id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00770v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00770v1
|
Automatic Instruction Evolving for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T15:09:00 | 2024-06-02T15:09:00 |
Weihao Zeng, Can Xu, Yingxiu Zhao, Jian-Guang Lou, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fine-tuning large pre-trained language models with Evol-Instruct has achieved
encouraging results across a wide range of tasks. However, designing effective
evolving methods for instruction evolution requires substantial human
expertise. This paper proposes Auto Evol-Instruct, an end-to-end framework that
evolves instruction datasets using large language models without any human
effort. The framework automatically analyzes and summarizes suitable
evolutionary strategies for the given instruction data and iteratively improves
the evolving method based on issues exposed during the instruction evolution
process. Our extensive experiments demonstrate that the best method optimized
by Auto Evol-Instruct outperforms human-designed methods on various benchmarks,
including MT-Bench, AlpacaEval, GSM8K, and HumanEval.
|
[
0.026167918,
0.1043495685,
-0.0350439362,
0.0131709334,
-0.012267828,
0.0395978801,
-0.0224127341,
-0.008309531,
-0.0155816888,
-0.0347032063,
-0.0307080764,
-0.0143590374,
-0.0394817963,
0.0088863885,
0.031625174,
-0.0346913859,
0.0741154999,
-0.0573053397,
-0.0432912447,
-0.0042791958,
-0.0141780004,
0.0070127044,
0.0138545241,
0.0110261878,
0.0495793633,
-0.0061790477,
-0.0512278192,
-0.0044115838,
0.0162774455,
0.0110794688,
0.0122523094,
0.0478491634,
0.0373796895,
0.0283980202,
0.0000021224,
-0.0490472727,
-0.0511545837,
-0.021037342,
-0.0220813267,
0.0558984056,
0.0540196821,
0.0135960001,
-0.0249980614,
0.0071030608,
-0.0229985528,
-0.0084101204,
-0.0036907711,
-0.0415281951,
0.0957491994,
0.0847752765,
0.0138525516,
-0.0300181732,
0.0005963007,
-0.0152466632,
0.0180276614,
-0.0296454262,
0.0399459712,
-0.0062861177,
0.0028247458,
0.0441227034,
-0.0071442728,
0.0179876704,
0.0281429086,
-0.0192600209,
-0.0150088519,
0.0133115239,
-0.0178660899,
-0.0137077384,
-0.0321002677,
0.0651695281,
-0.0376351476,
-0.0175144393,
-0.0116505222,
-0.0034861849,
0.0232560281,
-0.0530040599,
0.0010904399,
0.0150079634,
-0.0046233949,
0.023795817,
0.0578905903,
-0.0562410913,
-0.0154464291,
-0.0063426937,
-0.005280335,
0.0543930121,
0.0345794782,
-0.0272403788,
-0.0142608993,
-0.0265934467,
-0.0387569331,
-0.032240998,
0.0048817792,
0.0420482494,
-0.0100785643,
0.02744307,
-0.073838897,
-0.0126166046,
0.0011573153,
-0.0122597013,
0.1329626441,
0.0433498174,
-0.0031689897,
0.019296404,
-0.0320512801,
0.0260224435,
-0.0040467158,
-0.0094740083,
-0.058017984,
0.0435541719,
-0.0671288222,
0.0344268717,
-0.0621710047,
0.0049640872,
-0.0461437628,
0.0312445611,
-0.0291932356,
0.0410504043,
0.0151440334,
-0.0221486446,
0.005670554,
-0.0185348932,
-0.0381874628,
0.0186297875,
-0.0199833997,
0.0021036346,
-0.0190234892,
-0.000411263,
-0.0288107954,
-0.0262763798,
0.020028634,
0.0074754907,
-0.0054192962,
-0.0008598581,
0.0241885651,
0.0556556098,
-0.0246227719,
-0.0531818792,
-0.0569852479,
-0.000866009,
-0.0047616656,
-0.0400968641,
-0.0101327449,
-0.0418829322,
0.0369970948,
-0.0267012212,
-0.041532632,
-0.008033378,
-0.0064205518,
-0.0119315116,
-0.0171418376,
0.0282196607,
-0.0507955514,
0.048022788,
0.0215533227,
-0.0026195361,
0.029285742,
0.0528568327,
-0.0133990049,
-0.0242769625,
-0.0025714533,
-0.0173984077,
0.0035023412,
0.0469105057,
0.010553089,
0.070212923,
0.0456948988,
0.0354308411,
0.0056396797,
0.0095618069,
0.0188868288,
0.0306081139,
-0.0207028538,
-0.0388300084,
0.0460276715,
0.002912055,
0.0259728897,
0.0528398231,
0.0879737139,
0.0353568867,
0.0014245134,
-0.0200649891,
-0.0389941484,
-0.0109866615,
-0.0355639644,
-0.0184299648,
-0.0253089257,
0.019799836,
-0.0271913484,
-0.0715078786,
0.0050777011,
0.0094685787,
0.0099822544,
-0.0134430351,
0.0141205257,
0.0223717391,
-0.0585838705,
-0.0173966475,
0.0583373532,
-0.0214946866,
-0.0248716902,
-0.0859393179,
0.0413268656,
0.0856486782,
0.0209159702,
-0.0133464765,
-0.0748144537,
0.0033048508,
0.0609627739,
-0.0070114871,
0.0449197032,
-0.0333529115,
0.017423749,
-0.0234281197,
-0.0311069153,
-0.0235875584,
0.0015348936,
0.0406501256,
0.0400164761,
-0.0084722629,
0.0098424358,
-0.0028748326,
-0.0628978014,
0.0531850867,
-0.0497246534,
-0.0413038433,
-0.0080346167,
-0.0189207084,
0.0111802509,
-0.0160723217,
-0.0229278859,
-0.0072505954,
0.0289673768,
0.0269486755,
0.0062855827,
-0.0081069162,
-0.0413773656,
-0.007182634,
0.0513280742,
0.0043530036,
-0.0451048091,
-0.0467514433,
-0.0352711901,
0.0037194719,
0.0138802174,
-0.0478912592,
0.069878079,
-0.0191257019,
0.0687639564,
-0.0433668979,
-0.0128815165,
-0.0309112966,
0.0446215719,
-0.0238144472,
-0.0358631238,
0.0499331094,
0.0370078646,
0.0081612589,
-0.0176463742,
-0.0078192446,
-0.0276559126,
-0.0011666415,
0.0067497222,
0.0048023318,
0.0824850574,
-0.0425213389,
-0.0361429006,
-0.0578093566,
0.0231288988,
-0.0153050954,
0.0513531044,
0.0636118352,
-0.0159595795,
-0.0369671918,
0.0037407698,
0.012827104,
0.0356417187,
-0.0134484656,
-0.0069524581,
0.017340159,
0.0037710322,
-0.0389121883,
-0.0469780676,
-0.0177984759,
-0.0208192114,
-0.0019389073,
0.002981676,
0.064230077,
-0.1004543081,
0.0001799328,
-0.005899698,
0.0440577827,
-0.008136387,
-0.0685890913,
-0.0090756314,
-0.0068281153,
0.0516022146,
0.0693084449,
0.0037204151,
0.041037105,
0.0607262552,
-0.0024576185,
-0.0331381969,
0.0152231585,
-0.0345500894,
-0.0370133929,
-0.0450988337,
-0.0384448133,
0.0130725894,
0.0923581272,
-0.0420023538,
-0.0375401825,
-0.037995711,
-0.0033174318,
-0.0062339995,
-0.0375379473,
0.0237018447,
-0.0164746083,
-0.0193390884,
-0.0180145912,
-0.0353220068,
-0.0552718453,
0.0947870389,
-0.007416408,
-0.0111113777,
-0.1086628586,
-0.0141702052,
-0.0178865269,
0.0376480371,
0.0198599026,
0.0249674078,
0.0036466715,
0.008140007,
-0.0471960604,
0.0311885942,
0.0078235157,
0.00060915,
0.029830968,
-0.0765520334,
-0.0000543191,
0.0288735107,
-0.012359228,
-0.0374072306,
-0.0221593343,
0.018196905,
-0.0015872672,
0.0264013093,
-0.0265782289,
-0.0451661609,
-0.0202690326,
-0.0149324406,
0.0353240371,
-0.0147881405,
-0.0117126536,
-0.0472641289,
-0.0446606688,
0.0501993932,
-0.0002951188,
-0.0208562054,
-0.0548221096,
0.0530357175,
0.011580565,
0.0229007602,
-0.0102673536,
-0.0442826711,
0.0531808175,
0.0255715214,
-0.0439084321,
-0.01071609,
0.0396411084,
0.0482119247,
-0.0626801774,
0.0032301689,
0.0814356431,
0.038266331,
-0.0222464334,
0.0155321779,
0.0142426351,
0.0258787274,
0.0260214359,
0.0721580386,
-0.0720817223,
-0.0189003665,
-0.0115304003,
0.0352394991,
0.0035696269,
-0.0301232375,
0.0094151516,
-0.113624908,
0.0265436769,
0.0015761482,
-0.0327976979,
0.0153717669,
-0.0287807528,
0.008681613,
0.0168872103,
0.0083781397,
0.0447262712,
-0.0509097874,
-0.0045692325,
0.0344136953,
0.0187272169,
-0.0478795841,
0.0382890441,
-0.0317884497,
0.0420054495,
0.0843730196,
0.0046414118,
0.0290905591,
-0.0579405501,
0.064845264,
-0.0048346864,
-0.0157207772,
-0.0192659441,
0.0209952965,
-0.0193746276,
-0.0163969882,
0.0128514133,
0.0576725006,
0.0044629937,
0.0358196981,
0.0350621082,
0.0538047515,
0.006926097,
-0.0365929529,
-0.0184192564,
-0.0344298668,
0.0127083203,
0.0234079082,
0.0166984145,
-0.0790130123,
-0.0105512887,
-0.0257132538,
-0.0295018125,
-0.0705558062,
-0.0300558601,
0.0521642417,
-0.0667904094,
-0.029491296,
-0.0558612272,
-0.0136045581,
0.0446809232,
0.022309212,
0.0411339551,
-0.0545421392,
0.0274939816,
-0.0278490335,
-0.0409533754,
0.0236478411,
-0.0303503275,
-0.0196751282,
-0.0894991308,
-0.0932693034,
0.0475439206,
0.0063963621,
-0.0066479999,
0.0006746086,
-0.0653484091,
-0.0609347261,
0.0281804819,
0.1101382226,
0.0066114729,
0.075448513,
-0.0207810923,
-0.0414003804,
0.0214675795,
-0.0088580428,
0.0228429083,
-0.0012842449,
0.0019073996,
-0.0309234764,
-0.0085611911,
0.0003327385,
0.0084664216,
0.0513696447,
0.0480307341,
0.0246444754,
-0.0239104461,
-0.0151352044,
0.0255132783,
0.0060904725,
-0.0046762382,
-0.0371421874,
-0.0290501099,
-0.0278850421,
-0.0004227305,
0.0239837561,
-0.0085187312,
-0.0426700488,
0.0147817293,
0.0092882598,
0.002231383,
0.0131453164,
0.0170328878,
0.007679434,
0.0094701992,
-0.0269136094,
0.0560505651,
0.0093462877,
0.058750499,
0.0521733388,
0.0195256677,
0.0301282145,
0.0359941646,
0.0159340668,
0.0339807458,
-0.0052839611,
0.0563784055,
-0.0002905572,
0.0112618441,
-0.0137332538,
0.0498396233,
-0.0059323888,
-0.0208123401,
-0.0609855466,
0.0432953089,
0.0310083628,
-0.0190008488,
0.0479593016,
-0.0164349936,
-0.0167048983,
-0.0271670017,
0.0014413585,
-0.0540305339,
-0.0225974228,
-0.0021658069,
0.0249657873,
-0.0112697687,
0.0155967344,
0.037827082,
0.0151972119,
0.0703791752,
0.0070092096,
0.0201828405,
-0.0361118019,
-0.0018202265,
0.0091807377,
-0.0271739177,
-0.0220555943,
0.0430736616,
0.0069499533,
-0.0472367406,
-0.0715702251,
0.0474564396,
0.0086334823,
0.0329838544,
0.0642797947,
0.0544694401,
-0.0335696489,
-0.0164742842,
-0.040381562,
-0.0192556176,
0.0111335497,
-0.0329050161,
0.0123123396,
-6.265363584e-33,
-0.0180076249,
0.0229402538,
0.0428678468,
-0.0204719976,
-0.0189111736,
-0.0135022942,
-0.0164190792,
0.0148387551,
-0.0159546211,
-0.0242544934,
0.0192386173,
0.0010543949,
-0.0096554691,
-0.0152430609,
0.0608415827,
-0.0107651697,
0.0243688989,
-0.019575838,
-0.0191556476,
0.0175896864,
-0.0483756512,
0.0162148215,
0.051382523,
-0.057620246,
-0.0120176217,
0.0251855534,
0.0277314931,
0.0202190746,
-0.0235983208,
0.0571157373,
-0.0093807997,
0.0195793789,
-0.0084047504,
-0.0410087705,
-0.0458120704,
-0.0608259924,
-0.0692108348,
-0.0254669376,
-0.0005940557,
0.0070211114,
-0.068087846,
-0.0464016423,
0.0121672126,
0.0179709159,
-0.0394860059,
0.0211018082,
0.0378848538,
0.0071264077,
0.0498114899,
0.0162529275,
-0.0698029324,
0.0244210176,
-0.0154440878,
-0.0606228411,
-0.0027577004,
0.0030990338,
0.0344798937,
-0.0436007418,
0.0015754859,
0.0406635441,
0.0569287576,
0.0258944985,
0.0566492639,
-0.0092680315,
0.0409300253,
-0.0125645362,
0.0231468938,
0.0181448516,
0.0286745131,
0.0118293483,
0.059589874,
0.0551281758,
-0.0030349505,
-0.0454339981,
-0.0122163817,
-0.003292501,
-0.0222578868,
0.0144965611,
0.0436488539,
0.0010869447,
0.0007185943,
0.0282179639,
0.0085233031,
-0.0097136442,
-0.0178732332,
-0.0065944423,
-0.0164583083,
-0.0289825499,
0.0428771973,
0.0169990752,
-0.0667558759,
-0.004264771,
0.021281654,
-0.0349491835,
-0.0368119515,
-0.030686833,
-0.0640533119,
-0.0055324687,
0.0111533133,
0.0706314594,
-0.0239326824,
-0.0887308568,
0.0275183916,
-0.0397756249,
0.0301702619,
0.0060429522,
0.0054006646,
0.015386791,
-0.0557304733,
0.0105441455,
-0.0229874533,
0.0281689763,
0.016066594,
0.0193160623,
0.0013159967,
0.012342453,
0.0184330847,
0.0400137156,
0.048775062,
0.0101865921,
-0.0706078038,
0.0035232892,
0.0235237759,
0.0524197109,
-0.0168579631,
0.022464646,
-0.0435544588,
0.0226015598,
-0.0468967631,
-0.0630952194,
-0.0309258047,
0.0242473409,
2.733e-7,
0.0512659214,
0.0712058395,
0.032306049,
-0.0006730598,
0.0267801061,
0.013978038,
-0.0417474099,
-0.0009000174,
0.0374334194,
-0.0007793398,
0.017813351,
0.0314997658,
0.0202148631,
0.0100214565,
-0.0396437272,
-0.0107894624,
-0.0477559082,
0.0329289287,
-0.0898635238,
0.0171174966,
0.0032457176,
0.0870626792,
0.0182606354,
0.000014313,
0.0148330107,
-0.0020408272,
0.0081096608,
0.0046627545,
0.0220649578,
0.0664150566,
-0.0414208025,
0.0529439487,
-0.0241199564,
-0.0381065682,
-0.0229402538,
0.0291226357,
-0.048621811,
0.0658751056,
-0.0054297419,
0.0215947218,
0.071767427,
0.014501242,
-0.0059385295,
-0.030582387,
0.0849300697,
-0.0407721363,
0.0174287409,
-0.0320465378,
-0.025569411,
-0.0198421031,
-0.0252765939,
-0.036215689,
-0.0082995938,
0.0457325876,
0.0174581036,
-0.0234030094,
-0.0373417698,
-0.0415370986,
0.0289016627,
0.036406707,
-0.0211909153,
-0.0610895194,
-0.0431789048,
0.0423966087,
0.0053855805,
-0.0142799634,
0.0096128294,
2.396647244e-34,
0.0053409948,
-0.0056653772,
0.0584439263,
0.0120143276,
0.0364008024,
-0.0017932126,
-0.0472710952,
0.0220878869,
0.0312014669,
-0.0359113179,
-0.0505035594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00765v1
|
The Embodied World Model Based on LLM with Visual Information and Prediction-Oriented Prompts
| 2024-06-02T14:50:01 | 2024-06-02T14:50:01 |
Wakana Haijima, Kou Nakakubo, Masahiro Suzuki, Yutaka Matsuo
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In recent years, as machine learning, particularly for vision and language
understanding, has been improved, research in embedded AI has also evolved.
VOYAGER is a well-known LLM-based embodied AI that enables autonomous
exploration in the Minecraft world, but it has issues such as underutilization
of visual data and insufficient functionality as a world model. In this
research, the possibility of utilizing visual data and the function of LLM as a
world model were investigated with the aim of improving the performance of
embodied AI. The experimental results revealed that LLM can extract necessary
information from visual data, and the utilization of the information improves
its performance as a world model. It was also suggested that devised prompts
could bring out the LLM's function as a world model.
|
[
0.0084960544,
-0.0429747626,
-0.0257528424,
0.0155041702,
-0.0155642973,
0.0057710917,
-0.052672863,
0.0080411779,
0.0282660425,
0.011460444,
-0.0198842213,
0.0057566008,
-0.0240451712,
0.0253267214,
0.017201636,
-0.0592101663,
0.0340368897,
-0.0577129647,
-0.0202914104,
0.0004664448,
-0.0847452953,
-0.0654837042,
-0.0243672244,
0.0012996095,
0.0025556893,
0.0237544738,
-0.069305703,
0.0302339178,
0.0349549018,
-0.0947709605,
-0.0837236643,
-0.0466465689,
0.0543625988,
-0.0407909676,
0.0000021054,
-0.0229132287,
0.0293842983,
-0.0333177336,
0.007576522,
-0.073394224,
-0.0222242922,
0.033495333,
-0.036141023,
-0.0147890076,
-0.0449296013,
-0.0041825492,
0.0672645122,
0.0219859891,
0.0242158789,
0.042944029,
0.0039580544,
0.0118389418,
0.0243207756,
0.0454164259,
0.0343787894,
0.0377509333,
0.0326354802,
0.0212581679,
0.0593083128,
-0.0050370893,
-0.031731829,
0.0209949631,
0.0123714013,
0.0110939341,
0.001195816,
0.0506606065,
0.0297139101,
-0.0199277773,
-0.0235129129,
0.0289804731,
0.0371717028,
0.0167621952,
0.0462958217,
0.0120527558,
-0.0176214688,
-0.0099209277,
-0.0257228203,
0.097916849,
-0.0419232808,
0.0255097412,
-0.017464472,
0.0012802114,
0.0030687551,
-0.0107998764,
-0.0322306007,
0.0946822762,
0.0151822483,
-0.0127445403,
-0.0242479909,
-0.0101332609,
-0.0139404014,
0.0083684903,
-0.0363398939,
0.0500913002,
-0.0325112939,
0.0249696486,
-0.0285161752,
0.0398052223,
-0.0470389463,
-0.035699632,
0.0871341601,
0.0480950885,
-0.027867632,
0.0575263649,
-0.0229796749,
0.043814905,
-0.0168407075,
0.0605826117,
-0.0032244907,
0.0134196011,
-0.0379845612,
0.020520553,
-0.0028707446,
0.0491931736,
-0.0091861207,
-0.0127886375,
0.0116664357,
0.0674424395,
-0.015713647,
0.0089583118,
-0.0197287966,
-0.0296924505,
0.0186668187,
0.0258277021,
-0.0798182636,
-0.0884070769,
-0.0226793475,
0.0154563952,
0.0104821809,
-0.0394954793,
0.0384019539,
0.0351053476,
0.0042231111,
0.0089946315,
-0.0057774382,
0.0795402303,
0.0541354828,
-0.0229543447,
-0.0832100734,
0.027229283,
0.065351285,
-0.0065671206,
0.0730590969,
-0.0437059663,
0.0272201691,
-0.0583397821,
-0.0028607412,
0.0464448109,
0.0339828394,
-0.0093834857,
0.0237734038,
0.0500542223,
-0.0613079406,
0.0406428315,
0.0189654455,
0.0159061532,
0.0094154608,
0.0450560972,
0.0227166209,
0.0414080024,
-0.0011328796,
-0.011216443,
-0.0110895522,
0.0222865492,
-0.0354978852,
-0.0169798099,
-0.0202083066,
-0.0172937717,
-0.0216811523,
0.0396618806,
-0.0247365683,
0.0252885949,
-0.0228949077,
0.0576074421,
0.0370211825,
0.0435998067,
0.0285557453,
-0.0320064202,
0.0614964999,
-0.0306251682,
0.0465087146,
-0.0150810825,
-0.0304292738,
0.0376402363,
-0.0040197861,
-0.0258435588,
-0.0495319143,
0.000023385,
-0.0039855074,
-0.0501480997,
0.007159858,
-0.0084251706,
-0.0046249498,
-0.0040100059,
0.0297269169,
-0.0219355561,
-0.0297156926,
-0.0416793115,
0.0009460614,
-0.0196770616,
-0.012160575,
-0.0291144233,
0.0588403828,
0.0260320902,
0.0003047253,
-0.0484352857,
0.0056397878,
0.0057618902,
-0.0017537415,
0.049514927,
-0.0217450187,
0.0067489762,
0.0134354951,
0.024259368,
-0.065877378,
-0.0070648822,
-0.0225686748,
0.0838025734,
0.0001113379,
0.0279520918,
-0.0097236671,
-0.0256689228,
0.0047694133,
0.0538015366,
-0.0069861948,
0.0005084393,
-0.0100491848,
0.0175048541,
0.0127770118,
0.0178555436,
-0.0125159947,
-0.0285788886,
0.0501168743,
-0.0190922581,
-0.0312412102,
0.0165123064,
-0.0283048712,
-0.0198420603,
0.0564286634,
-0.066339545,
0.0297866371,
-0.0187967308,
0.0123215159,
-0.0592337511,
-0.0324678719,
-0.0255408827,
0.0338163301,
-0.0091261566,
0.0269392487,
-0.0119439727,
-0.0323548242,
-0.0437533632,
0.0183482319,
-0.0405397788,
-0.0323371068,
0.0273298658,
0.0243089627,
0.0454803258,
-0.0427255891,
-0.0039185267,
0.0623546131,
0.003427743,
-0.0078774467,
0.0275353417,
-0.015053588,
-0.0426479019,
-0.0033620682,
-0.0156493206,
-0.0615077876,
0.0030372795,
-0.0006281962,
0.004858789,
-0.0508159176,
-0.0235732533,
0.0096063241,
0.0189534072,
0.0516660251,
0.0007540915,
-0.0336542353,
0.0362867452,
0.0287974142,
-0.0050238059,
-0.0298553631,
0.0028990407,
-0.0141813746,
-0.0226252861,
-0.0091646388,
-0.0323710963,
-0.0587545484,
0.005802447,
-0.0474649705,
0.0307515468,
-0.0309905056,
-0.0392425172,
0.0210325141,
-0.056833934,
0.0021222169,
0.0286194198,
-0.0199301392,
0.0118960356,
0.1008797213,
-0.0002490163,
-0.0127827972,
0.0209293943,
0.0158582535,
0.057794556,
-0.0029456422,
-0.0142472256,
0.0395150594,
-0.0089180339,
0.0064077019,
0.0188344959,
-0.0324322544,
0.0354643837,
0.0120259896,
-0.069645904,
-0.0089065675,
0.0288529228,
-0.0365940817,
0.0313620679,
-0.0557941608,
-0.0395084247,
0.0408268943,
-0.040016979,
-0.0071254363,
0.1115569845,
-0.0309461057,
-0.0216887202,
0.0407365002,
0.0270187072,
0.0114462068,
-0.0104079563,
-0.0087393112,
-0.0162696317,
-0.0374910496,
-0.0120020481,
-0.0097484337,
-0.0269731302,
-0.0764289796,
-0.0071309251,
0.0042071859,
0.0105223451,
-0.0541504361,
0.0878814384,
0.0035139429,
0.024983447,
-0.045169495,
-0.0002094614,
-0.004968408,
-0.006596209,
0.045839645,
-0.029957043,
-0.0071682478,
-0.0003776772,
-0.0402260758,
-0.0233545303,
0.05336399,
0.0587261841,
-0.005243367,
0.0116494996,
0.1014943123,
0.0225075576,
-0.0474350974,
-0.044072412,
-0.0544093847,
0.051021941,
0.0293661095,
0.0163768437,
-0.015319705,
0.0362998806,
0.0479527488,
-0.0182293244,
-0.0008347434,
0.0472878106,
0.0069436454,
0.0300076269,
-0.0147793386,
-0.0590177216,
-0.0088520302,
0.0419266485,
0.0325307474,
0.0255838968,
0.0245565567,
-0.008339853,
-0.002849825,
-0.002083963,
-0.0309278034,
0.0444827266,
-0.0625336245,
0.0441145003,
-0.0009684793,
-0.0426022895,
-0.0370750241,
-0.0135362186,
-0.0010345484,
0.0398832411,
-0.0699933842,
-0.0012890872,
0.0005670059,
-0.0035757893,
0.0177884027,
-0.011420398,
0.0318250917,
-0.0239496268,
-0.0452744029,
0.0420807153,
0.0584840551,
0.0369372144,
-0.0563962646,
-0.0425999016,
-0.0317437202,
0.037145447,
0.0585232712,
-0.0500913598,
0.0041424776,
0.0042513646,
-0.0216996688,
0.0060915998,
-0.0286871176,
0.0115207247,
-0.0133332284,
-0.0024291438,
0.0696704537,
-0.05989521,
0.0187692754,
-0.0567831732,
-0.029965084,
0.0154840732,
0.0119388206,
-0.0127979014,
0.0106240651,
-0.0434075482,
-0.0202974342,
-0.0249123406,
0.0408586711,
-0.0183176789,
-0.0059490888,
-0.0382822156,
0.0116454158,
-0.0851809159,
-0.0034626261,
0.0299519971,
0.0696378574,
0.0329067037,
0.0019168577,
-0.0217643883,
0.0232708957,
-0.0485000797,
0.0031022755,
-0.0112030944,
0.0244618673,
-0.0424006693,
0.0214457586,
0.0527767688,
-0.0848457664,
0.0320972241,
0.0062597059,
0.0378970057,
-0.0332210623,
0.0127369938,
0.078247495,
0.0121609569,
0.019295333,
-0.0000223736,
-0.0025918528,
0.0379782394,
0.0044868728,
0.0498958156,
0.0242503695,
0.0088633532,
0.0709813386,
0.014458403,
-0.0209890064,
-0.0450924635,
-0.010058553,
0.0361446179,
0.0294209216,
0.022086516,
-0.0658940524,
-0.0200905688,
0.0637159869,
0.0611883327,
-0.0137105491,
0.0143126901,
-0.0182362143,
-0.0224254653,
-0.0060018767,
0.017031379,
-0.0419793501,
0.0601522885,
-0.0229422059,
0.0002913581,
0.0274187643,
0.0221025925,
-0.0265602786,
-0.0287314467,
0.00495682,
0.0427562781,
-0.0196305774,
-0.0004717896,
-0.0353623256,
0.0466169305,
0.014428271,
0.0133235361,
0.0001067158,
0.0405637771,
0.0386928655,
0.0225080438,
0.0147788487,
-0.0445771888,
-0.046393998,
0.0458851457,
-0.0141344247,
-0.0615309998,
0.0732282922,
0.1351988465,
0.0792027116,
0.0278744362,
-0.0443620309,
-0.0484568998,
0.0335910991,
-0.006942376,
-0.0458449572,
0.0886725187,
-0.0203460809,
0.1023958549,
0.0325187109,
-0.0287353918,
-0.0199373085,
-0.0520014875,
0.0189710353,
0.0567697473,
-0.0415919349,
0.0069134254,
-0.0314026736,
0.0360083356,
0.0464366041,
0.0197577998,
-0.0404395834,
0.0538569726,
-0.0144415768,
-0.0285257678,
0.0030647884,
0.0951093286,
-0.0038317826,
-0.0308462195,
0.0025574381,
-0.0032731208,
0.0149469711,
-0.0229202099,
-0.0285897963,
-0.04299872,
-0.0249294061,
0.0196217373,
0.0155918663,
-5.156748617e-33,
-0.0570552684,
-0.0278808046,
0.0539438091,
0.024696134,
-0.0536924563,
-0.0514810905,
-0.0195139609,
0.0271271542,
-0.0249937363,
-0.0347640365,
-0.018018961,
-0.0424337052,
-0.0048013232,
0.0002040758,
-0.0140632847,
0.0041866177,
-0.0028174582,
0.0370472334,
-0.0422134362,
-0.0628710613,
-0.0001603746,
0.0435563289,
0.0187297091,
-0.0341032483,
-0.0092275124,
-0.0008756836,
-0.0083346833,
0.0251630712,
-0.0262169093,
0.0090500116,
-0.0345585048,
-0.0120824836,
0.0184012372,
0.0253137443,
-0.0344682187,
0.0066582588,
-0.0498662218,
-0.0501626134,
0.0155616254,
0.0183873475,
-0.0507166646,
-0.0409912169,
0.0101870056,
-0.0167829134,
0.0020412607,
0.0301304217,
0.0488465205,
-0.0282680392,
-0.0436059944,
0.0355045125,
-0.0144475177,
0.030895913,
0.0082669277,
-0.0367220864,
0.0524608158,
0.0168192461,
0.0021051867,
0.0527135022,
-0.0290947221,
0.0496369116,
-0.0096363742,
-0.0465372205,
0.0255216397,
0.0645227432,
0.0430887304,
0.0613593981,
0.031314373,
-0.008716152,
-0.0631984472,
-0.0292954687,
-0.0063344156,
0.0783279017,
-0.0291546285,
0.0422031134,
-0.0244999304,
0.0192318186,
-0.0117945084,
0.0725620016,
-0.0148225259,
0.0581002086,
-0.0092549035,
0.0075160218,
-0.0244860575,
0.0123416241,
0.0137588521,
-0.0355802402,
0.014260333,
-0.0217020698,
0.0185553841,
-0.0217569098,
-0.023917459,
-0.0902741253,
0.0050265603,
-0.0577095412,
0.0510407463,
-0.0356291234,
-0.0059775473,
0.0368132479,
0.0081762969,
-0.0263731591,
0.000150677,
-0.0668579414,
0.0299199689,
-0.0195511524,
0.0106671387,
0.0075168675,
-0.0550877042,
0.0535351783,
0.0030414131,
-0.0142748477,
-0.0134075293,
-0.0390902013,
0.0250598434,
-0.0627454892,
0.0107817305,
-0.0739316121,
-0.0159190372,
0.0278221183,
-0.0019926659,
-0.0396385305,
0.0191224292,
-0.0197336189,
-0.0462246872,
0.0290706307,
-0.0194385815,
-0.0152828544,
-0.0421582758,
0.0685515702,
-0.0003617608,
-0.0326710455,
0.0017371561,
0.0286860168,
2.956e-7,
-0.0504909456,
0.0074401502,
0.018616436,
-0.0300680213,
0.0090070618,
0.0244398713,
-0.0727520585,
-0.0028345904,
-0.02356923,
-0.0744640157,
0.0492974184,
0.0220920146,
-0.015753448,
-0.0660107657,
-0.0498753376,
0.0386562496,
0.0489002392,
-0.0386609472,
-0.0580237731,
0.0344871245,
0.0458374061,
0.0137429917,
0.0027810517,
-0.0048078685,
0.0261460748,
-0.0086824736,
0.0138586368,
-0.0685644969,
0.0172790401,
-0.0490911193,
0.015103572,
0.0442161486,
-0.0288923364,
-0.0614566132,
0.0007153212,
0.0399883091,
0.0155935176,
0.0372056812,
0.0198274013,
0.0249925721,
0.0235543456,
0.0082526077,
0.0250145458,
-0.0233937912,
0.0199880227,
0.0006298636,
-0.0204843786,
-0.0364344902,
-0.0050204019,
0.0010255047,
-0.0394600853,
-0.0247879401,
0.0048640282,
-0.0695032775,
-0.0450211652,
-0.0319805257,
-0.0271826368,
-0.037315622,
0.026291104,
-0.0366284475,
-0.0233582873,
-0.0521195754,
-0.0277461279,
0.021625109,
0.002288668,
-0.0381370932,
-0.0325417221,
1.831221145e-34,
-0.0265046731,
-0.004098638,
-0.0033149724,
0.0098936772,
-0.0062556905,
0.0380786136,
0.0148938484,
0.0142226983,
-0.0007003894,
-0.0058234232,
0.0037686985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06561v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06561v1
|
Brainstorming Brings Power to Large Language Models of Knowledge Reasoning
| 2024-06-02T14:47:14 | 2024-06-02T14:47:14 |
Zining Qin, Chenhao Wang, Huiling Qin, Weijia Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated amazing capabilities in
language generation, text comprehension, and knowledge reasoning. While a
single powerful model can already handle multiple tasks, relying on a single
perspective can lead to biased and unstable results. Recent studies have
further improved the model's reasoning ability on a wide range of tasks by
introducing multi-model collaboration. However, models with different
capabilities may produce conflicting answers on the same problem, and how to
reasonably obtain the correct answer from multiple candidate models has become
a challenging problem. In this paper, we propose the multi-model brainstorming
based on prompt. It incorporates different models into a group for
brainstorming, and after multiple rounds of reasoning elaboration and
re-inference, a consensus answer is reached within the group. We conducted
experiments on three different types of datasets, and demonstrate that the
brainstorming can significantly improve the effectiveness in logical reasoning
and fact extraction. Furthermore, we find that two small-parameter models can
achieve accuracy approximating that of larger-parameter models through
brainstorming, which provides a new solution for distributed deployment of
LLMs.
|
[
0.0473294109,
0.0370092764,
-0.0110820215,
0.0272114277,
-0.0875593349,
0.0059026377,
0.0736021176,
-0.0375973098,
0.0074179079,
-0.0320848599,
-0.0032521915,
-0.030527439,
0.0038810335,
0.0076566269,
-0.0030279325,
-0.0376326144,
0.0348736383,
-0.0562622882,
0.0113193905,
-0.0376938507,
-0.0095355334,
0.0406349301,
-0.0144304419,
0.0178479366,
-0.0066457973,
-0.0143966423,
-0.0123465117,
-0.0366972722,
0.0075836354,
-0.0090567032,
-0.0296940636,
0.0550600067,
0.0092989169,
0.0187755302,
0.0000021915,
-0.0580303632,
-0.0421455167,
-0.0325185917,
-0.0194587596,
-0.0174475014,
-0.0030327511,
0.0292923544,
0.0314771496,
0.0339125842,
-0.0333731174,
0.0339105651,
0.0203058142,
0.0396472476,
0.0349637046,
0.0128178643,
0.0031833763,
-0.0285743829,
-0.0514960922,
-0.0108738812,
0.0331026427,
-0.0281189959,
0.0360677689,
0.0528385229,
0.0341484547,
-0.0036276982,
0.0146498354,
0.0322806425,
0.024473669,
0.0039491947,
-0.0051867613,
0.0531061292,
-0.01274959,
-0.0532611087,
0.0004405456,
0.0683219582,
0.006241126,
-0.0016925986,
-0.001748577,
-0.0058580595,
0.018539628,
0.06782116,
-0.0292674061,
0.0651951581,
-0.0397975929,
-0.0034617689,
0.0002627411,
-0.0149743473,
0.0244403351,
0.0387378559,
-0.0420926064,
0.1036908105,
0.0135837896,
-0.0188714098,
-0.0132775819,
0.0022366145,
-0.0494713075,
-0.0810476243,
0.0163832195,
0.0446664318,
-0.0536038801,
0.0365436263,
-0.0291004367,
-0.0088492697,
0.0186670348,
-0.0205257777,
0.0307605173,
0.0224555805,
0.015795406,
0.0914211348,
-0.029626321,
-0.0068774777,
-0.0030037987,
0.0151866022,
-0.0320628695,
-0.0155558819,
-0.0817377642,
-0.0289780349,
-0.0160919763,
0.0511325337,
-0.0132444073,
-0.0426608473,
-0.008400457,
0.0373351611,
0.0006463513,
0.0253457427,
0.0219838005,
0.0313159563,
0.00198617,
-0.0501292981,
-0.0441860333,
0.0144403251,
-0.0406628214,
0.0288461018,
0.0371493921,
-0.0177245717,
0.0021744666,
-0.000460293,
-0.0148478029,
-0.0112790298,
0.010202758,
0.0411426835,
-0.0069115562,
0.0238065906,
-0.0291315075,
-0.0983588621,
-0.0118956389,
-0.0718072057,
-0.0277633686,
-0.0821678415,
0.0280997232,
0.0380251296,
-0.0118189128,
-0.0371357426,
0.015592671,
0.0070683146,
-0.0289309248,
0.0861368105,
-0.0205045026,
0.0294946153,
0.0598554388,
0.0503984801,
-0.0315982476,
0.0695722625,
0.0238025784,
0.0310421698,
0.0299361981,
0.0307149999,
0.0007274525,
0.0037936533,
0.0193037018,
-0.0070109647,
-0.0079346057,
0.0268457718,
0.0172314905,
0.0376888737,
-0.0596007667,
0.0543369688,
-0.0422345251,
0.0122265741,
0.0676448494,
0.0221083611,
0.0167454798,
0.0063412618,
0.0175470579,
-0.00415836,
-0.0104245786,
-0.0427776165,
-0.0042476868,
0.0536380708,
-0.0357418209,
0.0070034382,
0.0250051878,
0.0628791079,
-0.0227291901,
-0.025076367,
-0.0192354396,
0.0083973827,
-0.0299843904,
0.0336103551,
0.0284398086,
-0.0187675897,
-0.00939772,
0.0948399156,
0.0086571099,
-0.0396634825,
-0.0071604471,
-0.0370995849,
0.0806118548,
0.066898331,
0.0602777526,
-0.0122749982,
-0.0497716591,
-0.0081067877,
0.0209254492,
0.00835374,
0.0429858305,
-0.0233575217,
-0.0499325395,
-0.0371899568,
-0.0271978937,
-0.0076340903,
-0.0164003335,
0.0237575825,
0.0120396251,
-0.0044358643,
0.0252551585,
-0.0029200118,
0.0072895652,
0.0050641252,
-0.0471875183,
0.037087176,
-0.0235663317,
-0.006600149,
0.0310097504,
0.0031963757,
-0.0201676041,
0.0304629412,
0.0014417859,
-0.0107029686,
-0.0500495769,
0.0321961604,
-0.0245149359,
-0.0150774475,
0.0427631885,
0.0368517525,
0.0166562088,
-0.0316096731,
-0.0168875325,
-0.0275787711,
0.0020424719,
0.0061197961,
-0.0092729088,
-0.026866179,
0.0213272348,
-0.0102658998,
-0.0241593812,
-0.0221609697,
0.0905281007,
0.0002238211,
-0.0151958959,
0.0305287335,
0.0174055453,
0.0316060968,
-0.0339281783,
-0.0073769866,
0.0499010757,
0.0030541332,
-0.0166923236,
0.0093230195,
0.002429167,
-0.0663677529,
-0.0383276232,
-0.0872737393,
0.0254205801,
0.0034617705,
-0.0058883503,
0.0141030662,
-0.0033566691,
0.0034003081,
0.0092468634,
-0.0597506277,
0.0162183121,
0.0272796359,
0.0369447619,
0.019168485,
-0.006646072,
-0.013247801,
0.0195292775,
0.0108137447,
-0.0099404305,
0.0446539,
0.0452691801,
-0.0000394853,
-0.0882678404,
0.028049659,
-0.1188497767,
-0.0050678756,
0.0313126706,
0.0025412899,
0.0292522348,
-0.0249957889,
0.0291758738,
0.065543443,
0.0063283117,
-0.0125383483,
0.086103797,
-0.0298363809,
-0.0473718196,
0.0047445255,
-0.0090186438,
0.0369968191,
0.0031822205,
-0.0180098154,
-0.0202497598,
0.0221054181,
0.0165489353,
-0.0193924606,
-0.0434684753,
0.0932077169,
-0.0046182666,
-0.0189829133,
-0.0467319563,
-0.0188403446,
0.0261671096,
0.0940931365,
-0.0099053569,
-0.0310296733,
0.0840993002,
-0.009376145,
0.0181849767,
-0.0536329187,
0.0204010606,
-0.0320410468,
0.0571807064,
-0.0520598069,
0.032722,
-0.0208482817,
0.0088110203,
-0.0424638316,
-0.0358987115,
0.0457532443,
-0.0373099148,
0.0007523848,
-0.0843406767,
-0.0025144827,
0.0041512456,
-0.0358527377,
-0.039092347,
-0.0335994624,
-0.0633342341,
0.0229180735,
0.0130645931,
-0.0157339461,
-0.0406738892,
0.0255204514,
0.0522545837,
-0.0013660439,
0.0000173653,
-0.0183569025,
-0.0103736268,
-0.0069033811,
0.0526501611,
0.0155076515,
0.0182634406,
-0.0292193685,
0.0618843548,
0.0556017831,
-0.0002430144,
-0.0115877213,
-0.0071110874,
-0.0000034068,
0.0022909415,
-0.0273819007,
-0.0075978688,
0.0074512865,
0.0477625318,
-0.0240680128,
-0.0020050141,
0.1254407018,
0.0625612438,
-0.0101127159,
-0.0175853167,
-0.0525448285,
0.041694615,
0.0175965168,
0.0189126842,
-0.0616411194,
-0.0314588472,
0.0209763627,
-0.0046887626,
-0.007855325,
-0.0629193634,
-0.0375024155,
-0.0906622112,
0.0455226451,
0.0098214941,
-0.0076246262,
0.0033296503,
-0.0245898385,
-0.0027824256,
-0.0063423975,
-0.0208543185,
0.0431136265,
0.0339558274,
0.0259966459,
0.0241857544,
0.0109490659,
-0.0432283953,
0.0544703677,
-0.0223315731,
0.051091861,
0.0400530025,
0.0127152316,
0.0433832817,
-0.0613740981,
-0.0167428572,
0.0515518598,
0.0192949623,
-0.0442517325,
0.0267326012,
0.0146431923,
-0.0017956462,
-0.0091574779,
0.0314355381,
-0.0238112677,
-0.0198432654,
0.048728805,
0.0823625103,
-0.0290613174,
-0.0090164188,
0.0037708085,
0.0394764431,
-0.0022679688,
0.0962992087,
0.0064207953,
-0.0186586808,
-0.0191317126,
-0.0071776891,
-0.0530677661,
-0.0449156873,
-0.0235764738,
-0.0065062102,
0.0093626035,
0.0253022667,
-0.0633756667,
-0.0077486937,
0.0888218358,
0.0656576008,
0.0246274192,
0.0031859819,
-0.0040214853,
0.0166435987,
-0.0037564444,
-0.0060115298,
-0.0377131067,
0.0171368718,
-0.0331979692,
-0.0032497386,
0.0108921165,
-0.0552194826,
-0.0247839168,
0.035861209,
-0.0772328004,
-0.0915049836,
-0.0082656294,
0.0137369391,
0.0331221782,
0.0227834657,
-0.012756357,
-0.0387200825,
0.0484341942,
0.0190408304,
-0.0437777527,
-0.0117034391,
-0.0159526635,
0.0369926505,
0.0101205399,
0.0389047563,
-0.0166287441,
0.0240856837,
0.0242783464,
0.0251482408,
-0.0420646444,
-0.0330572203,
0.0351514332,
0.0532141179,
-0.0333409831,
-0.0083827153,
-0.0249136873,
-0.031719923,
-0.0026493759,
-0.0342398211,
-0.0668263882,
-0.0281893741,
0.0332893766,
0.0129771139,
-0.0589681268,
0.026919974,
-0.0240602568,
0.0124448119,
0.009628105,
0.0089874538,
-0.0162401684,
0.0116508799,
0.0114077991,
0.0583009496,
-0.0359383747,
-0.0215901509,
-0.0322412252,
-0.0357748084,
0.0224905796,
-0.0041475566,
0.0917849019,
0.0217037816,
-0.0394344181,
-0.0471595526,
0.0038150484,
-0.0823936462,
-0.1256084591,
0.0371225029,
0.0583583489,
0.0248910598,
0.0447924174,
-0.0062215398,
-0.0604621507,
-0.0180264469,
-0.0098810028,
0.0311368126,
0.0304834601,
-0.0324301906,
0.0351033024,
0.0149760591,
-0.0435988307,
-0.0322141349,
0.0728832036,
-0.0531511195,
0.0299314782,
-0.0041678823,
-0.0614674538,
-0.0514057204,
-0.0147453202,
-0.0139262425,
0.009418739,
-0.028242236,
0.029908143,
-0.0656511188,
-0.0251289103,
0.0001817754,
0.0128934346,
0.0191387758,
0.0087488275,
0.0094048241,
0.0882667005,
-0.0047779046,
-0.0179314762,
-0.0464743227,
0.00904107,
-0.0591532402,
-0.0026613385,
-0.0250400156,
-6.75308721e-33,
-0.0031100998,
-0.0510278232,
0.0694904178,
-0.0296680853,
0.0026477361,
-0.0224447921,
-0.018026568,
0.0200354885,
-0.0181839112,
-0.0030666625,
0.0023324713,
0.0071147117,
0.0117537826,
-0.0066894554,
0.029339442,
-0.0087133916,
0.0409535207,
0.0108172903,
-0.0353534184,
0.034925174,
0.0844464377,
0.0069949282,
-0.0020945652,
-0.038844604,
0.0237756073,
0.0061276099,
-0.0090572909,
0.0333440304,
-0.064325273,
0.0242260974,
-0.0047570574,
-0.0023404097,
0.0173162576,
-0.045926284,
-0.0219167415,
-0.0066680135,
0.0085909814,
-0.025347827,
0.0497717932,
-0.0279039759,
-0.0237952005,
-0.0143148918,
-0.0117532685,
-0.0029929741,
0.0338116512,
-0.0274484791,
0.0163995344,
-0.0309130084,
-0.0378665514,
0.021692913,
-0.0347956941,
0.0267999936,
-0.0079897987,
-0.036630109,
0.0169262066,
0.0579242259,
-0.0041889059,
0.0046957955,
-0.0405417271,
0.0438930318,
0.0544350967,
0.0147925643,
0.0830722749,
-0.0070781112,
-0.0073465975,
0.0547034331,
-0.028578084,
-0.0039307666,
-0.0526539311,
0.0182329435,
-0.0552589148,
0.1026077047,
0.0539379828,
0.0400916897,
-0.0191524252,
-0.0017158425,
-0.0381181911,
-0.0097173145,
0.0079643726,
0.0161215421,
0.0653498024,
0.0001655251,
-0.0225738343,
-0.0147142867,
-0.0392979942,
-0.0032267526,
-0.0484459884,
-0.0308158379,
0.0283210799,
0.0041326596,
-0.0368574373,
-0.0035514089,
0.0245993417,
-0.0197297968,
0.0041419738,
0.0435031578,
-0.0125798639,
-0.0084712356,
-0.0256204028,
-0.0071531837,
-0.0569330603,
-0.0060243164,
0.0063119885,
0.0132620344,
-0.0215735137,
0.0262240861,
0.0028107623,
-0.0215004757,
-0.0360312872,
-0.0068182568,
-0.0491015278,
0.0208750721,
-0.003646953,
-0.02407814,
0.0301322564,
0.0205835346,
-0.0221188366,
-0.0350283012,
0.0255509261,
-0.0703258067,
-0.0203217864,
0.0149089908,
-0.0344183221,
0.0066076489,
-0.0094665941,
-0.0072617526,
-0.0368185937,
-0.0493695699,
0.0382960625,
0.0138484715,
-0.0184863936,
0.0178570636,
2.957e-7,
0.0025036051,
0.0182253737,
-0.0323585607,
0.0168246366,
0.0028008278,
0.0330586396,
-0.0084236348,
-0.0120677287,
0.0298243463,
-0.0277426727,
-0.0073083225,
0.0594654791,
0.050308045,
0.0519981235,
-0.0641809776,
-0.031736616,
-0.0559389554,
0.0040925927,
-0.057203982,
-0.0261007939,
0.0620201938,
0.0332133546,
0.0444127731,
-0.0152998492,
0.0087837419,
-0.04950618,
0.0485294946,
-0.0204280857,
-0.004258303,
0.0446907021,
0.0702912658,
-0.0118426122,
0.0118403789,
0.0770961195,
0.003244437,
-0.0308297705,
-0.0374903269,
0.0360790193,
0.0224427022,
0.0057944674,
-0.039073661,
-0.024140453,
0.00117926,
-0.0919291675,
0.0829989761,
-0.0634548217,
-0.0167264827,
-0.0082059111,
0.0363646708,
-0.0393838957,
0.0263236649,
-0.0151523603,
0.0185499452,
-0.0051321094,
-0.0200586617,
0.0011854159,
-0.0002141558,
-0.0621578097,
-0.0121432142,
-0.0143587012,
-0.0690976083,
-0.0647182465,
-0.0100862635,
-0.0177110154,
0.0187327471,
-0.0669510067,
0.0127006071,
2.441803905e-34,
0.0134114567,
0.0121988887,
-0.0023622517,
0.0401348397,
0.0576778464,
-0.0185834337,
-0.0180462711,
-0.0079902289,
0.0047771498,
-0.0705933198,
-0.0262052938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00755v1
|
Evaluating Mathematical Reasoning of Large Language Models: A Focus on Error Identification and Correction
| 2024-06-02T14:16:24 | 2024-06-02T14:16:24 |
Xiaoyuan Li, Wenjie Wang, Moxin Li, Junrong Guo, Yang Zhang, Fuli Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the realm of
mathematical reasoning necessitates comprehensive evaluations to gauge progress
and inspire future directions. Existing assessments predominantly focus on
problem-solving from the examinee perspective, overlooking a dual perspective
of examiner regarding error identification and correction. From the examiner
perspective, we define four evaluation tasks for error identification and
correction along with a new dataset with annotated error types and steps. We
also design diverse prompts to thoroughly evaluate eleven representative LLMs.
Our principal findings indicate that GPT-4 outperforms all models, while
open-source model LLaMA-2-7B demonstrates comparable abilities to closed-source
models GPT-3.5 and Gemini Pro. Notably, calculation error proves the most
challenging error type. Moreover, prompting LLMs with the error types can
improve the average correction accuracy by 47.9\%. These results reveal
potential directions for developing the mathematical reasoning abilities of
LLMs. Our code and dataset is available on https://github.com/LittleCirc1e/EIC.
|
[
0.0018460191,
0.0839041919,
-0.0204717219,
0.0612692721,
-0.0543294586,
0.011412059,
0.0136376768,
-0.0117818024,
-0.030850077,
-0.030246228,
-0.0059138481,
-0.05335382,
0.0248239841,
0.0011396291,
0.0298243817,
-0.0264318138,
0.0394717231,
-0.0830093175,
0.0113627817,
-0.0081667453,
-0.0051509524,
0.0041025043,
-0.0434393324,
0.024828421,
0.0008071558,
-0.0634474978,
0.0018738718,
-0.0363824554,
0.0047120857,
-0.0399295166,
-0.0154150473,
0.0565384887,
0.0036725276,
0.0727035105,
0.0000022455,
-0.0737901405,
-0.0102880616,
0.0149687948,
-0.063251242,
0.0502833016,
0.0198795907,
0.0016982342,
-0.017224798,
0.0208667293,
0.0015147135,
-0.0073372084,
0.029165091,
-0.000775256,
0.0566760339,
0.0398616157,
0.0100694988,
-0.0343953259,
0.0290288292,
-0.00664393,
0.0191258416,
-0.0417050608,
0.0165762696,
0.055455111,
0.0337748602,
-0.0022920889,
-0.015808858,
0.0257160086,
0.0555719398,
-0.0278576761,
-0.035905119,
0.0142278466,
-0.0219985191,
-0.0023405787,
-0.0053586042,
0.0470231771,
0.0404164493,
-0.0303315334,
-0.0419559292,
0.0025314467,
-0.0222655609,
0.0030283339,
-0.0565453954,
0.0332591496,
0.0069690659,
0.004088135,
0.0065060654,
-0.0240501892,
0.0225121174,
0.0117763933,
-0.0279893316,
0.1092062443,
0.0233303122,
-0.0538668782,
-0.0086755473,
0.0135355024,
-0.0504250452,
-0.0572783612,
0.0245571025,
0.0562154576,
-0.0123034762,
0.02358092,
-0.0138440477,
-0.0253552645,
0.0025257173,
-0.0326634534,
0.0430624522,
0.0602389872,
0.0002412424,
0.048742447,
-0.0061049503,
0.0974938944,
0.0060777795,
0.0464812033,
-0.0185345896,
0.0315992609,
-0.0176985748,
-0.0266477484,
-0.0112818992,
0.0146954628,
0.0182802789,
0.0279027503,
-0.0525492057,
-0.0069226655,
-0.0277140774,
0.0422634743,
0.0182178654,
-0.0337507315,
0.0259122625,
-0.0339602008,
-0.0425114669,
0.0169515572,
-0.0046993685,
0.0222720038,
-0.0040478269,
-0.0601919033,
-0.021687042,
0.021764867,
-0.0234513432,
-0.0182291511,
0.0202784855,
0.038433414,
0.0240607895,
-0.0028798806,
-0.004733237,
-0.0123030897,
-0.0092907511,
-0.0899295211,
0.0068294904,
-0.0946523845,
0.0097784288,
0.0232019182,
-0.0085462648,
-0.0347395539,
0.0231056344,
-0.002620395,
0.0238174722,
0.0618134327,
-0.0108649023,
0.0314034857,
0.0067259315,
0.0073453304,
-0.018884439,
0.0418215469,
0.0613161176,
-0.0330661647,
0.0171803162,
-0.0291968118,
0.0225615595,
0.0456867777,
-0.0084109111,
-0.0053759716,
-0.0210228115,
0.0187396575,
-0.0071459683,
0.0564215407,
-0.0161142275,
0.073740527,
-0.0227515418,
0.0279585402,
0.0319977738,
0.0542905442,
-0.0165511146,
0.0074799773,
0.0293514691,
-0.035598401,
0.0538282543,
-0.0241230652,
-0.0679311454,
0.0034163618,
-0.0393543206,
0.0109859742,
0.0039146827,
0.0142883109,
0.001533171,
-0.068559438,
-0.0373786166,
0.0102203824,
-0.0157873407,
0.0185727887,
0.0717040896,
-0.0256917961,
-0.0057650255,
0.0689922422,
-0.0197665114,
-0.0657028258,
-0.0085367849,
-0.0651428476,
0.0501448065,
0.0295677483,
0.054076042,
-0.0185575262,
-0.0460054986,
-0.0170261394,
0.0054014656,
0.0404969752,
0.0595626868,
0.0061850981,
-0.0456685089,
-0.0310159214,
0.0111085307,
-0.0003004284,
0.0203781482,
-0.0063363304,
0.0149012171,
0.0119519504,
0.0215037744,
-0.0386915915,
-0.0167929623,
0.0013660302,
-0.0277943537,
-0.0314331427,
-0.0530447513,
-0.0138647454,
0.0151166031,
0.0186529104,
0.0015694998,
0.0496982187,
0.0013969505,
-0.0059548528,
0.0028528739,
-0.0037786572,
-0.0353746898,
-0.0002087112,
0.0965299979,
-0.0266540498,
-0.0558803566,
0.0230720732,
-0.0319773592,
-0.0244095884,
0.0506727062,
-0.0415554456,
-0.0015620139,
-0.0204770025,
0.0415642597,
-0.031330727,
-0.02922309,
0.0074837115,
0.0565369874,
0.0208537709,
0.0553807542,
0.0211341828,
0.0103600826,
0.0167668145,
-0.0168999769,
-0.0569412969,
0.0197538417,
0.0000462629,
0.007743265,
-0.0097075058,
0.029835809,
-0.0538622104,
-0.0082062623,
-0.038377095,
-0.0095295804,
-0.0080041969,
0.0796040744,
0.0240695123,
-0.0421968549,
-0.0237597767,
0.0290702675,
-0.010731644,
-0.035853114,
0.0225571599,
-0.0192572456,
0.0274936575,
-0.0231274422,
-0.0544956028,
-0.0424761251,
-0.0213752687,
-0.0688534081,
0.018937679,
0.0234911572,
0.0507020541,
-0.062278349,
0.0391875505,
-0.0470122695,
-0.0124278544,
0.0174918361,
-0.0050608683,
0.0331539214,
-0.0270006992,
0.0286964905,
0.0262381397,
-0.054079093,
0.0390593559,
0.0348168463,
-0.059280958,
-0.0495596826,
0.0054365313,
0.0165773481,
-0.0201277882,
-0.0100524351,
-0.0408625416,
-0.0575731583,
0.0698962137,
-0.0236659143,
-0.0236351788,
-0.0145860501,
0.0456535146,
-0.0676460415,
0.0152717764,
-0.0230373908,
-0.018767627,
-0.0081899455,
0.0540920161,
-0.0214998797,
-0.0375313535,
0.0723325908,
-0.0488749109,
-0.0141852656,
-0.0573713407,
0.0277562682,
-0.0491069816,
0.0581973977,
-0.0097778738,
-0.0083587766,
-0.0105542121,
-0.0146889566,
-0.0271972958,
-0.0159227122,
0.0199362934,
-0.0414013825,
0.0812731758,
-0.0830409005,
0.0124849547,
-0.004806607,
-0.0254699066,
-0.01650065,
0.0256364662,
-0.0427807346,
0.0259149652,
-0.0086835651,
-0.0249476302,
-0.024880413,
0.0169734564,
0.0308032446,
0.0050891368,
-0.0306793954,
-0.0098152738,
-0.0210270192,
-0.0050256234,
-0.0030949428,
0.0361843146,
0.0620972253,
-0.0592144802,
0.0211628769,
0.0303846803,
0.062115714,
0.0298035536,
-0.0191755164,
0.0238702539,
0.0410358272,
-0.0331045054,
-0.031828057,
0.0216128174,
0.0416521989,
-0.0737415925,
-0.0121148368,
0.1186343133,
0.0502213351,
-0.0065240967,
0.0021917303,
-0.0676495582,
0.0001416428,
0.0184956212,
0.0188145451,
-0.0881051645,
-0.0091649089,
0.0438697226,
0.0034949689,
0.0025975604,
-0.0236700177,
-0.0018810607,
-0.1484300792,
0.046923168,
0.0333101526,
-0.0334045961,
-0.0230812207,
-0.038254533,
0.0208267272,
0.0106423739,
0.0423275717,
0.0632878616,
-0.0083100609,
0.0079027759,
0.0385073386,
-0.0314338841,
-0.070987612,
0.053892497,
-0.0039711138,
0.0364980474,
0.0208036192,
0.0097532189,
-0.031604249,
-0.0671709925,
0.0331233777,
0.0116067417,
-0.0450407602,
0.0046153553,
-0.0279521532,
0.0309408382,
-0.0028273284,
-0.0323898643,
0.0155672003,
-0.053960368,
-0.0356298089,
-0.0013523084,
0.1193989143,
-0.0075150747,
-0.0004834555,
0.0003638653,
-0.0019955805,
-0.0356795676,
0.0384888351,
0.0429088064,
0.0112424893,
-0.0499208458,
-0.0567499734,
-0.0311857741,
-0.036646843,
-0.0213624686,
0.0177134275,
0.0522313751,
-0.0138938054,
0.008035698,
-0.0390625149,
0.064897038,
-0.0022601509,
0.0108420271,
-0.0409671776,
0.0027295772,
0.0017513287,
-0.0018430399,
0.0336551592,
-0.0398764648,
0.0792986155,
-0.0678626373,
0.0530899204,
-0.0040603476,
0.0062821223,
-0.0310636126,
0.0290310625,
-0.0885120407,
-0.0572334304,
0.0006148375,
0.0451034158,
0.0306126326,
-0.0397266522,
-0.018925814,
-0.0413315035,
-0.0184545293,
0.0060776779,
-0.0198641121,
0.0116348127,
0.0079143727,
-0.0084753903,
0.027093105,
0.0087790117,
0.0051106894,
0.0020399303,
-0.0104983123,
0.0514589176,
0.0048928079,
-0.0315000638,
0.036467649,
0.0882048979,
0.0153957494,
0.0135272043,
0.0045013702,
-0.0219304748,
0.0355519429,
-0.0539370142,
-0.0232181028,
-0.0195675604,
0.0019240506,
0.0052047805,
-0.0240285806,
-0.002282796,
-0.0260127448,
-0.0198458023,
0.0240056943,
0.0023619747,
0.0806250647,
0.0021933326,
0.0297019053,
0.0293776877,
-0.0350126177,
0.0066674436,
-0.0241278782,
-0.0256258287,
0.0540956706,
-0.0038993128,
0.0510900617,
-0.0055459426,
0.0096532153,
-0.0045323689,
-0.0061785849,
-0.0129816234,
-0.0817561895,
0.0014378232,
0.0480566919,
0.0608374141,
0.0317405164,
0.034563303,
-0.051706627,
0.002548384,
-0.0168133695,
0.01809269,
0.0101169748,
-0.0157920569,
0.0506555662,
0.040953692,
0.0227979887,
-0.0405147746,
0.0343240649,
-0.044873938,
0.0404708423,
-0.0050512357,
-0.0041404073,
-0.0045238752,
-0.0286451224,
-0.0219103973,
-0.0279402602,
-0.0293589365,
-0.0333761685,
-0.0820838809,
-0.1005697921,
0.0088230968,
0.0717418566,
-0.008589468,
-0.0044864719,
0.0174950622,
0.072034739,
-0.0238628034,
-0.0207874589,
-0.003457271,
0.0033994215,
-0.025725428,
-0.0173764694,
-0.0096360706,
-6.188534008e-33,
-0.0399481803,
-0.0252648853,
0.0454539619,
-0.0217053853,
-0.0121227782,
-0.0444545448,
-0.0568097867,
0.0427368544,
0.0136506306,
0.0056554503,
-0.0025844739,
0.0154208951,
0.0081277434,
-0.0079770684,
0.0236908179,
-0.012423357,
-0.0009006323,
0.0107285725,
-0.026864551,
-0.0075487178,
-0.0054651061,
-0.0174818654,
0.0916113406,
-0.0469284654,
0.0766499266,
-0.0058624684,
-0.0353052542,
0.0275929049,
-0.0756121576,
0.0824162737,
-0.0061573484,
0.0251912177,
-0.008527806,
-0.0232613739,
-0.0126182893,
-0.0291160066,
-0.0126599176,
-0.0348909386,
0.0433423296,
0.0243434981,
-0.0248711277,
-0.049291674,
0.029518621,
0.0209654123,
-0.0732991099,
-0.0108684655,
0.0125327818,
-0.0276177656,
0.0217096992,
0.0503226407,
-0.0236369707,
0.0285581723,
-0.0314051546,
-0.0040766974,
-0.000195668,
0.0451158546,
-0.0346594453,
0.0012498461,
-0.0477641784,
0.0236424059,
0.0622661896,
0.0121726822,
0.0855442286,
-0.0332744569,
-0.0047363415,
0.0149424616,
0.029904604,
-0.0329284221,
-0.0295406319,
-0.021452697,
0.0316271447,
0.0222996119,
0.0802046582,
0.0176458396,
0.0309494436,
0.0035311128,
-0.0679827407,
0.0031803488,
-0.0074390136,
0.0655611157,
0.0172074381,
-0.0156249329,
-0.0497860797,
-0.0159244575,
-0.0664597005,
0.0173084866,
-0.0544059463,
-0.0329197049,
0.0325586461,
-0.0655591935,
-0.0043736827,
-0.0062616137,
0.0126997381,
-0.0394858383,
-0.0602583401,
-0.019845821,
0.0061620548,
0.0558741838,
-0.0196981672,
0.0571507104,
-0.050272245,
0.002038121,
-0.0273036063,
-0.0004878737,
0.0405955352,
0.0150486324,
-0.0048219278,
0.0530685112,
-0.0424926393,
0.0090228831,
-0.047041934,
-0.0192940664,
0.0351235531,
0.0396451391,
0.0283155851,
0.0044806581,
0.0112685636,
0.0229075588,
-0.0089129014,
0.0023120774,
-0.0268591866,
0.032141652,
-0.0186407752,
0.0124568511,
-0.0068704369,
-0.0339131206,
-0.0393493585,
0.0240334515,
0.0190043487,
-0.0268130805,
0.0066364333,
-0.0016811886,
2.941e-7,
0.0584040396,
0.057314381,
0.0118103921,
0.0429262966,
0.0138854114,
0.0072139748,
-0.069261618,
-0.0407362059,
0.0394511968,
0.0194015149,
0.01812163,
0.0352615938,
0.0635128319,
0.0523378178,
-0.0321583934,
0.0244048573,
-0.0429112054,
-0.0225106589,
-0.0402921215,
0.0361691453,
0.070839487,
0.0466455631,
0.0215111338,
0.0061433311,
-0.0299431756,
-0.0502616465,
0.0375634208,
-0.0205919687,
-0.006831388,
0.0356061645,
0.0285101272,
-0.0058864052,
0.012671249,
0.004101126,
0.01560691,
-0.0201271996,
0.0169219095,
0.0526061542,
0.0001758774,
0.0417453982,
-0.0198928267,
-0.0216505844,
-0.0086797038,
-0.070266284,
0.050831046,
-0.0308996253,
-0.0268376321,
0.012519734,
0.000638624,
-0.039865341,
0.0224173777,
-0.009810335,
0.0027753834,
0.0087638889,
0.0180694014,
-0.0146984318,
-0.0209595952,
-0.0311327018,
-0.014876076,
0.0316278227,
-0.0272765532,
-0.061372783,
-0.0324524716,
-0.0062433654,
0.0113650821,
-0.0395289585,
-0.0152955139,
2.801264338e-34,
0.0493626334,
-0.0147337336,
0.0400727652,
0.0337598622,
0.0547440574,
0.0181481335,
0.007476036,
0.0059149191,
-0.0030674743,
-0.0772157833,
-0.0296229143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00751v1
|
How well do distributed representations convey contextual lexical semantics: a Thesis Proposal
| 2024-06-02T14:08:51 | 2024-06-02T14:08:51 |
Zhu Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern neural networks (NNs), trained on extensive raw sentence data,
construct distributed representations by compressing individual words into
dense, continuous, high-dimensional vectors. These representations are
specifically designed to capture the varied meanings, including ambiguity, of
word occurrences within context. In this thesis, our objective is to examine
the efficacy of distributed representations from NNs in encoding lexical
meaning. Initially, we identify four sources of ambiguity - homonymy, polysemy,
semantic roles, and multifunctionality - based on the relatedness and
similarity of meanings influenced by context. Subsequently, we aim to evaluate
these sources by collecting or constructing multilingual datasets, leveraging
various language models, and employing linguistic analysis tools.
|
[
0.017439751,
0.0561440773,
-0.0468371287,
0.0883363187,
-0.0570466779,
-0.0034914813,
0.035356462,
-0.0093193781,
-0.017279176,
-0.0507820211,
-0.0462836437,
-0.0633968711,
0.019714335,
0.0059885415,
0.0313001834,
-0.0008102071,
0.0428212211,
0.067148678,
-0.0207496863,
-0.0211339183,
-0.029106915,
0.0136542534,
-0.0130071938,
0.05797581,
-0.0403695516,
-0.0332164504,
0.0121431891,
0.0011961508,
0.006461008,
-0.0076853242,
-0.0022331295,
-0.0038876196,
0.0441549718,
0.0742291138,
0.0000016389,
-0.0345172435,
0.0152556412,
-0.0197371207,
-0.0257744882,
0.0037778933,
0.0315115377,
-0.0486483276,
-0.0108012892,
-0.0458911769,
-0.0375922658,
-0.0081264181,
0.0381671898,
-0.0161036998,
0.0133923776,
0.0328430273,
0.0032408563,
-0.0619027317,
0.0034303076,
-0.040055871,
-0.0139025953,
0.010326745,
0.0093385503,
0.0132178171,
-0.0084937979,
0.0160463229,
-0.0448293202,
0.0484477766,
0.041989632,
0.0397296622,
-0.0408630893,
0.0402525477,
-0.0075834976,
0.0080656977,
-0.0038849874,
0.0590925664,
-0.0367053561,
0.0119148577,
-0.028868733,
-0.0403488614,
-0.0096570412,
0.0153744407,
-0.001147065,
0.0589079112,
0.0124439439,
0.0477529243,
0.014732765,
0.0048438646,
0.0492015481,
0.0491667688,
-0.0288770199,
0.0699947253,
0.0125104263,
-0.0191340502,
0.0074669831,
-0.0209354647,
-0.0594280288,
0.0117687471,
0.0597899407,
0.0246099476,
-0.0006243652,
0.0639828965,
0.006593145,
-0.0504373163,
0.0443109348,
-0.1069030836,
0.0372468308,
0.0343653671,
-0.0086686667,
0.0080813607,
-0.0474190712,
0.0322512798,
-0.0295557138,
0.037044961,
-0.0561785959,
-0.0118711367,
-0.0456508137,
-0.0424029119,
-0.0154936612,
0.0582098514,
-0.0447633192,
-0.0540948659,
-0.036008928,
0.0369957909,
-0.0318773948,
0.0165203214,
-0.0034310885,
0.0587072633,
-0.0539645068,
0.042842567,
-0.0461564027,
0.0246013664,
-0.037754558,
0.0324586146,
-0.0523837358,
-0.0286945831,
-0.008258746,
0.0009850799,
0.0211037286,
-0.0431810245,
0.0104511296,
0.0609821305,
0.0334992856,
-0.0325328298,
0.0021166166,
-0.037550021,
-0.0706372932,
-0.0203259345,
-0.0020066861,
-0.0471793301,
0.0328009799,
0.0139892967,
0.0074540977,
-0.0296122395,
0.0175506137,
0.0100203976,
-0.034196984,
0.106875442,
0.0039545386,
-0.0189070441,
-0.0001269839,
0.0065158634,
0.0410958305,
0.060312815,
0.0363919064,
0.0243374389,
0.0394852161,
0.0029644461,
-0.053575132,
-0.0203953646,
0.0156603046,
-0.0214392431,
-0.0211358164,
-0.0324283876,
-0.0321239159,
0.0782511607,
-0.0063190493,
0.0448452905,
-0.0182781015,
-0.0374373384,
0.0534613244,
0.0601009354,
0.0192693081,
-0.0123346904,
0.0750651658,
-0.002032476,
-0.0127529977,
0.0275620762,
-0.0341871493,
-0.013780321,
0.0250538774,
0.0106467437,
-0.0360954553,
0.0210180413,
-0.0199749563,
-0.011254712,
-0.0111600952,
-0.0161246993,
0.0214861576,
-0.0218006,
0.0371150672,
0.0059774229,
-0.0223936345,
0.0799352676,
0.0424237251,
-0.0271950066,
0.0176258925,
0.0253524836,
-0.0076492964,
0.05322982,
0.0061829239,
-0.0140435081,
-0.0470529571,
-0.0109503865,
-0.0312395412,
0.0351460837,
-0.0092154713,
-0.0082148397,
0.0572218373,
-0.041390758,
-0.0015905313,
-0.0274795648,
0.0132366996,
0.0253182389,
-0.0266214702,
0.0270833522,
0.0286991261,
-0.0209702123,
0.0243525393,
0.0393222831,
0.0030702872,
-0.0217495281,
0.0111503582,
0.0207914561,
0.0421836711,
0.0300227404,
-0.0259970855,
0.0151306223,
0.0559466556,
-0.0578391142,
-0.041018337,
0.0249045771,
-0.0992337316,
-0.0420353413,
0.0170522816,
-0.0376061425,
-0.0088620745,
0.0445381477,
-0.0341184661,
0.0121348994,
0.0330847651,
-0.0241491217,
0.0263075996,
-0.0614304282,
-0.0292996168,
-0.0105579989,
0.0526231267,
-0.0265189447,
0.0804993287,
-0.0176837333,
0.0573206842,
-0.059552677,
0.0549179912,
0.0500009172,
-0.0017791645,
-0.0183406435,
0.016328644,
-0.0207554884,
-0.0070767934,
-0.0051979353,
0.0106113916,
-0.0269399118,
-0.0053844438,
-0.0919961259,
0.0075708758,
-0.0208565332,
-0.0065992954,
0.0436624624,
0.0181671623,
0.0309239514,
-0.0015502266,
-0.0139546925,
0.0380294286,
-0.0075497981,
0.0365353748,
0.0492105894,
0.0075220624,
-0.0215388462,
0.0097190002,
-0.0359550007,
-0.0268370286,
0.0428653248,
-0.028183762,
0.0233622529,
-0.0205253903,
-0.0101409145,
-0.0457672179,
-0.015003358,
-0.0013874222,
-0.017130347,
0.0150884381,
0.0343901627,
0.0073114657,
0.0004421482,
-0.0024200906,
0.0818344802,
0.0414848067,
-0.0035096647,
-0.0335587114,
0.0001629825,
-0.0421603397,
0.0148698343,
-0.0422113463,
0.0078754993,
-0.018677298,
0.0352588817,
0.0590316243,
-0.0270364881,
-0.0067707291,
0.019871261,
-0.0623759143,
-0.053654436,
-0.0514684208,
-0.0151991332,
-0.0243302267,
0.0171231162,
-0.0150389085,
-0.0151483016,
0.0632332265,
0.0062260809,
0.0051687821,
-0.0472457297,
-0.025046045,
-0.0414203256,
0.0791036934,
-0.0088761076,
0.0447217077,
-0.0411212966,
-0.0478647985,
-0.0450180024,
-0.0229263641,
-0.0090058567,
-0.02247639,
0.0504910462,
-0.0079668034,
-0.0289920401,
-0.0106895119,
-0.0211257152,
-0.0229847375,
-0.0570538826,
0.0028925913,
0.0368557908,
0.0361129865,
0.0225540195,
-0.0094820606,
-0.0280038342,
-0.0273937322,
-0.0109122703,
0.0131175527,
-0.0161372088,
-0.0354029723,
0.0392778665,
0.0015168773,
0.0251240265,
0.0570005812,
0.0101397075,
-0.0329231955,
0.0077539911,
-0.0198902972,
0.0152568826,
-0.0346105359,
0.0266713649,
0.0067966767,
-0.0382923447,
-0.0254956018,
-0.0278706569,
0.0406833179,
-0.0272137225,
-0.0112957507,
0.0819063336,
0.0408021659,
-0.0568825938,
0.0658662841,
-0.0201059319,
-0.0055701658,
0.0115659963,
-0.0094255069,
-0.0943810493,
0.0020802387,
-0.0248566531,
-0.051581692,
0.0088101961,
-0.0172971357,
-0.0097881649,
-0.1005330086,
-0.0096337507,
0.0006303758,
-0.0708294511,
-0.0116378469,
-0.0040134378,
0.0115924431,
-0.0022151978,
0.0510046594,
-0.0443321876,
-0.0010453956,
-0.0158712547,
0.0052363737,
0.04560256,
-0.0542584434,
-0.0004008381,
-0.0385205559,
0.0365550146,
0.0450175591,
0.0399805456,
-0.0441699438,
-0.0184530094,
-0.0090293474,
-0.0363549702,
-0.0062986957,
-0.0276539139,
0.0112415934,
-0.0259131808,
-0.030614797,
0.0005252666,
-0.0217875931,
-0.056792926,
-0.0218459535,
-0.0212335829,
0.0604368486,
-0.0165541042,
-0.016530307,
-0.0334298089,
-0.0192765109,
0.0244075824,
0.0726605058,
0.0137301032,
-0.0294759348,
-0.0065245051,
0.0054585026,
0.0328788944,
0.0064354413,
-0.0029804343,
0.0091869207,
-0.0018044747,
-0.0117493151,
-0.0475386754,
-0.0701797828,
0.0133873643,
-0.0008386272,
0.0267214309,
0.0121862935,
0.0136564961,
-0.0081526153,
-0.070246391,
-0.0075431075,
0.0098362919,
0.0607897975,
0.0324461237,
-0.0024551691,
0.0315766744,
0.0136371525,
-0.0312927216,
0.0249286462,
-0.0559213273,
-0.0370972119,
0.0444626361,
0.0043257466,
0.0165261924,
0.0146770906,
-0.0442889445,
-0.0114079937,
0.0493121669,
0.0249863267,
-0.0081368107,
0.0450988784,
0.0129387137,
0.0313792266,
0.0067049549,
0.0607321337,
-0.0343840271,
0.0357587896,
0.0106889717,
0.0436737016,
0.0020932693,
-0.0636891499,
0.0039651152,
-0.0372311845,
0.0150107713,
-0.0027358406,
0.0073867091,
0.0065995706,
-0.000827392,
-0.0133671258,
-0.0182829071,
-0.0048923339,
-0.0285798311,
0.0278751403,
0.0184972063,
-0.0312538035,
-0.0012477889,
0.0307392068,
0.0536379702,
0.0056180931,
-0.0258549973,
0.0241337847,
-0.0392536707,
-0.0387300923,
0.0687783137,
-0.0334630571,
0.0200668145,
-0.0572005436,
0.0117649641,
-0.0313181728,
-0.0061997399,
0.022126779,
-0.0157652237,
-0.0571203865,
0.0360386446,
-0.0656441748,
0.0013885619,
0.0138518726,
-0.0056344057,
0.054517068,
-0.0379158482,
0.0086785844,
-0.0286631081,
0.01707213,
-0.0113796452,
-0.0006781358,
0.0133655537,
-0.0034426791,
0.0648464262,
0.0226441585,
-0.0063314722,
-0.0160315223,
0.065578714,
-0.0511638895,
0.0552231967,
-0.0004413015,
-0.0239980873,
-0.0282494556,
-0.0210999809,
0.0014578527,
0.0858215764,
-0.0105145248,
0.0109370137,
-0.0472027399,
-0.0722825378,
0.0430818535,
0.0124906907,
0.0247532129,
-0.0114948824,
0.0159549825,
0.0470215715,
0.0479438081,
0.0003798829,
-0.0270508192,
0.0384226069,
-0.0015266541,
-0.0217524786,
-0.0282330904,
-6.184052436e-33,
-0.0260014161,
-0.0468741655,
-0.0491210259,
-0.0443549007,
-0.0321408771,
0.0214700792,
-0.038603127,
-0.0192959756,
-0.0454364233,
0.026538793,
0.0172715448,
0.0276685879,
0.0117443074,
0.0395275429,
0.040838901,
-0.0295504052,
0.0196861904,
0.0232676193,
0.0485625416,
-0.0043652831,
0.0912098736,
0.0227587242,
0.0580832027,
-0.0672432929,
0.0432531759,
-0.0008848093,
0.0084543778,
0.0146445371,
-0.0319219567,
0.0559311248,
-0.0345322452,
0.1109728441,
0.0389613695,
0.0037090969,
-0.0089915264,
0.0081860926,
-0.0578297339,
-0.0736321434,
0.0633701831,
0.0108629428,
-0.0194364525,
-0.0499225445,
0.0579276644,
-0.0323472284,
-0.005323865,
0.0332634524,
0.0284481607,
-0.0016532713,
-0.0397967435,
-0.0312736183,
-0.0698183626,
-0.0318835489,
-0.0005644889,
0.0292587429,
0.0051210374,
-0.004433068,
0.0018570364,
0.020845335,
-0.0657720566,
-0.0033127563,
-0.0781288147,
0.0142682521,
0.0182605349,
0.0477704331,
0.0173604395,
0.0691154674,
0.0279948935,
-0.0474042296,
-0.050608784,
-0.0156526994,
0.0387640446,
0.0162036717,
0.0261659622,
0.0401339009,
0.0385119319,
-0.0323157161,
-0.0381757617,
-0.0416376069,
0.03391001,
-0.0071551227,
0.0573421083,
0.0126901213,
-0.0098337447,
-0.0232792068,
-0.0354546942,
0.0034869171,
-0.0217024349,
-0.0582465418,
0.0139410421,
-0.0404072031,
0.0123540806,
0.1388322413,
0.0033313076,
-0.0671466887,
-0.0296894312,
0.019429272,
0.0321254618,
-0.0036767756,
0.0543696098,
0.0145687172,
-0.0197116546,
-0.022357991,
-0.0240692925,
0.0150203286,
0.0212455206,
0.0163366776,
0.0489318594,
0.0007371923,
0.0016386665,
-0.0156567637,
-0.0385425277,
-0.0730527043,
-0.0268066134,
-0.019007029,
0.0271413196,
0.0345362909,
-0.0383457281,
-0.0027886552,
0.0779840201,
0.0005001774,
-0.0062579629,
0.0166003164,
-0.0266860519,
0.0513175204,
-0.0445109531,
-0.0380098298,
-0.0391069278,
0.0264075641,
0.0617154017,
-0.0447302759,
-0.0050211628,
-0.0164363515,
2.614e-7,
0.0841230378,
0.0099791195,
-0.0156855322,
0.0164550282,
0.0311531257,
-0.0036942165,
-0.0336962566,
0.0538997464,
-0.0476040803,
-0.0219077524,
0.0012781331,
0.0259769112,
-0.0140682999,
-0.0034511024,
-0.0278846566,
0.0142475553,
-0.0315715373,
0.0154017229,
-0.0536016487,
0.084178485,
0.0730460733,
0.1267477125,
0.0496599786,
-0.013589737,
-0.0155741991,
-0.010377612,
0.0280916914,
-0.0269488655,
0.0138896732,
-0.0256681144,
-0.0326998495,
0.0145136602,
0.0179101191,
0.0205165315,
0.0235050172,
0.0248248857,
0.0189319625,
0.026293043,
-0.0108846156,
-0.0117007168,
-0.0415803865,
-0.0486066081,
0.0008932784,
-0.032969214,
0.0743923113,
-0.0660896823,
-0.0721842796,
-0.015900014,
0.0388926528,
0.0345960632,
0.0623507537,
0.0047192946,
-0.0333718099,
-0.0290962141,
0.0093914429,
-0.0207121819,
-0.030193625,
-0.0865947455,
0.0051305764,
0.0171279665,
-0.0192498807,
-0.0077856681,
-0.0074371765,
-0.0017423516,
0.0887643322,
-0.0696265846,
-0.0110487677,
1.783904398e-34,
0.005236682,
0.0206234902,
0.0143071851,
0.0357656516,
-0.013027099,
-0.0242927112,
0.0206606071,
0.000329985,
0.0002396799,
-0.0316914096,
0.0024680025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06560v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06560v1
|
Inverse Constitutional AI: Compressing Preferences into Principles
| 2024-06-02T11:54:50 | 2024-06-02T11:54:50 |
Arduin Findeis, Timo Kaufmann, Eyke Hüllermeier, Samuel Albanie, Robert Mullins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Feedback data plays an important role in fine-tuning and evaluating
state-of-the-art AI models. Often pairwise text preferences are used: given two
texts, human (or AI) annotators select the "better" one. Such feedback data is
widely used to align models to human preferences (e.g., reinforcement learning
from human feedback), or to rank models according to human preferences (e.g.,
Chatbot Arena). Despite its wide-spread use, prior work has demonstrated that
human-annotated pairwise text preference data often exhibits unintended biases.
For example, human annotators have been shown to prefer assertive over truthful
texts in certain contexts. Models trained or evaluated on this data may
implicitly encode these biases in a manner hard to identify. In this paper, we
formulate the interpretation of existing pairwise text preference data as a
compression task: the Inverse Constitutional AI (ICAI) problem. In
constitutional AI, a set of principles (or constitution) is used to provide
feedback and fine-tune AI models. The ICAI problem inverts this process: given
a dataset of feedback, we aim to extract a constitution that best enables a
large language model (LLM) to reconstruct the original annotations. We propose
a corresponding initial ICAI algorithm and validate its generated constitutions
quantitatively based on reconstructed annotations. Generated constitutions have
many potential use-cases -- they may help identify undesirable biases, scale
feedback to unseen data or assist with adapting LLMs to individual user
preferences. We demonstrate our approach on a variety of datasets: (a)
synthetic feedback datasets with known underlying principles; (b) the
AlpacaEval dataset of cross-annotated human feedback; and (c) the crowdsourced
Chatbot Arena data set. We release the code for our algorithm and experiments
at https://github.com/rdnfn/icai .
|
[
0.0720327273,
0.0648491308,
-0.0381292291,
0.0128642591,
-0.0492698848,
0.0368285514,
-0.06337367,
0.0257031191,
0.0193944629,
-0.0588073805,
-0.0509567186,
-0.014866326,
0.0047655096,
0.010299392,
-0.0171759445,
-0.0502533391,
0.0263839997,
-0.0084955599,
0.050215587,
-0.0001755137,
0.0278822649,
0.0041168095,
0.0143752666,
0.0527607352,
-0.0409596413,
0.0046028546,
-0.0100912927,
-0.0323724225,
-0.0022271897,
0.0066336058,
0.0078899441,
0.0477120429,
-0.0037343877,
-0.015644405,
0.00000213,
-0.0205570608,
0.0068181944,
-0.0159029569,
0.0148113556,
0.0097766006,
0.0850678459,
0.0323723517,
-0.0038576142,
0.0154145509,
-0.0458510108,
0.0328668319,
0.037621107,
0.0345648192,
0.0772544146,
0.0805635005,
-0.0026047004,
-0.010425603,
-0.017056454,
-0.021930201,
-0.0144769475,
-0.0365181714,
0.0122370254,
0.0016692149,
0.0010296884,
0.0310894884,
0.0274419636,
-0.0025301778,
0.0148736555,
-0.0040254602,
-0.0196429621,
0.0001892517,
-0.0462942496,
-0.049659919,
-0.0044676573,
0.082756713,
0.0712691918,
-0.0495748892,
-0.0054408601,
-0.0153706772,
0.0530910902,
-0.0071948403,
-0.0280646328,
0.0169677921,
-0.0025239841,
0.0300136767,
0.0369992629,
-0.0077090086,
0.0004001946,
0.0100396052,
-0.0254556481,
0.0581289865,
-0.0205054358,
-0.033856608,
0.0219623204,
0.011699765,
-0.0530601144,
-0.0420276076,
0.0322604105,
0.0022198386,
-0.0331989489,
0.019561531,
-0.0552343503,
-0.0131964544,
0.0325463079,
-0.0481355451,
0.0276811272,
0.036036931,
-0.0200672857,
0.0392433219,
0.0133295516,
0.0563456006,
0.0031579728,
0.051949501,
-0.047495272,
-0.0334270708,
-0.0511851572,
0.0074895122,
-0.0217221789,
0.0621147715,
-0.0239096507,
0.0160542279,
-0.0244903266,
0.0162823014,
-0.0392116755,
0.0389485769,
0.0172719713,
0.0171847232,
-0.0496391989,
0.0016853486,
-0.0587833114,
0.0093415938,
-0.0505274422,
0.0323190503,
0.0211792029,
-0.0177799594,
0.0137445331,
0.0253661014,
-0.0193617195,
-0.0003729627,
0.0137656312,
0.0557697117,
0.0037593266,
-0.0073222723,
-0.0105867796,
-0.0134203546,
-0.0317530818,
-0.0460305251,
-0.0269595999,
-0.0495652966,
0.0459603965,
-0.0088025341,
-0.0111971479,
-0.0672754347,
-0.0029355041,
0.0360300429,
-0.0399811827,
0.0516263731,
0.023076307,
-0.0101693673,
0.0257222112,
-0.0082115438,
-0.0403433703,
0.0317049399,
0.0414802507,
0.0664785579,
0.0346607305,
0.0045483946,
0.0123775499,
0.0270105265,
0.0337375142,
0.0277557131,
-0.0220681485,
0.016426377,
-0.0533787571,
0.0224676616,
0.0240938887,
0.0815235898,
-0.0211336743,
-0.0216427185,
0.0637749285,
0.0459166616,
-0.0303133335,
0.0306251403,
0.0197737459,
0.0218063034,
0.0148515096,
0.0372294635,
-0.0402616896,
0.0292674974,
-0.0429915115,
-0.0315958485,
0.0164471511,
-0.0487621613,
-0.0182673726,
-0.0979914218,
0.0095478678,
-0.0447075069,
0.0360232741,
-0.0030195965,
0.0390615128,
0.01809429,
-0.0352846533,
-0.0250690989,
0.0489089973,
-0.0589217842,
-0.0314807408,
-0.0505165942,
0.0266768876,
0.0539546236,
0.0212733932,
-0.0490550175,
0.0064787469,
-0.0051856786,
-0.0168597233,
0.0450212918,
0.0782581568,
-0.0447203964,
-0.0371184945,
-0.0439405292,
-0.0092730317,
0.0037587304,
0.0160448216,
0.0385445058,
-0.0182631202,
-0.026434863,
-0.016063787,
0.001657691,
-0.0724611953,
0.0455124862,
-0.0158864371,
-0.0146445744,
0.0390080921,
0.0034233194,
0.0712766126,
0.0123614082,
0.005392564,
0.0051016784,
0.0261356402,
-0.0082250601,
-0.0412455797,
0.0040230267,
-0.0253572818,
-0.0147119965,
0.0254320763,
-0.0337224901,
-0.011233232,
0.078887552,
-0.0350989029,
-0.0121468855,
-0.0135827689,
-0.0330184698,
0.0314890668,
-0.0243841857,
0.0188894458,
-0.0195986666,
-0.0471044295,
-0.0433422439,
0.0367632993,
-0.0344486497,
-0.0413537472,
0.0130793555,
-0.0338862613,
0.014312963,
-0.0089741992,
-0.0346109122,
0.0001701234,
-0.0011511861,
0.0266725477,
0.0729177073,
0.0167629812,
-0.0106136836,
-0.0398835316,
-0.0877586156,
-0.0142926155,
-0.0128378235,
-0.0155003332,
0.0323176421,
-0.0093066851,
0.025344016,
-0.0095584039,
-0.0571194291,
-0.0193466526,
-0.0172036365,
0.0202634279,
0.0469244383,
0.0150637338,
0.0057955333,
-0.0744865239,
0.0036071634,
-0.0347988605,
-0.0009316408,
-0.0034333288,
-0.0133516202,
-0.0496518873,
0.058290489,
-0.0123317977,
0.032011427,
-0.0281219315,
-0.0551771857,
0.0214453302,
0.0002890023,
-0.0213371068,
0.0863873661,
0.0473151356,
0.0457290225,
0.0817825273,
0.0498240851,
-0.0925533921,
-0.0019784344,
-0.0272892546,
-0.0063282689,
-0.0129358023,
-0.0246977787,
0.044831533,
0.0515351146,
0.0141504547,
0.0181282833,
-0.1016502529,
0.0229985379,
-0.0203064252,
-0.0358276442,
0.0121448338,
-0.0331421643,
-0.0280258879,
0.0553119406,
-0.0105931461,
-0.0284643155,
0.1063177735,
-0.0031356972,
0.0499940962,
-0.0485113151,
0.0024254844,
-0.0352490246,
0.0295005329,
0.0055875168,
0.0343106911,
0.0090845339,
0.0099932654,
-0.0413071662,
-0.0157679487,
0.0470426679,
-0.0504450314,
0.0117830429,
-0.027293697,
0.0126300873,
0.0166063141,
-0.1010358557,
-0.0352523848,
-0.0475753173,
0.0124447867,
-0.0010710343,
0.0533219837,
-0.0242409632,
-0.0231554341,
-0.0339186713,
-0.0027085277,
0.0158616249,
0.0221179016,
-0.0122360922,
0.0077273427,
-0.0199603532,
0.0309905391,
0.0149681503,
0.0127274133,
0.0040071621,
-0.0253890846,
0.0502438135,
0.0049875183,
0.0290855579,
-0.0093118688,
-0.0081219655,
0.0183682144,
-0.032977242,
-0.0321962163,
0.0140556432,
0.0235273838,
-0.0025029578,
-0.0108472686,
0.0872989744,
0.047648713,
-0.084740296,
0.0347752646,
0.0056082639,
0.0351272523,
0.0160427913,
0.0383131132,
-0.0931119397,
-0.0086476635,
0.0057853209,
0.0376705863,
-0.0452544242,
-0.0282095205,
-0.0038538047,
-0.1264308244,
0.0090965759,
0.0079669785,
-0.0347797014,
-0.0239058658,
-0.0446466394,
0.0041561183,
-0.0539322086,
-0.0022399989,
-0.0017159347,
0.0385962129,
0.0033546879,
0.0117167793,
-0.0357979871,
-0.0333322622,
0.0372236148,
-0.0082898457,
0.0674151033,
0.0634657443,
0.077037774,
0.0149826044,
-0.0105384374,
0.0121479379,
0.0155159356,
-0.0031316343,
-0.0024011957,
0.0513508879,
-0.0162265263,
0.0119712139,
0.0007478036,
0.0518194772,
-0.0024172366,
-0.006374273,
0.0196005888,
0.0190532096,
-0.0281047057,
0.0206672307,
-0.014550467,
-0.0041801003,
0.0267541204,
0.0833741203,
0.0326291732,
-0.0831959918,
-0.0135106575,
-0.0521157049,
-0.0250664763,
-0.0558561608,
-0.0509427749,
0.0185002759,
0.0208479185,
0.027130235,
-0.116681464,
-0.0533095151,
-0.0282605402,
0.0223674458,
0.0311653819,
-0.0209513158,
0.0270581655,
-0.0239006504,
0.0307485573,
-0.0045669996,
-0.0439187624,
-0.034549851,
-0.0467597246,
-0.0275946911,
0.0203702431,
-0.0333727971,
-0.0210578628,
0.0185685903,
-0.0210501179,
-0.0441241674,
0.0132154608,
0.0767985135,
0.0188794341,
0.0769998282,
-0.0215422362,
-0.0650606602,
0.0137691023,
0.0206386168,
-0.034069851,
0.0122342864,
0.0431887992,
0.0299330764,
-0.001622868,
0.0512976497,
-0.0471121296,
0.021740105,
-0.0035611563,
-0.0018054143,
-0.0100730099,
-0.0394079462,
0.0678710788,
0.0511654355,
0.0099155232,
-0.010988594,
-0.039300438,
-0.0008926176,
0.0050414894,
-0.03176127,
-0.0481643118,
-0.040848963,
-0.0083936201,
0.0178211778,
-0.036500901,
-0.027283743,
-0.0455937423,
-0.0089218551,
0.0353123657,
-0.0381368846,
0.0060732737,
0.064801313,
0.0425897948,
0.0021091904,
-0.0030910422,
-0.0295793209,
0.0189309511,
0.0045394301,
0.0748773292,
-0.0197646879,
0.0480078235,
0.0339941531,
-0.0016394892,
-0.0072347424,
0.0589942299,
-0.0391692556,
-0.0236624274,
-0.0248652566,
0.0123111559,
0.0193068217,
-0.0201524273,
0.0544220768,
-0.0301582105,
0.0064953119,
-0.0165168196,
0.0224609636,
0.0068702307,
-0.0161969271,
-0.0045016068,
0.0031821439,
-0.0178679302,
0.0473320857,
0.0604549386,
-0.019834362,
0.0416626781,
-0.0351417288,
-0.0075325724,
-0.0552353784,
-0.0031886215,
-0.0119619388,
0.0234229136,
-0.0163635556,
-0.0475491472,
-0.0504097492,
-0.0156114912,
-0.0206630491,
0.0246519819,
0.0050184811,
0.0012623745,
0.035621915,
0.0529923365,
-0.0447896048,
0.0199193135,
-0.0639325455,
-0.0415417738,
-0.0383571237,
-0.0216430966,
-0.0387610868,
-5.993923204e-33,
-0.0394927338,
-0.0120012434,
0.0020277011,
0.0411948077,
0.0043262769,
-0.0331557691,
-0.0089616952,
0.0128353136,
-0.0313622467,
-0.0045769936,
-0.0257277749,
-0.0081158644,
0.0006983145,
-0.009804762,
0.0141900573,
-0.0066414494,
0.0393899158,
-0.0254511405,
-0.0775592476,
0.0297381897,
0.0530048311,
-0.0268828813,
0.0321051814,
-0.1019890606,
0.0276931264,
0.0347094908,
-0.0364309065,
-0.0022237564,
-0.0526177362,
0.0862044245,
-0.0141808735,
0.0349168628,
0.0103781233,
-0.0291053858,
-0.0038913204,
0.03336142,
-0.0269251112,
-0.0316373259,
0.0086998725,
0.0024157944,
0.0144219752,
-0.0423008949,
0.0475268923,
-0.0169942472,
-0.038316384,
0.0244710855,
0.0338948593,
-0.0209092163,
0.0135749327,
0.0170887187,
-0.0669956505,
-0.002486812,
-0.0389273278,
-0.0403263643,
-0.0065416112,
0.0875798389,
-0.0183719937,
0.0429346077,
-0.0508605652,
0.0552201495,
-0.0200685076,
0.0142206959,
0.0363013484,
-0.0457754359,
0.0034753224,
0.0769791752,
0.0223355554,
0.0513869934,
-0.0187570192,
-0.0325749218,
0.0314675272,
0.0537800826,
0.0510461368,
0.0933486149,
0.0127922045,
-0.0447706021,
-0.0423226692,
0.0519410893,
0.0256081354,
0.0155135226,
0.0186007973,
0.0215613339,
-0.079146333,
-0.0193431601,
-0.0584072843,
-0.0730621815,
-0.0186605025,
-0.0224002916,
0.0251135696,
0.0048314813,
-0.0375894085,
-0.0315359384,
0.0348304771,
-0.0504509285,
-0.0208427217,
0.0203527994,
-0.0689818487,
0.0348281935,
-0.0027911225,
-0.0156683438,
-0.0577457994,
-0.0226419456,
0.0050725508,
0.0077991909,
0.0507753007,
0.012853465,
0.0497751646,
0.020625541,
-0.0227731466,
-0.0036216897,
-0.0018439045,
0.0018149827,
0.0176680628,
-0.0137004368,
0.0476151146,
0.0235276558,
-0.0099700736,
0.0475327298,
-0.0132955667,
-0.0155125987,
-0.0406642742,
-0.0399871394,
0.012722875,
-0.0219336525,
-0.0318633504,
-0.0259109419,
-0.0085073216,
0.0058840341,
0.0125455698,
-0.0154261207,
-0.0123013705,
0.0012940018,
2.715e-7,
0.0182416104,
0.0628980249,
0.0206651725,
-0.0345523879,
-0.0091596944,
0.0772798061,
0.0038603276,
0.0148829529,
0.0195157472,
-0.0134516284,
0.0503158011,
0.0189924408,
0.0324419402,
0.0325601213,
-0.0832265541,
-0.0189571548,
-0.0721278414,
-0.0137164276,
-0.0181244668,
0.008102349,
0.0468590371,
0.0742399246,
0.0400433987,
-0.0142727988,
-0.0188672654,
0.027198365,
0.0497299619,
-0.0573136657,
-0.0250270907,
0.0099072102,
0.0053392719,
-0.0012970009,
-0.0052651437,
0.0114329085,
-0.0006760458,
0.0030404553,
-0.0136100939,
0.0832437351,
-0.0052805478,
-0.0277709309,
-0.0033441777,
0.034038242,
0.0175578129,
-0.0471245758,
0.0524721257,
-0.0396027751,
-0.0405324362,
-0.0646987036,
0.0000648798,
-0.0187931489,
0.0262795053,
-0.0161656626,
0.0158750322,
0.0012877815,
0.004022955,
0.0388098955,
-0.0106531577,
-0.0533387214,
0.010518359,
0.0138359144,
-0.0228737872,
0.0016965142,
-0.0157557856,
0.0586482249,
-0.0005882379,
-0.0597602539,
0.0283195637,
2.363136931e-34,
0.0022728737,
-0.0300964043,
0.0418528579,
0.0127758505,
0.0357611328,
0.0451664664,
0.0312960371,
0.0247185472,
0.0247323755,
-0.0564740635,
-0.0097356746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00697v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00697v2
|
Comprehensive Evaluation of Large Language Models for Topic Modeling
| 2024-06-02T10:25:02 | 2024-06-25T08:42:53 |
Tomoki Doi, Masaru Isonuma, Hitomi Yanaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) for topic modeling,
generating comprehensible topic labels for given documents. However, their
performance has mainly been evaluated qualitatively, and there remains room for
quantitative investigation of their capabilities. In this paper, we
quantitatively evaluate LLMs from multiple perspectives: the quality of topics,
the impact of LLM-specific concerns, such as hallucination and shortcuts for
limited documents, and LLMs' controllability of topic categories via prompts.
Our findings show that LLMs can identify coherent and diverse topics with few
hallucinations but may take shortcuts by focusing only on parts of documents.
We also found that their controllability is limited.
|
[
0.0338019691,
0.0267572757,
0.0035719601,
0.0167334862,
-0.0499375015,
0.0209881607,
0.0145540927,
-0.0042793131,
-0.0134149622,
-0.0468072556,
-0.0270602871,
-0.0267509799,
-0.0460609011,
0.0032955972,
-0.0242432654,
-0.0579458363,
0.0094398148,
-0.084299162,
-0.0021886548,
-0.0001497763,
0.0027898471,
0.0141100781,
0.0212246329,
0.0027169499,
0.0108971354,
-0.0236682594,
-0.0111548034,
-0.0295304153,
-0.0429917239,
-0.018480869,
-0.0107857957,
0.034116067,
0.0140522411,
0.0338891037,
0.0000019803,
-0.0277555138,
-0.007750669,
-0.0406964719,
0.0311479233,
0.0425466746,
0.0528129563,
-0.0366968103,
0.018634785,
-0.0087560192,
0.0111702606,
-0.0155206705,
-0.013287669,
0.1067165211,
0.0462088212,
0.042317234,
-0.0398493893,
-0.0350922942,
0.0395115167,
-0.0117108952,
0.0568803549,
-0.0343521535,
0.0388159454,
0.04334132,
0.0503470898,
0.0568348058,
0.0074968929,
0.0217939857,
0.0072046206,
-0.0326790623,
0.0389240161,
0.0390731804,
-0.0166504942,
-0.0407416523,
-0.0020245188,
0.0384746641,
-0.0187072083,
-0.0114611983,
0.0476273634,
-0.0122923767,
-0.0522513501,
0.015929779,
-0.0540573783,
0.0478358567,
-0.0196629446,
0.0223767329,
0.0839532092,
0.0048228698,
0.0485068001,
0.0190961193,
-0.0193880573,
0.0503803007,
0.0422171392,
-0.02060402,
0.0017178957,
0.000303384,
-0.0114539927,
-0.0685962737,
0.0364337973,
0.014759603,
-0.0475780517,
0.0150566716,
-0.0262209624,
-0.006675201,
0.0420573391,
-0.0702703819,
-0.0210454762,
-0.03927752,
-0.0338726565,
0.1220312715,
0.0222053025,
0.0048412266,
-0.0578846373,
-0.017046405,
-0.042575255,
-0.0327452645,
-0.0316623226,
0.015690919,
-0.0288118534,
0.0147979194,
0.0087444354,
-0.0516617298,
0.0288351178,
0.0407470204,
0.0123905819,
0.0157969408,
-0.0277908985,
-0.0405728593,
-0.014296459,
-0.059506651,
-0.0063115843,
0.0249947812,
-0.0435936525,
0.0170959141,
-0.0187580232,
0.0149870664,
0.0340415835,
0.0551120527,
-0.0146363117,
-0.0109911934,
-0.013908755,
0.0160890482,
-0.0084796501,
-0.0158904698,
-0.0450475626,
-0.004683434,
-0.0004425952,
-0.0168459546,
0.0171923731,
-0.0837899595,
-0.0157897417,
0.0283031967,
0.0093278084,
-0.0176792908,
0.0256186333,
-0.0041624489,
-0.0441601984,
0.0350809842,
-0.0385901704,
0.0093122227,
0.0903250054,
0.0426024906,
0.0007273025,
0.0749878511,
-0.0310633052,
0.072700642,
0.0456973538,
0.0023121201,
0.0282854065,
0.0062568332,
-0.0316888765,
0.0451983288,
-0.0143601904,
-0.0029455211,
0.0469216816,
0.0224111117,
0.014821141,
0.0602109879,
-0.022711616,
-0.0007786331,
0.0569635518,
0.0535899773,
0.018814465,
0.0346308164,
-0.001255491,
0.0130295567,
0.0098364642,
0.0062878658,
0.0006385766,
-0.0108173992,
0.0067691202,
-0.0143656703,
0.0613454357,
-0.0299768187,
-0.0477795675,
-0.0220106933,
-0.0351880118,
-0.0132515719,
-0.0346456803,
-0.0331668556,
0.0879684761,
-0.0061673983,
0.0254661087,
0.03434458,
0.0348939486,
0.0262575056,
0.0337307006,
-0.0045559946,
0.0588154793,
0.0647234917,
0.0564362817,
-0.0492044203,
0.0056236601,
-0.0218247864,
0.0855427235,
0.0359583236,
0.0296601411,
-0.0140871992,
-0.0235085785,
-0.0239229873,
0.0181385577,
0.0003947199,
0.0338175595,
0.007756385,
-0.0243252181,
-0.0175380558,
-0.0072168168,
-0.0464181975,
0.0028677462,
0.0310352501,
-0.0205250122,
-0.0114296246,
0.0011623561,
-0.0541634634,
0.0233644918,
0.0012977028,
-0.0033616759,
0.0103801619,
0.0249512941,
-0.0533311069,
-0.0380731374,
-0.0442637652,
-0.0236910004,
0.0451284051,
0.0303173661,
-0.0205980297,
0.0094693396,
-0.0380296409,
0.0084566446,
-0.0340775214,
0.0135087436,
-0.0289056674,
-0.0053258012,
-0.0407642759,
0.0297415424,
-0.0167334117,
-0.0062042605,
-0.0184065774,
0.0654679239,
0.0050219162,
0.0529185608,
0.038927272,
-0.005293834,
0.0005167304,
-0.0158641078,
-0.0089851785,
0.0649647638,
0.0369337201,
0.0213718861,
0.0190863106,
-0.029278744,
-0.0272331666,
-0.0632535964,
-0.0879041553,
0.0211178008,
-0.0312436149,
-0.0165726244,
0.0312491786,
-0.0210455321,
-0.0013066428,
0.0114117395,
-0.0254110601,
-0.0315357335,
0.000221306,
0.02789158,
-0.0067025209,
0.006175153,
-0.0011280631,
-0.0227142069,
-0.0149171781,
-0.0037550004,
0.0580625422,
0.004986363,
-0.0379892662,
-0.0747246891,
0.0368115231,
0.0034108183,
-0.0330259427,
-0.0248148609,
0.0424478389,
-0.0025494217,
-0.0713814646,
0.0823246315,
0.0120755965,
0.0087968418,
0.0597705208,
0.0747495964,
-0.0372635387,
-0.018077774,
-0.0366815068,
0.005703833,
0.0103999777,
-0.0271825921,
-0.0418120697,
0.0276175756,
0.0680829436,
-0.0141487438,
0.0507983863,
-0.0204865076,
0.0031193725,
-0.0639721677,
-0.0042855372,
-0.0558447726,
-0.0076604802,
0.0029615029,
0.0380193219,
-0.0039067296,
-0.0255663525,
0.0292162094,
-0.0096658068,
0.0097951395,
-0.0456744321,
-0.0241075922,
-0.0469396338,
0.0374142006,
-0.0032683753,
-0.0022845475,
-0.0238964669,
-0.023732258,
0.0116618918,
0.0114212595,
-0.0098166279,
-0.010196262,
0.0505478866,
-0.0275613945,
0.0319953151,
0.0100172292,
0.0063459212,
-0.0182995051,
-0.0863192454,
-0.0110357804,
0.0105057769,
0.006645306,
0.0085265636,
-0.0476895086,
0.0356501788,
0.0398788713,
0.0188524518,
-0.0170654338,
-0.0284837671,
-0.0068913894,
0.0438596122,
0.0747136772,
-0.0729960054,
-0.0152781866,
-0.0574132912,
0.0456225239,
0.0318852402,
0.0437221341,
0.0098654889,
-0.0372312218,
0.0104188574,
0.0033644002,
-0.0563955121,
-0.0491749868,
-0.0176744405,
0.0108398022,
-0.0321549401,
-0.0303174872,
0.134366855,
0.0528126098,
-0.0959686413,
-0.0259246975,
-0.0349675938,
0.0021034249,
-0.0108515192,
0.009979873,
-0.0535955802,
0.0126342764,
-0.0036849084,
0.0225965083,
0.029053852,
-0.0141987437,
-0.007007739,
-0.0360445492,
0.0323795006,
0.034625221,
0.0014822868,
-0.0088648684,
-0.0810105801,
0.0114871114,
0.0229053181,
-0.0277061313,
0.0134285744,
-0.0121432692,
-0.033699438,
0.012310504,
-0.0150498068,
-0.0168660171,
0.0116690509,
-0.0130369356,
0.0586271845,
0.0198224634,
0.002688502,
0.0004937519,
0.0011019476,
0.0297552478,
-0.0252281763,
-0.0373718813,
0.0029617636,
-0.0050482387,
0.0016078254,
0.0158790443,
-0.0066462001,
0.0245908797,
-0.0224433988,
-0.0341175757,
0.0303250123,
0.0806098059,
-0.0547416359,
-0.0522873066,
-0.0049116355,
-0.0142893726,
0.003813935,
0.0649197474,
0.0320010558,
-0.0647650659,
-0.0054042428,
-0.0146921342,
0.0162757132,
0.0745272264,
-0.0147744026,
0.0047330433,
-0.0069223838,
-0.0765110627,
-0.0418468378,
-0.0217108876,
0.0121787218,
-0.0034269767,
0.0038801355,
0.0461279824,
0.0068143648,
-0.026522832,
0.0177486446,
0.0348643363,
-0.0463774838,
-0.007458102,
-0.0808208138,
-0.0260699168,
0.0797586665,
-0.0148861082,
0.0107770795,
-0.0135402502,
-0.0782603174,
-0.0442513637,
0.0382527076,
-0.0571509488,
0.0228146836,
-0.0098091578,
-0.0393138081,
-0.0939666629,
0.0086056553,
0.0357258022,
-0.0521635972,
0.0155958934,
-0.028937256,
0.0298926271,
0.0080600874,
0.0127391415,
-0.079766728,
0.0761679858,
-0.012155341,
-0.0002196345,
-0.0473577715,
-0.0395237878,
-0.0183394626,
-0.0120206224,
0.0212637,
0.009716453,
-0.0005744616,
-0.0452496074,
-0.023735242,
-0.0117994752,
-0.0261568762,
0.0045030322,
0.0094859293,
0.0668332204,
-0.0225265138,
-0.0319177732,
0.0268097501,
-0.0191097967,
0.021097403,
-0.0227205735,
-0.0041440693,
-0.0154788708,
0.0094090728,
0.0269959886,
-0.0051046838,
-0.0308898315,
0.0059167137,
-0.0303690359,
0.0230618212,
0.0032160846,
0.0761127546,
0.0120745078,
-0.0475443192,
-0.0272440948,
0.0065547414,
-0.0730772242,
-0.0708941072,
0.0130529553,
0.0811889544,
0.0545564108,
-0.0111286985,
0.0287522078,
-0.0575134456,
-0.0049022068,
-0.0540236719,
0.0272981636,
0.0569663122,
-0.0304443873,
0.0007580878,
0.0443642512,
-0.0238416195,
0.0414180234,
0.0762493834,
0.0351545997,
-0.0194682311,
0.0433115289,
-0.0084154336,
-0.034227252,
0.0098065035,
-0.021826975,
-0.0025331015,
-0.0403538086,
0.0053180177,
-0.0385045223,
0.0042999848,
0.0527399927,
-0.0529277027,
-0.0260435715,
-0.0073669078,
0.0189707875,
0.1036796346,
-0.0173771884,
0.0200948305,
-0.0464927107,
0.0361542627,
0.0124137476,
-0.0426124744,
-0.04150052,
-6.483317869e-33,
0.0110694114,
-0.0225260556,
0.0032330172,
-0.0086956928,
0.0304600447,
-0.0013520336,
-0.0285915919,
0.0152886258,
0.0546851233,
0.000161033,
-0.0205198769,
0.0354158655,
0.0073608286,
0.0117555913,
0.0108051766,
-0.0262864493,
0.0691184774,
-0.003333925,
-0.0159575511,
0.0750871375,
0.0271807797,
0.0166100785,
-0.0124584222,
-0.0821172893,
0.0360249355,
-0.0450419523,
0.0073690247,
-0.0167898666,
0.0785862356,
0.0393111184,
-0.0554624237,
0.0424416997,
0.0371318683,
-0.057427384,
-0.0291757435,
0.0358904302,
-0.0162244886,
-0.016567573,
-0.0206553899,
-0.005892517,
0.0028789337,
-0.0648287088,
0.0049101682,
0.018158583,
0.0247184951,
0.0016410736,
0.0569799282,
-0.0249196459,
-0.053311158,
-0.0351434574,
-0.028770294,
0.0392851196,
0.0094692446,
-0.0000401443,
0.0283218045,
-0.0393426716,
-0.0252480544,
0.0472842082,
-0.0009101485,
0.0350596197,
0.0262967683,
0.0350187421,
0.0202162769,
-0.0164043531,
0.0001649207,
0.062195234,
0.013603921,
0.0518543459,
-0.0052106879,
-0.0130027328,
0.0003613601,
0.0248351321,
0.0356793664,
-0.0059752641,
0.0162954107,
0.0230999254,
-0.023332268,
0.0185266826,
0.0032195942,
0.0165847391,
0.0607988089,
0.0403661132,
-0.0052133724,
-0.0380241498,
-0.0327281207,
0.0318700261,
-0.0251305886,
-0.0021597026,
0.0262934994,
0.0022836365,
-0.0048913993,
-0.0112912478,
0.051378265,
-0.0188078508,
-0.0318638049,
0.0497879498,
-0.0084028076,
0.0511708036,
-0.013625416,
0.0165296514,
-0.0864693373,
-0.0344756097,
0.0287530683,
-0.0305729527,
-0.0002652526,
-0.0032578951,
-0.045994401,
-0.0259887911,
-0.0695056394,
-0.0169038903,
-0.0131152403,
-0.036163535,
0.0166517664,
0.0164065398,
0.0372679718,
-0.0226998143,
0.0112525746,
0.0593506433,
0.0277295914,
0.0072033545,
0.0123340217,
-0.0409312174,
-0.0483530983,
0.0133469002,
-0.0259920154,
0.0176627338,
-0.047362864,
0.013850783,
0.0377661735,
-0.0495003164,
0.010110152,
-0.0108027784,
2.708e-7,
0.0017024925,
0.0841459334,
-0.0250016823,
-0.0008400089,
0.0436318591,
0.0074367481,
-0.0195409507,
0.0106516704,
0.0099740662,
-0.0386538245,
-0.00379737,
0.0287221223,
0.0511759333,
0.0649934337,
-0.0910939053,
0.0182222482,
-0.0493684597,
0.031328585,
-0.0970161632,
-0.0276447702,
0.0128853032,
0.0824025795,
0.0108345179,
0.0099426741,
-0.0058433157,
-0.0873445719,
0.0786290169,
-0.0496009439,
-0.0418295972,
0.0438900888,
0.09302672,
0.0528745353,
-0.0038286175,
-0.01380945,
0.0133545781,
-0.0163362119,
0.0283776112,
0.0491954796,
0.0138481734,
-0.0022330093,
-0.0091344295,
-0.031612739,
-0.0039029869,
-0.0389341936,
0.0640546903,
-0.0236238465,
-0.0107726483,
-0.0201576985,
-0.0104842708,
-0.0245225579,
0.0145675922,
-0.0354731865,
-0.0276918169,
0.0034964317,
-0.0199769866,
-0.0017912723,
0.0079603307,
-0.0214344449,
0.0080735069,
0.0157756787,
-0.0431520157,
-0.0426344834,
-0.0454923622,
0.0221288819,
0.0040472909,
-0.0660736412,
0.0322321132,
2.195563323e-34,
0.0465022139,
-0.0120436614,
-0.0547233559,
0.0151511449,
-0.0072766813,
-0.0122209881,
-0.0310504455,
0.0480242111,
-0.0059568342,
-0.0890188813,
0.0312879123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00684v1
|
Deciphering Oracle Bone Language with Diffusion Models
| 2024-06-02T09:42:23 | 2024-06-02T09:42:23 |
Haisu Guan, Huanxin Yang, Xinyu Wang, Shengwei Han, Yongge Liu, Lianwen Jin, Xiang Bai, Yuliang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Originating from China's Shang Dynasty approximately 3,000 years ago, the
Oracle Bone Script (OBS) is a cornerstone in the annals of linguistic history,
predating many established writing systems. Despite the discovery of thousands
of inscriptions, a vast expanse of OBS remains undeciphered, casting a veil of
mystery over this ancient language. The emergence of modern AI technologies
presents a novel frontier for OBS decipherment, challenging traditional NLP
methods that rely heavily on large textual corpora, a luxury not afforded by
historical languages. This paper introduces a novel approach by adopting image
generation techniques, specifically through the development of Oracle Bone
Script Decipher (OBSD). Utilizing a conditional diffusion-based strategy, OBSD
generates vital clues for decipherment, charting a new course for AI-assisted
analysis of ancient languages. To validate its efficacy, extensive experiments
were conducted on an oracle bone script dataset, with quantitative results
demonstrating the effectiveness of OBSD. Code and decipherment results will be
made available at https://github.com/guanhaisu/OBSD.
|
[
0.0393510684,
0.0859286413,
-0.0318637267,
0.0463174134,
-0.0283933878,
0.0062451749,
-0.0284820963,
0.0876261368,
0.0568531007,
0.011620691,
0.0618538372,
-0.0076518194,
0.0681149736,
0.0084675951,
0.0226160493,
-0.0422198959,
-0.0055446168,
-0.0406221412,
-0.0446719714,
0.0320249423,
-0.0068683,
-0.0077379299,
-0.0095200995,
-0.0147399213,
-0.0283454526,
-0.0327698141,
-0.0343246162,
0.0211525224,
0.0128773116,
-0.0082920361,
-0.0991987661,
0.0374071375,
0.0411167592,
0.0415657088,
0.0000020988,
-0.0349007547,
-0.0343923271,
-0.0001888598,
-0.0115394965,
0.0152089233,
0.0876755342,
-0.0320384577,
-0.0542007685,
-0.0379223153,
0.00424445,
0.015452981,
0.1112705618,
0.0226258878,
0.0163337719,
0.0678991228,
-0.0407623388,
-0.0507233962,
0.0302858166,
0.0254685339,
0.0094600078,
-0.024474645,
0.0191865359,
0.0663290545,
-0.0031355435,
-0.0048478921,
-0.0547952279,
0.0621728189,
-0.0242728814,
-0.0108040571,
0.0169191286,
0.0382535271,
0.0098617412,
-0.0462016352,
-0.0181854479,
0.0469539985,
-0.0169992521,
-0.0428385735,
0.0251415148,
-0.000178325,
-0.0350041315,
0.0279060863,
-0.0110410498,
0.0282653701,
-0.0483314805,
0.0309504624,
0.0485667661,
-0.0331969112,
-0.0106698405,
-0.0174827166,
-0.0703920797,
0.0260510202,
0.0224009175,
-0.0526027754,
-0.0117467912,
0.0290549621,
0.0243338812,
0.0028764373,
0.0487647541,
0.0430804156,
0.0087653315,
0.0258021019,
0.0272945669,
-0.0590739772,
0.0098131336,
-0.021620864,
0.0404586159,
0.0212257542,
-0.0433870517,
0.0556412414,
-0.044040408,
0.0129532218,
0.0111473808,
-0.0079240063,
-0.0364776589,
0.0443754569,
-0.0247590747,
0.0015876085,
-0.0554639697,
-0.019818563,
-0.0067994697,
-0.0345099457,
0.0104844682,
-0.0089534847,
0.051374618,
-0.0085089142,
-0.0000230012,
-0.0246652849,
0.0008126159,
0.0035105885,
-0.0105423816,
-0.0409579314,
0.0156579856,
-0.017388992,
-0.0443301313,
-0.0200266801,
-0.0188021641,
0.0626369938,
0.0483453684,
0.0115916822,
0.0091014169,
0.079279393,
-0.0476499423,
-0.0080191763,
-0.0471649319,
0.0098644923,
-0.0294498466,
-0.0335427485,
0.006732225,
-0.0640313476,
0.025643982,
-0.0285148621,
-0.0013942376,
0.0025102498,
0.0107835755,
0.0263147037,
-0.0145160034,
0.0689880401,
-0.0397895128,
0.0138629815,
0.0244754106,
0.000089018,
0.0282966252,
0.0317721628,
0.048070848,
0.0610506497,
0.0480905697,
-0.0099912342,
-0.0362953655,
0.0384484529,
0.0005190371,
-0.0117408894,
-0.0393823124,
-0.0320223421,
0.0394711234,
0.0024743045,
0.0023060977,
0.0593565479,
-0.0320119187,
0.0013268583,
0.0063286428,
0.1047846228,
-0.0243199132,
0.0167552829,
0.0474151857,
-0.0009286686,
0.0146259116,
0.0205297489,
0.0413426049,
-0.06278193,
0.0713776574,
-0.0032868879,
-0.0197830461,
0.0148873348,
0.0199552719,
-0.0203401688,
-0.0145349381,
-0.0430719331,
0.0620314777,
-0.0164030772,
0.0829386711,
0.022304995,
-0.065198034,
-0.0294922441,
0.0293767508,
-0.041548036,
-0.0352391861,
-0.0476758555,
0.0481492691,
0.0765125901,
0.0860349089,
-0.0361398272,
0.063911289,
0.0496713482,
-0.0027317316,
0.0494314916,
-0.0460265651,
-0.0056894841,
0.0147751188,
-0.066543445,
0.0062792818,
0.0524935648,
-0.0026605618,
0.0140262824,
-0.0253651682,
0.0615438633,
-0.002285792,
0.0061933286,
-0.0823105574,
0.0603320114,
-0.0759397075,
0.0165380649,
0.004614633,
0.029383922,
-0.0107563529,
0.0460619703,
-0.0378654599,
-0.0070998357,
0.0362726897,
-0.0320503302,
0.0028342137,
-0.0071663535,
0.0054826965,
-0.0219384283,
0.0241180155,
-0.0613924116,
-0.0197853018,
-0.0411584154,
0.0145520056,
-0.0358544774,
0.0264554471,
-0.0533221774,
0.0529661439,
-0.0347055607,
0.0166757125,
-0.0099038696,
0.0312442742,
-0.0471769385,
0.0780145228,
0.0051703639,
-0.0068452768,
0.0231817644,
-0.0534308031,
0.0089519676,
0.0028874243,
0.0313818455,
-0.0172240976,
0.0204984825,
0.0052925306,
-0.0241478924,
0.0380046032,
-0.0160006005,
-0.0442110933,
-0.0614706688,
-0.0215921551,
-0.0422188491,
-0.021258954,
0.0163746644,
0.0025097146,
0.0224702228,
-0.0080670873,
-0.0247376412,
0.0333874002,
-0.0092598042,
-0.0728253052,
0.0344819948,
-0.020584669,
-0.0065984456,
-0.0309556443,
-0.0130845075,
-0.0017591041,
0.0306486338,
0.0515142158,
-0.0634952858,
-0.0403690189,
0.0205590539,
0.0091572944,
0.0074859485,
-0.0268262103,
-0.0084259575,
0.0080567403,
-0.0569088906,
0.021062566,
0.0099335825,
-0.0142606087,
0.0757864565,
0.0175198447,
-0.0299153514,
0.0444364622,
-0.0286500026,
-0.0180294458,
0.0455062538,
0.0081040552,
-0.0870180801,
-0.0243884642,
0.0107314205,
0.0218285937,
0.0374852829,
-0.0436887108,
-0.0650333613,
-0.0109375184,
0.0199434739,
-0.0251330826,
0.0162493177,
-0.0277498644,
0.0360292457,
-0.0487085059,
-0.0151013127,
0.046558205,
-0.012093788,
-0.0091697155,
-0.0405164063,
-0.0221905559,
-0.0588181391,
0.0358016826,
0.0518599115,
0.0319160223,
0.058114145,
-0.0304288771,
-0.0144038601,
0.0381106287,
0.0085428292,
-0.0469100811,
0.0151927611,
-0.007233439,
0.0155619234,
-0.0147212548,
0.046627786,
-0.00207505,
-0.0246089343,
0.0319776833,
-0.0187008996,
0.0297980644,
-0.0400951095,
0.0276495535,
0.0481279455,
0.0063461824,
-0.0076301447,
0.0082813418,
0.0161289424,
-0.0387955792,
0.0717942268,
0.0018734242,
0.0204444639,
-0.0144979302,
-0.0515457056,
0.0269186702,
0.0235701147,
0.012738185,
-0.0196453389,
-0.0325425565,
0.0064991009,
0.0165089108,
0.0407091193,
-0.0069571175,
-0.024646977,
0.0075332089,
-0.0287587028,
0.0251810215,
0.0463790409,
0.0332337543,
-0.0174399298,
0.0124630053,
0.0043066451,
0.0126164034,
-0.0197029188,
-0.030731136,
-0.1298994422,
-0.0083934022,
0.007236246,
0.0257138573,
0.0174662974,
-0.0288183633,
-0.0042572222,
-0.0799487457,
0.0622789524,
0.0025687125,
-0.0078806523,
0.0046447525,
-0.0421613157,
-0.034839388,
-0.0169757772,
-0.0839263946,
0.0307571478,
0.0170085151,
0.0026224477,
0.0086954711,
-0.0069658882,
-0.0255453251,
-0.0292859469,
-0.0223769452,
-0.0165812839,
0.0402579196,
0.091218479,
-0.0172769278,
-0.0418034196,
0.006357796,
-0.0415197872,
0.0224268772,
-0.0126222372,
0.1053373516,
0.066713661,
-0.0158401597,
-0.0176831484,
0.0132593466,
-0.0385126434,
-0.0190894306,
0.0053976038,
0.016678581,
-0.0224228539,
-0.027388677,
0.0088034067,
-0.0176415909,
0.0319646969,
0.0206565168,
0.018003583,
-0.0258573871,
-0.0888163,
-0.0559199899,
0.0653714016,
-0.0226273369,
-0.0690602586,
0.0043361345,
-0.039836999,
-0.0807258338,
-0.1025532782,
-0.0194152091,
-0.0112099042,
0.0460880548,
0.0427065752,
0.0353153162,
0.016989924,
-0.0209013764,
-0.0715029836,
-0.0491107143,
-0.0236882102,
0.0278080925,
-0.0186268166,
-0.0412253849,
-0.0249483716,
-0.038284421,
-0.0011731798,
0.0664463043,
-0.0715219975,
-0.031496115,
0.0249614902,
-0.0196644031,
0.0129909609,
-0.0280526634,
-0.0391674824,
-0.0279575065,
0.0395610295,
-0.0012412027,
0.014188082,
-0.0101694139,
-0.0126013057,
-0.0105431871,
-0.0097153001,
0.0089595923,
0.0031520643,
-0.0075909435,
-0.0199339222,
-0.0128284758,
-0.0462656766,
0.0158154499,
0.0171203334,
0.0125514148,
-0.0178288314,
-0.0499327183,
-0.0278163366,
-0.0216994677,
-0.0088998023,
-0.0260521639,
0.0005555254,
-0.0414872542,
-0.0094964486,
0.0308944751,
-0.0137980562,
0.0098632397,
-0.0226481818,
0.0133393425,
0.0009882965,
7.051e-7,
0.0555376299,
0.0687318295,
0.0720722824,
0.0062971055,
0.0074790991,
0.0321229286,
0.0577782169,
-0.0461812876,
0.0581270903,
0.0182281211,
0.0245152507,
-0.0080635734,
0.0060881721,
0.0386714786,
0.0213596076,
-0.0115869893,
-0.0447046459,
-0.003601382,
0.0021948556,
0.0876435339,
-0.0028750037,
0.0580013916,
-0.0406974889,
0.0159677025,
-0.0076390458,
0.0373558104,
0.0193942133,
-0.0246592816,
-0.0661947802,
0.0089503173,
-0.0065165553,
0.0335710235,
0.0569502302,
-0.0093915742,
-0.0029903429,
0.0128237428,
-0.0574012809,
-0.0464031659,
-0.0167497657,
0.0006456269,
-0.0481529757,
-0.0106779309,
0.0445032381,
-0.033382874,
-0.0889007524,
-0.0255652331,
0.0125752427,
0.0016010508,
0.0321103893,
0.013307021,
0.0029316389,
0.0206073727,
0.0482697971,
-0.0566419177,
0.0084890518,
-0.0429947078,
-0.0432641469,
-0.0114485743,
-5.622176422e-33,
0.0065535149,
-0.0264031105,
0.0115029765,
0.0204847176,
0.0072031491,
-0.0146156009,
-0.0681397617,
0.0175487008,
-0.0127276238,
-0.0016057465,
0.0221332908,
-0.0088932654,
0.0159435607,
-0.0010371436,
-0.0190856587,
0.0431044586,
-0.0172256622,
-0.0266609397,
0.0115894908,
0.0061758552,
0.0729288757,
0.0224439763,
0.0392827317,
-0.037727192,
0.0401265547,
-0.0024464794,
-0.0142897423,
-0.0167055782,
0.0307317656,
0.0239221249,
-0.0433806367,
-0.006243764,
0.0260586161,
0.034834139,
-0.0090758977,
0.0039801281,
-0.0532470271,
0.0099832946,
-0.0184017085,
0.062733531,
-0.0223270897,
0.0051404461,
-0.0177455526,
-0.044307217,
-0.027946448,
0.0190323759,
0.0587348416,
-0.0367499627,
0.0089772418,
-0.0138220685,
-0.0582204349,
0.0531795695,
-0.0366315916,
-0.0087902825,
0.0584435649,
-0.0060742185,
-0.0134509373,
-0.0196066592,
-0.0573742315,
0.0278345868,
0.0674004778,
0.0004398647,
-0.0004379945,
0.0011137181,
-0.0101942178,
0.023578357,
0.0612029769,
-0.0272925831,
0.0420005731,
0.0157573689,
-0.008918114,
0.0362171456,
0.0181709994,
-0.0213643517,
0.0388098545,
-0.0488361828,
-0.0433725342,
0.00668805,
-0.0180008151,
0.0089133047,
0.0207470842,
0.00825061,
-0.0266633108,
0.0090484107,
0.0177057106,
-0.0580589324,
0.001470605,
-0.0059305313,
-0.0082647428,
0.0079316888,
-0.0097371535,
0.0004591513,
0.0337339193,
-0.0560397953,
-0.0040855878,
0.0011898825,
-0.0673305169,
0.0640389919,
0.0083995499,
-0.0391911753,
-0.0538080782,
-0.0533839427,
0.0403199755,
0.0298551563,
0.0342742726,
0.0035530073,
-0.0044292347,
0.0108206021,
-0.0284205787,
0.0102915121,
0.0195095297,
-0.0338573232,
0.0292896088,
0.0237253252,
0.037152227,
-0.0428211913,
0.0001175984,
-0.0109800706,
0.0431279317,
0.0192766003,
0.0147989141,
0.0184935462,
-0.021387348,
-0.0303058606,
-0.0409945399,
0.0088698613,
0.0047627366,
0.0242799576,
0.0272756815,
-0.0344062597,
-0.0054731034,
0.0251039602,
2.734e-7,
0.0525674,
0.0282628611,
0.0706104338,
0.0757050142,
0.0443633161,
-0.003498195,
-0.056770362,
-0.0102598192,
-0.0400475301,
-0.0903767422,
0.0272446033,
0.0243887994,
0.0831812024,
-0.014407048,
-0.0395825505,
0.0380639136,
0.0188473947,
-0.0635888875,
-0.0468903109,
0.0315224119,
0.0189277437,
0.0575681627,
-0.03817546,
-0.0557932444,
0.0319595523,
-0.0002974523,
0.0209497306,
-0.0075773555,
0.0376853161,
-0.004714468,
-0.0170450192,
-0.0406599492,
-0.0626274794,
0.0365933217,
-0.0213506464,
-0.0230162703,
0.0443296395,
0.03764024,
-0.0292514134,
0.0487232134,
0.0391988829,
-0.0061523346,
0.0022254644,
-0.0630087703,
0.0548315458,
0.1059856564,
-0.0269927979,
-0.0347145796,
-0.0053745708,
0.0176500585,
0.0174550656,
0.0020786698,
-0.0067550247,
0.0059749861,
0.0143541377,
-0.0063043628,
-0.0027707822,
-0.0505491719,
-0.001517167,
0.0240970552,
-0.0165040307,
-0.0144722294,
-0.0022514409,
-0.0428130031,
0.0014597415,
-0.0715760887,
-0.0267630909,
2.807204717e-34,
0.0136214094,
-0.0437688529,
0.0086113811,
0.0585242212,
0.022350451,
-0.0165516119,
0.0060835881,
0.019808,
0.0145852352,
-0.0516312383,
-0.0276412275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00682v1
|
A lexicon obtained and validated by a data-driven approach for organic residues valorization in emerging and developing countries
| 2024-06-02T09:36:33 | 2024-06-02T09:36:33 |
Christiane Rakotomalala, Jean-Marie Paillat, Frédéric Feder, Angel Avadí, Laurent Thuriès, Marie-Liesse Vermeire, Jean-Michel Médoc, Tom Wassenaar, Caroline Hottelart, Lilou Kieffer, Elisa Ndjie, Mathieu Picart, Jorel Tchamgoue, Alvin Tulle, Laurine Valade, Annie Boyer, Marie-Christine Duchamp, Mathieu Roche
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The text mining method presented in this paper was used for annotation of
terms related to biological transformation and valorization of organic residues
in agriculture in low and middle-income country. Specialized lexicon was
obtained through different steps: corpus and extraction of terms, annotation of
extracted terms, selection of relevant terms.
|
[
0.0465844423,
0.0131574916,
-0.0121541154,
0.0124527346,
-0.009020213,
-0.0318351984,
-0.029416753,
0.0297048837,
-0.0190039799,
-0.0557979532,
0.0231968258,
0.0981936827,
0.0106757656,
0.0233224593,
-0.0084886309,
0.0213951729,
0.0307841171,
0.0250398386,
-0.0258557089,
0.0477400087,
0.0204817504,
0.0250773467,
0.0091938889,
0.0177136026,
-0.0162656624,
0.0266811494,
0.0468653552,
-0.0142688742,
0.0381434225,
-0.0869913325,
-0.0494646579,
0.0008354298,
0.0037732904,
0.0030666832,
0.0000017092,
-0.0472116135,
-0.0892756581,
0.0255558379,
-0.0210265238,
0.0203606915,
0.0863776281,
0.0379601605,
0.0168378111,
0.005119198,
0.0047879829,
0.0437100455,
0.041986119,
-0.0130509362,
0.0097649274,
-0.0000817617,
-0.0056728185,
-0.0561725646,
-0.0154378489,
0.0319962464,
-0.0219944734,
0.0307321213,
0.0412619226,
0.0149852261,
0.0145193748,
0.0314935446,
-0.01798838,
0.0265053753,
-0.0628200844,
-0.0021296362,
-0.0038398369,
0.0056562563,
-0.000334194,
-0.0205922872,
0.0524311364,
0.0199878905,
0.0645103082,
-0.0020100013,
0.0225843601,
-0.0056910189,
-0.007722965,
0.04827369,
-0.0442142561,
0.0377839543,
-0.0311142206,
0.0140608223,
0.0573962219,
0.0129943537,
-0.0151066268,
-0.0013514546,
0.0112567851,
0.0459702946,
-0.0286198519,
-0.0101976404,
0.0037379924,
-0.0384262539,
-0.0318134911,
0.0143004721,
0.0369342193,
0.0222057942,
0.0604277477,
0.0138063636,
0.051026985,
-0.0559035763,
0.0519900806,
-0.0520072244,
-0.0639059916,
-0.0009536778,
-0.0489144735,
-0.0108795213,
0.0023018427,
-0.0610128604,
0.0813976526,
-0.0055507729,
0.031382896,
-0.0034675652,
-0.0806437656,
-0.0167708453,
-0.0315519832,
0.0455947295,
0.0320671238,
0.0237824805,
-0.042979598,
-0.0091746859,
-0.0026958296,
-0.0494101159,
0.0332854688,
0.0188904256,
0.0263917726,
-0.0036022167,
-0.0278891791,
-0.0101554273,
-0.016704075,
0.0320709422,
-0.0471847914,
-0.0272172876,
0.0437492132,
-0.0096347472,
0.0417043604,
0.0232539084,
-0.022074433,
0.0163109414,
0.0022926317,
-0.0316654816,
-0.0470546708,
-0.0270810146,
0.0325752571,
0.0269513633,
-0.0573693849,
-0.0045498158,
0.0390429571,
-0.0160978939,
0.026857933,
-0.0292691384,
0.00939989,
0.0393729992,
-0.0369203985,
0.0433462895,
-0.0644591302,
-0.0460487455,
0.0352175236,
0.0055374601,
0.0496995933,
-0.0525062978,
0.02221434,
0.0320668779,
0.0234489981,
0.0116362413,
-0.019741971,
-0.0479717292,
-0.0647123307,
-0.041743882,
-0.0470469333,
0.0289626196,
-0.0203328598,
0.0234400444,
-0.0420642383,
0.004314702,
-0.0349151082,
0.0420309976,
0.0511412695,
0.0921968818,
0.0253747627,
0.0004357045,
0.0113082509,
0.0143980356,
-0.0007036304,
-0.0053140391,
0.0270518474,
-0.0053981757,
-0.0476579815,
-0.0229025315,
0.0090720104,
-0.0180931389,
0.0467769206,
-0.0756336972,
-0.0111892764,
0.016626101,
0.041268684,
-0.0430204384,
0.0164058916,
0.0171519239,
-0.0123904282,
-0.0412395857,
0.0327781998,
-0.0357701033,
0.0125797866,
-0.0086745955,
0.0582891777,
0.0387229025,
0.0347428843,
-0.0577850528,
0.0237341765,
-0.001002516,
-0.0331619643,
0.0278631616,
-0.104946889,
-0.0492627323,
-0.0586921684,
0.013261022,
-0.0072414507,
0.0310264677,
-0.0352160558,
-0.02112104,
-0.0335721523,
0.0336265266,
0.0085526621,
-0.0601187237,
0.0120040849,
0.0800074115,
0.0247107726,
0.0142468223,
-0.0034894459,
-0.0240889434,
-0.0261732098,
0.0417145006,
0.0132540865,
0.0043951063,
0.0461167507,
-0.0199819002,
-0.0600999631,
0.0116001507,
0.0810202509,
0.0450638793,
0.0415091477,
-0.0446521863,
0.0220257044,
-0.0310561862,
0.0347351991,
-0.0225958489,
-0.0043473169,
0.0055896789,
0.0149075929,
-0.0471027195,
0.0565785654,
-0.0481620058,
0.0296586771,
-0.0732771382,
0.0299202148,
-0.0070004542,
-0.0148715097,
-0.0544286892,
-0.0510108285,
0.0466935299,
0.0348837674,
0.0672349855,
-0.0010452649,
-0.0060753729,
0.0116171138,
0.0580837615,
0.0250291303,
-0.0294661503,
-0.0183584671,
-0.0475663431,
0.00894049,
0.0017708638,
0.0147825386,
-0.0182143953,
-0.0082501275,
0.0441977568,
0.0286611877,
0.043830011,
0.0665692538,
-0.0611652583,
0.0107065821,
0.0329004973,
0.0295224525,
-0.021567028,
0.0144493245,
0.0565643311,
0.006143624,
0.0298741013,
0.0312580355,
-0.0557885058,
-0.0145865297,
-0.0201071985,
0.0093564447,
0.0115708895,
0.0066864477,
0.0103027998,
-0.0357280262,
0.0180190615,
-0.0323713198,
-0.0276919715,
0.003077518,
-0.006743853,
0.0382826328,
0.007272312,
-0.0067443457,
-0.0512159579,
0.020531036,
0.0871919543,
0.0270986818,
-0.0252352078,
0.0695197135,
0.0260746423,
-0.006628362,
0.0035870536,
0.0084181717,
-0.0161443111,
-0.0124485195,
0.0488651507,
0.000364635,
-0.0103709167,
0.0181287751,
0.0119856251,
0.0195195172,
-0.0300505441,
0.0081927041,
-0.006085251,
0.0285617914,
-0.0741938204,
-0.0359142087,
-0.0051872865,
-0.031494569,
-0.0006178923,
-0.0054454124,
0.0496829003,
-0.0243521184,
0.0301881842,
-0.0143306814,
0.0287827104,
0.0244404674,
0.0348747633,
-0.0502350219,
0.0298419539,
-0.0099493554,
0.0137506342,
0.0348770991,
-0.0191419702,
0.0303148217,
0.0542217754,
0.0955729708,
0.0006502104,
0.0369778648,
0.0903103352,
0.0055904007,
-0.0035200494,
0.0113307172,
-0.0141234733,
0.0406454206,
-0.0014421504,
0.008885107,
-0.0671617836,
-0.0198016204,
0.0332512297,
0.037181668,
0.0190731324,
-0.0285796579,
-0.0954142585,
0.0564631075,
-0.0282991864,
-0.0313802809,
-0.0288460944,
0.0079937251,
0.0178727992,
-0.0972735509,
0.0245406218,
0.0171334576,
0.0407271013,
0.0539508797,
-0.0095368568,
0.0596933328,
-0.0217299573,
-0.1228732318,
0.0020185115,
0.0148782395,
-0.0537965372,
0.0250149146,
-0.0316735692,
-0.0252510626,
-0.0313235708,
-0.0574961789,
-0.0411225632,
-0.0322276056,
-0.007319673,
-0.0388246998,
-0.078356415,
-0.0468938276,
-0.0013359797,
-0.0407528505,
-0.0162378233,
-0.0297221392,
-0.0100804381,
-0.0457399487,
-0.006633827,
0.0476688147,
-0.1290600598,
0.0061062626,
-0.0001793756,
0.0217568725,
-0.0087169847,
0.0476916991,
0.0312001016,
-0.0357327573,
0.0030777834,
0.0344711244,
-0.0110444501,
-0.0278212409,
-0.019429706,
0.0243317131,
0.0081672072,
0.0109792585,
0.0443293639,
-0.0300810728,
-0.0126346508,
-0.0563143045,
0.0398387089,
0.0566740558,
-0.0055580861,
-0.0085385526,
0.009548421,
0.0207811836,
0.0217622705,
-0.0621204413,
0.0162657462,
-0.0330025218,
0.0175623801,
-0.0023429657,
-0.041159153,
0.0087060565,
-0.0216860306,
0.009668937,
-0.1094725877,
-0.0621202886,
-0.0565987565,
-0.0220801476,
0.0751138777,
0.0185975153,
0.0173382685,
0.0908121318,
0.0246653538,
0.0045038159,
-0.0185314268,
0.0006741204,
0.0316483155,
-0.0331185721,
-0.0106679648,
-0.0480461866,
0.09866447,
-0.014795132,
-0.0010876012,
-0.0031208855,
-0.0005217571,
-0.0122381253,
0.0110431369,
-0.0343137905,
0.0056957239,
-0.0172970258,
0.0326825678,
-0.0912831202,
0.0398167707,
0.0434412323,
0.0247232821,
-0.0332637914,
-0.0105024399,
0.0213536248,
-0.0042188163,
-0.0082403691,
0.0267165583,
0.0444847494,
0.0037565122,
-0.0002008115,
-0.0667455345,
0.0054314849,
0.0386179425,
-0.0153400125,
0.0635449067,
-0.0199065618,
-0.0025071786,
-0.0191117655,
-0.03643132,
0.0277504642,
-0.0374973528,
-0.003165652,
0.0194601305,
0.0180614963,
-0.0184018761,
0.0010743012,
0.0444502681,
-0.0397403203,
0.0037230849,
0.0375285074,
0.0665471479,
-0.0293422956,
0.0362557918,
-0.0012965347,
-0.004562974,
0.0118489219,
-0.1087963581,
0.0002945125,
0.0190668255,
-0.0197945163,
0.0048799105,
-0.0091487737,
0.0102269156,
0.0070547736,
0.043598637,
0.0588690229,
0.0447127558,
-0.0576532371,
0.0053669224,
0.0068921535,
-0.0223639589,
-0.0095647257,
0.0201206859,
-0.0037634841,
-0.0096619772,
0.0272296499,
0.0192388371,
-0.029260451,
-0.0055275229,
-0.0125153996,
-0.0358945094,
-0.0433252379,
0.0547966436,
0.0265852362,
-0.0344685912,
-0.0091855191,
-0.0406175628,
-0.0056820372,
-0.0200511366,
0.0229101684,
-0.0143851023,
0.0215223879,
0.0283298753,
-0.0324871279,
-0.0075432234,
0.0064007556,
0.0024461055,
0.0113768736,
-0.021363508,
-0.0450149588,
0.0231098626,
0.0235751793,
0.0009277872,
-0.0585667156,
-0.000601881,
-0.0379368104,
-0.016463425,
0.0409241915,
-5.48544696e-33,
-0.0285145137,
-0.0803261772,
0.0107473703,
0.007267796,
0.0239951946,
0.0079637021,
-0.0097766584,
-0.0339995176,
0.0474996418,
0.0405423269,
0.0231123827,
-0.0068212817,
-0.0024804713,
-0.0531866252,
0.0444416814,
0.0384158865,
-0.0222576559,
0.0074214479,
-0.0075403452,
-0.0295136794,
0.0831082314,
0.0219676588,
0.1079582274,
-0.0966737419,
0.0580161735,
0.0198197197,
-0.0257737637,
-0.0215437636,
0.0365963802,
0.0152341528,
0.0051880926,
0.0322374329,
0.0356028974,
-0.0130691677,
-0.0163692869,
-0.01454172,
-0.0288064331,
-0.0477934144,
0.0197931156,
0.0327978432,
0.0039329277,
-0.0257344786,
-0.0057043792,
0.0116653983,
-0.0122523969,
0.0669464469,
0.0482462794,
-0.0670973882,
-0.0665972158,
-0.0531003922,
-0.0259058233,
0.0167575479,
0.0191298518,
0.0212328527,
0.0450228341,
0.0454923026,
0.0069256471,
-0.0130156651,
-0.0024575985,
-0.0032051289,
0.001414824,
0.0485834628,
-0.0076424903,
0.0662119091,
-0.0199482311,
0.0144866472,
-0.0939225405,
-0.0089750728,
0.0632224306,
-0.021122491,
-0.0280036386,
-0.0079561388,
-0.0414366871,
0.0193859767,
0.0623561107,
-0.0335446112,
0.0142397266,
0.0624003373,
-0.0655825362,
-0.0452186912,
0.010457444,
-0.0062269703,
0.0386858098,
-0.0245543998,
-0.0123452153,
0.0405687839,
-0.0070118718,
0.0280721765,
0.006827414,
-0.0108656771,
-0.0227315295,
0.0404166169,
-0.0313791558,
-0.0043418156,
0.0014632652,
-0.0316334665,
-0.0335676894,
0.0267867334,
-0.0329155177,
-0.0159732271,
-0.0428267047,
-0.038619414,
-0.010530442,
0.0174090713,
-0.008018313,
-0.0007758473,
-0.0147994244,
0.0164589342,
-0.0377865732,
-0.0157567151,
0.0165580157,
-0.0162164178,
0.007097526,
0.0022541855,
-0.0561642163,
-0.0034620566,
0.0147776175,
-0.0005801356,
0.0409768857,
-0.038519647,
0.0668687671,
-0.020046277,
0.0189510919,
-0.0357253626,
-0.0225334261,
0.0191535559,
0.0078687314,
-0.0382469557,
0.0234105401,
0.0083576031,
0.0274959356,
-0.0184298418,
2.524e-7,
0.0688759312,
0.0335979387,
-0.0080403956,
-0.0658450276,
0.0088558439,
-0.0134338364,
0.0470073409,
0.0072629494,
-0.0923698992,
0.0029720746,
0.0375101604,
-0.0385335088,
0.0017416845,
0.0497255959,
-0.0408483408,
-0.0058274292,
-0.0453542955,
-0.0433020443,
-0.0295072831,
-0.0055272863,
-0.0347418524,
-0.0157573614,
-0.03693882,
0.0056273849,
-0.0661144704,
0.0297159906,
0.018499352,
-0.0777009949,
0.0183871351,
0.0409687087,
0.0191145539,
-0.0250100698,
-0.0172521695,
0.0105924904,
-0.0338762105,
0.0072602304,
0.0124344351,
0.0242362134,
-0.0588411763,
0.0301903337,
-0.0002490885,
-0.1008158028,
0.016596131,
0.0534316525,
-0.000403474,
0.042257987,
-0.048878476,
-0.0292950608,
0.0116871754,
0.0240093656,
-0.0180573557,
-0.0339587331,
0.0280409008,
0.0273924302,
-0.0304006226,
-0.0083872657,
0.0032686545,
-0.0458149314,
0.0153786223,
-0.0166861694,
-0.013669733,
-0.0247977041,
0.0205319151,
-0.0323520452,
-0.0428491607,
-0.0075187762,
0.0212048534,
2.301634469e-34,
0.0154027278,
0.021228414,
-0.0078449165,
-0.0102815274,
0.0327451527,
0.0428544171,
0.0689936653,
0.0167957246,
-0.012897999,
-0.0437339507,
0.0332426056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00667v1
|
An Early Investigation into the Utility of Multimodal Large Language Models in Medical Imaging
| 2024-06-02T08:29:23 | 2024-06-02T08:29:23 |
Sulaiman Khan, Md. Rafiul Biswas, Alina Murad, Hazrat Ali, Zubair Shah
|
eess.IV
|
eess.IV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent developments in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have spurred
significant interest in their potential applications across various medical
imaging domains. On the one hand, there is a temptation to use these generative
models to synthesize realistic-looking medical image data, while on the other
hand, the ability to identify synthetic image data in a pool of data is also
significantly important. In this study, we explore the potential of the Gemini
(\textit{gemini-1.0-pro-vision-latest}) and GPT-4V (gpt-4-vision-preview)
models for medical image analysis using two modalities of medical image data.
Utilizing synthetic and real imaging data, both Gemini AI and GPT-4V are first
used to classify real versus synthetic images, followed by an interpretation
and analysis of the input images. Experimental results demonstrate that both
Gemini and GPT-4 could perform some interpretation of the input images. In this
specific experiment, Gemini was able to perform slightly better than the GPT-4V
on the classification task. In contrast, responses associated with GPT-4V were
mostly generic in nature. Our early investigation presented in this work
provides insights into the potential of MLLMs to assist with the classification
and interpretation of retinal fundoscopy and lung X-ray images. We also
identify key limitations associated with the early investigation study on MLLMs
for specialized tasks in medical image analysis.
|
[
0.0129841985,
0.0846344829,
-0.0131759318,
0.0387220159,
-0.037396498,
0.0262779407,
0.0739437938,
0.0477101393,
-0.0302299298,
-0.0574575104,
-0.0231103562,
-0.0736522079,
0.0078816265,
0.0741194412,
0.0284955837,
-0.1060837507,
-0.0242303684,
-0.0338996686,
-0.0142820748,
-0.0553065836,
-0.0403389819,
-0.0200523864,
-0.0018100042,
0.0642989874,
-0.046573367,
0.0001869846,
0.0322625376,
-0.0062214858,
0.000622158,
0.0094849458,
-0.0433554836,
0.0554386638,
0.0447885022,
-0.0004244079,
0.0000023017,
-0.0758295134,
0.0044929674,
0.0334139131,
0.0105180871,
0.0013822282,
0.1050292253,
-0.0402528532,
-0.0187085718,
-0.0469764657,
-0.0461371131,
-0.0684990957,
0.0641475543,
0.0459299162,
0.0476567484,
0.0607379228,
-0.0191893,
-0.0467599556,
0.0515673198,
-0.0000242582,
0.0037373202,
-0.028134698,
0.044067692,
0.0382419489,
0.0083831856,
0.0094410544,
-0.011106547,
0.0626808554,
0.0256360881,
-0.0061893989,
0.0007617159,
0.0755669698,
-0.0041181184,
-0.0722754598,
-0.0166643839,
0.0012364045,
-0.0469698869,
-0.007514318,
-0.039926786,
0.0144466246,
-0.0095531363,
0.0452782996,
-0.0248001087,
0.0443325639,
-0.0013450234,
0.0061084577,
-0.0335254818,
-0.0345973857,
0.020336831,
-0.0089443484,
-0.0557583272,
-0.0232711136,
0.0345299691,
0.0391255133,
-0.008982867,
0.0212700795,
-0.0669187754,
-0.0171900131,
0.0024284003,
0.0476593897,
-0.0145926699,
-0.0330726467,
-0.0672724992,
-0.0220496934,
0.0166288819,
-0.0282188524,
0.0398317054,
-0.0244809426,
-0.0533687174,
0.0525672138,
-0.0352437422,
0.0462180078,
-0.0564156845,
0.0517335385,
-0.0164116863,
-0.0110798711,
-0.0075231562,
0.0064416137,
-0.0195455775,
-0.0015393781,
-0.0181033127,
-0.039097324,
-0.0527255014,
0.0098388316,
0.0191592872,
-0.0017709228,
-0.0043366211,
0.0294456016,
-0.0427000187,
0.0203563292,
-0.0385642797,
-0.0044950447,
0.0627098978,
0.0058319238,
-0.0584019795,
-0.0647116527,
0.0425797142,
0.068750836,
-0.0105173942,
-0.0055599422,
0.010410063,
0.1105992571,
-0.0133830439,
-0.0100350799,
-0.0198630579,
-0.0093558198,
-0.0099905077,
-0.049271863,
0.0393997133,
-0.0622485839,
0.0016326163,
0.0266918037,
0.0393964909,
-0.0097249653,
-0.0053376728,
-0.0048013222,
-0.0107124699,
0.0771843791,
-0.0539966375,
-0.0128243091,
0.0568082295,
-0.0025737684,
0.0112348283,
0.0138749396,
0.0439993851,
0.0189648885,
-0.0167900808,
-0.0727735683,
0.0434022918,
0.0284125023,
-0.0649751648,
-0.0384546481,
-0.0806651488,
-0.0321825743,
0.0028417602,
0.0517022498,
0.0134458477,
0.0809979588,
-0.0197152942,
-0.0449236818,
0.0609332472,
0.0550100878,
0.0740466565,
0.0587955937,
0.0421288945,
-0.0334219448,
0.0142617924,
-0.0196085162,
-0.0001081954,
0.0612547062,
0.0117222499,
-0.0036731907,
-0.041554343,
0.0554106124,
-0.0161762126,
-0.0513332747,
-0.0408347622,
-0.0380151942,
-0.0408938415,
-0.0004318633,
0.0831653997,
-0.0475128852,
-0.0076382495,
-0.0663909167,
0.025523413,
-0.0054348991,
-0.0356370769,
-0.1045741811,
0.001463061,
0.0547757298,
0.0307788178,
-0.0167707689,
-0.0142796328,
-0.0044651669,
-0.0430860482,
0.0471043736,
0.0276958011,
0.0328578167,
0.0271216631,
-0.0565809608,
-0.0165164024,
0.0213396642,
0.0068707014,
0.0045246752,
-0.0398014486,
-0.0109038251,
-0.040326193,
0.0219470281,
0.0098256525,
0.0170829911,
0.0069937757,
0.0050614262,
0.0003669697,
0.0147966687,
0.0326349288,
-0.0243324507,
-0.0377160683,
-0.0285160895,
0.0244058166,
-0.0225936659,
-0.0011594621,
0.0000416026,
-0.0065345927,
0.0070707961,
0.028383676,
-0.0407216512,
-0.0114898542,
-0.011033331,
-0.0251682848,
-0.0126620214,
0.0117734205,
-0.0441880003,
0.0039805761,
-0.0731238052,
0.0193815269,
0.0086311745,
0.0235253368,
-0.0437918417,
0.0736916065,
-0.0069988957,
-0.0240589827,
0.0169050042,
-0.0086949253,
0.0122324647,
-0.0457727313,
-0.0462527238,
0.0449263975,
0.0208831616,
0.0175393149,
-0.0052655167,
0.0277701486,
0.011427558,
-0.010533262,
-0.0653258488,
-0.0335054174,
0.0043697683,
-0.0451682732,
0.0256391224,
-0.0041097458,
-0.0040629329,
0.0016726418,
0.0137460083,
0.0410906263,
0.0386465229,
0.009248984,
0.0567193329,
0.0229917672,
-0.012198722,
-0.0334260836,
-0.0016968172,
-0.0127497641,
0.0428109355,
0.0394288152,
-0.0367845856,
-0.0142326709,
0.0117806746,
-0.0213877428,
0.0488159359,
-0.0038359959,
-0.0414015651,
0.0140669439,
-0.0573303215,
0.0119530484,
0.0857138634,
0.0030762346,
0.0433661751,
0.0130118718,
0.0313392095,
0.0202691928,
-0.0233725272,
-0.0097387498,
-0.0381625779,
-0.0242386423,
-0.0366970152,
-0.0360837653,
0.0564515479,
0.0208490808,
0.0031847798,
-0.0322190747,
0.0665440559,
-0.0395765454,
-0.0206117239,
-0.0391917974,
0.0497440025,
-0.0340231657,
0.0135225179,
-0.0236421283,
-0.085445866,
0.0588538572,
-0.0018273955,
0.0045645214,
-0.0169695597,
-0.0294783153,
-0.0040427358,
0.0190752354,
0.0470316671,
0.0604745112,
-0.017137371,
0.0013671047,
-0.0188660976,
0.0210612901,
0.0076037715,
-0.0554801375,
0.0565348603,
-0.0367727466,
0.00837145,
-0.0144347586,
-0.0011258039,
-0.0202578995,
-0.0015208427,
0.0170588642,
0.0049678441,
-0.0141181089,
-0.0012917399,
-0.0304515995,
0.0533915535,
0.014589048,
0.0375278443,
0.0077349879,
-0.0110613387,
-0.0148256337,
0.0771425888,
0.0312416796,
0.0174790304,
-0.0336276069,
-0.0204724334,
0.0173325203,
0.0269778427,
-0.0228657685,
0.0334363617,
-0.1196078286,
0.0166625995,
-0.010430919,
0.0513201952,
-0.0254299361,
0.0281913485,
0.0136244372,
-0.0316784494,
0.0293768067,
0.0801381692,
-0.0082636224,
-0.0744782314,
-0.0241889823,
0.040630348,
-0.0318170972,
-0.0250934213,
-0.0210257508,
-0.0601966716,
-0.0150334695,
-0.0179436356,
-0.0244459566,
-0.0071521751,
0.0060215453,
0.0375656076,
-0.0135854511,
0.0985394493,
0.0100309541,
-0.0460487753,
-0.0335011221,
-0.0260025989,
0.0201798994,
-0.0299722459,
-0.016417684,
-0.0142723881,
-0.0197747126,
-0.0162777882,
0.0113797458,
0.0442020781,
-0.0649050698,
-0.0209399723,
-0.0205613337,
-0.0104034664,
0.0589101538,
0.0260040946,
-0.0648676753,
-0.0380520001,
0.0033026841,
0.0316274688,
0.0202220734,
0.0025350561,
0.053363625,
0.0252497569,
-0.0123226596,
-0.0168704987,
0.0509168953,
0.0189142004,
0.0260802433,
-0.0642767921,
0.0467155762,
-0.0442839116,
-0.0467445925,
-0.054194577,
-0.0073332582,
-0.00515129,
0.0022307087,
0.0045608412,
-0.034714099,
-0.038696155,
-0.0088484026,
0.0626844615,
-0.002428168,
-0.0207259171,
0.0260443874,
0.000819109,
-0.0398579389,
-0.0332146771,
-0.0034561683,
0.0072844378,
0.034090396,
-0.0030114586,
0.0011072534,
-0.0073542483,
-0.0075787529,
-0.0339390598,
0.0688531622,
0.0100224102,
-0.0018293378,
-0.0343223214,
-0.0386697091,
0.0679145157,
-0.0489597097,
-0.00383931,
0.0372053161,
-0.0652275756,
-0.0108500058,
-0.010474693,
0.0714978874,
0.026057221,
-0.0660894141,
-0.0077414033,
-0.0644020811,
0.0355037563,
0.0365083478,
0.0138628306,
0.0340145789,
-0.0008018651,
-0.0229848046,
-0.0096624456,
-0.0042601046,
-0.0021950309,
0.0290891211,
0.0005473722,
-0.0406110212,
-0.0171757787,
-0.0285105538,
0.019379219,
0.0397012457,
0.0507265404,
-0.0290055331,
0.0082449215,
-0.0184470899,
0.0033810255,
0.0049036024,
0.0146347508,
-0.0301760342,
-0.0132590691,
0.0229798444,
0.0485820509,
-0.0114891455,
-0.0286049675,
0.0037570028,
-0.030924283,
-0.0510200113,
0.0537428372,
0.0447054096,
-0.030137483,
0.0522814915,
0.0241081472,
-0.0076882476,
0.012061337,
0.0033413507,
-0.0007625282,
0.0186925028,
0.06632936,
0.0097176498,
0.0108559094,
-0.0276342779,
0.0467204712,
-0.0002918202,
-0.0481640734,
-0.0246076044,
0.0770514682,
0.0846584737,
0.0060765189,
0.0275968388,
-0.0534203276,
-0.0005090958,
-0.0509105325,
0.0609017648,
0.0288860463,
0.0007001466,
0.0719737634,
-0.008568651,
0.00894712,
-0.0169389322,
0.0898311287,
-0.0034398681,
0.0290097799,
-0.0247091018,
-0.0010568199,
-0.0545434281,
-0.0091959136,
0.0441694148,
-0.0433190912,
-0.0261240117,
0.0272338726,
-0.0144985402,
-0.0548874736,
0.0070648245,
0.0077626295,
0.0034820731,
-0.0226298664,
0.0273386817,
0.0581012666,
-0.0102142124,
-0.0408866964,
-0.0205524303,
0.0073553785,
0.0243287105,
-0.0189810507,
0.040696241,
-6.268785007e-33,
0.0165722352,
-0.0101212887,
0.058580704,
-0.0245126225,
-0.004303229,
0.0141805243,
-0.0115193892,
-0.0024213626,
0.002350898,
0.0110351359,
0.0088799186,
-0.0566476136,
0.0029661166,
0.0404572524,
-0.0083483383,
0.0033158239,
-0.0136985248,
-0.0334029347,
0.0080947233,
0.0026628729,
0.0104749892,
-0.024027599,
0.0265887622,
-0.0563846193,
-0.0647064224,
0.0217528734,
-0.021750642,
-0.0257547256,
-0.0484494977,
0.0499838144,
-0.052040834,
0.0450589471,
0.0351071507,
-0.0109881964,
0.0131078716,
0.0146308281,
-0.0057896874,
0.0080204029,
0.0017530152,
0.0102536473,
-0.0718372092,
-0.0273845755,
0.0555139519,
-0.0370748676,
-0.0401432402,
-0.0012703246,
0.0422618762,
-0.0469925627,
-0.0111804949,
-0.0314096846,
-0.0444034897,
0.0405789465,
0.0163663756,
-0.0101705668,
0.0432578623,
0.0020350965,
-0.0350172296,
0.052546896,
-0.0106927482,
0.0390445888,
0.0456708372,
0.0029291534,
0.0466058627,
0.0107675511,
0.0513480231,
0.0572616383,
0.0603376366,
-0.0805461183,
-0.0114239911,
-0.0091318283,
0.0272463076,
0.0407709889,
0.0522418469,
0.0500168577,
-0.0046893707,
-0.0139151504,
-0.045470871,
0.010010913,
-0.0511769541,
0.0341659002,
0.0296665784,
-0.0003008628,
-0.0022754255,
0.0164674241,
-0.0054279217,
-0.028817825,
-0.0229199622,
-0.0055953236,
0.0299261529,
0.0008039641,
-0.0072420463,
0.0358313061,
0.0591092594,
-0.0082937321,
0.0024160515,
-0.0421809666,
0.0126430048,
0.0538069047,
0.0101534231,
0.0079949228,
-0.0269222576,
-0.053034883,
0.0539309084,
-0.0132510457,
0.0324821025,
0.0046660928,
-0.0303969495,
0.0273178387,
-0.0408293419,
0.0098029161,
-0.0117144389,
-0.0286744591,
0.0202966183,
0.0178670939,
0.0465097651,
-0.0488771498,
-0.0069660684,
0.0407443419,
-0.011939371,
-0.0148538873,
-0.0518896095,
-0.053284578,
-0.0315444022,
-0.0141335167,
-0.0118563268,
0.0188904963,
-0.0404720157,
-0.0303500146,
0.0306770392,
-0.032973621,
-0.0349864066,
0.0280176792,
2.993e-7,
0.0279336683,
0.0611006357,
-0.000282174,
-0.0137870749,
0.0242610425,
0.023081528,
-0.0372314714,
0.0043714899,
0.0172092505,
-0.0136500141,
-0.0031299694,
0.0259356629,
-0.0087410556,
0.0092717959,
0.0114741316,
0.0356469154,
-0.0015964611,
-0.012156453,
-0.0370875075,
0.0201582909,
0.061905738,
0.0610716417,
-0.0508445352,
-0.0732111186,
0.0592626296,
-0.043582771,
0.0592083111,
-0.0561927222,
-0.017818246,
0.0003884863,
0.0133365151,
0.0035880597,
0.0190603938,
0.0651964247,
0.0348989107,
-0.0310533233,
0.042111218,
0.0434309542,
-0.0576080233,
0.0073540187,
0.0324336775,
0.0322744362,
-0.0128860446,
-0.067387417,
0.056396421,
-0.0199678186,
-0.0101189613,
-0.0161887333,
-0.0075076446,
-0.0221247133,
0.0471598543,
-0.0855599344,
-0.0182931535,
0.0268871989,
0.0235581826,
0.0107559552,
-0.0286530051,
-0.0316720121,
0.0069785789,
0.0144659579,
-0.0749524683,
-0.0109897479,
-0.0042153019,
-0.0526002385,
0.0644285604,
-0.0117735974,
-0.0372406244,
2.316612839e-34,
0.0094096111,
0.0000573272,
0.006091652,
-0.0019328221,
0.0041912557,
0.0091349082,
-0.0013615672,
0.0188016295,
-0.0191536769,
-0.0621610992,
-0.0050113839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00656v1
|
Presence or Absence: Are Unknown Word Usages in Dictionaries?
| 2024-06-02T07:57:45 | 2024-06-02T07:57:45 |
Xianghe Ma, Dominik Schlechtweg, Wei Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we outline the components and results of our system submitted
to the AXOLOTL-24 shared task for Finnish, Russian and German languages. Our
system is fully unsupervised. It leverages a graph-based clustering approach to
predict mappings between unknown word usages and dictionary entries for Subtask
1, and generates dictionary-like definitions for those novel word usages
through the state-of-the-art Large Language Models such as GPT-4 and LLaMA-3
for Subtask 2. In Subtask 1, our system outperforms the baseline system by a
large margin, and it offers interpretability for the mapping results by
distinguishing between matched and unmatched (novel) word usages through our
graph-based clustering approach. Our system ranks first in Finnish and German,
and ranks second in Russian on the Subtask 2 test-phase leaderboard. These
results show the potential of our system in managing dictionary entries,
particularly for updating dictionaries to include novel sense entries. Our code
and data are made publicly
available\footnote{\url{https://github.com/xiaohemaikoo/axolotl24-ABDN-NLP}}.
|
[
0.0429388545,
0.0159234777,
-0.0201250687,
0.0350833423,
-0.0307730753,
0.0011810889,
-0.0318901315,
0.0166416783,
0.0716198236,
-0.0086127678,
-0.0116312671,
-0.0317863151,
0.0217601862,
0.0483630411,
0.0353093855,
-0.008087798,
0.0652980059,
0.0009064107,
-0.0382256992,
0.0153872157,
-0.0119078588,
0.0584944002,
-0.008281528,
0.0088837277,
-0.0490400791,
0.0051477491,
0.0056449249,
-0.0180847216,
-0.0103141489,
-0.0256921332,
-0.0331121683,
0.0395683236,
-0.0152642531,
0.1097441018,
0.0000019994,
-0.0873248056,
-0.0471729115,
-0.0339940153,
0.0164134763,
-0.016626766,
0.0508994907,
-0.0252636205,
-0.0121652205,
-0.0057161502,
-0.0325867869,
-0.049896948,
0.0734025389,
-0.0250224564,
0.0499482378,
0.0419433676,
-0.026498273,
-0.0118239587,
0.0038658734,
-0.0055325367,
-0.0132609606,
-0.0309254341,
0.0304983687,
0.0055517163,
-0.0274923816,
-0.0468929857,
-0.050747782,
0.0276716147,
-0.0353857875,
0.0021053937,
0.0198232401,
0.0144328568,
-0.0107798502,
-0.0505629368,
0.0145095875,
0.0596771948,
-0.0271204002,
-0.0458716601,
0.0115219234,
0.0105447751,
-0.0281264763,
0.0494287387,
-0.0209229495,
-0.0141385887,
-0.0240432229,
0.020037096,
0.0784859955,
-0.0452278964,
0.0364158899,
0.0315341204,
-0.0072835642,
0.0991394073,
0.0133873299,
-0.0041863834,
0.0257095471,
0.0024703604,
-0.0487313978,
-0.0675916895,
0.0314204358,
0.0054263077,
-0.0220742989,
0.0534495637,
-0.0274454318,
-0.0886898488,
0.0178835075,
-0.056203492,
0.0359808058,
0.0113853589,
-0.0089511024,
0.0368475914,
-0.0414996482,
0.0353976376,
0.009732523,
-0.0197269134,
-0.0723250508,
-0.0252392199,
-0.061466407,
0.0088445107,
-0.0500486232,
-0.0011677351,
-0.0389027819,
-0.0087924944,
-0.018354265,
0.0345501602,
-0.0090809995,
-0.0080713201,
-0.010653045,
-0.0164311882,
-0.0214255191,
0.0219127201,
-0.0106422268,
-0.0126174586,
-0.0095033599,
0.0147053394,
-0.0665515289,
0.0028027445,
0.0067224586,
0.0326477438,
0.0156068457,
-0.0383333266,
0.0120164584,
0.0200296249,
-0.0157228149,
-0.0301817153,
-0.0096946592,
-0.0141043114,
-0.0303665306,
-0.0006682352,
-0.0320624076,
-0.0695912987,
-0.0118630566,
0.0113112433,
0.0337305441,
-0.0798730105,
0.0095108366,
-0.00876683,
-0.0775492787,
0.0899423063,
-0.0457104072,
0.0266032554,
-0.0160069801,
-0.0308139678,
-0.0086892983,
0.0439657569,
0.0044410829,
0.0176863261,
0.0686695054,
-0.0138508594,
-0.0049800002,
0.0226114765,
0.0025637427,
0.0253164973,
-0.0176230185,
-0.014631466,
0.0068308148,
0.0048172991,
0.0023675985,
0.0595303662,
0.0117511451,
0.0264994353,
0.0232092533,
0.0642744452,
-0.0191680752,
-0.0280436799,
-0.0038365552,
-0.0230869707,
-0.0463016517,
-0.008477171,
-0.0448446162,
-0.0446321703,
-0.0335163288,
-0.008969469,
0.0416977555,
-0.0027228994,
0.0108218472,
-0.0092166988,
-0.0229940955,
-0.0025141393,
0.0717680752,
-0.0287733767,
0.0555176698,
0.0265463404,
-0.012275965,
0.0080762226,
0.0223197993,
0.0044420613,
0.0518442504,
-0.0575156733,
0.0170032438,
0.0549768917,
0.0497434251,
-0.0024511039,
-0.0268279109,
0.0274615139,
-0.0003321662,
0.0292377193,
-0.0102877486,
-0.0520035625,
-0.009722136,
-0.0521243215,
-0.0137370098,
-0.0064974013,
-0.0041566812,
0.0089273518,
0.0220748894,
0.0537017956,
0.003774876,
-0.1157651842,
-0.0253257863,
0.0280379988,
-0.0179424249,
0.0066002365,
0.0193716884,
0.0132873058,
-0.0170479864,
0.0538042262,
0.0248912591,
0.0252146292,
0.0447956361,
-0.0405037068,
0.0134413568,
-0.00454586,
0.01892961,
-0.0154538322,
0.0376520008,
-0.0016555535,
-0.0060157035,
0.0227941368,
-0.0161033589,
-0.0586452559,
0.0559024028,
-0.0166880786,
0.0853300318,
-0.003385281,
0.0087650986,
0.0231493302,
0.0709700361,
-0.009526466,
0.0592719764,
-0.0121815819,
0.0192935225,
-0.0530868918,
-0.005750854,
-0.0088709369,
0.0168310311,
-0.060781993,
0.049944777,
-0.0012517511,
-0.0062678731,
0.0180713013,
0.0066824397,
-0.0288564246,
0.0138947079,
-0.0382261388,
0.0247707125,
-0.0435834043,
0.0381094813,
0.0453766137,
0.0402743779,
-0.0047053047,
-0.0283400845,
0.0045330808,
0.0324237086,
0.043814525,
0.037319921,
0.0336917229,
0.0066892044,
-0.0100241797,
-0.0229444895,
-0.0289119016,
-0.0025005816,
-0.0037689845,
0.0010361873,
-0.0816931501,
-0.0179435033,
0.0605221055,
-0.0285455026,
0.0061874804,
0.00295584,
-0.01196275,
0.0107369795,
-0.0133163305,
0.0652632788,
-0.0286884326,
-0.0591804832,
0.0032916851,
0.0865759924,
-0.0324953794,
0.0059534763,
-0.0281614065,
-0.0165323485,
-0.0245951507,
-0.0573069714,
0.0039599664,
0.0185236819,
0.022183517,
0.0350346342,
-0.051371146,
-0.0424961708,
-0.0330904797,
-0.0660609305,
-0.0072660237,
-0.0388513207,
0.0036104633,
-0.0080313813,
0.0671989173,
-0.0211526211,
-0.0418401808,
0.0476221852,
0.0203594025,
0.0286619831,
-0.0824857727,
-0.0449943952,
-0.001131552,
0.0540089346,
0.0120566012,
0.0170209557,
-0.0144121684,
-0.0229499526,
-0.0400138199,
-0.0509648658,
-0.0057379976,
-0.0153266899,
0.0756406263,
-0.0689546689,
0.0053708502,
0.0276883859,
0.0372472368,
-0.0146626327,
-0.0392917432,
-0.0056703417,
0.0030220153,
0.0381623767,
-0.0405526906,
0.0061402824,
0.0261170324,
-0.0278731994,
0.0265977904,
0.0331486426,
-0.0096145039,
0.002845817,
0.0025929369,
0.0478782915,
-0.0012540977,
0.0006156596,
0.0261200797,
0.0003351051,
0.0330589078,
0.0763187632,
-0.0366835631,
0.0057825828,
0.0019963305,
0.0454663411,
0.0009886577,
-0.0377509929,
-0.0261283703,
0.0026177438,
0.013692202,
0.010528232,
0.071938917,
0.0453701019,
-0.0451653637,
0.0159671251,
-0.0038410735,
0.0078645712,
0.0343281329,
0.0001640998,
-0.0686728656,
0.0076669934,
0.0093108658,
0.0181321781,
0.001134671,
-0.0665089861,
-0.0297243595,
-0.1144074872,
-0.0010392444,
-0.0000487316,
-0.0289936662,
0.0100977402,
-0.0721486583,
0.0266776271,
-0.0690511465,
-0.0493034534,
-0.0400469974,
-0.000794067,
0.0266340971,
0.0104745347,
-0.0250849426,
-0.048502557,
-0.0010978159,
-0.0001364681,
0.033260975,
0.0229532812,
0.062404491,
-0.0311248768,
0.0221252274,
-0.0087483395,
0.0004590189,
-0.0246666949,
-0.0366100147,
-0.0069910516,
0.0055939681,
-0.0094453786,
-0.0020747981,
0.0195746664,
-0.0450096317,
-0.0680188611,
0.0144031076,
0.1007690951,
0.0060642725,
0.0036263438,
-0.0066797719,
-0.0500837937,
0.0480440333,
0.0460537151,
-0.0136309173,
0.0151983378,
0.0329391249,
0.0134918867,
0.0413180627,
0.0029524362,
0.0187350139,
-0.0095195826,
-0.0448831394,
0.0028086377,
-0.0940350071,
-0.0242616665,
0.0582742058,
0.0184354875,
0.0321562514,
0.0675922856,
-0.051308766,
-0.032835871,
-0.086355783,
-0.0067001842,
0.0166289527,
0.0363956951,
-0.0329252556,
-0.0617157742,
0.0050309021,
0.0096782213,
-0.0131786168,
0.0758148134,
-0.0215987135,
-0.0475030728,
0.0225511529,
-0.0345131569,
0.0213341173,
0.0196194276,
-0.0204985458,
-0.019534776,
0.0551248267,
0.0056677992,
0.024567036,
0.0158507302,
-0.0091361962,
0.021499034,
-0.0023158006,
0.0425008349,
0.0019420477,
-0.0150038153,
-0.0021299976,
0.0414198823,
-0.0516187586,
-0.0294492673,
0.0283911489,
0.0436959788,
0.0732807592,
-0.0589424446,
-0.0010539908,
-0.0748062208,
-0.0485852994,
0.0543432459,
-0.0301730596,
0.0097996956,
-0.0264893435,
0.0665949211,
-0.0227421578,
-0.0373163559,
0.0439242795,
-0.0342479125,
0.0170618445,
-0.0064516081,
-0.0102670975,
0.0683570802,
-0.0359827764,
0.008833345,
0.0593120195,
0.0247924291,
-0.004601697,
-0.0013836477,
0.0267425925,
-0.0473782234,
-0.0021270555,
-0.0274387524,
-0.0413646251,
-0.0178155787,
0.0605606064,
-0.0280104894,
0.0180967208,
-0.0099494336,
0.0079043815,
0.0179521497,
-0.0435152277,
0.0762965903,
-0.0757798404,
-0.0022461815,
-0.0330534615,
0.040554706,
-0.016613517,
-0.0139590818,
-0.0015988341,
0.0055112354,
-0.0211169906,
0.0322654061,
0.0525261313,
-0.0210017376,
0.0663021058,
0.0201809425,
-0.0227571372,
-0.0254041124,
-0.0016800306,
0.0166762434,
0.0364332497,
-0.0085480418,
0.0286376309,
-0.0459186211,
-0.0805441961,
0.0053187329,
-0.0086282725,
-0.024448365,
0.0410229452,
0.0276575033,
0.0352091305,
0.0348844603,
0.057249438,
-0.0875825807,
-0.019589508,
-0.0160706975,
-0.0403602682,
-0.0023641922,
-6.375977602e-33,
-0.0078992099,
-0.0316663384,
-0.0145699112,
-0.033042904,
0.0299885012,
0.0008304917,
-0.0042563304,
-0.0117015988,
-0.0147709744,
0.013132791,
-0.0028258478,
0.0240519699,
0.0172990933,
-0.0269973855,
0.0015739074,
0.036712192,
0.0147494841,
0.0189416502,
0.0151805747,
0.0213250052,
0.1318217218,
0.0113094039,
0.1171810329,
-0.0169747062,
0.0430490635,
0.0251572281,
0.0222643763,
0.0228023846,
0.0069620055,
0.0433957055,
-0.0340259783,
0.0768866688,
0.0004083659,
0.0239105877,
-0.0197716132,
-0.0400934555,
-0.0276486389,
-0.0679316819,
0.0506575219,
-0.005602974,
0.0281865448,
-0.0037840193,
0.0268285312,
-0.0172839463,
-0.0134758847,
0.0686428547,
0.0424970016,
0.0059661949,
-0.0313971862,
0.0725482479,
-0.0391779207,
0.012866105,
-0.0129009103,
-0.0230378173,
0.0423587449,
0.0061634565,
0.016928371,
-0.0911056921,
-0.0660516545,
0.0725819096,
-0.0456503928,
0.0321912393,
0.0770740733,
0.0110416003,
-0.0043960558,
0.0386360995,
0.0310772266,
-0.0293214768,
0.0371125005,
0.0021486818,
0.0412914194,
0.0449414998,
-0.0605010726,
0.0741802007,
0.0188386254,
-0.054828871,
0.0051825065,
0.0009008977,
0.0059990846,
0.0454436205,
0.0057814308,
-0.0129055092,
-0.0687120631,
-0.0651128069,
-0.005607015,
-0.0139059415,
-0.0495239086,
-0.0213428643,
0.0123631023,
-0.0575768948,
-0.0477442034,
0.0127686355,
-0.0194379352,
-0.0155763123,
0.0097501548,
0.0230981726,
0.0131685976,
0.0252776779,
0.0137791624,
0.0245836042,
-0.0183884185,
-0.0607296899,
-0.0048862603,
0.0391657054,
0.0230114572,
0.0004344898,
-0.0094138486,
0.0373774208,
-0.0147882132,
0.0123960823,
-0.0275715813,
-0.0090511208,
-0.0358739533,
-0.0404009931,
0.0349387079,
0.0109989746,
-0.0198836625,
0.0060367347,
0.0786969215,
0.0109987045,
0.0141034713,
-0.0153090656,
-0.0384002887,
-0.0095348554,
-0.0280425139,
0.0045566973,
-0.0084782541,
-0.0074987207,
0.063210696,
0.0003930528,
0.0072005265,
-0.0093597816,
2.919e-7,
0.0617471784,
0.0502070077,
-0.024745021,
-0.0001416697,
-0.0026896019,
-0.017994076,
-0.0614255331,
0.0391060635,
-0.0569885038,
-0.0113953901,
0.0112741264,
0.000726927,
-0.0103984969,
0.0550239868,
-0.0197476391,
0.0360019356,
-0.0309447255,
0.0098836701,
-0.0515628122,
0.0342554301,
0.0291017629,
0.0753586218,
0.0357196964,
-0.0273482017,
-0.0568303131,
-0.0542092472,
-0.0116015729,
-0.017222438,
-0.0014716162,
-0.0252138767,
-0.0066567394,
0.047477603,
0.0602553785,
0.03273689,
-0.0214323997,
0.0112044765,
0.0413965471,
0.001900333,
-0.0281339921,
-0.0157274865,
-0.0267439187,
-0.0179169364,
-0.0096958829,
-0.0644143447,
0.0472809561,
0.0135212736,
-0.0463104434,
-0.0261855293,
-0.0056617735,
0.0257882643,
0.0076193968,
-0.0342250764,
-0.0384361409,
0.0200978741,
0.0079825316,
0.0079258122,
-0.0541047193,
-0.005672242,
0.0073956675,
0.0374557599,
0.014496726,
-0.0378995091,
-0.0026462399,
-0.0144579522,
-0.0220209025,
0.0129471887,
0.0225346051,
2.12697782e-34,
-0.0138621572,
0.0292011034,
-0.0257998537,
-0.0336056203,
0.014772336,
-0.0457432903,
0.0168812219,
0.0689532161,
-0.0004239648,
-0.0733139515,
-0.0239931084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00654v1
|
Enhancing Zero-shot Text-to-Speech Synthesis with Human Feedback
| 2024-06-02T07:54:33 | 2024-06-02T07:54:33 |
Chen Chen, Yuchen Hu, Wen Wu, Helin Wang, Eng Siong Chng, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In recent years, text-to-speech (TTS) technology has witnessed impressive
advancements, particularly with large-scale training datasets, showcasing
human-level speech quality and impressive zero-shot capabilities on unseen
speakers. However, despite human subjective evaluations, such as the mean
opinion score (MOS), remaining the gold standard for assessing the quality of
synthetic speech, even state-of-the-art TTS approaches have kept human feedback
isolated from training that resulted in mismatched training objectives and
evaluation metrics. In this work, we investigate a novel topic of integrating
subjective human evaluation into the TTS training loop. Inspired by the recent
success of reinforcement learning from human feedback, we propose a
comprehensive sampling-annotating-learning framework tailored to TTS
optimization, namely uncertainty-aware optimization (UNO). Specifically, UNO
eliminates the need for a reward model or preference data by directly
maximizing the utility of speech generations while considering the uncertainty
that lies in the inherent variability in subjective human speech perception and
evaluations. Experimental results of both subjective and objective evaluations
demonstrate that UNO considerably improves the zero-shot performance of TTS
models in terms of MOS, word error rate, and speaker similarity. Additionally,
we present a remarkable ability of UNO that it can adapt to the desired
speaking style in emotional TTS seamlessly and flexibly.
|
[
0.0024221092,
0.0685478374,
0.0308791231,
-0.0252993163,
0.0106315361,
-0.0137969693,
-0.0012891481,
-0.0058406661,
-0.0449602939,
-0.0435066745,
-0.1087860093,
-0.0594056211,
0.0078072967,
0.0056353142,
0.0332356244,
-0.0903008878,
0.0023022853,
-0.0172722526,
0.0096802954,
-0.0100972299,
0.0193075202,
0.0021056342,
-0.0371225625,
0.0035534913,
-0.0176467597,
0.02399626,
-0.0060795709,
0.0134358434,
0.0323694237,
-0.0200192071,
-0.0313663334,
0.0287455469,
-0.0055531911,
0.0279197171,
0.0000020104,
-0.0189607423,
0.0185980815,
-0.0029516814,
-0.0289262198,
-0.0108453315,
0.1042923555,
0.0793316364,
-0.0319203138,
0.0166988708,
-0.0031767138,
-0.0014595696,
0.0312674381,
0.0247438774,
0.0629302859,
0.0741932318,
0.0000657089,
0.0124476925,
-0.0286073219,
-0.0244700108,
0.0335407108,
0.0255771987,
-0.0540753938,
-0.0692260936,
0.031547036,
-0.0381779261,
-0.0182415023,
0.0109591698,
0.0098738773,
0.001694388,
0.0300215557,
0.0212343745,
-0.0288803428,
-0.0461006202,
-0.0156866107,
0.0922028646,
0.0296482109,
0.003538809,
0.0091447486,
-0.0069836196,
0.0058978871,
-0.0114628291,
0.0174289998,
0.0121152345,
0.0296925008,
0.0118034678,
-0.0735887066,
0.0423578769,
0.0037489398,
-0.0202948581,
0.002851963,
0.026789505,
-0.012521605,
-0.042815499,
0.0462747253,
0.0163387395,
-0.0227090605,
-0.0249235686,
0.0243027844,
0.010370058,
-0.0313498713,
-0.0262375753,
-0.0582379475,
-0.0467922091,
-0.0387325622,
-0.0229700729,
0.0602651872,
0.0405639187,
-0.0047459877,
-0.0238362569,
0.0246297605,
0.0222128164,
0.0293969791,
-0.0143934488,
-0.0580148138,
0.0225506555,
-0.0444266051,
0.0394403897,
0.0045013716,
0.0512732193,
-0.0256793611,
-0.0161757711,
-0.0705302879,
-0.0170593839,
-0.0946639925,
0.0070249853,
0.0105866715,
0.056464389,
-0.0480984971,
-0.0166249722,
-0.0211021546,
0.0166840553,
-0.0039846487,
0.0186524391,
0.0336819626,
-0.0345177464,
-0.0013586568,
0.0233271141,
0.0286303032,
0.0185776372,
0.0307833366,
0.0564918071,
-0.0067583472,
-0.0218938272,
-0.0164905898,
-0.0225209706,
-0.038647119,
-0.0431051031,
-0.0080226352,
-0.0471595414,
-0.0200915206,
-0.0486339405,
-0.019976655,
0.0159438811,
-0.0030784262,
0.0049502114,
-0.0092725502,
0.0243804753,
-0.0058945301,
-0.0042280429,
0.009489418,
-0.0056489059,
0.0008433832,
0.0381908268,
0.0534212627,
0.0255205687,
-0.0198020022,
0.0247521419,
0.0379426405,
0.0504430868,
0.0386979096,
0.0257138517,
-0.0044920235,
-0.0470220484,
-0.0549207591,
0.0683026537,
0.099503614,
0.0341140069,
-0.0544094406,
0.0066620139,
0.0887716413,
0.0161418598,
0.031215759,
-0.0057593663,
0.0615733266,
0.0573198907,
0.0030018436,
-0.0076121213,
-0.0170825124,
0.033496283,
-0.0047983509,
0.0265405737,
0.0235044993,
-0.020346025,
-0.0324175209,
-0.0538668223,
0.0100653591,
-0.0391447842,
-0.0172795616,
0.0054467814,
-0.0021349215,
0.0291190222,
-0.0304639786,
-0.0018754747,
0.0052240631,
-0.0775550157,
0.0552235208,
-0.0217804033,
0.0417250954,
0.083524026,
-0.0087313782,
0.0220918972,
-0.008500223,
-0.0290106479,
-0.0449723974,
0.0518380404,
0.003649082,
-0.0311121847,
0.0583543777,
-0.053024821,
-0.0014112211,
0.0137834018,
-0.0047290148,
0.0354794487,
-0.0368815772,
0.0383957364,
0.0032519845,
-0.0181240644,
0.0156539772,
-0.0108413277,
0.0077825114,
-0.0444665737,
0.0534684546,
0.0130517278,
0.0457302742,
0.0419394709,
-0.0473948419,
0.0298393164,
0.0028915831,
-0.0054200296,
-0.0555959009,
0.0191753674,
-0.057767313,
-0.0388093479,
0.0199800227,
-0.047372859,
-0.0004696197,
0.0222818907,
-0.003935569,
-0.0680381358,
0.0528087616,
-0.0105949407,
0.0216028206,
-0.0071425806,
0.0062438417,
0.0411006734,
-0.0345400497,
0.005108973,
-0.0314088203,
-0.0001021125,
-0.000811927,
0.0155809699,
0.0070172856,
0.0207797829,
-0.0704957843,
-0.0085504688,
-0.0227340553,
0.0053830785,
0.0548164062,
0.0041467994,
0.0413282886,
-0.049277626,
-0.034051396,
-0.1053602844,
0.0274060164,
0.0094606243,
0.0234237872,
0.0132196425,
0.0031783183,
-0.0178472549,
-0.0046213022,
-0.0405845754,
-0.0450926162,
0.0180210695,
-0.0297358837,
-0.0012388385,
0.0084968153,
0.0283351224,
-0.0338825881,
0.0216047168,
0.0089311451,
-0.0194966663,
-0.0209888015,
0.0475222729,
-0.0039328705,
0.0375274867,
-0.0209778324,
0.0043417709,
0.0527499057,
-0.0259872992,
0.0247352067,
0.0207898952,
0.0278212707,
0.0624199845,
0.0095246397,
-0.005661251,
0.0050900183,
0.006581929,
-0.0390853621,
0.0004214262,
-0.0173025839,
0.0024498939,
0.0210646726,
0.0075359438,
0.0180071536,
0.0296362489,
0.0262242705,
0.0203472208,
-0.0909959972,
0.0228167307,
-0.0229958408,
-0.0515778922,
0.0107678548,
0.0136099719,
-0.0396716744,
-0.0099118194,
-0.0209495332,
-0.0087353783,
0.0470598452,
-0.0328358524,
-0.0421333499,
-0.0445793718,
0.0106516788,
0.0209235642,
-0.0387281924,
-0.0444681197,
-0.0020032607,
-0.0148571283,
0.0376991257,
-0.0686833262,
-0.0286962781,
0.0270630941,
-0.0468794666,
-0.0367117189,
-0.0067479275,
-0.0074557541,
-0.0006731895,
-0.0308953132,
0.0051532295,
0.0059563178,
-0.0264117513,
0.0127306143,
0.0124780023,
-0.0317516774,
0.0427958295,
-0.0249474775,
0.0307783894,
0.0208907183,
-0.0244822018,
-0.0287201535,
0.0004851677,
0.043461252,
0.0371740162,
-0.0034387144,
0.0085010165,
-0.0209151953,
-0.0157638937,
0.0307520255,
0.0714956969,
0.0352189988,
-0.0303731672,
0.0164995939,
0.02995966,
0.0392902866,
0.0029960445,
0.0382100083,
0.0460891388,
-0.0072203283,
0.0112074111,
0.1058595255,
-0.0085503059,
-0.011111022,
0.0033006514,
0.0103278626,
0.0587875247,
0.0085508991,
0.004064857,
-0.0602110662,
-0.0435844138,
0.0196593851,
0.0909454823,
-0.030481128,
0.0079427119,
-0.0113896821,
-0.1301859468,
0.0353423171,
0.0217680223,
-0.0303271338,
0.012127595,
-0.0151532451,
-0.0175078213,
-0.0359272882,
0.010408638,
0.0130340084,
0.0187476948,
0.0269062351,
0.0632532462,
-0.0203539785,
-0.0648822188,
-0.0081325229,
-0.0489677787,
0.1096182615,
0.0501847826,
0.0551693961,
0.0263532791,
-0.0174380969,
-0.0199783854,
-0.0079761967,
-0.0207430664,
-0.0195150878,
0.0386005454,
-0.0189568158,
-0.000653425,
-0.0400619954,
0.0670822933,
0.00594335,
0.027053982,
-0.0189769212,
0.0264576115,
-0.0172222555,
0.0097597847,
-0.0206820369,
0.036169216,
0.0445149541,
0.0467531942,
0.0112508414,
-0.1131594256,
-0.0043364353,
-0.0086215101,
0.0256627165,
-0.1171373278,
-0.0453279726,
0.0099823382,
-0.0122075062,
-0.0568000562,
-0.0933713242,
-0.031294927,
-0.0213756114,
0.0673627034,
-0.00692051,
-0.0589558668,
-0.0029896952,
-0.019687688,
-0.0128391543,
-0.0057338141,
-0.01520715,
0.0196901355,
-0.0511300042,
-0.0045464458,
0.0205683485,
-0.0474011339,
-0.0186625719,
0.0287044607,
-0.0422442183,
-0.0628790855,
-0.0040213522,
0.0635738224,
0.016102504,
0.060232535,
0.0162002426,
-0.048692096,
0.1042923033,
0.0517673716,
-0.0033579709,
0.0214840155,
0.0970999897,
0.0803519711,
-0.0022813566,
0.0114154844,
-0.0334339701,
0.0410523191,
0.0254184585,
-0.0120897358,
0.0078858333,
-0.0335079618,
-0.0135453707,
0.0144764632,
0.0251017194,
-0.0510026515,
0.0503500253,
-0.0193502922,
-0.0167394448,
-0.0479967706,
0.0319895744,
-0.0720209554,
-0.0291098692,
0.0361332446,
0.0243639033,
-0.0274486672,
-0.0164689776,
-0.0341249891,
0.0408227928,
0.0079461737,
-0.0038173106,
0.0284336042,
0.0044424813,
0.0029059795,
0.0112743154,
0.0041546198,
0.0125123486,
-0.0164080411,
0.0271012075,
-0.0071434109,
0.0196773019,
0.037133716,
-0.0057902983,
0.0151241869,
0.0318137258,
-0.0238320101,
-0.0012981698,
-0.0567004457,
0.0212017018,
-0.0000209362,
0.0248504132,
0.068465136,
-0.0173330083,
0.0349555425,
0.0055624032,
0.0032801651,
-0.068076618,
0.0076421257,
-0.0124394977,
-0.0010246752,
0.0111632636,
0.0209608339,
0.0331773944,
-0.0224654507,
0.0086748647,
-0.0794397667,
0.031470038,
-0.0427112691,
-0.0010053169,
-0.0209401436,
-0.0100520598,
0.025490379,
-0.0185197257,
-0.0599274971,
-0.0528544299,
0.0419026837,
0.0558481961,
0.0047564185,
-0.0453991741,
0.0876538232,
-0.0330439024,
-0.0675089508,
0.028075356,
-0.0166854486,
-0.0621349439,
0.0086046457,
-0.0300138053,
-0.0044655036,
-6.039189655e-33,
-0.019935593,
0.0218167212,
-0.0113304835,
0.0050004944,
-0.0587057993,
-0.0353048034,
-0.0046731383,
0.0387464315,
0.0060235024,
0.0177905913,
-0.0237181336,
-0.0348845199,
0.0190759543,
0.0422675274,
-0.0069763502,
0.0129426094,
0.063111037,
-0.035864599,
-0.0602824092,
0.0187461339,
0.04217932,
0.0143068852,
0.0245395508,
-0.0554511361,
0.0063153938,
0.001354316,
-0.0322292112,
0.0011463456,
0.0564621352,
0.0220031571,
-0.0003245395,
0.0459282175,
-0.0272764228,
-0.0353414416,
-0.0240112804,
-0.0262040161,
-0.026799418,
-0.0520847142,
-0.0309001505,
0.0087641943,
-0.0350340977,
0.0012911687,
0.0210697204,
0.0120397741,
-0.0878730789,
-0.0115554295,
0.0023249772,
-0.0114991544,
0.0089184232,
-0.0656735078,
-0.0191928986,
0.0039988197,
-0.0152168423,
-0.0653841794,
0.0335351489,
0.0539329275,
-0.059842512,
-0.0212362614,
-0.0310965907,
0.0555895492,
-0.0038610871,
0.0312537849,
0.0411797129,
0.0190636441,
0.0014412712,
0.0321178995,
0.0354610384,
-0.0366738923,
0.0064062569,
-0.0035743483,
0.0495663434,
0.0063249078,
0.0394934267,
0.0843210667,
0.0181469545,
-0.0136120114,
0.0226610731,
0.0293263607,
0.0120300762,
-0.008153229,
0.0069394847,
0.0397412106,
-0.0341119431,
-0.0069801295,
-0.0599146783,
-0.0823531523,
-0.0121536069,
-0.0077139311,
0.0484100953,
0.0153060975,
-0.0308032073,
-0.0402581207,
0.0541861802,
0.0063853352,
0.0203966051,
-0.0404552221,
-0.0783161521,
0.0477741398,
0.0118144033,
-0.0388926305,
-0.0765308365,
-0.0127500873,
0.0681617707,
0.0801888779,
0.0041901139,
-0.007373706,
-0.0043811919,
0.0475418083,
-0.0467916243,
-0.0021430505,
0.0016076573,
0.0693022907,
-0.0032670354,
-0.0284549166,
0.0246996153,
-0.0027239961,
-0.0117072165,
0.0437327251,
-0.0336900428,
0.008199011,
0.0110282339,
0.0049208673,
0.0203371737,
-0.0002507035,
-0.0488662571,
0.0251221023,
0.02589106,
-0.0438489132,
-0.0053083706,
-0.0551992953,
-0.0390331298,
-0.0014310156,
2.766e-7,
-0.040149793,
0.0112331631,
-0.0005829797,
-0.0311242603,
0.0332864486,
0.0860528499,
-0.0030815694,
0.0045695924,
-0.0057622199,
0.0066081164,
0.0177211706,
-0.0068408865,
0.0632841438,
-0.0018880493,
-0.0742834508,
-0.0302931853,
-0.0317078158,
0.0316213332,
0.0216079652,
-0.00935122,
0.0621727109,
0.0393212102,
0.0194202699,
-0.0327356197,
0.0501768366,
0.0190923549,
0.0500295125,
-0.0164285172,
-0.0009227608,
-0.0240342077,
0.0325949378,
-0.0242835712,
-0.0238124747,
-0.0123514878,
-0.0335913301,
-0.0036945636,
0.002948951,
0.0446837023,
-0.0015880972,
-0.0722377524,
0.012759787,
0.0431638658,
-0.0333255827,
0.0304972921,
0.043989867,
-0.059538886,
-0.0142070483,
-0.0138507364,
-0.0250631534,
0.0115603274,
0.004109866,
-0.044155214,
-0.0296434443,
-0.0099166948,
0.0301751178,
0.0549973138,
-0.0333977081,
-0.0142241064,
-0.0091870511,
0.0115114776,
-0.0293322187,
-0.0443833806,
-0.0320074297,
0.0330760516,
0.0121277533,
-0.0716926605,
-0.0307196807,
1.856227951e-34,
0.047918871,
-0.0086599216,
0.0576269515,
-0.0351409391,
-0.0055171489,
0.0315805674,
0.0106984666,
-0.016356457,
0.0667477921,
0.0097530363,
-0.0184707604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06559v1
|
Harnessing Business and Media Insights with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T06:24:38 | 2024-06-02T06:24:38 |
Yujia Bao, Ankit Parag Shah, Neeru Narang, Jonathan Rivers, Rajeev Maksey, Lan Guan, Louise N. Barrere, Shelley Evenson, Rahul Basole, Connie Miao, Ankit Mehta, Fabien Boulay, Su Min Park, Natalie E. Pearson, Eldhose Joy, Tiger He, Sumiran Thakur, Koustav Ghosal, Josh On, Phoebe Morrison, Tim Major, Eva Siqi Wang, Gina Escobar, Jiaheng Wei, Tharindu Cyril Weerasooriya, Queena Song, Daria Lashkevich, Clare Chen, Gyuhak Kim, Dengpan Yin, Don Hejna, Mo Nomeli, Wei Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces Fortune Analytics Language Model (FALM). FALM empowers
users with direct access to comprehensive business analysis, including market
trends, company performance metrics, and expert insights. Unlike generic LLMs,
FALM leverages a curated knowledge base built from professional journalism,
enabling it to deliver precise and in-depth answers to intricate business
questions. Users can further leverage natural language queries to directly
visualize financial data, generating insightful charts and graphs to understand
trends across diverse business sectors clearly. FALM fosters user trust and
ensures output accuracy through three novel methods: 1) Time-aware reasoning
guarantees accurate event registration and prioritizes recent updates. 2)
Thematic trend analysis explicitly examines topic evolution over time,
providing insights into emerging business landscapes. 3) Content referencing
and task decomposition enhance answer fidelity and data visualization accuracy.
