626261,
-0.1651155949,
0.2945394218,
-0.449881494,
-0.4568696022,
-0.2124911696,
-1.0429110527,
-0.185638234,
0.1102581397,
-1.0281788111,
0.6656484604,
-0.270409435,
-0.0560786426,
0.1099358872,
0.5592066646,
-0.7676978111,
0.3808568716,
-0.1016638204,
1.0321139097,
-0.5510994196,
1.2880638838,
0.9359741211,
-0.3691881895,
-0.7753213644,
0.1437671185,
-0.4684934914,
-0.6530707479,
0.6826550961,
0.0128084831,
-0.2502662838,
0.5265183449,
-0.2373561859,
-0.8905388713,
0.9927010536,
0.4459959567,
-0.6126734614,
-0.2077795267,
-0.1792400777,
0.3553593755,
-0.0793325603,
0.2475966215,
0.4040942192,
0.1283203661,
0.1986530274,
-1.0389403105,
-0.123651579,
-0.2537031472,
0.156421259,
0.4728526175,
-0.5598917603,
0.7861233354,
-0.0873571709,
-0.2205441594,
0.0077578621,
0.5906024575,
-0.0164584499,
0.3758954108,
0.2110001296,
0.5821170211,
0.7725884318,
-0.0446381755,
0.9777157903,
-0.6532633305,
0.3726837635,
1.4022017717,
-0.2212634832,
0.9577374458,
0.3377766907,
-0.191367954,
0.2042163908,
0.6720371842,
0.4499942958,
0.9093179703,
-0.1353490353,
-0.2208708674,
-0.2952238917,
-0.0927746445,
-0.565908134,
0.4019890726,
0.6202981472,
-0.1827556491,
-0.4360973239,
-0.0297970306,
-0.2531638741,
0.3331243992,
-0.6691179872,
0.9558301568,
0.1488589346,
-0.6509491801,
0.6835831404,
0.2216448933,
0.756067872,
-0.6539926529,
0.1002155691,
-0.3304859102,
0.1568132937,
-0.1670868993,
-0.5096973777,
0.161088258,
-0.6143730879,
-0.4829381108,
-0.0814357549,
1.209854722,
-0.5704638958,
-0.1596727222,
0.2802112401,
0.2833770216,
-0.1137513891,
-0.3722427487,
-0.7070427537,
-0.2448833883,
-0.3645228446,
-0.3214595318,
0.8805356622,
0.6527608633,
0.1319781095,
0.5048747659,
0.6694594622,
0.1855605394,
0.0026560901,
0.0735390931,
1.2717525959,
-0.4148774445,
-0.6059072614,
-0.5398384929,
-0.0115002105,
0.3419246376,
0.1362907737,
0.5119054317,
0.6720133424,
0.8834424615,
0.0578251369,
0.5086024404,
0.1163739562,
0.5743308663,
-0.6924725771,
0.7492400408,
-0.5939981937,
0.1786824018,
0.0452515632,
-0.7762214541,
-0.116140455,
0.4241731465,
-0.363378942,
0.0497586578,
0.5119765997,
1.0473688841,
-0.3947607875,
-0.2353815287,
0.2612208724,
0.1041574702,
-0.1719007492,
0.2935286462,
0.2956702709,
-0.6050699949,
0.6224888563,
-0.2570827007,
-0.1028240323,
-0.4974898994,
-0.7114203572,
-0.6650421023,
-0.8003939986,
-0.1295000613,
-0.3064785004,
0.4346383512,
0.6211723685,
0.758944273,
-0.617389679,
-0.0023695009,
-0.1204943061,
0.0944317505,
0.0312286392,
-0.1902656108,
0.437016964,
-1.0290323496,
-0.5454328656,
0.3315538764,
0.2706891596,
-0.2322448492,
0.2520983517,
-0.114091523,
-0.6134282947,
-0.1438584179,
0.4549573064,
0.3098254204,
-0.2866236567,
0.08297389,
-0.1476278752,
-0.1718313396,
0.158072412,
0.89421314,
-1.0467162132,
0.5322911143,
0.4660642147,
0.3188040555,
0.7602261901,
0.317361027,
0.6439929605,
-1.1395056248,
0.3272476196,
0.4092932045,
0.128323853,
0.0315481424,
-0.5307878256,
0.331186533,
0.0472874045,
-0.7364418507,
-0.6422258615,
0.0525894798,
-0.6403164864,
-0.1699982733,
1.0186328888,
-0.1991000623,
0.0982027799,
-0.374676466,
-0.2019816786,
0.3738230169,
-0.4755293131,
0.7533614635,
0.3124416769,
-0.158163324,
-0.1536786854,
-0.5936844349,
0.7139228582,
0.2624234557,
-0.4198805094,
-0.0527951457,
0.2617905736,
0.0341538861,
-0.2722329795,
0.9047343731,
-0.1704593152,
0.1988800168,
-0.3281308413,
-0.4275704622,
-0.317712009,
-0.1962383389,
-0.0316140056,
0.0313097052,
0.5401283503,
-0.1356123835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16913v1
|
New Intent Discovery with Attracting and Dispersing Prototype
| 2024-03-25T16:31:55 | 2024-03-25T16:31:55 |
Shun Zhang, Jian Yang, Jiaqi Bai, Chaoran Yan, Tongliang Li, Zhao Yan, Zhoujun Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
New Intent Discovery (NID) aims to recognize known and infer new intent
categories with the help of limited labeled and large-scale unlabeled data. The
task is addressed as a feature-clustering problem and recent studies augment
instance representation. However, existing methods fail to capture
cluster-friendly representations, since they show less capability to
effectively control and coordinate within-cluster and between-cluster
distances. Tailored to the NID problem, we propose a Robust and Adaptive
Prototypical learning (RAP) framework for globally distinct decision boundaries
for both known and new intent categories. Specifically, a robust prototypical
attracting learning (RPAL) method is designed to compel instances to gravitate
toward their corresponding prototype, achieving greater within-cluster
compactness. To attain larger between-cluster separation, another adaptive
prototypical dispersing learning (APDL) method is devised to maximize the
between-cluster distance from the prototype-to-prototype perspective.
Experimental results evaluated on three challenging benchmarks (CLINC, BANKING,
and StackOverflow) of our method with better cluster-friendly representation
demonstrate that RAP brings in substantial improvements over the current
state-of-the-art methods (even large language model) by a large margin (average
+5.5% improvement).
|
[
-0.2917484939,
-0.8490579128,
0.7623026371,
0.3079948425,
-0.2912970483,
0.36163342,
-0.2102438956,
-0.2512851655,
0.3680483699,
0.0151715195,
-0.2967695296,
-0.8805354238,
-0.7592949271,
-0.3040824831,
-0.483243078,
0.9060047269,
0.0914690271,
-0.6400845647,
-0.271782279,
-0.0414260142,
-0.2888690531,
-0.3099515438,
-0.5751057863,
0.0667107925,
0.3256183267,
0.7976934314,
0.2735083699,
0.314102143,
0.4711884856,
0.1135255322,
-0.3154354692,
0.2352967709,
-0.3760657012,
-0.1312257797,
-0.0777166337,
-0.3605667949,
-0.5011895299,
0.1367276013,
0.8036423922,
0.8302921057,
-0.4383038282,
0.0712964907,
0.0492514707,
0.6690744758,
-0.7503542304,
0.2238101214,
-0.6588439941,
0.0351791866,
-0.3438006639,
-0.1125304028,
-0.7860002518,
-0.1835824102,
0.5817469358,
-0.6243818998,
0.3392059207,
0.0215430669,
0.5547114015,
-0.2493689805,
-0.1784727722,
-0.4839185774,
-0.8354830146,
0.7318071127,
-0.3147678077,
0.292034626,
0.1658069342,
0.4642839134,
-0.3723978698,
-0.8043705225,
-0.1790988445,
-0.1740735322,
0.0313692912,
-0.0479605608,
-0.3788227439,
-0.236365959,
-0.0353882648,
0.2478218228,
-0.277447015,
0.0743700862,
-0.2673845887,
-0.179110378,
0.4977701902,
-0.3112131357,
0.1861038506,
0.1490512788,
-0.6589463353,
-0.2346531749,
-0.4682324231,
0.6870480776,
0.1263156831,
0.5715922117,
-0.2195373476,
0.2235296369,
0.002724088,
0.597679317,
0.5245505571,
-0.2098465264,
0.4488057792,
0.0610004999,
0.1167855859,
0.3373616636,
0.5738880634,
0.3496817052,
-0.1312976927,
-0.2988671958,
0.0562622882,
-0.166400522,
0.3216424882,
-0.3835727274,
-0.0729850158,
0.051984597,
-0.6685340405,
-0.3026777208,
0.3036776781,
-0.7188931108,
-0.1799040437,
0.1906830072,
0.4139981866,
-0.5795614123,
-0.488619715,
0.2079594433,
-0.2674277127,
0.3558744788,
0.2997759283,
-1.1934448481,
0.4597053528,
0.6058351994,
1.2108963728,
-0.4910811484,
-0.2116025686,
-0.4932920933,
0.2611604929,
-0.2589321136,
1.1804943085,
-0.6251853704,
-0.4861233532,
-0.4276013374,
-0.2519752085,
-0.1346776634,
-0.6370542049,
0.491542846,
-0.3006402552,
0.0091510462,
0.0370445177,
-0.4181414843,
-0.3768222332,
0.1909143031,
-0.4264107049,
0.87659657,
0.492559731,
-0.5735992789,
0.8438019753,
-0.9213170409,
-0.4078327417,
0.0333935581,
-0.1572620124,
-0.55583179,
0.4174753726,
0.0202515516,
0.4772664309,
0.2110374421,
0.2214321047,
-0.2910158932,
-0.3291226327,
0.1375093311,
-0.1605027318,
0.4321404397,
-0.0780865923,
-0.4513840377,
0.4640813768,
-0.8353645205,
-0.3345972002,
-0.0081161633,
-0.0478525832,
-0.5148560405,
0.2851356864,
-0.2666633725,
0.0151141295,
0.1688428074,
-0.5568057895,
0.3321688473,
0.0210226793,
0.3020381033,
0.8090680242,
0.0736415982,
0.7253319621,
-0.2585642338,
0.4301932752,
0.3048018515,
0.4719593525,
0.2442355901,
-0.7334856391,
-0.1399956197,
-0.2422391921,
0.2128330767,
0.1413889974,
-0.3134533763,
0.3598510027,
-0.0547558852,
-0.4323839843,
-0.1647780091,
0.0123994127,
-0.0566000566,
0.4318667352,
0.4642092586,
-0.6105536819,
-0.4340675175,
-0.6168243289,
0.1570497304,
-0.3606999218,
0.0701810718,
0.5771116018,
-0.026502626,
-0.255707413,
1.2062191963,
-0.5285612941,
-0.7438907027,
-0.5583104491,
0.1829279959,
0.3114731014,
0.1749691665,
0.8621009588,
-1.1294232607,
-0.8182556629,
0.1309219152,
-0.2584222555,
0.0674935952,
-0.0891826153,
-0.0954145193,
-0.4013299048,
0.8383879066,
-0.053037487,
0.538787663,
0.4701635242,
-0.4042522311,
0.6569803357,
-0.0791888237,
-0.2957496345,
-0.9700949192,
-0.0544492304,
0.163471818,
0.09797851,
-0.6470398903,
-0.4396344423,
0.0243892092,
0.246613279,
-0.6502096653,
0.4857970476,
-0.2623543143,
-0.1802921295,
-0.3990211487,
0.175586313,
-0.2046973556,
0.2247886062,
0.2741705179,
0.62018013,
0.9886212349,
-0.9082874656,
-0.021921685,
0.4483780861,
-0.4997688234,
0.4928942323,
-0.3161428273,
-0.2234040946,
-0.3719353378,
0.2717989087,
-1.0645054579,
-0.2004710138,
0.1031838283,
-0.5786842704,
0.1605045646,
-0.4008481503,
0.1107904986,
-0.2240584046,
-0.3090839684,
0.4921006262,
0.7038074136,
-0.7287572026,
0.8258153796,
0.2508939207,
-0.1240546331,
-0.497257024,
-0.1715598404,
-0.1018308252,
-0.4792100489,
-0.2157916874,
0.7448477745,
0.2039607614,
-0.0303301327,
0.0250814557,
0.0533775017,
-0.0183237996,
0.2338944525,
0.1495257914,
0.1172136888,
-0.0134727638,
0.0643619075,
-0.0352110155,
-0.2675862312,
0.0531179346,
-0.2360226363,
0.4831754565,
0.0899521634,
-0.2931038737,
-0.302842468,
0.3276149333,
0.9127604961,
-0.2455523163,
0.7345728278,
1.0051224232,
-0.0532690212,
-0.5376982689,
-0.2382550687,
-0.1945059896,
-0.439324528,
0.2949580252,
-0.3265376985,
-0.9345010519,
0.496601522,
-0.4943068326,
0.3918991983,
0.1190495342,
0.2544296682,
0.0848030448,
0.977060914,
1.116528511,
0.0299864803,
0.8386202455,
-0.3315035403,
0.4587130249,
-1.5417302847,
-0.4472533464,
-0.0938185602,
-0.6842017174,
-0.3096354008,
-0.3849646449,
0.5491466522,
0.1673219353,
0.4884472489,
0.17060031,
-0.5494287014,
0.1613370329,
0.6016504765,
0.0480390824,
0.1444809437,
0.0470380373,
-0.5329538584,
0.0475944728,
-0.6649749279,
-0.2549319267,
1.4461553097,
0.1616836041,
0.6212021112,
0.5158160329,
0.7796615362,
0.2434678823,
0.535739243,
-0.8814668655,
0.4396271706,
-0.5895465612,
-0.2713471651,
-0.180282712,
-0.2915495634,
-0.9516620636,
0.0569635928,
-0.2537581027,
-1.0280691385,
0.596901834,
0.1250112951,
-0.6222297549,
0.5756652355,
-0.6568309665,
0.6638849378,
-0.1941262037,
-0.2925163209,
0.1395501047,
-0.380758673,
0.3586672246,
0.0494613759,
0.264929831,
-0.4502320886,
0.0891186148,
0.6694377661,
0.1928967685,
0.7420199513,
-0.5445069075,
-0.1097426042,
0.3820049763,
-0.1850681156,
0.4659553468,
0.0371145122,
-0.0525853634,
-0.4039182067,
-0.5693470836,
-0.2922862768,
-0.6384370923,
0.3934669495,
-0.4832996726,
-0.3526463807,
-0.1271747947,
-0.4368648231,
-0.1564700156,
0.2499333918,
0.4000607431,
0.4792622328,
-0.4684173465,
0.4156399071,
0.7901889086,
-0.0594093688,
0.4988924265,
0.6009050012,
-0.304715842,
-0.0124459071,
0.9032280445,
-0.26602301,
0.4750640988,
0.3714416623,
0.4846456051,
-0.7269799709,
-1.0302792788,
-0.1994250566,
-0.0927678198,
-0.1903323382,
0.1466016322,
-0.7157779932,
-0.1506573409,
-0.5739181638,
-0.2942963243,
-0.414778918,
-0.0915945545,
-0.328083396,
0.0560324825,
0.3501143157,
0.5717684627,
-0.2731308639,
0.4624319673,
-0.4025820494,
0.4069160819,
0.5068551898,
0.7024519444,
0.1232023314,
-0.5045062304,
-0.070523262,
-0.2124504298,
-0.2735949159,
-0.4467949569,
0.1340262145,
0.4877385795,
0.8095248938,
0.8431571126,
0.2632865906,
0.3350401521,
-0.304166913,
0.3950485885,
0.1096106544,
-0.430493921,
0.8319492936,
-0.1677332371,
0.1303564906,
0.7204781175,
0.5889731646,
-0.5296968818,
-0.1465939283,
-0.8882793188,
-0.9175149202,
0.5467408299,
-0.12929672,
-0.047605969,
-0.3123272359,
0.6401910782,
0.213729769,
-0.0555533096,
-0.7954672575,
-0.3247382045,
0.0878584608,
-0.1932245195,
-0.0926236287,
-0.2340432554,
0.2288531959,
-0.1741752028,
0.5806439519,
-0.274497509,
0.3301686943,
0.2586331367,
0.1125051528,
0.2281453162,
0.3888042569,
0.4398922026,
0.4344558716,
-0.6522107124,
0.2334796637,
-0.3128144741,
-0.9626729488,
0.5008332133,
-0.0529653132,
-0.353163898,
0.0349798389,
-0.0017207866,
0.6762222052,
0.2499334514,
-0.6758870482,
0.6785189509,
-0.2753862739,
-0.5917696357,
-0.1471186727,
0.3982201517,
-0.2234110087,
0.0205580257,
0.6352576017,
0.16931732,
0.2092921883,
-0.7015976906,
0.4437061548,
0.6144429445,
-0.753631115,
-0.4345473945,
0.3066157401,
0.1124475077,
-0.1558987051,
0.5149292946,
-0.8111082911,
-0.4372561574,
0.3847940564,
0.7941427231,
0.9330441952,
-0.2829379141,
0.6171407104,
0.3684739769,
-0.0059130094,
-0.2293818891,
0.0248849392,
-0.3305853605,
-0.9421421885,
-0.3058049679,
-0.5679474473,
-0.4633593261,
0.0416283719,
-0.8008458018,
0.2122614682,
-0.7527791262,
-0.2604606748,
0.0575585514,
-0.2097091526,
-0.0771807581,
-0.2929368317,
-0.1889422089,
0.6414531469,
-1.0439796448,
0.6078249812,
0.9882697463,
0.3104608357,
-0.701834619,
-0.0580718666,
0.0855472162,
-0.6134947538,
0.1926543862,
0.2362149507,
0.0235414263,
0.2865867317,
-0.1568783075,
-1.0959690809,
1.1408668756,
-0.1292858124,
-0.404482007,
0.0365998521,
-0.1732602119,
0.1899754405,
-0.7952778339,
-0.0284752473,
0.6790635586,
0.3553111553,
0.5222292542,
-0.5476418734,
-0.3010084033,
-0.1948432773,
-0.2977022827,
0.5086320043,
-0.5124579668,
0.8011119962,
-0.5845679641,
-0.427657932,
-0.1397109628,
0.5827489495,
0.4512570202,
0.412704736,
0.7288295627,
0.622697711,
0.5407076478,
-0.0942655727,
0.5015692711,
0.0644360483,
0.1342038065,
1.0927380323,
-0.3009087443,
0.8900834322,
0.4193276763,
-0.3762010932,
1.1353543997,
0.4774586558,
0.0866036043,
0.8944523335,
0.0086764442,
-0.4609136581,
0.084314689,
-0.1915923506,
-0.1206076071,
0.6566237807,
0.7619951963,
-0.194340542,
-0.4060530365,
0.2819381952,
-0.5750268698,
0.1851868331,
-0.2284351289,
1.0052155256,
-0.3172235191,
-0.4451850951,
-0.0266747791,
-0.0321129784,
0.9650403857,
-0.5501095653,
-0.0948646367,
-0.0157194883,
0.1761671752,
-0.2692781687,
-0.5698271394,
0.1017713249,
-0.3609723151,
-0.36254704,
0.0066484031,
0.5950018764,
-0.2992706895,
-0.5202308893,
0.2644229829,
0.2380895317,
-0.029689515,
0.085607484,
-0.5380310416,
0.0303893313,
0.0680050254,
0.4293574095,
0.3614438176,
0.4204718173,
-0.2435778826,
0.5879631639,
0.7747520208,
0.2056030482,
0.0715549812,
0.198772639,
0.5269378424,
-0.5087344646,
-0.8208739758,
-0.6137771606,
0.1631366014,
-0.0447975658,
-0.2153327018,
0.7413569093,
0.4886609614,
0.6572393775,
0.2342594266,
0.5400802493,
-0.3876757622,
0.7126178741,
-0.2516204417,
0.1681260467,
-0.1683061272,
0.3593063653,
-0.3763475716,
-1.1590175629,
-0.2332451791,
0.7537224293,
-0.3024821281,
0.0995270237,
0.417865783,
0.3946133554,
-0.3797005415,
-0.2344039679,
0.0478732213,
0.0901656374,
0.5856176615,
0.8657038808,
0.9615140557,
-0.1666908413,
0.2239487618,
-0.3184545338,
-0.8245040178,
-0.457120806,
-0.9084068537,
-0.5552139282,
-0.5794172287,
-0.3991538584,
0.3000628054,
-0.2052220255,
0.648160696,
0.982006669,
-0.5912473798,
-0.1674277037,
-0.480940938,
0.2778027952,
-0.7121750116,
-0.2986139059,
0.5735769272,
-0.4777009487,
-0.3759534061,
0.4054918289,
0.5904300809,
0.5486894846,
-0.2079866678,
0.0901716202,
-0.4695812464,
-0.3254032433,
0.7897792459,
0.3602724671,
-0.3572335243,
-0.3727463186,
0.023077799,
0.4100678563,
0.1750788689,
0.896648109,
-0.9761356115,
0.3728600442,
-0.0544294417,
0.2446422726,
0.3610822856,
0.2038890123,
0.2952527106,
-0.9504356384,
0.3113484681,
0.2116534859,
-0.0668166578,
0.0643784627,
-0.3980773687,
0.2301789671,
0.0559962876,
-0.2000796348,
-0.535846889,
0.1861717701,
-1.180773735,
-0.3090038896,
0.8496225476,
-0.0281562023,
-0.3713180125,
-0.5309891105,
-0.0995747447,
-0.2987622619,
-0.5077959299,
1.0426770449,
0.3801952004,
-0.6210506558,
-0.1646322012,
-0.1379983276,
0.7071797848,
0.1953295022,
-0.6252318025,
0.1914340407,
0.1660316736,
0.2778421044,
0.3963169456,
0.6564499736,
-0.4753808677,
0.6812769175,
-0.2362184674,
-0.1804497242,
0.0130601432,
-0.7496265769,
0.1121849418,
0.3239894807,
0.4290504456,
-0.2009857595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16909v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16909v1
|
Towards Algorithmic Fidelity: Mental Health Representation across Demographics in Synthetic vs. Human-generated Data
| 2024-03-25T16:21:25 | 2024-03-25T16:21:25 |
Shinka Mori, Oana Ignat, Andrew Lee, Rada Mihalcea
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Synthetic data generation has the potential to impact applications and
domains with scarce data. However, before such data is used for sensitive tasks
such as mental health, we need an understanding of how different demographics
are represented in it. In our paper, we analyze the potential of producing
synthetic data using GPT-3 by exploring the various stressors it attributes to
different race and gender combinations, to provide insight for future
researchers looking into using LLMs for data generation. Using GPT-3, we
develop HEADROOM, a synthetic dataset of 3,120 posts about
depression-triggering stressors, by controlling for race, gender, and time
frame (before and after COVID-19). Using this dataset, we conduct semantic and
lexical analyses to (1) identify the predominant stressors for each demographic
group; and (2) compare our synthetic data to a human-generated dataset. We
present the procedures to generate queries to develop depression data using
GPT-3, and conduct analyzes to uncover the types of stressors it assigns to
demographic groups, which could be used to test the limitations of LLMs for
synthetic data generation for depression data. Our findings show that synthetic
data mimics some of the human-generated data distribution for the predominant
depression stressors across diverse demographics.
|
[
-0.5539320111,
-0.8033256531,
0.90242064,
0.2105695009,
0.0491762683,
0.2445824146,
0.0129971309,
-0.5954601765,
0.2682668269,
0.2040773928,
-0.9184975624,
-0.4454059303,
-0.425169915,
0.4895489216,
-0.1934537143,
1.1719868183,
-0.101851888,
0.1671014279,
-0.367212683,
0.2481459528,
-0.350569129,
-1.0172387362,
-0.7270034552,
-0.4793873429,
0.3881659508,
0.2792751193,
0.9898338318,
0.4367030561,
0.5519946814,
0.1797133237,
0.2761067152,
0.0275708735,
-0.6939935088,
0.0178320054,
-0.0654682443,
-0.2400995493,
-0.4438266754,
0.0469686314,
0.0944782495,
0.482834667,
-0.1248987094,
0.3830393553,
-0.0327542908,
0.5543329716,
-0.3596836627,
0.0538599491,
-0.7429830432,
0.1883265972,
-0.3404415548,
-0.2637397647,
0.0789050534,
-0.5240966082,
-0.1230296791,
-0.545769155,
0.6932862401,
-0.1384366453,
0.4639307261,
0.5998931527,
-0.4221898317,
-0.1260354966,
-1.0420922041,
0.2947821319,
-0.3592464626,
0.0343507864,
0.5343968868,
0.4095993638,
-0.4351452887,
-0.4888134003,
-0.5522191525,
-0.0189592373,
-0.0662888959,
0.1502133161,
0.0679511726,
-0.1980206966,
0.4211737514,
0.6260465384,
-0.7948289514,
-0.306527704,
-0.7739161849,
-0.2772044837,
1.0319709778,
0.561324954,
0.5437846184,
-0.1217787862,
0.0099659851,
-0.0330555514,
-0.6348015666,
-0.262049377,
0.4156373143,
0.3211510777,
-0.1123336256,
0.9647690058,
0.0856068879,
0.2021150142,
0.1137391105,
-0.0919697881,
0.2729780376,
-0.4248476326,
-0.0252841767,
0.2858535945,
0.8008832932,
0.5595838428,
0.2070759088,
-0.0756227002,
-0.1028531641,
0.374050796,
0.737490952,
-0.6094028354,
-0.2394685447,
0.2690671682,
-0.3127999008,
-0.1350378394,
0.0222140718,
-0.7195945978,
-0.4644307196,
-0.5448023081,
0.063737914,
-0.5425295234,
-0.1927696913,
0.0841693133,
-0.1612611413,
0.0137485527,
0.108001329,
-0.6970923543,
0.5500879288,
0.7225632071,
0.9636058211,
-0.4683567584,
0.1974517256,
0.0872564241,
0.2084471881,
-0.3611143529,
0.4636420012,
-0.4167323411,
-0.6804910898,
-0.3023562133,
-0.2879508436,
0.1323129684,
-0.8171713948,
0.4919829667,
-0.1143677011,
0.2278236598,
-0.4060507715,
-0.1931097507,
0.1627332866,
0.0193354413,
-0.8550370932,
1.2558294535,
0.6609438062,
-0.9050261974,
0.5061625838,
-0.4903161228,
-0.1735922545,
0.1036999077,
-0.5813586116,
-0.5533485413,
0.1886603087,
0.2007326931,
0.2130703181,
-0.1515032798,
0.3076682985,
-0.7112330794,
-0.5920107961,
0.3945444822,
-0.0629789233,
0.568025589,
0.1878108382,
-0.1868637055,
-0.1166239902,
-0.669872582,
-0.2284603119,
0.1128880605,
0.1657902747,
-0.2674795389,
0.1072752625,
0.0938756391,
0.4477989376,
-0.0691412389,
-0.6038987041,
-0.0017289787,
0.0604553074,
0.3582324982,
0.6008155346,
0.4433557093,
-0.0223512761,
-0.7081422806,
0.8034587502,
-0.0714572147,
0.1893894523,
0.4380251765,
-0.6066081524,
0.097289972,
-0.4447655678,
-0.1294817179,
0.8517682552,
-0.6669784188,
0.3910829723,
-0.323160708,
-0.5418290496,
-0.3696315885,
-0.1596407443,
-0.0981994346,
0.4123550355,
0.4291202426,
-0.1837365627,
-0.8259878755,
-1.0428270102,
-0.158804819,
-0.1675671786,
-0.4655029774,
0.3794844449,
0.5383341908,
-0.5977763534,
0.9692572355,
-0.699552834,
-0.0710084215,
0.0384377651,
0.2445300519,
0.1418810636,
0.6612337828,
0.4445083141,
-0.4434444308,
-0.237840876,
-0.210120663,
-0.7898749113,
-0.0853669196,
-0.1780102849,
-0.4086925387,
-0.1016458124,
0.3134185374,
-0.7357032895,
0.4354559183,
0.4360221028,
-0.1647827476,
0.6024930477,
-0.0510714129,
0.0632939115,
-1.139492631,
0.1403343379,
0.121788539,
-0.0853354037,
-0.4701987207,
-0.2096960992,
-0.2454389036,
-0.6096507311,
-0.06059945,
0.2068646848,
-0.0913679451,
-0.0097926352,
0.061580237,
-0.2873457372,
-0.2112889439,
0.0121295396,
-0.1569469422,
1.0826525688,
0.1169270799,
-0.1673510075,
0.3437838554,
0.2329348773,
0.0719365403,
0.7427036762,
-0.7954558134,
0.3839240074,
-0.2816131711,
0.5679826736,
-0.8558003902,
-0.751006186,
0.5029389858,
-0.4393637776,
-0.0864392966,
0.2815698981,
-0.5717107654,
-0.6452071071,
-0.4810961187,
0.8334159851,
0.5900474787,
0.1225477085,
0.2684184015,
0.6326153278,
-0.4543762803,
0.1068886891,
-0.8050596118,
0.148815468,
-0.7279981971,
-0.6427358389,
0.8438881636,
-0.0502306409,
-0.475181371,
0.0748629496,
-0.1427136511,
-0.1626270264,
-0.0604624599,
0.4237995744,
0.3528264761,
0.0957418308,
0.0914293677,
-0.2515945435,
0.0743814856,
0.3827317357,
0.0039614267,
0.3369739652,
0.1876915097,
-0.285266012,
-0.397347182,
0.6224404573,
0.4339442551,
0.2422768772,
0.583381176,
0.5878791809,
-0.7129366994,
-0.0098796366,
-0.3564536273,
-0.2182778269,
-0.4058953524,
0.0220805574,
-0.3930984139,
-0.9229403734,
0.7475111485,
0.1289462149,
-0.1532598734,
0.4249666631,
0.7269777656,
0.018870987,
1.1742184162,
0.3752335906,
0.1073076203,
0.1478794515,
0.0480298474,
0.1522150785,
-0.6457880139,
-0.1792228222,
-0.3256077766,
-0.3917910159,
-0.8948710561,
-0.6283193827,
0.8059330583,
-0.2832581997,
-0.4937056303,
-0.0988779441,
-0.6374841928,
0.1058990732,
0.4213876426,
0.4562593102,
0.1263498813,
0.0849765539,
0.2364310175,
-0.3595240414,
-0.2138191164,
-0.5133471489,
1.2512329817,
0.2426818311,
0.7938930392,
-0.146241501,
0.8822054863,
0.4806114137,
0.4146049917,
-0.3844032288,
0.1664042622,
-0.1087618023,
-0.8136000633,
-0.0955711603,
-0.580678761,
-0.8589615822,
-0.2170874774,
0.0084733507,
-0.6366997957,
0.3891680539,
0.1606113911,
-0.6637541652,
-0.0627343133,
-0.5149559379,
0.5249785781,
-0.1950223446,
-0.2039735019,
-0.1630983204,
-0.4362875819,
0.8318791986,
-0.6637519598,
0.2217684537,
-0.4760322571,
-0.000756417,
0.5853483081,
-0.5470054746,
0.6602901816,
0.0250467639,
-0.1179150194,
0.2627056539,
0.174391821,
0.1698781401,
0.4559983611,
-0.3126573861,
0.1691070348,
0.3069951236,
-0.4709583819,
-0.74554497,
0.509852767,
-1.043807745,
-0.6591514349,
-0.6154718399,
-0.6815363169,
-0.467672199,
-0.1830577403,
0.1245677695,
0.1155934855,
-0.2858360708,
-0.1094225869,
0.1555647552,
-0.3482739031,
-0.1694846302,
-0.1078800634,
-0.0083878161,
-0.8319935203,
0.7221033573,
0.1994391829,
0.0621621348,
-0.193493247,
-0.0095520485,
-0.1237284243,
-0.1282659024,
-0.054835353,
0.439670831,
-0.2724873424,
-0.2331557423,
-0.3213714659,
-0.3873406649,
-0.317658186,
-0.2058092803,
-0.2863587141,
-0.3194371462,
-0.2993865311,
-0.2729442716,
0.4413844645,
0.7695798874,
-0.2632751763,
0.128476277,
-0.5170946717,
0.7803328037,
0.2345499843,
0.3236852884,
-0.385486573,
0.1215603277,
0.0097198635,
0.3536455333,
-0.4099965096,
-1.056120038,
0.3847064972,
0.1547229737,
0.4520322382,
0.1351197064,
0.3654437363,
0.8957579732,
-0.3666051328,
0.92230618,
-0.1258632094,
-0.7693681717,
0.4290982485,
-0.5749387741,
0.0900782868,
0.939219892,
0.6170184016,
-0.6196126938,
-0.3392306864,
-0.8036893606,
-0.7659896016,
0.6788771749,
0.5472121835,
0.1030251235,
-0.1913451105,
0.8726668358,
0.312312305,
-0.0501175188,
-0.4377779961,
-0.0835210904,
-0.357598573,
-0.4266630113,
-0.0112897176,
-0.1813287437,
-0.4353427291,
-0.3887949884,
0.339721024,
-0.0626582056,
0.6035245061,
0.4123828709,
0.387450248,
-0.2790975273,
-0.0948802754,
0.4770282209,
0.6472442746,
-0.5954934359,
0.3110589683,
0.0763608515,
-0.5190903544,
0.4796312749,
0.1642118841,
-0.2024977207,
-0.0687170327,
0.3513064384,
0.6118277311,
-0.2986280024,
-0.5885414481,
-0.0166698974,
-0.2960900962,
-0.227745086,
-0.5614863634,
0.1512720585,
-0.055751875,
0.1451502442,
0.267120868,
-0.0728674009,
0.2558162808,
-0.7337486148,
0.5055077672,
0.4618170559,
-0.1013323143,
-0.6162977219,
0.8728395104,
0.076244317,
-0.2130535692,
0.9116304517,
-0.0024993436,
-0.2333718687,
0.5647318959,
0.5115289688,
0.9089800119,
-0.2065404803,
0.3832611144,
0.4951559901,
0.1954935342,
-0.0398952179,
0.6392581463,
0.2223520875,
-0.5979873538,
-0.3925920725,
-0.4306579828,
-0.45017156,
0.3455835581,
-0.892203629,
0.2397938073,
-0.3562202454,
-0.7633274198,
-0.3445236683,
-0.087957643,
-0.8010075688,
0.232305631,
0.5487222075,
0.6960157156,
-1.0158138275,
0.3673430383,
0.6420819163,
-0.087819986,
-0.5130299926,
0.4740560353,
0.197523132,
-0.6652291417,
0.3980940282,
0.2271739244,
0.2116870582,
-0.1813357472,
-0.3636487722,
-1.0343101025,
1.0657913685,
0.6832203269,
-0.2178040147,
-0.1276638508,
0.6587634683,
0.8320772648,
-0.312910974,
0.0399168618,
0.8144446015,
0.504360497,
0.12446931,
-0.7843971848,
0.3220613301,
-0.3810400963,
0.4094886184,
-0.2031187415,
-0.2749094069,
0.9236718416,
-0.0945594832,
-0.4869758487,
-0.2679621279,
0.365083307,
0.7281658649,
0.3779034019,
0.3568035662,
0.6443297863,
0.7576984763,
-0.043691054,
1.3788928986,
-0.3292030394,
0.2688739896,
1.007363677,
-0.4716307521,
0.3884760141,
0.3546111584,
-0.5980192423,
0.3264996707,
1.2716914415,
0.0571984351,
0.2667036355,
0.5174172521,
-0.3299310207,
-0.0588297769,
-0.1051175222,
-0.5377711654,
0.2836237252,
0.4198871553,
-0.2613224983,
-0.2255610526,
-0.1167648733,
0.1194371805,
-0.2446827441,
0.0323491767,
0.7383307219,
0.2367359996,
-0.5031064749,
0.7200014591,
-0.0116698807,
0.2928031087,
-0.3181561232,
-0.0531285293,
-0.3506013155,
-0.0251779836,
-0.2452749461,
-0.7447527051,
0.8491026759,
-0.0991271362,
-0.1721379757,
-0.1223950014,
0.4854937494,
-0.3642231226,
-0.9089346528,
0.0769228116,
0.6864578128,
0.0732469782,
-0.4428437948,
-0.4291769266,
0.232115224,
-0.2763907909,
-0.1400221288,
0.236097306,
0.4724232256,
-0.37492612,
0.4435320199,
0.5225906372,
0.5244572163,
-0.088587217,
-0.2838528752,
0.7027725577,
-0.7773371339,
-0.3183525205,
-1.0917176008,
0.2038189173,
-0.0666701198,
-0.1834202111,
0.5834084749,
0.5078439713,
0.7172846198,
-0.1085909307,
1.044563055,
-0.0259118564,
0.2671332061,
-0.118722178,
0.3029614985,
-0.2979355752,
-0.1682191789,
-0.2378348261,
-0.9269851446,
-0.416374594,
0.3664340377,
-0.4699327648,
0.0093362071,
0.5524358749,
0.8412803411,
-0.023618754,
-0.0118317641,
-0.2178444415,
-0.0973020792,
0.5572957993,
0.5432790518,
0.6886028647,
-0.0951933265,
0.0802741051,
-0.4451900721,
-0.0776966065,
0.0443493091,
-0.653311789,
-0.5278488398,
-0.5756710768,
-0.315110594,
-0.3402659297,
0.0552895702,
1.036745429,
0.5450725555,
-0.7565459609,
-0.1973606199,
-0.0196124744,
-0.1643232107,
-0.2736776471,
-0.2773009241,
0.2705225348,
-0.0577834062,
-0.4682809114,
0.0577591695,
0.0546488129,
0.1985997111,
-0.3747121096,
0.018873062,
0.3729340732,
0.1781401187,
0.4672097266,
-0.0395436734,
-0.5916121602,
-0.381372124,
-0.3198437691,
-0.1521608829,
0.0233639739,
1.0872124434,
-0.8583043814,
0.1118989885,
0.4290785193,
0.6149436831,
0.2199987918,
0.5702436566,
0.9626308084,
-0.7654208541,
-0.1464630365,
0.2690893114,
0.1746832132,
0.5193182826,
-1.0006619692,
0.7922302485,
0.3765660822,
-0.5379016399,
-0.8939906955,
-0.0662504584,
-0.7636548877,
-0.1095336378,
1.056779623,
0.3062645495,
-0.0349384062,
-0.2514225245,
-0.3713943064,
0.272549361,
-0.4246332347,
1.4137181044,
0.6874517798,
-0.8178839684,
-0.0387548134,
-0.8139118552,
0.8060444593,
-0.0842645317,
-0.9912251234,
0.0050984938,
0.5995990038,
0.2092002034,
0.0100649185,
0.847063005,
-0.2834767699,
0.2360535711,
-0.0800174847,
0.071991235,
0.040295396,
0.097181797,
-0.0738168731,
0.2334934175,
-0.3314763308,
0.2152901292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16899v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16899v1
|
State Space Models as Foundation Models: A Control Theoretic Overview
| 2024-03-25T16:10:47 | 2024-03-25T16:10:47 |
Carmen Amo Alonso, Jerome Sieber, Melanie N. Zeilinger
|
eess.SY
|
eess.SY, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SY
|
In recent years, there has been a growing interest in integrating linear
state-space models (SSM) in deep neural network architectures of foundation
models. This is exemplified by the recent success of Mamba, showing better
performance than the state-of-the-art Transformer architectures in language
tasks. Foundation models, like e.g. GPT-4, aim to encode sequential data into a
latent space in order to learn a compressed representation of the data. The
same goal has been pursued by control theorists using SSMs to efficiently model
dynamical systems. Therefore, SSMs can be naturally connected to deep sequence
modeling, offering the opportunity to create synergies between the
corresponding research areas. This paper is intended as a gentle introduction
to SSM-based architectures for control theorists and summarizes the latest
research developments. It provides a systematic review of the most successful
SSM proposals and highlights their main features from a control theoretic
perspective. Additionally, we present a comparative analysis of these models,
evaluating their performance on a standardized benchmark designed for assessing
a model's efficiency at learning long sequences.
|
[
-0.1478354633,
-0.6433706284,
0.5152061582,
0.1558284163,
-0.0771677047,
0.1995296031,
-0.0025759165,
-0.1547261924,
0.2413352877,
0.2596351206,
-0.3569663763,
-0.1287355721,
-0.612387836,
-0.2829859257,
-0.7760235667,
0.4033029675,
-0.5716121197,
0.0823781937,
-0.0780626461,
0.1578727514,
-0.3815537989,
-0.5372787714,
-0.1467562765,
-0.5270339847,
0.170854345,
-0.2697327733,
0.838365972,
0.3955101967,
0.4658558667,
0.3305683434,
-0.3633490801,
-0.0936890095,
-0.4078060687,
-0.0026878221,
-0.2397717386,
-0.5110487938,
-0.2456513345,
0.0747880787,
1.0182150602,
1.1161526442,
-0.4439407289,
-0.385532707,
0.0087516438,
0.6895871162,
-0.6227766275,
0.164082706,
-0.208155632,
0.46884799,
0.222727865,
-0.0017616405,
-0.2256846577,
-0.7184461951,
0.0935395658,
-0.3246989846,
-0.1205241978,
-0.2715217471,
0.6792322993,
0.4158347249,
-0.5527586341,
-0.2055233717,
-1.182107687,
0.6473144889,
-0.7197216749,
0.5157578588,
-0.0320129953,
0.3460874259,
-0.6433185339,
-0.6621654034,
-0.4834028184,
-0.2552151382,
-0.07501816,
0.1536821574,
-0.0942569971,
0.113457337,
0.0637105703,
0.5173019767,
-0.377417177,
0.2245573252,
-0.5333461165,
-0.1365894377,
0.3475927114,
0.4502111971,
-0.011034023,
-0.0844460353,
-0.6477798223,
0.1542749107,
-0.788649261,
0.2516325712,
-0.0148453088,
0.1959599406,
-0.2056664079,
0.6372718811,
-0.1941735893,
0.7545639873,
0.1267661005,
0.090564698,
-0.253857553,
-0.2794466615,
-0.4675654769,
-0.3373440504,
0.5436548591,
-0.1248870045,
0.08614517,
-0.3740776777,
-0.1791375279,
0.5688497424,
0.5945538878,
-0.7489822507,
-0.2237407863,
0.0410104431,
-0.5386283994,
-0.3049399853,
0.1405653059,
-0.4634248316,
-0.4845343828,
-0.7767999768,
0.3308168352,
-0.3713347316,
-0.5419919491,
0.2776916623,
0.2417789549,
0.5823626518,
0.2344781309,
-0.5973408818,
0.8589374423,
0.6901923418,
0.8987109065,
-0.6927329302,
-0.0917423889,
0.1123781949,
-0.0637240708,
-0.8872323036,
0.1336775422,
-0.4792358577,
-0.5402926207,
0.0210439283,
-0.1144359484,
-0.0904949009,
-0.2120617777,
-0.1061923355,
-0.85769099,
-0.0019606641,
-0.0777748674,
-0.8266929388,
-0.1990903169,
0.0007196253,
-0.6804427505,
0.7698407173,
0.1449202895,
-0.1081937551,
0.2503562868,
-0.5968851447,
-0.7602757215,
-0.1996747702,
-0.3890092075,
-0.1109019369,
0.3228408992,
-0.4415809512,
0.7989171743,
-0.1244555041,
0.6214716434,
-0.2495017499,
-0.4952466488,
0.2654859722,
-0.1731316745,
0.3020969033,
0.4659781754,
-0.4429293573,
0.1125923768,
-0.6884944439,
0.0807599798,
-0.0141980276,
-0.5013697147,
-0.1866383553,
0.4186334312,
-0.343303591,
0.5047835112,
-0.0035810214,
-0.0259089172,
0.1796752512,
-0.3290830255,
0.7046151161,
0.5550596118,
-0.0997407883,
0.9568511248,
0.0497503951,
0.6598010063,
0.0779619738,
-0.1032455638,
-0.2141876221,
0.0930360854,
-0.5611633658,
0.0472466797,
0.2630920112,
0.4003097415,
-0.476554811,
0.5730354786,
-0.0798546076,
-0.4216435254,
0.0102666011,
-0.1578684002,
0.1946444064,
0.2411029935,
0.3420245945,
-0.2824302018,
-0.1545875818,
-0.7250899673,
0.1590910554,
0.3492313325,
0.508836925,
0.2163746506,
0.6404310465,
0.1603116989,
0.856132865,
-0.2705281973,
0.1772834808,
-0.0127655016,
-0.3027160466,
0.400519222,
0.9019274116,
0.5192744732,
-1.0465663671,
0.1139585301,
-0.2961989641,
-0.8255494833,
0.5165734887,
0.1802618951,
-0.0150859561,
-0.1248929501,
0.5211099982,
-0.8988072276,
0.7251342535,
0.4578587413,
-0.3340778053,
0.3916481435,
0.0675525442,
0.0589369349,
-1.0852082968,
0.1428436637,
-0.1067967638,
0.044112578,
-0.7404921055,
0.4911772907,
0.2104885429,
-0.2911105752,
-0.463360697,
0.2245621532,
-0.4462291002,
-0.6394411325,
-0.4422509074,
-0.2220660895,
-0.2119210064,
0.7019566894,
0.1173324734,
0.5004578233,
0.5377138853,
-0.9777837396,
0.2364404052,
-0.0295512937,
-0.5394719243,
0.2337174714,
-0.5612514615,
-0.1158649921,
-0.0094356732,
0.584086597,
-0.9961864948,
-0.0800863728,
0.1079067513,
-0.1178240851,
0.5893802047,
-0.2203104794,
-0.15671134,
-0.4077194929,
0.2565205693,
0.1598756313,
0.5752239227,
-0.1876662225,
0.8350990415,
0.311986804,
0.0864386261,
-0.630718112,
-0.876734972,
-0.2070556432,
-0.1251317114,
-0.1697862595,
0.3718369901,
0.0294563193,
-0.1069019064,
0.1606590748,
-0.4906258285,
-0.0984068662,
0.5855007768,
0.6362872124,
0.1347926855,
-0.4729314148,
0.072558634,
0.1809826493,
-0.0211858749,
0.0301886741,
-0.7361075282,
0.6189065576,
-0.5633434057,
-0.387432158,
-0.5641742945,
0.1154578403,
0.5156900883,
-0.2246528417,
0.675881207,
-0.1185063124,
-0.6575610042,
-0.1819573492,
-0.1307492107,
-0.2378065735,
-0.451359868,
0.1885630637,
-0.596422255,
-1.1446819305,
0.5452588797,
-0.502210021,
-0.0334497206,
0.3054317534,
0.6001823545,
-0.3612436056,
0.5473185778,
0.8921604156,
-0.4070574045,
0.4745142162,
-0.717374742,
-0.0650096014,
-0.5617812872,
-0.2657286227,
-0.4856949747,
-0.8009870648,
-0.3149058521,
-0.53145504,
-0.1729228348,
0.6116816998,
-0.5707643628,
0.4872185886,
-0.2066268623,
0.4095435441,
0.0112075685,
-0.104930155,
-0.1075779721,
-0.1869609356,
-0.5374023318,
0.1414288133,
-0.9482164979,
-0.4805449843,
0.6734761596,
0.3664596677,
1.0754933357,
0.2366476655,
0.3900828362,
0.226898253,
0.0075225988,
-0.6314020157,
0.3863174319,
-0.2012814581,
-0.540522337,
-0.3558620512,
-0.2698561549,
-0.7529764175,
0.3878806233,
-0.0198903345,
-0.6705235839,
0.5488293767,
0.2949348986,
-0.7178524137,
0.4270830452,
-0.387016207,
0.5992618203,
-0.3607592881,
-0.3097398579,
-0.3935266137,
-0.6736076474,
0.3584574759,
0.0802740082,
-0.1416124254,
-0.1359413117,
-0.0185403973,
0.3693857789,
-0.3289094269,
0.9719417691,
-0.4157224,
-0.0919304341,
0.2046042234,
0.5058256984,
0.3238430619,
-0.1575668156,
-0.1017723531,
0.0398059115,
-0.1502788067,
-0.4331892133,
-0.5275556445,
0.8549989462,
-0.8522933722,
-0.2383051068,
-0.2124368548,
-0.2143220752,
-0.2902763188,
0.2616145015,
-0.108520411,
0.5269721746,
-0.237416327,
0.5714514256,
0.7854175568,
-0.0103769936,
0.5758706927,
0.5527116656,
-0.2968673408,
-0.0365881063,
0.2309516519,
0.1134082302,
0.1994564533,
0.6202371716,
-0.0100174965,
-0.2838914394,
-0.6083077192,
-0.2445891947,
-0.1913997978,
-0.7483511567,
-0.1329730302,
-0.2286669314,
-0.4292563796,
-0.1990212053,
-0.3034676015,
-0.5278903246,
-0.5430344939,
-0.2393906564,
-0.4356613457,
0.1194478124,
1.0671831369,
0.1495977193,
0.5937098265,
-0.1430585533,
0.2870091498,
0.0149796447,
0.6341385245,
0.2025790066,
-0.3009625971,
-0.2397927791,
-0.1386644542,
-0.1410113275,
-0.8936024308,
0.0584120639,
-0.0049015591,
0.7027558088,
0.1803136617,
-0.3595263064,
0.6326620579,
-0.6018411517,
0.9003762603,
0.248534441,
-0.8881057501,
0.5753490329,
0.0314308964,
0.1217728555,
0.1196263582,
0.6631524563,
-0.2339873463,
0.0000385071,
-0.4805262089,
-0.5497274399,
0.465492636,
-0.0505096018,
0.1534525305,
0.3743376434,
0.7610938549,
0.0267808586,
0.5388032198,
-0.4425656497,
-0.0808348358,
-0.5231060982,
-0.073472321,
-0.1908754259,
-0.0170442536,
-0.1018719599,
0.1336912513,
0.3726912439,
-0.2175573409,
0.36821118,
0.0955381021,
-0.3252738714,
-0.3063922524,
0.2010359019,
0.753467083,
0.923301518,
0.2237991244,
0.0873484537,
-0.0106510501,
-0.0978217274,
0.6367168427,
0.199317947,
-0.362626195,
-0.3885068297,
0.0747012049,
1.1589244604,
0.7904309034,
0.2116212547,
0.4142706692,
0.419205308,
-0.179861024,
-0.40170452,
0.4267896414,
0.1203325987,
0.5034635663,
0.3007262945,
0.3750713468,
-0.018430369,
-0.2262915522,
0.1913926154,
0.3478532732,
-0.4735675156,
-0.4663931131,
0.8063963652,
0.1439323276,
-0.082146138,
0.5020821095,
0.4645299613,
-0.4494026303,
0.9494483471,
0.4521618187,
0.5680751801,
-0.1346394122,
-0.0444316156,
0.1062601358,
0.3255885243,
-0.2023192644,
0.5109378099,
-0.2327165008,
-1.1428252459,
-0.7606983185,
-0.7916663289,
-0.2767190933,
0.3638839424,
-0.6800628304,
-0.1811030358,
-1.0000680685,
-0.3341481984,
-0.0662377477,
0.1973749697,
-0.7073115706,
0.335480392,
0.3874804378,
1.4819639921,
-0.9116418362,
1.0170215368,
0.6068925261,
-0.2700285614,
-1.1025401354,
-0.3634849489,
0.0101765096,
-0.4431791604,
0.5700774193,
-0.1006577983,
-0.3353075087,
0.0378330909,
-0.6081869602,
-1.117620945,
1.3713872433,
0.0393569358,
-0.6940508485,
-0.1772808284,
-0.1923813671,
0.5272224545,
-0.4055818021,
-0.2849387527,
0.6385734081,
0.2809346616,
-0.1437560022,
-0.5152844787,
-0.1108076647,
-0.1715305746,
0.4097076058,
0.5730663538,
-0.7299103737,
0.7603322864,
-0.0563314036,
-0.1218564734,
0.5481331348,
1.0960230827,
0.3897738457,
-0.1164570227,
0.3758695126,
0.505179584,
0.6856329441,
-0.3878551126,
1.1430412531,
-0.5156232715,
0.2603578269,
0.94097507,
-0.7082175016,
0.7619578838,
0.3727933764,
-0.4304093122,
0.6267907619,
0.5531098843,
-0.0719144046,
0.6236760616,
0.4913788736,
0.3633585572,
0.0126942666,
0.5942488313,
-0.4269149601,
0.1082220897,
0.6341583133,
-0.3025213778,
0.0980377346,
0.0054765511,
-0.1425820738,
0.113982141,
-0.4853081107,
0.5460065603,
0.4116607904,
-0.5108374357,
0.1580106765,
0.1193155274,
0.4043058157,
-0.9032921791,
0.0849692822,
-0.3995347023,
0.2308863699,
-0.0848311111,
-0.656146884,
0.126861304,
-0.1969834566,
-0.409948349,
-0.3000665903,
0.9683613181,
-0.371858418,
0.0116995061,
0.3482696414,
0.4349041879,
0.1659429073,
0.4096260965,
-0.7868613601,
-0.0070594917,
-0.5610824823,
-0.4108296335,
-0.0376297124,
0.0132949501,
-0.3675162792,
0.6263054609,
0.5896576643,
0.2423778921,
0.4300591648,
-0.1368166208,
0.7296056747,
-0.9907270074,
-0.9139841795,
-0.6223987937,
0.340444535,
0.253505379,
-0.1295970678,
0.2621816993,
0.3863456249,
0.7450701594,
-0.0908840895,
0.734179318,
-0.2813599408,
0.3375307024,
-0.8312470913,
0.7854109406,
-0.3359234929,
-0.1490551531,
-0.0925300494,
-0.7302188277,
-0.0722468644,
0.5423005223,
-0.2481751591,
0.2710564435,
0.3884114027,
0.531105876,
-0.0901529789,
0.1538076997,
0.324124366,
0.3360887766,
0.1970854551,
0.7115410566,
1.402695775,
-0.2665806115,
-0.0159984175,
-0.2154505402,
0.0485481396,
-0.2727333307,
-0.9616041183,
-0.4545533657,
-0.4554247558,
0.0508379377,
-0.2196511179,
-0.06911017,
0.7296694517,
1.1033076048,
-1.177834034,
-0.4089016914,
-0.3336376846,
0.0709919408,
-0.2530131936,
-0.1373558193,
0.3850358129,
-0.099104926,
-0.3503101766,
0.946570456,
0.319816798,
0.3014630377,
-0.6495105028,
-0.4825751185,
-0.1165806651,
0.000667937,
0.4919325411,
0.4471754134,
-0.9510045648,
0.0723009184,
0.0688189343,
-0.3214742541,
-0.0962063819,
1.2673819065,
-0.937122345,
0.1148389354,
0.3336831629,
0.9358707666,
0.4969163537,
-0.103382878,
0.6408176422,
-0.7254395485,
0.2308460772,
0.2649129927,
0.6460703015,
0.2102468163,
-0.2638976276,
0.6210107207,
0.2635938227,
-0.2501271665,
-0.5372071862,
0.3441261947,
-0.8071712255,
-0.5534018874,
0.7154613733,
-0.2026452124,
-0.0798041448,
0.5182477236,
0.2563227117,
0.332443893,
-0.1327082962,
0.428722918,
0.7763326764,
-0.1326233894,
-0.1745493561,
-0.3582738936,
0.5729304552,
0.3221107125,
-0.6880001426,
-0.3397613466,
0.5034521222,
0.2520780265,
0.2979097664,
0.4212307334,
-0.2228659242,
0.3664490581,
-0.4377114773,
0.0269277319,
-0.0429367609,
-0.813392818,
-0.9646670222,
0.3508023024,
-0.3764152229,
-0.0544470362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16865v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16865v2
|
Encoding of lexical tone in self-supervised models of spoken language
| 2024-03-25T15:28:38 | 2024-04-03T12:59:20 |
Gaofei Shen, Michaela Watkins, Afra Alishahi, Arianna Bisazza, Grzegorz Chrupała
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Interpretability research has shown that self-supervised Spoken Language
Models (SLMs) encode a wide variety of features in human speech from the
acoustic, phonetic, phonological, syntactic and semantic levels, to speaker
characteristics. The bulk of prior research on representations of phonology has
focused on segmental features such as phonemes; the encoding of suprasegmental
phonology (such as tone and stress patterns) in SLMs is not yet well
understood. Tone is a suprasegmental feature that is present in more than half
of the world's languages. This paper aims to analyze the tone encoding
capabilities of SLMs, using Mandarin and Vietnamese as case studies. We show
that SLMs encode lexical tone to a significant degree even when they are
trained on data from non-tonal languages. We further find that SLMs behave
similarly to native and non-native human participants in tone and consonant
perception studies, but they do not follow the same developmental trajectory.
|
[
-0.1775843352,
-0.2218987197,
0.4534697831,
0.2871842384,
-0.3326160312,
-0.2476432621,
-0.1911264062,
-0.3709639013,
0.3609401584,
0.9355352521,
-0.3116250932,
-0.5981098413,
-0.1011275724,
0.3169678152,
-0.5182859898,
0.9016046524,
0.2629929781,
0.2897459865,
0.0166279059,
-0.4043649435,
-0.1985751092,
-1.1313316822,
-0.0831054375,
-0.3449958265,
-0.1286411136,
0.1272271723,
0.6358258724,
0.5712394118,
0.3240236342,
0.1566990912,
-0.3498449326,
-0.0742200017,
-0.3609580398,
0.091579929,
-0.0430041589,
-0.41191414,
-0.2189254761,
0.0655663535,
0.666834414,
0.6713485122,
-0.2692713141,
0.058523614,
0.197429046,
0.7160536647,
-0.2495126426,
0.2731019557,
-0.5073953867,
-0.0036684817,
-0.0500632487,
-0.2831780016,
-0.5093255639,
-0.1912194937,
0.1640048027,
-0.3527936935,
0.2806025743,
-0.2865796089,
0.7623950839,
0.2917855978,
-0.4268823266,
-0.5494096279,
-0.7038639188,
0.5991435051,
-0.7824910283,
0.4129270911,
0.4518060386,
-0.0241762847,
-0.0728928968,
-0.2999181449,
-0.0388456807,
-0.5004691482,
-0.3967997134,
0.3110233247,
0.0118817482,
0.50990206,
0.1415635943,
0.5592349172,
-0.7486991286,
0.1607847363,
-0.5021576285,
-0.2929163575,
0.8512296677,
0.0759596601,
0.2152618319,
-0.6775075197,
-0.4694318473,
0.0713345781,
-0.4131273329,
0.0264656395,
0.1158427671,
0.6724956632,
-0.3993154466,
0.4396927655,
-0.1162283495,
0.7121566534,
-0.2320570499,
-0.5079333186,
0.2926394939,
-0.3843657374,
-0.0616487935,
0.4257890284,
0.5987077355,
0.1464142352,
0.6723155379,
0.0522167981,
-0.4505198002,
0.1239185482,
0.062397562,
-0.455480665,
-0.1425837427,
0.0651119798,
-0.6176297069,
0.1264334172,
0.1505203396,
-0.5388513207,
-0.3943103552,
-0.3775486648,
0.341887176,
-0.5287290215,
-0.5141621232,
0.190902397,
0.0029499531,
0.4271738529,
-0.1124422997,
-0.9459863901,
0.4300872386,
0.6214978099,
0.9615554214,
-0.2141622156,
-0.279902935,
-0.1027467474,
-0.2519784272,
-0.4255520105,
0.4219661951,
-0.470849514,
-0.8238717914,
0.179366082,
0.0809812471,
-0.1944421828,
-0.8466781378,
0.3976973891,
-0.282238543,
-0.2645209432,
-0.2107699364,
-0.6848506927,
-0.0773366317,
-0.1969970167,
-0.4719143212,
0.9301255345,
0.4192702174,
-0.5581343174,
0.31816414,
-0.2286679745,
-0.491527766,
-0.0130510218,
-0.3028644919,
-0.2600874603,
0.5822851062,
0.2255558819,
0.2159434259,
0.0310485382,
0.2500436306,
-0.034384571,
-0.5141915083,
0.3732242286,
-0.1809293628,
0.6893182993,
0.4737095237,
-0.1530054063,
0.0772177055,
-0.8597698808,
-0.0084948204,
0.2322898358,
-0.2520838976,
-0.3807475269,
-0.3852376938,
-0.0449087024,
0.2925290763,
0.3344468176,
-0.274925679,
0.0307314489,
-0.338036716,
0.6472710967,
0.3963622451,
0.2752989233,
0.4094773829,
-0.148701936,
0.5492078662,
0.4455321431,
-0.088030532,
-0.6222759485,
-0.2827140689,
-0.8837721348,
-0.0143908011,
0.0375143513,
0.4291376173,
-0.3209700286,
0.0601306371,
0.1996643692,
-0.3472039104,
-0.7424743176,
0.184151113,
0.5366741419,
0.4419759214,
0.4167942107,
-0.536800921,
-0.5540308952,
-0.8788855076,
-0.3824312389,
-0.4960184395,
-0.0926203579,
0.3933039606,
0.1317802072,
-0.077519469,
1.0239701271,
-0.1479238868,
-0.3962244391,
-0.3179094195,
0.3278858364,
0.18225573,
0.3459838629,
0.4873918295,
-0.6588781476,
-0.104820773,
-0.1996078789,
-0.6144294143,
-0.5760256648,
-0.2641268671,
0.4939649999,
0.4435872138,
0.7061233521,
-0.208497569,
0.2894367576,
0.7065477371,
-0.2962807119,
0.786711514,
-0.5329605937,
-0.1232420206,
-0.5918779373,
-0.3439758122,
0.2742266059,
-0.0939129144,
-0.9397370815,
-0.2637672722,
0.1632662117,
-0.3509465456,
-0.333666414,
0.2936315835,
-0.6491441727,
-0.6855415702,
-0.4811069965,
0.2053666264,
0.0288661793,
0.5262286663,
0.4049291015,
0.779540062,
0.5452305079,
-0.6473333836,
0.031979721,
-0.1445645392,
-0.31554842,
0.591357708,
-0.6564195752,
0.2135160714,
-0.2337213457,
-0.0190189555,
-0.7144050002,
0.05775778,
-0.2214756608,
-0.2550778389,
0.056659352,
-0.3452804983,
-0.3791074753,
-0.1592097431,
0.2600587606,
0.4020380974,
0.764151454,
-0.4494592547,
0.2328253984,
0.5984721184,
0.2248026282,
0.066171132,
-0.7248725295,
-0.1659004092,
-0.5416870117,
-0.1513977051,
0.07184349,
0.3605726361,
-0.4099178612,
-0.1632731706,
-0.1959097981,
-0.1514929533,
-0.0299443621,
0.4263328016,
0.0105773248,
-0.504924655,
0.3221316636,
-0.5187990069,
-0.1265273988,
0.1833901703,
-0.6666762233,
0.5596283674,
-0.2994399667,
-0.355792731,
-0.6747592092,
0.0948156267,
0.5190193653,
-0.4573341012,
0.5517581701,
0.5331737995,
-0.1463112384,
-0.1537223458,
-0.4217332602,
-0.2561758757,
-0.4568350911,
0.3369565904,
-0.4680864513,
-1.0514475107,
0.6576874256,
-0.0010618912,
-0.4654948711,
0.2576152086,
0.5112885833,
-0.1226657182,
1.0123443604,
0.4588908255,
-0.2589298785,
0.5054888129,
-0.0328941345,
-0.2407203168,
-0.6950659156,
-0.0856103376,
-0.5020177364,
0.0285910461,
-1.0673214197,
-0.4570499063,
0.3249135017,
-0.0162000116,
-0.1195886061,
0.2239928246,
-0.6412764788,
0.282456398,
0.5873633027,
-0.2018771023,
0.2080211788,
-0.188028425,
-0.1310528815,
-0.3629617393,
-0.6696914434,
-0.5707609057,
0.6750167608,
0.4016779661,
1.0979865789,
-0.337517947,
0.9442828894,
0.2055304796,
-0.3273935318,
-0.8089925051,
0.473004818,
-0.3023219109,
-0.4598506391,
-0.3423422575,
-0.5180843472,
-0.8788204193,
0.3813232183,
0.0038257351,
-0.7771453261,
0.4669550359,
0.1915953606,
-0.1701140106,
-0.0176427346,
-0.5818573833,
0.7458338141,
-0.4824475646,
0.3274243474,
-0.0477803275,
-0.5097242594,
0.2120667547,
0.1370225996,
0.3523950577,
-0.3408159018,
0.2656955123,
0.7421163917,
-0.2959359586,
0.9143345952,
-0.3017290533,
-0.2168085277,
0.6916739345,
0.1872229278,
0.0407921486,
0.0843377411,
0.0127530089,
0.2994040251,
0.1396227032,
-0.3353631198,
-0.4621595442,
0.4031957686,
-0.9572483897,
-0.8123874068,
-0.4391624331,
-0.6283262968,
-0.0795065835,
0.0593333431,
0.1974743158,
0.4539620578,
-0.1793640554,
-0.200206995,
0.4812634587,
-0.0861554444,
0.320854336,
0.4313631058,
-0.5274128914,
-0.0763437077,
1.0847879648,
0.4518911242,
0.539896071,
0.0888673291,
0.4248026609,
-0.3289443254,
-0.6323918104,
-0.1815975457,
0.3959017098,
-0.7771980762,
0.2202235609,
-0.4492571354,
-0.6779720187,
-0.5345152617,
0.0963599011,
-0.4781393707,
-0.4461348355,
-0.498221755,
0.0671266392,
0.2650010288,
0.9940406084,
-0.2594174147,
0.4076314867,
-0.908598721,
0.3374778032,
0.4060817957,
0.0606960095,
-0.1176584214,
-0.971786797,
-0.4687964022,
-0.0195116848,
0.1406567097,
-1.1404967308,
0.7264303565,
0.3464856744,
0.4624928534,
0.5592260361,
0.1688668877,
0.7373392582,
-0.1910288632,
0.6233279705,
-0.3109100461,
-1.2110074759,
0.8207548857,
-0.1996701658,
0.6493314505,
0.4865019619,
0.0936561823,
-0.8132066131,
-0.4928325117,
-0.6112071872,
-0.4610681832,
0.8769644499,
0.1996623576,
0.0793067738,
0.0946992487,
0.549936533,
0.0355407819,
0.0366465561,
-0.6671278477,
-0.0557961948,
-0.5761276484,
0.0095201237,
-0.3135454953,
-0.5814968348,
-0.0291257277,
0.1235482618,
0.0865524262,
-0.0984084383,
-0.1100603193,
0.5620161295,
-0.4451369643,
0.1979706436,
0.3409931064,
0.7006537318,
0.3844765425,
-0.3085487783,
0.5205917954,
0.222767815,
-0.3969781995,
0.4319214523,
-0.2238792926,
-0.1320289671,
0.2679966986,
0.5908366442,
0.9470514655,
0.2169648409,
-0.4670172036,
0.0950495675,
0.1504388452,
0.1177083105,
-0.2475507557,
0.1856940091,
0.0115350597,
0.0701093674,
0.2682738602,
-0.4854591191,
0.1372554004,
-0.6658949256,
0.1943564266,
0.1514636725,
-0.7927004695,
-0.6607242823,
0.4458554089,
0.1422836632,
-0.3680221736,
0.6683579087,
-0.3394200802,
-0.6318207979,
0.6474943757,
0.9075123072,
0.7657728195,
-0.4576546252,
0.2181543261,
0.5069089532,
0.5628529191,
0.008177639,
0.3929837346,
-0.1459439695,
-0.85638237,
0.0836169049,
-0.8823177218,
-0.4884079993,
0.017402621,
-1.1783299446,
0.2002672255,
-0.3570104837,
-0.2263363898,
-0.2828221023,
-0.277677238,
-0.3919322491,
0.3574881554,
0.642467618,
0.5860999823,
-1.0041527748,
0.9159243703,
0.6477645636,
-0.208875984,
-0.868824482,
-0.0620917231,
0.2206227034,
-1.1000285149,
0.6040576696,
0.4253002703,
-0.150033623,
0.0721648559,
-0.0868547261,
-0.8871212006,
0.7252402902,
0.4717476666,
-0.3995448351,
0.1400272101,
0.788523376,
0.7740302086,
-0.6659525037,
0.0541106425,
1.106564045,
0.2501298785,
0.1331097335,
-1.0660288334,
-0.1582988799,
0.0790395886,
0.3952093422,
-0.1551385522,
-0.7725625634,
0.9263577461,
-0.1589953452,
-0.4847464859,
-0.3317653835,
0.8581471443,
0.4173704684,
0.1099318936,
0.4747749567,
0.3841279447,
0.6838049889,
-0.0868835002,
0.6873936057,
-0.5483309031,
0.4335082769,
0.9674767852,
-0.2404697686,
0.3959856927,
0.2544509768,
-0.1413572282,
0.330242157,
0.8295829296,
-0.0527902991,
0.3592389226,
0.2306470573,
0.0619020537,
-0.35833776,
-0.4335126877,
-0.3578192294,
1.0907946825,
0.5376549363,
-0.3528912663,
0.0445047468,
-0.0406890623,
-0.0190698523,
0.2088174075,
-0.6463807225,
0.8470708728,
0.5449209809,
-0.4917089939,
0.8292065263,
-0.3638004661,
0.5364031792,
-0.4181753695,
0.1612464786,
-0.4023739994,
-0.0629082322,
-0.2828036249,
-0.7107573152,
0.2410926819,
-0.1227446571,
0.0675161332,
-0.2839839756,
0.6084506512,
-0.5242875814,
-0.4448092282,
0.563585341,
0.5518572927,
0.4536681175,
-0.0286810864,
-0.5476199389,
0.1009241045,
-0.152679503,
-0.1594359428,
0.1680181623,
0.5058794618,
-0.0424315408,
0.590667069,
0.3101584613,
0.3683318496,
0.2417258918,
0.499425739,
0.5513322949,
-1.1933425665,
-0.777066946,
-0.9001643062,
0.1023767442,
0.4094307125,
-0.3459691107,
0.793648541,
0.30943501,
0.8581951857,
0.0607010722,
0.5164495707,
0.6510097384,
0.1021772102,
-0.7448763847,
0.7039422989,
-0.4289821386,
-0.0172492694,
-0.0819792971,
-0.8602955937,
-0.120126076,
0.5311579704,
-0.107580252,
0.2348167002,
0.4170271754,
0.6321880221,
0.3314253092,
0.2178538889,
0.621914804,
0.3275793195,
-0.010810174,
0.2810794115,
0.8269877434,
0.2166342288,
0.4683251679,
-0.4006612897,
-0.0050442852,
-0.4144314528,
-0.3535270989,
-0.9940475821,
-0.6973288059,
-0.1536568254,
-0.3268030882,
-0.1227593347,
0.7972623706,
0.6412911415,
-1.0452259779,
-0.8369553685,
0.1007693261,
0.0639860556,
-0.2682075799,
-0.191806525,
0.3998340666,
-0.5053123832,
-0.5996130705,
0.492072463,
0.4810078442,
0.4196560979,
-0.5747071505,
-0.0601587743,
0.1059417799,
0.0999415964,
0.1995438784,
0.4368132055,
-0.8116099238,
-0.0757709444,
0.0835743994,
-0.4136852324,
0.5086152554,
1.0632885695,
-0.9011549354,
0.6956225634,
0.2600222826,
0.1986881793,
0.4849482477,
0.0808128044,
0.506626308,
-0.6675773859,
0.593074441,
0.398119241,
0.5972929001,
0.530251503,
-0.1376814842,
0.5019770265,
0.174447298,
-0.5320262313,
-0.8195860982,
0.3316440284,
-0.7780431509,
0.0780645013,
1.1432189941,
-0.2848452926,
-0.286380291,
-0.237530455,
0.0039122673,
0.4175822735,
-0.1609580368,
0.662116468,
0.5479989052,
-0.3957549632,
-0.3648407161,
-0.3450635076,
0.5802817941,
0.6750612855,
-0.4207133353,
0.2287278771,
0.1781457812,
-0.1187968627,
0.2956753671,
0.519497633,
-0.0086755445,
0.2241415977,
0.3180789649,
0.0531835221,
0.195043087,
-0.2740522027,
-1.0236682892,
-0.0164256897,
0.3908993006,
-0.0058819079
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16854v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16854v3
|
An Expert is Worth One Token: Synergizing Multiple Expert LLMs as Generalist via Expert Token Routing
| 2024-03-25T15:17:05 | 2024-06-11T15:12:09 |
Ziwei Chai, Guoyin Wang, Jing Su, Tianjie Zhang, Xuanwen Huang, Xuwu Wang, Jingjing Xu, Jianbo Yuan, Hongxia Yang, Fei Wu, Yang Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present Expert-Token-Routing, a unified generalist framework that
facilitates seamless integration of multiple expert LLMs. Our framework
represents expert LLMs as special expert tokens within the vocabulary of a meta
LLM. The meta LLM can route to an expert LLM like generating new tokens.
Expert-Token-Routing not only supports learning the implicit expertise of
expert LLMs from existing instruction dataset but also allows for dynamic
extension of new expert LLMs in a plug-and-play manner. It also conceals the
detailed collaboration process from the user's perspective, facilitating
interaction as though it were a singular LLM. Our framework outperforms various
existing multi-LLM collaboration paradigms across benchmarks that incorporate
six diverse expert domains, demonstrating effectiveness and robustness in
building generalist LLM system via synergizing multiple expert LLMs.
|
[
-0.4264736176,
-0.6639257669,
0.6997227669,
0.0848183706,
-0.2703160048,
0.429076612,
-0.0917126685,
-0.2947893441,
0.7945517898,
0.4616244435,
-0.5986325741,
-0.6309805512,
-0.4911324382,
-0.1729507893,
-0.3794830739,
0.7768290639,
0.2250377089,
0.4120965302,
-0.3239766955,
-0.3223874569,
-0.5594086051,
-0.5707210302,
-0.9325491786,
-0.1488666683,
0.7818228602,
0.5196239948,
0.6276066899,
0.5309146047,
0.4936740398,
0.4252383709,
0.114384383,
0.2657318413,
-0.043412786,
0.159144327,
-0.6586587429,
-0.4590306878,
-0.9629591107,
-0.037512321,
0.215581879,
0.8372659683,
-0.2489478737,
0.1225005612,
0.0286384821,
0.6536871195,
-0.3832145631,
-0.1337876469,
-0.7161467075,
-0.0274691153,
-0.3523280025,
-0.0772577003,
-0.1809811443,
-0.0651025623,
0.2893861234,
-0.8616009355,
0.3956869543,
0.2700487077,
0.0972587466,
0.420240283,
-0.2478229851,
-0.167752713,
-0.4492734075,
0.5139137506,
-0.4318293035,
0.2373758703,
-0.2690246999,
0.5066685081,
-0.0887313858,
-1.083343029,
-0.369017303,
0.4276973605,
0.10477826,
0.1482250988,
-0.1216585189,
0.4554151297,
-0.3298971057,
0.1610843092,
-0.2043274045,
0.2568905354,
-0.1783811748,
-0.1522139162,
0.5599809289,
0.2711327374,
0.098468855,
0.3014191091,
-0.6938812733,
0.4668016136,
-0.4075509906,
-0.1630649865,
0.5891534686,
0.2077223808,
0.0283883251,
0.0539266914,
-0.1088513955,
0.7188893557,
0.2497895509,
-0.306968987,
0.2311297208,
-0.5130301714,
-0.0638963208,
0.0217673834,
0.7777841687,
0.1867104918,
0.1271766275,
-0.8254134059,
0.1126692891,
-0.3774164319,
0.3308017552,
-0.4422137737,
-0.3911435008,
0.0535991006,
-0.2899267972,
-0.2514480352,
0.4115381241,
-0.9485399127,
-0.3746879995,
-0.3545043766,
0.4909422696,
0.1185190827,
-0.6417346001,
0.283657968,
-0.3136208951,
-0.2199747115,
0.4928971529,
-0.9869262576,
0.756988585,
0.9086179137,
0.8002878428,
-0.3132678866,
-0.6066766381,
-0.433766216,
0.4440526962,
-0.2682251632,
0.8668789864,
-0.670822978,
-0.4911695123,
-0.1208996624,
-0.2969138324,
-0.2163283676,
-0.2720892131,
0.4373154938,
-0.5962007642,
0.2669415176,
-0.4800493121,
-0.5050571561,
-0.3625993431,
0.2116637379,
-0.6452715993,
0.6481159925,
-0.0814082623,
-0.6905338168,
0.4613828361,
-0.9244824052,
-0.230824545,
0.3800100386,
-0.5602234006,
0.219673425,
0.0224035904,
0.163910836,
0.3748093843,
-0.2947280705,
0.2141508162,
-0.4240549505,
-0.3325734437,
-0.029912401,
-0.3705452085,
0.3781698644,
-0.0643292814,
-0.3049578667,
0.1392363757,
-0.6501514316,
-0.0024571531,
-0.2999975085,
-0.5412200093,
-0.1530848593,
0.0981701985,
-0.2389338166,
0.1727338284,
0.4352134168,
-0.3552557528,
0.6285933256,
-0.3374940753,
0.2624715865,
1.197281003,
0.1192424223,
0.6961979866,
-0.2546175122,
0.4536396265,
0.0647714436,
0.1471542716,
-0.2508052289,
-0.7559975386,
-1.066998601,
-0.4818275571,
0.3389332592,
0.3643808067,
-0.505969286,
0.2576521039,
-0.2188097984,
-0.2017920017,
-0.9345238209,
0.3445561528,
0.329218477,
0.5676582456,
0.6452158093,
-0.49316746,
-0.4551153779,
-0.8862099648,
-0.583930552,
-0.0212734733,
0.0454967506,
0.1713203341,
0.1392557025,
-0.3514031768,
1.3015720844,
-0.3143818676,
-0.5531704426,
-0.0230592247,
0.2121134549,
0.2354753017,
0.5945477486,
0.5856055617,
-0.7885452509,
-0.5796611905,
-0.0792814717,
-0.7677506804,
0.1765924692,
0.0944283977,
-0.3129576743,
0.0762920976,
0.4359191954,
-0.5600119233,
0.3478119075,
0.1888188422,
-0.4383280873,
0.4869230688,
-0.0775123239,
0.2878698409,
-1.1884429455,
-0.0216561332,
-0.3357591927,
-0.0396537334,
-0.7838077545,
0.1651581377,
-0.5794183612,
0.2894921005,
-0.3534531891,
0.8825430274,
-0.2524728477,
-0.228222996,
0.0191449951,
0.0383767672,
-0.0353409499,
0.7639597058,
-0.3119191825,
0.7127100825,
0.9362545013,
-0.4909460247,
0.6401818991,
0.0091558285,
0.3211416304,
0.9981389642,
-0.6772279143,
0.5072190166,
0.2509529889,
-0.0110445181,
-0.9850948453,
-0.1790493876,
0.5637285709,
-0.3885575533,
0.2327911407,
-0.3533630371,
-0.5822110772,
-0.319590807,
0.0171402972,
0.286213249,
0.1023257002,
-0.5680078268,
1.2269581556,
0.0841487423,
-0.2852054834,
-0.796975553,
-0.7509291768,
0.4564665854,
-0.0411486253,
-0.7253491282,
0.4408144355,
-0.3141675889,
-0.2287419438,
0.2808230817,
-0.2918089032,
-0.1426160783,
0.3715905547,
0.2812896371,
-0.059627369,
-0.0530128703,
0.3503081799,
0.1044730246,
-0.518997848,
0.248332262,
-0.7735279799,
0.2737995684,
-0.1395210624,
-1.0847375393,
-0.362154901,
0.6623904109,
0.7911829948,
-0.0982090682,
0.5717033148,
0.7863281369,
-0.2960217297,
0.0213753358,
-1.0102407932,
-0.0108991666,
-0.5309645534,
0.2722943723,
-0.4392950237,
-0.973669529,
0.664722085,
-0.3002497256,
0.2294310778,
0.5119478703,
0.3647507131,
0.1190307364,
1.0967121124,
0.7877712846,
-0.3927503824,
-0.0197025258,
-0.1590244323,
0.2414333522,
-0.4998674691,
-0.6793242097,
-0.4041242599,
-0.3660287261,
-0.1092811525,
-0.4979658425,
0.4735665023,
0.2003050447,
-0.4241431653,
-0.30195719,
-0.6242141128,
0.5001831055,
0.8368206024,
0.1209425777,
0.4662161767,
0.0082193874,
-0.6788314581,
0.3833978474,
-0.9757564068,
-0.494833827,
1.0932284594,
0.3428525925,
0.6962366104,
0.1513759047,
0.7425586581,
0.4852846265,
0.2662244439,
-0.6292757988,
0.7555544376,
0.0507756919,
-0.5813513994,
-0.2267941386,
-0.2637837231,
-0.4532617033,
0.2587353885,
-0.2116192132,
-0.6148369908,
0.1011403874,
0.1038986072,
-0.3486022949,
0.8439301848,
-0.5812747478,
0.7268358469,
-0.3692209125,
-0.4712019861,
-0.5772663355,
-0.6512172222,
0.1295118779,
-0.1716045886,
0.3255581558,
0.1151419058,
-0.5089277625,
0.9385143518,
-0.3897963762,
0.8559522033,
-0.2524854541,
0.3406176865,
0.2006972283,
0.1159834489,
0.3189310133,
0.0747985542,
-0.2592701018,
0.2068212926,
-0.7007550001,
-0.557197094,
-0.4160151184,
0.7688530684,
-0.9050770998,
-0.8538963795,
0.0003157346,
-0.287604779,
-0.2998477221,
0.4055166841,
0.1255239844,
0.5210376978,
-0.2143821567,
-0.3111328185,
0.7168332934,
0.3312301338,
0.4653743505,
0.6151653528,
0.2517554462,
-0.8663803935,
0.7130605578,
0.1432559043,
-0.010986398,
0.3136239946,
-0.0407923348,
-0.2532924414,
-0.7668501735,
-0.5123282671,
-0.1696514934,
-0.9683794379,
-0.25464347,
-0.9819970131,
0.1464757025,
-0.2161696553,
-0.6418267488,
-0.4069949985,
-0.4039323032,
-0.5466644168,
-0.392559737,
0.5349443555,
0.9149671793,
-0.226703018,
0.3587853611,
-0.7899613976,
0.032277476,
1.0878829956,
0.5836305022,
0.3664781451,
-0.2325826734,
-0.5327809453,
-0.0823286101,
-0.3035805523,
-0.7394248247,
-0.1657359004,
0.1241525114,
1.2636740208,
0.9263093472,
-0.2570909858,
0.7154471874,
-0.5550981164,
0.8327148557,
0.7610488534,
-1.1487740278,
0.2066223621,
-0.3551303744,
-0.0572332554,
0.7783859372,
0.3294663429,
-0.3884824812,
-0.4017207325,
-0.7631313801,
-0.9122430682,
0.4046614468,
-0.3609156609,
0.0270629972,
-0.1241184846,
0.3546845019,
0.235860154,
0.5910587311,
-0.3909499347,
-0.5557072163,
-0.2237784714,
-0.0540866479,
0.2685238719,
-0.1877559721,
-0.6019867063,
-0.1552899778,
0.2815268338,
-0.3515777588,
0.4322274625,
0.0865143612,
0.100775063,
-0.2521467209,
0.2652496994,
0.2762256861,
0.9811088443,
0.0248309784,
0.373334825,
0.6448293328,
-0.049446959,
0.167833671,
0.0299062133,
0.3827628493,
-0.0175676234,
0.5808496475,
0.4900585413,
0.6533023715,
-0.0047289701,
0.612662971,
0.1204549223,
-0.571089983,
-0.0449495167,
0.220340088,
0.290923208,
0.3904882371,
0.854942143,
0.6307605505,
0.1058718488,
-0.1292812526,
0.433234781,
0.3753983676,
-0.2815570533,
-0.5051600933,
0.8825906515,
0.8837848902,
-0.5608876944,
0.0982763022,
-0.2899561822,
-0.7853559256,
0.3699196875,
-0.0604060888,
1.0893734694,
-0.0967200324,
0.0510525182,
0.1942031831,
0.0441613495,
-0.0677601323,
-0.055538822,
-0.0005074497,
-0.4655915201,
-0.453502506,
-0.2652740777,
-0.8061138391,
-0.5885590911,
-0.6694651842,
0.1049974486,
-0.4267712831,
-0.1439791769,
-0.2486307919,
0.0939877778,
-1.0556143522,
-0.0649351701,
-0.066849567,
1.1034986973,
-0.6899626851,
0.5139480233,
1.0936927795,
-0.3578235507,
-0.6059074402,
-0.3551760316,
-0.006968738,
-0.8245860338,
0.6393886805,
-0.0154427718,
-0.36000368,
0.0007396954,
-0.5783094764,
-0.5601036549,
1.3958015442,
0.0603956878,
-0.6350938082,
-0.2459596395,
0.1817804873,
0.378411293,
-0.675758183,
0.4761591852,
0.301350981,
0.4785167873,
0.1677721888,
-0.7956377268,
0.0125344526,
-0.0371695049,
-0.4410347342,
0.0075889011,
-1.0405727625,
0.8750133514,
-0.2951896191,
-0.0496687926,
-0.0115433466,
0.5492739081,
0.0332976207,
0.3737784028,
0.660400629,
0.9392790198,
0.9648569226,
0.2126751989,
0.2961952388,
-0.7110996842,
0.0421082824,
0.8787534833,
0.0146017894,
0.3564054966,
0.4765337706,
-0.0543334223,
0.8219538927,
0.5002158284,
0.1385643035,
0.5662537217,
0.0716514289,
-0.5182085633,
-0.6081080437,
-0.0568163581,
-0.6072037816,
-0.010576047,
0.1998904496,
-0.1315989941,
-0.3129385412,
-0.2375616431,
0.31194368,
-0.080057472,
-0.5348560214,
0.8357878327,
0.0428122319,
-0.4609423876,
-0.0612925701,
0.0153522445,
0.8492420912,
-0.684699297,
-0.0581608415,
-0.1812837422,
0.0200146828,
-0.4065722525,
-0.5838934183,
-0.080531612,
-0.2312042266,
-0.3588081002,
-0.2371635884,
0.8349401951,
-0.4371901751,
-0.3360570669,
0.5406442881,
1.0684123039,
-0.0163480733,
0.0391807519,
-0.7924400568,
-0.4455949664,
-0.2472751439,
-0.1208093688,
0.4486089051,
0.7628719211,
0.5931305885,
0.7732440233,
0.6910549402,
0.098184824,
-0.0909077153,
0.2286018282,
1.2489646673,
-0.4913485646,
-0.6335473061,
-0.7863788009,
0.7215133905,
-0.0998679772,
-0.3999261856,
0.7156249881,
0.3629973233,
0.8168691993,
0.1922128797,
0.9368815422,
0.3387946188,
0.5261662602,
-0.2876632214,
0.5310161114,
-0.5227883458,
0.4724830687,
-0.3477828801,
-0.5469774008,
-0.1011505723,
0.1904969513,
-0.0110814339,
0.0108311474,
0.4206712842,
0.657769084,
0.0423043333,
-0.0738363042,
0.1812657565,
-0.2161554992,
0.3747996986,
0.4336346984,
0.6778311729,
-0.031578254,
0.5411649942,
0.0707476437,
-0.2902056575,
-0.2087906599,
-0.8494930267,
-1.1191868782,
-0.173190549,
-0.2011180669,
0.1071545929,
0.1818403006,
1.1644449234,
1.154242754,
-0.4852441847,
-0.0767845884,
-0.345708549,
0.6704972982,
-0.3353424966,
-0.222066015,
0.2472199798,
-0.5353965163,
-0.4486258626,
0.4322804213,
0.465521723,
-0.1091174185,
-0.7183712125,
-0.3085399866,
0.0127126472,
0.0152671728,
0.271981895,
0.0341542512,
-0.6762099862,
-0.3659487367,
0.1007972062,
0.0998549014,
-0.0389568694,
0.8544908166,
-0.823374927,
0.6612569094,
0.4223701656,
0.7448242307,
-0.0664077699,
0.0525700636,
0.5180837512,
-0.7780840993,
-0.087751098,
0.2084851712,
0.3262300193,
0.0619269423,
-0.3110066354,
0.7066190243,
0.6605469584,
-0.7134987116,
-0.5338963866,
0.0917848572,
-0.888786912,
-0.144793272,
0.9013002515,
-0.3603484631,
0.3668898642,
-0.5587360263,
0.0752343908,
-0.0530408807,
-0.5885472894,
0.4393793046,
0.7299473882,
-0.1187610701,
0.0709584281,
-0.3300603926,
0.2690802515,
0.2505093217,
-0.6657598019,
-0.4400926828,
0.0456784926,
0.3705432713,
0.3077744842,
0.8926285505,
0.3483459055,
0.2218977213,
0.1166774854,
0.2578700185,
-0.6993563175,
-0.8050143719,
0.0064180982,
0.3151550293,
0.0973277241,
-0.4318269789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16852v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16852v2
|
Towards Explainability in Legal Outcome Prediction Models
| 2024-03-25T15:15:41 | 2024-04-16T03:53:28 |
Josef Valvoda, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Current legal outcome prediction models - a staple of legal NLP - do not
explain their reasoning. However, to employ these models in the real world,
human legal actors need to be able to understand the model's decisions. In the
case of common law, legal practitioners reason towards the outcome of a case by
referring to past case law, known as precedent. We contend that precedent is,
therefore, a natural way of facilitating explainability for legal NLP models.
In this paper, we contribute a novel method for identifying the precedent
employed by legal outcome prediction models. Furthermore, by developing a
taxonomy of legal precedent, we are able to compare human judges and neural
models with respect to the different types of precedent they rely on. We find
that while the models learn to predict outcomes reasonably well, their use of
precedent is unlike that of human judges.
|
[
-0.1930817068,
-0.3324196339,
1.0305764675,
-0.0657799765,
-0.6327432394,
-0.280898273,
-0.0546146296,
-0.4648199677,
0.239930138,
0.6123561263,
-0.4350406229,
-0.5859861374,
-0.3931829631,
-0.1536945403,
-0.5774949193,
0.6983391643,
0.2542370558,
0.2134015411,
-0.5587325692,
-0.2616993785,
-0.4862076938,
-0.7182070613,
-0.6080952287,
-0.6462213397,
0.4332194924,
-0.0654336959,
0.8371539712,
0.6543147564,
0.2023638338,
0.266674757,
-0.2815685272,
-0.4492441714,
-0.0430286601,
-0.2862227857,
-0.3071050346,
-0.7272545099,
-0.3845958412,
-0.1503635049,
0.2543230355,
0.7292596698,
-0.3846073449,
-0.2905900478,
-0.4497386217,
0.6382693648,
-0.5528626442,
0.1010706052,
-0.647361517,
0.4309217334,
-0.1031899378,
-0.4446181059,
-0.4829698205,
-0.4496275187,
0.1401741207,
-0.8353163004,
0.3052571714,
0.0935435221,
0.5237560868,
0.065791361,
-0.4101694822,
-0.3041635752,
-0.6061346531,
0.3061212897,
-1.0796989202,
0.2120401114,
0.1461457908,
0.9210524559,
-0.1876622587,
-0.9293558002,
-0.9512966871,
-0.383166343,
-0.3133625388,
0.3855485618,
0.019618405,
0.215799287,
0.2178943902,
-0.0414539166,
-0.5561178327,
0.4464710653,
-0.2204385698,
-0.0891815573,
0.4358178973,
0.1930725873,
0.2017732859,
-0.4473356903,
-0.1687938571,
0.5580314398,
-0.7067623138,
0.4905828238,
0.425627768,
0.4980448782,
0.0565070584,
0.2860875428,
-0.230012536,
0.7583757043,
-0.2021566778,
0.0784005299,
-0.1718471795,
0.2440778762,
-0.2036442459,
0.3591595888,
0.4027865529,
0.3598624766,
0.304358989,
-0.1715494543,
-0.0324594453,
-0.1787410975,
0.5097895265,
-0.4368611276,
0.1653836817,
0.367557019,
-0.798581779,
-0.4033500254,
0.1649069041,
-0.7144550085,
-0.7619560957,
-0.3194565773,
0.3637310863,
-0.2672691643,
-0.1983344853,
0.3900916576,
-0.321388036,
0.4680541158,
0.4884016216,
-0.6045758128,
0.53018713,
1.1439820528,
0.5557640195,
0.1263723969,
-0.1930403411,
-0.5339901447,
-0.053832233,
-0.4073392153,
0.5786063075,
-0.4777382612,
-0.221382156,
0.20945023,
-0.1013811827,
0.1970096976,
-0.4061447084,
0.812274754,
-0.5519527793,
-0.1729539186,
-0.1155862138,
-0.5854403377,
-0.5091816783,
0.0545629039,
-0.4874252677,
0.0076981043,
-0.2794585824,
-0.7519461513,
1.1881680489,
-0.5595181584,
-0.6736859679,
0.2652394176,
-0.3580701649,
-0.5598415732,
0.3451941907,
-0.0235414375,
0.490606606,
-0.1890559793,
1.0635122061,
-0.5806849003,
-0.4086641073,
0.0789418146,
-0.272179991,
0.8362460732,
0.2125117481,
-0.1132349968,
0.1180507764,
-0.7476347089,
-0.261826098,
0.03252149,
0.0681230947,
-0.3354137838,
0.4981154501,
-0.2813255191,
0.5101448298,
-0.0997665823,
-0.1352373511,
-0.0275178328,
-0.3060994446,
0.5330418348,
0.8703818321,
-0.0855039731,
0.3211039603,
-0.4158213437,
0.6016702056,
0.013382569,
0.2270814329,
0.0805643424,
-0.6907038093,
-0.4772951007,
0.1421675682,
0.4315057993,
0.2130736858,
-0.159956485,
0.1828732342,
-0.433906287,
-0.3157485425,
-0.2314405888,
-0.4156350493,
0.2831058502,
0.6407769918,
0.2021215856,
-0.3268365264,
-0.8748959303,
-0.9682502151,
-0.9397307634,
-0.5279790163,
0.1602740437,
0.5618117452,
0.6530336142,
0.288383007,
1.0586607456,
0.0354055166,
0.1422918141,
-0.4336416423,
0.3021538258,
0.7245807052,
0.1654809564,
0.3872662485,
-1.0200340748,
-0.0515814833,
0.2039821148,
-0.8685463667,
0.2617562115,
-0.533164978,
0.1717749238,
-0.0501080155,
0.6582681537,
-0.4204942584,
0.965588212,
-0.5008121133,
-0.6366773248,
0.8908208013,
-0.3436921537,
-0.0290707331,
-0.5116196275,
-0.0285777804,
-0.0792930424,
-0.4113027453,
-0.6714537144,
0.0353286341,
-0.0459705181,
0.0336800292,
-0.6092643738,
0.6253831983,
-0.0983515605,
-0.4869960845,
0.0582074374,
-0.0202489141,
-0.0437212102,
0.1438196152,
0.4150028527,
0.2416903675,
0.5373670459,
-0.6635875106,
0.0672851726,
0.1493914574,
-0.3183654249,
0.5950422287,
-0.6631351709,
-0.374199003,
-0.3639420271,
0.2714798152,
-0.5328256488,
-0.4494334459,
-0.0375319123,
-0.4299197197,
0.1173628941,
-0.7265613079,
-0.281224668,
-0.7397140265,
0.1898728758,
-0.0317218751,
0.584387362,
-0.5731933117,
0.9140245318,
0.15794155,
0.0709676817,
-0.6597616673,
-0.5563334823,
0.1329381168,
-0.8224775791,
-0.2467269897,
0.3533859551,
0.2688782811,
-0.5729436874,
0.0775057897,
-0.2020289153,
-0.2701711655,
0.5015885234,
0.6628667116,
0.1144260317,
-0.3426267803,
0.5294064879,
-0.0216322877,
-0.0074748173,
0.4569921792,
-0.2152311504,
0.2611043155,
0.1811152101,
-0.3448706567,
-0.5783318281,
0.309328109,
0.4787872434,
0.0573874488,
0.6368898153,
-0.0785665289,
-0.5061845779,
-0.2043847889,
-0.2821091115,
0.0870403945,
-0.3533698618,
0.1303288341,
-0.5439113379,
-0.3918319643,
0.7924648523,
0.0244983826,
-0.0245125964,
0.618537426,
0.4193853736,
0.0677689761,
0.5658007264,
0.4057847857,
0.0891226232,
0.120673582,
0.2203945816,
0.3140794039,
-0.2751312852,
-0.2774834037,
-0.4541209638,
0.1306852698,
-0.5436033607,
-0.050166145,
-0.1347611099,
0.2996208966,
-0.1704358459,
0.4835861921,
-0.3007294536,
0.541960001,
0.5121243,
-0.0187516008,
0.4258699715,
-0.5612078905,
-0.4432197511,
0.2533896863,
-0.7089180946,
-0.7094708681,
1.1421413422,
0.118414335,
0.3148373365,
0.0567098558,
1.1250491142,
0.2583101988,
0.0944522992,
-0.6580038071,
0.4805202782,
-0.2214484513,
-0.6679870486,
-0.107203804,
-0.1230799705,
-0.9563627243,
0.2155731767,
-0.5106219649,
-1.0433856249,
0.328779906,
0.016705336,
-0.9150565863,
0.293695569,
-0.2582300305,
0.8380615115,
-0.2093954682,
-0.3584420085,
-0.1914757639,
-0.8596025109,
0.4410474002,
-0.0854145736,
0.600443244,
-0.0718134269,
0.4161758423,
0.8860308528,
-0.6661444902,
0.6446936131,
-0.1850287169,
0.378634572,
0.2846410871,
0.0444851667,
0.4246352017,
0.3209208846,
-0.3267447948,
-0.3550070524,
-0.0572704226,
-0.1570667177,
-0.7826777101,
0.6560599208,
-0.3904980123,
-0.7331383824,
-0.4096726179,
-0.2894947827,
-0.0158589594,
0.0798097178,
0.2016738057,
0.3678070009,
-0.3750422597,
-0.1844577789,
0.0350934379,
-0.3125467598,
0.6167379618,
0.720185101,
-0.1804337651,
0.126738444,
0.5390251279,
0.334472537,
-0.330060333,
0.1188331172,
0.5015642643,
-0.5085659623,
-0.8182348609,
0.1096181571,
-0.1414331198,
-0.9978908896,
0.2152005285,
-0.5434839725,
-0.1256651729,
-0.2823465466,
-0.5016686916,
-0.0488545783,
-0.6203110814,
-0.2495560944,
-0.2672848105,
0.2687674165,
0.8200816512,
-0.0300497003,
0.21174106,
-0.2212574035,
0.5354391932,
0.5641455054,
0.4763947427,
-0.0093745785,
-0.8017949462,
0.2409377247,
-0.4417944252,
0.0310190041,
-0.8249881268,
0.4317576885,
0.1790154576,
0.8879643679,
0.5947618484,
0.196386382,
0.7704530358,
-0.6618227363,
0.642421484,
0.2756923139,
-1.0160624981,
0.9029405117,
-0.1913797557,
-0.2888801992,
0.5632849932,
0.2941727936,
-0.436211139,
-0.0705514774,
-1.0503031015,
-1.0194354057,
0.4949586689,
0.0992579758,
-0.0735638291,
-0.1239723414,
0.7343232036,
0.6222285628,
0.1761252135,
-0.7956081629,
0.0759998485,
-0.2529415488,
0.3475536704,
-0.1806193888,
-0.0647566915,
-0.0122626517,
-0.3480996788,
0.4701815248,
0.0683062375,
0.1226139516,
0.1026756912,
-0.2388456911,
0.2361859679,
0.4859047234,
0.6748133898,
1.1341081858,
-0.467779696,
0.209458366,
-0.0807041302,
0.1431925297,
0.0267877132,
0.1411671788,
-0.0196951013,
0.1927822381,
0.6881241798,
0.7434557676,
0.1773302108,
-0.4399638772,
0.521690309,
-0.0435740426,
-0.3011579216,
-0.7822962999,
-0.03708129,
0.1774926484,
0.2955870628,
0.3027490377,
0.1771066934,
0.550980866,
-0.8263405561,
0.5991553068,
0.2838455737,
-0.7269696593,
-0.166934669,
0.9612301588,
0.056482356,
-0.490724951,
0.2791242301,
-0.1901713908,
-0.3679017723,
1.146592021,
0.513391614,
0.5321134925,
0.336791873,
0.3028247952,
0.4302867353,
-0.1253885478,
-0.361687988,
0.1455259472,
0.1853582561,
-0.535649538,
-0.3363433778,
-0.4708642662,
-0.3686297238,
0.0437521823,
-1.0609147549,
0.2438714951,
-0.5429524183,
-0.1442576051,
0.6229859591,
-0.3371533453,
-0.734297514,
0.3469917178,
0.1351859272,
1.0165374279,
-1.0879484415,
0.7956691384,
0.3082018197,
-0.5361939073,
-0.5133650899,
0.1311555803,
0.1371153593,
-0.7130038142,
0.6236457825,
0.4217038751,
0.1578669399,
-0.3930412829,
-0.4116048515,
-0.041483216,
0.9847356081,
0.1173757017,
-0.4912115633,
-0.141002655,
-0.0975870565,
0.6707153916,
-0.4925948977,
0.2259114981,
0.6831259131,
0.4705989361,
0.1735997796,
-0.4830174744,
0.1545013487,
-0.1632468402,
0.0106261466,
-0.0370089039,
0.2084450573,
0.6517928243,
-0.6181914806,
-0.0801436082,
0.0937603936,
0.5768267512,
0.2733151317,
0.7324387431,
0.4107381701,
0.5128933191,
0.8109334111,
-0.2865585089,
1.5192023516,
0.1772320569,
0.3174949288,
1.4665620327,
-0.2879293561,
0.7182099223,
0.68110919,
-0.2524493039,
0.6260860562,
0.6450282335,
0.1460583508,
0.5739534497,
0.5687523484,
0.0763837323,
-0.8551291823,
0.1023604199,
-0.0507680103,
0.4926932752,
0.1359305978,
-0.5092525482,
-0.2288581878,
-0.2850145996,
-0.4085764587,
0.5455168486,
-0.6333972216,
0.7654588223,
0.1321059614,
-0.6689589024,
0.2585867643,
-0.3357539773,
0.1955744624,
-0.2673510611,
-0.1328909099,
-0.0413843095,
-0.0852946043,
-0.1800674647,
-1.0444571972,
0.427374512,
-0.4035874605,
-0.1196708158,
0.3310267627,
0.36786744,
0.1478367299,
-0.4003985226,
0.4800946414,
0.4779423177,
0.2032511979,
0.0434132926,
-0.7386389971,
-0.6592459679,
-0.4382623434,
-0.0361873582,
0.1308076382,
0.631069839,
-0.4015437961,
1.0373976231,
0.314410001,
0.2305615991,
-0.0024743252,
0.083399117,
0.504255414,
-0.9412472248,
-0.7027157545,
-0.9898484945,
0.6747592688,
-0.2678374648,
-0.3484042585,
0.176142782,
0.3431528509,
0.1958297789,
-0.0374518707,
0.739710927,
-0.0827161074,
0.4173960388,
-0.7863500714,
0.6400889158,
-0.5982216597,
0.2739776969,
-0.1604001075,
-0.1493146867,
-0.6189141273,
0.5550310612,
-0.4701230824,
-0.1381494552,
0.5595968366,
0.3353893757,
-0.2387841791,
-0.0093777562,
0.7071475387,
0.1019746438,
-0.0468625389,
0.4281797707,
0.770641923,
0.0467307083,
0.4542763233,
-0.1541674882,
0.1984210163,
-0.5213735104,
-1.1078803539,
-0.9647209048,
-0.4288214743,
0.047603257,
-0.136124894,
0.4715417624,
0.5026991367,
0.6485245824,
-0.9814324975,
0.0037420061,
-0.7280082703,
0.4907415509,
-0.3816412687,
-0.1319938153,
0.3532288671,
-0.3069124818,
-0.1458436996,
0.2299138755,
0.1929279715,
-0.0852455571,
0.4185142517,
-0.1821991801,
-0.1833842397,
0.2763813138,
0.1313645095,
0.5043339729,
-1.3792669773,
-0.3587191403,
-0.794041276,
0.3786350787,
0.2791407406,
0.9085066915,
-0.894293189,
0.7451218367,
0.226675123,
0.1190168783,
0.4276978672,
-0.1098098233,
0.9833469987,
-0.3329238892,
0.2310885489,
0.3412464261,
0.8839533329,
-0.0740066543,
-0.4595449269,
0.6396293044,
-0.1689182222,
-0.2640414834,
-0.4953805208,
0.4660862684,
-0.9988457561,
-0.5468607545,
0.5507360101,
-0.5396483541,
-0.2353321016,
-0.5459225774,
0.269554764,
0.2596062422,
-0.25541839,
0.8586224914,
0.4062295556,
0.1068626195,
-0.2066840678,
-0.9144849777,
0.64089185,
0.1727939844,
-0.6120793223,
0.102673322,
0.2593323588,
0.2055334449,
0.1162103117,
0.4630404115,
-0.3260651827,
0.6626335979,
-0.044881884,
0.0634612441,
-0.0431595445,
-0.2587868273,
-0.6664131284,
0.1805927008,
0.0761791468,
0.3393844068
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16851v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16851v1
|
Can ChatGPT predict article retraction based on Twitter mentions?
| 2024-03-25T15:15:09 | 2024-03-25T15:15:09 |
Er-Te Zheng, Hui-Zhen Fu, Zhichao Fang
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Detecting problematic research articles timely is a vital task. This study
explores whether Twitter mentions of retracted articles can signal potential
problems with the articles prior to retraction, thereby playing a role in
predicting future retraction of problematic articles. A dataset comprising
3,505 retracted articles and their associated Twitter mentions is analyzed,
alongside 3,505 non-retracted articles with similar characteristics obtained
using the Coarsened Exact Matching method. The effectiveness of Twitter
mentions in predicting article retraction is evaluated by four prediction
methods, including manual labelling, keyword identification, machine learning
models, and ChatGPT. Manual labelling results indicate that there are indeed
retracted articles with their Twitter mentions containing recognizable evidence
signaling problems before retraction, although they represent only a limited
share of all retracted articles with Twitter mention data (approximately 16%).
Using the manual labelling results as the baseline, ChatGPT demonstrates
superior performance compared to other methods, implying its potential in
assisting human judgment for predicting article retraction. This study uncovers
both the potential and limitation of social media events as an early warning
system for article retraction, shedding light on a potential application of
generative artificial intelligence in promoting research integrity.
|
[
-0.074372679,
-0.9426493645,
0.4435322583,
0.0726406351,
-0.3832424581,
0.5427158475,
-0.110451147,
-0.6505020261,
0.4946073294,
0.2118515521,
-0.646080792,
-0.0786049888,
-0.9848715663,
0.0236410461,
-1.1642136574,
1.1365859509,
-0.1570039243,
-0.5613773465,
0.2936026156,
0.2016283423,
-0.3825512826,
-0.181068778,
-1.0054671764,
-0.4255410135,
1.0933331251,
0.1343010217,
0.5233861208,
0.3798503876,
0.918805182,
0.2670729756,
0.077527158,
-0.1078898311,
-0.7411285043,
-0.0117108934,
0.0030334652,
-0.3533364236,
-0.1265998483,
0.0791404545,
0.4824760854,
0.3581125438,
-0.294786334,
0.1633333862,
0.3715384901,
0.6062930822,
-0.1190006137,
-0.0999557823,
-0.9125061035,
0.2728398144,
-0.1442100704,
-0.4023222327,
-0.2734433413,
-0.8664241433,
0.3386115134,
-0.543314755,
0.60488832,
0.1898693442,
1.2462909222,
0.1940285116,
-0.2204561681,
-0.1066283137,
-0.8831058741,
0.5370147824,
-0.5310833454,
0.1703978777,
0.265330404,
0.5101665854,
-0.1684900969,
-0.9691889286,
-0.4807439446,
-0.1835021973,
-0.0722296387,
0.0063348566,
-0.398768574,
-0.6503395438,
0.231595993,
0.0476472378,
-0.3277460039,
-0.2093030363,
-0.6441626549,
-0.3675110042,
0.55614537,
-0.183092162,
0.3347338438,
-0.0353272185,
-0.4987392128,
0.3121141791,
-1.0280413628,
-0.466230005,
0.3074091375,
-0.0260336157,
-0.0132805314,
0.477184087,
0.1115731224,
0.0402173102,
-0.0033109332,
0.2466365099,
0.2822766304,
-0.3797061443,
0.0198891032,
0.1143147647,
0.9819697738,
0.3756460249,
0.2367305905,
-0.5368041992,
-0.3021996021,
-0.2861179113,
0.4534292519,
-0.4115210176,
-0.3632677794,
-0.0427108444,
-0.539080739,
-0.4990058839,
0.0681961551,
-0.6412912011,
-0.5788041949,
0.0410106182,
0.6264256239,
-0.6973178387,
-0.4484992325,
-0.2631955147,
-0.1893758327,
0.1752072722,
0.6147236824,
-0.239609018,
-0.1020261794,
0.9045185447,
1.1448354721,
-0.4537980556,
-0.2454461902,
-0.2241950482,
0.1938333511,
-0.3650266826,
0.9808849096,
-0.1705525666,
-0.1414511353,
0.0363695174,
0.3120395839,
-0.012439305,
-0.0574787222,
1.0457177162,
-0.5245625377,
-0.0692123547,
-0.3521413803,
-0.4091036022,
-0.1482892781,
0.3687722683,
-0.818177402,
0.405849576,
-0.0896223709,
-1.016851902,
0.3744297028,
-0.0614896193,
-0.5100002885,
-0.0701550171,
0.0962501913,
-0.8620674014,
-0.1397895515,
0.166873455,
0.1740710288,
-0.0662903488,
0.4720759392,
-0.295506984,
-0.3959512115,
0.4190078974,
-0.6065742373,
0.7590125799,
0.3604625762,
-0.3169798553,
0.053417027,
-0.4395974278,
-0.4440925717,
0.1857126206,
-0.3651447892,
-0.0733694881,
0.0858163983,
-0.0449890494,
-0.0166645795,
-0.1749614477,
-0.6679794192,
0.0866932422,
-0.0528862998,
0.5308480263,
0.7378576398,
0.4217083454,
0.1685619205,
-0.6528550982,
0.4411973059,
-0.2150482684,
-0.0775719732,
0.0957762152,
-0.6705963612,
-0.7592843175,
0.0504594184,
0.4213708043,
0.5936393738,
-0.9334367514,
0.2729861736,
-0.4666049778,
-0.723256588,
-0.3715389073,
-0.1033282578,
0.3169294,
0.6362856627,
0.0652667806,
-0.0542539693,
-0.86349684,
-0.75746876,
-0.9022009969,
-0.4019807279,
-0.1001568511,
-0.0417724662,
0.4039995074,
0.0146377254,
0.9175456166,
-0.3425000906,
-0.2780591547,
-0.1268168986,
0.8337959647,
0.117577292,
0.3524202704,
0.2539058924,
-1.0073287487,
-0.3805561066,
-0.1282134801,
-0.8716204762,
-0.0717927068,
-0.3653479815,
-0.0424337834,
0.1419126987,
0.6996163726,
-0.6451359391,
0.553516686,
-0.0089416299,
-0.1896973997,
0.7302930951,
0.2892473936,
0.2608031034,
-1.0448651314,
0.1872354299,
0.1445809305,
-0.2719922364,
-0.4767802656,
-0.6469449997,
-0.1675582528,
0.0718702152,
-0.3789682984,
0.1305080354,
-0.389324218,
0.1680878103,
-0.2177094966,
-0.0239414945,
-0.3003228605,
-0.2209926695,
0.2200400084,
0.602561295,
0.065248616,
-0.3482444286,
0.1570049226,
0.155504927,
-0.465842545,
-0.1626627594,
-0.6655982137,
0.0264913775,
-0.0192508623,
0.1655995399,
-1.2363985777,
0.0821838304,
0.5061573982,
-0.9724482894,
0.2608677447,
-0.2823533714,
-0.302102983,
-0.3956576288,
-0.3409799039,
0.068201676,
0.4146282077,
0.0258981232,
0.3109440804,
0.283978194,
-0.5696254373,
-0.5146315694,
-0.6097194552,
0.3720381558,
-0.3385600448,
-0.3834391832,
0.3686132133,
0.1815690398,
0.0065709655,
0.4856036603,
-0.0260120668,
-0.0129310442,
0.1845578998,
0.2469152063,
0.2439365089,
0.1046963856,
0.3342457116,
-0.1490026563,
-0.2100482583,
0.3612403572,
0.2540064454,
0.3283921778,
-0.1134564728,
-0.4250579476,
-0.1691315472,
0.1950310916,
0.1195201129,
0.0106937904,
0.7157551646,
1.297773242,
-0.6811609864,
0.422399193,
-0.7228136659,
-0.3924163878,
-0.372061044,
0.328923434,
0.2181672752,
-0.7008735538,
0.6020165086,
0.0123481266,
0.2400720865,
0.7066173553,
0.3780997992,
-0.3168990314,
0.5247965455,
0.6237691641,
-0.2989377975,
0.6355109215,
-0.1463645697,
0.5694613457,
-0.6813828945,
-0.1797624677,
-0.749612391,
-0.2969298065,
-0.7582934499,
-0.0034078807,
0.0539729334,
-0.0811736956,
0.0271234028,
0.4653777182,
-0.4482339919,
0.2571108341,
0.5506921411,
0.2277730554,
0.3870404959,
0.380910635,
0.399428606,
-0.062055476,
-0.624204278,
-0.5552972555,
0.9783936739,
0.2113043219,
0.7494535446,
-0.0214194134,
0.8032242656,
0.7818054557,
0.938137114,
-0.5991376042,
0.3163275421,
0.4661619365,
-0.5328643918,
-0.3436055779,
-0.3862095177,
-1.0954339504,
-0.122858651,
-0.3447573483,
-0.8112342358,
0.2075624019,
-0.2879791558,
-0.37705338,
0.5286563635,
-0.8269095421,
0.1055281013,
0.1379537135,
-0.4067710936,
-0.1844054759,
-0.6000239849,
0.4605747461,
-0.2782151103,
0.2858538926,
-0.4669385254,
0.0510539599,
1.1110305786,
-0.0981670767,
0.8636156321,
0.1203742474,
0.0869955271,
0.5933671594,
0.2562924623,
0.4139763415,
0.242696017,
0.0724670738,
0.0871122777,
0.0404242054,
-0.1272950768,
0.0021171772,
0.7963303328,
-0.7021628618,
-0.7168343067,
-0.6285462976,
-0.1279069185,
-0.1354528964,
0.3876297772,
0.5249071121,
-0.2297726721,
-0.2331739664,
0.1293352991,
0.5062778592,
-0.0926191956,
0.7435426116,
0.5095344782,
0.0292519517,
-0.3749073148,
1.0165438652,
0.2966510355,
-0.2333206534,
0.2993301451,
0.1455874741,
-0.0462856963,
-0.770142436,
0.0894485265,
0.1072919816,
-0.2602317035,
-0.5839360952,
-0.5808693171,
-0.4257567227,
-0.4542165399,
-0.1516254395,
-0.3831609488,
-0.438524425,
-0.3329224885,
-0.3398861885,
0.2791531384,
0.5379674435,
-0.0260965209,
0.2375923842,
-1.0695480108,
0.4073694646,
0.0154492194,
0.455152899,
0.1300593168,
-0.4920736849,
-0.1785550565,
0.0083623659,
-0.6190143228,
-0.8724927306,
0.6041303277,
0.2303100973,
0.4935149252,
0.5040636659,
0.2149282843,
0.2669864297,
-0.4325866997,
0.5786100626,
0.4124849141,
-0.3834770918,
0.5866274238,
-0.6823789477,
-0.1984397471,
0.1491208673,
0.7329885364,
-0.6744901538,
-0.5729463696,
-0.7726718187,
-0.9665398598,
0.4516172111,
0.4431385994,
0.0201141238,
-0.2383257598,
0.3223998249,
0.4557735622,
0.3159812391,
-0.7895284295,
-0.0264810771,
0.1580532044,
0.3449606001,
0.0202562977,
-0.5994563103,
-0.2211374044,
-0.1392005533,
0.7676177025,
0.3269157112,
0.605697155,
0.3869978487,
-0.2067983449,
-0.2702931166,
0.152300179,
0.2846993208,
0.9072300792,
-0.5349280834,
-0.1627659649,
-0.293282181,
-0.5129297376,
-0.0219844002,
0.2524630427,
-0.3610286415,
0.1464016438,
0.6178052425,
0.1828925759,
0.1485551894,
-0.1494937688,
0.2674632668,
-0.154876098,
-0.3011884987,
-0.7344551682,
-0.4020926654,
0.2982643843,
0.1775533706,
0.8403679729,
0.1198014319,
0.2776922286,
-0.4458343983,
0.6379261613,
0.1575841159,
-0.6074297428,
-0.5651978254,
0.6619438529,
0.2501858771,
-0.3928383589,
0.6411640048,
0.096291706,
-0.4306485057,
0.6753559113,
0.3317778707,
1.0651226044,
-0.2296311706,
0.256480962,
0.3662214875,
0.647751987,
0.0052776481,
0.0116870552,
0.4643504322,
-0.8236085176,
-0.425411433,
-0.3157060742,
-0.0768418536,
-0.014116805,
-0.4916164279,
0.3172920346,
-0.2479244918,
-0.5416924357,
0.2127986848,
-0.1174034104,
-0.4607313871,
-0.1647879779,
0.1342648864,
0.8125189543,
-1.0984750986,
0.5854840279,
0.4123497605,
-0.4891573787,
-0.5750389099,
0.1726962477,
0.2653233707,
-0.4404036105,
0.2283050716,
0.1467044502,
-0.2264323235,
-0.142981559,
-0.5835695267,
-0.7825402617,
1.0642665625,
0.5879536867,
-0.5013009906,
0.1116872504,
-0.1543331742,
0.3867833316,
-0.1397372484,
0.0314119086,
0.5411278605,
0.2561691701,
0.3753457963,
-0.961063385,
0.1568233073,
-0.2184338868,
-0.3899415433,
0.2672916353,
-0.5974112749,
0.6469044685,
-0.3333730698,
-0.4279054701,
0.0041353814,
0.4262804389,
-0.1293596625,
0.643063128,
0.3626281917,
0.3466473818,
0.4144178927,
-0.4317494929,
0.9511375427,
0.1946733445,
0.5005604625,
0.7931680083,
0.0116717098,
0.7571699619,
0.8100574017,
-0.2122678608,
0.2643741965,
0.746173501,
0.0699829534,
0.5896439552,
-0.1038936079,
-0.1503755152,
-0.198426798,
-0.2843793333,
-0.6658766866,
0.0440538265,
0.6207063198,
-0.5355697274,
-0.464672178,
-0.0990510359,
0.3171277642,
-0.2309250087,
-0.1478807032,
0.7970606685,
0.1310477108,
-0.7982340455,
0.5441690087,
-0.3164836168,
0.4555637538,
-0.4154291153,
-0.2515514791,
-0.2998260558,
0.1970970929,
-0.2669844627,
-0.9679009318,
0.7302774787,
-0.4074357748,
0.1874937266,
-0.2416266501,
1.3784581423,
-0.1609681547,
-0.5099027753,
0.129615739,
0.8170410991,
-0.0608547553,
-0.2017499059,
-0.8818572164,
-0.0348582752,
0.3402051628,
-0.3827581704,
0.347081542,
0.5324659944,
-0.1189198345,
1.2166208029,
0.6482197642,
0.2281583697,
0.114835158,
-0.2017162591,
1.0356388092,
-0.4860189259,
-0.1962481737,
-0.7862717509,
0.1277479976,
-0.1678515226,
0.1003599018,
0.6074039936,
0.4203768075,
0.314620018,
-0.1378537565,
0.9929137826,
-0.3477955163,
0.9401577711,
-0.2848570645,
0.8633463979,
-0.3166634738,
0.5005966425,
-0.4046634436,
-0.5401887298,
-0.2310336679,
0.2730616629,
-0.6108572483,
-0.0563274473,
0.7403864264,
0.3914513886,
0.0009527225,
0.0859295428,
-0.1096064001,
0.0521855429,
0.6132516265,
0.3502812386,
0.7669517994,
-0.2117318213,
0.9962425232,
-0.3302195072,
-0.0570435114,
-0.6671219468,
-1.0576221943,
-0.541593194,
-0.6715362072,
-0.5509759188,
-0.540030539,
0.5380681753,
0.4336449802,
0.2229676247,
-0.7444760799,
0.2845802009,
0.0520575047,
0.3423613906,
-0.3006816208,
-0.2775891423,
0.6551603675,
-0.2120653987,
-0.2554963231,
-0.2667024136,
-0.0447309017,
0.0212797876,
0.2459313422,
0.4446668327,
-0.6040270329,
-0.3222484887,
0.4855935276,
0.5136185288,
-0.4933305979,
-0.7377058864,
-0.0870837122,
0.0058978526,
-0.0666765943,
0.9239949584,
-0.9100980759,
0.0001549305,
0.4520541131,
0.4757599235,
0.5550198555,
0.286885947,
0.7358283997,
-0.5226548314,
0.0108470935,
0.5226977468,
0.5007665753,
0.2511172593,
-0.3304291368,
0.7059399486,
0.5149637461,
-0.4967096746,
-0.6385642886,
-0.0221420303,
-0.6840735674,
0.2008846998,
1.0622634888,
-0.449590981,
-0.3564539254,
-0.2014598399,
-0.2370198667,
0.5545320511,
-0.5487059355,
1.4828429222,
0.9241392612,
-0.0410692245,
-0.7194016576,
-0.8188866973,
0.467863977,
0.2719114423,
-0.4376917481,
0.2471262515,
0.249018237,
0.3476606309,
0.2148309946,
0.6171348691,
-0.2693602145,
0.3619909286,
-0.0496586636,
-0.1750500053,
-0.0870358124,
0.0160286073,
0.3082602322,
0.0575043,
0.2213976234,
-0.2400892377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16820v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16820v1
|
Cross-lingual Contextualized Phrase Retrieval
| 2024-03-25T14:46:51 | 2024-03-25T14:46:51 |
Huayang Li, Deng Cai, Zhi Qu, Qu Cui, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Lemao Liu, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Phrase-level dense retrieval has shown many appealing characteristics in
downstream NLP tasks by leveraging the fine-grained information that phrases
offer. In our work, we propose a new task formulation of dense retrieval,
cross-lingual contextualized phrase retrieval, which aims to augment
cross-lingual applications by addressing polysemy using context information.
However, the lack of specific training data and models are the primary
challenges to achieve our goal. As a result, we extract pairs of cross-lingual
phrases using word alignment information automatically induced from parallel
sentences. Subsequently, we train our Cross-lingual Contextualized Phrase
Retriever (CCPR) using contrastive learning, which encourages the hidden
representations of phrases with similar contexts and semantics to align
closely. Comprehensive experiments on both the cross-lingual phrase retrieval
task and a downstream task, i.e, machine translation, demonstrate the
effectiveness of CCPR. On the phrase retrieval task, CCPR surpasses baselines
by a significant margin, achieving a top-1 accuracy that is at least 13 points
higher. When utilizing CCPR to augment the large-language-model-based
translator, it achieves average gains of 0.7 and 1.5 in BERTScore for
translations from X=>En and vice versa, respectively, on WMT16 dataset. Our
code and data are available at \url{https://github.com/ghrua/ccpr_release}.
|
[
-0.3294402361,
-0.6368821859,
0.3238699436,
0.2893365324,
-0.3760071695,
0.089184694,
-0.4271646738,
-0.4370512068,
0.2892690599,
0.5110622644,
-0.2349639684,
-0.3719017208,
-0.6597969532,
-0.0094166659,
-0.4554462433,
0.7294210196,
0.0929296464,
0.3925396502,
-0.1294514984,
-0.0451946482,
-0.558324039,
-0.6422066689,
-0.4141566753,
-0.3540897071,
0.6335827708,
0.5429518819,
0.7728514671,
0.388746202,
0.4806264043,
0.2334415019,
-0.3493304253,
0.0608686991,
-0.6803679466,
-0.0437100232,
-0.5190392733,
-0.3339425623,
-0.1077734604,
-0.1516879797,
0.5525408983,
0.9729366899,
0.0705283806,
-0.2092320025,
0.2599724829,
0.4849024713,
-0.7390416861,
-0.1097874492,
-0.8274528384,
0.3912000656,
-0.2015298158,
-0.3575145602,
-0.4058935046,
0.1039508805,
0.4801431,
-0.4913382828,
0.2146168947,
0.2389667183,
0.8145382404,
0.0596044436,
-0.4289942682,
-0.2607011497,
-0.267628938,
1.0486243963,
-0.505295217,
0.5610949993,
0.1424884796,
0.2010319233,
0.2444143295,
-0.9567770958,
-0.3483318388,
-0.1844123304,
-0.3647353351,
0.1952407062,
0.0321386345,
-0.2005925775,
0.1668508053,
0.6035606265,
-0.6448921561,
0.0092298388,
-0.2164834887,
-0.0814694986,
0.4926405251,
0.1496817768,
0.5573897362,
-0.2508876324,
-0.7978870273,
-0.1225933507,
-0.6117863655,
-0.0831216797,
-0.0072105387,
0.4957483113,
-0.2217869163,
0.7900494933,
-0.2946714163,
0.6055810452,
0.0924454927,
0.2245948464,
0.3233165145,
-0.7083120942,
-0.1122235283,
0.3170938492,
0.6994960308,
0.3861427009,
0.0941104814,
-0.5074381828,
-0.3007113039,
-0.2917056978,
0.1785900593,
-0.7600266933,
0.0030238889,
-0.0471174084,
-0.4535994828,
0.0770259574,
0.1468159705,
-0.7583143115,
-0.0041599036,
-0.5774125457,
0.3517638445,
-0.5219358206,
-0.0675630793,
0.2414720953,
-0.2990837097,
0.503443718,
-0.017974278,
-0.782769382,
0.3363583386,
0.8006948829,
0.8862925768,
-0.4976549745,
-0.2970936596,
-0.6080567241,
0.2447475642,
-0.3779048622,
0.3748350441,
-0.6649059653,
-0.4343678951,
-0.082897909,
0.0878127441,
-0.3029725254,
-0.7592630386,
0.5628068447,
-0.5220422745,
0.3249329925,
-0.5332456231,
-0.4746664166,
0.05597293,
0.2895758748,
-0.5646054745,
0.8880336285,
-0.1114991903,
-1.033262372,
0.1046848744,
-0.1721827686,
-0.5216147304,
0.0441212244,
-0.1169808507,
-0.0529427938,
0.2817359269,
0.3137944639,
0.4082789421,
-0.3166015446,
0.2383781672,
-0.2543136179,
-0.5356912613,
-0.0506601073,
-0.2269096971,
0.8310847878,
0.2811756432,
-0.3796950281,
-0.0804955959,
-0.2025521547,
0.131490171,
-0.0892806277,
-0.1927915066,
-0.6755607724,
-0.1579564661,
0.2592933774,
0.4741306603,
0.4964341819,
-0.6121658087,
-0.0313255675,
-0.396517545,
0.0419296212,
0.2998379469,
-0.2653919756,
0.5780655146,
-0.1648133993,
0.4440715313,
0.1100690067,
-0.1150262877,
0.0959774628,
-0.2162656486,
-0.458789289,
-0.1522580385,
0.3362633586,
0.7487848997,
-1.0156632662,
0.5043219924,
-0.4665917456,
-0.3762671351,
-0.294791162,
0.364064604,
0.7078406215,
0.6213194132,
0.7413253784,
-0.4212016165,
-0.5652061105,
-0.7861514091,
-0.2920257747,
0.4787830114,
0.045387581,
0.4060389102,
0.2542921007,
-0.2614367902,
0.864504993,
-0.6082992554,
-0.3764978051,
-0.6529483795,
0.3799651563,
-0.064538233,
0.6006265879,
0.4900423586,
-1.2250385284,
-0.8078809977,
0.2670562565,
-0.5214115977,
-0.3221689165,
0.0501901656,
-0.2939624786,
-0.0530482829,
0.8521922827,
-0.5202495456,
0.01030677,
0.6761437654,
-0.2712785006,
0.4732761681,
-0.0788031667,
0.0541155152,
-1.2677010298,
0.3601110876,
-0.0634618998,
-0.1638901532,
-0.4167840183,
0.175836727,
0.0652684271,
-0.1142464429,
-0.6787994504,
0.6712123156,
-0.5865113139,
-0.2867065668,
-0.3459301293,
0.4210651517,
0.0523137152,
0.3531450629,
0.3744286597,
0.9228528142,
0.3322313428,
-0.3652728498,
0.2361415327,
0.1421507597,
-0.2813797593,
0.5895480514,
-0.7405800819,
-0.1239605471,
-0.0776122063,
0.2167984098,
-0.7635858655,
0.0942432955,
-0.075592652,
-0.3403118849,
0.3750202954,
-0.010131848,
-0.4247021079,
0.1082805693,
-0.0009617303,
0.6302157044,
0.2539836764,
-0.6389895082,
0.3903897107,
0.4322185218,
-0.3106588423,
-0.8753583431,
-0.7125044465,
0.2235364765,
-0.0925767496,
-0.3510169983,
0.8544840217,
0.1020119712,
-0.1518546194,
0.0929887593,
-0.2006372064,
-0.1145431921,
-0.193370983,
-0.3898598552,
0.1294061393,
-0.1611200571,
-0.0545728281,
-0.0819399506,
-0.1345653832,
-0.0429893546,
-0.2731024921,
0.7623621821,
-0.1365775466,
-0.1020204425,
0.082487233,
0.5490845442,
0.1146577075,
-0.393674314,
0.4766530693,
1.1340911388,
-0.1966463774,
-0.0224180408,
-0.3366501629,
-0.0544848442,
-0.4053779244,
0.4132396877,
-0.5650259256,
-1.0667030811,
0.375851661,
0.0667589232,
-0.2799605727,
0.2383597642,
0.4201998115,
0.1961327642,
1.1218076944,
0.5809344649,
-0.2069444954,
0.5520059466,
-0.2301485538,
0.1150797904,
-1.0042369366,
-0.2269716114,
-0.4600370228,
-0.3964615464,
-0.5422174335,
-0.7709932923,
0.2103953809,
0.2891091108,
0.1010971144,
0.5282090902,
-0.3158076406,
0.3233352304,
0.5129905343,
0.1632701606,
0.1755888164,
-0.0852772743,
-0.6608650684,
-0.3432475924,
-0.699653089,
0.0535538457,
0.6517570615,
-0.1262775213,
0.8095075488,
0.0963670313,
0.6783005595,
0.0296036657,
-0.053933464,
-0.7712796926,
0.6593142152,
-0.6009019613,
-0.3749599755,
-0.0364573412,
-0.6757934093,
-0.9983589649,
0.5729406476,
-0.0610925592,
-0.5521494746,
0.2956839502,
-0.0376630314,
0.020073669,
0.0554706343,
-0.6420989037,
1.2239894867,
-0.6162441969,
-0.5847011209,
-0.3962971568,
-0.8863643408,
0.2866022587,
-0.0381943583,
-0.1761763692,
0.0506853461,
-0.3706201017,
0.2490351349,
-0.1815297455,
0.7224455476,
-0.0770736635,
-0.0286840796,
-0.036696393,
-0.1410596818,
0.2101895213,
-0.0854724124,
-0.0101681901,
0.1449859142,
-0.1000433564,
-0.5188602805,
-0.6670923233,
0.9973002076,
-0.5158725381,
-0.4979962707,
-0.386316061,
-0.8311896324,
-0.148778066,
0.3917325437,
0.2080816627,
0.340703547,
-0.1293607652,
0.6608231664,
0.8224520683,
-0.476529628,
0.2485668957,
0.3323732316,
-0.1446232945,
-0.5289719701,
0.8922618628,
-0.1106125936,
0.4553181827,
1.1141631603,
0.2322612405,
-0.4828570187,
-0.2906638086,
-0.2063101381,
0.1771783531,
-0.4857493639,
-0.1026097834,
-0.6547159553,
-0.1285191923,
-0.6295820475,
-0.3242158592,
-0.2644674778,
-0.4688928425,
-0.1361473799,
0.1646981835,
-0.1975107342,
0.180920884,
-0.0852721781,
0.1482014954,
-0.8407644629,
0.4457292259,
0.0774194524,
0.1291963905,
-0.2434401363,
-0.4714336395,
-0.3286402524,
-0.0886475295,
-0.0949084163,
-0.560721159,
0.7251959443,
0.1296992302,
0.6483640671,
0.1740619093,
0.0669754222,
0.9516712427,
-0.5313423276,
0.7009644508,
0.1845482886,
-1.0118172169,
0.4402834475,
-0.0677972287,
0.5466915965,
0.6056415439,
0.7491919994,
-0.7084405422,
-0.0503594279,
-0.3762329519,
-1.2002235651,
0.5613692999,
-0.1014386714,
0.200789541,
-0.0677894503,
0.0794915855,
-0.1234914735,
0.2343432158,
-0.7031071782,
0.0294664465,
-0.1278128922,
-0.3599818349,
-0.3505150676,
-0.2170093209,
0.0108782379,
-0.2230935842,
0.6235649586,
-0.2997225821,
0.0372290909,
0.3900895417,
-0.3863443434,
0.2206718326,
0.3763686717,
0.3106763661,
0.4926248491,
-0.1339878738,
0.276273638,
0.1807743162,
-0.2106465548,
-0.259174943,
0.4503336549,
-0.2177338302,
0.1802711636,
0.1420534253,
0.5233052969,
0.7014431953,
-0.9839575291,
0.7178900242,
0.1408542395,
0.06422095,
-0.1847417355,
-0.2466202527,
0.0691771433,
0.114889957,
0.279976368,
-0.2849617302,
0.3783885539,
-0.4767345786,
0.5539611578,
0.766946733,
-0.6233165264,
-0.0670828745,
0.6092857122,
-0.024709696,
0.1588939577,
0.5042073727,
-0.0675143898,
-0.6907631159,
0.2458956838,
0.7207396626,
0.753007412,
-0.0659179315,
0.0054726759,
0.2861466706,
0.0712368414,
-0.1703339815,
0.2544152141,
-0.3109223247,
-0.6609476805,
-0.611686945,
-0.6211391687,
-0.3679043651,
-0.1882416308,
-0.7347907424,
0.3521530926,
-0.0019226331,
0.1657877117,
-0.2628779411,
0.1457274705,
-0.3720944822,
0.2693856955,
0.1858944148,
1.0455946922,
-0.5633787513,
0.9503368735,
0.785130024,
-0.4090416729,
-0.6687848568,
0.0395603441,
-0.1704828441,
-0.7263880968,
0.8276768923,
0.2247212529,
-0.1824108213,
0.0046354625,
-0.2544750571,
-0.8659848571,
1.0534145832,
0.2777090669,
-0.613591969,
-0.2647575736,
0.3553863168,
0.6201245785,
-0.465963304,
0.1005704775,
0.2786600888,
0.2695215344,
0.1474770308,
-0.9076766372,
0.0952670053,
-0.2689197958,
0.3448756933,
0.0752780288,
-0.5239524841,
0.852648437,
0.0394685455,
-0.0416029915,
0.1150110513,
0.65984267,
0.1248891801,
0.1384961754,
0.5637231469,
0.8128197193,
0.1528921425,
-0.1154202074,
1.0686080456,
-0.6045747995,
0.304546982,
1.2883994579,
-0.28434062,
1.0398342609,
0.7332317829,
0.4450244009,
0.4089613259,
0.4085984826,
0.1282473356,
0.6843791008,
-0.0622378588,
-0.2082352489,
-0.2852471769,
-0.3734858334,
-0.2036610991,
0.3856477439,
0.4016266763,
-0.4933259189,
-0.2454905212,
0.0647083074,
-0.1512046307,
0.2090052217,
-0.249665454,
0.6798281074,
0.3913857341,
-0.8730708361,
0.5876946449,
-0.005004955,
0.7807215452,
-0.5251243711,
-0.0062142313,
-0.210005939,
0.3896888196,
-0.13732858,
-0.7134823799,
0.4496135414,
-0.2364209443,
0.1145062223,
-0.5288997293,
0.7038257718,
-0.9716752172,
-0.2854189575,
0.7087615728,
0.5752906799,
-0.0236938503,
0.0456198417,
-1.0534631014,
0.0391781293,
-0.0473669358,
0.0377232805,
0.4103709459,
0.6036465764,
0.0415268838,
0.3486371636,
0.4477420151,
0.2259024233,
0.0834780708,
0.2458561957,
0.8160257339,
-0.7125350237,
-0.4416235685,
-0.5163627863,
0.2510987818,
-0.2166451216,
-0.1977362037,
0.8398967981,
0.9274445176,
1.3273211718,
0.0333264619,
0.4996555448,
-0.270821631,
0.6000062823,
-0.6113740206,
0.2473174483,
-0.9241529703,
0.2848100364,
-0.3220946193,
-0.9245648384,
-0.1770895869,
0.3266975582,
-0.3616438806,
-0.1021165177,
0.7637501955,
0.8365798593,
-0.5185325742,
-0.1568161249,
0.2347858697,
-0.0206561908,
-0.0163042266,
0.6270421743,
0.5884329081,
-0.3378394544,
0.8288437724,
-0.4830961823,
0.0799326003,
-0.2933482528,
-0.6548292041,
-0.5618367195,
-0.3905189335,
-0.0210212208,
-0.1892860979,
0.2140250355,
0.801122427,
0.6085924506,
-0.7371883988,
-0.4232717454,
-0.1114116982,
0.0769042745,
-0.4377001822,
-0.3178352714,
0.098172158,
-0.8961051106,
-1.0786390305,
0.5070205927,
0.0554358438,
-0.1235460788,
-0.1016178951,
-0.1496773064,
-0.536642015,
-0.2117157429,
0.7404085398,
0.1194184497,
-0.586961031,
-0.2515645921,
0.1334896982,
-0.5288251638,
-0.0253064223,
1.08829391,
-0.5062209368,
0.3204920888,
0.8250800967,
1.0742659569,
0.5714091063,
0.2270344496,
0.8191003799,
-0.9253423214,
0.1769123673,
0.2406968474,
0.477458328,
0.5342386961,
-0.239860028,
0.6015428901,
0.3236744404,
-0.3994777799,
-0.5529434085,
0.2116629928,
-1.1470896006,
-0.4481174946,
1.1259223223,
-0.2151009738,
-0.0656708777,
-0.0265878253,
-0.2176420242,
0.142943874,
-0.087638095,
0.503475368,
0.4818708003,
-0.0527834669,
-0.2892104387,
-0.3594888747,
0.3614124656,
0.925324142,
-0.6009289622,
-0.0888115987,
0.5365875363,
0.134544462,
0.2967565656,
0.3934229612,
-0.339073509,
0.214808017,
-0.1451991051,
-0.0140740331,
0.3154720366,
-0.2051169723,
-0.2380446345,
0.2194260657,
-0.3017869592,
0.0390883759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16804v1
|
TEI2GO: A Multilingual Approach for Fast Temporal Expression Identification
| 2024-03-25T14:23:03 | 2024-03-25T14:23:03 |
Hugo Sousa, Ricardo Campos, Alípio Jorge
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Temporal expression identification is crucial for understanding texts written
in natural language. Although highly effective systems such as HeidelTime
exist, their limited runtime performance hampers adoption in large-scale
applications and production environments. In this paper, we introduce the
TEI2GO models, matching HeidelTime's effectiveness but with significantly
improved runtime, supporting six languages, and achieving state-of-the-art
results in four of them. To train the TEI2GO models, we used a combination of
manually annotated reference corpus and developed ``Professor HeidelTime'', a
comprehensive weakly labeled corpus of news texts annotated with HeidelTime.
