id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08355v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08355v1
|
Seal-Tools: Self-Instruct Tool Learning Dataset for Agent Tuning and Detailed Benchmark
| 2024-05-14T06:50:19 | 2024-05-14T06:50:19 |
Mengsong Wu, Tong Zhu, Han Han, Chuanyuan Tan, Xiang Zhang, Wenliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents a new tool learning dataset Seal-Tools, which contains
self-instruct API-like tools. Seal-Tools not only offers a large number of
tools, but also includes instances which demonstrate the practical application
of tools. Seeking to generate data on a large scale while ensuring reliability,
we propose a self-instruct method to generate tools and instances, allowing
precise control over the process. Moreover, our Seal-Tools contains hard
instances that call multiple tools to complete the job, among which some are
nested tool callings. For precise and comprehensive evaluation, we use strict
format control and design three metrics from different dimensions. Therefore,
Seal-Tools can serve as a new benchmark to evaluate the tool-calling ability of
LLMs. Finally, we evaluate several prevalent LLMs and our finetuned model on
Seal-Tools. The results show that current systems are far from perfect. The
code, data and experiment results are available at
https://github.com/fairyshine/Seal-Tools .
|
[
-0.0357562713,
-0.010895988,
-0.0135096814,
-0.0006528794,
-0.0241867993,
-0.0114794569,
0.0085555511,
-0.0101523995,
0.0249575581,
0.0054516937,
-0.0434425995,
0.0895690024,
-0.0669350997,
0.0275292024,
0.0038732316,
-0.0069100736,
0.0625155121,
0.0071964734,
-0.0645209476,
-0.010842612,
-0.0506434254,
-0.0238601677,
-0.031483829,
0.0300138276,
0.0024483751,
-0.025530532,
-0.0342303962,
0.0331411995,
0.020573847,
-0.0232152995,
0.037610162,
-0.0031189488,
0.0237085242,
0.0632606745,
0.0000019541,
-0.0554435775,
-0.0238473397,
0.0100891357,
-0.0498552844,
-0.0260263067,
0.0119392388,
-0.0025235279,
-0.00700161,
0.035075441,
-0.0198913291,
0.0256209485,
0.0290565435,
-0.0145778004,
0.0948986635,
0.0892155617,
0.0372829176,
0.0419072621,
-0.0151519282,
0.0067647882,
-0.0480368175,
-0.040551763,
-0.0091318088,
-0.0048434511,
0.0044634226,
-0.0308444854,
0.0413733199,
-0.0212307293,
0.0404427908,
-0.003006041,
0.0185061321,
0.014324774,
-0.0373128578,
-0.0385970771,
-0.0198773239,
0.0080743581,
-0.0183391962,
-0.0123187965,
0.0099824751,
-0.020788407,
0.0112791769,
0.0083107064,
-0.0157413185,
0.0223335624,
0.0052430429,
0.0007132813,
-0.030662233,
0.0079088612,
-0.007947484,
-0.0324164703,
0.0049547665,
0.0987813771,
-0.0070970259,
0.0256902054,
-0.0220801197,
-0.0182717983,
0.0534647107,
-0.0161372647,
-0.0284549855,
0.0632606745,
-0.0793194622,
-0.0371713191,
-0.0322772712,
0.040384613,
0.0229253676,
-0.0252871476,
0.0495409444,
-0.0238554571,
-0.0150386523,
0.0013380529,
-0.0443965383,
0.0176416673,
0.0325335152,
0.0638531446,
-0.0028571314,
0.0179956742,
-0.0541520901,
0.0418002419,
-0.0010843921,
0.0381977782,
0.0192747042,
0.0267594401,
-0.0285202004,
0.0398010276,
-0.0315392874,
0.0310176238,
-0.0217459612,
-0.0398655348,
-0.041698575,
0.0063459482,
-0.0604335703,
-0.0487122387,
-0.0581228733,
0.0148910461,
0.0226509739,
-0.0223419368,
-0.0176724792,
0.0066372841,
-0.040670272,
-0.0095118396,
0.0247078538,
0.1165427715,
0.0146941952,
0.011432224,
-0.0708463639,
-0.0370821282,
0.1004165262,
-0.0596100576,
-0.0285808519,
-0.0545276925,
-0.0023781378,
-0.0352708623,
-0.0199649837,
-0.0358098112,
-0.0058789733,
-0.0419076383,
0.0061688321,
0.0407460742,
-0.0151926829,
0.0345753506,
-0.0122385519,
0.0107292226,
-0.0484162383,
0.0661558136,
-0.0116658891,
0.0696359873,
0.0218737684,
-0.019582307,
0.0420578644,
0.0242355987,
-0.0386793204,
0.0319286101,
0.0058762245,
0.0248512607,
0.0208490267,
0.0527150668,
0.0220613014,
-0.0412406512,
-0.0166183654,
-0.0226929914,
0.0501227491,
0.0101479236,
0.0457505658,
0.0171395522,
0.0230812225,
0.0410962403,
0.0179623011,
-0.0341027342,
-0.0701075122,
0.0299998745,
-0.0393732525,
0.0176098198,
-0.0587936155,
0.0614999495,
-0.0509192683,
-0.0336936824,
-0.0045615495,
-0.0100144502,
-0.0834096596,
0.004943091,
0.0538184904,
0.003601318,
-0.0583377853,
0.0218497999,
0.021105215,
-0.060703177,
-0.0677207634,
-0.085404858,
0.0246770997,
0.0195068028,
0.0555866286,
-0.0696427673,
-0.0884395316,
0.0006542425,
-0.023341652,
0.0190417953,
-0.0051513636,
-0.028103387,
0.0250616465,
-0.0143839233,
-0.0578413233,
-0.0060360515,
-0.0025943068,
0.032731358,
0.0489815734,
-0.0415524319,
-0.0312133469,
-0.0611686036,
-0.0023063514,
0.0633341894,
0.003735187,
-0.0301434472,
0.0038170123,
0.0044959611,
0.0485188551,
0.0051693404,
-0.0270351712,
-0.028813675,
0.0629430413,
0.0280099511,
-0.0340644158,
-0.0171572808,
0.0074845464,
0.0221549012,
0.0125698103,
-0.015174943,
0.0107136955,
0.0435933955,
-0.0436644666,
-0.0516612045,
-0.0318281725,
0.0128862355,
0.0229002014,
0.0136590637,
0.0431497432,
-0.0611596853,
0.0154226245,
-0.0188174155,
0.0316652693,
-0.0013158225,
-0.0355980285,
-0.0193456206,
0.0425217599,
0.0060835378,
-0.018020656,
-0.0007443133,
0.0044044526,
-0.0003797023,
0.0346572474,
0.0365816355,
0.0210094359,
-0.0325342715,
-0.0254905466,
-0.0126143778,
0.0485758707,
-0.0103757484,
0.0041740993,
-0.0001790306,
-0.0356743112,
-0.0065696184,
-0.0331790522,
0.0160447173,
0.0497404635,
-0.022367809,
0.0230925996,
-0.0013009083,
0.0031813176,
-0.0568691976,
-0.0152168404,
0.0022914154,
0.004232808,
0.0043452005,
0.0121264346,
0.0334705785,
-0.0724316165,
0.0912704766,
-0.0034319989,
-0.0051400559,
-0.0220219418,
-0.0504897423,
0.020438442,
0.0000173222,
-0.0669365004,
0.0840635002,
-0.0616145171,
0.0440749936,
0.0878491551,
0.0229331721,
-0.0763771534,
0.0073518595,
-0.0249937233,
-0.0535558164,
-0.0358248278,
0.0250458289,
-0.0167284813,
0.0078299064,
-0.0273861159,
0.0066799549,
0.0060953125,
0.0172499344,
0.0589145608,
-0.0658341646,
0.0159373842,
0.0310253296,
-0.0371917784,
0.0190885812,
-0.012422692,
-0.1062453538,
0.0104415771,
0.0145520559,
-0.0078890277,
0.0158885662,
-0.0713271573,
-0.0399304777,
0.0576001592,
0.0396321975,
-0.0098723322,
-0.0033490646,
-0.0147906253,
-0.0401191078,
-0.0027715261,
0.0387174562,
-0.0162403714,
-0.0285565052,
-0.0223183427,
-0.0046402654,
-0.0120818289,
-0.0448240824,
-0.0427116714,
0.0318407081,
0.003064289,
0.0327116475,
-0.0479908511,
-0.0663117766,
-0.0342592075,
-0.0153779211,
0.0219854731,
0.0077156387,
-0.0097694434,
-0.0135897985,
-0.0483051874,
-0.0196279362,
-0.0110459281,
0.0078577502,
0.0190237835,
-0.008314901,
0.0601694621,
0.0267704595,
0.0434756204,
-0.0585865416,
-0.0652654618,
-0.0104682846,
0.0033553145,
-0.0765829384,
0.032082431,
0.0286371205,
0.059557315,
-0.0613483004,
0.012789079,
0.0312525071,
0.0050235572,
-0.0258335043,
0.0141358264,
-0.0076441537,
0.0084748976,
0.0660485849,
0.0467402227,
-0.0067002461,
-0.0103591336,
0.027770238,
0.0722281858,
-0.0194982383,
-0.0417185873,
0.0281210057,
-0.0912389085,
0.0656109899,
-0.0059179026,
-0.0207514782,
0.0140044214,
-0.0737129226,
0.0236036573,
-0.068838343,
-0.0241535325,
0.0519702062,
0.0074449796,
-0.0174973328,
0.0231438521,
0.0235099699,
-0.0048255911,
-0.0040703136,
-0.0665744692,
0.0756834298,
0.0329924561,
-0.012782854,
-0.0146281719,
0.0141883669,
0.0523940362,
0.0524082035,
0.0203798376,
-0.0113844303,
0.0319295786,
0.0225472599,
-0.00755218,
0.0166183226,
0.0345338173,
-0.0378797315,
-0.0001511519,
0.0368996225,
0.0616990477,
-0.039798826,
-0.0083112009,
-0.0261282846,
-0.0465515442,
0.0037943111,
0.0440058894,
-0.0029718177,
0.0028337291,
-0.0539132096,
-0.0202979874,
-0.0291466452,
-0.0165864211,
-0.0302992053,
0.0310054328,
-0.0839373991,
-0.0135480603,
-0.0315036811,
-0.0439992212,
0.0389981233,
0.0467208438,
0.026863426,
-0.0167747624,
-0.0197811611,
0.075385116,
-0.0285228137,
-0.0115303556,
-0.0095231738,
0.0171745699,
-0.0351391919,
-0.0354411528,
0.0501210913,
0.0022718899,
0.007691761,
0.0075824773,
-0.0447635278,
-0.0582269989,
0.0252907425,
0.0783123225,
0.0325351842,
0.0465176664,
-0.0147651294,
-0.0254499037,
0.059196651,
0.0658181757,
-0.0239856299,
-0.0053921086,
0.0291388687,
0.0201733168,
0.0036868674,
0.0319394097,
-0.0535045378,
0.0294965915,
0.0197317488,
0.0014315839,
-0.0438212901,
-0.0255988073,
0.0036796024,
0.0233600941,
-0.0529782474,
0.0102604302,
0.0117090167,
-0.0174306594,
0.0390876308,
0.0219782125,
0.0111777885,
-0.0319066346,
0.0687685907,
-0.0344000533,
-0.0293623023,
0.0531522222,
0.0208873078,
0.0585243031,
0.0048354738,
-0.0092401318,
0.0258647222,
-0.0106687639,
0.0282488111,
0.0176016707,
0.0210562665,
0.0125343353,
0.0224886555,
0.0146863312,
0.0305217505,
0.0472756252,
0.0024377033,
0.0171478353,
0.0509314351,
-0.0581010468,
0.0070395116,
-0.0336252451,
-0.0940682665,
-0.0074466895,
0.0155390585,
0.0673340037,
0.0032595086,
0.0289340373,
-0.0251547638,
0.0013557296,
-0.0070657204,
0.0016590081,
-0.0146871246,
0.0437679812,
-0.0271635652,
0.0237833448,
-0.0105502196,
0.0099001899,
0.0653024465,
-0.0096507454,
0.1129583716,
-0.0128494883,
-0.0056150951,
-0.0785555542,
-0.0419140607,
0.0236657262,
0.010834028,
0.0248043872,
-0.0514960214,
-0.016724458,
-0.006799086,
-0.0080995671,
0.0604372695,
0.0202806108,
-0.0132413367,
0.0244119186,
0.0352439843,
0.0136898737,
0.0084946211,
-0.0210712664,
-0.0554475114,
0.0086614015,
-0.0068662209,
0.024116803,
-5.066068411e-33,
0.0003495139,
-0.0128675997,
0.0532067232,
0.0420686528,
0.0091721322,
-0.024227947,
-0.0058421474,
-0.0052703219,
0.0325963125,
0.0041959258,
-0.0227333456,
-0.0148839522,
0.0314854756,
-0.0281746145,
0.0389981493,
0.0289049,
0.0554907545,
-0.0412248708,
-0.0471964367,
0.0067469385,
0.0139744449,
0.0335364826,
0.0420512743,
-0.0438469648,
-0.0372048803,
0.0157247689,
-0.0186409857,
0.0419783518,
-0.0443146154,
0.0260026548,
0.0406742804,
0.0159363709,
-0.023429092,
-0.00804363,
-0.0259097274,
-0.058187671,
-0.0259983223,
-0.0579783805,
-0.0440617353,
-0.009685697,
-0.0313331895,
-0.0599376373,
0.0460925363,
-0.0057916045,
-0.0390977338,
0.0125468494,
0.0357117057,
-0.0122677302,
0.0025541754,
-0.0457620993,
-0.0194549207,
0.0340373293,
-0.0271108486,
-0.0518764183,
0.0026681945,
-0.0527195744,
0.0066811419,
-0.0123019964,
-0.0458009727,
0.0202101879,
0.0138985924,
0.0047749714,
0.0470024459,
0.0279832464,
0.0053889793,
0.0325572193,
0.0431910083,
0.0308007561,
0.0565293133,
-0.0128637571,
0.0101303291,
0.1202072129,
0.0124190943,
0.0254807081,
-0.0375918485,
0.0004972492,
0.0122297294,
0.0874005482,
0.0725462586,
0.0417979509,
0.0189858247,
0.0154981371,
-0.0220957194,
0.0312746614,
-0.0211998057,
-0.0662432015,
0.0097039677,
-0.0283727851,
0.0265565235,
0.0280441288,
-0.0119880689,
-0.0442647636,
0.006464357,
-0.0078870244,
0.0772955716,
-0.023624314,
-0.0121106263,
0.0227339622,
0.0130483015,
-0.0195243154,
-0.0334716924,
-0.0581693165,
-0.0355127752,
-0.029570723,
0.054746218,
-0.0298510194,
-0.0050456049,
0.0388779752,
-0.0440897904,
0.0330741927,
-0.0726519451,
0.0110361548,
0.0199449584,
-0.0545782521,
-0.0065738265,
-0.0333533622,
0.0074532595,
0.004393043,
-0.0184331629,
-0.04038205,
-0.0179804452,
0.0374116749,
0.0098395972,
0.0120214177,
0.0045709871,
0.0134272166,
-0.0686730966,
0.0168976467,
-0.0004873214,
-0.0101639982,
-0.0144586517,
-0.0023139273,
2.659e-7,
-0.0365431085,
0.00932498,
0.0227364786,
0.0549356267,
0.0085216267,
0.0644645765,
-0.0320458636,
0.0182880517,
-0.0527259223,
-0.0069327783,
0.0098259998,
0.0292825457,
0.031440977,
0.013207701,
-0.032595396,
0.0170682333,
0.0214904509,
0.0302641504,
-0.0669279471,
-0.0622198023,
-0.0209891163,
0.0429360792,
0.0501868799,
-0.0397547446,
0.0167734716,
-0.0400756523,
-0.0227062907,
-0.0244623758,
-0.0033460401,
0.0592683367,
-0.0253947284,
0.033129245,
-0.0060219588,
0.0069678542,
-0.0074328524,
0.0338319987,
-0.0246748775,
0.0558181256,
0.0204814337,
-0.0340735167,
0.0147856995,
-0.0334288552,
0.0163292326,
0.0033995234,
0.0372246355,
0.0145097328,
-0.024862187,
-0.0393247493,
-0.0105282729,
-0.0132803386,
0.0019740814,
-0.0170608759,
0.007260568,
0.0312362071,
-0.0221910328,
-0.0281547941,
-0.0291874129,
-0.0309470296,
0.0067685107,
0.0120893018,
-0.034533862,
-0.0927452818,
0.0129301585,
0.0130359093,
-0.0184264407,
-0.0126568191,
-0.0174007379,
2.391621776e-34,
-0.0108183045,
-0.0089721242,
0.0230527986,
0.1017512977,
0.0181275252,
0.0106018484,
-0.0304325894,
0.0091430163,
0.0194639619,
0.0070721395,
-0.0047747972
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08317v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08317v1
|
SpeechGuard: Exploring the Adversarial Robustness of Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-05-14T04:51:23 | 2024-05-14T04:51:23 |
Raghuveer Peri, Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Srikanth Ronanki, Anshu Bhatia, Karel Mundnich, Saket Dingliwal, Nilaksh Das, Zejiang Hou, Goeric Huybrechts, Srikanth Vishnubhotla, Daniel Garcia-Romero, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Kyu J Han, Katrin Kirchhoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Integrated Speech and Large Language Models (SLMs) that can follow speech
instructions and generate relevant text responses have gained popularity
lately. However, the safety and robustness of these models remains largely
unclear. In this work, we investigate the potential vulnerabilities of such
instruction-following speech-language models to adversarial attacks and
jailbreaking. Specifically, we design algorithms that can generate adversarial
examples to jailbreak SLMs in both white-box and black-box attack settings
without human involvement. Additionally, we propose countermeasures to thwart
such jailbreaking attacks. Our models, trained on dialog data with speech
instructions, achieve state-of-the-art performance on spoken question-answering
task, scoring over 80% on both safety and helpfulness metrics. Despite safety
guardrails, experiments on jailbreaking demonstrate the vulnerability of SLMs
to adversarial perturbations and transfer attacks, with average attack success
rates of 90% and 10% respectively when evaluated on a dataset of carefully
designed harmful questions spanning 12 different toxic categories. However, we
demonstrate that our proposed countermeasures reduce the attack success
significantly.
|
[
0.0329166651,
0.0861186907,
-0.0119016608,
0.0487893075,
-0.0144004943,
-0.0018592855,
0.0310809333,
-0.0172485728,
0.039313402,
-0.0636762604,
-0.0367705822,
-0.0279513244,
-0.0060529821,
0.009770372,
0.0788727254,
-0.0284918956,
0.0505156964,
-0.070559524,
-0.0359183513,
-0.0043288716,
0.0384043716,
-0.0096592801,
-0.0196921285,
0.0405438431,
0.0066588712,
-0.0341866538,
-0.0080041215,
0.0180863217,
0.0113495812,
-0.0265222453,
0.0260451399,
0.0357072093,
0.0054337378,
0.0684962347,
0.0000018647,
-0.018266961,
-0.0079719564,
0.015543595,
-0.0042331167,
0.0367573127,
0.0067043109,
-0.0357280858,
-0.00892857,
0.0387315005,
-0.0213146899,
-0.0002594729,
0.0211979263,
0.0535490364,
0.108118616,
0.0812501088,
-0.0022873967,
-0.0161966067,
0.0755766183,
-0.0270905476,
-0.000765382,
-0.0714192241,
0.0195513256,
-0.0227898527,
-0.0290054958,
0.02534559,
-0.0207788609,
0.0316281207,
0.0110071423,
-0.007001942,
-0.0479131788,
-0.0067341402,
-0.0292922817,
-0.0302597452,
-0.0078318119,
0.1094871461,
-0.0193618275,
-0.0056455117,
-0.0006188203,
0.0282231737,
0.0212516561,
0.006840948,
-0.0656131729,
0.0202941932,
0.0258968975,
-0.0340990908,
-0.0244222637,
-0.0382250659,
0.0331026204,
0.0157097541,
0.0160263702,
0.0086310375,
0.0390309803,
-0.0102423541,
-0.0030770509,
-0.0367517918,
-0.045802407,
-0.053970132,
0.0085040694,
0.0153047722,
-0.0260078367,
0.0139283631,
-0.0956277177,
-0.0343470201,
0.0255551301,
-0.0404768214,
0.0207100026,
0.0015846437,
-0.034369804,
0.0321967304,
-0.005741945,
0.032890223,
-0.0502029583,
0.0295608155,
-0.0004632327,
-0.0010030268,
-0.014190197,
-0.0363662019,
0.0008826285,
0.0156024424,
-0.0389793776,
-0.018483961,
0.0025691926,
0.02903172,
-0.0222447552,
0.0269410852,
-0.0432801619,
0.0374815576,
0.0068257116,
-0.0019205819,
0.0167766046,
-0.006621182,
-0.0153567549,
0.0114278859,
0.008597278,
-0.0721816719,
-0.0281388462,
0.0290950481,
-0.0498081073,
-0.0314152539,
-0.0013297707,
0.1339304894,
0.0159441177,
-0.0143855279,
-0.0360796303,
-0.0823758692,
-0.0318554156,
-0.0490376465,
0.0522846729,
-0.045122385,
0.0009080987,
-0.0293223318,
-0.0057529514,
-0.0565292649,
0.0251627937,
0.0217930861,
-0.0300134365,
0.0533359908,
0.0463693962,
-0.0218667388,
0.0074000233,
0.0425427109,
0.0106150871,
0.0553850755,
0.0208257139,
0.0102455402,
0.0669394657,
-0.0379250012,
0.0311635807,
0.0544699579,
0.0368139409,
0.0338224322,
-0.0265960786,
0.0040590502,
0.0143557815,
0.0032625073,
-0.0192286614,
0.0467049666,
-0.0092729256,
-0.0708514303,
0.1330412179,
0.0493426286,
-0.0691935718,
0.0330789499,
-0.0197614059,
-0.0386187993,
0.0167311523,
0.00522407,
-0.066265665,
0.0092185251,
-0.0751960576,
-0.0336765908,
-0.0007743349,
0.0489159934,
-0.0125864381,
0.000177759,
0.0375952944,
-0.014241565,
0.0204340611,
0.0199672356,
0.0056702793,
0.0321428515,
-0.0222266559,
0.0383126214,
-0.011409766,
-0.0082629919,
-0.0194398593,
-0.0449759141,
-0.0069829701,
0.0198889934,
0.0557646118,
-0.019090876,
-0.0019389676,
-0.0597139932,
0.040935345,
0.0300432891,
0.0094504785,
0.0037948946,
0.040593639,
-0.0321345925,
-0.0047142603,
-0.0266863257,
0.0000335479,
0.0218708366,
0.0203191135,
-0.0088598859,
-0.0076343738,
0.0099313464,
-0.0154739041,
0.0210413709,
0.016965054,
-0.0565377586,
0.024762677,
-0.001757268,
0.0291948989,
0.0162755791,
-0.0379226618,
0.0265283789,
0.0628642663,
-0.0175895449,
-0.0056712409,
-0.0090078842,
-0.0440307446,
-0.0430687219,
0.0165995415,
-0.0339783505,
-0.0137856025,
0.089531295,
-0.0311185494,
0.0118750548,
0.0474795774,
-0.0470820628,
0.0008708998,
-0.0058600591,
0.019332502,
0.0119047146,
0.0260323789,
-0.0368679538,
0.0126429442,
-0.0204845816,
-0.0130678387,
0.0036110766,
0.0262609422,
-0.0089874864,
-0.0247514565,
-0.0321405903,
0.0281138625,
-0.0271821786,
0.024567483,
-0.0092552919,
-0.0279600322,
-0.0336457752,
0.0005215947,
-0.0528976731,
-0.0035646281,
-0.017257465,
0.0036246052,
0.029143624,
0.00601205,
0.0109164631,
-0.0188587327,
-0.0255802274,
-0.0259743538,
0.0071727391,
0.0146704102,
-0.0092714122,
-0.0250030272,
-0.0092998371,
-0.0314383246,
-0.0107041048,
-0.0086402837,
0.0671145618,
-0.0405306034,
0.012670055,
-0.0185232572,
-0.0278322939,
-0.0222309306,
0.0724643618,
-0.0185802262,
-0.0442127585,
0.0242233276,
0.023682287,
-0.0135751786,
0.1078793928,
0.0569144189,
0.0179664697,
0.0462391563,
0.0137587246,
-0.0301882811,
0.0112228692,
0.0245494749,
-0.0181366447,
-0.0327371545,
-0.0016887763,
0.0086514801,
0.0435827896,
0.0461812988,
0.0092907632,
-0.005173028,
0.0468930304,
-0.0047142035,
-0.0551711954,
-0.0166061372,
-0.0053019328,
-0.0494210608,
-0.01428812,
-0.022693567,
-0.0461319797,
0.0636538491,
-0.0425255261,
0.0034736507,
0.0050756903,
-0.0658935457,
0.0087501919,
0.0509725697,
0.0056208707,
0.0184343699,
0.0363765098,
-0.0067647244,
-0.0570825711,
-0.0388098359,
0.0222413559,
-0.0200305432,
0.0331654623,
-0.02913462,
-0.0204927716,
-0.0012638464,
-0.0505898781,
-0.0566717722,
-0.0731020942,
-0.0241994802,
-0.0114218537,
0.0321974494,
-0.0308933184,
-0.015401097,
-0.0297167096,
0.0410290584,
-0.0137748681,
-0.0312349647,
0.0140532674,
-0.033770781,
0.0705140531,
0.1044660062,
-0.0026485012,
-0.0049891747,
-0.0144790933,
0.071855098,
0.0774254501,
0.0264418423,
0.0200534798,
-0.0225415286,
-0.0029918044,
0.0046117166,
0.0416205637,
-0.0073695742,
0.0078009106,
0.0640627891,
-0.049506478,
0.0029585445,
0.0547463112,
0.000677085,
0.0189048406,
0.0064213178,
0.018170353,
0.040288005,
0.0110451384,
-0.0007710641,
-0.0597772226,
-0.0511587039,
0.0137489261,
0.0588834211,
-0.0028716703,
-0.0023311737,
-0.0165470764,
-0.109815523,
-0.0100339744,
0.014615736,
-0.0388043299,
-0.0167304594,
-0.0174167752,
-0.0326911174,
0.0075394413,
0.03230666,
0.0029988869,
0.0062502441,
-0.0330492109,
0.0217921417,
-0.033614222,
-0.0060498537,
0.0353385843,
-0.0364621803,
0.0473192222,
0.0987156034,
0.0151788015,
-0.0300341118,
0.0025631487,
0.0510939807,
-0.0051411767,
-0.0210118145,
0.02585629,
0.0683599934,
-0.017671654,
-0.0252487753,
-0.0061322739,
0.0830686539,
-0.0006793939,
-0.011839374,
0.0563146807,
0.0442539379,
-0.0017111578,
-0.023972597,
-0.0518318191,
0.0286327936,
-0.0012452535,
0.0629333183,
0.0205618236,
-0.0711055845,
-0.0380543172,
-0.0663896874,
-0.0317491256,
-0.0553674027,
-0.0486552119,
0.0195164941,
0.0301360413,
0.0032013138,
-0.067542173,
-0.0200253278,
-0.0061588134,
0.0404245444,
-0.0020081899,
0.0064878031,
-0.0297712889,
0.0208436064,
-0.0019782572,
0.0096800989,
-0.0090981172,
0.0517186821,
-0.05375202,
0.0232259836,
0.0297085997,
-0.0253060218,
-0.0274472516,
0.0212619212,
-0.0848817602,
-0.090015091,
-0.0002945599,
0.0616820455,
0.0150743984,
0.0407415666,
-0.0245286003,
-0.0757632107,
0.0443948619,
0.0608442202,
-0.04460489,
0.0159443282,
0.0806778148,
-0.0129515259,
0.0080912709,
0.0302631464,
-0.0453714617,
-0.0100958236,
0.0355771966,
0.0072954325,
-0.0466682091,
0.0015914232,
-0.0080899084,
0.0235760249,
0.0226296261,
0.0058989832,
0.0077918428,
0.02232017,
0.0330681652,
0.0040870733,
-0.0235593934,
-0.0254377183,
0.0392047837,
0.0370506942,
-0.0159607083,
0.021232117,
-0.00564666,
0.0210649278,
0.0147615829,
-0.0202796031,
0.0211874191,
0.0394242257,
0.0261803977,
0.0147837931,
0.0122441771,
-0.0292485766,
0.0593287908,
0.0025711516,
0.0353974253,
-0.0022955057,
0.0744737461,
0.0010457151,
-0.0226466823,
0.0059377942,
0.0196076613,
-0.083297886,
-0.0560742244,
-0.0227194093,
0.0603651144,
0.0077271867,
0.0048024082,
-0.0023447885,
0.0043716491,
-0.0151226632,
-0.0270254202,
0.0013956814,
-0.003914502,
-0.0237566289,
0.0534846634,
0.0235192981,
0.0045830775,
0.0314085856,
0.0777817369,
0.0691836402,
0.0670449063,
0.0200781319,
-0.0165768992,
-0.0346081927,
-0.0356745124,
0.0573431887,
0.0070559792,
-0.0201245882,
0.000089442,
-0.0305997804,
-0.0964950472,
-0.0177591871,
-0.004565944,
0.0308224224,
-0.0188017432,
-0.0143796541,
0.0087108193,
0.0112419752,
0.0181646273,
-0.0331136398,
0.0198158436,
-0.0129661309,
-0.0552571267,
0.0314739756,
-6.049431149e-33,
-0.0012805357,
-0.0335509516,
-0.0294155367,
-0.0369976051,
0.0104643134,
-0.0075566703,
-0.0051168702,
0.0116718337,
-0.0225819144,
-0.0262840111,
0.0044457898,
0.0075199176,
-0.0197236538,
0.0451904498,
-0.0341065191,
-0.0690977871,
0.0119177606,
-0.0325900093,
-0.0184129775,
0.0273821671,
0.0597512834,
0.0150529379,
-0.0026244882,
-0.04370296,
0.0367256887,
-0.0174120869,
-0.0345377401,
0.000784022,
-0.0439941213,
0.0731697753,
-0.0147795016,
0.0196493734,
-0.0036374431,
-0.012816322,
-0.0029179365,
0.0793127716,
-0.0324688107,
-0.0037954568,
0.0037317444,
-0.0047777891,
-0.0498056784,
-0.0219967235,
0.0331684276,
-0.0142367827,
0.0124758659,
-0.0248832479,
-0.0122779747,
-0.0032979967,
-0.0101567991,
-0.0042107794,
-0.0130337011,
0.002874813,
-0.0396392979,
-0.0469040982,
-0.0217891634,
0.0559628084,
0.0306984019,
0.0076413485,
-0.0185101405,
0.0106172599,
0.0244182143,
0.0137873087,
0.0442722924,
0.0119326664,
0.0049309903,
0.0696911886,
0.0148654226,
-0.0270912126,
-0.0012350706,
-0.0124756517,
-0.0064187772,
0.0472374856,
0.0811506584,
0.089935109,
0.0338969044,
-0.0219352935,
-0.0730536208,
-0.0122542372,
-0.0117889326,
0.0243204311,
0.0279982612,
0.0006343217,
-0.0105134668,
0.0057394952,
-0.0641892925,
-0.0238749459,
-0.0391306505,
-0.0146397166,
0.0569748431,
0.0227311533,
-0.0389163233,
-0.0113347042,
0.0240719691,
-0.0603251234,
-0.0074927672,
0.0342040993,
-0.0218631923,
-0.0136348493,
0.0064251204,
0.0300909877,
-0.0132129621,
0.0300214514,
0.0515330993,
-0.0549132526,
0.03343812,
0.0040548523,
0.0329267234,
0.0249697473,
-0.0555039346,
-0.0229511429,
-0.0244240426,
0.0559370853,
0.0007120423,
0.020684205,
0.029970495,
-0.0076720212,
-0.0270155631,
0.0089727202,
0.0102699762,
0.0055440674,
-0.0435017496,
-0.0296249054,
-0.0263308175,
0.0099988123,
-0.0278798752,
-0.02612908,
-0.0012170544,
-0.0350749753,
0.0259259529,
-0.0921484455,
0.007268812,
-0.0286091659,
2.642e-7,
-0.034654621,
0.0272301454,
0.0139984246,
0.0127248857,
0.0551957935,
0.0762798563,
-0.0171082653,
0.0724090934,
0.0108753974,
-0.0478632152,
-0.0461655594,
-0.0045866701,
0.0746420696,
0.030828381,
-0.0473016798,
-0.0315744653,
-0.0893069133,
-0.0054493961,
-0.0525040105,
-0.0248777326,
0.031979654,
0.1166296303,
-0.0033410231,
-0.030060418,
0.0167281963,
-0.069642961,
0.031932272,
-0.0177839734,
-0.0044216514,
-0.0479632989,
0.0267136451,
0.0234885812,
0.006208193,
0.0158116687,
-0.0241842177,
-0.029685827,
-0.0043612984,
0.0724889338,
0.0136368806,
-0.0644738302,
-0.047077693,
-0.0130926389,
-0.0008304549,
-0.020620618,
0.0770774037,
-0.0104408348,
-0.0198370293,
-0.048227746,
-0.0119784139,
-0.0328713655,
0.0253024437,
-0.0520236157,
-0.0056697624,
-0.0235359687,
0.0127782822,
0.0115092443,
0.0265072696,
-0.0598693453,
-0.0100451196,
0.0043749451,
-0.0257173777,
-0.0549593121,
-0.029817706,
0.0102456762,
0.0156544112,
-0.0335220397,
-0.0105837286,
2.396032405e-34,
0.0098357135,
-0.0323160551,
0.0304728355,
0.008933357,
0.0438247994,
-0.0022229427,
0.02687479,
-0.0211044848,
0.0328017808,
-0.0699040964,
-0.0385981388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08311v1
|
A Decoupling and Aggregating Framework for Joint Extraction of Entities and Relations
| 2024-05-14T04:27:16 | 2024-05-14T04:27:16 |
Yao Wang, Xin Liu, Weikun Kong, Hai-Tao Yu, Teeradaj Racharak, Kyoung-Sook Kim, Minh Le Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Named Entity Recognition and Relation Extraction are two crucial and
challenging subtasks in the field of Information Extraction. Despite the
successes achieved by the traditional approaches, fundamental research
questions remain open. First, most recent studies use parameter sharing for a
single subtask or shared features for both two subtasks, ignoring their
semantic differences. Second, information interaction mainly focuses on the two
subtasks, leaving the fine-grained informtion interaction among the
subtask-specific features of encoding subjects, relations, and objects
unexplored. Motivated by the aforementioned limitations, we propose a novel
model to jointly extract entities and relations. The main novelties are as
follows: (1) We propose to decouple the feature encoding process into three
parts, namely encoding subjects, encoding objects, and encoding relations.
Thanks to this, we are able to use fine-grained subtask-specific features. (2)
We propose novel inter-aggregation and intra-aggregation strategies to enhance
the information interaction and construct individual fine-grained
subtask-specific features, respectively. The experimental results demonstrate
that our model outperforms several previous state-of-the-art models. Extensive
additional experiments further confirm the effectiveness of our model.
|
[
0.0444750562,
0.0144724529,
0.0254383851,
0.0610197261,
-0.0192277953,
0.0622639097,
-0.01619149,
-0.0067533129,
-0.0043237559,
-0.0534807406,
-0.0213192776,
-0.0211039018,
0.0013029586,
0.0054724715,
-0.0220699236,
-0.0624732412,
0.0226764455,
0.01402051,
0.0278759543,
0.037563432,
0.0059856051,
0.0206781868,
-0.0250527151,
-0.0235803127,
-0.0379760712,
0.0230507515,
-0.0007393378,
-0.0165150203,
0.0352515243,
-0.0125070084,
-0.0042009433,
0.0262958501,
-0.0028122398,
0.0122409333,
0.0000017779,
-0.0404290892,
-0.038521383,
0.0311366785,
-0.03451645,
-0.0583362021,
-0.0111648049,
-0.0442015715,
-0.0126057882,
-0.0333148837,
-0.0191367269,
-0.101096794,
0.0357166529,
0.099536553,
-0.0092059849,
0.0365138091,
-0.0432090312,
-0.031195417,
0.0682676286,
-0.0287739616,
-0.0121111432,
-0.0303264856,
0.0286699142,
-0.0197373629,
-0.0337416567,
0.0110159945,
0.0165555999,
0.0083935559,
0.0032266863,
0.0212371852,
0.0078004366,
0.0573925115,
-0.0284319296,
-0.0249408707,
-0.0196733419,
0.0772772506,
-0.0197679084,
0.0544940159,
0.0466267951,
0.014584613,
-0.005716817,
0.0097081847,
-0.0173337255,
-0.0189753231,
-0.0515155904,
-0.0007245543,
0.0258517154,
0.0205355603,
0.0056358725,
0.0113994796,
-0.009407945,
-0.0195017718,
-0.0054205847,
-0.0236976277,
0.019374676,
0.0435733795,
0.0058814879,
-0.0375659168,
0.0381185859,
0.0321442522,
0.0429481752,
0.0281674061,
-0.0270798076,
-0.0395364724,
-0.0254076067,
-0.05180379,
-0.0196953975,
-0.0004187823,
-0.0279400758,
0.0808076262,
-0.0605411492,
0.0077109234,
-0.0078585269,
-0.0166024193,
0.0039281962,
-0.0215515681,
-0.0516904742,
0.0104392143,
-0.0227650702,
0.0970094651,
-0.038891606,
-0.0180250201,
0.0055702268,
0.0025257557,
0.0031350893,
0.0218090024,
-0.0090115266,
0.0079923104,
-0.0143714026,
-0.0025663066,
-0.0005177828,
0.0276064593,
-0.0491766408,
0.0081178155,
0.0001415058,
-0.0214583538,
-0.0172899514,
-0.0517839268,
0.0525233671,
-0.0487953164,
0.0051234458,
0.092227377,
0.000862062,
-0.0609972477,
-0.0323727988,
-0.0537791997,
0.0086449347,
-0.0290263146,
0.0438961573,
-0.026644757,
0.1140362322,
0.0243727304,
-0.0012841031,
-0.0343726352,
0.0314595997,
-0.0280575696,
-0.0796741769,
0.0777358562,
-0.0266775712,
-0.010634277,
0.0030715859,
0.0221013818,
0.0380783752,
0.0714203566,
0.0466522947,
0.0259974189,
0.0388960242,
0.0142771006,
-0.0255712233,
0.0024605673,
0.0191090573,
-0.0314666368,
0.0447791293,
-0.0097337086,
0.0061801053,
-0.0385713428,
0.0383818969,
0.0405232012,
-0.0201950278,
0.0019780258,
0.0197101161,
0.027908558,
0.0177060347,
0.0265865307,
0.0142232431,
-0.0018711215,
0.0260206889,
0.0511378832,
-0.0511277057,
0.0276957117,
-0.0179032907,
0.0223303605,
-0.0210373234,
0.0614825673,
-0.0143801961,
-0.0150630455,
0.0204335786,
-0.0354278684,
0.0012867345,
0.0104084695,
0.0752018616,
0.0216212999,
-0.029266512,
0.043598704,
0.06248625,
-0.0297791176,
-0.004032481,
0.006404507,
-0.0157480706,
0.0246343985,
0.0190342702,
-0.019373104,
-0.0442443825,
-0.0044903015,
-0.0351910144,
-0.0012109288,
0.036952205,
-0.0410450362,
0.0529445298,
-0.0203948785,
-0.0667206645,
0.0418318138,
-0.0094815632,
0.0104051307,
0.0160964616,
-0.0108995261,
0.0357005671,
0.038721174,
0.0065583279,
0.029548768,
-0.0138309225,
-0.0404644124,
-0.0096055958,
0.0512245595,
0.0166461114,
0.0563576221,
-0.0104388706,
-0.0198429767,
0.0475790687,
-0.0287816543,
-0.0019050462,
0.0020121895,
-0.017371377,
-0.0442534313,
-0.02342082,
0.0479158945,
-0.0239817761,
-0.044585932,
-0.0172628853,
-0.0364545025,
-0.0477290191,
0.0297130011,
0.0569137894,
-0.0015108819,
0.0063800686,
0.0603140555,
0.0084317317,
-0.0529377274,
0.0730231032,
-0.009958975,
-0.027718883,
-0.0104030697,
-0.0763184577,
-0.0322985575,
-0.0238638073,
-0.0096337916,
0.0358215421,
0.0023060532,
-0.0397556536,
-0.0053673163,
-0.0210687127,
-0.0579095557,
-0.0458665676,
-0.0631390736,
0.0121456189,
0.0114028128,
0.0645637065,
0.0041369316,
0.025348518,
-0.0245970935,
-0.0152802812,
-0.0101343412,
-0.0093843006,
-0.0360805131,
0.0136298789,
0.0085979942,
0.0563454777,
0.0058893673,
-0.0207980275,
-0.0040810443,
-0.0420059264,
0.0304203108,
0.0112444898,
-0.0784157515,
-0.0060499157,
0.0419287793,
-0.0349549688,
0.0456123762,
0.0171752721,
0.002933675,
-0.0401821882,
0.0089515792,
0.0251937788,
0.0378162973,
-0.0329190269,
0.0771364868,
-0.0260781571,
-0.0551764295,
-0.0239218641,
0.0501515418,
-0.0536047108,
0.0388956666,
0.0085046841,
0.002253378,
-0.000509318,
0.0630872622,
-0.0196830127,
0.0273898393,
-0.0129386699,
0.0074484041,
0.0013322515,
-0.0192051474,
-0.0181050897,
0.023800971,
0.0188282561,
-0.0005209617,
-0.0914413109,
0.0003576529,
0.0784173906,
-0.0219736006,
-0.0072527179,
-0.0039837393,
0.0281367674,
-0.0433463752,
0.0883709267,
-0.0058501177,
0.0195591021,
0.0282960124,
-0.0525472164,
-0.0186856557,
0.0382885933,
-0.0060241986,
-0.0326864421,
0.0417396091,
-0.0185446981,
0.0179474615,
-0.0292983539,
-0.005410057,
-0.0196688604,
-0.0077304337,
-0.0165708307,
0.0081881024,
-0.0140148755,
-0.0104291914,
0.0169960111,
0.0400170758,
0.0142526366,
0.0010718509,
0.0016098702,
-0.0106937904,
-0.0257739071,
0.0658340678,
0.0374103524,
0.0264573675,
-0.0286430344,
0.0174660161,
0.0243178066,
0.0496622548,
0.0269798748,
-0.003887482,
0.0411031172,
0.0165953562,
0.0179422665,
-0.0490117893,
-0.0118407467,
-0.0345520116,
0.0334057622,
-0.0561529398,
0.0203909222,
0.1089771017,
0.0235464815,
-0.0270781126,
-0.0388364904,
0.0500568077,
0.0102203712,
0.0035084514,
0.0132666714,
-0.0230321959,
-0.0233059116,
0.0133757889,
-0.0299842618,
0.0182650518,
-0.0608184002,
-0.0077981232,
-0.0848179162,
-0.0036752787,
0.0038430097,
-0.0483281687,
-0.0159273706,
-0.0524280369,
0.0461626053,
-0.0209619552,
-0.0129950354,
-0.0133736543,
-0.0365231,
-0.0091950335,
-0.0013242655,
0.0303890742,
-0.046447821,
-0.0019259178,
-0.0376661867,
0.0099762045,
0.055014275,
0.0227839202,
0.0035258043,
0.0330536366,
-0.0111335581,
-0.060864795,
-0.0193025693,
-0.0356485248,
0.0920055881,
-0.0717574954,
-0.0173490364,
-0.030554533,
-0.015567679,
-0.0468123481,
-0.009983521,
-0.0182815325,
0.0385797769,
0.01861264,
0.0074839676,
0.007949614,
-0.0558748804,
0.0082225371,
0.0855621099,
-0.0008960424,
-0.0022952692,
-0.0007868319,
0.026332926,
-0.003206491,
-0.0060381801,
0.0067914538,
-0.0127269523,
-0.0649517626,
-0.0294087734,
-0.0539340191,
-0.093688339,
0.072465539,
0.0301054064,
0.015086527,
0.0272605382,
0.0551923178,
0.0187161826,
-0.0736828297,
0.0218465105,
-0.0005448816,
-0.0116574699,
-0.0005870325,
-0.0179005358,
0.0005181156,
-0.0116475001,
-0.0365236141,
0.0000451751,
-0.0458961613,
-0.046163857,
0.0131103853,
0.012491839,
0.0134354513,
0.0386940092,
-0.0036946605,
-0.024334535,
-0.0130670685,
0.011660126,
-0.0623653084,
-0.0040354514,
0.0072719427,
-0.0115035744,
-0.0178821329,
0.0244423579,
-0.0426418297,
0.0350229703,
-0.004108693,
0.0208037179,
-0.067601338,
-0.0240313467,
0.003005445,
-0.0133924,
0.0688581467,
0.0164724085,
0.0122833895,
-0.0551410429,
0.0240927357,
-0.0170938764,
-0.0015802791,
-0.0423284024,
0.0040846276,
0.00342977,
0.0084989965,
0.006792089,
0.046326831,
0.0442248061,
0.0120573109,
-0.0390337147,
-0.0303682517,
-0.0115401419,
0.010158808,
0.0004320044,
-0.0101723047,
0.0101247197,
0.045252949,
0.0261723213,
-0.0079669794,
-0.0383571014,
0.0163325164,
-0.0006518894,
-0.028353082,
-0.0179178249,
0.0239135008,
-0.0298769306,
0.0440816879,
-0.0437833108,
0.0445614308,
0.0212984886,
-0.0392941423,
0.0506934188,
0.0106595997,
-0.0096381847,
0.0186592657,
0.0136046987,
-0.0133636147,
0.0273678508,
0.021460006,
0.0333231501,
-0.0198862925,
-0.0235490147,
0.0720616505,
-0.0190033503,
0.0336906761,
0.0130016916,
-0.0072553754,
-0.0258095842,
-0.0254140273,
0.0183163974,
0.001154242,
-0.0152504155,
0.0143616032,
-0.0300204251,
-0.0233526174,
0.0167213846,
-0.0425685123,
-0.0022590344,
0.0134356963,
0.0242023654,
0.0194724724,
0.0150362337,
-0.0632188618,
-0.0290858652,
-0.0024244543,
-0.0310409367,
-0.0066493014,
0.007692399,
-6.048562753e-33,
-0.0925748497,
-0.0157563668,
-0.0004625573,
0.0474451259,
-0.0257423501,
0.0582604483,
-0.0118356533,
-0.0036671527,
-0.0202082936,
0.0047996053,
0.0047811596,
-0.0019408769,
0.0425917841,
0.0015008502,
-0.0241185706,
-0.0237922482,
0.0300510284,
0.0223554317,
0.0170478728,
0.0211701244,
0.0339730419,
0.0645888448,
0.0485723987,
-0.1120604873,
0.0247305427,
0.0105918907,
0.0249538701,
0.0239217505,
0.0685720667,
0.0706279874,
-0.0287181996,
-0.0080250762,
0.0409973823,
-0.0089699626,
0.0059712012,
0.0498319454,
-0.2089165151,
-0.0029606884,
-0.0201736651,
0.0146769537,
-0.0278432518,
-0.0289606098,
0.0170592722,
0.0075830771,
0.0634646267,
-0.0513465293,
0.0080743087,
-0.0312049072,
-0.002278981,
-0.0411828533,
-0.0478077158,
0.0291759092,
0.0610516481,
-0.0007024179,
0.085594438,
-0.0248501301,
0.0560381301,
-0.0319503956,
-0.0493152775,
-0.0426239297,
-0.0066918847,
0.0138471657,
0.0252324808,
0.0459887572,
-0.0164418351,
0.0507431701,
-0.0026981083,
-0.0103561124,
-0.0403881893,
0.0189891402,
-0.0240788087,
0.0687178075,
-0.0503873304,
-0.0001846163,
0.0176222119,
0.0029110967,
-0.0565412901,
0.0292996559,
0.0152457366,
0.0480154864,
-0.0610772446,
-0.003201369,
-0.0658244193,
0.0183873083,
-0.0056264605,
0.0093417307,
-0.022455778,
-0.0340260342,
0.0059158802,
0.0301924739,
-0.0441242233,
0.0690646321,
-0.0043083304,
0.0043598092,
-0.0180146322,
0.0045663444,
0.0355054811,
0.0359667949,
-0.0183517858,
-0.0429544523,
-0.0614526831,
-0.0529570282,
0.0030149561,
-0.0073485123,
0.0018560609,
0.0219888389,
0.0605247393,
-0.0400142968,
-0.0380203016,
-0.0151111828,
-0.0272799749,
0.0179666001,
-0.0079279207,
0.0183945317,
0.0294511374,
0.0088249324,
-0.0177826397,
0.0081157647,
0.0698946416,
0.0198723413,
-0.0480877347,
0.0427211635,
0.0029036093,
0.0227539483,
0.0504447035,
-0.0127654057,
0.0009862345,
-0.0481904857,
0.0374088548,
-0.0249380618,
-0.001835636,
0.0012682144,
2.567e-7,
0.0130061731,
-0.0016603485,
0.0705441833,
-0.0031773939,
-0.0034042688,
0.0266239401,
0.0400629491,
0.0549507327,
0.0024047468,
-0.0329337493,
-0.0174391065,
0.018704081,
-0.0070082196,
0.0359500311,
-0.0548091307,
-0.050223697,
0.0132973464,
-0.0471263081,
-0.0506853983,
0.0133319274,
0.0661044121,
0.0513241254,
0.0243480429,
0.0059411959,
-0.049456507,
-0.0324197672,
0.0541277528,
-0.008431864,
-0.0027756677,
0.0521353036,
-0.0188630018,
0.0364559703,
-0.0238528065,
0.0659821257,
-0.0218000617,
0.0303844921,
0.0267624501,
0.0479265861,
-0.0331655443,
-0.0189990755,
-0.0086534256,
-0.0266319718,
0.0141763128,
0.0333387703,
0.0897178873,
-0.0651743561,
-0.002206997,
0.0000709387,
-0.0075010085,
0.0459720045,
-0.0620043352,
0.0409399532,
-0.0191231612,
0.0398003347,
0.0303756595,
-0.0131020509,
-0.0582752861,
-0.0933154374,
-0.0089764195,
0.0644611344,
0.0237798896,
-0.0152415577,
-0.0138890622,
-0.0568618588,
0.0019911795,
-0.0587055087,
-0.0459392108,
2.329383483e-34,
-0.0703312308,
0.0305489916,
-0.0111146597,
0.066278927,
-0.0029174448,
-0.0506403632,
-0.0888937339,
0.0100242216,
-0.034386836,
-0.0460075699,
0.0230420977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08304v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08304v2
|
Computational Thought Experiments for a More Rigorous Philosophy and Science of the Mind
| 2024-05-14T03:58:19 | 2024-05-15T02:32:00 |
Iris Oved, Nikhil Krishnaswamy, James Pustejovsky, Joshua Hartshorne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, q-bio.NC
|
We offer philosophical motivations for a method we call Virtual World
Cognitive Science (VW CogSci), in which researchers use virtual embodied agents
that are embedded in virtual worlds to explore questions in the field of
Cognitive Science. We focus on questions about mental and linguistic
representation and the ways that such computational modeling can add rigor to
philosophical thought experiments, as well as the terminology used in the
scientific study of such representations. We find that this method forces
researchers to take a god's-eye view when describing dynamical relationships
between entities in minds and entities in an environment in a way that
eliminates the need for problematic talk of belief and concept types, such as
the belief that cats are silly, and the concept CAT, while preserving belief
and concept tokens in individual cognizers' minds. We conclude with some
further key advantages of VW CogSci for the scientific study of mental and
linguistic representation and for Cognitive Science more broadly.
|
[
0.0375164635,
0.0273947772,
-0.0798340291,
0.013382256,
-0.0402873456,
-0.0049834237,
-0.0020351924,
0.0003357578,
0.0259301867,
-0.042514015,
-0.0298532918,
-0.0287385304,
0.0350320078,
-0.0233492497,
0.0772214606,
-0.0552087575,
0.0452093557,
-0.0240807403,
-0.0051385816,
0.0006989614,
-0.0445118658,
-0.0071107764,
-0.0362763442,
0.018521687,
0.0095133632,
-0.0181292444,
-0.0557716638,
-0.0221634209,
0.011736894,
-0.0587127171,
-0.0709965676,
-0.054151047,
0.0370267481,
0.0284271147,
0.0000021715,
-0.0173790064,
0.0284518152,
-0.0060102097,
-0.0176471286,
-0.0217732973,
-0.0112800449,
0.0439213365,
-0.0008482058,
-0.0126361931,
-0.0211137757,
-0.0265007596,
0.056096781,
0.0087756636,
-0.0322673209,
0.0083251074,
0.0061338353,
0.0045582913,
-0.0008300019,
0.0342432,
0.0423493721,
0.0638149157,
0.0280383546,
0.053187713,
0.0575531535,
-0.0066326568,
-0.0371588059,
0.0062174597,
0.0277798772,
0.0111262985,
-0.0086351233,
0.0242197271,
-0.0521849915,
-0.0059594614,
0.0289233122,
0.0309425946,
0.0810910091,
-0.0206200108,
0.0104639744,
0.0509683788,
-0.0013598271,
0.0443086214,
-0.0116656013,
0.0405058637,
0.0059469887,
-0.0182018988,
0.0447734408,
0.0471239053,
0.0048326673,
0.0321801864,
-0.0299911126,
0.0519579239,
-0.006064869,
-0.0177686475,
0.0110377269,
0.0102505423,
-0.0532916449,
-0.0385178216,
-0.0251817591,
0.0127545763,
-0.0091064861,
0.0030889604,
0.0099187531,
0.0181548372,
-0.0194020849,
-0.069459796,
0.1008596569,
0.0450750366,
0.0279606581,
0.0158484541,
0.0210336018,
0.0363020487,
-0.0211024582,
0.0356077999,
-0.0033602915,
0.0354556553,
-0.0757744387,
-0.0071817096,
-0.0316844508,
0.066638492,
0.0332717597,
-0.026282493,
0.0137225119,
0.0034995016,
-0.0543510877,
-0.0086788423,
-0.1057419702,
-0.0038757208,
0.0077875839,
0.0409235507,
-0.0367299393,
-0.0005950588,
-0.0379653275,
0.0157991629,
-0.0242804494,
-0.0725729316,
-0.0082712155,
0.0070808101,
-0.0259427931,
0.006210329,
-0.0222319085,
0.0206974689,
0.0420449823,
-0.0175312832,
0.0679591224,
-0.0364171416,
0.0135346781,
-0.0187939778,
0.0185152814,
-0.0091305729,
0.0042080195,
-0.0165902991,
0.0182638168,
0.0072428561,
0.0067202812,
-0.0205661338,
0.0078144642,
0.1065623164,
-0.0175333675,
-0.0244028959,
0.0341499373,
0.029938696,
-0.0014719667,
0.0093477862,
0.0061122961,
-0.0400074571,
-0.0396623723,
-0.0052677453,
0.0104266079,
-0.0231583212,
-0.0006632651,
-0.0356209315,
-0.0336957052,
-0.0160178356,
0.0273098629,
0.0629411563,
-0.034173023,
0.0257598329,
-0.0538503081,
0.0379780233,
0.0503245108,
0.077345252,
-0.0336686857,
0.0133260395,
0.062014211,
-0.0363025256,
0.0396745764,
0.0204259865,
-0.0478917547,
0.0482686907,
0.0120558403,
-0.003906135,
-0.0332739875,
-0.0041681174,
-0.0239258204,
-0.0162408315,
0.0049005821,
0.0090968078,
0.0326091051,
-0.0106197493,
0.0108329346,
-0.013211648,
0.0463318191,
-0.0393498354,
0.0167535376,
-0.0175603256,
-0.0279309098,
-0.0586053059,
0.0332955942,
0.030867964,
0.0382721499,
-0.0211464092,
-0.0095455451,
-0.0094296159,
0.0107083209,
0.0799153149,
0.052037131,
-0.0042217281,
-0.0627327561,
0.0230518486,
0.0330563337,
-0.0466347598,
-0.0104708476,
0.0270577073,
-0.0676425472,
0.0429020599,
-0.0260064881,
0.0667072684,
0.0264809038,
0.0347542726,
-0.018309962,
0.0033509354,
-0.0758353099,
-0.0080970479,
0.0045324964,
-0.003477514,
-0.0022361327,
0.0079294788,
0.025155589,
-0.0033535622,
-0.0095798941,
0.0652173087,
-0.0215941202,
0.0260265637,
0.0264961217,
-0.0917691812,
0.0246020537,
0.0028923606,
0.0584986284,
0.0190887786,
0.065681994,
-0.0434205122,
0.0540006608,
-0.0151092634,
0.020770397,
-0.0306731574,
-0.006217171,
0.0168090258,
0.0176627692,
0.0157328546,
0.0320248865,
0.031034302,
-0.0208529588,
0.0581955649,
-0.0309331585,
0.0059899404,
0.0310592782,
-0.0017815125,
0.0046571349,
-0.0173024796,
-0.0573242493,
-0.0507004596,
-0.0044790311,
-0.0882390887,
-0.0474858768,
0.0288306065,
-0.048001647,
-0.0118395565,
-0.0503978916,
-0.014987044,
0.0056128325,
0.0043596961,
0.0356163122,
0.0006631552,
0.0258887131,
0.0157768242,
-0.0250625014,
-0.0136829112,
-0.0157648586,
0.0428026691,
-0.0409247875,
0.0509820879,
0.0133527322,
-0.0301277526,
-0.0426689088,
0.0020573724,
-0.0962826982,
-0.0137716355,
0.0058156154,
-0.0386209264,
0.0656908527,
0.0197974909,
-0.012143271,
0.0373838395,
-0.0211685896,
0.0182030257,
0.0815226883,
-0.0029308721,
-0.0253326036,
-0.014835787,
0.0284667052,
0.0242517013,
-0.0041166148,
-0.0401063785,
-0.0190084334,
0.0528762229,
0.0232574455,
0.0144599536,
-0.0626991466,
0.1356325895,
-0.0385995954,
-0.0531997718,
0.012481885,
-0.0375005677,
-0.0077738157,
0.0020591761,
-0.0336766429,
0.0204581618,
0.0784843266,
0.0156156067,
-0.009576912,
0.0065551335,
0.0246155281,
0.0329261906,
0.0269527007,
0.0148917167,
0.0114334142,
0.0613993667,
0.033184953,
-0.0654256791,
0.0215139166,
-0.013324487,
-0.0150730489,
-0.0378049202,
-0.0557606257,
0.0092727859,
0.0047265235,
-0.0057458929,
-0.0586593635,
0.0744768381,
-0.0587289892,
0.0172603168,
-0.0099083157,
0.0287622903,
-0.0454842299,
-0.0215896796,
0.0592383668,
-0.0142713422,
0.0212094411,
-0.0453173406,
-0.0387730971,
-0.0656805485,
0.0399149694,
0.0832063109,
0.0414285064,
0.0076941336,
0.036620006,
0.0407375954,
-0.0268557556,
0.0167702641,
-0.0375992209,
-0.0025348209,
-0.0009974864,
-0.02647838,
-0.0085168984,
0.0055157561,
0.0362892635,
-0.0040566917,
-0.0314055532,
0.0574237853,
0.0446893647,
0.0229244884,
0.0444255844,
-0.0430047065,
-0.0428988375,
0.0469900779,
0.0229306221,
-0.0551379099,
0.0370483138,
-0.0147926649,
-0.0565201044,
-0.0432124361,
-0.0580053851,
-0.011387663,
-0.0627245456,
0.0048605283,
0.0109684234,
0.0146644702,
0.0036206683,
0.0150840003,
0.0221469514,
0.0244371332,
-0.0377464741,
-0.0047684694,
0.0219105314,
0.0376940779,
-0.0140120191,
0.0288662985,
0.0482682437,
-0.0037949807,
0.0019280267,
0.065801993,
-0.0027964017,
0.0269675422,
-0.0141849229,
-0.1102450117,
-0.0687461197,
-0.0296139438,
0.0335200466,
0.004256899,
0.0048098336,
0.0003740202,
0.010587181,
-0.0453935713,
-0.0186609626,
-0.0190374888,
-0.0392664038,
0.0242200047,
0.0650246143,
-0.0748299956,
-0.0397000462,
-0.0024458661,
0.0356119648,
0.0002414355,
0.0299150068,
0.0374855325,
-0.0527421795,
0.022339765,
-0.0294458792,
0.0260928292,
0.092955932,
-0.0983541682,
-0.0439156257,
0.04612289,
0.0365899391,
-0.0801439881,
-0.0320514813,
0.0080418624,
0.0343035571,
0.0081470981,
-0.0357089415,
0.0361255221,
-0.0132880062,
-0.0441334173,
0.0167557858,
-0.0222370811,
-0.0027100646,
0.0199111812,
-0.0314779915,
0.0461952202,
-0.0608119778,
0.0048332699,
0.0251519829,
0.0323229693,
-0.0514151454,
0.0164832566,
0.0290433858,
0.0256004352,
-0.0187028702,
0.0235626921,
-0.001337372,
0.0168692991,
-0.0361184031,
-0.0406921878,
0.0585417338,
-0.0211349279,
0.0572033711,
0.0040782401,
0.0017368674,
0.0479248986,
0.0073654307,
-0.0344377011,
-0.0301633328,
-0.0516202077,
-0.0391777791,
0.0280819852,
-0.0080860741,
0.0290540922,
0.0164443273,
0.0335916728,
0.0279773008,
-0.0161478706,
-0.0419106521,
-0.0095888348,
-0.0022387891,
-0.0629527122,
-0.0215809215,
0.0517624356,
0.0241962019,
-0.0305771995,
-0.0270572677,
0.0232919101,
0.0535614528,
-0.0326359384,
0.0039787022,
0.0320276916,
-0.0449089818,
0.0456950292,
0.0091854651,
0.0466955155,
-0.0604440495,
0.0491158776,
-0.018906178,
0.0612296239,
0.0225622356,
-0.0183478463,
-0.0466813333,
0.0055809352,
-0.0406018831,
-0.0945012048,
0.0744712055,
0.0493812189,
-0.0003833761,
0.0179471634,
-0.0107415644,
-0.0495959148,
0.0100551946,
0.0158810262,
0.0343065783,
0.0487916693,
-0.0364508852,
-0.0086935433,
0.0351172499,
-0.0255072564,
-0.0497620665,
-0.0191028919,
-0.0687902644,
0.02150172,
-0.0323295966,
-0.0065919589,
-0.0166336745,
0.0000560799,
-0.028040614,
0.0355412327,
0.0213503428,
0.0212449841,
-0.0846743956,
-0.0372442566,
0.045075085,
0.0229264796,
-0.011231117,
-0.0431011282,
0.0248595327,
-0.0072913822,
0.0395573415,
-0.0180577524,
0.0260095727,
0.0359244198,
-0.0049646166,
-0.0076806764,
-0.0440314971,
-5.794585076e-33,
-0.054230731,
-0.0173522495,
0.0278768335,
0.0088524166,
-0.0643635616,
0.0014381367,
-0.0471347235,
0.0291246511,
-0.0231662709,
0.0075261155,
0.0065649617,
-0.0151931019,
-0.0088572232,
-0.026654236,
0.0408426598,
-0.0073604998,
-0.0024868827,
-0.0117146391,
-0.0389091745,
-0.0436513945,
0.0117128352,
-0.0442784727,
0.010023281,
-0.0825379863,
0.0343350656,
0.0122236339,
0.0334941484,
-0.0335672162,
-0.0312266145,
0.0011090139,
-0.0652602464,
0.0395291373,
0.0170511957,
-0.0014878539,
0.020369783,
0.0233350694,
0.0067792707,
-0.0683877245,
0.0096389474,
-0.0002338097,
-0.0403203256,
-0.016891161,
-0.0274362974,
-0.0054354677,
-0.0163922086,
0.0416687541,
0.0313057862,
-0.030935308,
0.0062367488,
0.028272178,
-0.0663085282,
-0.0582607612,
-0.0022311618,
0.0003330049,
0.0390155539,
-0.0080385273,
-0.0250849165,
-0.0229582787,
-0.056951832,
0.0388157926,
-0.0447632447,
-0.0331460312,
0.0329457894,
-0.0156690814,
0.0459093414,
0.0585681088,
0.0425080098,
0.0486110412,
-0.0889712796,
0.0124191968,
0.031123586,
0.0135387294,
0.0278325751,
0.0679216757,
0.0033843522,
-0.0045035933,
-0.0277051553,
-0.0257100482,
0.0246383958,
-0.0068149697,
0.0312107392,
0.0032440152,
-0.0381693579,
0.0042747487,
0.0195459407,
-0.0146137122,
-0.0098516569,
-0.0349282473,
-0.0215623658,
-0.0484824888,
-0.0229730569,
-0.0282199867,
0.0152747631,
-0.047430899,
-0.0192744769,
-0.0394721813,
-0.0073316973,
0.0409630723,
0.0089790784,
-0.0345822535,
-0.0079054283,
-0.0304119959,
-0.0008025968,
0.0600585863,
0.0441254377,
0.0098785134,
-0.0082160151,
0.0154084675,
0.0088868169,
-0.0122107593,
-0.0016630868,
-0.0176138636,
0.0389685258,
-0.0137906941,
0.0217762403,
0.0276072286,
0.0010693135,
-0.1010522917,
0.0384802222,
-0.028660059,
-0.008481021,
0.0552175827,
-0.0730334818,
0.0256908182,
-0.0078091547,
0.0083557758,
-0.0723407567,
0.0240566712,
0.0434842035,
-0.0756259933,
-0.040966142,
-0.0188105907,
3.1e-7,
-0.0309261717,
0.0320312567,
0.0195118077,
0.0371684283,
0.0446734317,
0.0300304629,
0.0169616938,
0.019761581,
0.0325576961,
-0.0922938287,
-0.0246238504,
0.0328123942,
0.0158577822,
0.0062903496,
-0.0240294039,
-0.0197598357,
0.0384663902,
0.0205196682,
-0.0355405211,
0.0550527349,
0.0281783435,
0.0041178907,
0.0471517779,
0.0043673292,
-0.007661806,
0.0465061814,
0.014307308,
-0.0069705532,
0.040526215,
-0.0185299087,
-0.040009249,
0.0061359648,
-0.0058721961,
0.0301935673,
0.03370516,
0.0065348358,
0.0200197324,
-0.0474768728,
-0.0043055117,
0.0245654769,
-0.0090569146,
-0.0305421352,
-0.0082599232,
-0.0287854448,
0.0545779578,
-0.104325965,
-0.0140141034,
0.0197154097,
-0.0203179717,
-0.0173968431,
0.0119096963,
-0.0069338204,
-0.0195959471,
0.0128247105,
-0.0308699533,
-0.0068106316,
0.0176503807,
-0.0256072171,
0.0138554452,
-0.0413207337,
-0.0249902382,
-0.0272825174,
0.0061570909,
-0.0346429758,
0.0388836563,
-0.0585576333,
0.0086793536,
2.245059441e-34,
-0.0250643175,
0.0485781766,
0.0379017852,
-0.0087129846,
0.0213030502,
-0.0000234765,
0.0182491951,
-0.0063972143,
0.073704645,
-0.0076452885,
-0.0108986627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08295v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08295v2
|
SpeechVerse: A Large-scale Generalizable Audio Language Model
| 2024-05-14T03:33:31 | 2024-05-31T17:47:40 |
Nilaksh Das, Saket Dingliwal, Srikanth Ronanki, Rohit Paturi, Zhaocheng Huang, Prashant Mathur, Jie Yuan, Dhanush Bekal, Xing Niu, Sai Muralidhar Jayanthi, Xilai Li, Karel Mundnich, Monica Sunkara, Sundararajan Srinivasan, Kyu J Han, Katrin Kirchhoff
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown incredible proficiency in performing
tasks that require semantic understanding of natural language instructions.
Recently, many works have further expanded this capability to perceive
multimodal audio and text inputs, but their capabilities are often limited to
specific fine-tuned tasks such as automatic speech recognition and translation.
We therefore develop SpeechVerse, a robust multi-task training and curriculum
learning framework that combines pre-trained speech and text foundation models
via a small set of learnable parameters, while keeping the pre-trained models
frozen during training. The models are instruction finetuned using continuous
latent representations extracted from the speech foundation model to achieve
optimal zero-shot performance on a diverse range of speech processing tasks
using natural language instructions. We perform extensive benchmarking that
includes comparing our model performance against traditional baselines across
several datasets and tasks. Furthermore, we evaluate the model's capability for
generalized instruction following by testing on out-of-domain datasets, novel
prompts, and unseen tasks. Our empirical experiments reveal that our multi-task
SpeechVerse model is even superior to conventional task-specific baselines on 9
out of the 11 tasks.
|
[
-0.0049383268,
0.008983097,
-0.0078047751,
0.0360475145,
-0.0009457836,
0.009545533,
0.0498579443,
-0.053573478,
-0.0506275296,
-0.0544834137,
-0.0720682889,
-0.0300689936,
-0.0105943866,
-0.007842063,
0.034582518,
-0.066147387,
0.0300452299,
-0.0813449696,
-0.0077695544,
0.0081538716,
0.0131019242,
0.026559405,
-0.0486190654,
0.0753734931,
0.0013571798,
-0.043362774,
0.0060040662,
0.0179923978,
0.0108294217,
-0.0269550141,
0.005396171,
0.0309051313,
0.0783818513,
0.017628286,
0.000001806,
-0.0224545859,
0.0230087433,
-0.0243698321,
-0.029334886,
0.0040570474,
0.0243784077,
0.0155940996,
-0.0267196801,
0.0370555371,
-0.0065980223,
-0.0116622653,
0.0224512685,
0.0190514997,
0.0674165487,
0.0550170355,
-0.0115607679,
-0.0422267914,
0.0065002753,
-0.0217657611,
0.0205106791,
-0.0482142232,
-0.0217868686,
-0.0006117548,
0.0303749256,
0.0095242178,
-0.0464035198,
0.0432352498,
0.0175498892,
0.0109969098,
0.0127820903,
0.0219813138,
-0.039177008,
-0.0314175896,
-0.0578037314,
0.1095095202,
-0.0116975727,
-0.0057868673,
-0.0039027133,
0.008394002,
-0.0364027098,
-0.0338109583,
-0.0656097308,
0.043770276,
0.031520661,
-0.0026248849,
-0.0244479049,
0.0245666765,
0.0235970914,
-0.0158951711,
-0.0018030955,
0.0121724913,
0.0144171054,
-0.0301523991,
0.0094577037,
-0.0159222353,
-0.0751692131,
-0.0334827714,
0.0209824145,
0.0317156091,
-0.0646722019,
0.0061225388,
-0.0498495363,
-0.0441819094,
-0.0160949323,
-0.0099228807,
0.0485073291,
0.0588513613,
-0.0798734799,
0.0755976662,
-0.0094693592,
0.0724534467,
-0.0100248409,
0.0069239833,
-0.0060967254,
0.0178564526,
-0.053990148,
0.0065944348,
-0.022532206,
0.0113838585,
-0.0394115373,
-0.0450657718,
-0.0059018927,
0.0140906284,
-0.028901197,
0.0334173888,
0.043580614,
0.0169877019,
-0.06198043,
-0.0054902043,
0.0241431277,
0.0539345481,
-0.0081135975,
0.0700321496,
-0.0170991849,
-0.0173434895,
-0.0024315973,
0.0181492716,
0.0251431763,
-0.0048055062,
0.0339673385,
0.0794282109,
-0.0280729886,
-0.0453260317,
-0.033639431,
0.0009727867,
-0.0205023699,
-0.0720602497,
-0.0155247021,
-0.0434819609,
0.0165525228,
-0.0014371299,
0.0201938599,
-0.0017835356,
-0.0052832467,
0.0078689223,
0.001401399,
0.0643884018,
0.0398971885,
0.0311122127,
0.0290424284,
0.0222290959,
-0.002729465,
0.074789077,
0.0394858681,
0.0144858053,
0.012917364,
-0.0088026403,
-0.0266965199,
0.0898489878,
-0.0213156287,
0.0095420498,
-0.0157481898,
-0.0079097627,
0.0205828026,
0.0302392803,
0.0283009745,
0.0230843388,
-0.0280917175,
0.0044542309,
0.0762462765,
0.0586985834,
-0.0115429685,
-0.0379471369,
0.0785777271,
0.0289733596,
-0.0153597966,
-0.0041575879,
-0.0514213257,
0.0042089261,
0.0160812438,
0.0027562433,
0.0161352735,
0.0196326189,
-0.0443179905,
0.0140976328,
0.0215718709,
-0.0346440002,
-0.007766983,
0.0230625477,
0.0481667407,
0.0098928241,
-0.0783349425,
-0.0201713592,
0.0124348029,
-0.0420918912,
0.0204609688,
0.0047858446,
0.0159337129,
0.0772717148,
0.0186789203,
-0.0325244516,
-0.0342672169,
-0.0386767276,
0.051759433,
0.0425842181,
-0.0016222227,
-0.0123863341,
0.0507512204,
-0.0727493092,
-0.0281536374,
0.0055349828,
0.0131965699,
0.0379521735,
-0.0245779082,
0.0199641958,
0.0044432604,
-0.0101771997,
0.0171661042,
0.0190761704,
-0.0515759923,
-0.03384424,
-0.0088975271,
0.0208650026,
0.0288549904,
0.0336616896,
-0.0349955671,
-0.0233903173,
0.0461159758,
-0.0295325667,
0.0376057625,
0.0220302884,
-0.073439084,
-0.0288697202,
0.0254722666,
-0.0254789144,
0.0047590388,
0.0328420028,
-0.0217855871,
-0.0423018821,
0.0143601419,
0.0153215379,
0.0352607965,
-0.0329940878,
0.0377399102,
0.00892545,
-0.0219693668,
0.0016159447,
-0.0150361517,
0.0204574708,
-0.0109056523,
0.0432223938,
0.0030150954,
0.0059816688,
-0.05872849,
-0.0372986011,
0.0031412798,
0.0001863474,
0.0198701806,
-0.0133633893,
0.0145604797,
-0.0340856686,
-0.0077875848,
-0.1017931253,
0.0378352813,
-0.0321480222,
-0.0067593046,
0.0204439517,
-0.0036405937,
-0.0001912405,
-0.0337861627,
-0.0062113614,
-0.005206841,
-0.0002751775,
-0.0005832855,
-0.0533576719,
0.0029644184,
-0.0139077101,
-0.0183594599,
0.015452126,
0.0080148065,
-0.0015984054,
-0.0249460954,
0.0291507598,
-0.0328232497,
0.0243042577,
0.0093601681,
0.0540890768,
-0.0255762693,
-0.0152303511,
0.0039530164,
-0.012408453,
0.0396433696,
0.0661439821,
-0.0020847935,
0.0031802785,
0.0269442238,
-0.0000688399,
-0.050640773,
0.0149924448,
0.0027239465,
-0.0249538738,
-0.0502653383,
0.0329981633,
-0.0464774147,
0.0521250851,
0.0417954735,
0.0389490463,
-0.0859814882,
-0.0424122699,
-0.0270244423,
-0.0343323052,
-0.0519306213,
-0.0215187278,
-0.0368859023,
-0.0000872749,
-0.0229613893,
-0.009658413,
0.0277389083,
-0.0740051568,
-0.0429761969,
-0.0339343362,
-0.0254876465,
0.0021015019,
0.0292885546,
-0.0223577432,
-0.0038545318,
0.0231624581,
-0.0263477433,
-0.0671667159,
0.022266699,
0.0301020425,
-0.0283707939,
0.0348757096,
-0.0469708852,
-0.0260866676,
-0.0055105258,
-0.0248535667,
-0.0486968011,
-0.0226895753,
-0.0278235506,
-0.0073974999,
-0.0319256186,
-0.0016767422,
-0.0470045246,
0.007818114,
0.0361366905,
0.0750610977,
-0.0122721139,
0.0135101313,
-0.0651187673,
-0.0042072739,
0.0514244772,
0.0031185169,
-0.0582867973,
-0.0465465933,
0.0526571609,
0.0079469513,
0.0647920966,
-0.0259708613,
-0.0420830101,
0.0387287699,
0.0385145098,
0.0247107148,
-0.0389601924,
0.0671954006,
0.0771534294,
-0.0647062808,
0.0150423981,
0.1148768738,
0.0101748481,
-0.0283197723,
-0.0199357998,
0.0377443656,
0.0101073086,
0.0342252664,
-0.0150972502,
-0.0742872804,
-0.06027456,
0.0266681332,
0.038565401,
0.0490531884,
0.0138483681,
-0.003292674,
-0.0909268633,
0.0326775573,
0.0195984263,
-0.0311156157,
0.0022989186,
-0.0175920222,
0.0015855316,
-0.0174094792,
0.0339014605,
-0.0141197434,
-0.0337488353,
-0.0101693152,
0.0304577164,
0.0180040412,
-0.0637313649,
0.0635071993,
-0.0377465487,
0.0744916126,
0.070634447,
0.017108541,
0.0066332407,
-0.0192422848,
0.0145918662,
0.0221999735,
-0.0005111443,
0.0081923334,
0.038672477,
-0.0326360054,
-0.0184609462,
0.0431155674,
0.0599879324,
-0.0175306443,
-0.009843614,
0.033451058,
0.0721454993,
-0.0154754566,
0.0235562176,
0.005074081,
0.0283427592,
0.0236639977,
0.0760330707,
0.0039149164,
-0.0642215014,
0.0010581989,
-0.0001478093,
-0.018266134,
-0.0604312606,
-0.0294028353,
0.0155258123,
-0.0223002154,
0.0046518091,
-0.025394287,
-0.0069447667,
0.0575418882,
0.0543136336,
0.033671882,
0.0064681526,
0.0298500881,
0.0308036786,
-0.0395865105,
0.0368811376,
-0.0098031349,
0.0605520159,
-0.0931662917,
-0.0354096591,
0.037441846,
-0.0545984469,
-0.0314951763,
0.0165304132,
-0.0840781778,
-0.062860705,
-0.0157843195,
0.0222972725,
0.0173783936,
0.0615269579,
-0.0132553661,
-0.0422181636,
0.024823945,
-0.0105012581,
-0.0819537491,
0.0501415096,
0.050590273,
-0.0302303676,
-0.0123693319,
0.0072601778,
-0.0478275754,
0.0542395972,
-0.0052460092,
0.0367229469,
0.0149709061,
-0.0007776471,
-0.0218466725,
-0.0105947684,
0.0624321364,
-0.0225298535,
0.0219254233,
-0.0432185419,
0.0345540233,
0.00276988,
0.022781752,
-0.057295043,
-0.0025302011,
0.027809713,
0.0067399633,
-0.0089168381,
0.0009475943,
-0.0018248755,
0.0203298051,
-0.0637258738,
0.0346130617,
-0.0025413095,
0.0079561854,
0.0349519849,
0.0187551286,
0.0069045131,
0.0289711487,
0.0183676761,
0.0129513955,
-0.0014877472,
0.0846241042,
-0.0118258027,
0.0187144075,
-0.0169809815,
0.0096985111,
-0.0566051453,
-0.0299266707,
-0.0247150213,
0.0415800624,
0.0616621897,
-0.0184517186,
0.0224190857,
-0.0076379841,
0.0145747764,
-0.0316507369,
0.0455379337,
-0.0260453876,
-0.0239792429,
0.0297295321,
0.0084049916,
0.0076065222,
0.023719877,
0.0661465451,
0.013980452,
0.0543275177,
-0.0202369429,
0.048142381,
-0.043925792,
-0.0359228663,
0.0280781239,
0.0358145945,
-0.0060032904,
0.0408833474,
-0.0005270821,
-0.0632992759,
-0.0030615169,
-0.0120569943,
-0.0146012418,
-0.0335746147,
0.0374773666,
0.0102308849,
-0.0432663783,
-0.0007626257,
-0.0072747017,
-0.0512246899,
0.0013765222,
-0.021256173,
-0.0226095207,
-5.598632004e-33,
-0.0326488912,
0.0276368205,
0.0362792723,
0.005960756,
-0.0157792624,
-0.0152889378,
-0.0283656083,
-0.0022331486,
0.0045187129,
-0.018487189,
0.0004869004,
0.0188788641,
0.0232318733,
0.0545580834,
-0.014502814,
-0.0057208324,
0.0900657326,
-0.0569474958,
0.0116731739,
0.0372425504,
0.0508103184,
0.03319766,
0.0365894921,
-0.0729520768,
-0.0032045932,
-0.0008681318,
-0.0158101767,
-0.0017707704,
0.0246054344,
0.0661578849,
-0.0046624006,
0.0250436589,
-0.0125446497,
-0.0691399127,
-0.0309001561,
0.0296020415,
-0.0824681744,
0.0058814134,
0.0175549816,
0.0236333646,
-0.0164697226,
-0.0111224893,
0.0082850195,
-0.017490007,
-0.0173933152,
-0.0206842031,
0.0504852496,
-0.025285244,
-0.0048624063,
-0.0129235163,
-0.0525274165,
-0.0154012386,
-0.0397222079,
-0.0477696061,
0.0478499122,
0.0478023253,
-0.0116598206,
0.0174716692,
-0.0364369862,
0.047834143,
-0.0077095074,
0.0137479538,
0.0594754368,
0.0321473964,
-0.0056026448,
0.041322466,
-0.0139218979,
-0.0514099635,
-0.0052220123,
-0.0184064992,
0.0438909568,
0.0496737696,
-0.0029255757,
0.0355187841,
-0.0047164806,
-0.0012157811,
-0.0542791188,
0.0019578738,
0.011693879,
0.01374075,
0.0245918985,
0.0138880676,
-0.029983988,
0.012219063,
-0.0576425195,
0.0109294355,
-0.0183258355,
-0.0047888537,
0.0878514051,
0.0214540623,
0.0124643482,
-0.0112343514,
0.078265965,
-0.0498813093,
0.0212859213,
0.0371587649,
-0.0360475816,
0.0153098488,
-0.0043007825,
0.0408350788,
-0.0617373511,
-0.0323881432,
0.090712592,
0.0031335282,
0.0340871215,
0.0001429762,
0.0275779162,
0.0472378582,
-0.0492623039,
-0.00779167,
-0.0075644483,
0.0107261324,
0.0136066014,
0.0560187586,
0.0351062343,
-0.0045315968,
-0.0349403247,
0.0702729002,
-0.0296021663,
-0.0468507074,
-0.0241016019,
-0.0683923289,
-0.0124597615,
0.0356025137,
-0.0509887934,
0.0037452928,
-0.0242876578,
-0.034875311,
0.0330470353,
-0.0434297696,
-0.0132246139,
0.008220843,
2.561e-7,
-0.0173867457,
-0.0003014618,
-0.0340848975,
0.0180255789,
0.0328340605,
0.0345508531,
-0.0624599494,
0.0206940267,
0.0160934124,
-0.0143570602,
0.0158541687,
0.0426327735,
0.0486344807,
-0.0134405699,
-0.0882457793,
-0.0034989745,
-0.0444823429,
0.0338166803,
-0.061225228,
0.0056550023,
0.0319901146,
0.0965931639,
-0.0176731441,
0.0070305853,
0.0315668024,
-0.0072996491,
0.041110605,
-0.0215187576,
0.0024976155,
-0.0578346364,
-0.039828591,
0.0153878238,
-0.0473033339,
0.0110566374,
-0.0435551591,
0.0296870265,
0.0231809448,
0.1059274375,
-0.0087895766,
-0.0326693878,
-0.027224917,
0.0318643376,
-0.036830999,
-0.0160861537,
0.0654794276,
-0.050178729,
-0.0158420466,
0.0094491048,
-0.0460632816,
-0.0086406451,
-0.0290164389,
-0.0126473708,
0.0202071331,
-0.0223696809,
0.0241565611,
-0.0140505945,
-0.0212942846,
-0.0834300965,
0.0203077812,
0.0407034904,
-0.0602348335,
-0.0319262482,
-0.0434923135,
-0.0334140435,
0.0052864621,
-0.0562134236,
-0.0119798994,
2.188365028e-34,
0.0286535043,
-0.017133452,
0.0424898043,
-0.0210705772,
-0.009797629,
-0.013045107,
-0.0112535032,
0.0060290899,
0.0246907715,
-0.0834499151,
-0.0378969908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08254v1
|
Detecting Fallacies in Climate Misinformation: A Technocognitive Approach to Identifying Misleading Argumentation
| 2024-05-14T01:01:44 | 2024-05-14T01:01:44 |
Francisco Zanartu, John Cook, Markus Wagner, Julian Garcia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Misinformation about climate change is a complex societal issue requiring
holistic, interdisciplinary solutions at the intersection between technology
and psychology. One proposed solution is a "technocognitive" approach,
involving the synthesis of psychological and computer science research.
Psychological research has identified that interventions in response to
misinformation require both fact-based (e.g., factual explanations) and
technique-based (e.g., explanations of misleading techniques) content. However,
little progress has been made on documenting and detecting fallacies in climate
misinformation. In this study, we apply a previously developed critical
thinking methodology for deconstructing climate misinformation, in order to
develop a dataset mapping different types of climate misinformation to
reasoning fallacies. This dataset is used to train a model to detect fallacies
in climate misinformation. Our study shows F1 scores that are 2.5 to 3.5 better
than previous works. The fallacies that are easiest to detect include fake
experts and anecdotal arguments, while fallacies that require background
knowledge, such as oversimplification, misrepresentation, and slothful
induction, are relatively more difficult to detect. This research lays the
groundwork for development of solutions where automatically detected climate
misinformation can be countered with generative technique-based corrections.
|
[
0.0173231903,
0.0298147313,
-0.0036845184,
0.026612103,
-0.0311420131,
0.0322156474,
0.0367606431,
-0.020133974,
0.0086161792,
-0.0379683226,
0.0081507359,
0.0063598114,
0.0235620607,
0.0206220374,
0.0229683276,
-0.0753628463,
0.0292756204,
0.0088683711,
0.0578861348,
-0.0170724429,
0.0032919033,
-0.0028334123,
-0.0566056669,
0.0069856648,
0.0002024281,
-0.045929417,
0.0258600991,
0.0038752744,
0.0709868148,
-0.0661691874,
0.0429712087,
0.0284721628,
0.0172521714,
0.0465941876,
0.0000019588,
-0.0275564492,
-0.0281433929,
-0.0028861538,
-0.0115464078,
0.0226695538,
0.0728790984,
-0.0015102751,
0.0100701526,
0.0508929305,
-0.0217555668,
-0.0091175437,
0.0577493459,
0.0776159987,
0.0597922131,
0.0318153501,
0.0109284054,
0.0076918043,
0.0034783741,
0.0384632498,
-0.0462868512,
0.0569100119,
0.0516472794,
0.0355216637,
-0.0736152604,
0.0288400427,
0.020935066,
0.0081545319,
-0.0093730558,
-0.0141556207,
-0.0127808731,
0.0011116688,
-0.0281775743,
-0.0251418911,
-0.0239194483,
0.0236890055,
0.0614548624,
-0.0207905918,
0.0033246186,
-0.00955592,
0.0210966486,
0.0419605523,
-0.0427561551,
0.0060736411,
-0.022628678,
-0.0149953449,
0.0185266025,
-0.0014021898,
-0.0054474277,
0.0435343944,
0.0509244427,
0.0627593771,
-0.0393396579,
-0.0343371443,
0.0064078979,
-0.0025460797,
0.0685106888,
-0.0193440542,
-0.0083076898,
-0.0177069157,
-0.0028014805,
0.0073124692,
-0.0015752873,
-0.0112022255,
0.0257538706,
-0.0669240803,
0.0205777436,
-0.0098043457,
0.0148073584,
0.0121547766,
0.0693650469,
-0.0046997755,
-0.009528826,
0.0337484851,
0.008795171,
0.0127951084,
-0.065233849,
-0.0269692224,
0.0062155984,
-0.0288404655,
0.0207559429,
0.0526591651,
-0.0081012491,
-0.0836777985,
-0.0465035588,
-0.0067567551,
-0.0467493422,
0.0164499301,
0.0181030761,
-0.0132094119,
-0.0489528514,
0.0947250724,
-0.0183853414,
0.0402366258,
-0.0012608168,
-0.0384971015,
-0.0363487378,
0.0228760242,
0.0021885089,
0.0187687427,
-0.0108170174,
-0.0243256688,
0.016540736,
0.0343011916,
-0.0443345197,
-0.0283651818,
0.0110099912,
-0.0391056016,
0.0426882878,
-0.0291431379,
-0.0519017391,
-0.0263984147,
0.0041673509,
-0.0495083854,
-0.0304237679,
-0.0162642989,
-0.0236882046,
0.0712444633,
-0.0483249091,
-0.0433278345,
0.1066786945,
0.0376501121,
-0.0255684573,
0.0541735142,
0.0105448551,
0.0236903522,
0.0005076975,
0.0130462386,
0.035686776,
-0.0426040702,
0.0162965935,
0.0135734128,
0.0164006036,
-0.0147211254,
-0.0727263466,
-0.0058816792,
0.0250257012,
0.0005463735,
-0.0065815477,
0.0150544243,
0.0470520742,
-0.0098415771,
-0.0286459234,
0.0256452262,
0.0060648527,
0.0182016157,
0.0086581353,
0.0086242547,
-0.0159410574,
0.0341142267,
-0.0422160886,
-0.0400436595,
-0.0059740827,
0.0233325325,
-0.0170258265,
-0.0440403186,
-0.0372162424,
0.0154215218,
0.0159025062,
-0.0185399652,
-0.0112354243,
0.0040986487,
-0.0202099457,
-0.0089332648,
0.018618742,
0.0165324137,
-0.0378251188,
-0.0105664013,
-0.0034265295,
0.0045855059,
-0.0395325832,
0.0095497165,
-0.0197474603,
-0.0457223542,
0.0241451059,
0.0103057679,
0.0999593586,
-0.0196808558,
-0.0826696754,
-0.005136563,
-0.0384951904,
-0.0231879894,
0.0249073636,
0.0234568547,
0.0113862352,
0.0246530678,
0.0077064857,
0.0306337997,
-0.0266986396,
0.0236402471,
0.0125668449,
-0.0006958608,
-0.0657224879,
0.0156673323,
0.0640013292,
-0.0104678264,
0.0213596523,
0.004075638,
0.0357716866,
0.0192893986,
-0.0816191956,
0.0590447411,
0.004097126,
0.0387276858,
0.0110377921,
-0.0623046942,
-0.0380408987,
-0.0020567735,
-0.0358826779,
0.022281846,
0.0601815842,
0.0021479004,
-0.0225320589,
0.0022318431,
-0.0512913987,
-0.0168685485,
0.0089595858,
0.0394509658,
0.0593806617,
-0.0357220508,
-0.0043651126,
-0.0131002665,
-0.0014594109,
-0.0091517121,
-0.030341953,
0.0454559028,
-0.0251182728,
-0.0037613814,
-0.0289587732,
-0.0015164862,
-0.065626964,
-0.0646366328,
0.0577937998,
-0.0228643902,
0.0021460303,
-0.0114263287,
0.0375653692,
0.0219509061,
-0.0636162907,
-0.0173221473,
0.0294622909,
0.0215732828,
-0.0326125547,
-0.0230047796,
0.0354612097,
0.0321118571,
-0.0288219973,
0.0291028041,
0.003938247,
0.0538241006,
-0.0456300043,
0.0417662412,
0.0636921749,
-0.0477108397,
-0.0492858328,
0.0104058348,
-0.0233425163,
-0.0285209455,
-0.0098665413,
-0.0092204856,
-0.007112321,
0.0434760749,
-0.0370550528,
0.0165324267,
0.0547706783,
0.0568162799,
0.0143160932,
0.0316517614,
-0.0022574903,
-0.0012203613,
0.0050812671,
0.0094923088,
0.0347188078,
-0.0380423814,
-0.016332753,
0.0264772158,
0.0067714266,
0.0251596086,
0.0464145392,
0.1061449498,
-0.0558994375,
-0.0212363061,
0.0253234748,
-0.0406662002,
-0.0128766838,
0.0429765433,
-0.0392387584,
-0.0306292549,
0.0559234917,
-0.0119347721,
0.0540141724,
-0.0808475912,
-0.0173531603,
0.0322333835,
0.0070409677,
-0.0210903734,
0.0252431538,
0.0904269069,
0.019876197,
-0.009696275,
-0.0852756426,
0.0418643095,
0.0079771476,
-0.0410317779,
-0.0915177166,
0.0100698126,
0.0191090051,
-0.0077661583,
-0.0367021151,
-0.0072765546,
-0.0535846762,
-0.0227807704,
-0.0143689029,
-0.0450632013,
-0.0822744966,
-0.036182642,
0.0614295304,
0.0170595124,
0.0381963477,
-0.0208623074,
0.0600102358,
0.0013432193,
-0.0110212425,
0.0551690906,
0.0696817115,
-0.0046297521,
-0.0105311554,
0.0536644123,
-0.0281229746,
-0.0150772668,
-0.0358586721,
-0.0248953868,
-0.0148608051,
0.0143998452,
0.0130517371,
-0.0138301533,
0.03038124,
-0.0356761478,
0.0237293355,
0.0596445091,
0.0305270925,
0.0274286699,
-0.0039350381,
-0.0115478402,
-0.0285795964,
0.0224183314,
-0.0297518577,
-0.0639066771,
-0.004095919,
0.0094927307,
0.0006479559,
-0.0550406799,
-0.0201810375,
-0.0173889529,
-0.042638395,
0.0698927343,
0.0173485149,
0.0305029303,
-0.0178341195,
-0.087704286,
-0.0028200266,
0.0097857704,
-0.0441402122,
-0.0287776701,
0.006112427,
0.023664007,
0.0302888118,
-0.0548222624,
-0.0205437522,
0.0107814502,
0.0272484701,
0.0406475179,
0.0365287252,
0.0589255281,
-0.0000245903,
-0.0279422365,
-0.0039164247,
-0.0176417623,
-0.0134598734,
-0.0311209802,
0.0132341934,
0.0118107218,
0.0140775554,
-0.006241465,
0.0753663629,
0.0041504633,
-0.0454687588,
0.0366601944,
0.0827530101,
-0.005725787,
-0.0366894118,
0.0066116294,
0.0336910896,
0.0364052318,
0.0524332374,
0.0034007765,
0.0581479296,
-0.0169939715,
-0.0843714848,
0.0168620571,
-0.0097184554,
-0.0459546559,
0.0484842286,
0.0392548069,
-0.0089664208,
-0.014956262,
-0.03739281,
0.0122823082,
-0.0043294281,
-0.0190074164,
-0.0364666544,
0.0883681104,
0.0283130668,
-0.0682955831,
0.0230740383,
-0.0220046714,
0.0251063444,
0.0356574729,
-0.0672453046,
-0.0039612567,
0.0144782355,
-0.0180209838,
0.0466902927,
-0.0189330839,
-0.0361969583,
0.0091724982,
0.0216461755,
0.0196665637,
-0.0075959386,
0.0252385568,
-0.0045994096,
0.0313750133,
0.0433529764,
-0.0125611024,
-0.0010825371,
0.0105332984,
-0.0062669888,
0.0228231642,
-0.0195622612,
0.0406354964,
0.0347495861,
-0.0080053313,
0.0164077897,
-0.07801155,
0.0579376817,
0.0219125357,
-0.0236099288,
0.0729579255,
-0.0189634059,
-0.009298129,
-0.0205002502,
-0.0306669585,
0.0158430319,
-0.0495296046,
0.0344437584,
0.0167046841,
0.0020218433,
0.0045638573,
-0.0330652632,
0.0184998922,
-0.0674795508,
-0.0107461158,
-0.0008527356,
0.0637341067,
0.021740362,
0.0567994714,
-0.0197973307,
-0.0060197939,
-0.0030465007,
-0.0542007163,
0.0052792253,
-0.0070514698,
0.0553590506,
0.0173666179,
0.0124522094,
0.0231217239,
-0.0010543102,
-0.0368682221,
-0.0368267894,
-0.039091967,
-0.0057531237,
0.0361633562,
-0.0179192815,
0.0326268971,
-0.0047464757,
-0.0213212818,
-0.0338594951,
-0.0072162114,
0.005083737,
0.0034143568,
-0.0271117836,
0.0549859926,
0.0019688157,
-0.068104282,
-0.0071934522,
0.0153697748,
-0.0478177145,
0.0754491463,
0.0201603565,
-0.0851508379,
-0.0337889455,
-0.055565659,
-0.0916086733,
-0.0385922119,
0.0380637944,
0.0184060875,
-0.0983143672,
-0.0275195651,
0.0478832349,
0.0251068734,
0.0207110904,
0.0024683992,
-0.02600904,
0.0328998491,
-0.0367085673,
-0.0403432287,
-0.0076627438,
0.0377603732,
-0.0414953455,
-0.0124155106,
-0.0203810167,
-6.136350508e-33,
-0.0265019294,
-0.0970247686,
-0.0024514666,
0.039632827,
0.0121270083,
0.0335968547,
0.0032025394,
0.0149363419,
-0.0297544394,
0.088934876,
0.0291339234,
0.0038568338,
0.0024495046,
-0.0222020671,
-0.0195976179,
0.0212971829,
0.0484156385,
-0.0243368447,
-0.0186413061,
-0.031837251,
0.0358959623,
-0.0032798981,
0.0386885293,
-0.0880676359,
0.0411426574,
-0.0217710342,
-0.0145590119,
0.0009435577,
-0.0188581105,
0.0165943503,
0.0142906401,
0.03714047,
0.0278908312,
-0.0358277671,
-0.0192839038,
0.0501040518,
-0.0811014771,
-0.0343709849,
0.0474382564,
-0.0208018441,
0.0187899843,
0.0158211812,
-0.0234434325,
0.0275967978,
-0.0236739796,
0.0130304014,
0.0194128286,
-0.044073049,
0.0263394844,
-0.0187009592,
-0.0364515819,
0.004341471,
-0.0312770195,
0.0532205664,
-0.0759265125,
0.0706826076,
-0.0142936641,
0.0427464172,
-0.1414500475,
0.0453246757,
0.0378232896,
-0.0190170463,
0.028693378,
-0.0199604128,
0.0054187616,
0.0712643415,
-0.0108120795,
0.0035088842,
-0.0992766917,
-0.0285085067,
0.0015174769,
-0.0366316624,
0.0473781377,
0.0897492096,
0.0406652987,
-0.0460182354,
-0.0683033019,
-0.014119355,
0.0174280014,
0.0421651416,
0.0098107336,
-0.0213424619,
0.0004101289,
-0.0150303012,
-0.0494036227,
-0.0269925203,
-0.0229042713,
0.0071890061,
0.0142959477,
0.0168879516,
-0.0242911298,
0.0371625349,
-0.025267804,
0.0017048432,
0.0129665202,
0.0081401812,
0.0240956377,
0.0094725695,
0.0233970881,
0.0262364056,
-0.0541432761,
0.0308130905,
-0.0194106624,
0.0543003231,
0.0455311015,
-0.0469888076,
0.0595155023,
-0.0234397724,
-0.0228464678,
-0.0216013268,
-0.0266431943,
0.0295131691,
-0.0228386093,
-0.0522879139,
0.0002421219,
0.027560968,
0.0015117624,
-0.0554011874,
-0.0066152276,
0.0259886496,
-0.0004148807,
0.0113406312,
-0.0486929826,
0.036089059,
-0.0303921271,
-0.0057761548,
-0.015153667,
-0.0211769026,
-0.0042970269,
-0.0838813931,
0.0115314862,
-0.0005445902,
2.658e-7,
0.0176588744,
0.0605564862,
-0.0182001498,
-0.0478648916,
0.0330399722,
0.0600326732,
-0.0005142688,
0.0036249461,
0.0107385386,
-0.0429826565,
-0.0326455683,
0.0253903326,
0.0109207695,
0.0055795433,
-0.0370000415,
-0.0606731698,
-0.0025331206,
-0.018044237,
-0.0323913358,
0.0090596601,
0.0407774635,
-0.0039739572,
0.0181555301,
0.0054759174,
-0.0291320253,
0.0329163037,
0.0725677684,
-0.0124572525,
0.0096271392,
-0.0283707064,
0.0230437573,
-0.0477507748,
0.025793111,
0.0454575121,
-0.0249041133,
-0.0711635798,
-0.0311718397,
0.014560936,
0.0372548662,
-0.0503266342,
-0.0207174364,
0.0299595986,
0.0080721583,
-0.0374065675,
0.0016474472,
-0.0797550827,
-0.0481515415,
-0.0365627259,
-0.055249881,
0.0490789823,
-0.0188065302,
0.0009560118,
-0.0051111588,
0.0206285287,
-0.0183544587,
0.0099466564,
0.0227219258,
-0.0092579648,
0.0200785436,
0.0033062398,
-0.0290816929,
-0.0344252847,
-0.0139987255,
-0.0539214388,
0.0448915437,
0.0234545805,
0.0220616367,
1.844713616e-34,
0.0155270053,
-0.0011476118,
-0.0166653562,
-0.0687140673,
0.0416614562,
0.0337035805,
0.0382501669,
-0.0100006107,
0.0183099024,
0.0033846679,
0.0171275809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08238v1
|
Silver-Tongued and Sundry: Exploring Intersectional Pronouns with ChatGPT
| 2024-05-13T23:38:50 | 2024-05-13T23:38:50 |
Takao Fujii, Katie Seaborn, Madeleine Steeds
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
ChatGPT is a conversational agent built on a large language model. Trained on
a significant portion of human output, ChatGPT can mimic people to a degree. As
such, we need to consider what social identities ChatGPT simulates (or can be
designed to simulate). In this study, we explored the case of identity
simulation through Japanese first-person pronouns, which are tightly connected
to social identities in intersectional ways, i.e., intersectional pronouns. We
conducted a controlled online experiment where people from two regions in Japan
(Kanto and Kinki) witnessed interactions with ChatGPT using ten sets of
first-person pronouns. We discovered that pronouns alone can evoke perceptions
of social identities in ChatGPT at the intersections of gender, age, region,
and formality, with caveats. This work highlights the importance of pronoun use
for social identity simulation, provides a language-based methodology for
culturally-sensitive persona development, and advances the potential of
intersectional identities in intelligent agents.
|
[
0.0590262078,
0.0465698577,
-0.0397467129,
0.0165619459,
0.0059994147,
-0.0082421936,
0.0569495261,
-0.019112777,
0.0526009612,
-0.0382876955,
-0.0249337517,
-0.0349728689,
0.0246232729,
-0.0065053604,
0.0088603646,
-0.071831651,
0.0210937168,
0.0335946456,
0.0461489782,
-0.0347288251,
0.0013268717,
0.0488596745,
0.0124433851,
0.0752525777,
-0.0533975698,
-0.0108495848,
0.012420767,
-0.0076195621,
0.0191273391,
0.0282468367,
0.0705491602,
0.0184813105,
0.008378665,
0.0472942777,
0.0000019139,
-0.0535946786,
0.0323944353,
-0.0297046658,
0.0112433182,
0.0104144504,
0.0332597047,
0.0735774487,
-0.0352326371,
0.0104965074,
-0.0643028989,
-0.0054085255,
0.0412313826,
0.0472151004,
0.0453908965,
0.011114642,
-0.0109485229,
-0.0154945785,
-0.065747641,
-0.0061348733,
-0.0103617124,
-0.0076476238,
0.0051206867,
-0.0436806157,
-0.0087542674,
-0.0371851809,
-0.0174644254,
0.0061589102,
0.0301523134,
-0.004949546,
-0.0114413863,
0.03555106,
-0.0245549288,
-0.0201214291,
0.0090289228,
0.0537255518,
0.0775489882,
-0.0080080293,
-0.0138674853,
0.0673419014,
0.0036810234,
-0.0346626043,
-0.0018931906,
0.0127118509,
0.0009901029,
-0.0040580537,
-0.035761226,
0.0135180037,
-0.0190747771,
0.0288483668,
-0.0216808952,
0.0610400401,
0.0107638361,
-0.0051887231,
-0.0125034843,
-0.0283659399,
0.0194364171,
-0.0670038909,
-0.0041938461,
0.0182197411,
-0.0489102677,
0.0256391987,
-0.0326375291,
0.0139192697,
0.0006090255,
-0.0213089772,
0.0174517781,
0.0423058979,
-0.0283711702,
-0.0185786802,
0.014115354,
0.0288403835,
0.0290520005,
-0.000914161,
-0.0291759595,
-0.0216265004,
-0.0242405571,
-0.0629328042,
-0.0491520502,
-0.0058788816,
-0.0058765491,
-0.0032750592,
-0.0235197023,
-0.0093055675,
-0.0637840331,
0.0227480289,
-0.0542458482,
-0.0061958889,
-0.0184406079,
0.0178215709,
-0.0260057431,
0.0434459299,
-0.0773958191,
0.0079825111,
-0.0121893762,
-0.0728784651,
0.0471810214,
-0.011347984,
-0.0014406771,
-0.0179058816,
-0.0247704107,
0.0324161276,
-0.0222743414,
-0.0288103539,
0.0100627551,
-0.0364581421,
-0.0060127438,
-0.0507740453,
0.0168547332,
-0.0251274612,
0.0219382606,
-0.0143882371,
0.0365551151,
-0.0658749416,
0.0389722735,
0.011675247,
0.0094493711,
0.0607446507,
0.0337564535,
0.0128974104,
0.0258898102,
0.0275571179,
0.0266818609,
0.0484390706,
0.0597040206,
-0.0230159871,
0.0411299318,
-0.0259027537,
0.0231990293,
0.0013005876,
-0.005204435,
0.0259091444,
0.0194703452,
-0.0298863593,
0.0390776284,
0.0344650336,
0.067681402,
0.013952693,
0.0142062232,
-0.0506909788,
0.0688686818,
0.0866413265,
-0.0515006706,
0.0347454995,
0.0482892059,
0.0533096343,
-0.0058722971,
0.036907468,
-0.0435372479,
0.011520749,
-0.0169498418,
-0.0277054776,
-0.0371399373,
0.0560330972,
-0.0324858762,
0.0167733729,
0.0021001706,
0.0307500325,
0.0397016741,
0.001919701,
-0.0453897491,
0.0239217747,
0.0278356522,
0.0270367526,
0.0550682545,
-0.0808528438,
-0.0206533577,
-0.020259738,
-0.0259313714,
0.0495566353,
-0.029265346,
0.001254159,
0.0318650343,
-0.0167405792,
0.0385645665,
0.05076579,
0.0574775301,
0.0121639678,
-0.0019072798,
0.0007736242,
0.0111784209,
0.0052202404,
-0.0099554481,
0.0731707886,
0.0273262635,
0.0524519756,
0.0083491867,
0.0314502008,
0.0135411965,
-0.0081078466,
-0.0457352363,
-0.0328146741,
0.0112087447,
0.0118258074,
0.0266739093,
0.0143620623,
-0.0251741391,
-0.0109091476,
-0.0060377698,
0.0217914786,
-0.0509380177,
0.1229663268,
-0.0302578937,
0.0135738421,
0.019030733,
-0.0637321174,
-0.035285674,
0.004211626,
0.0263938047,
-0.0069316244,
0.0573520996,
-0.0062240125,
0.0335573442,
-0.0380259305,
-0.0235292856,
-0.0163324028,
0.0488688536,
-0.0069461521,
-0.0054889875,
0.0113128051,
-0.0408199243,
-0.0297661405,
0.017016938,
0.0224511027,
-0.0511515625,
-0.0319657326,
0.0351501852,
-0.0257650614,
0.032943625,
-0.0157046691,
-0.0037916603,
-0.0252692588,
-0.0529728085,
-0.1266999096,
-0.0556973368,
0.0061872033,
-0.0534260161,
-0.0341488048,
0.0041302685,
-0.0491673648,
-0.0032603927,
-0.0284325536,
0.0040039402,
0.0100635616,
0.0041125193,
-0.0020927412,
-0.0018630523,
0.0087521626,
0.0061417976,
0.0108218547,
-0.0527389757,
0.0446390584,
-0.0147943422,
0.0129812695,
0.0162299946,
-0.0836366266,
-0.0470194556,
-0.0061382502,
-0.0180723853,
-0.0641147941,
0.0582507737,
0.0228075199,
0.0646356195,
0.0411810391,
0.0290011801,
0.0595171601,
0.0116368383,
-0.0768995956,
-0.0304791424,
0.0172636025,
0.035370443,
-0.0054451628,
-0.0152761927,
-0.0968022868,
0.0007624602,
0.034904141,
0.0280847196,
0.0001477075,
-0.0610430688,
0.0508278981,
-0.0310901664,
-0.0627150387,
0.0022210774,
-0.0145660816,
-0.0223454703,
0.0161549356,
-0.0103575466,
0.0337599292,
0.0581058636,
0.0057847532,
-0.0422254391,
-0.0014637482,
0.0267627835,
-0.0092690345,
0.0962499902,
-0.0267094001,
0.028497899,
0.0491920076,
-0.0361595489,
-0.0205898788,
-0.0018576133,
-0.0079670595,
-0.0377814807,
0.0096269166,
-0.0452945381,
-0.0004046986,
0.0212891847,
-0.017570043,
-0.0341510959,
-0.0189963449,
-0.0329810791,
0.0050801877,
-0.0152367279,
-0.0003185296,
0.0178674292,
0.0133020524,
0.0068560834,
-0.0107646314,
-0.0255207345,
0.0130927088,
-0.0242976919,
-0.0456791967,
-0.0017059366,
0.0305634849,
0.0058831074,
0.0247370992,
0.0410395004,
0.0065490212,
0.0290166158,
0.0125404745,
-0.0156813338,
0.0015876922,
0.0291056745,
-0.0097797355,
0.0200755056,
-0.0163314641,
0.0683077872,
-0.0522880964,
0.0281413831,
0.0793883204,
-0.0006092499,
0.0060818261,
0.0106934505,
-0.0166854747,
0.0300112944,
0.0188281275,
0.0394754075,
-0.0972131938,
0.030740872,
0.0176590253,
-0.0146001242,
-0.0800460801,
-0.0367347673,
-0.0230876077,
-0.099199824,
0.0354923382,
0.0176989045,
-0.0605360977,
-0.008620671,
0.0218463577,
0.0157133862,
0.0357323252,
0.0494871661,
-0.0092297848,
-0.0059736641,
-0.0281865429,
-0.0331391916,
-0.0534737669,
-0.0197070278,
0.0193753652,
-0.0475187972,
0.0447726771,
0.0025329115,
0.0788097084,
0.0063958275,
-0.0018075602,
0.0034877623,
-0.0131133636,
-0.0042997282,
-0.0261298344,
-0.0014258943,
-0.0225953776,
-0.0269104037,
-0.0194485579,
0.0114932973,
0.0294450242,
0.0064595845,
0.0231718309,
-0.0180405937,
-0.0108207166,
-0.0541420281,
0.002704835,
0.0419454202,
0.0132294009,
0.0426384173,
0.0485078916,
-0.042337127,
0.0131017799,
-0.044756446,
0.0225371774,
0.0319282897,
-0.0728110895,
0.0146949133,
0.0024430158,
-0.0498231091,
-0.0470795371,
-0.0985322073,
0.0318134129,
0.0091937957,
0.0370626524,
-0.0655042082,
-0.0119412448,
0.0058308565,
0.0068793297,
0.0100941714,
-0.0804923922,
0.079685472,
0.0181011446,
-0.0371500403,
0.0080370819,
-0.0255252235,
0.0226746034,
0.0046112435,
0.0404252149,
-0.0330728479,
0.0442773178,
0.0497056246,
0.0233895462,
0.0313394032,
-0.0254379846,
-0.0420947,
-0.0237780288,
0.0109430505,
0.0243972167,
0.0522276461,
0.0187911578,
0.0303857457,
-0.0148471771,
0.0194018036,
0.0087663466,
0.0191467088,
-0.0385640003,
-0.026810592,
-0.0546861552,
-0.0718493536,
0.0044824369,
-0.0048702005,
-0.0184706133,
-0.0386254936,
0.0571208447,
-0.0094594993,
-0.0439179689,
-0.058851324,
-0.0188138448,
-0.0159341935,
-0.0678509399,
0.0177586228,
0.0430575013,
0.0252350029,
-0.0287974961,
-0.0373687558,
0.0150337731,
-0.0155555867,
-0.0228983052,
0.0267570633,
0.0703740492,
-0.0415252075,
0.0313911922,
-0.0154851917,
0.0139877032,
0.008880741,
0.0079809483,
0.0189321861,
0.0453125574,
0.0135309603,
-0.0630609468,
-0.0036455919,
0.0026786758,
-0.0302728657,
-0.0010540955,
0.0181475393,
0.0074915928,
0.0360819697,
-0.006630715,
0.0296364743,
-0.0487507656,
-0.0051693697,
0.0119449496,
0.0021916723,
0.0341055356,
-0.084511593,
0.0158972628,
-0.0100177051,
-0.0066319439,
-0.0185525659,
0.026599491,
0.0073317681,
0.0347454585,
0.0222014729,
-0.0192841105,
-0.0347487591,
-0.0209713932,
0.0230892058,
-0.0049195364,
-0.0036600083,
-0.0159657598,
-0.0952725857,
-0.0504056811,
0.0016190156,
-0.0134733375,
0.0439351574,
-0.018314153,
0.0100828707,
0.0228518397,
0.0025402843,
-0.0201696027,
-0.0070356955,
-0.0027242932,
-0.0332122259,
0.0118163107,
0.0134415841,
-6.222422041e-33,
-0.0670986548,
-0.0263241287,
0.0131434426,
0.0370138325,
-0.0763553753,
-0.0347775407,
-0.0624244176,
-0.001316155,
0.0232025515,
0.0181117319,
-0.0318076648,
0.0038335752,
0.0157112218,
-0.0180228967,
-0.0128022209,
0.0037874256,
0.0616141409,
0.0425144322,
-0.0123090036,
-0.0135943536,
0.0033975975,
-0.0105320401,
0.0093276948,
-0.0849442855,
0.0309629403,
0.0114977276,
-0.0519548766,
0.0098197553,
-0.0125673162,
-0.014667959,
-0.0191831607,
0.0673905462,
-0.0016195476,
0.0322479717,
0.0206635185,
0.1111778319,
-0.0565386228,
-0.0516639166,
-0.0165752247,
0.0162219908,
0.0326206349,
-0.0794021338,
-0.0082437443,
-0.0358212776,
-0.0270229038,
0.0282103363,
0.0517683439,
0.0200639647,
0.0460069813,
0.0277451389,
-0.087832354,
-0.0400774777,
-0.0209903661,
-0.0025451623,
-0.0302305948,
0.0003860914,
0.0177651644,
-0.0923574567,
-0.0091569424,
0.0144904284,
-0.0290150195,
-0.055978585,
0.0102210362,
0.0551462695,
0.0344695263,
0.021663757,
0.0583047718,
0.0521987602,
-0.0246435553,
-0.010522021,
0.0871944875,
-0.0259681139,
0.0004038546,
0.0799386278,
-0.0989032313,
-0.071485281,
0.0414705053,
-0.0107668862,
0.0900839716,
-0.0319746509,
0.0146977557,
-0.0017417928,
-0.0263189171,
-0.0483842082,
-0.045704525,
-0.0498588756,
-0.0023991216,
-0.0255846474,
0.0001629382,
-0.0289864577,
-0.0416528843,
0.0142936101,
0.0326536261,
-0.042237293,
-0.0366111472,
-0.0417340919,
-0.0126194041,
-0.0099339662,
0.0182570163,
0.0075940569,
0.0168354139,
-0.0118118776,
0.0198110286,
0.0038666104,
0.0266006645,
0.0210348889,
-0.0168136302,
0.0170206688,
-0.0336145721,
-0.0113717876,
-0.0056396476,
0.028824063,
0.0155801084,
-0.0273398235,
0.0127697596,
0.0587764494,
-0.0109128533,
-0.0317127742,
0.0511143431,
0.0387991108,
-0.0633193552,
-0.0211080667,
-0.0803391263,
0.0038529451,
-0.0266221929,
0.031693548,
-0.0363611728,
0.031076733,
0.0728757828,
-0.0120564513,
-0.0212029237,
-0.0509498715,
2.723e-7,
-0.058689218,
0.0235842615,
0.0129485391,
0.006500701,
0.0327127092,
0.0363116488,
0.020128997,
0.047688935,
0.0706836209,
-0.0130329384,
-0.0113475872,
0.0481048934,
0.0867538452,
0.0293181855,
-0.1005513072,
0.0009647636,
-0.0089516556,
-0.0074698199,
-0.0648261458,
0.0465502255,
0.0081292931,
0.0272513479,
0.066041097,
0.0099948468,
-0.0173397884,
0.0071237562,
0.0316035971,
-0.0167792235,
0.0046319705,
0.0298242364,
0.0117285093,
-0.0307179093,
0.0529407747,
0.0212013908,
0.0445503369,
0.0031168077,
0.0173431616,
0.0218160618,
-0.0234243162,
0.0165320374,
-0.0018383815,
0.0233191531,
-0.0412310287,
-0.0335764512,
0.0340025835,
-0.0338929407,
-0.0068929843,
-0.0118918521,
0.0001476011,
-0.0232557766,
0.0397929512,
-0.0313947499,
-0.0666656792,
0.0584244989,
0.0036742431,
-0.0324403122,
0.0316246338,
-0.0444962643,
-0.0020560143,
-0.0255629383,
-0.0094403988,
-0.0272703543,
0.0257115178,
0.0130793983,
0.0017911902,
-0.0179625954,
0.0391767994,
1.985564931e-34,
-0.0269061886,
0.031397447,
-0.0000443137,
0.0035935966,
0.0693080649,
0.020151522,
0.0224236064,
0.0240674261,
0.0419083834,
0.0351031497,
0.0040250518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08237v1
|
A predictive learning model can simulate temporal dynamics and context effects found in neural representations of continuous speech
| 2024-05-13T23:36:19 | 2024-05-13T23:36:19 |
Oli Danyi Liu, Hao Tang, Naomi Feldman, Sharon Goldwater
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Speech perception involves storing and integrating sequentially presented
items. Recent work in cognitive neuroscience has identified temporal and
contextual characteristics in humans' neural encoding of speech that may
facilitate this temporal processing. In this study, we simulated similar
analyses with representations extracted from a computational model that was
trained on unlabelled speech with the learning objective of predicting upcoming
acoustics. Our simulations revealed temporal dynamics similar to those in brain
signals, implying that these properties can arise without linguistic knowledge.