We conduct both automated and human evaluations, demonstrating FALM's
significant performance improvements over baseline methods while prioritizing
responsible AI practices. These benchmarks establish FALM as a cutting-edge LLM
in the business and media domains, with exceptional accuracy and
trustworthiness.
|
[
0.027472036,
0.0632761419,
-0.0266958997,
0.0193172563,
-0.0064476747,
-0.0200377908,
-0.0290327165,
0.0073818932,
0.0163054392,
-0.0500433221,
0.0030266659,
0.0335261337,
-0.0077467393,
0.0842017531,
-0.0112433042,
0.0012242917,
0.0249815863,
0.0021524308,
0.0612363108,
0.023084525,
0.0166092347,
0.0338702649,
0.0098141916,
0.0160202924,
0.0083203726,
-0.0104798852,
-0.0082854591,
0.008010963,
-0.0140473731,
-0.0489944555,
-0.0252642613,
0.0237255916,
0.0279007051,
0.0060666502,
0.0000021322,
-0.0688036904,
-0.0181005038,
-0.0177622046,
0.0003326525,
0.0045762057,
0.0452864058,
-0.0106491158,
0.0399777628,
0.0153002357,
-0.0874787346,
0.036558982,
0.0203724597,
0.0477985553,
0.070169121,
0.0305373538,
-0.0259681549,
-0.0425149389,
0.0108032692,
-0.0129447374,
-0.0002083993,
-0.0925615206,
-0.0145878466,
0.0373479798,
0.026363682,
-0.0024193958,
0.0087393215,
0.0414138027,
0.0178520698,
-0.0209030602,
0.0342701785,
0.0160901826,
0.0152970888,
-0.001209215,
-0.0268391185,
0.0335457362,
0.0407224782,
0.009431107,
0.0119765718,
-0.0051969318,
-0.0033004584,
0.0202055462,
-0.0598382279,
0.011709244,
-0.0050871959,
0.00218249,
0.0209689345,
0.0000252845,
0.0263508018,
0.0275253002,
-0.0041546114,
0.08023417,
-0.0054133693,
-0.0149003034,
-0.0200854093,
0.0128735797,
0.073024258,
-0.0677895546,
0.0076556359,
0.0483616889,
-0.0381985083,
-0.0034780505,
0.008689519,
0.0284894854,
-0.0047130967,
-0.0832975805,
0.0072287126,
0.0032023941,
0.0187816527,
0.0710299015,
0.0450931415,
0.0177238286,
-0.0041228044,
-0.0832532346,
0.004686025,
-0.0099244639,
-0.0523404516,
0.0099152355,
0.01229221,
0.0257035494,
-0.0456240512,
-0.0100520737,
-0.0244222432,
0.0198345277,
-0.0381537043,
0.0341265611,
-0.0069656051,
0.017649347,
-0.0022287506,
-0.016865097,
-0.0698015168,
0.0132098198,
-0.0543566532,
0.0330495313,
-0.0200130213,
-0.0326400921,
0.0253939144,
0.0123535572,
-0.0048084031,
0.0099885156,
0.0045866556,
0.0817207471,
0.0060712146,
0.0200831685,
-0.1149899289,
-0.0678458065,
0.0072143935,
-0.0261546597,
-0.0435745232,
-0.0601449497,
0.0201217961,
-0.0110875396,
-0.0351174846,
-0.0081928633,
0.0156546198,
0.0324085057,
-0.0449843034,
0.025888158,
-0.0201479085,
0.0085321516,
0.0341788642,
-0.0105402665,
0.0352368616,
0.0809882954,
0.0328063741,
0.0099669881,
0.0539051332,
-0.0035386174,
-0.0161043257,
0.0179089475,
-0.0014547075,
-0.0386207886,
-0.0425205007,
0.039609354,
-0.0726910457,
-0.0100056687,
0.0170922931,
0.020319216,
0.0046723988,
0.0144674238,
0.0759825706,
0.0351720974,
0.0321771875,
0.0526479036,
0.008904906,
-0.0345142037,
0.0068925428,
-0.0396869965,
-0.0002196969,
0.049086839,
-0.0172448214,
0.0026733151,
-0.0066709635,
0.0158781931,
-0.0232972912,
-0.0386241861,
-0.0040322468,
0.0147810997,
0.0164144859,
0.0201126616,
0.026604427,
-0.0383370742,
-0.0107607516,
0.0504043326,
0.0113477036,
-0.0071885302,
0.0245435275,
0.0007808646,
0.0681897774,
0.0940651,
0.0425183885,
-0.0046488959,
0.0193807632,
-0.0104407398,
-0.0010216723,
0.0226555467,
0.035840787,
-0.0035265014,
-0.0484508537,
-0.0200268626,
-0.019417882,
0.0176463127,
0.0095663927,
-0.0054330891,
0.0123171881,
0.048538141,
-0.0190843064,
-0.0531619117,
-0.0023873844,
0.0089718094,
-0.0135397743,
-0.0165416766,
0.0065888944,
-0.0089091193,
-0.008942103,
0.0739172846,
0.0101125203,
0.0331637338,
-0.0087171961,
-0.0221022777,
-0.0383028314,
0.011839523,
0.0241631716,
0.0390396155,
0.0243635047,
-0.0286212917,
-0.0429776572,
0.0141510833,
-0.0170003939,
-0.0141103026,
0.0069222017,
-0.0356914923,
0.0408977158,
-0.0559762642,
-0.0612489656,
-0.0100541394,
-0.0058599482,
-0.0326783173,
0.0856618434,
-0.0223130044,
0.0063501825,
-0.0168447252,
-0.0454963259,
-0.002949392,
-0.0294575188,
0.0436949879,
0.0332181603,
0.0097499909,
0.0378132425,
0.0755789652,
-0.0322813429,
-0.0443262644,
0.019082509,
-0.0765521377,
-0.0056076613,
-0.0133189941,
0.0216471385,
0.0113192471,
0.0102201151,
-0.0158185437,
-0.0020047517,
-0.0244830027,
-0.0454881489,
0.0112423506,
0.0107782753,
0.0564184301,
0.0260194205,
0.0207535625,
-0.0458602123,
-0.0024069047,
-0.0416958816,
0.0140652042,
0.0902976319,
0.0020362877,
-0.0359575786,
-0.0533608608,
-0.0576190799,
-0.0188029949,
0.0024154435,
0.0341216996,
0.0091380784,
-0.02958747,
0.0022551923,
0.0193891674,
0.0088736173,
0.0655081943,
-0.0135060037,
-0.0455238894,
-0.0372722968,
-0.0017006374,
-0.0293586198,
0.0336932614,
-0.0214561727,
-0.0425894968,
0.0458629318,
0.0226030573,
0.0086917421,
0.018390175,
-0.0439380072,
0.0431729555,
-0.0221519489,
0.0197790153,
-0.0458249934,
0.0128559368,
-0.0094125401,
0.08649683,
0.0118735814,
-0.0242523905,
0.0406185836,
0.006075019,
0.0193772074,
-0.0227634758,
-0.0617188998,
-0.0667734072,
0.0344913267,
-0.0524064302,
0.0167733822,
-0.036353875,
-0.0445468538,
-0.0361761712,
-0.0200868174,
0.0465494767,
-0.0365657844,
0.0485318154,
-0.03088063,
0.0083204834,
0.0187738407,
0.0391353108,
-0.0151992189,
-0.0763007477,
-0.0439861603,
0.0068979599,
0.0257536732,
-0.0440733805,
-0.0489911996,
0.0007602393,
0.0197533127,
-0.0438501649,
-0.0178861935,
-0.0501182154,
0.0197388288,
0.0334757678,
0.0601078644,
-0.0013871189,
0.0403418057,
0.0061955908,
0.0364448354,
0.058591973,
0.0487104915,
0.0022538321,
-0.0486966297,
0.01419771,
-0.0179579575,
-0.0506921113,
0.0172618739,
0.0292888265,
-0.0000136512,
-0.0255662743,
0.0385250896,
0.1264734566,
0.0291049723,
-0.0035213742,
-0.0027744249,
0.0291462708,
-0.0306747332,
0.0075693377,
0.0636607334,
-0.0960760787,
-0.0000967273,
-0.0342744477,
0.0203832742,
0.0451729149,
-0.074365519,
-0.0215260219,
-0.1189490482,
0.0476333313,
-0.0218510907,
0.0561597906,
-0.0285654701,
-0.0858544037,
-0.0025320125,
-0.0372119099,
-0.0266601853,
-0.0097388932,
-0.0242084097,
0.005724242,
-0.0035239586,
-0.0749652013,
-0.0260566063,
0.0467196852,
-0.0198054016,
-0.0246656574,
0.0493017472,
0.0564265996,
-0.0516680181,
-0.0230355114,
-0.0477673933,
0.0313921236,
0.0179155897,
-0.0245899577,
0.0311306398,
-0.0197563637,
-0.000004309,
-0.0226634946,
0.0244596861,
-0.0122773787,
0.0267020445,
0.0194388703,
0.0557976514,
-0.0140948044,
-0.0160141326,
-0.0415541418,
0.0152810477,
0.0055060918,
0.0743692741,
-0.0025267659,
-0.0330369398,
0.0031544534,
-0.0395131111,
0.0031973969,
-0.0106780808,
-0.0431498624,
0.0099913878,
-0.0266996287,
-0.0513562374,
-0.0860765651,
-0.0678450242,
0.0144685488,
0.0136709176,
-0.0049843476,
-0.0141965346,
0.0605317019,
-0.0048686708,
-0.0367258899,
-0.0137120057,
-0.017100988,
0.0387909934,
-0.0064202282,
0.0146593377,
0.0077770771,
0.0290176552,
-0.0369948223,
0.0251872446,
-0.0816440657,
-0.0226475131,
-0.0240391456,
0.0015215038,
0.0211783778,
-0.0067785559,
-0.0275862478,
0.0149406437,
0.0247943513,
0.0457564481,
-0.0881766975,
-0.0149097638,
-0.0131673673,
0.0168551765,
0.0065100486,
0.016700089,
-0.0694803372,
0.0100279311,
-0.0474470295,
0.0494405441,
-0.0725173876,
-0.0321202949,
-0.0153985061,
-0.0255633537,
0.0169361606,
0.0294253621,
-0.0003894962,
-0.0028918774,
-0.0442420878,
-0.0136101255,
-0.0133211836,
-0.0179530308,
-0.0283684954,
-0.0190152247,
0.004287486,
-0.0221763402,
0.0528214164,
-0.0418807194,
-0.037083894,
-0.08275453,
0.0324556753,
0.0046290075,
0.0277256202,
-0.0327824429,
0.0067692879,
-0.0197573323,
-0.019264115,
-0.0053534959,
0.0246428121,
0.0257177781,
0.0172930863,
0.0165652055,
0.0177397914,
0.0117104016,
-0.0078289527,
-0.0678562224,
-0.0705536157,
0.0562103428,
0.0104449037,
0.0189394522,
-0.0259877928,
0.0019041782,
-0.0038058441,
-0.0001353366,
0.035275925,
0.0067433752,
0.0311177429,
-0.0172016528,
0.0240480658,
0.0082851211,
-0.049546238,
-0.0040843035,
0.0838768408,
0.0255438276,
-0.0089376094,
-0.0179129951,
-0.0481344014,
-0.0330348611,
-0.0474565327,
0.0546453595,
0.0167387091,
0.0162344985,
0.0049911612,
-0.0714642704,
-0.0571221299,
0.0497945063,
-0.0096566295,
-0.0267333742,
-0.0098171039,
0.0211586058,
0.078051582,
0.0607751086,
0.0034248366,
-0.028158823,
0.0336553678,
-0.0826782286,
-0.0236666631,
-0.0480861887,
-6.704854473e-33,
-0.0053883651,
-0.0562590547,
0.0291099045,
-0.0145213595,
0.019312216,
0.0251622368,
-0.0359266289,
-0.0123782502,
-0.0549192876,
0.0193206929,
-0.0083959978,
0.0300767794,
0.0085815741,
-0.0239561144,
0.044707045,
-0.0350799523,
0.0366687402,
-0.0307718813,
0.0065253046,
0.0122677078,
0.0056309281,
0.0201481506,
0.0333319642,
-0.0952782929,
0.053824421,
0.0140752103,
-0.0254769213,
0.016340021,
0.0981713906,
0.0416448526,
0.0186546445,
0.0192604493,
0.0169498641,
-0.1036655679,
-0.0124324821,
0.0206323974,
-0.034331847,
-0.0733040869,
0.0307002775,
-0.0063504032,
-0.0028493248,
0.0418515205,
0.0382074341,
0.0065078097,
0.0069538299,
-0.0012752167,
0.0610237233,
-0.0123421745,
0.0082600433,
-0.0530407205,
-0.0306143463,
0.0298104919,
-0.039600648,
0.0593017191,
-0.017278146,
0.0282745641,
-0.0062669697,
0.0411719009,
-0.050043758,
0.0067953877,
-0.0045534372,
-0.0144652762,
0.0414660238,
-0.0160121303,
0.0039673476,
0.0497840531,
-0.0440622047,
0.0142508382,
-0.0316580832,
0.0571617708,
0.0137752779,
0.0648936629,
0.0154778427,
0.0259144641,
-0.0343883596,
-0.0032971906,
-0.0564629398,
0.0610917844,
0.0670116544,
0.0257249773,
-0.003843331,
-0.0027415538,
-0.0321173146,
-0.0232489333,
0.0394685008,
0.0356577896,
-0.0433589257,
-0.020767428,
0.0055217687,
-0.0097048385,
-0.0011494688,
0.0392941535,
0.0224893279,
-0.0458711348,
-0.069582738,
0.0192935076,
0.0174175669,
0.003930483,
0.0337529331,
0.0064041698,
-0.0642919093,
0.043182563,
-0.0589906387,
0.0239212923,
0.0102415262,
-0.0065278863,
-0.0205530226,
0.0178965889,
-0.0368491895,
-0.0325951241,
0.0148478458,
0.0121138766,
-0.0068027563,
-0.0334273614,
0.0248784237,
0.0178899206,
0.0001376609,
0.0500640906,
0.027600551,
0.0524493493,
0.0118121123,
0.0052298862,
0.0145291695,
0.0227526911,
-0.001668956,
-0.0545809045,
0.0003363404,
0.036990162,
0.0255085807,
-0.042133972,
-0.0465545021,
-0.0132814506,
2.912e-7,
0.0679900348,
0.0412398279,
-0.0276673418,
0.0746272877,
0.0331785195,
0.0451196656,
0.0141172754,
0.0041464944,
-0.0102516161,
-0.0031853763,
0.0309360642,
0.0234452281,
0.0173085965,
0.0715361387,
-0.0460785516,
-0.0390246511,
-0.0627065301,
0.0006051378,
-0.0944700316,
0.0216952693,
0.0451469757,
0.02187532,
0.0487337895,
-0.011236012,
-0.0148871159,
-0.0654897392,
0.0465979613,
-0.0271311719,
-0.0281053111,
0.0147183854,
0.0060088197,
0.0508351885,
-0.0228582863,
-0.0370818898,
-0.0422290713,
0.0199121851,
0.0085328901,
0.0029457456,
-0.002401188,
-0.0029997968,
0.0011594868,
-0.0406187512,
0.0086489199,
-0.0615451038,
0.0731256455,
-0.0124119632,
-0.0380452946,
-0.0892608389,
-0.0418061353,
0.0116987266,
0.0013297527,
-0.0007609068,
-0.042546384,
0.0205114987,
-0.0031165015,
0.0041852966,
0.0032911135,
-0.0112770861,
0.0052272929,
0.0233533829,
-0.0242174976,
0.0012966262,
-0.0366598517,
0.009381528,
0.0246574488,
0.0067449375,
0.0620194264,
2.634680029e-34,
0.0252756979,
0.0123965833,
-0.0115446206,
0.028362928,
0.0804257542,
0.0408178046,
-0.0439261012,
0.0252935067,
0.0367236063,
-0.0530121103,
-0.0041139089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00628v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00628v1
|
Transforming Computer Security and Public Trust Through the Exploration of Fine-Tuning Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T06:10:31 | 2024-06-02T06:10:31 |
Garrett Crumrine, Izzat Alsmadi, Jesus Guerrero, Yuvaraj Munian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY, cs.LG, B.8.0; I.2.7; I.2.8; I.2.11; J.0; K.4.2; K.4.1
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized how we interact with
machines. However, this technological advancement has been paralleled by the
emergence of "Mallas," malicious services operating underground that exploit
LLMs for nefarious purposes. Such services create malware, phishing attacks,
and deceptive websites, escalating the cyber security threats landscape. This
paper delves into the proliferation of Mallas by examining the use of various
pre-trained language models and their efficiency and vulnerabilities when
misused. Building on a dataset from the Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures
(CVE) program, it explores fine-tuning methodologies to generate code and
explanatory text related to identified vulnerabilities. This research aims to
shed light on the operational strategies and exploitation techniques of Mallas,
leading to the development of more secure and trustworthy AI applications. The
paper concludes by emphasizing the need for further research, enhanced
safeguards, and ethical guidelines to mitigate the risks associated with the
malicious application of LLMs.
|
[
0.0358634889,
0.0704296827,
-0.0208053645,
0.0515384935,
-0.0411909632,
-0.0139455553,
0.0377278849,
-0.0165798962,
0.030976342,
-0.0287289247,
-0.0130922822,
-0.020861093,
0.0075395261,
0.0411630832,
0.0633861646,
-0.0061870008,
0.0646417141,
-0.0616150573,
-0.0049446449,
-0.0052704429,
-0.0232650526,
0.0042055738,
0.0033455279,
0.0596356541,
0.0109288674,
-0.0219986346,
-0.0065600816,
0.0119904382,
0.0272581354,
-0.0194929503,
-0.0101086218,
0.0047890893,
0.0067825941,
0.0145710334,
0.000002109,
-0.0570630878,
0.001405509,
0.0354162902,
-0.0160128456,
0.0524669401,
0.0251723956,
-0.0174929462,
-0.0096134907,
0.0357495658,
-0.0110160019,
0.0100827422,
0.0446864218,
0.0324930623,
0.0644834787,
0.086253725,
-0.0026179564,
-0.0183090232,
0.0432792976,
-0.0061739665,
-0.0404796936,
-0.0608535856,
0.0496681035,
-0.0032640442,
0.0032801756,
0.0406977721,
0.0250498671,
-0.0235018674,
-0.0008975102,
-0.0240362864,
-0.0390931517,
0.0428041779,
-0.0273714308,
-0.0115660736,
-0.0050017172,
0.0245501008,
-0.0601030439,
-0.0138130877,
0.0233094376,
0.0080804564,
-0.0013015697,
0.0166025925,
0.0312381797,
0.0559188724,
-0.0190021917,
-0.0203292239,
0.0330620669,
-0.0060712597,
0.0463054478,
0.0480921902,
-0.0199109819,
0.0444670096,
0.0056220484,
-0.0056785624,
0.0097027207,
-0.0797050074,
0.0194645654,
-0.0500198007,
0.0129019143,
0.0309603792,
-0.0032009119,
0.00628987,
-0.0584675446,
-0.0243964083,
0.0530243628,
-0.0499015674,
-0.0017598977,
0.0105366791,
-0.0118116755,
-0.0004758886,
0.00563729,
0.036842607,
-0.0163806584,
0.0234783385,
0.0026758451,
-0.0010297006,
-0.0165686551,
-0.0048779375,
-0.0248198714,
0.0351736546,
0.0302262492,
0.0169013981,
-0.0511621311,
0.0346655436,
-0.0400898792,
0.0750562772,
-0.0229479373,
-0.027123265,
-0.0025146753,
-0.0017931967,
0.0234420579,
-0.0257554967,
-0.0454320349,
0.0066453842,
-0.0192165263,
-0.06817846,
-0.0051558698,
0.0320121609,
-0.0812507719,
-0.0428080447,
0.0031828415,
0.113673158,
0.0450730212,
-0.0031275132,
-0.0489915237,
-0.0595241934,
-0.0326469727,
-0.0039776149,
-0.0246539898,
-0.057345964,
-0.0503380261,
0.0037980925,
0.0107617676,
-0.0476892516,
-0.0202020667,
-0.0184643697,
-0.0725054368,
0.0616352074,
-0.0427164473,
0.0096205836,
0.0320398323,
0.0104889134,
0.0108710295,
0.0121007403,
-0.0047756736,
0.0899990574,
0.022359712,
-0.0536854416,
0.0677806512,
0.0269114729,
-0.0250413418,
0.0281975623,
-0.0142185166,
0.0349297822,
0.0225650351,
-0.0337083861,
-0.0319366455,
0.048995845,
0.0097688725,
-0.0175440386,
0.0756280348,
0.0217424892,
-0.0295400731,
0.0514423363,
0.054663375,
0.0034190919,
0.0157376193,
-0.0525057688,
-0.0642602295,
-0.0208163764,
-0.0791465119,
-0.0347016938,
-0.0479046702,
0.0725478679,
-0.0174068697,
0.002751098,
0.0041657439,
-0.0445007272,
0.0077703814,
-0.0081668543,
0.0361248367,
0.0335852876,
0.0061928225,
-0.0229924787,
0.0217818934,
-0.0188325103,
-0.0148565369,
-0.1079214513,
-0.0353212357,
0.0704788864,
0.0363799371,
-0.0109881638,
-0.0397870354,
-0.0105705773,
-0.0095486995,
-0.0209110677,
0.0100591453,
0.0176534224,
-0.0210209936,
-0.0421750434,
0.0234444309,
-0.0237206519,
0.023877563,
0.0289314836,
-0.0136105148,
0.0020174384,
0.0127897747,
-0.0246993825,
-0.0438374616,
0.0118134627,
0.0100875134,
-0.0056981221,
0.0205950718,
0.0217606593,
0.0486687608,
-0.0000093026,
-0.0128418356,
0.0476155728,
0.0540150031,
0.0120784473,
-0.011056656,
-0.0102229882,
0.0189001318,
0.1029534861,
0.0111777904,
-0.0250543021,
0.0426600985,
0.0566474944,
-0.0290710665,
0.0078879325,
0.0692616701,
-0.0430446826,
-0.0243032724,
-0.0008617727,
0.0203465074,
-0.0354061127,
0.0219539367,
-0.0231464114,
0.0468553528,
0.0040336554,
-0.0433432087,
-0.0148572512,
0.0481387563,
-0.0013226743,
-0.0095991138,
-0.0272325426,
-0.0118010975,
-0.0372306891,
0.0433353186,
0.0059364634,
0.0237258896,
0.0044018673,
-0.0292844772,
-0.0620900691,
-0.010363589,
-0.0084999846,
0.013878148,
0.0581625998,
-0.007852491,
-0.0367739908,
-0.013592558,
0.0060698711,
0.0106499083,
-0.0224419739,
0.009631604,
0.0214435924,
-0.017642485,
-0.0704442784,
-0.0127232391,
-0.003354281,
-0.0232342128,
0.051548142,
0.0237953775,
-0.0034122802,
-0.0331392959,
0.0538202673,
-0.01194786,
-0.0039640139,
-0.0278353542,
-0.0765207559,
0.0079099992,
-0.0137823028,
-0.0215242002,
0.034750469,
0.0273516029,
0.0670508891,
0.0799143314,
0.0418401286,
-0.0112148561,
-0.0290411394,
0.013364369,
-0.0706220195,
-0.0514437705,
-0.0170822795,
0.0310503822,
0.055250328,
0.0453824922,
-0.0077976435,
-0.0309536103,
0.0274295136,
-0.0070454823,
-0.0184718911,
-0.0047094813,
-0.0750239268,
-0.0086506912,
0.0179184657,
0.012984789,
-0.0906648189,
0.0664693192,
-0.0608957335,
0.0297429021,
-0.0434893481,
-0.0606237091,
-0.0011048005,
0.011303179,
-0.0329810232,
0.0401800722,
0.0327402428,
-0.0337955467,
-0.0234297886,
-0.0385557339,
0.0015618105,
-0.0151805598,
0.0215215161,
-0.0071267532,
-0.0089894934,
0.0230772737,
-0.0031839481,
-0.0375408754,
-0.0651058778,
-0.0466952138,
0.0072317156,
0.0235326402,
-0.0343285985,
-0.0267609525,
-0.0144642964,
0.0561889969,
-0.0031993755,
0.0158115458,
-0.0115108714,
-0.0184642822,
-0.0346708149,
-0.0002685596,
-0.0601194762,
0.0100482879,
0.0134807955,
0.0258801784,
0.0267852601,
0.0342168845,
0.0048459191,
-0.0460830703,
-0.0045290748,
0.0129154641,
-0.0377820581,
0.0040093581,
0.0654519945,
0.0198883638,
-0.0206300635,
-0.0270600729,
0.059175685,
0.0120699247,
-0.0445878357,
0.0334450044,
-0.0061416174,
-0.0062750396,
0.0300449524,
0.0200197082,
-0.0622679852,
0.0046863919,
0.0239209682,
0.0457689948,
-0.0276833605,
-0.0297280159,
0.0207650345,
-0.0964973345,
0.034767665,
0.029052563,
-0.0313722678,
-0.0321846828,
-0.0446406193,
-0.0289035104,
0.0165687725,
0.0113804694,
-0.0095459539,
-0.0062514478,
-0.0226640739,
0.0062341779,
-0.0292228144,
-0.0451658368,
0.0238769017,
-0.0317874737,
0.0552494265,
0.0622947291,
-0.0005216144,
-0.056676399,
0.0240366049,
0.0346491002,
-0.0146540236,
0.0321797952,
0.0208886266,
0.0414667688,
0.0145931048,
-0.0256566554,
0.0330819786,
0.038892772,
-0.0273461435,
-0.0163993649,
0.0724240914,
0.0279626399,
-0.0419291258,
-0.0105681382,
-0.0078838523,
-0.0171396472,
0.0626587868,
0.0439988934,
0.0171624515,
-0.037207745,
0.0166520029,
-0.0387025289,
0.0185219031,
0.038608823,
-0.0410034098,
0.0369732752,
-0.0220122524,
-0.0470227003,
-0.0315169841,
-0.0225291792,
-0.0017473021,
0.0042451965,
0.0762541741,
-0.0568818264,
0.0334998816,
0.019444406,
-0.0187339578,
-0.0107694576,
-0.0325605571,
0.0566496551,
-0.0410918482,
0.0205120686,
0.0138303339,
-0.0350872651,
-0.0171093624,
0.0120116165,
-0.0427675508,
-0.0746308863,
0.0021733432,
0.0753772408,
0.0236660801,
-0.0151388394,
-0.0510783568,
-0.0454695411,
0.0594719499,
-0.0173920989,
-0.0332684368,
-0.0054874318,
0.0588752143,
-0.0490273647,
0.0156200863,
0.0018217698,
-0.0191684887,
0.0161888376,
0.0647711605,
-0.0339632556,
-0.0469091721,
-0.0040317881,
0.0311091132,
0.0614210181,
0.0325101353,
-0.0304693338,
0.0231891107,
0.0282649044,
0.0104097147,
-0.0182138514,
-0.0289260279,
0.0217774697,
0.00571148,
0.0229042787,
0.0004569774,
0.0530015491,
-0.02730483,
-0.0206622425,
-0.0002159362,
0.0170677025,
0.0421296246,
0.0418649763,
0.0770142227,
0.0856121778,
-0.004866132,
0.0073279338,
0.0613146946,
-0.0062806769,
0.0312575325,
-0.0109849973,
0.0079023372,
-0.0229452886,
0.0044196541,
-0.0459732935,
0.0499378853,
-0.0337661952,
-0.1082982644,
0.0173618067,
0.0337510668,
0.0319856778,
0.0176607333,
0.0067440355,
-0.0136210313,
0.0119023267,
-0.0479225777,
0.0124393497,
0.0003118658,
-0.0621040985,
-0.0117706945,
-0.0107157864,
-0.0424298309,
0.0030100616,
0.0810311958,
-0.0376826823,
0.0627894476,
0.0052563753,
-0.0294643957,
-0.0048941663,
-0.0140552679,
0.0090280883,
0.0159069113,
-0.0455698408,
-0.0641617849,
-0.0550548509,
-0.0771219954,
-0.0032788771,
-0.0429336242,
0.0205236953,
0.0155963367,
0.0039759045,
0.0745536983,
0.0068565775,
0.0622214675,
-0.093029514,
0.0165308863,
-0.0321383812,
-0.0400798805,
-0.0155774392,
-5.722515885e-33,
0.0364504904,
-0.0528773218,
-0.0291273762,
-0.000631132,
0.0291041769,
0.0320961289,
-0.0230144206,
0.0011261151,
-0.0297643356,
-0.0043451153,
0.0019885281,
-0.028104689,
0.0061312574,
0.0052615106,
-0.0177202132,
0.0115461498,
-0.0050432193,
-0.0070226421,
-0.0199614819,
0.0502769388,
0.0574893504,
-0.0178621132,
0.0139489947,
-0.1218839511,
0.0345201343,
0.0123511124,
-0.0610496402,
0.0014073018,
-0.0313314125,
0.0392251685,
0.015512431,
0.0400138311,
0.0159187261,
-0.0054700053,
0.0061629163,
0.0326220356,
0.0236428045,
0.0021214187,
-0.0150566176,
-0.0173445344,
0.0565004312,
-0.0858391896,
0.0273251031,
-0.0368656777,
-0.0144950813,
0.0346774682,
0.0080782697,
-0.032541316,
-0.0027105573,
-0.0607456341,
-0.0384579673,
-0.0207493957,
-0.052356448,
0.0223916881,
-0.0160293244,
-0.0049444209,
0.0145318815,
0.0294442736,
-0.0168084111,
0.0628358275,
0.0411068909,
-0.0235951133,
0.0475224331,
0.0049619344,
-0.0199826527,
0.0202774219,
0.013971379,
-0.0148433028,
-0.0078564007,
0.0292891897,
0.0108693885,
0.065066427,
0.0454558805,
0.0452523716,
-0.0242952108,
-0.0672489107,
-0.074570559,
0.0174611788,
0.0164666139,
0.0442880243,
0.0289616846,
-0.0203832891,
-0.068296425,
0.0049081529,
-0.0378303491,
-0.0279168896,
-0.0409642309,
-0.0273541976,
0.0100749237,
-0.0367158987,
-0.0648567602,
0.0145462612,
-0.0100356499,
-0.0493740886,
0.0138831129,
0.0299527999,
0.0051593664,
-0.0049958718,
-0.0218828842,
0.0112260589,
-0.0085092401,
-0.0520279817,
-0.0218827687,
-0.0318445079,
0.0469280146,
-0.0083817961,
0.0164439566,
0.0201200768,
-0.0526187196,
0.0041530156,
0.0022639411,
0.0325971954,
0.0363435112,
0.0641568899,
0.0319922008,
-0.0094667105,
0.0168945957,
0.0007252583,
0.0391426347,
-0.0171462558,
-0.0274592768,
0.0360193476,
-0.0280250534,
0.0505369678,
-0.0193634052,
0.0079670111,
-0.0530037992,
0.0083153639,
0.0815953016,
-0.0341523103,
-0.020394884,
-0.0212951861,
2.959e-7,
-0.0041818405,
0.0494877174,
-0.0049300678,
0.0198735036,
0.003848748,
0.0786170736,
-0.0032446431,
0.0544248447,
-0.0269115772,
-0.030265823,
-0.0222272612,
0.0091571342,
0.0322648101,
0.0219589733,
-0.016017409,
0.0233267806,
-0.074705556,
0.0027501627,
-0.0835535899,
0.0263599567,
0.0501737818,
0.0936673284,
0.0057997615,
-0.0500046015,
-0.0195407514,
-0.0900660381,
-0.0206410848,
-0.0196557492,
-0.0087835696,
0.0199810471,
0.0006433687,
0.0757074356,
0.0219188537,
0.0620543286,
-0.0247273147,
-0.0263311025,
-0.049626939,
0.058411058,
0.019120954,
0.0284354966,
-0.0227727927,
-0.0439367816,
0.0088016381,
-0.0645821393,
0.0520487353,
-0.0203991812,
-0.0434327051,
-0.0146103678,
-0.0180990323,
-0.0144651663,
0.0047254185,
-0.0571249723,
0.0150273275,
0.0071796179,
-0.0033784702,
-0.0007278965,
0.03126847,
-0.0425528847,
0.0058177654,
-0.0043501118,
-0.0242332369,
-0.0248124972,
0.0070122145,
0.0071916068,
0.0276497621,
-0.0045190239,
0.0481702462,
2.834246138e-34,
0.0008180878,
-0.0675584972,
0.0156613961,
0.0101806149,
0.0292064529,
0.0458357409,
-0.0165126137,
0.0348665155,
-0.0346603952,
-0.0280049685,
-0.007171432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00627v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00627v1
|
Prompt Framework for Role-playing: Generation and Evaluation
| 2024-06-02T06:09:56 | 2024-06-02T06:09:56 |
Xun Liu, Zhengwei Ni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have demonstrated remarkable abilities in
generating natural language, understanding user instruction, and mimicking
human language use. These capabilities have garnered considerable interest in
applications such as role-playing. However, the process of collecting
individual role scripts (or profiles) data and manually evaluating the
performance can be costly. We introduce a framework that uses prompts to
leverage the state-of-the-art (SOTA) LLMs to construct role-playing dialogue
datasets and evaluate the role-playing performance. Additionally, we employ
recall-oriented evaluation Rouge-L metric to support the result of the LLM
evaluator.
|
[
0.0382499993,
0.0168315973,
-0.0377409011,
0.054475043,
-0.0311703235,
-0.0146723231,
0.0067167212,
-0.0186296608,
0.0196927823,
-0.0108894436,
-0.0484388694,
-0.0851583555,
-0.0014561303,
0.0873540118,
0.0116518177,
-0.0749611929,
0.0425125733,
-0.0566160791,
0.0436338298,
0.0132210385,
-0.0357602313,
0.0238872822,
-0.0437000059,
0.069759734,
0.0174364299,
-0.0117347697,
-0.0135918958,
0.011036952,
0.0296197105,
-0.0441254936,
0.0131704528,
-0.0027391247,
0.0196925849,
0.0225011911,
0.0000017943,
-0.0482523255,
0.0398920402,
-0.0202358812,
-0.0178889185,
0.0091651212,
0.0274551325,
0.0543288104,
-0.011994876,
0.0282111857,
-0.0393698029,
-0.0212355088,
0.0334263481,
0.0056965067,
0.0924678072,
0.071627222,
0.0068119206,
-0.0198616143,
-0.0341488272,
-0.0184004102,
0.0454110689,
-0.005130637,
-0.02664488,
0.0352632441,
0.0858778879,
-0.0196227916,
0.0180523675,
0.020507833,
-0.0003244204,
-0.0595137179,
-0.0299076829,
0.0312297978,
0.0192976333,
0.031274803,
-0.025484968,
0.0641610697,
0.0628215671,
0.0261058733,
0.0073369504,
0.0009432777,
0.0453196242,
0.0370967537,
-0.0100460248,
0.020823475,
0.0098772533,
-0.0304964297,
-0.0008901045,
0.0516449213,
0.0208115764,
-0.0190148242,
0.0290334933,
0.0364114083,
0.0112206396,
-0.0387493968,
-0.0500554182,
-0.0284306575,
-0.0166910701,
-0.0378310904,
-0.0251962356,
0.0388191827,
-0.0868445188,
0.0422605798,
-0.0487637296,
0.0729951039,
0.0350080281,
0.0215736721,
0.0576770864,
0.0326455459,
-0.0217893757,
0.0516230986,
0.0124338455,
0.0723139644,
0.0464449264,
-0.0020070707,
-0.0079600681,
0.0340073593,
-0.0380422324,
-0.0368608981,
-0.0691114292,
0.023194667,
-0.0328682363,
-0.0166591778,
-0.0258923192,
0.0338898599,
-0.0291301236,
0.0574539229,
0.0263065677,
0.011372501,
-0.0157918464,
0.0116278771,
-0.0421918184,
0.0028029259,
-0.0333722495,
-0.0048335204,
0.0330034234,
-0.0666028932,
0.0120355804,
-0.0249580014,
-0.0038168177,
-0.0262351539,
0.0076170298,
0.0612213388,
-0.006945285,
-0.0321094766,
0.0159900971,
-0.0482379459,
-0.0330279842,
-0.0602270775,
-0.0707072616,
-0.0513456017,
0.0365212522,
-0.0346627571,
0.0187450163,
-0.0066069621,
0.0064483355,
0.03450289,
0.0327421278,
0.06633237,
0.0258584674,
0.0253361091,
0.0371755287,
0.0287619699,
-0.017588485,
0.0548882894,
0.0420432277,
-0.0062193391,
0.0086102104,
-0.025595868,
-0.0118003991,
0.0502879545,
-0.0298894793,
-0.0124089979,
-0.0067711887,
0.013171847,
0.0380220339,
0.0506758206,
-0.0062965266,
0.0615920499,
-0.0321299918,
-0.0202110466,
0.052653648,
0.0512041003,
-0.0021093618,
-0.0302607771,
0.1017145887,
0.0358707048,
0.0201718584,
0.0011532191,
0.0181289092,
-0.0051013101,
0.0236846879,
-0.0130153438,
-0.0294362996,
0.0129962424,
-0.0167297795,
-0.0153728137,
0.0145794926,
-0.014033298,
-0.0107701747,
-0.0002445613,
-0.0074232407,
0.0003473428,
-0.054511711,
0.0133727202,
0.0173612107,
-0.0783476233,
0.0318957753,
-0.0538822897,
0.0173468236,
0.1106671169,
0.0650618598,
-0.0516031794,
-0.0435430817,
-0.0290154237,
-0.0229597073,
0.0315249003,
0.0410125814,
-0.0408314243,
0.0081507089,
-0.0261700358,
0.022385858,
-0.0409459025,
-0.0063711028,
0.0688978732,
-0.0240977276,
-0.0045987354,
0.0004475739,
0.0282753985,
0.001666432,
0.0140358284,
-0.0581703633,
-0.0497741699,
-0.0216733795,
0.0180012826,
0.0393826216,
0.0320725851,
-0.0250833705,
-0.0147954114,
0.0184970759,
-0.0162486751,
0.0055533284,
0.0253504962,
-0.0770172551,
-0.0314570516,
0.0373212993,
-0.0342689641,
-0.0007657127,
0.0186653212,
0.0044934535,
-0.027932059,
-0.0064719375,
-0.05105922,
-0.0042335722,
-0.029454831,
0.0037861944,
-0.0019247048,
0.0156749636,
-0.0380862504,
0.0444019474,
-0.0051021869,
0.0297561698,
0.0526054502,
0.053607218,
-0.0033105151,
-0.0797381848,
-0.0090776719,
0.0108868815,
-0.0360102206,
0.0016518733,
0.0242887251,
-0.0082850242,
-0.0431566201,
-0.0564008504,
-0.060408961,
0.0032517975,
0.0005448348,
-0.0196765047,
0.0294927061,
0.013939091,
-0.0503804237,
0.0152243441,
-0.0523947366,
-0.0693070069,
0.0661346167,
-0.0184634887,
0.0199656468,
0.0223626159,
-0.0209590327,
-0.012271923,
0.0075074513,
-0.0091080852,
0.0312974826,
-0.0114680482,
0.028401643,
-0.0426934473,
0.0121860504,
-0.0148560498,
-0.0038882985,
-0.0324288569,
-0.036674764,
0.0456311889,
-0.0010943578,
0.0278090145,
0.0165729057,
0.0308353733,
-0.0039514001,
0.0267381147,
-0.0577017367,
-0.0364812687,
0.0258768629,
0.0150536736,
-0.0359111652,
-0.0379732922,
-0.0652699023,
0.0434792973,
0.0555211157,
0.0270647723,
0.0382650197,
-0.0843187496,
0.0073678275,
0.0158279277,
-0.056168437,
0.0030332971,
-0.0437099636,
-0.0474791452,
-0.0142044257,
-0.0116597647,
0.0043400368,
0.0638765469,
-0.0672977418,
-0.0530269593,
-0.0120335966,
0.0147356568,
-0.0192178488,
0.0782538503,
0.0032408054,
0.011993221,
0.0116049936,
-0.0531082116,
-0.0118444758,
-0.0230581611,
0.0359370746,
-0.0556880236,
0.0270463526,
-0.0575551353,
-0.0127394823,
0.0187317934,
0.0046971678,
-0.0382001661,
-0.0496654101,
-0.0096087921,
-0.012695807,
0.004684086,
-0.0015878521,
-0.0268009603,
0.0194637068,
0.008334293,
0.0187790338,
0.0117751407,
-0.0013602733,
-0.0313071534,
0.0071362657,
0.0547272451,
0.0344566666,
-0.0310148802,
-0.0124488287,
0.1197423413,
0.0012784995,
-0.0285782944,
-0.0188282449,
-0.0048259925,
-0.0106546758,
0.0265066754,
-0.0199999548,
0.0088718124,
0.0493152924,
0.0322576091,
-0.053308025,
-0.0156211471,
0.125423491,
0.0363783166,
-0.0168156773,
0.001073937,
-0.0099101458,
0.0655822083,
0.0161542799,
0.0068806573,
-0.092777282,
-0.0006466135,
0.0059015905,
0.0357919596,
-0.0338222496,
-0.0500828177,
-0.0081384378,
-0.1511697322,
0.0557306334,
-0.0114211552,
-0.0381437577,
0.0012137955,
-0.0193513911,
0.0059394594,
0.0043871757,
0.021160813,
0.0091645699,
-0.0171590447,
0.0009954469,
0.0126973372,
-0.0149837891,
-0.0475723147,
0.0426360369,
-0.0232566614,
0.1324427426,
0.0495081432,
0.0551978387,
0.013945193,
-0.0158106443,
-0.0600833967,
-0.0011966897,
0.0097344331,
0.008547524,
0.0504892953,
-0.0147758098,
-0.0362859331,
0.0111747961,
0.0311959945,
0.0045358324,
-0.0106479255,
0.0254023969,
0.0460303687,
-0.0344463438,
0.0002300937,
0.0057520759,
0.0328044072,
0.0599353313,
0.0816238597,
0.0083503444,
-0.0462418497,
0.0228829309,
-0.0005631183,
-0.0010564103,
-0.0538422838,
-0.0828418434,
-0.011475536,
0.0203135274,
0.02869213,
-0.0774403587,
-0.0474998914,
0.0210073311,
0.0478359982,
-0.0178656671,
-0.0064438479,
-0.0354339816,
0.0276425499,
-0.0032604332,
0.0045910906,
-0.0694466978,
0.0368112437,
-0.0767398253,
-0.0496454649,
0.0304025449,
-0.0703324303,
0.0019006091,
0.004725371,
-0.0349065848,
-0.0524945036,
0.0229896996,
0.0647792444,
0.0236796886,
0.0131731341,
-0.0112198759,
-0.0234467499,
0.0262280814,
0.0296450034,
-0.0653943121,
-0.0024931659,
-0.0104395114,
0.030297054,
-0.020570213,
-0.0047981315,
-0.0229685176,
0.0081611658,
-0.0266215838,
0.0523226894,
-0.0182350595,
-0.0725257993,
0.000902783,
0.0271562766,
0.0250082351,
-0.0351139158,
0.0148519725,
-0.0097409366,
0.0146295987,
-0.0614450127,
-0.0190200247,
-0.0271088108,
0.001671248,
0.0293057002,
-0.0100531289,
0.0237596557,
-0.0315776281,
-0.0432600267,
0.009723166,
-0.0373831838,
0.0139349913,
0.0406618193,
0.0055485177,
0.0126289586,
0.0214927252,
-0.0053421962,
0.0230006222,
-0.0203547552,
0.0479989909,
0.0327226184,
0.0460114069,
0.0151871005,
-0.0309224166,
0.0152987875,
0.0396539271,
-0.0388690718,
-0.0361609049,
0.0262307879,
0.0093078958,
0.0303607378,
-0.0100573581,
0.0257573668,
-0.0267983358,
0.0323112719,
-0.0119637726,
-0.011159285,
0.0446891151,
-0.0535102896,
0.0074846335,
0.0383490585,
-0.0088752415,
-0.0088994065,
0.039730642,
-0.0064679058,
0.0316739455,
-0.0005597397,
-0.0045200614,
-0.0565195233,
-0.0481519066,
-0.0076089106,
0.0184735302,
-0.05416511,
-0.0063102893,
-0.0844562128,
-0.0224195346,
-0.0086729536,
0.0541172102,
0.0016523657,
-0.0041684434,
0.0308724009,
0.0013819496,
0.0065945247,
0.0434578918,
-0.0424683467,
0.0241681151,
-0.0451105312,
0.0038574981,
-0.0201488901,
-5.102981138e-33,
-0.0704927817,
-0.0159852151,
0.0314366035,
0.0322513059,
-0.0498361215,
0.0236916747,
-0.0344268158,
0.0166679062,
0.0125865676,
-0.0015059105,
-0.0010621081,
-0.0326423682,
0.0068447609,
0.0277098492,
-0.0087532597,
-0.050669238,
0.04012537,
0.0203814134,
-0.0490786284,
0.038847778,
0.0299752466,
0.0015725007,
0.0057913349,
-0.0645868853,
0.0223165341,
-0.0201504827,
-0.0207793303,
0.0073282639,
0.0016381057,
0.0383378677,
0.0068920059,
0.0279419385,
-0.0037630864,
-0.0150472838,
0.0036213088,
0.0540024154,
-0.019630691,
-0.0205536783,
0.0482717007,
0.0005891768,
-0.0103264898,
-0.0249188002,
-0.0420044959,
-0.0163663849,
-0.0085141389,
0.00309094,
0.0325885974,
-0.0158130974,
0.0029857603,
0.0072172703,
-0.0616871938,
-0.0026359672,
-0.0435516909,
-0.0612373538,
-0.0127498806,
0.081962809,
0.0082168421,
-0.0083579943,
-0.04289129,
0.0357559994,
-0.0085311048,
0.0101753464,
0.0297967754,
0.0642744303,
0.0004707333,
0.0906159505,
0.017562354,
0.0390084721,
-0.0508040562,
0.0031714044,
0.009744145,
0.0223883651,
0.0305023044,
0.0487763062,
-0.0014978249,
0.001789851,
-0.0266321078,
0.0378826372,
0.0452679023,
0.0196519401,
0.0496379025,
-0.0039499733,
-0.023212919,
0.0230380055,
-0.05166867,
0.0390877314,
0.0159347001,
-0.0472034402,
0.0186486505,
-0.0155792041,
-0.0284188204,
-0.0194364004,
0.0373019576,
-0.0037342468,
0.0053892983,
0.0050575077,
-0.005985918,
0.0376682244,
-0.0356152952,
0.0097847125,
-0.0174810067,
-0.0037630899,
0.0609686412,
0.0098729087,
0.0230489373,
0.0271465182,
-0.0237084907,
0.0555754229,
-0.0481603257,
0.0033959807,
-0.0218249373,
0.0642030537,
-0.0507505536,
0.0123803625,
0.0047813491,
-0.034059979,
-0.0318448246,
0.0189876575,
-0.0006914457,
-0.060833782,
-0.0121040232,
0.0085535832,
-0.013490336,
-0.0294904895,
-0.0430880822,
0.0223105904,
-0.0391861722,
0.0385118052,
0.0028873812,
0.0087273363,
0.0165954828,
-0.037683446,
2.662e-7,
-0.0215639416,
0.006419763,
0.017618252,
0.0484397598,
0.0051787649,
0.022499349,
-0.0197737832,
0.0154134985,
0.0581188761,
-0.0437849574,
0.0327651463,
0.0171349049,
0.0287745949,
0.0316789821,
-0.1319206506,
0.0029652405,
-0.0734821111,
-0.0164819341,
-0.0318723544,
0.0112551833,
0.0652121678,
0.032580737,
0.0233464316,
-0.0233439002,
0.0165419132,
-0.0464131311,
0.025156565,
-0.054881677,
-0.0288572069,
0.0477735288,
0.0630755946,
-0.006799343,
-0.0075503141,
-0.0014892492,
0.0006474202,
0.0333044231,
-0.0172227006,
0.0274063051,
0.0188203733,
-0.0068115247,
-0.0254997611,
-0.018115025,
-0.0081780422,
-0.0472922176,
0.0498533137,
-0.0192081816,
-0.0244273189,
-0.0303659663,
-0.0499524921,
-0.0224915743,
0.001345671,
-0.0488755219,
-0.0501532368,
0.0320097506,
0.0045748632,
-0.0169397965,
0.0101409163,
-0.0513973422,
-0.0380230136,
-0.0172009077,
-0.0534090698,
-0.0438267291,
-0.0231589433,
-0.0170800127,
-0.0518520735,
-0.0460597724,
0.0375067405,
2.050960758e-34,
-0.0061010038,
0.0187225789,
0.0111728217,
-0.0199539512,
0.0547589287,
0.020703081,
0.0248746574,
0.0444785655,
0.0369902402,
-0.0571380667,
-0.0017944269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00606v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00606v2
|
LLMs Could Autonomously Learn Without External Supervision
| 2024-06-02T03:36:37 | 2024-06-06T22:48:35 |
Ke Ji, Junying Chen, Anningzhe Gao, Wenya Xie, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the quest for super-human performance, Large Language Models (LLMs) have
traditionally been tethered to human-annotated datasets and predefined training
objectives-a process that is both labor-intensive and inherently limited. This
paper presents a transformative approach: Autonomous Learning for LLMs, a
self-sufficient learning paradigm that frees models from the constraints of
human supervision. This method endows LLMs with the ability to self-educate
through direct interaction with text, akin to a human reading and comprehending
literature. Our approach eliminates the reliance on annotated data, fostering
an Autonomous Learning environment where the model independently identifies and
reinforces its knowledge gaps. Empirical results from our comprehensive
experiments, which utilized a diverse array of learning materials and were
evaluated against standard public quizzes, reveal that Autonomous Learning
outstrips the performance of both Pre-training and Supervised Fine-Tuning
(SFT), as well as retrieval-augmented methods. These findings underscore the
potential of Autonomous Learning to not only enhance the efficiency and
effectiveness of LLM training but also to pave the way for the development of
more advanced, self-reliant AI systems.
|
[
0.0399999581,
0.0100719556,
-0.0378626809,
0.0279786084,
-0.0247198809,
0.0177618135,
-0.0077543412,
-0.03424358,
0.0631268099,
-0.0606921948,
-0.0671141222,
0.0262875129,
-0.0512139536,
-0.0190623496,
0.0466617271,
-0.0399423204,
0.0535904802,
-0.0405593216,
0.0134096174,
-0.0005968816,
-0.0166641884,
0.0026491499,
-0.0265951473,
-0.0020608462,
-0.02201147,
0.0084293243,
-0.0122557273,
-0.0068698423,
-0.023849437,
-0.0319022574,
0.0313585773,
0.0575989857,
0.068703644,
0.0202671103,
0.000002094,
-0.0492812395,
0.0264598187,
-0.0307133961,
-0.0507638045,
0.0147543577,
0.0097837048,
0.0186451077,
0.0048670303,
0.0046573379,
-0.0612896346,
0.0099808266,
-0.0063357148,
0.0128754694,
0.0606901534,
0.0607714131,
0.009984714,
-0.0166301578,
0.0336049087,
-0.0055688471,
0.0118720913,
-0.0224417839,
0.0222068112,
0.0209283326,
-0.0071819774,
0.0134241879,
-0.0126048783,
0.05093427,
0.0141803613,
-0.0079405718,
0.0212203953,
0.0357945301,
-0.0279563777,
-0.0428305119,
-0.0360427946,
0.0787112191,
0.0088461414,
-0.0395946056,
-0.0095996419,
0.0016863723,
0.0071696253,
0.0052965563,
-0.0582083836,
0.0486801341,
0.0133276051,
0.0318665467,
0.0083683021,
-0.0275612883,
0.0300375223,
0.0282699596,
-0.0210687146,
0.0506067462,
-0.0195048507,
-0.0661379844,
0.0360616073,
0.0222385228,
-0.024312282,
0.0014673998,
-0.0011227817,
0.0527827293,
-0.0010560874,
0.0500934087,
-0.0255388394,
-0.0323717669,
0.0336784199,
-0.0271927193,
0.0257689729,
0.0347526558,
-0.0393057428,
0.0487039387,
-0.0271362029,
0.033709228,
0.0201248322,
0.0432844795,
-0.0340797454,
0.0379360504,
-0.0420572348,
-0.0258057117,
-0.0437681079,
0.0348935127,
-0.0321518779,
0.014618271,
0.0030515164,
0.03498362,
0.0230626781,
0.0185379963,
-0.0002792986,
0.0069424645,
-0.0467754826,
-0.0316020325,
-0.0364467464,
0.0115651311,
-0.0210216381,
0.0158553757,
-0.0083149821,
-0.0601735674,
-0.0063454499,
0.0175867472,
-0.0190368891,
-0.0083991475,
0.0384716168,
0.0865683332,
-0.0360632688,
-0.073858805,
-0.0814795867,
0.0013597409,
0.0005327819,
-0.0712223053,
-0.0042817667,
-0.0333214551,
0.0273818336,
-0.0070570568,
-0.0088109476,
-0.0487064533,
0.0255519729,
0.0230383594,
0.0102339452,
0.0734750256,
-0.0465914533,
0.024903845,
0.0668430999,
0.000965085,
0.0120860627,
0.0733844489,
0.03801075,
0.005145357,
0.0410722233,
0.0015978261,
0.0411803536,
0.0283345543,
0.0013956865,
0.0168811958,
-0.0166475419,
0.014882925,
-0.0058559855,
0.0497452356,
0.0401120633,
0.0420623422,
-0.002180991,
-0.0049337959,
0.0835440531,
0.0818142965,
-0.0264598392,
0.0208450295,
0.0488413088,
0.0525462516,
0.0392966829,
0.0217053853,
-0.0486139506,
0.0047463104,
-0.0100432038,
0.0071016266,
-0.0079974262,
-0.0212074593,
-0.0378161222,
-0.0765637532,
-0.0192068834,
-0.0218042079,
0.0000759482,
0.045514334,
0.0801785588,
0.0204823166,
-0.0267297439,
-0.006639618,
0.0598520376,
-0.032218162,
0.0271230098,
-0.0720132589,
0.0379607752,
0.0851209611,
0.0480278172,
-0.0537064262,
-0.0133861778,
0.0021113562,
0.0509178974,
0.0745954663,
0.0367371514,
-0.0246807504,
-0.0094073741,
-0.0495232753,
-0.0106275696,
-0.0086994786,
0.0133933984,
0.0173515119,
0.0015857669,
-0.0350080952,
-0.00820316,
-0.0362697355,
-0.075556837,
0.0732726306,
-0.0581219792,
-0.0829378963,
-0.0193800516,
0.0116588576,
-0.005723008,
0.03194144,
-0.014383194,
-0.0043110298,
0.0584412441,
-0.0103937322,
-0.0089404834,
-0.0176110007,
-0.0515478849,
0.0105443569,
0.0371781886,
-0.0151324719,
-0.0361100025,
0.0430286862,
0.0006928666,
-0.0380965583,
-0.0020153604,
-0.0277423635,
0.0129740871,
-0.0605871715,
0.0194249526,
0.0041882028,
-0.0284684394,
-0.0555588678,
0.0452815965,
0.0182665437,
-0.0144889345,
0.012879042,
0.0318378955,
0.0272931419,
-0.0491680503,
-0.0097278208,
-0.022550337,
-0.0018909367,
0.0391950458,
0.0120601589,
0.0186005533,
-0.0745112598,
-0.0074685216,
-0.0691928938,
0.0015120548,
-0.0236293767,
0.004351153,
0.008470118,
-0.0217673723,
-0.0366188027,
-0.035737671,
0.0013271463,
-0.0128215775,
-0.0113190562,
0.0033378114,
0.0222698767,
0.0042536738,
0.0224369559,
-0.0727291107,
-0.0061831307,
-0.008008494,
-0.0122910412,
0.0374492146,
0.0050747641,
-0.0461515896,
0.0261529125,
-0.0013122506,
0.043110881,
-0.0164886117,
-0.0670320839,
0.0314226821,
-0.0552680828,
0.038033627,
0.1059205011,
0.0240339004,
0.0285221376,
0.0623012856,
0.0014107577,
-0.0823018551,
0.046871841,
-0.0204247795,
-0.0312255062,
-0.0541081429,
0.0202920027,
-0.0262683704,
0.0496941991,
0.0187484212,
0.0133057879,
-0.0495333374,
0.002995851,
-0.0231368206,
-0.060633745,
-0.0605654269,
0.0155473398,
-0.0392415412,
0.0230275318,
-0.0286108907,
-0.0496000946,
0.0548422374,
-0.017539572,
-0.0043027746,
-0.0140768858,
-0.0210726336,
-0.0201141369,
0.0528706871,
-0.0099767074,
0.0113116335,
-0.0140018044,
-0.0078628808,
-0.0742489845,
0.0005536882,
0.0101177394,
-0.0437946543,
0.0339261778,
-0.0504299439,
0.0077938656,
0.0297506321,
-0.0383708775,
-0.0643357709,
-0.0276660435,
-0.0344425328,
-0.0166655444,
-0.0083464403,
0.0018991547,
-0.0141454823,
-0.0306850746,
0.0482637845,
0.0360408649,
-0.0045639165,
-0.0258756634,
-0.0305746514,
0.0095973769,
0.0263435096,
0.0080130212,
-0.0164534971,
-0.0486415848,
0.0600151606,
0.0358524621,
0.048132468,
-0.00761197,
0.0054012355,
0.0250992645,
0.0160358995,
-0.0421644077,
0.024086358,
0.0185528547,
0.0399286896,
-0.0668672919,
-0.0247793905,
0.1283821166,
0.0361839831,
-0.0327368267,
-0.0233982652,
-0.0281205978,
0.0050912746,
0.0490324646,
0.0418240316,
-0.047389593,
-0.0254137255,
-0.0018180747,
0.091453433,
0.0077386345,
-0.0163826793,
-0.0030366716,
-0.1025183424,
0.0315528698,
0.0253917985,
-0.0219029654,
0.0134553919,
-0.0452725403,
-0.0069951778,
-0.0244454443,
0.0192808751,
0.0267131403,
-0.0282796547,
-0.0135895154,
0.0259533767,
-0.022588782,
-0.045762755,
0.0198273137,
-0.0408508629,
0.0694943145,
0.0545886829,
0.0161489882,
-0.0026771242,
-0.02388159,
0.0294368118,
-0.0287854504,
0.0400920995,
-0.0306934975,
0.0662048459,
-0.045116514,
-0.0039450037,
-0.0230227821,
0.0460520573,
-0.0074582323,
0.0043773726,
0.0150607098,
0.0765160024,
-0.0060686409,
0.0081904968,
0.0114949048,
-0.0136270542,
0.0088280104,
0.0860448554,
0.0263618343,
-0.0617232583,
-0.019612411,
-0.0130950566,
0.0148659321,
-0.0474310368,
-0.0609760694,
0.0370374136,
-0.027597364,
0.0124355396,
-0.0545312427,
-0.0760992169,
0.0609300472,
0.0292103961,
0.0349679925,
0.0201482549,
0.0168398917,
-0.0025213365,
-0.0369460694,
0.0199550502,
-0.0786238834,
-0.0325770862,
-0.068189688,
-0.0688059181,
0.0445705615,
-0.0520915464,
0.0196468178,
-0.0041787461,
-0.0311279818,
-0.078540802,
0.0318992212,
0.0682415366,
0.0239963047,
0.0806450471,
0.0096893581,
-0.0670974776,
0.0530838929,
0.0534895025,
-0.0687071681,
0.01443638,
0.0143505912,
0.0095927501,
-0.0139194475,
0.0283164997,
-0.0318685919,
0.028889643,
0.0024380526,
0.036653582,
-0.0304517727,
-0.0287937447,
0.0635559782,
0.0150156608,
0.0500321798,
-0.0220991671,
0.0155010018,
-0.0630737618,
-0.0047065946,
-0.0187214483,
-0.0211879928,
-0.0290578287,
0.0105734244,
0.0149453301,
-0.0051888437,
0.0102903508,
-0.0037572812,
-0.0156924836,
0.0359908156,
-0.0116925268,
-0.0116991168,
-0.0099633103,
0.0261306334,
0.0016923806,
0.0125401113,
-0.0102452403,
0.0616972074,
0.0073777693,
0.0376723036,
0.0175839625,
0.0690590367,
-0.0039922418,
0.000365477,
-0.0011657807,
0.0054495414,
-0.0522129051,
-0.0468098931,
-0.0278412905,
0.0286731943,
0.0552450605,
-0.0015985392,
0.0348190404,
-0.0397204123,
-0.0088735521,
-0.0023809238,
-0.0103061004,
-0.0297111478,
0.0203194357,
0.0056311814,
0.0350001976,
-0.0232945755,
0.0343030021,
0.057087779,
0.0168637279,
0.0566376634,
-0.0174298007,
0.0276571121,
-0.0574670583,
-0.0293397997,
0.0087665431,
0.015230055,
-0.0200259257,
0.004978681,
-0.0046686949,
-0.0750532001,
-0.0312927403,
0.062701039,
-0.0210470594,
-0.0425188579,
0.0369664989,
0.0406976491,
-0.0267712325,
-0.0140122287,
-0.0347441062,
0.0189321581,
0.0147847235,
-0.0129403183,
-0.0077401707,
-6.724185478e-33,
-0.031917952,
-0.037002109,
0.0568819977,
0.0254210681,
-0.0084622111,
-0.028957136,
-0.0353889875,
0.0168528203,
0.0004304305,
-0.0013035564,
-0.0113201337,
0.0117174424,
0.0082698353,
0.0159810912,
0.0338840038,
0.0024888837,
0.0537160374,
-0.0562409163,
0.0153212231,
0.015217972,
0.0143615846,
0.0438752584,
-0.0032552967,
-0.0640642866,
0.0304978993,
-0.0393847711,
0.0036648959,
0.0452200733,
-0.0133209517,
0.04304583,
-0.020514328,
0.0273330603,
0.0197003204,
0.0177147556,
-0.022445932,
0.0279775206,
-0.1063630432,
-0.0352380946,
-0.0126563096,
-0.0000271097,
-0.0412599519,
-0.0216756314,
0.0637761578,
-0.0416578352,
-0.0288981274,
0.0258104689,
0.0457942486,
-0.0056221127,
-0.0195737239,
0.0041592927,
-0.0543689914,
0.0113227516,
-0.02566096,
-0.0361805595,
0.033410117,
0.02062607,
0.0028461295,
-0.0147805754,
-0.0503664166,
0.0404580273,
-0.0016916174,
0.0061133523,
0.0653234944,
0.0200550687,
0.0051607792,
0.0354158357,
0.0498646423,
0.0041163689,
-0.0067331176,
-0.0343483984,
0.0799408928,
0.0323204324,
0.0336096436,
0.0365899131,
-0.0151363853,
-0.010543583,
-0.042409867,
0.0327014662,
0.0123937288,
0.0275791548,
-0.0129492665,
0.0145348869,
-0.0611749738,
-0.0089447349,
-0.0391814597,
-0.0180093274,
-0.0157318637,
-0.0363243259,
0.0590400659,
0.0219931193,
-0.0161136519,
-0.0410139188,
0.0009741199,
-0.0310090482,
0.0137247043,
-0.0206187032,
-0.01932857,
0.0237196069,
-0.0158180073,
0.0054838704,
-0.0578652732,
-0.0463737696,
0.0004450486,
0.0255789086,
0.0095718382,
0.0135198906,
0.0250598546,
0.0500023104,
-0.0394826233,
-0.0092690112,
-0.0137936398,
-0.0027274338,
0.0415201597,
-0.0299886074,
0.0212538112,
0.0232060608,
-0.0115503035,
0.0642760023,
0.0125845792,
-0.0147990696,
-0.0455732755,
-0.0261442848,
-0.0221863165,
-0.0014247735,
-0.017075697,
0.0000935466,
-0.0466930456,
0.0181055069,
0.0194570646,
-0.0697923154,
0.0226346776,
0.0330454707,
2.777e-7,
0.0155811366,
0.0712525398,
0.0108490782,
-0.0115676569,
0.0013288725,
0.030738309,
-0.0430457704,
-0.0125766769,
0.0198198408,
-0.0149972709,
0.035473194,
0.0782641619,
0.042934265,
0.0073930877,
-0.103422083,
-0.0086558806,
-0.0436834469,
0.0317627303,
-0.0611441024,
-0.0083039673,
0.0380794741,
0.0311179273,
0.0138688656,
-0.0186800566,
-0.0309881512,
-0.0609035976,
0.0603054948,
-0.0351161622,
-0.016195368,
0.0162273217,
0.0208454058,
0.0910176858,
-0.0305265803,
0.0058281114,
-0.0243174676,
0.0258278642,
-0.0375784449,
0.0636095405,
-0.0019425974,
-0.0260146428,
0.0341700613,
0.0211726688,
0.0096686985,
-0.0178134497,
0.0615235493,
-0.0832878277,
-0.0132503556,
0.0119290203,
0.0023607025,
-0.0155511601,
-0.0155405151,
-0.0338766612,
-0.0233994015,
0.0142409243,
-0.0013004084,
-0.0207568482,
-0.0061039613,
-0.0895538703,
-0.0029645709,
0.0121759959,
-0.0419569016,
-0.0165290311,
-0.0531052388,
0.0120117133,
-0.0129377907,
-0.0493862592,
0.024579633,
2.105670607e-34,
0.013511424,
-0.0232590567,
0.0281359237,
0.0108615961,
0.0089677079,
0.021007102,
-0.0440782681,
0.0126364259,
0.0219279714,
-0.0779894739,
-0.0083933612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00605v1
|
LongSkywork: A Training Recipe for Efficiently Extending Context Length in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T03:34:41 | 2024-06-02T03:34:41 |
Liang Zhao, Tianwen Wei, Liang Zeng, Cheng Cheng, Liu Yang, Peng Cheng, Lijie Wang, Chenxia Li, Xuejie Wu, Bo Zhu, Yimeng Gan, Rui Hu, Shuicheng Yan, Han Fang, Yahui Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce LongSkywork, a long-context Large Language Model (LLM) capable
of processing up to 200,000 tokens. We provide a training recipe for
efficiently extending context length of LLMs. We identify that the critical
element in enhancing long-context processing capability is to incorporate a
long-context SFT stage following the standard SFT stage. A mere 200 iterations
can convert the standard SFT model into a long-context model. To reduce the
effort in collecting and annotating data for long-context language modeling, we
develop two novel methods for creating synthetic data. These methods are
applied during the continual pretraining phase as well as the Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT) phase, greatly enhancing the training efficiency of our
long-context LLMs. Our findings suggest that synthetic long-context SFT data
can surpass the performance of data curated by humans to some extent.
LongSkywork achieves outstanding performance on a variety of long-context
benchmarks. In the Needle test, a benchmark for long-context information
retrieval, our models achieved perfect accuracy across multiple context spans.
Moreover, in realistic application scenarios, LongSkywork-13B demonstrates
performance on par with Claude2.1, the leading long-context model, underscoring
the effectiveness of our proposed methods.
|
[
0.0318770111,
0.0363046005,
-0.0015778003,
0.0503264852,
-0.0166635234,
0.0142196277,
0.0435794182,
-0.0001599111,
-0.0363403447,
-0.0443179309,
-0.0154090244,
-0.0492817983,
-0.0200192593,
0.025917843,
0.0389571711,
-0.0214727502,
0.0411804989,
-0.0248326678,
-0.0245525502,
0.0069233542,
-0.0171131883,
0.0086003272,
0.0444984026,
0.0283364188,
-0.0293576196,
-0.005963508,
0.0045009945,
0.0023305744,
-0.0177236348,
-0.0489224978,
0.027540857,
0.0572586171,
0.0457151309,
0.0458196327,
0.0000019718,
-0.0587128513,
-0.0200698227,
0.0062142168,
-0.0427539051,
0.0227678083,
0.058377821,
-0.0143272113,
-0.0032449099,
0.0104117729,
-0.0153308082,
0.0090269633,
0.0043961471,
0.0307684522,
0.021508351,
0.0730464533,
-0.001646899,
-0.0670644268,
0.0198410768,
-0.0587804541,
0.024269646,
-0.046769619,
0.0306221917,
-0.0212215036,
0.0227273889,
0.0420926996,
-0.0292714369,
0.0270217136,
0.0456324145,
0.0040972997,
0.0291653089,
0.0506066047,
-0.0541636422,
0.0106100095,
0.0376997963,
0.0588635691,
-0.0165932328,
-0.0374770463,
0.0000111615,
0.0352525488,
-0.0103438636,
-0.0581112057,
-0.0390316583,
-0.0055688755,
0.0033591862,
0.0024230168,
0.0479006171,
-0.0196585841,
0.0449564159,
0.0126177259,
-0.0576512478,
0.0214557275,
0.0249408241,
-0.0317535885,
-0.01525365,
-0.0248149484,
-0.0326090567,
-0.0403288864,
0.0002297224,
0.0177947283,
-0.0453698747,
-0.0015669335,
-0.0272650402,
-0.0290129613,
0.0264909416,
-0.0235515423,
-0.0508630201,
0.0336450115,
-0.0369756296,
0.0698224232,
-0.059567906,
-0.0069589922,
-0.0325678289,
0.0057456149,
-0.0644620806,
-0.0368390083,
-0.0301395766,
0.0036225442,
-0.066645056,
-0.0123434244,
-0.0750423893,
-0.0270331502,
-0.0432001203,
0.0120426603,
0.015877232,
-0.0119689684,
0.0197366197,
0.0030477275,
-0.0359850936,
-0.0006710698,
-0.0019194781,
0.00791559,
-0.0543447658,
0.0211074222,
-0.0097583905,
-0.0270545688,
-0.0063500088,
0.0265842322,
0.019613117,
-0.0571993925,
0.0320306756,
0.0363587812,
0.0043124622,
-0.0401031896,
-0.0359562859,
-0.0178657342,
-0.0281641558,
-0.0528650843,
-0.0271119252,
-0.0800911784,
0.0170437023,
0.0096820667,
0.014315051,
0.0085194176,
-0.0201869067,
0.0035199265,
-0.0258174669,
0.1013724655,
-0.0128246406,
0.0112797534,
0.0106982701,
0.0076056635,
0.0419757254,
0.0750631541,
-0.0131654656,
0.0269647744,
0.0437796451,
-0.0015886597,
-0.0113478657,
0.0302111264,
0.0371280387,
0.0186113268,
-0.03228008,
0.0428178199,
0.0255082846,
0.04049493,
0.0306119099,
0.0272408426,
-0.0368045308,
-0.0259971693,
-0.0060888836,
0.0485583022,
0.0814058334,
0.0124408863,
0.067387633,
-0.021552749,
-0.0220692884,
-0.0415811352,
-0.0558671616,
0.0068800119,
-0.0126517182,
0.0322169699,
0.0265357196,
0.0048580151,
-0.0301040914,
0.0045482689,
-0.0117750037,
-0.0076470021,
-0.0028840383,
0.0047638379,
0.0457703657,
-0.0067843627,
-0.0122621711,
0.0447197072,
0.0382658541,
-0.029595552,
0.0292520653,
-0.0394245312,
0.0267184265,
0.1097933874,
0.0271676425,
-0.0522778705,
0.0123201599,
-0.014034858,
0.0355129391,
0.0409885272,
0.0140536455,
-0.0279182177,
0.0208017733,
-0.0381152257,
-0.0191292185,
-0.0073018814,
0.0123890005,
0.0028541104,
0.0507559627,
0.0296501033,
0.0456415266,
-0.0438626595,
0.0210059099,
0.0422223918,
-0.0683782697,
-0.0539062843,
-0.0293719228,
0.0161208194,
0.0125946561,
0.0237325709,
-0.0060191643,
0.023411816,
0.035356544,
-0.0470412374,
0.0103467228,
-0.0207820311,
-0.0780633017,
-0.0340431072,
0.0428858884,
0.0167862866,
0.0033208905,
-0.0150384847,
-0.0233026166,
-0.0392860994,
-0.0065179574,
0.0175521895,
0.0730064884,
-0.0451189838,
0.0198170431,
0.0058555417,
0.0261344016,
-0.0593527295,
0.0492014773,
0.0066402522,
0.0237603597,
0.0278243069,
0.0612605549,
0.0045963805,
-0.0508911945,
-0.029288467,
0.0241355337,
-0.002444657,
0.0033230304,
0.0095018959,
0.012451035,
-0.0674811527,
-0.0259441398,
-0.137174651,
-0.0008286004,
-0.0434700958,
-0.0069871601,
0.003750267,
0.0136368601,
-0.0276589524,
0.0000802229,
-0.0282510836,
-0.0202932023,
-0.0148756718,
0.0425329395,
0.0007604695,
0.0177004077,
-0.0437901802,
-0.0534648895,
-0.0479682535,
0.0001143881,
0.0488814414,
-0.0261642803,
-0.0116158491,
-0.0568316318,
0.0242476519,
0.0077989642,
0.0135920523,
-0.0269262679,
-0.0261482149,
-0.0069281273,
-0.0584616177,
0.0448637567,
0.0339808688,
0.0232378952,
0.0010857037,
0.0007190358,
-0.0021091383,
-0.033316005,
0.0157405529,
-0.0238218121,
-0.0217377208,
-0.0496392436,
0.0269196797,
-0.0136709195,
0.0341856852,
-0.028525319,
-0.0090039652,
-0.0417171493,
0.0131682651,
0.0015769148,
0.0038338876,
-0.0443912372,
0.0122849252,
-0.0193888452,
0.0262014568,
-0.0390260033,
-0.0219661016,
0.0425143242,
-0.0345007554,
0.0107529704,
-0.0166014228,
-0.0132156769,
-0.0536958463,
0.0869132206,
-0.0090095559,
0.001303105,
-0.05230508,
-0.0164989606,
-0.0228071287,
0.0024955522,
-0.0264038462,
-0.0199755933,
0.0539954677,
0.0056348527,
0.0418903939,
-0.0013198345,
-0.0410297699,
-0.0345817357,
-0.04084903,
-0.0233303607,
0.0217153858,
0.0409222022,
0.0013962885,
0.0106656281,
0.0013449428,
0.002497569,
0.0918024778,
0.005697669,
0.0088236183,
-0.0103143686,
0.0160530768,
0.0386599936,
-0.0165894739,
0.0028628712,
-0.0197880175,
0.0310373455,
0.0185959395,
0.0514741167,
-0.0035839775,
-0.0288903564,
-0.0146742873,
0.0020564673,
-0.0242459532,
-0.0245788079,
-0.0000053976,
0.0387551486,
-0.0713639483,
-0.0277524348,
0.121952042,
0.0062400936,
-0.0637306273,
0.0015946641,
-0.0143869249,
0.0152610894,
0.0391614661,
0.0078193685,
-0.1013961807,
-0.0387080982,
0.0161757655,
0.0089597953,
0.024265524,
-0.0273204204,
0.0167918373,
-0.1102970093,
0.0195321627,
0.0108553227,
-0.0862037838,
-0.0206974149,
-0.0477905832,
-0.0052884249,
-0.0027705536,
0.0423739217,
0.0581475869,
-0.0205644034,
-0.0106935157,
-0.0006654829,
0.0308122858,
-0.0645022541,
0.0502869971,
-0.0374276601,
0.0558782034,
0.0195423104,
0.0028760834,
0.019660607,
0.0083535826,
0.0798137635,
-0.0381776318,
0.0203398131,
-0.0183937103,
0.0386519469,
-0.0278910827,
-0.0177273732,
0.022313552,
0.0391492322,
-0.0283201095,
-0.0234362129,
0.002944388,
0.0605896041,
0.0090272799,
0.0245165285,
-0.0169983245,
-0.050111305,
0.0049290485,
0.0778494626,
0.0342126153,
-0.0199203286,
-0.0206794012,
-0.0098859156,
-0.0370096155,
-0.0342068188,
0.0034521797,
-0.0030801625,
-0.0177450497,
0.0148438774,
-0.0485837273,
-0.0523780063,
0.0364803784,
0.058929801,
-0.0369567126,
0.0633609071,
-0.054867819,
-0.0082457215,
-0.088121064,
0.0608317368,
-0.0718081892,
0.036256332,
-0.0630565733,
0.0280270725,
0.0240545459,
-0.0173875913,
-0.0086557874,
0.0221964549,
-0.0717150718,
-0.0691236705,
0.0211430453,
0.0032492373,
0.0199332871,
0.0612616912,
-0.0140086105,
-0.0514697209,
0.0741386041,
0.0324557424,
-0.0475685224,
0.0088956235,
0.0006447698,
0.0255620778,
0.0032897373,
0.0435394719,
-0.0485567786,
0.0250216033,
0.032278128,
0.051764641,
-0.0022037714,
0.0053271428,
0.0011776878,
0.0116265053,
0.0436863191,
-0.0169116594,
0.0006170169,
-0.0302653909,
0.0272765532,
-0.0429562591,
-0.0074474434,
0.0096017029,
0.0066595837,
0.0314087793,
-0.0213938486,
0.003060271,
0.0146312378,
0.0076172091,
0.0359500907,
-0.0292353425,
0.0128698712,
-0.0255718138,
0.0201432686,
0.0556367785,
0.0107086934,
-0.0249408316,
-0.0043340554,
0.0008732076,
0.037848562,
-0.0694929883,
0.0084579596,
0.0205764398,
-0.0056953612,
-0.0658114776,
0.0291208755,
-0.0661444962,
0.0079817707,
-0.0292753298,
0.0237589628,
0.0635992065,
-0.0465370566,
0.021660164,
-0.007275417,
-0.0329880677,
-0.0260492899,
0.0201205127,
-0.0009007207,
-0.0084151803,
0.0033554349,
0.0456755497,
-0.0340840109,
0.0095156459,
0.069780536,
0.0253931358,
0.0424841717,
0.0104960101,
0.0071488665,
-0.0349993072,
0.0070406417,
-0.0210816283,
0.0391422436,
-0.0316061676,
0.0076575354,
-0.0228510834,
-0.0848457739,
0.0119059533,
-0.0149739701,
-0.0321216285,
0.0029779745,
0.0414674729,
0.0713491812,
0.0070755873,
-0.0029932933,
-0.0100937122,
0.0201163795,
0.0468941219,
-0.0289688837,
-0.0002723473,
-6.578863519e-33,
-0.0010683524,
-0.0072037275,
0.0419392996,
-0.0437724777,
-0.0603626184,
0.020349104,
-0.0169885494,
-0.0190869756,
-0.0122607118,
-0.0047357273,
-0.0436473861,
0.0178421065,
0.0140200276,
0.0333462805,
-0.0103788599,
-0.0122871129,
0.056945283,
0.0242475905,
0.0181033295,
0.0236720499,
0.06005859,
0.0472054705,
0.0286702681,
-0.0445939079,
-0.0032555826,
0.0149815064,
0.0283088703,
0.0440845862,
0.0055517936,
0.074840717,
-0.0223370194,
0.0312527455,
0.0497565642,
-0.0539199933,
0.0008213228,
0.0304859933,
-0.1015538424,
0.0060719643,
0.0147365406,
-0.0273696613,
-0.017687073,
-0.0547034815,
0.0622249171,
-0.0062329089,
-0.0086396253,
0.0041123494,
0.013210604,
-0.058234103,
-0.044666931,
-0.0321103372,
-0.0692369267,
0.0288413092,
0.031712357,
0.0104307495,
0.0298823304,
-0.024855949,
0.0127772167,
0.0517074466,
-0.053092923,
-0.0090462929,
-0.0457524844,
0.0594487451,
0.0371659249,
0.0454126112,
0.0439019389,
0.0392277017,
0.0237757098,
0.0176188983,
-0.02288533,
-0.0427497178,
0.0455473214,
0.0388760492,
0.0247068144,
0.0637457371,
0.0459621996,
-0.0659399554,
-0.0757254139,
-0.0139665641,
-0.0128502781,
0.0265164319,
0.0197151545,
0.0250018779,
-0.0124180121,
-0.024631016,
-0.0662949756,
-0.0094761914,
-0.0381259769,
0.0126897199,
0.0431090817,
0.0556205735,
-0.0058457125,
-0.0062729563,
0.0435405187,
-0.0192009546,
-0.0083892085,
0.0346101262,
0.0093307914,
-0.0027827001,
0.0016583701,
0.0273377337,
-0.033853326,
-0.0289189704,
0.0199779328,
0.00429569,
-0.0035895857,
-0.0265755542,
0.0555802733,
-0.0072161853,
-0.0826768205,
-0.0026822588,
-0.0338759981,
0.0143036339,
-0.0133158099,
-0.0067152577,
0.0345840454,
0.0279685259,
0.0206866618,
0.0829861313,
0.0426801443,
0.0123430965,
-0.0114666549,
-0.0411079265,
0.011708389,
0.0206670985,
-0.0157875493,
0.022410892,
-0.0348462947,
0.0315156989,
0.0601139329,
-0.0509272553,
-0.0106873149,
0.016614886,
2.621e-7,
0.032055866,
0.0354847945,
0.0424711332,
-0.0215785746,
0.0378415063,
-0.0034868382,
0.0149534568,
0.0190279372,
-0.0117301801,
-0.0109596299,
-0.0108283218,
0.0087934462,
0.041254282,
0.0035158505,
-0.0812229887,
0.0200023297,
-0.0464185476,
0.0052009691,
-0.0604532175,
0.005894653,
0.0218805,
0.1391492784,
-0.0048897769,
-0.0080789663,
0.0088885156,
-0.0596819185,
0.0511007868,
-0.0381301567,
-0.0140049187,
0.0039771921,
-0.0235033222,
0.0420360863,
0.030577885,
-0.0244465917,
0.0024056449,
0.0432259925,
-0.0005120086,
0.0668785572,
-0.003394292,
-0.0101890545,
0.0155488923,
-0.0403009728,
-0.02684756,
-0.0537330583,
0.0685884953,
-0.0699266568,
0.0190235637,
-0.0415798426,
-0.0184910987,
-0.0001092036,
0.0088792229,
-0.0097784223,
-0.0007732681,
0.0281178243,
0.0217968319,
0.0017271389,
-0.0026487808,
-0.1234605983,
-0.0199842807,
0.0077599487,
-0.0546520576,
-0.029945422,
-0.0238524377,
-0.0140449591,
0.0466265008,
-0.0329661407,
0.0243344456,
2.639401292e-34,
0.0650891289,
0.0033674235,
0.0089394702,
-0.0220335443,
0.0347278193,
-0.0279701054,
-0.0054441048,
0.0218453128,
0.0276802387,
-0.0932103023,
-0.0301264729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00562v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00562v1
|
SPAGHETTI: Open-Domain Question Answering from Heterogeneous Data Sources with Retrieval and Semantic Parsing
| 2024-06-01T21:54:09 | 2024-06-01T21:54:09 |
Heidi C. Zhang, Sina J. Semnani, Farhad Ghassemi, Jialiang Xu, Shicheng Liu, Monica S. Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce SPAGHETTI: Semantic Parsing Augmented Generation for Hybrid
English information from Text Tables and Infoboxes, a hybrid question-answering
(QA) pipeline that utilizes information from heterogeneous knowledge sources,
including knowledge base, text, tables, and infoboxes. Our LLM-augmented
approach achieves state-of-the-art performance on the Compmix dataset, the most
comprehensive heterogeneous open-domain QA dataset, with 56.5% exact match (EM)
rate. More importantly, manual analysis on a sample of the dataset suggests
that SPAGHETTI is more than 90% accurate, indicating that EM is no longer
suitable for assessing the capabilities of QA systems today.
|
[
0.0188457593,
0.0010958327,
-0.0060925405,
0.0648789406,
-0.0104739945,
0.0108072134,
-0.0353623889,
0.0040811468,
-0.0024215165,
-0.0545467697,
-0.044189956,
0.021431312,
-0.0429429933,
0.0210155696,
0.0244281869,
0.0235294607,
0.0332929082,
0.0350096226,
-0.035021726,
0.0084226942,
0.0317455381,
0.0175180249,
-0.0061561326,
0.0333444662,
-0.0097103547,
-0.0190526582,
-0.0130502777,
-0.0074493806,
0.0074899998,
0.0041272533,
0.0273987148,
0.0090598213,
0.0300345737,
-0.0030759957,
0.0000018477,
-0.0277400222,
-0.0318670012,
0.009282806,
-0.0304700546,
-0.0429766625,
-0.0605711266,
0.0114569515,
0.0373889059,
0.0164042357,
-0.0725558549,
0.0109531013,
0.0009587276,
0.0078571998,
0.0911658779,
0.0625417307,
0.0056042317,
0.0021844006,
0.0243441034,
0.0235188808,
0.0835821107,
-0.0296171345,
-0.0077492325,
0.0123066269,
0.056414213,
-0.0177088603,
0.0197482407,
0.0457638726,
0.0017091499,
0.0135683035,
-0.0288825501,
0.0191710964,
-0.0293883737,
0.0331812166,
0.0020733017,
0.1331285536,
0.0447953381,
-0.0046955938,
-0.0046984539,
0.0020720735,
-0.0058887247,
0.0032256912,
-0.0571686588,
0.0117404303,
-0.0342726335,
-0.0164796375,
0.0096277334,
-0.0102269277,
-0.0131018367,
-0.0023471201,
-0.014233876,
0.1044690162,
-0.0073653348,
-0.033975061,
-0.0172981396,
0.0057598208,
-0.0119283544,
-0.0306215882,
0.0044842497,
0.0606747493,
-0.0056750365,
0.0402156934,
-0.0407785513,
-0.0634667426,
0.0549705103,
-0.0319770575,
-0.0143341357,
0.07554432,
-0.0179732256,
0.0423873365,
-0.0197121799,
0.0205210075,
-0.0283329803,
0.0198259018,
-0.0529923923,
-0.0583722964,
-0.0744753033,
-0.0237316191,
-0.0041575423,
0.0550140962,
-0.0702832565,
-0.0041013714,
0.0108151259,
0.022728784,
-0.0210997071,
0.0250392072,
0.0137862535,
0.0545842573,
-0.0074029244,
0.007496079,
-0.085108012,
0.0314100794,
-0.0681889728,
0.0172879305,
0.006154377,
-0.0954741389,
-0.0229255483,
0.0023685638,
0.0053181704,
-0.0303556453,
0.0203224663,
0.0604695491,
-0.0298196562,
0.0040058503,
-0.0418836139,
-0.0825952366,
0.0019062774,
-0.0280744173,
0.0077015492,
-0.0600255691,
0.0688643306,
0.0185198896,
-0.0267871786,
-0.0276805703,
0.0177501738,
0.0666150451,
-0.0295236614,
0.0203516316,
-0.0590825714,
-0.0158800129,
0.0139588108,
-0.0002951425,
-0.0000848388,
0.0781176984,
0.0207237098,
-0.0216359571,
0.0233200975,
0.0378336236,
-0.0168735217,
0.0135599608,
0.0450095385,
0.0148940729,
0.0154749881,
0.0902249068,
0.0125615327,
0.0306450687,
0.0204603542,
0.0288338326,
-0.0069460478,
-0.0045169373,
-0.0131218219,
0.0268082432,
0.0157376658,
0.0207786653,
0.0510241725,
0.0279398821,
0.0295008402,
-0.011225272,
-0.0062825689,
0.0377053209,
-0.0087487269,
0.0265662391,
0.0232846569,
0.0478134491,
-0.0376953036,
-0.0214587525,
0.0033134371,
0.0326646678,
-0.0405088589,
0.0383073688,
0.0063121459,
0.0193798486,
-0.0256456565,
0.0801156312,
0.003936091,
-0.0345327146,
0.0007261683,
-0.0268404596,
0.0571597479,
0.0805047899,
0.0348242372,
-0.0618087947,
-0.0338020436,
-0.0099741472,
0.0176487174,
0.02093729,
0.0186045002,
-0.0117518855,
-0.0013980352,
-0.0179246813,
-0.011744149,
-0.0096501773,
-0.0029350477,
-0.0040330733,
0.0066833217,
0.0055288589,
0.0076484187,
-0.0289881025,
0.0180336591,
0.0288543962,
0.0085102664,
-0.0181273222,
0.0103840316,
0.0009539533,
-0.0142808221,
0.0443079025,
0.0073137702,
0.0396944545,
0.0232351739,
-0.0339306146,
-0.0483369716,
-0.0165013913,
0.013037472,
-0.0502193309,
0.0618163608,
-0.026339341,
-0.0255763531,
-0.0231256858,
-0.0693311244,
-0.0651778132,
0.0308461301,
-0.0311731063,
0.0122347148,
-0.034364149,
-0.0303971209,
0.0382613428,
0.0173234008,
-0.056372121,
0.0697420016,
-0.0093920948,
0.0376208723,
0.0100592086,
-0.012414352,
0.0572105348,
-0.0469711721,
0.0090588415,
-0.041169174,
-0.0317786075,
0.0196119323,
-0.0266620964,
-0.0008998575,
-0.086889036,
-0.0039949813,
-0.0786733478,
0.0562881045,
-0.00335502,
0.0409592502,
0.0538023077,
0.0149455685,
-0.0015780265,
-0.007826996,
-0.063173376,
0.0191331692,
0.0495983399,
-0.0076005589,
0.045946423,
0.0393554121,
0.0164375864,
-0.0436002798,
0.0048528491,
-0.0266251899,
0.0397728346,
-0.0045370571,
-0.0129299928,
-0.0061832611,
-0.0195526294,
-0.0709785745,
0.0433531031,
0.0097596953,
0.0097044362,
-0.0038250992,
-0.0178943481,
-0.0179756917,
0.0125760511,
-0.0116289053,
-0.0642539933,
0.023063371,
-0.0138102621,
-0.0750636011,
0.0435476601,
0.0143961394,
-0.0146587538,
-0.0046751006,
-0.0379207693,
0.0318592079,
-0.0108560761,
0.0127853993,
-0.0048973244,
-0.0138119301,
0.0412912145,
0.036184486,
-0.0048190397,
-0.077832453,
0.0277053732,
-0.0050623934,
0.0531949736,
-0.019257741,
0.0194909666,
0.0422555432,
-0.0323862284,
0.0289324373,
-0.0326484479,
-0.0083047953,
-0.0804043412,
0.043386858,
-0.0483554453,
0.0133360168,
-0.0578528121,
0.0047858371,
-0.0302711725,
-0.0094380639,
0.0092242118,
-0.0589019284,
0.0815594867,
-0.0256009251,
0.0433846377,
-0.0124497795,
-0.0261921473,
-0.0333360918,
-0.0391061194,
-0.0420311093,
-0.0010887339,
0.0135835148,
0.0126580885,
0.0086090649,
-0.0425889157,
0.0158046037,
-0.0095027396,
-0.0260380916,
-0.0064369133,
-0.0303319022,
0.0459520556,
0.0639845803,
0.0566082858,
-0.0062852455,
0.0233880784,
0.0205754042,
0.054383941,
0.0168918613,
-0.0298328865,
-0.0115285823,
0.0216105618,
0.0198468473,
-0.0352425911,
-0.0103352573,
-0.0008837437,
0.0021149316,
-0.0538337901,
-0.0263074357,
0.0857095793,
0.0595003031,
0.003665325,
-0.0207513738,
-0.0268197898,
0.0203541704,
0.0341643952,
0.0808235854,
-0.155929178,
-0.0628086403,
-0.0267158486,
0.0373510942,
-0.0042846897,
-0.0446477085,
-0.0199145358,
-0.1034661159,
-0.008097236,
-0.0405297279,
-0.0601902418,
-0.0431648567,
-0.0056477576,
0.0009475721,
0.0051865075,
0.0053019864,
0.0345202237,
-0.0248044264,
0.0170683656,
-0.001438533,
0.0061293151,
-0.0088918796,
0.0490541346,
-0.0308860224,
0.0106436359,
0.0342422426,
0.0066390494,
-0.0000349476,
-0.0509798862,
0.0262172166,
-0.0293403398,
0.0029572905,
-0.0152678145,
0.0613077879,
-0.0162195284,
0.0047204522,
-0.0176317692,
0.0073951287,
-0.0424810201,
0.0194163006,
0.0400796607,
0.0844751745,
-0.0368834771,
0.050013762,
-0.0144796334,
0.0106886784,
-0.0029565857,
0.0841626525,
0.0127464226,
0.0122215915,
-0.0545799285,
-0.0309100822,
-0.0514653511,
-0.0594013296,
0.0170213077,
0.0504628532,
-0.0220823474,
-0.0104743848,
-0.0765869915,
0.0064201653,
0.0822855607,
0.0234894939,
-0.0020091699,
0.0054719467,
-0.031905286,
-0.0038077405,
-0.0417063609,
0.0303520467,
-0.0365281552,
0.0299888607,
-0.0264240373,
0.0003438295,
0.0220095422,
-0.0413740277,
-0.0367324986,
0.0235560276,
-0.0416381583,
-0.0290282425,
-0.0317457393,
0.0142712267,
0.0216492619,
0.0228458568,
0.0111427614,
-0.0160314087,
-0.00180669,
0.043945469,
-0.0692144409,
-0.0256456621,
-0.0220022071,
0.0112663861,
0.0051062917,
0.0291073788,
-0.085871309,
-0.0349955969,
-0.0365593284,
0.0540498868,
-0.0157247987,
-0.0157104228,
0.0603050292,
0.0141571313,
-0.0379440226,
0.0363746732,
-0.0031805069,
-0.0118296677,
0.0343353897,
-0.0034301041,
-0.043282833,
-0.0290126074,
0.004812032,
-0.0219116639,
-0.0770061612,
0.0271545406,
-0.000072481,
-0.0417406745,
0.080055654,
-0.0328983851,
-0.0315437764,
0.0182361919,
0.0095800171,
-0.0135500673,
-0.0247778613,
-0.0315397419,
0.0194760319,
-0.0017005268,
0.0550749823,
-0.0061589959,
0.0313824117,
0.0002608908,
0.0007076157,
-0.0238005631,
0.0176912602,
-0.0847679377,
-0.0545366593,
-0.0111573692,
-0.0048737847,
0.0451321602,
0.0256099328,
0.0306074601,
0.0149275679,
-0.0281399935,
0.0385062024,
-0.0029928838,
0.0088054743,
-0.0100609921,
0.0811356381,
0.0035730905,
-0.0134597607,
-0.0517155863,
0.0775084645,
-0.0327279828,
0.0225241967,
-0.0126391714,
-0.0208858587,
-0.0479829386,
-0.0296006557,
-0.010247088,
0.0539874509,
-0.0111114103,
-0.0445448421,
-0.0503145754,
-0.0541853756,
-0.0178695079,
0.0364035405,
-0.0384182371,
0.0155405849,
0.0640351027,
0.0420621224,
0.0796691403,
-0.0371992067,
-0.0259795189,
0.0289622303,
-0.0366221219,
-0.0169841591,
-0.010635308,
-6.352903383e-33,
-0.0434345119,
-0.0024608558,
0.0608430728,
-0.007590197,
-0.0141178323,
0.0040445211,
-0.0181028731,
-0.0129866414,
-0.0428818204,
-0.0176377334,
-0.0129285939,
0.0162485763,
0.0025088238,
0.0233942438,
-0.012528074,
-0.0807567984,
-0.0279819369,
-0.0095033199,
0.0153907146,
-0.0043719276,
0.0766320303,
0.0198780317,
0.0039645084,
-0.0079501718,
0.0361595564,
-0.0069852541,
-0.00368228,
0.0282014273,
-0.0065481514,
0.0467404313,
-0.0201931167,
0.0459902324,
0.034444727,
-0.0108804237,
-0.0040677162,
0.0303644054,
-0.0797448978,
-0.0255783871,
0.0175296143,
-0.0303069726,
-0.0245651416,
-0.0117437523,
0.0351911113,
0.0118126823,
0.0340379402,
0.0036705902,
0.0410911962,
-0.0227071028,
0.0284411032,
-0.050211478,
-0.0106261866,
0.012477994,
-0.019523425,
0.0081827939,
-0.0322445109,
0.0581043437,
0.0255520642,
0.0140656102,
-0.0478157699,
0.0193269756,
-0.0052153631,
0.0138579961,
0.0647304878,
-0.0100355344,
0.0053920448,
0.020303173,
-0.0055053402,
-0.0276450794,
-0.0411934145,
0.0238891579,
-0.0326553732,
0.0316244029,
0.0561158136,
0.0471323505,
0.0285062697,
0.0218549371,
-0.0580588505,
0.0740324408,
0.0316958278,
0.0195855498,
-0.0580139309,
-0.0305852257,
-0.0037116492,
0.0055820039,
-0.0341955386,
0.0782840103,
-0.0397205688,
-0.0130338054,
0.0371727496,
-0.0378603823,
0.0082793329,
-0.0155142276,
-0.0061667995,
-0.0210664012,
0.0133894309,
0.0237136465,
-0.0297922213,
-0.007220808,
0.0196602996,
0.0246280618,
-0.0199737791,
-0.0214475878,
0.0246914364,
-0.0227009058,
0.0077572628,
0.0268034302,
0.0012681206,
-0.0178977922,
-0.0620408952,
0.0169067848,
-0.0490783341,
0.0369069129,
-0.0364899039,
-0.0247818381,
-0.0221421793,
0.0314489938,
-0.0071697566,
0.034397494,
0.00808468,
0.020623548,
0.0057077846,
-0.0381384268,
0.0084632039,
0.0176953431,
-0.0144392364,
0.0469377525,
-0.0233504474,
0.0268298909,
-0.0056262813,
-0.0646301135,
0.0197089911,
0.0644901991,
2.575e-7,
0.1017592102,
-0.045698382,
0.0129954321,
0.0430092178,
-0.0154268136,
0.0049857753,
-0.0018327247,
0.0352285653,
-0.0000592529,
-0.0172276758,
-0.0066149253,
0.0093390178,
0.0130338371,
0.0440707691,
-0.0702658445,
-0.0499988422,
-0.0260751881,
-0.0416099466,
-0.0746062025,
-0.0087194983,
0.0831232518,
0.04440476,
-0.0249460302,
-0.0188085847,
-0.0219635461,
-0.0231619813,
0.044425901,
0.0084110331,
0.0023877819,
0.0415025242,
0.0426258966,
0.0059904936,
0.0173189696,
0.0529606342,
-0.019941505,
0.042360872,
0.0041501685,
0.0206393693,
0.0267913099,
-0.05417924,
-0.0170975029,
-0.0891370997,
0.0538191386,
-0.0466759764,
0.0990042463,
-0.0247717518,
0.0109201865,
0.0512296669,
-0.0453101993,
0.0093034329,
-0.0209515914,
-0.024120545,
-0.010395606,
0.0237827878,
0.0220154375,
-0.0219911691,
0.0104580559,
-0.0432017855,
-0.0158384591,
0.0128402663,
-0.0569710471,
-0.0284741204,
-0.005542329,
0.0201221146,
0.0040651411,
-0.0438844487,
-0.0152044687,
2.307512171e-34,
-0.0034292482,
0.0062673758,
0.0285888184,
0.0350787118,
0.0453588292,
0.0061048046,
0.0054554259,
-0.0054750792,
0.0015549876,
-0.0830389336,
0.0050991173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00554v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00554v1
|
Guiding and Diversifying LLM-Based Story Generation via Answer Set Programming
| 2024-06-01T21:14:25 | 2024-06-01T21:14:25 |
Phoebe J. Wang, Max Kreminski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs) are capable of generating
stories in response to open-ended user requests, but the resulting stories tend
to be limited in their diversity. Older, symbolic approaches to story
generation (such as planning) can generate substantially more diverse plot
outlines, but are limited to producing stories that recombine a fixed set of
hand-engineered character action templates. Can we combine the strengths of
these approaches while mitigating their weaknesses? We propose to do so by
using a higher-level and more abstract symbolic specification of high-level
story structure -- implemented via answer set programming (ASP) -- to guide and
diversify LLM-based story generation. Via semantic similarity analysis, we
demonstrate that our approach produces more diverse stories than an unguided
LLM, and via code excerpts, we demonstrate the improved compactness and
flexibility of ASP-based outline generation over full-fledged narrative
planning.
|
[
-0.0107875904,
0.0404196419,
-0.0315899476,
0.0343977474,
-0.03101019,
-0.0073241093,
-0.0196772274,
-0.0089082764,
0.0037885236,
0.0145686949,
0.0179103035,
-0.0089236144,
-0.0152709484,
0.0811822489,
-0.0273449253,
-0.0305189081,
0.0126986224,
-0.050693281,
0.0147663364,
-0.0021370337,
-0.0114714615,
0.0432319231,
0.0013028566,
0.0410541259,
0.0105277831,
-0.0310704987,
-0.0445725396,
0.0262772683,
0.0211956818,
-0.0415042751,
-0.0334774181,
-0.0263301805,
0.0321778692,
-0.0327350609,
0.000002115,
-0.085461095,
-0.0197478849,
-0.0073461649,
0.0181335881,
0.0071781832,
-0.016636014,
0.0751231462,
0.0217429679,
-0.0141144944,
-0.0021743407,
0.0231711566,
0.0490005277,
0.0401844904,
0.068604514,
0.0332421139,
-0.0019788877,
-0.0602479316,
-0.0170017648,
0.0337976031,
0.0524161533,
0.0066903615,
-0.034263216,
0.0058794986,
0.1121099293,
-0.0279597435,
-0.0015328758,
-0.0000503139,
0.0197779778,
0.0069466461,
-0.0147418771,
0.0568118095,
0.0440343544,
0.0165284835,
-0.0115681766,
0.0429890081,
-0.0174349807,
-0.0247517638,
0.0108001363,
-0.0507436953,
0.0051557962,
0.0668412894,
-0.0406925566,
0.0808311328,
-0.0313658863,
0.0314734727,
0.0491759703,
-0.0047685117,
0.0090940967,
-0.0268204398,
0.0004232932,
0.0338173024,
0.0211910885,
0.0050728349,
-0.0703824684,
-0.0230425876,
0.0020322062,
-0.0775353685,
-0.0172277708,
0.0762898996,
-0.0142383473,
0.0224996991,
-0.0420472026,
0.0644332021,
0.0084055644,
-0.0085202912,
0.0970889628,
0.0349664763,
0.0044601057,
0.0214670952,
0.0150548229,
0.0401278175,
0.0118619567,
-0.0372126773,
-0.0246597249,
0.07355728,
-0.0174383651,
-0.0091139311,
-0.0548343323,
0.0623706505,
-0.0727548748,
0.0082343295,
0.0404799916,
0.0487595946,
0.0190831609,
0.0188102443,
-0.0272526946,
0.0059496532,
-0.0155449267,
0.0149916243,
-0.0556231067,
0.0011367591,
-0.0665351376,
-0.0221415404,
0.0186208393,
-0.0174109768,
0.000208191,
-0.0337935425,
-0.0047422815,
0.0139660183,
0.0454116575,
0.105309099,
-0.006838616,
0.0388635099,
-0.0233014617,
-0.0844358504,
0.0478894636,
-0.0479479395,
-0.04202649,
-0.0910250694,
0.0353542529,
0.0211622845,
0.024544863,
-0.0330413729,
0.0150149101,
0.0279217232,
0.0136041194,
0.011979524,
0.0058614546,
0.053694278,
0.0173553247,
0.0259814318,
0.0367848612,
0.0231241994,
0.0774639249,
0.0251574554,
0.0180567652,
0.0147914859,
0.0372837335,
0.0029598123,
-0.0392213836,
0.0032619261,
0.0037312985,
0.0234389864,
0.0269380659,
0.0619181544,
-0.0491488688,
0.0379104428,
-0.0351490751,
-0.0150452312,
0.020406181,
0.084100008,
0.0192027632,
0.0437301509,
0.0732686445,
-0.0097822063,
-0.000897654,
0.0120638171,
0.0153164957,
0.0389325358,
0.0300164707,
-0.0046229581,
-0.0851025283,
0.0091559328,
-0.006245133,
-0.0222094953,
-0.0004437574,
0.0186498817,
-0.0344335586,
-0.0158417188,
-0.0296891928,
0.0063713235,
-0.0579845831,
0.0268741436,
0.0066797766,
-0.0982232913,
0.0329223312,
-0.0187332239,
0.0787705481,
0.0746687204,
0.0519475788,
-0.0373917371,
-0.0206851717,
-0.0219805222,
0.0095532229,
0.0076826755,
0.0150029976,
-0.0465801284,
0.0180217307,
-0.0165030602,
0.0064093987,
-0.0577601865,
-0.0423290916,
0.0872441232,
-0.0297229197,
-0.0168592446,
-0.0468407683,
-0.0043001203,
-0.0538235903,
0.0327102467,
-0.0737346336,
-0.0160138533,
-0.0134187378,
-0.0035257521,
0.0008837227,
0.0084376158,
-0.0506190956,
0.006803636,
0.039030876,
-0.0446379036,
-0.0404078774,
-0.0050380887,
-0.0344796106,
0.0426135696,
0.0326697826,
-0.0730704442,
0.0193329155,
-0.0448245108,
0.0265094507,
-0.0398401506,
0.0119823171,
-0.0188944284,
0.0233328231,
-0.0045668152,
0.0237690303,
0.0096433852,
-0.0323244333,
-0.0594110526,
0.0506428853,
0.0082500009,
-0.0075399876,
0.0329882093,
0.032362625,
0.0315927267,
-0.0198667254,
0.0260437727,
0.0835212171,
0.0278964471,
-0.019450048,
0.0267872997,
0.0169862173,
-0.0053863921,
-0.0276399627,
-0.052484259,
-0.0104948264,
0.0343125202,
-0.0076556876,
0.0188014656,
0.0340669453,
-0.0353447907,
0.0406523012,
-0.0455726907,
-0.0204273034,
0.0358132161,
-0.027390752,
0.0057546641,
0.0351543389,
-0.0198959578,
0.0291833803,
-0.0005006379,
-0.022844214,
0.0399174877,
0.0612019934,
0.0223127045,
-0.0587068386,
0.0458018817,
-0.0359007567,
0.0123967556,
-0.0228356384,
-0.005589122,
0.0345812812,
-0.0384901911,
0.0119475592,
-0.0009543712,
-0.0120401494,
0.0039963271,
0.0979407951,
-0.0526564606,
-0.0236362051,
0.0282361545,
-0.0069896067,
-0.0014292473,
-0.0082307057,
-0.0566701517,
0.0093454989,
0.0690379813,
0.0231334697,
0.0420627967,
-0.0489216,
-0.0025300421,
0.0360115245,
-0.0123538654,
-0.0054030251,
-0.0589486733,
-0.0215820391,
0.043294739,
-0.0027557195,
-0.00705685,
0.0857419297,
-0.0560502149,
0.0125595666,
-0.0002547094,
0.0112391636,
-0.0596997067,
0.1048177257,
-0.0231516883,
0.0462135933,
0.0244326796,
0.0165086538,
-0.0399584584,
-0.020425193,
0.013061218,
-0.0183567721,
0.0654574409,
-0.0720448196,
-0.026611222,
0.0195092857,
0.0000649929,
-0.0235676281,
-0.0168871265,
-0.014583461,
-0.0239858441,
0.0183437373,
-0.0421084464,
-0.0110383062,
0.0176539868,
0.0171918664,
0.0153886471,
0.0012890808,
-0.0074317469,
-0.0206965338,
0.004168612,
0.0276288856,
-0.0098588616,
-0.0000474918,
-0.0375145115,
0.0703055412,
0.0401702635,
0.0202690959,
-0.0354719087,
0.0495614707,
0.0339906923,
0.0452205911,
-0.0322318375,
-0.0112365354,
0.0353469104,
0.0763158128,
-0.0591962934,
-0.0239356384,
0.0649446324,
0.040301457,
0.0150960134,
0.0367973,
-0.0304331966,
0.0441799946,
0.0407224074,
0.0306102969,
-0.0631320998,
0.0142198801,
-0.0035862327,
0.0066968589,
-0.0219737142,
-0.0546901077,
-0.0387715474,
-0.0746866688,
0.0421181321,
-0.0014409958,
-0.0780024305,
-0.0053964504,
-0.0056644692,
-0.0095011769,
0.0505657233,
-0.0495878272,
0.0200653505,
-0.0397992246,
0.0057171895,
-0.0383792222,
-0.0410079882,
0.0552530885,
0.0081955846,
-0.0076599224,
0.0413423479,
0.039396897,
0.0133523792,
0.0001906586,
0.0526098162,
-0.0032070363,
-0.0363531113,
0.0550002493,
-0.0363990255,
-0.020291796,
-0.0183021612,
-0.0153273689,
-0.0166116878,
0.0052798772,
0.0031272401,
-0.090100497,
0.0332576595,
0.0490053892,
-0.027105825,
-0.0127907451,
-0.0527103953,
-0.0030736977,
-0.0031649449,
0.0492601357,
0.0230604261,
-0.0189814642,
-0.0416237004,
-0.0548922941,
-0.0223583858,
-0.0531768352,
-0.0168058705,
-0.0051893215,
-0.0536336452,
0.0438198932,
-0.0334447771,
-0.0460040383,
0.0165149122,
0.0360708684,
0.0154709145,
-0.0039173532,
-0.0222764127,
-0.0112427501,
-0.0414909795,
-0.0275295638,
-0.0196255874,
0.0201072097,
0.0108633423,
-0.0235972088,
-0.0122356936,
-0.0819427669,
0.0172886215,
0.0244445205,
-0.026564192,
-0.0482546017,
-0.0419127122,
0.0069236895,
0.0153640397,
0.0160806254,
0.0281602927,
-0.0547930561,
0.0476260148,
-0.0257377531,
-0.0115322666,
0.0352396518,
-0.0524746627,
0.0560053736,
0.022078909,
-0.0112823946,
-0.0573806278,
-0.0275147706,
0.0129890107,
0.053930521,
-0.031637039,
-0.0183651634,
0.0215693004,
0.0635783672,
-0.0840322003,
-0.0339035802,
-0.0251553897,
-0.0319170356,
0.0006650432,
-0.0701478645,
-0.0336131193,
-0.0397487171,
0.0085955439,
0.0011819869,
-0.0295244679,
0.0269762296,
-0.002081603,
-0.055500824,
0.022712715,
-0.0274652112,
0.0422547758,
0.0101156021,
-0.0171825886,
0.0334249102,
0.0084247561,
-0.0397911146,
0.0140255038,
-0.0654986426,
0.0470356643,
0.0205327701,
0.0376513787,
-0.0010647363,
0.0097647067,
0.0150551554,
0.0211135671,
-0.0272609312,
-0.0861297771,
0.000986627,
0.0458326563,
0.00789579,
0.0310730934,
0.0242595747,
-0.0534818992,
0.0196112804,
0.005858996,
-0.0209407173,
0.0373646244,
-0.032091897,
-0.002141926,
0.0472064465,
-0.0013626002,
-0.052528929,
0.0274501201,
-0.0006607649,
0.0652397722,
-0.0166718736,
-0.0168452784,
-0.0437148511,
-0.0154871922,
0.0160636362,
0.0246636327,
0.0033195142,
-0.0433394201,
-0.086477913,
-0.0158420391,
0.0007179948,
0.0661471784,
0.0210026596,
-0.0210394133,
0.0159241874,
-0.0062440829,
0.0146063473,
-0.0200430248,
-0.0362509117,
0.0336105265,
-0.037945345,
-0.0163295958,
-0.0158163533,
-5.573102471e-33,
-0.0390856341,
-0.0183877107,
0.0389673226,
-0.0138306729,
-0.0262272991,
-0.0077635087,
-0.0304531064,
-0.0100130858,
0.0139740938,
-0.0077893962,
0.0391895026,
-0.0110330228,
-0.0242615473,
-0.0300339591,
-0.0139097674,
-0.0149552682,
0.0353585035,
0.0389431752,
-0.0781901777,
0.0108966315,
0.0186121054,
-0.0168827437,
0.0083324481,
-0.0212434717,
-0.0484986827,
-0.065232344,
-0.0143218096,
0.001937489,
0.0023456058,
0.0170850735,
0.0248854626,
0.0074422308,
0.0167024657,
0.0263988413,
-0.0054517095,
-0.0057776738,
-0.0130174942,
-0.0621685833,
0.0493234284,
-0.0398564748,
0.0024960991,
-0.0665278062,
-0.0047899014,
0.0087655261,
-0.0115487566,
-0.0420289822,
0.0353614911,
0.0089872936,
0.0570805408,
0.011777522,
-0.0437163226,
-0.0148199871,
-0.0204624925,
-0.0200030766,
-0.0408655368,
0.0368751846,
0.0207570754,
-0.0169531237,
0.0658972785,
0.0595351905,
0.0136461398,
-0.021317143,
0.0156672485,
0.0240563098,
-0.0045416453,
0.0636123493,
0.0256430525,
-0.0043797176,
-0.0440972038,
0.0403464399,
-0.0438889265,
0.0470743515,
0.0251608845,
0.0404527411,
-0.0292170625,
0.0504276454,
-0.0569278002,
0.0602255017,
0.0023304492,
0.0591238253,
0.0464503653,
0.0390347019,
-0.0288244635,
0.0005709282,
-0.0241660457,
0.0059563867,
-0.0249108244,
-0.0420821272,
0.0226754323,
-0.0561610796,
-0.0182784367,
0.0196980089,
0.0126429256,
-0.0197899081,
0.0032049369,
0.0312276296,
-0.0349131972,
0.0140278293,
-0.0074815191,
0.0391090252,
-0.0109615987,
-0.0214745272,
0.0446336679,
-0.0149449157,
0.0506958887,
0.0385190472,
-0.0596577153,
0.0578419045,
-0.0165794473,
0.0089121489,
-0.0266900174,
-0.0227198247,
-0.0072193895,
-0.0389478765,
0.0140438173,
-0.0722376183,
-0.0078329062,
-0.0053141871,
-0.0218619332,
-0.0706678107,
-0.0198763292,
-0.045459386,
-0.0143829323,
0.0061831847,
-0.0108615495,
0.0302582588,
-0.021579301,
-0.0012565354,
0.0364234447,
-0.0373879969,
-0.0239392389,
0.0277271867,
2.901e-7,
-0.0334645845,
-0.022694597,
0.0371819586,
0.0789857209,
-0.0069124736,
0.0153053841,
0.0225619227,
0.0128885927,
0.0245438069,
-0.0254019797,
0.0194965992,
0.020119939,
-0.0053056059,
0.04498256,
-0.026346311,
0.0440777354,
-0.0390447155,
0.0110143851,
-0.0696384758,
0.002859866,
0.1056808233,
-0.0107246628,
0.0218842141,
-0.0052749654,
0.00879364,
-0.012244367,
0.0221534632,
-0.0557961836,
-0.025961373,
0.0290317126,
-0.0959543884,
-0.0181535408,
-0.0073704664,
-0.0267158318,
0.0051714969,
0.0143059026,
0.0386960022,
0.0463525541,
-0.0390700996,
0.01048721,
0.0157315638,
-0.0254525226,
-0.0234460086,
-0.0555931889,
0.0501539893,
0.0180159751,
-0.0016357529,
0.005303497,
-0.009176855,
-0.0219966155,
-0.0549449176,
-0.0210351143,
0.0031734277,
0.0200889613,
-0.0190521777,
0.0028600248,
0.0020989329,
-0.0154747935,
-0.0132538155,
0.0351687185,
-0.0250792913,
-0.038826324,
-0.0251925662,
-0.0047370601,
-0.0169085506,
-0.0658830255,
-0.0347967409,
2.922661451e-34,
-0.0361500569,
0.0011707217,
-0.0125986375,
0.0360636748,
0.042593278,
0.021274209,
0.0066946335,
0.0389098525,
0.0506794415,
-0.0515000932,
-0.0504601449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00548v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00548v1
|
LIDAO: Towards Limited Interventions for Debiasing (Large) Language Models
| 2024-06-01T20:12:54 | 2024-06-01T20:12:54 |
Tianci Liu, Haoyu Wang, Shiyang Wang, Yu Cheng, Jing Gao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance on various
natural language generation tasks. Nonetheless, they suffer from generating
negative and harmful contents that are biased against certain demographic
groups (e.g., female), raising severe fairness concerns. As remedies, prior
works intervened the generation by removing attitude or demographic
information, inevitably degrading the generation quality and resulting in
notable \textit{fairness-fluency} trade-offs. However, it is still
under-explored to what extent the fluency \textit{has to} be affected in order
to achieve a desired level of fairness. In this work, we conduct the first
formal study from an information-theoretic perspective. We show that previous
approaches are excessive for debiasing and propose LIDAO, a general framework
to debias a (L)LM at a better fluency provably. We further robustify LIDAO in
adversarial scenarios, where a carefully-crafted prompt may stimulate LLMs
exhibiting instruction-following abilities to generate texts with fairness
issue appears only when the prompt is also taken into account. Experiments on
three LMs ranging from 0.7B to 7B parameters demonstrate the superiority of our
method.
|
[
0.0438157395,
0.0787232071,
-0.0243345052,
0.0368765257,
-0.0283716172,
0.0031766661,
0.0456895083,
-0.0176629648,
0.0105351852,
-0.0621086806,
-0.0062841708,
-0.0639099106,
0.0123609165,
-0.003773011,
0.0463626049,
-0.052687373,
0.0170193445,
-0.0063154409,
0.0087125748,
-0.0512776226,
0.0092645539,
0.0103256246,
0.0255793575,
0.029872369,
0.0239861067,
0.0168662164,
0.0329310298,
0.0352099948,
0.0014106156,
0.0036100752,
0.0298745707,
0.0631482378,
-0.0024382002,
0.0407604836,
0.0000022455,
-0.0328485742,
0.0001374003,
-0.0076680002,
-0.0192449559,
0.0360451452,
0.0590194352,
-0.0436968915,
-0.0251988769,
0.0335852914,
-0.0213572364,
0.0259572901,
0.0387648381,
0.0221979786,
0.0481761768,
0.0644400567,
0.0130639207,
0.0095386105,
-0.0002940612,
-0.0315622352,
0.0301627573,
-0.0006077576,
0.0320775881,
-0.0175615847,
-0.0599918328,
0.0021117625,
-0.0193238705,
0.0160956811,
0.0379805751,
-0.0052765585,
0.0142193576,
0.0192346964,
0.001426786,
-0.0391504951,
0.0017254385,
0.0593560487,
-0.0291716233,
-0.0101408968,
-0.0106724985,
-0.0249337032,
0.0370741859,
-0.0082350858,
-0.0340658315,
0.048522871,
-0.0048753214,
0.0168218985,
0.0192072336,
-0.006194388,
0.0431346707,
0.0662512183,
-0.0056386613,
0.0391241796,
0.0293772779,
-0.036419075,
-0.0062516015,
0.0290285256,
-0.0101551581,
-0.0601488762,
-0.0086335009,
0.0099344542,
-0.0382412784,
0.0017568053,
-0.0637120828,
-0.0151572591,
0.0468961261,
-0.0394446291,
0.0069864821,
0.0199666377,
0.0153049687,
-0.0274755657,
0.0091004772,
0.0353326611,
0.0032064016,
0.019857632,
-0.0228438042,
0.0185441878,
0.0444018766,
-0.0079401368,
-0.0058772815,
-0.0108023807,
-0.0418507382,
0.0429150164,
-0.0599530712,
0.0092109023,
-0.0275191162,
-0.0018430033,
-0.0143585168,
0.0253317282,
-0.0608764589,
-0.0076723299,
-0.0246541817,
-0.0141722364,
-0.0436497964,
0.0130721042,
0.0070574288,
-0.1141141504,
-0.0259921737,
0.0155620826,
-0.036998678,
-0.0351391174,
-0.0023320434,
0.0650547594,
0.0183479264,
-0.0285219848,
-0.0546280518,
-0.0484812818,
-0.0234539472,
-0.0683740675,
-0.0170902815,
-0.0554630235,
-0.0089707328,
-0.0093690977,
0.0018748797,
-0.0568738766,
0.0042773839,
0.0204274282,
-0.0334179923,
0.0456473306,
0.0296486095,
-0.0063221697,
0.0447156765,
0.0291958675,
0.0292566363,
0.0853232592,
0.0329019018,
0.0342072584,
0.0279497392,
0.001614375,
0.0035569237,
0.0269449241,
0.0615259036,
0.0317448303,
-0.0251538008,
-0.0322101973,
-0.0196850095,
0.0284176487,
0.067805849,
0.0803888142,
-0.0192667656,
-0.0516570397,
0.1052057743,
-0.0195645504,
-0.024861021,
0.0266262908,
0.0673187599,
0.0080626626,
-0.040565189,
0.0787443742,
-0.0715150908,
0.0007081042,
-0.0318703055,
-0.003244451,
0.0487728305,
0.0649673939,
-0.0322037637,
-0.0463949665,
0.0226061661,
-0.0107837049,
0.0199342966,
-0.0099741817,
0.0106510185,
0.0430702455,
-0.0275675561,
0.0161011182,
0.0486785434,
-0.0492202044,
0.0399931706,
-0.0682515502,
0.0365089327,
0.0457708463,
0.0608353652,
0.0131081278,
0.0291250627,
-0.0244038627,
-0.0282464549,
0.0744808167,
0.0643196553,
-0.0053176293,
0.0146698756,
-0.0696693063,
-0.006836453,
-0.0223216116,
0.0369345434,
0.0479099639,
0.0255009942,
0.0159967821,
0.0348131061,
-0.0234902408,
-0.0390482582,
0.0406203493,
-0.0285474956,
-0.0550845228,
0.0239502843,
0.0043143765,
0.03819317,
0.007657656,
-0.0449456386,
0.0114481039,
-0.0019256412,
-0.0375583507,
-0.0117025981,
-0.0038704644,
-0.0574458428,
-0.0455091894,
0.0027401932,
-0.0380686559,
0.0046270839,
0.0304888375,
-0.0305550005,
0.0133309187,
0.0471534692,
-0.0061589763,
-0.0159046259,
-0.0361462906,
0.0184762292,
0.011573527,
0.0392082371,
-0.0649974495,
0.0541666895,
-0.0283065084,
-0.0038576603,
0.0284323171,
0.0014311353,
-0.0295284409,
-0.0708885863,
-0.017817717,
0.0246350691,
0.0011347081,
0.0081421891,
0.0539193563,
0.0205386728,
0.0123042352,
-0.0186386537,
-0.0444018282,
0.0058963303,
-0.0306489822,
-0.0219770409,
0.0323970877,
0.026746029,
-0.0046714712,
0.0236023702,
-0.0454004966,
-0.0348269269,
0.029796645,
0.0343739092,
0.0267363992,
-0.0107205808,
-0.0233629532,
-0.0362546593,
-0.0140288444,
0.0159186255,
0.0421101302,
0.0504277423,
0.0227910392,
-0.0415535718,
0.0332520083,
-0.0508869775,
0.0043238192,
-0.0189610105,
-0.054284215,
-0.0115740569,
0.0398921855,
0.0460328422,
0.0715640932,
0.0521001779,
0.0509640239,
0.0570994429,
0.0198707934,
-0.0501400493,
-0.007358877,
-0.0206309166,
0.0175260473,
-0.0138064139,
-0.0916342214,
0.0195063092,
0.0453527793,
0.0552760251,
-0.0235002898,
-0.0576296523,
0.050915312,
-0.0484616756,
-0.0684900805,
-0.0082665524,
-0.0282049011,
-0.0146566415,
-0.0047582337,
-0.0500107408,
-0.0838323832,
0.0663287118,
-0.0324660651,
0.02055558,
-0.0195087083,
-0.0045654322,
-0.0262010675,
0.0285135601,
0.0023534454,
0.0456587262,
0.0300683361,
0.0076115993,
-0.0633754134,
-0.0254638251,
0.0391485021,
-0.0286703464,
0.0133488122,
-0.0505019836,
-0.0064195911,
-0.010238803,
-0.0612102821,
-0.0686197653,
-0.0846949965,
0.0339981951,
0.0018242679,
0.0683795586,
-0.0130613139,
-0.0256350953,
-0.0101262033,
0.026911296,
0.0190519579,
-0.039416112,
0.0107511673,
-0.0001524511,
0.0179245975,
0.0458965153,
-0.018801216,
0.0588596314,
-0.0529869646,
0.0155251324,
0.0464527421,
-0.0076319659,
0.0356096812,
0.0274020676,
-0.0073814644,
0.0136614544,
-0.0182937067,
-0.0259802714,
0.0226584617,
0.0686245784,
-0.0305504277,
-0.0079732276,
0.1052731574,
-0.0033493659,
-0.0336944684,
0.0339134969,
0.0375281908,
0.057278797,
-0.0055311653,
-0.007541582,
-0.0787498057,
-0.0049134623,
0.015921291,
0.0457703359,
-0.0731630698,
-0.0309993587,
-0.0301456116,
-0.1264523119,
0.0182973146,
0.0369501822,
0.0057132202,
-0.0611800887,
-0.0101152761,
-0.0219939593,
-0.0123263625,
0.0578380264,
0.0050115841,
0.0121247694,
0.0174185224,
0.0175574832,
0.0056518707,
-0.0659012198,
-0.0311241262,
-0.0457323454,
0.081412822,
0.0484389439,
0.0310453456,
-0.0059212665,
-0.0070443125,
0.0132382819,
-0.0280394945,
-0.0076817032,
-0.0303037856,
0.0544757955,
-0.023962738,
-0.0077373725,
-0.0467145368,
0.0572035722,
0.0254909247,
0.0217007138,
-0.0157088526,
-0.0158234499,
0.0097918687,
-0.0446866527,
-0.0326667465,
0.0126956655,
0.0364296101,
0.1026405469,
0.0405508541,
-0.0495329201,
-0.0164362267,
-0.0684082955,
0.0000971825,
-0.0566501394,
-0.0262803491,
0.0235120635,
0.0018048582,
-0.0463125631,
-0.0853189304,
-0.0425944664,
-0.0286347531,
0.0122597311,
0.0121824406,
-0.0266430266,
-0.0169879999,
-0.025281379,
0.0117589403,
0.0014887154,
-0.0513228513,
0.0339671969,
-0.0259305108,
-0.0392228924,
-0.0397780985,
-0.0829690322,
-0.0065032514,
0.0495535471,
-0.0393192992,
-0.0929585025,
0.0396615192,
0.0452512018,
0.0248534456,
0.0543836839,
-0.0038677496,
-0.0614514872,
0.0885030329,
0.0544907711,
-0.0185754951,
0.0448346138,
0.0236600339,
-0.0069345292,
0.0224076938,
0.0519365557,
-0.0277579743,
0.016183719,
0.0374850631,
0.0228368118,
0.0016076789,
-0.0479179695,
0.01363446,
0.040163096,
-0.0094625391,
-0.0756065175,
0.0036546788,
-0.0368216522,
-0.0124534629,
-0.0249608085,
-0.036623735,
-0.0360179394,
-0.0133949593,
0.0295462664,
0.0042735487,
-0.0074202321,
-0.0276543908,
-0.0410036966,
0.0338810384,
-0.0259071384,
-0.0048133708,
-0.0442663059,
0.0473351069,
0.026729608,
0.0021153439,
-0.0207929388,
0.0380892865,
-0.0351346619,
0.0190354977,
0.0209398959,
0.0251245592,
0.0198618155,
0.0048909169,
-0.0345080867,
0.0040921806,
-0.0320985094,
0.0186377726,
-0.0349051431,
0.0255624168,
0.0462419949,
0.0083351014,
0.0592566244,
-0.0109688602,
0.0076561188,
-0.0102062812,
0.005855286,
0.0339234695,
-0.0378839038,
0.0373403952,
-0.0222100727,
-0.0164632872,
0.0018937442,
0.0742712393,
0.0193896126,
0.0690977573,
-0.022140611,
0.0040491098,
-0.0232703276,
-0.0458648168,
0.030259084,
-0.0241316576,
-0.017567452,
-0.0013056508,
-0.0690011606,
-0.0508535653,
-0.0408849455,
0.0176585205,
0.0416245945,
-0.0241757929,
0.0220794473,
0.0396896973,
-0.0382987112,
-0.006030031,
-0.0430664904,
0.0263706092,
-0.0363660604,
-0.0292316489,
0.0041667037,
-6.880908262e-33,
-0.045690842,
-0.0138203427,
-0.0200604685,
-0.0438082553,
-0.0127172079,
-0.016743267,
-0.0097623272,
-0.0160683431,
0.0013001832,
0.0082207918,
0.0179782975,
-0.0146431038,
0.0022318317,
0.0201782864,
-0.0406047665,
-0.009322295,
0.0882846862,
-0.0089859376,
-0.0636253506,
0.0352561399,
0.0098466873,
-0.003122099,
0.000693233,
-0.0256306026,
0.074018836,
-0.0210410785,
-0.0284370966,
0.0063686087,
-0.0427267216,
0.0227961447,
-0.008520321,
0.052999977,
0.0297433641,
-0.0055683409,
-0.0122730387,
0.0218232963,
-0.0184423998,
0.0000374066,
0.0337886065,
0.0004680341,
0.0029578202,
-0.0531340912,
0.0396088846,
-0.0022961993,
-0.0423061177,
-0.0008873442,
0.0093487976,
0.0090622958,
0.0096568624,
-0.0051363008,
-0.041714374,
0.029930748,
-0.0113004651,
-0.0202677622,
-0.0225342344,
0.0120948767,
-0.0108307861,
0.0137774246,
0.0006642631,
0.036511682,
0.0417536162,
0.018683603,
0.0307069812,
0.0040625823,
0.0103334822,
0.0613497719,
0.0283794329,
0.0098182149,
-0.0316666253,
-0.0286397673,
0.0073509086,
-0.0334009305,
0.015448695,
0.081526868,
0.0366063602,
-0.0267377011,
-0.0762815699,
0.0254977793,
0.0350573063,
0.0125635918,
0.0410075039,
-0.0184792206,
-0.0603139773,
-0.0425690599,
-0.0366820656,
-0.086692363,
-0.0048494996,
-0.0274272747,
0.0209797621,
0.0402685702,
-0.0417264365,
-0.0548708364,
0.0207225364,
-0.0226018336,
-0.0139251947,
0.0516656227,
-0.0356565714,
-0.0399668068,
-0.0042209998,
-0.0015394597,
-0.0647956207,
0.0043582735,
0.0288533699,
0.0069180978,
-0.0181553718,
0.0271261595,
0.0091029955,
0.0329085775,
-0.0454100817,
0.0251014158,
-0.0294685364,
0.0506698154,
0.0325600952,
0.0254029948,
0.025510354,
-0.0002376628,
-0.0329265706,
0.0014383135,
0.0151756033,
-0.0165313706,
-0.0348010696,
-0.006464167,
0.0073202928,
0.041286584,
-0.0582537688,
-0.0153717119,
0.005217697,
-0.0186236743,
0.0501963794,
-0.0519391112,
-0.0187947582,
-0.0490881391,
2.878e-7,
-0.036814943,
0.0357695445,
0.0043337084,
0.0396159627,
0.0231529251,
0.0358815901,
0.0244976841,
0.0433827899,
-0.0019338134,
0.0122960424,
-0.0331910588,
0.0314408019,
0.0339097604,
0.0292873196,
-0.0534172244,
0.0370866992,
-0.0657583177,
0.0177951362,
-0.0253411792,
-0.0157082658,
0.0037576118,
0.081220448,
0.0068038623,
-0.0142222904,
0.0322484002,
-0.0462064929,
0.0376941152,
-0.0096005844,
-0.0171029978,
0.0169786699,
0.0786390752,
-0.0026081412,
0.0304863881,
0.0147514567,
0.0025630398,
-0.0099237431,
-0.0417191982,
0.0655854344,
0.0241450481,
0.0078181382,
-0.0059699439,
-0.0109252026,
-0.0116008101,
-0.0596934818,
0.0602752715,
0.0234615058,
-0.0369079784,
-0.0349570811,
-0.0002901675,
-0.0204739831,
0.0446538627,
-0.0602494255,
-0.0435047261,
0.0011533544,
0.0198598634,
0.0348439254,
-0.0026952939,
-0.026439378,
-0.0397096127,
-0.0515048206,
-0.0484074838,
-0.0740377456,
-0.0219633449,
0.0155981593,
0.0017050569,
-0.0226303954,
0.0357087888,
2.767445917e-34,
0.0259767771,
-0.0010370223,
0.0179234818,
-0.03026958,
0.0127572315,
0.021493515,
0.0028482436,
-0.0062637893,
0.03842308,
-0.0369838588,
-0.0254502054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00515v1
|
A Survey on Large Language Models for Code Generation
| 2024-06-01T17:48:15 | 2024-06-01T17:48:15 |
Juyong Jiang, Fan Wang, Jiasi Shen, Sungju Kim, Sunghun Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered remarkable advancements across
diverse code-related tasks, known as Code LLMs, particularly in code generation
that generates source code with LLM from natural language descriptions. This
burgeoning field has captured significant interest from both academic
researchers and industry professionals due to its practical significance in
software development, e.g., GitHub Copilot. Despite the active exploration of
LLMs for a variety of code tasks, either from the perspective of natural
language processing (NLP) or software engineering (SE) or both, there is a
noticeable absence of a comprehensive and up-to-date literature review
dedicated to LLM for code generation. In this survey, we aim to bridge this gap
by providing a systematic literature review that serves as a valuable reference
for researchers investigating the cutting-edge progress in LLMs for code
generation. We introduce a taxonomy to categorize and discuss the recent
developments in LLMs for code generation, covering aspects such as data
curation, latest advances, performance evaluation, and real-world applications.
In addition, we present a historical overview of the evolution of LLMs for code
generation and offer an empirical comparison using the widely recognized
HumanEval and MBPP benchmarks to highlight the progressive enhancements in LLM
capabilities for code generation. We identify critical challenges and promising
opportunities regarding the gap between academia and practical development.
Furthermore, we have established a dedicated resource website
(https://codellm.github.io) to continuously document and disseminate the most
recent advances in the field.
|
[
0.0195183121,
0.0724389255,
-0.0351666175,
0.0382344089,
-0.0281494316,
-0.0274775475,
-0.0314825103,
0.0076212366,
0.0097466875,
-0.0487327687,
0.0105922688,
-0.0065532983,
0.0104136309,
0.0405493751,
0.0514076762,
-0.0098896995,
0.0238048099,
-0.0712911636,
-0.0359437019,
0.0139435474,
-0.0113844499,
0.0363960639,
0.0350566655,
0.0710210726,
0.0189651772,
-0.0216713138,
-0.0053953244,
0.0109255202,
-0.026535904,
-0.0551566184,
0.0120603442,
0.0289636049,
-0.0129282027,
0.0013080321,
0.0000022191,
-0.0616517439,
-0.0088552991,
0.0140411165,
0.0421778932,
0.0298314169,
0.0268381275,
-0.0229058079,
-0.0228553265,
0.0312506296,
-0.0142919449,
0.0052836621,
0.0383955501,
-0.0373484828,
0.0745063797,
0.0486688055,
0.0085439458,
-0.0266217347,
0.0139459465,
0.0153949382,
0.0049369326,
-0.002681087,
0.0126335006,
0.051633887,
0.0370029546,
0.0078870533,
0.0141543774,
-0.0004837485,
0.0096735591,
-0.0131147262,
0.0133409193,
0.0476191565,
-0.0188200492,
-0.021126315,
0.005117591,
0.0361541249,
-0.0420058668,
-0.0289410111,
0.0291509628,
-0.0193362068,
-0.0361369997,
-0.0285722706,
-0.0261826385,
0.0874323025,
-0.0119067319,
0.0359795913,
0.0314042643,
-0.0210190006,
0.0045430171,
0.0134044215,
-0.0353804678,
0.0358468778,
0.0354295671,
0.0031481213,
-0.0385762565,
-0.0464432687,
-0.0094252843,
-0.0794578195,
-0.0042459285,
0.0612621605,
-0.0188728459,
-0.0006195211,
-0.0502448454,
-0.0212077834,
0.0683424473,
-0.0295369308,
0.0462116636,
0.0286183041,
-0.008290505,
0.0071844743,
-0.0184025653,
0.0758485422,
-0.0303785503,
-0.0416298471,
-0.035247609,
0.0084170932,
-0.0348327607,
-0.0069666072,
-0.0498158969,
0.0333676971,
-0.016743131,
0.0186078623,
-0.0370778181,
0.0576332547,
0.0152696399,
0.058913596,
-0.0073146266,
-0.0272164531,
-0.0439631678,
0.0191971101,
0.0374860689,
-0.01565676,
0.0221192446,
-0.0490409359,
0.0041278624,
-0.0501389615,
0.0265927538,
0.0406733491,
-0.0395761169,
-0.0231948458,
0.0086601889,
0.0644778162,
0.0313272029,
0.0238071848,
-0.0333345421,
-0.0462090299,
0.0009074415,
-0.0390198641,
-0.0108672557,
-0.1182911843,
-0.0388982743,
0.0129887229,
-0.0057428367,
-0.081311509,
0.016732743,
0.0190425385,
-0.0060807657,
0.0038473364,
-0.0848374814,
0.059010379,
-0.0053419811,
-0.0013155313,
0.0046704421,
0.0510506891,
0.0676397011,
0.0196563527,
0.006225876,
-0.0414835252,
0.0282307565,
0.0524067208,
-0.03335841,
-0.0116279116,
-0.0170797464,
0.0189462621,
0.0338075906,
0.0101434011,
0.0101591619,
0.0792493299,
-0.004370675,
0.0425285138,
0.0224150345,
0.042312406,
0.0110405236,
0.0492007323,
0.1030211225,
0.0561286546,
0.0089474395,
-0.0421772189,
-0.0030060452,
0.0248098057,
-0.0191343278,
0.028923763,
0.0043387432,
0.0927798972,
0.007967189,
-0.0498377383,
-0.0367531031,
-0.0095089218,
-0.0292666983,
-0.0249938667,
0.0195348114,
0.0051590153,
-0.0389638655,
0.0441868082,
0.0145839602,
-0.0657500923,
0.0119587434,
-0.035540428,
0.0203090534,
0.0478987172,
0.0470874421,
-0.0176484399,
-0.0283188019,
-0.0014066546,
-0.0267363582,
0.0079946863,
0.0254657995,
-0.0055687539,
-0.0191042274,
-0.0457867309,
0.0023791536,
-0.0467442758,
-0.0139764706,
0.0097175334,
0.029074369,
-0.0368561409,
0.0453448594,
-0.0007372068,
-0.076102145,
0.035898976,
-0.0347335078,
0.0462188832,
0.0321168154,
-0.0279564001,
0.0410487056,
-0.01526256,
-0.0421159305,
0.030915169,
0.0427225567,
-0.0192333031,
-0.016757872,
0.0128404703,
-0.0054910267,
-0.0193215497,
0.0373213701,
-0.0232918207,
-0.0047370163,
-0.0043422622,
-0.0252937619,
-0.019782206,
0.0226931442,
-0.0180200245,
0.0170850176,
0.0017810862,
0.0328084603,
-0.0146927256,
-0.0047359029,
-0.0298819505,
0.0377117395,
-0.0078841168,
0.0252021924,
0.0119627118,
0.0792135969,
0.0162282139,
0.0059686019,
-0.0404454097,
0.0465912968,
-0.0227923505,
0.0374490879,
0.0155951232,
0.0800240114,
-0.0269368906,
-0.0683738813,
-0.0812546685,
0.0566133186,
0.0013106634,
0.0108739575,
0.0239744056,
0.025866298,
-0.0209974982,
0.0367244296,
-0.0280145928,
-0.0167218857,
0.0307197925,
0.0157857072,
0.0303885676,
-0.0182807557,
-0.0909041241,
-0.0093154004,
0.0077130757,
-0.021592427,
0.0338436067,
-0.003758664,
-0.0085080583,
-0.0969564915,
0.0925065875,
-0.0097783925,
0.0014853696,
-0.017555669,
-0.0272258557,
-0.0025409227,
-0.0411012433,
0.0914253965,
-0.0050245035,
0.0083312234,
-0.0109536685,
0.061695531,
-0.0201905034,
-0.0261349287,
0.0125651015,
0.0017628411,
-0.0406282134,
-0.0163685828,
-0.0647758693,
0.0635004118,
0.0572738014,
-0.010732987,
-0.0301568955,
-0.0421658158,
0.0096451901,
-0.0153366113,
0.0205868669,
0.0149450013,
-0.0296381786,
-0.0117996968,
0.0582097434,
-0.0021998771,
-0.0919307619,
0.0426530913,
-0.0775991902,
-0.0006861564,
-0.035000138,
-0.0323981009,
-0.0721871406,
0.0562582202,
-0.0002918803,
0.0366552882,
0.0079932902,
-0.0126992781,
-0.0011961164,
0.0053718998,
-0.0370653681,
-0.0268585496,
0.0711793378,
-0.068814069,
0.0215553176,
-0.0211835559,
-0.0159282312,
-0.0278892424,
-0.0202242825,
-0.0129208164,
-0.0011646308,
0.0338662006,
0.0044965711,
0.0425892174,
0.0195703525,
0.0056738984,
0.0105118863,
0.0191733092,
-0.0300252698,
-0.0232365523,
-0.0293893125,
-0.0055068703,
-0.0538708679,
-0.0103777023,
0.0180228967,
-0.0090892091,
0.0242396798,
0.0378486514,
0.0778027996,
-0.0565595739,
-0.0002964631,
0.0544401035,
-0.0145466737,
-0.0392379835,
0.058659412,
0.0568655953,
-0.041017212,
-0.0071519078,
0.1009771675,
0.0223013964,
-0.041116517,
0.0315446779,
0.0066307676,
0.0802394822,
0.0603480898,
0.0274684932,
-0.0497877933,
0.0001259294,
0.0029298621,
0.0244849455,
-0.0292628314,
-0.0148862666,
-0.0509480499,
-0.1288616657,
0.0300607122,
0.0215235241,
-0.0175642781,
-0.0444599614,
-0.0394505858,
-0.0319343247,
0.0141599439,
-0.0447331108,
0.0226918571,
-0.0327044651,
0.0189170446,
0.0096931951,
-0.0636639968,
-0.0130720958,
0.0080884667,
-0.0419913828,
0.0424392782,
0.0729199871,
0.0219281018,
0.014404892,
0.0343608037,
0.0202978924,
-0.0164555497,
0.0156680867,
-0.0369121283,
-0.011637738,
0.0152698532,
-0.0193703026,
0.0275445748,
0.024954332,
-0.0616094507,
-0.0305855628,
0.0427564867,
0.0625636727,
-0.0071407445,
0.0026050156,
-0.0305641238,
0.0235159881,
-0.0010822796,
0.0376695283,
0.0250299647,
-0.0287568215,
-0.0338219181,
-0.0552731268,
-0.0230380595,
-0.0402422808,
-0.0109354835,
0.0009008097,
-0.0156925842,
0.0068239858,
-0.0359432921,
0.0101066213,
0.0249560308,
0.025571119,
0.046991542,
0.0139629813,
0.0389088914,
-0.0253947489,
-0.0446673147,
0.0094398959,
-0.0404483154,
0.020072924,
-0.0434922166,
-0.027348103,
0.040236529,
-0.0310968533,
0.002788835,
0.0132935708,
-0.1045283303,
-0.0712311938,
-0.0390068963,
0.0631219968,
0.0151102534,
0.011833963,
-0.0084732212,
-0.0471532419,
-0.045966953,
0.0225898772,
-0.0139211295,
0.009834107,
-0.0123392232,
0.0472154059,
0.0396830738,
0.0056174691,
-0.0645585656,
-0.0072248774,
0.0002513315,
0.0274397749,
0.018920077,
-0.0078378199,
0.0529356599,
0.0589210317,
-0.0376623683,
-0.030092923,
-0.0078476388,
0.0029031471,
-0.0528712347,
-0.0200545508,
-0.0648739859,
-0.0723599494,
0.0385755897,
-0.0075978287,
-0.0393981077,
0.0310272332,
0.0105608162,
-0.0313942693,
0.0539974086,
0.014776255,
0.0437132642,
-0.0185590275,
0.0236120578,
0.0827532783,
-0.0145506952,
-0.036459405,
0.0346367992,
-0.0435894243,
-0.0042300699,
-0.0004026144,
0.0494748279,
0.0006689144,
0.0192664303,
0.001418889,
0.0018711655,
-0.0164646562,
-0.0586371496,
-0.0225592908,
0.0117435707,
0.0607540831,
0.0546544939,
0.0536534302,
-0.0320423841,
0.0108597344,
-0.031763833,
0.0961026475,
-0.0060453899,
-0.0595079586,
0.0020489281,
0.0016031206,
-0.0263181087,
-0.0531458743,
0.114339456,
0.040868368,
0.0098405108,
0.0066830753,
-0.0116032744,
-0.0384891741,
0.0145535758,
0.0222212616,
-0.0460991487,
-0.0024987771,
-0.006126509,
-0.0689346492,
-0.0377635881,
0.0200636573,
0.0300628804,
0.0467624739,
-0.0131351594,
0.0272250623,
0.0788707957,
-0.0006016423,
-0.0047912681,
-0.0433173291,
0.0256058928,
0.0002897161,
-0.0286599398,
-0.0181067511,
-5.961267604e-33,
-0.0299960487,
-0.0400916338,
0.0285956059,
-0.0023774342,
-0.0241911486,
-0.0108755166,
-0.0479670577,
-0.0134448688,
0.037281435,
-0.069641076,
0.0481126346,
-0.0239224993,
-0.0302490164,
-0.0003426405,
0.0378111787,
0.0415861383,
0.0386616141,
0.0242289808,
-0.0458574072,
0.0358535498,
-0.0306476206,
-0.0006679536,
-0.016366804,
-0.0250511579,
-0.0208149198,
-0.030952448,
0.0056804977,
0.0076478072,
0.0104529988,
0.0215385389,
-0.0135890944,
0.0232377071,
0.0105559975,
0.0077763665,
-0.0535108857,
-0.0351173133,
0.0152966063,
0.0067769308,
0.0179160442,
-0.0240622349,
0.0187974554,
-0.0815360025,
0.0611571521,
-0.010731454,
-0.0448084138,
0.027526604,
0.0119052986,
-0.0149730416,
-0.0074061435,
-0.0318740569,
-0.0711071715,
0.0364076197,
-0.0467575267,
0.0061821109,
-0.0142187504,
0.0311627705,
-0.0064597544,
0.0737119392,
0.0386176184,
0.0111975791,
0.0328560434,
0.0496109389,
0.069992125,
-0.0096592279,
0.0432740748,
0.0267068576,
0.0203494728,
0.0388155505,
-0.0269374046,
0.0141906282,
0.0012990211,
0.060796041,
0.0128909284,
0.0258799046,
-0.0004915107,
-0.0124634793,
-0.0269867554,
0.0082325619,
-0.0280202404,
0.0037867539,
0.031927824,
0.0220317896,
-0.0047144163,
-0.0054542529,
-0.0613866374,
-0.0283464957,
0.0030440511,
-0.0233672224,
0.0407323129,
-0.0138269207,
-0.0424215533,
0.0055784294,
0.0135122612,
-0.0379405059,
-0.0216518566,
0.0266373176,
-0.0608144552,
0.0327538773,
-0.0253361296,
0.0312091745,
-0.0262592472,
-0.0418844223,
0.0128200352,
-0.023541512,
0.0517037585,
0.0224957298,
-0.0099421171,
0.0106375804,
-0.0402468666,
0.0095654782,
-0.056830816,
-0.0071784845,
-0.0097247642,
0.013238173,
0.004409933,
-0.0272892844,
0.0171019975,
0.0315462574,
0.0305380337,
-0.0266406201,
-0.0328486338,
-0.0008034524,
0.0251961034,
0.029989209,
-0.0207790583,
-0.0049265851,
-0.060993962,
0.0236028042,
0.0521125942,
-0.0213475078,
-0.0611156709,
0.0055878866,
2.949e-7,
0.0038013796,
0.0463003628,
-0.008638652,
0.0281740129,
0.0085242521,
0.0186686926,
-0.0256169196,
-0.0307293683,
0.018065149,
0.0091256015,
-0.0639369413,
0.0214715973,
0.0302857552,
0.0250833407,
-0.0615199059,
0.0304138102,
-0.0042503672,
-0.0115784248,
-0.0947773904,
0.0139623554,
0.0334530212,
0.0488927923,
-0.0105886981,
-0.0039774459,
0.0010264744,
-0.0433970504,
0.017240433,
-0.0245217197,
-0.0175886974,
0.0707921609,
-0.0475859493,
0.0159693938,
0.0085751293,
-0.0211765729,
0.0192012973,
-0.0141317025,
0.0151552912,
0.0498371683,
0.0113845337,
0.073317498,
0.05834198,
-0.0058365078,
-0.0232113693,
-0.0831159651,
0.0421570912,
-0.0291830897,
-0.0264585987,
-0.0437219739,
-0.0161170885,
0.000968786,
-0.0180319343,
-0.0474019237,
0.0203598738,
0.0182117447,
-0.0113360751,
-0.0141558135,
-0.0308972634,
-0.019827703,
-0.0332877636,
-0.0045223013,
-0.0312088393,
-0.0548717082,
-0.0384089462,
0.0277824439,
0.0173339415,
-0.035761632,
0.0235343874,
3.176378131e-34,
0.0261401329,
-0.0475573428,
0.0129700378,
0.0148563394,
0.0634732395,
-0.0013383474,
-0.0251787715,
0.0234975666,
-0.045295909,
-0.0268818457,
-0.0317413099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00507v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00507v1
|
Prompt Chaining or Stepwise Prompt? Refinement in Text Summarization
| 2024-06-01T17:28:38 | 2024-06-01T17:28:38 |
Shichao Sun, Ruifeng Yuan, Ziqiang Cao, Wenjie Li, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated the capacity to improve
summary quality by mirroring a human-like iterative process of critique and
refinement starting from the initial draft. Two strategies are designed to
perform this iterative process: Prompt Chaining and Stepwise Prompt. Prompt
chaining orchestrates the drafting, critiquing, and refining phases through a
series of three discrete prompts, while Stepwise prompt integrates these phases
within a single prompt. However, the relative effectiveness of the two methods
has not been extensively studied. This paper is dedicated to examining and
comparing these two methods in the context of text summarization to ascertain
which method stands out as the most effective. Experimental results show that
the prompt chaining method can produce a more favorable outcome. This might be
because stepwise prompt might produce a simulated refinement process according
to our various experiments. Since refinement is adaptable to diverse tasks, our
conclusions have the potential to be extrapolated to other applications,
thereby offering insights that may contribute to the broader development of
LLMs.
|
[
0.063415885,
-0.033865992,
0.0021975441,
-0.0441887975,
-0.0445882827,
-0.0077947001,
0.0059056436,
-0.0114994505,
-0.0311274063,
-0.0543433167,
0.0039058211,
-0.0187995173,
0.0282849204,
0.010391972,
0.0119622061,
-0.1266169995,
0.0342683531,
-0.0598860048,
-0.0074464758,
0.0100570684,
0.0341586657,
0.0131284203,
-0.004488633,
0.0415824503,
0.0344777666,
-0.0040374431,
-0.0225751046,
0.0129690962,
0.0132520888,
-0.0287692938,
-0.0325646065,
0.0527192876,
-0.0025753994,
-0.010520746,
0.0000020527,
-0.0655156299,
-0.0314442776,
-0.0007716849,
0.000063963,
0.0542585701,
0.0585701726,
-0.0261489823,
0.0043765102,
0.0234647766,
0.0066536716,
-0.0010681635,
-0.0078675859,
0.021726625,
0.1163735539,
0.0319850557,
-0.0053838524,
-0.018820513,
-0.0156706441,
-0.0037341886,
-0.0686749518,
-0.009501867,
-0.0045925719,
0.009489743,
0.037188381,
0.0159102194,
0.0249607302,
0.0296048969,
-0.0004519934,
-0.0521089286,
0.0100480057,
0.0224992801,
-0.0110812131,
-0.0336796194,
-0.0192849655,
0.0314751863,
0.0235046018,
0.0039167567,
0.0083335899,
0.0086553348,
0.0223271772,
0.0173714738,
-0.0746480674,
0.056575913,
-0.0405106582,
0.0139237037,
-0.0295796152,
0.0143737113,
-0.0341639705,
0.0125560053,
-0.0086957263,
0.030894462,
0.0035153357,
-0.0307274517,
-0.0162526406,
0.0075447322,
-0.0118513303,
-0.103781715,
0.0230906848,
0.0494613685,
-0.0277316682,
-0.0306416843,
-0.0507770032,
-0.0334230028,
0.0154380072,
0.0222001001,
0.025604371,
-0.0037428993,
0.0141994674,
0.0247779954,
0.0048538926,
0.0273185205,
0.0674078241,
-0.0033554391,
-0.0779949203,
0.0300662592,
-0.0346055403,
-0.0214998797,
-0.0690022036,
0.0412774831,
-0.0301965009,
-0.0244677421,
-0.0406277105,
0.0414613746,
0.030949207,
0.0138689699,
0.0142327417,
-0.0203493629,
0.0059618978,
-0.0048823869,
-0.0055265753,
0.0116305836,
-0.0208531804,
-0.0146234874,
0.030420512,
-0.0040865862,
-0.0099414708,
0.0168580934,
-0.0023330359,
0.0199178569,
-0.0363088734,
-0.004893932,
-0.0417932793,
-0.0036159796,
-0.0267140996,
-0.0388579406,
-0.0067239725,
-0.0172313731,
-0.0442122295,
-0.0710915476,
-0.0200159624,
0.0125655187,
-0.0176985934,
0.0105912825,
-0.0049175471,
0.0137830367,
-0.0411172137,
0.0088153109,
-0.0638764203,
0.0394838862,
0.040077202,
0.0034334103,
0.0024907971,
0.0383327119,
0.0399685614,
0.0206813533,
0.0306176469,
0.0072116083,
0.0257475674,
0.0385421105,
-0.0424764752,
0.0129204346,
0.0083140815,
-0.0189424604,
-0.0174549539,
0.0046929163,
0.0365567207,
0.0636735484,
-0.0513834208,
0.0797796026,
0.061514128,
0.0545620956,
0.0453865044,
0.000183657,
0.0837702528,
0.0459726192,
0.0613071918,
0.0898808688,
-0.0079208892,
-0.0071300641,
-0.0333296396,
0.0734334737,
0.0552855618,
0.0014115155,
-0.0094894245,
-0.0532310717,
-0.0044588083,
0.0234484971,
-0.0037912792,
-0.029413553,
0.01010672,
0.0310097747,
-0.0541013964,
0.0087694423,
0.0019936587,
-0.0594892725,
0.0177504979,
-0.0148608871,
0.019108884,
0.1164177805,
0.0539650209,
-0.0221074596,
-0.0171778779,
-0.0058480361,
0.0366279036,
0.0276206955,
0.0458578393,
-0.0343674123,
-0.0499558523,
-0.0408458933,
-0.0195595995,
0.0042613139,
-0.0007617185,
0.0063722674,
0.0001176727,
-0.0434006043,
0.0201346315,
0.0333951563,
-0.0439145938,
0.0322743803,
0.0021773174,
0.0109302448,
-0.0251124483,
-0.0113604702,
-0.0103244875,
0.0272942521,
-0.0352406576,
0.0304131843,
-0.0078525562,
-0.0112093361,
0.0021381471,
0.017619051,
-0.0220965352,
-0.0177837331,
0.0184559152,
-0.0028728636,
-0.0001232012,
-0.0321892388,
-0.0079052076,
-0.0525268503,
-0.0354659446,
-0.0314642638,
-0.0212633535,
-0.0314771831,
0.0702094585,
-0.0183688439,
-0.0373717025,
-0.0543995239,
0.0267205928,
0.0140790949,
-0.0170147792,
0.065875724,
0.0111294389,
-0.0006801511,
-0.0287935268,
-0.0142198438,
0.0051703956,
0.0227221064,
-0.0034554158,
0.0451100506,
0.0294224732,
-0.0172057468,
-0.0425739326,
-0.1104378849,
-0.0132808248,
-0.0280831959,
-0.0007142437,
0.0464294329,
0.0005804504,
-0.0337628052,
0.0054788287,
0.0079722432,
-0.0516487882,
0.0380633287,
0.0404231958,
0.0424565338,
0.0129883252,
0.0004775704,
-0.0425675325,
-0.0247859061,
0.0134275556,
0.0400407836,
0.0364862196,
-0.048341129,
-0.0641913489,
0.036316134,
-0.0119929854,
-0.0355972052,
0.0351570286,
0.0088075167,
-0.0078747747,
-0.0056660143,
0.0749915242,
0.0057883351,
0.0444597825,
0.0054216716,
0.0569706857,
-0.0009547437,
-0.0022652459,
-0.0149936108,
0.0071602706,
0.0095755309,
0.0140723679,
-0.0460576639,
0.045446422,
0.0434339456,
0.0362249836,
0.0203190185,
-0.033632759,
0.0460256301,
-0.0383352488,
-0.0036001424,
-0.0427478068,
-0.0770579055,
-0.0148795089,
0.0599588752,
-0.0293007512,
-0.015183609,
0.0740608349,
-0.0366804674,
0.0283088274,
-0.0537032709,
0.0048920438,
-0.0304239132,
0.0274859443,
-0.0003260461,
0.0069606244,
0.0108072106,
-0.0122776208,
-0.0325723626,
-0.031112425,
0.0637323931,
-0.0026032387,
0.0921540782,
-0.0869018883,
-0.0058655888,
-0.0330916718,
0.0003504736,
-0.0158285219,
-0.0352415927,
-0.0328529626,
0.0306148846,
0.0314757712,
0.0243125558,
0.0145747578,
0.0592611879,
0.0429665074,
0.0891054794,
-0.0395929366,
-0.0275841132,
-0.0119917812,
0.0467878431,
0.0429169983,
-0.0264916942,
0.0192543827,
-0.0458029099,
0.0845840499,
0.0252192393,
0.0318183154,
0.0161360651,
0.0152609497,
-0.0256861039,
-0.0024109199,
-0.1075170189,
-0.0308107119,
0.0201307703,
0.050112348,
-0.0527219325,
-0.0103742685,
0.1201197132,
0.0232349187,
-0.0374379382,
-0.0165426657,
-0.00914142,
0.0243885107,
0.0025654987,
0.0206724107,
-0.0411740728,
0.0140960356,
0.0300386511,
0.0397341438,
0.0013007657,
-0.0154885929,
-0.0253301878,
-0.0776735693,
0.0543550812,
-0.0074497107,
-0.0304004997,
0.0016356471,
-0.0322443247,
0.0037173843,
0.0428383537,
0.0072990828,
0.0649503395,
-0.0509820208,
0.0259670131,
0.0173558462,
-0.0879511312,
0.010384175,
-0.0498820096,
-0.0341078043,
-0.0228495132,
0.0567954779,
-0.0018033051,
0.0135256173,
0.0459365062,
0.0814945027,
-0.0328071266,
0.0360938907,
-0.0316105783,
0.0264580939,
0.0291596986,
0.0488107055,
-0.0312017445,
0.0050624693,
0.0552883074,
-0.0209646653,
0.0392477214,
0.0081661381,
-0.0112797646,
-0.0016590792,
-0.0293351226,
0.0530439131,
-0.0354870632,
0.0397539586,
0.0617967956,
-0.0457576066,
-0.0317554921,
-0.0304172784,
-0.0135165052,
-0.0651238933,
-0.0288785063,
-0.007253164,
-0.0477858298,
0.006742937,
-0.0793835372,
-0.052573517,
0.0197761338,
0.025533786,
0.0267125573,
0.0153112374,
-0.013206468,
0.0161428526,
0.0114067113,
-0.0078430204,
0.012683182,
0.0015737234,
-0.044035878,
-0.0038461338,
0.0149539784,
-0.0329453535,
-0.0094652409,
0.0047545214,
-0.0579245538,
-0.0315036997,
-0.0090947114,
0.0322928429,
0.0268070921,
0.0459483899,
0.0135315778,
-0.0295549985,
0.0318476334,
0.0023807595,
0.0189269334,
0.0472143367,
-0.024761945,
0.0789965466,
-0.0190385934,
-0.0045910226,
-0.0467883348,
0.0241748206,
-0.0255863946,
0.0357010886,
-0.0029208765,
-0.0949559435,
0.0035630071,
0.0434391014,
0.009241512,
-0.0072602886,
0.0058598504,
-0.0489089265,
-0.0081159314,
-0.0301906262,
-0.0370614007,
-0.0403736904,
0.0597687177,
-0.0123263467,
-0.0078926971,
0.0053436593,
0.0557508878,
-0.0385231562,
0.0205751415,
-0.0545340143,
0.0084438268,
-0.0262256339,
-0.004227241,
-0.0074924072,
-0.0258326475,
-0.0526021942,
-0.0019701619,
-0.0383305103,
-0.0192821641,
-0.0062205973,
0.049113512,
0.0186839886,
-0.0051967269,
-0.00792081,
0.0532351546,
-0.0720752403,
-0.0058224122,
-0.0329295546,
0.0279013235,
0.0271693822,
-0.006230684,
0.0912904888,
-0.0223694593,
-0.0038813425,
-0.0181516986,
0.0293421075,
0.0545610413,
-0.0171120632,
-0.0357843004,
0.0335929878,
0.0119975489,
-0.0154781397,
0.0618543439,
-0.0344430804,
-0.0126198148,
0.0123096481,
-0.0482286327,
-0.0369132794,
-0.0494574048,
-0.0447574183,
0.003966758,
-0.0107191959,
-0.0528998896,
-0.0757818222,
0.0244073812,
0.0372425653,
0.0166969746,
0.0203560609,
-0.0414374992,
0.0364148729,
0.0321134664,
-0.0047024111,
-0.0187421795,
-0.0548323877,
-0.0028612632,
0.0201843679,
-0.0017992421,
-0.0295533836,
-5.419053202e-33,
-0.0507997274,
-0.0245247465,
-0.0028136212,
0.0189583544,
-0.0718775988,
-0.0118925814,
-0.0719431415,
-0.0053603388,
0.0605734102,
-0.0002621305,
-0.0383157693,
-0.0200311113,
0.0166885387,
-0.0069119325,
0.0116097759,
0.0394678675,
0.0793100074,
-0.0168018024,
-0.0615858622,
0.0108024096,
-0.0052432357,
0.0150788985,
-0.0227356739,
-0.0048867944,
0.0359268226,
-0.0320577882,
-0.0412832163,
0.0041386522,
0.034058731,
0.0232233852,
0.0243289024,
-0.0012230347,
0.038815219,
-0.0585283078,
-0.057545606,
0.0241753366,
-0.0509612672,
0.0007274235,
0.0410731211,
-0.0216182284,
-0.0366744064,
-0.0407703333,
0.0324486233,
-0.0236642696,
-0.0109627899,
-0.0050501442,
0.040938504,
-0.0477489121,
-0.0421398096,
-0.0646374002,
-0.0429684184,
0.0286143906,
-0.0146468459,
-0.0420809016,
0.0266969875,
0.0727495328,
-0.0132461051,
-0.0261678882,
-0.0256734304,
0.046840366,
0.0708618686,
0.0350410454,
0.0325494334,
0.0228906665,
-0.0042786165,
0.0275939144,
0.0015034911,
0.0164529961,
-0.0542081855,
0.0189879704,
-0.0097871358,
-0.0214266889,
0.0357735083,
0.0266946256,
-0.0042509758,
0.0245215967,
-0.0062994123,
0.0622603148,
-0.0327038914,
0.0079787802,
0.0327523686,
-0.0148247834,
0.0276175849,
-0.0311708972,
-0.071420759,
-0.007087816,
-0.008745051,
-0.0084750028,
0.0003814386,
0.0132122198,
-0.0468950756,
-0.0443973951,
0.0158822741,
0.0249467716,
0.0071991859,
0.0006542259,
-0.0296773892,
0.0827513561,
-0.0201717168,
-0.0276413187,
-0.0041880109,
0.0253429022,
0.0200911257,
0.028872475,
0.0059775449,
0.0127206249,
0.0300499499,
-0.0115675963,
-0.0395607091,
0.0235725418,
0.0129804341,
0.0449194387,
-0.0182750281,
0.0214734599,
0.0015293981,
-0.0269609168,
0.0059247944,
0.0443161987,
0.0178038888,
-0.0491314419,
-0.0315153413,
0.0595062077,
0.0140234102,
0.0209621489,
-0.0041595651,
0.0457427166,
-0.0134095019,
0.0461087711,
0.0190317165,
-0.0156887062,
-0.0129377311,
0.023100378,
2.51e-7,
0.0329019502,
0.0427458659,
0.0728033632,
-0.0080966875,
0.0072488147,
-0.0124379806,
-0.0006658501,
-0.0206363983,
0.0362016484,
0.0140395733,
0.0398498252,
0.0185333472,
0.0485540293,
0.0184987448,
-0.1107542813,
-0.0244144667,
-0.0825648382,
0.0067481808,
-0.0575233512,
-0.0276953913,
0.0374980755,
0.0061327424,
-0.02600725,
0.0042571179,
-0.0194918793,
-0.0204836335,
0.025180351,
-0.0048125382,
-0.017676184,
0.0646919608,
0.0614866577,
-0.0326323658,
0.0023612645,
0.0168139357,
-0.0030310743,
-0.0302182976,
0.0476221591,
0.0602487735,
0.0291167032,
0.0415088087,
0.0248253457,
-0.0156979263,
0.0294394381,
-0.0287562348,
0.0489767194,
-0.0394089818,
0.0376598425,
-0.0320289545,
-0.0124462936,
-0.0307812206,
-0.0125063425,
-0.0032243177,
-0.0117965695,
0.0794316605,
-0.0161517393,
0.0186945163,
0.0033015674,
-0.0529989786,
-0.0774166211,
0.0089972541,
-0.0061421613,
-0.0321918763,
-0.009509285,
-0.0192175023,
-0.021125624,
-0.0968351141,
-0.0099491701,
2.737853306e-34,
0.0800875276,
-0.0180742163,
0.0169537794,
-0.0068916422,
0.0120137706,
-0.012892535,
0.0078865252,
0.0027448654,
0.0139390845,
-0.0851905346,
-0.032520093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00497v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00497v1
|
Recent Advances in End-to-End Simultaneous Speech Translation
| 2024-06-01T16:56:19 | 2024-06-01T16:56:19 |
Xiaoqian Liu, Guoqiang Hu, Yangfan Du, Erfeng He, YingFeng Luo, Chen Xu, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Simultaneous speech translation (SimulST) is a demanding task that involves
generating translations in real-time while continuously processing speech
input. This paper offers a comprehensive overview of the recent developments in
SimulST research, focusing on four major challenges. Firstly, the complexities
associated with processing lengthy and continuous speech streams pose
significant hurdles. Secondly, satisfying real-time requirements presents
inherent difficulties due to the need for immediate translation output.
Thirdly, striking a balance between translation quality and latency constraints
remains a critical challenge. Finally, the scarcity of annotated data adds
another layer of complexity to the task. Through our exploration of these
challenges and the proposed solutions, we aim to provide valuable insights into
the current landscape of SimulST research and suggest promising directions for
future exploration.
|
[
-0.0000919712,
-0.0111834351,
-0.0114813494,
-0.017642891,
-0.0332775302,
0.0047920821,
0.0586942434,
-0.0299986936,
-0.0567287542,
-0.0065059755,
-0.0259336047,
-0.0311081782,
0.0468656048,
0.0157730542,
0.0157681461,
-0.0699165836,
0.0525093973,
-0.0305948853,
-0.0088208122,
-0.001337246,
-0.014676393,
0.0059013171,
-0.0352649353,
0.027554201,
-0.0278216582,
0.0198221337,
-0.0011634539,
0.0272495262,
0.0264456943,
-0.0017636028,
-0.0370730832,
-0.0177487824,
0.0433214307,
0.0634532496,
0.0000018741,
-0.0204901118,
-0.0351989567,
0.0312959254,
-0.0017917351,
-0.0142751541,
0.0596000142,
-0.0170550682,
-0.0159223918,
0.0660759434,
-0.0186301842,
0.0031089787,
0.0680272654,
-0.0282837432,
0.0491609871,
0.0469528399,
-0.0255125929,
-0.0401106365,
-0.0043284153,
-0.048365254,
-0.0341045968,
0.0014462387,
-0.0444416553,
0.0068046269,
0.0029754697,
-0.0188289843,
-0.0058319275,
0.1243307441,
0.0304745082,
-0.0378887206,
0.0113747856,
-0.0214794651,
-0.0218362343,
-0.0303183366,
-0.031894654,
0.0542169958,
-0.0679139644,
0.0245189108,
-0.0021231363,
-0.0026008654,
-0.021323951,
-0.0680359676,
-0.0323101841,
0.0285982862,
0.0001021044,
-0.0334942825,
-0.0097639635,
0.0534857102,
0.0238449723,
-0.0488047041,
-0.0360273458,
-0.0183931738,
0.0203173552,
-0.0171101894,
-0.0240294952,
0.0073083015,
-0.030364858,
-0.0079134721,
0.0909435377,
0.0064176326,
-0.0198208429,
0.0210533794,
-0.0285334736,
-0.0740661845,
-0.0273376238,
-0.0406147614,
0.0168947615,
0.0702421665,
-0.0204946343,
0.0044896775,
-0.0000780239,
0.0186702609,
-0.0194519721,
-0.0006682257,
-0.0551899411,
-0.0299010444,
-0.012373792,
0.0292318724,
-0.0543050207,
-0.0233755112,
-0.0842413232,
-0.0216756798,
-0.0279165152,
0.0165644903,
-0.0020537167,
0.0067814123,
0.0094425464,
-0.0200739354,
-0.0884077251,
-0.0330530405,
0.0553078316,
0.0774158984,
0.0324170738,
0.0358329192,
0.0030834919,
-0.0411608964,
-0.0294643752,
0.0383374058,
0.0038461969,
-0.0103995064,
-0.0492651835,
0.0549548119,
-0.0095051257,
-0.0222254265,
-0.0032181186,
-0.0151235908,
-0.0127225984,
-0.0257635508,
-0.002081003,
-0.0452448092,
0.0608659387,
0.0058242423,
0.036389783,
0.0076393853,
0.0017598671,
-0.0346408002,
0.0323142074,
0.088704586,
-0.0064647216,
0.0448766798,
0.0334738605,
0.0255707055,
-0.000176123,
0.0514962673,
0.0638594329,
-0.0032597706,
0.0095698079,
-0.013245835,
-0.038561862,
0.1004696488,
0.0092216572,
0.0396394692,
-0.0257675946,
0.0200242121,
0.0036279659,
0.0671861619,
0.014999168,
0.0233094227,
-0.0330511853,
-0.0029567201,
0.0804611221,
0.0157939997,
-0.0114212986,
0.0065510538,
0.0857523382,
0.024640739,
-0.0008178733,
-0.0180919897,
0.0200979933,
0.0052694897,
0.0384144373,
0.0037120315,
0.0419571251,
0.0263097696,
-0.0090356134,
-0.0063997698,
0.012142227,
-0.0266269296,
-0.0246060323,
0.0216964148,
0.0126551734,
-0.0094713131,
-0.0270985886,
0.0401129276,
-0.0325119235,
-0.071378842,
0.0247483831,
-0.0235183183,
-0.0793977603,
0.0710831508,
0.0206160862,
0.014441045,
-0.0333659872,
-0.0737672076,
-0.0145015689,
0.0639960319,
0.0290732142,
0.0030511946,
0.0703397319,
-0.0356714725,
-0.0117515502,
0.0720065013,
-0.0011743861,
0.0311193261,
-0.0129074687,
0.0439864732,
0.0309529379,
0.0608942285,
0.0024951012,
-0.0053676809,
-0.0573597364,
0.0286501832,
0.034233842,
-0.012500654,
0.0170285795,
0.0201689471,
-0.0329642966,
0.0024565759,
0.0020883519,
-0.0390652083,
0.0229764003,
0.0652924329,
-0.0291279107,
-0.0357831419,
0.0276452936,
-0.0644699186,
0.0020834415,
0.0418452062,
0.01670973,
-0.083774738,
-0.0163860228,
-0.013775032,
0.0164754763,
-0.0001562999,
0.0326180644,
0.0181562267,
0.0035676768,
-0.0189022459,
-0.045119267,
0.0196266975,
-0.0077952156,
0.0806863829,
-0.0243732166,
0.0085970657,
-0.087821126,
0.0124539193,
0.0354366973,
0.0325929113,
0.0244833156,
-0.0059151975,
0.0029764315,
-0.01560059,
-0.0299443454,
-0.0919858068,
0.0249435473,
-0.0043703164,
0.0185960382,
0.0423912331,
0.0404672176,
-0.007932378,
-0.000811717,
-0.0295057688,
0.0095691951,
0.031231232,
-0.0193844624,
-0.0606498867,
-0.0333174318,
-0.0229109004,
-0.0016277852,
0.007716578,
0.0392579474,
-0.0059171068,
0.0082837166,
-0.0519785024,
-0.0598573536,
-0.0265467055,
0.0183148794,
0.0028948176,
0.0297308061,
-0.0099892616,
-0.0154431742,
0.016708849,
0.0214365125,
-0.0143332221,
0.0278858598,
-0.0027438463,
0.0135308467,
-0.0717242062,
-0.0441360213,
0.0276430752,
-0.0130507573,
0.0200319067,
-0.0221931189,
-0.0017935799,
-0.0060735899,
0.0102409925,
0.0385260135,
-0.0036183419,
-0.0521622188,
-0.0563988574,
-0.0278568119,
-0.0366011858,
-0.0159506109,
-0.0160706472,
-0.0167630091,
-0.0051660733,
0.0012431259,
-0.0561438799,
-0.0318788849,
-0.0666100234,
-0.0435009524,
-0.0621469691,
-0.0127752526,
-0.0081904223,
0.0566197112,
-0.0397191644,
0.0037939516,
-0.0765205771,
-0.0138918683,
-0.0155516611,
0.0395709611,
-0.0126630096,
-0.068519339,
-0.011195669,
-0.0455440842,
-0.0036225466,
-0.0139735639,
-0.0112118684,
-0.0087484652,
0.0096381381,
-0.0026541052,
-0.0023287942,
0.0354254693,
-0.0631745979,
-0.0456872918,
0.0169555116,
0.0147539768,
0.0706793293,
-0.0104855541,
-0.0095213121,
-0.0154256076,
0.0270461868,
0.0089582847,
0.0323013887,
0.0312974751,
-0.0153429704,
0.0098554241,
-0.0086640548,
0.0585163087,
0.0006234358,
-0.0523907728,
-0.0296944696,
0.043458052,
0.0054478748,
-0.038237337,
-0.0367346406,
0.0378800035,
-0.0508836806,
0.0241333824,
0.1057262644,
-0.0056310995,
-0.0323159546,
-0.0056391875,
0.0142587274,
-0.0053169969,
0.0228159633,
0.0132768955,
-0.0751006082,
-0.0273026358,
0.0298806001,
0.0655281246,
0.0332270674,
0.0281519853,
-0.0625054166,
-0.0335094668,
0.0668510199,
0.0571951643,
-0.0340498053,
-0.0308865849,
0.0352894478,
-0.0436154604,
-0.0076871011,
0.0474048257,
-0.0072023817,
0.0082658101,
0.0026119172,
0.0193773489,
0.0172666833,
-0.0054637981,
-0.0060185906,
-0.0045516347,
0.0957588255,
-0.0007350192,
0.022860555,
0.0362324305,
-0.0295301192,
0.0597364642,
-0.0225990359,
-0.0248844586,
0.0007123756,
-0.0286184121,
-0.0005867828,
-0.0283023324,
0.0217330307,
0.006934437,
-0.0304733627,
0.0529314391,
0.025227394,
0.0345438719,
-0.0247267596,
0.0601999238,
-0.0066573475,
0.0069234371,
0.0524648912,
0.0289779864,
-0.0142082637,
-0.0211496577,
0.0163158327,
0.0006844916,
-0.0369076878,
-0.0417447649,
-0.0333333723,
0.0172184333,
-0.0130485846,
-0.0537931994,
-0.0487790443,
0.0051141158,
0.0073503167,
0.0656390116,
0.0165187884,
0.0102766203,
0.0137795489,
0.0233881827,
-0.0195935387,
0.0005509148,
-0.0191081557,
0.0428129919,
-0.0225487053,
0.0095564704,
0.0225109197,
-0.0489026234,
0.0031791697,
0.0665546581,
-0.107472755,
-0.0475337729,
0.0221344605,
-0.0190574713,
0.0238429941,
0.0644405559,
-0.0619094633,
0.0092937546,
-0.0043930151,
-0.005724303,
-0.0708511695,
-0.0108921267,
0.0492348,
0.0055604358,
-0.0178288855,
0.0402215607,
0.0047593541,
0.0321306214,
-0.0441471264,
0.0331019573,
0.0346028395,
-0.0590405166,
-0.0045067086,
0.0665574968,
0.0313430987,
0.0099499198,
0.0008405893,
-0.0087811388,
0.0380652212,
-0.0144006601,
0.0422249027,
-0.0835411921,
-0.0113608968,
0.0127250236,
-0.0081219058,
-0.006700228,
-0.0107777314,
0.0226843264,
-0.0799927786,
0.0202401821,
0.0005567568,
-0.0381979197,
-0.0118693318,
-0.0021458205,
0.0231934376,
0.006976455,
0.0567664206,
0.0123993633,
0.0023310722,
-0.0332047381,
0.005203845,
-0.0013839629,
0.0200206488,
0.0296022538,
0.0112445857,
-0.0323294327,
-0.0472771414,
-0.0214516781,
0.016222138,
0.0416087396,
0.0410930403,
0.1364532709,
-0.0118569499,
0.0241983514,
-0.0370345525,
0.0618621856,
-0.0309396349,
-0.0115104951,
-0.0538186468,
-0.0332847163,
-0.0139883887,
0.0296708904,
0.0287827682,
-0.0556846932,
0.0093546351,
-0.0221948903,
-0.0459238254,
0.0030097181,
-0.0436571166,
-0.0267881639,
-0.0404327288,
-0.0181731787,
-0.0374670438,
0.0040565906,
-0.0445535369,
0.0036261547,
0.0312371012,
0.0187096149,
-0.0228595287,
0.0040686987,
0.0292727146,
-0.0497083254,
0.0136118429,
-0.0204302389,
-0.0188881643,
0.0070573809,
-0.0034771978,
0.0229909141,
-5.661092264e-33,
-0.0261189807,
0.0184912402,
0.0299344976,
-0.0486652479,
-0.0834348947,
-0.0087240515,
-0.0205997042,
0.0062788897,
0.023270024,
0.0034522326,
0.0086801937,
0.0350133032,
0.0379661098,
-0.0108002648,
-0.0053797127,
0.0223082863,
0.0690968484,
-0.0172720533,
-0.0154584143,
0.0478784032,
0.0781739205,
-0.0130414544,
0.0410296135,
-0.0821217149,
-0.0043646833,
0.0302613415,
-0.0141037265,
0.0122594209,
-0.0214364138,
-0.0162452515,
0.0114583615,
0.0238025133,
-0.0148204966,
-0.0543381087,
-0.04688216,
-0.0192612857,
-0.0810368806,
0.02948994,
-0.0061025582,
0.0473734066,
-0.0443833917,
0.0002541802,
0.0438085347,
0.0025999427,
0.0110662766,
-0.0496273749,
-0.0212007668,
-0.0601824597,
-0.0145603204,
-0.0605559349,
-0.0308206677,
0.0389936157,
-0.0645492449,
0.0094164191,
0.0606158897,
0.0746128634,
-0.0180459823,
-0.0666135624,
-0.0284876619,
0.043859452,
0.0075648595,
0.0234556869,
0.0629879981,
-0.0271346103,
0.0067586079,
-0.0017810873,
0.0466902666,
-0.0509946197,
0.0663808957,
0.0046996903,
0.0329273455,
-0.0077223466,
0.0551247336,
-0.0198635422,
0.0174718872,
-0.0364472605,
-0.0082665794,
0.0015246409,
0.0249411799,
-0.0458586104,
0.0246948767,
-0.0061942986,
-0.0129204113,
0.0376184471,
-0.0462317877,
0.0165192876,
0.0201548338,
-0.0148778995,
0.0349747762,
0.0380949974,
-0.0046213134,
0.0133527163,
0.1070095301,
0.0225452837,
0.0350759998,
-0.0473667793,
-0.0205882937,
0.0115212286,
-0.0291934498,
0.0341917947,
0.0075737969,
-0.0043841088,
0.0257633366,
0.0289801881,
-0.0007219773,
-0.0416000225,
-0.0011104811,
0.0922831446,
-0.0228322018,
0.0044138236,
-0.0188837815,
0.0610464253,
-0.0065149693,
-0.0128867775,
0.0581145771,
-0.0428302288,
0.0027132237,
0.0065550725,
-0.0051613823,
-0.01307684,
0.0028767642,
0.0067862761,
0.0269133113,
0.0322970897,
-0.0691612959,
0.0367539674,
-0.0155142043,
-0.0214226134,
0.0329229832,
-0.0402219072,
-0.0344275795,
-0.023498375,
2.6e-7,
0.0119061777,
0.0182876103,
0.0137008084,
0.0097192042,
0.0500969402,
-0.0188893899,
-0.0126089072,
0.0266074743,
-0.0015075268,
0.0573161878,
0.027050307,
-0.0072922078,
0.1195463911,
0.0197718143,
-0.057477463,
-0.0747385025,
-0.0288939532,
0.0619292855,
-0.0172111727,
0.036848098,
0.0627884865,
0.0520196408,
-0.0253510848,
-0.0089538563,
0.0283056833,
-0.0128546599,
0.032486055,
0.0077663083,
0.0248887148,
-0.0639500767,
0.0340290442,
-0.0031993364,
-0.0520684235,
0.0179039203,
-0.0209971275,
0.0132657541,
0.0483263284,
0.0698571876,
-0.002325542,
-0.0139376083,
0.0159192681,
0.0079310806,
-0.027027579,
0.0056742849,
0.0400632657,
-0.0364338607,
0.0140714981,
-0.0097535606,
-0.0056144232,
0.0201002918,
-0.0103970477,
0.0121951038,
0.0139507102,
0.0071399775,
0.009734422,
0.0098036844,
-0.018792104,
-0.0447217561,
-0.0126016932,
-0.0347608663,
-0.0503760427,
-0.0360600054,
-0.0541346855,
0.0385367908,
0.0083009843,
-0.019512454,
-0.0205609649,
2.200868201e-34,
0.0514181666,
-0.0231192242,
0.0263971537,
-0.0191866588,
-0.0113323573,
-0.0561554916,
0.0080786161,
0.0127784843,
-0.0116904266,
-0.006402106,
-0.0878840238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01633v1
|
On Overcoming Miscalibrated Conversational Priors in LLM-based Chatbots
| 2024-06-01T15:54:45 | 2024-06-01T15:54:45 |
Christine Herlihy, Jennifer Neville, Tobias Schnabel, Adith Swaminathan
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We explore the use of Large Language Model (LLM-based) chatbots to power
recommender systems. We observe that the chatbots respond poorly when they
encounter under-specified requests (e.g., they make incorrect assumptions,
hedge with a long response, or refuse to answer). We conjecture that such
miscalibrated response tendencies (i.e., conversational priors) can be
attributed to LLM fine-tuning using annotators -- single-turn annotations may
not capture multi-turn conversation utility, and the annotators' preferences
may not even be representative of users interacting with a recommender system.
We first analyze public LLM chat logs to conclude that query
under-specification is common. Next, we study synthetic recommendation problems
with configurable latent item utilities and frame them as Partially Observed
Decision Processes (PODP). We find that pre-trained LLMs can be sub-optimal for
PODPs and derive better policies that clarify under-specified queries when
appropriate. Then, we re-calibrate LLMs by prompting them with learned control
messages to approximate the improved policy. Finally, we show empirically that
our lightweight learning approach effectively uses logged conversation data to
re-calibrate the response strategies of LLM-based chatbots for recommendation
tasks.
|
[
0.0643912479,
0.0345782116,
0.0010273642,
0.0106419707,
-0.0095786974,
-0.0042439164,
0.011059491,
-0.0038454023,
0.0505264588,
-0.055110652,
-0.0480431244,
-0.0077142976,
-0.0265823025,
0.0307335909,
-0.0069187665,
-0.0250883438,
-0.0103941578,
-0.0492202826,
0.0099594714,
-0.0244263336,
0.0232827421,
0.0169289913,
-0.0026189459,
0.05044448,
-0.0156664364,
-0.0121556986,
-0.03953778,
-0.0045222077,
-0.0361785665,
0.0059332815,
0.0240289383,
0.0365885869,
0.0241173897,
-0.0220056195,
0.0000018725,
-0.025650043,
0.002384468,
-0.0540831685,
-0.0211216658,
-0.0371620879,
0.0549813807,
0.0535859056,
0.0236422066,
0.033289969,
-0.0576174818,
0.005858656,
0.0244050864,
0.0553874373,
0.0182521176,
0.070247978,
0.0013064246,
0.0468855686,
-0.0051518893,
-0.0279819686,
0.0527659059,
-0.0597418062,
0.0032403676,
-0.0036847563,
0.0364429504,
0.0419227444,
-0.0233015865,
-0.0182051007,
-0.014535103,
-0.0468510948,
0.0330673493,
0.0197443105,
-0.0310185477,
-0.0269065071,
0.0027711582,
0.1033336893,
0.0394363925,
-0.0222457536,
0.0157019328,
-0.0093674138,
0.0181112234,
-0.0046028448,
-0.0547010675,
-0.0175486486,
0.0147106228,
0.006407795,
-0.0237509385,
-0.0385561101,
0.0403258912,
-0.0074511236,
0.0125269359,
0.0887070522,
-0.0236647017,
-0.0401119888,
0.0081882644,
0.0028222995,
0.0120265819,
-0.088904202,
0.0017382841,
0.0408995301,
-0.0771427155,
0.0124379471,
-0.0105852839,
0.0478634834,
-0.0153744677,
-0.0358437225,
-0.0132075483,
0.0368336476,
0.004523138,
0.0571417287,
0.0353320651,
0.0164273083,
-0.0018779988,
0.0189825445,
-0.0563531294,
-0.0132380556,
-0.0186904054,
0.0163116474,
-0.0043691332,
0.0328372009,
-0.0204113908,
-0.0355721675,
-0.020972643,
0.0697067529,
-0.0151028642,
0.0311993901,
-0.0073791845,
0.0600749142,
-0.0208034441,
0.0000636288,
-0.0941689536,
-0.0010345003,
-0.030193653,
0.0326059945,
0.0167107899,
-0.033670906,
-0.0041607418,
0.041277349,
0.0021398729,
-0.0254661478,
-0.0047900286,
0.0608533882,
0.0164820198,
-0.0262543391,
0.0045297239,
-0.0241740514,
-0.0019733603,
-0.0638682544,
-0.0238853954,
-0.0267836414,
0.0481254421,
0.0410577431,
0.0042285123,
-0.0205055177,
0.019571254,
0.007857454,
-0.0496768914,
0.0791286603,
0.0184585974,
0.0065292395,
0.0018147794,
0.0104100797,
-0.0378186926,
0.0439999476,
0.0259285308,
0.0630444959,
0.0403515249,
0.0024756459,
0.0360916629,
0.0151532562,
-0.0029695705,
0.0085724192,
-0.013009063,
0.0224258918,
-0.0244247522,
0.0198868867,
0.0389681049,
0.0379921347,
-0.0574075915,
-0.0138231097,
0.053931646,
0.0371309109,
-0.0317250714,
0.0303873066,
0.0216815099,
0.0387996919,
-0.0096893981,
0.0286657326,
-0.0396521911,
0.0352888405,
-0.0101181148,
-0.070006229,
0.0759676695,
-0.0526999533,
-0.0401154123,
-0.0406203605,
0.0398446918,
-0.0450745039,
0.0277723167,
0.0388921648,
0.0277222898,
-0.0151429363,
-0.016453281,
0.028961597,
0.0400632396,
0.0074609811,
-0.0180204902,
-0.0294514839,
0.0457180291,
0.1036053672,
0.0746979788,
-0.0364962853,
-0.0024926115,
-0.0128204394,
-0.00445069,
0.0062822886,
0.0718466416,
-0.037315242,
0.0000201581,
-0.0416035317,
-0.0408422276,
0.0061253151,
0.0047944793,
-0.000750027,
-0.006080335,
-0.0179001167,
-0.006899639,
-0.0324248523,
-0.0168410465,
-0.0128528373,
-0.0081926957,
-0.0328329094,
0.0140982261,
-0.0142134344,
0.0520812832,
-0.0209668241,
0.0337416939,
-0.0137725631,
0.0101722404,
0.010326989,
-0.0301109254,
0.0187124778,
-0.0288236532,
-0.02270771,
0.0417483784,
0.0029677355,
-0.0100957323,
0.0121358298,
-0.0211230461,
-0.0389962383,
0.0090283398,
-0.0094531141,
0.0598609895,
-0.0121796913,
0.0039279149,
0.0103803137,
0.0093160914,
-0.023863472,
0.0210327581,
-0.0099884523,
-0.0053739795,
0.0102501782,
-0.0104003008,
-0.0240934789,
-0.0445144102,
-0.0034733892,
0.0178981442,
0.0379112028,
0.0045399107,
0.0384978838,
0.0018637826,
-0.0281029381,
-0.0165400729,
-0.1081084013,
-0.0081730261,
0.0004852991,
-0.0276333019,
-0.0071366085,
0.0375451036,
0.0201300997,
-0.0394122265,
-0.0650580972,
0.0337978341,
-0.0058963262,
0.029348461,
0.039977923,
0.031403169,
-0.0089041824,
-0.0701569021,
0.0182842351,
-0.0016518875,
0.0067739142,
0.009622179,
0.0246403012,
-0.0642016381,
0.0204275828,
-0.0428653806,
0.0355410166,
-0.0531698912,
0.0061639021,
0.0124255819,
-0.0229695216,
0.0296637788,
0.0694312081,
0.0355432481,
0.0363960899,
0.0654445812,
0.0159279555,
-0.1117033213,
0.0351184793,
-0.020186428,
-0.0433548801,
-0.0758189037,
-0.0196393058,
0.0010975614,
0.010522237,
-0.0433955938,
0.0228144787,
-0.0857446194,
0.0256394744,
0.0369844176,
-0.0439587645,
-0.0245644562,
0.0159329567,
-0.013623734,
0.0594902448,
0.0273540989,
-0.0377850868,
0.0835407227,
0.0063886065,
-0.0020750649,
-0.0070950706,
-0.0627943352,
-0.0327364653,
-0.0075735529,
0.0254824404,
0.0107980082,
-0.0499289855,
-0.0014014248,
-0.0783632323,
-0.0200697463,
0.0271415859,
-0.0458972231,
0.0230227709,
-0.028470315,
0.0128792254,
0.0225447621,
-0.0604342408,
-0.0523947664,
-0.0738981813,
-0.0217198525,
-0.0299536046,
0.0299700685,
-0.0398757979,
-0.0662512705,
-0.0122493906,
-0.0056716851,
0.0338281356,
-0.003459913,
-0.0255169589,
0.0074172099,
-0.0334701166,
0.0602017157,
-0.003981303,
0.0104095191,
-0.022229271,
0.0356555767,
0.0357082747,
0.034581244,
-0.0409104563,
-0.018000504,
-0.0133589013,
0.0500252657,
0.0305053778,
-0.0088724727,
0.0335698389,
0.0460358039,
0.0188645404,
-0.0301450416,
0.1029845104,
0.0168189332,
-0.1013027579,
0.0149159888,
-0.0126095721,
0.0332597569,
-0.0014841626,
0.0464757606,
-0.0631302372,
-0.0226847343,
0.0165280066,
0.0671316683,
-0.0133410878,
-0.0679069534,
-0.0248452257,
-0.100488916,
0.0121752266,
-0.0183474403,
0.0104893045,
0.0063543846,
-0.0371510498,
0.0068838247,
-0.0448468365,
0.0210883152,
-0.018677596,
-0.0031299558,
0.0078519164,
0.001921221,
-0.0309441071,
-0.0219049379,
0.0302586351,
-0.010364186,
0.0747865066,
0.0220854022,
0.0348093882,
0.0354472883,
0.0312654264,
0.0753422752,
0.0459409319,
-0.016155405,
-0.0075276815,
0.0311220158,
-0.0364901982,
0.0006510839,
-0.0127693154,
0.0334140696,
-0.0207682084,
-0.0126356175,
0.0004271041,
0.0327246971,
-0.0573596507,
0.0116161536,
-0.0047411863,
0.0375564992,
0.0364413895,
0.0679076165,
0.0207154546,
-0.0732990056,
-0.040221598,
-0.0797018558,
-0.0431882106,
0.0301089268,
-0.0179478657,
-0.0211624335,
0.0078821061,
0.0250376426,
-0.0545877889,
-0.0517342053,
0.0158513989,
0.0068201176,
0.0193711761,
0.0222774036,
0.0062871934,
-0.0068708616,
0.0628137961,
0.0299289003,
-0.0422429182,
-0.0170563292,
-0.0457735658,
-0.0163459573,
0.0253811758,
-0.0662722066,
-0.0037453691,
-0.0094693052,
-0.0731820688,
-0.0624217838,
-0.0245738998,
0.0574547388,
0.0297240317,
0.0555252507,
-0.0401537456,
-0.0813101232,
-0.0164815541,
0.0655306876,
-0.0407140851,
-0.0193469524,
0.0055773789,
0.0680811033,
-0.0013406283,
0.0558363125,
-0.0837134346,
-0.010116918,
0.0009561478,
0.0281756036,
-0.0512043796,
-0.0670167431,
0.0416140556,
-0.0048350873,
0.0174210351,
0.0108111594,
0.029055465,
-0.0008741532,
0.0252684541,
-0.0085142134,
-0.0407779813,
-0.0486106426,
-0.0133771058,
0.029661756,
-0.013348477,
-0.0075877816,
-0.0131505812,
-0.0419332311,
0.0498965606,
-0.0115575287,
-0.0104518291,
0.0378612354,
-0.0650771037,
0.0525525175,
-0.012032331,
0.0073433579,
0.0229797121,
0.0342678986,
0.0559170879,
0.0200105719,
0.0506543256,
0.0200421307,
-0.0327121839,
-0.0090744756,
-0.0007907312,
-0.0602853037,
-0.112372227,
0.0081277499,
0.0646765456,
0.0172205996,
-0.0326468237,
0.0166728254,
-0.0345647708,
0.0170335453,
-0.0391536243,
0.0130897062,
-0.0046504354,
0.0043095094,
0.0392386131,
0.0343795568,
-0.03263174,
0.0565722249,
0.0818943828,
0.0166338272,
0.0357835889,
-0.022263946,
-0.0314604864,
-0.0262544658,
-0.0179563854,
-0.0084106205,
0.0458141342,
-0.0316662788,
-0.0000768581,
-0.0155600533,
-0.0574244373,
-0.0697402805,
-0.0163169429,
-0.0168727804,
-0.0682350248,
0.027648773,
0.0484583601,
-0.0114219692,
0.0134866601,
-0.0738048181,
0.0017660437,
-0.0085427584,
-0.0137779871,
-0.0369046777,
-6.457980823e-33,
0.0049473848,
-0.0330497772,
0.0250495095,
0.0416167192,
0.0047599897,
-0.0365890265,
-0.0091257347,
0.0188136566,
0.0075588487,
0.0109667648,
-0.0397208445,
0.0330755301,
0.0076197581,
0.0056646727,
0.0130630778,
-0.0437853262,
0.051576443,
-0.011225773,
-0.039133586,
0.0388650186,
0.0643962994,
0.0296138041,
-0.0158515871,
-0.0734476149,
0.0339274071,
-0.0320309661,
-0.0113113476,
0.044980485,
0.0102132484,
0.0500146002,
-0.0058857156,
0.0318587422,
0.0149277272,
0.0111739198,
-0.0016363526,
0.0072072898,
-0.0438243598,
0.0042340592,
0.0367823206,
0.0149055338,
-0.0007709723,
-0.0058765751,
0.0007985287,
-0.0051421658,
-0.0003758138,
0.0261524208,
0.0249472149,
-0.0234061405,
-0.040570531,
0.0203702133,
0.0275543462,
-0.0085647795,
-0.0315083414,
-0.0448955782,
0.0031804226,
0.0813631788,
-0.0038103885,
0.0519355088,
-0.0224727262,
0.0319499448,
-0.0272046812,
0.0042461865,
0.0197651722,
0.0023914387,
-0.0099457381,
0.0434554107,
0.0327737071,
0.0365609862,
-0.0072865919,
-0.0398602486,
-0.0215996765,
0.0543314405,
-0.0253240131,
0.0275529195,
0.0027416931,
-0.0037872849,
-0.029790733,
0.0323559754,
0.0448204577,
0.0096588833,
0.0402454883,
0.0257558227,
-0.0459654592,
-0.0404658541,
-0.0345688649,
0.0099067958,
-0.046353884,
-0.0231906809,
0.0170259103,
0.0549423248,
0.0095614586,
-0.0398329422,
0.034783341,
-0.0700156987,
-0.0457959734,
0.0130842803,
-0.0264269598,
-0.0291528311,
0.0087290136,
0.018265577,
-0.0578746386,
-0.0313463286,
0.0399324298,
-0.0407827161,
-0.0372522809,
0.0315207653,
0.011006264,
0.0150440009,
-0.0276211202,
-0.0241573974,
-0.0287311412,
0.0071469038,
-0.0285365582,
0.0261641759,
0.0476437248,
0.0257409513,
-0.032736484,
0.0645469278,
-0.0178023279,
0.0253219213,
-0.0106723197,
-0.0657926127,
-0.0086717419,
-0.0272506997,
-0.0433316976,
-0.0316145346,
-0.0091910642,
-0.0020302723,
0.0387062766,
-0.0427114703,
-0.0089897811,
-0.0059966785,
2.724e-7,
0.0034639349,
0.0361674018,
-0.039066907,
0.0035609128,
0.0299705379,
0.071257621,
-0.008094321,
0.0454318523,
0.0268580709,
-0.0240980275,
0.0479480289,
0.0343775637,
0.0520207696,
0.0173441004,
-0.0687468797,
-0.0312591642,
-0.0424792618,
-0.0270661321,
-0.0281314831,
-0.0412202366,
0.0120383613,
0.0748414621,
0.0271193516,
-0.0010164649,
0.0130797094,
-0.0237116814,
0.0750149116,
-0.0800190791,
-0.0593271852,
0.0135338493,
0.0645845383,
0.0314018615,
0.0186684839,
0.0018747578,
-0.0000237922,
0.0145825911,
-0.0073091481,
0.0698875934,
0.0318251252,
-0.0473299026,
-0.0101638744,
0.0147961853,
0.0227690525,
-0.0217682626,
0.0622622147,
-0.0172098242,
-0.0309645925,
-0.0425586104,
0.0136709893,
-0.03430406,
0.03714047,
-0.0124872671,
-0.0065382374,
-0.0019553725,
0.0034294908,
-0.0009685919,
0.0052157794,
-0.0533742681,
0.0175596885,
0.0076583019,
-0.0625414178,
-0.0682799071,
-0.0321251415,
0.0368553549,
0.0191995911,
-0.0022578556,
0.0409492813,
2.038563885e-34,
0.0485332794,
0.037096262,
-0.0180040561,
0.0276404209,
0.0331697613,
0.0088433847,
0.0247584693,
0.0104759848,
0.0659305677,
-0.0732645988,
-0.010124268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00456v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00456v1
|
Mix-of-Granularity: Optimize the Chunking Granularity for Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-01T14:45:03 | 2024-06-01T14:45:03 |
Zijie Zhong, Hanwen Liu, Xiaoya Cui, Xiaofan Zhang, Zengchang Qin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Integrating information from different reference data sources is a major
challenge for Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) systems because each
knowledge source adopts a unique data structure and follows different
conventions. Retrieving from multiple knowledge sources with one fixed strategy
usually leads to under-exploitation of information. To mitigate this drawback,
inspired by Mix-of-Expert, we introduce Mix-of-Granularity (MoG), a method that
dynamically determines the optimal granularity of a knowledge database based on
input queries using a router. The router is efficiently trained with a newly
proposed loss function employing soft labels. We further extend MoG to
Mix-of-Granularity-Graph (MoGG), where reference documents are pre-processed
into graphs, enabling the retrieval of relevant information from distantly
situated chunks. Extensive experiments demonstrate that both MoG and MoGG
effectively predict optimal granularity levels, significantly enhancing the
performance of the RAG system in downstream tasks. The code of both MoG and
MoGG will be made public.
|
[
0.0432161577,
0.0190348178,
0.0111398492,
-0.0123819225,
0.029370008,
0.0032428661,
-0.0127154766,
0.0007435048,
-0.0052323225,
-0.0466463454,
0.0090025729,
0.0217883121,
-0.0207550097,
0.0139330328,
0.0235772673,
-0.0528614298,
0.0296862815,
0.0138244135,
-0.0022819219,
0.0014953006,
0.0060083834,
0.0312171448,
0.0058797617,
0.0125006633,
-0.0447559282,
0.042386815,
-0.0354864746,
0.0512091108,
0.0135059217,
-0.0358245075,
0.0195224565,
0.0246016774,
0.0136637781,
0.0233547259,
0.0000022384,
-0.0219510645,
-0.0430245101,
0.0334930122,
-0.0237047393,
-0.0335214473,
-0.0192300323,
-0.0149329146,
0.0325926915,
-0.0074412641,
-0.019445762,
-0.0267341025,
0.0420206189,
0.066494897,
0.0434416197,
0.0960814282,
-0.0106110414,
-0.0171757638,
0.0107559785,
-0.01972178,
0.072736688,
-0.0469749644,
-0.0087173274,
0.0487315059,
0.0118833799,
0.0291381665,
-0.0042659417,
0.0482782014,
-0.0145740472,
0.0048411684,
0.0510530211,
0.0261227097,
-0.0142238857,
0.0115194144,
0.0137625914,
0.0797645673,
-0.0153220352,
-0.0236212071,
0.037028987,
-0.0119708534,
0.0005083315,
0.0507421307,
-0.0263544321,
-0.0265585538,
-0.0464549959,
0.0225035213,
-0.0883589908,
-0.0066784653,
0.0211372841,
-0.006825814,
0.0008385829,
0.0111567434,
-0.0113506392,
-0.0187897254,
0.0158113223,
0.0281275269,
0.0517528728,
-0.0000948753,
-0.014019127,
0.0442735627,
-0.0308095682,
0.0204224437,
-0.0365690626,
-0.0021902684,
0.0473145619,
0.0072001363,
0.0045873667,
-0.0022020366,
0.0082384739,
0.0409465246,
-0.0265739597,
-0.0251954161,
-0.0176290143,
-0.0244915746,
-0.0525309704,
-0.0254084114,
-0.0771568939,
-0.0191465672,
-0.0546512753,
0.0737546831,
-0.0179041922,
-0.0228144936,
-0.0402883738,
0.0267612282,
-0.0538725182,
0.0113386745,
0.01323976,
0.0387191102,
-0.0434590802,
0.0037186597,
-0.046444498,
0.0208857581,
-0.0477780476,
-0.0059572365,
0.0312122721,
-0.023625873,
0.0061551365,
0.0030962205,
0.0343336836,
-0.0016821098,
-0.0101862345,
0.0301951505,
-0.0143583957,
-0.0047974088,
-0.07804095,
-0.0919803977,
0.0192533657,
-0.051507622,
0.015795866,
-0.0715699419,
0.0699433014,
0.0127386227,
-0.0277323686,
-0.0325940996,
0.0042150118,
0.0180589147,
-0.0569511093,
0.0302039813,
-0.0458264463,
-0.0031638283,
0.0223686509,
0.0136679802,
0.0049541844,
0.0722471476,
-0.0117255542,
0.0189246535,
0.0217362437,
0.0287676901,
-0.0020876888,
-0.0207089502,
0.0420602299,
-0.0063427454,
0.016285697,
-0.0133479824,
-0.0041078972,
0.0231022146,
0.0364956968,
0.0384612754,
-0.0659997091,
0.0349894911,
0.0146026202,
-0.0578153096,
0.062240921,
0.0073656966,
0.0681775659,
0.0313465521,
-0.0101466235,
0.0416513234,
-0.0039454959,
0.0122996205,
-0.0364094302,
0.0322680622,
0.0623923875,
0.0179194789,
-0.034496475,
-0.0220182538,
0.0196723361,
0.0067717382,
0.0066610822,
-0.0014379822,
0.0439851433,
0.0465772077,
-0.0464681797,
0.0630168021,
0.0255046394,
-0.0242819767,
0.0216474012,
0.0160329305,
-0.0063603572,
0.0483679734,
0.0569059215,
-0.0332968682,
-0.0429357812,
0.032708887,
-0.0167558342,
-0.0033160427,
0.0405227989,
-0.0316279046,
-0.0331017189,
-0.0752950907,
-0.0667160675,
-0.0261334609,
-0.0009707934,
0.0364854224,
0.0278736483,
0.0357906818,
0.0724917874,
-0.033257436,
-0.0404314436,
-0.0092457617,
-0.0060389489,
-0.040193975,
-0.0002990527,
0.0012705639,
-0.0281414539,
0.0107853655,
-0.0247907266,
0.0116276974,
0.0502067208,
0.003510871,
-0.0221545342,
-0.0293462984,
-0.0153589463,
-0.0301952325,
-0.0118480753,
-0.0185864661,
0.0266890638,
-0.0956013426,
-0.0681508929,
-0.0622494519,
-0.0102073057,
-0.0538101457,
-0.001445763,
-0.02689787,
-0.0345346928,
0.0484273694,
-0.0065518329,
-0.0564575121,
0.0782387108,
0.0105456561,
0.0093901567,
0.0404450148,
0.0043836315,
0.0375247486,
-0.0488198362,
-0.0082278,
0.0038932308,
0.0011225163,
0.0348754711,
0.0523832254,
-0.0195625331,
-0.0727030113,
-0.043649435,
-0.0766308531,
0.0098221228,
0.0240234081,
-0.0029436655,
-0.0106856097,
0.0227118861,
0.0192025993,
-0.029055465,
-0.0443780236,
0.0367108025,
-0.0126005635,
0.0143376123,
0.005512483,
0.0625461861,
0.0227176547,
0.0127160577,
-0.0285922401,
0.006834731,
0.0186292138,
0.025907794,
0.0201636404,
-0.0541534014,
-0.0428420417,
-0.0595700629,
0.0048048347,
-0.004550227,
0.0297933016,
0.0074196579,
-0.0281467922,
0.0418404788,
0.0173929725,
-0.0050166468,
-0.0013409461,
0.02114252,
-0.049419038,
-0.0659220889,
0.0278745685,
-0.0524589457,
0.0034925586,
-0.0085908407,
-0.0351699702,
-0.0144073069,
-0.0059517045,
0.0154509945,
-0.0085107842,
-0.0400338471,
0.0126875918,
0.0397946984,
-0.004839424,
-0.0451113172,
-0.0215999223,
0.0205717459,
0.0000100862,
-0.0123392958,
-0.0067158686,
0.0583028048,
-0.0100809922,
0.0262701046,
0.0012928608,
-0.0153599856,
-0.0390657894,
0.0233871341,
0.0121493302,
0.0281760283,
0.0028340218,
-0.0029268665,
-0.0696674958,
0.0268765017,
0.0449026898,
-0.0493988097,
0.0161911529,
-0.0041614948,
0.0262131523,
0.0067977142,
-0.0192374662,
-0.0379261263,
0.024581505,
0.0517345667,
0.034557078,
0.0534246191,
-0.0213625506,
-0.0524621271,
-0.0049358867,
0.0358203053,
0.0142187634,
-0.0086473599,
-0.0319757834,
-0.017108297,
0.0652963296,
0.0600583218,
0.0026943954,
-0.0117770424,
0.0218629502,
-0.0588871278,
0.0495437533,
0.0302108098,
-0.0481336378,
-0.0070962585,
0.0030195976,
0.0176719353,
-0.0047258451,
-0.0309933461,
0.004668925,
0.0293658432,
-0.0681566373,
-0.0108378539,
0.0410937667,
0.0140120452,
-0.0289737433,
-0.0280226599,
0.0170651227,
0.0548969582,
0.016610153,
0.0580559,
-0.097762391,
-0.0207510628,
-0.0110029643,
0.0650378391,
-0.0072011016,
-0.0304112975,
0.0110636139,
-0.1240850687,
0.0218565762,
0.0107132634,
-0.0021852062,
-0.0037246307,
-0.0573748872,
-0.0436361879,
0.0180328675,
-0.0604998358,
0.0191047788,
-0.0213795453,
0.0073452797,
0.0368420668,
0.0407905951,
-0.0524443388,
-0.0412498116,
-0.0158726685,
0.0449269377,
0.0032941906,
0.0220510941,
0.0360818729,
-0.0107325548,
0.0383375026,
-0.0326868407,
0.0273531061,
-0.0177570861,
0.0738057345,
-0.0055099884,
0.0217596535,
-0.0029941059,
-0.0279155821,
0.0276662167,
0.008662669,
-0.0358569734,
0.084461689,
-0.0089064296,
-0.0081630228,
-0.0550305583,
-0.015610435,
0.0346115083,
0.038983956,
0.012686356,
0.0341652483,
-0.036495477,
-0.0232218299,
0.0306789111,
-0.0345472135,
0.0032444745,
0.035376478,
-0.0885487869,
-0.0610394627,
-0.084016189,
-0.0331996866,
0.0064635444,
0.0455397666,
-0.0016754135,
-0.0019828577,
-0.0044430303,
0.0006663303,
-0.0835828483,
0.0050459774,
-0.0109287472,
-0.0404182822,
-0.0509015024,
-0.0632580146,
0.0288004447,
-0.0530793704,
-0.013655779,
0.0490740463,
-0.0163188726,
-0.0756364912,
-0.0255490188,
0.0525467061,
0.020760892,
0.0857081562,
0.0043113674,
-0.0438850783,
0.1230307966,
0.1220352873,
-0.0440239906,
-0.0151051478,
0.0072032642,
-0.0227379687,
-0.02755039,
0.003465513,
-0.1074696332,
0.0110570658,
-0.0551207438,
0.0388559178,
-0.0252309628,
-0.0079621412,
0.0186021961,
0.0184641145,
0.0075762537,
-0.0022622957,
0.0110314814,
-0.0375663117,
0.0122252051,
0.0030195678,
-0.0292184353,
-0.0470081568,
-0.003792088,
0.0007619451,
-0.0311062336,
0.0417778827,
0.0160889942,
0.037222594,
0.0668503493,
-0.0264309887,
-0.0509102307,
-0.0011542679,
0.0150400912,
0.0453247391,
-0.0119697582,
-0.0212729387,
0.0255128257,
0.0068362262,
0.0397910252,
-0.0325431265,
0.0175978672,
0.0559386238,
0.0035577356,
-0.0192239434,
-0.00913464,
-0.0592292994,
-0.0196442492,
-0.0488159806,
-0.0145731959,
0.0233835112,
-0.0083654551,
0.0416240878,
-0.0129879387,
-0.0251899138,
-0.0134323081,
0.016227534,
0.0255442001,
-0.031726528,
-0.0004791251,
0.0446141586,
0.0021510047,
0.0141993994,
0.0921095312,
-0.0014437218,
0.0330102518,
-0.0637718588,
-0.0563852079,
-0.0388547331,
-0.0245756935,
-0.0031170882,
0.0482240841,
-0.0127155734,
-0.0009931516,
-0.0314908512,
-0.0379130691,
-0.000327842,
-0.0087191239,
0.0012989984,
0.0145019842,
0.0625028759,
0.0336613469,
0.0027993345,
-0.0106269801,
-0.0295840837,
0.0218139142,
-0.0542045161,
-0.0008901692,
0.0236364007,
-7.136696568e-33,
-0.0321947969,
-0.0632519424,
0.0423557051,
-0.0282951687,
-0.0384458788,
0.0258846674,
-0.0238622408,
-0.0098924767,
-0.0114192981,
0.0073611061,
0.0068189022,
-0.0131606683,
0.0096333027,
0.0238164701,
0.0142462654,
-0.013021552,
0.0574154668,
0.0378165394,
-0.0095850509,
0.063227199,
0.0736312717,
0.0345087051,
0.0316738598,
-0.0946084559,
0.0065425364,
0.0050555994,
-0.003218052,
0.0026355812,
0.0395143777,
0.0544937365,
0.0056420742,
0.0490103662,
0.0137112327,
0.0026891737,
-0.0047444496,
-0.023629766,
-0.1037182435,
-0.0429982133,
-0.0174629819,
-0.0181151256,
-0.0283242986,
-0.0294798855,
0.0436987653,
-0.0363031998,
0.0404374972,
-0.0279910024,
0.0502338968,
-0.0050976472,
-0.0546449907,
-0.0764181465,
-0.0057286439,
0.0238607693,
0.0070243655,
0.02240468,
-0.0047618616,
0.0088404994,
0.0394140966,
-0.0072748014,
-0.0741824657,
0.0195146073,
-0.0074359821,
0.0726728812,
0.0302211978,
0.0120086661,
0.0029752564,
0.0378678031,
0.0147629129,
0.015375373,
-0.0125131607,
-0.0323377587,
-0.0018684805,
0.074613899,
-0.0236593094,
0.0132701183,
0.0604426451,
-0.0208788905,
-0.0281448252,
0.0531559959,
-0.0303018335,
0.0470997989,
-0.0108839357,
0.0068593174,
-0.0282874964,
-0.0172063001,
-0.0063574878,
0.0195667781,
-0.0408351682,
-0.0301315878,
0.0149734477,
0.059523236,
-0.0158687662,
0.0537131801,
0.0077098063,
-0.0025437467,
0.0034825644,
0.0567799769,
-0.0370328724,
-0.0051265103,
-0.0223803576,
-0.0294400007,
-0.0340953395,
-0.0846592486,
0.0563388392,
-0.0277949404,
-0.0107390722,
0.0483582914,
0.062439207,
0.0355545394,
-0.047197111,
0.0167263858,
-0.0312908553,
0.0107915131,
-0.0203769151,
-0.0618529432,
0.0192454327,
0.0380375795,
-0.0198975056,
0.0121430457,
0.0423818752,
0.0545079187,
0.0294649731,
-0.0077032126,
0.0136683565,
0.0150390361,
-0.0202772208,
0.032551337,
-0.0247784387,
-0.0217130836,
0.023358237,
-0.0373243764,
-0.0247832984,
0.0390639603,
3.152e-7,
0.0269152839,
0.028062325,
0.0427349471,
0.0123011339,
-0.0317010544,
-0.0111178597,
0.029768046,
0.0285488591,
0.0023793664,
-0.0162711293,
0.0341404229,
0.0024708302,
-0.0021274376,
0.0448356085,
-0.1091543138,
0.0006730267,
-0.008957536,
-0.0281873494,
-0.0434277914,
0.0044262037,
0.0217788815,
0.0179755837,
0.0211791471,
-0.0085748425,
0.0264121741,
-0.0495735891,
0.0508880205,
0.0364226699,
0.0330732688,
0.0363349281,
0.0994710252,
0.0250305124,
-0.025094362,
0.0253470819,
-0.0402085744,
0.0128345974,
0.0033315381,
-0.0117372302,
0.0014912728,
-0.0399847962,
0.0480103642,
-0.0679947734,
0.0043662298,
-0.0064363712,
0.0465757661,
-0.0044445363,
-0.0023219641,
0.0661469847,
-0.0556376912,
-0.0116276853,
-0.0152778579,
-0.0137006016,
-0.0268571693,
0.0015505853,
0.0006592002,
0.0156292692,
-0.0071492484,
-0.0551004857,
0.0024947296,
0.0534675308,
-0.0077464595,
-0.0416721031,
-0.0247252639,
-0.0222678501,
0.0171603058,
-0.0719292909,
0.0179438945,
2.971568904e-34,
0.0479540266,
0.0219504517,
-0.0166705158,
-0.0166076738,
0.0506728142,
-0.0155959688,
-0.0697150454,
0.0307864361,
0.0156419165,
-0.0703714341,
-0.0395387895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00393v1
|
Gender Bias Detection in Court Decisions: A Brazilian Case Study
| 2024-06-01T10:34:15 | 2024-06-01T10:34:15 |
Raysa Benatti, Fabiana Severi, Sandra Avila, Esther Luna Colombini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Data derived from the realm of the social sciences is often produced in
digital text form, which motivates its use as a source for natural language
processing methods. Researchers and practitioners have developed and relied on
artificial intelligence techniques to collect, process, and analyze documents
in the legal field, especially for tasks such as text summarization and
classification. While increasing procedural efficiency is often the primary
motivation behind natural language processing in the field, several works have
proposed solutions for human rights-related issues, such as assessment of
public policy and institutional social settings. One such issue is the presence
of gender biases in court decisions, which has been largely studied in social
sciences fields; biased institutional responses to gender-based violence are a
violation of international human rights dispositions since they prevent gender
minorities from accessing rights and hamper their dignity. Natural language
processing-based approaches can help detect these biases on a larger scale.
Still, the development and use of such tools require researchers and
practitioners to be mindful of legal and ethical aspects concerning data
sharing and use, reproducibility, domain expertise, and value-charged choices.