This corpus comprises a total of $138,069$ documents (over six languages) with
$1,050,921$ temporal expressions, the largest open-source annotated dataset for
temporal expression identification to date. By describing how the models were
produced, we aim to encourage the research community to further explore,
refine, and extend the set of models to additional languages and domains. Code,
annotations, and models are openly available for community exploration and use.
The models are conveniently on HuggingFace for seamless integration and
application.
|
[
0.1762260199,
-0.6455658674,
0.5568296909,
0.4196287394,
-0.1829752773,
0.3624742329,
-0.3756263554,
-0.9050970674,
-0.1106558889,
0.0397827215,
-0.3480948508,
-0.323138833,
-0.7857307792,
-0.1092527434,
-0.4439081252,
0.7543338537,
-0.1080998555,
-0.0377444848,
0.0540055521,
-0.3345396519,
0.16810745,
-0.1737208068,
-0.5225076675,
-0.5625422001,
0.6709743142,
0.1236606836,
0.3656904995,
0.5356552005,
0.1472366899,
0.2452929169,
-0.2563940585,
0.0303704925,
-0.2409376651,
-0.1192298084,
-0.1692040414,
-0.1122476608,
-0.2138730288,
0.2315168083,
0.558739543,
0.5803776383,
-0.1549367905,
0.4184072912,
-0.3697707057,
0.2648175955,
-0.6252667308,
0.27308622,
-0.3191148341,
0.0806519464,
-0.6119971275,
0.0238714442,
-0.2606094182,
-0.3999589682,
0.1650405675,
-0.6795860529,
-0.0033831347,
-0.198596105,
1.1863228083,
-0.0665040538,
-0.7869886756,
0.0248427503,
-0.7261093855,
0.4943599701,
-0.8962925076,
0.4948533177,
0.0647106618,
0.4062258005,
0.1646943539,
-0.8751437664,
-0.52285254,
-0.0390319452,
-0.254455179,
0.203745842,
0.1871503741,
-0.4864395261,
0.3866425753,
0.2351561189,
-0.6629515886,
0.2275460511,
-0.6117649674,
-0.2064002454,
0.376406461,
-0.0654820427,
0.2461899221,
-0.1848782748,
-0.6975608468,
0.2630335093,
-0.3912930787,
-0.0237133391,
0.4906466007,
0.1478424519,
-0.2920923829,
0.3311586678,
-0.3540955186,
0.2898094356,
-0.2852938175,
-0.1937080324,
0.2501780093,
-0.0566303805,
0.0183342919,
-0.0822555125,
1.059261322,
0.2468646318,
0.392503649,
-0.3703955412,
-0.2397057116,
0.1035549343,
-0.0035424836,
-1.0065282583,
0.0911699906,
0.2094810754,
-0.2198142558,
-0.1896976084,
0.0239969585,
-1.1190630198,
-0.3947347105,
-0.1234705299,
0.3155156374,
-0.4561054409,
-0.7048227191,
-0.2456515878,
-0.2367589772,
0.0711345598,
0.0847703591,
-0.5004684329,
0.1631479412,
0.740624547,
0.908029139,
-0.1276921034,
-0.3379943073,
-0.7345191836,
0.2907243371,
-0.4685299695,
0.5941242576,
-0.6236068606,
-0.1896673441,
0.1609377116,
0.0623813458,
-0.225163728,
-0.2719896138,
0.4982182384,
-0.9456883073,
0.8005768061,
0.1268222034,
-0.4859668016,
-0.1500159204,
0.1752595603,
-0.924854815,
1.3176119328,
0.6128525138,
-0.6087763906,
0.0958310515,
-0.8754689097,
-0.5200453401,
0.284581989,
0.2043203562,
-0.4391494691,
0.3387974799,
-0.0511871949,
0.0151428925,
-0.631298244,
0.4871782362,
-0.0564612001,
-0.059948016,
0.0946611613,
-0.2750787139,
0.9951444268,
0.480135709,
-0.4180475473,
-0.0312536731,
-0.7152564526,
0.113096267,
0.2156535983,
-0.3067912757,
-0.2423333973,
-0.0836795121,
0.4875514805,
0.2833972275,
0.4658938944,
-0.6822267175,
0.0843432099,
-0.1410367042,
0.5780051947,
0.4574292898,
-0.0333118252,
0.2605269849,
0.0615218356,
0.4744434655,
0.1233305261,
0.3446365893,
-0.3775908053,
-0.4951895773,
-0.2524085641,
-0.0947796479,
0.5232402086,
0.7951949835,
-0.6590098739,
-0.1597389579,
-0.5043261051,
-0.5043500662,
-0.3884983063,
0.0746529326,
0.5595315099,
0.7350332737,
0.3597688079,
0.051179938,
-0.1884257048,
-0.9591389894,
-0.5177782178,
-0.288485229,
-0.0227154531,
0.1998739988,
0.3304800391,
-0.3604496717,
0.72719872,
-0.2229925692,
-0.0061287582,
0.0381655693,
0.5932048559,
0.1025629863,
0.1755155027,
0.7843924165,
-0.824572742,
-0.5119128823,
0.1961045116,
-0.6540970206,
-0.5821424127,
-0.1093026772,
-0.1276449114,
0.5146996379,
0.459298104,
-0.3671898842,
0.3341294527,
0.6402534842,
-0.6372267604,
0.0921611711,
0.0166316573,
0.2055263072,
-1.1903939247,
0.302641809,
0.2768763006,
-0.4751144052,
-0.5776507258,
0.4549177289,
0.3445477188,
-0.2222766727,
-0.6916130781,
1.0497325659,
-0.5345591903,
-0.0416729823,
-0.045736935,
0.015282427,
0.0597591624,
0.42281124,
0.0698386729,
0.8042600751,
0.1148342565,
-0.3028175533,
0.1598810107,
-0.0883113891,
-0.4650650918,
0.4120052159,
-0.7948819399,
0.2654143572,
-0.03347601,
-0.1188273951,
-0.6329722404,
-0.4542920291,
0.1426116526,
-0.4679657519,
0.4108494818,
-0.4477740526,
-0.5977262259,
-0.144387722,
-0.1919914037,
0.3430971503,
0.4870645702,
-0.7636049986,
1.1882373095,
0.2503803074,
-0.0518624708,
-0.4458420277,
-0.4970650971,
0.3403724134,
-0.3549309373,
-0.4476914108,
0.683757782,
0.0402495004,
-0.242150709,
0.0039196326,
-0.020257622,
-0.2866681218,
0.296872735,
-0.0070884456,
0.2566963434,
-0.0954987481,
0.138804242,
0.0978171453,
-0.3160149753,
-0.2365759462,
-0.213504374,
0.400044024,
-0.0104208412,
0.1210096702,
-0.546880424,
0.8306912184,
0.7314513326,
-0.5052999854,
0.4835154116,
1.3482909203,
-0.733682096,
0.3014537096,
-0.4609385133,
0.0774101391,
-0.4256041348,
0.1931041181,
-0.3476749659,
-0.6821472645,
0.3228489459,
-0.2935643196,
0.2955903411,
0.6860691309,
0.5637245774,
-0.0289055426,
0.6679707766,
0.5557661057,
0.0253065843,
0.7793129086,
0.0178923607,
0.00317837,
-0.7726873755,
-0.3509407341,
-0.5360177159,
-0.3254314959,
-0.6193683147,
-0.2685616612,
0.5387121439,
0.0871256739,
-0.2968458533,
0.2417306453,
-0.2200172096,
0.3833462,
0.7203809619,
0.0093818791,
0.0489415936,
-0.0045114825,
0.1645430624,
0.0056117475,
-0.4183588922,
-0.5407577753,
0.6245192289,
0.3191663623,
0.4525741041,
0.6902361512,
0.4591884315,
0.3355697691,
0.5296120048,
-0.5333212018,
0.3414782584,
-0.3077146709,
-0.813574791,
0.0690195337,
-0.4450685382,
-0.7123231292,
-0.2157731205,
-0.2195430547,
-1.1543531418,
-0.0845015123,
-0.0646250844,
-0.3940252364,
0.0509689897,
-1.051014781,
1.0366095304,
-0.5025385022,
-0.753798604,
-0.1797002405,
-0.6214344501,
0.0721362904,
0.0730009302,
0.2471213043,
-0.4565673172,
-0.3128252029,
0.9233806133,
-0.2647881806,
0.8635984659,
-0.341889292,
-0.00880141,
0.3308899105,
0.0647979528,
0.427714467,
0.3815593719,
-0.1764962226,
0.5923585296,
0.2931204438,
-0.6289602518,
-0.2996548116,
0.9228820205,
-0.7988162041,
-0.3751215041,
-0.4291294515,
-0.2534106374,
-0.1277990192,
0.3781591654,
0.315897882,
0.652623713,
-0.0323659219,
-0.157921806,
0.3414487541,
-0.1717823595,
0.8749465942,
0.6115785837,
-0.1581060141,
-0.4832798839,
0.7236894369,
-0.0182340201,
0.1122610718,
0.5403240323,
0.4985978901,
-0.3688332736,
-0.0460774601,
-0.6976451874,
0.2811866105,
-0.3575562239,
-0.046431955,
-0.8197187781,
0.1571659148,
-0.5676728487,
0.2840904593,
-0.3189451694,
-0.7783218622,
-0.3028483391,
0.0643864051,
0.6225235462,
0.3773215115,
0.1776220649,
0.6279891133,
-1.0348598957,
0.5071415305,
0.1519131362,
0.5740258098,
-0.5659449697,
-0.4191883206,
-0.3785766363,
-0.3086462915,
0.0152685754,
-1.2997938395,
0.3864971101,
0.5628669858,
0.3282052577,
0.2251866907,
-0.1146467626,
0.4194642305,
-0.6435755491,
0.8822354078,
-0.1015122309,
-1.0594906807,
0.3766009212,
-0.3006110191,
0.3567382693,
0.2457837462,
0.6117361784,
-0.762462616,
0.1208017915,
-0.5385509729,
-1.0352576971,
0.649911046,
-0.1575483531,
0.1264573187,
-0.0600745194,
0.619669497,
0.2057023197,
0.1043639183,
-0.4808456302,
0.2317459434,
-0.1469359994,
-0.4583739042,
0.1632131636,
-0.5034283996,
-0.2019445002,
0.2025440335,
0.7650507689,
-0.5049623847,
0.5447416902,
-0.0697902218,
-0.3379076123,
-0.1815327704,
0.2033877671,
0.4338880777,
0.4611622691,
-0.0582092591,
-0.0196732394,
-0.172800988,
-0.0245084558,
-0.2619145811,
0.5177740455,
-0.1859560907,
0.2400181741,
0.5581837296,
0.8452890515,
-0.0498891883,
-0.7235383391,
0.4319833815,
-0.0802970082,
0.1458206922,
-0.6174187064,
-0.0566203222,
0.2203104496,
0.6603214741,
0.3354718089,
-0.3658638,
0.2628099024,
-0.5799337029,
-0.1244163662,
0.1027129367,
-0.308095932,
-0.5714375377,
1.0037013292,
0.1782473326,
-0.6471223235,
0.7827416062,
-0.2353405505,
-0.8480250835,
0.640235424,
0.3156591952,
1.0654197931,
-0.317153573,
0.0116893454,
0.5854680538,
0.2181404084,
-0.014207677,
0.4634903967,
0.0633747578,
-0.4605946243,
-0.4520512819,
-0.4072088003,
-0.2414520681,
-0.0149672115,
-0.5766898394,
0.2847782373,
-0.3560200036,
-0.4155976176,
0.2435710579,
-0.0177130792,
-0.7314170599,
0.0739398524,
0.343015641,
1.0165857077,
-1.0288168192,
0.833584249,
0.8670420647,
-0.307605803,
-0.2345468551,
0.1247231141,
0.23188667,
-0.4614247382,
0.5303007364,
0.3237876892,
0.1168264821,
-0.0018233526,
-0.257576257,
-0.6347392797,
1.1360416412,
0.1912607849,
-0.7236979604,
-0.2383534014,
-0.2092374265,
0.6031306982,
-0.150260523,
0.6131734252,
0.4508620501,
0.628626585,
-0.1523969471,
-0.8786121011,
-0.1368318051,
-0.5101441741,
0.0440022014,
0.5066062808,
-0.9040260911,
0.6969084144,
-0.336058259,
-0.5180419087,
0.253438592,
0.6281245947,
-0.2920712233,
0.5753157735,
0.4912082255,
0.3891393244,
0.704085052,
-0.4617811441,
1.1235433817,
-0.6212369204,
0.4327264428,
1.1560814381,
-0.2954357862,
0.7174996734,
0.4398214817,
0.1332466602,
0.5215725303,
0.6342696548,
0.3367796242,
0.3414596915,
-0.299399972,
-0.4370210767,
-0.2332708538,
-0.3349782825,
-0.0347668864,
0.1992197186,
0.5657975078,
-0.1336495727,
-0.2323906124,
-0.0706863925,
0.3692592978,
0.1174037308,
0.2539048791,
0.7165394425,
-0.2308689058,
-0.5043004751,
0.2431512475,
0.3520115316,
0.4935736656,
-0.5960214734,
0.1051469445,
-0.3501582444,
0.150574863,
-0.0564473234,
-0.6568719745,
0.3751131594,
0.2631580532,
-0.0098023843,
-0.1972848773,
0.3872265816,
-0.6535600424,
-0.520403862,
0.405784905,
0.5708435178,
-0.1217486411,
0.15691109,
-0.6095292568,
0.0711953789,
-0.3133654594,
-0.6341150999,
-0.0242139883,
0.5756233335,
-0.7923446894,
0.2208122462,
0.345310986,
-0.1602795124,
-0.0159380715,
0.2647436559,
0.5032845736,
-0.7523756027,
-0.3063127697,
-0.6558741331,
0.4838302135,
-0.317673564,
-0.5286172628,
0.1007439271,
0.6042404175,
0.583486557,
0.1571409106,
0.6881588101,
-0.3170298934,
0.7374076843,
-0.5647320747,
0.4414707124,
-0.6991559267,
0.1664851308,
0.0779529139,
-0.5707770586,
-0.2053452134,
0.1125703529,
-0.1186234504,
0.1895785183,
0.6326438785,
0.5082531571,
-0.1803907156,
-0.2942946553,
0.0228723194,
0.2128814608,
0.7200493813,
0.7898051739,
0.6580634117,
-0.5884962678,
0.2982494831,
-0.4869210124,
-0.3529182076,
-0.2785694599,
-1.2597234249,
-0.8160710931,
-0.6171480417,
-0.6736594439,
-0.3462123275,
0.3095923662,
1.1658264399,
0.6931635737,
-0.4887232482,
0.0355885103,
0.5519070029,
-0.2037528157,
-0.311193198,
-0.2233796865,
0.3401087523,
0.0506244078,
-1.218346715,
0.4347888231,
0.1804885417,
-0.1255953759,
0.0149597079,
0.0704144165,
-0.2616884112,
0.1423360258,
0.6548127532,
0.4931456149,
-0.5265803337,
-0.3451414108,
0.2041543126,
-0.1367454082,
-0.1258636266,
0.8682767153,
-0.8780781627,
0.4210824966,
0.6438167095,
0.7715394497,
0.6087507606,
-0.1165954694,
0.2900603414,
-0.8180677891,
0.2727909386,
0.044515688,
0.533465445,
0.539314568,
-0.3477579057,
0.9196509123,
0.5836749077,
-0.0237212796,
-0.5049214363,
0.3150609434,
-0.9228707552,
-0.3100351095,
1.3042600155,
-0.1233451143,
-0.4599863887,
0.2953914702,
0.0259258989,
0.3837202489,
-0.5327937007,
0.7886975408,
0.5302590132,
0.3059591949,
-0.3442940116,
-0.7355940342,
0.004321136,
0.0882473737,
-0.9053714275,
-0.1334723979,
0.6447600722,
0.3224787414,
0.2955557406,
0.464519769,
-0.4360102117,
0.398578763,
-0.3693954647,
0.1576469988,
-0.27974087,
-0.4633588791,
-0.0951349214,
0.17590639,
-0.0259065554,
0.0426341556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16792v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16792v3
|
Iterative Refinement of Project-Level Code Context for Precise Code Generation with Compiler Feedback
| 2024-03-25T14:07:27 | 2024-06-11T02:38:20 |
Zhangqian Bi, Yao Wan, Zheng Wang, Hongyu Zhang, Batu Guan, Fangxin Lu, Zili Zhang, Yulei Sui, Hai Jin, Xuanhua Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable progress in automated code
generation. Yet, LLM-generated code may contain errors in API usage, class,
data structure, or missing project-specific information. As much of this
project-specific context cannot fit into the prompts of LLMs, we must find ways
to allow the model to explore the project-level code context. We present
CoCoGen, a new code generation approach that uses compiler feedback to improve
the LLM-generated code. CoCoGen first leverages static analysis to identify
mismatches between the generated code and the project's context. It then
iteratively aligns and fixes the identified errors using information extracted
from the code repository. We integrate CoCoGen with two representative LLMs,
i.e., GPT-3.5-Turbo and Code Llama (13B), and apply it to Python code
generation. Experimental results show that CoCoGen significantly improves the
vanilla LLMs by over 80% in generating code dependent on the project context
and consistently outperforms the existing retrieval-based code generation
baselines.
|
[
-0.3132897317,
-0.4848440886,
0.3155084848,
0.5221982002,
-0.1449820101,
0.298327893,
-0.6144451499,
-0.3094500005,
-0.0080004577,
0.4919504821,
-0.4656510949,
-0.8036476374,
-0.2414069325,
0.3023691773,
-0.4072093666,
0.7899832726,
-0.3409076035,
-0.2108119279,
-0.4596835375,
0.2462239116,
-0.5891614556,
-0.4947187006,
-0.1299269646,
-0.2097163945,
0.3176218867,
0.809617877,
0.0248018634,
0.461663723,
0.3097475469,
0.2665508389,
0.0291775335,
0.257294178,
-0.5908231139,
0.1474326402,
0.0538114645,
-0.3050780892,
-0.1887012422,
-0.322080344,
0.4506269395,
0.4244881272,
-0.1507979184,
0.3298243582,
0.3057081997,
0.5002214909,
-0.7371942997,
0.4372297227,
-0.6681954265,
-0.0154036311,
-0.0468304493,
-0.6569602489,
-0.4572815299,
-0.5032320023,
-0.1020503044,
-0.3002075851,
0.5400308371,
-0.0997868702,
0.6115394831,
0.3890338242,
-0.0325764567,
-0.4014178514,
-0.56034863,
0.8757195473,
-0.8412607908,
0.0139439916,
-0.0330998264,
0.0159968771,
-0.3616614938,
-0.9310379028,
-0.3435548842,
-0.6772928834,
-0.0135820862,
-0.1647853553,
0.067820847,
-0.086721234,
0.2947694659,
0.4197627306,
-0.435633719,
-0.0417187922,
-0.6317225695,
-0.2333502024,
0.607935667,
0.1237543449,
0.1309095174,
-0.1230395064,
-0.1658002436,
0.0938354209,
-1.1396169662,
-0.1545096487,
0.3065515757,
0.3627362549,
0.11559055,
0.5389488339,
-0.2988458276,
0.7642251253,
0.0183739886,
0.1030774191,
0.305943042,
-0.3083458543,
-0.0584812686,
0.4018188715,
0.5605990291,
0.4681561589,
0.1736862361,
-0.0300574265,
-0.1950347126,
0.2982789278,
0.4696265757,
-0.9231597185,
-0.2562250495,
0.4561989009,
-0.1958470643,
-0.6236233115,
0.0452036187,
-0.4705862403,
-0.2644813061,
-0.3191255033,
-0.2980479598,
-0.0960507169,
-0.1516651958,
0.0175004862,
-0.0580842309,
0.2562365234,
0.3497529626,
-0.619135201,
-0.0417799875,
0.6653253436,
0.6736313701,
-0.0642598718,
-0.1010953262,
-0.617442131,
0.1016763449,
-0.569350183,
0.7800958753,
-0.5276669264,
-0.4587084055,
0.2185422778,
-0.2972417772,
0.2542193234,
-0.8568478227,
0.1370852292,
-0.2877754867,
-0.0271663405,
-0.2712385952,
-0.4148117304,
0.2366352975,
0.3698883951,
-0.326248616,
1.0847065449,
0.2993801236,
-0.7808132768,
0.528265059,
-0.5414546728,
-0.3978921771,
0.1307627261,
-0.3996650577,
-0.4189221263,
0.3793523014,
0.1473831981,
0.0990118608,
-0.4410014153,
0.4534402788,
-0.2354410142,
-0.5281729102,
0.1197765842,
-0.0753728077,
0.4974262714,
0.4218012691,
-0.4769273698,
0.3755425513,
-0.8335079551,
0.3207142949,
-0.0597018041,
-0.6794626117,
0.2381618321,
0.1398520619,
0.0556146614,
0.1770713627,
0.2873726189,
-0.4696746469,
0.5261752009,
-0.2584323287,
0.5659941435,
0.595241487,
0.0234019663,
0.2242512256,
-0.1394673586,
0.4839639068,
-0.1236419007,
-0.0646630004,
-0.3351868689,
-0.3930022418,
-0.8587756157,
-0.100021489,
0.2543517351,
0.3005123436,
-0.5785341263,
0.3652107716,
-0.0527888834,
-0.1396399289,
-0.1138999313,
0.5178918839,
0.3011907041,
0.4558289647,
0.1220167279,
-0.5588827729,
-0.8048384786,
-0.6656628251,
0.0245506093,
-0.318241626,
0.0098546688,
0.2718207836,
0.3425475955,
-0.6074488759,
1.2182182074,
-0.567219913,
0.160753876,
-0.198474139,
0.2354468703,
0.1472666562,
0.6789575815,
0.3960068822,
-0.4824254513,
-0.2874772549,
0.0180890094,
-0.3504876792,
-0.6224954724,
0.0117929038,
-0.0432145372,
0.0798047632,
0.7817686796,
-0.1455830783,
0.2580491602,
0.4761552513,
-0.003251791,
0.658579886,
-0.1762764454,
-0.0560740791,
-0.9965012074,
0.4456294179,
-0.2864715159,
-0.1803046018,
-0.4160420597,
0.4283899665,
0.2509748936,
-0.1325358748,
-0.4434617758,
0.3435061574,
-0.5035300851,
-0.0728512034,
-0.4701822698,
0.0439951457,
-0.0472563207,
0.302847892,
0.0977206156,
0.8496339321,
0.5774493814,
-0.6555793881,
0.4473018944,
-0.1491189599,
-0.4369932115,
0.160958603,
-0.5532310605,
0.4078886807,
0.0908174515,
0.3745864928,
-0.8915826082,
-0.480142802,
0.1242521033,
-0.3468716741,
0.3812179565,
-0.1408781707,
-0.5973953605,
-0.5750058293,
-0.3969742954,
0.4429501891,
0.4619555771,
-0.5847922564,
0.212754637,
-0.027310187,
-0.1413474828,
-0.673142612,
-0.6212038398,
0.2512803376,
0.0356635414,
-0.5719218254,
0.2436623424,
-0.2688382864,
-0.2721533179,
-0.156369403,
-0.3748275042,
-0.0660801902,
0.0964288116,
0.2337470204,
0.2006366551,
-0.2425612807,
-0.1484280825,
0.0192689523,
-0.1046074703,
-0.0238596089,
-0.5161659718,
0.8022356033,
-0.2711062431,
-0.3181518912,
-0.1031797826,
0.1163727716,
0.4711858332,
-0.4005610943,
0.267118305,
0.317953825,
-0.2300443202,
-0.5413278341,
-0.55348593,
0.0442741178,
-0.4790548682,
0.2746689618,
-0.2651621103,
-0.9653083682,
0.5094162822,
-0.4093913734,
0.2180932015,
0.2556604147,
0.9326637983,
0.3566562533,
0.9789693952,
0.8762632012,
-0.0880732313,
0.4425985813,
-0.4694087207,
0.2279628664,
-0.6985026002,
-0.2662389874,
-0.6934190392,
0.0441299342,
-0.549228251,
-0.5697901249,
0.0399126075,
0.3735554218,
-0.0359155759,
0.6510441899,
-0.6790118814,
0.595228076,
0.5167173147,
-0.1140453666,
0.1924664378,
0.0167631768,
-0.3304871321,
0.4338635206,
-0.8281029463,
-0.4820204675,
0.9299474359,
0.1301607341,
0.8600411415,
-0.0985506475,
1.01633811,
0.0987848938,
0.8589535952,
-0.5095410943,
0.3136982918,
0.2030970752,
-0.3178724945,
0.2131545395,
-0.638052702,
-0.6161475182,
-0.1340647489,
0.2484591007,
-0.7384553552,
0.225460887,
0.4377243221,
-0.3518608809,
-0.1743877083,
-0.578073442,
0.7318490744,
-0.0037163247,
-0.5150721669,
-0.1814610213,
-0.3111330569,
0.3812437356,
-0.2228069901,
0.0402321853,
-0.0049846652,
0.1058556587,
0.1212002262,
-0.7421482801,
0.774100244,
-0.0441946909,
-0.6193273664,
0.7675927877,
0.1741282195,
0.5108017325,
0.3370365202,
-0.1192805544,
-0.0115212929,
-0.2850563228,
-0.3788052201,
-0.4119550884,
1.0714949369,
-0.4038036466,
-0.6732911468,
-0.1917888671,
-0.6990332007,
-0.1941428334,
0.2190140933,
0.5623380542,
0.5052453279,
-0.0297033675,
0.1497874856,
0.3655382395,
-0.504578948,
0.3193595111,
0.3467191756,
-0.3151418269,
-0.2911533713,
0.8870908618,
-0.3710316122,
0.0907577425,
0.1036757156,
0.0504655987,
-0.1596072018,
-0.4340465665,
-0.521620512,
0.0239255242,
-0.6660473943,
-0.3923885226,
-0.1357937008,
-0.1562935561,
-0.4302203059,
-0.4652179778,
-0.4236625433,
-0.2721312344,
-0.2822226882,
0.0480047651,
-0.0191037636,
0.8221083879,
0.125459075,
0.0918739513,
-0.7792273164,
0.0185098834,
0.0703388974,
0.442923367,
-0.2606247962,
-0.0709829107,
-0.2684057653,
-0.142745927,
-0.420165807,
-0.684669733,
0.2884997427,
0.0054964377,
0.3458746374,
0.2912040651,
0.0320824832,
0.7965731025,
-0.4889306128,
0.9465023279,
0.1673228741,
-1.1061499119,
0.6636875868,
-0.1751734316,
0.4940421879,
0.4608740211,
-0.2324122936,
-0.4262687266,
-0.8022947311,
-0.4343160391,
-0.9913061857,
0.6099365354,
0.3575269878,
0.1890038401,
-0.1843589991,
0.6114490032,
-0.0947926193,
0.4480347037,
-0.6472553015,
0.0725413039,
-0.1809515506,
-0.198394835,
0.0150226979,
-0.1888298541,
-0.162824899,
-0.057590384,
0.3485066891,
-0.4457341135,
0.3732075989,
0.1713840365,
-0.2743922174,
-0.4645070732,
0.2167103738,
0.8419470191,
1.1019212008,
-0.245892331,
0.1470781565,
0.144926846,
-0.1689040661,
0.0833575949,
-0.1821948439,
-0.0604935549,
-0.0245340336,
0.496814549,
0.4238422513,
-0.0176486857,
-0.9991539121,
0.5526370406,
-0.0090312473,
-0.1697967649,
-0.2558403909,
0.3487803042,
-0.1368649751,
0.1596555561,
0.2455624193,
0.0978251696,
0.0812669322,
-0.548604846,
0.4099188149,
0.2689476013,
-0.311699152,
-0.0142062623,
0.6471790075,
0.350921154,
-0.0196172558,
0.7108560801,
-0.1443220377,
-0.7144785523,
0.8628026247,
0.7712069154,
1.0228676796,
0.0118084485,
0.0739651248,
0.531916976,
0.2312054932,
-0.1440262198,
0.3075699806,
-0.4481315613,
-0.3970437944,
-0.7904619575,
-0.6137419939,
-0.3644472957,
-0.0505531989,
-0.4724530578,
0.5129864812,
-0.734469533,
0.028862793,
-0.6533135772,
-0.0570736937,
-0.4131588042,
0.0998245031,
0.3104835749,
1.0293009281,
-0.5320469737,
0.8205170631,
0.6125534773,
-0.2846491337,
-0.7785465121,
0.3195181489,
-0.0644738302,
-0.6319283843,
0.8049624562,
0.4484875202,
-0.1229317039,
-0.1409865469,
-0.836830914,
-0.7958648205,
0.9915442467,
0.4691199064,
-0.8748323917,
0.1494140625,
0.1278829575,
0.5931750536,
-0.5117173195,
0.1166364551,
0.4684439301,
0.2269133627,
0.1403820813,
-0.8420058489,
0.0503136516,
-0.4747346938,
0.4730885029,
0.0989649594,
-0.5586939454,
0.6742709875,
-0.4253288209,
-0.1629868448,
0.3770487309,
0.5967170596,
0.5753740072,
0.0491040424,
0.2018350959,
0.3507063687,
0.6961811185,
-0.1006389037,
1.1637091637,
-0.9131973982,
0.6220738292,
0.9753531814,
-0.3077540398,
0.5926589966,
0.3935942948,
0.278296411,
0.5653369427,
0.6845575571,
-0.0463047661,
0.4844305813,
0.7826567888,
-0.2490773499,
0.041484613,
0.0638627261,
-0.5629241467,
0.1106008962,
0.1751587987,
-0.3567941785,
-0.1143322736,
-0.1743912846,
0.021268582,
-0.2511696219,
-0.2192812711,
0.4527757764,
0.0219776798,
-0.7864763141,
0.9004734755,
0.2208857089,
0.4568938911,
-0.3648211658,
-0.2591691911,
-0.5016111732,
0.4588501453,
-0.4209527075,
-0.3893173039,
0.2466247231,
0.4455285072,
-0.0300176851,
-0.1523075998,
0.6346626878,
-0.4409116507,
-0.388248235,
0.1890793294,
-0.0167794786,
-0.1013946757,
-0.0648261607,
-0.4881825447,
0.4613362253,
0.1990707219,
-0.1437786222,
-0.0294986703,
0.1931964755,
-0.0684446767,
0.5526490211,
0.6377471685,
0.1049803942,
0.2435253263,
0.1692454815,
1.1594158411,
-0.5323447585,
-0.300804317,
-0.6797421575,
0.4345483482,
-0.0689853951,
-0.3089002371,
0.6631599665,
0.7192574143,
1.1031264067,
-0.1454886496,
0.8683313727,
-0.274918139,
-0.0514886118,
-0.4260879755,
0.3144303858,
-0.4606687725,
0.8053051829,
-0.518586576,
-1.4739904404,
-0.5388364196,
0.6388532519,
-0.1484825015,
0.0224998668,
0.5690857172,
1.0567606688,
0.0603831336,
-0.2672222853,
-0.1182300225,
0.2002031654,
0.6433575749,
0.5482576489,
1.0706579685,
-0.1431660205,
0.5592960715,
-0.2831632495,
-0.3336372972,
-0.444553256,
-0.9941329956,
-0.5873137712,
-0.2610654235,
-0.5714611411,
-0.603900373,
-0.1590781957,
0.9688770771,
0.6867383122,
-0.9259231091,
-0.5590575337,
-0.6438145638,
-0.1160693839,
-0.0929300934,
-0.2689591646,
0.1161472723,
-0.8839132786,
-0.6741784811,
0.4565237164,
0.3711710572,
-0.4524807036,
-0.336697191,
-0.3387779593,
0.4023104906,
0.0737717301,
0.5407069325,
0.3944818974,
-0.6426548362,
-0.2936154902,
-0.0373625271,
-0.2205336988,
0.2088520825,
1.3972445726,
-0.6332822442,
0.5855560899,
0.6409934759,
0.3226948082,
0.4810493886,
0.0465230234,
0.7663968205,
-1.0879774094,
0.1253696382,
0.1176150367,
0.3591268063,
0.2412481457,
-0.2998449504,
0.4030119181,
0.1704746038,
-0.5488482118,
-0.9074355364,
0.2400922626,
-0.7179328799,
-0.434235245,
1.2441359758,
0.0096176043,
-0.2619844377,
0.1007808968,
-0.5177343488,
0.1893076003,
-0.2312523425,
0.9480978251,
0.5431051254,
-0.0972327664,
-0.1009024009,
-0.221199289,
0.464684695,
0.1925786436,
-0.819568038,
0.3405929804,
0.7850168347,
0.4367915392,
0.4575288892,
0.5996000767,
-0.2794635594,
0.4512824416,
0.0343591683,
0.3309382796,
-0.0434838645,
-0.5308160782,
-0.1536984146,
0.2265565097,
0.3904191256,
0.0675376654
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16777v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16777v1
|
Can Machine Translation Bridge Multilingual Pretraining and Cross-lingual Transfer Learning?
| 2024-03-25T13:53:04 | 2024-03-25T13:53:04 |
Shaoxiong Ji, Timothee Mickus, Vincent Segonne, Jörg Tiedemann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual pretraining and fine-tuning have remarkably succeeded in various
natural language processing tasks. Transferring representations from one
language to another is especially crucial for cross-lingual learning. One can
expect machine translation objectives to be well suited to fostering such
capabilities, as they involve the explicit alignment of semantically equivalent
sentences from different languages. This paper investigates the potential
benefits of employing machine translation as a continued training objective to
enhance language representation learning, bridging multilingual pretraining and
cross-lingual applications. We study this question through two lenses: a
quantitative evaluation of the performance of existing models and an analysis
of their latent representations. Our results show that, contrary to
expectations, machine translation as the continued training fails to enhance
cross-lingual representation learning in multiple cross-lingual natural
language understanding tasks. We conclude that explicit sentence-level
alignment in the cross-lingual scenario is detrimental to cross-lingual
transfer pretraining, which has important implications for future cross-lingual
transfer studies. We furthermore provide evidence through similarity measures
and investigation of parameters that this lack of positive influence is due to
output separability -- which we argue is of use for machine translation but
detrimental elsewhere.
|
[
-0.4019332528,
-0.4249061644,
0.4052362144,
0.4159197211,
-0.3017289639,
0.1108719334,
-0.2430379838,
-0.5360510945,
-0.0837709159,
0.4106895924,
-0.375882864,
0.0529413074,
-0.7820551991,
0.4130849838,
-0.3078321815,
0.8742169738,
-0.4877336025,
0.3841975629,
-0.2465000302,
-0.0800720006,
-0.841997087,
-0.7030434608,
-0.5293785334,
-0.5501319766,
0.6758868694,
0.1729871482,
0.5678982735,
0.4448838234,
0.5685248971,
0.3079880774,
0.5527504086,
0.0582635216,
-0.4370359778,
0.0123746004,
-0.1032465994,
-0.6635828614,
-0.161734432,
0.2432620972,
1.1316719055,
1.2316572666,
0.4094036818,
-0.2531118393,
0.2635688484,
0.6534591913,
-0.4370169342,
-0.0091659436,
-0.4722163975,
0.3541416824,
0.0112824114,
-0.1201138571,
-0.3902676404,
-0.0439157821,
0.1922154725,
-0.745606184,
-0.136337027,
0.200027898,
0.9595855474,
0.3850597739,
-0.6418700218,
-0.2490037084,
-0.5415862203,
0.8192234039,
-0.4047734439,
0.7506974339,
0.3449543417,
0.3590153158,
0.2696766853,
-0.4375815988,
-0.2840833664,
-0.1848376691,
-0.5607137084,
0.2925057113,
-0.052577626,
-0.1305735558,
0.1833843142,
0.2791356146,
-0.7839613557,
0.1648826301,
-0.3073956966,
-0.2252499461,
0.3549220264,
-0.109805584,
0.6501514316,
0.0499770939,
-0.635130465,
-0.1432691813,
-0.5904518962,
0.0540420152,
0.3863498867,
0.3606228232,
-0.1709326059,
0.4227114022,
0.2476294637,
0.6206707954,
-0.0993864983,
0.1177219301,
0.3384615779,
-0.7113149166,
0.0049154516,
0.224934116,
0.6450896859,
0.237634182,
0.5138658881,
-0.4742940366,
-0.1241519004,
-0.0944892019,
0.2957664132,
-0.6518571377,
0.063172549,
-0.1595470905,
-0.361727953,
0.2262575477,
0.2719687521,
-0.2457770407,
0.1922927499,
-0.5288788676,
0.3855469227,
-0.4387120306,
-0.3238619566,
0.1609700322,
-0.0226998571,
0.21509929,
0.0631088018,
-0.9536792636,
0.2653777003,
0.6601459384,
0.7117456198,
-0.4439504147,
-0.8019818664,
-0.6177366376,
0.2049036771,
-0.5479297042,
0.3248556852,
-0.4557558298,
-0.1590985656,
-0.0601775162,
0.372561574,
-0.5786038041,
-0.497022599,
0.1139295474,
-0.5478063822,
0.4435832202,
-0.3535758555,
-0.3264033496,
-0.2371193171,
0.2060268372,
-0.7586106658,
0.6262616515,
-0.0234746933,
-0.5337407589,
0.4354368746,
-0.285092473,
-0.7981643081,
-0.2961033285,
0.0905170739,
-0.2226798534,
0.0494129844,
0.1806303561,
0.3717380166,
0.0074489913,
0.2446963638,
-0.1747115701,
-0.3721874952,
0.1884672642,
-0.4541741908,
0.7310926318,
0.209713012,
-0.3355220854,
-0.0888619423,
-0.2640858591,
-0.1847711056,
-0.1458030343,
-0.2570025921,
-0.4313252866,
-0.6012673378,
-0.0535589084,
0.4910660386,
0.4176320732,
-0.2551606894,
-0.0480303876,
-0.4427769482,
0.0198457558,
0.476595521,
-0.3232918382,
0.9674035311,
-0.2305831909,
0.7648277283,
0.2184212655,
-0.2936081886,
-0.2852737904,
-0.1947607398,
-0.6264321804,
-0.05388413,
0.6078825593,
0.7472726107,
-0.8161898255,
0.1930805147,
-0.3454721272,
-0.0342862308,
-0.6908032298,
0.3167329133,
0.6160748601,
0.4567071497,
0.4032588303,
-0.5061978698,
-0.7194679379,
-0.7907545567,
-0.495029062,
0.1055258811,
0.1443495899,
-0.1432038695,
0.444270134,
-0.2254450321,
0.4677844942,
0.0947270915,
-0.3356907666,
-0.2162505686,
0.2453290969,
-0.1539286524,
0.5822306275,
0.7015066743,
-0.8848389387,
-0.7819125652,
0.5671722889,
-0.9066375494,
-0.1653244644,
-0.4244376719,
-0.2569416463,
0.298600316,
0.4590619206,
-0.4198754728,
0.005854785,
0.7920479178,
-0.0957918763,
0.3179751635,
-0.3987587988,
0.4350201786,
-0.9693821669,
0.2834772766,
-0.3674145341,
-0.4556877911,
-0.6258808374,
-0.1224640012,
-0.0079596676,
-0.1839985102,
-0.3436833322,
0.5375532508,
-0.5768851638,
-0.4429416656,
-0.2360123098,
0.292244792,
0.1099358797,
0.2649861872,
0.2216709256,
0.7827290893,
0.3794066608,
-0.3752064705,
0.1179243699,
0.0621237084,
-0.0073650493,
0.5323790908,
-0.4738209844,
0.124726817,
0.0046255006,
0.0655002892,
-0.7003719211,
0.0707403347,
0.4533480406,
-0.5904221535,
0.5941194296,
0.0495889634,
-0.203922987,
0.064017646,
0.0315345228,
0.5113579035,
0.2997571528,
-0.311286658,
0.3173736632,
0.0582311302,
-0.1860007644,
-0.688506186,
-0.9547806382,
0.0704734772,
-0.2469759434,
-0.5294174552,
0.4168881476,
0.2299175262,
-0.0294128656,
0.1382960677,
0.0063898652,
0.0968030915,
0.069930695,
-0.0074853958,
0.1807687283,
-0.3452872932,
0.09243384,
0.0756064504,
-0.4539415836,
0.0633954331,
-0.5432677269,
0.3709712923,
-0.1477937251,
-0.4979259968,
-0.1904362142,
0.6715149879,
0.3247903287,
-0.4773341715,
0.7686116695,
0.9580742121,
-0.3325691223,
0.2855671644,
-0.1401014477,
-0.0816368759,
-0.3465684652,
0.4954131246,
-0.7186900973,
-0.9300050139,
0.3700931072,
-0.1047659889,
-0.0147732375,
0.4325156212,
0.3270679414,
-0.3084050715,
1.0736345053,
0.7747904658,
-0.1131807044,
0.5950131416,
0.0560244992,
0.2282893211,
-0.5743538141,
-0.0168088339,
-0.467692554,
-0.3497160673,
-0.6282898784,
-0.2269515842,
0.005977178,
0.3385280967,
-0.1912878752,
0.5789961219,
0.0368440412,
0.1386349946,
0.3962471187,
-0.2531604767,
0.2578634322,
0.2302889675,
-0.2571994662,
-0.3416655958,
-0.7548536658,
-0.5024060011,
0.7421262264,
0.1841210425,
0.4396512508,
-0.1309428662,
0.7681770325,
0.0466029309,
0.1600597352,
-0.4285429418,
0.1569122672,
-0.4297748506,
-0.3952890337,
-0.3025377095,
-0.6991106868,
-1.1088125706,
0.5243469477,
-0.1978185624,
-0.3485805392,
0.0071788607,
0.0068637189,
0.1533712149,
0.171531871,
-0.8166620135,
1.325014472,
-0.7974628806,
-0.2487550378,
-0.267080158,
-0.9164839387,
0.1327206343,
-0.3904389739,
0.2376774848,
0.2404956818,
-0.0143621182,
0.5640121698,
-0.0729918256,
0.6074852347,
-0.0987148508,
-0.0347279087,
-0.1744637191,
-0.1624897569,
0.1012184396,
-0.2565066218,
0.1673556715,
0.1582855582,
0.1014652923,
-0.5339291096,
-0.8698906898,
0.4057047367,
-0.8805042505,
-0.5510875583,
-0.3408755064,
-0.7027128935,
-0.198905319,
0.5314967036,
0.2738884389,
-0.0174476691,
-0.041045554,
0.1574895978,
0.4215248227,
-0.0892228112,
0.1438114345,
0.1951844394,
-0.4770729542,
-0.312538594,
1.1559942961,
0.0906390995,
0.5545524359,
0.7065591812,
-0.0797623098,
-0.2995841503,
-0.3982419372,
-0.5740467906,
0.2649698555,
-0.6227756143,
0.2416371554,
-0.5760219097,
0.0263475515,
-0.559030354,
-0.2684290111,
-0.1757704765,
-0.2685150504,
-0.2750068009,
-0.0650948808,
-0.2942118347,
0.4666311741,
-0.3674043119,
0.2306888849,
-0.9537158608,
0.4183414578,
0.2059122026,
0.0277104732,
-0.3123852611,
-0.4935136437,
-0.5362659693,
0.2983216047,
-0.0296050198,
-0.6643213034,
0.2579657137,
0.2736990154,
0.7922817469,
0.1169289052,
-0.2248477489,
0.8858787417,
-0.5223585367,
0.4175657034,
0.4398580492,
-0.8533065915,
0.2060598582,
0.0618213564,
0.3713736236,
0.6012793779,
0.8612959981,
-0.7873117328,
-0.2235531658,
-0.1140186936,
-0.5230338573,
0.6061528921,
-0.0155209899,
0.1531916708,
0.2695793211,
0.110402368,
0.3292186856,
0.1689978987,
-0.7283785343,
0.0603066869,
-0.3169284165,
-0.0965268016,
-0.4934948087,
0.1219937205,
0.1417033821,
-0.129641518,
0.4885715544,
-0.1309305131,
0.0774972886,
-0.0581084453,
-0.6875957847,
-0.068518512,
0.1826349199,
0.3374660611,
0.4174875617,
0.1503473669,
0.180410102,
0.2781438828,
-0.2928893864,
0.2647710443,
0.3874807358,
0.0426523648,
0.1118607968,
0.7035984993,
0.8821566105,
0.4026674628,
-0.3291977346,
0.2386271805,
0.0799934119,
-0.1344127804,
0.0431808084,
-0.331969589,
0.1422644705,
0.1022755951,
0.1343726069,
0.1735446155,
-0.0771771073,
-0.8470775485,
0.2702824771,
0.3676326573,
-0.620179832,
-0.3386034369,
0.6043653488,
-0.002559718,
-0.0958916247,
0.7417237759,
0.0092774751,
-0.8133106232,
0.3774876297,
0.658375442,
0.6325238347,
-0.3006390333,
-0.0192061979,
0.159601137,
0.5327633619,
0.0071601798,
-0.1185521483,
-0.2138053477,
-0.6779940128,
-0.6577458382,
-0.5060996413,
-0.0898407698,
-0.6078309417,
-0.6212850809,
0.2356440723,
0.2175430059,
-0.0619441569,
-0.3274987042,
-0.0262801778,
-0.73899436,
0.1839853227,
0.3354078233,
0.4330455661,
-0.932051003,
0.8386818171,
0.8839503527,
-0.6157847047,
-0.6395958066,
-0.1706298888,
-0.4397821724,
-0.5929692984,
0.9261310697,
0.3743906021,
-0.348765105,
-0.0850854889,
0.1288651526,
-0.5113216639,
0.8303197026,
0.8131047487,
-0.5325965881,
-0.3387125134,
0.7302590609,
0.422760874,
-0.6019477844,
0.0378168188,
0.4675990045,
0.5711254478,
-0.1291480958,
-1.0852454901,
0.0132676763,
-0.18664518,
0.0551984385,
0.0819148719,
-0.195937559,
0.7287030816,
-0.0377844274,
-0.3343241811,
-0.1627090126,
0.6092720032,
-0.0719038546,
0.2270943969,
0.4724858105,
0.5402297378,
0.5435260534,
-0.154376179,
0.9603654742,
-0.2829223871,
0.0832262114,
1.0507390499,
-0.2396834195,
0.6766273379,
0.6131414175,
-0.0723559633,
0.3091284335,
0.7949309349,
0.3400991261,
0.5934878588,
-0.0640665069,
0.0565446094,
-0.3833881319,
0.0507755056,
-0.6418097019,
0.2763858736,
0.1658193022,
-0.4402487278,
-0.1842269599,
0.3749279082,
-0.1804582477,
0.118665114,
-0.0721166655,
0.5997135639,
0.4892078042,
-0.8913700581,
0.6407517791,
-0.3207505941,
0.6064254642,
-0.608895123,
-0.1933504194,
-0.1308021396,
0.0392044187,
-0.2363185138,
-0.5561926365,
0.62457937,
-0.2166278809,
-0.1026230678,
-0.8730019331,
0.7731397748,
-0.7106160522,
-0.295247674,
0.5979151726,
0.7865956426,
0.4219142497,
0.0209763218,
-0.7269145846,
0.0301811136,
0.0284497719,
-0.0086796237,
0.5002333522,
0.5448898673,
-0.1074154824,
0.3609132767,
0.5792117119,
0.0857676044,
0.3150310218,
0.1627655327,
0.4565746188,
-0.4950152636,
-0.3750337064,
-0.720323503,
0.3114248216,
0.2008947283,
-0.2490957677,
0.7571693063,
0.6085942984,
1.3103442192,
-0.0625918359,
0.6830418706,
0.1677949727,
0.0969669968,
-0.6698272228,
0.674254775,
-0.7706621885,
-0.1480624676,
-0.0303813312,
-0.9653750658,
-0.2855286002,
0.5532546639,
-0.5958611965,
0.0732623488,
0.8412240148,
0.4366641939,
-0.1914421916,
-0.1772015244,
0.5027184486,
-0.285490185,
-0.0214412957,
0.7065093517,
0.8603432775,
-0.3774162233,
0.7162622213,
-0.1168688759,
0.0662035495,
-0.0517771542,
-0.6138507128,
-0.8666263223,
-0.6690497398,
-0.1402616501,
0.0086157667,
0.2861981392,
0.5047059059,
0.6944265962,
-0.7077088952,
-0.3336045742,
-0.02104518,
0.1325826943,
-0.3119949996,
-0.1111345813,
0.1004051343,
-0.8273274302,
-0.8149090409,
0.222178489,
0.2177625448,
0.1552443504,
-0.4042128026,
-0.4021811485,
-0.3174132705,
-0.6212088466,
0.6644152999,
0.2594230473,
-0.5071992874,
-0.2341038883,
0.3560020328,
-0.3441381454,
0.0837473646,
0.8046716452,
-0.6418774724,
0.5030768514,
0.4939338267,
1.2446517944,
0.6841719747,
-0.2229865491,
1.0194596052,
-0.5199754834,
0.0924331993,
0.0439687036,
0.3129763305,
0.4992196858,
-0.1397126615,
0.3650588989,
0.1676105559,
-0.2921215892,
-0.523073554,
0.3010036647,
-0.4750055373,
-0.132241264,
0.7339367867,
-0.4689118862,
-0.1556009948,
-0.1171860695,
-0.0474980436,
0.6723747849,
0.1618329734,
0.1382764131,
0.9430527687,
0.0490879342,
-0.3150178194,
-0.7954956889,
0.0460485555,
0.8244341612,
-0.7005517483,
-0.262390703,
0.2029993236,
0.0547480844,
0.2845186591,
0.3583163619,
-0.1797721833,
0.2833588719,
0.0103770448,
-0.118271105,
0.1786760092,
-0.4279497862,
-0.452858448,
-0.09805765,
0.0528206341,
-0.3956153095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16771v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16771v2
|
Synthetic Data Generation and Joint Learning for Robust Code-Mixed Translation
| 2024-03-25T13:50:11 | 2024-04-29T20:45:53 |
Kartik Kartik, Sanjana Soni, Anoop Kunchukuttan, Tanmoy Chakraborty, Md Shad Akhtar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The widespread online communication in a modern multilingual world has
provided opportunities to blend more than one language (aka code-mixed
language) in a single utterance. This has resulted a formidable challenge for
the computational models due to the scarcity of annotated data and presence of
noise. A potential solution to mitigate the data scarcity problem in
low-resource setup is to leverage existing data in resource-rich language
through translation. In this paper, we tackle the problem of code-mixed
(Hinglish and Bengalish) to English machine translation. First, we
synthetically develop HINMIX, a parallel corpus of Hinglish to English, with
~4.2M sentence pairs. Subsequently, we propose RCMT, a robust perturbation
based joint-training model that learns to handle noise in the real-world
code-mixed text by parameter sharing across clean and noisy words. Further, we
show the adaptability of RCMT in a zero-shot setup for Bengalish to English
translation. Our evaluation and comprehensive analyses qualitatively and
quantitatively demonstrate the superiority of RCMT over state-of-the-art
code-mixed and robust translation methods.
|
[
-0.2363294214,
-0.8343991041,
0.1996723413,
0.3287906945,
-0.4171386063,
0.5159471035,
-0.5073499084,
-0.5677850246,
0.2776395082,
0.6330533028,
-0.3358902931,
-0.4789157808,
-0.4414403737,
0.3669627607,
-0.1780303568,
1.181437254,
-0.2874546945,
0.2239602059,
0.0108435974,
-0.4159852266,
-0.6732828021,
-0.5814145803,
-0.0981144682,
-0.0597976707,
0.5265275836,
0.428920716,
0.7768296003,
0.8145411015,
0.4001871347,
0.2117586732,
0.1616238952,
0.6271234751,
-0.4892032146,
0.4866351783,
0.0199319366,
-0.4519274235,
-0.3167110085,
-0.249162212,
0.4730347395,
0.7177383304,
0.1417220384,
0.1263547242,
0.1859988123,
0.2092349678,
-0.607399106,
0.1818807721,
-0.7957063317,
0.0346698016,
-0.149661392,
-0.3190078437,
-0.2842719853,
-0.1690399349,
-0.4701430202,
-0.6877573729,
-0.0125086978,
0.2052596658,
0.7994465232,
0.4436546862,
-0.4001721442,
-0.1911931932,
-0.8663977385,
1.061419487,
-0.6042728424,
0.3655455709,
0.3675568998,
0.2819974422,
-0.2335391641,
-0.5813097358,
-0.5919829607,
-0.0469274856,
-0.1643804163,
0.23878178,
0.264508307,
-0.0872027501,
0.0832415745,
0.3075366914,
-0.742257297,
0.058598306,
-0.4154110551,
-0.3651932478,
0.4880233407,
0.1398328096,
0.4748946726,
-0.2842378318,
-0.4891230166,
-0.2016794384,
-0.5347945094,
-0.2937066257,
0.5282528996,
0.6254790425,
-0.5423589945,
0.490855068,
-0.0097873174,
0.5997925997,
-0.1634558737,
-0.2892774045,
0.3054270744,
-0.7555662394,
-0.0437135361,
0.0659669861,
0.9621625543,
-0.0277657323,
0.1817270964,
-0.0895044133,
-0.4115453362,
0.1909910738,
0.1106185317,
-0.6353171468,
-0.1341655552,
0.2316451073,
-0.3097625971,
-0.4112614989,
-0.2251735479,
-0.9393567443,
-0.0617044494,
-0.2813435793,
0.3689970672,
-0.3017278314,
-0.4309689701,
0.0941702351,
0.280696094,
-0.180139944,
0.0565349013,
-0.5811386108,
0.1295464784,
0.2464533597,
0.6933461428,
-0.3241771758,
-0.4990762174,
-0.3845204711,
0.2502130568,
-0.2928694189,
0.4616402388,
-0.3649187088,
-0.1570936292,
0.0877965614,
-0.2660921216,
-0.0912262201,
-0.7573174834,
0.329818666,
-0.4343064129,
0.0356394202,
0.4186114073,
-0.0600908101,
0.1987189502,
0.3839226663,
-0.5495619774,
1.0120539665,
0.2788214684,
-0.9815970063,
0.2379315943,
-0.3893738091,
-0.8647869229,
0.1550424099,
-0.2469881624,
-0.736469686,
-0.0495139509,
0.310490638,
0.2791436613,
-0.089925319,
0.2891662419,
-0.2729898393,
-0.5209701657,
0.5026292801,
-0.5478625894,
0.6687911749,
0.5989084244,
-0.0428833924,
0.1164525449,
-0.85728544,
0.1234530732,
0.0753977224,
-0.4570648968,
-0.3088946939,
-0.2802931368,
0.4923729897,
0.3309229314,
0.1694451272,
-0.417735368,
0.183061555,
-0.3942196965,
0.4085785151,
0.3151571155,
0.2378617823,
0.3046216071,
-0.3996602893,
0.7312445045,
0.2227772027,
0.0570378192,
-0.3390175998,
-0.3973803222,
-0.4933605492,
-0.6485732794,
0.4959043264,
0.6236659288,
-1.0589462519,
0.2016309202,
-0.2352768332,
-0.0157195386,
-1.0267057419,
0.3128378987,
0.3256109059,
0.129991293,
0.6916149259,
-0.2347049266,
-0.8716735244,
-0.688668251,
-0.1289102882,
0.0356314667,
0.0098831877,
0.0879514366,
0.2669809759,
-0.4297296703,
0.5962382555,
-0.148740992,
-0.0509566218,
-0.5111816525,
0.2464284599,
0.0666261539,
0.6932992339,
0.1479942501,
-0.9353916049,
-0.6763145924,
0.2830170691,
-0.6121493578,
-0.254738301,
-0.5530946851,
-0.1361416131,
0.1962479353,
0.4016724825,
-0.4574691951,
0.2983652055,
0.7813330293,
0.3164380789,
0.5368179083,
-0.2707526088,
0.3507496715,
-1.6418298483,
0.0443570353,
-0.2899896502,
-0.3785940409,
-0.3440564275,
0.3705325425,
0.0343607925,
-0.2929999828,
-0.6114233136,
0.34909904,
-0.5155729055,
0.1163960546,
-0.3469954729,
0.0089671528,
-0.2389435023,
0.6590924263,
-0.1813355237,
0.809360981,
0.2849246562,
-0.4620220065,
0.2118405849,
0.2671664953,
-0.028012136,
0.1827819347,
-0.2563838363,
0.1358734816,
0.229868874,
0.1325046867,
-0.6867131591,
-0.5491585135,
0.317183733,
-0.6543030143,
0.5029778481,
-0.2644384503,
-0.6490340829,
-0.1005897373,
-0.0712854862,
0.7536051273,
0.617641151,
-0.460131526,
0.0590571389,
0.3638470173,
-0.0474225245,
-0.3944661319,
-0.9165489674,
0.2210354805,
-0.0675774366,
-0.4041498601,
0.3079464138,
0.0450702757,
-0.0893144757,
0.0172230136,
-0.1712181419,
-0.5173255801,
-0.0930032507,
0.2160465866,
0.3998024464,
-0.153687343,
-0.272574842,
0.148859486,
-0.1357201636,
-0.1939950436,
-0.4115130901,
0.5202773213,
0.2271544337,
-0.2770942748,
-0.2172036469,
0.6358792186,
0.6183517575,
-0.305726409,
0.7320561409,
0.7284098864,
-0.3872729838,
-0.5678119659,
-0.104514122,
-0.2160935849,
-0.4118438959,
0.4965869784,
-0.4668784738,
-0.9495280385,
0.397644341,
-0.108339943,
-0.1632354856,
0.084723644,
0.7753305435,
-0.1220248938,
1.1314642429,
0.6145898104,
0.1133125573,
0.2239851505,
0.0848087966,
0.6209790111,
-0.2681794763,
0.0988027602,
-0.4333117604,
-0.2974779606,
-1.2167793512,
-0.3819774091,
0.4722992182,
0.2656919658,
0.0555324554,
0.6803280115,
-0.4119975865,
0.2393959165,
0.4237383902,
0.1829976887,
0.3856564164,
0.2579960823,
-0.2873395383,
-0.2419736087,
-0.9474515915,
-0.2406293005,
1.0571529865,
0.0543179922,
0.7536064982,
-0.2242465019,
0.8373758793,
-0.0260397065,
0.0414883718,
-0.4813528061,
0.4387075603,
0.022904804,
-0.5093477964,
0.0801411271,
-0.8678670526,
-0.8532117605,
0.1357813329,
-0.5214087963,
-0.1279737502,
-0.229316473,
0.1943697184,
-0.1197007298,
0.2866244018,
-0.6114701629,
0.7369568348,
-0.245898664,
-0.7222218513,
-0.37018466,
-0.8297721148,
0.407173872,
-0.4969276488,
0.3898768425,
0.2542001307,
0.058105547,
0.3154204488,
-0.2159841061,
0.7443244457,
0.2301200777,
0.1426589191,
0.3087877631,
0.2247821987,
0.4274710715,
0.0380287617,
0.1818943769,
0.4106274545,
0.0987314209,
-0.7102484703,
-0.5652300119,
0.6048595905,
-0.6505874991,
-0.0185546279,
-0.3758449256,
-1.0871946812,
-0.3475946188,
0.2532171309,
0.3230488002,
0.0081962058,
0.2800597548,
0.1379374415,
0.3721693754,
-0.5362719297,
0.2085307539,
0.4241372645,
-0.2255777568,
-0.73293221,
1.0371638536,
0.060181316,
0.3642892838,
0.3936425745,
0.0524070561,
0.0491352603,
-0.6773672104,
-0.6497225761,
0.1417966485,
-0.226493001,
-0.3674025536,
-0.5601655841,
-0.3098542988,
-0.3339659274,
-0.3027580976,
-0.5278610587,
-0.3378249705,
0.1559571028,
0.1980484426,
0.1287393719,
0.6180461645,
-0.0699027553,
0.0384487547,
-1.0131809711,
0.3296598196,
-0.2042856961,
0.3058041632,
-0.4038520157,
-0.2608789206,
-0.7451708317,
0.2636607587,
-0.1864629835,
-0.8126448989,
0.6732492447,
-0.271601975,
0.2995572984,
-0.2006568164,
0.3958940208,
0.7297876477,
-0.2705079317,
0.5609356761,
0.1781956404,
-0.4887059033,
0.3158859611,
-0.5846232176,
0.2246057987,
0.5521755219,
0.3776604533,
-0.3500347733,
-0.6798229218,
-0.3945415318,
-0.8831034899,
0.3778843284,
0.3056411147,
0.0291175023,
0.1430496126,
0.1691877395,
0.3210113347,
0.3100144267,
-0.837256968,
-0.0096995421,
-0.122474581,
-0.6225297451,
0.3438078463,
0.0382118374,
0.1736862659,
-0.2247925401,
0.5135595202,
-0.0907311961,
0.1296809912,
-0.1405723691,
-0.2693759501,
-0.2860618234,
0.4638401866,
0.3106226921,
0.2335820198,
-0.1581248194,
0.1540352851,
0.0695204362,
-0.5864908695,
0.1477749199,
-0.0096282167,
-0.3941580057,
-0.0349294096,
0.4706801772,
0.5825701356,
0.3624908924,
-0.7344395518,
0.3626493514,
0.2906579375,
-0.188787207,
0.1282845736,
-0.1259340495,
-0.1263689101,
-0.0603371859,
-0.0375316963,
0.535574615,
-0.157372728,
-0.4641911685,
0.4528605044,
0.0544158518,
-0.1771209985,
-0.3880178034,
0.7317686081,
0.2764638364,
-0.2464849502,
0.5182561278,
-0.3910328448,
-0.5903378129,
0.2634289265,
0.8690692186,
0.8639988303,
-0.0692767873,
0.0157203991,
0.331002593,
0.3286069036,
0.0376699306,
0.3409228623,
-0.2454597652,
-0.5328089595,
-0.8071421385,
-0.7770671844,
-0.4217188656,
0.2265280038,
-0.6290899515,
0.3404724002,
-0.2116184384,
0.2147077471,
-0.5225306153,
0.0280819312,
-0.4512591064,
-0.0539749898,
-0.1957525015,
0.3723244071,
-0.8331746459,
1.2207897902,
0.740814507,
-0.6231061816,
-0.8271163106,
0.3392367065,
-0.2550214529,
-0.6312025189,
0.3216728866,
-0.0033328328,
0.1200956777,
-0.0323324464,
-0.4661810696,
-0.4060231745,
0.5633462071,
0.533085525,
-0.4541907609,
0.2891353369,
0.5446162224,
0.6290178299,
-0.137703836,
-0.1014724672,
0.1682073921,
0.4211206436,
-0.0169857498,
-0.9286974072,
-0.1720075905,
-0.2145391107,
-0.1492876709,
0.393263638,
-0.3761760592,
0.7304368019,
-0.0479958132,
-0.2781463563,
-0.0046791974,
0.5067276955,
0.1328123659,
0.2715038061,
0.2238275707,
0.2983909249,
0.2820472419,
0.1519326717,
0.9271887541,
-0.5415922403,
0.2199394703,
1.0877908468,
-0.4072451591,
0.9460513592,
0.7283275723,
-0.1527015269,
0.0327757038,
0.44585374,
0.1962176412,
0.4351297319,
0.1671703011,
-0.361464113,
-0.2222539037,
-0.2341887057,
-0.1054744646,
0.4286232293,
0.1260853261,
0.0339234062,
-0.1435362101,
0.21712327,
-0.0892070383,
0.6650128961,
0.0572642013,
0.5736903548,
0.0873881355,
-0.5735890865,
0.782902658,
0.1747546196,
0.9632758498,
-0.5230683088,
-0.3062287569,
-0.3291395903,
0.3155221045,
-0.1774519682,
-0.5090256333,
0.6107349396,
0.0948196799,
-0.1598142236,
-0.5319650769,
0.6525273323,
-0.9559618235,
-0.4503985941,
0.3604041636,
0.5313025117,
0.022789523,
0.3277391493,
-0.5446538329,
0.3468024731,
0.0735859349,
0.1961448342,
0.6465131044,
0.3252178133,
-0.0649208874,
0.3393219411,
0.7080447078,
0.5091824532,
0.2390265018,
-0.24566634,
0.6245695353,
-0.3729738295,
-0.4945869744,
-0.4858617783,
0.3808231652,
0.1798314154,
-0.2548587322,
0.8397356868,
0.6521112919,
1.3557677269,
-0.1295087039,
0.9810369015,
0.0887274146,
0.580100596,
-0.5372565389,
0.8166672587,
-0.513866365,
0.2739087343,
-0.0179339871,
-0.8582651615,
-0.5651922822,
0.4855440855,
0.1646346003,
-0.1125108823,
0.7057160139,
1.167249918,
-0.3371891975,
-0.1948951781,
0.5391430259,
0.2417788506,
-0.0090681193,
0.664262712,
0.6295087934,
-0.614667356,
0.9007391334,
-0.3274584115,
0.0089959726,
-0.1150748059,
-0.6154178381,
-0.6940412521,
-0.5676780939,
-0.3958733082,
-0.6721864343,
0.2950039804,
1.2072775364,
0.8018335104,
-1.0109471083,
-0.357311219,
-0.1918479502,
0.0434718505,
-0.4187238514,
-0.1804750711,
0.0725921839,
-0.5509722829,
-0.7987311482,
0.6240817904,
0.3246928751,
0.1277798861,
-0.1845994145,
-0.2590619624,
-0.2480789423,
0.0463149697,
0.2912882268,
0.2004967928,
-0.2580626905,
-0.1000104174,
-0.041600287,
-0.5207996964,
0.1769909859,
0.9036920667,
-0.6402775049,
0.5540898442,
0.5377072096,
1.0228116512,
0.5586861372,
-0.2486328334,
0.6729295254,
-1.0683240891,
0.5108688474,
0.3250504136,
0.0477933288,
0.3801057339,
-0.1965133846,
0.3844276965,
0.4939039052,
-0.3988296092,
-1.0547811985,
0.1957276314,
-0.9176723361,
-0.2727933526,
1.1246509552,
-0.0048225145,
-0.2688263059,
-0.308357358,
-0.1968178004,
0.6673399806,
-0.0882012993,
0.6426339746,
0.343046844,
0.2127997577,
-0.1217096075,
-0.7648989558,
0.2681172788,
0.5023215413,
-0.6802855134,
-0.0976861417,
0.3480375409,
0.0581223257,
-0.0812182203,
0.1949537992,
-0.1850884557,
0.0726204738,
0.3334345222,
0.2671726942,
-0.3157708645,
-0.3411652446,
-0.2330754995,
0.2725231946,
-0.1084250659,
-0.5067759156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16702v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16702v1
|
ProCQA: A Large-scale Community-based Programming Question Answering Dataset for Code Search
| 2024-03-25T12:34:33 | 2024-03-25T12:34:33 |
Zehan Li, Jianfei Zhang, Chuantao Yin, Yuanxin Ouyang, Wenge Rong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.SE
|
Retrieval-based code question answering seeks to match user queries in
natural language to relevant code snippets. Previous approaches typically rely
on pretraining models using crafted bi-modal and uni-modal datasets to align
text and code representations. In this paper, we introduce ProCQA, a
large-scale programming question answering dataset extracted from the
StackOverflow community, offering naturally structured mixed-modal QA pairs. To
validate its effectiveness, we propose a modality-agnostic contrastive
pre-training approach to improve the alignment of text and code representations
of current code language models. Compared to previous models that primarily
employ bimodal and unimodal pairs extracted from CodeSearchNet for
pre-training, our model exhibits significant performance improvements across a
wide range of code retrieval benchmarks.
|
[
-0.4012233019,
-0.4078730345,
0.3030187488,
-0.0586482435,
-0.2883340418,
0.496093303,
0.0336037017,
-0.1583402902,
0.3190063834,
0.3251969218,
-0.5256581903,
-0.3442607224,
-0.2081376761,
0.0348158963,
-0.3680846393,
0.7968320847,
-0.0688440725,
0.3295860887,
-0.3450942934,
-0.1635276675,
-0.4904600084,
-0.6432948112,
-0.2039719373,
0.2372150272,
0.4277707934,
0.3414413035,
1.0186104774,
0.2751327157,
0.5740503669,
0.2235420048,
0.2570770383,
0.0201649349,
-0.4781663418,
-0.0739977509,
0.02962658,
-0.3855929673,
-0.0818542093,
0.0079971757,
0.165038079,
0.5586252809,
-0.1679637432,
0.3099281788,
-0.1478981525,
0.4520556927,
-0.7524122596,
-0.1250220835,
-0.5566478968,
-0.3231388628,
-0.0917513072,
-0.3184335232,
-0.1423344463,
-0.7355132699,
-0.1220475361,
-0.6611942649,
0.0015114202,
0.0586086847,
0.7198709846,
0.2630352378,
-0.5289674401,
-0.4530614913,
-0.4156208038,
0.7271081209,
-0.7807650566,
0.3473655283,
0.3740907311,
0.3528082073,
0.0114517612,
-0.781953752,
-0.8818791509,
0.0647929758,
-0.1414630562,
0.302516371,
0.0445628949,
0.1303500235,
-0.0507018119,
0.7790104151,
-0.9335151315,
-0.1783688068,
-0.4674507678,
-0.1611114293,
0.3395211995,
0.0071499879,
0.4551443458,
-0.0718635619,
-0.1896591187,
0.1118294373,
-0.6194089055,
0.2295321971,
0.3357541561,
0.0971599519,
0.0243813284,
0.3924373686,
-0.1041940153,
0.9495901465,
-0.1669532359,
0.2554588318,
0.3585396111,
-0.6971955895,
-0.2166835964,
-0.3275887966,
0.52546978,
0.3019251525,
0.2692757249,
-0.3786998689,
-0.1033801734,
0.1531743705,
0.6180868745,
-0.6841641665,
-0.5960046053,
0.3592298925,
-0.5559741259,
-0.3574583828,
0.3444795012,
-0.4372656047,
-0.1384892315,
-0.5174795985,
0.5869387388,
0.0077160229,
-0.2746335268,
0.1647320241,
0.0988118201,
0.4377575219,
0.0625555143,
-0.5218311548,
0.126664713,
0.5184542537,
0.4991278052,
0.0657455102,
0.0876048654,
-0.7008643746,
-0.2827871442,
-0.4217442274,
0.5958641171,
-1.0950752497,
-0.2061055303,
0.0697016716,
0.05993082,
-0.0185736101,
-0.7655189037,
0.2226849645,
-1.2467041016,
0.2852041721,
-0.2405984253,
-0.2755387127,
0.0538189821,
0.3545385301,
-0.6743844748,
1.195040822,
0.431335777,
-0.9197260141,
-0.0052916743,
-0.3833740652,
-0.1982883215,
-0.0223787669,
-0.5075079799,
-0.1626124978,
-0.0009956004,
0.3577427864,
0.1347902119,
-0.3619314432,
0.3512288332,
-0.0853101909,
-0.7626153231,
0.3765967488,
-0.0292536244,
0.7134762406,
0.5053391457,
-0.0953404456,
0.1528820992,
-0.5303285122,
0.3853725493,
-0.2304438651,
-0.5515888929,
-0.3870464563,
-0.1170058921,
-0.1477835774,
0.5092405677,
0.2719608247,
-0.5145597458,
0.2732792199,
-0.4276134372,
0.4951426685,
0.5017200708,
-0.0162312575,
0.4547695816,
-0.2342676222,
0.8431452513,
0.1556074172,
0.3098730445,
-0.1409992725,
-0.1261876822,
-0.4036884904,
-0.3049448133,
0.470150888,
0.5828536153,
-1.3246139288,
0.3718523085,
-0.0670265481,
-0.379786104,
-0.7717852592,
0.1827537119,
0.6714020371,
0.427526474,
0.5886248946,
-0.5589740276,
-0.7217122912,
-0.8546568155,
-0.0532938987,
-0.1477851123,
-0.338935703,
0.3424296081,
0.3270595074,
-0.2715645134,
1.0083317757,
-0.7575427294,
0.1885408163,
-0.1255553663,
0.1224180162,
0.4014270306,
0.5686993599,
0.3131996393,
-1.1192344427,
-0.4218047261,
-0.3898974657,
-0.3602626324,
-0.2220692188,
-0.0396309011,
-0.3779414594,
-0.2793065608,
0.7618178129,
-0.1167040542,
0.2644750476,
0.8741502762,
-0.2416611165,
0.7632557154,
0.0405919701,
0.5598218441,
-1.4238342047,
0.464471668,
-0.5485443473,
-0.2523335814,
-0.441331476,
0.374950707,
0.3019465804,
-0.2012599111,
-0.4448393881,
0.2457280755,
-0.4538728893,
-0.2822315097,
-0.1461141557,
0.2799124122,
0.161411047,
0.5767878294,
0.1542891711,
1.3635854721,
0.5850621462,
-0.4520661831,
0.355730176,
0.338586092,
-0.4159453511,
0.3021452427,
-0.9189600348,
0.3870016336,
-0.0511541404,
0.2980999649,
-1.2237528563,
0.0235752854,
-0.070542112,
-0.6164376736,
-0.0590648055,
-0.1463174224,
-0.3766277432,
-0.4540584683,
-0.3622912169,
0.945887208,
0.4246330857,
-0.5104089975,
0.1818529367,
0.1890117377,
-0.1914999336,
-0.7337447405,
-0.4919753969,
-0.1362327784,
0.2857858539,
-0.3692952096,
0.2557317913,
-0.3718801737,
-0.0597007573,
-0.2797024846,
-0.323225975,
-0.4904036522,
0.1354538947,
0.1148807183,
0.4410251379,
-0.2811380327,
0.1728524268,
-0.2898692787,
-0.1090248898,
-0.1380324215,
-0.335564971,
0.6048028469,
-0.0878538266,
-0.3216307461,
0.003253822,
0.4820618927,
0.3411013484,
-0.7390499711,
0.6558200121,
0.2554460168,
-0.1655078083,
0.1601300091,
-0.4340877831,
-0.103406325,
-0.4789768755,
0.3421633244,
-0.0638078377,
-1.1769987345,
0.5547521114,
-0.0852553472,
0.0506710969,
-0.1435474157,
0.4384231865,
-0.2727002501,
0.8556323051,
0.4760071039,
-0.1148457825,
0.3638640344,
0.0308653191,
0.4121712148,
-0.6353367567,
-0.2193014771,
-0.7922656536,
-0.3573759794,
-0.2458490878,
-0.812389195,
0.2260234505,
0.4013289511,
-0.527161777,
0.5571220517,
-0.5992544293,
0.7394874096,
0.5965145826,
0.2918866873,
0.2618426979,
-0.3629011512,
0.0457853749,
-0.0139892884,
-0.5008808374,
-0.3153583109,
0.9707435369,
-0.0878066421,
0.7294235826,
0.311234653,
0.4313645363,
0.1757082343,
0.2487748563,
-0.358936578,
0.2668713927,
-0.151044786,
-0.7549979091,
-0.0398105271,
-0.6102904081,
-0.7424096465,
-0.0922843665,
-0.2549262643,
-0.3409904242,
0.3697977066,
0.2366294414,
-0.5099864006,
-0.0560856871,
-0.5573425889,
1.1330236197,
-0.4332204163,
-0.0407976247,
-0.0241769888,
-0.7702414393,
0.1486302316,
-0.1149497479,
0.2407131046,
0.3849838674,
-0.0323145688,
0.5882201195,
-0.3673360944,
0.5561034679,
-0.1063255966,
0.0191806182,
0.4314065576,
0.3472301364,
0.246353507,
0.2404056042,
-0.0150590967,
-0.1621459872,
0.2693618834,
-0.8532662392,
-0.6624608636,
0.4773672223,
-0.8804789186,
-0.2880194485,
-0.0548297316,
-0.3178791702,
-0.4807171226,
0.1813737601,
0.1786832958,
0.8889955878,
-0.0159717314,
0.5281442404,
0.8372713923,
-0.3999616504,
0.2173710763,
0.4492288232,
-0.1868382543,
-0.3860078156,
0.7022745013,
-0.377869606,
0.3977204859,
0.5518878102,
-0.3196257651,
-0.3167767823,
-0.5297003984,
-0.2247792184,
0.0068071662,
-0.5923275948,
-0.5026398301,
-0.4693397284,
-0.1230484545,
-0.4068829119,
-0.5163316131,
-0.2824639678,
-0.0943513662,
-0.1158487424,
0.036193613,
0.077088587,
0.3410023749,
0.4163444936,
0.2658743858,
-0.8840461373,
0.5817197561,
0.5324359536,
0.6489398479,
-0.2041615248,
-0.5465121269,
-0.2834661603,
0.0367838666,
-0.0931662321,
-0.9883793592,
0.1060070843,
0.062262781,
0.6252513528,
0.084684141,
0.3557565808,
0.556011498,
-0.0352792926,
0.9460792542,
0.3978465199,
-0.8674391508,
0.5257532597,
-0.2519507408,
0.6262053847,
1.2665164471,
0.655200243,
-0.6165043116,
-0.1510263979,
-0.2885694802,
-0.6886261106,
0.4502495229,
0.3012565076,
0.174489364,
-0.2133796662,
0.4839167297,
0.059799023,
0.4578973949,
-0.8623161912,
0.0264759958,
-0.5247907639,
-0.5773521662,
0.0946080163,
-0.0749178305,
-0.0221856795,
-0.2310864329,
0.4234948158,
-0.5096226931,
0.3762370944,
0.1640524566,
-0.4044895768,
0.2368827164,
0.3081725836,
0.1719881296,
0.8019104004,
-0.0505045243,
0.2757313848,
-0.0274063963,
-0.5400010943,
0.0340934731,
-0.0249124989,
0.1530704349,
-0.334002763,
0.2793710232,
0.1611527801,
0.3223285079,
-1.137044549,
0.964525342,
-0.2438052297,
-0.2070501447,
-0.1134985685,
0.0189190377,
0.2879029512,
0.2025666386,
0.3643366694,
-0.0049278382,
0.1599153876,
-0.6610607505,
0.3363601863,
0.2451032102,
-0.3371923864,
-0.1695963293,
0.6076959968,
0.4178707302,
-0.1486594528,
0.9169794321,
-0.0745015889,
-0.6864990592,
0.7434194088,
0.2355239242,
0.5144657493,
-0.0196245983,
0.2374026775,
0.4720175266,
0.0516229495,
0.1205068231,
0.5662735701,
-0.3466686606,
-0.5836203098,
-0.4623190165,
-0.5958077908,
-0.2281844616,
-0.1216972843,
-0.6011936665,
0.2336844355,
-0.3905158341,
0.2984710932,
-0.452834636,
0.1121736467,
-0.6320431828,
0.3878944218,
0.0806766227,
1.0679129362,
-0.7601606846,
0.9339100122,
0.8221299648,
-0.6993855834,
-1.0356346369,
0.1407078505,
-0.2987992465,
-0.6299831271,
0.3773816526,
0.1110962108,
-0.0712643787,
0.0989917964,
-0.9272460938,
-0.8324679136,
1.1318260431,
0.2068713456,
-0.4757321477,
-0.0403976291,
0.0391366854,
0.6401379108,
-0.4524239004,
0.5922408104,
0.316552341,
0.1512623727,
0.1505476236,
-0.885266304,
0.0248012114,
-0.6046622992,
0.0625353679,
0.0458228812,
-0.4715811908,
0.7051131129,
0.0497747697,
-0.0672101602,
0.0023810489,
0.5723003149,
0.1370263249,
0.1148895323,
0.4302248359,
0.1454148889,
0.6270596385,
0.0468781106,
0.7575026751,
-0.5095598102,
0.1711573005,
1.0698311329,
-0.1436358541,
0.9137903452,
0.4026756585,
-0.1961939931,
0.7345067263,
0.7456181645,
0.2197487354,
0.5931586027,
0.3937350512,
-0.0590087585,
-0.6671739221,
0.2116095424,
-0.4351107478,
0.2502291501,
-0.0712603629,
-0.2319499105,
-0.1957698613,
-0.2443695515,
-0.1602537483,
0.5710510612,
-0.2485940307,
0.6640427709,
-0.1492548436,
-0.7763462663,
0.6941911578,
-0.1744462848,
0.8870536685,
-0.6378654242,
0.0738371611,
-0.6121171713,
-0.0447669066,
-0.3267964423,
-0.7152742147,
0.3565336764,
0.0587888286,
-0.2665004134,
0.0357728004,
0.4073518217,
-0.5132833123,
-0.1414969712,
0.1878340095,
0.326995492,
0.0541617274,
-0.0963259414,
-0.9103294611,
-0.0975757837,
-0.0301469006,
0.043770574,
0.3570337892,
0.1770644635,
-0.0497645438,
0.3653069139,
0.5182632208,
-0.3773956597,
-0.0506732091,
-0.0135547416,
1.2703682184,
-0.5049475431,
-0.5852321386,
-0.1904647648,
0.5265269279,
0.0109475991,
-0.3457542956,
0.3328559101,
0.7283070087,
0.8911215663,
-0.0450407714,
0.5784947276,
-0.2543394566,
0.5588349104,
-0.4337528944,
0.3849637508,
-0.5709699392,
0.3500500917,
-0.1832092851,
-1.0020127296,
-0.2258411795,
0.3707964718,
-0.3393111229,
0.1947765797,
0.5261375308,
1.3051627874,
-0.1613735259,
-0.0716704726,
0.2437000424,
-0.0298042838,
0.2046501935,
0.8341295123,
0.7556813955,
-0.4552741051,
0.9063257575,
0.1798095554,
-0.2749796808,
-0.1982586682,
-0.7040994763,
-0.6992248893,
-0.6614001393,
-0.2639300525,
-0.3796100616,
0.1457585841,
0.9611418843,
0.7764151096,
-0.9600454569,
0.1277949214,
-0.0585113503,
-0.2928984463,
-0.2291774601,
-0.1735339761,
0.3055796623,
-0.1948337257,
-0.3618125618,
0.333422184,
0.0165999327,
-0.4079227149,
-0.1892741323,
-0.2426500022,
-0.4912683368,
0.2435474247,
0.2904599607,
0.4473641813,
-0.1671105474,
-0.2723098695,
0.4608605802,
-0.4779727757,
0.1569592506,
1.0766534805,
-0.9883192182,
0.4835485816,
0.7103193402,
0.9597893357,
0.0680672824,
0.4089164138,
0.6684769988,
-1.0246087313,
-0.1048087478,
0.3570157886,
-0.005152863,
0.1120065898,
-0.3030503094,
0.42750597,
0.057243526,
-0.6837092638,
-0.518214047,
0.3128570318,
-0.9550017715,
-0.6672948003,
0.9679237604,
-0.2050246,
0.0164447054,
-0.6466137171,
-0.4044408202,
0.1227857172,
-0.0703627318,
0.6359770894,
0.336312592,
0.127692312,
-0.2545577586,
-0.4959738255,
0.3735150695,
0.4562417567,
-0.8302308917,
0.1532631963,
0.6779536605,
0.1217270717,
-0.0535171665,
0.8860809803,
-0.4489879608,
0.6484344006,
-0.1120559648,
0.309799552,
-0.1480590701,
-0.1209218726,
-0.217448473,
0.1638853699,
0.1193477437,
-0.1068441272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16685v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16685v2
|
ToXCL: A Unified Framework for Toxic Speech Detection and Explanation
| 2024-03-25T12:21:38 | 2024-05-20T04:06:00 |
Nhat M. Hoang, Xuan Long Do, Duc Anh Do, Duc Anh Vu, Luu Anh Tuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The proliferation of online toxic speech is a pertinent problem posing
threats to demographic groups. While explicit toxic speech contains offensive
lexical signals, implicit one consists of coded or indirect language.
Therefore, it is crucial for models not only to detect implicit toxic speech
but also to explain its toxicity. This draws a unique need for unified
frameworks that can effectively detect and explain implicit toxic speech. Prior
works mainly formulated the task of toxic speech detection and explanation as a
text generation problem. Nonetheless, models trained using this strategy can be
prone to suffer from the consequent error propagation problem. Moreover, our
experiments reveal that the detection results of such models are much lower
than those that focus only on the detection task. To bridge these gaps, we
introduce ToXCL, a unified framework for the detection and explanation of
implicit toxic speech. Our model consists of three modules: a (i) Target Group
Generator to generate the targeted demographic group(s) of a given post; an
(ii) Encoder-Decoder Model in which the encoder focuses on detecting implicit
toxic speech and is boosted by a (iii) Teacher Classifier via knowledge
distillation, and the decoder generates the necessary explanation. ToXCL
achieves new state-of-the-art effectiveness, and outperforms baselines
significantly.
|
[
-0.0515093058,
-0.5981724858,
0.8974062204,
0.3975521326,
-0.0858881921,
-0.0930757821,
-0.255052954,
-0.2332055271,
-0.7177557945,
0.6594314575,
-0.6924627423,
-0.9840093255,
-0.688419342,
0.0325081944,
-0.7803603411,
1.2895233631,
0.3544516265,
-0.0610275827,
-0.240533635,
-0.0371050984,
-0.2669558823,
-0.4771772921,
-0.8444131613,
-0.4064322412,
0.6667401195,
0.5440087914,
0.4280627072,
0.6906419992,
-0.1766227931,
0.3853392601,
-0.2744142711,
-0.1910706609,
-0.7846143842,
0.1470466703,
-0.459602803,
-0.522089541,
-0.2942975163,
-0.4408855438,
0.4737794399,
0.6417427063,
-0.2078501135,
0.1627063155,
-0.0527547933,
0.4839222729,
-0.752148807,
0.0645828247,
-0.5589199662,
0.0730552226,
-0.2102438807,
-0.2814933658,
-0.6850517392,
-0.213321209,
-0.0028248418,
-0.6481352448,
0.1307221204,
-0.1407822818,
-0.0276115499,
0.3813929856,
-0.8031061292,
-0.5015901923,
-0.94944942,
0.6065087318,
-0.5749874711,
0.2693735957,
0.0023727315,
0.2436349094,
-0.1047898307,
-0.8801831007,
-0.6969184875,
-0.0073118694,
0.0214113183,
0.1874422729,
-0.445419848,
0.2664746046,
0.0067904317,
0.0242004227,
-0.7429280877,
0.0565377623,
-0.2968255281,
-0.3481834233,
0.5682530403,
-0.0247583538,
0.549605608,
0.008563064,
-0.6039461493,
0.0930955112,
-0.4421232641,
-0.0934250876,
0.3907696009,
0.3521518707,
-0.0058651138,
0.1665874273,
-0.0025412431,
0.3379290104,
-0.0741773322,
-0.0123308292,
-0.0159790851,
-0.1491956264,
0.1068830192,
0.8756460547,
0.6123674512,
0.1737814099,
0.3005237877,
-0.1101516336,
-0.0376680642,
0.5596693754,
0.0128511516,
-0.8167856336,
-0.1502006799,
0.2861829996,
-0.4063958228,
-0.5425878167,
-0.3817011416,
-0.9950967431,
-0.3671025932,
-0.1925992519,
0.2954719961,
0.0466764271,
-0.7788938284,
0.2459162176,
-0.3484246433,
-0.3830092251,
0.042056296,
-0.6853479147,
0.6295878887,
0.6290519834,
0.5024680495,
-0.4022938013,
0.218290627,
-0.5132864118,
0.4852455556,
-0.1001917198,
0.9608130455,
-0.7457382679,
-0.5648629665,
0.0911831111,
-0.2389648855,
0.188784048,
-0.4961572886,
0.8624154925,
-0.2545584738,
0.5869421959,
-0.0377409123,
-0.2357352823,
-0.4203533828,
-0.1326354742,
-0.2159609497,
0.8710913658,
-0.086109601,
-0.7301034927,
0.1513772905,
-0.976531446,
-0.1145625934,
0.0506429747,
0.2819053531,
-0.4367958009,
0.1691931784,
0.0504796915,
0.0044333097,
-0.2788877189,
0.4619494081,
-0.455363363,
-0.3831051588,
0.1793133169,
-0.739210546,
1.0323177576,
0.4860893488,
-0.428822577,
0.4657999575,
-0.7679600716,
0.1815107316,
0.197280854,
-0.2783269286,
-0.5555493832,
0.3241359293,
0.3820885122,
0.3909210861,
-0.1902098656,
-0.4572514296,
-0.6237898469,
-0.1124195904,
0.6140519977,
0.7905832529,
0.1431843042,
0.1218970492,
-0.1962281615,
0.3335848153,
0.0683784261,
0.3625738621,
-0.1821858585,
-0.2605937123,
-0.3723733425,
-0.2222950011,
-0.1045323312,
0.5322995186,
-0.5225901604,
0.1812333912,
-0.3859198093,
-0.2015681714,
-0.0460251905,
-0.1042036265,
0.6614088416,
0.7948649526,
0.4243479967,
0.0237418171,
-0.4932602346,
-0.6066988111,
-0.3222517371,
-0.3677039742,
-0.0505457297,
0.049237404,
0.3878282011,
-0.2818695307,
0.9772322774,
-0.2298281491,
-0.1472772062,
-0.0202931203,
0.1040327102,
-0.2117797732,
0.3325669765,
0.5730119944,
-0.9535441995,
-0.4301395118,
-0.1696177572,
-0.5963354111,
-0.6485449076,
0.2159547359,
-0.1239563227,
-0.1121655926,
0.6932080388,
0.275033474,
0.1595395952,
0.7044075727,
-0.4128819406,
0.4094978273,
-0.1095071733,
-0.145775944,
-0.8739919066,
-0.0169832185,
0.0559752844,
-0.385730207,
-1.0199867487,
-0.1923871636,
-0.223969698,
-0.3547002077,
-0.9143814445,
0.3551390171,
-0.2032729983,
0.2867026329,
-0.2965927124,
0.3678054214,
-0.1131693125,
0.6136841774,
0.040995352,
0.6786919236,
0.5180621147,
-0.6432706714,
0.3480882943,
0.2683392763,
0.1678604931,
0.7219407558,
-0.6167520285,
0.1219877452,
-0.3707734644,
0.3466771245,
-1.329300046,
-0.0127801588,
0.4170579612,
-0.4428215623,
0.129466936,
-0.2460498214,
-0.5694907308,
-0.3772514164,
-0.0708530769,
0.8411253691,
0.46580109,
-0.8154125214,
0.446675092,
0.5264108181,
-0.1837316155,
-0.4340880513,
-0.5950924754,
-0.0923734009,
-0.5292028189,
-0.6799447536,
0.2159950286,
-0.2823632956,
-0.2477155775,
0.0576920509,
-0.4375148118,
-0.4013284743,
0.0604673624,
0.2835408747,
0.0332388692,
-0.2366219014,
0.3450775445,
0.2727376223,
-0.3424457908,
0.6959087849,
-0.4069063365,
0.3054257929,
-0.0075686257,
-0.1304384023,
-0.3835448027,
0.6517472267,
0.7242595553,
-0.064456284,
0.2784663737,
0.3486447334,
-0.2032977045,
-0.4595123529,
-0.1069588363,
-0.0896643102,
-0.5373128653,
0.4260663986,
0.1773793548,
-0.7114373446,
0.4056236744,
-0.6347393394,
-0.2314680964,
0.4622927606,
0.452598542,
0.3124755025,
1.5689045191,
0.6047945023,
0.144033283,
0.3270633519,
0.3565947413,
-0.0360121131,
-0.4678892493,
-0.3535499275,
-0.7074653506,
0.2566248477,
-0.4084343016,
-0.1529668719,
0.6903367043,
-0.4158546329,
-0.6734735966,
-0.2956714034,
-0.9131647944,
0.5771669745,
0.1204100102,
-0.0114838332,
0.4993521273,
0.2475621849,
-0.1900220513,
0.1112145633,
-0.7623746991,
-0.5234925747,
0.9406681657,
0.4210249186,
0.4847995937,
0.1805638969,
0.3663170338,
0.499003768,
0.5177725554,
-0.3272681832,
0.5709742308,
-0.4577472806,
-1.1908942461,
-0.007152922,
-0.3834972978,
-0.6648777723,
0.3364833593,
-0.2421816289,
-0.7060354352,
0.1299700886,
0.3151026666,
-0.3016936779,
0.2330812663,
-0.6620427966,
0.8809108734,
-0.4851198494,
-0.5478325486,
-0.2059181184,
-0.6673126817,
0.7652106881,
-0.2351270318,
0.5946390033,
-0.2173291892,
-0.029642798,
0.6524623632,
-0.3724269569,
0.9549857974,
-0.2526390254,
-0.4833490252,
0.2745873332,
-0.2318538278,
0.1859718114,
0.1726335883,
-0.2726451159,
0.3457235694,
0.0099556446,
-0.1189357191,
-0.4717092216,
0.5242353082,
-0.5398757458,
-0.5367459059,
-0.3847228289,
-0.4428108633,
-0.0462907068,
0.2005946487,
0.3758266568,
0.4185541272,
-0.1453751028,
-0.0600504354,
0.9612694979,
-0.5982157588,
0.1820973158,
0.6170815825,
-0.4011307061,
-0.230339244,
1.1147818565,
-0.4577881098,
0.465834856,
0.1551053971,
0.3569699228,
-0.5906404257,
-0.4405767918,
-0.1163679361,
0.2431837171,
-0.8838908076,
0.0394250602,
-0.5645528436,
-0.1292062104,
-0.2505773008,
0.1738939732,
-0.3176278174,
-0.0166808292,
-0.388143152,
0.0971603543,
0.1835990697,
0.8471508622,
-0.2870992124,
0.5033736825,
-0.5748070478,
0.3153522015,
0.4793990552,
0.3562396169,
-0.1333040297,
-0.4756237268,
0.3924956322,
0.3511109054,
-0.3103007972,
-1.1320633888,
0.3612309992,
0.3130897582,
0.5011392832,
0.6828967929,
0.4041078985,
0.6012294888,
-0.4520637989,
0.6063275933,
0.2228959501,
-1.3195855618,
0.7243151069,
-0.3778606057,
-0.1060396135,
0.2898050845,
0.511482954,
-0.8936954141,
-0.5477288365,
-0.4778370559,
-0.9769785404,
0.7642124295,
0.2381518185,
0.195744738,
0.0227772146,
0.2307611853,
0.1700455546,
0.1229879707,
-0.8552080393,
-0.5370162129,
-0.3058760166,
-0.2549103796,
0.0160900801,
-0.5954908133,
-0.5323776603,
-0.1607331485,
0.5289424062,
-0.010394806,
0.4585606158,
0.035254579,
-0.1728288084,
-0.480094552,
0.514567554,
0.8229256272,
0.502104342,
-0.0076923701,
0.3321131766,
0.2126134485,
-0.309797883,
0.2981827259,
0.0165378582,
0.0228888784,
0.0746276826,
0.3241382539,
0.7404031754,
0.3706147969,
-0.8307627439,
0.7250025868,
-0.1800956577,
-0.4180079997,
-0.5632462502,
0.3245359659,
-0.0239119064,
0.1326972395,
0.3935473561,
0.0230017379,
0.3788222969,
-0.7319869399,
0.2909102142,
0.2766278982,
-0.6116846204,
-0.3619941771,
1.0633598566,
0.2766459882,
-0.0284792259,
0.4402263165,
0.0694486275,
-0.8564242721,
0.3420122564,
0.8295511007,
0.5029130578,
-0.3233728111,
0.412899524,
0.1446871758,
-0.1383039802,
0.1127543226,
0.1769567877,
-0.1532886773,
-0.5229943991,
-0.2715221643,
-0.3408528268,
-0.1804255992,
0.1053514928,
-0.6207080483,
-0.0591299795,
-0.2688679099,
0.1777237058,
0.1267894655,
-0.4232549071,
-0.0832782537,
0.0141736567,
0.5333037972,
0.6178290248,
-1.2473152876,
0.4572486281,
0.3597105742,
-0.1268115789,
-0.6227956414,
-0.0178850256,
0.4355425537,
-0.8089358807,
0.9223402739,
0.089969039,
-0.1499496847,
0.2843321264,
-0.79088974,
-0.7651324868,
0.7467232943,
0.5938100815,
-0.372494638,
-0.0405149236,
0.3167087734,
0.6332526803,
-0.2745314538,
0.2339145988,
0.3805291653,
0.8181396723,
0.3399251401,
-0.6465070844,
0.2285301536,
-0.2664066255,
0.1610536128,
-0.047577519,
-0.1574160159,
0.7178713083,
-0.1928705722,
-0.7088990211,
-0.2560142875,
0.4468843937,
0.224778384,
0.689473927,
0.7751851678,
0.1617681682,
0.7086378336,
-0.1476009041,
0.8870010376,
-0.0730164275,
0.0605591871,
1.0350711346,
-0.2753437757,
0.4841654003,
0.0423665531,
0.0909942091,
0.6382611394,
0.5439611673,
0.1849222779,
0.6089372635,
0.4657682776,
-0.7796259522,
-0.3282228112,
-0.4841929674,
-0.4224149287,
0.4127096236,
0.6764330864,
-0.3225989938,
-0.7308426499,
0.5020517111,
0.0780202672,
0.4222183526,
-0.5463563204,
0.8347277045,
-0.0405823402,
-0.5870864391,
0.7167750597,
-0.1965606362,
0.5721220374,
-0.5281181931,
-0.0644070134,
0.2210730761,
0.4415960312,
-0.2516080439,
-0.6393484473,
0.38494277,
-0.0232972093,
-0.0817452297,
-0.5228539705,
0.760348618,
-0.761515677,
-0.1492623389,
0.5775713921,
0.214045465,
0.2452848405,
-0.3664671183,
-0.7339360118,
0.1639281064,
0.0101383943,
0.2370341867,
0.0426388867,
0.6495720744,
-0.1995972395,
0.55351758,
0.8766610622,
0.0870437473,
0.1687571257,
-0.1174020171,
0.8948619366,
-0.1130473316,
-0.4300684929,
-0.7576526999,
0.6953639984,
-0.0057566497,
-0.1222733706,
0.439217627,
0.412830174,
0.7660713792,
0.1084299907,
0.8888847232,
0.3666002154,
0.4536032379,
-0.2870049477,
0.9349416494,
-0.6199707985,
0.2294960469,
-0.1781361997,
-0.8399041295,
-0.4091679454,
0.3678064346,
-0.0826304778,
-0.0430782996,
0.8993660808,
0.7809147835,
0.0735043064,
0.2165659368,
0.2311964184,
0.4955077171,
0.5130648613,
0.6381362081,
0.858614862,
-0.1361628771,
1.0575617552,
-0.0961546153,
-0.1813058853,
-0.1100344434,
-1.0462158918,
-0.7472975254,
-0.6736077666,
-0.4017789364,
-0.2906508744,
0.4215703309,
0.7662895322,
0.6734721661,
-0.6773763895,
-0.1393183619,
-0.2401901186,
0.3620133698,
-0.2391918302,
-0.1877459735,
-0.0200328752,
-0.2466164827,
-0.7641385198,
0.4180574119,
0.2061519921,
-0.1285256743,
-0.007182498,
-0.1005814895,
-0.0176925249,
0.0727799982,
0.7654394507,
0.5207147002,
-0.6411780119,
-0.3790493309,
-0.3093530536,
-0.0153312953,
-0.1457794011,
0.7622634172,
-0.5217496753,
0.5743513703,
0.2979376316,
0.1904106438,
0.3104054332,
-0.0848832875,
0.5529033542,
-0.7532176971,
0.0622277036,
0.3108513951,
0.0076493472,
0.2008768469,
-0.433743149,
0.3873179555,
0.2854136825,
-0.4401293695,
-1.0930395126,
0.2238313407,
-1.0881195068,
-0.6071516275,
1.3419702053,
0.0378345475,
-0.4103987217,
-0.5775290728,
-0.3008215427,
0.6922329068,
-0.5778277516,
0.6989071369,
0.2846443951,
0.1540742815,
-0.0665815324,
-0.5297212005,
0.5282385349,
0.1982279867,
-0.8862790465,
0.3015632331,
0.4968345463,
0.6263868809,
0.2936386764,
0.3853756487,
-0.2967858911,
0.4449331462,
-0.1700624377,
0.0890680775,
-0.3354759812,
-0.2209930718,
-0.3552878797,
0.3985542953,
-0.4179905653,
-0.0856404975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16668v1
|
Who is bragging more online? A large scale analysis of bragging in social media
| 2024-03-25T12:07:21 | 2024-03-25T12:07:21 |
Mali Jin, Daniel Preoţiuc-Pietro, A. Seza Doğruöz, Nikolaos Aletras
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Bragging is the act of uttering statements that are likely to be positively
viewed by others and it is extensively employed in human communication with the
aim to build a positive self-image of oneself. Social media is a natural
platform for users to employ bragging in order to gain admiration, respect,
attention and followers from their audiences. Yet, little is known about the
scale of bragging online and its characteristics. This paper employs
computational sociolinguistics methods to conduct the first large scale study
of bragging behavior on Twitter (U.S.) by focusing on its overall prevalence,
temporal dynamics and impact of demographic factors. Our study shows that the
prevalence of bragging decreases over time within the same population of users.
In addition, younger, more educated and popular users in the U.S. are more
likely to brag. Finally, we conduct an extensive linguistics analysis to unveil
specific bragging themes associated with different user traits.
|
[
-0.5093263984,
-0.9999858141,
0.0278900564,
0.8798395395,
-0.069498837,
0.5840593576,
-0.3423706591,
-0.6220366359,
0.7402148247,
-0.3778493106,
-0.4038720727,
-0.3155890703,
-0.9675046802,
-0.1263215095,
-0.3346195519,
0.8887842298,
0.1067958996,
-0.1124886125,
-0.209067896,
0.283549577,
-0.5510166883,
-0.7015385032,
-0.6551799774,
0.052615881,
0.8761575222,
0.2637512088,
0.4054567516,
0.3720199466,
0.4530956745,
0.2572666109,
-0.0553576648,
-0.1707139015,
-1.2278227806,
-0.0035114854,
-0.4026190042,
-0.5319437385,
-0.4178766906,
0.0199621916,
0.5189769864,
0.3467767239,
0.0757990628,
0.635648787,
0.2889353335,
0.6606315374,
-0.5576239824,
0.1386990547,
-0.5167630911,
-0.0619260967,
-0.4084115028,
-0.3936621547,
0.2209632844,
-1.043342948,
0.0216719471,
-0.494962275,
0.2441953123,
-0.1623477042,
0.7043315172,
-0.3683842421,
-0.6821957231,
-0.1477315873,
-0.5522212982,
0.7037348151,
-0.2356851399,
0.5991814137,
0.6351912618,
0.2415826619,
0.2138941139,
-0.4336765409,
-0.11112082,
-0.0184630863,
-0.0470883064,
0.0268215053,
-0.437376827,
-0.1404038221,
-0.1051703915,
0.4026686847,
-0.5333096981,
-0.0167635046,
-0.6579427123,
-0.1699344367,
0.6662489772,
-0.2811390758,
0.3810119033,
-0.2011247873,
-0.5471816063,
0.0541874319,
-0.2411478609,
0.3938920498,
0.4054275453,
0.2119642943,
-0.0031985983,
0.6200535297,
-0.1040194556,
0.1297783852,
0.2464205027,
-0.2515539527,
0.0724041238,
-0.1055009589,
0.1296922266,
0.3594178557,
0.5928211808,
0.8808476925,
0.8670309782,
-0.1011881307,
0.0797136948,
0.1903731823,
0.2889792621,
-0.7204585671,
0.2303455919,
0.021325022,
-0.5220957994,
-0.1083422974,
0.3819202185,
-0.6040453911,
-0.5061289668,
-0.010121786,
0.1998960674,
-0.349430263,
-0.3362099826,
-0.2548365593,
-0.3407399952,
0.1348112971,
0.0215285793,
-0.6583868265,
0.4681518674,
0.9997369647,
1.0505360365,
-0.0435626097,
-0.2918076515,
-0.4121111333,
0.1246353984,
-0.6961449981,
0.9140778184,
-0.1455846727,
-0.3429507613,
0.0321017802,
-0.0111986538,
-0.0852533355,
-0.1411713213,
0.6592053175,
-0.7234366536,
-0.509683609,
-0.6195807457,
-0.6972848773,
0.0355345905,
0.2468699217,
-0.2643481493,
0.7015976906,
0.0355808847,
-0.5162270069,
0.704836905,
-0.2744636834,
-0.501342833,
0.3489224017,
0.119462952,
-0.147424385,
0.4725238085,
0.0676781833,
0.659784615,
0.0652587712,
-0.0064232736,
-0.3534277678,
-0.3547548354,
0.5595273376,
-0.020557059,
0.2662109435,
0.2794008851,
-0.1728786975,
-0.2719976902,
0.3015508652,
0.0003041377,
-0.1128326133,
-0.090910174,
-0.411043793,
0.0818297863,
-0.1778334528,
0.1601498425,
0.4080071747,
-0.8142728209,
0.2225996256,
-0.2072296888,
0.317604661,
0.6890816689,
0.5020326376,
0.0477846824,
-0.6230251789,
0.449192673,
-0.4246646166,
0.0939129218,
0.449546963,
-0.5253747106,
0.1881123185,
-0.4361559749,
0.1885825545,
0.4605324268,
-0.1812374145,
0.2484787554,
-0.8454538584,
-0.7164253592,
-0.1582446098,
0.2646735907,
0.3369499743,
-0.2855855525,
-0.1364277005,
0.2141477466,
-0.5111743808,
-1.0966539383,
-0.9867950678,
-0.4802487791,
-0.0520324446,
0.139019087,
0.1595517695,
0.1791339517,
0.8022139668,
-0.7369464636,
-0.8786902428,
-0.3644490242,
0.4333343804,
-0.1921469569,
0.0408677012,
0.7159391642,
-0.9982876778,
-0.7651329041,
0.2406663597,
-0.7635943294,
0.0669971779,
-0.0586801469,
-0.1282772273,
0.1588672251,
0.6375484467,
-0.2181015313,
0.2765140533,
0.4989101887,
-0.4747358859,
0.4250733852,
0.0750271529,
0.599919796,
-0.5677523613,
-0.4571522474,
0.8245190978,
-0.1653560251,
-0.4367796481,
0.0155928833,
-0.2075446695,
0.4036470354,
-0.1731092781,
0.1199203357,
-0.5934138894,
-0.050871104,
-0.1146074682,
0.1650093347,
-0.3166263103,
0.1190221757,
-0.1520301551,
0.4285794795,
0.8544927239,
-0.5577111244,
0.3329187036,
0.0512250774,
-0.3660045862,
0.8851704597,
-0.774107933,
-0.1124505922,
-0.2445290089,
0.3554795682,
-1.3670972586,
-0.5575655699,
-0.3573051393,
-1.016761899,
0.0892836899,
-0.2363805324,
-0.4872784317,
-0.7931940556,
-0.6862410903,
0.1824587435,
0.4304363728,
-0.2861483395,
0.2508461773,
0.9033504725,
-0.4896327853,
-0.1946818382,
-0.9448193908,
0.2327530235,
-0.4070913494,
-0.8711293936,
0.4985435009,
0.2721213698,
-0.4051888287,
-0.304223597,
-0.1386859119,
-0.1294517219,
-0.0887560397,
0.1120167449,
0.035117805,
-0.0746800527,
0.2504425049,
-0.1071659103,
0.3002702594,
0.1360243857,
-0.1151006445,
0.7843747735,
-0.7658610344,
-0.1942388713,
-0.6950995922,
0.4137081504,
0.3388742208,
-0.0071503306,
1.1255309582,
0.7319164872,
-0.3149696589,
-0.1028414443,
-0.7681217194,
-0.2160635889,
-0.4276194572,
0.5149284005,
-0.3225260973,
-0.8378965259,
0.5991322398,
0.0092380038,
-0.0658650622,
0.2919257283,
0.3424655497,
-0.3042375445,
1.0092209578,
0.6673679352,
-0.0258023422,
0.2460339218,
-0.0988088548,
0.0478847213,
-0.4052370787,
-0.0767589658,
-0.305585444,
-0.8556268811,
-0.9555945396,
-0.2844120562,
0.3881065845,
0.1175867319,
0.0710949972,
0.3024839461,
-0.521915257,
0.507491827,
0.0814176127,
0.2565484941,
0.3012489974,
0.027853379,
0.7164604664,
-0.3796866834,
-0.3283316195,
-0.3420341611,
0.6082502604,
0.2642838061,
0.8433623314,
0.547596097,
0.5899089575,
0.7870245576,
0.3947802186,
-0.9837767482,
0.601534903,
-0.2365462631,
-0.7221826315,
-0.3008926511,
-0.6134324074,
-0.9884490967,
-0.2568113208,
-0.308427006,
-1.057456255,
0.1604184955,
0.3738288581,
-0.3421036601,
0.5611554384,
-0.7417280674,
0.5430967808,
-0.3080397546,
-0.3622252047,
-0.3099086583,
-0.7592006922,
0.5457056165,
-0.1315548122,
0.5334356427,
-0.12158712,
-0.0699872524,
0.6591460109,
0.0581560545,
0.9554624557,
-0.2464880198,
-0.033125788,
0.3760969043,
0.1256180108,
0.3587126732,
-0.1496594697,
0.113412708,
0.1286948323,
0.1962685585,
-0.4580895901,
-0.2639895976,
1.0351785421,
-0.8427420259,
-0.2374039441,
-0.2107603103,
0.1685356945,
-0.1968209893,
-0.3557701409,
0.3693614006,
0.4150188267,
-0.7970093489,
0.2740772665,
0.4141412079,
-0.0406508408,
0.1541032493,
-0.2265289128,
-0.5639039874,
-0.1706514806,
1.5839949846,
0.6414102912,
0.2025200129,
0.1652204096,
0.3611316979,
-0.4331523478,
0.0194872208,
0.0642185733,
0.6624165773,
-0.287491858,
0.0904771686,
-0.5126603842,
-0.1250438839,
-0.8741702437,
-0.4802515209,
-0.3588324487,
-0.4962356687,
0.1353871524,
-0.196663484,
0.4528915286,
0.9907470345,
-0.3574078679,
0.6117625237,
-0.5996456742,
0.3315116465,
0.581715405,
0.6179143786,
0.1221559644,
-0.325858891,
0.0171259008,
-0.0259787198,
-0.2296637893,
-0.8918730021,
0.2414656281,
0.6548678875,
0.6975944638,
0.7678716183,
-0.0061927219,
0.5971230865,
0.2323336005,
0.8059921861,
-0.0217041485,
-0.7669447064,
0.15974693,
-0.6716672778,
-0.007903154,
0.4575508237,
0.4920708835,
-1.0939209461,
-0.3023455441,
-0.5118694901,
-0.7992069125,
0.2690134943,
0.1390235573,
0.3335868418,
-0.2207867801,
0.1685015261,
0.0640809759,
0.2720687985,
-0.6639195681,
-0.44951123,
-0.1421713382,
0.3786075413,
0.0002063496,
-0.3007343411,
0.0065192822,
-0.4206459522,
0.6059058905,
0.0361843929,
0.3033058047,
-0.0561934374,
-0.2356202751,
-0.2269600332,
0.2091964781,
0.2566639781,
0.7434551716,
-0.3576746285,
0.1187347248,
0.1404069215,
-0.4923225641,
-0.1418474913,
-0.2353360355,
0.2588736117,
-0.0748859495,
0.2159879804,
0.4811249971,
0.329921484,
-0.2105099559,
0.7131063938,
-0.064318262,
-0.5101614594,
-0.4630912542,
-0.4225114286,
0.4616093338,
-0.0493794754,
0.7995721102,
0.0892848521,
-0.025214104,
-0.7712554336,
0.173282966,
0.5012001991,
-0.5694681406,
-0.4625639915,
0.710491538,
0.028825406,
-0.2920946181,
-0.0037036787,
-0.4308181405,
-0.5590022802,
0.3869818449,
0.4554798901,
0.7080977559,
-0.0391280353,
0.6942474246,
0.514154315,
0.2119631171,
-0.0238867942,
0.0228723604,
0.0560804866,
-0.3865163326,
-0.3460370004,
-0.8229162693,
0.1649992317,
-0.4833061993,
-0.7294130325,
0.4364230931,
-0.350980401,
-0.7880823016,
0.0697337538,
-0.1492047161,
-0.3840124011,
0.0672826245,
0.4011539519,
0.3916724622,
-0.7144118547,
-0.020781083,
0.8384137154,
-0.066551961,
-0.6958352327,
0.3622530699,
0.6058127284,
-0.6421684623,
0.8150416017,
0.2080062926,
-0.4758685231,
0.2267350256,
-0.6528668404,
-0.6416701078,
0.6608294845,
0.096981667,
0.0625953376,
-0.0393413119,
0.2141256034,
0.7498537898,
-0.0717606992,
0.0412221812,
0.5453878641,
0.3856847882,
0.3915786445,
-0.9772089124,
-0.2068894356,
-0.0188882705,
0.0520750992,
0.1875654012,
-1.015052557,
0.8704500794,
-0.1995125562,
-0.6921239495,
-0.3177748322,
0.9170311689,
-0.0151541531,
0.1100971252,
0.5593943596,
0.1764597595,
0.6506400704,
-0.0677947998,
0.7942832708,
-0.2267616242,
0.3010162711,
0.541574657,
0.1799309403,
0.6364238858,
-0.0417216346,
-0.3577193916,
0.6690459847,
0.5467835069,
0.1543294042,
-0.0721579343,
0.3865081072,
-0.1626847386,
-0.2718176842,
-0.2034674883,
-0.4905103445,
0.7268283963,
0.3559087813,
-0.2759271562,
-0.2755741179,
0.1523318589,
0.3663484156,
0.3141148984,
-0.7610842586,
0.8961873651,
-0.0215351228,
-0.5372706056,
0.4767897725,
-0.2717313766,
1.0018250942,
-0.6874084473,
0.3547947407,
-0.0195405837,
0.3087444007,
-0.5656346083,
-0.8819006681,
0.3682288826,
0.1321347356,
0.1343461275,
-0.3737947643,
0.7288016081,
-0.0227345303,
-0.5704491735,
0.6026467681,
0.7965728045,
0.5435844064,
-0.4599793255,
-0.136087358,
-0.4597679079,
-0.1831666827,
-0.2044716626,
0.4085363448,
0.4228978455,
-0.2623061538,
0.8103016615,
0.6339942217,
0.2949317992,
0.3973509371,
0.2036707252,
0.7223809958,
-0.3567984402,
-0.6682721972,
-1.1345918179,
0.1005432457,
-0.4668061435,
-0.4479224086,
1.4458481073,
0.6641181111,
0.4048056006,
-0.0044679404,
0.6012458801,
-0.399210304,
0.6715169549,
0.3610450625,
0.9886491895,
-0.5944477916,
-0.1015586108,
-0.6045995951,
-0.7960894108,
0.0883434042,
0.1692701876,
-0.4274311364,
0.0126149254,
0.1123729572,
0.4989879429,
0.2475090921,
0.2319289595,
0.3752220869,
0.3033208847,
-0.0119261807,
-0.2380318195,
0.790333569,
0.2809458375,
0.5352439284,
-0.1133640781,
-0.7622608542,
-0.2115537226,
-0.5524047017,
-0.8863537908,
-0.4273225665,
-0.25657022,
-0.2807625532,
-0.0689838007,
1.0665205717,
0.6109362841,
-0.5079947114,
-0.4861063957,
0.2106497735,
0.1865508705,
-0.5500439405,
-0.3719180226,
-0.043547675,
-0.2291391194,
-0.438075155,
-0.1174944267,
0.0511242822,
-0.3048854172,
-0.3285678327,
0.5015907288,
-0.5269826055,
0.3912923634,
0.8163560033,
0.5504191518,
-0.3036908209,
-0.2894538343,
0.4730234146,
-0.0676282942,
0.1063674465,
0.6027207971,
-0.3690565825,
0.2299940288,
0.6513193846,
0.091445975,
0.6101616025,
0.7862454057,
0.407921046,
-0.9173152447,
-0.5359585285,
-0.027996907,
-0.1971300542,
0.426846087,
-0.5281959772,
0.1702004373,
0.5250982046,
-0.7716875672,
-0.607539475,
-0.1927003264,
-0.8750356436,
-0.2422068864,
1.1288142204,
0.2360407114,
-0.2052768916,
-0.1059951708,
-0.1971605718,
0.299693346,
-0.7911343575,
0.9487168789,
0.8017763495,
-0.3172729015,
0.2945795059,
-0.423571676,
0.4078164697,
-0.2022064775,
-0.7434201241,
0.1670877784,
0.3710922897,
0.2856849432,
0.4029450119,
0.4117008448,
0.284525156,
-0.1330536604,
0.0428548381,
-0.1604941636,
0.4141889215,
-0.1538281739,
0.1930396706,
0.5158623457,
-0.3138115406,
0.0445406362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16662v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16662v2
|
RU22Fact: Optimizing Evidence for Multilingual Explainable Fact-Checking on Russia-Ukraine Conflict
| 2024-03-25T11:56:29 | 2024-03-26T07:13:15 |
Yirong Zeng, Xiao Ding, Yi Zhao, Xiangyu Li, Jie Zhang, Chao Yao, Ting Liu, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fact-checking is the task of verifying the factuality of a given claim by
examining the available evidence. High-quality evidence plays a vital role in
enhancing fact-checking systems and facilitating the generation of explanations
that are understandable to humans. However, the provision of both sufficient
and relevant evidence for explainable fact-checking systems poses a challenge.
To tackle this challenge, we propose a method based on a Large Language Model
to automatically retrieve and summarize evidence from the Web. Furthermore, we
construct RU22Fact, a novel multilingual explainable fact-checking dataset on
the Russia-Ukraine conflict in 2022 of 16K samples, each containing real-world
claims, optimized evidence, and referenced explanation. To establish a baseline
for our dataset, we also develop an end-to-end explainable fact-checking system
to verify claims and generate explanations. Experimental results demonstrate
the prospect of optimized evidence in increasing fact-checking performance and
also indicate the possibility of further progress in the end-to-end claim
verification and explanation generation tasks.
|
[
-0.4198041856,
-0.6077570915,
0.6583199501,
0.1848875135,
-0.4081416428,
0.0222970396,
-0.0006722163,
-0.4815995991,
-0.2085746676,
0.088373445,
-0.5596030354,
-0.3202263415,
-0.5971832275,
0.3609757721,
-0.3478087783,
1.1093821526,
-0.1987227648,
0.4182536304,
-0.1788529456,
-0.2893258631,
-0.0264236815,
-0.3891556859,
-0.2776758671,
-0.4423047006,
0.3437505662,
0.800742805,
0.3550508916,
0.70983845,
0.5454084277,
0.468069315,
0.280005455,
0.1612339765,
-0.3510632217,
0.0607801303,
-0.2962864935,
-0.57390064,
-0.3714289963,
-0.1222854331,
0.5295937061,
0.3246689737,
-0.412445873,
0.3702544272,
-0.3201605976,
0.3484763205,
-0.5162478089,
-0.1489116102,
-0.562554121,
-0.0777997226,
0.0969952792,
-0.1916950494,
-0.2783462405,
-0.420144707,
0.1892036647,
-0.7237296104,
0.4473785162,
0.0015239578,
1.2691013813,
-0.2077293843,
-0.5839298368,
-0.2812783122,
-0.3810729384,
0.6256536245,
-0.5503153205,
0.5031817555,
0.2930198014,
0.1170811877,
-0.1177430004,
-0.4693675637,
-0.5879456401,
0.0248124357,
-0.2570922971,
0.3669421375,
-0.3627763093,
-0.3487503231,
0.2143769711,
0.0554112084,
-0.8514193296,
-0.0981443673,
-0.0477049872,
-0.6598367095,
0.4368924201,
-0.0878482088,
0.4086381495,
-0.29165712,
-0.2568948269,
0.1279464662,
-0.7076568007,
0.0743811727,
0.6548611522,
0.0563236214,
-0.2939764559,
0.6052302718,
-0.6744166017,
0.5621738434,
-0.0573481284,
-0.3770451248,
-0.2106911987,
-0.722296834,
-0.058574114,
0.1433112025,
0.620931983,
0.6064360142,
-0.1645773798,
-0.1682016104,
0.0916050002,
0.3390136361,
-0.0775112882,
-1.2126009464,
-0.0563836507,
0.4338797033,
-0.4643596709,
-0.2785707116,
-0.0178805832,
-1.3068392277,
-0.2846461833,
-0.2521654367,
0.5864323378,
-0.1771011055,
-0.2617076039,
0.2723084092,
-0.2336426377,
-0.2623046041,
0.4339057207,
-0.4343267977,
-0.0452198386,
0.4562911987,
0.645578444,
0.1185007393,
-0.1763115972,
-0.9632461071,
-0.1757352054,
-0.3916731775,
1.0722123384,
-0.3847484887,
0.059437193,
0.2290003002,
0.233006686,
0.6574530005,
-0.3208787143,
0.7815864086,
-0.562782824,
0.4465375245,
-0.4687075019,
-0.3184346557,
-0.1494378746,
0.2912677526,
-0.5611907244,
0.7638704181,
-0.4089034498,
-0.7997858524,
0.7724190354,
-0.7489339113,
-0.5485767126,
0.1572168469,
0.0382442176,
-0.5548997521,
-0.1136890426,
0.1293593943,
0.4004347026,
-0.3075532913,
0.5742609501,
-0.205115363,
0.1783392876,
0.4066982269,
-0.1702702492,
0.7355460525,
0.1989087015,
-0.5131147504,
0.1004125625,
-0.9871098995,
-0.2731480896,
0.2613821924,
-0.917540133,
-0.0942787305,
0.2821521461,
-0.1254199594,
0.1548373401,
0.44022277,
-0.8770470619,
-0.02085579,
-0.0627535805,
0.213611275,
0.3084095418,
-0.0043580621,
0.2453167439,
-0.2414579391,
0.4306382239,
0.1319844276,
0.1758137494,
-0.5503653288,
-0.1061188653,
-0.9952161312,
-0.0336271264,
0.3417028487,
0.5888161659,
-0.6487370133,
0.2725849748,
-0.1941517591,
-0.3299125731,
-0.4302497506,
-0.1629039943,
0.2645119727,
0.562631309,
0.3969743848,
0.2015826702,
-0.8151805401,
-1.0629986525,
-0.349938184,
-0.3239578605,
0.3096512556,
-0.0147845577,
0.7000724673,
0.1478883773,
0.8669009805,
-0.4099138677,
0.203896448,
-0.1301669329,
0.4945261776,
-0.0334757529,
0.3165102899,
0.191839844,
-0.9926987886,
-0.4015328884,
0.2568649352,
-0.7995001674,
-0.1638740897,
-0.3563040793,
-0.1463878602,
0.4560721517,
0.3586835265,
-0.4780500829,
0.3760899603,
0.4415909946,
-0.6106848717,
0.7415866852,
-0.3165285587,
0.5312356353,
-0.9587923288,
0.3107804656,
0.0457091667,
-0.6211717129,
-0.5316072106,
0.2068851292,
0.3384055793,
-0.0640092567,
-0.113969028,
0.081001088,
-0.451972127,
0.0879257768,
-0.2860540152,
0.2105144858,
0.0791805387,
0.1564772874,
-0.0654983521,
0.7859039903,
0.5516552925,
-0.4590015113,
0.3278923631,
0.1695790887,
-0.6754546762,
0.5822002888,
-0.3136371672,
-0.4520514905,
-0.1240163445,
0.1805478185,
-1.0696672201,
-0.5487069488,
-0.1004680097,
-0.5567204952,
-0.0474353284,
-0.6020590663,
-0.4032405317,
0.0261236168,
0.1323121041,
0.0159486104,
0.3282675445,
-0.6850055456,
0.8100780845,
0.3723469079,
-0.3662107587,
-0.9238561392,
-0.2982938588,
0.5762598515,
-0.5551483035,
-0.5466960669,
0.2396628559,
-0.1789896041,
-0.4808826149,
0.0025229866,
-0.2508934736,
-0.1265081912,
0.0496986061,
0.0319554396,
0.1363455355,
-0.2649369538,
0.1901095957,
-0.2933864892,
-0.1614306718,
0.2814627588,
-0.0086616883,
0.347394228,
-0.1662759036,
-0.2730901241,
-0.6083788276,
0.7039817572,
0.7674466372,
-0.2864477932,
0.5806415677,
0.7081627846,
-0.3116943538,
-0.0895357504,
-0.8078505993,
-0.3631124496,
-0.4101515114,
0.5614643097,
-0.2546041012,
-0.7139623761,
0.8396470547,
-0.4646752775,
0.1332326829,
0.4690390527,
0.5083140135,
0.0168038178,
0.98344028,
0.5827152729,
0.1719365269,
0.2351398617,
0.0351026542,
0.3530891836,
-0.1636788398,
-0.4470584691,
-0.8363081217,
0.1924524456,
-0.3333192468,
-0.0133279795,
0.2086462677,
-0.016164735,
0.0732043758,
0.1277050525,
0.0050494936,
0.5533902049,
0.3447465301,
-0.001665859,
0.44020769,
0.0808797181,
-0.2828876376,
-0.0379048437,
-0.7949963212,
-0.2519643009,
0.7081122398,
0.0619938374,
0.5742800236,
0.6484112144,
0.36984846,
0.1714251488,
0.1384262443,
-0.6234403253,
0.4795204997,
0.1714965403,
-0.8836054802,
-0.1706356853,
-0.4759920537,
-0.9697064161,
0.2570453286,
-0.6890828609,
-0.6576880217,
0.1284997165,
0.3984986842,
-0.1806515157,
0.0478860922,
-0.6481993794,
0.7515735626,
-0.3011344075,
-0.6045506001,
-0.7228006124,
-0.491065979,
0.4469881654,
-0.1848462224,
0.4998573363,
0.1134060621,
0.101804927,
0.648742795,
-0.5674738884,
0.4690602422,
-0.1701120883,
-0.2728945315,
-0.0795858204,
0.1933464557,
0.6799114943,
0.3827221394,
0.1098322719,
-0.1656307727,
-0.0920552835,
-0.3748350143,
-0.4310223758,
0.5731343627,
-0.5940110683,
-0.5830571651,
-0.5545336604,
-0.3453499973,
0.1251726747,
0.2302209139,
0.3345223367,
0.9262145758,
-0.4541672766,
0.3742600977,
0.7923787236,
-0.280382365,
0.550971508,
1.2355896235,
-0.2904833257,
-0.2297123671,
1.0539413691,
0.171566084,
-0.0032648372,
0.6078758836,
0.4850744605,
-0.4139792919,
-0.749358356,
-0.7399404645,
-0.0173453912,
-0.8339312673,
-0.3205385506,
-0.6701778769,
0.446775943,
-0.0523872226,
0.1983583272,
-0.2755799294,
-0.3072741926,
0.1596666873,
0.0222470313,
0.3752274513,
0.827342391,
-0.5058591366,
0.2465944439,
-0.5167427063,
0.6940407753,
0.3458682299,
0.4155679643,
-0.264757067,
-0.571341753,
-0.7134442329,
0.0516132452,
-0.0884047747,
-1.1849591732,
0.0640076846,
0.1255442202,
0.4107458591,
0.518396318,
0.0482351109,
0.8556181192,
-0.5253251791,
0.7008259892,
0.1312387735,
-0.9191299081,
0.4382384419,
-0.4998564124,
0.1685734838,
0.3138081133,
0.54231143,
-0.3740999699,
0.0918645933,
-0.6675988436,
-0.7007012963,
0.8018202782,
0.0226237755,
-0.3874928057,
0.3177690506,
0.2384257019,
0.2927359641,
-0.0837313309,
-0.696447432,
-0.1613623202,
-0.300170511,
-0.1343203783,
0.1472717077,
-0.2873898745,
-0.6268043518,
-0.0393530279,
0.9909389615,
-0.321616143,
0.1603926867,
0.3193432987,
-0.4966593385,
-0.4553258121,
0.5137578249,
0.929320991,
1.1366590261,
0.0432768017,
0.3924531341,
0.3835305274,
-0.5079935193,
0.2140169442,
0.2709470391,
-0.1204938963,
0.2040287107,
0.3417573571,
0.4508286715,
0.0180267859,
-0.9670326114,
0.6895750165,
-0.3688941002,
-0.3804244995,
-0.310341239,
-0.2580782175,
0.216280371,
0.2532115579,
0.5864732862,
0.0031021365,
0.184496671,
-0.5330795646,
0.2869222462,
0.5179418921,
0.2321614027,
-0.3564971685,
0.110102199,
0.218078956,
-0.1775102317,
0.1247244626,
-0.2175240815,
-0.7199641466,
0.5402570963,
0.3282745183,
0.3178035319,
-0.2029297352,
0.5046147704,
0.5960478783,
0.3609469831,
0.0574754439,
0.4630331695,
0.2163863927,
-0.6252382994,
-1.0010459423,
-0.3121338487,
-0.3067924678,
0.6734135151,
-0.7926117182,
0.1512495726,
-0.2226822078,
0.0550536104,
0.4567542672,
0.0890869945,
-0.6349800229,
0.3593819737,
-0.1916724592,
0.6241004467,
-0.9678868651,
0.2695045173,
0.4409938455,
-0.1256173551,
-0.3861358464,
-0.0731194019,
0.242214337,
-0.7391882539,
0.606200397,
0.0558562614,
-0.2698846459,
-0.3031167984,
-0.6771270633,
-0.9086384177,
0.5611183047,
0.6277469993,
-0.4363662601,
0.4958201051,
0.0268795304,
0.2714082003,
-0.2105437815,
0.1695890725,
0.3944533169,
0.7886691093,
-0.4063620269,
-0.5657711029,
0.1945601851,
-0.4299968779,
-0.9208290577,
0.3486708999,
-0.7047761679,
0.3166783154,
-0.338326484,
-0.3974340558,
0.0638941005,
0.4929990172,
-0.1652185619,
0.1072871387,
0.5237621069,
0.6906645298,
0.5942736268,
-0.253485769,
0.6524205804,
-0.4209531248,
0.2826669216,
1.0125898123,
0.0398556367,
0.7650002837,
0.4593668878,
-0.1493806839,
0.8003954291,
0.6007430553,
-0.2079131156,
0.308508724,
-0.0718069747,
-0.4936968684,
-0.727019012,
-0.4236449599,
-0.0345419608,
0.7232695818,
0.3652017713,
-0.0009540962,
-0.5806477666,
-0.1486488879,
0.3220567107,
-0.0558152534,
0.1835549772,
1.1609522104,
-0.6168856025,
-1.2351636887,
0.4015966356,
0.2557872534,
0.2502973378,
-0.8329085708,
-0.2837066054,
-0.0823917538,
0.1218018085,
-0.3595644534,
-0.7418894768,
-0.038578514,
0.4692188501,
-0.2616475224,
-0.0545085035,
0.616944015,
-0.690122366,
-0.1978294402,
0.1591078043,
0.5971171856,
0.2031630278,
0.0853110552,
-0.5835277438,
0.0933443755,
0.0999525562,
-0.2317557782,
0.3783633411,
0.7032950521,
0.1382487714,
0.7282560468,
0.8938136697,
0.0827260911,
-0.1819240004,
0.0107587464,
0.708114624,
-0.1945560277,
-0.6086025834,
-1.0181213617,
0.7974854708,
-0.2106964141,
-0.2081187069,
0.7522927523,
0.9134688377,
0.3350795209,
0.1527784318,
1.1782900095,
-0.1673275381,
0.4884619117,
-0.5270314217,
0.7606198788,
-0.6547839046,
-0.5012720823,
0.103908591,
-0.3828305006,
-0.0744026378,
0.5997447968,
0.2253651023,
-0.2350809574,
0.9783130288,
0.8336240649,
-0.248283267,
0.0914943367,
0.1222273707,
0.4782832861,
0.2109631151,
0.145590961,
0.7621364594,
-0.270231545,
0.8511525989,
-0.1255753189,
-0.3399421573,
-0.369086653,
-1.4256135225,
-0.8755320311,
-0.8241654634,
-0.3277668059,
-0.5180739164,
-0.0584906302,
0.6429585218,
0.8835443854,
-0.7608880401,
-0.1163525283,
-0.1905258894,
0.0931403786,
0.1642055959,
-0.0854506642,
0.3265808523,
-0.158656016,
-0.4394629002,
0.5452550054,
0.0518268645,
0.0705675185,
-0.2755350173,
-0.1692852229,
-0.5156546235,
0.0232605655,
0.4609898031,
0.2644774616,
-0.8796415329,
-0.3134557605,
-0.1176217198,
0.4669997096,
0.0667111278,
1.0355246067,
-0.4133609831,
0.6746906638,
0.6107221842,
0.6379951239,
0.5388035178,
0.1188584492,
0.5571021438,
-0.4716591537,
-0.0198338814,
-0.2891404927,
0.7544566393,
0.5960360765,
-0.3082861304,
0.2615939081,
0.2711705565,
-0.6180372238,
-0.7717676759,
0.3914432824,
-0.8985176086,
-0.372790426,
0.9138863087,
-0.3829666972,
0.1743762642,
-0.6367031932,
-0.0523949862,
0.4949265122,
-0.5966097116,
1.0633897781,
1.1864432096,
0.169754684,
-0.1976785213,
-0.6152200103,
0.7296401262,
0.5613622069,
-1.2506186962,
0.5698655844,
0.6315566301,
0.4801546037,
0.3686026633,
-0.2116264552,
0.2053545862,
0.5367580056,
0.0721586347,
0.0289392937,
0.0176967252,
-0.52180475,
-0.2876876593,
0.3390714228,
-0.3304514885,
0.2033078671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16655v1
|
Grammatical vs Spelling Error Correction: An Investigation into the Responsiveness of Transformer-based Language Models using BART and MarianMT
| 2024-03-25T11:45:21 | 2024-03-25T11:45:21 |
Rohit Raju, Peeta Basa Pati, SA Gandheesh, Gayatri Sanjana Sannala, Suriya KS
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text continues to remain a relevant form of representation for information.
Text documents are created either in digital native platforms or through the
conversion of other media files such as images and speech. While the digital
native text is invariably obtained through physical or virtual keyboards,
technologies such as OCR and speech recognition are utilized to transform the
images and speech signals into text content. All these variety of mechanisms of
text generation also introduce errors into the captured text.