Another property shared between brains and the model is that the encoding
patterns of phonemes support some degree of cross-context generalization.
However, we found evidence that the effectiveness of these generalizations
depends on the specific contexts, which suggests that this analysis alone is
insufficient to support the presence of context-invariant encoding.
|
[
-0.0360461771,
0.0547971763,
-0.0242620632,
-0.0260462388,
-0.0270138271,
-0.0106782299,
0.0120398533,
0.035413567,
-0.0314617679,
0.0262689721,
-0.014820151,
-0.063702926,
0.0723282769,
0.0415073596,
0.0073117376,
-0.042349495,
0.0320432335,
-0.0514602065,
-0.0067348103,
-0.0038257055,
-0.034806747,
-0.0548085719,
-0.0567956641,
0.0155314002,
-0.0195949115,
-0.0076542129,
-0.0398736075,
-0.0609155186,
-0.0218080599,
-0.0344347954,
-0.0286895335,
0.0290698279,
0.0459148958,
0.0203971025,
0.0000017288,
-0.0320904553,
0.0032936668,
-0.0213223416,
-0.0381722264,
-0.0231473334,
-0.0265486632,
-0.0004697741,
-0.0278145112,
-0.0419812426,
-0.0045520845,
0.018544009,
0.0304753575,
0.0170348044,
-0.0188361835,
0.0010356639,
-0.0163414199,
-0.0176278334,
0.0612198599,
0.0171086546,
0.0529571734,
0.0125935636,
0.0207624622,
-0.0186745226,
0.0124040134,
-0.0249902271,
-0.0404305644,
-0.0024918776,
0.0415374748,
0.0726636648,
-0.0203250572,
0.1063268557,
0.0041343533,
-0.0081427125,
-0.0534014404,
-0.0009186576,
0.0199897625,
-0.0695218295,
-0.0187062845,
0.0282505173,
-0.0184983276,
-0.0382123962,
-0.034555614,
0.0186612196,
0.0085696662,
0.0381664038,
0.0066960976,
0.0210091081,
-0.0035515213,
-0.029232664,
0.0278891176,
0.0629862994,
-0.0002984003,
-0.0478926189,
-0.0024462459,
-0.0174792185,
0.0010334643,
-0.0089349495,
0.0067895507,
0.0084303394,
-0.0165007077,
-0.0069764215,
0.0131094595,
0.0101909209,
-0.0028843165,
-0.0237139817,
-0.0128613552,
0.0406562351,
-0.0512027182,
-0.0286910757,
-0.0574519634,
0.0661925003,
-0.0144237261,
-0.0207573771,
-0.0149019854,
0.0417133495,
-0.0580663346,
-0.0251919571,
0.0134687563,
0.0087387795,
0.0017513621,
-0.0030536382,
-0.0431794375,
0.0057064118,
-0.0154489037,
-0.015774373,
-0.0288501643,
0.0178336333,
-0.0146663561,
0.0255775303,
-0.0554611683,
-0.0294050947,
-0.0132065415,
0.0739074573,
-0.0202790052,
-0.0186820775,
-0.0302178487,
0.001294816,
0.0156365223,
-0.0067364457,
-0.0177689921,
0.0581897832,
-0.0247559864,
0.0172422715,
-0.0195445511,
-0.0284247752,
-0.0210375134,
0.0106159383,
0.0275431126,
-0.0255639441,
-0.000222047,
-0.0038838824,
-0.0244577117,
-0.0045435685,
-0.0240143426,
-0.0312548615,
0.0206747502,
0.0513730198,
0.0304148514,
0.0247425195,
0.0656238124,
0.0189260915,
0.0179655049,
0.0059323548,
0.0087187206,
-0.0187994,
-0.0298390668,
-0.0050433828,
-0.0443041548,
0.0156016564,
0.0118956035,
-0.0447052754,
-0.0767633021,
-0.0371209718,
0.0374237597,
0.0343909822,
0.0469515473,
-0.0128683634,
-0.0366273485,
-0.0814969242,
0.0352542177,
0.0683507696,
0.0261985417,
0.0192386992,
0.054461088,
-0.0448436849,
0.0021589124,
0.0367698111,
-0.0223269109,
0.023580106,
0.0023491867,
0.0191998575,
0.0018419279,
-0.0282100998,
-0.0081907166,
0.0089402618,
0.0102444962,
-0.0572200045,
-0.0164543949,
-0.0190368108,
0.0033733994,
-0.0217522923,
-0.0374536254,
0.0315627642,
-0.00912832,
0.0289503466,
0.0013581276,
0.0197449289,
0.0319832861,
0.0451804437,
-0.0307312068,
-0.0234679747,
-0.0286741182,
0.0044795703,
-0.0240825601,
0.018438179,
0.0064176726,
0.0066738073,
0.0640813485,
0.018351743,
-0.0361182839,
0.0623747595,
-0.0321354121,
0.0443913043,
0.0042261472,
0.0090001412,
-0.023150105,
0.0341553725,
0.0274109039,
0.0060687247,
-0.0596515536,
-0.0567831919,
-0.0499872789,
-0.0367033966,
0.0453700274,
-0.0359592587,
-0.008100952,
0.0361143574,
0.0230436847,
-0.0051684412,
0.0075205294,
0.0369642042,
-0.1045641825,
-0.02477419,
0.0278209075,
0.0275740027,
0.0068901349,
-0.0133216446,
0.0511366017,
-0.0477156155,
0.0408287458,
0.0129360976,
0.100703828,
-0.0157605708,
-0.0179184936,
0.0031113636,
0.017650377,
0.0350912139,
0.0347006321,
0.0034135631,
-0.0078041954,
0.0322527327,
0.0168950465,
0.0063204649,
-0.0488336757,
-0.0124605866,
0.0293297172,
-0.0356542803,
-0.0475162826,
-0.0360014103,
-0.0601435043,
-0.0820830166,
0.0240926892,
-0.1181562096,
-0.0352634825,
0.0694213286,
-0.0300897192,
-0.0129661663,
-0.0458880998,
-0.0023257562,
0.0103624053,
-0.0291505102,
0.0008451321,
0.0116586313,
0.0400803536,
-0.0505583622,
0.0148102958,
-0.0431274362,
-0.037763942,
0.0114730317,
-0.0380628668,
0.0398776345,
-0.0397002026,
-0.0479915254,
-0.0255210884,
0.0233813655,
-0.0132353455,
0.031377621,
0.0071000508,
0.006666726,
0.0270276181,
-0.0086039007,
0.0391795076,
0.0246629156,
-0.0007259886,
-0.0099295629,
0.031426914,
-0.0316213183,
-0.0135883279,
-0.0214318596,
-0.0612115227,
0.0336299501,
-0.0007342469,
0.0087495754,
-0.0452347174,
0.1000672132,
0.0760770291,
0.0236903187,
-0.0192581993,
-0.0275841095,
-0.0387072861,
-0.0577938296,
-0.04121067,
-0.0497934408,
-0.0808017328,
0.0593975782,
-0.0216358062,
-0.0320573039,
0.0806482434,
0.0021718761,
0.0007794552,
0.0067945123,
-0.0250667725,
0.0022960084,
0.0363512486,
0.0144076096,
-0.0240665078,
0.0333167948,
-0.0114623075,
-0.0568619296,
-0.0047891699,
-0.0421795808,
-0.0057785106,
-0.0270169601,
-0.013298355,
-0.0145268133,
0.024386419,
0.0271662436,
-0.058421053,
-0.0041397447,
-0.0168190598,
0.0488073863,
-0.0310388301,
0.0421369374,
0.0002465796,
0.0239043236,
0.0009125296,
0.0200708602,
-0.0163213406,
-0.0429406501,
0.0300992671,
0.0596991479,
-0.0117173409,
0.0246481076,
-0.0110606905,
-0.0125004398,
0.0455872677,
-0.0147231268,
0.0638452768,
0.0619863123,
-0.0417315215,
0.0688620731,
-0.0043498594,
0.0049267849,
-0.0564268492,
0.0569366105,
-0.0351920351,
0.0022424569,
-0.0329597443,
0.0848351866,
0.0304394737,
-0.0197654795,
0.0306173898,
-0.026493093,
0.0139153097,
0.0044070561,
0.0136145651,
-0.0154951867,
0.0204385221,
0.0013965538,
-0.0312325209,
-0.0218120571,
-0.00949689,
0.0118788499,
-0.0359147228,
-0.0141061125,
0.0516867228,
-0.0500920229,
0.046566885,
0.0030688005,
-0.0051582041,
0.0375102833,
0.0145880552,
0.0126032587,
0.0008378816,
-0.0063349707,
0.0589926578,
-0.040357288,
-0.0018976115,
0.0230628103,
0.0227928571,
0.0688267723,
0.0481801033,
0.0188062508,
-0.0126078641,
-0.0437436774,
0.0439294502,
0.0008403662,
0.035176497,
-0.0060022301,
0.0117147667,
0.0536740124,
0.0115309805,
0.0010274963,
0.0089349234,
-0.0171901211,
-0.0886944309,
-0.0054251784,
0.1415443718,
-0.0222134311,
-0.0056650853,
-0.0031887665,
0.0387641825,
-0.0116766328,
0.056777548,
0.028255336,
-0.0370309465,
0.0058741989,
0.0036080582,
0.0528717041,
0.0108537273,
-0.0450851433,
-0.0002454302,
0.0180944055,
-0.0065758252,
-0.0265705865,
-0.0041744406,
-0.0408115424,
0.0088940365,
0.0461802669,
0.0126793347,
-0.0049004029,
-0.0374831222,
-0.0431592576,
-0.0226972066,
0.0232758746,
0.0031285598,
-0.0169596914,
-0.0303090438,
0.0392110795,
-0.0561236292,
-0.017219292,
0.0034649158,
-0.0149309561,
-0.0617978722,
0.0561666302,
-0.0347057879,
0.0224525593,
0.0459232181,
0.0360498056,
-0.0022742718,
0.1029855609,
-0.0210515633,
-0.0336651653,
0.0570162199,
0.0047219857,
0.0352936126,
0.0173112135,
-0.0077565131,
-0.0488349609,
0.0442404933,
-0.0313149951,
-0.0409731492,
-0.0172290038,
0.02896256,
0.0557690486,
-0.0573015474,
0.0790413842,
-0.0081940778,
0.0054810024,
0.0092505589,
-0.0096011171,
0.0198738948,
0.0633562282,
0.0516292453,
-0.0259476658,
0.0492329225,
0.0786440969,
-0.0128993066,
-0.0245995373,
0.0030640736,
0.0006366823,
0.0110597285,
0.0026916724,
0.0262247287,
0.0026544153,
-0.0270240977,
0.0463923626,
0.0248413384,
0.0152502926,
-0.0665490627,
0.0112548061,
0.0071859779,
0.0191579983,
0.0020897959,
0.0190907195,
0.007779941,
-0.0546158813,
-0.0754536837,
-0.0021720114,
0.0310226064,
-0.009457916,
0.001224573,
-0.0548530035,
-0.0420972072,
-0.023097042,
0.0663146004,
-0.0054513658,
-0.0332107022,
-0.0570477657,
0.0120328246,
0.0493353121,
0.0317712016,
-0.0029581927,
0.000412962,
0.0509181544,
-0.0098849852,
0.0390623398,
-0.0235649776,
0.0232185647,
-0.0257649086,
-0.0267791077,
-0.0109553728,
0.0377651863,
-0.0481733829,
-0.0249010883,
0.001559397,
-0.042114947,
0.0663100779,
-0.0041106362,
0.0752230808,
-0.0288989488,
-0.0015414708,
0.0150741879,
-0.0171297453,
0.0177570935,
0.04222662,
-0.009474013,
0.0244330633,
-0.0064551365,
-0.0305055548,
-5.77232856e-33,
-0.0154646887,
-0.0149536859,
0.0304241069,
0.008398911,
-0.0087608164,
0.0293272752,
-0.0447374545,
0.0123956557,
0.0507998914,
-0.0171522088,
-0.0064704856,
0.0017681349,
0.0284174774,
-0.0163251348,
0.0723667741,
0.0054848916,
-0.0037983016,
-0.0521085598,
0.0558767281,
-0.0459489785,
0.0753910318,
0.0403913744,
0.0383270942,
-0.0514281876,
0.0098830191,
0.0522029698,
0.0213961452,
0.0020753825,
0.0248468537,
0.0454887152,
-0.0648176074,
0.0438356623,
0.0359180607,
-0.03208258,
-0.0261398535,
0.0308453571,
-0.0254381001,
-0.0499791913,
0.0372454189,
0.0012815457,
-0.013956097,
-0.0112156048,
0.051997114,
-0.0353074372,
-0.0451082438,
0.0289521664,
0.0206693076,
-0.0446809679,
-0.0339911431,
-0.0328777544,
-0.0507367812,
-0.0235067997,
-0.013942224,
0.0214781202,
0.0762232319,
0.0512984917,
-0.021333335,
-0.0182357654,
-0.0340172537,
0.0592911951,
-0.0474497229,
0.0354230925,
0.0119815776,
0.0110191442,
0.0488403477,
0.0618521795,
0.1115397885,
-0.0321822502,
-0.0027213434,
-0.0167359058,
0.0337124877,
0.0188109986,
-0.023986958,
-0.0317793265,
0.0462306701,
-0.0663123652,
0.0234974977,
-0.0014866376,
0.0142985545,
-0.0198279358,
0.0331403166,
0.03772448,
0.007683808,
-0.0208902173,
0.0001783943,
-0.0003950895,
-0.0288989693,
-0.0082298899,
0.0318993814,
-0.0331462994,
0.0758402646,
0.0112524359,
0.0615916029,
-0.0299567617,
0.041783303,
-0.0288411118,
-0.0211031102,
-0.011696185,
0.061968293,
0.005961136,
-0.050870005,
-0.0318936259,
0.040839117,
-0.0084757674,
0.0495823957,
-0.0179428551,
-0.0269312281,
0.041968409,
-0.0122155305,
-0.0238558073,
-0.0298849829,
-0.0398865826,
0.0882505924,
-0.0692587867,
0.0610214993,
0.001424753,
-0.0204288308,
-0.0631490797,
0.0030762777,
-0.005274137,
-0.0258364268,
0.0361807197,
-0.0509015918,
0.0671216697,
-0.0187991317,
-0.0400412194,
-0.0020360916,
0.0036771952,
0.0437631197,
-0.0138176167,
-0.0239247978,
0.0225084312,
2.715e-7,
-0.0425512828,
0.0056604631,
0.0165096242,
-0.0080080889,
0.0967567414,
-0.0239241216,
-0.0250353627,
-0.0103239352,
0.0037703391,
-0.0501097627,
0.034284696,
0.0039519295,
0.0161221474,
0.0134549439,
-0.0141177531,
-0.0649256334,
-0.0494965538,
0.061247699,
-0.0333002098,
0.0259725992,
0.0306772143,
0.0489423573,
-0.0149024529,
-0.0356081575,
0.0076406915,
0.0050225439,
0.0683958977,
-0.0435311645,
0.0245212894,
-0.0738388821,
-0.0666058213,
-0.0365349613,
-0.006499494,
0.0333450437,
-0.0063691265,
0.0064006969,
-0.013627518,
-0.0233490132,
0.0073117269,
-0.0704836398,
0.0443568826,
0.021165207,
-0.0369668603,
0.0017647544,
0.0343323611,
-0.047710374,
-0.0293907151,
-0.0036454182,
-0.0252193864,
0.0012733297,
0.007939036,
0.0522048771,
-0.0001798946,
-0.0283823013,
-0.0435774252,
0.0331904292,
-0.0158802755,
-0.0159787741,
-0.0330370218,
0.0795911476,
-0.0879056454,
-0.0012473544,
-0.0493986532,
-0.0348309465,
0.0388893969,
-0.0398068205,
-0.0061386512,
1.942197914e-34,
-0.0199169256,
-0.0013869678,
0.0607130527,
0.025297882,
-0.033640597,
-0.0553030632,
0.0478580892,
0.0276323408,
0.0636925995,
-0.0211151168,
-0.0337481499
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13012v1
|
Divergent Creativity in Humans and Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T22:37:52 | 2024-05-13T22:37:52 |
Antoine Bellemare-Pepin, François Lespinasse, Philipp Thölke, Yann Harel, Kory Mathewson, Jay A. Olson, Yoshua Bengio, Karim Jerbi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The recent surge in the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led
to claims that they are approaching a level of creativity akin to human
capabilities. This idea has sparked a blend of excitement and apprehension.
However, a critical piece that has been missing in this discourse is a
systematic evaluation of LLM creativity, particularly in comparison to human
divergent thinking. To bridge this gap, we leverage recent advances in
creativity science to build a framework for in-depth analysis of divergent
creativity in both state-of-the-art LLMs and a substantial dataset of 100,000
humans. We found evidence suggesting that LLMs can indeed surpass human
capabilities in specific creative tasks such as divergent association and
creative writing. Our quantitative benchmarking framework opens up new paths
for the development of more creative LLMs, but it also encourages more granular
inquiries into the distinctive elements that constitute human inventive thought
processes, compared to those that can be artificially generated.
|
[
0.0346474834,
0.0349097997,
-0.0568335839,
0.0130756507,
-0.045143716,
0.022133505,
0.015915148,
0.0020342821,
-0.0232080203,
0.0049515865,
-0.042018529,
-0.0591626652,
0.0143443244,
0.0524414741,
0.0195774902,
-0.0145793296,
0.0007151938,
-0.0563602448,
0.0246048551,
0.0018892509,
-0.0531937182,
0.031261649,
0.0042338353,
0.0544069447,
0.0266792197,
-0.0139399311,
0.0158132259,
-0.0024749076,
0.0217345897,
0.016502196,
-0.041151993,
0.073565267,
-0.015614748,
0.0845653489,
0.0000015669,
-0.0570217595,
0.0659691542,
-0.0482136197,
0.0329484679,
-0.0113270655,
0.0305206738,
0.0315761343,
-0.0319081917,
0.0030556694,
-0.0375939645,
0.024968531,
0.0462100618,
0.0541506559,
0.0103311716,
0.0353781618,
0.0144002708,
-0.0509791486,
0.0457998402,
-0.0478508435,
0.0177366771,
0.0353768058,
0.0241756365,
-0.0066700699,
0.0326522291,
-0.0475763977,
-0.0274981707,
0.0062921518,
0.0384010524,
-0.0087132808,
0.0109466845,
0.0462527983,
-0.0123753725,
-0.0318815336,
0.0434335917,
0.0319758728,
-0.0105364546,
-0.0186268259,
0.0008181016,
-0.008088313,
-0.000584726,
0.0173836015,
-0.0254498255,
0.0582445301,
0.0086548375,
0.0121291885,
0.0276530031,
-0.0233438537,
-0.0056030778,
0.0322411135,
0.0171047114,
-0.0039814576,
0.0334565751,
0.0127201276,
-0.0141148763,
0.0270445514,
-0.0363964811,
-0.0679647997,
0.0000589152,
-0.0371551253,
-0.0253200103,
-0.0145860529,
-0.052577436,
-0.0319828875,
0.0102817882,
-0.0272382367,
0.1116961315,
0.009983385,
0.0327390321,
0.0379400998,
0.0041332575,
0.0319542363,
-0.0422255732,
0.0290630758,
-0.064316377,
0.0198798571,
-0.0512195043,
-0.0533474199,
0.0311707053,
-0.0296156332,
-0.0217153616,
-0.0384553894,
-0.029364815,
0.0436290056,
-0.0101544335,
-0.0519204102,
-0.0328388885,
0.0387722924,
0.0011483766,
-0.0211305339,
-0.0506218262,
-0.013977048,
-0.016698828,
0.0444619879,
0.0117976824,
0.0107869459,
-0.014502692,
0.0155247664,
-0.011150552,
-0.0590380989,
0.0165990405,
0.010947465,
-0.0220025666,
-0.0259966832,
-0.0050926483,
-0.0148948003,
0.0108437166,
-0.0580587722,
0.0671315789,
-0.0614527613,
0.0364830792,
0.031406682,
-0.0197886862,
-0.0632293671,
-0.0252471119,
0.0200050138,
-0.0419442989,
-0.0030771317,
-0.0263986439,
0.0514428243,
0.0209778249,
0.0041290903,
0.016263539,
0.0040522343,
0.0803551152,
0.0168735757,
-0.024481684,
0.0244749729,
0.0108854333,
-0.0088741388,
-0.0338704921,
-0.0140320221,
-0.0459858179,
-0.0419254638,
-0.0147426566,
0.0680950135,
0.0517564341,
0.0623204522,
-0.0132439034,
0.0187536757,
0.1209565625,
0.0825569257,
0.0319594406,
0.0450773835,
0.0353130773,
-0.0220890939,
0.0284491945,
-0.0148033453,
-0.0207782742,
0.0630099848,
0.0265630931,
0.0247458648,
0.0180895925,
0.0634791404,
-0.0305797923,
0.0188538674,
-0.016528992,
0.0229483619,
0.0104766814,
-0.0407679342,
-0.0178904869,
0.0213014428,
0.008251355,
-0.0128782364,
-0.001593574,
-0.0255086478,
-0.0029938463,
-0.0184319206,
0.0617258884,
0.0917681754,
0.0378379487,
0.0410308689,
0.0104677845,
-0.0181308948,
0.0027416972,
0.0849372,
0.0036771374,
-0.000498064,
-0.0041233245,
0.0130033698,
0.0260273479,
-0.0425956398,
0.0200021807,
-0.0023889749,
-0.0542445704,
0.0023872736,
-0.0195144862,
-0.020223964,
-0.0010703561,
0.0225595683,
-0.081916824,
0.0156025058,
-0.0128291296,
0.0054421276,
-0.0044566281,
0.0258008651,
-0.0704543144,
0.0496364795,
0.0075587812,
-0.0469661839,
-0.0736144036,
0.0552650429,
-0.0337161794,
-0.0015670279,
-0.0015901708,
-0.0887007937,
-0.0017899564,
0.0035765544,
0.0591625832,
-0.026584534,
0.0381735712,
-0.0465866737,
0.0437402613,
-0.0353857689,
0.0198251531,
-0.0137403365,
0.0222375076,
0.0086572738,
0.0802894086,
0.0013867288,
0.0163280927,
-0.0043814885,
-0.0077840649,
0.0051307972,
0.0064408556,
-0.0134783918,
0.0019246675,
0.0311824009,
0.0091718547,
-0.0208962895,
-0.007916877,
-0.072330758,
-0.0525316931,
-0.0510940477,
-0.0069974926,
0.0191325955,
-0.0032768776,
0.0153935738,
-0.0085705779,
-0.0324367993,
0.0329710543,
-0.0284325238,
-0.0239771176,
0.0378792249,
0.0506211296,
0.0219313595,
-0.0033301767,
-0.019030476,
0.0199214034,
0.002285833,
0.0054836427,
0.0319806412,
0.0384203196,
0.0132350251,
-0.0145523744,
0.0312546603,
-0.0687213093,
-0.0485610142,
-0.0257426817,
-0.0234428439,
0.0376782231,
-0.0009231703,
0.0818959847,
0.0242274031,
0.0129738608,
-0.0232382882,
0.0648376569,
-0.013842144,
0.0102947438,
-0.0286605135,
-0.0090504689,
0.0419604927,
-0.0053752293,
-0.0160405245,
-0.0393835716,
0.0526139848,
0.0133309793,
0.0171682611,
-0.0054530855,
0.1017934158,
0.0326120034,
-0.0726035833,
0.0004684265,
-0.032974124,
-0.0451344512,
0.0883576721,
-0.0388979614,
-0.0556364022,
0.049165789,
0.0230897497,
-0.000699174,
0.0211787056,
0.0148124984,
-0.0080240788,
0.0883504152,
-0.0040800157,
0.0180347767,
0.0066572665,
0.0093926415,
-0.087706387,
0.0286618229,
0.0203703772,
-0.0226439517,
0.04495975,
-0.0085014272,
-0.0174199715,
-0.0169935115,
-0.0403960496,
-0.0352887698,
0.0089588594,
-0.0113536408,
0.0210289564,
0.0445837043,
-0.0251346808,
-0.0269865375,
-0.0300724097,
0.0204645768,
0.0001197282,
0.003740228,
0.0122734075,
0.0055200523,
0.0090808803,
0.0649946257,
0.0018122495,
0.0069262288,
-0.061332833,
0.0028798361,
0.0182252657,
-0.0598855093,
0.0447584279,
-0.0076787095,
0.0526181534,
-0.0022172045,
0.0247085318,
-0.008540255,
0.0043525845,
0.0590711348,
-0.006919493,
-0.0181234907,
0.0571440533,
0.010562106,
0.0003754078,
0.0257760305,
-0.0052462388,
0.0090491259,
0.021497041,
0.0335961729,
-0.0190629456,
0.0008176615,
-0.0044618845,
-0.0126342401,
-0.0091027729,
-0.0611981042,
-0.0255405288,
-0.0856558233,
0.0378206223,
0.028244108,
-0.0220965762,
-0.0034196663,
-0.0008540478,
-0.017558787,
0.0402175598,
-0.0275736414,
0.0088744592,
0.00761721,
-0.0047435937,
-0.0364932045,
0.0129006263,
-0.0370159149,
0.0076223467,
-0.0588540323,
0.0484565608,
0.0543492623,
0.0329713747,
-0.0165786929,
-0.0558954962,
-0.0214416049,
-0.0181234162,
0.0288788844,
0.0066138972,
0.0201834738,
0.0614940748,
0.0086759701,
-0.069046028,
0.0349260494,
-0.0477213301,
-0.0492571592,
-0.0426707603,
0.0811390579,
-0.0299495272,
-0.0380377397,
-0.0386399329,
0.0018689892,
-0.0209772307,
0.0455954373,
0.0242299605,
-0.0702265799,
-0.0302337389,
-0.0014543245,
-0.0271749366,
-0.0657573342,
-0.043735221,
-0.0242381208,
0.0286576971,
-0.0227395967,
-0.080712907,
-0.0135373939,
-0.0148188649,
0.0301181655,
0.0149421087,
0.0324921571,
-0.0501656011,
-0.0395270288,
-0.0317245163,
0.0244763531,
0.0220931061,
0.0336921774,
-0.0112742977,
-0.0357818231,
-0.0438395292,
-0.0724047646,
-0.0178255159,
0.0029644533,
-0.1474789679,
-0.0765564367,
0.0183590651,
-0.0232701041,
0.0221215598,
-0.0156332478,
0.0368263647,
-0.0851358101,
0.0343355276,
0.0535712168,
0.028409604,
0.0783459693,
-0.0585025661,
0.013257293,
0.0117319953,
0.0236555394,
-0.0049393396,
0.0200006608,
0.0741069391,
0.0519909151,
0.0221516658,
-0.0226492267,
-0.003596402,
-0.0081407418,
-0.0004037103,
-0.0283538606,
0.02112047,
-0.083592765,
-0.0333227739,
0.0035382472,
-0.0152595816,
-0.0316053107,
-0.0438753888,
0.0452640429,
0.0039149406,
-0.0104366951,
-0.0038390092,
0.0025517396,
0.0436795689,
-0.057029333,
-0.0067924219,
0.0111492472,
0.0017754375,
0.023522431,
0.0183297228,
0.0153583121,
0.053397987,
-0.0637772158,
0.0527633913,
0.0097868489,
0.0450156629,
-0.0100426003,
-0.0089809773,
-0.0087914336,
0.0260329805,
-0.082804583,
-0.0803651661,
0.0165720414,
0.0050112172,
0.0667308271,
-0.0066973781,
0.0311136506,
-0.0396374278,
0.0225529652,
-0.0385157652,
0.0362050124,
-0.0405256152,
-0.0303889979,
-0.0355657749,
0.0183150806,
0.0054512881,
-0.0199064072,
0.0413461588,
-0.0570850335,
0.0111987442,
-0.0162838306,
-0.0000109578,
0.0013946529,
-0.0222055446,
0.0191581976,
0.0185443256,
-0.0012859566,
0.0343143567,
-0.0561835133,
-0.0564762019,
0.0649378896,
0.0062615881,
0.0301705878,
-0.0056024981,
-0.0004324123,
0.0454554334,
-0.0212656185,
-0.0068899845,
-0.0181471258,
-0.009119872,
-0.0311726462,
-0.0096643716,
-0.0521914363,
-5.186693234e-33,
-0.0074080136,
-0.0109384321,
0.0108703133,
-0.0428271145,
-0.0329772271,
-0.0475038104,
-0.0595310107,
0.0504665375,
-0.0047971304,
0.026393991,
-0.0205300748,
0.0014913563,
-0.0078042559,
-0.0006685168,
0.0468183234,
-0.0007788087,
0.0270516332,
0.0013831699,
-0.0052030529,
-0.015158671,
0.0560890213,
-0.005086591,
-0.0022470404,
-0.0348439217,
-0.0136707891,
-0.0463646166,
-0.0098980973,
-0.0198470261,
0.0112429401,
0.0625043064,
-0.0192325488,
0.0273417365,
0.0651066676,
0.0119647756,
-0.0237316955,
-0.0373305157,
0.0279948432,
-0.0495377332,
-0.015687149,
-0.0411893465,
0.0295191873,
-0.0303479154,
0.0454316884,
0.0018976101,
-0.0504879802,
-0.0201194882,
0.039572496,
-0.0099777412,
-0.001848913,
-0.0194494668,
-0.0919842049,
-0.0194367729,
0.0007773709,
-0.0159610044,
-0.0252711251,
-0.0622198023,
-0.0146276066,
-0.0144372983,
-0.0681073219,
0.0813876018,
-0.0200514551,
0.0073973606,
0.0538287871,
0.0231812019,
0.0038220407,
0.0645214692,
0.0581964292,
0.0676543191,
-0.0177060887,
0.0307864118,
0.0129486714,
0.0847316086,
0.0178855639,
0.0664598122,
0.0154852755,
-0.0092337374,
0.0366539843,
-0.0126877027,
0.0035071627,
-0.0274140351,
0.0369173475,
0.0152045144,
-0.0011858115,
-0.035427127,
0.0040317653,
-0.0370745733,
-0.0227042604,
0.0079957647,
0.0156519171,
-0.0205793679,
0.0284614321,
-0.032059487,
0.0357247107,
-0.0262801852,
0.0248585343,
-0.0052747424,
-0.0656864196,
0.0494972952,
0.0026280438,
-0.0263482537,
-0.0415748022,
-0.0491466746,
0.0245194994,
0.062356431,
0.0318927579,
0.0185627602,
-0.001508071,
-0.0147240749,
-0.0453802645,
0.0012899176,
-0.0372016728,
-0.0078676734,
0.0482775718,
-0.0370397754,
0.0302807074,
-0.0272778533,
-0.0099126659,
-0.0540463217,
0.0262758471,
0.0052657686,
-0.02818707,
-0.0099807195,
-0.0333678089,
-0.0031808561,
-0.0023373291,
0.015782509,
-0.0310363863,
-0.0191757493,
0.0664257258,
-0.0485748686,
-0.0186261237,
-0.0159027688,
2.379e-7,
0.0139646949,
0.0418476053,
-0.0221834127,
0.0427061841,
0.0503291525,
0.0256832484,
-0.0331235118,
0.0053321407,
0.008356778,
0.0351776592,
-0.0052987752,
0.0226496588,
0.0420698002,
0.0258815885,
-0.0694624931,
0.0695806891,
-0.0807645172,
0.0525912009,
-0.065470688,
-0.0344571918,
0.0592475235,
0.0113627501,
0.0142036742,
-0.0682293624,
0.0100943157,
-0.0610045567,
0.050911922,
-0.0131403022,
0.0309189148,
-0.0144498423,
-0.0066162827,
-0.0146232303,
0.0144807436,
0.0045218957,
-0.0224823151,
0.0098600369,
0.0020646513,
0.0049337912,
0.0040454501,
0.0240356792,
0.0130208004,
-0.0054580364,
0.0077015013,
-0.0454084463,
0.0456566364,
0.0073947734,
-0.023165565,
-0.0004520994,
0.0255021825,
0.0117007857,
0.0317162685,
-0.0301260129,
0.030737821,
-0.022350749,
0.0320937671,
0.0187749695,
0.0081531685,
-0.0152690355,
-0.015856633,
-0.0029626789,
-0.0780521706,
-0.0609858483,
-0.0558235273,
0.0344194584,
0.0518293157,
-0.0329922996,
-0.0075196722,
1.809829788e-34,
0.0191470124,
-0.0079367589,
0.0233805832,
0.0206637774,
0.0149974395,
-0.0033868139,
0.0334776491,
0.009309967,
-0.0198340081,
-0.0765252858,
-0.0450211503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08223v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08223v1
|
An information-theoretic model of shallow and deep language comprehension
| 2024-05-13T22:29:33 | 2024-05-13T22:29:33 |
Jiaxuan Li, Richard Futrell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IT, math.IT
|
A large body of work in psycholinguistics has focused on the idea that online
language comprehension can be shallow or `good enough': given constraints on
time or available computation, comprehenders may form interpretations of their
input that are plausible but inaccurate. However, this idea has not yet been
linked with formal theories of computation under resource constraints. Here we
use information theory to formulate a model of language comprehension as an
optimal trade-off between accuracy and processing depth, formalized as bits of
information extracted from the input, which increases with processing time. The
model provides a measure of processing effort as the change in processing
depth, which we link to EEG signals and reading times. We validate our theory
against a large-scale dataset of garden path sentence reading times, and EEG
experiments featuring N400, P600 and biphasic ERP effects. By quantifying the
timecourse of language processing as it proceeds from shallow to deep, our
model provides a unified framework to explain behavioral and neural signatures
of language comprehension.
|
[
0.017366875,
0.0102356672,
-0.0408388563,
0.0419087671,
-0.0514735729,
0.014320096,
-0.0218499806,
0.0418841913,
-0.037119519,
-0.0135141797,
0.0119693354,
-0.0364599042,
0.0524341427,
0.0223516561,
0.0249063279,
-0.0601659305,
0.0393541493,
-0.0211505704,
0.0167185999,
-0.0223685447,
-0.0109435581,
-0.050017558,
-0.030967677,
0.0331961401,
0.0178509653,
0.0269022081,
-0.0544409864,
-0.0101235388,
-0.0255819242,
-0.0256288741,
-0.0563790537,
0.0392520204,
-0.0078760879,
0.0469289906,
0.0000017573,
-0.0319757722,
0.0293405522,
-0.0061752177,
-0.0905820206,
0.0184248947,
-0.0433388762,
-0.0221972503,
0.0312174521,
-0.0402791724,
0.0308912992,
0.0134298746,
0.0515142828,
0.0564116947,
-0.0124791954,
0.0354346633,
-0.0039459174,
0.0078167934,
0.0571237616,
-0.028695317,
0.0726119354,
-0.0604516566,
0.0308624282,
-0.0418363102,
-0.002190785,
0.0184936356,
-0.0752680376,
0.0104274824,
0.0316183344,
0.0381041504,
0.0389387459,
0.0523603372,
0.0368803665,
-0.0212165825,
-0.035969913,
0.0408150889,
0.0317630544,
0.0179416984,
-0.0062226043,
-0.0041326843,
-0.0376218818,
0.0182565525,
-0.0123430369,
-0.031904351,
-0.0261724256,
-0.0072466279,
0.0241294242,
-0.0293971095,
0.0182583332,
0.0020077967,
0.0003387306,
0.0837386698,
0.0021795197,
-0.0732824355,
0.0095433407,
0.0150765255,
0.0026936226,
-0.0190986693,
0.005700578,
0.0369487032,
0.0119830323,
-0.0030005251,
0.0171606895,
-0.0370715223,
-0.0061734882,
0.0108820237,
0.0023147198,
0.0482976288,
0.067660071,
0.0528982542,
0.0067752097,
0.0264488943,
-0.00376457,
0.0022397002,
-0.0172838811,
0.033518184,
-0.003645912,
-0.0457424372,
-0.021365257,
-0.011311193,
-0.0277857278,
-0.0537150502,
-0.0567562282,
-0.0322161168,
-0.0187526662,
-0.0532123335,
-0.0339683294,
-0.0147363208,
-0.030620629,
0.0074474993,
-0.0660139248,
0.0068259416,
-0.0383600965,
0.0480156131,
-0.0073348675,
-0.0273103211,
-0.0115530659,
0.0049725748,
-0.0054315194,
-0.0057042055,
-0.0300687235,
0.0478187688,
0.0156890973,
-0.0410183184,
-0.0310296658,
-0.0253944919,
-0.0166012086,
0.0126494607,
0.0030118402,
-0.0481986329,
0.0378632061,
0.0101038618,
-0.0096131908,
-0.0165510941,
-0.0261964593,
-0.0105835823,
-0.0202173498,
0.0685714781,
-0.0350990482,
0.0288543794,
0.0450667441,
0.0308507755,
0.0067170202,
0.030804703,
0.0510951132,
-0.0372043699,
0.0134856412,
-0.0288165752,
-0.0421795584,
0.0401546285,
-0.0055130711,
-0.0008345156,
-0.0226252284,
-0.0519804209,
-0.0620407276,
0.0457513444,
0.0221379716,
0.0418627113,
-0.0483810231,
-0.0085989283,
0.0718762577,
0.0761655495,
0.0033889315,
0.020804055,
0.027469689,
0.0214634929,
0.0185808372,
0.0405547246,
-0.0144682564,
0.0133971628,
0.0238289498,
-0.0022260158,
0.0544030517,
-0.0653433353,
0.0076134885,
-0.0253766645,
0.0364583917,
0.0254026968,
0.0495516099,
0.0277499873,
0.0210217722,
-0.03059691,
-0.0352469794,
0.015847398,
0.0000916567,
0.0240327232,
0.0371774808,
-0.0404820815,
0.0193911921,
0.0673134625,
0.0027990225,
-0.0108858719,
0.067564033,
0.0390594117,
-0.025199078,
0.063657105,
0.0105325682,
-0.0011897524,
0.0272132829,
0.0025409765,
-0.0113024348,
-0.0130493324,
0.0068899221,
-0.0248014815,
-0.0254033227,
-0.00953699,
-0.0219020471,
-0.006723843,
-0.0165773723,
0.0231351536,
-0.0089775426,
-0.0193342213,
-0.0518879518,
0.0353728756,
0.0212911796,
-0.0342299528,
-0.0130804321,
0.0148664033,
-0.0181058906,
0.0003267918,
0.0032542692,
-0.0259249657,
-0.0103588384,
0.0122884447,
0.0025444019,
-0.0333076231,
-0.0229964387,
0.0261400118,
0.0519964136,
-0.0332649499,
-0.0167124774,
-0.0949893445,
0.0387121551,
-0.0035051499,
0.0022847329,
-0.0227817837,
0.0183420628,
-0.0655428618,
0.0584907904,
-0.0033763729,
0.0702494159,
-0.002635696,
-0.0264134202,
0.0028305303,
-0.0420704223,
-0.020434564,
-0.0139781144,
0.0064980639,
-0.047641281,
0.0008279099,
-0.0300447121,
-0.063133195,
0.0013720941,
-0.0720103681,
-0.0549254231,
0.0296367779,
0.0132981846,
0.0237531886,
-0.0160106327,
-0.0014025691,
0.0267696362,
0.0147503922,
0.0641952977,
-0.0158947259,
0.0570224598,
0.0103407474,
0.0314975493,
-0.0381608494,
0.0107268086,
-0.0293208119,
-0.0403924994,
0.049843803,
0.0296854824,
-0.0385483578,
-0.0571210943,
0.0362770259,
-0.0216281712,
-0.0044080415,
0.0123139368,
0.0019231973,
0.057507135,
0.0187141374,
0.0546396263,
0.0766096488,
0.0236577485,
0.0639202371,
0.0403427966,
-0.0261071417,
-0.0376862921,
0.0160811935,
-0.0445367284,
0.0461892262,
-0.0479005501,
-0.0467503145,
0.0085229035,
0.1120334342,
0.0598175414,
0.0023422609,
-0.05982792,
-0.0099913608,
-0.0684968382,
-0.0788260177,
-0.0359953083,
-0.0250594188,
-0.0321140885,
0.0764322132,
-0.0536184348,
-0.0678319633,
0.0935163274,
0.0017693456,
0.0212799441,
0.0037539902,
0.0329109393,
0.0360211954,
0.0552130006,
0.0145430779,
0.0344332829,
-0.0555699691,
-0.041480504,
-0.0345862992,
0.0254502725,
0.0191990677,
-0.0107212383,
0.0628039762,
-0.0130342189,
-0.0046946653,
0.0094481707,
-0.0112143941,
0.0108502628,
0.0070021264,
-0.0116657624,
-0.0314536951,
0.0346955471,
-0.007365447,
-0.0130521785,
-0.020432068,
0.0426023751,
0.0173643101,
-0.0026884039,
-0.0719633102,
-0.0002954976,
-0.0057540676,
0.0015471077,
0.0397171862,
0.0551046506,
-0.0747367367,
0.0403891914,
0.0353369787,
-0.0021414545,
0.0437195785,
0.0170643833,
0.0150609585,
0.0280091316,
-0.0220944807,
-0.0300822929,
0.051161129,
0.0466518104,
-0.0489821136,
-0.0385713913,
0.0913024768,
0.0024153553,
-0.0562938601,
0.0387149379,
-0.0646634027,
0.0232492648,
0.011221448,
-0.0054362775,
0.0046430374,
-0.028022876,
0.0004551959,
0.035445828,
-0.0263685044,
-0.0334738977,
-0.0246911142,
-0.0159219448,
-0.0086207073,
-0.0233163405,
-0.0310705416,
-0.0014379518,
-0.0375740267,
0.0183567889,
0.0638402104,
0.0116929868,
0.0055702003,
0.0011335746,
0.0159005597,
0.0178409051,
-0.001983159,
-0.0101385051,
0.0368416198,
0.0225908179,
0.0301275402,
-0.0147626465,
0.0245175567,
-0.0540672578,
-0.0045613935,
0.0044258581,
-0.0498694703,
-0.0032472266,
-0.0094397971,
0.0222807676,
0.024153268,
-0.0079417899,
-0.0596057437,
-0.0078485487,
0.0418061838,
-0.044559814,
-0.0206627175,
0.04915547,
-0.0155282691,
-0.0380840302,
0.0211387053,
0.011337881,
0.0209467541,
0.0772038102,
0.0640366599,
-0.072422497,
-0.0230072364,
-0.0009409995,
0.0276815556,
-0.0524161085,
-0.0794099942,
0.0299202818,
0.0410103612,
-0.0038560114,
-0.0282288343,
-0.0301450845,
0.0138352094,
0.0337038711,
0.059674304,
0.0464821421,
0.0675338358,
-0.0526074022,
-0.0156085417,
0.0004082327,
0.0216959659,
0.0006637449,
-0.0601293668,
-0.0234731305,
-0.0499668196,
-0.0160520077,
-0.0109005403,
0.0279336348,
-0.0490635186,
-0.0408065952,
0.0792048946,
-0.0349837206,
0.0308449902,
-0.0186857414,
0.0321440287,
-0.083074294,
0.0384903401,
-0.0107211247,
-0.019939607,
0.0540728793,
-0.0162318163,
0.0244587511,
0.0125996871,
0.03179425,
-0.0237812288,
-0.0160812549,
0.0233065374,
0.0289668571,
-0.0121663222,
-0.0198192336,
0.0184989497,
0.0319733545,
0.0270627923,
-0.019826699,
-0.000107504,
-0.0247620083,
-0.0252465475,
0.0300861876,
0.0464813896,
-0.0276037715,
-0.0998087227,
0.0347722098,
-0.0117504746,
-0.0152516011,
-0.0046628769,
0.0492015891,
-0.0674845353,
-0.0258131865,
-0.0076993862,
-0.0294415466,
-0.0226012003,
0.0146785146,
0.0221681688,
0.005493002,
0.0177534241,
-0.0803378448,
0.0124992384,
0.0365892649,
0.044173982,
0.0537798852,
-0.0077663776,
-0.0324007124,
-0.0233260803,
-0.0307073798,
-0.0606321841,
0.1051375568,
-0.0084233675,
-0.0155022014,
-0.0215060227,
0.018975161,
-0.0451253764,
0.0208167117,
-0.0364638679,
0.0306627098,
-0.0183504187,
-0.0329142772,
0.0617488883,
0.0273003075,
0.0207104664,
-0.004198039,
0.078585647,
0.0114271445,
0.0472439677,
0.006920164,
0.0122003052,
-0.0132122114,
-0.0315579362,
-0.0323793478,
0.0465677194,
-0.0527762026,
0.0224369951,
-0.0543728992,
-0.0548683144,
-0.0265162401,
0.0150151169,
0.0490970872,
-0.025429925,
0.0038178687,
0.0605210215,
-0.0064893225,
-0.0301570613,
0.0005284169,
0.0206354056,
-0.0232415069,
-0.016229419,
-0.0111105535,
-5.677626327e-33,
0.0176962521,
-0.0399416424,
-0.007927306,
0.0205221791,
-0.0270572379,
0.0710157603,
-0.0433238223,
0.0314948522,
0.0052841832,
0.0256507732,
0.0000375279,
0.013139029,
-0.0016575442,
-0.0024198396,
0.004791216,
-0.0009225834,
-0.0170947891,
-0.0137805799,
-0.0406887457,
-0.0181193184,
0.043623209,
-0.0030825711,
0.0561546795,
-0.0076838112,
0.0492342226,
0.0238329489,
0.0257790461,
0.0426362157,
-0.0158036742,
0.0443947464,
-0.0562720075,
0.0599351488,
0.0530184656,
-0.0492274351,
0.0022761987,
0.0363431461,
-0.0631150007,
0.0021646717,
0.0260111298,
0.0066766525,
-0.0888431296,
-0.0009627706,
0.0760690793,
-0.0061367848,
0.0095533943,
-0.0131422337,
0.0190198012,
-0.00658334,
-0.0245176591,
0.012121384,
-0.0641922876,
-0.0110480841,
-0.0468395576,
0.0014875169,
0.0148722529,
0.0230677202,
-0.0356463008,
-0.0128186652,
-0.0855088532,
0.0044119069,
-0.0502696782,
0.0493623875,
-0.0041747466,
0.013090726,
0.0473048054,
0.0564626567,
0.0431075245,
0.0488699302,
-0.0386996157,
-0.0214201286,
0.0460108258,
-0.0095766317,
0.0059757372,
-0.0202445071,
0.0771773234,
-0.0283163302,
-0.0881330818,
0.0106637999,
0.0200804789,
0.0365559496,
0.0268674139,
-0.022454951,
-0.0664316416,
-0.025329208,
-0.031277813,
0.0336275771,
-0.041268304,
-0.0050852713,
0.0398286991,
-0.0270640273,
0.0003417249,
-0.0347505547,
0.0372635014,
-0.0391410924,
0.0256518666,
-0.0230566412,
0.002573194,
0.0271598808,
0.02031436,
-0.0091614975,
-0.0085850349,
-0.028612962,
-0.0269067138,
0.0100259753,
0.041810073,
0.0055294437,
-0.0345701054,
0.0153642576,
-0.0165788531,
-0.0069739181,
-0.0285003595,
-0.0375652499,
0.0327262282,
-0.0307049677,
0.0812492147,
-0.0149654439,
-0.0272701811,
-0.0567735434,
-0.0163403824,
-0.0039495626,
0.0049645174,
-0.0075810715,
-0.0251272563,
0.0523414686,
0.0017243633,
-0.0430268645,
-0.0507282615,
-0.0222477373,
-0.0013301045,
-0.0497376584,
-0.03450647,
0.0301418211,
2.758e-7,
0.0125493994,
0.0445285216,
-0.0029683721,
0.0496772528,
0.0354135223,
0.0040569101,
0.0248753801,
0.0104402769,
-0.0214157458,
-0.0382942185,
-0.0020214333,
0.0398764797,
-0.0017094056,
-0.0300538931,
-0.0306998994,
-0.0864196792,
-0.0116629442,
0.0815888196,
-0.0325004049,
0.0333660431,
0.0617822781,
-0.0086925421,
-0.0077856923,
-0.0019034564,
0.0083909938,
-0.0157512724,
0.0646865964,
-0.017887257,
0.0484285057,
0.0142189609,
0.0571995489,
-0.005050947,
0.0262476373,
0.0795897171,
0.019664282,
-0.0147674587,
0.0224615615,
0.0031407916,
-0.0039601065,
0.0360626169,
-0.0011228962,
-0.0274065807,
-0.0151985446,
-0.0491784289,
0.0337863341,
-0.038813144,
-0.0886713341,
0.0558219366,
-0.0184616726,
-0.030945966,
0.008360018,
0.0200038105,
-0.0247130282,
-0.0486554503,
0.001123336,
-0.0151218595,
0.0081689097,
-0.0345215425,
0.0176289491,
0.0574003085,
-0.0415102653,
-0.0104286391,
-0.0850778967,
-0.0182300024,
0.0518501177,
-0.0625065491,
-0.0191087704,
2.027962395e-34,
-0.0410389081,
-0.0159638077,
0.0583946928,
0.0136966556,
-0.0124322865,
-0.0291431379,
0.06227744,
-0.0329226218,
0.0167268608,
-0.0714970306,
-0.0147136403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08213v1
|
Interpreting Latent Student Knowledge Representations in Programming Assignments
| 2024-05-13T22:01:03 | 2024-05-13T22:01:03 |
Nigel Fernandez, Andrew Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Recent advances in artificial intelligence for education leverage generative
large language models, including using them to predict open-ended student
responses rather than their correctness only. However, the black-box nature of
these models limits the interpretability of the learned student knowledge
representations. In this paper, we conduct a first exploration into
interpreting latent student knowledge representations by presenting InfoOIRT,
an Information regularized Open-ended Item Response Theory model, which
encourages the latent student knowledge states to be interpretable while being
able to generate student-written code for open-ended programming questions.
InfoOIRT maximizes the mutual information between a fixed subset of latent
knowledge states enforced with simple prior distributions and generated student
code, which encourages the model to learn disentangled representations of
salient syntactic and semantic code features including syntactic styles,
mastery of programming skills, and code structures. Through experiments on a
real-world programming education dataset, we show that InfoOIRT can both
accurately generate student code and lead to interpretable student knowledge
representations.
|
[
0.0079177814,
0.0218267925,
-0.047346618,
0.0530732051,
-0.0192882661,
0.0141269183,
-0.0219582077,
-0.0243212432,
0.0015151022,
-0.0143309087,
0.0176587887,
0.0366918072,
-0.0239890423,
0.0617608726,
0.0365774333,
-0.0336735733,
0.0114249783,
-0.0202801898,
-0.0335799754,
-0.0003202366,
0.0142407985,
-0.0095315482,
-0.027038645,
0.0753712058,
0.0490624383,
-0.0544556603,
-0.0299839154,
-0.0213395841,
-0.0264086016,
-0.0279512759,
0.001813455,
0.060067419,
0.0383002348,
-0.0581894517,
0.0000021269,
-0.0290036928,
-0.0026008645,
-0.0287111867,
-0.0221784543,
0.0152660701,
-0.0287314877,
0.0207591671,
0.0389465727,
0.0077011916,
-0.0552952625,
-0.0616058335,
0.0508738942,
-0.0050941156,
0.0378311239,
0.021357825,
0.016598206,
0.0145610115,
0.0487557352,
0.0144355372,
0.1189575046,
-0.0139366752,
0.0363013186,
0.0311904028,
-0.0010835048,
0.0390372314,
-0.0506874584,
-0.0215885267,
0.0345889069,
-0.0072018192,
0.0506040491,
0.0119353486,
-0.0241239537,
0.0138371754,
0.0398479141,
0.0699286088,
0.0042328741,
-0.0089836828,
-0.0096367877,
-0.0249473099,
0.0125479437,
0.0284015313,
-0.0640726015,
-0.0012211598,
0.0005683572,
-0.0062808455,
0.0150454538,
-0.0208229292,
-0.0233944245,
-0.0058656344,
-0.0293031149,
0.0631880239,
-0.0001296783,
-0.0375486501,
-0.0376595035,
0.0109831253,
-0.0294736866,
-0.0266703926,
-0.0165880378,
0.0667310953,
0.014683851,
0.001052535,
0.0043003536,
-0.0332993232,
-0.0111686513,
0.0109436335,
0.0077278959,
0.0265945289,
-0.000558447,
0.0133052245,
-0.006263556,
0.0710981786,
-0.0020927794,
0.0104579944,
-0.0423350595,
0.0001341747,
-0.0811793804,
-0.0158023797,
0.0010079861,
0.0768380985,
0.0483628921,
0.0442244448,
0.0028865589,
0.0496502295,
-0.0385608897,
0.0374415442,
-0.0590113997,
0.0361634381,
-0.0133738741,
0.0219936874,
-0.0530716851,
0.0393259525,
-0.0442190282,
-0.0267320629,
-0.0103201224,
0.0247067083,
-0.0105361864,
0.0449654683,
0.0097595155,
-0.0263659954,
-0.0137540447,
0.026699489,
0.0096181622,
0.0278914757,
-0.0225757919,
-0.0561345778,
0.0309770126,
-0.0026742676,
0.027651947,
-0.0682993904,
-0.0166725796,
0.056291122,
-0.0157558806,
-0.0776863322,
-0.0141112301,
0.006203555,
0.0295542385,
0.0433305576,
-0.047823064,
-0.0357052647,
-0.0049448819,
0.019958239,
0.0169201661,
-0.0105897067,
0.0210662652,
0.025825398,
-0.0080795558,
-0.0566189736,
0.0281433519,
-0.0210733898,
0.0104119638,
0.0044903699,
-0.0106781349,
0.0584114268,
0.0425782762,
0.0068059973,
-0.0064566424,
0.0170336794,
-0.0000499478,
0.0201874077,
-0.0051925248,
0.0095931347,
0.0170295779,
0.0375427864,
0.0247564539,
0.0789994672,
0.0158870127,
0.0312562548,
-0.0261956062,
0.0679413602,
0.0266795866,
-0.0146237761,
0.0357956477,
-0.0142017957,
-0.0055412548,
-0.0755287409,
0.0111358752,
-0.0161395408,
-0.0098878816,
0.0233858004,
0.0562408827,
-0.0099483216,
-0.0102336258,
-0.0047374098,
0.0351026058,
-0.0123073971,
0.0232099183,
-0.0641470701,
0.0672880709,
0.0471832603,
0.0378407612,
-0.0739253536,
-0.0107599292,
-0.0252515189,
-0.0197212547,
-0.0233797412,
0.0335364304,
-0.0384988487,
-0.0117166508,
-0.0364418365,
-0.0479134135,
-0.0083075082,
-0.0100445589,
0.0289571434,
-0.0194109622,
-0.0388442948,
0.0110780885,
-0.0098290555,
-0.0032329359,
0.0084683597,
-0.0098031452,
-0.0658031255,
0.0099090738,
-0.0034730972,
0.0209043119,
-0.0148103992,
0.0015357696,
0.0099718096,
0.0227454118,
-0.0219214298,
-0.0188977402,
-0.089362286,
-0.0531784333,
-0.0341668576,
0.0163880326,
-0.053632699,
0.0102444328,
0.0443879589,
-0.0246329959,
-0.0459878445,
0.087211363,
-0.0216858387,
0.035946738,
0.0108250845,
-0.0395014919,
-0.0032160447,
-0.0045995573,
-0.0271706004,
0.0412724353,
0.0090485495,
0.054586459,
0.0252126567,
0.0027238729,
0.0471975505,
0.0174541641,
0.0005536669,
-0.0003202377,
-0.0255643334,
0.0359024033,
0.0290529262,
0.0046852138,
-0.0241067037,
0.0046694973,
-0.0313740075,
-0.0079876427,
-0.0132156033,
0.0020724866,
0.0091944532,
-0.0127392206,
0.0267889444,
-0.0016063892,
-0.0631249771,
0.0078980653,
-0.0524651594,
0.0027493755,
0.0349609517,
0.0190272983,
-0.016275866,
-0.0359441787,
-0.0167339575,
-0.0483156219,
0.0556408204,
0.0378302671,
0.0280477665,
-0.0404703356,
0.0580295026,
-0.0246990584,
-0.0035694614,
-0.0261913072,
-0.0112459995,
0.0261962153,
-0.0444563702,
0.0683012903,
0.0442547128,
-0.0211779606,
0.0270685516,
0.0592454337,
0.009026085,
-0.0804060027,
0.0292519741,
-0.0167508107,
-0.0090440838,
-0.0386500806,
-0.052997116,
0.0064507462,
0.0439028516,
0.0454385802,
-0.0397752412,
-0.0363466032,
0.0369805656,
-0.0086638266,
-0.0033411263,
-0.0586501285,
0.0054016649,
0.0175808277,
0.0459007323,
0.0040907189,
-0.0594876185,
0.0942372307,
0.0098663047,
0.0046300022,
-0.0089760181,
-0.0164613668,
-0.0486591458,
0.0612467825,
0.0276045334,
-0.0113845048,
-0.0250075683,
-0.0127647286,
-0.0772312358,
0.0389780365,
0.0054220236,
-0.0326987989,
0.0171380509,
-0.0291153546,
-0.060519699,
0.0085454602,
0.0012463322,
-0.0368005,
-0.0112566017,
0.0509911999,
-0.0034680397,
0.0548473559,
-0.0288309846,
0.0375651717,
-0.0292726886,
0.0509408265,
-0.0350840911,
-0.0067983945,
-0.0377871804,
-0.0262835715,
0.0062921289,
0.0482867919,
-0.0435071066,
-0.0260360371,
-0.0353097282,
0.0006765743,
0.0409668572,
0.0452594534,
0.0379230492,
-0.0210604239,
0.0330694653,
0.0276970174,
-0.0199192315,
-0.0143027175,
0.0493324995,
0.0313772149,
-0.055332914,
-0.0110556874,
0.0690824911,
0.0148511343,
-0.0604561269,
0.0112302536,
-0.0169769134,
0.0214925539,
0.0547792129,
0.0520162322,
-0.0576458201,
-0.0153818429,
-0.0589883663,
0.0425049253,
0.0029888505,
-0.0581592247,
0.0072184345,
-0.0447898097,
-0.0053677796,
0.0030852996,
-0.0180010535,
-0.0710520744,
-0.028678257,
-0.0258783884,
-0.0166531913,
-0.0260469448,
-0.0045289034,
0.0102057504,
0.0617903583,
0.040472284,
-0.0063865134,
-0.0032539167,
0.0391004756,
0.0192437991,
0.0531440563,
0.0498412699,
-0.0147665087,
-0.0321262106,
-0.0272524636,
-0.0362268798,
-0.017046582,
-0.0153383082,
0.0098386183,
0.035124246,
-0.0059201689,
-0.010905371,
-0.0034833616,
0.0172879212,
-0.0657333434,
-0.0045182924,
0.0745643154,
0.0730968416,
-0.0369687155,
-0.0063633556,
-0.0548525155,
-0.0428830124,
0.0119697461,
0.0528569333,
0.0657450631,
-0.0612532906,
-0.0028814722,
-0.0950054303,
0.0070719686,
-0.0213000365,
0.0164269749,
-0.0159861334,
0.0283002276,
0.012359933,
-0.029426232,
-0.0435440652,
0.0646904856,
-0.0020029463,
0.0167672597,
-0.0114425467,
0.0217886958,
-0.0215835329,
-0.0571514964,
0.0067999386,
-0.0047441144,
-0.0200444814,
-0.0085426103,
-0.0484478287,
-0.0153290536,
-0.0729975626,
-0.0518738627,
-0.0330528766,
-0.097263135,
-0.0131873041,
-0.0053810775,
0.0485214032,
0.0165218152,
0.0239488371,
0.0103760213,
-0.0541940369,
-0.0233892761,
0.0068592192,
-0.0173396356,
-0.0078903865,
-0.003772211,
0.001757927,
0.0114069469,
-0.0065450734,
-0.0621208362,
0.0200153887,
0.0291263144,
0.0003516122,
-0.0259061027,
-0.0350615121,
0.0291757826,
0.0352763906,
0.028055707,
0.0766432062,
-0.0366693586,
-0.0243970249,
0.0132491961,
0.0293085556,
-0.0111334007,
-0.0387622491,
-0.0343043953,
0.0258799344,
-0.0034964292,
0.0185610261,
-0.0044411048,
0.0110020982,
0.0480769202,
-0.0554538444,
0.0235004798,
-0.0044631297,
0.0428656898,
0.052628804,
-0.0001774939,
-0.0308489054,
0.0399362184,
0.0134762609,
0.055560302,
0.0036244062,
0.082490325,
0.0021117907,
0.0404388458,
0.0372793265,
-0.0136921313,
-0.0519077256,
-0.0616382845,
-0.0014216694,
0.0216312632,
-0.0217514895,
0.0659061074,
-0.0187294874,
-0.0282204114,
0.0413709395,
-0.0176975317,
0.0833645388,
-0.0099591445,
-0.0628966391,
0.0078790793,
0.0422139242,
0.008419428,
-0.0215991288,
0.0831166655,
0.0241046473,
-0.0032034486,
-0.0298937652,
-0.0052354084,
-0.0537723117,
0.0319852158,
0.0604782924,
0.0693008527,
0.024864804,
0.0481972843,
-0.0364383236,
-0.0581349358,
-0.0248484779,
0.0512006097,
0.0222440697,
-0.0218784884,
0.0238690246,
0.0666445419,
-0.0413326807,
-0.0332760923,
-0.0198427998,
0.0108059635,
-0.0295212455,
-0.0449585617,
-0.0365884528,
-6.186742114e-33,
-0.0339198597,
-0.0315553173,
-0.0054731211,
0.0468953215,
0.0362502933,
-0.0034870864,
-0.0442798734,
0.015615901,
-0.0271041431,
-0.0298613366,
0.0257690009,
0.0350723267,
-0.0260751341,
0.0494511053,
0.0359862186,
-0.0108120246,
0.0220308676,
0.0194793101,
0.017538283,
0.0778410882,
0.0213410724,
-0.0000118878,
0.0557590164,
-0.0605013855,
0.0423279777,
-0.0638511032,
0.0489969216,
-0.0223282427,
-0.0168538652,
0.0374883264,
-0.0290544555,
0.0658614114,
0.0192163642,
-0.0382005088,
-0.0235555954,
-0.04481465,
-0.047846213,
-0.0911639705,
-0.0085945111,
-0.0237748418,
-0.0235444102,
-0.0507728606,
0.0599545874,
0.0146537125,
-0.0050464878,
-0.0230916627,
0.0977085084,
0.0329033546,
0.0110879447,
-0.0289375018,
-0.0319968276,
-0.0159977302,
-0.0715705231,
-0.0120706214,
-0.0323853306,
0.0490976125,
0.0090762898,
0.0052244421,
-0.0079876194,
0.0120760454,
0.0377364419,
0.0487273,
0.0532125272,
0.0059908596,
0.0016634808,
0.0450071469,
0.0592114776,
0.0052174674,
-0.0403470099,
0.0117156524,
0.0376251563,
0.0109686283,
0.0460732356,
0.0413503572,
0.0421291888,
0.0094180424,
-0.0836107433,
0.0259054676,
0.0059994198,
-0.0055328049,
-0.0031857486,
-0.0064040013,
-0.0644373819,
-0.03684723,
-0.040332038,
-0.012683453,
-0.0202376824,
-0.0557472482,
0.0433448702,
-0.0517830066,
-0.0195791535,
0.0097534331,
0.0262187663,
-0.0473215394,
-0.0046625366,
0.0027583833,
-0.01562359,
0.0396180116,
0.0005045645,
0.0112749785,
-0.0487790108,
-0.0009799531,
0.0337700322,
-0.0683786571,
0.0589646474,
0.0602050014,
0.0107848272,
0.0212547556,
-0.0386292189,
-0.0443558954,
-0.0696462765,
-0.0303783827,
0.0167332795,
0.0116857933,
0.0076080486,
0.0366668701,
-0.0054314598,
0.0369308069,
-0.0076537752,
-0.0592263751,
-0.0403910428,
-0.0662663281,
0.0002167918,
-0.0221637264,
-0.0200859308,
-0.0389689505,
-0.0449191257,
0.0055400524,
-0.0011425617,
-0.029047912,
-0.015616795,
0.0391928852,
2.672e-7,
0.0338170268,
0.0212767646,
-0.0178640839,
0.0387296006,
-0.0125103621,
0.0319994874,
-0.0119959069,
0.0342413262,
0.0449922644,
-0.0235292744,
-0.0112310611,
0.0469461605,
-0.0068634017,
0.0260700211,
-0.0505729355,
0.0143102249,
0.0420309864,
-0.0037968056,
-0.0444142744,
0.0602573007,
0.1450278908,
0.0357721373,
0.0251855962,
0.0238116309,
0.0393785387,
-0.0332858674,
0.0127811292,
-0.0244269259,
0.013615015,
0.0125856325,
-0.0422896706,
-0.0012051946,
0.0299410969,
0.0430698991,
0.0180805102,
-0.0526566319,
0.0150541365,
0.039384637,
0.0028723232,
0.0164761953,
-0.004779784,
-0.0099341115,
0.0181156546,
-0.0716714785,
0.0492839478,
-0.055519361,
-0.008559959,
0.0701736882,
-0.0301673692,
-0.028876625,
-0.0176897328,
0.009914292,
0.0322381929,
-0.0364764221,
-0.013139653,
-0.0501642115,
-0.0058527286,
-0.0142653063,
-0.0141820926,
-0.0078869751,
-0.0340001807,
-0.0378388204,
-0.049281422,
-0.0537991263,
0.0419088267,
-0.0037776527,
0.0091590527,
2.654158797e-34,
-0.0073199016,
-0.0146299647,
0.021311583,
-0.0092137456,
0.0364851095,
-0.0204355847,
-0.0164414663,
0.0278927572,
0.0284022372,
-0.0539551079,
-0.0440946855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08209v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08209v1
|
Who's in and who's out? A case study of multimodal CLIP-filtering in DataComp
| 2024-05-13T21:53:06 | 2024-05-13T21:53:06 |
Rachel Hong, William Agnew, Tadayoshi Kohno, Jamie Morgenstern
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
As training datasets become increasingly drawn from unstructured,
uncontrolled environments such as the web, researchers and industry
practitioners have increasingly relied upon data filtering techniques to
"filter out the noise" of web-scraped data. While datasets have been widely
shown to reflect the biases and values of their creators, in this paper we
contribute to an emerging body of research that assesses the filters used to
create these datasets. We show that image-text data filtering also has biases
and is value-laden, encoding specific notions of what is counted as
"high-quality" data. In our work, we audit a standard approach of image-text
CLIP-filtering on the academic benchmark DataComp's CommonPool by analyzing
discrepancies of filtering through various annotation techniques across
multiple modalities of image, text, and website source. We find that data
relating to several imputed demographic groups -- such as LGBTQ+ people, older
women, and younger men -- are associated with higher rates of exclusion.
Moreover, we demonstrate cases of exclusion amplification: not only are certain
marginalized groups already underrepresented in the unfiltered data, but
CLIP-filtering excludes data from these groups at higher rates. The
data-filtering step in the machine learning pipeline can therefore exacerbate
representation disparities already present in the data-gathering step,
especially when existing filters are designed to optimize a specifically-chosen
downstream performance metric like zero-shot image classification accuracy.
Finally, we show that the NSFW filter fails to remove sexually-explicit content
from CommonPool, and that CLIP-filtering includes several categories of
copyrighted content at high rates. Our conclusions point to a need for
fundamental changes in dataset creation and filtering practices.
|
[
0.0367025472,
0.0934539437,
-0.0261805672,
-0.0074703987,
-0.0170072392,
0.014487897,
0.0609709471,
0.0176516157,
-0.0042207092,
-0.0715518296,
-0.0006111434,
-0.0157973692,
0.0023347137,
0.0370280445,
-0.0083614178,
-0.0281929839,
0.0007231238,
0.064286612,
0.0146730691,
-0.0084691187,
0.0018626652,
0.0077668312,
0.0295508541,
0.0544999354,
0.0028493819,
-0.0065877051,
0.0729586631,
0.0194898844,
-0.0106733004,
-0.0008893512,
0.0428359732,
0.0179368984,
-0.0122958226,
0.0238622632,
0.0000019145,
-0.0541736782,
-0.0025182122,
0.0381463096,
0.02916063,
-0.0257759262,
0.0353388824,
0.0009925974,
-0.0030896023,
0.0206384454,
-0.0151526313,
0.050153777,
0.0464665927,
0.0011295524,
0.0753287598,
-0.0028012716,
-0.0474454761,
0.018612396,
-0.0678994581,
0.0015429156,
0.0316015817,
0.0322020091,
0.0403882861,
-0.0109444782,
0.0070472448,
-0.028830573,
-0.020863004,
0.0458842888,
-0.007169507,
0.0379735976,
0.026374789,
0.0214870516,
-0.0407812335,
-0.0975065231,
0.0442178808,
0.0497053601,
0.0042625866,
0.0280794073,
0.0145537108,
0.0006031217,
0.01800262,
0.0268671587,
-0.0456855558,
0.0799651369,
-0.0254752673,
0.0372840948,
-0.0967666879,
0.0011410449,
0.0435882956,
0.0319541506,
0.0117920088,
0.0047419402,
0.0084343199,
-0.0128106307,
0.0071119349,
-0.0023469885,
0.028142808,
-0.0101467986,
0.0681123063,
-0.0182798374,
0.0457331762,
-0.0096633341,
-0.0512351021,
-0.0191026274,
0.0404455587,
-0.0299487375,
0.0165187474,
0.0352010615,
-0.0221150536,
0.0539269783,
0.0075864331,
-0.0146465283,
0.0305141564,
0.0462500006,
0.042953264,
0.0015447211,
0.0137167452,
0.0149861891,
0.060765069,
0.0244201515,
-0.0100582195,
0.0288075153,
-0.0486431718,
0.0121883545,
-0.0696908683,
0.0206196755,
-0.036690928,
0.0254148785,
-0.0216684509,
0.0463393703,
-0.0346981958,
-0.0493058898,
-0.0092701763,
0.037199229,
-0.0093114562,
-0.0571422428,
0.023086926,
-0.0087966789,
0.0279823709,
-0.0375225917,
0.0544514656,
0.0647207946,
0.0171374865,
-0.0317389034,
-0.0307314228,
-0.0317609124,
-0.0139532071,
-0.0038347356,
0.0541084409,
-0.0205757618,
0.0295264665,
0.0026638911,
0.0054111877,
-0.0663775802,
-0.0266851895,
0.0429744944,
-0.0631095767,
0.0763015598,
0.0286951661,
-0.0152166281,
0.0372241177,
0.040001519,
-0.0507348888,
0.0908665061,
0.0189585388,
0.0211536679,
0.050922107,
-0.0163536835,
-0.0135227283,
0.0197919104,
0.0467995293,
0.0364772528,
-0.0835016519,
0.0126273269,
-0.0102190925,
-0.0274635348,
0.0301056765,
0.0020649654,
-0.0305766203,
-0.0590891279,
0.0484328009,
0.0654905066,
-0.0124632046,
0.0554191209,
-0.0205394272,
0.0144954128,
-0.0037629143,
-0.0130496863,
-0.0831894502,
-0.0051832874,
0.0267815702,
-0.0647756308,
0.0075365286,
0.030681245,
-0.0249511525,
-0.0100894598,
0.0044039697,
0.0089286156,
0.0677403733,
0.0001781018,
0.0148870815,
0.0120734507,
0.0073360833,
-0.0286455452,
0.0242214184,
-0.0210389607,
0.0135399252,
-0.0510237329,
0.0065865484,
0.0125554372,
0.0197358727,
-0.04327989,
0.0305675156,
-0.0433783643,
0.0150320223,
-0.0254085176,
-0.0111763291,
0.0241353158,
-0.0006165686,
-0.0394972004,
-0.0675844401,
-0.0094911968,
-0.0071740677,
-0.0140361693,
0.0280765127,
0.0125371618,
0.0143357906,
0.0187082049,
-0.0506110117,
0.0275220722,
0.0510095321,
0.0173552185,
-0.0118350508,
0.0338216834,
0.046593044,
0.0046448037,
-0.029992912,
-0.0209998954,
-0.0038389727,
0.0188594796,
-0.010574745,
-0.0256592128,
0.0183131378,
0.0377604999,
0.0500945486,
-0.125513941,
-0.0308472775,
0.0601847917,
-0.0121241808,
0.0448130779,
0.0223124083,
-0.0120824613,
-0.0089434516,
-0.0188476108,
-0.033328101,
-0.0083153639,
0.0356848612,
-0.0147052426,
0.0345390514,
-0.0156286489,
0.0179924518,
0.0209062248,
-0.0384405032,
0.0205061473,
0.0085805533,
-0.0255921539,
0.0057186084,
-0.0584213957,
0.0276481435,
0.0260496028,
-0.0192734562,
-0.0247943848,
0.019045718,
-0.0044331341,
-0.0028977382,
0.0153646348,
-0.018035369,
-0.0149215935,
-0.0240149293,
-0.0230677854,
-0.0402715988,
-0.0333734192,
-0.066197522,
-0.0232896954,
0.0633146986,
0.0086879544,
-0.0185450092,
0.0320171639,
0.0136036091,
-0.0646226332,
-0.0128976619,
0.0790501833,
0.0217801873,
-0.0245965328,
0.063717626,
0.0120052267,
-0.0568227693,
-0.007826929,
-0.0106855016,
0.0027194314,
0.0361605659,
0.0123400213,
-0.0574242957,
0.0277969874,
0.0320045836,
0.0449472703,
0.0173181519,
0.0421431251,
-0.0058576502,
0.0000457255,
-0.0111559797,
0.0606796779,
0.0485574901,
-0.0407369584,
-0.0027237306,
-0.0298641734,
-0.0125046056,
-0.0173093434,
-0.0571373254,
0.0962531269,
-0.0613363124,
-0.0417783484,
-0.0822156817,
-0.0002936699,
-0.009663498,
0.0259516444,
-0.0549908876,
-0.0346811041,
0.0289050881,
0.0340030231,
0.0139849735,
0.0192816481,
-0.011053836,
0.0097608399,
0.0063290019,
-0.0066564004,
0.0487354174,
-0.0201110616,
-0.020204531,
-0.0463843457,
0.0070689339,
0.0616904125,
-0.0751436278,
0.0328781828,
0.0171978585,
-0.0179179125,
-0.0214438345,
-0.0576445833,
-0.0327134095,
-0.0632196367,
0.0222434793,
-0.0112538589,
0.0096422592,
0.0034606019,
0.0020412672,
0.0102933208,
-0.0067301379,
0.0317141339,
-0.0124843335,
-0.023718236,
0.0127183888,
-0.0012741033,
-0.0044499249,
-0.0177504309,
0.0014994759,
0.0092867753,
-0.0636582226,
0.0690961927,
0.0129960459,
-0.0194420908,
0.0239878893,
0.055345621,
0.0188593939,
0.0087071005,
-0.0039341766,
-0.0152242118,
0.0320935547,
-0.0171293113,
0.0338316374,
0.0201608725,
0.0066736909,
-0.0545759983,
-0.0158943217,
0.0263587646,
-0.0232342649,
0.0427659899,
-0.030170938,
-0.1103999987,
0.0096833734,
0.0108783934,
0.0451966524,
-0.0739216581,
-0.0587749593,
-0.0201084539,
-0.0517204218,
0.0554984882,
0.0074248221,
-0.043760743,
-0.0283663049,
-0.0557901785,
0.0422711112,
-0.0278385729,
-0.0048902868,
-0.0493997149,
-0.0077585713,
0.006170928,
0.0184427332,
-0.0277440473,
-0.0739957616,
-0.0078215515,
-0.0378868952,
-0.0040530651,
0.0255659353,
0.0760876387,
-0.0478451177,
-0.0143916123,
0.0447545052,
-0.0216236003,
-0.022148205,
-0.0182934534,
0.075229533,
-0.0467863567,
-0.0276839416,
-0.0291671194,
0.0615862384,
0.020151943,
-0.0116958255,
-0.0291102473,
0.0087891826,
-0.0195602681,
-0.0142852366,
-0.0865470842,
0.0043759402,
-0.0085858982,
0.0716932341,
0.0418703556,
-0.0510159917,
0.0115129622,
-0.0644035488,
0.0169218853,
0.0108021703,
-0.0173011795,
0.03542725,
-0.0184130836,
-0.0489853173,
-0.0048537413,
-0.0355112515,
0.0153447324,
0.0128062572,
0.0181684066,
-0.0703493804,
-0.0164343454,
-0.0118650543,
-0.0478351153,
0.0151672671,
-0.0164298508,
0.0046412339,
0.0282840151,
-0.0075940927,
-0.0567071363,
-0.0311035831,
-0.0415232144,
0.0288331807,
-0.0320264921,
-0.0143090021,
0.0244725924,
0.0565867424,
0.0294565614,
-0.0037589108,
0.0045351395,
-0.0320250057,
0.0522657447,
0.0935804322,
-0.0028469022,
-0.0289139282,
0.0501535274,
-0.0576212145,
-0.0104163047,
0.0032355902,
-0.0248160176,
0.0219981354,
0.0088340007,
-0.0549107306,
-0.011884178,
0.0281964149,
-0.0005048132,
0.0062342114,
0.0040917341,
-0.0297143683,
0.0040442804,
-0.0074817585,
-0.0318654031,
0.0294896774,
-0.0175943971,
-0.0109074209,
-0.0090269698,
0.0029119514,
0.0046476265,
-0.0663892329,
0.0485192984,
-0.0118634161,
0.0490307249,
-0.0858747959,
-0.0020539006,
0.0141002508,
-0.0216937754,
-0.0035106279,
0.0062041669,
0.0110733453,
0.0209854916,
-0.0009380731,
0.0158582721,
-0.0054612923,
0.0352182537,
0.0379599705,
0.0431167558,
0.0065446412,
0.0135814482,
-0.0482385233,
-0.0023283169,
-0.0078308349,
-0.0277845152,
0.0039578229,
-0.0136299049,
-0.0201724041,
-0.0087187719,
-0.041561082,
0.0034667044,
0.0055865059,
0.0120215686,
-0.0154187707,
0.0129792998,
-0.0148940207,
-0.0117208799,
-0.0077407961,
0.0426508486,
-0.0079766195,
0.0276318975,
-0.0202795547,
-0.0608365797,
-0.0143834213,
-0.0155924102,
0.0260718502,
0.0466216244,
0.0029674212,
-0.0248816498,
-0.0646328554,
-0.0548344739,
-0.0344462059,
-0.0521074384,
0.0575248189,
0.0034135799,
-0.0165702421,
0.0378222466,
-0.0104338862,
-0.024513483,
-0.0152308382,
-0.0286862627,
0.0000405394,
0.013367258,
0.0309730116,
-6.297072544e-33,
0.0189439561,
-0.0021784299,
-0.0482718535,
0.0113605279,
-0.0147119798,
0.0070237969,
0.0156692564,
-0.0636652336,
0.0099164592,
-0.0221508071,
-0.0175844748,
0.0237737466,
-0.0004981803,
0.0067607355,
0.0002836042,
-0.033638265,
0.0593738966,
-0.0014960177,
-0.0509393029,
0.0076062586,
-0.0109682353,
0.0419380069,
-0.014982569,
-0.0739651248,
0.035494063,
0.0247201975,
-0.0447757207,
-0.0405826755,
0.0471376255,
0.052632831,
-0.0223550759,
0.0478573628,
0.0358661003,
-0.0536368638,
0.0083491988,
0.0365550183,
-0.0949536115,
0.0010052781,
-0.0074286778,
0.0377591327,
0.0234520677,
-0.0221776143,
0.0596407875,
-0.0013046332,
0.0063980133,
-0.0650435612,
0.0589252114,
-0.0460496172,
-0.0090062581,
-0.0331522636,
0.0260970928,
0.0149501059,
-0.0395570956,
0.0330973193,
0.0359278657,
0.0798489898,
0.0163189378,
0.0542309321,
-0.0602867492,
0.0248754248,
0.0153004415,
-0.0563914925,
0.0394359678,
0.0119365864,
0.0492393412,
0.067788586,
0.0236143023,
0.0247533191,
-0.0149010113,
-0.0807916671,
0.0603644252,
0.0189368688,
-0.0430595838,
0.0413507745,
0.0791788623,
-0.0660396591,
-0.0433107354,
0.0034855744,
-0.0324304774,
-0.0141273914,
0.0211251881,
-0.0083431909,
-0.0221051462,
-0.0105495695,
-0.019734364,
-0.0726936534,
-0.0311029181,
-0.0254070945,
0.0207175277,
-0.0190031398,
-0.0736934021,
0.096334748,
-0.0128105013,
-0.0531689934,
-0.0650983527,
-0.0100842575,
-0.032977961,
-0.0193364359,
0.0261990316,
-0.0390686244,
-0.0393044315,
0.0064064772,
0.0334942676,
-0.0199063029,
0.0540518984,
-0.0096024228,
0.0462282002,
0.0517069213,
-0.0480116308,
-0.0231300816,
-0.0337581821,
0.0486743078,
0.0280865114,
0.046090968,
0.0339962952,
0.0382936075,
-0.0001202941,
-0.0022066263,
0.0575964488,
0.0763739124,
-0.0268318914,
-0.0327197537,
-0.0175852515,
0.008257621,
-0.0047707213,
-0.0587063245,
-0.002672073,
0.0265532639,
0.0675438866,
-0.0860313028,
-0.0196405705,
-0.0427809171,
2.652e-7,
0.0269042067,
0.0002853432,
0.0009646236,
-0.0107298233,
0.0177010857,
0.0282121934,
0.0099865356,
0.0426204503,
0.035829667,
-0.0185335111,
-0.016047975,
0.0349851921,
0.0209618453,
0.0477545038,
0.00087591,
-0.0537695885,
-0.0414017402,
-0.0151254535,
-0.0268640332,
0.0396987535,
0.0069792592,
0.0698744953,
0.0480618812,
-0.0599131994,
0.0135436542,
-0.027555421,
0.0236419104,
-0.0388596281,
0.0203692652,
-0.0348005146,
0.0375479646,
0.0446579717,
0.0115586212,
0.0211162213,
-0.0421342887,
-0.0013528249,
0.048974853,
0.0235451609,
-0.0033998352,
0.0509967618,
-0.0048542656,
0.005009023,
-0.0000340681,
-0.0359767415,
0.0956103802,
0.007700704,
-0.0219964366,
-0.0584618077,
-0.0632041544,
-0.0491753742,
0.0742686838,
-0.0158703532,
-0.0090144919,
-0.0079538114,
-0.0082456199,
0.0048321276,
-0.0123804016,
-0.0901718438,
0.0004398185,
-0.0248629972,
-0.0127198631,
-0.0295645799,
-0.002802725,
0.0235036686,
0.0396023169,
-0.0150812156,
-0.0014586654,
2.409668829e-34,
0.0130825909,
-0.0059960433,
0.0296615995,
-0.0472737998,
-0.0161036719,
0.0047782315,
0.0355100073,
-0.0226002894,
-0.0178088751,
0.0556826778,
0.0141896522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08172v1
|
CANTONMT: Investigating Back-Translation and Model-Switch Mechanisms for Cantonese-English Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-13T20:37:04 | 2024-05-13T20:37:04 |
Kung Yin Hong, Lifeng Han, Riza Batista-Navarro, Goran Nenadic
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper investigates the development and evaluation of machine translation
models from Cantonese to English, where we propose a novel approach to tackle
low-resource language translations. The main objectives of the study are to
develop a model that can effectively translate Cantonese to English and
evaluate it against state-of-the-art commercial models. To achieve this, a new
parallel corpus has been created by combining different available corpora
online with preprocessing and cleaning. In addition, a monolingual Cantonese
dataset has been created through web scraping to aid the synthetic parallel
corpus generation. Following the data collection process, several approaches,
including fine-tuning models, back-translation, and model switch, have been
used. The translation quality of models has been evaluated with multiple
quality metrics, including lexicon-based metrics (SacreBLEU and hLEPOR) and
embedding-space metrics (COMET and BERTscore). Based on the automatic metrics,
the best model is selected and compared against the 2 best commercial
translators using the human evaluation framework HOPES. The best model proposed
in this investigation (NLLB-mBART) with model switch mechanisms has reached
comparable and even better automatic evaluation scores against State-of-the-art
commercial models (Bing and Baidu Translators), with a SacreBLEU score of 16.8
on our test set. Furthermore, an open-source web application has been developed
to allow users to translate between Cantonese and English, with the different
trained models available for effective comparisons between models from this
investigation and users. CANTONMT is available at
https://github.com/kenrickkung/CantoneseTranslation
|
[
0.0358783044,
0.0243125837,
-0.0179865435,
0.0560797714,
-0.0529226027,
0.0087538362,
0.0265095662,
-0.011150443,
-0.0200940687,
0.0041093836,
-0.0564400144,
-0.0557432212,
0.0395184979,
-0.0258637071,
0.0241717584,
-0.0326788649,
0.0292200577,
0.0339514911,
-0.012223077,
0.007320168,
-0.0137656303,
-0.0030855024,
0.0235909764,
0.0511061698,
0.0166478436,
-0.0222326983,
0.0351669677,
0.0781636685,
0.0547794029,
-0.0285655633,
-0.0026383414,
0.0235139672,
-0.0247870684,
0.0564654209,
0.0000022763,
-0.027051026,
-0.0274423342,
0.0346052162,
0.0259670224,
0.0456242785,
0.0418432988,
-0.0360367298,
-0.0061868373,
0.0503883697,
-0.0027526591,
-0.0045402711,
0.0719599351,
0.0399998315,
0.0545329265,
0.090145804,
-0.0240857136,
-0.0572435744,
-0.0014009567,
-0.0613565892,
-0.0528872125,
-0.0471008979,
-0.0140808579,
0.0068418002,
-0.038455788,
-0.0237571094,
-0.0323876664,
0.0456889495,
-0.0035831043,
0.0041809259,
-0.0140095372,
0.0036752643,
-0.0298843198,
-0.0317276008,
-0.0056286724,
0.0943809003,
-0.0817982405,
-0.0062971245,
-0.0297709405,
-0.0177945681,
0.0044145659,
-0.000931121,
-0.0224683657,
0.0238022879,
0.0217336919,
0.0219314899,
-0.0130818738,
0.0073432885,
0.0491166115,
-0.0028896609,
-0.0247520581,
-0.052570492,
0.0283396356,
-0.0377522968,
-0.0146931298,
-0.0097280685,
0.0089295981,
0.0072553302,
0.0511050932,
-0.0121028293,
0.0174056273,
0.0280597117,
0.0110134985,
-0.0300522037,
-0.0049369964,
-0.096200116,
0.0357374772,
0.0748948678,
-0.0336107798,
0.0214986764,
-0.0172064658,
0.0564753227,
-0.0316710807,
0.0082807746,
-0.0833420977,
-0.00669199,
-0.034993194,
0.0291897003,
-0.0672805309,
-0.0046081259,
-0.0488168113,
-0.0420651622,
-0.0104028825,
-0.0149019854,
0.0213651955,
-0.0291999988,
0.048209656,
-0.0406942926,
-0.0512645282,
0.0173748769,
0.0024425164,
0.0418091193,
0.0002751342,
-0.0154388081,
-0.018056713,
-0.0561060198,
-0.0147711392,
0.0086471047,
-0.0364421271,
-0.0339754894,
-0.0134124449,
0.0826437399,
-0.0277654137,
-0.0165409222,
-0.0371307358,
0.0408915132,
-0.0248961262,
-0.0525189675,
-0.0068188054,
-0.0475498103,
0.0402549542,
-0.0092717344,
0.0521474779,
-0.0234084968,
0.0018096762,
-0.0130308541,
-0.0075693503,
0.0322682224,
-0.0139397327,
0.0058282847,
0.0294108838,
-0.0071514468,
-0.0213491526,
0.0877445489,
0.0587864667,
0.0295993444,
0.0268020686,
-0.0304510891,
-0.0381898284,
0.0178749971,
-0.0136212446,
0.0201621577,
-0.0800366923,
-0.0049881181,
-0.0136157395,
0.0497058257,
-0.0209790356,
0.0650887713,
-0.034837272,
0.0212601069,
0.043454919,
0.0134437671,
0.0414786637,
0.0681712478,
0.0469073728,
-0.0061305226,
0.0100809727,
-0.0143765286,
-0.0158751458,
0.0368893668,
0.0010199816,
0.0032327978,
0.0060449895,
0.0431929603,
-0.0224320125,
-0.0498699807,
-0.0298179518,
-0.0129842432,
0.0173398592,
-0.0337069519,
0.0139898891,
-0.0092050033,
-0.0465720445,
0.0461181737,
-0.0259068497,
-0.0241268184,
0.0261248946,
-0.031176012,
-0.0518752448,
0.1090172753,
0.0229788441,
0.0423386395,
-0.0408869274,
-0.0303808339,
-0.058641322,
0.0564152151,
0.0673420802,
0.0209317897,
0.0133804614,
-0.0671145841,
0.0047670547,
0.0312762037,
0.0023281272,
0.0215903781,
-0.0004386921,
0.0515786223,
0.0399618037,
-0.0344090573,
-0.0831644312,
0.0296430867,
-0.029174991,
-0.0024322211,
0.0376465134,
0.0164357778,
0.0490851738,
0.011916439,
-0.0205571502,
0.0152996071,
0.0202702265,
-0.0250999536,
-0.0346673653,
0.053241387,
-0.005426174,
-0.041890081,
0.0308164936,
-0.0492231138,
0.0111591853,
0.0494589843,
-0.0587051772,
-0.0594240427,
-0.0428312719,
-0.0110487454,
0.0329355486,
-0.0797716081,
0.0417319238,
-0.0272461865,
-0.0102671003,
-0.0175678246,
0.0486821234,
-0.0084028402,
0.0087166606,
0.0036057513,
0.0066789584,
0.0425322689,
-0.0577415526,
-0.0586698875,
0.0384435654,
0.0186885707,
0.0608353913,
0.0116796112,
0.0196314435,
-0.0104604801,
-0.0220167357,
-0.0645275339,
0.0136820823,
-0.0291091166,
-0.0037139989,
0.0400865451,
0.0150702065,
-0.0003344229,
-0.0062549473,
-0.0094085177,
0.030392874,
-0.0574401766,
0.0199861787,
-0.0029047313,
-0.0151767414,
0.0319069326,
-0.0311429221,
-0.0152281579,
0.0380041637,
0.0256649684,
-0.0056464956,
-0.0097844778,
-0.0709588006,
0.0010354751,
-0.0028304672,
-0.0259029251,
0.005476675,
-0.0922880545,
-0.0013153211,
-0.0207848847,
0.0163478553,
0.0291138981,
0.0196712762,
-0.0019055707,
0.0176948644,
0.0313857831,
-0.0376091301,
0.0078231655,
-0.0125012239,
-0.0344862752,
-0.0376529396,
-0.0428384431,
-0.0156472139,
0.0540171415,
0.0364496112,
-0.0003963654,
-0.1026071534,
-0.0730569661,
-0.0337973088,
-0.0115765613,
0.0010215769,
0.0446419455,
-0.0146019794,
0.0064287269,
-0.0265269093,
-0.0338547528,
0.0510037616,
-0.0281761829,
0.0123142628,
-0.0795589313,
0.017118128,
-0.0218253992,
0.0193502549,
-0.0532453805,
0.0292282291,
-0.0297330748,
-0.0209003165,
-0.0143343993,
0.0166597962,
-0.0023501532,
-0.0332454666,
0.0063318214,
-0.0233468972,
-0.0151703451,
-0.0271313917,
0.001480037,
-0.0146255381,
-0.0461308882,
-0.0043517211,
0.0072671487,
0.0341326222,
-0.0186559483,
-0.0226183739,
0.0638084337,
-0.0351439714,
0.0430165827,
-0.0183525719,
0.0480913818,
-0.0012025484,
-0.0039578206,
-0.0179981925,
-0.0008856658,
0.0248717126,
-0.0304508712,
0.0553539544,
-0.0084840711,
-0.0078871436,
0.021161506,
-0.0282428209,
-0.0159316584,
0.0289022643,
-0.0167921688,
-0.0520372242,
-0.0122994408,
0.0529484525,
-0.0366675667,
-0.0058776638,
0.1104998663,
0.0141810365,
-0.048054982,
-0.0030200505,
0.013080392,
0.0003865876,
0.007354632,
-0.0062197507,
-0.0370417237,
0.0009444187,
0.0027138286,
0.0336135514,
0.0585325733,
0.039494127,
-0.006329196,
-0.1173404232,
0.0415426791,
0.054041326,
-0.0703919679,
-0.0316784643,
-0.0130316997,
-0.0303159636,
-0.0524721704,
0.0531063601,
-0.0067968988,
0.0173441302,
-0.0140227228,
0.008306656,
0.0576638728,
-0.0683550239,
-0.00371388,
-0.0560376793,
0.0284216926,
0.0542781018,
0.0585698113,
-0.020294087,
-0.0112996325,
0.0196782965,
-0.0402436033,
0.0006793023,
-0.0004303888,
0.0209845677,
0.0035720074,
-0.022499904,
0.0271929894,
-0.0122385854,
0.0040595168,
0.0367932394,
0.0003583077,
0.0256949589,
0.0037303134,
0.0034144218,
0.0192372054,
-0.002626874,
-0.0100316601,
0.0760031939,
0.0284195356,
-0.048963096,
0.0040459619,
0.0236632768,
-0.034434095,
-0.0560545325,
0.013535901,
0.0557088368,
-0.0685706213,
-0.0559760444,
-0.0985176712,
-0.0372920968,
-0.0226311758,
0.019426994,
0.0430968888,
0.0078299986,
0.020924855,
0.0229551923,
-0.0197473764,
0.027031729,
0.0240873136,
0.0219139792,
-0.0581025593,
0.0065534324,
0.0565868393,
-0.0252385065,
0.0259066708,
0.001589396,
-0.0408686996,
-0.0530916415,
-0.0174032804,
0.0391195416,
0.0109085832,
0.0162916332,
-0.0562805757,
-0.0088440031,
-0.0044570635,
-0.0092717018,
-0.0188106801,
-0.0294553395,
0.0277947225,
-0.0106965201,
-0.0283711478,
0.0253566448,
-0.020182915,
0.0046341955,
-0.0041080867,
0.0708427057,
-0.0039437246,
-0.0396568589,
0.0206465051,
0.0145029714,
0.0307365712,
-0.0601750501,
-0.0364571847,
-0.0314306021,
0.0465973318,
-0.0044718343,
-0.0204272568,
-0.0465058014,
-0.0353534855,
0.1101853177,
0.0015255162,
-0.0072461455,
-0.0083913431,
0.0009708332,
-0.0434207246,
0.0168593433,
0.0105582103,
-0.0399873927,
0.0684399456,
0.0200465396,
0.0377431251,
-0.0431741588,
-0.019373728,
-0.0142522631,
-0.0095512765,
-0.0184603631,
0.0458022244,
0.0324230455,
0.0528103635,
0.0146295996,
0.0505057313,
-0.0181726869,
-0.0351814702,
-0.0331900343,
-0.005546737,
0.0746577606,
-0.0001965828,
0.1078328118,
-0.0022299141,
-0.0104115549,
-0.0312800296,
0.0197993796,
0.0086884741,
0.023440456,
-0.0090159867,
-0.0176714454,
-0.0172963701,
-0.0021871021,
0.0580977388,
-0.0023658357,
0.0080621457,
0.0059210644,
0.001129192,
-0.0132951969,
0.0006459494,
0.0047426536,
0.0051944698,
-0.0229634326,
-0.0283541288,
-0.0356423147,
-0.0542416498,
-0.0079731196,
0.0075770048,
0.0196326021,
0.0210220646,
-0.0112535805,
0.0743884593,
-0.0038555576,
0.0184301585,
-0.0680710748,
-0.0081335921,
0.0049182489,
0.0082999375,
-0.0396423563,
-6.431412447e-33,
-0.0318809561,
0.0133552225,
0.0046212384,
-0.0331663787,
-0.0453585871,
-0.0370135196,
-0.0408624224,
-0.0331313722,
-0.0248131379,
-0.0100307865,
0.0092762029,
0.0177130383,
0.0312870443,
0.0150075471,
0.0208798628,
0.0232912526,
0.0532916076,
0.0001880045,
-0.0312959179,
-0.0019384908,
0.037378747,
0.0519145802,
0.0535785295,
-0.0383911692,
0.0012768253,
-0.0205664337,
-0.0164118651,
0.0254683644,
-0.0227239635,
0.0313746072,
0.010014887,
0.0117483223,
0.0200123079,
-0.0151864635,
-0.0256258287,
-0.0380710103,
-0.1091746688,
0.0025602398,
0.0374167822,
0.0402001441,
0.0124146687,
-0.0205171183,
0.0471249931,
-0.0293402188,
0.0113093946,
-0.0205374621,
0.0087917522,
-0.064137347,
-0.021493366,
0.0222857315,
-0.0495778136,
0.0285485853,
-0.0121658081,
-0.0219676699,
0.0188019909,
0.0526576005,
-0.0520647652,
-0.0008815319,
-0.0813595876,
-0.014625188,
-0.0025492224,
0.0325821973,
0.0495849624,
0.0386279561,
0.0130243618,
-0.0209275354,
0.0501490198,
-0.0112710167,
0.0645473525,
0.0101356842,
0.058102455,
0.0529400893,
0.0687274635,
0.0232417304,
0.0559613667,
-0.0509325899,
-0.0547511466,
0.0175129306,
-0.0151983574,
-0.0029546937,
0.0314162783,
0.0397156551,
-0.0256264452,
-0.0103947483,
-0.0212088432,
-0.0687351599,
-0.0083593652,
-0.0544525012,
0.0288027804,
0.0272093341,
-0.0331693962,
-0.0138276499,
0.0671770126,
-0.0325681046,
0.0512277633,
-0.0130428923,
-0.0095534818,
0.0106094945,
-0.0265764501,
0.0602628514,
-0.0532191806,
-0.0437809341,
0.0056593507,
0.0223826524,
-0.0126001071,
-0.0146994879,
0.0322229601,
0.0267515834,
-0.0225776136,
0.0238279533,
-0.0349531099,
-0.0485626645,
0.0018157531,
0.0381858684,
-0.0164022017,
-0.0159562044,
0.0028810091,
0.0417058654,
0.019248493,
0.026333265,
-0.0320711248,
-0.013534396,
0.0374227427,
0.0162129365,
-0.0432400294,
0.0221185721,
-0.0115764849,
0.0401199944,
0.0605647229,
-0.0481454693,
-0.0273534674,
0.0445814431,
2.973e-7,
0.0638445616,
-0.0037717225,
0.0323558152,
0.0029725982,
-0.0044541918,
-0.0075719506,
-0.0586052947,
0.0264799222,
0.0189721584,
0.0829700679,
0.0583876856,
0.0250918437,
0.1092391014,
0.0249860045,
-0.0799690112,
-0.0149942208,
-0.0433523916,
0.0154883321,
-0.0176902656,
0.018202344,
0.0268411096,
0.086620912,
-0.0069834534,
0.0205776691,
-0.002371477,
-0.018263774,
0.0596194752,
-0.0158115737,
-0.0049743722,
0.0183678754,
0.0239774715,
0.0502607115,
-0.0439169891,
-0.0276442729,
-0.0399105437,
0.0347412713,
0.0471475907,
0.0813935101,
-0.0182419308,
-0.0507948101,
0.0132630402,
-0.0033626785,
-0.0010783315,
-0.0402496606,
0.0399332754,
-0.0077247098,
-0.0066088783,
0.0378792249,
-0.0024521581,
0.0199800767,
0.0443363041,
-0.0611182712,
-0.0343926586,
0.0232310034,
0.0441432409,
-0.0044609969,
-0.023176102,
-0.0337650478,
-0.0363076702,
0.0110661909,
-0.0250680819,
-0.0517600216,
0.0014733399,
-0.0228656754,
0.0046431138,
-0.0125928083,
0.0009088924,
2.072063407e-34,
0.0357099548,
-0.0296832025,
0.0075606261,
0.0314689428,
0.0175431371,
-0.0417691059,
-0.0292749107,
-0.0070941113,
-0.0417966768,
-0.0440605693,
-0.0369807892
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08151v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08151v2
|
Benchmarking Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models in Biomedical NLP: Application, Robustness, and Self-Awareness
| 2024-05-13T19:51:20 | 2024-05-16T13:53:26 |
Mingchen Li, Zaifu Zhan, Han Yang, Yongkang Xiao, Jiatan Huang, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
various biomedical natural language processing (NLP) tasks, leveraging the
demonstration within the input context to adapt to new tasks. However, LLM is
sensitive to the selection of demonstrations. To address the hallucination
issue inherent in LLM, retrieval-augmented LLM (RAL) offers a solution by
retrieving pertinent information from an established database. Nonetheless,
existing research work lacks rigorous evaluation of the impact of
retrieval-augmented large language models on different biomedical NLP tasks.