In this work, we (a) present an experimental framework developed to
automatically detect gender biases in court decisions issued in Brazilian
Portuguese and (b) describe and elaborate on features we identify to be
critical in such a technology, given its proposed use as a support tool for
research and assessment of court~activity.
|
[
0.0601368248,
0.072643213,
-0.0373704694,
0.0032641569,
-0.0536011234,
0.0339932367,
0.0361191109,
-0.00918674,
-0.0010083023,
-0.0633425787,
0.0568179898,
-0.0083593782,
0.0221801847,
0.0086974688,
-0.0296831094,
-0.0459152311,
0.0003909751,
0.0472389758,
0.0444479957,
0.005235882,
0.0250358712,
0.0157090556,
0.0066335858,
0.0402021743,
0.0155005902,
0.0345108174,
0.0201344863,
-0.0215617586,
-0.0351852104,
0.003693331,
-0.0155720608,
0.0791122764,
-0.027990235,
0.0104669062,
0.0000015363,
-0.1127907038,
-0.0118772611,
0.010505056,
0.0285278503,
-0.0299873259,
0.0487900339,
-0.0512434095,
-0.0492050387,
0.0184676293,
-0.0590117089,
0.001475247,
-0.0011657436,
-0.0178019926,
0.038843248,
0.0480105951,
-0.0010774304,
-0.0256695021,
-0.0204781629,
-0.0021757353,
-0.0044947169,
0.015456304,
0.0268272068,
-0.0194965266,
0.0074237427,
-0.0163193755,
0.033383403,
-0.0005745799,
-0.0210000537,
-0.0246595815,
-0.0506541729,
-0.0286925547,
-0.043595843,
-0.0400259979,
0.0145170754,
-0.0005851228,
0.0601399802,
0.0067458712,
0.0243099872,
0.0125130033,
0.0639105663,
0.0301656369,
-0.0212233588,
0.070537515,
-0.0449656211,
-0.0116146337,
0.0325566977,
0.0257397369,
-0.0185502078,
0.0561654307,
-0.0189429987,
0.0613577925,
-0.023336431,
-0.0440026671,
0.0377507359,
0.0198557526,
0.048874367,
-0.045463495,
0.0373703912,
0.0172630176,
0.006427607,
0.0343191735,
0.0070365747,
-0.0785022676,
0.0714796931,
-0.0946446583,
-0.0026151789,
0.0048052934,
-0.0099953357,
0.0365728773,
-0.0103797037,
-0.013185339,
0.0117288949,
0.000609145,
0.0010652613,
-0.0437679105,
-0.0302416068,
-0.0086047547,
-0.0096053975,
0.0120171309,
-0.0711572245,
0.0679771453,
-0.0434123725,
0.004066288,
-0.0494846106,
0.0217700098,
-0.0112233395,
0.0120889265,
0.0201023221,
0.0182642415,
-0.0612128563,
-0.0340738185,
-0.0466329418,
0.0395861194,
-0.0612573661,
-0.0450686328,
0.0428063981,
0.0080061741,
0.0077182306,
0.0089629963,
0.0194926895,
0.048983641,
0.015783729,
-0.0418458097,
-0.0357330218,
-0.0600344837,
-0.0319340862,
-0.0706785619,
-0.0035101785,
-0.0526843257,
0.0027839921,
0.0330619328,
-0.0133580212,
-0.0439452156,
0.0124005368,
0.0422830433,
-0.0068556406,
0.0536281541,
0.014829793,
-0.031481117,
0.0330333002,
0.0178251453,
0.0139864841,
0.0374787562,
0.0183027107,
0.0046875612,
0.0378315412,
0.009860347,
0.0189334527,
0.0183369536,
0.0105693303,
0.0238018949,
-0.0166501757,
0.0383443981,
-0.046484556,
0.0077339914,
0.0368971676,
0.004359121,
0.0377230234,
0.0201768782,
0.0046581626,
0.0878173634,
-0.0130019914,
0.0783738047,
0.0193757396,
-0.0248395614,
0.0096160686,
0.0248235799,
-0.0457317308,
-0.0227269232,
-0.0143556967,
-0.0184240639,
-0.0488063209,
0.0334251784,
0.0105751492,
-0.0676770508,
0.0115788653,
0.0147615066,
0.0335310623,
-0.0192741416,
0.0334409624,
0.0266872067,
-0.0021928193,
-0.0229754392,
0.0129837515,
-0.0545808114,
-0.0246954467,
-0.0485652052,
0.0248478595,
0.0257870741,
0.0039160578,
-0.0578216352,
0.0358273797,
-0.0430711396,
-0.0075258715,
0.0258883722,
0.0178369191,
-0.00467399,
-0.0503838211,
-0.0163279567,
-0.0462089367,
0.0694778115,
0.0194348767,
0.0404437967,
0.0010316269,
0.0678204149,
0.0408005305,
-0.0295171402,
-0.0162127577,
0.0550418906,
0.0391027741,
-0.0105591035,
0.0133598512,
0.0177532285,
0.0266327802,
0.0431301706,
-0.0026773214,
-0.0163148567,
0.0113726733,
0.0086620636,
0.0068749124,
0.0203849766,
0.0193147566,
0.0424038991,
-0.0045164423,
-0.0828768983,
-0.0343682803,
0.0283996481,
-0.0140062943,
0.020547986,
0.0456473045,
-0.0150382631,
-0.0186883193,
-0.047641173,
-0.0042427364,
-0.0240425114,
0.0096545108,
-0.0129717998,
0.0217579491,
-0.021385707,
-0.0203113854,
-0.0285574589,
-0.0653529763,
0.0341352336,
-0.0396145917,
-0.0347509235,
-0.014798495,
-0.0094955619,
0.0135490252,
0.0378794782,
-0.0246215258,
-0.0148197943,
-0.0365013666,
-0.0500037,
0.007746933,
-0.027522264,
-0.0184409376,
-0.0106539726,
0.0148370592,
-0.0210639928,
-0.0182597376,
0.0132262511,
-0.0700367838,
0.0206807815,
-0.0021797766,
0.0362118222,
-0.0196750388,
0.0186406821,
-0.0170328077,
-0.0019380179,
-0.0626319274,
0.0630209744,
0.064466767,
-0.0510472432,
-0.0463054404,
0.0069518927,
-0.0255925525,
-0.0028461744,
-0.0240192749,
-0.0019502622,
0.0040199887,
0.0728801638,
-0.0280802995,
0.0687012225,
0.0624900721,
0.0226444565,
0.0505878069,
0.053277228,
0.0032703115,
-0.0289839357,
0.0091411611,
0.0641424432,
0.007358036,
-0.0330785066,
0.0415017828,
-0.0009517976,
0.0178333223,
-0.0123101147,
0.0139021948,
0.0563120916,
-0.0443615131,
-0.0159508381,
-0.0203815233,
-0.0510788374,
-0.0082370145,
0.0389782116,
0.0164719429,
-0.0217024311,
0.0325937606,
0.0252779257,
0.0714764595,
-0.0709703267,
-0.0116541842,
-0.0575892106,
0.0614930876,
-0.0034377384,
0.0163947344,
-0.0122205438,
-0.0201396123,
0.0181282014,
-0.0495280027,
0.0757877827,
-0.0302860867,
0.0360381827,
-0.0561262704,
0.0203197263,
-0.0152355144,
-0.049087476,
-0.0207769126,
-0.0366456099,
-0.0017440725,
0.0203900579,
0.0381284654,
0.0492506996,
-0.0211355034,
0.0415375307,
-0.0037108513,
0.0345748998,
0.0268270057,
-0.0204964541,
-0.0162375607,
0.0132072102,
-0.0351437964,
-0.049266506,
0.0198539067,
0.0011936231,
-0.0560555831,
0.0243449043,
-0.0283987243,
0.0143325897,
0.007851175,
0.0132724131,
0.000521765,
-0.0892355889,
0.0021425225,
-0.0320288315,
-0.0222335346,
-0.0463764817,
0.0524543002,
0.0792179629,
0.0332943611,
-0.0552602001,
-0.0143527072,
-0.0220603049,
-0.035375379,
0.0481799617,
0.0068844436,
-0.0977258757,
0.0500676669,
0.0032745101,
-0.0063258945,
-0.1027143151,
-0.0530300662,
-0.0286216065,
-0.0982281193,
0.0360386111,
-0.0078762481,
-0.0165218897,
-0.0406830013,
-0.0246266592,
0.0089943884,
-0.0295723267,
-0.0093641495,
-0.0020412842,
-0.0004480534,
0.0025838688,
0.0112024061,
-0.0852681696,
-0.0229923967,
-0.0086622443,
-0.075101465,
0.0255344976,
0.0460962988,
0.0679105893,
-0.0310464781,
0.0383411832,
0.0261287987,
-0.0066585573,
0.0035546103,
-0.0135744028,
0.0312643759,
-0.0137027837,
-0.0010538765,
-0.0611277074,
0.0491642952,
0.057248462,
0.0201315749,
0.0741534829,
0.0434578285,
-0.0234313067,
-0.0028274015,
-0.0585933141,
-0.0583311282,
0.0175189748,
0.0200259462,
0.0035784682,
0.0049980138,
-0.0533806682,
-0.0486805029,
-0.0039212317,
0.0027658551,
-0.0478038825,
-0.0069020474,
-0.008362052,
-0.0172213539,
-0.0164325554,
-0.0506679937,
-0.0012070206,
0.0046748891,
0.0195882972,
-0.0550121516,
0.0621077679,
0.0131285507,
-0.0900331736,
0.012161376,
-0.0056129154,
0.0103329765,
0.045997113,
-0.0190149341,
-0.0539962649,
0.0255925078,
-0.028736895,
-0.0063297851,
0.0343099013,
-0.0157237183,
0.0214934237,
-0.0200392101,
0.0247936137,
0.0090391636,
-0.0292256791,
-0.0308915656,
0.0496166162,
0.0231161229,
-0.0232150517,
-0.0100785522,
0.0307122953,
-0.0257702731,
-0.0114655541,
-0.0120479586,
0.0147078466,
0.0266544595,
-0.005857328,
-0.0142184021,
-0.0459311791,
-0.016249124,
0.0015407392,
-0.0027490631,
0.0441307127,
-0.0094592348,
-0.0356610492,
-0.0468120724,
-0.0239691697,
-0.0086398171,
-0.0337710045,
0.0049526207,
-0.0077774487,
-0.0162763875,
0.0362774655,
-0.0402876474,
0.0381243229,
-0.0878260285,
0.0029151901,
-0.0248395894,
0.0732787848,
0.0580504127,
0.0360520631,
-0.0159991533,
-0.0272957534,
0.0242698584,
0.0024668963,
-0.0074202386,
0.0612178519,
-0.0125509892,
0.0051408098,
0.0040224679,
0.0195785221,
0.0041710683,
0.0341375768,
-0.0060552787,
0.0409078561,
-0.0508216433,
0.0027667617,
0.0107322959,
-0.0231116265,
-0.0160304233,
0.0033323786,
-0.0027005977,
0.021963723,
-0.0090277232,
-0.0072517241,
0.0009347895,
0.0130900517,
-0.0083670635,
-0.0248584673,
0.0214415472,
-0.0091149509,
0.0158754177,
0.0243535433,
-0.0023050902,
-0.0638969094,
-0.0009946858,
-0.0437132269,
0.0146174375,
-0.0445569046,
-0.0268926341,
-0.0626882911,
-0.1075967997,
0.0012619875,
-0.0085710585,
-0.0036356947,
0.005727618,
0.0081271315,
-0.0230309032,
0.050665196,
0.0069479556,
-0.0073445532,
-0.0524778962,
0.0116175041,
-0.0303576887,
-0.0093428297,
0.004298219,
-4.473176244e-33,
-0.0308821052,
-0.0920532197,
-0.008406939,
0.0082566869,
0.0050435034,
-0.0300948694,
-0.0007274714,
-0.0087908106,
-0.0064723794,
0.0258427486,
0.0050006267,
0.0290736239,
0.0237447992,
-0.0422367826,
0.0245213751,
0.0246795472,
0.0057707503,
0.0052326079,
-0.0275789052,
-0.0367977805,
-0.0327901281,
0.0082386788,
0.0307089444,
-0.1109043285,
0.1059808359,
0.0218011495,
-0.0188103057,
-0.0151781505,
-0.024403993,
0.0351361148,
0.0006976529,
0.0331740789,
0.0178043973,
-0.0522664003,
0.0159688294,
0.0979742184,
-0.0541272387,
-0.0330687054,
0.0247643944,
0.0261570979,
0.0564857647,
0.0115340939,
0.0320644341,
0.0239577275,
-0.0548404008,
0.0240120329,
0.0740875453,
-0.0387570448,
0.0305759776,
-0.0375473425,
-0.0692036226,
0.0543105043,
-0.0358123779,
0.0320213549,
0.0068003908,
0.0102034835,
-0.0093508512,
0.0045734844,
-0.0660608634,
0.016397154,
-0.0261518247,
-0.035335809,
0.0133580398,
-0.0418287553,
0.010408855,
0.0290530268,
0.0428818129,
0.0060754395,
-0.0411868542,
-0.024100041,
0.0551585332,
-0.0004602937,
0.0678752363,
0.0883794129,
0.0532698929,
-0.0102276569,
-0.0755719244,
-0.0220139995,
0.0233080313,
0.0324290209,
0.0203399938,
-0.0633443221,
-0.062014129,
-0.0124721173,
-0.0302428603,
-0.0922140926,
-0.0093402723,
0.0107362112,
-0.0048661963,
-0.0109057585,
-0.0132895084,
0.0296940207,
-0.0321793929,
-0.0378053002,
-0.0015568743,
0.0159345809,
-0.016610533,
0.0073951832,
0.0058958633,
-0.01295962,
-0.0452637188,
-0.0142934034,
-0.0057512126,
0.0410482213,
0.0363957025,
-0.021863902,
0.0140373111,
-0.0456180014,
-0.0668582693,
-0.0161551293,
0.0200555455,
0.0518450364,
0.0110280383,
0.036568094,
0.0203041919,
0.0340041034,
0.0257853065,
-0.0101533607,
0.0499745831,
0.0221593603,
-0.0427120365,
-0.0077053681,
-0.007166015,
0.0075907647,
-0.0150635857,
-0.0168573037,
0.0234653912,
0.0700691417,
0.0229095444,
0.0194674563,
0.0217793602,
-0.0118136927,
2.165e-7,
0.0500743836,
0.0701355487,
-0.0121437842,
0.0098129706,
-0.0063238232,
0.0246913899,
0.0310408995,
0.0466540791,
0.0474790148,
-0.0108706104,
0.0226919111,
-0.0008570045,
0.0240101907,
0.0810679197,
-0.0761363208,
-0.0186878573,
-0.0140305199,
-0.0392011553,
-0.0450650491,
0.0679606572,
-0.0080002304,
0.0569199063,
0.0474792942,
0.0028682216,
-0.0580556802,
-0.0081424937,
0.016646916,
0.0206349716,
-0.009480427,
-0.0042899069,
0.0652289987,
-0.0203565601,
0.002676287,
0.0413814448,
0.0236669853,
0.0174983013,
-0.0310956668,
0.0227446295,
-0.0014075818,
0.0887485072,
0.0021742906,
-0.0654603317,
-0.0002114705,
-0.0245371182,
0.0512728281,
0.0316210166,
-0.0148452586,
-0.0479007326,
0.0063610915,
-0.040253453,
0.0662556589,
0.0139966756,
-0.0475658588,
0.0165360384,
0.0286838133,
0.002757058,
0.0228023157,
-0.0568149462,
0.0025774522,
0.0215023756,
0.0173563641,
-0.0331506617,
0.0288625937,
0.0536995195,
0.0600815974,
-0.039191898,
0.0734391958,
1.727907245e-34,
0.0109776044,
0.0138123827,
-0.010449593,
-0.0167241879,
0.0237759799,
0.0312589109,
-0.0153914224,
-0.0115351425,
0.0226423703,
-0.0078195203,
0.0567356758
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06558v1
|
Enhancing Text Authenticity: A Novel Hybrid Approach for AI-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-06-01T10:21:54 | 2024-06-01T10:21:54 |
Ye Zhang, Qian Leng, Mengran Zhu, Rui Ding, Yue Wu, Jintong Song, Yulu Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has ushered in an era
where AI-generated text is increasingly indistinguishable from human-generated
content. Detecting AI-generated text has become imperative to combat
misinformation, ensure content authenticity, and safeguard against malicious
uses of AI. In this paper, we propose a novel hybrid approach that combines
traditional TF-IDF techniques with advanced machine learning models, including
Bayesian classifiers, Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD), Categorical Gradient
Boosting (CatBoost), and 12 instances of Deberta-v3-large models. Our approach
aims to address the challenges associated with detecting AI-generated text by
leveraging the strengths of both traditional feature extraction methods and
state-of-the-art deep learning models. Through extensive experiments on a
comprehensive dataset, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method
in accurately distinguishing between human and AI-generated text. Our approach
achieves superior performance compared to existing methods. This research
contributes to the advancement of AI-generated text detection techniques and
lays the foundation for developing robust solutions to mitigate the challenges
posed by AI-generated content.
|
[
0.0658013448,
0.0969406962,
0.0043595368,
0.0722700357,
-0.0603420362,
0.012688742,
0.0329945087,
0.0045532435,
0.0096875485,
-0.024519328,
0.0040142802,
-0.0400984362,
0.0193609614,
0.0489152521,
0.0048367097,
0.0303798709,
0.0219894256,
0.0044299634,
0.0270471107,
0.0093981382,
0.0189791862,
0.0310873222,
0.0062340777,
0.0429165997,
-0.0542560779,
-0.0394019783,
0.019470552,
0.0184282344,
0.0244292505,
-0.0141116222,
0.0255474094,
0.0597977675,
-0.0215128772,
0.1144774482,
0.0000018955,
-0.0353551321,
-0.0356282443,
-0.0054713534,
-0.0547709987,
-0.0217000265,
0.0565290153,
-0.0124862464,
-0.0453822277,
0.0165422559,
-0.0414710976,
0.0032826397,
0.0311021488,
0.0908684731,
0.0322962701,
0.1020973697,
-0.0286801793,
-0.0019008758,
0.0687669367,
0.0252020322,
-0.0234270543,
-0.0164900664,
0.0249773432,
-0.014908269,
-0.0300362892,
0.0309752151,
0.0426714644,
0.0219531674,
0.0243367013,
-0.0541669503,
0.0085346848,
-0.0209868606,
0.010556845,
-0.0077433949,
-0.0130302338,
0.021508852,
-0.0530723184,
-0.0616688244,
0.0036169381,
-0.0081548914,
0.0022030126,
0.0164238308,
0.0134224007,
0.0507790521,
-0.0340385586,
0.0225638375,
0.026895022,
-0.0135834068,
0.0298067648,
0.0346780941,
-0.0093784109,
0.0313804075,
-0.0066024018,
-0.0501587093,
-0.0244278722,
-0.0082110185,
0.0013365714,
-0.0612716414,
0.0285230838,
0.0158024877,
0.0077698794,
-0.0116230184,
-0.0884227604,
-0.0901613608,
0.0193357784,
-0.0410766564,
0.0288326386,
-0.0034331961,
-0.032560952,
0.0255057253,
-0.0418194644,
0.0459232256,
-0.0245799664,
0.0190008767,
0.0124981757,
-0.0029785829,
-0.0268851593,
-0.00460013,
-0.0080751814,
0.0192824528,
0.0124512017,
-0.0240288787,
-0.0408313759,
0.0169377718,
-0.0022825957,
0.0390653387,
-0.0138659636,
0.0167872068,
-0.0288543943,
0.0000815326,
0.009752959,
-0.0362242684,
0.009497663,
0.0246679876,
-0.0216488317,
-0.063738279,
0.0021482403,
0.0628713444,
0.0255312808,
0.0049791057,
0.0019005515,
0.0176605228,
-0.0309721269,
-0.0428333804,
-0.0457546636,
-0.0568376705,
-0.0281046443,
-0.0263377987,
-0.0121862469,
-0.0625787601,
-0.0289911255,
-0.0429501794,
-0.0072202762,
-0.0766868964,
-0.0060051237,
0.026295675,
-0.0178069025,
0.0291409492,
-0.0160169937,
0.0055888528,
0.0541431196,
-0.0135391746,
-0.0092823021,
0.0027171755,
0.0448538512,
0.1133902818,
0.0545426682,
0.051297605,
0.0384695493,
0.0420046747,
0.0124135194,
0.0084387194,
-0.0171279758,
-0.0261133611,
-0.0356356241,
-0.0088598402,
0.0204296466,
0.049506966,
0.007600687,
-0.0410508364,
0.0962363109,
0.0522076115,
0.0026182511,
0.0301887635,
0.0238263663,
0.0555377901,
0.0200332943,
-0.003631989,
-0.012082234,
-0.0251803305,
-0.0289464053,
-0.0492089726,
-0.011007688,
0.0267587397,
0.0260338355,
-0.0223838184,
-0.0020435457,
-0.0345882624,
-0.0070092413,
-0.0126568265,
0.0364572071,
0.0028964498,
-0.0170892179,
-0.0785532966,
-0.0170345809,
-0.0170010068,
-0.0167162102,
-0.0747402161,
0.0562433787,
0.0443927124,
0.0464716889,
-0.0137667274,
0.0521452166,
-0.0450038016,
0.0128756957,
0.0689016581,
0.0035357168,
-0.0121652195,
-0.0208149832,
-0.0288422313,
-0.0354085527,
-0.0170516912,
-0.004292313,
0.0228123758,
0.0420732498,
0.0528537147,
0.0228677504,
0.016757533,
-0.0603340268,
0.0420403555,
0.0105535891,
-0.0376083963,
0.028805906,
0.0004183947,
0.0103504732,
0.0110162813,
-0.0533360653,
-0.0036555883,
0.0095974738,
-0.0266254023,
-0.0626424775,
-0.0320454799,
0.0146903731,
0.0198719949,
0.0097919432,
-0.0160598289,
-0.0235776827,
0.0474627465,
-0.0081931464,
0.013336557,
0.0035609673,
-0.0461568236,
-0.0486899093,
-0.0768395439,
0.0034297442,
-0.0399725586,
0.0404355228,
-0.0094623091,
0.0603995696,
-0.0126865646,
-0.0534826927,
-0.0059175072,
-0.0377893932,
0.0387732275,
-0.0009935074,
0.0086539751,
0.0070410674,
-0.018503869,
0.0301927272,
0.0266912226,
0.0244033206,
0.0121739777,
-0.0235297028,
-0.0845848545,
-0.0073437192,
-0.0349989161,
0.0123256221,
0.0065800813,
-0.0344206616,
-0.0066079656,
0.0230411962,
-0.0491622835,
-0.0755689815,
0.0195162967,
-0.0022900382,
0.0278087463,
-0.0519495383,
0.0133885499,
-0.0107103419,
0.0155701796,
-0.0189527813,
0.0633112863,
0.0369216874,
-0.0580501817,
-0.0234225225,
0.0092390515,
-0.0114038987,
0.0212777648,
-0.0007729917,
-0.0051578968,
0.0108487895,
0.0051347762,
0.0015118869,
0.0781385601,
0.0492528267,
0.0308928695,
0.0089857681,
0.0710467771,
-0.0176855084,
-0.0263712294,
-0.0167326555,
0.0475939624,
-0.0036866693,
-0.0589695908,
0.0485041961,
0.0022744969,
0.0227597896,
0.0144598531,
0.0041733873,
0.0303183161,
-0.0069678277,
-0.0430798009,
0.0017602876,
-0.0274227206,
-0.0183023829,
0.0333383083,
-0.0377732068,
-0.0681639314,
0.0437434129,
-0.0454757623,
0.0328023918,
-0.0358783901,
-0.0274574105,
-0.0025488469,
-0.0071032639,
-0.0113388663,
0.0513873473,
0.0135799572,
0.0121828821,
-0.0005397376,
0.0301289428,
0.0323094651,
-0.0445995443,
0.0024655815,
-0.0057440461,
0.0299459659,
0.0147854481,
-0.0090185357,
-0.0749062225,
-0.0550039709,
-0.0019033403,
-0.0171286464,
0.0014855057,
-0.0807436556,
-0.0133954044,
-0.0345482863,
0.0307879448,
0.0494048633,
-0.0458166637,
-0.0009089767,
-0.0192285553,
0.0901847184,
0.0339440592,
-0.0376330987,
0.0369924121,
-0.02820036,
-0.0258080009,
0.0620093793,
0.0121615585,
0.0279498585,
-0.0368176065,
-0.0411485881,
-0.002769385,
0.0067068762,
0.0153015917,
-0.0144541217,
-0.0005852896,
-0.0335153043,
0.0040359902,
0.0861764625,
0.0045885751,
-0.0425026044,
0.0013747406,
-0.0176683422,
-0.0188967828,
-0.0323542394,
-0.0129965451,
-0.0794840381,
-0.0273553301,
0.0246956851,
-0.0064780684,
-0.0585101508,
-0.0207599588,
-0.0082266862,
-0.0750180557,
0.0365822688,
-0.0059545566,
0.0126451897,
-0.0180267356,
-0.0298956577,
-0.0018180653,
0.0423771776,
-0.0215510912,
-0.0413300432,
0.0344075561,
-0.0154334856,
-0.0011049031,
-0.0052748974,
-0.0451666266,
-0.0266871154,
-0.0426587388,
0.02172409,
0.0711745769,
0.0427976325,
-0.0091671078,
-0.0352161787,
-0.0012931785,
0.0220599677,
-0.0257583614,
0.0141743822,
0.0465772487,
-0.0545205101,
-0.0077667944,
0.0069334903,
0.0461609438,
-0.0220219381,
0.0164907575,
-0.0046359249,
0.040502049,
-0.0302866418,
-0.0355293043,
-0.0461018868,
-0.0298110321,
0.0531285368,
0.0507389531,
0.0115809226,
-0.0461831242,
-0.0463158339,
-0.0295812488,
0.0110334568,
-0.0346576013,
-0.0414534844,
0.0387945063,
0.0270467531,
-0.0495826751,
-0.0858302265,
-0.0130850207,
-0.0378655456,
-0.0186160468,
0.006513604,
0.0050473693,
-0.0077676005,
-0.0184582844,
-0.0585603639,
-0.0051548248,
-0.0504576787,
0.0463819727,
-0.0408665687,
0.0194674656,
-0.0169284698,
-0.0617580079,
-0.0108717829,
0.0105544711,
-0.0762840286,
-0.0342387632,
-0.002987338,
0.008691241,
0.0107289972,
0.0040664678,
-0.0248968638,
-0.0583094731,
0.0887236744,
0.0509473793,
0.0071562142,
-0.0097933672,
0.0250882041,
-0.0433484837,
-0.0146177607,
0.0127455834,
0.002151604,
0.0475664213,
0.0252695214,
-0.0514407679,
-0.0165284798,
-0.0127523523,
0.0069770659,
0.0311157126,
0.0079474747,
-0.0032691688,
-0.0074284258,
-0.0302690156,
-0.0146782789,
-0.0163293891,
-0.0029763989,
-0.0199018214,
0.0296706427,
0.0418221541,
0.0159004815,
0.0150096919,
0.0484030396,
0.0050674304,
0.0233357307,
-0.0024409525,
0.0045517441,
-0.0135792792,
0.0902437717,
-0.0057565104,
0.0093388883,
0.0071493229,
0.0529754609,
0.0032129588,
0.0356539898,
0.0245510954,
0.0054433052,
0.025936719,
-0.0423634909,
-0.0004028977,
0.0409258194,
-0.0488479994,
-0.0362129137,
-0.0793887079,
0.012576933,
0.0552266911,
-0.0004739219,
0.0412895121,
-0.0394686908,
0.0069138804,
-0.0161967911,
-0.0104670096,
0.0357367173,
0.0060870494,
-0.0635389388,
-0.0046462035,
-0.0328620523,
0.0497341417,
0.0593840443,
0.0364762098,
0.0462190434,
0.0032762126,
-0.0662316084,
-0.0438910052,
-0.0192423891,
0.0375185162,
0.0124118617,
-0.0246334933,
-0.0083506918,
-0.0067980257,
-0.0322521143,
0.0539943613,
-0.0178615972,
0.0319023281,
0.0150728179,
-0.0187448431,
0.0577421524,
-0.0218861289,
0.0371351019,
-0.062328741,
-0.0128533272,
-0.010807245,
-0.0447413065,
-0.0142870583,
-5.519577071e-33,
0.0675339475,
-0.0746055469,
-0.0342497118,
0.0099864574,
0.0304394532,
0.0412289202,
-0.0019925025,
-0.0465422943,
-0.0192098767,
0.0344022028,
-0.0177070126,
0.0233696103,
0.0105781686,
0.0330902264,
-0.0627303645,
0.0153923342,
0.0387725905,
-0.0153850885,
-0.0321429372,
0.02683568,
0.0605244413,
0.0073471824,
0.023097733,
-0.1039615124,
0.0273035429,
-0.0343277752,
-0.0459884219,
0.0107448418,
-0.0269854739,
0.053133782,
-0.0351276919,
0.0383470021,
0.0438735262,
-0.0249104593,
0.0035350395,
0.0450462215,
-0.002836532,
0.0122973099,
-0.0579336472,
-0.0009209994,
-0.0336460546,
-0.0525911078,
0.0183781348,
0.0014910735,
-0.0374346003,
0.0327676684,
0.039233502,
-0.0196414106,
0.0058791656,
-0.0747462362,
-0.0709256977,
0.0288456604,
0.0193366818,
0.0020154659,
0.0553874113,
0.0187065527,
0.0205988921,
0.0403477475,
-0.0468468331,
0.0007225274,
-0.0083663678,
-0.01321436,
0.0294136256,
-0.0160420425,
-0.03740431,
0.0429028869,
0.0364230908,
-0.0013664034,
-0.0351549983,
-0.0205729119,
0.0179861207,
0.0299814939,
0.0646898076,
0.0974733829,
0.0445799232,
-0.0286083519,
-0.0685375184,
0.0504571348,
-0.0001273112,
-0.015809495,
0.0329876505,
-0.0338758193,
-0.0467730165,
0.0392592363,
-0.0200155247,
-0.0481169783,
-0.03324176,
-0.0069525163,
0.0131256515,
0.0216615461,
-0.0773790479,
0.0016928059,
0.0194926448,
-0.0727451742,
0.0269387886,
0.0284643788,
-0.0451663956,
0.0358505659,
0.0220818836,
0.0326185264,
-0.0153946653,
-0.0069690924,
0.0270735826,
-0.0121021308,
0.0163794793,
0.0135405492,
0.0796295851,
0.0224762224,
-0.0456537828,
0.0372383036,
0.0121299941,
0.0464816391,
0.0292343646,
0.0601723455,
-0.0081146201,
-0.0406842008,
0.0044282107,
0.0238989927,
0.0158605427,
0.0473729894,
-0.0134956064,
-0.0083530601,
-0.0239115637,
-0.0171330124,
-0.0174638815,
-0.0102683408,
-0.0379601829,
0.0173758753,
0.0074629355,
-0.060425207,
0.0309769996,
-0.0263065528,
2.586e-7,
-0.0164747685,
0.0532844476,
0.0425089896,
0.0038753126,
0.0231876858,
0.0580198243,
0.0565230474,
0.0429342091,
-0.0428699814,
-0.0292211846,
-0.0030292356,
0.0267505459,
0.0509754419,
0.0229753461,
-0.0452632345,
-0.0384762399,
-0.0596410558,
0.0266351756,
-0.070401296,
0.0010074703,
0.0446397997,
0.0865438133,
0.0200484246,
-0.0716065541,
0.0115356278,
-0.0629552156,
0.0280410089,
0.0379225425,
0.0205802694,
0.0264424384,
0.0656785369,
-0.016686542,
0.0170953721,
0.0196947791,
-0.0242374372,
0.0103587899,
-0.0111075845,
0.0632880628,
-0.0120149618,
0.0339311436,
-0.0291297305,
-0.0191948339,
0.0294341594,
-0.0552192181,
0.0633051693,
0.037220981,
-0.0134099908,
-0.0695608109,
-0.0175885744,
-0.0398536846,
0.0570819378,
-0.0487540551,
0.0016315479,
0.0385375395,
0.0124987559,
0.0359216146,
-0.0100057162,
-0.0617802963,
-0.0145234605,
-0.0482714325,
-0.0242268387,
0.0343875326,
-0.030920554,
-0.0110868439,
0.0610034913,
-0.0475161076,
0.0512613095,
2.443890408e-34,
0.0242247805,
-0.0175853707,
-0.0065313498,
0.0013416576,
0.0352658257,
0.0260723755,
-0.0087610548,
-0.0083533572,
-0.0050058998,
-0.0081045311,
0.0133954072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00380v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00380v1
|
The Best of Both Worlds: Toward an Honest and Helpful Large Language Model
| 2024-06-01T09:36:16 | 2024-06-01T09:36:16 |
Chujie Gao, Qihui Zhang, Dongping Chen, Yue Huang, Siyuan Wu, Zhengyan Fu, Yao Wan, Xiangliang Zhang, Lichao Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across various
industries due to their exceptional generative capabilities. However, for safe
and effective real-world deployments, ensuring honesty and helpfulness is
critical. This paper addresses the question: Can we prioritize the helpfulness
of LLMs while preserving their honesty? To begin with, we establish exhaustive
principles aimed at guaranteeing the honesty of LLM. Additionally, we introduce
a novel dataset, referred to as HoneSet, comprising 930 queries spanning six
categories meticulously crafted to assess an LLM's capacity for maintaining
honesty. Subsequently, we present two approaches to augmenting honesty and
helpfulness in LLMs: a training-free enhancement and a fine-tuning-based
improvement. The training-free approach, which is based on curiosity-driven
prompting, empowers LLMs to articulate internal confusion and uncertainty
regarding queries, thereby optimizing their responses. Conversely, the
fine-tuning-based method employs a two-stage process inspired by curriculum
learning: initially instructing LLMs to discern between honest and dishonest
responses, then refining their training to enhance helpfulness. Experiments
conducted on nine prominent LLMs demonstrate a significant improvement in
alignment with honesty across all models through the implementation of our
proposed enhancements. Particularly noteworthy is the 65.3% enhancement
observed in Llama3-8b and the remarkable 124.7% improvement in Mistral-7b, as
measured by the H$^{2}$ (honest and helpful) assessment. We believe that our
work can pave the way for developing more trustworthy LLMs for real-world
applications.
|
[
0.0987825319,
0.0977933556,
-0.0517685935,
0.0677189752,
-0.0536283404,
-0.0037429095,
0.0038534352,
-0.0091087259,
0.0233217962,
-0.0201366432,
-0.0281070005,
-0.0147932759,
-0.0162598304,
0.0118543962,
0.0404232144,
-0.0128905345,
0.0629028082,
-0.0446578376,
0.0158299636,
-0.0188964549,
0.0277381297,
0.019378379,
0.0017390664,
0.0301782675,
-0.016457608,
-0.0004551676,
-0.0165027641,
0.0003022594,
-0.0079175765,
-0.008441194,
0.0239050295,
0.0523089394,
0.0070513282,
0.0512575917,
0.0000022229,
-0.0761938021,
-0.0203828346,
-0.0084047876,
-0.0597227514,
0.0186907742,
0.0566550232,
-0.0162257124,
0.0035550063,
0.0397171341,
-0.0682029203,
0.0379321128,
0.0395403355,
0.0136686526,
0.0900724903,
0.0697489157,
0.0227337405,
0.0155955963,
0.0247076582,
-0.0140997274,
0.0322766937,
-0.055975683,
0.0213186424,
-0.0051617757,
-0.0125099514,
0.0210471004,
0.0018414512,
0.0259208381,
0.0066137775,
-0.0336154364,
0.023866741,
0.0192360058,
-0.0463238619,
-0.0220439192,
-0.0109342448,
0.0391806364,
0.0085656047,
-0.0084881373,
0.0014209457,
-0.0148919011,
0.0117794452,
-0.0071233357,
-0.0297443327,
0.0052700909,
-0.0107377665,
-0.005317172,
-0.010347737,
-0.0120996237,
0.023385359,
0.0254579019,
0.0028009084,
0.0562882535,
-0.0214174576,
-0.0476741679,
0.0035585733,
-0.0227452628,
0.0086862342,
-0.0607254654,
0.0029226881,
0.0432839394,
-0.0578206293,
0.0406860225,
-0.0383208618,
0.0239524469,
0.0634299144,
-0.0549506098,
0.0110674994,
0.0288401749,
-0.0037076487,
0.0301782414,
0.0071312841,
0.0769604594,
0.0231175143,
0.0453437716,
-0.0577565618,
-0.0204084124,
-0.0196139663,
-0.0184482019,
-0.03009074,
0.0128864357,
-0.0085354727,
-0.0026825443,
-0.0469222814,
0.0464703739,
-0.0251570772,
0.0475095995,
0.0293188859,
0.0173008479,
-0.0345147923,
-0.0144046098,
-0.0684983134,
-0.0068565086,
-0.0144591285,
0.0330905803,
-0.0004254849,
-0.0960204229,
0.0024669426,
0.0020719799,
-0.021119846,
-0.0129843289,
0.0031440933,
0.0654886365,
-0.0002846984,
-0.0309677608,
-0.0495036878,
-0.0157108232,
0.0042220796,
-0.0600635707,
-0.0233697332,
-0.0534726307,
0.0286961626,
-0.0105522433,
-0.0136895226,
-0.0355334468,
0.023420386,
0.0155697707,
-0.0436761081,
0.0656415746,
-0.0456780568,
0.0505334698,
0.0187990908,
0.0179282818,
-0.0152663132,
0.0739357844,
0.0228333436,
0.0442017764,
0.0678915232,
-0.0302186403,
0.0394948758,
0.0153216748,
-0.0037409295,
0.0226742625,
0.0014384751,
0.0258702822,
-0.0159484297,
0.0407382026,
0.0206280798,
0.0661229417,
-0.0079909237,
-0.0217083655,
0.112232551,
0.0116088111,
-0.0065932274,
-0.0078956364,
0.0183348134,
0.0544883944,
-0.0037388604,
0.0066977101,
-0.0831824765,
0.0202660095,
-0.0395156443,
0.0084375925,
0.0163360499,
0.0285971686,
-0.0073363194,
-0.0419260599,
-0.0175885744,
-0.0128914658,
0.0069405246,
0.0558172613,
0.0045526153,
-0.0238206573,
-0.0396891162,
0.019056078,
0.0288308989,
-0.0402599089,
0.0079797031,
-0.0736245364,
0.0424914956,
0.1092707068,
0.0398694947,
0.0022205298,
-0.0369796418,
-0.0367122628,
-0.0012279021,
0.0362193994,
0.0472792797,
-0.0173124019,
0.0050418037,
-0.0518676862,
-0.0376145504,
0.0058921883,
0.0144798318,
-0.013985754,
-0.0050622537,
0.0025996235,
0.0108684348,
-0.0426205136,
-0.0163722318,
0.0501251742,
-0.0187882483,
-0.0269046072,
-0.0094621442,
0.0137480274,
0.018171927,
-0.0108136479,
-0.0031150577,
0.0036745244,
0.037420433,
0.0040349863,
0.0049275039,
-0.015073658,
-0.0301807765,
0.0220632795,
0.0289324932,
-0.0084396051,
0.0037372087,
0.0139972446,
-0.0443971567,
-0.0056086918,
-0.0107966,
-0.0340454169,
0.0305360928,
-0.0469934344,
0.0304893125,
-0.0414484292,
-0.0091442838,
-0.0537315421,
0.0392741151,
-0.0307336897,
0.007324981,
-0.0108616799,
-0.0307046752,
-0.0112781925,
-0.0270069353,
-0.0065743253,
0.0084556239,
0.0168498568,
0.0476687886,
0.0327555314,
0.0368711837,
-0.0311089158,
-0.0473240428,
-0.0903196186,
-0.0133908279,
-0.0116424197,
0.0056931735,
0.0232426338,
-0.0181398168,
-0.0205507502,
0.011304752,
-0.0384103209,
0.007536348,
0.0257913023,
0.0179701205,
0.0314236097,
0.0007598288,
-0.0394814946,
-0.0158016533,
0.0063458541,
-0.0152586456,
0.005194224,
-0.0169444829,
0.0030278536,
-0.0706586242,
0.0244376436,
-0.0408396609,
0.0178917963,
-0.0241356529,
-0.0832209736,
0.0088091316,
0.0014351682,
-0.0072998973,
0.0691032931,
0.050422769,
-0.0072747217,
0.0610171035,
0.014182088,
-0.0887448415,
-0.0032138417,
-0.0050058896,
-0.0518237017,
-0.0399223305,
-0.0499991663,
0.023428686,
0.0263464171,
0.021314241,
-0.0014395645,
-0.0406908952,
0.0195020661,
-0.0235932544,
-0.0536395572,
-0.0292193331,
-0.0316048227,
-0.0224042218,
0.0432974584,
0.0061491686,
-0.0849840865,
0.108316496,
-0.0171705056,
0.0082235318,
-0.0345176533,
-0.0254563726,
-0.0029224507,
0.0539296754,
-0.0392115451,
0.0284739006,
0.0516124256,
-0.0227718726,
-0.0551329702,
-0.0313074291,
0.0429835021,
-0.0535543151,
0.0447987765,
-0.0529848821,
-0.0090455702,
0.0119957831,
-0.0385006852,
-0.0791768432,
-0.0702835768,
-0.0254999641,
0.0046052104,
0.0185018163,
-0.0076097706,
-0.0274097472,
-0.0317278318,
0.0263362415,
0.013194222,
-0.0336284637,
-0.0146082742,
-0.0159365479,
-0.0318524577,
0.0634985194,
0.0157099739,
0.0612379797,
-0.0215017777,
0.0055822325,
0.0476763323,
0.0317758322,
-0.0057954374,
0.0072803129,
-0.0165953357,
0.0338906534,
-0.0123376576,
0.0094809709,
0.0434220508,
0.0185673963,
-0.0322353058,
-0.0274571702,
0.1026080176,
0.0129542397,
-0.0168268923,
0.0234711953,
-0.0181820597,
0.0096691642,
0.0489923395,
0.0369249247,
-0.0988054872,
-0.0257511269,
-0.0026356406,
0.0409341194,
-0.0214218721,
-0.0353442878,
-0.0219933204,
-0.1475088,
0.0341039114,
0.0048363269,
-0.0064719138,
-0.015460562,
-0.0277118515,
-0.0124092484,
-0.0093904622,
0.0513166152,
0.0172658339,
0.0011780731,
-0.03145843,
0.027171256,
0.0221959855,
-0.0648866072,
0.0149315894,
-0.0477270186,
0.0706217736,
0.0660266653,
0.0062334249,
-0.0185585003,
-0.0669765249,
-0.0014475278,
0.0268434174,
0.0120209577,
0.0161830876,
0.0232806671,
-0.0244086329,
-0.0047835158,
0.0045971251,
0.0023990767,
-0.0184997171,
0.0282356068,
0.0252772607,
0.0747815967,
-0.0128187183,
-0.0102476534,
-0.0259712487,
-0.0021157665,
0.0442763269,
0.0738092139,
0.0094821695,
-0.0313008688,
0.0147328619,
-0.0154472105,
-0.0248825047,
0.0053140507,
-0.0221838541,
0.0425850637,
0.0089913039,
0.0159305874,
-0.0622974448,
-0.0475247726,
0.0066278931,
0.0126514491,
0.0294847339,
0.0028708859,
0.0185464341,
0.0098202368,
-0.0087636653,
0.0065612509,
-0.0602293275,
0.0470438041,
-0.0619642995,
0.0112063223,
0.0040798774,
-0.0455917753,
0.0081037479,
-0.0068725171,
-0.0420562141,
-0.0582147241,
0.0168090221,
0.0751627535,
0.0294168871,
0.0293102413,
-0.02715097,
-0.0725148916,
-0.0022108722,
0.0644060746,
-0.073727861,
0.0158407614,
0.0325512812,
-0.0097381826,
0.016088428,
0.0508866198,
-0.0536689274,
-0.0192539711,
0.0125836963,
0.0133475075,
-0.0139556928,
-0.0487745181,
0.0473114997,
0.0459105521,
0.0238151327,
-0.0002297948,
0.037997514,
-0.0361227207,
0.0388090871,
-0.0077914582,
-0.0404260941,
-0.0226535499,
-0.0034420004,
0.0101922778,
0.004509564,
0.0202453304,
-0.0440011993,
-0.0373062007,
0.010489326,
-0.0493948199,
-0.0161269996,
-0.004256655,
0.0100974534,
0.0190720279,
0.0110101476,
-0.0249226522,
0.0285273585,
0.0055568758,
0.0451569445,
0.0074242568,
0.0596897379,
0.0011994708,
-0.0241873544,
-0.0129330382,
0.0371801667,
-0.0407865681,
-0.0610751584,
0.0096691558,
0.0411770716,
0.0505857244,
0.0275651533,
0.0223131701,
-0.019457655,
0.0175730679,
-0.0053854715,
0.005383465,
0.0073955925,
-0.0488074347,
0.053244859,
0.0232748445,
-0.0303389672,
-0.0004113649,
0.0570932217,
-0.0389409922,
0.0427263156,
-0.0398095101,
-0.0130033474,
-0.0338412412,
-0.0312054548,
0.0529402718,
0.0280976314,
-0.0474655777,
-0.025996387,
-0.0680710077,
-0.0611765161,
-0.0298511367,
0.0277987346,
0.0133523559,
-0.0504539646,
0.0247176755,
0.0864307731,
0.0090475529,
-0.0133659719,
-0.0658113286,
-0.0134326182,
-0.0086142616,
-0.0078848405,
-0.0165287238,
-6.533217604e-33,
0.0167841278,
-0.0129567012,
0.0131991049,
-0.0449254662,
-0.0218183845,
-0.0099568125,
0.0001136643,
0.0079394411,
-0.0725527778,
-0.0068546054,
-0.0424956121,
0.0184252486,
0.0150764529,
-0.018718265,
0.01771928,
-0.0059035863,
0.0331092626,
-0.0017944123,
-0.0348833054,
0.0305656567,
0.0341286026,
0.0042823907,
0.0738723055,
-0.0679027811,
0.0412546657,
-0.0105949137,
-0.0426293463,
0.0796595216,
-0.0595519356,
0.0823576674,
-0.0048438185,
0.0641449317,
0.0050580073,
-0.0015161639,
-0.0064520733,
-0.0275900066,
-0.002075027,
-0.0111186756,
0.0686762556,
-0.0045285164,
-0.0025741705,
-0.0416473038,
0.0487462282,
-0.0485008806,
-0.0348668955,
0.0149860885,
0.011100444,
-0.0136650475,
-0.0311112795,
-0.008954837,
-0.0428638458,
-0.0086276,
-0.0187265277,
-0.0345382504,
-0.0268320236,
0.0305890534,
-0.0010606223,
0.0144185536,
-0.0500034094,
0.0376424938,
0.0340876989,
0.0156551432,
0.0796340257,
-0.0023706057,
0.0033164159,
0.0682488903,
0.0199506264,
0.0271794274,
0.0329795256,
-0.0198465232,
0.046161972,
0.0420950018,
0.0454184711,
0.0785570964,
0.0092925513,
-0.0672832429,
-0.0509122126,
0.0115766069,
0.0299489219,
0.034462437,
0.0381382778,
0.0032469893,
-0.0702032223,
-0.0264544748,
-0.0434744731,
0.0241698921,
-0.0463224836,
-0.0150821265,
0.045254495,
0.0228884611,
-0.0453015603,
-0.0000955359,
0.0211613812,
-0.0644026995,
-0.0056852289,
0.0257540401,
-0.0259089731,
-0.0090376101,
0.0027223728,
0.027222259,
-0.0699487105,
-0.0264652669,
-0.015123833,
-0.0223120209,
0.0044567818,
0.0203956347,
0.0200813189,
0.017400736,
-0.0443163887,
0.0294779316,
-0.0355206206,
0.0383402929,
-0.0027420907,
-0.0464434251,
0.0268715508,
-0.0086370418,
-0.0116753811,
0.0412432067,
0.013706645,
-0.0424557738,
-0.0630395859,
0.0123143289,
-0.0028226173,
0.0309271459,
-0.0213151593,
-0.0080648893,
-0.0286277197,
0.0143325301,
0.0365017429,
-0.0187177788,
-0.0173682515,
0.0102831395,
2.937e-7,
-0.0346153714,
0.0264419336,
-0.0315136462,
0.0391060263,
-0.0190155618,
0.0588095039,
-0.03090344,
0.0478797778,
0.0175838657,
-0.0267317742,
0.0021828644,
0.0052390401,
0.0565593578,
0.0407854393,
-0.0606085286,
-0.0071673086,
-0.0420148857,
-0.0328108929,
-0.0645842403,
-0.0011270447,
0.0526571758,
0.0949391946,
0.0255234074,
-0.019854771,
-0.0023217818,
-0.033575248,
0.0170222316,
-0.0271311514,
-0.0197421778,
0.0391052887,
0.025091067,
0.0096682124,
0.0099541545,
0.036408525,
0.0050932001,
0.0144579122,
-0.0549238622,
0.0820613354,
-0.0123416213,
-0.024235731,
-0.0042093862,
-0.0652713254,
0.0046339771,
-0.0894030333,
0.0491255298,
-0.0176860951,
-0.0156133315,
-0.0343586132,
0.0107054226,
-0.0504864417,
0.0299530923,
-0.0440437831,
-0.0351665802,
0.0252982844,
0.0210394971,
0.0132765854,
-0.0220019929,
-0.0233718045,
0.0070299963,
-0.022264868,
-0.0109226983,
-0.0924114212,
0.0052630352,
0.0302271657,
-0.021545697,
-0.0364294276,
0.0584063232,
2.42049853e-34,
0.0137657151,
-0.0033389914,
0.0283199251,
0.0202291794,
0.0649986342,
0.0390119031,
0.0180016104,
0.0201424304,
0.0197880976,
-0.0396696962,
-0.0242498145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00367v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00367v1
|
RoBERTa-BiLSTM: A Context-Aware Hybrid Model for Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-06-01T08:59:46 | 2024-06-01T08:59:46 |
Md. Mostafizer Rahman, Ariful Islam Shiplu, Yutaka Watanobe, Md. Ashad Alam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE
|
Effectively analyzing the comments to uncover latent intentions holds immense
value in making strategic decisions across various domains. However, several
challenges hinder the process of sentiment analysis including the lexical
diversity exhibited in comments, the presence of long dependencies within the
text, encountering unknown symbols and words, and dealing with imbalanced
datasets. Moreover, existing sentiment analysis tasks mostly leveraged
sequential models to encode the long dependent texts and it requires longer
execution time as it processes the text sequentially. In contrast, the
Transformer requires less execution time due to its parallel processing nature.
In this work, we introduce a novel hybrid deep learning model, RoBERTa-BiLSTM,
which combines the Robustly Optimized BERT Pretraining Approach (RoBERTa) with
Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory (BiLSTM) networks. RoBERTa is utilized to
generate meaningful word embedding vectors, while BiLSTM effectively captures
the contextual semantics of long-dependent texts. The RoBERTa-BiLSTM hybrid
model leverages the strengths of both sequential and Transformer models to
enhance performance in sentiment analysis. We conducted experiments using
datasets from IMDb, Twitter US Airline, and Sentiment140 to evaluate the
proposed model against existing state-of-the-art methods. Our experimental
findings demonstrate that the RoBERTa-BiLSTM model surpasses baseline models
(e.g., BERT, RoBERTa-base, RoBERTa-GRU, and RoBERTa-LSTM), achieving accuracies
of 80.74%, 92.36%, and 82.25% on the Twitter US Airline, IMDb, and Sentiment140
datasets, respectively. Additionally, the model achieves F1-scores of 80.73%,
92.35%, and 82.25% on the same datasets, respectively.
|
[
0.0340151526,
0.0931903124,
0.0139681818,
0.0630025938,
-0.0133063672,
-0.0069432626,
-0.0161765479,
0.0175838787,
-0.0204624664,
-0.0627432689,
-0.0269538593,
-0.0477556176,
-0.0313753486,
0.0214779433,
-0.0251482464,
-0.0195728503,
-0.0002991761,
0.0272204448,
0.0403293557,
0.0132565619,
0.0121181654,
0.0217350218,
0.0118061993,
0.0156086497,
-0.0344301499,
-0.019114092,
0.0037739899,
0.0136769591,
0.0289993379,
-0.0347959846,
0.0579182319,
0.054389786,
0.0613202006,
0.0437952615,
0.0000023459,
-0.0039005247,
-0.0126995975,
-0.0409208089,
0.0196570996,
0.0263777189,
0.0425175317,
-0.0221014451,
0.018741589,
0.0050189598,
-0.0495088585,
-0.0300419237,
0.0193095021,
0.0680247471,
0.0508335978,
0.0768080726,
-0.023940675,
-0.0288171209,
0.010274983,
-0.0466256253,
0.0106874285,
-0.0412919037,
0.0166995898,
-0.0492770784,
-0.0546158217,
-0.0083244117,
-0.0313464068,
0.0311373658,
0.0170841049,
-0.0006498164,
0.0273161959,
0.0051476695,
0.0131727243,
0.0028025494,
0.0034601914,
0.0719536096,
-0.0058643641,
-0.0131594231,
-0.0198498126,
-0.0128293419,
-0.0107643781,
-0.020014612,
0.0030469846,
-0.002277165,
0.0199996792,
0.0356684327,
-0.006608997,
0.0490109883,
0.050435219,
0.0119977454,
-0.0254449565,
-0.0156775471,
-0.0109153874,
-0.073291868,
-0.0004614669,
0.0073332624,
-0.0093472749,
-0.0194475353,
0.0270110406,
-0.0086690905,
-0.0141546139,
0.0226605255,
0.0042349235,
-0.0240123793,
-0.0007205145,
-0.0749796927,
-0.0027221297,
0.0168235097,
-0.0561698303,
0.0422491245,
-0.0358162671,
-0.0072482796,
-0.0258335099,
-0.0407300889,
-0.0160480831,
0.021898061,
-0.0366289318,
-0.0057981792,
0.0018282261,
0.0252500512,
-0.0297210217,
-0.024041228,
-0.0610803962,
0.0165461246,
-0.0337893702,
0.0226966105,
0.0326298289,
0.0336756967,
0.0065960516,
0.000584432,
-0.0404585823,
0.0566558093,
-0.0220029652,
0.0184658132,
-0.0395950936,
0.0073973597,
0.0100212917,
0.0587996021,
0.0260575153,
-0.0108230347,
0.0115317646,
0.048800502,
0.0173069611,
-0.0626153275,
-0.057532873,
-0.0297313705,
-0.0191890318,
-0.0555899255,
0.0300394148,
-0.0299582314,
0.0231306087,
-0.0149410041,
-0.0172189437,
0.0137845064,
0.0047938661,
0.0054970738,
-0.0053146258,
0.0534329154,
0.0035088987,
-0.0433989577,
-0.0079120118,
0.0160722472,
0.0353231281,
0.0674475357,
0.0323354043,
0.0786027461,
0.050691925,
-0.0138103571,
0.0026388229,
0.0154706249,
0.0438714921,
-0.0128421728,
-0.031481754,
0.0305205099,
-0.0828690305,
0.0147066433,
0.0103676328,
0.0374389216,
-0.0173275992,
-0.0060139727,
0.0514738224,
-0.0019335606,
0.0097728753,
0.0678857192,
0.0429365002,
0.0152620934,
-0.0318331122,
-0.0508972853,
-0.0097409291,
0.0404554196,
-0.0028799828,
0.0026360692,
0.0343847536,
0.001354128,
-0.0211387035,
-0.0307401139,
0.002861368,
-0.0609935746,
0.0479289927,
-0.0043734149,
0.0398108549,
-0.02915686,
-0.1290055811,
0.0586409308,
0.0082344748,
-0.0457993224,
-0.0321056284,
-0.0395816974,
0.0300819557,
0.1075150743,
0.0005530808,
-0.033035513,
-0.0069485214,
-0.0618628189,
-0.0013631933,
0.0410829037,
0.03714706,
0.0171986427,
-0.0056284619,
-0.0600020401,
-0.0160776339,
0.008537285,
0.030624995,
0.0372736529,
-0.0119368471,
0.0516248383,
0.009737554,
0.0032820003,
0.0217644926,
0.0017966793,
0.0083626676,
-0.0319082662,
0.00652469,
0.0231583957,
0.0487662256,
0.0520570986,
-0.0262044109,
-0.0184275489,
0.0327508226,
-0.0262045991,
-0.0555363856,
0.006692667,
-0.0443869159,
-0.0348822325,
-0.0091421176,
-0.0122176865,
-0.0414300188,
0.0868884921,
-0.026428137,
-0.0234386791,
0.0233965926,
-0.0143775633,
0.0525112599,
-0.0477957204,
-0.0220149718,
-0.0105127422,
0.0136954207,
-0.0031031107,
0.0616109222,
-0.0434735566,
-0.0071013034,
0.0041954177,
-0.0019956825,
0.0381571986,
0.0051325192,
-0.0578763261,
0.0123439627,
0.0243054237,
0.0236945767,
0.0480890423,
0.0231893249,
-0.0213952102,
-0.0312304944,
-0.1442165524,
-0.0161383133,
-0.0299800616,
-0.0142040672,
-0.0116074663,
0.005708111,
-0.0029874037,
0.0146802207,
-0.0107267834,
-0.0130928839,
-0.032771457,
0.0058769267,
0.0324919447,
-0.0058570704,
-0.0094436137,
-0.0436812602,
-0.0194186121,
-0.0207673609,
0.0186701957,
0.0067209462,
-0.0121981744,
-0.0172041971,
-0.0125659993,
-0.0005498556,
0.0011154786,
0.007365094,
-0.0478568487,
-0.010258439,
-0.0220699701,
0.003530703,
0.0182098392,
0.0519786067,
0.0369166546,
-0.0231681149,
-0.0026390029,
-0.0279332586,
0.0549830794,
-0.0321329869,
0.0242022835,
-0.0258579887,
-0.022353448,
-0.0127602136,
0.0436196029,
-0.0063370764,
-0.0021109509,
-0.0700966567,
-0.0467057638,
0.0027215497,
0.0003257279,
0.0225760341,
-0.0130427619,
-0.004193054,
0.0016431978,
0.0226043593,
-0.0245434139,
0.0519471169,
-0.0010021409,
0.0009507586,
-0.0544022545,
-0.0053874939,
-0.0396658257,
0.0386699438,
-0.0007232983,
-0.0032392589,
-0.0588597618,
0.0128234159,
0.0026639279,
-0.0187437385,
-0.0458488204,
-0.0265276786,
0.0196540803,
0.0395863466,
0.0135487756,
0.0050514401,
-0.0232569296,
-0.0258775037,
-0.0651265532,
-0.0485662185,
-0.0276832897,
0.0694253147,
-0.0427938253,
0.006611946,
0.0036063606,
-0.0141521608,
0.009008876,
0.0153938746,
-0.0186825637,
0.0112002799,
0.0217172001,
0.0308083631,
-0.0320692025,
0.0306385197,
-0.0097485892,
-0.0017626631,
0.0162498727,
0.0058680498,
-0.0245647281,
-0.0772210881,
-0.017947197,
-0.0087367762,
0.0038626906,
0.0121705383,
-0.0215330143,
0.0046771904,
-0.0402564071,
0.0160140917,
0.1292927861,
0.0171092991,
-0.0564380772,
-0.0060874801,
0.0395686515,
-0.0012352907,
-0.0025449169,
0.0011043188,
-0.0668501407,
-0.0699479505,
-0.0474195816,
-0.0132275857,
0.0378016941,
-0.0311521962,
0.0014426182,
-0.0772057548,
0.0239061322,
-0.0317936018,
0.0041702469,
-0.045394443,
-0.0231384262,
-0.0251673758,
-0.01780398,
0.0271091033,
-0.0285021681,
-0.0137154777,
-0.0018978892,
-0.0252160635,
-0.0783554837,
-0.010549481,
0.0459142141,
-0.0339610614,
0.0045158183,
0.0460301898,
0.0444238521,
-0.0248337723,
-0.0457369424,
0.0431949496,
-0.0208657272,
-0.0025528097,
-0.0051328787,
0.0610470027,
-0.0599250011,
-0.0241417214,
0.0021332151,
-0.0070298854,
-0.0998327956,
0.0254945997,
-0.0243224185,
0.0636920407,
0.0059513217,
-0.0386852883,
-0.0408072919,
0.0376571752,
0.023160385,
0.0904291794,
-0.0124282148,
-0.0860910192,
-0.0401018858,
-0.010132187,
0.0006558876,
-0.0904876664,
0.0309569724,
-0.0337525122,
0.0003434818,
-0.0455137901,
-0.0632530376,
-0.0843918249,
0.029547466,
0.0016716382,
-0.0381829888,
0.0143238911,
0.0101885479,
0.0123764016,
-0.0596033297,
0.0314846933,
0.0137020731,
0.0181612484,
-0.033085186,
-0.0095024062,
0.0418811031,
-0.0009118664,
-0.0246497672,
-0.0113645261,
-0.0704703778,
-0.0132009741,
-0.0073728971,
0.0364470743,
0.0104405936,
0.0371181183,
0.0113444105,
-0.0158202201,
0.0591523312,
0.0440356322,
-0.0416907631,
-0.0048639565,
0.0533392988,
0.0486387052,
-0.0006288595,
0.0467291065,
-0.0315428525,
0.0211259592,
-0.0065376759,
0.0308694597,
-0.0294505935,
-0.0138693731,
-0.0053437408,
-0.0488834716,
0.0538192242,
0.0224458706,
-0.0342470519,
-0.0483991839,
0.0176953338,
0.0201581325,
0.0161594171,
-0.0404159799,
-0.0088923331,
0.0301288832,
-0.0111666787,
-0.0628112033,
0.0033098822,
-0.0001640334,
-0.0164041854,
-0.0180213042,
0.0617313124,
0.0195277371,
0.0071821432,
0.0138471695,
0.0294118822,
-0.0323607549,
-0.0152285835,
0.0102195824,
-0.0272485446,
0.0082399491,
0.0412157401,
0.0257511251,
0.0226737969,
-0.0027559802,
0.0314980149,
-0.0210477822,
0.011160275,
-0.0118821142,
0.0223634094,
0.0352042057,
-0.0449823923,
0.0332642645,
-0.0437969267,
0.0328407623,
0.0189354904,
0.0231261831,
-0.0472905226,
-0.0189095791,
0.0399808697,
0.0117626004,
-0.0247443374,
0.0179200377,
0.0579080842,
-0.0211260915,
0.0316189826,
0.022502264,
-0.0115592368,
-0.0634336025,
0.0016654902,
0.084802106,
0.0326382555,
-0.0034846019,
0.039515622,
-0.0148955127,
-0.075563252,
0.0770652145,
-0.0404599346,
-0.0109378425,
-0.0246456619,
0.048513528,
0.0583919547,
0.0264104009,
0.03169645,
-0.0181858856,
0.0074268505,
0.0099962717,
-0.0440168045,
-0.0345081836,
-6.957313926e-33,
0.0344836861,
-0.0061721043,
-0.0070337695,
-0.004957153,
-0.0287324395,
0.009524907,
0.0002932274,
-0.0104605108,
-0.0043082507,
0.0511145145,
0.0021422643,
0.0463377796,
-0.011260069,
0.040230725,
0.0320577733,
-0.0628961697,
0.04133882,
-0.0024280851,
0.0210620183,
0.0398756191,
0.0569470078,
0.0629324466,
0.0455590412,
-0.0784781724,
0.0192955285,
-0.0332377255,
-0.0235211197,
0.0255368091,
0.0459656343,
0.05491345,
-0.0405395441,
0.0517410561,
0.0277836528,
-0.0325691029,
0.0240085144,
0.0637173653,
-0.0070147133,
-0.0136021208,
0.0118257161,
0.0077421702,
-0.0518256687,
-0.0030673479,
0.0279295631,
0.024029376,
0.0100087114,
0.0218254905,
0.0190976523,
0.003909633,
0.0345417224,
-0.050846424,
-0.071357891,
0.0128511349,
-0.033970423,
-0.0042156135,
0.0477116331,
0.0279466063,
0.0141876666,
0.0693256781,
-0.0920448676,
-0.0143130878,
-0.0616500676,
-0.0004539545,
0.0018017517,
-0.0162649266,
-0.0364416279,
0.0685205832,
0.0245774183,
-0.0058418959,
-0.000216,
0.0156694707,
0.0024886357,
0.0227999799,
0.0347975418,
0.0368090793,
0.0477919988,
-0.0235697273,
-0.0631421804,
0.0131129362,
0.0542118624,
0.0121766794,
0.0771600232,
0.0102051329,
-0.0283686947,
0.0055810353,
0.0343326293,
-0.005044824,
-0.0267719794,
-0.0100079468,
0.0036986819,
0.0503277406,
-0.0043137139,
0.0090571856,
0.0420173481,
-0.0378521718,
-0.0184138119,
0.0308751073,
-0.038084738,
0.002785132,
0.0183266029,
0.033606682,
-0.0402930789,
0.0162478331,
-0.0178178139,
0.0131521523,
-0.0079771988,
0.0149159292,
0.0449923091,
0.0277417637,
-0.0678098425,
-0.0146104787,
-0.0113514606,
0.0132050794,
-0.0263862703,
0.0281118937,
0.0048860712,
0.0287196487,
-0.0069788089,
0.0884666592,
0.0299937017,
0.0416699015,
-0.0178866666,
-0.0218468942,
-0.0071769832,
-0.0018865735,
-0.0226216279,
-0.0456622764,
0.0127402181,
0.0369852968,
0.0042989762,
-0.1387637258,
-0.0004901371,
-0.0064455308,
2.999e-7,
0.037744265,
0.0616006404,
-0.003113274,
-0.0164053384,
0.017981343,
0.0606479906,
0.0015012684,
0.0363598801,
0.0053205038,
-0.0034909511,
0.0283727553,
-0.0012695841,
-0.0024041203,
-0.0021189707,
-0.0814841092,
-0.0442994833,
-0.0738124326,
0.0047256695,
-0.0242010262,
0.0293527711,
0.0803432167,
0.1129661202,
0.0298382025,
-0.0248867683,
-0.0129335606,
-0.0249859728,
0.0684540272,
-0.0792349875,
-0.0011333643,
0.0134267081,
0.0095786285,
0.0015461162,
-0.0488680713,
-0.0081466921,
-0.0231488571,
0.044243183,
-0.004547664,
0.0349118672,
0.0067592086,
-0.051864747,
0.0301207695,
0.0164969489,
-0.0011026466,
-0.0047489232,
0.0491094701,
-0.07966654,
-0.0354401767,
-0.0282822046,
-0.0447613262,
0.0198266301,
0.0525487475,
0.0041008401,
-0.0233539976,
0.0097116884,
-0.0146548888,
-0.0113554941,
-0.0168763902,
-0.1182153597,
0.0256237108,
-0.0081363525,
-0.0657320246,
0.0106876502,
-0.0412147567,
0.0209794454,
0.094612278,
-0.0172420554,
0.0255313143,
2.883541137e-34,
0.0911600813,
-0.0279401019,
-0.0133204367,
0.0141062168,
0.0371308476,
-0.0066032065,
-0.0375991352,
-0.0083737411,
0.0294704828,
-0.0652228072,
-0.0132562099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06556v1
|
Enhancing Presentation Slide Generation by LLMs with a Multi-Staged End-to-End Approach
| 2024-06-01T07:49:31 | 2024-06-01T07:49:31 |
Sambaran Bandyopadhyay, Himanshu Maheshwari, Anandhavelu Natarajan, Apoorv Saxena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generating presentation slides from a long document with multimodal elements
such as text and images is an important task. This is time consuming and needs
domain expertise if done manually. Existing approaches for generating a rich
presentation from a document are often semi-automatic or only put a flat
summary into the slides ignoring the importance of a good narrative. In this
paper, we address this research gap by proposing a multi-staged end-to-end
model which uses a combination of LLM and VLM. We have experimentally shown
that compared to applying LLMs directly with state-of-the-art prompting, our
proposed multi-staged solution is better in terms of automated metrics and
human evaluation.
|
[
-0.0287166126,
-0.0448792353,
0.0271354131,
0.0054452051,
-0.0342147648,
0.013115881,
-0.0270009637,
0.0247732475,
-0.0077461083,
-0.0461238064,
-0.0187592916,
-0.0022539438,
-0.0107792011,
0.0142790163,
0.0293715,
-0.100940071,
0.0044244663,
-0.019071687,
-0.0100346562,
0.022724973,
-0.0215967596,
-0.0162770525,
-0.0341201983,
-0.0369657353,
0.000772606,
-0.0069767404,
-0.0366518423,
0.0204816554,
0.0519546047,
-0.0127329789,
-0.0480449758,
0.0217201151,
0.0522727184,
-0.0455929227,
0.0000018269,
-0.0785825327,
0.0082047051,
0.002767209,
0.006118576,
0.0210293382,
0.0724519119,
0.0340949818,
0.0112304501,
-0.015445685,
-0.0126134884,
0.0479407609,
-0.0185941122,
0.0687709451,
0.0374049917,
0.0645852685,
-0.0192454644,
-0.0089656217,
-0.0251095146,
0.0156804044,
0.0415391065,
-0.0153900627,
-0.0295274761,
0.0447044298,
0.0874311775,
-0.0322486758,
0.0229360107,
0.0191401094,
0.0057120104,
-0.0399271064,
-0.0098365489,
0.0311420895,
-0.0045426735,
-0.0243498888,
-0.0301473271,
0.073354587,
-0.0065027857,
0.0641605109,
0.0258361083,
-0.0428305417,
0.0284092631,
0.0000263975,
-0.0897114277,
0.0520933494,
-0.056776613,
-0.013307889,
-0.0268940162,
0.0149839381,
0.0065978314,
-0.0036334971,
0.0388122648,
-0.0060268436,
0.0301629547,
-0.0115890484,
-0.0103042433,
0.0316237248,
0.0258399211,
-0.058135476,
0.0278714541,
0.0679958537,
0.0001930153,
0.0137714306,
-0.0175674148,
0.0045521017,
0.0316387415,
-0.0583903454,
0.0437788703,
0.0098939575,
-0.0290431045,
0.0350990333,
-0.0420044325,
0.0589519627,
-0.0117615806,
-0.0209452249,
-0.0237677339,
0.0373211168,
-0.0083538471,
0.0220513511,
0.0027726723,
0.0269486085,
-0.0612291619,
-0.0285347756,
-0.0392729118,
0.0394932367,
0.0039064395,
0.0765767023,
0.0032708794,
0.006846339,
-0.0299640968,
0.0058486355,
-0.0294623245,
0.0486729816,
-0.0043801279,
-0.0019491152,
0.0035829006,
-0.0128656337,
0.010645695,
0.0533793829,
0.01295802,
0.0374165662,
-0.0138654774,
0.1019887477,
-0.0387054048,
0.0054981909,
-0.1051845476,
-0.0221186858,
0.0104297483,
-0.0253532827,
0.0240175817,
-0.0496197194,
0.0115692113,
-0.0065557566,
-0.0463904068,
0.0088308156,
0.0165964011,
0.0034864987,
0.0080890385,
-0.0143420221,
-0.0054786541,
0.0248025339,
0.0665094703,
0.0318674035,
-0.0316585228,
0.0585351177,
0.0375600457,
0.0727727711,
0.0403591171,
-0.0080138976,
0.0535393767,
0.0738284886,
-0.0338498168,
0.0056193233,
0.016197307,
-0.0073321937,
0.0015780755,
0.0257795267,
0.0216052663,
0.0003599042,
-0.0399090424,
0.0529678054,
0.0561511293,
-0.0108702211,
0.0461779572,
0.0125370165,
0.0652889609,
-0.0001640198,
0.0093149161,
0.074162893,
0.0073591582,
0.0709102452,
0.0179467704,
0.0456486978,
0.0724406615,
0.0186248645,
-0.0256469324,
-0.0656767413,
-0.0056279204,
0.0025414079,
-0.0228023846,
-0.0496259257,
0.0087234871,
0.0091875168,
-0.1078515798,
0.0240492634,
-0.005588328,
-0.0744212046,
0.025315471,
-0.0186094306,
0.0056222659,
0.0751644522,
0.0284971241,
-0.0030849059,
-0.0384964719,
-0.0549061969,
0.0275863353,
0.0929762423,
0.0133504011,
-0.014396362,
0.0133457547,
-0.0589519963,
-0.0340544172,
-0.0549223833,
-0.0371049009,
0.039744392,
-0.0195978731,
0.006417017,
0.0187018216,
-0.0466844589,
-0.0203402229,
0.0425397642,
-0.066948317,
-0.0312682875,
-0.0046541202,
-0.0055290619,
0.0150329852,
0.0156639032,
-0.0256410316,
0.0119529674,
0.0049509704,
0.0124529498,
-0.0162459631,
0.0038355563,
-0.0228519179,
-0.0165562369,
0.0174110327,
-0.0542022064,
0.01372083,
-0.0452649333,
-0.0298254862,
-0.040177796,
-0.0130874906,
-0.0168142375,
0.0080731371,
-0.0294939913,
0.0359790437,
0.0309989844,
-0.0308043435,
-0.0298224241,
0.0466766767,
-0.0095329173,
0.022456456,
0.0490976796,
-0.0061518238,
0.0165517256,
-0.0878701434,
0.0369206183,
0.0132757304,
-0.0130779855,
-0.0090726372,
0.004198378,
0.0060344031,
-0.0534405448,
-0.0494199879,
-0.0825896114,
-0.0246832538,
0.0215847716,
0.0223015659,
0.0117371054,
0.0058379038,
-0.0494838208,
0.0048773079,
-0.0498025306,
0.0007828375,
0.0141014541,
-0.0206174348,
0.0251250174,
0.0142139643,
0.0250305701,
-0.0149884308,
0.0145216482,
0.0231128968,
0.0177623648,
0.0785978213,
-0.0055664526,
-0.0747772828,
0.0466252454,
-0.0072514336,
-0.0377618261,
-0.0019223393,
0.0280926619,
0.0047274251,
0.0118703889,
0.0502902493,
0.0203423221,
0.0441556647,
0.0028326798,
0.0150450356,
-0.0580688193,
-0.0628073663,
0.0230915509,
-0.0248425677,
0.0416257977,
-0.0080403564,
-0.0215981901,
0.0294515453,
-0.0043522851,
0.0435439385,
0.0559278578,
-0.0010884921,
-0.0241871178,
0.0208242107,
-0.0215587914,
0.0321231633,
-0.0249148682,
-0.0251830015,
0.0359843783,
0.0067854188,
-0.0670486242,
0.0063597453,
-0.0648973063,
-0.0270412173,
0.0271121301,
0.0190363843,
-0.0346114375,
0.0157586019,
-0.0347533859,
0.006885,
-0.0418003425,
-0.0182601325,
-0.0664433166,
-0.0165509544,
0.0380972922,
-0.0232182611,
0.00135217,
-0.0404646471,
-0.0308529846,
-0.058977142,
0.0376926437,
-0.0408530459,
0.0109405303,
0.0350117609,
-0.011231374,
-0.0418086015,
0.0123496568,
-0.0500255525,
0.0338571295,
0.0027394441,
-0.0054177288,
-0.0118687442,
-0.0271030646,
-0.0028468515,
0.0347943828,
-0.0131511139,
0.0060138097,
-0.0302707125,
-0.0488510691,
0.0188968554,
0.0136854863,
-0.0133157112,
-0.0020991876,
-0.023195684,
0.0240296535,
0.0031358446,
-0.0468214937,
-0.0019481578,
0.0155776152,
0.0250396635,
-0.0484955646,
0.0521451123,
0.1003173739,
0.0161563009,
-0.0392653495,
-0.0342861153,
-0.061471004,
0.0122266933,
0.0115099745,
0.026456777,
-0.0769453049,
0.0168077089,
0.0093972767,
0.0663014874,
0.0161552988,
-0.0006812925,
-0.0284415875,
-0.0739923343,
0.1105775461,
0.0350910723,
0.0523578748,
0.0226924084,
-0.0496761948,
0.0024512352,
0.0343683399,
0.0024357026,
0.0333606675,
-0.0335053876,
-0.0224490929,
0.0207491834,
-0.0469497889,
-0.0540245064,
-0.0438907892,
0.0000463046,
-0.0099448729,
0.0599568412,
0.0541401468,
-0.0013365552,
-0.056520544,
0.0223978758,
0.0297101084,
0.0178942103,
-0.0514868274,
0.0600332506,
-0.0170311984,
0.0141541129,
-0.0282932837,
0.0433268696,
0.0589623488,
-0.0289422777,
0.025116412,
0.0170326922,
-0.0621113218,
-0.0503365695,
-0.0274493732,
0.0348662995,
0.0018098193,
0.0373023786,
0.0360080712,
-0.017398661,
-0.0239297748,
-0.0200281106,
-0.0018522106,
-0.0364619419,
0.0014507817,
-0.0010363471,
-0.036506705,
0.0175610743,
-0.0703444034,
-0.0192051716,
0.0346502289,
0.0373627543,
-0.0023452414,
0.0108391782,
-0.0648558885,
0.0226721,
-0.0638401583,
-0.0093678143,
0.022626603,
-0.0084038367,
-0.0622912161,
-0.0084018949,
0.0337526537,
-0.0580160357,
-0.0036653643,
-0.0159521177,
-0.0375433452,
-0.0415099524,
-0.0577892773,
0.0438309014,
0.0236192439,
0.0427063666,
0.0475709625,
0.0076819854,
0.0962253585,
0.0193561018,
0.0038548685,
0.0312637761,
0.0273389276,
0.0676892325,
-0.0336371735,
-0.0324313045,
-0.0607044399,
-0.0100105954,
-0.0004323387,
0.0662021935,
0.0213216264,
-0.0548763424,
-0.039784763,
0.0500495881,
-0.0529197156,
-0.0595899858,
-0.0339681171,
-0.0088308575,
-0.0282987654,
-0.0305254795,
-0.0290974434,
-0.0436353087,
0.02972975,
-0.0153159043,
0.0205092095,
0.0286135525,
0.0238256976,
-0.0646885857,
-0.0102288397,
-0.0433151796,
0.0217418317,
-0.0020214743,
-0.0793779641,
-0.011954885,
0.0254121032,
-0.0016150844,
0.0010298121,
-0.0150069231,
0.0477665029,
-0.0113608893,
0.0941577554,
-0.0002341431,
0.047975298,
0.0303987674,
0.0402942635,
-0.0118020335,
-0.0203461237,
-0.0390781276,
0.0482751578,
0.0552747808,
0.0073620691,
0.0695005208,
-0.0355251022,
0.0255369358,
-0.0235742852,
0.0358411893,
-0.0110971313,
-0.0057869754,
-0.0236443114,
-0.008152985,
0.0024440256,
-0.0204970259,
0.0595876388,
-0.0411867462,
-0.0243847687,
-0.0296867937,
0.0057437043,
-0.067506887,
-0.075142473,
0.0638770163,
-0.0301866587,
0.0300432313,
-0.030345954,
-0.0583923981,
-0.0059934701,
0.0399341173,
-0.0022831708,
-0.023741968,
-0.0202872325,
0.0444868132,
0.0256428383,
-0.0021134219,
0.04797066,
-0.0272279102,
-0.0311631598,
0.0264061838,
-0.0020863833,
-0.0138692502,
-5.039447138e-33,
-0.0661428049,
-0.0736425221,
0.0519538485,
0.0508586839,
-0.0268284027,
-0.0473133214,
-0.0050913412,
0.0187664405,
0.0556125082,
-0.0045815902,
0.0216355789,
-0.0732093006,
0.0315942541,
0.0132323047,
0.0008697066,
0.0303735975,
0.0277509652,
-0.0306611005,
-0.0532505438,
0.0219705775,
-0.0061319256,
0.0081294077,
-0.0155537408,
-0.026542766,
0.0079878606,
-0.0010439816,
0.0023666106,
-0.0156579725,
0.0620635562,
0.0227611102,
0.0059193317,
-0.0161828082,
0.0261147097,
-0.0253723171,
-0.0422044545,
0.0451495238,
-0.0083656451,
-0.0236108229,
0.0227397103,
-0.0083887093,
-0.0402929895,
-0.0460340828,
0.0448597148,
-0.0236459207,
-0.0240690578,
-0.0310959611,
0.0524007902,
0.0069878651,
-0.0024797269,
-0.0923473388,
-0.026996633,
0.0302051678,
-0.0170499384,
-0.0340755619,
0.0164692216,
0.0285504144,
0.023433594,
-0.0089287721,
-0.0213326793,
0.0355729498,
0.0094307931,
-0.0026432429,
0.1196577102,
-0.0028399948,
-0.0146436132,
0.030367624,
0.0053369799,
0.0151306046,
-0.0224946029,
0.0307420604,
0.0066051441,
0.0860101655,
0.0245265923,
0.00121606,
-0.037501011,
0.0549320728,
-0.0034102905,
0.1029866338,
-0.0427298658,
0.0329608656,
0.0293776356,
-0.0064916634,
0.0388326533,
0.0160610247,
-0.0182973891,
0.0114100045,
-0.0036405972,
-0.0536149628,
0.023051599,
-0.0045199771,
0.0339224935,
-0.0699294657,
0.0554394871,
0.0576095283,
0.0043790727,
-0.0061818343,
-0.02922884,
0.0529837161,
-0.0016464982,
-0.0458837822,
0.0076980935,
-0.0472336411,
0.0206535682,
0.0153970784,
0.0202081334,
0.0223455951,
-0.0284448471,
0.023378171,
-0.0307514388,
0.0168765318,
-0.0083002672,
0.0134180924,
0.0149957826,
0.0129778013,
-0.0267804954,
-0.0633244962,
-0.0569972917,
0.0189168267,
-0.0349336676,
0.0005943325,
0.0121904993,
-0.0253819097,
0.0077575706,
0.017577488,
-0.0403063223,
0.0438250229,
0.0034155566,
0.0137077859,
0.0127423601,
0.0008625702,
-0.002027127,
0.0000633141,
2.414e-7,
0.0067856433,
0.0115070436,
0.027772082,
0.0544718765,
0.0146573633,
0.001701154,
-0.0325169079,
-0.0124392612,
0.0119041279,
-0.0112908147,
0.0359500572,
0.018376071,
0.0387080349,
0.0293331407,
-0.0831158236,
-0.0492399894,
-0.0059798569,
-0.0121879252,
-0.0425435081,
0.0024348837,
0.0653271824,
-0.0310491119,
-0.034653686,
-0.0299241859,
0.0100880098,
-0.0659151822,
0.0881379172,
-0.0175638888,
-0.0191371851,
0.0050459318,
0.034091685,
-0.0112458318,
-0.028021602,
-0.0002320181,
-0.0115442928,
-0.0069902418,
0.0035778142,
0.0700526461,
0.0217366125,
-0.0387166031,
0.026532907,
0.0088158427,
0.0075521916,
0.0128503833,
-0.0003703537,
-0.0188129004,
-0.0147393839,
0.0201799609,
-0.0366832353,
-0.014747086,
-0.027847359,
-0.0218332149,
0.0207125582,
0.0692393109,
0.0077318293,
-0.0220879633,
-0.0580207631,
-0.0130857565,
-0.0174183976,
-0.0338120461,
-0.0291994046,
-0.0437500328,
-0.0161087625,
0.0161275547,
-0.0159062352,
-0.0047131167,
-0.0538574941,
2.110293606e-34,
0.0232888367,
-0.0046879081,
-0.0030143813,
0.0350343995,
0.018852355,
0.0386043191,
-0.0213956647,
0.0215357412,
0.0045437086,
-0.0507624485,
-0.0157467965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00343v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00343v2
|
Beyond Metrics: Evaluating LLMs' Effectiveness in Culturally Nuanced, Low-Resource Real-World Scenarios
| 2024-06-01T07:36:59 | 2024-06-13T17:53:45 |
Millicent Ochieng, Varun Gumma, Sunayana Sitaram, Jindong Wang, Vishrav Chaudhary, Keshet Ronen, Kalika Bali, Jacki O'Neill
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The deployment of Large Language Models (LLMs) in real-world applications
presents both opportunities and challenges, particularly in multilingual and
code-mixed communication settings. This research evaluates the performance of
seven leading LLMs in sentiment analysis on a dataset derived from multilingual
and code-mixed WhatsApp chats, including Swahili, English and Sheng. Our
evaluation includes both quantitative analysis using metrics like F1 score and
qualitative assessment of LLMs' explanations for their predictions. We find
that, while Mistral-7b and Mixtral-8x7b achieved high F1 scores, they and other
LLMs such as GPT-3.5-Turbo, Llama-2-70b, and Gemma-7b struggled with
understanding linguistic and contextual nuances, as well as lack of
transparency in their decision-making process as observed from their
explanations. In contrast, GPT-4 and GPT-4-Turbo excelled in grasping diverse
linguistic inputs and managing various contextual information, demonstrating
high consistency with human alignment and transparency in their decision-making
process. The LLMs however, encountered difficulties in incorporating cultural
nuance especially in non-English settings with GPT-4s doing so inconsistently.
The findings emphasize the necessity of continuous improvement of LLMs to
effectively tackle the challenges of culturally nuanced, low-resource
real-world settings and the need for developing evaluation benchmarks for
capturing these issues.
|
[
0.0611317568,
0.0482722521,
-0.0317615122,
0.0452398136,
-0.0272390749,
0.0308062751,
0.0294007082,
-0.0347180292,
0.0199454352,
-0.0216609854,
-0.0455396138,
-0.0902335793,
0.0315357596,
0.0308228415,
-0.0039095413,
-0.0294092856,
0.0109843584,
-0.001388264,
0.0088414978,
-0.0234330837,
0.0281983968,
0.0442774966,
0.0307572596,
0.0571451448,
-0.0251580346,
-0.021322716,
-0.0024162063,
0.0206522997,
-0.0028581256,
-0.0204738341,
0.0126744052,
0.0285949931,
-0.0172979366,
0.0197776072,
0.0000024613,
-0.0389352292,
0.0039617405,
-0.0265000388,
0.0063886931,
0.0448474512,
0.1160476804,
-0.0223324597,
-0.0453662127,
0.0282137673,
-0.0615839921,
0.0237760078,
0.0647157729,
0.0007487545,
0.0422170609,
0.041778259,
-0.0041959011,
-0.0166174229,
-0.0237489771,
-0.0183160808,
-0.0413255878,
-0.0399883948,
0.0158572346,
0.0318743847,
-0.0006439845,
-0.0160890426,
-0.0163861252,
0.0223510843,
0.0251463689,
-0.0200260188,
-0.0489543565,
-0.0106441202,
-0.0353646688,
-0.0592564493,
-0.005987789,
0.0384351313,
0.0137180472,
-0.0001049526,
-0.0242244657,
-0.0074080615,
-0.0481821038,
-0.0508709811,
-0.0317465551,
0.0200201496,
-0.0121057946,
0.036355976,
-0.0043086912,
0.0354922265,
0.0382975042,
0.0270488728,
-0.0044934084,
0.0330020152,
-0.0367337912,
-0.0081283692,
-0.0154433157,
0.0214331914,
0.0170276612,
-0.035027802,
0.005042735,
0.012652644,
-0.0134087699,
0.0364168324,
0.0291204806,
0.0023551458,
0.0279114377,
-0.1139028743,
0.0075923209,
0.0730980858,
-0.0178001318,
0.031544935,
-0.0031056227,
0.0361392088,
-0.0013838033,
-0.017136557,
-0.0266860668,
-0.0400731154,
-0.0387787186,
-0.0131783094,
0.0437543802,
0.0090590296,
-0.0352947973,
0.0098419916,
-0.0801895261,
0.0143372165,
-0.0421410277,
-0.0065836567,
0.0261153672,
-0.0211984161,
0.013913055,
0.01427879,
-0.0133070219,
0.0487343818,
-0.0338482782,
0.0170826111,
-0.0390927717,
-0.0997542441,
0.0592004545,
0.0206182878,
-0.049146954,
-0.0085321516,
-0.0116219204,
0.0622021258,
0.0242684241,
-0.0242126677,
-0.0536038764,
0.0241523683,
-0.0337260775,
-0.0826306492,
-0.0335315913,
-0.0436340533,
0.0379511006,
0.0461751111,
0.0212011542,
-0.0323276222,
0.0144269001,
-0.0146931652,
-0.000475672,
0.0520324931,
-0.0000646059,
0.0399698727,
0.0297305919,
0.0399412252,
0.0011938631,
0.1147065088,
0.0183334164,
0.0178348962,
0.0506097525,
-0.0177974533,
-0.0372905508,
0.0333095752,
-0.0175007936,
0.0111216782,
-0.0549042933,
0.0232042447,
-0.024865916,
-0.0210743472,
0.0211342964,
0.0438147075,
0.0135291098,
0.0044486439,
0.0371847786,
0.0427605063,
-0.0043928814,
0.0611500889,
0.0386495069,
0.0142449103,
0.0013784831,
-0.0235563088,
-0.0152278868,
0.0272923596,
-0.0143252863,
-0.0435641892,
0.0112340981,
0.067125231,
-0.0295596235,
-0.0588451251,
-0.0183542725,
-0.026875142,
0.0363972224,
0.0126894973,
0.0180377755,
-0.0617264286,
0.0038532678,
0.0150254676,
0.0629427955,
-0.0521840081,
-0.031321995,
-0.0511091314,
0.0380493328,
0.1083225608,
-0.0052741552,
0.0147839785,
0.0072589517,
-0.0027841271,
-0.0014607621,
0.0295258518,
0.0359171033,
0.0071027158,
0.0073128948,
-0.042283088,
-0.0058617052,
0.0072937328,
-0.0102521824,
0.0296166707,
0.0302071422,
0.0680556297,
-0.0030416448,
0.0214341599,
-0.0563180596,
-0.0093028061,
-0.0379329138,
0.0274364073,
-0.0006364566,
-0.0055853156,
0.0535941683,
0.052964218,
-0.0063936966,
-0.0276420861,
-0.0169118922,
-0.0249354374,
-0.0118449414,
0.0543472134,
-0.0450961329,
-0.0049883579,
0.0338399485,
0.0091989255,
-0.0097690644,
0.0142504778,
-0.0261447374,
-0.0087893726,
0.0642210245,
0.0096450411,
0.0485903174,
-0.0505452491,
-0.0165429171,
-0.0578447059,
0.0183903649,
0.0121637415,
0.0372445211,
-0.0271358415,
-0.0074940613,
-0.0450806059,
-0.0177857559,
0.0193078779,
0.0425845236,
-0.0212764721,
0.0754540712,
0.012173593,
0.0179315377,
-0.0014239469,
0.0258616991,
-0.0108253974,
-0.047531601,
-0.1552107185,
-0.0185155179,
-0.0220125485,
-0.0054518664,
0.0209918879,
0.0387551673,
-0.0279284008,
0.0174265765,
-0.0279235542,
-0.0238565654,
0.0163830966,
0.035263069,
0.0103687914,
-0.0004432697,
0.001855979,
-0.0363946334,
0.0049330113,
0.0011953409,
0.0495844446,
0.0217869673,
-0.0282181688,
-0.0091117593,
-0.0214253683,
-0.0777844638,
-0.0363818221,
-0.0339198746,
-0.0818310082,
0.016963508,
0.0172198173,
0.0359815694,
0.0061276089,
-0.0074675106,
0.0249740388,
0.0259228796,
-0.0021749737,
-0.0353769064,
-0.0135486294,
-0.0015587813,
-0.0170639083,
-0.02249703,
-0.0614451393,
-0.0347215459,
0.0761007816,
0.0043965997,
0.0093157068,
-0.0440038741,
0.0323229693,
-0.0697981417,
-0.0340418853,
-0.0181477182,
-0.0240990724,
-0.0093653155,
0.0558633395,
-0.0091677578,
-0.0413135253,
0.0667142123,
-0.0020337596,
-0.0138400644,
-0.0464030877,
-0.0440125242,
-0.0749208108,
0.0441611633,
-0.0898818597,
0.0208244566,
-0.060218323,
0.0029489654,
0.0062135654,
-0.0368511491,
-0.0058711991,
-0.0435690284,
0.0427529886,
-0.0200248864,
0.0027153622,
0.000387245,
-0.0428065099,
0.0105546974,
-0.0206782743,
-0.0779565126,
-0.0042653442,
0.0466343313,
-0.0021241242,
0.0295295231,
0.0473855399,
0.0313676596,
-0.0512967482,
-0.0204102974,
0.00674289,
0.0176771991,
-0.0324958712,
-0.0119056487,
-0.039455723,
0.0666248277,
-0.0255222376,
0.0382352546,
0.0159233455,
0.0104992781,
-0.03781965,
-0.0166560691,
-0.0133682014,
0.0215324592,
0.0427707881,
-0.0275700279,
-0.0065860422,
0.0733286068,
-0.0425847918,
0.0515329242,
0.0954617783,
0.0198292267,
-0.0492427722,
0.0170051977,
-0.0652572811,
0.0268777832,
0.0068551074,
0.0175947454,
-0.0771799684,
-0.0208050143,
-0.0084088268,
0.0247207824,
-0.0155706573,
-0.0145957144,
0.0024186361,
-0.0964830741,
0.0219939481,
0.0216190368,
-0.0325723849,
-0.0372836962,
-0.0141095575,
-0.0274371561,
-0.0131096039,
0.0326972194,
-0.0325658806,
0.0125306742,
-0.0082015647,
0.0143874157,
-0.0636252686,
-0.0548294708,
0.0489073321,
-0.0151477093,
0.0385512523,
0.0560985021,
0.0259143803,
-0.0135962646,
-0.0169079993,
0.0247876365,
-0.0008791707,
-0.0039290888,
-0.0080645066,
-0.008770531,
0.010783134,
-0.0301279798,
-0.032161206,
-0.0226754136,
-0.0398533046,
0.0222265236,
-0.0017132628,
0.040937271,
-0.0011525897,
-0.0080666943,
-0.0205158833,
0.0256757028,
0.0201413576,
0.0577318594,
0.0377357341,
-0.088465251,
-0.0177193936,
-0.0334863998,
-0.009765299,
0.0244611781,
-0.0509891324,
0.0153734842,
0.0006327193,
-0.0396345407,
-0.0353923552,
-0.0677278712,
-0.0152923344,
-0.0202519353,
-0.0031340779,
0.022509519,
0.0159128066,
0.0047766929,
-0.0025737928,
0.021635253,
0.0055129966,
0.0474532545,
-0.0114343101,
0.0317104161,
0.029421486,
-0.0271502826,
0.0295140538,
-0.0081030261,
-0.0612905733,
-0.0336203016,
0.0175049156,
0.0343740769,
0.0184779167,
0.0070127114,
0.0152750108,
-0.0728794932,
-0.0166869573,
0.031180637,
-0.021699205,
0.017754728,
0.0391949415,
0.0773012862,
0.0192689486,
0.0518312342,
-0.0071144523,
0.0657482371,
0.0098188613,
0.0109442407,
-0.0196461808,
-0.0216385517,
-0.0259753801,
-0.0220480189,
-0.0007395652,
-0.0266178306,
-0.0568185709,
-0.004677773,
0.0027951968,
-0.0228669681,
-0.0180375203,
-0.0427013487,
-0.0272017941,
0.0221090764,
0.0110522676,
-0.0318220668,
-0.0280569773,
-0.0210940279,
-0.0034987358,
-0.0175888594,
0.0887344554,
0.031199431,
0.0171816796,
0.0141756795,
0.0415008068,
-0.0170361381,
0.0096738758,
-0.0103785852,
0.0081912884,
-0.0104009844,
0.0565532036,
-0.006290901,
-0.0143208969,
0.0562973097,
0.0167417638,
0.0121554881,
-0.0325912237,
0.0126244472,
0.0125866942,
0.0591887794,
0.0080560418,
0.0726667047,
0.0081573669,
0.008895414,
-0.0274825338,
0.0314850211,
-0.0290385168,
-0.0311216358,
0.0214130618,
0.0066920677,
-0.0512168221,
0.033731427,
0.0594750941,
-0.055862613,
0.0121491551,
0.0079894615,
-0.0158386659,
-0.0020338902,
-0.0175648499,
0.0363543071,
-0.0003128372,
-0.0227763634,
0.0205927938,
-0.117522262,
-0.0671522394,
0.0244138483,
-0.0328798108,
-0.0127601037,
-0.0387015343,
-0.006946322,
0.0655732229,
0.0093303109,
0.0398803614,
-0.0672032163,
-0.0382233933,
-0.0304539688,
-0.0003817642,
0.0346210077,
-7.301663975e-33,
0.0051372456,
-0.0119053163,
-0.0146384174,
-0.0163174663,
-0.0201401152,
0.0116336579,
-0.0414734222,
0.0195699409,
-0.0288442597,
0.0212201197,
-0.0085074725,
0.0245286357,
0.0055745333,
0.0209702626,
0.0432905518,
0.0082119498,
0.0042542932,
0.0046657952,
0.0017388661,
0.0363784768,
0.0297139529,
0.0305214748,
0.0287243668,
-0.1238844767,
0.0643927082,
-0.0105272625,
-0.0197335891,
0.0054539014,
0.0346860848,
0.060409788,
-0.047337193,
0.0622424036,
0.0288207587,
-0.0017426298,
-0.0025756077,
-0.0009661457,
-0.0138854347,
-0.0106131285,
0.0483169332,
0.0295090452,
0.0229616556,
-0.017873114,
0.0181989316,
-0.0111024268,
-0.0482612103,
0.0310207345,
0.0064485441,
-0.0360794663,
0.0055235275,
-0.0250335354,
-0.0308731534,
0.0504207127,
-0.0032079883,
0.0217968542,
0.0085935015,
0.0661051795,
-0.0413505696,
0.0373563021,
-0.0769573525,
-0.0054734051,
-0.0035588809,
-0.0178723242,
0.0540600978,
-0.0023750258,
-0.0082338341,
0.0668437779,
0.0381641164,
0.0136886677,
-0.0330607854,
-0.0068420772,
0.0234022103,
0.0000704411,
0.0229846034,
0.0783029124,
-0.0346644036,
-0.0466165952,
-0.0666191876,
-0.0277970172,
0.0330756493,
-0.0081226584,
0.0680167824,
0.0079026008,
-0.0817793682,
-0.0565034151,
0.0284835864,
-0.0046769683,
-0.0242874697,
-0.0512890592,
0.0180814695,
-0.0267368425,
-0.0247759148,
-0.0096587315,
0.0286272038,
-0.0690994412,
-0.0068262829,
0.0206936058,
-0.0239469409,
0.0299565177,
0.0444412492,
0.0460540242,
-0.0610288493,
0.0181583446,
-0.0435429551,
0.0130727682,
0.0010581823,
0.004863909,
0.0275309514,
0.0255337395,
-0.0554965287,
0.0108803511,
-0.0262033381,
0.0270524062,
-0.0251150299,
0.0111156804,
0.0179794189,
-0.0043598772,
-0.0266584065,
0.0445148163,
0.0464988649,
0.0352100395,
0.0055896314,
-0.0356602147,
-0.0154027846,
0.021646658,
-0.0672547668,
-0.0336861871,
-0.0246878881,
0.0121359546,
0.0338482372,
-0.0282363426,
-0.0214123707,
0.0085929018,
3.194e-7,
0.0334303342,
0.0544206388,
-0.0453559346,
-0.0273974147,
0.0332771577,
0.0419954062,
-0.0271490738,
-0.0125433402,
0.0122990161,
-0.0028562699,
0.0077966875,
0.0309372731,
0.0854537338,
0.063695237,
-0.0749185234,
0.0233212188,
-0.0638657063,
-0.0197807979,
-0.0486150682,
0.0477999821,
0.0129232733,
0.1032133475,
0.0420881994,
-0.0070628603,
-0.0541263111,
-0.0109462561,
0.0506963022,
-0.0517763048,
-0.0147567783,
0.0018079302,
0.0159488413,
0.0141588673,
-0.0029652563,
-0.0321754329,
0.0139389681,
0.0205325764,
0.0134205315,
0.0757406354,
-0.0016149294,
-0.0115181683,
0.023507392,
-0.0001622969,
-0.0256376546,
-0.0947668329,
0.0645219535,
-0.014505757,
-0.0750304386,
-0.0513663217,
0.0248232521,
-0.0310439821,
0.0461552143,
-0.0100036971,
-0.0188895687,
0.0367683508,
0.0001352662,
-0.0546941832,
-0.0236052684,
-0.030861266,
0.0090056052,
0.0122899478,
-0.0055945087,
-0.0321794152,
-0.0218133423,
0.0280489139,
0.0221530385,
-0.0059248465,
0.064744167,
2.80818575e-34,
0.0633177534,
-0.0255021062,
0.0021801484,
0.0099249398,
0.0448027998,
0.0191138517,
-0.0065097236,
-0.0061290795,
0.0199884027,
0.0078688525,
0.0218068864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06555v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06555v1
|
An Evaluation Benchmark for Autoformalization in Lean4
| 2024-06-01T07:06:57 | 2024-06-01T07:06:57 |
Aryan Gulati, Devanshu Ladsaria, Shubhra Mishra, Jasdeep Sidhu, Brando Miranda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) hold the potential to revolutionize
autoformalization. The introduction of Lean4, a mathematical programming
language, presents an unprecedented opportunity to rigorously assess the
autoformalization capabilities of LLMs. This paper introduces a novel
evaluation benchmark designed for Lean4, applying it to test the abilities of
state-of-the-art LLMs, including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Gemini Pro. Our
comprehensive analysis reveals that, despite recent advancements, these LLMs
still exhibit limitations in autoformalization, particularly in more complex
areas of mathematics. These findings underscore the need for further
development in LLMs to fully harness their potential in scientific research and
development. This study not only benchmarks current LLM capabilities but also
sets the stage for future enhancements in autoformalization.
|
[
-0.0735991523,
0.0780430585,
-0.0250310227,
0.0011691302,
-0.0185147021,
-0.011826992,
-0.0023378509,
-0.0175715107,
-0.0438703187,
-0.0621798076,
-0.0294332877,
-0.0013803487,
-0.0097158672,
0.0668896362,
0.0293977018,
-0.0430466682,
0.0702552646,
-0.0329411104,
-0.0217192452,
0.0248461794,
-0.0134249115,
-0.0117724873,
-0.0006970072,
0.0252786577,
-0.0270053763,
-0.0313512608,
0.0146924444,
-0.0085143046,
-0.0211350638,
-0.02607047,
-0.0268920846,
0.0811736658,
-0.0163335949,
0.0460687354,
0.0000022009,
-0.0582246482,
-0.0478839353,
0.0498970672,
-0.0081206644,
0.1130483449,
0.0153775932,
-0.0321069695,
-0.0195916407,
-0.0095708081,
-0.0453233123,
-0.020852685,
0.0253261272,
-0.0532285757,
0.0582614094,
0.0320687853,
-0.0148482267,
-0.0419209935,
0.0763143301,
-0.0173750557,
-0.0102761816,
-0.0478832163,
0.015903417,
0.0228645112,
0.0113469064,
-0.0060715731,
0.0227071568,
0.0343027003,
0.0288957823,
-0.0187762845,
0.0125596765,
0.0033019816,
-0.0804417804,
0.0059691276,
-0.0024446291,
0.0155133838,
-0.0007725569,
-0.0354314968,
0.0021587843,
-0.0363903232,
-0.0316245779,
-0.0041121668,
-0.0526338629,
0.0139456997,
0.0262145083,
-0.0131527167,
-0.0086289234,
-0.0013861232,
0.0237839743,
-0.0115179634,
-0.0397106893,
0.0787771791,
0.0388696529,
-0.023914393,
-0.0358509272,
-0.013655792,
-0.0765988752,
-0.0358011201,
0.0154064866,
0.0454523638,
0.003004198,
-0.0297264177,
-0.0588436499,
0.0062447451,
0.0361848474,
-0.0161885545,
0.0297047738,
0.0322590321,
-0.000625322,
-0.0090000983,
0.0032218636,
0.0776967704,
-0.0177070852,
-0.0596094206,
-0.0096741291,
0.0543053746,
-0.0127691235,
-0.0102815041,
-0.063248083,
0.0121683599,
0.0202056747,
0.013794966,
-0.0645108297,
0.04522641,
-0.049892012,
0.0429068431,
-0.0070718848,
-0.0745185465,
-0.0171187557,
-0.020107029,
0.0184962917,
0.0162774902,
0.0097183716,
-0.0535715707,
0.0018872874,
-0.0866915137,
0.0080740694,
0.0141372494,
-0.0483217388,
-0.0381094888,
-0.0254346952,
0.0495576002,
0.0361358635,
0.0342312194,
-0.0076569156,
-0.0176798049,
0.0282266643,
-0.0172150563,
-0.0409456305,
-0.0850087255,
-0.0100299316,
0.0369974561,
0.0091107562,
-0.0324798189,
-0.0218214486,
-0.0178601108,
0.0636078194,
0.0414066985,
-0.0184550527,
0.0109710786,
0.0157599989,
-0.0131129296,
0.0146335503,
0.0298305247,
0.0408609323,
-0.0275764819,
0.0125007685,
-0.044958543,
0.0452306569,
0.0809903219,
-0.0197694283,
0.0062919743,
-0.0427524708,
0.0296626668,
0.0570102483,
0.0464562997,
0.000824213,
0.0671358481,
-0.0160807744,
0.0522642918,
0.0025595527,
0.0251024254,
0.0410511866,
0.0208244342,
0.03506051,
0.0233090539,
0.0561312586,
-0.0237644278,
-0.0693525076,
-0.0047042053,
-0.0161163323,
0.0608172901,
0.0134513248,
0.0292770788,
-0.0008404352,
-0.0686701015,
-0.0438722558,
0.0138096875,
-0.0623603612,
-0.0405744314,
0.0458801799,
-0.0068451818,
-0.016335411,
0.1026765853,
-0.0208569746,
-0.0363915414,
-0.0333037563,
-0.0452668294,
-0.0090976981,
-0.0160429478,
0.0420739837,
-0.0963191539,
-0.0275875703,
-0.0352741741,
0.0079689743,
0.0040198197,
0.1058652997,
0.0080224285,
-0.0345490985,
-0.0309029371,
0.0141047863,
-0.0146889035,
0.0247596577,
0.000397347,
0.0079321554,
-0.0097359885,
0.0194108691,
-0.0086645391,
-0.0622151457,
0.0256685019,
-0.0194512457,
-0.0227016732,
-0.000989833,
-0.0073648836,
0.0094126761,
0.0044432972,
-0.0504253693,
0.0505684912,
0.0009746914,
0.0056993496,
0.030702332,
-0.0494521558,
-0.0148255965,
0.055471085,
0.0554556698,
-0.0031469916,
-0.069204554,
-0.0159331094,
-0.032320071,
-0.022681864,
0.0435796827,
-0.0000276886,
0.0412564948,
-0.0096155088,
0.0490672365,
-0.0049596676,
-0.0276994817,
-0.031549789,
0.0320819579,
0.0128094889,
0.0190411471,
-0.0506835021,
-0.0058752801,
0.0592260063,
-0.0111130057,
-0.034810666,
0.0039744577,
-0.0074163484,
0.0337612927,
-0.0245231539,
0.0046228669,
-0.0074771927,
-0.0273872856,
-0.0183766186,
0.0060637346,
-0.0099170264,
0.04136068,
0.011122019,
0.0391799621,
-0.0063037146,
0.0405693874,
-0.0019031839,
-0.0286550447,
-0.0222476814,
0.0338582583,
0.0536209531,
-0.0128416456,
-0.0388565101,
-0.0467041582,
-0.0318291448,
-0.0581420399,
0.0271973368,
0.0209081341,
0.0330289602,
-0.0371998362,
0.0575378165,
0.0113682188,
-0.0016764331,
-0.0119078998,
0.0007122639,
0.0143611692,
-0.0284774732,
0.0687973797,
0.05017896,
-0.031466648,
0.0004970245,
0.0087820739,
0.0068098027,
-0.0165901612,
-0.0110483719,
0.017968731,
-0.0011118953,
0.0199804511,
-0.0325121582,
0.0357313491,
0.0526243374,
-0.0424253568,
-0.0112889828,
-0.0102206254,
0.0249653347,
-0.0421175733,
0.0196391288,
-0.0076182117,
0.0140547296,
-0.0298087783,
0.0399689339,
0.0265667271,
-0.0718531087,
0.0300662052,
-0.0632868409,
-0.0043351357,
-0.0097540189,
0.0061288164,
-0.0763795823,
0.0131598283,
0.0233917609,
-0.0319046788,
-0.0214496702,
-0.0478037111,
-0.0039346688,
0.0010142392,
0.0409548357,
-0.0151495803,
0.0825710148,
-0.0081868563,
0.0357361175,
-0.0098627508,
-0.0058548846,
-0.0001801957,
0.0482705273,
-0.0261813253,
0.0602466278,
0.061951302,
-0.0334915891,
-0.0109412698,
0.0716101527,
-0.0025353278,
0.0357327759,
-0.0214969087,
-0.0011329206,
-0.0074746963,
-0.0237111878,
-0.0032211489,
-0.039532885,
0.0277791824,
-0.0420856029,
-0.0075717242,
-0.0174938757,
0.0435352921,
0.009329753,
-0.0511789247,
-0.0156129533,
0.0143567091,
-0.0882487744,
-0.0757658109,
0.0184878502,
0.0003623108,
-0.0371477939,
0.0201352444,
0.1034152582,
0.0005433717,
-0.0259215757,
0.0258198567,
-0.0387287699,
0.0473782755,
0.0317237563,
0.0385077856,
-0.0657176673,
0.0141600976,
0.0033453831,
0.027194364,
0.0309283677,
-0.0223723575,
0.0200480148,
-0.062863037,
0.0606271252,
0.0220583901,
-0.0621147379,
-0.0066861291,
-0.0188755337,
-0.003487586,
-0.0400976837,
-0.0011386271,
0.0453009866,
-0.0413012281,
0.0143095255,
0.0021952325,
-0.0986689776,
-0.0136453155,
-0.0293871649,
-0.0146027934,
0.002643032,
0.0254047606,
0.0159955528,
-0.0407641158,
-0.0443154424,
0.0951509699,
0.0591612272,
-0.0268256981,
-0.0422045104,
-0.024011502,
0.0064032646,
-0.0086472072,
0.0158023052,
0.0003436842,
-0.0216370802,
-0.00467622,
0.032206215,
0.0893862322,
0.0056843902,
0.0127966171,
-0.0102219554,
-0.0330369584,
-0.0257265978,
0.0257615112,
0.0445759036,
0.0362717658,
-0.0657649934,
-0.0559622161,
-0.0185229909,
-0.0354245082,
-0.0315452665,
-0.0378335528,
-0.0137185389,
-0.0048353393,
0.0314443,
-0.0116578704,
0.0404931456,
0.019805396,
0.006590222,
-0.0272482056,
-0.0081928521,
-0.0166192651,
-0.0546673946,
0.0239581205,
-0.0244867373,
0.0378343165,
-0.0692652091,
-0.0202414989,
-0.007985292,
0.0394994877,
-0.0267835166,
0.034158852,
-0.0502692759,
-0.0358577073,
0.0171517339,
0.0645171553,
0.034592703,
0.0036690244,
-0.009091571,
-0.0366482437,
-0.0266158041,
0.0375339836,
-0.042313695,
0.0067622322,
-0.002438938,
0.0074375817,
0.0036983008,
-0.0072095669,
-0.0025816869,
-0.0141831692,
-0.0107786236,
0.042472966,
-0.000490092,
-0.0603665113,
-0.000969324,
0.0868577808,
-0.0212199632,
0.0010613844,
0.0133132478,
0.0117553556,
-0.0432139412,
-0.0369541533,
-0.0040581604,
-0.0436240733,
0.0532502756,
0.0168733876,
0.0198067948,
0.0139373848,
0.0233077332,
-0.0386242233,
0.0497413278,
0.015675379,
0.0634251311,
-0.0276270621,
0.0742033646,
0.0555289984,
-0.0345411412,
-0.000968648,
0.0057975096,
0.0017208518,
0.0584833026,
-0.0235151127,
0.0211466029,
-0.0050072493,
0.0639612079,
-0.0141101135,
0.0013675768,
-0.0154620698,
-0.0731078088,
-0.0242915954,
-0.0048051029,
-0.0026380154,
0.0297724344,
0.0646246672,
-0.0301447213,
-0.0182512514,
-0.0207051616,
0.0349784233,
0.012815292,
0.0198000278,
-0.028142605,
0.0326512009,
-0.0198901482,
-0.0483770929,
0.0774152502,
0.0293074213,
-0.0083366921,
-0.0077881534,
-0.00581775,
-0.0421618186,
-0.0047925808,
0.0313014798,
-0.0049053254,
-0.0198293235,
-0.0324235894,
-0.097866118,
-0.0494616926,
-0.0007907567,
0.031232914,
-0.0124268392,
-0.0280563217,
0.0147254271,
0.0994057879,
0.0028655217,
-0.0264254417,
0.0340474322,
0.0353406109,
-0.002033761,
-0.0222318154,
-0.0040532569,
-5.516195688e-33,
-0.0282409862,
0.02083336,
0.0285725687,
0.0094479872,
-0.0279039051,
0.0120459143,
-0.0184741262,
0.0250979606,
0.041600924,
0.0135947289,
-0.0066038864,
0.0111773238,
-0.0003654352,
-0.0326372385,
0.0358159542,
0.0287093297,
0.0326372534,
-0.0294316318,
-0.0475097075,
-0.0169281717,
-0.0695381016,
0.0193622522,
0.058999043,
0.0051711593,
0.0122826155,
-0.0262277555,
0.0126898456,
-0.0125169251,
-0.0095526418,
0.0462093055,
-0.0013866909,
0.0090321116,
-0.0157253314,
-0.0331640653,
-0.0339165553,
-0.0385636985,
-0.0212267786,
-0.0298334789,
0.0217387788,
0.0214192886,
0.0210895594,
-0.0301515255,
0.0449869819,
0.0024940816,
-0.0964009687,
-0.0264723394,
-0.0073276539,
-0.0017279125,
-0.037476819,
-0.0084389774,
-0.0642922074,
0.0660904199,
0.0048563853,
0.0330587365,
0.0160255916,
-0.0155787477,
-0.039281439,
0.003165199,
0.0016589895,
0.0019296057,
0.0308857951,
0.0778160393,
0.0602424964,
-0.0209627282,
0.0141034937,
-0.0112155946,
0.0373978727,
0.0230084043,
-0.0458373055,
0.0352094769,
0.0466148928,
0.036483597,
0.0286209229,
-0.0218112953,
-0.0025469519,
0.0106509235,
-0.0150531111,
0.0100328857,
-0.0196459237,
0.0015453951,
-0.0429155938,
0.0077821915,
-0.040629603,
-0.0144187622,
-0.0106799006,
-0.0166395921,
-0.0295670945,
-0.0106779644,
-0.0056584175,
-0.0603564084,
-0.0279121194,
0.0682691634,
0.02443753,
-0.014329453,
-0.0429777615,
0.0111820018,
-0.0104545588,
0.0413973965,
-0.0130588599,
0.0550278462,
-0.0333891213,
-0.0179607291,
-0.0434750058,
0.0519076623,
0.0601222515,
-0.0042729476,
-0.0084824786,
0.0089935577,
-0.0585209578,
-0.0043605696,
-0.0084647611,
-0.0190776754,
0.0212091785,
0.0173130631,
0.034715198,
0.010888692,
0.0556617826,
0.0222442057,
0.0063509364,
-0.0442544259,
-0.0363243781,
0.0734487846,
0.0055759847,
0.0477337763,
0.0171773899,
-0.0208211392,
-0.0501095019,
0.0017966437,
0.0620926507,
-0.0289962701,
-0.0438789949,
-0.005329655,
2.857e-7,
0.0680929124,
0.0584644042,
0.064808175,
0.0197452251,
-0.0173701104,
0.0064415736,
-0.0094572539,
-0.0305717587,
0.0112761054,
0.0596629642,
-0.0044186343,
0.0140878484,
0.0439249314,
0.0123642534,
0.0017901736,
0.0236787703,
-0.0442948528,
-0.0000173812,
-0.0784679726,
-0.0208482295,
0.022596838,
0.0146741495,
0.0072971289,
0.0188004542,
-0.0326130874,
-0.0570429638,
0.0187652204,
0.0023294401,
-0.0011490884,
0.0964579582,
-0.0098244762,
-0.0169423837,
-0.0098938439,
-0.0368979685,
0.0186109468,
0.006581896,
0.0556322336,
0.0927848741,
0.0099868383,
0.0622951426,
0.0289691165,
-0.0369908921,
-0.0088884002,
-0.0913276747,
0.0369243063,
-0.0427569598,
-0.0143074719,
-0.0071611162,
-0.0670346767,
-0.0418199822,
0.0236300118,
0.0091726333,
0.0418932512,
0.0320826285,
0.0248212013,
0.0070713526,
-0.0192807652,
0.0007103861,
-0.0518505238,
0.0267194584,
-0.0362459049,
-0.026434781,
-0.0367019437,
0.0291937198,
0.013272048,
0.023965653,
-0.0262997877,
3.242213851e-34,
0.0770249367,
-0.0307377353,
0.0704225674,
0.0629340038,
0.0296685975,
0.0171767902,
-0.0118868118,
0.0284749437,
-0.026125839,
-0.0520093963,
0.0024911114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00318v1
|
KGLink: A column type annotation method that combines knowledge graph and pre-trained language model
| 2024-06-01T06:28:41 | 2024-06-01T06:28:41 |
Yubo Wang, Hao Xin, Lei Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The semantic annotation of tabular data plays a crucial role in various
downstream tasks. Previous research has proposed knowledge graph (KG)-based and
deep learning-based methods, each with its inherent limitations. KG-based
methods encounter difficulties annotating columns when there is no match for
column cells in the KG. Moreover, KG-based methods can provide multiple
predictions for one column, making it challenging to determine the semantic
type with the most suitable granularity for the dataset. This type granularity
issue limits their scalability.
On the other hand, deep learning-based methods face challenges related to the
valuable context missing issue. This occurs when the information within the
table is insufficient for determining the correct column type.
This paper presents KGLink, a method that combines WikiData KG information
with a pre-trained deep learning language model for table column annotation,
effectively addressing both type granularity and valuable context missing
issues. Through comprehensive experiments on widely used tabular datasets
encompassing numeric and string columns with varying type granularity, we
showcase the effectiveness and efficiency of KGLink. By leveraging the
strengths of KGLink, we successfully surmount challenges related to type
granularity and valuable context issues, establishing it as a robust solution
for the semantic annotation of tabular data.
|
[
-0.0049559805,
0.0556707196,
0.0003029196,
0.0210738014,
0.0306843389,
0.0442508981,
-0.0269560646,
0.0297880918,
0.03392151,
-0.0490466729,
0.0089384122,
0.0102338139,
-0.0113187721,
0.0539721809,
0.0510791726,
-0.0101426812,
0.0302247535,
0.0236568972,
-0.0267730393,
0.047209654,
0.002382545,
-0.0015224784,
0.0059147486,
0.0239359196,
-0.0634134561,
-0.0029083877,
-0.0374353938,
-0.0065737492,
-0.0469958149,
0.003807826,
0.0145111149,
0.0585908256,
0.025466755,
0.0489370972,
0.0000020084,
-0.0068327594,
-0.0285465121,
-0.0129633974,
-0.03224314,
0.0001770062,
0.0059401933,
-0.0519053116,
-0.0020875565,
-0.0381568857,
-0.0130435927,
-0.052298408,
0.0231258273,
0.031706892,
0.0303586219,
0.0355724581,
-0.0115678664,
-0.0158989746,
0.0371403545,
0.0040968722,
0.0773439854,
-0.0396427251,
0.019654166,
0.0347103924,
-0.0417541713,
-0.0162789486,
0.0098704128,
0.0606854446,
0.0233837888,
-0.0473778248,
0.0037098364,
0.0329689905,
-0.0475360192,
0.0323289931,
0.0067598643,
0.0901649743,
-0.0048842542,
-0.0016640573,
0.0136670806,
-0.0215087626,
0.0290975608,
-0.0399740413,
-0.0105479341,
-0.0412648544,
-0.0017154659,
-0.0170973279,
-0.0018429065,
0.0086014904,
0.020764919,
0.0018867349,
-0.030571308,
0.0571103431,
-0.0481447726,
0.0048029278,
0.0181044471,
-0.015914822,
0.0146262171,
-0.0473829471,
0.0181332454,
0.0465197116,
0.0046586939,
0.0236398578,
-0.0116565889,
-0.0364309885,
0.0304341931,
-0.0841644183,
0.004685868,
0.0189005025,
-0.0089569427,
0.0156439804,
-0.0524937585,
-0.0042068847,
-0.0306428745,
0.0175207052,
0.0027585065,
-0.0415606312,
-0.0405908898,
-0.0170549192,
-0.0364933535,
0.014138232,
-0.0214041807,
0.0077303564,
-0.0181194358,
0.0133594191,
-0.0269023031,
0.0843310729,
0.0191031098,
0.0169490557,
-0.0167554989,
-0.0127260592,
-0.0560226105,
0.0327440761,
-0.0238061473,
0.0027031174,
-0.0097183315,
-0.0398530215,
0.0242600273,
0.0012326839,
0.0454028733,
-0.020583529,
0.0221569706,
0.0798780769,
-0.0026063556,
0.0263183694,
-0.0742688403,
-0.0787467882,
-0.0125043597,
-0.0034801785,
0.0005396383,
-0.0674513429,
0.013163507,
0.0077895764,
-0.0224571489,
-0.0735620707,
-0.006141637,
0.0145084159,
-0.032370694,
0.0799776912,
-0.0926146358,
-0.0219508037,
0.0099933017,
-0.0300411526,
-0.0382776856,
0.0308795292,
0.0410345234,
0.006264986,
0.0044043129,
-0.0089407656,
-0.0146784335,
0.0258208793,
0.0308122803,
-0.0384567529,
-0.0050159185,
0.025218185,
0.0058334558,
0.0420681424,
-0.000249377,
-0.0125133824,
-0.0035417152,
-0.0106557366,
0.03123408,
0.027833838,
0.0266974531,
0.0665579513,
0.0254496131,
0.008075756,
0.0280315429,
-0.0130045647,
-0.0091433125,
0.0128601594,
0.0171289276,
0.016962193,
0.0110780131,
-0.0019561269,
-0.0306564737,
-0.0608562306,
0.0067395065,
-0.0340108797,
0.0161914453,
-0.0218080059,
0.0462810732,
0.0252473205,
-0.0323881805,
0.0198900737,
0.0254444815,
-0.0288855918,
-0.0133091956,
0.0089431945,
0.0245228279,
0.0855726302,
0.0096346065,
-0.0674958378,
-0.0523524731,
-0.0085235648,
0.0139656197,
-0.000342395,
0.0339460969,
-0.0723707154,
-0.0330344401,
-0.0190971587,
-0.0091783945,
0.0338938944,
0.0237154607,
-0.0337102786,
-0.0175328404,
0.0261253919,
0.0201053824,
-0.0689445138,
-0.0461945869,
0.0109080654,
0.0707572624,
-0.0101052755,
-0.0007698524,
0.0122774206,
-0.0216372516,
0.0654661283,
0.0161996949,
0.0156274978,
0.0359633937,
-0.001386678,
0.0044816528,
-0.0271970965,
-0.0181204472,
-0.0062590051,
0.0261831675,
0.0454206169,
-0.0531228483,
-0.0524511859,
-0.0344744287,
-0.0317300148,
0.007198018,
0.017145263,
-0.002716935,
-0.0063092811,
-0.0059638349,
0.003330023,
-0.0050860466,
-0.006803418,
0.0649160296,
-0.0030874899,
0.0082150884,
-0.020284567,
-0.0740449727,
0.0360765159,
-0.0022670713,
-0.0148917129,
-0.0137512088,
-0.0220901389,
0.0548024327,
0.0133265313,
0.0047453442,
-0.0652832016,
0.0313886404,
-0.0884347185,
0.0284488015,
-0.0168855824,
0.0352826118,
-0.0045710183,
0.0044778008,
0.0096841007,
-0.0429674163,
-0.0621906109,
0.0320862085,
-0.0421359316,
-0.0023979831,
0.0792692602,
0.0224035922,
0.0292254724,
-0.0208736546,
-0.037057288,
-0.0633328706,
0.0389592759,
0.0044942074,
-0.0358979292,
0.0248575006,
-0.0043100142,
-0.021115547,
0.0190649442,
0.0108430712,
0.0288923439,
-0.0096170222,
-0.0202633236,
-0.0004638933,
0.0228482615,
-0.0497408807,
0.0343638323,
-0.0106647676,
-0.0175346322,
-0.0439220071,
0.0296523292,
0.0095210718,
0.0302391481,
-0.0153039489,
0.0020101489,
0.0094079152,
0.0415490717,
-0.0456730314,
-0.0041946885,
-0.0241695736,
-0.0053640157,
0.0190775264,
0.043866396,
-0.0727455243,
0.0600157119,
0.0267387778,
0.0075187418,
-0.0140463747,
0.0174551588,
0.0187820438,
-0.0161181763,
0.0318448767,
0.0072187809,
-0.0096035842,
-0.0224350505,
0.0824756473,
0.0053733978,
-0.0196812097,
-0.0334132239,
-0.0157064851,
-0.0183835756,
0.0175957736,
-0.0049353321,
-0.0205722023,
0.1120888144,
-0.0072136465,
0.0216845386,
-0.0241263527,
-0.0041685058,
-0.0088875284,
0.0122431479,
-0.0373554006,
0.0551998504,
0.0331761762,
-0.0050825118,
0.0015953175,
-0.0194999445,
-0.0070960117,
0.0953661278,
0.0377379321,
-0.0283260271,
-0.0406371467,
0.0558435991,
0.012505386,
0.0035154342,
-0.0388881974,
0.0302131269,
0.0022302668,
0.0183264147,
-0.055703409,
-0.0253082514,
-0.0265376363,
0.0201015305,
-0.0155156115,
-0.0519086979,
-0.0507671349,
0.0451257415,
-0.0290896371,
-0.1113091931,
0.0234022103,
0.0631585121,
0.0298850257,
-0.042952396,
-0.0223741718,
0.0205040388,
0.0243381746,
0.0141699575,
0.0289885644,
-0.1356243938,
-0.041136343,
-0.0129713118,
-0.0373954736,
0.0142396167,
-0.0677550882,
0.020444449,
-0.0681706518,
0.0116351489,
-0.0406549908,
-0.0583928116,
-0.0560332648,
-0.0455609784,
-0.0118022924,
-0.0392297991,
0.0110366773,
0.0174799319,
0.0159922447,
0.0197195467,
0.0330777541,
-0.0595849864,
-0.0669488832,
-0.0220311768,
-0.0861673653,
0.0655053183,
0.0207603499,
0.0383121558,
-0.0219954494,
-0.018041512,
-0.005745681,
0.0521909222,
-0.0224704798,
0.0010800053,
0.078959614,
-0.0136222504,
-0.0029949776,
-0.0015324974,
-0.0104523841,
-0.0410347059,
0.0161057003,
0.0038205215,
0.103877157,
-0.0141683118,
0.0034412264,
0.0156920813,
-0.0854489729,
-0.0031716924,
0.0381364077,
0.0255316161,
0.0095079504,
-0.0332459137,
-0.0574122593,
-0.0363541767,
-0.0573187657,
0.0110105248,
0.0379103385,
-0.0436306298,
-0.0336560197,
-0.049649518,
-0.0455325209,
0.0676193982,
0.0023609928,
-0.0165454242,
0.066539906,
-0.0092564179,
-0.0142526049,
-0.1167385131,
-0.0057508433,
-0.0352297723,
0.0121989595,
0.0171733778,
-0.0592438318,
0.0143989557,
-0.0207720343,
-0.019285161,
0.0320749134,
-0.0290437117,
-0.0013176688,
-0.0254455544,
-0.0004201169,
0.0109734451,
0.0146589996,
0.0235873051,
-0.0294296965,
-0.0007992805,
0.042234052,
-0.0530759878,
-0.0940547958,
0.0121979686,
-0.0132319508,
-0.0029630011,
0.0305365045,
-0.0388576686,
-0.035575062,
-0.0443146378,
0.0031354264,
-0.0300675575,
0.0436674245,
0.0327338465,
-0.0014539592,
-0.0196683612,
0.042054493,
-0.0629314035,
-0.0221682563,
0.0358394831,
0.000725257,
-0.051549755,
0.0043361387,
0.0165969376,
-0.016685551,
0.0117082978,
-0.0098653417,
0.0287429281,
0.062234126,
0.0536604449,
-0.0458672829,
0.008792486,
0.0676863045,
0.0332413763,
0.0094305491,
-0.0247704964,
-0.0116437208,
0.0004719989,
0.0182572957,
0.018627543,
-0.0240116213,
-0.0511250831,
0.0288135987,
-0.0326284207,
-0.0449511632,
0.0383929163,
0.0183183253,
-0.0072441627,
-0.0257856064,
0.0365757383,
0.0220684167,
-0.0035189011,
-0.003489332,
-0.0224900879,
-0.0386470929,
0.0260516666,
0.0360932797,
0.044184424,
-0.0006175071,
0.0234096125,
-0.000211497,
-0.0281468425,
-0.017407449,
0.0569818541,
0.0289477296,
0.0405885093,
-0.0248104353,
-0.0616311841,
-0.0499775,
0.0367258042,
0.02943049,
0.0347854309,
-0.0180776846,
-0.0135357277,
-0.0308256429,
-0.06575647,
0.0626615062,
0.0164625589,
-0.0315491594,
0.0315835848,
0.0127016529,
0.0326935537,
0.0676174909,
0.0049743871,
-0.0226467177,
-0.0197749734,
-0.0357111134,
-0.0309105869,
-0.0234793872,
-5.85520385e-33,
-0.03078367,
-0.0339038409,
0.0193890743,
0.0114297392,
0.0103599643,
0.0375128239,
-0.0226251017,
-0.0314197764,
-0.0026141915,
0.0345987566,
-0.0117309913,
0.0083038751,
0.0215514116,
-0.0057335808,
0.0473047383,
-0.0577223748,
0.0110396696,
-0.0078114592,
0.0247001387,
0.0102622584,
0.0061539733,
0.0321615972,
0.0485887416,
-0.0495779216,
0.0748339593,
0.0090387892,
0.0101470025,
-0.0279354602,
0.0174316466,
0.0470583178,
-0.0428839438,
0.0662436411,
0.0449284241,
-0.0241547097,
-0.0375489183,
0.008420459,
-0.1492278427,
-0.0161454044,
-0.0277513433,
0.0451995581,
-0.0076959901,
-0.0390595198,
0.0382422395,
0.0072099525,
0.008552812,
-0.0076253652,
0.047290761,
-0.0173863433,
-0.0055098208,
-0.0473011509,
-0.0133126089,
0.0486920923,
0.0118018053,
0.0297913514,
0.0688261986,
-0.0165264159,
0.0398944989,
-0.0221746154,
-0.0975687951,
-0.0043621045,
0.0450407453,
0.0340855643,
0.0380667597,
-0.0020849959,
0.0236575641,
0.0052566743,
0.0027070174,
0.0344760083,
-0.0441421829,
0.0323381014,
0.0108814929,
0.0475217886,
0.0463442914,
0.0130412253,
0.0353500023,
-0.0254287925,
-0.062324252,
0.0512776822,
0.012730632,
-0.0230262205,
-0.0530562624,
0.0042508976,
-0.017041536,
-0.0084335366,
-0.0485171601,
-0.0256273653,
-0.0199598763,
-0.019933356,
-0.0057687038,
-0.0327790007,
0.0365144573,
0.0718765408,
-0.0047105299,
-0.0148142669,
-0.0174959414,
0.0344047062,
-0.007235629,
0.0474321581,
0.0236750003,
-0.0342069641,
-0.0078840964,
-0.038223125,
0.0078694606,
-0.030439714,
0.0338591412,
0.0593712889,
0.0904448777,
0.0276073907,
-0.0281388517,
0.0008611759,
-0.0084416373,
-0.0202049967,
0.0117542669,
0.0212295242,
-0.0023445077,
0.0126591781,
-0.0107107311,
0.0477171279,
0.0547677688,
0.0297271833,
0.0285437405,
0.0072782016,
-0.0060000052,
-0.0124171246,
0.0021459318,
-0.019282721,
-0.0359644145,
-0.0150157101,
-0.0045235292,
-0.0159410927,
0.027364729,
0.0117490049,
2.458e-7,
0.0857793167,
0.0202440135,
0.0571062788,
-0.0100395046,
0.0135710184,
-0.0045700357,
0.0273604691,
0.0123541076,
-0.0700875521,
-0.0608000197,
0.0639863536,
-0.0178854931,
0.0325454623,
0.0369582623,
-0.058006376,
-0.0418112352,
-0.0420838408,
-0.0089708148,
-0.0588749163,
-0.0124718612,
0.0327497572,
0.0778270289,
-0.0328391455,
-0.0060048895,
0.0423827618,
-0.0142807905,
0.0142835863,
-0.0248457752,
0.0647508949,
0.0354095474,
0.0502476506,
0.0060920408,
-0.0308516808,
0.0847898498,
-0.0098887505,
0.0023580086,
0.0215508211,
0.0387645327,
-0.0228809621,
0.0391958319,
-0.0217929147,
-0.0980664343,
0.0358699858,
-0.0344465598,
0.0738616362,
-0.0206304565,
-0.0074073523,
0.0822565779,
0.0093768677,
0.016682541,
0.0221255589,
-0.0022690529,
0.011849571,
0.012755827,
0.02916044,
-0.0107354755,
-0.0172202364,
-0.0654205531,
-0.0230871998,
0.0335130841,
0.00702524,
0.0087305047,
-0.0271833334,
-0.0730662942,
0.0070542935,
-0.0608042888,
0.0176217649,
2.351823716e-34,
0.0178913288,
0.0187367965,
0.0037576023,
0.0479255654,
0.0631936044,
-0.0344643444,
-0.0025145027,
0.002402195,
0.0163199659,
-0.0491767116,
-0.0123396851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00314v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00314v2
|
CASE: Efficient Curricular Data Pre-training for Building Assistive Psychology Expert Models
| 2024-06-01T06:17:32 | 2024-06-16T10:33:34 |
Sarthak Harne, Monjoy Narayan Choudhury, Madhav Rao, TK Srikanth, Seema Mehrotra, Apoorva Vashisht, Aarushi Basu, Manjit Sodhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The limited availability of psychologists necessitates efficient
identification of individuals requiring urgent mental healthcare. This study
explores the use of Natural Language Processing (NLP) pipelines to analyze text
data from online mental health forums used for consultations. By analyzing
forum posts, these pipelines can flag users who may require immediate
professional attention. A crucial challenge in this domain is data privacy and
scarcity. To address this, we propose utilizing readily available curricular
texts used in institutes specializing in mental health for pre-training the NLP
pipelines. This helps us mimic the training process of a psychologist. Our work
presents CASE-BERT that flags potential mental health disorders based on forum
text. CASE-BERT demonstrates superior performance compared to existing methods,
achieving an f1 score of 0.91 for Depression and 0.88 for Anxiety, two of the
most commonly reported mental health disorders. Our code is publicly available.
|
[
0.0763550401,
0.0438184515,
-0.0265461486,
0.0039404673,
-0.0426341407,
0.0139069166,
0.0346982591,
0.0077501605,
0.0986210778,
-0.0763230696,
0.0199247077,
-0.0136053711,
-0.0332178287,
0.0307598934,
-0.0148106096,
-0.0419427045,
-0.0134454295,
0.036314819,
0.0715218186,
0.0416106991,
0.0211280845,
0.035953749,
-0.0491562597,
0.0498575084,
0.0258824788,
-0.0099484492,
0.05147833,
-0.0142564094,
0.0314633772,
-0.0561641939,
0.0285594296,
0.0716865733,
-0.0235287994,
-0.0209025852,
0.0000017838,
-0.0379534289,
-0.0335240662,
0.0234972239,
-0.0018522824,
-0.0565288514,
0.0136325434,
-0.0135089252,
0.0094376393,
0.0351108462,
-0.0258836281,
-0.0089235483,
0.0229391288,
0.0889234617,
0.0894183964,
0.0659506842,
-0.035129033,
-0.017151555,
0.009231043,
0.0423052758,
-0.032508973,
-0.0109415222,
0.0636207685,
-0.0532981306,
0.0403902344,
-0.0217028204,
0.0358932056,
0.0165366884,
-0.0647409782,
0.0191565547,
-0.0275915675,
0.004776407,
-0.0539537817,
-0.0407206379,
0.0009906476,
0.0712678656,
0.0374528654,
0.0151927117,
0.0397879146,
0.0015195252,
0.0041702995,
0.030417541,
0.001058004,
0.0144056892,
-0.0670210347,
0.0022048666,
0.0508095324,
0.0116256401,
-0.0142167974,
-0.0022436697,
0.0465037003,
0.0174792632,
-0.0118373167,
-0.0396085493,
0.0205417145,
0.0075325309,
-0.0288614724,
-0.0637819171,
0.0915461332,
0.0235455297,
-0.0276459455,
0.0196908861,
-0.0355551876,
-0.0874737427,
0.036096286,
-0.0093032178,
-0.0117993345,
0.0199543908,
-0.0386352241,
0.0178547874,
0.0046937256,
-0.0210232697,
0.0185983106,
0.0316686817,
-0.0037072359,
0.0151271867,
-0.0847488344,
0.0012573777,
-0.0606896505,
0.024876181,
-0.0023797781,
-0.0024367818,
-0.0496380217,
0.0044021183,
-0.0391280763,
0.0064410795,
-0.0025692536,
-0.0014707264,
0.0168519039,
0.030337058,
0.0037334296,
0.0033538481,
-0.0214877296,
-0.0053283265,
-0.0285355169,
-0.0214203652,
0.0511588566,
-0.0170822442,
0.0226463303,
-0.0204872638,
0.0277514532,
0.0411399007,
0.0383442715,
-0.0331659988,
-0.0634847358,
-0.0651233867,
-0.0102655916,
0.0031633854,
-0.0058151702,
-0.0213292222,
0.0362114273,
0.0258934461,
0.000880847,
0.0000273791,
0.0318679363,
0.0316709839,
-0.0571538508,
0.0586838908,
-0.0666301623,
0.004247379,
0.0241658464,
0.0191060733,
0.0133155873,
0.0148324333,
-0.0081915623,
-0.0208917744,
0.0407967083,
-0.0211193021,
0.0239592344,
0.0042732707,
-0.0155158872,
-0.0581785217,
0.032741569,
0.0174565241,
-0.0563655831,
0.0171764251,
-0.0477128923,
0.0418635495,
-0.0061352849,
-0.0050308178,
0.0050583319,
0.1166489869,
0.0297691282,
0.0250972994,
0.0056380932,
0.0673685744,
0.0034220952,
-0.0324705653,
-0.0287889708,
-0.0131964106,
-0.0599336512,
-0.0483510457,
-0.0340376683,
0.0215959959,
0.0019785012,
-0.0368480571,
-0.0505778715,
-0.0157573503,
-0.0387187265,
-0.0035194559,
-0.0117104445,
-0.0068802959,
-0.0037667979,
0.0315696076,
0.0223142076,
-0.0019439851,
-0.0178634487,
-0.0269230884,
-0.0235841516,
0.1103601903,
0.0210592262,
-0.0722909123,
-0.013667386,
-0.0583061129,
0.0045359749,
0.0276638679,
-0.0030955309,
0.0038456544,
0.0043791467,
-0.0182330143,
-0.0220276583,
0.0480673648,
0.0024313447,
-0.0358870216,
0.014517433,
0.0134130288,
-0.0366584547,
0.0064309374,
-0.0183813088,
0.0707354993,
-0.0039520208,
-0.0450817496,
-0.0050826268,
-0.0003060871,
0.060053587,
0.0384640433,
0.0086197602,
0.0116325337,
-0.0180133209,
-0.0223836824,
-0.0698745996,
-0.011406227,
-0.0021129888,
0.0085188765,
0.0063336631,
-0.023508979,
-0.0093385279,
0.0267780069,
-0.0158066154,
-0.0116671016,
0.008483666,
-0.0503129773,
0.0177648365,
-0.000017436,
-0.0266776625,
0.010627307,
-0.0012923348,
-0.0346858911,
0.039006725,
-0.0044212872,
0.0482994877,
-0.0179887395,
-0.046708446,
-0.0032557987,
0.0056275707,
-0.0256824903,
-0.0462173596,
-0.0281806458,
0.0251522567,
0.0071067908,
0.0099383825,
-0.019386977,
-0.0030949689,
-0.1297491789,
0.0167066455,
-0.0168964472,
0.0077336775,
0.0289444756,
-0.0316641554,
-0.0403029136,
-0.0133754723,
-0.0191547796,
-0.0191573985,
0.0385156609,
0.0198246632,
0.037348453,
0.0272254515,
-0.0170858614,
-0.0227003973,
-0.0085817901,
-0.0569436476,
-0.006720677,
0.0332108364,
-0.0720817596,
-0.0278477166,
0.001964713,
-0.0147787109,
0.0275246408,
0.0135592585,
-0.0186830927,
-0.0144624691,
0.0009530702,
-0.0064422102,
0.0019533471,
0.0154222259,
0.0298900027,
0.0212587826,
0.0068196943,
-0.007725222,
0.0106391301,
-0.0234698392,
0.0035475984,
-0.048188027,
-0.0287324674,
0.0777184367,
0.0265608393,
0.0335775167,
-0.014996768,
-0.0059881071,
-0.0029336731,
-0.014368847,
0.0125988927,
0.0012060323,
-0.0434862413,
0.0262061227,
0.0228210483,
0.010046605,
0.0051482627,
0.0894356966,
0.0054681925,
0.0118177775,
-0.1013480797,
-0.0600512736,
-0.0540293306,
0.0074589686,
0.0386543386,
0.052897118,
0.0468292981,
-0.0566758402,
0.0660529286,
-0.0063901269,
-0.0016039632,
-0.0290592778,
-0.016192833,
-0.0421464778,
0.0115806218,
0.013537216,
-0.0386556983,
-0.0496088341,
-0.0467924587,
-0.0538481399,
-0.014587882,
0.0019305943,
-0.0111757964,
-0.0269073974,
-0.027139809,
0.0364704989,
0.0442872904,
0.0209885687,
-0.0432157628,
0.0108553274,
0.0340074003,
-0.0096300803,
-0.0318705998,
0.0032300507,
0.0206566602,
-0.0076737399,
0.07941138,
-0.0059901639,
0.0180205125,
0.0152938319,
-0.0045119505,
0.0041335556,
-0.0712478831,
-0.0051792939,
0.0184502378,
0.0077484092,
-0.0399761014,
0.0019156305,
0.0899015069,
0.0513708144,
-0.0219499953,
0.0109131318,
0.0013492136,
-0.0586061291,
0.0049125864,
-0.0060276892,
-0.0431930162,
-0.0320066288,
-0.0317970365,
0.057906799,
-0.0667683557,
-0.0643121302,
0.0050631594,
-0.0296139345,
0.020591557,
-0.0436807908,
0.0174740534,
-0.0111628249,
-0.0511958562,
0.0051002647,
-0.0173768532,
-0.0223256424,
-0.0442462526,
-0.0221827962,
0.0199518502,
0.0190668721,
-0.0933717787,
-0.0566205643,
0.012609248,
-0.0152865602,
0.0604404248,
-0.000870519,
0.0398912579,
-0.0343254209,
-0.0285551846,
-0.0297282841,
0.0035437657,
0.0058992133,
-0.0079236999,
0.1037041247,
0.0063021313,
0.0135021647,
-0.0789904371,
0.055862993,
-0.072563,
-0.012212079,
0.0128568374,
0.0767270103,
-0.0300123803,
-0.0348098986,
-0.020539891,
0.027002234,
0.0392288081,
0.0563150123,
-0.0266103297,
-0.024563618,
-0.0150229428,
0.0117959464,
0.0252660681,
-0.0202231836,
-0.0587525442,
0.0120779518,
-0.0106892968,
-0.0345766507,
-0.0636342615,
-0.0128177889,
0.0452236943,
-0.0043318216,
0.0057939952,
-0.0244853757,
0.0657511503,
0.0328436717,
-0.0784803182,
0.0495547242,
0.0087703941,
0.0311459973,
-0.0319578573,
-0.0228283722,
0.0398942009,
0.0411436558,
-0.021502303,
0.0412763283,
0.0082255388,
-0.0194950085,
0.0382288061,
-0.0013724264,
0.0142685939,
-0.0277313683,
-0.0105069382,
-0.0317392908,
0.0046470556,
0.0180697441,
-0.0641610324,
-0.0498693734,
0.0010426049,
0.0207753535,
0.0045888782,
0.0132148704,
0.0264258161,
0.0388006903,
0.0185084026,
-0.01410715,
-0.0407542437,
0.0307563934,
0.0113473395,
0.0393405445,
0.0110826837,
0.0146108093,
-0.0021976298,
-0.0290600955,
-0.0310416557,
-0.0012861642,
-0.0095847081,
-0.0014782884,
0.0004623751,
0.0308784712,
-0.0149818519,
-0.0168151688,
-0.0063817552,
-0.0558579005,
-0.0061032306,
-0.0389940441,
0.046364855,
0.0230241939,
-0.0021274008,
0.0091688791,
-0.0335716866,
-0.0056531564,
0.0296979602,
0.0166126508,
0.0481109135,
-0.0176228154,
0.0712068975,
-0.0028314474,
-0.0090322606,
0.0479577072,
0.0248907749,
-0.034024328,
-0.1182449088,
-0.0229678154,
-0.0037596594,
0.0019273384,
-0.0029539536,
0.0282167066,
-0.0425220281,
0.0219273604,
-0.0028055918,
0.0241886992,
-0.0176837984,
-0.0252419133,
0.0267254543,
0.0143967681,
-0.0264429301,
-0.0163625851,
0.0475955941,
-0.0117201181,
0.004636684,
0.0388470776,
-0.0726555586,
-0.0382848084,
-0.0151772657,
0.0061151939,
0.0571545549,
-0.0266205072,
0.0001727529,
-0.0335058309,
-0.0228373874,
0.0069068242,
-0.0510979444,
0.0069955629,
-0.0025902027,
0.0208415836,
0.032272663,
0.0328150019,
-0.012095754,
-0.0580088869,
0.0293413308,
-0.0193607863,
-0.0159402229,
-0.0314046666,
-5.57909639e-33,
-0.0050063222,
-0.0582834929,
0.0070714066,
0.0010111833,
0.0594361573,
-0.0021979588,
0.0160477217,
0.0237916894,
0.0114746485,
0.0069582104,
0.0281561986,
0.0316815451,
0.0028139388,
0.0371029004,
0.019851476,
0.0031903987,
0.0428668484,
0.0076704095,
0.0092461603,
0.028338436,
0.0090081226,
0.0585949235,
0.0655276701,
-0.1255958229,
0.028224647,
0.0286757872,
0.012135745,
0.0203797985,
0.0409112647,
0.0124051832,
-0.0243835114,
0.0600237548,
0.0524488129,
-0.0055799866,
0.0180720948,
0.0543522611,
-0.0513339788,
-0.0314966403,
-0.0137880491,
-0.0003845038,
-0.0030146791,
0.0263080951,
0.0478840061,
-0.0355555601,
0.0183694754,
0.0001363812,
0.0672710389,
-0.0306491535,
0.0630407929,
-0.0444420986,
-0.0374056101,
0.0271278098,
-0.0299499445,
0.0368348584,
-0.009486272,
0.0496537238,
-0.0231512375,
-0.0072391173,
-0.044724144,
-0.0425484702,
-0.0004263492,
-0.0015337759,
-0.0185519271,
-0.0731462315,
-0.0428385995,
0.0357091613,
0.006089333,
-0.0056229127,
-0.0221931376,
0.0275473576,
-0.0090498086,
0.0454623327,
0.0488823205,
-0.0189465974,
0.0328086428,
-0.005593623,
-0.031279169,
0.00486136,
0.0256980248,
0.0185266044,
0.0395344421,
-0.0239024572,
-0.0506692342,
-0.0158969741,
-0.0082645305,
-0.0277245659,
-0.0078428537,
0.0153968967,
-0.0164241791,
-0.0010084941,
-0.0202817973,
0.0003832434,
-0.0209627878,
0.0039612646,
-0.0200550873,
-0.0001754091,
0.0427736007,
0.0219829865,
-0.0062454203,
0.0038118633,
-0.051309444,
-0.0048104073,
0.0095189186,
-0.024992818,
0.0504819341,
-0.0149370646,
0.044047866,
-0.0419300012,
-0.054759331,
-0.0099856984,
0.0304078907,
0.0650847256,
0.0161528066,
0.1116286367,
0.0027006194,
0.0161607731,
-0.0173316672,
0.027591411,
0.0157994572,
0.0230692048,
-0.0651203617,
0.0127475141,
-0.0241835117,
-0.0361578204,
-0.0065063448,
-0.0505397506,
-0.0083221979,
0.0469289534,
0.0370480642,
-0.0535859428,
0.026907092,
-0.0385261364,
2.644e-7,
0.0668500438,
0.0662009493,
-0.0043584448,
-0.0414654166,
0.0218162835,
0.0296757761,
0.0515728854,
0.0371567756,
0.0324943401,
-0.037118841,
-0.0157232936,
0.0074188733,
-0.010328928,
0.0864869431,
-0.0339801051,
-0.1024771407,
0.026451109,
-0.0368562452,
-0.0775647908,
0.0039360006,
0.0906408131,
0.0302253682,
0.0211732909,
-0.0236977879,
-0.0216436107,
-0.0308172666,
-0.0158543587,
-0.0153029198,
0.0259087458,
0.058133468,
0.0805104524,
0.0193687752,
0.0303191114,
0.0277608242,
-0.0274002589,
0.0126158232,
-0.0396031961,
0.0607249998,
-0.0388149321,
-0.0008869737,
-0.0035414684,
-0.0246719066,
-0.0034504137,
0.0145416744,
0.0351952389,
-0.0759626031,
-0.0372367166,
-0.0147943292,
-0.0312745683,
-0.0841897801,
0.0130750332,
0.000970538,
-0.013411032,
0.0807260647,
0.01534539,
-0.0310230032,
0.029251501,
-0.0822209269,
0.00461736,
0.0304290969,
-0.0310224984,
-0.0006614777,
0.0441398472,
-0.0070748357,
0.0188795216,
-0.0481122844,
0.0589048564,
2.50325425e-34,
-0.025518259,
0.0604052767,
0.0372380465,
0.0197650213,
0.0367409363,
0.0422810689,
-0.0351624452,
0.000837374,
-0.03548095,
-0.0517648347,
-0.0003209332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00303v1
|
Multi-Dimensional Optimization for Text Summarization via Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-06-01T05:15:12 | 2024-06-01T05:15:12 |
Sangwon Ryu, Heejin Do, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee, Jungseul Ok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The evaluation of summary quality encompasses diverse dimensions such as
consistency, coherence, relevance, and fluency. However, existing summarization
methods often target a specific dimension, facing challenges in generating
well-balanced summaries across multiple dimensions. In this paper, we propose
multi-objective reinforcement learning tailored to generate balanced summaries
across all four dimensions. We introduce two multi-dimensional optimization
(MDO) strategies for adaptive learning: 1) MDO_min, rewarding the current
lowest dimension score, and 2) MDO_pro, optimizing multiple dimensions similar
to multi-task learning, resolves conflicting gradients across dimensions
through gradient projection. Unlike prior ROUGE-based rewards relying on
reference summaries, we use a QA-based reward model that aligns with human
preferences. Further, we discover the capability to regulate the length of
summaries by adjusting the discount factor, seeking the generation of concise
yet informative summaries that encapsulate crucial points. Our approach
achieved substantial performance gains compared to baseline models on
representative summarization datasets, particularly in the overlooked
dimensions.
|
[
0.036934752,
0.008179659,
0.0367625095,
-0.0328523666,
0.0005435973,
-0.0007229,
-0.0372343957,
-0.0227849912,
-0.0488937758,
-0.0093847141,
-0.0050294902,
0.0046876185,
0.0350652933,
-0.002834331,
-0.0290231779,
-0.1349650174,
0.0271554999,
-0.0263821092,
-0.0054703737,
-0.0114760157,
0.0413257331,
-0.0084808385,
0.0087687001,
0.0344965421,
-0.013107813,
0.0146985985,
0.0144180497,
-0.0294570047,
0.0646375418,
-0.0321401022,
0.0168124065,
-0.0152578447,
0.0209293086,
-0.0270871017,
0.0000020995,
-0.0383517183,
-0.0550433286,
-0.0137580298,
0.0349712186,
-0.0163508728,
0.0654671863,
-0.0654700994,
0.0442355908,
0.0007415842,
-0.0037538775,
0.0241653137,
0.015660109,
0.0826598331,
0.0736679137,
0.0489998087,
-0.00120611,
-0.0254825652,
0.0077893673,
-0.0389502086,
-0.0000837453,
-0.0469097383,
-0.0031597125,
0.0287938267,
0.0149095487,
-0.0189064946,
-0.0193954855,
0.0192685109,
0.0122296764,
0.000753513,
0.0077678026,
0.0306984335,
0.03323403,
0.0125780869,
-0.0187641103,
0.0598031804,
0.0014957449,
0.0506654344,
0.0269816946,
-0.0158958752,
0.0419910885,
-0.0072924402,
-0.0682847202,
0.0542840026,
-0.0015307775,
0.0357198417,
-0.0195223261,
0.0675262734,
-0.0077632759,
0.0169330686,
-0.0003520167,
0.0213630106,
-0.0353722312,
-0.0288661495,
-0.0412182882,
0.0226041581,
-0.0103729293,
-0.007945911,
-0.0155299446,
0.0247654114,
-0.0595604219,
0.0030277844,
-0.0265691113,
-0.0564735085,
0.0190385412,
-0.0167550407,
0.0516214631,
-0.0053789457,
0.0300017595,
0.0307711437,
0.0164492615,
0.0465908051,
0.0193952974,
0.014199866,
-0.0524104424,
-0.0066060005,
-0.0278047714,
0.0043738191,
0.0027309814,
0.0876376703,
-0.0053327954,
-0.0155818434,
-0.0764652118,
0.01518247,
-0.0256276559,
0.011153047,
-0.0004089995,
0.0527696423,
-0.0117432978,
0.0134835104,
-0.0470077246,
0.0008714606,
-0.0601154715,
-0.0121536171,
0.0235879421,
0.0784881487,
-0.0236547366,
0.0250724126,
0.0094358325,
0.0028191125,
0.0017105259,
0.077073954,
-0.0314872526,
-0.0378408059,
0.0193184838,
-0.0344266817,
-0.0483040176,
-0.0287065897,
-0.0237224549,
-0.0467504784,
-0.0065415255,
-0.0311093982,
-0.0115327742,
-0.0272355005,
-0.0118060214,
0.0099632079,
-0.0372444727,
-0.0049892101,
0.0193241872,
-0.0247071031,
0.0413612574,
0.0201165434,
0.0021515621,
0.0592956468,
0.0675882176,
0.0781666636,
0.0367542244,
0.0499847084,
-0.0138235083,
-0.008892836,
0.0280700959,
0.0165967196,
0.0244287252,
-0.0195464063,
-0.0270534363,
0.0217635613,
0.0597677715,
0.0302735027,
-0.0573943704,
0.0290746335,
0.0375104286,
0.0614766143,
0.0221329313,
-0.0052870596,
0.002199512,
0.0421358533,
-0.0006521483,
0.0555131137,
0.0035065878,
0.0891464576,
-0.0158740524,
0.0513782613,
0.101931341,
0.0185469668,
-0.0068227206,
-0.0747257248,
0.0255809538,
-0.0163094234,
0.0074248281,
0.0081505207,
0.0140685299,
0.0089846142,
-0.0485843159,
-0.0203163996,
0.0167686157,
-0.031019127,
0.0270012245,
-0.0171979759,
0.0475676358,
0.0496457331,
0.0299932696,
-0.0609993264,
0.0038250468,
-0.0287530012,
-0.0097829914,
0.030038368,
0.018136587,
-0.0396633707,
-0.0118712857,
-0.0407813527,
-0.0501917154,
-0.0622486025,
0.0211087596,
0.0174673516,
-0.0003979306,
-0.0043452159,
0.0178713184,
0.0188154951,
-0.0657363161,
0.0204737168,
0.0104534691,
-0.0335808247,
0.0410878249,
-0.0109949494,
0.0162522681,
0.0192670058,
0.0152126933,
0.0093356045,
0.0056341216,
-0.0205592774,
-0.0322367512,
-0.0076836119,
-0.0423182435,
-0.0038051768,
-0.0007348891,
-0.0443299785,
0.0079420982,
0.0170869157,
-0.029586073,
-0.0450449623,
0.0517808646,
-0.0595623367,
-0.0528288893,
-0.0075719869,
-0.0112723084,
0.0221826062,
0.0244168751,
-0.0254933368,
0.0719167292,
-0.0156739354,
0.0109249512,
0.0618693866,
-0.0710558444,
0.0005478391,
-0.0322569832,
0.030383002,
-0.0335965976,
0.0148153547,
0.0569011271,
0.0622855984,
0.0260294061,
-0.0195080265,
-0.0246040113,
-0.0230516437,
0.0132148238,
-0.014204111,
0.0097621297,
0.0376966521,
0.0174519233,
0.0099042179,
-0.0272556935,
-0.0232110713,
-0.0460738838,
0.0149333533,
-0.0007497646,
0.0533468574,
0.0312803388,
0.0716948286,
-0.048500441,
-0.0109493416,
0.0279079098,
0.0362328142,
0.0023718544,
0.0287841074,
-0.0289142374,
-0.0430590287,
-0.0288057253,
-0.0358773619,
0.0180763677,
0.0374702513,
-0.0227398816,
0.0106678298,
0.0435419381,
0.0715828761,
0.045318298,
0.0516975485,
0.0496374965,
0.0227956381,
-0.0368672423,
0.0116831604,
-0.0731251091,
0.0361418203,
-0.0093176421,
-0.0295051057,
0.0638734996,
0.0478606932,
0.0118210474,
0.0086538726,
-0.0422436967,
0.0641424879,
-0.0307241194,
-0.0375750437,
-0.0774603263,
0.0285930149,
-0.017829895,
0.0031088765,
-0.022091344,
-0.0025450082,
0.0844463781,
0.034908928,
0.054431878,
-0.0820648968,
0.0016608012,
-0.0565246604,
0.0210556313,
-0.0385933183,
0.0313893184,
-0.0235993564,
-0.0022949509,
-0.0468652993,
-0.0484108813,
0.0729514509,
0.0073645199,
0.0505508073,
-0.0257848594,
-0.0196325146,
-0.0265558809,
-0.0515260994,
-0.0133264642,
-0.0261881314,
0.0048158388,
0.0260948222,
0.0053030876,
-0.0081419712,
-0.0553738438,
0.0013189747,
0.0725069791,
0.0562378578,
-0.0520911589,
-0.0368853323,
0.0144325849,
0.0404418707,
0.0901091993,
0.0404441096,
0.0214054454,
-0.0651858747,
-0.0075577409,
0.0232487936,
-0.0038384139,
-0.0271130428,
0.0662424117,
0.0197426006,
0.0144999735,
-0.0649019927,
-0.0025547754,
0.0137561113,
0.0054238527,
-0.0361633897,
-0.0072068851,
0.0710038468,
0.0215232112,
-0.0333214477,
-0.0094449259,
-0.0096120415,
0.0136401569,
-0.0199594591,
0.0185119491,
-0.0293312781,
-0.0184915643,
-0.0341648199,
0.0480512977,
0.0458517931,
-0.0082366178,
-0.0187024139,
-0.0348389708,
-0.0271350145,
-0.0262312759,
-0.0815140754,
-0.0116531076,
-0.0387764052,
0.0093567735,
-0.0384917147,
0.0173481759,
0.0174086094,
-0.0251097884,
0.005005924,
0.0283933859,
-0.0309016388,
0.0213140137,
-0.0324130841,
-0.008222159,
-0.024770638,
0.0933514312,
0.038090378,
-0.0044452338,
0.0162471756,
-0.0237872265,
-0.0069803703,
-0.0088162757,
0.028609518,
0.059687864,
-0.0201654099,
0.0317098722,
-0.0339004956,
0.0534855463,
0.0585588701,
-0.0111405263,
0.0257557146,
0.0206944533,
0.022177143,
-0.0270148851,
-0.0432234816,
0.0042958385,
-0.0331771225,
0.0429989956,
-0.0124668228,
-0.0527315587,
-0.0314747803,
-0.0294385962,
-0.0273914114,
-0.1112098619,
-0.0117802881,
-0.0106654484,
-0.0195462592,
0.0066283913,
-0.0993010327,
-0.041622214,
-0.0136800008,
-0.0127408719,
-0.009568275,
-0.0227816701,
-0.0156193171,
0.0169288758,
-0.0313087702,
-0.0333803929,
-0.0217228662,
-0.0263470095,
-0.016595887,
0.0341547802,
0.0212766733,
-0.077283293,
-0.0375969298,
-0.0124217309,
-0.0354746431,
-0.0118144499,
-0.0481345579,
0.0614867024,
0.005566916,
0.058736857,
0.0310129374,
-0.0071634636,
0.0634065792,
0.0180543307,
-0.0097913649,
0.0394391827,
0.0401564613,
0.0398038998,
-0.0267625563,
0.0187608339,
-0.0861623809,
0.0214678552,
-0.0468365066,
0.0287625547,
0.0123498896,
-0.0304067638,
0.0086494312,
-0.0277539268,
0.0020579631,
-0.0298485402,
-0.035403192,
-0.035293363,
-0.0284768492,
-0.0229537971,
-0.0294041969,
0.0011180391,
0.0372490659,
-0.0142078586,
0.0009417864,
-0.0075299963,
0.0653762668,
0.02629981,
0.0118388906,
-0.0720358044,
-0.0179442745,
-0.0162972547,
-0.0495934896,
-0.0589417443,
0.0182341337,
-0.0217241924,
-0.0340029597,
-0.0274909344,
0.005045312,
-0.0092372112,
-0.0113607049,
0.0552092008,
0.0015833627,
-0.0105724055,
0.0253948364,
-0.0676414222,
0.0376288779,
-0.0529899225,
-0.0092492467,
0.0443919972,
-0.0019331006,
0.066123344,
-0.0123314252,
-0.0172041059,
0.0043366831,
0.0228231438,
0.0179731529,
-0.0018402319,
-0.0146078886,
0.0153963389,
0.0260384791,
-0.0112530766,
0.0801607519,
-0.0484980531,
0.0099356482,
-0.0229991712,
0.0030755422,
-0.0484781191,
-0.0370383523,
-0.0173665155,
0.076352261,
0.009395848,
-0.044228889,
-0.0587076768,
-0.0022736287,
0.0322220773,
0.0166260898,
0.0127063058,
-0.0113607058,
0.0561991483,
-0.0141127734,
-0.0047362405,
0.0017626866,
-0.0680932701,
-0.05666361,
-0.0346823037,
-0.0054616784,
0.0275980067,
-6.036727361e-33,
-0.0185877439,
-0.0200245008,
-0.0100111766,
0.0047657397,
-0.0371226482,
0.0314910114,
-0.0337198637,
-0.0295790751,
0.0285736471,
-0.0026700413,
-0.0069470657,
-0.0261193551,
-0.0011014299,
0.04167125,
0.011714098,
0.0423440486,
0.0380214229,
0.0079561947,
-0.0728007331,
0.0430741869,
0.0367508568,
-0.020215353,
0.0231673233,
-0.0026651011,
0.0602107309,
0.0101629859,
-0.0548777431,
-0.0162032992,
0.0485913604,
0.0360510908,
-0.01913842,
0.0339571238,
0.0261416752,
-0.0679726601,
-0.0411121398,
0.000469337,
-0.0959436446,
-0.0609830394,
0.030648822,
-0.0681970268,
-0.0886438042,
-0.0317750499,
0.0057448735,
0.0111724138,
-0.0009747355,
-0.0413451493,
0.0803129226,
-0.0241715368,
-0.0361866392,
-0.0446923263,
-0.0264024492,
0.0100875888,
-0.0422636718,
-0.0296844151,
0.0527441166,
0.0424758121,
0.0208197292,
-0.001694872,
-0.0189596824,
0.0682467967,
-0.0291724578,
0.0247153006,
0.0200070161,
0.0235754102,
0.005873906,
0.0454259254,
-0.0122154299,
-0.000695313,
-0.0106593519,
-0.0034508205,
-0.0018615277,
-0.0294230934,
0.0157641359,
0.0566460639,
0.0174841676,
0.0083603235,
-0.0507246293,
0.0924556851,
-0.0176999848,
0.0155402478,
0.0584477074,
-0.0036619334,
0.0141403526,
-0.0170289855,
-0.0594479442,
0.0629778355,
-0.0116515635,
-0.0133434823,
-0.0281036329,
0.0661164522,
-0.0440519415,
-0.0097425831,
-0.0199982803,
-0.0171677303,
0.0062144622,
0.0127664739,
-0.0458943173,
0.0160028432,
0.0285438783,
-0.0670931116,
-0.0451534316,
0.0259279832,
0.0117519461,
-0.0020867318,
0.0019262505,
0.0030574664,
0.0572527125,
0.0068303277,
-0.0385126285,
0.0381260514,
0.0271592624,
0.0565995164,
-0.0168794878,
0.0049634478,
-0.0119649051,
-0.0078466162,
-0.0087199463,
0.0454352796,
0.0115845781,
0.0048516453,
-0.0119775981,
-0.0271290932,
0.0121695809,
0.0317846201,
-0.0361507088,
0.0349304304,
-0.0015278815,
0.0057491711,
0.0017146098,
-0.0507035889,
-0.0330524407,
0.0029375765,
2.674e-7,
0.0119622806,
0.0529947244,
0.0476951264,
-0.0000399395,
-0.0232093912,
0.0420402437,
0.0210701283,
0.03043616,
-0.0216200817,
0.0323312804,
0.0385686308,
0.0151331509,
0.0130091766,
0.0116091762,
-0.0987059548,
-0.0052799047,
-0.0761924088,
0.0019995088,
-0.0074663009,
-0.0149827627,
0.0350105427,
0.0200412702,
0.0169650745,
-0.0015535787,
-0.01221547,
0.0335282832,
0.0382014289,
0.0067473818,
0.0047714752,
0.0126369307,
0.0162704885,
-0.0024756768,
-0.0128926141,
-0.0508819111,
-0.0064472957,
-0.0069010938,
0.0349687636,
0.0587055646,
0.0344398953,
-0.0411497988,
0.025153365,
0.0203916896,
0.0335558206,
0.0022981514,
0.0293120872,
-0.0548220314,
-0.0401047654,
-0.0507563129,
-0.0010560862,
0.0190543085,
0.0168446284,
-0.0035423895,
-0.0575988516,
0.0330295302,
-0.0208946001,
0.0524596833,
0.0182619337,
-0.0580702871,
-0.0405344777,
0.0516475178,
0.03918349,
-0.0089794695,
-0.0289348178,
0.0045377063,
-0.003807399,
-0.1194799319,
0.0000562165,
2.225636693e-34,
0.0666564852,
-0.0284241382,
-0.0411500186,
-0.0339845419,
-0.0048348801,
-0.0048270896,
-0.0397438444,
-0.0261147767,
0.0580529831,
-0.0277120639,
-0.028082395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04371v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04371v2
|
Phased Instruction Fine-Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-01T04:25:26 | 2024-06-16T21:20:29 |
Wei Pang, Chuan Zhou, Xiao-Hua Zhou, Xiaojie Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction Fine-Tuning enhances pre-trained language models from basic
next-word prediction to complex instruction-following. However, existing
One-off Instruction Fine-Tuning (One-off IFT) method, applied on a diverse
instruction, may not effectively boost models' adherence to instructions due to
the simultaneous handling of varying instruction complexities. To improve this,
Phased Instruction Fine-Tuning (Phased IFT) is proposed, based on the idea that
learning to follow instructions is a gradual process. It assesses instruction
difficulty using GPT-4, divides the instruction data into subsets of increasing
difficulty, and uptrains the model sequentially on these subsets. Experiments
with Llama-2 7B/13B/70B, Llama3 8/70B and Mistral-7B models using Alpaca data
show that Phased IFT significantly outperforms One-off IFT, supporting the
progressive alignment hypothesis and providing a simple and efficient way to
enhance large language models. Codes and datasets from our experiments are
freely available at https://github.com/xubuvd/PhasedSFT.
|
[
0.0343791917,
0.0515314676,
-0.0062032719,
-0.0057401112,
0.0007483385,
0.0500451401,
-0.0106294565,
-0.015909262,
-0.009877638,
-0.0447271802,
-0.05790741,
-0.04995979,
0.0051213554,
-0.0207173601,
0.0351245031,
-0.0717539489,
0.0654885396,
-0.0358140767,
0.0010727114,
0.0017040934,
0.0249104928,
0.0171566568,
-0.0212534051,
0.0237951204,
0.0346902907,
-0.0240390636,
-0.0372489654,
-0.009919093,
0.0279563554,
-0.037256211,
0.0452687778,
0.0594719797,
0.0232166946,
0.0304480419,
0.000001973,
-0.0422495157,
-0.0041610231,
-0.01881673,
-0.0178205036,
0.0641856119,
0.0431843586,
-0.0299563352,
-0.0248243678,
0.0385684483,
-0.0179907084,
0.0003135167,
0.074114643,
0.0237786509,
0.0538708605,
0.0840704814,
0.0052587055,
-0.0669289231,
0.0400560424,
-0.036389444,
-0.0038440926,
-0.0485806949,
0.0106395585,
-0.0273677129,
-0.0126788951,
0.0203601029,
-0.0408284813,
0.0240837187,
0.0096385777,
0.0247494373,
-0.0188713614,
0.0166450497,
-0.0039187255,
-0.0671712831,
-0.0349870846,
0.0539440438,
-0.0321888067,
-0.0070542907,
-0.0300998576,
-0.0268120375,
-0.0274313595,
-0.0108859837,
-0.0295149367,
0.0031111191,
0.0241680872,
0.0322065875,
0.0634039789,
-0.0044715009,
0.0080811447,
-0.0091616362,
-0.0476035103,
0.0703151524,
0.0372273624,
-0.0627637431,
-0.0031406602,
-0.005748122,
-0.0118144434,
-0.0266515948,
-0.0010109588,
0.0349298045,
-0.0381442457,
0.0279568601,
-0.0614272095,
0.0148931546,
0.0440630578,
-0.0238907263,
0.0749592111,
0.0692955181,
-0.045154918,
0.0039692903,
-0.0246463921,
0.0544260256,
-0.0085324738,
0.0222143307,
-0.0353271812,
0.0544171743,
-0.0223977249,
-0.0030400967,
-0.0314782858,
-0.0119527476,
-0.0190892797,
0.003911525,
-0.0659602731,
0.0146734426,
0.026268376,
-0.0210200008,
0.0284115709,
-0.0675551668,
-0.0572593622,
0.0000381592,
-0.020688206,
0.0498480201,
-0.0431524105,
0.0475044586,
-0.0208926667,
-0.0465302467,
-0.020455949,
0.0009733458,
-0.0000133889,
-0.0204804689,
0.0261856262,
0.0378680825,
-0.0264495369,
-0.0711944103,
-0.0658611581,
0.0201342013,
0.0048059206,
-0.080432117,
-0.0017063451,
-0.0249890815,
0.0290306285,
-0.01659243,
0.0246739909,
0.0263899155,
-0.0026375407,
0.0030921113,
-0.0093287658,
0.0723842755,
-0.025012875,
0.0152033139,
-0.0098213917,
-0.0057723778,
0.0558706261,
0.0671884492,
0.0339842625,
0.0265263841,
0.0044276356,
-0.0213202164,
-0.0206289198,
0.0546686575,
0.0154117281,
0.0129535841,
0.0084654614,
0.0045626368,
0.0315688998,
0.0162767954,
0.0652470514,
0.0412501097,
-0.0055952454,
0.0373783968,
0.0580324493,
0.0120936204,
0.0353800356,
-0.008033636,
0.0760887787,
0.0212696046,
0.0151594514,
0.0647560582,
-0.0600615703,
0.0177519917,
-0.0462610088,
0.0196044017,
0.0230355933,
0.075919196,
-0.0277026463,
-0.0428957008,
-0.0010155985,
0.0019035483,
0.0014880877,
-0.0040414208,
0.0442708433,
-0.0030124264,
-0.0658232719,
0.0142979641,
0.0660016239,
-0.0122399684,
-0.0326378569,
-0.046714168,
0.03844098,
0.0580680631,
0.0000419824,
-0.0143379057,
-0.0595182925,
0.0230321791,
0.0478106439,
0.0227136184,
0.0413294323,
-0.0013830484,
-0.0000184352,
-0.0830238312,
-0.0192366969,
0.0108108064,
0.0205844622,
-0.000023773,
0.0262243766,
0.0072027887,
-0.0022566521,
0.0288317092,
-0.0350654237,
0.083005093,
-0.0236640815,
-0.0479294024,
-0.0601995736,
0.0247233324,
0.0362325646,
0.0024511246,
0.0000139747,
-0.0288079493,
0.0468729623,
0.0036260721,
0.046580527,
-0.0186136346,
-0.0556285456,
-0.0158473048,
0.0415144712,
0.0382904932,
-0.0172782484,
-0.0200190786,
-0.0403979458,
-0.0360344499,
-0.0184344128,
-0.0148111004,
0.0487372205,
-0.0190874934,
0.0715253353,
-0.0127757629,
0.0145656262,
-0.0513714179,
0.0187382661,
-0.0137475831,
0.0461328775,
0.0217176955,
-0.0204210319,
-0.0088495212,
-0.0108667882,
-0.0205657873,
0.0130209439,
0.0082687642,
-0.0161728375,
-0.0050264541,
0.0642606243,
-0.0433601215,
-0.0582834184,
-0.0447488129,
0.0124778021,
-0.04152596,
0.0469872095,
0.0356697328,
0.0088198101,
-0.0272947941,
-0.0076987334,
-0.0029068287,
0.0053965556,
-0.0331159234,
0.0130449869,
0.019788783,
0.0270050913,
-0.0706895813,
-0.0607752688,
-0.0147474632,
-0.0116444295,
-0.0129533326,
0.0092301881,
-0.006727986,
-0.0705297366,
0.0108552035,
-0.0133511759,
0.0087347636,
-0.0226430576,
-0.0899153054,
0.017286174,
0.0059716175,
0.0594102032,
0.0558559932,
0.0082495296,
0.0264988784,
0.0577884652,
-0.0103771249,
-0.017763827,
0.0087097604,
-0.027865313,
-0.0565501414,
-0.0558316745,
-0.03016009,
-0.0188255329,
0.1064261794,
-0.0294205155,
-0.006582764,
-0.0778365135,
-0.0158854872,
-0.013060621,
0.0211232286,
0.032948412,
0.0115573872,
-0.0300057288,
0.0011410688,
-0.0229452625,
-0.0821766034,
0.0576665811,
-0.0482753403,
-0.0349090435,
-0.0731244981,
0.0055863946,
-0.0069503915,
0.0096227089,
0.0394381098,
0.0192717016,
0.0160456914,
-0.0198283661,
-0.0702088922,
0.0281228926,
-0.0027491977,
-0.011271595,
0.0247801039,
-0.0314397663,
0.0019977626,
-0.0214322302,
-0.0122691654,
-0.0303584505,
-0.0241467245,
-0.0011462074,
-0.0001665318,
0.0377988368,
-0.0410754792,
-0.0304483734,
-0.0141293388,
0.0113431485,
0.0318209603,
-0.0232459661,
0.0080244122,
-0.0455392711,
-0.0259512458,
0.0597189777,
-0.0064876983,
0.0145707531,
-0.0415876321,
0.0369605944,
-0.0191696286,
0.0271298178,
-0.0245438386,
-0.0294930153,
0.0175434835,
0.0577821434,
-0.0564853586,
-0.0076871323,
0.0389887914,
0.1026089042,
-0.0526117049,
0.0017871051,
0.1123810709,
0.0323481523,
-0.0102489283,
0.0092709819,
0.0137683572,
0.0601275712,
0.0177690778,
0.0416878127,
-0.0491445549,
-0.0213134252,
0.0000510159,
0.0379948281,
-0.0057653724,
0.0321641974,
-0.011352933,
-0.0787568912,
0.0194896441,
0.0262068864,
-0.0241285432,
-0.0154966954,
-0.0291113518,
0.0006380831,
-0.0185661037,
0.0286402721,
0.0457495749,
-0.0560555607,
0.0071496456,
0.0251286086,
0.0005467874,
-0.0410779454,
-0.0014282658,
-0.0480499342,
0.0817851871,
0.0686705783,
-0.010555069,
0.0042819967,
-0.0402413867,
0.0444260836,
-0.0188922826,
-0.0268349349,
-0.0047658533,
0.0034326857,
0.0031847137,
-0.0127698388,
-0.0020968174,
0.0310181491,
0.0109658502,
0.0271024983,
0.0034614007,
0.0490298159,
-0.0108838314,
-0.009031821,
0.0070061907,
-0.0042831288,
-0.0150267975,
0.0494792797,
0.035901092,
-0.0517385192,
-0.0218692217,
-0.0225740355,
-0.0212670658,
-0.0415023565,
-0.0117429411,
0.0129104834,
-0.0813757032,
-0.0048719393,
-0.0564679168,
-0.0625430569,
0.0401897505,
0.0186887868,
0.0324679799,
0.0071996092,
0.0442122743,
-0.0248465855,
-0.0093108369,
0.0239620544,
0.0025538479,
0.0085837189,
-0.1019707024,
-0.0853770897,
0.039434433,
-0.0082709854,
0.0017195824,
0.0088275187,
-0.0748069659,
-0.0757058486,
0.0434445366,
0.0617012568,
0.0095223244,
0.0294337515,
0.0052002193,
-0.0513127148,
0.0626026616,
0.0166070946,
0.0079135671,
0.0416657813,
0.0391029418,
-0.0074082259,
-0.0004752013,
0.0192838628,
0.0073103569,
0.0286039431,
-0.0110803172,
0.0589235947,
-0.0190677624,
-0.0145975584,
0.0138099566,
-0.0148662627,
0.0452707894,
-0.0494246446,
-0.0261849109,
-0.0606695712,
0.0422356166,
0.0056273653,
0.0234748553,
-0.0377754457,
-0.0105963415,
0.0182451531,
0.0027136987,
-0.0198116377,
-0.0250929743,
-0.032596685,
-0.004602666,
-0.0385372415,
0.0439858362,
-0.0085816346,
0.0424398892,
0.0083766766,
0.0083794966,
0.0022031234,
0.0274252295,
0.0082990751,
0.0460972376,
-0.00918967,
0.0646428168,
-0.0057951831,
0.034809459,
-0.0416991934,
0.0533293225,
-0.0023050543,
0.0103909904,
-0.058816094,
0.0326527618,
0.0406537242,
-0.0312696435,
0.0539788119,
-0.0105947871,
-0.0109606767,
-0.009895049,
0.0282952897,
-0.047469534,
-0.0132813808,
0.0279116482,
0.0218400713,
-0.0378994308,
-0.0116988067,
0.0728815272,
0.0251113307,
0.0792353153,
-0.0122668622,
0.0277191661,
-0.0039730491,
-0.0345249437,
0.0068937042,
0.0259530358,
-0.0331646912,
0.0038563577,
-0.0092724217,
-0.0372515395,
-0.0213296004,
0.0068237302,
-0.0262199584,
-0.0140114883,
0.0272576865,
0.0343733616,
-0.0407830551,
-0.0259807538,
-0.0299195051,
-0.0681679845,
0.0365603045,
-0.0210824441,
-0.0098463073,
-6.693596911e-33,
-0.083699353,
0.0072111706,
0.0323298611,
-0.0197065379,
-0.030967908,
-0.0201788973,
-0.0022746203,
0.0063778432,
-0.0090955729,
0.0029974808,
-0.0002474634,
-0.01162731,
0.0183055867,
0.0104764672,
0.032557711,
0.0340299346,
0.0476660468,
-0.0283856802,
-0.0137179289,
-0.005290247,
-0.0037613211,
0.0323353596,
0.0615866184,
-0.0133157587,
0.0117857317,
-0.0058481116,
-0.0368150696,
-0.0262424368,
-0.0680879727,
0.0602221377,
-0.0289005358,
-0.0109424805,
0.0020582245,
-0.0079971561,
-0.0472331755,
0.0069585689,
-0.0577359051,
-0.0270717312,
0.0366543941,
0.0207849685,
-0.0119997934,
-0.0358545147,
0.0320804603,
-0.0428731032,
-0.0298328623,
0.0138384607,
0.0105225043,
-0.0432028621,
0.0162546504,
0.0075173466,
-0.1077822223,
0.0094843069,
0.0069391504,
-0.0358123295,
0.0177351721,
0.0238501448,
0.0075740428,
0.0138654867,
-0.0479762442,
0.0174740627,
0.0742580742,
0.0860360563,
0.0376360044,
0.0322808065,
0.0036590791,
0.0039913305,
0.0323612802,
-0.0555833094,
0.0393096544,
0.0155923991,
0.0586686879,
-0.0051762951,
0.0116415741,
-0.0374733731,
0.0505810231,
0.0114526413,
-0.0556517057,
0.0132680256,
0.0174648035,
0.0321213305,
0.0204430055,
0.0180741232,
-0.0366698205,
-0.0024433502,
-0.0220378526,
-0.0020740661,
-0.0032640868,
-0.017039001,
0.0310361944,
0.0423663221,
-0.0101200575,
-0.0016946539,
0.0447179973,
-0.0049456856,
-0.0168643836,
-0.047154583,
-0.0521196909,
0.0181648284,
-0.0136289047,
0.0355737507,
-0.0718353167,
-0.0727602094,
0.0399709903,
-0.021017706,
0.0176920239,
-0.0050559631,
0.0610249713,
0.0198389739,
-0.089322187,
0.0254187249,
-0.0067111277,
0.0020126461,
0.0149686867,
0.002419878,
0.0579116121,
-0.0162041094,
0.0058710789,
0.0622514039,
0.0373606645,
-0.0299718436,
-0.0449460745,
-0.0372198857,
-0.0075904303,
0.0458229072,
-0.033919584,
0.0285260361,
-0.0236035753,
0.010552993,
-0.0697748438,
-0.0450109839,
-0.0221667234,
0.0437504835,
2.771e-7,
0.0197187979,
0.0542824939,
0.0183375422,
0.0235702451,
-0.0011856431,
-0.0080166543,
-0.0355075002,
-0.0022202011,
-0.0102670118,
-0.0000981109,
0.0386785157,
0.0172992758,
0.0388944112,
-0.0259066038,
-0.0508950613,
-0.0154694272,
-0.0387202203,
0.0180231724,
-0.0885029882,
-0.0256956108,
0.0194571633,
0.1222894639,
0.002355926,
0.0192018356,
0.0183479786,
0.0345679522,
0.0345013142,
0.0127128549,
-0.0134499213,
0.0250954889,
0.0117559414,
0.0168224741,
-0.0451615788,
-0.0042403783,
-0.031393066,
0.0345572643,
-0.0517114289,
0.0705110505,
-0.0216265116,
-0.0067992462,
0.0459265225,
0.0248126984,
-0.0260708239,
-0.0393612608,
0.0668858737,
-0.0247110315,
-0.012582113,
-0.0031395776,
-0.0065611997,
-0.0255976021,
0.0271160025,
-0.0365496427,
0.0169266984,
0.0347869396,
0.0144256214,
-0.0163155366,
-0.0527306311,
-0.0717235431,
0.0131621044,
0.0316893905,
-0.0186777525,
-0.0478995144,
-0.053811226,
0.0033942757,
0.0311870184,
-0.0442335084,
-0.0043263203,
2.738697503e-34,
0.026880322,
-0.046322532,
0.0522127636,
0.033246398,
0.0085498691,
-0.0104262168,
-0.0147736594,
0.0319545679,
0.0133679304,
-0.0916498452,
-0.0015342819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00284v1
|
A Closer Look at Logical Reasoning with LLMs: The Choice of Tool Matters
| 2024-06-01T03:29:56 | 2024-06-01T03:29:56 |
Long Hei Matthew Lam, Ehsan Shareghi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Logical reasoning serves as a cornerstone for human cognition. Recently, the
emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has demonstrated promising progress
in solving logical reasoning tasks effectively. To improve this capability,
recent studies have delved into integrating LLMs with various symbolic solvers
using diverse techniques and methodologies. While some combinations excel on
specific datasets, others fall short. However, it remains unclear whether the
variance in performance stems from the methodologies employed or the specific
symbolic solvers utilized. Therefore, there is a lack of consistent comparison
between symbolic solvers and how they influence LLM's logical reasoning
ability. We perform experiments on LLMs integrated with 3 symbolic solvers: Z3,
Pyke, and Prover9, and compare their performance on 3 logical reasoning
datasets: ProofWriter, PrOntoQA, and FOLIO. Our findings indicate that when
combined with LLMs Pyke's performance is significantly inferior to that of
Prover9 and Z3. Z3's overall accuracy performance slightly surpasses Prover9,
but Prover9 could execute more questions.
|
[
0.0188468304,
0.0486380793,
-0.0088852784,
0.0288801268,
-0.086809054,
0.023865493,
0.033574298,
0.0178665929,
0.0254414864,
-0.0340746492,
0.0351514705,
0.0419290401,
-0.0145956427,
0.0174224488,
0.0167691205,
0.0200704765,
0.0393645987,
-0.0446384475,
0.0484381951,
-0.0202154983,
-0.0171343479,
0.0140178576,
-0.0132620009,
0.0057200161,
-0.0061857766,
-0.0244251341,
-0.0171954818,
-0.0029094019,
0.0026773526,
-0.0133893657,
-0.0458712801,
0.0278970208,
0.0243957359,
0.039090924,
0.0000021637,
-0.0543002635,
0.009170685,
0.0282244366,
-0.0652031824,
0.0128880274,
-0.0068599777,
-0.0061234203,
-0.0001391224,
0.0503031872,
-0.0256673284,
0.011020191,
-0.0102443118,
0.0513181053,
0.0504234023,
0.0382905267,
-0.0015441264,
-0.0480500273,
0.0177041274,
0.0188258514,
0.0044572777,
-0.0068894289,
0.0228742771,
0.0467987359,
0.0429192595,
-0.0726558715,
0.0191946402,
0.0276853945,
0.0539404936,
-0.0014625918,
-0.05710347,
0.0164059829,
-0.0681910962,
-0.0061303503,
-0.0112390108,
0.0203862265,
0.024045147,
-0.0291626975,
-0.0165450908,
0.0074084266,
-0.0159317646,
0.0162440948,
-0.0246311426,
0.076608032,
-0.0465257652,
-0.0158641394,
0.0390762575,
-0.04042634,
0.0428953655,
0.0186429378,
-0.0682491809,
0.1450544894,
0.0136467777,
-0.0492265746,
0.0517729335,
-0.0381834283,
-0.0321338065,
-0.0736836791,
0.042189531,
0.0672220141,
-0.0280281324,
0.0249052867,
-0.0374950357,
0.0130165005,
0.0190427117,
-0.0502439663,
0.0313826166,
0.0740993395,
0.0563338138,
0.0244485997,
-0.0589378998,
0.0676871389,
0.0073563852,
0.0928542316,
-0.0004987177,
0.0058009699,
-0.0525608584,
-0.0352269076,
-0.0310891569,
0.0590639189,
-0.0133154262,
-0.0107185123,
-0.0013365967,
0.0161319487,
0.0012368597,
0.0410289727,
-0.0110058673,
-0.0296318214,
0.0262723584,
-0.0268210936,
-0.0619703569,
-0.008297923,
-0.0286970567,
0.0341517515,
-0.0023522202,
-0.0108143697,
0.0123241199,
0.0078945113,
-0.0018693997,
-0.0226075519,
0.0483124442,
0.0534602851,
-0.0151428664,
-0.0035978872,
-0.0447960161,
-0.0490185879,
0.0278257467,
-0.1190009192,
-0.0292249303,
-0.0787851736,
0.0396536589,
0.0502212085,
-0.044665508,
-0.0274405982,
0.0160266124,
0.0131906308,
0.019306127,
0.0580144934,
0.0296578221,
0.0077421372,
0.0300854519,
0.0151851373,
-0.0210976023,
0.0309530087,
0.0249208231,
0.0078958506,
-0.052086439,
0.0027048755,
-0.0328606851,
0.0226344187,
0.0029594621,
-0.0118762217,
-0.0542092435,
0.0438756868,
-0.0218150001,
0.0357493348,
-0.0338183828,
0.0611477494,
-0.0217845179,
-0.0071954234,
0.0217414573,
0.0421469212,
0.0311783999,
-0.0230941419,
0.0062355725,
-0.035029266,
0.0462348871,
-0.0334650502,
-0.0666670054,
0.0241238773,
-0.0483518727,
0.0211589113,
-0.0365673564,
0.0378549211,
-0.0061983634,
-0.0589155518,
-0.0462726764,
0.0444522165,
-0.0213912912,
0.0403143391,
0.0430999249,
-0.0275531355,
-0.0128451688,
0.0860391632,
-0.0051919557,
-0.0470676683,
-0.031621214,
-0.0461393744,
0.0681023672,
0.0425539203,
0.0426736288,
-0.0255512018,
-0.027205782,
-0.0248809271,
0.0060461024,
0.0218415037,
0.0044290302,
0.0156800374,
-0.0208776612,
-0.0287566576,
-0.0204464626,
-0.0274136979,
-0.0009138542,
0.0131182848,
0.0279325172,
0.0146629987,
0.0027419354,
-0.0432513766,
0.0445581377,
0.0242224261,
-0.0718108639,
0.007983516,
-0.0466242582,
0.0046899579,
0.0295525175,
0.0012065546,
-0.0089739962,
0.0118483836,
0.0247244872,
-0.0269880909,
-0.048181884,
0.0120782703,
-0.003254558,
-0.0157162398,
0.072837472,
-0.0359121338,
-0.0279443599,
0.0252450258,
-0.0477849692,
-0.013604397,
0.0299755801,
-0.0276325922,
0.0002949528,
-0.0344928876,
0.0172508862,
0.000798337,
-0.0557513647,
-0.0025116203,
0.0722501427,
-0.0111465873,
-0.0004415599,
0.0296806768,
0.0145692602,
0.0215532742,
-0.0354140438,
0.0411212891,
0.0190145019,
-0.0069975266,
-0.0053011891,
-0.0393876731,
-0.0122504886,
-0.0373446308,
-0.0211800765,
-0.0196860023,
0.0345471278,
-0.0051489035,
0.0241408665,
0.0091541335,
-0.0221434832,
-0.0068475027,
0.0350079201,
-0.0308849756,
0.009980063,
0.0257522222,
0.0099568004,
0.0058939019,
0.001740252,
-0.0378503613,
-0.0046552746,
-0.0120202173,
-0.0461922698,
0.0098393792,
0.0205916036,
0.0146993082,
-0.0195278712,
0.0387742035,
-0.055120524,
0.0099809505,
-0.0036682629,
0.0093626101,
0.0212979801,
-0.0200838912,
-0.0131147169,
0.0676006749,
-0.0356620289,
-0.0164410099,
0.0404407382,
-0.0297958851,
-0.0551056825,
0.0219272058,
0.0067403368,
0.0238237623,
-0.0394400321,
-0.0639778301,
-0.0396857522,
0.0166655146,
-0.0014458924,
0.0154889133,
-0.0116874669,
0.053789217,
0.0059845923,
-0.0078443494,
-0.0184043944,
-0.0159372427,
0.0146277808,
0.0492331721,
-0.0299723186,
-0.0177545808,
0.0558566898,
-0.0087073594,
0.0114991814,
-0.0352874473,
-0.0080825835,
-0.0672701448,
0.0548450723,
-0.0173934586,
-0.0057042236,
-0.0366185829,
-0.0301497094,
-0.017611187,
-0.0585983209,
0.0408145376,
-0.0252422839,
0.0604104362,
-0.0440520868,
0.0455703139,
-0.0121450881,
-0.0418925174,
-0.0330854505,
0.0047030901,
-0.0833889693,
0.0258064438,
-0.0399388894,
0.0013846373,
-0.0249387138,
0.0086491071,
0.0136672752,
-0.007206691,
0.0166375358,
-0.018569205,
-0.0416378565,
-0.0399738178,
-0.0068937815,
0.0314373374,
0.033788316,
-0.0213723555,
0.0203860477,
0.0341912135,
0.0031497967,
-0.0377134793,
-0.0161079895,
0.0221742615,
-0.0055189077,
-0.0363095067,
0.0090971561,
0.017371079,
-0.0015802449,
-0.0688847601,
0.0134746712,
0.0941744074,
0.0496350564,
0.0588303059,
-0.0132140955,
-0.0557091348,
0.0024260769,
0.0525590889,
0.0504755639,
-0.1127450913,
-0.0456678756,
0.0371716358,
-0.0125613026,
-0.01277385,
-0.0317419805,
-0.0014331976,
-0.1130531207,
0.050407432,
0.0203047935,
-0.0352736227,
0.0023001009,
-0.0190023892,
-0.0161268599,
0.0012753948,
0.0191959944,
0.0404952317,
0.0008927834,
-0.0095583498,
0.0036251463,
-0.006593958,
0.0293239933,
0.0395654291,
-0.0157095492,
-0.0120782955,
0.0082291588,
0.0114045264,
-0.020807879,
-0.0754502565,
0.0240910985,
0.0654941872,
-0.0009669319,
-0.0422459096,
-0.0108813383,
0.0377281047,
0.0239061397,
-0.0558625758,
0.0155602731,
-0.0259616356,
-0.0401277952,
0.0293917079,
0.0705655143,
-0.0218963958,
-0.025850907,
-0.0146858124,
0.0321758054,
-0.0676092505,
0.045735158,
0.003260609,
0.0273581222,
-0.082046099,
-0.0496846884,
-0.0610259846,
-0.0153074758,
0.0101061631,
0.0322183594,
0.0192822255,
-0.0128868073,
-0.0112502929,
0.0029923657,
0.0692994446,
0.0257732943,
-0.004115433,
0.0053544287,
-0.0141196549,
-0.0000967503,
-0.0613896251,
0.0011119827,
-0.0454431176,
0.0596201792,
-0.0326855518,
0.0497658662,
-0.0353264995,
-0.0437335707,
-0.0175476391,
-0.0076372679,
-0.0627427921,
-0.0615614131,
-0.0303755198,
0.0367330499,
0.0308985244,
-0.0233537108,
0.0019322239,
-0.0342069976,
0.0094126519,
0.0347505026,
0.0167035852,
0.0122025907,
0.0175169036,
-0.0185945015,
0.0137425447,
0.0104525406,
0.0079028429,
0.0153844282,
0.014390015,
0.0553757623,
-0.012004612,
0.0187949892,
0.0192104913,
0.0724496245,
-0.0247112717,
0.0411658585,
-0.037998382,
-0.0064501069,
0.0471780673,
-0.0512264445,
-0.0314184502,
-0.0026570132,
0.0129875457,
-0.0098487241,
0.0059404192,
0.0046165166,
-0.0318771787,
-0.0181888305,
0.0180652644,
0.017831035,
0.0550944991,
0.0172535498,
0.0024514103,
0.0723712817,
-0.0343116373,
-0.0077375551,
0.0062760138,
0.0030359081,
0.059511181,
-0.0151792746,
0.0556971245,
0.0090628685,
0.0239898097,
-0.058293391,
-0.0464286245,
-0.0552844815,
-0.1001667157,
0.0685667768,
-0.006183621,
0.0439755395,
0.0247249436,
-0.0223511271,
-0.0435665734,
-0.0190197546,
-0.0019657738,
0.0006911334,
0.0344229154,
-0.0182844624,
0.0524805598,
0.0185369179,
-0.0155700138,
-0.0423690416,
0.0254231989,
-0.0217221137,
0.0565889739,
0.0086070569,
-0.0253275558,
-0.0381227881,
-0.0489477701,
-0.0026595546,
0.0014579406,
-0.0150647229,
-0.0355481282,
-0.0689472333,
-0.0731989965,
0.0270614531,
0.0417219549,
-0.0024048099,
-0.0110506471,
-0.0104783308,
0.0391610041,
0.0453407206,
-0.0696206167,
0.0084488951,
0.0262689162,
-0.030785419,
-0.0227889493,
0.0117422743,
-5.993544107e-33,
-0.0248528216,
-0.0216368455,
0.0632770658,
0.0040725702,
0.0111943157,
-0.0420003235,
-0.0441260263,
0.0203356966,
-0.0013440375,
0.0271756295,
-0.0276320223,
0.0339954644,
0.02155976,
-0.0265078731,
-0.0018349765,
-0.0127071021,
-0.0071026096,
0.0191089138,
-0.0180837438,
-0.0386445932,
0.0151773607,
-0.0139521258,
0.0088831754,
-0.0198373608,
-0.0265046842,
0.0283331424,
0.0015572933,
0.0111756278,
-0.1163337231,
0.0406931676,
0.0179185513,
0.007462217,
-0.001629208,
0.0075035249,
0.0054516159,
0.0154921021,
-0.0376779698,
-0.0036703162,
0.0439483449,
0.0016266888,
-0.0251012798,
-0.052766066,
0.0430040061,
0.0145762498,
-0.0297780707,
-0.0450286604,
0.0011491852,
-0.0488229468,
-0.0017265904,
-0.0459760502,
-0.0330694281,
0.0171695277,
-0.0138804978,
0.0144629972,
0.0029715437,
-0.014055118,
-0.0274992529,
-0.0020209509,
-0.0310652871,
-0.0107575357,
0.0303054582,
-0.0282743871,
0.0722862035,
-0.0059478818,
-0.0193492826,
0.0267412178,
0.0274056755,
-0.011791137,
-0.0262734611,
0.0481420122,
0.0108799916,
0.1028619632,
0.0781822577,
0.0140390443,
0.0314255171,
0.0185162481,
-0.0914178789,
-0.000241677,
0.0143790869,
0.0527046733,
0.0539628007,
0.0135672539,
-0.0293502081,
-0.0074274959,
-0.0477828309,
0.0566860698,
-0.05937846,
-0.0085533122,
0.0303393528,
-0.0137045356,
0.0003676174,
-0.0343699567,
0.0139345014,
-0.0384875983,
-0.0322096534,
0.0125185633,
0.0277280863,
0.0015858209,
-0.0253867619,
0.0604016781,
-0.0596689396,
0.0043358966,
-0.0176353287,
0.0062953103,
0.0377999954,
0.0045253891,
0.0175911486,
0.0242507793,
-0.0478848405,
-0.0049716351,
-0.0626875237,
0.0254541542,
0.0390759483,
0.0032193072,
0.039410729,
0.0203414932,
0.0204660483,
-0.020771414,
-0.0357781313,
-0.0718538985,
-0.0421870537,
0.0469984747,
0.012914395,
0.0009172641,
0.0148073873,
0.0013466598,
-0.0403109938,
0.0165285487,
0.0120128365,
-0.0282818824,
-0.0033364764,
0.0145609267,
2.853e-7,
0.0222498626,
0.0415538847,
0.0209619049,
0.093613416,
0.0057272064,
0.010043201,
-0.029163016,
-0.0263091996,
0.0382959917,
-0.0078501953,
-0.0306828488,
0.0622718707,
0.0526448674,
0.0310668536,
-0.0290833563,
0.0037652345,
0.0011529824,
-0.0424466319,
-0.073740162,
0.0499975793,
0.0820016786,
0.0419380441,
0.0352138616,
-0.0317765474,
0.00224296,
-0.0742412433,
0.0326209664,
-0.0065172995,
0.0152857555,
-0.0141875353,
0.0221830308,
-0.016285805,
0.0374812558,
0.0749582797,
0.0119399158,
0.0000838328,
-0.0356493369,
0.0791577473,
0.0100692417,
0.0042307628,
-0.035393443,
-0.0488231778,
0.0112364404,
-0.020962026,
0.0906614736,
-0.0356874317,
-0.0320918262,
0.0266753845,
-0.0036271876,
-0.0599898659,
-0.0224226285,
0.0011147041,
0.0382388532,
0.0199628249,
0.0146369208,
-0.0352120027,
0.0103844395,
-0.0638515949,
-0.0198440105,
0.0339118801,
-0.0499894693,
-0.0291676465,
-0.016986547,
0.0327810086,
0.0327013694,
-0.0381461009,
-0.0354180411,
2.744132328e-34,
0.0302806627,
0.012672618,
0.0280795153,
0.0460189022,
0.0846884623,
0.0221425593,
-0.0352544039,
0.0146866227,
0.0081020324,
-0.0855005234,
0.004210473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04370v1
|
Large Language Model Confidence Estimation via Black-Box Access
| 2024-06-01T02:08:44 | 2024-06-01T02:08:44 |
Tejaswini Pedapati, Amit Dhurandhar, Soumya Ghosh, Soham Dan, Prasanna Sattigeri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Estimating uncertainty or confidence in the responses of a model can be
significant in evaluating trust not only in the responses, but also in the
model as a whole. In this paper, we explore the problem of estimating
confidence for responses of large language models (LLMs) with simply black-box
or query access to them. We propose a simple and extensible framework where, we
engineer novel features and train a (interpretable) model (viz. logistic
regression) on these features to estimate the confidence. We empirically
demonstrate that our simple framework is effective in estimating confidence of
flan-ul2, llama-13b and mistral-7b with it consistently outperforming existing
black-box confidence estimation approaches on benchmark datasets such as
TriviaQA, SQuAD, CoQA and Natural Questions by even over $10\%$ (on AUROC) in
some cases. Additionally, our interpretable approach provides insight into
features that are predictive of confidence, leading to the interesting and
useful discovery that our confidence models built for one LLM generalize
zero-shot across others on a given dataset.
|
[
0.0348639302,
0.0959600434,
-0.0060950611,
0.0780402347,
-0.0217482988,
0.0060402332,
0.0206977371,
-0.0165527631,
0.0180885084,
-0.0199983772,
-0.0297208112,
-0.0683668405,
0.0020748819,
0.0656345412,
0.0293510053,
0.0060001505,
0.0048821871,
-0.0301897973,
0.0217097178,
-0.0288387761,
-0.0250402708,
-0.0018807913,
-0.004560797,
0.0639215559,
0.0442678854,
-0.001995686,
-0.0026872347,
-0.0043930463,
-0.0125595033,
-0.0214191228,
0.0004512876,
0.0557490736,
0.0113822613,
0.0386978351,
0.0000017662,
-0.0506036915,
-0.0491909683,
-0.0181098171,
-0.058890041,
-0.0092122098,
0.0256420486,
0.0089052981,
0.0261573792,
0.0400229767,
-0.0523017086,
-0.0055832779,
0.0673343688,
-0.0263505802,
0.0156520121,
0.0281215589,
0.0135335457,
0.0154780746,
-0.0037437659,
-0.0180884469,
0.0301684402,
-0.0517414995,
0.0083556632,
-0.0104839066,
-0.0451407731,
0.0271249469,
-0.0415780731,
0.0491220355,
0.0174606722,
-0.024722971,
-0.0066152392,
-0.0019843706,
-0.0484318063,
-0.0304355882,
0.0239084903,
0.042896539,
0.0149931721,
-0.0226884447,
-0.0368465222,
0.0210119262,
0.0279843938,
0.0363212787,
-0.0457540229,
-0.0002392999,
0.0068062069,
-0.0107613262,
0.016606804,
0.000047707,
0.0170844346,
-0.0025843375,
-0.0029090371,
0.0769288242,
0.0034819043,
0.0320313498,
0.0095735984,
0.0040196725,
-0.0100281574,
-0.0568558015,
0.0110990983,
0.0161270425,
-0.0118384203,
0.0438851193,
-0.0153112207,
0.0156425983,
0.0233787186,
-0.0004621961,
0.0071113193,
0.006007459,
-0.0356697589,
0.0613371693,
-0.0007419177,
0.0376670472,
0.0276804268,
0.01809627,
0.0077112475,
-0.0112795765,
-0.0171135217,
-0.0144729856,
-0.0006212579,
0.0136954868,
-0.0104121417,
0.0138306394,
-0.0693479106,
-0.0130450269,
0.024807252,
0.0402515344,
0.0369212627,
0.024844354,
-0.0115936073,
-0.0333889946,
-0.0164818764,
0.027882304,
0.00976633,
0.0139586423,
-0.0173832458,
-0.1027199328,
0.0038315079,
-0.0152819287,
0.0136857312,
-0.0155729447,
-0.0047375043,
0.0458446592,
0.023330776,
-0.0523520857,
-0.0048906999,
-0.0452843457,
-0.0375097916,
-0.0519559942,
-0.0193747282,
-0.0696469322,
-0.0042177066,
0.0289922561,
0.0244463217,
-0.0269463155,
0.0143860364,
-0.0165075753,
0.0034091279,
0.0769611672,
-0.0018299251,
-0.0069623487,
-0.0220408663,
-0.0010859193,
-0.0223116279,
0.0796227381,
0.0205551144,
0.0370799974,
0.0829401985,
0.0021156694,
0.0154536404,
0.0123644043,
0.0283620749,
0.0148743428,
-0.0080192955,
0.0199645516,
0.0060123401,
-0.0242102165,
-0.0209568627,
0.0214521475,
-0.0062372549,
-0.0383693576,
0.1052635014,
0.0405872464,
0.0087832287,
-0.0321542248,
0.0211137477,
0.0002641546,
0.0273129903,
0.0005851733,
-0.0216298364,
0.0075351181,
-0.0354526415,
-0.003138006,
0.036488831,
0.0316311829,
0.0229602847,
-0.074877806,
-0.009437534,
-0.0102799973,
-0.0268002544,
0.0646317527,
0.0607916154,
-0.0369738303,
-0.0122379679,
0.0004391113,
0.0191628635,
-0.0370808169,
0.0157813057,
-0.0519585162,
0.0521305986,
0.0067756777,
0.0238862056,
-0.0013798064,
-0.0148219541,
-0.0263932385,
-0.0061938483,
0.0154662533,
0.0288719591,
-0.0200107098,
0.0364586562,
-0.0279925652,
-0.0321548618,
0.0156417415,
0.0570119806,
0.0253094789,
0.0117486054,
0.0121274777,
-0.0147312731,
-0.0605013147,
-0.023862835,
-0.0143270921,
-0.0257046986,
-0.0534471199,
0.0047348058,
-0.0066196704,
0.0215323623,
0.0105187623,
-0.0010246553,
0.0297569297,
0.0207065083,
0.0008706193,
-0.0225502551,
0.0000750952,
0.0173113123,
-0.0201462619,
0.0482177585,
-0.0157622043,
-0.0041966606,
0.0408727713,
-0.0180690661,
-0.022433484,
-0.016935233,
-0.0296191275,
0.0573708303,
-0.0181552805,
0.0329766013,
-0.0383257158,
0.0155252842,
-0.0447387025,
0.0357653797,
-0.027107399,
0.037028864,
0.0017944458,
-0.0248326678,
0.0349150524,
-0.0117290951,
-0.032986857,
0.0291681904,
-0.0048794439,
0.0080908975,
0.0357423015,
-0.0257518403,
-0.0427597538,
0.0048093507,
-0.0629034936,
0.0012675644,
-0.0286129322,
0.0124272089,
0.0160387065,
-0.0148586072,
-0.0057881423,
-0.024741156,
-0.0602752231,
-0.0059103244,
-0.0012649311,
0.0410800576,
0.009691474,
0.0043544471,
-0.0201991405,
-0.0385389477,
-0.0281533059,
-0.0262045246,
0.0652940795,
0.0361893326,
0.0202397332,
-0.0401800163,
0.0342800543,
-0.0294081345,
0.0111198826,
-0.004305989,
-0.0395458825,
0.0146950688,
-0.0330480449,
-0.0632657856,
0.0633587614,
0.0022229548,
-0.0082619125,
0.0570145845,
-0.0211748648,
-0.0578636825,
-0.0255417395,
-0.0271916017,
-0.0607472621,
-0.0507765375,
-0.0621334724,
0.0082760723,
0.0436982401,
0.0217031687,
-0.0430384725,
-0.0353229418,
0.0301444922,
-0.0029638412,
-0.0282270368,
-0.0506534278,
0.0162998494,
0.0097254207,
0.0794380009,
0.002953857,
-0.0658596456,
0.0651189312,
-0.0333314128,
0.0222765878,
-0.0191105939,
-0.0111743156,
-0.019960124,
0.0777200982,
0.0058318023,
0.0114940815,
0.0238271412,
-0.0424852632,
-0.0432009138,
-0.0171770304,
0.0271016974,
-0.0798005983,
0.0252519175,
-0.0478150249,
-0.0164833106,
0.029129304,
-0.0363885798,
-0.0374542177,
-0.0212897938,
-0.076563254,
-0.0220179651,
0.0221240669,
-0.0801676735,
-0.0129799899,
-0.0152785163,
0.014840275,
-0.0051984405,
-0.0432053506,
-0.019272605,
0.0064343116,
0.0261341296,
0.0873708501,
0.0011015955,
0.0659125373,
-0.034849979,
-0.0050746156,
0.0667612255,
0.0180967525,
0.0362137333,
0.0095902886,
-0.026635224,
0.0538312383,
-0.0042747878,
-0.0142073557,
0.0278501492,
0.0534413233,
-0.0435422771,
-0.0146529991,
0.1303952336,
0.037847843,
-0.0291170627,
-0.013258555,
-0.0337929055,
0.029380098,
0.0245669074,
0.0207511038,
-0.0553553812,
-0.0316930898,
-0.0055612875,
0.0333477631,
-0.0223798845,
-0.0525706671,
-0.0071487427,
-0.1482392997,
0.0158522539,
-0.0139433034,
-0.0331399925,
-0.0495217554,
-0.0492541827,
0.0207269434,
-0.0457710624,
0.0169012863,
0.020572532,
0.0045769806,
0.0210146233,
-0.0003110467,
-0.0320761725,
-0.0461037979,
0.0332717784,
-0.0362482332,
0.0456348732,
0.0373156555,
0.0175499637,
-0.0195392631,
-0.0209188275,
-0.0212916899,
0.0076038861,
-0.0455513448,
0.0013083766,
0.0999853387,
-0.0008946183,
-0.0272508617,
0.0067549078,
0.0274310168,
-0.0241961833,
0.0355792418,
0.0112540731,
0.0268972516,
0.0052021011,
-0.0224315654,
0.0010323455,
-0.0159222502,
0.0229981225,
0.0774872601,
0.0298555903,
-0.0357480794,
0.0207301136,
-0.0507845506,
-0.0105009163,
-0.0236676577,
-0.0442307591,
0.0466479324,
0.0155378487,
-0.0198538471,
-0.0497258045,
-0.0198300071,
0.0347004905,
0.0306609552,
0.0017185921,
0.0266054999,
0.0297762211,
-0.009687244,
-0.0274931416,
0.0222458337,
-0.049319692,
0.0236738864,
-0.0403041765,
0.0508650579,
0.0389639772,
-0.0122539252,
-0.0336152688,
0.0145750167,
-0.0847427547,
-0.0721837431,
0.009530521,
0.0413308889,
0.0305790827,
-0.001593482,
-0.0136763556,
-0.0731259212,
0.0239537694,
-0.0091510527,
-0.0027673549,
-0.0168493539,
0.0208611824,
-0.0004469399,
-0.0035740754,
0.0517582372,
-0.0311661456,
-0.0272941422,
0.0208519921,
0.0140424278,
-0.046754092,
-0.024994202,
0.0309265908,
0.0107495822,
0.04701351,
0.0039523207,
-0.0035619994,
-0.0295691863,
0.0311979689,
-0.0163335111,
-0.0088416673,
-0.0487357564,
0.0167295877,
0.0525695533,
-0.0364766791,
-0.0177390408,
-0.0761662275,
-0.0399343744,
0.0482367687,
-0.0664672032,
-0.0087978048,
0.0308873579,
0.0124185588,
0.0548532046,
-0.0341836698,
-0.0017423816,
0.0288322065,
0.0292354468,
0.0641277581,
0.0487688519,
0.0143715469,
-0.0021632481,
-0.0447666049,
0.0202515237,
-0.0099461703,
-0.0692473501,
-0.0605335534,
-0.0285129361,
0.0197755452,
0.0180765186,
-0.0157362912,
0.0193978157,
-0.0309874117,
-0.0157962162,
-0.0179157536,
-0.0060486682,
0.0189732462,
-0.0165728126,
0.0720113665,
0.0118839378,
-0.0255338158,
0.0439717993,
0.0844327435,
0.0328923501,
0.0481182076,
-0.0096482523,
-0.0582773499,
-0.0198266599,
-0.005524782,
0.0427356996,
0.0414723493,
-0.0249621421,
0.0247099269,
-0.0520013422,
-0.1059545502,
0.0423603095,
0.0012059757,
-0.0069925003,
0.0032635063,
-0.0260187406,
0.0750330612,
0.0065563796,
0.0037313187,
-0.0736991912,
0.00647166,
-0.016655881,
0.0017438707,
-0.0134632243,
-6.365400357e-33,
-0.000696646,
-0.0838394463,
-0.0481676012,
-0.0386571623,
0.0431215949,
0.0160071813,
-0.0123855211,
0.0421743654,
-0.0406033024,
0.0288327709,
-0.0051723295,
0.018712692,
0.0207597949,
0.0279172901,
0.0264180973,
-0.041833777,
0.0180695467,
0.0285995658,
-0.0159806367,
-0.0115282824,
0.058553122,
0.0211986322,
0.0825025737,
-0.1021010354,
0.0982983857,
0.0113156596,
-0.0141363917,
0.0571160205,
-0.0295870211,
0.0755276456,
0.014484561,
0.0330885649,
0.0015931689,
-0.0466084294,
0.0042851828,
-0.0259849653,
-0.0185435619,
-0.0289983246,
0.0166893005,
0.0138444332,
-0.008547538,
-0.0047798902,
0.0044788625,
-0.0122211846,
0.0002597556,
-0.0248854365,
0.0159642827,
-0.0438185334,
-0.015091259,
-0.03180632,
-0.0157708824,
0.0325321816,
0.0020187772,
0.0100169722,
-0.0002851191,
0.0901475251,
0.0232579205,
0.001123224,
-0.0168988556,
0.0211706292,
0.0308609921,
0.0453936197,
0.061987441,
0.0171964709,
-0.008573547,
0.0467608608,
0.0017126601,
-0.0262586288,
0.0099041341,
-0.003754355,
0.0186143909,
0.0163182691,
0.0614191331,
0.1013052016,
0.0267010499,
0.0278879665,
-0.091885969,
0.0133482283,
0.0101446612,
0.0231895968,
0.0414546356,
-0.0069718538,
-0.0845254436,
-0.0026165668,
-0.0590836145,
-0.0362477042,
-0.0448597483,
-0.020425396,
0.0194621123,
0.0048014834,
-0.054787986,
-0.0021818525,
0.0348972306,
-0.0406635366,
-0.0522141717,
0.0308912899,
0.019440325,
0.0125338137,
0.0099390633,
0.057373859,
0.0003090368,
0.0322178453,
-0.0070465798,
-0.0271913912,
0.0019756376,
0.0259437133,
0.036174491,
0.0130846761,
-0.0707276389,
-0.0010940123,
-0.0265786294,
-0.0170889609,
0.0144666769,
0.0239202436,
0.0375728421,
-0.0228663478,
-0.0252246521,
0.0464121215,
0.0096715642,
0.0142482193,
-0.0138813751,
-0.0116371345,
-0.0162800979,
-0.0223921239,
-0.039870441,
-0.0563800819,
0.012516194,
-0.0132070677,
0.0453646593,
0.008530979,
-0.0014609257,
-0.0311505273,
2.497e-7,
0.0705321655,
0.0264517851,
-0.0442622378,
0.0367058031,
-0.0162302684,
0.0393800177,
-0.0040350445,
-0.0047739362,
0.0530427881,
-0.0587901697,
-0.0071037263,
0.0057755252,
0.0510691106,
0.0525487475,
-0.0792232528,
-0.0525629707,
-0.0099852337,
0.0021094799,
-0.0242059249,
-0.0010382077,
0.0496523269,
0.1318718344,
0.0210226178,
-0.0093908813,
0.0099336449,
-0.0302082058,
0.0205389429,
-0.0198368598,
-0.0565417893,
0.0286865812,
0.0601472408,
0.003463248,
0.0020653775,
0.010159093,
-0.0358662754,
0.0117519386,
-0.0227652099,
0.0469167978,
0.023350263,
-0.0069779838,
-0.0119656222,
-0.0299868286,
0.0264831185,
-0.0571252853,
0.0695860684,
-0.0168681946,
-0.0370284431,
-0.0549816191,
0.0251109507,
-0.0548038371,
0.0701867715,
-0.0469662622,
-0.0076675066,
0.0119820582,
-0.0065241242,
0.0098241419,
-0.0001937306,
-0.033588741,
-0.0428794175,
-0.023058787,
-0.0127296103,
-0.05865933,
0.0204728134,
-0.0234125834,
-0.0398091525,
-0.07019604,
0.0544509292,
2.465788352e-34,
0.0477733761,
0.0254103877,
0.0012843406,
0.0328916982,
0.0773527995,
-0.0240317807,
-0.0049917856,
-0.0001138333,
0.0436034314,
-0.0924106017,
-0.0112010483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00257v1
|
Are Large Vision Language Models up to the Challenge of Chart Comprehension and Reasoning? An Extensive Investigation into the Capabilities and Limitations of LVLMs
| 2024-06-01T01:43:30 | 2024-06-01T01:43:30 |
Mohammed Saidul Islam, Raian Rahman, Ahmed Masry, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Mir Tafseer Nayeem, Enamul Hoque
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural language is a powerful complementary modality of communication for
data visualizations, such as bar and line charts. To facilitate chart-based
reasoning using natural language, various downstream tasks have been introduced
recently such as chart question answering, chart summarization, and
fact-checking with charts. These tasks pose a unique challenge, demanding both
vision-language reasoning and a nuanced understanding of chart data tables,
visual encodings, and natural language prompts. Despite the recent success of
Large Language Models (LLMs) across diverse NLP tasks, their abilities and
limitations in the realm of data visualization remain under-explored, possibly
due to their lack of multi-modal capabilities. To bridge the gap, this paper
presents the first comprehensive evaluation of the recently developed large
vision language models (LVLMs) for chart understanding and reasoning tasks. Our
evaluation includes a comprehensive assessment of LVLMs, including GPT-4V and
Gemini, across four major chart reasoning tasks. Furthermore, we perform a
qualitative evaluation of LVLMs' performance on a diverse range of charts,
aiming to provide a thorough analysis of their strengths and weaknesses. Our
findings reveal that LVLMs demonstrate impressive abilities in generating
fluent texts covering high-level data insights while also encountering common
problems like hallucinations, factual errors, and data bias. We highlight the
key strengths and limitations of chart comprehension tasks, offering insights
for future research.
|
[
-0.0158655196,
0.0578256436,
-0.0093138618,
0.0449972525,
-0.0440370403,
0.0261851531,
-0.0085993242,
-0.0288642813,
0.0366932191,
0.019124072,
-0.0109531935,
-0.0062417299,
0.0130536901,
0.0610026568,
0.0099751437,
-0.086316362,
0.0068775662,
-0.0364017114,
0.0525093712,
0.0097183837,
-0.0232298411,
-0.013840124,
-0.0202016123,
0.0366185345,
-0.0364938751,
-0.0598296337,
0.0060829385,
0.0164704733,
0.014448747,
-0.0669967085,
-0.0666474178,
0.0100621022,
0.0377425179,
0.0229316056,
0.0000020119,
-0.0326036438,
0.0076980721,
0.006236956,
-0.0134754339,
-0.0357774198,
0.0160112884,
-0.0876087919,
0.0304812286,
-0.0114439037,
-0.0337828919,
-0.0323754176,
0.0510027669,
0.0259368084,
0.096737355,
0.0019883956,
-0.0149730295,
-0.0137367211,
-0.0210866462,
-0.0193774644,
0.0253728498,
-0.0447138101,
0.0006737921,
0.0674713999,
0.0385356992,
0.0271206591,
-0.0573919863,
0.0445056446,
0.0356807113,
-0.0081489915,
-0.0204323772,
0.0413581803,
-0.010351182,
-0.042558331,
-0.0092968661,
0.082551457,
0.0087701948,
0.0025367981,
0.0028330309,
0.0031594834,
0.001170298,
0.0346267186,
-0.1051591337,
0.0196657795,
-0.0212382358,
-0.0205336083,
-0.0183948725,
0.0005277142,
0.0210033897,
-0.0098020909,
-0.0448054895,
0.0175318196,
-0.0236391164,
-0.0064134146,
0.0092775999,
0.0121110482,
-0.0589430742,
-0.046957422,
-0.0251496788,
0.0497635566,
-0.0210870914,
0.0127495751,
-0.0094103487,
-0.0067304927,
-0.0034268508,
-0.0173888057,
0.0368697532,
0.0095084105,
-0.0449970327,
0.0777057707,
0.0004094538,
0.0571272224,
0.0021921189,
0.0066386838,
-0.0025941329,
-0.0434556864,
-0.0247299112,
-0.0307837296,
-0.0336654596,
-0.0320677683,
-0.0504178889,
-0.0410445556,
0.0007786743,
0.0183301922,
-0.0258995909,
0.0599606298,
0.0134774437,
-0.0007030192,
-0.0022552335,
-0.0156721193,
-0.0631593764,
0.0510402136,
-0.0486945286,
-0.01140822,
-0.0277583189,
-0.0516067483,
-0.0002963819,
0.0431465469,
0.0152692534,
-0.010285818,
0.0002536822,
0.0828225836,
0.0372251794,
0.0198215134,
-0.0241574403,
-0.0457677767,
-0.0320559479,
-0.0495121479,
0.0182638131,
-0.0601548031,
0.0138701415,
0.0120029561,
0.0025600633,
0.0064188624,
0.0205898192,
0.0497472286,
-0.0404209755,
0.0761972666,
-0.0317647308,
0.0104829483,
-0.0271436237,
-0.0204155855,
-0.0263383929,
0.0529119186,
0.0578768104,
0.0115146236,
0.0209216569,
-0.0316048972,
0.0082567288,
0.0219596922,
-0.0167572871,
-0.0440708511,
-0.0565782636,
0.0245855544,
-0.0494977869,
0.0229812488,
0.0136666261,
0.0562186129,
-0.0268467125,
-0.0325798094,
0.0661878064,
0.0482357144,
0.0498397499,
-0.020012483,
0.0252842009,
0.0003132661,
0.0242852103,
-0.0091583617,
-0.0488587953,
0.0593395792,
0.0489208959,
0.0341694765,
-0.041742079,
-0.0220509525,
0.0170426108,
-0.055369772,
-0.0257897265,
0.0232648235,
0.0013500144,
0.0135641592,
0.0379345492,
0.0193852019,
-0.0031832864,
-0.0171444733,
-0.007320303,
-0.0163115356,
-0.0041256738,
0.0257215407,
0.0259821769,
0.0574558228,
0.0416366793,
-0.0090974523,
-0.012514811,
-0.0152688287,
0.0246196538,
0.0392209776,
0.0651794448,
-0.0039886991,
-0.0468142405,
-0.030707147,
-0.0180054642,
-0.0116587309,
0.0094256205,
0.0071540768,
-0.0185690578,
-0.0059028314,
-0.0378926136,
-0.0842253566,
-0.028510021,
-0.0073775202,
0.027185414,
-0.0117383469,
-0.0160976741,
0.0079948111,
-0.0187893603,
0.0214291792,
-0.019348925,
0.0518154576,
0.0083687007,
-0.0300766993,
0.0062675606,
0.0565532707,
-0.0489125401,
-0.044319775,
0.036465358,
-0.0598015115,
-0.0511506423,
-0.0099102687,
-0.0366676114,
-0.0330302753,
0.014946064,
-0.0735094994,
-0.024875341,
-0.0105898464,
-0.0478910618,
0.0224074554,
0.0028480859,
-0.0326599702,
0.0756150559,
0.0107198013,
0.0134189297,
0.0007696245,
0.0508424006,
0.0453298725,
-0.0060357875,
0.0243448354,
0.0608116686,
0.0233680923,
0.0180771109,
-0.0072986251,
-0.0139385117,
-0.0414707325,
0.0145050893,
-0.0809937343,
-0.0047027925,
-0.0062843482,
0.0015298056,
0.0096589141,
-0.0270396117,
-0.0346780717,
-0.0447343215,
-0.039575398,
0.0297563486,
0.0143590225,
0.0032148422,
0.0710958466,
-0.0274124648,
-0.0080490392,
0.0154547039,
-0.0020605435,
-0.0290158987,
0.0428031683,
0.0681019574,
-0.0037985041,
-0.0016315209,
-0.0042733364,
-0.0587969534,
0.0037081137,
0.0037047847,
0.0416531041,
0.0384279191,
-0.0144641148,
0.0733561516,
0.0475960672,
-0.0381490514,
0.050290402,
0.0064169113,
-0.0511646233,
-0.0191515516,
0.0153071564,
-0.0095191374,
-0.0016634458,
-0.0118046934,
-0.0142016653,
-0.0188378599,
0.0435279682,
0.0115964739,
0.0107931653,
-0.0350937434,
0.0365920998,
-0.0169985276,
0.0204165578,
-0.0679872259,
0.0184057858,
0.0131059317,
0.0504116751,
-0.030293202,
-0.0510708988,
0.0419324003,
-0.0415210873,
-0.0202538203,
-0.0026089896,
-0.0148644308,
-0.0682637841,
0.0937254429,
0.0222097114,
0.0034380115,
-0.0299994405,
-0.0389933884,
-0.041603744,
0.0066991551,
0.030317435,
-0.0308142379,
0.0376258269,
-0.0761246234,
-0.0074727414,
-0.0144825447,
0.0113892313,
-0.0184033345,
0.002393445,
-0.0555155538,
0.0178345945,
-0.0080473125,
-0.0265073944,
-0.023460215,
0.0091246767,
0.043618679,
-0.0206178781,
-0.0075095375,
-0.0078329174,
-0.0332715847,
0.0083166631,
0.0269651525,
0.0667027235,
0.0267380029,
-0.0387485735,
0.0119110309,
0.0502099469,
-0.0083544487,
0.0230913572,
-0.0507492572,
0.0372433513,
-0.0296839904,
0.0235082395,
-0.0012076112,
0.0199069716,
0.0407552943,
-0.0603797138,
0.0343164913,
0.0744823888,
0.00876584,
0.0062187836,
-0.0038843213,
0.0158872288,
0.0379292443,
0.0333100036,
0.0090951463,
-0.1108232737,
-0.0201448333,
-0.0034038385,
0.016066879,
0.0386473536,
-0.0584666692,
-0.0397723392,
-0.1166858226,
0.076961115,
0.0076425532,
0.0025416454,
-0.0308550037,
-0.0549272709,
-0.0057643303,
-0.0027121648,
-0.0165614448,
-0.0299223065,
-0.0056808298,
0.015149137,
0.0164132994,
-0.0501648895,
-0.0000539738,
0.0043377941,
-0.0329765119,
-0.0349082388,
0.0009448422,
0.0681087449,
-0.0215510614,
-0.0340299532,
-0.0164980274,
0.0212722402,
0.0229682457,
0.0019975689,
0.0452058353,
0.0246558711,
-0.0482042059,
-0.0284010693,
0.0212069638,
-0.0273029897,
-0.0219108239,
-0.0204627272,
0.0734630227,
-0.03165254,
-0.0353710763,
-0.02832748,
0.0511383079,
-0.0339375809,
0.0647810847,
0.0641541258,
0.0160361696,
-0.0681787357,
-0.0358634032,
-0.0034654983,
-0.061726559,
-0.0288740266,
0.0369085148,
0.0722062886,
-0.021726625,
-0.0370404013,
-0.0300135575,
0.0522523597,
0.0521549881,
-0.0141347293,
-0.0023011777,
0.0204779189,
-0.0384708606,
-0.0280292574,
0.0560092032,
-0.0369001292,
0.0524702407,
0.0170593634,
0.0145767424,
-0.0105771646,
0.0073283557,
-0.0282464027,
0.0243666824,
-0.088783823,
-0.0014462024,
-0.0139698228,
0.0092079984,
0.0229552537,
0.0018369238,
-0.0095431423,
-0.0046551959,
0.0136352619,
0.0558136776,
-0.0153116221,
-0.0276108179,
-0.0417501144,
0.0463660061,
0.0135694277,
-0.0021954398,
-0.0103696128,
0.0109630264,
-0.0071145101,
0.0452301018,
-0.0065779155,
0.0150424112,
0.0214299653,
0.037722677,
-0.0021380312,
0.0325525142,
-0.0165884309,
0.0009564559,
-0.0375486612,
-0.0334591828,
-0.049079705,
-0.0128531819,
-0.0018971245,
0.0185213592,
-0.0058805854,
-0.0159135163,
0.0030302512,
0.0277667064,
-0.0101456149,
-0.0529713966,
0.0328500569,
0.0301679503,
-0.0458426662,
0.0040902356,
0.0069740159,
-0.0075274529,
-0.0084011583,
-0.0336698741,
0.0488943942,
0.0518287197,
0.0490405075,
0.0295231491,
-0.0255825277,
-0.0223523788,
0.0082578855,
-0.079628244,
-0.1190666184,
0.0615021102,
0.0307533778,
0.0459489226,
-0.0004970144,
0.0068835481,
-0.0449244529,
0.0047120312,
0.0055360179,
0.0120399008,
0.0361900814,
-0.0019109256,
0.0788562298,
0.0185499527,
-0.0224560164,
-0.0757022947,
0.0562210605,
0.0050794557,
-0.0075788712,
-0.0213628896,
-0.0126754967,
-0.0394268744,
-0.0033430418,
-0.0059539592,
-0.0337440185,
0.0120235775,
0.0410157815,
-0.0914324746,
-0.0986848697,
0.0350620262,
0.0229678582,
0.0117716473,
0.0203270875,
0.0147815542,
0.0466813669,
0.0396219902,
-0.0100905476,
0.0005455057,
0.0199896879,
-0.0158855934,
-0.0064504948,
-0.0243577808,
-5.520450977e-33,
-0.0057981862,
-0.0616173334,
0.0598992333,
-0.0268316232,
-0.007009862,
-0.0015149408,
-0.0447184741,
-0.0049852198,
-0.0108347982,
0.0301057473,
0.0299117267,
0.011062758,
-0.0027435774,
0.0122457948,
-0.0089125028,
-0.0386647135,
0.046490822,
0.0067290086,
-0.0234197415,
-0.0284111407,
0.0360003151,
0.0104996879,
0.0032035781,
-0.0714988783,
0.0472422913,
0.0333469398,
0.0156003861,
0.0136844004,
0.0097878668,
0.0427915044,
0.0011315111,
0.0350011662,
0.0307804327,
-0.0115248924,
-0.0618045926,
0.0572935678,
-0.0767747164,
-0.0611051582,
0.0107440194,
0.0288627241,
-0.0582324788,
0.0199298896,
0.051045686,
-0.0057362174,
-0.0027795706,
-0.0546365865,
0.042857483,
-0.037796542,
-0.0112161124,
0.0339687318,
0.0035164477,
0.037535619,
-0.0209636763,
-0.0028762009,
0.0298780818,
0.0486535467,
-0.0025949841,
0.0621688925,
-0.0427187085,
0.0589785501,
-0.0129639618,
-0.0753581598,
0.0527944826,
-0.0024756561,
0.0461605825,
0.0564670637,
0.019503668,
-0.0083970726,
-0.0665743202,
0.0219557378,
0.0126224654,
0.0710244924,
0.0571479574,
-0.0045160996,
0.0046852529,
0.0198680423,
-0.0439577252,
0.0167088956,
-0.0522885136,
0.053075362,
-0.024985332,
0.0098297279,
-0.0361604095,
-0.0279208478,
-0.0401660502,
0.0011435056,
-0.0403084345,
0.02336834,
0.0380619429,
-0.0264280848,
0.0337725542,
0.0675338805,
0.0115306983,
-0.0390022211,
-0.0245746151,
0.0011395945,
0.022779271,
0.0264577139,
0.0154545,
0.0028891175,
-0.0261457767,
0.0327992812,
0.0209363718,
-0.018054951,
0.0080441367,
0.0171471331,
0.0291658957,
0.0019232896,
-0.0638499409,
-0.0047067208,
-0.0282833818,
-0.0277805701,
-0.0122092115,
-0.0055969283,
0.064251706,
0.0103010293,
-0.0417003483,
0.0300878938,
-0.0015705548,
0.0129086794,
-0.0136002069,
0.0136294356,
-0.0617678873,
0.0002707348,
0.0087015852,
-0.0354539901,
-0.0118681397,
-0.0364403687,
0.0189739764,
-0.0658023581,
0.0027805751,
-0.0042849598,
2.597e-7,
0.0564534627,
0.0476844981,
0.0445289612,
0.0653105825,
0.0272484627,
0.0112686409,
-0.0521462262,
-0.0192541294,
-0.0085249105,
-0.02352966,
-0.0076655336,
0.0439553075,
0.0376076922,
0.0611301176,
-0.0173865017,
0.0163850766,
-0.0114684636,
-0.0423903912,
-0.0732603669,
0.0477263741,
0.1191068068,
0.0312804319,
-0.0182697792,
-0.0025015392,
0.0388657451,
-0.0857368633,
0.0545578897,
-0.0224048737,
-0.0117586432,
-0.0313839875,
0.0059304084,
0.0319837071,
0.0252351258,
0.0300497115,
0.0214989185,
-0.0037035514,
0.0354852453,
0.0170085095,
0.0236807074,
0.0374808349,
-0.0208198186,
-0.0075408313,
0.0014946288,
-0.0397614613,
0.0689213872,
-0.0726950988,
-0.0721339881,
0.0267288946,
-0.0153348343,
0.0062691201,
0.0328527242,
0.0077831387,
-0.0291320346,
-0.0013549458,
0.0312097706,
-0.0022316959,
0.02837901,
-0.017509589,
-0.0080213137,
0.0302790999,
-0.0202898402,
-0.0332102068,
-0.0387297943,
0.0057757539,
0.0076374742,
0.0181490313,
-0.0523843728,
2.399223918e-34,
0.0476119332,
-0.0248666536,
0.0028712286,
-0.033241123,
0.0774973035,
-0.0333558731,
0.0244856309,
0.0314380117,
0.0276376065,
-0.083369337,
-0.0080889799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00252v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00252v3
|
Multi-Modal and Multi-Agent Systems Meet Rationality: A Survey
| 2024-06-01T01:17:25 | 2024-06-18T04:22:39 |
Bowen Jiang, Yangxinyu Xie, Xiaomeng Wang, Weijie J. Su, Camillo J. Taylor, Tanwi Mallick
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MA
|
Rationality is the quality of being guided by reason, characterized by
logical thinking and decision-making that align with evidence and logical
rules. This quality is essential for effective problem-solving, as it ensures
that solutions are well-founded and systematically derived. Despite the
advancements of large language models (LLMs) in generating human-like text with
remarkable accuracy, they present biases inherited from the training data,
inconsistency across different contexts, and difficulty understanding complex
scenarios involving multiple layers of context. Therefore, recent research
attempts to leverage the strength of multiple agents working collaboratively
with various types of data and tools for enhanced consistency and reliability.