This project aims at analyzing different kinds of error that occurs in text
documents. The work employs two of the advanced deep neural network-based
language models, namely, BART and MarianMT, to rectify the anomalies present in
the text. Transfer learning of these models with available dataset is performed
to finetune their capacity for error correction. A comparative study is
conducted to investigate the effectiveness of these models in handling each of
the defined error categories. It is observed that while both models can bring
down the erroneous sentences by 20+%, BART can handle spelling errors far
better (24.6%) than grammatical errors (8.8%).
|
[
0.3051226437,
-1.0901427269,
0.5331399441,
0.2293704003,
0.369259268,
0.2867352068,
-0.4129560292,
-0.4064384997,
-0.0504880287,
0.532905221,
-0.3448596299,
-0.2140527815,
-0.6401186585,
0.4338635206,
-0.4634643793,
0.6710521579,
-0.2910110056,
0.3488138318,
-0.244938314,
0.0851680636,
-0.7438697815,
-0.7811121345,
-0.8175923228,
0.0671615228,
0.4844773114,
0.3173978329,
0.7108994126,
0.2950219512,
0.9230280519,
0.3979124129,
-0.1395299584,
0.2560130358,
-0.2532238662,
0.3811171651,
-0.2908752561,
-0.7483683228,
-0.6797459126,
-0.2356396914,
0.6119084954,
0.7347496152,
-0.0799148828,
-0.027972253,
-0.0619109608,
0.8237407207,
-0.4077196717,
0.1845048368,
-0.6463132501,
0.0307981763,
-0.2189845592,
0.1376496553,
-0.7023541927,
-0.6801187992,
0.0312068947,
-0.737398982,
0.4571147859,
0.0059468215,
0.7868240476,
0.4063384533,
-0.3361070752,
-0.6205801368,
-1.0802928209,
0.571190238,
-0.8558731675,
0.3461270928,
0.4912400246,
0.0573035106,
-0.2579143941,
-0.8857908249,
-0.823066175,
-0.0063182111,
-0.0547793061,
0.1878973395,
-0.3019256592,
0.2196457833,
0.2508555055,
0.3978002667,
-0.571490407,
0.2225288302,
-0.3848260343,
-0.1640913785,
0.3923554122,
0.2241726816,
0.4522214234,
-0.2956386805,
0.2221917361,
-0.3749878407,
-0.3194237947,
-0.0153788161,
0.3627665043,
0.5225547552,
0.0858704299,
0.7804349065,
0.1014496386,
0.4736695588,
0.1199702248,
-0.0565825626,
0.1066304073,
-0.4133398533,
-0.4830963314,
0.0342922956,
0.72807616,
0.2059633881,
0.3084187508,
0.0362488218,
-0.164963901,
0.2304922491,
0.5415828824,
-0.2418835908,
-0.2150511742,
-0.1243695766,
-0.4366229475,
-0.3840078712,
0.0710193366,
-0.6913481951,
-0.4818504453,
-0.5410611033,
0.476823926,
-0.3914954364,
-0.1053504795,
0.2145815641,
0.1274770498,
-0.3723973632,
0.520627737,
-0.898896277,
0.29747805,
0.2954038978,
0.5671158433,
0.1226242781,
-0.1023294702,
-0.1137674898,
-0.1854183227,
-0.401479274,
0.7409464121,
-0.1056650579,
-0.2530907094,
0.1515992582,
0.1501808167,
-0.6265294552,
-0.3864269853,
0.805929184,
-0.6113345623,
0.6491121054,
-0.2721202374,
-0.6227966547,
-0.4474339187,
0.3008360565,
-1.0835089684,
1.356369257,
0.2223646641,
-0.7438775897,
-0.0379043221,
-0.7729642987,
-0.4693670869,
-0.0986127481,
0.265604496,
-0.5901522636,
0.2983400822,
0.2973475158,
0.4122565091,
-0.1443839073,
0.2868062258,
-0.0081082182,
-0.1590803564,
0.5532640219,
-0.7479408383,
0.6247454882,
-0.0436113589,
-0.3777843416,
0.0113838855,
-1.0761004686,
-0.0929992795,
0.192582652,
-0.7858858109,
-0.3628997207,
-0.0203910246,
0.3914090097,
0.1071610898,
0.1302546859,
-0.5671109557,
0.3734002113,
-0.3155953288,
0.5361369848,
0.4830844998,
-0.2973548174,
0.5796088576,
-0.2175909132,
0.5541836023,
-0.1479558796,
0.0806380808,
-0.279161036,
-0.3941929042,
-0.9740613699,
0.1311715096,
0.7579352856,
0.767711401,
-0.938116014,
0.2744256556,
-0.4002757967,
-0.2873008847,
-0.8497120738,
-0.1406511217,
0.368386209,
0.7454966307,
0.3505224288,
-0.1192886606,
-0.7289821506,
-0.471708715,
-0.2379563302,
-0.4264572263,
0.4072468877,
0.1415385455,
0.2760826647,
-0.3628835082,
0.9234223962,
-0.1125354841,
-0.3308361471,
-0.2407697886,
0.0905039608,
0.0894180834,
0.3300885558,
0.5247741938,
-0.8303434253,
-0.5491182208,
0.1155474707,
-0.8036971092,
-0.1965727061,
-0.219361037,
0.2867610753,
0.8926687241,
0.4907982647,
-0.3242727816,
0.6263127327,
0.5510955453,
-0.3767380118,
0.7375589609,
-0.5197082758,
0.3686121404,
-1.038654685,
0.0230457056,
-0.1432587504,
-0.3831787705,
-0.7187209725,
0.1013604701,
0.4108400047,
0.0804149732,
-0.4198877215,
0.1575957984,
-0.3853460848,
0.1277474761,
-0.2807970643,
-0.0775931478,
0.249077186,
0.2387851924,
-0.1284170747,
0.7298582792,
0.1116221324,
-0.4632027745,
0.4919392169,
0.2975451648,
-0.0179914478,
0.6023041606,
-0.3965777755,
0.0418227538,
-0.2845108807,
0.155875504,
-1.1746329069,
-0.3288616538,
0.3698406816,
-0.5266381502,
0.6677674651,
0.1898550093,
-0.8237763047,
-0.5649291873,
0.0032613936,
0.2673017383,
0.2175936103,
-0.4004499316,
0.5522753,
0.0434075557,
-0.392208755,
-0.4504872262,
-0.9203860164,
0.3027634919,
0.1609875709,
-0.6582219005,
0.1549527496,
-0.0147983711,
-0.111368373,
0.3192352951,
0.2497191131,
-0.1092964485,
0.1289962083,
0.2627710402,
0.4278468788,
-0.4596908391,
0.4423401952,
0.1697143465,
0.0629767254,
-0.1067722067,
-0.0508386157,
0.3236007988,
-0.2082528323,
-0.379244715,
-0.5343497396,
0.2188689709,
0.7600681782,
-0.0516659431,
0.900903821,
0.4130998254,
-0.5244178772,
0.219313398,
-0.866845727,
0.069022961,
-0.381268084,
0.402849853,
-0.1820018589,
-0.6974897385,
0.5396942496,
0.057443805,
-0.201022625,
0.781981051,
0.3033302128,
-0.3856333494,
0.6552385688,
0.7491544485,
-0.037887387,
0.392267555,
-0.1445177794,
0.3519945741,
-0.5943318605,
-0.2450144887,
-0.7185544372,
-0.2719126046,
-0.4040060341,
-0.362652123,
0.0770233795,
0.0423976704,
-0.0132177118,
0.594316721,
-0.4135896564,
0.1489567012,
0.8105946779,
-0.028429918,
0.4569118619,
0.4135144055,
-0.3809885383,
-0.5426408052,
-0.8414888382,
-0.6062888503,
1.0279555321,
0.5077624321,
0.7042610645,
0.0128456112,
0.209115684,
0.2819412649,
0.1195422038,
-0.8043220043,
0.2825063169,
-0.5060907602,
-0.5551933646,
-0.3255316317,
-0.317902863,
-0.7820094824,
-0.0187811218,
-0.5691209435,
-0.337846756,
0.3457430601,
0.1820899695,
-0.1769370586,
0.6339820623,
-0.7337200642,
0.7389981747,
-0.1612242758,
-0.145857051,
-0.0204815958,
-0.7226939797,
-0.0322523452,
-0.1773698628,
0.3220710158,
0.2619856,
0.2988011241,
0.5446914434,
-0.3687819541,
0.9387303591,
0.1808294058,
-0.1733429283,
0.2513924539,
0.1185278147,
0.3728260994,
-0.6297408342,
-0.4184245467,
0.0532813184,
-0.1318107694,
0.044875443,
-0.5169535279,
0.2548520267,
-0.7153769135,
-0.0175234471,
-0.4179110229,
-0.4872858226,
0.107869029,
0.2742821574,
0.4499788284,
0.5762035251,
-0.3513490856,
0.0849612653,
0.5665871501,
-0.1902910471,
0.6702931523,
0.5591412187,
-0.1389182657,
-0.5425683856,
0.7621450424,
0.2887302041,
0.0953446403,
0.5032057166,
-0.0164780132,
-0.3352642059,
-0.3943091035,
-0.5889612436,
0.3015668988,
-0.7262711525,
-0.2476121485,
-0.5699151158,
-0.3463401496,
-0.5335248709,
-0.0303054955,
-0.4022622108,
-0.7194727659,
-0.5893415809,
-0.0864756629,
0.2666006386,
0.970928371,
0.05777945,
0.59263134,
-0.9414383769,
-0.0329587571,
-0.0808416232,
0.3567263484,
-0.1035031155,
-0.5310576558,
-0.2474046052,
0.117007561,
-0.525478065,
-0.9879016876,
0.4795144796,
0.2531141639,
0.2324866056,
-0.0166673269,
-0.232083112,
0.60180372,
-0.5476372242,
0.8685551286,
0.1857234836,
-1.0038994551,
0.6796956658,
-0.3221741021,
0.1184588745,
0.5361360908,
0.1171451658,
-0.92226547,
-0.4677859545,
-0.6762849092,
-0.6699198484,
0.8128386736,
0.2438218594,
0.042937614,
-0.0861920193,
0.5789761543,
0.1622543335,
0.1567379385,
-0.8711650372,
-0.1478907466,
-0.0127317552,
-0.6468809843,
-0.0424161926,
-0.4805651903,
0.4095457196,
-0.0277385395,
0.9029383659,
0.0333659947,
0.1619742066,
0.4213296473,
-0.5271311402,
-0.2672460675,
0.3828749359,
0.8242897987,
0.4152898192,
0.0202460717,
0.0739361718,
0.0823313296,
-0.8775538802,
0.2300361246,
0.0136887608,
-0.2587940693,
0.4138938785,
0.3340092897,
0.8308990002,
0.2982009649,
-0.4807618856,
0.4396609366,
-0.312852025,
-0.3565691411,
-0.222442314,
-0.3635770977,
-0.0541947186,
0.0106252674,
0.2669267058,
0.5662653446,
0.1597421318,
-0.3548400998,
-0.3435580432,
0.0249731354,
-0.3101679385,
-0.2924391031,
0.7328222394,
0.203968063,
-0.5297104716,
0.7658041716,
0.061387457,
-0.6160691977,
0.5917358994,
0.6576074958,
0.5959761143,
-0.5350298285,
0.3342285752,
0.3341603875,
0.5305923223,
-0.4169545174,
0.1015108302,
0.5487585664,
-0.7836216688,
-0.5709782243,
-0.3542506695,
-0.3832569718,
0.0731628686,
-0.5839244723,
0.0423337482,
-0.2735126913,
-0.5407855511,
-0.2082612514,
-0.2256289423,
-0.6040474176,
0.3886317909,
0.0714063868,
0.5797131062,
-0.9131765366,
0.4424814582,
1.0899808407,
-0.3465226293,
-0.9408305883,
-0.2762164474,
-0.1787971109,
-0.543071568,
0.6735135317,
-0.0905649886,
0.1775853336,
-0.1141912341,
-0.0722398013,
-0.7873552442,
0.8108506799,
0.4946204424,
-0.9499313235,
-0.278603375,
0.42759341,
0.7741178274,
0.1514963359,
0.3599209785,
0.370195955,
0.4483323693,
-0.0997524932,
-1.3893070221,
-0.161591664,
-0.2341045439,
0.3394333422,
0.1932732612,
-0.18188712,
0.7699326277,
-0.0569879413,
-0.1280869693,
0.2947302759,
0.4629700184,
-0.226705417,
0.3785871267,
0.2650046647,
0.7308792472,
1.1312606335,
-0.2064896077,
0.8731541634,
0.1067010462,
0.4812294841,
1.0506722927,
-0.0450594984,
1.1167769432,
0.3730016053,
-0.3501178026,
0.645481348,
0.4866225123,
0.0954229757,
0.1967592686,
-0.0235930048,
-0.1442701221,
0.1828171611,
0.2131782621,
-0.3015737236,
0.3128733039,
0.5101323128,
-0.6771973372,
0.0300374404,
0.409294039,
-0.0336416997,
0.5708705187,
-0.4595730901,
0.7486951351,
-0.1495357305,
-0.6215645075,
0.1179515645,
0.3902673721,
0.6700003147,
0.0007256457,
0.1465449482,
-0.1011275649,
0.579860568,
-0.2299660146,
-0.544187665,
0.442240566,
0.1147561297,
-0.6212941408,
-0.2984758615,
1.1451345682,
-0.4803193212,
-0.9345365167,
0.047748588,
0.3784776926,
0.0167875234,
-0.0986478403,
-0.5980685949,
0.0983114466,
-0.1312072575,
0.1588011533,
-0.193286851,
0.3668113947,
-0.0933640301,
0.3471258581,
0.4115939736,
0.1733986586,
0.4866134822,
0.2530660927,
0.4381482005,
-0.3475274444,
-0.4790577888,
-0.7818648219,
0.701824367,
0.0687978789,
-0.0684182793,
0.7143470049,
0.4651164412,
0.6622427702,
-0.5654340982,
0.7877706289,
0.1434313804,
0.7738713622,
-0.5996948481,
0.7632603049,
-0.2716677487,
0.0756623,
-0.4357272387,
-0.9743077755,
-0.6524524093,
0.7115389109,
-0.3006554544,
-0.2829286754,
0.913559556,
0.6299042106,
-0.0174667388,
0.1932555139,
0.1339751184,
0.2355622649,
0.1773018539,
0.4070083797,
0.7769855261,
-1.0093380213,
0.3974479735,
-0.0232686922,
-0.0486419313,
-0.5407534242,
-0.7236187458,
-0.6203565001,
-0.6637980342,
-0.5575938225,
-0.5736697912,
0.2336628437,
0.7442704439,
0.3520593643,
-0.7622525096,
0.0033957441,
-0.3716285229,
0.0630939007,
-0.1109690368,
-0.2691396475,
0.3748092055,
-0.4716033638,
-0.7974728942,
0.2126869857,
0.1110932082,
0.3639389277,
0.029443223,
0.1486451626,
-0.0397644415,
0.0312376935,
0.6411296725,
0.2272452563,
-0.6739339828,
-0.1207539141,
0.3960098624,
-0.4893953204,
0.1567937285,
0.6366994977,
-0.6356709599,
0.7013679147,
0.5352653265,
0.7705773711,
0.2454779446,
-0.2164958715,
0.5841113925,
-0.6512274146,
-0.1507412046,
0.0624847561,
0.3134059906,
0.6925435662,
-0.5796634555,
0.4686645567,
0.4893139303,
-0.6620790362,
-0.7020956874,
-0.2353763431,
-1.0249052048,
-0.1032141522,
0.9534039497,
-0.1621631086,
-0.1956287026,
0.025216734,
-0.7174052596,
0.4386406541,
-0.0577838048,
0.7560407519,
0.9454884529,
0.2145935148,
-0.1498996913,
-0.5093427896,
0.2458981723,
0.5616117716,
-0.663803339,
-0.2161868066,
0.4609311223,
0.2079888582,
0.4267628193,
0.4443341196,
-0.1710355729,
0.5067198277,
-0.1217617691,
0.2285709679,
-0.0828671306,
-0.2726033926,
-0.6956493258,
0.1528911442,
-0.0324228145,
-0.2725440264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16630v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16630v1
|
A comparative analysis of embedding models for patent similarity
| 2024-03-25T11:20:23 | 2024-03-25T11:20:23 |
Grazia Sveva Ascione, Valerio Sterzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This paper makes two contributions to the field of text-based patent
similarity. First, it compares the performance of different kinds of
patent-specific pretrained embedding models, namely static word embeddings
(such as word2vec and doc2vec models) and contextual word embeddings (such as
transformers based models), on the task of patent similarity calculation.
Second, it compares specifically the performance of Sentence Transformers
(SBERT) architectures with different training phases on the patent similarity
task. To assess the models' performance, we use information about patent
interferences, a phenomenon in which two or more patent claims belonging to
different patent applications are proven to be overlapping by patent examiners.
Therefore, we use these interferences cases as a proxy for maximum similarity
between two patents, treating them as ground-truth to evaluate the performance
of the different embedding models. Our results point out that, first, Patent
SBERT-adapt-ub, the domain adaptation of the pretrained Sentence Transformer
architecture proposed in this research, outperforms the current
state-of-the-art in patent similarity. Second, they show that, in some cases,
large static models performances are still comparable to contextual ones when
trained on extensive data; thus, we believe that the superiority in the
performance of contextual embeddings may not be related to the actual
architecture but rather to the way the training phase is performed.
|
[
0.0056875125,
-0.4326184094,
0.4791751504,
0.3008796573,
-0.2992598116,
0.069948785,
0.0298925638,
-0.4224758744,
0.0493014231,
0.5508939624,
0.0652305558,
-0.378448993,
-0.7236151099,
-0.0817053244,
-0.4387229383,
0.573284626,
-0.3134391904,
0.1331870407,
-0.6268303394,
-0.1052993238,
-0.49865821,
-0.4638693631,
0.1160106584,
-0.4451639056,
-0.0813472345,
-0.1847403347,
0.418104142,
0.426554054,
0.5273392797,
0.3618314564,
-0.2911388576,
-0.0979385525,
-0.2718833089,
-0.0192569215,
-0.3867498338,
-0.4801855087,
-0.01114514,
0.1400149763,
0.2476357222,
0.4551481605,
0.0286120996,
0.0281608514,
0.3650538027,
0.1058802903,
-0.4693464339,
0.1129236817,
-0.78853333,
0.4600660205,
0.2677509189,
-0.2910801768,
-0.5250248313,
-0.3958980739,
0.6004946232,
-0.4522010684,
0.6197423935,
0.4930008948,
1.1971558332,
0.2585207224,
-0.2786918581,
-0.3077738285,
-0.4048362672,
0.6207322478,
-0.7011916637,
0.2790907025,
-0.1165425554,
-0.1555327624,
-0.0707333982,
-1.0620990992,
-0.6987828016,
-0.4842695296,
-0.2519958317,
0.0797053799,
-0.418471694,
0.0241821352,
0.3467413187,
0.0804875046,
-0.7281653285,
0.1572042108,
-0.499103725,
-0.0500461534,
0.0559393577,
-0.1567451805,
0.0768181533,
-0.3053921759,
-0.8718425632,
-0.3179226518,
-0.8746489882,
-0.0480420552,
0.1813644618,
0.0469696596,
-0.0258764476,
0.5628973246,
-0.0504828691,
0.4617671669,
0.1366530061,
0.2103291452,
0.5563508868,
-0.0940590277,
-0.3805355728,
0.2497277111,
0.6869890094,
0.385904789,
0.2635914683,
-0.5712316036,
-0.0439981893,
-0.2095705569,
0.5680576563,
-0.7821033001,
-0.0561353266,
-0.1766988337,
-0.7402991652,
-0.1319456398,
0.4023046792,
-0.4263683856,
-0.3485155106,
-0.4181955159,
1.0401003361,
-0.203097105,
0.1134700626,
0.0988360792,
-0.6026242375,
0.42359671,
-0.2766806185,
-0.6767424345,
0.4189684689,
1.258054018,
1.0317060947,
-0.1081004441,
-0.5326346755,
-0.0353160426,
-0.1155059487,
-0.4147883952,
0.8816589713,
-0.4775276184,
-0.5798729062,
0.0354138613,
0.0629582182,
-0.3854643106,
-0.9532375932,
0.546202302,
-0.7041082978,
0.1912044585,
-0.2615891099,
-0.799151957,
-0.2613592446,
0.074448362,
-0.4286744893,
0.7290411592,
-0.0695902705,
-0.9548259974,
0.7810339332,
-0.5380706787,
-0.449221313,
-0.0973179713,
-0.0703224167,
-0.4937367439,
0.2851802111,
-0.2045584172,
0.6013127565,
-0.3929823339,
0.2184808254,
-0.3749589324,
-0.4753865302,
0.2856141627,
-0.1142243817,
0.5613191724,
0.2162548602,
-0.5790355802,
0.105270274,
-0.6097904444,
-0.0686207637,
-0.0800640881,
0.2590059042,
-0.709872663,
0.0634539798,
-0.167494759,
0.2459358722,
0.1826102883,
-0.8175022602,
0.0675973147,
-0.4827526808,
0.5549917817,
0.6286752224,
-0.1114881337,
0.3266200721,
-0.4970477819,
0.2948348522,
0.1005149931,
0.0226952359,
-0.2038847655,
-0.5074379444,
-0.5269949436,
-0.2335344106,
0.8051573038,
0.4691007137,
-0.1984646916,
0.5040821433,
-0.7645183802,
-0.4423664212,
-0.6395801902,
-0.278241843,
0.5119814873,
0.5445482135,
0.4328510463,
-0.7675868273,
-0.4549896419,
-1.1444706917,
-0.603110373,
0.0836504102,
-0.0101280855,
0.5294661522,
0.6223896146,
0.0610989146,
0.9762628675,
-0.5508332253,
-0.1423329264,
0.2447748035,
0.4483827651,
0.2524001896,
0.5676044226,
0.7029085159,
-0.6260618567,
-0.8223170638,
0.1525108814,
-0.6590663791,
-0.0698896199,
-0.082673274,
0.2675017416,
-0.041266378,
0.6775192022,
-0.6676608324,
0.553689003,
0.3310520053,
-0.470336169,
0.3679751158,
-0.5193424225,
0.3660043478,
-1.1562075615,
0.2208477557,
-0.3019398153,
-0.0801088214,
-0.5826370716,
0.0293085836,
0.2059724629,
-0.1477372497,
-0.5327133536,
0.4589734972,
-0.5033111572,
-0.2625098825,
-0.3813539147,
0.15486449,
0.1902372539,
0.1584519148,
-0.3610180616,
1.1106288433,
0.4934265614,
-0.3456628919,
0.1938959807,
0.4829573631,
-0.7930016518,
0.2956703007,
-1.0287622213,
0.19346717,
0.0847321823,
0.0980915055,
-0.8318783641,
0.3910838962,
-0.0393761806,
-0.1898441762,
0.3260463476,
0.0651171803,
-0.4615246058,
-0.5273198485,
-0.5630525947,
0.0978218168,
0.7251092196,
-0.8282303214,
0.5684019923,
0.0362114534,
-0.4054272771,
-0.7445194721,
-0.9159260392,
0.0778727829,
-0.4171859622,
-0.6085671186,
1.2835153341,
0.2970745862,
0.0309723951,
0.665915072,
0.0749088377,
-0.1762937456,
-0.128304854,
0.4938729703,
0.1422294825,
-0.521214366,
0.0303752553,
0.1933650225,
-0.1163514778,
-0.0656469837,
-0.2760183215,
0.3626870811,
0.2971375585,
-0.3965408802,
-0.4230196178,
0.1089168265,
0.4150277972,
-0.0175318588,
0.9061424732,
0.1231619492,
-0.1886099726,
-0.0846971944,
-0.614456296,
0.1296816766,
-0.4752087593,
0.3337688744,
-0.6808544993,
-0.933606863,
0.3275029957,
-0.3033992946,
-0.1994239837,
0.5604667068,
0.4621041715,
0.2245413959,
0.3604891896,
0.868715167,
-0.2367407978,
0.323189795,
-0.1676836908,
0.6034286022,
-0.8666237593,
-0.4007164538,
-0.7048937082,
-0.2222734541,
-0.3749771118,
-0.5653866529,
-0.1949040443,
0.02638424,
-0.3393807411,
0.9135145545,
-0.5363564491,
0.4496804774,
0.6365580559,
-0.2127020806,
0.0505424552,
0.2500860095,
-0.592363596,
-0.1116621047,
-0.5624648333,
-0.5857577324,
1.2618050575,
0.1759870201,
0.6764470339,
-0.2402533442,
0.4258475304,
0.5031400323,
0.1435931176,
-0.5664675236,
0.1871051788,
-0.4695981145,
-0.3084813654,
0.191489011,
-0.1360905766,
-0.8135336637,
0.4052129686,
-0.3237270117,
-0.7600186467,
0.5373691916,
-0.1468527466,
-0.3240052164,
0.2233768404,
-0.9792235494,
0.8684090972,
-0.1621488482,
-0.2774545848,
-0.581977129,
-0.3499010205,
-0.1288796812,
-0.2756777108,
-0.1904041171,
0.2875149548,
0.1489131898,
0.9646404982,
-0.214952141,
0.653319478,
-0.0812356174,
0.1934622824,
0.2410438806,
-0.3623005748,
0.1710616648,
-0.5851153731,
-0.2412151843,
0.0522851534,
0.077638939,
-0.0173031203,
-0.6663701534,
0.8699530363,
-0.5500614643,
-0.7224677205,
-0.4446678758,
-0.1776907444,
-0.0035905011,
0.1940971017,
0.3073973358,
0.4886904657,
-0.4894929528,
0.509340167,
0.290879488,
-0.3688858151,
0.3719001412,
0.4817571938,
0.3282155693,
-0.1559431404,
0.6628284454,
0.0701826289,
-0.1301826984,
0.6579312086,
0.0856688321,
-0.5117774606,
-0.4435285628,
-0.0330166928,
0.1811733097,
-0.6046264768,
-0.2748981416,
-0.9199629426,
-0.3649399281,
-0.4374812245,
-0.1630693972,
-0.3078681231,
-0.4349302053,
-0.3297910988,
-0.2413495332,
0.2362081259,
0.9073928595,
0.0118330484,
0.2009595186,
-0.5964716673,
0.3118621409,
0.4033873677,
0.5278023481,
0.2077158242,
-0.873036325,
-0.1447655857,
-0.1666135043,
-0.7416881323,
-0.5367535353,
0.0468877964,
0.3883477747,
0.6410093904,
0.4547046125,
-0.1335664093,
0.7319700122,
-1.0516492128,
0.8529983163,
0.102041088,
-1.2587817907,
0.0477152951,
0.3963220716,
-0.4503427744,
0.461071372,
0.4824840426,
-0.1382508129,
0.0902604312,
-0.7713840604,
-0.8013499975,
0.5059900284,
0.02370869,
0.5825957656,
0.2601017654,
0.4705249667,
0.2654455602,
0.208350867,
-0.4754094481,
-0.0180585925,
-0.2167072296,
-0.2875775099,
0.1461414546,
-0.315228641,
0.0390528701,
-0.1005329043,
0.4878339171,
0.3884362876,
0.5974057913,
0.2313990146,
-0.1603091359,
0.38489905,
0.3261987269,
0.6387774944,
0.4247221649,
-0.0849607065,
0.3141993284,
0.4092576206,
-0.5045139194,
0.1401502937,
0.3545863628,
-0.0040162937,
0.131628722,
0.5532005429,
1.0061281919,
0.3823515475,
-0.6460547447,
0.8101519942,
0.0988627076,
-0.3828561902,
0.2921613753,
0.0528661422,
-0.0184930451,
0.549644053,
0.1689394116,
0.1499330848,
0.3203296959,
-0.4764893055,
0.5416924953,
0.4691924453,
-0.5375987291,
-0.3502418101,
0.5395569205,
0.0321643241,
-0.5098206997,
0.187238425,
0.0346399322,
-1.0276702642,
0.7820212245,
0.8162308335,
1.0193858147,
0.0821170062,
-0.0609140471,
0.1297589988,
0.1704535931,
-0.32441926,
-0.1671963632,
-0.1057393104,
-0.4787480235,
-0.1249406412,
-0.2435566634,
-0.3738756478,
-0.1039745957,
-0.4817377627,
0.2694046795,
-0.3183470666,
-0.2678892016,
0.0058006346,
-0.175160557,
-0.6539970636,
0.0198717546,
-0.3470419943,
0.8636713624,
-0.8240628839,
0.7546577454,
0.4954760969,
-0.0140507091,
-0.6341028214,
0.2370237261,
-0.409275651,
-0.4663294256,
0.899710536,
0.3411268592,
-0.0917190164,
-0.2254066765,
-0.0041160006,
-0.538508594,
1.2787021399,
0.0834756494,
-0.4019099772,
0.1005944386,
0.2161188722,
0.605884552,
-0.6066127419,
0.1533223689,
0.3080932498,
-0.0262093097,
-0.1878054291,
-0.9860970378,
0.1351188719,
-0.1943846345,
0.2134817243,
-0.2103274018,
-0.4056008458,
0.7308725715,
0.0248017088,
-0.295807898,
0.4104652703,
0.3974744678,
0.0023772682,
0.2599109411,
0.2881837487,
0.7770456076,
0.4151163995,
-0.0103589203,
0.8491457105,
-0.638327837,
0.7632374763,
1.1635400057,
-0.6018466949,
1.1100860834,
0.3068550825,
-0.279697001,
0.4846616685,
0.0538580865,
-0.6318680048,
0.9094763994,
0.2768490613,
0.1635712385,
0.3957017362,
-0.1077883095,
-0.7286282182,
0.2743537128,
-0.1069241017,
-0.7336767912,
-0.0079414574,
-0.0689091459,
-0.2923214138,
0.1695234478,
0.3849663734,
0.701158464,
0.2372892797,
-0.5076140165,
0.3584457338,
0.3011374772,
0.8923819661,
-0.3039547503,
0.1645403057,
0.1151658818,
0.1411329955,
0.118424587,
-0.5956686139,
0.3819492757,
0.2807358801,
-0.1839251369,
-0.1481897235,
0.6305519342,
-0.0611507446,
-0.0747150406,
0.5403581858,
0.1009434536,
-0.0777804404,
0.2057300359,
-0.6327929497,
-0.1701401919,
-0.2291798741,
-0.0690392926,
0.0244678762,
0.2827066481,
0.2155093849,
0.4959661067,
0.3696278334,
0.096963577,
0.4108583629,
0.0793396905,
0.74789083,
-0.7150261998,
-0.4792355895,
-0.7134533525,
0.17238608,
-0.2637909651,
-0.4238607585,
0.6010663509,
0.8154368401,
0.5935842991,
-0.528337121,
0.4389419258,
0.0648727044,
0.5520027876,
-0.6080119014,
0.7050019503,
-0.4691087008,
0.1542811543,
-0.3134996593,
-1.1390844584,
-0.256432116,
0.7362298369,
-0.3533785343,
-0.0832245871,
0.9561660886,
1.01626122,
-0.5673339367,
0.102738373,
0.1279126257,
0.2430907339,
0.2744523287,
0.2598951459,
0.8792623878,
-0.6399181485,
0.0811860189,
-0.0091246329,
-0.0745255053,
-0.2917683721,
-0.9298657775,
-0.8248565793,
-0.6901358962,
-0.2382555902,
-0.0221982673,
0.1422331482,
0.7616632581,
0.6756259799,
-0.8534118533,
0.0984797552,
-0.0585443303,
-0.1281745881,
0.052744858,
-0.1902397126,
0.7195631266,
-0.1529528201,
-0.3879953027,
0.2427659333,
0.2816343307,
0.1297480762,
0.2038782835,
0.1913168877,
0.0575478673,
0.3702043593,
0.66431427,
0.0171485897,
-0.7825108767,
-0.4363752306,
-0.0159242973,
-0.2128674835,
0.1318197101,
1.0559483767,
-0.7878626585,
0.4925130308,
0.6776547432,
0.9026387334,
0.4718815684,
0.1213199869,
0.3040015399,
-0.4211220443,
0.5574008822,
-0.0631407052,
0.4393794537,
0.2769862711,
-0.0852397531,
0.2070851177,
0.0392115526,
-0.4421362877,
-0.6444199681,
-0.0371928029,
-0.9342536926,
-0.4742890894,
0.8817099333,
-0.4848400652,
0.0645658597,
0.005928522,
-0.1094514951,
0.2551995516,
0.0618678592,
1.0004649162,
0.7043210864,
0.1944201887,
0.4183208942,
-0.1879866719,
0.2255361676,
0.54952842,
-0.3304493129,
-0.2822945118,
-0.1938217878,
0.4375122488,
0.400993377,
0.1368128657,
-0.2630308568,
-0.0404181927,
0.2815969288,
-0.0045012166,
-0.1233013645,
-0.2721010447,
-0.4826249778,
0.3819254339,
0.0830089822,
-0.3474481702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16614v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16614v1
|
Semantically Enriched Cross-Lingual Sentence Embeddings for Crisis-related Social Media Texts
| 2024-03-25T10:44:38 | 2024-03-25T10:44:38 |
Rabindra Lamsal, Maria Rodriguez Read, Shanika Karunasekera
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tasks such as semantic search and clustering on crisis-related social media
texts enhance our comprehension of crisis discourse, aiding decision-making and
targeted interventions. Pre-trained language models have advanced performance
in crisis informatics, but their contextual embeddings lack semantic
meaningfulness. Although the CrisisTransformers family includes a sentence
encoder to address the semanticity issue, it remains monolingual, processing
only English texts. Furthermore, employing separate models for different
languages leads to embeddings in distinct vector spaces, introducing challenges
when comparing semantic similarities between multi-lingual texts. Therefore, we
propose multi-lingual sentence encoders (CT-XLMR-SE and CT-mBERT-SE) that embed
crisis-related social media texts for over 50 languages, such that texts with
similar meanings are in close proximity within the same vector space,
irrespective of language diversity. Results in sentence encoding and sentence
matching tasks are promising, suggesting these models could serve as robust
baselines when embedding multi-lingual crisis-related social media texts. The
models are publicly available at: https://huggingface.co/crisistransformers.
|
[
-0.1230121553,
-0.5033043027,
0.429869622,
0.6959779263,
-0.3173846602,
0.4648101032,
-0.217393443,
-0.4270570576,
0.5417820215,
0.1870409995,
-0.6603163481,
-0.4718683958,
-0.6949883699,
0.4360892475,
-0.4490465522,
0.7984622717,
-0.1895835102,
0.0878927112,
0.0132666938,
-0.0515288785,
-0.28631863,
-0.3529790938,
-0.3650343716,
0.4204218984,
0.6812549233,
0.5461858511,
0.8890179396,
0.2411748916,
0.4843446016,
0.3257240653,
-0.1048252881,
0.1431509256,
-0.8875337243,
0.1371319443,
-0.1408230215,
0.0823919475,
-0.005774131,
-0.4362025559,
0.4013207853,
0.3696940541,
-0.0516514666,
-0.2475584745,
0.1950557381,
0.2256304771,
-0.6875026226,
0.0739539936,
-0.472653538,
0.0726986229,
0.2921823263,
-0.3193840384,
-0.2460005879,
-0.2604358792,
0.2327341735,
-0.7141680121,
0.0366125368,
0.0282331426,
0.8046558499,
0.1188491508,
-0.6956398487,
-0.3238343298,
-0.6658673882,
0.4545730948,
-0.3113243878,
0.4455683231,
-0.012831158,
0.117297411,
0.1259374768,
-0.7182460427,
-0.4152494669,
0.3289075196,
-0.1211987063,
0.335670501,
-0.2827722728,
0.0518403128,
-0.1757936329,
0.0639879331,
-0.6103436351,
0.0037106527,
-0.3767984509,
-0.2393511832,
0.4701805115,
0.1921364814,
0.6474589705,
-0.6866333485,
-0.6504707932,
-0.1274889708,
-0.6841807365,
-0.1312776059,
0.235532105,
0.4889256954,
-0.4969072342,
0.5470253825,
-0.0408219099,
0.2980484366,
-0.3901328743,
-0.003069354,
0.1899244785,
-0.6036176682,
-0.0902927592,
0.2859608233,
0.8242975473,
0.6262785196,
0.2891636193,
-0.249634251,
-0.0615400076,
0.1009617671,
0.4103012383,
-0.9655179381,
0.2025817931,
0.1272214353,
-0.3354887962,
-0.136211589,
0.1975162774,
-0.701200366,
-0.3585766256,
0.0292712301,
0.4540543556,
-0.5129258633,
-0.176608339,
0.4180783927,
-0.4493805468,
-0.0758381709,
-0.0677236989,
-0.3702964485,
-0.0736353993,
0.6561867595,
0.9373324513,
0.2504876256,
-0.2186168134,
-0.2946184278,
0.2563162744,
-0.174844563,
0.7502148747,
-0.7459031343,
-0.4325897694,
0.5559441447,
0.3181419969,
-0.070396468,
-0.1976962984,
1.0193887949,
-0.3623232543,
-0.0060917721,
-0.5524359345,
-0.4038361311,
-0.0885833502,
0.2119463533,
-0.5852719545,
0.8301587701,
-0.0527395308,
-1.012827754,
0.3488808572,
-0.5343613029,
-0.6600270271,
-0.0281387735,
-0.0923629627,
-0.191815272,
0.0200911425,
0.5475110412,
0.92552495,
-0.2462058663,
0.1639658362,
-0.5327811241,
-0.3375112414,
0.1233738288,
-0.1833788753,
0.5217095017,
0.0838810205,
-0.0617118254,
0.1993174553,
-0.5294242501,
-0.1983574927,
0.2081623971,
-0.1995271444,
-0.7130805254,
-0.0303347744,
0.716461122,
0.4888957441,
0.1410603672,
-0.7437544465,
-0.1804584414,
-0.3013263047,
0.5900145173,
0.3809877336,
0.1526349038,
0.3780770898,
-0.3284546137,
0.4356351495,
0.3914487362,
0.0943060219,
-0.4079296887,
-0.3149171174,
-0.5376825333,
-0.2244259715,
-0.1633736938,
0.9183490276,
-1.1026030779,
0.3414106965,
-0.4684930146,
-0.4383407235,
-0.6223061681,
-0.11548765,
0.1937355697,
0.1087894961,
0.4659354091,
0.1413438022,
-0.7989957929,
-0.9325053692,
-0.3556063771,
0.0745640621,
0.1511856019,
0.1523952186,
0.4287739396,
-0.305434227,
0.7443253398,
-0.2250407636,
-0.1324020922,
-0.6629427671,
0.1688050479,
-0.3152881563,
0.005416397,
0.5690521002,
-1.1209357977,
-0.5704407692,
0.0349928252,
-0.6516584158,
-0.0382659547,
-0.3642852604,
-0.1557633281,
0.0543856956,
0.5658587217,
-0.4403557777,
0.2738257647,
0.6119166017,
-0.6198559403,
0.0615532212,
-0.0940771773,
0.4944264591,
-1.6425474882,
-0.2648273706,
0.0590014905,
-0.3056861758,
-0.7627871037,
-0.1034955308,
0.1751734614,
-0.2299040109,
-0.6466318369,
0.3984375298,
-0.5795466304,
0.0659877881,
-0.0418876484,
0.596797049,
-0.1560503393,
0.007302138,
0.0372391753,
0.4196867049,
0.7137554884,
-0.0699524805,
0.2405958027,
0.3436318338,
-0.4304410219,
0.5226224065,
-0.7170069218,
-0.3138847351,
-0.4748048484,
0.3004940152,
-0.860591352,
-0.1959363222,
0.2019165605,
-0.1212771833,
0.1143504158,
0.0976249799,
-0.6559273005,
-0.2998261154,
-0.3375014365,
0.3907286525,
0.1081603914,
-0.3155835569,
0.4728642404,
0.5305352211,
-0.2985992432,
-0.6536955833,
-0.7800744176,
0.3550723791,
-0.2849098146,
-0.8533773422,
0.4735962451,
0.1608269215,
0.03492973,
0.3487456143,
0.2288059294,
-0.0662792996,
0.0190164745,
0.2764369845,
0.2992486358,
-0.2525923252,
0.3361938894,
0.2935566306,
0.070913665,
-0.11307998,
-0.1659342349,
0.4978156984,
-0.0699339509,
-0.173077777,
-0.0488539077,
1.0034217834,
0.4455491006,
-0.0791486427,
1.0921138525,
0.6342584491,
-0.5993515849,
-0.0313178711,
-0.4629005194,
-0.0670135096,
-0.4280045331,
0.4793395102,
-0.074414663,
-1.4508736134,
0.6361275315,
0.152536571,
-0.0871347114,
0.3229231536,
0.5255957842,
0.2515746951,
0.7668309808,
0.6626073122,
-0.2621640265,
0.2638186514,
-0.0277902242,
0.5857453942,
-0.1937873363,
0.0190022681,
-0.3492561281,
-0.1381894648,
-0.6014416218,
-0.5588726401,
0.5228119493,
-0.0761333704,
-0.2070008814,
0.404587239,
-0.3256264031,
0.4666687548,
0.0365129448,
-0.0082387729,
0.1159769297,
0.0101861786,
0.0627612248,
-0.1691984832,
-1.0526229143,
-0.3931725323,
0.2893730104,
0.2677716911,
0.6664681435,
-0.0049382513,
0.7348965406,
-0.0609255098,
0.1060425118,
-0.5317155719,
0.2809500396,
-0.294323802,
-0.4373990893,
-0.0740644187,
-0.4247301221,
-0.8653942943,
0.1609819382,
-0.3323698938,
-0.6281423569,
0.3259880841,
-0.2955314219,
-0.6155787706,
0.0522205718,
-0.4325477481,
1.2074636221,
-0.12756598,
0.2085508257,
-0.4059896171,
-0.7066858411,
0.1482922882,
-0.1302802861,
0.5299287438,
-0.0163129736,
-0.2630606294,
0.50854671,
-0.3773582578,
1.076384902,
0.2153268903,
-0.0224768929,
0.265275687,
-0.2402481139,
0.3398097754,
0.1183141395,
0.2930181026,
-0.0350653268,
0.2488238066,
-0.3694655895,
-0.3758046925,
0.6716030836,
-0.6496784091,
-0.2437438965,
-0.1539502144,
-0.6430366039,
-0.148991704,
0.0585195236,
0.4588277638,
0.6379747391,
-0.4994231462,
0.3378405869,
0.3097176254,
-0.4784923494,
0.665645957,
0.2613732219,
-0.0635258555,
-0.427570194,
0.7392581701,
0.0901585445,
0.1314270198,
0.7472271919,
0.0258207247,
-0.1026629359,
0.1359705776,
-0.3017706573,
0.2229545265,
-0.9367499352,
-0.4170283377,
-1.0832468271,
-0.2514360249,
-0.4906128943,
-0.6324422359,
-0.2836378515,
-0.3453544676,
-0.2668918967,
-0.3427802026,
0.5626369119,
0.5998657346,
-0.3480020463,
0.1967878342,
-1.2852233648,
0.3069493771,
-0.4059520364,
0.1055329293,
-0.1857757717,
-0.2017338276,
-0.4134337306,
0.004537825,
0.048747208,
-1.2103017569,
0.4455884397,
0.3633075655,
0.1500471532,
0.4504264891,
0.3584127128,
0.7938714027,
-0.8130600452,
0.6807290912,
0.1596697271,
-0.881300211,
0.4894220233,
-0.4214012325,
0.1667333692,
0.3800531924,
0.9311379194,
-1.005158186,
-0.7100170255,
-0.2233627886,
-0.9744018316,
0.4549132288,
0.1599982232,
0.7106534243,
-0.4636955559,
0.0702904835,
-0.1350524873,
-0.1014682725,
-0.6453918219,
-0.1339746714,
-0.367287159,
-0.3509342968,
-0.0467082821,
-0.502554059,
0.0691007823,
0.0330400728,
0.4454768896,
0.0519079119,
0.143145591,
0.3805100918,
-0.0983336717,
-0.0996202901,
0.4519649744,
0.2930445969,
0.1254517287,
0.2467537969,
0.0083573041,
0.1903497875,
-0.3709667921,
0.1742010117,
0.3600652218,
-0.08591225,
0.2397156358,
0.4507997334,
0.6894519925,
1.1397072077,
-0.8591743708,
0.7347057462,
-0.2302450836,
0.0907716155,
-0.2885980308,
-0.4443584085,
0.3990443051,
0.5104951859,
0.3004865646,
-0.3101782501,
0.3590541482,
-0.7332078218,
0.2699731588,
0.339949578,
-0.3977275491,
-0.2036077231,
0.3701618612,
0.1586114317,
-0.0205509905,
0.1331316084,
-0.2623567283,
-0.8800939918,
0.3322642446,
0.5700560212,
0.9716416597,
-0.3827408254,
0.5823021531,
0.3242555857,
0.5245650411,
-0.3463086784,
0.6658079028,
0.2750365138,
-0.8296331167,
-0.4709322751,
-0.505889833,
-0.0530768484,
-0.2919532657,
-0.5942190289,
0.415612936,
-0.0951593518,
0.0820587352,
-0.2509086132,
-0.5338512063,
-0.6964017749,
0.0613050982,
0.124652952,
0.9893558025,
-0.916254282,
0.3452489972,
0.7017844319,
-0.1408949643,
-0.8402425051,
-0.1060408279,
-0.0759180933,
-0.359010756,
0.3364750147,
0.4739184678,
0.0890622586,
-0.2952131629,
-0.1921298951,
-0.9318462014,
0.8326387405,
0.4958347678,
-0.6095560789,
-0.3063717484,
0.5811692476,
0.6002996564,
-0.6257267594,
-0.0272804648,
0.1469864547,
0.3055231571,
0.020803066,
-0.7414368987,
0.2298734784,
-0.3824831545,
-0.0116508231,
0.2234850675,
-0.3977842629,
0.5536797643,
-0.0723073557,
-0.5719997287,
-0.160619393,
0.7832903266,
-0.231689468,
0.1715870947,
0.3716046512,
0.4381141365,
0.3611604571,
-0.0620646998,
1.2771316767,
-0.6682001352,
0.246023789,
0.8817106485,
-0.1261612624,
0.996396184,
0.0360206738,
0.4823121727,
0.5772337317,
0.5973753929,
0.184711501,
0.5042688847,
-0.1440560669,
-0.2850813866,
-0.4469214678,
-0.2764293551,
-0.0998737738,
0.4504143596,
0.4672064185,
-0.5316045284,
-0.4352385402,
0.2943568826,
0.1297207177,
0.04833946,
-0.2757091522,
0.551224947,
0.3069681525,
-0.3174095154,
0.2614876926,
0.1063491181,
0.6530634761,
-0.3062244952,
0.3399244845,
0.0412201285,
-0.0502340421,
-0.0961344466,
-0.6214286089,
0.7515262365,
0.0939892605,
-0.0134386765,
-0.3365671337,
0.866551578,
-0.7829195857,
-0.8006521463,
0.7336217761,
0.7956150174,
-0.2222540528,
-0.1933239698,
-0.5224400759,
0.2252885699,
-0.4328786731,
-0.1243438721,
0.0992569029,
0.8828639984,
0.1622042656,
0.4556179643,
0.2068227082,
-0.1478497535,
0.044495631,
0.3143883049,
0.9705582261,
-0.62128371,
-0.7751401067,
-0.8650957346,
0.5637073517,
-0.1713582426,
-0.3629248142,
0.748444438,
0.549464047,
0.8474978805,
-0.0137433028,
0.8229134679,
-0.0086198645,
0.4813394547,
-0.4378980398,
0.7954777479,
-0.7295598984,
-0.0897553563,
-0.5546910763,
-0.6394134164,
-0.1995649934,
0.4046310186,
-0.1681464911,
-0.2130849063,
0.5824617147,
0.8828526735,
-0.2480030209,
0.218295306,
0.220840469,
0.1897865385,
-0.0405778773,
0.6341761351,
1.0320934057,
-0.3326422572,
0.7867009044,
-0.162751466,
0.0510233305,
-0.2172658145,
-0.9217102528,
-1.0953623056,
-0.9326404333,
-0.2080367059,
-0.1645202637,
0.0669657141,
1.0190495253,
0.24215886,
-0.50043118,
0.0857413262,
0.1622539014,
0.086290665,
0.1233914346,
-0.2106490284,
0.0847356319,
-0.2843371034,
-0.4184373319,
0.4788074493,
0.5900774002,
-0.0101294965,
-0.2444638163,
0.1060872003,
-0.1338453442,
0.4493216574,
0.7588685751,
-0.2398385406,
-0.6515387893,
-0.5575036407,
0.2534992695,
-0.3007385135,
-0.1258421838,
1.0914152861,
-0.4232962728,
0.0107556963,
0.5582752228,
0.9287953973,
-0.0676650926,
-0.2295043617,
0.4717988074,
-0.7678358555,
0.2044688165,
0.1589261889,
0.7025080919,
0.8152276874,
-0.497664094,
0.3614350855,
0.1044455022,
-0.2769338787,
-0.7895727754,
0.1416811347,
-0.8644483089,
-0.4033077061,
1.3357764482,
-0.2687865198,
-0.0234032348,
-0.111996226,
-0.1279705912,
0.4090876877,
-0.4288570583,
0.8024058342,
0.7936710119,
0.5238119364,
-0.4343099296,
-0.3822999895,
0.4049809575,
0.3202182353,
-0.887537837,
-0.0100964764,
0.3774605989,
-0.0658530891,
0.2857726514,
0.3025257885,
0.0580314361,
0.3397982121,
-0.0887049362,
-0.3150839508,
0.1659843624,
-0.3484977782,
-0.2389444113,
0.2863485217,
-0.684687674,
0.2878177762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16609v1
|
Conversational Grounding: Annotation and Analysis of Grounding Acts and Grounding Units
| 2024-03-25T10:39:18 | 2024-03-25T10:39:18 |
Biswesh Mohapatra, Seemab Hassan, Laurent Romary, Justine Cassell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Successful conversations often rest on common understanding, where all
parties are on the same page about the information being shared. This process,
known as conversational grounding, is crucial for building trustworthy dialog
systems that can accurately keep track of and recall the shared information.
The proficiencies of an agent in grounding the conveyed information
significantly contribute to building a reliable dialog system. Despite recent
advancements in dialog systems, there exists a noticeable deficit in their
grounding capabilities. Traum provided a framework for conversational grounding
introducing Grounding Acts and Grounding Units, but substantial progress,
especially in the realm of Large Language Models, remains lacking. To bridge
this gap, we present the annotation of two dialog corpora employing Grounding
Acts, Grounding Units, and a measure of their degree of grounding. We discuss
our key findings during the annotation and also provide a baseline model to
test the performance of current Language Models in categorizing the grounding
acts of the dialogs. Our work aims to provide a useful resource for further
research in making conversations with machines better understood and more
reliable in natural day-to-day collaborative dialogs.
|
[
-0.4577185214,
-1.1704113483,
0.5519251227,
0.1462564021,
-0.1504179537,
0.1253691763,
-0.0346483104,
-0.3112342358,
0.0990749747,
0.7433969975,
-0.2724491358,
-0.5517762303,
-0.469550699,
-0.2005937099,
-0.2087663561,
0.7936744094,
0.2252762616,
-0.0005828601,
-0.6195880175,
-0.674423039,
-1.1649779081,
-1.043620348,
-0.6053506732,
-0.7482618093,
0.0886728615,
0.3088044524,
1.0129759312,
0.2157054842,
0.4177176058,
0.3485027552,
-0.2356262356,
-0.0224346817,
-0.5936440825,
0.32953462,
0.0426107831,
-0.4850968421,
-0.4313275814,
0.2548684478,
0.5687545538,
1.1737668514,
0.0695151538,
-0.2723076046,
-0.1837734878,
0.5615100861,
-0.2495066077,
0.3409253657,
-0.4542324245,
0.2153084278,
0.3579113483,
-0.5773970485,
-0.6230729818,
-0.4228931665,
0.1349966228,
-0.5675478578,
0.0690964609,
0.1065463349,
0.8458740115,
0.3523733914,
-0.2920512855,
-0.4444098771,
-0.4736509025,
0.4747495651,
-0.4319606423,
0.3457342386,
0.6535053849,
-0.0001444881,
-0.0612241253,
-0.4364183247,
-0.2711887658,
-0.7914596796,
-0.3795509934,
0.0257517304,
0.012486238,
0.3853178024,
0.4819816053,
0.4439342916,
-0.058541663,
-0.2387149036,
-0.2965811491,
-0.2183105052,
0.0895723775,
-0.0207908731,
0.5402466059,
-0.0247340314,
-0.3077052534,
-0.0463928506,
-0.5116550326,
-0.0615499802,
0.1597855687,
0.1991482824,
-0.3130981922,
0.5200530887,
-0.2111301422,
0.5501536727,
0.1839923561,
-0.0374485813,
0.2876295149,
0.0005453238,
-0.5425668359,
0.2230331153,
0.4828743935,
0.7987126708,
0.222285524,
-0.4053955078,
0.0533358902,
0.1971072257,
0.3604334295,
-0.5979939699,
-0.1653080881,
0.1376490146,
-0.3188260794,
-0.6613132358,
0.1314484179,
-0.2007755339,
-0.5911515355,
-0.7723721862,
0.2390569896,
-0.4568057656,
-0.3139288723,
-0.2177953124,
-0.2291185558,
-0.0609224848,
0.3336053193,
-0.6525728703,
0.6370177269,
0.7400076985,
0.8871360421,
0.3144806325,
-0.1632111222,
-0.7388442755,
-0.0220863912,
-0.5185636282,
0.5817033052,
-0.4750492275,
-0.3954895735,
0.1973394454,
0.2253120095,
-0.0444922745,
-0.4547441304,
0.7260727882,
-0.6112191081,
0.2231177688,
-0.492667675,
-0.5555554628,
-0.5349645615,
0.5166971087,
-0.524307847,
0.8677585125,
0.0770254582,
-0.8414649367,
0.1385675073,
-0.7103574276,
-0.3767788708,
0.2513144612,
-0.3225797713,
0.0754985586,
0.229318887,
-0.2435963899,
0.5459786057,
-0.1243316978,
0.4898670018,
-0.1611981094,
-0.3191900551,
0.3846932948,
-0.2563204765,
0.7189391851,
-0.1542045772,
-0.3934022784,
0.0817258283,
-0.737244606,
0.0053779795,
-0.1134898886,
-0.0414896682,
-0.4602196813,
0.0054970877,
-0.0982370377,
0.128743276,
0.1291774511,
-0.0202086959,
-0.0606859922,
-0.2721628547,
0.5221992135,
0.368452549,
0.2924937904,
0.5839774013,
-0.3349702358,
0.1234218925,
0.0783454701,
-0.2927679121,
-0.585052669,
-0.3769145608,
-1.0093386173,
0.0944228321,
0.1750582457,
0.6297221184,
-0.2975376546,
0.6683434248,
-0.2114639282,
-0.3512715995,
-0.2105030864,
-0.1659370661,
0.3530915976,
0.663197577,
0.3029819131,
-0.4166568518,
-0.5218927264,
-0.8803364635,
0.2880595624,
-0.5846925974,
-0.0024620956,
0.289938122,
0.0061079888,
-0.3251283765,
1.0712393522,
-0.2162582725,
-0.0641705021,
-0.017304359,
0.7202587128,
-0.2722634971,
0.651968658,
0.4771215618,
-0.7498542666,
-0.1092719808,
0.1053749397,
-1.2453639507,
-0.4672304094,
-0.2209586203,
-0.2612792253,
0.067225486,
0.6717957854,
-0.7944892645,
0.3710213304,
0.3824509084,
-0.3465403616,
0.2466515154,
-0.2352264673,
0.5705778599,
-0.5541661382,
0.0068267421,
-0.2635106742,
-0.4782978296,
-0.9492374063,
-0.0065706768,
-0.3136845529,
-0.0604162961,
-0.2216029614,
0.1109597459,
-0.3704071641,
-0.1764172167,
-0.3363900781,
0.4353123605,
0.1013228968,
0.4652062654,
0.1247454733,
0.8477212787,
0.517362535,
-0.7103437781,
0.07765086,
0.4354344308,
0.2973487079,
0.8673408628,
-0.6227448583,
0.5335521698,
-0.2376211137,
0.2923017442,
-0.9040426016,
-0.1270796508,
0.3644653857,
-0.4441790581,
-0.1419371068,
-0.4318167567,
-0.4602668583,
0.1981015205,
0.1066539809,
0.1464454681,
0.3751660287,
-0.2356922776,
0.656265974,
0.746511519,
-0.0173942801,
-0.0676891357,
-0.3470130861,
0.3787924647,
-0.4830565155,
-0.9506065845,
0.0825202614,
-0.1063216999,
-0.8180649877,
-0.4437794685,
-0.035798952,
-0.1567847878,
0.4699332416,
0.881100595,
0.0285714269,
-0.2653589249,
0.2666068673,
-0.3322575986,
-0.4016225934,
0.2926411629,
-0.1684276015,
0.8619168997,
-0.4174202681,
-0.2339473963,
-0.5941259861,
0.362439245,
0.8546467423,
0.0716541708,
0.8049992323,
0.3394956589,
-0.6041589975,
0.4565149546,
-0.8065910935,
-0.0842222348,
-0.4275209308,
-0.1345373243,
-0.4733331203,
-0.695327878,
0.5637646317,
-0.1241333559,
0.0189021192,
0.4191505313,
0.4093396664,
-0.1508060396,
0.7835522294,
0.7674524188,
-0.1218396276,
0.3285137415,
-0.0966567323,
0.1934278011,
-0.5183131099,
-0.1240666732,
-0.4778978527,
0.1774294525,
-0.427852571,
-0.5542002916,
-0.1260735691,
0.347217381,
0.0503107272,
0.1442827135,
-0.3338660002,
0.3723784685,
0.4473635852,
-0.1759414971,
0.2463770658,
0.0375824869,
-0.1131379157,
-0.0620202571,
-0.1377285123,
-1.1990783215,
0.4360286295,
0.5835881233,
0.1588721871,
-0.1754165292,
0.3199119568,
0.5887699723,
0.389872849,
-0.6362171769,
0.5860885382,
0.3608789146,
-0.3794593811,
-0.2387457341,
-0.2831524611,
-0.5291751623,
0.3882470727,
-0.0641647354,
-0.8238865733,
-0.1538579464,
-0.0264998171,
-0.1629614085,
0.0059345467,
-0.7671203613,
0.8578660488,
-0.0143152885,
-0.2024657279,
-0.404217869,
-0.8864144087,
0.1961451769,
0.3644685745,
0.2904401422,
-0.3305245638,
0.4702187777,
0.8550108671,
-0.1784141213,
0.9444410205,
-0.4136402309,
-0.17244187,
0.5605133176,
0.036935389,
0.1784089655,
0.0968499705,
0.0249327179,
0.3918665349,
-0.1034952179,
-0.328589052,
-0.4620909691,
0.3906821907,
-0.7076464891,
-0.5644190907,
-0.2847067118,
-0.4218963981,
-0.2357289195,
0.15263623,
-0.0835563242,
0.6142382622,
-0.6657786965,
0.4109266996,
0.8290574551,
0.1650662124,
0.1993806064,
0.3725614548,
-0.1895509511,
-0.4774345458,
0.6462957263,
-0.0151776243,
0.32640782,
0.3705508113,
-0.0375644714,
0.0625484139,
-0.3792760372,
-0.1107485294,
-0.0582580268,
-0.9638542533,
0.0720009133,
-1.0739820004,
-0.1938850135,
-0.3139279485,
-0.3829709589,
-0.0194597375,
-0.5696590543,
-0.3657325804,
-0.5722885132,
0.0477780588,
0.595649302,
-0.010966274,
0.6888589859,
-0.7613739371,
0.3610745668,
0.2206494212,
-0.1632097661,
-0.2010587305,
-0.2003135383,
-0.1103429422,
0.2954307497,
-0.3917866647,
-0.9235413671,
-0.0205042809,
-0.1722766161,
0.5022906661,
0.4092354774,
-0.0431975313,
0.7713787556,
-0.4807121158,
0.9106314778,
0.3937823474,
-1.1120098829,
0.5524382591,
-0.4623619616,
-0.1262503713,
0.8536468148,
-0.1860505939,
-1.057931304,
-0.5968267322,
-1.0130962133,
-0.7203892469,
0.5991928577,
0.533346951,
0.2920112312,
-0.0762906149,
0.1547691673,
0.0384120792,
0.2994904518,
-0.5769373775,
-0.2806603611,
-0.1491639167,
-0.0115826968,
-0.0567504056,
-0.390704155,
-0.6984779835,
0.1289457679,
0.4813750982,
-0.1910384148,
0.2568622231,
0.0771777853,
-0.5888866782,
-0.3115693033,
0.2792285383,
0.8916003704,
0.6613590121,
-0.3719896078,
0.4508348107,
0.3005705476,
-0.3671216071,
0.2555582821,
-0.0188477635,
-0.1421355456,
0.1327802837,
0.257309556,
1.0181407928,
0.41503039,
-0.5133855939,
0.3733528852,
-0.0961001068,
-0.0128727565,
-0.4635835886,
0.0705326796,
0.0264461692,
0.0056031668,
0.4488992095,
0.0832009539,
0.0005599627,
-0.6947027445,
0.3765221238,
0.2026864886,
-0.6634626985,
-0.4378105998,
0.2755684257,
0.4330691993,
-0.5290572643,
0.4052648544,
-0.2373277545,
-0.8259474635,
0.6162810922,
0.3498543501,
0.8878222108,
0.1032001525,
0.3374090195,
0.1002902016,
0.4140285254,
-0.1182633117,
-0.2953978181,
-0.1925356239,
-0.7323570848,
0.1444520801,
-0.0780371502,
-0.6744556427,
0.1392437965,
-0.4748745561,
0.2327987999,
-0.5595331192,
-0.2493208647,
-0.1580159664,
0.2268142998,
-0.5755009651,
0.5472586155,
0.415409863,
0.6026396751,
-1.1440938711,
0.1663131416,
0.895812273,
-0.5167251825,
-0.4773256481,
0.0933945328,
-0.1207308248,
-0.5801221132,
0.7113184929,
0.6394118071,
-0.169380933,
-0.1505345255,
-0.5197896957,
-0.5749124289,
1.0633065701,
0.1523599923,
-0.0552455634,
0.0449421443,
0.307626456,
0.5977853537,
-0.7037655115,
0.6064358354,
0.6178581715,
0.4956609905,
0.0475500822,
-0.8528498411,
0.1816653609,
-0.0834722519,
-0.2131511122,
-0.0616442747,
-0.7764626145,
0.6076201797,
0.4085331857,
-0.3500965536,
-0.0953668579,
0.7013849616,
0.3976891041,
0.7578249574,
0.7225944996,
0.6970940232,
1.0455963612,
-0.2488597035,
0.4720031619,
-0.4756619036,
0.1821729541,
0.8952391148,
-0.3744802177,
0.4353604913,
0.2743346989,
0.2299050093,
0.4746243358,
0.3165326416,
0.3186204135,
0.2356692702,
0.1125343218,
-0.2348737866,
-0.2700089216,
-0.2728529572,
-0.4232283831,
0.2283544391,
0.5453000665,
-0.2089290768,
-0.1511915922,
-0.0101561854,
0.1433329433,
0.0111657213,
-0.0448130965,
0.9239494801,
0.0626808926,
-0.7572168112,
0.4861955345,
-0.0570551306,
0.0998730287,
-0.0835943967,
-0.1558836102,
-0.2046128064,
-0.3292763233,
-0.1978099942,
-0.3773870468,
0.1184259802,
-0.0290453304,
-0.1890407503,
-0.4190131724,
0.924500227,
-0.1542347819,
-0.0362397097,
0.2572624087,
0.3722410202,
0.3783700764,
0.036187049,
-0.4230104387,
0.4221979678,
-0.121180743,
0.0133436685,
-0.0367994159,
0.7078819871,
-0.1220059022,
0.5140093565,
0.6435003281,
-0.3390731812,
0.0802324638,
0.391248256,
0.7876775861,
-0.7283859253,
-0.5683746338,
-0.5193861723,
0.901250124,
-0.4296680689,
-0.0962175652,
0.492238462,
0.4156863987,
0.2300726026,
0.2969433963,
0.8513703942,
-0.150914818,
0.2211526185,
-0.6482185721,
0.5618040562,
0.1098075286,
0.2295187712,
-0.0992302746,
-0.8141527176,
-0.1353747398,
0.9988251925,
-0.2699536383,
-0.1804670691,
0.8309720755,
0.4243053198,
0.0535786487,
0.321365118,
0.604445219,
0.2812481821,
0.4688056409,
0.0339586623,
1.2276906967,
-0.5092973113,
0.0887607336,
-0.1958777905,
-0.2630259097,
-0.444542557,
-0.7285888195,
-1.2779610157,
-0.4893661439,
-0.57956779,
-0.414033711,
0.1248790473,
0.9922905564,
0.8836883307,
-0.7082279921,
-0.1364031285,
-0.5013023019,
0.0101609649,
0.0813698396,
-0.2604915798,
-0.0576306507,
-0.6553971767,
-0.3695104122,
0.4649493396,
0.3200817704,
0.1740761846,
-0.1683225483,
-0.1560000926,
0.0059899404,
0.1954318434,
0.5534282923,
0.2220770568,
-0.7109905481,
-0.5689238906,
-0.2595980167,
-0.266225487,
0.3931339085,
0.8736937642,
-0.8517572284,
0.0533432439,
0.247973308,
0.4983931184,
0.0759477243,
0.4575619102,
0.6576675177,
-0.8938497305,
0.5569308996,
0.2428284734,
0.2486214042,
0.8092428446,
-0.4016141593,
0.6352328062,
0.3322736919,
-0.6311793327,
-0.9460492134,
-0.0154235084,
-1.1522265673,
0.2549982071,
1.0861274004,
-0.1911296695,
0.1565493494,
-0.237949878,
-0.6110596657,
0.4312241077,
-0.4130556881,
0.7172287703,
1.181586504,
0.3689666986,
-0.192126736,
-0.7040467262,
0.2530044913,
0.4834623039,
-0.969751358,
0.3531191349,
0.8251048326,
0.0208928306,
0.7807754278,
0.8848667145,
0.3139143288,
0.0694981068,
0.0788712725,
-0.1551432461,
0.3203667402,
-0.3423206806,
-0.2701315582,
0.571313858,
0.0780679435,
-0.1657622904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16592v1
|
TrustAI at SemEval-2024 Task 8: A Comprehensive Analysis of Multi-domain Machine Generated Text Detection Techniques
| 2024-03-25T10:09:03 | 2024-03-25T10:09:03 |
Ashok Urlana, Aditya Saibewar, Bala Mallikarjunarao Garlapati, Charaka Vinayak Kumar, Ajeet Kumar Singh, Srinivasa Rao Chalamala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
The Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit remarkable ability to generate
fluent content across a wide spectrum of user queries. However, this capability
has raised concerns regarding misinformation and personal information leakage.
In this paper, we present our methods for the SemEval2024 Task8, aiming to
detect machine-generated text across various domains in both mono-lingual and
multi-lingual contexts. Our study comprehensively analyzes various methods to
detect machine-generated text, including statistical, neural, and pre-trained
model approaches. We also detail our experimental setup and perform a in-depth
error analysis to evaluate the effectiveness of these methods. Our methods
obtain an accuracy of 86.9\% on the test set of subtask-A mono and 83.7\% for
subtask-B. Furthermore, we also highlight the challenges and essential factors
for consideration in future studies.
|
[
-0.4068873823,
-0.9445514679,
0.4554069936,
0.184238404,
-0.2491452396,
0.0868308693,
-0.0091963522,
-0.5507487655,
-0.0242636632,
0.6303940415,
-0.8141223788,
-0.5896917582,
-0.7799509168,
0.5280928016,
-0.2985493243,
0.7031401992,
-0.4412115812,
-0.1155867651,
-0.2910717428,
-0.1250086576,
-0.5475782752,
-0.806208849,
-0.646243453,
-0.108482182,
0.4162003398,
0.4641359746,
-0.0368849039,
0.0647117049,
0.5102848411,
0.2538933158,
0.1204900593,
0.7401422858,
-0.3112792671,
0.3077354133,
-0.152668342,
-0.2547979057,
-0.307649672,
-0.1420566589,
0.4708662629,
0.2104491889,
0.2461675853,
0.2511670291,
0.2829636931,
0.281124115,
-0.6929834485,
-0.0440886058,
-0.8063781857,
0.0654444024,
-0.6737129092,
-0.4574818611,
-0.6543432474,
0.0893282369,
-0.0451901853,
-0.3886521459,
0.2045281231,
0.2255039811,
0.8936111331,
0.1919646859,
-0.8177643418,
-0.5868657827,
-0.3575112522,
1.0273125172,
-0.7887137532,
0.3304186463,
0.4828488231,
0.1085815132,
-0.1350510567,
-0.5568037033,
-0.565069437,
0.1320063174,
-0.0271776635,
0.0440972298,
-0.0051074415,
-0.3016341925,
0.2893428504,
0.080091238,
-0.6487177014,
0.1244702563,
-0.0378982462,
-0.5655352473,
0.5775233507,
0.1506826729,
0.6216702461,
-0.2958476245,
-0.5151672363,
0.1098129004,
-0.753805995,
-0.1947425455,
0.5303199291,
0.0578806922,
-0.0629426986,
0.477114141,
-0.1889311075,
0.3993571103,
-0.2402133644,
-0.3270588517,
0.2975116968,
-0.7392097712,
-0.1176958904,
-0.1182952002,
1.0352771282,
0.0670764893,
0.4616599083,
0.0851255879,
-0.2651917338,
-0.0921184346,
0.2231815457,
-0.7221039534,
0.1401516199,
0.0678939149,
-0.4313298166,
-0.4611413181,
-0.1516132504,
-0.6903050542,
-0.5209800601,
-0.272611171,
0.3862576187,
-0.4769342244,
-0.1975504905,
-0.0854313076,
0.0563702658,
0.1398925185,
0.4140542448,
-0.5890259743,
-0.0266651344,
0.5234296322,
0.4648789167,
-0.6935113668,
-0.4802639186,
-0.4483836293,
0.0538089573,
-0.196496442,
0.889336586,
-0.2742991745,
-0.2277977765,
0.1638708711,
0.2949834764,
-0.2908115685,
-0.5802961588,
0.8363759518,
-0.6210238338,
0.0999020413,
-0.3328337967,
-0.6308222413,
-0.2435309291,
0.4476312399,
-0.6799972057,
1.0358839035,
-0.1409514993,
-1.030618906,
0.3306708932,
-0.5154999495,
-0.7159056067,
0.034551762,
-0.1580847651,
-0.6136984825,
-0.1085172221,
0.439910382,
0.7438713908,
-0.2466800511,
0.3978077471,
-0.1748643816,
-0.1180328727,
0.4523131549,
-0.7760900855,
0.6789610386,
0.3067623675,
-0.6779289842,
-0.0170123018,
-0.4875103235,
-0.017741004,
0.1382609308,
-0.1175208688,
-0.4763020873,
-0.3628120124,
0.1140544564,
0.1016406715,
0.6004350781,
-0.5957035422,
-0.2509452701,
0.0071219034,
0.0590953752,
0.7420794964,
0.355147779,
0.0849572495,
-0.0727910921,
0.7553259134,
0.43047297,
-0.073300615,
-0.6380589604,
-0.5715948343,
-0.6957198381,
-0.1720263958,
0.5037251711,
0.623224318,
-0.8533989191,
0.2452915609,
-0.0853816271,
-0.3246778846,
-0.1718503088,
0.19370538,
0.4836618304,
0.3577115834,
0.198593542,
-0.0982135236,
-0.7415797114,
-0.9894680977,
-0.4699813426,
0.2078315765,
0.3196229935,
0.3348793089,
0.868773222,
-0.6157405972,
0.4715647995,
-0.2724131048,
-0.0338152461,
-0.1418761313,
0.4516425133,
-0.2692233622,
0.3769047558,
0.4796688259,
-0.7886827588,
-0.6537070274,
0.033018034,
-1.1244374514,
-0.2808679044,
-0.0834526345,
-0.2024348378,
0.6331375241,
0.3785422146,
-0.4189109504,
0.4468992949,
0.5523888469,
-0.2511316836,
0.5390192866,
0.0751993507,
0.5559971929,
-1.3587390184,
0.0112933731,
0.1829702854,
-0.4247873724,
-0.6148139834,
0.1625499874,
0.2319401652,
-0.00761342,
-0.3588475883,
0.5760704279,
-0.4804810882,
0.1218272001,
-0.4237239063,
0.0030592487,
0.0879729763,
0.263974756,
-0.1163838804,
1.0345540047,
0.2921250463,
-0.5854346752,
0.0216000732,
0.020133609,
-0.3477172554,
0.5540882945,
-0.4295756817,
0.3669364452,
0.0294602476,
0.0468324758,
-1.0342082977,
-0.3076567054,
0.2682925165,
-0.6706513762,
0.2088030428,
0.1159830764,
-0.7088065147,
-0.041054111,
-0.1794726253,
0.354134202,
0.1499025822,
-0.461779356,
0.4830263555,
0.7876541018,
-0.3000942171,
-0.7122269869,
-0.6575425863,
0.2127155513,
-0.3417782485,
-0.8874837756,
0.214541465,
-0.0190405343,
-0.2171932757,
-0.2789819837,
-0.1767104268,
-0.2709178627,
0.258470118,
0.1450455934,
0.152955994,
-0.1721152514,
-0.3573276997,
0.3405402005,
-0.0037210654,
0.1515152603,
-0.1375894099,
0.5654736161,
0.0407912694,
-0.4321149886,
-0.5257171392,
0.5322759748,
0.5485985279,
-0.4538873434,
0.5978551507,
0.901776135,
-0.5661156178,
-0.503736794,
-0.5534280539,
-0.0267836135,
-0.4599998891,
0.2412023693,
-0.5535456538,
-1.1200968027,
0.4907258153,
-0.2282090336,
-0.0765997991,
0.4749732316,
0.7058346868,
-0.0381871797,
0.9954947233,
0.5828000903,
-0.0850967616,
0.0401700884,
-0.0381769389,
0.3682080209,
-0.5758863091,
-0.3326427042,
-0.6164286137,
0.0633785576,
-0.5870750546,
-0.5265701413,
0.3724490106,
-0.2329086363,
0.0218549687,
0.4453692436,
-0.1687402278,
0.15624246,
0.5833787918,
-0.1034655049,
0.2492943853,
0.1641289443,
-0.296005547,
-0.1075157002,
-0.3030974865,
-0.6605988145,
1.0252451897,
0.3848857284,
0.5755671263,
-0.0156321563,
0.8630615473,
0.4887824953,
0.0239926837,
-0.5208858848,
0.5039024353,
-0.1849463731,
-0.6513551474,
-0.1833792925,
-0.3001321554,
-0.8241403699,
0.2619317472,
-0.0039849286,
-0.5295885801,
-0.0858974978,
-0.0670158491,
-0.0196939651,
0.0270464178,
-0.5520912409,
0.9412264824,
-0.24207744,
-0.146973148,
-0.0385552831,
-0.3402763605,
0.4404937029,
-0.5676503778,
0.2634016871,
-0.1525839418,
-0.0990465954,
0.7297286391,
0.0279435255,
0.8233061433,
-0.0395711847,
-0.4096697867,
0.5978049636,
0.1798436493,
0.7017439604,
0.0450692102,
-0.0291766915,
0.3446785212,
-0.079437308,
-0.199812606,
-0.1321546137,
0.651953578,
-0.5919228792,
-0.1959728748,
-0.3295601904,
-0.4328299761,
-0.2726770043,
0.4538350105,
0.5819702744,
0.4597096741,
-0.224404186,
0.2053396553,
0.9365010858,
-0.4157132208,
0.3257781267,
0.4107925892,
-0.0138930166,
-0.2736571431,
0.8182780147,
-0.0575505085,
-0.149221018,
0.4052583873,
0.0149978232,
-0.2363407314,
-0.6266604662,
-0.474057138,
0.1217804849,
-0.7481757998,
-0.3175989687,
-0.7975354195,
-0.2419588715,
-0.6693360806,
0.149533093,
-0.1708965898,
0.0043833083,
-0.2352947444,
-0.0531088859,
-0.1206069887,
0.5529437661,
0.4083092511,
0.2033086568,
-0.9695047736,
0.376042515,
-0.0736727044,
-0.3220204711,
-0.3010714352,
-0.5308827758,
-0.2434457392,
0.079025805,
-0.2450799346,
-0.7984606624,
0.5044861436,
-0.0594201982,
0.7247151732,
0.178519398,
0.0241689719,
0.4098029733,
-0.6336430907,
0.8955873251,
-0.1094054803,
-0.9558832645,
0.6320999265,
-0.5047646761,
0.3053884506,
0.4839413464,
0.5821177363,
-0.4629263878,
-0.4049102068,
-0.4450086951,
-0.6325239539,
0.5048695803,
0.3508525193,
0.1943648905,
0.1217796057,
0.1868949234,
0.2793379724,
0.3077290356,
-0.5845069289,
-0.2458338737,
0.2117798179,
-0.3887539208,
0.1400252134,
-0.3892142177,
0.0944794491,
0.2569547892,
0.7775990963,
-0.208213672,
0.2093691081,
0.0545507446,
-0.3749701679,
0.0500824749,
0.3211133778,
0.8474220037,
0.6497725844,
0.3201224208,
0.2614532709,
0.28291291,
-0.5425907969,
0.0584488548,
0.0033292975,
-0.2776302397,
0.2196150571,
0.5145859718,
0.7124720216,
-0.0667562634,
-0.6419698,
0.5988294482,
-0.1468009055,
-0.2315977067,
-0.5135757327,
-0.1994377524,
-0.0485832728,
0.0103657562,
0.1506201625,
0.2219540477,
0.4175768197,
-0.3622022867,
0.4064860344,
0.391484797,
-0.2742942572,
-0.4603264332,
0.4961630404,
0.2616025209,
0.0317821316,
0.3266419768,
-0.3416665196,
-0.7645552754,
0.6822339296,
0.5471445918,
0.955237031,
-0.1852700412,
0.2231189609,
0.2398122549,
0.4564025104,
0.075335376,
0.36122033,
0.0492077358,
-1.0635244846,
-0.5528133512,
-0.5548052788,
-0.385943085,
0.422370255,
-0.2894947529,
0.2946215868,
0.0243342202,
-0.1552430987,
0.0613835305,
0.1051385552,
-0.6124843955,
0.1850644797,
0.3860822916,
0.7922850251,
-0.7539720535,
0.6965705752,
0.8898513317,
-0.0664697811,
-0.7842602134,
0.1903107762,
0.3978224397,
-0.7554857731,
0.6840109825,
0.347050339,
-0.4578312933,
-0.21849747,
-0.5861563087,
-0.6226792932,
1.0023298264,
0.0920850784,
-0.3354848921,
0.1862391531,
0.4246025383,
0.3749747276,
-0.4517983496,
0.0155624552,
0.427490741,
0.5138914585,
-0.2366998196,
-1.0043632984,
0.1020173207,
-0.285048753,
-0.0361463018,
0.0559340194,
-0.5611341,
0.7573288679,
0.2516800761,
-0.1520073414,
0.1233070493,
0.6107250452,
0.4251093566,
0.5929495096,
0.4635190964,
0.4962905943,
0.8695386052,
0.1801097691,
0.7987585068,
-0.4273116291,
0.338483721,
0.9002904296,
-0.5770081878,
0.5958783031,
0.2140222043,
0.1958944947,
0.4114676416,
0.7004452944,
0.139169246,
0.3249933422,
0.0622050576,
-0.4287353754,
-0.3004821539,
-0.2162434012,
-0.1444966644,
0.5193906426,
0.3729118109,
-0.4038643837,
-0.0568378642,
0.2344395965,
0.2799414396,
0.0183542781,
-0.1283239871,
0.5957182646,
0.2949016988,
-0.9262334108,
0.1935852021,
0.3611498177,
0.9873368144,
-0.4051560163,
0.0601295121,
-0.1446900368,
0.3612892628,
-0.0170585774,
-0.519528389,
0.2717252672,
0.2605433464,
0.0342098027,
-0.3817158937,
1.5237122774,
-0.3651076257,
-0.315841347,
0.1489572227,
0.7331677675,
0.1488616616,
-0.3066912591,
-0.6925355196,
0.3101433814,
0.2056352347,
-0.1482613683,
0.2332628518,
0.7052598596,
-0.1732295156,
0.4026218951,
0.3655036688,
-0.290866971,
0.2805813849,
0.0727623999,
0.4511577785,
-0.4202747643,
-0.2716191709,
-0.7903927565,
0.32048437,
-0.2411984354,
-0.3746848106,
1.1901756525,
0.6625852585,
0.9543656111,
-0.3538554311,
1.1167333126,
0.1064667106,
0.6076060534,
-0.6608794332,
0.5907859206,
-0.5835142732,
0.1627202034,
-0.2679145336,
-0.7064649463,
0.0219618119,
0.3715132475,
-0.0755543336,
-0.0246213768,
0.992429018,
0.701349318,
-0.0196236446,
0.1558567882,
0.3455425501,
-0.1571879238,
0.2070046514,
0.32170555,
1.025178194,
-0.6653828025,
0.4652130902,
-0.2628551126,
0.0673088655,
-0.1399411112,
-0.7019689083,
-1.1346230507,
-0.6096221805,
-0.4560352862,
-0.2025817484,
-0.0633863881,
0.4384680688,
0.7914910913,
-1.0605603456,
-0.1960440874,
0.0804272592,
0.0646061748,
0.1627239883,
-0.2330272645,
0.1382346153,
-0.5028191805,
-0.8960757256,
0.48723194,
0.1439505816,
-0.1171585098,
-0.3014030159,
0.111355938,
-0.1845294833,
0.2145240009,
0.7639147043,
-0.2098836303,
-0.4882897437,
-0.299574852,
0.2999072075,
-0.2943309844,
-0.2065919787,
0.9418157935,
-0.2719454467,
0.1213909164,
0.8387450576,
0.8258309364,
0.4239646792,
0.0620529838,
0.4747407734,
-0.8914376497,
-0.1676164567,
0.1132648289,
0.5232368708,
0.3572835922,
-0.5333530307,
0.5456092954,
0.3495736122,
-0.711848259,
-0.7893408537,
0.2415221632,
-0.8107227683,
-0.315538317,
1.2813674212,
-0.3946500421,
-0.2735107541,
-0.2893517017,
-0.1591684967,
0.2527786493,
-0.1810682714,
0.1784970015,
0.854460001,
-0.0155180776,
-0.1569439173,
-0.7707102299,
0.4186384678,
0.2912968099,
-1.1702342033,
-0.2518753111,
0.5157506466,
0.3882446289,
0.291624397,
0.7018471956,
-0.1855260581,
0.0434307046,
-0.089940168,
-0.0183836129,
0.0954175144,
-0.5771597028,
-0.1628594548,
0.2584729195,
-0.1674213558,
-0.1436509043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16584v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16584v2
|
Can Large Language Models (or Humans) Disentangle Text?
| 2024-03-25T09:51:54 | 2024-05-03T14:04:19 |
Nicolas Audinet de Pieuchon, Adel Daoud, Connor Thomas Jerzak, Moa Johansson, Richard Johansson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7; H.1.2
|
We investigate the potential of large language models (LLMs) to disentangle
text variables--to remove the textual traces of an undesired forbidden variable
in a task sometimes known as text distillation and closely related to the
fairness in AI and causal inference literature. We employ a range of various
LLM approaches in an attempt to disentangle text by identifying and removing
information about a target variable while preserving other relevant signals. We
show that in the strong test of removing sentiment, the statistical association
between the processed text and sentiment is still detectable to machine
learning classifiers post-LLM-disentanglement. Furthermore, we find that human
annotators also struggle to disentangle sentiment while preserving other
semantic content. This suggests there may be limited separability between
concept variables in some text contexts, highlighting limitations of methods
relying on text-level transformations and also raising questions about the
robustness of disentanglement methods that achieve statistical independence in
representation space.
|
[
-0.2616080642,
-1.0800548792,
0.8883211613,
0.0962130576,
-0.4839790463,
0.2505076826,
-0.4550524652,
-0.5389669538,
-0.0442200229,
0.5610995293,
-0.5983321667,
-0.2542070448,
-1.0000650883,
0.1839618534,
-0.7736286521,
1.0515362024,
-0.1117893606,
-0.0382592902,
-0.4528657496,
-0.042584382,
-0.2888441086,
-0.7238157988,
-0.4821182787,
-0.6802549958,
0.6901364923,
-0.0125186872,
0.7275004983,
0.7053301334,
0.7731540799,
0.4082692862,
-0.5293106437,
-0.0170302354,
-0.4826098382,
0.3456410766,
-0.4472381771,
-0.7545698881,
-0.2449801862,
0.3622174561,
0.693223238,
0.8861838579,
0.0388414338,
-0.1604922712,
0.2836245894,
0.845176518,
-0.3095880151,
0.1849491298,
-0.6264517307,
0.0096466038,
-0.189043209,
0.1978512555,
-0.5419569612,
-0.1901150495,
-0.0544101186,
-0.0153217083,
0.1691978723,
-0.0203874987,
1.1016237736,
0.5702813268,
-0.6254743338,
-0.2640542388,
-1.1158386469,
1.0199687481,
-0.5202289224,
0.0701308623,
0.7481779456,
0.0327408537,
-0.0253492091,
-0.2921223342,
-0.8095631003,
0.0114706801,
-0.1749459952,
-0.0064606746,
-0.2441413552,
-0.0783196911,
0.3426192105,
0.2559549809,
-0.3152295649,
0.2283368856,
-0.2125468552,
-0.1074787751,
0.778406918,
0.1965537518,
0.5173541307,
-0.4162856042,
-0.2599383593,
0.0128258839,
-0.5369875431,
-0.2158815563,
0.2840850353,
0.1657831818,
0.1076232865,
0.6619765759,
0.2198822349,
0.3095971644,
-0.0488033257,
-0.2630023956,
0.1983794868,
0.0549524352,
-0.2939576805,
-0.0173953921,
1.138368845,
0.2010622323,
0.1389208585,
-0.2494738698,
-0.3699699044,
0.2399446666,
0.0306164715,
-0.5290612578,
-0.1388273537,
0.1410873234,
-0.7126609683,
-0.3472721279,
-0.0677306727,
-0.7061853409,
-0.8601204753,
-0.3351029456,
0.3367400765,
-0.1359518915,
-0.5409482718,
0.1476965547,
-0.2582563162,
0.2968305945,
0.227358073,
-1.0757790804,
0.2745638192,
0.7989009619,
0.6738005877,
-0.1058695614,
-0.1772752106,
-0.2177114785,
-0.0311653186,
-0.3182667196,
0.223164469,
-0.6545668244,
-0.3257843852,
-0.2740623355,
0.0676274374,
0.1621164083,
-0.5997292399,
0.1852038354,
-0.634939909,
0.199307397,
-0.2804325521,
-0.7631742954,
-0.2161663175,
0.1624810696,
-1.0440410376,
0.4565397501,
-0.1446567774,
-0.804739058,
0.2005081773,
-0.0139180487,
-0.4487183392,
-0.3926741183,
-0.3677232862,
-0.4708870053,
0.359957993,
-0.1081088781,
0.4370057583,
-0.6178216338,
0.5003899932,
-0.446728766,
-0.3480584621,
0.6424735785,
-1.0397440195,
0.9141885042,
0.2065018415,
-0.4459447861,
-0.2425517738,
-0.7622857094,
-0.5481745601,
0.1541371047,
-0.3857522905,
-0.678109169,
0.3361337185,
-0.0386123657,
0.2687391937,
0.2662977874,
-0.7173615098,
0.1547224075,
-0.328923732,
0.5974785089,
0.936751008,
-0.2705849409,
0.599625051,
-0.0300801173,
0.2762033641,
0.390301913,
-0.270200491,
0.179061994,
-0.3146725893,
-0.7442960739,
-0.6706994772,
0.2917032242,
0.4382359385,
-0.6687256694,
0.566565156,
-0.0493151434,
-0.1431640983,
-0.5253258944,
0.1697293371,
0.4285935462,
0.373264879,
0.0493736714,
-0.0016529101,
-0.2371024489,
-0.8072555661,
-0.5074179173,
-0.3496487141,
-0.2334919125,
-0.1532549411,
0.5178773403,
-0.3460194468,
1.1042283773,
-0.6401731372,
-0.2193012089,
-0.202733323,
0.3521240652,
0.0903285593,
0.2585060298,
0.3345412612,
-1.1444556713,
-0.2144738883,
-0.1792978942,
-1.1508023739,
0.0123676267,
-0.2311329246,
0.192489922,
0.1203736141,
0.7794268727,
-0.7612584829,
0.6145298481,
0.3449189663,
-0.4788749814,
0.1311635524,
-0.3768702745,
0.0951652154,
-1.0184282064,
-0.1378005892,
0.3710075915,
-0.4327035248,
-0.4917050004,
-0.1279049367,
0.0535309501,
0.157397449,
-0.2764191031,
0.3934063613,
-0.3530459702,
0.3693605661,
-0.5656984448,
0.1988422722,
0.2545998693,
0.2146539092,
0.0880307481,
0.1633523256,
0.3542396724,
-0.3456014395,
0.2348011732,
0.3103308976,
-0.2218482196,
0.4045318365,
-0.5280544162,
-0.0737481266,
-0.7365201116,
0.182003662,
-1.1954770088,
-0.2358741611,
0.2537416518,
-0.2696177065,
0.2158471346,
0.1189865395,
-0.6146683097,
-0.0985224843,
-0.217190057,
0.3732335567,
0.7049326897,
-0.6237345934,
0.5530508161,
0.5512586236,
-0.0694494322,
-0.4894717336,
-1.1907447577,
0.125025928,
-0.626802206,
-0.1632096618,
0.1784809232,
-0.0085574035,
-0.6666145325,
0.112603128,
0.0115592368,
-0.4224860072,
0.2891327143,
0.4995448589,
0.4597598016,
0.2787796259,
0.6853855252,
0.117966637,
-0.0086264592,
0.3953127563,
0.0457163602,
0.3477976024,
0.0806316063,
-0.3995522559,
-0.5258840919,
0.3895992637,
0.6029979587,
-0.1638435423,
1.1264574528,
0.6307719946,
-0.5621508956,
-0.0444627143,
-0.3801867068,
0.0216902401,
-0.5156641006,
0.4734778702,
-0.2430374473,
-1.2238426208,
0.4787773788,
-0.1172249466,
-0.1205773205,
0.5013539791,
0.4648779929,
-0.3292101026,
1.2228548527,
0.8206110597,
-0.5334582329,
0.3305396736,
0.1294267774,
0.5178237557,
-0.68445611,
-0.0264171734,
-0.6794366837,
-0.2777346671,
-0.881812036,
-0.1579521,
-0.0718277544,
0.3201240003,
-0.1964346766,
-0.1331810951,
-0.4577516019,
0.7002074718,
0.2639326155,
0.2782397568,
0.3540871441,
-0.0942977592,
0.2684089839,
-0.2146266103,
-0.0741116852,
-0.7108383775,
0.8983150125,
0.561791122,
0.8397930861,
0.0737188533,
1.0292334557,
0.3327585161,
0.2861599624,
-0.6613050103,
0.592371285,
-0.5167302489,
-0.6639093161,
-0.4369442761,
-0.8629133701,
-0.8325425982,
0.3452364206,
-0.3175260127,
-1.0764868259,
-0.1276178658,
-0.0231858604,
0.1749777049,
0.6597809196,
-0.6573470831,
0.5976245403,
-0.057132557,
-0.3638261557,
-0.1118218303,
-0.5134663582,
0.534578681,
-0.397324115,
0.4754410386,
-0.3072845638,
0.1732397676,
0.7798299789,
-0.3451110721,
1.1471055746,
-0.0737699643,
-0.4336579144,
0.3753012419,
0.0648791119,
0.3053785264,
-0.0389962792,
-0.0537276864,
0.2393722832,
-0.1225480065,
-0.2033794075,
-0.38010782,
0.6025900841,
-0.8682594299,
-0.744212687,
-0.3526092768,
-0.5013982654,
0.0351014435,
0.3321959674,
0.0530664101,
0.2237904221,
-0.2543899417,
0.2609062493,
0.8631896973,
-0.4363541901,
0.7453721166,
0.2704368234,
-0.1813405156,
-0.0624218173,
1.120318532,
-0.2290441096,
0.1495363265,
0.6142374873,
0.3892729878,
-0.4124903381,
-0.3523877263,
0.1251295209,
0.3276149035,
-0.7761266232,
0.1630583405,
-0.3359820843,
-0.2093113661,
-0.0631816983,
0.07128492,
-0.313765347,
-0.2411727011,
-0.7300628424,
-0.149150759,
0.2420689464,
0.9435161352,
0.0007716126,
0.3158991337,
-0.9170872569,
0.4804257452,
0.3147495687,
0.2376195639,
-0.0639077052,
-0.2992079556,
-0.0241545066,
0.1095895395,
-0.0262765847,
-0.7188616395,
0.489107579,
-0.1570416987,
0.1394744515,
0.4343005717,
0.1760374308,
0.3199639916,
-0.5858342052,
0.8686048388,
0.6591715217,
-1.1689271927,
0.3082988262,
-0.4070039988,
0.4281953871,
0.3843422532,
0.4673649669,
-0.5739756227,
-0.8531796932,
-0.2417748719,
-0.9230779409,
0.5647249222,
-0.0105725937,
0.2501871586,
-0.2981627285,
0.605941534,
0.1618436724,
0.3215430975,
-0.8977690935,
-0.1793050766,
0.2791632712,
-0.7082799077,
-0.3236103058,
-0.3628692627,
-0.1799794883,
-0.06780155,
0.1613639444,
0.3147136271,
0.0687094405,
-0.0250417944,
-0.2750430405,
0.0139049599,
0.3073859513,
0.2195549011,
0.4700882137,
0.0768891275,
0.4343247414,
-0.292675823,
-0.5764920115,
0.531902194,
-0.1012986749,
-0.0870718062,
-0.2071359903,
0.5334704518,
0.4687676132,
-0.2402281314,
-0.6041641831,
0.5012300014,
-0.5246107578,
-0.4293115437,
0.0062938062,
0.0793951005,
0.3615476191,
0.41903916,
0.2525676191,
0.0235061236,
-0.1476721317,
-0.6080601811,
0.1512294859,
0.3876289725,
-0.603422761,
-0.3270613253,
0.8969109058,
0.09006311,
-0.2930650711,
0.6292250156,
-0.102880612,
-0.3169755638,
0.5937274694,
0.1879629344,
0.9614154696,
-0.0328911506,
0.3167669773,
-0.0787156448,
0.3148222268,
-0.4101379812,
-0.1246214658,
0.2845942676,
-0.8612651825,
-0.4728973508,
-0.5750671029,
-0.0709091052,
0.0619546473,
-0.7518517375,
-0.1020889878,
-0.3513336778,
-0.335000366,
0.367667824,
-0.2184723318,
-0.6142357588,
0.3266955018,
0.3518398702,
0.22013475,
-1.0224990845,
0.7824659944,
0.4204053581,
-0.4482946396,
-0.5478335619,
0.3386894763,
0.2720279098,
-0.1539821178,
0.7970240712,
0.1057359204,
-0.2575538456,
-0.417676121,
-0.6618804336,
-0.4566811323,
0.6601327062,
0.5562814474,
-0.7617878318,
0.0649786964,
0.4879569709,
0.6493722796,
0.1025674939,
0.1698296368,
0.7302950025,
0.3479373455,
-0.3203462064,
-0.807056427,
0.1457686424,
0.0200029388,
-0.0588720962,
0.306409508,
-0.8571684957,
1.2214277983,
0.2001027614,
-0.1488963813,
-0.1325319558,
0.6711977124,
-0.0525315553,
0.1430443972,
0.6811593175,
0.3209357858,
0.9409613013,
-0.147672683,
0.5836555362,
0.0241369307,
0.5988243818,
1.0260117054,
-0.4596915841,
0.7209504247,
0.6424745917,
-0.0540622473,
0.3476144075,
0.3246509433,
0.391066134,
0.6149753928,
0.1763314307,
-0.5299075246,
-0.3468713164,
0.2139680535,
0.1613315642,
0.781064868,
0.2773987055,
-0.5766416788,
-0.0814327374,
0.3011198342,
0.1124735177,
0.3649359047,
-0.1940048933,
0.8602179289,
0.2402231991,
-0.5458971262,
0.4170894623,
0.1354975402,
0.5563391447,
-0.4614290297,
0.0205320343,
-0.1651423573,
0.5887492299,
-0.0981377438,
-0.86565274,
0.4078299701,
0.1751072705,
-0.4083831608,
-0.4558708966,
0.8328031301,
-0.6294865608,
-0.4397221506,
0.4788403809,
0.5149427056,
0.054013554,
0.0223483723,
-0.3828099072,
0.3002300858,
0.1115090251,
-0.5073126554,
0.6505351663,
0.7334126234,
0.1393053681,
0.7265815735,
0.1593545973,
0.080471985,
-0.2912831306,
0.1021004096,
1.0221105814,
-1.0115841627,
-0.2380436212,
-1.4789685011,
0.3040213287,
-0.0861383304,
0.037341889,
0.7828754783,
0.1583189517,
0.5691586733,
0.0858459398,
0.9169655442,
0.0346192606,
0.3269909322,
-0.3925254941,
1.0075539351,
-0.5656000972,
0.4018938541,
-0.4825822115,
-0.7201718688,
-0.2740492821,
0.5090033412,
-0.2180117816,
-0.0930439085,
0.7370134592,
0.445091784,
0.1735755652,
0.125083521,
0.3826008439,
0.2213831097,
0.6822524071,
0.4648822844,
1.0436571836,
-0.1748253852,
0.436188966,
0.1357158571,
-0.4276091158,
0.0238298401,
-0.794267416,
-1.2255051136,
-0.542010963,
-0.3997747302,
-0.1830108464,
-0.132174477,
0.4762458503,
0.2419066876,
-0.3122580349,
-0.1185607016,
-0.1059428751,
0.461518079,
-0.0429186858,
-0.1904638708,
0.3632623255,
-0.1439895928,
-0.9271771312,
-0.0025253431,
0.2889910042,
0.0360963531,
-0.5467950702,
0.3174218237,
0.00281556,
0.2106915861,
0.6995196342,
-0.0843165368,
-0.5628040433,
-0.6530148387,
-0.3299179077,
-0.3485018015,
-0.1114780083,
0.6019742489,
-0.4930256009,
0.5102984905,
0.5588524938,
0.564365387,
0.3854185939,
-0.1154138446,
0.4182054996,
-0.8449209929,
0.4892469645,
0.1101103947,
0.3636592031,
0.1944798976,
-0.3409044445,
0.066525653,
0.0694942549,
-0.5000959635,
-0.815223515,
0.2293784022,
-0.6600022316,
-0.6697425842,
1.148370266,
-0.1677523404,
-0.6655216813,
0.042734541,
-0.0478252284,
0.3444420993,
-0.0363641456,
1.0050156116,
1.0781921148,
0.0786388218,
-0.046218425,
-0.3629462421,
0.3892905116,
0.2368581295,
-0.878854394,
0.4234686196,
0.6114400029,
0.2428621054,
0.0456590801,
0.7156149149,
-0.2068213373,
-0.2577531934,
0.1084273905,
-0.0638032109,
0.396984607,
-0.315938592,
-0.5072829127,
0.1659785956,
0.191706568,
-0.313172698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16571v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16571v1
|
NSINA: A News Corpus for Sinhala
| 2024-03-25T09:36:51 | 2024-03-25T09:36:51 |
Hansi Hettiarachchi, Damith Premasiri, Lasitha Uyangodage, Tharindu Ranasinghe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The introduction of large language models (LLMs) has advanced natural
language processing (NLP), but their effectiveness is largely dependent on
pre-training resources. This is especially evident in low-resource languages,
such as Sinhala, which face two primary challenges: the lack of substantial
training data and limited benchmarking datasets. In response, this study
introduces NSINA, a comprehensive news corpus of over 500,000 articles from
popular Sinhala news websites, along with three NLP tasks: news media
identification, news category prediction, and news headline generation. The
release of NSINA aims to provide a solution to challenges in adapting LLMs to
Sinhala, offering valuable resources and benchmarks for improving NLP in the
Sinhala language. NSINA is the largest news corpus for Sinhala, available up to
date.
|
[
-0.1305981278,
-0.3733600676,
0.306514889,
0.3293429315,
-0.5384349823,
0.1420044452,
-0.3165120184,
-0.5066363215,
0.6085224152,
0.6842714548,
-0.3793376088,
-0.4041614234,
-0.5018078089,
0.4726604521,
-0.7608302236,
0.8907402754,
-0.0901191831,
0.1087970734,
-0.2639573812,
-0.1171651557,
-0.5536072254,
-0.5037541986,
-0.65493083,
0.0634878278,
0.504783392,
0.3862878084,
0.353636831,
0.3427392244,
0.5524430275,
0.2016835958,
-0.0732167065,
0.2648822069,
-0.3524934351,
0.1739004552,
-0.1221183389,
-0.8938070536,
-0.2913651466,
-0.255019784,
0.796738863,
0.6376709342,
-0.1299979985,
0.2769086957,
-0.2430665046,
0.685567081,
-0.6082257032,
-0.3354363441,
-0.6279819608,
-0.0346093066,
-0.6843289733,
-0.2637925446,
-0.2872833014,
-0.5119234324,
-0.3932652771,
-0.4999126196,
-0.0548382327,
0.088652797,
0.9509523511,
0.7407466769,
-0.4608289003,
-0.4122473001,
-0.4967784286,
0.970638752,
-0.7570335269,
0.5228248239,
0.5920383334,
0.2713674605,
-0.0739981607,
-0.6002411842,
-0.3400014341,
-0.1273883581,
0.0210551228,
-0.3050943315,
-0.2375162989,
-0.2684054971,
0.186187461,
0.1672810316,
-0.4871740341,
0.137891382,
-0.5737053752,
0.0793599784,
0.5610539317,
0.1206078678,
0.4442107081,
-0.5555804968,
-0.3414457142,
0.3995924592,
-0.7967073321,
-0.5003574491,
0.5140604377,
0.3086237907,
-0.3110280931,
0.4703069031,
-0.4545148313,
0.9308315516,
-0.2547582686,
-0.4513856769,
0.2603114545,
-0.2763837278,
-0.3061684072,
0.5499706864,
0.5689107776,
0.2906378806,
-0.0848297998,
-0.0121535584,
0.0287239552,
0.042269133,
0.5010741949,
-0.7695693374,
0.4265255034,
0.2721629739,
-0.5809082985,
-0.4753394425,
-0.5356268883,
-0.9632544518,
-0.2847951055,
-0.6091988087,
-0.1771693677,
-0.1213914379,
-0.3403992355,
-0.0818618089,
-0.048875358,
0.2620634139,
0.4738554358,
-0.866348505,
0.3090676665,
0.6316877007,
0.8990519047,
-0.3896556795,
-0.234823525,
-0.5490701199,
-0.103764236,
-0.6403959394,
0.9246354699,
-0.4457831979,
-0.1413218528,
-0.2140316069,
-0.1027729288,
0.0394866653,
-0.5958576202,
0.8677302003,
-0.5431881547,
-0.1545565277,
-0.2235857546,
-0.1979422569,
-0.3492078781,
0.2577080429,
-0.6964197755,
0.799536705,
0.3333152831,
-0.7060982585,
-0.0861513466,
-0.5060126781,
-0.4677938819,
-0.0082584955,
0.0259686057,
-0.0545256101,
0.4583778679,
0.1647813469,
0.2394858301,
-0.7550376058,
0.7556932569,
-0.0588900968,
-0.1296096444,
0.2745162845,
-0.6338006258,
0.9410065413,
0.3328538537,
-0.0323450901,
0.080397509,
-0.8963081837,
-0.2092467546,
-0.1963069588,
-0.2448975146,
-0.5276907086,
-0.2922794819,
0.3385692537,
0.1847545952,
0.3714291453,
-0.4747535288,
0.0421278626,
-0.3805655539,
0.3131422997,
0.4707288444,
-0.083238475,
0.1387840509,
-0.1905072927,
0.7250827551,
-0.2439549714,
0.2460910082,
0.1023991406,
-0.2557616234,
-0.7282505035,
0.0027699945,
0.6982086897,
0.2721173465,
-0.7651509643,
-0.1205170676,
-0.1956293583,
-0.4493621588,
-0.7999091148,
0.5288974047,
0.2109822929,
0.4024285674,
0.2462213337,
-0.3922691643,
-1.0865706205,
-0.8745989203,
0.0568833724,
0.059114337,
0.3710777164,
0.2285482436,
0.3151924908,
-0.2758510113,
0.8498985767,
-0.2277304232,
-0.3469690084,
-0.461823225,
0.1503346115,
0.3803721964,
-0.0192543957,
0.6783816814,
-1.2057864666,
-0.4204677641,
0.0446883403,
-0.9735075831,
-0.3969786465,
-0.1322795302,
-0.3799782991,
0.5870200396,
0.5439055562,
-0.4880355597,
0.4484632611,
0.8283293843,
0.0523082986,
0.6368820667,
0.2788515687,
-0.0669578984,
-1.37801826,
0.3318120837,
-0.415443778,
-0.4010151327,
-0.7566766739,
0.0036083367,
-0.105745241,
-0.1804774404,
-0.8784659505,
0.9572119713,
-0.2563684583,
-0.3561090529,
-0.7163626552,
0.2004556358,
-0.1148855239,
0.2601706982,
0.2782422602,
0.8169044852,
0.4437683523,
-0.7518613338,
0.2988332212,
0.2911444306,
-0.3054873943,
0.7600457668,
-0.5376529694,
-0.317810595,
-0.2736939788,
0.2318596542,
-0.3739493191,
-0.5136772394,
-0.0972795188,
-0.3814396262,
0.1448515505,
0.1756898314,
-0.1239497811,
-0.162032634,
-0.2793062031,
0.4508239329,
0.0783613473,
-0.5137851238,
0.6334325671,
0.6362443566,
-0.3692393899,
-0.953938663,
-0.679706037,
0.4791855216,
-0.2968671322,
0.0386249349,
0.300740093,
-0.012980815,
-0.4002689719,
0.3159121275,
0.0454336554,
-0.3343549967,
0.3230391443,
0.4694983363,
0.3163618743,
-0.411652565,
0.2966448665,
0.1287278235,
-0.1932205707,
-0.2327012867,
0.1816867888,
0.9629632235,
0.0142009081,
-0.1001373455,
-0.6687693,
0.3121097982,
0.5202212334,
-0.2772682607,
0.6591809392,
0.5840061903,
-0.4682233632,
-0.198271811,
-0.482798636,
0.2583131194,
-0.3363049924,
0.2770501077,
-0.071749337,
-0.6756393313,
0.1150096506,
-0.2146765441,
0.0239235386,
0.6658470035,
0.6295975447,
0.2383821905,
0.4088122845,
0.6229421496,
-0.5481555462,
0.2441107929,
-0.180728659,
0.0821681693,
-1.2566883564,
-0.0507397167,
-0.6646754146,
-0.4423790872,
-0.343488425,
-0.4510970712,
0.0005225747,
0.1594906747,
-0.0192655977,
0.3823709488,
-0.2503606081,
0.4262877405,
0.6249138713,
-0.3291988373,
0.526217401,
-0.1273659766,
0.3563375473,
0.1271591634,
-0.5972082019,
-0.380863905,
1.3269222975,
0.0772001892,
0.8359793425,
0.2940738499,
0.8414089084,
0.1556447446,
0.4941731095,
-0.7919096351,
0.4028477073,
-0.4536457658,
-0.6635224819,
-0.0890126675,
-0.3912103176,
-0.994427979,
-0.0283750203,
0.0053423508,
-0.408513993,
0.3701688051,
-0.5253712535,
-0.525875926,
0.2936147749,
-0.0479590744,
0.3197621703,
-0.6075957417,
-0.0623185448,
-0.251599133,
-0.3876732886,
0.7471282482,
-0.4592104256,
0.3837980926,
-0.3924008906,
-0.2850711346,
0.8322967291,
-0.1212766543,
1.0488777161,
0.1934365481,
0.1131556258,
0.3047034144,
-0.2237388492,
-0.1503979862,
0.2954230905,
-0.2641643882,
0.3523994684,
-0.2377778143,
-0.128211841,
-0.2414103746,
0.917157948,
-0.8793286681,
-0.2597602606,
-0.6808534265,
-0.5887308717,
-0.0404861271,
0.4014740288,
0.01746854,
0.5878922939,
-0.2022732049,
0.5797097087,
0.3200199604,
-0.3376300335,
0.6620975733,
0.4157677889,
-0.5106593966,
-0.5968541503,
0.7901018262,
0.0469165482,
0.0061815856,
0.5444606543,
-0.0778661817,
-0.3436898291,
-0.5029204488,
-0.6582988501,
0.4120577574,
-0.4341465831,
-0.6737186313,
-0.6789670587,
-0.4864626825,
-0.2327813208,
-0.1718429476,
-0.4172806442,
-0.5488278866,
-0.555095017,
0.0198304988,
0.2462629229,
0.867800653,
0.013721887,
0.3749448061,
-0.7230265141,
0.7556481361,
0.2924111187,
0.2969868779,
-0.0344498716,
-0.3878365457,
-0.1485356092,
0.0382487066,
-0.2510599196,
-0.7595900893,
0.8051783442,
0.2256514132,
0.4705211222,
0.1439727545,
0.0860699192,
0.65162462,
-0.3376294971,
0.8399755955,
0.1681991667,
-0.8712052107,
0.7992505431,
-0.1942067593,
0.2046283782,
0.8870260119,
0.6867057085,
-0.5754371285,
-0.1324248761,
-0.5493612289,
-0.6496818662,
0.7455888391,
-0.0256992038,
0.342900306,
-0.0252565667,
0.3726110458,
0.1454028189,
0.6442787051,
-0.5877820253,
0.000117535,
0.0336044803,
-0.3139889836,
0.0008056003,
-0.4281431139,
0.0504912026,
-0.0630078167,
0.841545701,
-0.1839288473,
0.1320215762,
0.0500990301,
-0.3344874084,
-0.1981886029,
0.2362435162,
0.7597832084,
0.6102051735,
-0.1599315852,
-0.0157547239,
0.3264528215,
-0.5604771972,
0.0575001761,
-0.0555558652,
-0.469017297,
0.4955074489,
0.5003798604,
1.2884299755,
0.5324324965,
-1.0078001022,
0.3180419505,
-0.2956970632,
-0.0574408472,
-0.3741277754,
0.0631859526,
0.0651139319,
0.0389311463,
0.4240825474,
0.0149983959,
0.212503925,
-0.7654599547,
0.1761455089,
0.1674957722,
-0.2903263271,
-0.0409978628,
0.6155310869,
0.0347221904,
-0.3011390269,
0.591747582,
-0.1031835079,
-0.5010624528,
0.6599084139,
0.6524454355,
0.7374334335,
-0.4933894873,
0.6500759125,
0.5398552418,
0.1965850592,
-0.2772418261,
0.3040803969,
0.1584503353,
-0.4824872911,
-0.4702260196,
-1.5042673349,
-0.5847617984,
0.1218281016,
-0.5555769801,
0.6262585521,
-0.4354816377,
-0.1397020668,
-0.1278770268,
0.2680263221,
-0.3054741323,
0.2363889515,
0.2721074522,
0.8635617495,
-0.662977159,
0.9217013121,
0.4537063837,
-0.3043959439,
-0.666008234,
-0.0911388174,
0.0163162686,
-0.5814960003,
0.659676075,
0.2226880044,
0.1959605664,
-0.1898043752,
-0.2016628087,
-1.2195628881,
0.9714322686,
0.6513296962,
-0.6365628839,
-0.09521579,
0.2167889029,
0.4663627148,
-0.5638372302,
0.159479782,
0.4014206827,
0.6066998243,
-0.0827961639,
-1.0278730392,
-0.1739034504,
-0.2437987775,
0.0454117097,
0.2836644948,
-0.7767353654,
0.9275505543,
0.1577326208,
-0.097825937,
0.2006303221,
0.6973656416,
0.047978241,
0.3936932087,
0.2123242766,
0.6494165063,
0.9766920209,
0.167253837,
1.2843232155,
-0.2528246343,
-0.0480809323,
1.380256176,
-0.2553781569,
1.3020557165,
0.2932277918,
-0.1508520097,
0.7005188465,
0.4771433175,
0.3551876545,
0.3730035126,
-0.0059762415,
-0.2039662451,
-0.0129927732,
-0.9815044403,
-0.3785421848,
0.8963034749,
0.475248754,
-0.1822356284,
-0.5239269733,
0.3096092641,
-0.1247304603,
0.0815642253,
-0.6104090214,
0.5905097127,
0.3499982357,
-0.4785777628,
0.7871213555,
0.1198114753,
0.7739576697,
-0.6081690192,
0.0448490679,
-0.2892139256,
-0.2152124047,
-0.3230786324,
-0.3783752024,
0.8713249564,
0.2644992173,
-0.0213515516,
0.0797291845,
0.9611871243,
-0.4298017621,
-0.6910690069,
0.1818001121,
0.320366025,
0.2730733454,
0.0166593716,
-0.3576099873,
0.5218694806,
0.0159396864,
0.0302280113,
0.4930633307,
0.0336604789,
-0.3461036384,
0.4450034201,
0.8258733153,
0.4034710228,
0.0257665571,
0.1867468059,
0.6868036985,
-0.6727324724,
-0.253708452,
-0.6261086464,
0.0878556073,
-0.2876727581,
-0.5618039966,
0.6129766107,
0.5872452855,
0.4073836803,
0.0786407813,
0.6594148278,
-0.0627894774,
0.5506564379,
-0.6207396388,
0.5952501893,
-0.8285890818,
0.0244494844,
0.1318177879,
-0.9288304448,
-0.5053137541,
0.4691897631,
-0.0731045455,
-0.391195029,
0.7636341453,
0.5438551903,
-0.0489577726,
0.3260374963,
0.1983064413,
0.2616657913,
-0.0694060773,
0.5799286962,
0.6101244092,
-0.3840592504,
0.071719259,
-0.3765755892,
0.0362510905,
-0.5126355886,
-0.8759203553,
-0.8737597466,
-0.6955460906,
-0.0126532093,
0.1749257743,
0.0005448822,
0.9582551122,
0.5935328603,
-0.815004766,
-0.4133298099,
-0.0029964149,
0.4423845708,
0.0944311842,
-0.1877788156,
0.3646156192,
-0.4886001348,
-0.9569872618,
0.6452738643,
0.2065719068,
-0.3052023649,
-0.4740990698,
0.0528411157,
-0.529378891,
0.0866088197,
0.544128418,
0.383980304,
-0.5749991536,
0.1476380229,
-0.0988389775,
-0.1497907937,
-0.0882291272,
0.4900507629,
-0.7758234143,
0.0645530447,
0.3955715895,
0.9776880741,
0.3836939037,
-0.1258383393,
0.3691773117,
-0.7744930983,
0.4726430774,
0.2805921435,
0.1222640797,
0.5280916691,
-0.5673115849,
0.7899095416,
-0.0124124894,
-0.2518230379,
-1.3023790121,
-0.10703668,
-0.9892404675,
-0.2522254288,
1.1379011869,
0.423920095,
-0.8887716532,
-0.1336401701,
-0.2370767444,
0.1295378655,
-0.2073089927,
0.4768450558,
0.6685948372,
0.1850174963,
-0.1614712328,
-1.1999056339,
0.5124976635,
0.3394756913,
-1.2253127098,
-0.0216668937,
0.3177918792,
0.0996814072,
0.4576185346,
0.9053800106,
0.012358564,
0.4477202892,
-0.0672723278,
-0.0243899934,
0.0737464055,
-0.9258295894,
-0.4173752964,
0.2576223612,
0.0667258278,
0.1278260946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16554v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16554v2
|
PE: A Poincare Explanation Method for Fast Text Hierarchy Generation
| 2024-03-25T09:04:14 | 2024-06-12T11:17:47 |
Qian Chen, Dongyang Li, Xiaofeng He, Hongzhao Li, Hongyu Yi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The black-box nature of deep learning models in NLP hinders their widespread
application. The research focus has shifted to Hierarchical Attribution (HA)
for its ability to model feature interactions. Recent works model
non-contiguous combinations with a time-costly greedy search in Eculidean
spaces, neglecting underlying linguistic information in feature
representations. In this work, we introduce a novel method, namely Poincare
Explanation (PE), for modeling feature interactions with hyperbolic spaces in a
time efficient manner. Specifically, we take building text hierarchies as
finding spanning trees in hyperbolic spaces. First we project the embeddings
into hyperbolic spaces to elicit inherit semantic and syntax hierarchical
structures. Then we propose a simple yet effective strategy to calculate
Shapley score. Finally we build the the hierarchy with proving the constructing
process in the projected space could be viewed as building a minimum spanning
tree and introduce a time efficient building algorithm. Experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.186496824,
-1.0850944519,
0.6448405385,
0.3334966898,
-0.090669401,
-0.1295831949,
0.0931320339,
-0.2722982466,
0.3448389769,
0.0794022381,
-0.4269342422,
-0.5125355721,
-0.4042836726,
-0.4587408602,
-0.2013320625,
1.1223131418,
-0.3097550571,
-1.0511177778,
-0.0459642187,
0.2795588076,
0.2622826993,
-0.5840922594,
-0.3769887984,
-0.2768568397,
0.6081448793,
-0.033994887,
1.1590697765,
1.0251556635,
0.3144993484,
0.3355624974,
-0.4362852573,
0.1482794881,
-0.4195868671,
-0.0106870309,
-0.047557272,
0.0463123024,
-0.6044473052,
-0.1353347003,
0.6850185394,
1.0719455481,
-0.177001968,
-0.0646641031,
0.2488930672,
0.2290605754,
-0.9412865639,
0.1946360916,
-0.6059171557,
0.2665822208,
-0.2356878221,
-0.8135154843,
-0.061263904,
-0.2237734348,
0.4538861215,
-0.6874342561,
0.3490411937,
0.1112029776,
1.2253855467,
0.2167653292,
-0.1951508969,
-0.1953484416,
-0.4833833277,
0.8869010806,
-0.3490630388,
0.0442849807,
0.3523530364,
0.059692923,
-0.079861939,
-0.5463389754,
-0.5777081251,
0.0102000982,
-0.0969661251,
0.0407344401,
-0.0446534827,
-0.0426831581,
0.0001929948,
0.6538475752,
-0.1528303921,
0.0247339588,
-0.0376080312,
0.0201957878,
0.436088115,
0.0380612761,
0.1767571718,
-0.6447299123,
-0.4442659318,
0.0657774284,
-0.5943456888,
0.1517354995,
0.6103463769,
0.2131180912,
-0.0184155833,
0.5481137633,
0.4400659502,
0.2112148255,
0.0864048302,
0.0910591632,
0.130054906,
-0.3345507383,
-0.2309862673,
0.2262456566,
0.804407537,
0.153456226,
0.011405943,
-0.0788705796,
0.054047253,
0.0805421546,
0.2311187387,
-0.9008691311,
-0.4063830078,
0.2959907055,
-0.4924666882,
-0.6871017814,
-0.129241094,
-0.7349099517,
-0.3821246028,
0.221642375,
0.0836292431,
-0.4334305227,
-0.5975620747,
0.3822196722,
0.0083307941,
0.176916644,
0.2051055431,
-0.8910108805,
0.4087026119,
0.6160901189,
0.812802434,
0.0106883468,
-0.5455939174,
-0.612416625,
0.4599090815,
-0.3394306302,
0.7319381833,
-0.633516252,
-0.104666315,
0.1392048001,
-0.3397241533,
-0.0610650666,
-0.4806272388,
0.4356761575,
-0.1368510872,
0.4475483298,
0.1108742207,
-0.4502469003,
0.0324576944,
0.0280542467,
-0.5565923452,
1.1899516582,
0.2357457727,
-1.0932574272,
0.2919959426,
-0.7549238205,
-0.6012368202,
0.2175060511,
-0.0061451159,
-0.7912780046,
0.1469150484,
0.3626618087,
0.5727831721,
-0.0720411316,
0.3638372719,
-0.2188464105,
-0.0474457853,
-0.0999742672,
-0.1398266852,
0.7914181948,
0.0304774735,
-0.6312105656,
-0.1986105293,
-0.3008363843,
0.0140074911,
0.2433001697,
-0.4058812261,
-0.6410124898,
0.5260605216,
-0.0022387877,
0.0813935101,
0.1390020996,
-0.466106683,
0.0853667185,
-0.5807709694,
0.4290352166,
0.4395908117,
0.2981175482,
0.3532884419,
-0.1305465847,
0.274556905,
0.118693389,
0.1108371094,
-0.2203824669,
-0.497952342,
-0.2224802822,
-0.2184756994,
-0.0961472169,
0.3520695865,
-0.7193528414,
0.7113724351,
-0.2349271923,
-0.2925543189,
-0.5490462184,
0.2606763542,
0.6008712649,
0.3519923985,
0.2723845243,
-0.1646360457,
-0.3347530067,
-0.7982305288,
-0.3189013004,
-0.3948191106,
0.0500024557,
0.3000320792,
0.653590858,
0.076847367,
0.7416348457,
-0.5890197754,
-0.0844013691,
-0.105932802,
0.1470081955,
0.1210015565,
0.3653079271,
0.7140179873,
-0.9252130389,
-0.2021059394,
0.0657409802,
-0.6426972151,
0.1118742824,
0.0231337119,
-0.2139399648,
-0.2994391918,
0.4181983471,
-0.3791773319,
0.3776470721,
0.5342172384,
-0.4734623432,
0.4104522765,
-0.0855595097,
0.113251403,
-1.0025709867,
-0.1016804948,
0.36394611,
-0.1638928652,
-0.4363924563,
0.1453752965,
-0.2659095824,
-0.3043854535,
-0.6650614738,
0.4060278237,
-0.4595857859,
0.1805533469,
0.0464758128,
0.3530145586,
-0.0970831215,
0.7758535743,
0.032871902,
0.2196551114,
0.6724376678,
-0.6978752613,
0.1503885239,
0.2060614675,
-0.3177677989,
0.5228354335,
-0.84520787,
-0.2285813689,
-0.2677907646,
0.0738852099,
-1.1358985901,
-0.1669951975,
0.0927791893,
-0.2428407371,
0.0029223675,
-0.2977273762,
-0.7744128108,
-0.402795136,
-0.5109306574,
0.7368043661,
0.4756752849,
-0.8590099216,
0.4349132478,
0.6270011067,
-0.1394479126,
-0.2240168601,
-0.4138038754,
-0.1287468672,
-0.4022313356,
-0.695356667,
0.8557029366,
0.2257336229,
-0.3591638505,
0.289973259,
-0.0383711979,
-0.1602120399,
0.3168542087,
0.2671382427,
0.098012507,
-0.4187348187,
-0.018097356,
0.2797216475,
0.0026429591,
-0.0509827249,
-0.3740587831,
0.3383477628,
-0.1994301677,
-0.1255583465,
-0.7240147591,
0.4015910029,
0.5359038711,
-0.33168751,
0.8684450388,
0.1571033746,
-0.605912745,
-0.4597601593,
0.012454317,
0.0071159299,
-0.4301132262,
0.5684226155,
-0.3513799012,
-0.6543177962,
0.3869233131,
-0.2526479959,
0.3304194212,
0.8242542148,
0.8295071125,
-0.1219256893,
0.9752011299,
0.6994997263,
0.0807896256,
0.6238318086,
-0.2643079758,
0.503094852,
-0.5604146123,
-0.2415943891,
-0.5301085114,
-0.4053907394,
-0.513833642,
-0.3839606643,
0.3752821088,
0.227989912,
-0.1135821342,
0.5337193608,
-0.6195813417,
0.6912010312,
0.1144477129,
0.0514272898,
0.26590994,
0.3186707199,
-0.0595991462,
-0.1127901673,
-0.780606389,
-0.2649227679,
0.5104414821,
0.6100391746,
0.7168155909,
0.1161715686,
0.807942152,
-0.0208869483,
0.3036570847,
-0.6672428846,
0.1770873666,
-0.4749632776,
-0.4028315842,
-0.4131674469,
-0.4405079782,
-0.9994928837,
0.2172957808,
-0.2647924423,
-0.7203730345,
0.0953914449,
0.1856279075,
-0.514806509,
0.62034899,
-0.68638134,
0.7864077091,
-0.2310000509,
-0.6202287674,
-0.0708265603,
-0.2562399209,
0.3332376182,
0.2574650347,
0.0819052085,
0.0014829669,
-0.1295774281,
0.8836140633,
-0.7320275307,
0.7989091873,
-0.4208414257,
-0.3736667931,
0.3555508852,
0.3880283535,
0.3181357384,
-0.1847632974,
0.0016940283,
-0.1022901684,
-0.1931059659,
-0.5541003942,
-0.6604405642,
0.7701599002,
-0.8079383969,
-0.1556591988,
-0.0179229286,
-0.5693298578,
0.0022848339,
-0.2513503432,
0.276748687,
0.4966724813,
0.0324256904,
0.2130877674,
0.7309697866,
-0.1688724011,
0.4371021092,
-0.1707547158,
-0.1691212803,
-0.0570600033,
0.8040915132,
-0.0715711936,
-0.0868004933,
0.6399108171,
0.5344948173,
-0.2601904571,
-0.4924542308,
0.0153244352,
0.4220927358,
-0.165386647,
0.0923163295,
-0.718657434,
-0.2869648635,
0.1064217314,
-0.4789503813,
-0.4628811777,
-0.4859351814,
0.1693948954,
-0.0955917612,
0.1081486568,
0.6915794611,
0.6182295084,
0.541220665,
-0.3883631527,
0.3486580551,
0.2819796801,
0.4974752069,
0.2643708289,
-0.3194176853,
-0.3256676197,
-0.3988895416,
-0.6167671084,
-0.8933656216,
0.2165059298,
0.3375589848,
0.5455550551,
0.2962710857,
-0.2184715867,
0.7457599044,
-0.4524011612,
0.7438145876,
0.2650180757,
-1.0862436295,
0.8820522428,
-0.4318900108,
-0.0688855648,
0.1869939119,
0.6407382488,
-0.204621464,
-0.5881145,
-1.1549292803,
-1.1099029779,
0.1841879934,
0.4647464454,
-0.0252183247,
-0.1391815394,
0.6595924497,
0.1693981141,
0.0972137302,
-0.6538708806,
-0.2603069544,
-0.2717145979,
-0.2752495706,
0.0747539252,
-0.1458117068,
-0.014229442,
-0.262103796,
0.384197861,
-0.1060128659,
0.0749355927,
0.3262529969,
-0.1326863468,
-0.2163285613,
0.1369085312,
0.1006013975,
0.5642001629,
-0.0950275883,
0.4428364635,
-0.3262143731,
-0.1401809305,
-0.108903788,
0.2331736386,
0.2102862746,
0.1733316183,
0.6735481024,
0.6115111709,
0.5046130419,
-0.0855447128,
0.7263229489,
0.2747907937,
-0.5599128604,
0.3466591537,
-0.0769410357,
0.0770916045,
0.1614827067,
0.3478484452,
-0.3283465803,
0.0038310562,
-0.7006843686,
0.2914749086,
0.1869780719,
-0.3341576159,
-0.4408413172,
0.80057621,
0.2170280665,
-0.1404214054,
0.4732626379,
-0.0136622442,
-0.5814732313,
0.5776139498,
0.3878912926,
0.8588103652,
-0.1934047937,
0.5160844922,
0.2766432166,
0.0526230596,
0.0809715614,
0.1389427334,
-0.2388557643,
-0.7519139647,
-0.602496326,
-0.7527561784,
-0.3435736597,
0.0632511005,
-0.22582753,
-0.0243822336,
-0.7075920701,
0.0213061906,
0.6718258858,
0.1093762442,
-0.4367662966,
-0.1417794675,
0.0514122024,
0.5443066359,
-1.1256312132,
0.4722566605,
0.7495573759,
-0.2965737581,
-0.7379234433,
0.2306107581,
-0.0644426048,
-0.8093338609,
0.5418472886,
-0.1974834055,
-0.10545782,
-0.0385376811,
-0.680136025,
-0.2377644032,
0.7580830455,
0.3327014446,
-0.3358733058,
-0.4062148631,
-0.2849883735,
0.7214639187,
-0.3892949224,
-0.1709125489,
0.3488574028,
0.3477593064,
0.0423372686,
-0.6028323174,
0.1858749986,
-0.4974527657,
0.0176855419,
0.583825469,
-0.133681193,
0.9213477373,
-0.3368961215,
-0.324373126,
0.0660617277,
0.6660011411,
0.3389380276,
0.0812360197,
0.7155434489,
0.506172061,
0.866730988,
-0.051989343,
1.5521562099,
-0.1090988666,
0.6379736662,
0.7687509656,
0.094553031,
0.7263417244,
0.6034272909,
-0.2922568321,
0.8272789717,
0.603120625,
0.1607498676,
0.4582913816,
0.4416981936,
-0.1134410799,
-0.2244961262,
-0.2055168748,
-0.1730731726,
0.2369727194,
0.1890511811,
-0.3718272448,
-0.5618572831,
-0.2480016202,
0.2911192477,
0.247676447,
-0.3517595828,
0.5449685454,
-0.0549790412,
-0.5661423206,
0.5608389378,
-0.0585491098,
0.6139526963,
-0.4582359195,
0.0219419748,
0.1396123022,
0.3059365153,
-0.522949934,
-1.2064877748,
0.27223894,
-0.1359219998,
-0.3625068963,
-0.5119057894,
0.4007794857,
-0.7299323678,
-0.3850939274,
0.201519236,
0.6538506746,
0.2502357662,
-0.288860321,
-0.6526198983,
-0.4051502049,
-0.3022422194,
-0.178017661,
-0.0115073873,
0.9115747213,
-0.3348878622,
0.1870830655,
0.4538702071,
0.3056147099,
-0.0238513909,
0.0408416577,
0.7631596327,
-0.5505053997,
-0.783493638,
-0.9410437346,
0.5270437598,
0.0804136023,
-0.4410078228,
0.5835366845,
0.5399975181,
0.4447617531,
0.1835645437,
0.5938819647,
-0.1715012193,
0.1642404646,
-0.4349314272,
0.5776980519,
-0.6399387121,
0.0627155378,
-0.6343454123,
-1.1143555641,
-0.4794644415,
0.5601637959,
-0.2845620513,
-0.0165633373,
1.1043596268,
0.4311081171,
-0.2747028768,
-0.0651587471,
0.0703378692,
0.4065638483,
0.438026458,
0.9599993825,
0.8578286767,
-0.345146358,
0.5341427922,
-0.2966910601,
-0.6186468005,
-0.0649111867,
-1.0982342958,
-0.8457560539,
-0.7184804082,
-0.6571321487,
-0.4192613363,
0.0523673743,
0.3904254735,
0.7713183165,
-0.5858550668,
-0.0746449307,
0.0489727072,
0.4241031706,
-0.4551884532,
-0.2736877203,
0.8464452028,
-0.1590179503,
-0.6197423935,
0.0290794913,
0.4467631578,
-0.191565752,
-0.1932279766,
-0.1494313031,
-0.2955005169,
-0.1601960361,
0.5655022264,
0.2053855509,
-0.3467933238,
-0.2987625003,
-0.2749053836,
-0.0795195028,
0.197302863,
1.2166600227,
-0.7551941872,
0.0902150795,
0.6140909791,
0.6644866467,
0.5443281531,
0.0176236611,
0.3897129595,
-0.8662844896,
-0.0427667648,
0.071142979,
0.2848749161,
0.3148823678,
-0.3983076513,
0.2008515447,
0.4846847057,
-0.1726956815,
-0.50412184,
0.186058715,
-0.761061132,
-0.2947354019,
0.7863078117,
0.0324261524,
-0.6909999847,
-0.1434155256,
-0.08342769,
-0.0009851279,
-0.198621273,
0.8394426107,
0.5273919702,
-0.1749565303,
-0.0617430918,
-0.1254976988,
0.6035912037,
0.3135020435,
-0.9692473412,
0.3298701942,
0.1122776195,
-0.0395903699,
0.4999093711,
0.5107582808,
-0.4968858659,
0.3542147577,
0.0859336108,
-0.1429890692,
-0.203942731,
-0.6127237082,
0.0270535313,
0.6634511352,
-0.2599226236,
-0.1531525552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16543v1
|
Efficient Information Extraction in Few-Shot Relation Classification through Contrastive Representation Learning
| 2024-03-25T08:36:06 | 2024-03-25T08:36:06 |
Philipp Borchert, Jochen De Weerdt, Marie-Francine Moens
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Differentiating relationships between entity pairs with limited labeled
instances poses a significant challenge in few-shot relation classification.
Representations of textual data extract rich information spanning the domain,
entities, and relations. In this paper, we introduce a novel approach to
enhance information extraction combining multiple sentence representations and
contrastive learning. While representations in relation classification are
commonly extracted using entity marker tokens, we argue that substantial
information within the internal model representations remains untapped. To
address this, we propose aligning multiple sentence representations, such as
the [CLS] token, the [MASK] token used in prompting, and entity marker tokens.