This deficiency makes it challenging to ascertain the capabilities of RAL
within the biomedical domain. Moreover, the outputs from RAL are affected by
retrieving the unlabeled, counterfactual, or diverse knowledge that is not well
studied in the biomedical domain. However, such knowledge is common in the real
world. Finally, exploring the self-awareness ability is also crucial for the
RAL system. So, in this paper, we systematically investigate the impact of RALs
on 5 different biomedical tasks (triple extraction, link prediction,
classification, question answering, and natural language inference). We analyze
the performance of RALs in four fundamental abilities, including unlabeled
robustness, counterfactual robustness, diverse robustness, and negative
awareness. To this end, we proposed an evaluation framework to assess the RALs'
performance on different biomedical NLP tasks and establish four different
testbeds based on the aforementioned fundamental abilities. Then, we evaluate 3
representative LLMs with 3 different retrievers on 5 tasks over 9 datasets.
|
[
0.0869847387,
0.0189470463,
0.0148328785,
0.0066777929,
-0.0332487784,
0.0256207921,
-0.0198473204,
0.0167069994,
0.0627517551,
-0.0430567376,
-0.0388112068,
-0.0172258597,
-0.0379933454,
0.004438343,
0.0131409923,
0.0079003414,
0.0389030091,
-0.0068848059,
0.0232505817,
0.0058013946,
-0.0128135281,
-0.006518825,
-0.004542158,
0.0183144156,
0.041431576,
0.0053386078,
0.0548863932,
-0.0170966014,
-0.0054463865,
-0.0590687692,
-0.0128106298,
0.0349650197,
0.0078478903,
-0.0039238576,
0.0000016589,
-0.0837222412,
-0.0310455654,
0.0340221412,
-0.0413473547,
-0.0270785112,
0.0319797434,
-0.0110813444,
0.028787557,
0.0010653462,
-0.0446112156,
-0.0260965601,
0.00882011,
0.0806849003,
0.0263688434,
0.0587255098,
-0.0026743922,
-0.0280508157,
0.0409900025,
-0.0175513383,
0.023197392,
-0.0286449324,
0.0808075368,
-0.0018309619,
0.0506888255,
0.031729795,
0.0213286839,
0.062666066,
-0.0251493156,
0.0475860648,
0.0231530592,
0.0260191038,
-0.0653382391,
-0.0220756233,
-0.0040765591,
0.0565573014,
0.0024318018,
-0.0241418388,
0.0198162403,
0.0192314088,
-0.0101954397,
0.033053603,
-0.0469700508,
0.0019085956,
-0.0230657682,
-0.0017481741,
-0.0125175361,
0.0038490375,
0.054376889,
0.0225227494,
-0.0207773466,
0.0554685704,
0.0177749936,
-0.0422842428,
0.0289656315,
0.0089505427,
-0.017374156,
0.006559452,
0.0405154862,
0.0359365717,
-0.0109237498,
0.0342021622,
0.0385880433,
-0.0400489271,
0.0775946528,
-0.0833188593,
-0.0058082794,
-0.0147645604,
-0.0449073091,
0.0618834756,
-0.0588753447,
0.0010556987,
-0.0713866502,
0.0433851779,
-0.0254101939,
-0.0120065883,
-0.0383517146,
-0.0400779285,
0.0014522083,
0.0866522714,
-0.0332635418,
-0.0097619705,
-0.0708145276,
0.0030575944,
-0.0203767642,
-0.0181941614,
0.0034208326,
0.0663189292,
-0.0126250898,
-0.0235648435,
-0.0455701351,
0.0273972545,
0.016671719,
-0.0009303496,
-0.0245551057,
-0.0889139548,
-0.027481528,
-0.0107894558,
0.0307768881,
-0.0648786277,
0.0433253311,
0.0998402685,
0.0380059406,
-0.0584847182,
0.0015059697,
-0.0181568991,
-0.0407172069,
-0.065077737,
0.0102997506,
-0.0500014611,
0.0298461691,
0.0340364538,
-0.0109636756,
-0.0545814671,
0.034857858,
0.0095689548,
-0.0501788147,
0.0850627646,
0.0056212535,
-0.0137778278,
0.0113038197,
0.0063491785,
0.0041544526,
0.0330013335,
-0.0061164261,
-0.0366302915,
0.0275534932,
0.0041197496,
0.0163212046,
-0.018765457,
0.0308331586,
-0.0600427017,
-0.0313663706,
0.0497278124,
0.0141431764,
0.0578251369,
-0.0393797345,
0.0788013414,
0.0050463295,
-0.0292920694,
0.0195701756,
0.0752351806,
0.027050592,
-0.0071427072,
0.0117232101,
-0.0153779956,
0.0225904007,
-0.0186370313,
-0.0393838212,
0.0013287633,
-0.0487180017,
0.0350000411,
-0.0001801467,
0.0205274466,
-0.002702333,
-0.0252886843,
-0.0575024076,
-0.0021363813,
-0.0158506893,
0.0089303898,
0.0898441374,
-0.0031006499,
-0.0372947939,
0.0269560106,
0.0585207492,
-0.0247849617,
0.0260936599,
-0.0462441109,
-0.008232737,
0.022351848,
0.0512589552,
-0.0490792133,
-0.0083065461,
-0.0151538318,
-0.0136513701,
-0.0100458693,
0.0275358763,
0.0027784978,
0.0174527485,
-0.0107332813,
-0.0052761231,
0.0223822333,
0.008831325,
-0.0348922573,
0.0358512774,
0.016160924,
-0.0102552017,
-0.0249298122,
0.0014061033,
0.0487502478,
-0.0533756576,
-0.0293135755,
-0.0011499911,
-0.0105831148,
0.0236040074,
0.0209531765,
-0.0295086708,
0.044478178,
0.0709339008,
-0.0493996106,
-0.0527731031,
-0.0192185324,
-0.024246905,
-0.0405798592,
0.0178086758,
0.0241799206,
-0.0195034668,
0.0102367867,
0.0042333291,
-0.016807802,
0.0153046139,
-0.0130101498,
0.0216422863,
-0.0304783359,
0.0180984065,
0.0121724913,
0.0108337682,
-0.0818516761,
0.0548214465,
0.0001290301,
0.0224545337,
-0.0126997251,
-0.0396641791,
-0.0058400515,
-0.0473390333,
-0.0574869886,
0.0078062029,
-0.0107516283,
0.0058742324,
0.014855192,
-0.0383673571,
-0.0462262928,
-0.0206869096,
-0.0612750649,
0.0264572781,
0.004127996,
0.0149534261,
-0.0048071011,
0.0217961539,
0.0032748708,
-0.0262656324,
-0.0118262526,
-0.0305032544,
0.0369670205,
0.0289203189,
0.0376949161,
0.0483088903,
0.021623712,
-0.0373730808,
-0.0121685658,
-0.0198499598,
0.0671680272,
-0.0047600796,
-0.0484373979,
0.0111015989,
-0.0032298414,
-0.0440210588,
0.0190167315,
0.0093839811,
0.0101767313,
-0.0104797641,
-0.0254298989,
-0.0038410313,
0.0618672855,
0.0008175549,
0.0245582238,
0.0342796594,
0.0271934066,
-0.0262885652,
0.0203008931,
-0.076201193,
-0.0354258008,
-0.0061716549,
0.0188625623,
0.0091225635,
0.034024559,
0.027185984,
-0.0207202267,
-0.0219547637,
-0.002612653,
-0.0183746386,
-0.0022854754,
-0.0509964526,
0.0263913292,
-0.045286838,
0.0200527832,
-0.0189562384,
-0.0491097867,
0.1031986028,
0.0187358912,
0.0067219292,
-0.041316323,
-0.0119417626,
-0.0361533873,
0.0631123111,
-0.0073468518,
0.0297271367,
-0.0102203414,
-0.0139372395,
0.0157079883,
-0.0040361048,
-0.0249258056,
-0.0816739574,
0.0622900948,
-0.0286415629,
0.0406207964,
0.0228311196,
-0.0411603339,
-0.045643542,
-0.0001031358,
-0.0429518148,
0.0095920116,
-0.015335327,
0.0180138294,
-0.0551875792,
0.0145449322,
0.0455180183,
0.033173278,
-0.020966433,
-0.0215197857,
0.0001177636,
0.0028710424,
0.0536026508,
0.0013350499,
0.0453542545,
0.018221736,
0.0180829745,
0.0811917484,
-0.0009815565,
0.0074653313,
0.0125454441,
0.0194736309,
0.0195293166,
-0.0454119854,
0.0264910497,
0.026643429,
0.0171115771,
-0.0596193522,
-0.0267207902,
0.0914745033,
0.0356852561,
-0.046619691,
-0.0044553867,
0.0026125335,
-0.0272963326,
0.0182062276,
0.015626641,
-0.0394697897,
-0.0310633369,
-0.0413765311,
0.0132491393,
-0.0283116009,
-0.0543230996,
0.0199678615,
-0.106160447,
0.023898067,
-0.0165318102,
-0.0399958715,
-0.0508290455,
-0.0697413832,
0.0206883214,
-0.020456152,
0.0155823771,
0.0285300035,
-0.0483892709,
-0.0122482739,
0.0279831588,
-0.0307064187,
-0.1035858244,
0.0189961363,
-0.0520293675,
0.0392667837,
0.0644849762,
0.010502086,
-0.0179570653,
0.0142128635,
0.0235260036,
-0.0304582641,
-0.0058414871,
-0.0206332188,
0.0541188046,
0.0101708863,
-0.0090227658,
-0.0612302423,
0.0084130168,
-0.0329574049,
-0.0154159237,
-0.0440448932,
0.082955882,
-0.019265471,
-0.0128072919,
-0.0443383455,
-0.0117135234,
-0.028532844,
0.0919877589,
-0.0098767476,
-0.0169552378,
-0.0369988307,
0.0424896963,
0.0335357152,
0.0038350455,
-0.0501492508,
0.0310937241,
-0.0227574054,
0.019798385,
-0.0400492474,
-0.0198423248,
0.0108637149,
0.0163089931,
0.0040282663,
0.1037060544,
0.0139802936,
0.0035253817,
-0.0598840229,
0.0580940209,
0.0062711015,
-0.0118742511,
-0.01534387,
-0.0018214959,
0.0771499574,
-0.0249463469,
-0.025291184,
0.0189312417,
-0.0283564683,
-0.0490483977,
-0.0033736513,
0.034867581,
0.0226323996,
0.0077999099,
-0.0050454605,
-0.0531919003,
0.0198251996,
0.0533048771,
-0.0357101485,
-0.0038948571,
-0.0210826434,
0.0298219156,
-0.0090113366,
0.0392852426,
-0.0391033702,
0.0022242235,
0.0154044367,
0.0494764075,
0.01383847,
-0.0277521946,
0.047847908,
0.0437878966,
0.071614109,
0.0105880015,
0.0050816853,
-0.0083059575,
-0.0083313193,
-0.03277722,
-0.0087754726,
-0.0179914329,
-0.0038521788,
0.0477345213,
0.0052793496,
-0.0261073019,
-0.0180346612,
-0.0351777598,
0.0477860123,
-0.0363470986,
0.0048105498,
0.0008159199,
-0.0386630632,
0.04399281,
0.0045112264,
-0.0079026828,
0.0133378198,
-0.0077074966,
0.0182109084,
-0.0196061973,
0.0185920894,
0.0094862301,
-0.0039703161,
-0.0367608108,
0.0182945766,
-0.0848714337,
0.0091245174,
0.0001311879,
0.0261899903,
0.0177418571,
-0.0095069567,
0.0418170616,
0.0005651538,
-0.0279437862,
-0.038946908,
-0.0060840393,
-0.0316733085,
0.0262533594,
0.0793539286,
0.0271118358,
-0.0338926837,
0.0015076511,
0.0407470763,
0.0058085937,
0.0424207225,
-0.0032461681,
-0.058025118,
-0.020080274,
-0.0272525419,
0.0028845624,
-0.0082719801,
-0.0608101971,
0.0170575604,
-0.0677674189,
-0.0420184284,
0.0623515137,
-0.0029799542,
-0.0140934745,
-0.0298502818,
0.0388707407,
0.0748214051,
0.0364102907,
-0.0558522008,
-0.0246721841,
0.03612132,
-0.0243743006,
-0.0125509677,
-0.0074021108,
-6.21608833e-33,
0.010366004,
-0.0340027921,
0.0106430333,
-0.073148638,
-0.0030734313,
0.0239235908,
-0.0280272961,
0.0083855242,
-0.0475445017,
0.0203692764,
-0.0145963803,
-0.0077848043,
-0.0002252082,
0.0376221314,
-0.0114690494,
-0.0431796759,
0.0010659056,
0.0129063325,
0.0105378563,
-0.005025825,
0.0168321263,
0.0850545093,
0.056036476,
-0.0915450677,
0.0177345201,
-0.0079492107,
0.0415991694,
0.042378094,
-0.0215551313,
0.0710498989,
-0.0491437726,
0.0552700683,
0.0309978947,
-0.0130321449,
0.0127274822,
-0.0083844857,
-0.0994608253,
0.0047336989,
0.0141588273,
-0.0263555385,
-0.0098817572,
-0.0007079305,
0.0794402435,
-0.0169431157,
-0.0447903425,
-0.0043560686,
0.018696906,
-0.0167407207,
-0.0407533534,
-0.0280914772,
-0.0244052727,
0.0288058203,
0.0289077666,
0.0128419446,
0.0137735493,
-0.0095835784,
-0.0304278173,
0.0854529142,
-0.0225163382,
-0.0282799527,
-0.0143302949,
0.0111364881,
0.0084933219,
-0.0004457623,
0.0101033906,
0.07939367,
0.0224165414,
0.0092292232,
-0.0244431421,
-0.0396964177,
-0.0211692508,
0.0487387143,
0.0280706529,
0.0464392044,
0.0032957266,
0.0164171066,
-0.1058386937,
-0.0142511167,
-0.0418043733,
0.0521760322,
0.0332296751,
0.0053217397,
-0.0433589108,
0.0126877036,
-0.0275364574,
0.0348072276,
-0.0278275907,
-0.0218127854,
0.0308756512,
0.0029126597,
-0.0112654222,
0.0705673695,
0.0095429858,
-0.0396866947,
-0.0274855699,
0.0317548439,
0.0135497218,
-0.0071320739,
-0.0177478846,
0.0268923156,
-0.0590804182,
0.0019637209,
0.0067688269,
-0.0123788882,
0.0015974074,
-0.0156980753,
-0.0179279484,
-0.0276033171,
-0.0639023408,
-0.0190326832,
-0.0215009581,
0.0012682943,
0.0025790599,
0.019919442,
0.0425059982,
0.048990678,
0.0094049741,
0.067664668,
0.0348791406,
-0.0093043959,
-0.0351099484,
0.0185898077,
0.0134503674,
-0.0150269344,
-0.0059590009,
0.0086992281,
-0.013950075,
0.0676149949,
-0.0041757487,
-0.0609085001,
0.0079774689,
0.0040146322,
2.662e-7,
0.1028219536,
0.0401325859,
0.0221856777,
-0.0147616696,
0.0130468849,
0.0085903537,
-0.0206533112,
0.0222720522,
0.0208175853,
-0.0173341427,
-0.0183362868,
0.0421939529,
0.0085750818,
-0.0100133792,
-0.0544716045,
-0.0162248295,
-0.0851361603,
-0.0448233895,
-0.0282047372,
-0.0279654786,
0.0569292791,
0.0775229856,
-0.0186046865,
-0.0139671275,
-0.0029896551,
-0.0625926405,
0.0493655391,
-0.0302126445,
-0.0216517244,
0.0283672083,
0.0171547253,
0.0211729705,
0.0355605222,
0.0362885147,
0.0051104841,
0.0043288651,
0.0124552976,
0.0784160793,
-0.0377486497,
-0.030495327,
0.0329199471,
0.0073240376,
0.0231284853,
-0.0348132476,
0.0636289418,
-0.0749746189,
-0.049426768,
-0.0083299829,
-0.0053629512,
-0.0149866678,
0.052030839,
-0.0110952612,
-0.0110466033,
0.0215281155,
0.0263368916,
0.0221851096,
-0.0458797626,
-0.1018693596,
-0.0154261403,
0.0412269048,
-0.0493624508,
-0.0365165472,
0.0013097513,
0.0161822587,
-0.0028261552,
-0.0982330516,
0.0025624903,
2.364606069e-34,
0.022613259,
0.0202492848,
-0.0103736641,
0.0313533805,
0.044670213,
-0.0058624079,
-0.0003071087,
0.0318893865,
-0.0227625147,
-0.0927748159,
0.0296980701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08142v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08142v1
|
Discursive objection strategies in online comments: Developing a classification schema and validating its training
| 2024-05-13T19:39:00 | 2024-05-13T19:39:00 |
Ashley L. Shea, Aspen K. B. Omapang, Ji Yong Cho, Miryam Y. Ginsparg, Natalie Bazarova, Winice Hui, René F. Kizilcec, Chau Tong, Drew Margolin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, I.2.7, J.4
|
Most Americans agree that misinformation, hate speech and harassment are
harmful and inadequately curbed on social media through current moderation
practices. In this paper, we aim to understand the discursive strategies
employed by people in response to harmful speech in news comments. We conducted
a content analysis of more than 6500 comment replies to trending news videos on
YouTube and Twitter and identified seven distinct discursive objection
strategies (Study 1). We examined the frequency of each strategy's occurrence
from the 6500 comment replies, as well as from a second sample of 2004 replies
(Study 2). Together, these studies show that people deploy a diversity of
discursive strategies when objecting to speech, and reputational attacks are
the most common. The resulting classification scheme accounts for different
theoretical approaches for expressing objections and offers a comprehensive
perspective on grassroots efforts aimed at stopping offensive or problematic
speech on campus.
|
[
0.1164902449,
0.0366345234,
0.0005920784,
0.010296707,
0.0105311517,
0.0211384837,
0.0273363721,
-0.0061585191,
-0.0090658031,
-0.0855807066,
0.030401675,
-0.014804462,
-0.0071497718,
-0.0695536584,
0.0275113657,
-0.0455520451,
-0.0081327725,
0.0458991453,
0.065105103,
-0.0176260024,
0.084491767,
0.0001863165,
-0.0379983112,
0.0187341198,
-0.0391516201,
-0.0139692863,
0.0626773536,
-0.0171822868,
0.0459749252,
-0.0333272927,
0.0288363658,
0.0248094518,
0.0466229729,
0.0262226816,
0.0000014915,
-0.0689708441,
0.0365813635,
-0.0094316574,
0.0348701552,
0.005760977,
0.0381730832,
-0.0296772216,
0.0114308475,
0.0370916165,
-0.0068043326,
-0.0140788956,
0.0248500481,
0.0387423299,
0.04998409,
0.0622084588,
0.0037323297,
-0.0742901266,
-0.0511797369,
0.0297492985,
-0.0557044521,
0.0310607068,
0.0128225349,
-0.0318012089,
-0.0548993424,
-0.0218453333,
0.031261228,
-0.0148873962,
-0.0139304157,
-0.0011889959,
-0.0075473874,
-0.0276276693,
0.0195357297,
-0.0345143527,
0.0398114771,
-0.0018859614,
0.0350465924,
-0.0072769546,
0.003251882,
0.0182017274,
0.0068021761,
0.0395305343,
-0.056141492,
0.0464930795,
-0.0462630093,
0.0043964763,
-0.0259484388,
0.0059151342,
0.0188763961,
0.0844540298,
0.0726237968,
-0.0261376947,
-0.0366195329,
-0.0257287603,
-0.016437348,
-0.0219699107,
-0.0080545871,
0.0043397006,
-0.0042351885,
0.0202366523,
0.0047334922,
0.0101277018,
0.0080882506,
-0.0549527779,
0.049930729,
-0.0560174882,
0.0154816974,
0.037828479,
0.0232015718,
-0.0245533865,
0.0081946682,
0.0069017876,
-0.0283956937,
-0.007392358,
0.076049,
0.0358090959,
-0.0646227375,
0.0353636816,
0.0140233319,
-0.0122495526,
0.009825415,
0.0298944395,
0.0110948365,
-0.0303739421,
-0.0544259809,
-0.0321854353,
-0.0293523706,
0.0012920976,
0.023821108,
0.0150912441,
-0.0388232321,
0.0402186327,
-0.0579508953,
0.0283756536,
-0.0545246564,
-0.0478775837,
0.0028395315,
0.0198139623,
-0.0178466272,
0.0011953794,
-0.0070289732,
0.0650437027,
-0.0017052725,
0.0034768651,
-0.0243067052,
-0.0423144363,
-0.0245695952,
-0.0191828739,
0.0326543003,
-0.0434455909,
-0.0007532586,
-0.0020984334,
-0.0610016398,
-0.026124116,
0.0377254933,
0.0112428647,
-0.010050457,
0.028916914,
0.031066576,
0.008640443,
0.0981022418,
0.0537193306,
-0.0293951984,
-0.0058767875,
0.0016011216,
0.0125882672,
0.0073102992,
0.0042066691,
-0.0051757917,
0.0120186089,
0.0146432826,
0.0057585174,
-0.0273196548,
0.0330633037,
-0.069769837,
-0.0340029858,
-0.01045602,
0.0253569447,
-0.0235138014,
-0.0501497574,
0.0393703468,
0.0566729307,
-0.0917996168,
0.0160196777,
-0.0020886762,
0.0410651155,
0.0104026441,
-0.0606511161,
0.0156073663,
-0.0425507016,
-0.0149121946,
-0.0434045233,
0.019951161,
0.0414781235,
-0.0268615317,
-0.0102921268,
-0.0354552083,
0.0242714509,
0.0891291872,
-0.0359344408,
0.0070725069,
0.0251905322,
0.0094027985,
-0.0108931111,
0.0313812904,
-0.0089103961,
-0.0015382443,
-0.0677656606,
0.0451913625,
0.0295688305,
-0.0218260847,
0.0155968983,
0.0319968425,
-0.0619461127,
0.0921651274,
0.0891749188,
0.03605479,
-0.0276852511,
-0.0405486561,
0.0061423779,
-0.0345783122,
-0.01915011,
0.0100086108,
0.0229730979,
0.0553352274,
0.0230403747,
-0.0137540977,
0.0758046284,
-0.0119385496,
0.0138155594,
0.0823462605,
-0.0187973529,
-0.0331573784,
0.021736091,
0.0355950966,
0.0161059257,
-0.0101618832,
-0.0297895595,
0.020862272,
0.0115548298,
-0.0185188483,
-0.0180636607,
0.0108097745,
0.0654549748,
0.0128869396,
-0.047870934,
-0.0211443566,
0.0156440698,
0.0140104638,
0.0680708736,
0.0989116207,
-0.0315930247,
0.000849175,
-0.0119691025,
-0.057974156,
-0.0881104916,
-0.0064976411,
-0.0251429658,
0.0455011241,
-0.0341725014,
-0.0106800888,
0.0425476842,
-0.073474206,
0.0254334118,
0.0395768769,
-0.0519571267,
-0.0199556556,
-0.0305579491,
0.035160847,
0.0207720641,
-0.0371297933,
-0.0163869746,
-0.0004191954,
-0.0140701104,
-0.0347138755,
-0.0341662131,
0.033683449,
0.0444897451,
-0.032341104,
-0.0103347301,
0.0171979982,
0.0386039503,
-0.0527585484,
0.0091587957,
0.0456187762,
-0.0024820366,
-0.0289868079,
-0.0227121636,
0.0009935639,
0.0080781849,
-0.0231606364,
-0.0078837657,
-0.0094422922,
-0.1072018072,
0.0268367156,
-0.0108284615,
-0.0330335088,
0.0131535903,
-0.0254288372,
-0.0393951572,
0.066854246,
0.0413552895,
-0.0233194716,
0.0238235164,
0.0920462385,
0.111064367,
0.0133335451,
0.0323606469,
0.0034623474,
-0.0146140642,
-0.0131561495,
-0.0224353652,
-0.0330077149,
-0.0318184458,
-0.0102793481,
0.0399760455,
0.0376308262,
0.0246449485,
-0.0382848121,
0.0510433987,
-0.0793001801,
-0.0146308113,
-0.0252977051,
-0.0772001222,
-0.008451323,
-0.0083918953,
-0.0194785669,
-0.0082847234,
0.0014064697,
0.016371429,
0.0317948647,
-0.0101903323,
-0.0431562103,
0.0397597142,
0.0488857292,
0.0044600135,
0.0250231959,
-0.0253550559,
-0.0397430845,
0.0293700807,
-0.0444890484,
0.0826597363,
-0.0138872284,
-0.0009557489,
-0.0118158618,
0.0383129902,
0.0032514837,
-0.0130755017,
-0.0241960622,
-0.0612320788,
-0.033123415,
-0.0543794371,
-0.02445825,
0.0032939911,
-0.0209000073,
0.0408523865,
0.0354751125,
-0.030785758,
0.0179585889,
-0.0125698335,
0.0578954592,
-0.0670534372,
-0.0191633608,
0.0559976064,
0.0403167158,
0.0150805023,
-0.0229612328,
0.0643945113,
-0.0011464061,
-0.0210638978,
0.0097560314,
-0.0338330716,
0.004029694,
0.0249009356,
0.0186719298,
0.0035559146,
0.0399168581,
-0.0016704424,
0.0080266427,
0.0426189341,
0.0189743023,
0.0329898074,
-0.0407991782,
-0.0101990299,
0.0039794119,
0.0315480195,
-0.0329643264,
-0.0860196725,
0.0022293928,
-0.0343433805,
0.0118223391,
-0.0692839548,
-0.021156529,
-0.0188710708,
-0.0377872363,
0.0131989345,
-0.0371629931,
-0.0171221532,
-0.0136672202,
0.0067695831,
0.0206546783,
0.0324515589,
0.0200197324,
-0.0231963266,
0.0317523256,
-0.0127055142,
0.0319751352,
-0.0651972741,
-0.000011254,
-0.0142928576,
0.0094130328,
0.0077289967,
-0.0170349628,
0.0323828384,
-0.0118910549,
-0.0259716269,
0.0460241064,
-0.0247757025,
-0.037007641,
-0.0399248675,
-0.0099848285,
-0.000119732,
0.0100896936,
0.0066882907,
0.0240695886,
0.0092621781,
-0.0191352181,
0.0143960277,
0.0453767329,
0.0414097123,
-0.0202694293,
-0.0718494952,
0.0351181775,
0.0302157421,
0.0200609658,
0.0232134871,
-0.0212928187,
0.0273031853,
-0.0487863272,
-0.0154708615,
-0.0063819839,
-0.0412784368,
-0.0110025145,
0.0168254934,
-0.030827539,
0.0026169731,
-0.0333833694,
-0.0098965978,
-0.0170594566,
0.0262563284,
-0.0167181753,
-0.0036594209,
-0.0022886256,
-0.0354594067,
-0.0211061575,
0.0255712215,
0.0081797978,
-0.0106784794,
-0.025347352,
-0.0270599145,
0.0212533921,
-0.0515837781,
-0.0047238749,
0.0008801908,
-0.0400651619,
0.0519304872,
0.0358493701,
0.0210579541,
-0.0097946431,
0.0247831922,
-0.0412721485,
0.0279516857,
0.0337821394,
0.0020227842,
0.0156800784,
0.034915071,
-0.0018388511,
0.0193640534,
-0.0161145963,
0.0390631929,
0.049489364,
0.0289067458,
-0.0209076945,
-0.0746780261,
-0.0006904135,
-0.021642819,
-0.0601422526,
0.0348450392,
0.0212057121,
-0.0558213033,
-0.0112816524,
-0.0498730056,
0.0002886255,
-0.0317916907,
0.0029149454,
-0.0001845913,
-0.0084031103,
-0.0135536399,
-0.0265269522,
-0.0165487602,
-0.04707551,
0.043549072,
-0.0313083567,
0.0477248393,
0.0380683355,
0.0424847305,
-0.0350898579,
-0.0010030208,
-0.0056121615,
0.0412728228,
0.0361250937,
-0.0246595275,
0.0065859393,
0.0378076062,
0.0085854912,
0.0232204217,
0.0586815402,
-0.0480657667,
-0.0057235635,
-0.0455965362,
-0.0096774492,
-0.0043549449,
-0.0637385622,
-0.0222852882,
0.0497891754,
0.042888388,
-0.0183305256,
0.0137881106,
0.0039219982,
-0.0439028032,
-0.0660164952,
0.0566467531,
0.0349196568,
-0.0332800373,
0.0081695458,
0.0110002058,
-0.0420060977,
0.0272741131,
0.0467178784,
-0.0595648997,
-0.0209465586,
-0.0501790233,
0.0077995285,
0.0471532792,
0.0595712848,
0.0338544287,
-0.0497796163,
0.013350796,
-0.0188066904,
-0.0534891188,
0.036643073,
-0.0235694144,
-0.0387020372,
0.0315071531,
0.03726127,
0.0217108,
0.0191114359,
0.01237386,
-0.0251404643,
-0.0816370547,
-0.018410081,
-4.878692775e-33,
0.0021903347,
-0.0537705645,
-0.015192043,
0.0095373411,
-0.0021567382,
-0.0207142178,
0.0247861333,
0.0211735498,
-0.0176255219,
0.0291150827,
0.0165693946,
0.0088007469,
-0.0026334927,
0.0048677884,
-0.0176848266,
-0.0722367093,
0.0207931511,
-0.0633794889,
-0.0270354915,
-0.0058211568,
0.0401318893,
-0.0244472679,
-0.0285071619,
-0.0872647092,
0.0283700172,
-0.0203291811,
-0.031064434,
0.0115276119,
0.0554633401,
0.0440661572,
-0.0262490436,
0.0412587225,
0.0402043872,
-0.0145914005,
0.0201884564,
0.0997143164,
-0.0221898314,
-0.0118119661,
0.0495574102,
-0.0253542811,
0.0131373173,
0.0250564292,
0.0004657102,
0.0202138592,
-0.0376686081,
-0.0182117149,
0.0309478417,
0.0066585434,
0.0432549603,
-0.0294851977,
-0.0863627642,
0.0015595159,
-0.043643713,
0.0268009603,
-0.015745258,
0.0296684373,
0.0004477757,
0.0183174517,
-0.0733926669,
0.0226515867,
-0.0243063904,
-0.0130016161,
-0.0047879624,
-0.0320725888,
0.0303425454,
0.0557708889,
0.0029645711,
0.0528851859,
-0.0351710841,
0.0300871506,
-0.0123601835,
-0.0009990231,
0.0040472224,
0.0912071615,
0.0188654214,
-0.1383347064,
-0.0608476438,
-0.038342949,
0.0541790202,
0.0011301903,
0.0217488781,
-0.0431377664,
-0.028301781,
-0.0290386528,
-0.0055217571,
-0.0583414212,
-0.022246331,
-0.006902949,
0.0089650163,
0.0056257527,
-0.0235000495,
-0.0355841555,
0.0367510505,
0.0063492516,
-0.0243515354,
0.0388730206,
-0.0105811618,
0.0133126872,
0.0559477769,
0.0323382355,
-0.0463007316,
-0.0065335464,
-0.0142685222,
-0.0585541762,
0.0405209474,
-0.0029276321,
0.0715163499,
0.037012618,
-0.0483726859,
0.0070803608,
0.0118725002,
0.072901167,
-0.0501136407,
0.0330973864,
0.0048475545,
0.0717918649,
0.0061902856,
-0.0284620896,
0.0394324735,
-0.0329006761,
-0.0071301637,
-0.0031614485,
-0.0519563742,
-0.0117154447,
-0.0279178116,
-0.0090273703,
0.0124668488,
0.0290840399,
0.0205192398,
-0.1149977073,
0.0034193778,
-0.0413062461,
2.294e-7,
0.0098279556,
0.0386312455,
-0.0275314208,
-0.0023899623,
0.0611833893,
0.0228023492,
0.0517949797,
0.0319791809,
0.0429195464,
-0.0745566934,
-0.012986592,
0.0155228106,
-0.0353888832,
0.0370082036,
-0.0227452163,
-0.0693276525,
-0.0698020831,
0.0310901459,
-0.0132084992,
0.0358546861,
0.0012590175,
0.0055489889,
0.0218458455,
-0.0070040496,
-0.0760346726,
0.0104429414,
0.0307180062,
-0.0111718839,
0.0053179176,
-0.0514589101,
0.0506134443,
0.0008791208,
0.0313271992,
0.0362889618,
0.0183304586,
0.0388585627,
0.0012873509,
0.025564611,
0.0332283713,
-0.0084543079,
0.0016734673,
0.0140998904,
0.0227543917,
0.0115679353,
-0.018790625,
-0.0252165012,
-0.0226620305,
-0.040371161,
-0.0262793377,
-0.0252052695,
0.0208067335,
-0.0100676054,
-0.0412026495,
-0.0209328812,
0.0272481516,
0.0122042401,
0.0439708382,
-0.0455990136,
0.0244199485,
-0.0420416258,
-0.032992132,
-0.0297331903,
0.0082606068,
-0.0299589876,
0.0357544497,
0.0701002702,
0.0424077921,
1.57084708e-34,
0.0047599864,
-0.005818693,
0.0213569179,
-0.0538768284,
0.0467136689,
0.0444304608,
0.0060743946,
-0.0160412155,
0.0390091017,
0.0128902709,
-0.0448552407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13011v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13011v1
|
Unveiling Social Media Comments with a Novel Named Entity Recognition System for Identity Groups
| 2024-05-13T19:33:18 | 2024-05-13T19:33:18 |
Andrés Carvallo, Tamara Quiroga, Carlos Aspillaga, Marcelo Mendoza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
While civilized users employ social media to stay informed and discuss daily
occurrences, haters perceive these platforms as fertile ground for attacking
groups and individuals. The prevailing approach to counter this phenomenon
involves detecting such attacks by identifying toxic language. Effective
platform measures aim to report haters and block their network access. In this
context, employing hate speech detection methods aids in identifying these
attacks amidst vast volumes of text, which are impossible for humans to analyze
manually. In our study, we expand upon the usual hate speech detection methods,
typically based on text classifiers, to develop a Named Entity Recognition
(NER) System for Identity Groups. To achieve this, we created a dataset that
allows extending a conventional NER to recognize identity groups. Consequently,
our tool not only detects whether a sentence contains an attack but also tags
the sentence tokens corresponding to the mentioned group. Results indicate that
the model performs competitively in identifying groups with an average f1-score
of 0.75, outperforming in identifying ethnicity attack spans with an f1-score
of 0.80 compared to other identity groups. Moreover, the tool shows an
outstanding generalization capability to minority classes concerning sexual
orientation and gender, achieving an f1-score of 0.77 and 0.72, respectively.
We tested the utility of our tool in a case study on social media, annotating
and comparing comments from Facebook related to news mentioning identity
groups. The case study reveals differences in the types of attacks recorded,
effectively detecting named entities related to the categories of the analyzed
news articles. Entities are accurately tagged within their categories, with a
negligible error rate for inter-category tagging.
|
[
0.0786774084,
0.0746245757,
-0.0080275312,
0.0089571187,
-0.0011441747,
0.0617740564,
0.0469802208,
0.0180810224,
0.0119613418,
-0.0899709836,
0.033215791,
-0.0260972679,
-0.0047934949,
0.0020396924,
0.0130712641,
-0.01308221,
0.0369317718,
0.0468829088,
0.0524376296,
-0.0167263821,
0.0579200573,
0.02673571,
-0.0063202493,
0.0569556132,
-0.0418566242,
0.024165839,
0.0458453707,
-0.0084127244,
0.0391519256,
-0.0194914546,
0.0548015609,
0.0563258119,
-0.0194164366,
0.0769493133,
0.0000017011,
-0.0679593533,
-0.0071527781,
0.0019272689,
-0.0098626604,
-0.0598034188,
0.0584996566,
-0.030113034,
-0.014758735,
0.0127212061,
-0.0186818484,
-0.0140053043,
0.040389847,
0.0487903804,
0.061142996,
0.0636788458,
-0.0142623875,
-0.0752879307,
-0.0192737672,
0.0293850005,
0.01723985,
0.0224028621,
0.0438668691,
-0.0642564148,
-0.0449357256,
-0.0234698858,
0.048357062,
0.0052766544,
0.0100713372,
0.023422448,
0.0478665084,
-0.0032717166,
-0.0368277021,
-0.0347131789,
0.0062313043,
0.0366414115,
-0.0214465782,
0.0016255885,
0.0196906012,
0.0085384957,
-0.0202031061,
-0.0195942316,
-0.0101198126,
0.0195273645,
-0.0615725107,
-0.0014757034,
0.0035691797,
0.0158258025,
0.0365350507,
0.0647085011,
0.0279718377,
0.0301055927,
-0.0051050619,
-0.0200244393,
-0.0037783775,
-0.0134427836,
-0.0199175868,
-0.006097964,
0.0277890004,
0.0133519126,
0.0109718191,
0.032836698,
-0.0769101903,
-0.0559137762,
0.0199975129,
-0.0904356763,
0.0075642043,
0.0147277648,
0.0024550103,
-0.0121457428,
0.0064309002,
0.0259773526,
0.0224333033,
-0.0028451453,
0.0476409756,
-0.0124405073,
-0.0406730995,
0.0042264876,
-0.0111849634,
0.0347060114,
-0.0085277576,
0.0422957465,
-0.0575339831,
-0.0092979288,
-0.0602650978,
-0.0144019416,
-0.0257003363,
0.003490211,
0.0227675512,
0.0098021021,
-0.0183156747,
-0.0173362046,
-0.0316558927,
0.0090148002,
-0.046298746,
-0.0651505813,
0.0411824845,
0.0022918626,
-0.0029119744,
-0.0073823435,
0.0178929456,
0.0593284667,
0.0365326256,
-0.0570076928,
-0.0632803366,
-0.038435109,
-0.0011152291,
-0.0052178917,
0.0163795985,
-0.064239122,
0.0446154214,
-0.0042429799,
-0.0334016755,
-0.0642756,
0.0025686722,
0.0092626316,
-0.0530026294,
0.0808618665,
-0.0073940051,
-0.0028449947,
0.0856256932,
0.030639695,
0.0422694795,
0.0394587405,
0.0223397966,
0.0050431625,
0.0672425702,
-0.0094148749,
0.0098257316,
0.0427540019,
0.0237744115,
-0.0121614309,
0.0008601647,
0.0148262959,
-0.0455236696,
-0.0640507713,
-0.0207772441,
0.038076777,
0.0319308974,
-0.0743366331,
0.039886687,
0.0780945048,
-0.0617181771,
0.0357604213,
0.023627935,
0.0286390875,
-0.0094400682,
-0.053764917,
-0.0592010431,
-0.0523345359,
-0.0435778126,
-0.0679596886,
0.0368548967,
0.0461908206,
-0.0173409302,
-0.0188802481,
-0.0309868325,
0.014182874,
0.0714008361,
-0.0226513613,
0.0160663035,
0.0179503486,
-0.006961613,
0.0478461795,
0.0558472984,
-0.0114074973,
0.0261983015,
-0.0487315021,
0.0312913731,
0.0520660654,
-0.001496502,
-0.0161750894,
0.0055342778,
-0.0658780411,
0.0016333297,
0.0475339033,
0.0113675809,
-0.0127599249,
-0.0126130776,
-0.0069815898,
-0.0014843977,
0.0504179038,
0.0028646232,
0.0372432433,
0.0882885531,
0.0370701477,
0.0160801616,
0.0546246618,
-0.0414652266,
0.0347835496,
0.036417149,
-0.0343080722,
-0.002271584,
0.0197084956,
0.0392856374,
0.0503514558,
-0.013357454,
-0.0497684479,
-0.0132329306,
0.0015653549,
-0.062125396,
-0.0361415111,
-0.0065972842,
0.0251474716,
0.0267060064,
-0.020066455,
-0.0310997162,
0.0493141599,
-0.011650186,
0.0186613947,
0.0860939696,
-0.0303737018,
-0.0344493724,
0.0097653568,
-0.0414093174,
-0.0550642796,
0.0194807779,
-0.0259358864,
0.0772053972,
-0.0261773989,
0.0246744156,
-0.0262971651,
-0.0668221712,
0.0130795566,
0.011340674,
-0.0481923409,
-0.0262457207,
-0.0447891466,
0.0134922061,
0.0086955559,
-0.0342842266,
-0.0125075513,
0.0314741991,
-0.081609115,
0.0085897492,
-0.0182803161,
0.0162533633,
0.0213578567,
0.0121511715,
-0.0365100317,
0.0226180758,
0.0086044874,
-0.0498454385,
0.0341837928,
0.0188930351,
-0.0110632656,
-0.048279833,
-0.0287489593,
0.0049243602,
-0.0164559204,
-0.033874888,
0.0255591199,
0.0528909825,
-0.0861450583,
0.0263093077,
-0.0349654853,
-0.0486532971,
0.0015272592,
-0.0004525064,
-0.0299319942,
0.0375623479,
0.0381839834,
-0.0100045586,
0.0237847306,
0.0811957642,
0.0758226588,
-0.0175005868,
0.0071308212,
0.0019958606,
-0.0111288466,
-0.0296683852,
0.0426469669,
-0.0199184604,
-0.0577561557,
0.0242566112,
0.0877091959,
0.0570221879,
-0.0130501017,
-0.05562694,
0.0307637956,
-0.0799219906,
-0.0249225497,
-0.0255006887,
-0.0483081564,
0.0052077249,
-0.0528270938,
-0.0425419956,
-0.0281784404,
0.0667763874,
0.0082145296,
0.0226462446,
-0.0092929741,
-0.0426334329,
0.0058446033,
0.0236848406,
0.0093597108,
0.0248425677,
0.0120423986,
-0.0505408011,
0.0535070784,
-0.0049070073,
0.0215231832,
-0.0179807376,
0.0114099057,
-0.0009283207,
0.0210080985,
0.0139313769,
-0.0136909522,
-0.0741240606,
-0.0458393171,
-0.0669561625,
-0.027281519,
0.0107909534,
-0.0118683148,
0.0001345049,
0.0259895287,
0.0227225758,
-0.0246427525,
-0.0061168373,
0.0024595549,
0.0360236466,
-0.0067406693,
-0.0327027328,
-0.0434349552,
0.0205275156,
0.0053751073,
-0.0276589002,
0.0550053418,
-0.0088970046,
0.0103260875,
-0.0163560379,
-0.0030786055,
-0.0031607347,
-0.0257037319,
0.0109494384,
-0.0543575883,
0.031351503,
-0.0028918183,
0.0267299563,
0.093986243,
0.0334212817,
-0.0102418726,
-0.0076817069,
0.0197576061,
-0.0030079735,
0.0260439217,
-0.0188128911,
-0.0819874257,
-0.0004150329,
-0.0089389011,
0.0497926176,
-0.0812983215,
-0.0655873045,
0.0167594627,
-0.0396802686,
-0.004002539,
-0.0302775484,
-0.0472458228,
-0.0067614662,
-0.018367704,
0.0391588658,
-0.0106710214,
0.0045653014,
-0.0441056788,
0.0183955114,
0.0235034693,
0.005697594,
-0.0725592822,
-0.0088201389,
-0.0071288678,
-0.0284942966,
0.0448589437,
0.0160162337,
0.0387203693,
-0.0134679945,
-0.0129124075,
0.0696426183,
-0.0223856866,
-0.0255790409,
-0.0688077956,
0.0581245534,
-0.017417524,
-0.0293222331,
-0.024382785,
0.0475774072,
0.0094433492,
-0.0208727401,
0.0252920594,
-0.0094775045,
0.0243229456,
-0.0008603125,
-0.0403454863,
0.0071606706,
0.0134794377,
0.0692288801,
0.0249739904,
-0.0395036712,
0.0158452801,
-0.0765202567,
-0.0039136345,
-0.0445276313,
-0.0780468136,
0.0216661282,
-0.0262951348,
-0.0636315122,
-0.0164738372,
-0.0295858104,
0.0264861099,
0.0023606536,
0.0069912733,
-0.0362458378,
0.0156284552,
0.0088122226,
-0.065922901,
-0.0013238144,
-0.0062505701,
0.0544917993,
-0.02094955,
-0.0200880691,
-0.0290809963,
0.0276453085,
-0.0516700968,
0.0329447463,
-0.0388882421,
-0.0598773845,
0.0669662952,
0.0145449983,
0.0102009429,
-0.0014748056,
-0.0079614175,
-0.0779205859,
0.0506594405,
0.0525143482,
-0.0038536119,
-0.0089974245,
0.0137380287,
0.010626764,
0.0142954495,
0.0126694832,
0.0133611849,
0.0442865863,
0.0342920087,
-0.0501741022,
-0.0710875988,
0.013069639,
-0.0511409603,
0.0017801309,
0.0132077066,
-0.0007164939,
-0.0433876775,
-0.0122706415,
-0.0429611616,
0.0048430222,
-0.0363509357,
0.0242086202,
-0.0226919465,
-0.0179569535,
-0.0039842352,
-0.0385771878,
0.0130289914,
-0.0378592648,
0.0250215288,
-0.0626590773,
0.0315366015,
0.0426738933,
0.0696900859,
0.0195057038,
-0.0057509765,
0.0104686758,
0.0112563511,
0.0076656691,
-0.0083789518,
-0.0020561791,
0.0075001409,
-0.0032005361,
0.0058047357,
0.0121804178,
-0.0445095822,
0.0253793355,
0.0154392598,
-0.0205260515,
-0.0024392037,
-0.027326975,
0.0132120261,
0.0187849049,
0.0407928973,
-0.0255908594,
0.0065838434,
-0.0013765835,
-0.0324308947,
-0.0628890172,
-0.0024347953,
0.0297877286,
-0.0257413257,
0.0007775545,
0.0107169542,
0.0219148044,
0.0167144667,
0.0393083505,
-0.0609663315,
-0.0369848236,
0.0198893156,
0.0201094877,
0.0118377237,
0.0156999845,
0.0218950454,
-0.032353282,
-0.0292851627,
0.0263797473,
-0.0604091585,
0.0438178927,
0.0423728153,
0.0142142521,
0.0416926779,
0.0087601123,
-0.0160020143,
-0.0141391614,
-0.0013953062,
-0.0298528019,
-0.070187673,
0.0083446074,
-5.338108661e-33,
-0.0177284777,
-0.0421789736,
-0.0209892988,
-0.0111503955,
0.0122198053,
-0.0151699875,
0.0249461308,
0.0030196789,
0.0273247026,
-0.0033499964,
0.0210089739,
0.0251826812,
0.0035335755,
0.0121434936,
-0.0393676981,
-0.0258113872,
0.0384001881,
-0.0140917534,
-0.0051736766,
0.012897349,
0.0430138148,
0.0230304804,
0.0208715796,
-0.0842223912,
0.0552840792,
0.003702889,
-0.0018696281,
-0.0080297561,
0.058720842,
0.0614314675,
-0.0232147444,
0.0577379577,
0.0299034547,
-0.0218325462,
0.0238329843,
0.0886434317,
-0.0845246762,
0.0080219097,
-0.0090086181,
0.0164648723,
0.0502192415,
-0.015487819,
0.0326646604,
0.0124197677,
-0.0306528229,
-0.0170497224,
0.0427889563,
-0.012409959,
0.0459425785,
-0.0440572053,
-0.0703316182,
0.0358562246,
-0.0180067066,
0.0537095368,
-0.0140055139,
0.0128712403,
0.0500199944,
-0.0137534989,
-0.0645266771,
0.0108873583,
-0.0300574433,
-0.0436801314,
-0.0137619274,
0.0225260369,
-0.0063146567,
0.0333157517,
0.0121819703,
0.0171658173,
-0.0472771898,
0.0490028448,
0.0210385788,
0.0039074165,
0.0359433182,
0.0554525815,
-0.0019664802,
-0.0834115967,
-0.0479910187,
0.0035112943,
0.0547078773,
-0.0429550558,
0.0205393732,
-0.0418939292,
-0.0701431334,
-0.0107349548,
0.0057451506,
-0.0787679255,
-0.0252029411,
-0.0150378859,
0.0029608631,
-0.0070858281,
-0.0918954015,
0.0204776246,
0.0076947785,
-0.0164175369,
-0.0275322925,
0.0438887179,
0.0026473075,
0.0034831734,
0.0275331493,
0.0113678323,
-0.053510502,
0.0008821895,
0.0184080992,
-0.0293239187,
0.0518659279,
-0.0340641215,
0.0423124991,
0.0231340621,
-0.0729432702,
0.0135249663,
0.0187248215,
0.0844164863,
-0.0281381402,
0.0601001494,
0.0214686133,
0.0453659222,
-0.0116667887,
-0.0264570769,
0.0301192235,
-0.0145736411,
-0.006975214,
0.0223950464,
-0.0569780432,
0.0129412729,
-0.0157129522,
-0.022317851,
0.0053397468,
0.0166516043,
0.0144021166,
-0.0749422386,
0.0213631224,
-0.0712093562,
2.405e-7,
-0.0108026536,
0.0203647353,
0.0010239251,
-0.0110540632,
0.0359712504,
0.0290680919,
0.0977007002,
0.0395257361,
0.0014791456,
-0.0220446475,
-0.0378128961,
0.0478544161,
-0.0070827203,
0.0563640632,
-0.0296995677,
-0.0415151902,
-0.0082455445,
0.023777809,
-0.0625052974,
0.0351410992,
-0.0051281112,
0.0538826138,
0.084495157,
-0.0375006124,
-0.0536045805,
-0.0281873923,
-0.0110072372,
0.0025925697,
-0.0034706153,
-0.006839999,
0.0553000681,
0.0422123186,
0.0189831797,
0.0223752409,
-0.0127077634,
0.0163320377,
-0.0136921834,
0.0054207677,
0.0195081346,
0.0280182231,
-0.0071558375,
-0.0154551473,
-0.0014273737,
-0.0325082429,
0.0517239422,
-0.000605303,
-0.0207909551,
-0.0465356074,
-0.0274311416,
-0.0269153081,
0.0017587114,
-0.0039316858,
-0.0186452325,
0.0217790697,
0.0215272084,
-0.038689319,
0.0102077797,
-0.0944217816,
0.0389851779,
0.0058014109,
-0.0268674623,
0.0091988472,
-0.0067925085,
-0.0071626939,
0.0208882745,
0.0423618034,
0.0351097696,
1.773764726e-34,
-0.0213421285,
0.0082921572,
-0.0425571278,
-0.0152396886,
0.0207519997,
0.0343578868,
-0.0381499827,
-0.0045249267,
0.0336710252,
0.0012045283,
-0.0027469536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08134v1
|
Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) Prompting
| 2024-05-13T19:22:40 | 2024-05-13T19:22:40 |
Shashank Sonkar, Richard G. Baraniuk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Many-Shot Regurgitation (MSR) prompting, a new black-box
membership inference attack framework for examining verbatim content
reproduction in large language models (LLMs). MSR prompting involves dividing
the input text into multiple segments and creating a single prompt that
includes a series of faux conversation rounds between a user and a language
model to elicit verbatim regurgitation. We apply MSR prompting to diverse text
sources, including Wikipedia articles and open educational resources (OER)
textbooks, which provide high-quality, factual content and are continuously
updated over time. For each source, we curate two dataset types: one that LLMs
were likely exposed to during training ($D_{\rm pre}$) and another consisting
of documents published after the models' training cutoff dates ($D_{\rm
post}$). To quantify the occurrence of verbatim matches, we employ the Longest
Common Substring algorithm and count the frequency of matches at different
length thresholds. We then use statistical measures such as Cliff's delta,
Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) distance, and Kruskal-Wallis H test to determine
whether the distribution of verbatim matches differs significantly between
$D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$. Our findings reveal a striking difference in
the distribution of verbatim matches between $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm post}$,
with the frequency of verbatim reproduction being significantly higher when
LLMs (e.g. GPT models and LLaMAs) are prompted with text from datasets they
were likely trained on. For instance, when using GPT-3.5 on Wikipedia articles,
we observe a substantial effect size (Cliff's delta $= -0.984$) and a large KS
distance ($0.875$) between the distributions of $D_{\rm pre}$ and $D_{\rm
post}$. Our results provide compelling evidence that LLMs are more prone to
reproducing verbatim content when the input text is likely sourced from their
training data.
|
[
0.063134782,
0.0450823605,
-0.0308914594,
0.0629437044,
-0.0828974396,
0.0262484103,
-0.0096228011,
0.0496994592,
0.0163414273,
-0.0399232619,
0.0049712304,
-0.0214733556,
0.0138454698,
0.0038887511,
0.0332210846,
-0.0017742668,
0.0286912639,
-0.0044475365,
-0.0025385926,
-0.0211955626,
0.0476732142,
-0.0003007982,
0.0377271064,
0.026127791,
0.0313977487,
0.0066374438,
-0.0004545491,
-0.0069593457,
0.0084630447,
-0.0120623745,
-0.0038386856,
0.040568836,
0.0178530123,
0.067888245,
0.0000020085,
-0.0614263229,
-0.0325487107,
0.0058736834,
-0.0499281324,
0.0433070809,
0.0336071439,
0.0329621285,
0.010588902,
0.010704834,
-0.0298130196,
0.0571562648,
0.0282267407,
0.0223559495,
0.04502647,
0.1131303832,
-0.0132852923,
0.0253311209,
0.0417287424,
-0.0266420599,
0.0349889621,
0.0332075246,
0.0402608737,
0.0072391657,
0.0285366215,
0.0394923538,
-0.008460843,
0.035495162,
-0.0002505364,
-0.0157722812,
-0.0082069635,
0.0080018546,
-0.0225581769,
0.0038434027,
0.0248988532,
0.0449091494,
-0.0071352515,
-0.0176138487,
0.0496876091,
0.0099721039,
0.0103200907,
0.0481665023,
-0.043853309,
0.0219260696,
-0.0002214839,
-0.0015895937,
-0.0162664447,
-0.0352178663,
0.0410480909,
0.0022734641,
0.0299217086,
0.0026308089,
0.021283878,
-0.0492797866,
-0.0136567866,
-0.0261840522,
0.000010549,
-0.0791052356,
-0.0061921016,
-0.0041445927,
0.0318395346,
0.0204105023,
-0.0706045553,
-0.0505370311,
0.0394089222,
0.0117589319,
0.0056185056,
0.0217114147,
0.0015057941,
0.0520490184,
-0.0192850679,
0.0242565256,
-0.0338906534,
0.0423202105,
0.0126106068,
0.0418722816,
-0.0497128665,
-0.0410646908,
0.026639536,
0.0318615511,
0.0435288511,
-0.0342518613,
-0.0415936969,
0.018522026,
0.0127667999,
0.0186853819,
-0.0548929125,
-0.0160603151,
-0.0032064465,
-0.0123451082,
-0.0075722919,
-0.0225748457,
-0.0101923039,
0.0258419123,
0.0155857056,
-0.0426118672,
-0.0449226163,
0.0243146122,
0.0002413712,
-0.0265316032,
-0.0098620402,
0.0386067145,
0.0095071578,
-0.0426814742,
-0.0270813368,
-0.092621997,
-0.0218598731,
-0.0076989755,
0.0016189589,
-0.0689279214,
0.0200879108,
-0.0157711934,
-0.0049024108,
-0.0358947255,
-0.0135222487,
0.0335496031,
-0.0566934794,
0.044907067,
-0.0070305108,
-0.0017173919,
0.0098611824,
0.0197766908,
-0.0322556086,
0.0537977405,
0.0046186587,
0.0274852552,
0.0514449738,
0.0195506196,
0.0248352066,
0.0618165247,
0.0445594452,
0.047351107,
0.0105523877,
-0.0002673473,
0.0202748869,
0.0088345138,
0.030886624,
0.0477744862,
-0.0479590036,
-0.042450998,
0.0851676837,
0.1034464836,
-0.0548110083,
-0.0275585391,
0.0440494381,
0.0338552669,
0.0117376242,
0.0703328028,
-0.0229914524,
-0.034593273,
-0.043316029,
-0.016472023,
0.0338429846,
0.0203507282,
0.0259240828,
0.0015220006,
-0.0131891733,
-0.023018958,
-0.0032002812,
-0.023950262,
0.0111708045,
0.0112607833,
-0.0071030483,
0.0007193569,
0.014589712,
-0.0161459632,
0.0216797478,
-0.0657575876,
0.0268171988,
0.0537919737,
0.0653930306,
-0.0220623985,
0.0554866046,
-0.0506529436,
0.0176639408,
0.0147109861,
-0.0025784657,
-0.0039498955,
-0.0208475683,
-0.0263512861,
-0.0434653722,
-0.018404359,
0.02954497,
0.041882094,
0.043665152,
0.0314077102,
0.0305940844,
-0.0073043965,
-0.0394942202,
0.033480797,
-0.0371280685,
-0.0126416637,
-0.040256694,
-0.0109602176,
0.0500147454,
-0.0068397932,
-0.030784389,
0.0147045739,
0.016108783,
0.0086107999,
-0.0482966267,
-0.0183232035,
0.0296430159,
0.0053021437,
0.0363591574,
-0.0130906878,
0.0055655269,
0.034108784,
-0.0088689337,
-0.0070358971,
0.0043587997,
-0.0409804434,
0.0632699654,
-0.020502815,
0.0204092395,
-0.0125581687,
0.042328462,
-0.0312608965,
0.0393265486,
0.0019318732,
0.023785267,
0.0695738494,
-0.0637243837,
0.0216508098,
-0.0312143788,
-0.0412305221,
-0.0081669753,
-0.0246783607,
0.0065824548,
0.0388260409,
-0.0267127082,
-0.0533308461,
-0.015626533,
-0.0443919823,
0.0118493801,
-0.0196932536,
0.0331757702,
0.0264742188,
-0.0200426131,
-0.0527871214,
-0.0031981603,
-0.0289348755,
-0.0105483141,
-0.005552602,
0.0415560864,
0.0349013694,
-0.0006137888,
-0.0226309728,
-0.0301799756,
0.0051864097,
-0.020859411,
0.0524478257,
0.0414803326,
-0.0010077544,
-0.0290891659,
0.0352196991,
-0.0278791729,
-0.0353062116,
-0.0292617716,
-0.0240779426,
-0.0053502605,
0.004936141,
0.0381623171,
0.0713252053,
0.0416695662,
0.0200517401,
0.0168938935,
-0.0066698613,
-0.0737196058,
-0.052055981,
-0.0208160076,
-0.0332330279,
-0.0635788217,
-0.0405694395,
0.069017902,
-0.0001342741,
0.037484929,
0.0104195224,
-0.0279749408,
0.0505159795,
-0.0025436184,
-0.0118891643,
-0.0181007851,
-0.0584172122,
-0.0480543673,
0.0194840413,
0.0090641417,
-0.0542876944,
0.051309865,
-0.0656030998,
0.0522106625,
-0.0046172799,
-0.0119511886,
0.0309090558,
0.0289426651,
0.0247511491,
0.0103245685,
0.082808122,
-0.0057899253,
-0.0440662019,
0.0077177277,
0.0813466087,
-0.0351177491,
0.008440203,
-0.0084473118,
0.0165005531,
0.0192721691,
0.0073509854,
-0.0236364976,
-0.0873460844,
0.0004206574,
-0.0603310131,
0.0015348383,
-0.0387922674,
-0.0135467863,
-0.0399176069,
0.0499081016,
0.0056205615,
-0.0354129747,
-0.0043233489,
-0.0091479998,
0.0714330375,
0.0559580848,
-0.0315470994,
0.0113856597,
-0.0181134008,
0.0031058376,
0.0683310255,
0.0117471032,
0.0455076359,
0.0164877977,
-0.0443398878,
-0.0086377971,
-0.0227361545,
-0.0341647342,
0.0107803689,
0.012680172,
-0.0652030036,
0.0248140171,
0.0958509892,
0.0152542479,
-0.0516345203,
-0.0271816589,
-0.0220943801,
0.0568910725,
0.0043283282,
-0.0033627104,
-0.1131160781,
0.003878915,
0.0149322674,
0.0399645939,
-0.0500729233,
-0.0443526134,
-0.0296779666,
-0.1272022277,
0.0074398001,
-0.0020107995,
-0.0169220064,
0.0158199314,
-0.0436565578,
0.0133960433,
0.0254323911,
-0.0258612894,
-0.0195204783,
-0.0028582921,
0.0134321386,
-0.0051222527,
-0.0637820736,
-0.0905744731,
0.0225620996,
-0.0352388211,
0.0733106658,
0.0369046628,
0.0151950931,
-0.0159484688,
-0.0062952945,
0.0118044037,
-0.0219500102,
-0.0453681909,
0.0036696971,
0.1087575257,
-0.0195504278,
-0.0100082299,
0.0103914887,
0.0487419851,
0.0104441196,
0.0004182777,
0.0148753291,
0.0464966334,
0.0191284437,
-0.025988657,
-0.0271697976,
-0.0130482046,
0.0363644958,
0.0781895444,
0.0326649621,
-0.0036036661,
-0.0026847613,
-0.0337204635,
-0.0149791017,
0.0020229535,
-0.0367816426,
-0.0194285195,
-0.0159515906,
-0.0021127728,
-0.0967171565,
-0.0096196001,
-0.0115395272,
-0.0031020963,
0.0167710166,
0.0299081467,
0.0190861709,
-0.0187066365,
-0.0053802738,
-0.0250228066,
-0.0669522658,
0.0047845733,
-0.0385516509,
0.0258720666,
-0.0100075314,
0.0165207535,
-0.0270233527,
-0.0104169371,
-0.1078321263,
-0.0704568774,
0.0044186502,
0.0244084392,
0.0228835512,
0.0656921118,
-0.0015754945,
-0.0328080766,
0.0614265874,
0.0192362778,
-0.0135030225,
0.0398885347,
0.0164121147,
-0.0313570388,
0.0085911751,
0.0292195845,
-0.0381814018,
-0.0080855768,
0.0129993008,
-0.0645312294,
-0.0314058289,
0.0270403586,
0.0203068499,
0.0471550561,
0.0228790436,
-0.0132212797,
0.0264677145,
-0.0220728815,
-0.0027528452,
-0.0316037983,
-0.0057521504,
-0.0124996286,
0.0020458633,
0.0303186867,
-0.0082425475,
0.0024634197,
-0.0204644334,
-0.032646656,
0.0420147367,
-0.0589987673,
-0.0337530933,
0.0190366283,
-0.016825866,
0.0453468263,
-0.0111127403,
0.0060394434,
0.0154353026,
-0.0193559267,
0.0622949749,
-0.0213070344,
0.0324130058,
0.0048057018,
-0.0258026645,
0.0725738257,
0.0257593989,
-0.0987296179,
-0.0385463573,
0.0004354771,
-0.0159114152,
0.0085314112,
-0.034091875,
0.0503126569,
-0.0452804007,
-0.0049392907,
-0.0129063958,
-0.0272221509,
-0.0256425422,
-0.0101123117,
0.014734487,
0.0149707105,
-0.04702181,
0.0791247785,
0.0827740952,
0.0180337429,
0.0347134396,
0.0170179009,
-0.0694043562,
-0.0228257868,
-0.0172184482,
0.0665572733,
0.0310053024,
-0.0069071651,
-0.0458380468,
-0.0367073305,
-0.0531744808,
0.0109114191,
-0.0057052518,
-0.0030669314,
0.0121915368,
0.0086207651,
0.0714835376,
-0.0329529159,
0.0446424969,
-0.0356794596,
0.029423112,
-0.00383213,
-0.053970363,
0.013144318,
-6.1555118e-33,
0.0174488537,
-0.03159713,
-0.031102648,
0.0303429887,
-0.0307769626,
0.0320211723,
-0.0191836841,
-0.0100670606,
-0.0245752279,
-0.0000234339,
-0.0138812307,
0.0192377046,
-0.0055850116,
0.0097592445,
-0.0069234548,
-0.0359274484,
0.0103625469,
-0.022787489,
-0.0403471254,
0.0155240688,
0.0646186173,
0.0111249052,
0.0350418128,
-0.0506809428,
0.0641443655,
-0.0283298586,
-0.0410524532,
-0.0312460978,
0.0098266741,
0.0430848226,
-0.0313468985,
0.0320050232,
0.0054789898,
-0.0278197117,
-0.0097296406,
0.0246906336,
0.0193429068,
-0.0153228082,
0.0205218494,
-0.0328186415,
0.0319204852,
-0.0306889154,
0.0584914535,
-0.0307052899,
-0.0041724793,
-0.0199409891,
0.0354547575,
-0.0208618455,
-0.0005583696,
0.0033547182,
-0.0289252978,
0.0330805257,
-0.0174625292,
0.0016143896,
-0.01826551,
0.0472593121,
0.068776682,
0.0608315207,
-0.060048759,
0.046638716,
0.0113251451,
0.0491849966,
0.0270520281,
-0.0348355584,
0.0277594011,
0.0715274513,
-0.0156884212,
-0.0264596809,
0.0047210148,
0.0086554112,
0.0145917628,
-0.0138901677,
0.0418019593,
0.072575517,
0.0520956032,
-0.0241217073,
-0.0373079255,
0.0078024636,
0.019852262,
0.007456521,
0.0282554887,
-0.0208592974,
-0.0699098781,
-0.0227943026,
-0.011139066,
-0.0239590257,
-0.0059305578,
-0.0559327453,
0.0229940321,
-0.0021673874,
-0.0393383093,
-0.0387688205,
0.0150527004,
-0.0506196506,
-0.0273944642,
0.0273024011,
-0.0597238578,
0.0119838798,
0.0169733856,
0.0128140152,
-0.0238798447,
0.0169745181,
0.0169745274,
-0.0319947377,
0.0381341837,
0.0059352326,
0.0489405245,
0.0446784385,
-0.0885558724,
0.0020119781,
-0.0014196463,
0.0075514736,
-0.0089817662,
-0.015825646,
0.0270552672,
0.0051275459,
-0.0075789369,
-0.0124810589,
0.0446866304,
-0.0280720927,
-0.0505601428,
-0.0377929658,
-0.0364520662,
-0.0189245101,
-0.0075740661,
-0.0207648743,
0.0003163345,
0.0436514691,
0.0248430036,
-0.0742530152,
0.0158733688,
-0.026063785,
2.903e-7,
0.0340083353,
0.0233323611,
0.0274087414,
-0.0110239936,
0.024257971,
0.0337313376,
-0.0077069411,
0.0485578552,
-0.0113556655,
-0.0783988312,
-0.0082177427,
-0.0001642232,
0.0230752025,
0.0020073731,
-0.1091179848,
-0.0102694109,
-0.107299827,
-0.0348950922,
-0.0751162395,
-0.0299101193,
0.0623188727,
0.0610878542,
0.0527141169,
-0.011513127,
-0.0153652411,
-0.077473864,
0.04210639,
-0.0239812676,
-0.0401132107,
0.0039494298,
0.0743734837,
0.0092217494,
0.0256679226,
0.0081071174,
-0.0249121692,
0.0156446435,
-0.0052987356,
0.0278481375,
0.0535028502,
0.0001023178,
-0.0512002967,
-0.0402671508,
0.0123579372,
-0.0682246983,
0.0619363785,
0.0012198504,
0.0122309299,
-0.0259824879,
-0.0422703363,
-0.0842716098,
0.0674988776,
-0.0236252602,
-0.0293609332,
0.0207888838,
-0.0157688409,
0.0373611972,
0.0117002856,
-0.0708616152,
0.0005268077,
-0.0615063198,
-0.0410728417,
-0.0444306917,
-0.0476047173,
0.016700618,
0.0112924036,
-0.0199836418,
0.015824642,
3.00018714e-34,
0.0367287137,
-0.0356457084,
0.0240199529,
0.0209659729,
0.0272452179,
0.0269867908,
0.0172718875,
0.0082478952,
-0.0146337654,
-0.0662358627,
-0.0106751835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16892v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16892v1
|
Multilingual Entity Linking Using Dense Retrieval
| 2024-05-13T18:57:27 | 2024-05-13T18:57:27 |
Dominik Farhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity linking (EL) is the computational process of connecting textual
mentions to corresponding entities. Like many areas of natural language
processing, the EL field has greatly benefited from deep learning, leading to
significant performance improvements. However, present-day approaches are
expensive to train and rely on diverse data sources, complicating their
reproducibility. In this thesis, we develop multiple systems that are fast to
train, demonstrating that competitive entity linking can be achieved without a
large GPU cluster. Moreover, we train on a publicly available dataset, ensuring
reproducibility and accessibility. Our models are evaluated for 9 languages
giving an accurate overview of their strengths. Furthermore, we offer
a~detailed analysis of bi-encoder training hyperparameters, a popular approach
in EL, to guide their informed selection. Overall, our work shows that building
competitive neural network based EL systems that operate in multiple languages
is possible even with limited resources, thus making EL more approachable.
|
[
0.0146564776,
0.043745555,
-0.0067832572,
0.0314976461,
0.0081764385,
0.0219765101,
0.0158356596,
-0.0264326464,
0.017824214,
-0.0194095168,
-0.0024093296,
-0.0001691168,
0.0152912633,
0.0276518613,
0.0403748974,
-0.0304646827,
0.0341247842,
-0.0070736739,
0.0049082837,
-0.0350522436,
-0.0224861633,
0.0494867638,
0.001279009,
0.006241621,
-0.0122351255,
0.0303521622,
0.0027049526,
0.0058021056,
0.0233915951,
-0.0279819053,
-0.0146091077,
0.010749477,
-0.0000304016,
0.0710870773,
0.000001937,
-0.0536572561,
-0.033018373,
-0.0158213601,
-0.0269245766,
-0.0031320443,
-0.0233451277,
-0.0366261117,
0.0058068275,
-0.0301588438,
-0.0103508504,
-0.0568559133,
0.0266478434,
0.0227504764,
0.0359032117,
0.0341488346,
-0.0243953783,
-0.0538148582,
0.0586429872,
-0.0495401025,
-0.0615018085,
-0.0466839671,
0.0107194204,
-0.045294065,
-0.0282151289,
0.0297249313,
0.0022559632,
0.0686308891,
0.0266512856,
0.0336502977,
-0.0053845881,
0.0168124437,
-0.0511667468,
-0.0005008513,
0.0242209919,
0.0914841369,
-0.0497393794,
-0.0128121339,
0.0183857754,
0.0208610147,
-0.0160339139,
-0.0233003739,
-0.0233318899,
0.0174783729,
0.0062595494,
0.0261362214,
-0.0022948536,
0.0062924679,
0.0600152127,
0.0221312102,
0.0067919106,
0.003711191,
0.0161951687,
-0.0122231962,
0.0437405147,
0.0490775965,
-0.0089668259,
-0.021376323,
0.0414636321,
0.0043440647,
-0.0375435017,
0.016312344,
-0.0311395563,
-0.0355757847,
0.0148441941,
-0.0547444001,
-0.0397228114,
-0.0200566147,
-0.0042221104,
0.0431211703,
-0.0863005966,
-0.003914861,
-0.0218123365,
-0.0181285068,
0.0091782482,
-0.0829942375,
-0.012343985,
0.0010337692,
-0.0359662324,
0.0105711594,
-0.0364870913,
0.0110475468,
-0.048129987,
-0.0285935625,
-0.0366508476,
0.0981231034,
-0.0052297348,
0.0151026621,
-0.0158884842,
-0.0044672582,
-0.0422341935,
0.0165039022,
-0.056366168,
-0.0263782144,
-0.0316032916,
-0.0657578111,
0.0002141746,
0.0216894336,
0.0005780694,
-0.0689568073,
0.037114799,
0.0645754933,
0.0014005669,
-0.0078211604,
-0.0180054903,
-0.04038845,
0.032730855,
-0.0519896671,
-0.0009048987,
-0.1055282727,
0.0644337535,
-0.0072084065,
0.0006135063,
-0.0927575603,
0.0217279419,
0.0163084045,
-0.0708405897,
0.0795297027,
-0.0469179824,
-0.0449869148,
0.0388322435,
-0.0050501847,
0.0635979399,
0.0508237816,
0.067718178,
0.0089692269,
0.0664043128,
0.0367522091,
-0.0188354384,
0.0265409313,
0.0395159833,
-0.0238052458,
0.0239024702,
0.0038018555,
-0.0198399238,
0.0655336827,
0.0485829338,
0.0711716786,
-0.0431164503,
-0.0535562932,
0.0213501807,
0.0216430202,
-0.0013245324,
0.0477431938,
0.0508396029,
-0.032986097,
-0.0143760415,
-0.0584636629,
-0.015188857,
0.032216832,
0.0146560278,
0.0010829207,
0.045124013,
0.0645124912,
-0.036063645,
-0.0035447348,
0.0259307437,
-0.0211449843,
0.0032839195,
0.0218947865,
0.0793459713,
0.0053518126,
-0.0232864153,
0.0771156326,
0.0187547021,
-0.018883165,
0.0077826637,
0.0102557205,
-0.0394636169,
0.0336502455,
0.015908638,
0.0487258062,
-0.0162182264,
-0.0330592506,
-0.0177128464,
0.0336954929,
0.0347143449,
-0.029709287,
0.041466631,
-0.0580491424,
0.0041792477,
0.0020721455,
-0.0208084919,
0.0381633192,
0.0254968721,
0.075110808,
0.03161956,
-0.005227542,
0.001224802,
0.0141543727,
-0.0317109935,
0.00459512,
-0.0031734947,
0.0419318452,
-0.0249257721,
0.0509262756,
0.0206636693,
-0.038424965,
0.0407796912,
-0.0384121761,
0.0063444087,
0.0213956162,
0.0162083451,
-0.0275255907,
0.0211725086,
-0.0394780599,
-0.0107904952,
0.0019633283,
-0.011279027,
-0.0457901768,
0.0164314397,
0.0111993616,
0.012238727,
-0.0143316928,
0.0048097107,
0.0071831676,
0.0344088785,
-0.0204768423,
0.0570565872,
-0.0063170153,
0.0345362015,
0.043502491,
0.0053308592,
0.0471301787,
-0.0462093465,
-0.0733780041,
0.03952704,
0.0237366483,
-0.0162806027,
0.0062099989,
-0.0181838758,
-0.0338202268,
0.0004529693,
-0.063844122,
0.0402278937,
-0.0150353555,
0.0057016495,
-0.0144840106,
0.0148126939,
-0.0099272635,
-0.0174208414,
-0.0095836008,
-0.002429279,
-0.0095753297,
0.0154276183,
0.0469517186,
0.0130575346,
0.0098198848,
-0.0470311232,
-0.0271164607,
0.0035478191,
0.0637116879,
-0.0077417069,
-0.0575181805,
-0.0311026704,
-0.0004435222,
-0.0422921181,
0.035214562,
-0.0114700077,
0.0100655761,
-0.0216946825,
0.0273800176,
0.0239771642,
0.0556224473,
-0.0465385504,
0.0286195278,
0.0120623978,
-0.024834346,
-0.0768337548,
0.0531908646,
0.0088110091,
0.0170494728,
-0.0334519669,
-0.0111904591,
-0.0236257818,
0.0155763403,
-0.0610573962,
-0.0072735404,
-0.0163490735,
-0.0108972825,
0.0483622029,
-0.0128678679,
-0.0191088058,
0.0203187875,
0.034225978,
0.0192939695,
-0.0084387166,
-0.0149422009,
0.0188556425,
-0.0350358747,
0.0032382857,
-0.013107108,
-0.0144048026,
-0.0360927843,
0.039906811,
0.0232147221,
0.0163566731,
-0.0344794244,
-0.0130246952,
0.0011423663,
0.0861483365,
0.0012335671,
-0.0056391284,
0.0213662591,
-0.0051083039,
0.0237050168,
-0.014126095,
-0.030501429,
-0.005931465,
0.0298338439,
-0.0652327761,
0.0262631569,
0.0043791481,
-0.0176150259,
-0.0501492582,
0.0283076447,
0.0284850672,
0.044555977,
0.0281719379,
-0.0252974872,
0.0066564423,
0.0316420719,
0.054576356,
0.007125881,
0.0236367323,
0.002223237,
-0.0189027973,
0.0448344052,
0.0284482911,
-0.0336801484,
-0.0192546695,
-0.0164789911,
0.0244822428,
-0.0639171377,
-0.056632407,
-0.0326035805,
0.0157626644,
-0.0521214865,
-0.0096655833,
0.09301579,
0.0143840695,
-0.0849416927,
-0.0148593495,
0.026382776,
0.0137816863,
0.0067891101,
0.0358055495,
-0.0859966874,
-0.0288300123,
-0.0105390372,
-0.0366248377,
0.0230124742,
-0.0670227334,
-0.0000040884,
-0.1349285245,
-0.0331334919,
-0.0299935918,
-0.0093502011,
-0.0707682446,
-0.0508550927,
-0.0011375413,
-0.048961442,
-0.0070494101,
-0.0223612599,
0.0325096548,
0.0100050019,
-0.0124903619,
0.0014625954,
-0.0210531875,
0.0066842567,
-0.0997434556,
0.0428612716,
0.0243571661,
0.0441911109,
-0.002057319,
-0.0141326822,
-0.0314020813,
-0.0357796177,
-0.0388045274,
-0.0070125647,
0.0640452951,
-0.0521412268,
-0.005018645,
0.0087919319,
-0.0215290952,
-0.0347547494,
0.0056713377,
-0.0162039101,
0.0432595052,
0.0449079312,
0.0122244153,
0.000264749,
-0.0329129808,
-0.0057019275,
0.0448656008,
-0.0435668044,
-0.0231112223,
-0.0099658994,
-0.0441000871,
0.022812169,
-0.0434489399,
-0.0073456736,
0.0111907283,
-0.0394776277,
-0.0165675338,
-0.0661060363,
-0.0652080253,
0.0394365638,
0.0436976887,
-0.0156743824,
0.0376425348,
0.0213842597,
0.0010429851,
-0.0481417254,
0.0549135134,
-0.0314128213,
0.0243094191,
-0.0221625641,
0.0046020579,
0.0442251973,
-0.0197196789,
-0.0336327925,
0.0054063052,
-0.0684329942,
-0.0342375524,
-0.0306702591,
0.0194927789,
0.0099149691,
0.0622228161,
-0.0397556946,
-0.0724027231,
-0.0179270487,
0.0283040069,
-0.0279338248,
0.0021942602,
0.0184002053,
0.0064354297,
-0.0141234919,
0.0401013084,
-0.0382222757,
-0.0027687226,
-0.0029007185,
0.0240687244,
-0.0599171519,
-0.0690803081,
-0.0220644698,
-0.0093987035,
0.0505065396,
-0.0157890618,
0.0032274087,
-0.0399000272,
0.0253793392,
0.0161033664,
0.0058826129,
-0.0194980223,
0.0199571587,
0.0089304829,
0.0509140231,
-0.0195727479,
-0.0080852443,
0.0877423435,
-0.0128414314,
-0.0478281751,
0.003122682,
0.0259499513,
0.0135275256,
-0.0217738356,
0.0185865927,
-0.0024543854,
0.029427506,
0.0137926349,
0.0955635682,
-0.0721498653,
-0.0206522848,
-0.0021431539,
-0.0127890632,
0.0207047667,
0.0407003686,
-0.0063107233,
-0.0003490337,
-0.0072860043,
0.0044842097,
0.1240768284,
-0.0119151324,
0.0673814043,
0.0134103876,
-0.0150139229,
0.0266733821,
-0.0071395794,
-0.0204618834,
-0.0099728117,
0.0015114638,
0.0126594603,
-0.0122030443,
0.0761093721,
0.056910716,
0.0064113736,
0.0428263955,
0.0230578594,
0.0034384802,
-0.0267261229,
-0.0034955714,
-0.0047052596,
0.0305906329,
-0.016009314,
-0.0234519858,
0.0314387493,
-0.064115718,
0.0617681779,
-0.0230325386,
-0.0077051171,
0.0299888924,
0.0580481477,
0.0447551571,
0.0268998295,
-0.0085781924,
-0.0114106126,
0.0049685864,
0.0147058628,
-0.0240136031,
-0.0351394527,
-5.61159183e-33,
-0.0273048989,
-0.0063468073,
0.0194656774,
-0.0375561975,
-0.0082557639,
-0.013530965,
-0.0038679081,
-0.0322854742,
-0.0875268206,
-0.0121328514,
-0.0047027874,
-0.0009481169,
0.0154352263,
0.0293525718,
0.0158817675,
-0.0422430001,
0.0328760669,
0.0186068807,
0.0110424673,
0.0057994714,
0.0473100506,
0.0372537635,
0.0841600075,
-0.0646814182,
0.0300015584,
0.0013106555,
-0.0112196188,
0.0437906012,
0.0314386748,
0.0731976479,
-0.0058139991,
0.0259740222,
-0.003001292,
-0.0272222646,
0.0162986238,
-0.012233681,
-0.1415268034,
-0.0227561295,
-0.0257814191,
0.0404718742,
-0.0170574617,
-0.0371729992,
0.0394209735,
0.0203948021,
0.0543547943,
0.0047316747,
0.0401504189,
-0.0033630573,
-0.0335562602,
-0.074496977,
-0.0294229612,
0.0453430489,
0.0110136401,
0.0678574592,
0.0796995834,
0.0036521584,
-0.007449891,
0.0148452381,
-0.1169689447,
-0.0184925199,
-0.0516726673,
0.0129910763,
0.0338818803,
-0.0322092436,
-0.002034229,
0.0584619157,
0.0169671942,
-0.0216213968,
-0.0213421192,
0.0709877908,
0.0196329504,
-0.0134021798,
0.0482063144,
0.0628250912,
0.0183982793,
-0.0291727968,
-0.1019530892,
0.0082740299,
0.0514727086,
0.0115355244,
-0.0283607692,
0.0074608135,
-0.0072082113,
-0.0119816074,
-0.0318666846,
-0.0153117189,
-0.0042485096,
-0.0431824848,
-0.0003510362,
0.0089838421,
-0.0132031906,
0.0766391829,
0.0134995217,
-0.0019521862,
-0.0225041211,
0.0205563065,
0.035488572,
0.0334683731,
0.0293674152,
0.0296164919,
-0.0587466769,
-0.0216852799,
-0.0029840267,
-0.0151680047,
0.0220507663,
0.0212027244,
0.0454541594,
-0.026338147,
-0.0666496083,
0.0040558768,
0.0066597234,
0.0108704353,
-0.028603958,
0.0359174684,
-0.0042343591,
0.0034297202,
0.0045101843,
0.0093611674,
0.0449266806,
-0.0099201929,
-0.0364582427,
0.0147717772,
0.0238016397,
-0.0068904031,
-0.0015069959,
-0.0077798776,
-0.0537844524,
0.0112972064,
-0.0076130405,
-0.0963050053,
-0.0239591692,
0.0109301517,
2.59e-7,
0.0171388555,
0.0358982719,
-0.0025723111,
0.0040967637,
-0.0222920589,
-0.0095833112,
0.0534571186,
0.0520620495,
0.0002229781,
-0.0032133658,
-0.0248917192,
0.0257109404,
0.005558833,
0.0516337603,
-0.1126866639,
-0.0483308583,
-0.0766608343,
0.002143502,
-0.0404938757,
-0.0399163775,
0.0028487016,
0.0703703165,
0.0141930245,
0.0219571795,
-0.0144079411,
-0.0372982882,
0.0477977879,
-0.0162123777,
0.0114552807,
0.0088587236,
0.0075870506,
0.0275201313,
-0.0486398712,
0.0549694747,
-0.0115614915,
0.0631417111,
0.0467935093,
0.0437020063,
0.0127675179,
-0.0158847403,
0.004679847,
-0.0636599362,
-0.0171371102,
-0.0038576496,
0.0780005157,
-0.0022936591,
0.0007936654,
0.0288493261,
-0.0145542882,
0.0424822234,
0.044409398,
-0.0070239883,
-0.0207201838,
0.0253568832,
0.027376188,
-0.0206363313,
-0.018086737,
-0.0766886398,
-0.009405815,
-0.0027649663,
0.0033299199,
-0.0085400799,
-0.0132715926,
-0.05446418,
0.0096638435,
-0.0070129209,
0.0180836711,
2.175086074e-34,
0.010381748,
0.0004865103,
-0.0108944839,
0.019446684,
0.0463489518,
-0.0548126921,
-0.052429948,
0.0093924962,
0.0013557842,
-0.0482865982,
-0.007174538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08099v1
|
KET-QA: A Dataset for Knowledge Enhanced Table Question Answering
| 2024-05-13T18:26:32 | 2024-05-13T18:26:32 |
Mengkang Hu, Haoyu Dong, Ping Luo, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Due to the concise and structured nature of tables, the knowledge contained
therein may be incomplete or missing, posing a significant challenge for table
question answering (TableQA) and data analysis systems. Most existing datasets
either fail to address the issue of external knowledge in TableQA or only
utilize unstructured text as supplementary information for tables. In this
paper, we propose to use a knowledge base (KB) as the external knowledge source
for TableQA and construct a dataset KET-QA with fine-grained gold evidence
annotation. Each table in the dataset corresponds to a sub-graph of the entire
KB, and every question requires the integration of information from both the
table and the sub-graph to be answered. To extract pertinent information from
the vast knowledge sub-graph and apply it to TableQA, we design a
retriever-reasoner structured pipeline model. Experimental results demonstrate
that our model consistently achieves remarkable relative performance
improvements ranging from 1.9 to 6.5 times and absolute improvements of 11.66%
to 44.64% on EM scores across three distinct settings (fine-tuning, zero-shot,
and few-shot), in comparison with solely relying on table information in the
traditional TableQA manner. However, even the best model achieves a 60.23% EM
score, which still lags behind the human-level performance, highlighting the
challenging nature of KET-QA for the question-answering community. We also
provide a human evaluation of error cases to analyze further the aspects in
which the model can be improved. Project page: https://ketqa.github.io/.
|
[
0.0444143265,
0.0372465625,
-0.0132625196,
0.03128637,
-0.0210332144,
0.0431227833,
-0.038656354,
0.0246449355,
0.010143714,
-0.0134998569,
-0.0292811338,
0.049094189,
-0.0490274243,
0.0374594815,
0.0283094514,
0.0021629236,
0.03411033,
0.0234683249,
0.018298164,
0.0123799359,
0.0353045501,
-0.0079095196,
-0.0287720747,
0.0191449132,
-0.0177540276,
-0.0074592815,
-0.0267166458,
-0.0285638962,
-0.0128072863,
0.0029832448,
0.0257990286,
0.059658505,
0.0116653424,
0.0028452794,
0.0000020312,
0.0223499741,
-0.0247908384,
0.0040482306,
-0.0649164245,
-0.0260026492,
-0.0497774407,
-0.0109313121,
0.046925474,
0.0078434544,
-0.0543726832,
0.0014184089,
0.0227292497,
0.0636065677,
0.0644201338,
0.0272019412,
0.0145457061,
-0.0345712751,
-0.024417758,
0.0051147849,
0.0410024598,
-0.0528850295,
0.0225766469,
0.0447884351,
0.0189228598,
-0.0016207742,
0.008172824,
0.049942892,
0.0316993631,
-0.0056476472,
0.0118125593,
0.0425599702,
-0.0275918152,
0.0356179923,
0.0199139006,
0.1231939644,
0.0413925424,
-0.0229674149,
0.004659838,
0.0017430893,
0.0287540685,
0.0203433093,
-0.0563089401,
-0.0300921332,
-0.024741346,
-0.0460498407,
0.0038116111,
-0.0132860914,
-0.0026872337,
-0.0088838385,
-0.0092632733,
0.0620284267,
-0.0246203039,
-0.0434424542,
0.0082115354,
0.0076884525,
-0.0581382737,
-0.0217839461,
-0.0041064206,
0.0637082458,
-0.0253450777,
0.0395597965,
0.033791244,
-0.0159516986,
0.0390289128,
-0.0309397168,
-0.0037056452,
0.0323083065,
-0.0042704241,
0.0532856956,
-0.0311071444,
0.0148213487,
-0.0217674579,
0.0360472612,
-0.0274324771,
-0.0297006443,
-0.0625991672,
-0.018116191,
-0.0502843186,
0.0381799638,
-0.0632638186,
-0.0144696897,
0.0206374042,
0.0123171574,
-0.0029210241,
0.0267727636,
0.0375844724,
0.0545129441,
0.0009344209,
0.0154089006,
-0.0536825508,
0.0298620779,
-0.0724202096,
0.0147117693,
-0.0058359592,
-0.0552082509,
-0.0312945656,
-0.0136750359,
0.034353476,
-0.0213882923,
0.0253684688,
0.0531164147,
-0.0177057274,
-0.0019969526,
-0.032309562,
-0.0458380617,
-0.0299099702,
-0.0305690058,
-0.0063496321,
-0.0318239853,
0.0713042244,
0.0254384354,
-0.006514329,
-0.0369766876,
0.0060982681,
0.0469470471,
-0.0162163209,
0.0413791128,
-0.0201346297,
0.0142800175,
0.0157435574,
0.0048393928,
-0.0731324106,
0.0821855292,
0.019095663,
-0.0068583223,
0.0032718007,
-0.0239707008,
-0.0322813652,
-0.0007165703,
0.0582510382,
-0.0107948314,
0.0290481672,
0.0813113376,
-0.0340773873,
0.0244297069,
-0.0238655359,
0.0094016483,
-0.0409596004,
0.0187985003,
0.0001793451,
0.0140631348,
0.0206825901,
0.0369698033,
-0.0001473684,
0.0007247132,
0.0492467359,
0.0071613397,
-0.0068389573,
0.0663389489,
-0.0001286995,
0.0222003404,
0.0064581661,
-0.0191629156,
-0.0215817466,
-0.0392833725,
0.0110349962,
0.036771547,
-0.0366596207,
0.0254948828,
0.0298803728,
0.0365429893,
-0.0534432866,
0.011753384,
0.0169067588,
-0.0211519375,
-0.0185553972,
-0.0028047787,
0.0717872381,
0.0504688881,
0.042378664,
-0.058281187,
-0.0273090973,
0.011880259,
-0.0021928786,
-0.0182170123,
-0.0023152032,
-0.0579078346,
-0.0128868688,
-0.0056253616,
-0.0394700542,
-0.0061894441,
0.0207970794,
-0.0257048085,
0.0455851629,
0.0137011567,
-0.0150001235,
-0.0472569466,
-0.0092802495,
0.0090015056,
0.0363758132,
-0.0096916575,
-0.0205741283,
0.0048740236,
0.0140652815,
0.0342225097,
0.0058986619,
0.0448311269,
0.026311012,
-0.0302420817,
-0.0177841317,
-0.0115386285,
-0.027783623,
-0.0272399448,
0.0291731209,
0.0172333028,
-0.044101797,
-0.0208383184,
-0.0405546762,
-0.0596625842,
-0.0054282048,
-0.037136443,
-0.0264049955,
-0.0062912642,
-0.0408745855,
0.0410273187,
-0.014753012,
-0.0143890884,
0.085183166,
0.0165871717,
0.0262898337,
-0.0187275521,
-0.0846609324,
0.0281501412,
-0.027125679,
0.0196466576,
-0.0316660777,
-0.0061110989,
0.0338785872,
0.0275346041,
0.0082483878,
-0.0863161907,
0.0125628263,
-0.0797070116,
0.0326683968,
-0.041072987,
0.0230185576,
0.036291562,
0.0124634625,
-0.016163066,
-0.033065632,
-0.0561920404,
0.0101807378,
-0.0090988632,
0.0212091729,
0.0625457168,
0.0360654034,
0.0191339515,
-0.0430530757,
-0.0275718607,
-0.0135711292,
0.0282922853,
0.0026755149,
-0.0095484005,
0.0124587631,
-0.0104463482,
-0.0267904829,
0.0142728454,
0.0146684581,
-0.0024722251,
-0.0015184149,
-0.0274255872,
0.009025895,
0.0274408516,
-0.0465359464,
0.0001792667,
-0.0002905601,
-0.0103937201,
-0.040701706,
0.0240484737,
-0.0284267124,
0.0301960427,
0.0236332305,
-0.0217577592,
0.0378623419,
0.0261249393,
0.0031685212,
-0.0027124232,
-0.0618126392,
0.0475537069,
0.0116073061,
0.0129610738,
-0.1029781997,
0.0430697948,
0.0221064184,
0.0070114634,
-0.051036153,
0.0485508889,
0.0459590815,
-0.002294648,
0.0276523549,
-0.016226124,
0.0262563452,
-0.0560989007,
0.0511460379,
-0.0080841398,
-0.0038372073,
-0.0195206273,
-0.005426418,
-0.0193313491,
-0.0180527996,
0.0323399045,
-0.0405781269,
0.0766905993,
-0.0410036743,
0.0168993194,
0.0024125134,
-0.0306166355,
-0.0180535708,
-0.013519709,
-0.0512139909,
0.021933496,
0.0042107268,
-0.0147796739,
0.0019963367,
-0.0188724324,
0.0362140313,
0.0247578938,
-0.0205451064,
-0.0210175533,
-0.026519835,
0.0712428093,
0.0785702318,
0.0242418442,
-0.016945675,
0.0111594675,
0.0675287917,
0.0829226002,
-0.0163409226,
-0.0399393663,
0.0020704996,
0.0148185035,
-0.0027772801,
-0.0440641716,
0.0056681577,
0.0090648048,
0.0028174918,
-0.0602316894,
-0.0075100898,
0.0669804737,
0.0238240957,
0.0213649906,
-0.0182735398,
0.0043964949,
0.035621617,
0.0148236454,
0.0431052893,
-0.107774362,
-0.0491495728,
-0.0144858919,
0.0133107165,
0.0100943837,
-0.0617793165,
0.0052559697,
-0.0895154253,
0.0169763733,
-0.0516000241,
-0.0497110412,
-0.1116783693,
-0.0490882322,
-0.0021320127,
-0.0192474015,
0.0038634657,
0.0499947034,
0.0029966519,
0.0461766794,
0.0359882936,
-0.0271855984,
-0.0280657355,
0.0253562201,
-0.0418337062,
0.0085992888,
0.0143896397,
0.0200904012,
-0.0100034894,
-0.0199311394,
-0.054281354,
-0.0493614264,
0.03231306,
0.0068318434,
0.0621989407,
-0.0091673462,
-0.0207444932,
-0.0272862725,
-0.0018304577,
-0.0577196814,
0.0057809451,
0.0468078852,
0.0769900009,
-0.0292131826,
0.013847827,
0.0138481818,
-0.013572556,
-0.0202292502,
0.0677463114,
0.05864105,
0.0473967977,
-0.0424996428,
-0.0005215633,
-0.0474579632,
-0.0778224468,
0.0229763389,
0.0507071801,
0.001071793,
0.0398900695,
-0.0793950036,
-0.0372401662,
0.0764126256,
0.0442877598,
-0.0269840192,
0.0459810086,
-0.0266733207,
-0.0023115694,
-0.0530034937,
0.015232143,
-0.0594080091,
-0.0066626617,
-0.0024119855,
-0.0357337259,
-0.0128196441,
-0.0115551753,
-0.0404185988,
0.0130886491,
-0.0338577032,
-0.0058737551,
-0.0095925778,
0.0260079857,
0.0145931132,
0.0056289509,
0.0002664062,
-0.0049122963,
-0.0028271899,
-0.0204253662,
-0.0922711417,
-0.0609815232,
-0.0068265884,
-0.0417244323,
-0.0076446161,
0.0316724628,
-0.0545950122,
-0.0198823474,
-0.0093800649,
0.0619156286,
-0.0271278135,
0.0217685942,
0.0512339287,
0.0222671423,
-0.0174213741,
0.0678129643,
-0.0493838191,
-0.0304743536,
0.0278115477,
-0.0483736955,
-0.0251802634,
0.0016965799,
0.0111136688,
-0.0044520372,
-0.0532792807,
-0.0267909914,
-0.0072974982,
0.0126732541,
0.0186130144,
-0.0538067669,
-0.0112858592,
0.0766274631,
-0.0228434298,
0.0115260379,
-0.0410474204,
-0.0281616524,
-0.0296856537,
0.0363218114,
0.03782323,
0.003026997,
0.0228789691,
0.038146995,
-0.0509583466,
-0.0316332951,
0.0387001671,
-0.0647727847,
-0.0707628205,
0.0068477024,
0.0049156402,
0.0326914228,
0.0046923086,
0.0125511065,
-0.0112686343,
-0.0396457389,
0.0449611098,
0.0146181257,
0.0254796799,
0.0160370134,
0.0759536028,
0.0270074457,
-0.0066206343,
-0.0240556356,
0.0885286927,
0.006003147,
0.0517745465,
-0.0169877857,
-0.0303645078,
-0.0523156449,
0.0115824714,
-0.0158294365,
0.0025647136,
-0.0156380348,
-0.0109573817,
-0.0370345414,
-0.0412273929,
0.0101615498,
0.0391597338,
-0.0441572741,
0.0150347035,
0.0437789783,
0.0372083522,
0.0674727485,
-0.0484131351,
-0.0499975421,
0.0360199772,
-0.0415713191,
-0.0101826387,
-0.0058138389,
-6.453151011e-33,
-0.032809075,
-0.0234261844,
0.0253529064,
-0.0247925334,
0.0050267386,
0.0030214789,
-0.0514912531,
-0.0273771901,
-0.0367192551,
0.0412824824,
-0.029282812,
0.045510672,
0.0024728815,
-0.020086661,
0.0078854207,
-0.0882660076,
0.0064458926,
-0.011530756,
0.000842795,
0.0376514904,
0.0293792654,
0.0331578925,
0.0034287742,
0.0135240806,
0.0487125404,
0.0115719289,
0.0074469182,
0.0121803731,
-0.0241211466,
0.0487157777,
-0.0249058381,
0.0512095131,
0.0427916013,
-0.0532401837,
-0.0094460612,
-0.0013561207,
-0.1664676219,
-0.053238079,
0.000731428,
-0.0015182901,
-0.0348063037,
-0.0210431535,
0.0221588705,
0.0002383431,
0.0388259776,
-0.0152709037,
0.0167403091,
-0.0048598261,
0.0022015355,
-0.0154334158,
0.0052786586,
0.018137956,
-0.0357047729,
0.0099642975,
0.0130594093,
0.0451010242,
0.0374574848,
-0.0238517318,
-0.0555278659,
-0.0049704034,
-0.0088328775,
0.0090633193,
0.0183048043,
-0.0358869992,
0.0176675078,
0.0191028658,
-0.0001049404,
0.0070379535,
-0.0479384102,
0.0181856733,
-0.0707458332,
0.065594703,
0.0812143236,
0.0023541234,
0.015684789,
-0.0040444508,
-0.0716838688,
0.0565219596,
-0.0183414742,
0.0509245507,
-0.0334579796,
-0.0301736891,
-0.0466689542,
-0.02092674,
-0.0275597312,
0.014807051,
-0.0412483364,
-0.0018336668,
0.0187334344,
-0.0127630197,
0.0039476519,
-0.0165139195,
-0.0154447798,
0.0012281389,
0.0325826295,
0.0727930367,
-0.0042744312,
0.0087035717,
0.0243748929,
0.0089006005,
-0.0544777997,
0.0071249558,
0.0362610929,
-0.0269297659,
0.0218777936,
0.0437176004,
0.0436998606,
0.0021416075,
-0.0406531692,
-0.0084107891,
-0.0633951202,
0.0562165082,
-0.0321272202,
-0.0121310856,
-0.0011045425,
0.0575997345,
0.0008153572,
0.0303388629,
0.0329222418,
0.0444399677,
0.0035286171,
0.0168707147,
0.0087573742,
-0.0120916944,
0.0251393113,
0.0041107121,
-0.023521496,
0.0003105425,
-0.0238082167,
-0.0313948952,
0.0071774665,
0.0172044169,
2.588e-7,
0.0851099864,
-0.0141493864,
0.0715624541,
0.0541208871,
-0.0055078613,
0.0083225267,
0.006284303,
-0.0178219825,
-0.0019749661,
-0.0386206917,
0.0415450335,
0.0161237959,
0.0161883384,
0.034595415,
-0.0478811301,
-0.067803964,
-0.0635954589,
-0.0376747027,
-0.0322936699,
-0.0130076027,
0.0677573979,
0.0504586771,
-0.0354759395,
-0.0077486276,
-0.031307485,
-0.0249971151,
0.0295346286,
0.0002633489,
0.0234306194,
0.0157135744,
0.0771805272,
-0.0231230706,
0.0243414026,
0.0653001368,
-0.0306004323,
-0.0008512806,
0.0035689147,
0.027399607,
-0.0001395578,
0.0011519162,
-0.0272082724,
-0.0531003252,
0.0632823706,
-0.0767891854,
0.1218808442,
-0.0442204997,
-0.0184948947,
0.0680392608,
-0.044443015,
-0.0052695968,
0.0044366173,
0.0142966984,
-0.0157314744,
-0.0042930865,
0.0218731482,
0.0244533494,
0.0297970232,
-0.0622165091,
0.0080865091,
0.022480024,
0.0027650376,
-0.0048361123,
0.0037291565,
-0.0688764006,
-0.0244431514,
-0.0365776569,
-0.0312223677,
2.084539948e-34,
0.0254694652,
0.0187017787,
0.0510754026,
0.0366510339,
0.0690231472,
-0.0249843709,
-0.004405844,
-0.0390517935,
0.0299175587,
-0.0923586711,
-0.0272981599
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07990v1
|
Plot2Code: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Multi-modal Large Language Models in Code Generation from Scientific Plots
| 2024-05-13T17:59:22 | 2024-05-13T17:59:22 |
Chengyue Wu, Yixiao Ge, Qiushan Guo, Jiahao Wang, Zhixuan Liang, Zeyu Lu, Ying Shan, Ping Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The remarkable progress of Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) has
attracted significant attention due to their superior performance in visual
contexts. However, their capabilities in turning visual figure to executable
code, have not been evaluated thoroughly. To address this, we introduce
Plot2Code, a comprehensive visual coding benchmark designed for a fair and
in-depth assessment of MLLMs. We carefully collect 132 manually selected
high-quality matplotlib plots across six plot types from publicly available
matplotlib galleries. For each plot, we carefully offer its source code, and an
descriptive instruction summarized by GPT-4. This approach enables Plot2Code to
extensively evaluate MLLMs' code capabilities across various input modalities.