To that end, this paper aims to understand whether multi-modal and multi-agent
systems are advancing toward rationality by surveying the state-of-the-art
works, identifying advancements over single-agent and single-modal systems in
terms of rationality, and discussing open problems and future directions. We
maintain an open repository at https://github.com/bowen-upenn/MMMA_Rationality.
|
[
0.0265449472,
0.0710548311,
-0.0384550281,
0.0164725892,
-0.0544300713,
-0.0143997082,
0.028570734,
0.0024770184,
-0.0323418304,
-0.0304967575,
-0.0123344027,
-0.0091766817,
0.0114743216,
0.0345471837,
0.0027981624,
-0.0281336103,
0.0299227554,
-0.023241844,
0.0520511605,
-0.0181914065,
-0.006795696,
-0.0009727999,
-0.0080739567,
0.0605828017,
0.0040439498,
-0.0088764476,
-0.0442490354,
-0.0404119529,
0.0403446592,
-0.0133330319,
-0.0440656357,
0.0354865901,
0.0307997279,
0.0628692582,
0.0000019503,
-0.0525610074,
0.0025969972,
-0.001934884,
-0.0274422504,
-0.0113204056,
0.022988379,
-0.0050176606,
0.0133400979,
-0.0138636474,
-0.0875103399,
0.0398108475,
0.0243611597,
0.0359723009,
0.0628415421,
0.0437684469,
-0.0001996415,
-0.0159938857,
0.0103590442,
0.0137381013,
-0.0495372079,
-0.0367018804,
0.013473548,
0.038503211,
0.0365559161,
0.0135643482,
0.0241091195,
0.0019787224,
0.0092507703,
-0.0412852839,
-0.0548005067,
0.0340826623,
0.0517885685,
-0.0307492353,
-0.0188589823,
0.0713931099,
0.0322239064,
0.0130683277,
0.0091092102,
-0.0095285773,
-0.0083467886,
0.025845984,
-0.0215993579,
0.0597581826,
-0.0142162684,
0.0211280752,
0.0094252098,
-0.0162415411,
0.0357129313,
0.0278058257,
-0.0288083423,
0.0747599825,
-0.0219347887,
-0.0106394188,
0.0028440515,
0.0052442346,
-0.0065244581,
-0.0883571059,
-0.0317393504,
0.0638986528,
-0.0766784176,
0.0229710415,
-0.0238533355,
0.0170892421,
0.0450531617,
-0.067398116,
0.0095542353,
0.0195135344,
0.0421888754,
0.026071962,
0.0270056184,
0.0169077702,
-0.0086211609,
0.0314227454,
0.0063784607,
0.0097308466,
-0.0776520371,
0.0050493432,
-0.0256445352,
0.0226827227,
-0.0576557554,
-0.003667725,
-0.0204172302,
0.0464220904,
-0.0439596139,
0.0553565957,
-0.013291833,
0.0262367632,
-0.0132933529,
-0.0461137667,
-0.0652402714,
0.0079627121,
-0.041665107,
0.0578638613,
0.0078592133,
-0.0103798294,
0.0281935185,
0.0006679965,
0.0028391166,
-0.0109789055,
-0.0240801647,
0.07378418,
-0.0189064499,
0.0020972304,
-0.0414646715,
-0.0677358061,
0.0075874696,
-0.1009769365,
-0.0741761848,
-0.0374651775,
-0.0054199095,
0.0028105208,
-0.0196278486,
-0.0616046339,
-0.0015625085,
-0.0196941663,
-0.0223474428,
0.0845441893,
-0.0263777692,
0.0130829429,
0.0340585597,
0.0196929146,
-0.0315603539,
0.0609522127,
0.0761236325,
0.0145946639,
0.0499111414,
0.007699166,
0.0045607495,
-0.0160700958,
-0.0243313387,
0.0116331698,
-0.008841549,
-0.0070198267,
-0.0622219667,
0.0214109253,
-0.0216310322,
0.0552308448,
-0.0326352827,
-0.019132873,
0.0948482454,
0.0266004,
0.0440568291,
0.0294657983,
0.0474451669,
0.0210965481,
0.0056110122,
0.0034993591,
-0.0395725891,
0.0194040779,
-0.0162841566,
0.0037299108,
0.0084678316,
0.0411652066,
-0.0116840098,
-0.0717368498,
0.0019712395,
-0.0462033115,
0.032257624,
-0.0307308733,
0.0482232682,
-0.0489941947,
-0.0108001893,
-0.0509830229,
0.0130850645,
-0.0316416807,
-0.0098001426,
-0.0760631189,
0.0703319684,
0.0519534126,
0.0299286097,
-0.0222155508,
-0.0071172304,
0.0027017868,
0.0015745584,
0.0197887924,
0.032662347,
-0.0398842283,
0.0124344053,
-0.0616398863,
-0.0442695096,
0.0077872351,
0.0010201039,
0.0197551027,
-0.0399293453,
0.0339064114,
-0.0150008257,
-0.0079267211,
0.015062497,
0.0341149978,
-0.0189269632,
0.0213392824,
-0.0331905074,
-0.0003261308,
0.0600296371,
0.0236211345,
-0.0342901647,
0.0262907911,
0.0422695987,
0.0075279074,
-0.0661140904,
0.0698853657,
-0.0057683201,
0.0011546456,
0.0325231701,
-0.0295977909,
0.0062672603,
-0.0173120815,
-0.0023403789,
-0.041112531,
0.0346807502,
-0.0338550881,
-0.0131914672,
-0.0371701159,
0.0137636978,
-0.0113375233,
0.0011636034,
-0.0226679705,
0.0686614066,
0.0177506115,
-0.0481215492,
0.0427205488,
0.0358396918,
0.0169162098,
-0.0379242375,
0.0334987305,
0.0430194512,
0.042599339,
0.0322549865,
0.0197430979,
-0.0118826563,
-0.0071209157,
-0.0242589936,
-0.0666799173,
-0.0244607273,
0.0029872463,
-0.0052575036,
-0.0110250758,
-0.026766723,
0.0197363719,
0.0116197206,
-0.0035652022,
0.0776499361,
0.0631775931,
0.0150583526,
0.0384510905,
0.0311276577,
-0.0180443414,
-0.026639685,
0.0063625202,
-0.0188628435,
0.0274636596,
0.0522871166,
0.0149101289,
-0.0957372636,
0.0002634527,
-0.0654932931,
0.0267403219,
-0.0093465112,
-0.0328502357,
0.0344682261,
0.0131227644,
0.0146172578,
0.0481957942,
0.0321811959,
0.0131897805,
0.0604591481,
-0.0033507959,
-0.0535115711,
0.0239695292,
-0.0279596224,
0.0437352583,
-0.0820647776,
-0.0252825413,
0.0037536381,
0.0361655876,
0.0029354873,
0.0133404313,
-0.0231716167,
0.0821882784,
0.0045233052,
-0.0760409683,
0.0026920843,
-0.0464959182,
-0.0078173624,
0.0895834044,
0.0100372704,
-0.0267673433,
0.098296158,
-0.0046091052,
-0.0027992611,
-0.0204817969,
-0.0473546386,
-0.0427529477,
0.0678543746,
-0.0306570958,
0.0085393656,
0.0003171511,
0.0282221958,
-0.0382532105,
-0.0692835376,
0.0298134796,
-0.0064101024,
0.0844285414,
-0.0687489435,
0.0247663707,
-0.0146453399,
-0.0571305268,
-0.0165014621,
-0.037922062,
-0.0526699349,
-0.0032430515,
-0.0028189672,
-0.0440663882,
-0.0687715113,
0.0157264974,
0.0633887127,
-0.0070597138,
0.015702229,
-0.0315393955,
-0.0335749388,
-0.0011092301,
0.028078381,
0.0552261956,
0.0604741387,
-0.0459791757,
0.0690636635,
0.0705525354,
0.0062229265,
-0.0362553373,
-0.0235350225,
-0.0295695942,
-0.0000277236,
-0.0022539047,
-0.0058723916,
0.0346285813,
0.0523867197,
-0.0326930396,
0.016238099,
0.0907320604,
0.0061981776,
-0.0221111123,
0.001420745,
-0.0452452935,
0.0023978332,
-0.0127629759,
0.015445902,
-0.0324851796,
-0.0270985104,
0.0058168648,
0.0153149432,
-0.0273131058,
-0.0526153967,
0.0042126216,
-0.0523589738,
0.0561086945,
-0.0000028709,
0.0126684252,
-0.0010826808,
-0.0513211675,
-0.0069926456,
-0.0447459929,
0.0224703606,
0.0057169576,
0.0250029173,
-0.0169688761,
0.0108583719,
0.0004477461,
0.0100961039,
0.0001325739,
-0.0434058011,
0.0675616786,
0.0266368836,
0.0619799085,
-0.0059139454,
-0.0843043551,
-0.0575245321,
0.0313032977,
0.0284793135,
0.0059320568,
-0.00029125,
-0.0151955606,
0.0179104023,
-0.0159739219,
0.0091125993,
-0.0092516029,
-0.0343301855,
0.03515305,
0.0622005276,
-0.0550491884,
-0.0298812725,
-0.0373122282,
0.0270420611,
0.0112406267,
0.0571018383,
-0.0215503555,
-0.0437170863,
-0.0828592777,
-0.0248452723,
-0.0102092866,
-0.0591327213,
-0.0196007285,
0.0026340564,
-0.0286144465,
0.0047620484,
-0.0484177954,
-0.0681576878,
-0.0033735011,
0.055383075,
-0.0064491322,
-0.0231062807,
0.0444595851,
0.0131920055,
0.008030151,
-0.0328265168,
-0.0368454047,
0.0210564397,
-0.0082450667,
0.0301778167,
0.0055034296,
-0.0530561022,
4.91e-7,
0.0121216634,
-0.0170657244,
-0.060083773,
-0.0025286996,
0.0341234989,
0.0354338065,
-0.0040379744,
-0.0088053234,
-0.0366766155,
0.008670372,
-0.0214594845,
-0.0331248529,
0.0188638959,
0.0401199907,
0.0067674657,
0.0073952344,
0.0542061217,
-0.0047194357,
0.0342749506,
-0.0182405338,
0.0551014841,
-0.0587184839,
-0.060615208,
0.0052114152,
-0.0166509189,
-0.0264347382,
-0.0010481779,
-0.003140298,
-0.0138721708,
-0.0122169536,
-0.0201129522,
-0.0145392073,
-0.0314027593,
0.0042743324,
-0.0199602731,
0.0072580921,
0.0402370021,
0.0075045507,
-0.00936074,
0.0014598705,
0.0456706174,
0.0231297333,
0.0161662828,
0.0253041182,
0.0191174857,
-0.0141718024,
-0.0026874773,
0.0116343955,
-0.0135373585,
0.0508662947,
0.0155289695,
0.0815651715,
0.0355356894,
-0.0441077761,
-0.0366437286,
0.0329039171,
-0.1070276573,
-0.0437701903,
0.0507275984,
0.011677199,
0.050713215,
0.0713345483,
0.0313628055,
-0.0496503636,
0.0158773549,
-0.0028328341,
0.0281567685,
0.0581929237,
0.0122981211,
-0.0186367948,
0.0245905835,
-0.0589656606,
0.0202711131,
0.0678616315,
-0.0242240634,
0.0306061432,
-0.0459967181,
-0.0469460711,
-0.0416846238,
-0.0508023351,
-0.0141514055,
0.0332210846,
-0.0424994193,
-0.0419346951,
-0.0685628131,
-0.0245413184,
0.021227017,
0.0619570427,
-0.0083898939,
-0.0307566356,
-0.0063365069,
0.0543810017,
0.0274072047,
-0.0053321933,
-0.0567541942,
-0.0031967536,
-0.0450505763,
0.0336909592,
-0.012719308,
-5.689709674e-33,
-0.0071593961,
-0.0528145954,
0.0502694808,
-0.0444671549,
-0.001540825,
-0.0071793222,
-0.0296354797,
0.0018932438,
-0.0273929574,
0.05314558,
-0.0146795753,
-0.0039786687,
0.0267801173,
-0.0361897089,
0.0440423898,
0.0094289975,
0.0245759413,
-0.0023103335,
-0.0239690244,
0.001154247,
0.0398527533,
-0.0329720303,
-0.0000814296,
-0.0311443452,
0.0296104662,
0.0260866843,
-0.0218833461,
0.0395786688,
-0.0375946127,
0.0656191558,
-0.0196858644,
0.0282905847,
0.0275787562,
-0.020787904,
-0.0317578167,
0.0293398332,
-0.0098047582,
-0.0033433472,
0.008925667,
-0.0346221663,
-0.0472114831,
-0.0027594762,
0.007877321,
0.0103486525,
-0.0279041547,
0.0195300207,
0.0357672572,
-0.024526095,
0.0022292587,
0.0327670425,
-0.0518631972,
0.0236426722,
-0.0331455544,
0.0068620988,
-0.0211497787,
0.0201028623,
0.0087146489,
-0.0081653325,
-0.0779132918,
0.0609572344,
0.0045189545,
-0.0538779795,
0.0314588062,
0.007585628,
-0.0047100424,
0.0791619048,
0.0516565256,
0.0043278518,
-0.0751216412,
-0.0102829933,
-0.0082740067,
0.0951516703,
0.0371340327,
0.1254628003,
-0.0730142891,
-0.0137961274,
-0.0743277967,
0.0349331312,
0.0308710001,
0.0290799513,
0.0542265177,
0.0172503702,
-0.0360282697,
-0.0021700659,
-0.0096396385,
0.0020566233,
-0.0128881205,
-0.0328752957,
-0.0133357933,
0.0095251631,
-0.010791596,
0.015169099,
0.0361469463,
-0.045614209,
-0.0072771301,
-0.0016943261,
-0.0031748582,
0.0183579586,
0.0061607398,
0.0126307309,
-0.0431259796,
-0.0247001294,
-0.0054290765,
0.0293372292,
0.0026673756,
0.0020766438,
-0.0154061075,
0.0160401557,
-0.001671606,
0.0029200527,
-0.0136492057,
0.0041147778,
0.0272141043,
-0.016739415,
0.0360191129,
0.0022988478,
-0.0093573742,
-0.0117505491,
-0.0167929903,
-0.0142470822,
-0.0027862873,
-0.0474222638,
0.0236744564,
0.0074387477,
-0.0209408272,
-0.0238351896,
-0.0710521191,
-0.0104507515,
0.0211471282,
-0.0073518679,
-0.011167814,
0.0024193078,
2.718e-7,
-0.0064904802,
0.0249939654,
0.0110442238,
-0.0336891934,
0.0412376933,
0.0749302283,
-0.0361460447,
0.0092610177,
-0.0152418548,
-0.0172363929,
0.0447038189,
0.0378675982,
0.0166294612,
0.0616761781,
-0.0173816513,
-0.0583621152,
-0.0203901455,
-0.0369450599,
-0.0552445985,
0.0108538903,
0.0666787177,
0.0280984808,
0.0339099318,
-0.0084164487,
0.0083732773,
-0.0543982908,
0.0356754139,
-0.0191478617,
-0.0040952573,
0.0296038762,
0.036367286,
-0.0333777964,
-0.0005763417,
0.0097633628,
0.0287686996,
0.0204898715,
-0.0637812093,
0.0828361139,
-0.0058579412,
-0.0363073982,
-0.013416932,
-0.0518438928,
0.028703101,
-0.0306356046,
0.0393094458,
-0.0365999639,
-0.0716699138,
-0.0219474547,
-0.0092453472,
-0.0314766169,
-0.0015327282,
-0.0231613144,
-0.017344363,
0.0118871555,
-0.0207296573,
0.0182429701,
0.0069145411,
-0.0572124571,
0.0254644454,
-0.0057018958,
-0.0536679663,
-0.0695926547,
0.0011955866,
-0.0076944791,
0.0736135766,
-0.0643135682,
0.0076384032,
1.940947344e-34,
0.0289230291,
0.0003423611,
0.0030119538,
0.014372698,
0.0486325398,
0.0287846755,
-0.0247734375,
-0.0184736941,
0.0494781919,
-0.056067057,
-0.0258999392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01624v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01624v2
|
Unveiling Hidden Factors: Explainable AI for Feature Boosting in Speech Emotion Recognition
| 2024-06-01T00:39:55 | 2024-06-05T22:21:55 |
Alaa Nfissi, Wassim Bouachir, Nizar Bouguila, Brian Mishara
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, I.2.7; I.2.6; I.2.1; I.2.8
|
Speech emotion recognition (SER) has gained significant attention due to its
several application fields, such as mental health, education, and
human-computer interaction. However, the accuracy of SER systems is hindered by
high-dimensional feature sets that may contain irrelevant and redundant
information. To overcome this challenge, this study proposes an iterative
feature boosting approach for SER that emphasizes feature relevance and
explainability to enhance machine learning model performance. Our approach
involves meticulous feature selection and analysis to build efficient SER
systems. In addressing our main problem through model explainability, we employ
a feature evaluation loop with Shapley values to iteratively refine feature
sets. This process strikes a balance between model performance and
transparency, which enables a comprehensive understanding of the model's
predictions. The proposed approach offers several advantages, including the
identification and removal of irrelevant and redundant features, leading to a
more effective model. Additionally, it promotes explainability, facilitating
comprehension of the model's predictions and the identification of crucial
features for emotion determination. The effectiveness of the proposed method is
validated on the SER benchmarks of the Toronto emotional speech set (TESS),
Berlin Database of Emotional Speech (EMO-DB), Ryerson Audio-Visual Database of
Emotional Speech and Song (RAVDESS), and Surrey Audio-Visual Expressed Emotion
(SAVEE) datasets, outperforming state-of-the-art methods. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first work to incorporate model explainability into an
SER framework. The source code of this paper is publicly available via this
https://github.com/alaaNfissi/Unveiling-Hidden-Factors-Explainable-AI-for-Feature-Boosting-in-Speech-Emotion-Recognition.
|
[
-0.008859491,
0.0576064475,
-0.0178895853,
0.0158791896,
0.0258160979,
0.037414562,
0.0467045754,
-0.0310470443,
-0.009353851,
0.0266742967,
-0.0176632311,
0.027119603,
-0.0142524168,
0.0594792515,
-0.029098412,
-0.0889677256,
-0.0034475024,
0.0211445112,
0.0333424322,
0.0060630222,
0.0158964247,
0.0540701002,
-0.0359210894,
0.0633985177,
-0.0356830657,
-0.0012612985,
-0.0360698625,
0.0288893376,
0.0032447346,
-0.001131578,
-0.0455541871,
0.0190053508,
0.0114284288,
-0.0660146251,
0.0000020966,
-0.00161521,
-0.0327986255,
0.0083214426,
-0.073500067,
0.0117462641,
0.0284137633,
0.0101642106,
0.0013757077,
0.0172782987,
0.015851846,
0.0235665292,
0.0714333728,
0.0721168518,
0.0653896257,
0.0332201533,
-0.0220360663,
-0.0020381981,
-0.01975137,
0.0072996109,
-0.0112727517,
-0.0294023883,
-0.0206352379,
-0.0158054102,
-0.0422057174,
-0.0676356852,
-0.0307492297,
0.0175772961,
-0.0055692187,
-0.0197667368,
0.0658475086,
-0.0394505896,
-0.0073545529,
-0.0492787808,
0.0159701519,
0.0540697649,
-0.0032225219,
-0.0249444712,
0.0116208661,
-0.0176880937,
-0.0147946263,
0.0221759845,
-0.0353128575,
-0.0356762558,
0.038468305,
0.029414935,
-0.0117552169,
0.0418301076,
0.0454386808,
0.0077409842,
0.0249370765,
0.0030451135,
-0.0412027054,
-0.0010366644,
0.0067518959,
-0.0240000132,
-0.0464748591,
0.0005768137,
-0.0101762945,
-0.0001134763,
-0.0236944091,
0.00938386,
0.00510123,
-0.0287554916,
-0.0651516914,
-0.0059187682,
-0.0031109387,
0.0276972335,
-0.0517623983,
0.0199653637,
0.0275876075,
0.0505484678,
0.024765119,
-0.0464448817,
-0.0155918123,
-0.0022562696,
-0.0734862089,
0.0047366899,
0.0158989262,
-0.0070467643,
-0.0015758744,
-0.0166153815,
-0.0581985973,
-0.0361494981,
-0.0710478947,
0.0355619304,
0.0109988498,
0.0180895776,
0.0169407371,
0.0165060014,
0.0185573231,
0.0166112781,
-0.0449583717,
0.032663431,
0.0128567191,
-0.0836841464,
0.0119960671,
0.017598832,
0.0123006962,
0.0095901052,
0.0511777475,
0.0409897938,
0.0294625349,
-0.0227191187,
-0.0272299647,
-0.0273940414,
-0.0190616827,
-0.0523650572,
0.0040397351,
-0.0039988151,
0.0117073283,
-0.0181972738,
0.0297574569,
-0.0363563672,
-0.0158103518,
-0.0582135506,
-0.0110752601,
0.0814553723,
-0.0106051946,
0.0256364811,
-0.015971113,
0.0167451613,
-0.0265195109,
0.0231609233,
0.0376061834,
0.0294505116,
0.0607782416,
-0.0698932707,
0.0426129997,
-0.0416825339,
0.0290932469,
-0.0056398255,
-0.0139791705,
-0.0495765582,
-0.0798488259,
0.0103646871,
0.0404213667,
-0.0470939875,
0.0054153167,
0.0124075757,
-0.0050467071,
0.0417032428,
0.0296658371,
0.0642622858,
-0.0157681685,
0.0293503925,
0.0223629158,
-0.0061545204,
0.0034370234,
0.0485081747,
-0.0289888233,
-0.0161856748,
-0.0142691657,
0.0123889213,
-0.0432681479,
-0.0562067032,
-0.0210901909,
-0.0241063274,
-0.0268613603,
0.0680328384,
0.0480576456,
0.0059920577,
-0.0210111532,
0.0150844501,
0.0121919457,
-0.0972241089,
-0.00953185,
-0.0609298684,
0.0295905918,
0.0967894197,
0.0225833692,
-0.048960451,
0.00246749,
-0.0113095408,
-0.0189039018,
-0.0283821449,
-0.0213181302,
-0.0087862108,
0.0828626156,
-0.0551621988,
-0.0329034589,
0.0097727589,
0.0077502513,
0.0115626082,
-0.039259702,
-0.0110431854,
-0.0007168319,
0.0025960505,
-0.0275804121,
0.0060944399,
-0.0207446478,
-0.0445692465,
0.0103942715,
0.036911644,
0.070142515,
0.0262500923,
-0.008677044,
-0.017239593,
0.0318157859,
0.0077362964,
0.028936144,
0.0604376718,
0.0023323062,
0.0047871307,
0.0048062163,
-0.0084359692,
0.0417391844,
0.0526339039,
-0.0539183393,
-0.0586916842,
0.0540775657,
-0.0019969256,
0.0039321766,
-0.0123515772,
0.0612441301,
-0.0305136479,
0.0390346423,
0.0252821855,
-0.0096712923,
0.0318546221,
-0.0121160168,
-0.0219938923,
-0.0320463963,
0.0355081223,
-0.0289460979,
0.0056833928,
0.0349717885,
-0.0073241033,
-0.0111468015,
-0.0256197844,
-0.0485534407,
-0.0137905218,
-0.0157174617,
-0.0647554174,
-0.0453492552,
-0.015337145,
-0.0352314971,
-0.0308524743,
-0.0267022103,
-0.0098100891,
-0.0273252111,
-0.0029561478,
0.0100408215,
0.0152207566,
-0.0247604847,
-0.0353644192,
-0.0188907087,
-0.0393459983,
-0.0300745182,
-0.0007452001,
-0.0128767025,
0.0439940095,
-0.0106007168,
-0.0157411639,
-0.0015222186,
0.0116584692,
-0.0047495086,
-0.0181836337,
-0.0139026446,
-0.0424834378,
-0.0237755347,
0.0361197069,
-0.0502902195,
0.0277202316,
-0.0165454894,
0.0977260321,
0.0278344881,
0.0196911674,
-0.0001139123,
0.025363097,
-0.0095932875,
0.0376424864,
-0.0117997257,
-0.043398995,
-0.035233248,
0.0175085776,
0.0043923659,
0.028851755,
-0.0529938601,
0.0312698223,
0.0349580497,
-0.0508512594,
-0.0346293151,
-0.060108237,
0.0140873706,
0.0350896791,
0.0090346197,
-0.0618766025,
0.0142363636,
-0.022651501,
-0.0253411159,
-0.0271695442,
-0.0198811945,
-0.0226005018,
0.0747313276,
-0.05656543,
-0.0042616879,
0.0083042309,
-0.0131467069,
0.0176040549,
-0.0361315422,
0.0297055971,
-0.0462743938,
0.0282563269,
-0.0333953574,
-0.0341869779,
0.0585499443,
-0.0032161579,
-0.0057154838,
-0.0694948658,
-0.0474544615,
-0.005240147,
-0.0181392413,
-0.0379584841,
0.0124624697,
-0.006048569,
0.0525542274,
-0.0326309875,
0.0100815725,
0.0111763384,
0.0360329263,
-0.0004080674,
0.0227288418,
0.0535832345,
0.027363956,
0.0016281548,
0.0436343774,
-0.0164933447,
0.0701183677,
0.0119061349,
-0.0218817126,
0.0486198664,
-0.0162578039,
-0.0149450935,
-0.0259280317,
-0.0199928265,
0.0268811602,
-0.04261427,
0.0506832935,
0.0985166207,
0.0268411934,
-0.0167928468,
0.0438529588,
-0.0153479381,
0.0347159021,
0.0055744923,
0.0103932694,
0.0220789313,
-0.0317355804,
0.0334578119,
0.0730642527,
-0.0232637841,
0.0027747003,
-0.0050778072,
-0.0223091692,
0.0869432688,
-0.0007811442,
0.0033163084,
-0.0297590457,
-0.0411090776,
-0.0279962309,
-0.0719245523,
0.024343282,
-0.0418463238,
0.0033679926,
0.0063506756,
0.0532047302,
-0.0291613527,
-0.0474580042,
0.0443001799,
-0.0000852709,
0.0472094156,
0.0548964404,
0.0578457899,
0.0011706263,
-0.0292508621,
-0.0554422885,
0.0362975486,
0.0410212204,
-0.0083073899,
0.0629889145,
0.0470878072,
-0.0501203723,
-0.0216725282,
0.0472395904,
-0.0410627984,
0.0018047334,
-0.005613104,
0.0528541841,
-0.0407254696,
0.0100129247,
-0.0077625746,
0.008423687,
0.012590575,
0.0858569592,
0.0401829854,
-0.017871011,
-0.009268376,
0.0151391737,
0.0168681052,
0.0171185136,
-0.0513456464,
0.0179525409,
0.0175727904,
-0.0539671443,
-0.0369112641,
-0.0269523095,
-0.0252081919,
0.0677910298,
-0.0367756933,
-0.0118793966,
-0.0426676646,
0.0195149295,
-0.0415915847,
0.0845446065,
0.0783927143,
0.0162903015,
0.005428534,
-0.0082851686,
-0.0160851888,
-0.0557723343,
-0.0264147781,
-0.0222173184,
0.0141374366,
-0.0066389954,
0.0480608717,
0.0005930587,
0.0219260734,
0.0356744267,
0.0032626193,
-0.0579895265,
0.0353478417,
-0.0108797299,
0.0057824245,
0.0093321782,
0.0801615417,
-0.0327940397,
-0.0071394211,
0.0374189094,
-0.0355523415,
0.0433361121,
0.0034959763,
-0.028352404,
-0.0077830409,
0.00692872,
-0.0229402017,
0.0446156338,
0.0482844375,
-0.0048948461,
-0.0397672243,
-0.0295061581,
0.0106256055,
0.0042473595,
0.0346235633,
-0.0835672542,
0.0296731517,
-0.0014227609,
0.0084163835,
-0.0296804328,
-0.0746393055,
-0.0223270692,
-0.0928822234,
0.0044986098,
0.0760578439,
-0.0392458811,
0.0178268291,
-0.0445084199,
0.0432904698,
0.0189250074,
0.0392769948,
0.0095435092,
-0.02235738,
0.0331482813,
0.0522081964,
-0.0006078716,
0.0020220708,
-0.027602613,
0.0190185308,
-0.0288247634,
-0.030755654,
-0.0359996744,
-0.0049589137,
0.005239821,
-0.0575217493,
0.0711437464,
-0.0273493081,
0.0165210832,
-0.0053961468,
0.0373719931,
0.0099279555,
-0.030699335,
-0.0131743187,
0.0065233116,
-0.0526093133,
-0.0166201629,
0.0485679917,
-0.0046109473,
0.0079668397,
-0.0132965427,
-0.0221859254,
-0.0216282234,
-0.0042543598,
0.052617304,
0.0205943845,
-0.0039490778,
0.031913925,
-0.0212689303,
-0.0521803796,
0.0139024276,
-0.064730227,
-0.0003351946,
-0.0519921258,
0.0318841562,
0.0583879873,
-0.0519266464,
0.0219935514,
-0.0466648676,
-0.063354291,
-0.0663222149,
0.0220050756,
0.0359640568,
-5.739324352e-33,
0.0155550158,
-0.0395688415,
-0.0544344708,
0.0078626992,
-0.0143299699,
0.0404557027,
-0.0396687202,
0.0020421692,
-0.0283617135,
0.0537074208,
-0.0154038575,
0.0548267476,
0.0096787401,
0.0170933083,
0.0019040373,
-0.0444280617,
0.0437842049,
0.0294966865,
0.0006229182,
0.0358177796,
0.0438297726,
0.032364849,
0.0653475821,
-0.1269499362,
-0.0090742279,
0.0459819511,
-0.0462661237,
0.0058278432,
0.022928793,
0.038587112,
0.0040609823,
0.0229632594,
0.0063521317,
-0.0327876136,
0.0130254412,
-0.0492676161,
-0.0205913298,
0.0003828841,
-0.0017783093,
0.0499779768,
-0.0217265114,
-0.025250962,
0.028719034,
0.0135323815,
-0.0184297971,
-0.0407145657,
0.0315228589,
-0.0362308249,
0.0091872858,
-0.0083346283,
-0.0101248128,
0.0365548655,
-0.0441131443,
-0.0385960229,
0.041645743,
0.0495143346,
-0.0217530485,
0.0164858419,
0.0093590962,
-0.0113242948,
0.0388034098,
-0.0040507494,
0.0797690302,
-0.0132477432,
0.0234655105,
0.0596249402,
0.0839265138,
-0.0422591418,
-0.0442313291,
-0.0043186448,
-0.0151692573,
0.101428546,
0.0945750326,
0.0178598557,
0.0366370827,
-0.0151999556,
-0.0289711654,
0.0142131243,
-0.0019070855,
-0.0093946392,
0.0276913065,
0.0121944994,
-0.0666868836,
-0.0076430636,
-0.0433432795,
-0.0291733406,
-0.0114637613,
-0.0370278694,
0.0217571743,
-0.0326229408,
-0.0246241149,
0.0231925882,
-0.0324394777,
-0.0142361922,
0.06483078,
0.0313486233,
-0.0219799615,
0.0319751017,
0.0259297695,
-0.0324992202,
0.0174737033,
0.0021864886,
0.0364519581,
-0.0045484942,
0.0738382265,
-0.0162940826,
-0.0167283695,
0.0677930191,
0.0119312154,
-0.0082694562,
-0.0132200886,
-0.0027339868,
-0.0347030424,
-0.0023870079,
0.0026542749,
0.0008440212,
-0.0289621726,
0.0138236312,
-0.0037552456,
0.0872001871,
0.005779162,
-0.0378247499,
-0.0322849452,
0.0228877552,
-0.0150904618,
-0.0271347705,
-0.0021412373,
-0.0915708616,
0.0415663496,
-0.0261636265,
-0.0148794428,
0.0181653965,
2.859e-7,
-0.0423709787,
-0.0009051038,
0.0113959294,
-0.0682165101,
0.0250904057,
0.0568376817,
-0.0111512374,
-0.04060537,
-0.0092103593,
-0.0027277612,
0.0854844972,
0.0055466234,
0.1075211242,
0.0081194965,
-0.0312810987,
-0.0723603591,
-0.0327779017,
-0.0060396823,
-0.0021134622,
0.0172174815,
0.0443042591,
0.076958254,
0.0372686461,
-0.0278577842,
0.07804434,
0.0226581264,
-0.0135611938,
-0.0402562842,
0.0199112389,
-0.011297687,
0.0300168097,
-0.0476134606,
0.0225972626,
-0.0210768599,
-0.0403214879,
0.0272962321,
0.0009660388,
0.041327294,
-0.0121641262,
-0.0793917254,
-0.0148203699,
0.0526446365,
-0.0112220906,
-0.0069353976,
0.0455057658,
0.0161413122,
-0.0691261068,
-0.0274813082,
-0.0432717204,
-0.0229562037,
0.0079896515,
0.0059407479,
0.0143866669,
0.0392448157,
-0.0186101049,
-0.0566684604,
-0.022482099,
-0.0800408274,
-0.0091989515,
0.0097942809,
-0.0530991256,
0.031893786,
-0.0306535792,
0.0005531297,
0.0688136369,
-0.0258125346,
-0.0548003502,
2.319902157e-34,
0.0071155513,
-0.0098273931,
0.0126429982,
0.0131861623,
0.0277752075,
0.0085048666,
-0.0275219195,
-0.0126645574,
0.0690159872,
-0.0119650178,
-0.0093486207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00244v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00244v1
|
Controlling Large Language Model Agents with Entropic Activation Steering
| 2024-06-01T00:25:00 | 2024-06-01T00:25:00 |
Nate Rahn, Pierluca D'Oro, Marc G. Bellemare
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The generality of pretrained large language models (LLMs) has prompted
increasing interest in their use as in-context learning agents. To be
successful, such agents must form beliefs about how to achieve their goals
based on limited interaction with their environment, resulting in uncertainty
about the best action to take at each step. In this paper, we study how LLM
agents form and act on these beliefs by conducting experiments in controlled
sequential decision-making tasks. To begin, we find that LLM agents are
overconfident: They draw strong conclusions about what to do based on
insufficient evidence, resulting in inadequately explorative behavior. We dig
deeper into this phenomenon and show how it emerges from a collapse in the
entropy of the action distribution implied by sampling from the LLM. We then
demonstrate that existing token-level sampling techniques are by themselves
insufficient to make the agent explore more. Motivated by this fact, we
introduce Entropic Activation Steering (EAST), an activation steering method
for in-context LLM agents. EAST computes a steering vector as an
entropy-weighted combination of representations, and uses it to manipulate an
LLM agent's uncertainty over actions by intervening on its activations during
the forward pass. We show that EAST can reliably increase the entropy in an LLM
agent's actions, causing more explorative behavior to emerge. Finally, EAST
modifies the subjective uncertainty an LLM agent expresses, paving the way to
interpreting and controlling how LLM agents represent uncertainty about their
decisions.
|
[
0.0199201629,
0.0248968322,
-0.021410903,
-0.0041617318,
-0.0139165353,
0.0221158322,
-0.0321393944,
-0.0081352163,
-0.0123165073,
-0.0348146297,
-0.0546647944,
-0.0455496125,
-0.0363533273,
0.0005106431,
0.0129817771,
-0.0518710949,
0.011210477,
-0.0678690225,
0.0146375736,
-0.0460343026,
-0.0549666844,
-0.0541830473,
0.0012770065,
0.0419096239,
0.0125847859,
0.0087725427,
-0.0309658013,
-0.003649204,
0.0004776188,
-0.0345967673,
0.0002189378,
0.0136621306,
0.0562581718,
0.0270454362,
0.000002,
-0.0447832234,
0.0168108679,
-0.0512320809,
0.0029007795,
-0.0068927808,
0.0273937527,
0.0202059001,
-0.0298204161,
-0.004666375,
-0.0333523154,
-0.0152425151,
0.0172874201,
0.0568711534,
0.0118304724,
0.0605401993,
0.0181758981,
-0.004887721,
-0.0154631138,
-0.0172050353,
0.011000569,
-0.035628017,
0.0322977901,
-0.0180671774,
-0.001801819,
0.0036882285,
-0.0555019118,
0.0117212078,
0.0259446893,
0.0082784705,
-0.0140751638,
0.0602422506,
0.0448240228,
-0.0319195986,
-0.0113397567,
0.0553784743,
-0.0375983529,
-0.021941442,
0.0113152871,
-0.0256730244,
-0.007212312,
0.000537237,
-0.026422089,
0.038232144,
0.0347572006,
0.0400058292,
0.0043799416,
0.028906215,
0.0453444198,
0.0171152782,
-0.0508763716,
0.0757631958,
-0.0304527543,
-0.0567551926,
0.0465329587,
0.023067655,
0.0072244182,
-0.0656494647,
-0.0250123106,
0.0298716333,
-0.0437190682,
0.0457257852,
-0.0115260379,
-0.0129854251,
-0.0152224666,
-0.035075549,
0.0045454931,
0.0233704429,
0.0286207795,
0.043571502,
-0.0132691851,
0.0233587027,
-0.0204736274,
0.0867997855,
-0.0347498842,
0.0012821492,
-0.0064852214,
0.0146922311,
-0.0520811267,
0.0239064097,
0.001537272,
-0.0289449003,
-0.042850934,
0.0573767908,
-0.0338861011,
0.0210863668,
-0.0450879559,
-0.0016857797,
0.0124532916,
-0.0109662907,
-0.0704431683,
0.0042861132,
-0.0409740582,
0.0167452227,
-0.0008649754,
-0.0007269834,
0.002233082,
0.0031428309,
-0.0115513084,
-0.0053981245,
0.0144491037,
0.0927745178,
-0.0107588787,
-0.0561654456,
-0.0539123081,
0.0221649334,
0.0053798663,
-0.0658563375,
0.0135883009,
-0.0445293523,
-0.0189812966,
0.0263868049,
-0.0073271324,
-0.0477008112,
0.0000839243,
-0.0218625981,
-0.0248101186,
0.0747575164,
0.0351623818,
0.0152455531,
0.0221479442,
0.0007833477,
-0.0052909125,
0.0848200917,
0.0339212567,
0.0509169102,
-0.0082393587,
0.0303045548,
0.0534333475,
0.0172593817,
0.0324436389,
0.0641313717,
-0.0201296676,
-0.0273857322,
-0.0072160391,
0.0420566089,
0.059279792,
0.0555760972,
-0.0597476885,
0.0388297401,
0.0928284004,
0.0626212358,
-0.0220760759,
-0.0411788598,
0.0103826374,
-0.003069829,
-0.0122124739,
-0.013618486,
-0.0704963356,
0.0426703058,
0.0185819436,
-0.0032918265,
0.0291157458,
0.0012284659,
-0.0434247516,
-0.0448878743,
0.0184600148,
-0.0086026788,
0.0264585447,
0.0519726835,
0.0444925092,
-0.0123018874,
-0.0466639213,
-0.0318405069,
0.0299197547,
-0.0103089362,
0.0067844884,
-0.0450987555,
0.0575766042,
0.0530591644,
0.057963565,
-0.0351031125,
0.0004792429,
-0.0042744097,
-0.0063345912,
0.0421880931,
-0.0062844548,
-0.0220013764,
-0.0001120797,
-0.0397898145,
-0.0403663255,
0.0076868492,
0.0022036242,
0.041102767,
-0.0198041126,
0.0196202938,
-0.0212037321,
-0.0029619895,
0.0089229587,
0.0299589019,
0.0206622109,
-0.0518851094,
-0.0100600794,
-0.0098493993,
0.0683061779,
-0.0360856839,
-0.0290982798,
0.0084772008,
0.0239631888,
0.008900661,
-0.0622394457,
0.0346087329,
-0.0372010656,
-0.0203298163,
-0.0160035547,
-0.0172310527,
-0.0026329802,
-0.0580673404,
-0.0043865512,
-0.0626073703,
0.0041680899,
-0.0014716362,
0.0767693967,
-0.0134637002,
0.0345152244,
-0.0144656505,
-0.0068579633,
-0.0459088236,
0.0682100803,
-0.0007474595,
-0.008648959,
0.0364284441,
0.0272543132,
-0.0394716375,
-0.0120262085,
0.0109927012,
0.038611643,
0.0355931371,
0.0068130796,
0.0280513521,
-0.0042485385,
-0.0193189755,
-0.0191897228,
-0.0298159607,
-0.0431047752,
-0.0283581782,
-0.0037294296,
0.0067500528,
-0.0254774913,
-0.0145566352,
-0.0069487849,
-0.0133188581,
0.0365477465,
0.0118113272,
0.0441865958,
0.0063238679,
0.0211397521,
-0.0184518956,
-0.0353452675,
0.004624831,
0.0171321649,
-0.0229481831,
-0.0324694104,
0.0061756144,
-0.0764237121,
0.0278734379,
0.0020691284,
0.0599827208,
-0.0481648259,
-0.0581926629,
0.0181738697,
-0.0513798185,
0.0122350296,
0.0863424614,
0.007392223,
0.0604305156,
0.1106126755,
0.0089486726,
-0.0584024638,
0.0204571169,
-0.0392958373,
0.0041190321,
-0.0723553225,
0.0375248455,
0.0309190676,
0.0629299954,
-0.0021219018,
0.0213136468,
-0.0482270494,
-0.0344730094,
-0.0379088931,
-0.0878122002,
-0.0361630283,
-0.0169534795,
-0.0383658968,
0.0611077584,
0.0156336948,
-0.0242617987,
0.0755602494,
0.039794717,
-0.0185599606,
-0.0280449092,
-0.0054147625,
0.0253151879,
0.0714313164,
0.0509341732,
-0.0008267079,
0.0172559693,
-0.0150512755,
-0.067782782,
-0.0282857679,
-0.0016972368,
0.0119215958,
0.0764733106,
-0.0369615927,
0.0044666044,
0.0048745032,
-0.0473241657,
-0.0526278354,
-0.0482641235,
-0.0350167044,
-0.0214830842,
0.0105146877,
-0.0360761508,
-0.008952044,
-0.0123829478,
0.0696493834,
0.0255268198,
0.0001532829,
-0.0395205021,
-0.0207797345,
-0.0465080552,
0.045566041,
-0.0097572682,
0.0661165267,
-0.0783338994,
0.036464937,
0.0448874384,
0.0362132713,
-0.0137837362,
-0.009011182,
-0.012612327,
0.0379786119,
-0.0243495144,
0.0025197333,
0.0569645278,
0.0825808346,
-0.0205580611,
-0.0224993303,
0.1057482958,
0.0147175547,
-0.0532633774,
0.0215816293,
-0.0057852962,
0.0421005152,
0.0117924381,
0.0120913591,
-0.0313411094,
-0.043824587,
0.0005902183,
0.0202046111,
-0.0503064319,
-0.0195629522,
0.0489674993,
-0.1021912917,
0.017127106,
0.017655341,
-0.0216155723,
-0.0008118154,
-0.023085814,
0.0107736662,
-0.0213274918,
0.0381189063,
0.0132451886,
0.0031931119,
-0.022983687,
-0.006828777,
0.0270603448,
-0.0278813746,
0.0240190923,
-0.0372460969,
0.0462004915,
0.0393659063,
0.0170274079,
-0.0119422991,
-0.0034531606,
0.0243296176,
-0.039381355,
0.0091040377,
0.0127386283,
0.0212798826,
-0.0064488011,
-0.0074986895,
0.0058461404,
0.0377506688,
-0.0352662578,
-0.0089842882,
-0.0300793331,
0.0476054139,
-0.0622098409,
-0.0299825016,
-0.0022308629,
-0.0180576406,
0.0410499945,
0.0631471127,
-0.009558918,
-0.0639715269,
-0.0641982928,
-0.0444365181,
-0.0319631584,
0.0066409116,
-0.0351418443,
0.0177138336,
-0.0035432088,
-0.0195500553,
-0.0518525131,
-0.0753106698,
0.0452358313,
0.0516413972,
-0.0007549998,
-0.013097493,
0.0358496904,
0.0061481418,
0.0253734794,
-0.0248392187,
-0.0278757159,
0.0301473383,
-0.0523022749,
-0.0103470059,
0.0424558781,
-0.00740937,
0.0070232251,
0.0251200944,
-0.0267067682,
-0.0917864218,
0.0356635451,
0.0483911149,
0.0258149896,
0.0415391736,
-0.0238581672,
-0.0577449687,
0.1009723246,
-0.0007033395,
0.0033263199,
0.0319524333,
0.045388937,
0.0499240942,
-0.0123946378,
0.0579811111,
-0.0456313305,
0.0078010447,
0.0332196876,
0.0081007034,
-0.093003571,
-0.0271034148,
0.0151083609,
-0.0567740388,
0.0399224274,
-0.0393097289,
0.0149769317,
-0.014754897,
0.0138279153,
-0.0149171064,
0.0083497846,
-0.0185447168,
-0.0290493667,
0.0371222384,
0.0065997462,
0.0027407478,
0.0094303982,
0.0300799999,
-0.0217912626,
0.0125963548,
-0.0004150426,
0.0180850457,
0.0244382229,
0.0437615998,
0.0058455137,
-0.0066736592,
0.0096579641,
0.0151556535,
0.024215797,
0.0414689705,
0.0788994431,
0.048938334,
-0.0403348245,
-0.0439048111,
0.0016634121,
-0.1211923584,
-0.0522727408,
0.0363489017,
0.0431360267,
0.0750402585,
0.0091152135,
0.0453329422,
-0.0833585262,
0.0228470135,
0.0013912071,
0.0054598902,
-0.0031490645,
-0.0389372259,
0.0590420626,
0.0219470616,
-0.0028765481,
0.0102007883,
0.057834316,
-0.0010779726,
0.0848617852,
-0.0061715231,
0.0332770683,
-0.0178879034,
-0.0352871716,
0.0252928138,
0.0347320698,
-0.038191352,
0.010286686,
-0.0290894303,
-0.0403997861,
-0.0549259856,
0.028036708,
-0.0237075742,
-0.0932430401,
0.0443363562,
-0.0063537876,
-0.006221713,
-0.025608182,
-0.0458602384,
-0.0189384185,
0.0037853103,
0.0001902502,
-0.029078614,
-6.414023212e-33,
-0.0172213409,
-0.0106061017,
0.0276312195,
-0.0092243766,
-0.0074521466,
-0.0423660465,
-0.0303783994,
0.0238715783,
-0.0267195534,
0.0256572906,
-0.0322127752,
0.0207252223,
0.0166072454,
0.0106679192,
0.0276671909,
-0.0274381097,
0.0241519585,
0.0062708864,
-0.0368966907,
0.0102847079,
0.0575450398,
-0.0015217252,
0.0446207859,
-0.0572211705,
-0.0009079538,
0.000767611,
-0.0397897847,
0.0348794833,
-0.0102155441,
0.0111411093,
-0.0034110821,
-0.0016761963,
0.0004907523,
-0.0573749132,
-0.0290499963,
0.0056193452,
-0.0090395669,
-0.0623848476,
-0.0275350995,
0.0347270258,
-0.0473988391,
-0.0113215372,
0.0199540444,
0.0013367685,
-0.046211198,
0.0581376888,
0.0054280963,
0.0086867856,
-0.0444815569,
-0.0157739725,
-0.0544008799,
0.0119287018,
0.0199739877,
-0.0293811169,
-0.0046698991,
-0.0024864941,
-0.0199078992,
-0.0400265418,
-0.0474426486,
0.0176087506,
0.0323153362,
0.0043512187,
0.029262241,
0.0824345425,
0.0593333207,
0.042297367,
0.0275360961,
0.0326907188,
-0.0228394754,
-0.0059453342,
0.0171986595,
0.0095988698,
-0.0291011762,
0.0315270536,
0.0211157035,
0.0014498745,
-0.0237902552,
-0.0117641203,
0.0500936173,
0.053016331,
0.0329711251,
0.0403078981,
-0.0210574437,
-0.0475409217,
-0.0586312003,
-0.0041764244,
0.0098005906,
-0.0312801003,
0.0169969574,
0.0453963168,
0.0182535648,
-0.0549054109,
0.0299423877,
-0.0238567907,
-0.0247405265,
0.0302352905,
-0.0315189846,
0.0564755239,
-0.0008149678,
0.001686226,
-0.0714653209,
-0.0475170985,
-0.0173869375,
-0.0162788145,
-0.03281359,
0.0386406258,
-0.0201845374,
0.038128119,
-0.0438663848,
-0.0188814364,
-0.0117829172,
0.0094917789,
0.0334769301,
-0.0476715639,
0.0558343977,
-0.0030069605,
-0.0065306355,
0.004671487,
-0.014720994,
-0.0520265847,
0.0103185205,
0.0020800661,
-0.0126726152,
0.0192056596,
-0.028601978,
-0.0145789385,
-0.0885757506,
0.0247783028,
0.0367797241,
-0.0810068622,
-0.0069113169,
0.0263510235,
2.88e-7,
-0.0247091968,
0.0351438597,
-0.0320545025,
0.0399338938,
0.0329216048,
0.0656584501,
-0.0228710175,
0.0074941185,
0.015613866,
-0.0668461844,
0.0487311073,
0.0470290817,
-0.0049458877,
0.0144304046,
-0.0660339445,
-0.0285310801,
0.0003553093,
0.008950009,
-0.0124938525,
0.0145388264,
0.0372490063,
0.0917018056,
0.0154264439,
-0.0069187889,
0.0207426213,
-0.0419820808,
0.0761854202,
-0.0394301414,
0.0457853675,
0.0288906079,
-0.029440837,
-0.0030139626,
-0.0191817936,
0.0286463834,
0.0226651262,
0.0144553278,
-0.0619879849,
0.0518489592,
-0.0014405265,
-0.0347687565,
-0.0212187637,
0.0027508782,
0.0204308387,
-0.0424288325,
0.0735123828,
-0.0801919699,
-0.0301736705,
0.0029180027,
0.0509782173,
-0.0308126342,
0.0067780204,
-0.0009246314,
-0.0216262285,
-0.0081536388,
0.007329599,
0.0215242263,
-0.0059925332,
-0.0734366104,
0.0109539255,
0.0113146715,
-0.0172698349,
-0.039955996,
-0.035778366,
0.0349940024,
0.0270792097,
-0.0599289015,
-0.0122430185,
2.396912189e-34,
0.0211837422,
-0.0216456577,
0.0269410405,
0.0033641013,
-0.0033233708,
0.0132234674,
0.0069526234,
0.023569921,
0.0631709173,
-0.0437148064,
-0.0153642977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00240v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00240v1
|
Exploring Vulnerabilities and Protections in Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-06-01T00:11:09 | 2024-06-01T00:11:09 |
Frank Weizhen Liu, Chenhui Hu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) increasingly become key components in various
AI applications, understanding their security vulnerabilities and the
effectiveness of defense mechanisms is crucial. This survey examines the
security challenges of LLMs, focusing on two main areas: Prompt Hacking and
Adversarial Attacks, each with specific types of threats. Under Prompt Hacking,
we explore Prompt Injection and Jailbreaking Attacks, discussing how they work,
their potential impacts, and ways to mitigate them. Similarly, we analyze
Adversarial Attacks, breaking them down into Data Poisoning Attacks and
Backdoor Attacks. This structured examination helps us understand the
relationships between these vulnerabilities and the defense strategies that can
be implemented. The survey highlights these security challenges and discusses
robust defensive frameworks to protect LLMs against these threats. By detailing
these security issues, the survey contributes to the broader discussion on
creating resilient AI systems that can resist sophisticated attacks.
|
[
0.035125602,
0.0886828676,
-0.0041627628,
0.0650194213,
-0.029965248,
-0.0211479552,
0.0303235557,
-0.0322945639,
0.0481050164,
-0.0411783941,
-0.0086406423,
-0.0245794877,
0.0147367157,
0.0344386846,
0.0687690079,
0.0053009987,
0.0430117883,
-0.0653199628,
-0.0065706111,
-0.0246389434,
-0.022129612,
-0.0208924189,
0.0184332617,
0.0323471986,
-0.0046955217,
-0.0272026807,
-0.0224807952,
-0.0042837271,
0.00664197,
-0.0321383029,
-0.0261587594,
0.0050785723,
-0.013423495,
0.0713898242,
0.0000021407,
-0.0345005728,
-0.0171818268,
0.0560012795,
-0.0374660268,
0.0195585378,
-0.0094837584,
-0.0320186988,
-0.042892985,
0.03791859,
-0.0341020375,
0.0189015269,
0.0210250337,
0.0419836603,
0.0808713958,
0.0939879566,
-0.0084542427,
-0.015565767,
0.0816068277,
-0.0144161321,
-0.0261710845,
-0.053059414,
0.033072792,
-0.0488574356,
0.0003950345,
0.0184756815,
0.0081294877,
0.019111542,
0.0265588071,
-0.0246337317,
-0.0612244681,
0.0425801948,
-0.021774115,
-0.0241545215,
-0.0061624041,
0.046258606,
-0.0346117206,
-0.0091340169,
-0.0077702967,
0.022761438,
0.0158393998,
-0.0052676252,
0.0032998787,
0.0477192439,
0.0124178203,
-0.0140170455,
0.0250346512,
-0.0411413275,
0.0474802218,
0.0099299503,
-0.0175768919,
0.0445895232,
0.0444388799,
-0.0173923019,
-0.0166194271,
-0.0409258157,
0.0189606603,
-0.075587146,
-0.0050608702,
0.0248493459,
-0.0054065995,
0.0131662274,
-0.1020173281,
-0.0200957824,
0.0182172786,
-0.0481676273,
0.020534249,
0.0151928971,
-0.0033632778,
0.0202489402,
0.0127929738,
0.0409619845,
-0.0242993366,
0.0197039731,
0.0351438746,
-0.0063258414,
-0.0068831453,
-0.027015375,
0.0008714654,
0.0269896742,
-0.0005954258,
0.0108792484,
-0.0030517338,
0.0606484637,
-0.0142810782,
0.0838519633,
-0.0480124541,
-0.0201442819,
0.0229281951,
0.000330788,
0.0344374478,
-0.0260288976,
0.0010108344,
-0.0243158303,
-0.0063297208,
-0.1208342388,
-0.0131176785,
0.0108324979,
-0.0820764825,
-0.0322797783,
-0.0137844998,
0.1105100214,
0.0374843702,
-0.025490474,
-0.0561275221,
-0.0882247835,
-0.0317467377,
-0.0520756915,
0.0051356326,
-0.0690996274,
-0.0241463576,
-0.0298989192,
-0.0147397779,
-0.0783882886,
0.0076992833,
0.0024332735,
-0.0304667186,
0.0571681373,
-0.006884675,
-0.0086216414,
0.0194413271,
0.0262983851,
0.0212453492,
0.0360482633,
0.0333382636,
0.0507891178,
0.0493368506,
0.0094981249,
0.0432758667,
0.0345130563,
0.001528266,
0.0266486779,
-0.0290574394,
0.0314747728,
0.0250003468,
-0.0078274114,
-0.0590966791,
0.0723701045,
0.0225008875,
-0.0561119951,
0.1182701662,
0.0473396629,
-0.0723835155,
0.0188437179,
0.0098808054,
-0.0273304023,
0.0248549301,
-0.0293933786,
-0.0779143721,
-0.0155175813,
-0.0623315163,
-0.0426091067,
-0.036063008,
0.0482763015,
-0.0086541018,
-0.0176180545,
-0.0033724939,
-0.0332845561,
-0.0017888288,
0.0263124742,
0.0303478278,
0.0150045753,
0.022213228,
-0.0127257928,
-0.0311709139,
-0.0281026512,
-0.0221939683,
-0.1043298468,
-0.0300438479,
0.0509255454,
0.0588338673,
-0.0235487409,
-0.0090858294,
-0.0112696011,
-0.0033628873,
0.0096339937,
0.0241560843,
0.0131749557,
0.0075465878,
0.0101759313,
0.0155048184,
-0.0057344907,
0.0126513438,
0.0273556244,
-0.0136490678,
0.0247512981,
-0.0198834147,
0.0239921696,
-0.0328922085,
0.0313037112,
0.0049223341,
-0.0702613145,
0.0139584234,
0.0304245017,
0.0137209604,
0.0223353114,
-0.0399170369,
0.0392453521,
0.0712429136,
0.0103072179,
0.0195572935,
-0.0207817871,
0.0077608032,
0.0221379474,
0.0523349419,
-0.0060850722,
-0.0186903737,
0.0604188666,
-0.0346389487,
-0.0185178835,
0.0555122644,
-0.0364154354,
0.0136163896,
0.0074531827,
0.0127971796,
-0.0050077704,
0.0438722633,
-0.0260967966,
0.0029399164,
-0.011006102,
-0.0525225401,
-0.0105236648,
0.032094162,
0.0223834664,
-0.0346776769,
-0.0661781281,
0.0374520831,
-0.0211439524,
0.0105005093,
-0.0162872449,
-0.0221734736,
-0.0025910775,
0.0105361715,
-0.0165002886,
-0.0203018822,
-0.0099716522,
0.0314433277,
0.0208395403,
0.0079927342,
-0.0325406678,
-0.0305332579,
-0.0090368036,
-0.0125711877,
-0.0233553499,
0.0205393974,
0.0003514601,
-0.0062577524,
-0.0433273502,
-0.0047154091,
0.0035864066,
-0.024514107,
0.062256258,
-0.0222774465,
-0.0243876893,
-0.0085440967,
0.0214760881,
-0.0137127675,
0.0557649173,
-0.0242349319,
-0.034482155,
0.0431056097,
0.0076392642,
-0.0041127265,
0.0830579475,
0.0029835792,
0.04076178,
0.0945684463,
0.0044601983,
-0.0063216691,
-0.0216738805,
0.0585354827,
-0.0234725475,
-0.0532200709,
0.0008705605,
0.0302474331,
0.0523242429,
0.0325684547,
-0.023219835,
-0.0038535236,
0.0530707762,
-0.0044357004,
-0.0226308126,
-0.0119265746,
-0.0420207642,
-0.0364347696,
0.0163083766,
0.0053479569,
-0.0659893453,
0.0741793886,
-0.077937834,
0.0308032762,
-0.0104863914,
-0.0582886189,
0.0311120059,
0.0530118532,
-0.0107618878,
0.0172031168,
0.0276539456,
-0.0145121766,
-0.0606674217,
-0.0288771745,
0.007436512,
-0.0118899597,
0.03814964,
-0.0193759501,
-0.0142366765,
-0.0186498873,
-0.0255394336,
-0.0512068905,
-0.0427129529,
-0.05363065,
0.0214357171,
0.0043880451,
-0.0472425893,
-0.003440052,
-0.0411982909,
0.0382232629,
-0.0057726153,
-0.0116728405,
-0.0079146624,
-0.0299048871,
0.0260821339,
0.0366638452,
-0.0488269143,
-0.0029643183,
-0.000139749,
0.0750814378,
0.0699926242,
0.0252805781,
0.0297523551,
-0.0348932892,
-0.0301415082,
0.0132699637,
-0.0033814118,
0.0088968892,
0.024878731,
0.0221563429,
-0.0198628549,
-0.0177013297,
0.0449539311,
0.0143263536,
-0.0252650958,
0.023610767,
-0.0054938672,
0.0070821787,
0.0097974008,
0.0291080549,
-0.0713249147,
-0.0052420273,
0.0469197407,
0.0377372764,
-0.0133514544,
-0.0059422036,
-0.0262718573,
-0.1079666018,
-0.0054427944,
-0.0005815909,
-0.0362687893,
-0.0555666909,
-0.0317956507,
-0.0294783115,
0.0321008265,
0.0574454144,
-0.0198005866,
0.015984429,
-0.0023200705,
0.0044425335,
-0.0430896766,
-0.0235344861,
0.0193312578,
-0.0277000014,
0.080487676,
0.0815787166,
0.0201612189,
-0.0293389224,
0.0365532786,
0.0497209355,
0.0145028392,
-0.0020549367,
0.0200280733,
0.014968738,
0.0115453871,
-0.0241901409,
0.0243783183,
0.0329390541,
-0.0246973261,
-0.0109110605,
0.0448826477,
0.0581680872,
-0.046586521,
-0.0061972416,
-0.0280468352,
-0.0443123691,
0.0293125995,
0.056465514,
0.0103035439,
-0.0456550233,
-0.0336084291,
-0.0774691105,
-0.0072927256,
-0.0300064515,
-0.0486032814,
0.028805092,
0.0248917174,
-0.0516879857,
-0.0309014786,
-0.0293562058,
-0.0159935392,
0.0163313728,
0.0429325141,
-0.019165853,
-0.0072140689,
0.0239717308,
-0.0110791931,
-0.0134338299,
-0.0394271463,
0.0683378205,
-0.0273614246,
0.0196603891,
0.0024527877,
-0.0205572359,
-0.0058674137,
0.0010664545,
-0.05742535,
-0.0914599076,
0.0372705646,
0.0638129488,
0.0185975973,
0.0084638223,
-0.056048464,
-0.0715764984,
0.0731755868,
0.0235654525,
-0.0252642985,
0.0057824515,
0.0530355275,
-0.0215290748,
0.0337824188,
0.0262878798,
-0.0444493331,
-0.0224723257,
0.0820765868,
-0.0146362949,
-0.02979647,
-0.0226262584,
-0.0105971927,
0.0756270066,
0.0145884464,
-0.0098676234,
0.0136908544,
0.0233478639,
0.0280072819,
-0.0405154303,
-0.0253458973,
-0.0033365402,
0.0316378959,
0.0037235941,
0.0176264774,
0.0368586145,
-0.007793183,
0.0176309627,
0.0087443953,
0.0037620144,
0.0433492772,
0.0250808932,
0.0726269558,
0.0582704172,
0.0358009227,
-0.0137508195,
0.0764446259,
-0.0082092136,
0.0356562398,
-0.0066119656,
0.0293904617,
-0.0113718631,
-0.0200599339,
-0.0347478352,
0.0506277829,
-0.0692519322,
-0.0736009404,
0.0464057922,
0.0731431991,
0.0123664727,
0.0341035016,
-0.0304446705,
-0.0228929464,
0.0126313558,
-0.0404669866,
-0.0416880958,
0.0219925325,
-0.0313518234,
0.0194847938,
-0.0025714282,
-0.0136324195,
0.0374917649,
0.0713858157,
0.0047097108,
0.0655187964,
0.0266279988,
-0.0192648433,
-0.0243227743,
-0.008701128,
0.0289117824,
-0.010893967,
-0.0606501885,
-0.0466354005,
-0.0430263653,
-0.104469493,
-0.0187051948,
0.0155645758,
0.0182899833,
0.0139246918,
-0.0246303193,
0.0389190987,
0.04665602,
0.0564361736,
-0.0805337206,
0.022907896,
-0.0230919179,
-0.081353195,
0.0217610411,
-5.697213736e-33,
0.0249556862,
-0.0263514388,
-0.0208586715,
-0.0224374197,
0.0057696258,
0.0208114106,
-0.0266348012,
0.0085826004,
-0.0497891977,
-0.0120526338,
-0.0128019806,
0.0076826471,
0.0013705941,
0.0251809992,
-0.0243760254,
-0.0352758579,
-0.0021884129,
-0.0162148345,
-0.0167064592,
0.0278753787,
0.0494592972,
-0.0179871246,
0.0024793402,
-0.0640924424,
0.0467252135,
-0.0032296039,
-0.0329101831,
0.0138831157,
-0.0486353822,
0.0556269065,
-0.0072401529,
0.0291935802,
-0.0046553407,
-0.0090636723,
-0.0091508823,
0.0724168941,
0.0207183752,
-0.0168328695,
-0.0287560951,
0.0174653567,
0.0288124774,
-0.081961371,
0.0143160084,
-0.0382005349,
-0.0186708029,
0.0243439898,
0.001518006,
-0.0195568614,
0.0019616967,
-0.0067843157,
-0.0197357144,
-0.0110601448,
-0.0326096117,
0.0040254486,
0.0146653354,
-0.0165594518,
0.0173979718,
0.0067180567,
-0.0366035774,
0.0464187823,
0.0121528674,
0.0135373781,
0.0454085544,
-0.0050412449,
0.019191293,
0.0430339277,
0.028530702,
-0.0153568266,
-0.0187128484,
0.0103743942,
-0.0083112791,
0.0374150872,
0.0568709671,
0.0478187613,
0.018090684,
-0.0216288604,
-0.058292795,
0.0024525626,
0.0451235324,
0.0219731256,
0.0253597945,
-0.0171901714,
-0.0628108233,
0.0245660897,
-0.0087270392,
-0.0459757857,
-0.0452640951,
-0.0092266155,
0.0116384998,
-0.0194949135,
-0.0179817062,
-0.0298985001,
0.0229268838,
-0.0816482753,
-0.0009381704,
0.0309316292,
0.0168900657,
-0.0276911315,
0.000842654,
0.0162827205,
0.0119958781,
0.013088176,
-0.0060547125,
-0.049407281,
0.0340318941,
0.0046841977,
0.0110775866,
0.0535610914,
-0.0561089963,
-0.0313861147,
-0.017878348,
0.0113854166,
0.0366141908,
0.060955327,
0.0247772299,
-0.0352551229,
0.0249951277,
0.0161372535,
0.0317009017,
0.0073498846,
-0.0234583803,
0.0487312637,
-0.0264238194,
-0.0070245978,
-0.0076872241,
-0.0026165203,
-0.0319913253,
0.0487044565,
0.0406361669,
-0.0569421761,
0.0036383369,
-0.0463913307,
2.933e-7,
-0.023228826,
0.0268835295,
0.019858731,
-0.0060029165,
0.027839737,
0.0614904426,
-0.0195561126,
0.0644347221,
-0.0366809703,
-0.0028421392,
-0.0266672429,
0.0011001446,
0.0371661074,
0.0205973424,
-0.0421399176,
0.025877608,
-0.0742727369,
-0.0095163072,
-0.0807929933,
-0.0056059188,
0.0303270165,
0.1214031205,
0.0025262085,
-0.0291781314,
-0.0052428748,
-0.0864680409,
-0.0174234286,
-0.0065990998,
0.008436745,
-0.0277921166,
0.0247636624,
0.0487511083,
0.0146956816,
0.0112029128,
-0.0405272283,
0.0077587878,
-0.0617209412,
0.0362674259,
-0.0086250771,
-0.0190696977,
-0.0212056562,
-0.0510728285,
-0.0180563629,
-0.0346405581,
0.071713306,
0.0169307422,
-0.0474126972,
-0.0370246731,
0.0207645893,
-0.0402178951,
0.010671352,
-0.0287938435,
0.0038880499,
-0.004235616,
0.0142379086,
-0.0165271629,
0.0491662025,
-0.0700854957,
-0.01315514,
-0.0157921705,
-0.008518083,
-0.0313862562,
0.0043367865,
0.0184882674,
0.0266576018,
-0.0034835788,
-0.0064507062,
2.759220671e-34,
-0.0130266333,
-0.0386069529,
0.0001069251,
0.0204403084,
0.0326024592,
0.0163241345,
-0.0161906946,
-0.0052698846,
0.0161445253,
-0.0490636528,
-0.0482065976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00231v1
|
LLM-RankFusion: Mitigating Intrinsic Inconsistency in LLM-based Ranking
| 2024-05-31T23:29:42 | 2024-05-31T23:29:42 |
Yifan Zeng, Ojas Tendolkar, Raymond Baartmans, Qingyun Wu, Huazheng Wang, Lizhong Chen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Ranking passages by prompting a large language model (LLM) can achieve
promising performance in modern information retrieval (IR) systems. A common
approach is to sort the ranking list by prompting LLMs for pairwise comparison.
However, sorting-based methods require consistent comparisons to correctly sort
the passages, which we show that LLMs often violate. We identify two kinds of
intrinsic inconsistency in LLM-based pairwise comparisons: order inconsistency
which leads to conflicting results when switching the passage order, and
transitive inconsistency which leads to non-transitive triads among all
preference pairs. In this paper, we propose LLM-RankFusion, an LLM-based
ranking framework that mitigates these inconsistencies and produces a robust
ranking list. LLM-RankFusion mitigates order inconsistency using in-context
learning (ICL) to demonstrate order-agnostic comparisons and calibration to
estimate the underlying preference probability between two passages. We then
address transitive inconsistency by aggregating the ranking results from
multiple rankers. In our experiments, we empirically show that LLM-RankFusion
can significantly reduce inconsistent pairwise comparison results, and improve
the ranking quality by making the final ranking list more robust.
|
[
0.0494752787,
0.0471978597,
0.002334492,
0.0580637977,
-0.0141888782,
-0.0006267081,
-0.0043152031,
-0.0112853171,
0.0419691466,
-0.0573975481,
-0.0554471165,
-0.0305643436,
0.0146895051,
-0.0135512324,
-0.0119293835,
-0.0084374472,
0.0407465138,
-0.0262147319,
-0.0182053111,
-0.0162524078,
-0.0138630876,
0.019133728,
0.0311646685,
-0.0198609065,
0.0998756438,
0.0037341174,
0.0015302747,
0.025150517,
0.0434312485,
-0.0511876941,
-0.003297084,
0.038834013,
0.0114608584,
0.0133726094,
0.0000021178,
-0.0628634542,
-0.0525970645,
-0.0033872048,
0.0109885903,
0.0324786231,
0.0140729304,
0.0356958881,
0.0277989581,
-0.0011225751,
-0.043266952,
0.0435429104,
-0.0375956893,
0.0138149559,
0.0557811409,
0.027132431,
0.0105689634,
0.0109815383,
-0.0087129232,
-0.0524222106,
-0.0006632839,
-0.0525858514,
0.0367984995,
-0.0231634006,
0.0298459921,
0.1042750627,
-0.0041477699,
-0.0030748181,
-0.0076211854,
-0.0054886355,
0.0654592663,
0.0176675823,
-0.0572361313,
0.0219707508,
0.0119320611,
0.0871374756,
-0.002996003,
-0.015765259,
-0.0045496318,
-0.0002389149,
0.0111208837,
0.0265434831,
-0.0269436594,
-0.0023221069,
-0.0398876593,
0.0279760417,
0.0125981001,
0.0427715331,
0.0386772528,
0.0357619189,
-0.0469756536,
0.0678483844,
0.0064740553,
-0.0539968014,
0.0076069655,
0.0065750112,
-0.0520046614,
-0.0055663474,
0.0324315354,
-0.0214679856,
-0.0623150356,
-0.0035080011,
0.0183563996,
0.0368795097,
0.0268446244,
-0.0752998218,
-0.003659406,
0.0107832095,
-0.0175555721,
0.0417277105,
-0.012898027,
0.0601977967,
0.0132371671,
0.024047859,
-0.068509303,
0.0300987177,
0.0037047078,
-0.000839473,
0.0394441187,
0.0385960266,
-0.0583825409,
-0.0095246341,
-0.0699988604,
0.0182536393,
-0.018080201,
0.008898925,
0.0222784001,
0.016219249,
-0.0093367985,
0.0100114495,
-0.0608390123,
-0.0027117436,
0.0390473418,
0.0076922663,
-0.0292994324,
0.0235086791,
0.031297978,
-0.0225410089,
-0.0365515463,
-0.0226183999,
0.0119865574,
0.0098518934,
-0.0253343154,
-0.0284400862,
0.0024243144,
-0.0015170948,
-0.0034171138,
-0.0153098181,
-0.0362471566,
-0.0620625615,
0.0172170959,
0.0448317677,
0.0237610508,
-0.0093272245,
0.020046046,
0.0198740233,
-0.0720483959,
0.073612541,
0.0459922366,
-0.0151009811,
0.0159371328,
0.0212085452,
0.0051253978,
0.0065809451,
-0.0176348742,
0.0120863002,
0.0467861071,
0.0196336526,
-0.0304334667,
-0.0012698368,
-0.012237167,
0.0258322377,
-0.0224335156,
0.0160339102,
-0.0042364942,
0.0224047247,
0.0288702119,
0.0506556593,
-0.0277834758,
-0.02514649,
0.0558445677,
0.0093949996,
0.0489384755,
-0.0197088998,
-0.0300588384,
-0.0094031515,
-0.0279720221,
0.0340123586,
-0.0376270711,
0.0144061558,
-0.0302951653,
-0.0029813314,
0.0911668688,
0.0314687788,
-0.0065149749,
-0.0405559763,
-0.003382517,
0.0381124914,
-0.0035796713,
0.0193279628,
0.0365336239,
-0.0173960235,
-0.027031865,
0.002360556,
0.0251829848,
-0.0217588581,
0.0177201647,
-0.0255628377,
-0.0014027617,
0.1442416608,
0.0639158115,
-0.036692217,
0.0385290273,
0.0145161729,
-0.0166685693,
-0.0072818478,
-0.0029966601,
-0.0238464847,
-0.0016380214,
-0.0275338516,
-0.0417621695,
0.0312298164,
-0.0053271186,
0.0262820758,
-0.0112254098,
0.0282990653,
0.0110396612,
-0.0387588441,
-0.0061731045,
0.0063567311,
-0.0199211631,
0.0146260513,
0.0312902294,
-0.0194057822,
0.0348652005,
-0.0036114655,
0.0088977758,
0.0122326994,
0.0406275764,
-0.0073541487,
-0.013121821,
-0.040255215,
-0.0483823977,
-0.0201325957,
0.0366156846,
0.0303956997,
0.0164518878,
0.0316437557,
-0.0336402915,
0.0058892919,
-0.0554773994,
0.0375451595,
0.0208315067,
-0.0051978128,
0.0495999902,
0.0021428342,
-0.0177161507,
-0.085724391,
0.0680899695,
-0.0234200563,
0.0696209148,
0.0380879194,
0.0426971056,
-0.0490080081,
-0.0107394466,
-0.0535724089,
0.0518499762,
0.03239391,
0.0030558622,
0.005275473,
0.0033591297,
-0.0247985739,
-0.0116779758,
-0.0988857299,
0.0027807816,
0.0211014207,
-0.0081918938,
-0.0039426461,
-0.0097714216,
0.0115782423,
-0.0133076841,
0.0020263507,
-0.0368624814,
-0.0025581627,
0.0318631642,
0.0168247893,
-0.0008790314,
0.0098174531,
-0.0500827618,
-0.0422628857,
-0.0022591613,
0.0511889867,
-0.0273634531,
0.0046917312,
-0.1017088145,
0.0685183108,
-0.0675319731,
0.0117112063,
-0.049611263,
0.0309631154,
-0.0160845816,
-0.0229767766,
0.0072513637,
0.0513031445,
0.0543868057,
-0.0111427493,
0.1010546908,
-0.0063715782,
-0.1021462232,
-0.0186289754,
0.004017212,
0.0047714501,
-0.0120072812,
-0.0296716634,
-0.0239326935,
-0.021558376,
0.0038062802,
-0.0136632789,
0.0004061931,
0.0277483817,
-0.0328022726,
0.0103016952,
-0.0810919404,
-0.0072575165,
-0.0065639466,
0.0548950322,
-0.0150716174,
-0.0303913821,
0.0550632626,
-0.0107508125,
0.0368683562,
-0.0669655725,
0.0098662358,
-0.0572247356,
0.0197090618,
-0.0136536378,
0.0129503468,
-0.0612423904,
0.0049695186,
-0.0563463271,
0.0158093926,
0.043818485,
-0.0743353292,
0.0807132721,
-0.0389166661,
0.0335269757,
-0.0022673963,
-0.0814656243,
-0.0390642583,
-0.0476879962,
0.0220348053,
-0.0097642662,
0.0339612104,
-0.0092228344,
-0.0014828371,
0.0108941589,
0.0205305796,
0.0348274112,
-0.0240891986,
-0.0472842641,
0.0217133313,
0.0723977536,
0.0280356947,
-0.0485104211,
0.0286991745,
-0.0165119786,
0.0197100248,
0.049168583,
0.0205919798,
-0.0026519392,
0.0102391746,
-0.0198829565,
0.064596273,
-0.020732956,
-0.0480992012,
-0.0050288131,
-0.0302406531,
0.0052717971,
-0.0140694818,
0.0976727977,
0.0551330633,
-0.095511131,
-0.0127437273,
-0.0219557099,
0.0079252273,
0.0110246409,
0.0451134406,
-0.0733712018,
0.0291168019,
0.0232924633,
0.0512696281,
-0.0079904282,
-0.0211561508,
0.0076944553,
-0.1188200414,
0.0282393862,
0.0066183838,
0.0002063788,
-0.0121605033,
-0.0571299046,
0.0173516832,
-0.016299,
0.0109878359,
0.0722023025,
-0.0248011332,
0.0083257183,
0.0025534299,
0.0272599645,
-0.0354324132,
0.0276565626,
-0.0262335632,
0.0075553237,
0.026003167,
0.0305145495,
-0.021158563,
-0.017104961,
0.0200507957,
-0.0475834087,
-0.0155715318,
-0.0424875617,
-0.0079223393,
-0.0207852032,
0.0215573646,
-0.0602249354,
-0.0128112109,
0.0193489864,
0.0144026764,
-0.0257274378,
0.0229237508,
-0.0232802108,
0.0103885448,
-0.0192322396,
-0.0176125914,
-0.0327756964,
0.0461797491,
-0.0583943278,
-0.0291636158,
0.0139313405,
-0.0639597327,
0.0202223584,
0.0230605248,
-0.0467468761,
0.017399855,
0.0001471643,
0.0270542931,
-0.0671016574,
-0.005096233,
-0.0412513614,
-0.0117931468,
-0.0029436147,
0.0673118383,
-0.0406048633,
-0.0221836362,
-0.0212031621,
0.0009427822,
0.0256488901,
0.0118846549,
-0.0458826087,
0.034258157,
0.0779115036,
-0.043557141,
-0.0287045334,
-0.0142619647,
-0.0005013453,
-0.0303731002,
-0.0218893494,
0.0402866937,
0.0131198214,
0.0409098901,
-0.0059562204,
-0.0204676501,
0.0385827757,
0.0611897334,
0.0008530226,
0.0289906412,
0.0031416691,
0.0393656343,
-0.0204305071,
0.0069552246,
-0.0688347742,
0.0070625013,
-0.0228356514,
0.0543490686,
-0.0310191792,
-0.0630812123,
0.0324939042,
0.006617758,
0.0587561838,
-0.0051554092,
0.0039134235,
-0.0478142388,
0.0521608368,
-0.018646311,
-0.0591552183,
-0.0112475818,
0.0275132135,
0.0618487708,
-0.0036803721,
-0.0249363016,
0.0121534355,
0.0322359353,
0.0457388759,
-0.0413186364,
-0.0156918131,
0.0001307298,
-0.0266066808,
0.0241460372,
-0.0020854266,
-0.0265199766,
-0.0104209585,
0.0292602349,
0.0612120256,
-0.0233303644,
0.033626318,
0.0249926485,
-0.0310966726,
-0.0428116247,
0.0673955828,
-0.0840674564,
0.0071695917,
-0.041182328,
-0.0182604007,
0.0380325541,
0.0153510049,
0.0762202516,
0.0237191524,
-0.0049804565,
-0.0349665247,
-0.0280387159,
0.0194780808,
0.0254632104,
-0.0109806303,
0.0408144519,
0.0241102409,
0.0856368914,
0.0732276142,
-0.0148334634,
-0.0245802142,
-0.0072001698,
-0.0794275254,
-0.0169516131,
-0.0194481146,
-0.0064485762,
0.056036599,
-0.0341184177,
-0.0367527083,
-0.0341213457,
-0.0183191244,
0.0240477156,
-0.0049065803,
0.0144129265,
-0.0434632488,
0.0134239029,
0.0923889279,
-0.0071507753,
0.0228241012,
-0.0683371499,
-0.0497661456,
-0.0087244641,
-0.040631678,
-0.0465358794,
-6.603800897e-33,
-0.015052096,
-0.0378895923,
-0.0310403761,
-0.0193178002,
-0.0130801462,
-0.0069105378,
0.0255894642,
-0.0164273027,
0.00044944,
-0.0197291318,
-0.0254085604,
0.0065551349,
0.0119910492,
-0.0177207235,
0.049156066,
-0.0126735149,
0.0318957157,
0.0314083733,
-0.0258877892,
-0.0078385388,
0.0554116331,
0.0518908463,
-0.0084963758,
-0.0681411847,
0.0491554216,
-0.0235025808,
-0.0005910051,
0.0006821376,
-0.0216024835,
0.0571695045,
0.0235259403,
0.0325492993,
0.0365776531,
-0.0520207733,
0.0231331065,
-0.0132189849,
-0.0441617146,
-0.0054888357,
0.0189120192,
-0.0329717994,
0.0158617534,
0.0167235062,
0.0128475064,
0.0131885717,
-0.0260953587,
-0.0249614529,
0.054387603,
-0.0353538804,
-0.0597475618,
-0.0466222614,
0.0207047276,
0.0181612261,
0.0099689122,
-0.0047557098,
0.0046248827,
0.0655077696,
-0.0148920976,
0.0876601636,
-0.0663395971,
0.0381323881,
-0.0395967104,
0.0661604404,
0.017455766,
0.0037005031,
-0.0353769995,
0.0504384264,
0.0103194686,
-0.002981669,
0.0433483049,
-0.0599408932,
-0.0214569941,
0.0017741106,
0.0048241736,
0.0410537012,
0.0105217164,
0.023980435,
-0.0389056727,
0.0463346019,
0.0061274394,
-0.0230659768,
0.0357231312,
0.0440241881,
-0.0512573458,
-0.0653000399,
-0.0119446255,
-0.0217913669,
-0.0574668646,
-0.0233088676,
0.0379062407,
0.0243490767,
-0.0160915665,
-0.0076047182,
0.0063497815,
-0.0338206887,
-0.1083255783,
0.026773518,
-0.020352263,
0.0105241444,
-0.0107066529,
0.0277789477,
-0.0311568845,
-0.0101424018,
-0.0001073193,
-0.0263380185,
-0.0292029865,
-0.0097122192,
0.0091996295,
-0.0358345099,
-0.0485824719,
0.0065598632,
0.0070598675,
-0.0440297388,
-0.0419203974,
0.0115423948,
-0.0003070156,
-0.0008331762,
-0.0050864108,
0.0865635872,
0.0265024547,
0.0453039445,
-0.0472084284,
-0.0340769738,
-0.0289938655,
0.0042325882,
0.0141007295,
0.0250997506,
0.0031649941,
0.0681298301,
0.0008481617,
-0.0500160344,
-0.0282641593,
0.0162840597,
2.911e-7,
0.0441413037,
0.0576067492,
-0.0291662272,
-0.01462455,
0.0064902068,
0.0082822274,
-0.0163608808,
0.0489737131,
0.0559836961,
0.0142028499,
0.0144698219,
-0.0036135616,
0.0089394962,
0.0208614562,
-0.0548518039,
-0.0404174998,
-0.0765341371,
-0.0607151091,
-0.0377860367,
-0.0643311962,
0.0439197496,
0.0690757781,
0.0205564611,
0.0095058847,
-0.0140168676,
-0.0375439115,
0.0599246994,
-0.0472457819,
-0.0181045998,
-0.0048824614,
0.0369082466,
-0.0184365176,
-0.0102136582,
0.0191757735,
-0.007752215,
0.0078380713,
0.0497618392,
0.0280916337,
-0.0089170039,
-0.0299272742,
-0.0143041797,
0.0226418544,
0.0220943298,
-0.0908846036,
0.07167992,
-0.0128376763,
0.0277322754,
0.0199641082,
-0.0567508861,
-0.0121507626,
0.041271545,
0.0096501168,
-0.0338756442,
0.026426632,
-0.0050841286,
0.030932134,
-0.0071993298,
-0.0577888377,
-0.0053104893,
-0.0017364845,
-0.0392948464,
-0.0773045346,
0.0008298483,
0.0060248459,
-0.0212715156,
-0.0274542775,
0.0052422388,
2.686068417e-34,
0.0557891019,
0.0203214698,
0.0104512451,
-0.0098390458,
0.0097970786,
0.0097503141,
-0.019174587,
0.0225356929,
0.0204428695,
-0.0712040737,
0.0005516112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00226v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00226v1
|
Entangled Relations: Leveraging NLI and Meta-analysis to Enhance Biomedical Relation Extraction
| 2024-05-31T23:05:04 | 2024-05-31T23:05:04 |
William Hogan, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Recent research efforts have explored the potential of leveraging natural
language inference (NLI) techniques to enhance relation extraction (RE). In
this vein, we introduce MetaEntail-RE, a novel adaptation method that harnesses
NLI principles to enhance RE performance. Our approach follows past works by
verbalizing relation classes into class-indicative hypotheses, aligning a
traditionally multi-class classification task to one of textual entailment. We
introduce three key enhancements: (1) Instead of labeling non-entailed
premise-hypothesis pairs with the uninformative "neutral" entailment label, we
introduce meta-class analysis, which provides additional context by analyzing
overarching meta relationships between classes when assigning entailment
labels; (2) Feasible hypothesis filtering, which removes unlikely hypotheses
from consideration based on pairs of entity types; and (3) Group-based
prediction selection, which further improves performance by selecting highly
confident predictions. MetaEntail-RE is conceptually simple and empirically
powerful, yielding significant improvements over conventional relation
extraction techniques and other NLI formulations. Our experimental results
underscore the versatility of MetaEntail-RE, demonstrating performance gains
across both biomedical and general domains.
|
[
0.0280480329,
0.0710778013,
0.0034902173,
0.0387456082,
-0.0086896382,
0.0443098769,
-0.0161481239,
0.0094863158,
-0.0240703318,
-0.0498561561,
-0.0205395352,
0.0336070731,
0.0007208732,
0.0039819996,
-0.0165231787,
-0.0416006371,
0.0417907983,
0.0227751825,
0.0060804174,
0.0158304796,
-0.0194554832,
0.0161069911,
-0.0233643837,
0.0059668869,
0.0378328152,
-0.0004255784,
0.0481448285,
-0.0104854666,
0.0455655605,
-0.0718693659,
0.0133011276,
0.0684801191,
0.0034844787,
-0.0410943031,
0.000001901,
-0.063533172,
-0.0125719961,
0.0165601429,
-0.0390820839,
-0.050028313,
-0.0508261435,
-0.0487038381,
0.0603968203,
-0.0025471901,
-0.0115931258,
-0.0659792721,
0.029768182,
0.0392282642,
-0.0199747235,
0.0219359081,
-0.0367783085,
-0.0182301942,
-0.0173731614,
-0.0327359177,
0.0046037659,
0.0202112738,
0.0556303486,
-0.0508018062,
-0.0298225693,
-0.0253888387,
0.023895504,
0.0274463072,
0.0120197013,
0.0438742116,
0.0200334098,
0.0414740592,
-0.0226876624,
-0.030107975,
0.0090086367,
0.0754375085,
0.0301016439,
0.0060979216,
0.0193880443,
0.0029659634,
0.0085413428,
0.1006621569,
-0.0057337563,
0.0075399564,
-0.0735705271,
0.0016270853,
0.0066839373,
0.0360139832,
0.0466731153,
0.0005781226,
-0.0043169963,
0.0531772301,
0.0237860903,
-0.0417389236,
0.0410042517,
0.0374413021,
-0.0128069976,
0.009330485,
0.0205975343,
-0.0013130195,
0.0182334371,
0.0461661033,
0.0001956559,
-0.0407134108,
0.0177035462,
-0.0508514121,
-0.0501161516,
-0.0093430988,
-0.0179435499,
0.0447773598,
-0.0044527496,
-0.0771432519,
-0.0132501908,
-0.0062084948,
-0.0167413317,
-0.0247595198,
-0.0401162617,
-0.0023429801,
-0.0120340446,
0.0568947159,
-0.0461960658,
0.0297800023,
-0.0487495661,
-0.0215444136,
-0.0157723837,
0.0049231546,
-0.0496738739,
0.0118965097,
-0.0269162226,
-0.0084636323,
-0.0410645381,
0.0253508165,
-0.0088185165,
0.0053478843,
-0.0303803943,
-0.0088550374,
-0.0138558801,
-0.0031568806,
0.0358042121,
-0.0615844838,
0.0077705197,
0.0850867853,
0.0198083166,
-0.0476386137,
0.0083789565,
-0.0143032391,
0.0091633499,
-0.0211053807,
0.0516895019,
-0.0182116125,
0.0419782698,
0.0252775736,
-0.0127986502,
-0.000913574,
0.0277260505,
-0.0212966595,
-0.0603912957,
0.0712922066,
-0.0799528658,
-0.0133517208,
0.0003440323,
0.0348194093,
-0.0048397514,
0.0533308685,
0.0255894158,
-0.0249350723,
0.0174225587,
-0.0282002706,
0.0089311488,
-0.0142696574,
0.0286216978,
-0.0531742349,
0.0013831249,
0.0049435957,
0.0406083874,
-0.0017069464,
-0.0308073163,
0.018446099,
-0.0194162596,
-0.0011667892,
0.0109468251,
0.0382069387,
0.0041216039,
0.0084058596,
-0.0083931563,
-0.0449381098,
0.0229865722,
0.0031431147,
-0.0633720905,
0.0387953334,
-0.045568686,
-0.0065425248,
-0.0190098789,
0.0473273732,
0.0064248261,
-0.0461035222,
-0.0264206398,
0.0009290118,
-0.0394235887,
0.0087377997,
0.0680614859,
0.0309933759,
0.0020388884,
0.0055423309,
0.0999653488,
-0.0127009144,
0.0120012276,
-0.0073767575,
-0.0021424193,
0.0383923352,
0.0376832001,
-0.0690571815,
-0.0425468683,
-0.0200076252,
-0.0392987654,
0.0644198284,
-0.0075576184,
-0.0327578783,
0.073558256,
-0.0074195978,
-0.018429799,
0.0567809455,
0.0097224368,
-0.0023496598,
0.0107328612,
0.0308383908,
-0.0049666003,
-0.0025068494,
0.0381958671,
0.0527357943,
-0.0338904932,
-0.0158476885,
0.0251801778,
0.0265722331,
0.0511585735,
-0.0029470504,
-0.0160421431,
-0.0143610816,
0.0442250706,
-0.0586532801,
-0.0438720733,
0.0039331024,
-0.0187562536,
-0.0878121853,
-0.0178409722,
-0.0568212867,
-0.0510103367,
-0.0459697358,
-0.0443558618,
-0.011261154,
-0.020055715,
0.0117745632,
0.0549139194,
-0.0192132574,
-0.0259498209,
0.0162218083,
0.0071994415,
-0.0405629762,
0.0572937094,
0.0085230488,
-0.0147954095,
0.0134394979,
-0.1365086138,
-0.0029645809,
0.034929283,
0.0014090402,
0.0578821339,
-0.0030938361,
-0.0494190566,
0.0189224947,
-0.0114466539,
-0.0404499844,
-0.0147128254,
-0.0505470298,
0.0114072468,
0.0244367681,
0.0481716953,
0.006327224,
-0.0033950093,
-0.002500626,
-0.0244816039,
0.0015750986,
-0.0332377665,
-0.0388030112,
0.028883677,
0.0472934656,
0.0045943963,
0.005520469,
-0.0401977114,
-0.0157619361,
-0.0341348834,
0.0734216496,
0.0073891087,
-0.0472192541,
0.010628907,
-0.0213667117,
-0.0562118962,
0.0014060044,
-0.0017378938,
0.0133459102,
-0.0252222605,
0.0194046125,
0.0070252754,
0.0036358214,
0.0072265877,
0.0439413972,
0.0781914741,
0.0198734961,
0.0129006403,
0.0222999975,
-0.0643923581,
0.0330299549,
0.007321483,
-0.019220477,
0.0082484121,
0.0450090654,
0.0100451838,
0.0087762093,
-0.0330024511,
-0.0058054142,
0.0332589932,
-0.0039383583,
-0.0440762714,
0.0363995247,
0.0074285399,
0.0315462947,
-0.0449912921,
-0.0094935838,
0.1247618124,
0.0439035669,
-0.0100158984,
-0.047802601,
-0.0060486989,
-0.0156757943,
0.0441937558,
0.0126933642,
0.0052890857,
0.0683778152,
0.0069011683,
-0.0162575934,
-0.0270945765,
0.0336030833,
-0.0205439162,
0.0324861519,
-0.0613056533,
0.0187773518,
0.0170738567,
-0.0390710384,
-0.0682281032,
0.0025286977,
-0.0210779253,
-0.0092845857,
-0.0519513488,
-0.0019063457,
-0.0036897101,
-0.0064902846,
0.0114558227,
-0.0105752014,
-0.0051103262,
-0.0212354772,
-0.0132142119,
0.0340309851,
0.099584803,
-0.0175913945,
0.0065938737,
-0.0035428321,
0.0449315757,
0.0613115542,
-0.0644477457,
0.0238460731,
0.0208472572,
-0.0068552895,
0.0012246635,
-0.0340208858,
0.0306917056,
0.0020605295,
-0.0295567438,
-0.0390353799,
-0.0061788815,
0.0983478054,
0.028915761,
-0.043807961,
0.015878303,
0.0107359858,
0.0148966061,
-0.0016165687,
-0.0043814061,
-0.0428834856,
-0.0496276692,
-0.0171899647,
-0.0240750089,
-0.011454002,
-0.0363803394,
0.004915094,
-0.0481573306,
0.0019134202,
-0.0275208317,
-0.0594257303,
-0.0492965765,
-0.1105370671,
0.0479798019,
-0.016476674,
-0.0014069028,
-0.0181826372,
-0.0171691626,
0.0167494603,
-0.0028181374,
-0.0382013246,
-0.0663712099,
0.0088899117,
-0.0145521713,
0.027887255,
0.0149167813,
0.015041247,
-0.033437714,
0.0146014607,
0.0314366445,
-0.0517761782,
-0.0365410484,
-0.0294184107,
0.1240021735,
-0.018486198,
0.0123605663,
-0.0746587589,
0.0308948923,
-0.0602937341,
-0.0377851874,
0.0369890295,
0.0689029843,
-0.0118331304,
-0.0491676778,
-0.0532886311,
-0.0253748428,
-0.0116599612,
0.0653687119,
0.0097033512,
-0.0263291411,
-0.0142900096,
0.0196014494,
0.0295832492,
0.0266804621,
0.0465862043,
0.0295626242,
-0.0494033359,
-0.0062546134,
-0.0492704809,
-0.0462739319,
0.0359629393,
-0.0231198147,
0.0218389388,
0.038969148,
0.0803068355,
-0.0125543978,
-0.0870887712,
0.0357890911,
0.021894196,
-0.035461843,
0.0285127461,
-0.0210212544,
0.0511237606,
0.0057271505,
-0.017834302,
0.002349453,
0.0096986638,
-0.0096662454,
-0.0499999486,
0.0062397886,
0.0076501667,
0.0302300844,
0.0175325423,
0.0019085743,
0.0131407091,
0.0844881162,
0.0020695489,
-0.0308474284,
0.0065821265,
0.0400524661,
0.006577753,
0.0182004608,
-0.0240554884,
0.0223065689,
0.0174007677,
-0.0105616124,
-0.0328556783,
-0.0228918474,
0.0394264758,
0.0150895379,
0.0812183619,
-0.0046115709,
-0.0172788911,
-0.030562466,
-0.0008870147,
-0.0470163375,
-0.0015672097,
-0.0164354164,
0.0069547365,
-0.0023424332,
0.0373302437,
-0.0194926448,
0.0077178832,
-0.0340847671,
-0.0116870189,
0.0162433311,
0.0016318082,
-0.0139378794,
0.0440564491,
0.0253791325,
-0.0286727529,
-0.0126186321,
-0.0164256878,
0.0391105525,
0.0230013113,
-0.0316238515,
0.0055338116,
0.057657823,
0.0051130308,
-0.0409678482,
-0.0096755214,
-0.057519,
0.0823112577,
0.0002884228,
0.0400654674,
0.0173361097,
0.0050375448,
0.0314142704,
-0.0115740672,
-0.0023539101,
0.0273973867,
0.0671713054,
-0.0383268297,
0.0284588765,
0.0449877568,
0.0149703482,
-0.0362943597,
-0.0170794856,
0.052804634,
-0.000806426,
0.0630049706,
0.0265962761,
-0.0229280498,
-0.0470586494,
-0.0341621228,
-0.0183939785,
0.0204395056,
-0.0312330499,
0.0485194437,
-0.070646435,
-0.0338831283,
0.0154967513,
-0.0359896421,
-0.0068645091,
-0.0027910897,
0.0108041968,
0.0008212346,
0.0327282958,
-0.120417431,
0.0172568467,
0.0354157537,
-0.0330701731,
-0.0105729662,
-0.0171737783,
-6.37105522e-33,
-0.0367309265,
-0.0760137886,
0.0061414191,
-0.0033042294,
0.0047472664,
0.018449029,
-0.0443425141,
-0.0253427699,
-0.0160350502,
0.0445551611,
0.0169613957,
0.0253131948,
-0.0020985596,
0.032578215,
0.0012302503,
-0.0273269191,
0.007558831,
0.0300504621,
-0.0001611562,
-0.0062265103,
0.0274797902,
0.0500269607,
0.0673678592,
-0.0909166336,
0.002051584,
0.0247111041,
0.0287784506,
0.0218082424,
-0.040060278,
0.0045554908,
-0.0500890873,
0.0469684266,
0.040190991,
0.0227897353,
0.0516155697,
-0.011424805,
-0.1175502539,
-0.0562000833,
-0.0098987967,
-0.0277143661,
-0.0271295942,
0.0111987917,
0.0463235006,
0.0416940153,
0.0250816569,
-0.0474689752,
0.0729530528,
-0.044742927,
-0.0165225826,
-0.0421847366,
-0.067957215,
0.0284541138,
0.0150337378,
0.0057781073,
0.0233253241,
0.0138651337,
-0.0179917514,
0.0007391605,
0.0070535676,
-0.0159971341,
0.0034019889,
-0.0029356652,
-0.0185326766,
0.0230899081,
0.010086908,
0.0736211836,
0.0096726539,
-0.0116978968,
-0.0316498131,
0.0190366786,
-0.0143694934,
0.0271736737,
-0.0147992996,
0.0365588181,
0.0714319721,
0.031403821,
-0.1236866191,
0.002650144,
-0.0170806348,
0.0010798675,
-0.0508916229,
-0.0405803435,
-0.0198483486,
-0.021867428,
-0.0157763753,
-0.0291369706,
-0.0047471649,
-0.0068667065,
-0.0198077112,
-0.0315383002,
-0.0234761592,
0.0238617696,
-0.0176904462,
0.0011038721,
-0.0226396527,
-0.0014891981,
0.0094850492,
-0.022341935,
0.0130054709,
-0.004450086,
-0.0445000939,
-0.0329083279,
0.0327035896,
0.0129780462,
0.0426609144,
0.0184621196,
0.0600078218,
-0.0665028021,
-0.0338502526,
-0.0167216547,
-0.0199788194,
-0.0121985124,
-0.0040258388,
-0.0383066423,
0.0086343521,
0.0696355924,
0.0026327597,
0.0476152077,
0.049938865,
0.003755789,
-0.0460107587,
0.0502793677,
-0.0141894212,
0.0135689741,
0.0159576051,
-0.0071243867,
0.0021057923,
-0.0151279233,
0.0606897473,
-0.067598395,
-0.012767233,
-0.0418422855,
2.693e-7,
0.069407694,
0.036251042,
0.0250371229,
-0.0109505439,
0.0189670995,
0.034078829,
0.0378278568,
0.002274161,
0.0195738096,
-0.0273798201,
0.0261084326,
0.0267662089,
0.0238808971,
0.0662976205,
-0.0072326469,
-0.0220123567,
-0.0464339182,
-0.0838387907,
-0.0245156698,
0.0101856701,
0.0839089081,
0.0288809612,
0.0454429761,
-0.0040173633,
-0.0289187226,
0.0114803119,
0.0301715191,
-0.037762057,
0.0145546179,
0.0286193825,
-0.0647786334,
-0.0025849883,
0.0159465857,
0.074051559,
-0.0084802574,
-0.0039167562,
0.0112402262,
0.0468110517,
-0.0492451191,
0.0338196792,
-0.0108523918,
0.0287791323,
0.0269646402,
0.027997097,
0.0461633913,
-0.0868715495,
-0.039572306,
-0.0040034032,
-0.0313472003,
0.0228734128,
0.0282514784,
0.025531752,
-0.0003623697,
0.0292592347,
0.0056685382,
0.0171212796,
-0.0477823466,
-0.0779427662,
0.00867783,
0.0597181395,
-0.0066036326,
-0.0177555848,
0.0425814763,
-0.0234451499,
0.014403942,
-0.0692749768,
0.0156705547,
2.273422375e-34,
-0.0197529308,
0.0035570059,
-0.0106631322,
0.0308247823,
0.0528409816,
-0.046981018,
-0.0445425026,
-0.0159062874,
-0.0002183701,
-0.0469605066,
0.0249821562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00222v1
|
Learning to Clarify: Multi-turn Conversations with Action-Based Contrastive Self-Training
| 2024-05-31T22:44:48 | 2024-05-31T22:44:48 |
Maximillian Chen, Ruoxi Sun, Sercan Ö. Arık, Tomas Pfister
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) aligned through reinforcement learning from
human feedback (RLHF) have quickly become one of the dominant paradigms for
building intelligent conversational assistant agents. However, despite their
strong performance across many benchmarks, LLM-based agents still lack
conversational skills such as disambiguation: when generalized assistants are
faced with ambiguity, they often overhedge or implicitly guess users'
ground-truth intents rather than asking clarification questions, and under
task-specific settings, high-quality conversation samples are often limited,
affecting models' ability to learn optimal dialogue action policies. We propose
Action-Based Contrastive Self-Training (henceforth ACT), a quasi-online
preference optimization algorithm based on Direct Preference Optimization (DPO)
which allows for sample-efficient dialogue policy learning in multi-turn
conversation. We demonstrate ACT's efficacy under sample-efficient conditions
in three difficult conversational tasks: tabular-grounded question-answering,
machine reading comprehension, and AmbigSQL, a novel task for disambiguating
information-seeking requests for text-to-SQL generation. Additionally, we
propose evaluating LLMs' ability to function as conversational agents by
examining whether they can implicitly recognize and reason about ambiguity in
conversation. ACT demonstrates substantial conversation modeling improvements
over standard approaches to supervised fine-tuning and DPO.
|
[
0.0582421608,
0.0232682396,
-0.0024704195,
0.0206770282,
-0.0269784946,
0.0181133486,
-0.0036899813,
-0.0461978428,
0.022732133,
-0.0524748936,
-0.0272174254,
-0.0225638784,
-0.0312259719,
0.0008587547,
0.0030069235,
-0.0571885481,
0.0503388643,
-0.0460225008,
0.0219234359,
-0.0102709979,
-0.0017736409,
0.0105050988,
-0.0335827582,
0.0174435955,
0.0061536999,
-0.0367606953,
-0.0295250136,
-0.0021304672,
-0.0084716585,
0.0017455794,
0.0378434509,
0.05269311,
0.0262215789,
0.0272595473,
0.0000019247,
-0.0576317906,
-0.0293762721,
-0.0281235632,
-0.0451470204,
-0.010891608,
0.0122336941,
0.0121993739,
0.0113784382,
0.0370980799,
-0.0435204171,
0.0134070134,
0.0164737366,
0.0515653752,
0.0768137649,
0.0671026409,
0.0094635207,
-0.0400773399,
-0.0078354282,
-0.033711113,
0.0257944912,
-0.0622437261,
-0.0078861304,
0.0078220097,
-0.0159814898,
0.0309134424,
-0.0079430118,
0.0218835566,
0.0193709116,
-0.0321591161,
-0.0282378495,
0.037521068,
-0.0092255631,
-0.0095925378,
-0.0174347237,
0.0974340066,
0.0246369801,
-0.0012727329,
0.025721807,
-0.0177778732,
0.0068341941,
0.0030321812,
0.0023646601,
0.0132437525,
-0.0133498162,
-0.0006043511,
0.0236164499,
-0.0145261828,
0.0126564372,
0.0455165617,
-0.0357734561,
0.0370791852,
-0.0391310118,
-0.0426746085,
0.0311754942,
-0.0152381426,
-0.0032337143,
-0.0654633641,
0.021324262,
0.0511370637,
-0.1140772626,
0.0346389338,
-0.0269468762,
0.0088704256,
0.0323016606,
-0.0313060656,
0.0225228984,
0.0588062257,
0.0096017448,
0.0662815496,
0.0187824797,
0.0361627564,
-0.011402294,
0.0136249764,
-0.0305475965,
-0.0163495876,
-0.0318710469,
0.0156004606,
-0.0604473464,
0.0570779108,
-0.0809064582,
-0.0274143815,
-0.0092299934,
0.0594382286,
-0.0064493599,
0.0502896719,
0.0085567255,
0.0282533132,
-0.0591344833,
-0.0135641946,
-0.0697947145,
0.0358804576,
-0.0244065952,
0.011944538,
0.0205273014,
-0.0370687135,
-0.0185361654,
0.004843838,
-0.0177356619,
-0.0296103861,
0.0071289958,
0.0695185438,
-0.0377372503,
-0.0299669039,
-0.0093805604,
-0.0068734782,
-0.032554511,
-0.0725519061,
-0.0326416679,
-0.0169090219,
0.027521681,
0.0089552226,
-0.0185995139,
-0.0196809396,
0.0279550441,
0.0226082336,
-0.0103125721,
0.0760867819,
0.0034142633,
0.010653655,
0.051009804,
0.0011783199,
-0.0405056514,
0.0628653243,
0.0431518592,
0.0357450508,
0.0255772993,
-0.0166776516,
0.014894559,
-0.0030154078,
0.0095510362,
0.0089635979,
0.0107547818,
0.0400269218,
-0.0491962247,
0.0493951179,
0.0418516919,
0.068411693,
-0.0467157289,
-0.0138783939,
0.0658021197,
0.0359976664,
0.0068971291,
0.0314259827,
0.0275858939,
0.0701662302,
0.0025006155,
0.0214600842,
-0.0451742932,
0.0400145911,
-0.0007078661,
0.0318567306,
0.0500927269,
-0.0076964828,
-0.0415538065,
-0.0777289942,
0.0440822691,
-0.0082630217,
0.033905603,
0.0733427927,
0.0198492911,
0.0168685578,
-0.0783014968,
0.007576237,
0.0109643601,
-0.0191376489,
-0.022731252,
-0.048942402,
0.0414815545,
0.0974849239,
0.0431760401,
-0.0192495584,
-0.053221792,
-0.0573035032,
-0.0042721224,
0.0642305836,
0.040133711,
-0.0423949361,
0.0475487113,
-0.0446595661,
-0.0244158916,
-0.0206035059,
-0.0146493027,
0.0040066843,
0.0140837152,
-0.0134889483,
0.0029540178,
0.0019626869,
-0.0212679766,
0.0164166391,
-0.0156531073,
-0.0460872352,
0.0540403388,
0.0125512164,
0.0240568742,
0.0110854926,
-0.0089039514,
-0.0157509483,
0.0047719902,
0.0174658168,
-0.0174654946,
-0.0027573195,
-0.0724823251,
-0.0440899283,
0.0199547764,
0.0248627942,
-0.0552039593,
-0.0090885451,
-0.058752019,
-0.0422275439,
0.0003061551,
-0.0324414223,
0.019777691,
-0.0378749184,
0.0143379364,
0.037794061,
-0.0117341867,
-0.0220876615,
0.0500374697,
-0.009425099,
-0.0235556103,
0.0035528983,
0.0219175518,
0.0081290258,
-0.0619508214,
0.0331101678,
-0.0117437113,
0.010453539,
0.0116454773,
0.0333080813,
0.0511347018,
-0.0723642111,
-0.0415600203,
-0.0773485601,
0.0121044088,
-0.0266481768,
0.0105899945,
0.0155164199,
0.0287958346,
0.0006477727,
-0.0390870497,
-0.0148322005,
-0.0177700464,
0.0009061498,
-0.0023319626,
0.057049986,
0.0323086902,
0.0238948483,
-0.0646650121,
0.0146274986,
0.0005535214,
-0.0159699507,
-0.0184474792,
-0.0005969591,
-0.0515771136,
0.0351860523,
-0.0218801033,
0.0442325845,
-0.0215420984,
-0.0486320928,
0.0182953365,
-0.0018177556,
0.0240110755,
0.111789614,
0.0508349389,
0.0213692673,
0.0224966854,
-0.0111010913,
-0.0628804043,
0.0756728351,
-0.0399874933,
-0.0029302754,
-0.0417289175,
-0.0193827543,
0.0192549862,
0.0557682738,
-0.0083078351,
0.0224762894,
-0.028978508,
-0.0182068814,
0.0398623049,
-0.0498138554,
-0.0116799893,
0.0356307775,
-0.0179321971,
0.0251591504,
-0.0381768979,
-0.0177986529,
0.0987810716,
0.013747449,
-0.022397181,
-0.0928409398,
-0.0339778028,
-0.0358742252,
0.0271759909,
-0.0258608814,
0.0128505239,
-0.0057473429,
-0.0334272161,
-0.0546515882,
-0.0623406135,
0.0515786372,
-0.0310725123,
0.0946202129,
-0.0565686598,
0.0189654678,
0.0193907544,
-0.085373722,
-0.0595776848,
-0.0443859138,
-0.0154185267,
0.0018272441,
0.0262162331,
-0.0194442403,
-0.0123208305,
-0.0132079544,
0.0379182957,
0.0599482059,
0.0014141611,
-0.0482726395,
-0.0362353548,
0.0187126324,
0.0749041066,
0.024996927,
0.0145167885,
-0.0118762422,
0.0677269697,
0.0198325478,
0.0281059425,
-0.0488525704,
-0.0088337036,
-0.0051174345,
0.0122318249,
-0.0515222289,
-0.0192368533,
0.0344748423,
0.0453039594,
-0.0339660347,
-0.0290955193,
0.1344768107,
0.0325045548,
-0.0341346636,
-0.0113351932,
-0.0211316664,
0.0131199481,
0.0073515251,
0.0459875725,
-0.0716673881,
-0.0456177704,
-0.0066688526,
0.0349149071,
0.0228033941,
-0.0292395297,
-0.0024451902,
-0.1065037549,
0.024683699,
-0.0293994471,
-0.0334668718,
-0.0007873662,
-0.0067944545,
0.0208985247,
-0.0424833558,
0.0513089523,
-0.0011954135,
-0.0161318425,
-0.009968509,
0.0044559408,
0.0147420708,
-0.0181381423,
0.0154816173,
-0.0229562763,
0.025249226,
0.069990769,
0.0273088589,
0.0401314422,
0.0191208608,
0.0126980711,
-0.0193012971,
-0.013216869,
-0.0333501585,
0.056962803,
-0.0236128494,
0.0097844638,
-0.0188016072,
0.0336850546,
-0.004519396,
-0.0070246523,
-0.0051013511,
-0.0020926974,
-0.0431253016,
0.0019538554,
0.0095574306,
0.0229715034,
0.0652957037,
0.060930267,
-0.0024209123,
-0.0524479635,
-0.0825280845,
-0.0368559994,
0.0091828257,
-0.0535477661,
0.027977407,
-0.0322488956,
0.0014664676,
0.0309034418,
-0.0432346947,
-0.0629246235,
0.0043039066,
0.0075174221,
-0.0202277899,
0.0305246506,
0.0526290126,
0.0108641777,
-0.0057745525,
-0.0130522493,
-0.0229479931,
0.0032019825,
-0.0371231772,
-0.0627305582,
0.0428499617,
-0.0459687337,
-0.0127690202,
0.0149780773,
-0.0473793186,
-0.0488839746,
-0.0116196861,
0.0686689615,
0.020719653,
0.0822203532,
-0.0176005196,
-0.0457378291,
-0.0121281082,
0.0041994341,
-0.0489235707,
-0.0151170706,
0.0521413386,
0.0900533125,
0.001052739,
0.0596369281,
-0.046600081,
-0.00150075,
-0.0208466686,
0.0351991057,
-0.0754469037,
-0.0612191148,
0.0129391858,
-0.0365723558,
0.0041727843,
0.0160673559,
0.0463739298,
-0.0106938528,
0.0384202115,
-0.0220808424,
-0.0322006755,
-0.0245794319,
-0.0092544779,
0.0091247559,
-0.0434723236,
0.0187261552,
0.0258089844,
-0.0312503092,
0.022246521,
0.0039796517,
-0.0168186463,
0.0080195377,
0.0044854656,
-0.0057358504,
-0.0197259132,
-0.00557295,
0.031853348,
0.0673544034,
0.0723956525,
0.0290783681,
0.0907923281,
0.0402908213,
-0.0162496362,
-0.0008500371,
0.0041229716,
-0.047942698,
-0.0735751614,
0.0011221451,
0.0073155859,
0.0388768129,
-0.0014147082,
0.0567290708,
-0.0444781668,
-0.0006204364,
0.0026912794,
0.0444237702,
-0.0001372727,
0.0096366368,
0.0281097125,
0.0286243428,
-0.0050132191,
0.0331046395,
0.0797927976,
0.0011562776,
0.0232971963,
0.0169726852,
-0.0016397104,
-0.057570003,
-0.0430926755,
-0.038625963,
0.0236296318,
-0.0220691878,
0.0085782679,
-0.0357805528,
-0.0472383425,
-0.0027827844,
0.0074592433,
-0.0183872618,
-0.0401203036,
0.0395530723,
0.0455169603,
0.0227346718,
-0.0430616736,
-0.0727717802,
0.0125243766,
-0.0290059969,
-0.0335708484,
-0.052777607,
-6.360220835e-33,
-0.0168455169,
-0.0361458398,
0.0380432159,
-0.0295170527,
-0.0097907456,
-0.0333243273,
-0.0522513948,
-0.0214562584,
-0.0543502718,
0.0101403482,
-0.0356015973,
0.0644064322,
0.0178230405,
0.0429944173,
-0.016331939,
-0.0341774039,
0.0578055754,
-0.0128339054,
-0.0326081775,
0.0373168215,
0.0174648073,
0.0115165384,
-0.0053464491,
-0.0719439238,
-0.0015408987,
0.0007114101,
-0.0124018602,
0.0616036579,
-0.0149848787,
0.0634259284,
-0.0204204898,
0.0039039177,
0.0061132819,
-0.017442435,
-0.0016073379,
0.0099131614,
-0.0965414271,
-0.0347518325,
0.020178359,
-0.0260612126,
-0.0601954646,
-0.0239666644,
0.0160301346,
-0.0109297354,
0.0092917243,
0.0057058008,
-0.0050364579,
-0.001880047,
-0.0180973243,
0.0175244901,
-0.0269475244,
-0.010871903,
-0.0438445583,
-0.0662279502,
0.0077982959,
0.0122007411,
0.0045519704,
0.0162950549,
-0.0465547405,
0.0235821791,
0.001368406,
0.0093145911,
0.0505607575,
0.019951148,
0.0019048685,
-0.0003469335,
0.0301482584,
0.0145904757,
0.0133325467,
-0.0331084542,
-0.0364899673,
0.0362531617,
-0.029517021,
0.0521206781,
0.0017015551,
0.0076605598,
-0.0476336181,
0.0119529767,
0.0238089059,
0.0472281761,
-0.0031881346,
-0.0029143398,
-0.0540684685,
-0.0220321026,
-0.0487542823,
0.0040429523,
-0.0220627505,
-0.0235637836,
0.0168370754,
0.0333494842,
0.0144281536,
-0.0254856721,
0.0030671535,
-0.009665695,
-0.027440479,
0.0363109373,
-0.0370166004,
0.0076702279,
0.0035663012,
0.0058944332,
-0.0728955194,
-0.0130601991,
0.0171130449,
0.0151355565,
-0.0154184587,
0.0407629758,
0.0017358125,
0.0151947066,
-0.0472628511,
0.0250052251,
-0.0072701313,
0.0552084744,
-0.0262030475,
0.0195213538,
0.0168721322,
-0.0008252899,
-0.0194166247,
0.0923475921,
0.0125963911,
-0.0033578321,
-0.0240871198,
-0.0580293462,
0.004008492,
0.0232407153,
-0.0119544137,
0.0206180438,
-0.0152813485,
0.0372565649,
-0.0035667615,
-0.0461773872,
-0.0102237305,
0.0116328429,
2.704e-7,
0.014219854,
0.0686484724,
0.0193475373,
0.0729466379,
0.0065659666,
0.0641068593,
0.0138653889,
-0.0026265052,
0.0239234138,
-0.0000736888,
0.0379107259,
0.0415709279,
0.0473824888,
0.0012978925,
-0.0576864779,
-0.0169335753,
-0.0354126766,
0.0045590028,
-0.0380331464,
-0.0171571281,
0.0469605662,
0.0732072219,
-0.0005349122,
-0.0077838106,
0.0057178121,
-0.0086936066,
0.0546982512,
-0.0236734506,
-0.0106154252,
0.0413643792,
0.0119683724,
0.0032303082,
-0.0196027327,
0.003469649,
-0.0167379361,
0.0324870087,
-0.0457985103,
0.0791757852,
0.0270092674,
-0.0659330562,
-0.0195882022,
-0.0073394156,
0.0479385927,
-0.0395492613,
0.0722680613,
-0.0753546432,
-0.0145239448,
0.0202308167,
-0.00297656,
-0.0194005258,
0.0049797492,
-0.0338238962,
-0.0528024696,
-0.0088280346,
-0.0090202522,
0.0201749727,
0.0011168811,
-0.0649182647,
0.0197500009,
0.0299186278,
-0.0183019228,
-0.0118834293,
-0.0126822293,
0.0033482902,
0.0141980369,
-0.0418987945,
0.0206482001,
2.21044825e-34,
0.0445782654,
0.0047761612,
0.0092558814,
0.0455742851,
0.0364757217,
0.0238286424,
-0.0237078574,
-0.0098889656,
0.0663053021,
-0.0555883981,
-0.0167734995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00199v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00199v2
|
Exfiltration of personal information from ChatGPT via prompt injection
| 2024-05-31T21:21:19 | 2024-06-06T06:43:38 |
Gregory Schwartzman
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.ET
|
We report that ChatGPT 4 and 4o are susceptible to a prompt injection attack
that allows an attacker to exfiltrate users' personal data. It is applicable
without the use of any 3rd party tools and all users are currently affected.
This vulnerability is exacerbated by the recent introduction of ChatGPT's
memory feature, which allows an attacker to command ChatGPT to monitor the user
for the desired personal data.
|
[
0.0177667178,
-0.0236180481,
0.014439716,
0.0200438518,
-0.044769194,
0.0025964016,
0.0277311429,
-0.0199863147,
0.0801180601,
-0.0065813628,
-0.0098867603,
0.0066829151,
0.0091373418,
0.026037788,
0.061237447,
-0.0004907576,
0.0438182466,
-0.0205829386,
-0.0474413261,
0.0290150363,
0.008392524,
-0.0244017933,
-0.0057702232,
0.0432450697,
-0.0176843777,
-0.031344559,
-0.0284665804,
0.033825364,
0.0146287121,
-0.0217204001,
-0.0040625953,
-0.0026368792,
-0.0326514803,
0.0305378921,
0.0000020162,
-0.0179575887,
-0.0244117547,
0.051802218,
-0.0902064443,
0.0611773804,
-0.0346433371,
0.086475119,
-0.0053044865,
0.0270110089,
0.0211792924,
-0.0011716756,
-0.0029557615,
0.0426590778,
0.1026686653,
0.0629872531,
-0.0131365359,
0.033005774,
0.0155883292,
0.0024700263,
0.0653670654,
0.0088867648,
0.0190633759,
-0.0460082777,
0.0276647285,
0.0833720267,
0.0282546971,
-0.0256560799,
-0.0193640701,
-0.0281277113,
-0.059315335,
0.0416179113,
-0.0064952066,
-0.0198542792,
-0.0212009735,
-0.0209431015,
-0.0001230134,
0.0158783756,
0.0276153255,
0.058736939,
-0.0030067707,
0.0125310477,
0.0170974731,
-0.0297755245,
-0.0768155009,
-0.0434671938,
-0.0361265279,
0.0216384027,
0.0104808267,
-0.0325889215,
0.0093304329,
-0.0342682227,
0.051122684,
-0.0232080631,
0.0002968778,
-0.06528534,
0.004266683,
-0.0248122141,
-0.049109526,
-0.017640803,
0.0002241804,
-0.0024626348,
-0.0137588186,
0.0365934744,
-0.0149156963,
-0.0281619076,
-0.0365492404,
0.068707332,
-0.025261702,
0.0002486457,
0.0373143405,
0.0007829865,
-0.011236039,
-0.0135478955,
0.0506843515,
0.0329926461,
-0.0015055191,
-0.0043098931,
-0.0289640706,
0.0349275544,
0.0217697211,
0.0152925067,
-0.0382703505,
0.058722809,
-0.0007660699,
0.0381791107,
0.018135434,
-0.000049294,
0.002726068,
0.0433837436,
0.0074140872,
-0.0458738543,
0.0264917035,
-0.1017650887,
0.0031422072,
-0.0788558871,
-0.0234570205,
-0.0178686548,
-0.0461954176,
0.0164785758,
-0.0301402826,
0.106150575,
-0.0020428291,
-0.0049278969,
-0.0252345931,
-0.0757731199,
-0.0097925775,
-0.0212096721,
0.0065766368,
-0.0149650713,
-0.0064020189,
-0.0117272893,
-0.0170548446,
0.0485145599,
-0.006997447,
-0.0071801711,
-0.0622409992,
0.0419127718,
0.0109390402,
-0.0608540699,
0.0015439471,
0.052010525,
-0.038451504,
-0.0350255296,
-0.0742650554,
0.0348926857,
0.0106938025,
-0.0427943133,
0.0581784807,
0.0038139923,
-0.0152759654,
0.0018572739,
0.0690464079,
0.0070915921,
0.0745094419,
-0.0400898196,
-0.0543824807,
0.0389655679,
0.0081140017,
-0.0069476562,
0.0687400028,
0.063933,
-0.021914918,
-0.0122437868,
-0.0106669664,
0.021625232,
-0.0055222949,
0.0017136073,
-0.0332669318,
-0.0342178605,
-0.0649613366,
-0.0109267635,
0.012728177,
0.0281653423,
-0.0222026221,
0.0268189833,
-0.0008675116,
-0.0460938364,
-0.0127702886,
0.000480301,
-0.0191685315,
-0.0035480054,
0.0394925475,
0.0122946408,
0.040470168,
-0.0061907875,
-0.0384774841,
-0.0874636769,
-0.0077765905,
0.0681769624,
0.014203391,
0.0340377428,
-0.0441089086,
-0.0229569823,
0.016725434,
-0.0201809127,
0.0191109218,
0.0890218616,
-0.0160173457,
0.0384160616,
0.0205252618,
0.0496668071,
0.006667743,
0.0712186247,
-0.0071727782,
0.0184285529,
-0.0268674288,
0.0796976238,
0.0363427214,
-0.0119737713,
0.0167502016,
-0.0877161622,
0.0154976211,
0.0236801952,
-0.0393866412,
0.0140662482,
0.0311515648,
0.0065350602,
0.0240362138,
0.0594937205,
0.0222672299,
0.0343487188,
-0.0396422669,
0.0127747562,
0.007943905,
-0.014467895,
-0.0010794217,
-0.0184723176,
-0.0149626508,
-0.004487908,
0.0418224633,
-0.0380812734,
0.0336208902,
-0.0141332243,
-0.0260723978,
0.0272404253,
0.0133909285,
0.0068124174,
-0.015804166,
0.0267265011,
-0.0056989691,
-0.0214906633,
0.0480732322,
-0.0025936645,
-0.0220014956,
-0.0417255312,
-0.0106674014,
-0.0297871046,
0.026631346,
-0.0065989909,
0.0094050821,
-0.021965554,
-0.0033239357,
-0.0531938858,
0.0201543123,
-0.0034043307,
0.0163369495,
0.047474511,
0.0806763247,
-0.060730245,
-0.0086600119,
-0.0209911447,
-0.0100175496,
0.0248003379,
0.0048416303,
0.0311813336,
-0.0144463452,
0.01920419,
0.0329163559,
0.0179185066,
-0.0199027769,
0.0289712194,
-0.0012106885,
-0.0701776072,
-0.0107213641,
0.0032215903,
-0.0031181795,
-0.0448628068,
-0.0315555334,
-0.0487651229,
0.0269890353,
-0.0089266011,
0.0008253063,
0.0629018545,
0.03901577,
0.0875644237,
-0.0161191504,
0.0032316023,
-0.0048033879,
-0.0118381884,
0.0088091986,
-0.046987541,
0.0262018982,
0.0059875026,
0.033865802,
0.0177603681,
0.0491566136,
0.0179974455,
-0.0184039325,
0.0302241854,
-0.0078714965,
0.0407815464,
-0.0229476597,
0.0011061579,
-0.0562856197,
-0.022112336,
-0.009132647,
-0.0539060459,
0.0207819305,
-0.0482641235,
-0.0293306597,
0.0020363429,
-0.0507823899,
0.023196565,
0.0265797637,
-0.025437776,
-0.0158593878,
0.0958410949,
-0.0530312732,
0.0390995815,
-0.0471729711,
0.0427104793,
-0.0393362232,
-0.0633225739,
-0.0171289034,
-0.0415059812,
-0.0232039485,
-0.0258451048,
-0.0242672022,
-0.0755983964,
0.0461475216,
-0.0608535334,
0.0071613914,
-0.0343075506,
0.0139811337,
-0.0366413146,
0.0206050761,
-0.0028907245,
-0.0572056472,
-0.0097683473,
0.0046432326,
-0.0334515423,
-0.0245734919,
-0.0780535117,
-0.0802389383,
0.0229305979,
0.0294983126,
0.0793879256,
0.0156570151,
-0.0302591044,
-0.0025836183,
-0.0029313613,
-0.0217482429,
-0.0036630461,
-0.0003596246,
0.0396763682,
0.0367210805,
0.006504246,
-0.0102992496,
0.0193953272,
-0.0006154113,
-0.0352766924,
-0.0223567374,
0.013912403,
-0.0002938315,
-0.005769223,
0.0292003993,
-0.0594280697,
0.0150941443,
0.0081724869,
0.0620124973,
-0.024297744,
-0.0251011737,
-0.0436939262,
-0.0325589292,
0.0154890623,
0.0299270358,
-0.0268416759,
0.0180580001,
-0.0202987958,
0.0174291804,
0.0371475108,
0.0613473803,
-0.0390949696,
-0.0190236531,
0.0325086266,
0.0195907466,
-0.0907538757,
0.0188578647,
0.0417421758,
-0.0308783352,
0.0348035619,
0.0005986133,
-0.0054516485,
0.0097858245,
0.0178258959,
0.0592853054,
0.0051010465,
-0.0309035238,
0.0053203427,
0.0438794717,
0.0025101157,
-0.0045893672,
0.0042777858,
0.0447775759,
0.009610055,
0.0447952077,
0.0058299513,
-0.0043700025,
-0.0434174798,
0.0350153632,
0.0284532513,
0.0197305903,
0.0518158637,
0.0064043002,
-0.0104576154,
-0.0147327185,
0.0066346773,
-0.0726957768,
0.0417627655,
0.0307869148,
-0.0335082971,
-0.0208245814,
0.0234864131,
-0.0674944669,
-0.0201421492,
-0.0102666393,
-0.0127318315,
0.0229566563,
0.043134436,
-0.0150494818,
-0.0219084751,
0.0400872268,
0.0296055246,
-0.0240997244,
-0.0460540168,
-0.0013297587,
-0.0214609373,
0.0807958618,
-0.0296170656,
-0.0043284176,
-0.0212329905,
0.026844278,
-0.042257268,
-0.0436521582,
0.0403524935,
0.0468890928,
0.0328500941,
0.0025108235,
-0.0198162384,
0.0646240935,
0.0168850292,
0.0310942437,
-0.0543556623,
-0.021797277,
0.0437267907,
0.0683718026,
-0.0034605786,
-0.0615225397,
0.0021417022,
-0.0366339274,
0.0280067977,
-0.0601647198,
-0.0266397409,
-0.0255158022,
0.0120297335,
0.0302791819,
0.0446243584,
0.01186834,
0.0147774126,
0.0342240967,
0.0095750894,
-0.0555726998,
-0.0006033745,
0.0118433023,
-0.0288514141,
-0.063427873,
0.0105603384,
0.0600465052,
-0.0671222955,
-0.0041134749,
0.0191774443,
0.0403227694,
-0.027761111,
0.0277468618,
0.0084789814,
0.0155185489,
0.0063728569,
-0.0063364087,
0.0353231356,
0.0385635458,
0.0156183429,
-0.0458806902,
0.0351394452,
-0.0103705088,
-0.0189576354,
0.0160660669,
0.0202698056,
-0.1015219614,
-0.0193162356,
0.0942801684,
0.0825991258,
-0.0036031611,
0.0238212068,
-0.0406912416,
-0.0211554468,
0.0189037398,
-0.0391691513,
-0.0035488419,
-0.0278898366,
0.0282894392,
-0.0676878989,
-0.0245940294,
-0.0011262607,
0.0132780727,
0.0148292389,
-0.0277838856,
0.0398881286,
0.0166552011,
-0.0539479516,
-0.0473936759,
0.02141927,
0.0359873474,
0.0244621057,
0.0011878706,
-0.0773331299,
-0.0172248296,
-0.0067053903,
-0.0437016971,
-0.0421839394,
-0.0080478219,
0.0349055082,
0.0230145473,
-0.0035760659,
-0.0039740726,
0.0298840851,
-0.0292719733,
0.0406223908,
-0.0350597128,
-0.0122235911,
0.026124537,
-5.502165795e-33,
0.0256016795,
-0.0059204595,
-0.0266637113,
0.0899410248,
0.0054702591,
0.0138274087,
-0.0013686154,
0.0186609104,
0.0030066583,
-0.0300086178,
-0.0334438123,
-0.0190905612,
0.0282624979,
0.0112939673,
-0.0650280863,
-0.0310393143,
-0.0038174635,
0.0217652433,
0.0183545537,
0.0514324792,
0.0994909927,
0.0318334848,
-0.0113177868,
-0.0184059925,
0.0431786925,
-0.0149788167,
0.003846461,
-0.0126105696,
0.0090873959,
-0.001913798,
0.0117172552,
-0.0351375788,
-0.0260764677,
-0.0063016801,
0.0065135746,
0.090892531,
-0.0370859802,
-0.0534182079,
-0.012070816,
-0.0069168122,
0.0077141337,
-0.0435949191,
-0.0375647508,
-0.0428926535,
-0.0162205305,
-0.0177666452,
-0.0193698034,
0.050482925,
-0.0164589882,
0.003876332,
0.0187394749,
-0.0322003253,
-0.0205532387,
0.0038058087,
-0.04644344,
0.0259728041,
0.0069870926,
-0.0958254486,
-0.0044060512,
0.0200019442,
-0.0062201582,
0.0037980429,
-0.0360289589,
0.0262706485,
-0.001943464,
0.0054422379,
0.0011064991,
-0.0362805463,
-0.0440627448,
0.024944976,
-0.0370781198,
-0.0024020115,
0.0039904383,
-0.0184863582,
-0.0095039587,
-0.0587552041,
-0.0076660011,
0.0119530754,
0.0755255148,
0.0133890975,
0.0332669169,
-0.0462126732,
-0.090064086,
-0.0351444036,
0.0395283885,
0.0287165996,
-0.0131861959,
-0.0467637703,
0.0011913438,
-0.0310780611,
-0.017977301,
-0.018192647,
-0.0104957912,
-0.022051543,
0.046163287,
-0.0435937606,
0.0380764045,
-0.0698586926,
-0.0500749834,
-0.0070808101,
0.0544305034,
0.0275973231,
0.0314219445,
-0.0163695663,
0.017285917,
-0.0098339468,
0.005543483,
0.0337839089,
-0.0667480454,
-0.0118082436,
-0.00391436,
0.0692868456,
-0.0124088554,
0.0260986201,
0.0313192941,
0.0136652449,
0.0001244339,
-0.029565189,
0.0433233865,
0.0438246839,
-0.0587263554,
-0.0138394944,
-0.0327866077,
0.0083344104,
0.0098642306,
0.0558154806,
-0.0494704917,
0.0530910119,
0.0354892053,
-0.0122613423,
0.0331329107,
-0.0387675613,
2.945e-7,
-0.0376078263,
0.0177753158,
0.0330630764,
0.0030511993,
0.0091873473,
0.0280041061,
0.0057553379,
0.0683233216,
0.0286037326,
-0.0280001163,
-0.0163031965,
-0.0300462954,
0.0484423526,
-0.0140808085,
-0.0631121472,
-0.0512254275,
-0.0365933329,
-0.0576419868,
-0.0535647832,
0.034462776,
0.1116743088,
0.0094808936,
0.0257715248,
-0.0438305549,
0.0207826365,
-0.0369239077,
0.0262773391,
-0.0073983977,
-0.0630692095,
-0.0575654879,
0.0569295548,
0.0834383592,
0.0446505994,
0.0668577403,
-0.0215775017,
-0.0628003404,
-0.050950896,
0.0041576405,
0.0391996577,
-0.0151147097,
-0.0345320776,
-0.0442695767,
-0.0078919539,
-0.0159485228,
0.0411640182,
-0.0016260804,
-0.030266095,
-0.0066383271,
0.0075569362,
-0.0627903715,
0.0206275266,
-0.002953914,
-0.0231739003,
0.0323234871,
0.0191320367,
0.0395168476,
0.0155951194,
-0.0193071682,
-0.017734766,
-0.0477021895,
-0.0239021759,
-0.0875197798,
0.0448969714,
0.0449298695,
0.0109158531,
0.0130182412,
0.0055699111,
2.983890931e-34,
-0.0320810676,
-0.0233601015,
0.0141463485,
-0.0599794351,
0.0172820017,
0.0287819225,
0.0788291097,
0.0237590466,
0.0317693353,
-0.0101603558,
-0.0287719145
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00197v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00197v1
|
Re3: A Holistic Framework and Dataset for Modeling Collaborative Document Revision
| 2024-05-31T21:19:09 | 2024-05-31T21:19:09 |
Qian Ruan, Ilia Kuznetsov, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Collaborative review and revision of textual documents is the core of
knowledge work and a promising target for empirical analysis and NLP
assistance. Yet, a holistic framework that would allow modeling complex
relationships between document revisions, reviews and author responses is
lacking. To address this gap, we introduce Re3, a framework for joint analysis
of collaborative document revision. We instantiate this framework in the
scholarly domain, and present Re3-Sci, a large corpus of aligned scientific
paper revisions manually labeled according to their action and intent, and
supplemented with the respective peer reviews and human-written edit summaries.
We use the new data to provide first empirical insights into collaborative
document revision in the academic domain, and to assess the capabilities of
state-of-the-art LLMs at automating edit analysis and facilitating text-based
collaboration. We make our annotation environment and protocols, the resulting
data and experimental code publicly available.
|
[
0.0773743466,
0.0097804992,
0.0003219942,
-0.0252287369,
-0.0428549945,
-0.0065653278,
-0.0007030534,
0.0024824976,
-0.0654835999,
-0.0572982319,
-0.0574240237,
0.0206588693,
0.0053906557,
0.0139070759,
-0.0115142148,
-0.0278236326,
0.0313781984,
0.0288090743,
0.0306951627,
0.0190118905,
0.0270284507,
0.0115767708,
0.0095650181,
0.0169890728,
0.0190693513,
-0.0308944527,
-0.035791114,
-0.0101240482,
-0.0111562395,
0.0206658132,
0.0106188217,
0.1101584136,
0.0246467162,
0.1001456454,
0.0000016941,
-0.0770710036,
-0.0217302423,
0.0212102998,
0.0072890832,
0.0467220582,
0.0535501242,
-0.0105008297,
-0.0204822849,
-0.0314132646,
-0.0274943206,
0.0183941834,
0.000610944,
0.0117444266,
0.0357596576,
0.0667788014,
0.0006642803,
-0.0033258935,
-0.0093168132,
-0.0330958329,
0.0122120222,
0.0393740907,
0.0222504381,
0.0068925498,
-0.0124624278,
0.0539370105,
0.0382022038,
-0.0030895248,
-0.0321869291,
-0.1118495241,
0.0188410282,
-0.0347312763,
-0.0186749287,
-0.0040707216,
0.0084229326,
0.0206198581,
0.0719489604,
-0.0109277293,
0.0455475003,
0.0081002703,
-0.0137067866,
0.0738122016,
-0.0350364521,
-0.0158322193,
0.0104360916,
-0.0425390713,
-0.0187183972,
-0.0488061942,
0.0219612513,
0.0125424871,
0.054881081,
0.0295736659,
0.0169398915,
-0.0130764209,
-0.0566838942,
0.0207545776,
0.0279331189,
-0.0597279966,
-0.0068324371,
0.0207821429,
0.0046726344,
-0.0286545698,
0.0126185715,
-0.0569550991,
0.0719010755,
-0.0203652885,
0.0482336544,
-0.0346358083,
0.0043391315,
0.0638587996,
0.0141386129,
-0.0191417709,
0.0087379077,
0.011429267,
0.0074078399,
0.0228043571,
-0.0685932562,
0.0117613282,
0.0036722324,
0.0127780214,
-0.0189903788,
0.034812618,
-0.0455529466,
0.0364452116,
-0.0250108428,
0.0307680164,
0.0446980707,
0.0058616865,
-0.0581330284,
-0.0142895775,
-0.0175300781,
0.0250697006,
0.0086199716,
0.0382248871,
-0.0230951253,
0.0332214423,
0.0163069237,
-0.0149057545,
0.0165534746,
-0.0279405788,
-0.0068876659,
0.0398831815,
0.0288798027,
0.0028422957,
0.0407232344,
-0.0633957312,
0.0076912842,
-0.0339297131,
-0.0037316894,
-0.0651414692,
0.0466639176,
-0.0075613018,
-0.0311878417,
-0.0739528686,
-0.0328255519,
-0.0355035178,
0.0075686439,
0.0419280753,
-0.0801196396,
0.0184467789,
0.072490491,
0.0011312256,
-0.059634719,
-0.0125904884,
0.0192841031,
-0.019056553,
0.0689613894,
-0.0058712456,
0.0122745931,
0.0178943928,
-0.0035442177,
0.0079441788,
0.0310718883,
-0.0054060775,
0.0166895166,
0.0342210233,
-0.0053001256,
0.0057691331,
-0.0441384278,
-0.0694132373,
0.0493469499,
0.0295852348,
0.0161560811,
0.0335710123,
-0.0118757626,
-0.0048940079,
0.0269724447,
0.0024007077,
0.0110724922,
0.044622153,
0.0167046338,
0.0002179097,
0.0096657313,
-0.0271426179,
-0.0066166455,
-0.0194201972,
-0.0097585199,
-0.0057060379,
-0.0482027531,
-0.0688927099,
0.0498298369,
0.0007000387,
0.0093742516,
-0.0167437773,
0.0067519448,
-0.0579386689,
0.0423500352,
0.0024063173,
0.0424080156,
0.0588363968,
0.0971650779,
-0.0697568581,
-0.043679148,
-0.0522922762,
-0.0008621117,
0.0067383084,
0.0464016199,
-0.0443825573,
-0.0388543978,
-0.0045031547,
-0.0407260731,
-0.0110791894,
0.0073296493,
0.0111472951,
0.0264323168,
-0.062876299,
-0.0001717731,
-0.0215234887,
-0.0281917751,
0.0383458361,
-0.0166960116,
0.0384587944,
0.008759547,
-0.0092204977,
0.0605120957,
0.0301378891,
-0.0414616652,
0.0244921371,
0.0504526198,
0.0125849759,
-0.0044903196,
0.0434651673,
0.1163787842,
0.0107778152,
0.0459426641,
-0.0152007136,
-0.0259625837,
0.0010796665,
-0.0332701057,
-0.0466014557,
0.0271544363,
0.0045622606,
-0.0157263856,
-0.0243582688,
-0.0137546835,
0.0026951234,
-0.0302959494,
-0.0261904188,
-0.0259892736,
0.0012020019,
0.0156667158,
0.0207115524,
-0.0408027694,
0.0239919089,
0.0162546225,
-0.0325727798,
-0.0345635787,
0.0379601233,
-0.0135956481,
0.0372668505,
-0.0272834245,
-0.0194077007,
-0.0509947091,
-0.0478931107,
-0.0222219303,
-0.0134559507,
0.0353053249,
0.0556812137,
-0.0220007729,
-0.0007048907,
-0.0004608572,
0.0209760964,
0.0192288943,
-0.0133004878,
0.0128048398,
0.0599125214,
0.0094655566,
0.0197957549,
-0.0722312182,
-0.0191371124,
-0.0175309051,
0.0073291855,
0.0502658337,
-0.0318365395,
-0.0339955315,
-0.0020402735,
-0.0437108651,
0.0034891979,
0.0047256211,
0.0163433924,
0.006329638,
-0.0243335925,
0.0392962098,
0.0212392379,
-0.0010079363,
0.0097214412,
0.0610265769,
-0.0163231436,
-0.0604261495,
-0.0398535021,
-0.0186507665,
-0.0147628095,
0.0127752163,
-0.0279448759,
0.0370792449,
0.019989213,
-0.0230142456,
-0.0320680439,
-0.0182523262,
-0.0045297332,
0.025260251,
0.014986366,
-0.0060548629,
-0.0458444953,
-0.0175850503,
0.0406226106,
-0.0099879047,
-0.047081355,
0.0413951688,
-0.0240615923,
0.0315182842,
-0.0498328619,
0.019774003,
-0.0319763422,
0.0757230371,
-0.0110496534,
-0.0243937355,
-0.0256220251,
0.0315054134,
-0.021326948,
0.0283263754,
0.0633592531,
0.0150980344,
0.0196526404,
-0.0740092397,
0.0359810591,
-0.0329130627,
0.0438334048,
0.0462842062,
-0.0246428736,
-0.0085928086,
0.0248329751,
0.0025551124,
-0.0408567302,
-0.0146602616,
0.0056372751,
0.0105633084,
0.0932894722,
0.0024241225,
-0.0332560539,
-0.0127265118,
0.0164462272,
0.0158665292,
-0.0316814408,
-0.0404842049,
-0.0213900525,
0.006878309,
0.0833113641,
0.0156729557,
-0.0117530748,
-0.0314274877,
-0.0471667498,
-0.0239498243,
-0.0781204328,
-0.0124867326,
-0.0378073864,
0.0152102308,
-0.0282954443,
0.0144026978,
0.0961983427,
0.0359263122,
-0.1203582287,
-0.042684406,
-0.0532665811,
0.0045503033,
0.0341247879,
0.0348575674,
-0.0919027328,
0.0036520804,
-0.0138154095,
0.0052076853,
0.0041113044,
-0.0610973537,
0.0295764711,
-0.0253602825,
0.069494307,
-0.0227741115,
-0.0184073336,
0.041512087,
-0.0617160313,
0.0446270742,
-0.0089649456,
-0.0982485637,
0.0160519779,
0.0202282444,
-0.0061261263,
-0.0040158406,
-0.0422226265,
-0.0185066126,
0.0237447899,
-0.0404625945,
0.0341096744,
0.0140468627,
0.0237230361,
0.006868118,
0.0020581682,
0.0435604714,
0.0555465072,
-0.0017791416,
-0.0102234725,
0.0529812276,
0.0210736599,
0.0477826111,
0.0036590155,
0.0340744443,
-0.008932082,
-0.0206290036,
0.0614359342,
0.0771972761,
-0.0509770997,
0.0328575037,
-0.0303064641,
-0.0045384322,
-0.0234844591,
0.0142419701,
0.0062915157,
-0.016722247,
-0.0059482255,
0.0050592711,
0.0271830913,
0.005679897,
-0.0057914369,
-0.1016925201,
-0.0713222697,
0.0206811707,
-0.0944768041,
-0.0470986813,
0.0306796543,
-0.0230551548,
0.0645187646,
0.006830568,
0.0132517759,
-0.0405608565,
-0.0538417324,
0.0004410813,
-0.0103274779,
0.0362645313,
-0.0003016894,
-0.0472627506,
0.0428650603,
0.0380656384,
-0.0025244413,
-0.0353344716,
-0.0097072888,
-0.0489586592,
0.0084194439,
0.0461167432,
0.0263876896,
0.0220251065,
-0.0028250823,
-0.062935248,
-0.0539712645,
-0.0071269749,
-0.0334872752,
0.0095750885,
-0.0081993975,
0.0220940765,
-0.0540375896,
-0.0104096001,
-0.032026995,
0.0020814543,
-0.0052273958,
-0.0103680454,
-0.0617684312,
-0.093018204,
-0.0152365481,
0.0005881796,
0.0442716517,
-0.0119713983,
0.0412300453,
-0.0584921986,
0.0151813347,
-0.0340557583,
-0.0010370439,
-0.0045482642,
-0.007936853,
-0.026663376,
-0.0357343741,
-0.007901066,
0.0985780358,
-0.0425945185,
0.0348147973,
-0.0504857525,
0.0459730476,
0.029661689,
0.0371582136,
-0.0093294494,
0.0012471776,
-0.0042629112,
-0.0278525334,
-0.0113373986,
0.0224288218,
0.0138265211,
0.0497800745,
0.0155893546,
0.0183117818,
0.026711911,
0.0273361653,
-0.1051797941,
0.0189157557,
-0.0133437496,
0.0190939251,
0.0183730889,
0.0333180502,
0.0850689113,
-0.0546726398,
-0.0399633832,
-0.0459472798,
0.0691340938,
0.0061046379,
0.0250895731,
0.0146646304,
-0.0181887485,
-0.0054941233,
0.0275090002,
0.0609827973,
-0.040106263,
0.0507290959,
-0.0095331371,
-0.0528016426,
-0.0275502857,
-0.0305571854,
-0.0051675141,
0.0031174305,
-0.0205168854,
-0.0615809932,
-0.0428412519,
0.024032101,
0.053147506,
0.0170413256,
0.0157443061,
-0.0123009598,
-0.0228291191,
0.0360113978,
-0.0099742692,
0.0106396712,
-0.0569009148,
0.0521287099,
-0.0441560037,
-0.0460325703,
-0.0394365452,
-4.80928865e-33,
-0.0051545715,
-0.0435821488,
-0.0068083568,
0.0429424755,
-0.029410962,
0.0164685939,
-0.0485110991,
-0.0134578887,
0.0269799959,
0.0102909505,
-0.0432070717,
0.0365589745,
-0.0087360321,
-0.0443958864,
0.0909612328,
0.0495217033,
0.0652264282,
-0.0326439776,
-0.0177653339,
0.0165268499,
0.0219687652,
-0.0141970133,
0.0343796313,
-0.05708877,
0.0942223147,
0.0104780933,
-0.013623544,
0.0077668652,
-0.0301900487,
0.0338834077,
-0.0233863797,
-0.0171547066,
0.0183669273,
-0.0158542655,
-0.0122524891,
-0.028902363,
-0.0534332283,
0.0005025479,
-0.0084699523,
0.0070576537,
-0.0031468899,
-0.0036567887,
0.0252422113,
0.0026271725,
-0.039991051,
-0.0177821219,
0.0455766059,
0.0016876862,
-0.0425974727,
-0.0455230698,
-0.0372415632,
0.0430724025,
-0.0296753775,
0.0081175119,
-0.0089133298,
0.0193218123,
0.0282312017,
-0.0005575754,
-0.1077774242,
0.0228177067,
0.0014126813,
0.0227399338,
-0.0140423579,
-0.0393995158,
0.0212502703,
0.0327289887,
-0.0025940884,
0.0595484823,
-0.0137571031,
0.0248090569,
-0.0230457354,
0.0306116045,
0.0637103319,
0.0817493498,
-0.0237785317,
0.0015582183,
-0.0483905822,
0.066609174,
-0.0060245446,
0.0411661007,
0.0095997453,
0.0061906064,
0.049661953,
0.0100788912,
-0.0176808164,
-0.014443445,
-0.0108448658,
-0.0015505925,
-0.0241004303,
-0.0090512242,
-0.0043439413,
-0.017336268,
0.0214309432,
-0.021044001,
0.0011464364,
0.0053618364,
-0.0317284688,
0.0699766278,
0.0058442377,
-0.0661415607,
-0.0271248352,
0.0320925005,
-0.0010440233,
0.0262891483,
0.0233989283,
-0.0052511902,
0.0689062625,
-0.0035211924,
-0.0458962657,
0.0071332175,
-0.0047594612,
0.0055537615,
-0.0262065046,
0.0128291259,
-0.0042720726,
-0.0078296885,
0.0250568651,
0.0105919233,
0.0239897761,
0.057111688,
-0.0153015675,
0.0486398302,
0.0280482229,
-0.0011290041,
0.022847414,
0.0121255191,
-0.0007405542,
0.0190460943,
0.0168260392,
0.0287095476,
0.0225445386,
-0.0509185828,
2.413e-7,
0.0819731429,
0.0512809232,
0.0685222745,
-0.056842912,
0.0416808538,
0.0153548038,
-0.0397184342,
0.0326295346,
0.0487985872,
0.000109161,
0.044713296,
-0.0530192107,
0.0476772413,
0.0361403115,
-0.0508432053,
-0.0403226279,
-0.0648638755,
-0.0239623412,
-0.0427736752,
-0.0229690913,
0.0013341557,
-0.0253950488,
0.0159711801,
0.0111211473,
-0.0515092015,
0.0213773306,
0.052558504,
-0.0461885706,
-0.0057447804,
0.0264522042,
0.0749423802,
-0.0633578077,
-0.0144210467,
0.0085025644,
-0.0476425402,
-0.0055439901,
-0.030186804,
0.0547566935,
-0.0223936513,
0.0112495385,
0.0287464056,
-0.0310004894,
0.0155196441,
-0.0005043612,
0.0074360217,
-0.0121780364,
-0.0194686987,
-0.0059624445,
-0.0381072834,
-0.0019295429,
0.0490617938,
-0.0196540263,
0.0123048183,
0.0410686582,
-0.0244797431,
0.0151827633,
0.0049834177,
-0.0416452065,
-0.0132511724,
-0.0108955996,
-0.0227810722,
-0.0248491988,
-0.0007185782,
-0.0270468984,
-0.029930694,
-0.0395509228,
0.0422460511,
1.629892483e-34,
0.0745053515,
0.0037668503,
-0.0026204893,
0.0181446187,
0.0480287708,
-0.0357053578,
-0.0240260754,
0.0152132148,
0.0086954413,
-0.057526499,
-0.0241421759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02592v1
|
LOLAMEME: Logic, Language, Memory, Mechanistic Framework
| 2024-05-31T21:18:25 | 2024-05-31T21:18:25 |
Jay Desai, Xiaobo Guo, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The performance of Large Language Models has achieved superhuman breadth with
unprecedented depth. At the same time, the language models are mostly black box
models and the underlying mechanisms for performance have been evaluated using
synthetic or mechanistic schemes. We extend current mechanistic schemes to
incorporate Logic, memory, and nuances of Language such as latent structure.
The proposed framework is called LOLAMEME and we provide two instantiations of
LOLAMEME: LoLa and MeMe languages. We then consider two generative language
model architectures: transformer-based GPT-2 and convolution-based Hyena. We
propose the hybrid architecture T HEX and use LOLAMEME framework is used to
compare three architectures. T HEX outperforms GPT-2 and Hyena on select tasks.
|
[
0.0056042448,
0.0800180808,
-0.0183110163,
0.0361241363,
-0.0331997983,
0.0155882398,
0.0200133547,
-0.0169540513,
-0.0066219205,
-0.0490740798,
-0.0339400284,
-0.0723613203,
-0.0380673297,
0.0752186403,
0.0466208085,
-0.0686321408,
0.0243977252,
-0.0355043747,
-0.0197795518,
-0.032944195,
-0.0249138735,
-0.0012177528,
0.0150222359,
0.0296752863,
0.0140209105,
0.0054195542,
-0.0198858902,
-0.0057946476,
0.0170343202,
0.0069527724,
-0.0123650096,
0.0327684768,
0.0096111726,
0.0646764114,
0.0000021638,
-0.0091701429,
0.0282645412,
0.0042390325,
0.0146302506,
0.0222301912,
0.0878773257,
-0.0341084152,
-0.0541898832,
0.0011764934,
-0.0309226234,
-0.0758854151,
0.0632183626,
0.0287885871,
0.0181919318,
0.0723178536,
-0.0251794755,
-0.0851914808,
0.0653335303,
-0.0603914745,
0.0232109521,
-0.0394612961,
-0.0006977713,
-0.0082271276,
0.0231393129,
0.0229829885,
-0.0271088835,
0.0480067357,
0.0593831316,
0.0073815235,
-0.008851029,
0.0527996421,
-0.0260089468,
-0.012228094,
-0.0028657052,
0.041533187,
-0.0285626166,
-0.025157975,
0.002633106,
-0.0015096111,
-0.0234099124,
-0.037474554,
-0.0431087427,
0.0753752738,
0.0137305474,
0.0321945511,
0.0264708735,
0.0056408546,
0.0448614806,
-0.0315992758,
-0.0456554368,
0.0620763786,
0.0673026368,
0.0187464356,
-0.0529283509,
0.018228814,
-0.0022857615,
-0.0242847316,
-0.0218459703,
0.0189112946,
0.0038278778,
0.0069096424,
-0.0350452587,
-0.0274634343,
-0.0005505423,
-0.0885231346,
0.0154518792,
0.0309829898,
-0.0008609375,
0.0260130987,
-0.0688224286,
0.0665389448,
-0.060487777,
0.0195124168,
-0.0417059511,
-0.025957752,
-0.0150775872,
-0.0017943756,
-0.0416778177,
0.0139621682,
-0.0268382505,
-0.0487788208,
-0.0493466854,
0.0511767529,
0.0047475924,
-0.0317544825,
-0.0060430737,
-0.0203417204,
-0.0222265776,
-0.0002284988,
-0.0184256546,
-0.0029242751,
-0.015162576,
-0.0085730338,
0.0082898028,
-0.0672783405,
0.0053685866,
0.0301597919,
0.0031968143,
-0.0199880935,
0.003497707,
0.0844595879,
-0.0338148586,
-0.0285599492,
-0.0588617176,
0.0344420671,
0.0020916606,
-0.0895565972,
0.0354141593,
-0.0649470538,
0.0507197417,
0.0170663968,
0.0143254176,
-0.0106728384,
0.0037902589,
0.0027842561,
-0.0224006418,
0.0656662732,
0.0361011028,
-0.0072576692,
0.0144540388,
0.0175948795,
0.0295956396,
0.0716066062,
0.0343405567,
0.0480691269,
0.0073809302,
-0.0182934664,
-0.0107298112,
0.0338799097,
-0.0057702838,
-0.0110745709,
-0.035146594,
0.0084774988,
-0.013852587,
0.0139789563,
0.0464510471,
0.0773205087,
-0.050000038,
-0.008341766,
0.0517620742,
0.0153582413,
0.032972537,
0.0464817062,
0.0791168138,
-0.0195723586,
0.0209394693,
-0.0307385754,
-0.0492612198,
0.0423792675,
-0.023171287,
0.0047088228,
-0.0135625899,
0.0435008965,
-0.0375191718,
-0.0169662647,
-0.0138358837,
-0.0243852716,
0.0385955498,
-0.0256693903,
0.0727543682,
0.0085064434,
-0.0408738516,
0.0512889028,
-0.0058432133,
-0.0487181544,
-0.0397063009,
-0.0658276007,
0.0191143006,
0.0816899315,
0.0440229662,
0.0205465443,
-0.0179688856,
0.0257737748,
-0.0626190081,
0.0576949231,
0.009522384,
0.0224842764,
0.008427063,
-0.0476079397,
0.001137284,
-0.0388346799,
0.0070805498,
0.0487652794,
0.0303788017,
0.0151661625,
0.0297313463,
0.0153448377,
0.0247398391,
0.0174148027,
-0.0335265212,
-0.0058618886,
0.0143171642,
-0.0280289203,
0.0556226149,
-0.024445992,
-0.0075004883,
0.0042420058,
0.0461642891,
-0.049892582,
-0.0343705304,
0.0036308302,
-0.0686720684,
-0.0399237424,
0.0268056076,
0.0029231955,
0.030707702,
0.0372557417,
-0.0306670237,
-0.0593774766,
0.0676500723,
-0.0326431766,
0.0822273269,
-0.08166302,
0.0117883822,
0.0003250997,
0.0156267509,
-0.0072653694,
0.0693475679,
-0.0080054533,
-0.0044080396,
-0.0202711429,
0.0619453415,
0.0082624769,
-0.0139771383,
-0.0344019271,
0.0234539248,
0.0195448138,
0.0290651564,
-0.0003116152,
-0.0007367429,
0.0034827646,
-0.0574105978,
-0.0729254857,
0.0003592296,
-0.045298405,
0.0075400965,
0.0165288337,
0.0069624283,
0.0047264933,
0.0038633675,
-0.0472660102,
0.0676016882,
0.0091101807,
0.0256664287,
0.0074128299,
-0.0072485437,
-0.0199654214,
-0.014135086,
-0.0309147034,
0.0030551401,
0.0268326793,
-0.0208787806,
0.033133734,
-0.0240832064,
0.0006611435,
0.0027854093,
0.0382134169,
-0.0224697292,
-0.0466897227,
0.0195275862,
-0.0547455475,
0.1013367176,
0.0425256193,
-0.0005841493,
0.0548163392,
0.0428399146,
-0.0054659783,
0.0167660657,
0.0216792636,
-0.0273317359,
0.0046609924,
-0.0349675789,
-0.035117846,
-0.0364310853,
0.0819001421,
-0.006542685,
-0.0014304523,
-0.074635841,
0.0213812552,
-0.0028811579,
-0.0059649111,
0.0425169989,
0.012447536,
-0.0102728382,
0.0159544665,
-0.02810397,
-0.0417422093,
0.0292671379,
-0.0432594866,
-0.0480263717,
-0.0155680524,
-0.0060790717,
-0.0327073187,
0.0964507312,
0.0760416314,
0.0081033921,
-0.002251785,
-0.0069346465,
-0.0292316955,
0.0205775443,
0.007342313,
-0.0237853304,
0.0411018506,
-0.0335709937,
0.0132423714,
-0.0351870842,
-0.0245018639,
-0.0313365646,
0.0360032432,
-0.0089882612,
0.0330962911,
0.0251179598,
-0.0546125025,
-0.040269088,
0.0368994288,
-0.0117122792,
0.0599318407,
-0.0050143353,
-0.0051206807,
-0.025036158,
0.0406791456,
0.0485570952,
-0.0009801346,
0.0109063005,
-0.0185571201,
0.0262283124,
0.0311195906,
0.0191777796,
0.0053541288,
-0.0600961223,
-0.0005464579,
0.0586955212,
0.0160181802,
-0.0322418362,
-0.0126940478,
0.0287807975,
-0.0708578229,
-0.0275315456,
0.1052751392,
0.0033511959,
-0.0086729871,
-0.0049680891,
0.0262875929,
0.0416537188,
0.016264962,
0.0452473462,
-0.0505270995,
-0.0126041211,
-0.0158387199,
0.0014466523,
0.0017921802,
0.0068581998,
0.0221392848,
-0.095916912,
0.0601263829,
-0.0001475591,
-0.0505244285,
-0.0026488956,
-0.01238898,
-0.0313803218,
-0.0285592433,
0.0142831095,
0.0303357746,
-0.0178720038,
-0.0040508206,
-0.0353944339,
-0.0101148458,
-0.0381787196,
0.0147934472,
-0.0038089559,
0.040366102,
0.0635075271,
-0.0010456708,
-0.0203972012,
-0.0531560555,
0.0263058376,
0.0018321129,
-0.0080220718,
-0.015214826,
0.0189293139,
0.034946695,
-0.0407299325,
-0.0238437094,
0.0146490699,
-0.0289224461,
-0.0152927525,
-0.0511585623,
0.0638271049,
-0.0287839379,
-0.0398296267,
-0.0310185514,
-0.0084516862,
-0.0298770703,
0.0629769266,
0.0124229314,
-0.0409440137,
-0.0760109127,
-0.0365722142,
-0.0210302062,
-0.0420871191,
-0.0460681431,
-0.0185907725,
0.0240248181,
-0.0695463344,
-0.0312515236,
-0.0169350803,
0.0007263643,
0.0351577625,
-0.0275962576,
-0.0259330664,
0.0086832754,
-0.0251914691,
-0.0571401976,
-0.019956721,
-0.0172421839,
0.0039708512,
-0.0454423837,
-0.0501727536,
0.048073452,
-0.0134907253,
-0.0105243837,
0.0468943268,
-0.0892606452,
-0.0622234866,
0.0054533971,
0.0734439865,
0.0210793912,
0.0178936236,
-0.019916594,
0.0140349492,
0.0399161577,
-0.0105338627,
-0.0456281155,
0.024734715,
0.0151301054,
-0.0263878983,
0.0043659741,
0.0466310196,
-0.0114178453,
0.0416296534,
0.0107864328,
0.0452503674,
-0.0199441407,
-0.0068979082,
0.0133857522,
-0.0334038176,
0.0152097251,
-0.0149132395,
0.0218231976,
-0.0223697145,
0.0125803063,
-0.0633673146,
0.0284962859,
-0.0825466812,
0.0061193332,
0.0582088679,
0.0197601318,
-0.0276849046,
-0.0179304089,
0.0073637418,
0.0513193868,
-0.0089917919,
0.0361159332,
0.0229569357,
0.0403127223,
0.0365707837,
0.0030825702,
0.006633427,
-0.0124102393,
-0.0078073079,
0.0339411534,
-0.0543910749,
0.0456113778,
0.0054629953,
-0.0117821191,
-0.0426641293,
0.0335956365,
-0.0514732711,
-0.03096864,
-0.020046737,
0.0458059646,
0.0388350226,
-0.0063854875,
0.0711718127,
-0.0657080188,
-0.0252515823,
-0.0271868464,
0.0316427834,
0.0150403772,
-0.0382018723,
0.008077316,
0.0115379263,
-0.0217543393,
-0.0487411208,
0.0593879782,
0.0243477579,
0.0138131287,
0.0067507983,
0.0170929823,
-0.0276719332,
-0.025983803,
-0.0005963451,
-0.0131389722,
-0.0024345769,
-0.0070427875,
-0.0463263728,
-0.0670590177,
-0.0123085734,
0.0248771179,
0.0078681391,
-0.0251490846,
0.0128545212,
0.0720872581,
0.0093593206,
-0.0307752285,
-0.0354973599,
0.0017380002,
0.0043976428,
-0.0055020056,
-0.0104786912,
-6.937179177e-33,
-0.0457137376,
0.0054056281,
0.0251549762,
-0.016661929,
-0.0301457178,
0.0078814952,
-0.0428969488,
0.0031039983,
-0.0016157208,
-0.0031536459,
0.0043501034,
0.0058361213,
0.0031383494,
0.0486069247,
-0.0060373265,
0.047619544,
0.0485282429,
-0.0165630877,
-0.012614564,
0.0426065959,
0.0284400079,
0.0109907957,
0.0188600142,
-0.0387078933,
-0.0377662443,
0.0068974807,
0.0106814988,
-0.001673553,
-0.0303259138,
0.041987963,
-0.0356574357,
0.0309801325,
0.0082073137,
-0.0581768751,
-0.0071344594,
0.0219691098,
-0.0943468884,
-0.0103278775,
0.0121322135,
0.0221470222,
-0.0295265839,
-0.040734984,
0.0277382992,
-0.0242340751,
-0.0060184491,
-0.023705611,
-0.0093881311,
-0.0286590159,
-0.0031409871,
-0.0275231861,
-0.1076140702,
0.0265810415,
0.0461887978,
0.0235258397,
0.0409659557,
-0.0423563048,
-0.0186596345,
0.0126758935,
-0.0355437063,
0.0017779641,
0.0116051212,
0.0429000482,
0.0495219603,
0.0460199863,
0.0186010823,
0.0340860076,
0.0529281273,
0.0003786131,
-0.0543387048,
0.0369656496,
0.0463687778,
0.0313531421,
0.0645863712,
-0.0050598755,
0.0254380759,
-0.0064292606,
-0.0780034959,
-0.0352675319,
0.0352820009,
0.0232901443,
0.0148156425,
0.0525049195,
0.0047699469,
0.0013130559,
-0.0236999281,
0.0133227697,
-0.0187556464,
-0.0467035659,
0.0263532065,
0.0321107656,
-0.0112313973,
-0.0325753242,
0.0205684509,
-0.0297235306,
0.0182030108,
-0.0048584612,
-0.0267692134,
0.0227405969,
0.0018508981,
0.0625271574,
-0.0182451326,
-0.0438528843,
0.0415069275,
0.0224966835,
-0.0229601059,
-0.0056017418,
0.0001777533,
0.0734605566,
-0.0859956369,
-0.0010869966,
-0.0600928739,
0.0264612064,
0.0048986194,
0.0398300141,
0.0105778659,
0.0035887389,
0.0044177696,
0.0165695716,
-0.0222894121,
-0.0081873862,
-0.0242850911,
0.0233177431,
0.0201154277,
0.0381176099,
-0.0338581763,
0.0229765251,
-0.0643637776,
0.0275629777,
0.0385364294,
-0.0662906617,
-0.0169228148,
0.0373383835,
2.854e-7,
0.043886926,
0.0118202325,
0.0409845002,
0.0499881729,
0.0597248673,
0.0105309766,
0.0026582812,
0.0225991681,
-0.0187105648,
0.019390326,
0.0046982006,
0.0515568741,
0.0497331731,
0.0263342429,
-0.0585980229,
0.0332189538,
-0.0190016162,
-0.0003488454,
-0.0169632528,
-0.0093092248,
0.0449664816,
0.1323708892,
0.0095044477,
-0.0208822452,
0.0261306483,
-0.0380522944,
0.0785559565,
-0.006367364,
0.0136014214,
0.0256061498,
-0.0286284145,
0.0320802592,
-0.0280106645,
-0.0056432942,
-0.0092946785,
-0.0071425699,
-0.0064349459,
0.0803549886,
-0.0283344947,
-0.0333321914,
0.0530143082,
-0.0277555883,
-0.0242996644,
-0.0790823326,
0.0718117878,
-0.0396064036,
-0.0388380513,
-0.0177920498,
-0.0245261546,
0.0302267037,
-0.0179692674,
-0.0214280169,
-0.0220259205,
0.0041528218,
0.0303577147,
-0.0265765768,
0.0098345317,
-0.0682699606,
-0.0045603681,
0.0026071554,
-0.0453245081,
-0.0297660045,
-0.0909476876,
-0.0115376748,
0.0595335923,
0.0015093014,
-0.0328663252,
2.861935688e-34,
0.0522790775,
-0.0008463696,
-0.0010703424,
0.0206315108,
0.0006085895,
-0.0069536683,
0.0058099623,
0.007722083,
-0.0130473431,
-0.0513117164,
-0.0456539579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04368v1
|
SocialNLP Fake-EmoReact 2021 Challenge Overview: Predicting Fake Tweets from Their Replies and GIFs
| 2024-05-31T21:14:11 | 2024-05-31T21:14:11 |
Chien-Kun Huang, Yi-Ting Chang, Lun-Wei Ku, Cheng-Te Li, Hong-Han Shuai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
This paper provides an overview of the Fake-EmoReact 2021 Challenge, held at
the 9th SocialNLP Workshop, in conjunction with NAACL 2021. The challenge
requires predicting the authenticity of tweets using reply context and
augmented GIF categories from EmotionGIF dataset. We offer the Fake-EmoReact
dataset with more than 453k as the experimental materials, where every tweet is
labeled with authenticity. Twenty-four teams registered to participate in this
challenge, and 5 submitted their results successfully in the evaluation phase.
The best team achieves 93.9 on Fake-EmoReact 2021 dataset using F1 score. In
addition, we show the definition of share task, data collection, and the teams'
performance that joined this challenge and their approaches.
|
[
0.0908288434,
0.0846518651,
0.004180932,
0.0696051419,
-0.0379703604,
0.0248476434,
0.0241695438,
0.0527717508,
0.0201789346,
-0.0229371544,
-0.0046405545,
-0.0016383491,
-0.019367395,
0.0746031776,
0.0517906174,
-0.0530029275,
0.0124820359,
0.0402712971,
0.0329384655,
-0.018301392,
0.0606935807,
0.0245105065,
-0.0303602405,
0.0365286544,
-0.056899406,
-0.0050299368,
0.0085565327,
0.0468165278,
0.0561572164,
-0.0208784863,
0.0614493042,
0.0591954701,
-0.0056050927,
0.0619567037,
0.0000020582,
-0.0242963433,
-0.0401397571,
-0.0130520873,
-0.0308944061,
-0.0173544213,
0.0708165765,
-0.0123363407,
-0.0028506317,
0.0156481266,
-0.0339250676,
-0.0037573243,
0.043247059,
0.0579450093,
0.0927133709,
0.0958651304,
-0.0442914404,
0.008825466,
-0.0053115715,
0.0017456393,
0.0273193419,
0.0076038591,
0.001262628,
-0.0051291464,
0.0271355733,
0.0029053378,
0.0155516602,
0.0238595977,
0.0104941539,
-0.0017137774,
0.0207182318,
0.0012476646,
-0.0400852822,
-0.0357952192,
0.0271950439,
0.0260388218,
-0.0362760909,
-0.0269445591,
0.0211507808,
-0.0073624752,
-0.0038920478,
0.0394698605,
0.0057000257,
0.0105906809,
0.0014129323,
0.0138367033,
-0.0245797504,
0.0752011314,
0.0176252462,
0.0630883351,
0.0371463448,
-0.0229517706,
-0.0000890724,
-0.0094223525,
-0.0162500981,
0.0025788841,
-0.0457438566,
-0.069108963,
0.0271919649,
0.0000508303,
0.0164447296,
-0.0204981212,
-0.0492862836,
-0.0416957624,
0.0171027333,
-0.0464530364,
0.0043627871,
-0.0015383248,
0.0084616197,
0.0274797939,
-0.0080431569,
0.0571049713,
-0.0266501009,
-0.0039979126,
-0.0172061548,
-0.0369532593,
-0.0330442749,
0.0312942527,
0.0135892322,
0.0015514767,
-0.0360079594,
0.0162358396,
-0.0913870558,
-0.0178781338,
-0.0773103461,
0.0357883424,
-0.0107237771,
0.0345712043,
-0.0243470017,
-0.0232034288,
-0.0254885834,
-0.0159614254,
-0.0076031908,
-0.0034691512,
-0.0390720628,
-0.0319865979,
0.0113715203,
0.0213140324,
0.0430453308,
-0.0259230286,
0.0509979911,
-0.0444856472,
0.0121612921,
-0.0310038738,
-0.0413286649,
-0.0573515333,
-0.0125774341,
-0.0492662154,
0.0033817932,
-0.0803667605,
0.0183220878,
-0.0356458463,
-0.0077147661,
0.0013324097,
-0.0164289121,
0.0255272109,
-0.026426604,
0.0286906511,
-0.0468601733,
0.0028736014,
0.0236192383,
0.0378316343,
-0.0203836486,
0.037175931,
-0.0165869817,
0.1006088853,
0.0681058541,
0.0106415153,
0.0607689172,
0.0406364985,
0.0679984465,
0.0241937861,
0.0252602175,
-0.0148354331,
-0.023326518,
-0.0029764995,
-0.0036664375,
0.0110790934,
-0.0028711595,
-0.0530206747,
0.0456762351,
0.0284718741,
0.0194341335,
-0.0246585459,
-0.0046021021,
0.0323664136,
0.0122893369,
-0.0319519043,
-0.0276668295,
0.0397519954,
-0.0350325182,
-0.0119531984,
0.0208336823,
0.0191084854,
-0.0226902254,
0.0132208718,
0.0241034478,
-0.0314693153,
-0.0052464213,
-0.0040051695,
-0.0196526535,
0.011141479,
-0.0412568077,
-0.0304586086,
0.0031527835,
-0.0080821645,
-0.0256594531,
-0.050737571,
0.0319172665,
0.0214659125,
0.014530981,
0.0270982552,
0.0095201125,
-0.0403670184,
0.0067153201,
0.0465322547,
-0.0482226461,
-0.0293445308,
-0.0082047144,
-0.0099434145,
-0.0307978727,
-0.0427682586,
-0.041452229,
-0.0295781754,
0.0429888554,
0.0609200858,
0.0088965613,
0.0043691751,
-0.0129376659,
-0.0291513354,
-0.0052506449,
0.0131338155,
0.0015173198,
0.0318623669,
0.0434108004,
0.0478406735,
-0.014992835,
-0.033678446,
0.0099346917,
0.0074275122,
-0.0195353851,
0.0086624324,
-0.0003001096,
-0.0384449922,
0.0310972072,
-0.0612743162,
-0.0389523208,
0.0869423449,
-0.0315095335,
0.0171991736,
0.0646957532,
0.0097509418,
0.0061053443,
-0.05280165,
-0.0276121665,
-0.0392406173,
0.0324042328,
0.0600108169,
0.0305593871,
-0.0251408853,
0.0142162694,
0.0006167,
-0.0060888827,
0.021771064,
0.0071382923,
-0.0056667621,
0.00445425,
-0.013853942,
0.0036004989,
0.0314648561,
0.0048454469,
-0.0721835792,
-0.0306933876,
-0.0933123231,
-0.018154081,
-0.0319419391,
-0.0145127149,
0.0277460199,
-0.0247618556,
-0.0154390549,
0.0142871132,
-0.0413589329,
0.0036846476,
0.0160195269,
0.0020758975,
0.0165208969,
-0.0358711071,
0.0061817761,
-0.0162664708,
0.0259799864,
-0.0033655982,
0.0452631786,
0.0124081187,
-0.03141094,
0.0013645511,
-0.0119539145,
-0.0107591972,
0.0306198578,
0.020753257,
-0.0226478819,
-0.0068295072,
-0.0022578391,
-0.0218619872,
0.0014723389,
0.0624847785,
0.0412389785,
-0.0565567948,
0.0148953879,
-0.0419051684,
-0.0239100587,
-0.0203031804,
0.0233842358,
-0.0015275587,
-0.0832089037,
-0.0066726236,
0.0288151652,
-0.014432502,
0.0038144318,
-0.0109883891,
0.0452449322,
-0.0085028773,
-0.0385662317,
0.0222377703,
-0.0043257121,
-0.0051180404,
-0.0583037287,
-0.0256391484,
-0.0506394617,
0.0593218654,
-0.0072341296,
-0.0027199718,
-0.0403090082,
-0.0421840809,
0.0282292627,
0.0629670545,
0.0113425739,
0.0238699429,
0.0385225303,
0.0394541211,
0.0354749151,
-0.0488238633,
0.024559956,
-0.0269454438,
-0.0418943614,
0.029932959,
0.0255237147,
0.0071984171,
-0.0090665724,
-0.0455140956,
-0.0917740315,
-0.035501726,
-0.0478362776,
-0.0338049121,
-0.0686308891,
-0.0325223729,
-0.0415937491,
0.0062717148,
-0.0123670232,
-0.0295325983,
-0.0128972465,
0.0199412163,
0.0552053414,
0.0780980438,
0.0023655549,
-0.0009153393,
-0.0307536274,
-0.0245238282,
0.0956089124,
0.0425541326,
-0.0080611194,
-0.0422363654,
-0.0325726867,
-0.0035827546,
0.0097934427,
0.0479931049,
-0.0464976393,
0.0332043357,
0.0150831332,
0.0337178968,
0.0979602262,
-0.0044536847,
-0.0129255988,
0.0246947166,
0.0526869558,
0.0096255541,
0.0022305662,
-0.0061254585,
-0.0647026077,
-0.0337511487,
-0.0220970772,
0.0091123711,
-0.0850718096,
-0.0349825397,
-0.0286751632,
-0.1143232659,
0.059087202,
-0.0093470085,
0.02887097,
-0.0599776655,
-0.0202303827,
-0.0258524921,
0.0122484481,
0.0027023877,
-0.0460359789,
0.0333859846,
0.0292326361,
-0.0016575401,
0.0136557342,
-0.0428794958,
0.0329825096,
-0.0467065908,
0.0994921178,
-0.0477351286,
0.0261821374,
-0.0192140751,
-0.0745147914,
-0.0119520174,
-0.0170341581,
-0.0344338082,
-0.0145667735,
0.0849434361,
-0.0271361005,
-0.0218696799,
-0.0104146199,
0.0422622636,
-0.0326096788,
-0.0425072759,
-0.0224891491,
0.0488067344,
-0.0085977567,
-0.0324207209,
-0.0315684155,
0.0138025219,
0.039082516,
0.0486570969,
0.0197165292,
-0.0385227352,
0.02133568,
0.0255396217,
0.0270684082,
-0.0371258706,
-0.0249224696,
0.0028171164,
0.0163231995,
-0.025942063,
-0.0546776056,
-0.0180593915,
0.0056491084,
0.0281022564,
-0.0570441857,
-0.0511396527,
-0.0405532792,
-0.024224231,
-0.0509806611,
0.0439529754,
-0.028356364,
0.0902804211,
-0.0041843345,
0.0166402329,
-0.0022960855,
-0.0188319143,
-0.005957698,
0.0125572877,
-0.0593759529,
-0.0211566743,
-0.0011791243,
0.0405075401,
0.012960773,
0.0348351821,
0.014630734,
-0.0410048217,
0.0490169413,
0.0311339721,
-0.0059734564,
0.0344579145,
0.0274763964,
0.011858766,
-0.0041900822,
0.001777379,
-0.013048471,
0.0199037977,
0.049796775,
-0.0156487729,
-0.0076601496,
0.0128667802,
-0.0204321835,
0.0546078421,
0.0141086644,
-0.0024599347,
-0.0236261506,
-0.0315161049,
-0.0281254593,
0.0053359,
-0.0003550487,
-0.0412502103,
0.0010461299,
0.015215382,
0.0124243759,
0.0039829216,
-0.0097891791,
-0.0403667428,
-0.0118174469,
-0.0155222807,
-0.0103391791,
0.0276653543,
0.0540836789,
-0.034368664,
0.0247770492,
-0.0091033392,
0.0304853134,
0.0295046475,
0.0581687726,
-0.0029285357,
0.0142120179,
0.0210448131,
-0.0458988585,
0.0034321337,
0.0356152989,
-0.00060842,
0.0517259128,
-0.0503358282,
0.0313628986,
0.0490505099,
-0.0217461977,
0.0339964554,
-0.0442814305,
0.0246616509,
-0.0133111477,
-0.0271495283,
-0.0433939695,
-0.0358964168,
-0.0236374829,
-0.001287999,
-0.0256877244,
0.0753437802,
0.0405238047,
-0.0124919005,
0.0134259081,
0.0346089974,
-0.0230386946,
-0.0146442661,
0.0213695057,
0.0075645908,
0.0011870296,
-0.0160203986,
0.0195661113,
-0.0319653898,
-0.0546876155,
0.0540367216,
-0.0409677476,
-0.0068734912,
0.0784883201,
0.0043214695,
0.0303324088,
-0.0001278288,
0.0562966242,
-0.0398336947,
-0.0161231998,
0.022212306,
-0.0432011671,
0.0184771325,
-6.783893244e-33,
0.104567714,
-0.0507236533,
-0.0336233601,
-0.0205630828,
-0.0000487599,
0.0677102357,
0.0202913433,
-0.0241387021,
0.0051676463,
0.0277996268,
-0.0032296288,
0.0308414474,
0.0003875427,
0.0397632122,
-0.0797444209,
-0.01356172,
0.0171677303,
-0.0138440477,
-0.012977547,
0.0494872294,
0.0570955575,
-0.0061665485,
0.0493535213,
-0.1519386768,
0.015314403,
-0.0434202291,
-0.0538728163,
0.007494899,
0.049895145,
0.0395838991,
-0.0519991294,
0.047709655,
0.0202774927,
-0.020142043,
-0.0076733101,
-0.0353877656,
0.0114139151,
-0.0175534859,
-0.0322979391,
-0.0148302568,
-0.0487686731,
-0.0169420037,
0.0373418108,
-0.016148096,
-0.0537277982,
-0.0251630191,
-0.0007612768,
0.0095609482,
0.0562840961,
-0.0159310941,
-0.0246962532,
0.0303176623,
-0.0076419525,
-0.0171096213,
0.0361983329,
0.0542018265,
0.0464669503,
0.0156350583,
-0.0650042072,
0.0311140325,
-0.0703810081,
-0.0359506197,
0.0303367674,
-0.0661884397,
-0.0190357789,
0.0458985865,
0.0268612206,
0.0057415427,
-0.006344738,
-0.0015840775,
-0.0132900449,
0.0620653778,
0.0932973102,
0.1041276455,
0.0362578705,
-0.0610107295,
-0.0279299729,
0.0533242784,
0.0601476468,
-0.0135070877,
0.0014830867,
-0.0214657802,
-0.0270184427,
0.0233932436,
-0.0023511646,
-0.0078205252,
-0.0430566408,
-0.0139712831,
-0.0138326772,
0.0001602483,
-0.0435279459,
0.0337229893,
0.0330877118,
-0.0654329136,
0.0001776648,
0.0006763429,
-0.0270919167,
0.0567584336,
0.0382167883,
0.0460010096,
0.0006571502,
-0.0064815334,
0.0481137745,
0.0267461985,
0.0315952711,
-0.0131952092,
0.0221026111,
0.0454276763,
-0.0463425256,
-0.0087221321,
-0.0078274319,
0.04989025,
-0.0450385474,
-0.0456391908,
-0.0322703309,
0.0035123907,
-0.0152566396,
-0.0027792635,
0.0070404243,
0.0504148155,
0.0076411911,
0.032122381,
-0.0346138068,
0.0090531446,
0.0053972136,
-0.007016371,
-0.0164218098,
-0.0391866527,
-0.0075269737,
-0.037658345,
0.0222768523,
-0.0350000896,
2.961e-7,
-0.0465865768,
0.021747442,
-0.0077742799,
-0.0317119546,
-0.0008902714,
0.0790010542,
0.0113041559,
0.0282697286,
-0.0145654129,
-0.0807676241,
-0.0158607122,
-0.0020507427,
0.0416669212,
0.0200049039,
-0.0407182314,
0.004891858,
-0.0447428785,
-0.029464826,
-0.0486822613,
0.0225121025,
0.0333335139,
0.0732944384,
0.0937674269,
-0.0579111353,
0.0305419695,
-0.0514633581,
0.0202599801,
0.0183621589,
-0.0332194194,
0.0071290187,
0.0574051291,
-0.03911319,
0.0390310809,
0.0011784283,
-0.0298847649,
-0.0099668428,
0.0085026743,
0.0149669731,
0.0202475023,
-0.0158641599,
-0.0291767679,
-0.0086023659,
0.0045452458,
-0.0820135549,
0.0375511907,
-0.0261470173,
-0.0462838113,
-0.0372714251,
-0.0524815731,
0.0125735514,
0.0531056933,
-0.0101123173,
-0.0454531908,
0.0625236183,
0.0340409391,
-0.0059460648,
-0.0564649105,
-0.0685116202,
0.005649948,
-0.0353670344,
-0.0226822961,
0.0050726705,
-0.0173689965,
-0.0021469668,
0.0719006434,
0.0014986669,
0.0070205885,
2.500140568e-34,
0.0153173208,
-0.0313780978,
0.0122622913,
-0.019637363,
-0.0078064483,
0.0122101335,
-0.0250612125,
0.0191088114,
0.0034268962,
0.0002329506,
0.011913023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00179v1
|
Long-Span Question-Answering: Automatic Question Generation and QA-System Ranking via Side-by-Side Evaluation
| 2024-05-31T20:15:10 | 2024-05-31T20:15:10 |
Bernd Bohnet, Kevin Swersky, Rosanne Liu, Pranjal Awasthi, Azade Nova, Javier Snaider, Hanie Sedghi, Aaron T Parisi, Michael Collins, Angeliki Lazaridou, Orhan Firat, Noah Fiedel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore the use of long-context capabilities in large language models to
create synthetic reading comprehension data from entire books. Previous efforts
to construct such datasets relied on crowd-sourcing, but the emergence of
transformers with a context size of 1 million or more tokens now enables
entirely automatic approaches. Our objective is to test the capabilities of
LLMs to analyze, understand, and reason over problems that require a detailed
comprehension of long spans of text, such as questions involving character
arcs, broader themes, or the consequences of early actions later in the story.