Our method employs contrastive learning to extract complementary discriminative
information from these individual representations. This is particularly
relevant in low-resource settings where information is scarce. Leveraging
multiple sentence representations is especially effective in distilling
discriminative information for relation classification when additional
information, like relation descriptions, are not available. We validate the
adaptability of our approach, maintaining robust performance in scenarios that
include relation descriptions, and showcasing its flexibility to adapt to
different resource constraints.
|
[
-0.1607006341,
-0.4201459587,
0.4883562922,
-0.0547496565,
-0.3292281926,
-0.0662606806,
-0.0628976226,
-0.6205328703,
0.2274288237,
0.3041293323,
-0.4690412283,
-0.2292534411,
-0.5540614128,
0.0769770071,
0.1459202766,
0.9771860242,
0.1045787409,
0.2129535526,
-0.1796652079,
-0.3857728243,
-0.7240534425,
-0.4621354043,
-0.5941998959,
-0.4067491293,
0.4395160079,
0.5496300459,
0.4168231487,
0.6688299775,
0.6749078035,
0.3021667004,
0.1589612961,
0.4355577826,
-0.3909855485,
0.3450133204,
-0.0789152533,
-0.3789061308,
0.0324030258,
-0.0850477517,
0.6668359041,
0.7663055658,
0.10343986,
0.0846336111,
0.2402840257,
0.2124299407,
-0.8372997642,
0.5498048067,
-0.8464356065,
0.0014154398,
-0.3385080695,
-0.209008798,
-0.4642205834,
0.127180174,
0.1645608395,
-0.8311392069,
-0.0297676641,
0.2546969056,
1.0886019468,
0.1638221443,
-0.5443852544,
-0.3547880352,
-0.5609961152,
0.7416715026,
-0.3606541157,
0.260717988,
0.1484726518,
0.3822835386,
0.1049207523,
-0.8411495686,
-0.6451007128,
0.0423961654,
-0.525752306,
0.0821364969,
-0.1103600785,
0.0541859493,
0.2895283401,
0.2913600802,
-0.1043022648,
0.259260118,
-0.1685726792,
-0.1308399737,
0.2041935474,
0.3345770538,
0.1376250088,
-0.4513835013,
-0.7776905298,
-0.05803179,
-0.640380919,
-0.0862280503,
0.1045505404,
0.8024965525,
-0.2093544304,
0.6635349989,
0.124429293,
0.4842400849,
0.232411772,
-0.1934682578,
0.3824797273,
-0.4749217629,
-0.0942275748,
0.0515530668,
0.8178170323,
0.3972851336,
-0.1271502823,
-0.0206311401,
-0.1202872694,
0.0008899168,
0.0916941091,
-0.8756052256,
-0.0963035151,
-0.0237896554,
-0.6399902701,
0.0229533575,
0.4181779027,
-1.1401644945,
-0.6059788465,
-0.1240779757,
0.1809668243,
-0.4638990462,
-0.2500263751,
-0.4211141765,
-0.4218951166,
0.2584248781,
0.1821272075,
-1.1689127684,
0.4832140803,
0.4935244918,
0.942630887,
-0.2230600417,
-0.0756567344,
-0.8175327182,
0.4090748429,
-0.0156631507,
0.6265087128,
-0.827567637,
-0.2229014784,
0.3471533358,
-0.2000282854,
0.0455150343,
-0.5343229771,
0.3492257297,
-0.430744946,
0.2915564775,
-0.3201683164,
-0.8131836653,
0.0034365756,
0.1296498179,
-1.0029700994,
0.8824377656,
0.4078304172,
-1.1023293734,
0.5123467445,
-0.5623488426,
-0.2159256339,
0.3265680969,
-0.5715475678,
-0.5150595903,
-0.0835853219,
0.4561462402,
0.5497250557,
-0.0245377235,
-0.2036726922,
-0.2840843201,
-0.249182269,
0.1486803591,
-0.0216640681,
0.6432361603,
0.2514427602,
-0.1364688426,
-0.0069069494,
-0.801030755,
-0.4071047008,
0.1198802814,
-0.2826094031,
-0.5677990913,
-0.4497207701,
0.0432853773,
0.1928551346,
0.2202976793,
-0.4221497774,
0.2825382948,
-0.4029978812,
0.0809677914,
0.6846356988,
0.3627085388,
0.7437573075,
-0.1512343735,
0.4973877966,
0.6734896898,
-0.4561740756,
-0.5989438891,
-0.29954952,
-0.7137531042,
-0.3671761155,
0.3188955486,
0.416831702,
-1.0835939646,
0.2954503298,
-0.2939718068,
0.0258557238,
-0.7103610039,
0.2668563128,
0.479616195,
0.8510117531,
0.5934023261,
-0.1241793334,
-0.7440364957,
-0.6615746617,
-0.1601404548,
-0.316673398,
0.087995559,
0.2859978378,
0.4287572503,
0.029592704,
0.7223955989,
-0.5392385125,
-0.5270992517,
-0.275573045,
0.4227569699,
0.1256928444,
0.5047068,
0.5474925637,
-0.7834076285,
-0.3646908998,
0.1552268118,
-0.8228890896,
0.2159395516,
-0.4301184416,
-0.2872635126,
-0.2178915441,
0.4164324701,
-0.6567259431,
0.2492140681,
0.0311290938,
-0.1707471013,
0.2331068069,
0.1320778579,
0.0680504814,
-1.0897285938,
-0.1747747064,
0.1829518974,
-0.332301259,
-0.5059441924,
0.1246693581,
-0.0369270295,
0.0628017858,
-0.3627685308,
0.6374995708,
-0.7594336271,
-0.0682142824,
0.0154114608,
0.4913923442,
0.0211120266,
0.3811549544,
0.0921981335,
0.7031398416,
0.4634274542,
-0.5766486526,
0.3507344127,
0.5570560098,
0.0413948074,
0.9196357727,
-0.1492520422,
0.1734024733,
-0.2819697559,
0.0799525678,
-0.9551657438,
-0.2927719653,
0.4424113929,
-0.2413471192,
0.4936174452,
-0.1964537501,
-0.391477406,
-0.0957528427,
-0.49674353,
0.2468971908,
0.3038829863,
-0.8449710608,
0.7638729215,
0.3618315756,
-0.0398087725,
-0.6472924948,
-0.735365808,
-0.2504935861,
-0.5362035036,
-0.0792050064,
0.6350033283,
0.4607890844,
-0.2543563545,
0.3514880538,
-0.0890171304,
-0.391744405,
-0.0590373278,
0.2666712105,
0.4703572989,
-0.4774008095,
0.6851919889,
-0.2369955629,
0.0140331564,
-0.1870219857,
-0.0369355753,
0.3631922901,
0.1086750031,
-0.1264125854,
-0.4993668199,
0.5376935005,
-0.0005377248,
0.0178570673,
0.9649636745,
0.7027322054,
-0.7338488102,
-0.0129808821,
-0.3500144482,
-0.2459193319,
-0.3899055421,
0.257073015,
-0.7208614349,
-0.7962232828,
0.5875220299,
-0.2265333682,
-0.0290785972,
0.6346054673,
0.095691964,
0.0089748623,
0.6599150896,
0.7535896301,
-0.1526671946,
0.6382007003,
-0.0159068834,
0.0522047691,
-0.9625419378,
-0.3726790547,
-0.6317420006,
-0.0811293647,
-0.5241827965,
0.0087485695,
0.0480158664,
0.4693055749,
-0.1776608527,
0.5214872956,
-0.4531419575,
0.3317097723,
0.4362964034,
0.4677621126,
0.2763372064,
-0.010225106,
-0.2464819252,
-0.4108909965,
-0.6112117171,
-0.6138094068,
0.8443265557,
0.1952230483,
0.553730607,
0.1686765254,
1.0767172575,
-0.2588996887,
0.3650141656,
-0.8168773055,
0.1464348733,
-0.2260406166,
-0.4242436886,
-0.052717302,
-0.5930374861,
-1.0416568518,
0.2575311065,
-0.6113285422,
-1.0323961973,
0.2344003171,
-0.0181593616,
-0.5801435113,
0.0260579959,
-0.8243483305,
0.7854768634,
-0.1284042895,
-0.316394031,
0.0239612423,
-0.7873321772,
0.2682618201,
0.0561696589,
-0.0026621672,
0.1480745822,
-0.2231737673,
0.8082751632,
-0.1940345168,
0.8670182824,
-0.1458705664,
0.2931597531,
0.2524982095,
-0.1648910493,
0.3574281335,
-0.0253996234,
-0.1798903346,
-0.2291211784,
-0.2124211043,
-0.306304276,
-0.7672248483,
0.4410712719,
-0.500505507,
-0.2993736267,
-0.3745860755,
-0.2638057768,
-0.3780266941,
0.2296343446,
0.2330444902,
0.2158118784,
-0.3167011142,
-0.0596145242,
0.2108606249,
0.0339761265,
0.6101587415,
-0.0893230885,
-0.0704857036,
-0.5546014905,
0.6568947434,
-0.132465139,
0.0380250104,
0.5658963919,
0.0944798067,
-0.5211211443,
-0.2099401206,
-0.1521892548,
0.3924446106,
-1.1210196018,
-0.5917378068,
-0.4928923547,
-0.073574923,
-0.4904156923,
0.1034782529,
0.1311154962,
-0.3851658404,
-0.7601187229,
-0.3907005191,
0.1405819952,
0.7766445279,
0.038099777,
0.6725583673,
-0.8629031777,
0.671061337,
0.3747337461,
-0.1025529057,
-0.0433879867,
-0.2525020242,
-0.0503352843,
-0.2853212953,
-0.4704367816,
-1.253288269,
0.0234675016,
0.4644031823,
0.7011495829,
0.7680771351,
0.0394627564,
1.1192263365,
-0.3729413152,
0.8595122099,
0.7489289641,
-0.8795771599,
0.5416856408,
0.2515465021,
0.1548106372,
0.6815222502,
0.5376480222,
-0.206866309,
-0.1465840787,
-0.8011858463,
-0.6697570682,
0.6261659861,
0.1704211682,
0.3840734661,
-0.2821537852,
0.4459668398,
0.2404570729,
0.2083860636,
-0.9096750021,
-0.2812772989,
-0.1574002355,
-0.5660864711,
0.3935306668,
-0.4160763919,
-0.1422296762,
0.0117632523,
0.3926951885,
-0.2019958198,
0.3862175643,
0.0637143254,
-0.127517134,
0.0987497717,
0.2983357012,
0.0314990208,
0.522005558,
0.1186563075,
0.589595139,
0.2997224033,
-0.0874628499,
-0.0761164054,
0.2987054884,
0.0873861164,
0.2548476458,
0.7677408457,
0.7814468741,
0.2113422453,
-0.1945142746,
0.7595857978,
0.177083075,
0.2550825775,
0.1754104644,
-0.1916764677,
0.0484876297,
0.3802610636,
0.2402364463,
-0.1628947705,
0.2196060717,
-0.7615560293,
0.4715071619,
0.5110074878,
-0.5769740939,
-0.0213854481,
0.5426440239,
0.3133989871,
0.0484137461,
0.7159107327,
-0.2281218022,
-0.4208256304,
0.210589841,
0.5893990993,
0.6487797499,
-0.069574587,
0.1984124035,
0.7362043262,
-0.0875090882,
-0.0025744131,
-0.016556479,
-0.2107920498,
-0.8474792242,
-0.1496427506,
-0.3217647076,
-0.2244741768,
0.075666219,
-0.7767935395,
0.5577042699,
-0.3486599028,
-0.2416602224,
0.3601147234,
-0.0293459687,
-0.8373433352,
-0.0288364571,
0.186343953,
0.3577140868,
-0.8056827784,
0.6526221633,
0.5307251215,
-1.065643549,
-0.9116525054,
-0.0078090592,
-0.0632186979,
-0.7767168283,
1.0598633289,
0.5575283766,
-0.1800967157,
-0.3507276773,
-0.5238577724,
-0.2579398453,
0.8657924533,
0.7281122804,
-0.5775996447,
-0.1691184193,
-0.1021411121,
0.3784299493,
-0.9387818575,
0.3298766613,
0.3755579293,
0.2368102223,
0.252720803,
-0.5813004971,
0.2855350375,
0.0237021446,
0.0820390359,
-0.0187386535,
-0.3111365736,
0.6288616657,
-0.1494648755,
-0.6836056113,
0.0399121977,
0.9037739038,
0.2612053454,
0.2292782962,
0.5200671554,
0.2644505799,
1.1157470942,
-0.1078875288,
0.6436578631,
0.0459539033,
0.2886957824,
1.553345561,
-0.384437561,
0.8649407029,
0.753164351,
0.0045615733,
0.7722030878,
0.5555731654,
-0.0660367534,
0.6163804531,
0.0728117302,
-0.331479907,
-0.1516049206,
-0.3646230698,
-0.1887809932,
0.4881130755,
0.2852227092,
-0.497890532,
-0.2168251276,
-0.1080268696,
-0.0065461183,
0.2466948628,
-0.190083012,
1.2376979589,
0.242577821,
-0.5883069038,
0.2537383139,
-0.3853832781,
0.505856514,
-0.2547280192,
-0.7015113831,
-0.0056545394,
0.0030257034,
-0.3654349148,
-0.6604408026,
0.0540290736,
-0.1283992678,
-0.0404902734,
-0.0790084004,
0.7762262821,
-0.6773239374,
-0.2221676409,
0.2728901803,
0.4294454753,
-0.0253448915,
0.2261564583,
-0.5355864763,
-0.2754588723,
-0.2084746212,
0.2149537802,
-0.0174166411,
0.8362307549,
0.1651200205,
0.2773004472,
0.2500263453,
0.146179989,
0.0411434174,
0.1950085461,
0.9866063595,
-0.7742868066,
-0.6308037043,
-1.0889189243,
0.6002153754,
-0.5893249512,
-0.4316625893,
0.6158698797,
0.3446455896,
0.6367936134,
0.0010163384,
0.569737494,
0.1393942833,
0.34265697,
-0.86332196,
-0.0804175436,
-0.0847052708,
0.2518263459,
-0.3115964532,
-0.918056488,
-0.4491016269,
0.7386065125,
0.1625947058,
-0.0607633293,
1.1090137959,
0.3806831837,
-0.0452084541,
-0.0857350677,
0.1536083221,
-0.1002859026,
0.1236214712,
0.5885522962,
0.9129570127,
-0.496358484,
0.7447370291,
-0.1983877122,
-0.0331508033,
-0.1076306477,
-0.885075748,
-1.0901378393,
-0.6707079411,
-0.4974061847,
-0.3695851564,
-0.1888069212,
0.966581583,
0.8902974725,
-0.7479501367,
0.040516369,
-0.0191539172,
0.2414037734,
-0.3135751784,
-0.2502035797,
0.350270927,
-0.6589329243,
-0.5188993216,
0.1240541935,
0.2775252163,
0.259619087,
0.0183847938,
-0.0672869608,
-0.2864741683,
-0.331800878,
0.3822377622,
-0.018404521,
-0.6323196888,
-0.3659142554,
-0.3102819622,
-0.2528504729,
0.5081305504,
0.9053612947,
-0.6302323341,
0.5451509356,
0.2893303037,
0.8355615139,
0.7233583927,
0.2356729358,
0.3814807236,
-1.3842737675,
0.293199718,
0.227846235,
0.5046958327,
0.7073048353,
-0.6568188071,
0.5234388709,
0.0193308815,
-0.0477932319,
-0.4822751284,
0.5078410506,
-1.0794736147,
-0.0994964764,
1.0451593399,
-0.4761003554,
-0.0102097122,
-0.0993738174,
-0.3617760837,
0.4525292516,
-0.5417996645,
0.5014090538,
0.8892862201,
-0.3529754579,
-0.4665308893,
-0.0833479762,
0.3647805452,
-0.0013692831,
-1.1092188358,
-0.1313688904,
0.5424809456,
-0.1483987123,
0.5339587927,
0.6639300585,
-0.1808312684,
-0.0604964942,
0.2251083106,
-0.2728722692,
0.1721391976,
-0.113720648,
-0.4042262435,
0.3497825563,
0.1381384432,
-0.5734649897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16527v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16527v1
|
Hallucination Detection in Foundation Models for Decision-Making: A Flexible Definition and Review of the State of the Art
| 2024-03-25T08:11:02 | 2024-03-25T08:11:02 |
Neeloy Chakraborty, Melkior Ornik, Katherine Driggs-Campbell
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Autonomous systems are soon to be ubiquitous, from manufacturing autonomy to
agricultural field robots, and from health care assistants to the entertainment
industry. The majority of these systems are developed with modular
sub-components for decision-making, planning, and control that may be
hand-engineered or learning-based. While these existing approaches have been
shown to perform well under the situations they were specifically designed for,
they can perform especially poorly in rare, out-of-distribution scenarios that
will undoubtedly arise at test-time. The rise of foundation models trained on
multiple tasks with impressively large datasets from a variety of fields has
led researchers to believe that these models may provide common sense reasoning
that existing planners are missing. Researchers posit that this common sense
reasoning will bridge the gap between algorithm development and deployment to
out-of-distribution tasks, like how humans adapt to unexpected scenarios. Large
language models have already penetrated the robotics and autonomous systems
domains as researchers are scrambling to showcase their potential use cases in
deployment. While this application direction is very promising empirically,
foundation models are known to hallucinate and generate decisions that may
sound reasonable, but are in fact poor. We argue there is a need to step back
and simultaneously design systems that can quantify the certainty of a model's
decision, and detect when it may be hallucinating. In this work, we discuss the
current use cases of foundation models for decision-making tasks, provide a
general definition for hallucinations with examples, discuss existing
approaches to hallucination detection and mitigation with a focus on decision
problems, and explore areas for further research in this exciting field.
|
[
-0.6361937523,
-0.734154284,
0.8612371087,
0.2838062942,
-0.0155705512,
-0.4299664199,
0.10118296,
-0.6324849725,
0.3730819523,
0.640697062,
-0.7747457623,
-0.2999747396,
-0.528726995,
0.0674004108,
-0.6533167362,
0.4697861373,
-0.0040926035,
-0.0680385157,
-0.2489297986,
0.0095858779,
-0.8391727209,
-0.5457645655,
-0.2920473218,
-0.5616630912,
-0.32213974,
0.1277561784,
0.8014751673,
0.2269282341,
0.4606716931,
0.2628878653,
-0.0802383572,
-0.0231503621,
-0.2266221493,
0.1497894228,
-0.2194367796,
-0.128476724,
-0.3606993854,
-0.2064823955,
0.1830166876,
1.1237235069,
-0.2089161873,
-0.3695148528,
-0.2016465813,
0.7801569104,
-0.8534592986,
0.0872853324,
-0.507053256,
0.4501692057,
0.3704272211,
-0.03503225,
-0.5630748272,
-0.2292155772,
0.2753463984,
-0.3582956195,
0.4169901907,
-0.0494262949,
0.4401297867,
0.8050855398,
-0.1120200828,
-0.6816365719,
-0.9868845344,
0.6254146695,
-0.2994660139,
0.6599931121,
0.5650980473,
0.4849978387,
-0.5197699666,
-0.4149656296,
-0.593233645,
-0.3710187674,
-0.1547023654,
-0.1467850953,
-0.2579855919,
0.1991242915,
0.0859284326,
0.1838751733,
-0.5447557569,
0.0708405674,
-0.2383726537,
-0.2673438787,
0.5994591117,
0.1449638456,
-0.1260081381,
-0.4199375808,
-0.3532779515,
0.0734559223,
-0.3635446429,
-0.1553131789,
0.26042822,
0.3304696381,
0.1886817366,
0.5613768101,
-0.6216900349,
0.8487016559,
0.2545108795,
0.197601065,
-0.0015390082,
-0.2089530081,
-0.5865626931,
0.1166698039,
0.299618423,
0.3598048985,
0.4331112802,
-0.2968198955,
-0.5012574196,
0.5406901836,
0.5467023253,
-0.5160863996,
-0.4614679217,
0.3111517131,
-0.6098443866,
-0.4192101359,
0.1297916174,
-0.8043692112,
-0.8353774548,
-0.3916119635,
0.5147017837,
-0.2719012797,
-0.5412590504,
0.8036864996,
-0.0735662505,
-0.0060849609,
0.2263652384,
-0.8578196168,
0.4857567549,
0.4282224774,
0.7125276327,
-0.4773627222,
-0.2759456933,
-0.282777518,
-0.1756367832,
-0.4637306929,
0.9547203183,
-0.1766940653,
-0.5773394108,
-0.233515963,
0.1758546829,
-0.0253887828,
-0.8660076261,
0.3112906516,
-0.0038686648,
-0.3917869627,
-0.1973793954,
-0.1684868485,
-0.488835603,
0.109234713,
-0.7461564541,
0.5224488974,
0.2123646587,
-0.2251262814,
0.7316162586,
-0.5160034299,
-0.5520544052,
-0.0393490158,
-0.5205463171,
-0.383466363,
0.2629812062,
0.0388507918,
0.8423715234,
-0.1038540676,
0.5066406727,
-0.2905391455,
-0.4233093262,
0.2026245445,
-0.2140685916,
0.7023426294,
0.1639033407,
-0.8187873363,
0.1754650921,
-0.7785789967,
-0.2955674231,
-0.096028775,
0.2404333055,
-0.1333097219,
0.3102652431,
-0.1743409783,
0.0778441951,
-0.1926257461,
-0.0379325785,
-0.2726574838,
-0.0888467208,
0.1480348706,
0.745125711,
0.0896275267,
0.5784717202,
-0.4198255539,
0.4197997153,
-0.0379782766,
0.4011961818,
0.2237660885,
-0.4780266881,
-0.7453424335,
-0.1697403789,
-0.2104661614,
0.3625102937,
-0.4026718438,
0.7519853711,
0.1540682912,
-0.200226292,
-0.1961304098,
-0.2998278141,
-0.1438721567,
0.4950145483,
0.4634936452,
-0.1913731545,
-0.5613183379,
-0.7491775155,
0.2065554559,
-0.1277659237,
0.2626328766,
0.124083668,
0.9137986898,
-0.4603145719,
1.0365666151,
-0.3441123962,
-0.4826050103,
-0.2156956047,
0.0694913641,
-0.0718847215,
0.4754475355,
0.6187171936,
-1.1400279999,
0.2659668922,
0.1230920479,
-1.1671423912,
0.1695205271,
-0.3219070733,
0.0781263635,
0.3622075319,
0.3470664918,
-0.7795684338,
1.0159598589,
0.2720902264,
-0.3886660337,
0.7692328095,
-0.0348575562,
0.1183023974,
-0.4469888806,
0.0267209057,
-0.2258304656,
0.2103848904,
-0.6769388318,
0.0854910314,
-0.3476460278,
0.1674002707,
-0.1642259657,
0.274271518,
-0.3670342267,
-0.557168901,
-0.4564660788,
-0.0930972323,
-0.2788410187,
0.23986426,
0.4419588149,
0.4911074936,
0.4800296724,
-1.017764926,
0.3551189005,
0.2009497285,
-0.4948840439,
0.6168478131,
-0.3975331485,
-0.2248957008,
-0.1827749312,
0.3318905532,
-0.5917310119,
-0.5319595933,
0.4499487579,
-0.4125069678,
-0.3001440763,
0.3228492737,
-0.2203732878,
-0.3363532126,
0.0377962627,
0.1102043167,
0.185448125,
-0.5409983993,
0.872708559,
0.4602737129,
0.4025534689,
-0.6428143978,
-0.9091703892,
-0.2348518968,
-0.1781424433,
-0.6528121233,
0.2652485669,
-0.1765150726,
-0.5848510861,
0.0598230027,
-0.4682995975,
-0.1597832739,
0.529070735,
0.5868464112,
-0.0272314381,
-0.0003002618,
0.1364275664,
0.1834593713,
-0.2329790741,
0.2728708386,
-0.2370329946,
0.5815520883,
-0.322059989,
-0.5909557939,
-0.3803747296,
0.4959994555,
0.8110454082,
0.0185917355,
0.5867536068,
0.1892005503,
-1.0416550636,
-0.4969103634,
-0.5569577813,
-0.5836648345,
-0.393960923,
0.2407452613,
-0.5268934369,
-0.3013702333,
0.6001912951,
-0.2231789976,
-0.2627530396,
0.241793856,
0.5092524886,
0.1704862714,
0.9814473987,
0.8214845657,
0.2749931514,
-0.0504414476,
-0.4275895059,
0.4654478729,
-0.2693208456,
-0.4745278656,
-0.4443043768,
-0.2220963985,
-0.4373677075,
-0.1596345156,
0.0516093001,
0.2408193946,
0.0173359942,
0.2210908532,
-0.9028722644,
0.4118776321,
0.161592856,
0.1819642633,
0.4197176099,
-0.2434053421,
0.0539841689,
0.3503233492,
-0.5215210319,
-0.5278440714,
0.7123605013,
-0.0305198058,
0.5412976742,
-0.1584765762,
0.697609663,
0.4761072993,
-0.0159724001,
-0.8539827466,
0.5877372026,
0.1886844635,
-0.5385640264,
-0.4570321739,
-0.0522251092,
-0.7743501663,
0.2391862869,
-0.3015930057,
-0.8016809225,
0.9448923469,
-0.1275474429,
-0.7565491199,
0.2497391701,
-0.5811358094,
0.8500320911,
-0.0738515556,
0.1068117395,
-0.2891490459,
-0.5110420585,
0.479355216,
-0.2368308902,
0.1417058557,
0.0351703875,
0.370223403,
0.5137256384,
-0.0608108602,
0.7359563708,
-0.1763602644,
0.0843717158,
0.3167052567,
0.187670514,
0.4876358807,
0.0081385104,
-0.3197863996,
-0.0841312036,
-0.0889576375,
-0.1189482883,
-0.5198433995,
0.5520330071,
-0.4837623835,
-0.4319828153,
-0.5514743924,
-0.4722168148,
-0.0016050529,
-0.0016198761,
0.5720155239,
0.0307182074,
-0.3805027306,
0.2867345214,
0.8182220459,
0.0353621878,
0.3297219276,
0.1853137463,
-0.4427269995,
-0.0413765572,
0.763342917,
0.1815644354,
0.0640905201,
-0.0890972465,
0.041313611,
-0.2344396263,
-0.9089031219,
-0.1256603301,
0.0205728691,
-0.9117053747,
-0.0639311746,
-0.7503069043,
-0.1705399752,
-0.3780020475,
-0.509087503,
-0.3295543194,
-0.3393082321,
-0.471555233,
-0.4042717218,
0.1192200854,
0.8923658133,
-0.3069681525,
0.2473866493,
0.0157234818,
0.5629927516,
0.309266746,
0.1499039531,
0.1117365137,
-0.0173950512,
-0.0021630242,
0.0001645657,
-0.1919333935,
-0.868449986,
0.2901778221,
-0.3870757818,
0.7079209089,
0.5273889899,
0.444716543,
0.472336024,
0.13881585,
0.5313673615,
-0.0019783338,
-0.8503086567,
0.6342657804,
0.007146291,
-0.2288220525,
0.585033834,
0.5056008101,
-0.1561198235,
-0.1201770306,
-0.5067922473,
-0.481592536,
0.5829483271,
0.1700466573,
-0.3101328611,
-0.1411346495,
0.2149511725,
0.5364076495,
0.3082143068,
-0.7720634937,
0.0665619373,
-0.2889065444,
0.1450855434,
0.1668188572,
0.1328293979,
-0.024940718,
-0.2542809248,
0.3912505209,
-0.130849123,
0.2553528845,
0.2384977788,
-0.3122941256,
-0.3706018329,
-0.0938450769,
0.6652699113,
0.7266750932,
-0.3283165693,
-0.0025748997,
0.1143474579,
-0.2922908068,
0.2434237599,
0.0999793559,
-0.3947701752,
-0.0565041788,
-0.0143116685,
0.7353433371,
0.2128180116,
-0.6342567205,
0.4334767163,
0.2485778481,
-0.3599824607,
-0.6977210045,
0.1509427875,
-0.3197298944,
0.5333937407,
0.4003743231,
0.6548978686,
0.4718923867,
-0.6661656499,
0.4124485254,
0.4434983134,
-0.3560254872,
-0.2504611015,
0.4501260519,
0.1677886993,
-0.533883512,
0.6078540683,
-0.3668347597,
-0.4263687432,
0.8020877838,
0.3215474188,
1.1519478559,
-0.2543561757,
0.4318170547,
-0.0413147472,
0.5857717991,
-0.5747376084,
0.2397458702,
-0.1577472389,
-0.9200783372,
-0.1187543869,
-0.6075825095,
-0.3201496899,
0.3856084049,
-0.6705966592,
0.355564326,
-0.5833116174,
-0.2869020402,
-0.2579683959,
-0.1555904299,
-0.5779677033,
0.4122627079,
0.0086066676,
0.6666334271,
-1.028200388,
0.3640720248,
0.3471959829,
-0.2440238893,
-0.2315528542,
0.1130928323,
0.0131457606,
-0.322550267,
0.4296420217,
0.4702809453,
-0.5405658484,
-0.1449016184,
-0.3501304686,
-0.5260120034,
1.1567344666,
0.2328226715,
-0.1816995591,
-0.3101382256,
-0.0141014596,
0.3259159029,
-0.5718989968,
-0.0950670168,
0.9876434803,
0.7183408141,
0.0793319419,
-0.7285880446,
0.1033342332,
0.1660482734,
-0.3117940724,
0.2117269188,
-0.270101428,
0.8775034547,
-0.3955799341,
-0.3271461427,
0.2985602319,
0.568525672,
0.4876441061,
0.7430160642,
0.6734924912,
0.3770470321,
0.9418808222,
-0.1428727061,
0.8114837408,
0.017913131,
0.0217728,
0.7006607056,
-0.4240581393,
0.6343106627,
0.5091676712,
0.1872840375,
0.3564788997,
0.6572762132,
0.0663593337,
0.7055476904,
0.1438917816,
-0.1439679563,
-0.5456416607,
-0.0931275114,
-0.4165901244,
0.5673453808,
0.6374867558,
-0.1564447135,
-0.0572385453,
0.340149492,
-0.5239028335,
0.1394818276,
-0.0604362264,
0.4364618361,
0.0235814024,
-0.7965715528,
0.5460377336,
-0.3013676107,
0.5449629426,
-0.277069062,
-0.1548565775,
-0.21131064,
0.2968491316,
-0.3385998905,
-0.4370061755,
0.6016380787,
-0.3975528479,
-0.3286505938,
-0.1279937625,
0.6414791942,
0.2027892619,
-0.2835332155,
0.7240051627,
0.6121256351,
0.3115985692,
-0.3880760074,
-0.4537365139,
0.2812544405,
-0.0976239517,
-0.0283143204,
0.121358268,
0.4347376525,
-0.3181371987,
0.9050748944,
0.3595849574,
0.0712867528,
0.0512345545,
-0.1514254957,
0.5667466521,
-0.5821277499,
-0.5842652917,
-0.4929583371,
0.2919054031,
-0.0014301356,
-0.2220519632,
0.1697999835,
0.139452517,
0.9304613471,
-0.1289901286,
0.710226357,
-0.0354743376,
0.0625245497,
-0.5665536523,
0.7503113151,
-0.4306652844,
0.1612448692,
-0.2965119183,
-0.8875456452,
-0.4230387509,
1.1863611937,
-0.242075786,
0.0484158248,
0.8403167725,
0.8685488105,
-0.0202050004,
0.4791751206,
0.4172942042,
-0.0287872124,
0.0165270213,
0.4725626111,
1.0194395781,
-0.1839911342,
0.38921538,
-0.4433015883,
-0.3155719936,
-0.5811448693,
-0.7749975324,
-0.8854652643,
-0.9232118726,
-0.1394388229,
-0.1406642795,
0.2477998734,
0.7637159228,
0.8480680585,
-0.9693622589,
-0.3686516583,
-0.7292814851,
0.3366096914,
-0.6286887527,
-0.204577148,
0.1402133852,
-0.0800387561,
-0.3008586168,
0.6538597345,
0.2547311485,
0.4579540491,
-0.4908897281,
-0.3891673982,
-0.081939742,
-0.0532413386,
0.5257896185,
0.1963199079,
-1.0923519135,
-0.2276000082,
0.1758777797,
0.204409644,
-0.2183886915,
0.8005390167,
-1.142392993,
0.4107689559,
0.3830520511,
0.5544700027,
0.322861284,
-0.2923194766,
0.5158622861,
-0.1179617941,
0.2588435411,
0.518016994,
0.3060018718,
0.3432129323,
-0.5606061816,
0.7758865356,
0.3375404179,
-0.4693415463,
-1.1002597809,
0.3181441426,
-0.7399045825,
-0.5891820192,
0.6669470072,
0.3864207566,
-0.0216386113,
-0.4619222879,
0.042754624,
0.0798004642,
-0.1513528973,
1.2951915264,
0.8165516257,
-0.3615402579,
0.0230686963,
-0.6122276187,
0.680809617,
0.4180134833,
-0.7768261433,
0.2457893044,
0.6245853305,
-0.3724733591,
0.5166007876,
0.5928240418,
0.3161533475,
0.6755621433,
0.1160312146,
-0.0158907697,
0.1554020941,
-0.9733337164,
-0.4242025614,
0.214610666,
-0.1881346703,
-0.1815651804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16516v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16516v2
|
Visually Guided Generative Text-Layout Pre-training for Document Intelligence
| 2024-03-25T08:00:43 | 2024-03-27T12:32:31 |
Zhiming Mao, Haoli Bai, Lu Hou, Jiansheng Wei, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu, Kam-Fai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Prior study shows that pre-training techniques can boost the performance of
visual document understanding (VDU), which typically requires models to gain
abilities to perceive and reason both document texts and layouts (e.g.,
locations of texts and table-cells). To this end, we propose visually guided
generative text-layout pre-training, named ViTLP. Given a document image, the
model optimizes hierarchical language and layout modeling objectives to
generate the interleaved text and layout sequence. In addition, to address the
limitation of processing long documents by Transformers, we introduce a
straightforward yet effective multi-segment generative pre-training scheme,
facilitating ViTLP to process word-intensive documents of any length. ViTLP can
function as a native OCR model to localize and recognize texts of document
images. Besides, ViTLP can be effectively applied to various downstream VDU
tasks. Extensive experiments show that ViTLP achieves competitive performance
over existing baselines on benchmark VDU tasks, including information
extraction, document classification, and document question answering.
|
[
-0.4070926309,
-0.597835958,
0.7114846706,
0.1497045457,
-0.4773670137,
0.028337257,
0.0103438916,
-0.4153883159,
-0.0303288326,
0.4730484188,
-0.6610082388,
-0.6823630929,
-0.5195376277,
-0.0343622528,
-0.6074569225,
0.6343578696,
-0.0412262604,
0.077764675,
-0.4830005765,
0.1031805649,
-0.4666857123,
-0.5284884572,
-0.1272748113,
-0.0117772948,
0.5194935203,
0.4939903915,
0.3732897341,
0.6213104725,
0.7752298713,
0.4187927544,
0.0192773473,
0.2028125972,
-0.2280589044,
0.0402740687,
0.0563158765,
-0.4051376283,
-0.4802868962,
-0.1193479374,
0.7008761764,
0.3444565237,
0.0745413974,
-0.1241773367,
0.150974974,
0.663905859,
-0.6088663936,
0.0901335776,
-0.4260720313,
0.3095927835,
-0.2717087865,
-0.5634095073,
-0.5913174748,
-0.4673848152,
0.2317812294,
-0.7488831878,
0.4951175153,
-0.017513955,
1.0075632334,
0.1768131554,
-0.2009526491,
-0.1656872928,
-0.678288579,
0.3364053369,
-0.3146835268,
0.5628105402,
0.2025513053,
0.1141397282,
0.2107624561,
-1.2445160151,
-0.588100493,
0.1558380127,
-0.1975108534,
0.4436038435,
0.1926528513,
0.2158463448,
0.5627846122,
0.6183584332,
-0.8519779444,
0.0449871086,
-0.398696363,
-0.0935407951,
0.1333701462,
-0.0052350168,
0.6303867698,
0.0833896101,
-0.4975818992,
-0.3431682587,
-0.2965166271,
-0.109986566,
0.1277912408,
-0.1333274543,
0.0200967193,
0.597174108,
-0.1390938163,
0.8161179423,
-0.3227615654,
-0.0846030563,
0.2264480591,
-0.5106676221,
-0.4268729985,
0.149378106,
0.4806304276,
0.0940953419,
0.3707802594,
0.0514647439,
-0.0572251268,
0.0703615248,
0.5788933039,
-1.0041217804,
-0.1797878295,
-0.1606233567,
-0.4403491914,
-0.1715783328,
0.0750010908,
-0.735355258,
-0.3234717846,
-0.4496201873,
0.4622822702,
-0.8348370194,
0.0250622891,
0.2239350677,
-0.4672988653,
0.6188256741,
0.5855765939,
-1.0340908766,
0.0879878104,
0.4362618029,
0.975441277,
-0.0172490533,
-0.5438115597,
-0.6752311587,
0.1866949946,
-0.1602605432,
1.0900417566,
-0.3529053032,
-0.6715881824,
0.2106045187,
-0.1575918943,
-0.2197691798,
-0.2358917445,
0.652536571,
-0.448499918,
0.4343029559,
-0.2096295506,
-0.3084806502,
0.2124530971,
0.359070152,
-0.714402616,
0.6601284742,
0.2728461623,
-1.0115704536,
0.5646304488,
-0.5650320649,
-0.6198861599,
0.3276423514,
-0.4138510525,
-0.6042760611,
0.2443407923,
0.5791541934,
0.2254799008,
0.1382423341,
-0.3684880137,
-0.0528765135,
-0.3472822607,
-0.2180334777,
-0.4155076444,
0.5372616649,
0.119475022,
-0.0464180298,
0.3464342952,
-0.5466057658,
0.2319286764,
0.1349504292,
-0.4480734169,
-0.3974389434,
-0.1919876933,
0.2122433782,
-0.0077868858,
0.3112226427,
-0.2178287357,
0.5171172023,
-0.3336368799,
0.0675605834,
0.6005969644,
-0.3441591859,
0.5812073946,
-0.1191096008,
0.5024867654,
-0.1337817758,
0.3836696148,
-0.6013761163,
-0.4857939184,
-0.7431890368,
-0.3464073241,
0.3238723278,
0.5064499974,
-1.0496380329,
0.3031005561,
-0.3901002109,
-0.3414220512,
-0.0475080088,
0.067010656,
0.5736519694,
0.6519169211,
0.4308425188,
-0.6345323324,
-0.370039016,
-0.6330319047,
-0.1518502235,
-0.0663960502,
0.2186063081,
-0.115225777,
0.3477341831,
-0.2063449919,
0.7103529572,
-0.7160125971,
-0.7342071533,
-0.4762532115,
0.5777778029,
-0.0325708985,
0.3475650251,
0.5323851705,
-1.1204514503,
-0.6948645115,
0.1911573112,
-0.6792145371,
-0.0236680768,
-0.0381788127,
-0.2445608824,
0.145172745,
0.7812485695,
-0.625772357,
0.9018891454,
0.2475305498,
-0.335915029,
0.5810961127,
-0.7116575837,
0.0899798051,
-0.9785128832,
-0.1465738714,
-0.0186172444,
-0.1761519909,
-0.6071121097,
0.0726546049,
0.4641550183,
-0.2293052822,
-0.3914126158,
0.3897999227,
-0.7842396498,
-0.3621901572,
-0.1216816902,
-0.1273390204,
0.2552787364,
0.4344311953,
0.5337131023,
0.8866938353,
0.1529134661,
-0.3603405654,
-0.0292728618,
0.4822809696,
-0.7404589057,
0.7523832321,
-0.4004437625,
-0.011762402,
-0.3467768133,
-0.1131025478,
-0.9289200902,
-0.1536940187,
-0.2355182022,
-0.4401977956,
0.5406159759,
-0.022069728,
-0.4678166509,
-0.4456941187,
-0.2363123298,
0.3938578367,
0.5584212542,
-0.6323615909,
0.7825452089,
0.0543480925,
-0.2262927592,
-0.4914862812,
-0.6410085559,
-0.1030753106,
-0.0052598505,
-0.6083971858,
0.7232012153,
-0.0195653085,
0.2167210579,
-0.1824365109,
-0.0253703482,
-0.196571514,
-0.0003305958,
0.3000203073,
-0.0120019661,
-0.221097663,
0.1089425161,
-0.0313813277,
-0.1983017921,
-0.1774345338,
-0.3195934594,
0.8557481766,
-0.2760125101,
-0.6139349341,
-0.2378002405,
0.4380966723,
0.5613667965,
-0.7569569349,
0.4028839767,
0.8532209396,
-0.1541332006,
-0.2284713835,
-0.3628191352,
0.1099541858,
-0.4972331226,
0.5098049045,
-0.3869886994,
-0.4351135492,
0.0001572841,
-0.1689101905,
0.1153570041,
0.2737797797,
0.3847555518,
-0.3571502268,
0.9498147368,
1.0046252012,
0.1375988126,
1.0371713638,
-0.4236288965,
0.1101291627,
-0.5867285728,
-0.3000361323,
-0.5957611203,
-0.0718395039,
-0.0709480718,
-0.5275589228,
0.3706767261,
0.0721883699,
0.0417444445,
0.1784837246,
-0.6204221845,
0.622867465,
1.0039319992,
0.1378320009,
0.2473412752,
0.2789830565,
-0.2436888814,
-0.1075243726,
-0.6043647528,
-0.2613119781,
0.7633203268,
0.0793068334,
0.7509842515,
-0.2077602595,
0.7958089709,
0.2788634002,
0.2308032364,
-0.7260542512,
0.4887561202,
-0.2500931323,
-0.0107355332,
-0.4150012136,
0.0119754756,
-0.8194935322,
0.0633999184,
-0.2888074815,
-0.65658319,
0.1265344918,
0.1337804645,
-0.1880304515,
0.1779332757,
-1.0281997919,
1.0835307837,
-0.6393934488,
-0.1408383548,
-0.0092557082,
-0.3740844131,
0.1240338609,
0.0442711338,
-0.1027718261,
0.4511598647,
0.3439586759,
0.5023784041,
-0.7016603947,
0.4737233818,
-0.0838616788,
0.1259021759,
0.0855785087,
-0.3095268309,
0.2909963727,
-0.2342258543,
0.1624113023,
-0.1380174756,
-0.126723364,
-0.3723506629,
-0.6071411967,
0.3798584938,
-0.7374358773,
-0.6642412543,
-0.4133864343,
-0.3233659565,
-0.0388137065,
0.6589963436,
0.670347333,
0.6529726982,
-0.379748255,
0.3369143009,
1.1101424694,
-0.3043275476,
0.4902699888,
0.0008757232,
-0.3848204315,
-0.2602863908,
0.8792623281,
-0.0077407807,
0.0783021376,
0.7781579494,
0.0092883315,
-0.4909857512,
-0.8008688688,
-0.3941447735,
0.0177931134,
-0.8003192544,
0.1739722341,
-0.7014194131,
-0.5650142431,
-0.3442720473,
-0.4027749002,
-0.1419187486,
0.0379205607,
-0.3646842539,
-0.0472414866,
-0.0370906331,
0.5590177178,
0.2658541203,
0.5699028969,
-0.7249913216,
0.6721851826,
0.7013291121,
0.3062432408,
-0.2498167753,
-0.3679987192,
-0.279595226,
-0.3377261162,
-0.3979701698,
-0.7492220998,
0.5103915334,
0.1021960676,
0.5279554129,
0.4331978858,
-0.1005636901,
0.6404640079,
-0.5509893894,
0.509871304,
0.3630709648,
-0.7362584472,
0.7821734548,
-0.3066947162,
0.7261063457,
0.4476393759,
0.321098268,
-0.0294217207,
-0.0596121252,
-0.3907765448,
-0.7317344546,
0.6319390535,
0.2446185201,
-0.0945949331,
0.3264053166,
0.0478407741,
-0.149730891,
0.1809224784,
-0.7295418978,
0.2614304721,
-0.5143728852,
-0.225517109,
0.008504034,
-0.5235885382,
-0.0314126201,
-0.3659093678,
0.2645786107,
-0.2931145728,
0.4537911415,
0.4297387898,
-0.4519994557,
0.3432729244,
0.1871674508,
0.823331356,
0.6147345901,
-0.262355566,
0.0227503516,
-0.1666864604,
-0.9615505934,
-0.0618604831,
0.2180967927,
-0.1172132343,
0.0584267154,
0.5821208358,
0.8254141808,
-0.2721855044,
-0.4015956223,
0.7675302029,
-0.6167336702,
-0.4887646735,
-0.3130922019,
0.1101710796,
-0.0434286818,
0.1923654228,
0.2678497434,
-0.1648944616,
-0.0409434922,
-0.4469690919,
0.1322530359,
0.3838395476,
-0.6206309795,
0.0602023005,
0.7072988153,
0.203068614,
-0.5424166918,
0.8655080795,
0.1409479678,
-0.51843822,
0.773337841,
0.5138107538,
0.8863145709,
0.0347766057,
0.4102587402,
0.0972638652,
0.4178221822,
-0.0216593165,
0.4895945489,
-0.4419260025,
-0.5513392091,
-0.3118665218,
-0.6852382421,
-0.2595859468,
0.086489968,
-0.4891447723,
0.4051746428,
-0.6283453703,
-0.0709052682,
0.0172112677,
-0.1557440311,
-0.7970885634,
0.5591374636,
0.3688746691,
0.9627605081,
-0.4441719651,
1.1573301554,
0.5670707822,
-0.5072996616,
-0.4998703301,
0.2638469338,
-0.2653048635,
-0.7638781667,
0.6673929691,
0.5793501735,
-0.170899719,
0.1627778709,
-0.4240294397,
-0.4483076632,
1.1247563362,
0.0435173549,
-0.5869909525,
-0.3917168081,
0.1901311576,
0.6487848759,
-0.1594378352,
0.3296206295,
0.1570253819,
0.3847681284,
0.0001622234,
-0.4910541475,
-0.3659339845,
-0.4757294655,
0.2189639211,
0.1276574135,
-0.3669044971,
0.7861122489,
-0.1682912856,
-0.2468877584,
0.3063691854,
0.8114862442,
0.0841888636,
0.2950063646,
0.5188376904,
0.7072529793,
0.6368032694,
-0.2374107391,
1.1128873825,
-0.1555441618,
-0.1957859099,
1.1335396767,
-0.0829085335,
0.5653274059,
0.3784641325,
0.1292742342,
0.5247604847,
0.4023548365,
0.151018098,
0.738514483,
-0.1148077771,
-0.1917561144,
-0.2172298729,
-0.0404195823,
-0.5976845026,
0.3241584003,
0.5440475941,
-0.5384704471,
-0.1792241335,
-0.0112773273,
-0.4459224641,
0.2253320068,
-0.3460963368,
0.79013592,
0.0061198939,
-0.61349684,
0.2825109065,
-0.1666701436,
0.4959057868,
-0.8228814602,
-0.0345186293,
-0.2933676541,
0.2163048089,
-0.108270444,
-0.8681331277,
0.0379732661,
-0.178554818,
-0.3734317422,
-0.693744719,
0.9839361906,
-0.2502545416,
-0.3877058029,
0.1422873735,
0.4265229702,
-0.1838872433,
-0.2838948369,
-0.485978812,
-0.0901382565,
-0.0052292636,
-0.179203257,
0.5178897977,
0.5812304616,
-0.1232756674,
0.2921311259,
0.6319018006,
-0.081797868,
0.1077224314,
0.4045351148,
0.8467214704,
-0.6488552094,
-0.7420706749,
-0.7311102748,
0.5662686229,
-0.4284109473,
-0.3245656788,
0.5136291981,
0.5770716667,
0.9129487872,
-0.34992975,
0.8081872463,
0.2378766984,
0.0448224954,
-0.8446387053,
0.8198541999,
-0.823502779,
-0.163735047,
-0.5502416492,
-0.9190669656,
-0.2904084921,
0.4808568358,
-0.4482658505,
-0.1719100028,
0.9091289043,
0.5831625462,
-0.2181114703,
-0.1163965464,
0.4361017644,
-0.2405680567,
0.3998360932,
0.4385794401,
0.9640951157,
-0.1567685604,
0.6200832725,
-0.1751081944,
-0.0825731009,
-0.3022274971,
-0.8459371328,
-1.0868421793,
-0.7688551545,
-0.0025324831,
-0.0842036083,
-0.085476689,
0.1441180557,
0.7651779652,
-0.1482943445,
0.001848184,
-0.3632053733,
0.3276566863,
-0.0453822538,
-0.1606200933,
0.3766514957,
-0.3859941065,
-0.6506325603,
0.182083264,
0.6444689631,
0.4642480016,
-0.1475198418,
0.0529612154,
-0.2466916144,
-0.1510417759,
0.6149150729,
0.5165479779,
-0.2967662215,
0.0421480946,
-0.1324480027,
-0.3877203763,
0.3223315775,
0.9187489152,
-0.6339498758,
0.6656906605,
0.974894166,
0.6937634349,
0.7317177653,
0.2032588273,
0.6206344366,
-0.778254807,
0.4808008373,
-0.0363986641,
0.4950054288,
0.2327484041,
-0.3808263242,
0.4589011967,
0.1676410735,
-0.3062179685,
-0.6754210591,
0.2875173688,
-0.9810412526,
-0.4255641103,
0.7946899533,
-0.0777389333,
-0.4043714106,
0.0584874637,
-0.6643728614,
0.1399522871,
0.0411808006,
0.5804222822,
0.3462260067,
0.07945095,
-0.4770587385,
-0.2414132953,
0.6739313602,
0.3869532049,
-1.1263576746,
-0.3594213724,
0.4038375318,
-0.3425770402,
0.3960342705,
1.0519744158,
-0.0710200369,
0.3664075732,
0.1546055526,
0.1886328608,
-0.1413675398,
-0.8217603564,
0.0419579819,
0.2585282922,
0.1137364283,
-0.3110342622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16512v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16512v5
|
LLMs Are Few-Shot In-Context Low-Resource Language Learners
| 2024-03-25T07:55:29 | 2024-06-25T11:54:23 |
Samuel Cahyawijaya, Holy Lovenia, Pascale Fung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In-context learning (ICL) empowers large language models (LLMs) to perform
diverse tasks in underrepresented languages using only short in-context
information, offering a crucial avenue for narrowing the gap between
high-resource and low-resource languages. Nonetheless, there is only a handful
of works explored ICL for low-resource languages with most of them focusing on
relatively high-resource languages, such as French and Spanish. In this work,
we extensively study ICL and its cross-lingual variation (X-ICL) on 25
low-resource and 7 relatively higher-resource languages. Our study not only
assesses the effectiveness of ICL with LLMs in low-resource languages but also
identifies the shortcomings of in-context label alignment, and introduces a
more effective alternative: query alignment. Moreover, we provide valuable
insights into various facets of ICL for low-resource languages. Our study
concludes the significance of few-shot in-context information on enhancing the
low-resource understanding quality of LLMs through semantically relevant
information by closing the language gap in the target language and aligning the
semantics between the targeted low-resource and the high-resource language that
the model is proficient in. Our work highlights the importance of advancing ICL
research, particularly for low-resource languages. Our code is publicly
released at https://github.com/SamuelCahyawijaya/in-context-alignment
|
[
-0.374943763,
-0.3910081387,
0.4117261767,
-0.1023865119,
-0.1221827269,
0.4646990001,
-0.2570772469,
-0.611420393,
-0.1987321377,
0.2283923328,
-0.5840836167,
-0.6276288629,
-0.4367694557,
0.170969218,
-0.0995622277,
0.9078415036,
-0.0869517773,
0.2594750524,
-0.2117922902,
-0.4273315668,
-0.248747915,
-0.3495617807,
-0.4397573769,
-0.4686143398,
0.6771088839,
0.8441228867,
0.5152522922,
0.6413306594,
0.5724416971,
0.0947260037,
-0.3085469604,
0.2457844019,
-0.8704842925,
-0.2849882543,
-0.3049284518,
-0.4560725987,
-0.1473942399,
-0.1763896644,
0.8639877439,
0.9250845313,
0.1459725648,
0.1641785055,
0.467823714,
0.7812182307,
-0.7929697037,
-0.0684490725,
-0.8048946261,
0.0494646057,
-0.5768411756,
0.0516130738,
-0.3100296557,
-0.066740714,
0.2654923201,
-0.4451086521,
-0.1898879558,
0.3499120772,
0.8373203874,
0.4444044232,
-0.5160886049,
-0.1559055001,
-0.4628781676,
1.0689631701,
-0.7745446563,
0.6028524637,
0.414740324,
0.2580217123,
-0.0292734597,
-0.4738886356,
-0.4223110378,
-0.0582961664,
-0.3315210342,
-0.138910085,
-0.0458397381,
-0.0375271477,
0.1760141253,
0.1153160632,
-0.4386044741,
0.6571666002,
-0.13063775,
-0.0001485355,
0.2925189435,
0.3122552633,
0.347135216,
-0.1393682957,
-0.5394852757,
0.1776309907,
-1.2806335688,
0.3154713213,
0.096976608,
0.7602058649,
-0.4998646677,
0.4908548295,
-0.076433152,
0.8872343302,
-0.1620111465,
-0.5071321726,
-0.0174578559,
-0.4971608818,
-0.213205561,
0.2963681817,
0.6833952069,
0.1815277487,
-0.1172874197,
-0.1687567681,
-0.1473556012,
-0.3606790304,
-0.4068615735,
-0.7150268555,
0.3130292892,
-0.1654916555,
-0.3635321558,
0.0922321901,
-0.1956349909,
-0.4861591458,
-0.1686827093,
-0.2361994088,
0.1090160534,
-0.3856479824,
0.0576354153,
-0.1564751714,
0.3548871279,
0.4595727026,
0.2791223228,
-0.8303691745,
0.3197394311,
0.6177098155,
0.8210955858,
-0.5427659154,
-0.2852574289,
-0.4890885353,
0.2789171636,
-0.2775177956,
0.4336533248,
-0.6168745756,
-0.4221070111,
-0.0266276225,
-0.0542174205,
-0.0510285608,
-0.5739957094,
0.3377251923,
-0.5599611402,
0.0415040776,
-0.5386946797,
-0.6106238365,
-0.0053406497,
0.4014353752,
-0.4342236221,
0.9700648785,
0.1139804795,
-0.6589158773,
0.5113807321,
-0.3068554401,
-0.2634298205,
0.1217358708,
-0.5137125254,
-0.1499570161,
0.0485298857,
0.0209303554,
0.1129153818,
-0.5530330539,
-0.1121362746,
-0.0300900135,
-0.5156530142,
0.4379925132,
-0.4280459881,
0.7603148222,
0.1602237374,
-0.3505449593,
-0.2506159842,
-0.5065245032,
0.2139935195,
-0.082928732,
-0.5236257315,
-0.4183330536,
-0.2400607914,
0.1010030881,
0.4665355682,
0.2131656557,
-0.5148242712,
0.197070986,
-0.5658839941,
0.0813640729,
0.459669143,
-0.3169889748,
0.6607741714,
-0.2255261093,
0.5924905539,
0.0599127039,
-0.0606363602,
-0.0941703618,
-0.1635505706,
-0.5057794452,
-0.3666757345,
0.3442376852,
0.5291233659,
-0.6865020394,
-0.1167889088,
-0.214237079,
-0.2315808535,
-0.7000672817,
0.5278815627,
0.9275699258,
0.7336685061,
0.3405379951,
-0.1589821577,
-0.4264762998,
-0.8871504068,
-0.2146432698,
-0.1022545397,
0.2851810753,
0.5116914511,
0.303499192,
-0.1354009211,
0.9956355095,
-0.2463328391,
-0.4068845809,
-0.4485412836,
-0.3359463215,
0.0851088464,
0.3940552473,
0.5809828639,
-0.6019740701,
-1.0556100607,
0.2420340329,
-0.6070358157,
-0.0833567008,
0.3316521347,
-0.2315173447,
0.4045678675,
0.5200027823,
-0.2376028746,
0.222140342,
0.5568657517,
-0.0395857766,
-0.054022871,
0.03883617,
-0.0490939878,
-0.7541538477,
-0.1012683362,
0.0967348441,
-0.1258479655,
-0.4994740486,
-0.1776881665,
0.2541555166,
-0.0505325496,
-1.0053631067,
0.9194797873,
-0.6082420945,
-0.0266455319,
-0.2652423382,
0.3450037241,
-0.0298112947,
0.3728980422,
-0.0129885701,
0.8351672292,
0.4667277932,
-0.4446920455,
-0.3328635991,
0.0584652759,
-0.5122386217,
0.5450587869,
-0.1586188674,
-0.0139333662,
-0.1787742823,
-0.0127913319,
-0.9466303587,
-0.0895401463,
0.411940217,
-0.0064343335,
0.6842823625,
-0.3026216328,
-0.3948502541,
0.232630074,
-0.087052457,
0.9001405835,
0.3365964293,
-0.7595821023,
0.1433018744,
0.4258640707,
0.1379565001,
-0.8341576457,
-0.8652877808,
-0.0545361638,
-0.3330733776,
-0.4578978121,
0.5754947066,
-0.0638088211,
-0.5611165762,
0.00767816,
-0.0703029484,
0.005467169,
-0.0138726681,
-0.0826155394,
0.1736644655,
-0.4683304131,
0.2618038356,
-0.1555782557,
-0.0763075203,
-0.4404379427,
-0.3063200414,
0.3276365399,
-0.2806875706,
-0.6183118224,
-0.4224377573,
0.3667120039,
0.3348518014,
-0.0683199987,
0.7653732896,
0.2464271337,
-0.3659762442,
-0.167074278,
-0.3601415455,
0.0504112728,
-0.3962791264,
0.2855565548,
-0.3095179498,
-0.9465741515,
0.4377515614,
0.0154199693,
-0.1122310534,
0.2397077233,
0.3826777339,
-0.3382683694,
0.9685080051,
0.9482731819,
-0.2897327244,
0.5201840997,
-0.2451792955,
0.2606775761,
-0.9198057055,
-0.2255140096,
-0.4668622315,
-0.4231207371,
-0.6339902282,
-0.3051788211,
0.3945427239,
0.1818347126,
-0.1893852502,
0.0754903555,
-0.1853915155,
0.7908161283,
0.367936492,
0.0644371584,
0.4503999054,
-0.0571161732,
-0.1182010546,
-0.4646013379,
-0.9522954226,
-0.6079277992,
0.7225567102,
0.038138479,
1.1017984152,
0.3120615482,
0.8379611969,
-0.0546857156,
0.1655461043,
-0.8974995017,
0.2883021533,
-0.2911669314,
-0.511519134,
-0.3502235413,
-0.0845091939,
-0.8501549363,
0.4655600786,
0.0682635829,
-0.7481478453,
0.2883168161,
0.1753045917,
-0.4511974752,
0.4138210714,
-0.650095284,
0.8632400632,
-0.8437270522,
-0.6620194912,
0.0404301658,
-0.7844181657,
0.3333785236,
-0.3226315975,
0.3123532534,
-0.2306417525,
-0.4530592561,
0.3591124117,
-0.4574069381,
1.2074501514,
0.1758525372,
-0.1230236292,
0.2966817319,
-0.0497129932,
0.4758731425,
0.0371205509,
-0.089294903,
0.1020642594,
-0.0695079267,
-0.5704026818,
-0.3807370663,
0.8196578026,
-0.6769196987,
-0.5961655974,
-0.4413308799,
-0.6408174038,
-0.1302079409,
0.0944155008,
0.4770731926,
0.2184767425,
-0.1729246229,
0.1908605099,
0.7195468545,
-0.1932738423,
0.5521845222,
0.7425895333,
0.0006306486,
-0.1251826584,
0.8095460534,
0.4255768955,
0.4894762337,
0.7074579,
0.0994190723,
-0.1516033113,
-0.4768291116,
-0.4731037021,
0.2724931836,
-0.8762428761,
-0.409607321,
-0.3898694217,
0.0107045909,
-0.1115274429,
-0.4803249538,
-0.3475623131,
-0.2518195808,
-0.3662242293,
0.2274139225,
0.0390042365,
0.4451662004,
0.1554192752,
0.4837606251,
-0.7479560375,
-0.0875430107,
-0.0176093858,
0.1744993627,
0.0605419874,
-0.6161821485,
-0.615783751,
-0.1103666872,
-0.1802632958,
-0.6250095963,
0.2736394107,
0.3513351083,
0.7788106799,
0.3793330193,
0.0067942371,
0.8295884728,
-0.370441854,
0.6916383505,
0.1770458668,
-0.9279783368,
0.4408718348,
0.0144166751,
0.6454715133,
0.7654212117,
0.5203822851,
-0.6573415399,
-0.2856090963,
-0.404212296,
-0.8648913503,
0.9890329242,
-0.0493087284,
-0.0482595004,
-0.0341851674,
0.25485304,
0.1617459655,
0.0862741619,
-0.8398880959,
-0.3800558746,
0.2539990842,
-0.2574639618,
0.0657248423,
-0.3324106038,
-0.2426851988,
-0.1717168242,
0.7658036947,
-0.393948108,
-0.3583183289,
-0.0918345898,
-0.3771526814,
-0.3204710186,
0.362457335,
0.4800815284,
0.730902791,
-0.0767982975,
0.1821081489,
0.5407461524,
-0.0500142463,
0.2802496552,
-0.0517550297,
-0.2735174596,
-0.1696707159,
0.4829770327,
0.6634941101,
0.6645432711,
-0.8711312413,
0.4434452355,
0.0828269273,
0.4198466241,
-0.0083969645,
-0.0456041992,
0.0695313439,
0.3990355134,
0.1685117781,
-0.1629460603,
-0.165941447,
-0.5642219186,
-0.0732973814,
0.7087414861,
-0.6201585531,
-0.1574568748,
0.4454959929,
0.0282976013,
-0.1747259945,
0.5851838589,
-0.23591353,
-0.2255723178,
0.5185971856,
0.7042670846,
0.5821032524,
0.1841249168,
-0.135627985,
0.1938787997,
0.326254338,
0.0463837758,
0.102824077,
-0.2475131154,
-0.7422439456,
-0.4142610133,
-0.4581468105,
-0.5879446864,
-0.1028006822,
-0.4706172645,
0.5056388974,
-0.1687354892,
-0.0470560156,
-0.3500793576,
0.0135125965,
-0.7560597062,
-0.010695355,
0.2248983085,
0.8460772634,
-0.6991250515,
1.0877968073,
0.7080858946,
-0.5135291219,
-0.6745860577,
0.1044686362,
0.3213919401,
-0.795820117,
1.2417297363,
-0.0863893405,
-0.4174419641,
0.08098232,
-0.5599068403,
-1.2870146036,
1.119794488,
0.6150653362,
-0.7367535233,
0.0168920252,
0.3768128157,
0.447363168,
-0.6196247935,
0.0734373033,
0.4691403508,
0.2869209349,
0.1669373959,
-0.8339992762,
-0.1760513037,
0.1378899664,
0.1978480369,
0.3034461141,
-0.9118030071,
0.6004806757,
-0.3264151216,
-0.3472180068,
0.0608738363,
0.5961012244,
0.3625523746,
0.3827588856,
0.2215083539,
0.3885474205,
0.8634520173,
-0.1370425522,
0.9800450206,
-0.4208556116,
0.2101909518,
1.289270401,
-0.5431044698,
0.7124531269,
0.8267276883,
-0.073702231,
0.1896677464,
0.8224566579,
0.3937372565,
0.6057909727,
0.0910161957,
-0.4719520509,
-0.2656077743,
-0.5537824035,
-0.2653884888,
0.4061942697,
0.4816004038,
-0.2674247622,
-0.3317212462,
0.1168281585,
0.00785203,
0.0400761068,
-0.2224626243,
0.7772184014,
0.3470329344,
-0.4379856288,
0.8001719713,
-0.2036358565,
0.7255427837,
-0.5410531759,
0.0816665441,
-0.3688112199,
0.1512012035,
-0.4194290936,
-0.8077937365,
0.0737756789,
0.103657864,
-0.2676166594,
-0.2122858465,
0.5873885155,
-0.6100162864,
-0.2309333086,
0.5438172221,
0.7805307508,
0.1878469586,
0.4929546118,
-0.6743475199,
0.1905875653,
0.0412262976,
0.1086487323,
0.6967706084,
0.5434051156,
-0.2159073055,
0.6005699039,
0.2013501525,
0.115216665,
0.1130559221,
0.105243057,
0.679756999,
-0.630597353,
-0.2834533453,
-1.0014472008,
0.5052742362,
0.2159261853,
-0.4345727563,
0.7686598301,
0.7752221227,
1.5416940451,
0.1935698539,
0.7149313092,
0.1368913352,
0.2569323778,
-0.6790348887,
0.3830922544,
-0.8971375823,
0.5565611124,
-0.1721464545,
-0.7405448556,
-0.4350299537,
0.2054441273,
-0.2566100061,
-0.2314467877,
0.6586162448,
0.9073334932,
-0.206782937,
-0.53680861,
0.5988599062,
-0.1968403906,
0.1220698208,
0.4431217015,
0.9214981794,
-0.3018730283,
0.7744887471,
-0.5433090329,
-0.0065369443,
-0.3219060898,
-0.9024158716,
-0.6862446666,
-0.3834571242,
-0.4415825009,
-0.2155735046,
0.0750365555,
1.3259809017,
0.6007161736,
-0.6423476934,
-0.6804884076,
0.2842331529,
0.5639976263,
-0.0840757564,
-0.1868868023,
0.3246809244,
-0.5850263238,
-0.9496192336,
0.5639469028,
0.5732865334,
0.212841019,
-0.1480475515,
-0.428360194,
-0.3533828557,
-0.3217827678,
0.6258765459,
0.7003409266,
-0.9759931564,
0.0101769427,
0.0367508084,
-0.6878399849,
0.377800554,
0.7524946332,
-0.671122551,
0.4423745573,
0.6236789823,
0.8246213794,
0.4336596429,
-0.2009880841,
0.3322405517,
-0.9308645129,
0.2987659574,
0.1389988363,
0.474104017,
0.4984540045,
-0.375449717,
0.5739876628,
0.0153504247,
-0.4299982786,
-0.8590120077,
0.3686819673,
-0.6574050784,
-0.1680946201,
1.0535029173,
0.1131740734,
-0.2411992103,
0.0710270032,
-0.1929377466,
0.2298817486,
-0.3491805196,
0.4755207896,
0.6402937174,
-0.4887318909,
-0.2047800869,
-0.4905057847,
0.603905201,
0.4337929487,
-0.6272863746,
-0.2466312945,
0.2939073741,
0.0628089011,
0.0042265742,
0.6270281672,
-0.1306034178,
-0.0217939243,
-0.5598070621,
-0.0434751771,
0.4489017427,
-0.1278111488,
-0.4418940842,
-0.1023218706,
0.4936593175,
-0.0399475358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16504v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16504v1
|
LARA: Linguistic-Adaptive Retrieval-Augmented LLMs for Multi-Turn Intent Classification
| 2024-03-25T07:38:40 | 2024-03-25T07:38:40 |
Liu Junhua, Tan Yong Keat, Fu Bin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Following the significant achievements of large language models (LLMs),
researchers have employed in-context learning for text classification tasks.
However, these studies focused on monolingual, single-turn classification
tasks. In this paper, we introduce LARA (Linguistic-Adaptive
Retrieval-Augmented Language Models), designed to enhance accuracy in
multi-turn classification tasks across six languages, accommodating numerous
intents in chatbot interactions. Multi-turn intent classification is notably
challenging due to the complexity and evolving nature of conversational
contexts. LARA tackles these issues by combining a fine-tuned smaller model
with a retrieval-augmented mechanism, integrated within the architecture of
LLMs. This integration allows LARA to dynamically utilize past dialogues and
relevant intents, thereby improving the understanding of the context.
Furthermore, our adaptive retrieval techniques bolster the cross-lingual
capabilities of LLMs without extensive retraining and fine-tune. Comprehensive
experiments demonstrate that LARA achieves state-of-the-art performance on
multi-turn intent classification tasks, enhancing the average accuracy by 3.67%
compared to existing methods.
|
[
0.0344732553,
-0.937659204,
0.6081030965,
0.3742027581,
-0.2342296988,
0.4273213744,
-0.4144971073,
-0.3638337851,
0.5777025223,
0.799353838,
-0.533244431,
-0.5665470362,
-0.6498478651,
0.082362555,
-0.4331457019,
0.853336215,
0.0667596161,
0.0218417626,
0.027473202,
-0.329508543,
-0.6685349941,
-0.5314511061,
-0.7257267237,
-0.1024322435,
0.6702957749,
0.5810461044,
0.4611122012,
0.0418388397,
0.378816396,
0.3489484787,
0.1794836819,
0.7886069417,
-0.4914946854,
0.4582188427,
0.1126805544,
-0.5120462179,
-0.5994945765,
-0.1526443362,
0.692676425,
0.5212808847,
-0.3655537963,
0.0789625421,
0.0130887376,
0.5535498261,
-0.818173945,
0.4343112707,
-0.9051059484,
-0.2785471976,
-0.3916103244,
-0.5227299333,
-1.0455234051,
-0.2667668462,
0.2210277915,
-0.6768967509,
-0.1106494144,
0.2362792641,
0.2165246457,
0.0804503113,
-0.3433363438,
-0.5909081697,
-0.6250137687,
1.0644137859,
-0.4664263725,
0.516099453,
0.2705268562,
0.2710521221,
-0.122054629,
-0.8564656377,
-0.6187669635,
0.1544047743,
-0.0783461407,
-0.1086751148,
-0.03278042,
0.0765257105,
-0.0043413648,
0.0798070058,
-0.372595191,
0.0517071635,
-0.2578578889,
-0.1513082087,
0.6209326982,
0.2201509774,
0.6139066219,
-0.1162543967,
-0.4313735962,
0.0129951024,
-0.5803481936,
0.034559954,
-0.0074656741,
0.8628214598,
0.0281703789,
0.4771627784,
-0.2706187665,
0.7253096104,
0.0426965803,
-0.3481016755,
0.4053473771,
-0.2125697434,
-0.2434114069,
0.2340185344,
0.9676696658,
0.1691806167,
0.1372520775,
-0.098007217,
0.1336545199,
-0.2614678144,
0.2895305753,
-0.4448626637,
-0.0461518727,
0.0956071392,
-0.067456536,
-0.050865937,
-0.2116711438,
-0.6986933947,
-0.2729828954,
-0.0747849792,
0.4139935672,
-0.4142036736,
-0.2718952596,
0.4931719601,
0.2743108273,
0.3977377415,
0.5562974811,
-0.9268620014,
0.3354217708,
0.674831748,
0.9569308758,
-0.5940970778,
-0.7182251811,
-0.9771983624,
0.2723607123,
-0.2806446254,
0.7526234984,
-0.6947426796,
-0.1606466025,
0.3415620625,
-0.0883815438,
-0.2608188391,
-0.1580121815,
0.5933930278,
-0.9916908145,
0.4149935246,
-0.1406578869,
-0.2517640591,
-0.6601802707,
0.3573422432,
-0.5294369459,
1.0742148161,
-0.0256372299,
-0.5151066184,
0.3765647411,
-0.9164273739,
-0.6782598495,
0.3032023907,
0.2217267007,
-0.3084561527,
-0.110722445,
0.1722224951,
0.493414104,
-0.3356118798,
0.1870585382,
-0.2578949034,
-0.3219854832,
0.3297556341,
-0.651106596,
0.7204132676,
-0.1552796364,
0.0801996216,
0.6523111463,
-0.4943146408,
0.1806688756,
-0.2033046782,
-0.2874487936,
-0.5606512427,
0.0674877912,
0.1631527394,
0.1825113446,
0.2065599859,
-0.507948041,
0.2694578469,
-0.3613710701,
0.3418263495,
0.5023611784,
-0.0993930772,
0.6776742339,
-0.2231408507,
0.2906170487,
-0.1421636492,
0.3744935095,
-0.1622318774,
-0.7282518148,
-0.8240386844,
-0.560110867,
0.1883409768,
0.6301311851,
-0.9739800096,
0.1057337597,
-0.6444964409,
-0.2772633731,
-0.6522734165,
0.3430835307,
0.2694316506,
0.3136967123,
0.6426584125,
-0.3995851874,
-0.4001302719,
-0.4408414066,
-0.3522279263,
-0.3152368963,
0.1769787371,
0.3490158916,
0.0813132375,
-0.421443969,
0.8478805423,
-0.5120214224,
-0.3847731948,
-0.3920902908,
0.2180148065,
-0.0027008478,
0.071518369,
0.3270768225,
-1.1216136217,
-0.8056088686,
-0.0579199493,
-0.6883061528,
-0.000873763,
0.1404038072,
-0.2047947794,
0.2794454992,
0.2185037285,
-0.7178838253,
0.1142906174,
0.3154348731,
-0.0677980185,
0.2339174002,
-0.1813662946,
0.3227425218,
-0.7752113938,
-0.4685965776,
-0.2274282724,
-0.3062368333,
-0.8713109493,
-0.0765148625,
0.1042090058,
0.259513557,
-0.8298788667,
0.7579548359,
-0.4292011559,
0.0373113006,
-0.3849414289,
0.3049189448,
0.0174843688,
0.5661749244,
0.2742984593,
0.8028516769,
0.6025752425,
-0.9173385501,
0.3747173846,
0.3389277756,
-0.2178283036,
0.6852679253,
-0.1529149264,
0.4571331143,
0.003147014,
0.0504400097,
-1.0409101248,
-0.4434386194,
0.2478496581,
-0.4493975341,
0.2789461911,
-0.2279831767,
-0.3857187033,
0.1001331806,
-0.5386531949,
0.4630411267,
0.3573564887,
-0.862367928,
1.168503046,
0.6521315575,
-0.2217329592,
-0.7459309697,
-0.6605246663,
0.0088023748,
-0.3544376493,
-0.4652884901,
0.2931930423,
-0.1011437029,
-0.0100480607,
-0.4896849394,
0.1874808669,
-0.1589407474,
-0.1823564023,
0.0699666589,
0.2801834643,
0.0044701439,
0.2267779708,
0.1594179422,
-0.0785093531,
-0.1315276772,
-0.1601531059,
0.7925133109,
-0.0020655415,
-0.4097509086,
-0.234453395,
0.2755336463,
0.9410997629,
-0.331787914,
0.6856988072,
0.5592281818,
-0.2772865593,
-0.195831269,
-0.7069866061,
-0.0060958103,
-0.5002512336,
0.2888087034,
-0.5107077956,
-0.9821557999,
0.4585937262,
-0.1064712331,
0.1027010903,
0.2172044665,
0.6007906199,
-0.019883601,
0.9377353191,
0.6125597358,
-0.035346996,
0.7043306828,
0.0162936505,
0.1553097516,
-1.1350859404,
-0.3890701532,
-0.2915697694,
-0.1182687879,
-0.6653257608,
-0.6104896665,
0.3445994854,
-0.1913113445,
-0.2854937315,
0.2665944993,
-0.4879358113,
0.2786540091,
0.4762631953,
0.3704378903,
0.70656389,
-0.0307386257,
0.4588156343,
-0.0701681525,
-0.7186147571,
-0.3674899638,
1.0673927069,
0.0534798503,
0.9086908698,
0.4024118483,
0.4747642577,
0.3722418845,
0.6529089808,
-0.9093312025,
0.5297930837,
-0.069035612,
-0.481556803,
-0.3770349324,
-0.3860838413,
-0.846996665,
0.2787149251,
-0.2302581668,
-0.7136201262,
-0.0287136454,
-0.1001269743,
-0.193085283,
0.1591855586,
-0.7545558214,
0.712434411,
-0.5938655734,
-0.3288976848,
-0.1844752282,
-0.3802490234,
0.3124321401,
-0.0800630376,
0.3267679811,
-0.1301909834,
-0.2372596115,
0.7015795708,
0.1145220995,
0.9166322351,
-0.1273175776,
0.0322670676,
0.4306266606,
0.0846571401,
0.5056901574,
0.1863614768,
-0.0672617927,
-0.0382862464,
-0.2156210244,
-0.2695989311,
-0.7225722671,
0.8626964092,
-0.4555031359,
-0.3396086395,
-0.5479368567,
-0.5660448074,
-0.3316105902,
0.3769687116,
0.0227134936,
0.2906633914,
-0.1566076428,
0.0912360847,
0.7908378839,
-0.1577997357,
0.2730448842,
0.874140501,
-0.5950814486,
-0.2175297737,
0.8493896723,
0.010220916,
0.2592541873,
0.6113283038,
-0.0181816183,
-0.5601143241,
-0.6848214269,
-0.528336525,
0.1058499292,
-0.7490002513,
-0.4294210374,
-0.8700798154,
-0.0494310968,
-0.0829126164,
-0.0056630461,
-0.4200383723,
-0.1536769718,
-0.2100356966,
0.1022191197,
0.812399745,
0.6479175687,
0.4927982986,
0.5303573012,
-0.6498395205,
0.2571879923,
0.3495393395,
0.6085643768,
-0.2567410171,
-0.669030726,
0.1574627906,
0.0253702048,
0.0077695055,
-0.8569292426,
0.398717165,
0.344892472,
0.3918962777,
-0.1306288093,
0.1418958753,
0.5730511546,
-0.5964525938,
0.548109293,
0.1712584496,
-0.9162811637,
0.4728775024,
-0.1928462237,
0.2480443716,
0.7122056484,
0.388423562,
-0.5870087147,
-0.0399284698,
-0.2503393888,
-0.7858191729,
0.7661863565,
-0.1588272899,
0.413862288,
-0.0680082887,
0.5507996678,
0.1491145343,
0.1304291785,
-0.6933555007,
-0.1191466674,
0.2031232715,
-0.5463160872,
0.0513528474,
-0.2218998224,
0.1916794926,
-0.1727383733,
0.7081534266,
-0.496155262,
0.1037988663,
-0.0768891871,
-0.6029015779,
0.1349931061,
0.2383483797,
0.3764873445,
0.5424591899,
0.0054668137,
-0.0064561586,
0.6494521499,
-0.6426813602,
0.0128510399,
-0.0818729401,
-0.3450418413,
-0.0375212505,
0.2137154937,
0.8355915546,
0.5865405798,
-0.6507812142,
0.3578264117,
-0.364778161,
0.3084433973,
-0.3478818834,
0.2543132603,
-0.1430431902,
0.2386392504,
0.4620691836,
0.1007968187,
0.3871314526,
-0.6938346028,
0.0760218278,
0.5363574028,
-0.6576472521,
-0.207259953,
0.2475405186,
0.1806559414,
-0.8085021377,
0.6112502813,
-0.2772858441,
-0.66749084,
-0.205027625,
0.4351598322,
0.8500111103,
-0.3713343143,
0.1913651228,
0.2686879337,
0.1249124631,
-0.37779814,
0.4241971672,
0.0205737893,
-0.8929626346,
-0.6723846793,
-0.6509138942,
-0.6741256118,
-0.1661129445,
-0.4674414098,
0.4645007253,
-0.094478704,
-0.1359440088,
0.0263320245,
-0.1053951308,
-0.4435855746,
-0.1326611042,
-0.1811610311,
0.7211464047,
-0.6922463775,
0.8933035731,
0.6710878015,
-0.2350032777,
-0.3561944067,
-0.1343804449,
-0.1501788944,
-0.5723189712,
0.238207072,
0.059598729,
-0.728916049,
0.0838481262,
-0.4250043035,
-0.8270118833,
0.942556262,
0.3668299615,
-0.2697015405,
0.0256480575,
0.0109130321,
0.5794858336,
-0.6121510863,
0.3955117166,
0.4426858723,
0.3220164776,
0.0226816796,
-1.074703455,
-0.2199405134,
-0.0556095764,
-0.1601149887,
0.3451274931,
-0.7315667868,
0.5363484621,
-0.2001095563,
-0.1553595066,
-0.1557348371,
0.8542327881,
0.3621033728,
0.4464483857,
0.4752015769,
-0.0941358954,
0.9200730324,
-0.2249223292,
1.0195358992,
-0.1878813058,
0.3279791772,
1.1224147081,
-0.5056646466,
1.1491737366,
0.4454820752,
-0.1340644509,
0.7438889146,
0.331173718,
0.6581419706,
0.5941506028,
-0.2793511152,
-0.4600610137,
-0.2123171985,
-0.0040070983,
0.1878169477,
0.7610639334,
0.8299051523,
0.1196336672,
0.184819743,
0.4019914865,
-0.2163469046,
0.2204784751,
-0.3160864711,
0.9241983294,
-0.1543897837,
-0.7742209435,
0.2194531262,
-0.0153646329,
1.1329238415,
-0.6553265452,
-0.1025540456,
0.0881866515,
0.4507501721,
-0.1976413578,
-0.9764006138,
0.2736496627,
-0.1043241099,
-0.2925617397,
-0.1471185386,
1.0304914713,
-0.7035061121,
-0.4132242799,
0.6187593937,
0.5247983336,
-0.0176116899,
-0.1696382016,
-0.6833555102,
0.4148365259,
-0.2335914969,
-0.0358008184,
0.2542672157,
0.2831317782,
-0.196351707,
0.9504677653,
0.5309447646,
-0.1709873229,
0.2391431332,
0.1013420001,
0.5836727619,
-0.4410732388,
-0.3531866372,
-0.7944085002,
0.2562639117,
-0.0748471841,
-0.3071817458,
0.7825767398,
0.5814750791,
0.8274555206,
0.0619142279,
0.5530173182,
0.0755489767,
0.7358875871,
-0.6185946465,
0.3725008965,
-0.3174628317,
0.471265763,
-0.1475340873,
-0.754334867,
-0.4441129863,
0.6598050594,
-0.4277076125,
0.2872627974,
0.4162003398,
0.5202881098,
-0.3243776858,
0.1682118624,
0.0590129942,
-0.0181078874,
0.285071224,
0.5234946609,
0.7722254395,
-0.613307178,
0.4817068279,
-0.005933187,
-0.3056175113,
-0.3572052121,
-0.5838622451,
-0.8223801255,
-0.8318376541,
-0.2648569047,
-0.2496733665,
0.1010858715,
0.9950574636,
0.7950946093,
-0.788662076,
-0.3631434143,
0.3547595441,
0.4088079929,
-0.1605905145,
-0.2208906859,
0.3526704907,
-0.578481853,
-0.9240522981,
0.5244842172,
0.6546403766,
-0.3505585492,
-0.2646915019,
-0.2965761125,
-0.69052279,
0.0225203019,
1.0857493877,
0.2409270108,
-0.6717250943,
-0.4802024364,
0.462199688,
-0.1801140904,
0.287912637,
0.6634119153,
-0.6560823321,
0.5967725515,
0.4539847076,
0.6084503531,
0.8382688165,
-0.0636604354,
0.3544902205,
-0.7785938978,
0.0255318768,
0.270074904,
0.2458281964,
0.6205682755,
-0.3766346276,
0.4260814786,
-0.1255184114,
-0.3892894089,
-0.9113464355,
0.1757721305,
-1.2102931738,
-0.0342663117,
1.0822079182,
0.1253796518,
-0.3170826733,
-0.4368239939,
-0.3503561616,
0.2739353776,
-0.4104540944,
0.6762348413,
0.6658422351,
-0.3808128238,
-0.3340283632,
-0.6516788602,
0.5671476126,
0.2539588213,
-0.8002981544,
0.238769412,
0.1508800536,
0.280097127,
0.5171346664,
0.954931736,
-0.126058951,
0.4048621953,
-0.5387810469,
-0.0580304861,
0.2493595481,
-0.5908004642,
-0.1631201059,
0.1659160405,
0.268918395,
-0.0691821575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16483v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16483v1
|
Automatic Construction of a Large-Scale Corpus for Geoparsing Using Wikipedia Hyperlinks
| 2024-03-25T07:08:13 | 2024-03-25T07:08:13 |
Keyaki Ohno, Hirotaka Kameko, Keisuke Shirai, Taichi Nishimura, Shinsuke Mori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Geoparsing is the task of estimating the latitude and longitude (coordinates)
of location expressions in texts. Geoparsing must deal with the ambiguity of
the expressions that indicate multiple locations with the same notation. For
evaluating geoparsing systems, several corpora have been proposed in previous
work. However, these corpora are small-scale and suffer from the coverage of
location expressions on general domains. In this paper, we propose Wikipedia
Hyperlink-based Location Linking (WHLL), a novel method to construct a
large-scale corpus for geoparsing from Wikipedia articles. WHLL leverages
hyperlinks in Wikipedia to annotate multiple location expressions with
coordinates. With this method, we constructed the WHLL corpus, a new
large-scale corpus for geoparsing. The WHLL corpus consists of 1.3M articles,
each containing about 7.8 unique location expressions. 45.6% of location
expressions are ambiguous and refer to more than one location with the same
notation. In each article, location expressions of the article title and those
hyperlinks to other articles are assigned with coordinates. By utilizing
hyperlinks, we can accurately assign location expressions with coordinates even
with ambiguous location expressions in the texts. Experimental results show
that there remains room for improvement by disambiguating location expressions.
|
[
-0.7963037491,
-1.0747942924,
0.8751415014,
0.099680014,
-0.3347399533,
-0.1965326667,
-0.450858742,
-0.6217564344,
0.3843129873,
-0.2173956484,
-0.5084003806,
-0.8460187912,
-0.3373408318,
0.3310042024,
-0.4955861866,
0.9869844913,
-0.0026331022,
-0.2248872668,
-0.2998065054,
-0.1496779472,
-0.0280051529,
-0.5180451274,
-0.068459101,
0.3698984683,
0.8849522471,
0.3872276247,
1.0558056831,
0.7758495808,
0.6117560863,
0.3807154298,
-0.1438645571,
0.2989357114,
-0.2211598903,
0.0621921867,
-0.6845632195,
0.1452314109,
-0.0532144904,
-0.0992685556,
0.9799300432,
0.985732615,
-0.0393145084,
0.5799075365,
-0.0811028033,
0.3497377038,
-0.9623631239,
-0.0300815236,
-0.4255603254,
-0.0151621001,
-0.4016191661,
0.0536302924,
0.0333208144,
-0.6606311798,
0.2318840623,
-0.668415606,
0.4483321607,
0.3396700919,
0.8720598221,
0.0312860385,
0.0665784478,
-0.1762659997,
-0.6725856066,
0.5815171003,
-0.4544181228,
0.5937647223,
0.3673367202,
0.3288914859,
-0.1610993445,
-0.5108823776,
-0.8347395062,
0.0210192874,
-0.4419211745,
-0.3419497907,
0.0292730331,
-0.3263994455,
0.6444174647,
-0.0419127792,
-0.4617392123,
-0.0989421308,
-0.6242129207,
-0.2518747151,
0.3497561216,
-0.0304270647,
0.2043507546,
-0.681961298,
-0.38661924,
0.0162373167,
-0.5598415136,
-0.0028252129,
0.4122653306,
0.3875739276,
-0.1367543489,
0.7766721845,
-0.4900071919,
0.7408809662,
0.1211807057,
-0.2986390293,
0.2559152842,
0.1547891647,
-0.1909334362,
0.546120882,
0.9352185726,
0.387837559,
0.046702452,
-0.1932026297,
0.2458309531,
-0.383204788,
0.1835660338,
-0.4661657512,
-0.1047397107,
0.2773644924,
-0.3706434667,
-0.2020867467,
0.2660592794,
-0.8813849092,
-0.2751580477,
-0.1718760282,
0.0050887666,
-0.3204220533,
0.1540246606,
-0.219260186,
-0.1213659942,
-0.0270054583,
0.0642570779,
-0.9573093057,
-0.3728420734,
0.6783548594,
0.8245871663,
0.0169092212,
-0.8985215425,
-0.5496981144,
0.5721552968,
-0.175116837,
0.9924950004,
-0.4307640195,
-0.3564452529,
0.3585392833,
0.0473229289,
0.3861483932,
-0.2424495965,
0.7862668037,
-0.8465254903,
0.0950139761,
-0.4391300678,
-0.3221360445,
-0.0947087854,
0.3335826099,
-0.857327044,
1.2187865973,
0.1267111897,
-1.01828444,
0.0707854778,
-0.6584986448,
-0.5745031834,
0.1925630569,
0.3106241524,
-0.1241217181,
0.0583910793,
0.4037773311,
0.0756245777,
-0.1860805452,
0.5772487521,
-0.4753118157,
-0.3761351109,
0.2391364872,
-0.3079835474,
0.7132903337,
0.0612562448,
-0.3067223132,
-0.0677013919,
-0.5593778491,
0.1904955804,
-0.2502060533,
-0.3618366718,
-0.5294411778,
0.0557196215,
0.1308157891,
0.0699536651,
0.9594080448,
-0.6507282257,
-0.0748334005,
-0.3291010857,
-0.2150523812,
0.4686898589,
-0.1004280522,
0.5446252823,
0.2644088566,
0.1151853949,
-0.3272290826,
0.3943122327,
0.1358994991,
-0.497320503,
-0.4696135521,
0.0558024794,
0.1955807507,
0.3669182062,
-0.6480754018,
0.7821114063,
-0.6676174998,
-0.7961534858,
-0.3383289874,
0.0360279679,
0.1201240718,
1.0150797367,
0.814453721,
0.2873590291,
-0.5072056651,
-0.7652242184,
0.1311392188,
-0.3362743556,
-0.1474263668,
-0.0618149787,
0.3121749163,
0.0738936439,
1.1565964222,
-0.9488966465,
-0.0273504164,
0.2575625777,
0.0087346388,
-0.0583479665,
0.2070847601,
0.4726418853,
-0.9818032384,
-0.75757128,
-0.079081431,
-0.8802925944,
-0.1571424007,
0.4152390659,
-0.719401896,
-0.1015756428,
0.5554030538,
-0.8676501513,
0.2959718704,
0.4329786897,
-0.2834916115,
0.8458119631,
-0.435903877,
0.1159369126,
-0.8480923176,
0.3568040431,
-0.0716204494,
-0.2044039518,
-0.1164733991,
0.1851680726,
0.2074302584,
-0.3161703348,
-0.5966846943,
0.2490218729,
-0.2138176709,
-0.2505969405,
-0.1828849912,
0.5186842084,
-0.0582209565,
0.3301613331,
0.0837673396,
0.5155422688,
0.5157516003,
-0.3726474941,
0.8883001804,
0.3413697481,
-0.2603994608,
0.7137134075,
-0.2771661282,
-0.1550293416,
-0.231045723,
0.4138352573,
-0.8251022696,
-0.2631133795,
0.140019834,
-0.2707707584,
-0.15281187,
-0.2290896326,
-0.5498945713,
-0.5297316313,
-0.3236094415,
0.5007695556,
0.1333154142,
-0.8118822575,
0.2597810626,
0.4270979464,
-0.4316853881,
-0.7468129396,
-0.2521153092,
0.2274275124,
-0.3730013072,
-0.4044817388,
0.5263291001,
-0.1060086191,
-0.0071580922,
0.5396558046,
0.1918165684,
-0.2553776503,
-0.1460553259,
0.2981947958,
0.495939523,
-0.2001119703,
0.093942605,
-0.0196902826,
-0.2525609732,
0.1554356217,
-0.6235268712,
0.5250661373,
0.0961882025,
-0.4020015001,
-0.49116835,
0.7049748898,
0.6119514108,
-0.4836755395,
0.7304450274,
0.9074612856,
-0.3972252607,
0.1153898537,
-0.5450069904,
0.2963483036,
-0.4778361917,
0.1773988605,
-0.0821762905,
-0.7192018628,
0.3213476539,
-0.1399547011,
-0.2610728145,
0.7736359835,
0.4035959244,
-0.3922834396,
0.3821571171,
0.6069134474,
-0.5270411968,
0.2216886431,
0.1109695137,
0.5841360092,
-0.6333978176,
-0.2862045467,
-0.8022539616,
-0.5894682407,
-0.8580200672,
-0.4920917153,
0.446911186,
0.1940342784,
-0.386695236,
0.4150163829,
-0.3701663911,
0.7444767356,
0.8200574517,
0.0132102929,
0.1937198639,
0.4804917574,
-0.3486514986,
0.0523186401,
-0.3894744217,
-0.2716746032,
0.7796232104,
-0.1691616178,
0.5269951224,
0.3507963717,
0.4817041755,
0.3456241786,
0.2353224754,
-0.5945090055,
0.426222235,
-0.015812194,
-0.6387059689,
-0.7234269381,
-0.2496163547,
-0.7319672108,
0.000819099,
-0.3700041175,
-0.6592348814,
0.0106902532,
-0.1737041175,
-0.4773184359,
0.459833473,
-0.5482259393,
0.6785504818,
-0.0876630396,
-0.5763032436,
-0.0184885189,
-0.6870599389,
-0.1953908801,
-0.0342922062,
0.3350465894,
-0.1138747409,
0.1995817572,
0.3064550161,
-0.3693118691,
0.5272552967,
-0.4664371312,
-0.3188196719,
0.560023427,
-0.0428668372,
0.3184058964,
0.2815369368,
-0.0757986009,
0.553443253,
-0.2748150527,
-0.3593202531,
-0.5730538368,
1.1852340698,
-0.5467286706,
-0.3914674222,
-0.1734388173,
-0.6438346505,
-0.2126167566,
0.4731685221,
0.2448252589,
0.3644047379,
-0.1304856092,
-0.0918688476,
0.4307278693,
-0.3805046678,
0.6576281786,
0.3825801909,
0.0653806105,
-0.3924678862,
0.6696329713,
-0.0759716034,
-0.3165834248,
0.5358869433,
0.2064454854,
-0.8106896281,
-0.1756636351,
-0.5965563655,
0.1709882617,
-0.5418252945,
-0.4614472389,
-0.4340207875,
-0.0332238302,
-0.4044260085,
-0.5982547402,
-0.0963236243,
-0.3680847883,
0.2896674275,
-0.1308718771,
0.2152890563,
0.4904041886,
-0.2986704111,
0.0519348942,
-0.7576133013,
0.4713682532,
0.1414355636,
0.380266875,
0.0438342839,
0.1544751525,
-0.5892583132,
0.1619232744,
-0.1218956709,
-0.8175235391,
0.1575278193,
-0.2541482151,
0.240544796,
0.4218038321,
0.222644031,
0.9649344683,
-1.1315068007,
0.8649024367,
0.2819947898,
-0.7431368232,
0.5071336031,
-0.2814509273,
0.2764188051,
0.3606559336,
0.6556155682,
-0.5118456483,
-0.4081561267,
-0.4537903368,
-0.7442264557,
0.2020631284,
-0.0774338618,
0.1137717292,
-0.3165242374,
0.3890029788,
-0.2222944349,
-0.1470183879,
-0.4285161495,
-0.4308191538,
0.0469718315,
-0.2247614264,
-0.0959864184,
-0.4894064367,
-0.3036057353,
-0.3575731814,
0.4542152584,
0.0023516042,
0.0918820053,
0.5039686561,
-0.4081894457,
-0.1575912833,
0.1981856227,
0.3592320383,
0.851446867,
-0.1235838979,
0.4880693257,
0.4041289091,
-0.4453340173,
0.0746076927,
0.5422622561,
-0.4096899629,
0.4578902423,
0.206646353,
0.1128541604,
0.2969515026,
-0.5434792638,
0.4862011671,
0.4110568464,
0.4926738739,
-0.3636967838,
-0.2679277658,
0.3737107515,
0.3773185015,
0.4385409355,
-0.182947129,
0.2140686512,
-0.1784144342,
0.1200422421,
0.2321427613,
-0.1685889363,
-0.0662029013,
0.7201955914,
-0.0500771701,
-0.1186607704,
0.8211319447,
-0.447229594,
-0.6038690805,
0.3717142344,
0.5702525377,
0.5649498105,
-0.3528414369,
0.2894568443,
0.812481463,
0.1055117846,
0.2409969121,
-0.1093939692,
-0.1247058064,
-0.3665789962,
-0.4388382137,
-0.9932598472,
-0.2541012764,
-0.2634791732,
-0.6201843619,
0.4005291164,
-0.2243846804,
-0.1143812612,
0.1295074672,
-0.1716581285,
-0.6181396246,
0.2486571223,
0.3382719755,
0.8145439625,
-0.6653666496,
0.7303577065,
0.88996315,
-0.0414690711,
-0.4963566363,
0.2102860659,
-0.1270665973,
-0.2385835052,
0.6645470262,
-0.04918072,
-0.2672801614,
-0.1885887384,
-0.5367180109,
-1.0384620428,
1.0070185661,
0.1942202002,
-0.3462627232,
-0.2848382294,
0.5503559113,
0.5461698174,
0.029547967,
-0.0850724056,
0.0620139763,
0.4942144156,
-0.3430948853,
-1.0456800461,
0.2095618546,
0.2266574502,
-0.0999125615,
0.4122585952,
-0.3921125233,
0.6490744352,
-0.4137668312,
-0.0250215083,
0.1638155878,
0.678373456,
0.0033890782,
0.1796899736,
0.4630694985,
0.7576745152,
0.9435366392,
0.053992305,
0.897805512,
-0.5136939287,
0.9073960781,
1.2993450165,
-0.1001380384,
1.2082266808,
0.354018569,
-0.2136894315,
0.6999641657,
0.3465920687,
-0.2183209807,
0.6006502509,
-0.0391480848,
-0.6526169181,
0.0823834315,
-0.2563385069,
-0.4363254607,
0.530934453,
0.3684114218,
-0.2381724566,
-1.0655603409,
-0.0933761969,
0.1683881283,
-0.0464241356,
-0.2152915597,
0.3613067865,
-0.4048138857,
-0.52240026,
0.2527766228,
0.3476034105,
0.3094054461,
-0.7668859363,
0.0999332145,
-0.0801795721,
-0.2829945982,
-0.3296715021,
-0.8614985943,
0.4394524693,
0.4575361609,
-0.3878021836,
-0.02791504,
0.6831311584,
-0.5525271297,
-0.5584163666,
0.0494024307,
0.3116165102,
0.1158899739,
-0.1754346341,
-0.2278019339,
-0.2183869928,
-0.1401174664,
0.0092992419,
0.1741750836,
0.832259953,
-0.1609027088,
0.2237974256,
1.158995986,
0.1147756055,
-0.0055556521,
-0.3496427536,
0.7665436864,
-0.9829788208,
-0.7625855803,
-0.9407619834,
0.2015102655,
-0.3335453272,
-0.1638408005,
0.7677882314,
1.0618687868,
0.7493437529,
-0.1172505766,
0.7164806724,
-0.4605864286,
0.3391163051,
-0.1287129521,
0.7740812302,
-0.2298356742,
-0.2430394441,
-0.2845828235,
-1.2328317165,
-0.312048018,
0.6491581798,
-0.3490518928,
-0.5222181082,
0.8743658066,
0.5866088867,
-0.3064571023,
-0.1322822869,
0.259822011,
-0.116245985,
0.118517369,
0.3539764583,
0.7099303007,
-0.0168775953,
0.641492188,
-0.6995594501,
-0.0302259661,
-0.0620124601,
-1.0127077103,
-0.3094917834,
-0.6738214493,
-0.1233589649,
-0.3448432982,
-0.2726218104,
0.6693623662,
0.5293216109,
-0.572562933,
0.0985600054,
0.5058916807,
0.3825103939,
0.1293893009,
-0.2525581121,
1.0033304691,
-0.3783292174,
-1.0545518398,
0.3054161668,
0.3776404262,
-0.238181293,
-0.347098887,
0.2684785724,
-0.257309407,
-0.6258993149,
0.8213472366,
0.2387644649,
-0.4568246305,
-0.5190668106,
-0.1731895804,
-0.2820805013,
-0.1371502131,
0.6884648204,
-0.6662691832,
0.3849470913,
0.4087602794,
0.4920036495,
0.2229958177,
0.4524601698,
0.0160326529,
-0.7731084824,
0.2890497744,
-0.2956708074,
0.3383329809,
0.5082156658,
-0.5362513065,
0.1952554137,
0.2683597207,
-0.3895556629,
-0.2397293448,
-0.0012665689,
-0.8578686118,
-0.1460703164,
1.1576172113,
-0.2058337033,
-0.3240086436,
0.0074249855,
-0.1043328717,
0.2150959671,
-0.2117960006,
1.0218980312,
0.761458993,
0.15486072,
0.5663893223,
-0.59755826,
0.4141739607,
-0.0097823078,
-0.7115571499,
-0.0886376277,
0.9336264729,
0.4167276621,
0.8105014563,
0.1824989319,
-0.0603472516,
0.1134266332,
-0.066469118,
-0.0179868713,
0.0197947975,
-0.3163663447,
0.2513599396,
0.6181834936,
-0.1880683303,
-0.3011187017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16463v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16463v1
|
Few-shot Named Entity Recognition via Superposition Concept Discrimination
| 2024-03-25T06:45:09 | 2024-03-25T06:45:09 |
Jiawei Chen, Hongyu Lin, Xianpei Han, Yaojie Lu, Shanshan Jiang, Bin Dong, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Few-shot NER aims to identify entities of target types with only limited
number of illustrative instances. Unfortunately, few-shot NER is severely
challenged by the intrinsic precise generalization problem, i.e., it is hard to
accurately determine the desired target type due to the ambiguity stemming from
information deficiency. In this paper, we propose Superposition Concept
Discriminator (SuperCD), which resolves the above challenge via an active
learning paradigm. Specifically, a concept extractor is first introduced to
identify superposition concepts from illustrative instances, with each concept
corresponding to a possible generalization boundary. Then a superposition
instance retriever is applied to retrieve corresponding instances of these
superposition concepts from large-scale text corpus. Finally, annotators are
asked to annotate the retrieved instances and these annotated instances
together with original illustrative instances are used to learn FS-NER models.
To this end, we learn a universal concept extractor and superposition instance
retriever using a large-scale openly available knowledge bases. Experiments
show that SuperCD can effectively identify superposition concepts from
illustrative instances, retrieve superposition instances from large-scale
corpus, and significantly improve the few-shot NER performance with minimal
additional efforts.
|
[
-0.2846017182,
-0.9347268343,
0.5666351914,
-0.3740248978,
-0.153154999,
0.1412537396,
0.046756234,
-0.6425257921,
0.2577558756,
0.312440604,
-0.170937717,
-0.1133865938,
-0.6714906693,
0.2439620346,
-0.439515233,
0.9899417162,
0.0675488338,
-0.0874659866,
-0.0976250023,
0.1873420626,
-0.0738831013,
-0.2136393487,
-0.563024044,
-0.2926566899,
0.291893512,
0.4133386612,
0.3930660784,
0.4780793488,
0.6877279282,
0.3651695251,
-0.3991418481,
0.2914432883,
-0.3574302793,
0.08474534,
-0.2135572433,
-0.6590591073,
-0.0054716021,
-0.4130676687,
0.6789768338,
0.1027886271,
-0.0231268983,
-0.088584356,
-0.2587042451,
0.3870683014,
-1.1295661926,
0.2447649986,
-0.7937124968,
0.1761540473,
-0.3957099617,
0.0463385917,
-0.2792606354,
-0.0304364413,
0.4084455967,
-1.0709849596,
0.6272492409,
-0.2415676862,
1.096929431,
0.2702393532,
-0.2451934516,
-0.1795081496,
-0.9064260125,
0.6948430538,
-0.2356405556,
0.3663031161,
0.244851768,
0.6344454288,
-0.1292349994,
-0.5117214322,
-1.0819045305,
0.3097520471,
0.0149782477,
0.0688453466,
-0.4576162696,
-0.145918563,
0.4403378665,
0.2448696047,
-0.3279429078,
0.0403898507,
-0.3107036352,
-0.2896282673,
0.4992238283,
0.1010603905,
0.0789718553,
-0.3088616729,
-0.2687880695,
0.1633235216,
-0.5218752623,
-0.4092025757,
0.0168374553,
0.3202635944,
0.0752720013,
0.474142611,
-0.2549218535,
0.774153173,
0.5198494792,
-0.3920577466,
0.2318688333,
-0.1496846527,
-0.2072005272,
0.2184887677,
0.455634743,
-0.0779021233,
0.0787317827,
-0.0221837927,
-0.3441079557,
0.2199949473,
0.1785926074,
-0.7483121753,
-0.1990341693,
-0.0105511779,
-0.1382709742,
-0.0136098005,
0.0646716207,
-0.7392141819,
-0.5331340432,
-0.2283367962,
0.5663383007,
-0.6019534469,
-0.2805639207,
-0.1922805458,
-0.2170364112,
0.1919755191,
0.2908397019,
-0.8864060044,
0.1175131202,
0.6582446098,
0.8042922616,
-0.3075946271,
-0.0461677723,
-0.5083465576,
0.5891365409,
-0.1926045418,
1.2752109766,
-0.7584543824,
-0.2611777186,
-0.2860774994,
-0.1190397069,
0.0793147534,
-0.5936051607,
0.1150348559,
-0.799567461,
-0.2644659579,
0.1179802343,
-1.0134410858,
-0.2894752324,
0.3473013341,
-0.7996541262,
0.7778646946,
-0.0839524046,
-1.018056035,
0.7666960955,
-0.4605412185,
-0.3828206956,
0.5665684938,
-0.6191349626,
-0.5965047479,
0.2234381437,
0.065141812,
0.604229331,
-0.0832360312,
0.0161963087,
0.0585820861,
-0.4268460274,
0.1152044684,
-0.065275684,
0.3827163279,
0.0593383089,
-0.2989982367,
-0.0293898303,
-1.0995519161,
-0.2424601763,
0.2736732066,
-0.2555314898,
-0.7626386285,
-0.2068717629,
0.2075540572,
0.1933293492,
0.0155833261,
-0.7390880585,
0.2652607858,
-0.2606666982,
0.2703729272,
0.5782979131,
0.3749561608,
0.5931664109,
-0.0455841012,
0.5503151417,
0.2779465914,
-0.2437470555,
0.0440184511,
-0.2169445753,
-0.7141118646,
-0.7014678121,
0.4550643265,
0.5559969544,
-1.1090732813,
0.4598021805,
-0.222351566,
-0.5120238662,
-0.2090788037,
0.1601585001,
0.54686445,
0.2227210104,
0.6047590971,
-0.116796352,
-0.6625319719,
-0.7228901982,
0.1918151677,
-0.1280325204,
0.1383757442,
0.1985787451,
0.8017982244,
-0.1133623719,
1.22159338,
-0.8343473077,
-0.7920473218,
-0.5126207471,
0.2195547819,
0.1246174276,
0.4152458012,
0.1794655621,
-0.9849021435,
-0.388004303,
-0.1406064332,
-0.789260149,
0.3296774626,
-0.3091899157,
-0.0971730202,
0.0218055453,
0.6330855489,
-0.6303351521,
0.4620565176,
-0.0345693901,
0.1246920303,
0.5435358286,
-0.0710187405,
-0.4485886991,
-0.7739742398,
-0.1700141281,
0.1020794883,
0.1589560062,
-0.6026023626,
0.3370289803,
0.2368685007,
0.1903333664,
-0.8668999672,
0.5490122437,
-0.4888855517,
-0.0201848671,
-0.2919055521,
0.0275470447,
-0.1751369089,
0.0461919941,
0.4798550606,
0.6151506305,
0.7981849313,
-1.0647578239,
0.1527652591,
0.441613555,
-0.4863851964,
0.962942183,
-0.4963634908,
0.3689281642,
-0.4089136124,
0.5641140342,
-0.7208731174,
-0.2566799521,
0.0139862373,
-0.1541766375,
0.5081628561,
-0.3529582322,
-0.4905661643,
-0.2800389826,
0.099421598,
0.4032464027,
-0.2198734432,
-0.5660410523,
0.7107788324,
0.4605022371,
0.2588840127,
-0.5432063341,
-0.8112462163,
-0.2075643241,
0.0244395342,
-0.1756717265,
0.6281839013,
0.106839709,
0.1190577894,
-0.0498637557,
-0.3290294409,
-0.1683170646,
-0.1194558591,
0.3205984235,
0.1640714854,
-0.1852449179,
0.2529353499,
0.0199875589,
-0.5736428499,
-0.4951171875,
-0.1935062855,
0.2967166901,
0.1939883083,
-0.2918312848,
-0.6223476529,
0.2441755235,
0.1980817616,
-0.3077344298,
0.5453432202,
0.4804646373,
-0.7742025852,
-0.2841745317,
-0.6256736517,
-0.0802414045,
-0.4103103876,
0.2529554069,
-0.7379835248,
-0.9000983238,
0.248002395,
0.0072399741,
-0.1277770102,
0.3689566255,
0.2286775261,
0.3048119545,
0.9706084132,
0.5895244479,
-0.0876675099,
0.5727049708,
-0.8484859467,
0.0660669133,
-0.8165216446,
-0.0531846769,
-0.310054332,
-0.4281913042,
-0.3045901954,
-0.3597376049,
0.2502395213,
0.2769675255,
-0.0790095478,
0.5044332743,
-0.5234498382,
0.9890807867,
0.5726630092,
0.2075317949,
0.4022809565,
-0.0844537839,
-0.454816401,
-0.2059401721,
-0.3542273045,
-0.4705879986,
0.9976776242,
-0.0239135697,
0.6647027731,
0.2770446837,
1.2366669178,
-0.0111129321,
0.1782248914,
-1.1094062328,
0.7715131044,
-0.3796430826,
-1.0879358053,
-0.2427037507,
-0.3732681572,
-0.8819610476,
0.0962264463,
-0.5687640309,
-0.7000700831,
0.5089588165,
-0.1966311485,
-0.81867975,
0.1721797585,
-0.4760202467,
0.578533411,
0.0156103047,
-0.2899402082,
-0.1082324684,
-0.5091614723,
0.2912194729,
-0.1797419488,
0.059317708,
0.1102474779,
0.21318461,
0.7481396198,
-0.1414559186,
0.5834194422,
-0.3479787409,
0.0546257794,
0.2954277992,
0.2559221089,
0.4486366808,
-0.0074383896,
-0.1799267977,
0.0707084462,
-0.338291496,
-0.2356643081,
-0.5888981819,
0.4043501019,
-0.6926627755,
-0.4864443839,
-0.4278466105,
-0.2337886691,
0.185422346,
0.5440456867,
0.5214815736,
0.0906656608,
-0.410912931,
0.0233327411,
0.6552923322,
0.0179780386,
0.4580979645,
0.8360795975,
-0.0641597956,
-0.20958215,
1.2424287796,
0.342502892,
0.1530139744,
0.7694326043,
-0.0712976605,
-0.1331381649,
-0.6236331463,
-0.3377834857,
0.2708204389,
-0.5846346617,
-0.7231234908,
-0.8471159935,
-0.3388049603,
-0.1739268303,
-0.2824574113,
-0.3418149352,
-0.4600995481,
-0.5797042847,
-0.4717545509,
0.3090989888,
0.4921106398,
-0.1890854388,
0.5555887818,
-0.686891675,
0.9516625404,
0.7313902974,
-0.0685819387,
-0.092694588,
-0.4154956341,
-0.0140851904,
-0.2704176009,
-0.5778230429,
-0.6823841929,
0.1158680469,
0.5006364584,
0.6494911313,
0.9865726233,
0.0433075316,
0.7022255063,
-0.5168146491,
0.5006284118,
0.2619919181,
-1.0317403078,
0.7745477557,
0.1883093417,
0.1346047074,
0.6169989705,
0.5169149637,
-0.1268429011,
-0.3489614427,
-0.7420815825,
-0.7477752566,
0.8937745094,
0.1443494558,
-0.087119475,
-0.4586808681,
0.1362730861,
0.1826485991,
-0.318340838,
-0.449775368,
-0.374756664,
0.0243138429,
0.0517912284,
0.1193946004,
-0.0646912009,
0.0819024369,
-0.0138133913,
0.851129055,
-0.185642451,
0.3765262365,
0.1871867776,
-0.573076725,
-0.2432343364,
0.4641954303,
0.2193587422,
0.4144795835,
-0.1135808378,
0.5167456865,
0.0790771097,
-0.5191143155,
0.4408836067,
0.3440672159,
-0.6934336424,
0.1693269163,
0.2809141874,
0.5435604453,
0.295763582,
-0.3314682245,
0.6228401661,
0.1767674983,
-0.0433943309,
-0.0450635739,
0.45141083,
-0.045700036,
0.5391889811,
0.6801404357,
0.0034807655,
0.2355573475,
-0.3109641075,
0.509596169,
0.4064319134,
-0.5206904411,
-0.1878004223,
0.690430522,
0.1029705927,
-0.1441038847,
0.4921598136,
-0.6611074209,
-0.7029441595,
0.7669352889,
0.8878862262,
0.7286920547,
-0.4207772911,
0.4661307931,
0.3493440151,
-0.0805575922,
-0.3741937578,
0.3440066874,
-0.1420209259,
-1.2590088844,
-0.2331552356,
-0.5178809166,
-0.4242055714,
0.0645656809,
-0.5890401006,
0.5291808248,
-0.8358565569,
-0.2238902599,
0.6978251338,
0.0162768681,
-0.751206696,
0.1918761432,
0.3711003065,
0.6289721727,
-0.7520970106,
0.7935699224,
1.0290201902,
-0.7725518346,
-0.573415935,
0.0010110453,
0.3483914435,
-0.6193063259,
0.9129680395,
0.2841067612,
-0.1199387833,
0.3747937381,
-0.666203618,
-0.6706513166,
1.0509096384,
0.2365012169,
-0.6680183411,
0.0740062222,
-0.190335393,
0.4897210598,
-0.3521177471,
0.5133356452,
0.5492658615,
0.3893238902,
0.3275408745,
-0.6281349659,
0.0210948903,
0.0331111401,
-0.008458294,
0.3724575639,
-0.5480082631,
0.5749230981,
-0.549896419,
-0.4124801755,
-0.149283424,
0.9631953239,
0.6760649085,
0.4601065516,
0.6842619777,
0.7361865044,
0.6582054496,
0.1790075749,
0.5461815,
0.0985825285,
0.4731039405,
1.1147729158,
-0.4886728227,
0.9331228733,
0.3425920904,
-0.3221701682,
0.4588495195,
0.1088857278,
-0.0794922262,
0.7156716585,
0.2533278167,
-0.4351636469,
-0.4460388124,
-0.2141789198,
-0.3905308545,
0.7467902303,
0.7983939052,
-0.2611782253,
-0.2203255445,
-0.0474715754,
-0.2489290833,
-0.2884043157,
-0.2349245995,
1.1122744083,
-0.0389848985,
-0.0299756583,
0.5236786008,
-0.0262871366,
0.9762812853,
-0.4460372925,
-0.3127874434,
-0.1306058317,
0.3398432136,
-0.5023650527,
-0.4805769324,
0.0563488565,
0.0128812622,
-0.2536656559,
0.2427609712,
0.7940251231,
-0.2093261182,
-0.5740375519,
0.1518059373,
0.3686182797,
0.2264027297,
-0.2094327807,
-0.5387987494,
-0.3401318491,
-0.2785734534,
-0.0098656388,
0.1816762239,
0.7175560594,
-0.0473817699,
0.3873908818,
0.6541569233,
0.0400802903,
-0.0816881433,
0.0097995689,
0.8271934986,
-0.7778807282,
-0.6455441117,
-0.6260010004,
0.1732221842,
0.139902994,
-0.407414645,
0.4215321541,
0.7879973054,
0.9212377667,
-0.1162526309,
0.7832819223,
-0.2418362051,
0.6720621586,
-0.4309743941,
0.4821438789,
-0.3471153975,
0.2070781887,
-0.828643918,
-1.1577943563,
-0.7732207179,
1.055208683,
-0.2896592319,
-0.4495570362,
0.5679739118,
0.784799993,
-0.4111331403,
0.1173422337,
0.2729068995,
0.3579702377,
0.2602713406,
0.6213648915,
1.0574471951,
-0.3764068484,
0.7313859463,
-0.3115246296,
-0.1618397981,
-0.3713365495,
-0.735984385,
-0.4895653129,
-0.2477197647,
-0.7805266976,
0.0051942589,
0.066504471,
0.8073512912,
0.7922406793,
-1.1855125427,
0.2856644988,
-0.4489872754,
0.5191792846,
-0.423576951,
-0.3233225346,
0.3987937272,
0.1438752562,
-0.6728016138,
0.4730960727,
0.3279856741,
0.0678355917,
0.0470257178,
0.0693769753,
-0.5294566751,
-0.2131707668,
0.4030281901,
0.4180296063,
-0.5555251241,
-0.4484425485,
-0.1614611298,
-0.0169981308,
-0.1060419008,
0.8488202691,
-0.9653944373,
0.5751597285,
0.5100434422,
0.7548324466,
0.6505778432,
-0.1771671176,
-0.0982329845,
-0.7981818318,
-0.0176577345,
0.0736958683,
0.2951471508,
0.1621634364,
-0.3617421985,
0.498057276,
0.5102589726,
-0.1892727762,
-0.5188059211,
0.2534782588,
-0.8581110239,
-0.2041583061,
1.1355493069,
-0.2958259881,
0.1080937609,
-0.5749883056,
-0.2359247059,
0.3691984713,
-0.6117099524,
0.7135818005,
0.5275823474,
-0.3512430489,
-0.1733944118,
-0.024210684,
0.0508996025,
0.1513574719,
-0.7337573767,
-0.1815277487,
0.6231923103,
0.1427683681,
0.7028211951,
0.5188210011,
0.1620912552,
0.2616099715,
-0.0612898096,
0.1353341043,
0.0620282926,
-0.5897156,
-0.2019385695,
0.1399463266,
-0.4254186153,
-0.3278294504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16447v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16447v1
|
A Study on How Attention Scores in the BERT Model are Aware of Lexical Categories in Syntactic and Semantic Tasks on the GLUE Benchmark
| 2024-03-25T06:18:18 | 2024-03-25T06:18:18 |
Dongjun Jang, Sungjoo Byun, Hyopil Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study examines whether the attention scores between tokens in the BERT
model significantly vary based on lexical categories during the fine-tuning
process for downstream tasks. Drawing inspiration from the notion that in human
language processing, syntactic and semantic information is parsed differently,
we categorize tokens in sentences according to their lexical categories and
focus on changes in attention scores among these categories. Our hypothesis
posits that in downstream tasks that prioritize semantic information, attention
scores centered on content words are enhanced, while in cases emphasizing
syntactic information, attention scores centered on function words are
intensified. Through experimentation conducted on six tasks from the GLUE
benchmark dataset, we substantiate our hypothesis regarding the fine-tuning
process. Furthermore, our additional investigations reveal the presence of BERT
layers that consistently assign more bias to specific lexical categories,
irrespective of the task, highlighting the existence of task-agnostic lexical
category preferences.
|
[
-0.4405712783,
-0.9312103391,
0.4892818332,
0.2313354164,
-0.0545305572,
-0.2118019611,
-0.4835623205,
-0.6019644141,
0.2880415916,
0.1445722431,
-0.607648313,
-0.3009275496,
-0.8385518193,
-0.0648085102,
-0.2493125945,
1.2835222483,
0.1490943879,
-0.1556393057,
-0.2588685453,
0.0174299832,
-0.5775031447,
-0.4529896677,
-0.3596683145,
-0.0519912578,
0.9923647046,
0.2114933133,
0.9074123502,
0.8445743322,
0.9355026484,
0.2042915821,
-0.2567196786,
-0.1909244657,
-0.4221802056,
0.0728559271,
-0.6621285081,
-0.7737404704,
-0.2205850333,
0.0561887324,
0.5896728635,
0.9130722284,
0.1497133076,
0.7115343213,
0.3446983695,
0.727353096,
-0.8222140074,
0.3215308785,
-0.9947779179,
-0.3317862749,
-0.2500506043,
-0.1321963966,
-0.4476439357,
0.0695479959,
0.4956991673,
-0.4003917277,
0.7173087001,
0.0885209292,
1.0613516569,
0.6654407978,
-0.1336242855,
-0.1321368665,
-0.4176388979,
0.933752358,
-0.390842855,
0.2995996773,
0.3120979667,
-0.2545492649,
-0.057792969,
-0.5510066152,
-0.0389905944,
-0.0715036914,
0.0658335984,
-0.0068568671,
-0.0959494561,
0.1674484015,
0.2835741341,
0.2549980283,
-0.3769079745,
-0.1269070208,
-0.2467575967,
-0.312297523,
0.3422065675,
0.099573575,
0.1994130462,
-0.001336489,
-0.5832992792,
-0.2161711305,
-0.2954912484,
0.3872658014,
0.1815965623,
0.6161396503,
0.1992709637,
0.6417715549,
-0.2321178615,
0.9744164944,
0.3085580468,
0.183366105,
0.1019806936,
-0.3726676404,
-0.4679497778,
0.4017706215,
0.1860454232,
0.3507282734,
0.3148192465,
-0.281273663,
-0.0597127974,
0.5080388784,
0.746737361,
-0.2317280471,
-0.3172662854,
0.152843684,
-0.4533143342,
0.0702494085,
-0.1229124367,
-0.1033789665,
-0.1806211919,
-0.6553742886,
0.6846684217,
-0.4318540394,
0.1307649314,
0.0914935842,
-0.2717045248,
0.1887889802,
0.4046064913,
-1.1474000216,
0.3327823579,
0.8943282962,
0.5125335455,
-0.2900049388,
-0.2827277184,
-0.5098350048,
0.1917115897,
-0.331899792,
1.1299089193,
-0.753580749,
0.3199675083,
-0.2293832749,
0.1312488168,
-0.5945323706,
-0.5770168304,
0.4233889282,
-0.3974208832,
-0.1564765871,
-0.682331264,
-0.8057559133,
-0.2728178799,
0.0553089269,
-0.4984614849,
1.0906298161,
0.1075101495,
-0.8660883904,
0.8811875582,
-0.2847759724,
-0.4233821332,
-0.110961467,
0.116390653,
0.1577635556,
0.5188781619,
0.0026504672,
0.5278957486,
-0.0980020091,
0.183625102,
-0.3980486095,
-0.3602456152,
0.2036542147,
0.1340263635,
0.3543465734,
0.0015486982,
-0.3887369335,
0.2694277167,
-0.4201461673,
0.1318796128,
-0.3018445671,
-0.4414161146,
-0.5235632062,
0.2136885673,
-0.0555764921,
0.3121147752,
0.5391330719,
-0.7278687954,
0.1893668026,
-0.4627901912,
0.1917087734,
0.8704695702,
0.0371749252,
0.3117343783,
-0.4410336018,
-0.0773744956,
0.103689529,
0.1146713421,
0.0684853643,
-0.7894188762,
-1.0925393105,
-0.1491065919,
0.5102381706,
0.2262988538,
-0.0607070737,
0.4937425852,
-0.0512761548,
-0.3400224149,
-0.9572250247,
0.1980869025,
0.3864184916,
0.3822453618,
0.220985204,
-0.6227781773,
-0.1186572686,
-1.3064908981,
-0.4710372388,
-0.0447170436,
0.0659955591,
0.4347311258,
0.2208983898,
0.2196114659,
1.0833786726,
-0.6705821753,
-0.6861271262,
-0.1117989942,
0.2888218462,
0.258823812,
0.2640743852,
0.5496017933,
-0.6272748113,
-0.4888199568,
-0.1976154149,
-0.0204672497,
-0.0625244975,
-0.1698571891,
-0.3714311421,
0.3865525723,
0.479878217,
-0.4340580106,
0.3085327148,
0.2846204937,
-0.643815279,
0.2823889256,
-0.1754766256,
-0.2093128115,
-0.6295133233,
0.1716495156,
-0.0307527408,
0.0395413376,
-0.4479823112,
0.1722731143,
0.0568467639,
0.3301193118,
-0.4093443155,
0.3473460078,
-0.2337789685,
-0.4181075096,
-0.1314595938,
0.1705398709,
-0.0314580873,
1.0006774664,
0.1130605116,
0.5806645155,
0.5646243691,
-0.6205056906,
-0.0149330292,
0.0900266841,
-0.6227597594,
-0.0430275872,
-0.6808215976,
0.0495042279,
-0.2728894055,
-0.3243166804,
-1.594528079,
-0.2183095515,
-0.2400053591,
-0.4247866869,
0.3728042841,
0.3335628211,
-0.9970257282,
-0.065948993,
-0.2327154875,
0.0553440265,
0.3593317866,
-0.101599358,
0.1958584487,
0.4774152339,
-0.1981323361,
-0.3078739941,
-0.6017275453,
-0.3990328014,
-0.0147588542,
-0.5197256804,
0.4229667187,
-0.0466184132,
-0.0972402394,
0.1399016529,
-0.4556479752,
-0.1632646173,
0.2135182917,
0.2113824636,
0.0492391773,
-0.0524104536,
0.5338813066,
-0.0751819462,
0.2114372253,
0.2329847962,
-0.123950392,
0.5177477002,
-0.0456552207,
-0.0470153652,
-0.0597074777,
0.052895654,
0.4025248587,
-0.240050599,
0.8029147387,
0.7854603529,
-0.1361416727,
-0.0788612515,
-0.7090944052,
-0.2445345074,
-0.3973635733,
0.2465881556,
-0.2087441534,
-0.9537895918,
0.648694694,
0.3021250367,
0.0820459425,
0.5949910879,
0.8611797094,
-0.305501312,
1.0623124838,
0.6574827433,
-0.1475024819,
0.5253641009,
0.1522379667,
0.0359220915,
-1.0777519941,
0.1892888695,
-0.5639115572,
-0.8354187012,
-0.6674514413,
-0.2516717315,
0.2774150968,
0.0604498014,
-0.199027881,
0.4901292026,
-0.8230545521,
0.3630918264,
0.73308599,
0.3226181567,
-0.0822403207,
-0.1535167247,
-0.2601124048,
-0.178959012,
-0.7159137726,
-0.1517525911,
0.8300255537,
0.3911915123,
0.6535449028,
-0.0025731763,
0.4312055409,
0.2783179581,
0.0077154613,
-0.7951289415,
0.5155114532,
-0.399674207,
-1.0976302624,
-0.2904061675,
0.3248353302,
-1.0302352905,
0.0904888809,
0.096845001,
-1.2830955982,
0.3136838973,
0.0478640944,
-0.3892002404,
-0.18807818,
-1.1393364668,
1.0463223457,
0.2016229331,
-0.586446166,
-0.5080704093,
-0.9173548222,
-0.0357684977,
-0.1493800879,
-0.1805648804,
-0.7243522406,
-0.1057973132,
0.7595074177,
0.0083596557,
1.1343516111,
0.011965503,
-0.179923743,
0.3398098052,
0.0235844851,
0.2432654649,
-0.2476558089,
0.0595560037,
-0.0100596305,
-0.074260354,
-0.4041691124,
-0.3893502355,
0.6738014221,
-0.6487036347,
-0.8838093281,
-0.2074627578,
-0.9408831,
-0.4106962681,
0.171831429,
0.1520724595,
0.3517324328,
0.4316595197,
0.2915348411,
0.7334108353,
-0.0093221329,
0.3924899399,
0.382802397,
0.3548982143,
0.3896225095,
0.7331232429,
0.2338111401,
0.5156069994,
0.6528130174,
-0.0047137747,
-0.174945116,
-0.0698029846,
0.1450100988,
0.2260698527,
-0.7374194264,
-0.0652688444,
-0.5407043695,
-0.0712036118,
-0.3107674122,
-0.1689121425,
-0.3416324556,
-0.4741559327,
-0.3481782377,
0.282409817,
0.3424336314,
0.4237637222,
0.374196887,
-0.146185711,
-0.7154148221,
0.2186812907,
0.2757667601,
0.6322593689,
0.1766050607,
-0.4702381194,
-0.3736511469,
-0.1755299568,
-0.2855907083,
-0.30913499,
0.0003698712,
0.4057947695,
0.6443263292,
0.2777059376,
0.068773523,
0.6137176156,
-0.4649312794,
0.8904002309,
-0.1392942518,
-0.9740619659,
0.7317418456,
-0.6380892992,
0.9140079021,
0.6004313231,
0.2203380018,
-0.1013708413,
-1.0135666132,
-0.6787785292,
-0.6842529774,
1.072951436,
0.2137369066,
0.0549291186,
-0.3193768859,
0.0600682348,
0.1160608977,
0.3060656786,
-0.5685608983,
-0.0730927587,
0.3783496916,
-0.0935523733,
-0.024111975,
-0.2984028161,
-0.0059129694,
-0.2995711267,
0.2459857762,
-0.0305812974,
0.607195437,
0.42087695,
-0.1243739426,
-0.1624597758,
0.2774615884,
0.5603229403,
0.5815333128,
-0.5847420692,
0.0111016743,
-0.0351371169,
-0.5442750454,
-0.3022457659,
-0.1515135765,
0.2398213297,
0.0112643167,
0.6871176958,
0.9476335049,
0.6969109178,
-0.6087018847,
0.2885871232,
0.2714334726,
-0.2365772277,
0.253151238,
0.608982563,
0.0544220805,
0.272056222,
0.0987261236,
0.1748512387,
0.3217782974,
-0.7200036645,
0.1804839969,
0.3785678148,
-0.6067863703,
-0.2459965497,
0.6406169534,
-0.0606798604,
0.2052318752,
0.3342966735,
0.0802648887,
-0.3073586226,
0.8211116791,
0.478348434,
0.8102127314,
-0.1752895862,
-0.1815570742,
0.2756862342,
0.2507058084,
0.2677482665,
0.3423529565,
-0.3791596889,
-0.7381555438,
-0.499399513,
-0.87974298,
-0.1437209398,
-0.1828472167,
-0.9391816258,
0.2117860764,
-0.2825532556,
-0.5817838311,
0.6734466553,
-0.173939243,
-0.7272764444,
0.4341069162,
0.3970950246,
0.9041208029,
-0.478687644,
0.8294267654,
1.0624067783,
0.0106096119,
-0.8644521832,
0.2620341778,
-0.2889918983,
-0.8219095469,
1.0524322987,
0.2378228307,
0.1927257925,
0.0544869937,
-0.1907786876,
-1.4497696161,
0.581286788,
0.3301175237,
-0.3558155894,
-0.2984332442,
0.0750716925,
0.8178290129,
-0.1985028535,
-0.0146829644,
0.6053361297,
0.2895050943,
-0.1704650372,
-1.2191252708,
-0.1072458029,
-0.0945996717,
0.1612876952,
0.5481875539,
-0.8108261824,
0.8950656056,
-0.2018568069,
-0.2320601791,
-0.2706913054,
0.1504452676,
-0.1492087394,
-0.1538083553,
0.5480573177,
0.501809299,
0.2341425717,
-0.2833425105,
1.0985246897,
-0.4385798872,
0.495012641,
1.092856884,
-0.3008686304,
0.8550375104,
0.5900530219,
-0.2647862732,
0.5001926422,
0.6889517307,
-0.1845082194,
0.9450531602,
0.1787546128,
0.155395627,
-0.3727721572,
-0.555297792,
0.0653432757,
0.6506706476,
0.4940722585,
-0.4457730353,
-0.3473566175,
0.047773771,
-0.3153410554,
-0.1921376437,
-0.6331896782,
1.0692807436,
-0.2346608937,
-1.0713781118,
0.6424654722,
-0.2760653198,
0.1456935704,
-0.5644560456,
0.1846924275,
0.3005831838,
0.4863239527,
-0.091090627,
-1.1549406052,
0.3163910508,
-0.3115157485,
-0.5514691472,
-0.0613768548,
0.8700082302,
-0.3945743442,
-0.1997804344,
0.3493250608,
0.0352942832,
-0.0518134609,
-0.020844968,
-0.6152977347,
0.1515968293,
0.029780563,
-0.4297769964,
0.5148630738,
0.2438750714,
-0.0575647466,
0.5102758408,
0.4336297512,
-0.0487513952,
0.2792808712,
0.1500886381,
0.8028621674,
-0.4975775778,
-0.6895855665,
-0.6869766116,
0.4712296426,
0.1547145098,
-0.5541937351,
0.7691907883,
0.3080785871,
0.8799012899,
-0.4511962235,
0.3237002492,
-0.0403096564,
0.7358728647,
-0.4267681539,
0.459220171,
-0.6682777405,
-0.2291393131,
-0.5688871145,
-1.1803997755,
-0.2007307261,
0.4048551321,
-0.3457925618,
-0.2225304097,
0.8690004945,
0.3931782842,
0.1156057119,
-0.1403888613,
0.1491673887,
0.0407509096,
-0.2287779003,
0.7550732493,
0.3434052765,
-0.1535930932,
0.1027139425,
-0.1727636307,
0.0194168855,
-0.4642183185,
-0.654139936,
-0.9602891207,
-0.7777285576,
-0.3931483328,
0.107033737,
0.0551506504,
0.7977725863,
0.6035498977,
-0.8620568514,
-0.0100756139,
-0.1689916998,
-0.063824445,
-0.3908177316,
-0.342199862,
0.4691809118,
-1.2492659092,
-0.7787980437,
-0.2319819331,
0.5519305468,
-0.3476115465,
0.1374210864,
0.6631223559,
-0.5544428229,
0.1898225397,
0.5595118999,
-0.2656319141,
-1.0794519186,
-0.5630450845,
0.2221173048,
-0.4072009027,
0.1146140322,
0.6815893054,
-0.7729905248,
0.6815438271,
0.5148984194,
0.546628952,
0.2226214558,
0.0207883138,
0.5157187581,
-1.0704308748,
0.2344540358,
0.0601522177,
0.2336816788,
-0.1078420207,
-0.5972050428,
0.524810195,
-0.0412247367,
-0.6248955131,
-0.6305302978,
-0.0111441314,
-1.2074606419,
-0.3516944349,
0.9948297739,
-0.0297075175,
-0.3423877358,
-0.0042802747,
-0.238520503,
0.2197850645,
-0.4281108975,
0.9006184936,
1.3641762733,
-0.4318106472,
0.132945925,
-0.3839013875,
0.6887485981,
0.9035798907,
-0.4192828536,
0.3552263975,
0.1448318809,
0.1185679585,
0.5542441607,
0.2039687037,
0.1733033359,
0.4691281915,
-0.291174382,
-0.0774548799,
0.5505191088,
-0.3768023252,
-0.0188948754,
0.0631500408,
0.2152475268,
-0.2017873973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16446v1
|
Towards Automatic Evaluation for LLMs' Clinical Capabilities: Metric, Data, and Algorithm
| 2024-03-25T06:17:54 | 2024-03-25T06:17:54 |
Lei Liu, Xiaoyan Yang, Fangzhou Li, Chenfei Chi, Yue Shen, Shiwei Lyu Ming Zhang, Xiaowei Ma, Xiangguo Lyu, Liya Ma, Zhiqiang Zhang, Wei Xue, Yiran Huang, Jinjie Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are gaining increasing interests to improve
clinical efficiency for medical diagnosis, owing to their unprecedented
performance in modelling natural language. Ensuring the safe and reliable
clinical applications, the evaluation of LLMs indeed becomes critical for
better mitigating the potential risks, e.g., hallucinations. However, current
evaluation methods heavily rely on labor-intensive human participation to
achieve human-preferred judgements. To overcome this challenge, we propose an
automatic evaluation paradigm tailored to assess the LLMs' capabilities in
delivering clinical services, e.g., disease diagnosis and treatment. The
evaluation paradigm contains three basic elements: metric, data, and algorithm.
Specifically, inspired by professional clinical practice pathways, we formulate
a LLM-specific clinical pathway (LCP) to define the clinical capabilities that
a doctor agent should possess. Then, Standardized Patients (SPs) from the
medical education are introduced as the guideline for collecting medical data
for evaluation, which can well ensure the completeness of the evaluation
procedure. Leveraging these steps, we develop a multi-agent framework to
simulate the interactive environment between SPs and a doctor agent, which is
equipped with a Retrieval-Augmented Evaluation (RAE) to determine whether the
behaviors of a doctor agent are in accordance with LCP. The above paradigm can
be extended to any similar clinical scenarios to automatically evaluate the
LLMs' medical capabilities. Applying such paradigm, we construct an evaluation
benchmark in the field of urology, including a LCP, a SPs dataset, and an
automated RAE. Extensive experiments are conducted to demonstrate the
effectiveness of the proposed approach, providing more insights for LLMs' safe
and reliable deployments in clinical practice.
|
[
-0.1383901387,
-0.628230691,
1.033944726,
0.163137421,
-0.2149261087,
0.0952756256,
-0.4724285007,
-0.5077587366,
0.1858038306,
0.5199613571,
-0.4271275103,
-0.6492307186,
-0.7430550456,
0.4838865399,
-0.1843144298,
0.6726881862,
-0.0629725009,
0.5398137569,
-0.4951499104,
-0.2138237357,
-0.6899343133,
-0.1439070255,
-0.6791335344,
-0.5014260411,
0.1993048787,
0.1515384465,
0.8399702311,
0.648516655,
0.8555980921,
0.4001105428,
0.3918630779,
0.4014539123,
-0.1143752635,
0.3508924246,
-0.1821410507,
-0.1805433631,
-0.7319785357,
-0.0545075797,
0.683618784,
0.866807878,
-0.184799239,
0.0277494751,
-0.0048218807,
0.5710654259,
-0.3733940423,
0.1273560375,
-0.3444671333,
0.1639490575,
0.1967797428,
-0.4849692583,
-0.290590167,
-0.473664403,
0.1314007491,
-0.390437752,
0.103727214,
-0.090383783,
0.5562141538,
0.3292386234,
-0.3424693942,
-0.4201782644,
-0.6002357602,
0.5036500692,
-0.4014210999,
0.4890681803,
0.2747010589,
0.777123332,
-0.2292376012,
-0.6417430639,
-0.1877722889,
-0.8400526047,
-0.2705825567,
-0.0433999263,
0.0299925469,
0.2719079554,
0.0477725491,
0.2316488475,
-0.6148394942,
0.221686095,
-0.1510425657,
-0.2069417685,
0.9250243902,
0.6516355872,
0.3561649024,
-0.225826174,
-0.2946953773,
0.1360319406,
-0.4313783348,
-0.4036118686,
-0.196482867,
0.2225459665,
0.0448531248,
0.5832080841,
-0.1625588983,
0.5619648695,
-0.123174794,
-0.3137633801,
0.3160966337,
-0.3919609785,
-0.0844273865,
-0.142126292,
1.0000721216,
0.4438468814,
0.0827701092,
-0.4984879494,
-0.3486450613,
0.2355839163,
0.6208703518,
-0.5798413157,
0.0960041136,
0.5319557786,
-0.5309955478,
-0.3498343825,
-0.2438477427,
-0.7578932047,
-0.6990345716,
-0.5090740919,
0.5724622011,
-0.5655050278,
-0.055002328,
0.3456760943,
0.2989230752,
-0.0656149685,
0.4470287263,
-0.4744116962,
0.7767452598,
0.6688705683,
0.7033594251,
-0.4923476279,
-0.2181373537,
-0.6726296544,
-0.0053863195,
-0.1850147694,
0.7360719442,
-0.6141824722,
-0.4260634482,
-0.048244603,
0.0654814988,
-0.2650636137,
-0.7862625718,
0.4434875846,
-0.1877990663,
-0.1445590556,
0.0143966172,
-0.690048635,
0.0629843995,
0.3306291699,
-0.5294274092,
0.6307468414,
0.338411957,
-0.2853564024,
0.5568729043,
-0.991412282,
-0.3304362595,
0.382830143,
-0.3798831403,
-0.3973164856,
-0.1719461232,
0.2461075634,
0.5277234316,
-0.6069303155,
0.3826918304,
-0.1591165364,
-0.4247960448,
0.2160094529,
-0.1758863926,
0.6871520281,
0.107965976,
-0.3558697999,
0.3056400418,
-0.6911054254,
0.105938904,
0.026031306,
-0.1325891465,
-0.0067146677,
0.0352536589,
-0.2561638355,
0.0564557761,
0.1793698221,
-0.3313044906,
0.2165797353,
-0.3978042305,
0.0624879934,
0.5785024166,
0.1860875487,
0.2690747678,
-0.5616570115,
0.9079759121,
-0.3508122563,
0.5874310732,
0.1988066286,
-0.4016389251,
-0.4532374144,
-0.5525758862,
0.1250372827,
0.5886873007,
-0.5509411097,
0.8303266168,
-0.4113723636,
-0.5570496321,
-0.7269064188,
0.3030596077,
0.4311495423,
0.3758656085,
0.3096519411,
-0.4800630212,
-0.3767114282,
-0.7555134892,
-0.0663428754,
-0.3157423437,
-0.1182306111,
0.5605970025,
0.4725373685,
-0.7283814549,
0.682168901,
-0.2806478441,
-0.6196538806,
-0.3917485476,
-0.1864111573,
0.2205161899,
0.2905124128,
0.2629028261,
-0.3795056343,
-0.1942140758,
0.0020886832,
-1.0698815584,
-0.4427346885,
-0.1114755422,
-0.1053690389,
-0.0314406976,
0.255931586,
-0.4148727357,
0.474385798,
0.2198928446,
-0.3652011454,
0.6398057938,
-0.6123586297,
0.2678147256,
-0.5177496076,
0.1017202809,
-0.0546084195,
-0.3431940973,
-0.3867284656,
0.2571264505,
-0.0610394739,
0.0413518585,
-0.138006717,
0.7358774543,
-0.3490305841,
-0.3014672697,
-0.1065822318,
0.36409235,
0.0286604241,
0.0470026582,
0.0742355213,
0.4946146607,
0.6530758142,
-0.6015817523,
0.6130288839,
0.0630920082,
-0.2322205454,
0.788778007,
-0.5718764663,
0.072949715,
0.0547245517,
0.2048684806,
-0.6020619869,
-0.0250492021,
0.3286615014,
-0.3349114358,
0.0956161916,
-0.086004205,
-0.7559748292,
-0.3478822112,
-0.1824112833,
0.306663692,
0.3701770306,
-0.1047704592,
0.6770704389,
0.3096662164,
-0.028256027,
-0.3259083331,
-0.1206779256,
0.3387098312,
-0.1102081016,
-0.5888111591,
0.1909476966,
-0.0654785857,
-0.3089128733,
-0.1396090686,
0.2077951878,
0.1423844695,
0.2589826882,
0.4053208232,
0.5114594698,
-0.0624922812,
0.2514238656,
0.1691772193,
-0.3436538875,
0.2395423055,
0.033790987,
0.5452113152,
-0.3056481183,
-0.9038511515,
-0.535553515,
0.1633547992,
0.5405486226,
-0.1517399102,
0.3669123054,
0.6481073499,
-0.5497477055,
-0.0960266963,
-0.5597165227,
-0.4665403962,
-0.3926492333,
0.4851068258,
-0.2531842887,
-0.3054966033,
0.4077054262,
-0.1095442995,
0.0678803995,
0.2932231128,
0.8435925245,
0.0479392037,
1.0766351223,
0.3385357857,
0.3005709052,
-0.2634245455,
-0.2641610503,
0.1928890496,
-0.8560154438,
-0.458050102,
-0.3428031504,
0.0062691979,
-0.3795737326,
-0.6457931399,
0.8726360798,
-0.1731949747,
0.0613209605,
0.134595409,
-0.5365451574,
0.1143015772,
-0.1224571466,
0.3648180366,
0.528442204,
-0.186867401,
-0.4856241941,
0.022036707,
-0.5609725118,
-0.8270436525,
1.3682174683,
0.5719866157,
0.4837502837,
-0.0666247159,
0.813472569,
0.6342135668,
0.6696206927,
-1.0234402418,
0.782088697,
-0.0039709196,
-0.4228560627,
-0.4091660678,
-0.2486496419,
-1.0867092609,
0.3188021481,
-0.3543951213,
-0.6705600023,
-0.2062079161,
-0.2109276652,
-0.5343261957,
0.0096412087,
-0.3804491758,
0.6816158891,
-0.4452203512,
-0.2841086984,
-0.4380112588,
-0.6604816318,
0.0309204478,
-0.2705911994,
0.2153722942,
-0.1801460683,
-0.2902766466,
0.6161432862,
-0.3760897219,
0.5816543102,
-0.2860759497,
-0.0329337604,
-0.1333553344,
0.2431551218,
0.2163750529,
0.3475437462,
-0.2427145392,
0.0197129771,
0.2639973462,
-0.1645484865,
-0.8467361331,
0.3509093821,
-0.6465787888,
-0.4581966102,
-0.2709234953,
-0.4590595663,
-0.7047273517,
0.1026246622,
-0.1465421021,
0.4447236061,
-0.4023513794,
-0.2789648771,
0.3136580288,
-0.3745045066,
-0.1176845729,
0.8808198571,
-0.3718656301,
-0.2592973709,
0.6424577236,
-0.1686053127,
0.1296246797,
0.0022855352,
0.2859581709,
-0.6207860708,
-0.9406780005,
-0.5539764762,
0.5434999466,
-0.8352932334,
-0.1184410304,
-0.609929204,
-0.2953197062,
-0.2674103081,
-0.189104721,
-0.2343980223,
0.1951274425,
-0.0727315545,
0.1221544668,
0.1738885939,
0.7588751912,
0.0042340532,
-0.0471511781,
-0.7727968097,
0.4225811064,
0.0062772362,
0.4377282858,
-0.091631718,
-0.4881630838,
-0.2602067292,
-0.1611502469,
-0.2525053918,
-0.6504920721,
0.3687566221,
0.1201128513,
0.8011146784,
0.6136366129,
0.0293290447,
0.577449441,
-0.5584949255,
0.3384926319,
0.1035164222,
-0.6906028986,
0.5245423913,
-0.1054614633,
-0.2347591966,
0.6891390681,
0.2660624683,
-0.481685251,
-0.6134430766,
-0.4991798103,
-0.5726510882,
0.4156301618,
0.1243394092,
-0.1401804388,
-0.1420130432,
0.3687021136,
0.3363907337,
0.0040671281,
-0.3161329627,
-0.1205621064,
0.4097800255,
-0.3832451701,
-0.068347849,
0.112727493,
-0.4556751549,
-0.2839114964,
0.3115644157,
-0.2290329337,
0.4847317934,
0.4247917533,
-0.3526138663,
-0.0625430346,
0.1794232875,
0.2531761527,
1.0789649487,
-0.270301044,
-0.1137908846,
0.1542880386,
-0.5883622169,
0.3213059604,
0.1831901073,
0.202682659,
0.1300852299,
0.5789242387,
0.435439378,
-0.0127478689,
-1.0302795172,
0.7035422325,
-0.0717497915,
-0.0876224115,
-0.4248135984,
0.0916481018,
-0.3479170799,
0.2995820045,
0.2577894628,
-0.0747512728,
0.3750468791,
-0.3794261813,
0.5448373556,
0.4454670846,
-0.4550932944,
-0.1301494539,
0.4165693521,
0.1346546859,
-0.3480577469,
0.4816573262,
-0.2541501522,
-0.1910417378,
0.7456688881,
0.3403529823,
0.8592306972,
-0.1132977083,
0.3053697348,
0.0931841135,
0.2751651704,
0.0755512789,
0.1477370709,
0.2004510015,
-0.5560758114,
-0.3688412011,
-0.5987993479,
-0.3746024966,
0.1195937246,
-0.7240516543,
0.573628664,
-0.5973213315,
-0.3566799164,
-0.0326815322,
0.3270468414,
-0.7259724736,
0.2432961315,
0.0806567669,
0.745018065,
-0.7080447078,
0.7237004638,
0.6316564083,
-0.1923106909,
-0.4948856831,
-0.1750631183,
0.0393726006,
-1.0743447542,
0.5809160471,
0.1495346427,
-0.2309604287,
-0.3994837403,
-0.0343664959,
-0.3354021311,
1.1566791534,
0.2588186562,
-0.476919353,
0.0210902654,
0.2808742821,
0.9011069536,
-0.7864383459,
0.5756998658,
0.8115502,
0.486599803,
-0.1835101843,
-1.2747710943,
0.4511337578,
-0.1818212271,
-0.1223589554,
-0.0138429496,
-0.2044608593,
0.2510291934,
-0.4347901344,
-0.0590942279,
0.2621560395,
0.0625369176,
0.479267925,
0.4391709268,
0.6415151954,
0.3937503397,
0.775219202,
0.137994051,
1.1198620796,
-0.4827088118,
0.1792954355,
0.6579901576,
-0.6091352105,
0.4792704284,
0.262650758,
-0.4315727353,
0.3448737264,
0.4243732989,
-0.2327229381,
0.1097621992,
0.390262872,
-0.310156554,
-0.2631352246,
-0.1701980978,
-0.2525207996,
0.6227356791,
0.4650866091,
-0.6022921801,
-0.1805945039,
0.0526149869,
-0.0893556178,
0.1253169179,
-0.1597665995,
0.7879379392,
-0.0061209109,
-0.589260757,
0.7756548524,
0.0508003607,
0.1400468647,
-0.5875178576,
-0.1711438,
-0.0306033399,
0.1424606144,
-0.294490695,
-0.5271958709,
0.1865951717,
-0.0721079409,
0.243469432,
-0.0370297581,
0.5939409137,
-0.0185233485,
-0.5709365606,
0.5053905249,
0.6938079596,
0.4780354798,
0.2404707819,
-0.9736619592,
0.0403534248,
-0.4590489566,
0.1198744476,
0.3292798698,
0.2713138759,
-0.2288942337,
1.0342129469,
0.4161086679,
0.6066578627,
-0.3328653276,
0.5699805617,
0.7781257033,
-0.3752898872,
-0.2745475769,
-0.8146674037,
0.1979879141,
-0.0264602192,
0.1478387713,
0.3315722048,
0.4376083314,
0.1622571647,
0.197152704,
0.7271419764,
0.043954026,
0.4671953022,
-0.4557434916,
0.7791699171,
-0.5607706904,
0.604454577,
-0.3374075592,
-0.681887269,
-0.3770994544,
0.591547966,
-0.375349462,
0.1785801947,
0.8601311445,
0.6940830946,
0.1656389683,
-0.1792423427,
0.4572778046,
0.0817607269,
0.3109960258,
0.5898703933,
0.7353180051,
-0.3322518468,
0.1871526688,
-0.1420020461,
-0.471580416,
-0.3181203306,
-0.6418303251,
-0.8134061098,
-0.364549011,
-0.3310749531,
-0.3580447733,
0.2815909386,
1.1928566694,
0.7287195921,
-0.5288159847,
-0.3901441693,
0.2079740763,
-0.0207560491,
-0.3933489919,
-0.1835491955,
0.6068785787,
-0.4545564353,
-0.5162603855,
0.4384827912,
0.59123528,
-0.1681684554,
-0.6167530417,
-0.2844380736,
0.234876588,
-0.1087418571,
0.5035627484,
-0.178996101,
-0.6655942798,
-0.1013328359,
-0.0321554169,
-0.1893026978,
0.1777396351,
0.7454806566,
-0.9888064265,
0.5108489394,
-0.0638294667,
0.7461763024,
-0.102347225,
-0.1226203516,
0.6680734158,
-0.011823372,
-0.1438373178,
0.7810199261,
0.3190388083,
0.1574757099,
-0.42713359,
0.5349110961,
0.21583049,
-0.4682252705,
-0.8959296346,
0.0034162274,
-0.7671964765,
-0.1205757782,
1.2078075409,
-0.240987733,
0.0050260862,
-0.6175932884,
-0.0633834973,
0.1553303152,
-0.1443531364,
1.0369950533,
0.2355714738,
-0.438858062,
0.1980991811,
-0.7970964909,
0.5825986862,
0.4121482968,
-0.8771687746,
-0.1829290241,
0.4340980649,
0.4604257047,
-0.03225784,
0.8785769939,
-0.585983932,
0.4857785106,
-0.3516903818,
-0.0757072419,
-0.0960063413,
-0.4092897773,
-0.3825107515,
-0.0996161848,
0.1328971982,
-0.0816101208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16444v1
|
KIT-19: A Comprehensive Korean Instruction Toolkit on 19 Tasks for Fine-Tuning Korean Large Language Models
| 2024-03-25T06:15:21 | 2024-03-25T06:15:21 |
Dongjun Jang, Sungjoo Byun, Hyemi Jo, Hyopil Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction Tuning on Large Language Models is an essential process for model
to function well and achieve high performance in specific tasks. Accordingly,
in mainstream languages such as English, instruction-based datasets are being
constructed and made publicly available. In the case of Korean, publicly
available models and datasets all rely on using the output of ChatGPT or
translating datasets built in English. In this paper, We introduce
\textit{KIT-19} as an instruction dataset for the development of LLM in Korean.