Furthermore, we propose three automatic evaluation metrics, including code pass
rate, text-match ratio, and GPT-4V overall rating, for a fine-grained
assessment of the output code and rendered images. Instead of simply judging
pass or fail, we employ GPT-4V to make an overall judgement between the
generated and reference images, which has been shown to be consistent with
human evaluation. The evaluation results, which include analyses of 14 MLLMs
such as the proprietary GPT-4V, Gemini-Pro, and the open-sourced Mini-Gemini,
highlight the substantial challenges presented by Plot2Code. With Plot2Code, we
reveal that most existing MLLMs struggle with visual coding for text-dense
plots, heavily relying on textual instruction. We hope that the evaluation
results from Plot2Code on visual coding will guide the future development of
MLLMs. All data involved with Plot2Code are available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/TencentARC/Plot2Code.
|
[
-0.0326288119,
0.0753132403,
-0.0008636108,
0.0543038696,
-0.0298624411,
-0.0001230961,
0.0007820167,
0.0610362031,
-0.0053198487,
0.0160402674,
-0.0489912406,
0.0110454084,
0.0266936235,
0.0963895842,
0.0209189616,
-0.0470051467,
0.0045201452,
-0.0498763546,
-0.0083090616,
0.0036080615,
-0.0170106534,
0.0075076674,
0.0035229025,
0.039824415,
-0.0402709097,
-0.049867101,
0.0147540718,
0.0015190988,
0.0591773465,
-0.0297867004,
-0.0488548018,
0.0601388961,
0.0239852406,
0.0389376245,
0.0000022293,
-0.0368535593,
-0.0147911431,
0.039669726,
0.0415135734,
0.0716532767,
0.0664188564,
-0.0491307229,
-0.0257402845,
-0.0571037047,
-0.0142348791,
-0.0083943382,
0.0936812311,
-0.0204681288,
0.066649206,
0.0099872239,
0.0062873671,
-0.0158411022,
-0.0114752203,
0.0034924727,
0.0210504681,
0.009389637,
0.0081145987,
0.0368761905,
0.0408775136,
0.0342194363,
-0.0214539375,
0.0688362345,
0.0365865193,
-0.0510378331,
-0.0094096987,
0.0660223439,
0.0187870096,
-0.0158734359,
-0.0180842988,
0.07235533,
-0.041808892,
-0.0207218658,
-0.0119748451,
-0.0220734719,
-0.0372994356,
0.0075042276,
-0.0719011277,
0.0223678909,
0.0021197004,
-0.0153301507,
-0.0264341831,
-0.0232002363,
0.0109187141,
-0.0339275971,
-0.0094749937,
0.0091088619,
0.0242214352,
0.0006903109,
-0.0565694198,
0.0147992838,
-0.0410395861,
-0.0502035171,
0.0175747834,
0.0129135763,
0.0438516587,
-0.0130793015,
-0.04412774,
-0.0267949905,
0.0289101731,
-0.0204280671,
0.0713559985,
0.0084939636,
-0.0351337865,
0.0280204695,
-0.0300016012,
0.0508047268,
-0.0211918466,
-0.0104532568,
0.0341984481,
0.0257469676,
-0.0275462084,
0.0051072603,
-0.0148628633,
-0.0348173641,
-0.0217793677,
0.0197833236,
-0.0354941003,
0.0022128362,
0.0084030759,
0.0245335083,
-0.0030277413,
-0.0063800975,
-0.0247617513,
0.0293160826,
-0.001266524,
0.0298433434,
0.0068329261,
-0.0371559374,
-0.021096928,
-0.0494467318,
-0.0151587818,
0.0437250137,
0.000603641,
-0.0201374814,
-0.0140753286,
0.0807264373,
0.027582977,
0.0008312829,
0.0274844468,
-0.026067704,
-0.0311098378,
-0.0171233714,
0.0088951923,
-0.0568486042,
0.0089237737,
0.0161428098,
0.0309009645,
-0.0463815033,
0.0214672424,
0.0024360311,
0.0244890209,
0.0662666187,
-0.0582697652,
-0.0063461117,
0.0043317941,
0.0152371097,
-0.0308429189,
0.0219059344,
0.0579136945,
0.001301009,
-0.0105982134,
-0.0983281508,
0.0451754406,
0.0091697918,
0.0123154772,
0.0174676906,
-0.046816539,
0.0151028689,
0.0153018199,
0.0332818218,
0.0503389947,
0.0479012057,
-0.0450118817,
-0.0172490589,
0.0274378862,
0.0489566699,
0.0324358679,
0.0012944659,
0.0796917304,
0.0015451913,
0.0385715105,
-0.0373685136,
-0.0117205428,
0.0678627491,
0.0215094518,
0.0231199637,
-0.0164334979,
0.0407217592,
0.0174834561,
-0.0434073806,
-0.0131009994,
-0.0242038537,
0.0008994705,
-0.0524537005,
0.0169170666,
0.0010048196,
-0.0314941071,
-0.024690805,
0.0182325691,
-0.0997024775,
-0.024558302,
-0.0421636961,
0.0210161544,
0.0475227199,
0.0295824111,
0.0149674788,
0.0188397858,
-0.0096493643,
-0.0105080623,
0.036754787,
0.0463410579,
0.0145704634,
0.0318997651,
-0.0628354177,
-0.0238271076,
-0.0517632701,
-0.0231898129,
0.0636802837,
-0.0020535218,
-0.0073072226,
-0.0091902707,
-0.0160743725,
-0.0367440917,
0.0141162667,
-0.02270207,
0.0104300454,
-0.0310735162,
-0.0131492876,
0.0159526188,
-0.0270339884,
-0.0509279966,
0.019714836,
0.0608542897,
-0.0013200792,
0.0228768848,
-0.0073252926,
-0.0025043583,
-0.0342056118,
0.017956024,
-0.05044166,
-0.0504469387,
-0.0014734329,
0.0099521503,
-0.0081347181,
0.0006167267,
-0.0486222506,
0.0105237663,
-0.0088653173,
-0.0030025858,
-0.0400126949,
-0.0115955956,
-0.0245133098,
0.0218399446,
-0.0213211477,
0.0387809686,
0.0374445878,
0.0404835604,
0.0126418229,
0.0059681437,
-0.0225739609,
0.0303438082,
0.0338162556,
0.0033879168,
-0.0219301078,
0.0495154001,
0.0007492091,
-0.02775741,
-0.0722770542,
-0.0396490432,
0.0228071064,
-0.0277348347,
0.0261795279,
-0.0280289482,
-0.0095574306,
0.014067187,
0.012899721,
0.0322566368,
-0.0319530778,
-0.0141864438,
0.0462244712,
-0.0371498764,
-0.0498629846,
-0.0179703552,
-0.0187223852,
-0.0175783355,
0.0487096608,
0.0507138371,
0.011621437,
-0.0423952714,
0.0540641248,
0.001409489,
-0.0313690118,
-0.0038459715,
-0.0461876988,
0.0336467549,
-0.0294881668,
0.027898116,
0.0410450175,
-0.0253282376,
0.0073168594,
0.0497506857,
-0.027468551,
-0.0229030494,
0.0153344991,
0.0110534495,
0.0074615385,
0.03305462,
-0.0410277322,
0.0190574117,
0.0742908791,
-0.0028513719,
0.0316460691,
-0.051597856,
0.0068444819,
0.0031456477,
-0.0129929762,
-0.0037545054,
-0.0014913839,
0.0070189438,
0.0364762805,
-0.0098857814,
-0.1053321436,
0.0508058891,
-0.0720392615,
-0.0220239013,
-0.0223154239,
-0.0019841918,
-0.0372095257,
0.0319539309,
0.015884554,
0.0210056193,
0.0087287528,
-0.0243913922,
0.0151392519,
0.0172549263,
-0.0266672932,
-0.0491903238,
0.0469578542,
-0.0444541685,
0.0034556449,
-0.0213949494,
0.0048390799,
0.0155894794,
0.0262327865,
-0.0170638859,
-0.0403949097,
0.0306056086,
-0.0972773954,
0.0058977404,
0.029114373,
0.0233767964,
-0.023841992,
-0.0201945007,
-0.0241703466,
-0.0034209425,
-0.0161320772,
-0.0267399419,
-0.0046346621,
-0.0300371088,
-0.0443483703,
0.0118105132,
0.0355392061,
-0.0484412499,
0.0746005774,
-0.0651736856,
0.0369778126,
0.019246202,
0.0892122984,
-0.0312567204,
0.0310837645,
0.1036108509,
-0.0400841124,
0.0227821358,
0.0524099804,
0.006961369,
-0.0235882737,
-0.000893665,
-0.0164958313,
0.1022528782,
0.0176003631,
0.0068237977,
-0.0577545986,
-0.0135946982,
-0.0124503132,
0.0241127349,
0.0091420822,
-0.0034857159,
-0.0061099655,
-0.0786877796,
0.0944430605,
0.0466882363,
-0.0483584478,
-0.0419122688,
-0.0541371182,
-0.0231475253,
0.0089365374,
-0.0323035195,
0.010051786,
-0.0129298791,
0.0168970972,
0.0045839278,
-0.0071381945,
-0.037157733,
-0.0101666041,
0.0086631346,
-0.000693868,
0.0366384722,
0.0518335551,
-0.0159811582,
-0.0245339312,
0.0443112589,
0.0537563711,
0.0347158909,
-0.0319733284,
0.0572658703,
0.0627441183,
-0.0350250453,
-0.0040955823,
0.0084266607,
-0.0091474224,
-0.0317474008,
-0.0328652859,
0.0367458314,
-0.0105671287,
-0.0295807458,
-0.0547671951,
0.0139423143,
-0.0158027448,
0.0321511626,
0.0834924579,
0.0002645932,
-0.058614552,
-0.0961960927,
0.0429224931,
-0.0513166785,
-0.0602154396,
-0.0031329554,
-0.0001855737,
-0.0253660716,
0.0001885925,
0.0188396927,
0.0615171902,
0.0169322714,
0.0069694193,
-0.0272172894,
-0.0307041612,
-0.0320280977,
-0.0552062243,
0.0376603976,
-0.0270601846,
0.0404367819,
-0.0487142168,
-0.0224870089,
0.0183950495,
0.0217649955,
0.0012806944,
0.0445046611,
-0.0809128806,
-0.0315059982,
-0.0422393903,
0.0680028126,
0.0187726207,
-0.0173210781,
-0.0057868548,
-0.055753585,
0.0264321994,
0.0520992726,
0.0012930918,
0.0155827096,
-0.0195349623,
0.0089808358,
0.0066967583,
-0.0378556252,
-0.0015978606,
-0.0081866523,
-0.008563295,
0.0231916085,
0.0121668549,
0.0129555007,
0.0181114785,
0.0494643636,
0.0228820276,
-0.0109492866,
-0.039717935,
0.0107111828,
-0.0637417883,
-0.0296700131,
-0.0361570455,
-0.0580178164,
0.0069478038,
0.0420422219,
-0.0060652811,
0.017945135,
-0.0074050389,
-0.0018443412,
0.001745324,
-0.0489839651,
0.0753721222,
0.0277591329,
-0.016293399,
0.075217694,
0.0264836531,
-0.0045968378,
0.0061400789,
-0.0358618274,
0.026547078,
0.0155865848,
0.0213354249,
0.0056354096,
0.0001778407,
0.0441778377,
0.0413202122,
-0.0567067899,
-0.0511625074,
-0.0322483405,
0.0219033528,
0.0738271773,
0.0478415228,
0.067895025,
-0.0489427894,
0.0100381337,
-0.0406354405,
0.0498952493,
0.0136505486,
0.004666158,
0.0648362637,
0.0003843688,
-0.0296158884,
-0.0807425529,
0.0583500713,
0.0276806466,
0.0225536972,
-0.0200921893,
-0.0091003366,
-0.0307815801,
0.0202047694,
0.0082879011,
-0.0277612042,
0.0066307676,
-0.0201497208,
-0.0350969397,
-0.0738225505,
0.0295722708,
0.0531860702,
-0.0108274054,
-0.016236376,
0.040768344,
0.0112163043,
-0.0263052937,
-0.0020838934,
0.0158597045,
0.0242337231,
0.0400449671,
-0.0755025819,
-0.0218464844,
-5.52554748e-33,
-0.0257432293,
-0.039918635,
0.0123612881,
0.012020302,
0.0040851845,
0.010481379,
-0.035156507,
0.0067788037,
0.0263843685,
0.0084303664,
0.0683502778,
-0.0276466049,
-0.0295445751,
-0.0241727103,
-0.0169760883,
0.0227812175,
0.0196731072,
-0.0006927068,
-0.063682355,
0.0230061915,
0.0003000952,
0.0197376553,
-0.0036006987,
-0.0649109557,
-0.0482128188,
0.0313297808,
-0.0086414171,
-0.0489620566,
-0.0267058611,
0.0637041107,
-0.0128349885,
0.0288976654,
-0.0014094962,
0.0243306812,
-0.0573008209,
0.0345745608,
-0.0148300864,
-0.0346199013,
0.0025709381,
-0.0052071614,
-0.0415650159,
-0.0553585999,
0.0540640652,
-0.0142458268,
-0.0434799083,
-0.0405604839,
0.0227552895,
0.0139056351,
-0.0188537166,
0.012750851,
-0.0126608713,
0.0359866135,
-0.0247629005,
-0.0014747074,
0.0134626515,
0.027757816,
0.0136983981,
0.0744138733,
-0.0115981344,
0.0736952499,
0.0472437181,
0.0073574837,
0.0478963144,
-0.0120874261,
0.0386331156,
0.0560176745,
0.0629647002,
-0.0168767683,
-0.0167175364,
0.0137705328,
0.0298120305,
0.0650623962,
0.0561894178,
0.0168097261,
0.0126852319,
0.0053701,
-0.0118863722,
0.0289360043,
-0.0667822286,
-0.0061432426,
-0.0033918985,
0.029821191,
-0.0179802533,
-0.0307484362,
-0.0419740528,
-0.0015990679,
-0.0388184264,
-0.010827099,
0.0312278364,
-0.0634200275,
-0.0372884236,
0.0085639358,
0.012829165,
-0.0291965846,
-0.0299510416,
0.0012632227,
-0.058841303,
0.0861091018,
0.0128079941,
0.0152311297,
0.0041149026,
-0.0122320643,
0.037921425,
-0.0127968183,
0.079254508,
0.0103476103,
-0.0052384641,
0.0347968191,
-0.0473144539,
-0.0066442061,
-0.0184417684,
-0.0772063956,
0.033275418,
-0.0137175862,
0.0344522893,
-0.0424670689,
-0.0098010879,
-0.0017940028,
0.0083021699,
0.0046739643,
-0.0357335731,
-0.0356440544,
-0.0538294986,
0.0070293127,
-0.0338488445,
-0.0381861627,
-0.0610316284,
-0.0102164112,
0.042592749,
-0.0578569621,
-0.0658638403,
0.0170068908,
2.732e-7,
0.0573216639,
0.0548010357,
0.0275863409,
0.0172580909,
0.0177982897,
0.0214485992,
-0.0641673803,
-0.0086652832,
0.0076136012,
-0.029680891,
-0.052110713,
-0.0012525021,
0.0494162478,
0.0568942986,
0.018084038,
0.0274847616,
-0.0179462228,
-0.027259456,
-0.0642607659,
0.0235068519,
0.0707059205,
0.0252841245,
-0.0184322968,
-0.0219355132,
0.0450885147,
-0.0332501233,
0.0444221869,
-0.0619571134,
0.0126530761,
-0.00603174,
-0.1063353345,
-0.003765109,
-0.0013190112,
0.0116607761,
-0.0119183259,
-0.0532193184,
0.0414569303,
0.088755846,
-0.0247766133,
0.0667263567,
0.0662173629,
0.0101335151,
-0.0092493379,
-0.0594814681,
0.0293134954,
0.0088447602,
-0.0212521181,
-0.0235691536,
0.0173642393,
-0.0054056877,
0.0498669632,
-0.0579032078,
-0.0019703475,
0.014637392,
0.0116864927,
0.0117324218,
-0.0112803038,
0.0466616787,
-0.0409775823,
-0.0136046372,
-0.0344465114,
-0.0545052849,
-0.0790678859,
0.0057550771,
0.0286704972,
-0.0032697634,
-0.0338326581,
3.152095908e-34,
0.0369374305,
-0.0514919944,
0.0408439413,
0.0050681871,
0.0451755561,
-0.0090659577,
0.0062923944,
0.0108657321,
-0.0159979817,
-0.0287088007,
-0.0251461025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07960v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07960v3
|
AgentClinic: a multimodal agent benchmark to evaluate AI in simulated clinical environments
| 2024-05-13T17:38:53 | 2024-05-30T22:56:17 |
Samuel Schmidgall, Rojin Ziaei, Carl Harris, Eduardo Reis, Jeffrey Jopling, Michael Moor
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Diagnosing and managing a patient is a complex, sequential decision making
process that requires physicians to obtain information -- such as which tests
to perform -- and to act upon it. Recent advances in artificial intelligence
(AI) and large language models (LLMs) promise to profoundly impact clinical
care. However, current evaluation schemes overrely on static medical
question-answering benchmarks, falling short on interactive decision-making
that is required in real-life clinical work. Here, we present AgentClinic: a
multimodal benchmark to evaluate LLMs in their ability to operate as agents in
simulated clinical environments. In our benchmark, the doctor agent must
uncover the patient's diagnosis through dialogue and active data collection. We
present two open medical agent benchmarks: a multimodal image and dialogue
environment, AgentClinic-NEJM, and a dialogue-only environment,
AgentClinic-MedQA. We embed cognitive and implicit biases both in patient and
doctor agents to emulate realistic interactions between biased agents. We find
that introducing bias leads to large reductions in diagnostic accuracy of the
doctor agents, as well as reduced compliance, confidence, and follow-up
consultation willingness in patient agents. Evaluating a suite of
state-of-the-art LLMs, we find that several models that excel in benchmarks
like MedQA are performing poorly in AgentClinic-MedQA. We find that the LLM
used in the patient agent is an important factor for performance in the
AgentClinic benchmark. We show that both having limited interactions as well as
too many interaction reduces diagnostic accuracy in doctor agents. The code and
data for this work is publicly available at https://AgentClinic.github.io.
|
[
0.0409398116,
0.0419879258,
-0.0251117758,
0.0010610875,
-0.0303691197,
0.0061981524,
0.031721089,
0.0355582274,
0.0398702733,
-0.002050353,
-0.0265519246,
-0.033749707,
-0.0146675771,
0.0404450633,
0.0227435231,
-0.0636564568,
0.0272021592,
-0.0014653568,
0.0606998093,
0.0033943984,
-0.0000249793,
-0.0073021897,
-0.0777962729,
0.0629678667,
-0.0221365821,
-0.0131422756,
0.0097759366,
-0.0215645134,
0.014075866,
-0.0776852146,
-0.0309553463,
0.0234946813,
0.0024468387,
-0.004220956,
0.0000021892,
-0.0612811819,
0.0368873291,
-0.0061235284,
-0.0420277268,
-0.0525514185,
0.0469319001,
-0.0184123721,
0.0166794211,
0.0147281671,
-0.0576904155,
-0.0335460119,
0.0315135568,
0.045718234,
0.0575405397,
0.0594513826,
-0.0170699507,
0.0580826662,
0.0114977667,
0.00009941,
-0.0044829473,
-0.0852872804,
0.0174771901,
0.0166226011,
0.0486938842,
-0.0521202385,
-0.0066692014,
0.0322368182,
0.0027444167,
-0.0016923755,
-0.0197520591,
0.067992039,
-0.0108659919,
-0.0551813692,
-0.0301615801,
0.0839747563,
0.0335415527,
0.043603044,
0.0007263891,
-0.0099051557,
0.015242585,
0.013568718,
-0.0527738146,
0.005359896,
-0.0263761375,
-0.0256659482,
-0.0342339203,
0.0138158984,
0.0377270281,
0.0027104861,
0.0159340482,
0.0060281432,
0.0066965581,
-0.0009172845,
0.0407283157,
-0.015008877,
-0.0159729961,
-0.0604009852,
0.0089463927,
0.0539738089,
-0.1210669875,
-0.0016587441,
-0.0215419605,
0.0018807541,
0.0574486591,
-0.0480776951,
0.0273889042,
0.0259251576,
-0.0087885614,
0.0439855568,
0.0240876488,
0.030380521,
-0.0292490423,
0.0500258878,
-0.0195249878,
0.0272656828,
-0.0263679828,
-0.0114279343,
-0.0224117264,
-0.0049710111,
0.0040135118,
-0.0468192585,
-0.0389899872,
0.0010029632,
-0.0499652587,
0.0266867615,
-0.0117046684,
0.0554661453,
-0.004169431,
0.0489203744,
-0.072477527,
0.0095778424,
-0.0383496061,
0.0123815574,
0.0109548196,
-0.0478000529,
0.0163241476,
0.0028700843,
-0.0008784904,
-0.0135095771,
0.0179476459,
0.0988028497,
-0.0145180849,
-0.0100683384,
0.0221819282,
-0.028335534,
-0.0097470786,
-0.0488327146,
0.0103774257,
-0.027209362,
0.0551967099,
0.0104280394,
-0.0045922562,
-0.0544833913,
0.0244677979,
0.0047230935,
-0.0263398811,
0.0842851177,
-0.0092438385,
0.0159213468,
0.0453654639,
0.0473216474,
-0.0323925689,
0.0158313736,
0.0240427833,
-0.0215447675,
0.0222002119,
-0.0374940373,
0.0557745099,
0.0157067683,
0.0159071907,
-0.0161133856,
0.0229235254,
0.0120522631,
-0.0050473656,
0.1201798245,
-0.0244160853,
0.0792097375,
-0.0202831067,
-0.0193288438,
0.0529297478,
0.0523465425,
-0.0254070889,
-0.0475986227,
0.0211878978,
-0.0285268128,
0.0088831484,
-0.0054147043,
-0.0203407668,
0.0426827557,
0.0280242879,
-0.0248000938,
-0.0015115762,
-0.011790243,
-0.0291156862,
-0.0388439447,
-0.0439386927,
-0.0016195714,
0.0081982687,
0.0045708567,
0.0069272746,
-0.024485115,
-0.0444302075,
0.0190182831,
0.0322022289,
-0.011315465,
-0.0586079173,
-0.0907097906,
0.0173600093,
0.0948783457,
0.0451716445,
-0.0294603407,
-0.045693472,
-0.0074904864,
0.0131880958,
0.0284220446,
0.0633921474,
-0.0227693766,
0.0352692492,
-0.0307969991,
-0.0141218249,
0.0081043495,
0.0154971238,
-0.009961403,
-0.0169055387,
0.0193951689,
-0.0551852733,
-0.0183050875,
0.0129964547,
0.0458136275,
-0.0463969,
-0.0191871524,
-0.019370798,
-0.0041804486,
0.0533927418,
-0.0010504767,
-0.0316595174,
0.0181644112,
0.0195792746,
-0.0136235803,
-0.0191754196,
0.0415306576,
-0.0401544236,
-0.0252006762,
0.0013982935,
-0.0440849848,
-0.0198272076,
-0.0029021329,
-0.0275419541,
-0.0113195861,
-0.0222268458,
-0.0585497655,
0.011338314,
0.0102988156,
0.0149427578,
0.0372661017,
0.0166026149,
-0.0197246,
0.0160464142,
-0.0372310914,
-0.0223723296,
0.0346766673,
0.0247026812,
-0.0110400114,
-0.0426349789,
0.0066140834,
0.0244209208,
0.0239553098,
0.0093836421,
-0.0078740204,
0.0075052571,
-0.0398386307,
-0.0211714022,
-0.1371410191,
-0.0356710777,
0.0288340561,
-0.0507073924,
-0.0037385731,
0.0137256365,
-0.0125729442,
-0.0104005793,
-0.0294737704,
0.0485533997,
0.0522061512,
0.0376276188,
0.0350624807,
0.0498338901,
-0.0242819693,
-0.0486445688,
0.0177627616,
-0.0367533453,
0.0425397456,
0.0128057394,
0.0263615064,
0.0092848893,
-0.0357613601,
-0.0571377613,
0.0318690278,
-0.0257610641,
-0.0248756129,
0.0513626039,
-0.035530746,
-0.0187966712,
0.0751171708,
-0.0050081066,
0.037500523,
0.0419770703,
-0.0103339301,
-0.0426533297,
0.0368444249,
-0.0068803155,
-0.0210805032,
-0.0031903472,
-0.059628047,
-0.0069429381,
0.0744566917,
0.0218791794,
0.0520617068,
-0.0218307991,
0.044483304,
-0.0019672837,
-0.0359804966,
-0.0315877572,
0.0113850618,
-0.0330631025,
0.0565565303,
-0.015489677,
-0.0336506888,
0.1009793878,
0.0003129981,
0.0168479756,
-0.0369760841,
-0.0041554905,
-0.0324676745,
0.041026365,
0.0115761142,
0.0266823992,
0.0095522152,
0.0184485745,
-0.020732047,
-0.0197918583,
-0.0015512499,
-0.0554507002,
0.0213922895,
-0.0435550809,
0.0180840697,
-0.0006331801,
-0.0469017625,
-0.0417297333,
-0.0285108406,
-0.0343928672,
-0.0175451282,
-0.0035231258,
0.0100146821,
-0.0549158044,
0.0152872801,
0.0107503217,
0.0479465984,
0.0302719045,
-0.0277247149,
0.0019247123,
-0.0012353149,
0.0380944721,
0.0655004457,
0.0006754994,
-0.0368706696,
0.0688492358,
0.052397918,
0.0111249881,
0.0075470312,
-0.044925943,
-0.0003173739,
-0.0363958329,
0.0107548386,
0.0136927664,
0.0512991957,
0.0173988212,
-0.0406675488,
0.0072111804,
0.094514139,
0.0192961022,
-0.0703017786,
0.0188033376,
-0.0350277796,
-0.0197708867,
-0.007606898,
-0.0019718269,
-0.0587985069,
-0.0516519174,
-0.0029552642,
0.0139967147,
-0.0407775119,
-0.0437677875,
0.0340813845,
-0.0620542169,
0.0463139862,
-0.0347717404,
-0.0017227412,
0.0064262641,
-0.0365482531,
0.0126456581,
-0.0140567487,
0.022000134,
-0.017141182,
0.0292050857,
-0.0222303551,
-0.0206322148,
-0.0318346694,
-0.0443776026,
0.0580025613,
-0.0179859158,
0.0497153997,
0.0649921075,
0.0558855906,
-0.0270747654,
-0.034935534,
-0.0055822325,
0.0557411127,
0.0415562131,
-0.0086503886,
0.0880957544,
0.0070860297,
0.0148035903,
-0.0411384329,
0.0249430295,
-0.0119701717,
0.0001914727,
0.0218301397,
0.0778262243,
-0.0478291661,
-0.0379049741,
-0.0709428117,
0.0533837155,
0.0424928553,
0.0415732376,
-0.0001629004,
-0.0378821865,
-0.0509205721,
0.0279308669,
0.0380749144,
0.0106920525,
-0.0136189051,
0.0216703061,
-0.0019802493,
-0.0001559337,
-0.0612076931,
-0.052279938,
0.0363519751,
0.0035293095,
0.0079207709,
-0.0228383411,
-0.0067260731,
0.034082599,
-0.0272938982,
0.0424816571,
0.0459265187,
0.0418960117,
-0.0158115104,
-0.0084880544,
0.0318302177,
-0.026141189,
0.0203256011,
0.0291844737,
-0.0235798638,
-0.0007906839,
0.0042613591,
0.0841672122,
0.0204263404,
-0.0018087553,
0.0014747253,
-0.031591773,
0.0045292028,
-0.0082711186,
-0.052391842,
0.0233055875,
-0.0014175243,
0.0124619137,
-0.0247411784,
0.0124543365,
-0.0283369757,
0.0137708401,
-0.0210383441,
0.0322195664,
-0.0432253256,
-0.0473861992,
0.0256690923,
0.0120448107,
0.0138537018,
-0.0144279758,
-0.0090699019,
-0.0076974388,
0.008376413,
-0.0151998606,
0.0069085802,
-0.0157699808,
-0.0183418095,
-0.004245928,
-0.0015137226,
0.0222921688,
-0.006213794,
-0.0505792871,
-0.0484565571,
-0.0159962159,
0.0220192857,
0.0589838997,
-0.0187862795,
0.0238551851,
-0.0055805021,
0.0071499529,
0.0325754471,
-0.0076146042,
0.0415378585,
0.0233625378,
0.1184400916,
-0.0000222542,
-0.0067595923,
-0.0146100316,
0.0503282361,
-0.0394637212,
-0.06407547,
0.0274595991,
0.0628518239,
0.0414000228,
0.0284514818,
0.0029155293,
-0.0317812227,
0.0212253202,
-0.006876491,
-0.0058895438,
-0.000963873,
-0.0138940234,
0.0639606565,
0.0131380074,
0.0243537854,
0.0113684544,
0.0612963848,
-0.0250915065,
0.0500001237,
-0.0307010002,
-0.0277881939,
-0.0641884804,
-0.0221508816,
0.0332485251,
0.0308187678,
-0.0265639853,
-0.0004545038,
-0.0623104386,
-0.0324314609,
-0.0046320218,
0.0084283473,
-0.0412166901,
-0.069094561,
0.0511350334,
0.0455058254,
0.0303848367,
-0.0217668824,
-0.0097033922,
0.0467958301,
-0.0620971434,
0.0080186324,
-0.0276981499,
-5.797445568e-33,
-0.0143220378,
-0.0294685494,
0.0472510532,
-0.0346898772,
-0.0107651446,
0.029638622,
-0.0710602626,
0.0121976705,
-0.0157894325,
0.0410329998,
-0.0264493749,
-0.0010697236,
-0.0067782877,
0.0101973172,
-0.0141975461,
-0.0368932113,
0.0216881912,
-0.0093574971,
-0.0566320494,
0.0158464983,
-0.031829305,
-0.0012366786,
-0.0274725705,
-0.0917824581,
-0.0148783559,
0.0004540041,
-0.0031170163,
0.0089642722,
-0.0486497097,
0.0616994537,
-0.0383565389,
0.0287538636,
0.0426613651,
0.0125836097,
0.0027280312,
0.0134003554,
-0.033916872,
-0.0221056268,
-0.0053297393,
0.0031695554,
-0.0816996172,
-0.0108923148,
0.025280809,
-0.002361849,
-0.039829243,
0.004142046,
0.0212915465,
-0.0234777164,
0.0039615519,
0.0086280266,
-0.04358197,
0.0291795582,
-0.0248382334,
-0.0324188471,
-0.027586095,
0.0245907493,
-0.0417121165,
0.0076591759,
-0.038135238,
-0.0021018353,
0.0128970351,
-0.0449697599,
0.0302429609,
-0.0065095383,
-0.0122773368,
0.0824437663,
0.0783922747,
-0.0048330901,
-0.0561068207,
-0.0063641802,
-0.0395994484,
0.0554494224,
0.0562752225,
0.0761798918,
-0.0200666972,
-0.0073889336,
-0.0548204035,
0.0557307974,
-0.0172122717,
0.0466388837,
0.0538821742,
-0.0015284083,
-0.0655651465,
-0.0105390819,
-0.0362984464,
0.0157413762,
-0.0409329422,
-0.0398943275,
0.0515145175,
0.0043877615,
0.0284382459,
-0.0314674005,
0.0297768302,
-0.0020966693,
0.0368131623,
-0.0457639806,
0.0377838165,
0.0361160152,
-0.0334865376,
-0.0009076768,
-0.0348516442,
-0.0156521592,
0.0247602798,
0.0017353739,
0.0633656159,
0.0312816799,
-0.0216917302,
-0.0200871881,
-0.0135685448,
-0.0121728927,
0.0122294752,
0.0128449658,
-0.0061234715,
0.0239927545,
0.0340238214,
-0.0009548216,
-0.0353233293,
0.0297132842,
-0.0174099058,
-0.0194507763,
-0.0498890318,
-0.0694429874,
-0.0089362506,
-0.0198590253,
-0.0745470896,
0.0032037494,
-0.0778902471,
-0.0017544044,
0.0127267474,
-0.0842392668,
-0.0151880104,
0.0255124066,
2.892e-7,
0.0291512366,
0.0448460355,
-0.0000754814,
0.0097203413,
0.0502537861,
0.0453898311,
-0.0317289121,
0.025618501,
-0.0012254348,
-0.0594029538,
0.0255180411,
0.0359473936,
0.0189566202,
0.0456375815,
-0.0119912289,
-0.0354524031,
-0.0537675098,
-0.0172633789,
-0.0355813541,
-0.033824563,
0.0411592349,
0.046008788,
-0.0371326581,
-0.0475793518,
0.0337712467,
-0.0271568466,
0.0467231832,
-0.0305142291,
0.0039037396,
0.0272759963,
0.0042137336,
-0.0109190801,
0.0191480424,
0.0750294551,
-0.0028101041,
-0.0348478109,
-0.0052252421,
0.0962023512,
-0.0721066967,
-0.0350125022,
0.0073614339,
0.0035530732,
0.0226419549,
-0.0190501884,
0.0579552129,
-0.0426339135,
-0.0597426631,
-0.0274134409,
-0.0131905731,
-0.0243494287,
0.070941709,
-0.0442170836,
-0.0445541218,
0.0257619545,
0.0106632514,
0.0310318265,
-0.0194573235,
-0.0622843094,
-0.0184581876,
-0.0001223278,
-0.0435685329,
-0.0648943707,
0.025487056,
-0.0236168616,
0.00191407,
-0.0837984309,
-0.0106712207,
2.346108563e-34,
0.0386335254,
0.025478946,
0.0140981236,
0.0378054902,
0.042925939,
0.0020420493,
0.0158708859,
0.0196084157,
0.0633726045,
-0.0563400164,
-0.0050789919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07940v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07940v2
|
RAID: A Shared Benchmark for Robust Evaluation of Machine-Generated Text Detectors
| 2024-05-13T17:15:14 | 2024-06-10T15:51:16 |
Liam Dugan, Alyssa Hwang, Filip Trhlik, Josh Magnus Ludan, Andrew Zhu, Hainiu Xu, Daphne Ippolito, Chris Callison-Burch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Many commercial and open-source models claim to detect machine-generated text
with extremely high accuracy (99% or more). However, very few of these
detectors are evaluated on shared benchmark datasets and even when they are,
the datasets used for evaluation are insufficiently challenging-lacking
variations in sampling strategy, adversarial attacks, and open-source
generative models. In this work we present RAID: the largest and most
challenging benchmark dataset for machine-generated text detection. RAID
includes over 6 million generations spanning 11 models, 8 domains, 11
adversarial attacks and 4 decoding strategies. Using RAID, we evaluate the
out-of-domain and adversarial robustness of 8 open- and 4 closed-source
detectors and find that current detectors are easily fooled by adversarial
attacks, variations in sampling strategies, repetition penalties, and unseen
generative models. We release our data along with a leaderboard to encourage
future research.
|
[
0.0126381386,
0.0814174265,
-0.0017748309,
0.0862005875,
-0.0335560217,
0.0181196611,
0.0132140545,
0.0386344753,
-0.0002497034,
-0.000446356,
-0.0083959959,
-0.003303186,
-0.0083770445,
0.0688663572,
0.007603541,
0.0038484898,
0.0235843249,
0.0013237288,
-0.0319702327,
0.0259207003,
0.0049821478,
0.0040859561,
-0.0150444955,
0.0226918403,
-0.0141652673,
-0.0155191338,
0.0023477115,
0.0380792171,
0.0558021665,
-0.0527111925,
0.0081881182,
0.0442889817,
0.0010635189,
0.1451755911,
0.0000017895,
-0.0034160614,
-0.0255456958,
-0.0038871611,
-0.0296811778,
0.0190416873,
0.0830755904,
-0.0580774657,
-0.0656009614,
0.0094736135,
-0.0072268941,
-0.0129609844,
0.0455003791,
0.0494378693,
0.0255958214,
0.0794370025,
-0.0239206851,
-0.0166906677,
0.0602949522,
-0.0424228758,
-0.0558060892,
-0.0469069444,
0.0148658287,
-0.0250514615,
-0.0298827235,
0.0098637883,
-0.0028912532,
0.0290183183,
0.0472776555,
-0.0163207278,
-0.031966947,
0.039525602,
-0.0112371501,
0.0030878305,
-0.0133690462,
0.0507870764,
-0.0462630577,
-0.0121544935,
-0.0090358872,
-0.0351653434,
0.0005714349,
0.0077521913,
0.0136781232,
0.0253267325,
-0.0213254653,
0.0268028006,
-0.0564884543,
0.0287736561,
0.0231130142,
0.0281295553,
0.0196756106,
-0.0081423512,
0.0245240759,
-0.0242233239,
-0.0128433211,
0.0306387655,
-0.0201724079,
-0.0243430659,
0.0418429002,
-0.0172056668,
0.023300346,
-0.0049483581,
-0.1085445955,
-0.0912127867,
0.019881228,
-0.0151064787,
0.0399735384,
-0.0205808692,
-0.0593821779,
0.0356027968,
-0.0637733415,
0.0463123955,
-0.059932474,
0.0079127783,
-0.0070140488,
0.0129000442,
0.0072397157,
0.0007631122,
0.003903762,
-0.0395022854,
-0.0249267742,
-0.0300783888,
-0.0236226786,
0.0160551611,
0.02014862,
-0.0019236789,
-0.0465093628,
0.015912924,
-0.0548007265,
-0.0230131969,
0.0314160287,
-0.0119221248,
-0.0178109389,
-0.0064157993,
0.0199515801,
-0.1030463725,
-0.0525193773,
0.0650338605,
0.0005654902,
-0.0077181743,
-0.0094964663,
0.0833376125,
-0.0381035134,
-0.0497004688,
-0.0305966903,
-0.0203834344,
-0.0431361981,
-0.0384030305,
0.0413304418,
-0.0421673618,
-0.0280584395,
-0.0264235642,
-0.0069882153,
-0.0473837107,
-0.0013834697,
0.01732965,
0.017836336,
0.049620185,
-0.0066808071,
-0.0703046173,
0.0102005256,
0.0139463069,
-0.0015536837,
0.0650670603,
0.0065635634,
0.1016065851,
0.0193895288,
0.0394843891,
0.0393656455,
0.0610664636,
0.010515295,
0.0485230535,
0.0103171691,
-0.0114025073,
-0.0051524537,
0.0271989591,
0.0314228646,
0.0340505019,
-0.0144626293,
-0.0774762109,
0.0871331766,
0.0284490343,
-0.0106085399,
0.0126233716,
0.0213984009,
0.0119991461,
0.0093406299,
0.0026099118,
-0.0125475312,
-0.0113549232,
-0.0374065414,
-0.0313261934,
-0.0137348417,
0.0467163436,
0.0007938709,
-0.0169718377,
-0.0101547353,
-0.0220572669,
-0.0176628735,
-0.0479925424,
0.0666953921,
0.0254764967,
-0.0519833639,
-0.0319266617,
-0.013424553,
-0.0247484967,
-0.0206179619,
-0.0585982203,
0.0436713435,
0.0149630774,
0.0659868121,
-0.0035708135,
0.0457957014,
-0.0247976016,
0.0297454055,
0.0672598928,
-0.0106996577,
0.0319607407,
0.0348109417,
-0.0600687712,
-0.034662541,
-0.0147000374,
0.0137811927,
0.0510399491,
0.0479932651,
0.0267659388,
0.0110449828,
-0.0118408371,
0.0147425625,
0.0604736656,
-0.0122838067,
-0.0237724148,
0.0151952598,
-0.0012718581,
0.0419591591,
-0.0025158662,
-0.0517806672,
0.0061711147,
0.0336785354,
-0.048458837,
-0.013219065,
-0.0176192801,
-0.019260725,
-0.0437354892,
-0.0338656232,
-0.0571475886,
-0.0297041032,
0.0691347942,
-0.060962677,
0.0224208497,
0.0232994966,
-0.0437097773,
-0.0428108014,
-0.0656242073,
-0.0247894805,
-0.0124990745,
0.0558952987,
-0.0015700825,
0.0709234104,
-0.0478217155,
-0.0361303687,
-0.0083481381,
0.0329968594,
0.0423408076,
-0.0322977491,
0.0024752666,
-0.0041499459,
-0.0341226347,
0.0047809733,
-0.0130721861,
0.0213492848,
-0.0197148994,
-0.0086003616,
-0.0053386204,
-0.0024062432,
-0.0414485484,
0.0017195898,
0.0349863581,
-0.0280115735,
-0.0026605283,
-0.0264222156,
-0.0067177275,
0.0080150077,
0.0241858065,
-0.003390224,
0.0134560484,
-0.0344072841,
0.0277035963,
0.0031046092,
-0.0253839176,
0.0212107468,
0.056106098,
0.0272443872,
-0.0351694375,
-0.028630171,
0.0105997398,
0.0138800209,
0.0271983035,
-0.0305094179,
-0.0316391252,
0.0251524057,
0.0108629549,
0.0092615103,
0.089129515,
0.0332003534,
0.0149098299,
-0.0041024317,
0.0646790788,
0.0203985851,
-0.0108838398,
0.0115778707,
0.0263885688,
-0.0193423592,
-0.0067239916,
0.0436156988,
0.0507292226,
0.0137265278,
0.0080803381,
-0.0137078343,
0.0289357658,
-0.0209235623,
-0.0474755466,
-0.0147099225,
0.0039878399,
-0.036126364,
0.0166504867,
-0.0593990944,
-0.0863595158,
0.0340398364,
-0.0209313054,
-0.0038833567,
-0.0144002484,
-0.0284926854,
0.0075986693,
0.0454534665,
0.0199538898,
0.0167765114,
0.039962776,
-0.0033267178,
-0.017335441,
0.0106138811,
0.033827804,
-0.016444739,
0.013765024,
-0.0048806416,
0.0168856401,
-0.0090225134,
-0.0320474692,
-0.079971604,
-0.0281250831,
-0.015309128,
-0.0064848019,
0.0380814523,
-0.0323933624,
-0.0579291172,
-0.0263006929,
-0.0112987822,
0.0460293405,
-0.0120148947,
-0.0021884339,
-0.0265400056,
0.1021757871,
0.0359112807,
-0.044641193,
0.0426987559,
-0.0519797392,
-0.0113387881,
0.0849626586,
-0.0194598585,
0.0226496439,
-0.0308016203,
-0.0008960608,
0.0064187245,
0.0522419438,
0.0176378563,
0.0106913047,
0.0405855849,
-0.0272577014,
-0.0158225317,
0.0317154527,
-0.0096231839,
-0.0131068463,
0.0069800378,
0.0266304146,
0.0194891132,
-0.0064162514,
-0.0348376445,
-0.093920894,
-0.0374144539,
0.0136462841,
0.0185912009,
-0.0109312572,
0.001283896,
-0.007414035,
-0.1001328677,
0.0424245782,
0.0145511981,
-0.0242452603,
-0.0326398462,
0.0245154724,
0.0005595415,
-0.0279527269,
-0.0070959325,
-0.0125609962,
0.0424002111,
-0.0128795765,
-0.0093362955,
0.0303358454,
-0.0592785701,
-0.0195716862,
-0.0366088636,
-0.0035290953,
0.0971023142,
0.0324186534,
0.0107092038,
-0.0409687534,
0.0270180851,
-0.017492231,
-0.012463565,
0.0136149274,
0.0887140036,
0.0073560849,
-0.006508762,
-0.0229966715,
0.0491189398,
-0.0258200504,
-0.0064548943,
0.019467596,
-0.0070576109,
0.0126801776,
-0.053106457,
-0.0440245792,
-0.0081162425,
0.0166638251,
0.0530956499,
0.0081513869,
-0.0267273746,
-0.0474655144,
-0.0451750606,
0.0478320345,
-0.1114388034,
-0.0283757262,
-0.0002650364,
0.0157361366,
-0.0344263539,
-0.0581355095,
-0.0065442994,
-0.0351751819,
0.0280913524,
-0.020833971,
-0.0391177945,
-0.0393742062,
-0.0025091148,
-0.0456699319,
-0.0168452542,
-0.024850741,
0.0328790508,
-0.0481610745,
0.0052655227,
-0.0034047484,
-0.0455378555,
-0.0351789445,
0.0850466117,
-0.1111220717,
-0.0160946753,
0.0136986598,
0.0277082231,
0.0164382569,
-0.0036416471,
-0.0481759608,
-0.0384579897,
0.0972164497,
0.0346535742,
-0.0095762778,
-0.0031493108,
0.0358796269,
-0.0373082757,
-0.0298486091,
0.0228779446,
-0.0187463239,
0.0505192578,
0.0449421518,
-0.0571898594,
-0.0080509465,
0.008382489,
-0.0039892797,
-0.0261451229,
0.0520587787,
-0.0348121598,
-0.0190372523,
-0.0031047903,
0.0024454358,
-0.0072876117,
0.0028422922,
-0.0593524799,
0.0272902884,
0.0563532859,
0.0000814342,
-0.0118417172,
0.0571773611,
0.0267213657,
0.0612251051,
-0.0283191465,
0.0008146158,
0.0338401906,
0.0748112425,
0.0418597385,
0.0058056298,
-0.0002101841,
0.0318372659,
-0.014662751,
0.0178191271,
-0.0049619335,
0.0321754664,
0.021157885,
0.0051616458,
0.0258878451,
0.0290341899,
-0.0543245599,
0.0252200048,
-0.076400198,
0.0296747182,
0.0574160293,
0.0204470679,
0.0215252955,
-0.0347976759,
-0.0129035367,
-0.0427787863,
-0.0021868029,
0.0137250274,
-0.0375235714,
-0.0085550938,
-0.0069887475,
-0.0064679198,
0.0011081189,
0.0692929551,
0.0216217618,
0.0625617802,
0.0042680362,
-0.0142909335,
-0.0589281656,
-0.0149525153,
-0.002694136,
-0.023024546,
-0.0043649748,
0.0205948651,
-0.0195461735,
-0.0446609035,
0.0225810632,
-0.0099062258,
0.0221052431,
0.0250986032,
-0.0151152276,
0.0390233137,
-0.0082108444,
-0.003123967,
-0.0078520393,
0.0271330439,
-0.0263966601,
-0.0203909427,
-0.0067163012,
-5.782684298e-33,
0.0136030251,
-0.0280744862,
-0.0421659686,
-0.0918569937,
0.0082273874,
0.0299539901,
-0.0282775871,
-0.0306540933,
0.0053173047,
-0.0036356205,
0.0002013754,
0.0208777897,
0.0093135992,
0.0515710339,
-0.041482091,
-0.0299323872,
0.0621358305,
-0.0502456985,
-0.0478316918,
0.0028246155,
0.0266229827,
0.0328082703,
0.0226890333,
-0.0478702337,
0.0081968997,
-0.0201112479,
-0.059022408,
-0.0107194893,
-0.0404991992,
0.0599770769,
-0.0023414481,
0.0163513329,
0.0199447498,
-0.0067312536,
-0.0290675927,
0.0151148811,
-0.0399766527,
0.0218314789,
-0.0595738254,
0.0296383146,
-0.0497543067,
-0.0451012067,
0.014924176,
-0.0203243084,
-0.0095487097,
-0.022826843,
0.0165673383,
-0.0354528986,
-0.0043824068,
-0.0478585958,
-0.0469006859,
0.0389788449,
0.0049401433,
-0.0222984478,
0.008187091,
0.0293160379,
0.0505161807,
0.0271657072,
-0.0505885817,
0.0008791018,
0.0151369488,
0.015544069,
0.0363491513,
0.0294783767,
-0.0165680405,
0.0646409839,
0.0344497673,
0.0085324384,
-0.0325288847,
-0.0139645981,
0.0164993946,
0.0301243812,
0.0856921598,
0.0960931703,
0.0673458129,
-0.0088774255,
-0.0732591972,
0.0297286175,
0.0026825822,
-0.0164672025,
0.0177672021,
0.0285850205,
-0.0191130638,
0.031502936,
0.0077085276,
-0.0682658106,
-0.0143138617,
-0.0072868075,
0.0384609103,
0.0493541174,
-0.0573484786,
0.0119823748,
0.0154807055,
-0.0420015529,
0.010552601,
0.0283074267,
-0.0255962238,
0.0027352383,
0.0152649367,
0.0281261988,
-0.0248686504,
0.0028922514,
0.0722769871,
0.0089895427,
-0.0011394967,
-0.0410369746,
0.0682305843,
0.0191338081,
-0.0558692813,
0.0209182985,
-0.0463935509,
0.0636784881,
0.0473056436,
0.0354305692,
0.0265445225,
-0.0476739183,
-0.0102485828,
-0.0164832603,
0.0082298927,
0.0126399854,
-0.0278250091,
0.0215810202,
-0.0272315592,
0.0134365978,
-0.0120674549,
0.0044172723,
-0.0220814385,
-0.00283562,
0.0428772457,
-0.0594109148,
0.0129625155,
-0.0107708555,
2.31e-7,
0.024095498,
0.0241844431,
0.0557004176,
-0.0002850584,
0.0313675143,
0.034839008,
-0.0239249617,
0.0297328103,
-0.0528697371,
0.0230906866,
-0.0382370129,
0.0092428895,
0.0912262648,
0.0246247966,
-0.0515580066,
0.06088515,
-0.0621996708,
0.041460488,
-0.0374844857,
-0.0195477661,
0.0585372709,
0.0845136195,
-0.0126696341,
-0.0261915512,
0.0638106763,
-0.0753184855,
0.0507012084,
-0.0099427477,
0.0414238982,
-0.03912187,
0.023534866,
0.0224113595,
0.0012765271,
-0.019496616,
-0.0180549938,
-0.0286426526,
0.0358638987,
0.048244752,
0.0411115363,
-0.0179336723,
-0.0091440501,
0.0089595644,
0.0091253035,
-0.0008510216,
0.0616818219,
0.0034817921,
-0.0140064182,
-0.0211762842,
-0.0184786115,
-0.0392853245,
0.0397643857,
-0.0342496596,
-0.0145366238,
0.0178801194,
0.0099710505,
0.0125079872,
-0.015656665,
-0.0243541598,
-0.0186416972,
-0.0530129373,
-0.0632942617,
-0.023465829,
-0.0861849412,
0.033253517,
0.0567072406,
-0.0126086166,
0.0047393367,
1.796038737e-34,
0.0110875703,
-0.032479357,
-0.021162333,
-0.0190965142,
0.008930997,
-0.0202369541,
0.0487195067,
-0.0237760823,
-0.0242929514,
-0.0158653874,
0.0059695942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07938v1
|
EconLogicQA: A Question-Answering Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models in Economic Sequential Reasoning
| 2024-05-13T17:13:47 | 2024-05-13T17:13:47 |
Yinzhu Quan, Zefang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce EconLogicQA, a rigorous benchmark designed to
assess the sequential reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs)
within the intricate realms of economics, business, and supply chain
management. Diverging from traditional benchmarks that predict subsequent
events individually, EconLogicQA poses a more challenging task: it requires
models to discern and sequence multiple interconnected events, capturing the
complexity of economic logics. EconLogicQA comprises an array of multi-event
scenarios derived from economic articles, which necessitate an insightful
understanding of both temporal and logical event relationships. Through
comprehensive evaluations, we exhibit that EconLogicQA effectively gauges a
LLM's proficiency in navigating the sequential complexities inherent in
economic contexts. We provide a detailed description of EconLogicQA dataset and
shows the outcomes from evaluating the benchmark across various leading-edge
LLMs, thereby offering a thorough perspective on their sequential reasoning
potential in economic contexts. Our benchmark dataset is available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/yinzhu-quan/econ_logic_qa.
|
[
0.0109677473,
0.1216433421,
-0.0018334722,
0.0499477722,
-0.0505250469,
0.0093350345,
0.0120366188,
-0.0113746449,
0.0183451753,
-0.0251498614,
0.0236371271,
-0.0075818966,
-0.0453027487,
0.0509638675,
-0.0004845262,
-0.0232610051,
0.034919668,
-0.0221045259,
0.0363818519,
-0.0332630724,
0.0001536051,
0.0132236648,
-0.0374511145,
0.0211635176,
0.0217751525,
-0.0416428,
-0.0382936485,
-0.0301530808,
0.0269017443,
-0.0417246148,
-0.0117632905,
0.0449480787,
0.0210858714,
0.0164890438,
0.0000020566,
-0.0957151353,
-0.0315726399,
-0.0305239819,
-0.0356819183,
0.0139767332,
-0.0329653285,
-0.0050794189,
0.0424180701,
0.0158745013,
-0.0638319105,
0.0026330377,
0.0181275494,
0.0616371147,
0.0447480902,
0.0546530001,
0.0022885986,
-0.0457555465,
0.0152372411,
-0.0463254564,
-0.0403523929,
-0.0968651325,
0.0339578278,
-0.0071086325,
0.0118580302,
-0.0184423141,
-0.0040834821,
0.0173871014,
0.036268454,
0.010841486,
-0.0535795577,
0.0502596535,
-0.0138249081,
0.0298013557,
-0.0305332448,
0.0601041131,
0.0546533428,
0.0203662068,
0.0134976264,
-0.0077379737,
0.0141745852,
-0.0122255776,
-0.0538464636,
0.0246399362,
-0.0024484997,
0.0246825404,
0.0537796058,
0.0382026769,
0.0233210064,
0.036407087,
-0.0565780699,
0.1329468638,
-0.032117404,
-0.0378222167,
0.0030463489,
-0.0030831564,
-0.0253617186,
-0.0485597067,
0.0023492093,
0.0671473667,
-0.0569628626,
0.012391272,
0.0156580098,
0.0458736941,
-0.0308186859,
-0.0368747786,
0.0086867586,
0.0500054844,
0.0338433459,
0.0602834038,
0.0096598491,
0.0540061258,
-0.0284049511,
-0.0235856082,
-0.0204981212,
0.0270859394,
-0.0334410183,
-0.0298278145,
-0.0373005457,
0.0301337074,
-0.0190944448,
-0.022385465,
-0.0312335491,
-0.017860854,
-0.0508579947,
0.017999813,
0.0069114058,
0.0267548803,
-0.0133149484,
-0.0479032472,
-0.0960203037,
0.004556864,
-0.0457873568,
0.0437681042,
0.0014666318,
-0.0039884662,
-0.0074528726,
-0.0088240867,
-0.0197667722,
-0.0170053765,
0.0039365184,
0.1040209979,
0.0028744217,
0.0314699188,
-0.062914446,
-0.0387986004,
0.0211475715,
-0.0569192171,
-0.0250915773,
-0.0649039447,
0.0236704405,
-0.0026140225,
-0.0215084162,
-0.0169875026,
0.0194772705,
-0.0033235361,
-0.0146053918,
0.0405096151,
0.0263705123,
-0.0035245204,
-0.0396621488,
0.0010259406,
0.0401225761,
0.0650433376,
0.033151634,
0.0246748757,
0.0330720842,
0.016286429,
-0.0299475398,
0.0547613613,
-0.0220976882,
-0.0216583759,
-0.0330144949,
0.0437088832,
-0.0320021026,
0.0151997674,
0.0364965312,
0.0042663631,
-0.022539787,
-0.0262611918,
0.0180389732,
0.0059457342,
0.0056319032,
-0.0289734118,
0.0419394597,
0.0093113836,
-0.0124029471,
0.0092509938,
-0.0007871451,
0.0235226471,
-0.0094095627,
0.0054443083,
0.0197000708,
-0.0228824411,
-0.0161385927,
-0.0511508435,
0.0196985137,
0.0000413903,
-0.0019334491,
0.0250646751,
0.0218167938,
-0.0288579632,
-0.0470215529,
0.0604055338,
-0.0065057036,
0.0177427661,
-0.0226442721,
-0.0170530099,
0.0299620051,
0.0622962378,
0.0222627707,
-0.0402383804,
-0.0493406132,
0.0036325913,
-0.001345764,
0.03117094,
0.044489108,
-0.014237646,
0.0003994418,
-0.0031793558,
-0.0167883746,
-0.008039345,
0.0180410203,
0.0267432798,
0.0196881145,
0.0029252244,
-0.0160907265,
0.0243389644,
0.0544759482,
0.0177927818,
-0.0406354703,
-0.0567778833,
-0.0210488271,
-0.0089455694,
0.0362346545,
-0.0104884226,
0.0224676579,
0.0385967083,
0.0230971072,
-0.0283113606,
-0.0367556512,
0.0351437666,
-0.0391410813,
-0.001442139,
0.041022636,
0.0171746649,
-0.0438410044,
0.0122680925,
-0.0602812022,
-0.0491942503,
0.0118303224,
0.0168624613,
0.0135004567,
-0.0242912211,
-0.0125242714,
-0.0044866181,
-0.0181063898,
-0.0099118585,
0.0723186955,
-0.0261344314,
0.0484460704,
0.022418011,
0.0182813331,
-0.0070349807,
-0.0588663407,
0.0243563224,
0.0323370546,
-0.0203510653,
-0.0079859579,
0.0307080224,
0.0012015424,
-0.0406884253,
-0.0055074301,
-0.0424972922,
0.0188163482,
-0.0153140211,
0.0409813114,
0.003962324,
-0.0581088625,
-0.0079088975,
-0.0032242471,
-0.0169623755,
0.0098779509,
0.0304689575,
0.0123266112,
0.0298891589,
0.0285396762,
-0.0167064555,
-0.0143868728,
-0.0004347486,
-0.0436225533,
0.050237976,
0.0127658751,
0.029676728,
-0.0300715771,
-0.0476858132,
-0.0148352031,
0.0048918636,
-0.0248810854,
-0.0050386535,
-0.0085742921,
-0.0359149389,
0.0213050842,
0.0270983744,
-0.0252305437,
0.0359432697,
0.0264930148,
-0.0706313252,
-0.0485113263,
0.027945213,
-0.023012761,
0.0420447923,
-0.0676363111,
-0.0093960017,
-0.0073559922,
0.1100356132,
-0.0142028704,
0.0064308355,
-0.0369483195,
0.0604417063,
-0.0172095168,
-0.0222568531,
-0.0416207239,
-0.0145428646,
-0.005903271,
0.0939086452,
0.0054703876,
-0.0360522605,
0.061752189,
0.0064958753,
0.0002220924,
-0.0220192838,
-0.0012873323,
-0.0734983459,
0.0708431825,
-0.0074008624,
-0.0105284471,
-0.0293597337,
-0.033654388,
-0.0512120314,
-0.0000520288,
0.0139174061,
0.0102481227,
0.0314537324,
-0.0797902867,
0.0143688936,
-0.0127790282,
-0.0311146695,
-0.0173592251,
-0.050248459,
-0.0620005541,
0.0325996354,
0.0136888027,
-0.0031833437,
-0.0620454066,
0.0063223625,
0.008706294,
-0.0091971708,
-0.0153072635,
-0.0146415271,
-0.0002518804,
0.0571964197,
0.0291472264,
0.0182334185,
0.0309206489,
-0.0217602048,
0.0733505785,
0.0280873645,
0.0334759466,
-0.0023742763,
-0.023464445,
0.0178006124,
0.0193245038,
-0.0338217728,
-0.0020356039,
0.0561429709,
-0.0385389291,
-0.0686485097,
-0.0023184097,
0.1079883426,
0.0223700162,
0.0350715034,
0.0128172906,
-0.0189227499,
0.0242275652,
0.0245628674,
0.0310629699,
-0.0718908757,
-0.0252674706,
0.0204311796,
-0.0156843737,
-0.0013941242,
-0.0752544776,
-0.0315691978,
-0.0965071544,
0.0359679423,
-0.0255537983,
-0.0453473553,
0.0067956629,
-0.0306875501,
-0.0147959189,
-0.0311093554,
-0.0113246636,
0.0308665764,
-0.0214599203,
-0.0021729157,
0.0173282828,
-0.0581668057,
0.0126557285,
0.0640735626,
0.022280911,
-0.0112812519,
0.0179342739,
0.027377367,
-0.0385722667,
0.0267588254,
0.0010583689,
-0.0136416042,
-0.0136239538,
0.0030065712,
-0.0127343033,
0.0208124928,
-0.0170796365,
-0.0132930456,
0.0255081225,
-0.0135809453,
-0.0180933755,
0.0284594186,
0.0641189143,
-0.0150424754,
-0.0447679609,
0.0029431968,
0.0299138613,
-0.0500603095,
0.0598902665,
-0.0064196363,
-0.0367330462,
-0.0840373859,
-0.0282474216,
-0.0545139499,
-0.077844575,
-0.0241813343,
0.0152023779,
0.032499034,
-0.002190646,
-0.0437247902,
-0.094245404,
0.0056413603,
0.0198910404,
-0.0403473042,
0.0002445463,
0.0727681592,
0.0106132505,
-0.0130998986,
0.005624834,
-0.0512712151,
0.0307280235,
-0.0400135405,
0.0740778968,
0.00338008,
0.02522121,
-0.0667888969,
0.0346066281,
-0.0685366541,
-0.0312229712,
0.0142434612,
0.0169409253,
0.0182851646,
0.0014019355,
0.0016833218,
-0.0146719525,
-0.0213080868,
0.0312779173,
-0.004753904,
-0.0101812398,
0.0445029438,
0.0203165486,
0.0013182912,
0.0421230942,
-0.041600775,
0.0432616174,
-0.0298023615,
0.1017007977,
-0.0473622009,
-0.0518328734,
0.0242073834,
-0.0124049829,
0.0117689632,
0.0010611067,
-0.0198373403,
-0.0327421837,
0.0314050391,
-0.0108581521,
-0.0280847941,
-0.0148566794,
-0.0092477538,
0.0387202688,
-0.0225434043,
-0.010067394,
-0.0017153822,
0.009974963,
-0.0197511762,
0.0021334519,
0.028969245,
0.0420859307,
0.0089310892,
0.0375273637,
-0.0429274328,
-0.0214896053,
-0.0292497296,
-0.0110596428,
0.0472529419,
0.0105132116,
0.0664779097,
0.0395730324,
0.003524438,
-0.001197308,
-0.039183706,
-0.0650587976,
-0.0560479835,
0.0349179395,
-0.0049317945,
0.0739165246,
-0.0473669842,
-0.0072967294,
-0.0390701406,
0.0012809631,
0.0200390834,
0.0145575358,
0.0053553926,
-0.0444964431,
0.0634196177,
0.0358614065,
-0.0476530604,
0.0380428992,
0.0762068853,
0.0236334149,
0.037587475,
0.021778496,
0.0039900057,
-0.0289755967,
-0.0968699157,
0.0083756484,
-0.0071634953,
0.0003625278,
0.0176103748,
-0.0817116126,
-0.0172837097,
0.0098030362,
0.0290289726,
-0.0329180025,
-0.0126357153,
0.0066340859,
0.047361508,
0.0251443032,
0.0110363849,
-0.00697899,
0.0273033008,
-0.0650540814,
-0.0173192658,
-0.0463629812,
-5.691203654e-33,
0.0096378,
-0.0532220826,
0.0628108382,
-0.0277912635,
0.0299109314,
0.0132484343,
-0.0302195102,
-0.0160604008,
-0.0203681681,
0.0319273248,
-0.0087239156,
0.0015857976,
0.0167603996,
0.0032016728,
0.0184495207,
-0.0099583287,
-0.0033082268,
-0.0022251848,
0.0178946201,
0.0054331822,
0.009730123,
0.0264331233,
0.0505485274,
-0.0187590551,
0.0467747003,
-0.0132329119,
-0.0053664157,
0.0529428907,
-0.0049649375,
0.0583910607,
-0.0109852925,
0.0004348475,
0.0356730856,
-0.0849306807,
-0.0064340094,
0.0216847602,
-0.0422506109,
-0.0515619107,
0.0080207698,
-0.0018517787,
-0.0359958261,
-0.0000333138,
-0.0161636751,
0.0272926688,
0.0038733254,
-0.0091350824,
0.0161674302,
-0.0349370278,
0.0021852492,
-0.0184605401,
-0.0639306307,
0.0441667475,
-0.0540400334,
0.0304357409,
-0.0019851702,
0.1120777652,
-0.0005606593,
0.0205707047,
-0.0342505462,
0.0068119355,
-0.0152613744,
-0.0069000768,
0.0541119315,
-0.0141890272,
0.0141184097,
0.0558247045,
-0.0277251117,
-0.0140400575,
-0.0193346217,
0.0415505841,
-0.0079844417,
0.0585257299,
0.0303944163,
0.0287842266,
0.0169933494,
0.0426745825,
-0.0951263756,
0.0230155084,
0.0397364423,
0.0661254749,
0.0310659334,
0.0036055783,
-0.0021520429,
-0.0280111786,
-0.0792509168,
0.0389061309,
-0.0152917625,
0.0113899093,
0.0349294618,
-0.0139352521,
-0.0037664594,
0.0032818581,
0.0423707701,
-0.0334310867,
-0.0831428096,
0.0512758791,
-0.0039978824,
0.0062585906,
0.0120162768,
0.0889672413,
-0.0598836467,
0.006038724,
-0.0109040504,
-0.0241205655,
0.0111096827,
-0.0177023709,
-0.0124259861,
-0.0172136165,
-0.0344194062,
-0.0101676844,
-0.030363258,
0.0252009574,
-0.0015785634,
-0.0028685634,
0.0449943244,
0.0104544889,
0.0118761295,
0.0289945789,
0.0033009748,
-0.0247197524,
0.0079555493,
0.0045705675,
-0.0149855837,
0.0292433836,
0.0043807942,
0.0028952528,
-0.0431364588,
0.0664798096,
-0.0247179996,
-0.0280800108,
-0.0093774386,
0.0790300146,
2.583e-7,
0.0543738082,
0.0426901877,
-0.0001469962,
0.067522034,
0.0097061861,
0.0280702934,
-0.052579388,
-0.0066087064,
-0.0080929929,
0.003797818,
0.019521419,
0.0479190834,
0.033007998,
0.0331597626,
-0.0620146282,
-0.014461346,
-0.102330938,
-0.0127672143,
-0.0641551465,
-0.0207709279,
0.0621246025,
0.0529977083,
0.0095707625,
0.0023104183,
-0.0106114363,
-0.0599209219,
0.0598068237,
-0.0424685776,
0.01371089,
0.0235034637,
-0.0036767838,
0.014127031,
0.0105914874,
-0.0001750889,
0.0172607061,
0.0170313045,
-0.0451353677,
0.0808987096,
0.0453781895,
-0.0278731789,
-0.0050217658,
-0.056479454,
-0.0089177974,
-0.062276829,
0.0929021388,
-0.0818127617,
-0.0604628362,
-0.0236613434,
-0.0206711031,
0.0009886147,
0.004693775,
0.0190398172,
0.017707916,
0.0218537003,
-0.0003163803,
-0.0276425853,
0.017213013,
-0.0372771136,
-0.026221754,
0.0318754502,
-0.0283903163,
-0.0157572087,
-0.0307677295,
0.0203453712,
0.0139762983,
-0.0233221054,
0.0091916379,
2.319775424e-34,
0.0425269008,
-0.0043563847,
-0.0065179835,
0.0321161151,
0.0605736002,
-0.0211136118,
-0.0508132949,
0.0406113118,
0.0186030641,
-0.0975221694,
-0.0015532564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07932v2
|
PARDEN, Can You Repeat That? Defending against Jailbreaks via Repetition
| 2024-05-13T17:08:42 | 2024-05-14T15:56:37 |
Ziyang Zhang, Qizhen Zhang, Jakob Foerster
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown success in many natural language
processing tasks. Despite rigorous safety alignment processes, supposedly
safety-aligned LLMs like Llama 2 and Claude 2 are still susceptible to
jailbreaks, leading to security risks and abuse of the models. One option to
mitigate such risks is to augment the LLM with a dedicated "safeguard", which
checks the LLM's inputs or outputs for undesired behaviour. A promising
approach is to use the LLM itself as the safeguard. Nonetheless, baseline
methods, such as prompting the LLM to self-classify toxic content, demonstrate
limited efficacy. We hypothesise that this is due to domain shift: the
alignment training imparts a self-censoring behaviour to the model ("Sorry I
can't do that"), while the self-classify approach shifts it to a classification
format ("Is this prompt malicious"). In this work, we propose PARDEN, which
avoids this domain shift by simply asking the model to repeat its own outputs.
PARDEN neither requires finetuning nor white box access to the model. We
empirically verify the effectiveness of our method and show that PARDEN
significantly outperforms existing jailbreak detection baselines for Llama-2
and Claude-2. Code and data are available at https://github.com/Ed-Zh/PARDEN.
We find that PARDEN is particularly powerful in the relevant regime of high
True Positive Rate (TPR) and low False Positive Rate (FPR). For instance, for
Llama2-7B, at TPR equal to 90%, PARDEN accomplishes a roughly 11x reduction in
the FPR from 24.8% to 2.0% on the harmful behaviours dataset.
|
[
0.0459761992,
0.0480722375,
-0.0211678054,
0.0326747037,
-0.0420206152,
0.013196446,
-0.0042304047,
-0.0188256148,
0.060510058,
-0.0702164993,
-0.0285743419,
-0.0112651335,
-0.0084150666,
0.0440868549,
0.0209504943,
-0.0098304627,
0.0766275674,
-0.0083119199,
-0.000221354,
0.0203743372,
0.0339096971,
-0.0064671482,
0.004004275,
0.0331882089,
-0.0118384026,
-0.0258639939,
-0.000353556,
-0.003179186,
0.0348262079,
-0.0580472425,
0.0249037072,
0.0323215798,
-0.0178051628,
0.0618945286,
0.0000020657,
-0.04622069,
-0.0403798223,
0.012210466,
-0.0049505946,
0.0332629047,
0.0290974025,
-0.0517829917,
-0.0140958047,
0.0390283838,
-0.055454351,
-0.0096290875,
0.0448873714,
0.0499248318,
0.1055808514,
0.0799852833,
0.0031195469,
-0.0116104875,
0.0566560142,
-0.0218072869,
-0.0022591611,
-0.0442028493,
0.0387392379,
-0.0498576351,
-0.0235302914,
0.0160379205,
0.0132023636,
0.0083270399,
0.0211391114,
-0.0225425549,
-0.0289227851,
0.0058525964,
-0.0267177001,
-0.0646357909,
-0.0221767239,
0.0550243035,
-0.0415931717,
-0.0423980318,
-0.003268274,
-0.0053462107,
0.0298326891,
-0.0098574897,
-0.005306344,
0.0258592609,
-0.0066476245,
0.0217691902,
0.0329549164,
-0.0003376494,
0.0647587329,
0.0031606106,
0.0066584423,
0.0593198314,
0.0011642491,
-0.0366761722,
0.018246552,
-0.0259201508,
0.002625257,
-0.0419520549,
0.004447828,
-0.0032051785,
0.0090562589,
0.0243997406,
-0.0809179842,
-0.0184890497,
0.054272715,
-0.0554214567,
-0.0077493987,
0.0199135188,
-0.0581442565,
0.0122868614,
-0.0231123995,
0.0050655659,
-0.0109747779,
0.053387396,
-0.0070714368,
0.0278178994,
-0.0116043314,
-0.0311387088,
-0.0192919839,
0.0608324558,
0.0271032676,
0.0002372643,
-0.0442988537,
0.0309334137,
-0.0171075519,
0.0104694515,
-0.0143525917,
0.0037562731,
-0.0165080354,
0.0327730365,
0.024943281,
-0.0100192288,
-0.0128639415,
0.0153715536,
0.0058136936,
-0.0744054392,
-0.027732579,
0.0200541001,
-0.073632814,
-0.0330422185,
-0.0138892177,
0.0832857564,
0.0244262703,
-0.0360922329,
-0.0736932978,
-0.0628918037,
-0.0656769052,
-0.0050528981,
-0.0031087871,
-0.0476653501,
-0.0266874265,
-0.0319704451,
0.0238216575,
-0.082733579,
0.026324641,
-0.0072537572,
-0.0430021398,
0.0641078204,
0.0071044369,
-0.0347777605,
-0.0160827395,
0.0508948267,
0.0153628718,
0.0848744214,
0.0109403487,
0.0272433553,
0.0610805973,
-0.0131746018,
0.0186505169,
0.0396946706,
0.0120557277,
0.0182230398,
-0.0186834112,
-0.0280929301,
0.0198396873,
-0.0174839869,
0.0079248687,
0.0310247075,
0.013477562,
-0.0287765767,
0.0613646619,
0.0312824026,
-0.0241087917,
0.0278876498,
0.0053237635,
-0.0268568844,
-0.0159620345,
0.0172421578,
-0.0784725696,
-0.0066222916,
-0.0624683239,
-0.0233011972,
-0.0050309207,
0.0329487883,
-0.0014201996,
-0.020874517,
0.0061212489,
-0.0058282744,
0.0151950167,
-0.016914146,
0.0156947356,
0.0301903859,
0.0007424519,
0.0507301725,
0.0236386191,
-0.0408082381,
-0.0172551069,
-0.0783681944,
0.0342592448,
0.0579614528,
0.0350080319,
-0.0149748418,
-0.0203799326,
-0.0331798159,
-0.0028915806,
-0.0056983363,
-0.0095647797,
0.005314209,
0.0247606691,
-0.02883563,
-0.0328669511,
-0.0280513745,
0.030476287,
0.0137900291,
0.0263542105,
0.015308775,
0.0172482301,
-0.006608306,
-0.0156673286,
0.0660070553,
0.0287255924,
-0.0254874527,
0.0063395319,
0.0175129324,
0.0421050675,
-0.0003527584,
-0.0249600187,
0.0097506838,
0.0704248101,
-0.0161480624,
0.0205052048,
-0.0157820266,
-0.0473888628,
-0.0364228413,
0.0530977696,
-0.0275525637,
0.0073732613,
0.0967349857,
-0.0426684543,
0.0022657488,
0.0181336831,
-0.0340845287,
0.0340367071,
-0.0072147339,
0.031103421,
-0.0103425989,
0.0412001722,
-0.0128812324,
0.0246471837,
-0.0296759568,
-0.0143388668,
-0.0346383229,
0.0019700325,
0.0142113315,
-0.0002023817,
-0.0535777546,
-0.0151498504,
-0.0478046201,
0.024225872,
0.0125144515,
0.0302551705,
-0.0121043371,
-0.0351022817,
-0.0244448762,
0.0003127187,
-0.0396096036,
0.0299547147,
0.0419520885,
0.016023472,
-0.0210277885,
-0.0328798927,
-0.0095461626,
-0.0284709819,
0.0143683199,
0.0228827465,
-0.000370763,
-0.0378092974,
-0.050022386,
-0.0227412879,
-0.0115312785,
-0.0045062737,
0.0262763016,
-0.017879881,
-0.0448000692,
-0.0270128008,
0.0130590126,
0.006882811,
0.019997254,
-0.0194393024,
-0.047894109,
0.0237336457,
0.0252022892,
-0.0432360321,
0.0676746368,
0.012695943,
0.0396813564,
0.0707805753,
0.0383439474,
-0.0408312678,
-0.0146663375,
0.0195733458,
-0.0455265082,
-0.0405231118,
-0.0545555279,
0.0342381969,
0.0571646877,
0.0315885432,
-0.0026992757,
-0.0179032125,
-0.0062802099,
-0.0023494046,
-0.0443301238,
0.0118134553,
-0.063429825,
-0.0476259105,
-0.0107572777,
-0.0293067768,
-0.0943928137,
0.0683272183,
-0.0403675064,
0.0199627168,
-0.0301594976,
-0.0427362919,
-0.0063149198,
0.0455833264,
-0.0025890996,
0.0139446473,
0.0547218248,
-0.0466066115,
-0.0139927957,
-0.0218134914,
0.0176904742,
-0.0078769894,
0.0467380658,
-0.0485855602,
0.0074792556,
-0.0031383643,
-0.0612102337,
-0.0924791172,
-0.0735974833,
-0.0075972411,
-0.0352740586,
0.0108419666,
-0.0050338386,
-0.0245155953,
-0.0088532539,
-0.0069679217,
0.0010723289,
-0.0102775358,
0.007595811,
-0.0152787995,
0.0429042801,
0.0369945653,
-0.0453255996,
0.0231841877,
0.0151029062,
0.0378106609,
0.0874012485,
0.0046055787,
0.0263957884,
-0.0212033167,
0.0446733683,
0.0121230055,
-0.0146021303,
-0.0225152131,
0.0372479744,
0.0287123341,
-0.0380560979,
-0.0451463349,
0.0594746321,
0.04096549,
0.0005846337,
0.0213101525,
0.0114099951,
0.049590189,
0.0313059278,
-0.0151314912,
-0.0380947366,
-0.0366861708,
0.0303008538,
0.062325839,
-0.0328946672,
0.0023585064,
-0.0182082299,
-0.1124846116,
-0.0046507004,
0.0425647087,
-0.0143871158,
-0.0023143606,
-0.0417362191,
-0.0316282623,
-0.0041154511,
0.0163187142,
-0.0150991874,
-0.0135935443,
-0.0138553353,
0.0196913369,
-0.0510348864,
-0.0211664792,
0.008255193,
-0.0267780591,
0.0588909686,
0.100196071,
-0.0027950234,
-0.0380546935,
-0.0052621323,
0.0609942526,
-0.0310753062,
-0.0046298965,
0.0070552016,
0.0392392762,
-0.0180444922,
0.0110053886,
0.002396354,
0.0631514266,
-0.0124066174,
-0.0256228894,
0.0523505807,
0.0651715547,
0.0123787243,
-0.0102643175,
-0.0493216999,
0.006183913,
0.0095888162,
0.064144887,
0.032924369,
-0.0314015411,
-0.0374204665,
-0.0472856872,
-0.0298478305,
-0.0349776261,
-0.0176263191,
0.0463309512,
0.0028734144,
-0.0299421661,
-0.0646689832,
-0.0127319749,
-0.0307689104,
0.0263493154,
0.038193468,
-0.0042884648,
-0.0328462422,
0.0075472025,
-0.0406142846,
0.0027895565,
0.0042439564,
0.0351964869,
-0.0753244311,
0.044646088,
0.0218990296,
0.018217558,
-0.0229064748,
0.0194821376,
-0.0842871144,
-0.0883940235,
0.0335753746,
0.0701607093,
0.0234813727,
0.0179424342,
-0.0420296937,
-0.0477056876,
0.0603962876,
0.1079023778,
-0.0691639856,
0.002385047,
0.0701268762,
-0.0543253943,
0.0169066768,
0.0219968949,
-0.0253838357,
-0.0147896623,
0.0329952613,
-0.0012245359,
-0.0349917822,
-0.0126139913,
0.0295718443,
0.0360842422,
0.0400312021,
-0.0260469504,
0.0130106462,
0.0023547893,
0.0309994482,
0.0175725333,
-0.0308620911,
0.0143414754,
0.0478549525,
0.0475342609,
-0.0541327894,
0.000676042,
0.0221970286,
-0.0400386602,
0.0262772534,
-0.016154604,
0.0051730135,
0.0298599806,
0.0294638742,
0.0349775255,
0.0164175592,
-0.0277432986,
0.0400027633,
0.0159168057,
0.0233801212,
-0.0202627275,
0.0339847282,
-0.0189888366,
0.0054097325,
-0.0243395902,
0.0626040995,
-0.0496731214,
0.0077542458,
-0.032138817,
0.0520826094,
0.0013580486,
0.0089415945,
0.0413605124,
-0.0175897591,
-0.0004989328,
-0.0310447831,
0.0046225819,
-0.03319107,
-0.0540246964,
0.0220385622,
-0.0150148841,
-0.0325165503,
0.0074459575,
0.0635989681,
0.0056738392,
0.0598060973,
0.0306455735,
-0.0231986362,
-0.0511657782,
-0.0141726816,
0.081844233,
0.0329597518,
-0.0541798212,
-0.0335625298,
-0.0599788986,
-0.0803148523,
-0.0017269938,
-0.0054969774,
0.0442259833,
0.0073895045,
-0.0273101404,
0.0544619523,
-0.0059361663,
0.0090930453,
-0.0403230041,
-0.0024385182,
0.0328976177,
-0.0438780747,
-0.0063406676,
-5.959107265e-33,
0.0048048422,
-0.0209776629,
-0.0473316461,
-0.0181823131,
0.0065715858,
-0.0157247987,
0.0096396133,
0.0149552152,
-0.0072913952,
-0.0257821511,
-0.006176963,
-0.0015589648,
-0.0038556105,
0.0039069792,
-0.0103483349,
-0.0363395326,
0.0320701227,
-0.0045114425,
-0.0577562489,
0.0302400403,
0.0401832052,
0.0327958763,
-0.004042129,
-0.0595356226,
0.0317094214,
-0.0051709572,
-0.0388633944,
0.0145297348,
-0.0515167825,
0.0829053149,
0.0098675676,
0.0329033956,
0.0261148065,
-0.0025192408,
-0.0037169755,
0.0707441792,
-0.043639224,
-0.0189989712,
0.0120995492,
-0.0033024237,
0.008363124,
-0.045221623,
0.0837701336,
0.0059452085,
-0.0101157157,
-0.0054811821,
0.0018187778,
-0.0292986594,
-0.0357398167,
-0.0129751004,
-0.0288703982,
-0.0128728114,
-0.0205483921,
-0.041127108,
-0.012801664,
0.0263732541,
0.0136663085,
0.0053151585,
-0.0534784943,
0.0160060748,
0.0259496998,
0.0182664599,
0.0344336294,
-0.0051336526,
-0.0261592921,
0.0831988603,
-0.001114271,
-0.0434018634,
0.0201297142,
-0.0103887897,
0.0137020303,
0.0260193031,
0.038104862,
0.0710595399,
0.0517881848,
-0.0435271114,
-0.1049041748,
0.0287554786,
0.0067299139,
0.0376154333,
0.0215817988,
-0.0131652812,
-0.0495583303,
-0.004387558,
-0.0211942438,
-0.0081694126,
-0.0100404769,
-0.0493781455,
0.0485819504,
0.0041401414,
-0.0379919894,
-0.0221435595,
-0.0029308852,
-0.0531817973,
-0.0132329548,
0.0176506136,
-0.007216421,
-0.002810963,
-0.0124309994,
0.0376489237,
-0.0230895542,
-0.0053705303,
0.0212464575,
-0.0335959569,
0.0499362312,
-0.0175760668,
0.0954862237,
0.0357933342,
-0.0931301787,
0.0102355713,
-0.0238167737,
0.0620318465,
0.0139190806,
0.0456987843,
0.0184618197,
-0.0062692869,
0.002194949,
0.0141680734,
0.0197779685,
-0.0072937105,
-0.0564979017,
0.025092816,
-0.0164757539,
0.0215092879,
-0.0103434371,
-0.0029697944,
0.0014366665,
0.018292943,
0.0422784649,
-0.0865708068,
0.0030963514,
0.0001691487,
2.836e-7,
-0.0055559934,
-0.0124127101,
0.0262089185,
-0.0290323105,
0.0262438171,
0.0696431994,
-0.0383356772,
0.0910452306,
-0.0146573894,
-0.0502887368,
-0.0304221995,
-0.0191767476,
0.0552475192,
0.0598612279,
-0.0404203646,
0.0341038033,
-0.0832263529,
0.0218036491,
-0.0584497787,
-0.0148715246,
0.0484393872,
0.1280708909,
0.0309604239,
-0.0389982946,
0.0081161475,
-0.0734177679,
0.0118792644,
0.0228474718,
-0.0036103991,
-0.0108853206,
0.0165929925,
0.0520647652,
0.0034658434,
-0.0071548517,
-0.0370445102,
-0.0214884412,
-0.0506295301,
0.046814885,
-0.0036371634,
-0.0246061739,
-0.0424432494,
-0.0189043861,
0.0123128267,
-0.0450206138,
0.0790041387,
-0.0124120386,
-0.0038808661,
-0.030167155,
0.029052062,
-0.0315146819,
0.0370357931,
-0.0342944711,
0.0088543911,
0.0167020839,
0.0235992633,
0.0154739264,
-0.0062781414,
-0.0773968995,
-0.0279881675,
-0.0159748681,
-0.0033876053,
-0.0356594473,
-0.0149844941,
0.0501797795,
0.0285157356,
-0.0866536722,
0.0282049458,
2.855282666e-34,
-0.004485263,
-0.063404426,
0.019573193,
0.0143060554,
0.0119504388,
0.0125627918,
0.0245778263,
0.0158836413,
-0.0056996304,
-0.0031905007,
-0.000530183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07886v1
|
Russian-Language Multimodal Dataset for Automatic Summarization of Scientific Papers
| 2024-05-13T16:21:33 | 2024-05-13T16:21:33 |
Alena Tsanda, Elena Bruches
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The paper discusses the creation of a multimodal dataset of Russian-language
scientific papers and testing of existing language models for the task of
automatic text summarization. A feature of the dataset is its multimodal data,
which includes texts, tables and figures. The paper presents the results of
experiments with two language models: Gigachat from SBER and YandexGPT from
Yandex. The dataset consists of 420 papers and is publicly available on
https://github.com/iis-research-team/summarization-dataset.
|
[
0.0367203206,
0.0400714539,
0.027627049,
0.0087959478,
-0.0169624519,
0.0130895386,
0.0210918114,
0.0085099936,
-0.0254658386,
-0.0435511246,
-0.0261960719,
-0.0185728446,
0.0150011219,
0.0072093927,
0.0278379209,
-0.0973030031,
0.0210498385,
-0.0220625997,
-0.014935731,
0.001127506,
0.0405814312,
-0.0014616837,
-0.0171302799,
-0.0077250889,
0.0198961366,
-0.010527499,
0.0296086818,
-0.0040090261,
0.012462263,
-0.020895021,
-0.0090705501,
0.0219943747,
0.0298079047,
0.0144238016,
0.00000178,
-0.0545618832,
-0.0372181833,
-0.0069897305,
0.0862852931,
-0.0033464707,
0.101694189,
-0.0993509963,
-0.0170537904,
-0.0409530699,
-0.008104207,
0.0067625288,
0.0139485337,
0.0608425662,
0.0470698513,
0.0522434711,
-0.0208003204,
-0.084381558,
0.0461584963,
0.0257454868,
-0.0238772947,
-0.0027561258,
-0.0099583231,
0.0509901829,
0.0111366715,
0.0272679869,
0.0125025073,
0.056236092,
-0.0054116147,
-0.0515656658,
-0.0527314618,
0.0151075935,
-0.0550222322,
-0.0366755202,
-0.0014759266,
0.0671057031,
0.0168153699,
-0.0066350079,
0.0403349474,
0.0227889977,
-0.0323832333,
0.0493242852,
-0.1156829298,
0.0507024452,
-0.034180332,
-0.0189183801,
-0.0254777614,
0.0016865958,
-0.0465536974,
0.0100031551,
0.0178352483,
0.0463238358,
0.0058041071,
-0.0051590689,
-0.0117743742,
-0.0439689308,
-0.0046378938,
-0.0030768286,
0.0343132243,
0.0250462648,
0.0415876694,
-0.0049439794,
-0.0435729027,
-0.1156410873,
0.0441980772,
-0.0346343331,
-0.0092400536,
0.0025531072,
0.0157033801,
0.0507238507,
-0.0375494696,
0.0022901176,
0.0065010744,
0.0221336484,
-0.0259073954,
-0.0185439847,
-0.0074962545,
0.0238510463,
-0.0381208844,
-0.0044098734,
-0.0146782827,
-0.0373707488,
-0.0266174823,
0.0293442272,
0.0329246894,
0.0339084417,
-0.0088455146,
-0.0247454811,
-0.0152454609,
-0.0235925727,
0.0278647244,
0.0598700419,
-0.0189501848,
-0.0490643755,
-0.0179866031,
-0.007065929,
0.0283759311,
0.0512544997,
0.0334294513,
-0.0156977903,
-0.0059676385,
0.0314152539,
-0.0194727797,
-0.0490395837,
0.0260124523,
-0.027840618,
0.0138453832,
-0.0523321442,
0.0240823328,
-0.043416433,
0.0072780936,
0.0167127755,
-0.003946668,
-0.0170813724,
-0.00499852,
0.018516561,
-0.0481631272,
0.0414377041,
-0.0371912569,
-0.0023676883,
0.0546406992,
-0.0137840183,
0.0404136144,
0.0759673789,
0.0115700904,
0.0367264301,
0.0827515423,
-0.0327934884,
0.005781604,
0.0464791209,
-0.0036832469,
0.0167619213,
-0.0006044229,
-0.0102096489,
0.0017933038,
-0.0123428982,
0.030338699,
0.0157337207,
-0.0441551358,
0.0299298316,
0.0716578886,
0.0434627905,
0.0029181412,
0.0329939798,
-0.0243970919,
-0.0009983813,
0.0646838769,
0.0462883748,
0.0158531461,
0.0488770194,
-0.0138109336,
0.0847373605,
0.0725906342,
0.0314218551,
-0.0009710183,
-0.0219972767,
0.0079872664,
0.0007226318,
0.0210077129,
-0.0478340052,
0.0947059318,
0.0050355839,
-0.0494041257,
-0.0316111445,
0.013472016,
-0.0629695728,
0.0049380963,
0.0088440571,
0.0067252698,
0.0015379987,
0.0794074461,
-0.0895607844,
0.0045202589,
0.0116455089,
0.0362133496,
0.0401585326,
0.0265840441,
-0.0104725501,
-0.0357058682,
-0.0584704503,
-0.0335698947,
-0.0070774984,
-0.0236271732,
0.0030570705,
-0.0372836925,
0.0017567032,
0.0104742628,
0.0004547933,
-0.0331629552,
0.0210513435,
0.0076034879,
0.0369885489,
-0.0494737066,
-0.031918183,
0.0052239131,
0.0195350703,
-0.0323910303,
0.0331600048,
0.0323915407,
-0.0111541981,
0.0440497175,
0.0410632379,
0.0364506319,
-0.0125322836,
0.0199591331,
-0.0752577931,
0.0060572978,
0.0160246026,
0.001786276,
-0.0471216291,
0.0574087165,
-0.0342492647,
-0.0283969361,
-0.0069842194,
0.0140410494,
0.0206024926,
0.0453030579,
-0.000348366,
0.0357338339,
-0.0035880934,
0.0399683155,
0.0385931209,
-0.0444678813,
0.0222379547,
-0.0437401421,
-0.0279599521,
0.0301134307,
0.0088471724,
-0.0008846465,
0.0554536954,
-0.0063818698,
-0.0094976425,
0.000949093,
-0.0967204198,
-0.0057152756,
-0.0188275632,
0.0256206486,
0.0365418568,
0.0088759828,
0.0068055666,
-0.0238987785,
0.0056828656,
0.0192054734,
0.0302111804,
-0.0126698026,
0.0528685041,
-0.0088335611,
0.0435373783,
-0.0594712235,
-0.0423035808,
-0.0102381539,
0.025026679,
0.027022494,
-0.0344547965,
-0.0255985614,
-0.0012872892,
-0.0008322066,
0.0000296671,
-0.0091195935,
-0.0338763557,
0.0015255095,
-0.0343533419,
0.0322258994,
0.0927155316,
0.0280953757,
-0.0068238731,
0.0419682339,
-0.013792309,
0.0019766504,
-0.0153541323,
-0.0447305627,
0.0579983406,
0.0375108905,
-0.0286897235,
0.0340571031,
0.0251497757,
-0.0037531876,
0.0172232687,
0.0102007426,
0.0188028403,
-0.0204370916,
0.011492718,
-0.0389072187,
0.0462879762,
-0.0037763906,
0.0353194587,
0.0163789578,
0.0165306684,
0.0119359046,
-0.0472090133,
-0.0073346542,
-0.0812410265,
0.0049214596,
-0.0615476966,
0.0271229949,
0.045220878,
0.0251565631,
-0.026374843,
-0.0027396546,
-0.0380853601,
-0.0133367516,
0.0467367508,
0.000975146,
0.0286045969,
-0.059171997,
0.0247181077,
-0.0614081807,
0.0399042442,
0.0558221154,
-0.049213659,
0.0067675435,
0.0145535162,
0.025532268,
-0.0125404419,
-0.070048973,
0.0349575281,
0.0694068372,
0.0926448256,
-0.0383852944,
-0.018385442,
-0.0138757536,
0.0753208771,
0.1012564972,
-0.0045716409,
-0.0397600159,
-0.008616969,
-0.0056381468,
0.0503416136,
0.0182754267,
-0.0121983765,
-0.0037241653,
-0.0131307375,
0.0074993689,
-0.0425320491,
-0.0043776119,
-0.0462292209,
0.009942309,
-0.0189296678,
0.024652198,
0.0690525547,
0.0218943171,
-0.0412884578,
-0.0494564511,
-0.0140972957,
-0.0050314781,
-0.0012305323,
-0.0183729567,
-0.0655363724,
0.0137200765,
-0.0206252802,
-0.0090037603,
-0.0045869015,
0.0030331416,
-0.0122160725,
-0.044147335,
0.0045000417,
-0.008967625,
-0.1045866087,
-0.0393219069,
-0.0285143498,
0.0102706514,
-0.0127429143,
-0.0073450152,
0.0473107398,
-0.0459252372,
-0.001923405,
0.011200401,
-0.0725999773,
-0.0413140319,
-0.0773309395,
0.0014916671,
-0.0196324345,
0.0349393599,
0.0528052785,
-0.0482909977,
0.0229726974,
0.0269051157,
-0.0079910662,
-0.0263916645,
-0.0188980941,
0.0678629875,
0.0089258617,
-0.0134921232,
-0.0210809037,
0.04833702,
0.0213349871,
-0.0021715551,
0.0297703501,
-0.0260624979,
-0.0093680648,
-0.0028185868,
-0.0713291317,
0.0485111251,
-0.0482200459,
0.0073940777,
-0.0022601597,
0.0212596431,
-0.0341679715,
-0.0146169486,
-0.0095609799,
-0.0357331038,
-0.0213290099,
0.0057822298,
-0.0891097784,
-0.0474527702,
-0.0797450542,
-0.0488626398,
0.0214211792,
0.0170950126,
0.0077882078,
0.031309031,
-0.0405013412,
0.0268608723,
-0.0326593257,
0.0053106155,
0.0156855583,
-0.0171253793,
-0.0429421514,
-0.0303350799,
0.0683574229,
-0.0421692841,
-0.0175385922,
0.0048060212,
-0.0047651576,
-0.0334036313,
-0.0335111953,
0.0283163171,
0.0275982171,
0.0087637194,
0.0055455784,
-0.053795483,
0.0301288161,
0.0027678865,
0.0185989272,
-0.0084017022,
-0.0103026601,
0.0110241985,
-0.01984955,
-0.0194206648,
-0.0384419039,
0.0476665646,
-0.0208688788,
0.0053587235,
-0.035019666,
-0.0176283773,
-0.007598653,
0.0519801788,
0.0073056091,
-0.0175654832,
0.0017456252,
-0.0279247593,
-0.0176878199,
-0.0436100736,
-0.0067717759,
-0.0200127922,
0.0733645484,
-0.0121380808,
-0.0060270112,
-0.0060892855,
0.0621826276,
0.0037600026,
-0.0277539399,
-0.0282804668,
0.0480756238,
0.0317219943,
-0.010872242,
-0.0283321999,
-0.019902505,
-0.0303235445,
-0.0155948475,
-0.0536932051,
0.0051398738,
-0.0081500513,
0.0307723321,
0.0370859131,
-0.0532063022,
0.0188412797,
0.0822457001,
-0.0799624696,
0.0538758971,
-0.0487342626,
0.0368541218,
0.0697317645,
-0.0058647641,
0.1051824838,
-0.0429685973,
-0.0103967702,
-0.0106510874,
0.0628063232,
0.0801700801,
0.0242553875,
-0.0081381723,
-0.0107599217,
0.025547808,
-0.008372345,
0.0965394899,
-0.0106821395,
-0.0304401889,
0.0387073383,
-0.0085588647,
-0.0433428288,
0.0241129231,
-0.0038803762,
0.0005320225,
-0.0085765989,
-0.0442567095,
-0.0158800092,
-0.0034914841,
-0.0134606259,
0.0402277596,
-0.0346990153,
-0.0138028292,
0.031000264,
0.0416135862,
0.0286655892,
0.0126564084,
-0.0680611879,
0.0271905288,
-0.02910183,
-0.0306206066,
-0.0012827941,
-5.425141161e-33,
-0.0045382562,
-0.0011693204,
-0.0218033753,
0.0079430202,
-0.014893326,
-0.0303679463,
-0.0613467135,
-0.0430458933,
0.0114267422,
-0.0070139416,
-0.025301693,
-0.0100662382,
0.0126472544,
0.0018325688,
0.011797335,
0.049540475,
-0.0017958152,
0.000683705,
-0.0179684646,
0.0241549239,
0.0427846014,
0.002800226,
0.0892351791,
-0.056109231,
0.0431450643,
-0.0113578038,
-0.0041751252,
-0.0550999641,
0.070894599,
0.028310366,
-0.031576205,
0.0114683779,
0.0334402621,
-0.0448907577,
-0.0377408005,
0.0128636537,
-0.0638957769,
0.0074115456,
0.0362163708,
0.0510587394,
-0.0368091278,
-0.0106353257,
0.0476824231,
-0.0792799816,
0.0246144626,
0.0022915215,
0.0810468942,
-0.0545062982,
-0.0587114207,
-0.063711673,
-0.0527333431,
0.0384929515,
-0.0369479582,
0.013533555,
0.0714948922,
0.0435632169,
0.0139998952,
0.0046541709,
0.0001058901,
0.0518958271,
0.0025335012,
0.0415312499,
0.0489715226,
-0.0457567647,
0.0276812688,
0.0312308259,
0.0029641502,
-0.0222908109,
0.0348225087,
0.008742555,
0.0276420191,
0.0010827975,
0.0264727511,
0.050406035,
0.0248612054,
0.0129388003,
-0.0210511331,
0.0717743337,
0.0048469296,
0.0353884771,
0.0266796425,
-0.0119347777,
0.033668749,
0.021219261,
0.0207379255,
-0.0254256669,
-0.0215658396,
-0.0373757668,
-0.0162922554,
-0.0292993877,
-0.0485967062,
-0.0165349804,
0.0182902571,
-0.0185050741,
-0.0356358774,
0.0301673971,
-0.0068665654,
0.0689592808,
-0.028473625,
-0.042477157,
0.0079385247,
-0.0390216745,
0.0190833285,
0.0094025545,
0.003833551,
-0.0053827814,
0.017070245,
-0.0057286927,
-0.0170206763,
-0.0075052078,
0.0279758275,
-0.016727129,
0.0011957934,
0.0545920804,
-0.0228242017,
-0.0232105926,
-0.0044388324,
0.0192441437,
0.0429100022,
-0.0020836978,
-0.0217523351,
-0.0275867935,
0.0185828954,
0.0252905693,
-0.0061892532,
0.017984705,
-0.0310293697,
-0.0157396365,
0.0203152988,
-0.0180402361,
0.0005661245,
-0.0011119968,
2.426e-7,
0.0507977679,
0.0545455515,
0.0288253333,
-0.0178204477,
0.032342732,
-0.0171798673,
-0.0470837988,
0.0333159901,
0.0037059027,
0.0094142603,
0.0364715867,
-0.0374400839,
0.0380245037,
0.0220668428,
-0.0703185648,
-0.0568517409,
-0.0670310333,
-0.0503802933,
-0.045842845,
0.0437557921,
0.0413253009,
0.0582101308,
-0.068260856,
-0.0044323122,
-0.0377945751,
-0.0413062312,
0.0239496697,
-0.0257526301,
-0.0159287378,
0.0295163039,
0.0645459667,
-0.0114903422,
-0.0219981093,
0.0007323007,
-0.001349012,
-0.0407644473,
0.0630075857,
-0.004743454,
-0.0009592114,
0.017070055,
0.0451520681,
-0.0244490691,
0.0098904204,
-0.0336391889,
0.0655550212,
-0.0347887687,
-0.0270218607,
-0.0005172645,
-0.0452212282,
0.0004473173,
0.0079837637,
-0.0271161962,
-0.0590620302,
0.0679319873,
0.0054223728,
-0.0426920131,
0.020685792,
-0.0498762019,
-0.0175474212,
0.0310137961,
0.0095780203,
-0.0375925303,
0.0013386782,
-0.053101074,
0.0019213444,
-0.0232638456,
-0.0314768478,
2.118852674e-34,
0.0992412493,
-0.0084764762,
-0.0323507264,
0.0125133852,
0.0039406288,
-0.0565173849,
-0.029270079,
0.0139884045,
-0.014335379,
-0.0874533877,
-0.0067837941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07883v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07883v1
|
Zero-Shot Tokenizer Transfer
| 2024-05-13T16:17:10 | 2024-05-13T16:17:10 |
Benjamin Minixhofer, Edoardo Maria Ponti, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) are bound to their tokenizer, which maps raw text to a
sequence of vocabulary items (tokens). This restricts their flexibility: for
example, LMs trained primarily on English may still perform well in other
natural and programming languages, but have vastly decreased efficiency due to
their English-centric tokenizer. To mitigate this, we should be able to swap
the original LM tokenizer with an arbitrary one, on the fly, without degrading
performance. Hence, in this work we define a new problem: Zero-Shot Tokenizer
Transfer (ZeTT). The challenge at the core of ZeTT is finding embeddings for
the tokens in the vocabulary of the new tokenizer. Since prior heuristics for
initializing embeddings often perform at chance level in a ZeTT setting, we
propose a new solution: we train a hypernetwork taking a tokenizer as input and
predicting the corresponding embeddings. We empirically demonstrate that the
hypernetwork generalizes to new tokenizers both with encoder (e.g., XLM-R) and
decoder LLMs (e.g., Mistral-7B). Our method comes close to the original models'
performance in cross-lingual and coding tasks while markedly reducing the
length of the tokenized sequence. We also find that the remaining gap can be
quickly closed by continued training on less than 1B tokens. Finally, we show
that a ZeTT hypernetwork trained for a base (L)LM can also be applied to
fine-tuned variants without extra training. Overall, our results make
substantial strides toward detaching LMs from their tokenizer.