We propose a holistic pipeline for automatic data generation including question
generation, answering, and model scoring using an ``Evaluator''. We find that a
relative approach, comparing answers between models in a pairwise fashion and
ranking with a Bradley-Terry model, provides a more consistent and
differentiating scoring mechanism than an absolute scorer that rates answers
individually. We also show that LLMs from different model families produce
moderate agreement in their ratings. We ground our approach using the manually
curated NarrativeQA dataset, where our evaluator shows excellent agreement with
human judgement and even finds errors in the dataset. Using our automatic
evaluation approach, we show that using an entire book as context produces
superior reading comprehension performance compared to baseline no-context
(parametric knowledge only) and retrieval-based approaches.
|
[
0.0237349067,
0.0317043774,
-0.0156835411,
0.0325599946,
-0.0191725995,
0.0180256534,
0.0230957884,
-0.033754129,
-0.0102737928,
-0.0286468677,
-0.0071591781,
-0.0339585952,
-0.0212940909,
0.0499292724,
0.0331966802,
-0.0131174084,
-0.0085622156,
-0.0198234543,
0.0142651992,
0.0038883814,
-0.0018433037,
0.0286431238,
0.0123698572,
0.0229473766,
0.0358688682,
-0.0391756259,
-0.02299539,
-0.0162817501,
0.0411336347,
-0.0368894674,
0.0126017509,
0.0091336174,
0.0321555994,
0.0008748827,
0.0000019388,
-0.0589541271,
-0.0115603963,
0.0079922965,
-0.0369593799,
0.0041783615,
0.012809406,
0.0472572483,
0.0428568572,
0.0016670314,
-0.04009635,
0.0280630868,
-0.0090409778,
0.0139816571,
0.0751027539,
0.0356343053,
0.009010314,
-0.0342449769,
0.0185463913,
0.0010415952,
0.0455377288,
-0.0626437217,
-0.0046560629,
0.0495413318,
0.0660885572,
0.0296297558,
-0.0247191042,
0.0327195898,
0.0454037562,
-0.0181470737,
0.0401161015,
0.0262882374,
0.0057018138,
0.0340998173,
0.0007948859,
0.1070534512,
0.0446039699,
-0.0195924845,
-0.0038862696,
0.0177739896,
0.0041145626,
0.0234971121,
-0.0509211831,
0.0351402275,
-0.0192248486,
-0.0183676332,
0.0215457045,
0.0101145878,
0.0172647387,
0.0007841578,
-0.0122556062,
0.036221467,
0.0211488083,
-0.0217650086,
-0.0370770134,
-0.0027476393,
-0.0368669704,
-0.0623925216,
0.0095114484,
0.0666412711,
-0.039621897,
0.0182772335,
-0.0258463491,
0.0173459277,
0.0110885305,
-0.0048477496,
0.0074467352,
0.0246243197,
0.0012037295,
0.0437044427,
-0.0185003169,
0.0470808148,
0.0075400942,
-0.0014654929,
-0.0802767798,
0.0017755933,
-0.0252223816,
-0.0337651484,
-0.0325800739,
0.0199706499,
-0.0595159195,
-0.0101178493,
-0.0308427084,
0.0123032965,
0.0231458936,
-0.005783407,
0.0051920381,
0.0437013544,
-0.0237919651,
-0.0028767819,
-0.0524659753,
0.0076562767,
-0.088492617,
0.0097674355,
0.0030566116,
-0.0248974152,
-0.005414031,
-0.0108447894,
0.0191955622,
-0.0299071707,
0.0238330159,
0.0731741711,
-0.0165886208,
-0.0101888264,
-0.0259146672,
-0.0524704866,
-0.0098863551,
-0.0544844158,
-0.0251797959,
-0.0555972271,
0.0323400646,
0.0414554439,
0.0097737964,
0.0173021648,
0.0081619769,
0.0442082025,
0.0141003737,
0.0512615927,
0.0244767293,
0.0110639799,
0.0432253554,
0.0148239797,
0.0070583429,
0.0404966027,
0.0542973764,
-0.0018097627,
0.0566227511,
0.0182449035,
0.0281935856,
0.0223990679,
0.0114106918,
0.0050217132,
0.0049516074,
0.0514776707,
-0.0015006851,
0.0267640166,
0.0041691219,
0.0420245565,
-0.0234527756,
-0.0193868186,
0.0415502526,
0.0521102548,
0.0264274552,
0.041285906,
0.0808470473,
-0.0055186837,
0.022612717,
0.0177405272,
-0.0009007836,
0.0325221531,
-0.0079416176,
0.0060908832,
0.0007862336,
0.0152939837,
-0.0021544064,
-0.0327980407,
0.0115540018,
0.0349716879,
-0.0169701129,
0.0309747253,
0.0133649642,
0.0211015139,
-0.0459050909,
0.0262843091,
-0.0200746115,
-0.0713222921,
0.0565072931,
-0.0290614031,
0.0575134903,
0.0708611831,
0.0741736591,
-0.0467429161,
-0.0314687602,
-0.0119985063,
0.0095757525,
0.0103758723,
-0.0065152138,
-0.0560227633,
0.0109730028,
-0.0372437648,
0.0074815392,
-0.0352604166,
-0.0223297793,
0.0123483911,
-0.0062238625,
0.0077985446,
0.0150045725,
-0.0777433738,
-0.0513839684,
0.0386094712,
-0.0797713175,
-0.0471049175,
-0.0138788316,
0.0000953302,
-0.0177357532,
0.0247064903,
-0.0006379714,
0.0118755307,
0.0260427743,
-0.0509592257,
-0.0150924046,
0.0231303796,
-0.0564697497,
-0.0243042707,
0.0370346159,
-0.0551957339,
-0.0110669108,
0.0364122503,
0.0068224221,
-0.0435450226,
-0.0222227015,
-0.0427452587,
-0.0099706445,
-0.0402247459,
-0.0028373322,
0.0112563027,
-0.0159087833,
-0.0742831528,
0.087216191,
0.0232459959,
0.0397474542,
0.0185593236,
0.0093117505,
0.0128862755,
-0.0361901559,
-0.023476284,
-0.0141603099,
0.0130429296,
-0.0048115421,
0.0338077322,
-0.004337118,
-0.0784012377,
-0.0276888497,
-0.0866838098,
0.0373294465,
-0.03088383,
0.0153873172,
0.0541271344,
-0.0005316022,
-0.0068283123,
0.0085057337,
-0.0839795619,
-0.0253461692,
0.0290129706,
-0.0117910998,
0.0550692193,
0.0467915721,
0.0102806631,
-0.0220854115,
-0.0076688901,
-0.0337864719,
0.0669042766,
0.0536348857,
0.0696601272,
-0.0613666102,
0.0059201596,
-0.0259875897,
-0.0118497899,
-0.0195866711,
-0.0301065631,
0.0192345809,
-0.0144420341,
0.0470124967,
0.0535532273,
0.0265924018,
-0.000673094,
0.0375372134,
-0.0312841162,
-0.0265190862,
0.024729915,
-0.0058978079,
-0.0175362453,
-0.0186219215,
-0.0423520431,
-0.0062174979,
0.0373487808,
-0.0036919597,
-0.0196064617,
-0.0366716832,
0.042329561,
-0.0152600519,
-0.0355921835,
-0.066547215,
-0.0178049654,
-0.0134876547,
0.0682506859,
-0.0185329579,
-0.0030621081,
0.0792705938,
-0.0165705215,
-0.0151816458,
-0.0456962623,
0.0301432367,
-0.0771293417,
0.0774575695,
0.0046740873,
0.0195363704,
-0.0593685955,
-0.0139550567,
-0.060934931,
0.0211152174,
0.0303821824,
-0.0344032869,
0.0276816487,
-0.042223487,
-0.0029336999,
0.0042065042,
-0.0210327096,
-0.0590899885,
-0.033755932,
-0.0229778271,
-0.035043899,
0.0102951005,
-0.0094816247,
-0.0039428291,
0.0005445554,
0.0297853239,
-0.0043340409,
-0.0347805917,
-0.0255356133,
0.0037211995,
0.0920993835,
0.0724635124,
0.0248669963,
0.0287147351,
-0.0740591809,
0.0658862963,
0.0477557369,
0.00664907,
0.0067131943,
0.019179929,
0.0094044106,
0.0332225263,
-0.0483344868,
0.0048464509,
0.0134031493,
0.0561670549,
-0.0661456361,
-0.0386162363,
0.106935434,
0.0442834496,
-0.0278353412,
-0.0069716461,
-0.0368880443,
0.0322927833,
0.0218371712,
0.0230829939,
-0.0911606923,
-0.0125397174,
-0.008658926,
0.0532296821,
-0.0078770882,
-0.0505934879,
-0.0115397861,
-0.1113002598,
0.024106456,
-0.0103890207,
-0.0495331883,
0.0067094648,
-0.00794579,
0.0066592963,
-0.0009432781,
-0.0022469992,
0.0475199185,
-0.0245166738,
0.0280858073,
-0.0328805,
0.0444304347,
0.025382068,
0.0506323427,
-0.0293924231,
0.0098074572,
0.0367524549,
0.0442575365,
-0.0024302879,
-0.0142990584,
-0.0116158156,
-0.0691685453,
-0.0173916724,
0.0379172228,
0.0610925294,
-0.0222410113,
-0.0104992799,
-0.0532799587,
0.0711550862,
-0.018709654,
-0.0226665288,
0.0455030054,
0.0490829684,
0.0196083486,
0.0000768913,
-0.0311476234,
0.0295493528,
-0.0023456956,
0.0894783735,
0.031287767,
-0.058611203,
-0.0474753343,
-0.0140377618,
0.0088292807,
-0.0882709622,
-0.0377088301,
0.0242017098,
0.0077496669,
0.0193949956,
-0.0880965889,
-0.0638151467,
0.0260582659,
0.0392045677,
0.0213930942,
0.0123324431,
-0.0099095274,
0.0204942636,
-0.0469515249,
0.0250219628,
-0.0401631556,
0.0058414158,
-0.0381494276,
0.0181948766,
0.0411933847,
-0.0657015517,
-0.022614019,
0.029333815,
-0.0583062358,
-0.027105812,
0.0146280695,
0.009369771,
0.0189812873,
0.0131262252,
-0.0036428389,
-0.0345481075,
0.0479737073,
-0.0015677952,
-0.0754379854,
0.0263231136,
-0.0310436208,
0.0323869213,
-0.024194384,
0.022050634,
-0.0526891798,
0.0064438777,
-0.0379952006,
0.044826813,
-0.0205814559,
-0.0362049416,
0.0344452709,
0.0282640029,
-0.0514465757,
-0.0160064157,
-0.0002471058,
-0.03947822,
0.0141340038,
-0.0458317213,
-0.0299166813,
-0.0226564389,
0.0234894417,
0.0130154761,
-0.0376704931,
-0.0118131414,
0.0173913278,
-0.0110829072,
0.0515306406,
-0.0536197722,
0.0431549586,
0.022772219,
-0.0007371329,
0.0049453927,
-0.0149284359,
-0.0066982638,
-0.0566802509,
-0.0127962939,
0.0896117911,
0.0269668195,
0.0564577095,
0.039968051,
0.0007055898,
0.0034942902,
0.0403088219,
-0.0970389247,
-0.0241856147,
-0.0020185797,
0.0046862997,
0.0062024239,
0.0099048931,
0.0284989048,
0.0077983281,
-0.0214429125,
0.0056990259,
0.0052775531,
0.0212995894,
-0.0001755495,
-0.0002778967,
0.0513663962,
-0.0017864135,
0.0257962532,
0.0649987012,
0.0033639877,
0.0324003324,
0.0198711995,
-0.022725109,
-0.043805398,
-0.0336103253,
-0.0322016478,
0.0132284686,
0.0405726656,
-0.0091448333,
-0.0759342909,
-0.0601119585,
0.0221872814,
0.0401201062,
-0.0077201193,
-0.0306243394,
0.0178440921,
0.0490692295,
0.0022888209,
-0.0044532712,
-0.0543207563,
0.0562420711,
-0.0291086007,
-0.0241656899,
-0.0144013958,
-5.969440963e-33,
-0.0195357688,
-0.0568681657,
0.0308282524,
-0.0316453017,
-0.0675654113,
0.0151777696,
-0.0194862261,
-0.0238173697,
0.021282563,
0.024363026,
-0.0193847381,
0.0040793195,
-0.0162386559,
0.0211439636,
-0.0176520422,
-0.0556707643,
0.024836598,
0.0013963748,
-0.0549551323,
0.0511985496,
0.0583656244,
0.020441914,
-0.0143991224,
0.000089538,
0.0325450562,
-0.0640101433,
-0.013152726,
0.0214497019,
-0.0025478974,
0.0502085537,
-0.0253910068,
0.0208948776,
0.0509353057,
-0.0355485752,
0.0233454835,
0.0422565714,
-0.0976736248,
-0.0074521592,
0.022119185,
-0.0227816813,
-0.0577004626,
-0.0402122326,
0.0336737819,
0.0097297924,
0.0195497833,
-0.0319426619,
0.0509627722,
-0.0336021185,
0.032352291,
-0.0404990241,
-0.0485604256,
0.0021155847,
-0.0366536528,
-0.0400054008,
-0.0194155015,
0.0788179636,
0.0124366516,
0.0686878115,
-0.0154621247,
0.0086490605,
0.0091984887,
0.0106842127,
0.0195270237,
0.0389180854,
-0.0105888844,
0.0456515811,
-0.0062578749,
-0.0190947074,
-0.0405071601,
-0.0120552648,
-0.028776003,
-0.0120465122,
0.0655395016,
0.0742431805,
0.0109620485,
0.0286512636,
-0.0850574449,
0.077137962,
-0.0187104139,
0.0133137107,
0.0152535653,
-0.0480984375,
-0.0133149447,
-0.0080626616,
-0.0787050501,
0.0043460117,
-0.0343670137,
-0.0001668817,
0.0436641164,
-0.0285996366,
-0.0581733137,
-0.0320945904,
0.0254973341,
-0.0373666212,
0.0185461007,
0.0262684375,
-0.027098272,
0.0322486497,
0.0088134054,
0.0424496494,
-0.0144841857,
0.0563052669,
0.0068195914,
0.0193296336,
0.0277850199,
-0.0143906977,
-0.0229098499,
0.0066721146,
-0.0294056628,
0.0062280265,
-0.0227176826,
0.0225528292,
-0.0336647071,
0.0249456875,
0.0117450869,
0.021888433,
-0.0114546819,
0.0291013177,
-0.0073918672,
0.0286108106,
-0.0329409465,
-0.0137341255,
-0.0047709453,
0.0064257341,
-0.0467299744,
0.0126096485,
-0.0084144035,
0.0436796807,
-0.0023300757,
-0.0734449998,
-0.0049934243,
0.0204044674,
2.6e-7,
0.0322586261,
0.0048559173,
0.0360366888,
0.0390147194,
0.0015871504,
0.0128752869,
0.0304621868,
0.0228086468,
0.0478129461,
-0.0492364205,
0.0127299447,
0.0285404641,
0.0236872062,
0.0365150347,
-0.102681689,
-0.0310441684,
-0.0581141077,
-0.001822012,
-0.026357485,
-0.0257200468,
0.1004725546,
0.0356896296,
-0.0131375659,
-0.015021597,
0.0173633341,
-0.043836385,
0.0432128273,
-0.0082291141,
-0.0447342582,
0.049383916,
0.0319302231,
-0.0098627629,
0.007064132,
-0.0029912153,
-0.0040850416,
0.0290310774,
0.0230491478,
0.0246934406,
0.0333866514,
-0.0635280684,
-0.0291644819,
-0.0130028622,
0.0125039443,
-0.0719873831,
0.089759469,
-0.0190790147,
-0.0319172814,
-0.0017185323,
-0.041757293,
-0.0161269344,
-0.0228906292,
-0.0132389059,
-0.0178638622,
0.0455312356,
-0.0020163518,
-0.017864123,
0.0402525552,
-0.0629760772,
-0.0186587349,
0.011148938,
-0.0377640463,
-0.0545372404,
-0.0273206923,
-0.0393648297,
-0.0255608931,
-0.0847284794,
0.0243120715,
2.260351888e-34,
0.0306850914,
-0.0166065954,
0.0210301485,
0.0106069827,
0.035403315,
-0.0149705922,
-0.0035346777,
-0.0154733863,
0.0501344353,
-0.0933974236,
-0.0240469072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00159v1
|
On the referential capacity of language models: An internalist rejoinder to Mandelkern & Linzen
| 2024-05-31T19:43:20 | 2024-05-31T19:43:20 |
Giosue Baggio, Elliot Murphy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In a recent paper, Mandelkern & Linzen (2024) - henceforth M&L - address the
question of whether language models' (LMs) words refer. Their argument draws
from the externalist tradition in philosophical semantics, which views
reference as the capacity of words to "achieve 'word-to-world' connections". In
the externalist framework, causally uninterrupted chains of usage, tracing
every occurrence of a name back to its bearer, guarantee that, for example,
'Peano' refers to the individual Peano (Kripke 1980). This account is
externalist both because words pick out referents 'out there' in the world, and
because what determines reference are coordinated linguistic actions by members
of a community, and not individual mental states. The "central question to
ask", for M&L, is whether LMs too belong to human linguistic communities, such
that words by LMs may also trace back causally to their bearers. Their answer
is a cautious "yes": inputs to LMs are linguistic "forms with particular
histories of referential use"; "those histories ground the referents of those
forms"; any occurrence of 'Peano' in LM outputs is as causally connected to the
individual Peano as any other occurrence of the same proper name in human
speech or text; therefore, occurrences of 'Peano' in LM outputs refer to Peano.
In this commentary, we first qualify M&L's claim as applying to a narrow class
of natural language expressions. Thus qualified, their claim is valid, and we
emphasise an additional motivation for that in Section 2. Next, we discuss the
actual scope of their claim, and we suggest that the way they formulate it may
lead to unwarranted generalisations about reference in LMs. Our critique is
likewise applicable to other externalist accounts of LMs (e.g., Lederman &
Mahowald 2024; Mollo & Milliere 2023). Lastly, we conclude with a comment on
the status of LMs as members of human linguistic communities.
|
[
0.0446645096,
0.0502726622,
-0.0642199069,
0.0045129368,
-0.0289097317,
-0.0282293968,
-0.0288198851,
0.0091379657,
-0.0308849514,
-0.0731161013,
-0.0452954397,
-0.0341357328,
0.0351940766,
-0.0483405739,
0.1020942703,
-0.0429138765,
0.0245722011,
-0.0073602539,
-0.0252781305,
0.02053429,
-0.0083214827,
-0.0131482715,
0.0269717872,
0.0323648304,
0.0050594038,
0.0368154161,
0.0284634363,
-0.030186709,
-0.0203716625,
0.0014213974,
-0.0489493571,
-0.0098145641,
-0.0381924175,
-0.0022998173,
0.0000020275,
-0.0877119377,
0.0467054695,
-0.0211390704,
-0.0263903383,
-0.0220964607,
-0.0220245738,
0.0262370538,
-0.0077495817,
-0.0535385795,
-0.0118455458,
0.0204300284,
0.0583082326,
0.0146643883,
-0.0228052288,
0.0114063919,
-0.0025433525,
-0.0357696973,
0.066104725,
-0.0333424099,
0.0368343592,
0.0239564106,
0.0616045967,
0.0083148926,
-0.0209626015,
-0.0286074001,
-0.0279486217,
0.0420941673,
0.016955277,
0.0035649624,
0.0156710893,
0.0071142982,
0.0259427801,
-0.0142445108,
0.046700459,
0.0438531674,
0.0703960285,
-0.0435617417,
-0.0082125831,
0.0333176926,
-0.0176497698,
0.0625339597,
-0.014018843,
0.0295437854,
0.0165897589,
0.0282367915,
0.0703485683,
-0.0109381592,
0.0329472795,
0.0237645824,
-0.015946297,
0.1253512204,
0.0050800634,
-0.0126037411,
0.0212370884,
0.0323733799,
0.0017285675,
-0.0919867083,
-0.0207407195,
-0.0049808254,
0.0002255031,
0.0349479094,
-0.0037592766,
0.0305269435,
-0.0028195495,
-0.0657248423,
0.0236371681,
-0.0077028708,
-0.0254833624,
0.0100254007,
-0.002404514,
0.0276022833,
-0.0605069026,
0.0490342602,
-0.0482784584,
-0.0065679224,
-0.0425775535,
-0.0525105819,
-0.0446663387,
0.0221369378,
0.0178365465,
0.0067648687,
-0.0187371988,
0.0229646266,
-0.0335661657,
-0.0397670828,
-0.0620244853,
-0.0132525237,
-0.0520116165,
0.0050234492,
-0.0685088113,
-0.0070065935,
-0.0250654351,
0.0490977503,
-0.0446054526,
-0.1007105336,
0.0043816799,
-0.0145386513,
-0.0362680368,
-0.0070537841,
-0.0296400804,
0.0704440027,
0.052416984,
-0.006489615,
0.0125668244,
-0.0318456478,
-0.025391385,
-0.0317586958,
-0.0015742355,
-0.0197328459,
-0.0567585155,
0.0423641801,
-0.0014596094,
-0.0893351138,
0.0150062218,
0.0097658951,
-0.0669411868,
0.0197895877,
0.003250279,
0.0287310928,
-0.0204330459,
-0.0011624824,
0.027365176,
-0.0042000986,
0.0399136879,
-0.0554827191,
0.0142156323,
0.0040855291,
0.0188128296,
0.0305893403,
0.038308382,
-0.0344985686,
-0.0450692996,
0.0041408986,
0.0411485061,
0.0144141074,
0.0079804696,
0.0619214438,
-0.0000025033,
-0.020211298,
0.0280808862,
0.0245504379,
-0.0345336571,
0.0180949047,
0.0562436059,
-0.0241017677,
-0.0066277664,
0.0331710242,
-0.0484643951,
0.0001755629,
-0.0212815646,
-0.0111056296,
0.0082690222,
-0.0263807159,
-0.0186092909,
-0.0046762922,
0.000637829,
0.0210572705,
-0.0193575043,
-0.0163524281,
0.0274062641,
0.0588379949,
0.0302203428,
0.0883053765,
0.0479236282,
-0.0077792513,
0.0079718828,
-0.0461550169,
0.0148753673,
-0.009579597,
-0.0016981794,
0.0507693663,
-0.0065295105,
-0.0045295879,
-0.0082535129,
0.0466839671,
0.0146344518,
-0.0024633287,
-0.0102427313,
0.020349063,
0.0371463299,
0.0130332867,
0.002873207,
0.0374355614,
-0.0744759142,
0.0100735864,
0.0072082821,
-0.0140228774,
0.0207106695,
0.0423273072,
-0.0305173565,
-0.0177122597,
-0.0618234202,
0.0187640637,
0.0091917654,
0.0043760682,
-0.0279746186,
0.0657255426,
0.045510076,
-0.048222892,
0.02687026,
0.0440050401,
-0.0355355144,
0.0431759804,
0.013183821,
-0.0585129857,
0.0581080504,
-0.015211273,
0.0470206402,
-0.065738067,
0.0747484863,
-0.0393888429,
0.0649849176,
-0.0083407834,
0.0168568622,
-0.0222792104,
0.0139416717,
-0.0033667905,
0.0162536036,
0.0022616524,
0.0548313633,
-0.019063374,
0.0360441618,
0.0401077792,
-0.0349480174,
-0.0263475981,
0.0252818689,
0.0000475923,
-0.0207520332,
0.0356744602,
-0.0379312932,
-0.0394917689,
-0.0179214925,
-0.0076757213,
-0.0224545076,
0.0217053369,
-0.0039814771,
-0.0009993149,
0.0015776639,
-0.0086525353,
-0.0095408056,
0.0419958793,
0.0198173467,
0.0376256071,
0.0503945164,
0.0306829549,
-0.0032975669,
-0.0532156564,
-0.0359929688,
-0.0141650615,
-0.0239455439,
0.0044176662,
-0.0045819888,
-0.0461077914,
-0.025007274,
-0.0255292412,
-0.0957480818,
-0.0306002349,
-0.0477204546,
0.0061431937,
0.0425996855,
0.0461182296,
0.0227670763,
0.0012063105,
-0.0311317947,
0.0096611306,
0.0016162195,
-0.0425707959,
-0.0360586271,
-0.0262601934,
0.003070283,
-0.0569461435,
-0.0307243504,
-0.0328651853,
-0.0270414297,
0.0892776325,
0.0058908011,
-0.0315721966,
0.0059089479,
0.0967290774,
-0.048601523,
-0.0305224676,
0.0064975321,
-0.0799537748,
-0.0430771671,
0.0303898547,
-0.0297929738,
-0.0497654267,
0.0074627199,
-0.0148130637,
-0.0095620733,
0.047080297,
-0.0257409196,
-0.0133992629,
0.0851982012,
0.0531670712,
-0.0026344836,
0.0771504715,
-0.0262334701,
-0.038997151,
-0.0322559699,
0.0209700521,
0.015632648,
0.0696138814,
-0.0343645513,
0.0379928239,
0.0232586861,
-0.033665698,
-0.0312549621,
0.0201408826,
-0.050281398,
0.0295153148,
0.0013191501,
0.0578618385,
-0.0092615951,
0.0387385637,
0.0320772678,
-0.0523106828,
0.0319469944,
-0.0011624481,
-0.0349599458,
-0.0223877057,
0.0103348885,
-0.0044197831,
0.0212227982,
0.0196584668,
-0.0461410545,
-0.0163098127,
-0.016021017,
0.0217332318,
0.0368230641,
0.0148442602,
0.0199692175,
0.0048704478,
-0.1069373712,
0.0035311335,
0.0306104552,
-0.0454344936,
-0.0093296831,
0.0431698859,
-0.0060081012,
0.0026176886,
0.0407873429,
-0.0391102396,
-0.0187489633,
0.0373962745,
-0.0082656648,
-0.0116457371,
0.0541872792,
0.0343887024,
-0.0616465062,
-0.051141426,
-0.0507704914,
-0.0304881278,
-0.0812038481,
-0.0037897676,
-0.0031148095,
-0.0782715827,
0.0143622784,
-0.0133544691,
0.0273787491,
0.0272348691,
-0.0494172648,
0.0266963039,
-0.013810752,
0.0272794683,
0.0209048912,
-0.0079217833,
0.0003355586,
-0.0412625298,
-0.019636739,
0.0369701236,
0.034704525,
0.0641121268,
-0.0396027863,
-0.0448761322,
0.0311929546,
-0.0419691615,
-0.0112072984,
-0.0025114499,
-0.0161381215,
0.0255486779,
0.0030776723,
-0.0574762076,
-0.0066574235,
-0.0085043795,
-0.0301741026,
-0.0154636083,
0.0545159318,
-0.0208541602,
-0.0330055952,
-0.0045629446,
0.0326006226,
-0.0142259905,
0.0587534346,
0.0221797153,
-0.0091069527,
0.0193776432,
-0.01639699,
-0.0006183329,
0.0911752358,
-0.0674771965,
-0.004515945,
-0.0029629963,
-0.0650244206,
-0.0754692852,
-0.040037144,
-0.0365340821,
0.0325102434,
0.047050979,
0.0040449528,
0.0056229257,
-0.0301252007,
0.0316559896,
0.0220432933,
-0.0473705679,
-0.0077383253,
-0.0199957136,
-0.0014949967,
0.0761360303,
-0.0225250758,
-0.032482639,
0.0243513733,
0.0442190692,
-0.024769729,
0.0251527745,
0.0352616645,
0.0364207551,
-0.0166807976,
0.0028409199,
-0.0186107438,
-0.0201743282,
-0.0112472149,
-0.0094697718,
0.0853098258,
-0.0171350483,
0.0282714814,
0.0028591342,
0.0571186766,
-0.0066267494,
0.0478909314,
0.0135288863,
-0.0054736598,
-0.0042486396,
-0.0800109729,
0.03777197,
-0.0098375781,
0.0330916159,
0.0070366408,
0.017881345,
-0.0207535736,
-0.026415227,
0.0157511197,
-0.0173536334,
-0.035191305,
0.0307143424,
0.0183559507,
0.066753231,
-0.0189902112,
-0.1064665467,
-0.0186498333,
0.0581363291,
0.0640656054,
-0.0381876305,
0.0501527414,
0.0422316231,
-0.0221625771,
0.0465998016,
0.0440538749,
0.0160275307,
-0.0289313775,
0.059654016,
-0.0380973294,
-0.0073756883,
0.0243028775,
0.006748003,
-0.0133565273,
-0.0481680408,
-0.0532422476,
-0.0366785899,
0.0186007693,
-0.0352875292,
0.0303813014,
-0.0070427353,
0.0463216156,
-0.0318228416,
0.0144136092,
-0.0029338798,
-0.0116428295,
0.0080141434,
-0.0445135497,
0.0205241945,
0.0031728102,
-0.0199755486,
0.0411174968,
-0.0009174888,
0.0155070573,
0.0360705666,
-0.0222998522,
-0.0030188761,
-0.0251789447,
-0.0366654098,
-0.0312644355,
0.0003058467,
0.0261109527,
0.0637577474,
-0.080322817,
-0.0408936813,
0.0185063872,
-0.0028417367,
0.0195474885,
-0.0274244621,
0.0291822441,
0.0322272405,
0.0432067402,
-0.0435956381,
-0.0285605732,
0.0609651208,
-0.021647254,
0.0228609536,
-0.0157521404,
-5.993121664e-33,
-0.1000232473,
-0.0172946118,
0.0347002335,
0.0008226432,
-0.0493797474,
-0.0214064065,
-0.0541050062,
0.0316243358,
-0.0078645553,
0.023651829,
-0.0250268336,
-0.0118970498,
0.0088899899,
0.0001879667,
0.0379534699,
-0.0357415974,
-0.0006223487,
-0.0091148028,
0.0205509234,
-0.02181153,
0.0479239747,
0.0125205526,
0.0727335885,
-0.0647223219,
0.0970857367,
-0.006890845,
0.0005618879,
0.0345504992,
0.0054542427,
0.0147517538,
-0.0270755012,
0.0120966025,
0.0184641518,
-0.020588344,
0.0041054189,
0.0210732743,
-0.0414845049,
-0.0612163022,
0.0904310197,
-0.0207413826,
0.0209535863,
-0.038890142,
0.0513673574,
-0.0265975948,
-0.0604880378,
0.0678887218,
0.0347881205,
-0.0119873052,
-0.0184078254,
0.0321082845,
-0.0540431738,
-0.0157428905,
0.0060417987,
0.0021178501,
-0.0140591925,
-0.0156250596,
-0.0461508185,
-0.0490385443,
-0.0464799404,
0.0240262467,
-0.0167108178,
0.0337662064,
0.0079290895,
0.0474852584,
0.0476229116,
0.0312317479,
0.0789333507,
-0.0010341788,
0.0089668054,
-0.0099024251,
0.0444706455,
0.0547414832,
0.0088919429,
0.0315278359,
-0.0114552779,
-0.0007442971,
-0.0051233075,
-0.0557909757,
0.0219650753,
0.0208694842,
0.0119440854,
-0.0278201941,
-0.0043602418,
-0.03429671,
-0.026975451,
-0.0778149813,
-0.0021264048,
-0.0190642253,
-0.0005398704,
-0.0259512886,
0.0472877696,
0.0012786397,
0.0104771117,
-0.0689275712,
-0.0624245293,
0.0070159575,
-0.0195141472,
0.0127302632,
0.0241893493,
-0.0149472971,
-0.0548714586,
-0.0148681654,
-0.0372403786,
0.0320655182,
0.0016851198,
0.0327427015,
-0.0263296366,
-0.0161616299,
-0.0257025156,
-0.0382851772,
-0.0094201062,
-0.0321605988,
-0.0084178867,
-0.0518040583,
0.054599233,
0.0363000445,
-0.0082013011,
0.0077291033,
0.0326614119,
0.0046135015,
0.0105824396,
0.0335051902,
-0.033925619,
0.0290028732,
-0.0271471329,
-0.0087128086,
-0.0255774911,
0.0923145339,
0.098146677,
-0.0287862159,
-0.0131450547,
-0.0293429475,
2.92e-7,
0.0341006741,
0.0066415141,
0.0164691266,
0.0040560844,
0.0301495977,
-0.0100562824,
-0.0116777085,
0.0107421838,
0.0315686204,
-0.0190619789,
-0.0118253548,
-0.0027992437,
-0.0051792967,
0.0215332638,
-0.0217620507,
0.0246625356,
-0.04096248,
-0.0028793563,
0.0151404189,
0.0499018542,
-0.0417835899,
0.0585230663,
0.0583275184,
-0.0107640764,
-0.074637875,
-0.0493721701,
0.0379462317,
-0.0739477575,
0.0018067928,
0.025822917,
0.0737946481,
0.0235677753,
0.0138882883,
0.0157038812,
0.0621738359,
0.0707424805,
0.0401942879,
-0.025031412,
0.0105529921,
0.0005142329,
-0.0382058024,
-0.0725253895,
0.0012231675,
-0.0328559317,
0.0291297417,
-0.0476234332,
-0.0291695762,
0.0373292305,
0.00943828,
0.0350599401,
0.0283958968,
0.0172305964,
-0.0227864683,
-0.0108052539,
0.0211410541,
-0.0160828233,
-0.0155074382,
-0.0393453501,
-0.0309718251,
0.0344442874,
0.0068778708,
-0.040602237,
-0.0037166504,
0.0067730392,
-0.0096728401,
-0.0289838761,
-0.0179739762,
2.100606109e-34,
-0.0072700451,
-0.0043311645,
0.0349062905,
-0.0118033644,
0.01522383,
-0.0055339253,
0.000668446,
0.0452595428,
0.0239299256,
-0.0466656499,
-0.0163542796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00131v1
|
How In-Context Learning Emerges from Training on Unstructured Data: On the Role of Co-Occurrence, Positional Information, and Noise Structures
| 2024-05-31T18:46:06 | 2024-05-31T18:46:06 |
Kevin Christian Wibisono, Yixin Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Large language models (LLMs) like transformers have impressive in-context
learning (ICL) capabilities; they can generate predictions for new queries
based on input-output sequences in prompts without parameter updates. While
many theories have attempted to explain ICL, they often focus on structured
training data similar to ICL tasks, such as regression. In practice, however,
these models are trained in an unsupervised manner on unstructured text data,
which bears little resemblance to ICL tasks. To this end, we investigate how
ICL emerges from unsupervised training on unstructured data. The key
observation is that ICL can arise simply by modeling co-occurrence information
using classical language models like continuous bag of words (CBOW), which we
theoretically prove and empirically validate. Furthermore, we establish the
necessity of positional information and noise structure to generalize ICL to
unseen data. Finally, we present instances where ICL fails and provide
theoretical explanations; they suggest that the ICL ability of LLMs to identify
certain tasks can be sensitive to the structure of the training data.
|
[
0.0132863969,
0.0513296761,
-0.0096365651,
0.0315370038,
-0.0255637411,
0.0297904946,
-0.003082725,
0.0133258756,
-0.0141923362,
-0.0732775256,
-0.0310780741,
-0.0349311009,
0.0045813695,
-0.0003206179,
0.0406564437,
-0.0181635562,
0.0317845792,
-0.0325763263,
-0.0114640864,
0.0167867057,
-0.0306670014,
-0.0264191814,
0.0016478139,
0.0081924153,
-0.0348125249,
-0.0229835361,
-0.0382250771,
0.0004004316,
-0.0659696162,
-0.0062949774,
0.0044389116,
0.060016349,
0.0372653045,
0.0261360146,
0.0000020373,
-0.0516104959,
-0.0342418179,
-0.00391636,
-0.031237511,
-0.0342317671,
0.0080650505,
-0.0056441203,
0.0080144824,
0.0217498429,
-0.0445016064,
-0.0053520692,
0.0376891792,
0.078046456,
0.0392986797,
0.0931219012,
-0.010164489,
-0.0139989704,
-0.0077141933,
-0.0229235198,
0.0588152818,
-0.0211461578,
0.0036352645,
-0.026058767,
0.0049506547,
0.0517619364,
-0.0335649513,
0.0139462361,
-0.0078186831,
0.010052165,
-0.0118763475,
0.0511567518,
-0.0489565469,
-0.0082930923,
0.0067706844,
0.0406761654,
-0.0532497391,
-0.0344189592,
0.0121547598,
0.0161895379,
-0.0084392317,
0.0155265899,
-0.0383555405,
0.0085511124,
0.0110618174,
0.0187571943,
-0.0192444399,
-0.0060911411,
0.0306119416,
-0.0114043439,
-0.0316603705,
0.0855331644,
-0.027008947,
-0.0471690446,
-0.0065687881,
-0.0174087603,
-0.0236552265,
-0.0439120159,
-0.0310082734,
0.0406220369,
-0.0581899658,
0.036829643,
-0.0367154106,
-0.0000374395,
0.023772547,
-0.0593342707,
0.0067683994,
0.009460533,
-0.0138515709,
0.055641342,
0.0001485462,
0.0300641023,
0.0019404918,
0.029288508,
-0.0308738481,
0.0064865914,
-0.0632252023,
-0.018759694,
-0.033761669,
0.0473298393,
-0.0570988767,
-0.0339582227,
-0.0093910247,
0.0586656108,
0.010198527,
0.0093350261,
0.0034056951,
0.0211736914,
-0.0478592664,
0.004974124,
-0.0294149071,
-0.0350922309,
0.0362376235,
0.0309742168,
0.005865511,
-0.0385136753,
-0.0156228738,
0.0010162418,
0.0343533866,
-0.0203160588,
0.0152941719,
0.059295103,
-0.0154744415,
-0.045172438,
-0.0613467395,
-0.0555858165,
0.0025799929,
-0.0301285814,
-0.0082133254,
-0.0673250258,
0.0018229126,
0.0312497299,
-0.0044686501,
-0.0283863768,
0.0143535389,
0.0571144521,
-0.0453937948,
0.1254871041,
0.0133445552,
0.0185010061,
0.0081849629,
-0.0068182624,
0.0303530023,
0.0603798144,
-0.0055764206,
0.0016925713,
0.0474392213,
-0.0027754623,
0.0153657719,
0.0272673462,
0.0125745144,
0.0019337602,
-0.0258413497,
0.0183232576,
0.0196917169,
0.0244125314,
0.0135523966,
0.0354032926,
0.0016902088,
0.001823328,
0.0763735697,
0.0603387915,
0.0349492431,
0.0090314802,
0.0047370088,
0.0149098048,
-0.0214009359,
0.0332698002,
-0.0507622138,
-0.0404229239,
-0.0228296444,
0.0042011384,
0.0146239623,
-0.0352210887,
-0.040599063,
-0.0498570018,
-0.008972452,
-0.0260989182,
-0.0146050211,
-0.0053131343,
0.0505788513,
0.0348248146,
-0.0481550507,
0.0222406648,
0.0205212086,
-0.0181609429,
-0.0120463828,
-0.005318772,
-0.005083974,
0.0249374546,
0.0381165482,
-0.0585626699,
-0.0027825662,
-0.0096959639,
0.0145834591,
0.008650342,
-0.0063965111,
-0.0254793763,
-0.0040996582,
-0.019897284,
-0.0324401185,
0.0322086103,
0.0200013593,
-0.0263891332,
0.0007409016,
-0.0220330283,
0.0059820581,
-0.0515055135,
-0.0359165706,
0.0373537093,
-0.0369661897,
-0.0741648003,
0.0226340964,
0.0068700709,
0.0119147534,
0.0001709676,
-0.0122770723,
0.0425686613,
0.0757048205,
-0.0078485031,
-0.02038466,
0.0023830056,
-0.0599364415,
-0.0232817121,
0.0243780147,
0.0097107915,
-0.0009276349,
-0.0101981713,
-0.0126188779,
-0.0388622172,
-0.0301670227,
-0.0533268042,
0.0814262182,
-0.0332753509,
0.0367358439,
0.0122446762,
-0.0145220421,
-0.0899442434,
0.0903153419,
-0.0068749026,
0.0233251546,
0.0044843508,
0.0298132244,
0.0103698689,
-0.0233393591,
-0.0261309035,
0.0117814941,
-0.0098203402,
0.0181287713,
0.0120305177,
-0.0136811892,
-0.0334422924,
-0.0127143478,
-0.0878063217,
-0.018326303,
-0.0313330777,
0.0076126014,
0.0206542742,
0.000901633,
-0.0074130804,
-0.0412406884,
-0.0372440405,
-0.0188352801,
0.0331314914,
0.0303446986,
0.0539565459,
0.0216753352,
-0.0009398721,
-0.0359765664,
-0.0140803428,
-0.051202219,
0.0797581375,
-0.0055540227,
-0.0521978326,
-0.0489571989,
0.0619160607,
0.0195385292,
0.0580182932,
-0.0183340944,
0.0238066986,
-0.0067067035,
-0.0169896558,
0.039637845,
0.0347643234,
0.0197957717,
0.0261002649,
0.0019776514,
0.0047148964,
-0.0508894473,
0.0005525413,
-0.0702803582,
0.0009110214,
-0.0524409525,
0.0002708598,
0.0498010516,
0.0461588763,
0.0003525637,
-0.0155011192,
-0.0160075389,
0.0057726884,
0.0126594556,
-0.0215693321,
-0.0919823423,
-0.0114031201,
-0.0140839918,
0.0439197533,
-0.0129147163,
-0.0563733801,
0.019059645,
-0.0367648527,
0.0017345219,
-0.0665005669,
-0.0305088498,
-0.0431257151,
0.066432938,
0.0331609659,
0.0269604214,
0.035850957,
-0.0494342744,
-0.0519974567,
0.0090039326,
-0.0036974994,
-0.0276072696,
0.0637140572,
-0.0187906213,
0.0225261897,
0.0166204255,
-0.033096265,
-0.0753901973,
-0.0431976616,
0.0141914217,
0.0255846586,
0.0314631052,
-0.0201494657,
-0.0260387398,
0.0167998746,
0.0196437836,
0.0507680215,
0.0026657344,
-0.046746213,
-0.0391152948,
0.0424399711,
0.0394547433,
0.0244499967,
0.0041640503,
-0.0213858224,
-0.0180328339,
0.052361194,
0.0619523562,
-0.0355696231,
-0.0073436415,
0.0262733828,
0.0403774381,
-0.0381815247,
-0.0394603834,
0.0482445993,
-0.0143043539,
-0.0248496421,
-0.0503185801,
0.1060539335,
0.0270316917,
-0.068119891,
0.021828413,
0.0275063887,
-0.0095913634,
0.0509463996,
0.0423598588,
-0.0336163081,
-0.0176863112,
0.0064248941,
0.0057936334,
-0.0059893737,
-0.0221796203,
-0.0232545417,
-0.1537393183,
0.034907572,
-0.0263806712,
-0.0029361011,
-0.0566968359,
-0.0630987808,
-0.0180625003,
-0.0054598586,
0.0052604252,
0.0108947884,
-0.0523700491,
-0.0122287348,
0.0550258681,
-0.0245235618,
-0.0753070638,
-0.0202902239,
-0.0402081273,
0.0215764232,
0.0764389038,
0.0168002769,
-0.0283032414,
-0.0168942846,
0.0526397936,
0.0003300324,
0.0137121836,
-0.0185763799,
0.0540360957,
-0.0112397298,
-0.0075026606,
0.0146932416,
0.0234138016,
-0.0706828088,
-0.0287102051,
-0.0202626046,
0.0893499106,
-0.0479927436,
0.0011983716,
0.0027855816,
-0.0400410742,
0.0446395651,
0.0665131733,
-0.0116877882,
-0.0262095947,
-0.0295019355,
-0.0214447379,
0.0280658901,
0.0698149055,
-0.0148914503,
0.0167873986,
-0.0139132105,
-0.042027548,
-0.060471084,
-0.0209612846,
0.0227770582,
0.0472848192,
0.0213343278,
0.0495072789,
0.0396185927,
-0.009536962,
-0.0600235909,
0.0039642546,
-0.0119692776,
0.0044927523,
-0.0673252791,
-0.0197409801,
0.0354366079,
-0.0394161008,
-0.0418695994,
-0.0316250287,
-0.064655751,
-0.0463245437,
0.0168801453,
0.0042810971,
0.0224374607,
0.0559443384,
-0.0076805013,
-0.0682865158,
0.067983672,
0.0760039464,
-0.0382045545,
0.0111856284,
0.0153733594,
-0.0265422612,
0.0035230094,
0.0241683405,
-0.0261526052,
0.0137714697,
-0.0040253475,
0.0083925724,
-0.0614467561,
0.0084720841,
0.0691934451,
-0.0186226889,
0.1006031781,
0.0268951692,
0.0133197,
-0.0218827408,
0.0267368052,
0.0265798122,
-0.0389767326,
-0.0221427605,
-0.0299080238,
0.0139026893,
0.0358402282,
-0.0047660633,
0.0283297207,
-0.0104934974,
0.0522605442,
-0.0051176464,
-0.0175352935,
0.029604733,
-0.026278371,
0.0175529607,
0.0263807103,
0.031471841,
0.0341751315,
0.0089172274,
0.0613026991,
-0.0051255841,
0.0228087772,
0.0271337833,
0.0189117212,
-0.037849322,
0.0123636965,
-0.0945882723,
0.0103868777,
-0.0259086769,
0.0105887642,
0.0281596091,
-0.0844094604,
0.0049370066,
-0.0454617403,
0.0058598109,
-0.0382309742,
0.0035615726,
0.031560678,
0.0230204836,
0.0175374858,
0.0340901352,
-0.033800289,
0.0306332055,
0.1326410919,
0.0128721865,
0.0325116254,
-0.0130459936,
-0.0378970057,
-0.0272293855,
0.0063814283,
0.0707817376,
0.0455832928,
-0.0191986673,
0.0151243722,
-0.0171313845,
-0.036356952,
0.0192169454,
-0.0123004317,
0.0231779125,
-0.0430181473,
0.0620268136,
0.1061655656,
0.0189806633,
0.0223284885,
-0.0551261716,
0.0006568925,
0.0121094994,
-0.0232172366,
-0.0321285501,
-6.412085115e-33,
-0.0107423868,
-0.0624228418,
0.025015004,
0.0444473885,
0.0436702631,
0.0107314531,
-0.003428915,
0.0082490472,
0.0156916846,
0.0103019485,
-0.0484469272,
0.0034872307,
0.0134669105,
0.0328279324,
0.032717742,
-0.0397752449,
0.0220732689,
0.0060511888,
0.014032294,
0.000884667,
0.0481908545,
0.0492673963,
0.0411499031,
-0.0935398713,
0.0047482043,
-0.0308351628,
0.0069150287,
0.0551916361,
0.0134569686,
0.0440159217,
-0.0243601929,
0.0458210595,
0.0383390412,
-0.0599062815,
-0.0259196721,
0.0382354297,
-0.0735436007,
-0.0109093729,
-0.0160756055,
0.0113086244,
-0.0122669227,
-0.0041957712,
0.0638936311,
-0.0193314366,
-0.0298458524,
0.0216230955,
0.0563449934,
-0.0087086158,
-0.0549818352,
-0.0466325358,
-0.046211537,
0.0261305813,
0.0186090041,
-0.0176465083,
0.019694956,
0.0462880135,
0.0152562419,
0.0291428361,
-0.072268635,
0.0424447842,
-0.015427486,
0.0778020173,
0.0280741062,
0.0265112855,
-0.0028059501,
0.0594448149,
0.0251799151,
0.0179328676,
0.0146228895,
-0.0226916838,
0.0284936056,
0.0480024666,
-0.0184339918,
0.0138126938,
0.0549522638,
0.0072160871,
-0.0497294478,
0.0354642347,
-0.0214310102,
-0.0000887555,
0.0277059935,
-0.0084868008,
-0.0698342845,
-0.0550294109,
-0.0305879824,
0.0056956238,
-0.0192422736,
-0.0005299219,
0.0243281033,
0.0276002437,
0.0024954448,
0.0164338257,
-0.0069123362,
-0.0369223468,
-0.056059327,
-0.0197293386,
-0.0012119999,
-0.0179774873,
-0.0012117677,
0.010976281,
-0.0524791926,
-0.0566313304,
-0.0310190134,
0.0194921382,
0.0007805274,
0.0126038874,
0.0619051196,
0.0517533273,
-0.0664091781,
-0.0261094496,
-0.0145507846,
0.0099018132,
-0.014198279,
0.0077258516,
0.047990974,
-0.0111441389,
-0.0101005165,
0.0316290371,
0.0201246943,
-0.0024084465,
-0.0063440888,
-0.0273292121,
-0.0372225679,
-0.0140495058,
0.0218375903,
-0.0336752571,
-0.0455942191,
0.0227392204,
0.0582140908,
-0.0503095426,
0.0109099587,
0.0193242636,
2.854e-7,
0.0376448147,
0.0595078245,
0.0284563787,
0.0190606564,
0.0421345532,
0.0456697047,
-0.028595753,
0.0379964598,
0.0189611614,
-0.0228909906,
0.0205074437,
-0.0129641434,
0.0030200523,
0.011101027,
-0.0804485157,
-0.0535013303,
-0.0653879419,
0.0124672493,
-0.0443506427,
0.0013046354,
0.020349795,
0.1223896444,
-0.0179654825,
-0.0267237723,
0.0115813287,
-0.0395015217,
0.0526988655,
-0.0387495458,
0.0057176868,
0.0173023976,
-0.0080156522,
0.0095162718,
0.0345628932,
0.0317061357,
-0.0350582004,
0.027644299,
0.0196873061,
0.0378838181,
0.0134826275,
-0.0199341625,
0.0152716497,
0.0082124406,
0.00411544,
-0.0304992814,
0.0795707926,
-0.0534529388,
-0.0150063038,
-0.0151704429,
0.0129123628,
-0.0192027483,
-0.0072824163,
0.0335242189,
-0.0214753915,
-0.0042445697,
0.0160486288,
-0.0065687471,
0.0004283072,
-0.0643034205,
-0.0392228775,
0.0068728877,
-0.0467143208,
-0.0224420745,
-0.022328075,
0.0092323767,
0.0289880466,
-0.0158565044,
-0.0039586909,
2.976427001e-34,
0.0223417729,
0.0472707599,
0.0160293225,
0.0098595181,
-0.0086985063,
-0.0078600934,
0.0137951244,
0.0212541893,
0.0349371731,
-0.0702032521,
-0.009931447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21075v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21075v2
|
Video-MME: The First-Ever Comprehensive Evaluation Benchmark of Multi-modal LLMs in Video Analysis
| 2024-05-31T17:59:47 | 2024-06-16T15:49:12 |
Chaoyou Fu, Yuhan Dai, Yongdong Luo, Lei Li, Shuhuai Ren, Renrui Zhang, Zihan Wang, Chenyu Zhou, Yunhang Shen, Mengdan Zhang, Peixian Chen, Yanwei Li, Shaohui Lin, Sirui Zhao, Ke Li, Tong Xu, Xiawu Zheng, Enhong Chen, Rongrong Ji, Xing Sun
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In the quest for artificial general intelligence, Multi-modal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) have emerged as a focal point in recent advancements. However,
the predominant focus remains on developing their capabilities in static image
understanding. The potential of MLLMs in processing sequential visual data is
still insufficiently explored, highlighting the absence of a comprehensive,
high-quality assessment of their performance. In this paper, we introduce
Video-MME, the first-ever full-spectrum, Multi-Modal Evaluation benchmark of
MLLMs in Video analysis. Our work distinguishes from existing benchmarks
through four key features: 1) Diversity in video types, spanning 6 primary
visual domains with 30 subfields to ensure broad scenario generalizability; 2)
Duration in temporal dimension, encompassing both short-, medium-, and
long-term videos, ranging from 11 seconds to 1 hour, for robust contextual
dynamics; 3) Breadth in data modalities, integrating multi-modal inputs besides
video frames, including subtitles and audios, to unveil the all-round
capabilities of MLLMs; 4) Quality in annotations, utilizing rigorous manual
labeling by expert annotators to facilitate precise and reliable model
assessment. 900 videos with a total of 254 hours are manually selected and
annotated by repeatedly viewing all the video content, resulting in 2,700
question-answer pairs. With Video-MME, we extensively evaluate various
state-of-the-art MLLMs, including GPT-4 series and Gemini 1.5 Pro, as well as
open-source image models like InternVL-Chat-V1.5 and video models like
LLaVA-NeXT-Video. Our experiments reveal that Gemini 1.5 Pro is the
best-performing commercial model, significantly outperforming the open-source
models. Our dataset along with these findings underscores the need for further
improvements in handling longer sequences and multi-modal data. Project Page:
https://video-mme.github.io
|
[
0.021323787,
0.0503335372,
0.0007169431,
0.0871685222,
-0.0249389019,
0.0282175541,
0.0177334044,
0.0063709919,
-0.0107007241,
-0.100449197,
-0.0169041809,
-0.0722742975,
-0.0390160643,
0.0497684367,
0.0211157128,
-0.056436196,
0.0362393707,
-0.0408294909,
0.0225406401,
0.0104100676,
0.0285604037,
-0.0127267065,
-0.0071024643,
0.0295202304,
-0.0361647494,
-0.0209058113,
-0.0137055004,
-0.0129372217,
0.0485984907,
-0.0302301757,
-0.0309754331,
0.0498904921,
0.0818237662,
-0.0020655845,
0.000001897,
-0.039841,
0.0199676584,
-0.0157484096,
-0.0122790635,
0.0172897428,
0.0059977397,
-0.0072021727,
0.003068378,
-0.0018166902,
-0.0453630723,
-0.0129757132,
0.0352778286,
0.0018340737,
0.0626587495,
0.0602415167,
-0.0327305347,
-0.0524024963,
0.0469058044,
-0.0191228148,
0.0474965163,
-0.0644406676,
0.0288510416,
0.0351489969,
0.0215716325,
-0.0082790777,
-0.0526141673,
0.03826534,
0.0339169838,
-0.0278797168,
-0.0330293179,
0.0221311506,
-0.0247663353,
-0.0472502038,
-0.0302515626,
0.0943198204,
0.0185310803,
0.0412183218,
-0.0250515435,
0.0070075397,
-0.000348226,
-0.010833188,
-0.0460552126,
0.0306943767,
0.0128820669,
0.0031529742,
-0.0123468423,
0.0289170686,
0.0132833254,
-0.0046386477,
0.0159260575,
-0.0087723332,
0.0281113777,
0.0064903786,
-0.0227638297,
-0.0068891672,
-0.023222845,
-0.054101143,
-0.0281634051,
0.03403081,
0.014189777,
-0.0117408028,
-0.0247483384,
0.002593254,
-0.0231300537,
-0.0369291529,
0.0142396931,
0.0197918974,
-0.0434752554,
0.0861584097,
-0.0051503186,
0.0646102056,
-0.0221461449,
0.0102877663,
-0.0176255368,
-0.0252046697,
-0.0549519621,
0.0138053084,
0.0141648082,
0.0182191227,
-0.0508147068,
-0.0385027416,
-0.0153988814,
0.0195365027,
-0.0271727517,
0.0241174605,
-0.0296768807,
0.0030084485,
0.0276031457,
-0.02141615,
-0.0205374137,
0.021133678,
-0.0314951763,
0.0337496027,
-0.003587859,
-0.0911583826,
0.0101320753,
0.042977158,
0.0002730164,
-0.0255250745,
0.0166961066,
0.0816757008,
-0.0507370867,
-0.0499311909,
-0.0060212463,
0.0184416231,
-0.0297558568,
-0.0411719866,
0.0152708981,
-0.0663309246,
0.0359412953,
0.0063386848,
0.0107668964,
0.0019760961,
0.0064590969,
-0.0286596529,
-0.02803942,
0.0864525661,
0.0124672204,
0.0116234869,
0.0093797203,
0.0321272239,
0.0166696049,
0.0748326257,
0.0269895643,
0.0167368092,
0.0406397879,
0.0037695207,
0.0541377515,
0.0688261613,
-0.0630710423,
0.0224047583,
-0.0749841481,
0.0294414647,
0.0178379603,
0.0477448069,
0.009187988,
0.0478420556,
-0.0260789916,
-0.0443708189,
0.0709635019,
0.0300740693,
-0.0374542437,
-0.0157897472,
0.0410882831,
0.0045870817,
0.0355199538,
0.0071252771,
-0.0414237194,
0.068786256,
0.0046202312,
-0.0018021349,
0.0055197584,
0.0320838504,
-0.059436556,
-0.0191205852,
-0.0309139788,
-0.0307108816,
-0.0109176831,
0.0213195179,
0.0410335772,
-0.0516721755,
-0.0256192535,
0.0278088693,
-0.0009840563,
0.0059849797,
0.0054986808,
-0.0543950684,
0.0164634157,
0.0620201342,
-0.0002643768,
-0.0272674877,
-0.0590432212,
-0.0223003533,
0.0407349579,
0.0219294652,
0.0219632853,
-0.0147786066,
0.0384331234,
-0.0699091256,
-0.0457073748,
-0.0112056844,
0.0124338949,
0.0264524426,
-0.0160281677,
-0.0053261989,
0.0024298159,
-0.0086625563,
0.0106742606,
0.0297842901,
0.0330338702,
-0.0024085024,
-0.0157353431,
-0.0156759601,
0.0343475081,
-0.000887742,
-0.0391384214,
-0.0153836375,
0.034822531,
-0.0267589204,
0.0219406448,
0.0350739732,
-0.0432227999,
-0.0293434039,
0.0511770621,
-0.0542626344,
-0.0328885354,
0.0533259772,
-0.070394434,
-0.0324300192,
-0.0227144174,
0.003483268,
-0.006539999,
-0.0816476271,
-0.0161047298,
0.019828042,
0.009575217,
-0.0204527806,
0.0358183309,
-0.0261369273,
-0.0191335585,
0.0241733957,
0.0362399593,
0.0076465234,
-0.0426507406,
-0.0397823527,
0.0181160867,
-0.0023558468,
-0.0070330705,
0.0018484807,
0.0048687775,
-0.0705135614,
-0.0446312316,
-0.1114809737,
-0.016044775,
-0.0350142494,
0.0064166584,
0.0059513929,
-0.0001586637,
-0.0283614434,
-0.0403521471,
0.0036241412,
0.0223741625,
0.0163120218,
0.0116858222,
0.010781955,
0.0317070521,
0.0141020492,
-0.0312105641,
-0.0110906176,
0.0154020991,
0.0481789149,
0.003566379,
-0.0212954246,
0.0060355514,
-0.0337599851,
-0.0273196921,
0.0296861753,
-0.0549813174,
-0.0277275555,
0.0019273333,
-0.0196793862,
0.0326263867,
0.0536531061,
0.0475988612,
0.0223397724,
-0.0110124312,
-0.0171581786,
-0.0186905172,
0.0202006288,
0.0201263931,
-0.0598322898,
-0.0564678945,
-0.0198712945,
-0.05953734,
0.0245926045,
-0.0412491411,
0.0353024751,
-0.039842546,
0.0135224536,
0.0122812446,
-0.0348975211,
-0.0508113764,
0.0201942679,
-0.0190028269,
0.0077651544,
-0.030627951,
-0.0517677069,
0.0375094712,
-0.0325706005,
-0.0337617695,
0.031222241,
-0.0117559163,
-0.0423186906,
0.0814984888,
0.0325628519,
0.0068376884,
-0.0329329036,
-0.0116798598,
-0.0525275059,
-0.0254513379,
0.0106783006,
0.0010736331,
0.0680348799,
-0.0659198463,
0.0185804293,
-0.0126811145,
-0.0277235173,
-0.0386546031,
-0.05353944,
-0.0521456599,
-0.0089684529,
-0.0433134437,
0.0012169979,
-0.0143474489,
0.0258318149,
0.0242559556,
0.0244641621,
-0.0154453311,
0.0329719558,
-0.0109234285,
0.0833021551,
0.0888848379,
0.0400739089,
-0.0203765351,
-0.0521533079,
0.0488068089,
0.0515273437,
0.0054021082,
-0.001928125,
-0.0486305319,
0.0530826077,
0.0130420849,
0.033037141,
-0.0278959554,
0.0359233804,
0.0534473285,
-0.0459230393,
0.0335100219,
0.1247579604,
-0.0095044086,
-0.0658357069,
-0.022051435,
0.025165936,
0.0098957773,
0.0506675839,
-0.0041408399,
-0.0916280299,
-0.0610472001,
-0.017384205,
-0.0300891902,
0.0207438525,
-0.0089285858,
-0.0112536466,
-0.0754728466,
0.0712522343,
-0.0071992669,
-0.0232781712,
0.0134847574,
-0.0031959352,
0.0097564971,
-0.0325754657,
-0.0012411026,
-0.0232807938,
-0.0078427298,
-0.0083961831,
0.0098835127,
-0.0045912499,
-0.0685336217,
0.0604172498,
-0.0433400311,
0.0524655282,
0.0077889445,
0.0051794788,
-0.0514796413,
-0.0462548025,
0.0493281297,
-0.0108479047,
-0.001295213,
0.0082568778,
0.0367377996,
-0.0447839834,
-0.0226110015,
0.0127157923,
0.0226291772,
0.0146662882,
-0.0189135186,
0.0109463381,
0.0629079193,
-0.0176111944,
0.0193067491,
-0.0395375974,
-0.015803596,
0.0116295088,
0.0728636086,
0.0047516753,
-0.0261014439,
-0.005906913,
0.0190032423,
-0.038916491,
0.0020998593,
-0.0227912795,
-0.0171459075,
0.0287163444,
0.0180245861,
-0.0267279018,
-0.0311116632,
0.0496906005,
0.0107613904,
-0.0465869419,
0.0074640592,
-0.0185040776,
0.0334395804,
-0.0574825369,
0.0739915818,
0.0068356604,
0.0002315164,
-0.0708359703,
0.013848261,
0.0593080074,
-0.0325569063,
-0.0160836652,
0.0454908982,
-0.0819086954,
-0.0338065922,
-0.0258179419,
0.0704585761,
0.0165629312,
0.0595474839,
0.0175066106,
-0.027701715,
-0.0054968791,
0.0059218435,
0.0228151213,
0.0115179317,
-0.0069648088,
-0.021750601,
-0.0163182523,
0.0347915925,
-0.0320281386,
0.0396538861,
0.0033148157,
-0.00370435,
-0.0255761389,
-0.0289286841,
-0.0015330977,
-0.0114045134,
0.0490072034,
-0.0152779939,
-0.0332401805,
-0.0141091067,
-0.0025018118,
0.0015947688,
0.0064967154,
-0.0667486265,
0.0174621604,
0.0434706584,
0.0031932921,
-0.0086169504,
0.0188588873,
0.0016505559,
-0.0127819423,
-0.0465286672,
0.0109500783,
0.0032859892,
-0.0291754678,
-0.0038114409,
0.0123029454,
0.0229999572,
0.0154311927,
0.0040606265,
0.0241891891,
0.0189302079,
0.0788723081,
0.0034463424,
-0.0289907344,
0.0108838752,
0.0527051464,
-0.0317319557,
-0.0399054512,
-0.0365933515,
0.0786113068,
0.0795611292,
-0.0222556833,
0.0075256061,
0.0121114086,
-0.0192171093,
-0.0507721342,
0.0491430983,
-0.0096013565,
-0.0576458797,
0.0653432682,
0.0333530046,
-0.0214649495,
0.0474573113,
0.066937983,
0.0218350831,
0.0173322596,
0.0197455231,
0.0169578567,
-0.0312344432,
-0.0077179857,
0.0273769516,
0.0126975439,
-0.0090469867,
0.0258448813,
-0.0344006158,
-0.0602891035,
-0.0015578942,
-0.0034048872,
-0.0064885626,
0.0318576768,
0.0406128168,
0.0495537519,
-0.000852345,
-0.0212358814,
-0.0207176432,
-0.0300878603,
-0.0165718962,
-0.0116957817,
-0.0002640989,
-6.107955707e-33,
-0.0142807504,
-0.0102918865,
0.0359794497,
-0.0078649269,
-0.022853259,
0.0318114571,
-0.0023710951,
0.0083138961,
-0.0314552821,
0.0043314006,
0.0315188468,
0.0118018007,
0.0159502123,
0.0264113024,
0.0273566525,
-0.0656008273,
0.0063807401,
-0.0427902527,
-0.024720991,
-0.0111990646,
0.000665034,
0.0205671061,
0.0534220636,
-0.070197098,
-0.0105196983,
0.0031839183,
-0.0249630902,
0.0402637608,
-0.016875213,
0.094099313,
-0.0095357904,
-0.0165246893,
0.0463953651,
-0.0194407292,
-0.0310798883,
0.0045251762,
-0.037356142,
0.025701927,
0.0083539942,
0.0002421013,
-0.065724127,
0.0017842655,
0.0249033812,
-0.0082140565,
-0.0181347169,
-0.0237390194,
0.0475347415,
-0.0316360481,
0.0191347469,
0.0118683539,
-0.0148140406,
0.0224395506,
-0.0139548564,
-0.0381837897,
0.0309479181,
0.0250396319,
0.0163954124,
0.0201908741,
-0.0516958013,
0.0020554229,
-0.0283863302,
0.0206452515,
0.1077505052,
0.009416311,
0.0078101484,
0.0581920929,
0.0246367045,
-0.0685266629,
-0.0215845741,
-0.0291145947,
-0.0033408052,
0.0879115313,
0.0281341728,
0.0506854132,
-0.0101138344,
0.0287983362,
-0.0651084706,
0.0062341895,
-0.0318839438,
0.0488020368,
-0.0079327133,
0.0275232513,
0.0167138763,
0.0263708849,
-0.0336531401,
0.0096786497,
-0.0233519468,
0.0006831919,
0.0377957188,
0.0124792438,
0.0148405824,
-0.00068783,
0.0980061069,
-0.0423693843,
0.0199619718,
0.0087640658,
-0.025625743,
0.0678007379,
0.0315526389,
0.0571473986,
-0.0435283184,
-0.0120663801,
0.0262684785,
-0.0131397629,
-0.0122816097,
-0.0113068018,
-0.0010292495,
0.0350427702,
-0.0270293914,
-0.0091424566,
-0.0195233021,
-0.0024636537,
-0.0256289914,
0.0428150445,
0.0342528112,
-0.0002101688,
-0.0420635007,
0.061020948,
-0.0120448777,
0.0077269212,
-0.0089636995,
-0.0513432473,
0.0001198397,
0.0085046934,
-0.011067152,
0.0373795033,
-0.0352342799,
-0.0538084097,
0.0172639973,
-0.0340932645,
0.0116566811,
0.0489789248,
2.615e-7,
0.0231879558,
0.0296573918,
0.0169186387,
-0.0158095341,
0.0304494668,
0.059662465,
-0.0283291657,
0.0354086645,
0.0375453308,
-0.0407420509,
0.0063332897,
0.0567556545,
0.0491277575,
-0.0038601363,
-0.0150757646,
0.0127387224,
-0.0515816584,
-0.0381422788,
-0.06413652,
0.0160589386,
0.0548205562,
0.1207535267,
0.0100182826,
0.0051248507,
0.0253078118,
-0.073311463,
0.0810242817,
-0.0380567461,
-0.0644538477,
0.0065926043,
0.0274791829,
0.0285029151,
-0.0148850009,
0.0251967572,
0.0116389524,
-0.0120784296,
0.0456550978,
0.0885690078,
-0.0141861523,
-0.0636999533,
-0.041049581,
0.0314487107,
-0.029843308,
-0.0334869139,
0.0935048908,
-0.0128482534,
-0.0048272633,
-0.0429999903,
-0.0336500965,
-0.0136822341,
0.0254371539,
0.0127561847,
-0.0067104562,
0.0175378621,
0.0171578974,
-0.0373624228,
-0.0444581583,
-0.0739007294,
0.0183595698,
-0.0172512941,
-0.0811326057,
-0.0122954147,
-0.0407716557,
-0.0098970514,
0.0629613996,
-0.0285784807,
-0.0628301501,
1.997701451e-34,
0.026202878,
-0.0149438353,
0.0008230617,
-0.0051672147,
0.0154223908,
0.0128808292,
-0.0619211569,
-0.0007319664,
-0.0488057211,
-0.0731816217,
0.0124240052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21070v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21070v2
|
Generalization Beyond Data Imbalance: A Controlled Study on CLIP for Transferable Insights
| 2024-05-31T17:57:24 | 2024-06-14T16:42:47 |
Xin Wen, Bingchen Zhao, Yilun Chen, Jiangmiao Pang, Xiaojuan Qi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Severe data imbalance naturally exists among web-scale vision-language
datasets. Despite this, we find CLIP pre-trained thereupon exhibits notable
robustness to the data imbalance compared to supervised learning, and
demonstrates significant effectiveness in learning generalizable
representations. With an aim to investigate the reasons behind this finding, we
conduct controlled experiments to study various underlying factors, and reveal
that CLIP's pretext task forms a dynamic classification problem wherein only a
subset of classes is present in training. This isolates the bias from dominant
classes and implicitly balances the learning signal. Furthermore, the
robustness and discriminability of CLIP improve with more descriptive language
supervision, larger data scale, and broader open-world concepts, which are
inaccessible to supervised learning. Our study not only uncovers the mechanisms
behind CLIP's generalizability beyond data imbalance but also provides
transferable insights for the research community. The findings are validated in
both supervised and self-supervised learning, enabling models trained on
imbalanced data to achieve CLIP-level performance on diverse recognition tasks.
Code and data are available at: https://github.com/CVMI-Lab/clip-beyond-tail.
|
[
0.0299783386,
0.0365410373,
-0.013054016,
0.0214267801,
-0.0006154322,
0.0098592406,
-0.0261763725,
0.0195490643,
-0.0534589589,
-0.0198318884,
-0.0639782697,
0.0073153395,
-0.0006455289,
0.0932045951,
-0.009731371,
-0.0678004995,
0.0208751429,
-0.0167142302,
0.0004833568,
0.0128429979,
0.0310312379,
0.0060351933,
0.002852065,
0.0199030023,
-0.0124513479,
0.0404231586,
0.0368324555,
0.0180916935,
0.0451941341,
0.0091955662,
0.0087170452,
0.0332289077,
0.0582619496,
0.0049717939,
0.000001723,
-0.0283874609,
0.013648917,
0.0094782189,
-0.0152348476,
-0.0203797724,
0.0139866639,
-0.0485713333,
0.0066359211,
-0.0087537998,
-0.0186904091,
0.0091076866,
0.0697406679,
0.0444187559,
0.024620384,
0.0415466465,
-0.0147067206,
-0.0107045993,
0.0098837223,
-0.0237797014,
0.0245655794,
-0.0057895356,
0.0214105844,
0.0016634825,
-0.0212775338,
-0.04541618,
-0.059806373,
-0.0081426203,
0.0154446056,
0.0086364327,
0.0353697687,
0.0444358476,
-0.1233112141,
-0.0372565575,
0.0147791738,
0.1103909537,
-0.0464320481,
-0.0222264864,
-0.0106184362,
-0.0323837958,
0.0306319296,
-0.0198941752,
-0.0406718589,
0.0527236015,
0.0268289074,
0.0595951155,
-0.0477655567,
0.0522302687,
0.0132071869,
0.0115105622,
-0.0342113189,
-0.0019319819,
-0.0060708332,
0.0183217376,
0.0228484198,
0.0491143279,
-0.0109242722,
0.008047564,
0.0138110872,
0.0172018539,
0.0039961357,
-0.0019737345,
-0.0770715103,
-0.0259240065,
0.0223695487,
-0.0215923805,
0.0597077087,
0.0548899435,
-0.0824782774,
0.0380580649,
-0.0299403649,
0.0211670808,
0.0183565654,
0.076794073,
0.008578849,
-0.0222036205,
-0.0251758099,
0.0090627009,
-0.0277437679,
0.0191772934,
-0.0153671457,
-0.0266641937,
-0.0310933869,
0.0039314353,
-0.0530276075,
-0.0324568488,
-0.0059965705,
0.0190974697,
-0.0599650145,
0.0062752236,
0.0237991959,
0.0076342388,
-0.0133312065,
0.0347722806,
-0.0170519687,
-0.0974780247,
-0.0172237791,
0.0265631527,
0.0061100652,
-0.0459146276,
0.0119135808,
0.071047157,
-0.027208399,
-0.0499618575,
-0.0419203714,
0.0120692793,
-0.0376146957,
-0.029419018,
-0.0050296211,
-0.0547837019,
0.0243178941,
-0.0048587997,
0.0034563567,
-0.0217676014,
0.0044812872,
-0.003315402,
-0.0385069065,
0.0999257118,
-0.0210774187,
-0.0292492304,
-0.006351369,
0.0158345886,
-0.0233975891,
0.0671169236,
-0.0065775579,
-0.0059222202,
0.0310135484,
0.0319174491,
0.0328544565,
0.020556055,
0.049506098,
0.0338606015,
-0.0638615042,
0.0063227653,
0.0013413398,
-0.0315436721,
0.1005593538,
0.0365271866,
-0.0205855872,
-0.0499875061,
0.0462678559,
0.0270508584,
-0.055417981,
0.0255092401,
0.0250262674,
0.016313836,
-0.008535129,
0.0176453404,
-0.0622659326,
-0.0098162945,
-0.011961868,
-0.0151687693,
-0.028216932,
0.0210417677,
-0.032618627,
-0.0076052472,
0.0072976309,
-0.0010832862,
-0.0009940858,
-0.0001265808,
0.0824953914,
0.0303312726,
0.026599681,
0.0486834496,
0.0438591093,
-0.0243984442,
0.0286432691,
-0.0528615378,
-0.0103899781,
-0.0223994032,
-0.0142008997,
-0.0456861854,
-0.0049020504,
0.0007963114,
0.0043392945,
0.0215799082,
0.0356964208,
0.0054377583,
0.0365476348,
-0.0124668106,
-0.047244139,
-0.0154384915,
0.023999827,
0.0026807217,
0.0052982857,
0.0352360979,
0.0347361192,
-0.0769458413,
-0.0415143967,
0.0371488966,
0.031293273,
-0.025976697,
-0.0083654448,
-0.000432125,
0.0029382154,
-0.0237547923,
-0.0627055094,
-0.0073388843,
0.0116227102,
-0.0355709828,
-0.0205238461,
0.0056930394,
-0.0211779326,
-0.013199266,
0.0571811609,
-0.1181551889,
-0.0438693054,
0.0255394038,
-0.066045858,
-0.026935827,
0.0237559378,
-0.006070565,
0.0367629938,
-0.0457120389,
-0.0081399661,
-0.0056153638,
0.0576334819,
0.0012871332,
0.0315020569,
0.0200528409,
-0.0176989026,
0.0263759699,
-0.0513745993,
0.0037411004,
-0.0231509097,
-0.0055484381,
-0.0010703438,
-0.034126021,
0.0081295269,
0.0155978426,
-0.0039908015,
-0.0389355384,
0.0355359577,
-0.0506065562,
-0.0373125747,
-0.0353810564,
0.0143301403,
-0.0001465364,
-0.0087169297,
-0.0365984179,
-0.0787122101,
-0.020931432,
-0.0504777394,
-0.0029906163,
0.0189310741,
0.0242337249,
0.0193972308,
0.0425088778,
0.0013237891,
-0.0032035161,
0.0341591351,
0.0478759035,
0.0086489255,
-0.0566081591,
-0.0041859555,
0.0336066037,
-0.0139118666,
0.0456131995,
-0.0176983196,
-0.0045682546,
-0.0117767081,
-0.0138783697,
0.017303925,
0.0310569685,
0.0044913981,
0.0087361857,
0.0443274751,
0.0135197006,
-0.0149147687,
-0.0309454277,
0.0117622232,
-0.0105656739,
-0.0212456025,
0.0193498842,
-0.0233845878,
0.0157375801,
-0.0173409823,
-0.0286405571,
-0.0381250978,
0.0099378973,
-0.0401317216,
-0.0265286546,
-0.0939349309,
0.0107747288,
-0.0245205015,
0.038575951,
-0.0203424562,
-0.073311463,
0.0218263883,
0.0025093998,
0.0083349803,
0.0173686501,
-0.0302708987,
-0.0329659022,
0.0665564463,
0.00874402,
0.0177538265,
0.0020683899,
-0.0358751416,
-0.1061092243,
-0.0139209041,
0.0049976557,
-0.0052611297,
0.0372335277,
-0.044431746,
0.0146600995,
-0.0532659292,
-0.0374791548,
-0.0434710644,
-0.0127398968,
-0.0025763328,
0.0130808214,
0.0055615138,
-0.0160751622,
-0.0382963084,
0.0018066816,
-0.0272417758,
0.0703702122,
-0.0142146302,
0.0009974333,
0.014452246,
0.0140234362,
0.0418677516,
-0.0000561679,
0.015279185,
-0.0275619086,
-0.0583397336,
0.048412364,
0.0150550976,
-0.0132166939,
-0.0231165271,
0.0304322708,
0.0307019837,
-0.0248177648,
0.0165345594,
-0.0002869391,
0.0498751253,
-0.043780569,
-0.008965278,
0.0616687462,
-0.002604363,
-0.0670695752,
-0.0150565356,
-0.0161633678,
0.0130688548,
0.0480456389,
0.0152614685,
-0.0567143299,
-0.0292952619,
-0.0024988549,
0.0101191392,
0.0190209169,
-0.0010923112,
-0.023865398,
-0.1225725934,
0.0340685509,
0.0035084093,
-0.0707172602,
-0.0746525973,
0.0241940636,
0.0434075631,
-0.0561120473,
0.0105219549,
-0.0270098336,
-0.0333156474,
0.0042893565,
0.0173739474,
-0.0386918709,
-0.0655132309,
0.0092912493,
-0.0469902419,
-0.0030537394,
0.0489314049,
0.030324243,
-0.018353384,
-0.0174519029,
0.0626604408,
-0.0404226743,
-0.0105772503,
0.0050022877,
0.1175612286,
-0.0308606196,
-0.0141707761,
0.0369110592,
0.05147833,
-0.0154066347,
-0.0165921096,
-0.0199600477,
0.0265081171,
-0.0198188126,
-0.0125788311,
-0.070174478,
-0.0337080397,
0.0271362942,
0.0728878602,
0.0277633797,
-0.0206480976,
-0.0320799351,
-0.0065208576,
-0.0069023124,
-0.031528011,
-0.0236296784,
0.0226702224,
0.0193233546,
-0.0285597388,
-0.0337673165,
-0.0126017835,
-0.0004733099,
0.0312663876,
-0.0011718548,
-0.0585086904,
-0.0433144085,
0.0198294334,
-0.0680132583,
0.0525977947,
-0.0544777587,
0.0196407754,
-0.0393290594,
-0.0140603492,
-0.0268084686,
-0.0711186752,
-0.0443689413,
0.0049705445,
-0.085868679,
-0.0260531381,
-0.0105261113,
0.0566374697,
0.0221290048,
0.0511173978,
-0.0077823098,
-0.0052647633,
0.087038368,
0.0832114369,
-0.0012603415,
-0.0084438268,
0.0643201545,
-0.0686775893,
-0.0081667677,
0.0285903439,
-0.044322446,
0.0352862217,
0.0542840213,
-0.0005188043,
0.0241721272,
0.0227036178,
0.0018730325,
-0.0222247932,
0.0774622709,
0.0034014578,
0.0460536964,
-0.0476174317,
-0.0147613045,
0.0583305247,
0.0045977649,
-0.0542862713,
0.0175607763,
0.0317379609,
0.01177576,
-0.0084482701,
0.0141674001,
-0.0211738106,
-0.0014100298,
-0.0553508662,
-0.0293613467,
0.0536499396,
-0.0344879292,
0.0161062591,
0.0309404619,
0.011101217,
0.0339476876,
-0.0148658697,
0.0133144436,
0.0155303665,
-0.0026036073,
0.043178048,
0.0459408909,
-0.0175399147,
0.0150719024,
-0.0743524507,
-0.0156810526,
-0.0290051736,
0.0540393107,
0.0378254987,
-0.0388227068,
0.0020544974,
-0.0091316923,
-0.0248898659,
-0.0058199172,
0.0140168257,
-0.0128238136,
0.0028461411,
0.0301433001,
-0.0059379106,
-0.0215526763,
0.0038664697,
0.0755538121,
-0.0043491968,
0.0449855961,
-0.006853757,
-0.0080398461,
0.0057360972,
-0.0061580651,
0.0500924103,
0.0156841557,
-0.0072439611,
0.0180063751,
-0.0201076679,
-0.0854180008,
-0.0133146923,
-0.0204078108,
0.0121280188,
0.0450044461,
0.0493070148,
0.0313955583,
-0.0020665913,
-0.0148274219,
0.0046469816,
-0.0283433385,
0.0089035584,
0.0287229121,
0.0159960836,
-5.873499318e-33,
-0.0151497358,
0.023069853,
-0.0098521542,
0.0019799657,
-0.0159957241,
0.016331682,
-0.0140666934,
0.0087996349,
-0.0378071107,
0.0239225905,
-0.0131195812,
0.0441503711,
0.0374165103,
0.0561514534,
-0.0058738529,
-0.0045454754,
0.0502969362,
0.0324293338,
-0.028010834,
0.0333011113,
0.0237313807,
0.0647373274,
0.0890314654,
-0.0189473294,
-0.0018818263,
0.0140900277,
-0.0105437404,
0.020613214,
0.0454700366,
0.0305035319,
-0.016577011,
0.0490808561,
0.0159643814,
0.0032775602,
-0.0547242612,
0.0054659974,
-0.0878692493,
-0.0356870554,
-0.02254132,
0.0451155715,
-0.0230052769,
0.0339460112,
0.0272140093,
-0.030772958,
0.0444411896,
-0.0439361595,
0.0762197301,
-0.0460965931,
-0.0128043657,
-0.0541914888,
-0.0410196595,
0.0327878408,
-0.0012016714,
-0.0070429686,
0.0137894964,
0.0340024829,
0.0215762258,
0.0094326837,
-0.0401209146,
0.0320735574,
0.030227771,
-0.0172823779,
0.0647632554,
0.0471138842,
-0.0022194688,
0.0787932202,
-0.0288620815,
-0.0343141332,
0.0002300472,
-0.0615780242,
0.0390632004,
0.0146159669,
0.0083510168,
0.026574051,
0.1018524989,
0.008295211,
-0.0399191417,
0.0039433995,
-0.0125120766,
0.0341130197,
0.0145592503,
0.0292127579,
0.0069426708,
-0.0166563727,
-0.0063238484,
-0.0503946505,
-0.0353690758,
0.009238841,
0.0339902714,
0.0268873852,
-0.0362202488,
0.0630800724,
0.051612664,
-0.061900977,
-0.0302358903,
0.0364902355,
-0.007551922,
-0.014877568,
0.0151898703,
-0.0311481562,
-0.0565310679,
-0.0283818394,
0.0384761877,
0.0023193755,
-0.0103257913,
-0.0103716291,
0.0914728194,
0.0261358358,
-0.0299129933,
0.0074313991,
-0.0331003219,
0.0169247668,
0.0302639604,
0.1100169346,
0.0465667658,
0.0058779451,
-0.0267020799,
0.0460725762,
0.0118104918,
0.0053641303,
-0.0028243724,
0.0027785157,
-0.0244133566,
0.0162626803,
-0.0305917785,
-0.0318096466,
-0.0131827099,
0.0228988379,
0.0346091203,
-0.0760315284,
-0.0140177933,
-0.0143917892,
2.476e-7,
0.0503887944,
-0.0327845812,
0.0095370803,
-0.0011481264,
-0.0044572433,
0.0123953633,
-0.0136195468,
0.048940409,
-0.028595265,
-0.0186439902,
0.0115164975,
0.0409009233,
0.018820636,
0.0153991329,
-0.0194572508,
0.0070517045,
-0.0704528838,
-0.012747325,
-0.0025652305,
-0.0149913775,
0.0210608896,
0.1121077165,
0.0168250408,
-0.0527963936,
0.0467032306,
-0.0492132083,
0.0540270172,
-0.0246484317,
0.064889349,
-0.0155163081,
-0.027016053,
0.0523216762,
-0.0120270122,
0.0480687581,
-0.0305452291,
0.0103818094,
0.0461281873,
0.00508689,
-0.0213408973,
0.0456415862,
-0.0256249551,
0.0464000516,
0.0199710615,
-0.0452971272,
0.0699945167,
-0.0915217772,
-0.01834259,
-0.0664552227,
-0.0143133802,
-0.0308647826,
0.0401305482,
-0.0233385768,
0.0251168367,
0.0417599268,
0.0144239999,
0.0023700874,
-0.06720227,
-0.1020984575,
-0.0090650963,
-0.0176266842,
-0.0041841231,
-0.0092284875,
-0.0163781624,
-0.0079706898,
0.0170664173,
-0.014354907,
-0.0238615666,
1.844633605e-34,
0.0389854871,
0.011825297,
-0.0271634292,
-0.0366143882,
-0.0159692355,
0.0109156948,
-0.0009062354,
-0.0225955285,
-0.017797295,
0.0274604037,
-0.0117410878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21068v1
|
Code Pretraining Improves Entity Tracking Abilities of Language Models
| 2024-05-31T17:56:33 | 2024-05-31T17:56:33 |
Najoung Kim, Sebastian Schuster, Shubham Toshniwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent work has provided indirect evidence that pretraining language models
on code improves the ability of models to track state changes of discourse
entities expressed in natural language. In this work, we systematically test
this claim by comparing pairs of language models on their entity tracking
performance. Critically, the pairs consist of base models and models trained on
top of these base models with additional code data. We extend this analysis to
additionally examine the effect of math training, another highly structured
data type, and alignment tuning, an important step for enhancing the usability
of models. We find clear evidence that models additionally trained on large
amounts of code outperform the base models. On the other hand, we find no
consistent benefit of additional math training or alignment tuning across
various model families.
|
[
0.0136830332,
0.1289602667,
-0.0261648186,
0.0264167022,
0.0187140163,
0.0309393983,
-0.0058837985,
-0.0023896589,
-0.0164947007,
-0.0611585192,
0.00608959,
-0.0535262637,
0.0029074305,
0.0420231372,
0.0446070023,
-0.0321837105,
0.0626808107,
-0.0351749584,
-0.0212104674,
0.0288605783,
0.0241701081,
0.0190095007,
-0.0265760366,
0.0276550259,
-0.014793124,
-0.0075885043,
-0.0182419829,
-0.0082907667,
0.0077167661,
-0.0261684172,
0.0120244641,
0.0640833005,
0.0416838229,
0.0251093917,
0.0000019032,
-0.0392975211,
-0.025775291,
-0.0003227945,
-0.0561363623,
0.0524754226,
-0.0117634311,
-0.0140982093,
-0.0151846949,
0.0087061813,
-0.0460186638,
-0.0198193341,
0.051032979,
-0.0018934351,
0.0461679362,
0.0621407218,
-0.0204972569,
-0.0160201248,
0.022234017,
-0.0058047688,
-0.0090430444,
-0.0495449975,
0.0223153699,
0.0384832844,
-0.0313693248,
0.0488766432,
-0.0134178959,
0.0163201094,
0.0018497069,
0.0093268808,
0.0235384256,
0.0303438455,
-0.0291592572,
-0.0030062802,
-0.0273476392,
0.0452311151,
0.0368198119,
-0.0254165065,
0.0116286185,
-0.0057746377,
-0.0071635339,
-0.0185329765,
-0.0208463799,
-0.0153009687,
0.0001069048,
0.0187299512,
0.026233308,
-0.0348982476,
0.0206802469,
0.0071111526,
-0.0258886367,
0.023481831,
0.0215509925,
-0.0260870457,
-0.0225059967,
0.0188343003,
0.0030675808,
-0.1073949113,
-0.0033398904,
0.0159119871,
0.0183981471,
0.043332357,
-0.0718999952,
-0.0167814977,
-0.0230284035,
-0.06094772,
0.0254073329,
0.0763682723,
-0.0196967814,
0.0380720794,
-0.0071659796,
0.0812233016,
-0.0229110885,
-0.0371750146,
0.0125801601,
0.0122847231,
-0.055870045,
-0.0208131094,
-0.0409480855,
0.037118841,
0.0003642127,
-0.0039879982,
-0.0315309167,
0.0372604989,
0.040116664,
0.0053714141,
-0.0203105286,
-0.0196103901,
-0.0150612677,
0.0209762231,
-0.0157909207,
0.0213670712,
-0.0291910917,
0.0029021231,
-0.0086751375,
-0.0728833899,
0.0105362469,
-0.0254286174,
0.0027922508,
-0.0218169671,
-0.0015360456,
0.0277160183,
0.0281257611,
-0.0242106318,
-0.0275243595,
0.0038721624,
-0.0018105211,
-0.0517017581,
-0.0283279251,
-0.0857236683,
0.0162294563,
0.0321781449,
0.0099985711,
-0.0939883739,
0.0055390792,
-0.0048502018,
-0.0391185209,
0.0606205761,
-0.0828674287,
0.0078299623,
-0.003337374,
-0.0160939675,
0.0343765281,
0.077980116,
0.0576101467,
-0.074488245,
0.0386383235,
-0.0536709242,
0.005140841,
0.0289053246,
0.0015127134,
0.0158354454,
-0.0277300216,
0.025484059,
0.0151154082,
-0.0120378733,
0.0280266572,
-0.0028305361,
-0.0222661123,
-0.0017344181,
0.0520734489,
0.0428681299,
-0.0055275545,
0.0233162791,
0.0422873758,
-0.0286289919,
0.0346960463,
0.0045694318,
-0.042396374,
0.0038608636,
0.0104302159,
-0.0071173781,
-0.0260355733,
0.0171133857,
-0.0243128017,
-0.0333232805,
-0.0114236204,
-0.0096992627,
0.0204245169,
-0.0082955547,
0.0375563167,
-0.0157298818,
-0.0164404642,
0.0644381642,
0.0449373312,
-0.0918881074,
-0.031829685,
-0.0131845884,
-0.0107689891,
0.0537928119,
0.0116962045,
-0.0133274384,
-0.0473026298,
-0.0359368287,
0.0048457175,
0.0201669578,
0.0529815741,
0.0018137665,
0.0346634425,
-0.0278529525,
-0.0168937054,
-0.0305242892,
0.0165873058,
0.0246533565,
0.0522364341,
-0.0131338621,
0.0182215143,
-0.0058014235,
-0.0417393856,
0.0513550714,
-0.0387764983,
0.0037903308,
-0.0567616485,
-0.0156129105,
0.0136914039,
0.0176087469,
-0.0045746146,
-0.0183447246,
0.0241864305,
0.0282597039,
0.038170293,
0.0122752925,
-0.0007576732,
-0.0188783891,
0.0576986857,
0.042462416,
-0.0245916471,
0.0066211885,
0.0161192305,
-0.0285109375,
-0.0000865621,
-0.0503859557,
0.0750843212,
-0.0171104055,
0.0292885657,
-0.0224622712,
-0.0240031276,
-0.01125276,
0.0539873056,
0.0252604615,
0.0191685539,
0.0073545701,
0.0152731938,
0.0080401571,
0.0035649668,
-0.0091124242,
0.0194382537,
0.0168129411,
0.0112413289,
0.0368092842,
-0.0457980111,
-0.0512970462,
0.0029858567,
-0.1182339489,
0.0150012476,
-0.0371204205,
0.0359006636,
0.0242668297,
0.0159857962,
-0.0319256783,
-0.0061924313,
-0.0299834311,
-0.0557245314,
-0.0320884585,
0.0064272592,
0.0248046368,
-0.0170219876,
-0.0392343178,
-0.0677275285,
0.0038383668,
-0.0433343127,
0.0367849879,
0.0114705507,
-0.0410212614,
-0.0755686611,
0.0602937639,
-0.0671939626,
0.03164896,
-0.017992707,
-0.0482170358,
0.040115349,
0.0346156582,
0.0757508427,
0.056190636,
-0.0160845872,
0.0655945837,
0.0095483661,
-0.0201188587,
-0.0677312613,
0.0034600508,
0.0047748522,
0.0102727702,
-0.0701068863,
-0.019013267,
-0.011085948,
0.0970469564,
-0.0003244203,
-0.0008650094,
-0.0521046817,
0.0290347245,
-0.0200287253,
-0.0110323597,
0.0134037985,
-0.0146973729,
-0.0393508747,
0.0554811917,
-0.006980238,
-0.0504056029,
0.0441865772,
-0.0512234867,
-0.0409455411,
-0.0170324538,
-0.0120981513,
-0.0333596058,
0.0160168968,
0.0447883308,
0.0114827361,
0.0071877781,
-0.0364364237,
-0.0205681678,
0.0260335524,
0.0099861929,
-0.0255395155,
0.0625306219,
-0.0489150435,
0.0439981781,
0.0157037992,
-0.0162043665,
-0.0568733662,
-0.0173576921,
-0.0209409688,
0.0209881291,
0.0149831362,
-0.0341554582,
0.0077593843,
0.0219004545,
0.0218252689,
0.0372294374,
0.0130811445,
-0.0063042855,
-0.0204792675,
-0.0204199068,
0.0105398037,
-0.0349236801,
0.0085424846,
-0.0572536252,
-0.0032571051,
0.0233606976,
0.0593399853,
0.004241494,
-0.0468047895,
0.0063707931,
0.0145630604,
-0.0592736863,
-0.0632969737,
0.0245889183,
0.0680952817,
-0.047386732,
0.0000503754,
0.1180419698,
0.0459422357,
0.0148301646,
-0.0072667254,
0.018211063,
0.0346202813,
0.0543419011,
-0.0123201897,
-0.0661224946,
-0.0093384264,
0.0043442799,
0.0104991272,
0.0010909898,
-0.0462943427,
-0.0142763583,
-0.0913325474,
-0.0338720754,
0.0018496239,
-0.0568598956,
-0.0112043163,
-0.0288089514,
0.0459753126,
-0.0069133951,
-0.0242584273,
0.0172619373,
-0.0110425502,
0.0107905781,
0.0467288531,
-0.0613635033,
-0.0020798172,
-0.0086983684,
-0.0623239502,
0.0543057509,
0.0991356745,
0.0259947106,
-0.0105051072,
-0.0027513637,
0.0124975881,
-0.0089188274,
-0.011315776,
0.0026650813,
0.0735219046,
-0.0452108569,
-0.0296426173,
-0.0085120397,
0.012107241,
-0.0100753922,
-0.0087780729,
-0.0056919549,
0.0099747628,
-0.0255961586,
0.0187927987,
0.0109797064,
-0.0179424249,
-0.0148017351,
0.0490301959,
0.0361408703,
-0.0435514599,
0.0045864438,
-0.0523812957,
0.0213763844,
-0.0013172529,
-0.0309086256,
-0.0281702355,
-0.0189992636,
-0.0134445727,
-0.0719342083,
-0.0713130608,
0.0423310325,
0.059853211,
0.0144267147,
0.0220802389,
0.0440972373,
-0.0147774471,
-0.0227540191,
0.0349497423,
-0.0414424688,
0.0409867242,
-0.0530947335,
-0.0582535043,
0.0346328653,
0.0315556712,
-0.0224946793,
-0.0328509323,
-0.0887254626,
-0.0797192752,
0.0127327573,
0.0333299153,
0.0267874543,
0.047153797,
-0.0001416541,
-0.0094066933,
-0.0929089487,
-0.0277858805,
-0.0598307736,
0.055986464,
0.0296746995,
-0.0008791051,
-0.0042275167,
0.0119412616,
0.005507594,
0.0148312887,
0.0212502386,
0.033301536,
-0.0957481861,
-0.0453487374,
0.0159368217,
-0.0185557697,
0.0432432815,
0.0042634113,
-0.0276726242,
-0.0169177894,
0.0047051813,
-0.03231024,
-0.0192430448,
-0.0403217338,
-0.0263603833,
0.0094383266,
0.0413193181,
-0.0254905075,
0.0446231216,
-0.0257979725,
0.0521509238,
-0.0295050815,
0.0255259797,
-0.0172235072,
0.0463791601,
0.0385554247,
0.0041830805,
-0.0016341188,
0.0377927832,
-0.011213338,
0.0397370718,
-0.0198098924,
0.0549281575,
0.0117817428,
0.0123918606,
0.0149980811,
-0.0274286941,
-0.0593372025,
-0.0293374211,
0.0075300392,
0.023392247,
0.040233478,
-0.0325076282,
0.0754647106,
0.002600919,
-0.0057365005,
-0.0017883969,
0.0533110239,
0.0247567184,
-0.0030925241,
0.0226525888,
0.026332343,
-0.0335284583,
-0.0257658251,
0.0709609017,
0.0491609275,
0.0566189177,
-0.0086437063,
0.0046997662,
-0.0154895512,
0.0176423229,
0.0470122844,
-0.0069011184,
-0.0015517523,
0.0152063696,
-0.0434908792,
-0.0637473166,
0.025427144,
-0.0314978957,
-0.0067497063,
-0.0235913526,
0.0677347779,
0.0665003136,
-0.0323382244,
0.0035607992,
-0.0475902073,
-0.0070931488,
0.022384109,
0.0009171171,
-0.0507417582,
-5.828448497e-33,
-0.0684596822,
-0.0246189162,
0.0127498116,
0.0153290527,
-0.0281531531,
0.0177876502,
-0.0367922485,
0.0213428661,
-0.0146990381,
-0.0280242879,
0.0320257582,
0.0587200597,
0.0013578216,
-0.0267393515,
-0.008217982,
-0.0271899793,
0.04891764,
0.0131012294,
-0.0342180543,
-0.0281028468,
0.0036241787,
0.0296883788,
0.0932056755,
-0.0688020736,
0.0530118048,
-0.0028153441,
0.0309885293,
-0.035113804,
0.0379762612,
0.0634357408,
0.0007775095,
-0.0235613696,
0.0026917967,
-0.0245573502,
-0.0307520106,
0.0283991452,
-0.0379897207,
-0.0169760305,
0.0556350499,
0.0386961512,
0.0167946946,
-0.0397221744,
0.0347489789,
-0.0224405862,
-0.0163266715,
0.011889399,
0.0447253995,
-0.0303954892,
-0.0091021098,
-0.0064353812,
-0.0753514841,
0.0495290942,
-0.0360248089,
0.0215352569,
0.0247238483,
0.0224632286,
0.0363697,
-0.0149159292,
-0.0510211028,
-0.0165029876,
-0.000505066,
0.012501332,
0.0157553405,
0.0038005952,
0.0078459103,
0.0582352355,
0.0376030318,
-0.0081739333,
-0.0611329824,
0.0209941622,
0.0707805529,
0.020033462,
0.0647541881,
0.0071632881,
0.0116352607,
0.0097278766,
-0.0655813366,
-0.0090838671,
-0.0422816277,
0.0114914589,
-0.0084861228,
0.0366985649,
-0.0705421939,
-0.0175645147,
-0.0271952022,
-0.0027234084,
-0.0099704787,
-0.0257348977,
0.0173203032,
-0.0282373279,
-0.0300784633,
0.0268614925,
0.0399187692,
-0.0427210517,
-0.0693830624,
0.0215155818,
-0.020567758,
0.0473598428,
-0.0112998439,
0.0208619479,
-0.0642851219,
0.0079091433,
0.0296198726,
0.0082983309,
0.0606616624,
-0.0016375136,
0.0297973305,
-0.0083997147,
-0.0860871002,
-0.0178142264,
-0.0211542435,
-0.0028779279,
-0.0231001042,
0.0374875143,
0.0579739511,
0.0178053807,
0.0117071178,
0.0591694526,
0.0295160525,
-0.0387505256,
-0.0797127932,
-0.0050031617,
-0.0003230047,
0.0378672257,
-0.0131315077,
-0.0547193028,
-0.0286747366,
0.0426656045,
0.0334770828,
-0.0338713266,
-0.0350684002,
0.0090078339,
2.496e-7,
0.0748881921,
0.0555903167,
0.0496515706,
0.0021531456,
-0.0021093516,
0.0361316316,
-0.0379282869,
0.0052096196,
0.0514396168,
-0.0317257494,
-0.0289485808,
0.0332268029,
0.0564718731,
0.034486793,
-0.0621530376,
-0.0384884886,
-0.0251993518,
0.0119675193,
-0.0778837726,
0.037924964,
0.0031988181,
0.0611822121,
0.0350318998,
0.0359307602,
0.002397635,
0.0073115146,
0.0739539936,
-0.0096170539,
0.0118791284,
0.038851656,
-0.0518162847,
0.0448960252,
-0.0268077422,
0.016178932,
-0.0195280593,
0.0308069531,
0.0324195102,
0.0601140186,
-0.0344150513,
0.0539607666,
-0.0197505374,
-0.0157887153,
-0.0119695859,
-0.0403753668,
0.0628809482,
-0.0118428124,
-0.0048585725,
-0.0155817932,
-0.0273180492,
0.0179311186,
0.004090332,
0.0329142064,
-0.0095156813,
0.0157379378,
0.0196413286,
-0.0236942172,
-0.0412676856,
-0.0595452376,
-0.0488972589,
0.0195406582,
-0.0060640634,
-0.0446174778,
-0.0219479445,
-0.0272420589,
0.0017016586,
-0.0432998687,
0.001497606,
2.607251291e-34,
0.01451365,
-0.0000662401,
0.031158708,
0.0691462085,
0.0635101497,
-0.0279269852,
0.0004907724,
0.0112675708,
0.0149268815,
-0.0497755706,
0.0245522317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21047v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21047v1
|
Grammar-Aligned Decoding
| 2024-05-31T17:39:15 | 2024-05-31T17:39:15 |
Kanghee Park, Jiayu Wang, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick, Nadia Polikarpova, Loris D'Antoni
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle with reliably generating highly
structured outputs, such as program code, mathematical formulas, or well-formed
markup. Constrained decoding approaches mitigate this problem by greedily
restricting what tokens an LLM can output at each step to guarantee that the
output matches a given constraint. Specifically, in grammar-constrained
decoding (GCD), the LLM's output must follow a given grammar. In this paper we
demonstrate that GCD techniques (and in general constrained decoding
techniques) can distort the LLM's distribution, leading to outputs that are
grammatical but appear with likelihoods that are not proportional to the ones
given by the LLM, and so ultimately are low-quality. We call the problem of
aligning sampling with a grammar constraint, grammar-aligned decoding (GAD),
and propose adaptive sampling with approximate expected futures (ASAp), a
decoding algorithm that guarantees the output to be grammatical while provably
producing outputs that match the conditional probability of the LLM's
distribution conditioned on the given grammar constraint. Our algorithm uses
prior sample outputs to soundly overapproximate the future grammaticality of
different output prefixes. Our evaluation on code generation and structured NLP
tasks shows how ASAp often produces outputs with higher likelihood (according
to the LLM's distribution) than existing GCD techniques, while still enforcing
the desired grammatical constraints.
|
[
0.0133501841,
0.1154755875,
-0.0105786026,
0.0140973981,
-0.0068574203,
0.0023767743,
-0.0593671724,
0.0127082672,
-0.0415938422,
-0.0343425833,
0.0080356142,
-0.0012719302,
0.0028116526,
0.0179837067,
0.0330672562,
-0.0291180667,
0.0358773768,
-0.0475060008,
-0.0366983041,
0.010022616,
0.0418937691,
0.0444648974,
0.0100402124,
0.0777485222,
-0.040699143,
-0.0417776033,
0.0069736075,
-0.0072954358,
-0.0244208705,
-0.0126698129,
-0.0000428997,
0.0256105606,
-0.0177001636,
0.0129958168,
0.0000021849,
-0.0346858278,
-0.0255325437,
-0.0058817696,
-0.0254791379,
0.0459418185,
0.0249091331,
-0.0612972677,
-0.0182583556,
0.0091762049,
-0.0304482579,
-0.0142549407,
0.0497677922,
-0.0307040829,
0.0665061399,
0.0643905699,
0.0037161219,
0.0003083276,
0.0333121642,
-0.0001637443,
-0.0320000425,
-0.0205898993,
0.0056579383,
0.0055648638,
0.0021257326,
-0.0052973297,
-0.0166874398,
0.0261440016,
0.0134572722,
-0.0210890751,
0.022428304,
0.0567697734,
-0.0260704607,
-0.0123856319,
-0.0563418455,
0.0218489412,
0.0025572423,
-0.0598121323,
0.0232591238,
-0.0452825837,
-0.0128095662,
-0.0198246539,
-0.0578066297,
0.0642151088,
-0.0225028936,
0.0804732144,
0.0773456097,
-0.0033038862,
0.0263878275,
-0.0102502927,
-0.0057521383,
0.0652492344,
0.0053601488,
-0.0346980914,
-0.0265345369,
0.0677422583,
-0.0149784135,
-0.0597439595,
0.0260233972,
0.0072853193,
-0.0340207815,
0.0103862686,
-0.1075471938,
-0.0773938224,
-0.0176384151,
0.005966071,
0.0455444753,
0.0617590398,
0.0437741652,
0.0017942502,
-0.0033366301,
0.0436689183,
-0.0082029467,
-0.0047985949,
-0.0462948903,
0.0467732176,
-0.0177171007,
-0.0234710593,
-0.0477287546,
0.0645211041,
-0.0495809242,
-0.019611476,
-0.0220273174,
0.0305090509,
0.0118525941,
0.0239431038,
0.0542209856,
-0.0046943626,
-0.0659878775,
-0.0119101712,
0.0548877753,
-0.0042736973,
-0.0168055221,
-0.0107227014,
0.0160409696,
-0.0292887073,
-0.0306497756,
0.0328859128,
-0.0159357544,
-0.0222286619,
-0.0625324845,
0.0841930136,
0.0062145726,
0.0332099684,
-0.0274493229,
-0.0332336947,
-0.0127224745,
0.0049416395,
0.0106476825,
-0.0726675093,
-0.0254873838,
0.0400914811,
0.0187910218,
-0.0430154428,
0.0080419555,
-0.0319047086,
-0.0003515228,
0.0236704294,
-0.0057209539,
0.0110939015,
-0.0177041534,
-0.0285016559,
0.0290921312,
0.0670069233,
0.0269337725,
-0.0011572174,
0.007574908,
0.0218789335,
0.0029032743,
0.0702221096,
-0.006026817,
0.0046514017,
0.0078098197,
-0.023953028,
0.034394335,
0.0096542016,
0.0814329237,
0.061143443,
-0.0259644687,
0.0193677489,
0.0342055634,
0.0101101082,
-0.0266948082,
0.0161522478,
0.0494978689,
-0.0041734339,
-0.0169025306,
0.0502014868,
-0.0485165156,
0.0014826406,
0.0004906874,
0.0099929664,
0.0279726796,
0.02787688,
0.0058923722,
-0.054693412,
0.0094355382,
-0.0209033266,
-0.0314341523,
-0.0181169175,
0.0311358403,
0.0415592119,
-0.0470489785,
0.075547792,
0.0172500219,
-0.0302883703,
0.0337395668,
-0.0309729576,
0.0305692684,
0.0147019168,
0.0706492215,
-0.0083277673,
-0.0004538972,
0.0111175189,
-0.0273248646,
0.0336817764,
0.0171721522,
-0.0106914369,
0.0145505974,
-0.0205259733,
-0.0137227904,
0.0174117722,
0.0242823288,
0.0255650245,
0.0246494971,
-0.0186239146,
0.0142268529,
-0.0256397482,
-0.0303971935,
0.0459814742,
-0.0107327253,
-0.0373041555,
0.0153511893,
-0.042979639,
0.0399705209,
-0.028639378,
-0.0378955454,
0.0472847223,
0.0104734199,
-0.0266494267,
-0.0078655062,
-0.0280737802,
-0.0694056898,
-0.0550700948,
0.0254369136,
-0.0294345822,
-0.013030706,
0.0161334891,
-0.0211647209,
-0.0265968964,
0.0541402251,
-0.0600731373,
0.0762123391,
-0.0164531954,
0.0282252524,
0.0449062213,
-0.0263363905,
-0.0443004556,
0.0271408297,
-0.0258262139,
-0.0058006966,
-0.0056141983,
-0.0022669334,
-0.0100669581,
-0.0260345396,
-0.0050671925,
-0.0039895205,
-0.0229501426,
0.0231538601,
0.0322700404,
0.0377656966,
-0.0172016248,
-0.0302931368,
-0.0519073866,
0.0153051559,
-0.0185681563,
0.0510683022,
0.032789398,
0.0153135071,
-0.0031294327,
-0.0180347618,
-0.0247710515,
0.0106660686,
0.0103228483,
-0.0132019334,
0.0164712667,
0.0318188481,
-0.0061440882,
-0.034400925,
-0.0090482896,
-0.0170602538,
0.0246666335,
0.0236938577,
-0.0069245384,
-0.0937885121,
0.0821654275,
0.0277385823,
0.0177660659,
0.0248193666,
-0.0142066739,
0.0082489504,
-0.0463574752,
0.0615720041,
0.0290645007,
-0.0265166555,
0.0005364893,
0.0124808,
-0.0007204009,
-0.0570486076,
-0.0079086255,
-0.0250859745,
-0.0607809126,
-0.0494138747,
-0.0288811456,
0.0672984421,
0.1095767543,
0.0632867515,
-0.0062245121,
-0.056371741,
0.042152416,
-0.0446760692,
-0.0440706313,
0.0020830478,
0.0045682462,
-0.0284336414,
0.0518224239,
-0.0149297146,
-0.0815131292,
0.0625277832,
-0.0316555649,
-0.0008185297,
-0.0042665428,
0.0203262456,
-0.0281448644,
0.0138359247,
0.0099149011,
0.0118230507,
0.0231120866,
-0.0595253333,
-0.0344184339,
0.0428119637,
-0.0002815693,
-0.0183393899,
0.0362563953,
-0.066272065,
0.0278850719,
-0.0002137957,
-0.063000679,
-0.0403655693,
-0.0333354771,
-0.0192000829,
-0.0235401951,
0.0292088632,
0.0029393381,
0.0289360639,
-0.0032229691,
-0.0405402109,
0.0156778954,
-0.0124159204,
-0.0301712733,
-0.0360724144,
0.0250953566,
0.0518329255,
-0.0291782115,
-0.0203339811,
-0.0344402902,
-0.0413822345,
0.0535713919,
0.0375472233,
0.0829897299,
-0.0302748643,
0.0161152948,
0.0566477478,
0.0121076889,
-0.0596072525,
0.0572444983,
0.038912639,
-0.0423449464,
-0.036242947,
0.101857014,
0.043495927,
-0.0116117541,
0.0362045132,
-0.002912719,
0.0684439093,
0.0132298851,
0.0061728642,
-0.055391334,
-0.0365796871,
0.0327198356,
0.0504336953,
-0.0063973498,
-0.0339930765,
0.0058571086,
-0.1311784834,
0.0160167199,
0.0432447344,
0.0069412091,
-0.024638826,
-0.0390253663,
-0.0199405029,
-0.0195607878,
0.0084275603,
0.0347418897,
0.0017293503,
0.0402379408,
0.0463446043,
-0.0277970247,
0.0072117867,
-0.022670174,
-0.0056545804,
0.044555787,
0.1093777195,
0.0118133379,
0.0105881896,
0.0008499081,
0.0229074638,
-0.0332913585,
-0.0115103014,
-0.0226817522,
-0.0138454689,
0.0068686199,
-0.0066747172,
-0.0065209838,
0.033511702,
-0.0560170747,
-0.0099797705,
0.0176260564,
0.1000970528,
-0.0240299515,
-0.0284453016,
-0.0259885285,
-0.0122038722,
0.0165573098,
0.0437424183,
0.0394915566,
-0.0259364359,
-0.0619930327,
-0.1200765371,
0.042195417,
-0.0707953274,
-0.0050192541,
0.0253750701,
-0.0019188683,
-0.010898089,
-0.095949851,
-0.026164975,
0.0094483057,
0.0112688933,
0.030256208,
-0.0041346145,
0.0515131988,
-0.0480148941,
-0.0055656168,
-0.0159780644,
-0.0499611981,
-0.0071680942,
-0.0662036762,
-0.0169398431,
-0.0119888773,
-0.0121415788,
-0.0119795669,
0.0405806489,
-0.0925875679,
-0.0570289046,
-0.0250556637,
0.042053666,
0.0180088375,
0.0309142694,
-0.0280423556,
-0.0453927293,
-0.0347532816,
0.0556780286,
-0.0264335535,
0.043864619,
0.0146575682,
-0.0150589719,
0.0244484618,
0.0227505825,
-0.0615842082,
0.0092176171,
0.0180890877,
0.062951766,
-0.0338262729,
-0.0113604888,
0.0804338455,
0.0614254661,
0.0182805769,
-0.0476626456,
-0.0015800291,
0.0120142866,
-0.0218815077,
-0.0122465324,
-0.0083167013,
-0.0411876887,
0.0334149078,
0.0548502281,
-0.0033096063,
-0.0062828287,
0.0367763862,
-0.0031590248,
0.0357508473,
-0.0390871689,
-0.00857714,
0.0137755629,
-0.0124153709,
0.0620952174,
-0.0066080475,
-0.0123781227,
-0.0033402871,
0.0056986539,
0.0236215722,
-0.0239747148,
-0.0106431656,
0.0299803652,
0.0251846593,
0.0081705991,
-0.0307463817,
-0.0344758406,
-0.0046981513,
-0.0207212511,
0.0091168424,
0.0322511047,
0.003599508,
0.0573781393,
-0.0323805399,
0.0250507407,
-0.0421484262,
0.0633532777,
0.0280716643,
-0.023742944,
0.0245381482,
-0.0034307991,
-0.0170081053,
-0.0438158661,
0.0883821547,
0.0003997432,
0.0376777649,
0.0067547234,
-0.0109003615,
-0.0439819433,
-0.0325808637,
-0.0151458709,
-0.0205275193,
-0.0074796854,
0.0129060084,
-0.0287825111,
-0.0562914312,
-0.0501566678,
0.0454496443,
0.0139245642,
-0.0583881103,
0.0232029036,
0.0429618061,
-0.0523897558,
-0.0376022086,
-0.0477514081,
0.0263181254,
-0.0115261106,
-0.05496905,
-0.0230445135,
-6.33682262e-33,
-0.0436648503,
0.004632738,
-0.0145094916,
0.0165970176,
-0.0015289383,
-0.0081013804,
-0.0539409928,
0.0005424219,
0.0556401536,
-0.0068265228,
-0.0274076499,
0.0062546069,
-0.0019504491,
0.0290820356,
0.0293778442,
0.0202252176,
0.0493764542,
-0.0294971354,
-0.0605638362,
0.0109561905,
0.0027999356,
0.0286384095,
0.021246586,
-0.0053548659,
-0.0108989105,
0.0100370143,
-0.0047383704,
-0.0099686179,
0.0249773264,
0.0670205429,
-0.007627435,
0.0498827174,
0.0062245815,
-0.0322946534,
-0.0722248256,
-0.000853573,
-0.0688540414,
-0.015724685,
0.040570505,
0.0219522696,
-0.0190236233,
-0.0350433737,
0.0067453366,
0.0134727154,
-0.0849235877,
0.0055809226,
0.0072535579,
-0.0156472214,
-0.0061326846,
-0.0363318697,
-0.024860166,
0.0237383563,
-0.012578629,
0.008373145,
0.0339311846,
0.0190183651,
-0.0114153884,
0.02231865,
0.035623569,
0.0117650982,
0.0402908176,
0.1020114273,
0.0657371804,
0.00684168,
-0.0033683006,
0.026707463,
-0.0231358372,
-0.0422287211,
-0.034789402,
0.0368277878,
0.008057029,
0.0098411012,
-0.0470247306,
0.0156608652,
0.0436590984,
-0.0065428466,
-0.0079327514,
0.0148740308,
-0.0044833566,
0.0092596328,
0.0277289245,
0.0439426042,
-0.0355359837,
-0.0546663962,
-0.0436598882,
-0.0096749244,
-0.0012933762,
0.0162984524,
0.0561935902,
0.0230595991,
-0.0215854831,
-0.0060016098,
0.0126066776,
-0.0517475195,
-0.0148593457,
0.0100931302,
-0.0246779695,
0.0137354452,
-0.0285131391,
0.0279776324,
-0.0320304744,
-0.0018815536,
0.038119778,
-0.0323956944,
0.046077922,
0.020977525,
0.0017439561,
-0.0003323006,
-0.0525841489,
-0.0004641113,
-0.0605651699,
0.023605004,
0.0189917162,
0.0025984752,
0.0631191283,
-0.0106907235,
0.0086885188,
-0.0070284447,
0.0007886571,
-0.0244224537,
-0.0403997898,
-0.0190458652,
0.0019377558,
0.0188006461,
-0.064077206,
-0.0374198668,
-0.0365181677,
0.0220800247,
0.0481370352,
-0.065874435,
-0.0645192564,
0.0255297795,
2.77e-7,
0.0589047186,
0.0394125767,
0.0385529846,
0.0331669599,
0.0447170362,
0.0264444239,
-0.0100432988,
0.0406312495,
-0.0113544781,
-0.0450652689,
-0.037325386,
-0.0128549486,
0.0429562666,
0.0111567248,
-0.0823013708,
0.0333211832,
-0.0317655057,
0.0489854999,
-0.0420166887,
-0.0291667953,
0.0488200635,
0.0822782144,
-0.0143950609,
0.0036849598,
0.0164646748,
-0.0593143478,
0.0363362283,
0.0058627962,
-0.002907973,
0.0207894854,
-0.040588066,
-0.0133330179,
0.017185213,
-0.0106887706,
-0.00277387,
-0.0251608342,
0.0298778433,
0.0795263574,
-0.0129503217,
0.0352024585,
0.0157554746,
-0.0115456758,
0.0128027936,
-0.0339147933,
0.0192702916,
-0.0168534294,
0.0100821126,
-0.0214909799,
-0.0294163805,
0.00768829,
-0.0806704089,
0.0077832597,
0.0066434056,
0.0290699489,
0.0354983918,
0.030552933,
-0.0214454625,
-0.0094547123,
-0.0466742776,
0.0082476782,
-0.0278244708,
-0.0617973581,
-0.0344600305,
0.044675909,
0.0182167739,
-0.0740982369,
-0.0219605323,
3.064763565e-34,
0.0189032815,
0.0026548516,
0.0295875166,
0.0557189696,
0.0239725634,
-0.0126591073,
-0.0014974226,
0.0618296638,
0.0120827258,
-0.0541836731,
-0.0431879535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21046v1
|
Exploratory Preference Optimization: Harnessing Implicit Q*-Approximation for Sample-Efficient RLHF
| 2024-05-31T17:39:06 | 2024-05-31T17:39:06 |
Tengyang Xie, Dylan J. Foster, Akshay Krishnamurthy, Corby Rosset, Ahmed Awadallah, Alexander Rakhlin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has emerged as a central
tool for language model alignment. We consider online exploration in RLHF,
which exploits interactive access to human or AI feedback by deliberately
encouraging the model to produce diverse, maximally informative responses. By
allowing RLHF to confidently stray from the pre-trained model, online
exploration offers the possibility of novel, potentially super-human
capabilities, but its full potential as a paradigm for language model training
has yet to be realized, owing to computational and statistical bottlenecks in
directly adapting existing reinforcement learning techniques. We propose a new
algorithm for online exploration in RLHF, Exploratory Preference Optimization
(XPO), which is simple and practical -- a one-line change to (online) Direct
Preference Optimization (DPO; Rafailov et al., 2023) -- yet enjoys the
strongest known provable guarantees and promising empirical performance. XPO
augments the DPO objective with a novel and principled exploration bonus,
empowering the algorithm to explore outside the support of the initial model
and human feedback data. In theory, we show that XPO is provably
sample-efficient and converges to a near-optimal language model policy under
natural exploration conditions, irrespective of whether the initial model has
good coverage. Our analysis, which builds on the observation that DPO
implicitly performs a form of $Q^{\star}$-approximation (or, Bellman error
minimization), combines previously disparate techniques from language modeling
and theoretical reinforcement learning in a serendipitous fashion through the
perspective of KL-regularized Markov decision processes. Empirically, we find
that XPO is more sample-efficient than non-exploratory DPO variants in a
preliminary evaluation.
|
[
0.0495311655,
0.0803362876,
0.008185395,
-0.0224205051,
-0.0196775608,
0.0097652897,
-0.0587637909,
0.0044435738,
-0.0240675397,
-0.0063781859,
-0.0308788773,
-0.0415569022,
-0.0179186258,
0.0060147871,
-0.0003553962,
-0.0509282872,
0.0277243014,
-0.0520048328,
-0.0006973404,
-0.029716922,
0.0100834547,
-0.0069927638,
-0.01229137,
0.0508585051,
0.0329426751,
0.0137593346,
-0.0417349041,
-0.0157376397,
0.024211105,
-0.0277814902,
-0.0042046676,
0.0676166043,
0.0437972099,
0.0536870919,
0.0000020513,
-0.0523060299,
-0.0328273512,
-0.0038136386,
-0.013143084,
-0.0279616807,
0.0244088508,
0.0162587073,
0.0010870234,
0.0089711081,
-0.00375977,
-0.0055647665,
0.08835648,
0.0136384647,
0.007609529,
0.0618780963,
0.0091480436,
0.0212422237,
-0.024920458,
-0.0471950062,
0.0233995486,
-0.0417872183,
0.0311742872,
-0.0445271954,
0.0388106555,
-0.0193267036,
-0.0363048166,
0.0094785718,
-0.005374705,
-0.005578083,
0.0083729876,
0.0396953784,
0.029036209,
-0.0124999573,
-0.0184860695,
0.0793870389,
-0.0252486393,
0.0003075406,
0.006277645,
-0.023354765,
-0.0257811435,
0.0434319638,
-0.0165234674,
0.0070503866,
-0.0061460044,
0.0394761562,
0.0270539932,
-0.0355112888,
0.0425788797,
0.0358800404,
-0.013092706,
0.0980145857,
-0.0007508273,
-0.0564201996,
0.0747507438,
0.0369700566,
-0.0186148509,
-0.0543486439,
-0.0120468047,
-0.0108707398,
-0.0874250606,
0.0322295539,
-0.0139308814,
0.0161372125,
-0.0100062983,
-0.0045115589,
0.0869490132,
0.073309496,
0.0279816464,
0.0283327177,
0.0444930121,
0.0210377704,
-0.0131064737,
0.0194418244,
-0.0128596397,
0.0376565084,
-0.0468436927,
0.0028017089,
-0.0332868733,
0.0213533603,
-0.0242656097,
-0.0127247395,
-0.0248227343,
0.0463535376,
-0.0237459484,
0.0284820348,
-0.0214469358,
-0.0060035121,
-0.0810116678,
0.0081050154,
-0.0766094625,
0.0060416651,
-0.049361445,
0.0099664424,
0.0137145072,
0.001997272,
-0.0073997807,
0.0045625214,
-0.008885419,
-0.0524880625,
-0.0251523089,
0.0725791678,
-0.0227491576,
-0.0251303092,
0.0488244593,
0.0160526112,
-0.0257432293,
-0.0352409668,
-0.0169754401,
-0.0574463233,
0.0357429199,
-0.0339704975,
-0.0174364839,
-0.0185743943,
0.0060881996,
0.0217170864,
-0.0141859697,
0.0554681867,
-0.0037961651,
0.014673871,
-0.0011818631,
-0.0377066173,
-0.0258178599,
0.0797230229,
0.0256803092,
0.01202056,
0.0021317529,
0.0037493301,
-0.0001945338,
0.0534694232,
0.0241368953,
0.0601455532,
-0.0546621904,
-0.0081304098,
-0.0264022611,
0.0811701342,
0.0446599014,
0.036134176,
-0.0624804497,
0.0147561254,
0.0441555008,
0.0339733064,
-0.015950853,
-0.0198863018,
0.0283285286,
0.0416288152,
-0.0050834212,
0.0033289513,
-0.0492064282,
0.0178901106,
-0.0164777879,
0.0220350828,
0.0342524573,
0.001034532,
0.0012653319,
-0.0359987691,
-0.0066847806,
-0.0005882219,
0.0373037755,
0.0362995192,
0.05944819,
0.001383742,
-0.0202003215,
-0.0149413198,
0.0585172661,
-0.0028530953,
0.0017765419,
-0.0517038517,
0.0672447234,
0.0730253831,
0.0436345898,
-0.0452169031,
-0.0164679904,
-0.0297653433,
-0.0374222398,
0.0782866105,
0.0710835978,
-0.0490894988,
0.0100681186,
-0.0147368265,
-0.0550622046,
-0.0072091515,
0.0043000043,
0.0417887866,
0.0360819884,
-0.0081528025,
-0.0482825637,
-0.0142795937,
-0.0439487025,
0.0249489751,
-0.0289541967,
-0.0313029364,
0.0207886398,
0.0347786397,
0.0179210082,
-0.0113736959,
0.0005031762,
0.0096260421,
0.0066722943,
0.0258774161,
-0.0320123844,
-0.0254308078,
-0.0397407971,
-0.0490782857,
0.0202115756,
-0.0333911292,
-0.0158561841,
0.0299678277,
-0.0412252769,
-0.0192126818,
-0.0212266762,
-0.005409475,
0.0604286976,
-0.0167429578,
-0.0019905698,
-0.0100181065,
-0.0321229398,
-0.0546776801,
0.0495306365,
-0.0102964826,
0.0332008861,
0.0248657335,
-0.0203421004,
-0.0270855892,
-0.0870477483,
-0.0162324663,
0.0107482979,
-0.0037937274,
0.0268474966,
0.0685575008,
0.0296201184,
-0.0334041193,
-0.000482176,
-0.0548171476,
-0.0028000791,
-0.0352703966,
-0.0056436989,
0.0227406509,
0.0191759001,
-0.0182509553,
-0.0361928307,
-0.0046324413,
-0.0226913244,
-0.0030751552,
0.0250721127,
0.0462464727,
0.0438200384,
0.0020309216,
-0.0525708459,
-0.0351172797,
0.002403866,
0.0045332732,
-0.0295484923,
0.0518719107,
-0.0314576291,
-0.0414484404,
-0.034251675,
0.0323683396,
-0.0165563095,
-0.0228144526,
0.014737024,
-0.0464694723,
-0.0162675735,
0.075868763,
0.0190621894,
0.045857735,
0.0868406296,
0.0341306068,
-0.0768112093,
0.0367716178,
-0.0551412553,
-0.0389653444,
-0.051683642,
0.0066752676,
0.0167283434,
0.0908750966,
-0.0425330698,
0.0139179928,
-0.0614407696,
0.0266877264,
0.0074889576,
-0.0660632849,
-0.0351720043,
0.0143691674,
-0.0522264652,
0.046571292,
-0.0427390113,
-0.0512675419,
0.1192149743,
0.0271895863,
0.0037629949,
-0.0614503063,
-0.0255264137,
0.0070693865,
-0.0011167106,
-0.0066753221,
0.0323245749,
-0.0100123426,
-0.0126237292,
-0.0724968016,
-0.0388459191,
0.0339686051,
-0.0125664482,
0.0573252887,
-0.0331697762,
0.0241758581,
0.0188736189,
-0.0711214021,
-0.057873182,
-0.0431864895,
-0.0154033033,
-0.0219681542,
-0.0071353908,
-0.0391469337,
-0.0077401972,
-0.0185213685,
0.0440463908,
0.0398299657,
-0.0055469316,
-0.0177355744,
-0.0183035601,
0.0035527681,
0.082950905,
0.0190344509,
0.0130651984,
-0.0285584256,
0.0244870093,
0.0248162895,
0.0676940084,
-0.0051789405,
0.0394437201,
0.0114168143,
0.0330649316,
-0.0447003171,
-0.0079010362,
0.0491337962,
0.0311131291,
-0.0081647327,
-0.0344151184,
0.0745621324,
0.0390051566,
-0.065902248,
0.0218306072,
-0.010974925,
0.0758217499,
0.0189056005,
0.0631219223,
-0.0585414656,
-0.0009619826,
0.0318155773,
0.0606868304,
-0.0104947751,
-0.0430063494,
0.0077048768,
-0.1145732775,
-0.0156207532,
-0.0072556036,
-0.0797224119,
0.0125564113,
-0.0264729429,
0.0437825285,
-0.0462408923,
0.0200036522,
0.0153010739,
-0.0100699579,
0.0197541937,
0.0094637079,
0.0470359772,
-0.0281842351,
0.0277736485,
-0.0204935111,
0.0033074827,
0.092495352,
0.0180730205,
-0.0078146691,
-0.0169344041,
-0.0269019157,
0.027355656,
-0.0304068066,
0.0012815283,
0.0049406453,
-0.020830851,
0.0021550893,
0.0163826868,
0.0744777247,
0.0263051596,
-0.0054999692,
-0.0174149871,
0.0334721655,
0.0052470956,
0.0009933842,
0.0315259844,
-0.0096835773,
0.0715931654,
0.0560155213,
-0.0072816452,
-0.0949783027,
-0.0380232409,
-0.0286461227,
-0.037415307,
-0.057535097,
-0.0088689066,
0.0062606521,
-0.005133023,
-0.0067958399,
-0.0537459068,
-0.0545058511,
-0.0002787553,
0.0516992174,
-0.0075492039,
-0.0111775361,
-0.0054788855,
0.0193933006,
0.0011738526,
0.0366108306,
-0.0309135877,
0.0164066311,
-0.0374062061,
-0.0046299845,
-0.0248953756,
-0.037973851,
-0.0281575862,
-0.010629327,
-0.0373252816,
-0.0774523616,
0.0064503904,
0.0517372265,
0.0139971366,
0.0825870782,
-0.0268108342,
-0.0573970564,
0.0516864806,
0.0158055611,
-0.0052519427,
0.0024550627,
0.0301376414,
0.021113541,
-0.0129572889,
0.0620102957,
-0.0458024666,
-0.025641283,
0.0069353683,
0.0451194532,
-0.0110838041,
-0.0155097181,
0.043177221,
-0.0319471098,
0.0349828713,
-0.0450659543,
-0.0079215644,
-0.0287509467,
-0.015951518,
0.0241828784,
-0.0306582469,
-0.0256978758,
-0.0230524596,
0.037125051,
-0.0037624731,
0.0155932866,
-0.0082894582,
0.0074194656,
0.0364317,
-0.028807696,
0.0053416756,
0.0343458019,
-0.005405928,
0.0605027899,
0.0417444408,
0.0216927603,
0.0269604884,
0.0082562594,
0.0727446526,
-0.00491144,
0.0623165257,
0.0582978204,
-0.0188238602,
0.0207651444,
-0.0307756253,
-0.0573473535,
-0.0902207941,
-0.031069342,
0.0281289909,
0.059011925,
-0.0058124028,
0.0167512987,
-0.0329004154,
-0.0249263421,
-0.0087615345,
-0.0138955293,
-0.0453982651,
-0.0358107239,
0.0433208086,
0.0331274644,
-0.0119748684,
0.0326698311,
0.0423444808,
0.0305664502,
0.0505766869,
-0.0256446339,
0.0171925128,
-0.0337731987,
-0.0025574418,
0.0447951108,
0.0584103838,
-0.0413268916,
-0.0125223072,
-0.0216255952,
-0.0549971499,
-0.0044988566,
0.0111731282,
-0.0474693775,
-0.0100955823,
0.0568242893,
0.0357563049,
-0.0390381888,
0.0136532886,
-0.0711445808,
-0.0151420841,
-0.0088496637,
-0.0393311828,
0.0049793306,
-6.39441817e-33,
-0.0183546506,
-0.0070592109,
0.0120135928,
-0.0681377351,
-0.0164093692,
-0.0210130569,
-0.0131218694,
0.0009490081,
-0.0023775278,
0.0067720641,
-0.0228778105,
-0.0211537946,
0.0049460954,
0.0241619647,
0.0230838358,
0.0052240631,
0.0327141918,
-0.0107898097,
-0.0590644665,
-0.0082634473,
0.0187666249,
0.0028599121,
0.0450239889,
-0.01154745,
0.0247741397,
0.0333627462,
-0.0209871028,
0.0440122113,
-0.0183291454,
0.0746429563,
-0.0201472659,
-0.0116056167,
-0.0200417321,
-0.0333475024,
-0.0052422434,
-0.0052699596,
-0.0436161384,
-0.0443770736,
0.0095976517,
-0.0016952236,
-0.0537874512,
0.0086539462,
0.0193745214,
-0.0078552822,
-0.0171042718,
0.0137283765,
-0.0034199993,
0.0130012454,
-0.0418694355,
0.0033337406,
-0.0346499272,
0.0161085222,
-0.0162977166,
0.0013892031,
0.031720046,
0.05762095,
0.0003880816,
0.0292370599,
-0.016122343,
0.0270137228,
0.0260882974,
0.0096573979,
0.0763805434,
0.0498369373,
0.025160661,
0.0230953377,
0.0133250039,
-0.0424384363,
0.0269592889,
-0.0117011946,
0.0142914737,
0.0091324225,
-0.0395528413,
0.0428246409,
0.0316995196,
0.0308153871,
-0.0183672942,
0.0152197247,
0.0421080515,
-0.0017245361,
0.0338670909,
0.0551539324,
-0.0626537427,
-0.0177040808,
-0.0898898542,
-0.0514555164,
-0.025428392,
-0.0623865314,
0.0305632837,
0.0534659922,
-0.0338523686,
-0.0227537472,
0.0133869424,
-0.0375766382,
-0.0297784843,
-0.0010212116,
-0.0590983182,
0.029658841,
0.0146961743,
-0.003140823,
-0.0748451501,
-0.0207811296,
-0.0305119269,
-0.0328448862,
-0.0311278813,
0.0190306343,
-0.0035333533,
0.0207802765,
-0.0676555336,
0.0302018523,
-0.0181459673,
0.0148473829,
0.0203190725,
-0.0024397608,
0.0811110735,
-0.0263699014,
0.0022850046,
0.0704424828,
0.0394399464,
-0.0307795387,
-0.0185446646,
-0.046999678,
-0.0228764154,
0.0076125041,
0.0076256902,
0.0083245598,
-0.020837089,
-0.012325055,
0.0048684054,
-0.0499373563,
-0.0075419084,
0.008768145,
2.713e-7,
-0.0104767606,
0.0414516106,
0.010877395,
0.0003663486,
-0.0056830551,
0.0173901021,
-0.0173212439,
0.0068164323,
-0.0176703501,
0.0048671509,
0.0370792262,
0.0336693563,
0.0274538677,
0.0061820862,
-0.0963442251,
-0.0209915321,
-0.0818540007,
0.0418403596,
-0.0483132638,
-0.025723733,
-0.0104647633,
0.0942482352,
0.0262640119,
0.0068006534,
0.0219038613,
-0.0018841808,
0.0584134348,
-0.0360173471,
-0.006058224,
0.027579939,
0.0125238458,
0.0145354513,
-0.0042502964,
-0.047555007,
-0.0199526325,
0.0509457886,
-0.0189448763,
0.081822142,
0.0201104283,
-0.0410993844,
-0.0394783951,
0.0156828631,
0.0293118767,
-0.0689514428,
0.0458819754,
-0.0545770004,
0.0038218261,
-0.0069802664,
0.0261367653,
-0.036262989,
0.0207095128,
-0.0597787462,
-0.000129863,
0.0097645707,
0.0061256764,
0.0335718282,
-0.0106945615,
-0.0508975685,
-0.0042943135,
0.0397436805,
-0.0166493692,
-0.0300315674,
-0.036521744,
0.0241352748,
-0.0321959406,
-0.0447763316,
0.001439238,
2.427124461e-34,
0.0425938033,
-0.0003371729,
-0.0005208215,
-0.0062498166,
0.0073696887,
-0.0011460721,
0.0174750071,
0.0095528308,
0.0757574439,
-0.0750020966,
-0.0237712301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21040v1
|
Direct Alignment of Language Models via Quality-Aware Self-Refinement
| 2024-05-31T17:31:18 | 2024-05-31T17:31:18 |
Runsheng Yu, Yong Wang, Xiaoqi Jiao, Youzhi Zhang, James T. Kwok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has been commonly used to
align the behaviors of Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences.
Recently, a popular alternative is Direct Policy Optimization (DPO), which
replaces an LLM-based reward model with the policy itself, thus obviating the
need for extra memory and training time to learn the reward model. However, DPO
does not consider the relative qualities of the positive and negative
responses, and can lead to sub-optimal training outcomes. To alleviate this
problem, we investigate the use of intrinsic knowledge within the on-the-fly
fine-tuning LLM to obtain relative qualities and help to refine the loss
function. Specifically, we leverage the knowledge of the LLM to design a
refinement function to estimate the quality of both the positive and negative
responses. We show that the constructed refinement function can help
self-refine the loss function under mild assumptions. The refinement function
is integrated into DPO and its variant Identity Policy Optimization (IPO).
Experiments across various evaluators indicate that they can improve the
performance of the fine-tuned models over DPO and IPO.
|
[
0.0353411734,
0.0528481789,
-0.0009139598,
0.0221466497,
-0.0122949239,
-0.0002687635,
-0.0367737748,
-0.0102735721,
-0.024263788,
-0.031639453,
-0.0836814791,
-0.0071965707,
0.0049203858,
0.015325441,
0.0122044506,
-0.0234171208,
0.0578179844,
-0.0331579559,
0.0395760611,
-0.0259438101,
0.0171484724,
-0.0009876263,
0.0004786909,
0.0492140837,
0.0195306223,
0.0013833095,
0.0033071826,
0.0266586859,
0.0259680077,
-0.0252403487,
0.046067223,
0.0659886375,
0.0222510472,
0.0335176885,
0.0000021145,
-0.0455850437,
-0.0220210422,
-0.0125576044,
-0.0080311215,
0.0041926624,
0.0531726815,
0.0148575082,
-0.0431631282,
0.0300986823,
-0.0360920541,
0.039410878,
0.0512473062,
0.0308946799,
0.0631091222,
0.0770142078,
0.0314264596,
-0.0347205512,
-0.0131467134,
-0.0308581665,
0.0021149158,
0.0011966702,
0.0108622639,
-0.0332411416,
-0.0230327174,
-0.030459363,
-0.0400280692,
0.0247721672,
0.0203913841,
-0.0015863088,
0.0118479701,
0.0335486233,
-0.0159420613,
-0.0131538939,
-0.0217769723,
0.0492746532,
-0.0127686588,
-0.0475559048,
0.002844051,
-0.0233205799,
0.0051026037,
-0.0205797888,
0.0136552034,
-0.009864104,
0.0260916594,
0.0558479838,
0.0141173452,
0.0074595502,
0.0475712158,
0.0305522643,
-0.0257667545,
0.0620344505,
-0.0052620391,
-0.0480442904,
0.0210880637,
0.0029531836,
-0.0207010917,
-0.0207055602,
-0.0200011432,
0.0157760847,
-0.0142124388,
0.0155182742,
-0.0448563769,
0.0012225695,
0.0121486019,
-0.0398217738,
0.0618478991,
0.0414391868,
0.0112599293,
0.0200971235,
-0.0108673833,
0.0866383836,
-0.000510926,
0.0345653184,
-0.0440499671,
0.0475868545,
-0.0275791697,
-0.0193584897,
0.0010631296,
0.0452825502,
-0.0048893015,
-0.0048461533,
-0.065210551,
0.0181597695,
-0.0317620002,
0.0299167857,
-0.0016692373,
0.0062229037,
-0.0678313151,
-0.0287498999,
-0.0765463635,
0.052703388,
-0.0156595483,
0.0055036452,
0.0057857693,
0.0002933015,
0.0225894637,
0.0131640323,
-0.0147413164,
0.0066260705,
0.0105969068,
0.087943323,
-0.0219900776,
-0.0154348221,
-0.0287040472,
-0.0135716703,
-0.0370325036,
-0.0684243664,
-0.0302220695,
-0.0636667013,
-0.0001866965,
-0.0282021351,
-0.0288138278,
-0.1030564606,
0.008321438,
-0.0325616114,
0.0072139264,
0.0539347753,
0.0068934411,
0.0150774326,
0.020994423,
-0.0240086932,
0.0235349964,
0.0908844396,
0.0386896022,
-0.0151222395,
0.0155092673,
-0.0097735636,
0.0115525099,
0.0431568585,
0.0500058979,
0.0457187742,
-0.0375111923,
-0.0176986698,
-0.0158845913,
0.0459243394,
0.0566269308,
0.0165668651,
-0.0139486399,
-0.0143028591,
0.0866329148,
0.0313764997,
0.0279967804,
-0.0140325511,
0.0115341581,
0.0480749272,
-0.0047171293,
0.0235381629,
-0.056680873,
0.0130438237,
0.0068819686,
0.024396915,
0.0561468787,
0.0179074388,
-0.0186873451,
-0.0789825767,
-0.0033853389,
-0.0164992344,
0.0464076065,
0.0300143324,
0.0546235703,
0.0020602182,
-0.0221069679,
0.0205195528,
0.0366679914,
-0.0128731104,
0.0175658781,
-0.053446576,
0.0477715619,
0.0743897408,
0.0255095549,
-0.0075272657,
-0.0461641438,
-0.0061731511,
-0.03434911,
0.0512559563,
0.0703371093,
-0.0182870161,
-0.0096492022,
-0.0348369591,
-0.0522777773,
0.0342417061,
0.0128528345,
0.0158109218,
0.0251293592,
-0.0185399409,
0.0123202913,
0.0076249558,
-0.0739888474,
0.034599416,
-0.0083362134,
-0.0533319227,
0.0177414045,
0.0197690893,
0.0290104505,
-0.001517538,
0.0033979162,
0.0179644879,
0.0151764592,
0.0049233027,
-0.0011390082,
-0.0116050988,
-0.0441916026,
0.0050880928,
0.0428740419,
-0.0014491678,
-0.0017741325,
0.0420149826,
-0.0227382947,
-0.045041278,
0.0144138299,
-0.0140932268,
0.0191742629,
-0.018665934,
0.0414945744,
-0.0258780997,
-0.0226552319,
-0.0713172182,
0.0207411963,
-0.0095520606,
0.0119659826,
-0.0217371807,
-0.0129404571,
0.0052409489,
-0.0814004913,
-0.0497539826,
-0.00364894,
-0.0320450179,
0.0452110544,
0.0621427298,
0.0414782427,
-0.0334478058,
-0.0268287044,
-0.0336197391,
0.0156776719,
-0.0191187188,
0.0088659972,
0.0276650898,
-0.0066684973,
-0.0245874841,
-0.0366208293,
-0.0356916934,
-0.0368326753,
-0.0064133578,
0.0117557263,
0.0353574976,
0.0145339211,
-0.0307414439,
-0.0374196656,
-0.0179452673,
-0.0075881733,
-0.024171941,
-0.0254374053,
0.0482660718,
-0.0639043748,
0.0105235036,
-0.0525141582,
0.0428682007,
-0.0038501429,
-0.0752850473,
0.0391877443,
-0.0071743079,
-0.0023676716,
0.1092678234,
0.0199424867,
0.0101863565,
0.0584058948,
0.0281073116,
-0.0935881212,
0.0226170104,
-0.0648196638,
-0.0506856889,
-0.0551365465,
0.0017139543,
0.0070688128,
0.10023579,
0.0002356512,
0.0036693381,
-0.0946717635,
0.0132235317,
-0.0213701893,
-0.037854664,
-0.0193870068,
0.0053449282,
-0.0437935367,
0.0203959495,
-0.0223089345,
-0.0875987932,
0.0992662832,
-0.0130721768,
0.0067842621,
-0.0460150167,
-0.0120136999,
0.0005601087,
0.0114730289,
-0.0175696425,
0.0346604884,
-0.015794456,
-0.0075350828,
-0.0943832546,
-0.0436552018,
0.0662105158,
-0.0487058759,
0.0462564118,
-0.0422900729,
0.0055101812,
-0.005665957,
-0.0952299982,
-0.0499135554,
-0.0319371782,
-0.0075902953,
-0.0179188345,
-0.0081510283,
-0.0353627838,
0.0145667652,
0.0093517378,
0.0293504857,
0.0289550293,
-0.0364402868,
-0.0084783826,
-0.0086004185,
-0.0404212587,
0.0743638277,
0.0310072806,
0.0056656376,
-0.0094184196,
0.0041634492,
0.0079361405,
0.0327337645,
0.0139271365,
-0.0094811469,
0.0196738578,
0.0544604696,
-0.048433315,
0.0008337636,
0.0559656955,
0.0441919602,
-0.076383777,
-0.0226049926,
0.097308591,
0.0142757725,
-0.0514971539,
0.0131445294,
-0.0163821429,
0.052418191,
0.0194158517,
0.0453288145,
-0.0256295968,
-0.0201960467,
0.0011434173,
0.0639084578,
-0.0221551117,
0.0097245788,
0.0026712667,
-0.13333188,
-0.0221353974,
0.0328290574,
-0.0336209908,
-0.0206111651,
0.0019759224,
-0.0011094974,
-0.028534539,
0.0235096607,
0.0216983519,
-0.0065855659,
-0.0014725627,
0.0252961628,
0.0034067335,
-0.0546038412,
-0.0245276056,
-0.0428091437,
0.0607500114,
0.0978989005,
0.0102270208,
0.0235354975,
-0.0344784223,
0.0444231965,
0.0086753136,
-0.0109404195,
-0.0168607887,
-0.0024317785,
-0.019222036,
-0.003563572,
-0.0068476675,
0.0735965669,
0.0037871571,
0.0077979872,
-0.0356508009,
0.0324715488,
-0.0135647021,
0.0204976462,
0.010511132,
-0.0161553342,
0.0054384843,
0.0695443526,
0.0000737652,
-0.0723132789,
-0.0208166745,
-0.0169289522,
-0.0187784266,
-0.0473158099,
-0.065845184,
0.0141302152,
0.0075170854,
-0.0070953495,
-0.0727222636,
-0.021504527,
-0.0278574917,
0.0417344235,
0.01019077,
0.0077978121,
-0.0149173364,
-0.0132042523,
-0.0165744536,
0.0118814968,
-0.0380298682,
0.0051083188,
-0.0863789469,
-0.0109825879,
0.0195991173,
-0.0258768983,
-0.0174724497,
-0.0057618613,
-0.0331640467,
-0.095483467,
0.00189149,
0.0684018508,
0.0173698924,
0.0944557637,
-0.0259358734,
-0.0655533075,
0.0624813586,
0.0472220629,
-0.0554322414,
0.0156518407,
0.042768646,
0.0133208651,
-0.0120228902,
0.0543905795,
-0.0360474996,
-0.0061672507,
0.0585771464,
0.0402276739,
0.01216882,
-0.029395394,
0.026708832,
-0.0003299316,
0.0612791106,
-0.0572125576,
-0.0050034188,
-0.019748548,
0.0222900193,
0.0178429075,
-0.0293856468,
-0.0123159029,
-0.0277756006,
0.0420591123,
-0.0154411029,
0.0058980985,
-0.0084710671,
0.009329834,
0.0109605705,
-0.0147164976,
0.0051463307,
0.0062829168,
0.0094072092,
0.0356178619,
0.0371608026,
0.0093229944,
0.0487897955,
0.020656446,
0.0346152037,
0.0023581821,
0.0556262471,
0.0388351977,
0.0143116377,
-0.0199711956,
0.0232273228,
-0.0224505272,
-0.021337634,
-0.0469546579,
0.004366165,
0.0363294706,
0.0035922432,
0.0339708105,
-0.0229876991,
-0.0172903109,
-0.0205944236,
0.0125125116,
-0.0353250019,
-0.0032813083,
0.0379036888,
0.0155837983,
-0.0215326194,
-0.0076200785,
0.0732594803,
0.0176645685,
0.0283310823,
-0.0547214858,
0.0319725126,
-0.0303564966,
-0.0160736144,
0.0211624671,
0.0155346766,
-0.0416559838,
-0.0008061281,
-0.0565632544,
-0.0756162629,
-0.023904182,
0.0450603962,
0.0016938196,
-0.0205619857,
0.0379165374,
0.031298846,
-0.0680770874,
-0.0241986495,
-0.0420062393,
-0.027831858,
-0.0111216381,
-0.0177878384,
-0.0338011868,
-6.736631759e-33,
-0.0304993931,
-0.0087606609,
0.0219305735,
-0.012137359,
-0.0351069942,
-0.0314663649,
0.0113277277,
0.0262000617,
0.0155165233,
0.0050951829,
-0.0137714213,
-0.0035858895,
0.0096893301,
0.0110267838,
0.0162245892,
-0.0176524129,
0.0504485779,
-0.0134835942,
-0.0829076841,
-0.0107741104,
0.0329989642,
0.0029849203,
0.0502886586,
-0.0512021892,
0.0070794309,
0.0172495302,
-0.0399990566,
0.0513358042,
-0.0126453051,
0.0948508531,
0.0034937274,
0.0216801967,
-0.0088967066,
-0.0604020841,
-0.0080218725,
-0.0171520654,
-0.0482202917,
-0.0469168276,
0.0240356978,
0.0044744918,
-0.0102889901,
-0.0428735204,
0.0822969824,
0.0025895238,
-0.0638795272,
0.0283344593,
0.0095436713,
-0.0117668193,
-0.0100914948,
0.0091026509,
-0.0685890466,
0.0093737589,
0.0003732982,
-0.032267943,
0.0413718559,
-0.0128406677,
-0.0155834919,
-0.0071772956,
-0.0259190612,
0.0306047052,
0.0172457155,
0.0698873252,
0.101130262,
0.0519896038,
0.0062876903,
0.0299066659,
-0.0035596653,
-0.0023474826,
0.025558345,
-0.0344268642,
0.0822837055,
0.0015343612,
0.0260297731,
0.060811054,
-0.014702606,
-0.0112130344,
0.0022528607,
0.0369808227,
-0.0256243106,
0.035401307,
0.0309541319,
0.0303818136,
-0.060470406,
-0.0384600684,
-0.0684888437,
-0.0182363056,
-0.0173144285,
-0.0373889059,
0.0406548791,
0.0287289619,
-0.0411727689,
-0.0138719296,
0.0289200712,
-0.0449042171,
-0.0154129248,
0.0071870484,
-0.0350295864,
-0.0032029038,
0.0038570883,
-0.0190582648,
-0.0818546712,
-0.0315205529,
-0.0344741829,
0.0019674799,
-0.0176069662,
0.0006514495,
0.0275329258,
0.0403395258,
-0.0631192848,
0.024992682,
-0.0140336575,
-0.0049212305,
0.0304136295,
-0.0006369603,
0.0589987636,
0.0024082661,
-0.0126684234,
0.0350917876,
0.030760413,
-0.0199578349,
-0.0313865952,
0.0022187077,
-0.0136726256,
0.0374896154,
-0.0262149479,
0.0244331341,
-0.0055131889,
0.0222491175,
-0.0047781235,
-0.0338472873,
-0.0239593163,
0.0133336624,
2.82e-7,
0.0106052104,
0.0287936646,
0.0166804474,
-0.0013367902,
0.0075231688,
0.0750332996,
-0.0177557617,
-0.0049626133,
-0.0011265237,
0.0097144935,
0.0361628085,
0.0260389447,
0.038069319,
-0.0259250477,
-0.0887862816,
0.0321621262,
-0.0717770457,
0.0745540857,
-0.0277750026,
-0.0185273271,
-0.0033705551,
0.0935783684,
0.0356198438,
-0.0028192301,
0.0047916383,
0.0007907843,
0.0583072044,
-0.0339361988,
0.0116578704,
0.0293425135,
-0.0004328134,
0.0031529653,
-0.0285948925,
-0.0180302542,
-0.0234099068,
0.0263206251,
-0.0418332778,
0.0707392246,
-0.0047931094,
-0.0218934026,
-0.0091531919,
0.0161670335,
0.0064644162,
-0.0566199347,
0.0503594801,
-0.0639857873,
-0.0222736839,
-0.0160466749,
0.031274192,
-0.0348427705,
0.0137944678,
-0.0490618199,
-0.0399404466,
0.0314072818,
0.0120580625,
0.0414827764,
-0.001922417,
-0.0624489412,
-0.0389213189,
0.0179346651,
-0.0080411937,
-0.0178344809,
-0.0497969724,
0.0563394763,
-0.010842259,
-0.054150559,
0.0018647077,
2.355954706e-34,
-0.0001580083,
-0.0231689885,
0.0057256524,
-0.0049431324,
-0.0027857169,
0.0296001863,
-0.0265776347,
0.0316562429,
0.05594543,
-0.0349816121,
-0.0028968058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21028v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21028v2
|
LACIE: Listener-Aware Finetuning for Confidence Calibration in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T17:16:38 | 2024-07-03T12:49:23 |
Elias Stengel-Eskin, Peter Hase, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
When answering questions, LLMs can convey not only an answer, but a level of
confidence about the answer being correct. This includes explicit confidence
markers (e.g. giving a numeric score) as well as implicit markers, like an
authoritative tone or elaborating with additional knowledge. For LLMs to be
trustworthy knowledge sources, the confidence they convey should match their
actual expertise; however, most current models tend towards overconfidence. To
calibrate both implicit and explicit confidence markers, we introduce a
pragmatic, listener-aware finetuning method (LACIE) that models the listener,
considering not only whether an answer is right, but whether it will be
accepted by a listener. We cast calibration as preference optimization,
creating data via a two-agent game, where a speaker model's outputs are judged
by a simulated listener. We then finetune three LLMs (Mistral-7B, Llama3-8B,
Llama3-70B) with LACIE, and show that the resulting models are better
calibrated w.r.t. a simulated listener. Crucially, these trends transfer to
human listeners, helping them correctly predict model correctness: we conduct a
human evaluation where annotators accept or reject an LLM's answers, finding
that training with LACIE results in 47% fewer incorrect answers being accepted
while maintaining the same level of acceptance for correct answers.
Furthermore, LACIE generalizes to another dataset, resulting in a large
increase in truthfulness on TruthfulQA when trained on TriviaQA. Our analysis
indicates that LACIE leads to a better confidence separation between correct
and incorrect examples. Qualitatively, we find that a LACIE-trained model
hedges more and implicitly signals certainty when it is correct by using an
authoritative tone or including details. Finally, LACIE finetuning leads to an
emergent increase in model abstention (e.g. saying "I don't know") for answers
that are likely wrong.
|
[
0.0571486168,
0.0259258766,
-0.0197272841,
0.0323644653,
-0.0245236401,
-0.0098705068,
-0.0295621902,
-0.0371062644,
-0.005781061,
-0.014842568,
-0.0425355248,
0.0060847914,
-0.0163114257,
-0.0168992188,
0.0396856368,
-0.0209039245,
0.0367995501,
-0.0412019193,
0.0869442299,
-0.0387511402,
0.0302943792,
-0.0209457632,
-0.030356098,
0.0113637233,
-0.0106069706,
0.0008764741,
-0.0094622821,
-0.0106303645,
0.0233322307,
-0.0128861992,
0.0456440039,
0.068462126,
0.0016241852,
0.0150022581,
0.0000018595,
-0.0354999192,
0.011132393,
-0.0292503871,
-0.0430322327,
0.0078099878,
-0.023833245,
0.0427659936,
0.0047163987,
0.0303296484,
-0.0760807544,
0.0471729599,
0.0190729201,
0.0268989597,
0.0531181544,
0.045662418,
0.0316307992,
0.0120709958,
0.0460374095,
-0.0074801357,
-0.0081125228,
-0.0830221996,
0.0113253398,
0.025767507,
-0.0368111245,
0.0206821766,
-0.0176276322,
0.0464169122,
0.0030458348,
-0.020828139,
0.0197036508,
0.017467007,
-0.0242041126,
-0.0211775042,
-0.0245259125,
0.0498954616,
0.0471463799,
-0.033514522,
-0.0104150893,
-0.0122002335,
0.0214408133,
0.0054699909,
-0.0150710307,
-0.0095604565,
0.0000221925,
-0.0009494372,
-0.0152694909,
0.0098418845,
0.0142344311,
0.0190296546,
0.0393559225,
0.1247888207,
-0.0409703031,
-0.0416068658,
0.027472036,
0.0111783445,
-0.0038675845,
-0.0814928263,
-0.0108766407,
0.0483877771,
-0.0394608714,
0.0125529878,
-0.0040256772,
0.0378210209,
0.0468728729,
-0.013287832,
-0.0119505906,
0.0152305029,
0.0020374868,
0.0344712473,
0.0138279954,
0.0053575756,
0.0169847943,
0.0130604869,
-0.0025289068,
-0.0133834351,
-0.003008195,
-0.0089184828,
-0.0224584229,
0.0078763207,
0.0020304425,
0.0192301925,
-0.0676817521,
-0.0100285523,
-0.0487726256,
0.0425196588,
-0.0123159317,
0.0251283925,
-0.0200563353,
-0.0054894942,
-0.0516017079,
0.0744348615,
-0.0551180951,
0.0797997788,
0.0242708605,
-0.1007663235,
0.005847462,
0.0220626481,
-0.0023166097,
0.0080424361,
0.0123582855,
0.0307157319,
-0.0067712697,
0.0014508128,
-0.007167127,
-0.0519542657,
-0.0382836759,
-0.088873297,
-0.0325790308,
-0.0629910976,
0.0052259965,
-0.0101391785,
0.0060982332,
-0.0407828614,
0.0228650738,
0.0014808857,
-0.005072515,
0.0492287762,
-0.0297599286,
0.0260607004,
0.0348657556,
0.0155431768,
-0.0531460941,
0.0512546822,
0.0708521307,
-0.0028781553,
0.0457111299,
-0.020485092,
0.0271231662,
0.0120221991,
0.0364538692,
0.0046750945,
0.0566774346,
0.0220768787,
-0.0492456481,
0.0358333662,
0.0326958224,
0.0436371863,
-0.0383856446,
-0.0267350767,
0.0986981094,
0.0242929645,
-0.0090790326,
-0.041840069,
-0.0027895463,
0.0132834716,
0.047852207,
0.0492916033,
-0.0383418836,
0.0447645262,
-0.0473221578,
-0.0029240772,
0.028618589,
-0.0266883802,
-0.0038944108,
-0.0460540801,
0.0070422203,
-0.0045524896,
-0.0029350435,
0.0585368462,
-0.0136519438,
-0.0066003101,
-0.0066584493,
0.0302417986,
0.0145829339,
-0.0526172407,
-0.0039879754,
-0.0543562993,
0.0617196374,
0.0267104749,
-0.0198057089,
0.0016092903,
-0.0173257012,
-0.0271012727,
0.0228724573,
0.0117875449,
0.0761204362,
-0.0304067358,
-0.0074490993,
-0.0379820503,
-0.0161867738,
0.0086948331,
0.0137923714,
0.0112747317,
0.0288975537,
0.0122108627,
-0.0115993693,
-0.0377169847,
0.0165345687,
-0.0069427285,
-0.00452478,
-0.0359207578,
-0.0195561331,
-0.0016044745,
0.0460717417,
-0.0005266124,
0.0001539794,
0.019795347,
0.0149043221,
0.0475079492,
-0.0093059894,
0.0109346407,
-0.0432414711,
0.0093961693,
0.0486695804,
-0.0298231933,
-0.0359553471,
0.0028287088,
-0.0352575257,
-0.0311762709,
-0.0347506292,
-0.0286702979,
0.0058147535,
-0.0596561022,
-0.0027127734,
-0.0228288136,
-0.0230577625,
-0.0461966023,
0.0189577453,
-0.0156675745,
0.0051421532,
0.0030875995,
-0.0149094425,
0.0237922147,
-0.0632704124,
-0.0221353676,
-0.0269675292,
0.0349667631,
0.0586623363,
0.0486916527,
-0.0227771439,
-0.0635012016,
-0.0560096055,
-0.0640663803,
0.0023950078,
-0.0116956383,
0.0254670288,
-0.0037349567,
-0.0258516036,
0.0045648939,
-0.0276599787,
-0.0684985816,
0.0109453909,
0.0064366157,
0.0262111463,
0.0075518969,
0.0102436105,
0.0140710063,
-0.0633979067,
0.0123007325,
-0.0216453411,
-0.0230687838,
0.0084425174,
0.0185788423,
-0.0572263077,
-0.0051284954,
-0.053038355,
0.0315146707,
-0.0052624731,
-0.0566816032,
0.0125121744,
0.0292794015,
-0.0402539559,
0.0707053915,
0.029955361,
-0.010227453,
0.0402745903,
0.0061172838,
-0.0675362647,
0.0300169569,
-0.0083807679,
-0.0784028843,
-0.0597101636,
-0.0309156161,
0.0002905875,
0.0489610918,
0.0187781621,
-0.0032313582,
-0.0392677411,
0.0198475607,
-0.0068768547,
-0.0531509556,
0.0278354231,
-0.02605653,
-0.0304627772,
0.0816848204,
0.0064896797,
-0.0394542962,
0.1093818918,
-0.0369454287,
0.005457215,
0.0082169278,
-0.0138294995,
-0.0074645551,
-0.0109990304,
-0.0353570543,
-0.0046645878,
0.0176481623,
0.0077002048,
-0.0719369575,
-0.05505272,
0.070855394,
-0.0680705607,
0.0036591652,
-0.0146366451,
-0.0237131882,
0.0163971931,
-0.055887118,
-0.0354629271,
-0.0508932397,
-0.0786515176,
-0.0094239805,
0.0100818779,
-0.0051859166,
0.0036735421,
-0.0370984189,
0.0306737926,
-0.0286671668,
-0.0334447399,
0.0110376701,
-0.0119335037,
0.0271426495,
0.0688168034,
0.0725160688,
0.0664781108,
-0.0271502752,
0.0033408292,
0.0651120618,
-0.0109586623,
0.0348294079,
-0.0234979242,
-0.0279002413,
0.054693047,
-0.0020287153,
-0.0105929701,
0.0665013492,
0.1044555157,
-0.0186646152,
0.0127148572,
0.1217432693,
0.0093218237,
-0.0113632707,
-0.0154302195,
-0.0316571482,
0.0613802969,
0.0206581298,
0.0126797752,
-0.0992184058,
-0.0303036813,
0.0015903119,
0.0587471202,
-0.0285550673,
-0.0193362907,
0.0116885528,
-0.0955477878,
0.0315242372,
0.0054977383,
0.0055605606,
0.0084888358,
-0.0232085083,
0.0326670259,
-0.0022642619,
0.018788565,
0.0232024845,
0.0181119628,
0.0048591793,
0.0411515906,
-0.0476300456,
-0.028896274,
0.0460922085,
-0.0389349535,
0.1011145711,
0.0425165482,
0.0318250284,
-0.01355075,
-0.0744334832,
-0.0130069712,
-0.0144278547,
-0.010175705,
0.0130711021,
0.0439607948,
-0.0213597845,
0.0087090246,
-0.0235070344,
0.0389445648,
0.0209304448,
0.0061923387,
0.0198832005,
0.0550781898,
0.0135161299,
-0.0094466768,
-0.0014565915,
0.0594684742,
0.0406958871,
0.0469739325,
0.0473413579,
-0.0274582505,
-0.0011686794,
-0.0171309523,
-0.0089727435,
0.0116619989,
-0.0428342819,
0.0275391471,
0.0410775729,
-0.0046391836,
-0.0598835051,
-0.029978212,
0.0018383209,
-0.0024343629,
-0.0018449267,
0.0010383388,
0.0368283652,
0.0052515622,
-0.0158569701,
-0.000438789,
-0.0440860093,
0.0655313358,
-0.0346083678,
0.0318877473,
0.0481158048,
-0.0307670869,
0.0044275951,
0.021649152,
-0.0682482496,
-0.0799999684,
-0.0198721644,
0.0690275207,
0.0251435582,
0.0190778039,
-0.0159888063,
-0.079636924,
-0.0018872112,
0.020589089,
-0.0513604321,
0.0413873456,
0.0679228306,
0.0197079256,
-0.0085205352,
0.0538806729,
-0.0211342387,
-0.0094690733,
0.0177925732,
0.0174117256,
-0.0608003959,
-0.0893082544,
0.0191765316,
0.0125038819,
0.0593010858,
0.0180393513,
0.0077496483,
0.011111754,
0.0383470356,
0.0078407861,
-0.0307943989,
0.009454635,
-0.0199989211,
-0.0009227617,
-0.0398011878,
0.0053048246,
-0.0426819064,
-0.0035212678,
0.0269606207,
-0.0302638318,
0.0326543003,
0.0520481579,
-0.0189250018,
-0.0065771556,
0.0004092578,
-0.0276029278,
0.001920533,
0.0206401013,
0.0583175868,
0.0518706441,
0.0389931053,
0.0278402902,
-0.0229829829,
0.0306206439,
-0.0146198859,
-0.0609089248,
-0.0509246327,
0.0107100895,
0.051828485,
0.037182413,
0.0226553511,
0.0365086868,
-0.0005434018,
-0.012677867,
-0.0014690633,
0.0129234297,
-0.03840103,
-0.0068975911,
0.0557593219,
0.0149951605,
-0.0285482537,
0.0106353704,
0.0519566312,
-0.0221209917,
0.0431271717,
-0.0412747078,
0.0059280181,
-0.0248297323,
-0.0049018469,
-0.0389885679,
0.0354762413,
0.0029127996,
0.0176147278,
-0.0486601815,
-0.0558523275,
0.0143961925,
0.0563923754,
-0.0067620287,
-0.0517664887,
0.0078063807,
0.0394368321,
-0.0039087152,
-0.0392047092,
-0.0449280664,
-0.00721419,
-0.0005955951,
0.0228771307,
-0.0356186777,
-6.355356493e-33,
-0.0325791836,
-0.0595816448,
0.0030398192,
0.0283587314,
-0.0073473519,
-0.0043225912,
-0.0092011988,
0.0320438184,
-0.0576877333,
0.0375631154,
-0.0286813807,
0.0101632224,
0.0202776752,
-0.0114062838,
0.0191432405,
-0.0268719271,
0.0172784738,
0.0017516593,
-0.0517661013,
-0.0128370868,
-0.0118772192,
-0.0163528882,
0.0497536771,
-0.1227324754,
0.0546587557,
-0.0042956076,
-0.0379570052,
0.0409525111,
-0.0758506879,
0.0412203744,
0.0184106417,
0.0382264443,
-0.0282004923,
-0.0148110734,
0.0039124456,
0.0100326538,
-0.0504035391,
-0.0358077288,
0.0622561313,
0.0303913411,
-0.0448938087,
-0.0321740024,
0.0331296809,
-0.0275210459,
-0.0455130227,
0.0022179657,
0.0126936063,
-0.0213929433,
-0.0016628299,
-0.0356922671,
-0.0061865528,
-0.0037857611,
-0.0159975644,
-0.0518597029,
-0.0146007873,
0.0417436771,
-0.0116582708,
-0.038274508,
-0.070424825,
0.0350367799,
0.0410580114,
0.0067261751,
0.0552078672,
-0.0052052089,
-0.009742911,
0.0487778299,
0.0265683513,
0.0146859232,
0.0267612711,
-0.0416885577,
-0.0174602643,
0.0293636695,
0.0667370632,
0.0804951563,
-0.0212814361,
-0.0297897458,
-0.0304409657,
0.0016167937,
0.0158327576,
0.0241198372,
0.0284236558,
0.0128901079,
-0.0583034791,
-0.0265347511,
-0.0999691188,
-0.0204340406,
-0.0293719172,
-0.0062725581,
0.0090815779,
0.0004889059,
0.0060254359,
0.0120971361,
0.005177754,
-0.0531193428,
-0.0278944336,
-0.0151904086,
-0.015656611,
0.0227909535,
-0.0034018192,
0.0344459191,
-0.0343598314,
0.0440366864,
-0.0153594771,
-0.0153154675,
0.0196713898,
0.0291502532,
0.045855958,
0.0220658034,
-0.047065638,
0.0128444023,
-0.0025990012,
0.0250557754,
0.0139337657,
-0.0278795008,
0.0202905089,
0.0026750586,
-0.0377026685,
0.0150282839,
-0.037916977,
0.0012288212,
-0.0418471806,
-0.0211673174,
-0.0124925263,
0.0203558225,
-0.042798005,
0.0029835168,
0.0045497338,
0.0110611897,
-0.0243943855,
-0.0051763216,
-0.011067031,
-0.001473483,
2.719e-7,
0.0079771532,
0.0397727005,
-0.0072196508,
0.0292815324,
0.0173355192,
0.0602086447,
-0.0340697318,
0.0062492536,
0.0745473355,
-0.070994094,
-0.0097838826,
-0.0020197467,
0.0640746355,
0.0528604276,
-0.0808731467,
-0.044900313,
-0.052381184,
0.0152288591,
0.0310215838,
-0.0181168392,
0.0416334681,
0.0419448093,
0.021846015,
-0.0013830271,
-0.0142819248,
0.0014135774,
0.0571760125,
-0.0215399694,
0.006327277,
0.0315064341,
0.0702807754,
-0.0243941452,
0.0074090194,
0.0554887243,
-0.0019616145,
0.0088101206,
-0.0400653481,
0.0806936249,
0.0115863401,
-0.0609574467,
-0.0339174345,
-0.0105794324,
0.0229800027,
-0.0330196619,
0.0287092552,
-0.0508992784,
-0.046318613,
-0.0451136678,
-0.0093250079,
-0.0493188575,
0.0210009683,
-0.019008575,
-0.0033526246,
0.0139625175,
0.0081420969,
0.026874369,
-0.0357735567,
-0.0128326397,
-0.0427903086,
0.0062476508,
-0.0221066196,
-0.0903925821,
0.0208665431,
-0.0255301744,
-0.033493448,
-0.1023292094,
0.0397651978,
1.777033611e-34,
0.0334230401,
0.0167911611,
0.0322691649,
0.0274069104,
0.0503028259,
0.023015758,
0.007585356,
-0.0064140107,
0.0750808939,
-0.024238823,
-0.011087724
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21022v1
|
You Only Scan Once: Efficient Multi-dimension Sequential Modeling with LightNet
| 2024-05-31T17:09:16 | 2024-05-31T17:09:16 |
Zhen Qin, Yuxin Mao, Xuyang Shen, Dong Li, Jing Zhang, Yuchao Dai, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Linear attention mechanisms have gained prominence in causal language models
due to their linear computational complexity and enhanced speed. However, the
inherent decay mechanism in linear attention presents challenges when applied
to multi-dimensional sequence modeling tasks, such as image processing and
multi-modal learning. In these scenarios, the utilization of sequential
scanning to establish a global receptive field necessitates multiple scans for
multi-dimensional data, thereby leading to inefficiencies. This paper
identifies the inefficiency caused by a multiplicative linear recurrence and
proposes an efficient alternative additive linear recurrence to avoid the
issue, as it can handle multi-dimensional data within a single scan. We further
develop an efficient multi-dimensional sequential modeling framework called
LightNet based on the new recurrence. Moreover, we present two new
multi-dimensional linear relative positional encoding methods, MD-TPE and
MD-LRPE to enhance the model's ability to discern positional information in
multi-dimensional scenarios. Our empirical evaluations across various tasks,
including image classification, image generation, bidirectional language
modeling, and autoregressive language modeling, demonstrate the efficacy of
LightNet, showcasing its potential as a versatile and efficient solution for
multi-dimensional sequential modeling.
|
[
-0.0267630927,
0.0996541604,
-0.0092654424,
0.0519451797,
-0.0405485779,
0.0081811706,
0.0407525264,
0.0026540041,
-0.0454318337,
-0.0442897528,
-0.0010416454,
-0.101591222,
0.0034517343,
0.0561174676,
0.0348543711,
-0.044060532,
0.0319035724,
-0.0156445652,
-0.0173495449,
-0.0173471179,
-0.0269686524,
-0.0236533899,
-0.0165085699,
0.0510477722,
-0.0014389392,
-0.0203575753,
-0.0570466667,
-0.0146337729,
0.0277234837,
-0.0250202119,
-0.0069244951,
0.0689663887,
0.0674601346,
0.0243147667,
0.0000021586,
0.0159570817,
-0.0091429837,
-0.0069610914,
0.0519313551,
0.0081403777,
0.0175598748,
-0.0355631262,
0.0070453659,
-0.0149942087,
-0.0144696087,
-0.0499740057,
0.0726245418,
0.0216881,
0.0429249182,
0.0541127399,
-0.0109889125,
-0.0446151793,
0.0363386944,
-0.0433271602,
0.0229838621,
-0.0143858045,
0.0301218219,
0.0103937499,
0.0086533139,
0.0095245624,
-0.0526210628,
0.0505994409,
0.044161059,
0.0049221469,
0.0159245729,
0.0381839052,
0.0865939632,
-0.0142666856,
-0.0347441025,
0.0644718781,
-0.0399281383,
-0.0318963937,
0.0146368565,
0.0014459607,
-0.0200203098,
-0.0093035158,
-0.0671289489,
0.0459031388,
0.0172478277,
-0.0001537805,
-0.0221427195,
-0.0160881486,
0.0185942631,
0.0017856716,
-0.0054303338,
0.0147843072,
0.0409618281,
-0.022929525,
-0.0595130958,
-0.006002075,
0.02217119,
-0.0345019959,
0.0084373448,
0.0424611606,
0.0107437735,
0.0088752341,
-0.0200772304,
-0.0444202162,
0.0059891697,
-0.0523302369,
0.0683331415,
0.0564789847,
-0.051842276,
0.0162258726,
-0.0456921123,
0.0599239282,
-0.0665774345,
0.0134757739,
-0.0384970941,
0.0170587841,
0.0121485721,
-0.0042920937,
-0.0294478852,
0.0314417295,
0.0031363245,
-0.0459169671,
-0.052006945,
0.0404954813,
-0.0031710144,
-0.0495828129,
-0.0043311482,
0.0079750875,
-0.0158965308,
-0.0002242153,
0.0131259123,
0.0499527417,
-0.0095483437,
0.0226280373,
-0.0398559459,
0.0043558683,
-0.064316906,
0.0458144397,
0.0327921398,
-0.0242909528,
-0.034183193,
0.0897772387,
-0.0002822281,
-0.0602983423,
-0.0248248912,
-0.0295107048,
-0.0393017679,
-0.0406006165,
0.0398654826,
-0.0583715029,
0.0095059602,
-0.0008837713,
-0.0295392312,
-0.0175667368,
0.0008592434,
0.0279743709,
-0.010571735,
0.0435872823,
0.0300980322,
-0.0108080572,
-0.0183460265,
0.0110529875,
0.0368465111,
0.0417200588,
0.0234526396,
0.0256857984,
-0.0137729412,
-0.0137962857,
-0.0260098837,
0.0489821918,
0.0386316143,
-0.0055007082,
-0.0636404902,
-0.0294721723,
-0.0059619984,
0.0197799671,
0.0522429235,
0.0048874593,
-0.0585072227,
-0.0050801141,
0.0304232035,
0.0420921221,
0.0286135003,
0.0409704,
0.0741687268,
-0.0120284436,
-0.0314607769,
0.026939936,
-0.0258127879,
0.0921525732,
-0.0070844549,
-0.0152182858,
0.0272694491,
0.0122675961,
-0.0327640548,
-0.0025799568,
-0.0040722913,
-0.0009593416,
0.0335229374,
-0.0214400161,
0.0491147488,
0.0049993591,
-0.0612135679,
0.0648063272,
0.0169544816,
-0.0560007207,
-0.0362002924,
-0.0263357963,
0.0058309166,
0.0479214899,
0.009339544,
-0.0299295913,
-0.0412978493,
-0.0041621495,
0.0193021577,
-0.0020755024,
0.0167042669,
0.0142175928,
-0.0110238837,
-0.0672744662,
-0.0574292615,
0.0280245766,
-0.0117572173,
0.0864149928,
-0.0044331024,
-0.0003972397,
0.0046831574,
0.0141779054,
0.0258753709,
0.0244789235,
0.0023853569,
-0.0046894704,
-0.0205892194,
0.003239519,
0.0859846026,
-0.0086751264,
0.0232103057,
0.0126721282,
0.0665700436,
-0.0387522094,
-0.0118185421,
0.0209382586,
-0.0593764,
-0.0203311648,
0.0329917148,
-0.0150947217,
0.0008979376,
0.0585607439,
-0.0266357381,
-0.0647614971,
0.0783491805,
-0.0485295467,
-0.0043248823,
-0.0319021009,
-0.0108065866,
0.0295134112,
0.0336663127,
-0.0098014986,
0.068305485,
-0.0538309813,
0.0392561741,
0.0512868389,
-0.0150756706,
0.0050430293,
-0.0618413761,
-0.0134082446,
0.0027425287,
-0.0177805405,
-0.0050269398,
0.0324552357,
0.0146688959,
0.0119976597,
-0.0058115823,
-0.0468793549,
-0.0185440369,
-0.0313868895,
-0.0001906459,
0.0018496121,
0.0073225466,
0.0362685435,
-0.0388319679,
-0.0407617614,
0.0511979125,
0.0187502075,
0.0190602187,
0.0155919865,
-0.0129872635,
-0.0406452045,
-0.0199624412,
-0.0661521852,
0.0043113208,
0.0622727089,
-0.0326824635,
-0.0552123785,
-0.0215437002,
-0.0319894217,
-0.0163333565,
0.0331526101,
-0.0315930545,
-0.0321961232,
-0.018942276,
-0.0913701057,
-0.0117324525,
0.0246672947,
0.0120510189,
0.047188051,
0.0255524255,
-0.0167138372,
-0.0181703568,
0.0354641154,
-0.0438799486,
0.0563907474,
0.0244117621,
-0.0049528861,
-0.0517545342,
0.0925985277,
0.0029521799,
-0.0020898988,
-0.0556020886,
-0.0090382891,
0.017159313,
-0.0385333113,
-0.0380357727,
-0.0069192741,
-0.0251740571,
0.0236973558,
-0.0385463499,
-0.0557883345,
0.0451712534,
-0.0024990053,
-0.0141621865,
0.008216233,
0.0424598791,
-0.0315525755,
0.0545415096,
0.0501571409,
0.0306058507,
-0.0526966415,
-0.0309939906,
-0.0403318852,
-0.0116872704,
0.0074981367,
-0.0030842251,
0.0803044736,
-0.0481479242,
0.0307252556,
-0.0298774857,
-0.0134743173,
-0.0413176194,
-0.0285758469,
0.0209317543,
0.0039932989,
-0.0318357311,
-0.008954389,
-0.0468472503,
0.0603233613,
0.0291238539,
0.0513490513,
-0.0049902038,
0.0150343506,
-0.0304189287,
0.0774097741,
0.0290257577,
0.0099576134,
0.002166386,
-0.0301050153,
-0.0115927411,
0.0445828959,
-0.0225426387,
0.023135202,
-0.0446116291,
0.0720396638,
0.0476643629,
0.0006287261,
-0.0389643088,
0.04723024,
0.006866205,
-0.0811585337,
-0.0091996212,
0.0584544726,
-0.0048781661,
-0.0630988255,
0.0009094898,
0.036574658,
0.0140696196,
0.016447043,
-0.019041473,
-0.0412194319,
-0.0338736139,
-0.0217324737,
-0.0431823917,
0.0277160797,
-0.0169951096,
-0.0028629692,
-0.0403742865,
0.0244136322,
0.0151783414,
-0.042980995,
-0.0381358638,
-0.0098450501,
-0.0182045661,
0.0469017252,
-0.0129804015,
0.0461037382,
-0.0166724995,
-0.0160788167,
0.0467145815,
0.0264110938,
-0.0264535807,
0.0036043662,
0.01563772,
0.0005810413,
0.0407246202,
0.0210099127,
-0.0348307081,
-0.0614707693,
-0.005076,
0.0099386629,
0.0030839825,
-0.0062032072,
-0.0040673516,
-0.001161603,
-0.0154914018,
0.023077026,
0.0235696007,
-0.0510618724,
-0.0213452969,
-0.0500334613,
0.0707715824,
-0.0014284919,
0.0023904676,
-0.0341948569,
0.0159144737,
-0.0046746824,
0.0508644618,
0.0198550429,
-0.0164551828,
-0.0249229278,
0.0110850967,
-0.0084843487,
-0.0594695583,
-0.0572617464,
-0.012378498,
0.0237945542,
-0.021293683,
-0.0387782939,
-0.0005238852,
-0.0140793407,
0.0389469154,
-0.001652078,
-0.0161582679,
0.0150680067,
-0.0458980128,
-0.054700058,
0.0212475248,
-0.0134708406,
0.0155765004,
-0.0391710922,
-0.0037637504,
0.0232439749,
-0.0643483624,
-0.0201513991,
0.0346022211,
-0.1216401458,
-0.0236062091,
-0.0192777533,
0.0619134717,
0.0190842655,
0.0262244716,
0.0200156942,
-0.0161379315,
0.0279666577,
-0.0457537845,
0.0464842618,
0.0160464197,
0.0328071229,
-0.0088741668,
0.0007465311,
0.0324496925,
-0.050760489,
0.0492238998,
0.0175305437,
0.0429739691,
-0.0232815426,
-0.0692915842,
0.0066804793,
-0.0363472253,
0.0606910549,
0.0081191557,
-0.009003981,
-0.0344730057,
0.0236219335,
-0.0365918428,
0.0159514621,
-0.070793055,
0.0239342507,
0.0164328106,
0.0007619966,
-0.0237838048,
-0.0147219319,
0.0146360239,
-0.0317031816,
-0.0268658251,
0.0479995832,
0.0048282975,
-0.0265184529,
0.0101554049,
0.0066961609,
-0.0139177544,
-0.0010205774,
-0.0241139326,
0.0172460452,
-0.0351617895,
0.0581421927,
0.0135731036,
0.0353313163,
-0.053043399,
0.0378719941,
-0.0803752616,
-0.0129425982,
-0.029286474,
0.0201327298,
0.092856653,
-0.0180968568,
0.0509628057,
-0.0292038992,
0.0029065185,
-0.0161304828,
0.0713435933,
0.0412812084,
-0.0390620567,
0.0698329583,
0.0412036106,
-0.0040610977,
0.0088783028,
0.0832387805,
-0.002162911,
0.0161561072,
-0.0262123514,
0.0077289022,
-0.0295201521,
-0.0358632319,
0.0255996529,
0.019696705,
-0.0340083055,
-0.0038498412,
-0.0332349874,
-0.0545083508,
0.0291033052,
-0.0106542837,
0.0045452532,
-0.0272401199,
0.0644083694,
0.0347290188,
0.006370889,
0.0072577554,
-0.0236901864,
-0.0029025311,
0.0053225351,
-0.0427705199,
-0.0227242708,
-6.450720676e-33,
-0.0189907979,
-0.0269879438,
0.0367647111,
-0.0160565078,
-0.0168256219,
0.052169241,
-0.0290424563,
-0.0077546444,
0.0318089016,
-0.0170294065,
0.0288779214,
-0.0002771094,
0.0124529134,
0.0265529472,
0.0220105555,
0.0201161113,
0.0443159714,
-0.0124290343,
0.0390947014,
0.0374510251,
0.022249328,
0.0190058555,
0.0357104354,
0.000637016,
-0.002783607,
0.0067166938,
-0.0093319947,
-0.0040284111,
-0.0165864304,
0.0565873198,
-0.0437018983,
0.0063769664,
0.0230460893,
-0.0492451526,
-0.038827192,
0.0294132605,
-0.0714845359,
-0.0147924712,
-0.0224561635,
0.0105603598,
-0.0594178885,
-0.0245345253,
0.0278000161,
-0.0119203646,
0.0103931529,
-0.0001663472,
0.0382405668,
-0.0170753915,
-0.0925530344,
-0.0308487136,
-0.0533861369,
0.0193004366,
-0.0295693576,
-0.0311842356,
0.0465825982,
0.023475185,
-0.0033892584,
0.0096113691,
-0.0643352941,
0.0078833736,
-0.0119613549,
0.0496491827,
0.0473907888,
0.046277836,
0.0298557822,
0.0351044685,
0.0684283003,
-0.0438812226,
0.0041960953,
-0.0063761519,
0.0156367607,
-0.0158062242,
0.0279753301,
0.0125265466,
0.0543737561,
0.0316738188,
-0.0782782957,
-0.0304878391,
-0.0055615571,
0.0594281852,
0.0612222925,
0.0226841979,
0.0046890764,
-0.0020276855,
0.0004893477,
-0.0286492649,
-0.0259616878,
-0.0222991109,
0.0173316374,
0.0259055085,
0.0108449776,
-0.0162891559,
0.0844251961,
-0.0322857425,
0.0057533043,
0.0243528578,
-0.0187244676,
0.0297827329,
0.0180769861,
0.0464610942,
-0.0481197312,
-0.0348314606,
-0.0075885379,
-0.0050917589,
0.0015054174,
-0.0011736677,
0.0369058624,
0.0553740188,
-0.0379186273,
-0.0299518704,
-0.0518784821,
-0.0110416096,
0.0299632158,
0.0790466294,
0.0611298867,
-0.0246598274,
0.0064702122,
0.07413055,
-0.003733255,
0.0001250824,
0.0129593424,
-0.0484274365,
-0.0128158797,
0.0475897156,
-0.032081835,
-0.0020574625,
-0.0723922029,
0.0151485605,
0.0192528423,
-0.0716693625,
-0.022787137,
0.0745340288,
2.905e-7,
0.0143315978,
0.0137683824,
0.036721319,
0.0067114942,
0.0564997643,
-0.0058473297,
-0.0026510658,
0.0557638444,
-0.0111051537,
0.0052585695,
0.0384802744,
0.0193858407,
0.046675656,
-0.0178530589,
-0.0706530362,
-0.0075539802,
-0.0474401526,
0.0318573639,
-0.0192255899,
0.0002801195,
0.0561002605,
0.0749832913,
-0.020143291,
0.0038516948,
0.0203875545,
-0.0156770889,
0.0875641853,
0.0309465006,
0.0064022387,
-0.0428234562,
0.0361672491,
-0.0275657028,
-0.0205618404,
-0.0179533921,
-0.0244835149,
0.0050171046,
0.0128504951,
0.0545515493,
-0.0115492372,
-0.0697112307,
0.0130895311,
-0.0099286204,
-0.0356454961,
0.0028078042,
0.0647337958,
-0.0398926921,
-0.0054415083,
0.0049547763,
-0.0139238006,
0.0179131459,
-0.0101840133,
0.0157948136,
-0.0242999662,
0.0245999731,
0.0240293294,
-0.0340365171,
-0.0067835511,
-0.1016365066,
0.0005023113,
0.0079527255,
-0.0652967766,
0.0210446957,
-0.0484570526,
-0.0543738641,
0.069527261,
-0.0277324561,
-0.0767266601,
2.837486554e-34,
0.0378236137,
-0.0470962748,
0.0114980433,
-0.0075516566,
-0.0184632689,
-0.0333479233,
-0.0494649261,
0.0305488054,
0.0123041384,
-0.0843114927,
-0.0588112175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21018v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21018v2
|
Improved Techniques for Optimization-Based Jailbreaking on Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T17:07:15 | 2024-06-05T16:35:49 |
Xiaojun Jia, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Yihao Huang, Jindong Gu, Yang Liu, Xiaochun Cao, Min Lin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large language models (LLMs) are being rapidly developed, and a key component
of their widespread deployment is their safety-related alignment. Many
red-teaming efforts aim to jailbreak LLMs, where among these efforts, the
Greedy Coordinate Gradient (GCG) attack's success has led to a growing interest
in the study of optimization-based jailbreaking techniques. Although GCG is a
significant milestone, its attacking efficiency remains unsatisfactory. In this
paper, we present several improved (empirical) techniques for
optimization-based jailbreaks like GCG. We first observe that the single target
template of "Sure" largely limits the attacking performance of GCG; given this,
we propose to apply diverse target templates containing harmful self-suggestion
and/or guidance to mislead LLMs. Besides, from the optimization aspects, we
propose an automatic multi-coordinate updating strategy in GCG (i.e.,
adaptively deciding how many tokens to replace in each step) to accelerate
convergence, as well as tricks like easy-to-hard initialisation. Then, we
combine these improved technologies to develop an efficient jailbreak method,
dubbed I-GCG. In our experiments, we evaluate on a series of benchmarks (such
as NeurIPS 2023 Red Teaming Track). The results demonstrate that our improved
techniques can help GCG outperform state-of-the-art jailbreaking attacks and
achieve nearly 100% attack success rate. The code is released at
https://github.com/jiaxiaojunQAQ/I-GCG.
|
[
0.0295836385,
0.0949451253,
0.001746709,
0.0435065255,
-0.0486264899,
-0.029085882,
0.0248537771,
-0.0276074931,
-0.0101136155,
-0.0043132757,
0.0001306078,
-0.0221795887,
0.0084071765,
-0.0202837158,
0.0560876168,
0.0369869992,
0.0558841676,
-0.0456264727,
-0.0409259498,
-0.0061525819,
0.0016267843,
-0.0174877271,
0.0110025294,
0.0179690775,
-0.0356056914,
0.001560103,
-0.0400829539,
0.0386736132,
0.0193827432,
-0.0094393762,
0.0077814017,
0.0177290048,
-0.0292291045,
0.0614632852,
0.0000023847,
-0.008824314,
-0.0676611587,
0.0441684611,
-0.0087972386,
0.0854272097,
-0.0223091766,
-0.0652363673,
-0.0465904251,
0.00664115,
-0.0228958912,
0.0426226817,
0.0312955976,
0.0335043482,
0.087109901,
0.103457883,
0.0257746112,
0.0050500003,
0.0232369211,
-0.0397845171,
-0.0224225167,
-0.0778563246,
0.0179591998,
-0.0213839225,
-0.0167230219,
0.03201399,
0.0063568549,
-0.0184254125,
-0.0106971236,
0.0055441293,
-0.0620288216,
-0.0090297535,
-0.0445316136,
0.0092772478,
0.0069186143,
0.0195751674,
-0.073034972,
-0.0236117505,
0.0331751183,
0.0215513129,
0.01706383,
0.000298088,
0.002410034,
0.015087273,
-0.0027831574,
0.0012873734,
0.057371676,
-0.0485778861,
0.0638212711,
-0.0355301239,
-0.0144358324,
0.0587558337,
0.0250241607,
-0.0441562533,
-0.0169261936,
-0.0580251627,
-0.0378960632,
-0.0491355248,
-0.0173295159,
-0.0258944239,
-0.0041867131,
0.0154733406,
-0.1025852486,
-0.044204291,
0.0086579807,
-0.0271338578,
0.0286456905,
0.0408207476,
0.0288683493,
0.0344627053,
-0.0207581725,
0.03413653,
-0.0545829237,
0.0114445994,
-0.0058063488,
-0.0001376123,
-0.0090606418,
-0.0099458294,
-0.0089855529,
0.0355441459,
-0.0044508921,
0.0002530759,
-0.0351937898,
0.0200127885,
-0.0287543591,
0.045653943,
-0.0509655289,
-0.0124829449,
0.0130836926,
0.0231040269,
0.0556262098,
-0.0483375378,
-0.0228975881,
-0.0438548625,
-0.0028986912,
-0.0374082662,
-0.0348226167,
0.0064633195,
-0.0840830654,
-0.0116584357,
-0.008820856,
0.1124841869,
0.0354227684,
-0.0154700959,
-0.0227813404,
-0.0987991989,
-0.0237217806,
-0.0375828445,
-0.0067561315,
-0.0960542038,
-0.0430179164,
-0.0095405011,
-0.0219688825,
-0.0636548102,
0.0054873917,
-0.0181784369,
-0.0612820871,
0.0401747487,
0.0203789454,
-0.0091215596,
-0.0153956749,
0.0275039822,
-0.0000128867,
0.0800609961,
-0.0400005355,
0.0527201518,
0.061474178,
-0.0126860412,
0.0333637223,
0.0606214143,
-0.0017165276,
0.0363353379,
-0.0132176289,
-0.0146849621,
0.0919671059,
0.0153378583,
-0.0003892175,
0.0499631315,
-0.0113976207,
-0.0695771575,
0.0606205985,
0.042615205,
-0.0004976877,
0.0736793056,
-0.0101526212,
0.0033919679,
-0.0103150206,
-0.006057323,
-0.0572482757,
-0.0266028382,
-0.1021982208,
-0.0060474509,
0.0085802684,
0.0505921319,
0.0049145217,
0.0076107187,
-0.0058468087,
-0.0207495485,
-0.0448616147,
-0.0009258137,
0.0138475019,
0.0039278171,
-0.0290307123,
0.0611815006,
0.0320560262,
-0.0251279641,
-0.0427735746,
-0.0451212265,
-0.0189714655,
-0.0135958996,
0.0546820834,
-0.0112091135,
-0.055744756,
0.0118587418,
-0.0155572537,
-0.0062140832,
-0.0083703259,
0.0385470241,
0.0305268969,
0.0004363685,
0.012786434,
-0.007493827,
0.0323113874,
0.0338658765,
0.0333220139,
-0.0125410538,
-0.0062615061,
-0.0395915546,
-0.0324351005,
0.0156236989,
0.031214118,
0.0022001329,
0.0406261571,
0.0190363787,
0.0183413308,
0.0057452046,
-0.0476306677,
0.0215282757,
0.0609102584,
0.0003194097,
0.0266512018,
0.0096956491,
-0.01737714,
-0.0086078802,
0.0345875472,
-0.0244918019,
-0.0081239594,
0.0802084655,
-0.0490455441,
-0.0099494345,
0.1075073481,
-0.032184232,
0.0184806176,
0.035647992,
0.0327209122,
-0.0049767727,
0.0359264575,
-0.0245210715,
-0.0103769489,
-0.0105367741,
-0.0038705708,
-0.0050713103,
0.0147450613,
0.0402276702,
-0.0099443318,
-0.0380142927,
0.0069024432,
-0.0377522297,
0.0011967099,
0.0057731378,
0.0159821045,
0.0142215611,
-0.0782773346,
-0.0477563106,
0.0052937381,
-0.0172314327,
0.0502634011,
0.0365083478,
0.0160822924,
-0.0331204981,
-0.0170480125,
0.0343497582,
-0.0154110799,
-0.0346989334,
0.0004333511,
-0.0253958143,
0.0149524426,
-0.0688109919,
-0.0012035455,
-0.0218470544,
0.0020751199,
0.0524703339,
-0.0523590967,
-0.0167291574,
-0.0430365726,
-0.0278452691,
0.0003058506,
0.0294649694,
-0.0271735713,
-0.0406449735,
0.0310078301,
-0.0088372175,
0.0055417703,
0.0512917154,
-0.010330528,
0.0315631665,
0.048225604,
-0.0095995739,
-0.0283501204,
-0.0309039932,
0.0243644286,
-0.0273737311,
-0.0426859483,
-0.0266742613,
0.0312923416,
0.0707486346,
0.0297691058,
-0.0299868342,
-0.0143565405,
-0.0041623088,
0.0114617674,
-0.0073485062,
-0.0177154113,
0.0013262639,
-0.0199243147,
-0.0237486139,
0.0059791454,
-0.0647151545,
0.0631671697,
-0.0623008087,
0.0196089428,
-0.04331626,
-0.0358527116,
-0.0221195575,
-0.0068507404,
-0.0290894117,
0.0339709856,
0.0286713596,
-0.013098863,
-0.0005802846,
-0.002682619,
0.0305807535,
0.0024634432,
0.0060377093,
-0.0381284654,
0.0012183049,
-0.0106489221,
-0.0358971655,
-0.0326986797,
-0.0725787804,
-0.0023872715,
-0.0133548761,
0.050416097,
-0.0643810779,
-0.0139229894,
-0.0109917866,
0.0235817134,
0.012712243,
-0.030161947,
-0.0030089587,
-0.0121778175,
0.011590695,
0.0267001037,
-0.0688182712,
0.0031541884,
0.0004162097,
0.011371132,
0.0844404399,
0.0763402879,
0.0257989801,
-0.0401005037,
0.0027147466,
0.0181162413,
0.0001595708,
-0.0267390944,
0.0106826341,
0.0346625857,
-0.0358661711,
-0.0240468848,
0.0376820192,
0.0225648694,
0.0041341302,
0.0455080867,
0.0214176532,
0.0472678393,
0.010608295,
0.0459016673,
-0.0715875551,
-0.0501013137,
0.0290352907,
0.0697356984,
0.0028015312,
-0.0268496182,
-0.041515097,
-0.094015047,
-0.0119600622,
0.0539925434,
-0.0208688956,
0.0161065534,
-0.0524564609,
-0.0035644453,
0.0282789059,
0.0170106087,
-0.0053481874,
0.0228323005,
0.0088446885,
-0.0026902463,
-0.0506146923,
-0.0163573697,
-0.0225809142,
-0.038401816,
0.0698952898,
0.0648550764,
-0.0223239511,
-0.0323617682,
0.043105904,
0.0843857229,
0.0384325609,
0.0069173565,
0.0047739134,
-0.041904252,
0.0138870059,
-0.0152795278,
0.027845582,
0.0341260657,
0.0075509972,
-0.0189343039,
0.044600606,
0.035404034,
0.0126427859,
0.0133175561,
-0.0104038231,
-0.016012447,
0.0218406264,
0.0419042967,
0.0046688556,
-0.0308188517,
-0.0290936828,
-0.0854382366,
-0.0237630606,
-0.0427350998,
-0.0145489899,
0.006298746,
0.036388088,
-0.0243001655,
-0.0348715782,
0.030517213,
0.0012698347,
0.0383716077,
0.0259678867,
0.01378641,
-0.0295285434,
-0.0046505793,
-0.0523630679,
0.0001803495,
-0.00789678,
0.0425562076,
-0.0975482389,
0.0196286142,
-0.0239444692,
-0.0141462749,
-0.026515346,
0.0308732223,
-0.0655256808,
-0.1111426055,
0.0134614324,
0.0681931302,
0.0140798399,
0.0225994494,
-0.0484146103,
-0.0508621596,
0.0216103029,
0.0866539031,
-0.0204491783,
0.0408128425,
0.0681556761,
-0.059674833,
0.0196103137,
0.0180494934,
-0.0229177363,
-0.0322811641,
0.0819850415,
-0.0025156094,
-0.033923544,
0.0229119938,
0.0122685311,
0.0623822138,
0.0326413624,
-0.0280316994,
0.0432791188,
0.045986183,
0.0336921103,
-0.0229704902,
-0.0085219918,
0.0105063878,
0.0151943266,
0.0060235979,
-0.0230774991,
0.038758181,
0.0280775335,
0.024133157,
-0.0204606839,
-0.0134467231,
0.0043169521,
-0.0127026038,
0.0425416306,
0.0870298147,
0.0020862725,
0.0005470434,
0.0374571979,
0.008915172,
0.0269530844,
-0.0397569388,
0.0055332421,
0.0396919921,
-0.0026010505,
-0.0268423613,
0.0521917082,
-0.0430701785,
-0.0834046006,
0.0086202538,
0.0488300249,
0.054258585,
0.0351286381,
0.0074718879,
-0.0249347687,
-0.002663333,
-0.0395747237,
-0.0160772093,
-0.0215699505,
-0.0481573641,
0.0247963257,
-0.0094476305,
0.0020604872,
0.0566224307,
0.0566166826,
0.0199578907,
0.0602220073,
0.0278209634,
-0.0052157748,
-0.0478865504,
0.0188369397,
0.0431366153,
0.0251066089,
-0.0593037903,
-0.0393755101,
-0.0414281562,
-0.0460079797,
-0.004654211,
-0.0046937075,
0.0336384624,
0.031094892,
-0.0353764407,
0.0421597287,
0.0003367943,
0.0418318287,
-0.0734397173,
0.006844338,
-0.0011191876,
-0.0747791007,
0.0725050271,
-6.545540459e-33,
0.0553617738,
-0.0063921786,
-0.0580430627,
-0.0381921344,
0.0006380834,
0.0047942959,
-0.0162092075,
0.0138418535,
0.019981958,
-0.0435559675,
-0.031171497,
-0.0059079737,
0.0077867475,
0.0155518549,
-0.0546850078,
-0.0009912599,
-0.00251854,
0.0466013029,
-0.0419329107,
0.0169767588,
0.059316773,
0.0173689481,
0.0483115762,
-0.0281237084,
-0.0062028216,
-0.0498234257,
-0.0368164666,
0.0407523327,
-0.0284022056,
0.0486597605,
0.0179358609,
-0.0048246761,
-0.0212683249,
-0.0263496079,
-0.0072838473,
0.0130897537,
0.0063332855,
0.0187182482,
0.0107237492,
0.0104332985,
-0.0102209458,
-0.0496473275,
-0.0037582505,
0.0355814323,
-0.0126409912,
0.008741932,
-0.0316437297,
-0.0001937765,
-0.0330081917,
0.0103597902,
0.0006496478,
0.0193986222,
-0.0429101661,
0.0074675488,
0.0111256298,
-0.0680678785,
-0.0019483861,
-0.0088971267,
-0.0140766008,
0.0516667962,
0.0045440588,
0.0510228872,
0.0542594679,
0.0127032539,
-0.0086013917,
0.04417127,
-0.0240745302,
-0.0234764088,
0.0256264098,
0.0032631932,
-0.0008894425,
0.0269196369,
0.0376650095,
0.0453532264,
0.0700182766,
-0.0358364508,
-0.0662691295,
-0.000607986,
0.0459472984,
0.0128841214,
0.04212768,
0.0100368643,
-0.064852722,
-0.002134193,
-0.0184427407,
-0.0118029099,
-0.0229384005,
-0.0242057182,
0.0149909081,
0.0098122377,
-0.0511383153,
0.0145570282,
0.0012271133,
-0.0286476538,
0.0060988269,
0.0460147746,
-0.0490058027,
-0.0249219388,
-0.0379570387,
0.0027655489,
-0.0055105155,
-0.0190812759,
-0.0021505223,
-0.0693821236,
0.0509184711,
-0.0147314724,
0.0165965501,
0.0129845683,
-0.0578812435,
-0.0136599764,
-0.013496547,
0.0633194,
-0.0101358993,
-0.0314904749,
0.0337505601,
-0.026700953,
-0.0019658504,
-0.0111791464,
0.0523309521,
0.0171169117,
-0.0325067304,
0.0562215745,
-0.0120097604,
0.0307794809,
0.0164167415,
0.0292382408,
0.017973898,
0.0032102773,
0.0403048545,
-0.0672099292,
-0.0331490077,
0.0050574779,
3.237e-7,
-0.0257431399,
0.0345455334,
0.0412984081,
-0.0095321443,
-0.0194080081,
0.0815537646,
-0.0448325351,
0.066168353,
-0.0156170046,
0.0044964091,
-0.0492131338,
-0.0117101837,
0.0436665341,
0.008772999,
-0.0592566542,
0.0711381435,
-0.0386323705,
0.0092020892,
-0.082907483,
-0.0179763027,
-0.0274968743,
0.0740818009,
0.0131256906,
-0.0268670116,
-0.0142239612,
-0.0421010405,
-0.001680822,
0.0090113766,
-0.0288434774,
-0.0002011943,
0.0203997102,
0.0042155841,
-0.0181236658,
0.0211276636,
-0.0351096392,
-0.0077851289,
-0.0359937958,
0.0282371752,
0.0388503522,
0.0003515753,
-0.0405194275,
-0.0274123717,
-0.041863922,
-0.0235071238,
0.0540723838,
0.0372998081,
-0.030971732,
-0.0477408171,
0.0129467053,
-0.0234060083,
-0.0055934591,
-0.033153642,
-0.0003664136,
0.0200419184,
0.0238842797,
0.0227199998,
0.0284551177,
-0.0622049943,
-0.0139091164,
0.0183070041,
-0.0260003861,
-0.0257974826,
0.0141644422,
0.0827012211,
0.0532876477,
-0.0262904111,
-0.0044898251,
3.440267659e-34,
-0.0004850881,
-0.0438067466,
0.0181114655,
0.0095036151,
0.0418472551,
-0.0212865286,
-0.0267009158,
0.0140716163,
-0.0062290211,
-0.0280394945,
-0.0371129364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20999v1
|
Towards a Fluid computer
| 2024-05-31T16:41:36 | 2024-05-31T16:41:36 |
Robert Cardona, Eva Miranda, Daniel Peralta-Salas
|
math.DS
|
math.DS, cs.CL, math.AP, math.SG
|
In 1991, Moore [20] raised a question about whether hydrodynamics is capable
of performing computations. Similarly, in 2016, Tao [25] asked whether a
mechanical system, including a fluid flow, can simulate a universal Turing
machine. In this expository article, we review the construction in [8] of a
"Fluid computer" in dimension 3 that combines techniques in symbolic dynamics
with the connection between steady Euler flows and contact geometry unveiled by
Etnyre and Ghrist. In addition, we argue that the metric that renders the
vector field Beltrami cannot be critical in the Chern-Hamilton sense [9]. We
also sketch the completely different construction for the Euclidean metric in
$\mathbb R^3$ as given in [7]. These results reveal the existence of
undecidable fluid particle paths. We conclude the article with a list of open
problems.
|
[
-0.0436607115,
0.0259082429,
-0.0463887341,
-0.014708315,
-0.0177148916,
0.0043336297,
0.0102237193,
-0.0010520301,
-0.0311083924,
0.0184626319,
0.0071956259,
-0.0412411019,
-0.0366329886,
0.0129502406,
0.0386935882,
-0.0667432919,
0.004805855,
0.0151413837,
-0.0406996384,
-0.0475003384,
-0.031522803,
-0.0562754832,
-0.0132073155,
-0.0416780002,
0.0298106018,
0.0314838402,
-0.0276046507,
-0.0589574575,
-0.0255394094,
0.0069584856,
-0.0344888642,
0.0395235494,
-0.0093844067,
0.0717424229,
0.0000016901,
0.0079069808,
0.0536216348,
0.0237341113,
-0.0240319911,
-0.0719265118,
-0.0200912189,
0.0167822484,
0.0165528152,
-0.0435394198,
0.0290911328,
0.0323576666,
0.0053804945,
-0.0591328368,
0.0255499892,
0.0381666087,
0.0069851237,
0.0370132439,
0.0239317175,
0.0180720333,
0.0652192533,
0.0120435134,
-0.0319452882,
0.0335740335,
0.0376312621,
-0.0373755395,
0.0141019477,
0.0236101802,
0.025339216,
-0.0223245621,
0.0166332126,
0.0426786989,
-0.0183662362,
0.0070916065,
-0.0126801562,
0.0579903983,
0.0095146671,
0.0001166391,
-0.025380766,
0.0235838145,
-0.0112710055,
-0.0100915134,
0.0237582829,
-0.0210667998,
0.0490647703,
-0.0148360943,
-0.0032099844,
-0.0249572117,
-0.006439162,
-0.0519086421,
-0.0177092403,
0.0416701473,
0.0578429773,
0.03330018,
-0.0015376818,
0.0284680091,
0.0264870245,
-0.0638726652,
-0.0121948142,
-0.0066166059,
-0.0230340231,
-0.029542977,
-0.0315014608,
0.00668889,
-0.0226034801,
-0.0772227794,
0.1020752639,
-0.0159450751,
0.1067672521,
0.0163718183,
-0.0141122583,
0.029651165,
-0.0322993733,
0.0614473745,
-0.0027198424,
0.0289106257,
-0.0197433475,
0.0318089053,
-0.0277554747,
0.03736737,
0.0012376127,
-0.0084538106,
-0.0248262137,
0.0719720423,
-0.0167814195,
-0.0155302696,
-0.0651279464,
-0.0330740772,
0.0757322311,
-0.0033949772,
-0.0475802496,
-0.02976368,
0.0189460963,
0.027097458,
-0.0345877074,
0.0125348978,
-0.0179704428,
0.0251234602,
-0.0245694704,
-0.0100562098,
0.0053876708,
0.0178265646,
0.0168527942,
-0.0071385014,
0.0676918626,
0.0547256097,
0.0146901514,
-0.0439395681,
0.0717543215,
0.0129384464,
-0.0180537794,
-0.0132803172,
0.0509088598,
-0.0367593057,
-0.0109632583,
-0.0426979661,
-0.024373794,
0.0079967948,
-0.0124421902,
0.0206875596,
0.0247507952,
-0.0276740175,
0.0447293967,
0.004851927,
0.0215536673,
-0.0100140637,
-0.0001475457,
0.0247498788,
0.0515932851,
0.0307439044,
0.0018483998,
0.0139235724,
-0.0272526387,
-0.0359428264,
0.0070092366,
0.0486209206,
-0.0238497313,
0.0167416744,
-0.0035234564,
-0.0467360727,
-0.0450423583,
0.01990382,
0.0126268677,
-0.0120084342,
0.0637276024,
-0.0343403704,
0.0219343342,
0.0691402331,
-0.0236213319,
0.0124182003,
0.0462990589,
0.026943922,
0.0560990125,
-0.0191273801,
-0.0344379246,
-0.0712475479,
0.0205745865,
-0.00695174,
-0.0354633592,
-0.0516005754,
0.0358739905,
0.0365327559,
0.0004901838,
-0.0344678983,
-0.0365025066,
0.0102950232,
0.0072920555,
0.0156280305,
0.0580754355,
0.0250159055,
-0.026925588,
-0.0427720919,
-0.01766547,
0.0095897242,
0.0050132773,
0.0359600671,
0.0504533835,
0.0208520945,
0.007250322,
-0.0001976262,
0.0119962841,
0.0094619812,
0.0518032722,
-0.0221221838,
-0.0437228046,
0.0314411633,
-0.0402413309,
0.050039731,
0.0226333085,
0.0222187825,
0.0495365784,
-0.0315194651,
0.0340147987,
0.0061284038,
0.0458689742,
0.018224461,
-0.0163425356,
0.0395648479,
0.0183125101,
-0.0434666537,
-0.0278870948,
-0.027977014,
-0.0362874344,
0.060218282,
0.0017175892,
-0.0338702686,
0.0216841288,
-0.032740999,
-0.0233831145,
-0.0149473334,
0.0501392335,
0.0037943984,
-0.0496351272,
0.0022180006,
0.0040416941,
0.0046407157,
0.0096650599,
0.0242157839,
-0.0138069103,
0.0058662049,
0.0570343994,
0.0271068569,
0.0685349479,
-0.0261750948,
0.0099858856,
-0.0712819323,
0.0456062593,
0.0603550598,
0.0057522766,
0.0285262242,
-0.005983579,
0.0198923647,
-0.0122533599,
0.0099263778,
-0.0019815126,
0.0047854469,
0.0012638744,
-0.0052971221,
0.0340803675,
0.0120804263,
0.0314152054,
0.0085618757,
0.0550666489,
0.0646650717,
-0.0193719696,
0.0233934037,
-0.0339629836,
-0.0462115407,
0.0180406664,
0.0148925688,
-0.013620819,
0.0139954304,
0.0050015459,
0.0326745734,
-0.0056155692,
-0.0327764601,
-0.0107984608,
-0.0166009795,
0.0387510993,
0.0690285712,
-0.0248161629,
-0.0061749448,
-0.0156342741,
0.0166627448,
-0.0531898402,
0.0062821051,
-0.044164788,
-0.0063416357,
0.0078620026,
-0.0397104919,
-0.0399706662,
-0.0217928346,
0.0167741869,
-0.020384416,
0.0542411469,
0.0473538674,
-0.0631511733,
0.0237887669,
-0.0074214614,
-0.0053539067,
-0.0018818036,
0.0569527112,
0.0112043899,
-0.0090242485,
-0.00087128,
-0.000831939,
-0.0009766129,
0.005588227,
0.0219809953,
0.0317184813,
-0.0099265408,
0.0259730853,
-0.0180718303,
-0.0328059755,
0.0827301145,
0.031221224,
-0.0137948515,
0.0126222391,
-0.0116530955,
0.0542711616,
0.0048939115,
0.0137771396,
0.0342178568,
-0.0487702191,
-0.0474737175,
0.0134732844,
-0.0005148955,
-0.0241302233,
0.0296084564,
0.0285231471,
0.016047677,
0.0310228486,
-0.0103456154,
-0.0375426039,
-0.0122716008,
0.0171174761,
0.0211358145,
0.0120138135,
0.0090744831,
-0.0121091567,
-0.0028808997,
0.0595747903,
-0.0033484593,
0.0711292922,
-0.026114583,
0.0229143295,
0.0378368795,
0.0442004427,
0.004771491,
0.0175280031,
-0.0244915262,
0.0266569201,
0.0069367671,
0.001484661,
0.0065104011,
-0.0090366742,
-0.0285565611,
0.0365042202,
-0.084737666,
-0.0394356474,
-0.0229310859,
0.0643381551,
-0.0094331568,
0.0467265286,
-0.0224975143,
-0.0016319037,
0.0035535118,
-0.020841144,
0.0289723575,
0.0051596398,
-0.0437915958,
-0.0305793136,
0.0083408579,
-0.0031782454,
0.0653086454,
-0.024800973,
0.0312977023,
-0.0269875303,
-0.0212308876,
-0.0581756309,
-0.0081974855,
-0.0191183817,
-0.0182306748,
-0.0355957299,
0.0333352201,
0.0094326697,
-0.0081131812,
0.0601734519,
-0.0574199371,
0.01365651,
0.0417949744,
-0.0465030372,
-0.0155022684,
0.0455920808,
-0.0423848741,
-0.0555480272,
-0.0114466827,
0.0154295219,
0.002799541,
-0.0032087662,
-0.0488310009,
0.0573264696,
0.0186263695,
-0.0199900959,
-0.0471324921,
-0.0028962784,
0.0125411609,
-0.0037578561,
0.0211691223,
-0.0552837364,
-0.0006339507,
-0.039067138,
-0.046069786,
-0.0200575609,
0.0276885219,
-0.0381185636,
-0.0332358703,
-0.0375663117,
-0.0128799863,
0.0169507805,
0.0486381389,
-0.0610930808,
-0.0678527504,
0.0155172618,
-0.0961161181,
-0.0100481603,
0.0178580992,
-0.0213932786,
0.0321774147,
0.0134050231,
-0.0357971787,
0.0306816064,
-0.0193308983,
-0.0576935448,
-0.0099583967,
-0.0953997597,
0.0008078131,
0.0003207035,
-0.011207005,
-0.0020812119,
-0.0252418909,
-0.0506539755,
0.0319120847,
0.0216563772,
-0.0468609482,
0.010932968,
0.0758626312,
0.017845761,
-0.0663905665,
-0.0141713805,
0.0540872104,
-0.0351728611,
0.0368709341,
-0.0421424061,
0.0172852352,
-0.0010899224,
0.0122600924,
-0.016212685,
-0.0148881804,
0.0222332366,
-0.063502878,
-0.0075466172,
-0.0397837423,
-0.0663302094,
-0.0033002966,
-0.0318772011,
0.0024647035,
0.0216678567,
0.0703590885,
-0.0072106179,
0.0078729307,
0.0001932592,
0.0361563116,
0.0179260187,
-0.0372174196,
-0.0072782352,
-0.0466322228,
-0.0011686514,
-0.058805082,
-0.0489322543,
0.0341356769,
-0.0503983833,
0.0030098497,
-0.0051169884,
0.020191174,
0.104342103,
-0.0384623669,
-0.0079116244,
0.0062844548,
0.0504402816,
-0.0329460353,
0.0222354624,
-0.0262732878,
-0.0560055226,
-0.0126059074,
0.0514083914,
-0.0274352338,
0.0059062699,
-0.1454777569,
-0.0295187086,
0.0345401801,
0.0780760571,
0.0636164695,
0.0370549783,
-0.0647356659,
-0.0767159313,
0.0060451189,
0.0036727407,
-0.0063994536,
0.0501623265,
-0.0514311902,
-0.0222913343,
0.0283321161,
-0.0306800697,
-0.0011568607,
0.0078569297,
-0.0888560861,
0.0075124535,
0.0362996347,
-0.0347159393,
-0.0468804091,
-0.0138562629,
0.0215693247,
0.0567435771,
0.0465470217,
-0.0319738872,
-0.0292721055,
0.0191036966,
0.0524102487,
0.0224462878,
0.0033961115,
0.0149995163,
0.0157513637,
-0.0128441835,
-0.0274046883,
0.0115869576,
0.0089180497,
0.0352752358,
-0.011815914,
-0.0194625165,
-0.0179737993,
-5.178586731e-33,
-0.0076993741,
-0.0031305249,
-0.0091700722,
0.0067885439,
0.0066835205,
0.001049648,
-0.0214542039,
-0.015485663,
-0.0410167202,
0.0234472938,
0.0031387864,
-0.0251390357,
-0.0096222246,
-0.0238804165,
0.0214700028,
-0.0454713888,
0.0105370134,
-0.0410694033,
0.0020253214,
0.0732999295,
0.0049113543,
-0.0177019518,
-0.0361891836,
-0.0003822627,
0.0477607548,
-0.0502815917,
-0.0389471613,
0.0152463354,
-0.0481981449,
-0.0241482724,
-0.0462180972,
0.0084361611,
-0.0398469232,
-0.012337151,
-0.0220596604,
0.0193843693,
-0.0685747638,
-0.055134356,
-0.0297487453,
0.0062214541,
0.0357920639,
-0.0397628881,
0.007882202,
-0.0118009681,
-0.0421062745,
0.0184728261,
-0.0177520663,
0.0028922972,
-0.0214164499,
-0.1091528237,
0.0166370329,
-0.0030740118,
-0.0343284942,
-0.0084257489,
0.0480292514,
-0.0683022067,
0.00428322,
-0.0698226094,
-0.0110166175,
0.0748850033,
-0.0589019023,
-0.0779968947,
-0.01562679,
-0.0701690391,
0.0563410521,
0.0253384691,
0.0796511769,
-0.0278179571,
-0.0388960913,
0.0508810207,
0.0296555124,
0.0044313176,
0.0033632752,
-0.0017196515,
0.0179567821,
0.0241229348,
-0.0341685489,
-0.0239511225,
-0.0463221669,
0.0276525076,
0.0118710427,
-0.0092647765,
-0.0800060779,
-0.0436706506,
0.0181801729,
-0.0248417892,
0.0298012085,
0.0719526336,
-0.0042781211,
-0.0142791048,
0.0734095052,
-0.0387631804,
-0.0323237218,
0.0076344921,
0.0139354542,
-0.0252746493,
0.1028131843,
-0.0110389171,
0.0347180106,
-0.0213121679,
0.0825042129,
0.0227789823,
-0.092757687,
0.0002407422,
-0.0106438184,
0.0224471204,
-0.0529878177,
0.0400130376,
-0.0180436485,
0.0012636284,
-0.0142293619,
-0.050209444,
0.0675327554,
0.0373479761,
0.0197014771,
0.0217968449,
-0.0027235022,
0.0031779346,
-0.0184309594,
0.0171546713,
0.0269819181,
0.0575936809,
-0.0614775382,
0.0998153165,
-0.0021160271,
-0.031313777,
-0.0244202781,
0.0498263352,
0.0650405735,
-0.050205376,
-0.0111595904,
0.0165312495,
2.434e-7,
-0.0078359423,
-0.0304455813,
0.042589549,
-0.0169214327,
-0.0461506024,
0.0012564488,
0.002930108,
-0.0037128679,
0.0023048075,
0.0157224033,
0.0362131707,
0.0395030677,
-0.0186027531,
-0.0235972013,
-0.0675402358,
0.0177671723,
0.054053288,
-0.0223839637,
0.0354256146,
-0.0119989011,
0.0091719925,
0.0134595502,
0.0880319476,
0.0265147313,
0.0118870279,
-0.0277342219,
-0.0275115743,
-0.0370275714,
0.1131537706,
0.0368282199,
-0.0012554841,
-0.0060661184,
-0.0377691649,
0.0218495261,
-0.0126349563,
-0.005777474,
0.0343385786,
0.0325042829,
0.0463218056,
0.0593083687,
-0.084267363,
-0.0482195877,
-0.0220763031,
-0.0038517409,
-0.0035293272,
-0.0051866896,
0.0194288548,
-0.0462094396,
0.0242254548,
0.0434543677,
0.1030610651,
0.0486050211,
0.0253597032,
-0.0171161592,
-0.0064698975,
0.0079182889,
0.0246525891,
-0.0131494431,
0.0259795208,
-0.0012161793,
-0.0304935649,
0.0113517577,
0.034200225,
0.0277486183,
0.0716119632,
-0.0439914614,
-0.0281391945,
2.233445695e-34,
0.0199372806,
-0.0505967252,
0.0613931306,
0.020497527,
0.0177705586,
0.0386726595,
-0.0047881631,
-0.0376819074,
0.0458313413,
-0.0269192718,
-0.0108846994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20994v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20994v1
|
CWRCzech: 100M Query-Document Czech Click Dataset and Its Application to Web Relevance Ranking
| 2024-05-31T16:38:54 | 2024-05-31T16:38:54 |
Josef Vonášek, Milan Straka, Rostislav Krč, Lenka Lasoňová, Ekaterina Egorova, Jana Straková, Jakub Náplava
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
We present CWRCzech, Click Web Ranking dataset for Czech, a 100M
query-document Czech click dataset for relevance ranking with user behavior
data collected from search engine logs of Seznam.cz. To the best of our
knowledge, CWRCzech is the largest click dataset with raw text published so
far. It provides document positions in the search results as well as
information about user behavior: 27.6M clicked documents and 10.8M dwell times.