\textit{KIT-19} is a dataset created in an instruction format, comprising 19
existing open-source datasets for Korean NLP tasks. In this paper, we train a
Korean Pretrained LLM using \textit{KIT-19} to demonstrate its effectiveness.
The experimental results show that the model trained on \textit{KIT-19}
significantly outperforms existing Korean LLMs. Based on the its quality and
empirical results, this paper proposes that \textit{KIT-19} has the potential
to make a substantial contribution to the future improvement of Korean LLMs'
performance.
|
[
-0.1769683361,
-0.7002468109,
0.2570312023,
0.4594950676,
-0.2872115076,
0.2849751115,
-0.4776102602,
-0.0313684642,
0.0199072175,
0.6757316589,
-0.7298355103,
-0.8762848377,
-0.3203249872,
0.0405116566,
-0.0306304917,
0.823415041,
-0.1135504395,
0.4870765805,
-0.1320382059,
0.4248327017,
-0.6645360589,
-0.0485111922,
-0.6327455044,
-0.5097033978,
0.2715559006,
0.5858170986,
0.4269638658,
0.947127223,
0.6444071531,
0.3357644081,
0.049406942,
0.3468874395,
-0.5725010633,
0.1595143229,
-0.1969213635,
-0.6465930939,
-0.8252590895,
0.0344567448,
0.5630982518,
0.4322328568,
0.0259813648,
0.3084608614,
0.0048599429,
0.667349577,
-0.2166687846,
0.2906666994,
-0.6353971958,
0.0308203362,
-0.3226369023,
-0.2999534607,
-0.4566958547,
-0.1588003933,
-0.2385321856,
-0.771864593,
0.0650640726,
-0.1144946814,
0.8505166173,
0.3835712075,
-0.4289675653,
-0.4776004553,
-0.5497323275,
0.8225854039,
-0.8705906868,
0.4543533325,
0.6297534704,
0.499427259,
-0.3938295841,
-0.5728508234,
-0.0150277484,
-0.2744418979,
0.1018610746,
0.2068028152,
0.5046927929,
0.41147843,
0.0835035145,
0.4604512453,
-0.6072680354,
0.4424211979,
-0.4397414625,
-0.1764214635,
0.9334559441,
0.2212328017,
0.3018183708,
-0.3644586802,
-0.2942360044,
0.0551370829,
-0.8117995262,
-0.4198981524,
0.5290280581,
0.3870027065,
-0.3420808613,
0.6710903049,
-0.6720033884,
0.5515958071,
0.2142407298,
-0.6379002333,
0.3240579963,
-0.4001345932,
-0.3371360898,
0.0182140656,
0.5420088768,
0.3471846581,
0.5636760592,
-0.2528226376,
-0.4621604681,
-0.2257421315,
0.3451655507,
-0.6254101992,
-0.4293260276,
-0.1620413661,
-0.4565589428,
-0.4320245683,
-0.0403047651,
-0.7081851959,
-0.3703632057,
-0.7657145262,
0.4851003587,
-0.000199236,
-0.0570624433,
0.2042951286,
0.2659474909,
0.1763564348,
0.3186921775,
-0.5891824961,
0.2113750279,
0.7237268686,
0.6170809865,
-0.2612918317,
-0.2931882739,
-0.3415368199,
-0.0263525043,
-0.8016904593,
0.5639467239,
-0.4264733493,
-0.2396127135,
-0.0765758902,
0.55817765,
-0.1572143435,
-0.7983942628,
0.1726328731,
-0.4407487512,
0.1014419794,
-0.0269339923,
-0.6423498988,
0.0004502032,
0.1587665081,
-0.5264177322,
1.3187894821,
0.173434034,
-0.1509634852,
0.2037586272,
-0.7594741583,
-0.380012691,
0.3925297856,
-0.0546049438,
-0.2003919482,
0.0397162065,
0.0910982937,
0.8052139878,
-0.204929024,
0.4056885242,
-0.1002301127,
-0.3635990024,
-0.1387439072,
-0.4188715219,
0.6774396896,
0.0535285249,
-0.4075114727,
0.0496507213,
-1.0401113033,
0.1973512322,
0.0319832377,
-0.6448315978,
-0.2646191716,
-0.5425037146,
-0.283575058,
0.3240199685,
0.4849404991,
-0.3864406645,
0.1974554956,
-0.4395765662,
-0.0793423504,
0.9013502002,
-0.0860966593,
0.772331953,
-0.1868282855,
1.0143648386,
-0.4497968256,
0.2091054469,
-0.3763189912,
-0.5171262026,
-0.8008448482,
-0.214612782,
0.4379709661,
0.7623419762,
-0.8038597703,
0.4098997712,
-0.1315339655,
-0.5784459114,
-0.691967845,
0.473613143,
0.6685858965,
0.4227129519,
0.1263355017,
0.1639777422,
-0.6570184231,
-0.812612772,
0.2265128642,
0.2259390503,
-0.1836921573,
0.3398635983,
0.3884256184,
-0.1542575955,
0.2963982224,
-0.3587244749,
0.0399472937,
-0.235485673,
-0.1784289479,
0.2946930826,
0.4356225133,
0.1173546314,
-0.3365390897,
-0.7802721858,
0.3857803643,
-0.7439287901,
-0.3965268433,
-0.1215587407,
-0.4165133834,
0.1663551927,
0.8700417876,
-0.3806045651,
0.4060350955,
0.5506819487,
-0.2637004256,
0.8018293381,
-0.1696511656,
0.0588199347,
-1.3738129139,
-0.2220842689,
-0.3385942876,
-0.3395268023,
-0.5636791587,
0.2559806108,
0.1020651162,
-0.0858902633,
-0.4824319184,
0.9028105736,
-0.3186671734,
-0.0115100909,
-0.4713972211,
-0.0945603549,
-0.08479774,
0.248310715,
-0.2001914978,
0.9196298718,
0.1451721489,
-0.7556537986,
0.6009281874,
0.2171521783,
-0.4392541945,
0.5895576477,
-0.4386887252,
0.1430116892,
0.0558169037,
-0.0327788927,
-0.6505912542,
-0.6535701156,
0.327064395,
-0.1055817455,
0.6006815434,
-0.0927658975,
-0.2761707604,
-0.2661832571,
-0.2911401689,
-0.2790757418,
0.3695408702,
-0.5559588075,
0.4574733377,
0.1372525692,
-0.1484385282,
-0.7402549982,
-0.7069090605,
-0.0633009151,
-0.1815707684,
-0.5028710961,
0.4993165135,
-0.1631189585,
-0.1688866615,
-0.0567954704,
-0.2516232133,
-0.1195793226,
0.1052375734,
0.2875865996,
0.2132748514,
-0.4080902934,
0.3932052851,
0.145298183,
-0.2157673538,
0.0374317095,
0.076171279,
0.8367351294,
0.124429211,
-0.2696020007,
-0.4997791648,
-0.1643225253,
0.1621662527,
0.1950765103,
0.4879208207,
0.6446430087,
-0.2492027432,
-0.5764824748,
-0.4959287047,
-0.2045502067,
-0.6254575253,
0.8202970028,
-0.4629946947,
-0.5902273655,
0.5036822557,
-0.4863342643,
-0.0720998645,
0.195453465,
0.5144158602,
-0.1445383281,
0.7130351663,
0.4423336387,
-0.0051655443,
0.4686034918,
-0.3187302649,
0.0865893811,
-0.7484490871,
-0.5335031748,
-0.3683922887,
-0.5760524273,
-0.5681507587,
-0.5766729116,
-0.103993915,
0.3254258037,
-0.5381727815,
0.2695075274,
-0.268679291,
0.954701364,
0.6900485754,
0.238407284,
0.1975341737,
-0.1624260545,
-0.1001085937,
0.0256421417,
-0.8530433774,
-0.709343195,
1.3959678411,
0.1291061938,
0.9768574238,
-0.5969564915,
0.8942164183,
0.0567928739,
-0.1214795709,
-0.8165308833,
0.791441679,
-0.4009114206,
-0.5621594191,
-0.3176406622,
-0.3374798298,
-0.7965549231,
-0.4815377593,
0.2551071048,
-0.4390189052,
-0.1361306906,
-0.0132420994,
0.0557214618,
0.0352590904,
-0.8365018368,
0.9350848198,
-0.4252753556,
0.124925971,
0.0387927219,
-0.4707249105,
0.3704214096,
-0.2381870151,
-0.0465921685,
-0.240329206,
-0.1996317506,
0.6995891333,
-0.2082942277,
0.9025139809,
-0.2569222748,
-0.2470452487,
0.0897419527,
-0.0823922604,
0.5535419583,
0.2333756834,
0.0297363084,
-0.1968206316,
-0.2112341225,
-0.4504712522,
-0.6102023125,
0.7988862991,
-0.6844499111,
-0.4315690696,
0.195795849,
-0.7984138727,
-0.0595813915,
0.1822897792,
0.215701282,
0.3484283984,
0.0321908258,
0.3617565632,
0.8490990996,
-0.4876158237,
0.3676409721,
0.4968751371,
-0.5721049905,
-0.552054882,
1.0677244663,
0.3514688015,
0.6511818171,
0.3819492459,
0.1240448654,
-0.1163123474,
-0.4254245162,
-0.5048755407,
0.1653585434,
-0.9115614891,
-0.5252844691,
-0.21390149,
-0.5744379163,
-0.0114029404,
-0.3368352354,
-0.6201514006,
-0.4248046577,
-0.1821646541,
-0.1980832517,
0.3540264368,
0.8815954924,
0.0368776694,
0.7637304068,
-0.3729156554,
0.3100067377,
0.4127472639,
0.4542319179,
-0.161716193,
-0.4918822646,
-0.5181529522,
0.1986260116,
-0.253276825,
-0.5850403905,
0.1622052938,
0.4083843529,
0.5640114546,
0.3004237413,
-0.0349428207,
0.6204017401,
-0.397573173,
0.5808640718,
-0.4592016935,
-0.642675817,
0.4729036093,
-0.4542170763,
0.7257502079,
0.4847007692,
0.3923182487,
-0.5480947495,
-0.1816867888,
-0.4675157964,
-0.5033555627,
0.9901964664,
-0.2507286966,
0.3679688275,
0.1472748667,
0.4473618865,
0.3438892365,
0.2892488837,
-0.4900394082,
-0.2249264121,
-0.0085837068,
-0.4941744506,
0.1170052588,
-0.1521097422,
0.0637752637,
-0.1948667467,
1.0204687119,
-0.0696942583,
0.328733474,
-0.5337598324,
0.004619956,
0.0369018465,
0.0546568856,
0.4539901614,
0.7540996075,
-0.0054953555,
0.0101657612,
0.3842333257,
-0.8818598986,
0.3319078088,
-0.0405110084,
-0.3431016803,
0.0824668109,
0.3633502722,
0.8522564173,
0.5035359263,
-0.5684679151,
0.1988565922,
0.3549431562,
-0.1433359236,
0.0897989422,
0.137414366,
0.406557709,
0.2924065888,
0.0890508443,
-0.3765941858,
-0.1585369259,
-0.1887559295,
0.2086779475,
0.2913331985,
-0.2021248639,
-0.3846585751,
0.3015185595,
0.1571793109,
-0.6636180878,
0.4097050428,
-0.5897414088,
-0.4850468338,
0.8634910583,
0.7216356993,
0.6672743559,
-0.7869223356,
0.8101298809,
0.3554745913,
0.4261310399,
-0.2094495296,
0.6924866438,
0.3563299179,
-0.4012385607,
-0.9572664499,
-0.8088424802,
-0.0746978372,
0.7747429609,
-0.3557828963,
0.7155939937,
-0.3708551824,
0.295356214,
-0.3024955392,
0.204506427,
-0.7186224461,
0.4145800769,
-0.1484158188,
0.7502414584,
-0.7266019583,
0.7179011703,
0.7217789888,
0.0878731012,
-0.8373434544,
-0.3020002842,
0.0343107693,
-1.0763860941,
0.6323034763,
0.1124014482,
0.323805064,
0.1486513168,
-0.5149331689,
-1.0285022259,
1.0596795082,
0.4614075422,
-0.7947201729,
-0.11309091,
0.4846541882,
0.3583109379,
-0.4796024561,
-0.1454687864,
0.3752731681,
0.4252051711,
-0.2026758045,
-1.0433897972,
-0.1200009435,
-0.2053057402,
-0.0892541856,
0.2412507385,
-0.4460521936,
0.5385634899,
0.3305338025,
0.0388371795,
0.2612836957,
0.0988256261,
0.2264273763,
0.5317835808,
0.038382154,
0.5540462732,
0.8973277211,
-0.0012633596,
0.6843211055,
-0.3100393713,
-0.0369807109,
1.4238559008,
0.159896642,
0.6357678175,
0.1148777455,
-0.1978372633,
0.0370220691,
0.6952363253,
0.0219042078,
0.5689958334,
0.2775789499,
-0.2085888386,
-0.294518739,
-0.1374631822,
-0.3431743979,
0.6761375666,
0.2516673803,
-0.5256901383,
-0.2262944132,
0.2835481763,
0.3020343184,
0.0953215659,
-0.5813366175,
0.8055796623,
0.1397024393,
-0.1700659543,
0.5253215432,
-0.0730746984,
0.6350477338,
-0.662648797,
-0.0076540578,
-0.298168391,
0.1331374496,
-0.1829158813,
-0.4648666978,
0.1446951628,
-0.0653568655,
-0.2484805584,
-0.1528566629,
0.953119278,
-0.521315515,
-0.6607605815,
0.0680129975,
0.5298513174,
0.2481143177,
0.0243170969,
-0.6483370066,
-0.0744903982,
0.1054970622,
-0.2918682992,
0.5451779366,
0.5979251862,
-0.1575545371,
0.6088160872,
0.3838231564,
0.2244665325,
0.435865581,
-0.0304338075,
0.709743619,
-0.3079555929,
-0.1317887157,
-0.7371200323,
0.4500688612,
-0.1556564122,
-0.54517138,
0.9091921449,
0.5954124928,
1.2423026562,
-0.3604558706,
0.6967397928,
0.1836419404,
0.4436159432,
-0.6863354445,
0.7237643003,
-0.2472258359,
0.2013080716,
-0.0550043359,
-1.2541363239,
-0.050742127,
0.6012440324,
-0.3447228968,
0.1474416703,
0.5165674686,
1.1066622734,
-0.1622665972,
-0.1171237305,
0.3179454505,
0.0487790182,
0.0523286685,
0.1370974928,
0.7672288418,
-0.4062236845,
0.4142509997,
-0.8106607199,
-0.0416516587,
-0.0626085252,
-0.8074211478,
-1.2096068859,
-0.4591991007,
-0.2632877231,
-0.0186426807,
0.3129173517,
1.0316045284,
0.7511439323,
-0.8063573837,
-0.3158254623,
-0.2696320415,
-0.0149242273,
-0.0418632254,
-0.1975820661,
0.3432322741,
-0.7907192707,
-0.7911663651,
0.8770856261,
0.1917983294,
0.1175168604,
-0.3029061556,
-0.4788467884,
-0.2565689683,
0.0031588748,
0.4140713811,
-0.1545649171,
-0.5043837428,
0.2014118135,
0.4557941556,
0.0635356903,
0.0018702075,
0.4187091589,
-0.4629572034,
0.683688879,
0.4099068642,
0.8897460103,
0.3824156523,
-0.1927327216,
0.8080683947,
-1.1037636995,
0.0411926396,
0.0998882651,
-0.1627048254,
0.3677074909,
-0.3706899881,
0.8969694376,
0.0041148588,
-0.8775350451,
-0.8951421976,
0.0766550452,
-0.471732825,
-0.1195461452,
1.2373595238,
-0.1402615458,
-0.1826474965,
-0.0580395311,
-0.4943289161,
0.2773411274,
-0.2395618856,
0.778131783,
0.912417233,
0.308008194,
-0.0475095175,
-1.1371662617,
0.6362295151,
0.0825726092,
-1.0792794228,
-0.0655246526,
0.0250339024,
0.0437821485,
-0.1043088585,
0.1822114736,
0.0765760466,
0.3845751286,
0.0032828124,
-0.0912746564,
-0.3287402391,
-0.6037396789,
-0.1883351356,
-0.2472757995,
-0.0756315142,
-0.2959799469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16443v1
|
CodeS: Natural Language to Code Repository via Multi-Layer Sketch
| 2024-03-25T06:09:55 | 2024-03-25T06:09:55 |
Daoguang Zan, Ailun Yu, Wei Liu, Dong Chen, Bo Shen, Wei Li, Yafen Yao, Yongshun Gong, Xiaolin Chen, Bei Guan, Zhiguang Yang, Yongji Wang, Qianxiang Wang, Lizhen Cui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
The impressive performance of large language models (LLMs) on code-related
tasks has shown the potential of fully automated software development. In light
of this, we introduce a new software engineering task, namely Natural Language
to code Repository (NL2Repo). This task aims to generate an entire code
repository from its natural language requirements. To address this task, we
propose a simple yet effective framework CodeS, which decomposes NL2Repo into
multiple sub-tasks by a multi-layer sketch. Specifically, CodeS includes three
modules: RepoSketcher, FileSketcher, and SketchFiller. RepoSketcher first
generates a repository's directory structure for given requirements;
FileSketcher then generates a file sketch for each file in the generated
structure; SketchFiller finally fills in the details for each function in the
generated file sketch. To rigorously assess CodeS on the NL2Repo task, we carry
out evaluations through both automated benchmarking and manual feedback
analysis. For benchmark-based evaluation, we craft a repository-oriented
benchmark, SketchEval, and design an evaluation metric, SketchBLEU. For
feedback-based evaluation, we develop a VSCode plugin for CodeS and engage 30
participants in conducting empirical studies. Extensive experiments prove the
effectiveness and practicality of CodeS on the NL2Repo task.
|
[
-0.2603509426,
-0.2269042283,
0.1483479142,
0.6503438354,
-0.0762618557,
0.1178315803,
-0.0622816458,
-0.7284593582,
0.1860347688,
1.0076617002,
-0.3585980535,
-0.3603182733,
-0.0897609144,
0.3278568983,
-0.5196467042,
0.7433492541,
-0.2618747056,
-0.2386474609,
-0.1527587324,
0.0475458503,
-0.5256099105,
-0.3105177879,
-0.501178205,
-0.2944468558,
0.2408946455,
0.4919603467,
0.1820649058,
0.3193736374,
0.4111950994,
0.3444738686,
0.1723968536,
0.1419241279,
-0.3593823314,
0.068801567,
-0.0236436669,
-0.4595459998,
-0.3177946806,
-0.1413624883,
0.1755149066,
0.2712658048,
-0.0141425179,
0.3158592284,
0.0804354772,
1.0621979237,
-0.4718212187,
0.3954000175,
-0.3005070984,
0.1562795192,
0.2328815758,
-0.3417226672,
-0.6302797794,
-0.5680664778,
-0.0447235778,
-0.649692595,
0.1517113447,
0.0596404597,
0.6239740252,
0.1878703088,
-0.1600392908,
-0.5890479088,
-0.5184289217,
0.6207648516,
-0.8452233672,
0.0532547981,
0.2645800114,
0.4769719243,
-0.1372733861,
-0.9049010277,
-0.5356302857,
-0.54616642,
-0.2186061144,
-0.0249760132,
0.009014816,
0.0085294489,
0.3324362636,
0.4687738121,
-0.6788258553,
0.0504016466,
-0.40292418,
-0.3843412101,
0.6995570064,
-0.0848164931,
0.5846244097,
-0.577016294,
-0.4453299046,
0.0661510751,
-0.4478108585,
-0.0720331222,
0.5771909356,
0.4200475812,
-0.2793063223,
0.7958182096,
-0.3724283278,
0.3915060163,
-0.2943125963,
0.0338508151,
0.3433535099,
-0.3956224918,
-0.2133854926,
-0.0892266408,
0.6322457194,
0.2792285383,
0.3753936589,
-0.3527596593,
-0.3816224933,
0.1794479042,
0.6178126335,
-0.7475435734,
-0.4906047881,
0.43870157,
-0.4458360672,
-0.5591720939,
-0.0075803227,
-0.6079784036,
-0.3562950194,
-0.5532359481,
0.158962816,
-0.2402903736,
-0.3550590575,
0.1725758761,
-0.4593965113,
0.1799821407,
0.3884495795,
-0.562435925,
0.4046700001,
0.6573210955,
0.8674530387,
-0.0441581421,
-0.2917871177,
-0.5767341256,
0.241763249,
-0.3208147883,
0.8501241803,
-0.111592114,
-0.2071429044,
-0.0379428566,
-0.1562933922,
0.3168931305,
-0.5936607718,
0.2528612614,
-0.2235965729,
0.2030821443,
-0.0138901221,
-0.5341768265,
-0.0257521663,
0.2880033553,
-0.9846106172,
1.226524353,
0.474993825,
-0.7270778418,
-0.0295827184,
-0.9989589453,
-0.5489354134,
0.351862371,
-0.2942226827,
-0.1010881662,
-0.0275281593,
-0.059614528,
0.3612813652,
-0.3417780399,
0.3351041675,
-0.0090116961,
-0.4296290278,
-0.0164507385,
0.1177047938,
1.0407323837,
0.1191869527,
-0.5612962246,
0.125792563,
-0.8577234745,
0.2831215858,
0.1146867126,
-0.5960186124,
-0.0632088929,
-0.1519539952,
0.4796414077,
0.2061615288,
-0.0987468064,
-0.4204651415,
0.3062016368,
-0.4680242836,
0.7035088539,
0.5470260382,
-0.0718107969,
0.7473034263,
-0.3517020047,
0.4767826796,
-0.4979791343,
0.0493837781,
-0.1350430101,
-0.5179439187,
-0.6040992737,
-0.1183901951,
0.0196546894,
0.6095525622,
-1.0185152292,
0.4157199562,
-0.1490202844,
-0.3250602186,
-0.1376084536,
0.4618318379,
0.5469833612,
0.3786478341,
0.3176062703,
-0.5593308806,
-0.6287130713,
-0.9114688039,
-0.0772181973,
-0.3027772009,
-0.3815738857,
0.1702174544,
0.5648669004,
-0.4105151892,
1.0186604261,
-0.3725527227,
-0.4031459391,
-0.4635798931,
0.486405462,
-0.0595304631,
0.609033525,
0.8016076684,
-0.605961144,
-0.2187500596,
0.0199169498,
-0.6069387197,
-0.2868873179,
-0.2625952661,
-0.258092761,
0.3518205583,
0.424205631,
-0.6128489971,
0.1645906121,
0.5088371038,
0.0719193891,
0.7204952836,
-0.0564885363,
-0.0068529332,
-0.971693635,
0.5228558779,
-0.0722359046,
-0.0825654641,
-0.4955026507,
0.5730784535,
0.2126822919,
-0.2676886618,
-0.3583100736,
0.6937510967,
-0.471737355,
-0.3000770807,
-0.2625817358,
0.0111894188,
0.3398958743,
0.6742009521,
-0.0438940711,
0.6228988171,
0.1891549081,
-0.3927017152,
0.4836017191,
0.0614755563,
-0.6209316254,
0.2191857994,
-0.8101590276,
0.5549819469,
0.0643046424,
0.4030611217,
-0.8351547122,
-0.3197306693,
0.0534178391,
-0.4021829963,
0.3467229605,
-0.4185442924,
-0.8717200756,
-0.4565474689,
-0.5560166836,
-0.0599217154,
0.3084034622,
-0.2656180263,
0.5374584794,
0.4391201437,
-0.1579264551,
-0.4787504971,
-0.7827510238,
0.3494790196,
0.3460220397,
-0.509632051,
0.2932664156,
-0.144227013,
-0.1560140848,
0.1052602157,
-0.2902177274,
-0.4045732617,
-0.0299213715,
0.2974714637,
0.1518720835,
-0.1795356125,
-0.0847504064,
0.1012264937,
-0.4181362689,
0.2422656566,
-0.3945203424,
0.4341675341,
0.0126395784,
-0.3236942291,
-0.2348803282,
0.318866998,
0.4738523066,
-0.2095753551,
-0.1307400912,
0.3993739486,
-0.4281822145,
-0.6808812618,
-0.5125159025,
0.1125662401,
-0.4765148759,
0.2706232369,
-0.3516050279,
-0.9983784556,
0.4931480587,
-0.249610588,
0.4286728799,
0.1617534608,
0.3532639742,
-0.0406225733,
0.4892914295,
0.8684305549,
0.0120676896,
0.2932803631,
-0.4744704068,
0.2759487629,
-0.6850171685,
-0.2370174378,
-0.9305023551,
-0.2744365633,
-0.2090139836,
-0.655782938,
-0.1455857009,
0.3322512209,
-0.1469527632,
0.8050810695,
-0.735040009,
0.795060277,
0.4451551437,
-0.1790294796,
0.1374526471,
-0.1082617566,
-0.2428392172,
0.2324096113,
-0.5738616586,
-0.6219581962,
0.8011887074,
0.2942968905,
0.633595705,
0.0592816547,
0.9669485092,
0.3335483074,
0.3627090454,
-0.8166680336,
0.5502995849,
-0.0733569935,
-0.4973579347,
-0.2449845821,
-0.5374496579,
-0.439893961,
-0.0351877064,
0.0313443579,
-0.5721288919,
-0.0133056352,
0.1905019432,
-0.0411967263,
0.0478598513,
-0.9754898548,
0.9253491759,
-0.2667108178,
-0.2105985731,
0.0052653523,
-0.7310565114,
0.4113467038,
0.0443241522,
0.2827274203,
-0.0808165222,
0.1426642835,
0.5363948941,
-0.4324912429,
0.7859002352,
-0.2520281076,
-0.1929859519,
0.3446620405,
0.369512558,
0.4852166474,
0.3242453337,
-0.1982051879,
-0.1510825604,
0.0086711748,
-0.3635729551,
-0.6625211239,
0.6592445374,
-0.4329589009,
0.0237232484,
0.0017743938,
-0.4455534816,
-0.0436128862,
0.4430329502,
0.0097508207,
0.7611713409,
0.0432678424,
0.0017644687,
0.4098840058,
-0.690777123,
0.3983041942,
0.2758529484,
-0.3436828852,
-0.4033916593,
0.7094920278,
-0.2583855093,
0.2772012353,
0.6702186465,
0.1302695721,
-0.21349971,
-0.4998086691,
-0.7039658427,
-0.0103210341,
-0.8991549015,
-0.4694042504,
-0.4057180882,
-0.2682894766,
-0.4492454827,
-0.3809044063,
-0.5173299313,
-0.4682010114,
0.1603776067,
0.0769974738,
0.3078890741,
1.075422287,
0.187179625,
-0.298397094,
-0.823159039,
0.7012787461,
0.2656602561,
0.6764709353,
0.0587407947,
-0.0377578065,
-0.1128105372,
-0.154833883,
0.0150275445,
-0.5562903285,
0.2867538035,
-0.1206755862,
0.5870857239,
-0.0881626084,
0.1992621124,
0.5603395104,
-0.5727356672,
0.5596141219,
0.3526185155,
-0.9507857561,
0.7726925015,
-0.1198583767,
0.3488897383,
0.6953759193,
-0.0737101957,
-0.3204108775,
-0.8813391328,
-0.1850862503,
-0.999538362,
0.6397378445,
0.4259540737,
0.3406794667,
0.1208727062,
0.3692013621,
0.1171339601,
0.157973513,
-0.8438560367,
-0.1237062514,
-0.330539912,
0.0042739371,
0.2738342881,
-0.1965799183,
-0.1369779706,
-0.1343552172,
0.2710590661,
-0.4592796862,
0.4569147527,
0.0518514626,
-0.3319360912,
-0.0271241069,
0.3051037192,
0.7826227546,
0.7893567681,
-0.2904705107,
0.030961046,
-0.2513749301,
-0.5554664731,
-0.0778600127,
0.057934057,
-0.069406271,
0.1610309482,
0.5894467235,
0.4875197411,
0.5625879765,
-0.6960203052,
0.4387474358,
-0.0863655135,
-0.4769960344,
-0.3493402302,
0.1054480672,
0.2595595419,
0.0704492182,
0.3811064661,
0.3307709694,
0.2513335049,
-0.5367205739,
0.3676786423,
-0.0104627395,
-0.2605231106,
-0.0568763055,
0.4602119923,
0.6114282608,
-0.4749220014,
0.5584914088,
-0.5469453335,
-0.6058362722,
1.0072739124,
0.499199301,
1.1418659687,
0.3520938456,
0.3126473129,
0.4422340989,
0.598852396,
-0.2098464668,
0.3699913025,
-0.1352314204,
-0.3928446472,
-0.9971241951,
-0.5756149888,
-0.4109568596,
0.0334683396,
-0.6370006204,
0.3917230964,
-0.5906446576,
0.3347817063,
0.0246076249,
0.0511474423,
-0.4292890429,
-0.2111552656,
0.067606397,
1.1503902674,
-0.582649529,
0.9692418575,
0.874078691,
-0.4683808088,
-0.9233245254,
-0.1648690403,
0.2124017775,
-0.5113720894,
0.7184229493,
0.5344308615,
-0.0923481286,
-0.085915558,
-0.5350844264,
-0.5646730661,
0.9427875876,
0.5634540319,
-0.4605331123,
-0.0039081234,
0.0456699766,
0.5435792208,
-0.2554789484,
0.2213444114,
0.1937148422,
0.3077835739,
0.0524178483,
-1.0434389114,
0.0320278332,
-0.8721154928,
0.1608732343,
0.3376710415,
-0.0606572591,
0.4737065434,
-0.330378592,
-0.2788530588,
0.0917922109,
0.1329022497,
0.3327014744,
0.1188611463,
0.3463463783,
0.48214522,
0.4571704268,
0.0704594254,
1.3161048889,
-0.4394319654,
0.3428966999,
1.2988358736,
-0.466665566,
0.8582066298,
0.5366283059,
-0.2719348371,
0.5129031539,
0.1250548959,
0.0545961447,
0.2984496057,
0.6947383881,
0.3011134267,
0.1991310418,
0.0746227205,
-0.2763820291,
0.0628706515,
-0.1257064939,
0.0242079217,
-0.2003388554,
-0.1912195981,
-0.2138098478,
0.1048922166,
0.1244971156,
0.7366092801,
0.111784339,
-0.363493979,
0.2633666992,
0.1855855435,
0.5769284368,
-0.6067131758,
-0.3735417724,
-0.3453055918,
0.0375657082,
-0.3500780165,
-0.7936692834,
0.5042828321,
0.1695541143,
-0.0524078868,
-0.6663961411,
0.7044408917,
-0.0838130862,
-0.3593404889,
0.5024163127,
0.1854704171,
-0.0680775046,
-0.0329983346,
-0.7996054292,
0.0140840719,
-0.0514226966,
-0.2789807022,
0.2430652529,
0.4450422525,
0.0907474011,
0.7338243127,
0.8607223034,
0.0511039793,
0.0051760213,
0.63618958,
0.9402370453,
-0.4603299797,
-0.5594633818,
-0.3491261899,
0.7430423498,
-0.2807434201,
-0.4312720001,
0.5569376349,
0.8434171677,
0.9973513484,
-0.171575442,
0.7351346016,
-0.4731267989,
0.4650711715,
-0.5862118006,
0.8192759752,
-0.3013761342,
0.4240247607,
-0.5149677992,
-1.0636405945,
-0.4586523473,
0.7618997693,
0.2658494115,
-0.2303531766,
0.7991173863,
0.7503094673,
0.1030602604,
0.124814719,
-0.261344254,
-0.1474541426,
0.3636048138,
0.5840673447,
0.7932540774,
-0.5103777647,
0.5083784461,
-0.6664584279,
-0.0975917056,
-0.0823781416,
-1.0530200005,
-0.8746514916,
-0.4560436904,
-0.391556114,
-0.216084078,
-0.3375810981,
0.8763515949,
0.6527397633,
-0.9594653249,
-0.6013320684,
-0.4266383946,
0.1681631505,
-0.2500803173,
-0.3197672665,
0.0970940068,
-0.5725188851,
-0.4358740747,
0.2262019813,
0.796405375,
-0.0739479586,
-0.4283822179,
-0.4227729738,
0.0081309322,
-0.4013180435,
0.7706031799,
0.1857193708,
-0.6431775689,
-0.2043411285,
0.2018606514,
-0.509606123,
-0.1444115639,
1.2394094467,
-0.5801787972,
0.531475842,
0.6907690763,
0.7653036714,
0.331194371,
-0.2682313621,
0.6660609841,
-0.844923377,
0.1588823795,
0.3801481426,
0.1842012703,
0.1169258207,
-0.1870100647,
0.8872336745,
0.0090755941,
-0.3026677072,
-1.0704456568,
0.0487832613,
-1.1578527689,
-0.4038767517,
1.1081979275,
-0.0002683626,
0.1086544916,
-0.4949550629,
-0.2869002223,
-0.0319570974,
-0.1872707754,
0.6906788349,
0.4259978533,
-0.1158000007,
-0.288996309,
-1.1155182123,
0.5147586465,
-0.0219811369,
-1.1343301535,
0.0401346609,
0.4918058813,
0.2133629024,
0.3756650984,
0.8847972751,
-0.1908617169,
0.4070799053,
0.0898072124,
0.4132232666,
-0.2697065175,
-0.3230588138,
-0.0647294223,
0.1861972064,
0.0915430039,
0.235529691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16442v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16442v1
|
If CLIP Could Talk: Understanding Vision-Language Model Representations Through Their Preferred Concept Descriptions
| 2024-03-25T06:05:50 | 2024-03-25T06:05:50 |
Reza Esfandiarpoor, Cristina Menghini, Stephen H. Bach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent works often assume that Vision-Language Model (VLM) representations
are based on visual attributes like shape. However, it is unclear to what
extent VLMs prioritize this information to represent concepts. We propose
Extract and Explore (EX2), a novel approach to characterize important textual
features for VLMs. EX2 uses reinforcement learning to align a large language
model with VLM preferences and generates descriptions that incorporate the
important features for the VLM. Then, we inspect the descriptions to identify
the features that contribute to VLM representations. We find that spurious
descriptions have a major role in VLM representations despite providing no
helpful information, e.g., Click to enlarge photo of CONCEPT. More importantly,
among informative descriptions, VLMs rely significantly on non-visual
attributes like habitat to represent visual concepts. Also, our analysis
reveals that different VLMs prioritize different attributes in their
representations. Overall, we show that VLMs do not simply match images to scene
descriptions and that non-visual or even spurious descriptions significantly
influence their representations.
|
[
-0.4561656713,
-0.5412182808,
0.8776560426,
0.0513494946,
-0.3820358217,
0.0791471303,
-0.1528106481,
-0.770783782,
0.3921419382,
0.6232233047,
-0.4378574789,
-0.2065860331,
-0.6601803899,
-0.1755992621,
-0.6140179038,
0.85415411,
-0.0186272673,
-0.0620163307,
-0.4097650647,
-0.144978255,
-0.7331369519,
-0.5622584224,
-0.4005960226,
-0.0210680589,
0.356512785,
0.0618674643,
0.7127377987,
0.8008179069,
0.5173993707,
0.2628703713,
-0.3169206381,
0.1114706397,
-0.5040851235,
-0.0617856719,
-0.2044679075,
-0.5083671212,
-0.1673408151,
0.0505848862,
0.6965582371,
0.4798489511,
0.1526836604,
0.0886917561,
0.0549810044,
0.2615306079,
-0.3738977909,
0.5196074247,
-0.6964067221,
-0.0410909839,
-0.1466853917,
-0.3420860171,
-0.3692568839,
0.1348928958,
0.7565054893,
-0.6051046848,
0.1207752973,
0.4186675847,
1.3101699352,
0.1761416793,
-0.2449506819,
-0.1027026474,
-0.6242491007,
0.7632012367,
-0.2724821866,
0.1983568072,
0.2456485778,
0.3858950436,
0.1288893521,
-0.6651351452,
-0.7069752216,
-0.1520241648,
-0.4374214113,
-0.127923131,
-0.3061317801,
-0.0011389249,
0.3566247523,
0.2152513415,
-0.240362674,
0.0158115085,
-0.6986478567,
-0.3365006149,
0.7202900648,
0.3287355602,
0.4205110371,
-0.4829779863,
-0.9152697921,
-0.6021501422,
-0.5038076639,
0.5183308125,
-0.033141125,
0.2260449678,
0.0137758944,
0.774759829,
-0.0273025949,
0.6638209224,
-0.2936850786,
-0.0358097777,
0.2583340406,
-0.2764350474,
-0.1737452894,
0.0197248291,
0.5734758973,
0.7354525924,
0.1233241558,
-0.0372652225,
-0.2389411032,
-0.1045073047,
0.4792490602,
-0.7517504692,
-0.1771309525,
0.0506581739,
-0.5958439708,
-0.4412752986,
0.2890411019,
-0.8523725271,
-0.3942729235,
-0.2518247366,
0.4425272048,
-0.4330216646,
-0.3341885209,
0.0067150462,
-0.5419909358,
0.5350971818,
0.3814346194,
-0.8518067598,
0.2583943307,
0.5212087631,
0.906504333,
-0.5597430468,
-0.3572928011,
-0.3705594838,
0.1586557925,
-0.4058650434,
0.9416012168,
-0.6325154901,
-0.5054234266,
-0.0261235926,
0.2429952323,
0.162002027,
-0.3665101826,
0.4280441105,
-0.2622837126,
0.1473712325,
-0.4685775042,
-0.4360537529,
-0.4255790114,
0.0614852309,
-0.8790397048,
0.9830673337,
0.2518466413,
-0.7806672454,
0.5866895914,
-0.5841917396,
0.0018589868,
0.2217582762,
-0.6641792059,
-0.2961510718,
0.2804253995,
0.2452255338,
0.2680164874,
0.1149818003,
0.0924797803,
-0.2702915072,
-0.1831145734,
0.4926994145,
-0.1391378492,
0.3813720345,
-0.0609720871,
-0.2610112131,
0.4478521943,
-0.6056232452,
0.2295788825,
0.3683371544,
0.0323517919,
-0.6864534616,
0.4117284715,
0.0654435158,
0.045534391,
0.164815709,
-0.4281196296,
0.1499675512,
-0.4068712592,
0.3607915044,
0.8084446788,
0.0120991645,
0.421477288,
-0.1780426204,
0.4667609334,
-0.0709801018,
0.2577728927,
-0.348870635,
-0.3796955943,
-0.9875917435,
-0.3774642646,
-0.0938488394,
0.29685238,
-0.9642174244,
-0.1614118814,
-0.2294045091,
-0.1634240299,
-0.4725592136,
-0.2241017967,
0.459348619,
0.370341599,
0.3833138645,
-0.3802172244,
-0.7019947171,
-1.2067242861,
0.0000463764,
-0.4003572464,
0.0892385244,
0.5541835427,
0.3522704244,
0.1482806057,
1.3355827332,
-0.6861849427,
-0.1703531742,
-0.4168808758,
-0.1691408008,
-0.115879938,
-0.0643105358,
0.7545126081,
-1.2258111238,
-0.1508731246,
-0.1158626378,
-0.5496367812,
0.0572101027,
-0.0404761247,
-0.2642234862,
-0.1657073796,
0.4666426778,
-0.4635978937,
0.9045730233,
0.2266953886,
-0.5025841594,
0.3951384723,
-0.1593057215,
-0.210640654,
-0.598513186,
-0.1200903058,
-0.0997676849,
-0.2662063241,
-0.3194008172,
0.1318800002,
-0.0212491453,
-0.1838487387,
-0.6150572896,
0.7207425237,
-0.5076215267,
-0.3076773286,
-0.3286405206,
0.2913893163,
0.2863790393,
0.4778908789,
0.8069548607,
0.7712022066,
0.6565790176,
-0.6304944754,
-0.0149210542,
0.4771583378,
-0.4202213883,
0.2986646891,
-0.6989999413,
-0.03775502,
-0.0783930346,
-0.0326975137,
-0.726804316,
-0.0811493918,
0.1267855763,
-0.3576605916,
0.2578844726,
-0.1157855764,
-0.2481210232,
-0.3615207374,
-0.4986770749,
0.009720346,
0.5020694733,
-0.4701167047,
0.4511071444,
0.6240414381,
-0.0057039321,
-0.4423443675,
-0.3716260195,
-0.023095781,
-0.3126718998,
-0.3436869979,
0.4199334681,
0.1641140878,
-0.1682448089,
0.2569903433,
-0.0746755749,
-0.1006801426,
0.0730109289,
0.5115055442,
0.5724413991,
-0.1964526027,
0.1977486014,
-0.1469959021,
-0.0338388421,
0.0169874262,
-0.3401121795,
0.4272536039,
-0.25557217,
-0.2528437972,
0.1135173365,
0.5418354273,
0.4964652658,
-0.4429973364,
0.4418887198,
0.5186105967,
0.0099710599,
-0.2508243918,
-0.0669771805,
-0.0656407699,
-0.4317828119,
0.7004722953,
-0.307177037,
-0.8804014921,
0.2165222168,
0.1220567301,
0.0764015019,
0.5539317131,
0.3522195816,
-0.464887023,
0.9075297713,
1.317894578,
0.327557683,
0.7226895094,
-0.280267626,
0.218106702,
-0.9834519625,
-0.6470977664,
-0.203851983,
-0.198229745,
-0.3385720849,
-0.6790017486,
0.3523923159,
0.096729137,
0.2955725789,
0.5211892724,
-0.5985656381,
0.4978905618,
0.3856292963,
-0.0403671339,
-0.0173462108,
0.07455118,
-0.1674370915,
-0.1720151752,
-0.5604183674,
-0.7999644279,
0.9338880777,
0.4268454313,
0.681165576,
-0.0228016302,
0.3569315374,
0.1987932622,
-0.0545761324,
-0.8990297318,
0.6165781617,
-0.0817298442,
-0.3495814204,
-0.3923195004,
0.0921812728,
-0.8690556288,
0.4733663201,
-0.2395760864,
-1.0082697868,
0.4465431273,
0.1127847135,
-0.4089252651,
0.160368681,
-0.5837569833,
0.7058930397,
-0.5445569754,
-0.0481705852,
-0.1268259734,
-0.5279489756,
0.1847658604,
0.2279661745,
0.0970146582,
-0.0627049804,
-0.1906628609,
0.7342938781,
-0.3070811331,
0.8256247044,
0.0696129799,
0.1665022075,
0.5068042278,
0.1420201361,
0.1675508469,
-0.1796294451,
0.43514961,
0.1920753419,
0.2671738565,
-0.2086127847,
-0.8135704398,
0.1212086827,
-0.5897833705,
-0.6295693517,
-0.2823603153,
-0.2448462993,
-0.1492407918,
0.0409095511,
0.3397738934,
0.4800978899,
-0.2123028785,
0.0546871163,
0.7372490168,
-0.4402350783,
0.4800052643,
0.405464828,
-0.7373176217,
-0.0728727207,
1.1603244543,
-0.0987102315,
0.3135908842,
0.4899505973,
0.1475471556,
-0.4479930401,
-0.6045147777,
-0.4114516973,
-0.0207278356,
-0.8272371292,
0.0404230393,
-0.7083194852,
-0.3590536118,
0.0305186957,
0.1788883656,
-0.2848240733,
-0.3709664345,
-0.4375510514,
-0.4279958606,
0.5480006933,
0.8339532018,
0.1771323532,
0.2118510306,
-0.6354727149,
0.2082901001,
0.5304968953,
0.097577773,
0.1004205942,
-0.4263943434,
-0.2314849347,
-0.2710648775,
-0.2950970531,
-0.9613411427,
0.5434681773,
0.2817713022,
0.8095829487,
0.5942264199,
-0.0517987125,
0.6686252952,
-0.6271700859,
0.9831933975,
0.2150703669,
-0.8908073306,
0.8045687675,
0.0241886806,
-0.2305657864,
0.269056052,
0.2740205526,
-0.3704479635,
-0.4327259362,
-0.6672670245,
-0.9394824505,
0.8111619949,
0.1962298453,
0.4172149599,
-0.0436711051,
-0.0309171733,
0.1890054792,
0.1163264886,
-0.8889302611,
-0.0585021824,
-0.5141226053,
0.0936888754,
0.1534446478,
-0.6212091446,
-0.1326476634,
-0.0826334059,
0.0021650097,
-0.0730282441,
0.5199198127,
0.3944881558,
-0.236338377,
0.3645232916,
0.1353675276,
0.6834958196,
0.5183668137,
-0.1677437276,
0.4340751171,
-0.0532565862,
-0.376645714,
-0.1728285402,
-0.304176122,
-0.1852060109,
0.3362239599,
0.7445473671,
1.3625386953,
0.3029692471,
-1.0109075308,
0.7521221638,
-0.0638722479,
0.0096355993,
-0.1195988059,
0.3647645414,
-0.1803557426,
0.3484859169,
0.3446219862,
0.0660747513,
0.239599362,
-0.7419756651,
0.2962587774,
0.4695824087,
-0.7255654931,
-0.435288012,
0.4346032441,
0.116096057,
-0.2765209377,
0.2998114824,
-0.1475066841,
-0.9755161405,
0.5246409774,
0.2423395067,
0.6047247052,
0.28823632,
0.386407584,
0.1959700584,
0.3185337484,
0.1991260201,
0.1562490761,
-0.2580784857,
-0.6466084719,
-0.267986685,
-0.5552622676,
-0.3566769958,
-0.015899647,
-0.8075101376,
0.4214595556,
-0.3576129377,
-0.1691093892,
-0.1124337167,
-0.3622804284,
-0.6833651662,
-0.0759603903,
0.5195396543,
0.7691910863,
-0.7820872664,
0.8097949624,
0.4854774177,
-0.5907726288,
-0.9373636246,
-0.101539433,
-0.165460825,
-0.935465157,
0.9859218001,
0.0920524374,
-0.0866094902,
-0.4457064867,
-0.6999195814,
-1.0726259947,
1.0201917887,
0.4011263251,
-0.4457055628,
-0.1489463747,
-0.2147623599,
0.5594963431,
-0.5520886779,
0.3334213197,
0.3100613654,
0.253318578,
0.2715859711,
-1.0390905142,
-0.1219078898,
-0.1316414922,
0.3013555408,
-0.0910805017,
-0.5596377254,
0.8819303513,
-0.5639259815,
-0.644715786,
0.0107176816,
0.6583039761,
0.0039746859,
0.1543651819,
0.4285315573,
-0.0745783597,
0.6613207459,
0.0351881348,
1.3890454769,
0.1567738056,
0.3022795618,
1.2655923367,
-0.1021442935,
1.0345615149,
0.6763145924,
-0.1639822423,
0.4451641142,
0.6862139702,
-0.0672593713,
0.8484917879,
0.11571116,
0.2504951358,
-0.2435709685,
-0.1386033744,
-0.2535955608,
0.8241111636,
0.2918367386,
-0.573720634,
-0.2648979425,
0.1827339977,
-0.3842420876,
-0.1317152232,
-0.1267854422,
0.8532640934,
0.0948684439,
-0.4939028621,
0.4165867269,
-0.1958628148,
0.3555021286,
-0.5744031072,
-0.4982117414,
-0.0174988043,
-0.336325109,
0.0139382537,
-1.1209559441,
0.3533269763,
0.0254337974,
-0.3138380945,
-0.4467579722,
0.680521667,
-0.493814677,
-0.2700751126,
0.336835593,
0.303468287,
0.457547605,
0.00338744,
-0.5009832382,
0.3012045324,
0.3473744988,
-0.0121942218,
0.2963382602,
0.5447206497,
-0.4937118292,
0.7282458544,
0.4366721213,
0.3091562092,
0.1245898679,
-0.1833513379,
0.8839046359,
-0.5757842064,
-0.4744333923,
-0.9117369056,
0.5566028357,
-0.3612331152,
-0.2680000067,
0.6473840475,
0.394593209,
0.7802457213,
-0.1245252714,
0.6487367749,
-0.0979336724,
0.3534913063,
-0.8850528002,
0.5164546371,
-0.4891381562,
0.2735076845,
-0.2094852626,
-0.9216848612,
0.3296279013,
0.8112462163,
-0.2437347919,
-0.4407202005,
0.9231091142,
0.3272742629,
0.1365971714,
-0.1661906838,
0.4917448759,
0.0213052444,
0.3437665999,
0.4649156034,
1.1415747404,
-0.0012045705,
0.8058307171,
-0.0424765088,
-0.1023875102,
-0.2071543187,
-0.9275084734,
-0.8301777244,
-0.8850790858,
-0.2775227726,
-0.0357111543,
-0.422465682,
0.5627773404,
1.0322999954,
-0.5144395828,
-0.0637096018,
0.382545948,
0.2721047401,
-0.1341417432,
-0.215268895,
0.580578804,
-0.106453456,
-0.5509925485,
0.338178128,
0.6186873913,
0.3070587814,
-0.456079632,
-0.0191642921,
0.532741487,
0.0477093011,
0.7597988248,
0.2230847925,
-1.0416878462,
-0.5972675681,
0.0580251589,
-0.0794826001,
0.2584398687,
1.0373445749,
-1.0527871847,
0.7395339012,
0.0956510454,
0.4525540471,
0.6732997894,
-0.2607025504,
0.6150269508,
-0.5835520029,
0.3318940997,
0.2350666672,
0.3191067278,
0.2596897185,
-0.3143841922,
0.2495281249,
0.143368423,
0.2183620334,
-0.8198671341,
0.3223459721,
-1.4547659159,
-0.3245868087,
1.1699284315,
-0.3150158525,
-0.4135378003,
0.0935181156,
-0.6987599134,
-0.2595354915,
-0.3064139187,
0.510193944,
0.8283976316,
-0.1642873585,
-0.4832643569,
-0.7468460798,
0.6592797041,
0.0397076309,
-0.4921463132,
0.0260814931,
0.3271525502,
0.1293350905,
0.1648577452,
0.5848715305,
-0.2176139206,
0.044658564,
-0.0153848007,
-0.0956492871,
-0.2593508065,
-0.3540910482,
-0.0227245223,
0.0163863022,
0.2273655087,
-0.4779722691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16437v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16437v2
|
Reasoning Runtime Behavior of a Program with LLM: How Far Are We?
| 2024-03-25T05:37:16 | 2024-07-03T04:10:43 |
Junkai Chen, Zhiyuan Pan, Xing Hu, Zhenhao Li, Ge Li, Xin Xia
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Large language models for code (i.e., code LLMs) have shown strong code
understanding and generation capabilities. To evaluate the capabilities of code
LLMs in various aspects, many benchmarks have been proposed (e.g., HumanEval
and ClassEval). Code reasoning is one of the most essential abilities of code
LLMs, but existing benchmarks for code reasoning are not sufficient. Typically,
they focus on predicting the input and output of a program, ignoring the
evaluation of the intermediate behavior during program execution, as well as
the logical consistency (e.g., the model should not give the correct output if
the prediction of execution path is wrong) when performing the reasoning. To
address these problems, in this paper, we propose a framework, namely REval,
for evaluating code reasoning abilities and consistency of code LLMs with
program execution. We utilize existing code benchmarks and adapt them to new
benchmarks within our framework. A large-scale empirical study is conducted and
most LLMs show unsatisfactory performance on both Runtime Behavior Reasoning
(i.e., an average accuracy of 44.4%) and Incremental Consistency Evaluation
(i.e., an average IC score of 10.3). Evaluation results of current code LLMs
reflect the urgent need for the community to strengthen the code reasoning
capability of code LLMs. Our code, data, and \newname leaderboard are available
at https://r-eval.github.io.
|
[
-0.2000014037,
-0.4984548092,
0.588850081,
0.3347242773,
-0.1148339137,
0.254648,
-0.4626125693,
-0.4820595384,
-0.1963412613,
0.5420102477,
-0.4085562527,
-0.7081408501,
-0.3460323811,
0.0764004141,
-0.2128036171,
0.7646231651,
-0.2838875949,
0.0152871963,
-0.6353702545,
-0.2363067865,
-0.5350418091,
-0.48694098,
-0.2386958003,
-0.6092487574,
0.2060774565,
0.4595698714,
0.5202339292,
0.4807604551,
0.5562224984,
0.2485474646,
0.1455352008,
0.0888206661,
-0.5111210942,
0.3909105957,
-0.2643917203,
-0.5850529671,
-0.3903746903,
-0.081061244,
0.4843366742,
0.479401201,
-0.2070602179,
0.3026298285,
-0.1503656656,
0.7668014169,
-0.479650557,
0.0779243261,
-0.514361918,
-0.0958233327,
0.1392316669,
-0.4472190142,
-0.3573690951,
-0.7149935961,
-0.332088232,
-0.2059401572,
-0.1058084667,
-0.0444721058,
0.4876011014,
0.2528629303,
-0.0218588691,
-0.3743815422,
-0.7316833138,
0.8342066407,
-0.8815177679,
0.5791705847,
0.0999034122,
0.2091118395,
-0.3776446581,
-0.6270702481,
-0.4291383624,
-0.484218359,
0.2448329479,
-0.0436197631,
-0.1130816042,
-0.0046678758,
0.450607568,
0.3602053523,
-0.5805258155,
0.0486868918,
-0.1112325341,
-0.0466047786,
0.5617581606,
0.4748111367,
-0.0361913107,
0.2256153226,
-0.4649804235,
0.0534175485,
-0.7446508408,
0.1073546484,
0.3968064189,
-0.0111825084,
-0.0391060524,
0.5464606881,
-0.2533697486,
0.4435883164,
-0.1820533723,
-0.0228182822,
0.2613699436,
-0.4139475524,
-0.2892590165,
-0.2963171601,
0.5317621231,
0.4968337119,
0.5452702641,
-0.297449708,
-0.4726452231,
0.338819474,
0.4782919288,
-0.8003890514,
-0.2432676554,
0.2641668916,
-0.5307662487,
-0.2820824087,
0.0542210713,
-0.6622213721,
-0.3924382627,
-0.4311010242,
0.1354447156,
-0.5041100979,
-0.2321825325,
0.170516476,
0.2326677144,
0.505089283,
0.3712015152,
-0.3649238348,
0.1650684327,
0.9862316847,
0.5510863662,
-0.3987977803,
-0.3450095356,
-0.5561943054,
-0.1716891676,
-0.4877287745,
0.6080549359,
-0.7463450432,
-0.318897754,
-0.0972377285,
-0.1525720656,
-0.0907805264,
-0.6793851852,
0.2412089109,
-0.7892045379,
-0.3512242734,
-0.0042741108,
-0.7385126948,
-0.1003693566,
0.491768539,
-0.2250981331,
0.9139725566,
-0.0443856232,
-0.446088165,
0.1891003996,
-0.3244045377,
-0.5047792792,
-0.233702302,
-0.3887155652,
-0.3564234972,
0.1990202963,
-0.0086399391,
0.0447481982,
-0.2958420813,
0.4078787267,
-0.4243832231,
-0.7776855826,
0.6068116426,
-0.5986773372,
0.4805198014,
0.3077681959,
-0.2716204226,
0.1949243248,
-0.5472512245,
0.5202580094,
-0.1083232239,
-0.5454602838,
0.1553734392,
0.0248244926,
-0.4587840438,
0.0919052288,
0.4685507417,
-0.2478371412,
0.4715052843,
-0.1602383554,
0.2404973954,
0.8478959799,
0.0662915856,
0.2984106839,
-0.3839423656,
0.9367082119,
-0.1370560974,
0.3109176159,
-0.1897026449,
-0.3538133204,
-0.6410188079,
-0.0302429367,
0.0155398138,
0.5693218112,
-0.4851249456,
0.2586917281,
-0.1437004507,
-0.4236853421,
-0.0561296679,
0.2173487842,
0.7688621283,
0.2650724947,
0.2526632249,
-0.0806423277,
-0.6425802708,
-0.7361676097,
-0.5863867402,
-0.634026587,
0.2393038273,
0.1909217536,
0.5071324706,
-0.4312353134,
0.7952106595,
-0.4204620123,
0.3358676434,
-0.3484241068,
0.0379560217,
0.5303900838,
0.5021511912,
0.0053305831,
-0.4391850531,
0.0044389274,
-0.1608202606,
-0.8181126118,
-0.4615544975,
-0.1011224911,
-0.1577498764,
0.3563666642,
0.7847225666,
-0.1194234565,
0.4801592529,
0.6126003861,
-0.1607319564,
0.7786143422,
-0.1843982339,
0.2468583882,
-0.5541961193,
0.2259909511,
-0.1660698801,
-0.2398341447,
-0.247554183,
0.3359167874,
-0.0325725339,
0.08669056,
-0.181561783,
0.3069002032,
-0.3882947862,
-0.4812348485,
-0.3214134276,
-0.1842337698,
0.1969495416,
0.424513936,
0.1916468143,
1.0063450336,
0.3937771916,
-0.5384935141,
0.450969547,
-0.3326258361,
-0.3887643814,
0.442945987,
-0.746807456,
0.2746036649,
0.3029564619,
0.1714450568,
-0.8050605655,
0.171433866,
0.0567265972,
-0.5156024694,
0.2660370469,
-0.3342406154,
-0.4507788718,
-0.2864997685,
-0.2449358702,
0.4625683129,
0.5663130283,
-0.560416162,
0.3933929801,
0.0350605845,
0.2061538249,
-0.5605886579,
-0.4934800267,
0.1369600892,
-0.1353083104,
-0.6311658025,
0.0897421315,
-0.287625134,
-0.4865125418,
-0.2017121464,
-0.3464297354,
-0.0146654407,
-0.0095064975,
0.4415611923,
0.3103094697,
-0.283867687,
0.1341853142,
-0.3423591852,
-0.2382047921,
0.3014360666,
-0.1205983907,
0.3690723479,
-0.7681455016,
-0.76080513,
-0.140387699,
-0.0881168544,
0.656657517,
-0.1073918268,
0.4600223005,
0.1421303898,
-0.1293398142,
-0.1556228846,
-0.602837503,
-0.0126983915,
-0.4163105786,
0.2522858381,
-0.4506616592,
-0.6662454605,
0.7386344075,
-0.2637935579,
0.0228150636,
-0.1321558505,
0.5512007475,
0.1045264006,
0.8047503233,
0.4261752069,
0.1118584871,
0.1863375753,
-0.1458279639,
0.1677806377,
-0.8795407414,
-0.4708731472,
-0.3460404873,
-0.1135344803,
-0.4413484037,
-0.6363708973,
0.0820467919,
0.4923225641,
-0.2932769656,
0.3814311028,
-0.5187520385,
0.4929584563,
0.31479913,
-0.1214501858,
0.5218267441,
-0.3339099288,
-0.2004812509,
0.1482739449,
-0.4633929729,
-0.7930911779,
0.9178475142,
0.4542548656,
1.207316041,
0.1195588261,
0.7877911329,
0.3421711326,
0.4933466017,
-0.634308219,
0.6940746903,
0.2955052257,
-0.2312918752,
-0.0562249161,
-0.572815299,
-0.6086344719,
0.0329832658,
0.2249626368,
-0.6378256083,
0.0659841448,
0.0710994303,
-0.0359680876,
0.19596003,
-0.5844239593,
0.7818180919,
-0.3107222021,
-0.6527338624,
-0.1318981349,
-0.4280894697,
0.456273675,
0.0858027339,
0.1094179526,
-0.10756322,
-0.0616708212,
0.3739361763,
-0.6349039674,
0.6162424088,
-0.0487048402,
-0.3183807433,
0.4314166307,
0.3371526599,
0.5452666879,
0.4694292545,
-0.3402278125,
0.3638243079,
0.1768064201,
-0.0243527927,
-0.5875375867,
0.9319269657,
-0.4241959453,
-0.552788794,
-0.4362723231,
-0.4326124191,
-0.2394173741,
-0.0274980031,
0.1113278568,
0.4814727306,
-0.0609333292,
-0.011264869,
0.6379640102,
-0.3460047245,
0.2942885458,
0.6960830688,
-0.6748400927,
-0.1994256824,
0.7214792371,
-0.2897227705,
0.1954795718,
0.1643083543,
0.0344902687,
-0.3943693638,
-0.6265046,
-0.3874037564,
0.0505471118,
-0.7333191633,
-0.3780989945,
-0.1232047603,
-0.1800396144,
-0.1356605887,
-0.2274577022,
-0.5486882329,
-0.0597921908,
-0.0536312275,
0.2514313161,
0.3145673275,
0.7700562477,
0.1078046784,
-0.3864421248,
-0.705945909,
0.1666413248,
-0.0395413637,
0.7415166497,
-0.068787612,
-0.6281799078,
-0.1668598056,
-0.0489701591,
-0.1666579694,
-0.5581995249,
-0.0702675432,
-0.1651174575,
0.5877312422,
0.1690439582,
0.1610350758,
0.5967091918,
-0.26387012,
0.4877441227,
0.1104201302,
-0.9060735106,
0.5930117369,
-0.1316054314,
0.4038835168,
0.6846633554,
-0.2753202319,
-0.3951554596,
-0.4950094819,
-0.4252062142,
-0.3300700188,
0.4570127428,
0.2000207305,
-0.0121070808,
-0.182714954,
0.3705592155,
0.0179745331,
0.1586346626,
-0.611902535,
0.0381463058,
-0.0217307266,
0.075458318,
0.2588876188,
-0.0410141982,
0.0529569238,
-0.2216559947,
0.4168384671,
-0.2272521555,
0.2173039019,
-0.0383467078,
-0.065985091,
-0.1352644563,
0.2186035514,
0.7734288573,
1.1045706272,
-0.1794206649,
0.2683934867,
0.0902906805,
-0.3694472015,
0.1485403627,
-0.1244857684,
0.1022885889,
-0.3248805404,
0.5978237987,
0.2765228748,
0.1872809827,
-1.1243606806,
0.683087945,
-0.0837762877,
-0.1127805859,
-0.5015653372,
0.386436373,
0.2409807444,
0.5535387397,
0.0805344656,
0.1849954873,
-0.1787264496,
-0.4814625382,
0.2566834092,
0.4100204408,
-0.1997387707,
-0.2694967687,
0.4389345944,
0.1541846097,
-0.2914072573,
0.7990729213,
-0.2651177943,
-0.6384233236,
0.9233911633,
0.5638798475,
0.7494640946,
0.0579178892,
-0.1024221703,
0.2862788439,
0.3636188805,
-0.0201335959,
0.5368145704,
0.1111933142,
-0.7166852355,
-0.6259343624,
-0.7597292066,
-0.4487333894,
0.0494654961,
-0.5264607668,
0.3062974811,
-0.6126582026,
0.0408618934,
-0.5492886901,
-0.030461723,
-0.4226744771,
0.0666470379,
0.0767097026,
0.9549057484,
-0.4896405935,
0.906006217,
0.8835445642,
-0.3768295944,
-0.7131963968,
0.1143205538,
-0.2494949698,
-0.8837223053,
0.7254985571,
0.2053370029,
-0.4475845098,
-0.3224476874,
-0.4800798297,
-0.6616503596,
0.9147723317,
0.4320507348,
-0.6956914663,
0.3322698474,
-0.0643153861,
0.5809102654,
-0.4944509864,
0.2214077115,
0.5105807185,
0.5014774799,
0.2419815511,
-0.5537173152,
0.0637135804,
-0.2658022046,
0.1541558206,
0.247619018,
-0.4434594512,
0.6584314704,
-0.6808860898,
-0.0443338379,
0.2107094675,
0.5011802912,
0.7351860404,
0.598970294,
0.2052678764,
0.613319695,
0.5503907204,
0.0030668322,
1.0638164282,
-0.5295836329,
0.2841984332,
1.1499027014,
-0.5020546913,
0.7638915181,
0.4934652746,
-0.451284349,
0.6539108157,
0.3256627917,
0.0322842002,
0.2514503002,
0.620080471,
-0.2048019171,
-0.4803766906,
0.1417541206,
-0.4155124724,
0.3940205872,
0.1566309333,
-0.3397721648,
0.0250137858,
-0.4179557562,
-0.0577113852,
0.3786045611,
-0.0812776461,
0.362649709,
0.1253530681,
-0.7981096506,
0.7238386869,
0.1043920368,
0.4361069202,
-0.2835360467,
-0.4337552786,
-0.5262113214,
0.4041392803,
-0.3200155795,
-0.9865342379,
0.4917343855,
0.1693638861,
-0.312356323,
-0.0455786102,
0.7019138932,
-0.1013973728,
-0.2447939515,
0.3171648681,
0.4762127399,
0.3376743793,
0.2030730993,
-0.7084773779,
0.5190423727,
0.0638937429,
-0.2343794256,
0.3277613223,
0.3711770475,
-0.0295712501,
0.8817923069,
0.6327325702,
0.0155105572,
0.0178594738,
0.2577727139,
0.9012296796,
-0.5248365998,
-0.116627492,
-0.9932847023,
0.0570503771,
0.1066305861,
-0.2756201327,
0.7051022053,
0.7803742886,
0.589554131,
0.1416066438,
0.5460233092,
0.0984971151,
0.2601336241,
-0.6866232157,
0.142758444,
-0.2490331829,
0.9278179407,
-0.2397581488,
-1.2087535858,
-0.1267625988,
0.650624752,
-0.4247616529,
0.4053656459,
0.633431077,
0.9517489076,
0.0761636123,
0.1410547197,
0.2823336422,
0.040034499,
0.4047473371,
0.7667101026,
1.1180598736,
-0.1243952066,
0.5610778928,
-0.0282131825,
-0.2478538156,
-0.2636169493,
-1.2290425301,
-0.5916062593,
0.0738182664,
-0.4628258646,
-0.5962756276,
0.1855713427,
0.7308608294,
0.3821010888,
-0.5755004883,
-0.3659178317,
-0.6631612182,
0.3244106174,
-0.295442313,
-0.2811942995,
-0.0495407917,
-0.4882108867,
-0.3552737236,
0.4595001638,
0.4419800639,
-0.4775497019,
-0.4104284942,
-0.6216487288,
-0.0358121358,
0.1631037444,
0.3326848745,
0.4761192501,
-0.6756520867,
-0.4973874986,
0.0600032695,
-0.284989208,
0.0408247262,
0.892034173,
-0.856833756,
0.3687504828,
0.5757587552,
0.5557642579,
0.1567286998,
0.2006101906,
0.5855002999,
-0.5164008737,
-0.4345678985,
0.2787049115,
0.3260002136,
0.1212194264,
-0.1715915948,
0.769780457,
0.1930717528,
-0.8600274324,
-0.7962378263,
0.3910645247,
-0.7055981755,
-0.2308989912,
1.3172078133,
-0.3181641698,
0.0032800809,
-0.0842122585,
0.1112710834,
0.1485914141,
-0.302142024,
0.4043253064,
0.4867982268,
-0.5965614915,
-0.2609583139,
-0.4564006925,
0.1629889756,
0.2511607409,
-0.7284870148,
0.4579724967,
0.6483451724,
0.4286381304,
0.0168622769,
0.6228418946,
-0.4035360217,
0.2654221952,
-0.0424821042,
0.3261788785,
-0.243415758,
-0.2802772522,
-0.3666496873,
-0.0789484382,
0.3838043809,
-0.0895148292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16435v1
|
InstUPR : Instruction-based Unsupervised Passage Reranking with Large Language Models
| 2024-03-25T05:31:22 | 2024-03-25T05:31:22 |
Chao-Wei Huang, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This paper introduces InstUPR, an unsupervised passage reranking method based
on large language models (LLMs). Different from existing approaches that rely
on extensive training with query-document pairs or retrieval-specific
instructions, our method leverages the instruction-following capabilities of
instruction-tuned LLMs for passage reranking without any additional
fine-tuning. To achieve this, we introduce a soft score aggregation technique
and employ pairwise reranking for unsupervised passage reranking. Experiments
on the BEIR benchmark demonstrate that InstUPR outperforms unsupervised
baselines as well as an instruction-tuned reranker, highlighting its
effectiveness and superiority. Source code to reproduce all experiments is
open-sourced at https://github.com/MiuLab/InstUPR
|
[
-0.0000872882,
-0.6321029663,
0.4852676392,
0.3220145106,
-0.3865113258,
0.4543488622,
-0.5509380698,
0.0528100058,
-0.0147710843,
0.6054869294,
-0.1481401473,
-0.7643378377,
-0.4928879142,
-0.066660136,
-0.6247751117,
0.9711788893,
0.498492837,
0.4587199688,
-0.5924837589,
-0.0821324661,
-0.1795766354,
-0.4027397335,
-0.3910479248,
-0.5330193043,
0.3724841177,
0.9627053738,
0.360924989,
0.4298171699,
0.7207556367,
0.30902794,
-0.421510011,
0.0652230754,
-0.4667578638,
0.2481613904,
-0.3033957779,
-0.469162643,
-0.1810680628,
-0.1798695028,
1.0923749208,
0.875807941,
-0.3494784832,
0.1233205274,
0.4620388746,
0.5793650746,
-0.5589243174,
0.0014011215,
-0.647827208,
-0.1224755123,
-0.4483473897,
-0.2436254621,
-0.9401869774,
-0.6034502387,
-0.0101602767,
-0.228073284,
0.2800163925,
0.0993003845,
0.2514948845,
0.1300088614,
-0.567096591,
0.0117746126,
-0.1402941793,
0.8761931658,
-0.669937849,
0.6637657285,
0.060588602,
0.0967582315,
-0.3175539374,
-1.0403192043,
-0.2225891352,
-0.3565017879,
0.1035403833,
-0.0934628472,
0.210058108,
0.0578291751,
-0.1483482718,
0.4323124588,
-0.6161390543,
0.4373311996,
-0.3279093206,
0.089737609,
0.7027877569,
0.0365109034,
0.1850804538,
0.1649819165,
-0.4335820973,
-0.1946474463,
-1.000325799,
-0.0091026174,
0.2162463069,
0.3746687174,
-0.0927466229,
0.6283049583,
-0.252694279,
0.7198787332,
0.1032676399,
0.1950691789,
0.4643566906,
0.0312318727,
-0.0999457389,
0.1999470592,
0.7095741034,
0.236832723,
0.3105300963,
-0.628197372,
-0.4041339755,
-0.3647593856,
0.1793233752,
-0.9465053678,
-0.3206969798,
-0.1924868375,
-0.4122828841,
-0.2595428526,
0.2702231705,
-1.1097574234,
-0.0765600801,
-0.1652660966,
0.4529949129,
-0.245836392,
-0.0724880174,
-0.0701551586,
-0.0036072638,
0.6368317008,
0.1085233614,
-0.9023053646,
0.4959515333,
1.1213707924,
0.9141377211,
-0.4159682691,
-0.4968096018,
-0.8899543881,
0.0583042502,
-0.2851767242,
0.8171418309,
-1.0116893053,
-0.5555175543,
0.207357049,
0.1492057145,
-0.0957877561,
-0.5988489389,
0.7126221061,
-0.6974260807,
0.1313837022,
0.0135076437,
-1.0902032852,
-0.0327384956,
-0.0881844386,
-0.2941529751,
1.0351266861,
0.1242404804,
-0.3881105185,
0.0032144361,
-0.656462431,
-0.6298489571,
0.2762734592,
-0.008793503,
-0.25095281,
0.2619131505,
0.2354957312,
0.4178124666,
-0.1566064954,
0.022891935,
-0.2927984893,
-0.7685133219,
0.3416455388,
-0.4559984803,
0.7675095201,
0.1614372283,
-0.1135874316,
0.2098672837,
-0.2934489548,
0.3898327947,
-0.0437840931,
-0.5926895738,
-0.5298008323,
-0.1344559193,
-0.0329524949,
-0.2394889146,
0.3294822574,
-0.7743737102,
0.657377243,
-0.592492342,
0.4763540626,
0.8497347236,
0.1329379231,
0.6867771149,
0.099137038,
0.4746410847,
-0.2837462127,
0.2400787175,
0.1169835478,
-0.4555602968,
-0.823109448,
-0.0213315319,
0.7539407611,
0.6102811694,
-0.6519055367,
0.3069845438,
-0.4435910881,
-0.5745337605,
-0.6898701191,
0.4174454808,
0.9165489078,
0.3701773584,
0.4916977882,
-0.0338608772,
0.0468284972,
-0.6967131495,
-0.205188483,
0.1536705047,
-0.0104365265,
-0.2441984713,
0.4719624519,
-0.1491227299,
0.3251899183,
-0.9338160753,
-0.4375979304,
-0.5098562241,
0.1150957122,
0.2953264415,
0.610861659,
0.1900317818,
-0.7360697985,
-0.6203640699,
-0.3483158648,
-0.4190383852,
-0.1868839115,
0.4368641675,
-0.2452677637,
0.2563974261,
1.2038762569,
-0.2970450521,
0.138360545,
0.400529176,
-0.2434571981,
0.1791472882,
-0.5047352314,
-0.0295328107,
-0.984534204,
-0.393096298,
0.1338222027,
-0.2627115548,
-0.1748620719,
0.5029127598,
0.2614558041,
-0.0495953709,
-0.4713506699,
0.3888461292,
-0.6865245104,
-0.1791868657,
-0.1911399364,
0.0877360925,
-0.2615896761,
0.5276609659,
-0.1339597851,
0.9232557416,
0.5576887727,
-0.5376802087,
0.2318201214,
0.3335059285,
-0.7586071491,
0.5112774372,
-0.7539036274,
0.4474983513,
-0.0277627762,
0.2147182524,
-1.0442730188,
0.0190075673,
-0.0595962889,
-0.3248224556,
0.8522285223,
-0.6370998025,
-0.5025279522,
0.0465128496,
-0.3689512014,
0.4862885475,
0.4574742615,
-0.7864999771,
0.1285122484,
0.4797734916,
-0.324557811,
-0.4266393185,
-0.6904448867,
0.0155403381,
-0.1829845011,
-0.2811248302,
0.571662724,
-0.153038159,
-0.2782126665,
0.0160291214,
0.1978861243,
-0.1160443127,
-0.3140166104,
0.1268229187,
-0.0826953426,
-0.1896767765,
0.3269635737,
0.2049866468,
-0.1826211661,
0.0949973688,
-0.1017500609,
0.4844304919,
-0.3169591725,
-0.5321087241,
-0.2946867347,
0.534219861,
0.5666896701,
-0.5529015064,
0.5226908922,
0.2766575813,
-0.0456445888,
-0.4895962477,
-0.3523167074,
-0.2330309153,
-0.5052533746,
0.3231014311,
-0.1838347614,
-0.7835938931,
0.0025201947,
-0.1699366271,
0.2954170704,
0.1598112434,
0.3170199692,
-0.2979109287,
1.0329694748,
0.7337852716,
-0.3303804398,
0.6043342352,
-0.3458226025,
-0.1136561409,
-1.0931856632,
-0.3497283459,
-0.6685966253,
-0.4702281356,
-0.8002943993,
-0.3600618839,
0.5998411179,
-0.234319374,
-0.4771102071,
-0.3158394992,
-0.6334704161,
0.8805823326,
1.0800427198,
0.316819936,
0.2668514848,
0.0290777124,
-0.0943271369,
0.0174118076,
-0.7536732554,
-0.1821081042,
1.4262132645,
-0.0118468124,
1.0737452507,
0.4874660075,
0.8125753403,
0.5371769667,
0.579482615,
-0.7062250376,
0.7733343244,
-0.536575377,
-0.1826408654,
-0.4739153683,
-0.4424473941,
-0.9861390591,
0.4503857791,
-0.0401061922,
-0.5829095244,
-0.0806417987,
-0.1773380786,
-0.1447230279,
0.2407031059,
-0.8151142001,
0.7574691176,
-0.3493637443,
-0.3115574121,
-0.3632349968,
-0.6748825312,
0.3374037743,
0.2039372176,
-0.1408501863,
0.4216766059,
-0.1117385626,
0.8666514158,
-0.5529987812,
0.7101207376,
-0.1038476899,
0.2132842839,
0.1649517119,
-0.0115538212,
0.4778475165,
0.1740242839,
-0.1065937281,
0.0173373129,
-0.1881406307,
-0.2461960018,
-0.6430271864,
1.2093131542,
-0.6265318394,
-0.6097418666,
-0.5420167446,
-0.2163888663,
-0.2710103393,
0.1201616749,
0.4146291316,
0.8360479474,
-0.0353616104,
0.7144341469,
1.1934224367,
-0.0771852881,
0.4402085245,
0.7703942657,
-0.1978235096,
-0.5538731217,
0.9906891584,
0.1620048881,
0.164204523,
0.9866490364,
0.2847513556,
-0.9527294636,
-0.7216710448,
-0.3551110029,
0.4283508956,
-0.6545937061,
-0.3424702287,
-0.1994298398,
-0.3362917602,
-0.4778641462,
-0.2129432857,
-0.2964437902,
-0.060960114,
-0.1099487469,
-0.2008718699,
0.3776013553,
0.737277627,
-0.0602050945,
0.2785202563,
-0.6029378176,
0.209459126,
0.2787632048,
0.6801003814,
-0.096291922,
-1.0583195686,
-0.2428697348,
-0.1133005396,
-0.2102408707,
-0.8499797583,
0.110076718,
0.2315423638,
0.7548633218,
0.3479510546,
0.2441596836,
0.5198065639,
-0.4623295963,
0.3401364982,
-0.1935289055,
-0.77477777,
0.3806577027,
0.0066108056,
0.3523227572,
0.7558149099,
0.0032782273,
-0.2511970699,
-0.3432936072,
-0.4292466044,
-0.9232056737,
0.4167883098,
-0.3001728952,
0.2832427323,
0.1823175102,
0.3942265511,
-0.13994582,
0.0172576327,
-0.5830501914,
-0.2358416766,
0.0583814345,
-0.3922083676,
-0.4391986132,
-0.6175534725,
0.2067388147,
-0.3970755339,
0.8214835525,
0.0366826057,
-0.0700783357,
0.1075388342,
-0.3014121056,
0.0253319796,
0.4977448583,
0.4004985392,
0.5843371153,
-0.4034117758,
-0.0009120912,
0.1659435779,
-0.5678426027,
0.2014246136,
0.1125730127,
-0.498439908,
-0.0616760068,
0.3577401042,
0.2411442846,
0.7017967105,
-0.6123762727,
0.7096309662,
-0.0119756116,
-0.0684585571,
-0.5051925182,
0.0588838235,
0.0388588086,
0.4309495687,
0.218840763,
-0.6654133201,
0.1145172119,
-0.3484148383,
0.3053151071,
0.5320683718,
-0.5942963362,
-0.018735446,
0.6631402969,
0.5168191195,
-0.5422673225,
1.1306532621,
-0.2668168247,
-0.2971539199,
0.286894232,
0.6621150374,
0.8408125043,
-0.4728218019,
0.2051379085,
0.068180941,
0.5330862999,
-0.1748188883,
0.3021259904,
-0.0163537208,
-0.3762928545,
-0.4510701001,
-0.4971928298,
-0.7159054875,
0.3462125361,
-0.8437076807,
0.076257132,
-0.2896642685,
0.3389080763,
-0.2159973979,
0.1333361119,
-0.395160079,
0.0885996744,
-0.0931379274,
1.2357455492,
-0.5791406631,
0.8804745078,
0.888266027,
-0.4011074305,
-0.5012174249,
0.399630487,
-0.2014318258,
-0.5748144388,
0.443752259,
0.0638167709,
-0.2981769145,
0.3706670403,
-0.6265516281,
-0.7898731828,
0.8362525702,
0.4107272029,
-0.7251009345,
0.2457050979,
-0.0004842558,
0.3197132647,
-0.1551693231,
0.1152950376,
0.2822520435,
0.2429025322,
-0.0598054118,
-0.4635979533,
-0.2010786384,
-0.0974396393,
-0.2328239977,
0.4589538574,
-0.8269684911,
0.5777306557,
-0.401530236,
0.0139515642,
0.1660583913,
1.049013257,
0.1283988357,
0.3886760473,
0.5916593075,
0.7648413181,
0.6217554212,
-0.0190398786,
0.7777505517,
-0.1553008407,
0.0882320702,
1.3337692022,
-0.2449545711,
1.2207086086,
0.4092725515,
-0.0793816969,
0.673499763,
0.4393817186,
0.1354479641,
0.7109006643,
0.3435075879,
-0.3681264222,
-0.424066931,
-0.0778551176,
-0.4626191258,
0.7632802725,
0.3421927094,
-0.3827164173,
-0.2139004618,
-0.152691558,
0.0544725396,
0.2931242883,
-0.6309112906,
0.7727068067,
0.2715718746,
-0.7453047037,
0.35784325,
0.0868251175,
0.755907774,
-0.6792348623,
-0.2900908291,
-0.5461981893,
0.5557656884,
0.0662296489,
-1.2637947798,
-0.2038218677,
0.1085004508,
0.0256437436,
-0.3288164437,
0.4038570523,
-0.5579875112,
-0.7681086659,
0.1884210706,
0.5543742776,
0.3055377305,
-0.1303241998,
-0.4911614656,
-0.2815521359,
-0.0144622866,
-0.3354605436,
0.6557998061,
0.5822492242,
-0.319115907,
0.9220474362,
0.613509357,
-0.1897145361,
-0.0272706039,
0.4889160991,
0.7400022149,
-0.718313694,
-0.5245491266,
-0.8001682162,
0.1446974725,
-0.0648516342,
-0.4832926989,
0.6508989334,
0.8967675567,
1.0139284134,
0.0710916072,
0.4954347014,
0.549036026,
0.7296233773,
-0.7102289796,
0.702436626,
-0.7581309676,
0.2392580509,
-0.2162596285,
-0.8799654245,
-0.2606216371,
0.1944507658,
-0.1388150454,
-0.0202735104,
0.3747567236,
1.0429135561,
-0.3632895052,
-0.3920351863,
0.1446955353,
0.1049769521,
0.0290780403,
0.5612155199,
0.8766434789,
0.119206734,
0.7311483026,
-0.2795648277,
-0.1954910457,
-0.5421237946,
-0.6846520901,
-0.6993181705,
-0.5071480274,
-0.3486266434,
-0.0866317078,
0.2086714953,
0.7828249335,
0.4194253385,
-0.6336502433,
-0.2948299348,
0.0888535827,
0.5432778597,
-0.3757179379,
-0.2673995495,
0.596931994,
-0.4121144414,
-0.8327595592,
0.8008559942,
0.0929666013,
-0.0433459468,
-0.4001089633,
-0.073504135,
-0.1954860836,
-0.0855597258,
0.4934597313,
0.2773813605,
-0.4825351238,
-0.0464018993,
-0.123274222,
-0.1375365257,
-0.1405975372,
0.7358395457,
-0.6432813406,
0.1324894875,
0.5873010159,
0.4540210068,
0.3777733147,
0.2151470929,
0.3585242033,
-0.9343428612,
-0.000848874,
0.2157536894,
0.4749250114,
0.4306124747,
-0.1894181669,
0.6609223485,
0.0392808653,
-0.7757656574,
-1.0091241598,
-0.0004522542,
-0.9142695069,
-0.3314131796,
1.3353009224,
0.0386234745,
-0.0625577942,
-0.001213491,
0.1072700769,
0.1250876039,
-0.5788766742,
0.6665709019,
0.1501194686,
0.0665721521,
-0.3036170006,
-0.401446104,
0.1829256117,
0.280403614,
-0.6407135129,
0.003138579,
0.2838447094,
0.5231795907,
-0.3433243334,
0.5229692459,
-0.0663286746,
-0.0085304044,
-0.3024339378,
-0.0437457636,
-0.1888340265,
-0.4168936312,
-0.4156766534,
0.2096509188,
0.1523416787,
-0.6222442389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16432v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16432v3
|
$\textit{LinkPrompt}$: Natural and Universal Adversarial Attacks on Prompt-based Language Models
| 2024-03-25T05:27:35 | 2024-04-09T13:05:49 |
Yue Xu, Wenjie Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Prompt-based learning is a new language model training paradigm that adapts
the Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) to downstream tasks, which revitalizes
the performance benchmarks across various natural language processing (NLP)
tasks. Instead of using a fixed prompt template to fine-tune the model, some
research demonstrates the effectiveness of searching for the prompt via
optimization. Such prompt optimization process of prompt-based learning on PLMs
also gives insight into generating adversarial prompts to mislead the model,
raising concerns about the adversarial vulnerability of this paradigm. Recent
studies have shown that universal adversarial triggers (UATs) can be generated
to alter not only the predictions of the target PLMs but also the prediction of
corresponding Prompt-based Fine-tuning Models (PFMs) under the prompt-based
learning paradigm. However, UATs found in previous works are often unreadable
tokens or characters and can be easily distinguished from natural texts with
adaptive defenses. In this work, we consider the naturalness of the UATs and
develop $\textit{LinkPrompt}$, an adversarial attack algorithm to generate UATs
by a gradient-based beam search algorithm that not only effectively attacks the
target PLMs and PFMs but also maintains the naturalness among the trigger
tokens. Extensive results demonstrate the effectiveness of
$\textit{LinkPrompt}$, as well as the transferability of UATs generated by
$\textit{LinkPrompt}$ to open-sourced Large Language Model (LLM) Llama2 and
API-accessed LLM GPT-3.5-turbo. The resource is available at
$\href{https://github.com/SavannahXu79/LinkPrompt}{https://github.com/SavannahXu79/LinkPrompt}$.
|
[
-0.4707469642,
-1.191670537,
0.1591619849,
-0.0817061737,
-0.2621260881,
-0.2324665189,
-0.0158157982,
-0.2847628295,
-0.1297859102,
0.2849187851,
-0.7680828571,
-0.4020854533,
-0.4744527936,
0.2820555568,
-0.3501196504,
1.1481630802,
0.1785617322,
0.1482577771,
0.4500685036,
-0.2915747464,
-0.5333417058,
-0.3626848757,
-1.0323503017,
0.1419440657,
0.4809168875,
-0.1882158518,
0.921889782,
0.3894290626,
0.5840058327,
0.2550877929,
-0.1021835729,
-0.024574006,
-0.3408325613,
0.3773003519,
-0.2098502368,
-0.3527363241,
-0.1566053182,
0.2116441131,
0.5880762339,
0.5274215937,
0.1623663902,
-0.0548686907,
0.2098776102,
0.5551943779,
-0.4524935186,
-0.2019629627,
-0.9984295368,
-0.0592442974,
-0.2294265479,
-0.3822915256,
-0.4800705612,
-0.358525902,
-0.059902247,
-0.4882084131,
0.4989225864,
0.3389626741,
0.7787893414,
0.3815224469,
-0.4332612753,
-0.4994235039,
-0.135840565,
0.3932540417,
-0.404653132,
0.1292237639,
-0.0057700761,
0.2422696203,
-0.7850942016,
-0.6264870763,
-0.3493739069,
-0.4926981032,
0.0309987124,
-0.1243231148,
-0.6645852327,
0.2121009678,
0.4511432648,
0.2254959494,
-0.9361505508,
0.2008414119,
-0.1204119101,
-0.3284460902,
0.2663087547,
0.1679521799,
0.692546308,
-0.3036048114,
-0.6860306263,
0.1541619152,
-1.1449856758,
0.3543549776,
0.5389276147,
0.5466972589,
-0.1369584501,
0.2241103649,
-0.1762943268,
0.9280145764,
0.0896581858,
0.3239601254,
-0.2419232875,
-0.3071989715,
-0.2475803047,
-0.0478850752,
1.1786973476,
-0.0803502053,
0.2610433698,
-0.3377159536,
-0.1441148818,
0.0675649419,
0.3158115149,
-0.4888269305,
-0.2892385721,
-0.0875984058,
-0.2840571702,
-0.3843511343,
0.0917751715,
-0.4897643626,
-0.3863784671,
-0.1565431952,
0.5147645473,
-0.5355520844,
0.0499479435,
-0.0379686393,
0.1598221958,
-0.1005644873,
0.2091414481,
-0.7000849247,
-0.0250726808,
0.5789695978,
0.8577660322,
0.0201483015,
-0.3923527002,
-1.0515247583,
-0.2538365722,
-0.1007100493,
0.7413749695,
-0.3762549758,
-0.4273796976,
0.2297040969,
0.017985316,
-0.2640816867,
-0.2873761654,
0.7226798534,
-0.7619503736,
0.2995043397,
-0.4379761815,
-0.3287466168,
-0.0260187443,
0.1237310022,
-0.9165139794,
0.8374616504,
-0.1622058749,
-0.9364082217,
0.1219711453,
-0.849368751,
-0.500372529,
-0.0017177057,
-0.0017054718,
-0.1789709926,
0.0238016844,
0.2654203773,
0.3334872723,
-0.4879087806,
0.2639783919,
-0.3406336308,
-0.3172402084,
0.3601491451,
-0.6995604038,
1.232399106,
0.3631897569,
-0.5768706203,
0.3831535876,
-0.6129170656,
-0.3403905928,
0.2818656564,
-0.2124720216,
-0.2552307546,
-0.2433120757,
-0.396902442,
0.1452940106,
0.1989092082,
-0.359389782,
0.4273730516,
-0.5984172225,
0.0880616382,
0.8519726992,
0.2717047632,
0.4001022875,
-0.1847587824,
0.5961185694,
-0.2687631845,
0.4940437675,
-0.358289212,
-0.6386905313,
-0.5124932528,
-0.1865115911,
-0.0476715676,
0.5198076367,
-1.0593628883,
0.3078592122,
0.320762217,
-0.3031412661,
-0.4161483645,
0.1617028862,
0.6227092147,
0.6044415832,
0.4013785422,
0.0570751876,
-0.4923105836,
-0.457732141,
-0.54371804,
-0.2017838806,
-0.0830964521,
-0.1835428327,
0.3133346736,
-0.0088051781,
0.7145601511,
-0.3290608525,
-0.0306875687,
-0.0681530535,
0.4598470926,
0.2262200564,
0.2817307711,
0.7511816621,
-0.7830345631,
-0.3826554716,
-0.4645573795,
-0.7517278194,
-0.3274614811,
-0.1953496039,
-0.0475915894,
0.1754032522,
0.4760454595,
-0.6758541465,
0.3612125516,
0.4356150627,
-0.7007309794,
0.8259778619,
-0.0182761606,
0.1940409541,
-1.1194865704,
0.1195228025,
0.261251539,
0.085984543,
-0.5950051546,
0.5734341145,
-0.0384204872,
-0.3586121202,
-0.6809348464,
0.6799384952,
-0.4655110538,
0.1968240738,
-0.3219901323,
0.0744035468,
-0.1999962926,
0.4196560979,
-0.407404542,
1.0457617044,
0.7093453407,
-0.7634450793,
0.8171072006,
0.1682032347,
0.1348380893,
0.8105064034,
-0.5877711773,
0.0961760208,
0.0841888115,
0.1903465688,
-0.9235147834,
0.1814903021,
0.5554252863,
-0.661026597,
0.3577629924,
-0.0420974866,
-0.4197628498,
-0.1961903721,
-0.5643601418,
0.0236762054,
0.4059959054,
-0.8278676271,
0.1161665246,
-0.0974571407,
-0.1854852885,
-0.6277260184,
-0.0565565303,
0.4174535573,
-0.2071047276,
-0.5020499825,
0.0063876794,
-0.1985467821,
-0.1091218516,
0.0577509478,
0.1079878882,
0.2278210521,
0.407296896,
0.2581677735,
0.4221968651,
-0.2424192727,
0.0285258275,
-0.2554630935,
-0.3084476888,
0.3398869634,
-0.2111387849,
0.5619266629,
-0.1736858189,
-0.6192190051,
-0.4848840535,
0.2041230798,
0.3736983836,
-0.1668965816,
0.6410109401,
0.8632051945,
-0.2348766774,
-0.3235963881,
-0.3076768816,
-0.3712946177,
-0.5076921582,
0.2230258137,
-0.3819506168,
-0.8778134584,
0.5677238107,
-0.1276243776,
-0.1326504946,
0.6419616342,
0.4035901725,
0.059105102,
0.9664121866,
0.3012242019,
-0.3235647082,
0.4426914752,
-0.1940942556,
0.0538177229,
-0.9263033271,
-0.2380785048,
-0.7221640348,
-0.1149274856,
-0.4379202425,
-0.1441780627,
0.3362672627,
0.1907889396,
-0.3939055204,
0.5087890029,
-0.2530282438,
0.2688052654,
0.9129608274,
-0.0799074024,
0.101166904,
0.0869291052,
-0.5528925061,
-0.0806248635,
-0.7141411304,
-0.2378887385,
1.1626061201,
0.1125039235,
0.7270390987,
0.0801924914,
0.4229359031,
0.5703572631,
-0.0040751561,
-0.5141301155,
0.6205155849,
-0.0997448042,
-0.480766207,
-0.1015846208,
-0.5242227912,
-1.0997502804,
-0.129281804,
-0.2124965042,
-0.7818776369,
-0.0479490794,
0.0036163488,
-0.2472762018,
0.6722096801,
-0.4217344224,
0.800306201,
-0.2240279019,
-0.3777870834,
0.0803073645,
-0.6937428713,
0.248357743,
-0.0812505782,
0.0623355024,
0.0392762609,
0.1781445891,
0.5763991475,
-0.1634751856,
0.9453865886,
-0.2135898322,
-0.0803679973,
0.3564778566,
0.4506513178,
0.8995162249,
0.0692952052,
0.0038498293,
0.0194537565,
-0.5006503463,
-0.4893656075,
-0.6769813895,
0.8024989963,
-0.5094889998,
-0.7431636453,
-0.4021092951,
-0.5067280531,
-0.1074832231,
0.0179257765,
0.5366182923,
0.6804743409,
-0.3669311702,
-0.0111473231,
0.8030628562,
-0.3187790513,
0.6080338955,
0.7088186741,
0.2006197572,
-0.4381706119,
0.9076504707,
-0.3101335466,
0.303060323,
0.380179435,
-0.0043350267,
-0.4767494202,
-0.659805119,
-0.4265261292,
0.068736881,
-0.7533650994,
-0.4852548242,
-0.2921232581,
-0.1614435613,
-0.4469420612,
-0.3723532856,
-0.0037143703,
-0.0304278098,
-0.5465646982,
0.1502505988,
0.4080169499,
0.6967068315,
-0.1462765783,
0.2984639108,
-0.8152035475,
0.4947328269,
0.2763068378,
0.18492724,
-0.3097952008,
-0.5625906587,
-0.1106748283,
0.0404351987,
-0.4322930276,
-1.144970417,
0.2342475951,
-0.0249721073,
0.7634950876,
0.5769762397,
0.4323026836,
0.0964577869,
-0.2402476966,
0.8336433172,
0.4421217144,
-0.7326572537,
0.6976712346,
-0.4684906304,
0.2998066545,
0.4937529266,
0.5962309837,
-0.3545688689,
-0.4689486623,
-0.658968389,
-0.5582865477,
0.698749423,
0.1644923389,
-0.0676589534,
-0.1488003731,
0.3306057453,
-0.0720631257,
-0.031269405,
-0.7305567861,
-0.5459071994,
-0.0871093497,
-0.3200838864,
0.1762607247,
-0.2809572518,
-0.0259006396,
-0.0043593058,
0.6997537613,
-0.0870191976,
0.1461782157,
0.0511417724,
-0.1606676877,
-0.1750600487,
0.3602177203,
0.3013188839,
0.1800301522,
-0.1064997911,
0.1848731637,
0.1558117568,
-0.4780212343,
0.343406111,
0.2885204554,
-0.3732657135,
-0.0057766172,
0.5274073482,
1.0533795357,
0.4426420331,
-0.4326621294,
0.4362280071,
-0.1225889474,
-0.0118775042,
0.1527023464,
0.2766853571,
-0.328864038,
0.2544037104,
0.4769283533,
0.3192027211,
0.21641846,
-0.4296375215,
0.3161784708,
0.7786406875,
-0.6041085124,
-0.56204772,
0.8770633936,
0.3248656392,
-0.4669939578,
0.3189257681,
-0.5946709514,
-0.7360807657,
0.4713906944,
0.7166997194,
1.1187193394,
-0.5127785206,
0.3428654373,
0.3170362711,
0.4583332241,
0.1947402805,
-0.0066788769,
0.1085416898,
-0.3776077926,
-0.1920541525,
-0.617991209,
-0.1951203942,
0.2575791478,
-0.5123311877,
0.3890628815,
-0.587413609,
0.0570742115,
-0.1609029174,
0.081441395,
-0.4459991157,
0.1546648741,
0.003852508,
0.7953822017,
-0.966244936,
0.7859163284,
0.8072269559,
-0.5758820176,
-0.7077633739,
0.156883806,
0.4393121302,
-0.8234147429,
0.8612625599,
-0.1307816952,
-0.0733590424,
0.1235259771,
-0.2660747766,
-0.683562994,
0.7211399674,
0.7055453658,
-0.2262541205,
-0.2446348071,
0.1218076348,
0.238158524,
-0.1254594624,
0.071863085,
0.3901242912,
0.1969403625,
0.1203274876,
-0.7175734639,
0.510168016,
-0.4074586034,
-0.1843422204,
0.3085721135,
-0.2941589355,
0.9445055723,
-0.2399558425,
-0.2837115824,
0.0513665266,
0.3125474751,
0.2289847881,
0.270945251,
0.2628026307,
0.6545194387,
0.3870292306,
-0.0978346914,
1.0923366547,
-0.3755447865,
0.3267203867,
0.8528933525,
0.053481672,
0.4991986156,
0.219069466,
-0.4250301123,
0.241333887,
0.5391669273,
-0.0696054399,
0.4620820284,
0.0613066368,
-0.4411184192,
0.0945079699,
-0.2034520209,
-0.5587841272,
0.2570262849,
0.0728351846,
-0.1957218647,
-0.4695050716,
0.0745401233,
0.3139449954,
0.2077627033,
-0.2949672043,
0.770255208,
0.0234499816,
-0.4375833869,
0.8021850586,
-0.0499187447,
0.868077457,
-0.8806676865,
0.1488331854,
-0.1673318446,
-0.1882631034,
0.0338681191,
-0.4121719003,
0.0893846378,
0.2244796753,
0.0074478034,
0.109212935,
0.7965737581,
-0.01897889,
-0.3194904327,
0.3649302125,
0.1862107217,
-0.2659612894,
-0.3965827823,
-1.0453081131,
0.0086269109,
0.1550530344,
-0.4225208163,
0.4902196527,
0.3916678429,
0.1721441597,
0.6319061518,
0.9736619592,
0.4173656106,
0.0187015571,
0.0339088924,
0.846660912,
-0.576918602,
-0.5034322143,
-1.0298470259,
0.2342120707,
0.0228019245,
-0.3412974477,
0.853054285,
0.3646396101,
0.5843193531,
0.0440982915,
0.6607449055,
0.1139409021,
0.362172395,
-0.9121109247,
0.743080914,
-0.3996679485,
0.4268583655,
-0.3505567908,
-0.7496373057,
-0.282803148,
0.0506739803,
-0.3103371859,
-0.0493778586,
0.9939219952,
0.7636088133,
0.1188112348,
0.1135177165,
0.2333311737,
0.0608342141,
0.4104857445,
0.6567373872,
0.6846746206,
-0.3526974022,
0.6326697469,
0.0096046655,
-0.1129129454,
-0.3617949188,
-0.778985858,
-0.9500434399,
-0.6980794668,
-0.3186789453,
-0.2785035074,
0.3821861148,
0.9272967577,
0.2623973787,
-0.8469385505,
0.1904145777,
-0.3634542823,
0.0376605131,
0.1748497784,
-0.2282851934,
0.590909183,
-0.7313911319,
-0.462064296,
0.6087670326,
0.1675394028,
0.2305535972,
-0.2183264345,
-0.200411737,
-0.3794467449,
-0.0868017226,
0.2108575255,
0.6190798879,
-0.8090248108,
-0.0775750801,
-0.0628232434,
-0.1075357422,
-0.300034225,
0.7957986593,
-0.8147792816,
0.3555819094,
0.3610683978,
0.7456418276,
-0.3288975656,
-0.1111962572,
0.6186072826,
-0.7544142008,
0.4348469675,
-0.0318536162,
0.6220477819,
0.334077239,
-0.5859465599,
0.3413534164,
0.6042959094,
-0.2724610567,
-0.7961878181,
0.5796613097,
-0.6992796659,
-0.5503552556,
1.1206724644,
-0.3408566117,
-0.1361680478,
-0.0577824563,
-0.4306558967,
0.5706015229,
-0.3580997586,
0.7372925282,
0.1921062917,
0.1390455663,
0.176323697,
-0.5413858891,
0.7534769773,
0.3498106897,
-0.6039546728,
-0.1085473448,
0.416277647,
0.0548673272,
-0.0669753999,
0.170729965,
0.1529436857,
0.4827605784,
0.0969766453,
-0.1158662289,
-0.5682368875,
-0.3729364276,
-0.6185705066,
0.4650705457,
0.0657009557,
-0.291618973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16396v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16396v1
|
Is There a One-Model-Fits-All Approach to Information Extraction? Revisiting Task Definition Biases
| 2024-03-25T03:19:20 | 2024-03-25T03:19:20 |
Wenhao Huang, Qianyu He, Zhixu Li, Jiaqing Liang, Yanghua Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Definition bias is a negative phenomenon that can mislead models. Definition
bias in information extraction appears not only across datasets from different
domains but also within datasets sharing the same domain. We identify two types
of definition bias in IE: bias among information extraction datasets and bias
between information extraction datasets and instruction tuning datasets. To
systematically investigate definition bias, we conduct three probing
experiments to quantitatively analyze it and discover the limitations of
unified information extraction and large language models in solving definition
bias. To mitigate definition bias in information extraction, we propose a
multi-stage framework consisting of definition bias measurement, bias-aware
fine-tuning, and task-specific bias mitigation. Experimental results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework in addressing definition bias.
Resources of this paper can be found at
https://github.com/EZ-hwh/definition-bias
|
[
-0.7133582234,
-1.0266543627,
0.2932469547,
0.1100674197,
-0.1628194004,
-0.3573450446,
-0.0878359005,
-0.4174968898,
0.0797386169,
0.4188062847,
-0.87242347,
-0.1655713171,
-0.8013819456,
-0.0232029781,
-0.5329061151,
1.1799567938,
-0.0712671429,
0.181140095,
-0.1971548945,
-0.0911201909,
-0.6513528228,
-0.1749122739,
-0.2176428586,
-0.3204801977,
0.4422146678,
0.3935486972,
0.4079797864,
1.0338118076,
0.4394661188,
0.0517312028,
0.1483839899,
-0.0897330195,
-0.2923862636,
0.1422259361,
-0.4850939512,
-0.2584490478,
-0.2042869478,
0.4241932034,
0.3643708527,
0.6097220182,
-0.0221621301,
0.8011120558,
0.1103709489,
0.4980273247,
-1.0635896921,
0.0835421979,
-0.8567101359,
-0.0621644184,
-0.3813667893,
-0.2999519706,
-0.2513141334,
-0.1950422972,
0.4897320867,
-0.6884331107,
0.5726246834,
-0.0779631436,
1.020815134,
0.3154929876,
-0.2496636063,
-0.3796603382,
-0.6163789034,
0.8823145628,
-0.5124012828,
0.3552407026,
0.0537427478,
0.2113696039,
0.1962804943,
-0.3551539779,
-0.4994753599,
0.5317049026,
0.142150417,
-0.182246387,
-0.1205252334,
0.0380080193,
0.6290455461,
0.0592413135,
-0.2186530977,
0.0236546025,
-0.516241014,
-0.1183492988,
0.3974241912,
-0.2327583879,
0.1014469191,
-0.2341449857,
-0.4699786007,
0.0398063101,
-0.8967323899,
-0.3156008422,
0.3904803395,
0.4965241551,
0.2337899804,
0.4402785599,
-0.1061665341,
0.5352017879,
0.1945911199,
0.1454967558,
0.0352016352,
-0.3294070959,
-0.5864257812,
-0.0755984038,
0.370339185,
0.1377421916,
0.463608861,
-0.3578064144,
-0.0741816983,
0.0536584705,
0.4799316227,
-0.8085358143,
0.032654006,
0.0804865509,
-0.4990590215,
-0.506243825,
0.2836544812,
-1.2518495321,
-0.7760752439,
-0.5374615192,
0.7906642556,
-0.0113981301,
-0.3983052969,
-0.0721736997,
-0.4511744082,
0.2114664912,
0.0564965345,
-0.6404352188,
0.298504293,
0.4049932361,
0.4295881987,
-0.4004524648,
-0.0370288305,
-0.3087975681,
0.0470900275,
-0.306686908,
0.6400779486,
-0.4960685074,
-0.0591557249,
-0.0264885835,
-0.1570649743,
-0.1413854063,
-0.6563174725,
0.6238510609,
-0.4411552548,
0.2576301694,
-0.6563911438,
-0.533752203,
-0.2967213392,
0.1837557703,
-0.8643049598,
0.9898501039,
0.2079835683,
-1.2074354887,
0.8497654796,
-0.8618275523,
-0.4271702468,
-0.3507132828,
-0.4279468358,
-0.4072884917,
0.0649439991,
0.2233119011,
0.2877536118,
-0.7003049254,
0.3610490561,
-0.2224474698,
-0.2439937294,
-0.1579391062,
-0.3139939606,
0.9952489138,
0.1860726178,
-0.6207670569,
-0.1665248573,
-0.7439889908,
0.15697667,
0.1877818108,
-0.2546323538,
-0.2935925126,
0.1726471037,
0.0185322575,
0.6028724909,
0.1516298652,
-0.6241241097,
0.3666749001,
-0.0764732286,
0.1996396482,
0.888954401,
0.0710631907,
0.4970998168,
-0.1956477314,
0.3505962193,
0.3291090131,
0.0889308974,
-0.0841772705,
0.0278954543,
-0.7629834414,
-0.2820501029,
0.4934505224,
0.5094165206,
-0.3861182928,
0.2661926448,
-0.2231962085,
-0.1438500285,
-0.7619806528,
0.2085287273,
0.3541442156,
0.6646468639,
0.3858826458,
-0.219712168,
-0.9469254017,
-1.1534943581,
-0.685518384,
0.198346585,
-0.2713790536,
0.0404089503,
0.4312104583,
-0.2049015909,
1.1777231693,
-0.2527494431,
-0.4248279333,
-0.1965787709,
0.3266984522,
0.0127052721,
0.3541858792,
0.2436021715,
-1.0161560774,
-0.1297759116,
-0.3359051347,
-0.8294573426,
-0.1771187782,
-0.1149938628,
-0.135699302,
-0.139572531,
0.1947763115,
-0.7109512687,
0.7842479944,
-0.0910784826,
-0.0767521262,
0.6227400899,
0.3762491941,
0.0104432637,
-0.9057994485,
0.1373753548,
0.4276732802,
0.1340226978,
-0.8141688108,
0.3156730235,
0.2382461876,
0.4125512838,
-0.2018237859,
0.2852092087,
-0.4071140885,
-0.1655321121,
-0.2619715929,
0.23715657,
0.4285471737,
0.2982822955,
-0.2258651406,
0.6764208078,
0.6075681448,
-0.9325413108,
0.1729465127,
0.3041138053,
-0.23839055,
0.6091371775,
-0.4332200587,
0.1875234693,
-0.4316543937,
-0.0003883816,
-0.7507824302,
0.0263227597,
0.2761699557,
-0.2747377157,
0.4973220229,
-0.0207529068,
-0.3978783488,
-0.3122624755,
-0.3276431262,
0.2430196702,
0.1355491281,
-0.6395583749,
0.436345309,
0.5719106197,
-0.0080588507,
-0.7857109904,
-0.5186111927,
-0.2718730271,
-0.4952162504,
-0.4693617523,
0.270188421,
-0.0166179836,
-0.5368283391,
-0.3664105535,
-0.7010063529,
-0.3988110423,
0.1644969881,
0.1523023248,
0.3430379033,
-0.0611490458,
0.3742491603,
-0.0371020213,
0.389760673,
0.1972401738,
-0.4361824393,
0.3722546697,
0.5066786408,
-0.2849230766,
-0.3645271957,
0.3610355556,
0.4343927205,
-0.181334272,
0.2841697335,
0.5483545661,
-0.6029539108,
-0.0115099847,
-0.9260523915,
-0.308632493,
-0.351108104,
0.4006418884,
-0.4736245871,
-0.2326888144,
0.328541398,
-0.1878026277,
0.3951245844,
0.5518852472,
0.2102862149,
0.1112738177,
1.1183736324,
1.005956769,
-0.2444311678,
0.4026947021,
-0.0557853244,
0.3139613271,
-0.9915549159,
0.0911179855,
-0.7508710027,
-0.205989942,
-0.4288625717,
0.0682280809,
0.1486548334,
0.2549453378,
-0.1710752845,
0.183315292,
-0.5474109054,
0.2991459966,
0.4842212796,
0.0885830298,
-0.0249713976,
0.1229079515,
0.0015876156,
-0.0921861231,
-0.541133225,
-0.4964511693,
1.5523438454,
0.1739692688,
0.5819657445,
-0.2041390091,
0.4237975478,
0.4038785696,
0.1322247833,
-0.6257407665,
-0.0325545855,
0.2261144966,
-1.1061249971,
-0.3914062679,
-0.2756581903,
-0.5874090791,
0.4011636972,
-0.2939213514,
-1.0676143169,
0.3788084984,
0.0067715277,
-0.0423831604,
0.3575939536,
-0.60090518,
0.8177915812,
0.0958839208,
-0.5799737573,
0.1853880286,
-0.5779516697,
0.339402169,
-0.3716601133,
0.6033224463,
-0.0789083689,
0.4138389826,
1.0573010445,
0.3763880432,
0.5515890121,
-0.3316913843,
-0.0572232604,
0.3689821959,
0.3183447719,
0.5481213331,
-0.2578837276,
-0.3075891733,
0.1594786793,
0.3050349355,
-0.5316823721,
-0.5840672255,
0.1681677401,
-0.5338416696,
-0.4433916509,
-0.0628795475,
-0.4775368273,
-0.1940020621,
0.3878206909,
0.4926566482,
0.2608284354,
-0.3468069434,
-0.2321009338,
0.899379015,
-0.0292731449,
0.2573044896,
0.5443394184,
0.1054660156,
0.3522502482,
0.773558557,
0.168843329,
0.2610687017,
0.1284749806,
0.1442499906,
-0.0109608425,
-0.2119417191,
-0.4230840504,
-0.1676484197,
-0.8269837499,
-0.0998786241,
-0.5214086771,
-0.2346153259,
-0.6041718721,
0.4479911029,
-0.2823157012,
-0.425827086,
-0.375169009,
-0.2206764966,
-0.2405218482,
0.9384366274,
0.0496958904,
0.3298663497,
-0.3956640065,
0.5004092455,
0.0413096026,
0.0649535656,
-0.162764132,
-0.3832880855,
-0.2694455981,
0.2618454695,
-0.5958476663,
-1.0328223705,
0.2908548713,
0.2165887952,
0.5449072123,
0.688831389,
-0.2281088084,
0.5466521978,
-0.3993219137,
0.6862402558,
-0.0226675346,
-1.0143197775,
0.594522953,
-0.1509819329,
0.2031771243,
0.5579310656,
0.5123562217,
-0.4303243458,
0.0408129096,
-0.7470489144,
-0.7434660196,
0.649240911,
-0.0991261527,
-0.1937092245,
0.0016340791,
0.5727496743,
0.5595663786,
0.6303355694,
-0.6858180165,
-0.3638312519,
0.1002784669,
-0.1240924075,
0.2633638978,
-0.3159858286,
-0.2544709742,
-0.1184720248,
0.7183546424,
-0.1177479103,
0.3307524323,
0.2514344454,
-0.5359426737,
-0.4982895553,
0.5493670702,
0.1674708277,
1.2793467045,
-0.0546372794,
0.1491159201,
-0.1203081906,
-0.4495746493,
-0.2177517265,
0.1103014946,
-0.4939069152,
0.1096481159,
0.1479756981,
0.2946150601,
-0.0140464902,
-0.4028632045,
0.6778148413,
0.1500104964,
-0.1800457835,
0.0303779524,
-0.1288184375,
-0.4607521892,
0.0428915471,
0.5401543379,
0.045561552,
0.4659886062,
-0.4252623916,
0.4127861559,
0.717912972,
-0.5919725895,
-0.2528400123,
0.5290725231,
-0.0520021506,
0.1227202341,
0.5273765326,
-0.0938975289,
-0.5280993581,
0.6849193573,
0.4402977228,
0.8105197549,
-0.1257752031,
0.2107821107,
0.3893901408,
0.4275206029,
-0.0762174278,
0.1739094853,
-0.0496684872,
-0.818141818,
-0.3949761689,
-0.4591276348,
0.0911250561,
0.371668011,
-1.0096018314,
0.4349425435,
-0.2396278232,
0.0578460433,
0.4140371978,
-0.0260628741,
-1.0234062672,
0.2178189009,
-0.0463764109,
0.9004418254,
-0.9064136147,
0.7462320924,
0.3411523998,
-0.5967419744,
-0.5430016518,
0.0177702345,
0.2747378945,
-0.5874748826,
0.7077382803,
0.2921555936,
0.3243554235,
-0.1658191085,
-0.7811803222,
-0.9683590531,
0.9448418021,
0.1116524488,
-0.4229782522,
-0.4357080758,
-0.0637682676,
0.0177572165,
-0.6030343175,
0.2042749822,
1.1305238008,
0.5213804841,
-0.2695593834,
-1.0840359926,
0.0796697885,
0.0182179604,
-0.3538588285,
0.2004994601,
0.0505937971,
1.0397875309,
-0.1005498692,
-0.4302814901,
-0.2788055837,
0.0311076604,
-0.3533572853,
0.2449475825,
0.4120386243,
0.4898881912,
0.7610424757,
-0.0208055358,
0.6044954062,
-0.0800585374,
0.2843776941,
1.1341170073,
-0.2958236039,
0.2261496335,
0.72638762,
-0.0299949814,
0.2012500912,
0.7316846251,
0.1210255474,
0.4347048402,
0.4151704609,
0.0226145219,
-0.0365241915,
-0.1270757169,
-0.1787166297,
0.379737258,
0.5389623046,
-0.5150219202,
-0.3854050636,
-0.0943267345,
0.0623616911,
-0.3196330369,
-0.3585704267,
0.867394805,
-0.3326538503,
-0.6888946891,
0.3425297439,
0.028168831,
0.5547429323,
-0.3655908704,
-0.158013925,
0.1671022624,
-0.0570660494,
-0.3070470691,
-0.3033049405,
0.0937674046,
-0.1134405136,
-0.5226088166,
-0.0347870551,
0.8512105346,
-0.3598213792,
-0.2153565735,
0.1339378208,
0.868840158,
-0.0234639235,
-0.490020752,
-0.6028932333,
0.0228836723,
0.2374503016,
-0.1999362856,
0.389172107,
0.2997132838,
-0.0494167432,
0.3712427318,
0.2227473557,
0.2338963151,
0.4447214305,
-0.0612684861,
0.7525709867,
-0.3976165354,
-0.2507840991,
-0.8499367237,
0.2769105434,
-0.2975545228,
-0.1916778833,
0.6331029534,
0.5568200946,
0.8270841241,
0.2142837197,
1.2930487394,
-0.2720949948,
0.7839318514,
-0.1818907112,
0.2263239175,
-0.411783427,
0.1361982524,
-0.5136100054,
-1.1523098946,
0.0480316691,
0.6222925782,
-0.1445364803,
-0.0443823971,
0.5938370824,
0.5140984654,
-0.1676057428,
0.3401812017,
-0.1348471493,
0.1977938116,
0.2391700596,
0.1486465186,
0.3823741078,
-0.6070095301,
0.2444326282,
-0.0956599712,
-0.3712266684,
0.0152566517,
-0.742926538,
-0.6188660264,
-0.5322307348,
-0.2225509286,
-0.2373804152,
0.1710917354,
0.8041660786,
0.8876953721,
-0.6833105683,
-0.0338432342,
-0.1064031497,
0.4887230992,
-0.2609034777,
-0.3300480545,
0.2276151329,
-0.3946806192,
-0.4669213295,
0.127259925,
0.017592635,
-0.172432825,
-0.2691394389,
0.4614101648,
-0.6302213073,
0.2248970717,
0.2806661427,
0.2761655152,
-0.5462284684,
-0.455321312,
-0.1847656369,
0.0014400029,
0.4099836349,
0.976529479,
-0.4759478867,
0.6933649778,
0.1840020716,
0.5862329006,
0.5414710641,
0.1458700299,
0.5118189454,
-1.0039547682,
0.0000861425,
-0.1393442005,
0.0612115711,
0.1534820199,
-0.4770779312,
0.5622220635,
0.0368684791,
-0.4283474684,
-0.5785766244,
0.5570003986,
-0.5296530128,
-0.5008209944,
1.1687499285,
0.1147317439,
-0.1578579247,
-0.056004189,
-0.1446795613,
0.5807353258,
-0.0634218827,
1.116353631,
1.0121021271,
-0.1852611452,
0.1954981536,
-0.9771417379,
0.5588556528,
0.0487208106,
-0.6483666897,
0.2828790843,
0.5263442397,
0.6050961614,
0.3302764893,
0.2730375528,
-0.2573234737,
0.1464706808,
-0.3506106734,
0.5425786376,
0.1844149679,
-0.4583659172,
-0.2507560551,
0.1086965352,
-0.1953248233,
-0.2664493918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16394v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16394v1
|
Skews in the Phenomenon Space Hinder Generalization in Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-03-25T03:18:39 | 2024-03-25T03:18:39 |
Yingshan Chang, Yasi Zhang, Zhiyuan Fang, Yingnian Wu, Yonatan Bisk, Feng Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The literature on text-to-image generation is plagued by issues of faithfully
composing entities with relations. But there lacks a formal understanding of
how entity-relation compositions can be effectively learned. Moreover, the
underlying phenomenon space that meaningfully reflects the problem structure is
not well-defined, leading to an arms race for larger quantities of data in the
hope that generalization emerges out of large-scale pretraining. We hypothesize
that the underlying phenomenological coverage has not been proportionally
scaled up, leading to a skew of the presented phenomenon which harms
generalization. We introduce statistical metrics that quantify both the
linguistic and visual skew of a dataset for relational learning, and show that
generalization failures of text-to-image generation are a direct result of
incomplete or unbalanced phenomenological coverage. We first perform
experiments in a synthetic domain and demonstrate that systematically
controlled metrics are strongly predictive of generalization performance. Then
we move to natural images and show that simple distribution perturbations in
light of our theories boost generalization without enlarging the absolute data
size. This work informs an important direction towards quality-enhancing the
data diversity or balance orthogonal to scaling up the absolute size. Our
discussions point out important open questions on 1) Evaluation of generated
entity-relation compositions, and 2) Better models for reasoning with abstract
relations.
|
[
-0.388253957,
-0.6113430858,
0.6787446737,
0.312743187,
-0.4498358071,
0.0216824301,
-0.0935627371,
-0.4397883713,
0.2447887361,
0.4980089962,
-0.3921448588,
-0.3984603584,
-0.673425734,
-0.1476715505,
-0.3416995406,
1.2218614817,
0.0393249616,
-0.2229087055,
-0.5424157977,
-0.3163938224,
-0.3878260553,
-0.4866096377,
-0.2149766237,
-0.2632047534,
0.4567453265,
0.2589055598,
1.0781680346,
0.7779954076,
0.5774934292,
0.2584792674,
0.1460497826,
0.0884411037,
-0.5734556317,
0.3758223653,
-0.1353099048,
-0.7376608849,
-0.2066688091,
-0.1693508327,
0.8797539473,
1.1850808859,
-0.0786170587,
0.0464907065,
-0.1624562889,
0.9108950496,
-0.6402951479,
-0.0111771515,
-0.7995013595,
0.1191150025,
-0.2244888246,
-0.0281642899,
-0.179969117,
-0.0361936241,
0.4170773625,
-0.9997244477,
0.7004327178,
0.1941723973,
0.8244463205,
0.182814911,
-0.5216001868,
-0.4913097918,
-1.0805184841,
0.7879024744,
-0.3620362282,
0.1670755595,
0.3251528442,
0.128800869,
-0.1240165904,
-0.6173717976,
-0.5159394145,
-0.1002587005,
-0.0375002697,
0.0379671752,
-0.116947107,
-0.0331383161,
0.422670275,
0.5710687637,
-0.4877206683,
-0.2855508327,
-0.4163619876,
-0.0724636838,
0.6142678261,
0.2813084424,
0.4612999558,
0.0036083178,
-0.1492077559,
-0.3739494383,
-0.7566747069,
-0.2085469216,
0.5639196634,
-0.0957278013,
-0.0671457052,
0.7120280266,
0.1128318235,
0.3921263516,
0.2330708057,
0.1588598788,
0.251280427,
-0.3019772768,
-0.1129840091,
-0.3481768072,
0.9217346907,
0.4179008007,
0.3291457295,
-0.2970936894,
-0.0125461165,
0.3033431768,
0.3085092902,
-0.7894440293,
-0.450301677,
-0.0439892188,
-0.2451146841,
-0.2849861085,
0.2271725684,
-0.9308840632,
-0.1490697861,
-0.351323545,
0.2625930607,
-0.3427750468,
-0.3975822926,
-0.2099153399,
-0.3446182609,
-0.1607457995,
0.1053462178,
-0.9245920777,
0.0944936201,
0.3328054547,
0.7125637531,
-0.2856989801,
-0.1463414133,
0.1607664675,
0.2895135581,
-0.807907939,
0.7374880314,
-0.4080299437,
-0.4556958675,
-0.0207914878,
-0.2092797607,
0.1339951903,
-0.6275377274,
-0.0507370196,
-0.2749892175,
0.2440656424,
-0.1910364181,
-0.3638368547,
0.3364703655,
-0.0525606722,
-0.6087021828,
0.8656698465,
0.1431803405,
-1.0025348663,
0.8258360028,
-0.199661687,
-0.5717365742,
-0.0964586139,
-0.5625814199,
-0.7722859383,
0.6133284569,
0.1208610907,
0.3487171531,
-0.2301184088,
0.339879781,
-0.312894851,
-0.2377082407,
0.285389781,
-0.0194043294,
0.253896445,
0.1855119169,
-0.3543682694,
-0.3225359023,
-0.965430975,
-0.0763167366,
0.4240261316,
0.0167994108,
-0.7821315527,
0.2764387727,
-0.1072871089,
0.0533082411,
-0.0901378095,
-0.2702501714,
0.129572615,
-0.4727199078,
0.2342255116,
0.5113556981,
0.2749322951,
1.103369236,
-0.0298667159,
0.3114415705,
0.5697630644,
-0.1101714224,
-0.3676539958,
-0.4371257722,
-0.668448627,
0.0383625254,
0.0859035105,
0.2024549991,
-1.1845171452,
0.0187115446,
-0.5239995122,
-0.3638745546,
-0.2195815593,
0.237737909,
0.3799088001,
0.3667069376,
0.327167958,
-0.6003046036,
-0.1596315652,
-0.9953901172,
-0.4346122742,
-0.1993357241,
-0.3514444232,
0.1931328475,
0.4009074569,
-0.1628653705,
0.8941164017,
-0.5576868057,
-0.292039901,
0.0125059839,
0.3018982708,
-0.0031094465,
0.569052875,
0.8494884968,
-0.8597040772,
-0.4087004066,
-0.0483051129,
-0.8900308609,
0.1234061569,
-0.2809839547,
-0.177450195,
0.162207216,
0.26573053,
-0.8329777718,
0.5903669,
0.2043468505,
-0.2577961087,
0.334076494,
-0.1814506054,
-0.061785873,
-1.0428211689,
-0.2248061448,
0.3910642862,
0.093972154,
-0.7552475929,
0.0367254466,
-0.1448574513,
-0.1507115513,
-0.0228085443,
0.1896917373,
-0.5237869024,
-0.3248656094,
-0.2825793028,
0.0157190375,
-0.0704109445,
0.4358223379,
0.1747308075,
0.4352545142,
0.6601540446,
-0.7026160955,
-0.0310688931,
0.1197097972,
-0.0287413672,
0.9490972757,
-0.6342666149,
0.1176895723,
-0.4772018492,
0.2571384907,
-1.0100679398,
-0.5167259574,
0.2933889627,
-0.4961139858,
0.4014250934,
-0.0436195992,
-0.4843584597,
-0.307025075,
-0.1232765391,
0.5834828019,
0.5742357969,
-0.3512092531,
0.429281652,
0.2444392592,
0.0435042158,
-0.5005598068,
-0.9332226515,
-0.1381698847,
-0.2415873408,
-0.6126044989,
0.2029145509,
0.2521185279,
-0.2928804457,
0.1387149096,
-0.3729237318,
-0.0859518871,
-0.3182904422,
0.4095726311,
0.2323376238,
-0.3454244137,
0.3660291731,
0.238768369,
0.1382006705,
0.4183635116,
-0.5279437304,
0.1612118632,
0.2734827101,
-0.2366163135,
-0.0983599573,
0.3285314739,
0.3872948587,
0.2013460845,
0.7525185347,
0.3040568829,
-0.3394150436,
-0.3245091736,
-0.2767012417,
-0.03789974,
-0.4580702186,
0.4950276613,
-0.2503294647,
-0.6229875684,
0.3791208565,
-0.0618705824,
0.1527504623,
0.694100678,
0.352114439,
-0.437774092,
1.0314654112,
0.679825604,
0.1490939558,
0.3812531233,
-0.4023168683,
0.2140174508,
-0.50311625,
-0.2271420807,
-0.4025529921,
-0.3719160557,
-0.787799716,
-0.2756541669,
0.2368009984,
-0.0339160226,
-0.2595821321,
0.1597898602,
-0.620426476,
0.4063493013,
0.2675951123,
0.1656619161,
0.3476170599,
0.6111850739,
0.0360947624,
-0.4618122578,
-0.6368988156,
-0.2351447791,
1.392142415,
0.1485189945,
0.8426479101,
-0.2112086415,
0.564696312,
0.1701582521,
0.4680149555,
-0.4409303367,
0.3840495646,
-0.1776186079,
-0.5271283388,
-0.3891422153,
-0.763663888,
-0.9946578741,
0.3206837177,
-0.3090513647,
-0.3700846732,
0.5924055576,
0.6443984509,
0.3462974429,
0.2717505097,
-0.6750810742,
0.5055795908,
-0.1208755895,
-0.3400259018,
-0.1083141938,
-0.6866387129,
0.3957159221,
-0.1240934953,
0.3301466703,
0.0116516426,
-0.005813479,
0.4693014324,
-0.4348243475,
0.7595782876,
-0.3157297075,
0.0790926889,
0.2709708512,
0.0560595617,
0.2144196033,
0.10752666,
0.4359670877,
-0.0180792548,
-0.2123504579,
-0.7211838365,
-0.7621005177,
0.4356126785,
-0.9542362094,
-0.3881311715,
-0.1658552289,
-0.6104592681,
-0.4778497219,
-0.0185170956,
0.9843832254,
0.1220255271,
-0.2570329309,
0.1749830246,
0.7912054658,
-0.2295971215,
-0.0692328736,
-0.1121743545,
-0.3275176287,
-0.3765168786,
1.1267826557,
0.235816747,
0.6438413262,
0.124406226,
-0.1249492019,
0.0091327662,
-0.414190203,
-0.32282722,
0.3314289153,
-0.7174701691,
-0.0856406763,
-0.5879203081,
-0.00213585,
-0.1941437721,
0.0351181999,
-0.3054934442,
-0.4843178093,
-0.3925563693,
0.0526109599,
0.0695328414,
0.7857711911,
0.2195501924,
0.6797555685,
-0.145124048,
0.4884664416,
0.1900990605,
0.132226333,
0.2174392641,
-0.4618804455,
-0.2292293906,
0.2045970261,
-0.7299954891,
-0.8380335569,
0.1597353667,
0.5017033815,
0.3012042344,
0.4626755714,
-0.258271277,
0.6203323603,
-0.5104442835,
0.7308661938,
0.6768751144,
-0.6407960653,
0.6367843747,
-0.3449361324,
0.2432114035,
0.2834039927,
0.5014082789,
-0.2496541739,
-0.7971580625,
-0.8705301285,
-1.0170589685,
0.3022474647,
0.3038165867,
0.526301682,
0.0088502532,
0.6743674874,
-0.021555949,
0.3548361063,
-0.8540507555,
-0.3849697113,
-0.7506946921,
-0.1156806797,
-0.1572995633,
-0.1062498689,
0.0757553503,
-0.1182317659,
0.3432666063,
-0.0927915126,
0.3188060224,
0.3710892797,
-0.2316023409,
-0.4883244932,
0.1377807409,
0.3813087344,
0.7068306208,
0.2577369809,
0.1029721498,
-0.2522760928,
-0.7342782021,
0.3217644691,
-0.2658783197,
-0.3459156752,
0.1924999356,
0.4119134545,
0.9566898942,
0.1425366253,
-0.1521960944,
0.4166410267,
0.1887876391,
-0.6278635263,
-0.1156015471,
0.1461551338,
0.0287092477,
-0.054223571,
0.7538285851,
0.1892128438,
0.0919206366,
-0.6754252911,
-0.0400694795,
0.4581164122,
-0.1267949194,
-0.5971185565,
0.7176269889,
-0.1212203354,
0.032906156,
0.6500192285,
-0.0476041175,
-0.1654530466,
0.9440068603,
0.6552688479,
0.4318786263,
-0.093267642,
0.3832300603,
0.3030720651,
0.423984319,
-0.2335803807,
-0.112573646,
0.1468049437,
-0.7889606953,
-0.3101550639,
-0.2939315438,
-0.2542050481,
0.1207177043,
-0.6013854146,
-0.1079144999,
-0.639536202,
-0.5029832125,
0.1236969605,
-0.3237854242,
-0.7809426188,
0.3558164537,
-0.1026316509,
0.3965029418,
-1.0964710712,
0.4837635756,
0.9199362993,
-0.4356453121,
-0.6818512082,
0.2415007204,
-0.3428428769,
-0.4190396667,
0.5870521665,
0.0576759726,
0.3758169711,
-0.2235938758,
-0.8775629401,
-0.6597827673,
0.9390406609,
0.4060927927,
-0.5380477309,
-0.3239428699,
0.6361658573,
0.9376618266,
-0.4692977965,
-0.2373737395,
0.4174310863,
0.2303366214,
0.3604490459,
-0.3170239627,
-0.0778061152,
-0.0855882615,
0.4864517152,
0.394525826,
-0.3644257486,
0.628292501,
-0.2548705935,
-0.3243524134,
-0.0185685549,
0.7441554666,
0.186794728,
0.6858791709,
0.3568300605,
0.7386929989,
0.2951284051,
-0.2280038148,
1.1013940573,
0.2732790411,
0.3355551064,
0.9227277637,
-0.0417852737,
0.3950179219,
0.8001711965,
-0.3366847634,
0.3767556846,
0.4235648513,
-0.1427349448,
0.4746542275,
0.2708262503,
0.0005417924,
-0.0811838433,
0.2090966552,
-0.4100529552,
-0.0247367695,
0.6801865101,
-0.575266242,
-0.0941554084,
0.1404905915,
-0.4018377662,
0.317037493,
-0.340846777,
0.6546574831,
0.2159515619,
-0.5576278567,
0.2007671148,
-0.4716951549,
0.6317673326,
-0.3022731543,
0.0624380596,
-0.3645834923,
-0.0440066867,
-0.3533829451,
-0.7184878588,
0.4094021618,
-0.3549581766,
-0.4806424677,
0.1674716473,
0.8511229753,
-0.4393432736,
-0.6034696698,
-0.0037073116,
0.4675505757,
0.0836147517,
-0.0192590915,
-0.3850967288,
-0.2009806335,
-0.1064367965,
-0.3404262662,
0.5930777788,
0.8729644418,
-0.2651877701,
0.407796979,
0.5715995431,
0.2689737082,
0.2838279307,
-0.2490747869,
0.8277857304,
-0.313398093,
-0.3622713089,
-0.6346083879,
0.424906671,
-0.1509719193,
-0.273580879,
0.3834559321,
0.3550415039,
0.8827676773,
-0.3972340226,
0.7549045682,
-0.0715269148,
0.1746480465,
-0.2777169645,
0.5910693407,
-0.5845725536,
0.1349267513,
-0.4691163003,
-1.2689986229,
-0.3308769464,
0.4949065447,
-0.3868247867,
0.059197247,
0.489962548,
0.4612864852,
-0.2579126358,
-0.2104040384,
0.4031405747,
0.0989402235,
0.1102626473,
0.3469443619,
0.8414831161,
-0.4121230245,
0.5620566607,
-0.236058414,
-0.2256716639,
0.1361518502,
-0.7222223878,
-0.9925285578,
-0.8043392897,
-0.3063735664,
-0.2829940021,
0.1000777781,
0.3749699295,
0.6565585136,
-0.5297895074,
-0.0455117449,
-0.4372896254,
-0.0071157492,
0.1215573028,
-0.2529320419,
0.172120735,
-0.4577165246,
-0.4911943674,
-0.4375562668,
0.2819628417,
0.2821244597,
-0.2090094239,
0.0471351966,
0.3764956892,
0.0344021246,
0.4181485772,
0.442764014,
-0.5174826384,
0.0756654441,
-0.0382964984,
-0.1091924012,
0.2777873576,
1.1078346968,
-0.5521153212,
0.2140276879,
0.2607352138,
0.5569857359,
0.5219062567,
-0.0300758872,
0.6773298383,
-1.098654747,
0.424660027,
0.0728503317,
0.0713006631,
0.3056935966,
-0.5490444899,
0.4270749986,
0.6654331684,
-0.5559604764,
-0.7205187678,
0.397411108,
-0.5601913333,
-0.2485179007,
0.7487821579,
0.0293772742,
-0.1969890893,
0.1726598442,
0.0937642381,
0.1650842577,
-0.2666374147,
0.7725943327,
0.783675909,
-0.0383620262,
-0.089673467,
-0.577555716,
0.4261843562,
0.5888578892,
-0.8006383181,
-0.2179124355,
0.7612499595,
0.4207905531,
0.483841598,
0.4450766742,
-0.1198735684,
0.4328456223,
-0.0102875689,
-0.094027929,
0.372230202,
-0.310713619,
-0.0360935405,
0.1008318886,
-0.0008068722,
0.0654119998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16393v1
|
Concurrent Linguistic Error Detection (CLED) for Large Language Models
| 2024-03-25T03:17:27 | 2024-03-25T03:17:27 |
Jinhua Zhu, Javier Conde, Zhen Gao, Pedro Reviriego, Shanshan Liu, Fabrizio Lombardi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The wide adoption of Large language models (LLMs) makes their dependability a
pressing concern. Detection of errors is the first step to mitigating their
impact on a system and thus, efficient error detection for LLMs is an important
issue. In many settings, the LLM is considered as a black box with no access to
the internal nodes; this prevents the use of many error detection schemes that
need access to the model's internal nodes. An interesting observation is that
the output of LLMs in error-free operation should be valid and normal text.