|
[
-0.0245731007,
0.0517261922,
0.0027081156,
0.041113209,
-0.0238570925,
0.0174124781,
0.0001546856,
0.0071065389,
-0.043715477,
-0.0225461386,
-0.0234963186,
0.0037959944,
-0.0199422128,
0.033185754,
0.0514540561,
-0.0215961318,
0.0454563536,
-0.0014345676,
-0.0152427405,
0.0203939527,
-0.0061772135,
0.0288898535,
0.007645465,
0.0695510879,
-0.000001639,
0.0076293256,
-0.0212908052,
0.0181592349,
0.0165354013,
-0.0165661313,
-0.0255124327,
0.025286695,
0.0281991363,
0.0350698531,
0.0000016865,
-0.0068149786,
-0.0233604964,
-0.0132239349,
-0.0013099007,
0.0035044313,
0.0551994666,
-0.0562291704,
-0.0154699543,
0.0274249353,
-0.0207776744,
-0.062559396,
0.0374325141,
0.0261635501,
0.0465607829,
0.0752323046,
-0.012550232,
0.0007807901,
0.054580912,
-0.0284187701,
0.0198340267,
-0.0320548043,
-0.0001480633,
-0.0114234537,
-0.0244340207,
0.0150064668,
-0.0464800298,
0.0441192016,
0.0110129509,
0.0133102685,
0.0129150581,
0.0378506929,
-0.0731791556,
0.0028069306,
-0.0001851643,
0.0578657277,
-0.0921486616,
-0.0254567973,
0.0026072646,
0.0226226784,
0.0026111254,
-0.0116250739,
-0.0592201017,
0.0041305698,
0.0451690182,
0.0410177968,
0.0304485559,
-0.0390310474,
0.0383029021,
-0.0046349987,
-0.046520263,
0.0461471453,
0.0366154127,
0.0101852091,
-0.0364724696,
-0.0097669102,
-0.0039480319,
-0.0887734443,
0.0030742858,
0.0209979489,
0.0065606437,
0.0043652803,
-0.0544433445,
-0.048411686,
-0.0149834044,
0.0110768229,
0.0185283534,
0.0633284897,
-0.0169710815,
0.0153675834,
-0.0955006555,
0.042115286,
-0.0169081576,
0.0383074954,
-0.071434401,
-0.0370302573,
-0.0645600855,
-0.0239485018,
-0.0763169751,
0.0379650667,
-0.0197085831,
-0.0440644771,
-0.0285098683,
0.0120994737,
0.0261478536,
0.0091844061,
-0.015627332,
-0.0124343457,
-0.029250741,
0.0018968632,
0.0192264691,
0.0386680327,
-0.0153081864,
0.016997071,
0.0289508086,
-0.0358709395,
-0.0490923859,
0.0423668586,
0.0262973346,
-0.0148971062,
-0.0112850163,
0.0844279155,
-0.0339463539,
-0.0348818973,
-0.039762266,
-0.0119706895,
0.0109084863,
-0.0190024488,
-0.0001222798,
-0.0749742016,
0.0124032488,
-0.0046976036,
0.0131284324,
-0.0116871167,
-0.002302943,
0.0176946521,
-0.024179481,
0.0741024241,
-0.0112906443,
-0.0365917273,
0.0133239469,
-0.0184768159,
-0.0239449106,
0.0626121387,
0.0304773562,
0.0287136026,
0.0313284621,
-0.0348505788,
0.0012973435,
0.0517381392,
0.0289081894,
0.0083808638,
-0.0536242947,
-0.0352837481,
0.0569823347,
0.0318079963,
0.0623165555,
0.0405359268,
-0.0782252103,
0.0194586497,
0.0156601239,
0.094717212,
0.0177200641,
0.0112103056,
0.1017383635,
-0.0356887579,
-0.0569877699,
0.0109144924,
-0.0241836086,
0.0120821707,
0.0271207541,
-0.0099035427,
0.0326785222,
0.0030676099,
-0.0584750101,
-0.0323509611,
-0.0030831886,
-0.0349549614,
0.0018381767,
-0.0655260086,
0.0395188816,
0.0367428549,
-0.0524536967,
0.081838049,
0.0184049495,
-0.0512532555,
0.0465619974,
-0.0269875657,
0.0123571046,
0.0773714632,
0.0284573883,
-0.0028469688,
-0.0184773356,
-0.0209970977,
0.0070448755,
0.0199669693,
0.0226597171,
-0.0317975432,
0.0206556339,
-0.0863773152,
0.0076525183,
-0.0048176856,
0.0278271101,
0.0581542104,
-0.0500362404,
0.0506473556,
0.036051169,
-0.0340205878,
0.0127873626,
0.0322960019,
-0.044527065,
-0.0300584771,
0.0110317767,
-0.0002868435,
0.0188736506,
0.0208751727,
0.007861645,
0.0102297692,
0.0199436042,
-0.072959207,
-0.0327435322,
-0.0134345656,
-0.0593731478,
-0.0746894777,
0.0215219893,
-0.0430341773,
0.0431968309,
0.0349899083,
-0.0558716618,
-0.04620279,
0.0447741821,
0.0270358175,
0.078127481,
-0.0338663831,
0.0139870942,
0.03090919,
0.0398810245,
-0.0138840424,
0.0015283863,
0.0090236897,
0.0224175751,
-0.002112828,
-0.0171750486,
0.0253928583,
-0.0342088118,
-0.0251401011,
0.0431416929,
-0.0133355325,
0.0095353229,
-0.0072017801,
0.0107929176,
-0.007808385,
-0.0187649727,
-0.0938237682,
0.0174441971,
-0.0308435932,
0.0249824021,
0.0245029517,
-0.0010510565,
0.010650848,
-0.0063486975,
-0.0554240756,
0.0279320888,
-0.0058447449,
0.0147901801,
0.0403202474,
-0.0005518803,
-0.0340224467,
-0.0253333002,
-0.0341821797,
-0.0018598612,
0.0671651959,
-0.0660202876,
0.0025688088,
-0.0498404279,
-0.0168509837,
-0.0341207348,
0.0094083501,
0.0117468014,
-0.0548591353,
0.0033912177,
-0.0275706556,
-0.0053039202,
0.0489768386,
-0.0123061519,
0.010314608,
0.0302425008,
0.0206029844,
-0.0580355078,
-0.0271362942,
-0.0178098287,
-0.0065334821,
-0.0348554924,
0.0042293957,
-0.0026082727,
0.064434275,
-0.0190668497,
-0.0159751195,
-0.0827448219,
-0.0013596435,
-0.0256876964,
-0.0111862496,
-0.0191752817,
-0.0068017738,
-0.0076775942,
0.0272808,
-0.0087593989,
-0.0178205762,
0.030142596,
-0.054853633,
0.006736116,
-0.016071327,
-0.0176375173,
-0.042264387,
0.0011923871,
0.0219141766,
0.0292183049,
-0.0016002039,
-0.0564153828,
-0.0299804062,
-0.0178528726,
-0.0213788692,
-0.0118372859,
0.0261591319,
-0.0147721451,
-0.0113144787,
-0.0222088974,
-0.0256133843,
-0.0321353711,
-0.0083438838,
-0.0105077783,
0.0664373189,
0.0274789836,
-0.0009074787,
-0.0325250104,
0.0233146679,
-0.0183774512,
0.1081193164,
-0.0069363071,
0.0052414862,
-0.040895272,
0.0650572851,
0.0106903752,
-0.0237801746,
-0.0112500805,
0.0043868804,
0.0214531291,
0.0391639769,
0.0449581854,
0.0023039584,
-0.0375048444,
0.0195410997,
0.03148048,
-0.0215537734,
-0.0128952572,
-0.0180292986,
0.0350710452,
-0.0205490477,
-0.0081995986,
0.1192694679,
0.0224497709,
-0.0511856303,
0.011140801,
-0.0124720847,
0.0324642844,
0.02535001,
0.0039929445,
-0.1037656888,
-0.0276940241,
0.0221310537,
0.0116456663,
0.0332853757,
-0.0325942263,
-0.0174253024,
-0.1157529205,
-0.0054741353,
0.0423263237,
-0.0638492778,
-0.0110480683,
-0.0234706122,
-0.0294472836,
-0.0217983108,
0.0523057543,
-0.0104551408,
0.0225764476,
-0.0105211744,
0.0231556017,
0.0087080076,
-0.056042742,
-0.0035713199,
-0.0344809517,
0.064324446,
0.0332405679,
0.0141888717,
-0.0102321878,
-0.0121033173,
0.0471293777,
0.0073852534,
-0.0138436425,
-0.0122656701,
0.0431279726,
-0.053013064,
-0.02249383,
0.0826984942,
0.0320447385,
-0.0440591909,
-0.0225566905,
0.0055650589,
0.0902223215,
0.043135915,
-0.0093203774,
-0.0136304414,
-0.0404309146,
-0.0042215246,
0.0589542724,
0.0333982371,
-0.0343166552,
0.0218146686,
-0.0310167596,
-0.0032707644,
-0.0514575839,
0.0061973366,
-0.0144536486,
0.0008035483,
-0.0475548208,
-0.0960057899,
-0.0091189397,
0.0367389396,
0.0676752776,
0.0143122477,
-0.0022776173,
-0.0149922203,
-0.0295337252,
-0.0187645517,
0.0169576518,
-0.031839963,
-0.0075878161,
-0.0542664789,
0.0188180897,
0.0405476205,
-0.0163850375,
-0.0262803975,
-0.0302198455,
-0.0373420604,
-0.048787415,
-0.0378346704,
0.0468513705,
0.0150532927,
0.0582167208,
-0.0156833511,
-0.0524281748,
0.0538380034,
0.034638375,
-0.0367957205,
0.0018459201,
0.03649785,
0.0041094362,
-0.0027448612,
0.0463481881,
-0.0325484239,
0.0208093934,
0.0266864523,
0.0257620998,
-0.0115450565,
0.0149664059,
0.0016320026,
-0.0032252364,
0.0497295931,
-0.0064514722,
0.0457584187,
-0.0147616295,
0.0216154717,
-0.0367993712,
0.024135001,
-0.0526892617,
-0.0027783774,
0.0558974408,
-0.0117958104,
-0.0082668392,
-0.0103985723,
-0.019960247,
0.0428577624,
0.0069017224,
0.0077114492,
-0.0253659915,
0.0208565928,
0.0293594915,
0.0166504998,
-0.022880014,
-0.0331586413,
-0.0285463259,
0.0122370301,
-0.1001929417,
-0.0193120036,
0.022256108,
0.0499947779,
-0.0369568057,
0.0413546599,
-0.0408766046,
-0.0103534292,
-0.0231224578,
0.0268908013,
0.0447343923,
-0.0164252222,
0.0358354412,
-0.0036768911,
-0.0317036882,
-0.0143537717,
0.0213148128,
-0.0178486761,
-0.0256103147,
0.0409869812,
0.0363372937,
-0.0335414447,
-0.0022180022,
0.0709862337,
0.0127912583,
0.0383609235,
-0.0189257413,
-0.0019350023,
-0.0360828191,
0.0378084779,
0.0594002306,
0.0296128616,
-0.0061740158,
-0.0063198684,
-0.0057005007,
-0.1047491133,
0.03017704,
0.0116040073,
-0.02325112,
0.0305355992,
0.0224854723,
0.0429627709,
-0.0131961778,
-0.0060946317,
-0.0079944506,
0.0047197952,
0.0452517979,
-0.0474059209,
-0.0034181664,
-5.795716857e-33,
-0.026893612,
0.011083574,
0.0068817828,
-0.0251565557,
-0.0261165146,
0.0179468002,
-0.0255712513,
0.0044538402,
0.002260094,
0.0068531763,
-0.0222354941,
-0.0056663048,
0.0203200448,
0.0511701368,
0.0111107742,
0.0183106977,
0.0467828065,
-0.0137878451,
-0.0254313741,
0.0140749244,
0.0494081639,
0.0308492165,
0.0748171806,
0.0077459184,
-0.044161126,
-0.0048778537,
0.0152234202,
0.0365771204,
0.0561869368,
0.0352012515,
-0.0017523243,
0.0449214466,
0.0140225664,
-0.0605231524,
-0.023581313,
0.0346696712,
-0.0940368921,
-0.0514249615,
0.0138153816,
0.0082180407,
0.0062253829,
-0.1009748578,
0.0483131781,
-0.0235856306,
-0.0125858113,
0.0013448056,
0.0040401109,
0.0021691015,
-0.0466431379,
-0.0067298659,
-0.0623877123,
0.0048688785,
-0.0314662084,
-0.0044045267,
0.0626066551,
0.0260395091,
-0.0029661709,
0.0126739917,
-0.0598496571,
0.0109561505,
-0.0485875495,
0.0677604154,
0.071131058,
0.0195428375,
-0.0163992047,
0.0606606379,
0.0346169285,
-0.0251350142,
-0.0007815771,
0.0297137629,
0.0641833022,
0.005342382,
0.0419340841,
0.0099339224,
0.049653694,
-0.0506482273,
-0.062463291,
-0.0107653718,
-0.0221013781,
0.0130955633,
0.022644667,
0.0636452958,
0.0009590107,
-0.0206981972,
-0.0533303283,
-0.0480042771,
-0.0270265862,
-0.0565341227,
0.0386548005,
0.0088463742,
-0.0041039023,
-0.0158549156,
0.0658251271,
-0.0363584049,
-0.0232754089,
0.0409728587,
-0.013460557,
0.0072909114,
-0.0138040958,
0.0347037874,
-0.0697706789,
-0.0527509563,
0.0278126225,
0.0013326749,
0.030288348,
0.0062757796,
0.0707166493,
0.0208636336,
-0.0673031732,
-0.0182834398,
-0.0382915847,
-0.0016688762,
-0.0070793391,
0.0737825409,
0.0386123136,
0.0211057048,
-0.0053950516,
0.0129798129,
0.0028392274,
-0.0492693111,
0.0272602551,
0.0186159797,
0.0087921219,
0.0196320247,
-0.0478569977,
0.0067578144,
-0.0313541107,
0.0407679603,
0.0444350839,
-0.0337389,
-0.0182414688,
0.0470575094,
2.482e-7,
0.0240008403,
0.0102972398,
0.0299774371,
-0.0367541872,
0.0218882337,
0.0146375336,
-0.0271239094,
0.0581131391,
0.012890147,
-0.0049465438,
0.0071233241,
0.0296569187,
0.0261195116,
0.0252469722,
-0.1078224033,
0.0062588076,
-0.0350443311,
0.0283708032,
-0.0369622149,
-0.0023817553,
0.0549334846,
0.1075017303,
0.016170267,
0.0166617949,
-0.0025386401,
-0.0299201217,
0.0262872763,
-0.0000185916,
-0.0259871986,
-0.0050661885,
-0.0412294939,
0.0390429795,
-0.0077007273,
0.0029317243,
-0.0234039091,
0.0243346132,
0.0486137234,
0.0345421657,
-0.0248030629,
-0.0292463116,
-0.007513979,
-0.007724314,
-0.0275672097,
-0.0284370035,
0.0711396262,
-0.0638156757,
-0.0288620908,
-0.0278090294,
-0.0429039747,
0.0245572384,
0.0081132343,
-0.0025438385,
-0.0295238141,
0.0615914091,
0.0632639602,
0.0345476605,
-0.0240234379,
-0.0841216445,
0.0304797813,
0.0087300315,
-0.0462559573,
-0.0403464474,
-0.031481836,
0.0099719195,
0.020803839,
-0.0157296658,
0.0149723561,
2.153491875e-34,
0.0279564839,
-0.0243540648,
0.0312408283,
0.0364530124,
0.0086830221,
-0.0259218328,
-0.0197001509,
0.0119545963,
0.0233787298,
-0.0739894807,
-0.0233302098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07875v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07875v1
|
Reproducing the Metric-Based Evaluation of a Set of Controllable Text Generation Techniques
| 2024-05-13T16:02:57 | 2024-05-13T16:02:57 |
Michela Lorandi, Anya Belz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Rerunning a metric-based evaluation should be more straightforward, and
results should be closer, than in a human-based evaluation, especially where
code and model checkpoints are made available by the original authors. As this
report of our efforts to rerun a metric-based evaluation of a set of
single-attribute and multiple-attribute controllable text generation (CTG)
techniques shows however, such reruns of evaluations do not always produce
results that are the same as the original results, and can reveal errors in the
reporting of the original work.
|
[
-0.032947652,
0.0159596894,
0.0068057897,
-0.0142494487,
-0.037836723,
-0.0085271383,
0.0381937511,
0.0306235682,
-0.0254186708,
-0.0341717377,
-0.0283590611,
-0.0376037173,
0.0328462385,
0.0275376718,
0.0454794951,
-0.0465006717,
0.0050637866,
0.000946652,
-0.0111429272,
0.0184114408,
-0.0044854335,
-0.0080943592,
-0.0095656095,
0.0404489711,
-0.0155645469,
-0.0285433382,
-0.0250115059,
0.0006399169,
0.0144192558,
-0.0538187511,
-0.0107702427,
0.0545334555,
-0.0269321948,
0.0311240908,
0.0000020383,
-0.0333748162,
-0.0265855975,
0.0466397218,
0.0357221141,
0.0327407569,
0.090493612,
0.0347021371,
-0.009429723,
0.0160252955,
-0.0092614125,
0.0136865126,
0.0538234152,
0.0108714271,
0.0469258577,
0.0515450314,
-0.0124971382,
-0.0064562587,
-0.0235212743,
-0.0150123714,
-0.0051630675,
-0.008943107,
-0.0152122956,
0.0462249592,
0.0461619087,
-0.0196175519,
0.0115296151,
0.0399018489,
0.0007929411,
-0.0220627226,
0.030035561,
0.0381378047,
0.0171951689,
-0.0288952459,
-0.0229249056,
0.0186626166,
-0.0090172533,
-0.0103879739,
0.0323013812,
-0.0310778059,
-0.0361652449,
-0.0346338823,
-0.0348823033,
0.0089424672,
-0.0241432507,
-0.0077264491,
-0.0659726858,
0.0172481351,
-0.009664272,
-0.0207105316,
-0.0245148689,
0.0226811152,
0.0129583813,
-0.0424685068,
-0.0332776755,
0.0494719036,
0.0296003073,
-0.0854533836,
0.0197098143,
0.0200119615,
0.0184665881,
0.0138749499,
-0.0478888527,
-0.0848511904,
0.0486906879,
-0.042458605,
0.0634208173,
-0.0075148586,
0.0095294397,
-0.0406010412,
-0.0542215072,
0.1017957479,
-0.0061011277,
0.0194727238,
-0.0071975598,
0.0669570491,
-0.0360670201,
-0.0313828588,
-0.0228405576,
0.0362975858,
0.0075329053,
-0.0190144833,
-0.0759626701,
0.0260940641,
-0.011131309,
0.0271447878,
0.031879846,
-0.0147049809,
-0.0404772758,
0.0203964394,
-0.0012621634,
-0.0441576466,
-0.0096364664,
-0.0252244454,
0.0343248919,
-0.0360381752,
-0.0055458131,
0.0336779654,
0.0024038549,
0.0016944462,
-0.0352119654,
0.0625127479,
-0.0535744093,
-0.0103849377,
0.0326778106,
-0.048159495,
-0.0372982584,
-0.0247406438,
-0.0329084881,
-0.0537894964,
-0.0043744794,
0.0078697233,
-0.0054374156,
-0.0491174944,
0.0250546802,
0.0064683408,
0.0215854738,
0.0280067474,
-0.0140187331,
-0.010485501,
-0.0071328641,
-0.0177685749,
0.008396036,
0.035088893,
0.0548301823,
0.0808998048,
0.0174334999,
0.0176394656,
0.0326065272,
0.002013498,
0.0404871665,
0.0140220542,
-0.0338857174,
-0.0360108428,
0.0276253186,
0.0486522503,
0.0164871756,
0.0260950923,
-0.037451528,
0.0569823459,
0.0348970629,
0.0018340558,
0.0569815896,
0.0066862046,
0.0797301158,
-0.0030757566,
0.0051829889,
0.0105843311,
0.0299266148,
0.0075470069,
0.0228945874,
0.0616024733,
0.0364813767,
0.029139081,
0.0061237691,
-0.0495389067,
-0.0088775512,
-0.0041258316,
-0.0183457918,
-0.0499061793,
0.0567357689,
0.0481644198,
-0.0684783384,
-0.0284388661,
0.0062482948,
-0.080938749,
0.0022168898,
-0.0445662178,
-0.0002592065,
0.0703725666,
0.084876433,
-0.0040659676,
0.0093476176,
0.0412853062,
-0.0201079566,
0.0368469805,
0.0513919182,
0.0121570453,
-0.0386968739,
-0.0540349334,
-0.0251176413,
-0.0257277023,
-0.0088817794,
0.0550029427,
-0.0253711175,
0.0432999805,
0.0361279696,
0.0055509564,
-0.0608493686,
0.0339966044,
0.0279786158,
0.0100893192,
0.0256146211,
-0.0153546659,
-0.0020068015,
0.0247656107,
-0.0620408133,
0.0611994714,
-0.004252228,
0.0042984639,
-0.0444765575,
0.0024812385,
-0.0017154516,
-0.0300143603,
0.0047967732,
-0.0290115252,
0.0222027861,
-0.0328766331,
0.0108293761,
-0.0513779745,
-0.008238703,
-0.054129418,
0.0076236697,
-0.0175193027,
0.0475960225,
0.0033896994,
-0.0324568041,
-0.0391990207,
0.0597575754,
0.0099451626,
0.0108655281,
-0.0175099913,
0.0485865511,
0.028949555,
-0.0281247683,
0.0029798874,
0.0392985158,
-0.0013257063,
0.0058914288,
0.0104220193,
0.0334238112,
0.0066295257,
-0.0685134903,
-0.0355902165,
-0.0305109564,
0.0082941111,
0.0340633839,
0.0209047291,
-0.0247492865,
0.0030914354,
0.0255649984,
-0.0475804731,
-0.0350878276,
0.0194426067,
-0.0267079398,
0.0505300537,
0.0079056844,
-0.0040078708,
-0.0234428458,
-0.0270952694,
-0.0038327833,
0.0627585053,
0.0615281202,
-0.015098162,
-0.081137687,
0.0705885962,
-0.0528274253,
-0.0263313148,
0.029146824,
-0.0360055715,
0.0445722193,
-0.0009600615,
0.0462920144,
0.0328186341,
0.03650802,
0.0449866615,
0.022824889,
-0.0024241481,
-0.0516887195,
-0.0128209125,
-0.024696352,
-0.0075732074,
0.0477265157,
-0.0634827912,
0.0626343116,
0.02959162,
0.0405924395,
0.0325870439,
-0.0786601081,
0.0343947746,
-0.0360577367,
-0.0561328866,
-0.0204980355,
-0.0157858916,
-0.0182525795,
0.0479174592,
-0.017844703,
-0.0538360849,
0.0336024202,
-0.0589960031,
-0.0066548414,
-0.0267183967,
0.0312864333,
0.0109247072,
0.0267822351,
-0.0031764216,
0.0200402103,
0.0412398577,
-0.0125585282,
-0.0087158754,
0.0185239296,
0.0352055691,
-0.0307916217,
-0.0242367052,
-0.0254527833,
0.0136236399,
-0.0154631808,
-0.021156108,
-0.0143717043,
0.0110900244,
0.0171765424,
-0.0324557796,
0.0473527871,
-0.0497794859,
-0.0113491779,
0.0427758954,
0.0694192871,
0.0049595181,
-0.0403143391,
-0.0172092579,
-0.0043248604,
0.0056462646,
-0.00372925,
-0.04980148,
-0.0162861142,
-0.0542806387,
-0.0176241733,
0.0374848768,
0.0160535797,
0.0356268287,
-0.0162482969,
-0.0022592307,
-0.0098935235,
0.0095658815,
-0.0309734568,
0.0191303026,
0.0484647863,
-0.0246664751,
-0.0255049188,
0.0546680689,
0.0311049651,
0.0022739978,
0.0026482658,
0.0280142054,
0.0614380315,
-0.0015321255,
0.0215410758,
-0.0575124957,
0.0360830538,
-0.0009213024,
0.1005916372,
-0.0686967373,
0.0033354412,
-0.022574205,
-0.0786554441,
0.0496585555,
0.0151228337,
-0.0410923548,
-0.0179619379,
-0.002584599,
-0.01252886,
0.027293155,
-0.054735709,
0.0459280647,
0.0098947426,
0.0286248922,
0.0496651568,
-0.0327128842,
-0.0386962183,
-0.0426270403,
0.031014869,
0.0293965358,
0.0737561211,
0.0304184929,
0.0292170011,
-0.0315428227,
-0.0224582255,
-0.0015739757,
0.0680223107,
-0.0382157229,
0.0305331778,
0.030739747,
-0.0403529368,
-0.0174111333,
-0.0041737854,
0.0392712727,
-0.0001743198,
-0.0141411433,
-0.0002715203,
-0.0341739282,
-0.021140201,
-0.0032547624,
0.0004317978,
0.0255594626,
0.0014131768,
0.0437398367,
-0.0359247327,
-0.0917498618,
-0.0243530739,
0.0103201969,
-0.1216443852,
-0.0133295469,
-0.0341572128,
-0.0568149127,
-0.0647778735,
-0.0931889415,
-0.0186629873,
0.0099258628,
0.0960905701,
-0.0187499393,
-0.0270806774,
-0.0055358261,
-0.0077571655,
-0.0793010071,
-0.0334719829,
-0.0000992824,
0.0341401286,
-0.053723786,
-0.0240833797,
-0.0129779521,
-0.0153303556,
-0.0147604728,
0.0728723556,
-0.0255328156,
-0.056298919,
-0.0211755969,
0.062289793,
0.0268436465,
-0.027865354,
-0.029393293,
-0.029486293,
0.0537072457,
0.0228272919,
0.0135580674,
0.0347969756,
0.0246362127,
-0.0062381667,
-0.0136164371,
-0.0266429391,
-0.0244957786,
0.0029395125,
0.0186313652,
0.0239821933,
0.0136604561,
-0.0120891975,
-0.0166946333,
0.0473942012,
-0.0322645232,
-0.061784517,
0.0304946247,
0.0004673567,
-0.0284913462,
-0.0635307133,
-0.0103406888,
-0.070933491,
0.0263890028,
-0.0253104065,
0.0080235507,
-0.002904542,
0.0031932236,
-0.053868182,
0.0313559249,
-0.0174137037,
0.0375606343,
-0.0361402296,
0.0879205316,
0.0386815779,
-0.0024001878,
-0.0191543419,
-0.0071967118,
-0.007067577,
0.0078061474,
0.0063671088,
0.0156937465,
0.0530721098,
0.0196690932,
-0.0100267241,
0.0698175207,
-0.0183615107,
0.0258281454,
-0.0708389357,
0.0002626563,
0.0132347029,
0.1021927297,
0.0905794948,
-0.0437162519,
0.0204230677,
0.0015559638,
0.0513323434,
0.0249923989,
-0.0141808847,
-0.0499986932,
-0.0227979999,
-0.006728908,
-0.0704548359,
0.091440253,
-0.0378644615,
-0.0192078408,
-0.0740396827,
-0.034992449,
-0.0536096767,
-0.0225034505,
0.0032666849,
-0.0365050286,
0.0233134944,
-0.0658377111,
-0.0618723631,
-0.0330588371,
0.0530737191,
0.0509881116,
0.035986498,
-0.0079684304,
0.0515456796,
0.0190152563,
-0.001974564,
0.0252415109,
-0.0117151774,
-0.0129686436,
-0.0107129915,
-0.0121372035,
-0.0102814026,
-5.727268188e-33,
-0.0414626412,
-0.0371319093,
-0.0255167577,
-0.0357707292,
-0.068924889,
0.0010560364,
-0.0496912822,
0.0252985675,
0.0822214261,
-0.0076858993,
0.0142441122,
-0.0329836383,
0.0155078424,
-0.0303770546,
0.0086558359,
0.0301165134,
0.033700306,
-0.0312319864,
-0.0849213004,
0.0553991534,
0.0389146619,
0.0215341728,
0.0061868872,
-0.0670254156,
0.0513513386,
0.0218105577,
-0.044231724,
-0.0439693816,
0.0097253025,
0.0201405585,
0.0101284711,
0.0009067143,
0.0088241035,
-0.0477700904,
-0.0566088632,
0.0175664946,
-0.0058041345,
-0.0405149907,
-0.0198786128,
-0.0090557961,
-0.0192747246,
-0.02526097,
0.0311181862,
-0.010317279,
-0.059058819,
0.0179587044,
0.0131227309,
-0.004247583,
-0.0232331082,
-0.0678502992,
-0.0315955542,
0.0413970128,
-0.0011673152,
0.0006184216,
0.0075562373,
0.038925834,
-0.0220566094,
-0.006398024,
0.0108071892,
0.0329114012,
0.0719153732,
0.0044289366,
0.0558684655,
0.0454921648,
0.0478299856,
0.0209429823,
0.0378136821,
0.0436435752,
-0.0704909191,
0.007219437,
0.021332249,
0.03908002,
0.0695940182,
0.0452504978,
-0.0360179991,
-0.0133130541,
-0.026375033,
0.05420224,
-0.0445625857,
-0.0168810003,
0.0381374247,
0.0030235643,
-0.051502157,
-0.0078113116,
-0.0259965044,
-0.0100552607,
-0.0268325079,
-0.0474409126,
0.0327947102,
0.0140872262,
-0.0484871157,
0.0006879519,
-0.0032587291,
0.0227115825,
0.0007939418,
-0.0489506871,
-0.0398649834,
0.0645159259,
-0.0250714924,
-0.0358652808,
0.003789118,
-0.0222045612,
0.0428733006,
0.090066731,
0.0359959304,
-0.01070223,
-0.0173689146,
0.016166443,
-0.0549988747,
0.0217845291,
-0.0097275106,
0.0212554205,
0.038479574,
-0.0415898748,
-0.0207163692,
-0.0456848219,
-0.0145791126,
0.0361845195,
0.0101640038,
-0.0212261286,
-0.0280669965,
-0.0100534167,
0.0224287864,
0.0343356617,
-0.0324907638,
0.0161596332,
-0.028864665,
0.0245114844,
0.069460392,
-0.023966115,
-0.033775609,
0.0099087385,
2.689e-7,
0.0401019119,
0.0309624635,
0.0658091456,
0.0134132262,
0.0038111072,
0.007184837,
0.0042026849,
0.0341141634,
-0.009094975,
0.023293566,
0.0246477574,
-0.0147786913,
0.0641437545,
0.0000262988,
0.0141371191,
0.0186567456,
-0.0586995631,
0.0183075499,
-0.0559639633,
0.0003580297,
0.0814492404,
-0.0395678841,
-0.017009493,
0.024212094,
0.0252134632,
0.0083357515,
0.0320875086,
0.029400859,
0.0281238612,
0.0077177137,
0.0572081059,
-0.0406735018,
-0.009379332,
0.0104984213,
-0.0262940004,
-0.0551104769,
0.0639905557,
0.0238593481,
0.0115198614,
0.0087059112,
0.047640495,
-0.0285644233,
-0.0007246549,
-0.0591817088,
0.0134110041,
-0.0201607421,
0.0006702715,
-0.0086168787,
-0.004686784,
0.0115940105,
0.0085129198,
-0.0150525877,
-0.0013471034,
0.0358441062,
0.0035485041,
0.035886433,
0.0293244869,
-0.0078022899,
-0.0435679443,
-0.017253438,
-0.0459327511,
-0.0582317114,
-0.0630234182,
0.0481740609,
-0.002147279,
-0.0326240063,
-0.024274461,
2.471317768e-34,
0.0129384743,
-0.0551987402,
-0.0113983778,
-0.0333967097,
0.0102646798,
0.0112153441,
0.0441482589,
0.0112804566,
0.0247891583,
-0.024248926,
-0.0333100483
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07863v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07863v2
|
RLHF Workflow: From Reward Modeling to Online RLHF
| 2024-05-13T15:50:39 | 2024-06-12T04:40:53 |
Hanze Dong, Wei Xiong, Bo Pang, Haoxiang Wang, Han Zhao, Yingbo Zhou, Nan Jiang, Doyen Sahoo, Caiming Xiong, Tong Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
We present the workflow of Online Iterative Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF) in this technical report, which is widely reported to
outperform its offline counterpart by a large margin in the recent large
language model (LLM) literature. However, existing open-source RLHF projects
are still largely confined to the offline learning setting. In this technical
report, we aim to fill in this gap and provide a detailed recipe that is easy
to reproduce for online iterative RLHF. In particular, since online human
feedback is usually infeasible for open-source communities with limited
resources, we start by constructing preference models using a diverse set of
open-source datasets and use the constructed proxy preference model to
approximate human feedback. Then, we discuss the theoretical insights and
algorithmic principles behind online iterative RLHF, followed by a detailed
practical implementation. Our trained LLM, LLaMA-3-8B-SFR-Iterative-DPO-R,
achieves impressive performance on LLM chatbot benchmarks, including
AlpacaEval-2, Arena-Hard, and MT-Bench, as well as other academic benchmarks
such as HumanEval and TruthfulQA. We have shown that supervised fine-tuning
(SFT) and iterative RLHF can obtain state-of-the-art performance with fully
open-source datasets. Further, we have made our models, curated datasets, and
comprehensive step-by-step code guidebooks publicly available. Please refer to
https://github.com/RLHFlow/RLHF-Reward-Modeling and
https://github.com/RLHFlow/Online-RLHF for more detailed information.
|
[
0.0844403133,
0.06500642,
-0.0000804703,
-0.0087111434,
-0.0349726453,
0.0338312313,
-0.0102763325,
0.0180710144,
0.0147191966,
-0.0325959288,
-0.0744785815,
-0.0259001292,
-0.0087322267,
0.0223325845,
-0.0007494917,
-0.0603920929,
0.0197342373,
-0.0533927642,
0.0018833377,
-0.0143364128,
0.0276354346,
0.0206145067,
-0.0288727805,
0.0605530255,
0.0144853061,
-0.0080451779,
-0.0171573162,
0.0083311889,
0.0136235114,
-0.0205549747,
0.0180704296,
0.0588798709,
0.0326096341,
0.0419363081,
0.000002055,
-0.0395553857,
-0.0354821458,
-0.0174219478,
-0.0120320702,
-0.0338861048,
0.0582393482,
0.0239761621,
-0.0392389707,
0.0296082757,
-0.0095048659,
-0.01006399,
0.039504014,
0.0324806944,
0.045549266,
0.0794581845,
0.023358902,
0.0069149258,
0.0112133361,
-0.0354253091,
0.0141211292,
-0.0272944402,
0.0243660957,
0.0042633289,
0.0084832627,
0.000810594,
-0.0287949275,
-0.0039454475,
0.0372513197,
-0.0192353297,
0.0292645376,
0.0189675614,
-0.0373064056,
-0.0471300036,
-0.017737193,
0.117871955,
-0.011405929,
0.0000367599,
0.0293527171,
0.0109098917,
-0.0152447829,
-0.0123129943,
-0.0336581953,
0.0513170287,
0.002430412,
0.0170302987,
-0.0187019128,
-0.0410326123,
-0.0037710026,
0.0375623703,
0.0050260564,
0.0496454611,
-0.0126970951,
-0.0276736189,
0.014334308,
-0.0051711975,
-0.0342545137,
-0.0537149832,
0.0098705133,
0.0287943408,
-0.0898465216,
-0.0085626403,
-0.0239363126,
-0.0058411602,
0.0086914683,
-0.0299427435,
0.0519381203,
0.0296050962,
0.0141750351,
0.0501984507,
0.0026916072,
0.0552652217,
-0.003545427,
0.0438271277,
-0.0179343186,
0.0229871403,
-0.0377737917,
0.0161994435,
-0.0206316151,
0.0511279851,
-0.0075924774,
-0.0292512421,
-0.0461918078,
0.0173167456,
-0.022592051,
0.0475667976,
0.0119904326,
-0.0052751903,
-0.0762098283,
0.0033258882,
-0.0494241975,
0.0344550423,
-0.0309537668,
0.0019719221,
0.0201925803,
-0.0560233928,
0.0168304816,
0.0215278771,
-0.0031437241,
-0.0216236133,
0.0207096729,
0.0927252099,
0.0066639823,
-0.0233897287,
0.0361883603,
-0.0133956317,
0.0096956203,
-0.0811001733,
-0.0017088808,
-0.0572837666,
0.0306744054,
-0.0469646975,
0.0075065773,
0.0101090679,
0.0018010004,
0.024391029,
-0.01589722,
0.0550063588,
0.0017011916,
0.0171289258,
0.0106973266,
-0.018356923,
-0.0175037067,
0.0495775864,
0.0242101084,
0.0471246168,
0.0263129435,
-0.0002667431,
0.0131511567,
0.0303293839,
0.0186581649,
0.020803364,
-0.0419992507,
0.014624835,
0.0199285392,
0.071782805,
0.0417581312,
0.038953796,
-0.0734613687,
0.0309311859,
0.0801497325,
0.038871944,
0.0064630536,
-0.0101704439,
0.0110073546,
0.0654888675,
0.0102051692,
-0.0161604006,
-0.0512881801,
0.0428088903,
-0.0189622976,
-0.0120049873,
0.0206824169,
0.0065728882,
-0.0352715664,
-0.0460556149,
0.0241689365,
-0.0147272497,
0.0223993994,
0.0273069628,
0.0750398487,
0.0188336167,
-0.0445920117,
-0.0354609191,
0.0685316697,
-0.0146614201,
-0.0034826864,
-0.0773452297,
0.0707757622,
0.0922782272,
0.0759676695,
-0.027658999,
0.0041622599,
-0.0626750216,
-0.0081173815,
0.069901742,
0.013751559,
-0.0336663201,
-0.0314474255,
-0.0419686586,
-0.02965427,
0.0272914935,
-0.0154645797,
0.0228870101,
0.0505494587,
-0.014276471,
-0.0331660993,
0.034826465,
-0.0465571322,
0.0107649658,
0.0140691809,
0.0048658135,
0.0142956888,
0.0104871662,
0.0596266128,
-0.0182438567,
0.0009431955,
-0.0101428227,
-0.0006250135,
0.0001383743,
-0.0432282947,
-0.0191639178,
-0.0303883795,
-0.0174870845,
0.0441642851,
-0.0079315873,
-0.0018055867,
0.067890875,
-0.0432910062,
0.0124054039,
-0.0010171557,
0.0058356263,
0.0343102105,
-0.0104993545,
0.0119361812,
-0.0276986249,
-0.0141250398,
-0.0515837222,
0.0121321538,
0.0019738174,
0.0085646426,
-0.0173480697,
0.0063617574,
-0.0547552146,
-0.0593224168,
-0.0121284183,
0.0412502363,
-0.0190467425,
0.0289926603,
0.0237479284,
0.0531376861,
-0.0433072746,
-0.037266206,
-0.0422177017,
-0.0196284242,
-0.0240757689,
-0.0132708736,
0.0256651379,
-0.0201652758,
-0.0034511175,
-0.0460666902,
-0.0004701359,
-0.0004972048,
0.0177007727,
0.0391877145,
0.0231537335,
0.0077112741,
-0.0174903236,
-0.0538598783,
-0.0265751872,
0.0358220227,
-0.007617034,
-0.0131248143,
0.0100656394,
-0.0370945334,
0.0054442873,
-0.0366860107,
0.0168713666,
-0.025677368,
-0.0595304035,
0.0225244183,
-0.0464901701,
0.0179607235,
0.0975009277,
0.0296753366,
0.0333672687,
0.0243997127,
0.0116202431,
-0.0889515504,
0.0119478349,
-0.0316643156,
-0.0726058334,
-0.0463838167,
0.0247280598,
-0.0089818053,
0.0616391152,
-0.0254468042,
0.0407600179,
-0.0668342933,
-0.003089604,
-0.0125084259,
-0.0413009264,
-0.0494978204,
0.0155604156,
-0.0276731588,
0.0065876842,
-0.0140600158,
-0.0802692771,
0.1050132439,
0.0151313031,
0.0016490072,
-0.0591616705,
-0.0247353185,
-0.0190447941,
0.0140151521,
0.0059365253,
0.0327346101,
-0.0092023183,
-0.0224485155,
-0.0432382114,
-0.0422946885,
0.0304890089,
-0.0576311052,
0.0004117004,
-0.0130659537,
-0.0066272533,
0.0009835346,
-0.0598244034,
-0.027336698,
-0.0324226655,
-0.0441195667,
-0.0264772661,
-0.0109208561,
-0.0389678031,
-0.0052513722,
0.0111063449,
0.0309450235,
0.0298459642,
-0.0180910733,
-0.0155521203,
-0.0245363172,
-0.005605801,
0.0846682563,
0.039557565,
0.0031418132,
-0.0242222622,
0.0216390565,
0.0423101261,
0.0670927987,
-0.0015111596,
0.0216337685,
0.0095972689,
0.0359079763,
-0.0338904075,
0.0079270452,
0.0337441526,
0.0223148577,
-0.0466818549,
-0.0169513859,
0.1002376452,
0.0073130666,
-0.0875721648,
0.0100510148,
-0.0207656156,
0.0773252472,
0.0076495348,
0.0452892706,
-0.0830748677,
-0.026420664,
0.0281892493,
0.0482072644,
-0.0103585348,
-0.0307771098,
0.0215680487,
-0.1234016865,
0.0292746816,
-0.004638195,
-0.061655499,
-0.0271148644,
-0.0441285558,
-0.0014041495,
-0.0452338383,
0.0310667269,
0.0414624996,
-0.0064433557,
-0.0003658572,
0.0043889196,
0.0054351608,
-0.0251725093,
0.0420569293,
-0.0427640826,
0.0701748207,
0.1149893403,
0.0263102707,
0.0141354045,
-0.0022727088,
0.0246161651,
0.03419514,
-0.0131731816,
-0.0382994637,
0.0325799212,
-0.0389904343,
-0.0228156187,
-0.0555987693,
0.0635814145,
-0.0101372823,
0.0056663454,
-0.011411963,
0.0430582203,
-0.0000500512,
0.013879858,
0.0217729472,
0.0120674772,
0.0460858978,
0.050928548,
-0.0063440017,
-0.0945490375,
-0.0334895626,
-0.0163063183,
-0.0239070654,
0.0021127586,
-0.0352522843,
-0.0301321447,
0.0032903061,
0.0252289325,
-0.0603658631,
-0.0299209207,
0.0032611664,
0.0380807482,
-0.0140278023,
-0.023963429,
0.0276970491,
0.0317946337,
0.011846385,
0.0393349156,
-0.0690906718,
0.0232774764,
-0.0880646482,
-0.0262560491,
0.0368213579,
-0.0525483377,
-0.0084527079,
0.0084409863,
-0.0547259115,
-0.0370772406,
0.0008423597,
0.0562969483,
0.0195087325,
0.0689739212,
-0.0316123366,
-0.0584135912,
0.023787817,
0.0013501373,
-0.0436172262,
0.009981731,
0.0361495949,
0.0560351722,
0.000491778,
0.0451016724,
-0.0547354184,
0.0027556627,
0.0269106068,
0.0368372016,
0.0076593012,
-0.0211062022,
0.0176030025,
0.0108131152,
0.0231226273,
0.0138552329,
-0.0378323607,
-0.0300068539,
0.0375773497,
0.0099837491,
-0.0303805321,
-0.0458520167,
0.0137743661,
0.0310650878,
-0.0258243475,
-0.0063093784,
0.0022025888,
0.0184603445,
0.0263785832,
-0.0110319322,
0.0043908469,
0.0087537309,
-0.0031266552,
0.041846659,
0.0260728244,
0.0079742698,
0.0314538963,
0.0087588895,
0.040612556,
0.0058182632,
0.0705374256,
0.0317819417,
-0.032458473,
0.0064442093,
0.0109526189,
-0.0304674152,
-0.0648084283,
-0.0269572437,
0.0329493284,
0.0481943488,
0.0461114496,
0.0511087626,
-0.0042966632,
-0.0114798537,
-0.0216545742,
0.0184481107,
-0.0463034101,
-0.0268681496,
0.0068526668,
0.0318590775,
-0.019968858,
0.0290224273,
0.0552011281,
0.0059069525,
0.0338291526,
-0.0043979925,
0.0110901864,
-0.0203513131,
-0.0145359607,
-0.0084198145,
0.0151062524,
-0.0347518474,
-0.0158801004,
-0.0078245169,
-0.038077198,
-0.0294107441,
0.017669661,
-0.0385018289,
-0.0048244218,
0.0367679894,
0.0267232452,
-0.027033573,
-0.0062971949,
-0.081823647,
-0.0092269247,
0.0011578171,
-0.0234426893,
0.0016017482,
-6.381917522e-33,
-0.0361694433,
-0.0208155699,
0.0015505141,
-0.0137454998,
-0.0484311692,
-0.0198711939,
-0.0107450252,
-0.0151587762,
-0.0065418016,
-0.0116863865,
-0.0225000437,
0.009807189,
0.0222117417,
0.0206680447,
0.0065192454,
-0.0307169892,
0.0494303741,
-0.0284597091,
-0.0554880053,
0.0465955175,
0.0113297766,
0.017759813,
0.0325284749,
-0.01749379,
-0.006354535,
-0.000341583,
-0.0397991836,
0.0480781086,
-0.0525651239,
0.0786908492,
-0.0121075474,
0.0057800175,
-0.0101538338,
-0.0433716737,
-0.0193397943,
0.0212678835,
-0.0968512967,
0.0075571253,
-0.0378351212,
0.0241167396,
-0.0317088887,
-0.001051401,
0.0472015068,
-0.0145857697,
-0.0061364654,
0.0095541589,
0.0022075027,
-0.0104864882,
-0.0377483368,
0.0112661831,
-0.0384017155,
0.0081459144,
-0.0020773783,
-0.0280884262,
0.0040271971,
0.049371507,
-0.0191556923,
0.0516550615,
-0.0680852681,
0.0572323464,
-0.0099043688,
0.0040379553,
0.0460248441,
0.0211189445,
0.0602724403,
0.044499401,
-0.0023105452,
0.014692083,
0.0187406242,
-0.0154252686,
0.025816543,
0.0269275494,
0.0090253986,
0.0350162983,
0.0151902111,
-0.0025635934,
-0.0454768725,
-0.0114177652,
0.0351858586,
0.0652793795,
0.037634138,
0.0330626369,
-0.0544794984,
-0.0004862984,
-0.0381540209,
-0.0222966224,
-0.0270400736,
-0.0715655312,
0.0362397321,
0.0571745299,
-0.0323419683,
-0.0542629957,
0.0295853224,
-0.0338278338,
-0.031166967,
0.0334741399,
-0.0314779244,
0.0362743475,
-0.0147651117,
-0.0090917824,
-0.0987321138,
-0.0452335477,
-0.0016612735,
-0.0459985472,
-0.0243329462,
0.0082590394,
0.0204563439,
0.0455970876,
-0.057524059,
0.0227817465,
-0.0070644231,
0.0299000572,
0.01212529,
0.0486550257,
0.041018486,
-0.0385666974,
-0.0077797975,
0.0841659084,
-0.0153002655,
-0.0264215264,
-0.0317652114,
-0.0005934912,
-0.015310199,
-0.0148004508,
-0.0126041984,
0.0036966407,
-0.0582350753,
0.0105391443,
0.0037525392,
-0.03623854,
-0.0115241678,
-0.0226156022,
2.807e-7,
-0.0459945761,
0.0560048707,
0.0139076244,
0.0065825661,
0.0261225644,
0.0397002101,
-0.0097682131,
0.0181421004,
0.0067604049,
0.0114802402,
0.0204500314,
0.0533744693,
0.062497545,
-0.0145837283,
-0.0736943558,
-0.0305617843,
-0.0977996215,
0.001445053,
-0.0443892255,
-0.0468163602,
-0.0158862583,
0.1020100415,
0.0425950401,
-0.0178776719,
0.0368436314,
0.0233103205,
0.0415111296,
-0.028962655,
-0.0471717641,
0.0319748223,
-0.0181887969,
0.0231160745,
-0.0166174415,
-0.0226589888,
0.0204332322,
-0.0030066916,
-0.00136657,
0.0956775174,
0.0197779834,
-0.0461239368,
-0.0087188603,
0.0096539296,
0.0122728581,
-0.0485509373,
0.062628895,
-0.0612313747,
-0.0285693239,
-0.0387671217,
0.0124946395,
-0.0611100756,
0.0364124514,
-0.0581181757,
-0.0175635349,
0.0195911583,
0.0142712696,
0.0214432608,
-0.0262767952,
-0.0576083437,
0.0151249208,
0.0097533027,
-0.0381648727,
-0.0676831156,
-0.0490631498,
0.0142524326,
-0.0153799681,
-0.0323220231,
0.0133294994,
2.40670346e-34,
0.0287761893,
0.0073347096,
0.0083590047,
0.0265486296,
0.020970583,
0.0304101463,
0.0211687703,
-0.0011086112,
0.0542279594,
-0.0796059892,
-0.0068305186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07840v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07840v1
|
Open-vocabulary Auditory Neural Decoding Using fMRI-prompted LLM
| 2024-05-13T15:25:11 | 2024-05-13T15:25:11 |
Xiaoyu Chen, Changde Du, Che Liu, Yizhe Wang, Huiguang He
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Decoding language information from brain signals represents a vital research
area within brain-computer interfaces, particularly in the context of
deciphering the semantic information from the fMRI signal. However, many
existing efforts concentrate on decoding small vocabulary sets, leaving space
for the exploration of open vocabulary continuous text decoding. In this paper,
we introduce a novel method, the \textbf{Brain Prompt GPT (BP-GPT)}. By using
the brain representation that is extracted from the fMRI as a prompt, our
method can utilize GPT-2 to decode fMRI signals into stimulus text. Further, we
introduce a text-to-text baseline and align the fMRI prompt to the text prompt.
By introducing the text-to-text baseline, our BP-GPT can extract a more robust
brain prompt and promote the decoding of pre-trained LLM. We evaluate our
BP-GPT on the open-source auditory semantic decoding dataset and achieve a
significant improvement up to $4.61\%$ on METEOR and $2.43\%$ on BERTScore
across all the subjects compared to the state-of-the-art method. The
experimental results demonstrate that using brain representation as a prompt to
further drive LLM for auditory neural decoding is feasible and effective.
|
[
-0.0459553972,
0.0488537587,
-0.0042806538,
0.0362850577,
-0.0097496016,
0.0168184713,
0.0087556066,
0.0623817816,
0.0051626144,
0.0465182476,
-0.0734797046,
-0.0077387909,
0.0734536126,
0.0676903725,
0.0038153899,
-0.0034105051,
0.0047908602,
-0.0279532392,
0.0060049267,
-0.0040432257,
-0.0400247276,
0.0291777924,
-0.0725814179,
0.0472481996,
0.0502070449,
-0.0065945694,
-0.0020860652,
0.0043632947,
0.030650327,
-0.0378916822,
-0.052786991,
0.0293071121,
0.022223739,
0.0123208063,
0.0000017263,
-0.0193407871,
0.0187449958,
0.0033094431,
-0.0360729247,
-0.0173072983,
0.0126659879,
0.0142090451,
-0.009687257,
-0.0021649916,
-0.0056164488,
-0.0271791406,
0.0469971038,
0.090887025,
0.0009775524,
0.0119661065,
-0.0174106434,
-0.0076250713,
0.075705044,
-0.0165375527,
0.0292906296,
0.0107360044,
0.0043563433,
-0.062971577,
-0.0184934381,
0.0270561781,
-0.006842962,
0.0469539613,
0.0083010392,
0.0550201721,
-0.0086848373,
0.0792711675,
0.0200216528,
-0.0241182931,
-0.0618150011,
0.0579790287,
0.0759268701,
-0.0018762315,
-0.020479003,
-0.0028745921,
-0.0302286595,
-0.0134207681,
-0.0178517848,
0.0661641136,
-0.0301745068,
0.0800799131,
0.0181185622,
-0.024430912,
0.0286686011,
-0.0178943444,
-0.0139943128,
0.071622476,
-0.0031929002,
-0.0440140441,
0.0910560861,
0.0054931985,
-0.0342670977,
-0.0053825881,
0.0595602319,
0.0064288545,
-0.0142424786,
-0.0090484507,
-0.0456046984,
-0.0555953719,
0.0064180386,
0.007177589,
-0.000004428,
0.0540051535,
-0.063436456,
0.0185604971,
-0.0218154863,
0.0003726269,
-0.0502542481,
0.0537455715,
-0.0079334294,
-0.0139541663,
-0.0186549649,
-0.0138373571,
0.003921743,
-0.0043080016,
-0.0343386307,
-0.0284203589,
-0.0017158468,
0.0111391144,
0.0171546824,
-0.0424341857,
0.0198673848,
0.0019350199,
-0.0310522821,
0.0517772548,
-0.0128196543,
0.0147468923,
0.0366381891,
0.0230898373,
0.0231371578,
-0.0551411621,
-0.0519481376,
0.0400000066,
0.0102813076,
-0.0523430742,
-0.0182668455,
0.0399246216,
-0.0163976103,
-0.0217808727,
-0.0241216812,
0.0183660444,
-0.0003565289,
0.0457745753,
0.0106236739,
-0.0262240041,
0.0469878353,
0.0209608395,
-0.0062705753,
-0.0514076389,
-0.0092443572,
-0.0113231307,
-0.0384847708,
0.0433109552,
-0.0941080227,
-0.0272850115,
0.0825857371,
0.0471204072,
0.0015502017,
0.0136031127,
0.0256776139,
0.0174604319,
-0.0280381385,
0.0001620637,
-0.0471729375,
0.0525975227,
0.0230066478,
-0.0317206793,
-0.0184993893,
-0.034482684,
0.0250199009,
0.046830073,
0.0606265105,
0.0301729012,
-0.0250330176,
-0.007872859,
0.0340663828,
0.0709469467,
0.0046332274,
0.0024482131,
0.0011621276,
0.0038592666,
0.0034109131,
-0.0132941501,
-0.0106867198,
0.0270507615,
-0.0187932681,
-0.0051369872,
0.0407805108,
-0.0361307301,
0.0063530705,
0.0227234438,
0.0236452296,
-0.0318013243,
-0.0115442658,
0.0319088437,
0.0550212003,
-0.0270527322,
-0.0373213962,
0.0356766433,
0.0343435965,
-0.0065638986,
0.0146474894,
-0.0393338762,
0.0540091135,
0.0268459674,
0.0250631887,
-0.058464773,
0.0006925811,
0.014207501,
-0.0170074757,
0.0661146343,
-0.0293169301,
0.0513799973,
0.0684806257,
-0.0484783612,
-0.0548260994,
0.046864219,
-0.0181162227,
0.0187152307,
0.002700608,
0.0282266494,
-0.0337429866,
-0.0089935921,
-0.0079990337,
0.0350993276,
-0.0119722495,
-0.0212211106,
0.0330562443,
-0.0135798231,
0.0430299528,
-0.0164364856,
-0.0523815192,
-0.0056130695,
0.0323673524,
-0.0274615791,
0.0151093416,
-0.0367309861,
-0.0430963002,
-0.0137229571,
0.0057883477,
0.0143491952,
-0.0403666198,
0.0581697226,
-0.0007790714,
-0.0029621832,
-0.0203176271,
0.0033322854,
-0.0031306117,
-0.0570257492,
-0.0221559368,
0.0072220704,
0.022278402,
-0.0478404202,
-0.0182741974,
-0.0317781903,
-0.009057234,
0.023706194,
-0.0130900154,
0.0271211378,
-0.0764956027,
-0.016500473,
0.0908460692,
-0.0124248238,
-0.0267605241,
-0.0325395204,
0.0233838819,
-0.0460011959,
-0.0197596047,
-0.0913117677,
-0.011237829,
0.0107434718,
0.0091239493,
0.0366326645,
-0.0044899229,
-0.0125429602,
0.0063257199,
-0.0177936777,
0.0362373702,
0.0169081688,
-0.011210721,
-0.0246375967,
0.0086430227,
-0.0092240097,
0.0036902181,
-0.0011203272,
-0.0099406457,
0.0086311242,
-0.0329979919,
-0.033782836,
-0.0782032236,
0.0379647426,
-0.0168191567,
-0.0097551188,
-0.0092760567,
0.0547631532,
0.0586867221,
-0.0566249602,
0.0451234058,
0.0292543769,
-0.0171273872,
0.012854971,
0.0645307377,
-0.0071825306,
-0.01406636,
-0.0311473235,
0.0245185234,
-0.0188453142,
-0.0178804398,
-0.0071888287,
0.0572990999,
0.0263995863,
0.0901841745,
0.0367720388,
-0.0263492875,
-0.0349342823,
-0.0394234397,
-0.0339996554,
-0.073621653,
0.0264004953,
-0.0330441147,
0.0685153678,
-0.0138916057,
-0.0450016782,
0.0677750558,
-0.0588885993,
-0.009999034,
0.007533554,
-0.0403038301,
-0.0266629197,
0.0116197094,
-0.056398429,
-0.0017890595,
-0.0363634229,
-0.0740165487,
0.004094162,
0.0036949189,
-0.0506699644,
-0.043407958,
0.010110571,
-0.0261331033,
-0.0053468696,
-0.0245120749,
0.0082033854,
-0.0309872665,
-0.020971885,
0.0162018798,
0.0107697705,
-0.0054323301,
0.0292810258,
-0.0346176699,
-0.0373411588,
0.0218993984,
0.0496372804,
-0.0381023623,
-0.0217070859,
-0.0235177856,
0.0741696358,
-0.0107640848,
0.0288598519,
-0.0066195177,
-0.043046359,
-0.0185672119,
0.0330495983,
-0.0060642632,
0.0210741777,
-0.0569333807,
0.0300678592,
0.030969793,
0.0095477533,
0.0330046006,
0.0374970138,
-0.0091276551,
0.0063478388,
-0.0062418021,
0.1219223365,
0.0367116183,
-0.0890390351,
-0.0506179072,
-0.0279306509,
0.0654938221,
-0.0265807193,
-0.0210066028,
-0.0625133216,
-0.0077841999,
-0.0019875623,
0.0663947985,
0.0442914665,
0.004365209,
-0.0163496863,
-0.0135085136,
0.049536407,
0.011130685,
-0.0414225869,
-0.0168537349,
-0.0265672058,
0.0137286875,
0.0230437256,
0.0411601588,
0.0101428023,
0.0156255104,
0.0210810117,
0.0100440979,
0.0367868915,
-0.0332156681,
-0.0132568954,
-0.016268013,
0.0826219097,
0.0624426007,
-0.0033789934,
-0.03964426,
-0.0313426256,
0.0013483322,
-0.0125966519,
-0.0189175904,
-0.0580078848,
0.0282928571,
0.0131325182,
0.0097054662,
-0.0081613883,
0.0185107421,
-0.0321109481,
-0.0507658795,
0.0237210374,
0.0930588394,
-0.0654274374,
0.0033123165,
0.0148724355,
0.012416644,
0.0311108194,
0.0568262897,
0.0631191507,
-0.0403650105,
0.0201149136,
-0.0038976215,
0.0163401552,
-0.0219612923,
-0.031443093,
0.0073585189,
-0.0177339986,
-0.019653976,
-0.0010284984,
0.0071025933,
0.0671929717,
-0.0179751869,
0.040583197,
0.001309433,
0.0161294155,
-0.0288365837,
-0.0496849827,
0.0269366261,
-0.0166160595,
0.0013451532,
-0.0809321925,
-0.0188220702,
0.0086164018,
-0.0648884773,
0.007772482,
0.0738272592,
-0.0572848171,
-0.0293301102,
0.0305269659,
-0.0031359238,
0.0130163431,
0.004759334,
0.0134546217,
-0.0325807817,
0.0679519176,
0.0329842344,
-0.0207627974,
0.0619840436,
-0.0139885871,
0.0558747984,
-0.0068398467,
0.000864988,
-0.0486355908,
0.0053557795,
0.010131482,
0.0335308909,
0.0443325303,
-0.0025935322,
0.0493820794,
0.0507729128,
0.1071576402,
-0.0279529393,
0.0006968604,
-0.0433822498,
-0.0097450241,
0.0461892039,
0.0696883351,
-0.0146707464,
0.0128967417,
0.051003471,
-0.0304793753,
-0.0430132933,
-0.0246897247,
-0.018112639,
0.0069970777,
-0.0199334528,
-0.0109534711,
-0.0629984811,
-0.0126672722,
-0.0012893507,
0.0245449618,
-0.0440726839,
0.00912352,
-0.0422963984,
-0.0001763207,
0.0146163134,
0.065969035,
0.0049879062,
0.0103106229,
0.0049335207,
0.050269261,
-0.0022273217,
-0.0412565656,
0.0589368902,
0.0297746882,
-0.0062754732,
0.0567750111,
0.0339471996,
0.014209073,
0.0345002152,
-0.0362311676,
0.0224150699,
-0.0376320183,
0.0067024352,
0.0705418587,
-0.0136395646,
0.0334272087,
-0.0638519451,
0.0210392457,
-0.0307124387,
-0.058625482,
-0.0151170501,
0.052855432,
-0.0355121158,
-0.0422411785,
-0.0178377386,
0.0208853446,
-0.0578039214,
-0.0112007316,
0.0460616723,
-0.0049219797,
0.013570278,
0.0146289961,
0.0038499748,
-0.0406170636,
-0.0220817532,
-0.0106130159,
-0.0189594757,
-0.0140240286,
0.0515716784,
0.0006721684,
-0.0247801431,
-0.073556304,
-0.0407713056,
-5.569390848e-33,
-0.0762562901,
-0.0277966056,
0.002652043,
0.0541912504,
-0.0562440008,
-0.0188848283,
-0.0648808703,
0.012079116,
0.0417707823,
-0.0518857613,
-0.0236075968,
-0.0236497298,
0.0334639512,
0.0133385491,
-0.010035458,
-0.0101734726,
-0.0240498818,
-0.051163014,
-0.0186590366,
0.012415315,
0.0510241799,
0.0398044884,
0.0736619234,
-0.0593174957,
0.0106901433,
0.0259834602,
0.0256681945,
-0.0172552615,
-0.0231770892,
0.0141197285,
-0.0626492798,
0.0568463467,
0.0346250609,
-0.0070683672,
0.0056626699,
0.017423775,
-0.078692086,
0.0060940683,
0.020749649,
-0.0052337833,
-0.0706644356,
-0.0096824681,
0.0328402556,
-0.016873762,
-0.003856437,
-0.0158222001,
0.0289112534,
-0.0304007716,
-0.0162461661,
0.0011847089,
-0.011620705,
-0.0345594287,
0.0097359121,
0.0246988237,
0.0537119955,
0.0396812893,
-0.0503336191,
0.0510948673,
-0.0659645051,
0.0110531645,
0.004686574,
-0.0085860658,
0.0121961031,
0.02170798,
0.0004275715,
0.0340176485,
0.0524941385,
-0.0650077462,
-0.0483864769,
0.0154261626,
0.0361066908,
0.0379012786,
-0.0082972832,
-0.0144127281,
0.0404857397,
-0.0157298837,
-0.0252779964,
0.0293209702,
-0.0075413883,
-0.0433967076,
0.0032988572,
0.0081796022,
0.0230725408,
-0.0155661181,
-0.0275966153,
-0.0000749788,
-0.0497338213,
0.0027297598,
0.0652005523,
-0.0238149557,
0.006103334,
-0.0449664444,
0.0582807846,
0.0268179663,
0.0660588145,
-0.0160436351,
0.008930576,
0.0161133464,
0.0080602253,
-0.0161812697,
-0.0384611972,
-0.0258952435,
0.0708249509,
-0.0339581184,
0.0620217659,
-0.0235131346,
-0.0584376864,
0.0123518826,
-0.0269551203,
-0.0070015541,
-0.0097217551,
-0.0034107615,
0.0328043103,
0.010741801,
-0.0027921083,
-0.0455375463,
0.0114539331,
-0.0380716324,
-0.036583595,
0.0068767592,
-0.0594167523,
-0.0276017934,
0.0146591393,
0.0306169018,
0.0079886038,
0.04475284,
0.0345464051,
-0.0348604135,
0.0220118687,
-0.0380750373,
-0.0265575442,
0.0399264731,
2.471e-7,
0.0264637265,
0.0007171113,
0.0411971621,
0.0551083609,
0.0072815558,
-0.0185775515,
-0.0503869541,
0.0325749256,
0.0250134096,
-0.0348048098,
-0.0123167075,
0.0548388734,
0.0437009893,
-0.0005115148,
-0.0589976758,
-0.0036780201,
-0.0154194776,
0.0204948727,
-0.0750125498,
0.0078580016,
0.0902876034,
-0.0085238088,
-0.0394469053,
-0.0423725694,
0.0492198542,
0.0454106592,
0.0578367785,
-0.054695446,
0.0352395363,
-0.0426182151,
0.0235536415,
-0.0566510335,
0.0027131718,
0.0162748639,
0.0431356132,
-0.0098599894,
0.0083577428,
0.0098404931,
0.0077732913,
-0.0747437254,
0.0178843997,
0.0058664288,
-0.0100420183,
-0.0133498488,
0.0046253693,
-0.0250390433,
-0.0663291067,
0.0162703469,
-0.0168718453,
-0.0391329564,
0.0505092777,
-0.0428846106,
0.0142384702,
-0.0477814898,
-0.0076158149,
0.0046437546,
-0.0102533633,
-0.0069929673,
0.016709676,
0.0293211043,
-0.0806322321,
-0.0105627272,
-0.0142661845,
0.0223915111,
-0.0019598927,
-0.0701813549,
-0.006428529,
1.529264541e-34,
-0.0325681381,
0.0017701414,
0.0507579073,
0.0310408156,
-0.0163678899,
-0.0056674746,
0.0609612726,
-0.001660597,
-0.0496620461,
-0.0931048617,
-0.0398251414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07803v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07803v2
|
Decoding Geometric Properties in Non-Random Data from First Information-Theoretic Principles
| 2024-05-13T14:45:08 | 2024-05-18T01:24:24 |
Hector Zenil, Felipe S. Abrahão
|
cs.IT
|
cs.IT, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.IR, math.IT, math.ST, stat.TH
|
Based on the principles of information theory, measure theory, and
theoretical computer science, we introduce a univariate signal deconvolution
method with a wide range of applications to coding theory, particularly in
zero-knowledge one-way communication channels, such as in deciphering messages
from unknown generating sources about which no prior knowledge is available and
to which no return message can be sent. Our multidimensional space
reconstruction method from an arbitrary received signal is proven to be
agnostic vis-a-vis the encoding-decoding scheme, computation model, programming
language, formal theory, the computable (or semi-computable) method of
approximation to algorithmic complexity, and any arbitrarily chosen
(computable) probability measure of the events. The method derives from the
principles of an approach to Artificial General Intelligence capable of
building a general-purpose model of models independent of any arbitrarily
assumed prior probability distribution. We argue that this optimal and
universal method of decoding non-random data has applications to signal
processing, causal deconvolution, topological and geometric properties
encoding, cryptography, and bio- and technosignature detection.
|
[
-0.0676815286,
0.1160778627,
0.0088581052,
0.015796354,
-0.0646819249,
0.0265989527,
-0.0380301625,
0.0368503593,
-0.0230103713,
0.0261195973,
0.0636448488,
0.0032862439,
-0.0071360408,
0.0022177107,
0.0347814001,
-0.0031925614,
-0.0509174205,
-0.0049607339,
0.028055191,
-0.0542264059,
-0.1073843539,
-0.0464294255,
0.0039580651,
-0.0161577053,
-0.0083872536,
-0.0248794928,
-0.0452463105,
-0.0041884338,
-0.0429987162,
-0.0015353437,
-0.0560047254,
-0.0019904515,
-0.0034364704,
0.0198701341,
0.0000020336,
0.0335194245,
-0.0571530648,
0.0169353802,
-0.0386751182,
-0.0238052979,
-0.0445409119,
-0.0486643016,
-0.0163696837,
-0.0331891254,
-0.0449116379,
-0.0127610797,
0.0452810414,
0.0261116959,
-0.0517229512,
0.0673369318,
-0.0112042967,
-0.0599262938,
0.0583347902,
-0.0257974025,
0.0326833874,
0.0296547469,
0.0079430826,
-0.0190622229,
-0.0124903601,
0.0331830569,
-0.032024201,
0.0414777808,
0.0141528882,
0.0447061211,
0.0548253879,
0.0306855645,
0.0344903842,
0.0119867017,
-0.0347634256,
0.0064531225,
-0.0367774665,
-0.0279560704,
0.0143889757,
0.0202356093,
-0.0142681152,
0.0303752813,
-0.0254730657,
0.0180330612,
-0.0080327522,
0.049489364,
-0.069103606,
-0.0067984737,
0.0223538093,
-0.0234547257,
-0.0236021653,
0.0801604763,
0.0343162939,
0.0142237758,
-0.0625438169,
0.0189826004,
0.0308300275,
-0.0106587447,
-0.0498934649,
-0.0133325458,
0.0404356234,
-0.0091744885,
-0.0226655882,
-0.0215618759,
-0.0102235842,
-0.035672646,
0.0594821684,
-0.0220750608,
0.0316566154,
0.0378496014,
0.0218859129,
-0.0166235063,
-0.0623360947,
0.082447961,
-0.0344727859,
0.0178404562,
0.0004490213,
-0.0263492651,
0.0278831143,
0.0618727542,
0.0163592603,
0.0118695963,
0.0233686659,
0.0449393839,
0.0227968749,
-0.0307956394,
-0.0545979664,
0.0077905874,
-0.0209342111,
-0.0179182254,
0.0204731878,
-0.0396936312,
0.0390574411,
0.0185749531,
-0.0434261449,
-0.0440510772,
-0.0485058799,
0.0443907753,
0.0326524936,
0.0343810357,
-0.0003286256,
0.0352183767,
0.0091264807,
-0.0117440652,
0.0073201675,
-0.0090048686,
-0.0025145845,
-0.0097006718,
0.0573528782,
-0.0168066137,
0.0015707596,
-0.0139461244,
0.0028323738,
-0.0319375545,
-0.0125775449,
-0.0241386332,
-0.0498552956,
0.0762660503,
-0.0133500369,
0.0127221784,
0.0291353296,
-0.0120947948,
0.0222221985,
0.0187263247,
-0.0204379298,
0.0036207656,
0.0032688337,
0.0295836329,
0.0717706606,
0.0119321011,
0.0517639406,
0.0018311315,
-0.0092338501,
-0.0417924933,
-0.0113957627,
-0.0191916656,
-0.0154773621,
0.0441434048,
-0.0182079785,
-0.0460194983,
-0.0189666655,
0.0687024519,
-0.003575752,
0.0108881611,
0.0301818065,
0.0608373955,
-0.0141760511,
0.0445745476,
-0.0122647928,
0.0070550768,
-0.0416981578,
0.0015028928,
0.0387231633,
-0.0520286597,
-0.0310339257,
-0.0248770788,
0.0289042406,
-0.0905020162,
0.0181203652,
-0.0480483323,
0.1407884955,
-0.0115771266,
-0.0030926545,
-0.0508795716,
0.0203712489,
-0.0082157589,
-0.0228326377,
0.0223581474,
0.0327217914,
-0.0598428175,
0.0481027327,
-0.0678422377,
0.0717202574,
0.0110964943,
-0.0028787858,
-0.0549670607,
-0.037389461,
0.0086837178,
0.0442327708,
0.0313537046,
-0.0308630969,
0.0552814193,
0.0471463278,
0.0024758268,
-0.028885439,
-0.0160255022,
-0.0435121767,
-0.0014932101,
0.0256549455,
-0.0194498245,
0.0261794329,
-0.0297548044,
0.0542410091,
0.0097890235,
0.0657670721,
0.042875208,
-0.0189559236,
0.0362355523,
0.0381760485,
-0.058106482,
-0.0312202517,
-0.0283594076,
0.0252214633,
-0.0127611002,
0.0107126189,
-0.0931197554,
0.0219441168,
0.0324917175,
0.0167525951,
-0.03384161,
0.0588911846,
-0.0112814354,
0.0153906178,
-0.0185296219,
-0.0246649552,
-0.0031252131,
0.0116963675,
-0.0013422212,
0.0071119471,
-0.0059699751,
0.0241410192,
-0.0186260566,
-0.0352206565,
0.0552193038,
-0.0420550667,
-0.0135731604,
-0.0073276404,
-0.0468909703,
-0.010362138,
0.0272705611,
0.0197264217,
0.0840841681,
-0.0065409956,
-0.0110853538,
-0.0822852552,
-0.0138651785,
0.0088875843,
-0.0098750219,
0.0045131124,
0.0103713116,
-0.0427336656,
0.0072326586,
-0.0068405913,
0.023623785,
-0.0480787158,
0.0088218907,
-0.0144920684,
-0.00033616,
0.0505460128,
-0.0248686653,
-0.0190882683,
0.0579751581,
0.0177754108,
-0.0440520495,
-0.003736346,
0.0025181149,
0.0218628403,
0.036987178,
-0.0266864635,
-0.0189773515,
0.0115989484,
-0.0757973194,
-0.0340168215,
0.045072671,
-0.0116367945,
0.0154461693,
-0.0464995056,
0.0466848984,
0.0258440543,
-0.0210285615,
-0.0586297624,
-0.0118993158,
0.0042571086,
-0.0309455451,
0.0423434675,
0.0012712195,
0.027556289,
-0.0461459272,
-0.01830405,
0.0070224078,
0.0265927687,
-0.017248325,
-0.045069702,
-0.0066784942,
0.0019156357,
0.0340114459,
-0.0176280569,
-0.0059763324,
-0.0062447032,
-0.013046694,
0.0238407142,
0.0046745953,
0.0014990293,
0.0018426501,
-0.010308641,
0.033310689,
0.034165062,
0.0214197002,
0.0018183644,
0.029723784,
0.0126128774,
0.0057688835,
-0.0141420607,
-0.0675834268,
-0.0672695041,
0.0112697845,
0.033100117,
-0.0331155136,
-0.0052589546,
-0.0098219346,
0.0705476031,
-0.0526827425,
-0.0361036249,
-0.0125452038,
0.0322506987,
0.0207863078,
0.0005901393,
-0.0147650475,
-0.0048371339,
-0.0082058879,
-0.0078917164,
0.051195696,
-0.0376864746,
-0.0035717445,
-0.0504562631,
-0.0221419036,
-0.0653393194,
0.0248785149,
-0.0274266563,
0.0882676691,
0.0308294091,
0.0464050248,
0.0169135761,
0.0560910664,
-0.0299738478,
0.0332224928,
0.0193407722,
0.0643257052,
-0.0278619491,
-0.0238034558,
-0.0100180497,
-0.05268557,
-0.006179349,
0.0216227211,
-0.0662490577,
0.0024593445,
-0.0586137511,
-0.0687099621,
0.0204062611,
-0.0298469644,
-0.0208335407,
-0.0356763452,
-0.0084711472,
0.0259208027,
-0.0016949259,
-0.005167977,
0.0306537319,
-0.0263775308,
-0.1202996373,
-0.0442082249,
-0.0132379951,
-0.0063251816,
-0.0911197588,
-0.0521105304,
0.038152229,
0.0319914557,
0.0086405585,
0.0063484674,
-0.0355870239,
-0.0406465046,
0.0229349546,
0.0353540033,
0.0024153942,
0.0365198478,
-0.0206247531,
-0.0393573567,
-0.0981217399,
0.0665782392,
-0.0033292165,
0.0137042897,
0.013685463,
0.0830569342,
0.0124054542,
0.0425106548,
0.0457447842,
-0.0398286432,
-0.0008120427,
-0.0315390229,
0.0099389702,
-0.0016275931,
0.0043093804,
0.0084844902,
-0.0738807395,
0.069687143,
0.0401848443,
-0.0443909764,
0.0075250729,
-0.0540511273,
-0.0134414751,
0.1165007427,
0.023950642,
-0.0307965185,
0.0347411111,
0.0560251884,
-0.1244259402,
0.0169557016,
0.0472370796,
-0.0462157354,
0.0556790382,
0.0027775965,
-0.0118791135,
0.0684791058,
-0.0500077568,
-0.0517445169,
-0.072223179,
-0.0243057664,
-0.0150663257,
0.0231903512,
0.0026223513,
-0.0310041085,
-0.0446273535,
-0.0456258543,
0.0166357309,
-0.0106961718,
0.003567226,
0.0257297754,
0.0114200888,
0.018454913,
-0.0074215145,
-0.0234693363,
0.0300992411,
0.0425789729,
-0.0431545563,
0.0047607524,
0.0377088971,
0.0405999608,
0.0211276524,
0.0190172978,
0.0338042378,
0.0016408644,
0.0403024517,
0.0108388271,
-0.013880942,
-0.0399698094,
-0.0097617023,
-0.0212204587,
0.015265042,
0.0333557017,
0.0427786931,
0.0255471878,
0.0297318101,
-0.0181743093,
0.0082585979,
0.0510938838,
-0.0373426564,
0.0059065418,
-0.0037034701,
0.0067210719,
-0.0301506221,
-0.0227353759,
0.0231789835,
-0.018154176,
0.006014884,
-0.0594867505,
0.0370498337,
-0.0164720956,
0.0194894224,
-0.0056596836,
0.0380585343,
0.0291855037,
0.0448219627,
-0.0319178365,
0.008024767,
-0.0191539023,
0.0286074989,
0.0010162655,
-0.0173253715,
-0.0138919028,
-0.0706450269,
-0.0259986259,
0.0212013572,
0.0570731349,
0.0721159875,
0.0856611654,
-0.0482109375,
-0.0348869674,
0.0141094057,
-0.0475181118,
0.0495015904,
0.0266151913,
-0.0117917117,
0.0074981577,
-0.0051284521,
-0.0455504432,
0.0234221928,
0.0470403582,
-0.0293656979,
0.0256061759,
-0.109546043,
0.0276657585,
-0.0243014973,
0.0156220468,
-0.0156906582,
0.0545633771,
0.0037533827,
0.0481108986,
-0.006490326,
-0.002898027,
-0.0030924603,
0.0122729801,
0.0411227942,
0.0155364275,
0.0187781788,
0.0378942341,
-0.0650587156,
0.0316107161,
-0.003121532,
-0.0262637399,
0.0171620343,
-0.0177747793,
-0.0151939262,
-6.188612619e-33,
0.0224588905,
-0.0183425415,
-0.0585247502,
0.0222683437,
0.0760903955,
-0.0195959676,
0.0284734331,
-0.0338373184,
0.0086319437,
-0.0303975902,
-0.0179455318,
0.0379512832,
-0.0038671847,
0.0482969433,
-0.0006025383,
0.0168015845,
0.011705027,
-0.018593898,
-0.0129540451,
0.0141490586,
0.0174766369,
-0.0093171895,
0.0061373403,
-0.0703629479,
0.0264133662,
0.0089011621,
-0.0001537194,
0.0251530502,
0.0015070926,
-0.0077391067,
-0.0203394946,
-0.0268684756,
0.007259354,
-0.0298604723,
-0.0096704355,
0.0139926188,
-0.0100109028,
-0.0085722273,
-0.0175638665,
0.0088631865,
-0.0064733238,
-0.0719920173,
-0.0077808187,
-0.0073843403,
-0.0255296715,
0.0082237246,
0.0058680647,
0.0070053358,
0.0251848064,
-0.0279850345,
0.0395325013,
0.0324257389,
-0.0522594936,
-0.0097144125,
0.0728647411,
-0.0565426946,
-0.0240574256,
-0.0123066166,
0.0254877787,
0.0519370921,
0.0309281871,
-0.0459556393,
-0.0094589507,
-0.027430594,
0.0069508343,
0.0439899154,
0.0688028261,
-0.0849059373,
-0.030131625,
-0.0537197292,
-0.0378864519,
-0.0286698826,
-0.0440639704,
0.0538435467,
0.0393666327,
-0.0069703953,
-0.0754782259,
0.0445682928,
-0.0318009704,
-0.0615440309,
0.0007319877,
-0.0082139028,
-0.0428570658,
-0.0760979503,
0.0466244631,
-0.0735439882,
0.0239589401,
0.0369748026,
-0.0234695412,
0.0237762313,
-0.0099658687,
0.0023855909,
0.0019751862,
-0.0463634394,
-0.0036170348,
0.0380016007,
0.0600561462,
0.0280315727,
0.0073890849,
-0.0174626373,
0.0154923322,
0.0258123502,
-0.0081241699,
0.0086851632,
0.0236847848,
0.0091953333,
-0.0029172613,
0.074292846,
0.011883473,
-0.0465476848,
0.0194264315,
-0.0695821941,
0.0556086265,
-0.0384612866,
0.0406246781,
0.0132620279,
0.011756652,
0.0404754952,
-0.0074029434,
0.0497819893,
0.0245867055,
0.0053267409,
-0.0350241661,
0.006830256,
-0.0175400041,
-0.0026127019,
-0.0119024636,
-0.0333056301,
0.0617817082,
-0.0161366481,
-0.0248854458,
-0.0013713646,
3.071e-7,
0.0197372269,
0.002407291,
0.0598882884,
-0.0111875022,
0.0279509481,
0.0127476407,
0.0018489963,
0.0413651988,
-0.0604629293,
0.012017807,
0.0054374733,
0.0137998424,
0.0043775393,
-0.0507705398,
-0.0980307162,
-0.0157657079,
0.028622482,
-0.0045513464,
0.0157205276,
0.02918908,
0.0627209693,
-0.0242936201,
0.0109586669,
0.0089069167,
0.0355845131,
0.0154021578,
-0.019603366,
-0.0049918024,
0.0540831909,
0.0071541183,
0.0193652678,
-0.0240664519,
0.0301359557,
0.0297304597,
0.0166242663,
-0.0406983867,
0.0136972684,
0.0381004885,
-0.007523682,
-0.0040952484,
-0.0304664709,
-0.0141089521,
-0.0278638527,
0.0227284227,
0.0254938528,
-0.019143628,
-0.0560623445,
0.0208303649,
-0.0109127024,
0.0454396494,
-0.00698236,
0.0715634376,
0.0074108993,
-0.0435863473,
-0.0314312875,
0.0291848835,
0.0733757615,
0.0092935581,
0.0388034694,
0.0393666402,
-0.0411390923,
0.0067404681,
0.0155462697,
-0.0048814388,
0.0618166775,
-0.0278360881,
-0.0038957917,
2.511296514e-34,
-0.0509020835,
0.0120767811,
0.0199306179,
0.0042059491,
-0.0494116209,
-0.0170182809,
0.0086156921,
-0.0160585288,
0.0203312207,
-0.0217722002,
-0.005118656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07788v1
|
DEPTH: Discourse Education through Pre-Training Hierarchically
| 2024-05-13T14:35:30 | 2024-05-13T14:35:30 |
Zachary Bamberger, Ofek Glick, Chaim Baskin, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language Models (LMs) often struggle with linguistic understanding at the
discourse level, even though discourse patterns such as coherence, cohesion,
and narrative flow are prevalent in their pre-training data. Current methods
address these challenges only after the pre-training phase, relying on
expensive human annotated data to align the model. To improve the discourse
capabilities of LMs already at the pre-training stage, we introduce DEPTH, an
encoder-decoder model that learns to represent sentences using a
discourse-oriented pre-training objective. DEPTH combines hierarchical sentence
representations with two objectives: (1) Sentence Un-Shuffling, and (2)
Span-Corruption. This approach trains the model to represent both
sub-word-level and sentence-level dependencies over a massive amount of
unstructured text. When trained either from scratch or continuing from a
pre-trained T5 checkpoint, DEPTH learns semantic and discourse-level
representations faster than T5, outperforming it in span-corruption loss
despite the additional sentence-un-shuffling objective. Evaluations on the
GLUE, DiscoEval, and NI benchmarks demonstrate DEPTH's ability to quickly learn
diverse downstream tasks, which require syntactic, semantic, and discourse
capabilities. Overall, our approach extends the discourse capabilities of T5,
while minimally impacting other natural language understanding (NLU)
capabilities in the resulting LM.
|
[
0.0182926059,
0.0563997291,
-0.0064008292,
0.0623779818,
-0.0086425468,
0.0052510831,
-0.0159410238,
-0.0655948371,
-0.0266753379,
-0.0546660684,
-0.00809203,
-0.0039446838,
0.0255625639,
0.0307694729,
-0.0186719261,
-0.1013157666,
0.0409110039,
-0.0241060387,
0.0116195828,
-0.0250601918,
0.0058359257,
0.0157714952,
-0.0157397855,
-0.0036913541,
-0.0222476218,
-0.0362212546,
-0.0282627903,
0.0270923506,
0.0270920526,
-0.0321002528,
0.0474238433,
0.0626513138,
0.0607456788,
0.0433306694,
0.0000021326,
-0.0133731142,
-0.0001436365,
-0.0372756682,
-0.0208578873,
0.0469138026,
0.0261324104,
-0.0231861752,
0.015460127,
0.005726622,
-0.0241183173,
0.0172748268,
-0.017449541,
0.0774141178,
0.0959963948,
0.0529876016,
-0.0060132728,
-0.0454728268,
0.0057930737,
-0.018935388,
-0.0639584512,
-0.0595169142,
-0.0112829329,
0.0345313065,
-0.0276742447,
0.0426377356,
-0.0450074486,
0.0280144848,
0.0445897356,
-0.0018771561,
0.0239879154,
0.0275335424,
-0.0174507145,
-0.0008307387,
-0.0192090515,
0.0814611241,
0.0121376663,
-0.0126673346,
-0.0215876251,
-0.0034771867,
0.0075654769,
-0.0156125342,
-0.0167838596,
0.0274725221,
0.0150664933,
0.045068793,
0.008678481,
0.0083741508,
0.0027757604,
0.0020245914,
0.0131886126,
0.0240838733,
-0.0095555959,
-0.0271531362,
0.017426962,
0.0311025791,
0.0088703232,
-0.0463143475,
0.0088721402,
0.0088566868,
-0.0566731021,
0.0270897429,
-0.0478691719,
-0.008412987,
0.0148033239,
-0.0950066,
0.0069074454,
0.0194309428,
-0.0292736385,
0.0155060599,
-0.0079631843,
0.044231534,
0.0188664347,
0.0098220194,
-0.0283896346,
-0.0074495757,
-0.0249439124,
-0.0340414383,
-0.0602190271,
0.047235243,
-0.0946421027,
-0.0253389813,
-0.0364959911,
0.0021985522,
-0.0011339379,
-0.0200661421,
-0.0134966727,
0.0247647446,
-0.033805754,
-0.0021130089,
-0.0280248597,
0.0722049773,
-0.0298106465,
0.0289058518,
0.0021363944,
-0.0217430405,
-0.037389446,
0.0057833921,
0.0071336729,
-0.0018982093,
-0.0082710451,
0.0264363717,
-0.0441734232,
-0.0239054952,
-0.0402600579,
-0.0109842326,
-0.0276709758,
-0.0427301191,
0.000605827,
-0.0469115153,
-0.0143229123,
-0.0146546206,
0.0156219034,
-0.0286883172,
0.0250976738,
0.0183190629,
-0.0233279411,
0.0485151,
0.0003061111,
-0.032153938,
0.0279875621,
0.0231816899,
0.0534807183,
0.0737386718,
0.0357271433,
0.0171559639,
0.0060488135,
-0.0048001707,
-0.0386992916,
-0.0159127414,
0.0032280812,
-0.0184789468,
0.0120957205,
0.0131826075,
-0.0329266638,
0.0449389219,
0.0521499068,
0.0465175733,
-0.0425281264,
-0.0084061753,
0.0682579726,
0.0319508985,
-0.037576437,
-0.0109218406,
0.039617151,
0.0382268168,
-0.0148459645,
0.0493242517,
-0.0256722514,
0.0044560842,
0.0206349008,
-0.0077130455,
0.0285142884,
0.0044897627,
-0.0267910808,
-0.0432906672,
0.0002233256,
-0.0180352777,
0.0267737396,
-0.0288249366,
-0.0053782454,
0.0492243357,
-0.0711909533,
0.0665493459,
0.0522827543,
-0.0629967973,
0.0153973112,
0.0244130194,
-0.0046220478,
0.0711553395,
0.0426819399,
0.0084956838,
-0.048463054,
-0.0154067427,
0.0651595443,
0.0966851562,
-0.0003234139,
-0.0194518808,
0.0357147343,
-0.0527343303,
-0.0308338907,
-0.0679528937,
0.0182028115,
0.0431780145,
-0.0009600686,
-0.0270161368,
0.0046322076,
-0.0164264478,
-0.0568064339,
0.0314257704,
-0.0367876701,
0.0002065404,
0.0105737681,
0.0061620134,
0.0232506897,
0.0274615102,
-0.0112263244,
-0.0312393885,
0.0518454276,
-0.0415544622,
-0.0123568447,
0.0065032835,
-0.1212296635,
-0.0662682503,
0.0039757844,
-0.0757390037,
-0.0368987508,
0.047347948,
-0.0461222157,
-0.0366500244,
0.0503202043,
-0.0279827677,
0.0176669881,
-0.0487732217,
-0.0030617861,
-0.0001175554,
-0.0011717605,
-0.0047894367,
0.0767873004,
-0.0086079417,
-0.0145330522,
-0.0075811902,
-0.0100508938,
0.0170754902,
-0.0267039258,
0.0009233021,
0.0047612274,
0.0019429127,
0.0054992945,
0.0037786795,
0.0245087706,
-0.0410205945,
-0.0185739864,
-0.1084350049,
-0.0212628748,
-0.0359279402,
0.0020553404,
0.0385113806,
-0.0057039182,
0.0187350977,
-0.0497382022,
0.0037879157,
-0.0086081177,
-0.0124087371,
-0.0131850243,
0.0569933988,
-0.0022700671,
0.0324165151,
-0.0227276944,
0.0081596263,
0.0034514803,
0.040739581,
-0.0099431118,
-0.0164663736,
-0.026659539,
-0.0129472231,
-0.0121764513,
0.0016222924,
-0.010194418,
-0.0535733961,
0.0222350359,
0.0539989546,
0.0737606287,
0.0545491166,
0.0494647399,
0.0968678296,
0.0231975615,
-0.0092811286,
-0.0183819514,
0.0434132777,
-0.009340669,
0.0515709333,
-0.0759050921,
0.0327262878,
-0.014712723,
0.0820114464,
0.0052250829,
0.0293431524,
-0.0562414601,
-0.006516262,
-0.0108619537,
-0.045033101,
-0.0043711378,
-0.060061764,
-0.026314836,
-0.0057176957,
-0.0741719827,
0.0222682077,
0.0462840982,
-0.0552611165,
-0.0095992731,
-0.0710030869,
0.0057396288,
-0.0361258052,
0.0431918725,
0.0136352647,
0.0110938754,
-0.0073670899,
-0.0663280338,
-0.0324599557,
0.0157007463,
0.0439697951,
-0.0075072832,
0.0481606312,
-0.0535429902,
-0.0031825835,
-0.0020953519,
-0.0564387441,
-0.0540615879,
-0.043460615,
-0.0065592006,
0.0104517872,
-0.0295884274,
0.0124760168,
-0.0408586897,
-0.0353071801,
0.0141417002,
0.053914655,
-0.0093107475,
0.0230877977,
-0.0463487692,
0.0369605944,
0.0366405845,
0.036536321,
-0.0008041493,
-0.0615335517,
0.0528236479,
0.0452438295,
-0.0557738617,
-0.0212729052,
-0.0312131699,
0.0112977307,
-0.0207572728,
-0.0097009111,
-0.0099771218,
-0.0106575824,
0.0679102242,
-0.0589456521,
-0.0456613004,
0.1194268391,
0.0158024635,
-0.0074443212,
-0.0039073909,
-0.0082435254,
0.0668000281,
0.0214149375,
-0.017021317,
-0.0795676932,
-0.0471700653,
0.0073270672,
0.0151520669,
0.0425426327,
-0.0202924758,
0.0127620092,
-0.1017545909,
0.0139380209,
-0.0008084673,
-0.0107771298,
0.0043112529,
-0.0342484638,
-0.0087701082,
0.0215583965,
0.0689742714,
-0.0029885164,
-0.0200992581,
-0.0102002826,
0.021656679,
-0.0106502445,
-0.0553639568,
0.0090790233,
-0.0201348793,
0.0383860767,
0.0321263596,
0.0388976745,
-0.0089689353,
0.0062837419,
0.0465937369,
-0.0037791429,
-0.0046797865,
0.0042793755,
0.0789282098,
-0.0344202742,
0.0145603875,
-0.0065722764,
0.0407884419,
-0.0135047631,
-0.0122993104,
-0.0243009254,
0.03921891,
-0.0117511004,
-0.0208563916,
0.0061711296,
0.0275940802,
-0.0025443956,
0.0830437988,
0.0552617535,
-0.0080147451,
-0.0377386101,
-0.0398023687,
0.0365487821,
-0.0555756651,
0.0094277672,
0.0166750252,
0.0152070513,
0.0124077853,
-0.069645822,
-0.0716565698,
0.0012654266,
-0.0079717441,
0.0065562609,
0.0083819898,
0.0341122262,
-0.0150169963,
-0.0389421172,
0.0084830122,
-0.0238397028,
-0.0136198951,
-0.0401831679,
-0.0237518698,
0.0057858895,
-0.0258860029,
-0.0275617484,
-0.0045051058,
-0.0390824527,
-0.0552036501,
0.013020467,
0.0161436722,
0.0072130184,
0.0848373026,
-0.0125739789,
-0.0093210442,
0.0748708099,
0.0152076762,
-0.036895141,
0.0327742137,
0.0455756262,
0.0002802828,
-0.0080098137,
0.0423079059,
-0.026271889,
0.0257675424,
-0.0182502121,
0.0403745882,
0.0008374628,
-0.0351032354,
0.0118932091,
-0.0403216593,
0.0514695309,
0.002455608,
-0.0039299885,
-0.0578261912,
0.0449259616,
-0.0629576445,
-0.0181399994,
-0.0235008541,
0.0208415054,
0.0208075419,
0.0051983492,
0.0029293536,
0.0218423307,
-0.0010180556,
0.0634584352,
-0.0187024288,
-0.0003393553,
0.0277854186,
0.0075881109,
-0.012031951,
0.0196527615,
-0.0131602436,
0.0164749976,
-0.0163472332,
0.0453367308,
-0.0130888587,
0.0388684496,
0.0224819388,
-0.0017465362,
0.006042317,
0.0239488538,
-0.0688602477,
0.0404295661,
-0.0327632315,
-0.0008325044,
0.066126667,
-0.0164739899,
0.0777121931,
-0.0045817797,
0.0150546897,
0.0121241901,
0.0494186617,
-0.0142607111,
-0.0587226301,
0.0035180196,
0.0070284116,
-0.0251420382,
0.0209316369,
0.0679098964,
0.0094411643,
0.0360106751,
0.0369830653,
0.0296225883,
-0.0500134304,
-0.07169085,
-0.0101508861,
0.0551616251,
-0.0157265197,
0.034779232,
-0.0116237439,
-0.0154857505,
0.035842523,
-0.007888075,
-0.0035939163,
-0.0309092421,
0.0493428558,
0.0316990986,
-0.0050041908,
-0.0160768181,
-0.0274183638,
-0.0082804654,
0.0124131944,
-0.0295492876,
-0.0299275741,
-6.676362694e-33,
-0.0460733511,
0.004813123,
-0.0022053493,
0.0101720449,
-0.038409207,
0.0279506762,
-0.0795814991,
0.0035771611,
0.0108007109,
0.0583514087,
0.0273552053,
0.0284464192,
-0.0005155305,
0.0668138042,
-0.0023815304,
0.0035999662,
0.0788764879,
-0.0125854379,
-0.0293491986,
0.0285782125,
0.0550904013,
0.0326099396,
0.0522213206,
0.0167304017,
-0.0131036779,
-0.0152683305,
0.013673814,
0.0294129662,
0.0243751872,
0.0155490208,
-0.0126887243,
0.0122475047,
0.0260198247,
-0.0015477752,
-0.0238634888,
0.0282405671,
-0.1061155051,
-0.0220455769,
0.0258992147,
0.0161623098,
-0.0913253799,
-0.0300317723,
0.0234583318,
0.0172795262,
0.0322165228,
-0.0379917808,
0.0366438217,
0.0163657237,
0.0064675086,
-0.0190394074,
-0.0635454506,
-0.0048631411,
-0.0467878208,
-0.0257011577,
0.008166573,
0.0337701812,
0.0225885343,
0.0001068258,
-0.0493714623,
0.0126565937,
-0.0159114636,
0.0226183254,
0.0129826963,
-0.0027373957,
-0.0385997295,
0.0999641418,
-0.0460558049,
-0.0037379779,
-0.0474492274,
0.0251374226,
0.0214105677,
0.0186176971,
0.013219065,
0.013478769,
0.0211579241,
0.0133918794,
-0.0734103769,
0.0080115944,
-0.0341234915,
0.0654492378,
0.0102708051,
0.0119882468,
0.0151596991,
-0.0113631617,
-0.0450961068,
-0.0126606235,
0.0175930392,
-0.0236295648,
0.0193874966,
0.0067934636,
-0.014170344,
0.0013046648,
0.0263223518,
-0.0095494771,
-0.0144523345,
0.0361911915,
-0.0177914873,
0.0016290634,
0.0164177567,
0.0587569848,
-0.0394828133,
0.013762285,
0.0586913973,
0.0155390864,
0.0096727572,
-0.0157901775,
0.0688506812,
-0.0189620275,
-0.0226412453,
0.0227823295,
-0.0190648809,
0.0331928097,
-0.0573581755,
0.0677122325,
0.0125865955,
0.0318925381,
-0.026177356,
0.0412590653,
-0.014950919,
0.006292738,
-0.0480982773,
-0.0222334061,
-0.0127216829,
0.0237898435,
-0.0271193422,
-0.0169297159,
-0.0642363578,
0.0176700205,
0.0106380396,
-0.0705738664,
0.0022506823,
0.0255455971,
2.685e-7,
0.0053891679,
0.0788699016,
0.063751705,
-0.017219644,
0.0444912165,
0.0035284162,
-0.0137031898,
0.0473119952,
-0.0150544811,
-0.0492365472,
-0.0062113893,
0.0593456253,
0.0687732995,
0.0235158559,
-0.1209248602,
-0.0268643443,
-0.1004353389,
-0.0176979378,
-0.0520240627,
-0.0033457861,
0.0714184269,
0.0477710888,
-0.0235849079,
0.0012588362,
0.0086476244,
0.0242816918,
0.0553638376,
0.0168648697,
-0.0012724821,
0.0078617791,
-0.0498656817,
-0.0006942948,
-0.0286277682,
0.0113941012,
-0.0288323928,
0.0385543555,
-0.0324455462,
0.0576966144,
-0.0053418861,
-0.0617763139,
-0.0231893267,
0.0321750455,
-0.0073536239,
-0.0101700295,
0.0365382321,
-0.0567786731,
-0.044993367,
0.0238443948,
-0.079438962,
0.0054969834,
0.0094764121,
0.018015122,
-0.0505619049,
0.0037628287,
0.0035287368,
-0.0254884548,
-0.0015654616,
-0.0732250214,
0.0021860774,
-0.0014700647,
-0.0337892324,
0.02113235,
-0.0184670892,
-0.023857262,
0.021040367,
-0.0505804271,
0.0271252226,
2.343394365e-34,
0.0542865582,
-0.0367885306,
0.01289469,
0.0050823325,
0.0307302698,
-0.0129680485,
-0.0243000854,
-0.0156970341,
0.0011907176,
-0.0571937039,
0.0127033629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07778v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07778v1
|
A Comprehensive Analysis of Static Word Embeddings for Turkish
| 2024-05-13T14:23:37 | 2024-05-13T14:23:37 |
Karahan Sarıtaş, Cahid Arda Öz, Tunga Güngör
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Word embeddings are fixed-length, dense and distributed word representations
that are used in natural language processing (NLP) applications. There are
basically two types of word embedding models which are non-contextual (static)
models and contextual models. The former method generates a single embedding
for a word regardless of its context, while the latter method produces distinct
embeddings for a word based on the specific contexts in which it appears. There
are plenty of works that compare contextual and non-contextual embedding models
within their respective groups in different languages. However, the number of
studies that compare the models in these two groups with each other is very few
and there is no such study in Turkish. This process necessitates converting
contextual embeddings into static embeddings. In this paper, we compare and
evaluate the performance of several contextual and non-contextual models in
both intrinsic and extrinsic evaluation settings for Turkish. We make a
fine-grained comparison by analyzing the syntactic and semantic capabilities of
the models separately. The results of the analyses provide insights about the
suitability of different embedding models in different types of NLP tasks. We
also build a Turkish word embedding repository comprising the embedding models
used in this work, which may serve as a valuable resource for researchers and
practitioners in the field of Turkish NLP. We make the word embeddings,
scripts, and evaluation datasets publicly available.