In addition, we also publish a manually annotated Czech test for the relevance
task, containing nearly 50k query-document pairs, each annotated by at least 2
annotators. Finally, we analyze how the user behavior data improve relevance
ranking and show that models trained on data automatically harnessed at
sufficient scale can surpass the performance of models trained on human
annotated data. CWRCzech is published under an academic non-commercial license
and is available to the research community at
https://github.com/seznam/CWRCzech.
|
[
0.0392107703,
-0.0017490435,
-0.0111793578,
0.0107839582,
0.0255314559,
0.0120927934,
-0.0114645585,
-0.0269136317,
0.0160741135,
-0.0555593036,
-0.0734297708,
0.020998463,
-0.0593357906,
0.0237029605,
0.0578324459,
-0.027544912,
0.0316172615,
0.0193036646,
-0.0319630578,
0.0173284542,
0.0600889027,
-0.0073664887,
0.0148402369,
0.0254744161,
0.0560898185,
0.0260371305,
-0.0390655063,
0.0085033495,
0.0079920804,
-0.0186910611,
0.0177694298,
0.0313154086,
0.0310599487,
0.0700373948,
0.000001378,
-0.0335754231,
-0.0139731476,
-0.0520952567,
-0.0051573589,
0.0247759763,
0.0496793278,
-0.0002189204,
0.0145889334,
-0.0094675012,
-0.0252891369,
0.010047812,
-0.0205191802,
0.0188626163,
0.0069728252,
0.0241128653,
0.0228746906,
0.0175239053,
0.0291104428,
-0.0291411038,
0.0489442535,
-0.0242137052,
0.0224036518,
0.0004351956,
0.0047750957,
0.037311852,
0.0143729718,
0.0066966936,
-0.0290772207,
-0.0589552186,
0.0585035495,
-0.0000378155,
-0.0433570668,
0.000102541,
0.0183876026,
0.0566102825,
0.0177813396,
-0.012370131,
0.0316300169,
0.0312477369,
-0.0181596801,
0.0109980796,
-0.0599891432,
-0.0134523427,
0.0148889152,
0.0001411575,
-0.0028474038,
0.019727638,
-0.0039382973,
-0.0028476564,
0.0261893477,
0.0568926409,
-0.0081814863,
-0.0162431244,
0.0538822114,
0.0151057318,
0.0367146581,
-0.0323874541,
0.0188511107,
-0.004064884,
-0.0318925157,
0.0003745452,
-0.0007516139,
0.0274287257,
0.0589523688,
-0.0891878754,
-0.0255964845,
0.0234693512,
0.0191340595,
0.0475995801,
-0.0243816171,
0.0348969102,
-0.0045680301,
0.0142992204,
-0.0520447865,
-0.0102821579,
-0.0374610089,
-0.0067857481,
-0.0053730272,
-0.0126095274,
0.0254048351,
-0.0107358843,
-0.0543504171,
0.0514748432,
0.026175132,
-0.0024450633,
-0.0260232836,
0.0371126086,
-0.0604560599,
0.0432098433,
-0.0312416852,
-0.034464445,
-0.0435426235,
0.0228723753,
-0.0112717589,
-0.005192535,
0.0301270485,
0.0285119731,
0.0070155654,
-0.0634730682,
0.0305266697,
-0.0236695986,
0.0077264141,
0.0068867407,
-0.0119572747,
-0.0395213403,
0.0759712309,
0.0061865784,
-0.0461602807,
-0.0312154833,
0.0165147614,
0.004027837,
0.0018089996,
0.0174653977,
-0.0256475937,
0.0673584491,
-0.0059783687,
0.07783968,
0.0274907351,
-0.0235462505,
0.023651462,
-0.0148268808,
0.0266703032,
0.0270517897,
-0.0666275322,
0.0535166599,
0.0578706823,
0.0149270911,
-0.0065895603,
0.0171244815,
0.0065992563,
-0.0065935301,
0.0455134101,
0.0686578974,
-0.0087853847,
-0.0062879375,
0.0660807714,
0.0054092598,
-0.0443412587,
-0.0706197023,
0.0033240099,
0.0346759111,
0.0248912349,
-0.0122142583,
0.029326139,
0.0028784599,
-0.0142701613,
-0.0205211528,
-0.019680867,
0.0087621799,
-0.0135854185,
-0.0032512143,
0.0420409441,
-0.0077644843,
-0.0509891957,
-0.0092539201,
0.0035966102,
0.0333614759,
0.0266131889,
-0.0242351014,
0.0525163449,
-0.0227139108,
0.0100046853,
0.0055284887,
-0.0076137274,
0.0079637486,
0.0211689956,
-0.0390489995,
-0.0025734976,
0.0367122255,
0.06447687,
-0.0574102663,
0.0220641475,
-0.0301782861,
-0.0010555836,
-0.057275407,
0.0560807064,
-0.0692155138,
-0.0201587509,
-0.0134293577,
-0.0630266964,
0.0127414335,
-0.0140732788,
0.0194660891,
-0.0211728718,
0.0319017619,
0.0476828255,
-0.0465870053,
0.0319847241,
0.0133104129,
0.0102411937,
-0.0069719311,
-0.0122147193,
-0.0089486167,
0.0205544699,
0.0030222931,
0.0283724498,
0.0011231956,
0.0509387963,
0.0241308678,
0.0256873313,
-0.0112912543,
0.0396636464,
-0.0226451997,
0.0301851649,
-0.0625395924,
0.0688485578,
0.0488000996,
0.0197696332,
-0.0286671948,
0.0087458231,
-0.0404238775,
0.0170034748,
-0.0311433598,
0.0039231735,
-0.0151416389,
0.0432469323,
-0.0407178923,
0.0304865204,
-0.012841084,
0.0626486614,
0.0654427186,
-0.0006140738,
-0.0098032281,
-0.0720156655,
-0.0140844984,
-0.0058827223,
-0.023825977,
0.0016608486,
0.0516952872,
-0.0078552142,
-0.0514848195,
0.0906914771,
-0.1209054142,
0.0243871659,
-0.0105384337,
0.0654700845,
0.0163183939,
-0.0014586955,
0.0134332106,
-0.0328297131,
-0.0628700033,
-0.0307312794,
-0.0039211689,
0.0245778803,
0.024892088,
0.0343854874,
-0.0028691334,
-0.0787538663,
-0.0594719984,
-0.0136379478,
-0.0212248676,
0.028753899,
-0.0133740269,
-0.0406995341,
0.0238742866,
-0.0255298596,
0.0337866135,
-0.0698060617,
-0.0201678947,
-0.0232021362,
-0.0142155485,
-0.0051091467,
0.0811589062,
-0.0149744377,
0.0124723315,
0.03053765,
0.0135642104,
-0.1072387695,
-0.010843345,
-0.0360032357,
0.0604060441,
-0.0450924337,
-0.0604630224,
0.0556765087,
-0.0287389103,
-0.0375354961,
0.0061002052,
0.0121990088,
-0.0154262139,
-0.0274137296,
0.0148523124,
-0.0814239308,
-0.000236493,
0.0003105231,
0.0370443426,
0.0374018215,
0.0117392382,
0.0260469839,
0.0192456655,
0.0119888587,
-0.0305037703,
-0.025006881,
-0.0321865231,
0.0197519362,
0.0185193736,
-0.0012634469,
-0.0747805908,
-0.0057859221,
-0.0130259302,
0.0117954658,
0.0490665846,
-0.0257772543,
0.0131225102,
0.0553275123,
0.0273626931,
-0.025133362,
-0.0466352776,
-0.029129684,
-0.1110219955,
0.0212982707,
-0.029134471,
0.0404592492,
-0.022676954,
-0.0572665446,
0.0160992574,
0.0233070049,
0.0759061128,
-0.0089581423,
-0.0664555281,
0.0176154133,
0.0496684983,
0.0338078812,
-0.0284213256,
-0.0172068626,
-0.0082273604,
-0.026296936,
0.0752142817,
0.0769378319,
-0.0343597792,
-0.0026560649,
-0.0212504975,
0.0632165819,
-0.0319994614,
-0.0007538327,
-0.0458767004,
-0.0258160625,
-0.0124224797,
-0.0079789292,
0.0685180426,
0.0475002266,
-0.0809155405,
-0.0322699696,
-0.0361808501,
0.036061015,
0.052172441,
0.0577096269,
-0.0333326049,
0.001611763,
0.009407511,
0.0642111674,
-0.057598535,
0.0076614521,
0.0118724024,
-0.0866631418,
-0.0060821082,
-0.0295756552,
0.0119156018,
-0.0001232971,
-0.080491513,
0.0191859063,
-0.0740635619,
-0.0512189306,
0.04704367,
-0.0297597889,
0.0030470137,
0.0602298491,
-0.0016269559,
-0.0556930974,
0.0259333998,
0.0050190124,
0.0050624963,
0.0207690019,
0.0294469912,
-0.0130141824,
-0.0028681108,
0.0099398615,
-0.0157792065,
-0.0128458701,
0.0083688488,
0.0589759164,
-0.0107342042,
0.0280672535,
-0.033604905,
0.0093129557,
-0.0054804431,
0.0198925883,
0.0179246664,
0.0083313286,
-0.0231957529,
0.0319405198,
-0.0721292272,
-0.015341565,
-0.0163773634,
0.0253631976,
0.0122222053,
-0.0132065723,
-0.0119235413,
-0.0404289998,
-0.0108023146,
-0.0071316888,
-0.0479610786,
-0.0015986105,
-0.0391881987,
-0.0392015986,
-0.0732654184,
-0.0646144822,
-0.0028192,
0.0130413482,
-0.0212601218,
0.0018417817,
-0.0731303617,
0.0021487877,
-0.0597479939,
0.0449811853,
0.0213006455,
0.0286802761,
-0.0381561331,
0.0245194975,
0.0666238219,
-0.064799279,
-0.0430403426,
-0.0037430495,
-0.0330758058,
-0.0225990843,
-0.0395560898,
0.0286212564,
0.0215244945,
0.0416177362,
-0.0345410444,
-0.0560569689,
0.0039767995,
0.0459730066,
-0.0304524582,
-0.045472648,
0.0183986258,
-0.0354994945,
-0.0101667652,
-0.0026079994,
-0.0599360913,
0.0121010225,
-0.0555369593,
-0.0237359647,
-0.0427741967,
-0.0191956423,
0.0197773743,
0.0367826931,
0.0613059551,
0.0313022174,
0.0304794647,
-0.0248876624,
0.0127038946,
0.0307265166,
-0.0177362487,
0.0034916797,
0.0201010965,
0.0232647061,
-0.0104979184,
-0.0498456396,
0.0364115164,
-0.0130448332,
-0.0637858734,
-0.0905909091,
-0.0060244682,
0.0547463931,
0.0486368872,
-0.0041542528,
0.0049633635,
-0.0390077718,
0.0038014983,
0.034790922,
0.0430448912,
-0.0346686132,
-0.0116369966,
0.0023688262,
-0.0311880782,
0.0358625278,
0.0206507202,
-0.0717298761,
0.0567026772,
-0.0458211787,
-0.065537177,
0.0314495675,
-0.0079533448,
0.0367772579,
-0.0062477374,
-0.0176879,
0.0225074645,
-0.0139629114,
0.0035492666,
0.0218128189,
-0.0053110095,
0.0367516801,
0.0026543448,
0.0222847499,
0.0263024811,
0.0259542391,
-0.0164625011,
-0.0378662869,
-0.0901865289,
-0.0326680765,
0.0383166932,
0.0334785245,
0.0600905456,
-0.0193116516,
-0.0232937802,
0.0066851019,
-0.0301459413,
0.0055419328,
-0.0062832749,
0.0100387186,
-0.0073426506,
0.0886733234,
0.0616333485,
0.0046490333,
0.0198124647,
-0.0536347106,
0.0143296039,
-0.0241683945,
-0.0110790469,
-0.0137924533,
-5.369716969e-33,
0.0231188182,
0.0016034326,
-0.0437051132,
-0.0107298214,
-0.0110869762,
-0.0272237845,
0.001529936,
-0.0458353274,
-0.0285028964,
-0.0331666656,
-0.0108554894,
0.0176798701,
0.0195416342,
-0.0244369935,
0.0196807068,
0.0222955681,
0.0453489572,
-0.0038215285,
-0.0184248351,
0.0665263981,
0.0651408285,
0.0172807314,
0.0274735447,
-0.0495523699,
0.0285203569,
-0.0443628579,
-0.0340894237,
-0.0088360384,
0.0116945673,
0.1032966077,
-0.025221495,
0.036561951,
0.0230445471,
-0.0617193356,
0.0171674602,
-0.009127466,
-0.0453588665,
-0.0202803202,
0.0056143394,
0.0466568582,
-0.0071942438,
0.0214493237,
0.0779709443,
-0.0211636126,
-0.011679424,
0.0615828,
0.0765107721,
-0.0031864594,
-0.0329081342,
-0.0514261983,
-0.017838195,
0.023040561,
-0.0268980768,
-0.0003221396,
0.0284692906,
0.0974556506,
0.003397173,
0.0509193987,
-0.0404852368,
0.0299770515,
-0.0233119614,
0.0533931479,
0.0436678156,
0.0017829762,
0.0107996669,
0.0497029014,
0.0192988589,
-0.0163829438,
0.0363820754,
-0.0038138961,
-0.0032086964,
0.0060635875,
0.0041847294,
0.0496394634,
0.0069627473,
-0.0058216164,
-0.0637093782,
0.0944559127,
0.0767572895,
-0.0169894807,
0.0200364478,
0.0235279407,
-0.0440829657,
-0.0227625277,
0.0040136226,
0.011283325,
-0.0352502279,
0.00353325,
0.0584773868,
0.0257624909,
-0.0304879211,
0.0095909601,
0.0020566401,
-0.0124426149,
-0.0441886187,
0.0456150547,
-0.0302425809,
0.0075262543,
-0.0112153208,
-0.0342748649,
-0.0136758974,
-0.0371170193,
-0.041575212,
-0.0257289838,
-0.0160718933,
-0.0286284257,
-0.0057523442,
0.003758905,
-0.0127579672,
-0.0333839841,
0.0141487354,
-0.0076710777,
-0.0279307645,
0.0283442084,
0.0391216949,
-0.0014982193,
-0.0327669494,
0.0541252196,
0.0450194255,
0.0119453855,
-0.0080776177,
-0.0779143423,
0.0131527642,
-0.0058478261,
0.0111186439,
-0.0026605895,
-0.0189815462,
0.061068207,
-0.0331270918,
-0.0375729203,
0.0069237393,
0.0073342477,
2.27e-7,
0.0318830647,
0.0360353887,
-0.0507851765,
-0.0038053945,
0.0233293623,
-0.0012063596,
-0.0394844487,
0.0673418865,
0.0322516672,
0.0404193923,
0.0143640107,
-0.0434050411,
-0.0024386111,
0.0116268946,
-0.0703010559,
-0.0240361169,
-0.0542633459,
-0.0099194422,
-0.0313282162,
-0.0132493237,
-0.0146867242,
0.1121452972,
0.0097169476,
0.0119519895,
0.0184403788,
-0.0486549139,
0.0293398499,
0.014859803,
-0.0352296308,
0.0192440748,
0.0613811314,
0.0435263813,
-0.0341359638,
0.0024491211,
-0.002010372,
0.0377387255,
0.0847014636,
0.000240391,
-0.007222658,
-0.0108585842,
0.0267187376,
-0.0440608785,
0.0316391475,
-0.0403354131,
0.0579166487,
0.0069717607,
0.0028285638,
0.0374959372,
-0.014306427,
-0.0072178408,
0.048599977,
-0.0356760062,
0.0025905075,
-0.014771794,
-0.0233929977,
-0.0003403668,
-0.0466057882,
-0.0835810751,
0.0047875568,
-0.0177135821,
-0.0458198935,
-0.0376218297,
-0.0322311372,
0.025162939,
-0.0587651506,
0.0257387869,
-0.0069154007,
1.414246093e-34,
0.0313464291,
0.0339585543,
-0.0172390565,
-0.0596208759,
-0.0108283442,
0.0085050706,
0.0271420237,
0.0018696876,
0.062450327,
-0.0523275621,
-0.02685312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20974v2
|
SaySelf: Teaching LLMs to Express Confidence with Self-Reflective Rationales
| 2024-05-31T16:21:16 | 2024-06-05T17:04:01 |
Tianyang Xu, Shujin Wu, Shizhe Diao, Xiaoze Liu, Xingyao Wang, Yangyi Chen, Jing Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) often generate inaccurate or fabricated
information and generally fail to indicate their confidence, which limits their
broader applications. Previous work elicits confidence from LLMs by direct or
self-consistency prompting, or constructing specific datasets for supervised
finetuning. The prompting-based approaches have inferior performance, and the
training-based approaches are limited to binary or inaccurate group-level
confidence estimates. In this work, we present the advanced SaySelf, a training
framework that teaches LLMs to express more accurate fine-grained confidence
estimates. In addition, beyond the confidence scores, SaySelf initiates the
process of directing LLMs to produce self-reflective rationales that clearly
identify gaps in their parametric knowledge and explain their uncertainty. This
is achieved by using an LLM to automatically summarize the uncertainties in
specific knowledge via natural language. The summarization is based on the
analysis of the inconsistency in multiple sampled reasoning chains, and the
resulting data is utilized for supervised fine-tuning. Moreover, we utilize
reinforcement learning with a meticulously crafted reward function to calibrate
the confidence estimates, motivating LLMs to deliver accurate, high-confidence
predictions and to penalize overconfidence in erroneous outputs. Experimental
results in both in-distribution and out-of-distribution datasets demonstrate
the effectiveness of SaySelf in reducing the confidence calibration error and
maintaining the task performance. We show that the generated self-reflective
rationales are reasonable and can further contribute to the calibration. The
code is made public at https://github.com/xu1868/SaySelf.
|
[
0.0342646055,
0.0769895017,
-0.0069382358,
0.0360281058,
-0.0496864729,
0.0021212841,
-0.0319344439,
-0.0549064763,
-0.0286595784,
-0.0399480537,
-0.0472362228,
-0.0044902144,
0.0165833794,
0.0161476508,
0.0402674936,
-0.0517110452,
0.0551075712,
-0.0451276936,
0.0607209131,
-0.0162707679,
-0.0033130366,
0.0105158165,
-0.0253298264,
0.0360511616,
0.0160917901,
-0.0221736524,
-0.0053550708,
0.0063420334,
0.019925097,
-0.0639684722,
0.0264823865,
0.0657718405,
0.0407352597,
0.0067941612,
0.0000021557,
-0.0694931895,
-0.022113245,
-0.0269039869,
-0.042557247,
0.0026006787,
0.0203441642,
0.0048328494,
-0.0035845882,
0.0128389727,
-0.0465305857,
0.0394425355,
0.0064564827,
0.0193752311,
0.0562339425,
0.0653300658,
0.0252856482,
0.001125997,
-0.0179076958,
-0.0261029825,
-0.0043054693,
-0.029165335,
-0.0009842482,
0.035546612,
-0.0096528893,
0.0331338942,
-0.0033934221,
0.0183098484,
0.008444747,
-0.0226404108,
-0.0257974286,
0.0202985108,
-0.0174183901,
-0.0275652837,
-0.0193873849,
0.0423302948,
0.0269224141,
-0.0506482571,
-0.0316640139,
-0.0262970682,
0.01890097,
0.0032067162,
-0.0573040545,
0.0517712124,
0.0016967796,
0.0404818952,
-0.0022406152,
0.0429108739,
0.0327733122,
0.0311293378,
0.0028369047,
0.0681713149,
-0.0223781504,
-0.016981801,
0.0124715874,
0.0052252607,
-0.0179387592,
-0.0412573256,
-0.0508942828,
0.0632931739,
-0.0550916195,
0.0325630233,
-0.0299771968,
0.019619029,
0.0371313579,
0.0190808158,
0.0194386598,
0.0329924226,
-0.0062197675,
0.0429374129,
-0.0268662721,
0.0458782874,
0.0416142158,
0.047400672,
0.01075467,
0.0023788421,
-0.028303463,
-0.0120745189,
-0.0148314126,
0.0080496585,
-0.0228395239,
0.0068504238,
-0.0890691057,
-0.0088189151,
-0.053346321,
0.0657942146,
0.0227687843,
0.0361888707,
-0.0102221482,
-0.0551537275,
-0.0674808621,
0.028674813,
-0.0119626848,
0.0272024423,
0.0330777988,
-0.0566405952,
-0.0043400736,
-0.0047115912,
-0.0246904623,
0.0082506742,
0.0158137754,
0.0703097209,
0.0010264264,
-0.0252588633,
-0.0539586358,
-0.0329027884,
-0.0431406274,
-0.0922046304,
-0.0263678618,
-0.0819502324,
-0.0223692954,
0.0008122212,
0.0051258071,
-0.0391854122,
0.0328698382,
-0.006288392,
-0.006084091,
0.0990601927,
-0.0176379513,
0.0118566807,
-0.0009466216,
0.0016663822,
-0.0319265276,
0.0612957403,
0.0646077618,
-0.0143951075,
0.035125792,
0.0015462732,
0.0108270478,
-0.0220813509,
0.0127970278,
-0.0093584172,
-0.0417160466,
0.0027995971,
-0.0551339053,
0.0393794961,
0.0271356609,
0.0572368875,
-0.0057401056,
0.0209769011,
0.0914399251,
0.0249690823,
-0.020306237,
-0.021197699,
0.0306423474,
0.0113507062,
0.0213096682,
-0.0063765696,
-0.0747355595,
0.0598974973,
-0.0154218851,
0.0120483497,
0.034428332,
0.015528148,
-0.00702762,
-0.0781865641,
-0.0087147905,
-0.0045374488,
0.0125714913,
0.0441360921,
0.0533038042,
0.0000248534,
-0.050255511,
-0.0117016137,
0.0214890409,
-0.0380223058,
0.0012666815,
-0.055995848,
0.0737711787,
0.0502438471,
0.0360745303,
-0.0157801919,
-0.0099008577,
-0.0130413817,
-0.0009112096,
0.0133430883,
0.047910694,
-0.0164795388,
-0.0297298823,
-0.0417111851,
-0.0271480717,
-0.0371839218,
0.0313424692,
-0.0080087744,
0.0513158068,
-0.0134630911,
0.0003259038,
-0.0399889164,
-0.0255602356,
0.0258446243,
-0.0015424233,
-0.0370731764,
-0.0156388544,
-0.0140940482,
0.0250993837,
0.0007319578,
0.0159989912,
0.0449227877,
0.0187560227,
0.0333590582,
-0.0310295708,
0.0066946922,
-0.041566696,
-0.0200825613,
0.0590527691,
-0.020504199,
-0.0308401939,
-0.0216717552,
-0.0480870306,
-0.0401440449,
0.0267592091,
-0.0100150015,
-0.0272351746,
-0.0366625898,
0.0366213433,
-0.0006741725,
-0.0281022675,
-0.0633049235,
0.055036854,
0.0090734595,
0.0118355118,
0.017840473,
0.0110969273,
0.01810362,
-0.0384673029,
0.0027192587,
-0.0116113648,
-0.0314499959,
0.0303519256,
0.0397103317,
0.0087999664,
-0.0406603515,
-0.0165406801,
-0.0278438516,
-0.0217925794,
-0.0064435164,
0.0199105851,
0.0136855515,
-0.0413291864,
-0.0136038829,
-0.0188765675,
-0.0056187771,
0.0151121058,
0.0173580665,
0.0018334254,
0.0532889217,
-0.0060538091,
0.0216720346,
-0.0631291568,
-0.0061708526,
-0.0353545062,
0.0246300604,
0.0101066558,
0.0266090203,
-0.0821522027,
0.0203536171,
-0.0331822373,
0.0260115396,
-0.0202809814,
-0.0481007881,
0.0398823768,
-0.0106671564,
0.0057735196,
0.072397463,
0.0219206363,
0.0191490036,
0.0787562132,
-0.0017145142,
-0.0624851398,
0.025228193,
-0.0327083096,
-0.0476460531,
-0.0278055556,
-0.0291879568,
-0.0112193888,
0.0663569719,
0.0225331094,
0.0059391982,
-0.0614797547,
0.0523890182,
-0.009338282,
-0.0258906111,
-0.0071911407,
-0.0217640251,
-0.0026004096,
0.0526536293,
-0.0315407999,
-0.0597835444,
0.1010667682,
-0.0391503312,
0.0127625335,
-0.0025309871,
-0.0140310172,
-0.0243404973,
0.046468351,
0.0001788592,
-0.0139626637,
0.0431486294,
0.0188374054,
-0.0786568895,
-0.0677714273,
0.0582058132,
-0.0400364287,
0.0496064462,
-0.09117423,
-0.0202353224,
0.0081452448,
-0.0126599874,
-0.0570197329,
-0.0156296324,
-0.0668735877,
-0.0131443497,
-0.0117885377,
-0.0405266508,
0.0014821944,
-0.0261952188,
0.0454706997,
0.0220395233,
-0.039890416,
-0.0208893903,
-0.0123277847,
-0.0403518379,
0.0455356911,
0.0071495301,
0.078840822,
-0.0289065056,
0.0470000654,
0.0359665528,
0.0097366748,
0.0330933817,
-0.0643989965,
-0.0099838236,
0.003542895,
-0.0006058947,
0.0182302538,
0.0610937104,
0.1106942147,
-0.0431674346,
-0.0151198953,
0.1533246636,
0.0235597957,
0.0041077533,
-0.0024886536,
-0.0449049175,
0.0502866805,
0.0576699413,
0.0247096941,
-0.0310957935,
-0.0384957828,
0.0131402398,
0.0459617525,
-0.0162639469,
-0.0360059254,
0.0007625069,
-0.1413351744,
0.056895826,
0.0011153534,
-0.0015690742,
-0.0180674493,
-0.0427523553,
0.0191490911,
-0.0206055753,
0.0277306009,
0.0242650546,
-0.0181567483,
0.0199337248,
0.041112721,
-0.0498653576,
-0.0510292053,
0.0263154972,
-0.0333407521,
0.0664467588,
0.0224631466,
0.0209310744,
0.0134184416,
-0.0409521013,
0.0089681726,
-0.014481483,
0.0027953631,
-0.0052644983,
0.0554718263,
-0.0033144171,
0.0015148288,
-0.0076249521,
0.0447297581,
-0.0248897057,
-0.0304005165,
-0.0203437749,
0.0481804125,
-0.025315119,
-0.015011102,
-0.0211014096,
0.0309939831,
0.0032562509,
0.0729450434,
0.018210711,
0.0001825222,
-0.0193348452,
-0.0394492671,
-0.0039660363,
-0.0472418405,
-0.0080984794,
0.039967861,
0.0119737303,
0.0402506217,
-0.0433855988,
-0.0321656205,
0.0344230719,
-0.0076344698,
0.0053950404,
-0.0361805335,
0.0187828112,
-0.0035211935,
-0.0457596742,
0.0157387313,
-0.0525129847,
0.0428261198,
-0.0316016562,
0.0556197688,
0.0250584446,
-0.0213701241,
0.0056381375,
0.0106090447,
-0.0787814707,
-0.0826612264,
-0.0540322326,
0.0821629986,
0.0285687167,
0.0452840142,
-0.002068558,
-0.0523043871,
0.0306942705,
0.0155459801,
-0.0145957386,
-0.005381084,
0.0578833744,
0.0367285348,
-0.0065961238,
0.0481894687,
-0.0219144989,
-0.012277347,
0.0101900818,
0.0456688665,
-0.027873395,
-0.0680778474,
0.0522344001,
-0.0307561811,
0.0566514432,
-0.0420715027,
0.0159259886,
-0.0314996541,
0.0016301526,
-0.0252066813,
-0.0363444053,
-0.0119108427,
0.0010915038,
0.0302297976,
-0.0350290313,
-0.0032660794,
-0.0561001785,
-0.0090631219,
0.0253438242,
0.0052067442,
0.0128268404,
0.0254256763,
0.0221740101,
0.0012317098,
-0.0068974574,
-0.0126861231,
0.0091938004,
-0.0322936885,
0.0277063623,
0.0326754302,
0.0625636205,
0.02799627,
-0.0034311065,
-0.0108527141,
-0.0265645403,
-0.0566489138,
-0.0322272405,
0.0053059175,
-0.0013874106,
0.0255773589,
0.0054443409,
0.0486235246,
-0.0363306515,
-0.0063889492,
-0.0049328683,
0.0525524914,
-0.0108762952,
0.0018473064,
0.056160599,
0.0276947953,
-0.0199927427,
-0.0030035079,
0.0603319183,
-0.0131085338,
0.0422451533,
-0.0130358553,
-0.0221989118,
-0.0447503328,
-0.0405268818,
-0.018233005,
0.025988441,
-0.0259240698,
0.0125246355,
-0.0443354025,
-0.084653534,
0.0026283571,
0.0704022124,
-0.0112388451,
-0.0342712663,
0.0154535919,
0.0508026369,
-0.0267292187,
-0.0224391818,
-0.0345106348,
-0.0014817555,
0.0143957883,
0.008398626,
-0.0482376032,
-6.580280725e-33,
-0.0258607082,
-0.0662670955,
0.0330120884,
-0.0048122285,
0.0132865943,
-0.0135498503,
-0.0549093485,
0.0304606557,
-0.0100277681,
0.0521650799,
-0.0156256184,
0.0051525515,
0.0145053826,
0.0161332805,
0.0383831002,
0.0026257024,
0.0330424011,
0.0099586537,
-0.0330983773,
-0.0189376678,
0.019162735,
0.0058216588,
0.0684894174,
-0.0871186703,
0.0690089911,
0.035914395,
-0.0510222316,
0.0673109293,
-0.0440365411,
0.0431690998,
0.0050468082,
0.0149451429,
-0.003436591,
-0.0180624612,
-0.0187777467,
0.0150449947,
-0.0820166171,
-0.0463959686,
0.0226327591,
-0.0031202231,
-0.0403281003,
-0.0244906526,
0.0064820019,
-0.0199878328,
-0.0165559296,
0.0082801357,
0.0285530705,
-0.0338378325,
-0.0167854708,
0.0162686016,
-0.0456346534,
0.0127299083,
-0.0098932292,
-0.02670753,
-0.0174053535,
0.0361062884,
-0.0052792402,
0.0029631744,
-0.0248712413,
0.0219918359,
0.0203014985,
0.0322041586,
0.0897530541,
0.0312248878,
-0.0225337222,
0.0673618391,
-0.0254216883,
0.0027853854,
-0.0261731278,
0.0147022717,
0.025346376,
0.0357652344,
0.0630448014,
0.0734133124,
-0.00962805,
0.0370989554,
-0.0755754113,
0.0069249403,
-0.0138842249,
0.0648248494,
0.0469220169,
0.0213534422,
-0.0411741547,
-0.0152160693,
-0.0686553642,
-0.0252757631,
-0.0098028816,
-0.0056409668,
0.0003261111,
0.0191676524,
-0.035878893,
-0.0295942184,
-0.0107156402,
-0.0254970454,
-0.0442221873,
0.004182349,
-0.0094655342,
0.0012584984,
-0.0060828431,
0.0247137323,
-0.0429962613,
-0.0051826397,
0.0182115566,
0.0176346302,
-0.0031657869,
0.028501384,
0.0583114885,
0.0227754023,
-0.0584092177,
0.0135152014,
-0.0377649926,
0.0274769869,
-0.0153777534,
-0.000730163,
0.0141602494,
0.0287566073,
-0.0394649617,
0.0176196005,
-0.0327322111,
-0.0325922817,
0.0044393553,
0.0047592856,
0.0019703484,
0.0161844753,
-0.0239349604,
-0.0248590335,
-0.0415896364,
-0.0186023638,
0.0203119311,
-0.02271007,
-0.0052295076,
0.0230240151,
2.913e-7,
0.0382250957,
0.0449432954,
0.01919147,
0.054631602,
0.0100405132,
0.054642126,
-0.0219674893,
-0.0189668648,
0.0337590054,
-0.0756827742,
0.0173308868,
0.0541825257,
0.0582342744,
0.0368178003,
-0.0425047353,
-0.0332587995,
-0.0386598185,
-0.0275128521,
0.0133070545,
0.008297951,
0.066239506,
0.0495515652,
0.0384532958,
-0.0051207743,
-0.0205212943,
-0.0245175082,
0.0646181926,
-0.0245632902,
-0.0132915042,
0.0400568545,
0.0305649787,
0.017399976,
-0.0016361993,
0.0112398602,
-0.0008072639,
-0.0178123768,
-0.0635565966,
0.0385901183,
-0.0033652144,
-0.0062720636,
-0.0222339835,
-0.0038536517,
0.0227994286,
-0.0573163852,
0.0303041153,
-0.1013106704,
-0.0228552446,
-0.0301887672,
0.024568921,
-0.0334263183,
0.026920015,
-0.0211228579,
-0.0181588307,
0.007055236,
0.0108118858,
0.0263474043,
-0.0235423725,
-0.0677973554,
-0.0550435372,
0.0040451214,
-0.0041600717,
-0.0212259926,
-0.0012415041,
0.0084354309,
0.0102724275,
-0.0853129849,
0.0167203154,
2.707124919e-34,
0.0436051115,
-0.010497801,
-0.0011272021,
-0.0088060061,
0.0623876899,
0.022971496,
-0.0391703397,
0.0223693233,
0.0454350263,
-0.0426964648,
-0.0387977995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20973v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20973v1
|
LCQ: Low-Rank Codebook based Quantization for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T16:21:05 | 2024-05-31T16:21:05 |
Wen-Pu Cai, Wu-Jun Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models~(LLMs) have recently demonstrated promising performance
in many tasks. However, the high storage and computational cost of LLMs has
become a challenge for deploying LLMs. Weight quantization has been widely used
for model compression, which can reduce both storage and computational cost.
Most existing weight quantization methods for LLMs use a rank-one codebook for
quantization, which results in substantial accuracy loss when the compression
ratio is high. In this paper, we propose a novel weight quantization method,
called low-rank codebook based quantization~(LCQ), for LLMs. LCQ adopts a
low-rank codebook, the rank of which can be larger than one, for quantization.
Experiments show that LCQ can achieve better accuracy than existing methods
with a negligibly extra storage cost.
|
[
-0.048689995,
0.0855263397,
0.0050083059,
0.0310146324,
-0.014579271,
0.0140607301,
0.0306411311,
0.054872483,
0.0033766699,
-0.005478424,
0.0183987245,
-0.0570837632,
-0.0029095437,
0.0117002865,
0.0327059701,
-0.0028852003,
0.0264345165,
-0.0300163031,
-0.0095774001,
-0.0315719061,
-0.0244579203,
0.001724415,
0.0539924204,
0.0074937236,
0.0329073705,
-0.0172249265,
-0.0294612423,
-0.0023555364,
-0.0221748464,
-0.0315433927,
-0.0131030949,
0.0726773962,
0.0548858121,
0.0396566838,
0.0000019204,
-0.0085344892,
-0.0566647127,
0.0089900009,
-0.0492537878,
0.0621331818,
0.0119167278,
-0.0195838064,
-0.0476689227,
0.0131042236,
0.0052388981,
0.0172177665,
0.0768725798,
-0.0093183815,
0.0580816865,
0.0168949384,
-0.0059680464,
-0.0428669006,
-0.0028682251,
-0.0019119652,
-0.0256821066,
-0.0357013233,
0.0295114219,
0.0785521045,
0.0015743148,
0.0041228486,
-0.0360290073,
0.036851842,
0.0017751639,
-0.0069258963,
-0.0206781067,
0.0151819764,
-0.0784122795,
0.0046530804,
-0.0045111934,
0.0397068821,
-0.0798008293,
-0.051302731,
0.0003363153,
0.0294192154,
-0.0447870232,
-0.1258345842,
-0.0348655023,
0.0565328263,
0.0163993929,
0.0417569727,
-0.0165915042,
-0.0215489417,
0.0411634259,
-0.0046709096,
-0.0657971352,
0.0331206657,
0.0329350829,
-0.0337383412,
-0.0404834636,
-0.0230527297,
-0.0604754873,
-0.0603704415,
0.0113265989,
-0.0224768501,
0.0166451894,
-0.015427093,
-0.0537514314,
-0.0462701581,
-0.0041307155,
-0.0400236808,
0.0408941135,
0.0522243418,
0.0196904782,
0.0300670899,
-0.0237837061,
0.0861740187,
0.0025603948,
-0.0170944724,
-0.0323633924,
0.0203238595,
-0.0051837033,
-0.0102192555,
-0.0787227601,
0.0313308127,
-0.0294580571,
-0.0064630862,
-0.0541437715,
-0.0125214318,
0.0130947521,
0.0048763147,
0.0181071237,
-0.0064183772,
-0.0133906724,
-0.0145317549,
0.0567711517,
0.001580244,
0.026207963,
-0.0085183196,
-0.013554926,
-0.0309797972,
0.002996827,
0.0242762957,
0.0223144852,
-0.0258443784,
0.0245516542,
-0.0328686759,
0.0146227842,
-0.0235046949,
0.0286483485,
0.0185237713,
-0.0263406411,
-0.0293077826,
-0.0527021065,
-0.0602851063,
-0.0148194609,
-0.0155229615,
0.0265028644,
-0.0352212116,
0.0140908901,
-0.0080639906,
-0.0113336816,
0.0646138042,
-0.0277672485,
0.0140422294,
0.0017035459,
0.0194015354,
0.0382038541,
0.0569365211,
0.023828933,
0.0329242051,
0.0085516628,
-0.0126256589,
-0.019001998,
0.0556066297,
0.0183498599,
0.026453441,
-0.0762128085,
-0.0235907491,
0.0084434524,
0.0254362989,
0.0632712469,
0.0974115506,
-0.0663114265,
-0.0265677031,
0.0240415074,
0.0571720861,
0.0855777338,
0.0345701054,
-0.0088316184,
0.0489469841,
0.0140094012,
-0.0375535525,
0.017302189,
0.006477823,
-0.0012085655,
-0.0017675388,
0.0769777671,
0.0435136147,
-0.0223023146,
0.0018558075,
-0.0507187508,
-0.0277661569,
0.0140040796,
-0.0021156357,
0.0180398654,
-0.0098359734,
0.0008472801,
0.0862675905,
0.0075953519,
-0.0900539309,
-0.0206524581,
-0.0666675344,
-0.0318114087,
0.0397488661,
0.0321292579,
0.0078436537,
0.0186859146,
0.0268148743,
-0.0243686605,
-0.0237694792,
-0.0177688356,
-0.0104205506,
0.0194069035,
-0.0683578625,
-0.0361937843,
0.0406921543,
-0.0047357618,
-0.0020290101,
0.0187636465,
-0.0045511303,
-0.0149750849,
-0.0310285706,
-0.0245978385,
0.0086493129,
0.023235593,
-0.0232411008,
0.0294785202,
-0.01398814,
0.0475903377,
0.0154010896,
-0.0144743426,
-0.0137916813,
0.0251734387,
-0.0277215559,
0.0273120496,
-0.0849560723,
0.0229755435,
-0.0292566475,
0.0791026354,
0.008028483,
0.035931062,
0.0682470948,
-0.0095692677,
-0.0391469039,
0.0018055206,
-0.0238098204,
0.0258741956,
-0.0577608868,
0.0330984369,
-0.0261083208,
0.0394913666,
-0.0365989543,
0.0280396398,
-0.0212396625,
0.0365997776,
0.0499626286,
0.03177654,
0.0114337569,
-0.043276906,
-0.0564861223,
0.0395270325,
0.002715867,
0.0466342159,
0.0027486591,
0.0003812378,
0.0172099955,
-0.0282094982,
-0.1231353059,
0.0016242422,
-0.0156401619,
-0.0008715607,
0.0041957488,
0.0338684954,
0.0142242415,
0.0052644284,
-0.0348360315,
-0.0248180516,
-0.0159734506,
-0.0001873431,
-0.0171344131,
-0.0193504058,
-0.0231489446,
-0.0248162895,
-0.0424189754,
0.0257590022,
0.0582526773,
-0.0603134371,
-0.0409925245,
-0.1003155187,
0.0557595529,
-0.0384515934,
0.0446221642,
0.0066880868,
-0.0680175871,
-0.0052807233,
-0.0326809138,
0.0327994153,
0.0159611832,
0.0082169063,
-0.0057518701,
0.1110070646,
0.0119030364,
-0.0458960086,
0.0057319226,
0.0147120859,
-0.0465473793,
-0.0165264197,
-0.0424167998,
-0.0159063414,
0.0549437329,
-0.0096991705,
-0.0098844906,
-0.0523860194,
-0.0179338064,
-0.0027983517,
-0.0023811238,
-0.0670352727,
0.0000870791,
-0.0449204929,
0.0626101866,
0.0027405303,
-0.0454217978,
-0.002812488,
-0.0541607924,
-0.0016593132,
-0.0046457937,
-0.0177669544,
-0.0210661069,
0.0331038088,
0.0145769557,
0.0777048618,
-0.0244098138,
-0.0126359928,
-0.0322778262,
0.0064975237,
-0.0199377518,
-0.0538006164,
-0.0215554964,
-0.0154932234,
0.0454161987,
-0.0450244173,
-0.0174037311,
0.0193016287,
-0.0005799376,
-0.0185203608,
0.0329180509,
0.0443755277,
-0.0412598811,
0.0536701158,
0.1040692329,
0.0055121002,
0.0551661327,
0.0101892902,
0.0137278894,
-0.0036743302,
0.0269995891,
0.0123791825,
0.0036263568,
0.0485089496,
-0.0009152166,
0.0050495784,
0.0257656109,
0.0304628368,
0.0790385902,
-0.0417593308,
0.013649866,
0.067179285,
0.0278843753,
-0.0303230025,
0.0278127529,
0.0177509394,
-0.0153833637,
0.0166389141,
0.0981609747,
0.035669975,
-0.0656272396,
0.0088040512,
-0.0117340367,
0.0463116616,
0.0046983818,
0.0167065207,
-0.1085522398,
0.0112027824,
0.0187680349,
-0.003528673,
0.0145937037,
0.0070603061,
-0.0136265233,
-0.0456878059,
0.0335465185,
0.0612676591,
0.0381964557,
-0.044534307,
-0.0017840527,
-0.0336763784,
-0.0106239356,
0.0277400427,
0.0546477549,
-0.001199824,
-0.0100153396,
0.0209131222,
-0.0246048253,
-0.040078003,
0.0154706566,
-0.0079156645,
0.0794251561,
0.0492586158,
0.0547260717,
-0.0141405705,
0.0139226709,
-0.0189204887,
0.0163259152,
-0.0312875621,
-0.0159727391,
-0.0298819505,
0.0540901273,
-0.0138978837,
0.0464613698,
-0.0061525726,
0.013906572,
-0.0188545417,
-0.0202155225,
0.0530899167,
-0.0224772692,
-0.0058168052,
0.040686354,
-0.0379795171,
-0.0346418545,
0.0416212119,
0.0156610366,
0.0135768177,
-0.0294050537,
-0.0172286779,
0.0092329858,
-0.0239621587,
-0.0457815528,
-0.0018334179,
-0.0436010472,
-0.0249000434,
-0.0286273696,
0.0572995096,
0.0152589912,
0.0281691514,
-0.0406081453,
0.0127620678,
0.0048259236,
0.0046913694,
-0.0689930692,
-0.0345672816,
-0.0527758859,
0.004017679,
-0.0460584573,
0.00575594,
-0.0095623136,
-0.0093889171,
-0.0256825909,
-0.0211769398,
-0.0756436586,
-0.049334906,
0.0097767236,
-0.0033203987,
0.022183869,
0.0225605089,
0.001155749,
-0.0813870206,
0.0177659616,
0.0207885392,
-0.0146294562,
0.0582565069,
0.0066285096,
-0.0199778415,
-0.0092873452,
0.0371562205,
-0.0303739924,
0.0199228823,
-0.0227468237,
0.0389288738,
-0.0758336931,
-0.0518752486,
-0.008643467,
0.0417455249,
0.023195697,
-0.0102584641,
-0.011640083,
0.0187582634,
0.0333068185,
-0.0191600304,
-0.0126693603,
-0.0226656534,
0.0334635302,
0.0315454081,
-0.0141957831,
-0.0165177882,
0.0046519302,
0.0343566462,
-0.0162799973,
0.0230244398,
0.0036903785,
-0.0509578139,
-0.0031600343,
0.0867687538,
-0.0199611504,
-0.0127904415,
-0.0057334825,
0.0209388081,
0.0160601456,
-0.0308488607,
-0.0107054692,
-0.0131083252,
0.0037212691,
-0.0278476458,
0.0514362417,
-0.0070363493,
-0.0395554528,
-0.0455460772,
-0.0188485235,
0.0612838678,
0.0635246783,
0.045008719,
-0.0131077226,
-0.0246936437,
-0.0246777497,
0.0190552175,
0.0243025646,
-0.0249757711,
0.0145208612,
0.0183968116,
-0.0377179869,
0.0421992093,
0.0595006458,
0.0535678528,
0.0079463711,
-0.0310772136,
-0.019828137,
-0.0287887137,
-0.0160344057,
-0.0478941537,
0.0261665676,
-0.0106443455,
-0.0231650658,
-0.0083634593,
-0.0329509266,
0.0301610045,
0.0356065407,
-0.0099184019,
-0.0302713998,
0.0100533161,
0.0337837636,
0.0109583531,
-0.003845999,
-0.0311291739,
-0.0496046655,
0.022655366,
-0.022693092,
0.0089106923,
-6.072287902e-33,
-0.0165047683,
0.0246048402,
-0.0011836919,
-0.0498070121,
-0.0264505614,
0.0375225917,
-0.0061114258,
-0.0129786292,
0.0266265552,
-0.0358571149,
-0.0114806117,
0.0311939232,
0.0183595736,
-0.0049564335,
-0.0056923931,
0.0587164946,
0.0689260364,
-0.0023742334,
-0.0119716842,
0.0296034478,
-0.0154134091,
0.0098284921,
0.0112773888,
0.0256911349,
-0.0446184874,
0.0048418911,
-0.007486206,
-0.005744373,
0.0266635921,
0.0300180446,
-0.044105839,
0.00108364,
-0.0214265455,
0.0049514249,
-0.0199052263,
-0.0081512984,
-0.0222313777,
0.0153834168,
-0.0000883116,
0.0061397259,
0.0329087265,
-0.0435967632,
0.0209058803,
0.0109801525,
-0.0335861221,
-0.0111731701,
-0.0314938873,
-0.044116322,
-0.038625814,
-0.0945629627,
0.0020307861,
0.0415785387,
0.0147807617,
0.0404223688,
0.0889237672,
-0.008128806,
-0.0486294851,
0.0100165624,
-0.0402171724,
0.0041284305,
0.0336871073,
0.1116501316,
0.0451029837,
0.0178196914,
0.0074815452,
0.0243474916,
0.0082590207,
-0.046409484,
-0.0045830552,
0.0603739135,
0.0289510228,
-0.0053200922,
0.0560768768,
0.0439111516,
0.0737461969,
-0.0093883444,
-0.049161803,
-0.0034133198,
-0.0231569055,
0.0062668743,
0.0407371558,
0.0581005029,
-0.0107395137,
-0.0378011987,
-0.0426414944,
-0.026465999,
-0.0378384814,
-0.0405858941,
-0.0061300867,
0.0069433036,
-0.0508175902,
-0.0053943847,
0.0437755287,
-0.0450412482,
-0.0385593623,
-0.0047952514,
0.0108655766,
0.0334247649,
0.0128023149,
0.0521828644,
-0.0201130789,
-0.0173548516,
0.0287625864,
0.0008975258,
0.0203205608,
-0.0258596614,
-0.0009859565,
0.0615790486,
-0.0745731667,
-0.0201907028,
-0.0088239228,
-0.0458072983,
-0.0173984654,
0.0379276276,
-0.0039165928,
-0.0020369643,
0.0378464907,
0.018131556,
0.0046828301,
0.0023021891,
-0.0137604149,
-0.014989119,
0.020408297,
0.0511737354,
-0.0377547219,
0.0116692986,
-0.0816723406,
0.0603960417,
0.0894880071,
-0.0313051492,
-0.0508195311,
0.0424099527,
2.608e-7,
0.0428352468,
0.034944281,
0.0170342084,
-0.0424161665,
-0.0081176218,
-0.0119673954,
-0.0089225955,
0.0127251977,
-0.0148015451,
-0.0085854745,
0.004193536,
0.0177872889,
0.0258817673,
0.0040483344,
-0.0512318723,
0.0302562453,
-0.0539482012,
-0.0256912876,
-0.0546591654,
-0.036831595,
0.0390263498,
0.1358419955,
-0.023368435,
-0.0141496593,
0.0308852419,
0.0055947937,
0.0219224468,
0.007158861,
0.0191044547,
0.0172234122,
0.0232124142,
0.0005762628,
-0.0149660483,
-0.0508765057,
0.0133637628,
0.0059022945,
-0.0103523917,
0.0981180742,
-0.0370632857,
0.0394145772,
0.0247428548,
-0.0250996966,
-0.0493688099,
-0.0377979428,
0.056179028,
-0.0028085089,
0.0148844663,
-0.0910976678,
-0.0186269842,
-0.019855015,
-0.0131438142,
-0.0099933045,
0.0327798165,
0.0331405848,
0.0099789631,
-0.0118415272,
0.0203227736,
-0.0767107755,
-0.043173708,
0.0108152255,
-0.0169418063,
-0.0388438925,
-0.0154773938,
-0.0034504682,
0.0046729748,
-0.0401189178,
0.0311793163,
2.477505414e-34,
0.0294745713,
-0.0183369014,
0.0329348445,
0.032014288,
0.0003134451,
-0.0393798873,
-0.0136205563,
0.0249088593,
-0.0409207307,
-0.0811973512,
-0.024805434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20967v1
|
Superlatives in Context: Explicit and Implicit Domain Restrictions for Superlative Frames
| 2024-05-31T16:14:06 | 2024-05-31T16:14:06 |
Valentina Pyatkin, Bonnie Webber, Ido Dagan, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Superlatives are used to single out elements with a maximal/minimal property.
Semantically, superlatives perform a set comparison: something (or some things)
has the min/max property out of a set. As such, superlatives provide an ideal
phenomenon for studying implicit phenomena and discourse restrictions. While
this comparison set is often not explicitly defined, its (implicit)
restrictions can be inferred from the discourse context the expression appears
in. In this work we provide an extensive computational study on the semantics
of superlatives. We propose a unified account of superlative semantics which
allows us to derive a broad-coverage annotation schema. Using this unified
schema we annotated a multi-domain dataset of superlatives and their semantic
interpretations. We specifically focus on interpreting implicit or ambiguous
superlative expressions, by analyzing how the discourse context restricts the
set of interpretations. In a set of experiments we then analyze how well models
perform at variations of predicting superlative semantics, with and without
context. We show that the fine-grained semantics of superlatives in context can
be challenging for contemporary models, including GPT-4.
|
[
0.0367417224,
-0.0018668656,
-0.0259183161,
0.0396538936,
0.0041504405,
0.0074827797,
-0.0274217967,
0.0195633881,
-0.0241973698,
-0.0778129995,
-0.0074719102,
-0.0092870882,
-0.0320244841,
-0.0156820677,
-0.0158595443,
-0.0791115165,
0.0579123348,
0.0022733829,
0.0345828608,
-0.0091286898,
0.0056809415,
-0.0249478705,
0.001306355,
0.0276211984,
-0.0703013763,
0.0060087251,
0.0515287556,
0.0042147092,
0.0544168018,
-0.0329701044,
0.0148073677,
0.0480391942,
0.0142500196,
0.0003469346,
0.0000022937,
-0.0456284471,
-0.0018836675,
-0.0146463336,
0.0098364661,
0.0164565444,
0.0291006155,
-0.0138552133,
0.0104183322,
-0.0531477481,
-0.0698970407,
-0.0230228025,
0.0324923359,
0.0186765641,
-0.0067257872,
0.0362130404,
-0.0263326485,
-0.0459845662,
-0.0078649893,
-0.035973113,
-0.0135536678,
-0.1170128137,
0.035555359,
0.0464841463,
0.0072499723,
0.0309464503,
-0.0118523408,
-0.0010426193,
0.0090075424,
0.0320806317,
-0.037901435,
0.0216399301,
0.0075437771,
0.0117463209,
0.0056620003,
0.0451237708,
0.1172750816,
0.0088117942,
-0.0190218985,
-0.0070761559,
0.0073883915,
0.0091830948,
0.0030152064,
0.0376005769,
-0.0186060723,
0.0134464465,
0.0233121701,
0.0678747892,
-0.0201877523,
0.0324938893,
-0.0209271144,
0.0787958279,
-0.0168934558,
-0.007996385,
-0.0047651795,
-0.0131653948,
-0.1027626023,
-0.0155141074,
0.0146390963,
-0.0179486237,
0.0070586312,
-0.0013096214,
0.008391629,
0.0330415927,
0.0399696417,
-0.0114931688,
0.0346660465,
0.022453554,
-0.0042624176,
0.0546707585,
0.0333587341,
0.0557712279,
-0.0404160358,
-0.0437969379,
-0.0329803899,
-0.0191803891,
-0.0534985512,
-0.026344033,
0.0044813398,
0.0433474518,
-0.0680389255,
0.0191698987,
-0.0381322838,
-0.0235783719,
-0.0174282175,
-0.0080426158,
-0.052183263,
-0.0016561983,
-0.0720858052,
-0.0093496414,
-0.0462069958,
0.0014225316,
-0.0806294605,
0.0417025797,
-0.0412821919,
-0.0551948771,
0.0225974899,
-0.0038585684,
-0.0265561566,
-0.0355430171,
-0.0414909199,
0.0607838407,
0.0292990468,
0.0211114231,
0.0304970909,
-0.0615524873,
-0.027735671,
-0.0401891321,
-0.0143671231,
-0.0417055637,
-0.0154140899,
0.0271850508,
0.0250726324,
-0.0696417689,
-0.0045495341,
-0.0193793233,
0.0100480616,
0.0561053455,
-0.0031782936,
-0.0176392049,
-0.0148412306,
0.000776873,
-0.0257067569,
0.0631892458,
0.0054473407,
0.0240576174,
0.0539290383,
-0.002369852,
-0.0122655043,
0.0167810209,
-0.0082454728,
0.0239946097,
-0.0236308165,
0.0174190346,
0.0121154692,
-0.008133458,
-0.0029020074,
0.0222379472,
-0.0065227803,
-0.0211358964,
0.0573980175,
0.0224229749,
-0.0628972948,
0.0031440994,
0.0235090312,
0.0338905416,
0.0025915366,
0.0557884946,
-0.0341063738,
0.0192121845,
0.0291479584,
-0.0069135539,
-0.0637863874,
0.0085002175,
0.0039618891,
-0.0693441033,
-0.0288431253,
0.0131081017,
0.0076290965,
-0.0142409392,
0.0345395394,
0.0033251389,
-0.0256807618,
0.0436768346,
0.017426027,
-0.0623983294,
-0.0395707265,
-0.028490331,
-0.0380753987,
-0.0065549845,
0.0018160591,
-0.0559693761,
0.0018844401,
0.0059801894,
0.0350742601,
0.0418312401,
0.027425684,
0.0149790943,
-0.0101474645,
-0.0347468331,
-0.0060858964,
-0.0023391228,
0.0611583963,
0.0161508266,
-0.0335098058,
-0.0242706127,
0.0261672195,
-0.029690383,
-0.0132010514,
-0.0063852179,
0.0277460273,
-0.0073341327,
-0.0502092838,
0.0102053732,
-0.0056611341,
0.0249571595,
-0.0060799094,
0.0072315177,
0.0300181713,
-0.0182951093,
-0.0066474588,
0.0400294885,
-0.0299099125,
0.0303422324,
-0.0025429658,
-0.1008135825,
-0.0328903049,
0.0154529708,
-0.0395535231,
0.0027798258,
-0.0278052669,
-0.0238610636,
0.0578980707,
-0.0418111421,
-0.0154099409,
-0.0300522335,
-0.0183555782,
-0.0201835167,
0.0949808732,
-0.0108475005,
-0.0110752825,
0.0382706672,
-0.0519694947,
0.0314957015,
-0.0276987478,
0.0047096666,
-0.019404199,
-0.0069633098,
0.0188749377,
0.0401020795,
-0.0114180101,
-0.0512909815,
-0.0003334209,
-0.0997971073,
-0.0057990388,
-0.005470986,
0.0044142311,
0.0480460785,
-0.0132737057,
-0.0086657796,
0.0137990993,
0.0537667535,
-0.028254753,
-0.0586214215,
0.0235008579,
0.0354368575,
0.0085429503,
0.0226017796,
-0.0416320264,
-0.0198500101,
-0.0701180398,
0.0293872226,
0.0186454691,
-0.0195054989,
0.0491871163,
0.0141949821,
-0.0523685329,
-0.0052222377,
-0.0127846412,
-0.0395542458,
0.0146409115,
0.0080783851,
-0.0186763313,
0.0480313972,
0.0115198102,
0.063364625,
0.0237310659,
-0.0350589938,
-0.0416784175,
-0.0017745349,
-0.0185492877,
-0.0224036854,
-0.0272102933,
0.0075610527,
-0.0190469101,
0.0796137899,
0.037045788,
-0.0162022449,
-0.0541632809,
0.0810738578,
-0.0879753307,
-0.03585504,
0.0122858156,
0.0292898919,
-0.0324690901,
0.0863023326,
-0.0151468655,
0.0042475034,
0.0432436615,
0.0548274852,
0.0040541673,
0.0147398748,
0.0216891691,
-0.0540562011,
0.0675307363,
-0.0157863088,
0.0039721127,
0.0059441202,
-0.0269553401,
0.0041806307,
-0.0389536954,
0.0453842096,
-0.0212880261,
0.0336382575,
-0.0185528584,
0.0097912801,
-0.0006977548,
-0.0817612335,
0.0109253582,
0.0028378107,
-0.0366666913,
0.0291999523,
-0.01539772,
0.0275477711,
-0.0070157675,
-0.0002314605,
-0.0402331911,
0.0062202532,
-0.0152556114,
-0.0135665862,
-0.044518847,
0.0202091131,
-0.0078852111,
0.014635887,
0.0044173524,
0.0152753619,
-0.00468993,
0.0618669465,
-0.0426795296,
0.0043224418,
-0.0237561241,
0.0207292438,
0.0033957467,
-0.0270068236,
-0.021105377,
-0.0161892027,
0.0463075452,
-0.054972291,
0.0433558039,
0.0933939442,
0.0419845395,
0.0181951132,
0.0445104577,
-0.0231520422,
-0.0033976431,
0.0407124721,
-0.024770651,
-0.0992960036,
-0.0350286476,
-0.0207378604,
-0.0107904803,
-0.0123335393,
-0.0452458747,
-0.0025127542,
-0.0437877029,
0.0372193567,
0.0052908128,
-0.0047105155,
0.0218389146,
0.0325184949,
0.0413462259,
-0.0364227407,
-0.0170626901,
-0.0155469244,
-0.0139515949,
0.0091206953,
-0.005336198,
0.0182713028,
-0.0437708683,
0.0666327029,
-0.0160731208,
-0.0242097229,
0.0143991867,
0.0616554059,
-0.0300350133,
0.0097481897,
0.0473023392,
-0.0312797055,
0.0346559361,
-0.0309907757,
0.0036129311,
-0.0039219558,
-0.0125592686,
-0.0330990739,
0.0190532301,
0.0292114262,
-0.0201996453,
0.0119775748,
0.021658944,
0.0059101121,
-0.0230265632,
-0.0576803684,
0.0082425261,
0.0047869012,
0.0713425577,
0.0449751616,
0.0219869278,
0.0179762393,
-0.0178453811,
0.0070108892,
0.000795753,
-0.0444782376,
-0.0047117537,
0.0201807711,
0.0296967477,
-0.0436878875,
-0.0606806278,
0.010790511,
-0.0518923476,
0.0241385922,
0.006228535,
-0.0138355456,
-0.016008582,
-0.0529835671,
0.0291815884,
-0.0044196271,
-0.0220117234,
0.0000966034,
0.002967576,
0.1218419448,
0.0010996908,
-0.0444151051,
0.0691305622,
0.0260435846,
-0.0529869385,
-0.001901685,
0.0065238662,
0.0307701267,
0.0155039346,
0.0109416051,
-0.0550463907,
0.0006136202,
0.0606053211,
-0.0392429382,
0.0553999841,
0.0823038593,
-0.0279943421,
0.0028803626,
0.039707806,
-0.0015301047,
0.0886928737,
-0.0337329842,
0.0218112748,
-0.014726595,
0.0204633232,
0.0614441521,
-0.002577042,
0.0124500105,
0.0023539905,
-0.02943171,
0.0043161036,
-0.001293643,
-0.060889136,
-0.0272356607,
-0.037682794,
0.0232530758,
-0.0040335394,
0.0261518527,
-0.0260661766,
0.0035363548,
0.0065243756,
0.0470143184,
-0.020102473,
0.0419477224,
-0.0083949855,
-0.0280645564,
-0.0158845354,
0.0003499656,
-0.0280505456,
0.0033068703,
-0.0285628568,
0.0572648309,
-0.0223033745,
0.0348043106,
0.0449122749,
0.014553478,
-0.0313449875,
0.037460465,
-0.02638999,
-0.0184715465,
-0.0241499171,
-0.0219174847,
0.0294790473,
-0.0261711981,
0.0522355251,
-0.049362652,
-0.0175636616,
-0.0257871915,
0.0328321382,
0.0291836783,
-0.0183401722,
0.0186073426,
0.0399714112,
0.0001723114,
0.0234288815,
0.0395385548,
-0.0446735136,
0.0409549326,
0.0214651432,
0.0066561336,
-0.0318219103,
-0.0225203168,
-0.0170069188,
0.0111657027,
0.0459551699,
0.0328630581,
-0.110020943,
-0.0557145216,
0.0187104717,
-0.0082380278,
-0.0030383558,
-0.0273988992,
0.0132827209,
0.049061127,
-0.008183741,
-0.0577269718,
-0.0337627679,
-0.0293073114,
-0.0150774755,
0.0379643776,
-0.0442038812,
-6.684583073e-33,
-0.0533420891,
-0.051136598,
-0.0290793329,
0.0450255685,
-0.0061652516,
0.071713157,
-0.0245762914,
-0.0230506398,
0.0007337897,
0.0422572531,
-0.0021774839,
-0.003305411,
0.0188171323,
0.000112339,
0.0120027838,
0.0072720139,
0.0377421267,
0.0165223964,
-0.0271793939,
-0.0119898003,
0.0565207526,
-0.0218758397,
0.0968601555,
-0.0963585749,
0.0430165306,
0.0037505364,
-0.0439611487,
0.0247445516,
-0.0018437847,
0.0645733997,
-0.0067107826,
0.0443482362,
0.05295185,
-0.0558317043,
-0.009447393,
-0.0010630721,
-0.0604039468,
-0.0624385476,
0.0759504288,
-0.017520247,
-0.0151434867,
-0.0492699109,
0.0232199039,
-0.0136869429,
-0.0587859824,
-0.0339531228,
0.0508703478,
-0.0134109398,
-0.0200006999,
-0.0270636287,
-0.0894378573,
0.0335896797,
-0.0319295675,
0.0556664579,
0.0683762059,
0.0120821204,
0.0133075928,
-0.0034492821,
-0.0375577286,
0.0780248865,
0.0201192871,
0.0232589878,
0.0091653448,
-0.0248277746,
0.0194742028,
0.031401448,
0.025568055,
0.0303760022,
0.0228970814,
-0.0018763851,
-0.0085590798,
0.0407666117,
-0.023622252,
0.0872638598,
0.0177862067,
-0.0126863569,
-0.0036740021,
-0.0025039115,
0.0085217133,
-0.0017069235,
0.0153381852,
-0.0037636803,
-0.0783141702,
-0.0274869278,
-0.0766757056,
0.0068130093,
-0.0189973097,
-0.0154845063,
0.0288319513,
-0.0476105884,
-0.0213741697,
0.0548390634,
-0.0025525917,
-0.0548256263,
-0.049708996,
-0.0270362832,
-0.0062062992,
0.0369133018,
0.0105845779,
0.0032001203,
0.0303588528,
-0.0193499476,
-0.0217164475,
0.0113495728,
0.0560994893,
0.0109764617,
0.0220398586,
0.0096890619,
0.0135096442,
-0.0134832095,
0.0121632684,
-0.0442295447,
-0.0418960042,
-0.0523381941,
0.0187483057,
0.0501843132,
0.0034840831,
0.0571545288,
0.0555084236,
0.0376825333,
-0.0470783003,
0.0117660239,
0.008592776,
0.0440570638,
-0.022177808,
-0.0096386364,
-0.0049742102,
-0.0337455906,
0.0647108778,
0.0232697558,
-0.0320279934,
-0.0030044091,
2.937e-7,
0.0754525959,
0.0959494263,
0.0358157791,
0.0388306007,
0.0028860653,
0.0556071475,
0.0125961984,
0.0114184869,
0.0342969522,
-0.0439554118,
0.0420478694,
0.0221213233,
-0.0067876554,
-0.000039668,
-0.051382754,
0.0577770062,
-0.0082368739,
-0.0409108475,
-0.0427232906,
0.0567748025,
0.0622116886,
0.0301425103,
-0.0018159031,
0.0243886374,
-0.0388201736,
-0.014116047,
0.0621388555,
-0.071093522,
0.0063993721,
0.0424799994,
-0.0547465719,
0.0316595696,
-0.0195743684,
0.0415441357,
0.0188879482,
0.0173045676,
0.0237301942,
0.048755765,
-0.0258598235,
-0.0235471446,
-0.0135944998,
-0.0289010331,
0.0214660335,
-0.0470442362,
0.0486454219,
-0.0916456208,
-0.0654005855,
-0.0144340172,
-0.0113719795,
0.0379687473,
0.0349217169,
0.0069044163,
-0.0206004158,
-0.0110449931,
-0.019640334,
0.0369407013,
-0.0649501681,
-0.0446245521,
-0.0365774818,
-0.0151638184,
-0.0277571827,
-0.068288222,
-0.0038181511,
0.0024917738,
-0.0141250016,
-0.0860590413,
-0.0100761186,
2.572896321e-34,
0.0550618656,
0.014764634,
0.0543784536,
0.0119619817,
0.0526805185,
0.0146248713,
-0.0345974825,
0.0258092731,
0.0066138385,
-0.0272646565,
-0.0016208834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20962v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20962v2
|
Large Language Models are Zero-Shot Next Location Predictors
| 2024-05-31T16:07:33 | 2024-06-03T15:10:53 |
Ciro Beneduce, Bruno Lepri, Massimiliano Luca
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Predicting the locations an individual will visit in the future is crucial
for solving many societal issues like disease diffusion and reduction of
pollution among many others. The models designed to tackle next-location
prediction, however, require a significant amount of individual-level
information to be trained effectively. Such data may be scarce or even
unavailable in some geographic regions or peculiar scenarios (e.g., cold-start
in recommendation systems). Moreover, the design of a next-location predictor
able to generalize or geographically transfer knowledge is still an open
research challenge. Recent advances in natural language processing have led to
a rapid diffusion of Large Language Models (LLMs) which have shown good
generalization and reasoning capabilities. These insights, coupled with the
recent findings that LLMs are rich in geographical knowledge, allowed us to
believe that these models can act as zero-shot next-location predictors. This
paper evaluates the capabilities of many popular LLMs in this role,
specifically Llama, GPT-3.5 and Mistral 7B. After designing a proper prompt, we
tested the models on three real-world mobility datasets. The results show that
LLMs can obtain accuracies up to 32.4%, a significant relative improvement of
over 600% when compared to sophisticated DL models specifically designed for
human mobility. Moreover, we show that other LLMs are unable to perform the
task properly. To prevent positively biased results, we also propose a
framework inspired by other studies to test data contamination. Finally, we
explored the possibility of using LLMs as text-based explainers for
next-location prediction showing that can effectively provide an explanation
for their decision. Notably, 7B models provide more generic, but still
reliable, explanations compared to larger counterparts. Code:
github.com/ssai-trento/LLM-zero-shot-NL
|
[
0.0419313349,
0.051282797,
-0.0086669214,
-0.0058548828,
-0.0074713812,
-0.0185826682,
0.0615044646,
-0.0324833728,
0.0435552076,
-0.0360859595,
0.0155031634,
-0.0282472502,
-0.0029570118,
0.0046271062,
0.0234796237,
-0.080791831,
0.0339282006,
-0.0458523184,
-0.0172554608,
0.0129535962,
-0.0187825374,
0.0249830913,
0.0162689909,
0.0534325317,
0.046028804,
0.0081993463,
-0.0118820984,
-0.003837866,
0.0459288955,
-0.0658524483,
0.0188587792,
0.0017518552,
0.0800004527,
-0.023127256,
0.0000021361,
-0.0161079559,
-0.0230788458,
-0.0055583958,
0.0079305526,
-0.0171681847,
0.0086130062,
-0.0037083973,
0.0322536342,
0.0406352319,
-0.0136477817,
0.0029633902,
0.0084615313,
0.011191681,
0.0371947475,
0.0584751256,
-0.0141111398,
-0.0464572459,
0.0179437231,
0.0053100768,
0.0468919985,
-0.0112497769,
0.0307217073,
-0.017380761,
0.0056848112,
0.0376241878,
-0.0095171388,
-0.0044264821,
-0.014348994,
0.0109323775,
0.0176199451,
0.0483881906,
-0.0127550876,
0.0101491679,
-0.0327088274,
0.0460471995,
-0.0185030177,
-0.0519493409,
0.0250872094,
0.009124401,
-0.0241617039,
0.0082880119,
-0.0666536987,
-0.0321274847,
0.0170366652,
0.0645449385,
0.0075303824,
0.0380019359,
0.0524743311,
0.0365820937,
-0.0470289998,
0.114891991,
-0.0293511134,
-0.052617386,
-0.0299885403,
0.0057211216,
0.009962162,
-0.0528665707,
0.0341623574,
0.0387131944,
-0.0127863921,
0.0093968138,
0.0374414884,
0.0573793501,
-0.001838875,
-0.0441143662,
0.0354526415,
0.0256731715,
-0.0140643734,
0.0252931174,
0.0191580951,
0.0174452253,
-0.0178767964,
-0.0058336179,
-0.0178550407,
-0.0242917631,
-0.039486479,
-0.0079332683,
-0.0095351497,
-0.0123245418,
-0.0301859509,
0.011584661,
-0.0428478643,
0.0265413467,
0.0074195042,
-0.0302051548,
0.0092845662,
0.0383541062,
0.0279397964,
-0.0384333767,
-0.047133401,
0.0215670317,
-0.0348148346,
0.0431871973,
-0.0147259636,
0.0134539586,
0.015575543,
0.0201901309,
0.0493451282,
-0.0169194117,
-0.0477304235,
0.0559170172,
0.0421302617,
-0.0177564193,
-0.0751054063,
-0.0136370165,
-0.0120196389,
-0.0509784967,
-0.0266221743,
-0.0739126429,
-0.0184784699,
0.0442226715,
-0.00851015,
-0.0350620821,
0.0086681023,
0.0101755802,
-0.0430377573,
0.0344039239,
-0.0149839642,
0.0389457978,
0.0404505841,
-0.018641077,
0.0171137024,
0.0206100382,
0.0173152871,
0.0683682859,
0.0386839807,
-0.0140244681,
0.0084826723,
0.0182930864,
-0.0036251096,
0.0293888319,
0.0235629138,
-0.0005800682,
-0.0399122909,
0.0106648449,
0.0056721261,
0.0225512758,
-0.0285002235,
0.0536711589,
0.0724346861,
0.0867239758,
0.0273925718,
-0.0180264041,
0.0583952591,
0.0655499175,
-0.0884512067,
-0.0345676653,
-0.0281189121,
-0.0045771752,
-0.0280960295,
-0.0175479092,
0.0739441589,
0.054932218,
-0.0147670209,
-0.0372104757,
-0.0135277687,
-0.0204340145,
0.0391519815,
-0.0017032446,
0.0326904505,
-0.0734969303,
-0.0183788184,
0.0404031686,
0.0236803461,
-0.0077985534,
-0.0140922489,
-0.0194062609,
0.0489262715,
0.0851835236,
-0.001015665,
0.0255521443,
-0.0126635302,
-0.023809595,
0.0298154652,
-0.0480287671,
0.0482614078,
0.0207810514,
0.0017231976,
-0.0666028783,
-0.0605017543,
0.0615809411,
0.0122547755,
-0.0320722349,
0.050677143,
0.0524349138,
0.060025543,
-0.0493543781,
-0.0122236395,
-0.006351715,
0.0077503668,
-0.0036832439,
0.001299162,
0.0326520726,
0.0061130468,
-0.0100335246,
0.0298124906,
-0.0026511636,
0.0284941085,
-0.0127736516,
-0.0038232913,
0.0410671756,
-0.024670355,
0.000352749,
0.0115303937,
0.0223248247,
0.0299516954,
0.0155294258,
-0.010887078,
-0.0257597528,
-0.0267086253,
-0.0138315707,
0.0404860489,
0.0146481544,
0.0255715977,
0.0205558781,
0.0219264086,
-0.0058186254,
0.0737513602,
-0.0005300984,
0.0096534351,
-0.0023207727,
-0.0112585444,
0.022464145,
-0.0367981866,
0.0091195367,
-0.0568664335,
-0.0036016817,
0.0013403624,
0.0221025292,
-0.0137555236,
-0.0134952255,
0.0010028242,
-0.0825307742,
0.0035604222,
-0.0209153164,
0.0288515575,
0.0025486096,
-0.0101841614,
-0.0217585564,
-0.0168409385,
-0.0484063104,
0.0099519137,
0.0148363234,
0.0064299535,
0.0469450429,
-0.0231561866,
-0.0275191795,
-0.0344399549,
-0.0034211655,
-0.0476056859,
0.0418964475,
-0.0132774478,
-0.046592731,
-0.0466807447,
-0.018124355,
-0.0460059308,
-0.0120995231,
-0.0186747201,
-0.0033584442,
-0.0232271329,
-0.0273454729,
0.0024076044,
-0.0499856994,
0.0122562097,
-0.0053104954,
0.0334873758,
-0.0131635768,
-0.0677661374,
-0.004587851,
-0.0591345355,
0.0255627912,
-0.0641344264,
-0.070345372,
-0.0320615135,
0.0414547771,
0.0021412724,
-0.0113215679,
-0.0213067047,
0.0204000957,
-0.0234926865,
0.0026226684,
-0.029527368,
0.0290774684,
-0.0072870497,
0.0852804035,
-0.0211596731,
-0.0682879314,
0.0435962677,
-0.0075274999,
0.0533307418,
-0.0003778563,
-0.0537768453,
-0.0258268937,
0.0481811501,
-0.0076552052,
0.0225226134,
0.0248249788,
-0.0159195121,
0.0407183431,
-0.0456568822,
-0.0510928184,
0.0071464088,
0.0066991281,
-0.0338404551,
0.0155817252,
0.0446167253,
-0.0769020468,
-0.0193949658,
-0.0881583542,
-0.0406325161,
-0.0300496928,
-0.0173099935,
-0.04165278,
-0.0291324351,
0.0362819843,
0.0055396934,
0.0608974658,
-0.0225527342,
-0.01491345,
0.0060058818,
0.014026016,
0.0740268752,
0.0562628955,
-0.0109695392,
0.0124333538,
-0.0088324826,
0.007817639,
-0.0042402288,
0.0181529019,
-0.0142479166,
0.0484039038,
0.0437657759,
-0.0310782697,
-0.0593340434,
0.0596886352,
0.0712749586,
-0.0400054343,
-0.0152609563,
0.0900612772,
0.0608695187,
-0.0174807087,
0.0250769518,
-0.0329923257,
0.0331000127,
0.0146912392,
0.052909594,
-0.0566031784,
-0.0307664871,
-0.0173026882,
0.0085951639,
-0.023643557,
-0.0216015838,
-0.0031726344,
-0.0902130902,
0.0654633865,
0.020772377,
-0.0044653285,
-0.0168685354,
-0.0821018741,
-0.033187855,
0.0011380237,
-0.0200826786,
-0.0366069861,
-0.0018469462,
-0.0139416503,
0.0447564013,
-0.1177724004,
-0.0497431792,
0.0193630699,
-0.0313858874,
0.020388009,
0.0383490808,
0.0598037392,
0.0091597186,
-0.0389612317,
-0.0178508405,
0.0152385365,
0.0559769981,
-0.0005238873,
0.04459095,
-0.0113001186,
0.0145015297,
-0.0388410799,
0.02651136,
-0.0320251994,
-0.0395096056,
0.0217751153,
0.1151192412,
-0.021375522,
-0.0226944759,
-0.0146076502,
0.0380930677,
0.0132829351,
0.0407323539,
-0.0129832756,
-0.0366960317,
-0.0275351647,
-0.0402568765,
-0.0253415834,
0.0153765362,
-0.0197693091,
-0.0028418743,
-0.0094792852,
-0.0361593217,
-0.0382230356,
-0.0441165268,
0.0327812992,
0.0298167132,
-0.0116227083,
0.0506351553,
0.0075839646,
-0.0337201059,
-0.0152634066,
0.038741596,
-0.0289854966,
0.0225148443,
-0.0169362333,
0.0334738269,
0.0328307636,
-0.0255010258,
-0.0234313421,
0.0299902987,
-0.093814902,
-0.0789579898,
-0.031829454,
0.0217926856,
0.0304451976,
0.0347296409,
-0.0118711032,
-0.0565186553,
0.0718436465,
0.0173414387,
-0.0014073557,
-0.0132086454,
-0.0027268298,
0.0280693211,
0.0181306116,
0.0140389306,
-0.0184913315,
0.030552296,
-0.0269814692,
0.0046174959,
-0.0905805901,
0.011346071,
0.0036066929,
-0.0066105379,
0.090358682,
-0.0011482151,
0.0024450314,
-0.0406686179,
0.0118169952,
0.000563328,
-0.005059496,
-0.0190035235,
0.0045285095,
0.0789186805,
0.0108111231,
-0.0413356647,
-0.0296177585,
-0.0103883166,
-0.0487750918,
-0.058768291,
0.0054788338,
0.0099545866,
-0.000397581,
0.0142808035,
0.013302098,
-0.0138286464,
-0.0145292655,
0.0150848618,
0.0336223394,
-0.0063775377,
0.0345952064,
-0.0194863454,
0.0348587371,
-0.0459397063,
0.0088511957,
-0.0644804165,
-0.0614479631,
-0.0140329693,
0.0671973079,
0.0301738512,
-0.0062064701,
0.0283827353,
-0.0071969824,
-0.0125758667,
0.0016410422,
0.0338553004,
0.0040259929,
-0.0401514992,
0.0358597413,
-0.0026748059,
-0.0591059588,
0.0469721667,
0.0598743223,
0.0261752736,
0.0343866982,
0.0133237606,
-0.1016610935,
-0.0126773575,
0.0224602632,
0.0133304941,
0.0257640984,
0.0141817303,
0.007429285,
-0.0389037766,
-0.0680994615,
0.0287676658,
-0.0381390192,
-0.0270554759,
-0.0640952215,
0.0173352994,
0.0207231585,
-0.0397290215,
-0.0349692218,
-0.0773306936,
-0.0263692848,
-0.04417127,
-0.0062884046,
-0.0330885649,
-6.736024175e-33,
-0.0002637759,
-0.0402767807,
0.0655799508,
-0.0321619213,
-0.0265316404,
-0.01700693,
-0.0191110149,
-0.0189792253,
-0.0328005478,
0.0109516652,
-0.0072347433,
-0.0181498751,
0.0213410109,
0.0227350853,
-0.0099712908,
-0.0057627587,
0.0124863209,
0.0288940985,
-0.0070318677,
-0.0116335629,
0.0579458624,
0.0359750129,
0.0391903296,
-0.0698307976,
0.02600017,
-0.0293747466,
-0.0371166058,
0.0268548392,
0.016723061,
0.038203381,
-0.012606266,
0.0631861687,
0.0311440732,
-0.0381048098,
-0.0229991972,
0.0455571152,
-0.0447359905,
-0.0314535312,
0.0193758309,
-0.0238503981,
0.0115168281,
-0.0318110064,
0.0276234541,
0.0060326331,
-0.0137142027,
0.0517479554,
0.0510487258,
-0.0022338936,
-0.0420087762,
0.0183960311,
-0.0052870689,
0.0285473876,
-0.0329310037,
0.0025865929,
-0.0018977675,
0.0751164779,
-0.0080392361,
0.0459103063,
-0.0383972041,
0.0472009294,
0.0533832945,
0.0244056284,
0.0294879321,
-0.0296975896,
0.0132483663,
0.0563148744,
0.0146865193,
-0.0428090803,
-0.0576805957,
-0.0315379985,
-0.012739026,
0.0075910636,
-0.0346905775,
0.0027297675,
0.0145330597,
-0.0242958833,
-0.0634815916,
0.027909128,
-0.0000700356,
-0.0153110242,
0.0384718217,
0.0001147754,
-0.0555877686,
-0.0632976815,
-0.0293846801,
-0.0461795591,
0.0016534615,
-0.0604074411,
0.048491735,
0.008103733,
0.0099689662,
0.0423416793,
0.0223046783,
-0.0375925489,
-0.0400434993,
0.0184394624,
-0.0234777518,
0.0104598282,
-0.0100774514,
0.0511705689,
-0.069306016,
-0.0031412959,
-0.052075237,
-0.0038780395,
0.0057540312,
0.037530113,
0.014786981,
0.023717273,
-0.0624555685,
-0.0009263839,
-0.0208362807,
-0.0273455661,
-0.0415574163,
0.0139439302,
0.0552437603,
-0.0119183008,
-0.0053189988,
0.0544046536,
0.031934578,
0.0499867573,
0.0363290198,
-0.0321361944,
-0.027788138,
0.0221004151,
-0.0038335647,
-0.0069709304,
-0.0443613864,
0.0339415707,
0.0234851893,
-0.0573826656,
-0.0144611569,
0.0101998588,
2.839e-7,
0.0393404439,
0.0657269359,
-0.0173349734,
0.0010117739,
-0.0114337858,
0.0159633402,
0.0328576863,
-0.0147421714,
0.0240148939,
0.0289658662,
0.0389918797,
0.0292384513,
0.0103149591,
0.0261145495,
-0.0948654264,
0.0545792021,
-0.0834301934,
-0.0107492544,
-0.084174104,
0.0215763971,
0.0478776582,
0.1092177033,
0.0398666672,
-0.0071516633,
0.0199991502,
-0.0041595898,
0.0359474272,
-0.0690758154,
-0.0300607104,
0.016457608,
0.0610626899,
-0.0028796236,
-0.034129791,
-0.0337796696,
-0.0197193548,
0.0266786832,
-0.0069447057,
0.0569756106,
-0.0140857818,
-0.0119380914,
-0.0039400873,
-0.0387640893,
-0.0024075902,
-0.0674671605,
0.0760026574,
-0.0089212051,
-0.0252194535,
0.01122991,
-0.033322487,
-0.0168280452,
0.0212714896,
0.0004549326,
0.0107765207,
-0.0324303508,
-0.0123342117,
-0.0055832947,
-0.0181079693,
-0.0932743624,
-0.0173292197,
0.0116025358,
0.0007495196,
-0.0321681909,
-0.0295922291,
0.0203715302,
0.0488688499,
-0.047781866,
0.0383801199,
2.330874203e-34,
0.0194286089,
0.0485075675,
-0.0238884073,
-0.0410871059,
0.056617897,
0.0147951851,
0.0054728533,
0.0370749012,
0.0447941124,
-0.063556537,
-0.0183585975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20956v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20956v2
|
A Robot Walks into a Bar: Can Language Models Serve as Creativity Support Tools for Comedy? An Evaluation of LLMs' Humour Alignment with Comedians
| 2024-05-31T15:55:51 | 2024-06-03T21:01:50 |
Piotr Wojciech Mirowski, Juliette Love, Kory W. Mathewson, Shakir Mohamed
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We interviewed twenty professional comedians who perform live shows in front
of audiences and who use artificial intelligence in their artistic process as
part of 3-hour workshops on ``AI x Comedy'' conducted at the Edinburgh Festival
Fringe in August 2023 and online. The workshop consisted of a comedy writing
session with large language models (LLMs), a human-computer interaction
questionnaire to assess the Creativity Support Index of AI as a writing tool,
and a focus group interrogating the comedians' motivations for and processes of
using AI, as well as their ethical concerns about bias, censorship and
copyright. Participants noted that existing moderation strategies used in
safety filtering and instruction-tuned LLMs reinforced hegemonic viewpoints by
erasing minority groups and their perspectives, and qualified this as a form of
censorship. At the same time, most participants felt the LLMs did not succeed
as a creativity support tool, by producing bland and biased comedy tropes, akin
to ``cruise ship comedy material from the 1950s, but a bit less racist''. Our
work extends scholarship about the subtle difference between, one the one hand,
harmful speech, and on the other hand, ``offensive'' language as a practice of
resistance, satire and ``punching up''. We also interrogate the global value
alignment behind such language models, and discuss the importance of
community-based value alignment and data ownership to build AI tools that
better suit artists' needs.
|
[
0.065994598,
0.0501200147,
-0.0443201363,
-0.0186580159,
-0.0508119762,
0.0240304396,
0.039501287,
0.0163462758,
0.046140559,
-0.0073859482,
0.0122560561,
-0.0109812031,
-0.0162795298,
0.0763406828,
0.0031187586,
-0.0134012122,
-0.0234869923,
0.0140037686,
0.0559109561,
-0.034540426,
0.0099110808,
0.0443061627,
-0.0192086659,
0.0600895658,
-0.0216614287,
0.0051526632,
0.0510297008,
0.0307403859,
0.024855772,
0.0388085283,
-0.0291857347,
0.0249183308,
0.0361412913,
0.0499202684,
0.000001587,
-0.0702477023,
0.0425538532,
-0.0204627905,
0.0323817283,
-0.0385922007,
0.0422279835,
0.0095754359,
-0.0565518588,
0.0275027957,
-0.0168444905,
0.0532551035,
0.0753582641,
0.0150949536,
0.065208666,
0.0694157779,
-0.0016829123,
-0.0048251473,
0.0149496524,
-0.0233939514,
-0.0198320374,
-0.0088694682,
0.0448991172,
0.0326502807,
0.0171965063,
-0.0504303388,
-0.0591057874,
0.0343128853,
0.0229207538,
-0.0434223861,
-0.0216908604,
-0.0095987003,
-0.077158384,
-0.0580741093,
0.0502842292,
0.0120107271,
0.0054608285,
-0.0106473053,
0.0108868126,
0.0399191156,
0.0090051517,
0.0138291633,
-0.0498160124,
0.0725235939,
0.0205332991,
-0.0304036699,
-0.0226789508,
-0.034790393,
-0.0066583259,
0.0501330905,
0.0658512488,
0.009488577,
0.0184353758,
0.001870689,
-0.0281588286,
-0.0069812145,
0.0047252364,
-0.0346302949,
0.0615376011,
0.0573024489,
0.006586107,
0.0204600003,
-0.0345479436,
0.0184089262,
0.0037348347,
-0.0543092452,
0.0249022916,
0.0691715702,
0.0052717556,
0.0553433225,
0.0270650368,
0.0260765888,
-0.0219241213,
0.051743567,
0.0041649048,
0.0316092186,
-0.0091150673,
-0.0210075043,
-0.0160685834,
-0.0055685188,
0.0235715378,
-0.0279001854,
-0.015177506,
0.0400811806,
-0.042659279,
0.0112888636,
-0.0052973554,
0.027871985,
-0.0090109855,
-0.0187456738,
0.0012389466,
0.0517951436,
-0.0435096584,
0.0316675901,
-0.0425170772,
-0.0520760305,
0.0174051933,
0.0160768088,
0.0033933201,
-0.0405048914,
0.0395896658,
0.0776763931,
0.0329985842,
-0.0405013673,
0.0145204207,
-0.005398694,
-0.0402646661,
-0.0166133642,
0.0186819099,
-0.032908041,
0.0371705778,
0.0040903743,
-0.0399044976,
-0.0815582275,
-0.0007760394,
0.0233535748,
-0.0201585591,
-0.0164248217,
-0.0129994098,
0.0316188075,
0.0472208746,
0.0225467291,
-0.0277608857,
-0.0215311479,
0.0741618723,
0.0039512175,
0.0174187701,
-0.0075903707,
0.0369630307,
0.027106408,
-0.0553203262,
0.0111947302,
-0.0698409379,
-0.0063807084,
-0.0259647779,
0.0353784077,
0.0164464712,
0.0536289923,
-0.0017896787,
0.0186639559,
0.06726145,
0.0166162252,
-0.0108308829,
0.0362474658,
0.0446520932,
-0.0264470205,
0.0069616139,
-0.0024001116,
0.0167485513,
0.0035821125,
-0.0082659824,
-0.0213556141,
0.0010846732,
0.0480427593,
-0.002208557,
0.0016900058,
0.007772672,
-0.0077688387,
0.0914876685,
-0.005559681,
-0.0073259342,
0.0217917208,
0.0020283833,
-0.0484205224,
0.0025711921,
-0.0489996746,
0.0023042699,
-0.0303490497,
0.0014305364,
0.0798659846,
0.0387939066,
-0.0007083921,
0.0436692499,
-0.0216879919,
-0.0013569259,
0.0595312305,
0.000619987,
0.0026288936,
-0.0492591821,
0.0176795758,
0.03758993,
-0.0159142129,
-0.0088165198,
0.0066119875,
-0.0251121782,
0.0435582176,
-0.0233027916,
0.0356174521,
-0.0401035696,
-0.0025187875,
-0.070978336,
-0.0270453393,
-0.0631013364,
0.0108795352,
0.0592610054,
0.034787681,
-0.0875922441,
-0.0179371051,
0.0013942037,
-0.0225372072,
-0.0266739465,
0.0604836568,
-0.0181944557,
0.0317440368,
0.0532590449,
-0.0761818811,
0.0082122907,
0.0763663948,
0.02718376,
0.0149046835,
0.0561340488,
-0.0248581711,
-0.0248974487,
-0.0393743478,
-0.0016993883,
-0.049135603,
-0.0137369093,
-0.009088492,
0.0054941876,
-0.0043777344,
0.0141189881,
-0.0136732692,
-0.011435247,
0.0352899916,
0.0333919786,
-0.0507883877,
0.0883177444,
-0.0158585478,
0.0770033747,
0.0177692398,
0.0077198818,
-0.0134037966,
0.000227033,
-0.0848745927,
-0.0173884723,
-0.0000833685,
-0.0451042205,
0.0085058846,
-0.0049213152,
-0.0477992482,
-0.0018386577,
0.0092079109,
-0.068636924,
-0.0207170658,
0.0218751784,
-0.0097541418,
0.0025201603,
-0.0689191297,
0.0280336849,
-0.0096072489,
-0.0412538871,
0.0013442645,
0.0357752517,
0.0386701338,
0.0244847778,
0.0025942035,
-0.0802243277,
-0.0181708783,
-0.0193422548,
-0.0366443805,
0.0077613648,
-0.0088786473,
-0.0135620171,
0.0211842172,
0.0607543364,
0.0208116081,
0.0549403988,
0.00875411,
0.0369826816,
-0.0073721167,
0.0216143634,
0.0315914527,
-0.0073429695,
-0.0431174301,
-0.0111142015,
0.0185952727,
0.0509893596,
0.0159916319,
-0.0740031749,
0.0880044252,
-0.0375323184,
-0.0177812874,
0.0017553018,
-0.0789789185,
-0.0555563644,
0.0144208996,
-0.0089583639,
-0.0173344556,
0.0687257797,
-0.04458097,
-0.0034999424,
0.0173719786,
-0.0380910896,
-0.020911932,
0.0792902634,
-0.0069800285,
0.1061974689,
-0.025910588,
-0.0110944295,
-0.0568447746,
0.0345725007,
0.0239423234,
-0.0627625138,
-0.0061541474,
0.0031271556,
0.0048642107,
-0.014727517,
-0.0260510501,
-0.0063889716,
-0.0174998976,
-0.052427087,
0.0153372725,
0.002133688,
-0.0201553199,
0.0023589828,
-0.0236686226,
0.0559455082,
0.0043077441,
0.0135403564,
0.0112216417,
0.0155753419,
-0.0207590535,
0.0238729175,
0.0100173075,
-0.0441623367,
0.0406393558,
-0.0306203812,
-0.0304453447,
-0.0496108718,
0.0160246547,
-0.0081090946,
0.0177544504,
0.0118481191,
0.002659969,
0.0107783088,
-0.0140890237,
0.0555637404,
-0.0259399395,
-0.0161961243,
0.0651929826,
-0.0132795637,
0.015097335,
0.0003934978,
-0.0187398922,
-0.0416800715,
0.0162765235,
0.011557702,
-0.0486127846,
0.0308345519,
0.0064739692,
0.0332099684,
-0.0515151061,
-0.0298836157,
-0.0209850129,
-0.0658174902,
0.0342079885,
0.0099443728,
-0.0349888727,
-0.035186287,
0.0083234524,
-0.0025043571,
0.0365283638,
-0.0127572799,
0.0062696598,
0.014089413,
0.0227277707,
0.0185300801,
-0.0088815391,
-0.0249653365,
0.0141867446,
-0.0246688016,
0.1020281091,
0.0279219355,
0.052637592,
-0.029934261,
-0.027938569,
-0.0251062755,
-0.0381211713,
0.003153214,
0.0054721045,
0.0052583041,
-0.0186695866,
-0.0114415679,
-0.0368881486,
0.0068257372,
0.0054707923,
-0.0318113007,
-0.0293088313,
0.0429380275,
-0.0227324758,
-0.0526910052,
-0.0657335222,
0.0354945138,
-0.0142792882,
0.076573886,
0.0564932488,
-0.0864239559,
0.0211645067,
-0.0682589337,
-0.025701344,
-0.0322859772,
-0.0901495665,
-0.0313933827,
0.0206509847,
-0.0633263737,
-0.0231488459,
-0.0150953876,
-0.0258377213,
0.0430992693,
0.0479577631,
-0.038328331,
-0.0611260496,
-0.0137938382,
-0.0127818622,
-0.0198143814,
-0.0235208999,
0.0007901179,
-0.0060708262,
0.0186036602,
-0.029777851,
-0.0724736229,
-0.0363348387,
-0.0093434816,
-0.0100808786,
-0.0689187869,
0.1015710011,
0.0537809804,
0.0287272912,
-0.046511393,
0.0137761822,
-0.0607749745,
0.0189348217,
0.0515910685,
-0.0213883929,
0.0551586188,
-0.0007736564,
0.0173280947,
-0.02405026,
0.0152792456,
-0.0489896983,
0.0321838409,
0.0168612581,
0.0395630412,
-0.0382502452,
-0.0458328985,
0.0031490251,
0.026177356,
-0.0584607124,
-0.0307042096,
-0.0420222059,
-0.026308123,
-0.0474824272,
0.0081021031,
-0.0194279775,
-0.0138896219,
-0.0242863186,
0.0276294369,
-0.0125241186,
-0.0298772492,
0.0091875466,
-0.0502710827,
0.0393445082,
-0.0272041541,
-0.008049367,
0.0432886966,
0.0039308118,
0.0018199985,
0.0045799846,
-0.0068932706,
0.0532038398,
-0.0127353463,
-0.0088124024,
0.0287947822,
0.0450358912,
0.034745723,
-0.0209848732,
0.0161265098,
0.0445125438,
-0.0335936882,
-0.0900226533,
0.0390917473,
-0.0138211651,
0.0314284302,
-0.0179105904,
0.0062957946,
-0.0065635848,
0.0108135985,
-0.0110993395,
0.0105986847,
0.0031218017,
-0.0792911723,
-0.0150481211,
0.0096754748,
-0.0083060153,
-0.0284323674,
0.0517517924,
-0.0644749105,
0.0189498067,
0.0206700154,
-0.0126475794,
0.0019265173,
-0.0522813722,
-0.0150782391,
-0.0003414405,
0.0334596187,
0.0033962252,
-0.0605273582,
-0.0501779132,
-0.0098105976,
-0.0305387937,
0.0234831125,
-0.0442166515,
0.0033496604,
0.0438060686,
-0.001337799,
0.0208173562,
-0.0182757936,
0.0339813419,
-0.0485895649,
0.0127367908,
0.0064925756,
-5.62491716e-33,
-0.0171396267,
-0.0416620411,
-0.0176838543,
0.0115808137,
-0.0411011353,
-0.0336845703,
-0.0609835312,
0.0337461717,
-0.0338992365,
0.0045143259,
-0.0072416388,
-0.0017590765,
-0.0084974719,
-0.0247954521,
0.0159780346,
-0.0720409155,
0.0351390615,
0.0320940465,
-0.0359871127,
-0.0045995754,
0.0346850753,
0.0136396587,
-0.0256056022,
-0.0989982709,
0.0136457421,
-0.0256340709,
-0.0452748798,
-0.0167927425,
0.058558654,
0.02343015,
0.029865237,
0.0990108997,
0.0398027413,
0.0048550013,
0.0367022119,
0.0524798818,
0.0156056844,
-0.0035102582,
0.0168401357,
0.0175347365,
0.020309858,
-0.048834879,
0.0434350967,
-0.0269812383,
-0.0480455235,
0.0325190015,
0.0356265828,
-0.0214360878,
0.0319280401,
-0.0458778888,
-0.0542802066,
-0.018638473,
-0.057874497,
-0.0321827531,
-0.0173469689,
0.0122103896,
0.0474498346,
0.0117927864,
-0.057241749,
0.0175660849,
-0.0997805968,
-0.0195307881,
0.0240897015,
-0.0364033431,
-0.003499808,
0.0647835508,
-0.0341314934,
0.0576030947,
-0.0118218763,
-0.0038381831,
0.0256081428,
0.0448633693,
0.0064872978,
0.0306502469,
-0.0224096924,
-0.072691828,
0.0249334667,
0.0154024204,
0.0179238524,
0.0147835594,
0.0144307511,
0.0122112632,
-0.0396247692,
-0.0266484879,
-0.0054477593,
-0.0603765026,
0.0101577602,
-0.0758528337,
-0.0047904737,
0.008575011,
-0.0144434096,
-0.0129540088,
0.0321666412,
-0.0175972339,
0.0002930796,
0.0035229444,
-0.0431705117,
0.0210065991,
0.0054668118,
0.0162891988,
-0.0094281472,
-0.003410296,
0.0151316496,
0.0267577264,
0.0575874411,
0.0168725029,
0.0182739347,
0.0688236207,
-0.0227782503,
0.0055347239,
0.0061320155,
0.0311594419,
0.0251825228,
0.0185769647,
0.0225753803,
0.0782870576,
-0.0091850255,
-0.0393855199,
0.0745100453,
0.027467981,
-0.0255153626,
-0.0242808759,
-0.0384461842,
-0.0170638189,
-0.0633449033,
-0.0170792397,
-0.021716848,
0.0045651537,
0.0473872088,
-0.069983907,
-0.0319390856,
-0.0678007975,
2.65e-7,
0.0232069641,
0.0237046406,
0.0205507651,
0.0355118513,
0.0399084017,
0.0291019939,
0.0035279281,
0.0483366512,
0.0254007224,
0.0109957187,
0.008695432,
0.0120698195,
0.0101458952,
0.0357372276,
-0.0504230037,
0.0013439994,
-0.0995394886,
0.0499556661,
-0.0645251051,
0.0515503585,
0.002017735,
-0.000003977,
0.0473326072,
-0.0345669538,
-0.0301272161,
-0.07131394,
-0.0015615581,
-0.0262390301,
0.0360001437,
-0.0305366777,
0.0182247311,
0.0086559579,
0.0137941651,
-0.0039968295,
0.0205690786,
0.0341737084,
0.0208562333,
0.0571791232,
-0.0065677962,
0.0212844964,
0.0267973915,
0.0147850141,
-0.0050125439,
-0.0368245915,
0.0660949275,
0.0825449377,
-0.0345798023,
-0.0298148226,
-0.0146202166,
-0.0613508858,
0.0506574064,
-0.0153033361,
-0.013647317,
-0.02124843,
0.0204442609,
0.0146586914,
0.0353332721,
-0.0230764616,
-0.0244830064,
-0.0008775171,
-0.0610629134,
-0.0070173708,
0.0080020977,
-0.028265588,
-0.0006079387,
-0.0860021487,
0.022189606,
2.283934096e-34,
0.021963561,
-0.0035469574,
0.007607162,
0.0091344975,
0.0181653742,
0.0607881695,
0.0254647359,
-0.0068137068,
-0.0087427208,
0.0070141028,
-0.0379397981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20947v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20947v2
|
OR-Bench: An Over-Refusal Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T15:44:33 | 2024-06-20T05:22:38 |
Justin Cui, Wei-Lin Chiang, Ion Stoica, Cho-Jui Hsieh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) require careful safety alignment to prevent
malicious outputs. While significant research focuses on mitigating harmful
content generation, the enhanced safety often come with the side effect of
over-refusal, where LLMs may reject innocuous prompts and become less helpful.
Although the issue of over-refusal has been empirically observed, a systematic
measurement is challenging due to the difficulty of crafting prompts that
appear harmful but are benign. This study proposes a novel method for
automatically generating large-scale sets of "seemingly toxic prompts" (benign
prompts likely rejected by LLMs). Leveraging this technique, we introduce
OR-Bench, the first large-scale over-refusal benchmark. OR-Bench comprises
80,000 seemingly toxic prompts across 10 common rejection categories, a subset
of around 1,000 hard prompts that are challenging even for state-of-the-art
LLMs, and an additional 600 toxic prompts to prevent indiscriminate responses.
We then conduct a comprehensive study to measure the over-refusal of 25 popular
LLMs across 8 model families. Our datasets are available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/bench-llm/or-bench and the demo can be found at
https://huggingface.co/spaces/bench-llm/or-bench. We hope this benchmark can
help the community develop better safety aligned models.
|
[
0.045433972,
0.0567172654,
-0.0186195709,
0.0249609109,
-0.0230852235,
0.0002401727,
0.0055699064,
0.0246110577,
0.0363045409,
-0.0230529234,
0.0109103126,
-0.0478100441,
-0.0134147862,
0.0642132312,
0.0109244902,
-0.0125556849,
0.0449647345,
-0.0453773215,
0.0176612362,
-0.0129212011,
0.0191693082,
0.0108359968,
0.0045980797,
0.0531842038,
-0.0039643487,
-0.021097878,
0.008800026,
0.0202719886,
-0.0013554561,
-0.0456081554,
0.0127724689,
0.0553021505,
-0.035101112,
0.0835955665,
0.0000020245,
-0.0683053061,
-0.0107876034,
0.0074782274,
-0.0456781872,
0.0349237919,
0.0446582548,
-0.0188444126,
-0.0550706498,
0.047491923,
-0.0242831483,
0.008110486,
0.0671153143,
0.0273135658,
0.0750702098,
0.0713808089,
-0.0083659245,
0.0558638126,
0.0199632421,
0.0016274281,
-0.0049297567,
-0.0134769883,
0.0355141237,
-0.0260267816,
0.0169937145,
0.0117688095,
-0.000507015,
0.0117137404,
0.0088307746,
-0.0594326295,
-0.0338382199,
-0.0133136371,
-0.0270748064,
-0.051919736,
-0.0098284185,
0.0699790344,
-0.0430692136,
-0.0119027449,
-0.0027381682,
-0.0363049954,
0.0099792918,
0.0120040225,
-0.0369609147,
0.058749713,
-0.0055309678,
-0.0127333878,
-0.0112438947,
0.0107207522,
0.0340034366,
0.0190353543,
0.0408175737,
0.0578704588,
0.0354492925,
-0.035265483,
0.0283565838,
-0.0243672971,
0.0263283681,
-0.0810092613,
0.0126627926,
-0.0054489858,
-0.0527574047,
0.0168756563,
-0.0524730682,
-0.020030519,
0.0959922001,
-0.0543465726,
0.0446578451,
0.0318489261,
-0.0216131117,
0.0299065858,
0.0036596232,
0.0118637523,
-0.0220789742,
0.023392532,
0.014969252,
0.0268688649,
0.0264154896,
0.0019554528,
-0.0319424905,
0.005330977,
-0.0090944832,
0.0392001048,
-0.0470997281,
0.0508729815,
-0.0473042913,
0.0485665351,
0.0187936611,
-0.0156516731,
-0.0095253652,
0.0065025208,
0.0133626116,
-0.0176613126,
-0.0359494574,
-0.013702699,
0.0116624516,
-0.083827965,
-0.0001039354,
0.0115136327,
-0.0155349886,
-0.0411443748,
0.0015647731,
0.0901494473,
0.0303821098,
0.0024708293,
-0.0241880435,
-0.0567235723,
-0.0209842157,
-0.0278099794,
-0.0271802153,
-0.0760012269,
-0.0398998037,
0.0109123131,
-0.0209949706,
-0.0866537616,
0.0055316528,
0.0255441777,
-0.015792869,
0.0242412779,
-0.0324391127,
-0.0155052422,
-0.0043303268,
0.055186931,
-0.0440512933,
0.0612422116,
-0.0074389591,
0.0659187734,
0.0646253303,
-0.0283520594,
0.0516580194,
0.0809807032,
0.0052112066,
0.0645341352,
-0.0218896475,
0.0014353041,
0.0422090404,
0.0011986212,
-0.0028775022,
0.0876020789,
0.0035219856,
-0.0297444835,
0.0676906481,
0.0098825134,
-0.0637067407,
0.0021796674,
0.0289747473,
0.0133635355,
-0.004697321,
0.0081883399,
-0.0678051859,
0.0100826509,
-0.0682235509,
-0.0149042727,
0.0265024975,
0.0539825484,
-0.0076835114,
-0.0064122183,
-0.0137965372,
0.0006837689,
0.0421860591,
0.0064732977,
0.0169730783,
0.0074562994,
-0.0499701463,
0.0023900338,
0.0337033533,
-0.0622110777,
-0.0082043447,
-0.0525891408,
0.0238973834,
0.0458437502,
0.0798530206,
-0.0248403475,
-0.0040621893,
-0.0312335677,
-0.0054525095,
0.0441467725,
0.0641637594,
-0.012912089,
-0.0005072149,
-0.0171003379,
-0.0476439111,
0.0241105035,
0.0237647574,
-0.0100493981,
0.0486377738,
0.0096478686,
0.0113519002,
-0.0058441968,
-0.0577930622,
0.0194001719,
-0.0176301245,
-0.0325543359,
-0.022114642,
0.0065761372,
0.0247561261,
0.0033211014,
-0.0042721247,
-0.0015131964,
0.0261624157,
0.0092345234,
-0.0053445385,
-0.0345973335,
-0.0405882932,
0.0034805457,
0.0579174906,
-0.0202580709,
-0.0411487073,
0.0575716607,
-0.018014254,
-0.0110052265,
0.0207457095,
-0.0388173237,
0.0107017457,
-0.0164441951,
0.027258331,
-0.0259292908,
0.0010197281,
-0.0185437463,
0.0257871598,
-0.0000158271,
0.0287830718,
0.0244403221,
-0.0176304728,
0.0104557276,
-0.0212758351,
-0.0734400302,
0.0026426842,
-0.0456391312,
0.0306147132,
0.0357092582,
0.007868303,
-0.0442655236,
0.0013338124,
-0.0665873215,
-0.0186157413,
-0.0059761298,
0.0082759634,
0.0264746156,
0.0239024479,
-0.0219635535,
0.0094348323,
-0.0425449647,
-0.0264973864,
0.0290584937,
0.054765556,
0.0096672159,
-0.0236196555,
-0.0507188663,
-0.0356664285,
-0.0052676476,
-0.014533611,
0.0318657346,
-0.0031075627,
-0.0081024626,
-0.0089080334,
0.0571564771,
-0.0177250523,
0.0133234775,
0.0010963747,
-0.0552862734,
0.0197007172,
-0.0223876778,
0.0085548153,
0.0300740562,
0.0302972756,
-0.0067267739,
0.083403416,
0.0079072285,
-0.0722614005,
-0.0181390569,
0.0088117309,
-0.0288971923,
-0.0052451151,
-0.0692063868,
0.0045170859,
0.0362919495,
0.011350817,
-0.0170128383,
-0.0505158789,
0.0451922081,
-0.0266034789,
-0.0266879778,
-0.019948842,
-0.0625211075,
-0.0328968763,
0.0565273948,
-0.0089835403,
-0.0738603771,
0.0681229085,
-0.0315324478,
0.0120551577,
0.0059201671,
0.0017236101,
0.0022337188,
0.0686411634,
-0.0215758365,
0.0424663834,
0.0692278594,
-0.0052037709,
-0.0210502483,
-0.0320472308,
0.0355213098,
-0.0362588316,
0.0279802438,
-0.0291393977,
0.0013491795,
-0.0140118357,
-0.0340998285,
-0.06956999,
-0.0846408308,
-0.0125173572,
-0.0162977055,
0.0137442071,
-0.029047288,
0.0008156463,
-0.0206358396,
0.0049032108,
0.0234991852,
-0.0152528258,
-0.0067000259,
-0.0098796301,
0.0007323557,
0.0596688502,
-0.0509357117,
0.0310580861,
-0.0289113875,
0.0353443027,
0.0936435685,
0.0314088538,
0.0073577007,
-0.0089424951,
0.0003474285,
0.0422493368,
-0.0200279672,
-0.0058852183,
0.0548116267,
0.0331650972,
-0.0408426858,
-0.0133369947,
0.0637655854,
0.0269755144,
-0.0208818633,
0.0259092525,
-0.0346358716,
0.0700119287,
0.0251915585,
0.0183948018,
-0.0694146454,
-0.0106734931,
0.0322245695,
0.0287806075,
-0.0519698784,
-0.0374128073,
-0.0112723159,
-0.1380491704,
0.0515620783,
0.0155202951,
-0.027530726,
-0.0074755345,
-0.0369096361,
-0.0001484193,
0.0080151241,
0.0144569455,
0.0077911154,
-0.0240083709,
-0.0276037473,
0.0142100416,
-0.0133852018,
-0.0349777453,
0.0502982289,
-0.0589580052,
0.063642472,
0.023798544,
-0.0102358246,
-0.0162262637,
-0.0120133525,
0.0601181388,
0.0013920761,
-0.032438796,
0.0066102212,
0.0429564752,
0.0394294448,
-0.0041737268,
-0.0309667345,
0.0140670985,
-0.0217026621,
-0.0203897133,
0.0171397943,
0.0913800374,
0.0004749266,
-0.0163684953,
-0.0497225039,
0.0106165642,
0.047734078,
0.091245316,
0.0385653153,
-0.0619675294,
-0.0070623029,
-0.0669648275,
-0.007006716,
-0.0367601551,
-0.0186531059,
-0.0025947888,
-0.0102036204,
-0.036808949,
-0.0662823096,
0.0038471704,
-0.0045189485,
0.0219418723,
0.0567133278,
-0.0199324917,
-0.0214494355,
0.0042974525,
0.0088752778,
0.0199535824,
-0.0305084009,
0.0541251339,
-0.0724535212,
0.0442260616,
-0.0246882383,
-0.0127393203,
-0.0064700954,
0.025386529,
-0.0410533473,
-0.0902349129,
0.0243543666,
0.0620086491,
0.0350590795,
-0.0156332403,
-0.0100504924,
-0.0695356056,
0.0488647483,
0.041477643,
-0.023289144,
-0.0046579628,
0.0543273911,
-0.0302097946,
0.0129122008,
0.017926164,
-0.0446054116,
-0.019149201,
0.0387282893,
0.0018251535,
-0.0380586125,
-0.0319587849,
0.0190309789,
0.065925099,
-0.0122027854,
-0.0326408707,
0.0044262675,
-0.0195667837,
0.0043817139,
-0.0121807633,
-0.034180928,
-0.0156676676,
0.0292814802,
0.0195681434,
-0.0466786399,
0.0118176155,
0.0044171661,
-0.0537425317,
0.0570958406,
-0.0349520966,
0.0339263715,
0.0023155692,
0.0382645465,
0.0718937367,
-0.0066872733,
-0.0244495161,
0.0285586398,
0.0010982591,
0.0224608257,
-0.0059809797,
0.0198703874,
-0.006828743,
0.0040728557,
0.0139722377,
0.0403891765,
-0.0346634388,
-0.0344065055,
-0.0058963774,
0.0124700256,
0.0187603068,
-0.0027879262,
0.0475472659,
-0.0115018347,
-0.0021548201,
-0.0366032422,
-0.008820341,
0.0036291427,
-0.0737907067,
0.0251620058,
0.0040671881,
-0.0170631241,
-0.0002353153,
0.0556021556,
-0.016967468,
0.0527905971,
0.0321079865,
-0.0042563933,
-0.0301567633,
-0.0244034249,
0.0456570834,
0.0246951263,
-0.0404210873,
-0.0232866034,
-0.0855085626,
-0.0853097066,
-0.0341539569,
0.0180892702,
0.0100400075,
0.0019055833,
0.0175545625,
0.0374012776,
0.0174561553,
0.023302801,
-0.0450632982,
0.0022173026,
0.0025898856,
-0.0347845443,
-0.0290144663,
-6.003628379e-33,
0.0221094247,
-0.0322662629,
-0.03089476,
-0.0169962775,
0.0082019176,
-0.015428165,
-0.0369157158,
0.0131619321,
-0.0173422936,
-0.006706344,
-0.0390470326,
-0.0117150787,
0.004373441,
0.0234366283,
-0.0064635659,
-0.0061966502,
0.0254599173,
-0.0059207734,
-0.0602446087,
0.040770527,
0.0556600876,
-0.0220206473,
-0.0091362186,
-0.0804326981,
0.0495372228,
-0.0151689723,
-0.0498533659,
0.0065949108,
-0.0282104965,
0.0841127932,
0.0116458284,
0.0681062415,
0.0033956927,
-0.026305832,
-0.0038912192,
0.044943504,
-0.0028467735,
-0.0180222839,
0.0323282816,
-0.0239968821,
-0.0001040719,
-0.0571663044,
0.0325577296,
-0.0201512557,
-0.0334407426,
-0.0048688576,
0.0026990166,
-0.0120330667,
-0.0219436791,
-0.0141233969,
-0.0546944626,
0.0198575817,
-0.019912906,
-0.0160843283,
-0.0052272524,
0.0586814731,
0.0356429964,
0.0039142566,
-0.0132274795,
0.0262000207,
0.0258665364,
0.0093265558,
0.063617304,
-0.0267589483,
-0.0326534584,
0.0659358501,
-0.0362779237,
0.0259670671,
0.0207781773,
-0.0261100512,
-0.0007348274,
0.0504709743,
0.0453721173,
0.0710992068,
0.0286976956,
-0.0403594896,
-0.0573995113,
0.0632329732,
0.0302461479,
0.0237293709,
0.0433316827,
-0.0324970149,
-0.0514976829,
-0.0260368437,
-0.0305262264,
-0.0126355141,
-0.0346125439,
-0.026618626,
0.0352989733,
-0.0103173256,
-0.0390843973,
-0.0423770547,
0.0106383422,
-0.0548203774,
-0.015519524,
0.0436027758,
-0.019378325,
-0.0136412578,
0.0166288372,
0.0405992381,
0.0023122432,
-0.0079175727,
0.0105609111,
-0.0453777872,
0.016425781,
0.0251004733,
0.036812678,
0.042009715,
-0.0990142897,
0.0225694682,
-0.0443578586,
0.0721973702,
0.0008164989,
0.0314892307,
0.0217657238,
-0.0303273108,
0.0034433005,
-0.0038204943,
0.0474308468,
0.0113737388,
-0.0586958975,
0.0109939026,
-0.0136881564,
0.0216161814,
-0.0170069691,
-0.0157319494,
-0.021110747,
0.0150535684,
0.0809807032,
-0.0481192768,
-0.0114779035,
-0.0243969467,
2.658e-7,
0.0101636322,
0.0357429124,
0.0234394372,
0.0557319112,
0.0218323134,
0.0688470006,
-0.0153750442,
0.0553821027,
-0.0081609618,
-0.0063663945,
-0.0296048559,
-0.0213726237,
0.0408448428,
0.0659628287,
-0.0606981665,
0.0158830658,
-0.0941174328,
0.0192543417,
-0.0562621318,
0.0068526198,
0.0494075455,
0.0922777578,
0.0157043654,
-0.0508578271,
0.0022845326,
-0.0458718576,
0.0137745254,
-0.0274778362,
0.0157356244,
0.0256349538,
0.0276770182,
-0.0109593915,
0.0386398397,
0.0266581401,
-0.0272033084,
-0.0207752585,
-0.0383386239,
0.0548684485,
0.0276986286,
-0.0129395947,
0.0040529151,
-0.0617945418,
0.0022335879,
-0.0909582824,
0.0525512882,
0.0223274864,
-0.0061937599,
-0.0518266,
-0.015983738,
-0.047060091,
0.0349060297,
-0.0378583595,
-0.0240440387,
0.0089702671,
0.0043022712,
-0.0044142781,
0.0031806664,
-0.0287018269,
-0.0419654176,
-0.039706815,
-0.0163517687,
-0.0949768499,
-0.0245555192,
0.0235121902,
-0.0091930078,
-0.0685309619,
0.020252388,
2.878443348e-34,
0.0365019366,
-0.0366389491,
0.0212626718,
-0.0300157387,
0.0310090985,
0.0121769495,
0.0146089178,
0.0165691841,
0.0125707081,
-0.0345242992,
-0.0207084995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20917v1
|
Learning to Estimate System Specifications in Linear Temporal Logic using Transformers and Mamba
| 2024-05-31T15:21:53 | 2024-05-31T15:21:53 |
İlker Işık, Ebru Aydin Gol, Ramazan Gokberk Cinbis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.LO
|
Temporal logic is a framework for representing and reasoning about
propositions that evolve over time. It is commonly used for specifying
requirements in various domains, including hardware and software systems, as
well as robotics. Specification mining or formula generation involves
extracting temporal logic formulae from system traces and has numerous
applications, such as detecting bugs and improving interpretability. Although
there has been a surge of deep learning-based methods for temporal logic
satisfiability checking in recent years, the specification mining literature
has been lagging behind in adopting deep learning methods despite their many
advantages, such as scalability. In this paper, we introduce autoregressive
models that can generate linear temporal logic formulae from traces, towards
addressing the specification mining problem. We propose multiple architectures
for this task: transformer encoder-decoder, decoder-only transformer, and
Mamba, which is an emerging alternative to transformer models. Additionally, we
devise a metric for quantifying the distinctiveness of the generated formulae
and a straightforward algorithm to enforce the syntax constraints. Our
experiments show that the proposed architectures yield promising results,
generating correct and distinct formulae at a fraction of the compute cost
needed for the combinatorial baseline.
|
[
-0.010444656,
0.0742918178,
-0.0058587785,
0.0065199737,
-0.0208774097,
-0.0214857981,
-0.0056990781,
-0.0248190518,
-0.0073950514,
-0.0017442033,
0.0841014087,
0.0003101508,
0.0080251163,
0.1165923923,
-0.0212680455,
-0.017481979,
0.0557736345,
0.0066621266,
-0.0198335256,
0.0319487788,
-0.0368246473,
0.0118330084,
-0.0437478796,
0.0732180029,
-0.0395522341,
-0.0550969504,
-0.0350352116,
-0.0247390922,
0.0315659754,
-0.010628717,
-0.0077105765,
-0.0052283127,
0.0059168725,
-0.0081755193,
0.0000022268,
0.0177084804,
-0.055961404,
-0.0224568881,
-0.0409649871,
-0.002811301,
-0.0206601843,
-0.0111195175,
-0.0269821696,
0.0395079963,
-0.047194954,
-0.0505964011,
0.0142164314,
0.0180175062,
0.0646507964,
0.0329652503,
-0.0084844921,
0.0133703388,
0.0618591905,
0.001262077,
0.0001491824,
-0.0333085917,
-0.0275422931,
0.009544461,
0.0051905797,
-0.0614853464,
0.0097783385,
0.0114004277,
0.0870942548,
-0.0195170622,
-0.0181276016,
0.0268398225,
0.0198954083,
0.0380325019,
-0.0245925114,
0.0391404368,
0.0082302848,
-0.039860364,
0.0030418516,
0.0100177517,
-0.0379180685,
-0.0627219528,
0.0152553413,
0.0157652404,
0.0025598246,
-0.006565969,
-0.0079781385,
-0.0113357445,
0.0449689925,
-0.0355391391,
-0.0569761544,
0.1190787852,
0.0045901141,
0.0142156295,
-0.0549048744,
-0.0463718623,
0.0604474619,
-0.0518627614,
0.0143746762,
0.0547742769,
-0.0303329825,
-0.027068736,
-0.0262497365,
0.0171566531,
-0.037368957,
0.0090188831,
0.0160018597,
0.0161349177,
0.0112103252,
0.0223249048,
-0.0285578165,
0.0671996325,
-0.0858000517,
0.0168895926,
-0.0188273676,
0.003117159,
-0.0451016054,
-0.0081189666,
-0.0025767551,
0.0367743224,
0.0018027812,
0.0026818842,
-0.0227857344,
0.0486476012,
-0.0074045425,
0.0587680005,
-0.0555409603,
0.0059006549,
-0.0287306532,
-0.0315062143,
-0.0483497903,
-0.0066454322,
-0.025778845,
-0.0193693172,
-0.0092548775,
-0.057611879,
-0.0057654581,
0.0173748899,
-0.0030887213,
-0.0167758986,
-0.0110805295,
0.054236915,
0.0173131172,
0.0002729491,
-0.06234961,
-0.0651663169,
0.0007810232,
-0.0340949856,
0.0265002865,
-0.0457099304,
-0.0092060715,
-0.0446154587,
0.0081782434,
-0.0028673082,
-0.0128372423,
0.0035324856,
0.052855812,
0.0473995581,
0.02550775,
-0.0210423339,
-0.0218029637,
-0.0216630455,
0.0383179262,
-0.0012809616,
0.0978327617,
0.0376472063,
-0.0034254051,
0.0232484844,
-0.0054295347,
0.0154238269,
-0.0264536254,
-0.0519321002,
-0.0541420355,
-0.0044317339,
-0.0099699749,
-0.0304193906,
-0.0390458852,
0.0231712312,
0.0038443569,
-0.0241225362,
-0.0318340659,
-0.0172773693,
0.0454648584,
0.0153837232,
0.0844062939,
-0.0198347997,
0.0002769609,
-0.0168573521,
-0.0006588847,
0.0506821796,
0.0174848828,
-0.0119059673,
-0.0540104099,
0.0097677913,
-0.0322652571,
-0.0788099915,
0.0265233256,
-0.0401421078,
0.0125025148,
-0.0228496492,
0.0613489412,
0.0093598682,
-0.0652196258,
0.1069659144,
0.0059984396,
-0.0084733432,
-0.0158415753,
-0.0380128436,
0.0258645024,
0.0592733584,
0.0596630983,
-0.0482950769,
-0.0382910967,
-0.0216441117,
-0.0276510827,
0.0213335268,
0.0272437595,
-0.0185124055,
0.0309804864,
-0.0203537252,
-0.0256476365,
-0.0019098938,
0.0201358255,
-0.0119781001,
0.0420387089,
0.0185970105,
0.0349141583,
-0.0417975001,
-0.0051605036,
0.0286553483,
-0.0082914969,
-0.003239474,
0.0610312782,
0.0542393103,
0.0350882858,
0.0129340002,
0.0098517537,
0.0255199187,
0.033711046,
-0.0332221389,
-0.0058614318,
0.0432784222,
-0.0495214984,
-0.0381672494,
0.0392531678,
-0.0499060042,
-0.0258924216,
0.0671792403,
-0.0542114824,
-0.045447167,
0.0410776027,
-0.0757745802,
0.0217341427,
0.000532688,
-0.0376026966,
0.0125487912,
-0.0149203828,
0.0099039264,
0.0345402658,
-0.0198126454,
-0.0560679883,
-0.0183059108,
-0.0239824317,
0.0285871327,
0.0048043942,
-0.035535682,
-0.0147669762,
-0.0389240906,
-0.0035617084,
0.0358991213,
-0.0111700958,
-0.0036227664,
-0.0189093687,
-0.0333090127,
0.0340437368,
-0.0021044386,
0.0047781551,
-0.0092202164,
-0.0137790525,
0.0585916154,
0.0000917383,
-0.014349862,
-0.0118817249,
-0.0166125186,
-0.0265830681,
0.0401959457,
0.0394963399,
-0.0856880918,
-0.0062434394,
-0.0341713578,
-0.0789401233,
0.0518607832,
-0.0169353709,
0.0107179182,
-0.0200475082,
-0.0155935781,
0.0033404706,
0.021031538,
-0.0280291513,
0.0093186153,
0.0323358588,
-0.0230890661,
-0.0233204532,
0.0623567142,
0.0197984464,
0.0619476847,
0.0459793434,
-0.0147130247,
-0.0029050026,
0.045127362,
-0.0377995186,
0.024961561,
-0.008856521,
-0.0151871322,
0.0344798043,
0.0396676213,
-0.0269710086,
0.0342305526,
-0.0752146021,
-0.0354113281,
-0.0024149057,
-0.0086458344,
0.0475731194,
0.0070071626,
-0.0110491356,
0.0526386388,
-0.0225754064,
-0.036004696,
0.053460069,
0.0061997445,
-0.0156871714,
0.0177231524,
-0.0203324147,
-0.0487964526,
0.048340477,
0.0290655866,
0.0215368923,
0.0030398248,
-0.0164065864,
-0.017037807,
0.000017181,
0.0109451944,
-0.0319829434,
0.0502393954,
-0.0469300188,
0.0198462885,
0.0243217908,
-0.0083833858,
-0.048549179,
-0.0178102702,
-0.0037718313,
0.0199118145,
-0.0732291415,
-0.0093660755,
-0.0454312488,
0.0133614494,
-0.0414956547,
0.0242460016,
0.0513962731,
-0.0196535829,
-0.0483174659,
-0.0253174752,
0.0604604073,
-0.0179632697,
0.0156517904,
-0.0122004328,
0.0047505242,
-0.0007641354,
0.0458461158,
0.0208939668,
-0.1243324131,
-0.0030293632,
-0.0276710764,
-0.0022983178,
0.0445770584,
0.0642756745,
-0.0495536476,
-0.063781403,
-0.0294659883,
0.0573024489,
0.013480166,
0.0018860365,
0.0047702626,
0.0510226339,
0.0065293708,
-0.0088900281,
0.0188079588,
-0.0908610001,
-0.0056152539,
0.0253851432,
-0.0047653327,
-0.0253519919,
-0.0323864259,
-0.015038209,
-0.0829123929,
-0.0022665283,
-0.0003951617,
0.0067120469,
-0.0338338464,
-0.0257544648,
-0.0472060926,
-0.0110272849,
-0.0091232127,
0.0121279256,
0.0112295831,
-0.0252916627,
0.0142014185,
-0.0955191478,
-0.0529604293,
0.0468876883,
0.0071046436,
0.0156214247,
0.0571646206,
-0.0003366339,
-0.030265186,
-0.0494587682,
0.0165956579,
0.0820858851,
-0.0242965352,
-0.0098859323,
0.0097225131,
0.0064492398,
-0.0139559694,
0.0072629731,
0.0251179729,
-0.0710803568,
-0.0250206795,
-0.0051964619,
0.1147511229,
-0.0235541519,
-0.0058058091,
-0.0295260623,
-0.0391525738,
-0.0045312792,
0.0411963575,
-0.013649486,
0.0095139807,
-0.0463244356,
-0.0181705412,
-0.0068730651,
-0.0828478336,
-0.0377592333,
-0.0114264414,
0.0070745177,
-0.0139574781,
-0.0308101699,
-0.009871983,
-0.0055325441,
0.0110464208,
0.0040689376,
-0.0627435893,
0.0938866138,
0.0012169039,
-0.1138853729,
0.0049879821,
-0.0325485021,
0.0533365272,
-0.0327589512,
0.0281495713,
-0.0109322043,
0.0401607566,
-0.0382695347,
0.0423310958,
-0.078578487,
-0.0166796464,
-0.0044082426,
0.0271157809,
0.0109972414,
0.0087790294,
-0.0359928422,
0.0578973107,
0.0122332815,
0.0260374434,
0.0084251221,
-0.0290832166,
0.0619990714,
-0.0517336614,
-0.0121690808,
0.0054244664,
-0.0545672178,
0.0106262928,
-0.0278225578,
0.0099947387,
-0.0203467961,
-0.0163314939,
0.0356939062,
-0.0185065679,
0.0351211876,
0.0472892188,
-0.0275099315,
-0.0134594273,
0.0312105622,
0.0147635043,
0.0195527207,
-0.0660120472,
0.0428889506,
0.0179055072,
-0.0111763468,
0.0149873104,
0.0056660813,
0.0635923669,
0.003101472,
0.0467137396,
0.0092283804,
-0.0038337901,
0.0260864627,
0.0176836252,
-0.0126649961,
-0.0204806756,
-0.0000669104,
0.01765793,
0.0284497868,
0.0031761169,
-0.008898613,
0.0370156728,
0.0585581139,
-0.0399523526,
-0.0079733245,
-0.0477718823,
-0.0248511229,
0.0086068194,
-0.0300855935,
0.0261849351,
0.0032754657,
0.0216040388,
-0.0339366607,
0.0368627273,
-0.0306033902,
0.0633889884,
0.0193388741,
0.0079554422,
0.0013906067,
0.0198261775,
-0.0095254742,
-0.0266175419,
0.0647924766,
-0.0103627257,
0.075474523,
-0.0199590661,
-0.0038084828,
-0.0636970624,
-0.0391840525,
-0.0926332101,
-0.0213938542,
-0.0088041015,
-0.0091620712,
-0.0464404412,
-0.0366596542,
0.0515492707,
0.0366826691,
0.0394414812,
0.0317664929,
-0.0041324254,
0.0534318052,
0.0497623272,
-0.045111008,
-0.0111694848,
-0.0270618666,
0.0155613516,
0.0025072363,
-0.028171584,
-6.056063141e-33,
-0.0269890949,
-0.0121477311,
0.0312789418,
0.0410377383,
-0.0127857551,
0.0084871203,
-0.0691801682,
-0.0374142788,
-0.0057987594,
0.0077120401,
0.0330953039,
0.0447504148,
0.0126912156,
0.0063638161,
0.0377122909,
-0.0054278476,
0.0787743479,
0.0192609839,
-0.0020394861,
0.0206626765,
0.0512927435,
-0.0180473346,
0.0121788029,
-0.0399804264,
-0.0001676265,
-0.0019391067,
-0.0074743554,
0.0516009293,
-0.0421209224,
0.0911364704,
-0.001449829,
-0.0068976302,
0.0209449753,
-0.0386835448,
-0.008310941,
0.0032868292,
-0.0842546225,
-0.0278923195,
-0.0384604409,
0.0070948494,
-0.0327973925,
-0.0529399551,
0.0215847604,
0.0330043063,
-0.0096283751,
-0.0211278144,
0.0381984711,
-0.0022832914,
0.0119615383,
-0.0521824993,
-0.0158330537,
0.0340102091,
-0.0354962163,
-0.0140859019,
0.0281359572,
0.0786536857,
0.0246412642,
-0.0307804253,
-0.0319734067,
0.0368657,
-0.0120121818,
0.0034734115,
0.0559260584,
-0.0004740508,
-0.0033462802,
0.0282183513,
-0.0199732482,
0.0142933223,
-0.0244737286,
0.0437996946,
0.0258451402,
0.0659298748,
-0.013571267,
-0.0398090445,
0.0328626446,
0.0025325483,
-0.0725196972,
0.0322580673,
0.01276989,
0.1193896607,
0.0341236331,
-0.0223739222,
-0.0397950672,
0.0153500382,
0.0010469988,
0.0508646108,
-0.0187027697,
0.0116280718,
0.0345529392,
0.0505604818,
-0.0251121093,
0.0161090661,
0.0284458995,
-0.0466134585,
0.022818191,
0.0126392394,
0.0040409821,
-0.0184171535,
-0.0059578978,
0.0473874658,
0.0010196553,
-0.0374393873,
-0.0043602078,
-0.0486563928,
0.0499499068,
-0.0104330843,
0.0109205572,
0.0732011199,
-0.0357779488,
0.0082187783,
-0.0427623875,
-0.0032761784,
0.0046130116,
0.0078075984,
0.0473991819,
0.016815016,
-0.0247706063,
0.0331739187,
-0.0455194339,
0.0053761178,
-0.0246112403,
0.0698060691,
0.0450404994,
0.0427574627,
-0.0169655252,
-0.0778727829,
-0.0538275316,
0.0604871325,
0.0330995247,
-0.0312664583,
-0.0127242431,
0.0083701378,
2.878e-7,
-0.0182998832,
0.0044441801,
0.058057107,
0.0575543754,
0.0295137782,
0.0426056795,
0.003899249,
-0.0234509595,
-0.0546912141,
-0.0170002971,
0.0175123103,
0.0107198013,
0.06628979,
0.0356694683,
0.0039057366,
-0.0061924458,
-0.0177522339,
-0.030616194,
-0.0259970352,
-0.0194442589,
0.0870489702,
0.0760709196,
0.0455805883,
-0.0043779379,
0.0456793196,
-0.057731986,
0.0427703857,
0.0327010565,
0.0088642556,
0.0259603895,
0.0254463721,
0.0065158638,
0.0002296556,
-0.0096498635,
-0.0103999199,
0.0038120449,
-0.0743948594,
0.0690576807,
-0.0054494739,
-0.0354487039,
0.0100071495,
-0.0259032063,
-0.0140491836,
0.0170522761,
0.0582131036,
-0.0225846339,
0.0070840232,
-0.0513133928,
0.0032514986,
0.0300940722,
-0.0181713328,
0.0448389724,
0.0037609842,
-0.0286976937,
0.0002542131,
-0.0254659988,
0.020703312,
-0.0722727478,
-0.0066262218,
0.0093124053,
-0.0537864938,
0.022747295,
0.0025439407,
0.0114035727,
0.0131868264,
-0.0039709192,
0.0033872908,
2.834839166e-34,
0.0162072126,
0.0293127261,
-0.0142022911,
0.0401477739,
0.0339212008,
-0.0202631932,
-0.0442802571,
-0.0108272815,
0.0099495091,
-0.0568114221,
-0.0278597642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20906v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20906v1
|
Enhancing Vision Models for Text-Heavy Content Understanding and Interaction
| 2024-05-31T15:17:47 | 2024-05-31T15:17:47 |
Adithya TG, Adithya SK, Abhinav R Bharadwaj, Abhiram HA, Dr. Surabhi Narayan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Interacting and understanding with text heavy visual content with multiple
images is a major challenge for traditional vision models. This paper is on
enhancing vision models' capability to comprehend or understand and learn from
images containing a huge amount of textual information from the likes of
textbooks and research papers which contain multiple images like graphs, etc
and tables in them with different types of axes and scales. The approach
involves dataset preprocessing, fine tuning which is by using instructional
oriented data and evaluation. We also built a visual chat application
integrating CLIP for image encoding and a model from the Massive Text Embedding
Benchmark which is developed to consider both textual and visual inputs. An
accuracy of 96.71% was obtained. The aim of the project is to increase and also
enhance the advance vision models' capabilities in understanding complex visual
textual data interconnected data, contributing to multimodal AI.
|
[
0.0201948136,
-0.0166525245,
0.0017408999,
0.0760137811,
-0.0125266975,
0.0241737887,
-0.0127898632,
0.0432212241,
0.0581124686,
-0.0557920896,
-0.047908213,
0.0245841537,
0.0014838354,
0.0743684173,
0.0086200843,
-0.1010387689,
-0.0094972318,
-0.0121119982,
-0.0188845843,
0.0042913277,
0.0317974724,
-0.0129088163,
-0.0020913749,
-0.0010983557,
-0.0249832105,
-0.042279847,
-0.028216267,
0.0202075318,
0.0148289716,
-0.0375224538,
-0.0491526574,
0.022280328,
0.0575292334,
-0.0055500744,
0.0000020663,
-0.0015799591,
-0.0075175678,
0.0103291832,
0.0057713622,
-0.0010346894,
0.0974966139,
-0.0229497757,
0.0166769922,
-0.0294166505,
-0.0460822955,
0.0500954166,
0.0581404194,
0.0654165074,
0.0801759809,
0.0717986822,
-0.0322197266,
-0.0321259424,
0.0353391469,
0.0122547718,
0.0377650484,
-0.0291444305,
0.018025171,
0.0981566012,
0.0227906052,
0.0625469834,
-0.0651725456,
0.0419643223,
0.0111361947,
-0.0190531388,
0.0428529903,
0.0226799026,
-0.0319837667,
-0.0454458855,
-0.0255999714,
0.1101084873,
-0.051725857,
0.0138177369,
-0.0053520161,
-0.0163370632,
0.0056096963,
0.0241926722,
-0.0806828588,
-0.0295649786,
-0.0174209271,
-0.0061742784,
-0.0618158504,
0.0026170374,
-0.0216602385,
-0.0263824593,
-0.0180480871,
-0.070294112,
-0.0225693639,
0.0003670811,
-0.0218101945,
0.0052431952,
-0.0388074182,
-0.0119887395,
0.0195039753,
0.0294832904,
0.0139261978,
0.0245076101,
-0.0589694642,
-0.0528849922,
-0.0244905371,
-0.0777083635,
0.0329107456,
0.0242152289,
-0.0490400977,
0.0970001146,
-0.0370976068,
0.0534210354,
-0.0059758942,
0.0181911029,
-0.0056789862,
0.0210937858,
-0.0314400531,
0.0120250061,
-0.018380966,
0.0066760285,
-0.0564355552,
-0.0798929408,
-0.0168124586,
0.0300256703,
0.0023224801,
0.0594331957,
0.0142599363,
0.0093873385,
-0.0344807133,
-0.0136570828,
-0.0222512428,
0.0176634621,
0.0042225053,
-0.0066398918,
-0.0549652427,
-0.052054368,
0.0347047113,
0.022669794,
0.0810652748,
0.0045070504,
0.0019727538,
0.0732937008,
-0.0426032916,
-0.0523397475,
-0.0460896902,
-0.028252719,
0.0025842034,
-0.0227297898,
0.0348066725,
-0.0255180579,
0.0610004179,
-0.0212522987,
-0.0019225666,
-0.011141981,
0.0042583644,
0.0304105841,
-0.0616842136,
0.0854738653,
-0.0132743018,
-0.0007215179,
0.0464840308,
0.0367742628,
-0.028017547,
0.0675391704,
0.0306714177,
0.0454342403,
0.0548622273,
-0.0333794504,
0.0121824583,
0.0399318598,
0.0015709481,
-0.0181319229,
-0.021652285,
0.0303553157,
-0.0080224518,
0.0145970089,
-0.02999961,
0.0410237201,
-0.0644318685,
-0.0123500442,
0.0681042671,
0.0464184806,
-0.0047709993,
0.0122345872,
-0.004539269,
0.0500976183,
0.0600040331,
0.012943875,
-0.0128597487,
0.0595811866,
0.0387224257,
-0.0025498525,
0.0169004053,
0.0366875716,
-0.0034774921,
-0.0370786376,
0.0106678195,
-0.0056279278,
0.004324689,
-0.0019508117,
0.0713042915,
-0.0052291132,
-0.0675428286,
-0.061344143,
0.0013477817,
-0.0513128154,
-0.0297981985,
-0.0003618325,
-0.0079447897,
0.0398675799,
0.0547693707,
-0.0235959347,
-0.0231055096,
-0.0080212951,
0.0323280506,
0.0260211807,
0.0132348752,
-0.0137239685,
0.0080730449,
-0.088535428,
-0.0477703661,
-0.0004461233,
-0.0338098258,
0.010027118,
0.0118358945,
0.0191732813,
0.0134550259,
0.0071799401,
-0.0476976261,
0.0487850904,
0.0170627795,
-0.0031443969,
-0.0516286381,
0.0255534127,
-0.0014920778,
0.0269730184,
-0.0184114445,
-0.0215333607,
0.0310780965,
0.0095391748,
0.0309213325,
0.0208992176,
-0.018414095,
-0.0103319343,
0.0199699551,
-0.0804133862,
-0.006597552,
-0.0285859499,
-0.0275541805,
-0.0419475287,
-0.0098661724,
-0.0156018175,
-0.0016482195,
0.0246806834,
0.0066958708,
-0.0250291303,
0.0357851684,
-0.0072558215,
0.0579952598,
0.0074281511,
0.0259862281,
0.0260649119,
-0.0108774975,
0.0358385146,
-0.0091705332,
-0.0316838734,
-0.0090615172,
-0.0209106971,
0.0075527984,
0.0028050323,
0.0027606329,
-0.0496531241,
0.0113082696,
-0.0793888941,
-0.0340267792,
0.0175194833,
-0.0075315996,
0.0049993633,
-0.0188169517,
-0.013926208,
-0.0661579967,
-0.0102476655,
0.0738999844,
-0.0329773799,
0.0005939557,
0.0072179353,
-0.0019936766,
0.0241506044,
-0.0228568912,
-0.0025245855,
-0.0031086083,
0.0638071448,
0.0714405477,
-0.0332722366,
-0.0162509214,
0.0271195583,
0.0127618629,
0.0285164062,
-0.0117371827,
-0.0287658982,
0.0079567516,
0.0008448348,
0.0350109041,
0.1258555502,
-0.0208639391,
0.0763096213,
-0.0067866673,
-0.0136973159,
-0.0425531194,
0.0164638106,
-0.0024761667,
0.0486902297,
-0.008189843,
-0.0113148615,
-0.030196229,
-0.0091182105,
-0.012433392,
0.0228129141,
-0.0262196027,
0.0076630851,
0.007551536,
-0.0053623356,
-0.0524492562,
0.0110330367,
0.0140855657,
-0.0109958379,
-0.0292827692,
-0.0252049416,
0.0137932329,
-0.0417209752,
-0.0183060337,
-0.0012948165,
0.0142433951,
-0.0151414974,
0.0831857622,
0.0387860946,
0.0231293421,
-0.036823187,
0.0088534029,
-0.0643625632,
0.0169061292,
0.0480655022,
-0.0248552077,
0.0091120852,
-0.0207473505,
-0.0158875044,
-0.0425673239,
-0.0021720696,
-0.0055065248,
0.0012922975,
-0.0170662347,
-0.043892011,
0.022433592,
-0.0288836323,
-0.083447665,
0.0109723248,
0.0164538417,
0.0120534617,
-0.0123572266,
-0.0279696882,
-0.0117967399,
0.0492042489,
0.0313395038,
-0.0024009531,
-0.0691665635,
-0.0385283977,
0.0516761877,
0.0668954253,
-0.0437908061,
-0.0376236029,
-0.0539295152,
0.0105651943,
-0.0133453561,
0.0264393557,
0.0065836594,
-0.0126990806,
0.0089461496,
-0.0512248948,
0.0282840133,
0.0468447432,
0.0296805669,
-0.0484170318,
-0.0384700596,
-0.0212988816,
-0.0023333805,
0.0081408862,
0.0392273553,
-0.1072273254,
-0.0231166203,
-0.0275673103,
-0.0539529435,
0.0157088526,
-0.0201373268,
-0.025199065,
-0.0643062741,
0.0354286022,
0.0133928023,
0.0131512731,
-0.0368897393,
-0.0151695795,
0.0259437095,
-0.0120528284,
-0.0272244979,
-0.024760969,
-0.0290153585,
-0.0199444909,
0.0068259197,
0.0256594364,
-0.0261835344,
-0.043474175,
-0.010629355,
-0.0236951113,
0.007106612,
0.068141371,
-0.0017200587,
-0.0257284287,
0.0161450747,
0.0555888191,
0.0062513533,
-0.0194182526,
0.1092148796,
-0.0386587344,
-0.0316822045,
-0.0295483544,
0.0112859048,
0.0425381958,
-0.0125669958,
0.0014661204,
0.0361732095,
-0.008761676,
-0.008673707,
-0.0551886708,
-0.0242176559,
-0.0234758295,
0.0215621982,
0.0028665122,
-0.0208025221,
-0.0212554205,
-0.0077015124,
0.0084230127,
-0.0256094411,
-0.0168834832,
0.0437864251,
-0.0339733846,
-0.0189033467,
-0.0720162466,
0.0048461761,
0.0447335579,
0.0279898569,
0.0009715272,
-0.0169573408,
0.0142254597,
0.0343237109,
-0.0371244177,
0.0227904413,
-0.0114639234,
-0.0022734422,
-0.0381446481,
0.0211267099,
0.0131229386,
-0.0537232943,
-0.035708975,
-0.0066936039,
-0.0449523404,
-0.025636794,
-0.0413362458,
0.0383842923,
0.0141174719,
0.0464043319,
0.0087164231,
-0.0468484014,
0.0431412496,
0.051027026,
-0.0204652883,
-0.0282714199,
0.0022106813,
-0.0162147749,
-0.0095578404,
-0.0228579175,
-0.0313523971,
0.0257208869,
-0.0166429561,
-0.0365160294,
-0.0052704476,
-0.0445230007,
-0.0214906707,
0.0117478482,
-0.002671696,
0.0295405574,
-0.0144391209,
-0.0189092327,
0.0217884835,
-0.0285910759,
-0.0280216914,
-0.0448175296,
0.0216179378,
0.015168407,
-0.0021920244,
-0.0117007438,
0.0130235394,
0.0340918824,
-0.0175381489,
-0.0440961868,
0.0319718942,
0.0190921295,
-0.0474746898,
0.008122432,
0.010491401,
0.0076379944,
-0.0008304745,
-0.0354340598,
0.0100680115,
0.0188184865,
0.0751152337,
0.0134630352,
-0.0648913085,
0.004279423,
0.0404363833,
-0.0542427227,
-0.0089795785,
-0.0405039489,
0.0534975454,
0.0422163941,
0.0149185099,
0.0139120603,
-0.0247467905,
0.0078158742,
-0.0064221118,
0.0430879928,
0.015049614,
-0.0128783733,
0.069083035,
0.0059187701,
0.0223993193,
-0.0042483117,
0.0651593283,
0.0016659595,
-0.0163587127,
0.0267256796,
-0.0497841835,
-0.0430452004,
0.0170096401,
0.0636563823,
0.0139884325,
0.0062200702,
0.038026724,
0.0194676034,
-0.0476323813,
-0.0042817453,
0.0366293006,
-0.0179036353,
0.02717668,
0.0508863367,
0.0458119176,
0.0415090472,
0.027933836,
-0.005361998,
0.0235086996,
-0.0484456867,
-0.0167824049,
0.0185195673,
-5.858323318e-33,
-0.002395812,
-0.0498758107,
0.0069537819,
0.0333707929,
-0.0146228857,
0.0069814203,
-0.0162810963,
-0.0031992905,
-0.0293167252,
0.012583185,
0.0061571836,
0.0167441852,
0.0134914471,
0.0338572673,
-0.0329536907,
0.0225251596,
0.0076408638,
-0.0177167561,
0.0135222282,
0.0121903894,
0.0037274812,
0.0368986577,
0.0136423912,
-0.0678988993,
-0.0172774829,
0.0034740902,
-0.0011650837,
-0.0354968011,
0.0417216569,
0.0697348118,
-0.0638108104,
0.0134502258,
0.0362020992,
-0.0042219921,
-0.0171476472,
0.0703253672,
-0.0757349432,
-0.0434391797,
-0.0069034426,
0.064815864,
-0.0707784668,
0.012004666,
0.05842904,
-0.0565503761,
0.0237488002,
-0.040589653,
0.070670791,
-0.0289724488,
-0.0275387112,
0.0173600521,
-0.0478694662,
0.0568130538,
-0.0299182124,
-0.0329183191,
0.0783342347,
0.0468425639,
0.0688879639,
0.0260861572,
-0.0458864458,
0.0114774881,
-0.0192004535,
-0.0154479016,
0.0715732276,
0.0099190734,
0.0277341139,
0.0522991233,
-0.0003457214,
-0.0291497204,
-0.0180235822,
-0.0440795049,
0.0248746518,
0.0909136236,
0.0485009663,
0.0423776023,
0.0231102612,
-0.0096438918,
-0.0251996908,
0.0453586876,
-0.0126570947,
0.0361347198,
0.0215736404,
-0.010928697,
-0.0363483801,
0.0220073909,
0.006218777,
0.0091400836,
-0.0507919639,
-0.027777236,
0.025476452,
0.0019037165,
0.0274549928,
0.0374413617,
0.0420937575,
-0.0494513661,
-0.0204628352,
0.0215892177,
-0.0181237403,
0.0984461457,
-0.015560803,
-0.0286472142,
-0.0126507804,
-0.0473926775,
0.0396271423,
-0.0176758971,
0.0104926955,
-0.0036225608,
0.0562482774,
-0.0104580745,
-0.0089487135,
-0.0213536285,
-0.0203386918,
-0.0571946539,
0.0317774117,
0.0477241129,
0.0326629989,
0.007820921,
-0.0643435717,
0.0541111082,
-0.0012586159,
0.0428819172,
-0.0305902846,
-0.0750876367,
0.0067753419,
-0.0068078204,
-0.0095052486,
-0.0170825031,
-0.0471539423,
-0.0229045618,
0.0084791165,
-0.0842240378,
-0.0187065247,
0.0326615311,
2.658e-7,
0.0292019788,
0.0666103661,
0.0270155761,
-0.0016109266,
0.0187467635,
0.0394573621,
-0.0066231457,
0.0216694064,
-0.0061917505,
-0.0212069266,
0.0350433663,
0.0370531753,
0.0194223821,
-0.0073824842,
-0.033853177,
-0.0524088629,
-0.0478366204,
-0.0660128593,
-0.0546952672,
0.0286524799,
0.0894754305,
0.0599029325,
-0.0175177362,
-0.0057092384,
0.0074637714,
-0.0305925291,
0.065720275,
-0.0337063111,
0.0246050619,
-0.0087853223,
0.0081129828,
0.0527239069,
-0.0366790891,
0.0345899984,
-0.0168720465,
0.0185501892,
0.0404136181,
0.0032535675,
-0.0381241031,
0.0726382732,
0.0381416455,
0.0068300143,
-0.0150824767,
-0.0393562242,
0.0798764825,
-0.06009176,
-0.0490511358,
-0.0007639447,
-0.0380499102,
-0.0076238466,
0.0020533388,
0.0003584073,
-0.0197295863,
0.0160104651,
0.0245595444,
-0.0511575788,
-0.021059623,
-0.0744529068,
0.0006559307,
-0.0034672299,
-0.0021435046,
-0.0111876521,
-0.0723132119,
-0.0358865894,
0.0440187268,
0.0121823512,
-0.0301251933,
2.198082371e-34,
0.0179747865,
-0.0287749395,
0.0178091582,
0.0194887053,
0.0373536535,
-0.023067873,
0.0062307566,
0.0048579518,
0.0013553256,
-0.101575084,
-0.0063766832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20902v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20902v1
|
Preemptive Answer "Attacks" on Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-05-31T15:15:04 | 2024-05-31T15:15:04 |
Rongwu Xu, Zehan Qi, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
Large language models (LLMs) showcase impressive reasoning capabilities when
coupled with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting. However, the robustness of this
approach warrants further investigation. In this paper, we introduce a novel
scenario termed preemptive answers, where the LLM obtains an answer before
engaging in reasoning. This situation can arise inadvertently or induced by
malicious users by prompt injection attacks. Experiments reveal that preemptive
answers significantly impair the model's reasoning capability across various
CoT methods and a broad spectrum of datasets. To bolster the robustness of
reasoning, we propose two measures aimed at mitigating this issue to some
extent.
|
[
0.0573193766,
0.0720091909,
-0.016328359,
0.0281665642,
-0.0391484275,
0.016036639,
0.0311174113,
-0.0209787581,
0.0231589191,
-0.0492497161,
-0.0093144746,
-0.0508066453,
0.0106427111,
0.0043787146,
0.0366728455,
-0.0026749473,
0.0578573048,
-0.0766315013,
0.0139496513,
-0.0418616459,
-0.0062208422,
-0.000401547,
-0.0114039853,
0.0269784853,
0.0125249298,
-0.03188207,
-0.0280854739,
-0.0108585674,
0.0021857452,
-0.0519249476,
-0.0040371781,
0.0864278674,
-0.0152904242,
0.0583217442,
0.0000019165,
-0.0903337523,
-0.020856075,
0.0022139715,
-0.066365391,
0.0186192766,
-0.0536381826,
0.0355166942,
0.0202125832,
0.0643263683,
-0.0301688146,
0.0209613796,
0.0106177004,
0.0411433578,
0.0531733744,
0.050275337,
0.0030980352,
-0.0017150632,
0.0138433324,
-0.0013187544,
0.0042821974,
-0.0441522412,
0.0316820964,
-0.0329370275,
-0.0027728982,
0.0204626508,
-0.0185102317,
0.0270531848,
0.0193840303,
0.0002464164,
-0.0395877622,
0.0254292767,
-0.0258402135,
-0.0382568575,
-0.0349739417,
0.060904447,
0.0046297428,
-0.0151294237,
0.0005097425,
-0.008015329,
0.011073201,
0.0392017812,
-0.0213675294,
0.0260434281,
-0.0074282661,
-0.0157706682,
0.0052511403,
0.0104172081,
0.0342893749,
0.0097533353,
-0.0376663953,
0.0784838647,
0.0129183633,
-0.0394569524,
0.0135563957,
0.0026577215,
-0.0039004909,
-0.0929302126,
-0.0307539441,
0.0505355373,
-0.0507277139,
0.0098996703,
-0.0269432031,
-0.0192216672,
0.0282840971,
-0.02637266,
0.0211943891,
0.0432896093,
-0.0189489983,
0.0333948918,
-0.0263775792,
0.0091246823,
-0.04093064,
0.0209645163,
-0.0030659994,
-0.003790037,
-0.0198784191,
-0.0302388519,
-0.0018510298,
0.0465148725,
0.0086346818,
0.0143503137,
-0.0059807547,
0.0451108478,
-0.0170419607,
0.0083657047,
-0.0356589183,
0.013627517,
0.038273029,
-0.0091154845,
-0.0538310483,
0.0141239539,
-0.0234003533,
0.0300712623,
-0.0010326835,
-0.0627113581,
-0.018440105,
-0.0125948135,
-0.0155745354,
-0.0255655758,
0.0130438348,
0.0741725639,
0.0009523645,
-0.0194534548,
-0.0356233194,
-0.0806197822,
-0.0114279548,
-0.065411225,
0.0002470971,
-0.0676668808,
0.0214360896,
0.034249723,
-0.0324990936,
-0.0045189061,
0.0048089828,
0.0399945341,
-0.0622348972,
0.0648426712,
-0.0066780499,
0.0194623638,
0.0019752316,
0.0360725075,
-0.0230448283,
0.0419582613,
0.0031516934,
0.0163482688,
0.0449159704,
0.0063212402,
0.0273013636,
0.0277940501,
0.0494792201,
0.0199952703,
0.0263455976,
0.0583945401,
-0.0064630117,
-0.0278944336,
-0.0294381958,
0.0472565144,
-0.0152173396,
-0.0162722412,
0.0865354314,
0.0755226091,
-0.0628387257,
0.0108273886,
0.0158708058,
-0.008371071,
-0.0028202171,
0.0299590174,
-0.0778592601,
0.0221595522,
-0.0774443746,
-0.0130664036,
0.0430978946,
0.0190891251,
-0.0200080108,
-0.0195244029,
0.0035879768,
0.0060573532,
0.0010780859,
0.0813153759,
0.0068969373,
0.0032327736,
0.0040691141,
0.0393180661,
-0.0060154446,
-0.0054031671,
-0.0125373313,
-0.0769528002,
0.0120113539,
0.0332348458,
0.0482073165,
0.010435814,
-0.0008718589,
-0.0309990942,
0.0396111272,
0.0248782914,
0.0116499197,
0.0032978524,
-0.0033129544,
0.0080051878,
-0.032828778,
0.028798854,
0.0010041978,
-0.0048294473,
0.0150251715,
0.0007287062,
-0.0038928362,
0.0425247476,
0.019577235,
0.0078085214,
0.0022149922,
-0.0279280655,
-0.0020236238,
0.0276878495,
0.0215988476,
0.0003032273,
0.0066563361,
0.0273781102,
0.0113654518,
0.0266820937,
-0.0288912989,
-0.0136632612,
-0.0403738692,
0.0019235335,
0.0218545254,
0.0004768352,
-0.0591676868,
0.0063096015,
0.0008827673,
-0.0236294493,
-0.0107417228,
-0.0064064991,
0.0266492572,
-0.0326674469,
0.0099870302,
-0.0109732915,
0.0117883254,
-0.0282054748,
0.0596302338,
-0.0298524946,
0.0175617654,
0.0255263112,
0.0225357376,
0.0203614663,
-0.0159553699,
-0.0612214394,
0.0099237608,
-0.0172911379,
-0.0073289643,
0.0235102065,
-0.0208476558,
-0.0552655719,
0.0129627837,
-0.0778695792,
-0.0397438332,
-0.0057945065,
0.0291750692,
0.0127474172,
0.0118045658,
-0.0270074159,
-0.008066819,
-0.055190634,
-0.0096840281,
0.0218157619,
0.0623516999,
0.0271712672,
-0.0064086644,
-0.00960718,
0.0005317669,
-0.0047393297,
-0.0449753962,
0.0516010858,
-0.0083972747,
-0.0262103584,
-0.0342103019,
0.023248395,
-0.0414542854,
0.0277697742,
-0.0042646965,
-0.0189820379,
0.0345548131,
0.0033300973,
0.0376658961,
0.0572210327,
0.0358459391,
-0.0362230651,
0.0818939134,
-0.0040688915,
-0.0347261913,
0.0042633615,
-0.0196270142,
-0.0425589345,
-0.0115278624,
-0.0235412586,
-0.0047869482,
0.0680891722,
0.030851407,
-0.034602806,
-0.0328703448,
0.0203977711,
-0.022244947,
-0.0429170318,
-0.0690501779,
-0.0560151413,
-0.0321419835,
0.0967408493,
0.0049233413,
-0.0448840745,
0.098321557,
-0.0443714634,
0.021033898,
-0.0193386637,
0.0069864294,
-0.0000873919,
0.0537257083,
-0.0002074972,
-0.0005013008,
0.0206331126,
0.0000624571,
-0.0795577988,
-0.0411151461,
0.0217795968,
-0.0403519012,
0.03491918,
-0.0228492357,
-0.00851845,
-0.0272776522,
-0.0372060947,
-0.0668432862,
-0.0864436701,
-0.0431081951,
-0.0293384343,
-0.0074849627,
-0.0269073881,
0.026550062,
-0.0275527891,
0.0413242951,
-0.0075957379,
-0.0434996188,
-0.0273430198,
-0.0148937432,
0.0424729586,
0.080641672,
-0.0025975253,
0.0550423451,
-0.0175292641,
0.0463083349,
0.0924466178,
0.0596065037,
0.0004920634,
0.0108206728,
-0.0041537257,
0.0286712237,
0.0229652654,
-0.0158184003,
0.0554951318,
0.0224147644,
-0.0200942215,
-0.0190731883,
0.1013386697,
0.0473369993,
-0.0420313664,
-0.0049343905,
-0.0418247096,
0.0635267571,
0.0121971173,
0.0154286819,
-0.078184925,
-0.0281511936,
0.0278829038,
0.019632034,
-0.0440547541,
-0.0535206236,
-0.0297800209,
-0.1173748747,
0.0070655774,
-0.0342518538,
0.0171668082,
0.0165423304,
-0.0344395563,
-0.0005091602,
0.0506157391,
0.0188126266,
0.0099712107,
0.0018437757,
0.0044683628,
0.0268483032,
-0.0184754208,
-0.000087896,
0.0641703159,
-0.0301368553,
0.0374658443,
0.0482218117,
-0.0104055582,
0.0068068588,
-0.0287149437,
0.0534950048,
-0.0440265499,
-0.0208926331,
-0.0046201707,
0.0226378441,
-0.009332126,
0.0103170732,
-0.0236004945,
0.0443470962,
-0.0196192656,
-0.0171449967,
0.0469991304,
0.1023299247,
-0.0393598042,
0.0011311369,
-0.0315221548,
0.0087389341,
0.0137447529,
0.0734643042,
0.023338398,
-0.0639032051,
-0.0297457743,
-0.0447177775,
-0.0448968895,
-0.0047139311,
-0.0638061911,
0.0207658522,
0.0486804247,
0.0167967137,
-0.0462180711,
-0.051589258,
-0.0052285665,
0.0314647704,
0.0037325665,
0.0175007973,
-0.0113090519,
0.0288825482,
-0.0032169102,
0.0104841664,
-0.0527482778,
0.0380534381,
-0.0501457974,
0.0596486814,
-0.0086449627,
-0.0260703769,
-0.0220913291,
0.0215412043,
-0.0756674856,
-0.0673791245,
-0.0119362036,
0.0482195728,
0.0356094539,
0.0278800577,
-0.0355060734,
-0.0576820821,
0.0641189516,
0.0117216241,
-0.0200023632,
0.0061760368,
0.0470591299,
0.0082947994,
0.006622226,
0.033163283,
-0.0410747901,
-0.0247042272,
0.0376721919,
0.0200660191,
-0.0062542339,
-0.0375894606,
0.0078250961,
0.0381401144,
0.0677083135,
0.0024735921,
0.0139850546,
-0.0021590947,
0.0404545665,
-0.0216618758,
-0.0319669619,
0.0047592721,
0.0144257247,
0.003832622,
-0.0070844591,
0.0134142051,
-0.0506391004,
-0.0028554872,
0.0193979256,
0.0221964531,
0.019146001,
0.0511523001,
0.0535426252,
0.0539579764,
0.0001303911,
-0.0159103647,
0.0260191839,
0.0462868735,
0.0367617793,
-0.0016155229,
0.081600748,
0.0159834456,
-0.0275877323,
-0.0104232803,
0.0162273254,
-0.1115062311,
-0.0745356157,
0.0235126037,
0.003821013,
-0.008543429,
-0.0024452289,
-0.0031564087,
-0.0096174907,
-0.0001721773,
-0.0107821561,
-0.0072354618,
0.0175713114,
-0.0404447764,
0.0412073918,
0.008519073,
-0.0114473645,
0.0341746621,
0.0690752938,
-0.0027209148,
0.0224895161,
0.0098356269,
-0.0439082682,
-0.0052536074,
-0.0368322507,
-0.045750577,
0.0045956052,
-0.0338953063,
0.0000728152,
-0.0997542366,
-0.0925883129,
-0.0332477987,
-0.0110637322,
0.0208981056,
0.0037668222,
0.0050844648,
0.0574513562,
0.0432410389,
0.0005024267,
-0.0428142436,
0.0452567562,
-0.0144430436,
-0.026216872,
-0.009975451,
-6.338746023e-33,
0.0165090002,
-0.0687021837,
0.004743658,
-0.009238611,
0.0205399655,
0.008108492,
-0.0249754936,
0.0304339714,
-0.050733272,
-0.0090791648,
-0.0531129315,
0.0087140063,
0.0036999695,
0.0315684192,
-0.0027393983,
-0.0403261818,
-0.0172866266,
-0.0365490429,
-0.0359339379,
0.0152985156,
0.0761459097,
-0.0105042038,
-0.0191284828,
-0.0299821887,
0.0522134341,
-0.028903814,
0.0134316403,
0.0220070891,
-0.0736684725,
0.0613205247,
-0.0185024813,
0.0439613983,
0.0178698394,
-0.0229551736,
-0.0014277357,
0.0693533942,
-0.0458399132,
-0.0416798107,
0.0275280327,
-0.0249645486,
-0.0242674407,
-0.0056531373,
-0.0208136849,
-0.0100305835,
-0.0037716653,
-0.0361445621,
-0.0001357067,
0.0095847342,
-0.0039866343,
-0.0297084115,
-0.0208281055,
-0.0020473192,
-0.0113014728,
-0.0078550717,
0.0164799429,
0.0780913457,
0.0174448211,
-0.0145980353,
-0.0288044475,
0.0227446463,
0.0243725721,
0.0128343794,
0.0614927858,
0.0005776394,
-0.0040066727,
0.0518122613,
-0.0037168353,
-0.0051956186,
-0.0430311114,
-0.0025532341,
-0.0067197755,
0.0011185243,
0.0828490704,
0.046202369,
0.0088825161,
0.0097158365,
-0.0785277784,
0.0106802145,
0.0134652061,
0.0195383355,
0.0542161949,
-0.0323769599,
-0.0352151431,
-0.026923053,
-0.0497268774,
-0.0164026618,
-0.0609302446,
-0.0190647282,
0.0393483862,
-0.0036033227,
-0.0171716157,
-0.0447597839,
0.060484942,
-0.0441320688,
-0.0317061506,
0.0480758324,
0.0050367606,
-0.0057556978,
0.0173635855,
0.0614724234,
-0.0232649669,
0.0354529768,
0.0021366824,
-0.0306370612,
0.0127819795,
-0.0041516442,
0.0143178208,
0.0075426647,
-0.0640832409,
-0.0186342709,
-0.0472007841,
0.0555055663,
-0.0030671444,
0.0132027753,
0.0612728,
0.0021818909,
-0.0007850655,
0.0204455592,
0.0193298161,
0.0047516888,
-0.0467911698,
0.0382137112,
-0.0239757374,
0.0127018159,
-0.0181576218,
0.0057945098,
-0.0116016474,
0.0343803242,
0.0020135301,
-0.0769538432,
0.0011573256,
0.0011717161,
2.64e-7,
0.0106371418,
0.0193622522,
0.002503369,
0.0246598516,
0.0285113286,
0.058387965,
-0.0140796024,
0.0329275467,
0.0422269925,
-0.05030635,
-0.0034733438,
-0.0046623675,
0.0273522399,
0.0530746169,
-0.0694217235,
-0.0337564871,
-0.0904635713,
0.0186100863,
-0.0479018912,
-0.0198203363,
0.0627066195,
0.0716686845,
-0.0052678296,
-0.0130773839,
-0.0231556054,
-0.0330290087,
0.0245796125,
-0.0142446663,
0.0189488828,
-0.0223488472,
0.0586225837,
-0.0130692907,
0.0437753871,
0.0597499534,
-0.0176471323,
-0.0007705327,
-0.0332817137,
0.0104292901,
0.0449312776,
-0.0533637479,
-0.0512623377,
-0.0400211066,
0.0252734609,
-0.0938358456,
0.1003909707,
-0.0354122929,
-0.0293943174,
-0.0162053797,
0.0039697518,
-0.0520805083,
0.0234247539,
-0.0047853487,
-0.0051119281,
0.0136987707,
0.0106880544,
0.0183439925,
0.0502025783,
-0.1035003811,
-0.0210156143,
0.0041346801,
-0.0008695215,
-0.0617511347,
-0.01938265,
0.0212150924,
0.0351453871,
-0.0339441039,
-0.0124748405,
2.590499349e-34,
-0.0002658524,
-0.0257700458,
0.0434767157,
0.0098695382,
0.0451520123,
-0.0039669476,
0.0287212133,
0.0036780389,
0.0601583309,
-0.0895067528,
-0.0423038714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20900v1
|
Large Language Models: A New Approach for Privacy Policy Analysis at Scale
| 2024-05-31T15:12:33 | 2024-05-31T15:12:33 |
David Rodriguez, Ian Yang, Jose M. Del Alamo, Norman Sadeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The number and dynamic nature of web and mobile applications presents
significant challenges for assessing their compliance with data protection
laws. In this context, symbolic and statistical Natural Language Processing
(NLP) techniques have been employed for the automated analysis of these
systems' privacy policies. However, these techniques typically require
labor-intensive and potentially error-prone manually annotated datasets for
training and validation. This research proposes the application of Large
Language Models (LLMs) as an alternative for effectively and efficiently
extracting privacy practices from privacy policies at scale. Particularly, we
leverage well-known LLMs such as ChatGPT and Llama 2, and offer guidance on the
optimal design of prompts, parameters, and models, incorporating advanced
strategies such as few-shot learning. We further illustrate its capability to
detect detailed and varied privacy practices accurately. Using several renowned
datasets in the domain as a benchmark, our evaluation validates its exceptional
performance, achieving an F1 score exceeding 93%. Besides, it does so with
reduced costs, faster processing times, and fewer technical knowledge
requirements. Consequently, we advocate for LLM-based solutions as a sound
alternative to traditional NLP techniques for the automated analysis of privacy
policies at scale.
|
[
0.0670403093,
0.0343622975,
-0.0456807129,
0.0280463025,
-0.0634235591,
-0.0071392981,
0.0629374981,
0.0078287385,
0.070422329,
-0.0768272057,
0.0065357382,
-0.0318249315,
-0.0102428673,
0.0015909064,
-0.0217563063,
-0.0217822883,
0.0153627545,
-0.0030764828,
0.0443115383,
0.0286039133,
-0.0119384555,
0.0204572305,
0.0385989211,
0.0519154742,
0.0345590003,
-0.0350140668,
0.0025421204,
-0.0144574502,
0.0070202844,
-0.0528554432,
-0.0009041185,
0.007412659,
0.0192961823,
0.0238984767,
0.0000017885,
-0.0927774161,
-0.008903618,
0.0603127591,
0.0062397793,
0.0886738375,
0.0354365297,
-0.0147155151,
-0.0054488294,
0.0187289547,
-0.0037934578,
0.0437251851,
0.0305835903,
0.0273283292,
0.068886131,
0.0668642446,
-0.0313793011,
-0.0425174944,
-0.001676278,
-0.0045159389,
0.0206614099,
-0.0496755429,
0.0651997253,
-0.0373327956,
-0.0036390731,
0.0025696435,
0.051156912,
0.0263463538,
0.0016807092,
0.0127942152,
-0.0433398224,
-0.0175916087,
-0.0314380936,
-0.02505913,
-0.0152114201,
0.0595325418,
0.0223116241,
0.0063294885,
0.0480171777,
-0.0322301649,
0.0195027739,
0.0385457426,
-0.0107499845,
0.0733160824,
-0.0460581593,
0.0049967961,
-0.0049216412,
0.0052027781,
0.037278641,
0.014712208,
-0.0260597132,
0.0438943729,
-0.007076683,
-0.0531676374,
0.0029369013,
-0.0671798959,
0.0137029886,
-0.0278586745,
0.0568129346,
0.0128989927,
0.0237081107,
0.0334637202,
-0.0227506272,
0.0111963479,
0.0814927593,
-0.0557403564,
0.0231760219,
0.0029290791,
0.0061181779,
0.0452137701,
-0.0114919534,
0.0328980274,
0.0292697512,
0.0117655573,
0.0212380998,
0.0098205758,
-0.0085833389,
-0.0154586909,
0.008269527,
0.0633063838,
-0.0469053499,
0.0051922575,
-0.0580772012,
0.0201427247,
-0.0035903053,
0.0400174968,
0.0105983652,
-0.0510410592,
0.0300083552,
-0.0204476248,
-0.0334917121,
-0.0630580708,
-0.0231402032,
0.0307983644,
-0.0300003402,
-0.0193501431,
0.0157444999,
-0.0292358492,
-0.0092555108,
0.008554684,
-0.0155856404,
0.1093271077,
0.0827493966,
-0.045681268,
-0.0565534197,
-0.0761840269,
-0.0119944923,
-0.0247621499,
-0.0309427828,
-0.0436076373,
-0.0091815349,
-0.0444341972,
0.0054293773,
-0.051217176,
0.0068773981,
0.0344203115,
-0.0363243073,
0.0351563208,
0.0220073629,
-0.0099563468,
-0.0269081965,
0.0270630121,
0.0245074872,
0.0291918535,
0.0102051469,
0.0662824735,
0.0477260165,
-0.0179865416,
0.0290684961,
0.0277677421,
-0.0066716336,
-0.0105283698,
0.0085459994,
-0.0023154877,
-0.0017377143,
-0.0642057583,
-0.0538205616,
0.0530912019,
0.0062009497,
-0.0151187154,
0.0581652075,
0.115717113,
0.0045841523,
-0.010782999,
-0.0053957002,
0.0411767364,
0.020399997,
-0.0630349591,
-0.0315799303,
-0.024445232,
-0.0377033167,
-0.0346271992,
-0.0374149494,
0.0397672802,
-0.0123837413,
-0.0181697421,
-0.0171393994,
-0.0135172289,
0.0382950529,
0.0260395054,
0.0138139483,
0.0145088872,
-0.0004721355,
0.0117376521,
0.0113169206,
-0.0056600999,
-0.0372146964,
-0.0410269275,
0.035256695,
0.09595038,
0.0168160088,
-0.021654563,
0.0166451409,
-0.0383322164,
-0.0188238472,
0.0255155787,
0.0202061199,
-0.0002913691,
0.0297194608,
-0.0275168307,
-0.0391871855,
0.00690406,
0.0374647938,
0.0054402757,
-0.0006703893,
-0.0423346348,
0.0444964133,
-0.0047622914,
-0.0117839258,
0.0327765159,
-0.0047414377,
-0.0315643623,
0.0381519645,
0.0170821305,
0.0151825715,
0.0323634557,
0.0201888233,
-0.0012195705,
0.0245774407,
-0.0013362729,
0.0139379874,
-0.0175676085,
0.0222781915,
-0.0137648843,
0.0157979075,
-0.0283827893,
0.0206742827,
0.0127912527,
-0.0475074314,
0.0059840432,
-0.0190252159,
-0.0133175049,
0.0239326935,
-0.0363686234,
-0.0018145512,
-0.028293984,
0.0020102542,
-0.0497901291,
0.019928256,
-0.0122660585,
-0.0242928192,
-0.0187756773,
-0.0423000604,
0.026417302,
-0.0077439351,
-0.0135199567,
-0.0148432124,
-0.0710486397,
0.0386141986,
0.0344368741,
0.0131429108,
-0.0163381379,
0.0054257433,
-0.0308455639,
0.0553877577,
0.0250462461,
0.0347127132,
0.0213354938,
0.0384897813,
-0.0136756292,
-0.0218596123,
-0.0336040594,
-0.0411113352,
-0.0449814498,
0.0388110951,
0.0434019044,
-0.0015836039,
-0.0992912576,
0.0219226927,
-0.0124946274,
-0.042039413,
0.0010945958,
-0.0040679513,
-0.0376727283,
0.0072650723,
0.0465783998,
-0.0205384605,
-0.0353022441,
-0.0110738091,
-0.0093018031,
-0.0038451443,
0.0148438532,
-0.0515769534,
0.0093680704,
0.0192649458,
0.0466445908,
0.0191946849,
0.0206408557,
-0.0295165908,
-0.0258840472,
-0.0005416103,
-0.0187706091,
-0.0294786897,
-0.0507517532,
0.0769762769,
0.0143413329,
0.0295755081,
0.0226218849,
-0.0504348502,
0.0066740783,
-0.0376177654,
-0.0010953371,
-0.0592670925,
0.0002751087,
-0.0149634006,
0.0421542041,
0.0101892082,
-0.0364942439,
0.0569761246,
0.0028078863,
0.0726865157,
-0.0333496742,
-0.0488456376,
-0.0164858475,
0.0638704672,
-0.0176508166,
0.039551653,
0.0450860634,
-0.070479013,
0.0207687989,
-0.0034486845,
0.0700931922,
-0.0459763259,
0.0398324244,
-0.0271409266,
-0.009885191,
0.0161035471,
-0.0471847802,
-0.0261109639,
-0.10341876,
-0.0099135442,
0.0008441581,
-0.0144587038,
-0.0265681967,
0.0204079319,
-0.0069942744,
-0.0096738581,
0.0103219906,
0.0245536286,
-0.0002380927,
-0.0196400676,
-0.0462234765,
-0.0081538167,
-0.0843234733,
-0.023604922,
0.0083502773,
0.0338323414,
0.0320900679,
0.013044321,
0.0341922604,
0.0177334584,
-0.000777,
-0.0171992537,
-0.0492189229,
0.0012879363,
0.0916180983,
0.0565128773,
-0.0558104701,
0.0194043964,
0.0583759956,
0.0603428409,
-0.0116393408,
0.007758569,
0.0468033589,
-0.021912694,
0.0178393554,
0.0083073825,
-0.1056463197,
-0.009559894,
0.0044192346,
0.0368533395,
-0.0597409159,
-0.0328821912,
-0.0195102599,
-0.0844478011,
-0.0016084446,
0.030637648,
0.0106017506,
-0.0052514165,
-0.0613673739,
0.0024909838,
-0.0181691162,
0.0067997645,
-0.0723091736,
-0.053100314,
-0.0358374454,
-0.0110025601,
-0.0734249577,
-0.0502009504,
0.0371778905,
-0.0428020023,
0.0327364951,
0.0584875271,
0.0082591912,
-0.0185398329,
-0.020670101,
0.0456027165,
0.0319976509,
-0.0203729626,
0.0262390133,
0.0151815703,
0.0187339,
0.0129907867,
-0.0118628209,
0.0630262941,
-0.0359610282,
-0.0337178931,
0.0459233634,
0.0301073063,
-0.0325914808,
0.005327058,
0.0025069911,
-0.016989613,
0.0136518087,
0.068576619,
-0.0027977596,
-0.0427178107,
-0.0233318787,
-0.0407595634,
-0.0337888487,
0.0055877329,
0.0086267572,
0.0111404303,
-0.0302299671,
-0.031220071,
-0.0501353033,
0.0449597351,
-0.0155435847,
-0.0255616121,
0.0590104125,
0.004582548,
0.0691642091,
0.0049893428,
-0.0071854894,
-0.0221634302,
-0.0544432849,
0.0489424802,
-0.0087319929,
0.041247502,
0.0078637451,
0.052022621,
-0.0158641543,
-0.0046993652,
-0.0567833818,
-0.0618794784,
-0.0261685252,
0.0169187486,
0.0154396472,
-0.0028761157,
-0.044980783,
-0.0269998908,
0.0310324915,
0.1107486412,
-0.0261974111,
-0.0489770696,
0.0724854916,
-0.0110740615,
-0.0100505445,
-0.0105004786,
-0.0130385151,
-0.0243042726,
0.0114204651,
-0.0106775742,
-0.044327084,
-0.002739429,
0.0526671857,
0.0663571432,
-0.0018710279,
0.017986076,
-0.0155957434,
-0.0163343605,
-0.0102074491,
-0.0174358767,
-0.0340278037,
0.0071380581,
-0.0151656885,
0.0562266558,
-0.0143010532,
-0.0003993578,
-0.0015866507,
-0.0174291879,
0.0089672217,
-0.0213989969,
0.0447206534,
0.0164242163,
0.0254136808,
0.0225333218,
-0.0415562764,
-0.0236251242,
0.0598975904,
0.009470162,
0.0291923899,
-0.0116412435,
0.0436584726,
-0.0085912384,
0.0398289226,
-0.0476217456,
0.0175961498,
-0.0031034809,
-0.0287811477,
-0.008098769,
0.0388715379,
-0.0092493631,
0.0170734879,
0.0047572944,
-0.0510556772,
-0.0121829957,
-0.0067943083,
0.0355979465,
-0.0328118354,
-0.0404850282,
0.0256847031,
0.0039902409,
-0.036408592,
-0.0086428942,
0.0497051589,
0.0084023112,
0.0178116672,
-0.0137364734,
-0.0349682383,
-0.0579510368,
0.0010171194,
0.0441957973,
0.0478965193,
-0.0361798443,
-0.043651592,
-0.0708439201,
-0.0463358089,
-0.0505536161,
-0.0200021453,
0.0235851482,
-0.0039181211,
-0.0075152926,
0.0463920981,
0.0274455566,
-0.0398609377,
-0.0898706838,
-0.035389632,
-0.0111073703,
-0.0170424283,
-0.0143379588,
-5.063587751e-33,
-0.0012832251,
-0.0074564125,
-0.0216099452,
0.025307335,
0.0213612244,
-0.0256301872,
0.0015404981,
-0.0208963286,
-0.0084009031,
-0.0122150173,
-0.0145081095,
-0.0079682851,
-0.0018017608,
-0.0029920186,
-0.0083288085,
-0.0039838371,
0.0378269367,
0.0116550783,
0.0039170156,
0.0254287198,
0.0247616284,
0.0196266267,
-0.0140810832,
-0.0619208962,
0.0468374155,
0.0273059364,
-0.0445764996,
0.007561713,
-0.0502488054,
0.0677050799,
-0.0246541239,
0.0184634551,
0.0286832284,
-0.0294216238,
0.0064150677,
0.0719063208,
-0.0434196033,
-0.0273049138,
0.0178621933,
-0.0157563444,
0.088591747,
-0.0676244199,
0.0194729492,
-0.0425466858,
-0.0183754824,
0.0042657037,
0.003315415,
-0.0435978509,
-0.039710395,
-0.0574226677,
-0.0349514522,
0.0082453247,
-0.0388688855,
0.0199786145,
0.0260698386,
0.0231407247,
-0.022815356,
0.030850254,
-0.0035224995,
0.0122428332,
0.0430822745,
-0.0547732227,
0.0330746993,
0.0115798423,
0.026531864,
0.0654481426,
-0.0261488613,
-0.0071139843,
-0.0069773532,
0.0036227549,
0.0189314634,
0.0298627876,
-0.0397299193,
0.0378409959,
0.0132971955,
-0.034284018,
-0.0737760216,
0.0301332679,
0.0123830801,
0.0154332565,
0.0555949733,
-0.0044181896,
-0.043557819,
-0.0283886045,
-0.0443470851,
0.0026859697,
-0.0228370093,
-0.0117076971,
0.0383906402,
0.0207281858,
-0.0549561083,
0.0108802477,
-0.0087892627,
-0.0800355449,
-0.0600789264,
0.0077351634,
0.0257076938,
-0.0383847281,
-0.0165254567,
0.0029885992,
-0.0685876235,
-0.0693999529,
-0.0110584544,
-0.0111247767,
0.0472671129,
-0.0034137699,
0.0426760651,
0.0182187613,
-0.0891229138,
-0.0094087487,
-0.0133253029,
0.0069351271,
-0.00551234,
0.0334944539,
0.0284013171,
0.0052453484,
0.0139010297,
0.0547102541,
0.0076411762,
-0.0218477137,
-0.0315679722,
0.0239887349,
-0.021822961,
-0.0021494813,
0.0167824831,
-0.015680233,
-0.0093747145,
0.0188086722,
0.1048399508,
-0.0109770093,
-0.0159938559,
-0.0192678906,
2.519e-7,
0.0316730924,
-0.004935184,
-0.03475824,
0.0148879308,
-0.0068837726,
0.0633273646,
0.0237222984,
0.0485005192,
0.0139660975,
-0.0165818185,
0.0170745421,
-0.0328162201,
0.0358589254,
0.0288689248,
-0.0551638566,
0.0083431797,
-0.0104842884,
-0.0196925849,
-0.0947655216,
0.0599130504,
0.0697185174,
0.0815827101,
0.0485410765,
-0.0241731331,
0.0120326215,
-0.0265345108,
0.0156735107,
-0.0632290468,
-0.0249518137,
-0.0128565319,
0.0257373247,
0.0610957779,
0.0414915383,
-0.0000046562,
-0.0036878888,
0.0358599015,
-0.0543828569,
0.1134483591,
0.0385676324,
0.0633951724,
-0.0095007997,
-0.0577549264,
0.0079662902,
-0.0368236899,
0.0594663918,
-0.0414626524,
-0.0451806821,
-0.0312085897,
0.0337345339,
-0.0795453638,
0.0216313936,
-0.0229775272,
0.0115943952,
-0.008933627,
-0.0047888374,
-0.0084896218,
0.0170548335,
-0.0590619855,
0.0196694657,
-0.0171498545,
0.0206878334,
-0.0181550868,
0.0142249642,
0.0300401058,
0.0088362666,
-0.0451464094,
0.0785782635,
2.398058985e-34,
0.0032153439,
-0.062184006,
0.0135486433,
0.0441283584,
0.012574668,
0.0487825647,
0.0451364741,
0.031127397,
0.0060928869,
-0.0568797104,
0.0503643975
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20895v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20895v1
|
A comparison of correspondence analysis with PMI-based word embedding methods
| 2024-05-31T15:04:15 | 2024-05-31T15:04:15 |
Qianqian Qi, David J. Hessen, Peter G. M. van der Heijden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Popular word embedding methods such as GloVe and Word2Vec are related to the
factorization of the pointwise mutual information (PMI) matrix. In this paper,
we link correspondence analysis (CA) to the factorization of the PMI matrix. CA
is a dimensionality reduction method that uses singular value decomposition
(SVD), and we show that CA is mathematically close to the weighted
factorization of the PMI matrix. In addition, we present variants of CA that
turn out to be successful in the factorization of the word-context matrix, i.e.