Therefore, when the text is not valid or differs significantly from normal
text, it is likely that there is an error. Based on this observation we propose
to perform Concurrent Linguistic Error Detection (CLED); this scheme extracts
some linguistic features of the text generated by the LLM and feeds them to a
concurrent classifier that detects errors. Since the proposed error detection
mechanism only relies on the outputs of the model, then it can be used on LLMs
in which there is no access to the internal nodes. The proposed CLED scheme has
been evaluated on the T5 model when used for news summarization and on the
OPUS-MT model when used for translation. In both cases, the same set of
linguistic features has been used for error detection to illustrate the
applicability of the proposed scheme beyond a specific case. The results show
that CLED can detect most of the errors at a low overhead penalty. The use of
the concurrent classifier also enables a trade-off between error detection
effectiveness and its associated overhead, so providing flexibility to a
designer.
|
[
-0.1509000361,
-0.6283234954,
0.6477118731,
0.3633509576,
-0.5666831136,
-0.0831153914,
-0.6267026663,
-0.4330637753,
-0.1338937879,
0.5906426907,
-0.4187519848,
-0.6640717983,
-0.7261751294,
0.2283101976,
-0.5359165072,
0.728315413,
-0.2965235114,
0.0309146531,
-0.1556589305,
-0.4212371111,
-0.7747799158,
-0.7083386183,
-0.576153934,
-0.2185960114,
0.2654013932,
0.4604942203,
0.3047906458,
0.4751265645,
0.3923728764,
0.3113383651,
-0.0223498438,
0.4762327373,
-0.4828723371,
0.2120728791,
-0.2962380946,
-0.5246822238,
-0.4492756128,
-0.3961335123,
0.8590851426,
0.4038400948,
0.0085831657,
-0.0544319376,
0.1877072901,
0.7007752657,
-0.431221962,
0.2936472893,
-0.7753804326,
-0.1113392636,
-0.6567925811,
-0.0252976883,
-0.4609433413,
-0.2504606545,
-0.0438371487,
-0.2729164362,
0.0504327454,
0.0575920045,
0.6394431591,
0.3310485184,
-0.1571024805,
-0.456976831,
-0.591137588,
0.9559285641,
-1.0547276735,
0.362172842,
-0.2549609542,
-0.0403970256,
-0.2813825011,
-0.319757998,
-0.848808527,
-0.0115967197,
-0.2132219821,
0.0289915018,
0.0267704856,
0.1094497889,
0.2263087034,
0.2999308407,
-0.5152462721,
0.4502628148,
-0.0849388242,
-0.1642616987,
0.4883769453,
0.1692215651,
0.4145231545,
0.1012165025,
-0.2398727536,
0.1201834679,
-0.5823863745,
-0.2658839822,
0.075157851,
0.2020498365,
-0.5182435513,
0.3425364494,
-0.1619826257,
0.6633641124,
-0.1461607963,
-0.2624729872,
0.1907938272,
-0.3719527125,
-0.0452965833,
0.1316523552,
0.7503824234,
0.3520954847,
0.5028473139,
-0.0511046089,
-0.602743566,
0.2330614626,
-0.1303952187,
-0.4298447371,
0.0100615071,
0.4473992586,
-0.2415891737,
-0.2255045325,
0.0235003941,
-0.8021261692,
-0.3729026318,
-0.0876699761,
0.0774610862,
-0.3008938432,
-0.3430888057,
0.1666561663,
-0.0236866195,
-0.156745553,
0.3130515218,
-0.6917079091,
0.2112270743,
0.705716908,
0.9764919281,
-0.7433568239,
-0.3371642232,
-0.4874299467,
0.2821490765,
-0.2299355865,
0.7936948538,
-0.2683683336,
-0.2838807702,
-0.038534198,
-0.037241172,
-0.1032764241,
-0.5252346396,
0.5701153278,
-0.3464686275,
-0.2644951642,
-0.1299847066,
-0.8160248995,
-0.2436814606,
0.2207640707,
-0.6895129681,
0.6343007684,
0.0071319044,
-0.9521216154,
0.2819114029,
-0.6953131557,
-0.2894696295,
0.150562495,
-0.2011540979,
-0.7126066685,
0.0998061448,
0.1169595644,
0.2535138428,
-0.1113050133,
0.4616333842,
-0.4808399081,
-0.3996711075,
0.358968854,
-0.4054249823,
0.6521834135,
0.0697019026,
-0.4155538678,
0.0504667237,
-0.8506952524,
0.0832899064,
0.169362396,
-0.5170893073,
-0.4121823311,
0.2518884242,
0.02151208,
-0.0648067519,
0.3410694003,
-0.5741716623,
0.0753967613,
-0.3207431138,
0.1969033778,
0.7030521631,
0.1127848253,
0.3074578941,
-0.4073398411,
0.1553945094,
0.4225402772,
-0.1359256357,
-0.2148183882,
-0.3412105441,
-0.9023836255,
-0.2108757496,
0.3816406727,
0.7467077971,
-0.7594258785,
0.4822453558,
-0.1329406649,
-0.286060065,
-0.1533824056,
0.4651549459,
0.5567317009,
0.1342055351,
-0.0071132998,
-0.2765446305,
-0.740252018,
-0.4703764319,
-0.4500350356,
0.024799088,
0.4239204824,
-0.0145142507,
0.5146454573,
-0.1729187816,
0.9031098485,
-0.2667904794,
-0.318801403,
-0.4181136787,
0.0622924827,
0.3766146302,
0.6344918609,
0.3996645808,
-0.651807189,
-0.5841438174,
0.163121447,
-0.8958272338,
-0.7059234381,
-0.0631171167,
0.1202059016,
0.553622067,
0.3395835459,
-0.5027890801,
0.2281331271,
0.8073084354,
0.1319846362,
0.7492470145,
-0.2013684809,
-0.1188940629,
-0.8308710456,
-0.1259095818,
-0.1186939776,
-0.4588194489,
-0.7661436796,
0.076122947,
0.1125627682,
0.2831573188,
-0.447265625,
0.5767508745,
-0.5636667609,
-0.2399306446,
-0.4673522115,
0.3844332099,
-0.1028456986,
0.3058569729,
0.1874265224,
0.6852759719,
0.4371218085,
-0.6254792809,
0.3053353131,
-0.1157392859,
-0.3342875242,
0.6150295138,
-0.5946121216,
0.1551733613,
-0.2539050579,
0.1246915832,
-0.8384780288,
-0.2539386153,
0.2430664301,
-0.3035329282,
0.2112154961,
0.0101403976,
-0.6804430485,
-0.3043164313,
-0.2252009511,
0.4163618088,
0.2346694469,
-0.6528240442,
0.3285420239,
0.4293745458,
0.0639503822,
-0.5362146497,
-0.718225956,
-0.1520092487,
-0.0581480563,
-0.8241353631,
-0.090389818,
-0.0564229302,
-0.2600278556,
0.1072784588,
-0.157087028,
-0.1571218222,
0.3559021056,
0.1435500085,
0.1374357939,
-0.3191766143,
0.1848234981,
-0.0855125114,
-0.1000733078,
-0.2765361071,
-0.481010586,
0.6452506781,
-0.1224754453,
-0.4844412208,
-0.5860298872,
0.3073852956,
0.7774524689,
-0.3085052669,
0.7259790897,
0.3734853268,
-0.4892828465,
-0.6724225879,
-0.7464248538,
-0.025592776,
-0.4353541732,
0.2916074395,
-0.0651324391,
-0.8725884557,
0.5899834037,
0.1155036986,
0.2105045319,
0.2553537786,
0.7183632851,
0.0141325984,
0.6826047897,
0.724804163,
-0.0830185488,
0.4260110259,
0.1144369245,
0.2078054398,
-0.6183362603,
0.1336655468,
-0.4059708416,
-0.1935917288,
-0.4376469553,
-0.3033446372,
0.553221941,
0.1544192284,
0.1016467512,
0.1384783536,
-0.3776589036,
0.5359782577,
0.526725173,
-0.0014804233,
0.6569435596,
-0.0807301402,
-0.2662031353,
-0.0292580873,
-0.479667455,
-0.3825624287,
0.715360105,
0.2319819778,
0.6743808389,
0.0400516242,
0.8608054519,
0.3225685954,
0.4620672464,
-0.5833072066,
0.6362878084,
-0.4905222356,
-0.3461668491,
-0.2387607992,
-0.4381024241,
-0.4795158505,
0.4088785648,
-0.1227908283,
-0.9040215611,
0.2142923176,
0.3935090601,
-0.1370526552,
0.6994163394,
-0.7705537081,
0.8764983416,
-0.2610193789,
-0.1765330881,
-0.1536491513,
-0.3266498446,
0.8233819008,
-0.4699796736,
0.222742036,
-0.0858721212,
0.0955892727,
0.5755382776,
-0.4853224754,
0.9857569337,
-0.1719969064,
0.0164882522,
0.203938216,
0.1080884039,
0.7486547828,
-0.0395748802,
-0.1013109758,
0.1860626191,
0.006484923,
-0.0895708948,
-0.2068723589,
0.7018849254,
-0.5377557874,
-0.6277046204,
-0.6135712862,
-0.9424404502,
-0.0774235427,
0.4377412498,
0.0622310825,
0.3358199,
0.0938951373,
0.1051429287,
0.4814208746,
-0.3159667253,
0.6169311404,
0.8309662938,
-0.2007649094,
-0.1595399976,
0.8818505406,
0.0673035234,
0.5095914602,
0.188205421,
0.1619234234,
-0.0932523534,
-1.0517724752,
-0.3887069821,
0.5377919078,
-0.7283318639,
-0.1132902727,
-0.5436870456,
-0.312816292,
-0.2003431916,
-0.0007737608,
-0.3658336699,
-0.1215446517,
-0.2520076334,
0.1685428172,
0.0491637103,
0.7542203665,
0.138808012,
0.4292973876,
-1.2378532887,
0.0069005843,
-0.1912620068,
0.3379901052,
0.0037265464,
-0.1889944375,
-0.2239695787,
0.0446228497,
-0.3089914024,
-0.8172002435,
0.424163729,
0.1834736019,
0.5272465348,
0.224202022,
0.168468684,
0.4405201674,
-0.4651098549,
0.622831285,
0.1262024492,
-1.1909002066,
0.2466801107,
-0.219524771,
0.4195540845,
0.2842099965,
0.0297177061,
-0.7499033809,
-0.8152547479,
-0.2633208334,
-0.493819952,
0.8461800814,
-0.0527596027,
-0.3780711591,
-0.1147730201,
0.1137840897,
0.0479295328,
0.352812022,
-0.9693982601,
-0.0158118773,
0.3003802896,
-0.2953341007,
0.2532258928,
-0.4196609855,
0.1521437019,
0.2579077184,
0.6951392889,
-0.0770484209,
-0.0574802086,
0.2572287321,
-0.4155304134,
-0.0885513499,
0.5229940414,
0.6979404688,
0.7576285005,
-0.0229700934,
0.1240933985,
0.3052183986,
-0.271890521,
-0.0775264949,
-0.3274413943,
-0.3873462975,
0.3176263571,
0.1893671602,
0.5880897641,
0.1811607778,
-0.9917408228,
0.6402637959,
0.2944386899,
0.025575934,
-0.3727223873,
-0.197519213,
0.1725899577,
0.2883795798,
-0.0341664888,
0.1105413735,
-0.0706214085,
-0.4102555811,
0.420779258,
0.4130524099,
0.0447353832,
-0.227018863,
0.5040300488,
0.2527765036,
-0.032594569,
0.2910090089,
-0.4768503904,
-0.9429873228,
0.6715111136,
0.7538195848,
0.8206470013,
-0.1492094696,
-0.0134269325,
0.0395281799,
0.2960639,
-0.3669224381,
0.2661153972,
0.4434526265,
-1.0574557781,
-0.4484247565,
-0.6196828485,
-0.5223810673,
0.048132211,
-0.1792978942,
0.5441475511,
-0.5220302939,
0.21562244,
-0.2787924707,
-0.4149517417,
-0.1816434562,
-0.0088234888,
0.3793506026,
0.7347252965,
-0.6119450331,
0.9585700631,
0.4632787108,
0.0921040475,
-0.6550916433,
-0.0049583982,
0.2093173265,
-0.7082089782,
0.7516546845,
0.1650674194,
-0.0523684584,
-0.1598122865,
-0.2932576835,
-0.6498143673,
0.9321204424,
0.2588728666,
-0.9040770531,
0.0049369787,
0.1881121844,
0.3545254767,
-0.4202257991,
0.0679234639,
0.6059032083,
0.5241297483,
-0.1083388776,
-1.1534270048,
0.1201691777,
0.2303843945,
-0.0414790809,
0.512819469,
-0.6583507061,
1.0835843086,
-0.044732634,
-0.5714583397,
0.1351895332,
0.540276885,
0.3356695473,
0.455601573,
0.8997040391,
0.6815233231,
0.9103559852,
-0.2698965669,
0.9460017085,
-0.4697420597,
0.4992430806,
1.0036787987,
-0.4954974949,
0.8707752228,
0.2725330591,
0.0241855104,
0.1941639781,
0.1683318615,
-0.104398407,
0.3480130136,
0.2947126329,
-0.4563608468,
-0.0941903889,
-0.0629151613,
-0.1549714953,
0.1652989835,
0.7119349241,
-0.2207822055,
-0.5208090544,
0.0485217273,
0.1810948253,
0.1248144656,
-0.4375929534,
0.5246698856,
0.3285965323,
-0.6818686724,
0.61041224,
0.084974274,
1.0154038668,
-0.4411495924,
0.020286914,
-0.175970152,
0.5649722219,
-0.4029210508,
-0.6306344271,
0.4886834621,
0.087159574,
-0.2351473272,
0.0229315124,
0.9109768867,
-0.8210317492,
-0.3106994629,
0.3792688549,
0.487616539,
0.1619453728,
0.0645854995,
-0.4562899172,
0.6669598818,
0.0227606241,
0.3058614433,
0.0955668539,
0.4312791824,
-0.2290281057,
0.6412650347,
0.5271558762,
0.332662791,
0.2797771096,
0.0283578634,
0.7907862663,
-0.3821093738,
-0.650893569,
-0.944681704,
0.3242017925,
-0.2825077176,
0.045978345,
0.6186066866,
0.3294383287,
0.9236744642,
-0.1508803517,
1.0308229923,
0.0029737914,
0.6874493957,
-0.7544417381,
0.5722200871,
-0.4696317315,
0.8322425485,
-0.0829178095,
-0.8131565452,
-0.3842067122,
0.1536597013,
-0.3199395835,
-0.2947646379,
1.1682741642,
0.8338041306,
-0.0180476569,
0.1811360121,
0.3536608219,
0.4679549336,
0.3916453123,
0.7020122409,
0.5536736846,
-0.0916601568,
0.5437327027,
-0.2123225182,
-0.222072795,
-0.1308366954,
-0.9398548007,
-0.9899995327,
-0.3175252378,
-0.2898611426,
-0.3435607851,
0.4301996231,
0.9425820112,
0.3390058279,
-1.0595674515,
-0.4296879172,
-0.1268745363,
0.4808146954,
-0.1899144202,
-0.2408609092,
0.0806857198,
-0.6929069161,
-0.9731351733,
0.207402274,
0.3468439877,
-0.0889763832,
-0.1240179092,
0.1174110025,
-0.0567982532,
-0.1407237798,
0.3222012222,
0.2423600256,
-0.731626451,
-0.5597946644,
-0.3265994489,
-0.0670542568,
0.0329293683,
0.9224021435,
-0.1862203032,
0.382484287,
0.7891039252,
0.9147002101,
0.1346841156,
-0.0929422453,
0.6782738566,
-0.8668195605,
0.2799586654,
0.0172045175,
0.6415607333,
0.3274263442,
-0.2636491358,
0.3102037609,
0.7131863832,
-0.6863269806,
-0.8819733262,
0.2251187712,
-1.3406872749,
-0.0716024041,
1.1479762793,
-0.4804580808,
-0.4955151379,
-0.3961888254,
-0.1980769932,
0.0566658378,
-0.4292710423,
0.4165611565,
0.9356186986,
0.2997039557,
-0.3492861092,
-0.6806152463,
0.3400758803,
0.3363445401,
-0.7268532515,
0.1116419435,
0.3467720151,
0.519466579,
0.1963724494,
0.5131770968,
-0.1957163364,
0.3589313924,
-0.3239094317,
0.0850865096,
-0.0210275874,
-0.028837679,
-0.3029713035,
0.0896714032,
0.05380347,
-0.3458891511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16385v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16385v2
|
Synthesize Step-by-Step: Tools, Templates and LLMs as Data Generators for Reasoning-Based Chart VQA
| 2024-03-25T03:02:27 | 2024-03-28T16:45:44 |
Zhuowan Li, Bhavan Jasani, Peng Tang, Shabnam Ghadar
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Understanding data visualizations like charts and plots requires reasoning
about both visual elements and numerics. Although strong in extractive
questions, current chart visual question answering (chart VQA) models suffer on
complex reasoning questions. In this work, we address the lack of reasoning
ability by data augmentation. We leverage Large Language Models (LLMs), which
have shown to have strong reasoning ability, as an automatic data annotator
that generates question-answer annotations for chart images. The key innovation
in our method lies in the Synthesize Step-by-Step strategy: our LLM-based data
generator learns to decompose the complex question into step-by-step
sub-questions (rationales), which are then used to derive the final answer
using external tools, i.e. Python. This step-wise generation procedure is
trained on synthetic data generated using a template-based QA generation
pipeline. Experimental results highlight the significance of the proposed
step-by-step generation. By training with the LLM-augmented data (LAMENDA), we
significantly enhance the chart VQA models, achieving the state-of-the-art
accuracy on the ChartQA and PlotQA datasets. In particular, our approach
improves the accuracy of the previous state-of-the-art approach from 38% to 54%
on the human-written questions in the ChartQA dataset, which needs strong
reasoning. We hope our work underscores the potential of synthetic data and
encourages further exploration of data augmentation using LLMs for
reasoning-heavy tasks.
|
[
-0.4769937694,
-0.8303594589,
0.8097551465,
-0.2172184587,
-0.3303747475,
0.2985015213,
0.2022266537,
-0.4218010306,
0.1315760016,
0.8548261523,
-0.6944102049,
-0.6754243374,
-0.1951031685,
0.138270244,
-0.3753948808,
0.6166256666,
-0.2192914039,
0.1940104216,
-0.3084311485,
-0.0167462938,
-0.5757518411,
-0.4060711861,
-0.5364322066,
-0.1793300062,
0.4703809321,
0.6341951489,
0.6758441329,
0.6574431062,
0.1608385295,
0.2979860306,
0.1697104573,
0.6247655749,
-0.6177192926,
0.4906625748,
-0.0409525633,
-0.4783100784,
-0.5268355012,
-0.1107218266,
0.0922948569,
0.7270562053,
0.4528158903,
0.3978663087,
-0.3124547899,
0.7179014683,
-0.3235551119,
0.692340672,
-0.5374673605,
-0.0749979019,
0.0658028126,
-0.267570883,
-0.3698458076,
-0.4914942682,
-0.0709760785,
-0.8900276423,
0.0263707526,
0.1259884089,
0.5971846581,
0.3073042631,
-0.7850641608,
-0.1573960036,
-0.7139977217,
0.5054276586,
-0.5418341756,
0.2419953644,
0.1773098111,
0.7385041714,
-0.2389959991,
-1.2222862244,
-0.657345593,
-0.1294164956,
0.098323606,
0.2837535739,
0.0177070908,
-0.1942700744,
0.4888061881,
0.2199502289,
-0.4944105446,
-0.0837853551,
-0.6385003328,
-0.1586289704,
0.9884824157,
0.5099973083,
0.4829664528,
-0.4098423123,
-0.2895333767,
-0.3125327528,
-0.9615094662,
0.0032751006,
0.2132923156,
0.2104036659,
0.1584337652,
0.8965673447,
-0.4318448603,
0.5341100693,
0.099240765,
0.0625621676,
0.3047066331,
-0.3710108697,
-0.1209236681,
0.1145179123,
0.653298676,
0.4417447448,
0.3604342937,
0.1727369875,
-0.1973233074,
-0.0520671308,
0.3463784158,
-0.64668715,
-0.5016730428,
0.4547902346,
0.089683108,
-0.3215954304,
-0.1982512623,
-0.3185446858,
-0.7046273947,
-0.6916081905,
0.4627465904,
-0.5234518647,
0.0353079326,
-0.0101046059,
-0.0892978832,
0.2292242795,
0.7275742888,
-0.391361028,
-0.0781023875,
0.6363399625,
0.2466262579,
0.0517966598,
-0.0998076499,
-0.6933487058,
0.2061798424,
-0.82824862,
0.812917769,
-0.2045452148,
-0.1996369213,
-0.1186869815,
0.0144320689,
0.2107269466,
-0.4968670309,
0.4550338686,
-0.5314155817,
0.1665789485,
-0.4203748107,
-0.7238063812,
-0.3392442763,
0.2514127493,
-0.883907795,
0.9391118288,
0.2997927368,
-0.6885409951,
0.3890324831,
-0.4880933166,
-0.3248967528,
0.2671025693,
-0.5098069906,
-0.3390067518,
-0.2706627846,
0.875297308,
0.3339837492,
-0.45674932,
-0.0907874033,
-0.1234590709,
-0.3587923944,
0.493280381,
-0.142430082,
0.7043590546,
0.2209887654,
-0.375644803,
0.4062581062,
-0.7922031879,
0.2739330232,
0.2973500192,
-0.2139002085,
0.067655541,
-0.0756186694,
0.0783754513,
0.1861665696,
0.0666801259,
-0.2753228247,
0.259123981,
-0.3685659766,
0.326798439,
0.6640216112,
0.3345794082,
0.2126248181,
-0.278701663,
0.6781190634,
0.122301124,
0.0391383544,
-0.3047858477,
-0.6071481705,
-0.8180642128,
-0.317181617,
0.2912119627,
0.5247207284,
-1.1342917681,
0.2244439423,
-0.4833173752,
-0.7962078452,
-0.416724205,
0.2185950875,
0.0164622292,
0.8772339225,
0.4080623388,
-0.2237915099,
-0.7290808558,
-0.7549273372,
0.2341982275,
-0.2102381885,
-0.0812960342,
-0.0471609384,
0.368080914,
-0.142700538,
0.7987084985,
-0.6125373244,
0.2484751344,
-0.6619296074,
0.0949215591,
0.1559197456,
0.3076966405,
0.4916167855,
-0.7690576315,
-0.3647860289,
-0.1870859563,
-0.7981209755,
-0.1938543618,
-0.4120859206,
-0.4428624213,
0.0031171024,
0.6182911992,
-0.6370034218,
0.6012846231,
0.012350617,
-0.3369716704,
0.6702342629,
0.0768927038,
0.2699328959,
-1.0739147663,
-0.1201719642,
-0.0448858999,
-0.2349445075,
-0.769080162,
0.0846565589,
0.0284569021,
-0.3250891864,
-0.3335003853,
0.5309764147,
-0.3203433156,
-0.0034789005,
-0.1940958351,
0.0627851933,
0.1665508598,
0.3834077716,
0.1466978043,
0.6903259158,
0.5513926148,
-0.4044758976,
0.6710649729,
0.475607872,
-0.3628313839,
0.4446073472,
-0.6595613956,
0.1991208792,
-0.2208590508,
0.3960649371,
-1.2605227232,
-0.3944380283,
0.4621060193,
-0.3240164518,
0.09609586,
-0.2876268625,
-0.5998194218,
-0.4584875107,
-0.1680339575,
0.214354679,
0.5734373927,
-0.6180634499,
0.6058962345,
0.2149246931,
-0.329836756,
-0.2781680822,
-0.6001471281,
0.2144762725,
-0.2347742766,
-0.805587709,
-0.1167542562,
-0.132695362,
-0.2584922314,
-0.3063324988,
-0.0704221204,
-0.0684056357,
-0.12682347,
0.4070150852,
0.4306441545,
-0.12811023,
0.0928014964,
0.0793508738,
-0.319726944,
0.3119532764,
-0.1978990883,
0.3247132003,
0.1893589646,
-0.7110612988,
-0.3587845862,
0.1860697269,
0.6951426268,
-0.2765601277,
0.2481811345,
0.6227089167,
-0.1940443516,
-0.1733382642,
-0.3077753186,
-0.1425475925,
-0.4969546497,
0.1724670678,
-0.3497719467,
-0.4477578104,
0.3666124046,
-0.1362508386,
0.1963456422,
0.340289712,
0.6212230325,
-0.3246988058,
1.1362525225,
-0.1749958545,
0.2725808024,
0.1969013214,
-0.5820172429,
0.1916888952,
-0.5103367567,
-0.1588753164,
-0.0586048104,
-0.32880494,
-0.524772644,
-0.6944003701,
0.7497138381,
-0.0858217105,
-0.4991323054,
-0.0666080117,
-0.4507537782,
0.1311550289,
0.6646870375,
0.3066881001,
0.1739458889,
-0.02722211,
0.177007854,
-0.1111752167,
-0.583283186,
-0.5339919925,
1.5046197176,
0.0863027275,
0.6985723376,
-0.206530422,
0.7098351717,
0.0747531056,
0.2283771187,
-0.693454504,
0.6544035077,
0.4060353339,
-0.4016155303,
-0.4103762209,
-0.3982322812,
-0.8787351847,
0.1459471434,
-0.4937303066,
-0.4584893882,
-0.065843381,
0.2527214885,
0.0482088514,
0.0773849934,
-0.8359661698,
0.8078775406,
-0.3997241855,
-0.235626027,
0.1031513438,
-0.5101921558,
0.517834425,
-0.0981212407,
0.1464308798,
0.1596006155,
0.1787530333,
0.3682105541,
-0.7408703566,
0.6795222163,
-0.0605150349,
-0.1845413148,
0.7714318633,
0.1321673989,
0.7428444028,
0.0406495444,
0.0250756443,
-0.3359079063,
-0.2010776848,
-0.6123983264,
-0.897752583,
0.3988602757,
-0.4854426384,
-0.702231288,
-0.119897753,
-0.7273148894,
-0.4549109042,
-0.0028502934,
-0.0726253167,
0.5597313046,
0.3056104481,
0.0964089334,
0.3703307211,
-0.1930013597,
-0.1893171519,
0.0361594781,
-0.4883488715,
-0.7079051137,
0.8081023097,
0.2378012091,
0.2499862313,
0.095212847,
0.035797976,
-0.4336647689,
-0.6070396304,
-0.6400137544,
0.054617323,
-1.0339875221,
-0.0061643287,
-0.2823570967,
-0.2923101485,
-0.348693341,
-0.1140752584,
-0.0993857458,
-0.8307655454,
-0.2235394567,
-0.4804627001,
0.7226862311,
0.6749529839,
-0.0406649411,
-0.0686685219,
-0.5739004612,
0.7263957858,
0.6303164959,
-0.3240862489,
-0.070818156,
-0.1238415614,
-0.2425872982,
0.1314864159,
-0.359072119,
-0.9687414169,
0.3113870919,
-0.379123807,
0.3455601037,
0.0182891432,
0.069249779,
0.7510368824,
-0.2066239268,
0.8619131446,
0.2027392387,
-0.7169661522,
0.5644292235,
-0.3332106173,
0.3686943352,
0.1146989614,
0.279317677,
-0.1453348398,
-0.6168384552,
-0.5287941098,
-1.2146389484,
0.3673810661,
0.3753261268,
-0.0796185061,
0.2087121308,
0.4187609255,
0.1159186438,
0.2018116415,
-0.4249638617,
-0.3439258635,
-0.5551446676,
-0.444896251,
-0.0985931754,
0.1213040501,
-0.1878890544,
-0.6286395788,
0.5452453494,
-0.4361932576,
-0.1957871914,
0.1976868808,
-0.0467955917,
-0.0715555176,
0.1462665349,
0.0450223163,
0.9650128484,
0.0332622789,
0.1794308573,
0.1266252995,
-0.3560566008,
0.0961973891,
0.2376715839,
-0.4330621958,
-0.159452334,
0.5473154187,
0.7788268328,
0.0071921884,
-1.0628274679,
0.1524897069,
-0.0213196166,
-0.216627121,
-0.331815511,
0.2862417698,
0.5388382077,
0.4892327785,
0.6023942828,
-0.3480603099,
0.0422024243,
-0.4571260512,
0.2757226229,
0.1913377345,
-0.0903766677,
-0.0294209439,
0.9016174078,
-0.0439496525,
0.0060527297,
0.6177003384,
-0.071446307,
-0.3965177536,
0.7443121672,
0.23016949,
0.3992784321,
0.2269095778,
0.4473914206,
0.4653034508,
0.2036170065,
0.4197170138,
0.935968399,
0.1381401569,
-0.2947443426,
-0.6184290051,
-0.0719712004,
-0.5930750966,
0.3366421461,
-0.4714464545,
0.2067792863,
-0.4232460558,
-0.1003989503,
0.0183954705,
0.0073181405,
-0.8161498904,
0.6060906053,
0.2367143929,
0.6973907351,
-0.6533260942,
0.4034871161,
0.702826798,
-0.8155180812,
-1.1269721985,
-0.1419729739,
-0.1310030073,
-0.7041147947,
0.7559046149,
-0.0566008352,
0.3426632583,
-0.0871630684,
-0.8690494299,
-0.6945789456,
1.2985450029,
0.5383643508,
-0.3389293253,
0.243214488,
0.4952773154,
0.7141541839,
-0.4222711027,
0.22682558,
0.3723053336,
0.6305379868,
0.4563004375,
-0.4849383831,
0.3821839392,
-0.2663274109,
-0.1414629817,
-0.1401517838,
-0.110603489,
0.8362233639,
-0.3494775593,
-0.107313104,
-0.0441617481,
0.7427550554,
0.5791157484,
0.4834138751,
0.4281599224,
0.4907822907,
0.7673386931,
-0.0982350409,
0.9658106565,
-0.2248220742,
-0.0358424522,
1.1744995117,
-0.1955812573,
0.6275381446,
0.4612228572,
0.0139257004,
0.6091264486,
0.6427722573,
0.1762703806,
0.2029311359,
0.3628011346,
0.0993798226,
-0.6501861215,
0.0832780302,
-0.2195251286,
0.2899431288,
0.3462958038,
-0.3359571397,
-0.1792354733,
-0.2127407938,
-0.1785782427,
0.0750662908,
-0.259180665,
0.5620008707,
-0.0154596334,
-0.399741292,
0.8891134858,
-0.4494448304,
-0.3239196837,
-0.3863732219,
-0.2803925574,
-0.1541317552,
-0.3565221727,
-0.0674173534,
-1.1322364807,
-0.1429356337,
0.0201191194,
0.2275007367,
-0.1738282442,
0.5379370451,
-0.3759891987,
-0.7630042434,
-0.2426795065,
0.9305225015,
-0.0102949878,
0.0189589225,
-0.5927886963,
-0.0691941604,
0.0948292762,
-0.3639646471,
-0.0173283052,
0.6319380999,
-0.2178822011,
0.9509801865,
0.7894804478,
0.0687381998,
0.1476253569,
0.2498427629,
1.0564181805,
-0.596662879,
-0.4645569324,
-0.2260503024,
0.8875145912,
-0.2006690949,
0.0133159077,
0.6430051327,
0.5683026314,
0.5856781602,
-0.1812714934,
1.1166775227,
0.2425128669,
0.5420581102,
-0.7117577791,
0.5211340189,
-0.5917730927,
0.2154205739,
-0.2884189188,
-0.7245196104,
-0.0209492575,
0.2645177841,
-0.4436900318,
-0.2010810226,
0.5845835209,
0.8372983336,
-0.1335461885,
-0.0229564365,
-0.0252184067,
0.2202346623,
0.5416555405,
0.5790130496,
0.8861290812,
-0.4492148161,
0.7426422834,
-0.305408448,
0.0965898484,
-0.0146762636,
-0.594289422,
-0.7735833526,
-0.7440437078,
-0.4733347297,
-0.4607743025,
-0.2776764929,
0.7573262453,
0.3860854805,
-0.6598702669,
-0.0444277264,
-0.1313554496,
0.2237508446,
-0.2310957164,
-0.2885124683,
0.6275038719,
-0.1366948187,
-0.6709915996,
0.5513069034,
0.1019743979,
0.3039751649,
-0.4430156052,
-0.1802903265,
0.1418046355,
0.2718121111,
0.4825428128,
0.2175176293,
-0.4773786366,
-0.4389073253,
-0.117440708,
0.0080525782,
0.2490617633,
0.5834465623,
-0.9047046304,
0.8003965616,
0.6198840737,
0.4900653064,
0.7582794428,
0.2544111609,
0.7053092718,
-0.4305534661,
-0.0792786628,
0.2006124705,
0.4019989371,
0.4965223074,
-0.2116955668,
0.6653783321,
-0.0010116067,
-0.1898541003,
-0.8121874332,
0.4278473556,
-1.0986912251,
-0.2454790622,
0.9869728684,
0.0463891961,
-0.3428313136,
-0.1298677325,
-0.7327107191,
0.3907814324,
-0.2107648253,
0.8175106645,
0.3156417608,
-0.461065799,
-0.0932352468,
-0.4062634706,
0.3742224574,
0.0018088742,
-1.2245956659,
-0.0607240945,
0.9879136086,
0.231542483,
0.1269927025,
0.5022834539,
0.071033217,
0.4710312784,
0.2019462138,
-0.2313028127,
-0.3191182017,
-0.0346739255,
0.2601098716,
0.218852818,
0.1908091158,
-0.0273773856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08656v1
|
Linear Cross-document Event Coreference Resolution with X-AMR
| 2024-03-25T02:49:06 | 2024-03-25T02:49:06 |
Shafiuddin Rehan Ahmed, George Arthur Baker, Evi Judge, Michael Regan, Kristin Wright-Bettner, Martha Palmer, James H. Martin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Event Coreference Resolution (ECR) as a pairwise mention classification task
is expensive both for automated systems and manual annotations. The task's
quadratic difficulty is exacerbated when using Large Language Models (LLMs),
making prompt engineering for ECR prohibitively costly. In this work, we
propose a graphical representation of events, X-AMR, anchored around individual
mentions using a \textbf{cross}-document version of \textbf{A}bstract
\textbf{M}eaning \textbf{R}epresentation. We then linearize the ECR with a
novel multi-hop coreference algorithm over the event graphs. The event graphs
simplify ECR, making it a) LLM cost-effective, b) compositional and
interpretable, and c) easily annotated. For a fair assessment, we first enrich
an existing ECR benchmark dataset with these event graphs using an
annotator-friendly tool we introduce. Then, we employ GPT-4, the newest LLM by
OpenAI, for these annotations. Finally, using the ECR algorithm, we assess
GPT-4 against humans and analyze its limitations. Through this research, we aim
to advance the state-of-the-art for efficient ECR and shed light on the
potential shortcomings of current LLMs at this task. Code and annotations:
\url{https://github.com/ahmeshaf/gpt_coref}
|
[
-0.6439097524,
-0.3982875049,
0.6137623787,
-0.2604922354,
-0.3102792203,
0.1870016903,
-0.6262232661,
-0.9585741162,
0.2018439174,
0.2304451764,
-0.3556586504,
-0.5473627448,
-0.5918901563,
0.282017082,
-0.242540285,
1.1639006138,
-0.3684838414,
-0.3659958839,
-0.070575282,
-0.3576353192,
0.0752466619,
-1.0658459663,
-0.7105146646,
-0.5663765669,
0.6639063358,
0.2994629741,
0.5615870953,
0.675577879,
0.412827462,
0.3055027425,
-0.0760542527,
0.1604944617,
-0.2291624099,
0.0270275474,
-0.072504662,
-0.2907908559,
-0.6137053967,
0.0653977171,
0.5391412377,
0.3889122307,
0.2991223037,
0.0652503967,
0.1170062646,
0.1470007002,
-0.3813888133,
0.4378844798,
-0.5096219778,
-0.229955703,
-0.5069425702,
-0.3360862434,
-0.2797179818,
0.0299129263,
0.1479386836,
-0.6604890227,
0.4790531993,
0.3708254397,
1.037445426,
-0.0895060226,
-0.1437084079,
-0.5042968392,
-0.6782535315,
0.7169957161,
-0.3892581165,
0.2821913064,
0.1691780388,
0.1580943912,
0.1607377976,
-0.7732494473,
-0.7070372701,
-0.1320518404,
-0.2312895507,
-0.1756751388,
-0.5703195333,
0.2245421708,
0.5052376986,
0.1936865896,
-0.5338512063,
0.1831290871,
-0.2239319384,
-0.298461318,
0.379135251,
0.222780332,
0.2197251916,
-0.1957236677,
-0.2126211077,
0.0523591936,
-0.6359599233,
-0.0094411587,
0.1933171153,
0.3022784293,
-0.117542401,
0.4420059919,
-0.1318748444,
0.3267942667,
0.4039827585,
0.0219432674,
0.3747044206,
-0.5880929232,
0.2843091488,
0.0664528459,
0.8110663295,
0.5804022551,
0.252631098,
-0.2851415873,
-0.0970325023,
0.250200063,
-0.0595805235,
-0.8849209547,
-0.2901722789,
0.1139345691,
-0.2127099335,
-0.0525973216,
-0.2741600871,
-0.6442480087,
-0.4053709209,
-0.3500880599,
0.2547208667,
-0.3090487421,
0.2516155839,
-0.3746703267,
-0.1164414957,
0.1839511693,
0.6011416912,
-0.5613898039,
0.3441767097,
0.6057884693,
1.0179766417,
0.1512157172,
-0.2141458839,
-0.6912087798,
0.1057962328,
0.2060638219,
0.9731054902,
-0.6242651343,
-0.5013412833,
-0.1975141019,
-0.1979777664,
0.1994666755,
-0.2992105186,
0.9222829938,
-0.2934616804,
-0.1013098061,
-0.5788352489,
-0.5777102709,
0.0379554369,
0.465862155,
-0.5545886159,
0.749940753,
-0.2140755951,
-1.0301413536,
0.3467130959,
-0.5554522872,
-0.1804929674,
0.2676863074,
-0.7030463219,
-0.4277916551,
-0.3426807523,
0.5169612765,
0.544978857,
-0.4149256647,
-0.1161634251,
-0.3501560092,
-0.0935602263,
0.255774796,
0.1648795754,
0.3410793841,
-0.2248459756,
-0.4391222596,
0.4503192902,
-0.8497543931,
-0.1932932287,
-0.0744662732,
-0.047360491,
-0.6199795604,
0.0735612512,
0.1262789369,
0.4686692655,
0.2059677541,
-0.8411605954,
0.2558765113,
-0.0050904448,
0.4689109027,
0.6733031869,
-0.085768491,
0.4364944696,
-0.2623463571,
0.2729628384,
-0.0308620781,
-0.0059304438,
-0.4339352548,
-0.634368062,
-0.781999588,
-0.304063499,
0.0138170272,
0.4554411471,
-0.5466786623,
0.4898160696,
-0.4372628927,
-0.3965267241,
-0.2107282579,
0.0931586847,
0.5502631068,
0.5878136158,
0.5126373768,
-0.1121426076,
-0.8969529271,
-0.7680796385,
0.1213792562,
-0.415630877,
-0.0679605901,
0.3416294754,
0.5906962156,
-0.1044237837,
0.9904745221,
-0.3618467748,
-0.436712116,
-0.1877936572,
0.6580668688,
0.0383455306,
0.3254550993,
0.5204511881,
-0.4686215222,
-0.3862038851,
0.2642261684,
-0.50073874,
-0.4393084943,
-0.1803290248,
-0.0389221571,
0.1648314446,
0.3742505312,
-0.4004004002,
0.5854275823,
0.4608941972,
-0.3625122011,
0.7318884134,
-0.1750717163,
0.1904984266,
-0.7323969603,
0.2854408324,
0.2541850805,
-0.4101026058,
-0.5256614685,
-0.2305351943,
0.1884611398,
-0.0686613843,
0.1034196168,
0.670370698,
-0.6962739229,
0.0803138018,
-0.4404855967,
0.5114471316,
-0.1027577892,
0.5516982079,
0.3203134239,
0.4651742876,
0.2908113897,
-0.5159937739,
0.3453478217,
0.3675167859,
0.0131404381,
0.8750761747,
-0.5926264524,
0.3417610824,
-0.0032240024,
0.5898160934,
-0.7485830784,
0.1347761899,
0.4097118378,
-0.4739141464,
0.2482438684,
-0.3089819551,
-0.4360761046,
-0.3711704314,
-0.3680669963,
0.3773883581,
0.3945254087,
-0.7534988523,
0.7914242148,
0.2488816828,
-0.3407555819,
-0.3940173984,
-0.4241127372,
0.3544699848,
-0.0017606027,
-0.6890311837,
0.6513265371,
-0.0711360052,
-0.0887715891,
0.0969766155,
-0.0908445492,
0.2469172031,
-0.4937156737,
0.500323534,
0.3610970378,
0.0041829948,
-0.146759972,
-0.1877022982,
-0.5677346587,
0.058887288,
-0.3132973313,
0.3293252289,
-0.3365560472,
-0.3970412612,
-0.3355936706,
0.5089299679,
0.3006792665,
-0.2892203331,
0.3575496376,
0.6522300243,
-0.495833993,
-0.0900768563,
-0.7236715555,
0.007501395,
-0.3705758154,
0.3117884099,
-0.5788975358,
-0.9046559334,
0.8013418913,
0.0948953778,
0.2892155945,
0.2117283046,
0.6357395649,
0.1221126169,
0.8815872073,
0.3724539578,
0.0325654261,
0.3948830664,
-0.1428597271,
0.1382904798,
-1.1154907942,
-0.0923374891,
-0.9084379673,
-0.3557103276,
-0.3024671972,
-0.7153095603,
0.3390955329,
0.0146659333,
0.0099190772,
0.4115228653,
-0.2442730218,
0.3525691926,
0.5872588158,
0.1249610409,
0.5659809113,
-0.3099225461,
-0.1414910555,
-0.1383068711,
-0.4302277565,
-0.5629521608,
0.8151150346,
0.2097348869,
0.8369250894,
-0.1111659557,
0.8414803743,
0.1179807037,
0.529296279,
-0.6971056461,
0.539267242,
-0.0307578016,
-0.407346338,
-0.1319492757,
-0.5130854249,
-0.8347226381,
0.1414262503,
-0.0831105635,
-1.0553152561,
0.4962764084,
0.3405041695,
-0.3019556999,
0.6239178181,
-0.332811743,
0.6287116408,
-0.125661701,
-0.2480942011,
-0.1421034634,
-0.6431284547,
0.0099856993,
-0.1238076985,
0.309091419,
-0.1838963479,
-0.20760414,
0.9759536386,
-0.4294883013,
0.973131001,
-0.0663463324,
0.1485175639,
0.2946381569,
-0.1800990105,
0.929513514,
-0.1614819914,
-0.0296181682,
0.282065928,
-0.1778415442,
-0.3533860147,
-0.5447465181,
0.7576028109,
-0.8073061705,
-0.3589719534,
-0.4306926727,
-0.3155784607,
-0.0083257649,
0.0064482032,
0.397808224,
0.7329745889,
-0.2714873552,
-0.1682322621,
0.2469051331,
0.0494494811,
0.5466149449,
0.3650964499,
-0.2111182511,
-0.6506054997,
0.6067947745,
0.4052945375,
-0.0254939068,
0.4381530285,
0.1355614364,
-0.4089535475,
-0.5991863608,
-0.4924236536,
0.4523682296,
-0.9359236956,
-0.2487687171,
-0.8980528116,
0.1132936627,
-0.2853183746,
-0.5005104542,
-0.0778693557,
-0.5238818526,
-0.2162254453,
-0.158451736,
0.3551307321,
0.4967588186,
-0.2974750698,
0.256151855,
-0.8229125142,
0.0418199934,
0.0667542294,
0.1834927201,
0.0000164937,
-0.4762373269,
-0.3735044599,
-0.4272371829,
-0.2417662442,
-0.8028346896,
0.12547943,
0.3104325235,
0.5552826524,
0.4859992266,
0.4075669944,
0.8238739967,
-0.5573814511,
0.5127126575,
0.4980703592,
-1.1918884516,
0.3974551857,
-0.1654479206,
0.1944479644,
0.3230654001,
0.4254979193,
-0.8072550893,
-0.4470064044,
-0.6666179895,
-1.0782492161,
0.6906242371,
0.2872332931,
-0.223289907,
-0.2012978792,
0.4587472677,
-0.0040698182,
-0.2058748752,
-0.4913624227,
-0.430819124,
0.0729367435,
0.0311187264,
-0.1568638682,
-0.2152653039,
-0.0780137107,
-0.014113605,
0.7720386386,
-0.2345655113,
0.3086690903,
0.4647345543,
-0.2584799826,
-0.2410376072,
0.4664975405,
0.326856792,
0.5250502229,
-0.1872784048,
0.5014278293,
0.1865119338,
-0.2969117165,
0.2293681949,
0.5263101459,
-0.167657882,
0.1680386066,
0.4527629912,
0.7746035457,
0.4480665624,
-0.3981467485,
0.4953337312,
-0.1134185791,
-0.0667745844,
-0.2854104936,
-0.3107632995,
-0.0509446077,
0.3362168372,
0.5875784755,
0.0041216691,
0.0606607683,
-0.2732431889,
0.4241400659,
0.2140080184,
-0.3691246808,
-0.6670081615,
0.5878928304,
0.7526467443,
0.0095051704,
0.4492225349,
-0.4905746281,
-0.7980698347,
0.2281737924,
0.3425809741,
0.8795186877,
-0.121631369,
-0.0661487132,
0.6399251819,
0.3777794838,
0.2553999722,
0.0385799594,
-0.1945271939,
-0.8542371988,
-0.6203855276,
-0.4350214005,
-0.8329533339,
-0.0943006277,
-0.5297735929,
0.4285035729,
-0.5783635378,
-0.4519768357,
0.3752111197,
0.097302191,
-0.7121406794,
-0.1094468832,
0.6174685359,
0.7218857408,
-0.7734933496,
0.785256207,
0.9822437763,
-0.5895189047,
-0.4069325924,
-0.310554564,
0.1496566385,
-0.4511992037,
0.5712684393,
0.2237601578,
-0.0916684121,
0.0036558637,
-0.1354209483,
-0.6237541437,
1.0035555363,
0.0737101957,
-0.9575937986,
-0.3329112232,
-0.1163502783,
0.2521101236,
-0.3574053943,
0.5233872533,
0.4016371965,
0.5744030476,
0.1049686819,
-1.2522546053,
0.4591219425,
-0.3282775879,
-0.1205497086,
0.5417135954,
-0.4255658984,
0.6608737707,
-0.4503825307,
-0.4178386033,
0.047078874,
0.9082992673,
0.1911783665,
0.4502846301,
0.6076153517,
0.4836010039,
0.8837271333,
-0.200762257,
0.8616756201,
-0.3185950518,
0.4766912758,
1.2723587751,
-0.456020236,
0.7106374502,
0.4819894135,
-0.2888071239,
0.3382331729,
0.3291644156,
0.0720851198,
-0.0779025406,
0.2668542564,
-0.5608282089,
-0.3261997998,
0.0518920347,
-0.2378402948,
-0.0126373284,
0.4842504561,
-0.3605848253,
-0.6248972416,
0.1639813632,
0.353835851,
-0.1437737644,
-0.4107251167,
0.5437728763,
0.0864089876,
-0.2559823096,
0.2971892655,
0.0619649366,
0.9094640017,
-0.5388943553,
0.0452228449,
0.1194149181,
0.3526936769,
-0.2263631821,
-0.7459076047,
0.2717729807,
0.2436287254,
-0.2615156472,
-0.0398076698,
0.7755143642,
-0.3654061556,
-0.2982701361,
0.6552875638,
0.4222251773,
0.1392481029,
-0.2700106502,
-0.5797616243,
0.3391079009,
-0.0755259469,
-0.2110180855,
0.2872779667,
0.4271457195,
-0.3687770963,
0.5002933741,
0.5412109494,
0.0191549081,
0.1660029888,
0.0891891271,
1.0090579987,
-0.8639104366,
-0.5770528913,
-0.7000117302,
0.255030632,
-0.195628047,
-0.3424820006,
0.4906076193,
0.5182457566,
0.8106797338,
0.3608736098,
1.116071105,
-0.3811804056,
0.5643980503,
-0.1834951192,
0.2331196666,
-0.0044057011,
0.1245778352,
-0.4194535911,
-0.6692585349,
-0.5784733891,
0.4542682171,
-0.5960963964,
-0.0452334993,
0.7155835032,
0.773393631,
-0.027998792,
0.0096193245,
0.4356414378,
0.2853055298,
0.552688241,
0.5701290369,
0.8739353418,
-0.1415815502,
1.0103691816,
-0.5365204215,
-0.6005343199,
-0.3446764052,
-1.0951981544,
-0.899204731,
-0.7055639625,
-0.880453527,
-0.4505854547,
0.1598758399,
1.3488138914,
0.7040609717,
-0.8233960271,
-0.087013036,
0.3065037131,
-0.2302777469,
-0.1391642243,
-0.1154722795,
0.5166526437,
-0.3872247636,
-0.759224236,
0.0513103269,
0.1907478273,
-0.1156710312,
-0.056856554,
-0.1922067404,
-0.0881124735,
-0.1444057375,
0.6434941292,
0.4136336148,
-0.7492277622,
-0.6097872853,
-0.3393659294,
-0.029120313,
0.2551434338,
1.1832766533,
-0.6509339213,
0.3133699894,
0.5160910487,
0.5189763308,
0.6765307784,
0.0398826301,
0.3142337799,
-0.8231336474,
-0.1946274936,
0.1473374665,
0.7240386009,
0.3054784536,
-0.3568276465,
0.3137013018,
0.4282236695,
-0.6721229553,
-0.4513616562,
0.0573963746,
-1.4245451689,
0.2099389583,
0.9762079716,
-0.4760300815,
-0.2942955196,
-0.4885872602,
-0.5101733804,
0.2174497545,
-0.733771801,
0.4725264907,
0.6674420834,
-0.6743108034,
-0.4883172512,
-0.0068484736,
0.1147902682,
-0.1474812031,
-0.6664915085,
0.3548087776,
0.6847374439,
0.2301332802,
0.5724705458,
0.7942221761,
-0.1776209176,
0.2141436785,
0.0933016688,
0.6552034616,
-0.1920903772,
-0.0234795939,
-0.2639136016,
0.150735721,
0.2076945454,
-0.052190084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16345v1
|
Enhanced Facet Generation with LLM Editing
| 2024-03-25T00:43:44 | 2024-03-25T00:43:44 |
Joosung Lee, Jinhong Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
In information retrieval, facet identification of a user query is an
important task. If a search service can recognize the facets of a user's query,
it has the potential to offer users a much broader range of search results.
Previous studies can enhance facet prediction by leveraging retrieved documents
and related queries obtained through a search engine. However, there are
challenges in extending it to other applications when a search engine operates
as part of the model. First, search engines are constantly updated. Therefore,
additional information may change during training and test, which may reduce
performance. The second challenge is that public search engines cannot search
for internal documents. Therefore, a separate search system needs to be built
to incorporate documents from private domains within the company. We propose
two strategies that focus on a framework that can predict facets by taking only
queries as input without a search engine. The first strategy is multi-task
learning to predict SERP. By leveraging SERP as a target instead of a source,
the proposed model deeply understands queries without relying on external
modules. The second strategy is to enhance the facets by combining Large
Language Model (LLM) and the small model. Overall performance improves when
small model and LLM are combined rather than facet generation individually.
|
[
-0.4799960852,
-0.5159009099,
0.7189351916,
0.2548751533,
-0.0407089442,
0.1465392113,
-0.1162620261,
-0.5754922032,
0.2278912663,
0.9216024876,
-0.9273691177,
-0.2325768173,
-0.4356235266,
0.0092450362,
-0.0582205318,
1.0206497908,
0.3331872523,
0.1656500697,
-0.3075850606,
-0.0368106849,
-0.4609443843,
-0.4800767303,
-0.8083210588,
-0.1398468316,
0.3409118652,
0.273521781,
0.4733932614,
0.4042419791,
0.4624698758,
0.2780781686,
-0.0874738768,
0.4753801525,
-0.3468074799,
0.5300953984,
-0.3855458498,
-0.4143378139,
-0.4298460484,
-0.1500560641,
0.4756374061,
0.7342911959,
-0.0149120977,
-0.2066980898,
0.2441949546,
0.8709055185,
-0.5685669184,
0.1913572997,
-0.9190648794,
-0.0434408858,
-0.437895298,
-0.2540342808,
-0.3284413815,
-0.1101149097,
0.0161126629,
-0.4534826577,
0.3172745705,
0.051106628,
0.5435001254,
0.1197892129,
-0.3380771279,
-0.1149421707,
-0.5673213601,
0.3935895562,
-0.4777358174,
0.4267115891,
0.4470466673,
0.4409764409,
-0.3943457305,
-0.6682412624,
-0.4320909381,
-0.1099576578,
-0.0881777629,
0.3028199077,
0.0460722782,
0.0243034177,
0.2979300916,
0.2930329144,
-0.4725533128,
0.0753419772,
-0.2233987749,
-0.0736528561,
0.5352559686,
0.0153921796,
0.0238506254,
-0.4757427871,
-0.2120516449,
-0.0571234934,
-0.9036185145,
0.022781767,
0.2553890347,
0.4248739183,
0.3922668099,
0.6695076823,
-0.5121036172,
0.4408639371,
0.4610424638,
0.0225475468,
0.0253845602,
-0.0095375311,
-0.3006256223,
-0.1655764282,
0.4749385715,
0.2324092537,
-0.1114939153,
-0.2770507038,
-0.5179060698,
-0.286498636,
0.3299223483,
-0.9541781545,
-0.243941173,
0.1468065083,
-0.2019368261,
-0.4568570256,
0.1680649519,
-0.8426135182,
-0.9282051325,
-0.3425396085,
0.5283158422,
-0.3974150419,
0.0557258278,
-0.2919347584,
-0.0301316585,
0.0159071404,
0.7074792385,
-0.7237845659,
0.3102353215,
0.6048156023,
0.7138158083,
-0.143624559,
-0.2600187659,
-0.8545886278,
0.4372634888,
-0.0442949086,
0.9909209013,
-0.5689833164,
-0.4476591945,
0.1263415366,
0.1208904386,
-0.0736540779,
-0.6126742363,
0.3633801341,
-0.952640295,
0.3597539663,
-0.4569792747,
-0.4038801789,
-0.1964219809,
0.0609042086,
-0.871750474,
1.079303503,
0.2334312499,
-0.7742213011,
0.3008799851,
-0.8154953122,
-0.6339051723,
0.396148771,
-0.3729198277,
-0.504648447,
0.4235135615,
0.6761386395,
0.6073915958,
-0.1446544677,
0.2321651131,
-0.1978450418,
0.0479990058,
0.0663580373,
0.0961933136,
0.5715480447,
-0.0060330261,
-0.3220806718,
0.1255318522,
-0.613901794,
-0.0619375966,
0.1034435183,
-0.2777497768,
-0.3191739619,
0.1270625591,
0.0955610052,
0.2451055497,
0.4514560699,
-0.4056294262,
0.3268539906,
-0.5039021373,
0.0780348852,
0.9970907569,
0.1911928952,
0.4046684206,
-0.4517282546,
0.6032342315,
-0.0437823124,
-0.0369007066,
-0.1013620868,
-0.7164607048,
-0.601472199,
-0.2506487072,
0.1924046427,
0.582416594,
-0.9018025994,
0.125086993,
-0.3319785893,
-0.2862212658,
-0.4088415802,
0.2551533282,
0.1221383438,
0.4199196994,
0.3226591945,
-0.3810539842,
-0.6987544298,
-0.7714672685,
-0.5414769053,
0.1836061478,
-0.2736854851,
0.8210684061,
0.3508627713,
-0.2073230445,
0.9971015453,
-0.6299355626,
-0.5221840143,
-0.2666071057,
0.1379651278,
0.0423056558,
0.2929147482,
0.3090405762,
-1.0229650736,
-0.6867018342,
0.1788790971,
-0.5653190613,
-0.3057788014,
-0.1230537742,
-0.1382801533,
0.0299849287,
0.2727093697,
-0.5787159801,
0.444449693,
0.363740027,
-0.0292731803,
0.5031862259,
-0.1605075896,
0.197309643,
-1.0666763783,
-0.0982518718,
0.0927058905,
-0.3927989304,
-0.600171864,
0.2429537028,
0.3389600217,
-0.5746948123,
-0.3032944798,
0.6099691391,
-0.5060977936,
-0.4249997735,
-0.5341578126,
0.1470016539,
0.0170008726,
0.4469570816,
0.1323952228,
1.1819150448,
0.306024909,
-0.6098803282,
0.178847611,
0.3626480699,
-0.1799369454,
0.6330215335,
-0.387275815,
0.2732217014,
-0.0919254422,
0.3750957549,
-0.7605916858,
-0.5509232283,
-0.2384336293,
-0.3451809287,
0.3311474621,
-0.1626306921,
-0.6105556488,
-0.0949385017,
-0.5552526712,
-0.1770133078,
0.3266159892,
-0.7370379567,
0.7698872685,
0.3829549253,
-0.5299651027,
-0.1927682757,
-0.4818778336,
0.3367573917,
-0.0859198198,
-0.9538276792,
0.7645547986,
-0.0631815046,
0.1003743261,
-0.13630265,
-0.0590004101,
-0.0369314887,
0.1008229926,
0.4238073826,
0.1672909111,
-0.1099045053,
0.0257115029,
0.2101785988,
0.0445474386,
-0.2938698232,
-0.3371451497,
0.4441920221,
0.0946942866,
-0.3025806546,
-0.4161837995,
0.5427712202,
0.5915520191,
-0.5529426932,
0.7053326964,
0.4822820723,
-0.5307170749,
-0.2966469526,
-0.801597178,
-0.2126354724,
-0.5173686743,
0.1964659393,
-0.6196700931,
-0.8329176307,
0.5818155408,
-0.5458554029,
-0.2847865522,
0.5679801702,
0.5112602115,
-0.1203146949,
1.3289643526,
1.0881588459,
0.0955582932,
0.6242952347,
-0.1506502181,
0.0832190514,
-1.25986588,
-0.2210157663,
-0.3292268515,
-0.2100868523,
-1.0693019629,
-0.3104501367,
0.5135230422,
0.0596921183,
0.0526135415,
0.4203003943,
-0.5382763743,
0.264636606,
0.6308483481,
0.5791114569,
0.1995744854,
0.2308521271,
-0.1563238651,
-0.23912929,
-0.3245027065,
-0.2100984454,
1.1061270237,
0.0238465164,
0.567419529,
0.2569875419,
0.8461201787,
0.2915630043,
0.2449205369,
-0.5458273292,
0.4052869976,
-0.4806318283,
-0.5482186675,
-0.1135466993,
-0.2846753597,
-0.6690240502,
0.3623932004,
-0.0865116939,
-0.8396995664,
0.303157866,
-0.0805900097,
-0.3764332831,
-0.0118245734,
-0.4909814894,
0.5597642064,
-0.2329977304,
-0.5847294331,
-0.0198952332,
-0.3174870908,
0.1900815815,
-0.3479047418,
0.1895374209,
0.3072863519,
-0.0724271983,
0.6634626985,
-0.3149499297,
0.8513735533,
-0.2600708604,
0.2536180913,
-0.1188037544,
0.1678755879,
0.9462524652,
0.0836655721,
-0.2173458785,
-0.3850839436,
-0.2572397292,
-0.2953220904,
-0.6675005555,
0.7490400672,
-0.6082764864,
-0.8722679019,
-0.322917372,
-0.4475944042,
-0.4686993957,
0.3782441616,
0.15261738,
0.0216146763,
-0.0321785361,
0.4159801304,
0.7803260684,
-0.2246736139,
0.1608706713,
0.4160023928,
-0.3521374464,
-0.4079683423,
0.7140824199,
0.0610301644,
0.052761253,
0.4403376877,
0.3756136,
-0.1866413802,
-0.6796094179,
-0.2399694622,
0.1535125077,
-0.7115587592,
-0.2937908173,
-0.7204005718,
-0.3102550507,
-0.838290453,
-0.1026577652,
-0.1729608923,
-0.3683013022,
-0.1644525081,
0.1705944389,
0.3408145905,
0.8149077892,
-0.1007734835,
0.6210723519,
-0.5400377512,
0.4632248282,
0.570351541,
0.281024456,
-0.2422821522,
-0.4305886924,
-0.2488211691,
-0.0505251065,
-0.4642521441,
-1.1086453199,
0.5935688615,
0.3285235167,
0.5669929385,
0.1363459826,
-0.1131596938,
0.7257266045,
-0.6590702534,
0.7425821424,
-0.1720307767,
-0.8262378573,
1.0149964094,
-0.4830836356,
0.2243104279,
0.7148451805,
0.317233026,
-0.5318638086,
-0.2908234,
-0.708650291,
-0.8145111203,
0.87422961,
0.2960048616,
-0.1372202188,
0.3523179889,
0.4877056181,
0.2720398903,
0.4909687042,
-0.6587150693,
0.2125436366,
-0.1636296958,
0.0309630651,
0.1943088323,
-0.1348945946,
0.0716661885,
-0.1248551831,
0.7407467365,
-0.2941938639,
0.2328187823,
0.1102705821,
-0.2778962851,
-0.1525710225,
-0.1027509943,
0.4822465777,
0.6979990602,
-0.4939015806,
-0.0882916674,
0.0390117839,
-0.5513877869,
-0.4336676896,
0.1493014246,
-0.2324571759,
-0.0934791714,
0.0571037717,
0.7991205454,
0.0876133591,
-0.3722591102,
0.6664024591,
0.0823967457,
0.147924915,
-0.3800064325,
-0.020006666,
0.0601128116,
0.4944952428,
0.5690866113,
0.0059705945,
0.1342254579,
-0.4523391724,
0.4248352647,
0.4765895903,
-0.1601639539,
-0.1563712358,
0.7012919784,
0.2055042535,
-0.4039151967,
0.4049259722,
-0.2461684048,
-0.7683189511,
0.4845851958,
0.3934472799,
1.2170442343,
-0.5329349041,
-0.0224397425,
0.0700203925,
0.30145064,
0.0039834869,
0.1243576407,
-0.0850206912,
-0.5098991394,
-0.4391705394,
-0.7637441754,
-0.501665473,
0.5885903239,
-0.4746395051,
0.3025722504,
-0.6731428504,
0.0342191868,
0.2662926614,
0.3633371294,
-0.9389025569,
0.3665056229,
0.0843385682,
0.5528098345,
-0.7128124833,
0.8988044262,
0.7444747686,
-0.6192820668,
-0.2906769812,
0.2036561519,
0.0837143734,
-0.8543871045,
0.8761213422,
0.335973978,
-0.0869746134,
-0.1136580035,
-0.4302039146,
-0.7380034924,
1.1991859674,
0.2344516963,
-0.3850727379,
-0.244709447,
-0.0248141009,
0.2123235762,
-0.7582197785,
0.098272942,
0.2424797416,
0.388851583,
0.1836119443,
-0.8416413665,
0.2027947307,
0.0637155846,
0.3287087977,
-0.1044191942,
-0.3501261771,
1.027472496,
0.1865455806,
-0.1816495359,
-0.0338668115,
0.647530973,
0.197846517,
0.2583021522,
0.3212542832,
0.359846741,
0.6489400268,
0.3054320216,
1.0730633736,
-0.2336596102,
0.2615292072,
1.2283550501,
-0.4818594754,
0.9542164207,
0.4190137982,
-0.1743807197,
0.1770773232,
0.7329283953,
-0.0342759639,
0.7960656881,
-0.1400332749,
-0.3322930634,
-0.2330238819,
0.009104833,
-0.3447400331,
0.504317522,
0.4400943816,
-0.394180268,
-0.2609422803,
0.0924375579,
0.0378456041,
0.1445726156,
-0.0861768797,
0.9728233218,
-0.1133945286,
-0.5318247676,
0.1507638991,
0.2784226537,
0.7235789299,
-0.4429228306,
0.0965688154,
-0.3522093296,
0.136491105,
-0.2969301939,
-0.5223225951,
0.2048781365,
-0.0986925736,
-0.2530550361,
-0.4162324667,
1.0529609919,
-0.2897349,
-0.6125581861,
0.304941535,
0.6874494553,
0.0409375392,
-0.7962480783,
-0.769662261,
-0.1622485965,
0.2181818336,
-0.4226825833,
0.7403600216,
0.5095379949,
-0.0163081326,
0.3927997053,
0.8006781936,
0.2796462178,
0.0641405061,
-0.0172411595,
1.0831614733,
-0.651601851,
-0.6326557994,
-0.4579978883,
0.4279303849,
-0.3531870544,
0.0966223404,
0.5637679696,
0.5075941682,
0.7304531336,
-0.0895406604,
1.0786458254,
0.0697477683,
0.6964011788,
-0.6016055942,
0.7484763861,
-0.7316961288,
0.3215591908,
-0.2230972499,
-1.0719012022,
-0.0697063357,
0.5712287426,
-0.3753129244,
0.2084789872,
0.7704913616,
0.9105645418,
-0.1847049743,
-0.0375645496,
0.3943039775,
-0.0136270132,
0.5083789825,
0.3922260702,
0.3939164579,
-0.3864645362,
0.1777170151,
-0.5780395269,
-0.41569224,
-0.5478457212,
-0.8488848805,
-0.7599354386,
-0.6453905702,
-0.1821870655,
-0.1551067382,
0.2011433542,
0.4281901419,
0.6286877394,
-0.7143428922,
-0.144380331,
-0.0228328779,
-0.0654128939,
-0.1705237627,
-0.2288533747,
0.4625577033,
-0.4353029728,
-0.6026403308,
0.7010830641,
0.3394948244,
-0.1583616585,
-0.3338329792,
0.2133803666,
-0.3018512726,
0.1023875251,
0.8008406758,
0.1340295374,
-0.7244519591,
-0.2590457201,
0.0620263182,
0.0612130128,
0.149089694,
0.8075175881,
-0.9403958321,
0.4765166938,
0.4666701257,
0.9394777417,
0.8809458017,
0.0978314504,
0.5511007905,
-0.985118866,
0.0287229698,
0.2370898426,
0.0667376295,
0.6527765989,
-0.9119654298,
0.4369143546,
0.294514358,
-0.374234885,
-0.6134533286,
0.4258650243,
-0.828663528,
-0.3492933214,
0.9009255767,
0.0501788072,
-0.2522960305,
0.2284936905,
-0.112652123,
0.1833787858,
-0.4738277495,
0.7203551531,
0.5556670427,
-0.4774498343,
-0.2259620577,
-1.035697937,
0.5209311843,
0.2008697242,
-0.8765122294,
-0.0350020863,
0.4081477821,
0.1449143589,
0.1498946249,
0.4794240892,
-0.0698060319,
0.2844768465,
-0.2881932259,
-0.0461748764,
-0.0897230431,
-0.3160321116,
-0.3180439174,
0.34459427,
0.092720598,
-0.1156390086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.08655v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.08655v1
|
Transformer-based Joint Modelling for Automatic Essay Scoring and Off-Topic Detection
| 2024-03-24T21:44:14 | 2024-03-24T21:44:14 |
Sourya Dipta Das, Yash Vadi, Kuldeep Yadav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Automated Essay Scoring (AES) systems are widely popular in the market as
they constitute a cost-effective and time-effective option for grading systems.
Nevertheless, many studies have demonstrated that the AES system fails to
assign lower grades to irrelevant responses. Thus, detecting the off-topic
response in automated essay scoring is crucial in practical tasks where
candidates write unrelated text responses to the given task in the question. In
this paper, we are proposing an unsupervised technique that jointly scores
essays and detects off-topic essays. The proposed Automated Open Essay Scoring
(AOES) model uses a novel topic regularization module (TRM), which can be
attached on top of a transformer model, and is trained using a proposed hybrid
loss function. After training, the AOES model is further used to calculate the
Mahalanobis distance score for off-topic essay detection. Our proposed method
outperforms the baseline we created and earlier conventional methods on two
essay-scoring datasets in off-topic detection as well as on-topic scoring.
Experimental evaluation results on different adversarial strategies also show
how the suggested method is robust for detecting possible human-level
perturbations.
|
[
-0.5933167338,
-1.0298919678,
0.5650088787,
-0.1132177263,
-0.1253895611,
0.0935883895,
-0.1546816975,
-0.0977308974,
0.4394377172,
0.5905946493,
-0.3716426492,
-0.5935029387,
-0.61860919,
-0.0147466809,
-0.5175061226,
1.0083646774,
-0.2680971622,
-0.1749896258,
-0.5917640924,
-0.2055768073,
-0.461727649,
-0.0762369186,
-0.6097322702,
-0.1606748402,
0.2952951491,
0.4056509733,
0.0846550018,
0.3224592805,
0.8328757286,
0.3651651442,
0.1428414136,
0.1514019966,
-0.1567051858,
0.1579979807,
-0.2914904356,
-0.7799250484,
-0.3044376969,
0.2452060878,
0.5932471156,
0.5223136544,
0.0893968046,
0.2703672349,
0.0610075369,
0.3797115386,
-0.7037313581,
-0.0152725624,
-0.5779981017,
0.1659593433,
-0.2265381515,
-0.2623182237,
-0.649817884,
-0.2099878192,
-0.072069943,
-0.5859018564,
0.2714666426,
0.2318433374,
0.8373344541,
0.3523958921,
-0.3934951723,
-0.148430869,
-0.7196370363,
0.8953464031,
-0.1443127543,
-0.0634024367,
0.1872272789,
0.2716791928,
0.0379628018,
-0.4866222739,
-0.5102802515,
0.0306758806,
-0.347286731,
0.4235132933,
-0.4497944415,
0.1711713821,
0.0256165788,
0.4953206778,
-0.7040867209,
0.0250918083,
-0.1489783973,
-0.1603612006,
0.5209037066,
0.3205984831,
0.2172261626,
-0.2101787925,
-0.3045513034,
0.005778227,
-0.3085493743,
0.4283130169,
0.6402388811,
0.319737196,
-0.0260806605,
0.5162933469,
0.1805543602,
0.6218949556,
0.4363450408,
0.0807146803,
-0.2262717932,
0.0624371842,
0.0504409894,
-0.10580118,
0.8448534608,
0.3186480105,
-0.1323322952,
-0.400948137,
-0.1748817861,
0.6841033697,
0.5541457534,
-0.4209913313,
-0.1665208489,
-0.1625251323,
-0.7839109302,
-0.5828416944,
0.3861981332,
-1.0509812832,
-0.2598864436,
-0.151902616,
0.9157602787,
-0.0796204135,
-0.0186110493,
-0.1245846525,
-0.0662482008,
-0.0450960398,
0.122798726,
-0.400334537,
0.6751452088,
0.2352104038,
0.7736773491,
-0.6182704568,
-0.1703248918,
-0.5903493762,
-0.1106630191,
-0.4018826783,
1.0987522602,
-0.7481068373,
-0.4333390296,
-0.0865446553,
0.0783659816,
-0.2511360943,
-0.2963128984,
0.9350965619,
-0.5988987684,
0.7593771219,
-0.0347199626,
-0.7371079326,
-0.1462709755,
0.4118015468,
-0.6236187816,
1.1781960726,
0.1044004261,
-1.0349578857,
0.1249413639,
-1.1369341612,
-0.338999778,
-0.2535049319,
-0.0514251702,
-0.897844255,
0.0357092805,
0.0966168419,
0.2820146978,
-0.4285342097,
0.344088465,
-0.1617725641,
-0.7497567534,
-0.0140114035,
-0.4678970277,
0.3177341521,
-0.186300531,
-0.4471159577,
0.2747740746,
-0.7370083332,
-0.089853175,
0.0504729673,
-0.1319499612,
-0.6124039292,
-0.3148695529,
0.050614655,
0.2726941109,
0.0699122101,
-0.8308041692,
0.1042922586,
-0.4095975161,
0.0950295553,
0.6106665134,
0.2396027744,
0.4401257634,
-0.6226276755,
0.6154909134,
0.0919002816,
0.027377801,
-0.1846437305,
-0.8146176338,
-0.7958742976,
-0.2960880399,
0.3852207363,
0.5849993229,
-0.6765488386,
1.0180900097,
0.0722578615,
-0.4925958812,
-0.4770577252,
-0.4301007688,
0.3604711294,
0.571144104,
0.6673562527,
-0.1715066731,
-0.4368503094,
-0.5346776843,
-0.4798432589,
-0.23578915,
-0.1640703082,
0.00957911,
0.5320846438,
0.1743540019,
1.2846750021,
-1.0073810816,
-0.7710470557,
-0.0856232569,
0.7174066305,
-0.1925745308,
0.3554528356,
0.477514863,
-0.9466842413,
-0.5899696946,
-0.395825237,
-0.5614725947,
-0.2615856528,
0.0487726666,
-0.0338353515,
0.0941501409,
0.511572659,
-0.6431818604,
0.9541804194,
0.1141984686,
-0.4587137103,
0.3275001049,
-0.2387438864,
0.608658433,
-1.2346363068,
0.201230377,
0.3711804748,
-0.0319261476,
-0.4815324545,
-0.0757946447,
-0.1401977539,
-0.2340932488,
-0.1345935017,
0.5138537288,
-0.0041122595,
0.0612242334,
-0.599083364,
-0.0669048652,
0.4629215896,
0.650372684,
0.0307928659,
0.4895740151,
0.5306766033,
-0.2594767809,
0.3016389906,
0.2075684369,
-0.0808516145,
0.8019417524,
-0.4082895219,
0.0824875161,
-0.1357313991,
0.4207125008,
-1.2883341312,
0.0768269747,
0.2075639665,
-0.6025822759,
0.3631932437,
-0.0612040125,
-0.0103791961,
-0.3020063043,
-0.6683970094,
0.2101767063,
0.4198783934,
-0.480219543,
0.8882871866,
0.4662852585,
0.0557357483,
-0.2412834615,
-0.4515508115,
-0.0556180403,
-0.582136631,
-0.5266031027,
0.8794565201,
0.1329009533,
-0.2516312897,
0.3815945685,
0.0634025037,
-0.287304014,
-0.0728804246,
0.3619457781,
0.4235613942,
-0.2957634628,
0.0956756026,
0.2261864543,
-0.3213459551,
0.2045264095,
-0.5484929085,
0.1047910601,
0.1118339151,
-0.5146691799,
-0.425095886,
0.7460564971,
0.7539044619,
-0.2540017366,
0.8813449144,
0.7477417588,
-0.6586275101,
-0.2416784763,
-0.4882708192,
-0.3684514761,
-0.4310202301,
0.1669249088,
-0.1723403037,
-0.6968122125,
0.5172833204,
-0.1131679416,
-0.1366169155,
0.856267035,
0.4975942373,
-0.1699368805,
0.8761925101,
0.792157948,
-0.2212808877,
0.2172478884,
-0.3318939507,
0.6759217978,
-0.4303757846,
-0.2119022757,
-0.8256375194,
-0.2537343204,
-0.6618471742,
-0.257542938,
0.6370512843,
-0.1476551741,
0.2573798299,
0.1576424092,
-0.5563872457,
0.5398086309,
0.4708890915,
0.0462506935,
0.2780347466,
-0.0738642216,
-0.294480443,
-0.019381877,
-0.3633494079,
-0.5122544765,
1.1066088676,
0.1473336965,
0.5425830483,
-0.1460548341,
0.4575110376,
0.8673209548,
0.2863762677,
-0.5441865325,
0.5358140469,
-0.420363605,
-0.4711149335,
-0.590470314,
-0.5021706223,
-0.5841609836,
0.0685885474,
-0.1925404966,
-0.7558672428,
-0.1146714911,
-0.1401466429,
-0.5500693917,
0.7659783363,
-0.3938063681,
0.863266468,
0.277290374,
-0.5315537453,
-0.0734013319,
-0.5235956311,
0.1203338876,
-0.2987963259,
0.0650848597,
0.239224121,
0.1875515431,
1.241818428,
-0.2024955601,
0.6838377118,
-0.3464648128,
0.027207287,
0.5827747583,
-0.1945627481,
0.3805057406,
0.0669543147,
-0.010985502,
0.1842176765,
-0.2815069258,
-0.1203182489,
-0.7686502337,
0.837846756,
-0.714320004,
-0.5258846879,
-0.5287718177,
-0.4367993772,
-0.1570656002,
0.052168183,
0.5720580816,
0.3269654512,
-0.2328220159,
-0.0521056503,
0.6797859073,
-0.1369522512,
0.4963250458,
0.7809134722,
0.19001849,
-0.1806572229,
0.9908317924,
0.0484794267,
-0.4585360289,
0.7004619837,
0.34327209,
-0.576297164,
-0.2369177341,
-0.439278692,
-0.0448038317,
-0.6252257824,
-0.3720971346,
-0.8012542129,
-0.0697792172,
-0.4172993898,
-0.4032795727,
-0.3300862908,
-0.3919554949,
-0.3335827291,
-0.0127187036,
0.2482975274,
0.5598375797,
-0.0401995294,
0.0704053789,
-0.6640207171,
0.4207352996,
0.0857965723,
0.506893158,
-0.1144148707,
-0.9332063198,
-0.0262040682,
-0.3084664345,
-0.769833684,
-0.5448107719,
0.0966883451,
0.0260577258,
0.3687953055,
0.6147338152,
0.4395217001,
0.3073270917,
-0.1947243959,
0.6652062535,
-0.0482885651,
-1.0336112976,
0.5838023424,
-0.2297120392,
-0.0400671847,
0.5510883331,
0.6765138507,
-0.3263187408,
-0.5112370849,
-0.3774757385,
-0.5677059293,
0.996537149,
0.3573863506,
-0.0510002561,
0.1862765551,
0.3403987586,
0.2714016736,
-0.0391974598,
-0.7194105387,
-0.2957907319,
-0.0701979399,
-0.4537271857,
0.1538324356,
0.1786165535,
0.1729457676,
-0.2025700957,
0.9119460583,
-0.0180481523,
0.4149818718,
-0.0719080865,
0.2244290859,
-0.6840070486,
0.1777159125,
0.3386997283,
-0.0326627195,
-0.2678325474,
-0.0613696352,
0.1799758077,
-0.5091184378,
0.6109417677,
0.2921426594,
-0.2749423087,
0.047894489,
0.4433560073,
0.4400153458,
-0.0480942279,
-0.4150104523,
0.7595541477,
-0.4092622995,
-0.1179223433,
-0.3106117845,
-0.03387665,
-0.2986359596,
-0.1623402536,
0.2745689452,
0.5506170988,
0.1752305925,
-0.3130619824,
0.4412631392,
0.2461953163,
-0.6643229127,
-0.3620499969,
0.6126374602,
0.2433466315,
-0.370926857,
0.1745237112,
-0.4383071065,
-0.6544499397,
0.7487210631,
0.353069067,
0.8993555307,
-0.5535673499,
0.1890798211,
0.1534000337,
0.173302114,
-0.0747805536,
0.0963082239,
0.064001292,
-0.3863075376,
-0.1711880565,
-0.7658107281,
-0.4603838921,
0.3251568973,
-0.8162581325,
0.7380901575,
-0.0324643143,
-0.1179868802,
0.0709658861,
0.1185725033,
-0.115421541,
0.5930848122,
-0.1498956233,
0.5032256246,
-1.3427017927,
0.5754294395,
1.0102107525,
-0.1763595045,
-0.4310944974,
0.5115065575,
-0.039652396,
-0.0080174962,
0.3096289635,
0.3962672651,
-0.2888475955,
-0.0176595449,
0.3919276595,
-0.6697496176,
0.766811192,
0.0341881253,
-0.1892087758,
-0.187234953,
0.4567619264,
0.5808159709,
-0.2369747758,
0.7989479899,
0.2981238067,
0.5242391825,
-0.1403568536,
-0.5524331927,
-0.1515101343,
-0.206162259,
-0.4517613053,
0.7579320669,
-0.7113554478,
0.8817321062,
0.274125278,
0.0625160113,
-0.0290064905,
0.3660417497,
-0.3512781262,
0.8522036672,
0.6794920564,
0.8224033713,
0.3525136113,
-0.2248654515,
0.5684280396,
-0.3620762229,
0.4979693294,
0.4764501452,
-0.4820907116,
0.4883015752,
0.1726533771,
-0.1970371157,
0.4144921005,
0.3278413415,
-0.1088421047,
0.6870991588,
0.250828594,
-0.2626731098,
-0.2668544352,
-0.332025975,
-0.0842467323,
1.0212380886,
0.2542556822,
-0.3231703937,
-0.3929218948,
0.3980174959,
-0.2739158273,
0.543566823,
-0.2161348909,
0.6033733487,
-0.0958885178,
-1.1615539789,
0.1116164774,
0.7465134263,
0.7418879271,
-0.5081832409,
-0.148827076,
-0.1950722188,
0.3818293512,
-0.0604965836,
-0.4478591979,
0.7422516942,
0.2738645673,
-0.4845511913,
-0.0079313042,
1.0542269945,
-0.322071135,
-0.6763442159,
0.4593943357,
0.3494704664,
-0.282463938,
-0.0827069059,
-0.4452114403,
-0.1670137197,
-0.4027389884,
-0.2383169234,
0.3480983377,
0.3642165363,
-0.4007201195,
0.2556052208,
0.380471617,
-0.3567012548,
-0.5021390915,
-0.152674064,
0.8351855278,
-0.3083524108,
-0.9916548133,
-0.8423613906,
0.1784062684,
-0.0238225982,
-0.3113556504,
0.7029064894,
0.552247107,
0.6499451995,
0.0409430936,
0.7442106009,
0.1733412296,
0.8394708037,
-0.4012647569,
0.8346047401,
-0.6475280523,
0.1968851238,
-0.6716299653,
-0.8714090586,
-0.352787137,
0.4044189155,
-0.5279048681,
0.0741018206,
0.8886796832,
0.8242010474,
-0.2624383271,
0.437155515,
0.4857926667,
-0.2764424682,
0.1406257898,
0.487157315,
1.0296741724,
-0.5648376942,
0.7396877408,
-0.2466448843,
-0.3590076566,
-0.1326926202,
-0.6041675806,
-1.3470288515,
-0.6524981856,
-0.6105360389,
0.0828403458,
0.0435813852,
0.6552013159,
0.4414794743,
-0.9511404634,
0.1555781215,
-0.1739507616,
-0.1406203061,
-0.0216824152,
-0.3427115679,
0.6648313403,
0.107690759,
-0.4176893234,
0.3025675416,
0.6073446274,
-0.2291914821,
-0.402348429,
0.2401421517,
-0.2793285847,
0.4546197653,
0.1052386016,
-0.2209059447,
-0.5301588178,
-0.2209459841,
0.1101091132,
0.1296491772,
-0.0156114884,
1.0560394526,
-0.7757686377,
-0.018085137,
0.3643765152,
0.5284007788,
0.1034803391,
0.1599392891,
0.0494893864,
-0.8103437424,
0.012227837,
0.3260359466,
0.3274125457,
0.2760913968,
-0.6907147169,
0.0409576856,
0.6064532399,
-0.5208774209,
-0.6711500287,
-0.1535845697,
-0.3868274987,
-0.3712306917,
0.4103259146,
-0.6288815737,
-0.035202235,
-0.4582236111,
-0.1014734954,
0.4716026485,
-0.2694309056,
1.4302796125,
0.5286114812,
-0.0777479336,
0.3081454635,
0.1581382751,
0.2261043042,
0.565949142,
-1.1618314981,
-0.3329812288,
-0.0710541531,
-0.0888618678,
0.5876373649,
0.3257736266,
0.0854533687,
0.4296879768,
-0.0461492054,
-0.1510842294,
-0.0294691026,
-0.6218709946,
-0.2374448925,
0.7201339006,
-0.4675140381,
-0.4934653342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16303v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16303v3
|
Large Language Models in Biomedical and Health Informatics: A Bibliometric Review
| 2024-03-24T21:29:39 | 2024-04-23T23:13:24 |
Huizi Yu, Lizhou Fan, Lingyao Li, Jiayan Zhou, Zihui Ma, Lu Xian, Wenyue Hua, Sijia He, Mingyu Jin, Yongfeng Zhang, Ashvin Gandhi, Xin Ma
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have rapidly become important tools in
Biomedical and Health Informatics (BHI), enabling new ways to analyze data,
treat patients, and conduct research. This bibliometric review aims to provide
a panoramic view of how LLMs have been used in BHI by examining research
articles and collaboration networks from 2022 to 2023. It further explores how
LLMs can improve Natural Language Processing (NLP) applications in various BHI
areas like medical diagnosis, patient engagement, electronic health record
management, and personalized medicine. To do this, our bibliometric review
identifies key trends, maps out research networks, and highlights major
developments in this fast-moving field. Lastly, it discusses the ethical
concerns and practical challenges of using LLMs in BHI, such as data privacy
and reliable medical recommendations. Looking ahead, we consider how LLMs could
further transform biomedical research as well as healthcare delivery and
patient outcomes. This bibliometric review serves as a resource for
stakeholders in healthcare, including researchers, clinicians, and
policymakers, to understand the current state and future potential of LLMs in
BHI.
|
[
-0.0758331344,
-0.6227309704,
0.6600657701,
0.2327588052,
-0.0953438058,
0.149525851,
-0.3597297072,
-1.0848232508,
0.189708665,
0.7157723904,
-0.2535913289,
-0.3777549565,
-0.7261055112,
0.302120626,
-0.505666554,
0.8823773265,
0.1546300054,
0.4972688258,
-0.3765736222,
-0.063773647,
-0.205709517,
-0.6000117064,
-0.4373335242,
-0.768974483,
0.9574512839,
0.0398341231,
0.989226222,
0.60022825,
0.9102050662,
0.229907766,
-0.4853495359,
0.003000105,
-0.5105068684,
0.3043356538,
-0.2352539897,
-0.3033336699,
-0.5408126116,
-0.3082256317,
0.6877817512,
1.3362265825,
-0.0116727464,
0.2344105691,
-0.11217843,
0.8916221261,
-0.1522356123,
0.1672758758,
-0.161477834,
0.097267434,
-0.3946551383,
-0.2567977905,
-0.3461950123,
-0.3712960184,
0.3307724297,
-0.0660478324,
-0.2785886526,
0.3412100971,
0.5221781135,
0.1433564425,
-0.5429965854,
-0.3226850927,
-1.0181633234,
0.8177024722,
-0.8432031274,
0.7971197367,
0.2811132073,
0.2135344148,
-0.4381870031,
-0.9208977222,
-0.2965859771,
-0.1469221115,
0.0496465303,
-0.0562494695,
-0.3687360585,
0.1280772835,
0.1660549939,
0.4494745433,
-0.6936510205,
0.5095572472,
-0.6106618643,
0.0161501411,
0.7743623257,
0.4306178093,
0.3440628946,
-0.2533081174,
-0.0794337392,
0.2531095147,
-1.0705240965,
-0.2703827322,
-0.0549442545,
0.1781824827,
-0.0240505114,
0.7189557552,
-0.1288075447,
0.7009342909,
-0.4287462533,
-0.374682188,
0.4890007079,
-0.506752789,
-0.5240756273,
0.1021611989,
0.9309353232,
0.3803207278,
-0.0151744876,
-0.2808022201,
0.1921397746,
-0.2416549176,
0.1902597398,
-0.9470194578,
0.0077236192,
0.7042950988,
-0.9317343235,
0.0025051346,
-0.1753437072,
-0.7208217382,
-0.6195103526,
-0.4217965901,
-0.2378150225,
-0.4692940712,
-0.1920624077,
0.3799465001,
0.1529799253,
0.0772583485,
0.2358603328,
-0.6744067073,
0.227892682,
0.9056895375,
0.9788439274,
-0.023244204,
-0.2603477836,
-0.0949857086,
0.3534673154,
-0.4600903988,
0.5392902493,
-0.3048277497,
-0.6118362546,
0.3515844047,
0.1239427701,
0.1740399003,
-0.5539385676,
0.2098111808,
-0.4514406025,
-0.0751221254,
-0.5082898736,
-0.5608780384,
-0.1421112865,
0.282807976,
-0.861107409,
0.3679690957,
-0.2386648804,
-0.9113979936,
0.1447854787,
-0.6706729531,
-0.5921976566,
0.4412932694,
0.0442361161,
-0.4398894608,
0.0216648094,
-0.1613043547,
0.6346275806,
-0.7816461325,
0.4422492385,
-0.4717416763,
-0.2348881215,
0.4424465001,
-0.0305671468,
1.0449798107,
0.2556815445,
0.0668231174,
0.3423581123,
-0.6645233631,
-0.1607679576,
-0.0527036265,
-0.1919372529,
-0.3657282889,
0.3812656105,
0.2973723114,
0.021759551,
0.4051205218,
-0.5335537791,
-0.0477482416,
-0.7436198592,
0.5951820612,
0.2787253559,
0.1408281028,
0.3516048789,
-0.2991413176,
0.337843895,
-0.2027736306,
0.540147543,
-0.0307170078,
-0.6425908208,
-0.1096683145,
-0.2408288717,
0.382374227,
0.4738918543,
-0.3708438575,
0.5162518024,
-0.2354437113,
-0.6870804429,
-0.5810571909,
0.0281741414,
0.0944740102,
0.3762896359,
0.2853454649,
-0.167365849,
-0.5707817078,
-0.8720397949,
-0.040207278,
-0.3060564399,
0.0380511209,
0.1839645505,
0.4876058698,
-0.932659328,
0.600923419,
-0.0219072066,
-0.1382744163,
-0.3874891698,
-0.084397234,
0.1724770069,
0.1130070686,
0.2313932478,
-0.8277316689,
-0.2590310574,
0.3505623937,
-0.9578431249,
-0.0873365551,
0.364122808,
0.0387809537,
0.0549625605,
0.3581467569,
-0.5721090436,
0.2284034044,
0.734265089,
-0.3208962977,
0.3877258599,
-0.1248178706,
-0.0609826148,
-1.0243897438,
0.3705918193,
0.048098702,
-0.2301630676,
-0.5683723092,
-0.0088816658,
-0.0758979097,
0.0044431332,
-0.0487255529,
0.6180109978,
-0.5617552996,
-0.1246544719,
-0.4253748655,
-0.3032042384,
-0.1279814392,
-0.5508911014,
-0.1606418788,
0.2338231504,
0.5572839975,
-0.3594353199,
0.5535874963,
0.545462966,
-0.5170301199,
0.4771054685,
-0.8425168395,
-0.1061614379,
-0.1698648781,
0.4020648897,
-0.5622771382,
-0.3450356722,
0.0477917902,
-0.3064967096,
0.2273137271,
0.1339862347,
-1.0116244555,
-0.586683929,
-0.2529179752,
0.1489866674,
0.3535518646,
-0.2910094559,
0.289239198,
0.7448826432,
-0.4437357485,
-0.3660080433,
-0.9699651003,
0.4353528619,
0.090487808,
-0.4686035812,
0.3331187665,
-0.1611850411,
-0.6401583552,
0.1391247809,
0.2888291478,
0.0090989787,
0.0640839636,
0.3633354008,
0.4783442616,
-0.0461586006,
0.361897856,
-0.085103251,
0.1278597414,
0.2643702626,
-0.0577490106,
0.5416939259,
0.0637418628,
-0.1566768885,
-0.3189482987,
0.6688469648,
0.5538904071,
-0.3384344876,
0.8561709523,
0.4941373467,
-0.4956906736,
0.3316119611,
-0.5095089078,
-0.1370935738,
-0.3012683392,
0.6666512489,
0.3865354657,
-1.1678862572,
0.3772915006,
-0.1902881116,
0.200899899,
0.0897018537,
1.0944755077,
-0.0599734448,
0.8334342837,
0.7723046541,
-0.2240690142,
0.2125577629,
0.0452681407,
0.5527706742,
-0.9221310019,
-0.6070759892,
-0.5599742532,
-0.1710174978,
-0.9237808585,
-0.2723597884,
0.5728251338,
-0.3111245334,
-0.2261236757,
-0.2209861279,
-0.2081174999,
0.060347043,
0.2157808542,
0.0419721939,
0.4189002216,
-0.1941218674,
0.1653210074,
0.0209976882,
-0.5707747936,
-0.5312880874,
1.1296474934,
0.6883295774,
0.7968905568,
0.1386490762,
0.5944503546,
0.0268909223,
0.4386685193,
-0.8502159119,
0.3754992783,
-0.178529337,
-0.8551225662,
-0.4395483136,
-0.5022789836,
-1.29424119,
-0.0392139629,
-0.2684968412,
-0.7964978218,
0.0917876437,
-0.0755242407,
-0.173504293,
0.3754358292,
-0.3039123416,
0.5735448599,
-0.4207350314,
-0.5071083307,
-0.2842897773,
-0.9437904954,
0.3079882562,
-0.0553772561,
0.3723683655,
-0.1236702427,
-0.0559216738,
0.652363956,
-0.1489075869,
0.6840979457,
0.236178562,
-0.0457696356,
-0.0893256962,
-0.0288642608,
0.0846936405,
0.0017311795,
-0.3015795946,
0.5732012391,
0.3725000024,
-0.2576811612,
-0.162649855,
0.8030930758,
-0.5233926773,
-0.4256226122,
-0.5868626237,
-0.6789895296,
-0.4993967712,
0.3791945577,
0.0164821632,
0.3723883629,
-0.2984437048,
0.4470010996,
0.788844347,
-0.3621375263,
0.2741818726,
0.3801858425,
-0.4414359629,
-0.2448463142,
0.6552126408,
0.23820436,
-0.0523938201,
0.3821495473,
0.3442604542,
-0.319583416,
-0.9225925207,
-0.1716949344,
0.716298461,
-0.5338395834,
-0.1635462791,
-0.6288307905,
-0.2983143628,
-0.4676436186,
0.109628886,
-0.152899906,
0.1729693264,
-0.2511501014,
-0.0237753689,
0.4209467471,
1.1497417688,
-0.0073544444,
0.1128330454,
-0.8581673503,
0.1327581257,
-0.0561189279,
0.5404313207,
0.041302193,
-0.1228991002,
-0.4973402619,
-0.3051272333,
0.0997088924,
-0.9987365603,
0.5171276331,
-0.1719607413,
0.4554412961,
0.1416085064,
-0.3944506347,
0.3180430233,
-0.9012439251,
0.7414349914,
0.4299476743,
-0.5601076484,
0.2546374202,
-0.3535140753,
0.3339236379,
0.4055453539,
0.7582618594,
-0.857247293,
0.0791580081,
-0.3142650127,
-0.9854880571,
0.1983803511,
-0.2124644071,
-0.0101229576,
0.0732422397,
0.1295738816,
0.0690136179,
0.3657681346,
-0.4932174087,
-0.2317065746,
0.1840508282,
-0.326790452,
-0.0544708297,
-0.5380476713,
-0.2971996665,
-0.0960953832,
0.5480420589,
0.015708074,
0.3258239031,
0.177831471,
0.2072873265,
-0.3091363609,
0.4539348483,
0.0974637195,
0.8363181949,
-0.2142208517,
-0.0497933067,
-0.1628050059,
-0.296785295,
-0.2031145841,
0.2811236978,
-0.1957143694,
0.0530479811,
0.5164714456,
0.5812313557,
0.311173737,
-0.877584815,
0.372669369,
0.2168712914,
-0.113439545,
-0.2410340756,
-0.3310590684,
0.4103927314,
0.4431893229,
0.0599876791,
-0.2903868854,
0.4642417133,
-0.6863499284,
-0.1867147982,
0.5649492145,
-0.2261845171,
-0.3171378076,
0.4171414077,
0.1406700313,
-0.3413285613,
0.2283941805,
0.2360970229,
-0.0472077578,
0.1324895769,
0.4743289351,
0.3787843585,
-0.2919486761,
0.0606915094,
0.082687594,
0.3513392508,
-0.433903724,
0.237070784,
0.428481698,
-0.5034268498,
-0.7636294961,
-0.6378522515,
-0.8211094141,
0.3899492919,
-0.4278059006,
0.1633040756,
-0.4513098598,
-0.2103723884,
0.3392178416,
0.1295142919,
-0.5884125233,
0.2157639414,
0.3742589056,
0.7469311357,
-0.4902065992,
0.8679621816,
0.7664475441,
-0.2489442676,
-0.4869801104,
-0.0763694942,
0.1257063895,
-0.4045874476,
0.4872283936,
-0.1644872725,
0.07231877,
-0.3572906554,
-0.7091678977,
-0.8481371999,
1.0104455948,
0.3136067986,
-0.9496458173,
-0.310408771,
0.1097587571,
0.8569909334,
-0.1861776561,
0.0494814739,
0.4533978105,
0.5732862353,
-0.0944255888,
-1.1253428459,
-0.0885536745,
-0.1454898268,
0.1051204875,
0.0527517796,
-0.7696402073,
0.7565358877,
-0.0061488207,
0.2106860578,
0.2352265716,
0.4973701537,
0.2861819863,
0.5715815425,
0.0237193834,
0.2797220349,
0.9299867153,
0.2080529034,
1.3447619677,
-0.2090841532,
0.1919689029,
0.6703566313,
-1.016587615,
0.7784844041,
0.6019594073,
-0.3836301267,
0.5008721352,
0.5468250513,
0.0029691744,
0.0410856903,
0.2072975636,
-0.1657378525,
-0.0908979401,
-0.3155710995,
-0.4685504436,
0.330520153,
0.6419454813,
-0.5042283535,
0.122795403,
0.2041220814,
0.2218491435,
0.1833658814,
-0.3799566031,
0.5893526673,
0.2813256383,
-0.2429869622,
0.2242314219,
0.1224785,
0.4694068432,
-0.7330597639,
0.0795303434,
0.1519518346,
-0.0504952483,
-0.3823696673,
-0.7571951151,
0.4241628945,
0.0350280926,
-0.3897832632,
-0.1125804856,
0.8788756132,
-0.2543626428,
-0.5897854567,
0.6580878496,
0.6093205214,
0.0920419246,
0.3544713557,
-0.6311725974,
0.4716277122,
-0.1121942252,
-0.3593789637,
0.4762072265,
0.3552488983,
-0.0732369795,
0.7387365103,
0.7730365992,
0.6618570685,
-0.1965239346,
0.1111328453,
0.6266868114,
-0.8822183013,
-0.1904469579,
-0.8761373758,
0.0264387466,
-0.1546602249,
-0.0672679693,
0.6384970546,
0.4608922005,
0.431977123,
0.224000752,
1.011544466,
0.0305054802,
0.9395768046,
-0.4458440542,
0.8221930265,
-0.5373908281,
0.1252651811,
-0.0981718302,
-0.5303811431,
-0.7271644473,
0.4906685352,
-0.4791602194,
0.0259800814,
0.767310679,
0.5116811991,
0.2413523942,
0.2151031047,
0.4662084579,
0.5401764512,
0.4106377065,
0.3025973737,
0.6153836846,
-0.1003045589,
-0.0181938354,
-0.0110181998,
-0.0713910833,
-0.5101786256,
-0.8238696456,
-0.9132432342,
-0.4074120522,
-0.2109558731,
-0.3706026375,
0.2576997578,
1.1036515236,
0.7130457759,
-0.6725931168,
-0.4215045869,
0.2007650286,
0.1504374892,
-0.032831613,
-0.1532326788,
0.152992934,
0.0541653931,
-0.6125603318,
0.4528107643,
0.7590689659,
-0.1483576149,
-0.7027099133,
-0.0212982222,
-0.2478324175,
0.0034208789,
0.8388189673,
0.2905563414,
-0.7018036842,
0.0946681648,
0.0623190627,
-0.3116609752,
-0.1140811145,
0.7954740524,
-0.4354255497,
0.3757481277,
0.4299952686,
0.8172256947,
0.1890326738,
-0.4584437311,
0.3079045117,
-0.0044159968,
0.1187122539,
0.5537856221,
0.5754102468,
0.7406275868,
-0.3281250596,
0.4870906472,
0.1231315956,
-0.9531156421,
-1.1002570391,
0.1696854532,
-1.1695281267,
-0.2981992066,
1.3810691833,
0.1457381845,
-0.5608472228,
-0.3438457549,
-0.0339170471,
0.1479927748,
-0.107772842,
0.7320898175,
0.4959710836,
-0.2129849344,
-0.0210726373,
-0.8558237553,
0.2961540818,
0.2573049963,
-1.1235712767,
0.1399986595,
0.497933358,
0.1102377921,
0.0168933682,
0.6855641007,
-0.5521214008,
0.1789576709,
-0.6493276954,
0.1218970865,
0.0770817026,
-0.2038543969,
-0.3608915508,
-0.0608208366,
0.2951209545,
0.475451082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16295v1
|
LexDrafter: Terminology Drafting for Legislative Documents using Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-03-24T21:02:35 | 2024-03-24T21:02:35 |
Ashish Chouhan, Michael Gertz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the increase in legislative documents at the EU, the number of new terms
and their definitions is increasing as well. As per the Joint Practical Guide
of the European Parliament, the Council and the Commission, terms used in legal
documents shall be consistent, and identical concepts shall be expressed
without departing from their meaning in ordinary, legal, or technical language.
Thus, while drafting a new legislative document, having a framework that
provides insights about existing definitions and helps define new terms based
on a document's context will support such harmonized legal definitions across
different regulations and thus avoid ambiguities. In this paper, we present
LexDrafter, a framework that assists in drafting Definitions articles for
legislative documents using retrieval augmented generation (RAG) and existing
term definitions present in different legislative documents. For this,
definition elements are built by extracting definitions from existing
documents. Using definition elements and RAG, a Definitions article can be
suggested on demand for a legislative document that is being drafted. We
demonstrate and evaluate the functionality of LexDrafter using a collection of
EU documents from the energy domain. The code for LexDrafter framework is
available at https://github.com/achouhan93/LexDrafter.
|
[
-0.4936197698,
-0.5455096364,
0.4576916099,
0.1258601695,
-0.7053034306,
0.3958598375,
0.1598909646,
-0.4570850432,
0.8093754053,
0.7556359768,
-0.2538512945,
-0.2203587145,
-0.4914003015,
0.3361588717,
-0.5030621886,
0.6481608748,
-0.4462405443,
-0.2454983443,
-0.2075492144,
-0.1813018918,
-0.3700432479,
-0.1668550521,
-0.4912784696,
-0.6647965312,
0.498491168,
-0.1804094017,
0.5009064674,
0.817127943,
0.5383828282,
0.3988946676,
-0.210489139,
0.069986254,
-0.194394052,
0.2636796832,
-0.3469571173,
-0.2774846852,
-0.5507535338,
-0.2072450519,
0.8236658573,
0.170372501,
-0.2878550887,
0.3437544405,
-0.0588248633,
0.6319723725,
-0.8076311946,
0.1152247339,
-0.9351491332,
-0.0356993824,
-0.304602176,
-0.6237670183,
-0.1258045733,
-0.3079290688,
-0.2273316085,
-0.7377420068,
0.3011398315,
0.2649452388,
1.2282916307,
0.3821054399,
-0.1035778373,
-0.5152626038,
-0.407563597,
-0.0212902669,
-0.4640986919,
0.5177296996,
-0.0484258868,
0.4601991773,
0.2271257639,
-1.2335041761,
-0.7912476063,
-0.1204514056,
-0.2818929255,
0.2026159167,
-0.2567948103,
0.3015844822,
0.4184199274,
0.2841330171,
-0.453173995,
-0.0810334459,
-0.4533583522,
-0.4973430336,
0.6677122116,
0.0644167438,
0.208350122,
-0.4747406542,
-0.6821357012,
-0.027925007,
-0.9313547611,
-0.2529931366,
0.7304077744,
0.3280837834,
-0.0572870858,
0.8666309714,
0.2127956301,
0.4493311346,
0.0699198171,
0.458453536,
0.5435029268,
-0.3976096511,
-0.2678813636,
0.3420693874,
0.2658450007,
0.2890566587,
-0.5980225801,
-0.136882484,
-0.6351313591,
-0.2718524933,
0.3617709577,
-0.9572954178,
0.0585133843,
0.1151180267,
-0.4777595103,
0.0182038937,
0.381739974,
-0.8769296408,
-0.4111281037,
-0.689607203,
0.1084456593,
-0.2906029522,
-0.4687177837,
0.045398511,
-0.8939118981,
0.4013459086,
-0.0115597546,
-0.6584189534,
0.0866626352,
0.8419386148,
0.7703108191,
0.0322023407,
0.18510589,
-0.7291328907,
0.1256761551,
-0.1004341766,
0.9920876622,
-0.554494977,
-0.7944530845,
0.1536958665,
0.1724496186,
0.0259865746,
-0.4206848145,
0.4882766008,
-0.5582060814,
-0.1586520821,
-0.1195073426,
-0.8953971863,
0.0351500027,
0.0238663275,
-0.9414588809,
0.840393424,
0.3501173556,
-0.6972034574,
0.7720184326,
-0.9149703979,
-0.2531863153,
0.8819903135,
-0.480935812,
-0.3466685116,
0.2831360102,
-0.3751966655,
0.1037713364,
0.0615011528,
0.168111816,
0.11854285,
-0.0704777017,
-0.308246851,
0.1287371665,
0.8626458645,
0.5973292589,
-0.099191457,
0.3003919423,
-0.7148560286,
0.0595734417,
-0.2498443723,
-0.5822868347,
-0.5734210014,
-0.1279875636,
0.5204380155,
0.0898705646,
0.5042980313,
-0.7114816308,
-0.1092870608,
-0.4708286226,
0.2456008196,
0.3652321994,
0.2531729639,
0.3664721549,
-0.6052609086,
0.7839912772,
-0.4992938638,
-0.3584240675,
-0.1249496937,
-0.1126980633,
-0.6124662161,
-0.0814355388,
0.6203036308,
0.5808503628,
-1.1963133812,
0.7830967903,
-0.2537605464,
-0.5604228973,
-0.5306797028,
0.0596455745,
0.3788352609,
0.0881111771,
0.2194780856,
0.1526607871,
-1.0411471128,
-0.75997293,
-0.3394017816,
-0.1985138655,
-0.0195050389,
0.2725564837,
0.5848457813,
-0.1219553277,
0.9236397743,
-0.0990279168,
-0.1334116012,
-0.4713370204,
0.679620266,
-0.1439497173,
0.2067071348,
0.5955376029,
-1.1033375263,
-0.4042175412,
0.1114348248,
-0.4211729169,
-0.2676779032,
-0.6116369963,
-0.0838997886,
0.2888889611,
0.864187479,
-0.4167202711,
0.3432943821,
0.2295610607,
-0.6211443543,
0.548104465,
-0.3802386522,
-0.285400629,
-1.4343723059,
0.4980229437,
-0.1307279617,
-0.2131350487,
-0.253921926,
0.7146233916,
0.2596482038,
0.1102702096,
-0.7186324596,
1.0254286528,
-0.4874430001,
-0.0163977519,
-0.2406771034,
0.3679858148,
0.1344318837,
-0.3208039105,
-0.0153500801,
1.0814042091,
0.2700336874,
-0.4026414752,
0.4895484149,
0.5307097435,
-0.2805404067,
0.4295757115,
-0.4994074404,
-0.0637165308,
-0.1842724532,
-0.0083216466,
-0.451397717,
-0.0944356844,
-0.1580078453,
-0.1847395003,
0.5556336641,
0.154341206,
-0.5960445404,
-0.5207079053,
-0.2763795257,
-0.2078659534,
0.197878018,
-0.3661592603,
1.1368300915,
0.6480281949,
-0.1810991019,
-0.5719656944,
-0.416449517,
0.1227965504,
-0.1892905235,
-0.3760709167,
0.7263601422,
-0.0231466405,
-0.5639458895,
0.3130325079,
-0.3582075238,
0.0566168092,
-0.0272605475,
0.4181732833,
0.3486357927,
-0.0830292702,
0.2969813347,
0.2870201766,
0.0058108703,
0.128831014,
0.2076351792,
0.5587638021,
0.0119707063,
-0.0432032831,
-0.0453949869,
0.3012240231,
0.2441027015,
-0.1622089297,
0.3122259676,
0.5663392544,
-0.1047041193,
-0.3184944689,
-0.5478739142,
0.1293079555,
-0.5284804702,
0.0959403664,
-0.6305828094,
-0.9902306795,
0.6068772674,
-0.3366625905,
0.561799109,
0.6819130182,
0.4465638995,
0.1863386333,
0.2959843278,
0.9686424732,
0.3128003478,
0.5451357365,
-0.1706545204,
0.2397785932,
-0.8333051801,
-0.1839770228,
-0.8186685443,
-0.1172473058,
-0.6686998606,
-0.2129026651,
0.1289503574,
-0.1123465225,
0.1961777359,
0.8025793433,
-0.4821188748,
0.5981219411,
0.2132867873,
-0.2966167927,
0.0685655177,
-0.0631511137,
-0.4669084549,
0.3910404146,
-0.3211870193,
-0.6801493764,
0.7599113584,
0.0381398201,
0.363966614,
-0.2493515611,
1.2063592672,
0.3402463198,
0.3061725497,
-0.8512806296,
0.5563684702,
-0.1754382551,
-0.6635201573,
-0.2873853445,
-0.4601155519,
-1.0386612415,
0.1673803777,
-0.3701831996,
-0.3507356048,
0.3746365309,
-0.0976591408,
-0.5600547194,
0.5042695403,
-0.2216983885,
0.5234780908,
0.0347210243,
-0.2075489461,
-0.2112077773,
-0.2975649536,
0.0731286332,
-0.4216120541,
-0.021609392,
-0.3385812044,
-0.2245449275,
0.6256714463,
-0.3705300987,
0.1895758212,
-0.3753730953,
-0.2818426192,
0.6008633971,
-0.0647955984,
0.1769360155,
0.1136865541,
-0.5212612748,
-0.0989992321,
0.4070557952,
0.0221655462,
-0.3688265085,
0.2234369963,
-0.1615522355,
-0.4426525235,
-0.1622656286,
-0.5217419863,
0.1823506951,
0.5681005716,
0.4850527048,
0.4615729153,
-0.4496564865,
0.1940177083,
0.2363129258,
-0.0314085744,
0.5217300057,
0.4710977972,
-0.3088596463,
-0.0913789049,
0.807525754,
0.0686291009,
-0.2470195144,
0.4920489192,
-0.0289124921,
-0.8206143379,
-0.5820140839,
-0.2144399583,
0.0808395147,
-0.6728788614,
-0.4648138583,
-0.2273930609,
-0.5571835041,
-0.1492937058,
-0.2910407782,
0.0716516078,
-0.6147407293,
-0.0377504006,
-0.2711159885,
0.2478294969,
0.5516555309,
-0.217078045,
0.060124848,
-0.8373678327,
0.4283926189,
0.1280221045,
0.4526337981,
-0.6709761024,
-0.1802720726,
0.0833293349,
-0.0943766758,
-0.4113335311,
-0.4321964681,
0.4019933641,
0.2381666601,
0.747123003,
0.2940171957,
0.0617474951,
0.5994722247,
-0.6140408516,
0.6442161798,
0.2904088199,
-0.9624654651,
0.4715729058,
-0.2124309689,
0.1822431833,
0.7497426867,
0.1416658014,
-0.3742209673,
-0.5986124873,
-0.602819562,
-1.0191332102,
0.0534257181,
0.1937139481,
0.6394955516,
-0.1231937259,
0.607329607,
0.2281074524,
0.2048956454,
-0.225127548,
-0.0858871639,
-0.1084615663,
0.1675155759,
0.3018978834,
-0.0815817788,
-0.2049240917,
-0.1226573139,
0.8350269794,
-0.0611427911,
0.3428346515,
0.0397384726,
-0.0523216352,
-0.2616486549,
0.622303009,
0.5144196749,
0.9273908138,
-0.4182561934,
0.1121150106,
-0.1114823073,
-0.6736614704,
-0.0932080224,
0.6224467754,
-0.4162349403,
0.6832718253,
-0.0057787402,
0.7495033145,
0.131230846,
-0.7814998627,
0.1934327036,
-0.1347578019,
-0.8781765103,
-0.471257031,
0.0530691296,
0.0131211765,
0.2178777307,
0.2841877043,
0.1196655929,
0.1721112877,
-0.3708538413,
0.6115783453,
0.47927019,
-0.0433463491,
0.0411587246,
0.6860287189,
0.2510683239,
-0.3273167312,
0.1714270413,
-0.5858958364,
-0.2202106565,
0.6249719858,
0.418936044,
0.9899991751,
0.070910424,
0.2460811883,
0.4238967299,
-0.0011618782,
0.106369637,
0.6376441717,
-0.1307639182,
-0.6859152317,
-0.2824759185,
-0.9948897958,
-0.3945429623,
-0.0176387522,
-0.835740447,
0.4297848642,
-0.4836113155,
-0.5048232079,
0.3880294561,
0.1555124372,
-0.4821553528,
-0.5624873638,
0.3186627328,
1.4668449163,
-0.4325792789,
0.7157133818,
0.9288076758,
-0.449115932,
-0.8119874001,
-0.1146552935,
-0.0163358562,
-0.6953372955,
0.5099146962,
-0.0505318232,
-0.2732059658,
0.0788630173,
-0.2101781964,
-0.7579200268,
1.2858278751,
0.1501725614,
-0.6866250038,
-0.2863102853,
0.0559643283,
0.4331920743,
-0.2316893637,
-0.2526661754,
0.6516621709,
0.7293868661,
0.468531251,
-0.9670203924,
0.1653107703,
-0.7033475637,
0.0684869811,
0.470341742,
0.0195879359,
0.4529231489,
0.2323218286,
-0.5712057948,
0.3732691705,
0.4664458632,
0.2217704356,
0.3052244186,
0.4816857278,
0.5765724778,
0.8573619723,
-0.117745623,
0.8369671106,
-0.8049414158,
0.241131857,
1.1730496883,
-0.6328759789,
0.9847068191,
0.6073979139,
0.1163701639,
0.5192562938,
0.2469355315,
-0.3953481913,
0.3233640492,
0.2132499814,
-0.3775871098,
-0.0612675957,
-0.1586421579,
-0.3330197036,
0.3893082738,
0.5419300199,
-0.3686443269,
-0.8343827724,
-0.0317997448,
-0.1251797229,
0.243607372,
-0.4347632229,
0.9258430004,
0.032458622,
-0.5940239429,
0.6098433137,
-0.0068670781,
0.4070814252,
-0.4418491423,
-0.1975404024,
0.0034365179,
-0.1109160408,
-0.1849489957,
-0.9416366816,
0.8232169747,
0.0622220151,
0.2119368762,
-0.6122466326,
0.6824520826,
-0.233434692,
-0.4553305805,
0.1968931258,
0.7722550631,
0.1597606987,
0.2231610417,
-0.9559203982,
-0.0089594722,
-0.2828653157,
0.1043303162,
0.0336151123,
0.3761800826,
0.2890484333,
0.2106354684,
0.3498337269,
0.4471926391,
0.0782503858,
0.1129481345,
1.024428606,
-0.1428767592,
-0.6564046741,
-0.5467336774,
0.5145103931,
-0.3205406964,
-0.242660746,
0.6075772047,
1.0423579216,
0.6791189909,
0.1275519133,
0.8267862797,
-0.5311891437,
0.4240889549,
-0.7267981172,
0.9989851117,
-0.510001123,
0.1852281839,
0.1009451076,
-1.0865063667,
-0.3027562201,
0.41669029,
-0.075841777,
-0.3989166021,
0.7060750127,
0.7333264947,
-0.0422387421,
0.1023083478,
0.2174759209,
-0.1128672287,
0.0851353407,
-0.1421239525,
0.4364897609,
-0.0212025288,
0.2620950341,
-0.0353569016,
0.2338571995,
-0.0324187018,
-0.9088153839,
-0.7814229727,
-0.8472459912,
-0.1027448401,
-0.1932518631,
0.0430662036,
1.2178206444,
0.3951602876,
-0.62480551,
-0.2997344732,
-0.3947216272,
0.1746978462,
-0.0156991407,
-0.2413923293,
0.4274196625,
-0.6951029301,
-0.3930721879,
0.2321189046,
0.1041230336,
0.0156815089,
0.0130391875,
0.0557198003,
-0.0866791308,
0.3642713726,
0.4336199164,
0.4457153678,
-0.6806557178,
-0.0846310779,
-0.487855196,
0.0357504487,
0.1537035257,
1.1354262829,
-0.7236710191,
0.5506973863,
0.6013526917,
0.6986204982,
0.4491758943,
0.1146610081,
0.2687216699,
-0.9196822643,
0.144942224,
0.2582153678,
0.7622480989,
0.0819875896,
-0.3816108406,
0.5607779622,
-0.0109124091,
-0.1708970368,
-0.5978402495,
0.0317466781,
-0.9812365174,
-0.3234251738,
0.948223114,
0.03003796,
-0.2083216757,
-0.2046682537,
-0.2936831713,
0.4144425392,
-0.4204845726,
0.8742383122,
0.4715347886,
-0.0134383636,
-0.1621839255,
-0.7190318704,
0.7333370447,
-0.2608888745,
-1.0047274828,
0.24007155,
0.542650938,
0.1373804212,
0.5450401306,
0.5263913274,
-0.1694243401,
0.374633044,
0.2051639259,
0.1676580906,
-0.3849686682,
-0.0015038763,
-0.3722591996,
0.2031137943,
-0.3014883995,
0.2490883172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16265v1
|
Connecting the Dots: Inferring Patent Phrase Similarity with Retrieved Phrase Graphs
| 2024-03-24T18:59:38 | 2024-03-24T18:59:38 |
Zhuoyi Peng, Yi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We study the patent phrase similarity inference task, which measures the
semantic similarity between two patent phrases. As patent documents employ
legal and highly technical language, existing semantic textual similarity
methods that use localized contextual information do not perform satisfactorily
in inferring patent phrase similarity. To address this, we introduce a
graph-augmented approach to amplify the global contextual information of the
patent phrases. For each patent phrase, we construct a phrase graph that links
to its focal patents and a list of patents that are either cited by or cite
these focal patents. The augmented phrase embedding is then derived from
combining its localized contextual embedding with its global embedding within
the phrase graph. We further propose a self-supervised learning objective that
capitalizes on the retrieved topology to refine both the contextualized
embedding and the graph parameters in an end-to-end manner. Experimental
results from a unique patent phrase similarity dataset demonstrate that our
approach significantly enhances the representation of patent phrases, resulting
in marked improvements in similarity inference in a self-supervised fashion.
Substantial improvements are also observed in the supervised setting,
underscoring the potential benefits of leveraging retrieved phrase graph
augmentation.
|
[
-0.0387475528,
-0.7232525349,
0.6855325103,
0.230142951,
-0.3346445262,
0.4204331338,
0.2921520174,
-0.5511805415,
0.7375645638,
0.8184322715,
-0.2388268858,
-0.6362013221,
-0.4810700715,
0.0719007105,
-0.2845377028,
0.547616303,
0.0674288422,
-0.1592281908,
-0.6363575459,
0.0567026809,
-0.3654552698,
-0.5024502873,
-0.1757016927,
-0.3895712197,
0.3817047179,
0.4204886556,
0.327455014,
0.7582294345,
0.3737097085,
0.3624653816,
-0.211196363,
0.3091333508,
-0.2537510991,
0.1333173811,
-0.0618578121,
-0.2602779567,
-0.1729078293,
0.150173679,
0.3534538746,
1.0612769127,
0.3804292977,
-0.0208251346,
0.4122892916,
0.2895616889,
-0.299620986,
0.2316710949,
-0.7850863338,
0.304207325,
-0.0650425479,
-0.5547146797,
-0.3591303825,
-0.3442697227,
0.1877425164,
-0.9178749919,
0.5369149446,
0.4719867706,
1.1765282154,
-0.0035384994,
-0.4972808361,
-0.2779271007,
-0.1138716489,
0.3764162362,
-0.3647929728,
-0.0314250998,
0.3424092233,
-0.2201279253,
-0.4333193302,
-1.4923125505,
-0.536662221,
-0.4200774431,
-0.2445982695,
-0.0017170451,
-0.2098109424,
-0.0059517645,
0.236878261,
0.0619408339,
-0.662828207,
-0.0050128452,
-0.4454493225,
-0.2487181425,
0.1813106239,
-0.3265223503,
0.1818598211,
-0.5248420835,
-0.7503560781,
0.0138818575,
-0.9237830639,
-0.1329956055,
0.1477271616,
0.5028012395,
0.2692337036,
0.5850996375,
-0.3762268722,
0.6823095679,
0.3195641935,
0.2538881302,
0.634711802,
-0.3744133711,
-0.2684153914,
0.4332421124,
0.5917547941,
0.380997926,
0.1767454445,
-0.6034300327,
0.2310349941,
-0.5268735886,
0.1640433669,
-0.7406978607,
-0.3989869952,
0.0249480419,
-0.52150774,
0.012421621,
0.2007894516,
-0.5819519162,
-0.6279585958,
-0.5379971862,
0.7592514753,
-0.2671232522,
0.2406965643,
-0.1387841254,
-0.6864414215,
0.1393403709,
-0.2293676436,
-0.7988013029,
0.1094032675,
1.072298646,
1.1128332615,
0.1218978986,
-0.4633991718,
-0.4460295439,
0.508633852,
-0.520929873,
1.075184226,
-0.5219183564,
-0.8718956113,
-0.2727867365,
0.2301641405,
-0.2922581136,
-0.8043490052,
0.3640307784,
-0.5179189444,
0.2032628059,
-0.2343175411,
-0.9061027765,
0.0665922463,
0.2279431522,
-0.4373526573,
0.7895255089,
-0.1571254581,
-0.9502238035,
0.8545030355,
-0.5765987635,
-0.6946414709,
0.0762805641,
-0.3319348097,
-0.5430852175,
0.0241652951,
0.2479458302,
0.3567050695,
0.0867990851,
-0.0506967679,
-0.7432928085,
-0.0000364962,
0.1216067225,
0.2801274955,
0.9305199385,
0.2008153647,
-0.1019876078,
0.1395063996,
-0.8492276669,
-0.0495395213,
-0.0945350677,
0.2129891962,
-0.7840451598,
-0.0992485061,
-0.6372119784,
0.0185643546,
0.4637724757,
-0.9127923846,
0.0248055346,
-0.4988594949,
0.3920087814,
0.7631968856,
0.4810009003,
0.3198625743,
-0.0129434625,
0.3162583709,
-0.2216587216,
0.07513652,
-0.1643868685,
-0.7029168606,
-0.4611437619,
-0.4991985559,
0.4262152612,
0.2994323671,
-0.616867125,
0.5620713234,
-0.5724384785,
-0.2811453342,
-0.2571629584,
0.1094093323,
0.2594745457,
1.1451672316,
0.2823350728,
-0.36210379,
-0.3178550899,
-0.8762999177,
-0.5523347259,
0.078607522,
-0.1541821212,
0.6011793017,
0.3740153909,
0.152955547,
1.3127741814,
-0.8742996454,
-0.5156543255,
0.3628585935,
0.5678454638,
0.4494704902,
0.4152419567,
0.6255041361,
-0.7155436873,
-0.8484200835,
0.4426866174,
-0.743478775,
-0.0153807644,
0.0775355101,
0.0464378819,
-0.4483977556,
1.0409480333,
-0.5088135004,
0.3830920458,
-0.0081846043,
-0.5639490485,
0.1835770011,
-0.6572670937,
0.2946425676,
-1.2456341982,
0.2241389453,
-0.2967877686,
-0.1585872173,
-0.3135504723,
-0.0813044906,
0.0834925696,
-0.3859808445,
-0.2873010635,
0.5705733895,
-0.6880023479,
-0.3034557998,
-0.4276579618,
0.4516726732,
0.502371192,
0.1194723099,
-0.397921443,
1.0547792912,
0.7716960311,
-0.4729550481,
0.5161733627,
0.3429590166,
-0.3892974854,
0.5326691866,
-0.792288065,
0.0885050371,
-0.0322579034,
0.0607661121,
-1.0175468922,
-0.0446390063,
-0.0839462578,
-0.5568638444,
0.3447645307,
-0.3272597194,
-0.6753432155,
-0.4796707034,
-0.2400390804,
-0.0286256839,
0.2220025361,
-0.9084567428,
0.5398743153,
0.4928458929,
-0.4197223485,
-0.46401757,
-0.7559954524,
0.5020191073,
-0.6045063138,
-0.6384472251,
0.8069993854,
0.4547102451,
0.114395678,
0.3412028849,
0.2063111216,
-0.3013214469,
0.024626838,
0.4058754742,
-0.0673145503,
-0.1805550456,
0.5686536431,
0.0580912344,
-0.4115628004,
-0.0625805855,
-0.9796268344,
0.2166623175,
0.3365667164,
-0.3068324327,
0.0626924932,
0.2786362469,
0.0492946394,
-0.2019448578,
0.2135591358,
0.3686897755,
-0.1473608017,
-0.1421750486,
-0.1545469612,
-0.0031738968,
-0.5332561135,
0.113673687,
-0.7374948859,
-0.9780384302,
0.5031809211,
-0.5701059103,
-0.5528841615,
0.5319776535,
0.1745327413,
-0.108242929,
0.4434756935,
0.6601009369,
-0.0364488997,
0.4827915728,
-0.3057869971,
0.7047973871,
-0.7115417123,
-0.3197654486,
-0.7015402913,
-0.0994268507,
-0.4544336498,
-0.6499453783,
0.2955453992,
0.152427882,
-0.1386131048,
0.5375347137,
-0.6950830221,
0.5555137992,
0.9492141604,
0.1210866719,
0.217582643,
0.5834932923,
-0.7930657268,
0.0133655705,
-0.4832530022,
-0.2695252895,
1.1713472605,
-0.0584448837,
0.6292150021,
-0.3755087852,
0.8437297344,
0.6153386235,
-0.2369498909,
-0.4631029665,
0.4519771934,
-0.3511663079,
-0.2891095579,
-0.0338915028,
-0.2565806508,
-1.3109977245,
0.0666195378,
0.0145309018,
-1.0069330931,
0.6929755807,
0.1657359302,
-0.2638868988,
-0.081570141,
-0.9706170559,
1.0949614048,
-0.248097375,
-0.4448393583,
-0.4393882751,
-0.5911652446,
-0.1799506098,
-0.1265402883,
-0.1100387499,
0.044021409,
0.168117404,
0.6901728511,
-0.7215579748,
0.9306465983,
-0.0367995091,
0.1583771706,
0.4950317442,
-0.3329976499,
0.165015921,
-0.3541842699,
-0.1161784902,
-0.0872834176,
-0.2320716381,
-0.4954449534,
-0.6697362065,
1.1702165604,
-0.2790687978,
-0.5698565841,
-0.3468769789,
-0.2482590377,
-0.1212229878,
0.6481555104,
0.0841120109,
0.6378145218,
-0.0550583787,
0.0379018374,
0.2296157628,
-0.0345228165,
0.3846808672,
0.201314345,
-0.0446467288,
-0.6455383897,
1.2175523043,
0.2056171,
0.0786452517,
0.5663900971,
0.190040797,
-0.7309001088,
-0.3760535717,
-0.1246022508,
0.2101776749,
-0.8820877075,
-0.1209659576,
-0.6778723001,
0.0034690318,
-0.7495594621,
-0.0572826862,
0.1091829091,
-0.8144553304,
-0.4209625423,
-0.4067187905,
0.7517652512,
0.6307321787,
-0.3232024014,
0.1245103776,
-0.5210738182,
0.4176592529,
0.5201064348,
0.4425581694,
-0.2271123081,
-0.379598856,
-0.3091996908,
-0.0785269737,
-0.5080031753,
-0.4787419438,
0.2260363698,
0.5510908961,
0.6177700758,
0.443231076,
0.1034489796,
0.9905757904,
-0.7372097373,
0.743322134,
0.1416764408,
-0.8195258975,
0.8111899495,
-0.0187313017,
-0.2997278571,
0.2748883069,
0.3061516881,
0.1079786494,
-0.2582820952,
-0.8013620377,
-1.009642005,
0.1693328917,
-0.123416245,
0.298902899,
-0.3746867478,
0.4653481841,
-0.0927705839,
0.0942689702,
-0.4455098212,
-0.0437545367,
-0.1299739927,
-0.149999395,
0.2705187201,
0.131051749,
-0.302216202,
0.0279793013,
0.4957203865,
-0.2983443141,
0.2804465294,
0.6443604827,
-0.0065711434,
0.3373568952,
-0.1650280356,
0.208148703,
0.7729462981,
-0.1815028936,
0.4051156044,
-0.1313364953,
-0.3179062009,
-0.2208375186,
0.7776774764,
-0.1627378017,
0.2830348015,
0.3626177311,
0.581679225,
0.1511979103,
-0.5138412118,
0.4983642697,
0.2305359542,
-0.0595202409,
0.1198655739,
-0.2458681315,
0.0551806986,
0.3734207153,
0.5139394999,
-0.1215128228,
0.5333772898,
-0.443107605,
0.8185198307,
0.5453494787,
-0.5494429469,
0.0730975568,
0.587084353,
0.1533342898,
-0.1565116346,
0.1129476503,
-0.1590189487,
-0.5038948059,
0.8112232089,
0.7462425232,
1.0131604671,
0.2819474339,
0.1535073519,
0.2598195374,
-0.1033444554,
0.3276432157,
-0.1166497543,
-0.4648580551,
-0.3166734576,
-0.28352651,
-0.1536379606,
-0.342177242,
-0.6338939071,
-0.2000773698,
0.1581608653,
-0.2802908719,
-0.4130614102,
0.0640060082,
0.1046051607,
-0.2671886086,
0.1534999162,
-0.218822822,
0.5590852499,
-0.7150931358,
0.788038969,
0.5584810376,
-0.5622487664,
-0.5183344483,
-0.0607050546,
-0.3114459217,
-0.9002166986,
1.0007270575,
0.1709770709,
-0.1732061654,
0.0500217043,
-0.3791257143,
-0.906463027,
1.3053907156,
0.13435404,
-0.0851757005,
0.2048017532,
0.2995541394,
0.4625815451,
-0.4952968061,
-0.1795554459,
0.1737339795,
-0.0660986304,
0.2887833118,
-0.8284647465,
0.0641159341,
-0.2079523057,
-0.1319328696,
-0.0626196712,
-0.2133332789,
0.6862214208,
-0.3211500943,
-0.2516269386,
0.2273298353,
0.8098629117,
0.2100906074,
0.6412498951,
0.2635725141,
0.7723610997,
0.9324065447,
0.1446945816,
1.0093430281,
-0.8270257711,
0.5675674081,
1.4466706514,
-0.3123143911,
0.8208455443,
0.4701824486,
-0.0332909711,
0.4290723205,
0.5190199018,
-0.3108943999,
0.6782919168,
0.1183846891,
-0.1944004744,
0.057248719,
-0.5824721456,
-0.4971732199,
0.0011221034,
0.3279418647,
-0.717830956,
-0.2349663824,
-0.0807870403,
-0.0825307146,
0.2096633017,
0.101308465,
0.8381525874,
0.3274011314,
-0.3968584538,
0.3988893926,
-0.3807176054,
0.0511206053,
-0.3100808263,
-0.1009703055,
-0.1110797748,
0.2167019099,
-0.0206301268,
-0.9441954494,
0.1573833376,
-0.1338817179,
-0.1181058735,
-0.2075367272,
0.8135085702,
-0.2874022126,
-0.5931634307,
0.5092591047,
0.1537833214,
0.1778123975,
0.0794060677,
-0.6095728278,
-0.643584609,
-0.1408311725,
0.3395596445,
0.1369964331,
0.893902123,
0.0949655473,
0.6615604162,
0.5851124525,
0.165550068,
0.4111243784,
0.246554479,
1.0224474669,
-0.6448173523,
-0.7827262878,
-0.4143135548,
0.1727765799,
-0.7228822112,
-0.3535335064,
1.0055719614,
0.858722508,
0.4953073859,
-0.1924294382,
0.7000365257,
-0.0426646546,
0.8126004338,
-0.5540577769,
0.4486279488,
-0.509745717,
0.1337044239,
-0.3273510039,
-0.6652233601,
-0.5953553915,
0.4921313524,
-0.4119707644,
-0.1481803656,
0.6206365228,
1.0903009176,
-0.3653070033,
-0.3007717133,
0.0905453637,
0.3682459295,
0.4388172925,
-0.1139777675,
0.5090077519,
-0.3867534697,
0.4151466787,
-0.2690164745,
-0.0786521286,
-0.1100494787,
-1.1464571953,
-0.5578625798,
-0.41160357,
-0.5190086365,
-0.3963091373,
0.1306153238,
0.6925047636,
0.6714874506,
-0.6794950962,
-0.0401659012,
-0.3233032227,
0.3666371703,
-0.0106182275,
-0.2624945045,
0.9996476769,
-0.7269765735,
-0.4482481182,
0.5221443772,
0.5900373459,
-0.0986618623,
0.2632431388,
0.2703267038,
-0.3059326112,
-0.1389071345,
0.7013518214,
0.5227669477,
-0.6709775925,
-0.4830159843,
0.0817683712,
0.075007692,
0.2316331416,
1.0075955391,
-1.0280419588,
0.9714179635,
0.7919879556,
0.8074913025,
0.6113445163,
0.3610966802,
0.5679277778,
-0.9358908534,
0.174889937,
-0.1259337664,
0.5468267798,
0.457318902,
-0.2294503748,
0.3970689178,
0.3664294779,
-0.5879672766,
-0.3731850088,
0.1069375947,
-1.1473872662,
-0.4221777916,
0.6908707023,
-0.5725640655,
-0.1799354255,
-0.3228212595,
-0.1293803006,
0.1026147753,
-0.0477742553,
0.8040654659,
0.221601814,
-0.2695003152,
0.2436765432,
-0.0647902191,
0.2306959182,
0.1577961445,
-0.5930971503,
-0.0967992172,
0.403459847,
0.2678345144,
0.555971086,
0.5512025952,
-0.1648690104,
-0.09634462,
0.3844684362,
-0.045302555,
-0.0299729388,
-0.1223728955,
-0.0284157675,
0.3932141662,
0.1731684208,
-0.6687044501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16248v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16248v2
|
Large Language Models Offer an Alternative to the Traditional Approach of Topic Modelling
| 2024-03-24T17:39:51 | 2024-03-26T17:46:26 |
Yida Mu, Chun Dong, Kalina Bontcheva, Xingyi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Topic modelling, as a well-established unsupervised technique, has found
extensive use in automatically detecting significant topics within a corpus of
documents. However, classic topic modelling approaches (e.g., LDA) have certain
drawbacks, such as the lack of semantic understanding and the presence of
overlapping topics. In this work, we investigate the untapped potential of
large language models (LLMs) as an alternative for uncovering the underlying
topics within extensive text corpora. To this end, we introduce a framework
that prompts LLMs to generate topics from a given set of documents and
establish evaluation protocols to assess the clustering efficacy of LLMs. Our
findings indicate that LLMs with appropriate prompts can stand out as a viable
alternative, capable of generating relevant topic titles and adhering to human
guidelines to refine and merge topics. Through in-depth experiments and
evaluation, we summarise the advantages and constraints of employing LLMs in
topic extraction.