|
[
0.0031768363,
0.0054653329,
-0.0280490052,
0.0177143738,
-0.0453046486,
0.0429389253,
0.0069108624,
-0.0048173764,
-0.0277003665,
-0.0357468911,
-0.0266433805,
-0.0598019958,
0.0477658845,
0.006121296,
0.0630862862,
-0.0342595354,
0.046598535,
0.0133918691,
-0.0067537017,
0.0179459434,
0.049714461,
0.0120547144,
-0.0240722839,
0.0420603417,
-0.047355298,
-0.0018304802,
0.0195489358,
-0.0586992167,
0.0156637896,
-0.024493048,
-0.0412529856,
0.0107364831,
0.0124881323,
0.0117205177,
0.000001706,
-0.0052484144,
0.0291977674,
-0.0117550893,
0.0069631678,
-0.0031123182,
0.0676524937,
-0.0506447367,
-0.0566313826,
-0.0012901252,
-0.0190535374,
-0.0411854647,
0.0541064627,
0.0159568451,
0.0059890342,
0.0336729363,
-0.0026940594,
-0.0821245834,
0.0161223914,
-0.0265741963,
-0.0382108726,
-0.0340208523,
-0.0040564914,
-0.031505134,
-0.0627390221,
0.022980446,
-0.0401064008,
0.0496595763,
0.0081360321,
0.0056820395,
-0.0021873864,
0.0394660793,
-0.0674564987,
-0.0476193354,
0.0427112766,
0.0524830744,
-0.0104274023,
-0.0208829176,
-0.0201043319,
0.033035174,
-0.0149417752,
0.001775022,
-0.045859918,
0.0169376265,
0.0188757181,
0.0246129297,
0.0617281273,
0.0815292224,
0.0465457886,
0.0115902247,
-0.0037747002,
0.0016115243,
0.0405691862,
-0.0474477485,
-0.0004495625,
0.0125126429,
0.0082159778,
-0.0096663898,
0.0289286096,
0.0152258109,
0.0148382038,
0.0383480974,
-0.0024846978,
-0.0376368724,
0.0400045253,
-0.0845907256,
0.0347607397,
0.0588075332,
0.0006390589,
0.0332458317,
-0.1084731817,
0.004183556,
-0.0090505872,
0.0142731983,
-0.0112521863,
-0.0118886176,
-0.0363542773,
-0.0148259569,
-0.0351606272,
0.0446291007,
-0.0459266715,
-0.025960736,
-0.0289707445,
0.0539486222,
-0.0053929188,
0.0085029071,
-0.0047140014,
0.0045550535,
-0.0226995368,
0.0445869379,
-0.0155548295,
-0.0432639606,
-0.0663313344,
-0.0358785205,
-0.0623946376,
-0.0191859026,
0.034461204,
-0.0112810601,
0.0158842821,
0.0057653259,
-0.0174078476,
0.0442513116,
0.0118607627,
-0.0631851852,
-0.0218845997,
0.0401032902,
-0.0339440927,
-0.0392952524,
-0.0559680089,
-0.0495269485,
0.0272348374,
0.0069882348,
0.0017759142,
-0.0148031488,
-0.0029673555,
0.0535916202,
-0.0041867066,
0.0971250981,
0.0899576172,
-0.0066980701,
-0.0111524956,
-0.0060104486,
0.0580857396,
0.0636838451,
0.0269713514,
0.0018406574,
0.037192516,
-0.0153293572,
-0.0398518257,
0.0048866384,
0.0090364618,
-0.006232759,
-0.0448690765,
0.038913928,
0.0246365257,
0.0635557249,
-0.0380531102,
0.0486275069,
-0.0020434405,
-0.0128483996,
0.0319406576,
0.096087873,
0.0154095599,
0.0433197953,
0.0755814463,
-0.0127832992,
-0.0243802015,
-0.0107957106,
-0.0061604874,
-0.0275722425,
0.0132279592,
0.0217428282,
0.0093729068,
0.0305418056,
-0.0114233531,
-0.0401091464,
-0.0301427785,
-0.0179344062,
0.0556703173,
-0.0674404278,
0.0610358454,
-0.0037732366,
-0.0829438344,
0.0116879381,
0.0254597496,
-0.0231212154,
-0.0102822101,
0.0091750296,
0.0217813533,
0.035877727,
0.0670469254,
-0.0023753229,
0.0050993441,
-0.0090676546,
-0.0143968239,
0.038667202,
0.0433262736,
-0.0523251183,
0.005699838,
-0.0460730977,
0.0321824141,
0.0152684776,
0.0338762254,
0.0330228843,
-0.0179682933,
0.0659030974,
0.0303206574,
-0.0281776059,
0.0101062478,
0.0434183255,
-0.0226487853,
-0.0157753229,
-0.0334699377,
0.0173074808,
-0.0060226345,
0.0300481506,
-0.0150078088,
0.0210947115,
0.0429229811,
-0.0600045286,
0.0224031098,
0.0088844355,
-0.0608821474,
-0.0379963107,
0.015174699,
-0.0352225825,
-0.0207078345,
0.0227608327,
-0.0200960394,
-0.0182142481,
0.0478832349,
-0.0059079039,
0.0570081733,
-0.0438671075,
0.019080162,
-0.0062455162,
0.0493142232,
-0.0081768967,
0.0578478388,
-0.0391059332,
0.0215459019,
-0.0142218946,
0.0377951227,
0.0174799338,
-0.001634515,
-0.0351536386,
0.0395909324,
0.0224921238,
-0.0157198235,
-0.0234250166,
-0.0258386135,
0.0077123027,
0.0127020404,
-0.0872962922,
0.008272877,
-0.0286237393,
0.0396131612,
0.0053437063,
0.0158709027,
-0.0057912781,
-0.0066599892,
-0.0117849028,
-0.0141149526,
0.0145730097,
0.0211296994,
0.0465566441,
-0.0198976677,
-0.0262741055,
-0.0490895659,
-0.0088875573,
0.0134637691,
0.0293933135,
-0.0219090525,
-0.0209563058,
0.0170560777,
0.0242909491,
-0.0007919478,
-0.0076014525,
0.0028270066,
-0.0271988586,
0.013840626,
0.0176882036,
0.0509807914,
0.0316420607,
-0.0130687794,
0.0394923873,
0.0185224656,
-0.0030682767,
-0.0149053605,
-0.0416431129,
-0.0191428978,
-0.0027782796,
-0.0322825983,
0.021467872,
-0.0068345261,
0.0482650101,
-0.0131631726,
-0.0117997713,
-0.0701984689,
-0.0142298229,
-0.0731130689,
-0.0141960867,
-0.0412659161,
0.00696111,
-0.0559459068,
0.0322598368,
-0.0105421292,
-0.0087842979,
0.0075310683,
-0.042500142,
0.0175744332,
-0.0433597565,
-0.0112572173,
-0.0475669429,
0.017406255,
-0.0165233985,
0.0051869354,
-0.0495225638,
-0.0206155833,
-0.0307309646,
0.0010786538,
0.0189669076,
-0.0392052047,
0.0322017521,
0.0045010909,
-0.0061105019,
-0.004731969,
0.0006090915,
-0.0243262779,
-0.0848769322,
-0.0074576605,
0.0340402648,
0.0369803868,
0.0369330458,
0.0000247247,
0.042375762,
-0.024591282,
-0.0107846521,
0.020053165,
0.0043215714,
-0.0470059067,
0.009631223,
0.0168330688,
-0.0259188898,
0.0170075856,
0.045828715,
0.0294263214,
0.0279298704,
0.0165739115,
-0.0212387256,
-0.032138966,
-0.0147353252,
0.0198006369,
-0.0520003624,
-0.0318790004,
-0.0573157817,
0.0188459214,
-0.0159875434,
-0.0039732768,
0.0770680457,
0.0416133627,
0.0027742651,
0.058119908,
-0.0031181276,
-0.0021336055,
0.0295537021,
-0.0154456282,
-0.0344569571,
0.0004867489,
0.0380890667,
-0.0283184983,
0.0022244188,
-0.0023159476,
0.0546607561,
-0.1399338692,
-0.0494669303,
0.0007247597,
-0.043695122,
-0.0348319262,
-0.0439220257,
-0.0152277127,
-0.0280893072,
-0.0076965941,
-0.0341344364,
-0.0084778843,
0.0296542346,
0.0230025519,
-0.0466789529,
-0.0893749669,
-0.0127533767,
-0.0122188497,
0.020020932,
0.0248563047,
0.0402208678,
-0.0313103832,
0.012712487,
0.0403162166,
-0.0537081771,
-0.0163273308,
-0.0035126598,
0.0138228424,
-0.0376596376,
-0.0239862483,
-0.0360513814,
-0.0513750315,
-0.0492627658,
-0.0000253024,
-0.0413557254,
0.0513599366,
0.0350249559,
0.0378460288,
-0.0129244039,
0.0044629108,
0.0126590682,
0.0555557944,
-0.0076440806,
-0.0080048274,
-0.0273321941,
0.0157074276,
-0.0184487011,
-0.0258510001,
-0.0414638929,
0.0162909329,
0.0111869508,
0.0199722499,
-0.0767923817,
-0.0798799172,
0.035624668,
0.0206897352,
0.0055424701,
0.0350202285,
-0.0767445639,
-0.0236787666,
-0.0167485513,
-0.0049516228,
0.0229068566,
0.020094566,
-0.0072058574,
0.0222850218,
0.03977184,
0.0172884502,
-0.0202675629,
0.0029850025,
-0.0543184914,
-0.0277439747,
0.0028683357,
0.0019662296,
0.0042464971,
0.0075332033,
-0.0567188039,
-0.0130930785,
0.0735429823,
-0.0413919613,
-0.0607568622,
-0.0018173599,
0.0146061024,
0.0132421162,
0.0209475644,
0.0493720248,
0.0035053736,
0.0170726646,
0.0093283383,
0.0066111931,
-0.0074412008,
0.023190951,
-0.0064050476,
-0.0350530148,
-0.0161306318,
-0.017835306,
0.0215224773,
-0.0329365991,
-0.0007958863,
-0.0038359342,
0.018751597,
0.0239206497,
0.0039516464,
0.0656441227,
0.0188031513,
-0.0273572821,
-0.0208418276,
0.0013892084,
0.0256682187,
-0.0395782329,
0.0209033769,
0.053228125,
-0.0189108346,
-0.0121655175,
0.0786633566,
-0.0379636586,
0.0166621283,
-0.0801023543,
-0.0101108383,
-0.0544232093,
-0.0283777714,
-0.0395382866,
-0.0054076691,
0.0003739666,
0.0506600961,
-0.021209063,
0.038592387,
0.0104638599,
0.0813517123,
0.0571174212,
-0.0600189827,
0.0254511479,
-0.0188043546,
-0.00993622,
-0.006546983,
0.020804964,
-0.040665485,
-0.0340175703,
0.0246719159,
-0.0063599618,
-0.0341945514,
-0.0326732993,
0.0503697917,
0.002719848,
0.0210360158,
-0.026732346,
0.0127076795,
-0.0127329361,
0.0482846387,
0.0018723307,
0.0660479069,
-0.0205907207,
0.0240620226,
-0.0821744204,
-0.1121359915,
-0.029112285,
0.0198782105,
-0.0066437447,
-0.0206363145,
-0.0066001024,
0.0576703288,
0.0737785399,
0.06654457,
-0.0351696052,
0.0277309678,
-0.0106701124,
-0.0313650519,
-0.0534169376,
-5.283942249e-33,
-0.0173763894,
0.0397562161,
-0.0327337049,
-0.0452892855,
-0.0097669009,
-0.0000222408,
-0.0252991598,
0.0023504116,
-0.0176697858,
0.0174582414,
-0.0508768745,
0.0163288191,
0.0138599165,
-0.0128547978,
0.0046742484,
-0.0603446029,
0.009899809,
-0.0058417125,
-0.0166277681,
0.0264133941,
0.0839904547,
0.0397885889,
0.0729659721,
-0.0343541503,
0.0262715705,
-0.0261443555,
0.0394794978,
-0.0090962155,
0.0507685542,
0.1006302014,
-0.0384405926,
0.0476719663,
0.0380820855,
-0.0199031457,
-0.0246115234,
0.0197692141,
-0.08691594,
-0.0212522931,
0.0437766872,
0.0356560014,
-0.0331223533,
-0.0193984788,
-0.0179867502,
-0.0325738862,
-0.015727926,
0.053642638,
0.0126342671,
-0.0090578971,
-0.059572693,
0.0232298858,
-0.0923025906,
0.0439888053,
-0.0146030383,
0.0264226925,
0.0652387962,
-0.0049281036,
0.0297807641,
-0.0017178287,
-0.0520241596,
-0.018685719,
-0.0856944248,
0.0130191259,
0.0537062362,
-0.0192869008,
-0.0008778921,
0.048704084,
-0.0620188676,
-0.0230413824,
-0.0347639211,
-0.0187784918,
0.0061252145,
-0.0025296619,
0.0087682884,
0.053985592,
0.0466542467,
-0.0671179891,
-0.05435206,
-0.0169982649,
0.0556604825,
0.0333428904,
0.0449686423,
0.0068115946,
-0.0663016289,
-0.0218999367,
-0.011848717,
-0.0352160744,
0.0082236072,
-0.0395408757,
0.0558278374,
-0.0250282399,
-0.0149252592,
0.0165897701,
-0.0007021091,
-0.049075406,
0.0215049479,
0.0037127724,
0.0409744568,
0.0129856318,
0.0113450056,
0.0187258814,
-0.0363105126,
-0.0371482596,
-0.0155916717,
0.0260873549,
0.0133194048,
-0.0100419214,
0.037679676,
-0.0148539431,
-0.0386339836,
0.0088678487,
-0.0350182094,
-0.0286607556,
-0.0151077854,
0.0412889905,
0.0716701895,
0.0033254961,
-0.0139051974,
0.0005099552,
0.0572491437,
0.0055845659,
0.0178058185,
-0.0282204524,
0.013059631,
-0.0074391342,
0.0045825853,
0.009028527,
-0.0121548306,
0.040444538,
0.058387626,
-0.0260975249,
-0.0018708693,
0.006737567,
2.482e-7,
0.0558454134,
-0.0165270157,
0.0331605822,
-0.0070393668,
0.0327830464,
-0.015086743,
0.0027169986,
0.0325174704,
-0.0437199362,
-0.0138537111,
0.0076846262,
0.0051350775,
0.0571227595,
-0.0143164853,
-0.0533574373,
0.0072993273,
-0.0507274866,
0.0250685178,
-0.0133147193,
0.0181277972,
0.0301410817,
0.1187372878,
-0.0019769077,
0.0168906245,
-0.0758321062,
-0.0307564773,
0.0616247393,
-0.0371983908,
-0.0006447187,
-0.0347288884,
-0.0357840694,
0.0608649924,
0.022238411,
0.0009039819,
-0.0395177081,
0.0925714001,
0.0773383453,
0.0439147353,
-0.0132284332,
-0.0033678047,
0.0141480034,
-0.049531579,
-0.0163164046,
-0.0595686175,
0.116158396,
-0.0130185541,
-0.0560514852,
-0.0124484673,
0.0181624666,
0.0454592556,
0.0344229005,
0.0355508439,
-0.0673996136,
0.0206909087,
0.0454487689,
-0.0089233844,
-0.0015336399,
-0.0793969706,
0.0166903995,
0.016756488,
-0.0148029113,
0.0013980416,
-0.0147643788,
-0.0009157595,
0.0585371852,
0.0328394286,
-0.0506771505,
1.907104242e-34,
0.0058470736,
0.0465667844,
0.0403581522,
0.013257484,
0.0129292542,
-0.0104595516,
0.0508164242,
-0.025590701,
0.0532966927,
-0.0421164371,
-0.0091889584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07766v1
|
Challenges and Opportunities of NLP for HR Applications: A Discussion Paper
| 2024-05-13T14:09:06 | 2024-05-13T14:09:06 |
Jochen L. Leidner, Mark Stevenson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.1
|
Over the course of the recent decade, tremendous progress has been made in
the areas of machine learning and natural language processing, which opened up
vast areas of potential application use cases, including hiring and human
resource management. We review the use cases for text analytics in the realm of
human resources/personnel management, including actually realized as well as
potential but not yet implemented ones, and we analyze the opportunities and
risks of these.
|
[
0.0711106881,
0.0502796806,
-0.0148119349,
-0.056310609,
-0.0387300141,
0.0132295191,
-0.0111392438,
0.0356584676,
0.0340210646,
-0.0793366879,
0.0591876544,
-0.0014962516,
0.0053959778,
-0.0140977502,
0.0074770958,
-0.0355770849,
0.0177425146,
0.0793162733,
0.0145002715,
0.0339889862,
0.0064615328,
0.0712514892,
0.008483218,
0.0611452945,
-0.025432989,
-0.01466945,
0.0282901824,
-0.035739921,
0.0448518805,
0.006469327,
-0.0108227534,
0.0336903594,
-0.0086761573,
-0.0462601259,
0.0000017882,
-0.0271451864,
-0.0143875908,
0.0288252719,
-0.015669195,
-0.0354389921,
0.0673359409,
-0.0018021609,
-0.0073736701,
0.0470077507,
-0.0249912851,
0.0556863435,
0.0036016023,
-0.0053449306,
0.0425541326,
0.0289408434,
-0.0124834385,
-0.0075614681,
-0.0375792012,
-0.0105431257,
0.0027499064,
-0.0340499841,
0.0127010215,
-0.0414764285,
-0.0094047338,
-0.0105903223,
0.040873792,
0.013053406,
-0.0533453636,
-0.0239320863,
0.044744283,
0.0073251701,
0.0167196169,
-0.0040849326,
0.0018545497,
0.0006522833,
0.0296347849,
0.0157550927,
-0.0051413612,
-0.0384590514,
0.0346613228,
0.0367790982,
0.0366690382,
-0.0003356889,
-0.0349033289,
-0.0200504512,
-0.0678826272,
0.0126677658,
-0.0445518866,
-0.0139476862,
0.0238227565,
0.0163438991,
-0.0076695625,
-0.0319277979,
0.0750582665,
0.0533948503,
0.0820265934,
-0.022268679,
0.0398195758,
0.0222873073,
0.0044707856,
0.02066838,
-0.0119585441,
-0.0255900286,
0.051874049,
-0.0776760355,
-0.0198541619,
0.0256759077,
0.0180390589,
0.028747851,
0.0529551283,
0.0012002051,
0.0298512708,
-0.0552588962,
0.0022032717,
-0.0394049063,
-0.0739996657,
-0.0114508821,
-0.0098413434,
-0.0054435357,
0.0070876651,
0.0367430411,
-0.0736911371,
-0.0012919118,
-0.0159649998,
-0.0113105001,
-0.017556645,
0.0193907879,
0.0231389683,
0.0453309007,
-0.0948970467,
-0.0387912281,
-0.0098028826,
-0.0118410429,
-0.0566743836,
-0.0030733345,
0.0620896183,
-0.00763391,
0.0266174749,
0.0234450493,
0.0164940264,
0.0282383747,
0.0029599238,
-0.0217018742,
-0.0483014397,
-0.0456590094,
-0.0077402801,
-0.004958428,
-0.0466460772,
-0.0401608013,
0.0623702295,
-0.00207284,
-0.0386220813,
-0.0434776172,
0.0238175206,
0.090056546,
-0.0448761508,
-0.0177542251,
-0.0386417657,
0.0126320431,
0.0342555642,
-0.012110617,
0.0224069599,
0.0277855955,
0.0188716147,
0.0218257681,
0.0313596614,
-0.0295974612,
0.0218770672,
0.0416619815,
0.0043137595,
-0.0453113578,
-0.0028149947,
0.0431431681,
-0.0252542105,
-0.0083764186,
-0.0130634587,
0.0295274872,
-0.0392973386,
0.0239140894,
-0.02281739,
0.113705717,
0.002057394,
0.0318804532,
0.041827552,
0.0398996361,
-0.0368054174,
-0.0475389063,
0.0083526615,
-0.0041975235,
-0.0018691882,
-0.0558521859,
0.0082338434,
0.0110097732,
-0.0344264805,
-0.04943984,
-0.0223514773,
0.0054986998,
-0.0101389438,
-0.0298455358,
0.0211286023,
-0.0165672544,
-0.0261024646,
0.0101592159,
0.0625400618,
-0.0437399819,
-0.0112474291,
0.0012936606,
-0.0335951336,
0.116346918,
0.038080968,
-0.030927131,
0.0599018186,
-0.065428786,
-0.0324983448,
0.0463057309,
0.0517233796,
0.0040053665,
-0.0172413122,
-0.0201140381,
-0.001873379,
0.0521170907,
-0.0252460651,
0.0074010929,
0.0149877453,
0.0416450389,
0.0155267352,
0.0509275422,
-0.0683698207,
0.0624891073,
0.0407480448,
-0.0083941193,
0.005189023,
0.0395064913,
-0.021562105,
0.0645393431,
0.0040991921,
0.0098967487,
-0.0285842847,
0.024284333,
-0.0468830056,
0.0045492537,
0.0313712656,
-0.0022665651,
0.0120257717,
-0.021018561,
-0.0523788296,
-0.0068472489,
0.0323947668,
0.0437365137,
-0.0123690832,
-0.0481351539,
0.018218061,
-0.017021792,
0.0013287567,
-0.0584832206,
0.0158643983,
-0.0517832935,
0.0833970457,
0.0135266036,
0.0476282276,
-0.0215912517,
-0.0552296415,
0.0336587131,
-0.0764170364,
-0.0148739098,
-0.0262516923,
0.0223053861,
0.022177862,
0.0607915372,
-0.0234155599,
-0.0480612777,
0.0149292303,
-0.0540457815,
-0.0223947335,
0.0211756285,
0.0096042948,
0.0104259113,
-0.0314906463,
-0.011937351,
-0.024147179,
-0.0046617072,
-0.0291051231,
0.0426596105,
-0.004989678,
0.0429094918,
-0.022723766,
0.0254059304,
-0.0145475706,
-0.035610646,
-0.0480001271,
0.0100037539,
0.0808773339,
0.0064329305,
-0.0597634614,
0.0577797256,
-0.0187387001,
0.0100743044,
0.0105325487,
0.017552007,
0.0295573454,
0.0133375023,
0.0035365112,
0.0125142979,
0.0088587003,
0.050498262,
0.0063227019,
-0.0039171414,
0.0176206771,
-0.0043563298,
-0.0235279743,
0.0440706089,
-0.016047949,
-0.0576522574,
0.0287717506,
-0.032007046,
0.0236154981,
-0.0171969533,
-0.046043098,
0.003611817,
-0.0793877989,
0.0146307629,
-0.0718527287,
-0.0292566624,
-0.0114695635,
0.052479323,
0.0521702655,
0.0067117838,
0.008228397,
0.0072723189,
0.0505747087,
-0.0829960778,
-0.0663539171,
-0.0357290767,
0.0513659641,
-0.0020376593,
0.0110359322,
-0.004265944,
-0.0178886894,
0.0217527207,
-0.0429949462,
-0.0243105777,
-0.0176394489,
-0.0058398969,
-0.0001985647,
0.0079486212,
-0.0064454498,
0.0091666263,
-0.0481299572,
-0.078793034,
-0.0122295776,
0.0035987995,
0.0321775638,
0.0062766755,
-0.0757684708,
-0.0132741304,
0.0196804367,
-0.0294762831,
0.0404249541,
-0.0465560071,
0.0226906743,
0.001484461,
0.0190095659,
0.0040646163,
0.0130528538,
-0.001150779,
-0.02169149,
0.0539001375,
0.0069082985,
-0.0230323225,
0.0203630924,
-0.0241896845,
-0.0311234072,
-0.0643477961,
0.0339639895,
0.0023689228,
-0.0047532744,
-0.0185926203,
0.0445397086,
0.0423432514,
0.0526942722,
-0.0445437729,
0.0028783071,
0.0151538793,
-0.0393872783,
0.023717083,
0.0545849353,
-0.0124899419,
0.008335541,
-0.0465179794,
0.026293993,
-0.0556524098,
-0.053745579,
0.0010581231,
-0.0836086348,
0.0254934225,
-0.0440690368,
0.0196807887,
-0.0236049891,
0.0059602452,
-0.009543567,
-0.0232148487,
-0.0405688845,
-0.0295617394,
-0.035110075,
-0.0032890479,
0.0268097203,
-0.0649227202,
-0.018732097,
0.0427799337,
-0.0144901443,
-0.0633489937,
0.0372661687,
0.0878833681,
-0.0271961428,
-0.0181554276,
-0.0174887031,
0.0076781241,
0.0375370942,
0.0229676235,
0.0815558583,
-0.0205764547,
-0.0215236191,
-0.0725829676,
-0.017990889,
-0.0215404332,
0.0100616654,
0.0458553024,
0.0644220561,
-0.0206067692,
0.0288888458,
-0.0270732213,
0.0310494117,
-0.0104614533,
0.0302508753,
-0.0507282764,
-0.0796263143,
0.0044862297,
-0.0274403393,
0.053279683,
-0.0095688943,
-0.0561290756,
0.0286799334,
-0.0387874395,
0.0162778404,
-0.0272837412,
-0.0956212208,
0.0505046993,
0.0071650045,
0.0186437014,
-0.0082894387,
0.0167349968,
-0.008696706,
-0.0133973574,
-0.0200828426,
-0.0113511849,
0.0809697285,
0.0227590464,
-0.0443738326,
-0.0408660136,
0.0413761958,
-0.0360675938,
-0.0255381633,
-0.0418478996,
-0.0215252899,
-0.042799145,
-0.0284682512,
0.0114338016,
-0.0143505381,
0.0097331395,
-0.0346023142,
0.0250851437,
0.0260765571,
-0.0896341428,
0.0316921137,
-0.063566111,
0.0720751658,
-0.0282162931,
-0.021921346,
0.001830489,
0.0046092123,
-0.0136295017,
-0.0499079525,
-0.0048791184,
-0.0144619113,
-0.0254809726,
-0.014342458,
-0.0638342574,
0.0100440662,
-0.0049467776,
-0.0420808233,
-0.0211808365,
-0.0236131586,
-0.0269637797,
0.0006870807,
-0.0413745232,
-0.005348003,
0.0261945426,
-0.0133648198,
0.0003906486,
-0.0541598313,
0.0047262642,
-0.0265972782,
0.060180746,
0.0304843727,
0.05723067,
-0.0124942036,
-0.015104467,
0.0011567604,
-0.0471784547,
-0.0381421894,
0.0474362336,
0.0180886053,
0.0449750945,
-0.0011213839,
-0.0082005961,
0.0247278754,
0.0018281884,
-0.0203784779,
-0.041427765,
0.0196972284,
-0.0362158045,
-0.0086736633,
-0.0161901396,
0.0298737623,
-0.0089793047,
-0.0036849675,
0.0416800007,
-0.0280923583,
0.0281989351,
0.0116534792,
0.0212697256,
-0.0153380036,
-0.0306544658,
-0.0112119233,
-0.0087035708,
0.0357931145,
0.0081840316,
-0.046935305,
-0.0444400385,
-0.0295192525,
-0.0121613583,
0.0457764827,
0.0657619685,
-0.0110676419,
-0.000290993,
-0.1092166379,
-0.02087529,
0.0078052981,
-0.0303855352,
0.0239409152,
-0.0194500536,
0.0219010729,
0.0143636279,
0.0149272513,
0.0095607983,
-0.0834776014,
0.0355590433,
-0.0386142991,
0.0483808257,
-0.0245431829,
-5.419635439e-33,
-0.0159279965,
-0.0687668547,
0.0350357816,
-0.0012134251,
-0.0001939856,
-0.0042008287,
0.0496074781,
-0.0238336045,
-0.0345977731,
-0.0190115161,
-0.0068256618,
0.0288983621,
-0.0173275303,
0.0070007788,
0.0209682435,
0.0377015956,
0.0064172284,
-0.0337674655,
-0.0036920744,
-0.0273064356,
0.0294272434,
0.0226510167,
0.0561811253,
-0.0512655079,
0.0486090556,
0.0142442212,
-0.0248866659,
0.0249604601,
0.0624838695,
-0.0091861421,
-0.0360983685,
0.0075435163,
0.0317771509,
-0.0276060123,
0.0311022662,
0.0734124258,
0.0053113727,
-0.050580442,
0.0121673355,
0.0215782598,
0.0210211463,
0.017643543,
0.0033014941,
0.0098612141,
-0.0136591354,
-0.0062292316,
0.0783318058,
0.0270973518,
0.0165202189,
0.0273244251,
-0.0364641957,
0.0535156168,
-0.0638318732,
0.0518074296,
0.0011137269,
0.0314510763,
-0.0093783289,
0.0258617271,
-0.1235761195,
-0.0120738065,
-0.0032221077,
-0.0393442251,
-0.0145959668,
-0.0362683348,
-0.0154945487,
0.072083272,
0.0339266248,
0.0078608049,
-0.0114943432,
-0.0024578574,
-0.0049645975,
0.0426865779,
0.019560203,
0.0101322187,
0.0086062597,
-0.0489168689,
-0.0417846628,
0.0099804346,
0.0165236946,
-0.0110035948,
0.024786219,
-0.0037126064,
-0.0733878911,
-0.0283825584,
0.0272346716,
-0.0022874973,
-0.003926801,
-0.0248939972,
0.000740915,
-0.0032013711,
0.0180942863,
0.0407911129,
-0.0219758619,
-0.0022829161,
0.0052891285,
0.0250887033,
-0.0498776883,
-0.0132317794,
-0.0004942813,
-0.0398683622,
-0.1087418199,
0.0182894208,
-0.0130017241,
0.0265933648,
0.0363305025,
0.0053830869,
-0.0032186697,
-0.0156613141,
-0.0770731643,
-0.002987321,
0.0161540247,
0.0509327762,
-0.0171319507,
-0.0212520789,
0.0232536588,
0.0221953411,
0.0098737618,
0.0651317015,
0.0280651618,
0.0000429181,
0.0160588399,
-0.0078041079,
0.0603516698,
-0.0277101528,
0.0041363845,
-0.0339590758,
0.0313313939,
0.0412002057,
0.0623581186,
-0.0150441285,
0.0055654938,
-0.0357654393,
2.212e-7,
0.0745047927,
0.0389995612,
-0.0259657726,
-0.0322187617,
0.0195954721,
0.0348599404,
0.032470081,
0.0146439523,
0.0234622546,
0.048915308,
0.0352282375,
-0.0221536495,
0.0284772236,
0.0537401401,
-0.0492136404,
-0.0367538966,
-0.0097165601,
-0.0983316749,
-0.0540257134,
0.0278343149,
0.082491152,
0.0501703061,
0.0738486126,
-0.0164748821,
-0.0491577573,
-0.0230752341,
0.0376897976,
0.024551576,
-0.0161065627,
0.0164310988,
0.0090260589,
0.0014763507,
-0.0309142731,
0.0641949922,
-0.0325438194,
0.0741558671,
0.0697545931,
0.0235910285,
-0.0710010678,
0.0293429382,
0.0298975911,
-0.0470196903,
-0.0386989042,
-0.0068424679,
0.0378315523,
0.0280093458,
-0.0360203646,
-0.0215691347,
0.0064617028,
0.0002343471,
0.0248448122,
0.0507865176,
-0.0215905812,
0.013320026,
-0.0014906886,
-0.0238691177,
-0.0416495502,
-0.0391347073,
0.0401714668,
-0.0007164794,
-0.014229482,
-0.0508232228,
0.0277911611,
0.0530446023,
0.0098860105,
-0.0086679738,
0.0474015065,
1.362461893e-34,
-0.0071808165,
0.0225727148,
-0.0416390188,
-0.0005799803,
0.0608937591,
0.0571988262,
0.0150808515,
0.0087788301,
0.0194310322,
-0.028527271,
0.0149223013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07765v1
|
TANQ: An open domain dataset of table answered questions
| 2024-05-13T14:07:20 | 2024-05-13T14:07:20 |
Mubashara Akhtar, Chenxi Pang, Andreea Marzoca, Yasemin Altun, Julian Martin Eisenschlos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models, potentially augmented with tool usage such as retrieval are
becoming the go-to means of answering questions. Understanding and answering
questions in real-world settings often requires retrieving information from
different sources, processing and aggregating data to extract insights, and
presenting complex findings in form of structured artifacts such as novel
tables, charts, or infographics. In this paper, we introduce TANQ, the first
open domain question answering dataset where the answers require building
tables from information across multiple sources. We release the full source
attribution for every cell in the resulting table and benchmark
state-of-the-art language models in open, oracle, and closed book setups. Our
best-performing baseline, GPT4 reaches an overall F1 score of 29.1, lagging
behind human performance by 19.7 points. We analyse baselines' performance
across different dataset attributes such as different skills required for this
task, including multi-hop reasoning, math operations, and unit conversions. We
further discuss common failures in model-generated answers, suggesting that
TANQ is a complex task with many challenges ahead.
|
[
0.0183078405,
0.070830971,
-0.0101075182,
0.0272203796,
-0.0176165421,
0.0238131788,
-0.0121152755,
-0.002550957,
-0.010356918,
-0.009428191,
-0.037008848,
0.0012980616,
-0.0311033409,
0.0438054167,
0.0367229544,
0.0038710313,
0.0239220411,
0.0002324829,
-0.0117501235,
0.0124223568,
-0.0096334601,
0.021143388,
-0.0233619567,
0.0212472696,
-0.010586556,
-0.0399226323,
-0.0090795122,
-0.0263998359,
-0.0280412845,
0.010335099,
0.0022507648,
0.0781145245,
0.0183917638,
0.0381218567,
0.0000017902,
-0.0047614141,
-0.0173422173,
-0.0048956065,
-0.0403434299,
-0.0213614758,
0.0024976067,
-0.0031614383,
0.0448755436,
0.0270734113,
-0.0843219832,
-0.0336697102,
0.0090402691,
0.0459710695,
0.080009833,
0.0391770005,
0.0057933074,
-0.0266624391,
0.0072583798,
0.0013807195,
0.0499969386,
-0.048050046,
-0.0026376159,
0.0633107424,
0.0228355043,
-0.0089025488,
0.0133558959,
0.0405409746,
0.0458406508,
-0.0120795025,
-0.0187902804,
0.0240608659,
-0.042318996,
0.0477901511,
0.0217030831,
0.1137917265,
0.0300512835,
-0.0156579372,
-0.0140807843,
0.0122952051,
0.0316331536,
0.0099335723,
-0.078608714,
0.0056194123,
-0.0140178213,
-0.0290680677,
-0.014002433,
-0.0226818174,
-0.0041447431,
-0.0110011725,
-0.017229544,
0.0640316978,
-0.0062602651,
-0.0214645416,
-0.0098711317,
-0.0042160689,
-0.0330084823,
-0.0354675241,
0.00406557,
0.0484258048,
-0.0337692499,
0.0291095432,
-0.0144249154,
-0.0163275432,
0.0231174193,
-0.0403758362,
0.0292439628,
0.0391680449,
-0.0075606876,
0.0583411157,
-0.0248539504,
0.0234350841,
-0.0268818848,
0.0259431601,
-0.0416164696,
-0.037807364,
-0.0701149404,
-0.0247448776,
-0.038679719,
0.0294288769,
-0.074967593,
-0.0008161726,
0.0174744669,
0.0169747379,
0.0012614426,
-0.0009601742,
0.0387914926,
0.0506575033,
-0.0113667333,
0.0075331954,
-0.054588493,
0.0203430615,
-0.0549411625,
0.015050021,
0.0048367782,
-0.099256672,
-0.0273507237,
-0.0186327398,
0.003026217,
-0.0367377214,
0.0322455391,
0.0844438672,
-0.0152302217,
0.0227078423,
-0.0224752985,
-0.0465862378,
-0.0019290665,
-0.0582221858,
0.003560618,
-0.0574632064,
0.058018215,
0.0446484834,
-0.0275238845,
-0.0600783601,
0.0045121736,
0.0771073699,
-0.0126129128,
0.035853181,
0.0000668938,
0.004780699,
0.033008337,
-0.0050150631,
-0.0221561808,
0.0888589248,
0.0396995842,
0.005090232,
0.0153079098,
-0.0079615908,
-0.0003700709,
0.0223989896,
0.0494321063,
0.0139291734,
-0.0053106216,
0.0915606916,
0.0061243367,
0.0332744718,
-0.0099956999,
0.03460107,
-0.0136532122,
-0.0118344678,
0.0328842811,
0.0379821919,
-0.0020585253,
0.0547338724,
0.0019293043,
-0.015818011,
0.0485984422,
-0.0181883536,
-0.020417124,
0.0611047335,
0.009003981,
0.0133112259,
0.0223550256,
0.0137446215,
-0.0295718499,
-0.0374083072,
-0.0069282316,
0.029793445,
-0.0386822857,
0.0365038887,
0.0312586986,
0.0267766658,
-0.0447773375,
0.0425089747,
-0.0146114724,
-0.0664439201,
-0.0105245011,
-0.0205740277,
0.0488209836,
0.0126937386,
0.0553761311,
-0.0541595146,
-0.0184512008,
-0.0267984215,
0.0361730009,
0.01574881,
0.0338099115,
-0.0401321054,
-0.0082498081,
0.0049436609,
-0.010136513,
-0.0039146519,
0.0112206759,
-0.0140058696,
0.0270917602,
-0.000707285,
-0.0115901018,
-0.072028771,
-0.0263086203,
0.0249828063,
0.0008331285,
-0.0296659749,
-0.001373176,
-0.0146203153,
0.0025567659,
0.0445329286,
0.0072166924,
0.0555239432,
0.0370485298,
-0.0212344229,
-0.0205146912,
-0.0126918992,
-0.011238887,
-0.0027292289,
0.0570452213,
-0.010164992,
-0.0453201085,
0.0282259528,
-0.0399040915,
-0.0699908659,
0.0270490423,
-0.0250249151,
-0.0195405632,
-0.0376211405,
-0.032853175,
0.0237259082,
-0.0040756837,
-0.0207788516,
0.0890857354,
0.0062501072,
0.0549987741,
0.0046803765,
-0.0518967658,
0.0552450158,
-0.0366200842,
0.0490734018,
-0.0233574901,
-0.0169906504,
0.0366005152,
-0.0004408736,
0.0165533982,
-0.0811566859,
0.0065807668,
-0.0688663647,
0.0328824371,
-0.0318694264,
0.0289254691,
0.043364197,
0.0048778439,
-0.0116805118,
-0.027404489,
-0.0864170417,
-0.0208783932,
0.0254556183,
0.0130864354,
0.0603776276,
0.0129807256,
0.026980076,
-0.0349927284,
-0.0261397902,
-0.0351516195,
0.0431430563,
-0.0133809512,
0.0240275431,
0.0030174674,
-0.0229880046,
-0.0376812853,
0.0326626673,
0.0168831367,
0.0163906496,
0.0097186333,
-0.0365543254,
0.0199963078,
0.0558337867,
-0.0210462585,
-0.0019074337,
-0.0012492165,
-0.0037950755,
-0.0474833548,
0.028966222,
-0.0029056007,
0.0010816447,
0.0157008246,
-0.0432419851,
0.0089094667,
0.0377830863,
0.0069600279,
-0.0021385788,
-0.0388462096,
0.0417267643,
0.0131279603,
-0.0047434852,
-0.0969601423,
0.0468461104,
0.0100022536,
0.0405493304,
-0.0268413685,
0.0057571065,
0.0282143131,
-0.0270870458,
0.0066134189,
-0.0321538895,
0.0193632971,
-0.0709480569,
0.076683782,
-0.0193555504,
0.0028645438,
-0.0300613176,
-0.0153965931,
-0.060182713,
-0.0019100386,
0.0012123203,
-0.0541683659,
0.0797541887,
-0.0409914777,
-0.0004624287,
-0.0193690713,
-0.0359195508,
-0.021618221,
-0.0339277834,
-0.0280088354,
0.0309971888,
0.0051739807,
-0.027399864,
-0.0225355029,
-0.0330436453,
0.0451323763,
0.0032587745,
-0.0354729369,
-0.020090783,
-0.0173276532,
0.0668394938,
0.077137351,
0.0288766213,
0.0129035944,
-0.0224057902,
0.0112961316,
0.0581786595,
0.0533460937,
-0.0027602348,
0.0127522377,
0.0127272625,
0.0146409301,
-0.026866857,
0.0000582802,
0.016803924,
0.0011228794,
-0.0466938466,
-0.0213814359,
0.0852321759,
0.0394543186,
0.0017545751,
-0.0263435338,
-0.0364285037,
0.0220750235,
0.0273429584,
0.0593342409,
-0.1348884106,
-0.0248107947,
-0.0214785784,
-0.000423429,
0.0318281502,
-0.049771674,
-0.0101550817,
-0.117079787,
0.0183627959,
-0.0407844111,
-0.072036691,
-0.0638777614,
-0.0400717892,
-0.011726927,
-0.0301735308,
-0.0032777681,
0.0505329035,
-0.0085745966,
0.0447427146,
0.0234404486,
0.0048907846,
0.0111448113,
0.045137357,
-0.0327905193,
0.0049913889,
0.041624058,
0.0199741907,
-0.0167953856,
-0.0347906649,
-0.0153773567,
-0.0323051326,
-0.01739485,
0.0087414067,
0.0612113699,
0.0031970579,
-0.0028718158,
-0.0176022612,
0.0216977652,
-0.0851104483,
0.0210775789,
0.0356937833,
0.0855232999,
-0.0070063774,
0.0268903617,
-0.00519859,
-0.0198156182,
-0.0038705352,
0.0917550251,
0.0336487405,
0.0025296449,
-0.0669956282,
-0.0378519781,
-0.039919395,
-0.0828202069,
-0.0083773052,
0.0408993587,
0.0220105201,
-0.0036391139,
-0.0592787601,
-0.0396671183,
0.0694819465,
0.0511256754,
-0.0073113688,
0.0315408409,
-0.0313939266,
0.0066587897,
-0.0381854214,
0.0124896951,
-0.0564841814,
0.0154447677,
-0.0353093222,
-0.0088602537,
0.0042393808,
-0.036261674,
-0.0355631672,
0.0213403329,
-0.0604246929,
-0.0123637142,
-0.0042650984,
0.0189443957,
0.0255450271,
-0.0279269312,
-0.0105704963,
-0.0007507504,
-0.0150918672,
-0.0046649203,
-0.0990175605,
-0.0310546216,
-0.0052028182,
-0.0287729837,
-0.0004285976,
0.0495177768,
-0.0496381894,
-0.0031329619,
-0.0040067658,
0.0403630771,
-0.0101402756,
0.0012264176,
0.0522785485,
0.0028780366,
-0.0059758574,
0.0631418899,
-0.0404447392,
-0.0123614781,
0.0254589263,
-0.0460926406,
-0.0149664301,
-0.0170569755,
0.00780915,
0.0172548182,
-0.0358411819,
-0.0056238277,
0.0003299834,
0.0047170562,
0.0520605557,
-0.0523047522,
-0.0230708476,
0.0547652841,
0.0005983957,
-0.0008372372,
-0.0379700288,
-0.030174017,
-0.0313072167,
0.0015220995,
0.0479964986,
-0.0064230226,
0.0397069007,
0.0179082807,
-0.0249045119,
0.001164732,
0.0231209677,
-0.0930188447,
-0.0820365697,
0.0064211702,
-0.0005431442,
0.028005125,
0.0171851404,
0.0205411594,
-0.0004049871,
-0.0301985461,
0.0149150863,
-0.0026991691,
0.0335256346,
0.0152285676,
0.0468815193,
0.0310747232,
-0.0194251463,
-0.0369930826,
0.0932046175,
0.0204517078,
0.0242773276,
0.0012682566,
-0.0245991163,
-0.0273191407,
-0.0101774633,
-0.0262562893,
-0.0099028395,
0.0030584431,
-0.0019170309,
-0.0486941934,
-0.0610420294,
-0.0046129958,
0.0601912625,
-0.023725532,
0.0071767196,
0.0331815183,
0.0797063932,
0.0524660908,
-0.0423529856,
-0.0649756044,
0.0470715277,
-0.0351329707,
-0.0341096744,
-0.0137956729,
-5.728946574e-33,
-0.0226003453,
-0.0015042294,
0.0442241915,
-0.0187241938,
0.0293222647,
-0.0248531662,
-0.0315832905,
-0.0050853165,
-0.0534951389,
0.0013403267,
-0.0424746759,
0.0634973943,
0.0103383502,
0.0218953826,
0.02150511,
-0.0671574101,
0.0016219529,
-0.0303991232,
-0.0050628269,
0.0273648221,
0.0514121056,
0.009404514,
0.0179537889,
-0.0304606333,
0.0334215574,
-0.0218707658,
0.0115952976,
0.0251220837,
-0.0136196436,
0.0549435131,
-0.0203236844,
0.0286514238,
0.0327361338,
-0.0638652369,
-0.028178025,
-0.0041337744,
-0.1277301162,
-0.0383941047,
0.0111228274,
-0.0031450468,
-0.0660010353,
-0.0149659375,
0.0216754228,
0.0025742077,
0.0160365812,
-0.0407661237,
0.0271306951,
-0.02627475,
-0.0006608524,
0.0014545966,
-0.0015460176,
0.004849568,
-0.0155673688,
0.0117459232,
-0.0005613159,
0.08282125,
0.0042026504,
-0.0143127609,
-0.0358431377,
0.0195263401,
0.0082660969,
0.0280278847,
0.0506360158,
-0.0182260405,
0.0309959557,
0.0094838226,
0.0302160531,
-0.0015083642,
-0.0307743475,
0.001806043,
-0.0628767237,
0.0587837845,
0.0846675634,
0.0269635655,
0.0150767099,
0.0144082,
-0.0875432715,
0.0646109879,
-0.0074778511,
0.0120022846,
-0.023440918,
-0.0250187349,
-0.0162443034,
0.0014521786,
-0.0296691358,
0.0262083579,
-0.0387529396,
-0.0311438087,
0.0326337181,
-0.0368024595,
0.0288155712,
-0.016265057,
0.0347926654,
-0.0123569574,
-0.0072890734,
0.061990533,
-0.0062810681,
0.0116664944,
0.0303407703,
0.0428170301,
-0.0434122086,
0.0283493698,
0.0090307146,
-0.0023717619,
0.0187416151,
0.0404019132,
0.0369170345,
0.0048054946,
-0.0709966868,
-0.0109494319,
-0.0539165214,
0.0403141044,
-0.0129622454,
0.0036877845,
0.0021740177,
0.0218096599,
0.0194214005,
0.0358828679,
0.0011495583,
-0.0149379037,
-0.0313282236,
-0.0120020732,
0.0067129461,
-0.0285958722,
0.0158937704,
0.0091408724,
-0.0404963121,
0.0333554856,
0.007881633,
-0.0385592319,
0.0071056369,
0.0323985219,
2.354e-7,
0.0971984789,
-0.0144774253,
0.0485624447,
0.0771073923,
-0.0159055199,
-0.0019005061,
-0.0121847633,
0.023898514,
0.017801201,
-0.018115066,
0.0001582181,
0.0087269535,
0.0339791253,
0.0571125038,
-0.0656762198,
-0.0414005704,
-0.0728355721,
-0.0087318141,
-0.0411629863,
-0.0090671871,
0.0507534333,
0.0696335658,
-0.0428344682,
-0.0092386883,
-0.0221869461,
-0.0331918485,
0.0477279164,
-0.0287486557,
0.0144848088,
0.0157935824,
0.0443056263,
-0.0101497518,
0.0297997408,
0.0334747322,
-0.0221473202,
-0.013584557,
0.0229411852,
0.0328555703,
0.0178358965,
-0.0251522455,
-0.0223189499,
-0.0806754977,
0.0501952432,
-0.0685661435,
0.1028296053,
-0.0255433861,
-0.016047461,
0.0568832457,
-0.0096118199,
0.0005495729,
-0.0013100486,
-0.0022667763,
-0.0003550721,
0.000534851,
0.014193574,
0.0067791566,
0.0351664424,
-0.0343997777,
-0.0298994668,
0.040002618,
-0.0307049323,
-0.0201351289,
-0.0122842547,
-0.0301997159,
-0.0090452638,
-0.0190927275,
-0.0196660329,
2.179334154e-34,
0.0266337283,
0.0154462047,
0.0452650525,
0.0361894406,
0.0670212433,
-0.0564890839,
0.0099189943,
-0.0179838613,
0.0195869654,
-0.099563539,
-0.0316425897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07764v1
|
LGDE: Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion
| 2024-05-13T14:07:15 | 2024-05-13T14:07:15 |
Dominik J. Schindler, Sneha Jha, Xixuan Zhang, Kilian Buehling, Annett Heft, Mauricio Barahona
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI, physics.soc-ph
|
Expanding a dictionary of pre-selected keywords is crucial for tasks in
information retrieval, such as database query and online data collection. Here
we propose Local Graph-based Dictionary Expansion (LGDE), a method that uses
tools from manifold learning and network science for the data-driven discovery
of keywords starting from a seed dictionary. At the heart of LGDE lies the
creation of a word similarity graph derived from word embeddings and the
application of local community detection based on graph diffusion to discover
semantic neighbourhoods of pre-defined seed keywords. The diffusion in the
local graph manifold allows the exploration of the complex nonlinear geometry
of word embeddings and can capture word similarities based on paths of semantic
association. We validate our method on a corpus of hate speech-related posts
from Reddit and Gab and show that LGDE enriches the list of keywords and
achieves significantly better performance than threshold methods based on
direct word similarities. We further demonstrate the potential of our method
through a real-world use case from communication science, where LGDE is
evaluated quantitatively on data collected and analysed by domain experts by
expanding a conspiracy-related dictionary.
|
[
0.0186174009,
0.0427577235,
-0.0121224821,
0.0428900681,
-0.0311109275,
-0.005844614,
-0.0148798916,
0.0216038264,
0.0715759546,
-0.014866042,
0.0134628238,
-0.0150370561,
-0.0271316133,
0.0337233543,
0.038945578,
-0.0059072464,
0.0442767665,
0.0387994759,
-0.0315567963,
-0.0263221674,
0.0179541633,
0.0307215229,
0.0068982397,
0.0075723021,
-0.0256283563,
0.0329978876,
0.0308660697,
-0.0000474189,
0.0299349632,
0.001212331,
-0.0059895818,
0.0295924768,
0.036689017,
0.0582368746,
0.0000018236,
-0.0510185994,
-0.0261574183,
-0.0091086309,
0.0303061884,
-0.0478290394,
0.0531589352,
-0.0146416239,
0.0544557646,
0.0139299519,
-0.033095289,
-0.0491274223,
0.042515792,
-0.0163204651,
0.0210611876,
0.0581436045,
-0.0355575681,
-0.0690673962,
-0.0252677575,
0.0053312629,
-0.0177644864,
-0.003991392,
0.0553678945,
0.0029805154,
0.0188314691,
-0.0262308326,
-0.038425047,
-0.0004388094,
-0.0573213696,
-0.0085408567,
0.108111456,
0.0274887104,
0.0099013951,
-0.0348066799,
0.023980638,
0.0854938254,
-0.0224002041,
-0.0251002926,
0.0487524718,
0.0078037735,
-0.028912738,
0.1034202874,
-0.025647819,
-0.0307274759,
-0.0460298173,
0.023878416,
-0.0038727166,
-0.051092539,
0.0699265376,
0.0167004205,
-0.0231480226,
0.0716511458,
0.0064619561,
-0.0041762902,
0.01151961,
-0.0352407172,
-0.0221863016,
0.0017218282,
0.0367550291,
-0.0060570152,
0.0121328728,
0.0254213922,
-0.0018706062,
-0.021354679,
0.0077058473,
-0.0700627789,
0.0234575756,
-0.0285974201,
0.044571925,
0.0701461062,
0.0097514633,
-0.0227078479,
-0.0549953319,
0.0513599291,
-0.0589694157,
-0.0144100888,
-0.0465994067,
0.0128855165,
0.0065085771,
0.0051896321,
0.0007079786,
-0.0309580117,
-0.0025824981,
0.0357897207,
-0.0189782102,
-0.0183453318,
-0.025365768,
0.053513255,
0.0661042407,
-0.0110744778,
0.0008529871,
-0.0366666466,
-0.0492745377,
0.0354727022,
-0.0562827177,
0.0382294506,
-0.0049174149,
0.0029097791,
0.0695503056,
-0.0111120446,
-0.0110663874,
0.0077893077,
0.0454081371,
-0.0225268099,
0.0110386536,
-0.0176788643,
-0.0312827267,
0.0099006314,
0.0353568234,
-0.0862230361,
0.0074434835,
0.0070393933,
-0.0184903331,
-0.0471587516,
-0.0124825006,
0.0116876774,
-0.0824507922,
0.0499484539,
-0.0332669728,
0.0163340755,
0.0643712506,
0.0015033423,
0.0253609549,
0.0023611498,
-0.0195632316,
0.0533044375,
0.0722853243,
0.0112139573,
-0.0321409404,
0.0106421933,
0.0364741385,
0.0044131805,
-0.0275431238,
-0.0131867835,
-0.0174538922,
0.0106222611,
-0.0121445879,
0.0441629551,
-0.0747255757,
-0.0721530765,
-0.0088784099,
0.0973729715,
-0.0155539,
-0.0241799727,
-0.0140885673,
0.0346061215,
-0.0693393499,
-0.0206911061,
-0.004221967,
-0.0205898564,
-0.0278796032,
-0.0387727208,
0.1108937785,
0.0148687474,
-0.0127023337,
0.030741401,
-0.0510059148,
-0.0027385261,
0.0784606114,
-0.0448004678,
0.0261250399,
0.0079969075,
-0.0118830232,
-0.0091938395,
0.0517060272,
-0.0162620395,
0.0081320303,
-0.0037917926,
0.0046533155,
0.0468599238,
0.0510731712,
-0.0143405609,
-0.001680526,
0.0007302071,
0.0089000296,
0.0151653076,
-0.0024767667,
-0.0254364144,
-0.0624032542,
-0.0431847125,
-0.0315712467,
0.0176479127,
0.015907893,
0.0192684308,
0.0357277766,
0.0201612096,
-0.0063579325,
-0.0610207878,
-0.0148862023,
0.0109642493,
0.0372689143,
0.0118978629,
0.0256837681,
-0.0020570834,
0.0109006725,
0.0353195667,
-0.0303634964,
-0.0248221792,
0.0505564325,
-0.0348903127,
-0.0638213977,
-0.0190934129,
0.0341525711,
0.0205044784,
0.0446150824,
-0.0639255941,
0.0397297218,
0.0419672616,
0.0171578694,
-0.0041147126,
0.0887702256,
-0.0341920219,
0.0368396156,
-0.0255101956,
-0.067985557,
-0.0521460809,
0.047453586,
-0.0364114679,
0.0390335172,
-0.0191313159,
0.0202861149,
-0.0403743535,
0.0063298526,
0.0248385593,
0.0417370386,
-0.0604382865,
-0.0060580261,
0.0401616879,
0.0030020792,
0.0543768071,
-0.0514204651,
-0.0233056843,
-0.0042360416,
-0.0496816486,
-0.0158031657,
-0.0034762786,
-0.0164731015,
-0.0112874946,
-0.0058453595,
-0.008665327,
0.017826952,
0.0178803522,
0.0164863728,
0.0353143066,
0.0199608691,
0.0171703361,
-0.0463698059,
-0.0348911881,
-0.028233273,
-0.0394848958,
-0.0040316638,
0.0542104729,
-0.0060491213,
-0.06860248,
0.060961511,
-0.0022388254,
-0.0556129925,
-0.0015032304,
-0.0200151354,
-0.0040129311,
0.0059743347,
-0.0141069368,
0.0278940424,
-0.0010239395,
0.0207510553,
0.034176562,
0.0341731384,
0.0070475996,
-0.0184826609,
-0.043647103,
-0.0682194978,
0.0125094587,
-0.0287200436,
-0.0047441465,
-0.027542159,
0.0070814183,
0.0707173198,
-0.0315214433,
-0.0394593515,
0.0207487922,
-0.0394307412,
-0.0041834954,
-0.0452639423,
-0.0373092443,
0.0068576192,
0.0001304881,
-0.0150237009,
-0.0653524846,
0.0528857,
0.0395379886,
0.0518052056,
0.0010593862,
-0.0406084657,
-0.0110651916,
0.043033462,
0.0204036087,
0.0188789349,
-0.026148349,
0.0057979641,
0.0319912098,
-0.0180049986,
0.0464308821,
-0.0318016931,
-0.016207926,
-0.0180650111,
0.0296426136,
0.0498291776,
0.01781982,
-0.0231878199,
-0.0625946596,
-0.0030193294,
-0.0271347035,
0.0398612991,
-0.0599848256,
0.0507833026,
0.0049533076,
-0.0015905659,
-0.0104927151,
0.022415448,
0.0029971038,
0.0234188493,
0.0168951042,
0.0146264331,
-0.0021826639,
0.020606298,
0.0062079979,
-0.0185973067,
0.0258286782,
0.0221799593,
-0.0279445183,
-0.0314367861,
-0.0173808746,
-0.0211418197,
0.0071139941,
-0.003539714,
-0.0317829028,
-0.0129564097,
0.0440012068,
-0.0078931805,
0.0738309845,
0.0450789779,
-0.0434813239,
-0.0109531311,
0.0380314551,
-0.0050663496,
0.0439815223,
-0.0248619337,
-0.0743967816,
0.0300897527,
-0.0288133137,
0.0233773887,
0.0142719606,
-0.05136979,
0.0007663876,
-0.0362130739,
0.0170374699,
0.0093831224,
0.0032469365,
-0.007167141,
-0.116370298,
0.0170234833,
0.0078337928,
-0.0556823276,
-0.0476430953,
0.022875227,
-0.0024177341,
0.0243164711,
-0.0532270558,
-0.0436346419,
-0.0047578192,
-0.0309565924,
0.0161467846,
-0.0202242583,
0.0283418689,
-0.0139236609,
-0.0172903929,
-0.0137404036,
0.0310313348,
-0.0254579671,
-0.054231327,
0.0401525013,
0.0191292409,
0.0002237392,
0.0043013599,
0.0355547294,
-0.0403789096,
0.0014214615,
-0.0328406729,
0.0936234668,
0.0000678859,
-0.0357449129,
-0.0585331246,
-0.0024125818,
0.0022609385,
0.0008905699,
-0.0153684672,
0.0210506935,
0.0261364318,
0.0173486974,
0.0265199728,
0.0233831201,
-0.0562065989,
-0.0295679905,
-0.0102555174,
-0.0160931516,
-0.0551348403,
0.0098565994,
0.0016864707,
0.045451358,
-0.0128774755,
0.0073542399,
0.0287675001,
-0.0496440008,
-0.0973552093,
-0.0099737793,
0.0127499728,
0.0023245031,
0.056287583,
-0.0400926918,
0.0125820069,
0.0087816855,
-0.0526535287,
-0.0110915443,
-0.0656160563,
-0.0529311039,
0.028546093,
-0.0285047181,
0.0025557324,
0.038886819,
-0.0456605628,
-0.0376132615,
0.0671800375,
0.0273102708,
0.0242318213,
0.0235652942,
-0.000147096,
-0.0435992852,
0.0272668228,
0.0435764492,
-0.0188806579,
0.0171145201,
0.0238523483,
-0.0200292319,
-0.0614767373,
-0.0255305357,
-0.0136456583,
0.0299033727,
0.0543960445,
-0.010477175,
-0.0292953867,
-0.0959339887,
-0.0536745936,
0.0014194862,
-0.0134452796,
0.0350445025,
-0.0328807011,
0.0385502353,
-0.015207001,
-0.0475395769,
0.0053329798,
-0.0169742312,
0.0479169562,
-0.0318067968,
-0.0044206493,
0.0268908311,
0.0222027302,
0.0283176526,
0.0213115551,
-0.0222199839,
0.0091998773,
-0.0320578851,
-0.0219683517,
-0.0376749747,
-0.0124851782,
-0.0073728072,
-0.0326985605,
-0.0315243267,
0.0194990542,
-0.0483205654,
-0.0138778212,
-0.0134828333,
0.0263918117,
0.0252830982,
-0.0192084126,
0.0116881328,
-0.0070673777,
-0.0267329216,
-0.0208786447,
0.0216012876,
-0.0384986065,
-0.0529236533,
0.0238906667,
0.0195739977,
-0.0289997291,
0.0694405958,
0.0261612944,
-0.019233482,
0.0069816294,
0.0287298001,
-0.0534573235,
-0.0041554412,
-0.0069259396,
0.0065617603,
0.0956033394,
0.0160499327,
0.0682073683,
-0.0531228818,
-0.0351972356,
0.0500728078,
-0.0079123564,
-0.0338833369,
0.0304948986,
0.0502730459,
0.0755366534,
-0.0017509469,
0.0625267029,
-0.0403285064,
0.043478135,
-0.0220409613,
-0.0616895929,
0.040576797,
-6.49621892e-33,
0.0336075947,
-0.0638412684,
-0.0148985973,
0.0091584129,
-0.019247191,
0.0168809835,
0.0097616538,
-0.0082468623,
-0.0216758698,
0.0476991311,
0.000736653,
0.0375103205,
-0.0152636096,
0.00140768,
-0.0351520292,
-0.0098832799,
-0.0117984721,
0.0151544483,
0.0334783308,
0.0204636622,
0.0560409538,
0.0327579714,
0.0462359637,
-0.0475798734,
0.0280199982,
-0.0040035672,
0.0421028547,
0.0286671054,
0.0479693264,
0.0270768106,
-0.0257274359,
0.0764626637,
0.0079577388,
0.0080179833,
0.0080711627,
-0.0295282155,
-0.0120622981,
-0.0371883102,
-0.0035704751,
-0.0465369374,
0.0135116605,
0.033850994,
0.0457531586,
0.0167750474,
-0.0214116406,
-0.0116919121,
0.0679296479,
0.021039946,
-0.0588910244,
0.016077362,
-0.0317096189,
0.0521036983,
-0.032762114,
0.0106868101,
0.0068678576,
-0.0634660423,
0.0012859001,
0.0027953179,
-0.0329782106,
0.0576748848,
-0.0527618788,
-0.0146146482,
0.0021704535,
0.0033491789,
0.0339640155,
0.0992630646,
-0.0019380606,
0.0157358348,
-0.0188062601,
0.0324883424,
0.0430159308,
0.021587912,
-0.0199532174,
0.0852417573,
-0.0078206705,
-0.0629486814,
-0.0667801276,
-0.0069671678,
-0.0027949964,
-0.0224812981,
0.029124124,
0.0231320541,
-0.0402418934,
-0.0387240723,
-0.0096351532,
-0.0143918321,
-0.026003832,
-0.0076561845,
-0.0418611169,
-0.0082229674,
-0.0387062691,
-0.0151508972,
-0.020877298,
-0.0304819364,
-0.012754445,
0.0607638173,
0.0075121596,
-0.024982119,
0.0097145671,
0.0188202132,
-0.045286186,
-0.0146454079,
-0.0428971499,
0.012301161,
0.0098859081,
-0.0044973828,
-0.0433178544,
0.0086760772,
-0.0367268734,
0.0015517337,
-0.0046661864,
-0.0658980384,
-0.0543756001,
-0.0236050691,
0.0270151738,
0.0534603447,
-0.0023638243,
0.0540618226,
0.0721689761,
0.0664420128,
0.0291642062,
0.0022772141,
-0.0232069623,
0.0070442026,
-0.0087522175,
-0.0134288827,
-0.0134157166,
0.0246981345,
0.0470040888,
-0.0825441331,
0.0186322238,
-0.039383702,
2.747e-7,
0.0378093049,
0.0722683221,
0.0116312066,
-0.0255826414,
0.0080287931,
-0.010362329,
0.0405032709,
0.0398773141,
-0.0533298627,
-0.0465285331,
0.0136331292,
0.0725544468,
-0.0434984602,
0.0700833425,
-0.0364238098,
0.0568174757,
-0.0650341958,
0.0047368049,
-0.0357262976,
0.0096370606,
-0.0179282278,
0.0461818576,
0.0794683397,
-0.0018010946,
-0.027668776,
-0.042004779,
-0.0027616732,
-0.0167977326,
-0.0241029393,
-0.0070684385,
-0.0115593867,
-0.0357695334,
0.0208110698,
-0.0187990703,
-0.0119797494,
0.0411534347,
0.0337793045,
-0.0295971036,
-0.0130035644,
0.0162472893,
-0.0197088849,
-0.0391029418,
0.0129450206,
-0.0465133861,
0.0574491061,
0.0041141422,
0.0069010472,
-0.0685521737,
-0.0053533935,
0.0340851806,
0.084555842,
-0.0307349339,
-0.0302062947,
0.0124966213,
0.0193169471,
0.0190496277,
0.0367569216,
-0.0999250785,
0.0533468798,
0.0420271605,
-0.0464313067,
-0.0135043319,
0.0228980444,
-0.0142655456,
0.0297653321,
0.0894646868,
0.0268290192,
2.200770626e-34,
0.019635953,
0.0154286036,
-0.0184403248,
-0.0407649763,
0.0346431918,
-0.024083497,
-0.0445347875,
0.0006008769,
0.0460853912,
-0.0867650583,
0.0003973799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07745v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07745v1
|
LlamaTurk: Adapting Open-Source Generative Large Language Models for Low-Resource Language
| 2024-05-13T13:41:59 | 2024-05-13T13:41:59 |
Cagri Toraman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite advancements in English-dominant generative large language models,
further development is needed for low-resource languages to enhance global
accessibility. The primary methods for representing these languages are
monolingual and multilingual pretraining. Monolingual pretraining is expensive
due to hardware requirements, and multilingual models often have uneven
performance across languages. This study explores an alternative solution by
adapting large language models, primarily trained on English, to low-resource
languages. We assess various strategies, including continual training,
instruction fine-tuning, task-specific fine-tuning, and vocabulary extension.
The results show that continual training improves language comprehension, as
reflected in perplexity scores, and task-specific tuning generally enhances
performance of downstream tasks. However, extending the vocabulary shows no
substantial benefits. Additionally, while larger models improve task
performance with few-shot tuning, multilingual models perform worse than their
monolingual counterparts when adapted.
|
[
0.0021394696,
0.0616600588,
-0.0133234672,
0.0279566348,
-0.0156869143,
0.0403884724,
0.0538724102,
-0.02116202,
-0.0208575111,
-0.025780879,
-0.0542855337,
-0.0487155318,
0.0040281196,
-0.0044893064,
0.0387716033,
-0.0784400627,
0.0637636259,
-0.0767150596,
-0.0548987836,
-0.0326350741,
-0.0251533557,
0.0129391504,
-0.0293999501,
0.0278893448,
0.0272968691,
-0.0274649207,
-0.0035425615,
0.0035709215,
0.0172324032,
-0.020820925,
-0.033674825,
0.0494758599,
0.0278584789,
0.0335294157,
0.0000020811,
-0.0555792786,
0.0267482791,
-0.0045035458,
-0.0048320931,
0.0539055876,
0.0771873742,
-0.0006354519,
-0.0358721502,
0.0214281809,
0.0033068198,
-0.0565167442,
0.0813730806,
0.009977337,
0.0164695755,
0.0408690125,
0.0021219701,
-0.0516148321,
0.0206465181,
-0.0404480733,
0.021728361,
-0.0490161031,
-0.005331846,
0.042709779,
0.0182477999,
-0.0063827466,
-0.0348468535,
0.0487909466,
0.0482077524,
0.0069649848,
-0.0053284592,
0.0476421528,
-0.0054766396,
-0.0336964279,
-0.0036782913,
0.0461654365,
-0.0065726684,
-0.0225206427,
-0.0400460996,
0.0013509325,
-0.0112355221,
-0.0204700753,
-0.0425439999,
0.0300601441,
0.0282507706,
0.0097623114,
0.0280612186,
-0.0401539989,
0.0395926051,
0.009707747,
-0.0246557929,
0.0144387018,
0.0557085723,
-0.0123037091,
-0.0039848043,
0.0114239538,
-0.0240196194,
-0.0336335823,
0.000753832,
0.0175408348,
-0.0263652187,
0.0371320546,
-0.0354395546,
-0.0618300661,
0.0281473212,
-0.0386426188,
0.0548251718,
0.0584318489,
-0.0391206108,
0.0427936316,
-0.0301814098,
0.0324231982,
-0.0093245339,
0.0116671398,
-0.0551529787,
0.0091605969,
-0.0164362062,
-0.0096736355,
-0.0500299707,
-0.0057987059,
-0.0652419999,
-0.0296602044,
-0.0299719237,
0.0177735537,
0.0573428646,
-0.035684444,
0.0172305238,
-0.0092661213,
-0.0803299025,
-0.0116321994,
0.0146668833,
0.0578905828,
-0.0580103248,
0.0143024586,
0.0066935997,
-0.0802339837,
-0.0057366365,
0.009987521,
-0.0005736154,
-0.0539643057,
0.0106484517,
0.0452153645,
-0.0196871702,
-0.0359206423,
-0.0492631048,
0.0345198885,
-0.0097477771,
-0.0683537349,
0.0053693992,
-0.0549024493,
0.0097386856,
0.0003110692,
0.0307802632,
-0.0159062352,
-0.0039921827,
-0.0065519135,
0.0106062219,
0.0534608811,
-0.0162373483,
0.0191107765,
0.0229368135,
-0.0020998954,
0.0476729311,
0.0927246511,
0.0156256463,
-0.021283837,
0.0247255191,
-0.0408193469,
-0.0473092161,
0.0581629872,
-0.0136549249,
0.0245370474,
-0.0102127669,
-0.0133738657,
0.0198364146,
0.0361071751,
0.0634544864,
0.017162459,
-0.029835647,
0.0344045348,
0.0651355088,
0.0479043797,
0.0303701144,
0.0220348034,
0.0366374217,
0.0072169616,
0.011055965,
-0.0155705456,
-0.0366851725,
0.0087961471,
0.0138776945,
0.0328430086,
0.0218028221,
0.0771107972,
-0.0284519605,
-0.0407116748,
-0.0067918268,
-0.0104463231,
0.0139142377,
0.0341898166,
0.0979472846,
0.0246820003,
-0.0364888795,
0.0153695755,
0.0810959786,
-0.0580107011,
0.0230814777,
-0.0533054732,
0.0077760061,
0.0666930079,
0.0249398649,
0.0163886249,
-0.0287822597,
0.0143270409,
0.0286390595,
0.0610209517,
0.0384407975,
0.0196503326,
0.0490465946,
-0.0631682649,
0.0038021458,
-0.0021989662,
0.0232539549,
0.054397095,
0.0136967292,
0.0248891562,
0.0129543431,
-0.0539050773,
-0.0514326207,
0.0169037711,
-0.0639937371,
-0.0221643411,
-0.0018252915,
0.0068395585,
-0.0031439429,
0.0162210912,
-0.0293887164,
-0.0094498331,
0.010761939,
-0.0520850644,
0.0431849584,
0.0290871859,
-0.069543004,
-0.0125096785,
0.0303563625,
0.0077126017,
-0.0057093832,
0.0227039419,
0.0033553764,
-0.0414725356,
0.0326341763,
-0.0293315295,
0.048266761,
-0.0684300363,
0.0152034368,
-0.0241506044,
0.0230582971,
-0.0374886692,
0.0319702923,
0.0192083698,
0.0015700762,
0.0094770286,
0.0142544229,
0.0104777562,
-0.0524273589,
-0.0243712962,
0.0396594778,
0.0065363073,
-0.0044263471,
-0.0237172954,
0.0227712579,
-0.0473693423,
-0.0093708439,
-0.0898275748,
-0.0122051807,
-0.0330616236,
0.0317235962,
0.0192806441,
0.0275680833,
-0.0126259346,
-0.0125653027,
0.0071279602,
0.0240171514,
0.0074887369,
0.0219400823,
-0.0225238819,
0.0032576008,
-0.0304462072,
-0.0199263301,
-0.0250838548,
0.0419746377,
0.0141498735,
0.0252857916,
0.0039252397,
-0.0549492128,
0.0335093588,
-0.0108078849,
0.0125671979,
0.0033616594,
-0.0742123127,
0.0099158548,
-0.0030677624,
0.0939232633,
0.0666002184,
-0.01712735,
-0.0009890567,
0.0391534604,
-0.0085388161,
-0.0368190445,
0.0208965652,
0.0263110735,
-0.0906502381,
-0.0620281734,
-0.0169298798,
-0.03808764,
0.0697349906,
-0.0330570042,
-0.0187439378,
-0.0698101074,
-0.0148694944,
-0.0576111414,
-0.0535031222,
-0.0238202177,
0.0320177525,
-0.0259885807,
0.0123951528,
-0.0171648618,
-0.0541481301,
0.048338078,
-0.0348126814,
-0.0363473669,
-0.0592145957,
0.0074028573,
-0.0149812512,
0.0459289998,
0.0057179201,
0.0445007272,
-0.0109306118,
-0.034553092,
-0.0399854556,
0.025813384,
0.0184288081,
-0.0044360133,
0.0522642359,
-0.0350662209,
-0.0043633357,
-0.024573382,
-0.0314581506,
-0.012137536,
0.0081820944,
-0.0109715089,
-0.0105702374,
0.0370073542,
-0.0149472319,
-0.0543321632,
-0.0000539414,
0.0606387742,
0.0402411409,
-0.0042317645,
0.0066889683,
-0.0104105202,
-0.0143446093,
0.0400059596,
0.0301499087,
0.0164210573,
-0.0527742133,
0.0090906648,
-0.0040624053,
0.0399753675,
-0.0373118669,
0.0023637675,
0.0164433606,
0.0353634134,
-0.0068810601,
-0.0214151479,
0.0243129879,
0.0792548656,
-0.0609811991,
-0.0322279856,
0.0952853188,
-0.001892832,
-0.0412202552,
0.0230240151,
-0.0581401996,
0.0586574748,
0.0177260078,
0.0253938474,
-0.060615778,
-0.0177936647,
0.0156332161,
0.0188673772,
0.0275111422,
0.01066548,
-0.0133940801,
-0.1326063722,
0.0212052967,
0.0259256121,
-0.0521737933,
-0.0111617018,
-0.0330830961,
-0.0262547433,
0.0122156208,
0.0631860122,
0.0083034001,
-0.0233897939,
0.0021012956,
0.0202086437,
0.0026328331,
-0.0831708089,
0.013976967,
-0.0153362108,
0.0550908372,
0.0664808378,
-0.0150150564,
-0.0243307091,
-0.015339843,
0.0681547076,
-0.0054541579,
0.0183509029,
-0.0165192336,
0.0110259596,
0.0382337533,
-0.0407998487,
-0.0094277114,
0.0084847203,
-0.0063064992,
-0.0246475115,
0.0028522827,
0.0380154923,
0.021689713,
-0.0046892771,
0.0304708127,
-0.0315172337,
0.0000260536,
0.0502321571,
0.0414601862,
-0.0568136908,
-0.0222556945,
-0.0169312488,
-0.0193612427,
-0.0813491046,
-0.0158785284,
0.0277107395,
-0.0116291894,
-0.0650921315,
-0.0269420948,
-0.0525339581,
0.0122658554,
0.0324135907,
0.0194820277,
0.0226967465,
0.0053384826,
0.0086957794,
-0.0130324485,
0.0364866517,
-0.0308250561,
0.016609339,
-0.0718316883,
-0.0464291163,
0.0203471053,
-0.0192204472,
-0.0077403621,
0.0059538847,
-0.0431918837,
-0.0640433058,
0.0209191106,
0.0413184129,
0.0182195492,
0.0234967992,
0.0092776809,
-0.084347114,
-0.0014572517,
-0.0012949451,
-0.0007454825,
0.0760902986,
0.0262221564,
0.0017560172,
0.0125152683,
0.0615043826,
-0.0183545761,
0.0373441763,
0.0150565775,
0.0508799516,
0.0132744843,
0.0105706863,
-0.0233497117,
0.0288524814,
0.0043142852,
-0.0472041517,
-0.0097919647,
-0.0654028654,
0.0346579216,
-0.0417632498,
0.0370603204,
-0.0382926464,
-0.0149750477,
0.0548460372,
0.001669673,
0.01050088,
0.0164649244,
0.0187125504,
0.0168003049,
-0.04194469,
0.0437990129,
-0.0094303777,
-0.0228016973,
0.0321543328,
0.0272785965,
-0.0322420448,
0.001742158,
-0.0241592303,
0.0347267799,
-0.0199717358,
0.0375301205,
-0.0091708526,
-0.0250578597,
-0.0290309787,
0.0281969476,
0.005000561,
-0.0436783135,
0.0041810451,
0.0291767903,
0.074725464,
0.0154936481,
0.0834066793,
-0.0074884859,
-0.006715544,
-0.0314582214,
0.0048785876,
-0.0064869653,
-0.0400917269,
0.012905498,
-0.0007032118,
-0.0114654843,
-0.0273632426,
0.0774489716,
0.0332156606,
0.039518822,
0.0106434245,
0.0642584264,
-0.0154925548,
-0.0439812616,
-0.0225988738,
0.0201814994,
-0.0413000397,
0.0198508017,
-0.0067194086,
-0.0883021206,
-0.046953775,
0.0214412846,
-0.0306349248,
-0.007922194,
0.0094285998,
0.0322740488,
-0.0386429392,
-0.0432220027,
-0.0286733937,
0.0057542282,
-0.0097867604,
-0.0111532398,
0.0394574739,
-6.547715123e-33,
-0.0424010009,
0.0221074782,
0.0280280989,
-0.0596114025,
-0.0327028632,
-0.0224747546,
-0.0529133566,
0.0186097492,
-0.0344917029,
0.0034259723,
-0.009138545,
0.0014343758,
0.0255762357,
0.0451936685,
0.0099648703,
0.0208727494,
0.0496319719,
0.0312995948,
0.0017605025,
0.0423068851,
0.0154831912,
0.0236439463,
0.0864541307,
-0.0105301039,
-0.002694153,
0.0016090464,
0.0096265329,
0.0027497537,
0.0171432868,
0.0674316064,
-0.0324700437,
0.0639590099,
0.0031930786,
-0.0246713106,
-0.0508143939,
0.0067991046,
-0.0802465305,
-0.0112378467,
0.0431395657,
0.0369487852,
-0.0191312414,
-0.0481270142,
0.0211299583,
0.0051581678,
-0.0315596797,
-0.0116504133,
0.002908949,
-0.032224454,
-0.0265721045,
0.0356189497,
-0.075447455,
0.0072051915,
-0.001099542,
0.0138837611,
0.0029859995,
0.0196018238,
-0.0339862257,
-0.0244731326,
-0.0125520909,
0.0041478863,
0.0419084057,
0.057707157,
0.0931263715,
0.0513570532,
0.0329336673,
0.0253930986,
0.0395220034,
-0.0232355222,
0.0040611317,
-0.0228899531,
0.0660646111,
-0.0178101193,
0.0040546488,
0.0622039661,
0.0448416211,
-0.0295955818,
-0.0796034932,
-0.0238120053,
-0.0103885494,
0.0782393962,
0.0291816834,
0.0176609103,
-0.0125516793,
-0.0092336107,
-0.0565563738,
0.0215102397,
-0.0310165957,
-0.0383221991,
0.06768547,
-0.0072190785,
-0.0072588152,
-0.0159014016,
0.0580394045,
-0.0303689968,
-0.0160289593,
0.0149059137,
-0.0008479885,
0.026802754,
-0.0314663649,
0.0451472141,
-0.0532794148,
-0.0392335132,
-0.0013162798,
0.0230296534,
0.0003445609,
-0.0156062031,
0.0149831139,
0.004933882,
-0.0757794529,
0.022631757,
-0.0383344702,
-0.0000340762,
0.0342014134,
0.0474513769,
0.0413494147,
-0.0141300401,
-0.0191397537,
0.0708240196,
0.0151963057,
-0.0497829132,
-0.0283629615,
-0.0265771486,
0.0220089369,
0.0187276043,
-0.02061023,
0.0082106898,
-0.0423565209,
0.0174561255,
0.0279963817,
-0.0496554822,
-0.0292752236,
0.0201783124,
2.829e-7,
0.035329055,
0.0345455185,
-0.007027403,
0.0219886266,
0.0083964048,
-0.0030914899,
-0.0037378608,
-0.0043142438,
0.0068175825,
0.010904233,
-0.0281874333,
0.069120124,
0.0419069417,
-0.0026946636,
-0.0578618459,
0.0113755167,
-0.0315070711,
0.0689284131,
-0.0589065291,
0.0188817549,
0.011123972,
0.0902224854,
-0.042629797,
-0.0075655109,
0.0345342346,
-0.0782854632,
0.0536475554,
-0.0405529812,
-0.0108721228,
0.0125718582,
-0.0237837043,
0.0490252711,
0.0028564124,
-0.011330911,
-0.0347868837,
0.0079712039,
-0.0237869248,
0.0678137839,
-0.0300984103,
-0.0113500636,
0.0141254216,
0.0107283685,
-0.0434406176,
-0.0636905432,
0.0566407703,
-0.0473478027,
-0.0200922377,
0.0133033236,
-0.0011742078,
-0.0102175279,
0.018647695,
-0.0588312037,
-0.0252531096,
0.0080954134,
0.0337922163,
-0.0367851779,
-0.0247868542,
-0.0344956666,
-0.0170091204,
0.0207516216,
-0.0398792364,
-0.0639140233,
-0.0640882477,
-0.0112459464,
0.0142609365,
-0.010341364,
0.0065320586,
2.329283612e-34,
0.0413496718,
-0.010351412,
0.0344474949,
0.0306490455,
0.0124869989,
-0.034172155,
0.0113012549,
0.0000186195,
-0.0137063218,
-0.1235353202,
-0.0277336445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07730v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07730v1
|
Does Dependency Locality Predict Non-canonical Word Order in Hindi?
| 2024-05-13T13:24:17 | 2024-05-13T13:24:17 |
Sidharth Ranjan, Marten van Schijndel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Previous work has shown that isolated non-canonical sentences with
Object-before-Subject (OSV) order are initially harder to process than their
canonical counterparts with Subject-before-Object (SOV) order. Although this
difficulty diminishes with appropriate discourse context, the underlying
cognitive factors responsible for alleviating processing challenges in OSV
sentences remain a question. In this work, we test the hypothesis that
dependency length minimization is a significant predictor of non-canonical
(OSV) syntactic choices, especially when controlling for information status
such as givenness and surprisal measures. We extract sentences from the
Hindi-Urdu Treebank corpus (HUTB) that contain clearly-defined subjects and
objects, systematically permute the preverbal constituents of those sentences,
and deploy a classifier to distinguish between original corpus sentences and
artificially generated alternatives. The classifier leverages various
discourse-based and cognitive features, including dependency length, surprisal,
and information status, to inform its predictions. Our results suggest that,
although there exists a preference for minimizing dependency length in
non-canonical corpus sentences amidst the generated variants, this factor does
not significantly contribute in identifying corpus sentences above and beyond
surprisal and givenness measures. Notably, discourse predictability emerges as
the primary determinant of constituent-order preferences. These findings are
further supported by human evaluations involving 44 native Hindi speakers.
Overall, this work sheds light on the role of expectation adaptation in
word-ordering decisions. We conclude by situating our results within the
theories of discourse production and information locality.
|
[
0.0825360641,
0.0321908221,
-0.0297716148,
0.0312317573,
-0.0402484126,
0.0009486818,
-0.0139463302,
0.0014431597,
-0.0141014922,
-0.0407494642,
-0.0040968549,
-0.0298495125,
0.0618427061,
-0.0289614443,
0.0179151483,
-0.0644841641,
0.022974167,
0.0117271263,
0.0130482018,
-0.0096314335,
0.0271523371,
0.0235328972,
-0.0322486646,
0.006871826,
-0.0588340163,
-0.0065740799,
0.0050090044,
0.0137558449,
0.0053210696,
-0.0259110145,
-0.0174036808,
0.0784691945,
-0.0311497878,
-0.0163306892,
0.0000017361,
-0.0784643143,
-0.0063078282,
-0.055122532,
-0.0068914341,
0.0087736631,
0.0215174258,
0.0112466738,
0.0110628661,
0.0087267794,
-0.0262124464,
0.0118858255,
0.0661786497,
0.0424598232,
-0.0096427063,
0.0797472745,
-0.0335180461,
-0.0442165211,
-0.0207364094,
-0.0035502766,
-0.0221659746,
-0.008877622,
0.0013511073,
-0.0081532719,
-0.0152129652,
0.0044924421,
-0.0444279797,
-0.0055581569,
-0.0136714103,
-0.0086930357,
-0.0132099278,
0.0126039693,
-0.0484581813,
-0.0206256974,
0.0310596582,
0.0321651883,
0.0559494235,
-0.0599630401,
0.0062814746,
0.0019688739,
-0.001566852,
0.0208051987,
0.0047105388,
0.0260523688,
-0.0079714507,
0.0395980962,
0.0498115048,
0.0421434045,
-0.0726046786,
-0.0141511075,
0.0329618044,
0.0831994861,
-0.0174707714,
-0.025105847,
-0.0403884016,
-0.0029641648,
-0.0800964236,
-0.0538243391,
0.0112949451,
-0.040378172,
-0.0305405166,
0.0310054049,
-0.0056005404,
-0.048651237,
-0.0054886122,
-0.0679343641,
-0.0074778521,
0.0143955955,
-0.0207311157,
-0.010744364,
0.015702622,
0.0546763055,
-0.0158907957,
-0.0408370383,
-0.0459932201,
0.0432755947,
0.0125622945,
-0.0702394992,
0.0184198078,
0.0245496538,
-0.0576660372,
0.0031450044,
-0.0685692057,
-0.0033221557,
0.037200667,
-0.0569579825,
0.0138730071,
0.0340393297,
-0.0354329012,
0.0016698649,
-0.0293505695,
0.0224448536,
-0.0529138371,
0.0357699841,
-0.0416205563,
-0.0564525165,
-0.0023314145,
0.0463223122,
0.0099735437,
0.0041736881,
-0.0633192137,
0.0069459346,
-0.0238222163,
-0.0222961288,
0.0225529596,
0.0096313246,
-0.0794339553,
-0.0141744381,
-0.0210285056,
-0.0599806681,
0.0046941321,
0.0367759429,
0.0054032593,
-0.0342529751,
0.0034038569,
0.0152561953,
-0.0088035027,
0.0336093567,
0.0809094235,
0.037429668,
0.0144402003,
-0.0004539969,
0.0632101595,
0.0022167601,
0.0214296039,
-0.0295229629,
0.0203124918,
-0.007504724,
-0.0043046777,
0.0002187858,
-0.0411216803,
-0.0182627458,
-0.0159627441,
0.0105329165,
-0.0525186881,
0.0079553826,
0.0308520906,
0.0326540507,
-0.0261729155,
0.0000478693,
0.0321206078,
0.0437041186,
-0.0141823646,
-0.019837413,
0.0008213157,
0.0615001768,
-0.0027813797,
0.100543417,
0.015253556,
0.0030140474,
0.0186887998,
-0.0151637653,
-0.0270561762,
-0.0260498002,
0.0087263044,
-0.0249492787,
-0.0385081843,
-0.0136058126,
-0.0121642705,
-0.0455237478,
-0.0091806678,
0.0321568139,
-0.01581778,
0.0437481143,
0.0369397439,
-0.0752487704,
-0.0537195802,
0.0090251341,
0.0070371968,
-0.0032546767,
-0.0075433711,
-0.0101906816,
0.0113871433,
0.0549393557,
0.0140995961,
0.0804230943,
0.0082782786,
-0.0069773989,
0.0099471593,
0.0100901332,
0.0487188734,
0.027037153,
0.0021857638,
0.0282458402,
-0.0229488034,
-0.0208172575,
0.0159747172,
0.0371094495,
0.0112544568,
0.0298522115,
0.0045862659,
-0.026019495,
-0.0098726163,
0.0112820966,
0.0645265207,
-0.0312768519,
-0.0120245945,
0.0343406834,
0.0166819096,
0.0061661117,
0.0065796301,
0.083368361,
-0.0901206732,
-0.0511923544,
-0.0210805479,
-0.0557478704,
0.0311243683,
0.0126187783,
0.0092788162,
-0.0575081147,
0.0432691425,
-0.0183232892,
0.0612538718,
-0.0080408677,
0.0514139682,
-0.0142504778,
0.0050211069,
-0.0498310775,
0.0451761521,
0.0049060513,
0.0138974572,
-0.0006327715,
-0.0109286401,
0.0837755054,
-0.0039239228,
0.0198467299,
0.0228593014,
0.0249322485,
-0.0252524242,
0.0452109054,
0.0024118803,
-0.0612956583,
-0.0581803136,
-0.131882146,
-0.0400588438,
0.0205091517,
0.0209993999,
0.027473921,
0.0221795607,
-0.0247697402,
-0.0198771805,
-0.0030482335,
-0.0117778527,
0.0262164157,
0.0183455646,
0.0505929366,
-0.0214510839,
0.0043226518,
-0.0233506449,
-0.018987231,
-0.0357726105,
0.051323615,
-0.0286303516,
-0.0636318102,
-0.0375637561,
0.0605910532,
-0.0018220966,
0.00980091,
-0.0053164833,
-0.0311124586,
0.0237172283,
0.0478932969,
0.1000916511,
0.0400512367,
0.0047112014,
-0.0003734467,
0.0165353641,
-0.0091325883,
-0.0242467411,
-0.0247410797,
0.0181343257,
-0.0102033745,
-0.0091412263,
-0.0274592005,
-0.0408222713,
0.06678693,
0.0326588601,
-0.0317881443,
-0.0072215479,
0.0015977694,
-0.0537667647,
-0.0300203748,
0.0119637633,
-0.0495450273,
-0.062742494,
0.0662490502,
-0.0248110127,
-0.0113303838,
0.0124703012,
-0.0179233924,
0.0140741207,
-0.0572328679,
0.0613270514,
-0.0152290985,
0.055918213,
0.0339494832,
0.0127437031,
0.0018434413,
-0.0655658245,
-0.1116532013,
0.0259220991,
0.0091887154,
0.0277114995,
-0.0142680677,
-0.073151283,
-0.0099209435,
-0.0246383343,
-0.0857961178,
-0.0011091091,
-0.0735017434,
0.030867327,
-0.0164206792,
0.0191987194,
-0.0083270185,
0.0605037399,
0.0293337498,
-0.0049753049,
0.0026750288,
-0.0263599474,
0.0337028503,
-0.0031548911,
0.0483154766,
0.0357363895,
0.0237587597,
0.0258500036,
0.0288155396,
0.0009320918,
0.0077597694,
0.0038329465,
0.022940157,
0.003935792,
-0.0027639172,
0.0150939403,
-0.0166399032,
-0.1099720076,
0.0006677996,
0.0375343077,
0.0352405235,
-0.000758766,
0.0806091875,
0.0386702418,
0.0149516324,
0.0382297002,
-0.070270814,
0.0464829728,
0.0158026703,
0.0123669729,
-0.0700033307,
0.0160468575,
0.0180067159,
-0.0539274178,
-0.0456948131,
-0.035364788,
-0.0188763477,
-0.0753717721,
-0.0121863801,
-0.0131849423,
-0.0066292225,
0.0286192484,
0.0169111006,
-0.0195579715,
0.0406694002,
-0.0021423439,
0.0616641268,
-0.0558084361,
0.0226053298,
0.0351549052,
-0.0217126925,
0.0092138583,
-0.0286184251,
0.007247909,
-0.0289711021,
0.0113054868,
0.0092265978,
-0.0031071315,
0.0141180726,
-0.0086656585,
-0.0336597785,
0.0052358182,
0.0170745421,
0.0184222776,
0.0159785245,
-0.0047631483,
-0.053230416,
0.0022975584,
-0.0005819131,
0.0094711855,
-0.0019101991,
0.0131985182,
-0.0117693646,
-0.0223929361,
0.0177605916,
0.0112237083,
-0.0302125104,
0.0290678926,
0.0511082299,
-0.0377556458,
-0.0142484168,
0.0040150029,
0.0157376081,
0.0396995209,
-0.0564703643,
0.0082734702,
-0.0126031367,
-0.0763674453,
-0.092378594,
-0.0719091296,
-0.0305705555,
0.040665362,
0.0334652476,
0.0220089424,
0.008373253,
-0.0176718589,
-0.0132955872,
-0.0371524841,
0.0088116769,
-0.0308285281,
-0.0432355739,
0.0054869093,
0.0555097573,
0.0057598376,
-0.0186231714,
-0.020336099,
0.0156725924,
-0.0432808958,
0.0492627732,
-0.005161182,
0.021757165,
-0.0089426786,
0.0181587581,
-0.0536833853,
0.0264498461,
0.0112103038,
-0.0109037114,
0.0947413668,
0.0164409596,
-0.0281849056,
0.0120137511,
0.022849502,
0.0020394926,
0.0313125364,
-0.0129838614,
0.0000351058,
0.0003592906,
-0.0066778385,
0.0602955446,
0.0425515436,
0.0298881885,
-0.0650423765,
0.0407436192,
-0.0545984507,
0.0221791137,
-0.0191588718,
-0.0509306826,
0.0002854883,
-0.0106243789,
0.0375919007,
0.0847575217,
-0.0423017256,
-0.0303658992,
-0.0272308271,
0.0321452729,
0.0271815956,
-0.0015036605,
0.0607403107,
0.0314242505,
0.0150325252,
0.0298706628,
0.0006751752,
-0.0005630976,
-0.0249445252,
0.0318786353,
-0.0083174398,
0.0358834751,
-0.0123681268,
-0.0244256277,
-0.0197322294,
0.0515065417,
0.020543268,
0.0688355863,
0.0185146146,
-0.0023070408,
0.0464976318,
-0.0902976617,
0.1047015116,
-0.0387353227,
0.0400536135,
-0.0038288594,
0.0135732889,
-0.0054210285,
-0.0108333658,
0.012255379,
0.0002628827,
-0.0365876518,
0.0602687374,
0.107341893,
-0.0002809675,
-0.024109371,
0.0124836229,
-0.013936609,
-0.0253288224,
-0.0628525615,
-0.0175474733,
-0.018554654,
0.019817628,
0.0190861337,
-0.0675722435,
-0.0309510361,
0.0058069858,
-0.0483051799,
0.0606217533,
-0.0422822833,
0.0356606804,
0.0662769899,
0.0202203561,
-0.0403028987,
-0.0485876724,
-0.0160535313,
0.0151825855,
-0.0180766881,
-0.0258252583,
-5.690746681e-33,
-0.0628620908,
-0.0191290583,
-0.0407767594,
0.0518990457,
0.0187849738,
0.0263119619,
-0.0176812075,
0.0419948138,
0.0547167398,
0.0346242338,
-0.0493482016,
0.0234734043,
0.0161290206,
-0.0145413587,
0.0746636614,
0.0190447923,
-0.0077869897,
0.0029374936,
-0.0135058137,
-0.042598892,
0.0930249542,
-0.018237479,
0.0966003835,
-0.0296438895,
0.0499314778,
-0.0285442509,
0.0029029928,
0.0014782081,
-0.0234508216,
0.0289393719,
-0.0070951493,
0.0502180718,
0.0404487066,
0.0148720145,
-0.0084039839,
0.0522499345,
-0.026902318,
-0.0494788252,
0.0716821924,
0.0504009016,
-0.0332098231,
-0.0521500893,
0.0301950779,
-0.0265951622,
-0.0353415124,
0.0714601651,
0.0158992354,
0.019030679,
0.015926715,
0.017157631,
-0.0535508133,
-0.0093861651,
-0.0301816948,
0.0343754888,
0.0010742942,
0.0633610338,
-0.0203298982,
-0.0445172824,
0.0079999119,
0.034269277,
-0.0294982437,
0.0742542148,
-0.0147509724,
0.0072269174,
-0.011753032,
0.0245432593,
0.031546887,
-0.0215442088,
0.0466051772,
0.0030598408,
-0.0087274099,
0.0193979312,
-0.0098756067,
0.0281125046,
0.0280094817,
-0.0515585169,
-0.0480124131,
-0.0178265925,
0.007462834,
0.0422966182,
-0.0229381397,
0.0086952159,
-0.0531476215,
-0.081283778,
0.029534623,
-0.0218581241,
-0.0028153805,
-0.0375718139,
0.0354418978,
-0.0546376109,
-0.0102530904,
-0.000887257,
0.0304192305,
0.0052794935,
-0.020633243,
-0.011787314,
-0.0820839927,
0.0451096259,
0.0207787231,
0.0487069599,
-0.0487515703,
-0.0118127437,
0.0043359813,
0.0428868011,
0.0259083733,
0.0408645086,
0.037009716,
-0.0164669361,
-0.0576566532,
0.0015657439,
0.0059845047,
-0.0179970507,
-0.0439211391,
-0.0168978721,
0.0415558368,
0.0267458931,
-0.0061411154,
-0.0090948166,
0.0643160716,
-0.0064838193,
-0.0202074088,
-0.0062301452,
-0.0262964442,
0.0074272724,
-0.0056756488,
-0.0050146119,
-0.0259790234,
0.0213531442,
0.0359838717,
-0.0300928969,
-0.0044052401,
0.0108792884,
2.68e-7,
0.013504751,
0.0659134611,
0.0306795854,
-0.0385489911,
0.0280137565,
-0.0145224882,
-0.008506218,
0.0210533626,
-0.0093585262,
0.004032339,
0.0180583075,
-0.0194834303,
-0.0003724751,
-0.02327119,
-0.1160202175,
-0.0246604737,
-0.0810339972,
0.0084167682,
-0.0094190286,
0.0006069803,
0.0061036851,
0.0235037077,
-0.0224185809,
0.0167068448,
-0.0685498565,
0.009900487,
0.026556354,
0.004207076,
0.000941183,
0.011435803,
0.0102729201,
-0.046782054,
0.0186529458,
0.0256368034,
0.0215720776,
0.0167673528,
0.0320507735,
0.0337786004,
-0.003355681,
-0.0038715901,
0.0228236578,
0.0277346447,
-0.0301847439,
-0.0000294823,
0.044991836,
0.012008003,
-0.0511183217,
0.0268037077,
-0.042436298,
0.0040095453,
0.0098219141,
0.0292266626,
-0.0146826152,
0.0132605033,
-0.0090365084,
-0.0591311343,
-0.0144763179,
-0.0052159834,
-0.0514724329,
0.0378530249,
0.0001231345,
-0.0520097315,
0.0176768843,
0.0224666651,
0.0235333666,
-0.0393394157,
-0.0365896672,
2.379178066e-34,
0.0126006035,
0.0367605947,
0.078536354,
-0.0102468245,
0.0328566507,
-0.0400567427,
-0.0244862139,
0.0551420115,
0.0292723533,
-0.0690470487,
-0.0235797763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07726v1
|
Quantifying and Optimizing Global Faithfulness in Persona-driven Role-playing
| 2024-05-13T13:21:35 | 2024-05-13T13:21:35 |
Letian Peng, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Persona-driven role-playing (PRP) aims to build AI characters that can
respond to user queries by faithfully sticking with all persona statements.
Unfortunately, existing faithfulness criteria for PRP are limited to
coarse-grained LLM-based scoring without a clear definition or formulation.