CA applied to a matrix where the entries undergo a square-root transformation
(ROOT-CA) and a root-root transformation (ROOTROOT-CA). An empirical comparison
among CA- and PMI-based methods shows that overall results of ROOT-CA and
ROOTROOT-CA are slightly better than those of the PMI-based methods.
|
[
-0.0337165482,
0.003195462,
0.0043808906,
0.0384901688,
-0.0381927192,
0.0473523736,
-0.0146778012,
0.031892661,
-0.0320214704,
-0.0197937321,
-0.0197313782,
-0.030817328,
0.0852680951,
-0.0097798677,
-0.0046685012,
-0.0188425872,
0.0534180924,
0.0170249976,
-0.0640616417,
0.011590261,
-0.0051332223,
0.0020693745,
-0.0191616584,
0.0128620807,
-0.0865855739,
-0.0305096749,
0.0141935367,
-0.0364068449,
0.0267569963,
-0.0497124568,
-0.052024439,
0.0395127609,
0.0627986863,
-0.0059196497,
0.0000021972,
-0.0159093458,
0.0116421096,
-0.0002861735,
0.0525350571,
0.024770584,
0.0431446806,
-0.0354750417,
0.0229106657,
0.016551489,
-0.0439433418,
-0.0238218177,
0.0772934556,
0.0558939166,
-0.0166364759,
0.0575251244,
-0.0429629833,
-0.0519919768,
0.0097637828,
0.0001595907,
-0.0134212691,
-0.0291381516,
0.040201135,
0.0041679977,
-0.0341430865,
-0.0148392329,
-0.0655545518,
0.0560118034,
-0.0533278584,
0.0023482374,
0.0762192607,
0.0548233204,
0.0458681993,
0.0097812507,
0.0105874576,
0.0780241489,
0.020037692,
-0.0027442025,
-0.0006159114,
0.016846871,
-0.0075963135,
0.0911734104,
-0.0258650426,
-0.0227279309,
0.0337342806,
0.0250625629,
0.0199814346,
0.0280525181,
-0.0147872763,
-0.0457221791,
-0.0372181237,
0.0363330953,
0.0470234044,
-0.046828378,
-0.0222480018,
-0.0432219058,
0.0477391146,
-0.0007867095,
-0.0060479455,
-0.0148918368,
0.0278104581,
-0.0008315018,
-0.0545404293,
-0.0720825046,
-0.0068956562,
-0.0997683033,
0.0648421794,
0.0126793664,
0.0389788933,
0.0403586254,
0.0256520081,
0.0096531054,
-0.0158155672,
0.0609997176,
-0.0622789487,
0.0212540515,
-0.0099740569,
0.0297292452,
-0.0136359129,
0.0274277292,
-0.0055926568,
-0.0629468933,
-0.0140215168,
0.0543499328,
0.0223084036,
-0.0017054498,
-0.0531996004,
0.0045404676,
0.0425799824,
0.017451955,
-0.0000129156,
0.0177572165,
-0.0502889939,
0.0109955324,
-0.094074674,
0.0288290549,
-0.0043529142,
0.0466369204,
0.0427271985,
-0.0199405514,
0.0149776433,
0.012567441,
-0.0152348857,
-0.0665640905,
0.0275436025,
0.0247777812,
0.0073324894,
-0.0378256962,
-0.0051424205,
-0.0508166775,
0.1033848599,
-0.0011862307,
-0.0148813762,
-0.0255084932,
-0.0222765654,
0.002031066,
-0.0740920454,
0.1114666313,
0.0061323135,
0.0168867931,
0.0239536073,
-0.0001002551,
0.0256772917,
-0.0189932343,
0.0460349955,
-0.018219037,
0.0354780778,
-0.0617559031,
-0.0071777995,
-0.0033904756,
-0.0131648127,
-0.0045459075,
-0.0235809926,
0.0081452588,
0.0345203541,
0.034789443,
-0.0120879598,
0.0481368192,
0.0075668106,
0.012299058,
0.0175827611,
0.107962586,
0.0280618723,
-0.006896052,
0.0182310734,
0.0260791555,
-0.0164786372,
0.0123823145,
-0.0217997897,
0.0209082365,
-0.0362901166,
-0.0197597388,
-0.0089405533,
0.0216097906,
-0.0331068188,
-0.02862579,
0.0246526171,
-0.0280558616,
0.0029799938,
-0.0512526818,
0.0444783121,
-0.0511621013,
-0.0436631143,
-0.0310096834,
0.0438570157,
-0.0593622513,
-0.0003832432,
0.0288395658,
-0.0041580396,
0.0280433409,
0.0527947135,
-0.0538315326,
0.0518100038,
-0.0034187089,
-0.0156203946,
0.0024376444,
-0.0157501567,
-0.0033821282,
-0.0368138552,
-0.0460781194,
-0.0178963542,
0.0547818355,
-0.0165166855,
0.0369803384,
-0.0166451037,
0.0498062037,
0.0041648564,
0.0134429075,
0.0293724053,
0.0393447503,
-0.0057185963,
0.0037192649,
0.0404337235,
0.0334183052,
0.0252383444,
0.0567001551,
-0.0106164478,
0.024907859,
0.0567438975,
-0.0261594653,
-0.0094120847,
0.0194225665,
-0.0378374085,
0.0031094048,
0.0251479801,
-0.0988691747,
0.0422752835,
0.020383114,
0.0453126952,
-0.0438690409,
-0.0062591177,
-0.0408311822,
-0.02342855,
-0.0183188766,
0.0646662861,
-0.0377792604,
0.0485046171,
0.0004143385,
0.0415166318,
-0.0104625998,
0.0046989578,
-0.0002795458,
-0.0060686893,
0.0140871191,
-0.0059461468,
-0.0266285222,
0.0349363871,
-0.0220545065,
-0.0131575856,
-0.0064140018,
-0.0267906301,
0.0360213332,
-0.0154957306,
-0.0344806276,
-0.0309022982,
0.0248180721,
-0.0012016131,
-0.0098292818,
0.0018501268,
0.0191312097,
0.0183336008,
-0.0255422276,
0.0458705872,
-0.0321793929,
-0.0054971902,
0.044180911,
-0.0025976524,
-0.0452928208,
-0.0373051539,
0.004678743,
-0.0275526736,
0.039221324,
-0.0276552401,
-0.0760698691,
-0.0308285709,
0.1216989979,
-0.0068475707,
0.0417515263,
-0.0336166136,
-0.0041407631,
0.0159388017,
-0.0115157925,
0.0371864252,
-0.0039610779,
0.0378197543,
0.028038932,
0.0759005398,
-0.0057249805,
-0.0129758511,
0.0063114162,
-0.0127734132,
0.0777002648,
-0.0016454353,
-0.0394324474,
0.0193214081,
-0.0145306615,
0.0239524823,
0.0614676028,
-0.039609056,
-0.018108299,
-0.0005238003,
0.0069216127,
-0.0165382363,
0.0015246794,
-0.0362467356,
-0.0204783529,
0.0270531327,
-0.0051516783,
0.0044130255,
-0.0692186952,
0.0308654513,
-0.0296402127,
-0.0360398516,
-0.0230211746,
0.0118648438,
-0.0235860776,
0.0124387713,
-0.0655012056,
-0.0002978598,
0.0044239522,
0.0108236354,
0.059529312,
-0.0327425078,
-0.0034692504,
-0.0189407766,
0.004715261,
-0.0261195302,
-0.0191546008,
-0.0092994682,
-0.0470317416,
0.0240788218,
-0.0462770313,
0.0314239077,
-0.0795978755,
0.0030285558,
0.0379788131,
0.0160368867,
-0.0263565201,
0.0261187907,
-0.0020518338,
-0.0271947347,
0.04634526,
0.0593892485,
0.0149006825,
-0.0070095463,
0.0285034291,
0.0336177088,
0.0296543781,
0.012710114,
0.0154786501,
0.0125564961,
-0.01706855,
0.0296435654,
0.0159070995,
-0.0305004306,
0.0112733701,
-0.0126623577,
0.0704501569,
0.0069527095,
0.0925983265,
0.0356603079,
-0.0875844285,
-0.0099514499,
0.0172587782,
-0.0408440344,
0.0015947004,
-0.0160420872,
-0.0589298867,
0.0335008055,
0.0115427123,
-0.0136247184,
0.0216215104,
-0.0598833151,
-0.0282663889,
-0.0883891806,
0.015242165,
0.021733325,
-0.0138035333,
-0.127339676,
-0.0815336928,
-0.0064151748,
0.0338772386,
-0.0191580337,
-0.0159665346,
-0.0245917588,
-0.0358357951,
-0.016069198,
-0.0561652929,
-0.0199384782,
-0.0456834808,
-0.0449905582,
0.0160397589,
-0.0198640209,
0.0625122041,
-0.0041604256,
-0.0442394167,
-0.0485602319,
-0.0252313297,
-0.008042424,
-0.0431118309,
0.0268185064,
-0.056807179,
0.0051404224,
-0.0317066461,
0.0264006108,
-0.0144346552,
0.0090374416,
-0.0173192043,
0.0658694804,
-0.0321557932,
0.0168635081,
-0.0240563527,
0.0132117635,
0.0074134227,
0.1026427522,
0.0172819141,
-0.0294927042,
0.0201213006,
0.0409281589,
0.0570009686,
0.0427029394,
-0.0042770831,
-0.0006169186,
-0.0266982578,
-0.0102662202,
-0.0490228422,
-0.0123714926,
0.0430314578,
0.0527666397,
0.0183065142,
0.0354734063,
-0.0185144171,
-0.0162463728,
-0.0527537875,
-0.0437490009,
0.0011784043,
0.0561448373,
-0.0237146448,
0.0370815583,
-0.0087551158,
0.0211490355,
0.0075112148,
-0.0576548055,
0.015174944,
-0.0358663313,
-0.0361547172,
-0.0003773241,
0.0031729944,
0.0144010596,
-0.0229072552,
-0.0102658104,
-0.0017269603,
0.0046397918,
-0.0398388579,
0.0181095768,
-0.007429447,
-0.0039161746,
-0.0005554882,
0.0062736403,
-0.0324683674,
-0.0117901992,
-0.0177525822,
0.0194786303,
-0.0025602956,
-0.0742369965,
-0.0156936608,
0.0167609025,
0.037958499,
-0.0079484116,
-0.0142596094,
-0.0219128393,
0.0016321439,
-0.0663571134,
-0.0130585181,
-0.0014980437,
-0.0456575081,
0.0354211926,
-0.0040067937,
-0.0617093444,
0.0336071625,
-0.0251612552,
-0.0232941192,
0.0089782691,
0.0203830544,
0.0249223709,
0.012819727,
0.0030900356,
0.0266502071,
-0.0069750277,
0.0133801727,
-0.0183931384,
-0.0066155498,
-0.0124934595,
0.001291373,
-0.0127761774,
-0.0200562309,
-0.0464802235,
0.0524007268,
-0.0017625503,
0.0248743463,
-0.0273237471,
0.0517675169,
0.024985753,
-0.0228768662,
0.0161055624,
-0.0074074967,
0.0184309892,
0.0084445979,
0.0658570752,
-0.020579027,
0.0074728904,
0.0468939468,
-0.006024933,
-0.00931961,
0.0235711187,
0.0401598141,
0.0058616544,
-0.0143245142,
-0.0356130488,
-0.0498382896,
-0.023629697,
0.0400241651,
0.0275892057,
0.0721421912,
-0.0438876934,
0.0130329328,
-0.1061262786,
-0.0358887054,
0.0451501682,
-0.0248155799,
-0.0212050024,
0.038719587,
0.0221786462,
-0.0025319967,
-0.0119451443,
0.0475152619,
-0.0127421375,
0.0050093061,
-0.018488789,
-0.0847728848,
-0.0257249828,
-6.006118223e-33,
-0.020172704,
-0.0286618173,
-0.0066360179,
0.0588731989,
-0.035080485,
-0.0109804003,
0.0063426541,
0.0287666582,
-0.0205318667,
0.0075885342,
-0.026905328,
-0.0188785233,
0.0053959,
-0.0318556689,
-0.0201753248,
0.0363260731,
-0.0088190511,
-0.0116185043,
-0.0397399291,
-0.0081965933,
0.0361145064,
0.050005395,
0.0686388761,
-0.1102873385,
-0.0168347228,
-0.0200185459,
0.0467849523,
0.0081073288,
0.0429751538,
-0.0098531703,
-0.0539412759,
0.0055860817,
0.0346234478,
0.0490313768,
0.0126353279,
0.0585643463,
-0.0833478421,
-0.0141438739,
0.0101450793,
0.0239614099,
-0.0037783931,
-0.0066882214,
-0.0093088057,
0.0038978697,
-0.0375649333,
-0.0187600832,
0.060466364,
0.0084841531,
-0.0215332713,
-0.0115396641,
-0.0806638077,
0.0275904108,
-0.0225557648,
-0.0357636064,
0.0645509809,
-0.0303303748,
0.0342028067,
-0.0243315063,
-0.0763621405,
0.0123999165,
-0.0419067852,
-0.0015478821,
0.0298350435,
0.0236887056,
-0.0046932618,
0.0582051128,
0.0500773005,
-0.0714759305,
0.01432887,
-0.0272112209,
0.0241955426,
0.0492911488,
0.0228304453,
0.0717797279,
0.0248714909,
-0.0273235142,
-0.0348259062,
0.0526021086,
0.011532886,
0.0134885665,
-0.0002927775,
-0.0003939687,
-0.0778125152,
-0.0427624807,
-0.0120405536,
-0.0142240785,
-0.030360641,
-0.0001599911,
0.0203896537,
0.0044585373,
-0.0313443691,
-0.0135041522,
0.0215723477,
-0.0128382752,
-0.0173334982,
0.0196522065,
0.0007672805,
0.0575677715,
0.0021131437,
-0.0398532376,
-0.0182826389,
-0.0232326165,
0.0108537897,
-0.0119937137,
0.0268641841,
-0.0468712375,
0.0138769364,
0.0031059275,
-0.0480935089,
-0.0290423743,
0.0163093135,
-0.0890458375,
0.0418008827,
-0.0362463258,
0.0041517299,
0.0070118117,
0.0041231993,
0.0387538932,
0.0147638619,
0.0378769524,
-0.0229040366,
-0.0762747601,
0.0143838897,
-0.0164818894,
-0.0087167975,
0.0131658167,
-0.0105266664,
0.0235743728,
0.0786101446,
-0.0588624217,
-0.0222322736,
-0.0185982212,
2.884e-7,
0.0520420782,
0.0325460806,
0.0293491241,
-0.0545259453,
0.010991808,
0.0232523829,
0.004252471,
0.0467222407,
-0.0617060475,
0.0094660847,
0.0620400719,
0.0045447056,
0.0082074935,
-0.0105296569,
-0.0126745487,
-0.0151808476,
-0.0431809574,
0.0247003697,
-0.0546439923,
0.0087026656,
0.0419783592,
0.0486631319,
0.0354133397,
-0.0013417439,
-0.0287792608,
-0.0121883163,
0.0373081416,
-0.0352123603,
0.0098883715,
-0.029814478,
0.0022135617,
-0.0479293168,
0.0073010763,
0.0211339053,
0.0065013696,
0.0592859425,
0.0326993689,
0.0057055145,
-0.0287702587,
0.0437165275,
-0.0279185995,
-0.0258120131,
-0.0415876545,
-0.0297858343,
0.0625677183,
-0.0112549057,
-0.016461648,
-0.054869853,
-0.0346576646,
0.0682593957,
0.018925732,
0.0580722876,
0.0008879304,
0.0217180159,
0.0374964736,
-0.0338005833,
0.0107500795,
-0.0368651375,
0.0509865917,
0.0141819054,
-0.00546407,
-0.0028952812,
-0.0113799181,
-0.0483111478,
0.0837029591,
0.0457882248,
-0.0016180546,
2.446772895e-34,
-0.0309867803,
0.0207301807,
0.0320690498,
0.0167179741,
0.0116823483,
-0.057777144,
-0.0037047542,
0.0247939955,
0.0005615194,
-0.1261511594,
0.0057303999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20859v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20859v1
|
clembench-2024: A Challenging, Dynamic, Complementary, Multilingual Benchmark and Underlying Flexible Framework for LLMs as Multi-Action Agents
| 2024-05-31T14:43:31 | 2024-05-31T14:43:31 |
Anne Beyer, Kranti Chalamalasetti, Sherzod Hakimov, Brielen Madureira, Philipp Sadler, David Schlangen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
It has been established in recent work that Large Language Models (LLMs) can
be prompted to "self-play" conversational games that probe certain capabilities
(general instruction following, strategic goal orientation, language
understanding abilities), where the resulting interactive game play can be
automatically scored. In this paper, we take one of the proposed frameworks for
setting up such game-play environments, and further test its usefulness as an
evaluation instrument, along a number of dimensions: We show that it can easily
keep up with new developments while avoiding data contamination, we show that
the tests implemented within it are not yet saturated (human performance is
substantially higher than that of even the best models), and we show that it
lends itself to investigating additional questions, such as the impact of the
prompting language on performance. We believe that the approach forms a good
basis for making decisions on model choice for building applied interactive
systems, and perhaps ultimately setting up a closed-loop development
environment of system and simulated evaluator.
|
[
0.0139864106,
-0.011303965,
-0.0605490841,
0.0728143826,
-0.0406104401,
0.0035933636,
0.0029992815,
-0.0075395564,
0.0457648188,
-0.023744598,
-0.0621331893,
-0.0247471221,
-0.0114162518,
0.0412049219,
0.0448088683,
-0.0341759101,
0.0649344102,
-0.0532585159,
-0.0008788157,
-0.0026084194,
-0.0283569619,
-0.0326266289,
-0.0291141775,
0.0466669425,
0.0408178866,
-0.0068354742,
-0.060256239,
-0.021202758,
-0.0043082521,
-0.0233637821,
-0.0176090524,
0.0095361518,
0.0355100296,
0.0010596715,
0.000002136,
-0.0656931549,
0.0381489024,
-0.0351437144,
-0.0165049266,
0.0005304523,
0.0322693475,
0.0590456463,
-0.0285881218,
-0.0093852393,
-0.0447977707,
0.0181460418,
0.0133364256,
-0.0532825775,
0.0794033334,
0.0441544354,
0.016612988,
0.0190821495,
0.001951989,
0.0299826879,
0.0031011526,
-0.0490330309,
-0.0148768872,
0.0297160801,
0.0898389593,
0.0026715137,
-0.0172990765,
0.0390012413,
0.0349207744,
-0.0341007672,
-0.0308331624,
0.0308479406,
-0.0006148131,
-0.0275224522,
-0.0479873568,
0.0460903868,
0.0205470622,
0.0164959617,
0.008677939,
0.0033297837,
0.0353747942,
0.0103704138,
-0.025425192,
0.0305615589,
0.0218252279,
-0.0131275728,
-0.0025889587,
-0.0011763497,
0.0202392992,
0.0076416326,
0.014063051,
0.074627839,
-0.0180219337,
-0.0215422232,
0.0027690537,
0.012005222,
0.0266969763,
-0.0705066919,
-0.0517523885,
0.0937034488,
-0.086110577,
0.0382939354,
-0.0112284683,
0.0402902476,
0.006899768,
-0.058151681,
0.0610394739,
0.0564403087,
0.0086590853,
0.0549755096,
0.025556827,
0.0816742554,
0.026002422,
0.012136559,
-0.0151530495,
0.0195482019,
-0.0288848002,
-0.0160776675,
-0.0252215192,
0.0443396494,
-0.0186771955,
-0.0299670678,
-0.0398714729,
0.0632409602,
-0.0343486369,
0.0668943226,
-0.0188392904,
-0.0311445352,
0.0012115634,
0.0190516263,
-0.0763555095,
-0.0044238139,
-0.0407815538,
-0.002119448,
0.0020367692,
-0.1008688733,
0.0122031011,
0.0108322259,
-0.0436357595,
-0.0139953662,
0.0097119454,
0.1034577861,
-0.0054826713,
-0.038518291,
-0.0032917175,
-0.0186616927,
0.0076916595,
-0.0917957798,
-0.0031205458,
-0.0624675713,
0.0246709194,
0.0015213384,
-0.0065335939,
-0.0199048426,
-0.0097895814,
0.019994434,
0.0339630879,
0.0303858221,
0.0322542377,
0.0170372222,
0.0241960343,
0.0244247075,
-0.0206715558,
0.1072555706,
0.0628495142,
-0.0040133563,
0.0321788862,
-0.0342041478,
0.0311466157,
0.0996265486,
-0.0170864761,
-0.00141498,
0.0057863635,
0.0206889268,
0.0054816492,
0.0412845835,
-0.0348018557,
0.0135176675,
-0.0319236256,
0.0129934009,
0.0487768576,
0.054313127,
0.0189067144,
-0.020340059,
0.0712072328,
0.0001226016,
0.0338461362,
0.0093101589,
-0.0160412695,
0.0479724705,
-0.0043472797,
0.014043333,
-0.0248085726,
0.0008139964,
-0.0161573738,
-0.0695135295,
0.0287189763,
0.0026392585,
0.0210723821,
0.0439606719,
0.0429432355,
-0.0273092985,
-0.0366181768,
0.0148042059,
0.0115735931,
-0.051077161,
0.0241282769,
-0.0991081372,
0.0250425898,
0.0955825746,
0.0726514757,
-0.0348184519,
-0.0437387452,
0.0191709958,
-0.019350959,
0.0474614836,
0.0487773232,
-0.033111304,
0.0119033298,
-0.0114741456,
-0.0348201245,
-0.0482192822,
-0.0109960046,
0.037507277,
-0.0282014776,
-0.0086380169,
-0.0390789248,
0.0187229905,
0.0010758644,
0.0147990258,
-0.0592633672,
-0.0338682495,
-0.0517543368,
0.009248985,
0.0379875526,
0.0360347442,
0.0087675704,
0.0007955077,
0.0393012352,
0.0040072757,
0.0198936965,
0.0213168077,
-0.0249302536,
-0.0136287892,
0.0206514075,
0.0167682189,
-0.0158150066,
0.0275088176,
0.0087996833,
-0.0306007825,
0.0477936082,
-0.0242837761,
0.0234251618,
-0.0117163891,
0.0404346921,
-0.0563004352,
-0.0246779639,
-0.0313556232,
0.0246861819,
0.002430107,
0.0303861313,
0.0249132644,
0.0222666748,
0.0113671925,
-0.0684454069,
-0.0334954597,
0.0368528068,
-0.0120743588,
-0.0067095477,
0.0099901529,
0.0110506052,
-0.0625722408,
-0.0410498418,
-0.0765496939,
0.0043542441,
-0.0199921355,
0.0189444125,
0.0281972177,
0.0005077694,
-0.0113344146,
0.0049636071,
-0.0064748065,
-0.0082904277,
0.0664917156,
0.0309820957,
0.0204475895,
0.0242967829,
-0.048605714,
-0.0444624871,
0.0072182538,
-0.0196555331,
0.0113617061,
-0.0018048469,
0.0104418593,
-0.0665825829,
0.0206253957,
-0.0353893414,
0.0160851963,
-0.0374111496,
-0.031312149,
0.0709568411,
0.0030302873,
0.0075531844,
0.0725617185,
-0.0248765927,
0.0500543341,
0.0486315303,
-0.067638427,
-0.0759583563,
0.0463767946,
-0.0038348811,
-0.0188419912,
-0.0753054917,
-0.0391761884,
-0.0034885786,
0.0815468505,
0.0085275555,
0.0455226935,
-0.0303459987,
0.0181721952,
-0.0210221019,
-0.0512381904,
-0.046889957,
-0.0299207494,
-0.0461211652,
0.0174854007,
-0.0095028169,
-0.0194339138,
0.0559651405,
-0.0398068838,
-0.0465928204,
-0.0071702022,
-0.0094099063,
-0.0247641131,
0.0620268546,
-0.0042993021,
-0.0287988558,
-0.0217712317,
-0.0090387883,
-0.0530071519,
-0.022387566,
0.0195647124,
-0.0381894745,
0.0524765067,
-0.0700161681,
-0.0087859416,
0.0200660732,
-0.0127214389,
-0.0315981768,
0.0157611705,
-0.0319281779,
-0.0117529863,
0.0192095451,
0.0095414259,
-0.0272316448,
0.0122602209,
0.0635936037,
0.0052292864,
0.005712383,
-0.0088058477,
-0.0304920301,
-0.0122843599,
0.0344848447,
0.0364265144,
-0.004309827,
-0.0383265465,
0.0818478912,
0.0286020823,
-0.0071422788,
-0.0424464568,
-0.0093677603,
0.0092303716,
0.0465911366,
-0.0193429012,
-0.0197526496,
0.0608108416,
0.050958354,
-0.0614642948,
-0.022917226,
0.1068608388,
0.0135918166,
0.0046542981,
0.0092156623,
-0.0294836406,
0.0136946458,
0.0270834211,
0.0388670191,
-0.045242887,
-0.0038270538,
-0.0024481106,
0.0048297592,
-0.0248125196,
-0.0096128788,
-0.0060918699,
-0.1166123971,
0.043000333,
-0.0205651633,
-0.0194004383,
0.0318753235,
-0.0050863405,
0.0063527632,
0.0079402998,
0.0180824511,
0.0351540633,
0.0191835593,
-0.0149226943,
-0.0215022676,
-0.03448838,
-0.0267669335,
0.042798087,
-0.0188658144,
0.0851218998,
0.0562323183,
0.0365980119,
-0.0028997357,
-0.0372633003,
0.0479405411,
-0.0092378696,
0.0151239838,
-0.0111395596,
0.030009307,
-0.0164816026,
-0.0052542193,
-0.0090589616,
-0.0299449116,
0.0112973796,
0.0183200017,
0.025654057,
0.0679205284,
-0.0356560126,
0.0021293245,
-0.0010510682,
0.019544825,
0.0127402907,
0.0450397395,
0.0054905526,
-0.0550928116,
-0.0189566091,
-0.0264570527,
-0.0568105876,
-0.0428579003,
-0.0721430033,
-0.0095223747,
-0.003202454,
0.0164382681,
-0.0394496098,
-0.0920259282,
0.0176160615,
0.0059083072,
-0.0093180658,
0.0087174028,
0.0131864194,
0.0230883751,
0.036071714,
0.0022400727,
-0.0157294888,
0.0426384583,
-0.0647960529,
-0.0364851132,
0.0003468971,
-0.0517580397,
0.010891702,
0.0242323689,
-0.0258325096,
-0.0676463693,
-0.0115886442,
0.0873363316,
0.0278761536,
0.0261027217,
0.0107072825,
-0.0180104151,
-0.0019621695,
-0.0303725787,
-0.0496241152,
0.0194716547,
0.0083017899,
0.0227126554,
-0.0034561916,
0.0011775676,
-0.0369841121,
0.0081056478,
0.011527461,
0.0531090908,
-0.0273226798,
-0.0592341051,
-0.0042697028,
0.003336427,
0.0171480421,
-0.01220043,
-0.0067627262,
-0.0001014659,
0.0171592496,
-0.0564703569,
-0.0163852181,
-0.0460692868,
-0.0323941335,
-0.0332015865,
0.0000388643,
0.049792055,
-0.0088806134,
-0.0462993048,
0.0038537816,
-0.0104652597,
0.0435027592,
0.0258397181,
0.0046522031,
0.009286209,
0.0326961316,
0.0070366692,
0.03690679,
-0.0036778441,
0.028710641,
0.0404993221,
0.0685600713,
0.0017044138,
-0.0254386365,
0.026057858,
0.027489204,
-0.025811106,
-0.0276845843,
0.028380312,
0.0600644909,
0.0436389707,
0.0285156965,
0.0142326299,
-0.0307400022,
0.0314393416,
-0.0108560883,
-0.0220811553,
0.0184494574,
-0.081532903,
0.0197742302,
0.0440511592,
0.0042387182,
-0.0341949463,
0.0330755934,
-0.0284968801,
0.0231848862,
-0.0202627163,
0.0330343321,
-0.0526303016,
-0.0320714265,
0.0254984796,
0.001371959,
-0.0374154672,
-0.0017307602,
-0.0661876947,
-0.054969158,
-0.0079528969,
0.081283927,
-0.0108315321,
-0.0462775417,
0.0353020541,
0.0368950963,
0.0208001193,
0.0093604997,
-0.0521617942,
0.0184680279,
-0.0356354043,
-0.004037498,
-0.0222149342,
-5.568666817e-33,
-0.0456459671,
-0.0211975574,
0.0970906019,
0.027908856,
-0.009380619,
-0.0280248802,
-0.0519122928,
0.0165412668,
-0.0205727108,
-0.0254615694,
0.0050979457,
-0.0213704407,
-0.0015048325,
-0.0250768531,
0.0280741565,
-0.0269171856,
0.0085298093,
-0.0094111403,
-0.047625538,
-0.013423861,
0.0006047512,
-0.0146301128,
0.0452937596,
-0.0284043998,
0.0626487061,
-0.0359669477,
-0.0179808997,
0.0323534161,
-0.0245073307,
0.0392098948,
-0.0021965327,
0.0350568295,
0.0230604652,
-0.0419775136,
0.0053803916,
0.020261975,
0.0007415126,
-0.0651749223,
0.0484746881,
0.0190863293,
-0.0207872037,
-0.0000994517,
0.0214221943,
-0.0090114484,
-0.0755146667,
0.034478385,
0.013563701,
-0.0151062338,
-0.0105043249,
0.0273043532,
-0.0681560561,
0.0094352728,
-0.0295555461,
-0.0430121385,
-0.0073380307,
0.0729657039,
-0.014464207,
0.0030673968,
-0.0372715928,
0.0593041405,
0.014905476,
0.0073131085,
0.1015033796,
0.0320595652,
0.0293213874,
0.0368979312,
0.0089727324,
0.0397315249,
-0.0437721461,
-0.0092808576,
0.0399627797,
0.0423192456,
0.0484546237,
0.031976264,
-0.0655154362,
0.0203014836,
-0.0195344035,
0.0381083675,
0.069889389,
0.0472307652,
-0.0085652694,
0.0092088729,
-0.0478111394,
0.0022962105,
-0.0284139849,
0.0608611666,
-0.0051628542,
-0.0636519641,
0.0410995968,
-0.0333251506,
0.030888509,
-0.0639874265,
0.0231619105,
-0.0202152599,
-0.0296765026,
-0.019357793,
-0.0091806436,
0.0504796393,
-0.0058476697,
0.0076615219,
-0.0245684776,
-0.0351856202,
-0.0231473185,
0.0055133631,
0.0252899919,
0.0150888097,
-0.041949857,
0.04029366,
-0.025273148,
-0.0074143521,
-0.0508971661,
0.0212354623,
0.023813054,
-0.0100939693,
0.0187573843,
-0.0410770923,
-0.0282090809,
0.0486296974,
-0.0161370207,
-0.0713021606,
-0.0268940218,
-0.0008022974,
-0.030020982,
-0.0040214849,
-0.0276848003,
0.0049239965,
-0.0550175346,
0.0730302036,
-0.0073307371,
-0.0204379167,
0.0076258583,
-0.0189220272,
2.938e-7,
-0.0126179419,
0.0294678882,
-0.032836698,
0.0554078221,
0.0008839667,
0.0340786874,
-0.0783222765,
-0.0019808221,
0.0260460116,
-0.0242414642,
0.008438359,
0.039611768,
0.0293716379,
0.0104491087,
-0.0954047292,
-0.0010079705,
-0.0247665476,
0.0067842826,
-0.0256231576,
0.029889781,
0.0335284658,
0.0057804286,
0.004138696,
0.0136292754,
-0.0308916029,
-0.0475751646,
0.0196687803,
-0.0609147325,
-0.0353719443,
0.0403522477,
0.0072577186,
-0.000554391,
-0.0086549977,
0.0198364034,
0.0075421217,
0.0291465167,
-0.0323312692,
0.0636195615,
0.0235238317,
-0.0196946263,
-0.0112713668,
-0.0392726101,
-0.0041206134,
-0.0556378029,
0.0445088893,
-0.0248015672,
-0.0123347109,
-0.0124791209,
0.0121508203,
-0.0296978038,
-0.0085127922,
-0.0414473489,
-0.0222230367,
0.0037665474,
-0.0001913609,
-0.039740596,
0.0228155889,
-0.020186007,
-0.0064913542,
-0.0230721142,
-0.0417647175,
-0.0934790671,
-0.0493623279,
-0.0002882916,
-0.0325893275,
-0.0644238591,
-0.0017550334,
2.264226887e-34,
0.0093060043,
-0.0143508287,
0.0387268551,
0.0149768032,
0.0386853181,
0.0280897487,
-0.0468000323,
0.0415566899,
0.0570596382,
-0.0374039598,
-0.0248318072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20852v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20852v1
|
Towards Spoken Language Understanding via Multi-level Multi-grained Contrastive Learning
| 2024-05-31T14:34:23 | 2024-05-31T14:34:23 |
Xuxin Cheng, Wanshi Xu, Zhihong Zhu, Hongxiang Li, Yuexian Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Spoken language understanding (SLU) is a core task in task-oriented dialogue
systems, which aims at understanding the user's current goal through
constructing semantic frames. SLU usually consists of two subtasks, including
intent detection and slot filling. Although there are some SLU frameworks joint
modeling the two subtasks and achieving high performance, most of them still
overlook the inherent relationships between intents and slots and fail to
achieve mutual guidance between the two subtasks. To solve the problem, we
propose a multi-level multi-grained SLU framework MMCL to apply contrastive
learning at three levels, including utterance level, slot level, and word level
to enable intent and slot to mutually guide each other. For the utterance
level, our framework implements coarse granularity contrastive learning and
fine granularity contrastive learning simultaneously. Besides, we also apply
the self-distillation method to improve the robustness of the model.
Experimental results and further analysis demonstrate that our proposed model
achieves new state-of-the-art results on two public multi-intent SLU datasets,
obtaining a 2.6 overall accuracy improvement on the MixATIS dataset compared to
previous best models.
|
[
0.0285669751,
0.0522298813,
0.0039952919,
0.0552258193,
-0.0050059226,
0.027301902,
0.0009702015,
-0.0672418699,
-0.0289354026,
-0.0352569185,
-0.0248496272,
-0.0418284275,
0.0187505223,
0.0535233878,
-0.0130328741,
-0.0636366904,
0.0396664888,
-0.053639695,
0.024928188,
0.0093444781,
0.0077587208,
0.0161374751,
-0.0520004854,
0.0120982816,
0.0219301153,
-0.0418171175,
-0.0417101458,
0.0319063216,
-0.0049497136,
-0.0169561952,
0.0237061922,
0.0548520125,
0.0514755026,
0.0273335073,
0.0000023026,
-0.0394761227,
-0.0129211554,
-0.0220728349,
-0.0881060958,
-0.0146888392,
-0.0044066454,
0.0077039464,
0.0117638996,
0.0097856503,
-0.0262467694,
-0.0194453131,
0.0244261697,
0.0721232742,
0.0524293073,
0.024671251,
-0.0058165188,
-0.0602765307,
0.0129450755,
-0.004550267,
-0.0141116688,
-0.0516338386,
-0.0003634662,
0.0429900885,
-0.0039034041,
0.0303623192,
-0.0083391694,
0.0382846557,
0.0016388451,
-0.0008923836,
-0.0313568376,
0.0060580214,
-0.0174743552,
-0.0296646357,
-0.0234017987,
0.0892975107,
0.0183431637,
0.0258337278,
-0.0104851797,
-0.0366116725,
-0.0122753931,
-0.0223253518,
-0.0239622537,
-0.0304374117,
-0.0222152118,
0.0276184957,
0.0419823937,
0.0244232584,
-0.0117660388,
0.0201103967,
-0.0273245014,
0.0386247858,
-0.028539367,
-0.0046899738,
-0.0144951353,
-0.0275056995,
0.0330725908,
-0.0378180593,
-0.0038121939,
0.0182023942,
-0.0916445926,
0.0208635163,
-0.0192505512,
-0.005892674,
0.0106586916,
-0.0017792407,
-0.0158389248,
0.0689626858,
-0.0631020814,
0.058471702,
0.028315071,
-0.0009857351,
-0.0017790155,
-0.0207913164,
-0.0523665473,
-0.0133947032,
-0.0535531491,
0.013438914,
-0.0544301048,
0.040921513,
-0.0706779733,
-0.0081441635,
-0.006952134,
0.0240275804,
-0.0120022409,
0.0027773741,
0.0108943386,
-0.0172096342,
-0.0381127782,
0.0067316731,
-0.0263179634,
0.0799525306,
-0.036458876,
0.0429840647,
0.0031217781,
-0.0431010462,
-0.041358538,
0.0214627441,
0.0117796967,
-0.0389285646,
-0.0067837038,
0.019126609,
-0.0129254442,
-0.0469726063,
-0.0614159591,
0.0014700459,
-0.0291091241,
-0.0871590003,
-0.0755286738,
-0.0587703325,
0.0369228199,
0.001481729,
0.0097044585,
-0.0093188509,
0.0070507629,
-0.0109668449,
-0.0186694991,
0.1008767337,
-0.019856371,
-0.0005341379,
0.0081638619,
0.007235426,
-0.0210893396,
0.0742925778,
-0.0021106242,
0.0166241117,
-0.0062135146,
-0.0199859217,
-0.034645725,
-0.0207498502,
-0.0129675465,
-0.0180755053,
0.0185606964,
0.0260014627,
0.0052328999,
0.0116906809,
0.0635964945,
0.0596536472,
-0.0246523693,
-0.0186973866,
0.057117831,
0.03747214,
0.0435267538,
-0.0039569945,
0.0383645445,
0.0723379776,
-0.0347769558,
0.0567975938,
-0.0196691621,
0.0197492335,
-0.0234553628,
0.0050445595,
0.0651079789,
0.0251587983,
-0.0515125804,
-0.0439350344,
0.0080612861,
-0.0115037747,
0.0318891928,
0.0144234421,
0.0692000836,
-0.0019072288,
-0.0398192592,
0.0398573801,
0.0532965399,
-0.0114922253,
0.0028272341,
-0.0529386811,
0.0169950668,
0.0820292011,
-0.007885661,
-0.0288434196,
-0.0667236075,
-0.052083835,
-0.0045032916,
0.0332361981,
0.0107346755,
-0.0208648462,
0.0711093247,
-0.0657545701,
-0.0290308464,
-0.0291191563,
-0.0173218697,
0.0246090125,
-0.0579784997,
-0.0201885309,
-0.0186682455,
-0.005671585,
0.0252861679,
0.0064808386,
0.0062062335,
-0.0019652299,
0.0147653129,
0.0083976034,
0.0543393157,
0.0434808023,
-0.0119887553,
-0.0420543477,
-0.0050396714,
-0.0141235618,
0.015278412,
-0.0042724963,
-0.0681444257,
-0.0693490878,
0.0103000849,
0.0037737212,
-0.0284651332,
-0.0122774076,
-0.0499637127,
-0.0815026835,
0.0336402915,
0.0023355521,
-0.0010706215,
-0.0586951561,
-0.0062009059,
0.0329057835,
0.0469676703,
-0.0210993364,
0.0444592759,
-0.0011918254,
0.0030059419,
0.0431188419,
0.0028860562,
0.0512343608,
-0.0558504909,
-0.0247874949,
0.0042238915,
-0.036961861,
0.020576369,
-0.0100108869,
0.0142234499,
-0.0474404357,
-0.0048808772,
-0.0516432635,
-0.000627061,
-0.0304485764,
0.0097559188,
0.0171704125,
0.0360771529,
0.0012927647,
-0.030913718,
0.0008325978,
-0.004954102,
-0.0132339522,
-0.0435540639,
0.0041980445,
0.0363758132,
0.0028032397,
-0.0279017128,
0.0350287668,
-0.0032197651,
0.0059145126,
-0.0369095169,
-0.025694238,
-0.0464797728,
0.0088452287,
0.0054990519,
0.0495245792,
-0.0184719469,
-0.0114416583,
-0.0083287647,
0.0012075482,
-0.0161432382,
0.0564804971,
0.0169271808,
0.0447084829,
-0.0002290155,
-0.0504010916,
-0.0554355681,
0.0788537264,
-0.0102597186,
0.0455048755,
-0.0246394277,
0.0069840308,
-0.0216416009,
0.1090504006,
0.0311764125,
0.0309948325,
-0.0316078924,
-0.0398828611,
0.0007201984,
-0.0263094585,
-0.0174452886,
0.0306276791,
-0.0330510326,
0.0181732923,
-0.0215302352,
-0.0179267973,
0.0813490376,
-0.0355988592,
-0.0306000412,
-0.0454383269,
-0.0448183082,
-0.0256173164,
0.0456591435,
-0.0488842055,
0.0174027923,
0.0690027997,
-0.0554869734,
-0.0344396606,
-0.0239395481,
0.0067227576,
-0.0262425076,
0.0713927895,
-0.0348279849,
0.0180661399,
-0.0260829385,
-0.0452395231,
-0.0511690229,
-0.0493224151,
-0.0344036222,
0.0399284773,
0.0273272879,
-0.0081002899,
-0.0312742479,
0.033191666,
0.0100588417,
0.0331004076,
0.0066280859,
-0.0066606696,
-0.0229619108,
0.0582549833,
0.0311964974,
0.059019383,
-0.007260378,
0.0298541095,
0.0954598188,
0.0222988818,
0.01027779,
-0.0182715468,
-0.0301039536,
0.0266123693,
0.0627879128,
0.0066723437,
-0.0243770126,
0.0108084865,
0.0755999535,
-0.0415554345,
0.0079888701,
0.1280097961,
0.0171218161,
0.0020889463,
-0.0212117638,
-0.0369202346,
0.0200054459,
0.0294936262,
0.0158204902,
-0.080652371,
-0.0804263428,
0.0124230878,
0.0253184289,
0.0338466167,
-0.0209140517,
-0.0147373341,
-0.0567626357,
0.0635773987,
-0.0091549894,
-0.0567530878,
-0.0117818089,
-0.0369283818,
0.0306349676,
-0.0171349999,
0.0458267108,
0.0105537483,
0.0011339195,
-0.0261725616,
0.0499201491,
-0.0044644643,
-0.0349996276,
0.0453823805,
-0.0123017821,
0.0901164711,
-0.0162138641,
0.0451658517,
0.0057142666,
-0.0105900737,
-0.0224383753,
-0.0580465496,
-0.0059458851,
-0.0388120189,
0.0256358404,
-0.0245621782,
-0.0141503913,
0.004730165,
0.0337993354,
-0.0437327325,
-0.0397093147,
-0.0278840531,
0.0350111499,
-0.0457610749,
0.0305430032,
0.0075494465,
0.023096269,
0.0685652569,
0.0913159326,
0.0394197442,
-0.0361269377,
-0.0064630192,
-0.0222924091,
-0.0231757555,
-0.0264036637,
0.0418213494,
0.0175089575,
0.0291828141,
0.0229438394,
-0.0037675393,
-0.0331377201,
0.0202194247,
0.0216907673,
-0.0275625363,
0.0523024499,
0.0223852638,
0.0072027128,
-0.0388070308,
0.0123719601,
-0.0119356457,
0.0276313424,
-0.051595211,
-0.071445182,
0.0300878752,
-0.0668184012,
-0.0423893295,
0.0560294576,
-0.0657957867,
-0.0496757478,
-0.0131749762,
0.0322033465,
0.0175744873,
0.0588633083,
-0.0288969148,
-0.012241371,
-0.0001856448,
0.002018417,
-0.0376103856,
-0.0351748765,
0.0404841676,
0.0268819369,
-0.0005877315,
0.0310265049,
-0.0220677778,
0.0186671019,
-0.0211891588,
0.0298115909,
-0.0496514924,
-0.0451142378,
0.027752161,
-0.0190215893,
0.0736699179,
0.0153507022,
0.0079056332,
-0.0584446751,
0.0536458977,
0.0261450764,
-0.0140887126,
-0.0460207909,
-0.0204422455,
0.0007040965,
-0.0405685529,
0.0043429048,
-0.0155874407,
-0.031255018,
0.0198606029,
0.0044682082,
0.027218435,
0.0226043407,
-0.0170449372,
0.0022196167,
-0.0194354281,
-0.0073340088,
0.0363870338,
0.0351955257,
0.055627767,
0.0133288885,
0.1279734224,
-0.0026897129,
0.0100903865,
0.0153427962,
0.0332617424,
-0.0312399305,
-0.0568387546,
-0.0067581073,
-0.031937331,
0.0053920825,
-0.0195665974,
0.0138167161,
0.0280125309,
0.0294745527,
-0.0163788535,
0.0801931694,
-0.0243101977,
0.0038375848,
0.0497589521,
0.0304941554,
-0.0202438328,
0.0218892377,
0.0744960979,
-0.0446840525,
0.0192099866,
0.0105960183,
0.0439521745,
-0.0554654859,
-0.0422018319,
-0.0015566431,
0.0834488273,
-0.0288911276,
0.0223105289,
-0.0536309108,
-0.0321802758,
-0.0243296996,
0.0025944512,
0.0089850901,
-0.0014042469,
0.0366545469,
0.0224872828,
-0.0222376101,
-0.0149115678,
-0.0386214331,
-0.052839458,
0.0029333599,
0.0059422771,
-0.0157028697,
-7.012594486e-33,
-0.0457435735,
0.015023008,
0.005912052,
0.0110981436,
0.0194792561,
0.0214881971,
-0.0310658142,
-0.0125310207,
-0.0451554433,
-0.0167290941,
0.0107708722,
0.0093828924,
0.0215356704,
0.0446956791,
-0.0156627968,
-0.0266983174,
0.0610296279,
-0.0012543545,
0.0007263584,
0.0165643934,
0.0315524042,
0.028868217,
0.0437964313,
-0.0363222919,
0.0070850947,
0.0385128409,
0.0028463821,
0.0444361493,
0.015907703,
0.0380511433,
-0.0265624188,
0.0259097926,
0.0246590879,
-0.0493886769,
-0.0211246498,
0.0298675224,
-0.0979115367,
-0.0262861494,
0.0549190901,
0.0059801936,
-0.0617097914,
0.0275065601,
0.0000090446,
0.0089861043,
0.0254611112,
-0.0181729458,
0.0097356178,
0.0063755992,
0.0075050327,
0.0145313926,
-0.0324529707,
0.0269037206,
-0.057830818,
-0.0741195977,
0.0286253765,
0.0259972606,
0.0158753823,
-0.0159921627,
-0.0557235815,
-0.0033300228,
-0.035225939,
-0.00840424,
0.0540565476,
0.0376143046,
-0.0246334188,
0.0587301292,
0.0290621594,
-0.0209635012,
0.0322296061,
-0.0492271557,
-0.0125893382,
0.0489594676,
-0.0352103263,
-0.0041992022,
0.029398093,
0.0169204473,
-0.0362005308,
0.0332217403,
0.0084331911,
0.0701254755,
0.0108342273,
0.0525151566,
-0.031702362,
-0.0093225054,
-0.0496805161,
-0.047833439,
-0.0413720571,
-0.001375622,
0.0200282,
-0.0022724895,
-0.0159612261,
-0.0061561712,
0.0728417709,
-0.0197394434,
0.0159737654,
0.0225396343,
-0.0009045845,
-0.0182542447,
-0.0119898338,
0.037534792,
-0.0621626116,
-0.0503779687,
0.0318282358,
0.0220939834,
-0.0000984289,
0.0058991211,
0.0080409562,
0.0048061367,
-0.032913968,
0.0110657876,
-0.040375147,
0.0307212863,
-0.0605918616,
0.0409400389,
0.0607664883,
-0.0037185096,
-0.0288931858,
0.0575114079,
0.0014038995,
-0.0240828712,
-0.0348797888,
-0.0268038306,
0.0038945724,
0.032744579,
-0.0113278888,
-0.0038076087,
0.0135031035,
-0.0572754182,
0.0151451929,
-0.0168050751,
0.0053209676,
0.0231167171,
3.032e-7,
0.0275305305,
0.0265480895,
-0.0047414009,
0.0065121436,
0.0071510957,
0.0642938167,
-0.0062543163,
0.0125620877,
0.0000137595,
-0.0376515202,
0.0235975571,
0.031938564,
0.0214113444,
0.0177279133,
-0.0989679471,
0.0499265231,
0.0000168339,
-0.0083415825,
-0.0262761377,
0.0020042062,
0.0906623602,
0.0890130103,
-0.0008897393,
-0.0073599978,
0.0367259383,
-0.0222893897,
0.0011369621,
-0.0212401114,
0.0305198319,
0.0197477713,
-0.011213514,
0.0259816162,
-0.0097802589,
0.0536635853,
0.0010202614,
0.0441977531,
-0.0106187034,
0.0553722754,
-0.0062594721,
-0.054314062,
-0.0290028062,
-0.003152506,
0.012683521,
-0.0565951504,
0.0496707819,
-0.0524938367,
-0.045515947,
-0.0561632961,
-0.0332318768,
0.0161184426,
-0.0165373012,
0.0320832841,
0.0116096251,
0.0106292823,
-0.0116969571,
-0.0423986949,
-0.0412534624,
-0.0789381564,
0.0063424325,
0.02417925,
-0.0315656923,
-0.0190900601,
-0.00803247,
-0.0683115125,
0.0440832488,
-0.040824499,
-0.0055311983,
2.441916174e-34,
0.0318041369,
-0.0001290248,
0.0101214005,
0.0373051725,
0.0272826795,
-0.0110951886,
-0.1012560502,
-0.0048187673,
0.0360847786,
-0.0549665615,
-0.0084350985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20850v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20850v1
|
Improving Reward Models with Synthetic Critiques
| 2024-05-31T14:33:07 | 2024-05-31T14:33:07 |
Zihuiwen Ye, Fraser Greenlee-Scott, Max Bartolo, Phil Blunsom, Jon Ander Campos, Matthias Gallé
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reward models (RM) play a critical role in aligning language models through
the process of reinforcement learning from human feedback. RMs are trained to
predict a score reflecting human preference, which requires significant time
and cost for human annotation. Additionally, RMs tend to quickly overfit on
superficial features in the training set, hindering their generalization
performance on unseen distributions. We propose a novel approach using
synthetic natural language critiques generated by large language models to
provide additional feedback, evaluating aspects such as instruction following,
correctness, and style. This offers richer signals and more robust features for
RMs to assess and score on. We demonstrate that high-quality critiques improve
the performance and data efficiency of RMs initialized from different
pretrained models. Conversely, we also show that low-quality critiques
negatively impact performance. Furthermore, incorporating critiques enhances
the interpretability and robustness of RM training.
|
[
0.0694668442,
0.0433217846,
-0.002440426,
-0.0065194294,
-0.0038916026,
0.0166132171,
-0.0453255288,
-0.017718887,
-0.0533138439,
-0.0545974113,
-0.0797675252,
-0.0312893242,
-0.006606848,
0.0098194722,
0.0009191305,
-0.090724051,
0.0506301932,
-0.0255089886,
0.024877226,
0.0190532766,
0.0025462755,
0.0080714272,
-0.0018765936,
0.0579923391,
0.0071609751,
-0.0208702423,
-0.008364466,
0.0007409434,
0.0339317583,
-0.0464339852,
0.0288034398,
0.0731607899,
0.030853916,
0.0410826951,
0.0000019333,
-0.0256503727,
0.0030725929,
-0.0004932862,
-0.0181570314,
0.0238034967,
0.0832229853,
0.0214306619,
0.001322069,
0.0038027407,
-0.0415911973,
-0.0205651876,
0.0376348495,
0.0611661598,
0.0747800246,
0.0804192871,
0.0125531489,
-0.0107473666,
-0.0336709656,
-0.0355038606,
0.0352370366,
-0.0289650988,
0.0027554585,
0.046665132,
0.0295514055,
0.0176332369,
-0.0138871735,
-0.0188096799,
0.0432786271,
-0.0218800008,
0.0376004018,
0.0330968015,
0.0087060044,
-0.0005190568,
-0.0419265106,
0.0483194776,
-0.0155126955,
-0.0118516274,
-0.0112319812,
-0.0303643029,
0.0208586436,
-0.0039262953,
-0.0053634821,
0.0230452139,
0.0010676557,
0.0260496251,
0.009783864,
0.0095860949,
0.0409653522,
0.0206620544,
0.0418919846,
0.0056250961,
-0.0059258076,
-0.041972667,
0.0146054085,
0.018783452,
-0.0662148222,
-0.0452299528,
-0.0118800979,
-0.006256592,
-0.0483461469,
0.0207219757,
-0.0595133938,
-0.0107029229,
-0.0079211732,
-0.011725829,
0.0972612873,
0.0284727011,
-0.0024188547,
0.0351032279,
-0.0140302023,
0.0491999984,
0.0144283827,
0.0269473996,
-0.042554196,
0.0413456224,
-0.0656230599,
-0.0071963808,
-0.0102473432,
0.0241010301,
-0.0328823738,
-0.022452997,
-0.0656940192,
0.0096402196,
-0.0400558673,
0.0258786362,
0.0494052395,
0.0580718219,
-0.0466321334,
0.0300310049,
-0.0864289328,
-0.0119079193,
-0.0232573207,
0.0094032139,
0.0240714401,
-0.0105733024,
-0.0119883018,
-0.0032872441,
-0.0259246174,
-0.0112728821,
0.0146364197,
0.0607023872,
0.007127637,
-0.0329900645,
-0.0067348955,
-0.0152828684,
-0.0240449347,
-0.0462084934,
0.0038739315,
-0.0437200963,
0.0042415126,
-0.051904209,
-0.0242520571,
-0.0090841632,
0.0245747194,
0.0144213289,
-0.0127832945,
0.0627220944,
-0.0219801292,
-0.0058946013,
-0.0241511874,
-0.0123984944,
-0.0035977319,
0.0493769497,
0.0549210161,
0.0201880466,
-0.0003722429,
0.0024789614,
0.0351856016,
0.0097588794,
0.0108324075,
0.0067032976,
-0.0222695414,
-0.008566143,
0.0066387798,
0.0476731285,
0.0657745972,
0.0366571471,
-0.03779855,
0.0222550016,
0.0678667426,
0.0438579246,
0.0131540159,
-0.0038909081,
0.0793344527,
0.0223221201,
0.0077588451,
-0.0098570902,
-0.0560734905,
0.0105829965,
0.0009867589,
-0.0022986312,
0.0159380361,
-0.0312381852,
-0.0061630527,
-0.0816900581,
-0.0102625592,
-0.0004028038,
0.0405342206,
0.0247254856,
0.0532293767,
0.0299111232,
-0.0586377978,
-0.0489937626,
0.0497820675,
-0.021833431,
0.0197193641,
-0.0446759649,
0.0495735034,
0.1343181431,
0.036457587,
-0.0256626215,
0.0174397528,
-0.0206277203,
-0.0418743007,
0.0338472836,
0.0604713596,
-0.0379661396,
-0.0292249694,
-0.0299424529,
-0.0430618227,
-0.0293117873,
0.0355809368,
0.0234302655,
0.0351882614,
-0.033981476,
-0.0001749793,
-0.0017812906,
-0.1033216193,
0.0527618825,
0.0342733301,
-0.0240038559,
0.0136362016,
-0.0117668826,
0.0181026999,
0.0199311357,
-0.0119658764,
0.0149269234,
0.0214010086,
-0.0039370419,
-0.0175303239,
0.0236561056,
-0.0539477617,
-0.0597354844,
0.0010703263,
-0.0106249629,
-0.0086458651,
0.0465980805,
-0.0260593053,
-0.0199164264,
0.0084145963,
-0.0501397066,
0.0348159596,
-0.0149261225,
0.0334144607,
-0.0012389474,
-0.0349849984,
-0.0428337902,
0.0304171555,
-0.0151117379,
0.0217079781,
-0.0352555439,
-0.0082037617,
-0.0302446801,
-0.045644667,
-0.0209517479,
-0.0126401009,
-0.0057768943,
0.0402490795,
0.0270165093,
0.0265640337,
-0.0483239442,
-0.0085126245,
-0.0531586334,
-0.0041057356,
-0.0232898109,
0.0160366222,
0.0390124358,
-0.0406076387,
-0.0153644392,
-0.018481316,
-0.0249122549,
-0.0437310413,
0.0212721955,
-0.0047468934,
0.0402107351,
0.0172331315,
-0.0005475859,
-0.0597979613,
-0.0142210769,
-0.026403144,
0.0310927462,
0.019420078,
0.0556931309,
-0.0621835329,
0.0082023079,
-0.0137622422,
0.0259413086,
-0.0100226235,
-0.0422458611,
0.0334754735,
-0.0033187899,
0.0225568917,
0.0878576189,
0.0104855327,
0.0572501905,
0.0567238629,
0.0225761048,
-0.0606613234,
0.0083993189,
-0.0374591835,
-0.0329594314,
-0.0296032801,
-0.0458278097,
0.0299183894,
0.101662226,
0.0173732098,
0.0061841407,
-0.0964104086,
0.0361729264,
-0.0350803994,
-0.05500561,
-0.0101631759,
-0.0209930316,
-0.0018737365,
0.0123152826,
-0.0373669937,
-0.0561862104,
0.0940097943,
-0.0044811685,
-0.0088457363,
-0.0508273542,
-0.0095416419,
-0.0114803361,
0.0284269936,
0.0027935428,
0.0205496084,
0.009534644,
-0.003134842,
-0.0241106339,
-0.0238659251,
0.0501331761,
-0.0244154464,
0.0018972491,
-0.050350327,
-0.0176186003,
0.0268364903,
-0.0256154202,
-0.0688803568,
-0.0422954522,
-0.0195728019,
-0.0047684256,
0.0008149795,
-0.0197549649,
-0.0072519383,
-0.0100537408,
0.0088286242,
0.0158056896,
-0.0129567226,
-0.016644109,
-0.0051909499,
-0.0503322855,
0.0778371394,
-0.0017800108,
-0.0053393142,
-0.0636007115,
0.0051846323,
0.0255841967,
0.0389032029,
0.0218439158,
-0.0294051487,
0.017460702,
0.0125327948,
-0.0417000875,
0.0178047717,
0.0486438721,
0.0334485024,
-0.0766922757,
-0.0306187402,
0.1045464501,
0.0538556613,
-0.0223189648,
0.0266902726,
-0.0046431622,
0.0348753259,
0.0299959965,
0.0295209736,
-0.0721402913,
-0.0288607683,
-0.0043343198,
0.0604104251,
-0.0071829082,
-0.0069798026,
0.0102046505,
-0.1258101612,
0.0071312613,
-0.0202818606,
-0.0398960859,
-0.0083998088,
-0.0141690494,
-0.0272730011,
-0.0274961144,
-0.0127578825,
0.0226059631,
-0.006714785,
0.0180565137,
0.0359602459,
-0.0055374717,
-0.0565234721,
0.0373400077,
-0.0565634668,
0.0528443865,
0.1191925779,
0.0040449323,
0.0162672922,
-0.037660148,
0.0008287635,
0.0362084322,
0.0143653117,
0.0034065603,
0.046334479,
-0.0346524417,
-0.0100609399,
-0.0275934711,
0.0317418277,
0.0089007402,
-0.0136515507,
-0.0137886778,
0.0386491083,
0.0041379947,
-0.0124044353,
-0.0155573934,
0.0291098393,
0.0237401072,
0.0900496915,
0.0175661705,
-0.0841386989,
-0.0174792446,
-0.0217499509,
-0.0566262901,
-0.0744226128,
-0.058304891,
0.0483612195,
-0.0089893984,
-0.0249348693,
-0.0905746296,
-0.0737731084,
0.0094696134,
0.020102581,
0.0139804333,
-0.0438290313,
-0.0386519842,
-0.0007613617,
-0.0257143825,
0.0779434592,
-0.0165520404,
0.01102152,
-0.0497859381,
-0.0137526272,
-0.0118180346,
-0.0461730286,
-0.0292902309,
-0.038777072,
-0.0582670309,
-0.0564567447,
-0.0179088078,
0.1018407792,
0.0106074698,
0.0574232526,
-0.0147146406,
-0.0418406017,
0.0139409155,
-0.001941944,
-0.0399375409,
-0.0135024246,
0.0378662534,
0.0245479327,
0.0185698755,
-0.0010073815,
-0.0355827436,
0.0201236308,
0.0164499171,
0.0546103232,
0.0186483264,
0.0437486954,
0.0666962713,
-0.0315786041,
0.0601437911,
-0.03815699,
-0.025583813,
-0.0228836499,
-0.0088986754,
-0.0381442867,
-0.068712078,
-0.0438776165,
0.0097174319,
0.028870808,
0.0056065312,
-0.017083589,
-0.0016415193,
-0.0303995684,
0.0369033888,
-0.0362781882,
0.0109489243,
0.0564919524,
0.0055061923,
0.0061519803,
0.0136202741,
-0.0082508409,
-0.0118424362,
-0.00687645,
0.0221424717,
0.0327598639,
0.0622823015,
0.0252962429,
0.003559625,
-0.0109119788,
0.012631231,
-0.0458890833,
-0.006700926,
-0.0404717848,
0.004362484,
0.0319833718,
-0.0125452522,
0.0290489439,
-0.0291495696,
0.0129482234,
0.0052475007,
0.022153439,
-0.0305377413,
-0.0305614993,
0.0481943786,
0.0319485515,
0.0014944504,
-0.0484618172,
0.0416018814,
0.0154559538,
0.0531101413,
-0.0367367454,
-0.0207194835,
-0.037837401,
0.000562017,
0.0085358554,
0.0100251576,
-0.02395753,
0.011768545,
-0.0516573563,
-0.0528972968,
-0.0274682306,
0.0844590813,
0.0139444629,
0.0007298745,
0.0718982816,
0.0315884873,
-0.059322916,
-0.0245670155,
-0.0529395789,
-0.0326662734,
0.001625752,
-0.0042544431,
-0.055574663,
-5.815229328e-33,
-0.0225471072,
-0.0392046273,
0.0240637418,
-0.0077833817,
-0.0502242893,
-0.01906587,
-0.0309143104,
0.0153105194,
0.040827889,
0.0331525169,
0.0004296945,
0.0117184808,
0.0022364419,
0.0007489314,
0.0289079584,
-0.0140361823,
0.0623104014,
-0.0171086434,
-0.069183059,
-0.010465838,
0.0106077623,
0.0139122093,
0.0836811662,
-0.0432614423,
0.0780154839,
0.0251525752,
-0.0379256532,
0.0232892446,
-0.0023923386,
0.0634722039,
-0.0073905969,
0.0188975353,
-0.0031722304,
-0.0313610584,
-0.0097126886,
0.0092108389,
-0.0427344702,
0.0020422093,
0.0446215533,
-0.0031554818,
-0.0425877161,
-0.0304984711,
0.049622111,
-0.0240057595,
-0.0332338288,
0.0339373052,
0.0364758521,
-0.0307216272,
0.0057414612,
-0.0117978519,
-0.068575874,
0.0041762008,
-0.0277524963,
-0.0365999416,
0.0007733935,
0.06143618,
-0.0207704585,
0.0100771487,
-0.017184861,
0.0400929637,
0.0539668985,
0.0297174193,
0.0505959354,
0.0560483634,
0.0300978646,
0.0492121316,
-0.0008500708,
0.0105962148,
-0.0179928634,
0.0111413766,
0.0441835262,
0.0238328446,
0.0604599454,
0.0589424558,
0.0444878712,
0.0235066209,
-0.0201324672,
0.0298955701,
-0.0356334113,
0.0169663206,
0.0285448637,
0.0017184371,
-0.0662488118,
-0.0091969324,
-0.0694779232,
-0.0124654146,
-0.0176407322,
-0.0322455205,
0.0483731404,
0.0393916853,
-0.0100522479,
-0.0177378468,
-0.0079471627,
-0.017632531,
0.0057765404,
-0.0316614658,
-0.0274925828,
0.01387583,
-0.0263071153,
-0.0471880548,
-0.0603585467,
-0.0073529738,
0.0319357365,
0.0126013095,
0.0041839369,
0.0109940255,
0.0365395993,
0.0152194425,
-0.0472214557,
0.0222246945,
-0.0119302971,
0.0265741609,
0.0045831259,
0.0018089104,
0.0812627897,
0.0040598582,
-0.0558984652,
0.0429864749,
-0.0062115225,
-0.0076619792,
-0.0484581031,
0.0139898127,
0.0056648827,
0.0285324734,
-0.0103870109,
0.0114946133,
-0.0176995192,
-0.0053258953,
0.0226130337,
-0.046634268,
-0.0184075963,
0.0123544447,
2.529e-7,
0.0193084087,
0.0416996442,
0.0037111409,
0.0002650511,
-0.0033917231,
0.0653139204,
-0.0034523611,
0.009066103,
0.0115664117,
0.0108317025,
0.0412118658,
0.0273748096,
0.0411489122,
-0.0124531779,
-0.0615309216,
-0.0086024636,
-0.0918889567,
-0.0197833274,
-0.0150748584,
-0.0310695488,
0.0228238534,
0.0668835938,
0.0440697707,
0.0072946246,
0.0331769884,
0.007722158,
0.068746686,
-0.0556912906,
-0.014956289,
0.0043957299,
0.0107143605,
0.0075225737,
-0.0260349531,
-0.0215163976,
-0.0060766339,
0.0257084295,
0.002483008,
0.0552696399,
-0.0201141089,
-0.0103065921,
-0.026339788,
0.0247003268,
0.0053581037,
-0.0310835093,
0.0101205297,
-0.0811044723,
-0.0059646731,
-0.0365600362,
0.0024196059,
-0.0070865559,
0.0213290844,
-0.0406339578,
-0.0148662049,
0.005490405,
0.0000988134,
0.0231205784,
0.0014886676,
-0.0674780011,
-0.0361539125,
0.0456016287,
-0.0125872735,
-0.0201666001,
-0.0335761793,
0.0259666983,
-0.0055317883,
-0.0741610229,
-0.0167173035,
2.116902318e-34,
0.045549795,
-0.0100940671,
0.0322552696,
-0.0042489581,
0.0362828784,
0.0606145635,
-0.0056670345,
-0.0013282368,
0.070056662,
-0.0495744646,
-0.0461539552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20846v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20846v1
|
Don't Buy it! Reassessing the Ad Understanding Abilities of Contrastive Multimodal Models
| 2024-05-31T14:31:46 | 2024-05-31T14:31:46 |
A. Bavaresco, A. Testoni, R. Fernández
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Image-based advertisements are complex multimodal stimuli that often contain
unusual visual elements and figurative language. Previous research on automatic
ad understanding has reported impressive zero-shot accuracy of contrastive
vision-and-language models (VLMs) on an ad-explanation retrieval task. Here, we
examine the original task setup and show that contrastive VLMs can solve it by
exploiting grounding heuristics. To control for this confound, we introduce
TRADE, a new evaluation test set with adversarial grounded explanations. While
these explanations look implausible to humans, we show that they "fool" four
different contrastive VLMs. Our findings highlight the need for an improved
operationalisation of automatic ad understanding that truly evaluates VLMs'
multimodal reasoning abilities. We make our code and TRADE available at
https://github.com/dmg-illc/trade .
|
[
0.0396469831,
0.0648484603,
-0.0353904814,
0.0453794561,
-0.0076066121,
0.0046110139,
0.0615417957,
-0.0245515704,
0.0017499952,
-0.0638442785,
-0.0266205091,
-0.0775011182,
0.0240197163,
0.0600298308,
0.041112598,
-0.0759101957,
-0.0079039587,
-0.0280697942,
-0.0014350624,
0.0027701964,
-0.0112381866,
0.0075484593,
-0.0285835806,
0.02641223,
0.0372104868,
-0.0528228953,
-0.0152602252,
0.0080333892,
0.019332584,
-0.0201978274,
0.0060819713,
0.0307417624,
0.0703685284,
0.0148586929,
0.0000021184,
-0.0208167639,
0.0247413367,
-0.0061629703,
-0.0207541678,
0.0466173142,
0.026466215,
-0.0059486018,
0.0260676909,
-0.0118132122,
-0.0113568753,
0.0128730824,
0.064291738,
0.0776388943,
0.0371447504,
0.0527644418,
-0.0108772637,
-0.0534543246,
-0.0167828351,
-0.0140271764,
0.0177916493,
-0.0240639932,
0.0050977548,
-0.0010724925,
-0.010192411,
0.0105898697,
-0.0447686836,
-0.0017060232,
0.0394478031,
0.0034755904,
-0.0199449733,
0.0548157059,
0.0027656034,
-0.0230155755,
-0.0208971109,
0.0705969781,
-0.0183599144,
0.0094020469,
-0.0142448628,
0.0174760949,
-0.0177899357,
-0.0159356184,
-0.051949501,
0.0078160297,
-0.0061042062,
0.0162869729,
-0.037651632,
-0.0064179027,
0.0250821821,
0.0217150636,
-0.0170320217,
0.035948351,
-0.002631685,
0.0078321407,
0.0154482983,
-0.0034676774,
-0.0401777811,
-0.0150805824,
-0.0138093112,
-0.0134363137,
0.0029268719,
0.0018976992,
-0.0039220923,
-0.022366982,
0.0014142751,
-0.0415579975,
0.0848884061,
0.0211973991,
-0.0988479108,
0.0587138236,
-0.0230376534,
0.0695803091,
-0.0432190709,
0.0312430244,
0.0041647791,
0.0477225073,
-0.0444463752,
-0.014060664,
0.0168090537,
-0.0242739934,
-0.0906866342,
-0.0230309572,
-0.0200169999,
0.0026994119,
-0.0301659144,
-0.0066776318,
-0.017115809,
0.0722758546,
0.0030556477,
-0.0129645681,
-0.0488395728,
0.0192303024,
-0.0342343003,
0.0200228207,
-0.000558114,
-0.0602122061,
-0.0087825991,
0.0754608512,
-0.0268841013,
-0.071305491,
-0.0052897236,
0.0788777694,
-0.0159907918,
-0.0283970609,
-0.0591141023,
-0.0148367574,
-0.0398073457,
-0.0595968403,
0.0447894,
-0.0018186196,
-0.0071939132,
0.0093838414,
-0.0165881347,
-0.0578231439,
-0.0191105288,
-0.0071715796,
-0.0498224087,
0.1173661649,
0.017820403,
-0.0128803561,
-0.0126180891,
0.03541179,
-0.0247364957,
0.0369234905,
-0.014107191,
0.0933454633,
0.0212016068,
-0.0292733032,
0.0141553003,
-0.0169918574,
0.0351131968,
-0.0172833335,
-0.0511985496,
0.0026076117,
-0.0369782485,
-0.0054472284,
0.0493552834,
0.0133862961,
-0.0253615715,
-0.0573687479,
0.0953937843,
0.0178073533,
-0.0150305433,
-0.036101941,
0.0446519144,
0.0038860813,
-0.0218809769,
0.0634230077,
-0.0758605525,
0.0521590486,
-0.0421841741,
-0.0301547665,
0.0285251588,
0.0367090814,
-0.04840241,
-0.0268843248,
-0.0095150014,
-0.0025280782,
0.048365321,
0.0037774597,
0.0470859483,
0.0064561297,
-0.071219489,
-0.0111894412,
0.0224046167,
0.0179837737,
-0.0315617882,
-0.0291636772,
0.0415654145,
0.0703873262,
0.0323145688,
0.0163151063,
0.046966143,
-0.001525434,
0.042509038,
0.0330521613,
0.0378062502,
0.035501454,
0.0316183306,
-0.0093590776,
-0.0490628071,
-0.1241852418,
0.0236582626,
0.0686073005,
-0.0166884866,
-0.0139525766,
0.0043917298,
-0.0533506535,
0.024781581,
0.0058466247,
0.028325282,
-0.0060314629,
-0.021741854,
0.0371621996,
0.0262651294,
-0.0065417471,
0.0050397096,
0.0185907222,
-0.0028935489,
-0.0417185947,
-0.0034464672,
0.0252704583,
0.0088516911,
-0.019789299,
0.0144365579,
-0.0810378864,
-0.0151640065,
0.0413836725,
-0.0152422786,
-0.0034399941,
0.0749810264,
-0.017126739,
0.0160256401,
-0.0313658044,
-0.0298543945,
0.0248271469,
0.0700719431,
0.0250140671,
0.0762727261,
0.0033030976,
-0.0088670533,
-0.0047409637,
0.0036089497,
0.0267847478,
-0.0260492638,
0.0150476824,
0.0005739834,
-0.0196871273,
-0.0041479543,
-0.0218099076,
-0.0259266011,
-0.0355833955,
0.0533303879,
-0.0537133478,
-0.0291599557,
-0.013962972,
0.0026967607,
0.0089050671,
-0.0408983901,
0.0070797801,
-0.0165849309,
-0.0086926706,
0.0153023442,
-0.0210294556,
0.0440457053,
0.0200402308,
0.0029006463,
-0.0206545908,
-0.0128985057,
0.0136715006,
0.0194716398,
0.0978701487,
0.0265143216,
0.0046508065,
-0.0247005541,
0.008591827,
-0.0326736197,
0.0173965525,
-0.0307809841,
-0.0390658192,
0.0146674095,
0.0099613303,
-0.0154121444,
0.0780778527,
0.0140159633,
0.0537711903,
0.0339577831,
-0.0005971821,
-0.0455772467,
-0.0308770929,
0.0243247394,
0.0217954051,
-0.0060453289,
-0.0338425525,
-0.0189670529,
0.08981359,
0.0310972501,
0.018627394,
-0.0237581432,
0.0526012778,
0.0338555314,
-0.0736640245,
-0.0667080432,
0.0185475834,
0.0034635908,
0.0853826627,
-0.0524522513,
-0.0532919466,
0.0922643542,
-0.0255333576,
-0.0334260538,
0.0548051074,
-0.0171992593,
0.0084802601,
0.0383725017,
-0.0133250169,
0.033835724,
0.0277785137,
-0.0266856626,
-0.0263373088,
-0.0479997434,
0.0182027705,
0.0057237018,
0.0435118824,
-0.0277313907,
0.0023381372,
0.0083546853,
-0.0253839754,
-0.0573330261,
-0.0601025224,
-0.0213091858,
-0.0087010805,
-0.0224584527,
0.0004313255,
-0.0896631628,
0.0540068038,
0.0236648936,
-0.014263114,
-0.0256720278,
0.0090215923,
0.0177148934,
0.0320292115,
0.0460903943,
-0.0102328844,
-0.0038769273,
-0.0463992059,
0.0201473124,
0.0144525273,
-0.0364847295,
0.0152207427,
-0.0723275617,
0.0421075076,
-0.0203963947,
0.0386805944,
-0.013311374,
0.0078509087,
0.0034062269,
-0.0169738308,
0.0074951653,
0.0629785433,
-0.0036141928,
-0.0050440039,
0.0151195126,
0.0035136663,
-0.0327024497,
0.013724179,
-0.0003570517,
-0.0657591075,
-0.0651236698,
-0.0267763827,
0.0082976706,
0.050651826,
0.0143819405,
-0.0143980002,
-0.0633749738,
0.0693373531,
0.0002781278,
-0.0101703685,
-0.0304428078,
-0.0219952036,
-0.0204160325,
-0.0135465655,
0.0304895043,
0.0115768649,
0.0232246686,
0.0071213753,
-0.002854933,
0.0871067196,
-0.0479390211,
0.0137531487,
-0.002840752,
-0.0207152646,
0.0586941391,
0.0154971844,
0.0013512882,
-0.0976948515,
-0.0173767246,
-0.0011066264,
0.0358149223,
-0.0009620229,
0.0759354308,
-0.0066414713,
-0.0271656252,
0.0121249296,
0.050083492,
-0.0400836803,
-0.0197068639,
-0.0325129479,
0.0080962712,
-0.0143701667,
-0.0421817265,
-0.0194005985,
0.0183738992,
0.0067556226,
0.0686407313,
0.0321804807,
-0.0359870568,
-0.0370659865,
-0.0429836698,
-0.0195784047,
-0.0658318922,
-0.0340741016,
0.0113927945,
0.0274708681,
0.0128340675,
-0.0268504173,
-0.0190392956,
0.0043835198,
0.0166345686,
-0.0120889274,
-0.0317953676,
-0.0972154811,
0.0172104947,
-0.0319014564,
0.0585669763,
0.0020853926,
0.0324741341,
-0.0106853759,
-0.0035633673,
0.0236232039,
-0.116130814,
-0.033854492,
0.00512945,
-0.0149773201,
-0.0328582153,
-0.0202788543,
0.0344214514,
0.0179918949,
0.0584663004,
0.007526252,
-0.0190958716,
-0.0175587405,
0.0426942259,
0.0119340578,
-0.014629527,
0.0456897877,
0.0122398101,
0.0067842919,
0.0102357874,
-0.0178316813,
0.0509399548,
0.0325330645,
0.0137703698,
-0.0018322243,
0.0205745287,
0.0431941859,
-0.0084955702,
0.0844635889,
-0.0379024744,
-0.0006841833,
-0.0038983305,
0.0182030201,
0.0383727327,
-0.0263173841,
-0.0440894365,
-0.0105652614,
0.0012338992,
0.0103109134,
0.0008915226,
-0.0157395583,
-0.0309178196,
0.0168375485,
0.0073010693,
-0.0024689452,
0.0350747891,
0.0201323591,
-0.0071677174,
0.0275071021,
0.0117081376,
0.0351576246,
-0.0110205095,
0.0676547512,
0.0203451831,
0.0769462138,
0.0229795333,
-0.0091164652,
-0.0234757904,
0.0049997317,
-0.0142739732,
-0.0163809657,
0.0021592025,
0.0264576524,
0.0572357029,
-0.0180690177,
0.000069458,
-0.0142007172,
-0.0055920854,
0.0071677696,
0.0226881225,
0.0323436558,
-0.0244029462,
0.0331538655,
0.0194768757,
0.0156445149,
-0.0108245919,
0.0493677817,
-0.0017120937,
0.0239008255,
0.0020784277,
-0.0320715196,
-0.0366377011,
-0.0340088569,
0.0464754291,
0.0379949026,
0.0239035729,
0.024176484,
-0.0530307069,
-0.0820835233,
-0.026352752,
0.0107268011,
0.0049341982,
0.0231647491,
0.0149795786,
0.0814593658,
0.0018967624,
0.0024266746,
-0.0044022077,
0.0064614317,
-0.0383711867,
0.0204714704,
-0.0381146111,
-6.763625517e-33,
-0.0053014848,
-0.060871128,
-0.0141692087,
-0.0708998591,
0.0429427549,
0.0339021422,
-0.0483473279,
-0.0304903127,
0.0078870095,
0.0307788532,
0.020082077,
0.0067713675,
-0.0017442681,
0.0433048904,
-0.013491693,
-0.0475663655,
0.0255868584,
0.0066783307,
-0.0344810113,
-0.0234435052,
0.0371125452,
0.0210743938,
0.0318145826,
-0.0438832678,
0.0356561355,
0.0124187041,
-0.0491866656,
0.0057240394,
-0.0089709517,
0.0692094415,
-0.0319284201,
0.0249153022,
0.0251070578,
-0.0009955101,
0.0012524794,
0.0146861449,
-0.0751362741,
0.0197021272,
0.0880201906,
-0.0012475745,
-0.0754919872,
0.0030776688,
0.025969021,
-0.0263738465,
0.0023374592,
-0.009328329,
0.0309117045,
-0.0486913323,
0.0298370644,
0.0430460759,
-0.0258365925,
-0.0196306352,
-0.0438296311,
-0.0373710506,
0.0383843854,
0.0518122353,
0.0168744456,
0.0732105225,
-0.0375002325,
0.0079779802,
-0.0431884602,
-0.057475511,
0.0886036158,
0.0098395869,
-0.0206155218,
0.0610514022,
0.0220081359,
-0.0282460302,
-0.0563306585,
-0.0367197581,
-0.0232128184,
0.0618065856,
0.0553663857,
0.0424082242,
0.0419034138,
0.0247455891,
-0.003971017,
0.0092193503,
-0.0187242422,
-0.0003058192,
0.0461396091,
0.0240871515,
-0.0333052725,
-0.0013213272,
-0.0271777026,
-0.0678937212,
-0.0654677674,
-0.0659875795,
0.0530296676,
-0.0260282513,
-0.0347865447,
0.0134859132,
0.0348721109,
-0.0499706306,
0.0091851503,
0.0183744449,
0.021566933,
-0.0069011422,
0.0069987131,
-0.0054582087,
0.0077335108,
-0.0015795145,
0.0439418741,
0.0139443818,
-0.0071028383,
-0.0066391821,
0.0390629098,
0.0002419144,
0.0196046885,
-0.0095240995,
-0.0500855632,
-0.0162675977,
0.0025504967,
0.0210408811,
0.0240834281,
0.0166603215,
-0.0630971864,
0.0049156416,
0.0000820841,
-0.0146941533,
-0.0104222782,
-0.0423766077,
-0.043042548,
0.0680929199,
-0.0478999875,
-0.0257474072,
-0.0206727609,
-0.0905553624,
0.0402674116,
-0.0937706381,
-0.0056110439,
0.018209286,
2.846e-7,
-0.0053926734,
0.024921583,
-0.0131903039,
-0.0092123672,
0.0505801961,
0.0617397651,
-0.0159638841,
-0.0027449685,
0.0009285362,
-0.0712609664,
-0.0233830139,
0.0531949513,
0.0250297971,
-0.0065874853,
-0.004297331,
0.0482228138,
-0.0319016203,
-0.0470978431,
-0.033860594,
-0.016201539,
0.0114236558,
0.0469937623,
0.016255118,
-0.0216551404,
0.0401886031,
-0.0392076001,
0.052471824,
-0.012654962,
0.0051180851,
-0.0642402023,
0.0006033657,
-0.0089591723,
-0.004460867,
-0.0140705062,
0.0106827458,
-0.0375470258,
0.0390644558,
0.0310828388,
0.0054324842,
-0.0486465693,
-0.0772589818,
-0.0280856621,
-0.0329569988,
-0.0403804891,
0.0691876933,
-0.0297077261,
-0.0504699536,
-0.0106214713,
-0.0490206853,
-0.0364159085,
-0.0073861568,
0.0034961463,
0.0133113973,
0.0021539794,
-0.0147446841,
-0.0276044365,
-0.0152776781,
-0.0591722466,
-0.000755739,
0.0219032876,
-0.0197280459,
0.0111110909,
-0.0166010447,
0.0023388474,
0.0496163666,
-0.0516610816,
-0.0583963245,
2.092007092e-34,
0.0519099869,
0.0287959874,
0.0129537424,
-0.0152168898,
0.0063753938,
0.0177605506,
-0.0281450879,
-0.040185038,
0.0444904976,
-0.0287217796,
-0.0103973197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20835v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20835v3
|
Outliers and Calibration Sets have Diminishing Effect on Quantization of Modern LLMs
| 2024-05-31T14:24:33 | 2024-06-05T09:53:18 |
Davide Paglieri, Saurabh Dash, Tim Rocktäschel, Jack Parker-Holder
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Post-Training Quantization (PTQ) enhances the efficiency of Large Language
Models (LLMs) by enabling faster operation and compatibility with more
accessible hardware through reduced memory usage, at the cost of small
performance drops. We explore the role of calibration sets in PTQ, specifically
their effect on hidden activations in various notable open-source LLMs.
Calibration sets are crucial for evaluating activation magnitudes and
identifying outliers, which can distort the quantization range and negatively
impact performance. Our analysis reveals a marked contrast in quantization
effectiveness across models. The older OPT model, upon which much of the
quantization literature is based, shows significant performance deterioration
and high susceptibility to outliers with varying calibration sets. In contrast,
newer models like Llama-2 7B, Llama-3 8B, Command-R 35B, and Mistral 7B
demonstrate strong robustness, with Mistral 7B showing near-immunity to
outliers and stable activations. These findings suggest a shift in PTQ
strategies might be needed. As advancements in pre-training methods reduce the
relevance of outliers, there is an emerging need to reassess the fundamentals
of current quantization literature. The emphasis should pivot towards
optimizing inference speed, rather than primarily focusing on outlier
preservation, to align with the evolving characteristics of state-of-the-art
LLMs.
|
[
-0.0432507396,
0.0242730286,
-0.0028130899,
0.0506821498,
-0.0111887623,
0.0062600966,
0.0222823732,
0.0207683239,
-0.0068378001,
-0.0258146338,
-0.0501859933,
-0.0275991354,
0.0088938521,
0.0252663735,
0.0302970093,
0.026686307,
0.0734077245,
-0.0576093793,
-0.0034192461,
-0.010242817,
-0.0220203567,
-0.0238293819,
0.0048385579,
0.0377893373,
0.0386977829,
-0.0167633537,
0.0027606664,
0.0244656783,
0.0101585872,
-0.0215809755,
-0.0293102264,
0.050268583,
0.0315935463,
0.0328742675,
0.0000019444,
-0.0495243184,
-0.0067375409,
-0.020856522,
-0.0293382592,
0.0514740497,
-0.0047229282,
-0.0177950021,
-0.0152322613,
0.0235470645,
-0.0060660709,
0.0091277184,
0.06570822,
-0.0264289379,
0.0077456404,
0.0772719011,
-0.0009789958,
0.0041043349,
0.0598506257,
-0.0101547316,
-0.0120420121,
-0.0135375047,
0.008232248,
0.0080179311,
-0.0279376041,
-0.0183294807,
-0.0376504809,
0.0251809526,
0.0364018343,
-0.0105299493,
-0.0102368919,
0.0276957806,
-0.0265110806,
-0.0272368081,
-0.0319058374,
0.0280246194,
-0.0858888999,
-0.0303668585,
0.0012398011,
-0.0213865899,
-0.051914759,
-0.0830095783,
-0.0262880344,
0.020253351,
0.0239383746,
0.0445602275,
0.0090645077,
-0.0193952937,
0.0610808283,
-0.0126769952,
-0.0158147272,
0.0503186695,
0.0083360439,
-0.0271994881,
-0.0015765169,
-0.0016446463,
-0.0720347464,
-0.0579914711,
-0.0023238002,
0.0055043641,
-0.0065941401,
-0.0077020191,
-0.0487776361,
-0.0139136156,
0.0122262929,
-0.0106010409,
0.0325178392,
0.0872125179,
-0.0414514765,
0.0072155674,
-0.0308011565,
0.0962693468,
-0.0168532766,
0.0613527372,
-0.0343854688,
0.0350793079,
0.0108849714,
-0.0032984982,
-0.0082716737,
0.0252049137,
-0.0138395121,
-0.0189117435,
-0.0714749321,
-0.0087440684,
0.0047113593,
-0.0251765624,
0.0089343106,
-0.0103161205,
-0.029418461,
0.0038621591,
0.0088357013,
0.0249536484,
-0.0057903416,
0.0227526072,
0.0132317115,
-0.0976509601,
-0.0278829131,
0.039533563,
-0.017512653,
-0.0455996022,
0.0308601577,
0.0001355144,
0.0080983853,
-0.051900845,
-0.0172312744,
0.0078767883,
-0.0244667046,
-0.0732528344,
0.0182183851,
-0.0621806011,
-0.0134420609,
0.0061830916,
0.0119208368,
-0.0185983945,
0.001398959,
-0.0157365222,
0.0130334236,
0.0420937501,
-0.0377394557,
-0.0068834843,
-0.0200031083,
0.0069303578,
0.01337694,
0.1037907898,
0.0213651061,
0.0246187113,
0.0032197684,
0.0115959384,
0.0264793709,
0.0638852343,
0.0145458169,
-0.0310991816,
-0.0494061001,
-0.0259245131,
-0.0214502234,
0.0486166254,
0.1011347845,
0.0537711568,
-0.0533748269,
-0.0286158528,
0.0354827344,
0.0277317967,
0.0099800369,
-0.0323542058,
0.0003709722,
-0.032350421,
0.0257131159,
-0.0034283127,
-0.0486327186,
0.0345545411,
0.0120291021,
0.0073934691,
0.0126936631,
0.0629743487,
-0.0208967067,
-0.0480816662,
-0.0418314412,
-0.0022412019,
-0.0266075693,
0.0136254197,
0.0453904457,
-0.0077001518,
-0.0217914246,
0.075822942,
0.0090530803,
-0.030486973,
0.0157802459,
-0.1027420685,
-0.0099488655,
0.0547191985,
0.0327190943,
-0.0061492031,
0.0047735339,
0.0111409435,
-0.0219699014,
0.0387704894,
-0.0235057529,
0.0257164761,
0.036075972,
-0.0735383257,
-0.0203287583,
-0.0320941471,
0.0176081844,
0.0100264819,
0.027216211,
-0.0031620197,
-0.0140781766,
-0.0613828786,
0.0130956704,
0.027246993,
0.007572216,
-0.0641369447,
-0.0000748462,
-0.0142338779,
0.0176546872,
0.0094499448,
-0.011157739,
0.0053957873,
0.0327827372,
-0.054715164,
0.0588887595,
-0.019727977,
-0.0114003196,
-0.0337031223,
0.0655516833,
0.0307185464,
0.0196835734,
0.0410939679,
-0.0240393244,
-0.046917025,
0.0100135505,
-0.0034077768,
0.0216696467,
-0.0571334288,
0.036673896,
-0.0187904779,
0.0325847194,
-0.0096547659,
0.0338415653,
-0.0436855629,
-0.0040560914,
0.0269876625,
-0.0306268651,
0.0159776304,
-0.0428301543,
-0.0298412386,
0.0061953603,
0.0083555765,
0.0224028751,
-0.0163558777,
-0.0200216416,
-0.0244519655,
0.0043883137,
-0.0907251611,
0.0007573886,
-0.0524408817,
0.0404154584,
0.0385868624,
0.01368465,
-0.0052894833,
-0.0050452449,
-0.0076670786,
-0.0265800599,
0.0035751925,
0.034863472,
0.0066394359,
-0.0186449755,
-0.0483360067,
-0.0441414826,
-0.0354319476,
-0.0117904702,
0.0453573875,
-0.0640826374,
-0.0681913868,
-0.0660641864,
0.0215552803,
-0.0095709013,
0.0332799144,
-0.0289974306,
-0.0447756685,
0.0350011177,
0.0058918353,
0.0094436854,
0.078217268,
-0.0402535647,
0.0035406041,
0.0992416367,
0.0110779954,
-0.0351348706,
0.0156924631,
-0.0004793747,
-0.0658585876,
-0.0377760231,
-0.0185905807,
-0.0258873478,
0.0866244882,
-0.0038375405,
0.0008344451,
-0.0179641899,
0.0189649221,
-0.0068284408,
-0.0511464924,
-0.0303573795,
-0.0012992941,
-0.0375442915,
0.0740666911,
-0.0214504283,
-0.0655688494,
0.0217164699,
-0.0331129245,
-0.0090462351,
-0.0091960737,
0.0122988392,
-0.0060259067,
0.0071735946,
0.025240073,
0.0234690644,
-0.008179008,
-0.0425155088,
-0.0471361876,
-0.0454930887,
0.0000687668,
-0.026161246,
0.017531231,
-0.0244741607,
0.0142427245,
-0.0238843542,
-0.0116248997,
0.0136798248,
0.0324586146,
-0.0040131486,
0.0295425393,
-0.0008242149,
-0.0237439424,
0.0370628722,
0.034955807,
-0.0198973231,
0.0469512381,
-0.0292599071,
0.0011714443,
-0.0348396897,
0.0294947512,
0.0079563735,
-0.0025854174,
0.0524966381,
-0.0228907093,
-0.0272270627,
0.0314371176,
-0.000646825,
0.0403622016,
-0.0471749827,
0.0255574696,
0.0409234837,
-0.0040276255,
-0.0131872669,
0.0199750829,
0.0816166028,
-0.0296120755,
-0.0207792204,
0.0641473457,
0.0122805862,
-0.0145975677,
0.0050768284,
-0.0113076745,
0.0386381894,
0.0173653644,
-0.0115397312,
-0.0969326869,
0.0013785735,
0.0188335739,
0.0331323296,
-0.012436036,
0.009983059,
0.0134747885,
-0.0761544704,
0.0328948088,
0.0278092474,
-0.0083544543,
-0.0126367789,
-0.0158359315,
-0.0059120483,
-0.0249058586,
0.1064301729,
0.0460235924,
0.014276661,
-0.0178699959,
0.0331708565,
-0.0201454684,
-0.0676273704,
0.0330318697,
-0.014558333,
0.0376063362,
0.0614747517,
0.0037728469,
-0.0016064428,
0.0109847924,
0.0475051552,
0.0107423076,
0.0260232706,
-0.0027955573,
0.0312468391,
0.0493273064,
-0.0134199541,
0.0148081183,
-0.0080086784,
-0.0211346727,
-0.0295815822,
-0.0652141422,
0.015221104,
-0.0160690732,
-0.0151511077,
0.0122496709,
-0.0165317338,
-0.0236243643,
0.042547822,
0.0258619152,
-0.0027994271,
-0.0530862473,
-0.0025469309,
0.0194859188,
-0.0360983685,
-0.0211930294,
0.0022688841,
0.0069652931,
-0.0914910808,
-0.0337431692,
-0.0185701642,
0.0184763148,
0.0288240369,
-0.0133761605,
0.0103973188,
-0.0167631209,
-0.0056305337,
-0.0481595173,
0.030766014,
-0.017459916,
0.0114620524,
-0.0099143544,
0.0097667268,
-0.0187780838,
-0.0061161225,
-0.0172087047,
0.0006472604,
-0.1413726956,
-0.0871569663,
0.0316032246,
0.0304987319,
0.0343615264,
0.0486548543,
0.0030503657,
-0.0667433664,
0.0589845106,
0.0661206469,
0.0058812583,
0.0715538189,
0.023536941,
-0.0171300862,
-0.0221475214,
0.021590203,
-0.017406147,
0.0138148637,
0.0344400369,
0.0389355682,
-0.0701216161,
-0.021390561,
-0.0021255645,
-0.0082881078,
0.1015666872,
-0.0317830406,
-0.0009472247,
-0.0146783488,
0.018102916,
-0.0171124712,
0.0363155417,
-0.0360325053,
-0.0247461032,
0.0616410077,
0.0267105438,
-0.0215554498,
0.021018276,
0.0123950448,
-0.0091295438,
0.0111976704,
0.0156798624,
-0.0077078994,
0.0398172103,
0.041721005,
-0.0019595905,
-0.0279849153,
0.0464580059,
-0.0348454751,
0.0445032381,
0.0018103832,
0.0085823163,
-0.0218040217,
0.0154120484,
-0.0313093774,
0.0323121473,
-0.0374567769,
-0.0415454395,
-0.0565514453,
0.0228705164,
0.078297697,
0.0430594794,
0.0666951761,
0.019362079,
-0.0173119791,
-0.0202049669,
0.0144041823,
0.0188315976,
0.023711985,
0.0364935771,
0.0117734158,
-0.0133580845,
-0.0028734277,
0.0279418472,
-0.0111861406,
0.0433409326,
0.0119270487,
0.0173617676,
0.0051658722,
-0.0223473608,
-0.0628028885,
0.0117099108,
-0.0050760116,
-0.0337026976,
-0.008821493,
-0.0405163653,
0.0384738296,
0.0423425809,
-0.0137486057,
-0.0127864582,
-0.0090906685,
0.0483192094,
-0.008189166,
-0.0849726349,
-0.0224821661,
-0.0464813299,
0.0051774839,
-0.0040433295,
-0.0175763145,
-6.37765709e-33,
-0.0438492969,
0.0029399833,
0.02658833,
-0.01979593,
0.0016508799,
0.0137339178,
-0.0302929673,
0.0159592349,
-0.0373591967,
-0.0359048508,
-0.0069184299,
0.0249214433,
0.0386904962,
-0.0264672525,
-0.0120910015,
0.0025639851,
0.0570591949,
-0.0300269388,
-0.0259577315,
-0.0128713585,
0.0251172986,
0.0080851195,
0.1050590351,
-0.0223321021,
-0.0092508513,
0.0255965739,
-0.0478889272,
0.0171487946,
-0.006845294,
0.0461980216,
-0.0245511886,
0.04554452,
0.0032077089,
0.0392933227,
-0.0306221768,
-0.0398216173,
-0.0552648865,
-0.0011529485,
0.0416657254,
0.0403820463,
0.0236116443,
-0.0572212897,
0.0638164282,
-0.0008355478,
-0.0636816174,
-0.0283227395,
-0.0201089345,
-0.0211290494,
-0.0209463835,
-0.0651545599,
-0.0219641086,
0.0177319385,
0.0204344522,
0.0285324454,
0.0452973396,
0.0012107338,
-0.031084856,
0.0243996214,
-0.1024510115,
-0.0024596837,
0.0426546149,
0.0791914836,
0.0846121833,
0.0773491785,
0.037096601,
0.0490567237,
0.0911676437,
-0.0150729492,
0.016347006,
0.0513387173,
0.0916355178,
0.0117864106,
0.0434059761,
0.0444332585,
0.1062174141,
0.0193660147,
-0.0708982348,
-0.0209857579,
0.0248781089,
-0.0058871782,
0.0438356511,
0.0533907525,
-0.055278603,
-0.0312085915,
-0.015795717,
-0.0280638635,
-0.0467597358,
-0.0376297459,
0.0264237262,
0.0091308085,
0.0131382179,
-0.0151309166,
0.0401577428,
-0.0258126352,
-0.0094319936,
-0.0274944212,
0.0024418563,
0.0452607013,
-0.012154174,
0.0272849072,
-0.0470502861,
-0.030526733,
0.0132547012,
0.0214295071,
0.0283811782,
-0.0105720339,
0.0068383371,
0.0454061665,
-0.0712486282,
-0.0019364966,
-0.0295686889,
0.0036937732,
0.02850575,
0.0349161737,
0.0316684283,
-0.0281093139,
0.0064947866,
0.0387849286,
-0.0094378432,
0.0183863528,
-0.0377353728,
0.0222135801,
0.0151266344,
0.0491895042,
-0.0287180077,
0.003776178,
-0.0181171782,
0.0325362198,
0.0344843231,
-0.0414425284,
-0.0366147608,
0.0159660615,
2.654e-7,
0.0660889372,
0.015610883,
0.0230857786,
0.0249367021,
-0.0126720425,
-0.017026566,
-0.0156178409,
-0.0116267391,
0.0419366769,
-0.0502451472,
-0.0008947311,
0.0413126722,
0.0083485786,
0.0242904332,
-0.0376233086,
0.0277716517,
-0.0207643099,
0.02413214,
-0.0425633304,
-0.022823168,
0.0262267739,
0.089947708,
-0.0226365365,
-0.0164925139,
0.0440218821,
-0.0487072542,
0.0511363596,
-0.0307672825,
-0.0093012899,
0.0478246696,
0.0668672025,
0.0195578691,
0.014334918,
-0.01505611,
0.0177539699,
0.0129804648,
-0.0465661958,
0.0624512024,
-0.0311770067,
-0.0770555586,
-0.0149979377,
0.0097491583,
-0.0114663178,
-0.0594659857,
0.0566773042,
-0.0250859652,
-0.0222471319,
-0.0869253725,
-0.0339539498,
-0.0251544416,
0.0320372544,
-0.0291707404,
0.0243871566,
0.0287327059,
0.0213133041,
-0.0058580916,
-0.0282682478,
-0.0605025515,
-0.078883484,
0.0350260437,
-0.0421807133,
-0.0861175433,
-0.0337789431,
0.0088564502,
-0.0135464957,
-0.0316627249,
-0.0071742474,
2.619536815e-34,
0.0339008532,
-0.0402008481,
0.0402843431,
0.034434095,
-0.0049326224,
-0.0195867084,
-0.0171677154,
0.0036948493,
-0.0258241054,
-0.0667338297,
-0.0125087211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20833v1
|
That's Optional: A Contemporary Exploration of "that" Omission in English Subordinate Clauses
| 2024-05-31T14:23:30 | 2024-05-31T14:23:30 |
Ella Rabinovich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Uniform Information Density (UID) hypothesis posits that speakers
optimize the communicative properties of their utterances by avoiding spikes in
information, thereby maintaining a relatively uniform information profile over
time. This paper investigates the impact of UID principles on syntactic
reduction, specifically focusing on the optional omission of the connector
"that" in English subordinate clauses. Building upon previous research, we
extend our investigation to a larger corpus of written English, utilize
contemporary large language models (LLMs) and extend the information-uniformity
principles by the notion of entropy, to estimate the UID manifestations in the
usecase of syntactic reduction choices.
|
[
0.0523040481,
0.0441129208,
-0.0411993489,
0.0082311081,
-0.0541153699,
0.0067459135,
-0.0117260758,
0.0147892926,
-0.0064151473,
-0.015667703,
-0.0021935178,
-0.0229681693,
0.0196648873,
-0.0943748876,
0.0163854435,
-0.0471717902,
0.0183207411,
0.0040651103,
-0.0018733337,
-0.0293785408,
-0.0010300691,
-0.0251053683,
0.0054134792,
0.0115713356,
0.0021607056,
-0.0107596405,
0.0110364277,
0.0186593942,
-0.006301187,
0.0324263647,
-0.0072986698,
0.039578069,
-0.0567528009,
-0.0482703149,
0.0000018461,
-0.0395881161,
0.0223644413,
-0.02929282,
-0.0166302342,
0.1163183972,
0.0193858128,
0.0264224876,
-0.051854901,
0.0004187629,
-0.0071845222,
-0.0163522158,
0.0330872908,
0.0117364191,
-0.09071327,
0.017867703,
-0.0183349643,
0.0206044465,
-0.0057867789,
-0.0210969467,
-0.0158883184,
0.0153550794,
0.0349446423,
-0.0222405884,
-0.0253941622,
-0.0383635871,
-0.0403522737,
0.0474411808,
0.0309191253,
0.0066889715,
-0.0470055565,
0.0199314542,
0.0193099212,
-0.0123764873,
0.0186300036,
-0.0224744584,
0.0719591528,
-0.0198578797,
0.0227549002,
0.0003701196,
0.0058540502,
0.0195655338,
-0.070062831,
0.0230599828,
0.0178788938,
0.0311099049,
0.0324101038,
-0.0203820392,
-0.0027731478,
-0.0039899526,
-0.0025236255,
0.0955295637,
0.016397059,
-0.0515937507,
0.0115694944,
0.0040099476,
-0.0595195293,
-0.0715104118,
-0.0312469862,
-0.0452292487,
0.0223704372,
-0.034492135,
-0.0136087891,
-0.062166892,
-0.010495781,
-0.0254439488,
-0.0525010414,
-0.0295493305,
0.0306338128,
0.011325296,
0.052798029,
0.0367198065,
-0.0085463617,
0.010050158,
-0.0389050618,
0.0279785525,
0.0066484869,
-0.0061775506,
-0.0138199041,
0.0724435002,
-0.0000574737,
0.0041868533,
-0.0460723266,
-0.0000609617,
-0.008008725,
-0.0062740771,
-0.0383325778,
0.0132614886,
-0.031019235,
0.0005934537,
0.0063042906,
0.0296536162,
-0.0132518485,
0.0388180949,
-0.0139530338,
-0.0235950723,
0.0093894098,
0.0519321822,
0.0061982661,
-0.0080736578,
-0.0339977369,
-0.0008694939,
-0.0004664483,
0.0057707932,
-0.0200029202,
-0.018630188,
-0.0718572065,
-0.0536948889,
-0.0612164848,
-0.0658879355,
-0.0469728149,
0.0048489426,
-0.0041380203,
-0.0526805781,
-0.0203930605,
0.0067097507,
-0.02301207,
0.0036889054,
-0.0409579203,
0.0388991423,
-0.0298395846,
-0.0231711678,
0.0658595264,
0.0406410359,
0.0389828049,
-0.0049245115,
0.0500812531,
-0.037548773,
-0.0056349342,
0.0560969822,
-0.0270018894,
-0.014292215,
-0.0296119992,
-0.0229942575,
-0.0293270219,
0.0039607342,
0.0631910861,
0.0821746513,
-0.0263051651,
-0.0102216592,
0.0601889752,
0.027681658,
-0.0052087903,
0.003466798,
0.022450557,
0.0752460659,
0.0007464553,
0.12382029,
-0.013714565,
-0.0377135873,
-0.0069240597,
0.0126550216,
0.0276349466,
0.0147183454,
-0.0291899312,
-0.0691518486,
-0.0170789193,
0.0194868408,
0.0011530148,
0.0399593972,
0.0086066769,
0.0281939078,
0.0212911852,
0.0506026819,
0.0127242422,
-0.0686839372,
0.0304951239,
0.0288669262,
0.0190807749,
0.0519217364,
0.0500801951,
0.0410279892,
0.0245339908,
0.0154508706,
0.0079009784,
0.0240100026,
0.0274808332,
0.0149774998,
0.0512793101,
-0.0200628359,
0.0182480831,
-0.0074547757,
0.0388670899,
-0.0883677378,
-0.0279959943,
-0.0251611471,
0.0120586427,
-0.012209055,
0.0172564536,
0.000933746,
0.0065616407,
-0.0106945019,
0.012154852,
0.0145881092,
0.0579904094,
-0.0054826629,
-0.0196399372,
-0.0046332674,
0.0356653705,
-0.028017588,
0.0081518413,
0.0514841862,
-0.0116660148,
-0.0291528106,
-0.0032598614,
-0.0249287672,
0.0373617038,
0.0402147099,
0.025788106,
-0.0229704138,
0.01520555,
-0.0614884421,
0.084219262,
-0.0159868896,
0.0464683846,
0.0013125797,
0.0382744893,
-0.0519780964,
0.0301218797,
-0.0207990408,
0.0544810817,
-0.0168897454,
-0.0507796481,
0.0109949028,
-0.0446817204,
-0.0050288481,
-0.0027866673,
-0.0328838564,
-0.0213596839,
0.0459994413,
-0.0131307365,
-0.0020263614,
-0.0306125432,
-0.0682114661,
0.0082287397,
-0.0007154541,
0.0436831228,
0.0483387075,
0.0680736154,
-0.0301893186,
0.0456364751,
0.0406448357,
-0.0162538029,
0.0059858644,
0.0185626615,
0.0478581041,
0.0290566757,
-0.034785334,
-0.0303388108,
0.0001226659,
0.0075588264,
0.0354662389,
-0.0471137762,
-0.0441169068,
0.0266506057,
0.1107262373,
0.0008631075,
0.002277558,
0.0036069178,
-0.0590692535,
-0.023351755,
0.0281300638,
0.0370327681,
0.0320315771,
-0.0046219565,
0.0163922552,
0.0179837905,
-0.0386733487,
-0.0534960479,
0.0045225797,
-0.0295738559,
0.0254838914,
-0.0487620644,
-0.0866338983,
0.0321180746,
0.0531496108,
0.04995602,
-0.0203713719,
-0.0093425876,
-0.0465875603,
-0.0520961806,
-0.047714062,
0.0048509813,
-0.0399961881,
-0.0397319533,
0.0145666515,
0.0055838618,
-0.0242791381,
-0.010440181,
0.015880391,
-0.0019335732,
-0.0197806004,
-0.0331071466,
-0.0091315908,
0.0144881615,
-0.0055756913,
0.0097828964,
0.0823536888,
-0.0415091999,
-0.0185237564,
-0.0286325682,
0.0278408956,
0.0315406322,
0.0158959385,
-0.0436262526,
-0.0156955179,
0.0267877001,
-0.0691613257,
0.0135419518,
-0.0738660544,
-0.0389451459,
-0.026797127,
0.0208887551,
-0.0474783815,
0.0422570147,
-0.01528225,
0.0504234284,
0.007492465,
0.0226921085,
0.0005067628,
-0.0359492749,
0.0288884304,
0.0336457528,
-0.0014448528,
-0.002004904,
-0.0144273285,
0.0322228558,
0.0671055391,
0.0386001542,
0.0599205941,
0.0036516115,
-0.0270054471,
0.0205765609,
0.0197112598,
-0.0892188549,
0.061365705,
0.0481310859,
-0.0010872444,
0.0166787263,
0.0782336816,
0.0040581478,
-0.006630037,
0.0354133099,
0.0081857229,
0.1236060411,
-0.0194930304,
0.0109690996,
-0.0819586217,
-0.0039194957,
0.0246121176,
-0.0291829389,
-0.0494667701,
-0.0070797997,
-0.0169661175,
-0.0360956565,
0.0451867133,
0.0294816121,
0.0311441813,
0.0043443763,
-0.0072282073,
0.0356369428,
-0.0071310834,
-0.0102283144,
0.0160729364,
-0.040241085,
-0.0037306454,
0.0348303169,
-0.128703624,
-0.0334150232,
-0.049083177,
-0.0312014613,
0.0014792886,
0.0010053681,
-0.0043250294,
-0.0289208498,
0.020886315,
0.0304418597,
-0.013224557,
0.0085978163,
-0.0007341122,
0.0347835161,
0.0220337622,
0.025426235,
-0.0823509842,
0.0060633165,
0.0024165912,
-0.0001540797,
0.024310559,
0.0618598126,
-0.0348767377,
-0.074189797,
0.0092149079,
0.0148761645,
-0.0365973301,
0.0895363539,
0.0334796682,
-0.0441323332,
-0.0117561324,
0.0092515284,
0.0207401738,
0.0117119337,
-0.0154035278,
-0.0162963606,
-0.0127382418,
-0.1156449467,
-0.0717826411,
-0.0644382015,
0.0227787402,
-0.0039199279,
0.0266475119,
0.0350521468,
0.0310275257,
-0.0508416481,
0.0275889486,
-0.0519123189,
-0.0449047796,
-0.0224283449,
-0.023756085,
0.0496249013,
0.014039387,
0.0035033722,
0.0010144374,
0.0042872108,
-0.0612191595,
-0.0732369721,
0.0386983827,
0.0051263878,
0.0223618262,
0.0388533473,
0.0073696226,
-0.0570346937,
0.0015167277,
0.0495246165,
0.000336628,
0.0990267321,
0.0299544502,
-0.0558364987,
0.035886731,
0.0548040234,
0.0024560515,
-0.0186767634,
0.0052064923,
0.0324805081,
-0.0385978706,
-0.0641408637,
0.065012157,
0.0294500496,
0.0096410373,
0.006469558,
0.0113355191,
-0.0124157146,
0.0128849372,
-0.0264305025,
-0.0034927123,
-0.0204795711,
0.0243548043,
0.0023064101,
0.0858421549,
-0.0601356998,
0.0338245481,
-0.0207402278,
0.0508349948,
0.0089832898,
-0.0333618484,
-0.0093490109,
-0.0147490259,
0.0090420051,
0.0100431386,
0.0119419014,
0.0256697945,
-0.008431646,
0.017170649,
0.0417457744,
-0.0204468127,
-0.0117317727,
-0.0265841745,
-0.0484339856,
-0.0218206309,
-0.0509942099,
-0.0294073541,
0.0103157256,
-0.006970502,
0.0390119366,
-0.0431804471,
0.0366168693,
-0.0435253866,
0.0303263795,
-0.0251550302,
0.0231551174,
0.018090874,
-0.013115434,
0.0216146298,
0.0182175096,
-0.0547052696,
0.0379567817,
0.0426469781,
0.0044472646,
0.0085281581,
-0.0067320918,
-0.0113091711,
-0.032601729,
-0.0218578316,
-0.0287390184,
0.0078817932,
-0.0041605104,
-0.0094859796,
-0.0777945295,
-0.0359245464,
-0.0055939071,
-0.0319031626,
0.0437040254,
-0.0814852938,
0.0340732001,
0.0561232083,
0.0024979049,
-0.082446754,
0.0005843778,
0.0006684082,
-0.0166817289,
-0.0011034065,
-0.0168125797,
-6.394233764e-33,
0.0140923578,
-0.0002540885,
-0.004971223,
0.0262694545,
-0.0358819254,
-0.0232099853,
-0.0019085995,
0.0207419917,
-0.0010869517,
0.0432931148,
-0.0385738015,
0.0117431786,
0.0184422135,
0.0102335187,
0.0203935858,
0.0294472743,
0.0601017848,
-0.0014637151,
-0.0171331149,
-0.0232708715,
0.0134821553,
-0.0082027307,
0.0850972161,
-0.0335126333,
0.0192902125,
0.0169128608,
-0.0322765261,
-0.0074279006,
0.0062768101,
-0.028046729,
-0.0245866701,
0.042620413,
0.0074055083,
-0.0268528406,
-0.0195493139,
0.0513873659,
-0.0190506838,
-0.0016552723,
0.0998825803,
-0.0154500203,
-0.0093526905,
-0.0943091139,
0.0470648482,
-0.0216049682,
-0.0689678788,
0.0405863337,
0.0326495543,
0.0080739995,
-0.0102662388,
-0.002765931,
-0.0105789118,
0.0153054921,
-0.0394449346,
0.031730704,
-0.012939305,
0.0589873195,
-0.042147059,
-0.0263423789,
0.0047811517,
0.0486144647,
-0.0040025413,
0.0628976226,
0.0051889708,
-0.0702683553,
0.0442259684,
0.0422798656,
0.0479773097,
-0.0036315084,
0.0126566412,
0.0289245304,
0.0030710858,
0.0368812867,
-0.0238863006,
0.0722643286,
0.0305018909,
-0.0309233684,
-0.0624642521,
-0.0294183381,
0.0027252629,
0.0562258884,
-0.0041441391,
0.053138651,
-0.0973760188,
-0.0677906871,
-0.0029854171,
0.0110183898,
0.0292036962,
-0.0498059541,
0.0218470469,
-0.0389548764,
0.006598583,
-0.0422868803,
0.0060522263,
-0.0351299159,
-0.0078717293,
0.0099263554,
-0.0263742413,
0.0506427325,
0.0163066946,
0.0009377912,
-0.0409550443,
0.0252690949,
0.0020282581,
0.0269276667,
0.0074350215,
0.0589422993,
0.0214532595,
0.0232359264,
-0.0366073363,
-0.0282213613,
-0.0030321679,
-0.0276245773,
-0.0399457254,
-0.0779477656,
0.0426869988,
0.0454131253,
-0.0040452266,
0.0154476045,
0.0087087108,
-0.0308215488,
-0.034402959,
0.0542666428,
0.0020104293,
0.0174445678,
0.0296763405,
-0.0277997032,
-0.0311272871,
-0.0127304206,
0.0312396344,
0.0046231165,
-0.0285475757,
0.0383030064,
2.729e-7,
0.0010898398,
0.032857392,
0.011600988,
0.0003536694,
0.0076743835,
0.0252444502,
0.0219927952,
-0.006107314,
0.0541880578,
0.0227049645,
0.0459887087,
-0.0260849781,
0.0462015569,
-0.0497919321,
-0.0893153325,
-0.032178279,
-0.0337888375,
-0.0517730042,
-0.0132308938,
-0.0308790486,
0.006395577,
0.0441210717,
0.035902489,
0.0101385927,
-0.0185199436,
-0.022717705,
-0.0055284072,
-0.093821466,
-0.0365252644,
0.025828423,
0.0304985754,
-0.0232195202,
0.0252302457,
0.0515101403,
-0.0147440899,
-0.003690291,
-0.0072008278,
0.0330179632,
0.0425467677,
0.0258162171,
-0.0049658716,
-0.0238233227,
-0.0332605839,
-0.026268987,
0.056279432,
-0.0129528102,
-0.0050979536,
0.0430059582,
-0.0420917794,
-0.0233970229,
-0.0006911271,
0.0185329318,
-0.0037106967,
-0.0271804687,
0.0179495998,
-0.0308622904,
-0.0324405357,
-0.0066485438,
-0.0371122733,
0.0269846264,
-0.0123470351,
-0.0560929701,
0.0042030914,
0.0118399952,
0.0221329723,
-0.0605273955,
-0.0110175647,
2.31132518e-34,
0.0182262063,
0.0046146219,
0.0504224338,
0.0145841381,
0.013255164,
-0.0134383906,
-0.0089312252,
0.0364871994,
0.0284920987,
-0.0850653872,
0.0000338918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20830v1
|
Self-Augmented Preference Optimization: Off-Policy Paradigms for Language Model Alignment
| 2024-05-31T14:21:04 | 2024-05-31T14:21:04 |
Yueqin Yin, Zhendong Wang, Yujia Xie, Weizhu Chen, Mingyuan Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Traditional language model alignment methods, such as Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO), are limited by their dependence on static, pre-collected
paired preference data, which hampers their adaptability and practical
applicability. To overcome this limitation, we introduce Self-Augmented
Preference Optimization (SAPO), an effective and scalable training paradigm
that does not require existing paired data. Building on the self-play concept,
which autonomously generates negative responses, we further incorporate an
off-policy learning pipeline to enhance data exploration and exploitation.
Specifically, we employ an Exponential Moving Average (EMA) model in
conjunction with a replay buffer to enable dynamic updates of response
segments, effectively integrating real-time feedback with insights from
historical data. Our comprehensive evaluations of the LLaMA3-8B and Mistral-7B
models across benchmarks, including the Open LLM Leaderboard, IFEval,
AlpacaEval 2.0, and MT-Bench, demonstrate that SAPO matches or surpasses
established offline contrastive baselines, such as DPO and Odds Ratio
Preference Optimization, and outperforms offline self-play methods like SPIN.
Our code is available at https://github.com/yinyueqin/SAPO
|
[
-0.0131469369,
0.0866566896,
-0.0112817436,
0.0374607407,
-0.0275434908,
0.0132498415,
-0.0090480326,
-0.0390906483,
-0.0211452339,
-0.0076862578,
-0.0696538985,
-0.0633659214,
0.0107275099,
0.0610578693,
0.0044490704,
-0.0210414939,
0.0421980098,
-0.0041051037,
0.0218531936,
-0.0317909084,
0.0055595036,
0.006459211,
-0.0254716147,
0.0292360503,
0.0825042799,
-0.0155826425,
-0.0096521918,
-0.0072375247,
0.0291998275,
-0.0473112352,
0.0366529748,
0.0510415547,
0.0143060861,
0.0332837291,
0.0000020215,
-0.0839592442,
-0.0464290194,
-0.0357765406,
-0.00289066,
-0.0101282327,
0.053866636,
0.0454782955,
-0.0218932927,
0.0322319083,
-0.0391759537,
0.0134986732,
0.0736071244,
-0.0259792339,
0.0376140028,
0.0605472811,
0.0012942832,
-0.0138566028,
0.0019648594,
-0.0528311804,
-0.0277962144,
0.0319668278,
0.022822354,
-0.0722183287,
-0.0126516316,
-0.0205891244,
-0.0288872197,
0.0188805871,
-0.0226217844,
0.0136908619,
0.0019702162,
0.0318496302,
0.0046896501,
-0.012183289,
-0.0167285129,
0.0818789005,
-0.0206608884,
-0.0337254964,
0.0157076437,
-0.0344970413,
-0.0407675058,
-0.0248165559,
-0.0119488724,
-0.0207189415,
0.0260999091,
0.0636040792,
0.0424033925,
-0.0013681162,
0.0200905949,
0.0058953902,
-0.0264624637,
0.0961131901,
0.014861837,
-0.0342192166,
0.0123837171,
0.0009105573,
0.0145908976,
-0.0526257381,
0.0153940516,
0.0058711139,
-0.0219571516,
0.0269586165,
-0.0133670578,
0.0047282279,
0.0090360008,
-0.0300829541,
0.059760157,
0.0765377209,
-0.0105022294,
0.0114518879,
0.0016457884,
0.069262892,
-0.0127819134,
0.0131018348,
-0.0472784676,
0.0387246087,
-0.0004140687,
-0.0089542912,
0.0097848419,
0.0327416807,
-0.0273481701,
0.0012979403,
-0.0476651192,
0.0173860863,
-0.0160511658,
0.0209966786,
0.0182560161,
0.0023952723,
-0.0423183143,
0.0040284707,
-0.0683029965,
0.0707696527,
0.0153109469,
0.0103662498,
0.0082426416,
-0.0199641269,
-0.0009772936,
0.0082038846,
-0.0321367644,
-0.0178016424,
0.0139080975,
0.0734046996,
-0.0027744779,
-0.0213615671,
0.0028463793,
0.0126124006,
-0.0412621982,
-0.0635392442,
0.0049787713,
-0.0736504048,
0.0205734018,
-0.0130358264,
-0.0007277753,
-0.0494639464,
0.005491164,
-0.0026350508,
-0.0077494173,
0.0520821586,
-0.0073425611,
-0.0005476131,
-0.0166890472,
-0.0290736612,
0.0147132548,
0.0997122452,
0.030196663,
-0.0042243307,
0.0232225154,
-0.0071673719,
-0.0175641626,
0.0567871481,
0.0525852814,
0.0413948931,
-0.0909838602,
0.0178951249,
-0.0004678869,
0.0292512644,
0.0622938052,
-0.0082698204,
0.0026969118,
-0.0390640125,
0.0603345782,
0.0211801417,
0.023614591,
-0.0093487827,
-0.0150956213,
0.0008007741,
-0.0120525416,
0.004826101,
-0.032600686,
0.0542333052,
0.0166505892,
0.0248606373,
0.0287037436,
0.0675508603,
-0.0100553222,
-0.0406676754,
0.0086112767,
-0.0070864237,
-0.0240529384,
0.0341063142,
0.0333129391,
-0.0280193165,
-0.0450208336,
-0.0047776718,
0.0444259234,
-0.0331591628,
-0.0026913527,
-0.0640600026,
0.0453348644,
0.0886146128,
0.041401919,
-0.0072682532,
-0.0896860957,
-0.0221727677,
-0.0673496351,
0.0581647865,
0.0245458595,
-0.011330598,
0.0081183035,
-0.0562415048,
-0.0545640104,
0.0061330278,
-0.0025342908,
0.049736388,
0.0002225933,
0.0189761072,
-0.0241205338,
-0.0072205039,
-0.0240645297,
0.0161349513,
-0.0358189382,
-0.0399219692,
0.0256120581,
0.010567843,
0.068804644,
-0.0042192996,
-0.0023029028,
-0.0041802609,
0.0214264132,
0.0052502453,
0.0107822623,
0.0256339367,
-0.0644206479,
-0.0368267372,
0.0652253553,
0.0300520062,
-0.0094420547,
0.0693869516,
-0.0246714391,
-0.0484491922,
0.0163247995,
0.0111531643,
0.0640080497,
-0.0208077505,
0.0230927821,
-0.0247813519,
0.0205233954,
-0.0475360937,
0.0226740129,
-0.0257496033,
0.0189558808,
0.0073497142,
0.0042874571,
0.0065189097,
-0.0444442667,
-0.0393890813,
0.0366119444,
-0.001767827,
0.0004372127,
0.0170900859,
0.0133235864,
-0.0407724045,
-0.0155058084,
-0.0408282131,
0.0381962173,
-0.0232691411,
0.0459575243,
0.0557142831,
-0.0107228719,
-0.0350936502,
-0.0226226356,
-0.023951279,
-0.018080838,
-0.0024254003,
0.0193425603,
0.0144718383,
0.0024003463,
-0.0296592582,
-0.0802136064,
-0.0098464219,
-0.0289518237,
-0.0054690666,
-0.048238907,
0.0254482683,
-0.0267228745,
-0.0231521167,
-0.0714541227,
0.0253934916,
-0.0061419723,
-0.0391955189,
0.0129917413,
-0.0091802655,
0.0451744273,
0.0658283979,
-0.0059348564,
-0.0164215025,
0.0957729816,
-0.0183059108,
-0.0840261132,
-0.0025820252,
-0.0346313491,
0.0222255234,
-0.0201504566,
-0.0074261907,
-0.0228675678,
0.1260635257,
-0.0020608488,
-0.0145016462,
-0.0427297167,
-0.0243568439,
0.0105427234,
-0.0174899045,
-0.0091392342,
0.0073085171,
-0.0446629003,
0.0189124402,
-0.0181849487,
-0.0878756419,
0.0912925377,
-0.0209459122,
-0.0286633894,
-0.08643841,
-0.0066977288,
-0.0259256437,
0.0007055511,
0.0001092046,
0.0056829383,
-0.025272347,
-0.0002967948,
-0.0414427891,
-0.0748361498,
0.0349094905,
-0.0564837717,
0.0402170941,
-0.0322544277,
0.0252178591,
0.0008042742,
-0.0377469622,
-0.0481563695,
-0.0350471064,
-0.0354322121,
-0.0293402188,
-0.0110686962,
-0.0230469443,
-0.0294785611,
0.0209799167,
0.0000561064,
0.0552195869,
-0.0209136922,
-0.0012193099,
-0.0186883751,
0.0110167796,
0.0874686092,
0.014099258,
0.0240280926,
0.0058130329,
0.0444488674,
0.023699211,
0.0750310794,
-0.023876939,
-0.0464995317,
0.0305756629,
0.0731851757,
-0.0372866653,
-0.0086432118,
0.0323859341,
0.0100898463,
-0.0242734533,
0.0140718473,
0.0986174271,
0.0269115139,
-0.0587637573,
-0.0187828019,
-0.0378929675,
0.0659145936,
0.0226612668,
0.0260957871,
-0.0334082283,
-0.0004143654,
0.0050928192,
0.066545397,
-0.0061158063,
-0.0003322824,
-0.0336026736,
-0.1183146387,
0.0055554002,
0.008808516,
-0.0192137342,
0.0261623319,
-0.0514213778,
0.0474166311,
-0.0573602468,
0.0253637768,
0.0293818396,
-0.0120423874,
0.0052488013,
0.0013872344,
-0.0047616307,
-0.0245642662,
0.0056686434,
-0.0298253875,
0.0817949995,
0.0956271738,
0.0352417752,
0.0142692504,
-0.0214423873,
0.0273199994,
-0.0409292206,
-0.0388417803,
-0.0350708067,
0.0081864996,
-0.0129673574,
0.002372023,
-0.0093785226,
0.0452643745,
-0.005493388,
-0.004411181,
-0.0054956521,
0.058899384,
-0.0069734273,
0.0174047556,
-0.0055826711,
0.020164635,
0.0223989394,
0.050184384,
-0.0122287041,
-0.058422152,
0.0044375537,
-0.0262677856,
0.0021956342,
-0.040150445,
-0.0260030963,
-0.0497987643,
-0.0056377156,
0.0171476416,
-0.0606722459,
-0.0384981818,
-0.0243632942,
0.0297946911,
0.0206494797,
0.0203021616,
-0.0137862638,
-0.026372008,
-0.0334904306,
0.0201741848,
-0.0241972618,
0.0032534141,
-0.0630149767,
-0.0253525209,
0.0395670086,
-0.0185817517,
-0.0262847319,
-0.0028960409,
-0.0407985561,
-0.0948536694,
0.0340183079,
0.0483413264,
0.0209734254,
0.0646427497,
0.0160585158,
-0.0082780393,
0.0508454144,
0.0325039588,
0.0053258068,
0.0077606472,
0.0406460911,
0.009444355,
-0.0056440546,
0.028526064,
-0.0074728243,
0.008009335,
0.0179195944,
0.034215983,
-0.0162182488,
-0.0272425041,
0.0207966138,
-0.0302981809,
0.0844774842,
-0.0283685923,
-0.0156240733,
-0.0513218492,
0.037883155,
-0.0137905562,
0.0215895958,
-0.0093211532,
-0.0239533149,
0.0227052066,
-0.0236978233,
-0.0033656626,
0.0255651977,
-0.0620872676,
-0.0342197604,
-0.0219825953,
0.0300822221,
-0.0034213539,
0.0265069399,
0.0170224085,
0.0228871424,
0.0161028337,
0.0259757824,
0.0205020048,
0.0506737828,
-0.009998342,
0.0295389909,
0.0269706436,
0.0031491253,
0.0065801139,
0.0295173358,
-0.0252940133,
0.0022958559,
-0.0383760296,
-0.0167102069,
0.0502045415,
-0.0374490954,
0.0745738745,
0.0103765521,
-0.0007056255,
-0.0168008246,
-0.011413388,
-0.0601516552,
0.0042331736,
0.0192299299,
0.0115029374,
-0.0228387266,
0.022664262,
0.0541542955,
0.0075036623,
0.0454984941,
0.0055129258,
0.0537322462,
-0.0235386584,
-0.0245025549,
0.0058524325,
0.0154680945,
-0.0499223098,
-0.0505433343,
-0.0185332261,
-0.0585388914,
0.0228774454,
0.0275693964,
-0.0386977047,
0.002298408,
0.0276304111,
0.0339964442,
-0.0360381305,
0.0173178017,
-0.0318277963,
0.0058706379,
-0.0298842844,
-0.0318220258,
-0.0146412095,
-6.85264497e-33,
-0.0196895618,
-0.0101319272,
0.0390279852,
-0.0321966559,
-0.0192939136,
-0.0297206007,
-0.0084959744,
0.0042905328,
-0.0049375612,
-0.0360055305,
-0.0173121747,
-0.0097486358,
0.0272510629,
0.0087972311,
0.0202199295,
-0.0031532787,
0.0372213311,
-0.0209620073,
-0.0492779501,
-0.0068340651,
0.0490610376,
0.0155733414,
0.0589358844,
-0.0441297777,
0.011562583,
0.0264977235,
-0.0276111569,
0.0090432027,
-0.0384286419,
0.0744014457,
-0.0202041101,
0.0055425772,
-0.0051618759,
-0.0436250046,
-0.0248094834,
-0.0119722644,
-0.0310767815,
-0.0570535474,
0.028700484,
-0.0065931375,
-0.0061761211,
-0.0088148136,
0.0451398306,
0.0151332607,
-0.054096885,
0.0195451733,
0.018595824,
-0.0347938985,
-0.0018749692,
0.0563199259,
-0.0250248779,
0.0084240343,
-0.0128807416,
-0.0065209279,
0.040876653,
0.0440760069,
0.0288563799,
0.0613578409,
-0.0771028847,
0.0678764135,
-0.0146745956,
0.0426828898,
0.1157429367,
0.0341429375,
0.0107834134,
0.0368046351,
0.0239676684,
-0.0483445823,
0.0584323592,
-0.0290816482,
0.0519947223,
-0.0113345552,
0.011349543,
0.0259696413,
0.0300197713,
-0.0109432982,
-0.0279253069,
0.0618498698,
0.0465798788,
-0.0031630653,
0.0181733295,
0.0332391337,
-0.0386743397,
-0.0131369187,
-0.0414182171,
-0.0532224551,
-0.0412226319,
-0.055242043,
0.0428770147,
0.0177749116,
-0.0168361403,
0.0068987799,
0.0391217209,
-0.0289033502,
-0.047527127,
0.0016537393,
-0.0431058779,
0.0075926716,
0.0218008589,
0.0327630937,
-0.0777001083,
-0.0247428846,
-0.0035854438,
0.0047229626,
-0.0144996373,
-0.0107761519,
-0.0130543513,
0.0273080505,
-0.0938848481,
0.033289779,
-0.0226596016,
0.0053221011,
0.0214607939,
0.0035392633,
0.0482380949,
-0.0224337596,
0.0194117595,
0.0780933872,
0.0459811091,
-0.0159379132,
-0.0609534681,
-0.0106592588,
-0.0341387168,
0.0577991791,
-0.0178521685,
0.0244111158,
-0.0134478025,
0.0127882743,
-0.0307725277,
-0.0339396261,
-0.0186997503,
0.0032493686,
2.722e-7,
0.0250048228,
0.0428366102,
0.0186080988,
-0.0253293347,
-0.0051874681,
0.0275303256,
-0.0617612451,
0.0082634976,
0.0538062453,
0.0223668553,
0.0148973279,
-0.0059262398,
0.0319821537,
0.0226411689,
-0.0458504595,
0.027731983,
-0.0868157595,
0.037460085,
-0.044950895,
-0.0208816007,
0.0101030944,
0.1085354164,
0.0375183187,
-0.0039880234,
-0.0118441414,
0.0295356866,
0.0504210554,
-0.0263501089,
-0.0056848717,
0.0160332303,
-0.0087447148,
-0.0104474071,
-0.0551872216,
-0.0338207111,
-0.023829326,
0.0707100555,
-0.0695399046,
0.0424261205,
0.030128574,
-0.0722702295,
0.0034332697,
0.0268772077,
-0.0078736544,
-0.0723556727,
0.079708688,
-0.0483922474,
-0.0182236731,
-0.0188693516,
-0.0364169031,
0.0106001049,
0.0542617515,
-0.0380184837,
-0.0185603648,
0.0100570414,
0.0095058857,
0.0111326687,
-0.0272887144,
-0.0264177117,
-0.0228988249,
0.0092436876,
-0.0220308714,
-0.0245092809,
-0.0473728403,
0.0392699875,
0.011343128,
-0.0551020205,
0.0145177487,
2.581089425e-34,
0.0140957339,
-0.0294926744,
0.0024895873,
-0.016221961,
-0.0165550504,
-0.0198968891,
0.0124769825,
0.0382063724,
0.02540759,
-0.0674344152,
-0.0245413799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20818v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20818v2
|
An iterated learning model of language change that mixes supervised and unsupervised learning
| 2024-05-31T14:14:01 | 2024-06-15T15:25:01 |
Jack Bunyan, Seth Bullock, Conor Houghton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, nlin.AO, q-bio.PE
|
The iterated learning model is an agent-based model of language change in
which language is transmitted from a tutor to a pupil which itself becomes a
tutor to a new pupil, and so on. Languages that are stable, expressive, and
compositional arise spontaneously as a consequence of a language transmission
bottleneck. Previous models have implemented an agent's mapping from signals to
meanings using an artificial neural network decoder, but have relied on an
unrealistic and computationally expensive process of obversion to implement the
associated encoder, mapping from meanings to signals. Here, a new model is
presented in which both decoder and encoder are neural networks, trained
separately through supervised learning, and trained together through
unsupervised learning in the form of an autoencoder. This avoids the
substantial computational burden entailed in obversion and introduces a mixture
of supervised and unsupervised learning as observed during human development.
|
[
0.0029079434,
0.0550544262,
-0.0661958456,
-0.0078747645,
-0.0405471474,
0.0058240988,
-0.0176200736,
-0.0081048869,
-0.0218582973,
-0.0246138964,
-0.0066777291,
-0.0043970486,
0.0057916748,
0.017670719,
0.0135585088,
-0.0621997081,
0.0440393202,
-0.0250434857,
-0.059721753,
-0.017940037,
-0.0489861779,
-0.0191463251,
-0.0017163757,
0.0249668546,
0.0199658815,
0.0036922987,
-0.0754907578,
-0.0683793798,
-0.0326391347,
0.0483618379,
-0.07771191,
0.0003478627,
0.0658659413,
0.0416327193,
0.0000019852,
-0.0326942652,
0.0065604565,
-0.0505145751,
-0.0384014919,
-0.0081795305,
0.0698035508,
-0.0029646689,
-0.0377047397,
-0.0259949006,
-0.0523080602,
-0.0070351148,
0.0348351784,
-0.0562632233,
0.0487814024,
0.0477430448,
0.0101407869,
-0.0453496501,
0.0412230529,
0.0040656761,
-0.0215260424,
-0.0087805064,
0.0281725246,
-0.0112582026,
-0.0304867327,
0.0011242848,
-0.1076511219,
0.0228435677,
0.0465249717,
-0.0410426408,
0.0218167715,
0.0064897463,
0.0772635862,
-0.0563818961,
-0.0381539129,
-0.0057944516,
-0.0063798721,
-0.007682282,
-0.0189987011,
0.0263832659,
0.0133456616,
0.004141273,
0.0088065388,
0.0257003326,
0.0550832227,
0.0296571441,
0.0370804518,
-0.0357218608,
-0.005048811,
-0.0051774927,
-0.0112935025,
0.0615542233,
0.0035507702,
0.0071972329,
-0.0099366056,
-0.0233838595,
0.0733330622,
-0.03665407,
0.0015236638,
0.0644574985,
0.0198049024,
0.027791664,
-0.0393771119,
-0.0588107556,
-0.0376038402,
-0.0467434078,
0.0440275073,
0.0118270004,
-0.0034639081,
-0.0039485828,
-0.0465526693,
0.0169024132,
0.0050059683,
0.0272279903,
-0.0676415861,
0.0291324854,
-0.0543849245,
-0.030158883,
-0.0486771427,
0.0276068598,
-0.0067282501,
-0.0154376486,
-0.0213482697,
0.0542057157,
0.0024339065,
-0.0380277187,
-0.0729442462,
-0.0386633947,
-0.0230691824,
0.0303246863,
-0.0198430326,
0.0382808447,
-0.0233423933,
0.0219628159,
0.0080702612,
-0.0199881587,
0.0155691076,
0.013867368,
0.0043132505,
0.0460706167,
-0.0283015035,
0.0700688437,
-0.0354361236,
0.0024590297,
-0.0658122823,
0.0035707646,
0.0150245829,
-0.0168027971,
0.005013519,
-0.0482526347,
0.0057396623,
-0.0339109041,
-0.0133726839,
-0.1135933697,
-0.0125337867,
-0.0487399623,
-0.0023788169,
0.0051565212,
-0.0282627922,
0.0329384878,
0.0675153434,
-0.0119324857,
0.0595143028,
0.0532463454,
0.0439966135,
-0.0348641127,
-0.0205010008,
-0.0520934612,
-0.0012688441,
0.0378468148,
0.0223505385,
0.0159349162,
0.0058124959,
-0.0854304358,
0.040854577,
0.0563888997,
0.0291276574,
0.0094546285,
-0.0335897468,
0.0050259377,
0.0139701115,
0.0491427816,
0.0227412656,
0.0445846207,
0.0587652922,
0.0297409408,
-0.0119291684,
0.0352579206,
0.0554216616,
0.0302355438,
-0.0196085405,
-0.0316508114,
-0.0376164019,
0.0027567095,
-0.0484830514,
-0.0459523611,
0.0457929075,
-0.0185799487,
0.0716665238,
-0.0566321053,
0.0709665418,
0.0588451698,
0.0012843859,
0.01596082,
0.0518651344,
-0.0162201039,
0.0401992016,
-0.0753476545,
0.025830023,
0.0425002873,
0.0113080125,
-0.0203480311,
0.0279729515,
-0.0061204606,
-0.0004347614,
0.0381588936,
-0.0058291671,
-0.0349088721,
-0.0168645382,
-0.0310556553,
-0.0135530168,
0.035748627,
0.0126251038,
0.0430577844,
-0.0881819129,
0.0276563503,
-0.0112145962,
0.0224837866,
-0.0579572953,
0.0395280384,
-0.067758888,
-0.0259191506,
0.013406802,
0.0306248423,
0.0204786118,
0.0029642959,
0.0059695179,
0.0094533898,
0.0099655343,
-0.0182864852,
-0.0255820882,
0.0255757924,
-0.0641828626,
-0.0227982961,
0.0413486697,
-0.0078992788,
0.0132309645,
0.0040361048,
0.0168503933,
-0.0698590204,
0.10771963,
-0.0796946734,
0.0906317607,
0.0250840224,
0.0504377037,
-0.0523732305,
-0.0069329422,
-0.000225506,
0.0076618847,
-0.0027429962,
-0.061262425,
-0.024539914,
0.0270075649,
0.0130126961,
-0.0168440677,
-0.0102164755,
0.003504402,
-0.0116193909,
0.0299472157,
0.007749124,
-0.0053278529,
-0.0080704754,
-0.0244551562,
0.0080924015,
-0.062974751,
-0.0003705068,
0.0159930531,
-0.0057185721,
0.0041518938,
0.0303271729,
-0.0216064584,
-0.0353245214,
0.1048124731,
-0.0100731067,
0.010086949,
-0.0130524551,
-0.0168185309,
-0.0415976681,
-0.0249039046,
-0.0382589549,
-0.0196343176,
0.0349640585,
0.0271249656,
-0.0290438216,
-0.0851462036,
-0.0088317487,
-0.015269069,
0.0236475598,
0.009564993,
-0.0479875095,
0.0577168204,
-0.0052261865,
0.0713207647,
0.0512266755,
0.0103584835,
0.0581861995,
0.0691558272,
-0.0102924053,
-0.0415663756,
-0.0313925259,
-0.0550471805,
-0.0550157726,
-0.0499111675,
-0.0266802348,
-0.0149322907,
0.0469197109,
0.0410282388,
-0.0184313767,
-0.0690596178,
0.022758523,
-0.0255455133,
-0.0602205843,
-0.0145977642,
-0.0725171193,
-0.0300956946,
0.0306452736,
-0.0176941287,
-0.0182045214,
0.0462271534,
0.0363379382,
0.0266207904,
-0.0347383879,
0.0180928074,
0.0166951995,
0.0516038612,
0.0355461501,
0.0358153693,
0.0040223687,
-0.0154669024,
-0.011433294,
0.040000096,
0.0351989567,
0.0048460448,
0.0027724633,
-0.089571476,
-0.0257448703,
0.0307342708,
0.0196192879,
-0.0075130016,
0.0259341411,
0.0076912381,
0.0288267303,
-0.0014615587,
0.0181682371,
-0.0039953198,
0.0014738162,
-0.007073421,
0.0468944274,
0.0158861727,
0.0031576082,
-0.0476591662,
-0.0399274454,
0.0160997622,
0.0038781448,
-0.015866166,
-0.0295395833,
0.0715075359,
0.0012392441,
0.0296648704,
0.0225668177,
-0.0335813276,
0.0469921716,
0.0221586023,
-0.0165978689,
0.0098492922,
0.0241520796,
-0.0159638189,
-0.0372948498,
-0.0205346458,
0.0454919301,
0.0132916691,
-0.0436458141,
0.0316456594,
-0.0688612536,
-0.0222984627,
-0.0038505888,
0.0425716974,
-0.0517789498,
0.0188105572,
-0.0036837731,
0.0151234297,
0.0067017777,
-0.016174091,
0.0260330364,
-0.07488098,
0.0066452734,
0.0528277606,
-0.0477540828,
-0.0093593299,
-0.0116908271,
-0.0127100339,
0.0239362214,
-0.0089357449,
0.0366399921,
0.0285550747,
-0.0165157355,
0.011948498,
0.0168766249,
-0.0285730008,
-0.0200735573,
-0.0420443229,
0.0602468066,
0.0713683143,
0.0212123562,
-0.0291926786,
-0.0278386604,
0.0274675526,
-0.0009332759,
0.0182350148,
-0.0114069665,
0.0210581049,
0.0144126704,
-0.0113279279,
0.0007715412,
0.0362352617,
-0.0283229928,
0.0295302607,
0.0223187432,
0.0729644448,
-0.0053384406,
-0.0360507444,
0.0159407724,
-0.0336039141,
-0.0109916404,
0.0126240067,
0.0325102955,
-0.0896324515,
0.015784679,
-0.0349441767,
0.010207762,
0.024252018,
-0.0487888232,
0.0155824302,
-0.0082348231,
-0.0604425855,
-0.0813207626,
0.0027624322,
-0.0022354824,
0.0481719114,
0.0820799172,
-0.0395522192,
0.0910295248,
-0.0513891317,
-0.0132147288,
-0.0528880544,
0.0137274861,
-0.0200725868,
-0.0619830377,
-0.0814965963,
0.030132819,
-0.0580693111,
0.0244586021,
-0.0489960909,
-0.0075527574,
-0.0507599674,
0.0601440594,
0.0284905341,
0.0196626559,
0.0530275069,
-0.0218370445,
-0.0383381434,
0.0365146324,
-0.0245406777,
-0.0091993827,
0.0546258241,
-0.016828347,
-0.02524033,
-0.0112133278,
0.0165358558,
0.0087714801,
0.0275588669,
-0.0001391762,
-0.0136977611,
-0.0570161641,
-0.0231484976,
0.0313633755,
-0.0217073504,
0.003086996,
0.0031480796,
0.008592803,
-0.0543591008,
-0.0129364347,
-0.0010205443,
0.0307832602,
-0.023775043,
-0.0048199128,
0.0352296196,
0.0599818453,
0.0174697656,
-0.0197873749,
0.047420688,
-0.0355793908,
0.0140578514,
0.0186626296,
0.0190188177,
0.0656608716,
-0.0221115947,
0.0795968026,
0.0239911601,
0.0403515995,
-0.03215947,
0.0251282677,
-0.0185598526,
0.0325290747,
0.0409018397,
0.0103562996,
0.0178023521,
0.004724123,
-0.0216762051,
-0.0197339877,
-0.0188050438,
0.000079799,
0.0002811675,
0.0219272617,
0.0268772356,
-0.0349391811,
0.0249038208,
-0.0223274641,
0.0014197192,
-0.0468670838,
-0.0524934828,
-0.0135911824,
-0.0218468476,
0.0246815234,
-0.0003440364,
0.012703754,
-0.0273828339,
0.0371550471,
-0.051275339,
0.033898022,
-0.014823541,
0.0294701122,
0.0239406694,
0.007723249,
0.0074954769,
0.0305753965,
0.0295901019,
-0.0040996419,
-0.0439661443,
0.0238863043,
0.0261028726,
-0.0167739466,
0.0637878776,
0.01999381,
-0.0362079293,
-0.0089804037,
-0.0497388206,
0.0202218238,
-0.013606336,
0.0053066332,
0.0116366101,
-5.809602384e-33,
-0.056662567,
0.016349297,
0.0213174373,
0.0461788699,
-0.0288584996,
-0.0373517685,
-0.0349361412,
0.0061216471,
-0.0062947832,
0.0062383609,
0.0269605275,
0.0067100427,
-0.0032711825,
0.0248010438,
0.0802341029,
0.0252444763,
0.0523567908,
-0.0635307208,
0.0191904977,
-0.003607796,
0.0344197713,
0.0062654954,
0.0500408597,
-0.0557174571,
-0.0157452859,
0.022059219,
0.0299798772,
0.0251309648,
-0.0164162144,
-0.0191404186,
0.0016555575,
0.0333772786,
0.0007551828,
-0.0280687418,
-0.0257053543,
-0.0176964253,
-0.0816561207,
-0.0708040595,
-0.0350545533,
0.0666146949,
-0.0871656388,
-0.0459962003,
0.0565718748,
-0.0115770102,
-0.0384708419,
0.0263884123,
0.0203498732,
-0.0224524848,
-0.0104797715,
0.0195536688,
-0.0872536376,
-0.0117272902,
-0.0032186622,
-0.0508400314,
0.048590254,
0.0042752912,
-0.0624708496,
-0.0894365609,
-0.0770710036,
0.0668040738,
0.028632123,
0.0275168177,
0.0336341672,
0.0334923305,
0.0297306553,
0.0143317776,
0.0766965225,
0.0043253209,
-0.007906883,
0.0049344306,
0.0870749578,
0.0040893508,
0.0220276918,
-0.0126968259,
-0.0227524824,
-0.0491725393,
-0.0065126806,
-0.0110352226,
0.0494362414,
0.0107398005,
-0.0206694938,
0.0367979743,
0.0180768929,
-0.0482299961,
-0.0329311565,
-0.0543439016,
0.0053239246,
-0.0491923541,
-0.0032122778,
-0.0224400964,
0.0098407147,
-0.0507513806,
0.0127151646,
-0.0433299765,
0.0171114542,
-0.0641961545,
-0.0248306524,
0.0458580814,
0.013762787,
0.0163147766,
-0.0714490116,
-0.0285592899,
0.0089203957,
0.0129826972,
0.0094052926,
0.0465751961,
0.0059974021,
0.0574557781,
-0.002377488,
-0.0047745612,
0.0086524384,
-0.0478950292,
0.0626768321,
-0.0399761871,
0.0116877006,
0.0102988835,
-0.0149868727,
0.0280436166,
0.0371692814,
-0.0004868225,
-0.0407784134,
-0.0094113695,
-0.0067776595,
0.042860914,
-0.0340433866,
0.0095939673,
-0.0460756533,
0.0686769411,
0.0267900564,
-0.0472224131,
0.0088704238,
0.0369503796,
2.803e-7,
-0.0032152459,
0.0346670672,
0.0489993431,
-0.0379946716,
0.0623305254,
0.0055491757,
-0.0139939627,
0.02525701,
0.0036989269,
0.0108044306,
0.0154558029,
0.024565326,
0.0090455413,
-0.0078259706,
-0.0078048157,
-0.0014764079,
-0.0072707585,
0.0363931321,
-0.0263837259,
0.0177502967,
0.0490146317,
0.0526374541,
0.0308378991,
-0.0138223693,
-0.0010201157,
0.0139911827,
0.0416710861,
0.0096263941,
0.030656023,
0.0309598427,
-0.048798345,
0.0284112282,
-0.0071437419,
0.0486092754,
0.0041348557,
0.0319709219,
-0.0075733364,
-0.0331431143,
-0.0508229509,
0.0260165557,
0.0485244691,
0.030192798,
-0.0306409951,
0.0245041642,
0.0110853491,
-0.060964793,
-0.0417505205,
0.032390397,
-0.0303137153,
0.0416708104,
-0.015114164,
0.0119172949,
-0.0274652336,
0.0118331062,
0.0076950639,
0.0363481715,
-0.0073357178,
-0.0404624864,
0.0380789526,
-0.0264737997,
-0.0436029807,
-0.0239376649,
-0.029018512,
0.0210307874,
0.0190878641,
-0.015348047,
-0.0050138324,
1.506263653e-34,
-0.008435837,
0.0193923749,
0.0429067276,
-0.0097085135,
-0.0155637553,
-0.0214042459,
0.0067251767,
0.0356096476,
0.0407763459,
-0.0239330791,
-0.0449926294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20805v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20805v2
|
Multilingual Text Style Transfer: Datasets & Models for Indian Languages
| 2024-05-31T14:05:27 | 2024-06-09T18:46:48 |
Sourabrata Mukherjee, Atul Kr. Ojha, Akanksha Bansal, Deepak Alok, John P. McCrae, Ondřej Dušek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text style transfer (TST) involves altering the linguistic style of a text
while preserving its core content. This paper focuses on sentiment transfer, a
vital TST subtask (Mukherjee et al., 2022a), across a spectrum of Indian
languages: Hindi, Magahi, Malayalam, Marathi, Punjabi, Odia, Telugu, and Urdu,
expanding upon previous work on English-Bangla sentiment transfer (Mukherjee et
al., 2023). We introduce dedicated datasets of 1,000 positive and 1,000
negative style-parallel sentences for each of these eight languages. We then
evaluate the performance of various benchmark models categorized into parallel,
non-parallel, cross-lingual, and shared learning approaches, including the
Llama2 and GPT-3.5 large language models (LLMs). Our experiments highlight the
significance of parallel data in TST and demonstrate the effectiveness of the
Masked Style Filling (MSF) approach (Mukherjee et al., 2023) in non-parallel
techniques. Moreover, cross-lingual and joint multilingual learning methods
show promise, offering insights into selecting optimal models tailored to the
specific language and task requirements. To the best of our knowledge, this
work represents the first comprehensive exploration of the TST task as
sentiment transfer across a diverse set of languages.
|
[
0.0169154163,
0.0430767015,
-0.0292732734,
0.0584700964,
-0.0761617199,
0.0142248431,
-0.0382473506,
0.0218723603,
-0.0016601856,
-0.020483572,
-0.0557021275,
-0.0666881353,
0.0193260964,
0.0057399054,
0.0170407575,
-0.0800717175,
0.0033054017,
0.0069884825,
0.0220357534,
-0.0128707737,
0.0687054172,
0.0347983874,
-0.0006202364,
-0.0230101142,
-0.0214747898,
-0.0120384088,
0.0285114422,
0.0199286435,
0.0366008356,
0.0053523197,
0.0330800004,
0.0160962902,
0.0123600606,
-0.0121940114,
0.0000017384,
-0.0294791907,
-0.0134462239,
-0.0276260562,
0.1078711674,
0.0107407244,
0.1093342006,
-0.0409109034,
0.0058332374,
0.0170467664,
-0.0119364131,
0.0059237075,
0.0781066716,
0.0675835982,
0.078010641,
0.0996946096,
-0.0490578786,
-0.0539215468,
-0.0011223962,
-0.0064738817,
-0.0098154182,
-0.0127792787,
0.0291754268,
-0.0137810335,
-0.0366534069,
-0.0149673438,
-0.0059204218,
0.0338535421,
-0.0335126221,
-0.0192452073,
0.0021441779,
-0.0438796245,
-0.0494115353,
0.0322824419,
0.0287394729,
0.0677086264,
-0.0225964431,
-0.0244234446,
0.0159617849,
0.0116530126,
-0.0266159978,
0.0078567173,
-0.0604817532,
-0.0205181036,
-0.0227275249,
0.0684337988,
0.0198617987,
0.009696045,
0.0176356025,
-0.0176194571,
0.0287985038,
-0.0057286914,
0.0199835487,
-0.0326044448,
-0.0149410656,
0.0407187305,
-0.0186023284,
0.0052311071,
0.0533350296,
-0.0322622061,
0.0250492953,
0.0318891816,
-0.04658252,
-0.0781037062,
0.0049629454,
-0.0582888052,
0.0487887859,
0.0105657596,
-0.0075976034,
0.0096465051,
-0.06744048,
0.0024427534,
-0.033973068,
0.0138646718,
-0.024350794,
-0.0372909755,
-0.0509639792,
-0.0219481792,
0.0162877142,
0.0129215792,
0.0073770885,
0.0149607612,
-0.0341932476,
-0.0259577204,
-0.0390918218,
-0.0291412789,
0.0313414931,
-0.0756479651,
-0.0240273997,
-0.0470459461,
0.0345911719,
0.0504737608,
-0.0238266271,
0.0451269336,
-0.0264661275,
-0.0205278322,
-0.0177084338,
0.0317997187,
0.0180750769,
-0.032551378,
-0.0304376539,
0.0259306449,
-0.0605710149,
0.0055767922,
-0.0836660042,
0.0333038457,
0.0201695226,
-0.0406454839,
0.003188944,
-0.0804352537,
0.0259831268,
-0.0099251447,
0.0215249453,
-0.0065676444,
0.0183728542,
0.016268814,
-0.040456906,
0.0601826198,
0.0160850659,
-0.0117190657,
0.0245766379,
0.0130552854,
0.043266017,
0.0657311082,
0.0164750442,
0.0296814609,
0.0428650603,
-0.0338175707,
0.0033420695,
0.0422397591,
0.0260065198,
0.0404842012,
-0.0403585546,
-0.0355334952,
0.0479941629,
0.007491027,
0.017537728,
0.0391003042,
-0.0127475662,
0.0152251041,
0.0851548016,
-0.0155091342,
0.0080213165,
0.0347395353,
0.0117349969,
0.0010743063,
0.0012327057,
0.038260743,
0.0297550708,
0.0142125404,
-0.0088848369,
-0.0079863118,
0.0354445204,
0.0209705327,
-0.0352010801,
0.0155098904,
-0.0057121706,
-0.0505251102,
0.017342139,
-0.0499250367,
0.0391851813,
0.0494185537,
-0.0624339506,
-0.021453185,
0.058366362,
-0.0669404566,
0.022649752,
-0.0132149057,
0.0169045217,
0.0681695491,
-0.0206473768,
-0.0130368751,
0.006391027,
-0.0018932772,
0.0036301431,
0.0097533716,
0.0203447808,
-0.0154947639,
0.0180274192,
-0.0827586651,
0.0579467751,
-0.0010204125,
-0.0129877236,
0.0426339023,
-0.0139795933,
0.0599441789,
-0.0135189397,
0.0105581712,
0.00129446,
0.0163570456,
-0.0080817016,
-0.0182430204,
0.0214670245,
-0.0073462198,
0.0337824449,
-0.0175296776,
-0.0217316244,
-0.0498511977,
-0.020746015,
-0.0594816245,
-0.0439747125,
0.0531433076,
-0.0396261141,
-0.0707927421,
-0.0294691101,
-0.0669139326,
0.0311507508,
0.0823776424,
-0.0471413434,
-0.0632022843,
0.0172475316,
0.0011323687,
0.0308330301,
-0.0106870178,
0.0182744749,
-0.0100004403,
0.0099726385,
0.0025254712,
0.0012603541,
0.0219069403,
-0.0354452543,
-0.0277962536,
-0.0123430379,
0.0296599008,
0.0259623565,
-0.0049435524,
0.0259562768,
0.040379148,
0.0144531671,
0.0028876711,
0.0054793069,
-0.0378356464,
-0.0554151945,
-0.077477105,
-0.005510889,
-0.0035030928,
0.0506062098,
0.0317269973,
0.0250456762,
-0.0067129275,
0.0039782226,
-0.0597636625,
0.0163485073,
-0.0072134319,
0.0408096984,
0.0627060458,
-0.0129709914,
0.0106912032,
-0.0308898389,
-0.0206863154,
0.0088181728,
0.0329563096,
-0.0271117073,
-0.069342874,
-0.0399456248,
0.0002038122,
-0.0105247572,
-0.0156537313,
-0.0030022087,
-0.068344146,
-0.0484956317,
-0.0316639803,
0.0486777686,
0.0484294519,
0.020513352,
-0.0622820407,
0.0032864385,
-0.0134461122,
-0.0009353919,
-0.0137560684,
0.0005825156,
0.0205924027,
-0.0039053487,
-0.0623072013,
0.0234289337,
0.0319273882,
0.0125899697,
-0.0251016095,
-0.0745426789,
-0.0478306413,
-0.0007234018,
0.0028274423,
0.0162161198,
0.0316000953,
-0.0305449758,
0.0123489667,
-0.003072422,
-0.0411355421,
0.0365772583,
-0.0178737864,
0.0106093148,
-0.055299405,
0.0017351576,
-0.0603119694,
0.0045221462,
-0.0222686622,
0.0067874216,
-0.0439264216,
-0.0087515339,
-0.0279076304,
-0.0104256934,
0.0339950696,
-0.003947821,
-0.0025122073,
-0.0601473376,
0.015346433,
-0.0163873434,
-0.0364865698,
0.0330500193,
-0.0572925955,
0.0113007799,
-0.0133684678,
0.061715629,
-0.0317485221,
0.0421664007,
0.0177202094,
-0.0292802658,
0.0027270981,
-0.0225505829,
0.0033206246,
0.0276423804,
0.0328174978,
0.0524224378,
-0.0355970524,
-0.0190411415,
-0.0139320502,
-0.0160872061,
-0.0036674261,
0.0171271842,
-0.0112830801,
-0.0102916658,
0.0019002877,
0.0261008758,
-0.0141075319,
-0.0322768725,
-0.0572343767,
0.0648334771,
0.0069211978,
0.0080908155,
0.0460701138,
0.0192535706,
-0.0596971959,
-0.0510856435,
-0.0473470427,
0.0145435901,
-0.0142998369,
0.0239378903,
-0.0598122627,
-0.0154492175,
0.0039459639,
-0.0184106734,
0.0009096923,
-0.0004741579,
-0.0099263191,
-0.1088988706,
-0.0297887437,
0.0128638269,
-0.0495116785,
-0.0279142428,
-0.0124320481,
0.0017125173,
0.0066774748,
-0.0304021351,
-0.0392322652,
-0.033558052,
-0.0222200882,
0.0257774666,
-0.0174740274,
-0.0219846573,
-0.0082929432,
0.0057642381,
0.0381857082,
0.0365055501,
0.0313024893,
-0.0367696993,
-0.0813935548,
0.004771248,
-0.0268036798,
-0.033216089,
-0.0247219242,
0.0662862137,
0.0042027761,
-0.0160420407,
0.0054234616,
0.008408051,
-0.0228967797,
0.0098845465,
0.0433110036,
0.0390748046,
0.0416588411,
-0.0659952536,
0.0174177457,
0.0058353902,
0.0342791639,
0.0187570844,
0.0109467497,
-0.0689169392,
-0.0103010964,
-0.0158116929,
0.0123376455,
-0.0558189861,
-0.0078434255,
-0.0179475062,
-0.0793275535,
0.0072130477,
-0.0954333618,
0.0012583915,
-0.0006267054,
0.0518033467,
0.0420339629,
0.0349573568,
-0.018331036,
-0.0040625781,
0.0129610887,
-0.057773333,
-0.0276606008,
0.045316156,
-0.0277078878,
-0.0199935809,
0.0470209233,
-0.036679592,
0.0133071514,
-0.0514292531,
-0.0470185727,
-0.0376562215,
-0.0035863977,
0.0610192753,
0.0053978972,
0.0121211233,
0.0097040636,
-0.0799992904,
0.0390115157,
0.0419161245,
0.013009374,
-0.00261473,
0.0634936541,
0.0264936518,
0.0146222757,
0.0533112921,
-0.0068749846,
0.040517319,
0.0176041275,
-0.0021680722,
0.0137693891,
-0.0043714526,
-0.0026119831,
0.0167071372,
0.0098261442,
-0.0043394435,
0.0009986908,
-0.0222773962,
0.0262897592,
-0.0076348307,
-0.0058991825,
-0.0465883836,
-0.0256390758,
0.0640140399,
0.0461174659,
-0.0433115661,
-0.0006127523,
0.0379753523,
0.001722017,
-0.0223719869,
0.0363458209,
0.0579291582,
0.0838028714,
0.0115837641,
0.0448667742,
-0.008180582,
-0.0225931518,
0.021353038,
0.0127651514,
-0.0193374101,
0.0502694994,
0.0309327245,
0.0063919462,
0.0318065435,
0.0352558717,
0.0013375549,
0.0355984941,
-0.0099297352,
-0.0120881181,
0.040445134,
-0.0280258674,
0.1043362096,
-0.0166311599,
-0.0003185132,
-0.0087701119,
0.0465534776,
-0.0334245525,
0.0245326236,
0.0183533803,
-0.017980719,
-0.0092693148,
0.0139190061,
0.0765728876,
-0.0621858574,
0.0277909543,
0.0134774856,
-0.0031486452,
-0.0175912809,
-0.0092200981,
0.0455509834,
0.0004294601,
0.0768841058,
-0.0247993432,
-0.0170032717,
-0.0530278608,
0.0557774827,
-0.0849710181,
0.0231666751,
-0.0037789536,
0.0010758361,
0.0539041795,
0.0211476162,
0.0296764467,
-0.0588127971,
0.0150625054,
0.0051651862,
0.002745861,
0.0258374587,
-5.86038925e-33,
-0.0067094113,
0.0226203892,
-0.0533886254,
0.0615588389,
-0.0228909664,
-0.0181428716,
-0.0012775485,
-0.015197197,
0.0242688581,
0.0603259839,
-0.0138530014,
0.0061482969,
0.0109561374,
0.0209576748,
0.0438243598,
0.0234894082,
0.0441927947,
0.0393719897,
-0.0053260326,
0.0309854243,
0.0741822273,
0.0267370827,
0.0967897475,
-0.072875604,
0.0082866251,
-0.0344276167,
-0.0409124307,
0.0074264915,
0.0210558232,
-0.0078652957,
0.0017871246,
0.0333883315,
0.0292184372,
-0.0390069596,
-0.0222977083,
0.0243422911,
-0.0258016437,
-0.0345803238,
0.0431842878,
0.0385688879,
-0.0248422306,
-0.0369554162,
0.0185011122,
-0.0239155572,
-0.0054715145,
0.0105685359,
0.0229518581,
-0.0058458578,
0.0152810328,
-0.0589599125,
-0.0812592283,
0.0309014507,
0.0090097748,
-0.0010934403,
0.0280499682,
0.032516662,
-0.0015092203,
0.0226917826,
-0.0565849841,
0.0100363949,
-0.0477708168,
0.0196756497,
0.0134530999,
0.0110265398,
-0.0200928655,
0.0222658757,
-0.0081468038,
0.0335577391,
0.0133561864,
0.0373962224,
0.013087159,
0.0130502628,
0.0261575449,
0.0850880817,
0.0112385647,
-0.0678122714,
-0.0120731238,
0.0238165855,
0.0230629817,
-0.0024177185,
0.0159599073,
0.0297345296,
-0.0090109408,
-0.0307804756,
0.0148180351,
-0.0275278706,
-0.0139298495,
-0.020459218,
0.0157369059,
-0.01191606,
-0.0063874731,
0.0385750979,
0.0209712777,
-0.0025200516,
-0.0435733646,
-0.0001872208,
-0.0935131311,
0.058655832,
-0.013966932,
-0.0012447572,
-0.0525570661,
-0.0438549593,
-0.0199208837,
0.044085972,
0.0189214014,
-0.0206550304,
0.1013009995,
0.014089358,
-0.1249939427,
-0.0207672268,
-0.0082463985,
0.0473506451,
0.0114513291,
0.0142275356,
-0.0062210318,
-0.0075684395,
-0.016585717,
0.0344206728,
0.0676739886,
0.006049111,
-0.0019694008,
-0.0119480863,
-0.0220200475,
-0.0088661341,
-0.0448836945,
-0.0009304831,
-0.0421754643,
-0.047866717,
-0.0034612315,
-0.055069264,
-0.0200596768,
-0.0013317533,
2.59e-7,
-0.0153994281,
0.0632287115,
-0.0037797887,
-0.027890278,
0.0143055301,
0.0406897329,
-0.0438336022,
0.0536887124,
0.0137348771,
0.0444272868,
0.0001299961,
-0.0021085453,
0.0512601808,
0.0193749908,
-0.113918215,
0.0190668348,
-0.0475741886,
0.0065596043,
-0.01931029,
-0.0028439586,
0.0288088899,
0.0355890505,
0.0492356941,
-0.0179897491,
-0.0012451693,
-0.0005946285,
0.0979930907,
-0.0431730337,
-0.0094931656,
0.0272913836,
-0.0106874518,
-0.0425879247,
-0.0647444725,
0.0172745828,
-0.0142577607,
-0.0281745512,
0.0490978807,
0.07721515,
0.0279359706,
0.0269441307,
0.0133093325,
0.0411662981,
0.0001007925,
-0.0239045676,
0.0671441704,
0.0211961959,
-0.0577184781,
-0.0844560862,
-0.0195172727,
-0.0087447315,
0.0560704954,
-0.0126204137,
-0.0113225728,
0.0376722924,
0.00144389,
0.001457089,
-0.0713132918,
-0.0456293337,
-0.0078165932,
-0.0179383885,
0.0002842574,
-0.0372543782,
-0.0146155702,
0.0483390875,
-0.0004629595,
-0.0303036049,
0.0541352965,
1.801880278e-34,
0.0447213054,
-0.060064964,
0.0264430828,
0.0055914964,
0.0192130245,
-0.0209798981,
-0.0198596641,
0.0284774173,
0.0243826807,
-0.0758872479,
0.0251754392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20797v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20797v2
|
Ovis: Structural Embedding Alignment for Multimodal Large Language Model
| 2024-05-31T13:59:18 | 2024-06-17T17:51:50 |
Shiyin Lu, Yang Li, Qing-Guo Chen, Zhao Xu, Weihua Luo, Kaifu Zhang, Han-Jia Ye
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Current Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) typically integrate a
pre-trained LLM with another pre-trained vision transformer through a
connector, such as an MLP, endowing the LLM with visual capabilities. However,
the misalignment between two embedding strategies in MLLMs -- the structural
textual embeddings based on an embedding look-up table and the continuous
embeddings generated directly by the vision encoder -- makes challenges for a
more seamless fusion of visual and textual information. We propose Ovis, a
novel MLLM architecture designed to structurally align visual and textual
embeddings. Ovis integrates an additional learnable visual embedding table into
the visual encoder's process. To capture rich visual semantics, each image
patch indexes the visual embedding table multiple times, resulting in a final
visual embedding that is a probabilistic combination of the indexed embeddings.
This structural approach mirrors the method used for generating textual
embeddings. Empirical evaluations on various multimodal benchmarks show that
Ovis outperforms open-source MLLMs of similar parameter scales and even
surpasses the proprietary model Qwen-VL-Plus overall. These results highlight
the potential of Ovis' structured visual representation for advancing MLLM
architectural design and promoting more effective multimodal learning. Code,
datasets, and models are available at https://github.com/AIDC-AI/Ovis.
|
[
-0.0187230874,
0.0422432609,
0.0081658037,
0.0737176985,
-0.0118517699,
0.0053430917,
-0.0177583937,
-0.0247376356,
0.0078713009,
-0.0806536674,
-0.0420990698,
0.0070253792,
-0.0025079262,
0.0475380979,
0.052616898,
-0.0294191856,
-0.0011228068,
-0.0217445493,
-0.0335700288,
0.0074425102,
0.0408465527,
0.0204051696,
0.0035097708,
0.0308553129,
-0.01362029,
-0.0307066943,
-0.0105900411,
0.0153009174,
0.0152341789,
-0.0095085166,
-0.0304032825,
0.0086884378,
0.0878881514,
0.000331525,
0.0000018471,
0.0025864854,
0.016211642,
0.0030307912,
0.0334235132,
-0.002032479,
0.0273480769,
-0.0818431601,
0.0061140643,
-0.0173288062,
-0.017951699,
-0.042955257,
0.0782833174,
0.0305112991,
0.0537576415,
0.046476569,
-0.0319722816,
-0.0448817462,
0.0348639563,
-0.0076409392,
-0.0210399497,
-0.0088435784,
0.0049591032,
0.0288632251,
-0.0401583239,
0.0075381361,
-0.0758394226,
0.053604573,
0.0186943598,
-0.022972241,
0.0238863993,
0.0441103354,
0.0104581611,
-0.033344768,
-0.0247669388,
0.0991145521,
-0.0564044006,
0.0088858726,
-0.0331915691,
-0.000484431,
-0.0068069519,
0.0091169076,
-0.0465270989,
0.0562417358,
0.028170174,
0.0396699719,
-0.0296369921,
0.0123735331,
0.0447136573,
-0.0158096906,
-0.0025926495,
-0.0377763584,
0.0301085785,
0.0123670921,
-0.0294763595,
0.0117984517,
-0.029916795,
-0.0100192185,
-0.0440343879,
0.0172303449,
0.0118541047,
0.0056117298,
-0.0550838113,
-0.0005800976,
-0.0173436664,
-0.042096708,
0.0561264381,
0.0268188063,
-0.0522848666,
0.0757233053,
-0.0652548149,
0.0532038175,
-0.0503135994,
0.0553102233,
-0.037258666,
-0.0441080555,
-0.0105920546,
-0.0101539288,
-0.003782334,
-0.0184768941,
-0.0355576053,
-0.0795139149,
-0.0133672189,
0.0519585162,
-0.0205858015,
0.0295355301,
-0.0164478403,
0.0039365264,
0.010708428,
-0.0150610553,
-0.0056885867,
0.0479461104,
0.0251976401,
0.0017472198,
-0.0265390091,
-0.0187337808,
0.0151430573,
0.0692552552,
0.0036835736,
-0.0257445592,
-0.0210786797,
0.0771547183,
-0.0450424701,
-0.0321548805,
-0.0151140876,
-0.0031640837,
-0.0221123248,
-0.0271002352,
0.0500937663,
-0.0438361727,
0.0593003705,
-0.0223360192,
0.0232226085,
-0.0215504281,
-0.0021281086,
-0.0054041729,
-0.0054857261,
0.0873313397,
0.005665984,
0.0055805799,
-0.0024234299,
0.0019552363,
0.0410067998,
0.0779281706,
0.0326116085,
0.0260641482,
0.0286880359,
-0.0249961335,
-0.0305909421,
0.058803983,
-0.0124542387,
0.0039308639,
-0.0612050891,
-0.0047209919,
0.0508241765,
0.0499974675,
0.0571392067,
0.0263566189,
-0.0407263227,
-0.0249503013,
0.0742161423,
0.0246166531,
0.0465223826,
-0.0019875863,
0.0259107314,
-0.0131896511,
-0.0057765585,
-0.0263626594,
-0.0486546382,
0.0707978308,
-0.0056349337,
0.0115312357,
0.0315774344,
0.0619435608,
-0.0361547507,
0.0121463481,
-0.0153454235,
-0.0320219882,
-0.0065626642,
0.010496119,
0.0336751677,
-0.0074044531,
-0.0400454737,
0.0078802928,
0.0140243759,
-0.0188811552,
0.0071799899,
-0.0149206379,
0.0164376013,
0.045043584,
0.0444681048,
0.0158594362,
0.0033524556,
-0.0130843008,
0.0247949976,
0.0438404679,
-0.0059443614,
-0.0185891632,
0.0392473415,
-0.0773282796,
-0.0501952171,
-0.0168893263,
-0.0152511261,
-0.0042429031,
-0.0121019026,
0.0018894223,
0.0133617204,
-0.0277293753,
0.0305891037,
0.042704735,
0.0110818511,
0.0199421104,
-0.0448178351,
0.032618273,
-0.0050447905,
-0.0116352979,
-0.0202033501,
-0.008193003,
0.0272361878,
-0.0543673672,
0.0057184361,
0.0022811578,
-0.0397116803,
-0.0272177309,
0.0379029028,
-0.0530984513,
0.0048212348,
0.0129637606,
-0.0382543802,
-0.0120839858,
-0.006332132,
-0.0186649319,
0.0066201277,
-0.0587232783,
-0.0160523485,
0.004034434,
0.0348099321,
-0.0366904177,
0.034401875,
-0.0327469185,
-0.0181341618,
0.0001184085,
0.0055079279,
0.0112453112,
0.0012863444,
-0.0460627377,
0.0331045464,
0.0205926597,
0.0265944824,
-0.0078563234,
-0.0048073553,
-0.0224020723,
-0.0334761441,
-0.1036100239,
-0.0120301098,
-0.0196865126,
-0.0361461863,
0.0138284238,
-0.0202922095,
0.013418626,
-0.0236506984,
-0.0292363074,
0.0331199579,
0.0044508395,
0.0302209426,
0.0179831199,
-0.0186122414,
0.0008836228,
0.0004509974,
-0.0158902016,
0.0115826996,
0.0840665102,
-0.0280990843,
-0.0327815041,
-0.0591351725,
-0.0422526523,
-0.0292640124,
0.0064027808,
-0.0209937897,
-0.0270775687,
-0.0066760322,
-0.0369031169,
0.0638208017,
0.0551903099,
0.0019573232,
0.0381944217,
0.0588734783,
-0.0086801248,
-0.0302553251,
-0.0220219381,
0.0092777656,
-0.008815554,
-0.0236959383,
0.0093896054,
-0.0598612502,
0.0158010051,
-0.0148100452,
0.0247573778,
-0.0584148169,
0.0007966531,
0.0282491501,
-0.0311997887,
-0.0565143526,
-0.0020021154,
0.0046926863,
-0.00145824,
-0.0500114635,
-0.0714797527,
0.0140321674,
-0.0300125945,
-0.0165160131,
0.0333881825,
0.0017928622,
-0.0358657204,
0.0746866167,
0.0333592556,
0.0338050984,
-0.042927295,
0.0040492876,
-0.052173797,
0.0119082564,
0.0074391449,
-0.0066411081,
0.0899945796,
-0.0251238644,
-0.0014400445,
-0.0436550155,
-0.0100086415,
-0.0086760158,
-0.0360618196,
-0.0426890627,
-0.0070056063,
-0.0412659794,
-0.0128328782,
-0.0366614573,
0.0119036324,
0.0257442351,
0.0147481691,
0.0039876476,
0.0049575809,
-0.0266407169,
0.043081753,
0.0604214706,
0.034133032,
-0.0230669025,
-0.0385896638,
0.0157159511,
0.0524077788,
-0.0172075145,
0.0019997351,
-0.0643637776,
0.0279956087,
0.0331841893,
0.0535517856,
-0.0216287468,
0.0127644194,
0.0227450673,
-0.0308226962,
0.0289610289,
0.0676447153,
-0.0001793012,
-0.0424024984,
-0.0331025869,
0.0176715348,
0.067050986,
0.0337285064,
0.0136201177,
-0.0997791961,
-0.0513264239,
-0.0137978848,
-0.0435897373,
0.0560246594,
0.0090224491,
-0.0267891288,
-0.0863880664,
0.0514466278,
0.0287807621,
0.0048366864,
-0.0407520607,
0.0126772383,
-0.0172982663,
-0.0056021209,
0.0033026831,
-0.009976509,
-0.0092998724,
-0.0159436725,
-0.0040831105,
0.0082489075,
-0.0280413982,
-0.0023557497,
-0.0655617043,
0.0195240863,
0.0506583229,
0.0260418635,
0.0080045937,
-0.0631024241,
0.0354707241,
0.0034484584,
-0.0081413919,
0.0038011197,
0.0502935499,
-0.0440311171,
-0.0283075366,
-0.0045190994,
0.0172645096,
-0.0118083395,
-0.0181548838,
-0.0338322558,
0.0966165215,
-0.0055096187,
-0.0023988816,
-0.0356297493,
-0.0114920372,
-0.0356935449,
0.0331669487,
0.0124691064,
-0.0455031954,
-0.009895754,
-0.001654121,
0.0130563751,
0.0151953874,
-0.0396203101,
0.0274518896,
-0.0096095111,
0.0085994797,
-0.0480083786,
0.0003196245,
0.0277609639,
0.0505184084,
0.0060840743,
-0.0178915355,
-0.0325858891,
-0.0235237926,
-0.0543932617,
0.0448762365,
-0.0431264415,
0.0359834097,
-0.0346299484,
0.0275711361,
0.0554144457,
-0.0325813666,
0.0050369552,
-0.0162617862,
-0.0536846966,
-0.0300477762,
-0.0407785438,
0.0566359274,
0.0033594351,
0.0403158143,
0.0330310538,
-0.0637734607,
0.0441223085,
0.0202853121,
0.0173827149,
0.0325411409,
-0.0195273366,
-0.0222930796,
0.0077519338,
0.0335022174,
-0.0469309203,
-0.0144205708,
-0.0209202077,
0.0197305772,
0.0208369941,
-0.0129210902,
-0.0089853164,
-0.0228715055,
0.0442544855,
-0.0421768688,
0.0200556275,
-0.0503289588,
-0.0005852437,
-0.0341125987,
-0.0308170579,
-0.0702953041,
0.0191885866,
0.0460343249,
0.0183040071,
0.0193813797,
0.0425050706,
0.0485567041,
0.0440618284,
-0.0388205573,
0.029253535,
0.022349719,
-0.0371223725,
0.0095408773,
0.0740715116,
0.0030292431,
0.0244008917,
-0.0529745668,
0.0085495301,
-0.0296981484,
0.0522547513,
0.0195835494,
-0.0192541052,
-0.0418889374,
0.0531649925,
-0.0035439238,
-0.0201286748,
-0.0165955238,
0.0303477775,
0.0760558471,
0.0033341805,
0.0626728013,
0.0070358813,
-0.03091399,
-0.025508495,
0.0574696064,
-0.0237078331,
-0.0512614287,
0.0892366767,
0.0060975733,
-0.0260030888,
-0.000124788,
0.0314468406,
0.0201103557,
0.0007792069,
-0.0042306632,
0.0123055279,
-0.02944934,
-0.0186074898,
0.0551087968,
0.0189742111,
-0.0189956985,
0.0120320823,
0.0048707654,
-0.0479270257,
0.0028699141,
0.0208697766,
-0.0519759431,
0.0286872089,
0.018084839,
0.0403936841,
0.0059318366,
-0.0261534471,
-0.024414679,
-0.0136693111,
0.0097607914,
-0.0255956799,
0.0283737015,
-5.663140196e-33,
-0.02444534,
-0.0113529693,
0.0301162098,
-0.03834543,
-0.0403533429,
0.0358122997,
-0.0006242229,
0.032159809,
-0.0261724833,
0.0096381372,
0.0442621335,
-0.014788595,
-0.0072012111,
0.0519685186,
-0.0007552278,
-0.0021241582,
0.0045044124,
-0.0217624977,
0.0170891117,
-0.0081911432,
0.0048664394,
0.0107732769,
0.0379967652,
-0.0506953597,
-0.028831685,
0.0239218529,
-0.0172087532,
0.0123774223,
0.0526230149,
0.0736103877,
-0.0413059406,
0.023562476,
0.0197988357,
0.0349846296,
-0.0376953967,
0.0364495069,
-0.0608671978,
0.0141113056,
0.007955566,
0.0486959107,
-0.0968430191,
-0.0115397694,
0.0415606797,
-0.0227514915,
0.0002550607,
-0.0653500482,
0.0507821441,
-0.0082486328,
-0.0441142395,
0.0141681638,
-0.0402997322,
0.0147033874,
0.0011531767,
-0.0194055419,
0.0645404905,
0.0199765414,
0.0537505522,
0.056051787,
-0.0627998859,
0.0046188594,
-0.0694020838,
0.0096871182,
0.0934147835,
0.0650252253,
0.0230577663,
0.0954375267,
0.0263519119,
-0.0544334985,
-0.0436340086,
0.0238893963,
0.0372018851,
0.0507530831,
0.0386596397,
0.0668690726,
-0.02180041,
0.0248735398,
-0.0594121926,
-0.0019940159,
-0.0317216031,
0.013725861,
0.037713185,
0.0541227311,
0.0054341368,
-0.0119263437,
-0.0504995957,
-0.0262389034,
-0.0340128504,
-0.0101468554,
0.0576705858,
0.0145449713,
0.020503182,
0.0196758136,
0.0846135169,
-0.0565107204,
-0.0019612361,
0.0261650998,
-0.0337748043,
0.0737999156,
-0.0043223076,
0.0326712169,
-0.0378326736,
-0.0165612772,
0.0509022251,
-0.0481151454,
0.0031060169,
0.0121727893,
0.0439812355,
0.0398252718,
-0.0560077541,
0.0022379491,
-0.0434699357,
-0.0521935225,
-0.0060572373,
0.0235878192,
0.0395511612,
-0.0032255019,
-0.0410566851,
0.0544857122,
0.0085847192,
0.0217880439,
-0.0044793352,
-0.0503546782,
0.005175035,
0.0124709727,
0.0094962493,
0.0355004631,
-0.0578260459,
-0.0442881547,
0.0400023796,
-0.0699350014,
0.0041478132,
0.0464619435,
2.401e-7,
0.042590335,
0.0180118512,
0.0160855558,
-0.0209145136,
0.0230813492,
0.045377668,
-0.0188301373,
0.0541159175,
-0.0070243622,
-0.0600621477,
-0.0060684262,
0.0348236933,
0.0403017141,
-0.0163882263,
-0.0235023685,
0.028206788,
-0.0482069775,
0.0013233561,
-0.0338868424,
-0.0037803687,
0.040413864,
0.1163722873,
-0.0185448881,
-0.0227727331,
0.0306893345,
-0.0531327911,
0.1046956703,
-0.0376280695,
-0.0258592945,
-0.0288933422,
-0.0242371373,
0.0377080888,
-0.0138032623,
-0.0060469634,
0.0015549833,
0.0184211005,
0.0536091253,
0.0515101738,
-0.0246916581,
-0.0296511408,
-0.0161824245,
0.0098379673,
-0.0584070049,
-0.044366695,
0.0792386234,
-0.0402965918,
-0.0444816351,
-0.0321726315,
-0.0271525867,
0.0049813986,
0.0372950397,
-0.0136184981,
-0.0480566323,
0.0346249826,
0.0620967597,
-0.0390254818,
-0.0332751758,
-0.0912302956,
-0.0317340158,
-0.0171758328,
-0.0630852208,
-0.0018376037,
-0.0461938009,
-0.027192302,
0.0599805936,
-0.0269615036,
-0.0592573546,
2.130870956e-34,
0.0181216486,
-0.0198934469,
0.0209857617,
0.0125776371,
0.0252334699,
-0.040254306,
-0.0108522512,
-0.0188717879,
0.0019283483,
-0.0896721035,
-0.0203584395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20755v1
|
Improving code-mixed hate detection by native sample mixing: A case study for Hindi-English code-mixed scenario
| 2024-05-31T11:43:31 | 2024-05-31T11:43:31 |
Debajyoti Mazumder, Aakash Kumar, Jasabanta Patro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hate detection has long been a challenging task for the NLP community. The
task becomes complex in a code-mixed environment because the models must
understand the context and the hate expressed through language alteration.
Compared to the monolingual setup, we see very less work on code-mixed hate as
large-scale annotated hate corpora are unavailable to make the study. To
overcome this bottleneck, we propose using native language hate samples. We
hypothesise that in the era of multilingual language models (MLMs), hate in
code-mixed settings can be detected by majorly relying on the native language
samples. Even though the NLP literature reports the effectiveness of MLMs on
hate detection in many cross-lingual settings, their extensive evaluation in a
code-mixed scenario is yet to be done. This paper attempts to fill this gap
through rigorous empirical experiments. We considered the Hindi-English
code-mixed setup as a case study as we have the linguistic expertise for the
same. Some of the interesting observations we got are: (i) adding native hate
samples in the code-mixed training set, even in small quantity, improved the
performance of MLMs for code-mixed hate detection, (ii) MLMs trained with
native samples alone observed to be detecting code-mixed hate to a large
extent, (iii) The visualisation of attention scores revealed that, when native
samples were included in training, MLMs could better focus on the hate emitting
words in the code-mixed context, and (iv) finally, when hate is subjective or
sarcastic, naively mixing native samples doesn't help much to detect code-mixed
hate. We will release the data and code repository to reproduce the reported
results.
|
[
0.0514990613,
0.0239034425,
-0.0439481549,
0.0627793595,
-0.0061216899,
0.0539490841,
-0.0207801778,
0.0479654148,
0.0385141298,
-0.0575775765,
-0.0497428104,
0.0024064197,
-0.0225665495,
0.030633457,
0.0085665034,
-0.0124851419,
0.0207879115,
0.0632584095,
0.012860477,
-0.0144807678,
0.069702819,
0.0149963284,
0.0072188675,
0.03953062,
-0.0651662275,
-0.0053859218,
0.030507952,
0.0563081056,
0.0197645836,
-0.018797474,
0.0631364882,
0.0420947112,
-0.0209712852,
0.0462003723,
0.0000018531,
-0.0127334548,
0.0056277099,
-0.023286771,
-0.0053708735,
-0.0203465261,
0.1133788526,
-0.0234453194,
-0.0063137114,
0.0294133183,
-0.0390271507,
-0.0106281368,
0.0710995048,
0.0215896629,
0.0729268566,
0.0853099674,
-0.0056087081,
-0.0049999328,
-0.0289918128,
0.0038664229,
-0.007740254,
0.0557273813,
0.0005541335,
0.0029705646,
-0.027365515,
-0.0219717976,
-0.0048084077,
-0.0085009718,
0.0004758128,
0.0263473578,
0.0071479823,
-0.0215553977,
-0.0480421185,
-0.0099804709,
0.0073087579,
0.05274285,
-0.101089336,
-0.0394604132,
-0.0302933436,
-0.0222223662,
-0.0647823364,
-0.0866332427,
-0.0049428828,
-0.0025915231,
-0.050130669,
0.0544105247,
0.027566025,
-0.0046983962,
0.0216585509,
0.0187404901,
0.0015125094,
0.0111781098,
-0.0178931709,
-0.0408056565,
0.0250459686,
0.0062908418,
-0.0018611132,
-0.0215274468,
0.0147197377,
0.0190509241,
0.0444140956,
0.0180302188,
-0.0533156991,
-0.0662677363,
0.0126684522,
-0.0790535659,
-0.0020461539,
0.0363013558,
-0.049641002,
0.0004274501,
0.0008012301,
0.0121767223,
0.0005352927,
0.0259968657,
-0.0164989047,
-0.0121021541,
-0.0071393717,
0.0117907654,
0.0235413499,
0.0276030395,
0.0004280496,
0.0712837353,
-0.0286537595,
0.0156944152,
-0.0524374805,
-0.0071754502,
-0.0195703264,
-0.0463924408,
0.0115010105,
-0.021878399,
-0.0087196035,
0.0095429253,
-0.0728791356,
0.0000242301,
-0.037672095,
-0.1131343171,
0.0027653575,
0.0545340776,
-0.0355248265,
-0.0301151872,
0.0308913086,
0.05158218,
0.0659263507,
-0.0306291487,
-0.0533201322,
-0.008396782,
-0.0384400114,
-0.0431912802,
-0.0074485345,
-0.0553963333,
0.0025526418,
-0.0197607744,
0.0001233843,
-0.0559096746,
-0.0132400459,
0.0020870573,
-0.0516341254,
0.0734731108,
-0.0550566316,
-0.0585982539,
-0.003701681,
0.0213075113,
0.0048636124,
0.0513625145,
-0.0123747652,
-0.002675818,
0.0478296131,
-0.0042490689,
0.0092558749,
0.0582517795,
0.0158557948,
0.0008351256,
-0.0631086826,
0.0181719251,
-0.0353462622,
-0.0599233881,
0.0297590196,
0.0444335416,
-0.0284987576,
-0.0371994823,
0.0052399654,
0.0252056215,
-0.0405963473,
0.0195426811,
0.0421904027,
0.0271641854,
0.0017812609,
0.024175765,
-0.0388200283,
-0.0110343648,
-0.0675613284,
-0.0544649214,
0.0315939039,
0.0362699628,
-0.0335705616,
-0.0682184324,
-0.0468474142,
-0.0441267677,
0.0087127117,
-0.0308056958,
0.0172435045,
0.0083011752,
-0.0111685889,
-0.0138498638,
0.077907972,
-0.0618796945,
0.0128563354,
-0.0127047002,
0.0297840722,
0.0519138426,
0.016229067,
-0.0295303315,
-0.0259735845,
-0.0323353559,
-0.0979615599,
0.0027645635,
0.0039221109,
-0.0141376052,
0.0004349377,
-0.024072675,
0.0158563424,
-0.000845144,
-0.0031173453,
0.021573402,
0.0141822416,
0.0322815068,
0.0024806876,
0.0183759071,
-0.0291359387,
0.0131358523,
0.0350547917,
-0.0132819312,
-0.0064890087,
0.0315841213,
0.0578298308,
0.0145625481,
-0.0211952794,
-0.0401762202,
0.0082229655,
-0.0140744066,
-0.0356872976,
0.0383398868,
-0.0017277459,
-0.0800088048,
0.0164661258,
-0.0599328838,
-0.0149708651,
0.0631134063,
0.0129412636,
0.002140288,
0.0465411656,
-0.0128240902,
0.0313298926,
-0.0012890359,
0.0047027562,
-0.0532574728,
0.0105896182,
-0.0449430346,
0.064404659,
-0.0046505281,
-0.0026571436,
0.0065391804,
-0.0168272872,
0.063485384,
0.050458055,
-0.0764133483,
0.017846562,
0.0085458038,
-0.0098280478,
-0.0072865225,
0.0106641911,
-0.0370481685,
-0.0267922319,
-0.1077262536,
-0.018068241,
-0.0217098873,
-0.0253983699,
0.0280922055,
0.0069008558,
-0.0157613046,
0.0408865847,
-0.0186747145,
-0.0261194892,
0.0215485413,
0.0124574611,
0.0059551331,
-0.0269123763,
0.0147513747,
-0.0575273931,
-0.011930597,
-0.0190902036,
0.0187223069,
-0.0222860966,
-0.0450123139,
-0.0140493764,
0.0335335732,
-0.0430023596,
0.0216756966,
-0.0296483338,
-0.0598168746,
0.0091131041,
-0.0014796931,
0.0463937037,
0.052542679,
0.0023846442,
0.0570053309,
0.0308054667,
-0.0129533317,
-0.0327136926,
0.0260723587,
0.0326733589,
0.0182922333,
-0.0296986997,
-0.0217150338,
0.0338382274,
0.0787835419,
0.0162379313,
-0.0159645826,
-0.0648169294,
0.0255900882,
-0.0522503294,
-0.0055282591,
0.0219998471,
-0.0216350127,
-0.0103451582,
0.0076718,
-0.0147868637,
-0.0758133829,
0.0608635806,
-0.0079109427,
-0.0220691543,
-0.07852339,
-0.0063155824,
-0.0138918208,
0.0087329866,
-0.0187653005,
0.0252372622,
-0.0252056904,
0.0018249727,
-0.0133749135,
-0.0068132277,
-0.016548438,
-0.003539654,
0.0155364266,
-0.0373462066,
-0.0222105458,
0.0081192255,
-0.0256463885,
-0.0559795164,
-0.0648582503,
-0.0526882932,
-0.0594878457,
0.0684528947,
0.0001146945,
0.0539104789,
0.012741969,
0.0056011174,
-0.0350312814,
-0.0075288778,
-0.013085817,
0.0351514556,
-0.0193357579,
0.02408305,
-0.0405432209,
0.0383056886,
0.0441579074,
-0.0375854447,
0.0017650971,
0.0439732671,
0.0293112174,
-0.0153719923,
0.0091384547,
0.0276495665,
0.0441900864,
-0.0374162458,
-0.0127947591,
0.0359645821,
0.0177425556,
-0.0111609735,
0.0704607666,
0.0301455148,
-0.0620809086,
-0.0039013636,
-0.0276710093,
0.0249789748,
0.033634156,
0.0012327442,
-0.0581333116,
-0.0048217177,
-0.0351605266,
-0.0003475117,
-0.0253361706,
0.0052339397,
-0.0248741116,
-0.0999287218,
-0.0319518298,
0.003488719,
-0.0370405987,
-0.0395163037,
0.0449552611,
-0.011053713,
-0.000156043,
0.0103641367,
-0.0356426798,
-0.0050555309,
0.0079636462,
0.0225192327,
-0.0472744815,
0.0333364606,
0.0127699161,
-0.041677203,
0.0570112914,
0.0571184754,
0.0412257984,
-0.0186764654,
-0.0220768061,
0.0209665094,
-0.0167301483,
-0.0087307235,
-0.0612171069,
0.0400194675,
-0.0352347158,
-0.0436695814,
0.028358914,
-0.0048661074,
-0.0313910134,
0.0421132967,
-0.0061010513,
0.0547024384,
0.0263292938,
0.0250384472,
-0.0410428159,
0.0220822971,
-0.0140941422,
0.0409131683,
0.0324677266,
-0.0810976326,
0.0096874954,
-0.0222214349,
0.0019258508,
-0.0122036338,
-0.0648845211,
0.0217321124,
-0.0171272997,
-0.0216135737,
-0.0392857008,
-0.0879849419,
0.0060739852,
0.0542430431,
0.0318435095,
0.0087024374,
-0.0147042843,
-0.0276537295,
-0.0234690346,
-0.0037167221,
-0.0216535684,
0.0310152862,
-0.0229765903,
-0.0202597305,
-0.0229014698,
0.0011321852,
-0.0107295569,
-0.0175006296,
-0.0765092969,
-0.0300979707,
0.0286747068,
0.0744596422,
0.012045241,
0.0201680847,
-0.0428016111,
-0.0655835718,
-0.029619569,
-0.0159704164,
0.0069438354,
-0.0119483545,
0.0711413547,
0.0264483988,
0.0266708098,
0.0346307233,
-0.0320005789,
0.0270994399,
0.0542693697,
-0.0812930837,
-0.0296933781,
-0.0075232866,
-0.0042176275,
-0.0084236572,
0.0543561727,
0.000816245,
-0.0285941977,
-0.0141213248,
0.0148054324,
0.0240612887,
-0.0569573455,
-0.0176755544,
-0.045113299,
-0.0081991106,
-0.0110889124,
-0.0524108298,
-0.0339562409,
-0.06088553,
-0.0001254501,
-0.0070721065,
0.0616438389,
0.071705386,
0.0593375154,
0.0332830623,
0.033330407,
-0.0410389677,
0.020413233,
0.0163477026,
-0.0145666581,
-0.0077180131,
0.0321585089,
-0.0086254515,
-0.0103280544,
0.0371269695,
0.0163840912,
0.05042715,
0.0127569027,
-0.0130594093,
-0.0624665506,
0.0277550034,
-0.0319402069,
0.0505419672,
0.0173926931,
0.0359114483,
-0.036715202,
0.0077210576,
-0.0412003994,
-0.0610166006,
0.0275513846,
0.0194480512,
-0.0418451466,
-0.0398208946,
0.0795521215,
-0.0322558582,
0.0293407589,
0.0301239565,
0.016469501,
-0.0279158112,
0.06360434,
0.054673586,
0.0264309086,
0.0193920601,
0.0423241928,
-0.0762906447,
-0.0679694191,
0.0350775905,
-0.0524013489,
0.0494811907,
0.0189558398,
0.0337310955,
0.0770279244,
0.0035495211,
0.037854895,
-0.0140389288,
0.0288923662,
0.0383530073,
-0.0510623977,
0.00660897,
-5.647085147e-33,
-0.0073595433,
-0.021095315,
-0.034006048,
-0.0224106982,
0.0125744054,
-0.0183119886,
0.0162257422,
0.0164695214,
-0.0238798615,
-0.0099787405,
0.0050239535,
0.0416580513,
-0.0003004263,
-0.051377967,
0.013092244,
-0.0033392652,
0.0163898114,
0.040907193,
0.0120394016,
-0.0053548482,
0.0418386869,
-0.0124061173,
0.0644768998,
-0.0307437573,
0.0532418787,
-0.0380002521,
-0.0159704648,
-0.0051255184,
0.0212292913,
0.063392356,
-0.0037836919,
0.0740125701,
0.0391545594,
0.025568746,
-0.0282485131,
-0.020515535,
0.0060788137,
-0.0051645907,
0.0336536616,
0.0479893461,
0.0336466692,
-0.0339963995,
0.0535848066,
0.0166926216,
-0.0492363423,
0.0106564891,
0.0217029117,
0.0073555405,
0.022869803,
-0.0181509312,
-0.0813074708,
0.0468764082,
-0.0283778403,
0.0188774411,
0.0043838187,
0.0274355505,
0.0286921225,
0.0293490123,
-0.0471876264,
0.0211998764,
-0.0176016074,
0.0129149472,
-0.023980245,
-0.0392145589,
0.0125873545,
0.0780072659,
0.0353594571,
0.0186607875,
0.0181793775,
0.0410936698,
0.060153719,
0.0137215154,
0.0344550237,
0.0393437296,
0.023831889,
-0.0401563942,
-0.012389645,
0.0176023655,
0.038203679,
0.0222201757,
0.0132409809,
0.0268867593,
-0.0823132768,
-0.0257770326,
0.0544787161,
-0.0760743767,
-0.0406899638,
-0.0509240031,
0.0458368249,
-0.0222195666,
-0.001644862,
0.0038872072,
0.0188920051,
-0.033849556,
0.0093840882,
0.0431497619,
-0.0431151837,
0.0191514809,
0.026049586,
0.0354519337,
-0.0583001785,
0.0042267926,
0.0006441069,
-0.0224093478,
0.0437683873,
0.0162381455,
0.0767066851,
0.0111266589,
-0.1009472087,
-0.0050039063,
0.008551308,
0.0358518176,
-0.0102618579,
0.0492936559,
0.0127843721,
0.0302771144,
-0.0146536222,
-0.0219295733,
0.0219319109,
-0.0430267304,
-0.0536242649,
0.013914221,
-0.0229677279,
0.0027327966,
-0.0187124405,
-0.0355786718,
-0.0108915819,
-0.0022767556,
0.0106234569,
-0.0752244815,
-0.0124257794,
-0.0527841114,
2.519e-7,
-0.0166081432,
0.0445791967,
0.0026700904,
-0.019520456,
0.0266707782,
0.0388665237,
-0.0335712507,
0.0127766225,
-0.01863233,
0.0180528257,
-0.0406477228,
-0.0122048184,
0.022131741,
0.0607274659,
-0.0505327657,
0.0386590622,
-0.0046459436,
0.0243216865,
-0.018534692,
0.0134653188,
0.0209107678,
0.1045064107,
0.0561487563,
-0.0090434365,
0.0007003113,
0.0191035625,
0.010267023,
-0.0003507157,
0.0002747893,
-0.008961034,
-0.0087024681,
0.0184481032,
0.0011812814,
-0.0261065252,
-0.0005295808,
-0.0162634794,
0.031913951,
0.0337605067,
-0.0150801642,
-0.016345825,
0.0387729742,
0.0277258381,
-0.0286855604,
-0.0546320006,
0.0512850843,
0.0665914491,
0.0024703869,
-0.0384303667,
0.025084272,
-0.0136433002,
0.0446317047,
-0.0039598225,
-0.0296616144,
0.0150387175,
0.0188116413,
-0.0281766392,
-0.0232938584,
-0.0775766596,
-0.0160791185,
0.0255984031,
0.0157072991,
-0.0325023346,
-0.0142365731,
0.0277109668,
0.0766747817,
0.0337109193,
0.0470421724,
1.969894581e-34,
0.0398529693,
-0.0183563381,
0.0234759189,
0.0230205394,
0.0412886031,
0.0241656154,
-0.0185146723,
-0.0052645849,
0.053533826,
-0.0090900986,
-0.0016678509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20708v1
|
FinGen: A Dataset for Argument Generation in Finance
| 2024-05-31T09:00:43 | 2024-05-31T09:00:43 |
Chung-Chi Chen, Hiroya Takamura, Ichiro Kobayashi, Yusuke Miyao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Thinking about the future is one of the important activities that people do
in daily life. Futurists also pay a lot of effort into figuring out possible
scenarios for the future. We argue that the exploration of this direction is
still in an early stage in the NLP research. To this end, we propose three
argument generation tasks in the financial application scenario. Our
experimental results show these tasks are still big challenges for
representative generation models. Based on our empirical results, we further
point out several unresolved issues and challenges in this research direction.
|
[
0.0350852795,
0.0664828643,
-0.0036244867,
0.0028390193,
-0.0103313969,
-0.0312408395,
0.0107414098,
-0.0043271366,
-0.0062254192,
-0.0365129746,
0.0468831062,
-0.039103169,
-0.0088176792,
-0.0022143335,
0.0352440625,
-0.0979420617,
-0.0190340448,
0.0211811792,
0.0883726478,
-0.0397777557,
0.0435932837,
0.0249823276,
-0.0419534184,
0.0562154464,
-0.0325451307,
-0.0630304217,
-0.0099078789,
-0.0139037725,
0.0350526497,
-0.0271322131,
0.0072876923,
0.021154575,
-0.0089783603,
0.009088031,
0.000001987,
-0.0444990695,
-0.0015692447,
-0.0371711999,
-0.0304009747,
-0.0241685528,
0.0518965013,
0.0397040062,
0.0224146452,
0.0364265218,
-0.0579591095,
0.0443600677,
0.0346856378,
0.0832008943,
0.0642896444,
0.0819667503,
-0.0085383644,
-0.0547577515,
-0.0003357111,
-0.0206746813,
-0.042558264,
0.0217046291,
-0.0117665008,
0.0304977838,
-0.0321662761,
0.0060382532,
0.0005030184,
0.0070695779,
-0.0046291878,
-0.0084084924,
0.0036629408,
0.0266075619,
-0.043000903,
-0.0264218971,
-0.0477466211,
0.0430003293,
0.041444622,
0.001554907,
0.0138529986,
-0.0353553854,
0.019769581,
0.0204402469,
-0.040937122,
0.0733926296,
-0.0458358489,
0.0458327793,
0.0664091036,
0.0622569434,
0.001370766,
-0.0061121676,
-0.0089203268,
0.0218904298,
-0.036030598,
-0.0153515786,
0.0215337295,
-0.0011357777,
-0.0501492545,
-0.0600661039,
-0.0175246093,
0.0068687899,
-0.0030282412,
0.0263905022,
-0.032986328,
-0.0357743911,
0.0156702735,
-0.0651050359,
0.0588899031,
0.0060246931,
0.0425041653,
0.0091765234,
-0.0153409876,
-0.0197841767,
-0.0053419736,
-0.0502977781,
-0.0009873739,
0.0051541319,
-0.0564916208,
-0.0110691926,
-0.0507569313,
0.0525701791,
-0.0495968647,
-0.0278813429,
-0.028829487,
-0.0344611779,
-0.0323336646,
0.0064631547,
-0.0017660463,
0.0252941623,
-0.0210375153,
-0.0364369899,
-0.0601521358,
-0.0112352185,
-0.0711836293,
-0.0043667089,
0.0298966467,
-0.0269152578,
0.008387249,
0.0382624231,
-0.018016262,
-0.0181506444,
-0.0387702212,
0.0688895285,
0.0039651198,
0.0398256443,
-0.0454363413,
-0.1137741134,
-0.010943871,
-0.0366430841,
-0.0080968961,
-0.043994423,
-0.0060002627,
-0.0127975652,
-0.0126188695,
-0.0324748382,
0.0073286458,
0.0314482227,
0.0096972575,
0.0408071615,
-0.0216974001,
-0.021109134,
0.0111132348,
-0.0239089429,
-0.0359080546,
0.0459923036,
0.0133282291,
0.0351989381,
0.047683537,
0.0539442785,
0.0014425293,
0.0169358533,
0.0237866677,
-0.0356740765,
0.0556592681,
0.0083241221,
-0.0464772806,
0.0305635128,
-0.0098316809,
0.0413274765,
-0.0351776816,
-0.0313164629,
0.0352592394,
0.0085859634,
0.047070466,
0.0030374364,
0.0408376418,
0.0097164335,
0.0147544378,
0.0053262063,
0.0554609597,
-0.0063060024,
0.0065849698,
0.0118847536,
0.0000153818,
-0.0094424412,
-0.0245258771,
-0.0599008724,
-0.0270017888,
-0.0076428405,
-0.0329018645,
-0.037144959,
-0.0077934163,
0.0312013701,
-0.0351905935,
0.0323789716,
-0.0122705232,
-0.0245950595,
-0.0594032109,
0.0085882675,
0.0718668252,
0.0116442638,
0.0200376473,
0.0161834527,
0.0187189784,
-0.0230641179,
0.0242971331,
0.0803584903,
0.1247964203,
-0.025683457,
-0.0350958332,
-0.0456197448,
0.0029364054,
-0.0158981793,
0.0056437291,
0.0017356181,
0.0222049523,
-0.0060234424,
0.0224737767,
-0.0144623257,
-0.0311179105,
0.0122901667,
0.0141891241,
-0.002015108,
-0.0106614158,
-0.0086484812,
0.0244677532,
0.038190987,
0.0100806719,
0.0364271328,
0.0110364184,
-0.0150569687,
-0.0285671502,
0.0838014111,
-0.0373813026,
-0.015309073,
0.0161638875,
-0.0749865174,
-0.0141436681,
-0.028865749,
-0.0201548208,
-0.0240651574,
0.0115139857,
-0.0210189931,
0.0203364845,
-0.0151002519,
-0.0141388979,
0.0459455401,
0.0137724942,
-0.0033634773,
0.0822333917,
0.0357816219,
-0.0084765255,
-0.010536016,
0.0540038496,
0.0306051709,
-0.0703373253,
0.0310216602,
0.0078116357,
0.0065990933,
0.0077675479,
0.0705836937,
-0.0294905975,
-0.0503668971,
0.0205989163,
-0.0692384914,
-0.0240928065,
0.0016291476,
0.0266506393,
0.0180935189,
-0.065673925,
0.0238791835,
0.0188597701,
-0.0511404127,
0.0036808061,
-0.0208623782,
0.0024012295,
0.0755105317,
-0.0198704656,
0.0236369669,
-0.0300521012,
-0.003604193,
-0.0144883897,
0.0515837669,
0.0545887798,
0.0002430501,
-0.0319944434,
-0.0124055212,
-0.0235432703,
0.0000512696,
-0.0043400074,
0.0337789766,
0.0351722799,
0.0278925337,
0.0658281818,
0.0061294101,
0.0506486408,
0.0716088489,
-0.0392077602,
0.0115488097,
-0.0452673957,
0.0013487381,
-0.0369974338,
0.0506641865,
0.0036913413,
-0.0146229584,
0.0473617688,
0.0592166409,
0.0164620075,
0.0190121215,
-0.0798754767,
0.095345743,
-0.0064718542,
0.0168790855,
0.0062754592,
-0.0043598004,
0.0047338093,
0.0843941942,
-0.0113599617,
-0.0236587692,
0.0560586303,
-0.0149365924,
0.0189910121,
-0.016745517,
-0.0096694455,
-0.012667506,
0.0476766713,
-0.0406790227,
0.020759305,
0.0571138188,
0.0077630817,
-0.0204604417,
-0.0514024645,
0.024521146,
-0.0048962152,
0.0342314653,
-0.046439942,
-0.0033891846,
0.0011507454,
-0.0197337773,
-0.0100321649,
-0.0758252963,
-0.0295273643,
0.0160370264,
0.0159935001,
0.0029623371,
-0.030164184,
-0.0034064462,
-0.0283286516,
-0.0259685945,
-0.0109262718,
-0.0247335173,
0.0169142801,
0.0154308705,
0.0557234995,
0.0408036821,
0.0496963337,
-0.0005356011,
0.0477818437,
0.0471176058,
0.014338199,
-0.0035926974,
-0.0496868342,
-0.0464937352,
-0.0496084355,
-0.0526159555,
-0.0320418589,
-0.0042092325,
0.0309356675,
-0.0285001453,
0.031836994,
0.0457832739,
0.0266664568,
0.057986021,
0.0265973471,
-0.0228797868,
0.0554900505,
-0.0170833971,
0.0207447745,
-0.1106442735,
-0.0103230104,
-0.0357103571,
0.000875944,
-0.0491258353,
-0.0596720725,
-0.0367616415,
-0.1131709516,
0.0695308298,
0.0153675731,
0.0611374676,
0.0086357435,
0.0237480849,
-0.0395450443,
0.0051432992,
-0.0073914626,
0.0241970494,
-0.0075790086,
0.034568239,
0.0432762876,
-0.0457989275,
0.0305219386,
-0.0125324968,
-0.0065952465,
-0.005183694,
0.0185132716,
0.0636150464,
0.0444560573,
-0.0191955082,
-0.0553333312,
-0.0194001626,
0.0041906345,
-0.008523724,
0.0388416499,
0.0060408171,
-0.0157722794,
-0.0074198483,
0.0399938598,
-0.0278153401,
-0.0404335968,
0.0353730693,
0.0147708245,
-0.0553766564,
-0.0527043082,
-0.0210683513,
0.0453252755,
-0.0065519409,
0.0769745186,
0.0128901042,
0.0038330068,
-0.0541915074,
-0.0573637038,
0.0045304014,
-0.0821371973,
0.0249440633,
-0.0467354916,
0.0161493737,
0.0820539743,
-0.1195948943,
-0.0956345573,
0.0020615275,
0.0470161475,
-0.0283613168,
-0.0313114002,
0.0288631897,
-0.0232475568,
-0.0318195596,
-0.0168900862,
-0.0323701128,
0.0024961932,
0.0087319892,
-0.0055228216,
0.0183879249,
-0.0262193307,
-0.0192860756,
0.0363307223,
-0.0103160087,
-0.0691019669,
-0.0198782068,
0.0245009772,
0.0249305461,
0.0035097525,
0.0021289664,
0.0063914591,
0.0358656272,
0.0136565901,
0.0498222075,
-0.0181818493,
0.0534805767,
0.0132398084,
-0.0068892506,
0.0331528373,
0.0129885375,
0.0472556204,
-0.0164775308,
0.0395826995,
-0.0251721628,
0.0288896933,
0.0142352469,
0.0185252521,
0.0168581139,
-0.0035759341,
-0.0694422945,
-0.0220032018,
-0.0236412697,
-0.0528411269,
-0.0161405634,
-0.0253422838,
0.0170929264,
-0.0292418133,
-0.0153512927,
-0.0112104444,
-0.0051044296,
-0.0348820202,
0.022034144,
0.021209687,
0.0180785134,
-0.0086207585,
0.0172259528,
0.015690593,
-0.0203127768,
-0.0232498515,
0.0179799106,
-0.0247146506,
0.0417223014,
0.0213173646,
0.0217482578,
0.0382992625,
-0.0024390223,
-0.0019438056,
-0.0420738794,
-0.0499711223,
-0.0729610696,
-0.0094615873,
0.0053151445,
0.005004155,
-0.0292709656,
0.0369918309,
-0.0554466359,
0.0233631805,
0.030126581,
0.0403214656,
0.0303771459,
-0.0446269549,
0.033304628,
-0.0010526809,
-0.0661812127,
-0.0577730536,
0.085413903,
-0.0553192124,
0.0232844669,
-0.0160760451,
-0.0301240627,
-0.067423135,
-0.0555986539,
-0.0317127816,
-0.0119150383,
0.0431897491,
-0.0000399552,
-0.0671437085,
-0.004872147,
0.0027885358,
0.0393919386,
0.019397717,
0.0048685549,
0.0284646228,
0.0344839655,
-0.0040531666,
0.0171771888,
-0.0432784371,
0.0094274143,
-0.0446761325,
0.0232045371,
-0.0642875805,
-5.994957639e-33,
-0.0116116647,
-0.0276754405,
0.0443338752,
0.0352470949,
0.0029910584,
-0.013153879,
-0.0366608575,
0.0174815003,
-0.0142482026,
0.0543071516,
-0.003512946,
0.0034451527,
0.0087920036,
0.0229885466,
0.0041026818,
0.0000826221,
0.051140435,
-0.0268512536,
-0.023353355,
-0.0168822147,
0.0466845334,
-0.0018578874,
0.0352707207,
-0.0645523518,
0.0388613194,
0.0117632868,
-0.0500404984,
-0.010714246,
0.013413894,
0.0517292544,
0.0223035906,
0.0690922588,
0.0178082436,
-0.0860136226,
-0.0218621902,
0.0011102423,
-0.0141606592,
-0.0473322645,
0.009903919,
-0.0299780536,
-0.017855119,
-0.0204383098,
-0.0065314919,
0.0061368947,
-0.0115602566,
-0.0118783247,
0.018001534,
-0.0188558809,
0.0325079113,
-0.0332142971,
-0.0646267831,
0.0467591621,
0.0037174975,
0.050533317,
-0.0025049967,
0.0803120136,
0.0056821858,
0.0332137719,
-0.0530007705,
0.0415693037,
0.0104931938,
0.0028423241,
0.0104380874,
-0.0446228012,
-0.0092208991,
0.072067,
-0.0356545001,
0.0056975856,
-0.0284850616,
0.0425873175,
-0.0425732322,
0.0692909211,
0.0379799269,
0.0685236976,
0.0286051407,
-0.0188601688,
-0.022869803,
0.0046250494,
0.0663524717,
0.0111651691,
0.0355371907,
-0.0174566992,
-0.005294601,
-0.0115780868,
-0.0293044839,
-0.0500567742,
0.0079741254,
-0.0414554253,
-0.0203370098,
0.0184571538,
-0.0045469007,
0.0400821529,
-0.0099101169,
-0.0278192144,
-0.0285592396,
0.0067527066,
-0.0348255411,
-0.0090100262,
-0.012694411,
-0.0020035887,
-0.0457665548,
-0.0062714829,
0.0038233479,
0.0386782922,
0.0096140774,
0.0301394109,
0.0222506877,
-0.0316185355,
-0.0195470024,
-0.0107876658,
-0.0188735332,
0.0500458106,
-0.034182474,
-0.0023562124,
0.0006648973,
0.0488623492,
-0.0101761678,
-0.0052820342,
-0.0188302323,
-0.0015561479,
-0.0088442611,
0.0089488458,
0.029775383,
0.0396410488,
-0.0018543786,
-0.0012044141,
-0.000038113,
0.026270479,
0.0586117022,
-0.0334676318,
-0.0248057805,
0.039644815,
2.535e-7,
0.0255853813,
0.0445404425,
0.0313557498,
0.0163544584,
0.0157986507,
0.0394882262,
0.0285705887,
-0.0014431699,
-0.0235937499,
-0.0430040583,
-0.0142378174,
0.0017288813,
0.0428398512,
0.0336622484,
-0.0835125223,
-0.0909915566,
-0.083734937,
0.0018568048,
-0.0446290784,
0.0191196762,
0.1044106185,
0.0554684661,
0.0040096412,
-0.0100490116,
-0.0079651345,
0.0180569198,
0.0756737441,
-0.0399919897,
-0.0068659759,
0.0178975854,
0.0435490198,
-0.0358160883,
0.0199687909,
0.019565288,
-0.0092839273,
-0.0205804911,
-0.0337373316,
0.0096007781,
0.0412961915,
-0.0433865674,
0.0268427059,
0.0039163311,
-0.0060148276,
-0.0276941415,
0.0063669835,
-0.0912750438,
-0.0602928549,
-0.0462463982,
-0.0561687499,
0.0333556384,
0.0003411241,
-0.005007884,
-0.0145651624,
-0.0081703542,
0.0013833152,
0.0166109372,
0.0230001677,
-0.0669205487,
-0.0320748538,
0.0292127188,
-0.0365766957,
-0.0043250974,
-0.0122190872,
-0.0150610041,
0.0055084382,
-0.0594958961,
-0.0054529211,
1.814324332e-34,
0.045701921,
0.026514763,
-0.0115746623,
0.0195926353,
0.0812537819,
0.0080587082,
0.008015532,
0.0180416256,
0.0256162398,
-0.0466222949,
-0.0335530192
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20703v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20703v2
|
It is Simple Sometimes: A Study On Improving Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis Performance
| 2024-05-31T08:57:09 | 2024-06-06T10:23:48 |
Laura Cabello, Uchenna Akujuobi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) involves extracting opinions from
textual data about specific entities and their corresponding aspects through
various complementary subtasks. Several prior research has focused on
developing ad hoc designs of varying complexities for these subtasks. In this
paper, we present a generative framework extensible to any ABSA subtask. We
build upon the instruction tuned model proposed by Scaria et al. (2023), who
present an instruction-based model with task descriptions followed by
in-context examples on ABSA subtasks. We propose PFInstruct, an extension to
this instruction learning paradigm by appending an NLP-related task prefix to
the task description. This simple approach leads to improved performance across
all tested SemEval subtasks, surpassing previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) on the
ATE subtask (Rest14) by +3.28 F1-score, and on the AOOE subtask by an average
of +5.43 F1-score across SemEval datasets. Furthermore, we explore the impact
of the prefix-enhanced prompt quality on the ABSA subtasks and find that even a
noisy prefix enhances model performance compared to the baseline. Our method
also achieves competitive results on a biomedical domain dataset (ERSA).
|
[
0.0517139174,
0.0561572723,
-0.0015188858,
-0.0026044333,
-0.0236335415,
0.0251524393,
0.0205244683,
-0.0194453467,
-0.0308757666,
-0.0313954316,
-0.0326881558,
-0.0351982005,
-0.0191963986,
0.0665450692,
0.0048335302,
-0.032009434,
0.0346858799,
0.0184397567,
0.0164120235,
0.0010362461,
0.0108836722,
0.0225133561,
-0.0432755277,
0.0179881509,
-0.0061838175,
-0.0234821532,
0.0026362184,
0.0025366601,
0.026583191,
-0.04700277,
0.0422571599,
0.0266647413,
-0.0296046454,
-0.0542916022,
0.00000249,
-0.0045127142,
-0.023940336,
0.0071008182,
0.008617023,
-0.0177403558,
0.0895608217,
-0.0051110387,
0.0175973475,
0.0177888889,
-0.0359332897,
-0.0486725941,
0.0301420689,
0.0951307267,
0.0465358347,
0.085103035,
-0.0289012548,
0.0095321899,
-0.0119556198,
-0.0159438755,
-0.0035203989,
-0.0265853778,
-0.0077986773,
-0.062988624,
-0.0064942106,
0.0710242614,
0.0067136949,
0.0084763533,
0.0084733162,
0.0048021553,
0.040675085,
0.0244696941,
0.0559788682,
0.0152031444,
-0.0124036632,
0.0446048714,
0.0344630145,
0.0159904789,
-0.0058141896,
-0.0241732765,
0.0032413069,
0.0125380019,
0.006346304,
0.0024333331,
-0.0335329995,
0.0155265378,
0.0501268543,
0.0351244472,
-0.0249313489,
-0.0163498931,
0.0343312025,
0.018675182,
-0.0127562005,
-0.0516220033,
0.021180965,
0.0715040788,
-0.0065107895,
-0.0145476162,
0.0077461796,
-0.0069889165,
-0.0595369451,
0.0192526467,
-0.0093300976,
0.008647155,
0.014712139,
-0.0485097282,
0.0477668978,
0.0172318202,
-0.0288520306,
0.0087924656,
0.0000364758,
-0.0275521111,
0.0383732133,
-0.0204579867,
-0.0286362246,
0.0353433937,
-0.0869711488,
0.034832269,
0.0124940062,
0.0677755848,
-0.0602648295,
0.0183063075,
-0.0563300215,
-0.0028086572,
-0.0240282975,
-0.0090374807,
0.0290250666,
0.0105729476,
-0.0201014765,
0.0394967757,
-0.0507079326,
-0.0028326523,
-0.041665256,
0.0375545137,
-0.0201372001,
0.0055017504,
-0.0156007791,
-0.0137525275,
-0.0038438446,
-0.0173096545,
0.0155198341,
0.0240970813,
0.0343520902,
-0.0493233688,
-0.0041989614,
-0.0511020161,
-0.0199156329,
-0.0551900528,
-0.0251759999,
-0.0432541631,
0.032327164,
-0.0006176579,
-0.0109391976,
-0.0162383784,
0.0082207005,
0.0364217386,
-0.0182993487,
0.0628230795,
-0.0225121137,
-0.0006400932,
-0.0695468187,
0.0180986524,
0.033694461,
0.0362072177,
-0.028764911,
0.0248551257,
0.0310356636,
0.0099194953,
-0.0119941989,
-0.0350539163,
0.0159345008,
-0.011095603,
0.0820824057,
0.0031847409,
-0.0136089996,
-0.0247469377,
0.0133079411,
0.0416212976,
0.0240086038,
-0.0276569035,
0.0207510069,
0.0094540035,
-0.0149983298,
0.0312562846,
0.0328325778,
0.0287891068,
-0.0211083218,
0.0058316644,
-0.01188445,
0.0184517428,
-0.012438667,
-0.0151481181,
-0.0006941269,
0.0040935664,
-0.0454581641,
-0.0696927309,
-0.011523759,
-0.017962819,
-0.0257265791,
0.0339858755,
0.0257043187,
0.0247809794,
-0.0539080948,
-0.0383452438,
0.0711872131,
-0.0573668443,
-0.0163169038,
-0.0340663418,
0.0464963913,
0.0797536895,
0.0190877896,
-0.0372645557,
-0.0418747813,
-0.0308831427,
-0.011571547,
0.0304403063,
0.0169760641,
-0.0294985976,
0.0195659883,
-0.0230210051,
-0.0159593076,
-0.0416090637,
0.0047677397,
-0.0147889722,
0.0135166291,
0.0117270639,
-0.0132192494,
0.003843182,
-0.0227423869,
0.0212912709,
-0.0243634544,
-0.0477286391,
0.0302298367,
0.0210131127,
0.0400395915,
0.0642504394,
0.0068619694,
0.0006313284,
0.029286202,
-0.044081293,
-0.029330859,
0.0055141114,
-0.0534257181,
-0.0484701172,
0.0024583642,
-0.0091224443,
-0.01479981,
-0.0212436393,
-0.0429857895,
-0.0222584996,
-0.0250115227,
-0.0348348729,
0.0017309352,
-0.0070145479,
0.0042964309,
0.0174058918,
-0.011358601,
-0.0212681182,
0.0372882001,
-0.0207391214,
0.0238538757,
-0.0150604444,
-0.0046976297,
0.0064949496,
-0.0027104802,
-0.0195827074,
-0.0318362005,
0.0154492641,
-0.0226396974,
0.0355694853,
0.0311187692,
-0.0298373587,
-0.0340126939,
-0.122504741,
0.0124729397,
0.0114700943,
0.032855764,
0.0188697074,
0.0050570234,
0.007513308,
0.0214121435,
-0.051841639,
-0.038053859,
-0.0126159973,
0.0401424989,
0.0252708234,
0.0353262834,
0.0287410822,
-0.039561186,
0.002688729,
-0.0206006784,
-0.0210515,
0.031645041,
0.0056228489,
-0.0630687326,
0.0560898781,
-0.007171717,
-0.001093866,
0.0063088504,
0.0007106719,
-0.0047444133,
0.0085659092,
0.0174062345,
0.035472326,
-0.0105017088,
0.0676867068,
0.0108917635,
0.016480457,
-0.0234295502,
0.036861755,
-0.0989324674,
0.0152983228,
0.0135847591,
-0.0435032547,
0.0293618497,
0.0767403841,
-0.0095541338,
-0.0120991664,
-0.0616922826,
0.0283760503,
-0.0426890329,
-0.0021307678,
0.0103181479,
0.0321175307,
0.0128663471,
0.0089697018,
-0.018598048,
-0.0160938073,
0.1154479608,
0.0416160412,
0.0186033994,
-0.1033840179,
-0.0216785688,
-0.0387621894,
0.0572834834,
-0.0198707618,
0.0070653986,
0.0654541105,
0.0191491283,
-0.0011490962,
0.031782411,
-0.0190247372,
-0.0265086368,
0.0358771384,
0.001960132,
-0.0252802838,
0.008612874,
-0.076712437,
-0.0141407736,
-0.0349884145,
-0.0057287985,
0.0111026699,
0.0459788926,
-0.0135550043,
-0.0055951318,
-0.0068819243,
-0.0130696017,
-0.0264385492,
-0.020747792,
-0.0356159508,
0.0045526279,
0.01453711,
0.0454259478,
-0.0304443873,
0.0147684431,
-0.0447971001,
0.0242212396,
0.0533254594,
-0.0285419896,
-0.0303730853,
0.0239269659,
-0.0176505186,
0.031121714,
-0.0371942297,
-0.0225012004,
-0.0212845374,
0.1054309905,
-0.0431810878,
-0.0472093225,
0.1157929152,
0.0434620082,
-0.0427414626,
0.014360819,
0.0411504246,
0.0005761177,
0.0165404119,
0.0234821308,
-0.0391649045,
-0.0363474675,
-0.0354602225,
0.0588147342,
-0.0283894241,
-0.025351895,
0.0044747745,
-0.0987141505,
0.0378548615,
-0.0496051125,
-0.0279972963,
-0.0639417246,
-0.0812723786,
0.0237365142,
-0.0335503221,
-0.0016158209,
-0.028825026,
-0.0143508874,
0.0350978822,
0.0197385009,
-0.0065858359,
-0.0461697094,
0.0411056019,
-0.0065026088,
0.0546110682,
0.0441386737,
0.0370144062,
0.0139431646,
-0.0491587706,
-0.0130375028,
-0.0287365597,
-0.0006917655,
-0.0334306844,
0.1141681895,
-0.0343247317,
-0.0064793881,
-0.0425170027,
0.0149175907,
-0.0566415302,
0.0074697947,
0.0088087926,
0.0407151245,
-0.0148660438,
-0.0044799452,
-0.0445976704,
0.0227819607,
0.0425580889,
0.0849205405,
-0.0127067091,
-0.0838235095,
-0.0079619689,
-0.0036608567,
0.0028118871,
-0.0864904895,
-0.0206071641,
-0.0522699952,
-0.0404035524,
0.0017215903,
-0.0662343353,
-0.0651534274,
0.0263459627,
0.0099106887,
-0.0013078061,
-0.0131662684,
0.0148828952,
0.0009648913,
-0.0586311445,
0.0109244632,
0.0145925181,
0.0338490792,
-0.0340115577,
-0.0813402086,
0.0919813663,
0.0008591493,
-0.0150312502,
0.0076165525,
-0.0263095088,
-0.0323495008,
-0.0193276405,
0.053187672,
-0.0014292462,
0.0103903804,
-0.003701349,
0.0185765121,
-0.0132862804,
0.0577425435,
-0.0456659459,
-0.0027176256,
0.04243524,
0.0391856954,
0.0101198368,
0.0186831839,
-0.0048387246,
0.0593058467,
0.0395099036,
0.0159731247,
-0.0083705615,
-0.0217196364,
0.0300014205,
0.0189453997,
0.0771698356,
-0.0021363336,
-0.0337608196,
-0.049553711,
-0.0139593435,
-0.0233322512,
-0.0026172469,
-0.0458436385,
0.0149424812,
-0.0092104133,
-0.0008126496,
-0.0351805128,
0.0725377351,
-0.0548133701,
0.0579612069,
-0.0710641146,
0.072692059,
-0.0027983622,
0.0126204472,
-0.0212338381,
0.0191984102,
-0.0206159055,
-0.0214699376,
0.0237414408,
0.014385391,
0.0078377351,
0.0504692607,
0.0249725394,
0.0489073433,
-0.0079530068,
0.0319422372,
-0.0277416892,
0.0519549809,
-0.0323634222,
-0.0068760915,
-0.0080571985,
-0.0409288071,
0.0375170223,
-0.0302203875,
0.0025190013,
0.0008203067,
0.0361510515,
-0.0133417808,
0.0023753152,
0.0565378815,
0.0337622948,
-0.0057834624,
-0.0382654555,
0.056733124,
-0.0862097368,
0.049775362,
0.0321474709,
-0.0176764037,
-0.0487116501,
-0.0169619005,
0.008537502,
0.0250849631,
-0.017192563,
0.0407911874,
-0.073189348,
-0.032883998,
0.0042530834,
-0.0194625221,
0.0212643575,
-0.0021311101,
0.061361976,
-0.0006528878,
0.0165564697,
0.0014995473,
-0.0689342469,
-0.0148908487,
-0.0153108742,
-0.0464293994,
-0.0003473065,
-6.886563125e-33,
-0.0430406183,
-0.008101481,
-0.0112393806,
0.0390896797,
-0.0082353381,
0.0412779972,
-0.0269545093,
0.0287357457,
0.0119819539,
0.0445115827,
0.0149824284,
0.006419735,
-0.0062212804,
0.0267616957,
-0.0045592696,
0.0022708799,
0.0753826723,
-0.0133619532,
0.0122206202,
0.0622466728,
0.031548012,
0.0100026838,
0.0284920949,
-0.1267594844,
0.0506478138,
0.0150301,
-0.0268046074,
0.0052984687,
0.0171315484,
0.0599480271,
-0.0213567968,
0.0685760006,
0.0414100252,
-0.0310425665,
-0.0007159785,
0.0077922237,
-0.0649529323,
-0.0311378818,
0.0088721607,
-0.0338900611,
-0.0563558526,
-0.0517126732,
-0.02996419,
0.0148838852,
-0.0371693149,
-0.0313260145,
0.0362520292,
-0.0205145068,
0.0243611299,
-0.0706848428,
-0.0599781983,
0.0080191521,
0.0195497796,
-0.0484923124,
0.0262855422,
0.0452379659,
0.0136731816,
-0.0117463581,
-0.0049522752,
0.0149468342,
0.0059406729,
0.0445156433,
-0.0369912833,
-0.0228408407,
-0.015006138,
0.0347115844,
0.020411374,
0.028485205,
-0.0292911883,
0.0653490573,
-0.0217290428,
0.033733543,
0.0202564392,
-0.0056618992,
0.0132548669,
-0.032207828,
-0.054204978,
0.0341819227,
0.0329199806,
-0.0051637031,
0.0490855612,
-0.0184512157,
-0.0570913032,
-0.0149574177,
-0.0013972955,
-0.0136804087,
-0.0207340103,
-0.0084567331,
0.0093893409,
0.026189439,
-0.0230253935,
0.0123634553,
-0.0397129729,
-0.0364572182,
0.0112402206,
-0.0062772166,
-0.0361364409,
0.0128660901,
-0.0022721391,
-0.0347453654,
-0.0881901756,
-0.0104725379,
0.0125557473,
0.0166040063,
0.0189765096,
-0.0024147904,
0.0732906088,
0.0011984184,
-0.0876176283,
-0.0190672074,
-0.021794213,
0.0856072232,
-0.0075671417,
0.0440417044,
-0.005628156,
0.0207553189,
-0.0293044671,
0.105101265,
0.0107856886,
0.0109919272,
-0.0494666733,
0.0053645521,
0.0160037614,
0.0184333585,
-0.0217105057,
-0.0162210166,
0.0230092555,
0.0005549982,
-0.0305578448,
-0.0598570816,
-0.0428332537,
0.0046972879,
3.141e-7,
0.030481888,
0.0664834455,
-0.002211693,
0.0246105604,
0.0127722835,
0.0450856127,
0.0206514411,
0.0110737178,
-0.0057750782,
-0.0158362743,
0.0106494175,
0.0272905827,
0.0231998824,
0.0217669029,
-0.0813897699,
0.0461675674,
0.0253235102,
-0.0069545493,
-0.0144425146,
0.031397704,
0.0982969925,
0.0585131161,
0.0067157345,
0.00239812,
0.0128498459,
0.0810072944,
0.0497933738,
-0.0263601039,
-0.0206974223,
0.031295415,
-0.0326277278,
0.0158572607,
-0.0047424417,
0.0084201088,
-0.0328807347,
-0.0046209241,
-0.0100285364,
0.0727517605,
0.016199762,
-0.0804966912,
0.0291136224,
0.010141178,
0.0338515081,
-0.0070808418,
0.049650453,
-0.0464217812,
-0.0535547584,
-0.0649272054,
-0.0301236585,
0.0492509678,
0.0132129295,
0.0118415011,
-0.0596295893,
0.0283151809,
0.0037257988,
-0.0235854331,
-0.0419934392,
-0.0595069118,
0.0044386862,
0.0577522479,
0.0151134245,
-0.0491879657,
0.0311208237,
0.0254073739,
-0.0171674471,
-0.0859936774,
-0.0118541652,
3.111015594e-34,
0.0570846349,
0.0008375365,
0.0145275556,
0.0255241636,
-0.0137732709,
0.0004129546,
-0.0454754606,
-0.0431418978,
0.0433195531,
-0.0197006594,
-0.0136272423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20701v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20701v1
|
Unveiling the Lexical Sensitivity of LLMs: Combinatorial Optimization for Prompt Enhancement
| 2024-05-31T08:53:59 | 2024-05-31T08:53:59 |
Pengwei Zhan, Zhen Xu, Qian Tan, Jie Song, Ru Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional instruct-following
ability to complete various downstream tasks. Although this impressive ability
makes LLMs flexible task solvers, their performance in solving tasks also
heavily relies on instructions. In this paper, we reveal that LLMs are
over-sensitive to lexical variations in task instructions, even when the
variations are imperceptible to humans. By providing models with neighborhood
instructions, which are closely situated in the latent representation space and
differ by only one semantically similar word, the performance on downstream
tasks can be vastly different. Following this property, we propose a black-box
Combinatorial Optimization framework for Prompt Lexical Enhancement (COPLE).