|
[
-0.4858947098,
-0.857791245,
1.1185301542,
-0.0859413743,
-0.373744756,
0.043808721,
-0.6527656317,
-0.0339721814,
0.3172185719,
0.7131074071,
-0.4575071633,
-0.5293028355,
-0.7197833061,
0.0097502219,
-0.9426093102,
0.6957041621,
0.0407532342,
-0.2139327973,
-0.2817552686,
0.3426439762,
-0.5382496119,
-0.4245437682,
-0.4310961664,
-0.3596103787,
0.7235080004,
0.5093325973,
0.351336211,
0.495282501,
0.5502277017,
0.265168488,
-0.5177998543,
0.158531785,
-0.4694628119,
0.1346995085,
-0.3528823256,
-0.3197550774,
-0.0515202433,
0.1614958048,
0.8438394666,
1.0569194555,
-0.1512036622,
-0.1370547712,
-0.155482471,
0.5111518502,
-0.3334869444,
-0.1783226728,
-0.9584279656,
-0.121605821,
-0.1763297319,
-0.3075180352,
-0.3397509754,
0.0404794104,
0.3339957297,
0.0442558452,
0.08305379,
-0.1006162986,
0.6752177477,
-0.0847009942,
-0.4634519517,
-0.6475242972,
-0.7149150372,
0.7976103425,
-0.6791434884,
0.1943165511,
0.1715447009,
0.0654794201,
-0.2882924676,
-0.5322134495,
-0.488324374,
-0.2358593494,
-0.0839322135,
-0.1388580203,
-0.2612302005,
-0.309586525,
0.1129538789,
0.4600577652,
-0.5684623122,
0.5503972769,
-0.2698217332,
0.1312334538,
0.3666702509,
0.2492834032,
0.3908022344,
-0.3514355123,
-0.1675430536,
0.2691717148,
-0.9863029718,
-0.2053857446,
0.4345512986,
0.4447453618,
0.0550922193,
0.7979966402,
0.0219397303,
0.8003053069,
-0.0288674571,
-0.2065426111,
-0.1488324255,
-0.0546690412,
0.0460863598,
-0.1212533191,
0.5779675841,
0.0679569691,
-0.1230333596,
-0.4363248348,
-0.1789846718,
0.0702239722,
0.2407076508,
-0.8773404956,
0.1453162581,
0.5840268135,
-0.5407639742,
-0.2727683783,
0.1164539456,
-0.897811234,
-0.446266979,
-0.4307833016,
0.0175563488,
-0.1665797979,
-0.3815827668,
0.1411108375,
-0.2324618101,
0.3304176033,
0.4268543124,
-0.9528685212,
-0.0002440322,
1.1861307621,
0.8334761858,
-0.8459540606,
-0.1231684238,
-0.3915823698,
0.1014154777,
-0.7391551733,
0.8559141755,
-0.8736556172,
-0.5559285283,
0.1013070941,
0.1437632889,
0.353549242,
-0.584826529,
0.3350317478,
-0.6703031063,
0.2099325061,
-0.106157735,
-0.7192206383,
0.1655318588,
0.210868299,
-0.5774155259,
0.737260282,
-0.0981480032,
-0.7342339754,
0.2489467263,
-0.6578042507,
-0.1811904758,
-0.1176346317,
-0.3022971451,
-0.0572308637,
0.1966111958,
0.1558743566,
0.7033445239,
-0.7735328078,
0.8886916041,
-0.250941962,
-0.2688709497,
0.4580222666,
-0.5123344064,
0.3760582805,
0.2954246998,
-0.0832524672,
0.4150029123,
-0.5530165434,
-0.484185487,
-0.0140315862,
-0.2294901758,
-0.5409581661,
0.0057307486,
-0.1284195632,
0.1243124977,
0.4326018691,
-0.3804470301,
0.188426435,
-0.40667364,
0.5919276476,
0.6359962225,
0.0277156606,
0.541785717,
-0.1462551653,
0.4402316213,
-0.0368954204,
-0.452393949,
-0.5254517794,
-0.4760250449,
-0.63638556,
-0.6075167656,
0.5271304846,
0.2132363021,
-0.5257047415,
0.7710130215,
-0.1624711156,
-0.7077485323,
-0.1060217544,
0.1699684113,
-0.0389224142,
0.1447262913,
-0.1361177117,
-0.1451248229,
-0.3462929726,
-0.7803246379,
0.0714600906,
0.0825007707,
-0.2380856723,
0.1224296913,
0.5385864377,
-0.2792720199,
1.2660737038,
-0.6243697405,
0.15365915,
-0.3837500215,
0.374168247,
0.4448903799,
0.3624834418,
0.1553158462,
-0.9774438739,
-0.2116025537,
0.0874324515,
-0.85982728,
-0.0896263644,
-0.1452098787,
-0.1095325798,
-0.117395483,
0.8320084214,
-0.8810888529,
0.1819020808,
0.3924385607,
-0.1422776282,
0.4493837059,
-0.2751894295,
0.0057867095,
-1.1849476099,
0.2426233143,
0.0745489225,
-0.1907908767,
-0.513468802,
0.2052375823,
0.0387386754,
-0.8696858883,
-0.3345512748,
0.8179213405,
-0.5995013118,
-0.3384802341,
-0.7165136933,
0.5283460617,
-0.1429639757,
-0.0493756607,
0.3485058546,
0.7129421234,
0.7495697141,
-0.5193754435,
0.2987936735,
0.1667952985,
-0.3456371129,
0.0726126432,
-0.6456933618,
-0.0557005107,
-0.3022286594,
0.2058298141,
-1.1171001196,
-0.1707104295,
-0.2912347019,
-0.1403815895,
0.5133956075,
-0.1648073196,
-0.4357964993,
-0.5528416038,
-0.3047687113,
-0.1103928834,
0.538569808,
-0.5831885934,
0.4180984199,
0.6004756093,
-0.6286485195,
-0.4257151783,
-0.2249677777,
0.3640658259,
-0.7930422425,
-0.4452367127,
0.3969748318,
-0.0587009937,
-0.4675816894,
0.0023982443,
0.218776539,
0.0650925264,
0.2908707261,
0.2685709596,
0.2354652435,
-0.234034583,
0.3849698007,
0.0024353582,
-0.2350368202,
-0.1416289508,
-0.2442733198,
0.8690101504,
0.1442439109,
-0.4461850226,
-0.1926866174,
0.694152236,
0.5959762931,
-0.4701855183,
0.58729285,
0.2979542613,
-0.5312406421,
-0.2048438489,
-0.5583122969,
-0.2977408469,
-0.4372307062,
0.4088757038,
-0.0656494573,
-1.2805262804,
0.4137482345,
-0.5712942481,
-0.0286134891,
0.4400907159,
0.7886199951,
0.1157580838,
0.5667303801,
0.8600552678,
-0.0424686,
0.4177744389,
-0.0624317043,
0.3661258817,
-0.6716640592,
0.0422109738,
-0.7052866817,
0.1683390439,
-0.594717741,
-0.6895903945,
0.1318105608,
0.2174254507,
0.080085516,
0.1453116387,
-0.1743403673,
0.4558734894,
0.2379988879,
-0.1797535419,
0.2828337252,
0.1912669688,
0.2689855397,
0.1085777581,
-0.5613151193,
-1.0449768305,
0.9697151184,
0.4896003008,
0.6804928184,
-0.0697255731,
0.6542608142,
0.2816314995,
0.4449062943,
-0.779481411,
0.6157669425,
-0.4598506987,
-0.5453048348,
-0.7643636465,
-0.3656372428,
-1.076099515,
0.4747386873,
-0.292309463,
-0.9283176661,
0.1537730843,
-0.4219676256,
-0.3187192082,
0.4131993949,
-0.3400274813,
0.7360989451,
-0.0636903048,
-0.2581409216,
-0.2370854616,
-0.0801094547,
0.3490351737,
-0.7318085432,
0.2466477007,
-0.1530882865,
-0.065861389,
0.8146160245,
-0.2562018037,
0.9770917892,
0.2414860725,
-0.6824771166,
0.4132066965,
-0.2195464522,
0.3158177435,
0.1035336405,
-0.3537738025,
-0.0605839342,
-0.4142885506,
-0.119625248,
-0.436146915,
1.0307929516,
-0.4627249539,
-0.9572171569,
-0.2205491215,
-0.5706840754,
-0.2813297212,
0.2867389023,
-0.2311563343,
0.5250040889,
-0.4363957942,
0.2985686064,
0.6702562571,
-0.7362397313,
0.5883113146,
0.758867681,
-0.5151620507,
0.0028128584,
0.9270480275,
-0.2055067569,
0.0107147526,
0.4902637005,
0.3360863328,
-0.2525153756,
-0.6642263532,
-0.3098681867,
0.4263971746,
-0.6809279919,
0.0363157205,
-0.8151705265,
-0.0491897985,
-0.3092927635,
-0.2556375563,
-0.2963326871,
-0.0472765416,
-0.4811684787,
-0.2111330926,
0.3936644495,
0.730736196,
-0.2516182959,
0.5178593993,
-0.6960505843,
0.3738486767,
0.3901486099,
0.051185891,
0.1289141029,
-0.5661485791,
0.1704024971,
-0.23711209,
-0.1025501639,
-0.8133062124,
0.6304298043,
-0.3272886574,
0.5887891054,
0.4729209244,
-0.1399991512,
0.2892395854,
-0.6942282319,
0.8252330422,
0.3051739633,
-0.8665333986,
0.5444825292,
-0.637522161,
0.1429127306,
0.3176099956,
0.7366450429,
-0.4899175465,
-0.2898655832,
-0.4743623137,
-0.9780016541,
0.371907711,
0.0551527664,
0.3291610777,
-0.2618564069,
0.3332282603,
0.3165765703,
0.4159906805,
-0.4707188308,
-0.0274312403,
0.4863879383,
0.1226511151,
-0.2896920443,
-0.5966997743,
-0.033440467,
0.106043756,
0.5231559873,
-0.0074035823,
0.2087617517,
-0.1696574539,
0.0838155448,
-0.1985132843,
0.5947569609,
0.4285760224,
1.0467789173,
-0.2333519012,
0.1854175329,
-0.0344237834,
0.1907655448,
0.0080548059,
0.1096703336,
-0.1203905344,
0.1436822116,
0.3985967636,
0.5269594193,
0.1320623755,
-0.9363330007,
0.4557656348,
0.0184411108,
-0.068595551,
-0.2063873857,
-0.3240104318,
0.6462496519,
0.2127587497,
0.4593886733,
-0.7049152255,
-0.0336496308,
-1.0310931206,
0.4360100627,
0.6048311591,
-0.3959035277,
0.1510831714,
0.2399481237,
0.1400675625,
-0.2836372852,
0.3401703238,
-0.1114308834,
-0.4645139873,
0.8501259089,
0.5435350537,
0.3738396168,
0.0168844648,
0.4085462689,
0.078199178,
0.1309290081,
-0.205267325,
0.0487229675,
0.3727250397,
-0.5559694767,
-0.6061736941,
-0.7257462144,
-0.4384075701,
0.3852384686,
-0.4376238883,
0.3556536734,
-0.0493933186,
0.0726695061,
0.3166446388,
-0.1268228889,
-0.1566772461,
0.079219766,
0.2491855472,
0.8979198337,
-0.8444468379,
0.7409254909,
0.5451657176,
-0.112671949,
-0.3172568977,
0.1734865904,
-0.3809664845,
-0.4746815562,
0.6381185651,
0.2023552209,
0.2467186153,
-0.2763680816,
-0.4451017678,
-0.8714011908,
0.9314409494,
0.1751752794,
-0.7130663991,
-0.1498458236,
0.1045926884,
0.5466302037,
-0.5097901225,
0.1671150476,
0.3637367487,
0.4537885487,
0.2125305831,
-0.6214751601,
0.031674847,
0.0342441387,
-0.0764612928,
0.3901165426,
-0.3825748563,
0.9961215854,
-0.0394517817,
0.0280696452,
0.3123584092,
0.7895222902,
0.2355667353,
0.1878400147,
0.4627721608,
0.1545345038,
0.875864923,
0.108227998,
0.9408128262,
-0.2236424685,
0.2485496849,
0.9205869436,
-0.6308350563,
0.7966758609,
0.4742878079,
0.0983137786,
0.1762386858,
0.7095937133,
0.0088322544,
0.5410010815,
0.5052131414,
-0.0368591212,
-0.5572227836,
-0.2006611228,
-0.4499122202,
0.5473176241,
0.6929724813,
-0.4500837922,
-0.4555203915,
0.0997817963,
-0.1338433772,
0.2191131711,
-0.3764416277,
0.6732865572,
0.2351433337,
-0.6306200027,
0.2730262578,
0.2821011245,
0.8560522199,
-0.6540866494,
-0.104394868,
-0.2215225399,
-0.1866388917,
0.1615013331,
-0.6368795633,
0.2553068101,
0.3255342543,
-0.2016687691,
-0.1463614702,
1.0270587206,
-0.5378413796,
-0.5805079937,
0.2986910045,
0.6740208268,
0.3370574713,
-0.1419866681,
-0.3922371566,
-0.0137845417,
-0.0820313022,
-0.0646929368,
0.6100881696,
0.8847336769,
-0.2230882347,
0.6107168794,
0.6135475039,
0.0998474211,
-0.5401324034,
-0.1108101383,
0.9982634187,
-0.8333388567,
-0.4843937755,
-0.8752682209,
0.1636226177,
-0.1920951307,
-0.0823049322,
0.6970486045,
0.4929516017,
0.2634654939,
-0.0295305159,
0.8039019704,
0.1867280453,
0.7212799191,
-0.7245898247,
0.6238792539,
-0.716889441,
0.5601583719,
-0.4404222071,
-0.777652204,
-0.0838449746,
0.442727983,
-0.4893562496,
-0.1828319281,
0.6514190435,
0.7904245257,
-0.1394186169,
0.1193630323,
0.6359879375,
0.0568519719,
0.3761654496,
0.2338592708,
1.2147496939,
0.314486146,
0.1578854322,
0.0251492392,
-0.3596740961,
-0.1976001859,
-1.1076339483,
-1.2780559063,
-0.5727538466,
-0.1558699608,
0.0513594486,
0.0962704122,
0.6910452247,
0.4953970015,
-0.695258379,
-0.285074234,
0.1332026273,
0.307754159,
0.3518950939,
-0.1340841353,
0.5651890635,
-0.2211142033,
-0.6135612726,
0.6657186747,
0.2016976178,
-0.0142543316,
-0.5736297965,
0.3203381002,
-0.1995494366,
0.1453509331,
0.6899279356,
0.0510041751,
-0.648775816,
0.0515031144,
-0.1654819995,
-0.0469963551,
-0.1688124985,
1.1534919739,
-0.4323368967,
-0.1609018743,
0.3403262794,
0.8337758183,
0.517131567,
-0.0124369459,
0.7459657788,
-0.4032576978,
0.2407145798,
-0.0832306892,
0.5562002659,
0.5040131211,
-0.1882268488,
0.4215656221,
-0.0858329311,
-0.2215886265,
-1.0003554821,
0.1796271652,
-0.8776460886,
-0.9440388083,
1.5833346844,
-0.07526467,
-0.1951427311,
0.0112786032,
-0.3067206144,
-0.0579565056,
-0.3758068979,
0.7462473512,
0.6816493869,
0.3620757461,
0.0173047129,
-0.4823289514,
0.07750801,
0.2848016918,
-1.0519827604,
0.421821624,
0.5489352942,
0.1237549335,
0.3766336441,
0.5533947945,
-0.2442350537,
-0.1830695421,
-0.3589406908,
-0.1161554232,
0.3236042261,
-0.5250636935,
-0.4648500383,
0.4153393209,
0.2821390629,
0.4636021554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16247v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16247v1
|
Improving Sequence-to-Sequence Models for Abstractive Text Summarization Using Meta Heuristic Approaches
| 2024-03-24T17:39:36 | 2024-03-24T17:39:36 |
Aditya Saxena, Ashutosh Ranjan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.NE
|
As human society transitions into the information age, reduction in our
attention span is a contingency, and people who spend time reading lengthy news
articles are decreasing rapidly and the need for succinct information is higher
than ever before. Therefore, it is essential to provide a quick overview of
important news by concisely summarizing the top news article and the most
intuitive headline. When humans try to make summaries, they extract the
essential information from the source and add useful phrases and grammatical
annotations from the original extract. Humans have a unique ability to create
abstractions. However, automatic summarization is a complicated problem to
solve. The use of sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models for neural abstractive
text summarization has been ascending as far as prevalence. Numerous innovative
strategies have been proposed to develop the current seq2seq models further,
permitting them to handle different issues like saliency, familiarity, and
human lucidness and create excellent synopses. In this article, we aimed toward
enhancing the present architectures and models for abstractive text
summarization. The modifications have been aimed at fine-tuning
hyper-parameters, attempting specific encoder-decoder combinations. We examined
many experiments on an extensively used CNN/DailyMail dataset to check the
effectiveness of various models.
|
[
-0.356069088,
-0.6431987286,
0.3801113367,
0.2633670866,
-0.4870714843,
-0.0398442857,
-0.1073958129,
-0.4000461698,
0.1578345895,
0.2339543551,
-0.2968300581,
-0.4314888418,
-0.6224660873,
0.3584201336,
-0.581040144,
1.0557523966,
0.2182201743,
-0.2654135823,
-0.2829436958,
-0.1129688025,
-0.1420767754,
-0.4125154316,
-0.451751709,
-0.1301282346,
0.2601509094,
0.467630744,
0.5757518411,
0.6295591593,
0.3319981992,
0.2057403922,
-0.3885084689,
0.1589342505,
-0.2604671121,
0.0071511413,
-0.1325466633,
-0.1214921251,
-0.5779879689,
-0.234656617,
0.4909721017,
0.7834323645,
-0.0262130629,
0.4004774988,
0.3085474968,
0.8666433096,
-0.7528783679,
-0.0340498388,
-0.3495432138,
0.0810292959,
0.0679913089,
-0.3125148416,
-0.2968787849,
-0.3989640772,
0.2618477941,
-0.3954204917,
0.2143329084,
-0.249672085,
0.5567220449,
0.3010692596,
-0.5168352723,
-0.1237244755,
-0.6959668398,
0.3335953653,
-1.086699605,
0.1262867451,
0.2138112336,
0.1009316444,
0.2293415517,
-0.6115778089,
-0.2317539901,
-0.0222972929,
-0.1262132078,
0.2400935441,
0.0771777704,
-0.007758297,
0.2444214672,
0.0709669888,
-0.6129500866,
-0.1434242874,
-0.5126991272,
0.0203770213,
0.7445375323,
0.4033119678,
0.104576394,
-0.3522172272,
-0.1356488317,
0.3353507817,
-0.4347324967,
0.066707775,
0.3384547234,
-0.0013547355,
0.0498544201,
0.5078927875,
-0.6088642478,
0.6976085901,
0.2199225575,
0.1186871901,
0.2526224554,
-0.5701345801,
-0.0621516109,
0.0752460659,
0.597468555,
0.7676532865,
0.2673591077,
-0.185094133,
-0.1518161297,
-0.0786785483,
0.1441351473,
-0.8638708591,
-0.02054617,
0.353928864,
-0.7196375132,
-0.4349940419,
-0.0952407345,
-0.9040171504,
-0.1399542689,
-0.4411879778,
0.3866477013,
-0.2966223061,
-0.1479133964,
0.240914017,
-0.3358047307,
0.0902524367,
0.2340323776,
-0.9747563004,
0.2762647569,
0.4934476912,
0.8750221729,
-0.2287981212,
-0.094655171,
-0.202383101,
0.3345894516,
-0.1938025802,
0.7282967567,
-0.4377085567,
-0.1703430861,
-0.2012588084,
-0.2833277583,
-0.1012268811,
-0.2260491848,
0.5029123425,
-0.5198847055,
0.3275283873,
-0.1620619297,
-0.4937344193,
-0.3648816049,
0.431884706,
-0.6258631945,
0.6588959098,
-0.1747305691,
-0.9035797119,
-0.1762878299,
-0.8032495379,
-0.8973149657,
-0.3323009014,
0.1581669897,
-0.4880180359,
0.4193536937,
0.4772811532,
0.4502613544,
-0.1343937665,
0.3028388321,
0.1470512152,
-0.3682745695,
0.0607351176,
-0.3169954717,
0.5407850742,
0.1726839244,
-0.2551929355,
0.2403529435,
-0.8050200939,
0.0544559769,
-0.0516737513,
-0.3390905559,
-0.4053746462,
0.1403204501,
0.0668232366,
0.2477523685,
0.212725684,
0.009966189,
-0.09761969,
-0.6096800566,
0.7873964906,
0.3230321109,
0.361931324,
0.5707791448,
-0.3338236809,
0.25915429,
0.1336264461,
0.074330695,
-0.8600730896,
-0.3091304302,
-0.4192511439,
0.0054440433,
0.5197950602,
0.7699216604,
-0.4261184633,
0.4594252408,
-0.3437989354,
-0.252248466,
-0.1554293036,
-0.2157826275,
0.2532889843,
0.479026854,
0.413068682,
-0.3795621395,
-0.6300897002,
-0.6653487682,
-0.4666473866,
0.2401752174,
-0.110935986,
0.0247111134,
0.4297754467,
-0.1704638451,
0.7859963179,
-0.4099364877,
0.0444886573,
-0.3697554469,
0.3245479763,
0.3073395491,
0.4787748754,
0.2246658206,
-0.7953868508,
-0.1948199868,
-0.4707713127,
-0.7226678133,
0.1040577292,
-0.2228885144,
-0.0108253201,
0.2168278843,
0.7826862931,
-0.7064298391,
0.6571674943,
0.105557248,
-0.3768139482,
0.5945332646,
-0.1965576559,
0.1069629416,
-1.4194517136,
0.3179952204,
0.0518419817,
-0.2366523743,
-0.6226605773,
0.1384427249,
0.106729418,
-0.114575617,
-0.2317180634,
0.314304769,
-0.5719406009,
-0.3248428702,
-0.3811580539,
-0.112239182,
0.0044331071,
0.5538511276,
0.0162809957,
0.5407845974,
0.127891466,
-0.8598592281,
-0.017479375,
0.2617757618,
-0.143109858,
0.1835290343,
-1.0619734526,
-0.1413909942,
-0.6021825671,
0.4360190332,
-1.1230188608,
-0.3293202519,
0.1929396838,
-0.5370839238,
0.1122934893,
0.1422080249,
-0.3068111539,
-0.115482308,
-0.6085311174,
0.8171778321,
0.6505779028,
-0.0891568959,
0.6358676553,
0.1599143445,
-0.4627215862,
-0.5489171147,
-0.5111938119,
0.5000674725,
-0.0382920131,
-0.581582129,
0.7578081489,
0.0433791988,
-0.0999993607,
0.2176631689,
-0.1088856459,
0.0541635081,
0.0743948072,
-0.0012861986,
0.1706324071,
-0.1610228717,
0.0514755659,
0.2473601848,
-0.3722396493,
0.0234864168,
-0.3519555032,
0.3181368709,
0.0187069923,
0.0724282414,
-0.6399327517,
0.5796237588,
0.6952680349,
-0.5491077304,
0.437312305,
0.526550293,
-0.5795086622,
0.2935132682,
-0.3191712797,
-0.4966861606,
-0.3247285783,
0.7114586234,
-0.1955794543,
-0.5813718438,
0.497358948,
-0.2037834972,
0.1993776411,
0.4021105468,
0.4983868003,
-0.220826894,
1.1101434231,
0.4567963481,
-0.092583254,
0.4294985831,
-0.3076511025,
-0.1295325011,
-0.9240471125,
-0.0637975857,
-0.1985953599,
-0.4661889076,
-0.2338376939,
-0.1453906894,
0.4316183627,
-0.0290817562,
-0.0553671345,
0.2688858509,
-0.3973559439,
0.7343481779,
0.4252143502,
0.1951922029,
0.5077137351,
0.0524303764,
0.0674090311,
0.144388631,
-0.7396742105,
-0.4551898837,
1.0362328291,
0.3315075636,
0.5203927755,
0.0754429698,
0.5662936568,
0.3734597266,
-0.1174960509,
-0.6203408241,
0.5435044169,
-0.3341234922,
-0.3505876958,
-0.4492785335,
-0.196512416,
-0.7283373475,
0.0989791006,
-0.1831286103,
-0.457663238,
0.2703795135,
0.3021703064,
-0.8354076743,
-0.1678995192,
-0.3443311453,
0.8653568625,
0.0254527647,
-0.2957163453,
-0.2693886161,
-1.0465211868,
0.478443563,
0.364554882,
0.1820462644,
-0.0216691643,
-0.3681516349,
0.5806543827,
-0.2694670558,
0.8945304155,
0.1502661556,
0.0220951159,
0.2150994837,
-0.1941014081,
0.4927276373,
0.1116468608,
0.0407939143,
-0.0315366834,
-0.2665524483,
-0.4565155506,
-0.5343126655,
0.2091642916,
-0.5954734683,
-0.3781205118,
-0.2681732774,
-0.4854505956,
-0.0456140041,
0.0147124641,
0.6832876205,
0.7571613193,
-0.2042016238,
-0.1191943139,
0.7980740666,
0.0048420457,
0.8176834583,
0.1507049054,
0.1150008813,
-0.692342937,
0.61417377,
0.0822492316,
0.1820277572,
0.4053591192,
-0.0040822471,
-0.2422399223,
-0.7671976089,
-0.4611860216,
0.042054411,
-0.626388967,
-0.1899841726,
-0.8351181746,
-0.4446261525,
-0.5359638333,
-0.0229944363,
-0.0244959127,
-0.9123865366,
-0.4466278553,
-0.0661999434,
0.0808389485,
0.4310222864,
0.0429325812,
0.0971222967,
-1.1330217123,
0.5679258704,
0.2655699849,
0.0705572814,
0.0877232328,
-0.7070444226,
-0.3198513985,
-0.0502558835,
-0.2369158268,
-1.0361641645,
0.3748311102,
0.4104322195,
0.2993112206,
0.2275688648,
0.1009253711,
0.4553464353,
-0.6020662785,
0.5150882602,
0.038787771,
-0.8780818582,
0.5381759405,
-0.4981642663,
0.6458730698,
0.5697996616,
0.3694440424,
-0.596129775,
-0.1595325172,
-0.4038929045,
-1.1356247663,
0.4201729894,
0.3117128611,
0.2583915293,
0.042509567,
0.6273634434,
0.0380203985,
0.258020103,
-0.4039232433,
0.0675031543,
-0.4179909825,
-0.696224153,
-0.1090831533,
-0.521122098,
0.1099111959,
-0.2470702082,
0.6078082919,
-0.1548032165,
0.2022696882,
0.3179517686,
-0.3179632127,
0.0772145912,
0.3889847398,
1.0341560841,
0.6779419184,
-0.0401207954,
0.1427289099,
0.1151794866,
-0.4178855717,
0.1257369667,
0.216940254,
-0.4832188487,
0.1452548504,
0.3012669086,
0.6337485909,
0.3849593401,
-0.6575501561,
0.5674171448,
0.0350393504,
-0.2549029291,
-0.3643044531,
-0.0195250865,
0.194709152,
0.358423233,
0.4383485615,
0.4798516333,
0.763979733,
-0.5625337362,
0.1993087828,
0.145984605,
-0.1107254922,
-0.4896554053,
0.7823652029,
0.6430625319,
-0.2684668601,
0.3922308385,
-0.2917868495,
-0.5737387538,
0.7531865239,
0.5603170395,
1.1201578379,
-0.1082021892,
0.1031097472,
0.6738656759,
0.2677558064,
-0.46345222,
0.239650473,
-0.127224341,
-0.4088160694,
-0.5994805098,
-0.1908585578,
-0.1572993249,
-0.1563051641,
-0.549407661,
0.1991009116,
-0.272194773,
-0.1673011631,
-0.0115653966,
-0.3993500769,
-0.1990001798,
0.0499564931,
0.0526565202,
0.9898768067,
-0.701382935,
0.2605083287,
0.617790997,
-0.3036771715,
-0.0706102178,
0.4232185483,
-0.1669366062,
-0.2828196883,
0.3286224902,
0.3619795442,
0.3179740012,
0.3876426816,
-0.3225178421,
-0.7515320778,
1.1136865616,
0.0139122913,
-0.6812816262,
-0.4990050793,
0.0488384925,
0.3608165979,
-0.3228042126,
0.2039988935,
0.5859845877,
0.3592043221,
0.1636800468,
-0.5859435797,
0.136315465,
-0.4162360132,
0.1710210741,
0.3578953147,
-0.4569188058,
0.8485651016,
-0.712800622,
-0.082502678,
0.1836489141,
0.7287665606,
0.1122105569,
0.6599318385,
0.2747633159,
0.7282936573,
0.3303938508,
0.2663170695,
0.7461023927,
-0.4308936298,
0.1132725105,
1.3210712671,
0.0465579852,
0.8361874819,
0.2493603975,
0.2176373005,
0.316072166,
0.6287635565,
0.1086547673,
0.7042250037,
-0.0154576916,
-0.1935409158,
-0.1398384273,
0.203348279,
-0.2879298925,
0.3002506495,
0.4136919975,
-0.5745107532,
-0.335658133,
0.0848541111,
-0.1266497225,
0.151531741,
-0.4271789789,
1.1677136421,
-0.0335232913,
-0.7888815999,
0.3777395487,
0.3412842453,
0.7017052174,
-0.1363083571,
0.0554732047,
-0.252636373,
0.0011720263,
-0.3349403143,
-0.3637301028,
0.4607488215,
-0.0386723392,
-0.4084153771,
0.1933054328,
0.8793002963,
-0.6672759056,
-0.5169374943,
-0.3394338787,
0.5514066815,
-0.1267045736,
-0.3221626282,
-0.481190145,
-0.2070700675,
-0.2583446801,
-0.2367341816,
0.0217675865,
0.3073626161,
-0.0250298139,
0.2437882572,
0.4424100816,
-0.2645232081,
-0.1121280417,
0.0465797968,
0.5977495313,
-0.9846358299,
-0.8165419102,
-1.186737299,
0.7073133588,
-0.2550707459,
-0.2442707568,
0.4562453628,
0.6395597458,
0.2290952206,
-0.2418289483,
0.8922032714,
0.1387958825,
0.3403819203,
-0.5747518539,
0.592481792,
-0.29040429,
0.2044923156,
-0.2107884735,
-0.9103927612,
-0.2773249447,
0.4225454628,
-0.0177440997,
0.0927059278,
0.5771690607,
0.4911304116,
0.0284435749,
0.2169284523,
0.0906023085,
0.011430664,
-0.0615813136,
0.7436118126,
0.7627115846,
-0.725628376,
0.5565395355,
0.0306294225,
-0.1344197392,
-0.7920325994,
-1.0421662331,
-0.9080998302,
-0.66124475,
-0.4600526989,
-0.1402742863,
0.4626202881,
1.077732563,
0.6273915172,
-0.5854373574,
-0.0038591688,
-0.3754630089,
0.0576075613,
-0.3025151491,
-0.1648192704,
0.3509241641,
-0.4663258195,
-0.5105974078,
-0.072568886,
0.2989487946,
0.4033674002,
0.0074788793,
0.086771667,
-0.0005743536,
0.268045336,
0.8526086807,
0.3417302668,
-0.4236147702,
0.0004870046,
0.1817306578,
-0.2140898556,
-0.0082267057,
0.8470094204,
-0.8012366891,
-0.0431306884,
0.8314188123,
0.8384103775,
0.3508256078,
0.2972775102,
0.5274282694,
-0.6975614429,
-0.035202086,
0.2438022196,
0.1125985458,
0.2070176452,
-0.3729428649,
0.5400068164,
0.172415629,
-0.4045660198,
-0.5569299459,
0.0909561813,
-0.6644929647,
-0.3913776278,
1.0243688822,
0.2378226668,
-0.2804062963,
-0.0777832344,
-0.2418119311,
0.2377148718,
-0.3452204168,
1.0457865,
0.4622942805,
-0.1989367753,
-0.3363025188,
-0.3271746635,
0.6517784595,
0.3065608144,
-1.1628056765,
0.0637992024,
0.4459215105,
0.2761346102,
0.0912194103,
0.6199755073,
-0.1075085998,
0.7626972795,
-0.2518299222,
-0.0802464634,
-0.3091203868,
-0.4660203755,
-0.4366508126,
0.3161075115,
-0.3691729307,
-0.2957741022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16204v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16204v1
|
SQL-Encoder: Improving NL2SQL In-Context Learning Through a Context-Aware Encoder
| 2024-03-24T15:57:24 | 2024-03-24T15:57:24 |
Mohammadreza Pourreza, Davood Rafiei, Yuxi Feng, Raymond Li, Zhenan Fan, Weiwei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.HC
|
Detecting structural similarity between queries is essential for selecting
examples in in-context learning models. However, assessing structural
similarity based solely on the natural language expressions of queries, without
considering SQL queries, presents a significant challenge. This paper explores
the significance of this similarity metric and proposes a model for accurately
estimating it. To achieve this, we leverage a dataset comprising 170k question
pairs, meticulously curated to train a similarity prediction model. Our
comprehensive evaluation demonstrates that the proposed model adeptly captures
the structural similarity between questions, as evidenced by improvements in
Kendall-Tau distance and precision@k metrics. Notably, our model outperforms
strong competitive embedding models from OpenAI and Cohere. Furthermore,
compared to these competitive models, our proposed encoder enhances the
downstream performance of NL2SQL models in 1-shot in-context learning scenarios
by 1-2\% for GPT-3.5-turbo, 4-8\% for CodeLlama-7B, and 2-3\% for
CodeLlama-13B.
|
[
-0.0605291016,
-0.7853299975,
0.2062899917,
-0.0190570001,
-0.4104536772,
-0.1195851639,
0.0034038827,
-0.370451957,
0.3084216416,
0.4764116406,
-0.2287459224,
-0.4462692142,
-0.2874294817,
0.1631050259,
-0.5530864,
0.5394569039,
0.1940990537,
0.3377549946,
-0.5783617496,
-0.2408638895,
-0.4998467267,
-0.4735394716,
-0.7171921134,
0.0068746428,
-0.0792043656,
-0.1377158761,
0.3737399876,
0.4373470843,
0.386023134,
0.1554496884,
-0.3746877015,
0.2628642023,
-0.6368349195,
0.3375788927,
-0.2916420996,
-0.6978071332,
-0.1165954098,
-0.4262898266,
0.6564276814,
0.8797246814,
-0.2449716926,
0.3122321665,
0.578435123,
0.9020057321,
-0.3630379736,
0.1803883314,
-1.0425966978,
0.3489761949,
-0.0212113969,
-0.053724654,
-0.3181159198,
-0.653942585,
0.0960247666,
-0.3969394863,
0.2066006809,
0.3706696928,
0.804554224,
0.4284952879,
-0.5806766748,
-0.2334532291,
-0.115320757,
0.4098017216,
-0.4952915013,
0.6774944067,
0.4984260201,
0.4108623862,
-0.2537087798,
-0.4146673679,
-0.4584782422,
0.0737472475,
-0.3175554276,
0.1669149548,
0.0914476812,
-0.1270923913,
0.218254298,
0.234300524,
-0.9854460955,
-0.066096954,
-0.4118336737,
0.0437025689,
0.2521284223,
0.2202954143,
-0.117299065,
-0.3206777275,
-0.3672578335,
0.0387727916,
-0.817815125,
0.2176082432,
0.1081094444,
0.3402115703,
0.0015701969,
0.4798220694,
-0.1912988871,
0.8179680705,
0.0927772522,
0.2448072135,
0.2894999683,
-0.2440674007,
-0.2104157805,
0.1397882551,
0.5071957111,
0.5540428758,
0.1546788961,
-0.4199818969,
-0.0281162448,
-0.0461989418,
0.4224126637,
-0.790907979,
-0.1174913868,
0.1619091779,
-0.4196125269,
0.1015357822,
0.2243480384,
-0.6091606021,
-0.2659074664,
-0.3187714815,
0.2600990236,
-0.5211905837,
-0.1055808291,
-0.0228432957,
-0.2298254967,
0.6728363037,
0.0105341263,
-0.6312305927,
0.3912777305,
0.8841896057,
0.8803802133,
-0.3621453941,
0.1067350432,
-0.3245848119,
0.2127207965,
-0.5164170861,
0.5598211884,
-0.5926744342,
-0.2646356821,
0.007767933,
0.0609441996,
-0.121357359,
-0.7444317937,
0.1653701663,
-0.7227733731,
0.2011442482,
-0.4777248204,
-0.9159420729,
-0.0669799894,
0.7225105166,
-0.6851024032,
1.445507884,
0.310798347,
-0.64417696,
0.6450694799,
-0.5014178157,
-0.26883322,
0.2303045243,
-0.32028234,
-0.4415901005,
0.0517047867,
0.0821068957,
0.2923542857,
-0.3414697349,
0.3185159266,
-0.343480289,
-0.6820946336,
0.2015722692,
0.0895396024,
0.7021057606,
0.0248822197,
-0.0820716769,
-0.0140985288,
-0.48165223,
0.1615141779,
0.0290267859,
-0.3448851109,
-0.6166456938,
-0.1324039847,
-0.2036001831,
0.0702820942,
-0.0292639192,
-0.6233971119,
-0.1704540253,
-0.9412033558,
0.3176731765,
0.330080539,
0.166914627,
0.6670414805,
-0.0439270847,
0.4369297028,
-0.049456466,
-0.0327799171,
0.1203240678,
-0.409158051,
-0.3124939203,
0.0304673593,
0.2908133864,
0.4102371037,
-0.5758241415,
0.5349710584,
-0.4943632782,
-0.462436974,
-0.4655742943,
0.0341177434,
0.5274511576,
0.7770270705,
0.6825353503,
-0.4963857532,
-0.6709774137,
-0.8184167743,
-0.7087705731,
-0.0063690483,
-0.3259148896,
0.4067746401,
0.5454090834,
0.1240975633,
0.9814113975,
-0.4212325811,
-0.5100420713,
-0.0010773222,
-0.4088826776,
0.0892507806,
0.5911622643,
0.6564608812,
-0.6267191172,
-0.8573448658,
-0.1087459773,
-0.98718822,
0.4350022376,
0.2979937196,
-0.1744336039,
0.2466050833,
0.726195395,
-0.4794657826,
0.2766613066,
0.08616855,
-0.3430728316,
0.1822997332,
0.1098962203,
0.0829899907,
-1.3708685637,
-0.0995319113,
-0.0989590958,
0.061819572,
-0.3740932047,
0.2244078666,
0.3651587367,
-0.1825536489,
-0.3446434438,
0.5325413346,
-0.3702745438,
-0.3167859912,
0.2817111611,
0.1298950166,
0.1187299341,
0.4805177152,
-0.0054894248,
0.784751296,
0.5848144293,
-0.4161552787,
0.1198557541,
0.5174605846,
-0.7022656202,
0.7635553479,
-0.834002614,
0.3291575015,
-0.2005797625,
0.4402891099,
-0.9816835523,
-0.1692445874,
-0.0383591391,
-0.5118567348,
0.1087358668,
-0.4640256763,
-0.3968358934,
-0.2485543787,
-0.3655481637,
0.3311281204,
0.4221537411,
-0.6607022285,
0.6550104618,
0.3781173527,
0.0068531823,
-0.5999074578,
-0.9001233578,
-0.1000960991,
-0.3066331744,
-0.3344478607,
0.523347199,
0.3505081236,
0.1248276085,
0.1541142315,
-0.2940774858,
-0.3126333356,
0.0289623085,
0.3271482587,
0.0399908051,
-0.4163439572,
0.4750469625,
0.4187413454,
0.3153234422,
0.2396076918,
-0.5099684,
0.5088760257,
-0.3284890056,
-0.2874950767,
-0.0428317524,
0.2219397873,
0.0901739523,
-0.4057654142,
0.9125500917,
0.4393882751,
-0.5860900879,
-0.0748007223,
-0.4435995817,
-0.4584358037,
-0.4880156815,
0.6871809959,
-0.5873446465,
-1.0732779503,
0.4459094703,
0.0019183024,
-0.3127496839,
0.2545188069,
0.0900863335,
-0.3021508455,
0.718554616,
0.3076789379,
0.0547399111,
0.2838563621,
-0.3243730068,
0.1568177044,
-0.9158819914,
-0.8194630742,
-0.5373575091,
-0.2776146233,
-0.3421978354,
-0.551523447,
0.3668148816,
0.1701240987,
-0.5262641311,
0.6627044678,
-0.485814929,
0.8322132826,
0.1744844764,
0.1651758403,
-0.1184470803,
0.3381547332,
-0.2183935046,
-0.1871415228,
-0.7241142392,
-0.1624591947,
0.9752347469,
0.0099158473,
0.4747735262,
0.3414250016,
0.6571536064,
0.1353858262,
-0.0135414405,
-0.617914319,
0.4884704947,
-0.1059332639,
-0.5972581506,
-0.2863053381,
-0.4482999146,
-0.7831148505,
0.2315909415,
-0.2229892612,
-0.4139464796,
0.2142499983,
-0.1110228598,
-0.2772825956,
0.0717972592,
-0.4206781685,
0.9495567083,
-0.0771462694,
-0.3736311495,
-0.1091910154,
-0.6334924102,
-0.0735753551,
-0.0688533336,
-0.1165113375,
0.0393175893,
-0.1445054114,
0.803491354,
-0.0461284406,
0.6086844802,
-0.4420786202,
0.2608539462,
0.3613260686,
0.3440511525,
0.1745908856,
0.0283956211,
-0.4875122905,
0.1095252037,
0.1828651875,
-0.3955651522,
-0.7951334715,
0.559525311,
-0.266988337,
-0.2082895637,
-0.1037540957,
-0.1832086444,
-0.2522541881,
-0.1157208011,
0.1320515573,
0.6579396129,
-0.3442139328,
0.6854850054,
0.5575569868,
-0.0312376674,
0.179294914,
0.3430226743,
0.0297347419,
-0.0863259137,
0.5620185137,
0.0459138118,
-0.0791213959,
0.6097713709,
-0.0221220646,
-0.8066928983,
-0.3913057446,
-0.402462393,
-0.0539426468,
-0.7016807199,
-0.6855379939,
-0.6920419335,
-0.0973629355,
-0.2935448289,
-0.1604928672,
-0.2808704376,
-0.3372489512,
-0.1320768893,
-0.362308681,
0.4478400946,
0.5102761984,
0.6139864326,
0.0698830485,
-0.4529946744,
-0.1411283463,
0.185249716,
0.6018610597,
0.0602237657,
-0.8705509305,
-0.2520419657,
-0.0075819348,
-0.0764967427,
-0.8692058325,
0.3707287014,
0.835385859,
0.5451769829,
0.1846387237,
0.0860626325,
0.7542341948,
-0.461891979,
0.8428199291,
-0.0737969652,
-0.7150442004,
0.726277113,
0.1244470403,
0.1755045056,
0.9585487843,
0.7730029821,
-0.1948436648,
-0.164077118,
-0.1027430221,
-0.6188126802,
0.3904479146,
-0.0825527012,
0.2471933961,
-0.4826791883,
0.7670366764,
0.0723510236,
-0.0070118015,
-0.6195867062,
0.1263732761,
-0.3284979165,
-0.492274791,
0.3808482289,
-0.1659122556,
0.1661307067,
-0.5130080581,
0.319588989,
-0.4897330999,
0.3291068375,
0.158411026,
-0.4045689702,
0.1187774464,
0.1615578979,
0.0326475576,
0.3853610754,
-0.4185413122,
0.0352696106,
0.8146722913,
-0.2696371973,
-0.156621784,
-0.0047123674,
-0.1188110486,
-0.0779239759,
0.2215123028,
0.6233915091,
0.3898107409,
-0.8125417829,
0.5614225864,
-0.1393904537,
-0.0233557951,
-0.2706932724,
-0.0429873206,
0.2306216508,
0.2633179128,
0.2139195949,
-0.0143289873,
0.428168416,
-0.5892423987,
0.2426373065,
0.6172557473,
-0.9834942222,
-0.1721879691,
0.6398503184,
0.0344827324,
-0.3805307448,
0.8129115105,
-0.3875601292,
-0.7876198292,
0.7032900453,
0.703471005,
0.5074162483,
-0.2581541538,
-0.2570408583,
0.9489818811,
0.0771813691,
-0.0965177789,
0.5045955777,
-0.2073993981,
-0.6427835226,
-0.0139717571,
-0.8792157173,
-0.1796384901,
-0.379478991,
-0.9872805476,
0.1325317472,
-0.3117327392,
0.0770907328,
-0.3784249127,
-0.0587190762,
-0.6627301574,
0.1420328319,
-0.2845121324,
0.8805245757,
-0.6802629828,
1.0186706781,
0.6460759044,
-0.334959656,
-0.7114644051,
-0.1792635769,
-0.0989464298,
-0.4328215122,
0.5002291799,
0.4548845887,
-0.0055348901,
-0.1423694491,
-0.1471597552,
-0.6496353149,
1.3701843023,
0.3956049085,
-0.5258861184,
-0.0735560805,
0.2767073512,
0.7916121483,
-0.7095435262,
0.3545679748,
0.7192712426,
-0.1247738525,
-0.1896721274,
-0.6660373807,
0.185386166,
-0.2553914785,
0.1410594434,
0.2109943181,
-0.2611909211,
0.5210427642,
-0.0999003723,
-0.1732083559,
-0.0838867053,
0.6167046428,
0.1423138678,
0.2882434428,
0.3637878001,
0.3902195394,
0.7730588317,
-0.1349233091,
1.0592961311,
-0.3253172636,
0.3379127085,
1.4678571224,
-0.4148950875,
1.2720133066,
0.3512765169,
-0.3422045112,
0.5849028826,
0.5306864977,
-0.1758997887,
0.5357402563,
0.0825056061,
0.197717756,
0.0276913606,
-0.0837902501,
-0.6213986874,
0.5959770679,
0.532363534,
-0.4240269959,
-0.0243216008,
-0.2631335855,
-0.3547780514,
0.5098793507,
0.0145697286,
1.1010396481,
0.1588019729,
-0.5054000616,
0.6454064846,
-0.2233715057,
0.7151272893,
-0.4637928307,
0.0324420482,
-0.557536602,
0.021322215,
-0.056547489,
-0.7522031665,
0.8735105395,
-0.0982855931,
0.0215570293,
0.1546457708,
0.5537782907,
-0.7734432817,
-0.1363340765,
0.5778129101,
0.3403897583,
0.1675136536,
-0.458308965,
-0.861753583,
-0.2028967738,
-0.2606393397,
0.2250598818,
0.3694785237,
0.2430856824,
0.0450852774,
0.3725702763,
0.3253504336,
-0.3135068119,
0.1181283295,
0.199084118,
0.6337494254,
-0.5658333302,
-0.6013108492,
-0.6653124094,
-0.0297285244,
-0.3626870811,
-0.2955994904,
0.6729406714,
1.0842499733,
0.9530177116,
-0.3091507256,
0.1686574221,
0.1230294183,
0.4997349679,
-0.4632160366,
0.8854157925,
-0.6031349301,
0.2847665846,
0.0020462605,
-1.3121856451,
-0.2275154144,
0.660302043,
-0.1377205253,
-0.1292837262,
0.6592255235,
1.2735108137,
-0.1341380626,
0.1947099268,
0.2077301443,
0.1518007666,
0.0162022486,
0.6075516939,
0.6776323915,
-0.6966386437,
0.503230989,
0.0167363994,
0.1677601039,
-0.1439369172,
-0.5130498409,
-1.0131845474,
-0.7822938561,
-0.2238261551,
-0.4242803156,
0.3460029066,
1.0500793457,
0.6379960775,
-0.9243425131,
-0.2467080355,
-0.0369731747,
-0.0425494947,
-0.3842001855,
-0.2262479067,
0.6731687784,
-0.1676843613,
-0.2259510159,
0.488742739,
0.2433651984,
-0.1853386909,
0.1131079048,
-0.1344955564,
-0.2650434375,
0.2041938603,
0.8531972766,
-0.0224261247,
-0.8305954337,
-0.2978598773,
0.0871372819,
-0.1388747394,
0.0517783426,
0.3998451233,
-0.9469759464,
0.3409407437,
0.476190567,
0.9564806223,
0.7198662162,
0.0527410135,
0.2085685283,
-1.1986995935,
0.1098439768,
0.3129999042,
0.2815838456,
0.5456466079,
-0.4590065479,
0.8385049701,
-0.0547205843,
-0.1373448968,
-0.8390896916,
0.2303004563,
-0.8950399756,
-0.1327495724,
0.9065614343,
-0.1439138204,
-0.2461765409,
-0.3696335852,
0.1018606275,
0.1401097924,
-0.130681023,
0.6895819902,
0.05416134,
0.1390308887,
0.0650535375,
-0.2430040985,
0.6160823703,
0.552182734,
-0.630718708,
-0.2273267955,
0.1110010147,
0.4062999189,
-0.1671988219,
0.2670292258,
-0.3770617843,
0.1515576392,
0.1481629759,
-0.1982381642,
-0.1156223193,
-0.149659887,
-0.4017773867,
0.545604825,
-0.2912417352,
0.008107014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16187v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16187v2
|
ALoRA: Allocating Low-Rank Adaptation for Fine-tuning Large Language Models
| 2024-03-24T15:09:55 | 2024-04-15T13:25:05 |
Zequan Liu, Jiawen Lyn, Wei Zhu, Xing Tian, Yvette Graham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is widely studied for its
effectiveness and efficiency in the era of large language models. Low-rank
adaptation (LoRA) has demonstrated commendable performance as a popular and
representative method. However, it is implemented with a fixed intrinsic rank
that might not be the ideal setting for the downstream tasks. Recognizing the
need for more flexible downstream task adaptation, we extend the methodology of
LoRA to an innovative approach we call allocating low-rank adaptation (ALoRA)
that enables dynamic adjustments to the intrinsic rank during the adaptation
process. First, we propose a novel method, AB-LoRA, that can effectively
estimate the importance score of each LoRA rank. Second, guided by AB-LoRA, we
gradually prune abundant and negatively impacting LoRA ranks and allocate the
pruned LoRA budgets to important Transformer modules needing higher ranks. We
have conducted experiments on various tasks, and the experimental results
demonstrate that our ALoRA method can outperform the recent baselines with
comparable tunable parameters.
|
[
-0.4261952639,
-0.8842215538,
0.4421916902,
0.0897255912,
-0.1032215729,
0.0416774638,
-0.4461987615,
-0.3398221135,
0.1081896573,
0.3673752248,
-0.4073553681,
-0.2728830576,
-0.6235619783,
-0.1093342304,
-0.3071791828,
1.1082803011,
0.0310189985,
-0.5611877441,
0.3351048231,
-0.3157188892,
-0.5176582336,
-0.0125716049,
-0.8503311276,
-0.2247044146,
0.9102059007,
0.8682714701,
0.924739778,
0.8389480114,
0.6094917059,
0.2405572981,
-0.0802126303,
0.0774305537,
-0.5983489752,
0.1840916872,
-0.5252169371,
-0.5601002574,
-0.8746379018,
-0.2169699669,
0.8251675367,
0.7906594872,
-0.1959445328,
0.3842001259,
0.0904297084,
0.7722274065,
-1.0194829702,
-0.1670767367,
-1.1356240511,
-0.2535572648,
-0.3329762816,
-0.2893117368,
-0.4088382721,
-0.2741321623,
0.0203195568,
-0.8199158311,
-0.1613017768,
0.091969125,
0.8318310976,
0.7504983544,
-0.1565403044,
-0.0612505563,
-0.999233067,
0.7800413966,
-0.5432120562,
0.3045434356,
0.349085182,
0.2491504699,
0.1895289272,
-0.3284099996,
-0.2450404018,
-0.0790847614,
0.2650165856,
-0.0207520816,
-0.4498572648,
-0.035137523,
0.0057720579,
0.3334510326,
-0.1124853268,
0.5113261342,
-0.4039987028,
0.0653530732,
0.368422538,
-0.1855285317,
-0.071493119,
0.2417912036,
-0.0539116673,
-0.3810288906,
-0.8480525017,
0.061417263,
0.453638345,
0.5788051486,
0.0082174921,
0.3190761805,
-0.2805180252,
0.4831368029,
0.5202304721,
-0.0924850851,
0.1048628986,
0.0894273669,
-0.3409633338,
0.1952557266,
0.3032688498,
0.0242717769,
0.0705852136,
-0.0323974527,
-0.2261585444,
0.0687399879,
0.2355634868,
-0.6782252789,
-0.2753250003,
0.0124773085,
-0.4625206888,
-0.254830718,
-0.2717314363,
-0.9935517311,
-0.3778113127,
-0.2753906846,
0.9443759918,
-0.2229944021,
-0.1540295482,
0.091652602,
0.3378529549,
0.3877970874,
0.6037303209,
-1.2428129911,
0.4342422187,
0.5148775578,
0.692515254,
-0.3824400604,
-0.462423116,
-1.0130051374,
0.2756388485,
-0.1984124184,
0.9856218696,
-0.4740193784,
-0.0735849589,
-0.2198501378,
0.1038317829,
-0.4584103823,
-0.7170596123,
0.7847679257,
-0.5225665569,
-0.1282810867,
-0.0236002542,
0.0460353754,
0.0860148892,
-0.1855906695,
-0.716350615,
1.0732359886,
0.3728303611,
-0.3961797953,
0.1268574595,
-1.0764290094,
-0.6383897066,
-0.2313924283,
0.4152248204,
-0.4367322028,
0.3495412767,
0.2637348175,
0.2116196603,
-0.3687651157,
-0.2275977731,
-0.1927720904,
-0.4570292234,
0.026123371,
-0.4282530844,
0.4342340827,
0.3341015279,
-0.3700053394,
0.3988038599,
-0.6518222094,
-0.1366937608,
-0.2006605566,
-0.3740785718,
-0.45127666,
0.0477236733,
0.061855644,
-0.1736469567,
0.300235033,
-0.1744018942,
0.4948529303,
-0.4973569512,
0.6340204477,
1.1069331169,
-0.2325879186,
0.9028640389,
-0.277957052,
0.4714089334,
-0.2775195837,
0.4229845107,
0.2184365541,
-0.1963975728,
-1.3059880733,
-0.423050195,
0.5744255781,
0.5305737853,
-0.6362791061,
0.6067523956,
-0.4522115588,
-0.6220973134,
-0.7847723365,
0.2238866389,
0.0233350061,
0.1884779483,
0.46315521,
-0.0850988477,
-0.2001891732,
-1.0826694965,
0.034984462,
-0.2734969854,
0.0756689161,
0.0488832369,
0.4058014154,
-0.1997399032,
0.8077050447,
-0.5965692997,
-0.549320817,
-0.1222231463,
0.2304885238,
0.5020010471,
0.4840811491,
0.6641556621,
-0.5111898184,
-0.5028158426,
0.2671538591,
-0.104481101,
-0.2849955857,
-0.1870443672,
-0.5622414351,
0.1812042743,
0.5115182996,
-0.3987202048,
0.1079911068,
0.9644230604,
-0.3657506108,
0.0131154489,
-0.3741908967,
0.0659621283,
-0.8594728112,
0.170122236,
-0.3013418913,
-0.262537688,
-0.3971251249,
0.1444662809,
0.0835083947,
-0.0960508659,
-0.4704252481,
0.6088964343,
-0.2325562537,
0.0478847399,
-0.4191521704,
-0.2085999697,
-0.1327332407,
0.6954111457,
-0.3274439573,
0.9494823813,
0.5954552889,
-0.6728309989,
-0.0066680657,
0.191770196,
-0.4743919671,
0.5849544406,
-0.4326053262,
0.1557029933,
-0.0100893807,
-0.1051358283,
-0.7157444954,
-0.0900863335,
0.1976595968,
0.1021612585,
0.1289347559,
-0.2484734356,
-0.2176349908,
0.1935997605,
-0.2680742145,
0.4800775349,
0.6533590555,
-0.6788332462,
0.809709549,
0.4913967848,
-0.5170211792,
-0.2176336646,
-0.2801842988,
-0.129554525,
-0.6738932133,
-0.2828451693,
0.7961101532,
-0.2673924267,
-0.237471655,
0.0553241707,
-0.1483467966,
0.047284957,
0.5289708376,
0.156881094,
0.0341219716,
-0.3198276758,
-0.0221105367,
0.3880824149,
-0.1744541824,
-0.4181494415,
-0.0049620015,
0.4181618094,
-0.233056128,
-0.4386141598,
-0.2455777824,
0.2582854927,
0.8665347099,
-0.2099317014,
0.7718943954,
0.571047008,
-0.2804983854,
-0.4298979938,
-0.4104014039,
-0.0681160465,
-0.513541162,
0.4863481522,
-0.3249226809,
-0.8744100332,
0.5346368551,
-0.3173474073,
0.1123004928,
0.7155700326,
0.6136999726,
-0.0914107561,
0.8696319461,
1.0172852278,
-0.21581617,
0.7653285861,
-0.0569650829,
0.3753149807,
-0.8572357297,
0.3716169596,
-0.7096124887,
-0.7020218968,
-0.5974747539,
-0.4198458493,
0.7429358959,
0.3668492436,
-0.3164815605,
0.3697312772,
-0.3900220394,
0.4875583947,
0.5612413287,
0.0213610698,
0.4378704131,
0.0684539452,
0.4926214814,
0.1960038394,
-0.5046855211,
-0.183215037,
0.9123513103,
0.4310573936,
0.8777697682,
0.4537768364,
0.3905390203,
0.594047606,
0.4115918875,
-0.9872995019,
0.3286105096,
-0.4699136615,
-0.3570824564,
-0.7611532211,
-0.182199955,
-0.9711176753,
0.1688435078,
-0.1870408505,
-0.6739114523,
0.4747907221,
0.2748499811,
-0.8560949564,
0.0712307468,
-0.6878625154,
0.6420398355,
-0.2277716845,
-0.37728706,
-0.5672174096,
-0.2376948744,
-0.072600536,
-0.5079758763,
0.3084592223,
-0.3818975091,
0.0105555207,
0.8795326948,
-0.1126919091,
0.7116653919,
-0.1833174378,
-0.3930724263,
-0.0636894703,
-0.00051938,
0.7046519518,
0.0091297003,
-0.5200430155,
-0.1315311939,
-0.0089216195,
-0.4850091636,
-0.5685783625,
0.9244735837,
-1.0307372808,
-0.6236142516,
-0.2935060561,
-0.67541188,
-0.3844607174,
0.0867582858,
0.0806975141,
0.1094783545,
-0.1607972533,
0.3850927353,
0.6512110829,
-0.2580126226,
0.5162511468,
0.3494963348,
0.0703687221,
-0.2613010406,
0.9943341017,
0.0345423147,
0.2608034313,
0.5574461222,
0.2229803354,
0.0177587457,
-0.6816504598,
-0.5078890324,
0.0704924911,
-0.7207615972,
-0.278033793,
-0.1199234203,
-0.1254547834,
-0.1084818169,
-0.3535656631,
-0.7578329444,
-0.6066743731,
-0.1089059114,
0.1954238564,
0.6187908649,
0.4297738075,
0.0090755699,
0.7425224185,
-0.516038239,
0.3982307017,
0.4846555591,
0.404751569,
0.0001582358,
-0.8968740702,
-0.5143501759,
-0.1130957678,
-0.3331535161,
-0.5214188695,
0.294359386,
0.7284921408,
0.6164643764,
0.1564393044,
0.2351843715,
0.8305271268,
-0.6051753163,
0.2440263778,
-0.1864902675,
-1.1149616241,
0.5577092767,
-0.5302168727,
0.3409408033,
0.8952470422,
-0.0993707031,
-0.2441345602,
-0.0275977142,
-0.1161882654,
-1.1239688396,
0.6793649197,
0.1814105809,
0.2844389975,
0.3613829911,
0.3709268272,
0.2875236571,
-0.0909674317,
-0.7091600299,
-0.0899034366,
0.0383833423,
-0.2815877199,
0.0478213057,
-0.021216508,
-0.2382243127,
-0.5462572575,
0.9339214563,
-0.4781042039,
0.326616019,
-0.1697471142,
-0.3270494044,
-0.4740235209,
0.5793463588,
0.4004453123,
0.8992248774,
-0.3563129008,
0.1040126979,
0.496881336,
-0.2694759667,
0.0956190526,
0.1560515016,
-0.2539201379,
-0.3808380961,
0.2080911398,
1.089110136,
0.4826509058,
-0.575689435,
0.2163841873,
0.2112887353,
-0.2290876657,
-0.1530316919,
0.327133745,
-0.1219517961,
0.3502628803,
0.5848301053,
0.2335945815,
-0.1191100255,
-0.7342171073,
-0.1175642759,
0.1707311571,
-0.2443814129,
-0.3570018411,
0.4747242332,
0.4591801763,
-0.155009076,
0.3678401709,
0.0075612236,
-0.1233805194,
0.3305782676,
0.4389131367,
0.7569371462,
-0.4900517166,
0.2282963842,
0.1244197264,
0.2884651124,
-0.1882531196,
0.0869306773,
0.2438993603,
-0.6212732792,
-0.6134397984,
-1.0354503393,
-0.5134025216,
0.2499480695,
-0.6767890453,
0.4466483295,
-0.4541336298,
-0.0264285579,
0.0995267853,
-0.2385499179,
-0.50491786,
-0.1631777734,
0.1658474207,
0.8143312335,
-1.1006957293,
1.1916793585,
0.691827476,
-0.0306872576,
-0.4641020894,
0.2335365415,
-0.4324359894,
-0.8103420138,
0.4107295275,
-0.3198704422,
-0.3676492274,
0.430975914,
-0.1133862212,
-1.2856667042,
1.1596034765,
0.7572370172,
-0.48541677,
-0.1917412728,
-0.0218234081,
0.4398862123,
-0.1700329036,
-0.0295204856,
0.6253380775,
0.7259626389,
-0.1239131093,
-1.2033501863,
-0.0925273374,
-0.1711338013,
-0.109496735,
0.4663932621,
-0.7564073205,
1.0009694099,
0.0697463229,
0.0102743227,
0.3394373357,
0.5848373175,
0.1051259264,
-0.0461876914,
1.0241171122,
0.3138693571,
0.7973356247,
-0.0446657166,
0.6377136707,
-0.2215371132,
0.3077153862,
0.8594107032,
-0.4101546705,
1.2090117931,
0.6777618527,
-0.1639050394,
0.5493383408,
0.5102826357,
0.1016189829,
0.9938668609,
-0.0793578699,
0.0618656836,
-0.4281397462,
-0.2479266375,
-0.3763210177,
0.6670496464,
0.44326213,
-0.1478121877,
-0.2028455287,
0.1533931643,
-0.0776157305,
-0.0918381587,
-0.6196273565,
0.5506654382,
-0.0964718089,
-0.8213111162,
0.8609991074,
0.1753166765,
0.6283413768,
-0.4830684662,
0.0456918366,
-0.1873059273,
0.5501742363,
-0.0278486945,
-0.3637451828,
0.2574081421,
-0.0474428982,
-0.3829495013,
-0.4343856871,
0.5872504115,
-0.2299952954,
-0.6298562288,
0.3659840226,
0.5743875504,
-0.2359172255,
-0.1978290528,
-0.5419429541,
0.3576732278,
-0.181881085,
-0.3727523685,
0.705732286,
0.2550183237,
-0.4448263347,
0.4404029548,
0.616994977,
0.1327956021,
-0.1948771328,
0.1746286601,
0.8963044286,
-0.460100323,
-0.5020444989,
-0.6715810895,
0.2761008143,
0.3066305816,
-0.3015090823,
0.3956252933,
0.2523497939,
0.6201419234,
-0.0585895181,
0.6925408244,
-0.0986824557,
0.4270963073,
-0.7341401577,
0.7587509751,
-0.7314776778,
0.318701148,
-0.2680793107,
-1.3296576738,
-0.1806096733,
0.7739246488,
-0.2905054092,
-0.225272432,
0.7287409306,
0.7217573524,
-0.4330002367,
-0.3053309023,
0.2389556319,
0.4574600756,
0.0744717494,
0.6816316247,
0.7411002517,
-0.4258011281,
0.5934827924,
-0.1612229347,
-0.390805155,
-0.4090657234,
-1.0346175432,
-0.5201524496,
-0.5291223526,
-0.3918194473,
0.0797069296,
0.355188638,
0.9032764435,
0.9418042302,
-0.9548744559,
-0.296007961,
0.2010134608,
0.009770371,
-0.5642072558,
-0.1374213547,
0.6140543818,
0.0162124578,
-1.0329766273,
0.6326512098,
0.3322530985,
-0.4544665217,
-0.1061210111,
-0.1179099381,
-0.1618565917,
0.0389844328,
0.7137821913,
0.3075393438,
-0.6476851702,
-0.6675662994,
0.0446325429,
0.1252782196,
0.1240392476,
0.5624602437,
-0.7052464485,
-0.2332449704,
0.4055992365,
0.6756378412,
0.3884474039,
0.0157065149,
0.512545228,
-0.5904718041,
0.0971224904,
-0.0056889723,
0.3159627616,
0.2094306201,
-0.2123224437,
0.5767424703,
-0.181607604,
-0.5841510296,
-0.9554043412,
0.2034979463,
-1.3531166315,
-0.3339141607,
1.1658747196,
0.2528278232,
-0.150974229,
0.0364588201,
-0.3304727674,
0.1799734533,
-0.488237381,
1.0200642347,
0.4086160958,
-0.1352998167,
-0.2746346891,
-0.5703873634,
0.4256677926,
0.687127769,
-1.0249736309,
0.205576539,
0.0617558323,
0.0758621395,
0.2430729419,
0.4230859578,
0.2815228701,
0.1796871424,
-0.6686388254,
-0.1586737186,
0.1707704663,
-0.4957289398,
-0.3491276503,
0.229530856,
0.7323812246,
0.0397964679
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16176v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16176v1
|
Subspace Defense: Discarding Adversarial Perturbations by Learning a Subspace for Clean Signals
| 2024-03-24T14:35:44 | 2024-03-24T14:35:44 |
Rui Zheng, Yuhao Zhou, Zhiheng Xi, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Deep neural networks (DNNs) are notoriously vulnerable to adversarial attacks
that place carefully crafted perturbations on normal examples to fool DNNs. To
better understand such attacks, a characterization of the features carried by
adversarial examples is needed. In this paper, we tackle this challenge by
inspecting the subspaces of sample features through spectral analysis. We first
empirically show that the features of either clean signals or adversarial
perturbations are redundant and span in low-dimensional linear subspaces
respectively with minimal overlap, and the classical low-dimensional subspace
projection can suppress perturbation features out of the subspace of clean
signals. This makes it possible for DNNs to learn a subspace where only
features of clean signals exist while those of perturbations are discarded,
which can facilitate the distinction of adversarial examples. To prevent the
residual perturbations that is inevitable in subspace learning, we propose an
independence criterion to disentangle clean signals from perturbations.
Experimental results show that the proposed strategy enables the model to
inherently suppress adversaries, which not only boosts model robustness but
also motivates new directions of effective adversarial defense.
|
[
-0.540553987,
-0.6807771921,
0.2113710493,
-0.294768244,
-0.3223979771,
0.3432823122,
0.0295368526,
-0.0381827317,
0.2736212313,
0.6971287727,
-0.566061914,
-0.532263577,
-0.6591533422,
-0.3176796436,
-0.6091780066,
0.9199264646,
0.2931456268,
-0.1163370311,
-0.0153106861,
0.1244618148,
-0.4156628251,
-0.4839754403,
-0.4270703793,
-0.0181967393,
0.5647186041,
0.1773191988,
0.6468685269,
0.541680038,
0.5396715403,
0.3744753897,
-0.4528072476,
0.1320462525,
-0.7774217129,
0.2758005857,
0.1428904384,
-0.5926445723,
-0.1900709122,
0.118647173,
0.5248321891,
0.8620538712,
0.1990347207,
-0.0485680737,
0.1243571788,
0.662871778,
-0.6520658135,
-0.2557446957,
-0.853759408,
0.5748240948,
-0.4546485841,
-0.012406745,
-0.1921771765,
-0.229173854,
-0.2487971038,
-0.4455725253,
0.3751725554,
-0.6466472745,
0.9847125411,
0.4828123748,
-0.4121323526,
0.2994028628,
-0.9163825512,
0.6126589775,
-0.3094108403,
0.177363053,
0.2869848907,
0.4328820705,
-0.4277032316,
-0.7439235449,
-0.3843336403,
-0.365257293,
-0.0124504371,
0.1320790946,
-0.5832318068,
0.1387511492,
0.2478447855,
0.2511329651,
-0.2321288884,
0.1419454664,
-0.5171402097,
-0.4152120352,
0.4898385108,
0.0076311175,
0.207268849,
-0.1448166817,
-0.9796851277,
-0.4269319177,
-0.9025281668,
0.175898388,
0.8219835162,
0.0415367596,
0.189673245,
0.1629267931,
0.0832874104,
0.262265563,
0.1595149636,
0.19201985,
-0.0290055294,
-0.0819727853,
-0.1373555064,
-0.0670810863,
0.6420425773,
-0.2828838527,
-0.0749852583,
-0.3239205778,
-0.4506945908,
0.1903728992,
0.5251733661,
-0.3985282779,
-0.8522626758,
-0.0422433577,
-0.5943282247,
-0.7167187333,
0.0260540247,
-0.8677490354,
-0.8133788705,
-0.4054285884,
0.386208415,
-0.2547283471,
-0.2387841642,
-0.0606366172,
-0.2736274004,
-0.2945867479,
0.1162490696,
-0.6417307854,
0.6389304996,
0.7092521191,
0.2030497938,
0.1967387497,
-0.1092488617,
-0.3917986453,
-0.6019144654,
-0.4425123036,
0.3363897204,
-0.1034010723,
-0.2107423842,
-0.2757892609,
-0.3754247725,
0.2466179579,
-0.5655356646,
0.3818489611,
-0.7675722241,
-0.2485914379,
-0.5706157088,
-0.2753399312,
-0.5090066791,
0.122231625,
-0.8265870214,
0.3614923656,
0.0015345858,
-0.5311946273,
0.4750692844,
-0.4054843187,
-0.3545403481,
0.1023042202,
-0.2913304865,
-0.6598222256,
0.3832075596,
0.2228462547,
0.2837544084,
0.3996810019,
-0.0754050091,
-0.6797741055,
-0.4462851286,
0.4070847332,
-0.7148978114,
1.1075174809,
0.678910315,
-0.4853767157,
0.2088323832,
-1.0369919538,
-0.1360214353,
0.0762458071,
-0.0352408178,
-0.339248836,
0.283472538,
-0.4199085534,
0.0298190266,
-0.0223593153,
-0.6190891266,
0.1945292652,
-0.2259332538,
0.2284760326,
0.8682931066,
0.3205550313,
0.1302497685,
-0.1403587162,
0.5170191526,
0.1515617222,
0.3981779218,
0.2397542447,
-0.0474028625,
-0.7484927773,
-0.817258954,
0.4102599919,
0.2033228874,
-0.79741925,
0.4897083044,
0.0570016317,
-0.3406846225,
-0.2390832901,
0.386842072,
0.4959357381,
0.2382699847,
0.3502257168,
-0.2709025443,
-0.8902170062,
-0.8657509089,
0.1252327263,
0.0912657902,
0.1783984303,
-0.1193557382,
0.4599635601,
0.2966430187,
0.5788223147,
-0.3466544151,
-0.2567301095,
-0.0162126552,
-0.3342346847,
-0.0202402305,
0.3072354794,
0.7533818483,
-0.8638780117,
0.0098116864,
-0.3084368706,
-0.8442226648,
0.208198905,
0.0760158822,
-0.104278788,
-0.7472970486,
0.7850805521,
-0.2612641454,
0.7123318911,
0.1880618334,
-0.3257594407,
0.3701508343,
0.0110791074,
-0.2111171931,
-0.5334191918,
0.1875662059,
-0.096395053,
-0.3766001463,
-0.8495869637,
0.3716680706,
-0.2329439819,
-0.3800700605,
-0.424487859,
-0.0989750996,
-0.2028178126,
0.0726702735,
-0.2528192103,
-0.0252734572,
0.3232434988,
0.3528799117,
-0.3553995788,
0.3088656366,
0.336825043,
-0.6884741783,
0.3304181099,
0.3991206586,
-0.0944871008,
0.0915739834,
-0.5558463931,
0.1963096261,
-0.1834275424,
0.1463405639,
-1.2272034883,
0.3627646863,
0.4019577503,
-0.441392839,
0.4752880931,
-0.2601705492,
0.0624477305,
-0.2356185019,
-0.2854278386,
0.2732520998,
0.6204828024,
-0.7905202508,
0.0550980307,
0.2778799534,
0.3857084215,
-0.9293113351,
-0.6337396502,
0.0520371757,
-0.3342540562,
-0.2432921976,
0.0478538536,
0.4472486973,
-0.4467385709,
0.1093779728,
-0.1027274728,
0.0655950606,
0.9684690833,
0.430890888,
0.2605893612,
-0.1459561735,
0.0334408619,
-0.2571903467,
-0.1980179995,
0.3034107685,
-0.5780960321,
0.405521363,
0.1727681905,
-0.6765455008,
-0.3585063517,
0.2247386575,
0.5459085703,
-0.3947440088,
0.1898710579,
0.6107158065,
-0.4089466333,
-0.5410532951,
-0.2360893935,
-0.4160837233,
-0.5389569998,
0.6163987517,
-0.24662444,
-0.3438788652,
0.7450003624,
0.0321823917,
-0.1911847293,
0.4099398851,
0.0753355324,
-0.1764981896,
0.4757163823,
0.329911083,
-0.2785996199,
0.461760819,
-0.6333119273,
0.2764912844,
-0.6639637351,
-0.0322853215,
-0.3001428843,
-0.8684966564,
-0.3594186306,
-0.061519403,
0.4279579818,
0.340544492,
-0.3953751028,
0.1918812394,
-0.6561952829,
0.4541155696,
0.4921241701,
0.5468355417,
-0.311730206,
0.1921272427,
-0.2400242537,
-0.1137247607,
-0.5296268463,
-0.2400881797,
0.9686169624,
0.7268819213,
0.6255976558,
0.2543714941,
1.1259735823,
0.4929934144,
-0.2544531822,
-0.4493726492,
0.6727218628,
-0.7385562658,
-0.4517223835,
-0.0548352525,
-0.5303335786,
-1.0345336199,
0.324288249,
-0.3058064878,
-0.7383347154,
0.8547398448,
0.2809500396,
-0.5641480088,
0.7294576168,
-0.3783166111,
0.5286146402,
-0.2946325541,
-0.331596911,
-0.1239807382,
-0.3451805413,
0.4635019004,
0.3918939531,
-0.2998965085,
0.0585998744,
0.3063107133,
0.3851041496,
-0.3010041118,
1.1832015514,
-0.6722642183,
-0.0197511148,
0.5314766169,
0.4417372346,
0.1822389662,
-0.001011553,
0.3114403486,
0.1235068291,
-0.4031632245,
-0.3393656909,
-0.4305335283,
0.5082026124,
-0.7918485403,
-0.4794727266,
-0.1140404269,
-0.1429150999,
-0.1490328461,
0.1856306046,
0.5001623034,
0.581604898,
-0.2786220312,
0.2153106481,
1.0572063923,
-0.0954553708,
0.6400844455,
0.1030372158,
-0.0471330509,
-0.3530786932,
1.1382852793,
-0.0153422887,
0.4416123927,
0.254152149,
0.1122770682,
-0.249023661,
-1.0271303654,
-0.0697858408,
-0.5018419623,
-0.9399192929,
-0.2640425265,
-0.0814515427,
-0.2072771639,
-0.034204375,
0.2754533589,
-0.4412358999,
-0.3964086473,
-0.198167488,
-0.1792803705,
-0.0299239419,
0.9147050977,
-0.1762904227,
-0.051723104,
-0.5370727777,
0.4142608047,
0.579554975,
0.0766959935,
0.1495878249,
-0.2445880175,
0.0833315402,
0.1342059374,
-0.6821049452,
-0.809969902,
0.2171585858,
-0.0922770724,
0.7428486943,
0.7506297231,
0.1514963359,
0.2556135952,
-0.0671091229,
0.8913103938,
0.1897067279,
-1.0868649483,
0.3494965732,
-0.4595987797,
-0.1204070523,
0.5370559692,
0.0114362529,
-0.0911872685,
-0.263297677,
-0.732483685,
-0.6781842709,
0.1576996148,
0.0855878517,
-0.0782776028,
0.0806864798,
0.4333733618,
-0.1733551621,
0.3400136232,
-0.5525081158,
-0.3090246618,
-0.5271276236,
-0.1474787891,
0.096857816,
-0.1314520687,
-0.6927930117,
0.0687632412,
0.209165886,
0.1779619157,
0.2856026888,
0.3327130377,
-0.0268916693,
0.2017850727,
0.0830965191,
0.5890207887,
0.2597765028,
-0.0406736135,
0.4337255955,
0.1159107909,
-0.6262467504,
0.529646337,
0.1481080651,
-0.2359877825,
-0.2654660344,
0.4535482228,
0.7732529044,
-0.1317018718,
-0.0198518001,
0.6916459799,
-0.0866678953,
-0.5144059062,
-0.2029010057,
0.1241762191,
-0.4407986104,
0.2673520744,
0.2722841501,
0.8155754209,
0.2172330469,
-0.2365400493,
0.3813117146,
0.5550453663,
-0.8063225746,
-0.4051619768,
0.6980350018,
0.0851296261,
0.1312900186,
0.4702198207,
-0.3116476536,
-0.9688922167,
0.9291369915,
0.0189041737,
1.0264347792,
0.0574649535,
-0.044615455,
-0.112032935,
0.4137803912,
0.3684189916,
0.0712307021,
0.036655698,
-0.6125630736,
-0.1480523199,
-0.2682727575,
0.1017260402,
0.4453778565,
-0.6781431437,
0.0691772625,
-1.0128182173,
-0.0630369186,
0.2623933256,
0.1362892836,
-0.5340940356,
0.2690397501,
0.6769857407,
0.5583353043,
-0.9179137349,
0.5318368077,
0.3827477992,
-0.2906199396,
-0.8456209898,
-0.0563694015,
0.5054704547,
-0.3689703643,
0.9425124526,
-0.3723416924,
-0.3391542733,
-0.5537396073,
-0.4123213291,
-0.7652654648,
0.6224092245,
0.5995115042,
-0.3036370575,
0.4983932972,
-0.0966443717,
0.4924250245,
0.1741610616,
-0.0444091596,
0.2523776293,
0.3433616459,
-0.3672679961,
-0.3829381168,
0.1859382391,
-0.3581593931,
-0.120422706,
0.2566242218,
-0.7781676054,
1.2478631735,
-0.033755485,
-0.3304952979,
0.0737347379,
0.5952425003,
-0.3601649106,
0.0699488521,
0.8190967441,
0.6810708642,
0.6491516829,
-0.2092239708,
0.8651093841,
-0.0955673531,
0.3167269826,
0.7344477177,
-0.0260605197,
0.5518192053,
0.224136889,
-0.2082954943,
0.2213688791,
0.2318975478,
-0.4346871376,
0.6248168349,
0.7394372225,
-0.2532297075,
-0.1479495168,
0.4179910123,
-0.3628207445,
1.0472657681,
0.2749560475,
-0.201014325,
-0.2408786416,
0.2491651922,
0.0022845923,
0.6040765643,
-0.2382249683,
0.7264176011,
-0.2083792537,
-0.4181580842,
0.8488302827,
-0.459574759,
0.3047149479,
-0.7955303788,
-0.232117191,
-0.1683327258,
0.8093556762,
-0.3657035828,
-0.1410519779,
0.2257396579,
-0.4442225695,
-0.3148755431,
-0.0013458573,
0.8730913997,
-0.226670742,
-0.1046913192,
0.4472226202,
-0.0221409295,
-0.3392049968,
0.2407354563,
-0.2923369408,
-0.0313623026,
0.2300790697,
0.0301283076,
0.4169006944,
0.0965944305,
0.2970023751,
0.5302632451,
0.6067935824,
0.303165853,
0.0732704476,
-0.0040264353,
1.1115896702,
-0.1802844554,
-0.441647917,
-0.8087235093,
0.4158940017,
-0.150083214,
-0.4314676523,
0.9202635884,
0.1963587105,
0.4383889437,
0.0038195143,
0.7421773076,
0.2282992601,
0.4083966315,
-0.5264492035,
1.0465446711,
-0.2747206688,
0.7391108274,
-0.1769545972,
-0.3199635744,
-0.1316777021,
0.4394344389,
-0.0220005251,
0.0674290806,
0.3330073059,
0.5802087188,
-0.204921186,
0.0578531995,
0.2729927599,
0.1773996055,
0.744194746,
0.5423063636,
1.1308692694,
-0.5428956747,
0.4432059228,
-0.5201243162,
-0.2241960168,
0.061005827,
-0.7730475068,
-0.8504468203,
-0.2796384692,
-0.2350914478,
-0.6162961721,
0.2705497742,
0.4737568498,
0.9071148634,
-0.9460286498,
0.0867147967,
-0.0362231843,
0.214782685,
-0.6765553355,
-0.1623171419,
0.3667287529,
-0.3969906867,
-0.2687854767,
0.9057508707,
-0.0895780921,
0.0092403954,
-0.6924254894,
0.4637296796,
-0.024250932,
-0.2278173119,
0.0462775193,
0.5046366453,
-0.5510497093,
-0.4598000348,
-0.1730505079,
-0.1569522023,
-0.2664847374,
0.7353305817,
-0.7403507829,
0.5652281046,
0.5128566027,
0.6498395205,
0.0931531116,
-0.1543602049,
0.460476011,
-1.1786624193,
0.4239813685,
0.4877821505,
0.4741373956,
0.0533435158,
-0.6331745982,
0.0666575655,
0.1955814958,
-0.3802751303,
-0.6930454373,
0.2662379742,
-0.6911913157,
-0.4860852957,
0.7757531404,
-0.4663208425,
-0.142778337,
-0.1062293276,
-0.0817885697,
0.1309276223,
0.05882385,
0.7843459845,
0.3493495286,
0.1925219446,
0.2277468145,
-0.2036602795,
0.7957389355,
0.4067804217,
-0.3623151481,
0.0524931177,
0.2587033808,
0.3104521632,
0.5243100524,
0.0031400975,
-0.1002783179,
0.4354025424,
0.6188355088,
-0.1432917863,
-0.662781179,
-0.5372619629,
-0.759649992,
0.6047856808,
-0.0407352224,
-1.1314692497
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16167v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16167v3
|
Exploiting Semantic Reconstruction to Mitigate Hallucinations in Vision-Language Models
| 2024-03-24T14:21:06 | 2024-05-05T05:46:45 |
Minchan Kim, Minyeong Kim, Junik Bae, Suhwan Choi, Sungkyung Kim, Buru Chang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Hallucinations in vision-language models pose a significant challenge to
their reliability, particularly in the generation of long captions. Current
methods fall short of accurately identifying and mitigating these
hallucinations. To address this issue, we introduce ESREAL, a novel
unsupervised learning framework designed to suppress the generation of
hallucinations through accurate localization and penalization of hallucinated
tokens. Initially, ESREAL creates a reconstructed image based on the generated
caption and aligns its corresponding regions with those of the original image.
This semantic reconstruction aids in identifying both the presence and type of
token-level hallucinations within the generated caption. Subsequently, ESREAL
computes token-level hallucination scores by assessing the semantic similarity
of aligned regions based on the type of hallucination. Finally, ESREAL employs
a proximal policy optimization algorithm, where it selectively penalizes
hallucinated tokens according to their token-level hallucination scores. Our
framework notably reduces hallucinations in LLaVA, InstructBLIP, and mPLUG-Owl2
by 32.81%, 27.08%, and 7.46% on the CHAIR metric. This improvement is achieved
solely through signals derived from the image itself, without the need for any
image-text pairs.
|
[
-0.4436374307,
-0.6204450727,
0.5147346258,
0.0072300914,
-0.4219157398,
-0.1558942497,
-0.3558335602,
-0.393964231,
0.6389972568,
1.1501226425,
-0.4667333663,
-0.643989563,
-0.3159514964,
0.1324462146,
-0.4761924148,
0.853640914,
0.2781517208,
-0.0068564094,
-0.4062870145,
-0.0285465419,
-0.3519590497,
-0.3936086297,
-0.3704100549,
-0.2131612748,
0.1089390367,
0.1216830686,
0.6053355932,
0.2830886841,
0.4740705788,
0.2833969891,
0.0945055857,
0.5083084106,
-0.4892922938,
0.0782440007,
-0.0523032956,
-0.0349400938,
-0.0541372374,
-0.5864323378,
0.4758062661,
0.7428036928,
-0.4395529032,
-0.1984229684,
-0.007213369,
0.8028709292,
-0.695078969,
0.2428141534,
-0.8256978989,
0.4031161368,
0.1615454108,
-0.5152401328,
-0.6765933037,
0.0320120789,
0.0195165612,
-0.7930496931,
0.3678118885,
0.2015087903,
0.9706414342,
0.6591680646,
-0.1098407805,
-0.142404452,
-0.5275993943,
0.7421396375,
-0.4605280459,
0.3217120469,
0.3580691516,
0.3543427289,
-0.5144594312,
-0.4782482088,
-0.4355250001,
-0.1376040429,
-0.2901004255,
0.1387782246,
-0.2900768816,
0.3104442656,
0.3133755624,
-0.0119191799,
-0.7066481709,
0.0504636131,
-0.7219640613,
-0.7928549647,
0.3154088855,
0.0321542025,
0.322329253,
-0.3075020909,
-0.6005221009,
-0.1465973854,
-0.6737093925,
-0.3492976427,
0.4113990366,
0.3572260439,
0.4644410014,
0.6197918057,
-0.3197516501,
0.740804255,
-0.2443081439,
-0.1923754811,
0.4128114283,
0.1016276032,
-0.1758708954,
0.2748132646,
0.2740364373,
0.7768655419,
0.3512642086,
-0.5703600645,
-0.3908308148,
0.6233943105,
0.6177619696,
-0.6514729261,
-0.3047935665,
0.1726551652,
-0.2931483388,
-0.4057328701,
0.1608720422,
-1.1498816013,
-0.7196434736,
-0.397796154,
0.6077651978,
-0.3261822462,
-0.2158134133,
0.6111643314,
-0.1517382711,
0.4879464209,
0.3276308179,
-0.7465883493,
0.5365506411,
0.4541426003,
0.689027071,
-0.5216830969,
-0.3744988143,
-0.7406842113,
0.1521224231,
-0.368452251,
0.9407115579,
-0.3356306255,
-0.1939649731,
0.1771199703,
0.120823279,
0.1280993372,
-0.7723084688,
0.1728470027,
-0.2255837917,
-0.0487186797,
-0.0625951365,
-0.4059970081,
-0.3630534708,
0.1932223141,
-0.7018021941,
0.7421876192,
-0.1204690263,
-0.6160328984,
0.3424657881,
-0.295161128,
-0.5316393375,
0.0049331877,
-0.4066826403,
-0.5187075138,
0.422457844,
0.5313907862,
0.3476767242,
0.0550754555,
0.2314189821,
0.1315223277,
-0.6432061195,
-0.1784194857,
-0.1934301555,
0.4706048965,
0.060282398,
-0.5881809592,
0.3507608771,
-1.0375567675,
-0.1758177429,
0.0885464922,
0.1624943316,
-0.3303820193,
0.0829656646,
0.1951621324,
-0.0495345965,
-0.2658466697,
-0.5531118512,
-0.1549224555,
-0.6864768267,
0.1157714427,
0.8221442699,
0.129815951,
0.4834069312,
-0.1994541585,
0.4446952641,
0.1638854444,
0.1884528697,
-0.0429261029,
-0.2699229419,
-0.944453299,
-0.402615279,
-0.4055272043,
0.2072699964,
-1.0375415087,
0.4225004613,
-0.1100979224,
-0.3282359242,
-0.2804709375,
-0.2506832182,
0.3682224154,
0.6026658416,
0.5768578053,
-0.3938786089,
-0.5301091671,
-1.0138453245,
-0.0321305133,
-0.0920693949,
0.004889966,
0.0908806324,
0.6100963354,
-0.2318474203,
0.7369506955,
-0.493479073,
-0.9264025688,
-0.1204871312,
-0.1005126908,
-0.248355329,
0.4402546883,
0.5908955336,
-0.8269954324,
-0.072134912,
-0.1178497523,
-0.7091221213,
-0.1984655559,
-0.5610977411,
-0.1001274958,
0.5997130871,
0.6145694256,
-0.5700085163,
0.8312673569,
0.4573579133,
-0.5302758217,
0.5351432562,
-0.2943513393,
0.0209858455,
-0.8318706751,
-0.1156401858,
-0.5369021893,
-0.1582817286,
-0.3792207837,
0.0600734241,
-0.2540898025,
-0.2408330888,
-0.449881196,
0.4191544354,
-0.527454555,
-0.4648613632,
-0.1800254583,
0.3961246014,
0.1062037423,
0.7380945086,
0.3797679543,
0.5245515108,
0.981564045,
-0.2833321691,
0.2720369995,
0.2418069988,
-0.6205877662,
0.4697251022,
-0.4476128817,
0.1284198463,
-0.500044167,
0.0423406884,
-0.9240501523,
-0.2456267923,
0.3369523883,
-0.3511635661,
0.1091945097,
0.2509313226,
-0.4229159355,
-0.0652672276,
-0.3431360424,
0.1124623492,
0.4173566401,
-0.7559279799,
1.1004173756,
0.3612541258,
0.3993570507,
-0.7260359526,
-0.6729249358,
0.0734287351,
-0.1872010827,
-0.1638159752,
0.470543772,
0.1074448973,
-0.1175885573,
0.2568286657,
-0.1886806637,
0.3549522161,
-0.0148562798,
0.4005768895,
0.2001571208,
0.1573496163,
0.1308309734,
0.0728719234,
-0.2919704318,
0.0111167002,
-0.3246850967,
0.7804144025,
-0.2061135322,
-0.5252844691,
-0.47135818,
0.3195757866,
0.66514045,
-0.3263523877,
0.7498393059,
0.525039196,
-0.7726416588,
-0.5257213712,
-0.5956499577,
-0.7236723304,
-0.4364931583,
0.7776176333,
-0.373236686,
-0.5661686659,
0.6339854002,
0.0489218421,
-0.2070812136,
0.1598397344,
0.4057770371,
0.2421488166,
0.8675174713,
0.4540944099,
0.2179037631,
0.2481443882,
-0.2472320944,
0.2612994015,
-0.6890420914,
-0.5409266353,
-0.149978891,
-0.0002781581,
-0.3970687687,
-0.3103170395,
0.2135030478,
-0.2965423167,
0.0770930871,
0.3230832517,
-0.698269248,
0.7927643657,
0.4112479389,
0.237216413,
0.0840530023,
0.4548608065,
-0.025966933,
-0.1804549843,
-0.4443439841,
-0.4052190185,
0.7666931152,
-0.0257105157,
0.6166629791,
-0.0398474224,
0.94481951,
0.3254409432,
-0.0518425032,
-0.8129004836,
0.7920533419,
0.0226209257,
-0.3005569279,
-0.3982097507,
-0.4112299979,
-0.7029196024,
0.5765112042,
-0.3504753709,
-1.0008138418,
0.1606921554,
-0.0465515852,
-0.3820877075,
0.5018051863,
-0.4688819647,
0.7146373391,
-0.0817355216,
-0.1723271161,
-0.3210647106,
-0.5540844798,
-0.0235751141,
-0.11621847,
0.1498976201,
-0.0534807742,
0.2199222296,
0.6653012037,
-0.2316585332,
1.0415416956,
-0.3079060912,
0.219453752,
0.300650537,
0.2592727542,
0.5313969851,
-0.1835462153,
0.4038833678,
0.0965253189,
0.0525207408,
-0.4273533225,
-0.7652899623,
0.580452919,
-0.6352270246,
-0.4938574731,
-0.463370949,
-0.4845653176,
-0.2004366666,
0.0749807209,
0.3323273957,
0.6116970181,
-0.0851418674,
0.1936520338,
0.531964004,
-0.6697188616,
0.1272329688,
0.2408015281,
-0.6379759908,
-0.4996467829,
0.9897202849,
0.0163228717,
0.1394767016,
0.1098114997,
0.055557657,
-0.1586628258,
-0.6079705358,
-0.1648759097,
0.3466815352,
-0.9953403473,
-0.4355069697,
-0.524915874,
-0.0602909401,
-0.3802452683,
-0.3357691467,
-0.6214658618,
-0.2957711518,
-0.2206305116,
-0.3798350394,
0.2092026174,
0.6115608811,
-0.1431408674,
0.019960383,
-0.1886839867,
0.3737075627,
0.0412210673,
0.1924303323,
0.0197042394,
-0.530494988,
0.0959453508,
-0.3656941354,
0.180945009,
-0.6724416018,
0.7204067707,
0.2231892049,
0.473127991,
0.5549186468,
0.4342010915,
0.7352956533,
-0.5260028839,
0.6966212988,
0.3728644252,
-0.8237114549,
0.6013818979,
0.3117149174,
-0.0095826993,
0.4466787577,
-0.1073816344,
-0.3577511311,
-0.6373615265,
-0.3617879748,
-1.0085632801,
0.4541995227,
0.2313363552,
0.3259298801,
-0.1143283471,
0.3691065609,
0.1338285506,
0.0710726008,
-0.6418192983,
0.0936957449,
-0.2161434591,
-0.1513220519,
0.2006241977,
-0.2584294975,
-0.221220091,
-0.2698602676,
0.6401109695,
-0.2448456734,
0.207260102,
0.2786920965,
-0.2675077915,
0.0116501674,
-0.2915523052,
0.7613002062,
0.4982881248,
-0.2470795512,
0.4372875094,
0.0237626527,
-0.4600811899,
-0.2688662112,
-0.1695048809,
-0.4647672474,
0.1260492206,
0.3830592334,
1.0091340542,
0.0931536555,
-1.0121842623,
0.6444295049,
-0.0196028464,
-0.1741230935,
-0.6258811355,
-0.0912741572,
-0.4141308367,
0.3597439826,
0.1781841516,
0.336404115,
0.2188277394,
-0.3294978738,
0.4590840936,
0.2261862457,
-0.5507652164,
-0.3276834786,
0.6512164474,
-0.1025752202,
-0.3038079143,
0.7428305149,
-0.1660393327,
-0.7044751048,
0.6662603021,
0.7944357991,
0.8578074574,
0.2161755413,
0.5230786204,
0.4561297596,
0.3404119909,
-0.143458575,
0.1879917234,
-0.1403909922,
-1.0311053991,
-0.1333248764,
-0.8547257185,
-0.0537885539,
-0.0553319119,
-0.8086731434,
0.1904646456,
-0.2077973038,
-0.0009475359,
-0.3037276268,
-0.3109026551,
-0.4610558152,
0.0356132425,
0.2223974913,
0.4129525125,
-0.9732518792,
0.6292119026,
0.3491700292,
-0.5805560946,
-0.4388647377,
0.0304390006,
-0.0584307909,
-0.6913102865,
0.2766849995,
0.535872221,
-0.5455058813,
0.0822538137,
-0.3482907116,
-0.5069163442,
0.8680335879,
0.4257915318,
-0.454662919,
0.072634846,
0.1200894266,
0.6510022283,
-0.3493170738,
-0.4661360085,
0.4590984881,
0.2755984366,
0.1657559872,
-0.4974625409,
0.1688452512,
0.054932747,
0.0705180913,
0.0882798731,
-0.2905986309,
0.0961397216,
-0.5624706745,
-0.3745649755,
0.1916687787,
0.5680033565,
0.1473488063,
0.1303745806,
0.6556588411,
0.5157218575,
0.7895545959,
-0.0774891302,
0.8622789383,
-0.183584094,
0.3293218613,
1.0488904715,
-0.3387056887,
0.7689560652,
1.225233674,
0.3092130721,
0.2326464653,
0.3263052404,
-0.204309538,
0.9604747891,
0.3442830443,
-0.0016871565,
-0.3436111212,
-0.3285292983,
-0.0302060116,
0.6718758941,
0.1809043139,
-0.1765867621,
-0.0652845949,
0.6073204279,
-0.1615016758,
0.4715564251,
-0.1151202694,
0.8248199224,
-0.148896426,
-0.5800521374,
0.4941654503,
-0.4153545499,
0.437496841,
-0.3184801042,
-0.2710748911,
-0.4058265686,
0.2057423145,
-0.1538562477,
-0.2709051371,
0.6947966218,
-0.2395343035,
0.2508170605,
0.0452472381,
0.66912359,
-0.4511185884,
-0.3989941478,
0.6919699907,
0.1509341449,
0.4900470674,
-0.182592988,
-0.2246147245,
0.2434635758,
0.0642248467,
-0.2698610723,
0.12622118,
0.3599717319,
0.0150552029,
0.4160732329,
0.4575358629,
0.4136221409,
-0.0805623382,
0.4713597894,
0.8772236705,
-0.4115206301,
-0.2918438613,
-0.6300799847,
0.4186849892,
-0.1813214272,
-0.1623549461,
0.3297767639,
0.5277562141,
1.1448465586,
-0.4447839856,
0.2423923165,
0.140370056,
0.0834766701,
-0.697470665,
0.928131938,
-0.8577168584,
0.3187821805,
-0.2047681659,
-1.0773861408,
-0.8997045755,
0.9605196118,
-0.0968803391,
-0.3998959363,
0.5859719515,
1.4744782448,
0.2064759731,
-0.5184909105,
0.817112267,
0.0503989272,
0.0945463479,
0.376419276,
0.8732606769,
-0.3948532939,
0.6618515849,
-0.3425847888,
-0.1275683343,
-0.1415433586,
-0.592289567,
-1.024333477,
-0.8466925025,
-0.3393909931,
-0.4092077613,
0.1561356336,
0.9296767712,
0.5253176689,
-1.0015944242,
0.1151693612,
-0.2123911977,
-0.0754533187,
-0.3227849305,
-0.2223666459,
0.7429469228,
-0.4655702114,
-0.5659479499,
0.1712781787,
0.6847394705,
0.0140731093,
-0.4766209126,
-0.2860822082,
0.3365722299,
0.2932068706,
0.6550635695,
-0.0610650815,
-1.0727726221,
-0.6755180955,
0.1012585089,
-0.0630100965,
0.065579094,
0.5681737065,
-0.8473010063,
0.8869986534,
0.1738272905,
0.6686100364,
0.4709690809,
-0.2500020564,
0.1938353181,
-0.5816147327,
0.655100286,
0.2808595002,
0.4449461699,
0.542822063,
-0.2891913056,
0.6465092897,
0.4037601352,
-0.1697837561,
-1.0850493908,
0.4301653504,
-0.9786618948,
-0.4513329566,
1.2015115023,
0.11148794,
-0.3947632909,
0.0763226151,
-0.5604423285,
0.1041011065,
0.0259862803,
1.3322272301,
0.4556224942,
0.0370912179,
-0.0858887732,
-0.3229418695,
0.6909048557,
0.4982994497,
-0.6748629808,
0.0689674467,
0.6939884424,
-0.1255623996,
0.2046640664,
0.3490547538,
-0.2998688519,
0.1866150498,
0.2237010002,
0.2598790824,
-0.1016026139,
-0.8821418881,
-0.2708057761,
0.1502306759,
-0.2422432154,
-0.3454464674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16158v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16158v1
|
Korean Bio-Medical Corpus (KBMC) for Medical Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-03-24T13:51:05 | 2024-03-24T13:51:05 |
Sungjoo Byun, Jiseung Hong, Sumin Park, Dongjun Jang, Jean Seo, Minseok Kim, Chaeyoung Oh, Hyopil Shin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Named Entity Recognition (NER) plays a pivotal role in medical Natural
Language Processing (NLP). Yet, there has not been an open-source medical NER
dataset specifically for the Korean language. To address this, we utilized
ChatGPT to assist in constructing the KBMC (Korean Bio-Medical Corpus), which
we are now presenting to the public. With the KBMC dataset, we noticed an
impressive 20% increase in medical NER performance compared to models trained
on general Korean NER datasets. This research underscores the significant
benefits and importance of using specialized tools and datasets, like ChatGPT,
to enhance language processing in specialized fields such as healthcare.
|
[
-0.258672595,
-0.3514977098,
0.6915234923,
0.0815465525,
-0.2431580126,
0.3658485115,
-0.1818356514,
-0.5183452964,
0.4503129721,
0.6358990669,
-0.0431818143,
-0.7723714709,
-0.6250029802,
0.2606244087,
0.0644716248,
1.0489248037,
0.1640891284,
0.6098621488,
-0.0124486815,
-0.2293314487,
-0.3503885865,
-0.6770090461,
-1.1126133204,
-0.2930187583,
0.6702262163,
0.3634232283,
0.7304700613,
0.5682074428,
0.9230675101,
0.2082269341,
-0.0318106152,
-0.0211428273,
-0.1810303181,
0.2398297787,
-0.0768221989,
-0.2451752275,
-0.5649502277,
-0.323566854,
0.7254602909,
0.8720679283,
-0.0016362581,
-0.0581017397,
-0.2189725935,
0.958448112,
-0.3082291782,
0.5102304816,
-0.3971990049,
0.2457670271,
-0.1577231735,
-0.1724013984,
-0.2678777277,
-0.4915320575,
0.3762618601,
-0.5018442273,
0.2356737256,
-0.2488599569,
0.7995373011,
0.145710066,
-0.6294077039,
-0.4935209751,
-0.5806747079,
0.2106505781,
-0.4495703876,
0.7644974589,
0.4498125017,
0.5691306591,
-0.3577615917,
-1.0234810114,
-0.2359160632,
-0.4050053656,
-0.1819344312,
0.3185557723,
-0.1833203286,
0.3368589878,
0.1892039478,
0.1695547998,
-0.5374169946,
0.0046222932,
-0.7974689603,
-0.3762553036,
0.4123781919,
0.2530041635,
0.702265799,
-0.5192776322,
-0.1157642975,
0.1288990527,
-0.7081024051,
-0.128635928,
0.0225762893,
0.3440615535,
0.0927550569,
0.6756804585,
-0.2862292826,
0.5289561749,
-0.048249457,
-0.266100049,
0.4849569499,
-0.0762336403,
-0.3240219951,
0.6686747074,
0.8081230521,
0.3851385415,
0.2070556283,
-0.400963217,
0.1036462635,
0.0722261071,
0.3952359259,
-1.0315438509,
-0.7830743194,
0.1533684433,
-0.7379544973,
-0.3656382859,
-0.0678502917,
-0.8644793034,
-0.5449675918,
-0.375623107,
0.1786707342,
-0.4692805111,
-0.2653351128,
-0.1138156652,
-0.0665455461,
0.0902632549,
0.0526773334,
-0.5402417779,
0.440710634,
0.4690631032,
0.8809031248,
-0.1979475617,
0.2663461864,
-0.2757168114,
0.0447789207,
-0.4940124154,
0.9035913348,
-0.5443657637,
-0.4558516145,
-0.3367427588,
0.3370829523,
-0.2327839285,
-0.8675870895,
0.4661146998,
-0.5134176612,
-0.1639635116,
-0.2493730038,
-0.5924021602,
-0.2021970004,
0.1008865535,
-0.7993724942,
0.6689130664,
0.2095814347,
-0.7398751378,
0.46107921,
-0.8218401074,
-0.4283685684,
0.5657224059,
-0.5381405354,
-0.4408971369,
-0.0583247729,
0.2198400199,
0.5794750452,
-0.0457905829,
0.4408310652,
-0.1343412995,
-0.010376621,
0.4107634425,
-0.1618506014,
0.5749597549,
0.2768661082,
0.0425001904,
-0.1480580121,
-1.0257030725,
0.2822567523,
-0.0980633944,
-0.5719519854,
-0.4390722215,
0.0257525779,
0.0915313363,
0.3044579923,
-0.0885564536,
-0.6748552918,
0.0376991965,
-0.5411772132,
0.4821105599,
0.1405728161,
0.2657667398,
0.3898630142,
-0.0559812449,
0.7501297593,
0.0605167039,
-0.2994615138,
-0.0504222363,
-0.7330169678,
-0.4161840975,
-0.5781843066,
0.63014853,
0.7326549888,
-0.7080575228,
0.0141218379,
-0.2517233789,
-0.7867562175,
-0.9578461051,
-0.4594484866,
0.3750841916,
0.9676527381,
0.4214899242,
0.0335754417,
-0.9192750454,
-1.128570199,
-0.1696248353,
-0.0451450832,
-0.2729285955,
0.7118119597,
0.2862966955,
-0.4530914128,
0.9275609851,
-0.5536207557,
-0.0617115349,
-0.2284105718,
-0.0731222555,
0.4264421761,
0.380541712,
0.2778016329,
-0.9033982158,
-0.8904217482,
0.3507639468,
-0.633215785,
-0.4022007883,
0.1699296683,
-0.1480991095,
0.1392335147,
0.6829285622,
-0.530174315,
0.5119922161,
0.4714407325,
-0.4284530878,
0.6091804504,
-0.1522030085,
0.4361428916,
-1.4649223089,
0.3082502782,
-0.478575021,
-0.4579094052,
-0.7996576428,
-0.175610885,
0.3156863749,
-0.3565558195,
-0.3729476333,
0.5444014668,
-0.5643240809,
0.0320197903,
-0.4222538173,
-0.0909337252,
-0.3632684052,
0.0788684338,
0.3039508462,
0.6785769463,
0.5313096046,
-0.8290480375,
0.193682164,
0.3598050773,
-0.3262840211,
0.7213753462,
-0.8262205124,
0.0221596137,
-0.2367919087,
0.0687578022,
-0.7226173878,
-0.6023872495,
0.4619948268,
-0.6589388251,
0.4304984808,
-0.4981509447,
-0.3484093249,
-0.237651512,
0.2114532292,
0.196379438,
0.555742085,
-0.4534732699,
0.3091637492,
0.8029001951,
-0.3278616965,
-0.3074336648,
-0.7599482536,
0.0816789642,
0.0146774333,
-0.3340002,
0.636773169,
0.2567030787,
0.0762116313,
0.2141849399,
-0.3076975644,
-0.4327715933,
-0.2262013257,
0.5079831481,
0.4664587677,
-0.5565140247,
0.4712477326,
0.0014163008,
-0.387129724,
-0.0141153242,
-0.0503776707,
0.6091060638,
-0.0276591051,
-0.2100965381,
-0.0139171956,
0.1858555973,
0.3489435911,
0.0943729207,
0.8813462257,
0.5650436282,
-0.6842911243,
0.4715352952,
-0.4375241697,
0.1280823499,
-0.4389325976,
0.6831274629,
-0.1571589708,
-1.137614727,
0.4686053693,
-0.1198464856,
-0.4260235727,
0.5079098344,
0.6847102046,
0.009799188,
0.9825729132,
0.2869156897,
-0.0347922333,
0.0210705549,
0.3629343808,
0.4270220101,
-0.9829557538,
-0.4100705087,
-0.4044790268,
-0.3401861489,
-1.1076389551,
-0.4273569286,
0.4393561482,
0.0144172115,
-0.1509523988,
0.5324634314,
-0.6831821203,
0.5389180779,
0.3102857471,
0.286949724,
0.2585861981,
-0.0987504423,
-0.3964954019,
-0.2366666943,
-0.5795264244,
-0.5995051861,
1.0278425217,
0.1111260429,
0.4550494254,
-0.1592541635,
0.6525031328,
-0.1606622189,
0.3111048341,
-0.7029228806,
0.5541528463,
-0.2992468476,
-0.5447182059,
0.0724088103,
-0.5856034756,
-1.4217280149,
-0.0165801924,
-0.0922321081,
-0.6953082085,
0.1531267911,
0.0379975773,
-0.3758758903,
0.2173233926,
-0.6702749133,
0.7546503544,
0.1607465148,
0.5138936043,
0.1270148754,
-0.7505367994,
0.1992315054,
-0.2066472322,
-0.1570291519,
-0.1893009245,
-0.2058529854,
0.7505845428,
-0.4206326902,
0.4223689437,
-0.1507145315,
0.5766564012,
0.1421036571,
-0.1253142953,
0.1473535001,
0.4759891033,
0.2351485491,
0.3495477736,
0.0916858986,
-0.1270545423,
-0.2494318038,
0.6554710269,
-0.4296293557,
-0.0550039522,
-0.5029305816,
-0.420173645,
-0.3396035731,
0.4434846938,
0.396121949,
0.1678888053,
-0.3402139544,
0.4046088159,
0.6224466562,
-0.6857281327,
0.0436404385,
0.6959406734,
-0.4532088637,
-0.9014255404,
0.788048327,
0.2971614599,
0.2299906611,
0.5184024572,
0.0236575007,
-0.002926816,
-0.3153496981,
-0.2788397074,
0.1643756479,
-0.5655964017,
-0.4199874103,
-1.3142422438,
-0.8682206869,
-0.5229690075,
-0.088509649,
-0.2938408554,
-0.4967628717,
-0.0593103357,
-0.1276136339,
0.6647028327,
0.5320264697,
0.0831124634,
0.4699471891,
-1.0272529125,
0.5060908794,
-0.0833360255,
0.5762776136,
-0.3609540164,
-0.0227695592,
-0.072640352,
-0.0847953856,
-0.0228952914,
-1.1387492418,
0.6478101611,
0.0654521883,
0.6316439509,
0.2131869048,
-0.3812434971,
0.6980585456,
-0.8733317256,
0.5364198685,
0.0348174423,
-0.2736434042,
0.4884214997,
-0.2109120041,
0.5701801777,
0.6370552778,
0.7071451545,
-1.1840624809,
-0.1346746236,
-0.6997544765,
-0.9051375389,
0.5959043503,
0.233644262,
-0.1824481487,
-0.4075061977,
0.2843881845,
0.0647254363,
0.3020015359,
-0.2908488214,
-0.2709145844,
0.2095014155,
-0.3666250706,
0.1512252092,
-0.2618669569,
0.4777161181,
-0.1976549327,
0.6791630387,
0.0376435481,
0.703709662,
0.543312192,
-0.0987002701,
0.2860724926,
0.2685461938,
0.3224362433,
0.1736446321,
-0.018136777,
-0.0007035376,
0.150815323,
-1.1414433718,
-0.0975832492,
0.2961434722,
-0.161985904,
0.4296897054,
0.07158494,
0.7089352608,
0.4253939688,
-0.7760041356,
0.0603625588,
-0.0442320742,
-0.1662739515,
-0.1429133564,
-0.0758436993,
0.5101275444,
0.1712644398,
-0.0468779989,
0.1336944699,
0.3443189263,
-0.0909647346,
0.3554979265,
0.2130136788,
-0.6035984159,
-0.1348115504,
0.4970910549,
-0.3577946723,
-0.2734304368,
1.0664799213,
-0.1569590867,
-0.6265005469,
0.8271534443,
0.6712966561,
0.7804812789,
-0.402151525,
0.3700477481,
0.695748508,
0.1337484866,
0.0242414773,
0.494002521,
0.1837431043,
-0.5888238549,
-0.3613094091,
-0.6833034754,
-0.3421828151,
0.2526730299,
-0.555352211,
0.5583723783,
-0.3617121875,
-0.3463028371,
0.359916687,
-0.223513484,
-0.6852477193,
0.2424839884,
0.0428942665,
0.6934416294,
-0.2173344344,
0.6963906884,
0.9210974574,
-0.3375308216,
-0.847330749,
-0.3300813735,
-0.0940457433,
-0.8712562919,
0.7293201089,
0.2537023127,
0.5186198354,
-0.0415261574,
-0.1986914873,
-1.070818305,
1.0219128132,
0.2068241239,
-0.6981047392,
0.0358427651,
0.4105962217,
0.7454041839,
-0.3380078673,
0.0563658103,
0.4443962872,
0.3866836131,
-0.1607473195,
-1.0056775808,
-0.0294420365,
-0.3042933047,
-0.0849833935,
0.7669919729,
-0.2185612619,
0.4957900047,
-0.137529552,
-0.2119997144,
-0.1583391279,
0.2937693596,
0.4577465057,
0.6105563045,
0.2192422599,
0.4532452822,
0.988822341,
0.0116893258,
0.8343883753,
-0.2733259499,
0.0844383985,
1.1615138054,
-0.1727451533,
0.6346997023,
0.2273112833,
-0.3335904181,
0.2006551325,
0.5821686983,
-0.1689912379,
0.561419487,
0.201113984,
-0.4055643082,
0.0881601572,
-0.0601313189,
-0.5022318363,
0.3598996997,
0.4419597983,
-0.8234093785,
-0.1569832563,
0.2512363791,
0.3418501318,
-0.3409535587,
-0.5482535958,
0.8859465718,
0.3419561386,
-0.4213871062,
-0.0152886705,
-0.2273840308,
0.3981662989,
-0.5931453109,
-0.1173507199,
0.2135143578,
0.0989962369,
-0.303271234,
-0.7261731625,
0.6159234643,
-0.0283054411,
-0.2967166603,
0.2107715458,
1.4271075726,
-0.619004488,
-0.6832911372,
0.0801727846,
0.44873631,
0.6507540345,
-0.1335329711,
-0.4236663282,
-0.5010002851,
-0.1874152422,
0.0025075353,
0.5132312775,
0.4516662359,
-0.0429954603,
0.4886170328,
0.7961451411,
0.3965601921,
0.0796380788,
0.043788597,
0.6388496161,
-0.8015358448,
-0.4299714267,
-0.9500162601,
0.0755515844,
-0.2177396566,
-0.2417331934,
0.4685863853,
0.8275854588,
0.6903012991,
-0.413857609,
0.7445783019,
-0.2598729134,
0.850595355,
-0.308601141,
1.3258342743,
-0.0729278028,
-0.258346796,
-0.4025616944,
-0.5455210209,
-0.5309069753,
0.565833509,
-0.0727613568,
0.0023661454,
0.7586031556,
0.8162553906,
-0.0108186537,
0.1040967554,
0.4955991805,
0.2223835588,
0.1014197469,
0.5051445961,
0.4094622135,
-0.3646522462,
0.4257710874,
-0.3914929926,
0.0699363649,
-0.0259390604,
-0.9390524626,
-0.8556672931,
-0.4129188061,
-0.4145367146,
-0.4448861182,
0.2105282247,
1.1899248362,
0.5973294973,
-1.0338151455,
0.326744765,
-0.1844193339,
-0.2962577641,
-0.1285751909,
-0.2779251635,
0.5792186856,
-0.3474703729,
-0.3879291415,
0.4980387688,
0.4825187922,
-0.0376678891,
0.3084244728,
-0.0967520997,
-0.0316623114,
-0.1788244247,
0.5415002108,
0.3155713379,
-0.2567765713,
0.0820866078,
0.2994746864,
-0.4173733592,
0.3514573276,
0.8723915219,
-0.9805977345,
0.4464258254,
0.5004015565,
1.0256261826,
0.1903409362,
-0.384786725,
0.5550240874,
-0.3657161891,
-0.3320837021,
0.467502147,
0.281044066,
0.2934462726,
-0.5955321193,
0.828696847,
0.2892456949,
-0.9248156548,
-0.7278918624,
-0.0965551436,
-1.1447834969,
0.0567954816,
0.9188516736,
0.0170078538,
-0.1427961886,
-0.4550933838,
-0.6463620663,
0.5076890588,
-0.4651397169,
0.5467166305,
0.7925415039,
-0.3101737499,
0.038235914,
-1.2023049593,
0.5677267313,
0.0283153486,
-0.9806872606,
-0.3347629905,
0.1824107468,
0.5352915525,
-0.0587505139,
1.034463644,
-0.5729900002,
0.4474828541,
-0.0623855591,
0.0834500566,
0.1737159044,
-0.1311451346,
-0.1369353831,
0.0474056862,
-0.3093504012,
-0.2733941674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16142v1
|
What Happens to a Dataset Transformed by a Projection-based Concept Removal Method?
| 2024-03-24T13:28:27 | 2024-03-24T13:28:27 |
Richard Johansson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We investigate the behavior of methods that use linear projections to remove
information about a concept from a language representation, and we consider the
question of what happens to a dataset transformed by such a method. A
theoretical analysis and experiments on real-world and synthetic data show that
these methods inject strong statistical dependencies into the transformed
datasets. After applying such a method, the representation space is highly
structured: in the transformed space, an instance tends to be located near
instances of the opposite label. As a consequence, the original labeling can in
some cases be reconstructed by applying an anti-clustering method.
|
[
-0.4668328464,
-0.9871568084,
0.3607901931,
-0.2317638695,
-0.36893031,
0.1623512059,
-0.0861575603,
-0.6403418779,
0.6750509143,
0.5892169476,
-0.1738665104,
-0.2245820463,
-0.503988564,
-0.4474945068,
-1.0164241791,
1.0940499306,
-0.1482461989,
-0.0639659464,
-0.3094345033,
0.0731681362,
-0.3951224089,
-0.7381788492,
0.0572408251,
-0.3601100147,
0.252597034,
0.3788164854,
0.8046374917,
1.1595740318,
0.7688137889,
0.2830806673,
-0.2234068662,
-0.1894784719,
-0.9026564956,
0.017347537,
-0.2046914101,
-0.7223168015,
-0.022531718,
0.455630064,
0.8032130599,
1.3060762882,
-0.1905813962,
-0.0223383345,
0.1365622729,
0.4045984745,
-0.5934537649,
0.1933624595,
-0.7708278298,
0.2341665328,
-0.2365034372,
-0.3329111338,
-0.3314730525,
-0.3982205987,
0.2036831081,
-0.5759750605,
0.6909217834,
-0.0298395436,
0.8613619208,
0.0075592995,
-0.4310568273,
-0.388442874,
-1.4245471954,
0.8333297968,
-0.0870443359,
0.107974492,
0.2410049736,
0.2408234477,
-0.3470388055,
-0.5637094378,
-0.6229330897,
0.2803159654,
-0.2508603036,
0.053693261,
0.0837540254,
-0.0551845618,
0.6001855135,
0.4196814895,
-0.4471473098,
-0.1791985631,
-0.8916063309,
-0.1154437885,
0.5202679038,
-0.1411179155,
0.2044150531,
-0.4056913257,
-0.3981764913,
-0.2140395194,
-1.0546633005,
-0.5763075948,
0.0985341296,
0.4436271787,
0.4234263301,
0.7520914078,
0.1366683096,
0.6173587441,
-0.0628007725,
-0.0523342155,
0.4877367318,
-0.0031060432,
-0.3011888862,
0.280465126,
0.2827020288,
0.2902183831,
0.2556789815,
-0.1947207153,
-0.240316093,
0.5628668666,
0.2995737791,
-0.3852317333,
-0.2392042726,
-0.0253653023,
-0.4991276264,
-0.2293109298,
0.1353830546,
-0.5319875479,
-0.4503997862,
-0.4910094738,
0.509332478,
-0.479842484,
-0.3190355301,
-0.1451787949,
-0.1167691201,
0.1969468743,
0.2925778329,
-0.5886335969,
0.3407661915,
0.5812146068,
0.5183565021,
-0.2491447479,
0.3696924448,
-0.287524581,
0.2400755733,
-0.7858971953,
0.6705523133,
-0.6981928349,
-0.6088894606,
-0.0294015743,
-0.0056434255,
-0.0566920526,
-1.0227538347,
0.233603999,
-0.3786222339,
0.2351361364,
-0.3994974792,
-0.9576824903,
-0.1892017871,
0.0235286094,
-0.6141012907,
0.679243803,
-0.0864167884,
-0.4933951199,
0.4464135766,
-0.3666796982,
-0.4056454301,
-0.0074809296,
-0.218354553,
-0.1405834705,
0.3817936182,
-0.2489910126,
0.332388252,
0.0184553452,
0.1153258085,
-0.1219817698,
-0.4352540672,
0.1484055668,
-0.1641026139,
0.4666255414,
0.4234646857,
-0.0180120748,
-0.1089701876,
-1.2422577143,
-0.0548150688,
0.2958184183,
0.0915788859,
-0.9959828258,
0.4731026888,
-0.0169493388,
0.3419596553,
-0.0999118686,
-0.9601765275,
0.3081203401,
-0.614751339,
0.3031715751,
0.5548595786,
0.3845356107,
0.6776883602,
0.0238680523,
0.3232759237,
0.3973091543,
-0.0723023713,
0.022925213,
-0.4895241857,
-0.8270128369,
-0.0837686956,
0.1177255511,
0.505689919,
-1.1071895361,
0.18302463,
-0.2394437045,
-0.4040733278,
-0.1910791099,
-0.1504302323,
0.30120942,
0.5809239149,
0.3592776358,
-0.2473099232,
-0.7960662842,
-1.038454771,
-0.0988662317,
-0.2782722414,
-0.0587789826,
-0.2798584402,
0.6260909438,
-0.0530943274,
1.105253458,
-0.9150835276,
-0.2887514532,
-0.0712425336,
0.1093757823,
0.265068084,
0.7802985311,
0.6102322936,
-1.0253161192,
-0.2756051123,
-0.4029209912,
-0.8378572464,
0.1755468398,
-0.2681312859,
0.1248733774,
-0.0212840289,
0.6830519438,
-0.3753962517,
0.9119200706,
0.3048371077,
-0.0175366551,
0.5536610484,
-0.0863972381,
-0.0664839894,
-1.0707532167,
-0.0472440459,
0.2331432402,
-0.0586305223,
-0.9817997813,
0.0811668038,
-0.1761244237,
-0.1118990332,
-0.3869876266,
0.2160688341,
-0.1813309789,
-0.3362215459,
-0.2253573835,
0.1601585001,
-0.0634959191,
0.2002779841,
0.2376924306,
0.5682485104,
0.223487094,
-0.5399138331,
0.2026156038,
0.3911924958,
-0.4105960429,
0.4977791905,
-0.4642438591,
0.2719120979,
-0.5657248497,
0.0681400597,
-1.2695343494,
0.1388559639,
0.4173697829,
-0.148834005,
0.1928529441,
-0.0655393973,
-0.6306515336,
-0.2210473269,
-0.0287461281,
0.2457017601,
0.4185573459,
-0.4866501987,
0.0955254436,
0.5152227283,
0.0590657219,
-0.2755538821,
-0.8995549083,
0.1070418283,
-0.4637953639,
-0.1864993125,
0.5993083119,
0.0653354377,
-0.6662722826,
0.3189772964,
-0.0346733183,
-0.1882675737,
-0.1644731462,
0.2620782554,
0.2468984276,
0.0633326694,
0.3666346073,
0.0941449329,
-0.1096379682,
0.1318109185,
0.059254121,
0.4619490504,
0.3199740946,
-0.2895162702,
-0.1793171465,
0.6021209955,
0.2736802101,
-0.0490435921,
1.0393863916,
0.3081178069,
-0.6052262187,
-0.079521209,
-0.1705671251,
-0.1074705422,
-0.4401209056,
0.6188406944,
-0.57044065,
-0.2528449893,
0.6226859093,
0.0647071302,
0.0938809291,
0.4983550906,
0.4594622552,
-0.5383144617,
1.0328327417,
0.5345824957,
0.137506023,
0.6783373356,
-0.6247252226,
0.4545424581,
-0.6742098927,
-0.3215175569,
-0.6088386774,
-0.268081516,
-0.5353963971,
-0.4919301271,
0.3781041801,
0.1649490297,
0.3460109234,
0.5181159973,
-0.4985529184,
0.3536594808,
0.3642359674,
0.1332592666,
0.1880254745,
0.2418221384,
0.1510206759,
-0.3712738454,
-0.4768370986,
-0.3733425736,
0.9956135154,
0.1415692419,
0.6096025705,
-0.1090014204,
0.9007480145,
0.3269404769,
0.4420852065,
-0.929222405,
0.7288486958,
-0.2137676328,
-0.5101011992,
-0.2621118426,
-0.5210639834,
-0.9748239517,
0.4454425871,
-0.3156213462,
-0.7044388652,
0.5905294418,
0.2154727876,
0.3142616153,
0.4990246296,
-0.9231619835,
0.0309676956,
0.2576991022,
-0.1880973577,
-0.6830138564,
-0.2932064533,
0.0205370467,
-0.2411087602,
0.3836960793,
0.2062816769,
0.61263448,
1.1519204378,
-0.5334358215,
0.7612607479,
-0.6564417481,
-0.4347200096,
0.3870749772,
0.3160126209,
0.3477353752,
-0.4661832452,
-0.1035344675,
0.1222950369,
0.1673965752,
-0.4057456553,
-0.8052822948,
0.3253895342,
-0.6031973958,
-0.6647549272,
-0.3801678121,
-0.6552301049,
-0.3731611073,
-0.0746611878,
0.1341079026,
0.6184734702,
-0.4653885961,
0.0926992968,
0.3960501552,
-0.5037530065,
0.0350143164,
0.1728060246,
-0.3889164329,
0.172346741,
1.0349966288,
0.7017834187,
0.4535169303,
0.2992762327,
-0.1707376987,
-0.0853009894,
-0.4667180777,
0.1111333817,
0.2382407635,
-0.8876948357,
0.1565472931,
-0.0727706403,
-0.3538424671,
-0.3403418958,
-0.0675085858,
-0.4715736508,
-0.9354492426,
-0.1311840117,
-0.3112341762,
-0.1558504105,
0.7933211923,
-0.2279423028,
0.2732587457,
-0.4914043844,
0.4095682204,
0.0853997618,
0.0454420634,
-0.1552173197,
-0.4080741107,
-0.5147988796,
0.3336497247,
0.0154618062,
-0.6248025894,
0.5854262114,
0.2237805128,
0.5260118842,
0.4799212813,
-0.1430829465,
0.8046659827,
-0.5361935496,
0.5164654255,
0.1477955729,
-0.8073529005,
0.5162526965,
-0.3119655252,
0.0677686706,
-0.1011040285,
0.2678803205,
-0.7428079247,
-0.3552795947,
-0.4735641479,
-0.6000077128,
0.4289169312,
0.2386879027,
0.0533555336,
-0.170302555,
0.875646174,
0.0698286295,
0.1469219476,
-0.1565369815,
-0.552460134,
-0.2864789963,
-0.0333917215,
-0.4284490347,
-0.5148340464,
-0.0620633736,
-0.2545517981,
0.3791481555,
0.1549293846,
0.7878924608,
0.0328437835,
-0.3345140219,
-0.1448926628,
0.1226061657,
0.285017997,
0.7710028887,
-0.2726840973,
0.1815993488,
-0.3146579564,
-0.3309312463,
0.1831620038,
-0.1579480469,
-0.3750870526,
-0.0464796834,
0.4117836654,
0.5753180385,
-0.1641455442,
-0.2229023576,
0.0403697863,
0.2233299315,
-0.1914999485,
-0.2522664666,
0.0731052086,
-0.2754184604,
-0.2487571239,
0.6812942028,
0.3228024542,
0.3397176862,
-0.9736358523,
0.4449855387,
0.213473171,
-0.4710920751,
-0.6291645765,
0.327465713,
-0.2262062877,
-0.1133268625,
0.4692696631,
0.0873320252,
-0.5034490824,
0.6510435939,
0.8256441355,
0.4430257976,
-0.5115435719,
0.63034302,
0.2111794651,
0.1307241917,
0.0947396532,
0.1554925889,
0.3177737594,
-1.2420078516,
-0.5595552325,
-0.2229124904,
-0.2620208263,
0.0076904227,
-0.9453689456,
-0.123635456,
-0.3576307297,
-0.0453705378,
0.3724730015,
-0.1800611019,
-0.3814831376,
0.4654495716,
0.3139107227,
0.4788334966,
-1.2301990986,
1.0904048681,
0.7860053182,
-0.2326751649,
-0.5537137985,
0.047248356,
0.2665966451,
-0.7507012486,
0.769266665,
-0.2640440762,
-0.1463931501,
-0.1929639578,
-0.7825054526,
-1.1224606037,
0.2223555148,
0.4697276056,
-0.4563032091,
-0.0303970035,
0.4867983162,
0.9249625206,
-0.1417895257,
-0.2907345295,
0.3607316017,
0.2138943076,
0.2118130475,
-0.8649021387,
-0.0802724436,
-0.2040807158,
0.0903431401,
0.2767325044,
-0.2967168391,
0.9015026689,
0.1249882281,
-0.414444834,
-0.1132659093,
0.6058272123,
-0.0559898093,
-0.1408235878,
0.8586031199,
0.2590690553,
0.7176386118,
-0.1798253804,
0.7703974843,
-0.0643524155,
0.6618698239,
0.7640320659,
-0.4748996198,
0.7374674678,
0.8809165955,
-0.0785262957,
0.7740458846,
0.2633589804,
0.0562795065,
0.6624270082,
0.2876019478,
0.1953028589,
0.0859738365,
-0.2747130692,
-0.3184373379,
0.8377204537,
0.9774363637,
-0.2471930683,
-0.1014158502,
0.372967869,
-0.1039125994,
0.2628405094,
-0.1992699802,
0.5863204002,
0.1473275423,
-0.3551560044,
0.7302858233,
-0.1200568303,
0.1157578081,
-0.3914201558,
-0.2992475331,
-0.0455035158,
0.5659861565,
-0.34933424,
-0.6672198772,
0.8365566134,
-0.5216977,
-0.257086277,
-0.4288938344,
0.697809279,
-0.5069656968,
-0.444822669,
0.371621877,
0.5445120931,
0.1963834763,
0.2494197637,
-0.4353989065,
-0.0185300279,
0.2269139439,
-0.325275749,
0.4024055302,
0.0594258867,
-0.3603894711,
0.5788641572,
0.455075115,
0.4842883646,
-0.1764201373,
-0.0010308181,
0.8721423149,
-0.5585122705,
-0.5878737569,
-0.3174034953,
0.0201117825,
-0.2364588082,
0.2562378347,
0.7911971211,
0.6709293127,
0.8112319708,
-0.0173350163,
0.8012769222,
-0.2992261946,
0.9173822403,
-0.4117940366,
0.486705333,
-0.4381579161,
0.4203233421,
-0.8334898949,
-1.2387317419,
-0.5081803203,
0.7881764174,
-0.665230453,
-0.2509255111,
0.7168767452,
0.7073424459,
-0.0368500911,
-0.0623229556,
0.3414083123,
0.5642936826,
0.5365032554,
0.1082175821,
0.6982854605,
-0.3632588983,
0.3903183937,
-0.3937125504,
-0.300583154,
0.1744345874,
-0.2436923981,
-0.4375244081,
-1.0295906067,
-0.6135056615,
-0.4045990407,
0.1691459268,
0.7908584476,
0.742477119,
-1.1173182726,
-0.2255529165,
0.2264581174,
-0.106431596,
-0.2632241845,
-0.2951390147,
0.8061648607,
0.0184810925,
-0.7830239534,
0.4691143036,
0.1648620814,
-0.1186668426,
-0.3418733478,
0.4448431432,
-0.1493600309,
-0.0384411924,
0.6594496369,
0.2183668762,
-0.2615532279,
-0.8184717894,
-0.2776649892,
0.0862058774,
0.3845240772,
0.9102563858,
-1.1442284584,
0.6009088159,
0.6293910146,
0.0511529967,
0.7626244426,
0.1972232014,
0.7741350532,
-0.9940099716,
0.7402861118,
-0.0251831599,
0.2992812097,
0.0147235906,
-0.2313785553,
0.5106735229,
0.5753965378,
-0.0002636109,
-0.9507200122,
0.3472364545,
-0.5633353591,
-0.4710885286,
1.0388559103,
-0.0026891965,
-0.2084547281,
-0.3080474734,
-0.1234036162,
0.2667029202,
-0.1222672611,
0.9520184994,
0.4584599137,
-0.1017936841,
-0.0304420739,
-0.1248202994,
0.2125218362,
0.2259584963,
-0.5033360124,
-0.1587178111,
0.6148169637,
0.2138509005,
0.561368525,
0.366635859,
-0.2840424776,
-0.3554641306,
-0.0691280589,
0.2558129132,
0.3118386269,
-0.3221879005,
-0.1476154923,
0.4641665816,
-0.3669923544,
-0.3047300577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16139v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16139v1
|
A Little Leak Will Sink a Great Ship: Survey of Transparency for Large Language Models from Start to Finish
| 2024-03-24T13:21:58 | 2024-03-24T13:21:58 |
Masahiro Kaneko, Timothy Baldwin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on massive web-crawled corpora. This
poses risks of leakage, including personal information, copyrighted texts, and
benchmark datasets. Such leakage leads to undermining human trust in AI due to
potential unauthorized generation of content or overestimation of performance.