This paper presents a pioneering exploration to quantify PRP faithfulness as a
fine-grained and explainable criterion, which also serves as a reliable
reference for optimization. Our criterion first discriminates persona
statements into active and passive constraints by identifying the
query-statement relevance. Then, we incorporate all constraints following the
principle that the AI character's response should be (a) entailed by active
(relevant) constraints and (b) not contradicted by passive (irrelevant)
constraints. We translate this principle mathematically into a novel
Active-Passive-Constraint (APC) score, a constraint-wise sum of natural
language inference (NLI) scores weighted by relevance scores. In practice, we
build the APC scoring system by symbolically distilling small discriminators
from GPT-4 for efficiency. We validate the quality of the APC score against
human evaluation based on example personas with tens of statements, and the
results show a high correlation. We further leverage it as a reward system in
direct preference optimization (DPO) for better AI characters. Our experiments
offer a fine-grained and explainable comparison between existing PRP
techniques, revealing their advantages and limitations. We further find
APC-based DPO to be one of the most competitive techniques for sticking with
all constraints and can be well incorporated with other techniques. We then
extend the scale of the experiments to real persons with hundreds of statements
and reach a consistent conclusion.
|
[
0.0801367983,
0.0560121723,
-0.0231529661,
0.0343820639,
-0.0183105599,
-0.0147414487,
-0.0321637988,
-0.0185539667,
0.0201940276,
0.0095645599,
-0.018368436,
-0.0320376493,
0.008964465,
0.0130666634,
0.0224544164,
-0.0692922473,
0.047422491,
-0.0078584868,
0.033496201,
0.0125291673,
-0.0109845828,
0.02752221,
-0.0288381781,
0.0474480689,
0.0004826234,
0.0182630029,
0.0258144196,
0.0004694863,
0.0848490521,
-0.0502714962,
0.011801295,
-0.0280495938,
0.017809011,
-0.0460947491,
0.0000023439,
-0.0904159397,
-0.0072529521,
-0.0168743394,
0.0011509073,
-0.0436366424,
-0.0147985835,
0.0607754625,
0.0361015536,
-0.0125667937,
-0.0397347249,
0.0060477164,
0.0576926172,
0.053250622,
0.0731882155,
0.0616875552,
-0.0060599647,
-0.0373897441,
-0.0278261751,
-0.0162718687,
0.0281385016,
-0.0618737899,
-0.012812336,
0.0012919654,
0.0549468733,
-0.0289790723,
0.0151917096,
-0.0140432119,
-0.0218547825,
0.0043515889,
0.0004184559,
0.0260358211,
-0.0255894661,
-0.0060547492,
0.0491005816,
0.0620849207,
0.0854404122,
0.0077451332,
0.0178263653,
-0.01314619,
0.0331468508,
0.0634244159,
0.0102270488,
-0.0039598187,
-0.0078960173,
-0.0107244374,
-0.0057574366,
0.045760341,
0.0261742044,
0.0026074734,
-0.0239592716,
0.0509214737,
-0.0028248096,
-0.04069262,
-0.0021259342,
-0.010203463,
-0.0596255921,
-0.047010079,
-0.0140359951,
0.0350975245,
-0.081759356,
0.0257301368,
-0.042637568,
0.0811652914,
-0.003702898,
-0.0171503536,
0.0289640818,
0.0597607382,
0.0369995907,
0.027940046,
0.0143899117,
0.0973701701,
-0.0152321309,
-0.0115185585,
-0.0161917303,
-0.0019339161,
-0.0485267378,
-0.0314676389,
-0.0187337175,
0.0708293468,
0.0311111826,
-0.0036787856,
-0.0284103081,
0.0184192788,
-0.0628608912,
0.0528075509,
-0.0050700805,
0.0347019173,
-0.0508993901,
0.0017087264,
-0.1008468717,
0.0062574293,
-0.0687390268,
0.0123335058,
-0.0445658937,
-0.0038939228,
0.0069024875,
-0.0080860183,
0.0102216983,
-0.0286485869,
0.0242159292,
0.0864243209,
0.0243412629,
-0.0337226875,
0.0187435187,
-0.0312488116,
-0.0088607231,
-0.0791120306,
-0.0643550083,
-0.0199909173,
0.0204060748,
-0.0399728939,
0.0230927691,
-0.0516683497,
0.0016018192,
0.0119362418,
0.0254119989,
0.0774175227,
0.0643064752,
0.0172427129,
-0.0088969171,
0.006146682,
-0.0327535346,
0.0289003458,
0.0474494472,
0.0105117857,
0.0117426226,
0.0088986261,
-0.0117688645,
0.0110709742,
-0.0319397114,
-0.0283466298,
0.0096966652,
0.037544962,
0.0078936648,
0.0509413071,
0.0159486197,
0.0333503224,
-0.0485290475,
-0.0116198733,
0.050637763,
0.0359832197,
0.0055057262,
-0.0188619141,
0.0692668408,
0.0357302129,
-0.0032907492,
0.0341846757,
-0.046919059,
0.0242536087,
0.0372580886,
-0.0452170298,
-0.0257265642,
0.0148826046,
-0.0024152296,
-0.0457496792,
0.0428683683,
-0.0048204227,
-0.0177540928,
0.0269901622,
-0.0140525717,
-0.013904606,
-0.0307160169,
0.0209221169,
0.0078253681,
-0.0701959133,
0.0401807576,
-0.0505314209,
0.0250195768,
0.0820970088,
0.0492578968,
-0.0638636053,
-0.0515872948,
0.0133239692,
-0.0473752618,
0.0373341441,
0.020954458,
-0.0408995152,
0.0294406898,
0.0024918215,
-0.0098932562,
-0.0206389669,
-0.0003593166,
0.0674315616,
0.0130429296,
-0.0039935955,
-0.0198410675,
0.0087631429,
0.0060538887,
0.0450765379,
-0.0179898515,
-0.0415809974,
0.0027941803,
0.0455960892,
0.043857377,
0.0192437731,
0.0153660979,
-0.0231113415,
0.0114061208,
-0.0260678791,
-0.0091346828,
0.0340245329,
-0.0248360168,
0.0375169627,
0.034712974,
-0.0799127519,
-0.0401110575,
0.0456339307,
0.0126433251,
-0.0097855767,
0.0057098935,
-0.0504433401,
-0.0118506812,
-0.0109088244,
0.0075337887,
-0.0202493165,
0.0062466343,
-0.0407441258,
0.0739489868,
0.0171896797,
-0.0120084751,
0.0497299135,
-0.0215532165,
0.0189297311,
-0.0914732292,
0.0277023185,
-0.0246261656,
0.0087746466,
-0.0072192145,
0.0604919195,
-0.01598203,
-0.026548434,
-0.0401328951,
-0.046909254,
0.0019945949,
0.0134568717,
-0.0035461104,
0.0029071292,
0.0354886465,
-0.0365604013,
-0.0034948308,
-0.043559473,
-0.0651342273,
0.0033154406,
-0.0289517269,
0.0648645312,
0.0385059342,
-0.0061175297,
-0.0277768653,
0.0367634781,
-0.0313070528,
-0.0080769313,
0.0157041214,
0.0274008811,
-0.032397151,
-0.003494364,
-0.0521415174,
0.0138411066,
-0.0191328023,
-0.0082644932,
0.0546831191,
0.0123469885,
0.0162633583,
0.0588085689,
0.0272640325,
-0.0219272636,
0.0289872549,
-0.0057704379,
-0.0760120377,
0.0365237743,
-0.0013034985,
-0.0108095109,
-0.0328863487,
-0.050936833,
0.0856771767,
0.0292391889,
0.0011893319,
-0.0015620028,
-0.1043129489,
0.0555564724,
0.0043850727,
-0.0488925949,
0.0526048243,
-0.0106525291,
-0.013454753,
0.0073857931,
-0.0033790318,
0.0185479317,
0.0981251672,
-0.0291939452,
0.0189103317,
0.0046356032,
0.0010135039,
-0.0368915945,
0.0472929738,
0.0094857039,
0.0253431406,
0.0108331665,
-0.0145527944,
-0.0713654906,
-0.0344917513,
0.0765361041,
-0.0130974529,
0.0507711135,
-0.0440846048,
0.014174181,
0.0141080888,
-0.0346341245,
-0.0451180078,
-0.0328787044,
-0.008276606,
-0.0269073527,
0.0068003372,
-0.040965803,
-0.0342958085,
-0.007926194,
0.0135210268,
-0.0211842973,
-0.0143491551,
-0.0267054774,
-0.0373113267,
-0.0539294146,
0.0622066781,
0.0749240816,
0.0072684623,
-0.0050466261,
0.0088579562,
-0.003420782,
-0.0590711646,
-0.0206632223,
0.0088752257,
0.027211532,
0.0232143737,
-0.0552569702,
-0.0151376305,
0.0145040406,
0.0384099111,
-0.0371125862,
-0.0050495281,
0.1049567834,
0.0259581357,
-0.0239913315,
0.0183128901,
-0.0044151731,
0.0262391549,
0.0215943716,
0.0287157074,
-0.0404040813,
-0.0253164824,
-0.0232996214,
0.061128892,
-0.0242031571,
-0.0673433468,
-0.03483117,
-0.0949773937,
0.0090743732,
-0.0325614847,
-0.0348672532,
-0.0150930239,
-0.0350516625,
0.0330293514,
-0.0515572466,
-0.0123053882,
-0.0054539586,
0.0078511499,
0.005232926,
-0.0145520708,
-0.0314773582,
-0.0074518253,
0.0311671477,
-0.0566480532,
0.0429487415,
0.0478973985,
0.083612673,
0.0116580483,
-0.0461775772,
-0.0721286982,
0.0264364146,
-0.0092266863,
0.0043178988,
0.026490435,
-0.0388483554,
-0.0115337372,
-0.0249020085,
-0.0053244652,
0.0209847204,
-0.0110732298,
0.0057665091,
0.0459490493,
-0.0136530427,
-0.0155834425,
-0.0044853473,
-0.0065669003,
0.0086366804,
0.0634424016,
-0.0358036794,
-0.0440749265,
-0.0090225888,
0.0190061964,
0.0108545516,
-0.0724992007,
-0.0663452595,
-0.0407512188,
-0.0308930073,
0.0189380571,
-0.0636925176,
-0.03347205,
-0.0033167771,
0.0579467528,
0.0098329941,
-0.0187159516,
-0.0070857005,
0.029467022,
0.0037654187,
-0.0174404904,
-0.0695544854,
0.0133973118,
-0.0178870596,
-0.0258747954,
0.0288242884,
-0.0606962331,
0.0135894297,
-0.0120178526,
0.0142770773,
-0.0218014717,
-0.0133830681,
0.0626761466,
0.0219098087,
0.038864512,
-0.0112783574,
-0.0452394895,
-0.0195089243,
0.022826355,
-0.0255170148,
0.0122707803,
0.0038586541,
0.0248700529,
-0.0084320195,
0.0142981047,
-0.0655295998,
0.0022450883,
-0.0231030416,
0.0326713994,
-0.0073779928,
-0.0770161375,
0.0472279787,
0.0383654088,
-0.022972282,
-0.031701155,
0.0130667761,
-0.0099574523,
-0.0067580715,
-0.0286425594,
-0.023583103,
-0.0211617053,
-0.0066705681,
0.047116749,
0.0480111614,
0.0019547318,
-0.0329085775,
-0.0383073501,
-0.0016399854,
-0.0257431194,
-0.041345343,
0.0755158737,
0.013207606,
-0.0224953424,
-0.0095673194,
-0.0054905112,
0.0134127233,
-0.0047692908,
0.0877422839,
0.0090129953,
-0.0060309502,
0.0362356082,
0.0061490531,
-0.0215762183,
0.034848731,
-0.043018695,
-0.0251521803,
0.0416974984,
-0.0192364678,
0.0319047831,
0.0141426818,
0.0213161819,
-0.0078124641,
0.0205715541,
0.025746664,
-0.0170733184,
0.0465090349,
-0.003556869,
-0.0116890203,
0.0506209135,
-0.0031508652,
0.0255826339,
0.012531789,
-0.0027739753,
0.054428637,
-0.0771313533,
-0.015276338,
-0.0493058898,
-0.0659946799,
-0.0234860349,
0.0369184054,
-0.0356092602,
-0.005449947,
-0.1020322517,
-0.0354840644,
0.0073682806,
0.0470345393,
-0.0084359366,
-0.0271616969,
-0.0024623796,
0.002238754,
0.0244688392,
-0.0156819038,
-0.0302672274,
-0.0317151435,
-0.0503246486,
0.0423060842,
-0.0089029782,
-6.017467989e-33,
-0.0496734455,
-0.0197583288,
0.0294575077,
0.0097373417,
-0.0911010802,
-0.0202913415,
-0.0327386074,
-0.0268605072,
-0.0034603705,
-0.0156555362,
0.0011724051,
-0.0123312455,
-0.0086542564,
-0.0448914096,
-0.0114446357,
-0.0341703892,
0.0184471421,
0.0426196121,
-0.0873936713,
0.0164468531,
0.0582372099,
-0.0490123928,
-0.0165102519,
-0.0690568686,
0.0368075967,
0.0077169165,
-0.0344008952,
0.0377083123,
-0.0232495461,
0.050702177,
0.0044160476,
0.0026764169,
0.0264853314,
0.0218380596,
0.0259306971,
0.0134795671,
-0.0628690571,
-0.0553402714,
0.0414329022,
-0.0011388185,
-0.0167998113,
-0.030015232,
0.0062507032,
0.0071282801,
-0.0200042501,
0.0062415665,
0.0577819161,
0.0001632536,
0.052140668,
-0.0094007291,
-0.0563793592,
-0.0163257718,
-0.0503809564,
-0.0162030086,
-0.0132663008,
0.0722845271,
-0.0101732658,
0.0288673397,
-0.0367718562,
0.0423401892,
-0.044314798,
-0.0001307108,
0.0099461898,
0.0490823835,
0.0235461984,
0.0525382236,
0.0147563415,
0.0088048559,
-0.0473752283,
-0.0306431837,
0.0214445014,
0.0307553131,
0.0268950723,
0.0963711962,
0.0230586957,
0.0109963501,
-0.052574981,
0.053338889,
0.0208323542,
0.0356604941,
0.018104611,
0.015460792,
-0.0524325706,
-0.0056800423,
-0.0166477691,
-0.0006573961,
-0.0089266496,
-0.0300632827,
0.023338262,
-0.0221880358,
-0.0686031803,
-0.0038640972,
0.0106817381,
-0.055072464,
0.0089550829,
-0.0066299508,
-0.0161309466,
-0.0096013974,
0.0108143287,
-0.0013368722,
-0.0159305353,
-0.0063166507,
0.0400256626,
0.0007002261,
0.0583980009,
0.0245685577,
-0.0324398167,
0.0528478883,
-0.020067621,
-0.0191130769,
0.0068116789,
0.0138952928,
-0.051025629,
0.0157926958,
0.0183043741,
-0.0234035887,
-0.0097969556,
-0.0107068084,
0.0140173649,
-0.0294291172,
-0.0427409858,
0.0348862298,
-0.0056651826,
-0.0062323441,
-0.0118532032,
0.0166189019,
-0.0307567474,
0.0464104041,
-0.0418539271,
-0.0537621379,
-0.0261556916,
-0.0134692499,
3.15e-7,
-0.0243252981,
0.0078926571,
0.0054753809,
0.0385374464,
-0.0165482704,
0.0573168844,
0.0092839636,
0.0203392021,
0.0244112369,
-0.038768921,
0.0687822253,
0.0301524643,
-0.0152913025,
0.0233565811,
-0.0974100754,
0.0407887138,
0.0132476697,
-0.0085368911,
-0.0135598183,
0.0111881681,
0.0981825292,
0.0093016447,
0.0422433801,
-0.0175742451,
0.0181417521,
-0.0199312977,
0.0221078116,
-0.008678182,
0.0114163738,
0.0419612229,
0.0256021097,
-0.0291003976,
-0.0080730021,
0.033753179,
0.0116719743,
0.067209661,
0.0132756894,
0.0515682101,
-0.018606646,
-0.0157634635,
-0.0503438003,
-0.0142786717,
0.0228078235,
-0.0323882028,
0.0757601485,
-0.029535627,
-0.0250421278,
0.0030691279,
-0.0459374748,
-0.0135697424,
-0.001901791,
0.0135234082,
-0.0693752319,
0.0099641876,
0.0102441199,
0.0152020771,
-0.0342571139,
-0.0712930858,
0.0074364063,
-0.0402772799,
-0.0206097513,
-0.0277313218,
0.0204520039,
0.0314201154,
-0.003055413,
-0.0222990606,
0.0266850777,
2.616269996e-34,
-0.0557035021,
0.0418903306,
0.0243089478,
-0.0257441811,
0.0911681429,
0.0503244288,
-0.0301115569,
0.0293888561,
0.0656346455,
-0.0407014564,
0.0012377856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13010v1
|
UCCIX: Irish-eXcellence Large Language Model
| 2024-05-13T13:19:27 | 2024-05-13T13:19:27 |
Khanh-Tung Tran, Barry O'Sullivan, Hoang D. Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The development of Large Language Models (LLMs) has predominantly focused on
high-resource languages, leaving extremely low-resource languages like Irish
with limited representation. This work presents UCCIX, a pioneering effort on
the development of an open-source Irish-based LLM. We propose a novel framework
for continued pre-training of LLMs specifically adapted for extremely
low-resource languages, requiring only a fraction of the textual data typically
needed for training LLMs according to scaling laws. Our model, based on Llama
2-13B, outperforms much larger models on Irish language tasks with up to 12%
performance improvement, showcasing the effectiveness and efficiency of our
approach. We also contribute comprehensive Irish benchmarking datasets,
including IrishQA, a question-answering dataset, and Irish version of MT-bench.
These datasets enable rigorous evaluation and facilitate future research in
Irish LLM systems. Our work aims to preserve and promote the Irish language,
knowledge, and culture of Ireland in the digital era while providing a
framework for adapting LLMs to other indigenous languages.
|
[
0.0141306436,
0.0721352696,
-0.0104971165,
0.0487035513,
-0.0397465639,
0.0183228999,
-0.0108400993,
-0.0199601129,
-0.00736481,
-0.0223831888,
-0.047723908,
-0.0462880619,
-0.0522929654,
0.021453958,
0.0082561783,
0.0333023667,
0.0868054405,
-0.0322419219,
-0.0262035504,
-0.0511875413,
0.0183664709,
0.0173352994,
0.0004735089,
0.0002311544,
-0.0018486761,
0.0046590087,
0.020925913,
0.0007878569,
-0.0069691301,
0.0015677337,
0.004205246,
0.0069710976,
-0.0190617889,
0.008908364,
0.0000019016,
-0.0705969557,
0.0068299817,
-0.0264085345,
-0.0431439392,
0.0564376563,
0.0215592496,
0.0074970387,
0.0071202805,
0.0126178609,
-0.0336475484,
0.0060561579,
0.0295312814,
-0.0023480181,
0.0722130537,
0.0766562149,
0.0183905885,
-0.0392419808,
0.0260698814,
-0.0604675859,
-0.0147155272,
0.0140701449,
0.0361514725,
0.0571523011,
0.0098519651,
0.0010505938,
-0.0137907602,
0.0394850597,
0.0212672558,
0.0121663734,
-0.0507882424,
0.0294094458,
-0.0401402414,
0.0253200568,
-0.0106724901,
0.0639201775,
0.0171120949,
-0.0109473728,
-0.0041936417,
0.0168703124,
-0.0281933695,
-0.002365924,
-0.0745900944,
0.0118809575,
0.0051135682,
0.0255318396,
0.0309574325,
-0.0413386598,
0.0209407266,
0.0190571714,
-0.0169009548,
0.056050241,
-0.001055822,
-0.0193169173,
-0.0042773052,
0.0014427672,
-0.0136596309,
-0.010463031,
0.0017194612,
0.0750627145,
0.001933048,
0.0080095921,
-0.0026219697,
0.0011239187,
0.0426313765,
-0.0454799607,
0.0409626141,
-0.0053050295,
-0.0339719169,
0.0565224662,
-0.0336874165,
0.0475734361,
-0.0281585492,
-0.0107507426,
-0.0362264477,
-0.0510150492,
-0.0428256728,
-0.0078615369,
-0.0263912585,
0.0498574898,
-0.0362585671,
0.0060531595,
-0.0432504863,
-0.0048510521,
-0.0055859168,
-0.0140369162,
0.0655514672,
-0.000302968,
-0.0347589292,
-0.0016573868,
-0.030523492,
0.0683501512,
-0.0202477444,
0.0337086953,
-0.0509361923,
-0.0889151245,
0.0031360162,
0.0221403018,
-0.0172737539,
-0.0059001129,
0.0292965863,
0.0708236992,
-0.0109023554,
-0.0253788196,
-0.0532038808,
0.0027479541,
0.0245374031,
-0.0561157949,
-0.0250518303,
-0.0934695601,
0.0412353203,
-0.0391044393,
0.0487957411,
-0.0477797799,
0.0279992148,
0.023139216,
-0.0208593402,
0.0039857076,
-0.0198250525,
0.0276645906,
0.0118468618,
0.0056745489,
-0.0232686754,
0.0689038411,
0.031578131,
-0.017284831,
0.0572067909,
-0.0247833226,
-0.024574643,
0.0490561016,
0.0248781182,
-0.0172075834,
-0.0087865088,
0.0833481923,
-0.0098112244,
0.0061139478,
0.062125396,
0.0520751812,
-0.0012676435,
-0.0245725848,
0.0651073381,
0.0505500995,
0.0316676125,
0.0167822018,
0.0503293872,
-0.0342468768,
0.0167845227,
-0.0558833443,
-0.0313116834,
0.0151238497,
0.0429726541,
-0.0002057818,
0.0276896823,
0.0381712317,
-0.0289238263,
-0.0529489964,
-0.0028917515,
0.0053678085,
-0.0555458181,
0.0415225551,
0.023552984,
0.0018493845,
0.0205618571,
0.0162244812,
0.0533343554,
-0.033721514,
0.0387357958,
-0.062385913,
0.0783207119,
0.0352735557,
0.0443484671,
-0.0268837027,
0.0015928531,
-0.0313043594,
0.0466640554,
0.0227345265,
0.0248616673,
-0.0598216541,
0.0185466949,
-0.0334878936,
0.0347430855,
0.0049657184,
-0.0209211763,
0.0006316222,
0.0596100762,
0.0565871485,
-0.0215193685,
-0.0246657003,
-0.0471227169,
0.0201064143,
-0.0330829509,
-0.0347721279,
-0.0003885379,
-0.0177410748,
0.0205313191,
0.0344150625,
-0.0579530336,
-0.0347957835,
0.0335907489,
-0.0571307279,
0.0242482554,
-0.0120901419,
-0.0177869014,
0.0052061896,
0.0870676488,
-0.0174334627,
0.0136476206,
0.0558411963,
-0.0422078408,
-0.0344348252,
0.0212930832,
-0.0133858379,
0.046101924,
-0.0555866957,
0.0001201045,
-0.0016810123,
-0.0042759865,
-0.0397264622,
0.0807672366,
-0.0303427093,
0.0075116754,
-0.0287301615,
-0.0195654836,
0.0177714881,
-0.0537327304,
-0.024104856,
0.0348952562,
-0.0101943258,
0.0329211541,
0.0071306382,
0.0348236747,
-0.0075928117,
-0.0066010877,
-0.0846759155,
0.01619762,
-0.0426869616,
0.028902052,
0.0434627831,
0.0329121053,
-0.0226944331,
-0.0262174811,
-0.0509821177,
-0.0227925312,
0.0057192659,
0.0276432578,
0.0183007829,
0.0118023502,
0.0091717197,
-0.040188022,
-0.0194518622,
0.0081455689,
0.0226305034,
-0.0274777524,
-0.0054078056,
-0.0163761862,
0.0069947294,
-0.0595987253,
-0.0099674165,
-0.02459828,
-0.0184112247,
-0.0322382413,
-0.0106294565,
0.0319382399,
0.0046520992,
-0.0312537774,
-0.0010962882,
0.0202784557,
-0.0017583007,
-0.0568749011,
0.0209572744,
0.0024252869,
-0.0396290906,
-0.0472030193,
-0.0504886545,
-0.0047684116,
0.0680821836,
-0.009600264,
-0.0179631338,
-0.0128619261,
-0.0026114089,
-0.0434531458,
-0.0142467311,
-0.0603628121,
0.0393590368,
-0.0138436118,
0.0297855474,
-0.0671885088,
-0.0451660343,
0.0365488976,
-0.0110910637,
0.0062615206,
-0.0406161584,
-0.0402299985,
-0.0724707395,
0.0411239378,
-0.0107032871,
0.0379668996,
-0.0361346304,
0.0030572899,
-0.0284267757,
-0.0252695158,
-0.0064090956,
-0.0471235178,
0.0923360586,
-0.0344303995,
0.0286775548,
-0.0133946268,
-0.0217042379,
-0.0152686993,
-0.0139559209,
-0.0237907395,
0.0106326193,
-0.0252982508,
0.0000171266,
0.007595601,
-0.0215312392,
0.0134011311,
0.0137604689,
0.0095877936,
0.007206188,
-0.0066347145,
0.0846023187,
0.0492825396,
0.0300543476,
0.0125910426,
0.0065745199,
0.0297582541,
0.0171392299,
0.0307700001,
-0.0278366059,
0.0071960543,
0.0093011288,
0.0157210696,
-0.0573175065,
0.0009118047,
0.0058446834,
0.0606887192,
-0.01839111,
-0.0396087207,
0.0829333141,
0.0149411634,
-0.0121786231,
0.0026134548,
-0.052549012,
0.0355267525,
0.0536825545,
0.0429587178,
-0.0973784477,
-0.0167270415,
-0.0346780978,
0.0229431149,
0.0408445895,
-0.0135586718,
-0.0041833115,
-0.1016474888,
0.0314105824,
-0.010524191,
-0.0484163575,
-0.0045976159,
-0.0328356102,
-0.0052582389,
-0.0618748441,
-0.0080737825,
0.0128827253,
-0.0384062342,
-0.0089443084,
0.0209537987,
0.0095743164,
-0.0247968156,
0.0069762813,
-0.0506395102,
0.0757688135,
0.0232579857,
0.0010734205,
-0.0284309089,
0.0088650165,
0.047246445,
-0.0279618017,
0.0045430297,
0.0021773023,
0.0079325307,
0.0067053018,
-0.0292539857,
-0.0383442678,
0.007841114,
-0.0216813888,
-0.0004899784,
0.0349638164,
0.0853886902,
0.006363214,
0.0162502471,
-0.00636975,
-0.0151555743,
0.0020711073,
0.0663192868,
0.033442568,
-0.0277609769,
-0.0521953218,
-0.0130785219,
-0.0626474693,
-0.0169330221,
-0.0531278215,
0.0409070812,
0.0439677648,
0.0078653973,
-0.0774688348,
-0.0395231061,
0.0224880483,
0.0026973458,
0.00913807,
0.0253106765,
-0.0181229226,
-0.0118078822,
-0.0829501301,
0.0576523952,
-0.0917632952,
0.014347407,
-0.0846417397,
-0.0191730838,
0.081683293,
0.0030962371,
-0.0020678088,
-0.0009109851,
-0.0992958546,
-0.0473175608,
0.0072593773,
0.080919832,
0.0254740864,
0.0224750265,
0.0044726958,
-0.0613179095,
0.0479238629,
-0.0054098004,
-0.007453457,
0.039872244,
0.0086940536,
0.018746743,
-0.0057474724,
0.0453320108,
-0.0658710524,
0.0460349955,
-0.0063263155,
0.0380558409,
-0.0581624731,
0.0082130516,
0.0131070698,
0.0251134802,
-0.0377329551,
0.0003065736,
-0.001063925,
-0.0400363095,
0.0294735599,
-0.0211336743,
0.0024286271,
0.0131373163,
-0.0188914109,
0.0451154672,
-0.0040491228,
-0.0038833879,
-0.014662344,
0.0194279887,
0.0301665869,
-0.0547321886,
0.026863521,
0.0294983294,
0.0011654325,
-0.0042195939,
0.0213148165,
-0.0198358838,
0.0445607491,
-0.03476974,
0.0581447482,
-0.0147944354,
0.0353409387,
-0.0272114705,
0.003291111,
0.0056634285,
0.0191324763,
-0.0411757082,
-0.0677087381,
0.0108834635,
-0.0126209212,
0.0895108953,
0.0096489433,
0.0261198748,
0.0138504654,
-0.0098587219,
-0.0078445636,
-0.0124040693,
-0.0088213868,
-0.0161395576,
0.0527796932,
0.0326409154,
0.0026491901,
0.0222616754,
0.093848303,
0.00063537,
0.0604784079,
0.0121029448,
0.048819676,
-0.0282300785,
-0.0565147586,
0.025795253,
0.0088942554,
-0.0188737344,
0.006616822,
-0.0304643624,
-0.0664350316,
0.0206481274,
0.0265621077,
-0.0198134109,
-0.0039799502,
0.0293797981,
0.0284418873,
0.0417564586,
-0.017423749,
-0.0811176226,
0.002306279,
-0.0255967546,
-0.0109703531,
-0.0030799154,
-6.176785677e-33,
-0.0274718702,
0.0366981402,
0.0195974801,
0.0076302239,
0.006141244,
0.0203758143,
0.0030847369,
-0.0091396198,
-0.0737595707,
0.0061951233,
-0.0157624576,
0.0253411084,
-0.0051217373,
0.034188319,
-0.0145878289,
-0.0047166208,
-0.0061051226,
-0.0431626961,
0.0245320536,
0.0177320782,
0.0087820487,
0.0083485767,
0.0173820164,
-0.0595630482,
0.0038003249,
-0.0105066299,
0.021571042,
0.0528520569,
-0.0114529738,
0.0756737143,
-0.0451653078,
0.0653980598,
0.0380953252,
-0.0144117782,
-0.0135915037,
0.0018892891,
-0.1217168495,
-0.0533878133,
0.0410031937,
0.0009220347,
0.0088608814,
-0.0341285542,
0.0124305077,
-0.0108484318,
-0.0015870738,
0.0129795084,
0.0184888169,
-0.0164245814,
0.0066259354,
-0.0034949193,
0.000078884,
-0.0044654449,
0.0129486537,
0.0272329822,
-0.0142922094,
0.0243557822,
-0.0048786774,
-0.0143277599,
-0.0593720973,
-0.0071999417,
-0.0396438539,
0.0404093601,
0.0650951043,
0.0018466484,
-0.0173066873,
0.0428236835,
0.0184149779,
-0.009954297,
-0.0053419652,
0.027218774,
0.0011547531,
0.0125330696,
0.0547828749,
0.062597923,
0.0205958206,
0.0041985977,
-0.102002129,
0.0116453683,
0.0761992559,
0.0526098385,
-0.0147803612,
-0.006179824,
-0.0344899744,
-0.0017963478,
-0.0218654778,
-0.0053789234,
-0.0174352955,
-0.0241228547,
0.0615747944,
-0.0001546753,
0.0055611646,
0.0277425349,
0.0354897715,
-0.0520239994,
-0.0212818682,
0.055422917,
0.0499111563,
0.029544279,
0.0056499862,
0.0453815274,
-0.0742630437,
-0.0062736417,
-0.0128836026,
-0.0156286117,
0.027632229,
-0.0072567277,
0.0442860909,
0.0112598417,
-0.0809275731,
0.0192148183,
-0.0265281256,
0.0575464666,
-0.008090484,
0.0252703987,
0.0247613322,
-0.0009594109,
0.0117128612,
0.0242685433,
0.03124406,
-0.0693192109,
0.0083026532,
-0.055934947,
-0.0021450054,
0.0102485046,
-0.0378431156,
0.0177443456,
-0.0519562736,
0.0456727482,
-0.024983786,
-0.0367325097,
-0.0189367663,
0.0260280762,
2.477e-7,
0.0634298995,
-0.0069434391,
0.0543119311,
0.05378801,
0.0247346889,
-0.0499793924,
-0.0136178732,
0.0275649503,
-0.0470534712,
-0.0028758298,
-0.0042126593,
0.0561485253,
0.0533822775,
0.0263323747,
-0.0648890957,
-0.0100397384,
-0.0541929305,
-0.0144639788,
-0.059979219,
-0.0395764373,
0.0186579823,
0.0693340302,
0.0061519435,
-0.0309914723,
-0.0635683164,
-0.0840671882,
0.0505303144,
-0.055365324,
0.0194175281,
0.0339151993,
-0.0186145976,
0.056941662,
-0.0283723213,
-0.0100501534,
0.0182455722,
0.0183787197,
0.028887298,
0.0707668066,
-0.0128223067,
-0.0117141716,
0.0149551863,
-0.0232285131,
-0.0034673302,
-0.0452200621,
0.0795354471,
0.0322676711,
-0.0093487194,
-0.0135858543,
-0.0180790629,
0.0027684397,
-0.0022798097,
-0.0439683571,
0.0051226723,
0.0133395735,
0.0478992015,
-0.0290202722,
-0.0301721115,
-0.0829833597,
-0.0354957506,
0.0257784426,
-0.0032261207,
-0.0174260456,
-0.0162318368,
-0.0032694424,
-0.0400545821,
-0.0768449455,
0.0031771904,
2.153365372e-34,
0.0257757511,
-0.0368825085,
0.0278531499,
0.0827485174,
0.0281263459,
-0.0305092335,
0.0240883883,
-0.0418611467,
0.003386168,
-0.0567390099,
0.0176014397
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07703v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07703v5
|
OpenLLM-Ro -- Technical Report on Open-source Romanian LLMs
| 2024-05-13T12:46:11 | 2024-05-17T08:19:52 |
Mihai Masala, Denis C. Ilie-Ablachim, Dragos Corlatescu, Miruna Zavelca, Marius Leordeanu, Horia Velicu, Marius Popescu, Mihai Dascalu, Traian Rebedea
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved almost human-like
performance on various tasks. While some LLMs have been trained on multilingual
data, most of the training data is in English. Hence, their performance in
English greatly exceeds their performance in other languages. This document
presents our approach to training and evaluating the first foundational and
chat LLM specialized for Romanian.
|
[
0.0068991533,
0.0265330598,
0.008097575,
0.0738477036,
-0.0222735219,
0.011403814,
0.0027711045,
0.020696668,
0.0323839895,
-0.0258319657,
-0.074975796,
-0.0630400255,
-0.0110163623,
-0.0086203245,
0.0300363302,
-0.0235648938,
0.0534706302,
-0.0466195792,
-0.0503589623,
-0.0189837012,
-0.0015223966,
-0.0000050021,
-0.0248123668,
0.0219179671,
0.0284969304,
0.0055535147,
-0.0005434299,
0.0132942358,
-0.001266407,
-0.0125367781,
-0.0029673805,
0.0127399908,
0.0265272912,
0.0370183662,
0.0000015966,
-0.0620123595,
-0.0024962262,
-0.0156971477,
0.0099516753,
0.0055227717,
0.0650855005,
-0.0471521765,
-0.0351634286,
0.0513730161,
-0.0290746745,
-0.0115186293,
0.0270266403,
0.0388262644,
0.0375181399,
0.1007285938,
-0.0068610632,
-0.0317560099,
0.018924024,
-0.0388524346,
-0.0255857985,
-0.0087928455,
0.0340683423,
0.0026015146,
0.0119005563,
0.0070974161,
-0.0099997735,
0.0355286412,
-0.0054605599,
-0.0045952811,
-0.0196097214,
0.0203386955,
-0.0468962118,
-0.0270176493,
-0.0340655111,
0.0518467426,
-0.0038860345,
0.0040044249,
0.0214060303,
0.0233506635,
-0.0397219658,
-0.0308106542,
-0.0528863855,
0.0653336793,
0.0288444459,
0.0421235114,
0.0148573918,
-0.0143896267,
0.0126474351,
0.0048496407,
0.0077761589,
0.0632901415,
0.0426958464,
-0.0268457457,
0.0263216868,
-0.0091244671,
0.021924885,
-0.0290867388,
0.008839285,
0.0730414242,
-0.0095463097,
0.0348517336,
-0.0217100382,
0.0120393727,
0.0643585101,
-0.0837166533,
0.0171342753,
0.0263280235,
-0.0262409709,
0.0415278636,
-0.0399127118,
0.0523138121,
-0.016291339,
0.0196930356,
-0.032882873,
-0.020797858,
-0.0146186277,
0.0298572071,
-0.0450459607,
0.0117777325,
-0.0294104032,
-0.0068192761,
-0.0717583746,
0.0425307378,
0.0523792952,
0.0373704545,
0.0352653451,
-0.0332407877,
-0.0158571191,
0.0009383939,
-0.0374833047,
0.0262555014,
0.0088450611,
0.012596027,
-0.0602040142,
-0.0670952722,
0.0126492232,
0.0408729725,
-0.0123844361,
-0.0070989165,
0.0209717173,
0.0756197497,
-0.0014609689,
-0.0220999997,
-0.0307313818,
0.0263406746,
0.0101412414,
-0.098435089,
-0.0284729209,
-0.0721983761,
0.0106486846,
-0.0019053053,
0.0081391707,
-0.0556024984,
0.0161024723,
0.0350161456,
-0.0338859297,
0.0382324494,
-0.0491151065,
-0.0083132833,
0.0009375476,
-0.0015390821,
0.027835235,
0.0816722438,
0.0021752403,
0.0411743522,
0.0496536754,
0.0132112959,
0.0005274663,
0.0802880824,
0.009434199,
0.0231500566,
-0.0169508848,
0.0409806408,
0.0253479015,
0.0350677371,
0.0575740375,
0.0889027119,
-0.0000900157,
-0.0009284723,
0.0610298924,
0.0436355211,
0.0627203882,
0.0354831479,
0.0249560606,
0.004459898,
0.0205407292,
-0.0078782644,
-0.0300582182,
-0.0251846425,
-0.0012086029,
0.0140972724,
-0.009377853,
0.0339196585,
-0.0477523096,
-0.0190643743,
-0.0327353999,
-0.0485102385,
-0.0080080805,
-0.0356447361,
0.0831372067,
-0.0123335002,
-0.0331735872,
0.0724468604,
0.0681143701,
-0.0280608628,
0.0003273654,
-0.058074072,
0.0675719902,
0.0385643989,
0.0224201325,
-0.0371575989,
-0.0120683247,
-0.0192607958,
0.0210251901,
0.0551989973,
0.0459380448,
-0.0134523557,
-0.0053868843,
-0.0607509203,
0.0234898441,
0.0073309657,
-0.000454522,
0.0433048531,
-0.0308623686,
0.0276924837,
0.0181347057,
0.0180289987,
-0.0356766991,
0.0300496276,
-0.0277286768,
0.0151897185,
-0.0088745514,
-0.0143766841,
0.0086422833,
0.0250758771,
0.0064457492,
-0.026908651,
0.0547583215,
-0.0494276546,
0.0112179723,
0.0002569652,
0.0164526086,
-0.0319280773,
0.0711963922,
0.0001922265,
-0.016715534,
0.0193574969,
-0.0359174833,
-0.0366314426,
0.0479972698,
-0.0035807206,
0.0286735594,
-0.0608293079,
0.0374873281,
0.0023486442,
0.0389997289,
-0.0264327768,
0.0482367277,
-0.0121447435,
0.0129711861,
0.0627539456,
-0.0034623907,
0.0288868733,
-0.0552243181,
-0.044685334,
0.0310415309,
-0.008672813,
0.0197864734,
-0.0245067962,
0.0486184619,
-0.0198187809,
-0.0194523018,
-0.0763914958,
0.0376964286,
-0.051167611,
0.0358714871,
0.0130764134,
-0.0024700994,
-0.021098258,
-0.0460495166,
-0.0592762008,
-0.0059524868,
0.0197338127,
-0.0257668104,
0.0290430542,
0.0193471685,
-0.0473642386,
-0.0400305204,
0.0171083771,
0.0213557724,
0.000851522,
-0.022492025,
-0.016986398,
-0.0879095495,
0.0790215656,
-0.0686380193,
0.0528985225,
-0.0322008468,
-0.0473498814,
-0.0235758573,
-0.0076336018,
0.0514030047,
0.0147915808,
-0.0168108977,
0.008154518,
0.0607353412,
0.0264153462,
-0.0361153036,
0.0013085832,
-0.0052235923,
-0.0304943286,
-0.079669781,
-0.0150095169,
-0.009703882,
0.0429502502,
-0.042786479,
0.0129932119,
0.0102460319,
-0.0341344252,
-0.0363708772,
-0.0053342613,
-0.0341985598,
0.0138253905,
-0.0288073588,
0.0463563837,
0.021898564,
-0.0370776504,
0.0239681657,
-0.0622489825,
-0.0060672304,
-0.0333738923,
-0.067603007,
-0.0841706768,
0.0163520519,
-0.0216175299,
-0.000798726,
-0.0485124178,
-0.0299801175,
-0.0261789244,
-0.0283823218,
-0.0049865157,
-0.0275829546,
0.0768232644,
-0.026371913,
0.0136326421,
-0.0302488431,
-0.0260245297,
-0.0420875587,
-0.0223943684,
-0.0315550007,
0.0084669404,
-0.0008708912,
-0.013880372,
-0.0274634343,
0.0320670903,
-0.0141469892,
0.0265149698,
-0.0207224898,
0.0351043567,
-0.0122221634,
0.0218563378,
0.0461486094,
0.0114984522,
0.0074412511,
-0.046557229,
0.01052956,
0.0428440347,
0.0429669246,
-0.035426084,
-0.0314872414,
-0.0255241394,
0.044699315,
-0.0503951237,
-0.0237777922,
-0.0286916029,
0.0010150946,
-0.0327524282,
-0.0163586829,
0.1168564782,
0.015890073,
-0.0587242208,
-0.014162004,
-0.0449369885,
0.0359437913,
0.0241532251,
0.0511571839,
-0.0763946101,
-0.004070106,
-0.0158325173,
-0.0044074426,
0.0107697593,
0.0127108479,
-0.0302388426,
-0.0947489291,
0.0101756183,
-0.0017443141,
-0.0304563511,
-0.039997533,
-0.0344185047,
-0.0006741327,
-0.0406606495,
0.0354487486,
0.02673807,
-0.0542735457,
-0.0414437167,
0.0238056444,
-0.0483692624,
-0.0499460436,
-0.0173246693,
-0.0478379913,
0.0804773867,
0.0356056653,
0.0225560125,
-0.0249653663,
-0.0217500664,
0.0821373537,
0.0093412763,
0.0146790575,
-0.0448788255,
0.0189659055,
0.0025585862,
-0.0200572312,
-0.0014492576,
0.0002077969,
-0.0191917419,
0.0056493459,
0.013331797,
0.0575798899,
-0.0184859131,
0.0028945836,
0.0240104571,
0.0091372877,
0.024185434,
0.0392461121,
0.0155185005,
-0.0063355346,
-0.0239343327,
-0.018443564,
-0.0572644062,
0.0060032015,
-0.0466856211,
0.0149681726,
-0.0251603331,
-0.0534040444,
-0.0376481786,
-0.0302361269,
0.0427461639,
0.0114768734,
-0.0022840311,
0.0244764518,
0.001307936,
0.0089554973,
-0.0074987183,
0.0215246938,
-0.0350081399,
0.0156329013,
-0.0747708455,
0.001885162,
0.065922223,
-0.0288743749,
-0.012392587,
-0.0003524199,
-0.096538797,
-0.0494513623,
-0.0069135996,
0.0501604378,
0.0284158979,
0.0463690199,
-0.028424792,
-0.0640207604,
0.0201182906,
-0.0148410881,
-0.0260811485,
0.0149916857,
0.0423805155,
0.0328997597,
0.0178244077,
0.0557064898,
-0.0283462498,
0.0306749512,
0.0039076749,
0.0053290296,
-0.0077831689,
-0.0333606713,
-0.0110469265,
0.0307627153,
0.0204499401,
-0.0279998705,
-0.0259397682,
-0.0419630669,
0.068619974,
-0.0510687828,
0.0160482824,
-0.0159546584,
0.0242620874,
0.0265274551,
-0.005737138,
-0.0273884609,
-0.0225166306,
-0.0481517911,
0.0138316676,
-0.0229390431,
0.0324059278,
0.0023009814,
0.0085866395,
0.0482102968,
0.0221167933,
-0.0172039289,
0.0500012189,
0.0084621478,
0.0253737736,
-0.0299833715,
0.0206906125,
-0.0204974804,
-0.0063158646,
0.0076226662,
0.0278267507,
-0.0204583406,
-0.0101903426,
0.0106079765,
0.0494704135,
0.0870901421,
0.0372854173,
0.091841653,
-0.0348182283,
0.0071831555,
-0.0137095135,
0.0496049635,
-0.0365833677,
-0.0277740527,
0.0483063161,
-0.0147437481,
-0.0461710952,
0.0304325316,
0.0674987957,
0.0037031297,
0.00100636,
0.0130921723,
0.0126930736,
-0.0380870029,
-0.0055913059,
0.0099861184,
-0.0294723231,
-0.0460991859,
-0.0278992057,
-0.0364586823,
-0.0570052303,
0.0086897593,
0.0216318313,
-0.0383164585,
-0.0157014187,
0.0337990858,
0.0375205427,
0.0408259556,
0.0266386624,
-0.0578221045,
-0.0144471228,
0.0033466562,
-0.0200483482,
-0.0182723664,
-5.526772565e-33,
-0.0444172211,
0.0001282875,
0.0352996401,
0.0042806417,
-0.0345801078,
-0.0173529238,
0.0112186046,
-0.0033397835,
-0.0003347521,
-0.0078834314,
-0.0154578649,
0.0061405967,
0.0256911255,
0.0060142875,
-0.0146819251,
-0.0211556554,
0.0320814587,
-0.0077169021,
0.0120010655,
0.0148936566,
0.0104957633,
0.0545573607,
0.0812380165,
-0.0511009768,
0.0031220142,
-0.0414821506,
-0.0128861945,
0.0490747169,
0.0341627672,
0.0790958554,
-0.0365069322,
0.0403618775,
0.0188992582,
-0.0202469788,
-0.0037999637,
-0.0174291022,
-0.0417606272,
-0.0189045016,
0.0446959101,
0.05750525,
-0.0060970001,
-0.0147395479,
0.0222294927,
-0.011044303,
-0.0216819476,
0.0264721736,
0.0251782052,
-0.0307940003,
-0.0308233723,
-0.0034911411,
-0.0381178074,
0.0389379933,
0.0262424778,
0.010032922,
0.0314548463,
0.0209312774,
-0.0118107935,
-0.0140379043,
-0.0415732563,
0.0287093241,
-0.0101808291,
0.0373886786,
0.0775492415,
-0.0206138492,
-0.0035589589,
0.0438812897,
0.0151037676,
-0.0204814207,
-0.0138287041,
-0.0312887914,
0.0410031006,
0.0428242646,
0.0271435454,
0.0359426551,
-0.0256448165,
-0.0171498582,
-0.0978883952,
0.0025431302,
0.0736926049,
0.0301174149,
-0.0023218461,
-0.0134528959,
-0.0060649016,
-0.0146667864,
-0.0066879583,
0.0116666853,
-0.0225340556,
-0.0589995049,
0.0210684445,
-0.0023063906,
0.0097223883,
-0.0314255543,
0.0098659759,
-0.0418449305,
-0.037114542,
0.0006500115,
-0.0045585474,
0.0178841781,
-0.0308947172,
0.0456005782,
-0.0808623508,
-0.05331406,
-0.0250379778,
-0.005681721,
0.0025238506,
-0.0173619241,
0.0255270135,
0.0208496787,
-0.0663112998,
0.01408133,
-0.0240549669,
0.0273522232,
0.0123109519,
0.0711790249,
0.0204535481,
-0.0213678684,
0.0011440092,
0.0753441602,
-0.0084728394,
-0.0148704918,
-0.0221436508,
-0.0633861795,
0.0262784902,
0.0335453562,
-0.0481747054,
0.0355944224,
-0.0372906961,
0.046420116,
0.02512387,
-0.0286537707,
0.0094926069,
-0.0086715491,
2.288e-7,
0.0552987754,
0.057578668,
-0.0107258381,
0.0543836355,
0.0035443304,
-0.0246586762,
-0.0761183724,
0.0302244239,
-0.0071097366,
0.0473920107,
0.0241794661,
0.0315068737,
0.057371892,
0.0099475468,
-0.1102485508,
-0.0162302461,
-0.0704550073,
-0.024302572,
-0.0390216038,
-0.0112037007,
-0.0047929124,
0.1170928702,
0.0028112587,
-0.0114225317,
-0.0460825861,
-0.0343608037,
0.0548063293,
-0.03662543,
-0.0546920635,
0.0474718399,
0.0552408323,
0.0569846146,
-0.0328716412,
-0.0296136905,
0.0048887534,
0.0410246477,
-0.0099861147,
0.0745597929,
0.0093292361,
-0.0312169176,
0.0624968186,
-0.0316748172,
-0.0370519087,
-0.0138815762,
0.0557187945,
0.0038129832,
-0.0137895439,
-0.055570133,
0.0205196552,
-0.0164344348,
0.0195376072,
-0.036673665,
-0.0174388066,
0.0348100103,
0.0328200571,
-0.0610882938,
-0.0394511968,
-0.0638407096,
-0.0259737819,
-0.0263021681,
-0.0295918956,
-0.0648575053,
-0.0057544997,
0.001471385,
-0.0064746714,
-0.0421698056,
0.0051544276,
1.914777901e-34,
0.0621726736,
-0.0054070428,
-0.0328748226,
0.0629580468,
0.0110622803,
-0.0129673705,
0.0193683878,
0.0194043517,
-0.0053623435,
-0.0749733597,
0.0125599429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07700v1
|
Age-Dependent Analysis and Stochastic Generation of Child-Directed Speech
| 2024-05-13T12:35:10 | 2024-05-13T12:35:10 |
Okko Räsänen, Daniil Kocharov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Child-directed speech (CDS) is a particular type of speech that adults use
when addressing young children. Its properties also change as a function of
extralinguistic factors, such as age of the child being addressed. Access to
large amounts of representative and varied CDS would be useful for child
language research, as this would enable controlled computational modeling
experiments of infant language acquisition with realistic input in terms of
quality and quantity. In this study, we describe an approach to model
age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS using a language model (LM) trained
on CDS transcripts and ages of the recipient children, as obtained from North
American English corpora of the CHILDES database. The created LM can then be
used to stochastically generate synthetic CDS transcripts in an age-appropriate
manner, thereby scaling beyond the original datasets in size. We compare
characteristics of the generated CDS against the real speech addressed at
children of different ages, showing that the LM manages to capture
age-dependent changes in CDS, except for a slight difference in the effective
vocabulary size. As a side product, we also provide a systematic
characterization of age-dependent linguistic properties of CDS in CHILDES,
illustrating how all measured aspects of the CDS change with children's age.
|
[
0.009073399,
0.0734831169,
-0.0259437226,
-0.0085779373,
-0.0402214341,
0.0265150815,
0.0270574875,
-0.0003605803,
-0.0318102688,
-0.0103984699,
-0.0001323694,
-0.0832193717,
0.0552371219,
0.0122289676,
-0.0127261728,
-0.0418375134,
0.0608951598,
-0.0491065308,
0.0192850158,
0.0069209677,
-0.024833193,
0.0061391206,
-0.0096662762,
0.0144607974,
-0.0542162172,
-0.0039776419,
-0.0018798951,
-0.015669724,
-0.0444993079,
-0.0273992717,
-0.0004153464,
0.0499265827,
0.0467553176,
0.0552119166,
0.000002124,
-0.0553134494,
0.0455823801,
0.0033663756,
-0.0393636711,
0.0094239935,
0.068419233,
0.0086383503,
-0.0371358506,
0.0013909534,
-0.0202063136,
0.0109288618,
0.0491095111,
-0.043962311,
-0.021498464,
0.0460283644,
0.0020480992,
-0.0175265633,
-0.0027050346,
-0.0072342502,
-0.0050843591,
0.0091815386,
0.0030655926,
0.0275471732,
0.0415632278,
-0.0642439052,
-0.003898331,
0.0214896686,
-0.005651,
-0.0305175576,
0.0337575376,
-0.0154971806,
0.0283297468,
-0.0528263748,
-0.0333802961,
0.0274929833,
0.0331156664,
-0.0206617061,
0.0100544123,
0.0100131603,
-0.0251194797,
0.0097273057,
-0.0377759002,
0.0278779157,
0.0314523242,
0.0240206234,
0.003885851,
-0.0354576148,
0.0118202576,
-0.0250748191,
-0.0006759161,
0.0644242689,
0.0138508575,
-0.0634819195,
0.0198644567,
0.0263522286,
0.0363343768,
-0.0068379343,
-0.0091030197,
-0.0181573965,
-0.0333531052,
0.0244900268,
-0.0387190357,
-0.0132453339,
-0.0149699831,
-0.0015046059,
0.0385742486,
-0.0695156679,
-0.0408773981,
0.0033560984,
0.0279551819,
-0.0059622587,
0.0397187024,
-0.010943884,
-0.0612685904,
0.0211858507,
-0.0041683209,
-0.0029444692,
-0.0170471072,
0.0074664452,
-0.0247009285,
0.0047130133,
-0.0724396259,
0.0092483591,
0.0014407184,
-0.0443119481,
0.0238006767,
0.0203097854,
-0.0328357965,
0.0049340865,
-0.0271355584,
0.0215979721,
-0.0183259286,
0.0343098268,
0.015771294,
-0.0520591214,
-0.0139998114,
0.039408002,
0.0401367694,
0.0138274739,
-0.0156352334,
0.0590480976,
0.0033144853,
0.0276150703,
-0.0174871814,
-0.012444729,
-0.0468932092,
-0.0719380751,
0.0001978616,
-0.0692576393,
-0.0168791153,
-0.0107351867,
-0.0262482408,
-0.0670429841,
-0.0258406959,
-0.0160138402,
-0.0335751586,
-0.0379102901,
0.0000662707,
0.0617068745,
0.0027974632,
-0.0535108671,
0.0619122572,
0.0565413795,
0.0743916184,
-0.1030122042,
0.0535212569,
-0.0321716927,
-0.0661498755,
0.0692286044,
-0.0065435236,
0.0362692438,
-0.0136652142,
-0.0282050911,
-0.0185274165,
0.0125217298,
0.0606355146,
0.0134751135,
-0.0080426969,
0.0030070108,
0.0610726401,
0.0671716258,
-0.0179764275,
-0.0283744335,
0.0579874553,
0.0392807238,
0.0431452505,
-0.0253308713,
0.0123950476,
0.0183753483,
-0.0160267428,
-0.0686214939,
-0.0002452772,
0.0422089472,
-0.0257588401,
0.0140536269,
-0.0157989543,
-0.0067674941,
0.0020301403,
-0.0128112137,
0.0229053907,
0.0501071177,
-0.0147801526,
-0.0134799117,
0.0416479036,
-0.0502885394,
0.0141005255,
-0.0342349298,
-0.0232885312,
0.0255260784,
-0.0303311925,
0.0017167572,
0.0055164034,
0.0117954146,
-0.015467803,
0.0375273228,
-0.0163227897,
0.0101493383,
0.0265044998,
-0.0050178375,
0.0033574705,
0.077860795,
0.0274806321,
-0.0009749011,
0.0086352816,
-0.0216178671,
-0.0135836266,
-0.0012664485,
-0.0016612959,
0.0259577781,
-0.0511069037,
-0.0149683813,
0.0511968434,
-0.0100422427,
0.0478676856,
0.0154606076,
-0.0000859339,
0.0306392498,
0.0227484107,
0.0470553339,
0.0303846002,
0.0587598011,
-0.0484299138,
-0.0304362793,
-0.007596815,
-0.0006707074,
-0.0309920982,
-0.0212172661,
0.0228165239,
-0.017362725,
0.1099583134,
-0.0707884654,
0.020565832,
0.009929698,
0.0566867292,
-0.0238473341,
-0.023758091,
-0.0242294539,
0.0350686088,
-0.00535157,
-0.0205780603,
0.0084937913,
-0.01250578,
-0.0087790703,
-0.07681337,
0.0060684695,
-0.0438870639,
-0.0337291025,
0.0291789901,
0.004364376,
0.0028991746,
-0.0412362255,
-0.0285538994,
-0.0166901723,
-0.0265842807,
0.0135633377,
0.020235382,
0.0054029929,
-0.0101903314,
0.0199141167,
0.0238742903,
-0.0243877936,
0.0248013027,
0.0088244816,
0.0334379524,
0.0075636366,
-0.0521577522,
-0.053716626,
-0.0395693928,
-0.0196786467,
-0.0180419311,
0.0227958541,
-0.0090014422,
-0.039562352,
-0.0006994384,
-0.0017673626,
-0.0233617723,
0.0213281512,
-0.0045132185,
0.0312080234,
0.0361780301,
0.0189788416,
0.0845360309,
0.0318484306,
-0.0262424033,
0.0081217578,
0.0015313874,
-0.0854750648,
-0.0184480548,
-0.0107007641,
-0.0422986597,
0.0341648944,
-0.0397557542,
-0.0192108694,
-0.0008818174,
0.0518195406,
0.0469022878,
-0.0173136815,
-0.0383210517,
0.0354182236,
-0.0065860245,
-0.0166368447,
-0.0089741414,
-0.0509843454,
-0.0410368741,
0.0388159081,
-0.0168299861,
-0.0796131045,
0.0148485312,
0.0065947385,
-0.0294437483,
-0.0469601862,
-0.0066145235,
0.01503764,
0.0230092593,
0.0112800524,
-0.0160074998,
0.0107371137,
-0.0145203639,
-0.0770967901,
0.0510741249,
0.0632121041,
-0.0295017529,
0.0493880808,
-0.0830309466,
0.0101618608,
0.0669632256,
-0.0211310349,
-0.031228384,
-0.0332810916,
-0.0007974369,
0.0319009498,
-0.0125038512,
-0.0466569588,
-0.0329877883,
-0.0387056842,
0.0230209678,
0.0513189472,
-0.0037131768,
0.0404596515,
-0.0031616141,
-0.0025735043,
0.0335384756,
0.0063525159,
-0.0074999598,
-0.0367788263,
0.0099162869,
-0.008170777,
-0.0150787923,
0.0135884658,
-0.0092711905,
0.0451499261,
0.0163318459,
0.0616470911,
-0.0291233398,
0.0607775375,
0.0147967543,
-0.0172762424,
-0.0198257994,
0.0254924037,
0.0416793525,
-0.0057425774,
-0.0066246116,
-0.0129430462,
0.0662285388,
0.0136022912,
-0.0352552012,
-0.0415955782,
0.0195636842,
0.030687198,
0.0367358625,
0.0004455163,
0.006351951,
-0.0464084595,
-0.0977046192,
0.0588312633,
0.0127065564,
-0.0394827686,
0.0326840207,
-0.0120892152,
-0.0391430147,
0.0520173088,
0.0320566669,
0.0743706971,
-0.057267379,
-0.0340175405,
0.0375993475,
-0.0710112453,
-0.0797163695,
0.0439393371,
-0.0175722186,
0.0984087139,
0.0635216087,
0.009803541,
-0.0364223234,
-0.0030170276,
0.0041082106,
-0.0108608752,
-0.0428400673,
-0.0063725291,
-0.0296339951,
0.0331308208,
0.010567693,
-0.0471384041,
0.0757704303,
-0.0000957714,
0.009662712,
0.0391788557,
0.0491902977,
-0.030745985,
-0.0410334356,
0.0148012768,
0.0602438599,
0.0202531163,
0.0268451013,
0.0151088415,
-0.0724090636,
0.0161847286,
0.0241744723,
-0.0041719405,
0.017868964,
-0.0113970395,
0.0229871999,
-0.0128182778,
-0.0600809306,
-0.1152395979,
0.0428282544,
0.0085136332,
0.0029779603,
0.0418025069,
-0.0136840362,
0.0484538041,
-0.055500377,
-0.011860501,
0.0401109494,
-0.0000709244,
0.0093906913,
-0.0930491611,
-0.0657741427,
-0.0145182004,
-0.0510810167,
-0.0371616185,
-0.0128804538,
-0.0732524246,
-0.0672779679,
0.0405060984,
-0.0176394582,
0.0233596135,
0.0424919315,
0.0021166601,
-0.0353353024,
0.0392276049,
0.0083422894,
0.0323235504,
0.0095784804,
0.0165648963,
-0.0151062692,
0.0207855441,
0.0085385451,
-0.0227656085,
0.0473887622,
-0.0256938655,
0.0048954138,
-0.0311314147,
-0.056840308,
-0.0070131123,
-0.0193324871,
0.0291114561,
0.0021679311,
-0.0115573416,
-0.0799137503,
0.0162888877,
-0.0375381596,
0.0316086672,
-0.0094434349,
-0.0244763494,
-0.0007465279,
0.0285969395,
-0.006500714,
-0.0074756271,
-0.0694383457,
0.0129510155,
0.0212579593,
0.0605898611,
0.0090601267,
0.0445419662,
0.0096806055,
0.0399116427,
0.0156869236,
0.0413889773,
-0.0416385718,
0.064687781,
-0.0062668286,
0.0126899621,
-0.0307017975,
-0.0157680586,
-0.0072150771,
-0.0268594138,
-0.0124541782,
0.0439454541,
-0.0240795724,
-0.0394786708,
0.0393624455,
-0.0183622204,
0.0930643305,
-0.0363858454,
0.0392582491,
-0.0583182909,
-0.0060820766,
0.0021387865,
-0.0234967563,
0.0167155974,
-0.0228057168,
-0.0373295285,
0.0418667421,
0.0347041972,
0.0396316499,
-0.0126701826,
-0.057729248,
0.0297938753,
-0.0134877507,
-0.0300088599,
0.0223312415,
-0.0072537763,
-0.0681882948,
0.0266613103,
-0.038765613,
-0.0233423673,
-0.0167997051,
-0.0150843952,
0.0209269635,
-0.0232370179,
0.0594635159,
0.0103834337,
-0.0823913366,
-0.0128024658,
-0.0372929797,
-0.0186151862,
0.0040790327,
-0.030313598,
-0.0031120463,
-6.559772022e-33,
0.0042461446,
-0.0036515289,
0.0089754499,
0.0190627873,
0.0064521665,
-0.0062560407,
-0.0282055959,
0.046683006,
-0.0139459129,
0.006930911,
0.0012634239,
-0.0348050445,
0.0180453192,
0.0371366143,
0.0459129177,
0.0211263038,
0.0124331592,
-0.0366103463,
0.0437172838,
-0.0266363472,
0.0244370233,
-0.0144333569,
0.0508459881,
0.0083485153,
0.0556971617,
-0.004083111,
-0.0161533393,
0.005017186,
-0.0011794829,
0.0456580669,
-0.0105405077,
0.0395252444,
-0.0107977968,
0.0132290721,
-0.0042677326,
0.0155445784,
-0.0621152259,
0.0109086623,
0.0469576083,
0.0103731621,
-0.045748543,
0.039484743,
-0.0019170605,
0.0218290444,
-0.0219261553,
-0.0024861041,
0.0026106806,
-0.0079477113,
0.0020082265,
-0.0224868618,
-0.0891930014,
0.0169519335,
-0.0001874169,
-0.0052461638,
0.0188241471,
0.0321662985,
-0.0653047711,
-0.0211201906,
-0.007045879,
0.0310808849,
0.055221349,
0.0885375142,
0.0216357354,
0.0175004695,
0.038962733,
0.0308924876,
0.0383994617,
0.01222659,
0.020142654,
0.033123076,
0.0814153329,
0.0251991097,
0.0126435459,
0.0087009519,
0.0181645099,
0.0046077683,
-0.0920305178,
-0.0310062002,
0.032016065,
0.0479758568,
0.0185415931,
-0.0217374004,
-0.0156088881,
-0.0016864146,
-0.0525503047,
-0.0057053249,
-0.0017296985,
0.0027926913,
0.0039824736,
0.0034825008,
-0.0070769782,
-0.0432062596,
0.0234836787,
0.0159036629,
-0.0364870802,
-0.0513242893,
-0.0115032699,
-0.0177253149,
-0.0100722471,
0.0304349847,
-0.0450608023,
-0.0684427395,
0.0529083014,
0.0077685574,
0.0332979858,
0.0134659037,
0.0030380276,
0.0193111952,
-0.0855658129,
0.0077617951,
0.0026344762,
0.0506343469,
0.0115167908,
-0.0082825944,
-0.0015637652,
0.0037564132,
0.0015112933,
0.0544406399,
-0.0154900998,
0.007333715,
-0.0041457331,
0.0023374562,
0.0128659001,
0.0199853908,
-0.0422993898,
0.0127348322,
-0.0113335205,
0.0143286185,
0.0608309507,
-0.007620397,
0.0094661275,
0.0227907747,
2.888e-7,
-0.019988725,
0.1162140593,
0.007262765,
0.0128661366,
0.097557269,
-0.0228861477,
-0.0298868082,
-0.0256507508,
0.0446257144,
0.0070219561,
-0.0128010325,
-0.0581836961,
0.1029171422,
0.0218474362,
-0.1149359643,
-0.0444006957,
-0.0837341845,
0.0215841271,
-0.0305704549,
-0.0155610302,
-0.032823775,
0.0777511373,
-0.0139442887,
-0.0583165139,
-0.015900217,
0.0437409021,
-0.00340893,
-0.0236910861,
0.0083865682,
-0.0133131621,
-0.0329318941,
-0.0081253769,
0.0644033477,
0.0578137003,
-0.0786247402,
0.0748526305,
-0.0247615036,
0.0641203895,
-0.0434183814,
-0.0063735666,
0.0313867591,
0.0002220274,
-0.0647869408,
0.0040757377,
0.0237641744,
-0.0114932992,
-0.0065311869,
0.0215314999,
-0.0415151007,
-0.0054951147,
0.0028475926,
-0.052323617,
-0.0025600272,
0.0180619769,
0.0308312196,
-0.0060601532,
0.018744057,
0.0211081523,
0.017484352,
0.0257380363,
-0.0399144515,
-0.0983253047,
0.0303156637,
0.0315565951,
-0.0141943749,
0.0376684032,
0.0243930798,
2.397313051e-34,
0.0484551713,
-0.0200002976,
0.0477935486,
-0.0571686029,
0.025461942,
-0.0301414728,
0.046347551,
0.0291677397,
0.0436203256,
-0.0575858392,
-0.0220041089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07682v1
|
FastSAG: Towards Fast Non-Autoregressive Singing Accompaniment Generation
| 2024-05-13T12:14:54 | 2024-05-13T12:14:54 |
Jianyi Chen, Wei Xue, Xu Tan, Zhen Ye, Qifeng Liu, Yike Guo
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS
|
Singing Accompaniment Generation (SAG), which generates instrumental music to
accompany input vocals, is crucial to developing human-AI symbiotic art
creation systems. The state-of-the-art method, SingSong, utilizes a multi-stage
autoregressive (AR) model for SAG, however, this method is extremely slow as it
generates semantic and acoustic tokens recursively, and this makes it
impossible for real-time applications. In this paper, we aim to develop a Fast
SAG method that can create high-quality and coherent accompaniments. A non-AR
diffusion-based framework is developed, which by carefully designing the
conditions inferred from the vocal signals, generates the Mel spectrogram of
the target accompaniment directly. With diffusion and Mel spectrogram modeling,
the proposed method significantly simplifies the AR token-based SingSong
framework, and largely accelerates the generation. We also design semantic
projection, prior projection blocks as well as a set of loss functions, to
ensure the generated accompaniment has semantic and rhythm coherence with the
vocal signal. By intensive experimental studies, we demonstrate that the
proposed method can generate better samples than SingSong, and accelerate the
generation by at least 30 times. Audio samples and code are available at
https://fastsag.github.io/.
|
[
-0.0004416983,
0.0115099084,
0.0078238565,
-0.0261827894,
-0.018997144,
-0.0226669591,
0.0732539296,
-0.024211498,
-0.0439256504,
0.0273396466,
-0.055007115,
-0.0183771588,
0.005993742,
0.0307522453,
0.0229177717,
-0.0601645261,
0.0187502746,
-0.0293189399,
0.0169117507,
-0.0241425186,
-0.0013204446,
-0.0113402698,
-0.0191513691,
0.0285026673,
-0.0835289657,
-0.0253518075,
-0.0567460656,
0.010300165,
-0.0133587783,
-0.038922932,
-0.0796256587,
0.0020942609,
0.0066990731,
0.0105788838,
0.0000018394,
-0.028340647,
-0.0189066343,
0.0619977899,
0.0400529392,
-0.0232921056,
0.0189785119,
0.07100375,
-0.0621971264,
0.0159083903,
-0.004632182,
0.0304131862,
0.0322777107,
-0.0055406336,
0.0835335776,
0.0594322309,
0.0082652196,
-0.0257990062,
-0.0131250788,
-0.0535438284,
0.0267713219,
0.0195313897,
-0.0260321088,
-0.0271829478,
0.0604581684,
-0.0331600644,
-0.0098263733,
0.0689689443,
-0.007762773,
-0.0027216906,
0.1050226986,
0.0396239758,
-0.0274869632,
-0.082209155,
0.0264444239,
0.0418883637,
0.021787066,
0.0236746687,
0.0458115488,
0.0285931062,
0.0152932359,
0.0179814789,
-0.00871142,
0.0196531881,
0.0045663388,
0.0008636886,
-0.0265610106,
-0.0081950445,
0.0204531439,
-0.036800608,
0.043790821,
0.0208619479,
0.0406784862,
-0.0284960736,
-0.0037576368,
0.0096541187,
-0.0108098285,
-0.0354716629,
0.0287701413,
0.0174943693,
-0.0345289446,
-0.004213491,
-0.0514357984,
-0.0393248908,
-0.0243855435,
0.0211999416,
0.0766669437,
0.0158254486,
-0.0051224572,
0.0255583804,
-0.0379146524,
-0.0192053095,
-0.0259375107,
-0.0807110891,
-0.0261152331,
-0.0177376159,
0.0152922487,
-0.0114147505,
-0.0737627521,
0.0082645472,
-0.0224945284,
-0.0268414952,
-0.0384169742,
-0.0027586552,
-0.0653668493,
0.046303086,
0.0142221013,
0.0211649388,
-0.0589280538,
0.0034929344,
0.0244867876,
-0.0404273495,
-0.0124146575,
0.0453736782,
0.0370001793,
0.0217165668,
0.0073633227,
0.0220690668,
0.0136694228,
0.045959387,
0.0399074443,
0.0353495181,
0.0193360075,
0.0167711657,
0.0469906703,
-0.0607359633,
-0.0149271972,
-0.0487507023,
-0.0168521311,
-0.070679307,
0.0270606615,
-0.0411997996,
-0.0536877811,
-0.0082962224,
0.0197869036,
0.0083547542,
0.001299451,
0.0091150049,
-0.0251859445,
0.0775643215,
-0.0072281179,
-0.0047184601,
-0.0665471107,
-0.029855201,
0.0693915486,
0.0082421675,
-0.0156659391,
-0.031189112,
0.0069030216,
0.024836855,
0.0822406411,
-0.0017575662,
-0.020373553,
-0.0373894051,
-0.001725255,
0.0675965324,
0.0320711993,
0.0334948376,
0.0427059792,
-0.0246116091,
0.0213672649,
0.0223598965,
0.0547182709,
0.0893027261,
0.0649203658,
0.0254061185,
0.0003417023,
-0.0279882066,
0.0237267464,
0.0610790774,
-0.0014409529,
0.0200287346,
0.04890275,
0.0260025319,
-0.0418766066,
0.0150313014,
0.0211521257,
0.0012480259,
0.008869173,
-0.0115388082,
0.0682633966,
0.0526988842,
-0.0286088716,
-0.0056720697,
-0.0160722695,
-0.0895920321,
0.0238154083,
-0.0255371518,
0.0439508073,
0.0388551839,
0.0403355807,
-0.0169413779,
0.0537750535,
-0.025404321,
-0.0031680726,
0.0520273112,
-0.0156046953,
-0.0138305146,
0.024435157,
-0.000041029,
-0.016225297,
0.0245975163,
-0.0336794555,
0.0239847656,
-0.0324668363,
0.0216458514,
0.0127263274,
0.0518644638,
0.0585149676,
0.0143490406,
-0.0747064948,
0.016456984,
0.0293122344,
-0.0126512283,
0.0551593043,
0.0608380139,
-0.0203388203,
0.0374943949,
0.0287456829,
-0.0050676954,
-0.0023802174,
0.0280888341,
-0.0463163704,
0.0162794702,
0.0550793149,
-0.0365203731,
0.018894067,
0.0099484036,
0.0373013727,
-0.0636002496,
0.0942968875,
-0.032902889,
0.0084437709,
0.0043177018,
0.0151725328,
0.0353241302,
-0.0134615963,
0.0418166071,
-0.0133385519,
0.0458034463,
-0.0104370657,
0.0223795455,
0.0367462821,
-0.0115188649,
-0.0354857557,
-0.0067206603,
0.0183455404,
-0.0140784709,
0.0178785194,
-0.0305851102,
-0.0466243811,
-0.0460633449,
-0.0305024777,
-0.1175478175,
0.02090469,
0.006415782,
-0.0615840107,
-0.0160122439,
-0.0168412775,
-0.0091202538,
0.0014251166,
-0.0342530906,
0.0210843142,
-0.0045071226,
0.0066660154,
-0.0549409986,
-0.0054223146,
-0.0646140203,
-0.0180792958,
0.0017637806,
0.0246281102,
-0.0374642164,
-0.004457247,
-0.0044371444,
-0.03274858,
-0.0267949142,
-0.038979996,
0.0188840497,
-0.0126378583,
0.0050627817,
-0.0007977968,
-0.0157511178,
0.0383567885,
0.0217349436,
0.0128997378,
-0.0321105272,
0.0486475751,
-0.0063088979,
-0.0044796322,
0.0117529063,
0.0121947108,
0.0862757415,
0.0350556225,
0.0085873548,
-0.0153533593,
-0.012516804,
0.0795363262,
-0.0089757536,
-0.0075692399,
-0.0038065691,
-0.0103925457,
-0.0304628797,
0.0238478389,
-0.0174710136,
-0.0115169389,
-0.0129722003,
-0.0271225274,
-0.0395195372,
0.0255936887,
-0.0151103679,
-0.0485975519,
-0.0066232453,
-0.0527444445,
-0.0002893824,
-0.0103617711,
-0.0521680675,
0.0318235122,
-0.0827999413,
0.0179837421,
-0.0283801481,
0.0170888044,
0.0021529922,
-0.0875124484,
0.0012484682,
-0.0175242666,
-0.0167548861,
-0.0030264587,
0.0187441409,
-0.0381491967,
-0.0193832722,
0.0033176909,
0.0151725523,
-0.0500658751,
-0.0212934148,
0.0456775762,
0.0278425422,
0.0319954678,
0.0142110195,
0.0064162128,
0.0282054078,
0.0080676703,
-0.0060016718,
0.0389643535,
-0.0013659837,
-0.0381979719,
-0.0351617709,
0.0452337749,
0.022689905,
0.0204741042,
0.0295521189,
-0.0367869921,
0.0141069433,
-0.0255319308,
0.0331915505,
-0.0259795953,
0.0055698622,
0.0394708812,
-0.0281766467,
0.0490672216,
0.0584785454,
-0.0119424062,
0.0013972933,
0.0145937614,
0.0134209553,
0.0387262069,
0.0147824064,
-0.0250419434,
0.0222081356,
0.0125116063,
0.0666675046,
0.0510437861,
0.0378514677,
-0.0076936129,
-0.0192817599,
-0.015658062,
0.0494673885,
0.0498898588,
-0.0537728183,
0.0207472499,
-0.0319798626,
-0.0231397431,
0.0119925952,
-0.0421610996,
0.0414887965,
-0.0082577253,
0.0181355588,
0.0229049847,
-0.0111248353,
0.0339274406,
-0.0674445108,
-0.0949719474,
0.0914423242,
0.0734030604,
0.0507238917,
0.0140870139,
-0.0339309089,
-0.0164091047,
0.0519715175,
0.0350675695,
0.0094638122,
0.01862894,
0.0356411785,
0.0021226269,
0.0053846124,
0.0556516647,
-0.0645150021,
0.0342888609,
0.0257288497,
0.0565765984,
-0.030379422,
0.0035757597,
-0.0459195413,
0.0453739613,
0.0363082066,
0.0703185275,
0.0069077145,
-0.0778166801,
0.0090389429,
0.0016891889,
0.0205950662,
-0.0268676467,
-0.0098688398,
-0.0101548433,
-0.0101978006,
-0.0649210364,
-0.0590373501,
-0.0127047449,
0.0043293992,
0.0575555153,
-0.0115496963,
0.0341759436,
-0.0415196195,
-0.052524481,
-0.0737056136,
-0.0170075875,
-0.0274398886,
0.0129010445,
0.0067837625,
-0.0814790577,
-0.0070657716,
-0.031782683,
0.000820509,
-0.046730984,
-0.0578318723,
-0.0499581993,
0.0290522259,
0.0019379498,
0.0189875793,
0.0597967058,
-0.0051342044,
0.0118408427,
0.0281145852,
-0.0252843853,
0.0273852721,
0.0635574237,
0.0264066234,
-0.0363762341,
0.0216382034,
-0.0127962343,
-0.0526844487,
0.040359959,
-0.0042607444,
0.0622855872,
0.0674915984,
-0.0112258382,
0.0180340651,
0.0215959046,
-0.0009191709,
-0.0318206474,
0.0045643873,
-0.0294706877,
-0.0376084223,
-0.0512983836,
0.0056545213,
-0.0876601189,
-0.0071050636,
0.0079836473,
0.0175599605,
0.0010923254,
-0.0280738473,
-0.0344178602,
-0.0214453042,
-0.0215074476,
0.0121903559,
0.0114040095,
-0.0270463843,
0.0245775245,
0.0129291769,
0.066866219,
-0.0055375397,
0.0361492857,
-0.0276374929,
0.0160694476,
-0.0196914431,
0.0118911425,
0.0060216915,
0.0014886966,
0.0233832281,
-0.0114561301,
-0.0323772691,
-0.0083094407,
0.0277913045,
0.0640767738,
-0.0051686065,
0.0330266096,
0.0054282965,
0.0110377781,
-0.0249957256,
0.0685056672,
-0.0246096738,
-0.038852971,
-0.0191004146,
-0.0205696169,
-0.0057800263,
0.0263245013,
0.0469328649,
-0.0426342972,
0.0066285431,
-0.0443087071,
0.0089102602,
0.0112930518,
0.0133254789,
-0.018457979,
-0.0144730359,
-0.0107788574,
0.0060597574,
-0.0104363197,
-0.0555663221,
-0.0131426761,
-0.0309649613,
-0.0103679951,
-0.0295832511,
0.0531246141,
0.0001378783,
-0.0262202229,
0.0481196456,
-0.0195051301,
-0.0695589706,
-0.0353353694,
-0.0492966995,
0.0325177796,
-5.406487535e-33,
-0.0417029932,
-0.001209015,
0.0136377225,
0.0029939532,
-0.0557682291,
-0.0251716804,
-0.047637742,
0.012504003,
0.0150202606,
0.0019438406,
-0.010365935,
0.0520479567,
-0.0222845301,
0.0056525948,
0.0166967306,
0.0310281888,
0.0628552064,
-0.034448646,
-0.0311558023,
0.0447901748,
0.0505317412,
0.05311241,
-0.0685309619,
-0.0758114904,
-0.043788068,
-0.0024501206,
-0.0074687544,
-0.0449314155,
0.0186925735,
-0.0118271485,
-0.0193972308,
0.0265531093,
-0.0256312005,
0.0324616693,
-0.0145620955,
0.0214351937,
-0.0235614646,
-0.0643611103,
-0.0368662477,
-0.0060654413,
-0.0491883978,
-0.0176360905,
0.004595113,
0.0124515006,
-0.0569382198,
0.0076001119,
0.039765235,
-0.0341194533,
-0.034188319,
-0.058928322,
-0.0083917696,
0.0173235759,
0.0098779835,
-0.0546845831,
0.0756076202,
0.0415451527,
-0.008255762,
0.0021753546,
-0.0154858679,
0.0354771353,
-0.0542479455,
0.0180176012,
0.0688340217,
0.0193779208,
0.0294726007,
0.0324659534,
0.0663122088,
-0.0480749048,
0.0185355004,
0.0558836944,
-0.0214736871,
0.0702184662,
0.0398898348,
-0.0899802223,
0.0421312265,
-0.0450971723,
0.0165028851,
0.0231809076,
-0.0173469633,
-0.0493566021,
-0.0069834739,
0.0380111001,
-0.0492803007,
0.019214306,
-0.0491680428,
-0.042451065,
-0.038050469,
-0.0734239146,
0.0327141322,
0.011711115,
0.0003339671,
0.0033969642,
-0.0204705652,
-0.0046553514,
0.050790675,
-0.0244361889,
-0.0352439359,
-0.0091740759,
0.0422977954,
-0.0456222706,
-0.0029860139,
-0.0343685485,
0.0952021778,
0.0124403778,
0.0240641311,
0.0040779193,
-0.0194054414,
0.0772761703,
-0.0267956909,
-0.0247287564,
-0.000515734,
0.0391348749,
0.0391952842,
-0.0463407822,
0.0344322175,
0.0079049328,
-0.0186083037,
0.0404900238,
0.0106611047,
0.042517107,
-0.0144258859,
0.0002223082,
-0.0332793929,
-0.042202048,
-0.0218763482,
0.0288811624,
-0.0158537887,
-0.0503029227,
0.0577650815,
-0.0438280776,
-0.0583266951,
0.0031909212,
2.879e-7,
-0.0526049025,
-0.0103007061,
0.0000381726,
0.0083881086,
0.0330501311,
0.028751269,
-0.0813906789,
0.0181679782,
-0.0262724217,
-0.0198233314,
0.0319609381,
-0.0271334462,
0.0836405009,
0.0214798301,
-0.037542697,
-0.0265209898,
-0.0393368341,
0.0240120832,
-0.0285257585,
0.0259481352,
0.0008023022,
0.0389582291,
0.0408037305,
-0.0483478345,
0.0191039089,
-0.0039443895,
0.0499729924,
-0.0036494094,
0.0240908489,
-0.0853718147,
-0.0029278896,
-0.007541487,
-0.0013586761,
-0.0280341562,
-0.0444740504,
0.029194029,
0.0537434258,
0.0290127248,
-0.0087268082,
-0.0216041431,
0.0316396579,
0.0647471398,
0.0149283959,
0.0469352752,
0.0057652299,
0.0295602046,
-0.0142902974,
-0.0250720866,
-0.0668033436,
0.0305515807,
-0.0346704237,
0.0021936835,
0.0032795605,
-0.0333015062,
0.0121610481,
0.0006314546,
0.0531167649,
-0.0200067721,
-0.0117107797,
-0.0206636507,
-0.059510909,
-0.0334369875,
0.0086479681,
0.0303990915,
-0.0113121187,
-0.0204462539,
-0.0346051827,
2.231317178e-34,
0.04440099,
-0.0860101879,
0.0022976901,
0.0033113584,
0.0048779994,
-0.0066410503,
-0.0217824746,
0.0197920091,
0.0143654663,
-0.0145265535,
-0.0778343976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07673v1
|
An Empirical Study on the Robustness of Massively Multilingual Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-05-13T12:01:54 | 2024-05-13T12:01:54 |
Supryadi, Leiyu Pan, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Massively multilingual neural machine translation (MMNMT) has been proven to
enhance the translation quality of low-resource languages. In this paper, we
empirically investigate the translation robustness of Indonesian-Chinese
translation in the face of various naturally occurring noise. To assess this,
we create a robustness evaluation benchmark dataset for Indonesian-Chinese
translation. This dataset is automatically translated into Chinese using four
NLLB-200 models of different sizes. We conduct both automatic and human
evaluations. Our in-depth analysis reveal the correlations between translation
error types and the types of noise present, how these correlations change
across different model sizes, and the relationships between automatic
evaluation indicators and human evaluation indicators. The dataset is publicly
available at https://github.com/tjunlp-lab/ID-ZH-MTRobustEval.
|
[
0.0169536006,
0.0544014275,
-0.0023761031,
0.0596065819,
-0.0144541617,
0.0134905595,
0.0263586305,
0.0049580783,
-0.0426874943,
-0.0029576567,
-0.0632552281,
-0.0719823688,
0.0504902564,
-0.0386916064,
0.0583018474,
-0.0492050387,
0.0196817815,
-0.0295163002,
-0.0208634175,
0.0175154954,
-0.0131928818,
-0.0061349156,
0.0396578535,
0.0337660611,
-0.0121773453,
-0.0121713728,
0.0253237393,
0.0635420829,
0.0434380956,
-0.0412458777,
-0.0116298506,
0.0281535815,
-0.020601403,
0.0918303281,
0.0000020407,
-0.0249314848,
0.0037063975,
0.0379879586,
0.0002184928,
0.05369756,
0.0607694462,
-0.0604685545,
-0.0443284102,
-0.0026294268,
0.0188779142,
-0.00887632,
0.0461410657,
0.0321082585,
0.0699221566,
0.0741145313,
-0.005251775,
-0.0338842794,
0.0146216238,
-0.0449088886,
-0.0346456841,
-0.0445275232,
-0.012956379,
0.0053352998,
-0.0475728698,
-0.0023311726,
-0.0059432364,
0.0451037213,
0.0161048695,
-0.0109777348,
-0.0428466201,
-0.0229269676,
-0.0143134687,
-0.0466533601,
-0.0069090677,
0.0985243022,
-0.0606927685,
0.025964113,
-0.0474366434,
-0.017000014,
0.0078981128,
-0.0362257101,
-0.0269050375,
0.0250640977,
0.0064462814,
-0.0031807835,
-0.0182274897,
0.0385452248,
0.0656084642,
-0.0085080331,
-0.0152024161,
-0.0131932972,
0.0211411193,
-0.0459828824,
-0.0118337637,
0.0049500396,
-0.0115302503,
0.0066236309,
0.0331402235,
-0.0023343624,
-0.02457067,
0.0239740163,
-0.0451058857,
-0.0473879986,
0.0179729722,
-0.1098079979,
0.0561463833,
0.0360526256,
-0.024227662,
0.0419589691,
-0.0170160234,
0.0480520688,
-0.0572651625,
0.0191528555,
-0.0406147018,
-0.0163501352,
0.008451635,
0.0388936326,
-0.0120576173,
0.0162246414,
-0.021422185,
-0.0035159297,
-0.0481119491,
0.0014849894,
-0.0069682021,
0.0053528114,
0.0180117562,
-0.0214779992,
-0.0589468665,
-0.0418072753,
0.0184337627,
0.0318096839,
0.004037397,
-0.0188299958,
0.0062289359,
-0.0408647694,
0.0132542085,
0.0271096099,
-0.032168746,
-0.0413844176,
-0.0069937836,
0.1137611121,
-0.0107372915,
-0.0088745207,
-0.056866128,
-0.0013191032,
-0.0157967173,
-0.0275346879,
-0.0016718255,
-0.0303888842,
0.042762626,
-0.0127916299,
0.0269695558,
-0.0528995581,
0.0015744169,
-0.002641395,
-0.0178683251,
0.0538165532,
-0.0152366487,
-0.012186992,
0.0189134441,
0.0033157596,
0.0063168835,
0.0526833236,
0.0726541355,
0.0068900138,
0.0582505278,
-0.0016966515,
-0.0297997538,
0.0499546714,
-0.0073065641,
0.0333444402,
-0.0343092754,
0.0003929744,
0.0078642843,
0.039028652,
0.0031718218,
0.0915115327,
-0.0310118422,
0.0221221708,
0.0876026377,
0.0151364254,
0.0182345863,
0.0596760176,
0.0393811576,
-0.0154774114,
-0.000440439,
-0.0033090399,
-0.0290842913,
0.0255133566,
-0.0576727204,
0.0183669571,
0.0503821746,
0.0536665358,
-0.0091094524,
-0.070450075,
-0.0204589721,
-0.0124034565,
0.009381854,
-0.0331285112,
0.0245681871,
-0.0234298818,
-0.0485147871,
0.0190346558,
-0.0134516107,
-0.038622763,
0.0205753576,
-0.0450391285,
-0.0409117453,
0.0528548621,
0.0347720347,
0.0225204062,
-0.0290072691,
-0.0224010777,
-0.0184973273,
0.0608812012,
0.0565950647,
0.0188660398,
0.0441124327,
-0.0432558618,
-0.0032448294,
0.0383763313,
0.0132630533,
0.0502514429,
0.0065043173,
0.0356536284,
0.0428631231,
-0.0232470874,
-0.1207315028,
0.0230911225,
-0.0236766506,
-0.0256631356,
0.0332733244,
0.0085440679,
0.0401813313,
0.0335379206,
-0.0453452915,
-0.0131323375,
-0.0109503306,
-0.0178804845,
-0.0090285921,
0.0274940971,
-0.0345493145,
-0.0000607725,
0.0363901556,
-0.0109232459,
-0.0454611182,
0.0057222219,
-0.0373010524,
-0.0335973091,
0.0003950518,
-0.0189776365,
-0.0443817563,
-0.0562105328,
0.0478635766,
-0.0312507749,
0.0202234853,
-0.0318557397,
0.0270196423,
0.0109480545,
-0.0017747845,
0.0030058159,
0.0105899135,
0.0393159427,
-0.0379307643,
-0.0773259699,
0.0337995812,
0.01248948,
0.0595094077,
0.0105055552,
0.031606786,
0.0001996998,
-0.0388720296,
-0.0267936643,
-0.0114199016,
-0.0271222591,
0.0147673776,
0.0326809511,
0.0165353343,
0.013451797,
0.0046695806,
0.0133399451,
0.021212399,
-0.0037673882,
-0.005440976,
0.0199278258,
-0.0116533237,
0.0110345874,
-0.0222649891,
-0.0107566882,
0.0343280844,
0.0430205502,
0.0411841013,
-0.0542984046,
-0.0889644399,
0.0162175242,
-0.013743354,
-0.0218353029,
0.0072988295,
-0.0983780697,
-0.002134904,
-0.0148557769,
-0.0026209163,
0.0503761582,
-0.0116790663,
0.0016584654,
0.0321775489,
0.0114960354,
-0.0199557487,
0.0118903648,
0.0245036334,
-0.0258762371,
-0.024292253,
-0.0408952348,
0.01184256,
0.0397000946,
0.0024064302,
-0.012009494,
-0.0300878435,
-0.0136514781,
-0.0389268734,
-0.0297129638,
-0.0051052519,
0.0258009955,
-0.0100123137,
0.0449027941,
-0.0049668886,
-0.0429354161,
0.0677490458,
-0.029701516,
-0.0163929928,
-0.016591236,
0.0084146401,
-0.0153750414,
0.0360190831,
-0.0559184588,
0.0199064277,
-0.008386747,
-0.0259416308,
-0.0303065293,
-0.028928563,
0.0254765283,
-0.011460226,
0.0325861983,
-0.0729793385,
0.0003135024,
-0.0303622875,
0.0127179949,
-0.0013262905,
-0.0074525932,
0.0068571116,
0.0005735829,
0.037188489,
-0.0270182751,
-0.0170649178,
0.0347917341,
0.018521538,
0.0257229246,
-0.0109519456,
0.0056653656,
0.0107955737,
0.0117901443,
-0.031761039,
-0.0082740821,
0.0615412183,
-0.0775667801,
0.0390543789,
0.0062120832,
-0.0449345447,
0.010003983,
-0.0482326634,
-0.0305697657,
0.0238148868,
0.0140229063,
-0.0291871987,
0.0129255159,
0.0600379296,
-0.0510901436,
0.0152049968,
0.0915137231,
0.0069081122,
-0.0318965912,
-0.0033615441,
-0.0051598665,
0.0304048564,
-0.0195238814,
0.0203677826,
-0.0325637683,
-0.0140125705,
0.0098775709,
0.0449348353,
0.0337468907,
0.0145704513,
-0.003849759,
-0.0935750455,
0.0251655541,
0.0582807362,
-0.0778493732,
-0.0788439438,
0.0029062731,
-0.0312538259,
-0.0501326211,
0.0951271206,
-0.0133971106,
0.0293639917,
-0.0303374939,
0.017887393,
0.0195260178,
-0.0965697169,
-0.0171609242,
-0.0565891415,
0.0442901924,
0.0455594324,
0.0271091275,
-0.0287634805,
-0.0006871012,
0.0514609739,
0.0257472806,
-0.003130218,
0.0231653247,
0.022611253,
0.0338444747,
-0.0398357846,
0.0037095014,
-0.0209967718,
-0.0179265346,
0.0599692427,
0.02629916,
0.0315987468,
-0.0065266849,
-0.0021521016,
0.0171311684,
-0.0215342082,
-0.0012967001,
0.0395941064,
0.0234625693,
-0.0439688861,
-0.0101831174,
-0.0363481082,
-0.035442654,
-0.0735328421,
-0.0133021222,
0.0235569887,
-0.0699293688,
-0.0198711418,
-0.0983457267,
-0.0778888986,
-0.0364584103,
0.0393231176,
0.0208155587,
-0.0166458301,
0.0346175358,
0.0250262972,
0.0115571115,
0.0068815327,
-0.0038471124,
0.0226213988,
-0.0776334554,
0.0413076207,
0.0310925636,
0.0071879611,
0.0271877255,
0.0427558348,
-0.0792954564,
-0.0711940601,
-0.014157637,
0.0539500676,
0.0145119792,
0.0289016999,
-0.03855386,
-0.0623008497,
-0.0003212505,
0.0360834822,
-0.0030553774,
-0.0310907941,
0.0528797209,
0.0035976176,
-0.0154949632,
0.0448817164,
-0.020843599,
-0.0064895675,
0.0074950475,
0.0447360985,
-0.0155786909,
-0.0578743964,
0.0053730165,
0.0514980666,
-0.0180057939,
-0.0475987494,
-0.0187132731,
-0.0266013071,
0.0129474495,
-0.0213132892,
-0.0358552337,
-0.059238147,
-0.0123763019,
0.073998481,
-0.0001696035,
-0.0014569884,
0.0152758369,
0.0284910928,
-0.009846352,
0.0076379124,
-0.0051771747,
-0.0624661371,
0.0468620546,
0.0029103921,
0.0230544526,
-0.0371466912,
0.0155122345,
-0.0206761565,
0.0079043461,
-0.0098098787,
0.0415796861,
-0.0104509778,
0.0200878009,
0.0030580733,
0.0337329656,
-0.0331687331,
-0.017331196,
-0.0311698634,
0.0156210074,
0.0842127353,
0.0316422619,
0.103517428,
-0.0140147693,
-0.0210160911,
-0.0360688083,
0.0387369208,
0.0153751895,
0.0191295352,
-0.0010830181,
-0.0041502756,
0.0045303032,
0.0182593744,
0.0674371719,
-0.010715818,
-0.0235364381,
-0.0048301145,
0.0049906475,
-0.0211175382,
0.0045060166,
0.0042453608,
-0.0205509122,
-0.0323591605,
-0.0059218649,
-0.0193973929,
-0.0678299442,
-0.0035736528,
0.0319019444,
0.0325437002,
0.0053061405,
-0.040386308,
0.0722274482,
-0.010542606,
0.0686876103,
-0.0358762555,
-0.0199311208,
0.0226463601,
0.0258099232,
-0.039895691,
-6.206223729e-33,
-0.0255055893,
-0.0048690909,
-0.0130995698,
-0.0578605309,
-0.0144825699,
-0.0232576542,
-0.0207810197,
-0.0116274105,
-0.0269750748,
0.0070160413,
-0.0059254654,
0.0088243941,
0.0231421944,
0.0124789439,
0.0191572867,
-0.0019316045,
0.0426694117,
0.0026084159,
-0.0032317112,
-0.0023025705,
0.007527519,
0.024606755,
0.0791209638,
-0.0801289976,
0.0711264312,
-0.0002978435,
-0.0166641511,
0.0035906802,
-0.0118935574,
0.0453818925,
-0.0035619764,
0.0235236902,
0.002101975,
-0.0026531904,
-0.0313468687,
-0.0852300599,
-0.0667720214,
-0.0101464484,
-0.0023467997,
0.058333423,
-0.0082557127,
-0.0212649759,
0.0552240722,
-0.0420893393,
-0.0268852431,
-0.0276272316,
-0.0001865823,
-0.0540139936,
-0.0413222723,
-0.0092730746,
-0.0243357439,
0.0432814248,
-0.0005967271,
0.0086080907,
0.00794286,
0.027197523,
-0.0542068556,
0.0110893538,
-0.094686076,
-0.0260051358,
-0.0078098415,
0.0341208428,
0.0582089387,
0.0373280905,
-0.0089296587,
-0.0201711915,
0.0200808719,
0.0313392654,
0.0562353581,
0.0163141154,
0.0230630618,
-0.0194438789,
0.0949068442,
0.0844055489,
0.0423106886,
-0.0024613882,
-0.0701495111,
0.0307422001,
0.0041616382,
-0.0167876575,
0.032616742,
0.008469793,
-0.0196549352,
-0.0178952925,
-0.0204376169,
-0.0799073279,
-0.0342532545,
-0.0300424658,
-0.0042186622,
0.0041886028,
-0.0240819752,
-0.0285107885,
0.0551232919,
-0.0374091603,
0.0045911125,
0.0026952443,
-0.0023429969,
0.0167507511,
-0.0114531368,
0.0445121191,
0.023307519,
-0.0453612134,
-0.0296395123,
0.0513979532,
0.005121184,
-0.0495008938,
0.0547614731,
0.0309183747,
-0.0250378624,
0.0230612922,
-0.0201537963,
-0.0247997846,
0.0236310605,
0.027166035,
0.0075142221,
-0.0508521311,
0.0006062566,
0.0449620746,
0.0294055399,
0.0294082332,
-0.0049806256,
0.0066618007,
0.0097522093,
0.0189300552,
-0.0408608802,
0.0157313682,
-0.0256041009,
0.0009802665,
0.0449829698,
-0.049555447,
-0.0249894783,
0.0011811446,
2.741e-7,
0.0326586664,
0.0563005544,
0.0155387493,
0.0348352641,
-0.0030191361,
0.0240108874,
-0.0701149926,
0.0078329379,
-0.0241024736,
0.0657870695,
0.0299577117,
-0.0048082103,
0.0976417139,
0.052102685,
-0.0568107478,
-0.0660074726,
-0.0515730008,
0.0427116007,
-0.0291902963,
0.0006535486,
0.0460130647,
0.0936097801,
-0.037262477,
0.0141768893,
0.0044424036,
-0.0568702333,
0.0568650663,
-0.0042132931,
-0.0155444182,
0.0061120796,
0.0674544871,
0.0227606148,
-0.0270328987,
-0.0296299942,
-0.0238591582,
-0.0041279951,
0.0514614098,
0.0821361765,
0.0176479928,
-0.0116608981,
0.0271859448,
-0.0196769964,
-0.0120326336,
-0.0385848358,
0.0346675143,
-0.0341303982,
-0.0321816131,
0.0379124172,
-0.0207464118,
-0.0026025868,
0.0554581285,
-0.0635482445,
-0.0258361902,
0.0053334706,
0.0462140068,
-0.0260620173,
-0.0183538087,
-0.0219061058,
-0.0309919547,
-0.0048124925,
-0.0021135809,
-0.0529573262,
0.00574678,
-0.0150865335,
0.0247404575,
-0.0069485307,
0.0030268035,
1.907182531e-34,
0.0760587826,
-0.021751957,
0.0440680981,
-0.0329630338,
0.03040158,
-0.0145855276,
-0.0225966871,
-0.0357565358,
-0.0183915664,
-0.0333162621,
-0.0216921214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07671v1
|
Constructing a BPE Tokenization DFA
| 2024-05-13T11:59:24 | 2024-05-13T11:59:24 |
Martin Berglund, Willeke Martens, Brink van der Merwe
|
cs.FL
|
cs.FL, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Many natural language processing systems operate over tokenizations of text
to address the open-vocabulary problem. In this paper, we give and analyze an
algorithm for the efficient construction of deterministic finite automata
designed to operate directly on tokenizations produced by the popular byte pair
encoding technique. This makes it possible to apply many existing techniques
and algorithms to the tokenized case, such as pattern matching, equivalence
checking of tokenization dictionaries, and composing tokenized languages in
various ways.
|
[
0.0136070438,
0.0612255782,
-0.0282601472,
0.0342334099,
-0.0391392149,
-0.0007303359,
0.0022892545,
0.0499369577,
-0.0388238281,
-0.067885153,
0.0420046374,
-0.0072256099,
-0.014815188,
0.0862561613,
-0.0146941394,
-0.0301666148,
0.0455724522,
-0.012196904,
0.0126559669,
-0.0157589819,
0.0084620798,
0.0383017994,
-0.0039810874,
0.0293497946,
-0.0322795585,
-0.0151539585,
-0.0241672564,
-0.0208875127,
-0.0413330421,
-0.0179900527,
-0.0593745783,
-0.0005434267,
-0.0022983479,
-0.0049400381,
0.0000018804,
-0.071041435,
-0.0693970546,
0.0182482544,
-0.0020292804,
0.0150453178,
0.0399984457,
0.0004422027,
0.0052635483,
0.004326886,
0.0049320129,
-0.0730618685,
0.0842274874,
0.0256321505,
0.0874399096,
0.0277679861,
-0.0139343692,
-0.0324452929,
0.0519552268,
0.0539491437,
-0.0510332957,
0.0039337808,
0.0395754911,
-0.0079170326,
0.0502259322,
-0.0185176395,
-0.0225553885,
-0.0602861419,
-0.0711614937,
0.0061559025,
0.0021512748,
0.0251836982,
-0.0081047863,
-0.0332893804,
-0.0288873594,
0.0286406223,
0.0050875135,
-0.0128638055,
0.0120771583,
0.0277680047,
-0.0486091301,
-0.0003332251,
-0.0002661226,
0.072427325,
-0.0128176706,
0.0588878542,
0.0510429703,
-0.0086894939,
0.0086308466,
-0.0297654271,
-0.0751369894,
0.0964377671,
0.0401896723,
-0.0279627033,
-0.0416734628,
-0.0472024716,
-0.0124991853,
-0.1070947051,
0.0394817069,
0.0034470828,
0.0032732484,
0.0062796921,
-0.0475927107,
-0.0472184755,
0.0181084499,
0.0067222747,
-0.0130080599,
0.0469029881,
-0.0425083265,
-0.0134392614,
-0.0303485058,
0.0245882105,
0.0156261045,
0.0165229142,
-0.0464131311,
-0.0202668309,
-0.0514683574,
0.0156694241,
-0.0920755193,
0.0502910055,
-0.0110222204,
-0.0240355805,
0.0427374095,
0.0466468856,
-0.0152702164,
0.0363009647,
-0.0069183451,
-0.0290044919,
0.0197593179,
0.029192213,
-0.0154184029,
-0.0282678008,
-0.040466819,
-0.0150581589,
-0.0166810267,
-0.0282095522,
0.0287727751,
-0.0123721017,
0.0497183949,
0.0172321554,
-0.031569466,
0.0819567218,
0.0230914745,
-0.0182964262,
-0.0315567143,
-0.0239045508,
0.0407678522,
0.0131992297,
-0.0372815803,
-0.0546718054,
0.0122074997,
0.0119227637,
0.0052128579,
0.0111875953,
0.0272839926,
0.0294066668,
-0.0150365336,
0.0944453478,
-0.0898034051,
-0.0152279837,
0.030924907,
-0.0174786933,
0.0268873144,
0.0254821461,
0.0181131903,
-0.0197488926,
0.0446678028,
0.0096668703,
-0.0033313623,
0.0270705111,
-0.0266519021,
-0.022324644,
-0.0542806424,
0.0211068075,
0.0926621556,
0.0003387696,
0.0302053764,
0.1106659994,
-0.0437022224,
0.0284422319,
-0.0501135811,
0.0905006304,
-0.0067287213,
0.0323651992,
0.0447295159,
0.0325145423,
-0.0020234645,
0.0226680692,
0.0371588059,
-0.0376990512,
0.0765160024,
-0.0206553843,
0.0570463948,
0.0022890619,
0.0017254734,
-0.0347314775,
-0.0368375294,
-0.0245869495,
0.0664059967,
-0.0855351985,
0.0038809143,
0.0140547436,
-0.0435340069,
0.0658868477,
0.0291421395,
-0.0356396772,
0.0001130982,
-0.0712131113,
0.0319447108,
0.0666147619,
0.0453490727,
0.0040135779,
0.0417862944,
-0.033792004,
-0.0079377387,
0.009213767,
-0.0111586079,
-0.0302646141,
-0.0337847658,
-0.0301750563,
-0.0098138945,
-0.0335365273,
0.0226194337,
0.0155730834,
-0.0240966547,
0.0315003991,
-0.0101091051,
-0.0256942026,
-0.0256820899,
0.0470279381,
0.0765134394,
-0.0489795059,
0.0350488052,
0.0141959861,
0.0389148816,
0.0415305793,
-0.0324100703,
0.0540637113,
-0.0039098165,
-0.0266023707,
-0.0101750968,
0.007073292,
0.0364861377,
0.0395436697,
0.0442220792,
-0.0230717845,
0.0085620862,
0.0235308837,
-0.0162237734,
-0.043303661,
0.0160897337,
-0.0485073999,
0.04274223,
-0.0121681672,
0.0156135308,
0.0028920127,
0.0292660519,
-0.0083877621,
0.0140486574,
0.0219012331,
-0.0184056181,
-0.0565087683,
-0.0164966881,
0.0869325027,
-0.0147301964,
-0.0422612838,
0.0187105443,
-0.0308561604,
0.0099861752,
0.0285408664,
0.0024194533,
0.0031500771,
-0.0051763803,
-0.0837951079,
0.012886378,
-0.0191954132,
0.0269600525,
0.0293664187,
0.0552420802,
-0.0163033102,
0.0143956635,
-0.010258479,
-0.0069883368,
0.0224159751,
0.0016371188,
0.0575342365,
0.0067204661,
-0.0887161046,
0.0267515797,
-0.0127449278,
-0.0287383329,
0.0351732001,
0.0070847212,
-0.0445450097,
-0.0644451454,
0.0037762164,
-0.0138262035,
0.0558610111,
0.0468397029,
-0.0172847547,
0.0629554316,
-0.0269625243,
0.0341270678,
0.0293023139,
0.0285424814,
-0.0232206061,
0.0873812512,
0.0024726333,
0.005386109,
-0.0036915895,
0.0170959719,
0.0048896018,
0.0295800343,
-0.0398706086,
0.0681551546,
-0.0248077139,
-0.0011225279,
-0.0080807228,
0.0164870303,
-0.0316941924,
-0.0150864916,
0.015714379,
-0.0343169868,
-0.0946535915,
-0.0294924583,
0.0370102637,
0.0080567598,
-0.0154069643,
0.0349036567,
-0.0607083775,
0.0497156531,
-0.0715086758,
0.0213771146,
-0.0069342805,
0.0580088459,
-0.0303533133,
0.0529565066,
-0.0259212907,
-0.0651698858,
0.0018974751,
-0.0231977031,
0.0024425411,
-0.0090458458,
0.0146855777,
-0.028062297,
0.0188076161,
0.0011724803,
-0.0022534195,
-0.0725741163,
0.0356865115,
-0.0479996204,
0.0229335371,
0.0385286622,
0.0061885579,
-0.0236188751,
0.0455641523,
-0.0215801429,
0.0198637582,
0.0371229239,
0.0193788484,
-0.0182828214,
0.027639566,
-0.0231286101,
-0.012088079,
-0.0667441189,
0.0338083915,
-0.0203502681,
0.0142065706,
0.0429703854,
0.0182908121,
-0.0100515038,
-0.026557982,
0.0199645236,
-0.1008535773,
0.0136215361,
0.0165913403,
-0.006215442,
0.0257974528,
-0.0339857973,
0.1078107581,
0.0514938124,
-0.0158806387,
0.0242061224,
-0.0289838593,
-0.0827073902,
-0.0098511642,
0.0365285873,
-0.1142861173,
-0.0079136612,
0.0055946149,
-0.0062259315,
0.0119725065,
0.0203241687,
-0.0216322243,
-0.0901429951,
-0.0059057176,
-0.0085604731,
-0.0030369821,
-0.0084043974,
-0.0405983627,
-0.0083966861,
0.0025900549,
0.0013092448,
0.0198031142,
0.0665678456,
-0.0042622914,
0.0069792736,
0.0212179366,
0.0323036537,
0.0199944861,
-0.0482531898,
0.04920353,
0.070836924,
0.0623975508,
-0.0079306327,
-0.0165562592,
0.025271846,
0.0083772521,
-0.0160142519,
0.0055747121,
-0.0194598883,
-0.0222757477,
-0.006716751,
0.0461436622,
0.0372917391,
0.0123648252,
-0.0186459143,
0.0051299213,
0.014134326,
0.030105846,
0.0135786021,
-0.0216414928,
-0.0312832035,
0.0313092694,
0.0074476851,
0.0095186112,
0.0088946307,
-0.0207426287,
-0.0325182565,
-0.0071201622,
-0.0658776313,
0.0067224507,
-0.0715831146,
-0.0192566589,
-0.053693153,
-0.0826030374,
0.0706741661,
-0.0058241202,
0.0157891493,
-0.0056473315,
-0.0070033949,
0.0222797114,
0.0042570569,
-0.0578690283,
-0.0481725633,
-0.0098531935,
0.0249039605,
-0.0611004084,
-0.0521824844,
-0.0117972037,
0.0124668023,
-0.0502136983,
0.017659368,
-0.0031345759,
-0.0083327787,
0.0504567996,
0.0206928775,
0.0136946691,
-0.0016361019,
-0.025568489,
0.0064042062,
0.0311500151,
0.0614846312,
-0.0314819887,
-0.0099907182,
-0.0101846699,
0.0453047417,
0.0130995009,
-0.0093222568,
-0.0085922806,
-0.0085015185,
-0.0445734449,
-0.0077896011,
0.0322060548,
-0.033161737,
0.05419375,
0.0923489109,
0.0252788346,
-0.0129668275,
0.0351356193,
0.0044701686,
-0.0023126027,
-0.0339007787,
-0.0271089189,
-0.0186741371,
0.0387395099,
-0.0289628673,
-0.0274563264,
0.0030091519,
-0.0490775704,
-0.0652153194,
0.0181164518,
0.0831946209,
0.0362578556,
0.0266708974,
0.058623977,
0.0089344233,
-0.0221417043,
-0.0057317852,
-0.0275525805,
-0.0071889441,
-0.0144405328,
-0.0617768429,
-0.0201697499,
0.0086233346,
0.0124549437,
-0.0530395471,
0.0196816586,
-0.0011608007,
-0.0163778849,
0.0104291188,
0.0386387147,
-0.0157996155,
0.0083487509,
-0.0177420545,
-0.0577227846,
-0.0042337719,
0.0218624026,
0.0047625932,
-0.0147676598,
-0.0175008681,
0.0142620774,
0.0099541945,
0.0040142327,
-0.0611715056,
0.0407126509,
-0.0522730649,
0.0228326637,
-0.0148290582,
-0.0239420384,
-0.0496574678,
0.00804877,
-0.0007991118,
0.0635760427,
-0.0324721821,
-0.026623968,
-0.0034965943,
-0.0196779929,
0.024193693,
0.0450568274,
0.0466796383,
0.048766613,
0.0448588282,
0.0184282213,
0.052792687,
-0.0093022417,
-0.0143417148,
0.0050265342,
0.0159152225,
-0.057761658,
-0.0123820221,
-5.444951546e-33,
-0.0008087464,
-0.0039462168,
-0.0406667404,
-0.0254159551,
0.0064247549,
0.0087753395,
-0.015298943,
-0.025923986,
0.0383417048,
-0.0164760016,
-0.005130013,
0.0054335375,
0.0275239125,
-0.0013729542,
-0.0359051414,
0.0111614149,
0.0385155343,
-0.0373348407,
-0.0377797745,
-0.0056353062,
0.0815844908,
-0.0310555119,
-0.0205619037,
-0.0118863024,
0.0233988576,
-0.0450529307,
-0.0652424693,
0.0047587347,
0.0303248223,
0.0326887183,
-0.0260051284,
0.0267782286,
-0.0125979707,
0.0596505776,
-0.0161939226,
0.0648669824,
-0.054312326,
-0.0422991179,
0.0358811989,
0.0085773701,
0.022810623,
-0.0290641338,
0.0169015005,
-0.0205776319,
-0.0163676552,
0.0681492388,
-0.0119416118,
0.0062161353,
0.0077563077,
0.0164185222,
-0.0681376085,
-0.0031815469,
0.0059840088,
0.03003712,
0.0411436968,
-0.069505699,
0.0192924533,
-0.061333321,
-0.0026149757,
0.0523884259,
0.0305320974,
0.011319709,
0.0134508666,
-0.048666425,
0.0041497545,
0.0319842435,
0.0215266794,
-0.0454042666,
-0.013686819,
0.0598984063,
-0.0270416439,
-0.0012882598,
-0.036813695,
0.0423203781,
0.0636799708,
-0.0629115775,
-0.0422065929,
0.039323125,
-0.0070137521,
0.0095115518,
-0.0124964006,
0.0195822064,
-0.0157150179,
-0.0217528939,
-0.0563492477,
0.039520815,
-0.0363357328,
-0.0031433979,
0.0034487753,
-0.0194645412,
-0.0927776471,
-0.0260969196,
-0.0149874622,
-0.0501991771,
-0.0165261514,
0.0057974835,
-0.0052004796,
-0.0050853724,
-0.0253713932,
-0.0225383099,
0.0090540107,
-0.0692368597,
0.0164439287,
-0.0235769227,
0.0075915265,
0.0106551787,
-0.0404911861,
0.0175606366,
-0.0760717615,
0.0241042022,
0.0065957643,
-0.0047082212,
-0.0126951085,
0.0173079688,
0.0224536434,
0.0118908985,
0.0232318621,
-0.0450801663,
0.0244155359,
-0.0399853103,
-0.0034868303,
0.0177231152,
-0.0016146032,
0.0328479223,
-0.0351192318,
0.0145348655,
-0.0282792188,
0.0146446498,
0.0462205261,
-0.009271021,
0.00283768,
0.0204931609,
2.709e-7,
0.0197771527,
0.026529327,
0.0877469629,
0.0142039433,
-0.005570347,
-0.0135605894,
-0.0004820996,
0.0391099714,
-0.0467425995,
0.0035348323,
-0.0130517241,
-0.003794983,
-0.060550876,
0.0257533137,
-0.0841379315,
0.0266746674,
0.0175036713,
-0.014441154,
-0.0662518293,
-0.0111002978,
0.0926605389,
0.0346094891,
0.0066189831,
0.0131812692,
-0.0297066588,
-0.0674576461,
-0.0045280335,
0.0226119459,
0.0454244465,
0.0185994599,
-0.0295119639,
-0.0028054984,
0.0331156403,
0.0064503602,
-0.0071832384,
0.0252363924,
0.0082690129,
0.0052766819,
0.0132567622,
0.0560327843,
-0.0001360479,
-0.0284037888,
-0.0073181032,
0.0091633489,
0.0463894606,
0.0155856833,
-0.0283741839,
-0.044646211,
-0.0379379876,
0.0306623802,
-0.0633084401,
-0.0060012336,
-0.0281361435,
0.0703289583,
0.0024784259,
0.040218439,
0.0271605924,
-0.0430971012,
-0.0141708553,
-0.0667885616,
-0.0044052792,
-0.0221813656,
0.0055165575,
0.0323275104,
0.0551816262,
-0.0374246351,
0.0151571343,
2.38580262e-34,
0.0120816138,
-0.0208813902,
-0.03432725,
0.0176225249,
0.0044673919,
-0.0082895048,
-0.0056545539,
0.0248129349,
0.0066043045,
-0.0063091074,
-0.0255631413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07667v1
|
Backdoor Removal for Generative Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T11:53:42 | 2024-05-13T11:53:42 |
Haoran Li, Yulin Chen, Zihao Zheng, Qi Hu, Chunkit Chan, Heshan Liu, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
With rapid advances, generative large language models (LLMs) dominate various
Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks from understanding to reasoning. Yet,
language models' inherent vulnerabilities may be exacerbated due to increased
accessibility and unrestricted model training on massive textual data from the
Internet. A malicious adversary may publish poisoned data online and conduct
backdoor attacks on the victim LLMs pre-trained on the poisoned data.