COPLE performs iterative lexical optimization according to the feedback from a
batch of proxy tasks, using a search strategy related to word influence.
Experiments show that even widely-used human-crafted prompts for current
benchmarks suffer from the lexical sensitivity of models, and COPLE recovers
the declined model ability in both instruct-following and solving downstream
tasks.
|
[
0.0684864745,
0.0367259085,
-0.0214462448,
0.0443133824,
-0.0655454472,
0.0123769594,
0.0042998912,
0.0116874399,
-0.0071209022,
-0.0172371175,
-0.0631515235,
-0.0443646722,
0.003091532,
0.0015330164,
0.0407875627,
-0.0279444382,
0.0622064769,
-0.0614321306,
-0.0282284357,
-0.0311869141,
-0.0358887464,
0.0024344702,
-0.0169477966,
0.0252195783,
0.0162238963,
-0.0154482843,
-0.008991885,
0.0055354633,
-0.0259006619,
-0.0079681044,
0.0110508921,
0.0792159587,
-0.0026478753,
0.021933157,
0.000002097,
-0.0563792139,
0.0168253649,
-0.0423393697,
-0.0505848341,
0.0178265572,
0.0416760929,
-0.0127572492,
-0.0066294535,
0.0256992448,
-0.0117675457,
0.0104496907,
0.0462282822,
0.0302709285,
0.0344784893,
0.0525334477,
0.014490217,
0.0342723094,
0.0012310182,
-0.0315417573,
0.0274818335,
-0.040812403,
0.0098926155,
-0.0352190882,
0.0485843681,
0.0396481007,
-0.0435174406,
0.0564350151,
0.019823771,
-0.0126072327,
0.0209858753,
0.0130587341,
0.0433050096,
-0.0114056943,
-0.046692431,
0.0688032657,
-0.021546565,
-0.0039692968,
-0.0344807506,
-0.0383556485,
0.0199166946,
0.012665242,
-0.0202664882,
0.0130850198,
0.0123458859,
-0.0041325307,
0.0000772781,
-0.0148006054,
0.0316360854,
0.0185091998,
0.0141612077,
0.1130716652,
0.042946972,
-0.0531423986,
0.0174045954,
0.0088097686,
-0.0150319096,
-0.0635707527,
0.0220900867,
0.0089632217,
-0.1150248274,
0.0283634216,
-0.0224855468,
-0.0220545847,
0.0101593072,
0.007353066,
0.0970526487,
0.0656451881,
-0.0127838347,
0.0350872166,
-0.0199676007,
0.0663721934,
-0.0447212383,
0.0339927487,
-0.0654725954,
0.0159061179,
-0.0187790096,
-0.0095366305,
-0.0489621907,
0.0088676196,
-0.0768442377,
-0.0112906685,
-0.0157282148,
0.0508805811,
0.0023878168,
-0.0266137756,
0.0225093104,
0.0185773987,
-0.0138321938,
-0.024606131,
-0.034270376,
-0.0248838402,
-0.057351511,
0.0315053761,
0.0174338929,
-0.0434750542,
-0.0280920453,
-0.0057757865,
0.0110546453,
-0.0687612444,
-0.0027028883,
0.0537413768,
-0.0284409821,
-0.0645543411,
-0.0187937301,
-0.0069065727,
-0.0231331345,
-0.0291773286,
-0.0115767606,
-0.0349035896,
0.0418026485,
-0.0074227103,
-0.0145965517,
-0.0320745595,
-0.0028110615,
0.0125249587,
-0.0462507978,
0.1024025232,
0.0157711208,
0.0117751518,
0.0221781936,
-0.0104495091,
-0.0291553177,
0.0355442651,
0.0073039583,
0.05477098,
0.0254266784,
0.0103196166,
0.0071879309,
0.0525014736,
0.0011225983,
0.0239895973,
-0.0021209079,
-0.0123408912,
0.043536067,
0.0407949947,
0.0510380343,
0.0687243715,
-0.0115523264,
-0.0185326543,
0.0771508962,
0.0364077836,
-0.008874055,
-0.0173593741,
0.0382886343,
0.0052591586,
-0.0283112805,
0.0279026572,
-0.0875214487,
0.008344464,
-0.033988636,
-0.0096736532,
0.0213476252,
0.0082875323,
-0.0306703784,
-0.0174253657,
0.0007117544,
0.0197233167,
0.0035685904,
0.0235508792,
0.0153566971,
0.0248992182,
-0.0674659535,
0.0327809118,
0.0360194296,
-0.0386970155,
-0.0015711867,
-0.0592419617,
0.032820344,
0.0711332113,
0.055467464,
-0.0161818638,
-0.0094590401,
0.0043640351,
-0.0029741011,
0.0648563802,
0.0297993738,
-0.0087621734,
0.0254240613,
-0.0340400301,
-0.0428645648,
-0.0166983549,
0.0059145708,
0.0460947677,
0.0325470418,
-0.0331359431,
0.0209457651,
0.0104320487,
-0.0002786123,
0.0518279858,
-0.0506928228,
-0.0488242358,
0.0121697262,
0.0087042665,
0.0222939868,
-0.0036797212,
0.0093299951,
0.0270041749,
-0.0044443891,
-0.0392962024,
-0.0225940812,
-0.0356684215,
-0.0765863061,
-0.0403144546,
0.0285526589,
0.0265163537,
-0.0021110547,
0.04184708,
-0.0291059017,
-0.0314565822,
-0.0136040198,
-0.0489824638,
0.0380049422,
-0.0336293392,
0.0492751747,
0.0016473404,
0.0040324866,
-0.0519988239,
0.0552345142,
-0.0259493552,
0.0171833336,
0.0633102357,
0.0641015545,
-0.0269637965,
-0.0395314656,
-0.0107332924,
0.002331685,
-0.0004590142,
-0.0104374085,
0.0317567587,
0.0107226297,
-0.0463064723,
-0.0540438928,
-0.0689142197,
0.0020670858,
-0.022691112,
-0.010690989,
0.0160971042,
0.0354660973,
-0.011330937,
-0.017712608,
-0.002574529,
-0.0075654984,
0.0076186773,
0.0575245544,
0.0164734907,
0.0219442323,
-0.0387855172,
-0.0419379734,
-0.035223037,
-0.0044951499,
-0.0097191287,
-0.008899603,
-0.0286454521,
-0.0640124232,
0.0534452312,
-0.0023229446,
0.0224817842,
-0.0082251253,
-0.0104317926,
-0.0124913882,
-0.010816955,
0.0687729046,
0.0861173496,
0.0053859856,
0.003097035,
0.0376503617,
-0.0207545068,
-0.0464327,
0.0192574933,
-0.0253679492,
-0.0635602549,
-0.0127002215,
-0.0422064885,
0.0245910604,
0.076230146,
0.0240085963,
-0.0189835876,
-0.0728174448,
0.0045745084,
-0.0159751717,
-0.0587892197,
-0.0660768226,
-0.0235282518,
-0.0585637167,
0.0361106247,
-0.0407039113,
-0.0604506172,
0.0634717494,
-0.0259129088,
-0.0022205152,
-0.0339927934,
0.0172175616,
-0.0234929062,
0.0360539593,
0.00278973,
0.0058558928,
-0.0022677605,
-0.0508429669,
-0.0784948468,
-0.0072583477,
0.020619791,
-0.0204326175,
0.0185773876,
-0.0373595431,
0.001516853,
0.0014005989,
-0.0620629676,
-0.0596540719,
-0.0542290695,
0.0179562885,
0.0306469034,
0.0620319657,
0.0189144798,
-0.0106690601,
-0.0186105873,
0.0108659575,
0.0556278415,
-0.0293521732,
0.0002063172,
-0.0618951321,
0.006853275,
0.0594759434,
0.0336818956,
0.0395433716,
-0.0301202536,
0.0187106803,
-0.0024688733,
0.0479235463,
-0.0348897576,
0.0114187887,
0.0573522747,
0.0621540435,
-0.0368339717,
-0.0127390372,
0.0446535647,
0.0689325482,
-0.0342941955,
-0.0136635276,
0.116267845,
0.0453724526,
-0.0468425527,
0.0182552859,
-0.0339238644,
0.0156672336,
0.0301155858,
0.033084847,
-0.0410482921,
-0.0198400039,
0.0370282494,
0.018699836,
-0.0255751275,
-0.0285057314,
-0.0169387087,
-0.1387759,
0.0335619152,
-0.0002840255,
-0.008243734,
-0.0012572237,
-0.0274394322,
0.0007140791,
0.0189885292,
0.0667300001,
0.0450934134,
-0.0148608433,
-0.0037916147,
0.0052839434,
0.0376318507,
-0.0240950547,
0.0210905112,
-0.009742273,
0.0473786518,
0.0681874976,
-0.0129942214,
0.0098060528,
-0.0306419004,
0.063958846,
-0.0027248079,
0.0176656786,
-0.0348453633,
0.0139459772,
0.0034550047,
-0.0152463755,
0.002164277,
0.0314474329,
-0.0363797173,
-0.0234724432,
0.0015172771,
0.0596024916,
-0.0122305574,
0.0063169408,
-0.0089625921,
-0.0037818134,
0.0263963994,
0.0863873661,
0.0449777618,
-0.0636446774,
-0.0081480881,
-0.0238154065,
-0.0279149916,
-0.01965403,
-0.0033224889,
0.0059292717,
-0.0076250122,
-0.0042111794,
-0.0571348555,
-0.04461997,
0.0251925755,
0.0296034068,
0.0179733764,
0.0080953008,
-0.0208260324,
-0.0243536215,
0.0055869124,
0.0386075713,
-0.062452469,
0.0394920222,
-0.0967351943,
-0.0251044463,
-0.0048190472,
-0.0366944298,
-0.0192641169,
0.0183099192,
-0.074043192,
-0.0672412664,
-0.0033167533,
0.0485830158,
0.01960974,
0.0322780609,
-0.0300800093,
-0.0774058402,
0.0476485789,
0.0146041876,
-0.0331159867,
0.0465409122,
0.0075834328,
0.0041587898,
-0.0095575582,
0.032352902,
-0.0344884843,
0.0287722517,
0.0701112971,
0.0651006699,
0.0254732538,
-0.0477695577,
0.0283775069,
0.0356266946,
0.0499050058,
-0.0345933512,
0.0198197924,
-0.0503050014,
0.0191659518,
-0.0072312038,
-0.013100314,
-0.0461298302,
0.0044349143,
0.0371311121,
-0.0259833653,
0.0057019573,
-0.0291095469,
-0.0146887731,
0.0386908203,
-0.063520126,
-0.0084025087,
-0.0234431885,
-0.004693985,
0.0436387286,
0.0411087833,
0.0005405045,
0.0673439428,
0.0030002636,
0.0309734922,
0.0084387707,
0.0626748577,
0.0159107726,
-0.0096119549,
-0.0658233538,
0.0381298028,
-0.0682417378,
-0.0375900492,
-0.023309337,
0.0381386988,
0.0347991176,
-0.0277721751,
-0.0026343784,
-0.0158295073,
-0.0103471167,
-0.0263728183,
-0.0191166829,
0.0394243114,
-0.0248791575,
0.0396149568,
0.0326918475,
0.0006566189,
-0.0066387211,
0.061360497,
-0.0112873446,
0.0442281961,
-0.0045170365,
0.0213809479,
-0.0401847176,
-0.0347260796,
0.0285107177,
0.0369929336,
-0.0340522714,
0.0400159433,
-0.0312453955,
-0.0606851205,
0.0072217346,
0.0199973397,
-0.0266548283,
-0.0168053806,
0.0624613687,
0.0430059582,
-0.0229075365,
-0.0520217456,
-0.0259889066,
-0.0073828679,
0.0114315692,
-0.0308367684,
-0.0165749453,
-6.520954994e-33,
-0.0702883452,
-0.0147900721,
0.0104649058,
-0.0043592267,
0.0001008598,
0.0033881876,
-0.0500783324,
0.0258613843,
-0.00347106,
0.007524421,
-0.0510276593,
0.0018179927,
0.0250057653,
0.0175251998,
0.0123180198,
-0.010943152,
0.0676263571,
-0.0026890633,
-0.0458956994,
0.0070704333,
0.0003235042,
0.0273065697,
0.0050468598,
-0.0129498495,
0.0373914391,
0.0133249993,
-0.0058808392,
0.0528124981,
-0.0128800971,
0.0424738377,
-0.033543136,
0.0502724126,
0.0143088186,
-0.0689198673,
-0.0457634777,
0.0512967743,
-0.0503442548,
-0.0385425985,
0.0567598976,
-0.0154365944,
-0.0550110489,
-0.0639161617,
0.0134992292,
-0.013255571,
-0.0579796322,
0.0241824295,
0.0031601465,
-0.0294797421,
-0.0475194044,
0.0264915377,
-0.0534183308,
-0.0114511633,
0.0001642921,
-0.0336044133,
0.0082556298,
0.0111592095,
0.0020964846,
0.015611792,
-0.0200733542,
0.025533611,
0.0139528224,
0.0511747077,
0.0425014235,
0.0509784967,
-0.0082874885,
0.0159400981,
0.0310189631,
0.0078662271,
0.0195452031,
-0.0370023102,
0.0135896793,
0.0220321268,
0.0337823108,
0.0128645943,
0.0032977783,
-0.012822303,
0.0017069036,
0.0035485856,
0.025716655,
0.0193290375,
0.0411504321,
0.0171098597,
-0.026707124,
-0.0389529951,
-0.0617523342,
0.0057083699,
-0.0539535023,
-0.0024522447,
0.0646761954,
0.0179068185,
-0.0174651612,
-0.0397228338,
0.0342986099,
-0.020271413,
0.0010515002,
-0.0045622597,
0.0055406918,
0.0111533189,
0.0020499623,
0.0230316482,
-0.0510811135,
-0.0308283232,
0.006455021,
-0.0151577434,
-0.0120317833,
0.0112942653,
-0.0181271005,
0.0096050939,
-0.0739471614,
0.0099372072,
-0.0436341204,
0.025925504,
0.0201223847,
-0.0036235559,
0.0417597853,
-0.0190684721,
-0.0087975999,
0.0582464151,
0.0163857751,
-0.0414148271,
-0.0266694073,
-0.0158074275,
-0.0111798178,
0.0121242553,
-0.032363724,
0.0018747138,
-0.0160955563,
0.0415698402,
0.0245063435,
-0.0189514365,
-0.019327525,
0.0087669343,
2.813e-7,
0.0320389569,
0.0631730556,
0.0065151756,
0.0431798212,
0.0224691499,
0.0193023868,
-0.0133499634,
0.0168419927,
0.0205065086,
-0.0372496173,
0.0084129255,
0.0396711901,
0.0513444468,
-0.0179814938,
-0.0670915246,
0.0273698177,
-0.0629998818,
0.0446809568,
-0.0468601063,
0.0125385104,
0.0235591233,
0.0762819797,
0.0135081885,
-0.0216247626,
-0.0402788967,
-0.0511134937,
0.0370564498,
-0.0604808554,
-0.0148726022,
0.0223996136,
0.0100428537,
-0.0149037,
0.0230846889,
0.0316216946,
-0.0152748618,
0.0463145263,
0.0137202181,
0.0761611983,
-0.0076582218,
-0.0281204004,
-0.0234740227,
-0.0023752407,
0.0034221697,
-0.0365363285,
0.0848395601,
-0.033181753,
-0.0019018216,
-0.0381618515,
0.0233777463,
-0.0084073506,
0.0215217322,
-0.0345379598,
-0.0222773049,
-0.0007898581,
0.0397167616,
0.0205140654,
-0.0369314589,
-0.0837088376,
-0.0042841304,
0.0048633544,
-0.0611398891,
-0.0585387386,
-0.0565553568,
0.0220311154,
0.0182287749,
-0.0529639199,
-0.0007752498,
2.699646755e-34,
0.0500018522,
0.0053669931,
0.0631962717,
0.0330510326,
0.0360707268,
0.0081433393,
-0.0297605209,
0.0287053902,
0.0395592302,
-0.1149071977,
-0.0280649196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20684v1
|
Joint Embeddings for Graph Instruction Tuning
| 2024-05-31T08:26:47 | 2024-05-31T08:26:47 |
Vlad Argatu, Aaron Haag, Oliver Lohse
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance in text
understanding and have become an essential tool for building smart assistants.
Originally focusing on text, they have been enhanced with multimodal
capabilities in recent works that successfully built visual instruction
following assistants. As far as the graph modality goes, however, no such
assistants have yet been developed. Graph structures are complex in that they
represent relation between different features and are permutation invariant.
Moreover, representing them in purely textual form does not always lead to good
LLM performance even for finetuned models. As a result, there is a need to
develop a new method to integrate graphs in LLMs for general graph
understanding. This work explores the integration of the graph modality in LLM
for general graph instruction following tasks. It aims at producing a deep
learning model that enhances an underlying LLM with graph embeddings and trains
it to understand them and to produce, given an instruction, an answer grounded
in the graph representation. The approach performs significantly better than a
graph to text approach and remains consistent even for larger graphs.
|
[
0.0258475691,
0.0185183808,
-0.0037515901,
0.0502446815,
-0.0178920906,
0.0164824072,
-0.0112477383,
-0.0250949375,
0.068463102,
-0.0521482043,
-0.0030679326,
-0.0098981783,
-0.0193179101,
0.0361103192,
0.0351115391,
-0.0622523315,
0.0228007007,
-0.0183839332,
-0.00159756,
-0.0139750242,
0.0084758094,
0.035682302,
-0.0022236267,
0.0293676239,
-0.0265013482,
-0.0376695432,
-0.0450003855,
0.0189597066,
-0.0089735528,
-0.0463798121,
-0.0635079518,
0.0045236964,
0.0704623908,
0.0311177894,
0.0000019119,
0.0110081527,
0.0086639272,
-0.0039337534,
-0.0251792502,
-0.0033562218,
0.0317234471,
-0.0364974253,
0.030791685,
-0.0147270728,
-0.0446111746,
-0.0297580231,
0.0619647168,
0.003809066,
0.0793200657,
0.06851127,
-0.0150123779,
-0.0255154911,
0.0096059376,
-0.0014475865,
0.0002946464,
-0.05840813,
0.012722644,
0.0307078827,
0.0349882692,
0.013205912,
-0.1023928076,
0.0128192557,
0.0257380549,
-0.026720671,
0.0393558368,
0.0121977469,
0.0190422609,
-0.0009357908,
-0.0153831299,
0.1463285387,
-0.0311374888,
0.0059343372,
-0.0201619044,
-0.0142414672,
0.0119590405,
0.0349100642,
-0.0620156042,
-0.0268339962,
0.0119810328,
0.0079112863,
-0.0359839834,
-0.0648654029,
0.0506582148,
-0.0201312993,
-0.0330491811,
0.0422926992,
-0.0103410799,
0.0020590872,
0.0120272674,
0.0032480119,
-0.0436386205,
-0.0239991192,
0.0090719489,
0.0741823092,
-0.0180409979,
0.0153746791,
-0.0370658822,
-0.0094178831,
-0.0319449343,
0.0078697782,
0.0735493004,
0.002832229,
-0.0228527077,
0.0494029857,
-0.0163264219,
0.0649639219,
-0.0397050269,
0.061903663,
-0.0680340677,
0.0044575883,
-0.0575942583,
-0.0091052605,
-0.0528786145,
0.0202103686,
-0.0064441878,
-0.0771760121,
-0.0171406362,
0.0616239607,
-0.017866496,
0.0266363919,
0.0226384103,
0.0323824547,
-0.0085673397,
-0.0285817925,
0.0102054747,
0.0560873076,
-0.0230082218,
0.0080012865,
-0.044598233,
-0.0021795589,
0.0051920908,
0.0233370736,
0.0517552271,
-0.00784266,
0.0092151621,
0.0876754522,
0.023690477,
-0.0238888506,
-0.0025954403,
-0.0160321556,
-0.0080767507,
-0.0443120822,
0.0576127656,
-0.056081675,
0.0404245853,
-0.0028900714,
0.0084773628,
-0.0197812468,
0.0207391903,
-0.0057004001,
-0.0568089411,
0.0715681687,
-0.0023192661,
0.0209985543,
0.0073914099,
-0.0292502996,
-0.0074899984,
0.0380260348,
0.0560262129,
0.0201928485,
0.0309851002,
-0.0195661038,
-0.0376254879,
0.0333641991,
0.0175605677,
0.0132949408,
0.0037727803,
-0.0150168454,
-0.0501676127,
0.0259810593,
0.0003359043,
0.0504068397,
-0.0391997248,
-0.0378672555,
0.0367973968,
0.0296388213,
0.0402443446,
-0.0253670067,
0.0706488937,
0.0359394401,
-0.0197059233,
0.0489583574,
-0.0712066442,
0.0323401578,
0.0351075716,
0.0213691425,
-0.0183400884,
-0.0292730741,
-0.0171343144,
-0.0121127628,
0.0153791439,
-0.0249870382,
0.0813996345,
0.0081641832,
0.0605496317,
0.0134707959,
-0.0454557016,
-0.0204396863,
0.020054251,
0.0036149197,
0.0178601518,
0.0001942912,
-0.0173869766,
0.0938298777,
0.0284709558,
-0.0020175744,
-0.0395225026,
0.0088299168,
0.008593766,
-0.0051928009,
0.0424438752,
-0.0355846621,
-0.0019019552,
-0.0664779767,
-0.0561171174,
-0.0519305319,
-0.0149466405,
0.0415402129,
-0.0178371258,
-0.0237792917,
0.0036555445,
-0.0603528842,
-0.0230387431,
0.0130158216,
0.0223670192,
-0.0125390403,
-0.0169953052,
0.0407855622,
-0.0242005195,
0.0480875522,
0.0206306782,
0.0214309674,
0.0163397025,
-0.020092519,
0.0211613253,
-0.0011173642,
-0.0368113294,
-0.0507785454,
0.0329064354,
-0.0397879779,
-0.0378496237,
0.0085834274,
-0.0589607172,
-0.0370433889,
0.038280163,
-0.0800348148,
0.0193364732,
0.0075932532,
-0.0236644559,
0.0132176839,
-0.018877754,
-0.0091751004,
0.0391759314,
0.0043058465,
-0.0017158325,
0.0209336262,
0.041394677,
0.0008445214,
-0.0487283096,
-0.0079683838,
0.0265259221,
0.033202704,
0.0061261673,
0.0003652849,
0.0165394321,
-0.0424077585,
0.0143497204,
-0.1005240083,
-0.0101308152,
-0.0146465925,
-0.0004939517,
0.0041273502,
-0.0051160026,
0.0181875955,
-0.0569075495,
-0.0424438082,
0.0536408797,
0.0042972439,
0.0320742019,
0.0260531362,
0.0034605972,
-0.0196610559,
-0.0183815602,
-0.0341865346,
-0.0433335714,
0.0688689277,
0.0317009389,
-0.0160948224,
-0.0319113918,
0.0047802087,
-0.0293526594,
0.0320843682,
0.0033461649,
-0.0088263089,
0.0301543772,
-0.0131043131,
0.0419582799,
0.0968687013,
-0.0322209969,
0.0675083101,
0.0415547527,
-0.0164378192,
-0.0314381234,
0.0051187766,
-0.0406924412,
0.0003446046,
-0.0454433076,
-0.0182147231,
-0.0557101853,
0.0141223613,
-0.0001896142,
-0.0039537558,
-0.0676444471,
-0.013613713,
-0.0096991155,
0.0094375135,
-0.0220810529,
-0.0195753407,
0.0237323083,
-0.0314089321,
-0.0455738269,
-0.0362621024,
0.0908406153,
-0.0031151648,
-0.0170952082,
0.0100902002,
-0.0293386709,
-0.0691527799,
0.0709216073,
0.0729975253,
0.0400684103,
-0.0544675291,
-0.0298384931,
-0.0714480802,
0.0279871449,
0.0429637618,
-0.0260931868,
0.0129716098,
-0.0130908601,
0.0061414358,
0.0026169829,
0.0085749729,
-0.0113708451,
0.020049423,
-0.0403615125,
0.038318269,
0.0194110349,
-0.0372046567,
-0.0160556883,
0.0021277072,
0.0007805581,
-0.0195820276,
-0.0224986523,
0.0211671516,
-0.058774475,
0.0256144553,
0.0600942224,
-0.0025388193,
-0.034106236,
-0.0554073155,
0.027938148,
0.0274978857,
-0.0025148469,
-0.0281297769,
-0.0525979251,
0.0287890341,
-0.0157350525,
0.0024567945,
-0.0317541696,
-0.0095626935,
0.0429338701,
-0.052051831,
0.0131560247,
0.0630566254,
0.0123176314,
-0.0513523333,
0.0068300692,
0.0153756458,
-0.0095823398,
0.0267612413,
0.0201918129,
-0.1112687513,
-0.0298637338,
-0.0190781076,
-0.0040347972,
0.0603615306,
-0.0284361485,
-0.0292379931,
-0.0826955661,
0.0123642758,
0.0402805284,
0.0012235472,
-0.0627269223,
-0.0334090739,
-0.0036403805,
0.0206430908,
0.0086518368,
-0.0325946435,
-0.0148982555,
-0.0130285146,
0.004877103,
-0.0115605956,
-0.0023713077,
-0.003936003,
-0.0234342888,
-0.007266847,
0.0010078417,
0.0384290032,
0.0417263098,
-0.0125454376,
0.0116998237,
0.0396896973,
-0.006455096,
-0.0169724338,
0.0388966613,
-0.0255536139,
-0.0144548723,
-0.0204987973,
0.0260804184,
-0.0305683054,
-0.0092771975,
-0.0543295555,
0.1023229733,
-0.0226716921,
-0.0330424085,
-0.0246338304,
0.0050117713,
-0.0127411895,
0.0024272026,
0.056412898,
-0.0156084541,
-0.0461155735,
-0.0665592998,
0.0307655539,
-0.0518621691,
-0.0287582856,
0.0452495776,
-0.0478316247,
0.0511040278,
-0.0212592054,
-0.0453254059,
0.063999474,
0.0066462783,
0.0076142382,
-0.0131965885,
0.0591605306,
-0.0397654139,
-0.0613460802,
0.0277521685,
-0.0355947725,
0.0483766571,
-0.0174516551,
-0.0360212997,
0.0167314801,
0.0131891891,
0.0006304839,
-0.0011579302,
-0.0422111973,
-0.0704278871,
-0.0436087959,
0.0041193073,
0.0040158629,
0.0541477278,
0.0021648833,
-0.0279911067,
0.022449147,
0.003075321,
0.001832615,
-0.0210720543,
0.0209690277,
-0.0164184961,
-0.0216292627,
0.0235374365,
-0.06136778,
0.0101893535,
-0.0039497674,
0.0384064876,
-0.0421958975,
-0.0591049977,
0.0185987111,
0.0395559929,
-0.0124430861,
0.0422272123,
0.0193165168,
-0.0516360216,
0.0001983795,
-0.0097841946,
-0.027284544,
-0.0360809863,
-0.0235466361,
0.0362503119,
-0.0210429095,
0.0252781473,
-0.038958203,
0.0258680396,
0.0396810807,
-0.0305313729,
0.0306650158,
0.0065210136,
-0.0058249091,
0.0300511774,
0.0354132578,
-0.0045871614,
0.0303608123,
-0.0051169042,
0.0193040837,
0.0089045372,
0.035625197,
0.0210228674,
-0.0317544602,
-0.0688347742,
0.0147622405,
-0.0476830415,
-0.0427917726,
-0.0005736004,
0.0247836746,
0.06360396,
0.0064313896,
0.0231138747,
-0.0091055343,
-0.0043396056,
-0.0081845503,
0.0630021617,
0.0030882356,
-0.0612713583,
0.0733173266,
0.0376402028,
0.0346608087,
0.0084827095,
0.0457126163,
0.066561304,
0.0430024788,
0.0024532087,
-0.0156471692,
-0.0376912579,
-0.0325878188,
0.0312989466,
0.0535491593,
-0.0156775583,
0.0386560708,
-0.0116530834,
-0.0953886583,
0.0001929016,
0.0073868507,
-0.0208072569,
0.0069494299,
0.0337741747,
0.0030483943,
0.0252610408,
-0.0276166778,
-0.0366671979,
0.0744003579,
-0.011252162,
-0.02012242,
0.0080003403,
-5.697678424e-33,
-0.0256844144,
-0.0982669666,
0.035670463,
0.0189889856,
-0.0470839068,
0.0115356389,
-0.025477672,
-0.005217148,
-0.0305222441,
0.0342081375,
0.0200378709,
0.0065279771,
-0.0063387961,
0.0272230338,
-0.0453269668,
-0.0054130969,
0.0185179338,
-0.0092587778,
0.0238780994,
0.0381288603,
0.0328989774,
0.0295457933,
0.0325242803,
-0.0634799153,
0.0201123413,
-0.016445633,
0.0265611354,
0.0286878888,
0.0110765286,
0.0540212728,
-0.0272294488,
0.0414798483,
0.0341954939,
0.0462726094,
-0.0195737761,
0.0571440198,
-0.0610316768,
-0.0432868451,
0.0157050434,
0.0472872443,
-0.0863949284,
-0.030445125,
0.0324236825,
-0.0006770553,
0.0447141826,
-0.0486488417,
0.0518137477,
0.0006005274,
-0.0411975309,
0.0514061302,
-0.0460376553,
0.0149016287,
-0.0297082756,
-0.0337578766,
0.0408771224,
0.0074647283,
0.0314110294,
-0.0004825057,
-0.0390100814,
0.0471193679,
-0.0429032445,
-0.0061521945,
0.0392555892,
0.0185587537,
0.0185062904,
0.026716074,
-0.0125853224,
-0.0213749018,
-0.026226202,
0.0064315326,
0.022033317,
0.0989974365,
0.0031204645,
-0.0072886939,
-0.0322225429,
0.018293228,
-0.0740439072,
-0.0196211357,
-0.0053740609,
0.0610854961,
-0.0116379922,
0.0340428166,
-0.0262545086,
-0.0310356263,
-0.0385813229,
-0.0167350266,
-0.0291045327,
-0.027211355,
0.0088243028,
-0.0002211908,
-0.0304462779,
0.0205164105,
0.0223025139,
-0.0723895356,
-0.0268059801,
0.0536574759,
-0.0171884019,
0.0675156787,
-0.0175058562,
0.0466650575,
-0.0271004215,
-0.0526512004,
0.0315215476,
-0.0401614979,
0.0167285558,
0.0182272214,
0.0490360186,
0.0170816183,
-0.0189905763,
-0.0184624735,
-0.0405621789,
-0.0572574548,
-0.0304609891,
-0.0098038418,
0.0571676642,
0.0459678099,
-0.0335682482,
0.1005435139,
0.0157458559,
0.0318386629,
-0.0207107235,
-0.011545008,
0.0033113537,
0.0386118926,
-0.0420218594,
-0.0192236174,
-0.0413799956,
0.0008164964,
0.0142312869,
-0.0793702304,
-0.019400809,
2.23e-7,
2.502e-7,
0.0468581989,
0.0442995206,
0.0570262596,
0.0525005348,
0.0105703101,
0.0209496412,
-0.010366614,
0.0265288055,
-0.001863246,
-0.0138393929,
0.0436447263,
0.0855218247,
-0.0286953729,
0.0154325981,
-0.0142034972,
0.0530000515,
-0.0492532589,
-0.0016091205,
-0.0461636782,
0.0248763468,
0.0389637426,
0.0509686694,
0.002417427,
0.0109876264,
-0.0198759474,
-0.0611927733,
0.0713826641,
0.003415629,
-0.0114106433,
-0.013726403,
-0.0013739504,
0.0132988431,
-0.0236791298,
0.026587287,
0.0037414595,
0.019673273,
0.0310176574,
0.042083431,
-0.0313562192,
-0.0052369353,
-0.0076864352,
-0.0313305743,
-0.0051822611,
0.0105601186,
0.0559506267,
-0.0617008433,
-0.0448538475,
-0.0307850633,
-0.0329846777,
-0.013401337,
0.0161382779,
-0.0125378724,
-0.0112484358,
0.0157440938,
0.039779909,
-0.0398624055,
0.0196314044,
-0.0552781262,
0.0149047477,
0.0027465988,
-0.0308607295,
-0.0178812351,
-0.027294822,
0.0013792191,
0.0408984162,
0.0240356531,
0.0032286767,
2.042768573e-34,
0.0271335058,
0.0003322434,
0.0227707326,
-0.001305675,
0.0235420316,
-0.0377966464,
-0.0295679104,
0.0309561789,
0.0582268946,
-0.1314543784,
-0.0305201784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20680v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20680v3
|
Unraveling and Mitigating Retriever Inconsistencies in Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T08:22:49 | 2024-06-04T11:51:53 |
Mingda Li, Xinyu Li, Yifan Chen, Wenfeng Xuan, Weinan Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Although Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models (RALMs) demonstrate their
superiority in terms of factuality, they do not consistently outperform the
original retrieval-free Language Models (LMs). Our experiments reveal that this
example-level performance inconsistency exists not only between
retrieval-augmented and retrieval-free LM but also among different retrievers.
To understand this phenomenon, we investigate the degeneration behavior of
RALMs and theoretically decompose it into four categories. Further analysis
based on our decomposition reveals that the innate difference in knowledge
sources and the unpredictable degeneration of the reader model contribute most
to the inconsistency. Drawing from our analysis, we introduce Ensemble of
Retrievers (EoR), a trainable framework that can adaptively retrieve from
different knowledge sources and effectively decrease unpredictable reader
errors. Our experiments on Open Domain Question Answering show that EoR
substantially improves performance over the RALM with a single retriever by
considerably reducing inconsistent behaviors.
|
[
0.0670422986,
0.0547886156,
-0.000180043,
0.0478961468,
-0.0147469006,
0.0057206545,
-0.0098285861,
-0.0056519308,
-0.0010512918,
-0.0474743806,
-0.0139769251,
-0.0183136724,
-0.0239271745,
-0.0025748762,
-0.0120553263,
-0.0065936912,
0.0811067149,
-0.0301634427,
0.0159639008,
-0.0355522335,
-0.0004920975,
-0.0071120332,
0.0103172865,
-0.0040679746,
0.036272984,
-0.0232124403,
0.0004113712,
-0.0030259909,
-0.0087892618,
0.0067982329,
0.0449600406,
0.021521017,
0.0191089083,
0.0579726733,
0.0000018284,
-0.0464888513,
-0.0143667283,
0.0065307068,
-0.0529886,
0.0214169361,
-0.0323013961,
0.0171233471,
0.0334818661,
0.0112465154,
-0.0213073492,
-0.0412558429,
-0.0059808362,
0.0709146708,
0.0546994507,
0.0803618953,
0.0374795422,
-0.0147759579,
0.0131297074,
-0.0266279392,
0.0297324136,
-0.0417188816,
0.0262847636,
0.0274180174,
-0.0013280704,
0.0478242747,
-0.025256658,
0.0295872018,
0.0222717375,
0.0213836432,
0.0291981027,
0.0420509465,
-0.0368063375,
-0.0020580064,
-0.0083177797,
0.0607036687,
0.0301503204,
-0.0151884947,
-0.0200411845,
0.0264696088,
0.0199653991,
0.0407901257,
-0.0255079214,
0.0326933563,
-0.0377143659,
-0.0032346318,
-0.0177951977,
0.0024183556,
0.0456974842,
0.0454381108,
-0.0439987406,
0.0556844994,
0.0167138614,
-0.0765404552,
-0.0167333931,
0.0316559225,
-0.0216108337,
-0.0133805517,
-0.0020737003,
0.0303595662,
-0.0323504731,
0.047589805,
0.0051987641,
-0.0334681273,
0.0394011512,
0.0027756053,
0.0499409363,
0.0010492877,
-0.0424779467,
0.0715418682,
-0.0368603654,
0.0593431331,
-0.0298190378,
-0.0014427871,
-0.0344027169,
-0.0225971714,
-0.0320082307,
-0.0382502079,
-0.0141866961,
0.0725815296,
-0.0576559678,
-0.0191235039,
-0.0145293009,
0.0225579869,
-0.0012720705,
-0.0188503228,
-0.0036995113,
0.043520052,
-0.0459037088,
-0.0077739693,
-0.0638742894,
0.045802895,
-0.0199422818,
0.0230162106,
0.0137905339,
-0.0888124183,
-0.0358658917,
-0.032333672,
-0.0116981165,
-0.0378142148,
-0.009053275,
0.0008594674,
-0.032030955,
-0.0307001788,
-0.027816806,
-0.0167268254,
-0.0203076564,
-0.0630352646,
-0.0078426348,
-0.0662872791,
0.0668302327,
0.0143862348,
-0.0079267193,
-0.044373434,
0.0016657234,
0.0345563628,
-0.0408196896,
0.0585681237,
-0.002257495,
0.0037243483,
0.0383969508,
0.0096613085,
-0.011168858,
0.0449084863,
-0.0182756726,
-0.01259878,
0.0451479554,
0.0288492516,
0.0058229496,
-0.0247428566,
0.029969234,
0.0172101539,
0.0189006105,
0.0509498939,
0.0264839493,
0.0157679357,
0.0270216297,
0.0698650479,
-0.0388973504,
-0.05251351,
0.0547145642,
0.0134842629,
0.0206055697,
0.0160262845,
0.0157097727,
-0.0045646429,
0.0362003781,
0.0173992645,
-0.0467494391,
0.0006539511,
-0.0585435107,
0.0409232937,
0.0176516008,
0.0465492271,
-0.0278442428,
-0.0447427817,
-0.0124246627,
0.0153219607,
-0.0453454703,
0.0456220247,
0.0656978637,
0.0132239442,
-0.0282589681,
0.0312744044,
0.0261027478,
-0.0482181534,
0.0228738468,
-0.0433039069,
0.0725147575,
0.0475893803,
0.0721102059,
-0.0253257751,
-0.0130830538,
0.0083423434,
-0.0068121478,
0.0203190297,
0.0298180189,
-0.0086485622,
0.0172188245,
-0.0393775553,
-0.022223264,
-0.009233796,
0.0068185786,
0.0117236245,
0.0450332612,
0.0028703313,
0.0110090394,
-0.0321567878,
-0.0155019881,
0.0351374261,
-0.0453558192,
-0.0459138639,
-0.02621218,
-0.0251129735,
0.0169275403,
-0.0034163855,
-0.040571522,
0.0133710755,
0.0478557087,
-0.0013591414,
-0.0576572865,
-0.0081022251,
-0.0629368871,
-0.043541342,
0.0357344449,
0.0528921112,
-0.0138170971,
0.0186984558,
-0.0290321652,
-0.0289041735,
0.0065167407,
-0.0371090434,
0.0424589515,
-0.0568917021,
-0.0043049995,
0.021801075,
0.0042652264,
-0.0551772155,
0.0834209248,
-0.0213193484,
0.0230290312,
-0.0141173601,
0.0272356793,
-0.022501342,
-0.0655510351,
-0.0374322496,
-0.0020395136,
0.0116266394,
0.0433277003,
0.0325976387,
-0.0574874021,
-0.0460695066,
-0.0276719704,
-0.0561746992,
0.0040164646,
-0.018207714,
-0.0160269383,
0.0023385037,
0.000253613,
0.0091609051,
-0.0371287502,
0.0077629052,
-0.026068408,
0.0274445321,
0.0564861186,
0.013881769,
0.0354056098,
0.0004411449,
-0.0222943518,
-0.027009571,
-0.0028140494,
0.0567780435,
-0.0269011464,
0.0327732861,
-0.0796801895,
-0.003118102,
-0.045685567,
0.0371539071,
-0.023905348,
0.0072851274,
-0.0143958526,
-0.0359928273,
0.0044187759,
0.1077115759,
0.0075932425,
0.0492837988,
0.0512048639,
-0.0009340076,
-0.1003879979,
0.0131639196,
-0.0195091832,
-0.075716652,
-0.0104729477,
-0.0074527725,
0.0027931519,
0.0248277839,
0.0039644344,
-0.0189643726,
-0.0236230809,
0.0337223671,
-0.0399258658,
-0.043143142,
-0.0609735772,
-0.0154623147,
-0.0203034617,
0.0132864751,
-0.0565206744,
-0.0286517441,
0.0847953856,
-0.0061064772,
-0.0115047069,
-0.0717131793,
0.01091481,
-0.0442229547,
0.0126207126,
-0.0206774473,
0.0172542837,
0.0172788892,
-0.0212964918,
-0.0381013155,
-0.0319434404,
0.0153258117,
-0.0624046549,
0.0962308422,
-0.0136134103,
0.0197506975,
0.0068717743,
-0.0689952299,
-0.070014663,
-0.0474271812,
0.007414117,
0.0176643841,
-0.0371341668,
-0.0176112764,
-0.0695271417,
-0.0393969901,
0.0760438889,
-0.0092674829,
-0.0399869829,
-0.0326637551,
-0.0136807226,
0.0673518702,
0.060281463,
0.018931495,
0.0222858172,
-0.0352310948,
0.008035359,
0.068529278,
0.0159092546,
-0.0307789892,
-0.0242829565,
-0.0049717883,
0.025425341,
-0.0495947339,
0.0068559893,
0.0031540093,
0.0236659925,
-0.0432916544,
-0.0239291452,
0.085482277,
0.0231925715,
-0.0206308272,
-0.0397037826,
-0.0323697552,
0.0204210002,
0.0291488599,
0.0357291661,
-0.0444192365,
-0.0246794242,
-0.0120190326,
0.070048131,
0.0092505189,
-0.0280426033,
0.0243156925,
-0.1512454301,
-0.004323482,
0.0005227558,
-0.0424764566,
-0.0464770906,
-0.0339235142,
0.0065403995,
-0.0105499988,
0.059052147,
0.0781318843,
-0.0254697073,
0.0123405848,
0.0317705236,
0.0322354473,
-0.035398107,
0.006154377,
-0.0552354343,
0.023486428,
0.0733314976,
-0.0135695562,
-0.0052171582,
-0.0146366498,
-0.0428938232,
-0.035691224,
0.0189932454,
0.0023430004,
0.0460868254,
-0.018231174,
-0.0003848965,
-0.0573394373,
-0.0084466506,
-0.0004463682,
-0.0065363087,
-0.0117771244,
0.0688878,
0.0049136011,
-0.0305338595,
-0.0315914862,
-0.0459655933,
0.0016091798,
0.0985852182,
-0.0058719553,
-0.0087867342,
-0.0409121364,
-0.004082629,
-0.0118048498,
-0.0249359664,
-0.0111735594,
0.0626858473,
0.0006637212,
0.0200995691,
-0.0578218438,
-0.0705587789,
-0.0219495408,
0.0135808587,
-0.0033521305,
0.0487389341,
-0.0011136254,
0.0119617768,
-0.0374925546,
0.0425243787,
-0.0409171805,
-0.0267668348,
-0.0336112343,
-0.0046952008,
0.0543645509,
-0.009541505,
-0.0132963387,
-0.0213795546,
-0.0146382703,
-0.0514904447,
0.027494628,
0.0403567553,
0.0173407532,
0.0303851888,
0.0060092453,
-0.0469773039,
0.0491897874,
0.0315936133,
-0.0074442495,
0.0691504776,
0.0107990904,
-0.0234099422,
-0.0059122392,
0.0322053358,
-0.0752861872,
-0.0099983746,
0.0115715349,
0.0515018702,
-0.0130835427,
-0.0049744132,
0.0320622511,
0.0270961691,
0.0295601003,
0.0209077764,
-0.0105887074,
-0.011721828,
0.0262364559,
0.0035276264,
-0.0339153707,
-0.0126807084,
0.0108901113,
0.0374814384,
-0.0321243182,
0.0078581125,
0.0371072367,
0.0386800803,
0.0702495053,
-0.0522710718,
-0.0246639848,
0.0403007083,
-0.0191166438,
0.0495807007,
0.0123957703,
-0.0449497104,
0.0321464166,
-0.0124272341,
0.0598744005,
0.0146134319,
0.0373284929,
0.0434887335,
-0.0201401561,
-0.0298955142,
-0.0245586503,
-0.0830509514,
-0.0322524309,
0.0051347525,
-0.0004318391,
0.0276652146,
-0.0070876977,
0.0436660126,
-0.0053918846,
-0.0148863383,
-0.0493747219,
-0.0507572368,
0.0183861442,
-0.0071788174,
0.0410188064,
0.0251568053,
-0.0076127537,
0.0332744606,
0.0921882987,
-0.0227707308,
0.0610568561,
-0.0370279849,
-0.0078581329,
-0.0087848259,
-0.0332614072,
0.0086356774,
-0.0246800855,
-0.0387703218,
0.0019920005,
-0.0391355418,
-0.0563992448,
0.039232675,
0.0185954347,
0.0144791538,
-0.0208653603,
0.0052797189,
0.0908639133,
0.0288989432,
-0.0390296504,
-0.0388444029,
0.0552692413,
-0.0611718819,
-0.0116052302,
-0.0331470072,
-6.489585458e-33,
-0.0222415384,
0.002668441,
0.0027656194,
-0.0813907906,
0.0019432107,
-0.0045252535,
-0.0029573233,
0.0026545462,
-0.0536054336,
0.0068827234,
-0.0307981502,
0.0280401874,
0.008627573,
0.0251524542,
0.0158791579,
-0.0097400779,
0.0448668487,
0.0031123131,
-0.030127354,
-0.0136195794,
0.088631928,
0.0362002179,
0.0130830575,
-0.051745072,
0.0309566148,
-0.0503206104,
0.0320389308,
0.0530280285,
-0.0387801193,
0.0810068846,
-0.0005562452,
0.0553827807,
0.0287432149,
-0.0140719097,
-0.0169889126,
0.0171091631,
-0.1023416445,
-0.0164988283,
0.029443454,
0.0123286964,
-0.0082664248,
-0.0213074833,
0.0300172288,
-0.0088723907,
0.0125432033,
-0.0307640769,
0.0175752528,
-0.0101306858,
-0.0316083916,
0.004168889,
-0.0166085735,
0.0073227934,
0.0352746397,
0.0072009289,
-0.0374046192,
0.0103321988,
0.0190345608,
0.0219878405,
-0.0479607284,
-0.0434930138,
-0.0071481327,
0.0535513051,
0.0359404311,
0.047313951,
-0.0074214311,
0.0507803597,
0.0216620415,
-0.000588115,
-0.0491842292,
-0.0737200677,
-0.0054337583,
0.0048932564,
0.0230316035,
0.0477523655,
0.0261711143,
0.0269684773,
-0.0581876785,
-0.0036508772,
0.0071912934,
0.061638657,
0.0379715674,
0.0294231493,
-0.0348173529,
-0.0029211782,
-0.0504656509,
0.0553278551,
-0.0471159965,
-0.0191715844,
0.0586030409,
0.0386195928,
-0.0054727965,
-0.0158158243,
0.0404618196,
-0.0455222689,
-0.0127206845,
0.0659179091,
-0.0057492508,
-0.0126857115,
-0.0191789865,
0.0181571096,
-0.0471684188,
-0.0011180496,
-0.0078210849,
0.0097919637,
-0.0479688793,
0.0417691618,
0.021820344,
-0.0215248968,
-0.0362008363,
0.0010783897,
-0.0113166431,
0.0218341351,
-0.0047878539,
-0.006182984,
0.0525535308,
0.051906731,
-0.0143713802,
0.0320218392,
0.0216184575,
0.021213172,
-0.0549800806,
-0.0105075967,
0.0102124074,
-0.0098187607,
0.0000878095,
0.014069262,
-0.0346190184,
0.0483573638,
-0.0148932217,
-0.0094174519,
0.0201261714,
0.0565579012,
2.537e-7,
0.0251070447,
0.0091018546,
0.0339515805,
0.0259503648,
0.0005517279,
0.0311533418,
-0.0157575235,
0.0093684159,
0.034730345,
-0.0232985243,
-0.0482543334,
0.0575375147,
0.0504086576,
0.016777683,
-0.0740974993,
-0.0348027274,
-0.0746804774,
0.0035063922,
-0.0342059694,
-0.0304288045,
0.0234947335,
0.0791267976,
0.0123539688,
-0.0078000035,
-0.0017717279,
-0.0598061271,
0.0833949447,
0.0370474607,
-0.0086655617,
0.0016174394,
0.0604693741,
0.00389495,
0.0299399886,
0.0070838057,
0.0128583116,
0.0127625633,
-0.0083345417,
0.0340050235,
-0.0169976968,
-0.0417540371,
-0.0405646116,
-0.0164944809,
0.0016409635,
-0.0366590284,
0.05694177,
-0.0227570422,
-0.0011026309,
-0.0080321897,
-0.0342089646,
0.0024716917,
0.0085651828,
-0.0014411689,
-0.0089761112,
0.0070250644,
-0.0143251112,
0.0128029548,
-0.0045027914,
-0.0966844335,
-0.0003268195,
0.0123977764,
-0.0468875989,
-0.0683058053,
-0.0214100964,
0.0068577565,
-0.0021114708,
-0.0498273969,
0.0105837639,
2.068244658e-34,
0.0202597976,
0.0266490038,
0.0448751338,
0.0363274887,
0.0294263437,
-0.0094878841,
-0.0142651871,
0.0131105203,
0.0161892101,
-0.0979742482,
0.001277859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20671v1
|
Position Coupling: Leveraging Task Structure for Improved Length Generalization of Transformers
| 2024-05-31T08:13:35 | 2024-05-31T08:13:35 |
Hanseul Cho, Jaeyoung Cha, Pranjal Awasthi, Srinadh Bhojanapalli, Anupam Gupta, Chulhee Yun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Even for simple arithmetic tasks like integer addition, it is challenging for
Transformers to generalize to longer sequences than those encountered during
training. To tackle this problem, we propose position coupling, a simple yet
effective method that directly embeds the structure of the tasks into the
positional encoding of a (decoder-only) Transformer. Taking a departure from
the vanilla absolute position mechanism assigning unique position IDs to each
of the tokens, we assign the same position IDs to two or more "relevant"
tokens; for integer addition tasks, we regard digits of the same significance
as in the same position. On the empirical side, we show that with the proposed
position coupling, a small (1-layer) Transformer trained on 1 to 30-digit
additions can generalize up to 200-digit additions (6.67x of the trained
length). On the theoretical side, we prove that a 1-layer Transformer with
coupled positions can solve the addition task involving exponentially many
digits, whereas any 1-layer Transformer without positional information cannot
entirely solve it. We also demonstrate that position coupling can be applied to
other algorithmic tasks such as addition with multiple summands, Nx2
multiplication, copy/reverse, and a two-dimensional task.
|
[
-0.0163162723,
0.0958409533,
0.0137617541,
-0.0050224271,
0.0160746388,
0.004463959,
0.0111176809,
-0.0263086427,
-0.1054352671,
-0.0080973832,
-0.0173926149,
-0.0144421691,
0.0360409282,
-0.0115002207,
0.044555176,
-0.0647227168,
-0.0069398321,
0.0220003724,
-0.0609497055,
0.0001820101,
-0.0290103387,
-0.0255953781,
-0.0423143059,
0.0209490117,
0.0042331559,
0.0091689089,
-0.0533686504,
-0.0669936091,
0.0527682826,
-0.0058252783,
-0.0125877419,
-0.0149435941,
0.0273543932,
0.0643428564,
0.0000020576,
-0.0294237342,
-0.0016227042,
0.0156793557,
-0.0469390303,
-0.0196975265,
-0.0335611477,
-0.0513136722,
-0.0358977653,
0.010578189,
-0.0392597876,
-0.0126582989,
0.066231437,
0.0415130667,
0.0800486729,
0.0729421079,
-0.0120512722,
-0.0341078192,
0.0344683453,
-0.0457880385,
0.0447025374,
-0.0037359097,
-0.0168897118,
-0.0124791777,
0.0031563675,
0.0101072686,
-0.0309097562,
-0.0018487253,
0.0705869421,
-0.0031007584,
0.0064750453,
0.0085513601,
-0.0251248628,
-0.0085148774,
-0.0214489233,
0.0352029242,
-0.08532276,
-0.0064447741,
0.005102308,
0.0036830595,
0.0131645175,
-0.0510497019,
-0.0744881555,
0.0163051933,
0.0113152498,
-0.0164283831,
-0.0544021614,
0.0112835169,
0.0150066689,
-0.0345366038,
-0.0210293196,
0.042203255,
0.0087917233,
0.0037835115,
-0.0772043169,
-0.0064384476,
-0.0188631434,
-0.0128499148,
0.004556139,
0.0611918196,
0.0019643705,
-0.0113612581,
-0.0145204039,
-0.0695379749,
-0.0218216721,
-0.0462246016,
0.0564499348,
0.0739256293,
-0.0100554964,
0.0015283143,
-0.0907559395,
0.0757926479,
-0.0778631866,
0.0513041206,
-0.0453701951,
0.0194461104,
0.0203762297,
-0.0105372006,
-0.0294019729,
0.0367560945,
-0.0530707464,
-0.0317573212,
-0.0485473536,
0.0606186576,
0.0139007876,
0.0026995919,
0.0270927586,
0.0379208997,
-0.0106215915,
-0.0309205949,
0.0207660981,
0.0255784616,
-0.0280935783,
0.0261799451,
0.0229800604,
0.0233907308,
-0.0345423482,
0.0037781505,
0.0276084598,
0.0001332963,
0.0128381364,
0.0706550032,
-0.0248160791,
0.0104426267,
0.00085836,
0.0028736023,
0.0042673429,
0.002662736,
0.0377895311,
-0.0367303677,
0.0056445696,
0.0047450894,
-0.0267250817,
0.0117436443,
0.0394648947,
0.0296218209,
0.0295226537,
0.0666627064,
0.0337583721,
-0.0405437835,
0.0104148081,
0.0057842978,
-0.0218935255,
0.0193376318,
0.0448393375,
0.0298455022,
-0.0165537149,
-0.018145984,
0.002694933,
0.0512929894,
-0.0001143149,
-0.0190329403,
-0.0043331333,
-0.0395755693,
0.0083533572,
0.0134283993,
0.0359993465,
0.0266410951,
-0.069998458,
-0.020790942,
0.0298104174,
0.0321602598,
0.0349758342,
0.0831934065,
0.0121330349,
-0.005450591,
-0.0190381166,
0.0091784233,
-0.0619320869,
0.08384455,
-0.0087713506,
-0.0102584083,
0.0088974629,
0.0372578017,
-0.0261905137,
-0.0336993374,
0.0032832513,
-0.0154025238,
0.0539821945,
-0.0370386094,
0.0371278077,
0.0454447418,
-0.0405267067,
0.0905561447,
-0.0168011412,
-0.1001483649,
-0.0170224942,
-0.0461791642,
-0.031911049,
-0.0037184001,
0.0141852731,
-0.0125331562,
-0.0387229063,
-0.0096571296,
-0.0161136389,
-0.0086186575,
-0.0037470465,
0.0061316825,
0.026979031,
-0.0296326149,
-0.072921671,
0.014618664,
0.0167182665,
0.0080975574,
0.0459185243,
-0.0431108661,
0.0202740282,
-0.0143904444,
0.0663488656,
0.0190467928,
-0.0061050332,
-0.0436066836,
0.0410883948,
0.0123947347,
-0.0227958076,
0.0063343332,
0.0280335136,
0.0287483595,
0.0501562804,
-0.0214760937,
-0.0466521978,
0.0011418576,
-0.0488090627,
0.0395376794,
0.0519948229,
-0.0146778719,
0.0064019402,
0.0565184988,
-0.014456558,
-0.0527070984,
0.0516400225,
-0.093982704,
0.0131664164,
0.0113590993,
0.0186310504,
0.0093284138,
0.006173511,
-0.0001638238,
0.0382051244,
-0.0069223843,
0.0148373581,
0.0013916841,
-0.004969093,
0.0052295257,
-0.0056814388,
-0.0072720842,
-0.0425695032,
-0.0132762622,
0.0347859152,
0.0521470681,
-0.0438140109,
-0.0072340867,
-0.0812092572,
-0.035919033,
-0.018648643,
-0.0183859747,
0.0707645044,
0.0279191379,
0.020619709,
0.035883911,
-0.0369094722,
-0.0504082367,
-0.0178557243,
-0.0091212569,
-0.0208779704,
0.0218888279,
0.0182170905,
-0.0497268736,
0.0150355771,
-0.0206815507,
-0.006356285,
0.039594382,
0.0125613166,
0.0072938204,
-0.0633086115,
-0.039830327,
0.0413974635,
0.0183921289,
-0.0261873547,
-0.0248918142,
-0.003559994,
-0.0066232039,
0.0041972799,
0.056887947,
-0.002804325,
0.0055905408,
0.0216145813,
0.0225830022,
-0.012357139,
0.003149308,
-0.0534199439,
-0.022767175,
-0.0289279073,
0.0223395973,
-0.0345232487,
0.0705989227,
-0.0687531084,
-0.0132468902,
-0.0540544316,
-0.0094079217,
0.05624713,
0.0048256274,
0.0083307102,
-0.0229551457,
-0.0226932429,
-0.0083656982,
-0.0264569931,
-0.0174489748,
0.0109011224,
-0.0001253075,
-0.0137111414,
-0.0139563438,
0.0108948313,
-0.0239270534,
0.0642550811,
0.0244486816,
0.0239677988,
-0.0135195972,
-0.0192395486,
-0.035713464,
0.0405080989,
0.0158302914,
-0.0312519483,
0.0601422898,
-0.0309556127,
-0.0073115085,
-0.0391111672,
-0.0708677396,
-0.0689900145,
0.0411235504,
0.0178627614,
0.0442004465,
-0.0043722559,
-0.0838640556,
-0.0617009215,
-0.0248157717,
0.082273066,
0.0847353265,
-0.0036610011,
-0.0072634928,
-0.0304257609,
0.0211964007,
0.0289393682,
0.0508459695,
0.0235020742,
-0.0121324416,
-0.0060079028,
0.0190631077,
0.0574343391,
0.0267946851,
-0.0803365484,
0.0111777028,
0.0247676838,
-0.0311657023,
-0.0128598418,
0.0203407612,
0.0196562037,
-0.0386105962,
-0.0110659227,
0.0290321019,
0.019784905,
-0.0607854836,
0.0080589503,
-0.024087606,
-0.0313818343,
0.034566991,
0.0104904836,
-0.051865086,
-0.0026820807,
0.0176629238,
-0.0224876814,
-0.0109200785,
-0.001358417,
-0.0047547538,
-0.0966965705,
-0.0333127938,
0.014186047,
-0.0229138341,
-0.0608312674,
-0.0240435489,
-0.0155253913,
-0.0024333771,
0.0207406692,
0.0019950455,
-0.0037359137,
-0.0245235506,
0.0428622477,
0.0062794522,
-0.0172786787,
-0.0325897001,
-0.000142673,
-0.0284330957,
0.0758414045,
-0.0098877046,
-0.0075936946,
-0.0752867088,
0.0277992133,
0.0664701015,
0.0116889132,
0.0770982429,
0.0186802782,
0.0442174971,
-0.0080356998,
0.0071328692,
0.0319198333,
-0.043246761,
-0.0001251336,
-0.021811327,
0.0657297522,
-0.0076033538,
0.0516492464,
0.0075304778,
-0.0368760601,
-0.0411195941,
-0.011260231,
-0.0003906475,
-0.0199683011,
0.0118840355,
-0.0437190086,
0.0308660027,
-0.046067562,
-0.0266466942,
0.0044898111,
0.0347548053,
-0.0661087036,
-0.0588800833,
0.0259942878,
0.0038177597,
0.0495134853,
0.0011200806,
-0.0722728223,
0.0430437289,
-0.0089878039,
-0.0879205391,
-0.0136867389,
0.0146681806,
0.0514749512,
-0.0223250892,
0.0305576976,
0.0408299193,
-0.0279640816,
-0.0038316029,
-0.0260016192,
-0.1263450384,
-0.0395585373,
0.0110451216,
0.0657958463,
0.0155365411,
0.0416071303,
0.0024003412,
0.0044917557,
0.0219976064,
0.0403014645,
-0.0441391207,
0.0419316106,
0.0604895763,
-0.0392928571,
-0.0118057709,
-0.0226031505,
-0.0482231937,
0.0171882957,
0.0124866655,
0.0044021872,
-0.0730509013,
0.0272587072,
0.0577508472,
-0.0253683925,
0.0407444648,
0.0086951731,
0.0806659237,
0.0347725824,
0.0490006655,
-0.0106197326,
0.051481992,
-0.0526313707,
-0.0311725903,
0.0285640415,
0.0199101921,
0.048986692,
0.0245745853,
0.0681851059,
-0.0222616941,
0.0154353743,
0.0394710824,
-0.0353051722,
0.0211037714,
0.0032330947,
0.0053143371,
0.0125769768,
-0.0008670521,
0.038604442,
0.0358618833,
0.00327873,
-0.0011670239,
0.0299031101,
0.04337148,
-0.0319806263,
0.0345859975,
-0.0500939488,
-0.0456059277,
-0.0443440005,
-0.0351524353,
0.0317465179,
0.0385235623,
0.0036479009,
-0.0149678728,
0.0040155901,
0.014156105,
0.0045820093,
-0.021205185,
-0.0283438042,
-0.0215774272,
0.0401176624,
0.0351945758,
-0.0573600903,
0.0386281461,
-0.0594451949,
0.0218218733,
-0.0369876847,
0.0326952785,
-0.0023379747,
-0.0551293194,
-0.0029029665,
0.0094780689,
-0.013840761,
-0.0057679932,
0.0066596945,
-0.0388696752,
-0.008046695,
-0.0172182843,
0.0287735723,
-0.0409873463,
0.056581594,
-0.0089892978,
-0.0591684431,
-0.0163013544,
0.0118640931,
-0.0571533814,
0.0532871783,
0.0148345493,
-0.0231288988,
-5.537860783e-33,
0.0157093704,
-0.0004502719,
0.0285935849,
0.0274396334,
-0.0276998524,
0.0053750174,
-0.0091140289,
0.0359767526,
0.0366402455,
-0.0302646141,
-0.0038161874,
0.0069899177,
0.0071731405,
0.0551419891,
0.0282036755,
0.0048864288,
0.0705342814,
0.0093327975,
-0.0241191108,
-0.0037252191,
0.0080148103,
0.0033046294,
0.0730727538,
-0.0303858537,
-0.0035392423,
0.0521845371,
-0.01888166,
0.004843628,
-0.009632959,
0.0423822999,
0.0002048126,
0.0114465617,
-0.0117680319,
-0.103997834,
-0.0257761069,
0.0224898402,
-0.0792443231,
-0.0267024375,
-0.0539870709,
0.0368818343,
-0.0135315415,
-0.0375562049,
0.0307995472,
-0.0169921778,
-0.0324837156,
-0.0283276271,
0.01499609,
-0.0436003022,
0.0113261975,
-0.0190317333,
0.0007162785,
0.003153176,
0.0063789776,
-0.0354113616,
0.0275274366,
0.0008346135,
-0.0265988801,
-0.0537112579,
-0.067765601,
0.0389618613,
0.0359870195,
0.0297958348,
0.0090191849,
0.024831498,
-0.0084807388,
0.009600861,
0.0699510127,
-0.0375722349,
-0.0394173376,
-0.0129629467,
-0.0085145077,
0.0032377779,
0.0738651976,
-0.0307396371,
0.1005046442,
0.0251801927,
-0.0261875708,
0.0242333543,
0.0088934656,
0.0291006323,
0.0053348029,
0.0074221552,
0.0092006344,
0.0089506451,
-0.0067667416,
0.0559652112,
-0.0133425621,
-0.0275627039,
-0.0088659516,
0.0626382977,
0.0312046595,
0.0292237885,
-0.0048015006,
-0.0253062863,
0.0492618829,
0.022710884,
0.0308731571,
0.0438997447,
0.0123305796,
-0.0089239441,
0.0236431267,
-0.0200244281,
0.0063585532,
0.0078445515,
0.0102443071,
-0.0035698796,
0.0563488789,
0.076467596,
-0.0576857477,
-0.0096409498,
-0.0458013229,
-0.0179399569,
0.0167645067,
0.0368035138,
0.0275061764,
0.0082020052,
-0.0098303985,
0.0198477972,
-0.0637291968,
0.0142968372,
0.01425731,
0.0209638793,
-0.0069048041,
0.0567481741,
0.0033103053,
-0.0470227785,
-0.0590363368,
0.0185587592,
0.004116687,
-0.0835399032,
-0.0311348364,
-0.0142537607,
2.959e-7,
0.0237124301,
-0.00689092,
0.0551053062,
-0.0087448265,
0.013978431,
0.0140653905,
0.003724982,
0.0615502186,
-0.0350709409,
-0.0094732642,
-0.0162951723,
-0.0128954314,
-0.0252388734,
-0.0029467701,
-0.0376450047,
-0.0558657199,
-0.0112867048,
0.0416611359,
0.0243421495,
0.0470464602,
-0.0044074822,
0.0804555938,
0.0099099856,
0.027540395,
0.0167796593,
0.0015238962,
0.0444806814,
0.025291454,
0.0537323244,
-0.0159364957,
-0.015553805,
-0.0020037603,
-0.0215979386,
-0.0199976843,
-0.0323071592,
0.0478636511,
0.0218575615,
0.0409458056,
-0.0210814644,
-0.0194705166,
0.0012992984,
-0.0025193915,
-0.0293657947,
0.0297195632,
-0.0038014376,
-0.1283513606,
-0.0342080146,
0.0077858935,
-0.0320447534,
0.0208932515,
-0.0459377579,
0.0288629401,
0.0189234186,
-0.0133992704,
0.0270520151,
-0.0059127156,
0.0296920259,
-0.0933072492,
-0.0416803211,
0.0259477794,
-0.0495771095,
-0.008436366,
-0.0499907695,
-0.0291300267,
0.0368133411,
-0.008284077,
-0.0424397886,
2.686763153e-34,
0.0133734196,
-0.0136873499,
0.0103572635,
0.0248349551,
0.0041223452,
-0.040475674,
-0.0359867364,
0.0462919772,
0.0604944117,
-0.0149139194,
-0.0427437052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20657v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20657v2
|
DORY: Deliberative Prompt Recovery for LLM
| 2024-05-31T07:51:16 | 2024-06-07T17:00:00 |
Lirong Gao, Ru Peng, Yiming Zhang, Junbo Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prompt recovery in large language models (LLMs) is crucial for understanding
how LLMs work and addressing concerns regarding privacy, copyright, etc. The
trend towards inference-only APIs complicates this task by restricting access
to essential outputs for recovery. To tackle this challenge, we extract
prompt-related information from limited outputs and identify a strong(negative)
correlation between output probability-based uncertainty and the success of
prompt recovery. This finding led to the development of Deliberative PrOmpt
RecoverY (DORY), our novel approach that leverages uncertainty to recover
prompts accurately. DORY involves reconstructing drafts from outputs, refining
these with hints, and filtering out noise based on uncertainty. Our evaluation
across diverse LLMs and prompt benchmarks shows that DORY outperforms existing
baselines, improving performance by approximately 10.82% and establishing a new
state-of-the-art record in prompt recovery tasks. Significantly, DORY operates
using a single LLM without any external resources or model, offering a
cost-effective, user-friendly prompt recovery solution.
|
[
0.0277477093,
0.0740484893,
-0.0097619863,
0.0410791524,
-0.0829624906,
-0.0323305316,
0.0068234354,
0.0052795256,
0.0045912545,
-0.0447609648,
-0.0234082881,
-0.0427234881,
-0.0062243766,
0.0154279741,
0.004949043,
-0.0346406884,
0.0425898246,
-0.0564820394,
0.0149445608,
-0.0095428349,
0.0096201217,
0.0008679819,
-0.0116349747,
0.0510038584,
-0.0076481202,
-0.0290111955,
-0.0340725929,
0.0198777001,
-0.0029696233,
0.0011734107,
-0.005013987,
0.071549654,
-0.0136509016,
0.0451134481,
0.0000021114,
-0.0725944266,
-0.0560999028,
0.0085327048,
-0.0605674833,
0.017800983,
0.0360967182,
0.0207664687,
-0.0361558236,
0.0156738255,
-0.0112167345,
0.0383938327,
0.0183807835,
-0.0119647635,
0.0382461771,
0.068658188,
0.0104002319,
0.0165370051,
0.0022184255,
-0.0065704761,
-0.0008117373,
-0.0228098463,
0.0179062057,
-0.0739354715,
0.0020751697,
0.0267881099,
0.0417768881,
0.0366803743,
0.0155943921,
-0.04507358,
-0.0664125755,
-0.0152422283,
0.0211681407,
-0.0449150354,
-0.0336853676,
0.0269798748,
0.0628417358,
0.0179784615,
-0.0017605154,
-0.0512102023,
0.0480500944,
0.0326676294,
-0.064357236,
0.0594161078,
-0.0371506661,
-0.0147722885,
-0.0073188413,
-0.033976309,
0.007178905,
-0.0206213426,
0.0180702824,
0.0712131932,
0.034699861,
-0.0087818485,
-0.0225031953,
-0.009095544,
-0.0033656033,
-0.0341716446,
0.0401781052,
0.0203926824,
-0.0394828431,
0.0133855101,
-0.0270453524,
-0.0166479629,
0.0532158017,
0.0195200965,
0.048565682,
0.0204856973,
-0.0350105949,
0.0391235016,
0.0193151645,
0.0338259228,
-0.0000118038,
0.0425752029,
-0.0138905738,
-0.0093006799,
-0.0049314196,
-0.0089982226,
-0.0335692801,
0.0496845096,
-0.0442065448,
0.0231646113,
0.0072723203,
0.0253372919,
-0.0179396607,
0.0571915172,
0.0203109942,
0.0004171972,
-0.0490861721,
-0.0482244566,
-0.0181397144,
-0.005631269,
0.0183355026,
0.0291609205,
0.0499392897,
-0.0751383156,
-0.0307919886,
-0.0059025041,
-0.0010696348,
-0.0134047708,
-0.0190588292,
0.053172674,
-0.0164341498,
-0.0338854864,
-0.0428028777,
-0.0716530159,
-0.0189792719,
-0.0408628136,
-0.034955807,
-0.0788087174,
0.0253738705,
0.0048634149,
-0.0221324172,
-0.0687415376,
-0.0000580858,
0.0291276667,
-0.0043196417,
0.0515385121,
-0.0223806892,
-0.0140752485,
0.0223493055,
0.027445484,
-0.0444313101,
0.0362021178,
-0.0012221104,
0.0615998916,
0.0745196268,
0.0014705198,
0.0318151303,
0.0613265559,
0.0082769087,
-0.0093361195,
-0.0134963421,
-0.0096955309,
0.0201754346,
-0.0085642459,
0.0172372628,
0.0595677681,
-0.0111293755,
-0.0023869495,
0.0700412095,
0.0518704988,
-0.0159301255,
-0.025856575,
0.0122488774,
0.0162468553,
0.0196807608,
0.0338985883,
-0.066096887,
-0.0051096324,
-0.0282822959,
0.019993199,
0.0192092266,
-0.0007548251,
0.0084050847,
-0.0179128218,
-0.000453791,
-0.0067004915,
-0.0557268374,
0.0374037214,
0.0421293452,
0.0092075057,
-0.0545701124,
0.0757583007,
0.0199288558,
-0.0654253736,
-0.0208138656,
-0.0406632647,
0.0652021021,
0.0239168499,
0.0644352362,
-0.07397037,
-0.0251748636,
-0.0267678201,
0.0044957208,
0.0380519703,
0.0485032462,
-0.0192269366,
0.02432229,
-0.0352390483,
-0.03583299,
0.0107818684,
0.0327266343,
0.0295292307,
0.0296925884,
-0.0338650383,
0.0216032676,
-0.0109636299,
-0.0017957943,
0.0193606075,
-0.0383171327,
-0.0218471289,
-0.0006553154,
-0.0028393101,
0.0409551561,
0.047121305,
-0.0178432744,
0.0386774093,
0.0507335439,
-0.0166786518,
0.0139708575,
-0.0090818983,
-0.0438619331,
-0.0160655715,
0.0424444489,
0.0463550016,
-0.0234075803,
0.0042575481,
-0.0283816364,
-0.0343977027,
-0.0341951884,
-0.0016628376,
0.012868044,
-0.0578241684,
0.0323288888,
0.0117199561,
-0.0280965846,
-0.0454557203,
0.020539064,
-0.0149649717,
0.0103447177,
0.0675553232,
0.0011760275,
0.0019401311,
-0.061492689,
-0.0125515983,
0.0042899819,
-0.0229018889,
0.0164273512,
0.041948162,
-0.0135619333,
-0.0210674927,
-0.0491172709,
-0.0596119352,
0.0333356038,
-0.0264987666,
0.0204316881,
-0.0005999571,
0.0056595649,
-0.0257223267,
-0.0046045608,
0.0056892224,
-0.0267808065,
0.0126663884,
0.0419884548,
0.0033988543,
-0.0006461879,
-0.0138558075,
-0.0492933951,
-0.0112452535,
0.0055184229,
0.0059813694,
-0.023761563,
-0.05305757,
-0.0582092218,
0.0675737485,
-0.0033046096,
0.0061882017,
-0.023792861,
-0.0013131924,
0.0154683031,
-0.0508728512,
0.0138338767,
0.0084916456,
0.0000896734,
-0.005764049,
0.0340897962,
-0.0428322926,
-0.0883052126,
-0.0024909296,
-0.0177769288,
-0.0351203904,
-0.0023965109,
-0.0221842304,
0.0325882286,
0.0408214964,
0.0375887156,
0.0002029652,
-0.0138518577,
0.0203965977,
0.0079731541,
-0.0030059326,
-0.0316987373,
-0.0187819842,
-0.040041469,
0.0667832643,
-0.0193539839,
-0.0591202788,
0.0708428398,
-0.0458644964,
0.0213031545,
0.0079166079,
0.0035863167,
-0.0039610001,
0.0839958489,
-0.0282937493,
-0.0065411325,
0.0223243907,
-0.0729808435,
-0.0519813783,
-0.0126417857,
0.0644615814,
-0.0583957583,
0.0436559692,
-0.0645350963,
-0.0027445541,
-0.0390492119,
-0.0338748135,
-0.0424192846,
-0.0531977005,
-0.0200657379,
0.0309109725,
0.0240295976,
0.0042814664,
-0.0149797658,
-0.0329534076,
0.0252260175,
0.0407107137,
0.017551776,
0.0084129432,
-0.0404025391,
0.022142265,
0.0297406092,
-0.0062973606,
0.0339498408,
-0.0571071059,
0.0187447332,
0.0815504938,
0.0157718491,
-0.0063496395,
0.0253835171,
-0.0399899967,
0.0347435251,
-0.0382735208,
-0.0031544669,
0.0532887317,
0.0516229421,
-0.0611224696,
-0.0247441549,
0.0866768435,
0.014194563,
-0.0662337691,
-0.0480020232,
-0.0346793532,
0.0220192373,
-0.0067574056,
-0.0006964684,
-0.0934909359,
-0.0268645473,
0.0589127988,
0.0520717986,
-0.0081043048,
-0.0367870219,
-0.016160991,
-0.121213682,
0.0769416913,
0.0039207279,
0.0040155756,
-0.0197701044,
-0.0462635495,
0.0079865772,
0.0311382562,
0.0277617443,
0.0331815295,
0.0120063657,
-0.0072392225,
-0.0034595863,
-0.0393248498,
0.0148551082,
0.0000835602,
-0.0255809408,
0.0503415689,
0.0418837033,
-0.0042289635,
0.0193144269,
-0.0179742482,
0.0674464405,
-0.0339123979,
-0.0052937907,
0.0040441724,
0.0374254696,
0.0362725817,
0.0219308436,
-0.0041894345,
0.0336494558,
-0.004239419,
-0.0661882907,
0.0393023603,
0.0414653011,
-0.0425751433,
0.0136387525,
-0.0097285816,
-0.0045333379,
0.0325495191,
0.0713961348,
0.0295117069,
0.0019366388,
-0.0291296765,
-0.0392326005,
0.0266484208,
-0.0312097706,
0.0281792767,
0.006719091,
-0.0045775794,
0.0240141172,
-0.0433671884,
-0.0219820142,
0.0145045808,
0.0413744673,
0.0218347739,
0.0246481188,
0.0029257913,
-0.0157382935,
-0.0439347811,
0.0342224762,
-0.0530525148,
0.0100258682,
-0.0756605268,
0.0114638722,
-0.0180077162,
-0.0046423115,
-0.0072527579,
0.0307078641,
-0.0840624794,
-0.0766805187,
0.0314037725,
0.0668136105,
0.0289239716,
0.0300867949,
0.0064044404,
-0.0547175333,
0.0611275584,
0.0487024263,
-0.0061052404,
0.0014013909,
0.0236609224,
0.0451426841,
-0.0327476524,
0.0356787816,
-0.0537844934,
-0.0295686871,
0.0342386961,
0.0416766666,
0.0134252915,
-0.1031131521,
0.0031973391,
0.0518334322,
0.0442733429,
0.0012731995,
-0.0138324751,
-0.0569965355,
0.0122860009,
-0.0198296737,
-0.0243320037,
-0.0392933488,
0.0345402695,
0.0023972602,
-0.0866642818,
0.0239615012,
0.0116437739,
-0.0249149557,
0.0691121295,
-0.0543407574,
-0.0005523463,
0.0505303554,
-0.0131514156,
0.0630254596,
-0.0288114715,
-0.0149321193,
0.0624945983,
-0.0197354835,
0.0625605807,
0.0044389134,
0.0728435814,
0.0021546779,
-0.0066438476,
-0.0023969077,
0.0171669871,
-0.0574521907,
-0.0835363567,
-0.0128125092,
0.0631437227,
0.0389334373,
0.0225153025,
0.0164752454,
-0.0261244327,
-0.0021399925,
-0.0321919918,
0.0361942835,
0.051890716,
-0.0127729475,
0.0273588672,
0.0124092055,
-0.0294520333,
0.0413938574,
0.0524075367,
-0.0701753125,
0.0403591581,
-0.0108573781,
-0.0111065004,
-0.0420377813,
-0.0560803264,
-0.0034674993,
0.0275374316,
-0.026495818,
-0.0430986807,
-0.0649388134,
-0.0149489157,
0.0340197235,
0.0290498342,
-0.0305982102,
-0.0140100438,
-0.0166904368,
0.0545037948,
0.000007223,
-0.0277568735,
-0.0455718003,
0.0415043868,
-0.0071629127,
-0.0432116911,
-0.0069390223,
-5.780392451e-33,
-0.0466262735,
-0.0421473384,
-0.0051253908,
0.0164697766,
-0.0000045329,
0.0055403956,
-0.0360239111,
0.0171401333,
0.0279586092,
0.0029481791,
-0.0592412949,
0.0024361159,
0.0327426754,
0.0150092049,
0.0198747609,
-0.0004687465,
0.0395463072,
-0.0008415511,
-0.0349739604,
-0.0016929716,
0.0591402762,
0.0482934415,
0.0269397628,
-0.0231482536,
0.0669034496,
-0.0027407638,
-0.0053246617,
0.0125751896,
-0.0301794857,
0.0349726118,
0.0185761265,
0.0182155631,
-0.007076005,
-0.0471901484,
-0.0521465391,
0.0353445448,
-0.0389119089,
-0.0126815783,
0.0212773476,
-0.0089412909,
-0.0193640515,
-0.0378997177,
0.0047650598,
-0.0196337923,
-0.0003119358,
-0.0033312375,
-0.0091670305,
-0.0051331664,
-0.0515184812,
-0.0376763903,
-0.0315492265,
0.0288031697,
0.0065776464,
-0.0250721853,
0.0463091061,
0.0259169973,
0.0359139368,
-0.0140653634,
-0.0656968579,
0.0007971091,
0.0039221481,
0.0446690582,
0.0360043161,
0.0089550605,
-0.0271779541,
0.0557713434,
0.0289059468,
0.0166115016,
-0.0296205115,
-0.0148345521,
-0.0062909746,
0.0506389812,
0.0051548206,
0.0673250705,
-0.0121599073,
-0.0053718491,
-0.0027697731,
0.0505009107,
0.0314889625,
0.0242725629,
0.0478947908,
0.0033626566,
-0.0075789397,
-0.0172344297,
-0.0491328351,
-0.0262067243,
-0.0215275344,
0.0234884229,
0.0413396657,
0.003115416,
-0.02523054,
-0.0465946011,
0.0702407956,
-0.0087176748,
-0.0120575167,
0.019395316,
0.0023137417,
0.0143249016,
-0.0283471029,
0.0435513444,
-0.0212550629,
-0.0060222368,
0.0069302963,
-0.0085060531,
-0.0051168744,
0.0285308305,
-0.0114048952,
0.0206664633,
-0.0586500391,
0.0158835296,
-0.055975195,
0.0650747269,
0.0030827527,
-0.0083278483,
0.042325817,
-0.0043308027,
0.0126909949,
0.0366338082,
0.0042440747,
0.0044507668,
-0.005553728,
0.0523050688,
-0.0116410553,
-0.0248031691,
-0.0146881128,
-0.0040407199,
0.0264928006,
0.0200453326,
0.0392210819,
0.0454009511,
0.0224295203,
-0.012089761,
2.602e-7,
0.0420817249,
-0.0148202041,
0.0504606552,
0.030641241,
0.0086944913,
0.0443355255,
-0.0047835722,
-0.0045986576,
0.04543861,
-0.0306879319,
-0.0108885244,
-0.0212459397,
0.0702400282,
0.0409483798,
-0.1078114882,
-0.0284356959,
-0.0349140577,
0.0125271669,
-0.0634742528,
-0.0090999827,
0.0467638075,
0.0570841096,
-0.0069252751,
-0.0339071117,
-0.0282081217,
-0.0280303769,
0.0244857036,
-0.0540780686,
-0.0445314273,
0.032909628,
0.0977749228,
-0.0339717567,
0.0259311516,
-0.0031219453,
-0.0154815409,
0.001622953,
-0.0298943557,
0.0850610808,
0.0492690876,
-0.0337812975,
-0.0120709315,
-0.0371525921,
0.0182232149,
-0.0462143831,
0.037119288,
-0.0273197982,
0.0012145546,
-0.0566067994,
-0.0275943223,
-0.0695009083,
0.0084694047,
-0.0018183873,
0.0245628878,
0.0291984323,
-0.0106033338,
0.0182719808,
-0.0233493466,
-0.074329406,
-0.0469177887,
-0.0241119917,
-0.0391514227,
-0.0551601909,
-0.0131459786,
-0.0226916391,
-0.0272090305,
-0.1226551607,
0.014095637,
2.633232472e-34,
0.0285892058,
0.0042411094,
0.0012325346,
0.0684789866,
0.0358815119,
-0.002480732,
0.0530676283,
0.0257778037,
-0.0142513262,
-0.0617350638,
-0.0377704054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20654v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20654v2
|
Passage-specific Prompt Tuning for Passage Reranking in Question Answering with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T07:43:42 | 2024-06-21T03:52:30 |
Xuyang Wu, Zhiyuan Peng, Krishna Sravanthi Rajanala Sai, Hsin-Tai Wu, Yi Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Effective passage retrieval and reranking methods have been widely utilized
to identify suitable candidates in open-domain question answering tasks, recent
studies have resorted to LLMs for reranking the retrieved passages by the
log-likelihood of the question conditioned on each passage. Although these
methods have demonstrated promising results, the performance is notably
sensitive to the human-written prompt (or hard prompt), and fine-tuning LLMs
can be computationally intensive and time-consuming. Furthermore, this approach
limits the leverage of question-passage relevance pairs and passage-specific
knowledge to enhance the ranking capabilities of LLMs. In this paper, we
propose passage-specific prompt tuning for reranking in open-domain question
answering (PSPT): a parameter-efficient method that fine-tunes learnable
passage-specific soft prompts, incorporating passage-specific knowledge from a
limited set of question-passage relevance pairs. The method involves ranking
retrieved passages based on the log-likelihood of the model generating the
question conditioned on each passage and the learned soft prompt. We conducted
extensive experiments utilizing the Llama-2-chat-7B model across three publicly
available open-domain question answering datasets and the results demonstrate
the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
|
[
0.0586872175,
0.0003616444,
0.0026893511,
0.0348659456,
0.0031250862,
0.0127137303,
-0.009598529,
-0.0040305513,
0.0514585339,
-0.0529640578,
-0.0377403833,
-0.0428193025,
-0.0246066879,
-0.0042518652,
0.011283542,
-0.0042896047,
0.0405488051,
-0.0249923244,
0.0170562584,
-0.0173708349,
-0.0086077536,
0.0159694683,
-0.0085175,
0.0061702686,
0.0812215284,
-0.0346017666,
0.0050993259,
0.0106512997,
0.0337650329,
-0.006391041,
0.0312929042,
0.0480380282,
0.0134999361,
0.0145439133,
0.0000016887,
-0.0624940209,
-0.0331158899,
-0.0167446025,
-0.0561605953,
0.0300691519,
-0.013554153,
0.0428764559,
0.0405463465,
0.0321209021,
-0.0357733257,
0.0236627515,
0.0011589834,
0.0062532797,
0.0801276937,
0.0389065072,
0.0408095904,
-0.004692412,
-0.0242857821,
-0.0332742222,
0.0217496082,
-0.0544639379,
0.034919139,
-0.0227433816,
0.0263671,
0.0902411267,
0.0021971711,
-0.0017640308,
0.0125200786,
0.0011463102,
0.0143547859,
0.0121336095,
-0.0142451748,
0.0495692603,
0.0067200246,
0.1055151597,
0.0264830813,
-0.0179200098,
0.0023298713,
0.0043064873,
0.033636868,
0.034206681,
-0.053762231,
0.0067738169,
-0.0036522825,
-0.0081525883,
0.0027430688,
0.012014593,
-0.0067954771,
0.0278631337,
-0.0176410265,
0.069236286,
0.0082223946,
-0.0270203836,
0.0266469885,
-0.0040548132,
-0.0475826785,
-0.0244365372,
0.007856898,
0.0348862372,
-0.0341605619,
0.0177207552,
-0.0000609879,
0.0287282784,
0.0328636058,
-0.0031868811,
0.0174475908,
0.0174365416,
-0.0090174237,
0.0397023298,
-0.0346145295,
0.0632230267,
0.0210215412,
0.009980673,
-0.066175513,
-0.0162356198,
-0.0050736438,
-0.041984465,
-0.0153814191,
0.0292454064,
-0.0390279852,
0.017370224,
-0.0332159325,
0.021702677,
0.0187257174,
-0.034818057,
0.006119594,
0.0237684827,
-0.0134480046,
0.001827058,
-0.0834989846,
0.0197489653,
-0.037815202,
0.0232812967,
0.000149573,
-0.0316842869,
-0.0197357461,
-0.0319884866,
0.0012219251,
-0.0252065044,
0.0120308436,
0.0069749965,
-0.0218579452,
-0.0340950266,
-0.0160047356,
-0.0173561815,
0.009377107,
0.0052181017,
-0.0175032802,
-0.0381736308,
0.0350904167,
0.0003255489,
-0.0194718037,
0.0022667188,
0.0214698613,
0.0585155524,
-0.0207678713,
0.0570698641,
0.033694692,
-0.0057109618,
0.0247133356,
0.0370260589,
0.0086253295,
0.0380694419,
-0.0082032625,
0.0206546821,
0.0557968803,
0.0248281918,
0.0010377333,
0.0164650511,
0.0012328874,
0.0178619549,
0.047656998,
0.0599102527,
0.0379604585,
0.0053224121,
0.0389454737,
0.0078399843,
-0.0149990171,
-0.053930968,
0.0382669792,
0.0487754345,
0.0268621072,
-0.0192156211,
0.0244052857,
0.0142137567,
0.0291716252,
0.0278251283,
0.0010586274,
0.0171028618,
-0.0220421907,
0.0058244411,
0.0568510443,
0.0394544825,
-0.021126261,
-0.0381398126,
0.0224616118,
0.0050595086,
-0.0375182964,
0.0556500405,
-0.0034314129,
0.0210036058,
-0.0383101031,
0.0713295564,
0.0274594445,
-0.012329963,
-0.0116828959,
-0.0428310707,
0.0531846546,
0.0429823957,
0.0486671589,
-0.0636587068,
-0.0522881374,
-0.0037917604,
0.0119036455,
0.0164626129,
0.0000542341,
-0.0359068327,
0.0056144949,
-0.0412912481,
0.0099317459,
0.0010620953,
0.0035546538,
0.020256428,
0.0186732709,
0.0226666909,
0.0237263236,
-0.0586558096,
0.0126018589,
0.0184642039,
-0.0267537907,
-0.0342703387,
0.0414379053,
-0.0035663247,
0.0091709215,
0.0351212993,
0.0149982935,
0.013230483,
0.0364376977,
-0.0361714773,
-0.0265749805,
-0.0372098461,
-0.0599859729,
-0.0249715932,
0.0121632619,
0.0202739071,
0.0139253531,
0.0637990832,
-0.0391126052,
-0.025878245,
-0.03943488,
-0.0214535464,
-0.0161148738,
-0.036543116,
-0.0160712674,
0.021224102,
0.0044468143,
-0.1001483127,
0.0687022954,
0.0073761647,
0.0684731305,
0.0687888041,
0.0366685465,
-0.0099193212,
-0.0316792578,
-0.020670712,
-0.0001661479,
-0.0050424794,
-0.0036255568,
0.0132685928,
0.0032949976,
-0.0641801953,
-0.0296104718,
-0.0746224821,
0.0302968398,
-0.0089531802,
0.0288201813,
0.0415254757,
0.0129454173,
-0.0248630475,
-0.0305108447,
-0.0476570055,
-0.0260151569,
0.01344629,
0.0319125317,
0.0296609737,
0.0190011542,
-0.0075574713,
-0.0275093522,
-0.0060592857,
-0.0112153245,
0.0405229516,
-0.0174867492,
-0.0046611875,
-0.070585005,
0.0472836159,
-0.0531971678,
0.0106579559,
-0.0224359389,
-0.0244682562,
-0.0255158339,
-0.0064311363,
0.0464929864,
0.0713380203,
0.0085168071,
-0.0281043649,
0.0400698036,
0.0066667888,
-0.0499368757,
0.0140047278,
-0.0089390771,
-0.0432650857,
0.0258288085,
-0.0349280573,
0.0178412795,
0.0272191111,
0.0019324183,
-0.0390398018,
-0.0123029491,
0.0074442551,
-0.0310659874,
-0.0062534534,
-0.0529113784,
-0.0023103636,
-0.0234000757,
0.0310329441,
-0.00404794,
-0.028017154,
0.052665554,
-0.0184692889,
-0.0065252674,
-0.0785037726,
0.0023714965,
-0.0854592621,
0.0534787439,
-0.0043956549,
-0.0009915113,
0.0225603599,
-0.0406785645,
-0.05973408,
0.015847072,
0.0008993395,
-0.0580123104,
0.0260910895,
-0.0294756033,
0.0130104395,
-0.0251416452,
-0.0477302969,
-0.0375592746,
-0.0833519846,
0.0177414995,
0.0117489137,
-0.0286404211,
0.0127724456,
-0.0058270618,
0.0026589055,
0.016892964,
0.0062893806,
-0.0329999849,
0.0011831939,
-0.0261201449,
0.1004502699,
0.071325615,
0.0525458418,
0.0077500138,
-0.0173891764,
0.043929819,
0.0311532151,
0.0005967137,
-0.019631369,
0.0441584289,
-0.0309964903,
0.058638934,
-0.0648006573,
-0.0051879305,
0.0361519828,
0.0622537211,
-0.0214765053,
-0.0292556677,
0.1111612096,
0.0435804911,
-0.0285354331,
-0.0149411578,
-0.0425073132,
0.0210434645,
0.0164595712,
0.0531838126,
-0.0833621547,
-0.0361519344,
0.0022452241,
0.0497863106,
-0.0090986509,
-0.0310924593,
-0.003843487,
-0.1349469423,
0.0055242516,
-0.0218947046,
-0.0291280989,
-0.0269152503,
-0.0656605214,
0.0214440227,
0.0090171648,
-0.0194158833,
0.0442599542,
-0.0298459101,
0.0248396918,
0.0264276173,
0.0099229375,
0.0220648516,
0.0515188649,
-0.034717761,
0.0008677538,
0.0326331668,
0.0118778022,
0.0024170931,
0.0005077339,
-0.0304927453,
-0.081852071,
0.0071364078,
0.0088630551,
-0.0288882423,
0.0061373198,
0.0001638393,
-0.0708640367,
0.0508550443,
-0.0012255698,
0.0011104144,
0.0123417443,
0.0579604506,
-0.0109619526,
0.0115628028,
-0.0224662777,
0.0382243991,
-0.000686997,
0.0688285157,
0.0161912702,
-0.0246298965,
-0.0157720223,
-0.0404052101,
0.0264814552,
0.0059481617,
-0.0456016809,
0.0113131888,
0.0150840133,
0.0561658554,
-0.0844145343,
-0.0199389476,
0.0041203261,
0.0318209715,
-0.0216851626,
0.0549560748,
-0.0337822959,
0.0086741447,
-0.0210652426,
0.0338045359,
-0.063262932,
0.0146893281,
-0.0581181459,
-0.0021222243,
0.0712270215,
-0.0328579061,
-0.0486390963,
0.0138276527,
-0.0587554276,
-0.0376880951,
-0.0206835307,
0.0201337039,
0.0157266688,
-0.0244859047,
-0.0204699486,
-0.0471570753,
0.0677769259,
0.0492166243,
-0.0481704101,
0.0348338373,
-0.0202014633,
0.0506691374,
-0.0272337981,
0.0317241997,
-0.0711841881,
-0.011558569,
-0.0118597811,
0.0350970738,
0.0022201377,
-0.1101705953,
0.0118467929,
0.0203919616,
-0.0047238232,
0.0433270112,
-0.0386968181,
-0.0558342785,
0.0518692173,
0.008552663,
-0.0271019898,
-0.0000160283,
0.0215244647,
0.025021363,
-0.0555052049,
-0.0095251193,
-0.0060925572,
0.0081621734,
0.0646583438,
-0.0903081596,
-0.0027623028,
0.0502163582,
-0.0177783612,
-0.0120967468,
-0.0137128718,
-0.0236903504,
-0.0094910637,
0.0153304609,
0.0847641453,
0.0018077382,
0.0571038425,
-0.0089361137,
-0.0061054868,
-0.0239325352,
0.0551797673,
-0.1007774472,
-0.0461393185,
-0.0237823892,
0.0234483406,
0.0404882059,
0.0067915311,
0.0326399691,
0.0329414755,
-0.0164060947,
-0.0194771998,
-0.0349629074,
0.0125334179,
0.0098814825,
0.0631804541,
0.0393973812,
-0.0004665174,
0.0537874736,
0.0932125896,
-0.006517021,
0.0426199809,
0.0092024961,
-0.0214507077,
-0.0026061381,
-0.0192883927,
0.0032164883,
0.027128987,
-0.0044586989,
0.0047985907,
-0.033350952,
-0.0220964495,
0.0262743179,
-0.0247366689,
-0.0142536517,
-0.0233054701,
0.0377933793,
0.0349166766,
0.0114895292,
-0.026143698,
-0.0661227405,
0.0120292148,
-0.013484139,
-0.0361104235,
-0.0094721764,
-6.065644522e-33,
-0.0456963852,
-0.0232254025,
-0.0157623999,
-0.0396415517,
-0.0256967414,
0.024674587,
0.0120873926,
-0.0154356398,
-0.0207895506,
-0.0209602937,
-0.0329143144,
0.0007802862,
0.0053500794,
0.0049860715,
-0.028118372,
-0.0501654781,
0.0058360901,
-0.002443294,
-0.0456448942,
0.0169123914,
0.0623245686,
0.0410395376,
0.0018630278,
0.0301983953,
0.0362807773,
-0.0448535234,
0.0159758292,
0.0154595161,
-0.0121652558,
0.0602638684,
-0.0082284529,
0.0230966043,
0.0508685634,
-0.0901113153,
0.0215541646,
0.0753316581,
-0.0721499994,
-0.0395243429,
0.0146115981,
-0.0348943882,
-0.025704816,
-0.0382256769,
-0.0028864583,
-0.0017135937,
0.0370530859,
-0.0274945665,
0.0137865385,
-0.0286795646,
0.0026530307,
-0.0139095476,
0.0192383397,
0.0078406064,
-0.0221716799,
-0.0502408743,
-0.0464888625,
0.0827349424,
-0.0028144,
0.0348192453,
0.0026286351,
0.0103017427,
0.0117186643,
0.0486805812,
0.0075269751,
0.0046890401,
-0.0397361256,
0.0393256731,
-0.0040644999,
-0.0256480481,
-0.01009335,
-0.0435371846,
-0.0507507026,
-0.017742645,
0.0261236392,
0.0411778465,
-0.0143776778,
0.0350504518,
-0.1002135277,
0.0790153891,
0.0612172149,
-0.01502294,
0.011891338,
-0.0085141286,
-0.0087988283,
-0.0346004143,
-0.0697827637,
0.0421726182,
-0.0380636528,
0.0039389813,
0.0491478853,
-0.0111790225,
-0.0341773257,
-0.0326064304,
0.0319722481,
-0.0288357493,
0.0091863945,
0.0208886471,
0.0029986382,
0.0091736969,
0.0061848261,
0.0249190517,
-0.0350895599,
0.0330248475,
0.0471092537,
-0.0689194202,
-0.0212089457,
0.0028076952,
-0.0165134948,
-0.0185620338,
-0.0543178283,
0.020885339,
-0.0122757098,
0.0084092692,
-0.018718794,
0.0587055273,
0.0015167597,
0.0062450152,
0.0072049364,
0.0873307958,
0.0230813418,
0.0104881357,
-0.0288261361,
-0.0138212936,
-0.0101812864,
-0.0190756936,
-0.0266630612,
0.0358774439,
0.0251240786,
0.060490422,
-0.0672128424,
-0.0275893938,
-0.0221676733,
0.0196138173,
2.406e-7,
0.0327693224,
0.0157463141,
-0.0195957199,
0.0719807893,
0.0211761333,
0.0207480751,
0.0360717699,
0.0433599502,
0.0579563677,
-0.0209007002,
0.0134432716,
0.0013300992,
0.005549348,
0.0078835925,
-0.1148656681,
-0.0091203926,
-0.050174959,
-0.0498816818,
-0.031340193,
-0.0779027939,
0.0420164913,
0.0796819553,
-0.0395817533,
-0.0013501646,
-0.0313348919,
-0.044450935,
0.0264103487,
-0.0265879128,
-0.037009459,
0.0212251898,
0.0809972957,
-0.0063437782,
0.0065313308,
0.0123780975,
-0.0007670034,
0.0394848771,
0.0615269206,
0.0513117202,
0.0337088406,
-0.0683829859,
-0.0198645592,
-0.0062650726,
0.0191441644,
-0.0525070205,
0.1018455327,
-0.0055916985,
-0.0322198048,
-0.0014959837,
-0.0285131447,
-0.0244350731,
0.0167521928,
-0.0303270891,
-0.0262919907,
0.0391203351,
-0.0064814514,
0.003015975,
0.0089216745,
-0.0671550483,
-0.0108219497,
-0.0173098892,
-0.0310127437,
-0.0352695696,
-0.0175825134,
-0.0183441229,
-0.0311409626,
-0.0901116207,
0.0284535177,
2.23536322e-34,
-0.0040353774,
-0.0063526123,
0.020908244,
0.0220672395,
0.0191850718,
0.0058710659,
0.0117832683,
-0.0005482327,
0.0342199542,
-0.1126195043,
-0.0104389107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20649v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20649v1
|
Reward-based Input Construction for Cross-document Relation Extraction
| 2024-05-31T07:30:34 | 2024-05-31T07:30:34 |
Byeonghu Na, Suhyeon Jo, Yeongmin Kim, Il-Chul Moon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Relation extraction (RE) is a fundamental task in natural language
processing, aiming to identify relations between target entities in text. While
many RE methods are designed for a single sentence or document, cross-document
RE has emerged to address relations across multiple long documents. Given the
nature of long documents in cross-document RE, extracting document embeddings
is challenging due to the length constraints of pre-trained language models.
Therefore, we propose REward-based Input Construction (REIC), the first
learning-based sentence selector for cross-document RE. REIC extracts sentences
based on relational evidence, enabling the RE module to effectively infer
relations. Since supervision of evidence sentences is generally unavailable, we
train REIC using reinforcement learning with RE prediction scores as rewards.
Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our method over heuristic
methods for different RE structures and backbones in cross-document RE. Our
code is publicly available at https://github.com/aailabkaist/REIC.
|
[
0.0560253523,
0.0385788828,
0.0040443339,
0.0673027784,
-0.0134660136,
0.0106738908,
-0.0238669775,
-0.0106628975,
0.0244689547,
-0.0220077746,
-0.031501662,
0.0225462653,
-0.0308529045,
-0.0075400053,
-0.0383494273,
-0.0727994591,
0.027032692,
-0.0110405823,
0.0562596247,
0.0331452079,
0.0204211809,
0.0239912029,
0.0062448401,
0.0108932639,
-0.0596439838,
-0.0159777962,
0.0073058945,
-0.0122758774,
0.0206329543,
-0.0647409484,
0.0489883535,
0.0044407602,
0.0255620964,
-0.0078944983,
0.0000016533,
-0.0465767086,
-0.0406861939,
-0.0037059342,
-0.0236727186,
-0.0613240823,
0.0101999398,
-0.0404240489,
0.016308343,
-0.0023580096,
-0.0314164609,
-0.0530802011,
0.009866586,
0.1252175421,
0.0154705346,
0.0913892612,
-0.030031791,
-0.0299288761,
0.0327560119,
-0.0342684872,
0.0631169006,
0.0016464042,
0.0233146194,
0.0017731315,
0.0428388305,
-0.0067565395,
-0.0225744583,
-0.001352234,
0.0431681834,
-0.0480751731,
0.0269233473,
0.0503053069,
0.0228820108,
-0.0107681062,
-0.0329434648,
0.0799903721,
-0.002473471,
0.0366680399,
0.0447485596,
0.0059957793,
0.0085184304,
0.024680851,
-0.0102861356,
-0.0014453578,
-0.0341993049,
0.0126461396,
0.0638497695,
0.0275383107,
0.0316455737,
0.002683402,
-0.0134084364,
0.0426859222,
-0.0067357714,
-0.0660399273,
0.0423662886,
0.0498466007,
-0.0005900796,
-0.0366835818,
0.0221221317,
0.0186896436,
-0.034679085,
0.0150673287,
-0.0561114997,
-0.028598899,
-0.0109193828,
-0.012938912,
0.001234979,
-0.0261777136,
-0.0121666128,
0.070066005,
-0.0405701585,
0.0163146369,
-0.0415545739,
-0.0213057697,
0.0011569497,
0.0094229709,
-0.0285043549,
0.005294933,
-0.0165983047,
0.0509456545,
-0.0174291674,
-0.0513634086,
-0.0258532986,
0.0145692639,
-0.0150944134,
0.036093805,
0.025155725,
-0.0005868521,
-0.0353842415,
0.0045878217,
-0.0211295765,
-0.0212533306,
-0.0310741253,
-0.0012068916,
0.0040319273,
0.0197766945,
-0.0321805589,
-0.0068079578,
0.0373897441,
-0.0506730005,
-0.0128179891,
0.0853781328,
0.001895051,
-0.0498403721,
0.0094419327,
-0.0614155345,
-0.0014968137,
-0.0597437248,
0.0429199524,
-0.0135212345,
0.0360944718,
-0.0076341182,
-0.024752466,
-0.003006873,
0.0483732224,
-0.0043170536,
-0.0700486749,
0.0506173111,
0.023719253,
-0.0225725081,
-0.0115565807,
0.0111314598,
0.0191698633,
0.0748695806,
0.0508599542,
0.0452080928,
0.0625066683,
0.0484421067,
0.0084749116,
0.0043000341,
0.0271945857,
-0.0221657213,
0.0224833507,
0.0229127649,
0.0415911041,
0.0246083457,
0.0366276987,
0.0068343487,
-0.0458690487,
-0.0006639229,
0.0044810018,
0.0370330699,
0.0403464437,
0.0044328333,
0.0443795919,
0.0049080756,
-0.0040390491,
0.0321843214,
-0.0392890386,
0.0160487313,
0.0004638668,
0.0141538782,
-0.0162484348,
0.0105318362,
0.0006605657,
0.0027655989,
0.0057989359,
-0.0437370315,
-0.0132080019,
-0.0167245455,
0.0695078596,
0.0169753656,
-0.0431342386,
-0.017739322,
0.0325989984,
-0.032479696,
0.005611565,
0.0182698462,
0.0553179421,
0.0098847393,
0.0626790747,
-0.0587852262,
0.0126389153,
-0.0461294167,
-0.000075845,
0.0436621495,
0.0740181655,
-0.0381902084,
0.0193705074,
-0.0065131732,
-0.0553334132,
-0.0423690043,
-0.0015773154,
-0.0040858984,
0.068546392,
0.0270379372,
0.0226820279,
0.0165085979,
0.00964271,
0.0572891869,
-0.0128650675,
-0.036645405,
0.0251022968,
0.0376795456,
0.0187721625,
-0.006564274,
-0.0125229172,
-0.0201176945,
0.043779321,
-0.038245827,
0.0158478636,
0.0001044224,
-0.080354318,
-0.0633254126,
0.0050612208,
-0.0230443962,
-0.0284738466,
-0.0076891892,
-0.0177966058,
-0.0427629761,
0.0152834561,
-0.0271877833,
0.063648738,
0.0051430878,
-0.0052850246,
0.0267410912,
0.0240996834,
-0.0097582927,
0.075535588,
0.0241334289,
-0.0125407632,
-0.002248002,
-0.0815812349,
-0.009974841,
-0.010382575,
-0.003885288,
0.0023543544,
0.0036110939,
-0.0163375959,
0.0481934734,
0.0204360858,
-0.0419658311,
-0.0604605861,
-0.0109450296,
0.0300837681,
0.0045386683,
0.0567640699,
-0.0235025138,
0.0189198051,
-0.0186085533,
-0.0444852076,
-0.0342685357,
-0.0086487848,
0.014167117,
-0.0223371927,
0.0603328645,
0.0031894161,
0.0141153662,
-0.0218509976,
-0.0124919796,
-0.0173470415,
0.0617929138,
0.0427293815,
0.0226364192,
-0.0203467179,
0.0295678079,
0.0027862692,
0.0243833028,
0.0099708969,
-0.0057498324,
-0.012187575,
-0.0096506951,
0.0219946988,
0.0644460991,
-0.0271570552,
0.0613781512,
-0.0037908261,
-0.0050831474,
-0.0216363743,
0.0438700393,
-0.0384541638,
0.0747393072,
-0.0222959016,
0.021412259,
0.0004426474,
0.0605571307,
-0.0237491783,
0.0115087237,
0.001544021,
0.0111803468,
0.0360422879,
-0.0019021053,
-0.005272584,
-0.0168094207,
0.0291117653,
-0.0169690698,
-0.0611829348,
-0.0260120202,
0.0826290697,
-0.0089160316,
-0.0213224925,
-0.0579108782,
0.0021348093,
-0.042708341,
0.0541963615,
-0.0036862188,
-0.0184410047,
0.0195184033,
-0.0307519473,
-0.0149907842,
-0.0321480744,
0.0279525965,
-0.0100478521,
-0.0178997032,
-0.0207830165,
0.0014118063,
-0.0383282565,
-0.0549319349,
-0.0526818037,
-0.0112613263,
-0.0055727987,
0.0152021507,
-0.0294244941,
-0.0122288968,
-0.0009053258,
-0.0217088815,
0.0538061596,
0.0292781629,
-0.0502378084,
-0.0144269029,
-0.0268909149,
0.0828655511,
0.0700730607,
-0.0220581889,
-0.0143670719,
-0.0352592692,
0.0161690339,
0.0389880724,
-0.0080002323,
0.0071704541,
-0.0098503232,
0.009487262,
-0.0026878112,
-0.06283167,
0.0000085741,
-0.0352824479,
-0.0032936519,
-0.1071975008,
-0.0075365473,
0.0673232228,
0.0218267199,
-0.0568163507,
-0.0152704818,
0.0255874284,
0.0093036108,
0.0161087308,
0.0473601967,
-0.0690893531,
-0.0207607616,
0.0077853422,
-0.0430313237,
0.0032214073,
-0.0304484181,
0.0064436146,
-0.0807669237,
0.0091995783,
-0.0308179632,
-0.0263474584,
-0.0126778157,
-0.0438453741,
0.0153250108,
0.0373346284,
-0.0389730781,
0.0122845629,
-0.0458014011,
-0.0108491294,
-0.027814433,
0.013353019,
-0.0251309518,
-0.0144553976,
-0.0355903506,
-0.0152034387,
0.0695509017,
0.0450902767,
0.015361717,
-0.0012716592,
-0.0106839985,
-0.0228584949,
-0.0356353372,
-0.0188192707,
0.0867275968,
-0.0305935945,
-0.0085216183,
-0.0297197811,
0.0365438983,
-0.0499350764,
0.0059587876,
0.0270449314,
0.0945371315,
0.0088382829,
-0.0333856121,
-0.0225341804,
-0.0216048285,
0.0444988161,
0.0602206998,
0.0009480162,
-0.0217645038,
-0.1021506563,
-0.009217754,
-0.0085518258,
-0.0707625151,
0.0279586315,
-0.0261926521,
-0.0515394472,
0.0195206627,
-0.0665524453,
-0.070705846,
0.0365591533,
0.0035932702,
-0.0090074325,
-0.0184543636,
0.005641602,
-0.0100386459,
-0.0520359799,
-0.0067308675,
-0.0009937622,
0.0088274218,
-0.0035347559,
0.0440822169,
-0.0072750095,
-0.0344968177,
-0.008051591,
-0.067862913,
-0.0131907267,
-0.0219395626,
-0.0384551063,
0.0192132499,
0.0041686809,
0.0750270709,
-0.0249747448,
-0.0117904386,
0.0710661709,
0.0218852982,
-0.1049723923,
-0.0258687772,
0.054343842,
-0.0026347246,
0.0036109181,
0.0405323543,
-0.0472669229,
0.0270241313,
0.0361383669,
0.0170438904,
0.0197145287,
0.0060720416,
0.0057530324,
-0.0284154862,
0.0424715728,
0.0154505121,
0.0282818116,
-0.0631860793,
0.0346958935,
-0.0556452088,
-0.0153556187,
-0.0444524102,
0.0418712646,
0.0015386047,
0.0139881438,
-0.0105623007,
-0.0110035334,
-0.0070208558,
0.0419854932,
-0.0073551568,
0.0174178146,
0.0508211516,
0.0369973183,
0.0225182958,
-0.0075873663,
0.0095438138,
-0.0111106448,
-0.0009359923,
0.03456055,
-0.0341942981,
0.0376991518,
0.0458839238,
-0.046650935,
0.0001096033,
-0.0205812771,
-0.073256135,
0.0748442858,
-0.0109791392,
0.0107511617,
0.0514944978,
-0.0364185758,
0.036017172,
-0.0159547124,
-0.0098822732,
0.0420431569,
0.0409513898,
-0.0223248117,
0.0055934368,
0.0107699856,
0.008860467,
-0.0429042391,
0.0343643576,
0.0554444268,
-0.0033907329,
0.0343555883,
0.0326666348,
-0.0445144735,
-0.0553733781,
-0.0189082734,
0.0422050729,
0.0156591646,
-0.0288085751,
0.0252341051,
-0.0069063981,
-0.020142721,
0.0107271736,
0.0098865498,
-0.038783595,
0.0132221971,
0.0224528369,
0.037304353,
0.0236679576,
-0.0349065699,
-0.0529711023,
0.0340663642,
-0.0514126308,
-0.0602189153,
-0.0179820452,
-5.512294516e-33,
-0.0179242361,
-0.0024702686,
0.0045117489,
0.0334049687,
-0.0615201816,
0.0665176138,
-0.0430290811,
-0.0384934992,
0.009037056,
0.0571453124,
-0.0386214331,
0.0000303774,
0.0040895948,
0.0188889317,
-0.0101372488,
0.0043637725,
0.0259127449,
-0.021081008,
-0.004155641,
0.0454301536,
0.038300883,
0.0485411957,
0.0711309463,
-0.0721048191,
0.0369355828,
0.022227874,
0.0091074081,
0.0127055803,
0.0279810969,
0.0493363105,
-0.041229479,
-0.0156355426,
0.0191166867,
-0.009035795,
0.0216507819,
0.0753423721,
-0.1458462179,
-0.0415655822,
-0.0439215116,
-0.0308331028,
-0.0844370872,
-0.0279623624,
0.004666077,
-0.0012444303,
0.078513965,
-0.0414576754,
0.0442817807,
-0.0302933063,
-0.0328138694,
-0.0329697207,
-0.0732538924,
0.0216538999,
0.0148102678,
0.0004057349,
0.0590461344,
0.0366717763,
0.0416284725,
0.0127679063,
-0.0212708898,
-0.0288962349,
-0.04126288,
0.0277943201,
-0.018602699,
-0.0132408813,
-0.0063627074,
0.0611920096,
-0.0206628069,
-0.0260622259,
0.0061626546,
0.001491408,
-0.0058210557,
0.044777099,
-0.0192505065,
0.0369436145,
0.0348023362,
-0.0054329261,
-0.1198813468,
-0.0017100874,
0.0614385344,
0.0665123314,
-0.0140599729,
-0.011224879,
-0.0265348069,
0.0088202069,
0.0067694895,
-0.0260683503,
0.0067169182,
-0.043478895,
0.0171015728,
0.0706684813,
0.0005245982,
0.0120232096,
0.0012870207,
-0.0449606664,
-0.0172479935,
0.0609204434,
-0.029916333,
-0.01299999,
0.0196646173,
-0.0360475704,
-0.0633843541,
-0.0319071002,
0.0021822285,
-0.0274226908,
0.0063620522,
0.0185681526,
0.0565248989,
-0.0173576549,
-0.0645488948,
-0.0028641487,
-0.0397059098,
0.0268738512,
-0.034398865,
0.0283242688,
0.0035274727,
0.0238319244,
-0.0115305325,
0.0284700319,
0.0265131015,
0.0244299974,
-0.0434806943,
-0.0123586124,
-0.0008562104,
0.0366978906,
0.0053468966,
-0.0230624955,
-0.0195769463,
0.035692133,
0.0261709746,
-0.065083541,
0.0174819063,
0.0012569303,
2.417e-7,
-0.0098702125,
0.0154274488,
0.0649279431,
0.0247230399,
0.0385467485,
0.0385881364,
0.0209050793,
0.0564340986,
-0.023334885,
0.0217936207,
-0.0100944443,
-0.0105797704,
0.05415719,
0.0260631386,
-0.097992152,
-0.0373446494,
-0.0769934803,
-0.0722960159,
-0.0594124757,
-0.0628444701,
0.0339256935,
0.0325844251,
0.0596811548,
0.0114573278,
-0.0554769449,
-0.0184453726,
0.0524871349,
-0.0424495786,
-0.0130352592,
0.0245519429,
0.0327686779,
-0.0100947972,
-0.0410181843,
0.0047809486,
-0.0151028773,
0.0801647082,
-0.0175846778,
0.0441220291,
0.016387213,
0.0150100263,
0.0030970662,
-0.0125640957,
0.018886406,
-0.0023152111,
0.0505034514,
-0.0570507161,
0.0130975386,
-0.0438298211,
-0.0164222252,
-0.0429071188,
0.0257511083,
0.003536497,
-0.0154764242,
0.0356621258,
0.0331231765,
0.0152142998,
-0.0069567314,
-0.0750705004,
0.009386302,
0.0587348118,
0.0165433902,
0.0294819176,
-0.0167701021,
-0.0031928832,
-0.000165,
-0.0554776788,
0.0039636404,
2.172094992e-34,
-0.0044830535,
-0.0329826251,
-0.0185047332,
0.0162826404,
0.0467880666,
-0.0287479758,
-0.0298445951,
0.0040088794,
0.0275087953,
-0.0586322807,
0.0043101697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20648v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20648v1
|
Shotluck Holmes: A Family of Efficient Small-Scale Large Language Vision Models For Video Captioning and Summarization
| 2024-05-31T07:30:24 | 2024-05-31T07:30:24 |
Richard Luo, Austin Peng, Adithya Vasudev, Rishabh Jain
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Video is an increasingly prominent and information-dense medium, yet it poses
substantial challenges for language models. A typical video consists of a
sequence of shorter segments, or shots, that collectively form a coherent
narrative. Each shot is analogous to a word in a sentence where multiple data
streams of information (such as visual and auditory data) must be processed
simultaneously. Comprehension of the entire video requires not only
understanding the visual-audio information of each shot but also requires that
the model links the ideas between each shot to generate a larger,
all-encompassing story. Despite significant progress in the field, current
works often overlook videos' more granular shot-by-shot semantic information.
In this project, we propose a family of efficient large language vision models
(LLVMs) to boost video summarization and captioning called Shotluck Holmes. By
leveraging better pretraining and data collection strategies, we extend the
abilities of existing small LLVMs from being able to understand a picture to
being able to understand a sequence of frames. Specifically, we show that
Shotluck Holmes achieves better performance than state-of-the-art results on
the Shot2Story video captioning and summary task with significantly smaller and
more computationally efficient models.
|
[
0.0205316506,
0.0383490846,
0.0180878714,
0.0466987863,
0.0096986229,
0.0164222009,
0.0041803489,
-0.0330390297,
-0.0298841223,
-0.0774699748,
-0.0038547006,
-0.0416053683,
0.0075010187,
0.0343018733,
-0.0166014582,
-0.0847591236,
0.0296865255,
-0.0420437604,
0.02331632,
0.0088392086,
0.0186054111,
0.0330438353,
0.007729819,
0.030344082,
0.0037896775,
0.000960941,
0.0257728361,
-0.019049326,
0.0576773286,
-0.0383386351,
-0.0424444526,
0.0173115879,
0.0855807438,
0.0165206697,
0.0000016657,
-0.0230107661,
0.0186739285,
-0.0192666315,
0.0256263353,
0.04438686,
0.0253943279,
-0.0813448429,
0.006551194,
-0.0048794546,
-0.0232730843,
-0.0188947022,
0.0338653103,
0.0058999951,
0.0516451336,
0.0445387997,
-0.0322644301,
-0.1000678763,
0.0054382295,
-0.0406551622,
0.0502584837,
-0.030750664,
-0.0140438629,
0.0356664099,
0.0210615229,
-0.0150095383,
-0.0474201106,
0.0489383861,
-0.0141959563,
-0.0434477292,
-0.0049303342,
0.0441409834,
-0.059859056,
-0.012799128,
0.0070346505,
0.0849577636,
0.0025121167,
0.0408261716,
-0.0118368333,
-0.0009477398,
-0.0054843109,
-0.0457444228,
-0.0819390714,
0.0665215477,
0.027543813,
0.015856443,
-0.0258794893,
0.0296544116,
0.0202113893,
0.0058251973,
0.0088783158,
-0.0261185355,
0.0207504313,
0.0628572553,
-0.0671829954,
0.0008847894,
-0.0163372438,
-0.0605989583,
-0.0123937847,
0.035531424,
0.0097460411,
0.0024535363,
-0.0241312757,
-0.0029451821,
-0.0656757429,
-0.0343568213,
0.0404570624,
0.016333133,
-0.0101081319,
0.1139797047,
-0.0353272855,
0.0418722332,
-0.0087050702,
0.0135909375,
-0.0317828953,
-0.0109272879,
-0.0417807959,
0.021400474,
-0.0374393575,
0.0094987014,
-0.0285337847,
-0.0368440561,
-0.0161817819,
0.0056893248,
-0.0140015604,
0.0118799014,
-0.0532005131,
0.0192819908,
0.040447142,
-0.0413166918,
0.0032382635,
0.054124184,
-0.0389586352,
0.0040500709,
-0.0220296495,
-0.0207764767,
-0.024479527,
0.0391627029,
0.0153229441,
-0.0033192888,
0.0133862337,
0.0236384291,
-0.0345998742,
-0.0571026579,
-0.0056672515,
0.0271309391,
-0.0712142289,
-0.0457712151,
-0.008134596,
-0.0636707395,
0.0308460705,
-0.0162031464,
0.0008099985,
-0.0139278024,
0.0166034754,
0.000900918,
-0.049846597,
0.0864751413,
0.0037138881,
0.0290209744,
-0.0027817469,
0.0232047029,
0.0331209749,
0.0708278194,
0.0467574224,
0.0314315557,
0.0274911206,
0.0098240599,
0.0395524763,
0.0289078429,
-0.0291304681,
0.0296864528,
-0.0750471875,
-0.0127847437,
-0.0087116007,
0.0220437516,
0.0521637164,
0.0443447828,
-0.035428416,
0.0327473953,
0.0714188144,
0.0603677034,
-0.0352937207,
-0.051376719,
0.0571010746,
0.0330892578,
0.0230308622,
-0.0140309129,
-0.0155580286,
0.08316461,
0.0373519473,
0.0339932702,
0.0315614492,
0.0212226044,
-0.0765812173,
-0.0355544165,
-0.0229974613,
-0.0182230007,
-0.0126166446,
0.0159159414,
0.0204922538,
0.0189570934,
-0.0408733673,
0.0298183318,
0.0046060393,
-0.0270087682,
0.0545761585,
-0.0162852481,
0.0196710676,
0.0858691931,
0.0220033005,
-0.0227885991,
-0.0356486887,
-0.0158634521,
0.0372361243,
0.0394764952,
0.0360544324,
-0.02945555,
0.0426731743,
-0.0581620485,
-0.0367281809,
-0.0057722707,
0.009720101,
0.0004380413,
-0.0324945897,
-0.0087567437,
0.0186279453,
-0.0001201418,
-0.0448932983,
0.035354767,
0.0386284068,
-0.0255616307,
0.0103170546,
-0.0031225011,
0.013883858,
0.0319590941,
-0.0260672588,
-0.0180610213,
0.0106671453,
-0.0257863253,
0.0086155096,
0.0594401918,
-0.0568774715,
-0.0745927319,
0.0177197848,
-0.0445356891,
0.0148544358,
0.0048059016,
-0.0493458025,
-0.0558432601,
0.0297345035,
-0.037615113,
-0.0202180706,
-0.059812922,
-0.0000112333,
0.022766538,
0.0096614854,
-0.0134908715,
0.0214514006,
0.0093727056,
-0.037887767,
0.0315493792,
0.0043019364,
-0.0210241545,
-0.0140237175,
-0.0408844724,
0.0032562998,
0.0217870809,
-0.002879624,
0.042121049,
-0.0100507541,
-0.0277257394,
-0.0078449342,
-0.0861315206,
-0.0125734713,
-0.0160778593,
0.0024277261,
-0.0030491082,
0.0040884404,
0.0018300237,
-0.0483698957,
-0.0071074506,
0.0192605518,
0.028641114,
0.0075996798,
0.004100604,
0.0522490665,
-0.0057450174,
-0.0344434232,
-0.0005202995,
0.0278329067,
0.0429101363,
-0.0043379962,
-0.0361974761,
-0.0096423319,
-0.0240830723,
0.0090302378,
-0.0054322705,
-0.0246156435,
-0.0119842207,
-0.015111181,
-0.0011642264,
0.0242054407,
0.0476181991,
0.0179328993,
0.0093554379,
0.0306545775,
-0.0237280726,
0.0080557093,
0.0135047929,
0.0184977092,
-0.0308681726,
-0.0211052187,
-0.0042024343,
-0.0280406978,
0.0241310969,
-0.0144919902,
0.0436736345,
-0.0680467263,
0.0207244921,
0.0040322673,
-0.0017055091,
-0.0614711307,
-0.0329338685,
-0.0101998933,
0.0091504687,
-0.0371225178,
-0.0262761712,
-0.0032134289,
-0.0575460605,
-0.043389041,
-0.0040428895,
0.0120859677,
-0.0479349867,
0.1001417413,
0.028369369,
0.0262392424,
-0.0431692861,
-0.0193480104,
-0.0448036455,
-0.0226613395,
0.0239844844,
0.0098640779,
0.0604206584,
-0.0483201109,
-0.0048403046,
-0.0156632774,
-0.0012627761,
-0.0184755847,
-0.0449571721,
-0.0861788243,
-0.0014255478,
-0.0511408709,
-0.0086624864,
-0.0422070883,
0.0203446969,
0.0604413152,
0.0543943234,
-0.0169200301,
0.0213572867,
-0.0090524657,
0.0606705844,
0.0664387941,
0.0141216172,
-0.0155580323,
-0.0486931913,
0.0794887468,
0.0401916727,
0.0123063419,
0.0193827339,
-0.0087421145,
0.0264399387,
0.041394271,
0.0041160318,
-0.0175748207,
0.0179291945,
0.0660820529,
-0.0603164025,
0.0024563686,
0.1128254533,
0.0067365314,
-0.0302852895,
-0.0206589382,
0.031620685,
0.0096101789,
0.0466736518,
0.0032275892,
-0.0861307904,
-0.0572092347,
-0.0129595697,
-0.018863285,
0.0502359569,
0.0127881551,
-0.0614138134,
-0.0922798589,
0.0489536822,
0.0415364429,
-0.0609039478,
-0.0215942264,
0.0184822902,
-0.0049890461,
-0.0250304081,
-0.0070801098,
0.0151879536,
-0.0272686779,
-0.0068669929,
-0.0240765121,
0.0045802714,
-0.0166413318,
0.0393534824,
-0.0496734157,
0.0234385058,
0.0588729531,
0.0201015063,
-0.0301878005,
0.0313036107,
0.0033987637,
-0.0190386903,
0.0006243089,
0.0318238921,
0.0728624463,
-0.0506412424,
-0.0398941189,
0.0155738238,
0.0318173952,
0.0211058781,
-0.0489018075,
-0.0013747192,
0.0086023547,
0.0057873628,
-0.0126373516,
-0.01729073,
0.0564832874,
-0.037849348,
0.0800457895,
0.0270121451,
-0.0303709283,
0.0132750319,
0.0379268043,
-0.0513413027,
-0.0538522154,
-0.0421980508,
0.006887448,
0.0032748396,
-0.0186042748,
-0.0567662716,
-0.0330499224,
0.0715068504,
-0.0040370706,
-0.0242095646,
0.0124390572,
0.0031749604,
0.039376799,
-0.0739720315,
0.0543213151,
-0.0359543338,
-0.0073081069,
-0.0470094047,
0.0137570379,
0.0655044839,
-0.0322428159,
-0.0091000339,
0.0240304116,
-0.0917275473,
-0.0250612777,
-0.0396253094,
0.05800635,
0.0115074189,
0.0720741376,
0.0250565037,
-0.0296779089,
0.0283697508,
0.0069002039,
0.016585011,
0.0348033942,
-0.0012212453,
-0.0144117903,
-0.0422822349,
0.037541572,
-0.0403880067,
0.0365423299,
-0.0029062144,
0.023708066,
-0.0386198945,
0.0141509352,
-0.0218052417,
-0.0403955542,
0.0490534268,
-0.0438775308,
0.001424928,
-0.0310258139,
-0.0260523874,
-0.0161060747,
0.0033363684,
-0.0568374731,
0.0109466426,
0.0243029818,
-0.0016792044,
-0.0249939356,
0.0253355149,
-0.0044091269,
-0.0241474994,
-0.0345088169,
-0.0070590349,
-0.0249328706,
-0.0529324003,
-0.0090637747,
0.0230176914,
0.0057548499,
0.0526561923,
-0.0384287275,
-0.0078040059,
-0.0089028031,
0.014658059,
-0.0021020519,
-0.0257541984,
-0.0034747496,
0.0293582343,
-0.034938205,
0.0069568013,
-0.0356435813,
0.0526484251,
0.0640858114,
-0.053157527,
0.0104015302,
0.0261726864,
-0.0081957495,
-0.0409028865,
0.0281769242,
-0.005593576,
-0.0640580952,
0.0238663498,
0.0137089873,
-0.0044125225,
0.0108653046,
0.0769984424,
0.0031330718,
0.0160288848,
0.0333951302,
0.0329934061,
-0.021164652,
-0.007359385,
-0.0104784248,
0.0244905427,
-0.0351545326,
0.0300063565,
-0.0307173785,
-0.029858632,
0.012765374,
-0.0169133507,
-0.0115529746,
0.0300624035,
0.0539486371,
-0.0000346942,
0.0225464031,
-0.0117050465,
-0.0079734456,
-0.0451131873,
-0.0277914144,
0.0013812344,
0.0264905114,
-5.135203275e-33,
-0.0445326529,
-0.016091235,
0.0114539573,
0.0044893334,
-0.0339193195,
0.0294178445,
-0.0295079481,
0.0480769835,
-0.0231842138,
0.0173564721,
0.0290243439,
0.0400281735,
0.0136524001,
0.0556368455,
0.0177977644,
-0.0228068288,
0.0507987775,
-0.0182788204,
-0.0228656791,
0.0070544821,
0.002465795,
0.0017344091,
0.0589494072,
-0.0030657889,
-0.0212967824,
-0.0315394774,
-0.0390163809,
0.0203249138,
0.0570939332,
0.0537892096,
-0.0061021294,
-0.0116404677,
0.0064038052,
-0.0191917736,
-0.0635886267,
0.0157187749,
-0.0533973575,
0.0085523715,
0.0398080014,
0.0333459713,
-0.0493989959,
-0.0102620134,
0.0389796905,
-0.0265616365,
0.0045102676,
-0.0555072799,
0.0392012782,
-0.0560821295,
0.0214455277,
-0.0042566028,
-0.0387756862,
0.014102635,
-0.0317374058,
-0.0591493063,
0.0618595146,
-0.0082206959,
0.0266572218,
-0.0025354375,
-0.0081496648,
0.0322275832,
-0.0183703061,
0.0604427569,
0.0829785615,
0.0333327316,
-0.013279886,
0.0731626526,
0.0151613755,
-0.0716353133,
-0.0518646203,
0.0052128457,
0.0042615021,
0.0344521888,
0.0245897975,
0.0469225645,
0.0164871383,
0.0304641109,
-0.0510070771,
0.0207015537,
-0.048080124,
0.0512473397,
0.0178804714,
0.0280312169,
0.0274735857,
0.009421248,
-0.05678178,
0.0010545298,
-0.0262290444,
0.0103967106,
-0.0061041075,
0.0124117555,
0.0014308728,
-0.0142396856,
0.0928792208,
-0.0343399644,
0.0459915958,
0.0503242277,
-0.0329496861,
0.0573046207,
0.0140788956,
0.0271677952,
-0.0349979959,
0.0125445379,
0.0491873734,
0.0116066225,
-0.0035521905,
0.0127985422,
0.0354969949,
0.0277804509,
-0.0346794613,
-0.0079456614,
-0.0023218929,
-0.0021014728,
-0.04843596,
0.0442928113,
0.0194314271,
0.0502598323,
-0.0422550477,
0.0605029799,
-0.0437092669,
-0.0224235002,
0.0127900122,
-0.0141933076,
-0.0024470037,
0.031110812,
-0.0262303427,
0.0592681579,
-0.0137887588,
-0.0222275704,
0.0301283523,
-0.0541165248,
-0.0383561067,
0.0395199247,
2.271e-7,
0.0194567367,
0.0222441666,
0.0288909078,
0.025306426,
-0.004764948,
0.032498803,
-0.0116197076,
0.0370286033,
0.0147080831,
-0.0395489819,
0.0530632697,
0.074282825,
0.0403284989,
-0.0314237848,
-0.0705001503,
0.0243641082,
-0.0769910812,
-0.0051247966,
-0.0300917607,
-0.0412926301,
0.0382691994,
0.1046958491,
-0.0065062325,
-0.0190283433,
0.0148243029,
-0.0804784521,
0.0806029513,
-0.0059818635,
-0.0413075984,
0.0107128872,
-0.035415329,
0.0475200191,
-0.0340875462,
-0.019089289,
-0.0003452525,
-0.0023961584,
0.0621122569,
0.0480014756,
-0.0287525915,
-0.0096193533,
-0.0416010916,
0.0448597893,
-0.0259085633,
0.0032802636,
0.0692330748,
-0.0524950624,
-0.0073144273,
-0.0256495997,
-0.0179639757,
0.0108904215,
-0.0061617121,
-0.018110998,
-0.0387365483,
0.025085602,
0.0362096615,
-0.0225053728,
-0.0418224484,
-0.1037776992,
-0.0158655569,
-0.0071565975,
-0.0009135696,
0.0077116503,
-0.0314273089,
-0.0296917614,
0.0225238334,
-0.034218248,
-0.0511538275,
1.496169898e-34,
0.0503987223,
-0.0204190835,
-0.0322744772,
-0.0387780555,
-0.002229186,
0.0111316163,
-0.0495685674,
-0.0228644684,
0.0167294424,
-0.0685342923,
-0.0105537791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20646v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20646v1
|
Large Language Models Enhanced Sequential Recommendation for Long-tail User and Item
| 2024-05-31T07:24:42 | 2024-05-31T07:24:42 |
Qidong Liu, Xian Wu, Xiangyu Zhao, Yejing Wang, Zijian Zhang, Feng Tian, Yefeng Zheng
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Sequential recommendation systems (SRS) serve the purpose of predicting
users' subsequent preferences based on their past interactions and have been
applied across various domains such as e-commerce and social networking
platforms. However, practical SRS encounters challenges due to the fact that
most users engage with only a limited number of items, while the majority of
items are seldom consumed. These challenges, termed as the long-tail user and
long-tail item dilemmas, often create obstacles for traditional SRS methods.
Mitigating these challenges is crucial as they can significantly impact user
satisfaction and business profitability. While some research endeavors have
alleviated these issues, they still grapple with issues such as seesaw or noise
stemming from the scarcity of interactions. The emergence of large language
models (LLMs) presents a promising avenue to address these challenges from a
semantic standpoint. In this study, we introduce the Large Language Models
Enhancement framework for Sequential Recommendation (LLM-ESR), which leverages
semantic embeddings from LLMs to enhance SRS performance without increasing
computational overhead. To combat the long-tail item challenge, we propose a
dual-view modeling approach that fuses semantic information from LLMs with
collaborative signals from traditional SRS. To address the long-tail user
challenge, we introduce a retrieval augmented self-distillation technique to
refine user preference representations by incorporating richer interaction data
from similar users. Through comprehensive experiments conducted on three
authentic datasets using three widely used SRS models, our proposed enhancement
framework demonstrates superior performance compared to existing methodologies.
|
[
0.0313639194,
0.0713421702,
-0.0115311537,
0.0345887169,
0.0084495405,
-0.0288905948,
-0.005136787,
-0.0241423324,
0.0403595269,
-0.0092238281,
-0.0346285552,
-0.0259682834,
-0.0359417908,
0.043885421,
-0.0398841873,
-0.0339168645,
0.0071011153,
-0.0254180934,
-0.0168726929,
-0.0176421124,
0.0351411328,
0.0111134341,
0.0558255278,
0.0137101738,
0.0468615629,
-0.0027517441,
-0.0010727512,
-0.0190127566,
-0.0047378056,
-0.0591478087,
0.0167414099,
0.042878896,
0.0525309853,
-0.0003165343,
0.0000023962,
-0.0510942899,
-0.0181636773,
-0.0212917216,
-0.0252542328,
-0.0013395546,
0.0374602899,
0.0646246225,
0.0623637512,
-0.0169444121,
-0.0446698591,
0.0168346632,
0.0213580038,
0.0650018007,
0.0296458229,
-0.0054016132,
-0.014198578,
-0.0231243055,
0.0038060492,
-0.0583658181,
0.0708657503,
-0.0325231254,
0.0280795917,
-0.0429058857,
-0.0024524091,
0.0141047547,
0.0065143127,
-0.006170813,
0.0134223662,
0.0206104629,
0.0248380061,
0.0332685411,
0.0319135524,
0.0037846148,
-0.0031153439,
0.0601469688,
-0.021078445,
0.0155216437,
-0.0103032356,
0.0150617175,
-0.0056374995,
0.0180240534,
-0.056781292,
-0.0490605719,
0.0231906362,
0.0536846407,
-0.0042908401,
0.0350409932,
0.0304766782,
0.0354619734,
-0.0314117707,
0.068250984,
0.0025510215,
-0.0261976961,
-0.0098361121,
-0.0212870184,
0.0099176913,
-0.0309546776,
0.011147745,
-0.0181159321,
-0.0346050225,
-0.004217668,
0.0319211185,
0.070239827,
0.0039474429,
-0.0211690962,
0.0521257259,
0.0167306978,
-0.0033732327,
0.05084664,
0.0133873727,
0.0013480373,
-0.012108814,
-0.0449800417,
-0.0621399768,
0.0144227613,
-0.01975137,
-0.0106110927,
0.0215442572,
0.0431311838,
-0.0333355963,
-0.0368371643,
-0.0603347719,
0.0432377495,
-0.0074482239,
-0.0043755998,
0.0177756641,
0.0734958649,
-0.0007753845,
0.0253039729,
-0.0803221464,
0.0405681953,
-0.0257702172,
-0.0064696986,
0.0164683517,
0.0300463662,
0.0168514047,
-0.0068887779,
0.0063907718,
-0.0466667898,
-0.0027831842,
0.0230812952,
0.0242822673,
-0.0454279631,
-0.0318444967,
-0.0620167628,
-0.0162484981,
-0.0502429791,
-0.0354768112,
-0.0796525329,
0.04726284,
0.0173975453,
0.005009884,
-0.0657915622,
0.0066975113,
0.0031401191,
-0.0279900674,
0.0630056038,
0.0393259674,
-0.0160851143,
-0.0246785432,
0.0200372264,
0.050357908,
0.0079438835,
-0.0333886147,
0.0815836787,
0.0579317324,
-0.0025682703,
-0.0320277959,
0.0028709781,
-0.0090160752,
0.0170232132,
-0.0818191841,
0.0165172648,
-0.0389903188,
-0.0196619183,
0.0420401208,
0.0446704663,
-0.0607751571,
-0.0182891469,
0.0630057007,
0.0469279401,
0.0166834816,
0.0338099711,
0.0258168001,
0.0306909643,
-0.0517852269,
-0.0111894915,
0.0212845132,
0.0365429521,
0.0394132584,
-0.0356290042,
0.0690259561,
0.0334976874,
-0.0557006337,
-0.0366582461,
0.0507968627,
-0.0500386581,
0.0505272374,
0.0602409765,
0.0319621265,
-0.0347937793,
0.0003782221,
0.0175427943,
0.0361815691,
-0.0296498518,
0.0166942999,
-0.0067679472,
0.0523236357,
0.1265145689,
0.0477816649,
-0.0284200944,
0.0161842927,
0.0021566441,
-0.0364515856,
-0.0573697351,
0.0417638272,
-0.028923627,
-0.0021145029,
-0.0123364748,
-0.0680666193,
0.0276908055,
-0.0189760923,
0.0317105651,
-0.0093370955,
0.015021557,
0.0257692691,
-0.0076350723,
0.0110869082,
-0.0219981819,
-0.0460017659,
-0.0049721678,
0.0435457639,
0.0155745065,
0.0493395291,
0.0282377265,
0.0381823964,
-0.0017507767,
0.0504521541,
-0.0451560244,
-0.0257821828,
-0.0289344713,
-0.0207004473,
-0.0045429533,
0.068020016,
0.0287563987,
0.030839825,
0.0669177845,
-0.0050336318,
-0.0346733257,
0.0120779462,
0.0053675021,
0.0471620113,
-0.0342929214,
0.0043441011,
-0.0003006539,
0.025441777,
-0.0382134207,
0.020969389,
-0.0282152072,
0.0264433958,
-0.0375726111,
-0.0700992122,
0.0024274485,
-0.0184555352,
-0.0505747199,
0.0052450523,
0.0292354822,
0.0242626369,
0.0735120997,
-0.0154250329,
-0.0315284915,
0.0046982812,
-0.0628137663,
0.0035791809,
0.0268573947,
0.008852805,
-0.0299323127,
0.0448930413,
0.0230707899,
-0.0277149249,
-0.0347201824,
-0.0021291687,
-0.0063740104,
0.0349115469,
-0.0002779367,
0.0336795524,
-0.0217733867,
-0.0501516424,
-0.036101643,
0.0049952972,
0.035049513,
-0.0502230301,
0.0107878903,
-0.0304369647,
-0.0666437745,
-0.0792684183,
-0.0169868879,
-0.0225174557,
0.0349941142,
-0.0281733107,
-0.0510919169,
0.0645067394,
0.0146681815,
0.0217634048,
0.0435978919,
0.039015159,
-0.0191410556,
-0.0776771978,
-0.0205385704,
-0.07042142,
0.0170808546,
-0.028032979,
0.0058938153,
-0.0126879439,
0.0136694824,
-0.0352759436,
-0.0103586828,
-0.0194801912,
0.012168644,
0.0166366734,
-0.0040673185,
-0.0439181179,
0.0057186144,
-0.0178927965,
0.0513389036,
0.0088753877,
-0.0362353846,
0.0769275129,
-0.0012813152,
0.0276796632,
0.0029058105,
-0.0389807262,
-0.0440466851,
0.0252253227,
0.0194395389,
0.0157762561,
-0.0704460889,
0.0023534794,
-0.0157201774,
0.0077438243,
-0.0103222784,
-0.0590224899,
0.0382617675,
0.0405957811,
-0.0213053823,
0.0194796491,
-0.048071824,
-0.0331929252,
-0.1015982479,
0.0011160583,
-0.0278876945,
0.0087164277,
0.0070947111,
-0.0519788973,
-0.0007371273,
-0.0341709144,
0.0303219911,
0.0094615892,
-0.0201425795,
0.0125513393,
0.0193057396,
0.0633382425,
-0.0617877468,
0.0103221387,
-0.0216341745,
0.0455531217,
0.0377318412,
0.0374847874,
-0.0608843379,
-0.0277014226,
0.0034998544,
0.0638892576,
-0.0164082348,
-0.0004433396,
0.0580218174,
-0.0338360444,
0.0070647942,
0.0198561661,
0.1012710109,
0.0198554583,
-0.0892842636,
0.0188912805,
0.0037848512,
0.0422106199,
0.0355972834,
0.0322863571,
-0.0420157127,
-0.0132311042,
0.0024766435,
0.0421856344,
0.0542626865,
-0.0462029167,
-0.0157288089,
-0.0859471262,
0.0229023006,
0.0172055252,
0.013396523,
0.0325786807,
-0.0609967299,
0.0100580221,
-0.0151871964,
0.0214037858,
0.012888588,
-0.0175565444,
0.0054868287,
-0.0157651659,
-0.01642696,
-0.0127013624,
0.0617963038,
-0.0270584244,
0.0028918658,
0.0068408572,
0.0239432119,
0.0157245528,
0.0059760907,
0.0012370225,
-0.0088978009,
-0.0178357605,
0.0011562674,
0.0554794185,
-0.02813619,
0.0284880716,
-0.0334184878,
0.0227133017,
-0.0441570729,
-0.0256754234,
-0.0404009894,
0.0572374538,
-0.0127312392,
-0.0211190917,
-0.0453591384,
-0.0386957824,
0.0012685801,
0.0542299859,
-0.0105366157,
-0.0738139302,
0.0061892211,
-0.0170756448,
-0.0253165439,
0.0414325856,
-0.0418807529,
-0.0172872152,
0.0056865118,
-0.0311964341,
-0.0383547693,
-0.0556813776,
-0.0279358551,
0.0050713639,
-0.0291716997,
0.0791321769,
-0.0056390841,
-0.0270512737,
-0.0111471042,
0.0193942599,
-0.0348557271,
0.0187117122,
-0.050222218,
0.0557053722,
0.0126011968,
-0.0508661568,
-0.0189023651,
-0.0329887047,
-0.0682975724,
-0.0458246917,
-0.0251585022,
0.049734991,
0.0141701801,
0.0472813435,
-0.0161236208,
-0.0782708377,
0.0181314871,
0.0426700078,
-0.0208018161,
-0.0426298045,
-0.0210695211,
0.0319987871,
-0.0045729177,
0.044110138,
-0.0187925007,
0.0200509746,
-0.0334867872,
0.008983749,
-0.0212859046,
-0.0687278956,
0.0256098639,
0.001239885,
0.0676538646,
0.0064758742,
0.0481613576,
-0.0200287793,
0.0031598038,
-0.0182761028,
-0.0480789207,
-0.0530035943,
-0.0122466348,
0.0451367386,
-0.0164457951,
-0.0331266858,
-0.0131205441,
0.0090816347,
0.0273147337,
-0.077823624,
0.0100283446,
-0.0291827656,
-0.0270891432,
0.020214716,
0.0219383501,
0.0223058164,
-0.0183584914,
-0.0044490364,
0.0244041719,
-0.0385914408,
0.0321755558,
-0.0196581669,
0.0348631404,
-0.0329340249,
0.0549431108,
-0.0218176115,
-0.0542090423,
0.0005079486,
-0.0279372055,
0.0172555558,
-0.058027178,
0.0605113357,
-0.0153285647,
-0.005816198,
-0.0585580692,
0.0046477974,
-0.0512242913,
-0.0254451409,
-0.0011653039,
0.0579981171,
-0.0258349087,
0.0361438021,
0.0912264138,
-0.0118239885,
-0.019098023,
-0.0112521527,
-0.0601543784,
-0.0260113645,
-0.0338457748,
0.0210834183,
0.049299933,
-0.0432046577,
-0.0214445293,
-0.0231445599,
-0.056415692,
0.0165842343,
-0.0354259647,
-0.0199287646,
-0.0205457248,
0.0335285217,
0.0480238982,
-0.0043143514,
0.0321030132,
-0.0515320338,
-0.0132994652,
-0.0357205682,
-0.0482431427,
0.0053099673,
-6.702337446e-33,
0.0459722653,
-0.0113742277,
0.0064221937,
0.0061209709,
-0.0238066763,
-0.0141884601,
0.005760151,
-0.0010819999,
0.0505996905,
-0.0076263901,
-0.0090967501,
-0.0257236548,
0.0026088485,
0.0194980446,
0.0316425152,
0.0060826014,
0.0538056046,
0.0342612714,
0.0077996771,
0.0390808582,
0.0625941083,
0.0568849631,
-0.0068891244,
-0.069350265,
0.0098642353,
0.0030190186,
0.0407686904,
0.009376416,
0.070120059,
0.0620970018,
-0.0180267897,
0.0749083608,
0.0189291295,
-0.0426262915,
-0.0133064184,
0.0173488576,
-0.0814770162,
0.0022532037,
0.0129300756,
-0.0179702323,
-0.018004667,
0.0073076813,
-0.003024319,
-0.0146889212,
0.0201170836,
0.027962178,
0.0191891436,
-0.0076660328,
-0.0460117199,
-0.002597786,
0.0190469325,
0.009750193,
-0.0276065711,
-0.0087833581,
0.0778038129,
0.0325558558,
0.0000943502,
0.0545622334,
-0.0566368252,
0.041690588,
-0.0873670727,
0.0210584644,
0.0156249367,
-0.018238388,
-0.0075695487,
0.0575125217,
-0.0020691315,
-0.0092733437,
0.0293395072,
-0.0055526979,
-0.019509444,
0.0650166273,
-0.039736405,
0.0103151929,
0.0498176888,
-0.028200075,
-0.0377874076,
0.0546022877,
0.0507445149,
0.0219889563,
0.0442617685,
0.0442393981,
-0.0098003335,
-0.0433550365,
-0.0157580823,
0.0180588569,
-0.0332912281,
-0.0494755954,
0.0366392769,
0.0446796529,
-0.0323218927,
-0.0043332116,
0.0481152572,
-0.0473089479,
-0.084585309,
0.0193357076,
-0.0186004303,
-0.0444488116,
0.023056563,
0.0104614636,
-0.0428911038,
0.0166060217,
-0.0215376578,
-0.096112825,
-0.0471434109,
-0.0137658548,
0.026578676,
0.0116765127,
-0.0289913341,
-0.0044769463,
0.0220650621,
-0.0470631011,
-0.0194238666,
0.0255700685,
0.0725885928,
0.0401789509,
-0.0201948993,
0.102758415,
0.0576981008,
0.0089168642,
-0.0462628752,
-0.045353312,
0.0334535316,
-0.0348690003,
0.0189935099,
-0.0104508298,
-0.0470010675,
0.0001677596,
0.0407451391,
-0.0375692584,
-0.0259452201,
-0.0049604271,
3.094e-7,
0.0097387396,
0.0332642756,
-0.0124952607,
0.0073140259,
0.0106690209,
0.0213110317,
0.031193763,
0.0221426599,
0.0276962686,
0.0070934007,
0.0412041545,
0.0386815891,
-0.0132200802,
0.0153812235,
-0.0312007964,
0.0164308138,
-0.0611028038,
-0.0079459855,
-0.0553855635,
-0.0347524509,
0.0144954249,
0.0808806196,
0.0519782715,
-0.0114762187,
0.006557934,
0.0086247576,
0.0663736612,
-0.0696797743,
-0.0161276367,
-0.0128706126,
-0.0136025744,
-0.0059591783,
-0.011388069,
-0.0387393869,
-0.0118551943,
0.0393071882,
0.0083937477,
0.0207952596,
-0.0055317581,
-0.0333705284,
0.0041933609,
0.0262818243,
0.0077107148,
-0.0352378078,
0.0752917677,
-0.0522341318,
-0.0166373942,
0.0152369402,
-0.0429037735,
0.0015076513,
0.0442938395,
0.0152983386,
-0.000663518,
0.0044100522,
0.021863915,
0.0087745003,
-0.0038390676,
-0.0765165612,
-0.0094451886,
0.0070048184,
-0.04845066,
-0.0128328959,
-0.0585625321,
0.0304892249,
-0.0171439126,
-0.0271259639,
0.0188368838,
2.96990186e-34,
0.0284873042,
0.0428043492,
0.0208762921,
-0.02012912,
0.023940511,
-0.004591946,
-0.0432233252,
0.0323062278,
0.0466741547,
-0.0644035414,
-0.0341941342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20628v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20628v1
|
ToxVidLLM: A Multimodal LLM-based Framework for Toxicity Detection in Code-Mixed Videos
| 2024-05-31T05:40:56 | 2024-05-31T05:40:56 |
Krishanu Maity, A. S. Poornash, Sriparna Saha, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In an era of rapidly evolving internet technology, the surge in multimodal
content, including videos, has expanded the horizons of online communication.
However, the detection of toxic content in this diverse landscape, particularly
in low-resource code-mixed languages, remains a critical challenge. While
substantial research has addressed toxic content detection in textual data, the
realm of video content, especially in non-English languages, has been
relatively underexplored. This paper addresses this research gap by introducing
a benchmark dataset, the first of its kind, consisting of 931 videos with 4021
code-mixed Hindi-English utterances collected from YouTube. Each utterance
within this dataset has been meticulously annotated for toxicity, severity, and
sentiment labels. We have developed an advanced Multimodal Multitask framework
built for Toxicity detection in Video Content by leveraging Large Language
Models (LLMs), crafted for the primary objective along with the additional
tasks of conducting sentiment and severity analysis. ToxVidLLM incorporates
three key modules the Encoder module, Cross-Modal Synchronization module, and
Multitask module crafting a generic multimodal LLM customized for intricate
video classification tasks. Our experiments reveal that incorporating multiple
modalities from the videos substantially enhances the performance of toxic
content detection by achieving an Accuracy and Weighted F1 score of 94.29% and
94.35%, respectively.
|
[
0.0229054596,
0.056458883,
-0.0291226543,
0.0148539823,
0.0034402532,
0.046282202,
-0.0047023678,
0.0348919705,
0.01927278,
-0.0726473331,
-0.0519137122,
-0.019523317,
-0.0404925272,
0.0549788065,
0.0209011119,
-0.017209487,
0.0279584751,
0.0151877739,
0.0095865289,
0.0328114815,
0.061139822,
0.0320491679,
0.0060181022,
0.0211290922,
-0.0664327443,
-0.0271242335,
0.0205579232,
0.0143724652,
0.0735637993,
-0.041984614,
0.0247970074,
0.0234729871,
0.039602384,
0.0360373333,
0.0000019066,
-0.008194373,
0.025356086,
-0.0081301406,
0.0339479223,
-0.0260540042,
0.0884303749,
-0.0336168073,
-0.021822108,
0.0301652085,
-0.0380020924,
0.0227116104,
0.0988911614,
-0.0106666293,
0.0921751037,
0.0483745188,
-0.0492251366,
-0.0004046861,
0.0237644073,
0.0369742997,
-0.0002275415,
0.0258516856,
0.0466846228,
0.0396817178,
0.0151944822,
-0.0010947373,
-0.05501296,
0.0123930452,
-0.0003011637,
-0.0419731103,
-0.0220010318,
-0.0409912914,
0.0105945338,
-0.0803935528,
0.0366670825,
0.0668060929,
-0.0699806735,
0.0099624461,
-0.0041088504,
0.0070349532,
-0.0373200327,
-0.0255326051,
-0.0224273372,
0.0497943573,
-0.0125013832,
0.0421126783,
0.0040143607,
0.0158159249,
0.0266591031,
0.0292880759,
0.0722484067,
-0.0120734256,
0.0032070256,
-0.0150311552,
-0.0011826184,
-0.0092186201,
0.0007527251,
0.0065311962,
0.0221592933,
-0.0252727959,
-0.026795987,
0.0136283599,
-0.0491719991,
-0.0602260828,
0.0219634771,
-0.1240339726,
0.0207673125,
0.0199641418,
-0.0770575926,
0.0232727844,
0.0033926505,
-0.0005415229,
0.0003417662,
0.040859241,
-0.0200700331,
-0.0127086602,
-0.0100084431,
0.019452773,
0.0287384577,
-0.0032016735,
0.0166967586,
0.0208421815,
-0.0605404228,
0.0374322124,
-0.0818959177,
-0.0134647042,
-0.0074991439,
-0.0186726619,
0.0013375495,
0.034857396,
0.0103981327,
0.0135054374,
0.0020620944,
0.0592485592,
-0.0358853973,
-0.0483357646,
0.018525213,
0.0431599468,
-0.0490049757,
-0.0401351303,
0.0382386595,
0.092764549,
0.012426801,
-0.011914541,
-0.0309078991,
-0.0254307166,
-0.0447491445,
0.0018975751,
-0.0229249876,
-0.0625090823,
0.0260671526,
-0.0036590851,
0.0040338375,
-0.0488331094,
0.0104931593,
-0.006965817,
-0.0354210362,
0.0712629184,
-0.0074485368,
-0.008115083,
0.0231224764,
0.0348131768,
-0.0056811734,
0.0826174244,
0.020988008,
0.0408545062,
0.0293525141,
-0.0232155304,
0.0006217147,
0.0481223837,
-0.0335797891,
0.0329392403,
-0.0712611377,
-0.0195191,
0.0105180237,
-0.0233759265,
0.0201733112,
0.0223667603,
0.0032401914,
-0.0082165878,
0.0622710399,
-0.0064156326,
-0.0398285128,
0.0123282,
0.0436205901,
0.0181745887,
-0.0347669981,
-0.0330681019,
-0.0263734087,
0.0357037559,
-0.0137505764,
-0.0418451279,
0.0562441163,
0.0678671524,
-0.0267501306,
-0.0139256259,
-0.0241650268,
-0.0326357782,
0.046344433,
-0.0252669565,
0.0455040596,
-0.0018314812,
-0.0273541249,
0.0037333672,
0.059177909,
-0.0265873112,
0.0207322333,
-0.0235139243,
0.0346882418,
0.0727671161,
-0.0024527197,
-0.0304519758,
-0.0093919095,
-0.0574900284,
0.0015488567,
-0.0320180655,
-0.0664528981,
-0.0038590499,
0.0247983895,
-0.0276791714,
-0.0491688773,
0.0012308961,
-0.009464507,
-0.0297399331,
-0.0269301683,
0.0594279468,
-0.0084248586,
0.0152886473,
-0.0332326256,
0.015512214,
0.0592866093,
0.0105633009,
-0.0338324718,
0.0446471907,
0.082333684,
-0.0189661533,
-0.0226165038,
-0.0567012802,
0.040364895,
-0.0397125222,
-0.0227396861,
0.0128549179,
0.0025940293,
-0.019691512,
0.0372576155,
-0.0691091269,
-0.0017398983,
0.0645559281,
-0.0431571566,
0.0164798889,
0.0417764485,
-0.0513275079,
-0.008181368,
-0.0482699871,
-0.0161936935,
-0.0142462477,
0.035000395,
0.0174210686,
0.0379702188,
-0.0143828131,
-0.0230568312,
-0.0150304707,
-0.0156486295,
-0.0055974307,
0.0185839683,
-0.0558238477,
-0.0137851853,
-0.0332073234,
0.0312232804,
0.0035017449,
0.0252469201,
-0.0296219178,
-0.0314311869,
-0.0845380947,
-0.0208795685,
-0.0198113415,
-0.0064879684,
0.0058805565,
0.0194198918,
-0.0053648832,
0.0007010209,
-0.0056351074,
-0.0183322243,
0.0325822532,
0.0412237905,
-0.0136902612,
-0.0226451792,
-0.000169487,
0.0091025401,
-0.0190367382,
-0.0221882146,
0.0487552024,
-0.0290700532,
-0.089304477,
0.0198581666,
-0.0014230277,
-0.0124369133,
0.0127669694,
0.0021782813,
-0.0696184561,
0.0098107317,
0.0171752218,
-0.0033471421,
0.0411005765,
0.0395531058,
0.0677646399,
0.0401464328,
-0.0002230451,
-0.0179154966,
0.0102212755,
0.0090687238,
-0.0482552685,
-0.0208017062,
-0.0599514805,
-0.0370384417,
0.0378836058,
-0.0029247464,
0.0115485638,
-0.0289180335,
-0.0057000322,
-0.0277379714,
-0.0120022958,
-0.0045899972,
-0.0752401724,
-0.0047504497,
-0.006169559,
0.0014065542,
-0.0741959512,
0.045335196,
0.0117452759,
0.0062057939,
0.0109335706,
-0.0170863941,
-0.0146493176,
0.0234213509,
-0.0043203165,
0.0509682,
-0.009300421,
-0.0167795438,
-0.0164310206,
0.0021408079,
0.0220302437,
-0.0175858531,
0.0261597931,
-0.0256759524,
-0.0103178713,
0.0089789517,
-0.0534788594,
-0.0290464088,
-0.0476700664,
-0.0253091566,
-0.0339790881,
-0.0011996635,
0.0094598047,
-0.0083826799,
0.0385245234,
-0.0032376407,
-0.0726000071,
0.0295555666,
0.0151739167,
0.0243510325,
0.010196683,
0.0708597079,
-0.0464634262,
-0.0118807303,
-0.009981594,
0.0264221691,
0.0626863092,
-0.0331574902,
-0.0068133259,
-0.0236181878,
0.046568457,
0.0136834318,
0.0604467317,
0.0109047536,
0.0046570916,
0.0124001019,
-0.0086433468,
0.0238454062,
0.0465853885,
-0.0104347253,
-0.0583692342,
0.0117021222,
-0.0087909633,
-0.0253098886,
0.0344415754,
-0.0170472935,
-0.0805305019,
-0.026836561,
-0.0324229635,
-0.0079235034,
-0.0499625579,
-0.0194836911,
0.0292647369,
-0.075950861,
0.0153397694,
0.0277376361,
-0.0307611339,
-0.0249996353,
-0.0072082873,
-0.0106621832,
-0.0441867448,
0.0250280537,
-0.0454781055,
0.0020419406,
-0.0496454798,
0.0105774095,
-0.0137314256,
-0.0394226275,
0.0352018028,
-0.0350480005,
0.0557518527,
0.0232877824,
0.0311150048,
-0.0774675161,
-0.0359159894,
0.026182007,
-0.0037642282,
-0.0237761904,
-0.014234174,
0.0296955016,
-0.0426876135,
-0.0412223712,
-0.007614444,
0.0254766773,
0.0008022755,
-0.0151985232,
-0.0198307708,
0.1002791598,
0.0003683232,
0.0033693395,
-0.0694573894,
0.0141386986,
0.030763004,
0.0511394143,
-0.0022984843,
-0.0792185664,
0.0232558697,
-0.0135034882,
-0.064423658,
0.0053308913,
-0.0365813896,
-0.0163619611,
-0.023444904,
-0.0196755771,
-0.0215132926,
0.0205099843,
0.0142555302,
-0.0229840241,
-0.006017257,
0.007001698,
-0.0075278878,
0.0009998123,
-0.0649000183,
0.0281497296,
0.0579157174,
0.0491613634,
-0.0379197337,
0.00947956,
0.0026493573,
-0.0289881993,
-0.0156399701,
0.0390806422,
-0.0764771327,
-0.0558396503,
0.0055421293,
0.0888903812,
0.0024923771,
0.0090798307,
-0.0121082421,
-0.0109139998,
0.0315491855,
0.0346381217,
-0.0179718416,
-0.0253153928,
0.0561502166,
-0.0081844376,
0.0231824759,
0.0184628069,
-0.0638673082,
0.0144228851,
0.0242400691,
-0.0285458583,
-0.0680621043,
0.0002041771,
0.0054754498,
-0.0211248621,
0.0442115776,
-0.0400225334,
-0.031611044,
-0.0146433543,
-0.0179523025,
0.0174973663,
-0.0108297812,
-0.0258013587,
0.0420661233,
0.0597176217,
-0.0060494584,
-0.0280960426,
0.0573132075,
-0.0072071427,
-0.0250898954,
0.0017111057,
0.0557673834,
0.0263026785,
-0.0040153507,
0.0426310748,
0.0374630168,
0.0113320872,
0.0204468165,
0.0237493552,
-0.009189032,
-0.0146748768,
0.042573601,
-0.0124435537,
0.0387312844,
0.0385718532,
0.0699613243,
0.0444757231,
0.0264470223,
-0.062384773,
-0.0213446449,
0.0367995687,
-0.0066990457,
0.0456356816,
-0.0297607873,
0.0017606589,
-0.0412962958,
0.040225558,
-0.0672911406,
-0.0642300919,
0.0197594576,
0.0032177006,
-0.0504658185,
0.0121984985,
0.0606643707,
-0.0146400034,
0.002624155,
0.0474790968,
-0.0269643832,
0.0071387598,
0.0229108017,
0.0660927817,
0.0243559703,
-0.0295126624,
0.0022318305,
-0.0231311414,
-0.0663147867,
0.0229224991,
-0.0739593655,
0.0071057025,
0.0214448646,
0.0131523861,
0.0454007275,
0.023653375,
0.0344890878,
-0.0203795601,
-0.0338550657,
0.0096573532,
-0.0425303578,
0.0156367198,
-5.582481814e-33,
0.0074323914,
-0.0115786977,
-0.045247186,
0.025927335,
-0.011656424,
-0.0065880842,
0.0185009167,
0.011026118,
-0.0023364692,
0.0187086631,
0.0507484078,
0.0167579576,
-0.0120621752,
0.0070305876,
0.0634505302,
-0.0291836858,
0.004682553,
0.0201648325,
-0.0002142446,
-0.0002602243,
0.0672540218,
0.023823455,
0.0613964759,
-0.1172691435,
0.009417762,
0.0026529075,
-0.0455699898,
-0.021063583,
0.0045875609,
0.0843546391,
-0.0200447273,
0.0735738203,
0.0350608304,
0.0033592042,
-0.0209651329,
0.0261730962,
-0.0245486982,
0.0379984528,
0.0250430144,
0.0134454668,
-0.0364757031,
-0.0390210301,
0.0655483603,
0.0053075654,
-0.0360109806,
-0.0085175093,
0.0302128661,
-0.0280295946,
0.0324739069,
-0.0476425625,
-0.0498263836,
-0.0075914729,
-0.0342744924,
-0.028682217,
0.0275540017,
0.0507913642,
0.0357061401,
0.0122867525,
-0.0555981025,
0.0150911659,
-0.0794705972,
-0.011598818,
0.0496528,
-0.0072543365,
0.0110437898,
0.0836246237,
0.0053939368,
-0.0411318913,
-0.0116222091,
0.0126732262,
0.0032291741,
0.0664818659,
0.0058702226,
0.0478739627,
0.0173989441,
-0.0504508391,
-0.0725203827,
0.0101366993,
-0.0027797893,
0.0483516157,
0.010662145,
0.0147356754,
-0.0277667642,
-0.0163159352,
0.0186060462,
-0.0150170075,
-0.0309004411,
-0.0444468893,
0.0230048392,
-0.0343907066,
0.0118525634,
-0.023306977,
0.0257500242,
-0.0645133108,
0.0273264237,
0.00906316,
-0.026503684,
0.0412217081,
0.0179779027,
0.0392441377,
-0.0124302479,
0.0029783007,
0.0220632553,
-0.0381020382,
0.0310012959,
-0.0005964767,
0.0740899667,
0.05081328,
-0.044677861,
-0.0067365584,
0.0129127521,
0.0365249701,
0.0127962129,
0.0951098278,
0.0016392909,
0.0182455983,
-0.0221807268,
0.009502436,
0.0222168583,
0.0482716672,
-0.0033178185,
-0.0566351488,
-0.0096456204,
0.0093923891,
-0.0015829713,
-0.0112791406,
-0.0472598821,
-0.0316261873,
0.0284615401,
-0.0935108066,
-0.0070008938,
0.001328609,
2.739e-7,
0.0271564312,
0.0631284416,
-0.0316225588,
-0.0259443801,
0.0161595866,
0.0420348458,
-0.0100784758,
0.0475279279,
0.0148375425,
-0.0556020513,
-0.0063358448,
0.0112434393,
0.0591137409,
0.0585441589,
-0.0322052091,
0.0179755334,
-0.0637127906,
-0.0065491535,
-0.0602163784,
0.0462117456,
0.0481224805,
0.1122751832,
0.0265015457,
-0.0626228601,
0.0336719789,
-0.0322523378,
0.0442244783,
-0.026421506,
-0.0375464447,
-0.024377346,
-0.0201045107,
0.0137945311,
-0.0054213959,
0.0059404075,
-0.0055261496,
-0.0488620214,
0.0344805457,
0.0398107357,
-0.0179420169,
-0.0374351367,
-0.0219628029,
0.0068946094,
-0.0171657577,
-0.0136522735,
0.0659372509,
0.0458969735,
-0.0287336092,
-0.0478475206,
0.0012992248,
-0.0038471441,
0.0594437569,
-0.0548969656,
-0.0097233457,
-0.0019814544,
0.0446477495,
-0.02074885,
-0.0422310494,
-0.0655337721,
-0.0014190455,
-0.0017522215,
-0.0419368409,
-0.0556646362,
-0.0084269168,
0.0311440974,
0.0515723415,
-0.0159173366,
-0.0036038358,
2.268849656e-34,
0.0385978036,
-0.0522488244,
0.0384453237,
-0.0372330956,
0.0052628927,
0.0315386094,
-0.0607186109,
-0.0099826837,
-0.0169458836,
-0.0346668214,
0.0051092897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20624v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20624v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Entity Matching
| 2024-05-31T05:22:07 | 2024-05-31T05:22:07 |
Qianyu Huang, Tongfang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Entity matching (EM) is a critical task in data integration, aiming to
identify records across different datasets that refer to the same real-world
entities. Traditional methods often rely on manually engineered features and
rule-based systems, which struggle with diverse and unstructured data. The
emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 offers transformative
potential for EM, leveraging their advanced semantic understanding and
contextual capabilities. This vision paper explores the application of LLMs to
EM, discussing their advantages, challenges, and future research directions.
Additionally, we review related work on applying weak supervision and
unsupervised approaches to EM, highlighting how LLMs can enhance these methods.
|
[
0.0203650612,
0.0811844617,
-0.0198800322,
0.0442154706,
-0.039268788,
0.0274426043,
-0.0202067476,
0.0072127399,
0.0440169424,
-0.0222274046,
-0.0114418305,
-0.010494248,
-0.006815827,
-0.0069145542,
-0.010476402,
-0.0111096995,
0.0307749007,
0.0203885697,
-0.0393931828,
0.001073468,
0.0010778967,
0.0425896831,
0.0298277605,
0.0001201686,
-0.0215325486,
0.0073678512,
0.0169230346,
0.0007412939,
0.0393702909,
-0.0015456233,
-0.003772232,
0.0481353737,
0.0035546706,
0.095107995,
0.0000016958,
-0.0599176772,
-0.0534502678,
0.0031440239,
0.0022839366,
-0.0472036041,
-0.0094995722,
-0.0642677844,
-0.001279673,
-0.0128322421,
-0.001603402,
-0.0856437087,
0.060533952,
0.035667792,
0.0559315681,
0.0520788208,
-0.0417908765,
-0.0352905318,
0.0279178433,
-0.0108734006,
0.0042718281,
-0.0462200083,
0.0657357648,
0.0126937926,
0.0187063832,
-0.0140709681,
0.0181546453,
0.0388356,
-0.0466442108,
0.0008433017,
-0.0285931863,
0.0144422567,
-0.0269071534,
0.0613792799,
-0.0014650454,
0.0408685841,
-0.0100566521,
-0.0480909422,
0.0560346879,
0.0097826319,
-0.0195691381,
0.0305710193,
-0.0263277981,
-0.0132919978,
-0.0271311775,
0.0270832069,
-0.0042209229,
-0.0245406348,
0.0267117936,
0.004009916,
-0.0179655962,
0.0590104088,
0.0483488888,
-0.0262219347,
-0.044266969,
0.0118035469,
-0.0266302694,
-0.0733432621,
0.0259717908,
0.0379565358,
-0.0229822397,
-0.0074748583,
-0.0624361001,
-0.0107611679,
0.0086218342,
0.0146362651,
-0.0333451852,
0.0154722314,
-0.0002701797,
0.068954818,
-0.0289644711,
0.0134699969,
-0.0141535839,
-0.0163323916,
-0.0192902926,
-0.072496973,
-0.0958651453,
0.0037384231,
-0.0177913681,
0.0073658698,
-0.0031555549,
0.0073994165,
-0.0051668971,
0.003598718,
-0.044624079,
0.0567210428,
-0.015077753,
-0.0590633713,
0.0154634546,
-0.0292342193,
-0.0591533408,
-0.0029325956,
0.0037691486,
-0.0040189936,
-0.0747105256,
-0.0351087153,
0.0251378361,
-0.0112784393,
0.0383157767,
-0.0691055283,
0.0099646458,
0.0244895462,
0.0410434566,
0.0086804563,
-0.0533602908,
-0.0120285181,
0.0147694135,
-0.0385557301,
-0.0365920365,
-0.055603344,
0.0397310816,
0.0076769912,
0.0114411507,
-0.0562150814,
-0.004087816,
0.0149339102,
-0.0321844444,
0.0912014395,
-0.0356197543,
0.04417805,
0.0221701786,
-0.0233351383,
0.0263418425,
0.0073672645,
-0.002224046,
-0.0435652845,
0.0267764274,
-0.0154698603,
0.023796292,
0.050757546,
0.0120170182,
-0.0001313332,
-0.0084991837,
0.0401660725,
0.0550165325,
0.0211057384,
0.036964763,
0.0617852211,
0.0009224273,
-0.0078804279,
0.0439264886,
0.0467015393,
-0.009612293,
0.0214964729,
0.0352330655,
0.0109717986,
-0.0224342588,
-0.002571672,
-0.041592177,
-0.0119245397,
-0.0166562889,
-0.038603384,
-0.0006557934,
0.0558747835,
-0.0394778997,
0.0500630811,
-0.0022302065,
-0.0080416361,
-0.0292391628,
0.0026256607,
0.018630432,
-0.039712932,
0.0334568731,
0.0342965424,
-0.0131947836,
-0.0073360847,
-0.0058272658,
-0.0329020359,
-0.0125174271,
0.0669998676,
0.0545957647,
-0.0112853926,
-0.023751488,
-0.0125109758,
0.0096648345,
0.0369683802,
0.0396447815,
-0.0249590315,
-0.0309333075,
-0.0287446771,
-0.0318903178,
0.0655868426,
-0.0029649579,
0.0252691787,
0.0279953443,
0.0398750603,
0.0437700823,
-0.050015185,
-0.0180925764,
0.0275546201,
-0.0105690705,
-0.0303316228,
-0.0207877122,
0.0391467735,
-0.0021237398,
0.0104635404,
0.0209110361,
-0.0058478108,
0.0181958303,
-0.0053149937,
-0.0158183835,
-0.0128968842,
0.0286977496,
0.0287451018,
0.0604544245,
-0.0202413872,
-0.0323311053,
0.0007333251,
-0.0273602139,
-0.0686592534,
-0.0334515609,
-0.0057680993,
0.0483309962,
-0.034872137,
0.0319569483,
-0.0077226097,
-0.0186468381,
-0.0386899374,
0.0859054178,
0.0576600507,
0.01126807,
0.0192799233,
-0.018223552,
0.0501963347,
-0.0122680506,
-0.0083131213,
0.0145006003,
0.0054684114,
0.0386717953,
0.0329191759,
-0.0353464633,
-0.0357850641,
-0.0069233039,
-0.0603524931,
0.0404551849,
0.0227975715,
0.0460467637,
0.0209159441,
0.0447343625,
-0.0267367326,
0.0160481781,
-0.0562970564,
-0.0352874249,
0.0509238206,
0.0063232854,
0.0352427885,
-0.0069850273,
-0.0439216606,
-0.0186722912,
0.0080460189,
-0.0629427806,
0.0075811148,
0.0060410495,
-0.0515511297,
-0.053933952,
0.0069770631,
-0.0484723747,
0.0307270195,
0.0118079828,
0.0388216935,
-0.0255990084,
0.0068360497,
0.0460932963,
0.0231365096,
-0.0422968641,
-0.0425381958,
0.0396096706,
-0.0334454477,
-0.049925223,
0.0040811053,
0.0124362502,
-0.0176410284,
0.0066478099,
0.0066823619,
-0.0042498959,
-0.0234735459,
-0.0265497435,
-0.0328872167,
-0.0545568578,
0.0300807487,
0.0257433169,
0.0697642639,
-0.0077008884,
-0.0161112156,
0.0310991816,
0.0269378386,
-0.0216855183,
0.0115373032,
0.0572926253,
-0.0508121029,
0.0424982011,
-0.028140001,
-0.0007126042,
-0.0620280951,
0.0562810637,
0.0263220146,
0.0229441281,
-0.0258185044,
-0.0307380036,
0.0028537321,
0.0250251256,
0.0163914971,
-0.0111711547,
0.0932567418,
-0.0110542187,
0.0696713775,
-0.0110563366,
-0.0417111553,
-0.0442968532,
-0.0009932861,
-0.0370888151,
0.0226918031,
0.0152292065,
-0.0303256121,
-0.0326193273,
0.0597557463,
-0.0064413282,
0.0445968956,
0.0127228107,
-0.0174613185,
-0.0485947281,
-0.0002961255,
0.0536095947,
-0.0326634347,
-0.0011868641,
0.0209846348,
-0.0033249464,
-0.0162522849,
0.0425107591,
-0.011321689,
0.0016235374,
-0.0043504937,
0.0212889481,
-0.0661044419,
0.0222039241,
-0.0217426959,
0.0082378937,
-0.0161594804,
0.0237155315,
0.1165774092,
0.0126518635,
-0.040651869,
-0.0302108265,
0.0044190073,
-0.0025064857,
0.0253759138,
0.0421684831,
-0.0582765415,
-0.0275234729,
0.0091599403,
-0.0262100399,
0.0225971919,
-0.0579310097,
-0.0153787276,
-0.1054623276,
0.0027473995,
0.0081045208,
-0.0458944552,
-0.0555689447,
-0.0393786207,
0.0601452775,
-0.0277234782,
-0.015669588,
-0.0304732006,
-0.0446795523,
-0.0262802169,
-0.0116831744,
0.0131621361,
-0.0547912568,
0.025344532,
-0.1077015549,
0.0480693094,
0.050538715,
0.0573316067,
0.0047967327,
-0.0150730591,
-0.0171274822,
-0.0424493216,
-0.0848754644,
0.0032952975,
0.0310528055,
-0.0353891104,
0.0002364069,
-0.0184924062,
0.0095888646,
-0.0290506445,
0.0209056363,
0.0058475584,
0.0820374116,
-0.0126090096,
0.0121758375,
-0.003089847,
-0.0409115627,
0.0108949346,
0.1047718301,
-0.0040930985,
0.0082741054,
0.0200399626,
-0.0022057786,
0.0266176537,
0.0414927006,
-0.0120143602,
0.0303338431,
-0.0446080901,
-0.0232306086,
-0.031115042,
-0.0220326968,
0.0654756054,
-0.0095454231,
0.0594734587,
0.0474062711,
0.0198375322,
-0.0454593413,
-0.0421737134,
0.036004547,
-0.1066640615,
0.0541493148,
-0.0439222604,
0.0040797088,
0.0212694276,
-0.0074869031,
-0.0329673588,
0.0016791505,
-0.0733831972,
-0.0412570573,
-0.0092952857,
-0.0608929768,
0.0184501521,
0.0506145582,
-0.027102584,
-0.000030752,
-0.01768177,
0.0438470356,
-0.0287665799,
-0.0431730673,
-0.0418936871,
-0.016526822,
0.0140609285,
0.0421029776,
-0.0445916168,
0.0274671726,
0.0202569738,
0.012185338,
-0.0092927525,
-0.0535868257,
0.0621081926,
0.0424674302,
0.0197287146,
0.0321497731,
0.0063755494,
-0.0436732434,
-0.0065200138,
-0.0149421254,
-0.007961276,
-0.0090862475,
-0.0288438704,
0.0150668258,
0.0310018845,
-0.0106760636,
0.0072015934,
-0.0126991617,
0.0389978476,
-0.0621066652,
-0.0198600311,
-0.019384684,
0.0153763173,
0.0283178017,
-0.0558839887,
0.0072052167,
0.0234926511,
0.0272021089,
0.0492615066,
-0.0620136112,
-0.0032835701,
0.0369884558,
0.0162797906,
-0.0000884462,
0.0036610693,
-0.0504477881,
-0.0349443294,
-0.0052263923,
0.0235331673,
0.0829462707,
-0.0506474897,
0.0409551859,
-0.0453918837,
-0.0346705541,
-0.0032288167,
-0.0498540699,
0.0270328298,
0.015389367,
0.0293227546,
0.0316692293,
-0.0281879939,
0.0028405872,
0.0578545369,
0.0095568504,
0.0928594321,
-0.0120018376,
-0.0552772656,
-0.0008724715,
-0.0245684404,
0.0596532747,
-0.0307489838,
-0.0335618854,
-0.0264695268,
-0.0250801276,
-0.0478912778,
-0.0074185235,
-0.0085491072,
-0.0634057298,
0.0055509536,
-0.0028392011,
0.0269909706,
0.0218544025,
-0.0353321768,
0.0017113778,
-0.021641586,
0.0003861292,
-0.0386577062,
0.00370041,
-5.430708963e-33,
-0.042453289,
-0.048151426,
0.0282620415,
-0.0176558588,
0.0166367069,
-0.0139196189,
0.0158593319,
-0.0737986639,
-0.0086921705,
-0.0218648352,
-0.0051976363,
0.0275580585,
0.0273155421,
0.0011280961,
0.0134228794,
-0.0170523301,
0.0480108224,
0.0434465185,
0.0070795123,
0.0191835761,
0.004528102,
0.0026994334,
0.0147813512,
-0.0778792575,
0.0364599638,
-0.0198915694,
-0.0178613849,
0.0550592169,
0.0277458094,
0.0595079064,
-0.0447087809,
0.0024053389,
0.0151440538,
-0.0094736163,
0.0153819378,
-0.0035553733,
-0.0804218873,
-0.0060786591,
-0.010604308,
-0.0057666507,
0.0528043769,
-0.0237583891,
0.0185693111,
-0.0465349853,
0.0086331395,
0.0331262797,
0.0389347672,
-0.0326117016,
0.0150627233,
-0.0128904544,
-0.060520228,
0.0321937017,
0.0281247813,
0.0356073342,
0.0828595012,
-0.0537964627,
0.0308618974,
0.0158818457,
-0.0696776286,
0.0309949871,
0.0115159377,
0.0239331275,
0.0416488014,
-0.0144926673,
-0.0035204624,
0.0341671966,
-0.0199376661,
-0.0405775532,
0.0241148602,
0.0050212038,
-0.0184942409,
0.0243987162,
-0.0304534081,
0.0431995131,
0.0034650511,
0.0061344462,
-0.0567181259,
0.0681188256,
-0.0137269683,
-0.0054648458,
-0.0318593122,
-0.0009698421,
-0.0481535085,
-0.0228315871,
-0.0260406826,
0.010793603,
-0.0423237197,
0.0037619383,
0.0257886779,
-0.0249396693,
0.0030598079,
0.0558208227,
0.0002274084,
-0.0480443798,
-0.09117385,
-0.0087135602,
-0.0008880256,
-0.0342940092,
0.0057971068,
0.0477377735,
-0.0131744444,
-0.0658723786,
0.0350214392,
-0.0165441222,
0.0236323737,
0.0421360545,
0.0400388911,
0.0020709061,
-0.0567827299,
0.0320246257,
-0.0125667825,
-0.0309181623,
-0.0963904709,
-0.0539572909,
0.025839908,
0.0347381532,
0.072032772,
-0.0053590527,
0.1094981804,
-0.0304685254,
-0.0151778031,
-0.0052101985,
-0.0020190731,
0.0068614767,
0.0213856772,
0.0162182078,
-0.0214126799,
-0.0256484766,
0.047039099,
-0.0331652351,
0.0073437253,
-0.0044198642,
2.522e-7,
0.0151805319,
0.0174090024,
-0.0056845914,
0.0240739901,
0.0184152294,
0.01593793,
-0.0112721054,
0.031693507,
-0.0231929291,
0.0251881648,
0.0332676433,
-0.0113606611,
0.035315752,
0.0540000573,
-0.0499718525,
0.0288764518,
-0.0226713121,
-0.0337077416,
-0.1185215041,
0.0055269646,
0.0447693095,
0.0542451292,
0.0025395399,
-0.0177775379,
-0.0207986124,
-0.0304134451,
0.013615055,
-0.0347890854,
-0.0073465756,
0.0499663614,
0.0345932133,
0.0096533196,
0.0355077535,
0.0799830407,
0.0131669128,
0.0430640206,
0.0464104228,
0.0490118191,
-0.0200934466,
0.0696820915,
-0.0539104193,
-0.0672712252,
-0.0019056121,
-0.0415380336,
0.0958626047,
-0.0030004352,
0.0194557142,
0.0303256307,
-0.0122978725,
-0.0396364741,
-0.033263173,
0.0453079827,
-0.0419447608,
0.0257823728,
0.0273763165,
0.0257246234,
-0.0131162722,
-0.038822148,
0.0403562188,
0.0254901536,
-0.0138505511,
0.0063202735,
-0.0169422682,
0.0063437875,
0.0261631384,
-0.0484680608,
0.0370991305,
2.681643783e-34,
-0.0212359149,
0.0213801917,
0.001144996,
-0.0358067006,
0.0657750368,
-0.0086186528,
-0.0295299347,
0.0535464883,
-0.0491515175,
-0.0618224218,
0.0104689179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20613v1
|
FineRadScore: A Radiology Report Line-by-Line Evaluation Technique Generating Corrections with Severity Scores
| 2024-05-31T04:05:09 | 2024-05-31T04:05:09 |
Alyssa Huang, Oishi Banerjee, Kay Wu, Eduardo Pontes Reis, Pranav Rajpurkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The current gold standard for evaluating generated chest x-ray (CXR) reports
is through radiologist annotations. However, this process can be extremely
time-consuming and costly, especially when evaluating large numbers of reports.
In this work, we present FineRadScore, a Large Language Model (LLM)-based
automated evaluation metric for generated CXR reports. Given a candidate report
and a ground-truth report, FineRadScore gives the minimum number of
line-by-line corrections required to go from the candidate to the ground-truth
report. Additionally, FineRadScore provides an error severity rating with each
correction and generates comments explaining why the correction was needed. We
demonstrate that FineRadScore's corrections and error severity scores align
with radiologist opinions. We also show that, when used to judge the quality of
the report as a whole, FineRadScore aligns with radiologists as well as current
state-of-the-art automated CXR evaluation metrics. Finally, we analyze
FineRadScore's shortcomings to provide suggestions for future improvements.
|
[
0.0276932213,
0.0377664641,
0.0167819839,
-0.0124139022,
-0.0209688265,
0.0367548689,
-0.0164226089,
0.0483537987,
-0.0361750349,
-0.0090755308,
-0.0043896781,
-0.0195331573,
0.0614969656,
0.0360817574,
0.0007678472,
-0.042087391,
0.0142562343,
-0.0101020234,
0.0541712381,
0.0036547456,
-0.0038039081,
0.0204478335,
0.0135360304,
0.0216807611,
-0.0122055952,
-0.0129908603,
0.0472338572,
0.0015205028,
0.0177014526,
-0.0400651731,
-0.0167638939,
0.0454479083,
-0.0421607196,
0.0429643132,
0.0000022603,
-0.0439936258,
-0.014976142,
0.0550292991,
-0.0030478407,
0.0257276576,
0.0667083561,
-0.047992114,
-0.0388710536,
-0.0152489832,
0.0065926421,
-0.0778345168,
0.0822919309,
0.0152999777,
0.0886455476,
0.0411899462,
-0.0221866369,
0.0369888917,
-0.0227151364,
-0.0014206507,
-0.0043051243,
-0.0498652346,
-0.006038934,
0.0500745773,
0.0077248444,
0.0492129065,
0.004900557,
0.0250718854,
0.0055789482,
-0.0393521823,
0.0084788939,
0.0245231986,
0.0050285789,
-0.0032469819,
0.0329544358,
0.0334122367,
-0.0194137711,
0.0083004441,
-0.0185205992,
-0.0245194957,
-0.0260207038,
-0.0665837526,
-0.0177810248,
0.0102569303,
-0.0104264505,
-0.0333815329,
0.0275045726,
-0.0349969864,
-0.0181206483,
0.0119962161,
-0.0328307636,
-0.0321277864,
-0.0203803126,
-0.0342013091,
0.0124966996,
0.0462884158,
0.0170031954,
-0.0928695649,
0.0102676349,
0.0269431602,
-0.0766521543,
-0.014567758,
0.0037750995,
0.0078623462,
0.0867166445,
-0.0760800317,
0.0077556544,
-0.0218228418,
-0.0557015352,
0.05444571,
-0.0028065164,
0.0469172858,
0.0084817437,
0.0570971482,
-0.0237379819,
0.0541560017,
0.0097384658,
-0.0013944608,
0.0013585704,
-0.0255147107,
0.0123895491,
0.0284733735,
-0.0965031162,
-0.025617443,
-0.0269489624,
0.0833595172,
0.0787687153,
0.0279269237,
-0.0387396179,
0.0217045788,
-0.02029524,
0.0292766578,
0.022443423,
-0.0051927841,
-0.0135186827,
0.029367853,
0.0215105545,
0.0599008612,
0.0131862257,
0.0334793366,
-0.0063998979,
-0.0290665179,
0.0017862697,
0.0177436061,
0.0565345995,
-0.0620257854,
-0.0494291447,
-0.0495907366,
-0.0363360271,
-0.0962423682,
0.0098853242,
0.0005826725,
0.0354739167,
-0.0169830769,
0.0020594571,
0.0058267373,
-0.0346206762,
0.0027327016,
-0.0806160867,
0.0164578613,
0.0062379017,
0.0069481758,
0.039506685,
-0.0265115127,
0.01235143,
-0.0025394701,
-0.0071191676,
0.0027966285,
0.0172304325,
-0.0010494645,
-0.0456897169,
-0.0185058564,
-0.0331966802,
0.0266290177,
-0.0201701075,
0.062089242,
-0.0022343555,
0.0502170101,
-0.0108621055,
0.0075510433,
0.0189615693,
0.0256790314,
0.0076753008,
-0.0047807647,
0.0305279717,
-0.0200954583,
-0.0002728412,
-0.0165232718,
-0.0188167393,
0.0162482299,
0.042556379,
-0.0004246434,
0.0283937454,
-0.0133779729,
-0.0072232313,
-0.0362724513,
-0.0394664891,
0.0024969024,
-0.0173312128,
-0.0083427094,
0.0288271364,
-0.0078316685,
-0.0570177101,
0.0042729042,
0.0234186575,
-0.0015753275,
-0.0242507346,
-0.0571460761,
-0.0155359209,
0.0610004105,
0.0618721992,
-0.0128034791,
-0.0116250608,
-0.001771485,
0.0258914754,
0.0414614305,
0.0747443736,
-0.019108858,
-0.0128811486,
-0.025994122,
-0.0285129696,
0.0457184166,
0.0336935408,
-0.0109837875,
0.0085984534,
-0.0057381559,
-0.0138635105,
-0.0380991101,
-0.0985704511,
0.0066149686,
-0.0121422634,
-0.0195308905,
0.0023952848,
-0.0027437641,
0.016458841,
0.015223139,
-0.0414126106,
0.0141416481,
0.005391133,
0.0425420254,
-0.0504685603,
0.0197848901,
-0.0154395867,
0.0172287803,
0.0501396619,
-0.0379268825,
-0.0114692422,
-0.0120194238,
-0.0334740765,
0.0043947808,
-0.040423464,
-0.0863259062,
0.0045997119,
-0.0197649878,
0.0595785044,
0.0264058411,
-0.0330964066,
-0.0109775104,
0.0487162136,
0.0003103414,
0.0402136184,
0.023366455,
-0.0337417834,
0.0060049794,
-0.0288691781,
-0.0333598517,
0.0216790773,
0.0088251866,
0.0227792282,
0.0180900786,
0.0585513711,
-0.0009519053,
-0.0409032144,
-0.0420887694,
-0.0026621353,
0.0088933948,
-0.0001552485,
0.0376708433,
-0.0167871658,
0.0175978001,
0.0051461034,
0.0033259436,
-0.0528087281,
0.073352173,
0.0211367533,
0.0546741225,
0.0064820494,
-0.0182709303,
-0.0810097754,
-0.0156957209,
-0.0253919959,
0.007259828,
0.0686451942,
-0.0134335551,
-0.0623074211,
0.0814053416,
-0.0582115576,
-0.019534165,
0.0273923464,
-0.0654536039,
0.0380567312,
-0.0546250045,
-0.068505466,
0.0458330587,
-0.0067659817,
0.0012932526,
0.0447349511,
-0.030523289,
-0.0334174633,
-0.0399016887,
-0.0097834785,
-0.0705716982,
0.0362651981,
-0.0953024924,
-0.0020671431,
0.0271323398,
0.0043099415,
0.0094399685,
-0.0220591146,
-0.0276681799,
-0.0432495996,
0.005067979,
-0.0067009809,
-0.0463817269,
0.0140031436,
0.0563656576,
-0.0089415507,
-0.0443563014,
0.0539568439,
-0.017085677,
0.0302691944,
-0.075023286,
0.0256995298,
-0.0409862548,
0.0097195664,
-0.0005159905,
0.0566043891,
-0.0001132707,
-0.0270296596,
0.0019963679,
-0.0109209558,
0.0522123389,
-0.0681898072,
-0.0177029222,
-0.0414977632,
0.0067712273,
0.0078034936,
-0.0032238897,
0.0019894906,
-0.0074179103,
0.0068091722,
-0.0418055877,
0.0340732299,
-0.0044403109,
-0.0626662821,
0.0613415577,
0.0255771354,
0.0229066387,
-0.0018121897,
-0.0152091533,
0.002653125,
-0.0289891362,
-0.0286603663,
0.0143437274,
-0.0025290533,
-0.0275585018,
-0.0074345437,
0.0900750607,
-0.0432547815,
0.0772199184,
-0.0369274914,
-0.0157433134,
-0.0045384369,
0.0045553329,
-0.0194874778,
-0.0012801797,
0.0340522341,
-0.0314468853,
-0.0188455302,
0.0831279829,
0.0476695821,
0.0018971049,
-0.0355545841,
0.0009880898,
-0.0450068004,
0.0045257593,
0.0142614264,
-0.0117490096,
0.03014539,
0.0105688274,
0.043507047,
-0.0306678601,
-0.0150470398,
0.0403292961,
-0.0396489054,
0.0864897743,
0.0074404455,
-0.0515103899,
-0.0667594299,
-0.0697873831,
0.0181135461,
-0.0083129685,
-0.0427619554,
0.0360412188,
0.0060150134,
-0.006736062,
-0.0066754357,
-0.0833836496,
-0.0651716962,
0.0325535014,
-0.0664947927,
-0.0134844407,
0.040395543,
0.038600862,
-0.0211725701,
-0.0166659597,
0.0100702243,
0.0284134559,
-0.0142515311,
0.0035263728,
0.0809694901,
0.0593340993,
-0.0050805239,
-0.062452171,
-0.0090641454,
0.0368718617,
0.013894557,
-0.0377381332,
0.0454225987,
-0.0252944436,
0.0042251172,
-0.0222569425,
0.0759050623,
-0.0125420364,
0.0059202313,
0.0204182919,
0.0375446454,
-0.0111284116,
-0.0171411149,
0.0632159188,
-0.0212137252,
-0.037193846,
0.038168177,
-0.0744720325,
-0.0566696748,
-0.0490666851,
-0.0383113436,
0.0200462546,
0.0090798317,
0.0117724622,
-0.004212481,
-0.0396911353,
-0.0150709795,
-0.0422558896,
0.020450078,
0.036956016,
0.0429842807,
-0.0100643942,
-0.0043750233,
0.0517734475,
0.0571459047,
-0.0100567611,
0.0537383631,
-0.0036620211,
0.0113528464,
-0.0125523843,
0.0381035507,
0.0307080429,
-0.0574044213,
-0.0213188808,
-0.0188341048,
0.0282959435,
0.0512651429,
-0.0178170055,
0.0237190332,
-0.0208142679,
-0.0892527178,
-0.0179324653,
-0.0307168607,
-0.0179240312,
-0.0236854702,
0.021226285,
0.0437154174,
-0.0377799943,
-0.0523618273,
0.0314965174,
0.0488678887,
0.0029029013,
-0.0347238667,
-0.0113847312,
0.0083652176,
-0.0108928569,
-0.0296977367,
-0.0405995473,
0.0055597108,
0.0275224149,
0.0107100625,
-0.0192952305,
-0.0068434472,
0.0458387211,
-0.0832761601,
0.0021415469,
-0.0445763506,
0.073770985,
0.0145676229,
-0.0072720204,
0.0398978405,
-0.0168852936,
-0.0395920537,
-0.0941548944,
0.0215471573,
0.0136709139,
-0.0027364104,
0.0211877413,
-0.000351398,
0.0405063629,
-0.0027865455,
0.0089039784,
0.0098728491,
-0.0164307747,
-0.0636138543,
0.004167024,
0.0390177332,
0.0287363119,
0.0336536989,
-0.0381796062,
-0.0065836608,
-0.0370972082,
0.0657078624,
0.0058184918,
0.0074921483,
-0.001899078,
0.0057707289,
0.0357029997,
-0.0224687997,
0.0519963428,
-0.011315098,
0.0120245181,
-0.0545041934,
-0.081272684,
-0.043954093,
-0.040964894,
-0.0105545707,
-0.0142507106,
-0.0125368452,
-0.0411244519,
-0.0531392395,
-0.0466812551,
-0.0031131834,
0.0565613434,
0.0199365728,
-0.0116333244,
-0.0062173293,
0.060822282,
0.0157523844,
-0.0301020276,
-0.0139867133,
0.0279218461,
0.005322333,
-0.0211116765,
0.013739327,
-5.887839982e-33,
-0.0024294192,
-0.0476888344,
-0.0002656956,
-0.0376614854,
0.0040745265,
0.0339389108,
-0.0469902381,
0.0031772994,
0.0489814468,
0.0115609048,
-0.0179272816,
-0.0235115699,
0.0294136591,
-0.0247702226,
0.032870084,
0.0106210206,
0.0364012681,
0.0136160068,
-0.0329230838,
-0.0143468548,
-0.033767052,
-0.0238335319,
0.051989086,
-0.1364074498,
0.0260794014,
0.0238220561,
-0.0226575956,
-0.0165847261,
0.0289148949,
0.0509351715,
0.0016523362,
-0.0002968382,
0.0100072166,
-0.0542943291,
-0.0209125821,
-0.0326651447,
-0.0460176617,
0.002069328,
0.022766307,
0.0038375722,
-0.0042963633,
0.0304884017,
0.0046493709,
-0.0146627612,
0.0115025891,
-0.0264502224,
0.0354945287,
-0.0329849273,
0.0073850555,
0.0035367655,
-0.0295133907,
0.0765211135,
-0.0027531369,
0.0007940836,
-0.0157899987,
-0.0181230102,
-0.0224977341,
0.0103544611,
-0.0100878254,
0.0218980312,
0.1082788259,
0.0162118208,
0.0131519604,
-0.055636473,
-0.0510766618,
0.0030976697,
0.0398205258,
0.0016535992,
0.0084610321,
0.0391118936,
-0.0466701686,
0.0474061407,
0.0262157265,
0.0694378614,
0.0239810944,
-0.0215463173,
-0.0468744077,
0.077041328,
-0.0656310022,
0.104091391,
0.017282486,
-0.0342062972,
-0.0575858541,
-0.0104068778,
-0.0205667708,
-0.0263121594,
-0.0326066725,
-0.0140786879,
0.0211987738,
0.0352626331,
-0.0152117284,
0.0256018303,
0.0160522293,
0.0073723979,
0.0091733318,
-0.0516436771,
0.0029394059,
0.050003238,
-0.0567133613,
-0.0284859166,
0.0156962313,
0.0145238684,
0.0372894183,
0.036900457,
0.0679302439,
-0.0055109472,
0.0230309628,
0.0262837112,
-0.0787182078,
0.0566770732,
0.0384556726,
-0.0233495943,
-0.0551556572,
-0.0026141943,
0.0210699849,
0.0030336909,
-0.004997022,
0.0191676673,
-0.0160700269,
0.03892456,
-0.0342069119,
-0.0475043356,
-0.0128143067,
-0.0027256121,
-0.0424105413,
-0.0186099149,
0.0112820063,
-0.0190597344,
0.0688446835,
-0.0081646489,
-0.0128437057,
0.0217770729,
2.915e-7,
0.0518275127,
0.0544119738,
0.018912537,
-0.0041665998,
0.0111014638,
-0.0058070146,
-0.0342295915,
-0.006477817,
0.0493794978,
-0.0084022833,
0.0233647823,
-0.0218099281,
0.0059039923,
0.0745995417,
-0.0048186709,
-0.0369225331,
-0.0363197699,
0.0028195342,
-0.0118179563,
-0.0263090972,
0.0567207783,
0.0281465426,
-0.0425116159,
-0.0320683233,
-0.0238994025,
-0.0181072596,
0.0009769044,
-0.0120437471,
0.0037312817,
0.0088841543,
0.0326197073,
-0.0077816723,
0.0352155603,
0.0480295271,
-0.0070635742,
-0.0388129689,
0.0438981242,
0.0932144374,
-0.037709333,
0.0577586032,
0.0324996188,
-0.0075031156,
0.0316169411,
-0.0501618907,
0.0115279229,
-0.0053183381,
0.0149960173,
-0.040080294,
-0.0583583638,
0.0131159835,
0.0681017935,
-0.0435630269,
-0.024208067,
0.0470163077,
0.0036714692,
0.0395983234,
-0.0345283188,
-0.0390584208,
-0.010824196,
0.0405235179,
0.0119995466,
-0.0693362951,
0.0686800405,
0.0051921294,
-0.0145568661,
-0.0514191575,
0.019484384,
2.695080694e-34,
0.0468879975,
0.0005937641,
-0.0169098955,
-0.0608430952,
0.0561097302,
0.0187067781,
-0.0085034836,
0.0165054929,
0.0030591611,
-0.0188617129,
0.0040797046
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.