We establish the following three criteria concerning the leakage issues: (1)
leakage rate: the proportion of leaked data in training data, (2) output rate:
the ease of generating leaked data, and (3) detection rate: the detection
performance of leaked versus non-leaked data. Despite the leakage rate being
the origin of data leakage issues, it is not understood how it affects the
output rate and detection rate. In this paper, we conduct an experimental
survey to elucidate the relationship between the leakage rate and both the
output rate and detection rate for personal information, copyrighted texts, and
benchmark data. Additionally, we propose a self-detection approach that uses
few-shot learning in which LLMs detect whether instances are present or absent
in their training data, in contrast to previous methods that do not employ
explicit learning. To explore the ease of generating leaked information, we
create a dataset of prompts designed to elicit personal information,
copyrighted text, and benchmarks from LLMs. Our experiments reveal that LLMs
produce leaked information in most cases despite less such data in their
training set. This indicates even small amounts of leaked data can greatly
affect outputs. Our self-detection method showed superior performance compared
to existing detection methods.
|
[
-0.5258924365,
-0.5432056785,
0.8206689358,
0.0009052019,
-0.2878259122,
-0.0638662353,
-0.1271240711,
-0.7512992024,
-0.0995895565,
0.5673283339,
-0.4662667215,
-0.3780991435,
-0.9626839161,
-0.1858896613,
-0.6675041318,
1.0126255751,
0.2130521089,
-0.0548781455,
-0.0895776525,
0.099612467,
-0.3691757619,
-0.5174002051,
-0.7548587918,
-0.2844534516,
0.3172950745,
0.5273355246,
0.3548477292,
0.7852216959,
0.24444139,
0.2501543164,
-0.1763227582,
-0.1561625451,
-0.8013261557,
0.2148308456,
-0.3712665141,
-0.7201842666,
-0.0667028427,
-0.0329066813,
0.439506799,
0.2520970106,
-0.0988706127,
0.4557228982,
0.3370507658,
0.9223389626,
-0.7817860842,
0.3630297184,
-0.7766294479,
-0.0197504815,
-0.6082984805,
-0.1634903103,
-0.5179398656,
-0.085614562,
-0.0500360094,
-0.3389877677,
0.2553386688,
0.0832228363,
0.6649748683,
0.4060365558,
-0.1520831734,
-0.6076116562,
-0.6567768455,
0.8300610185,
-0.6488742232,
0.2452000529,
0.3665049076,
0.332773596,
-0.0308513697,
-0.493004024,
-0.6040227413,
-0.0830908716,
-0.017493397,
0.0382283442,
-0.432013005,
-0.3043299615,
0.2112021595,
0.284951508,
-0.5794081688,
0.2063490897,
-0.2904562056,
-0.3788878024,
0.8910858035,
0.1272284389,
0.2461570948,
-0.1388942599,
-0.4564478695,
-0.4230540097,
-0.9777072668,
-0.2498550862,
0.9307081699,
0.3021101058,
-0.3535907567,
0.4469506443,
-0.0434484221,
0.3213077784,
-0.1890895814,
0.0540628992,
0.0879144818,
-0.3662826121,
-0.0612151362,
0.1277593225,
1.0830125809,
-0.165847823,
0.4930863082,
0.113110967,
-0.2584176958,
-0.1624075919,
0.0587969497,
-0.7355399132,
-0.1224282309,
0.2542578578,
-0.3605279624,
-0.3907954991,
0.0887067243,
-0.5589069724,
-0.6188023686,
-0.1076302975,
0.3826338649,
-0.3255788982,
-0.2654531896,
-0.0290811006,
-0.1016521156,
0.035889294,
0.1972903758,
-0.8420257568,
0.1964378506,
0.783048749,
0.7863455415,
-0.3334574699,
-0.2403483242,
-0.5387204289,
0.199992165,
-0.3217838109,
0.7831816673,
-0.1372053623,
-0.2240772694,
0.182520166,
-0.2218228728,
0.3966760337,
-0.5223663449,
0.4058955312,
-0.3741099238,
0.0877498165,
-0.169060424,
-0.6276667118,
0.2088106722,
0.2066034675,
-0.7733459473,
0.6005214453,
-0.1642434001,
-1.0368381739,
0.3031816781,
-0.5607799292,
-0.1527357548,
0.0414174125,
-0.4453988969,
-0.5903121829,
-0.0273181833,
0.0782196,
0.7904503345,
0.0127811013,
0.2893702984,
-0.1375559717,
-0.4763358235,
0.4556701183,
-0.6581536531,
0.8518596292,
0.2040806264,
-0.3557646871,
-0.3177399039,
-0.4667887688,
-0.1299729645,
0.102821283,
-0.4840548337,
-0.3750899136,
-0.1965880692,
-0.1087457314,
0.0747008249,
0.141938448,
-0.5758349299,
0.1786704212,
-0.3672733903,
0.20844163,
0.9556937814,
0.1677313,
0.4874738157,
-0.329141438,
0.5231346488,
0.2467050105,
0.1233402491,
-0.333935231,
-0.6939342618,
-0.7237794995,
-0.1990843415,
0.3847725391,
0.2486919314,
-0.4952499866,
0.1510752589,
-0.4019984007,
-0.5732869506,
-0.5789164305,
0.407319814,
0.5971289873,
0.1125141159,
0.1227456033,
-0.2437298596,
-0.231213972,
-0.9189431667,
-0.7090570331,
-0.4318177998,
-0.2638860345,
0.5495011806,
0.6381343603,
0.1115248501,
0.8234658241,
-0.5389184356,
-0.6152074933,
-0.2154852003,
0.4603006244,
0.0240071379,
0.4775959849,
0.1953876466,
-0.4440584481,
-0.6590227485,
-0.3758595884,
-0.7355143428,
0.1232706755,
-0.0795615166,
0.004958652,
0.4162802696,
0.543345511,
-0.5620033145,
0.1918784529,
0.8231831193,
-0.3175903261,
0.3777632117,
-0.097423397,
-0.3165371418,
-0.8433371186,
0.0795700178,
-0.2182488739,
-0.3861159086,
-0.3404485881,
0.0353263132,
0.2317487597,
-0.109258078,
-0.7696729898,
0.5886368752,
-0.7368967533,
-0.2089341879,
-0.2292089313,
0.206619218,
-0.0474786423,
0.1331548095,
-0.2120249122,
0.7355175614,
0.5846196413,
-0.6764840484,
-0.0623482428,
0.1726317108,
-0.4630611241,
0.1889949143,
-0.4506885707,
0.4636320472,
-0.3221703768,
0.176121518,
-1.0167258978,
-0.162644431,
0.2438442558,
-0.6273556948,
0.6715593934,
-0.4790878296,
-0.5359072089,
0.0553135537,
-0.5208807588,
0.0397286303,
0.3743008971,
-0.5478923917,
0.0476551838,
0.3528110087,
-0.1099130064,
-0.8755512834,
-1.2151417732,
0.1596577466,
-0.0669513941,
-0.6406297684,
0.2609419525,
-0.1776914001,
0.0165950693,
0.0034117119,
-0.0225570519,
-0.1291818321,
0.2110158354,
0.3710348904,
0.1643660814,
-0.1547061801,
0.0888439864,
-0.1323444694,
-0.1741851568,
0.2704217434,
-0.078535825,
0.6818106771,
-0.1730434746,
-0.4399242699,
-0.5408967137,
0.2197026163,
0.4023834169,
0.0624102652,
0.963080287,
0.5141716599,
-0.2277648598,
-0.5112303495,
-0.5827349424,
-0.3405858576,
-0.4912022352,
0.1128827929,
-0.1274279058,
-0.6928790212,
0.3899675012,
0.1331951171,
-0.0994279757,
0.2504596412,
0.4889807105,
-0.0473255441,
0.642578423,
1.1042045355,
-0.4462549984,
0.3588142395,
-0.4700199366,
0.2595494688,
-0.5318006873,
-0.1257045418,
-0.599563539,
-0.2026357502,
-0.7488962412,
-0.328481108,
0.1686528027,
0.0918906927,
-0.1626922488,
0.1687262505,
-0.3764372468,
0.8218594193,
0.4054514766,
-0.1379593462,
0.7144172192,
-0.0449902192,
0.1853183955,
0.0192567632,
-0.4957259297,
-0.5724878311,
1.3798643351,
0.616255343,
1.058449626,
0.2530069649,
1.0510429144,
0.3822372854,
0.2700035572,
-0.7544407248,
0.28049317,
0.0021879326,
-0.8943721652,
-0.5193138123,
-0.3464742601,
-0.9815760851,
-0.0248790085,
-0.0975403488,
-0.6290693283,
0.3299210668,
0.3399439752,
-0.1398558319,
0.0940861031,
-0.5010612011,
0.6252090335,
-0.1046534926,
-0.5001481175,
-0.0294698179,
-0.4165149927,
0.8229171634,
-0.3899416029,
0.2180186212,
-0.1992665678,
-0.2423111647,
0.7911785245,
-0.0535176806,
0.9171953201,
-0.0980457515,
-0.1073101535,
0.2259020507,
0.4721398354,
0.8139375448,
0.1872083992,
-0.0980420038,
0.474860698,
-0.2561812699,
-0.2504705787,
-0.3136771917,
0.5553005934,
-0.722745657,
-0.3608421981,
-0.6059080362,
-0.1721051186,
-0.1818553656,
0.130903393,
0.7150377035,
-0.0258010123,
-0.0162266716,
0.1007673591,
0.7898472548,
-0.1421708912,
0.632387042,
0.7999061942,
-0.0736306459,
0.2221847177,
0.8806926012,
0.0445035547,
0.3891764879,
0.0092125107,
0.4176086485,
-0.3046945632,
-0.8189412355,
-0.4712299109,
0.5198394656,
-0.5593706369,
-0.5122404695,
-0.4072867036,
-0.4340164363,
-0.185005039,
0.2448097914,
-0.8635904789,
-0.1938708574,
-0.2498398274,
-0.0275859088,
0.1348125935,
1.0866531134,
-0.0887947753,
0.3552724123,
-0.7770742178,
0.1248363331,
0.213219732,
0.2268654406,
0.0982815251,
-0.5948711038,
-0.1372683048,
-0.0917905197,
-0.44945544,
-0.690315783,
0.4330048561,
0.1281533688,
0.5260677338,
0.6212747097,
0.1140522659,
0.2957889736,
-0.37056306,
0.8963412046,
0.1818579137,
-1.0192297697,
0.5193622708,
-0.2475353926,
0.0954506919,
0.585634172,
0.6706885695,
-0.3127555549,
-0.6681967378,
-0.7396873236,
-0.6996036172,
0.8010086417,
0.2803260982,
0.4029219747,
0.2453514636,
0.0406865291,
0.1975254267,
0.4789626002,
-0.7706485987,
-0.4959412515,
0.1321155578,
0.0450901985,
-0.0077997344,
-0.4333278835,
-0.0722463205,
0.1699753404,
0.5875177383,
-0.139022842,
0.2666561306,
0.1766280532,
-0.3118771315,
-0.0569470599,
0.522513032,
0.3829213381,
0.6360386014,
-0.0058597028,
0.2231263071,
-0.2064106464,
-0.6451416016,
0.236299336,
-0.3664021492,
-0.2129000723,
0.0054139849,
0.5574710369,
0.4452081621,
-0.0852727666,
-0.6637302041,
1.0970077515,
-0.0520415418,
0.0421812534,
-0.4168910682,
0.1756083816,
0.28803581,
0.0925928056,
0.2904850245,
-0.0496549718,
0.2342635691,
-0.868526876,
0.1258389205,
0.4616846144,
-0.2507588267,
-0.1849017441,
0.4314811528,
-0.1035812274,
-0.0354252681,
0.5862722397,
-0.2932675481,
-0.492331028,
0.210346356,
0.5041679144,
0.6677680016,
-0.3445755541,
0.2647112608,
0.1777590811,
0.4980224371,
-0.243347764,
0.2151270509,
0.0690665022,
-0.7293232679,
-0.3937018514,
-0.5105234385,
-0.3534072042,
0.6422539353,
-0.6246038675,
0.1255335659,
-0.3630187511,
-0.0578149818,
-0.1238373742,
-0.0132032773,
-0.7629634738,
-0.2293831557,
0.5874973536,
0.8501032591,
-0.9879279733,
0.6036823988,
-0.0047765817,
-0.4529465139,
-0.7275535464,
0.1504703462,
0.1750362366,
-0.7870057821,
0.7339960933,
0.1126931906,
0.0049537984,
-0.1698885858,
-0.9275016189,
-1.0698459148,
1.0091894865,
0.845887661,
-0.8287048936,
-0.0071632219,
0.4434821904,
0.3961999714,
-0.1946351528,
0.1153773069,
0.7556313872,
0.4828451276,
-0.3460397422,
-0.7553902268,
0.1594567597,
0.1084982827,
-0.0618817322,
-0.0832193345,
-0.6466411948,
0.9866771102,
-0.0778861269,
-0.3788737357,
-0.1575305462,
0.3552009761,
0.2568153441,
0.3870901167,
0.3918951154,
0.4372581244,
0.808793962,
0.1043145806,
1.2438749075,
-0.0944679976,
0.2595519722,
1.090935111,
-0.0178887006,
1.0767816305,
0.4394438863,
-0.0378764495,
0.2807730436,
0.2306548059,
-0.0917492658,
0.4302527905,
0.4888466299,
-0.0876327157,
0.0843920186,
-0.1293325424,
-0.254784286,
0.4930057228,
0.2513986528,
-0.5034382939,
-0.1600690633,
-0.0663051605,
0.398227334,
0.0108792018,
-0.1346179098,
0.8103064895,
0.3382609487,
-0.446585685,
0.593631506,
-0.0964849144,
0.7267301083,
-0.4909654558,
0.0022470625,
-0.3610499799,
0.0780213326,
-0.443980813,
-0.9766812921,
0.1137994975,
0.2180348337,
0.013456963,
-0.236532405,
0.7659063935,
-0.327393055,
-0.0702156052,
0.4039719701,
0.8212700486,
0.5226400495,
-0.5770164132,
-0.5003266335,
0.5502311587,
-0.0697772726,
-0.3674923778,
0.5168411732,
0.1459361613,
0.2365310788,
0.8442885876,
0.690516293,
0.3974067271,
0.3141490817,
-0.0559486896,
0.7795989513,
-0.5320032239,
-0.440584749,
-0.9681845307,
0.4329978526,
-0.2258348316,
-0.1131408811,
0.8194544315,
0.7422940135,
0.8654134274,
-0.1284015179,
0.9511432052,
0.3968364,
0.414932251,
-0.6919739246,
1.1749740839,
-0.272577256,
0.498878479,
-0.1339534372,
-0.9716438651,
0.1824605316,
0.2488410026,
-0.0481014624,
-0.1801653355,
0.8398874998,
0.5573011041,
-0.2887250781,
-0.0292239413,
0.4032509923,
0.4925994575,
0.4171811342,
0.5478098392,
0.9038380384,
-0.5372580886,
0.84735322,
-0.4351357818,
0.1051388085,
-0.2707267702,
-1.0047121048,
-0.7846637368,
-0.4234240651,
-0.3425301313,
-0.1851079613,
0.0637482405,
0.0887543336,
0.8524358273,
-0.6370670199,
-0.1784632206,
-0.1720161885,
0.0790491328,
0.1763190776,
-0.2384321988,
0.3411585391,
-0.2064147741,
-0.8246327043,
0.5418582559,
-0.0852082297,
0.2597562969,
-0.7155641317,
0.0853325725,
0.1757606715,
0.0909175649,
0.408028543,
0.3215745389,
-0.3562068641,
-0.158164382,
-0.437079668,
-0.2833669484,
-0.1509885639,
0.6582110524,
-0.73197788,
0.2088178396,
0.5301291943,
0.7359349132,
0.9341205359,
0.030106239,
0.3451006114,
-1.0289338827,
0.0545498729,
0.3035886884,
0.1710766256,
0.4538157284,
-0.6341317892,
0.4544176459,
-0.1138627827,
-0.5366526842,
-0.977139771,
0.1405337006,
-0.6839882135,
-0.274325043,
1.0272263288,
-0.2747395635,
-0.383674711,
-0.2224092335,
0.1760345548,
0.0837619826,
-0.6338713169,
0.665754199,
0.784848392,
-0.1636507064,
0.1881890595,
-0.9600664973,
0.6554748416,
0.0564017557,
-0.8176929355,
0.2731069922,
0.3727620244,
0.6085568666,
0.324269712,
0.554618597,
-0.1496864408,
-0.0052083619,
0.0329673477,
-0.0934256166,
-0.2611923516,
-0.5832700729,
-0.6203686595,
0.1435641646,
0.2188070416,
-0.1281525344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16129v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16129v1
|
A Survey on Lexical Ambiguity Detection and Word Sense Disambiguation
| 2024-03-24T12:58:48 | 2024-03-24T12:58:48 |
Miuru Abeysiriwardana, Deshan Sumanathilaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper explores techniques that focus on understanding and resolving
ambiguity in language within the field of natural language processing (NLP),
highlighting the complexity of linguistic phenomena such as polysemy and
homonymy and their implications for computational models. Focusing extensively
on Word Sense Disambiguation (WSD), it outlines diverse approaches ranging from
deep learning techniques to leveraging lexical resources and knowledge graphs
like WordNet. The paper introduces cutting-edge methodologies like word sense
extension (WSE) and neuromyotonic approaches, enhancing disambiguation accuracy
by predicting new word senses. It examines specific applications in biomedical
disambiguation and language specific optimisation and discusses the
significance of cognitive metaphors in discourse analysis. The research
identifies persistent challenges in the field, such as the scarcity of sense
annotated corpora and the complexity of informal clinical texts. It concludes
by suggesting future directions, including using large language models, visual
WSD, and multilingual WSD systems, emphasising the ongoing evolution in
addressing lexical complexities in NLP. This thinking perspective highlights
the advancement in this field to enable computers to understand language more
accurately.
|
[
-0.4981148541,
-0.7685133815,
0.9885041118,
0.1063119918,
-0.2441738695,
0.2624302804,
-0.255033493,
-0.6920141578,
0.0076251887,
-0.3072763979,
-0.5107721686,
-0.3002994359,
-1.1859865189,
0.3266690671,
-0.1070545241,
0.1428689361,
-0.0078281667,
0.166298449,
-0.3722251058,
-0.565563798,
-0.4407908022,
-0.3944765627,
-0.4064409137,
-0.5612023473,
0.5817778111,
-0.1428304166,
1.0981550217,
0.2993111908,
0.5417300463,
0.3387871981,
-0.6131610274,
0.3951278925,
0.1058047935,
0.0261374544,
-0.5203026533,
-0.3003664911,
-0.1337060481,
-0.2735332549,
0.1227327809,
1.4412845373,
-0.1131207347,
-0.1977925599,
-0.0802263841,
0.7085872889,
-0.9009618163,
-0.0911579356,
-0.6056223512,
0.1002968699,
-0.1659464538,
0.198931247,
0.0472805388,
0.0286711268,
0.221782282,
-0.6408227682,
-0.0858466476,
0.0910614878,
0.9416459203,
0.5977700949,
-0.3644869924,
-0.6555989385,
-0.4049232602,
0.7127566338,
-0.741975069,
0.807569921,
0.475853771,
0.143611908,
-0.3113592565,
-0.6997505426,
-0.9213451743,
0.057455644,
0.0773583353,
0.0082217231,
-0.512114048,
0.3949038684,
0.2615671158,
0.3026379347,
-0.5981413126,
0.3135281205,
-0.3260481358,
-0.3560208678,
0.3027671576,
-0.0466560125,
0.3180064261,
-0.3225786388,
-0.1712158322,
0.0652477816,
-0.1453027576,
-0.2152952552,
0.1939649433,
0.0768803284,
0.106455937,
0.4597816765,
0.1068589762,
1.1658751965,
-0.458294034,
0.0208255555,
0.3451256454,
-0.3436158299,
-0.2889704704,
-0.0995845348,
0.5217040777,
0.1718058586,
0.0872935653,
-0.1074813083,
0.0133385137,
0.485154748,
0.2226664424,
-0.1874436885,
-0.0171805602,
0.384832412,
-0.2190530002,
0.0636971146,
-0.184581399,
-0.5502387285,
-0.6009764671,
-0.7599604726,
0.3272099495,
-0.8976637721,
-0.3451344669,
0.6116836071,
-0.6000286937,
0.0228538606,
0.2005959302,
-0.6650318503,
0.2304902077,
0.6284709573,
0.7091118693,
-0.0767614543,
-0.2301373929,
0.0779397041,
0.049780596,
-0.3205597401,
0.5486624241,
-0.4637721777,
-0.2441572249,
-0.2317862958,
-0.2985889018,
0.0772951469,
-0.555356741,
0.3245513737,
-0.3900932074,
0.1912983656,
-0.2449834049,
-0.6858597398,
-0.2415588945,
0.3272684813,
-0.4886742532,
0.9889743328,
0.3141809702,
-0.7431860566,
0.5288237333,
-0.6444201469,
-0.2112256736,
0.3685754538,
-0.2442199886,
0.186274156,
0.5434783101,
0.1081265137,
0.0839798898,
-0.2476488948,
0.4475972652,
-0.2248131782,
-0.2161284834,
0.1579616219,
-0.1572632194,
0.8053178191,
0.3810807765,
-0.1139766648,
-0.1187665835,
-0.7127070427,
0.1703157872,
0.0832172483,
0.1641802341,
-0.8686991334,
-0.0950167626,
0.0112230359,
0.2387514263,
0.4457966983,
-0.4643343985,
0.0986208841,
-0.6902027726,
0.6376689076,
0.2688573003,
-0.388458848,
0.1594997644,
0.1224120408,
0.5523129702,
0.3097139299,
0.2112403363,
0.214832738,
-0.6037353277,
-0.4995476604,
-0.046562884,
0.5987103581,
0.4666363895,
-0.9184964299,
0.6429699659,
0.0269720145,
-0.3787365556,
-0.7972477078,
-0.0649494901,
0.1921317279,
0.4802564383,
0.5706060529,
-0.2698319256,
-0.5046043396,
-0.8091465235,
-0.4746254683,
-0.4441896379,
-0.0718286186,
0.0061379028,
0.4485753179,
-0.6855401397,
1.1025886536,
-0.5997982025,
0.0754304454,
-0.0590574034,
0.2872960567,
0.0969332978,
-0.0036264616,
0.4695241451,
-1.161711812,
0.1117410362,
-0.0574932769,
-0.68608284,
-0.1263086647,
0.2078302801,
0.1918217987,
-0.0175840128,
0.6399580836,
-0.3743900061,
0.5781317949,
0.6184806228,
-0.2460192889,
0.4487821758,
-0.3194799125,
-0.072951138,
-0.9866791964,
0.0882610977,
-0.1302973181,
-0.1466998458,
-0.6354088783,
0.183493197,
0.1166512519,
0.0927869305,
-0.3383283615,
0.5708405375,
-0.6423046589,
0.1174310446,
-0.3923547566,
0.5865013003,
0.2298022211,
0.014464586,
-0.0771374032,
0.4124213755,
0.6120490432,
-0.6509094834,
0.4860429168,
0.222280249,
-0.199590832,
0.5322893858,
-0.487976253,
-0.1487650126,
-0.5562285185,
-0.4028505683,
-1.0622144938,
-0.1062090248,
0.378688246,
-0.6354726553,
0.1684424579,
0.3579458296,
-0.4060467184,
-0.6683292389,
0.008280009,
0.7661004066,
0.1739384383,
-0.3840233982,
0.1410730034,
0.4998922646,
0.2402028143,
-0.6761054397,
-0.8059142232,
0.2589122653,
-0.1207088754,
-0.4024485946,
0.4393362403,
0.0567917004,
-0.6185974479,
-0.0355153605,
-0.2333018631,
-0.2641199529,
0.2863314152,
0.135439232,
0.2068474591,
0.1463740319,
0.5980629325,
0.2232468724,
-0.1213319078,
-0.0810235664,
-0.351429075,
0.5237047672,
-0.1698954254,
-0.4871638119,
0.1458519399,
0.4775713086,
0.3826547563,
-0.0823803619,
0.6145150661,
0.7688289285,
-0.8394931555,
0.0775489807,
-0.3436563611,
-0.1367694139,
-0.4541837275,
0.3298404515,
-0.4240604341,
-1.031324029,
0.4706361592,
-0.5178914666,
-0.3248126805,
0.384684056,
0.3928200603,
-0.1051331908,
0.8131057024,
0.6410045028,
0.0065040579,
0.1104826555,
0.1694824845,
0.6635255218,
-0.7076386809,
0.084096618,
-0.4521051347,
-0.346631676,
-0.5742387176,
-0.605545938,
0.5589822531,
0.4120561481,
0.2281705141,
0.2913470566,
-0.7262082696,
0.2953097522,
0.0788976923,
-0.1171175987,
0.4232102931,
-0.164951697,
-0.468334645,
-0.2664722502,
-0.7375626564,
-0.3834142983,
0.49252671,
0.1850062609,
0.3470180631,
0.1873971075,
0.4939143956,
0.1817486882,
-0.187396422,
-1.0085406303,
0.3372318745,
0.1322661191,
-0.3307649195,
-0.342299521,
-0.3456117511,
-1.3575870991,
0.4170506597,
-0.2211066186,
-0.8721550703,
0.4251852632,
0.0211499035,
-0.2936645448,
0.2749619782,
-0.608130753,
0.7082614303,
0.0406078175,
-0.1627177149,
-0.0687978119,
-0.7899016738,
0.2189446688,
0.0025979641,
0.5101661682,
-0.3150260746,
-0.3595659733,
0.2346284986,
-0.257889837,
0.4048279226,
-0.0357933454,
-0.483446449,
0.2139992863,
0.0685686469,
-0.1725752354,
-0.072447896,
-0.4363202155,
0.7302404046,
0.3521297574,
-0.3585510552,
-0.4728391171,
0.2374059409,
-0.3176300526,
-0.4329528809,
-0.7359325886,
-0.6596632004,
-0.6187179089,
0.2981688976,
0.323946178,
0.1487132162,
-0.1494389921,
-0.4865991473,
0.5488150716,
-0.3627530038,
0.5088052154,
0.2120582759,
-0.0524905697,
0.1160267293,
0.6803777814,
-0.04665659,
0.1259983778,
0.18155922,
0.2669475973,
-0.5156392455,
-0.676654458,
-0.3595329523,
0.3781009316,
-0.463452071,
-0.2593815327,
-0.380315572,
-0.1415464133,
-0.5114431381,
-0.1307720989,
-0.0257686228,
-0.2490615696,
-0.2439074218,
0.0150629962,
0.5583480597,
0.5931744576,
-0.2770646214,
0.2717273533,
-0.5999170542,
0.5792645812,
-0.1248621792,
0.4799111187,
-0.1926583052,
-0.1943452358,
0.0329127796,
0.2508347929,
-0.1320465058,
-1.3387048244,
0.4260699749,
0.1449069381,
0.3793349266,
0.3327572942,
-0.0333854854,
0.8545488119,
-0.2771325707,
0.7746238708,
0.4886071384,
-1.1806676388,
0.6034824848,
-0.2224880606,
0.6142738461,
0.6404647231,
0.6271868348,
-1.1267800331,
-0.3007442355,
-0.5988445282,
-1.0468984842,
0.2065302581,
-0.0230503231,
-0.1205521524,
-0.2035431117,
0.5961931944,
0.1359151006,
0.4825395942,
-0.2134910524,
-0.1933630407,
0.4114278853,
-0.4564515948,
-0.0682147518,
0.0191608649,
-0.0177624132,
-0.5109379292,
0.1521331817,
-0.39130494,
0.0702906102,
0.30455181,
-0.3341543674,
0.2613807321,
0.3124147952,
0.4174765646,
1.0652967691,
0.207855314,
0.2982259393,
0.2905878425,
-0.4796152413,
0.0386548229,
-0.1263213903,
0.1478593051,
0.2976351976,
0.2226153165,
0.5079494119,
0.0619080178,
-1.0071815252,
0.4689241946,
0.0283380616,
-0.2777481973,
-0.1376576573,
-0.1428563446,
0.226639092,
-0.0141739082,
0.1325491965,
0.1273669302,
0.5202701092,
-0.5016182661,
0.1179045141,
0.5037334561,
-0.4203339219,
0.044153858,
0.4927359819,
-0.3104762733,
-0.1218518764,
0.4475947917,
-0.4523586631,
-0.4448948503,
0.5110996366,
0.3668197393,
0.3834193945,
-0.1801568121,
0.0335131474,
0.0951820537,
0.3497487307,
0.0901172534,
0.6026746631,
-0.0977116972,
-0.8965146542,
-0.2019888759,
-0.6701143384,
-0.4891670048,
0.0218483135,
-0.8066561818,
0.1996287256,
-0.2998299897,
-0.4668437839,
0.4629399776,
-0.2147626728,
-0.4503998756,
0.1693113446,
0.4386356175,
0.8828384876,
-0.6741167307,
0.680051446,
0.9106255174,
0.0585299134,
-0.6378720403,
-0.0744486228,
0.2554966807,
-0.7144049406,
0.2985182106,
-0.0461927615,
-0.2818282843,
-0.1515429765,
-0.4237821102,
-0.4493695796,
0.6304817796,
0.4429765046,
-0.646846652,
0.0625978038,
0.3048063517,
0.7618593574,
0.3026252985,
0.2264938951,
0.9661999345,
0.7571154237,
0.0464216322,
-1.0065803528,
-0.1572762877,
-0.2552526593,
0.2248636037,
0.6239520907,
-0.1927676946,
0.6218708754,
-0.1291086525,
-0.2207207084,
-0.0735518709,
0.6187677383,
0.0228846576,
0.4664270282,
0.7253174782,
0.7285321355,
1.1650407314,
-0.3139732778,
0.7301854491,
-0.0770118833,
0.1287620068,
0.7477422357,
-0.1775595844,
0.4454225302,
1.0044552088,
-0.4043032527,
0.3748704493,
0.8449828029,
0.2314948291,
0.0329393558,
0.6492812634,
-0.4461647272,
-0.0749264732,
-0.2543832958,
-0.3607729971,
0.6034559011,
0.9883249402,
0.1230941489,
-0.3985522687,
0.3297282755,
-0.0900993645,
0.4340420663,
-0.2733434737,
0.8119032979,
0.1902639717,
-0.5169412494,
0.6439034343,
0.2254828364,
0.8786578178,
-0.7024407983,
0.1254759282,
0.103384912,
-0.0203425735,
-0.1585848927,
-0.5818904638,
0.5780554414,
-0.392265588,
-0.159833163,
0.0060891313,
0.9028140903,
-0.4682807326,
-0.3402305841,
0.5373317599,
0.9327155352,
0.2566854656,
-0.043545112,
-0.8560112715,
0.1257076561,
-0.203319639,
0.3188018203,
0.2288059443,
0.6472121477,
-0.1865838319,
0.4986052215,
0.2760014534,
0.2901330888,
0.141627416,
0.1940404624,
0.6787747741,
-0.7014844418,
-0.375220567,
-0.9109255075,
-0.0450608879,
-0.065736644,
-0.5729088187,
0.4991251826,
0.1317818016,
0.8490157723,
0.074752599,
0.4925554991,
-0.3096804619,
0.1749143451,
-0.1499062628,
0.4037611187,
-0.9302709103,
-0.0414147712,
-0.501853168,
-0.374600172,
-0.612334013,
0.7816100717,
-0.2545508742,
-0.1092379019,
0.7519670129,
0.6342601776,
-0.1010203063,
0.2559046149,
0.3654506207,
-0.1610531956,
-0.182636112,
0.6052262783,
0.6650806665,
-0.4554476142,
-0.1061488986,
-0.0792695284,
-0.2068073004,
-0.0568779856,
-0.9281025529,
-0.3716212213,
-0.9465420842,
-0.3031665981,
-0.1690104157,
0.0612076223,
0.7745665312,
0.590914011,
-0.4498116672,
-0.0560003221,
-0.2013726085,
0.4608730972,
-0.542835772,
-0.230882749,
0.2339919508,
-0.6427321434,
-0.9067907929,
0.4275713265,
0.5153505206,
-0.0818274468,
-0.1449443698,
0.1217005178,
-0.4562905133,
0.0554983541,
0.6455209255,
0.284615308,
-0.7206251025,
-0.159737289,
-0.2034836262,
-0.1419692934,
-0.1120320261,
0.6618797779,
-0.7714666724,
0.5604456663,
0.5176227689,
0.7474367619,
0.039649114,
-0.1287837327,
0.3760445416,
-0.6211521626,
0.5466448069,
0.4796578884,
0.2879202366,
0.2387090325,
-0.3005555868,
0.4873507619,
0.3861587048,
0.073255457,
-0.8898214698,
0.4656093121,
-1.0648260117,
-0.7940387726,
0.8813340068,
0.2455878258,
-0.3860258162,
-0.5274655819,
-0.1158361509,
0.266829133,
0.159977898,
0.7438256145,
0.9294149876,
-0.2533589602,
0.0048622894,
-0.5742137432,
0.5420369506,
0.8071804643,
-0.7240402699,
-0.1091469005,
0.4310936332,
-0.1150304824,
0.3467053473,
0.2525391579,
-0.2735064328,
0.1678008437,
-0.1812200546,
0.2261020094,
0.09042795,
-0.0593197867,
-0.6171505451,
0.0883425474,
0.0796994045,
-0.1345507801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16127v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16127v2
|
WangchanLion and WangchanX MRC Eval
| 2024-03-24T12:49:30 | 2024-04-23T12:31:30 |
Wannaphong Phatthiyaphaibun, Surapon Nonesung, Patomporn Payoungkhamdee, Peerat Limkonchotiwat, Can Udomcharoenchaikit, Jitkapat Sawatphol, Chompakorn Chaksangchaichot, Ekapol Chuangsuwanich, Sarana Nutanong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This technical report describes the development of WangchanLion, an
instruction fine-tuned model focusing on Machine Reading Comprehension (MRC) in
the Thai language. Our model is based on SEA-LION and a collection of
instruction following datasets. To promote open research and reproducibility,
we publicly release all training data, code, and the final model weights under
the Apache-2 license. To assess the contextual understanding capability, we
conducted extensive experimental studies using two Thai MRC datasets, XQuAD and
Iapp_wiki_qa_squad. Experimental results demonstrate the model's ability to
comprehend the context and produce an answer faithful to the reference one in
0-shot and 1-shot settings. In addition, our evaluation goes beyond the
traditional MRC. We propose a new evaluation scheme assessing the answer's
correctness, helpfulness, conciseness, and contextuality. Our code is available
publicly at https://github.com/vistec-AI/WangchanLion.
|
[
-0.214882344,
-0.6679562926,
0.1822423339,
0.3191772997,
-0.3405580521,
-0.100146383,
-0.0701954588,
-0.5024701357,
-0.2064655572,
0.3992078304,
-0.667163074,
-0.3784002066,
-0.3400683701,
0.4667009711,
-0.2102383375,
0.8395450115,
-0.3346336484,
0.2290702015,
0.1529733241,
-0.2913777232,
-0.639983058,
-0.1663883626,
-0.4649169147,
-0.3036957681,
0.7207481265,
1.0883209705,
0.5045194626,
0.6389293671,
0.895996511,
0.1614019126,
-0.1198638305,
0.1323983371,
-0.4272096753,
0.0623748973,
-0.2881267071,
-0.4642094672,
-0.4992828369,
-0.0099649709,
0.4528649449,
0.7834998369,
-0.2340719998,
0.2079136521,
0.1706012785,
0.9270230532,
-0.7775823474,
0.2665423155,
-0.1218401268,
0.491198957,
0.1344633251,
-0.521749258,
-0.7700636387,
-0.2752223015,
0.5282407403,
-0.8936244845,
0.0592608191,
0.1070459932,
0.8163259625,
-0.0088502141,
-0.5288700461,
-0.5909782052,
-0.2412762493,
0.886367023,
-0.5043004155,
0.3821150064,
0.9607691169,
0.4570957422,
0.3228405416,
-0.7997803688,
-0.555586338,
-0.368167311,
-0.1243756264,
0.1981997639,
0.0690948442,
0.0184265822,
-0.094391644,
0.5116735697,
-0.7742043734,
-0.1288155764,
-0.8362833858,
-0.0736341104,
0.4240818322,
0.2528352141,
0.0837026834,
-0.6851801276,
-0.2159678489,
-0.2466200739,
-0.4838957489,
0.0411419012,
0.2399310768,
0.2392330617,
-0.2106473446,
0.7403017879,
-0.4612617195,
0.5605196953,
0.0813296437,
-0.036357902,
0.1194227114,
-0.3827292919,
-0.4782057106,
0.008353495,
0.5051968694,
0.5194485188,
0.3860724568,
0.0285958685,
-0.2000785023,
-0.8334162235,
0.3742913604,
-0.9564710855,
-0.5693314672,
0.229719758,
-0.7464997172,
-0.8228337765,
0.4562067986,
-0.7316125035,
-0.3282861412,
-0.3452771008,
0.4137223661,
-0.5657727122,
-0.3656099737,
0.0607238412,
-0.0594529286,
0.5025679469,
0.0652437732,
-0.9548723698,
0.1130495742,
0.4019881189,
1.0637284517,
-0.2803425491,
-0.5460770726,
-0.2946139276,
0.018587986,
-0.4265576899,
0.7137899995,
-0.3940888047,
-0.6876264215,
0.0472195596,
0.469910413,
-0.0153434919,
-0.557199657,
0.4740336239,
-0.8865119219,
0.570312798,
-0.154745996,
-0.205893591,
-0.7524266243,
0.3345538378,
-0.6600719094,
0.7178999186,
0.3794546723,
-0.9946138263,
0.2533456683,
-0.8210681081,
-0.8436785936,
-0.3807423115,
0.4490349591,
-0.4239985347,
-0.1503684223,
0.14153108,
0.3929866552,
-0.2714585066,
0.0731030181,
-0.2349470854,
-0.300989598,
0.3430941403,
-0.6934612393,
1.0428950787,
0.6219650507,
-0.3805805147,
0.4141485393,
-0.763528347,
0.1621194929,
0.0084021017,
-0.3228046298,
-0.1216607988,
-0.255707562,
0.1014410034,
-0.0153993098,
-0.0183222406,
-0.0188672505,
0.1608260721,
-0.1725525558,
0.3101353645,
0.7617082,
0.087161608,
0.4124015868,
-0.0091164634,
0.7932665944,
0.1115823686,
0.0755168125,
-0.7217752934,
-0.1732120812,
-0.8499523997,
-0.2440591604,
0.4631908536,
0.8219973445,
-0.801599741,
0.1889296323,
0.0774846897,
-0.3644126356,
-0.2663131654,
-0.1429878622,
0.3169698119,
0.8872098327,
0.3402577937,
-0.1637089103,
-0.6126038432,
-0.6293959022,
0.0757300928,
-0.2248232365,
-0.0215488281,
0.4145807922,
0.56179142,
-0.1707590371,
0.526144743,
-0.6735516787,
-0.0023932839,
-0.3854722381,
0.197562024,
0.0311682969,
0.5207498074,
0.0713536143,
-0.4844075143,
-0.6308072805,
0.3765810132,
-0.9999898076,
-0.1282098442,
0.0554172248,
-0.2000737637,
0.2210296243,
0.5025988817,
-0.233431533,
0.5228419304,
0.5100514889,
-0.3131240308,
0.9031051993,
-0.4197562337,
0.844676733,
-1.0814685822,
0.4340626001,
-0.1863922775,
-0.2481693178,
-0.4375317395,
0.4320169985,
0.3738139272,
-0.1645696163,
-0.4006464183,
0.3583610654,
-0.4390681982,
0.2179942876,
-0.2674690187,
0.2978491783,
0.1239358336,
0.3929235935,
0.072615549,
1.0321782827,
0.4833571017,
-0.7782800198,
0.4766646922,
-0.0599537864,
-0.3037886024,
0.5732446313,
-1.0286260843,
0.1534874737,
0.2034268826,
-0.0127633,
-0.9920471311,
-0.6162343621,
0.549623847,
-0.3576445282,
0.4297350347,
0.2777936161,
-0.3850569129,
-0.3977630734,
-0.4072086811,
0.5930073857,
0.2374635786,
-0.5895369649,
0.2738454938,
0.2611587048,
0.0294558629,
-0.7346924543,
-1.1794275045,
-0.3032078147,
-0.1315619946,
-0.4672713578,
-0.2414580137,
0.1289807409,
-0.0891109183,
-0.1472405642,
-0.0381739698,
-0.7471866608,
-0.1860881895,
0.0317189805,
0.3479546309,
-0.5175911188,
0.098364614,
0.0362873375,
-0.2337403893,
0.0119642001,
-0.3329873681,
0.2316416949,
-0.015373745,
-0.242595762,
-0.8757315874,
0.0205903202,
0.5166650414,
-0.2825400531,
0.7662575841,
0.4827048779,
-0.2221758217,
-0.0495986976,
0.024098115,
-0.2298670858,
-0.519492209,
0.6312753558,
-0.6271951199,
-0.5102596879,
0.5392243862,
0.203921929,
-0.0695339516,
0.4648053348,
0.4247448742,
0.0095507978,
0.9066830277,
0.8258996606,
-0.0091777761,
0.2615662515,
-0.2110636085,
0.1358472854,
-0.6856828332,
-0.3857862949,
-0.3337814808,
-0.0705698729,
-0.3098730743,
-0.4736897647,
-0.0277299508,
0.279863596,
-0.1180524006,
0.4637227058,
-0.651758194,
0.5968607068,
0.3919256032,
0.0993542001,
0.5761625171,
-0.0633050203,
-0.4446600676,
-0.0829936713,
-0.6024397612,
-0.5902389884,
1.2152353525,
0.4042684734,
0.8474962711,
0.0212365929,
-0.0456208885,
0.2902028263,
0.2843083441,
-0.850215137,
0.3975472152,
0.277082324,
-0.8376755118,
-0.2950306237,
-0.4433934391,
-0.908649981,
0.3086457551,
0.5401206613,
-0.4100222588,
-0.0061684321,
0.0358568542,
-0.2582286596,
0.2637853324,
-1.0619021654,
1.2126241922,
0.074456282,
-0.1174410135,
-0.773624599,
-0.6561565399,
0.8172841668,
-0.0633664727,
-0.1939994693,
0.2145061195,
-0.0963292271,
0.5850247145,
-0.5229414105,
0.5451568365,
-0.060205806,
-0.1648628116,
0.5265571475,
0.1067563817,
0.0205986276,
0.2131362259,
-0.3772884905,
-0.0168399941,
0.343018949,
-0.5528069139,
-0.5016536713,
0.4284032583,
-0.6970608234,
-0.1434819996,
-0.5365892649,
-0.5550870895,
0.0638284236,
0.3811321259,
0.1497725397,
0.4644019306,
-0.2742806971,
0.2026835829,
0.7625951767,
-0.2908964753,
0.1446136534,
0.8197279572,
-0.5145452023,
-0.6182175279,
0.9218793511,
-0.0861288458,
0.3654707074,
0.4499360621,
0.1586296409,
-0.0775830895,
-0.179306522,
-0.4927837551,
0.0709436312,
-0.9951534271,
-0.1854613125,
-0.2136870623,
-0.221990779,
-0.1471361965,
0.0653311387,
-0.0445716009,
-0.4936175346,
-0.4461568892,
-0.1032527536,
0.1717323065,
1.0825875998,
-0.2348772883,
0.3978916109,
-0.4018891156,
0.3954265714,
0.1730811447,
0.4534294903,
0.2272229642,
-0.9943808317,
-0.5637189746,
-0.0415921956,
-0.5808522105,
-0.8831534982,
0.0784677491,
-0.0457650796,
0.1091490015,
0.824437499,
0.0381759554,
0.8247750998,
-0.693122983,
0.651104629,
-0.0077008139,
-0.9797543287,
0.6462901235,
-0.1205831394,
0.5022755265,
0.5647819638,
0.3790356219,
-0.8110203147,
-0.1930006295,
-0.1229854301,
-0.3221101761,
0.9365451336,
-0.1082220152,
-0.0821458846,
0.2130423337,
0.4036771655,
0.2632640004,
0.0290122163,
-0.4610000253,
-0.3022348285,
-0.3636811078,
-0.2846205533,
0.2030784041,
-0.3575768471,
0.1150771603,
-0.5806420445,
0.6520751715,
0.0098421481,
0.0508964956,
0.529466033,
-0.364867568,
-0.2360955477,
-0.0261842795,
1.1472895145,
0.996060133,
-0.0764375106,
0.2308307886,
0.3141619861,
-0.8926690221,
-0.0350146443,
0.0144980578,
-0.0031817753,
-0.0980233923,
0.6266582608,
0.4542500675,
0.2253464758,
-0.8498924971,
0.2673006654,
-0.0802646056,
-0.2899920046,
-0.0147814117,
-0.0707432479,
-0.1171297356,
0.0953476802,
0.3471244276,
0.1249928102,
0.1885490865,
-0.3461543918,
0.4266309142,
-0.0251950361,
-0.6601212621,
-0.5035021901,
0.6862713099,
0.2353648841,
-0.1382826269,
0.6248987317,
-0.4543900192,
-0.5468708873,
0.3984608948,
0.3967372775,
0.9148359895,
-0.3332269192,
0.364407599,
0.6307411194,
0.4905041158,
0.216647163,
0.2733269334,
-0.2554719448,
-0.2574172318,
-0.3899259567,
-0.0410365649,
-0.6244362593,
0.0017295652,
-0.7038836479,
0.3373931944,
-0.460839957,
0.2963232398,
-0.3332053721,
0.2425888181,
-0.173757866,
0.118490316,
-0.4065904617,
1.1065233946,
-0.3087849915,
1.0051033497,
0.4232583642,
-0.7338370681,
-0.9670760632,
0.3197132051,
-0.0393497795,
-0.8921952248,
0.7565096021,
0.2664780021,
-0.2299847007,
-0.2233611047,
-0.4724008441,
-0.378403306,
1.1862803698,
0.0746081993,
-0.2088938802,
0.1585606784,
0.1259545088,
0.3120707273,
-0.1161584631,
0.4292214513,
0.5500946641,
0.5827556849,
-0.128855601,
-0.9542562366,
-0.1174789742,
-0.0387364253,
-0.3076253831,
-0.4466042817,
-0.5974689126,
0.5701310635,
-0.5802509189,
-0.1498993486,
0.400744617,
0.9805596471,
0.2233272642,
0.3082608283,
0.2747299671,
0.2414949536,
0.9894021749,
0.2223629206,
1.1950415373,
-0.3622922897,
0.4528507888,
0.9306898713,
0.0041074189,
0.9943416119,
0.4129067659,
-0.2459536046,
0.6041559577,
0.9624143243,
0.249955982,
0.7733439803,
0.0734769106,
-0.1497218013,
0.3152397275,
0.0957373083,
-0.3485374749,
0.1694547683,
-0.1805793941,
-0.3327259719,
0.0461555421,
0.2015929669,
-0.0918647498,
-0.1825825721,
-0.2386972606,
0.4074171185,
0.1068518013,
-0.7588708401,
0.7761147022,
0.2405815274,
0.4466390014,
-0.552942872,
0.0227456894,
-0.2374823093,
0.4558752477,
-0.2956687808,
-1.1147272587,
0.3331571519,
0.1042959094,
-0.4320197105,
0.1078756973,
0.56921947,
-0.4411603808,
-0.438922286,
-0.1983931065,
0.2292697132,
0.3420504332,
0.2077302039,
-0.6976048946,
0.0212181471,
0.3186819851,
-0.3384457827,
-0.1888636202,
0.7755715847,
0.2682915628,
0.8770313859,
0.2839141786,
-0.0490252227,
0.0288145021,
0.1969400495,
0.5178765655,
-0.7071248293,
-0.366587311,
-0.6204981804,
0.5966653824,
-0.0642311424,
-0.7108643651,
0.7931672931,
0.6443098187,
0.7049070001,
-0.255574286,
0.5186592937,
0.062972784,
0.4987351596,
-0.4054448903,
0.9475567341,
-0.554384172,
0.1690084189,
-0.1084352955,
-0.5367004275,
-0.4181595147,
0.9376344085,
-0.2738475502,
0.0751823783,
1.1886595488,
0.8619168401,
-0.3205696046,
0.3441279233,
0.2849401236,
-0.0951759741,
0.1531257629,
0.3029516637,
0.8155257702,
-0.6845058799,
0.8405998945,
-0.5106095076,
-0.1090773195,
-0.3094255328,
-0.5738044381,
-1.1378977299,
-0.6319919229,
-0.22522524,
-0.32431072,
-0.0198458266,
0.561101675,
0.7833486795,
-1.2039724588,
-0.3753716052,
-0.3102763593,
0.5149877071,
-0.2503409386,
-0.372404784,
0.5191968083,
-0.7189626098,
-0.6326715946,
0.1389126778,
0.380340606,
-0.1928801239,
-0.5624244213,
-0.4938982427,
-0.0682708323,
-0.087768212,
0.6996796131,
0.343695581,
-0.6649685502,
-0.1638973951,
0.5355238318,
-0.510001719,
0.1189687103,
0.877618432,
-0.4275087714,
0.6820955276,
0.6077887416,
0.6258645058,
0.15886648,
-0.17048648,
0.8121322989,
-0.3635490835,
0.3464408815,
-0.0647126138,
0.1205054,
0.2281409949,
0.023275204,
0.6400587559,
0.1510678381,
-0.7688393593,
-0.9640453458,
-0.0906521082,
-0.6829660535,
-0.3762430847,
0.8393362164,
-0.2144044936,
-0.2808610201,
0.0292767361,
-0.6063492298,
0.3342757821,
0.0147804199,
0.6020103693,
0.8997134566,
0.0678807944,
-0.468359679,
-0.94819206,
0.2775869668,
0.5637320876,
-0.819044888,
0.0701819584,
0.1453567892,
0.2209305316,
-0.1175877303,
0.3251887262,
-0.0875639543,
0.6396383047,
0.153626889,
-0.0924180299,
0.1290317923,
-0.2553495765,
-0.5203310251,
0.0530481599,
0.0892051384,
-0.4143146574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16099v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16099v2
|
A Multi-Label Dataset of French Fake News: Human and Machine Insights
| 2024-03-24T11:29:55 | 2024-04-11T09:58:17 |
Benjamin Icard, François Maine, Morgane Casanova, Géraud Faye, Julien Chanson, Guillaume Gadek, Ghislain Atemezing, François Bancilhon, Paul Égré
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present a corpus of 100 documents, OBSINFOX, selected from 17 sources of
French press considered unreliable by expert agencies, annotated using 11
labels by 8 annotators. By collecting more labels than usual, by more
annotators than is typically done, we can identify features that humans
consider as characteristic of fake news, and compare them to the predictions of
automated classifiers. We present a topic and genre analysis using Gate Cloud,
indicative of the prevalence of satire-like text in the corpus. We then use the
subjectivity analyzer VAGO, and a neural version of it, to clarify the link
between ascriptions of the label Subjective and ascriptions of the label Fake
News. The annotated dataset is available online at the following url:
https://github.com/obs-info/obsinfox
Keywords: Fake News, Multi-Labels, Subjectivity, Vagueness, Detail, Opinion,
Exaggeration, French Press
|
[
-0.5235843062,
-0.7921760678,
0.4610896111,
0.4261892438,
-0.0105795581,
0.230754897,
-0.1031894237,
-0.4188240767,
0.3201080263,
0.7010390759,
-0.2092389911,
-0.3214987516,
-0.6791106462,
0.1227259561,
-0.6026284099,
1.1873650551,
0.0711386874,
0.1357903928,
-0.027290348,
-0.2951801717,
0.0269617401,
-0.8129961491,
-0.3692260385,
-0.1935863644,
0.7516041994,
0.2544496059,
0.5548992753,
0.4423089325,
-0.0330646262,
0.2231301665,
0.151328966,
0.1762872338,
-0.384373188,
-0.3389850855,
-0.4243640602,
-0.2794585526,
-0.3168756962,
0.353700459,
0.3873569667,
0.4194022417,
0.1906330884,
0.3263091743,
0.027528381,
0.4238179028,
-0.6010235548,
-0.1013770849,
-0.4119860232,
-0.226979956,
-0.2849704921,
0.0315445848,
-0.3888750076,
-0.1679208577,
-0.0725071058,
-0.60178262,
0.661734879,
0.0153962467,
1.0904823542,
0.2319759876,
-0.6522568464,
-0.2073675692,
-0.6973512173,
0.4657721519,
-0.2914446592,
0.5662347674,
0.243526116,
0.2982523739,
0.0731603429,
-0.6557835937,
-0.7148243189,
-0.0909643397,
-0.0622368306,
0.2002734393,
-0.2752467394,
-0.4245055914,
0.3075679541,
0.0645239279,
-0.576970458,
0.0010261126,
-0.6742253304,
-0.6400105953,
0.6186357737,
-0.5843148828,
0.246788919,
-0.2226029187,
-0.5604563951,
0.004137828,
-0.428712666,
0.0731696934,
0.6510536075,
0.0704946369,
0.0591802225,
0.4731000662,
-0.5276383162,
0.7884019017,
-0.1989904195,
-0.0329152569,
0.7151987553,
-0.0086182756,
-0.0646868944,
0.5184659362,
1.0113850832,
0.2879675329,
0.3212616444,
-0.1703687459,
-0.1803123206,
0.4315245748,
0.6463377476,
-0.4320070744,
-0.2522674203,
0.1843812466,
-0.2543317974,
-0.4541063905,
0.6273259521,
-0.7374580503,
-0.5342035294,
-0.4286363721,
0.5090671182,
-0.192529425,
-0.0075497432,
-0.0855525285,
-0.5837673545,
-0.2346960604,
0.4854922891,
0.1240905449,
0.1044260636,
0.362713486,
0.5627672672,
0.140268743,
-0.1896146834,
-0.605309546,
-0.0144455424,
-0.1000206545,
1.0142525434,
-0.3542631567,
-0.0339702442,
-0.1312501878,
0.3873032033,
0.2832063138,
-0.2688546777,
0.9660731554,
-0.4260118008,
0.1893576682,
-0.4109823108,
-0.2043756396,
-0.6008371115,
0.2765543759,
-1.0826753378,
0.9191383123,
0.0526046939,
-0.6522596478,
0.2127904445,
-0.4108368754,
-0.4303523004,
-0.2169282138,
-0.2474732846,
-0.3027364612,
0.2320300937,
0.4460330904,
0.4005994201,
-0.1315821111,
0.4158599675,
-0.3867181242,
-0.0919319466,
0.7981419563,
-0.5538662672,
0.762344718,
0.1433568746,
-0.3645545244,
-0.1867749244,
-0.7894229293,
-0.2625652552,
-0.0392733701,
-0.0361874327,
-0.430005312,
-0.2024255395,
0.2393036634,
0.6291102171,
0.0007357597,
-0.8805908561,
0.0355926864,
-0.0962562039,
0.4275856614,
0.5667815208,
0.2006082088,
0.0669092536,
-0.4152483344,
0.2345006615,
0.2466008514,
0.3586640656,
-0.1339432001,
-0.573990047,
-0.738643527,
-0.1784800142,
0.5139020681,
0.7720738649,
-0.7535771728,
0.2480845004,
-0.2396951318,
-0.4687611461,
-0.6249838471,
0.1442539394,
0.4708537757,
0.5899432898,
0.4412668347,
-0.1452661902,
-0.2029338926,
-1.4920870066,
-0.8061239719,
0.1998503655,
0.091900304,
0.0168488268,
0.6111671329,
-0.236632064,
1.0201185942,
-0.4315642715,
-0.3783714771,
0.2933157086,
0.7075207829,
0.0350695811,
0.1155841723,
0.6540513039,
-1.2875729799,
-0.3270052969,
-0.112824887,
-0.5269659758,
-0.1083814502,
-0.0819706991,
0.0713674575,
0.339684248,
0.4346770942,
-0.189705506,
0.4420442879,
0.3969813287,
-0.2433125079,
0.525249362,
0.0850668997,
0.4099413455,
-0.8291936517,
-0.0261165928,
0.4742339849,
-0.2443891019,
-0.5548678041,
-0.5290010571,
0.2520274222,
-0.06063262,
-0.7740413547,
0.8124886155,
-0.4145974517,
0.344479233,
-0.3206375539,
0.3082536757,
0.4009209871,
0.2641403377,
0.1138883457,
0.3202543557,
0.4107180536,
-0.482665658,
0.531699419,
-0.0374251343,
-0.1551407874,
0.5457223654,
-0.4886173308,
0.115689531,
-0.400593847,
0.6302397847,
-0.7815132737,
-0.5653778911,
0.5383853912,
-0.7718153596,
-0.1412985623,
0.085524261,
-0.7712771893,
-0.4923076928,
-0.2428233325,
0.1095035151,
0.013086739,
-0.3411579728,
0.4415765703,
0.4316356778,
0.0452362075,
-0.7453156114,
-0.8993793726,
0.0619974658,
0.0080499304,
-0.3250434697,
0.2653865516,
0.2602261901,
-0.3581591845,
0.4750129282,
-0.1817250848,
-0.2481832951,
-0.2689034045,
0.3930326402,
-0.0817814916,
-0.0817228481,
0.379218787,
0.1134112403,
0.0708481073,
-0.0059596188,
-0.4264806807,
0.0334243067,
-0.3162471652,
-0.0123601044,
-0.4225603938,
0.2839706838,
0.4345058203,
-0.2067078948,
0.8603485823,
0.7770459652,
-0.6188877821,
-0.4599775672,
-0.7457271218,
-0.2448823899,
-0.3226052523,
0.0348596536,
-0.2957111001,
-0.488825053,
0.3683252037,
0.0052849492,
-0.2105201036,
0.796540916,
0.3001495004,
-0.0414801277,
0.5300194025,
0.5064676404,
-0.1738381088,
0.0072836475,
-0.2105915844,
0.147905305,
-0.2593752444,
-0.3268447518,
-0.6669074297,
-0.3146798313,
-0.3353984058,
-0.48736462,
0.2452709824,
0.2126055211,
-0.0789299011,
0.2669249773,
-0.6971273422,
0.4156031311,
0.7212510109,
0.1481822133,
0.4424457252,
0.3291560113,
0.3370446861,
0.0641139001,
-0.603993535,
-0.7114403248,
0.8846206069,
0.3008170724,
0.4433045685,
0.0065634008,
0.2610482872,
0.6727056503,
0.9314604402,
-0.5412352681,
0.1098174378,
-0.2457916439,
-1.0413948298,
-0.0345457643,
-0.3843257427,
-0.540145278,
0.1727854013,
-0.2115482986,
-0.9073783159,
0.4883810878,
0.193939209,
-0.4496599734,
0.1686758697,
-0.6544845104,
0.836935699,
-0.5314255953,
-0.1431613564,
0.1405586004,
-0.5470837951,
0.4960054457,
-0.5239477158,
0.64885813,
-0.1026545539,
-0.2336814851,
0.7984359264,
-0.0640009269,
1.0092351437,
0.2119854689,
0.0844612271,
0.3230370581,
-0.2391880155,
0.1252906919,
0.2167493701,
-0.0648612529,
0.6715321541,
-0.1061692685,
-0.4220092893,
-0.4315581918,
0.8234223723,
-1.0437825918,
-0.1662284136,
-0.7255539894,
-0.1712824255,
-0.2640320659,
0.1985246092,
0.7723343372,
0.5489621758,
-0.3004204333,
0.214505747,
0.5206036568,
-0.3335440159,
0.2295381129,
0.5043078065,
-0.2209840268,
-0.6257504821,
1.2721806765,
0.5440440774,
-0.0743418708,
0.4038965106,
0.1381336004,
-0.4269440174,
0.2771194279,
-0.5140382051,
0.4377060831,
-0.6023301482,
-0.1082623824,
-1.0143420696,
-0.4404285252,
-0.5605116487,
-0.022257451,
-0.510266602,
-0.3942095041,
-0.3609684706,
-0.1354871243,
0.2173673064,
0.7143264413,
0.0255929511,
0.4771772027,
-0.8417155147,
0.7562459111,
-0.0064919707,
0.1562999934,
-0.5851604342,
-0.3364262879,
-0.0979677811,
0.3718971014,
-0.4725044072,
-1.373329401,
0.2543850243,
-0.1146821305,
0.6474074125,
0.5470499396,
0.3810180724,
-0.1532396674,
-0.1585660428,
0.665468514,
0.155872643,
-0.9886390567,
0.5395145416,
-0.5490395427,
-0.0528062545,
0.4424690604,
0.9142639637,
-0.453922987,
-0.3638348877,
-1.0340081453,
-0.6751816869,
0.6923663616,
0.3478176892,
-0.1901215464,
0.1606690437,
0.2091670185,
0.4213373661,
0.6469861865,
-1.0015208721,
-0.5695538521,
-0.5140416622,
-0.1132344455,
-0.3551047444,
-0.1463265121,
-0.424911648,
-0.0934612378,
0.8952145576,
-0.0752525181,
0.1240981668,
0.2938640416,
-0.1937172711,
0.1914720088,
0.2306924015,
0.7705696821,
0.7954030037,
-0.0541421622,
0.3562785983,
-0.3516523242,
-0.3347171843,
0.2042172104,
0.3000556529,
-0.4400220513,
0.4633062482,
0.2869110703,
0.9477226734,
-0.1549592465,
-0.5582771301,
0.4955618382,
0.1191454083,
-0.3642528355,
-0.5085781217,
-0.147104606,
-0.0627442002,
-0.0316101871,
0.4761025906,
0.3847658038,
0.2223610282,
-0.6679440141,
0.4160926342,
-0.0215812083,
-0.8222451806,
-0.3573349416,
0.6303751469,
0.3079605997,
-0.3850755692,
0.3611054122,
-0.3456631601,
-0.6920750141,
0.6779782176,
0.0621253066,
0.7017028332,
-0.25426355,
0.8981171846,
0.2058617771,
0.8812304735,
-0.3784992993,
-0.0430370942,
0.4838749766,
-0.8240967989,
-0.3260694742,
-0.6467269063,
0.0555463582,
0.5536480546,
-0.4591155648,
0.3589372039,
-0.1162366718,
-0.2705962658,
0.3331617415,
-0.3764805794,
-0.6564929485,
0.4858679473,
0.2395195663,
0.8314483166,
-1.1364153624,
0.7615790963,
1.0057358742,
-0.3446612954,
-0.4517425299,
0.2817402482,
0.4340876937,
-0.0932289734,
0.5705394745,
0.4262490869,
0.0619126149,
-0.1055824831,
-0.5317830443,
-0.6720530391,
0.3951967061,
0.4250684977,
-0.7928901315,
0.3697404861,
0.2880497575,
0.3992411196,
-0.258556217,
0.0415167585,
0.2594569027,
0.7997382879,
-0.3539297581,
-0.6819286942,
-0.0077271592,
-0.1407629102,
-0.4865659773,
0.1429272741,
-0.9254781604,
0.7419571877,
0.1591020077,
-0.0871202946,
-0.6297376752,
0.6177641153,
-0.2906484008,
0.7372108698,
0.5825760961,
0.6579172015,
0.7174525261,
-0.2617141008,
1.0863002539,
-0.1484995186,
0.3495991528,
1.2263766527,
0.1423879117,
0.5008897781,
0.1521478593,
0.3233273625,
0.4758128226,
0.6349056363,
-0.0405409932,
0.1953557879,
0.1998746544,
-0.1082188115,
-0.2593104243,
-0.185612902,
-0.2086054087,
0.406276077,
0.5426006913,
-0.5328500271,
-0.3462546468,
0.5859628916,
0.0680767521,
0.1428451985,
-0.3038495183,
0.3501682281,
0.32085675,
-0.527844131,
0.250406146,
0.2745608985,
0.2309531271,
-0.1537432373,
0.0366648547,
0.0949184969,
0.084776409,
-0.2090133429,
-0.661560595,
0.1242332235,
-0.1480355263,
-0.5346384645,
-0.1782567948,
0.7684397697,
-0.3039280176,
-0.7223725915,
0.3284228146,
0.6911935806,
0.0399712175,
-0.7796603441,
-0.7266383171,
0.148589313,
-0.0921267346,
-0.4354266822,
0.0260645486,
0.5398123264,
-0.4184045196,
0.4454260468,
0.5032260418,
-0.0295380596,
0.1557432562,
-0.0718561038,
0.735276103,
-0.7040405273,
-0.4192499816,
-0.6054058075,
0.5280246735,
-0.5181540847,
-0.627413094,
0.8388772607,
0.6934689879,
0.8590455055,
-0.19694978,
1.1388655901,
-0.072182335,
0.580874145,
-0.3072595,
0.7755075693,
-0.7361391783,
-0.1182127073,
-0.1039175168,
-1.0445494652,
-0.0781511664,
0.1159288362,
-0.3248357773,
-0.1399782151,
0.7667962909,
0.7361600995,
-0.3501035273,
0.0918438137,
0.0924220532,
0.5198182464,
-0.0678558946,
-0.0579379126,
0.9160234332,
-0.2623375952,
0.4420397878,
-0.6267570257,
-0.3659234345,
-0.3766797781,
-0.7026311159,
-0.8316867948,
-0.7660395503,
-0.7358860373,
-0.6083805561,
0.1392812878,
0.3195838034,
0.7221071124,
-0.7277903557,
0.2997776866,
0.1835172623,
0.1562529355,
-0.2928511798,
-0.3609959185,
0.3328511417,
0.026617663,
-0.7789825797,
0.0765738711,
0.2788175046,
-0.2439655066,
-0.3970056474,
0.2411767393,
-0.0661862195,
0.3059949875,
0.502949357,
0.3821229339,
-0.946891427,
-0.2974469364,
-0.1728994846,
-0.3162299097,
-0.2776946723,
0.903434515,
-0.9422326684,
0.5117559433,
0.4724659622,
0.4429108202,
0.2569809556,
0.4056940973,
0.3135136068,
-1.0178552866,
0.3406357467,
0.206443131,
0.0432962514,
0.2610608339,
-0.5006519556,
0.3534752429,
0.7211617231,
-0.1884355545,
-0.7669402957,
0.0375335775,
-1.157299161,
-0.7366179824,
1.326910615,
0.1404672712,
-0.6071209908,
-0.4067348242,
-0.1758963168,
0.0848926157,
-0.6554976106,
0.5519446731,
0.8343362212,
-0.0322798155,
-0.0727099404,
-1.0658701658,
0.509381175,
-0.1389765441,
-0.7460876703,
-0.5003631711,
0.6928402781,
0.311049372,
0.6750587821,
0.5036147237,
0.1397904158,
0.0214079544,
0.1128121316,
0.2813339233,
-0.0661889538,
-0.8549526334,
0.057920929,
0.3999740183,
-0.6845543385,
-0.156365335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16087v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16087v1
|
LLMs as Compiler for Arabic Programming Language
| 2024-03-24T10:57:08 | 2024-03-24T10:57:08 |
Serry Sibaee, Omar Najar, Lahouri Ghouti, Anis Koubaa
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper we introduce APL (Arabic Programming Language) that uses Large
language models (LLM) as semi-compiler to covert Arabic text code to python
code then run the code. Designing a full pipeline from the structure of the APL
text then a prompt (using prompt engineering) then running the prodcued python
code using PyRunner. This project has a three parts first python library, a
playground with simple interface and this research paper.
|
[
-0.1542761475,
-0.5081089735,
0.3888641894,
0.1094318703,
0.0093206801,
0.1437803954,
-0.1149246246,
-0.0462637693,
-0.3438873887,
0.4122955501,
-0.3457241654,
-0.5758008361,
-0.4384747148,
0.3676156998,
-0.5836026669,
1.1717342138,
-0.5271761417,
-0.1888728142,
0.1386305243,
0.2417777479,
0.2507193685,
-0.5722011328,
-0.4679554403,
-0.2326137871,
0.1741960198,
0.406555146,
0.8686326146,
0.7697251439,
0.2525982857,
0.3723249435,
-0.1277991086,
-0.1711765379,
-0.0166617818,
0.177399531,
-0.0456153676,
-0.3869212866,
0.1126173884,
-0.2890253067,
0.5527290106,
0.3261766434,
-0.1148717552,
0.3985030055,
-0.3090765178,
0.8739531636,
-0.7443391085,
0.1632226855,
-0.0738287717,
-0.0149176009,
-0.2282203734,
0.1351270527,
-0.2890906632,
-0.5894116163,
-0.02937885,
-0.0720815808,
-0.2460709214,
0.1403239518,
0.4133282304,
0.4891110063,
-0.6918901801,
-0.8889676332,
-0.7269319296,
0.914078176,
-0.8541454673,
0.0168026499,
0.030489115,
0.3963778913,
-0.1904412955,
-1.3890744448,
-0.7278847098,
-0.2761156857,
0.1789580137,
-0.2105324417,
-0.071092926,
0.3272192776,
0.26455459,
0.630307734,
-0.3665419817,
-0.2426438034,
-0.5209106803,
-0.3335200548,
0.8280105591,
0.2688922286,
0.8537412882,
0.1104656756,
-0.035324268,
0.2567574382,
-0.9540259838,
-0.1157607883,
0.3299576044,
0.0898092166,
-0.2612397969,
0.9356187582,
-0.1327819824,
1.0000895262,
-0.5997084379,
-0.4316975474,
-0.0422272608,
-0.1058411077,
-0.110147275,
0.3136978745,
0.6204072237,
0.206862852,
0.489192307,
0.0769659653,
-0.2563972175,
0.261123091,
0.013501429,
-1.0565683842,
-0.5752789378,
0.4311035573,
-0.590359509,
0.0105799204,
0.0185941719,
-0.2626483738,
-0.2871629894,
-0.0698776096,
0.1590962112,
-0.2035401016,
-0.1007920951,
-0.0127482181,
-0.0332331248,
0.2259101123,
0.3270128667,
-0.3339417875,
0.145222038,
0.5422080755,
0.9516582489,
0.0089846663,
-0.5511597991,
-0.3602868617,
0.3128899336,
-0.2138505131,
0.4718305171,
-0.5171986222,
-0.2932031453,
0.4593092203,
-0.3348293304,
0.1622898728,
-0.3928923309,
0.6124876738,
-0.6887041926,
-0.0316616222,
0.5531626344,
-0.6992058158,
-0.3715635538,
-0.1803720146,
-0.5515371561,
0.9291264415,
0.218710348,
-0.8101037741,
-0.1685551554,
-0.7301186919,
-0.5428278446,
-0.0805486366,
-0.1649931371,
-0.5354911685,
0.0990483761,
0.0522182174,
0.0482625514,
-0.1882226318,
0.1413482428,
0.3241405487,
-0.6034315825,
0.4974822998,
-0.0238479376,
0.6852089763,
0.744527936,
-0.191368103,
0.3286453485,
-0.6463338137,
0.0101900287,
-0.3485959768,
-0.9681401849,
0.3321714401,
0.2668217421,
0.3854103386,
0.5318537951,
0.5967329144,
-0.5817428827,
0.3894470036,
-0.416739434,
0.6630325317,
0.6453568339,
-0.146205768,
0.2899919152,
-0.4686469436,
0.6036838889,
-0.2978812456,
-0.3802824318,
-0.279779762,
-0.7052609324,
-0.9442330599,
-0.429101944,
0.1156750768,
0.6051415205,
-0.658829093,
0.25280267,
0.2494270653,
-0.2960962653,
-0.5614306927,
0.4307313263,
0.342366904,
-0.0087561691,
0.0277867317,
0.4092488587,
-0.9082546234,
-0.7622618079,
-0.3163578212,
-0.5165625215,
-0.0111984061,
-0.0090023344,
0.5719993711,
-0.2534075379,
0.9368742704,
-0.3971443474,
0.0297693685,
-0.8969295025,
-0.0281572007,
0.9368034601,
0.4195376635,
0.038882222,
-0.5782538056,
-1.1074872017,
0.1274510622,
-0.3137745559,
-0.5926724076,
0.1936969757,
0.132719934,
0.3743853271,
0.4610921443,
-0.6921584606,
0.8360280395,
0.7509011626,
-0.4840803742,
0.8572683334,
-0.07527408,
-0.1393399984,
-0.9580637813,
0.0759218261,
-0.2171055973,
-0.1432224214,
-0.6165189147,
0.3126800954,
0.0789155215,
-0.3279636204,
-0.8996993303,
0.656891942,
-0.5599766374,
-0.076933071,
-0.5769326687,
-0.658808589,
-0.4011500478,
0.0422206372,
0.2170976847,
1.4688719511,
0.7445226312,
-0.7829580903,
0.8007612228,
0.138222158,
-0.5079331994,
-0.3505199254,
-0.6015502214,
0.2970932126,
0.1535370052,
0.1951982081,
-1.1205258369,
-0.179900974,
-0.0061451518,
-0.2565501034,
0.1250551343,
-0.3366199136,
-0.6092455983,
-0.5480992198,
-0.3664509654,
0.3910625279,
0.8345392942,
-0.4678685069,
0.4539491236,
0.0461450219,
-0.1483323276,
-0.3144542873,
-0.6258858442,
0.0608130358,
-0.2500990331,
-0.6285597682,
0.284316957,
-0.1133022681,
-0.4008929133,
-0.1617830396,
-0.1816741824,
-0.070861049,
-0.1454817057,
0.2369650304,
0.2543093562,
-0.2581931651,
-0.4034573138,
-0.0154665252,
-0.2090238482,
0.0926960334,
-0.2435442805,
0.7537540793,
-0.2105500549,
-0.3656991124,
-1.0184776783,
0.3468185663,
0.6519454122,
0.0681654736,
0.9244929552,
0.0530459844,
-0.2186084688,
-0.0473856777,
-0.3555856049,
0.3933032751,
-0.5902684927,
0.426900804,
-0.4222713113,
-0.838077426,
0.380404532,
-0.5478176475,
0.005331106,
0.1945318282,
1.2066643238,
0.127079621,
1.1057244539,
0.6148798466,
-0.4066646993,
0.285864383,
-0.2560591996,
0.2983612418,
-0.8124781251,
-0.121627517,
-0.6804835796,
-0.242354691,
-0.3141174018,
-0.2932212651,
0.3546545208,
0.3068001866,
-0.871832788,
0.1502180099,
-0.5225266814,
0.673127532,
0.4041819572,
-0.2974523008,
0.3231611848,
0.0222287495,
-0.2913625538,
0.0867992714,
-0.5205477476,
-1.0125974417,
1.2859342098,
0.3814607859,
1.1911002398,
0.2583282292,
1.0035932064,
0.4533581436,
0.2932877243,
-0.9187816381,
0.45293051,
0.1299529672,
-0.7059662342,
-0.0586993881,
-0.1358202845,
-0.5121397972,
0.0077693118,
0.4878852665,
-0.9319894314,
-0.2719084024,
-0.1483579576,
-0.3314813375,
0.3794081807,
-0.7655840516,
0.8012084961,
-0.2414640486,
-0.1702341288,
-0.04013272,
-0.5400103927,
0.1391562521,
0.1885588169,
0.2889987826,
0.1265754849,
-0.4533023238,
0.8042593598,
-0.8213208914,
0.6041767597,
0.0632998869,
-0.0824288502,
0.6289633512,
0.3125012815,
0.5175688267,
0.2081944048,
-0.3597872555,
-0.0556394905,
-0.0860653594,
-0.3155208826,
-0.2972123027,
0.6947441101,
-1.231793642,
-0.6073430181,
-0.9261000752,
-0.7146149874,
0.2420576513,
0.1506878287,
0.0375739187,
0.0223260205,
0.0901588872,
-0.2550072968,
0.1148951203,
-0.3533116877,
0.7401301861,
0.5784151554,
-0.6304095387,
-0.5498914123,
0.6575574279,
-0.3301300406,
-0.0134003544,
0.3945167959,
0.033522822,
-0.3632592857,
-0.9195184112,
-0.5499181151,
0.2609380186,
-0.6526494622,
-0.3920217156,
-0.3619067073,
-0.6125391722,
-0.2330203354,
-0.4756296575,
-0.3412682116,
-0.5694406033,
-0.2438539714,
0.2098627836,
0.4237747192,
1.0873646736,
0.0981178284,
0.6543941498,
-0.6377362013,
0.2625033557,
0.2929356694,
-0.0899683759,
-0.1770404875,
-0.4406576157,
-0.4086388052,
-0.0782676488,
-0.5295496583,
-1.0073113441,
0.6711931229,
0.5486859679,
0.4764868617,
0.4114345908,
0.099216789,
0.3414047956,
-0.6097670794,
0.9245901108,
0.1572668552,
-1.1884608269,
0.7683953047,
0.1849750131,
0.207092464,
0.1358974427,
0.3577628434,
-0.6730335951,
-0.3811300695,
-0.1391317695,
-0.6739294529,
0.9593818188,
0.4826492667,
0.0830902308,
-0.0525996462,
0.3560480475,
-0.0122660566,
0.2041850984,
-0.6168510914,
-0.6093202233,
-0.2001730502,
-0.2778648138,
-0.0232843719,
-0.468806386,
0.0247698743,
-0.5461775064,
0.5588582754,
0.0665378347,
0.3236020207,
0.0458850004,
-0.3622048497,
0.0980056599,
0.4185958207,
0.2534307241,
0.8239195943,
-0.1731555164,
0.3126934469,
-0.0459942967,
-0.5137101412,
0.5535186529,
-0.0343156978,
-0.1704575717,
-0.1581694186,
0.3896899521,
0.3689405024,
-0.5009516478,
-0.8954579234,
0.275013417,
0.2065136284,
0.1811151206,
-0.4005478323,
0.1258441359,
0.419582963,
0.3156705201,
0.7375156879,
-0.3905571401,
0.2384066284,
-0.6326694489,
0.1896056086,
0.0777068809,
0.0604410321,
-0.2372686118,
0.6896396875,
0.2397869974,
-0.6670736074,
0.7525932789,
-0.0921508148,
-1.0064982176,
0.718958199,
1.2224012613,
0.6290970445,
-0.4670052826,
0.0064144605,
0.1874053627,
0.1535238177,
0.1067657098,
0.6839668751,
-0.0705147907,
-0.5774992704,
-0.7055622339,
-0.9717539549,
-0.6244888306,
-0.1161374301,
-0.1017201617,
0.3522474468,
-0.8011558056,
0.142863214,
-0.3791799247,
0.1415490359,
-0.216966942,
0.1163716167,
0.3440046012,
1.0836371183,
-0.7579055429,
1.3513640165,
1.4624449015,
-0.2458508909,
-0.6460627913,
-0.0623679571,
0.1192775518,
-0.849776566,
1.1058217287,
0.2783599198,
0.0901277512,
0.2380561084,
-0.5012062788,
-0.7304977775,
0.8932955861,
0.2815239131,
-0.3464006186,
0.1169888824,
0.3360990882,
0.2508572042,
-0.638189435,
0.5016987324,
0.5788276196,
0.2549716234,
0.2941669822,
-1.015395999,
0.004890027,
-0.4836945534,
0.4949344397,
0.2438959926,
-0.5194061995,
1.2343808413,
-0.2705325782,
-0.1728375256,
0.5383187532,
0.8455766439,
0.5291534662,
0.1920620501,
-0.2402292639,
0.458512038,
0.374499619,
0.2249046862,
0.99630934,
-0.8286286592,
0.43021819,
0.5373509526,
-0.3238661587,
0.7403954864,
0.6580317616,
-0.8973572254,
0.7059293389,
0.4948252439,
0.4514808655,
0.4851146936,
0.5099990964,
-0.7846035361,
-0.0520400368,
0.0704382583,
-0.4954137802,
0.1676769257,
0.5810776353,
-0.3902848363,
-0.2553566694,
-0.3287549019,
0.1227417141,
-0.0349571072,
-0.3226502538,
0.519515276,
0.2692036033,
-0.2820190191,
0.709977746,
0.4535476863,
0.839807868,
-0.4946611822,
-0.0620828308,
-0.2292360514,
0.335706979,
-0.4318584204,
-0.9165194035,
0.6487139463,
0.1895339638,
-0.0331765898,
0.115695864,
0.7602428794,
-0.1880440116,
-0.6498547196,
-0.159871161,
0.2938381732,
0.4441815913,
-0.1020179689,
-0.7744325399,
0.3359897435,
0.2093907893,
-0.2513950467,
0.1783045083,
0.3887761533,
0.1538357586,
1.0801670551,
0.7867544889,
0.3111305237,
0.3108949661,
-0.3754133582,
1.1915740967,
-0.8092483878,
-0.4954388738,
-1.2572410107,
0.400049001,
0.2433081716,
0.0085515687,
0.8736410737,
0.998883903,
0.5426876545,
-0.2904785872,
1.0894292593,
-0.3775237203,
0.3768269122,
-0.4552634358,
0.9352813959,
-0.140593946,
0.3606657684,
-0.1568035334,
-1.1269513369,
-0.3666526377,
1.2284634113,
-0.1391929835,
-0.1020745933,
0.9126278758,
0.8232449889,
0.1634977013,
-0.3476394117,
0.2025346756,
-0.0696821883,
0.2645514905,
1.0053832531,
1.3696168661,
-0.2587347925,
0.6636568308,
-0.3511289954,
-0.3581708074,
-0.0927969664,
-0.9033857584,
-1.1924906969,
-0.1241304353,
-0.5517510176,
-0.6796702743,
0.1116975993,
0.9449828863,
0.3695718944,
-1.0824631453,
-0.8753229976,
-0.2648995221,
0.4787698984,
0.1576781571,
-0.1735484749,
0.4668788314,
-0.2034184039,
-0.749563098,
0.0492365174,
0.2758758366,
-0.1840971112,
-0.2787504792,
-0.6483956575,
-0.3159791529,
-0.1933951229,
0.2742706835,
0.5581460595,
-0.6814925075,
0.1883274615,
-0.5828790069,
-0.0101622138,
0.0428788923,
0.9799006581,
-0.6695970893,
0.135115698,
0.5270053148,
0.5875777006,
0.498978436,
-0.1783169657,
0.6983082294,
-0.3481479883,
0.4280564487,
0.1307067275,
0.3190364242,
0.1663327515,
-0.2912832797,
0.2648031116,
0.0324010663,
-0.8551720977,
-0.67383641,
0.4486838579,
-0.4783583879,
-0.1785286814,
1.3464276791,
-0.3494444191,
-0.3763337135,
-0.4681456685,
-0.8097168803,
0.3511441946,
-0.5131338835,
0.6336788535,
0.8049084544,
-0.408161819,
-0.4008933604,
-0.3939674795,
0.5660148859,
0.1241436526,
-0.4496060014,
-0.3432572782,
0.413808465,
0.2371690869,
0.0363282301,
0.5657303333,
-0.0183078181,
0.3932130933,
-0.0480395779,
0.2916561663,
-0.2512739599,
-0.1729666889,
-0.1149129122,
0.0265157409,
0.5877010226,
-0.1876383871
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16084v1
|
Argument Quality Assessment in the Age of Instruction-Following Large Language Models
| 2024-03-24T10:43:21 | 2024-03-24T10:43:21 |
Henning Wachsmuth, Gabriella Lapesa, Elena Cabrio, Anne Lauscher, Joonsuk Park, Eva Maria Vecchi, Serena Villata, Timon Ziegenbein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The computational treatment of arguments on controversial issues has been
subject to extensive NLP research, due to its envisioned impact on opinion
formation, decision making, writing education, and the like. A critical task in
any such application is the assessment of an argument's quality - but it is
also particularly challenging. In this position paper, we start from a brief
survey of argument quality research, where we identify the diversity of quality
notions and the subjectiveness of their perception as the main hurdles towards
substantial progress on argument quality assessment. We argue that the
capabilities of instruction-following large language models (LLMs) to leverage
knowledge across contexts enable a much more reliable assessment. Rather than
just fine-tuning LLMs towards leaderboard chasing on assessment tasks, they
need to be instructed systematically with argumentation theories and scenarios
as well as with ways to solve argument-related problems. We discuss the
real-world opportunities and ethical issues emerging thereby.
|
[
-0.3359280825,
-0.9866066575,
0.6610824466,
-0.0395150483,
-0.1179487705,
0.2208343148,
-0.0557323396,
-0.3285658956,
-0.3398813903,
0.2381623983,
-0.2746618092,
-0.22740601,
-0.812525928,
-0.2278323323,
-0.3177537024,
0.8206081986,
-0.1494983584,
0.3350629807,
-0.4160569012,
-0.2684341371,
-0.5078282356,
-0.5543311834,
-0.9153903127,
-0.2563254833,
0.4960478842,
0.4129490554,
0.579890132,
0.4972862601,
0.3203057051,
0.3920721412,
-0.2858999968,
-0.0491059683,
-0.3626078665,
0.3213312626,
-0.4484309256,
-0.1396215409,
-0.3375415802,
0.2555435598,
0.7819465399,
0.9536239505,
-0.1895474643,
0.0542266592,
-0.0325923413,
0.8019278049,
-0.5063762069,
-0.257094413,
-0.5718045235,
0.2277850956,
0.0561288446,
-0.06861265,
-0.3979948461,
-0.5458468795,
0.5403122902,
-0.1625789404,
-0.2873025835,
-0.0375228785,
1.0051643848,
0.0434027687,
-0.4131461978,
-0.6111265421,
-0.707079947,
0.9279845357,
-0.9837359786,
0.3087550104,
0.0711045042,
0.2648349702,
-0.2627794147,
-0.9912387133,
-0.2634980679,
-0.2661770582,
0.5035923123,
0.071083948,
-0.2364640087,
0.0180689041,
0.1527928114,
0.3727820218,
-0.263097614,
0.4670363367,
-0.3501725495,
0.0080297086,
0.6810138226,
0.1689902842,
0.2044010013,
-0.2346097529,
-0.3375727832,
-0.0433709845,
-0.6256310344,
0.1878333092,
0.6329916716,
-0.0687315762,
0.2950473726,
0.348136127,
0.1381928474,
0.8056385517,
0.1306402087,
0.1377214789,
-0.3398527801,
-0.1531459093,
-0.2739955783,
-0.1026858538,
0.7918499708,
0.2157426029,
0.1076343358,
0.1944792569,
0.0206526183,
-0.1333527118,
0.4704309106,
-0.8428093195,
-0.0829527155,
0.4220392704,
-0.491437763,
-0.1652664393,
-0.0696422607,
-1.1770051718,
-0.4146307111,
-0.4121385217,
0.2288690358,
-0.3090475202,
-0.1174105257,
0.1200599074,
0.1846485883,
0.3576526344,
0.4436593652,
-0.8816043735,
0.2949638367,
1.0110434294,
0.471175909,
-0.3658219278,
-0.0717319995,
-0.4560147822,
-0.3251371682,
-0.8552981615,
1.0899186134,
-0.8594335914,
-0.3347793519,
0.0101919435,
-0.0739864558,
-0.0048788893,
-0.6672937274,
0.9546841383,
-0.5123150349,
0.5338835716,
-0.3213658035,
-1.0896103382,
-0.3836921751,
0.4411619604,
-0.3138030767,
0.8224381804,
0.0750906393,
-0.3322564662,
0.3719874918,
-0.7570567131,
-0.2469117343,
0.2182860821,
-0.1496358067,
-0.2159904838,
0.2779368758,
0.0764207765,
0.5416935682,
-0.3088664114,
0.4238565564,
-0.1986133158,
-0.1074087322,
0.3738406301,
-0.6873032451,
0.6999681592,
0.0920254812,
-0.3587531149,
0.0671642721,
-0.5105250478,
0.3251304626,
0.0305319931,
-0.1891002804,
-0.3031489253,
0.4231044054,
-0.4747273922,
0.1506294459,
0.1722477973,
-0.3249492347,
0.1519416273,
-0.5110092163,
0.6346068382,
0.8969172835,
0.1612347364,
0.1788076013,
-0.1980243921,
0.6207596064,
-0.2548913658,
0.3944893777,
0.0321103111,
-0.5881432891,
-0.7574615479,
0.3257966638,
0.6350268126,
0.3490585387,
-0.2797842026,
0.1955052912,
0.0254434459,
-0.5836930275,
-0.485467732,
0.1524281949,
0.104031086,
0.3146660924,
0.2562598288,
-0.1964854449,
-0.2765192389,
-0.6762979627,
-0.2689749897,
-0.45613873,
0.3105251789,
0.2979029715,
0.4448805153,
0.0439614914,
0.7963878512,
-0.1342448294,
0.1907551885,
-0.1432843655,
0.2717505693,
0.0144151114,
0.6383276582,
0.2949778438,
-0.5522974133,
-0.3295422792,
-0.1837737709,
-0.6259363294,
-0.1081036031,
-0.1748689264,
-0.1817635298,
0.1404349357,
0.4689388573,
-0.2764965296,
-0.1227781847,
0.5385132432,
-0.308878392,
0.7662947774,
0.0161720105,
0.2375770211,
-0.8871238232,
-0.2375657707,
0.0868097469,
0.0797370449,
-0.5740190744,
0.2425828129,
-0.4238090217,
-0.1928256154,
-0.4770195782,
0.5334333181,
-0.2289768606,
0.284832269,
-0.4102208018,
0.1433422267,
0.1409117877,
-0.0042564226,
-0.0587380789,
0.6341993213,
0.3464672863,
-0.2793537378,
0.3184109926,
-0.1720786691,
-0.5497322679,
0.9132572412,
-0.6470009089,
0.3503684103,
0.1363956332,
0.0354090817,
-0.735861659,
-0.1382438391,
0.1700492054,
-0.2670112848,
0.2969277501,
-0.32036677,
-0.1183924004,
-0.2565570474,
-0.2895038724,
0.2471070439,
0.5131063461,
-0.5287629962,
0.6268181801,
0.3847461641,
-0.4182925522,
-1.0160845518,
-0.2486241758,
0.3917454779,
-0.4276739955,
-0.4980518222,
0.181486696,
-0.130049333,
-0.6802087426,
0.0629406869,
-0.1285356432,
-0.3736341,
0.2116473317,
0.1993521154,
0.1488762796,
-0.505681932,
0.1285716891,
0.3416520655,
-0.0698268712,
0.4491565824,
-0.1179822907,
0.2944917381,
-0.2890301347,
-0.5532252192,
-0.2265592515,
0.6324495077,
0.4883657396,
0.0199004654,
0.4050264657,
0.3640971482,
-0.3706924319,
-0.3852488697,
-0.7160726786,
-0.0567021593,
-0.472045064,
0.3927849829,
0.0143262483,
-0.9890525937,
0.1342141777,
-0.350851059,
0.4978513718,
0.5266704559,
0.4333491623,
-0.3794002533,
0.9254701138,
0.1936735213,
0.2288251519,
0.3086174726,
-0.2683622539,
0.4534960985,
-0.8521623015,
0.0689624995,
-0.5803346038,
-0.230625093,
-0.1798689216,
-0.5535324216,
-0.0045478479,
0.2505261898,
-0.3579265177,
-0.3050846457,
-0.5522921681,
0.5705593228,
0.2189896405,
-0.2571538985,
0.0883785337,
-0.1023587957,
0.0363348275,
-0.3912388682,
-0.6904418468,
-1.0759884119,
0.6262611151,
0.6475931406,
0.5289822221,
-0.0906114802,
0.529022038,
0.4157116711,
0.5804299116,
-1.1008342505,
0.7255192399,
-0.2660267353,
-0.6142487526,
-0.1858644336,
-0.4810784161,
-0.9374245405,
0.2609411478,
-0.1748459041,
-0.7431188226,
0.1929478049,
0.1004115865,
-0.4260389209,
0.459777236,
-0.6584641933,
1.077819109,
-0.4261777103,
-0.6650567055,
-0.1778243184,
-0.3183222413,
0.4382327795,
0.1816558838,
0.1477619559,
-0.1983910799,
0.2103796005,
1.2697572708,
-0.2252471298,
0.6436998844,
-0.1755761355,
-0.4272179306,
0.8573355675,
0.1492238641,
-0.0152614536,
-0.1550253481,
-0.0798710659,
0.0162864942,
0.2821062207,
-0.216359973,
-0.7121536136,
0.6951897144,
-0.6656275392,
-1.0254507065,
-0.4190604389,
-0.298566848,
-0.2945302725,
-0.1936949342,
-0.0992132127,
0.4863301516,
-0.2692970932,
0.3138845265,
0.715939045,
-0.3357747197,
0.2837949991,
0.2477855682,
0.018170001,
-0.3718468547,
1.2503371239,
0.4277101755,
0.2009751946,
-0.1972026378,
0.6909208894,
-0.4910686612,
-0.8134557605,
-0.6912543774,
0.033504732,
-1.1880642176,
-0.1451695263,
-0.5267580748,
-0.2647643983,
0.0058354246,
-0.3813327551,
-0.6713672876,
-0.2880187631,
-0.3873620331,
-0.0858538225,
-0.0228959434,
0.7638370991,
0.1512241215,
0.1040020734,
-0.6837974787,
-0.123955287,
0.7216066122,
0.3125436008,
0.322316438,
-0.7568623424,
0.0929839984,
0.0291335657,
-0.6608009338,
-0.7873949409,
-0.0689307675,
0.0363515019,
0.5769851804,
0.610003233,
-0.0018141854,
0.5476574898,
-0.364954561,
1.3322530985,
0.0153349126,
-1.0427718163,
0.3051267862,
0.0637662858,
-0.0581511445,
0.4862041175,
0.5559725165,
-0.4467942715,
-0.2446273863,
-0.6508793831,
-0.7987516522,
0.2949611545,
-0.3656839728,
0.3483029902,
-0.0880905688,
0.4828031659,
0.1811767966,
-0.1218476743,
-0.6822357774,
0.3075118363,
-0.2604103386,
-0.2113039196,
0.4120303094,
-0.5135228634,
-0.361322701,
-0.3652588129,
0.5274838209,
-0.0801415667,
0.1349395812,
-0.0478462018,
0.194645226,
-0.0881511271,
0.7317509651,
0.7551503778,
1.0485916138,
0.1437581182,
0.1212127209,
0.3090243042,
-0.2360837907,
0.5058939457,
-0.0936498046,
0.0065061869,
-0.1989159584,
0.5302426815,
0.7120426297,
0.0016155482,
-0.6627926826,
0.4395722151,
0.0939867571,
-0.3516653478,
-0.1135206148,
0.2573697567,
0.2020297199,
0.2655135095,
0.3026677072,
-0.2481322438,
-0.0726462528,
-0.5944206119,
0.0064252685,
0.4763670266,
-0.6922625899,
-0.0594385304,
0.3641654849,
0.2012021244,
-0.3918669224,
0.4362144768,
0.085396193,
-0.602370739,
0.7697620988,
0.3920974731,
0.7366076708,
-0.316922605,
0.201431945,
0.3000630736,
0.2755087316,
-0.2317661345,
0.1246672571,
0.2371256649,
-0.6285709143,
-0.7639575005,
-0.4385187924,
-0.9466226101,
0.3127636909,
-0.4153204262,
-0.112985611,
-0.7432745099,
-0.2916865647,
-0.090480268,
0.1540730298,
-0.1106201336,
0.2273844928,
0.0585718341,
0.6892812848,
-0.7743335962,
0.4026843011,
0.8007141352,
-0.0212110132,
-0.4983256459,
-0.0044162255,
-0.2532049417,
-0.3087619543,
0.6606839895,
-0.0146459891,
-0.2626718581,
-0.1868485659,
-0.8444167972,
-0.3705872297,
0.4040276408,
0.3815865815,
-0.4346767068,
0.1082275957,
-0.2446078807,
0.7164388299,
-0.4113153517,
0.1989052147,
0.4441322684,
0.5474582911,
-0.082439445,
-0.2095590085,
-0.1263768524,
-0.0246777087,
-0.1915739477,
-0.2316673696,
-0.4671552181,
0.6343548298,
-0.1633530259,
-0.2282160521,
-0.0930821523,
1.0415527821,
0.1743920147,
0.3523126841,
0.4099328518,
0.3600142002,
0.5085732341,
-0.1799826771,
0.8662894964,
-0.0746121183,
0.1964410841,
0.9861667752,
-0.333902657,
1.0248852968,
0.4464422464,
-0.2241279632,
0.6905206442,
0.8850305676,
-0.031768322,
-0.1228023022,
0.4613725245,
-0.1499790847,
-0.4602347612,
-0.2440342754,
-0.2900964916,
0.5328815579,
0.7194722891,
-0.1577981412,
-0.1280295551,
-0.1645731181,
0.1003199071,
0.4763579965,
-0.1445916444,
0.6536426544,
0.0512133129,
-0.803994,
0.5377002954,
0.0940225795,
0.5016112924,
-0.4062492251,
-0.395303756,
-0.0971038267,
-0.3078067005,
-0.021138696,
-1.0737621784,
0.2295663804,
0.175895825,
0.1057548895,
0.0076821619,
0.5611758828,
-0.0699894354,
-0.3663029373,
0.2109569013,
0.6048356891,
0.0779378489,
0.4207192361,
-0.968298316,
0.3587815762,
-0.3632616401,
-0.443254292,
0.3148206472,
0.3693390787,
-0.0282581113,
0.6435664296,
0.5027656555,
0.1665113419,
0.1813797057,
-0.0226507615,
0.6196498871,
-0.3387246728,
-0.0301203709,
-0.958075285,
0.4267974496,
-0.2303134948,
-0.5397830009,
0.4307193756,
0.1074417904,
0.504789412,
0.3080667555,
0.4195748866,
0.0473461002,
0.3493098021,
-0.6132994294,
0.6964988708,
-0.4866196513,
0.0215135198,
-0.4509905875,
-0.9013149738,
-0.2139033526,
0.8643473983,
-0.3909851909,
0.1805606037,
0.7974414229,
0.2726122737,
-0.0773668215,
0.3037188947,
0.2614771128,
0.1026814058,
0.5261009932,
0.4809254408,
1.4437537193,
-0.3883602023,
0.2273046076,
-0.0788231939,
-0.140122816,
-0.0765459612,
-1.1173919439,
-0.814963758,
-0.5348291993,
-0.6341056824,
-0.4758507609,
0.122421436,
1.1328877211,
0.5599960089,
-0.8083463907,
-0.3535279036,
0.2488085926,
0.3586907089,
-0.3800408244,
-0.237640366,
0.6495819688,
-0.4238470793,
-0.7360810041,
0.5918869972,
0.1631662399,
-0.1588809937,
-0.4958395362,
0.0091904141,
-0.304392308,
0.5694114566,
0.8652888536,
0.4928628206,
-0.7903704047,
-0.5763713717,
-0.364708215,
-0.0206619166,
0.2088444382,
0.7962605357,
-0.2031057924,
0.6162530184,
0.3116607964,
1.2172915936,
-0.1815125048,
0.084987253,
0.5144948363,
-0.1762801409,
-0.3324378133,
0.5750304461,
0.3655222356,
0.4847200811,
0.013763696,
0.3084806204,
0.175070852,
-0.712146163,
-1.0290467739,
0.0642715394,
-0.878791213,
-0.4308155775,
1.1103384495,
-0.4585497975,
-0.1417224258,
-0.0913185179,
-0.2535148859,
-0.1283192635,
-0.2240314931,
1.0463594198,
1.1243755817,
-0.1322928965,
-0.3645114899,
-0.8677647114,
0.4359592497,
0.8534114361,
-1.0428621769,
0.2421376407,
0.509983182,
0.0958506986,
0.2477779537,
0.1965857297,
-0.3041837513,
0.2735020816,
0.0038318527,
-0.1771325916,
0.1666571647,
-0.4768080413,
-0.3853135705,
0.6203624606,
0.4537457526,
0.1302527487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2404.07954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2404.07954v1
|
An efficient domain-independent approach for supervised keyphrase extraction and ranking
| 2024-03-24T08:33:27 | 2024-03-24T08:33:27 |
Sriraghavendra Ramaswamy
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.3.1; I.2.7
|
We present a supervised learning approach for automatic extraction of
keyphrases from single documents. Our solution uses simple to compute
statistical and positional features of candidate phrases and does not rely on
any external knowledge base or on pre-trained language models or word
embeddings. The ranking component of our proposed solution is a fairly
lightweight ensemble model. Evaluation on benchmark datasets shows that our
approach achieves significantly higher accuracy than several state-of-the-art
baseline models, including all deep learning-based unsupervised models compared
with, and is competitive with some supervised deep learning-based models too.
Despite the supervised nature of our solution, the fact that does not rely on
any corpus of "golden" keywords or any external knowledge corpus means that our
solution bears the advantages of unsupervised solutions to a fair extent.
|
[
0.1569777429,
-0.3744048178,
0.5516183972,
0.1730426997,
-0.4875423014,
0.1932093352,
-0.2922124267,
0.1118384153,
0.2050886452,
0.9055696726,
-0.2164238393,
-0.9175277948,
-0.9643785357,
0.2316480726,
-0.6959542036,
0.9230151176,
0.3837895989,
0.0529738218,
-0.2630771399,
-0.0291888621,
0.0260664262,
-0.5287837982,
-0.2644710541,
-0.0180339534,
0.2486937642,
0.4604865909,
0.4112576246,
0.7138004303,
1.0689501762,
0.2730197012,
0.0117591145,
0.0791532621,
-0.1627116054,
0.5592234135,
-0.2049425095,
-0.2591508925,
-0.2215741426,
0.2599338591,
0.3006257117,
0.8128554821,
0.1037051976,
-0.05989879,
0.2423986793,
0.6755628586,
-0.5903029442,
0.2077423632,
-1.092959404,
-0.0332855918,
-0.4788572788,
-0.28676036,
-0.4289465249,
-0.4281349778,
0.1783992797,
-0.7358129025,
0.5449253917,
-0.154993251,
0.484991312,
0.1750631183,
-0.4226702452,
-0.4471500218,
-0.0032855654,
0.7170457244,
-0.4668860137,
0.2177458853,
0.2637572587,
0.0264511313,
-0.0564973168,
-1.2104518414,
-0.1089208052,
-0.024789758,
-0.0611188896,
0.2786766887,
0.1889848411,
0.2446693182,
-0.211516425,
0.2096131295,
-0.7053022385,
-0.0254954305,
-0.4264044464,
-0.0375976413,
0.7982000113,
-0.2156512141,
0.0764627904,
-0.5283178687,
-0.1561891735,
-0.3031513095,
-0.4014870524,
0.0127948793,
0.1244414002,
0.8253645301,
0.2959010601,
0.5392496586,
-0.4270762205,
0.1395263225,
0.1946151406,
-0.091639325,
0.2017809004,
-0.1883544922,
-0.0437663384,
0.2485449612,
0.953379631,
0.103808552,
0.4014345109,
-0.9289286137,
-0.1407105178,
0.0333586708,
0.4752064049,
-0.8023641109,
-0.7617242336,
0.2721876204,
-0.5486422777,
-0.8506319523,
0.3854773641,
-1.0102931261,
-0.2333595604,
0.0563854724,
0.630158186,
-0.4752202034,
0.2021553069,
-0.2428359389,
-0.735245645,
-0.2084075212,
0.0087780897,
-0.785349369,
0.3262249231,
0.7976602912,
0.8573225737,
-0.8321791291,
-0.1023672074,
-0.4017546773,
0.072272189,
-0.4165421426,
0.7013921738,
-0.7831574082,
-0.7309607267,
0.1119747385,
0.26179111,
-0.3634436429,
-0.598315835,
1.1384905577,
-0.7549108267,
0.1865760833,
0.1069765463,
-0.9074040055,
-0.13815552,
-0.174083069,
-0.616268158,
0.7623049021,
-0.1525877118,
-0.7798498869,
0.4054042995,
-0.886882782,
-0.7994899154,
0.3940717876,
-0.1242117509,
-0.4004235566,
0.2953975499,
0.5352922082,
0.5082231164,
0.0682111531,
0.1799242496,
-0.2928548455,
-0.200492397,
0.0793606117,
-0.2647604942,
0.9730488658,
0.3842630982,
-0.3002302349,
-0.203772828,
-0.6898797154,
0.5018652678,
0.3010985851,
-0.267388761,
-0.7731286287,
-0.0079963822,
0.2055851966,
-0.1460704058,
0.4872536361,
-0.5510164499,
0.4616265595,
-0.3918350041,
0.2482694983,
0.7178524733,
0.4654405415,
0.678417325,
0.014079175,
0.4866240621,
-0.2544752359,
-0.1167303622,
0.1247026548,
-0.4374523163,
-0.2001543194,
-0.8301448226,
0.6917077303,
0.6082987785,
-0.37703982,
0.5343295336,
-0.5236611366,
-0.4408896267,
-0.5478016734,
0.565939784,
0.2419484258,
0.2356831431,
0.3517747819,
-0.3542800844,
-0.2953629196,
-0.6093802452,
-0.4063625336,
0.1358795613,
-0.0078330422,
-0.1155671701,
0.6406907439,
0.0177258253,
1.0006457567,
-0.6970531344,
-0.6472465992,
-0.2029979676,
0.4681840539,
0.2830478847,
0.4412530065,
0.1800899655,
-1.2416696548,
-0.658157289,
-0.0779013634,
-1.1612163782,
-0.3160928786,
0.1670725644,
0.006024661,
-0.2710258365,
0.546019733,
-0.5876850486,
0.1412271857,
0.098291263,
0.2008089125,
-0.1313427538,
-0.219207719,
0.2389267683,
-1.0035327673,
0.2629950941,
0.0923648998,
0.2669664323,
-0.6182851195,
0.3644004762,
0.3849694729,
-0.2717711926,
-0.1996425986,
0.4661468863,
-0.2676379085,
0.2524473965,
-0.3157296181,
0.3735705912,
0.0297712926,
0.3541827202,
0.4686946273,
0.6958088279,
0.5232685804,
-0.5447054505,
0.1296209693,
0.4299790263,
-0.1930059344,
0.2624928653,
-0.6721026897,
0.106344983,
0.0713392943,
-0.0636385083,
-0.8434186578,
-0.1924491525,
-0.1717911959,
-0.6509449482,
0.345864743,
-0.3735840321,
-0.5227189064,
-0.1305146515,
-0.4586208761,
-0.118410401,
0.4079020321,
-0.5472665429,
0.1231831163,
0.7084565163,
-0.5643540025,
-0.3586568534,
-0.2241659462,
0.241741851,
-0.4760683179,
-0.4980908036,
0.6430659294,
0.2584624887,
-0.3185165524,
-0.0677669346,
-0.1907253563,
-0.6169633865,
0.484131515,
0.3786752224,
0.0873973966,
0.0898141786,
0.3397636712,
0.2033932805,
-0.1059671342,
-0.2788178325,
-0.3685467541,
0.0848753154,
0.1632046103,
-0.1035915837,
-0.4297891855,
0.6845450997,
0.8328709006,
-0.5399317145,
0.2997146249,
0.3056725264,
-0.4111002684,
-0.1005281731,
-0.0588438027,
-0.2232417166,
-0.4762688279,
0.19018659,
-0.3802368343,
-0.3784021437,
0.1672579497,
-0.15186055,
0.2250692546,
0.6853532791,
0.3374345601,
-0.2571220696,
1.2780528069,
0.6437072158,
-0.2153147608,
0.2425463796,
-0.1664608568,
0.3351227641,
-0.4303919077,
-0.0785150975,
-0.7916230559,
0.0201609731,
-0.8208686113,
-0.019846404,
0.4321891069,
0.2562162876,
0.0519730859,
0.4352158606,
-0.9385302663,
0.0815044194,
0.7238328457,
-0.0201624203,
0.3554314375,
0.0683704838,
-0.3201783895,
-0.1003323123,
-0.5382578373,
-0.6636997461,
1.7151340246,
-0.1107459813,
0.9332860112,
0.0536946692,
1.3358556032,
0.7394552231,
0.0946944281,
-0.5886227489,
0.3959139585,
-0.5111582279,
-0.800699234,
-0.3842489123,
-0.2611318827,
-1.2339118719,
0.5289749503,
-0.2541408241,
-0.8313847184,
0.0077435994,
-0.3990798593,
-0.4097650051,
-0.2900178134,
-0.653557241,
1.0139672756,
-0.4173039794,
-0.1589203328,
0.1298992783,
-0.6793196797,
0.2157791406,
-0.4136515558,
0.2768611908,
0.1990074813,
-0.0782783628,
1.2179389,
-0.3043980002,
0.3900607824,
-0.126835376,
0.2459052354,
0.1760511249,
-0.2421716005,
0.5923427939,
-0.0247224383,
-0.0853727758,
-0.1482944638,
0.2571615279,
-0.123693116,
-0.496183455,
0.7081090808,
-0.5634501576,
-0.3404542506,
-0.4191744328,
-0.3936325908,
-0.2806582451,
0.3998011053,
0.6765263677,
0.1803814322,
-0.1826779842,
0.6782773137,
0.8847796917,
0.2697385252,
0.4084591269,
0.3306899667,
-0.0087445993,
-0.4232579768,
0.7242529988,
0.2307246178,
-0.17152147,
0.7080789208,
0.3077483773,
-0.3467205763,
-0.6676232815,
-0.1030394956,
-0.0641594455,
-0.8249789476,
-0.0204657502,
-1.0479170084,
-0.2222924232,
-1.2315567732,
-0.2399161607,
-0.3206166923,
-0.7465540767,
-0.0554873012,
-0.0911059082,
0.3420680761,
0.1550026685,
0.020761719,
0.4477229714,
-1.0716912746,
0.5548421144,
0.3576150239,
-0.2540908158,
-0.4435011446,
-0.6907606721,
-0.2278468013,
-0.384391427,
-0.2853486538,
-0.8955519795,
0.6067301035,
0.5693688989,
0.9786036015,
0.5796904564,
0.5328063369,
0.3569279015,
-0.4289927781,
0.8080980182,
-0.1967198998,
-0.6482362747,
0.7641723752,
-0.2039858699,
0.1315785944,
1.2760385275,
0.5415706635,
-0.0551906265,
-0.6232694387,
-0.7713686228,
-0.8718578219,
0.3089933395,
0.3741783798,
-0.0418325514,
-0.283998698,
0.0586594976,
0.1937771887,
0.3057227433,
-0.5377590656,
-0.2341619879,
-0.1260875463,
-0.6175172329,
0.0199866444,
0.2666099966,
-0.1713834107,
-0.0945104361,
0.9652186632,
-0.2561469972,
-0.0487597547,
0.257409811,
-0.5316392779,
0.1060713083,
0.2133418322,
-0.0047166399,
0.2789960504,
-0.5694435835,
0.1286743283,
-0.2199189365,
-0.6627663374,
-0.0394372977,
0.3777104914,
-0.1648855805,
0.3606402576,
0.5241391063,
-0.1818050593,
0.4598605931,
-0.7475084066,
0.9339809418,
0.0012960308,
-0.2758190334,
-0.0641918555,
-0.159662351,
-0.0731763393,
0.2710296214,
0.8361808062,
-0.0129229128,
0.4565206468,
-0.4719897807,
0.7865277529,
0.7018918395,
-0.2306664437,
0.0196852237,
0.642162025,
0.1937599927,
-0.2766846716,
0.5321204066,
0.0076063555,
-0.7447097898,
0.4259521663,
0.2223888189,
1.0906239748,
-0.0823864192,
0.177953124,
0.1363119036,
0.2714565396,
-0.1096575707,
-0.1762078106,
-0.3592288792,
-0.6030889153,
0.2385815084,
-0.607563138,
-0.4089931548,
-0.0847939104,
-0.7392513752,
0.0057445429,
-0.1804277897,
-0.2040708065,
0.3403529823,
0.4818857908,
-0.4995419085,
0.3291115463,
-0.0478336141,
0.8691289425,
-0.8673533201,
1.0462911129,
0.4162755013,
-0.5924768448,
-0.1906891912,
0.1425317377,
-0.1298476607,
-0.7720375657,
0.8186590075,
0.1628409326,
0.0697037801,
-0.0830024704,
-0.5186679363,
-0.7517643571,
0.992642045,
-0.0748712569,
-0.0972505584,
-0.3508198559,
-0.2139285654,
0.295710206,
-0.3027632236,
-0.2538364232,
0.247815609,
0.2761803567,
-0.1337700337,
-0.7078513503,
-0.2751753926,
-0.3553223908,
-0.2610373199,
-0.0249462426,
-0.2479765117,
0.557488203,
0.1115897074,
-0.3072549403,
0.2698437274,
0.7240574956,
0.0339607447,
0.2605527341,
0.2522458136,
0.6134079099,
0.8370060325,
0.2864735126,
0.8508270383,
-0.7999501824,
0.4890679717,
1.0307215452,
-0.3248963058,
0.8789096475,
0.5070108771,
-0.0398076586,
0.0135499854,
0.5353183746,
0.0868323371,
1.4062018394,
-0.1127419621,
-0.2149630785,
-0.5418891907,
0.2718514204,
-0.2880063653,
0.7812540531,
0.2234160006,
-0.8235615492,
-0.3732487857,
-0.0042482698,
-0.1136301011,
0.2467938811,
-0.1293689758,
0.8077644706,
0.3112513721,
-0.8029627204,
0.1067229509,
0.0703743026,
0.5782820582,
-0.7967558503,
0.1527729183,
-0.072494559,
0.3500599265,
-0.1688699871,
-0.5807843208,
-0.1212986112,
0.3336789608,
-0.123105973,
-0.374936372,
0.7727508545,
-0.2696071267,
-0.7588716745,
0.0564772636,
0.6539744139,
0.2219401598,
-0.3726894557,
-0.5334908366,
-0.5174102783,
-0.1646743268,
-0.3256524205,
0.5645146966,
0.496332556,
0.1077122167,
0.2526979744,
0.5200076103,
0.0262827668,
0.1604020298,
-0.2292177081,
0.4363092184,
-0.4316390157,
-0.4747663736,
-0.6585693359,
0.1842811555,
-0.529828012,
-0.2202698588,
0.9411693215,
0.6283782721,
0.3601571023,
-0.0259078499,
1.1785584688,
0.1977124363,
0.6289858818,
-0.4916033745,
0.8962563872,
-0.5140501261,
-0.0939782783,
-0.4626432061,
-0.8220381737,
-0.3746400177,
0.7769201994,
-0.1791224033,
-0.3208822906,
0.7540376782,
0.7570824027,
0.0703157708,
0.0826338157,
0.2694002986,
-0.3809396923,
0.1888374388,
0.0686624944,
0.0817196891,
-0.4551361799,
0.4968942404,
-0.4383557737,
-0.3103654385,
-0.360892117,
-0.6890273094,
-0.5079309344,
-0.662745893,
-0.4977846146,
0.0765039474,
0.1858965755,
0.9944194555,
0.6141116023,
-0.9033879638,
0.0967942104,
0.0381171703,
0.3384868503,
-0.4975666702,
-0.2983250916,
0.7443535328,
-0.7421845794,
-0.7184428573,
0.7902061939,
0.2270219922,
-0.4522588849,
0.3062065542,
0.2866475284,
-0.3557933867,
0.1832081228,
0.3882514834,
0.1206630915,
-0.350592792,
-0.2660588324,
0.0946612209,
-0.4623644054,
-0.0132002607,
0.5870515704,
-0.6183515191,
0.4005244076,
0.5548869371,
0.8275077343,
0.2873594463,
0.1999894381,
0.3229907453,
-0.6526892185,
-0.1916036457,
0.240037784,
0.3388567269,
0.074678421,
-0.2692607045,
0.64100945,
0.5705725551,
-0.4253510237,
-0.6873929501,
-0.2675417662,
-1.1639082432,
-0.407523334,
0.9777129889,
-0.3071049154,
-0.1202551425,
0.0119764637,
0.2293066978,
0.2596004009,
-0.3060771227,
0.8772425056,
0.4211938381,
0.1367632747,
0.0837855116,
-0.3535816669,
0.2864798605,
0.1346843392,
-0.5153518915,
-0.0889857486,
0.1111074165,
0.3202722073,
0.3839434981,
0.5802448988,
-0.3629233539,
0.0966255441,
0.0557560697,
-0.0245495215,
0.1891616285,
-0.3354449272,
-0.3572796285,
0.9482654333,
-0.0072890576,
-0.582128346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16056v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16056v3
|
Qibo: A Large Language Model for Traditional Chinese Medicine
| 2024-03-24T07:48:05 | 2024-06-22T05:43:53 |
Heyi Zhang, Xin Wang, Zhaopeng Meng, Zhe Chen, Pengwei Zhuang, Yongzhe Jia, Dawei Xu, Wenbin Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) has made significant progress in a number of
professional fields, including medicine, law, and finance. However, in
traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), there are challenges such as the essential
differences between theory and modern medicine, the lack of specialized corpus
resources, and the fact that relying only on supervised fine-tuning may lead to
overconfident predictions. To address these challenges, we propose a two-stage
training approach that combines continuous pre-training and supervised
fine-tuning. A notable contribution of our study is the processing of a 2GB
corpus dedicated to TCM, constructing pre-training and instruction fine-tuning
datasets for TCM, respectively. In addition, we have developed Qibo-Benchmark,
a tool that evaluates the performance of LLM in the TCM on multiple dimensions,
including subjective, objective, and three TCM NLP tasks. The medical LLM
trained with our pipeline, named $\textbf{Qibo}$, exhibits significant
performance boosts. Compared to the baselines, the average subjective win rate
is 63%, the average objective accuracy improved by 23% to 58%, and the Rouge-L
scores for the three TCM NLP tasks are 0.72, 0.61, and 0.55. Finally, we
propose a pipline to apply Qibo to TCM consultation and demonstrate the model
performance through the case study.
|
[
0.1840298176,
-0.6872056723,
0.5022254586,
-0.0017424471,
-0.4934206903,
0.0534901246,
-0.6116737127,
-0.4108197391,
0.1287432611,
0.5472220778,
-0.2251891047,
-0.6665102243,
-0.4761057794,
-0.0625770614,
0.0156566687,
0.8690330386,
0.0788000301,
0.898725152,
0.3004078865,
0.103566654,
-0.5065656304,
-0.2092742175,
-0.9859185219,
-0.6801693439,
0.5602094531,
0.2733772993,
0.6095575094,
0.6790838838,
0.4176396132,
0.1112090498,
-0.126458779,
0.4236983061,
-0.3910013437,
-0.0093128001,
-0.2548604906,
-0.6025598049,
-0.6080177426,
0.0765604228,
0.7335073352,
0.6824401617,
-0.6117409468,
0.0243071448,
0.0462897792,
0.6947441697,
-0.3389985263,
-0.0252116844,
-0.6532019377,
0.1691207886,
-0.2111308724,
-0.351601392,
-0.362370193,
-0.3567963541,
-0.0624160133,
-0.5520165563,
0.0825402811,
0.091787681,
1.0925585032,
0.1327884346,
-0.4902884066,
-0.0745515078,
-0.4871487617,
0.5164499879,
-1.0682948828,
0.1143050715,
0.2991925776,
0.340509057,
-0.4996510148,
-0.8516259789,
-0.4518458247,
-0.5024912357,
-0.0306842327,
0.3274667561,
0.3236711323,
0.4651212692,
0.3242567778,
0.3706201613,
-0.5115671158,
0.3824238479,
-0.3312631845,
0.1182480976,
0.5420692563,
0.3610724211,
0.2561572194,
-0.0363570675,
-0.3144106865,
0.0659102723,
-0.7545022368,
0.0677465796,
-0.2721421123,
0.2697306275,
0.0340340473,
0.1486420631,
-0.3469183445,
0.8814419508,
0.1627254635,
-0.5467715859,
-0.0136587219,
-0.2315837741,
-0.4484639764,
0.0897088423,
0.9767317176,
0.2210085839,
-0.0040592914,
-0.0558962189,
-0.1581999958,
-0.2104349732,
0.3560071886,
-0.9825246334,
-0.400611341,
0.5173020959,
-0.656603694,
-0.2101744413,
-0.0816360191,
-0.1537446827,
-0.5647017956,
-0.4737589061,
0.2356244028,
-0.7411076427,
-0.290178746,
0.2626178861,
0.1512946934,
0.3440200686,
0.4629641473,
-0.8683953285,
0.2984466255,
0.9501659274,
1.0536072254,
0.0702026561,
-0.1532460302,
-0.7444527745,
0.332158953,
-0.7927721739,
0.6922149062,
-0.3936624527,
-0.3462510407,
-0.0853399634,
-0.1027421728,
0.1392550468,
-0.7605107427,
0.5176187158,
-0.0164545216,
-0.0094437711,
-0.2851352394,
-0.5284929872,
0.0074804067,
0.2852469087,
-0.391620785,
0.7275346518,
0.3346483111,
-0.5598395467,
0.5326051116,
-0.5051714778,
-0.6201219559,
0.3717052042,
-0.1455892175,
-0.3358600736,
0.0826833025,
0.0241615158,
0.5414927006,
-0.6536916494,
0.5925018787,
-0.2849048674,
-0.5370634198,
0.1025523692,
0.028279867,
0.9440713525,
0.3009675145,
-0.1076784804,
0.1997228414,
-0.8389179707,
0.1588158756,
-0.1199430227,
-0.3607453108,
-0.3582634032,
0.0971592516,
-0.0320564546,
0.2868274748,
0.1217326447,
-0.3930278718,
0.479603678,
-0.5775181651,
0.5925231576,
0.4189822674,
-0.3110860288,
-0.1003871933,
-0.3797750175,
0.2561933696,
0.1248189732,
0.212625891,
-0.0872538984,
-0.2553440034,
-0.5776969194,
-0.3895650506,
0.4575591087,
0.3632648289,
-0.798550427,
0.4417406321,
-0.1711512655,
-0.743716538,
-0.7929643393,
0.2914994359,
0.2651534379,
0.766233325,
0.3598697484,
-0.5343342423,
-0.0816001445,
-0.684859395,
-0.0629125461,
-0.3659052253,
-0.3373087049,
0.0497879237,
0.1540504545,
-0.3174329102,
0.5565001369,
-0.458529532,
-0.7029378414,
-0.2884098887,
0.3152041435,
0.357250154,
0.4110856056,
0.3884884119,
-0.5063067079,
-0.5422315598,
0.4546996355,
-0.4474104047,
-0.2918258011,
-0.2986878157,
-0.1433627754,
0.2641444802,
0.2973918319,
-0.3685042858,
-0.014418547,
0.6293120384,
-0.0697231963,
0.5750037432,
-0.6348944306,
0.0603293851,
-1.2184000015,
0.1821148843,
0.0664110556,
-0.1664897203,
-0.733782351,
0.0845776051,
0.4962295592,
0.1924227774,
-0.2742351294,
0.4367617965,
-0.5097042918,
0.4861423075,
-0.580621779,
0.1285029948,
-0.1489446163,
0.281101197,
0.4632918239,
0.2032326609,
0.50207901,
-0.5820349455,
0.7083507776,
-0.0735868216,
-0.4819273949,
0.6514777541,
-0.737914443,
0.0269154087,
0.1949736476,
0.3785091937,
-0.7181020975,
-0.2399098575,
0.1921758652,
-0.2611112893,
0.7605399489,
0.1547084153,
-0.582446754,
-0.3903300464,
-0.249762252,
0.0118344119,
0.415846765,
-0.2862845361,
0.5819972157,
0.0697363168,
-0.1143051907,
-0.5529059768,
-0.5008045435,
0.2044070214,
0.0092803445,
-0.5078638792,
0.3472083807,
0.1385568082,
0.048900608,
-0.2833803892,
0.007939362,
-0.0886557922,
0.2749480307,
0.1100445241,
0.2842550874,
-0.2496807724,
0.3056231737,
0.3290996552,
-0.0393413082,
0.1488241255,
-0.3440794945,
0.4469767511,
0.2250552326,
-0.1191635877,
-0.4901566207,
-0.0293283109,
0.1201794446,
-0.3022742867,
0.8651435375,
0.6557074189,
-0.4549792111,
-0.3216070831,
-0.6329113841,
-0.1193394959,
-0.3915701807,
0.5747465491,
-0.17147699,
-0.5663002133,
0.1614812165,
-0.1970616132,
0.2008616328,
0.0642587394,
0.8674741387,
-0.0054218378,
0.7470425367,
0.469961375,
-0.0616467558,
0.4071826935,
0.0204925891,
0.1319716871,
-0.7990807295,
-0.2628484964,
-0.2706976533,
-0.2022580206,
-0.6192951202,
-0.4022637308,
0.3548949957,
0.1684025377,
-0.190666154,
0.2617508173,
-0.3049495518,
0.1563571393,
0.6455180645,
0.4408196211,
0.2486484945,
-0.4257044494,
-0.0158308353,
0.2619189918,
-0.7470803857,
-0.4684340358,
1.1819393635,
0.5447714329,
0.8772754073,
-0.1474984586,
0.6308768392,
-0.2538831532,
0.5490912199,
-0.9105921388,
0.328697592,
-0.4048107564,
-0.6011428833,
-0.3430224359,
-0.4901406169,
-0.8546380401,
0.3300852776,
-0.419775784,
-0.3759920597,
-0.3115049601,
0.2264243662,
-0.927740097,
0.299977988,
-0.5882823467,
0.8024455905,
-0.5448284149,
-0.5000599027,
-0.3736769557,
-0.9666615129,
0.5850219727,
-0.3314163685,
0.0270040557,
-0.1150337458,
0.010230572,
0.5449041724,
-0.2880856395,
0.6004050374,
-0.0747697651,
-0.2016949356,
-0.0377362147,
0.0226968043,
0.1998884231,
0.3055393696,
0.010377394,
0.3214643598,
0.5478935838,
-0.5774864554,
-0.416811347,
0.4227684736,
-0.6518213153,
-0.7064013481,
-0.5963821411,
-0.5222818851,
-0.3565197885,
0.3425011039,
0.130171746,
0.2352543622,
-0.3580236137,
0.2473405451,
0.528501153,
-0.6813780665,
-0.0774047151,
0.9397083521,
-0.0380220786,
-0.1877271384,
0.5054478645,
0.223045066,
0.4752685726,
0.4855116904,
0.4900713563,
-0.0563206002,
-0.8498927951,
-0.1867322028,
0.412065804,
-0.260876596,
-0.2219575942,
-0.4790819585,
-0.4788027108,
-0.5838238001,
0.1868989617,
-0.2182363421,
0.278193593,
-0.2614509463,
0.1082058176,
-0.004361277,
0.5444657803,
-0.1672534496,
0.4692850113,
-0.8163321018,
0.5837052464,
0.130211845,
0.4740556777,
-0.0230783019,
-0.5996980071,
-0.7301627994,
0.2531101108,
-0.5094925165,
-0.5502226949,
0.5899193883,
0.1182211936,
0.4164541066,
0.9240090251,
0.0923500732,
0.8060765862,
-0.715916574,
0.776501894,
0.4695661068,
-0.711132288,
0.5940688848,
-0.2537660003,
0.1985339671,
0.3713011146,
0.2518544197,
-0.8352909684,
-0.5312237144,
-0.2182792723,
-0.6857671738,
0.8448219895,
-0.3144190311,
0.0510602519,
-0.0314541571,
0.5125792027,
0.0927006751,
0.1824842244,
-0.5228354931,
-0.1516519487,
0.0724911988,
-0.1415855289,
-0.1426333785,
-0.3793629706,
-0.3009763658,
-0.3516898155,
0.7109538317,
-0.2390740514,
-0.1523357183,
0.1293576211,
0.1217004508,
-0.314668566,
0.1772288531,
0.4718089104,
1.0093085766,
-0.3268729746,
-0.2147724926,
0.1621284187,
-0.6291528344,
-0.0748032704,
0.1376511008,
0.0679348558,
0.1207202747,
0.4619735777,
0.6891948581,
-0.0048405621,
-0.7632216811,
0.3296378851,
0.1147587597,
-0.1682670712,
-0.3239897192,
0.1995792687,
0.2098145485,
0.2435526848,
0.3069260716,
-0.5385195613,
0.1462424994,
-0.7879471183,
-0.0386450067,
0.532009542,
-0.3223265707,
-0.0776756704,
0.7779600024,
0.1372671872,
-0.0818579048,
0.5418922901,
0.1356477886,
-0.2880473733,
0.4535413086,
0.4631377757,
0.5865912437,
-0.4401122332,
0.2326869667,
0.485578537,
0.2114814818,
-0.634576261,
-0.0120822797,
0.1723070145,
-0.5342745781,
-0.444776684,
-0.5708115101,
-0.5566813946,
0.2425560206,
-0.8553696275,
0.716999948,
-0.6393969655,
-0.1611281633,
-0.0023668315,
0.4335300922,
-0.3347593546,
0.4846537411,
0.3558098376,
1.0087316036,
-0.2453056574,
1.5197548866,
0.545958817,
-0.2577689886,
-0.9865813255,
-0.0237493571,
-0.1318088472,
-0.936011374,
0.6423923969,
0.0749174058,
0.0519586019,
-0.3350926042,
-0.6075888872,
-0.4955331087,
1.307741046,
0.4510648251,
-1.145365715,
-0.2709144652,
-0.1631963551,
0.8367317915,
-0.1503466517,
0.4425275326,
0.7614010572,
0.0460316837,
0.0429084748,
-1.1671708822,
0.0198048893,
0.0636471808,
0.1632152051,
0.0748767182,
-1.0341694355,
0.9681938291,
-0.2652763128,
-0.2454062551,
0.3621974885,
0.5335689187,
0.3849878609,
0.2732779384,
0.2288762927,
0.2667858899,
0.940813005,
-0.2786909938,
0.9235755205,
-0.6329305172,
0.2409805506,
1.116915822,
-0.5826303959,
0.8837811947,
0.3476155996,
-0.1697270423,
0.4333385229,
0.9169790149,
-0.0294782333,
0.3303335607,
0.3866955936,
-0.0914831981,
-0.3251368403,
-0.056022089,
-0.5515080094,
0.2038720548,
0.3545304239,
-0.3813162744,
0.2162131369,
-0.1584937274,
0.1399724036,
0.1490721703,
-0.4992161989,
0.7183730006,
0.5076653957,
-0.5390483737,
0.6937547922,
0.1800501347,
0.6812528372,
-1.0664249659,
-0.0212115552,
-0.3549283147,
0.1625867039,
-0.2725312412,
-0.4916419685,
-0.122551024,
-0.284569025,
0.2223148197,
-0.0767288432,
0.3062148988,
-0.6542366743,
-0.5613350868,
0.3053815365,
0.0841801316,
0.0425910428,
0.0765423253,
-0.5131548643,
-0.3492828906,
-0.2434410155,
-0.195747301,
0.4237271547,
0.7456438541,
0.0111935446,
0.7696090937,
0.5547189713,
0.8676880598,
-0.4706736207,
0.1112713814,
0.8013119102,
-0.9851964712,
-0.5411394238,
-0.9139041901,
0.0685565397,
-0.0431915261,
-0.2444218248,
0.3528548777,
0.3844322264,
0.8071846962,
0.0850723684,
0.6852639318,
0.1404028833,
0.7106108665,
-0.8212608695,
0.9560276866,
-0.7856570482,
0.1776897311,
-0.2548823059,
-0.5939474106,
-0.3585488498,
0.6130777001,
-0.1534121931,
-0.1167501807,
0.8010516167,
0.5795981884,
0.4009703696,
-0.2907803953,
0.5663294196,
0.4409100115,
0.2914136946,
1.0784343481,
0.6489571333,
-0.1054573059,
0.2482874095,
-0.2297388464,
-0.2637661994,
-0.2287576497,
-0.6858868003,
-1.0229333639,
-0.2320408523,
-0.2788961828,
-0.4820361137,
0.1101160347,
1.3576629162,
0.530770123,
-0.8725042939,
-0.520817399,
0.4273759127,
-0.1999910623,
-0.5473669171,
-0.0853697062,
0.440341264,
-0.3617742062,
-0.6842781305,
-0.0383940861,
0.4005657136,
-0.1806328893,
-0.2036145329,
-0.0829509944,
0.013311808,
-0.1248806268,
0.5748474598,
0.0413010679,
-0.9024558663,
-0.0743696466,
-0.0380886272,
-0.4633724093,
0.1723167002,
0.8320720196,
-0.6749690771,
0.6064453125,
0.1308662593,
0.5193402767,
0.3046279252,
0.0636687651,
0.8064629436,
-0.0707330629,
0.132712543,
0.2295395732,
0.3545362651,
0.120866105,
-0.2967901826,
0.5183207393,
0.0126276575,
-0.3007344007,
-0.8432632685,
-0.157676667,
-1.0691635609,
-0.6374584436,
1.3832600117,
-0.2198637873,
-0.1094155163,
-0.0778245553,
-0.6896052361,
0.5637909174,
-0.3167272806,
1.0693314075,
0.7960688472,
0.0884048194,
-0.0554300956,
-0.6170555949,
0.4827212691,
0.3743074238,
-0.6817006469,
-0.065996103,
0.4553391337,
0.4704989195,
-0.13330625,
0.8410284519,
-0.0919830203,
0.35255301,
-0.2423247248,
0.1677784622,
-0.1465885937,
-0.0327915885,
-0.3589975536,
-0.0067856824,
0.4102908671,
-0.0081404522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.16038v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.16038v2
|
Monotonic Paraphrasing Improves Generalization of Language Model Prompting
| 2024-03-24T06:49:07 | 2024-04-18T05:22:01 |
Qin Liu, Fei Wang, Nan Xu, Tianyi Yan, Tao Meng, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Performance of large language models (LLMs) may vary with different prompts
or instructions of even the same task. One commonly recognized factor for this
phenomenon is the model's familiarity with the given prompt or instruction,
which is typically estimated by its perplexity. However, finding the prompt
with the lowest perplexity is challenging, given the enormous space of possible
prompting phrases. In this paper, we propose monotonic paraphrasing (MonoPara),
an end-to-end decoding strategy that paraphrases given prompts or instructions
into their lower perplexity counterparts based on an ensemble of a paraphrase
LM for prompt (or instruction) rewriting, and a target LM (i.e. the prompt or
instruction executor) that constrains the generation for lower perplexity. The
ensemble decoding process can efficiently paraphrase the original prompt
without altering its semantic meaning, while monotonically decreasing the
perplexity of each generation as calculated by the target LM. We explore in
detail both greedy and search-based decoding as two alternative decoding
schemes of MonoPara. Notably, MonoPara does not require any training and can
monotonically lower the perplexity of the paraphrased prompt or instruction,
leading to improved performance of zero-shot LM prompting as evaluated on a
wide selection of tasks. In addition, MonoPara is also shown to effectively
improve LMs' generalization on perturbed and unseen task instructions.
|
[
-0.3599519432,
-0.8013502359,
0.4404668212,
0.387427628,
-0.6012878418,
-0.217519477,
-0.4115403295,
0.2162682861,
0.1291531771,
0.5742276907,
-0.6467484832,
-0.6423534751,
-0.4648906291,
0.422319442,
-0.3138112128,
0.9917622209,
0.1292462647,
-0.2190019339,
-0.3779229522,
-0.2253275365,
-0.1029636264,
-0.5385811329,
-0.8811782598,
-0.2620974481,
0.7895948887,
0.6250549555,
0.6292552352,
0.6820462942,
0.0800617114,
0.3035680354,
-0.4206804335,
-0.1328573972,
-0.5259551406,
0.3381784856,
-0.053749077,
-0.4352104664,
-0.1393156648,
-0.2917493284,
0.7423319221,
0.8673850298,
-0.2178512514,
0.128902927,
0.5261566639,
0.541585207,
-0.6875893474,
0.1832607388,
-0.5743067861,
0.1571851075,
-0.0658646375,
-0.6606122255,
-0.4790010452,
-0.148453787,
0.4080071449,
-0.6429045796,
0.3084413409,
-0.2090979815,
0.4228400588,
0.2544422448,
0.1120954007,
-0.3358418345,
-0.2021757662,
0.9940683842,
-0.7660865188,
-0.0196154267,
0.1626575738,
0.0394961648,
0.058773268,
-0.4145233035,
-0.313475728,
-0.247292012,
0.0306634568,
-0.0320509784,
-0.1232401282,
0.2089675963,
0.2413856834,
0.1438854188,
-0.5008688569,
-0.1352511197,
-0.2872605026,
-0.2119226158,
0.0822210386,
0.2049144655,
0.0562787578,
-0.3597179055,
-0.6009045243,
-0.2187967002,
-0.4975211322,
0.3832234442,
0.2278058231,
0.4668412209,
0.0130569441,
0.1443633586,
-0.3898620009,
0.6078090072,
-0.027278211,
-0.0349551402,
0.128029108,
-0.5294412971,
-0.1735754013,
0.0380968899,
0.731269896,
0.3206292093,
0.3040368855,
-0.1364000887,
-0.0300466772,
-0.0996422917,
-0.1527317613,
-0.5268678665,
-0.0872954503,
-0.1708104163,
-0.4927100539,
-0.1921979785,
-0.1556889117,
-1.2714194059,
-0.1956151873,
-0.2807857692,
0.26134184,
-0.6933506727,
0.2279569209,
0.3485339284,
-0.4224885404,
0.4016187489,
0.3036781251,
-0.9202731848,
0.3403203487,
0.5102641582,
1.0008411407,
0.0965884924,
-0.7294768095,
-0.6292723417,
0.1354903579,
-0.2732902467,
0.7477446795,
-0.7258985043,
-0.5476484895,
-0.1977853179,
-0.4149252772,
-0.1699175239,
-0.5332358479,
0.6347072124,
-0.149475649,
0.0358385146,
-0.347686857,
-0.3671800196,
-0.0838214159,
0.1488252729,
-0.4358633757,
0.4727525711,
-0.098574847,
-0.5119495392,
0.2880059481,
-0.505437851,
-0.4387332499,
0.0033042007,
-0.2411844879,
-0.0154482787,
0.39469257,
0.5533474684,
0.1997060329,
-0.4136713743,
-0.1620804071,
-0.100102365,
-0.3905754387,
-0.1727705747,
-0.7352722883,
0.5831530094,
0.3453692794,
-0.1016683578,
0.1108897999,
-0.4700423777,
0.0787624195,
0.1024009287,
-0.3731513619,
-0.5458868146,
-0.0730520561,
-0.6022561193,
-0.0106859403,
0.3752271831,
-0.2066760957,
0.1307187378,
-0.2624630928,
0.3194562495,
0.8258088827,
0.2623997331,
0.5342916846,
-0.4946248233,
0.8076914549,
-0.0617482252,
0.1442255229,
-0.8217016459,
-0.4497599006,
-0.5611437559,
-0.3047920167,
0.0179663096,
0.5623557568,
-0.7404629588,
0.0573028363,
-0.2611583471,
-0.1650439799,
-0.7486753464,
0.4290739298,
0.6408984065,
0.8621332049,
0.6950659156,
0.2105565816,
-0.3394713998,
-0.7855110168,
-0.3088112772,
0.0688136593,
0.0120406942,
-0.0736638904,
-0.0181742832,
0.3167186379,
0.5862859488,
-0.199663803,
0.1075947136,
-0.4816913605,
0.4764140844,
0.4439132214,
0.3798647523,
0.2233085781,
-0.6091527939,
-0.5854706764,
-0.2736293077,
-0.7796345353,
-0.1541265398,
-0.2446666956,
0.0451592058,
-0.0440397114,
0.5299581289,
-0.6892131567,
0.2657402158,
0.1338635832,
-0.1013705879,
0.6215476394,
-0.4888676405,
0.2487804443,
-0.9188346267,
0.0109279072,
-0.111042656,
-0.0411100537,
-0.5509631634,
0.3399318159,
-0.0603094064,
-0.2346659601,
-0.3507326841,
0.4113098681,
-0.7171106339,
0.4087378979,
-0.2660706937,
-0.0395969674,
-0.0684059933,
0.5162926912,
0.0793977156,
0.8487323523,
0.9991282821,
-0.8772121072,
0.2688632607,
0.3500974774,
-0.2689198852,
0.3779200017,
-0.5719697475,
0.210348919,
-0.47006464,
0.0797035247,
-1.0255881548,
0.0429650135,
0.0513728149,
-0.4973995388,
0.161498934,
-0.2363421917,
-0.3271956742,
-0.1152116805,
-0.7217878699,
0.5336565971,
0.7199639082,
-0.4520436227,
0.0092256144,
-0.2303058058,
-0.5658342838,
-0.5991668105,
-0.6071130633,
0.3259833157,
-0.3965015411,
-0.5320208073,
-0.0026955737,
-0.0847085863,
-0.0795432627,
-0.4431284368,
-0.277952522,
0.1335880905,
-0.1117631197,
-0.3896817863,
0.107610479,
-0.3655204773,
0.0206071977,
0.2796927989,
-0.3494042754,
0.0387805104,
-0.3313351572,
0.7913060784,
0.0794477239,
-0.0480008125,
-0.4347463846,
0.5567462444,
0.6364099383,
-0.1940755695,
0.6204964519,
0.0461957157,
-0.0091617173,
-0.2946450412,
-0.1700538099,
-0.319113791,
-0.4604638517,
0.0718389452,
-0.5919722915,
-0.6070804596,
0.5013778806,
0.0050074114,
-0.0134400399,
-0.060875237,
0.2434827834,
0.2215196192,
0.9884063601,
0.2335322052,
-0.2267144769,
0.3240213394,
-0.1213182956,
-0.0938260779,
-0.6730242968,
-0.0025273061,
-0.5305294991,
-0.4234918654,
-0.1625491828,
-0.4503756464,
0.5382221937,
0.2667895257,
0.2011826485,
0.3301300406,
-0.4209856987,
0.6714646816,
0.8717727661,
0.3618893325,
0.3429832458,
0.2876350582,
-0.3752579689,
0.1387403011,
-0.9204761386,
-0.4778308868,
1.0702015162,
0.0926249623,
0.8733898997,
-0.1588042378,
1.1162378788,
0.0136199025,
-0.2965679765,
-0.541616559,
0.9244611859,
-0.1680238247,
-0.1883959621,
-0.6761492491,
-0.6272306442,
-0.9657320976,
0.1821787208,
0.1868920773,
-0.7680365443,
0.1959358156,
0.3707659841,
-0.7282114625,
0.1037784964,
-0.5202280283,
0.953325808,
0.2227875441,
-0.2384051085,
-0.1377782077,
-0.7214069963,
0.0078175291,
0.1103432178,
0.0968831033,
0.1613722444,
-0.440269053,
0.5334992409,
-0.503328979,
0.5816066861,
-0.3247510493,
-0.1160666347,
0.3323782086,
0.1417509913,
0.692343533,
0.0650403202,
-0.4509958029,
-0.2115067542,
-0.0478784293,
-0.821669817,
-0.6578342319,
0.7051452398,
-0.2034540623,
-0.8215846419,
0.0360406227,
-0.7737450004,
-0.2612266839,
0.0665539056,
0.8495690823,
0.5649693012,
0.1730683297,
0.3316670656,
0.9986988902,
-0.1894733608,
0.4722624123,
0.0861483663,
0.0053366083,
-0.3377715051,
0.8515051603,
-0.0369865,
0.4227056801,
0.603427887,
0.4410344362,
-0.2975916862,
-0.7655946016,
-0.3471293747,
0.1085349843,
-0.8247725368,
-0.0152118094,
-0.5491611958,
0.224306047,
-0.6572216749,
-0.2959218621,
0.0590466782,
-0.2058387846,
-0.1384735405,
-0.0750376657,
0.171480298,
0.0739261061,
0.0858069956,
0.2528862953,
-0.8318660855,
0.179652974,
0.4377809465,
-0.093098186,
0.0633612573,
-0.8609088659,
0.062551029,
0.0839200541,
0.0523620211,
-0.9337886572,
0.1962891817,
0.2158579081,
0.5319411755,
0.4374904037,
0.2778483927,
0.9221047163,
-0.4373940825,
0.582285285,
0.2415242642,
-1.1258753538,
0.3972864449,
-0.4931917191,
0.8449755311,
0.873220861,
0.2825348377,
-0.4660193324,
-0.5926429033,
-0.2803998888,
-0.8333474994,
0.6197715402,
0.0302123688,
0.6141222715,
-0.2709304392,
0.2787923813,
0.3094006479,
0.3333932757,
-0.6074370146,
-0.2131428272,
-0.0186996553,
-0.2444473952,
-0.1302853674,
-0.1950719357,
-0.0219519753,
-0.3296907544,
0.3563546538,
-0.1421846598,
0.229229033,
0.3744150698,
-0.1243340224,
-0.1770441681,
0.5262613297,
0.6898494959,
0.5614122748,
0.0510793328,
0.336112082,
0.4620767236,
0.1338059306,
0.1635344625,
-0.0047952556,
-0.2741464972,
0.2449442744,
0.5756736398,
0.8698971868,
0.4880808294,
-0.7203486562,
0.285143137,
0.2960954607,
-0.2387506664,
0.1468671113,
0.0301818103,
-0.0055671497,
0.2216180861,
0.491549015,
-0.2005173564,
0.2504572868,
-0.5224701762,
0.2627878487,
0.3458848298,
0.0876943991,
-0.1184054613,
0.4460214376,
-0.0779059008,
-0.2044209242,
0.4331400692,
-0.2561344504,
-0.2945289016,
0.5113033056,
0.6668790579,
0.7874576449,
-0.4674263895,
0.3469303548,
0.2667568028,
0.1966345608,
-0.1368033141,
0.3223769963,
-0.5003115535,
-0.3385977745,
-0.2948803604,
-0.6351299882,
-0.4161145091,
0.164757207,
-0.7075414062,
0.4043444097,
-0.6147486567,
0.30499053,
-0.1275276095,
-0.675244689,
-0.0876959488,
-0.0376581214,
0.2559108734,
1.1537642479,
-0.289755255,
0.6247220635,
0.8409150243,
-0.4366300106,
-0.6627036929,
0.2845743299,
-0.0532019064,
-0.8459559083,
0.1430358142,
0.2236620039,
-0.1648873836,
0.2689836919,
-0.5811643004,
-0.5023530722,
0.9162824154,
0.5936055183,
-0.5573132634,
-0.6054522395,
0.0905980393,
0.4785369337,
-0.2393544465,
-0.0119095659,
0.3528059721,
0.4155165553,
0.2247947156,
-0.7271983027,
0.2218036056,
-0.0912925303,
0.0044291122,
0.3615163267,
-0.416836977,
1.1489839554,
-0.2085659057,
-0.1693381965,
0.473095566,
0.4452314079,
0.2184920758,
0.4155203104,
0.4145011008,
0.5781550407,
0.521636188,
0.4006719887,
1.0311170816,
-0.4904644489,
0.3262250125,
1.1015678644,
0.0208200607,
0.6283185482,
0.766915679,
-0.0185529832,
0.2590614855,
0.2702850997,
0.3698480129,
0.6195517778,
0.2375842482,
-0.6085383296,
-0.4732998312,
0.1870102733,
-0.2109840065,
0.0871032327,
0.222593382,
-0.4528379738,
-0.9441696405,
0.426530987,
0.2116811872,
0.2673003078,
-0.5031043291,
0.8989588618,
0.1727775186,
-0.9727702141,
1.2800832987,
-0.288010776,
0.7291840911,
-0.7940947413,
0.0417250879,
-0.497402966,
0.002422208,
-0.0177043602,
-0.5171720982,
0.0978462473,
0.0695609748,
-0.243486926,
-0.3657496572,
0.4482230842,
-0.6554961205,
-0.2092803121,
0.4444568753,
0.4326896667,
0.2151327133,
-0.352111876,
-0.8343631625,
-0.188992247,
0.0537464954,
-0.306902796,
0.3896625638,
0.6145320535,
0.1765757203,
0.7170774341,
0.5255494118,
0.0308693983,
0.3221721053,
-0.1449335515,
0.8227486014,
-0.6858686209,
-0.5104333758,
-1.1650662422,
0.2215056866,
0.0079366611,
-0.4626637399,
0.8478163481,
0.3069233298,
0.6194938421,
-0.2351263463,
0.7108843327,
0.226897195,
0.4743512571,
-0.6204063296,
0.2509664893,
-0.4406643808,
0.3859218061,
-0.2671326399,
-0.8538219333,
-0.0469300635,
0.4959366024,
-0.2477115393,
-0.1460480094,
0.680254817,
0.9096581936,
-0.0964175314,
0.0187259857,
0.6552396417,
-0.0766583532,
-0.2524920404,
0.6397481561,
0.667129457,
0.0047048638,
0.936258316,
-0.2163117826,
-0.4693202376,
0.0750061572,
-0.5948907733,
-0.7419474721,
-0.274473995,
-0.1165737733,
-0.072584942,
0.2459304184,
1.0207519531,
0.3432198167,
-0.7092370987,
-0.4904563725,
-0.6079882383,
0.1779707372,
-0.4511881173,
-0.2097548246,
-0.0764359534,
-1.1453225613,
-0.8163769841,
0.7108427882,
0.3616788983,
-0.1864965409,
0.0438983254,
-0.2542533576,
-0.3674606979,
0.4207351208,
0.3797740042,
0.4747517407,
-0.4489290714,
-0.0619343072,
0.1061569154,
0.0335715711,
0.1157259867,
0.7353019118,
-0.6171461344,
0.4307235777,
0.6999137998,
0.524682045,
0.1082387567,
0.1679992378,
0.6060760617,
-0.8415450454,
0.1681550592,
0.2274021357,
0.3009293079,
0.092424266,
-0.0746522844,
0.0924246609,
0.3279676437,
-0.3467428982,
-0.7227286696,
0.2490814328,
-0.7223333716,
-0.5489777923,
1.0911284685,
-0.4606979191,
-0.3221750855,
-0.0274431817,
-0.3330234885,
0.1320931762,
-0.5689935684,
0.6527070403,
0.8937139511,
-0.0380224511,
-0.4874948263,
-0.1840891242,
0.3517754674,
1.1090846062,
-0.5712692738,
0.268084079,
0.2218482941,
0.1962565631,
0.215382129,
0.4726386666,
-0.0200741198,
0.6084666848,
0.0327669643,
-0.2382214516,
-0.1192509681,
-0.3375431895,
-0.7190252542,
0.3526780605,
0.0063516395,
-0.421312362
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.