Backdoored LLMs behave innocuously for normal queries and generate harmful
responses when the backdoor trigger is activated. Despite significant efforts
paid to LLMs' safety issues, LLMs are still struggling against backdoor
attacks. As Anthropic recently revealed, existing safety training strategies,
including supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human
Feedback (RLHF), fail to revoke the backdoors once the LLM is backdoored during
the pre-training stage. In this paper, we present Simulate and Eliminate
(SANDE) to erase the undesired backdoored mappings for generative LLMs. We
initially propose Overwrite Supervised Fine-tuning (OSFT) for effective
backdoor removal when the trigger is known. Then, to handle the scenarios where
the trigger patterns are unknown, we integrate OSFT into our two-stage
framework, SANDE. Unlike previous works that center on the identification of
backdoors, our safety-enhanced LLMs are able to behave normally even when the
exact triggers are activated. We conduct comprehensive experiments to show that
our proposed SANDE is effective against backdoor attacks while bringing minimal
harm to LLMs' powerful capability without any additional access to unbackdoored
clean models. We will release the reproducible code.
|
[
0.0567594431,
0.0771304369,
-0.0078462614,
0.0295771156,
-0.0416209958,
-0.0040754592,
-0.0150262797,
-0.0090612099,
0.0369940847,
-0.0491708107,
-0.0093609067,
0.0002594064,
-0.0148990555,
0.0448684357,
0.0620083325,
0.031380605,
0.0670694709,
-0.054103598,
-0.0352827869,
-0.001341212,
-0.0370162688,
-0.0036449707,
0.024828421,
0.0093849488,
0.0208758358,
-0.0174535513,
-0.0164641682,
-0.0030131538,
0.0333172716,
-0.019173231,
-0.0032587324,
0.0435665138,
0.0044324114,
0.0596747771,
0.0000020584,
-0.0419996157,
-0.0364416279,
0.0214139838,
-0.0032300872,
0.032268893,
0.0080333371,
-0.0157682132,
-0.0460338965,
0.0421628319,
-0.045251552,
-0.0204027947,
0.0071512689,
0.072958827,
0.0815686807,
0.104173407,
0.001651736,
-0.0505421087,
0.0804107338,
-0.0395750701,
0.0084487023,
-0.0523404703,
0.0514865778,
-0.038283091,
-0.0262376517,
-0.0079913158,
-0.0182227399,
0.0154775595,
-0.0114616174,
-0.0066091875,
-0.0274669509,
0.0436641276,
-0.0140754357,
-0.0243604742,
-0.0208079331,
0.0665541068,
-0.0354335904,
-0.005179564,
0.0181381349,
-0.0090900818,
-0.0043276139,
0.0226591453,
0.0157891847,
0.0339375399,
-0.0005704029,
0.0254791714,
0.0104309544,
-0.062063314,
0.0506122634,
0.04031175,
0.0069096098,
0.0423250981,
0.0188092608,
-0.0263829287,
-0.0020094372,
-0.0517953895,
-0.0136962626,
-0.050185509,
-0.0073690778,
0.0049396348,
-0.0086824158,
0.0294745825,
-0.0343303457,
-0.0174186677,
0.03634068,
-0.0460243039,
-0.0045593646,
0.0134797357,
0.0046644397,
0.0384747237,
-0.0410756953,
0.0203719642,
-0.0401104651,
0.045324374,
0.0329731666,
0.0193230715,
-0.0359116793,
-0.0150078386,
-0.0312055666,
0.003900632,
-0.0372953936,
-0.0144705735,
-0.0340278484,
0.0148622748,
-0.0169075411,
0.0208452046,
0.0026990231,
0.0253675729,
-0.030646449,
0.0049052606,
0.0006231582,
-0.0222052988,
0.0022743128,
-0.007648977,
-0.0101361005,
-0.0837547407,
-0.0177004039,
-0.0043560597,
-0.0230081677,
-0.0178626534,
0.0015335893,
0.0832480043,
0.024292158,
-0.0162240826,
-0.0923060626,
-0.0635973439,
-0.0169808306,
-0.0410848521,
0.0061487006,
-0.05937903,
-0.0260157324,
-0.0440058373,
0.0008559127,
-0.0284957401,
0.0145549607,
0.0232384801,
-0.0471161008,
0.0846905187,
-0.0046492401,
-0.0071656206,
0.0171707217,
0.0043435576,
0.0077723754,
0.0525272489,
0.0056478661,
0.0388689041,
0.0368268676,
-0.0255245846,
0.0311184917,
0.0383531004,
0.0155248716,
0.0263861809,
-0.0506119765,
0.0067207324,
0.0121067427,
-0.0068848161,
-0.0028681962,
0.0574761704,
-0.0318459421,
-0.0092357006,
0.0778604001,
0.021668287,
-0.0107123498,
0.0493974872,
0.0087437248,
0.0090315016,
-0.0488561429,
-0.0027437629,
-0.0773070976,
-0.0248077959,
-0.0831022859,
-0.0203051548,
0.0100872647,
0.0316734686,
0.0036739071,
-0.0168284662,
-0.0025765139,
0.0041322974,
0.0179830398,
-0.0038658513,
0.0459468588,
0.0679343641,
-0.011891243,
-0.011887568,
0.0169073232,
-0.0249668676,
-0.0078894719,
-0.0647402853,
-0.0360520482,
0.0786426589,
0.0915221944,
0.0175035112,
0.0098197274,
-0.0612955764,
-0.0341881551,
0.0178535413,
-0.0103406683,
0.0239183847,
0.0018952626,
-0.0394559838,
-0.0234258454,
0.031569086,
0.0281445049,
-0.0037791997,
0.0348447971,
-0.0256542377,
0.0104355868,
0.0148607213,
-0.0285840705,
0.0415928327,
-0.0107085537,
-0.0868242681,
0.0209439807,
0.0160751455,
0.030558832,
-0.023794964,
-0.0152260894,
0.026963735,
0.0359849185,
0.0148356948,
-0.037941657,
-0.0358153135,
-0.0041958406,
0.0172628351,
0.0272655133,
-0.011721665,
-0.0093741165,
0.0580734424,
-0.0395701863,
-0.0244525596,
0.0184701588,
-0.0365637466,
0.0187074933,
-0.0402801819,
0.0047583296,
0.0088647883,
0.0058853743,
-0.0297969319,
0.0584543273,
-0.0050412905,
-0.0115282256,
-0.0360218398,
-0.0029849957,
0.0107182628,
-0.0131519139,
-0.0451701321,
0.0172861964,
-0.0323132649,
0.0277066119,
-0.0095597878,
-0.0006668012,
-0.0517975986,
-0.01498775,
-0.0263827853,
0.0228343047,
-0.0199539363,
0.0374167524,
0.0209688544,
-0.0013520955,
-0.0385203809,
-0.0262972042,
0.0056949421,
-0.0053565442,
0.0002126545,
0.0318771899,
0.005460707,
-0.0114439558,
0.0046822261,
-0.0022087584,
-0.0112767313,
-0.0198949706,
0.0656698942,
-0.0114185344,
0.0220603701,
-0.0537840277,
0.0246206727,
0.0005586583,
0.0680430233,
-0.0170207955,
-0.0567804836,
-0.0040451195,
-0.0018846751,
-0.0090398649,
0.0608236343,
0.0301913694,
-0.0085242679,
0.0746016577,
0.0087669212,
-0.0596396513,
0.0171103328,
-0.0106414799,
-0.0698831305,
-0.0629097447,
0.0323842056,
-0.005375972,
0.0499993749,
0.0253864061,
-0.0286841318,
-0.029239893,
0.0212059747,
0.0114950659,
-0.0205359738,
-0.0276344623,
-0.0535254814,
-0.0509299934,
-0.0022685667,
-0.0218173899,
-0.0755032897,
0.0669277683,
-0.0197233167,
0.0440516807,
-0.0282200109,
-0.0117620984,
-0.0040743197,
0.0477419235,
-0.0158025026,
0.0219227578,
0.048855897,
-0.039811898,
-0.0418920889,
-0.0218371917,
0.0409492031,
-0.0260237828,
0.0052499874,
-0.0159338638,
-0.000077951,
-0.0140411584,
-0.0428159945,
-0.0599706657,
-0.0710877404,
-0.0192022938,
0.0159135871,
0.0222106427,
-0.0238955244,
0.005528565,
-0.0249281656,
0.0058842925,
0.0051395474,
-0.0157374274,
-0.0167287365,
-0.0350189656,
0.0062739868,
0.0640798286,
-0.0665361509,
0.0179864597,
0.0024614234,
0.0194056667,
0.0732097775,
0.0459039472,
-0.0095989099,
-0.0414506383,
0.0142267058,
0.0134471348,
-0.0270471331,
-0.001358352,
0.0218823608,
0.0015366178,
-0.0481727198,
-0.0189168677,
0.0669571757,
0.0086169578,
-0.0484420843,
0.0107486742,
0.0441602394,
0.0080412207,
0.0119733661,
0.0164723173,
-0.0680729151,
-0.0269064568,
0.0366226174,
0.0337467939,
-0.0276704356,
-0.0348061658,
0.0064649717,
-0.1723681688,
0.0259071402,
0.0099105639,
-0.02522262,
-0.0020657603,
-0.0611084886,
-0.0133693861,
-0.00710489,
0.0071643442,
0.0038887819,
0.0007983198,
-0.0185577944,
-0.0005866084,
0.0385426842,
-0.0486132838,
0.0072962753,
-0.0525534712,
0.0574615821,
0.0846613497,
0.0118221808,
0.0059775156,
0.0093063479,
0.0527369864,
-0.0011337076,
0.0210145693,
0.0054161595,
0.0515079238,
-0.015534088,
-0.0091742883,
0.0031425178,
0.0688322559,
-0.0125491982,
-0.0074654664,
-0.0001494467,
0.0645068884,
-0.0039677373,
-0.0033150672,
-0.0224196557,
-0.0258286037,
0.0272658281,
0.0563718602,
0.0051607252,
-0.0293897893,
-0.050799299,
-0.0509562604,
-0.0075083128,
-0.0016516245,
-0.0587332547,
0.0108505683,
0.0177936349,
-0.0553293042,
-0.0417690985,
0.0037805629,
-0.0060875583,
0.0104807643,
0.0373898521,
0.0258066673,
0.0040203058,
0.0279328618,
-0.0309655219,
0.0136139933,
-0.0510364808,
0.0399090238,
-0.0420137942,
0.0267635547,
0.0443045311,
-0.0090105776,
-0.0221640337,
0.0400130004,
-0.066435881,
-0.0953934193,
-0.0119076874,
0.0321419351,
0.0231423136,
0.0489340164,
-0.0520129837,
-0.0746305585,
0.080948554,
0.066487439,
-0.0519238375,
0.0054738731,
0.0467004776,
-0.0144958189,
0.0160443708,
0.0534504354,
-0.0203121044,
-0.0227077026,
0.059134014,
0.023193039,
0.0074380934,
0.0105979079,
0.0039944169,
0.0479032062,
0.1006161645,
-0.0206716806,
0.0120391268,
-0.0102294628,
0.0281172693,
-0.0192519333,
-0.034731172,
0.0133268973,
0.0495956987,
0.042302385,
-0.0161772352,
-0.00217674,
-0.0136905173,
0.0191276092,
0.0409577116,
-0.0437557474,
0.0195519086,
0.0293073058,
0.0144274784,
0.0623817593,
0.0060154167,
-0.0012130241,
0.043998234,
0.0376280583,
0.0081808269,
-0.0124055566,
0.0207606517,
0.0129041541,
0.0097258231,
-0.042580504,
0.005637079,
-0.0606679581,
-0.0558580533,
-0.0258070901,
0.038965743,
0.0237256661,
0.0128413457,
0.0203451291,
-0.0051326398,
-0.0185513329,
-0.020459611,
-0.0130260745,
-0.0168634783,
-0.044612214,
0.0312565379,
0.0049793934,
-0.0119761759,
0.0198602509,
0.0816145614,
0.0203842111,
0.1098720506,
-0.0122534623,
-0.0292720161,
-0.0302053988,
-0.0455883965,
-0.0012696143,
0.0024273279,
-0.0300931782,
0.0051988345,
-0.0310647059,
-0.0992694423,
-0.0453403406,
0.0156473219,
0.0333164968,
0.0228882395,
0.0167683195,
0.0516280495,
0.0143858558,
0.0066216947,
-0.0783684552,
0.0222048778,
0.012547628,
-0.0515376143,
-0.0218554456,
-6.459158521e-33,
0.0407159254,
-0.0251790341,
0.0033412727,
-0.005982649,
0.0014448503,
-0.0203356929,
-0.0011593411,
-0.007909962,
-0.0117067229,
-0.0053400304,
-0.0222336594,
0.0168629996,
-0.0063823778,
0.0251864437,
-0.0127632609,
-0.0025122503,
0.0471983515,
-0.0306301434,
-0.0236536674,
0.0363963768,
0.0579626746,
0.0259433184,
0.0294656195,
-0.0515973568,
-0.0000348944,
-0.0089769671,
-0.0659364611,
0.0365018658,
-0.0706980526,
0.0703406632,
-0.0121340919,
0.0172605328,
0.0031603223,
-0.0465110093,
-0.0036319834,
0.052993454,
-0.0469808802,
0.0149407107,
-0.0208286885,
-0.0240677334,
0.0216242447,
-0.0545121767,
0.0892972201,
-0.0140908249,
-0.018453069,
0.0107219052,
0.0060261604,
-0.0282731839,
-0.025995316,
-0.0509411357,
-0.0203249045,
0.0296853893,
0.0020001065,
-0.0123816309,
-0.0035309864,
0.0116574103,
-0.0085908873,
-0.0039462466,
-0.0230149608,
0.026803283,
0.0782177001,
0.0098678861,
0.0421535671,
0.0152822798,
0.02525541,
0.0641120076,
-0.0037483808,
-0.0102713834,
-0.0156256221,
-0.0174382478,
0.0215508156,
0.0779417157,
0.0156876482,
0.0639496222,
0.0735472962,
-0.034199588,
-0.0789072439,
0.0064059151,
-0.0356653146,
0.0581619106,
0.0452086516,
0.0278504305,
-0.0490156785,
0.0080317566,
-0.0792381763,
-0.0087436587,
-0.039000567,
-0.0042583132,
0.0191118401,
0.0402281284,
-0.0465809889,
-0.0204525758,
-0.0086593255,
-0.0613698512,
-0.0001009767,
0.0471629389,
0.0126071423,
-0.0235285982,
0.0076079629,
-0.0061738407,
-0.0127405869,
-0.0298356153,
-0.0089080231,
-0.0536984913,
0.0204915758,
-0.007126058,
0.0258284118,
0.0303325653,
-0.0940128118,
0.0025415642,
-0.034407109,
0.048151087,
0.0343435891,
0.036652334,
0.0416269079,
-0.0266826451,
0.0121693686,
0.0334682986,
0.0383268818,
0.0400034077,
-0.0305658467,
0.0426959023,
0.0031745764,
0.001546725,
0.0027805653,
0.0029708664,
0.0121587701,
0.024458224,
0.0574276298,
-0.0465705581,
0.008905868,
0.0123177171,
3.023e-7,
-0.0004299041,
0.0289125703,
0.0198194664,
0.014195933,
0.0396932699,
0.0782752335,
-0.0109020881,
0.0657396689,
-0.0047175786,
-0.0091066696,
-0.0112567898,
0.0068147876,
0.0393911153,
0.0225370247,
-0.0684861094,
0.0246497523,
-0.0685144663,
0.0146739539,
-0.0520122498,
-0.0287602525,
0.0230040848,
0.096243754,
0.0082648182,
-0.0213736836,
0.0100099398,
-0.063080132,
0.034801621,
-0.0093159834,
-0.0136587461,
0.0008555548,
0.0270565469,
0.0890316963,
0.0148913683,
-0.0050614281,
-0.0490257964,
0.007541697,
-0.0807263777,
0.0565959737,
0.0008889213,
-0.0498415381,
-0.018318085,
-0.038824968,
0.0179434102,
-0.034283869,
0.0682202056,
-0.0414555036,
-0.0277710408,
-0.038460318,
-0.0021429756,
-0.0490234047,
0.0350056849,
-0.0599186122,
0.0022396338,
0.0048981514,
-0.0051950966,
0.0127522787,
-0.0081793694,
-0.0854758024,
-0.0142645212,
-0.0361105986,
-0.04724456,
-0.0453149416,
-0.0071766083,
0.0344431177,
-0.007441659,
-0.0220646523,
0.0141914245,
2.868342133e-34,
0.0241548363,
-0.0197696984,
-0.0078566037,
0.0053286245,
0.0566094331,
0.0141788404,
-0.0090611931,
0.0157251041,
0.0112741608,
-0.0688320026,
-0.0373464748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07663v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07663v1
|
Sign Stitching: A Novel Approach to Sign Language Production
| 2024-05-13T11:44:57 | 2024-05-13T11:44:57 |
Harry Walsh, Ben Saunders, Richard Bowden
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Sign Language Production (SLP) is a challenging task, given the limited
resources available and the inherent diversity within sign data. As a result,
previous works have suffered from the problem of regression to the mean,
leading to under-articulated and incomprehensible signing. In this paper, we
propose using dictionary examples and a learnt codebook of facial expressions
to create expressive sign language sequences. However, simply concatenating
signs and adding the face creates robotic and unnatural sequences. To address
this we present a 7-step approach to effectively stitch sequences together.
First, by normalizing each sign into a canonical pose, cropping, and stitching
we create a continuous sequence. Then, by applying filtering in the frequency
domain and resampling each sign, we create cohesive natural sequences that
mimic the prosody found in the original data. We leverage a SignGAN model to
map the output to a photo-realistic signer and present a complete Text-to-Sign
(T2S) SLP pipeline. Our evaluation demonstrates the effectiveness of the
approach, showcasing state-of-the-art performance across all datasets. Finally,
a user evaluation shows our approach outperforms the baseline model and is
capable of producing realistic sign language sequences.
|
[
-0.0428601466,
0.0687116906,
0.0226181392,
-0.0216383506,
0.0082263118,
0.0097268373,
0.0106729064,
0.0045205606,
0.0355903991,
-0.0102393636,
-0.0008041437,
-0.0106645003,
0.0420030467,
0.0975440368,
0.0401681326,
-0.1256111264,
-0.0068784072,
-0.0114403572,
-0.0183921717,
-0.0226632804,
0.0435809046,
0.0480653606,
-0.0537736975,
0.0584210493,
-0.1170119196,
-0.002733842,
-0.037430346,
0.0224444028,
0.0445722453,
-0.0142519455,
-0.0863208324,
0.0205324236,
0.0579794757,
0.0004316948,
0.0000020969,
0.0047685523,
-0.0028388603,
0.0176677536,
0.0256635621,
0.0213253517,
0.0644610152,
-0.0496194549,
-0.048487436,
0.0227595381,
-0.0279674865,
-0.0727698132,
0.0516173765,
0.0532916188,
0.0561887994,
0.0360293351,
-0.0209057052,
-0.0000303071,
0.0269402526,
-0.042347081,
-0.0115282796,
0.0288137458,
0.0153214205,
0.0072998591,
0.0448265523,
-0.0835571289,
-0.0436689705,
0.061948847,
0.0482047834,
-0.0578064322,
-0.0286667496,
0.0270971972,
-0.0254723709,
-0.0315433145,
-0.0106911706,
0.0617105253,
-0.0685764998,
0.0176180433,
0.0317493491,
-0.0276155397,
0.0387362018,
0.0097299572,
-0.0018523679,
0.0222823247,
0.0007446408,
0.0141042275,
-0.0713630915,
0.0075115943,
0.0199304186,
-0.0381482728,
-0.0345365256,
-0.0175990406,
0.0254637692,
0.0310846176,
-0.0246106405,
-0.0235091131,
0.0044268793,
-0.0605543219,
0.0341746695,
0.005749891,
0.0117430333,
0.001566628,
-0.0364517011,
-0.0032765549,
-0.025169218,
0.0169150103,
-0.0607478172,
0.027646251,
-0.0000645552,
-0.0042256881,
-0.0095003117,
0.0195338149,
-0.0231023207,
0.0334989801,
-0.0404837467,
0.0089975046,
-0.0126617849,
-0.0176752806,
-0.0197473597,
-0.0238374751,
-0.0174959637,
-0.0630790293,
-0.026378043,
-0.0037169391,
0.0018219873,
-0.0173010584,
0.0142436679,
0.0515454598,
0.0063382555,
0.0023758768,
0.0090666777,
0.0161189344,
0.0132123325,
0.04750726,
-0.0120165991,
-0.0526648536,
0.0036662985,
0.0204839054,
0.0313972645,
0.0681544244,
0.0156955179,
0.0160028245,
-0.0258327071,
0.0158999208,
0.0405064374,
0.0102317426,
-0.0266536623,
-0.0201052483,
-0.0042632171,
-0.0251941625,
0.0136710824,
-0.0580091551,
-0.0056494544,
-0.0706567168,
0.0003865931,
-0.0251446385,
0.0472055748,
0.0174340308,
0.0077217789,
0.0039175428,
0.0250459034,
-0.0022245951,
-0.0174598824,
0.0058885338,
0.0854598805,
0.0418729633,
-0.0171733368,
-0.0035226066,
-0.005841075,
0.0625455081,
0.0132424533,
-0.0164886806,
-0.0252966341,
-0.0693235174,
0.0161342137,
0.0310077574,
0.0098376842,
0.0371138193,
-0.0239273757,
0.0066450979,
0.0053572562,
0.0543436445,
0.0578612946,
-0.0325407907,
0.0304150153,
0.0550328717,
0.0086559178,
-0.0599502251,
-0.011043936,
0.0592968464,
0.0364949256,
-0.0248418264,
-0.0175325368,
0.0289523378,
-0.0687865764,
-0.0098608024,
0.0122658843,
-0.0236290824,
0.03953363,
0.0157798324,
0.0422816016,
0.0487113521,
-0.0589017272,
-0.0475180782,
-0.0197667554,
-0.0496268161,
0.0276641902,
-0.0091329012,
-0.0158543531,
0.0234109797,
-0.0127221728,
0.0137089789,
0.0042583034,
-0.0077486378,
-0.0281596407,
0.0273219217,
-0.022111116,
-0.0179613382,
0.0452518649,
-0.0445080735,
-0.0255840141,
0.0584882982,
-0.0053303679,
0.0396313891,
-0.0493463054,
0.0592582785,
0.0114716254,
0.0288295951,
0.0353211462,
0.0561919957,
-0.057983432,
-0.0127192391,
-0.001877662,
0.0095362756,
0.023623677,
0.0249143355,
-0.0191520639,
0.0011726705,
0.0307812132,
-0.0258995537,
-0.0381092951,
0.047693897,
-0.035587322,
-0.0283820461,
0.0411833227,
-0.0706014857,
-0.0095395911,
0.0226476975,
-0.0067652636,
-0.0852037668,
0.0430742763,
-0.0204793625,
0.0256484393,
-0.0134839108,
-0.0124084149,
0.0219018664,
-0.00802748,
0.0069535193,
-0.0249038916,
-0.003695616,
-0.0375643112,
-0.0142048029,
0.00052212,
-0.0330112912,
-0.0284327157,
0.0186423846,
0.0655495003,
0.0007654553,
0.0068222578,
-0.0002057174,
0.0424045399,
-0.0308013111,
-0.0347842388,
-0.0487519875,
-0.022583168,
0.0192218665,
-0.0186827015,
-0.0201594662,
-0.033710558,
0.0012886138,
-0.0264272727,
-0.082743451,
0.0208201148,
0.0231267661,
-0.0751754045,
-0.014984617,
0.0010692447,
-0.0880855173,
-0.0366113856,
0.0054779886,
0.0111509357,
-0.0008131246,
0.0202282537,
-0.0613218509,
-0.0348590836,
-0.0270626228,
0.0129871182,
0.0152248219,
-0.0183396917,
-0.01427087,
0.0251209531,
0.0003223438,
-0.0110908942,
-0.0135842282,
-0.0108899605,
0.0128681706,
0.0073628291,
0.0032771674,
-0.0291918311,
-0.0155071737,
0.0028049168,
0.064952001,
-0.0270586163,
-0.0343637057,
-0.0149082225,
0.0077038435,
0.0341289565,
0.0640974194,
-0.0981313512,
-0.0243659578,
0.0196365286,
-0.071260184,
0.0199782141,
0.011345013,
-0.0330979824,
-0.0403080806,
-0.0255981795,
-0.057845816,
0.0264954399,
-0.0299696755,
-0.0789479539,
0.0494431928,
0.0179458149,
-0.0092910994,
0.0705840737,
0.0205166172,
0.026094215,
-0.0145445187,
-0.0348520167,
-0.0342014506,
0.0331142358,
-0.0191566311,
-0.0547386296,
0.0070103328,
-0.0524462238,
-0.0054686079,
-0.0162347648,
0.0302980728,
0.0075600692,
-0.0127573572,
-0.032555107,
-0.0054998924,
-0.0111790476,
-0.0599239096,
0.0027013421,
-0.005173204,
0.0010250837,
0.014909246,
0.0250816047,
0.0146789486,
-0.0147095481,
-0.0677350387,
0.042967122,
0.0325613692,
-0.0167015865,
-0.0232616067,
0.0170318298,
0.0327459984,
-0.0090902103,
0.0372076444,
-0.0375002623,
0.0008099183,
0.0133267818,
0.0605364218,
0.0052565644,
0.025083961,
0.0222801175,
0.0150112696,
0.0695521757,
0.0416652933,
-0.0134732183,
0.0028996603,
0.0344454348,
0.0578434952,
0.0310054794,
0.0110731646,
-0.030523641,
-0.0318584852,
-0.0452836789,
0.0219701268,
0.0292967521,
0.0592694506,
0.0148299914,
-0.0371636823,
-0.0312927142,
0.028201947,
0.0408762656,
-0.0777573958,
-0.0310969967,
0.0279425308,
0.0174542051,
0.011507065,
-0.0117924269,
0.02693321,
-0.0113418121,
0.011446856,
0.0403592773,
0.0272679888,
-0.0412409566,
-0.0154412286,
-0.0075734109,
0.0528555587,
0.0342670381,
0.0158217028,
0.0344565883,
-0.0641594753,
-0.0170988906,
0.0200720541,
0.0342348479,
-0.0062189717,
0.0270971525,
0.0204836763,
-0.0245163161,
-0.0127093038,
0.0860794708,
-0.1213772371,
0.0189163927,
0.0029275669,
0.0003951354,
-0.0122439573,
-0.0011529705,
-0.0122640543,
0.0006736214,
0.0007273526,
0.0074529308,
-0.0096617024,
-0.0513173118,
-0.0031307018,
-0.0100582847,
0.0193812978,
0.0495429598,
-0.071202293,
0.0375911929,
-0.0199782737,
-0.0830884725,
-0.054455094,
-0.0013948552,
0.0723839626,
0.0503763519,
-0.0079133809,
-0.0248776991,
0.0364561342,
0.0042675757,
-0.0347384438,
0.0328667127,
0.0096125817,
0.0443856977,
-0.0313353613,
-0.0046657315,
-0.0131980563,
-0.0006922978,
0.0328087173,
-0.0184590612,
-0.0832048878,
-0.0542865582,
0.0240163319,
0.0345605351,
0.0144595793,
0.0038430626,
0.0184888765,
0.0098850895,
-0.018286014,
0.048741743,
0.030790722,
0.04835039,
0.0489675775,
-0.0473901927,
0.0002053183,
0.0057348744,
-0.02699822,
0.0170988776,
-0.0381810553,
-0.0012649318,
-0.0630143732,
-0.0307598393,
-0.0161429122,
0.013002445,
-0.0370258205,
-0.0550942011,
-0.0136728799,
-0.051351577,
0.0064588129,
-0.0380597487,
0.0216692779,
-0.0931126699,
-0.0035222357,
0.0263862219,
0.0143817458,
0.0188058037,
0.0287517402,
-0.0161380824,
0.0222551264,
0.0256585069,
0.0387748368,
0.014109252,
0.0339159071,
0.0276022926,
0.0280843135,
0.0203372631,
0.0440557338,
-0.029175438,
-0.0078749629,
-0.0122823687,
-0.0116240196,
-0.0007303017,
-0.0029782851,
0.0305186324,
0.0256506279,
0.0333569609,
-0.0790967643,
-0.0211684126,
-0.0039243768,
0.0268916655,
0.0517169423,
0.1062265784,
-0.041428104,
0.0390000977,
-0.0252026059,
0.0234718453,
-0.0199801605,
-0.04061855,
0.0366528556,
-0.0359291546,
-0.0309888348,
-0.0279317945,
0.0250438508,
-0.0760683715,
0.0061949054,
-0.0230946019,
0.0338610969,
-0.0476142615,
-0.0225228928,
0.008714946,
-0.0552749634,
-0.0208659898,
0.0251276232,
-0.040105179,
-0.0330657475,
-0.0015867987,
0.0015034425,
-0.0036404997,
-0.0008826832,
0.0453167707,
-0.0666568428,
-0.0163199957,
0.0574417301,
-0.0055338331,
-0.0153478812,
-0.0262790658,
-0.0386599228,
0.004180721,
-5.555417526e-33,
-0.0385057516,
-0.0321569517,
-0.030103825,
-0.0130368769,
-0.029025929,
0.005719902,
-0.0382407196,
0.028082788,
0.0107299155,
0.0255125035,
-0.002828429,
0.0140926037,
-0.0047563058,
0.0173224304,
-0.0174846742,
0.0081054764,
0.0470123254,
-0.0367667899,
0.0101740677,
0.0381348133,
0.0309896227,
-0.0040612398,
0.0307658948,
-0.0877812952,
-0.036518909,
-0.0117869852,
-0.0703158006,
-0.0315719582,
0.0031918071,
0.002414631,
0.013420172,
0.0123421792,
-0.027156936,
0.0024727762,
0.0056433193,
0.0249050744,
-0.0161544513,
-0.0018254559,
-0.0704118758,
0.063782908,
-0.0636465475,
0.0327261314,
-0.0115991542,
-0.0196486879,
-0.0265998263,
0.0199408848,
0.0326035544,
-0.0224135295,
-0.007904239,
-0.0481181592,
0.0161874536,
0.0202643648,
-0.0281497855,
-0.0850609168,
-0.0033842616,
0.0450309962,
-0.002701744,
-0.0307322964,
-0.0135671739,
0.0366566069,
-0.0173698533,
0.0052165673,
0.0948617011,
-0.0152775673,
0.0546429977,
0.0573849231,
0.0217521824,
-0.0745947659,
0.0170472506,
0.0025915937,
0.0488169529,
0.0419892333,
0.0076252706,
0.0525282882,
0.0673060268,
-0.0430519618,
0.0042725438,
0.0277330279,
0.0509610511,
0.0291102398,
-0.0509780347,
0.0793377012,
0.0286642686,
0.0038258967,
-0.0447374061,
0.006474894,
0.025865579,
-0.0250520278,
0.0227140971,
0.0345701128,
-0.0026405596,
-0.0073620202,
0.0547198616,
0.0138566494,
-0.02165737,
0.0118767004,
-0.0413074009,
0.035514459,
0.0141629558,
-0.0075719492,
-0.0263867248,
-0.0371939316,
0.1219269559,
0.0124751311,
0.068154037,
0.0007917046,
-0.0260895044,
0.0772046149,
-0.0250688754,
-0.0034295977,
0.0048182975,
0.0565926805,
0.0344945155,
-0.0353541113,
0.0545132235,
-0.0415496752,
-0.0298258662,
0.0365150981,
-0.0233644098,
0.0052823965,
0.0016828744,
0.0333165228,
-0.0044820714,
0.0002177308,
-0.0635634437,
0.0175047852,
0.0098145464,
-0.0707450584,
0.0867113099,
-0.0666434392,
-0.0120499842,
0.0347543806,
2.728e-7,
-0.0151803615,
-0.0039122403,
0.0525180735,
0.0427881628,
0.0372383632,
0.0500072166,
-0.0287404489,
0.0271374136,
0.005641114,
-0.0147706708,
-0.0003999196,
-0.0369510837,
0.0703973994,
0.0261568986,
-0.040384803,
0.035610076,
0.0072039482,
0.0182568729,
-0.004320717,
0.0448233113,
0.0645310208,
0.0775540918,
0.0006286475,
-0.0251729414,
0.0599674322,
-0.0427781679,
0.0333387479,
-0.0240377188,
0.033748202,
-0.0392135754,
0.0119974725,
-0.0662382394,
0.0012979973,
-0.0141632557,
-0.0250637606,
-0.0157576539,
0.0352913663,
0.027962286,
-0.0518975966,
-0.0091040395,
-0.0037742546,
0.0387729853,
-0.0425772592,
0.0469115227,
0.0356482863,
-0.0215857122,
-0.0101306345,
-0.0404531509,
-0.0255364869,
0.0160801839,
0.0216752496,
0.007894136,
0.0017403164,
0.0685641021,
0.0273554828,
-0.0512234084,
0.00925986,
-0.0373216346,
-0.0567548387,
-0.043182604,
-0.0475793965,
0.0168383252,
-0.0111219566,
0.0121471127,
-0.0345306285,
0.0229402762,
-0.0550647415,
1.929952339e-34,
-0.0209829547,
0.0076238592,
0.0356001817,
0.0098425075,
-0.0175270028,
0.0063932654,
0.0132098701,
0.0434341207,
0.0237310566,
-0.016612079,
-0.0595256984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13009v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13009v1
|
METAREFLECTION: Learning Instructions for Language Agents using Past Reflections
| 2024-05-13T10:51:43 | 2024-05-13T10:51:43 |
Priyanshu Gupta, Shashank Kirtania, Ananya Singha, Sumit Gulwani, Arjun Radhakrishna, Sherry Shi, Gustavo Soares
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), crafting specific
prompts for LLMs to perform particular tasks remains challenging. Users often
engage in multiple conversational turns with an LLM-based agent to accomplish
their intended task. Recent studies have demonstrated that linguistic feedback,
in the form of self-reflections generated by the model, can work as
reinforcement during these conversations, thus enabling quicker convergence to
the desired outcome. Motivated by these findings, we introduce METAREFLECTION,
a novel technique that learns general prompt instructions for a specific domain
from individual self-reflections gathered during a training phase. We evaluate
our technique in two domains: Infrastructure as Code (IAC) vulnerability
detection and question-answering (QA) using REACT and COT. Our results
demonstrate a notable improvement, with METARELECTION outperforming GPT-4 by
16.82% (IAC), 31.33% (COT), and 15.42% (REACT), underscoring the potential of
METAREFLECTION as a viable method for enhancing the efficiency of LLMs.
|
[
0.0373700261,
0.0411727726,
-0.0366589017,
0.0192728713,
-0.0445589758,
-0.0342832878,
-0.0023930788,
-0.0266446788,
0.0079801101,
-0.0416287929,
-0.0389844403,
0.0175862983,
-0.0293859635,
0.0246112999,
0.0074698892,
-0.0313201696,
0.0576906092,
-0.0592228621,
-0.0316336416,
-0.010659894,
0.0106540089,
-0.0016533301,
-0.0274319425,
0.0509205908,
0.0276524443,
-0.0335037522,
-0.0414556414,
-0.0057367017,
0.0101885628,
-0.0353362076,
0.0162271056,
0.053286206,
0.0088821743,
0.0412692577,
0.0000021301,
-0.0432368442,
-0.0302387867,
-0.0178564005,
-0.0190671664,
-0.0154164378,
0.0174446199,
0.0011171398,
-0.030994216,
0.0572619587,
-0.0676408336,
-0.026298482,
0.0482309908,
0.0205718186,
0.0906305462,
0.0724969581,
0.0133521305,
0.0332033299,
-0.016823899,
0.011981572,
0.0110675283,
-0.0464672036,
-0.014352412,
-0.0272367001,
-0.0007530116,
0.0566323213,
-0.0129314614,
0.0200475715,
0.0420569554,
-0.021210555,
-0.0296172127,
0.0521597974,
0.0131377568,
0.0216756426,
-0.0542476401,
0.0597011372,
0.0288653187,
0.0112396013,
-0.0180252548,
0.0016604755,
0.0384779274,
0.0404696092,
-0.0240944177,
-0.0041711079,
0.0092661493,
-0.0054566548,
-0.0291391704,
-0.0015175591,
-0.0070220144,
0.0009029404,
0.0011704745,
0.0767879784,
-0.0093536228,
-0.020456031,
-0.0120283077,
-0.0189727731,
0.0653135628,
-0.0504369028,
-0.0180752352,
0.0682942495,
-0.0318373367,
0.0397487357,
-0.0210545287,
-0.0162751693,
0.0545384176,
-0.0106085762,
0.0200830624,
0.0324049592,
-0.0461795293,
0.0217529498,
-0.0222773869,
0.0579174645,
0.0031956977,
0.028155895,
-0.0292858537,
-0.0090475157,
-0.0689750984,
-0.0252421442,
-0.0481791943,
0.0498382784,
0.002159982,
0.0038698541,
-0.0222677812,
0.0608766973,
-0.0068744635,
0.0161574241,
-0.0279196221,
-0.0129954275,
-0.0217893943,
-0.0138820438,
-0.03664257,
0.0260773916,
-0.0249220226,
-0.0022681342,
0.0197976772,
-0.0643587857,
-0.0123391533,
-0.0093651582,
-0.0173487924,
-0.0121432524,
-0.0221507698,
0.0701010376,
0.0047534052,
-0.0372796692,
-0.0081464769,
-0.034833625,
-0.0195130259,
-0.0255298615,
-0.0029987418,
-0.0629517213,
-0.0174304042,
-0.0133895762,
-0.0205794498,
-0.016730478,
0.0157303549,
0.0058526299,
0.0090517718,
0.0799653679,
-0.0315109342,
0.0084645897,
0.0221939329,
0.0223130342,
-0.0205920339,
0.0716742799,
0.0050318497,
0.036401853,
0.0170248412,
-0.0050039301,
0.0664105713,
0.011911476,
0.0027437657,
0.031821657,
0.0096118571,
0.0222231019,
0.0237902272,
-0.0021685665,
0.0243422035,
0.0361341089,
-0.0054307343,
0.0075977393,
0.0584599227,
0.039629627,
-0.0196472257,
0.0237515289,
0.014687608,
0.0379240178,
-0.0043578842,
0.0018182113,
-0.053932,
0.0518988967,
-0.0212011728,
-0.0050911177,
-0.0343887396,
0.0042493092,
-0.0291853268,
-0.0229658764,
0.0119500775,
-0.017905185,
-0.0032940183,
0.0347411372,
0.01886658,
0.0370606557,
-0.0378285311,
0.0074983733,
0.0099659134,
-0.0497814156,
-0.0078818984,
-0.1131750792,
0.0099698808,
0.0950219333,
0.0405682549,
-0.0379635692,
-0.0530978814,
-0.015321943,
0.0158221815,
0.0500162765,
0.0306916833,
-0.0044218311,
-0.0136711588,
-0.019664757,
-0.0199554805,
-0.0240020081,
-0.0059784241,
0.0306930188,
-0.0044466127,
-0.0022929737,
-0.003992727,
0.002883452,
-0.0119496845,
0.0384181067,
0.0074871783,
-0.0391663164,
0.0231103301,
0.0095728859,
0.011941039,
0.0027242161,
0.0192969982,
0.0097225662,
0.0292544328,
0.0164756365,
-0.0542477146,
0.0332607776,
-0.0490595549,
-0.0367302448,
0.0303393099,
-0.0145304594,
0.0000052193,
0.0386324674,
-0.028584281,
-0.0328057595,
0.0401894636,
-0.0521082655,
0.0638990998,
-0.0254879054,
0.0032120831,
-0.0118792523,
-0.0093962317,
-0.0236623604,
0.0126530016,
0.0064277761,
-0.0255327653,
-0.0257797893,
0.0094648562,
-0.0062609152,
-0.0323450081,
0.0014640967,
0.0054385974,
-0.0013588642,
0.0399772786,
0.0289993007,
0.0495200343,
-0.0451382883,
-0.0445808098,
-0.1219905242,
-0.0316536203,
-0.0396853536,
0.0267066564,
0.0355441794,
0.0269072466,
-0.018179873,
-0.0539751016,
-0.0444499217,
0.0046921237,
-0.0028262485,
0.031621661,
0.0446985215,
0.0124208294,
-0.0264558718,
-0.045983132,
0.0075153783,
-0.0306645557,
0.0197469685,
-0.013076623,
0.0415598303,
-0.0616529696,
0.0239385478,
0.0207738541,
0.0358222201,
-0.0243040677,
-0.0916021317,
0.0378834084,
-0.0200469736,
0.0411656797,
0.0111588575,
0.0378895849,
0.0140351327,
0.0574756414,
0.0019061739,
-0.0874637067,
0.0248898901,
-0.0156721696,
-0.0585126467,
-0.0456257053,
-0.0133259567,
0.0400403477,
0.0504991375,
0.0105387978,
0.0047797216,
-0.0521754213,
0.0009425339,
-0.0118758222,
-0.0381169468,
-0.0111774802,
-0.0170005299,
-0.0244374368,
0.0286035817,
0.0129883699,
-0.0591191053,
0.099972561,
-0.0187045522,
-0.0117000174,
-0.0660385862,
-0.021406509,
-0.0411127768,
0.0742016509,
-0.0427292027,
0.028336931,
0.039862588,
-0.0386095196,
-0.0405278839,
-0.0427585803,
0.0169990771,
-0.0149454186,
0.0396790281,
-0.0532192849,
0.011785184,
0.0049692886,
-0.0786293969,
-0.0608406626,
-0.0502759106,
-0.0186113194,
-0.0087549575,
-0.0486619771,
0.0052749026,
0.0040600412,
-0.0039742151,
0.034786135,
0.0391595922,
-0.0220138617,
-0.0319834091,
-0.0157568045,
-0.0173345543,
0.0612682924,
0.0114446441,
-0.0078448569,
0.0183692984,
0.0875076279,
0.0435631052,
0.1107972041,
-0.0045757708,
-0.0457702614,
-0.0293586422,
0.0237157959,
-0.048381757,
0.0049210791,
0.0350977816,
0.0521185584,
-0.0581990853,
-0.029330384,
0.1051671728,
0.0375193357,
-0.0709124878,
-0.0105282813,
-0.0525488369,
0.0088345315,
0.0487560667,
0.0449315123,
-0.0591193624,
-0.0330953263,
0.0075506312,
0.0489072017,
-0.0033516118,
-0.0205652993,
-0.0101761259,
-0.1285106391,
0.0122481165,
-0.0305560715,
-0.0202063136,
0.0073996736,
-0.0540120453,
0.0097549763,
0.0251522381,
0.0054039243,
0.023347225,
-0.0313887894,
-0.0077306768,
0.0070830286,
-0.0259152874,
-0.0052694743,
-0.0027851313,
-0.0331306979,
0.0838049427,
0.076024726,
0.0031532592,
0.0050880834,
0.021887105,
0.0678681657,
-0.0337707363,
0.0319354199,
-0.0019125716,
0.0538412072,
-0.0149039226,
0.0100310137,
0.0059129316,
0.0293396246,
-0.0612708144,
-0.0072016292,
0.0803911537,
0.0738039613,
-0.0486855917,
0.0178034399,
-0.0312151425,
-0.0160099752,
0.0511459485,
0.041578576,
0.0208686143,
-0.0534158088,
-0.0314407349,
-0.0334092751,
-0.0000688741,
-0.0296499636,
-0.0395758748,
0.0161234792,
0.0328491367,
0.0214980803,
-0.0748623908,
-0.0867682025,
0.0287799854,
0.0316867232,
0.0096687535,
-0.014402858,
-0.0231149886,
0.0432805456,
-0.0052516027,
-0.0059375898,
-0.0560309403,
0.0079859132,
-0.0535393916,
-0.0250709094,
0.0533394367,
-0.0676438957,
-0.0000699882,
-0.035823334,
-0.0446223468,
-0.0678390041,
-0.005561735,
0.0729213506,
0.0225826316,
0.0227146801,
-0.0426157154,
-0.0169184022,
0.0427163579,
0.0219753757,
-0.0944936797,
-0.0115330983,
0.0543901846,
-0.0006300653,
-0.0113074491,
0.0320694633,
-0.0683140829,
0.0095506785,
-0.005656322,
0.039907977,
-0.0450928695,
-0.045298472,
0.0486800112,
-0.0017931318,
0.0492320731,
0.0001157015,
0.0091215782,
-0.0075728418,
0.0250786226,
-0.0118697351,
-0.0122547662,
-0.003088786,
0.030177474,
-0.013638515,
-0.03688078,
0.0575747415,
0.0202299412,
-0.0519192368,
0.0242927,
0.01837896,
0.031185491,
0.0295152105,
0.046281077,
0.0195439029,
0.0174245089,
-0.0198640376,
0.0252357423,
0.0440960787,
0.0086568417,
0.0091022104,
0.0620530769,
0.024153633,
-0.0368078128,
-0.0256464947,
0.0465758033,
-0.0954041108,
-0.0643302053,
0.0528513268,
0.0385133959,
0.0399836004,
0.074950479,
0.0247186571,
-0.0343427397,
0.0201778654,
0.0080683473,
0.0169919226,
-0.0063069565,
-0.0355068259,
0.033321131,
0.0215884298,
0.0044027711,
-0.0168898068,
0.0755816698,
-0.0164597761,
0.0503999405,
-0.0031099927,
-0.001927057,
-0.0538020208,
-0.0299147014,
-0.0105816778,
-0.01131217,
-0.0321045853,
-0.002301102,
-0.0545060895,
-0.042605985,
-0.0200400315,
0.0271020327,
-0.0030430013,
-0.0413610078,
0.0498878546,
0.0726659447,
0.021522196,
-0.030099934,
-0.0662227944,
0.0214372743,
-0.0131041398,
-0.0138845546,
-0.017879514,
-5.793009179e-33,
-0.0138162989,
-0.0414237566,
0.0501967892,
0.0363793038,
-0.0009092676,
-0.0015064176,
-0.0492962785,
0.0183285642,
-0.0249257348,
-0.0270336028,
-0.0318132155,
0.0269357301,
0.0173813496,
-0.0004623366,
0.0302455928,
-0.0104076443,
0.0603664555,
-0.0158507284,
-0.0446685702,
0.0484557077,
0.0096908789,
0.013306099,
0.0238160342,
-0.0424017832,
0.0100360075,
0.0093634734,
-0.0078305947,
0.0287716463,
-0.01819955,
0.0681510568,
0.0052134064,
0.0522078052,
0.0128810918,
-0.0197258964,
-0.0004092154,
0.0440673418,
-0.0461267568,
-0.0595513806,
0.0017003349,
-0.0082460782,
-0.056009084,
-0.0582978055,
0.0083310613,
-0.0238731094,
-0.0166730788,
0.0218291618,
0.0301294029,
0.01922803,
0.0110462653,
0.0211758036,
-0.0493973456,
0.0007384642,
-0.0183775853,
-0.0232358389,
-0.0011154322,
0.0615968518,
0.0152481319,
-0.0288525652,
-0.0179444999,
0.0445864797,
-0.0058724219,
0.0385228321,
0.0542337932,
0.0543735698,
-0.0127941901,
0.0414271131,
0.0383958332,
0.0196558461,
0.0275278799,
-0.0196641311,
0.0306665991,
-0.0173867438,
0.0232248548,
0.0702201501,
0.0083700884,
-0.0140887043,
-0.0314497277,
0.0191904623,
0.0493899174,
0.0505187884,
0.0534177199,
0.0053777886,
-0.0302231945,
0.0031313743,
-0.0600326471,
0.0142697981,
-0.0155202281,
-0.0644311532,
0.0401354954,
0.0288630519,
-0.0174884591,
-0.0351922214,
0.0248666406,
-0.0109581416,
-0.0150712132,
0.0193472672,
-0.0322381556,
0.0353804044,
-0.013626175,
0.0384183973,
-0.0356416702,
0.0117238779,
0.0089318473,
0.0196506903,
0.0184913501,
0.020484481,
0.028016299,
0.0459999703,
-0.0742025524,
-0.0028685117,
-0.0574278161,
0.0464224331,
-0.0242357682,
-0.0028445383,
-0.0026645591,
-0.0025207119,
-0.0103943748,
0.0357858986,
0.0029062489,
-0.034476988,
-0.0717291012,
0.009743765,
-0.0027317752,
0.0135089681,
-0.0371561311,
-0.0002643287,
-0.0467248,
0.0677107424,
0.0140111465,
-0.0737325922,
-0.0152704678,
0.0284586027,
2.874e-7,
-0.0169079769,
0.0248590261,
0.0198798962,
0.0280503072,
0.0213086214,
0.0584803335,
-0.0229430273,
0.0167170037,
0.0286490396,
0.0006979493,
-0.0088254018,
0.0518885441,
0.0303643532,
0.0548224077,
-0.1054727435,
-0.019033242,
-0.0479763187,
-0.0063884347,
-0.0589920543,
-0.0024350013,
0.0498186797,
0.0496197529,
0.0157113727,
-0.0091484049,
-0.0001949243,
-0.0207328703,
0.0256376807,
-0.0106177917,
0.0023027738,
0.0306012388,
-0.0402161665,
0.0249723885,
-0.0228101071,
-0.0031918378,
0.0112118274,
-0.0125516132,
-0.0648933649,
0.0260862038,
-0.0028505311,
-0.0625160635,
0.0096801203,
-0.0045405361,
0.015904963,
-0.0410886295,
0.0522654839,
-0.0413392335,
-0.0021939508,
-0.0156066464,
0.0071498384,
-0.0467957519,
-0.0118603585,
-0.04684541,
-0.0530008413,
0.009191107,
-0.0177486949,
-0.0079036606,
0.0077086021,
-0.0604678057,
0.0166576896,
-0.0190738179,
-0.0278499648,
-0.0410271361,
-0.0408804864,
0.0136719663,
-0.0108315423,
-0.0689650401,
0.0269064438,
2.394667271e-34,
-0.0076146335,
-0.0089880768,
-0.0017178882,
0.0511287712,
0.0284334347,
0.0178248733,
-0.0138639603,
0.0206346363,
0.0560105853,
-0.0382571109,
-0.0481302924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07623v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07623v1
|
COBias and Debias: Minimizing Language Model Pairwise Accuracy Bias via Nonlinear Integer Programming
| 2024-05-13T10:30:33 | 2024-05-13T10:30:33 |
Ruixi Lin, Yang You
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For language model classification, would you prefer having only one workable
class or having every class working? The latter makes more practical uses.
Especially for large language models (LLMs), the fact that they achieve a fair
overall accuracy by in-context learning (ICL) obscures a large difference in
individual class accuracies. In this work, we uncover and tackle language
models' imbalance in per-class prediction accuracy by reconceptualizing it as
the Contextual Oddity Bias (COBias), and we are the first to engage nonlinear
integer programming (NIP) to debias it. Briefly, COBias refers to the
difference in accuracy by a class A compared to its ''odd'' class, which holds
the majority wrong predictions of class A. With the COBias metric, we reveal
that LLMs of varied scales and families exhibit large per-class accuracy
differences. Then we propose Debiasing as Nonlinear Integer Programming (DNIP)
to correct ICL per-class probabilities for lower bias and higher overall
accuracy. Our optimization objective is directly based on the evaluation scores
by COBias and accuracy metrics, solved by simulated annealing. Evaluations on
three LLMs across seven NLP classification tasks show that DNIP simultaneously
achieves significant COBias reduction ($-27\%$) and accuracy improvement
($+12\%$) over the conventional ICL approach, suggesting that modeling pairwise
class accuracy differences is a direction in pushing forward more accurate,
more reliable LLM predictions.
|
[
-0.0097137634,
0.0616088435,
0.0055403723,
0.0600591376,
-0.0029222846,
0.0356722586,
-0.0026271089,
0.0171872173,
-0.0175980069,
-0.0974467471,
-0.034968432,
-0.0207754616,
0.0005043051,
0.0054719746,
0.0106950914,
-0.0067270068,
0.0392901488,
-0.0204587039,
0.0258326121,
-0.0305988397,
-0.0039641694,
-0.0123189129,
-0.014930279,
0.0073024523,
0.0156194,
0.0016051418,
0.0389734991,
0.0097128721,
0.0002200858,
-0.007447809,
0.080159083,
0.0679680333,
0.0226676874,
0.0290178675,
0.0000021938,
-0.0806074589,
-0.0239896663,
-0.001869826,
-0.0500110239,
-0.0016199697,
0.0677207485,
-0.0504027754,
0.0256469287,
0.0412067436,
-0.0443205349,
0.006472561,
0.0342771746,
0.0636767223,
0.0294959638,
0.047784213,
0.0015111159,
-0.0525509194,
0.0279543698,
-0.0167852025,
0.0308554117,
-0.0364342034,
0.0007142354,
-0.016623836,
-0.0419553407,
0.0145162158,
0.0011511274,
0.0014403694,
-0.0118301902,
0.0542046279,
0.0245650355,
0.0281723123,
-0.0199199207,
-0.0200478528,
-0.0015743932,
0.0336856321,
-0.0129057225,
-0.0533356071,
-0.0295663178,
-0.0303054489,
-0.0058677117,
-0.0216338988,
-0.019215446,
0.03850751,
-0.0086671477,
0.0483619049,
0.0539444275,
0.0273850355,
0.0599733479,
0.0403364524,
-0.0055566635,
0.0399755724,
0.0074234959,
-0.0190268233,
0.0221721958,
0.01920522,
-0.054980807,
-0.0163683631,
-0.0015791998,
0.0233464818,
-0.0119006531,
0.0054931976,
-0.0036189593,
0.0125790071,
0.0560559221,
-0.0959922224,
-0.016872704,
0.0346150137,
-0.0092757605,
0.0188801344,
0.0135956574,
0.0185701363,
0.0263853092,
0.0006618605,
-0.0185329802,
0.0121108452,
-0.0058190762,
0.0045327926,
-0.0237409007,
-0.0021405194,
-0.0415951796,
0.0376615115,
-0.0544314198,
0.012272222,
-0.0267217271,
0.0145946098,
0.0288711488,
0.029115025,
-0.0139974132,
-0.0012056916,
-0.0108450176,
0.002888236,
-0.0168627352,
0.0225009453,
-0.0404338092,
-0.0387556888,
0.0044689835,
0.01157011,
-0.0104022902,
-0.0250941198,
0.0360577144,
0.0829595178,
-0.0023347063,
-0.0385905281,
-0.0572884381,
0.0123830223,
-0.0149725657,
-0.0511030518,
-0.0466005579,
-0.0885526091,
0.0034849076,
0.0410655998,
0.003244261,
-0.0390038639,
0.0107929064,
-0.0075050434,
-0.0013717287,
0.0554190129,
0.0220672619,
-0.0147116939,
0.0784771815,
-0.002541909,
-0.0110322768,
0.0846883506,
0.0308617409,
-0.040909104,
0.0523257256,
-0.0040281559,
0.0313479975,
0.0309610758,
0.0245008096,
0.0215327311,
-0.0133953197,
-0.0072629536,
0.0396576039,
0.0077405861,
0.06492953,
0.0040048552,
-0.0078952853,
-0.0343312174,
0.0593682975,
-0.005859016,
0.0042966655,
0.0270626508,
-0.0374453589,
-0.0443780459,
-0.0308842119,
-0.0191229153,
-0.0962657928,
0.0297375433,
-0.0771770626,
-0.008021961,
0.0201896951,
-0.0205206219,
-0.0195320509,
-0.0534736775,
-0.0507194288,
-0.0214374978,
0.0270392913,
-0.0101784039,
0.0374071039,
-0.0356504172,
-0.0107426215,
0.0579529963,
0.0477400161,
-0.0146373101,
-0.0121865086,
-0.0428415537,
-0.0045205709,
0.0242311228,
0.0004192647,
-0.0523789376,
-0.0177510977,
-0.0085973777,
-0.0405391604,
0.0026931826,
0.0650935173,
0.001599536,
0.0351722017,
-0.0440800823,
-0.0024935582,
-0.0216333997,
0.0639908463,
-0.029725669,
0.0098907137,
0.0053371447,
-0.0043063457,
-0.0617134534,
-0.0650034472,
0.0379359834,
-0.0663071498,
-0.0698799267,
0.015939502,
0.0218258686,
0.0173826404,
-0.0293256454,
0.0126496563,
-0.0030191217,
0.0117552923,
-0.0294345114,
-0.0084326556,
-0.0300402567,
-0.030526232,
-0.0372597426,
0.0550841354,
-0.011362819,
0.0002954193,
0.0188205969,
-0.0484591946,
-0.0165891554,
0.0471665785,
-0.0000302326,
0.0268929116,
-0.0262349434,
0.0224785917,
-0.018977752,
0.0266633574,
-0.0555277914,
0.0687748343,
0.00018761,
0.0333315209,
-0.0202301405,
-0.0666647404,
0.0211401749,
-0.0061089457,
-0.0157673284,
-0.0042741867,
0.0020939086,
0.019895941,
0.0328117087,
0.0096976636,
-0.0426382497,
-0.0345401838,
-0.0739017949,
0.0051898863,
-0.0206145141,
0.0234436691,
0.0331157111,
-0.0297266617,
0.0035801001,
-0.0120843854,
-0.0435304269,
-0.0624434724,
-0.0132964682,
0.022987172,
0.027400393,
0.0170047209,
-0.0117564341,
-0.0377718695,
-0.0227683354,
-0.0197556335,
0.0367089435,
0.0028528071,
-0.0218102578,
-0.0626520067,
0.0887072235,
-0.0230999403,
0.0203381628,
-0.019220164,
-0.0109594222,
-0.0358513594,
-0.0068839765,
-0.0108749382,
0.0435425788,
0.0079100393,
-0.0120653799,
0.079713963,
0.0283348076,
-0.0596133322,
0.000317326,
-0.0050693997,
0.0068633878,
-0.0035702088,
-0.0406319425,
-0.026502138,
0.0799125582,
-0.0078295693,
-0.0164045487,
-0.0055382983,
-0.0196700916,
-0.0321695395,
-0.0051175733,
-0.0537758432,
0.0206426941,
0.0053249658,
0.071872972,
-0.0405803062,
-0.0694091469,
0.0521774441,
-0.0029865287,
-0.0197759923,
-0.0580460019,
-0.0121194441,
-0.0553231351,
0.0283518098,
-0.0005100656,
0.0190625004,
-0.0360427089,
0.0046741087,
-0.0618249178,
-0.0225147903,
0.0432694741,
-0.0460180044,
0.0723060369,
-0.0314428136,
0.0051325308,
-0.0322580412,
-0.066900298,
-0.0405590013,
-0.0383908302,
-0.0194546748,
0.0131482482,
-0.0165720694,
-0.004933768,
-0.0162256341,
-0.02281533,
-0.0240939036,
0.0394073613,
-0.0179638918,
-0.024252763,
0.0128936516,
0.0198532082,
0.0067317598,
-0.0213192832,
0.040336825,
-0.0190361124,
-0.0025029385,
0.0046404023,
0.056617856,
0.0606948696,
-0.0073205708,
0.0211126674,
0.054296229,
-0.0479681604,
-0.0520082936,
0.0127516231,
0.0184139125,
-0.0410062559,
-0.03939173,
0.1209254339,
0.028715197,
-0.0839509293,
0.0182638802,
-0.0094366083,
0.0079411222,
0.0431530029,
0.0218018442,
-0.0139666973,
-0.0434361957,
0.0052704173,
0.0287057031,
-0.0120663717,
-0.0212502833,
0.0049249013,
-0.105060488,
-0.0186445024,
0.0180239342,
-0.039626915,
-0.0484041721,
-0.0608743243,
0.0084180702,
-0.0714144558,
0.0540578961,
-0.0192524977,
0.0064918296,
0.011731497,
0.0546142645,
-0.0237891357,
-0.0403052494,
0.0361943506,
-0.0266920663,
0.0629552305,
0.0174342692,
0.0303935669,
-0.042306222,
-0.0213426035,
0.0983718485,
-0.0281725936,
-0.0269870143,
-0.0280395187,
0.0429851487,
-0.012002538,
0.0220670681,
0.0236794483,
0.0147863785,
-0.0489088744,
-0.0109916022,
-0.0168107878,
0.083192803,
0.0145643074,
-0.0119511643,
0.0165362954,
-0.0175817646,
0.013877565,
0.0647484511,
-0.0146685354,
-0.0375650786,
-0.0052145757,
-0.0665380806,
0.0330355316,
-0.0000416606,
-0.0015735449,
0.0458248556,
0.0252140053,
-0.0204378646,
-0.0211038552,
0.002607052,
0.0084865838,
0.0051832525,
0.0065694465,
0.0236519873,
-0.0523686111,
0.0063813645,
-0.0394719392,
-0.0191098116,
-0.0105094239,
0.0252160225,
-0.0309610087,
-0.0335640721,
0.0429678522,
-0.0493157059,
-0.0257783346,
-0.0177679509,
-0.0980897099,
-0.0537132695,
0.0173657201,
0.0349424481,
0.0159280039,
0.0585142821,
0.0105692213,
-0.0573721565,
0.0394184515,
0.1078110635,
-0.0195952952,
0.0320661142,
0.0526393726,
0.0552957654,
0.0045189001,
0.0370065197,
-0.0425131656,
-0.0155696329,
0.0556082726,
0.0207228903,
-0.0517788418,
-0.0426546596,
-0.0024845067,
-0.0013764328,
0.0391850211,
-0.0285435319,
-0.0664780587,
-0.024600612,
0.0038085543,
0.027400814,
-0.0301248468,
0.0075405664,
0.0151375057,
0.0354272239,
0.0208348464,
-0.0203778464,
0.0297025852,
0.0245583951,
-0.0090786964,
0.0033649246,
0.02292886,
0.0407201909,
0.026854394,
-0.0210758019,
0.0221046042,
-0.0370267518,
0.0264882166,
0.0107793426,
0.0408794917,
-0.0052003958,
0.02500448,
0.0161838979,
0.0592136979,
-0.0861222744,
-0.0038909649,
-0.0248827823,
0.032266207,
-0.0199294128,
0.0003801309,
0.0226960164,
-0.0241812728,
0.0182118118,
-0.0269681141,
-0.0089287451,
-0.024770692,
-0.0022794765,
0.0116361855,
-0.0093042683,
0.027604226,
0.0073196543,
0.0003653821,
-0.0048442516,
0.073836647,
-0.0183199774,
0.0578666665,
0.0094936024,
0.0012734868,
-0.0121194348,
0.0130137093,
0.0437303334,
0.039859686,
-0.0018334254,
0.0246246289,
-0.0434700102,
-0.0519873314,
-0.0152281718,
-0.008457453,
0.0317797884,
-0.0214747842,
0.0122771692,
0.0915069059,
-0.0239398163,
0.0015844844,
-0.0184430517,
-0.046148818,
0.015183961,
0.0149905421,
-0.0755675361,
-6.769805679e-33,
-0.0087845549,
-0.0110119907,
-0.0142344171,
0.023051301,
0.0514376685,
-0.03851806,
0.0119945863,
0.0278012995,
-0.0416848622,
-0.0022886053,
-0.0160313547,
0.0094142966,
-0.0068699829,
0.0043361359,
0.0354848728,
-0.0288852006,
0.0184967164,
0.0062583932,
-0.0318370275,
-0.0074163042,
0.034174718,
0.0048276349,
0.1064899638,
-0.0583580136,
0.0374959782,
-0.0090963496,
-0.0052195843,
0.0554395653,
-0.0259597395,
0.0294922758,
-0.0211081374,
0.0694169179,
0.056837827,
-0.0350011997,
0.0143962326,
-0.051576864,
-0.0201200377,
-0.0668693334,
0.0054345392,
0.0343861766,
0.0496014915,
-0.0224403497,
0.0528552271,
0.0117411837,
-0.079379037,
-0.0457798541,
0.0433142595,
-0.0095500546,
-0.0096064406,
0.0090774726,
-0.0284535997,
0.0105940979,
-0.0081648314,
-0.008360479,
-0.006415735,
-0.0466645099,
-0.0120071871,
0.0160501879,
-0.0515313745,
-0.0013903123,
-0.002113159,
0.0455742888,
0.0061275205,
0.0231970754,
-0.0283261985,
0.0523458309,
0.0711659268,
0.0148458807,
0.0170772467,
-0.0342471711,
0.0667368248,
0.000347977,
0.0686692968,
0.1062953174,
0.1259304434,
-0.009259725,
-0.0498060547,
0.0295785628,
0.0181588531,
-0.0194243826,
0.0102587668,
0.0143525358,
-0.0451554321,
-0.0486234948,
-0.0487895943,
-0.0398642011,
-0.0475779958,
0.0132615827,
-0.0133871026,
0.0221929085,
-0.0217286907,
-0.0042037508,
0.0122453077,
-0.0370704904,
-0.0618813708,
0.0432198383,
0.0105885193,
-0.0105588529,
0.019606607,
-0.0081624947,
-0.044804167,
-0.0394248292,
-0.014484317,
0.0182753336,
0.0328937732,
0.0092059625,
0.0714974552,
0.0056391917,
-0.0801771656,
0.0099804802,
-0.041300606,
0.0189719703,
0.0488302261,
0.051677376,
0.0245949756,
-0.0235857274,
0.0079281395,
0.0288364831,
0.0382207371,
0.0337673128,
-0.0319894701,
0.0163867157,
-0.0548454709,
0.0123777539,
-0.0095902421,
-0.0115715908,
0.0037363044,
-0.0378229357,
0.0080684917,
-0.0454032235,
-0.0044932859,
-0.0357808247,
2.831e-7,
0.0426558554,
0.0551934466,
-0.0556113794,
-0.023297485,
0.0323597156,
0.0747113079,
-0.0348158069,
0.0088061234,
0.0180846993,
-0.0142360022,
0.0189909469,
0.0270332508,
0.0140713984,
0.0511595309,
-0.0393461399,
0.0137526691,
-0.0455273949,
0.0643163323,
0.011084063,
0.0226194896,
0.0256622415,
0.0951104686,
0.0475969538,
-0.0325400308,
-0.0070672501,
-0.0588419326,
0.0451017059,
-0.0484696217,
0.033226829,
0.0211653449,
-0.0340349264,
-0.0119920252,
0.0479607396,
0.0280793849,
-0.0189168882,
0.0113129569,
-0.0223767944,
0.0109230913,
-0.0175095648,
-0.0247090273,
-0.0259568579,
0.0352490023,
-0.0072459327,
-0.0873065591,
0.057945203,
0.0174863413,
-0.0159851294,
-0.0521876402,
0.0229464006,
-0.0245374218,
0.0432646647,
0.0039810417,
-0.0203895383,
0.0088654207,
-0.0076363143,
-0.0048163333,
-0.0408293605,
-0.0753131434,
-0.0379733853,
-0.0125050312,
-0.0168451611,
-0.0519010387,
0.0082442667,
0.0365097336,
0.0490672924,
-0.0621987246,
0.0014462996,
2.83262639e-34,
0.0453957766,
0.0075321384,
0.0034247614,
0.0222970992,
-0.0030110553,
0.0170661099,
-0.0142910266,
0.0108235599,
0.0285892375,
0.0040113647,
0.0215719342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07615v1
|
ViWikiFC: Fact-Checking for Vietnamese Wikipedia-Based Textual Knowledge Source
| 2024-05-13T10:24:05 | 2024-05-13T10:24:05 |
Hung Tuan Le, Long Truong To, Manh Trong Nguyen, Kiet Van Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fact-checking is essential due to the explosion of misinformation in the
media ecosystem. Although false information exists in every language and
country, most research to solve the problem mainly concentrated on huge
communities like English and Chinese. Low-resource languages like Vietnamese
are necessary to explore corpora and models for fact verification. To bridge
this gap, we construct ViWikiFC, the first manual annotated open-domain corpus
for Vietnamese Wikipedia Fact Checking more than 20K claims generated by
converting evidence sentences extracted from Wikipedia articles. We analyze our
corpus through many linguistic aspects, from the new dependency rate, the new
n-gram rate, and the new word rate. We conducted various experiments for
Vietnamese fact-checking, including evidence retrieval and verdict prediction.
BM25 and InfoXLM (Large) achieved the best results in two tasks, with BM25
achieving an accuracy of 88.30% for SUPPORTS, 86.93% for REFUTES, and only
56.67% for the NEI label in the evidence retrieval task, InfoXLM (Large)
achieved an F1 score of 86.51%. Furthermore, we also conducted a pipeline
approach, which only achieved a strict accuracy of 67.00% when using InfoXLM
(Large) and BM25. These results demonstrate that our dataset is challenging for
the Vietnamese language model in fact-checking tasks.
|
[
0.0624356121,
0.0046090633,
0.011844716,
0.0412308499,
-0.0685773343,
0.0117964158,
-0.0177762341,
0.0205220226,
0.0303434227,
-0.0584164746,
0.0150817847,
-0.0201588478,
0.0268779192,
0.0187951308,
-0.0167325865,
0.0060350103,
0.0470797941,
0.0220011864,
0.0807035491,
-0.0161205661,
0.0096895471,
0.0183423124,
-0.0532637089,
0.0150553416,
-0.0338897854,
0.0043948409,
0.0346748643,
0.0031707468,
0.0204902031,
-0.0456981584,
0.0346976072,
0.0571381189,
-0.0089232568,
0.0596002564,
0.0000017762,
-0.030256927,
0.0283821039,
0.0061154049,
-0.0310010668,
0.033176776,
0.0346420892,
-0.0190906618,
-0.0145751266,
0.0104534971,
-0.0070366221,
-0.0463342443,
0.0303178094,
0.0633681566,
0.0823458135,
0.0940863788,
-0.0082827229,
-0.0266301837,
0.0109961769,
-0.0031171981,
0.0158741977,
0.0304671433,
0.0619699918,
0.0265968759,
-0.0251854546,
-0.0113857426,
0.0138368579,
0.0247462224,
0.0169615243,
-0.0264713243,
-0.005805599,
0.0167784151,
-0.0365573764,
-0.0393889695,
0.0430332422,
0.0412447564,
0.0354497544,
-0.0597087406,
-0.005894863,
0.0137353921,
0.0056544039,
0.0329314172,
-0.0069858311,
0.0370171964,
-0.0413523391,
0.0023770181,
0.0518849269,
-0.0099941781,
0.0202007964,
0.030446453,
0.0277430788,
0.0350522585,
-0.0141818654,
-0.0447071232,
0.0059701512,
0.0006369611,
-0.0381664112,
-0.0365290008,
0.0075235604,
-0.0111629646,
0.0132945944,
0.0096835252,
-0.0015782535,
-0.0014995793,
0.0856777653,
-0.1156013086,
-0.0760530308,
0.0056878878,
-0.0642039031,
0.0436930358,
-0.0136428578,
-0.0150762452,
-0.0273034964,
-0.0032177358,
0.0208981633,
-0.0241560489,
-0.0361619294,
0.0432389751,
0.0032121483,
0.0079916874,
-0.0079324283,
0.0026487934,
-0.0299975909,
-0.0242901836,
-0.0174662657,
0.0234153587,
0.046492327,
-0.0221857205,
-0.0278062355,
-0.005696293,
-0.0721612573,
0.0679953843,
-0.0037079568,
0.0748450905,
0.0099693472,
-0.0140181826,
0.0147582414,
0.0252227597,
-0.0006951967,
-0.0098624025,
0.0127088018,
-0.0261182487,
0.0058750133,
0.0425299145,
-0.0307063311,
-0.0054544192,
-0.0203369893,
-0.0520213284,
-0.0089017227,
-0.1096045077,
-0.0187939443,
0.0099763339,
0.0124601759,
-0.0238095094,
0.0094267242,
0.0482046902,
-0.0395344272,
0.0574482009,
-0.0165284593,
-0.022009505,
0.0461958088,
0.0057738023,
-0.0076408638,
0.0501902066,
0.005239421,
0.0214816891,
0.0675759465,
0.050771635,
-0.0131573286,
-0.0259089749,
0.0269779321,
0.0195150692,
0.0783001631,
0.0177036319,
-0.0084760962,
0.0016522586,
-0.0084217563,
0.0421267673,
-0.0142857898,
-0.0263914503,
0.0406129844,
-0.0388241522,
-0.0194308087,
-0.0591501296,
0.0375822969,
0.0083982013,
0.0594288595,
-0.0068292897,
-0.0664088279,
0.019943621,
-0.0333156064,
0.0034550223,
0.0013709315,
0.0472908616,
-0.0042614313,
-0.0434490815,
-0.0259118807,
-0.0083318055,
-0.0288440865,
-0.0279613622,
0.0123658897,
0.0135648055,
-0.019124981,
0.0590080954,
0.0784375668,
-0.0311879646,
-0.0193018168,
-0.0445010066,
0.0311570708,
-0.0142021142,
0.038509991,
-0.0073042121,
0.0312179383,
-0.0160053447,
-0.0006035617,
0.0527178533,
0.0557646304,
-0.0417218767,
-0.025820788,
0.0216096845,
0.0064269812,
-0.0048536924,
0.0536056645,
-0.0104649374,
0.0403534584,
0.0451337881,
0.0095878337,
-0.0605560876,
-0.0456781238,
0.0344272666,
0.024726795,
0.0136234146,
-0.0018154576,
0.0099827629,
0.0192677043,
0.0198209994,
-0.0408819541,
-0.0023021137,
0.0458164886,
0.0030527178,
-0.0169321429,
-0.013973576,
0.0456437394,
-0.064459309,
0.0512628108,
-0.0453114994,
-0.0133135607,
0.0550679229,
-0.0069052414,
-0.0089795627,
-0.0415286459,
0.0124123078,
-0.0113977501,
-0.0600994118,
0.003279472,
-0.0243668631,
0.032257881,
0.001519689,
0.0753824487,
-0.027862072,
0.0042358711,
0.0089889793,
-0.0301149376,
0.0192355942,
-0.0116512422,
-0.0403660834,
0.0292316526,
0.0337896794,
0.0184997674,
0.026825415,
-0.0198459756,
-0.0141671477,
0.0132787405,
-0.1079116985,
0.0282178577,
-0.0272830408,
0.0038379531,
0.0197196081,
-0.0536657833,
-0.0223295595,
0.0004593782,
0.0048857289,
0.01278459,
0.012343768,
0.008201167,
0.0055258246,
0.0098762317,
0.0222161599,
-0.0304736942,
-0.0014997498,
-0.0084388526,
0.0218142513,
0.0171616729,
-0.0862950608,
-0.0085670017,
0.0221382435,
-0.060894791,
-0.0210222732,
-0.0154441614,
-0.0029054894,
0.0162990429,
0.0019933847,
-0.0283233244,
0.0087627294,
0.0327158086,
-0.0036537326,
0.0321946479,
-0.0009616719,
-0.0135435658,
-0.008109537,
-0.0107834227,
0.0276063401,
-0.0273292847,
-0.0292841792,
0.0102813132,
0.0205497947,
0.0245485399,
-0.0139713222,
-0.0091177374,
-0.016121069,
-0.0131420959,
0.0003256125,
0.0292324964,
0.004429644,
0.0032358989,
0.02761323,
-0.0244074129,
-0.0117675057,
0.0821637958,
-0.0115414197,
0.0507538989,
-0.0429296456,
0.0051512816,
0.0178254005,
0.0001623026,
-0.0064444179,
-0.0016284405,
0.0359351151,
0.0165755954,
0.0207126196,
0.0375231244,
0.057823386,
-0.0457461812,
0.0255324654,
-0.0124835558,
0.0332968719,
0.0042508435,
-0.0252599306,
-0.0473125055,
-0.0526253507,
-0.0041161142,
-0.0247072279,
-0.0354843438,
0.0190286748,
-0.0542505533,
-0.0061364835,
0.0265242383,
0.0189184807,
0.0074982215,
0.0154843442,
0.0059482353,
0.0388830751,
0.0134475278,
-0.0223547723,
0.047470618,
0.0214280523,
0.0199855454,
0.0634801686,
-0.0339532383,
0.019459242,
0.0169741753,
-0.0517368205,
-0.026502436,
-0.0372846462,
-0.0080621708,
-0.0276953578,
0.0150989695,
-0.0319811366,
0.0077315848,
0.0697923973,
0.0263552573,
-0.0390642807,
-0.0392742306,
0.0104077505,
-0.0086420793,
0.0331047662,
-0.0023465531,
-0.0868563354,
0.0041401004,
0.0109035084,
-0.0192940217,
-0.0259309318,
-0.0113153681,
-0.0037378215,
-0.1002335325,
0.0313034877,
-0.0156556591,
0.0435741283,
-0.060919676,
-0.0822725594,
0.0088462783,
-0.0026918293,
0.0156970024,
0.0221312903,
0.0591040403,
-0.0087081715,
-0.0000451989,
-0.0042956085,
-0.0657599717,
0.0754278228,
-0.0251639578,
0.0493173599,
-0.0202585328,
0.0414426178,
-0.0304239895,
-0.0429512449,
-0.0008870458,
-0.0007954496,
-0.0557454117,
-0.0070588784,
0.080564633,
-0.0310079958,
0.0005535969,
-0.0332331955,
0.0115207992,
-0.0030801136,
-0.0231853388,
0.0245408434,
0.0752076283,
0.0074214777,
-0.0153394099,
-0.020043727,
-0.0116638904,
0.0323269889,
0.054959923,
-0.0197792519,
0.0180830471,
0.0244622659,
-0.0245514493,
-0.0802548975,
-0.0009085852,
-0.0656274185,
0.0506650247,
-0.0025954326,
-0.0521368235,
-0.0938526466,
-0.0208695848,
-0.0191230904,
0.0410813875,
-0.0242637862,
-0.012914815,
0.043703489,
0.0161140971,
-0.0342124887,
0.0051664044,
-0.0377425514,
0.0178348534,
-0.0074649025,
0.0029003718,
0.0192743521,
-0.0084535973,
0.010634589,
0.0151532125,
-0.041408103,
-0.0529410653,
0.0100733824,
0.0224275831,
0.0161208473,
0.0303743556,
-0.0328435451,
0.0120091261,
0.0330457836,
0.0613400638,
-0.0597730391,
-0.0045561357,
-0.0013143843,
-0.0461241417,
0.007722592,
0.026041789,
-0.022588104,
0.0095793372,
-0.0200990643,
0.033413142,
-0.0090707103,
0.0005424471,
0.0439260639,
0.0566093512,
0.065078564,
-0.0288283601,
-0.004172632,
-0.0792749375,
-0.0195153374,
-0.0416698605,
-0.0477777161,
0.0435037017,
0.0378378592,
0.0060964921,
-0.0152508765,
-0.0192454681,
0.0235307608,
-0.0141352136,
0.000051688,
-0.0135513861,
-0.0278362315,
0.0307621732,
0.064123705,
-0.0070280428,
-0.0312933959,
-0.0343416296,
-0.0489805602,
-0.0117942253,
0.0209982339,
-0.0218516383,
0.0290641468,
0.0176117439,
-0.031641975,
0.0237546787,
-0.0446817316,
-0.0485386103,
0.039923057,
-0.0300847981,
0.0163959507,
0.0611300953,
-0.0024254038,
0.0552717671,
-0.0504197367,
-0.0368289277,
-0.0163808614,
-0.0104587749,
-0.0026504367,
-0.003060088,
0.020115165,
-0.0064679319,
-0.0368831791,
0.0383257046,
0.0417683423,
-0.0265071504,
0.0504030548,
0.0228649341,
-0.0650556311,
-0.0163905732,
-0.0494180508,
-0.0401444249,
0.0401582681,
-0.0346388817,
-0.0416132733,
-0.0554434322,
-0.0493757576,
0.0027526778,
0.026761435,
0.0112235239,
0.027963683,
-0.0463306122,
0.0765271187,
0.0599075817,
-0.0100976117,
-0.0679038391,
0.0055440054,
-0.0551965199,
0.0330196731,
0.0340535678,
-6.148551037e-33,
-0.0382196531,
-0.0127677629,
-0.0196137223,
0.0345363542,
0.0332623757,
0.0084408605,
-0.0097945677,
0.0026158558,
-0.0711326152,
0.0813661888,
0.0253208727,
0.042203486,
0.0251629949,
-0.0323120132,
-0.0063382946,
0.0192451142,
0.0117739672,
0.0282821283,
-0.0455587693,
-0.0109664081,
0.0450580083,
-0.0241766013,
0.0576031171,
-0.0860042647,
0.1000032723,
-0.0068301768,
-0.0032615515,
0.0094385119,
-0.0220082514,
0.0436445549,
-0.0138830459,
0.0939268097,
0.0335889235,
-0.0272821952,
0.0081534246,
-0.0356975533,
-0.1066985056,
0.0000527353,
0.0517027974,
0.0081750024,
-0.0146660907,
0.0103076221,
0.0112433508,
0.009103585,
0.001942712,
-0.0005045021,
0.0351841971,
-0.0385678746,
0.0270817019,
0.0137514817,
-0.0642151088,
0.0276913047,
0.0406137519,
0.0122206165,
-0.0530467108,
0.0446197093,
0.0103123523,
-0.0108843111,
-0.1336409003,
0.0201618206,
-0.0648710281,
0.0115928082,
-0.0031894534,
-0.0630430505,
-0.0295868795,
0.0561847277,
-0.0144043593,
0.0087589975,
-0.0530302934,
0.0358837321,
0.0136921862,
0.0350604169,
0.0252883807,
0.1053872928,
0.0388743021,
-0.074931331,
-0.1046699286,
0.0143409241,
0.0412982926,
0.0357931554,
0.0117567126,
-0.0263477061,
-0.0455805697,
-0.0119198421,
-0.0254161246,
-0.0275183804,
-0.0373213813,
-0.0068427436,
-0.007805875,
0.0418848507,
-0.0191607755,
0.0100812158,
0.0182287488,
-0.0346361101,
0.0298292115,
0.0477992147,
-0.0721745491,
0.0132648125,
-0.0197918173,
0.0251027383,
-0.068263039,
0.0355232656,
0.0046458277,
0.0181406252,
-0.0264161322,
0.001763546,
0.0584498569,
-0.0007044497,
-0.0604189336,
0.0163798127,
-0.028106397,
-0.0083404444,
-0.006093441,
-0.0019382505,
0.0038566869,
0.023593273,
0.0065945871,
-0.0233798772,
0.0042649521,
0.0093129249,
-0.0328920558,
-0.050395593,
0.0051891231,
-0.0087191304,
-0.0144133847,
0.0112387454,
-0.0378267914,
0.0476154201,
-0.023806965,
-0.0494163707,
0.025334347,
0.0300192442,
2.527e-7,
0.0286891293,
0.0284840502,
0.0182477999,
0.013400659,
0.0091900686,
0.0165696442,
-0.0075369328,
-0.0045790938,
0.0184611622,
-0.130477488,
-0.0262518227,
0.0474265292,
0.0207384117,
0.0497655272,
-0.0522214435,
-0.0532412119,
-0.0074505773,
-0.0451879054,
-0.0406396762,
-0.0350365862,
0.0023341416,
0.0543484204,
0.0171396267,
-0.0075578089,
-0.0143996729,
-0.0247234702,
0.0564174391,
0.0498291105,
-0.0524369031,
0.0087151639,
0.0878795907,
-0.0140241869,
0.0226231348,
0.0270431601,
-0.0105269495,
0.0151493158,
-0.002971906,
0.0471440256,
0.0174666718,
0.0125876907,
-0.0399778448,
-0.0292943437,
0.0227639042,
-0.0459571145,
0.0498844832,
0.0297102164,
-0.0140115991,
-0.0373823531,
-0.0179653447,
0.0268087722,
0.0354660451,
-0.0051710806,
-0.0510257818,
0.0082518579,
-0.0043557179,
0.0391549654,
-0.0328224264,
-0.0106870579,
-0.0613560267,
0.0071496041,
-0.0443278216,
-0.0594554991,
0.0600253269,
-0.0376666747,
0.0322375782,
-0.0563184656,
0.0536255017,
1.843423328e-34,
0.0338071026,
-0.0073632752,
-0.0175881777,
-0.0495824032,
0.0652584434,
-0.0044545797,
-0.059608046,
-0.0347265601,
-0.0149603141,
-0.0253438484,
0.0099148089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07609v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07609v1
|
NoiseBench: Benchmarking the Impact of Real Label Noise on Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-05-13T10:20:31 | 2024-05-13T10:20:31 |
Elena Merdjanovska, Ansar Aynetdinov, Alan Akbik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Available training data for named entity recognition (NER) often contains a
significant percentage of incorrect labels for entity types and entity
boundaries. Such label noise poses challenges for supervised learning and may
significantly deteriorate model quality. To address this, prior work proposed
various noise-robust learning approaches capable of learning from data with
partially incorrect labels. These approaches are typically evaluated using
simulated noise where the labels in a clean dataset are automatically
corrupted. However, as we show in this paper, this leads to unrealistic noise
that is far easier to handle than real noise caused by human error or
semi-automatic annotation. To enable the study of the impact of various types
of real noise, we introduce NoiseBench, an NER benchmark consisting of clean
training data corrupted with 6 types of real noise, including expert errors,
crowdsourcing errors, automatic annotation errors and LLM errors. We present an
analysis that shows that real noise is significantly more challenging than
simulated noise, and show that current state-of-the-art models for noise-robust
learning fall far short of their theoretically achievable upper bound. We
release NoiseBench to the research community.
|
[
0.0393261574,
0.0626457259,
0.0055876495,
0.033324603,
0.0407976322,
0.0463917069,
-0.0032936656,
0.0277822372,
0.013547047,
-0.0240580793,
-0.0162333697,
-0.0184690021,
0.0100487694,
-0.0185926463,
0.0544659272,
-0.0373813547,
0.0267247446,
-0.0193056539,
0.0424673595,
0.0210833307,
-0.0174976531,
-0.0383450836,
0.0081675407,
-0.0033380906,
-0.0362055637,
0.0199679937,
-0.0074849296,
0.0345569104,
0.0247031823,
-0.0593787394,
0.0306478813,
0.0536011942,
-0.0210667588,
0.0799599513,
0.0000019101,
-0.0449073911,
-0.0356949084,
0.0309736039,
-0.0447073206,
0.0045545027,
0.0110979388,
0.0001377657,
-0.0203912407,
-0.010210216,
0.01706619,
-0.0571336932,
0.0463352762,
0.0753537491,
0.0411977023,
0.0720183477,
-0.0049824822,
0.002274968,
0.03178389,
-0.0292286724,
0.0242002569,
-0.0637046173,
0.04572846,
-0.0176034831,
-0.0401916355,
0.0110845938,
0.0109612728,
0.0021120107,
-0.0245561004,
0.0022865278,
0.0212872233,
0.0319006853,
-0.0357017964,
-0.0058112587,
-0.0052538323,
0.0842981189,
-0.013471962,
0.0252310708,
0.0452301577,
-0.0161955394,
0.0168294813,
-0.0418392718,
0.012953137,
-0.007286686,
-0.0451506339,
0.005344952,
-0.0359228887,
0.0134706637,
0.0474663675,
-0.0197874364,
0.0294215679,
-0.0045288759,
-0.0000691769,
-0.0571099035,
0.031168893,
0.0252780132,
-0.0008060175,
-0.0340680368,
0.004945782,
-0.0019196138,
-0.0097591141,
0.0175460093,
-0.0719716027,
-0.0345036574,
0.0122047188,
-0.0594853051,
-0.0160828419,
-0.0257066172,
-0.0262402054,
0.0473318323,
-0.0338308103,
-0.0195983984,
0.0168253239,
0.0343198292,
0.0337085091,
-0.0020334919,
-0.0085251518,
0.0314021744,
-0.0139175868,
0.0580484606,
-0.0271289386,
0.0312576704,
-0.0524502806,
-0.0091912411,
-0.0426395908,
0.0577292778,
-0.0094518531,
-0.0014393429,
-0.0038421028,
-0.018239513,
-0.031264849,
-0.0383935235,
-0.0050049787,
0.0034290436,
-0.0056899167,
-0.0580824986,
0.0174617115,
-0.0162645504,
0.0009265259,
-0.0199950319,
0.0351090804,
0.0939420983,
0.0403664298,
-0.0837734714,
-0.1071410328,
-0.0109964116,
0.0078907879,
-0.0113968486,
-0.0104015572,
0.0019387063,
-0.0035081473,
-0.0283024237,
-0.0017645898,
-0.0676363185,
0.028823901,
-0.0333241858,
-0.0631857216,
0.0901069045,
-0.0941193402,
-0.0249577388,
0.0405668691,
-0.0007904927,
0.0194341373,
0.031885542,
0.0518718734,
-0.0326116122,
0.0492112935,
-0.0029995139,
0.0163223762,
0.0187363848,
0.0381769873,
-0.0277077425,
0.0176919699,
0.0047751539,
0.0086660711,
0.0176467448,
0.0146863535,
0.0562783256,
-0.0072907577,
-0.0401644036,
0.0524547473,
-0.012311833,
-0.0409958884,
-0.0161125306,
-0.0380625129,
-0.0235398076,
0.0370730981,
-0.0182757769,
-0.0435253792,
-0.0228640679,
-0.0505767651,
0.0118837869,
0.042685125,
0.0223195292,
-0.0265748743,
-0.0452789105,
-0.045772817,
-0.0186848491,
-0.0236711521,
-0.0047838911,
0.0536397733,
0.0106819225,
-0.0646756068,
0.0395215154,
0.02552603,
-0.0079712449,
-0.0117245065,
-0.0129435444,
0.0295405313,
0.0416326299,
0.0429794118,
-0.076415129,
-0.0219514128,
-0.0715021491,
-0.0213316064,
0.0558270961,
0.0234933421,
-0.0062688128,
0.0288570151,
-0.0409314483,
-0.0214135069,
0.0716294795,
0.029844258,
0.0138345081,
0.034553282,
0.0003567686,
0.0071140365,
-0.0630365163,
-0.0816205218,
0.0409868173,
-0.0143982423,
-0.0581359677,
0.0049974546,
0.0221056025,
0.0141666923,
0.0481865741,
-0.0371238366,
-0.0321817286,
0.0169440936,
0.0122048408,
0.0170989502,
-0.0186008122,
0.0127163148,
0.0094381608,
0.0262709633,
-0.0260366891,
-0.0867615938,
0.0002309436,
-0.0371952318,
-0.0294242278,
-0.0349635966,
-0.007374505,
-0.0150484489,
-0.0272517353,
0.0306307431,
0.0248408969,
0.0189691149,
-0.026389122,
0.0654261485,
-0.0278931055,
0.0422271192,
-0.005654783,
0.0181950759,
-0.0037619651,
-0.0277330559,
-0.0558540076,
-0.0215151031,
-0.0254792124,
-0.0005901884,
0.001643175,
-0.0383447297,
-0.0645834357,
-0.0067699142,
-0.0297930837,
-0.0434112288,
-0.0125948507,
0.0309438594,
-0.0246801041,
-0.0041064015,
-0.0260930434,
-0.0402070582,
-0.0038720458,
-0.0066746627,
-0.0373509713,
0.0059884866,
0.0461914055,
-0.0127299726,
-0.0107294125,
-0.0165100545,
0.003177695,
-0.0148927616,
0.0182940178,
0.0355259739,
-0.0756245032,
-0.0849020779,
0.0528968722,
-0.0097014653,
0.0405390672,
0.0078010908,
0.0230907947,
0.0009402077,
0.0378593169,
0.0054145544,
0.0277816504,
-0.0098471753,
0.0244803131,
-0.0084740883,
0.0003646909,
-0.0053955149,
0.037344493,
-0.0021534171,
0.0316652991,
-0.02751383,
-0.0498898961,
0.0098174391,
0.0552010611,
-0.0469551012,
0.0114666456,
-0.0390739553,
0.0015861853,
-0.0135509949,
-0.016826814,
-0.0365408584,
0.0250571482,
-0.0252586454,
0.050152231,
-0.0264206193,
-0.0051829102,
0.0446047485,
-0.0218489189,
0.0098213917,
0.0325897001,
0.0100118481,
0.011085853,
0.013641201,
0.017843226,
-0.0076769567,
0.0751323551,
-0.0679029301,
-0.0051339515,
-0.0011423049,
0.0583497025,
-0.0469517782,
0.0203327872,
-0.008907727,
0.0359152779,
-0.0056747291,
-0.0214115158,
-0.0497012511,
0.005939289,
-0.0216695741,
-0.0095772455,
0.0026883155,
-0.0280567724,
-0.0115944473,
0.0139402151,
-0.0190913584,
0.0463692918,
0.0275666714,
-0.0284195654,
-0.011515962,
0.0577953383,
0.010495468,
0.0168713517,
0.0631202757,
-0.043292243,
-0.0254486203,
0.0113997245,
0.0100804185,
0.0091337562,
0.0138485767,
-0.0108482102,
0.0192902777,
-0.0326906145,
0.0091946824,
0.0201658197,
0.0417887419,
-0.0182944313,
-0.0379790589,
0.0829745233,
-0.0086003933,
-0.003195253,
-0.0188250057,
0.0265367627,
0.0278653502,
0.0211912952,
0.0092725791,
-0.0471267998,
-0.0256888624,
0.0316884778,
0.0496035628,
-0.0062124343,
-0.0834547132,
0.0225867406,
-0.1126952171,
0.0401870161,
-0.0121216709,
-0.0706413463,
-0.0202445854,
-0.0589559115,
0.022420641,
-0.04933431,
0.0259163734,
-0.0265713446,
0.016615279,
-0.0241989717,
0.0414161421,
-0.0190470014,
-0.0746850744,
-0.0329072513,
-0.0599561967,
0.1160911694,
0.0396757238,
0.0020592592,
-0.0382690504,
-0.0389125161,
0.0487933308,
0.0391793363,
-0.0318368599,
0.0174627118,
0.101814121,
-0.0132033797,
-0.0322491974,
-0.016881831,
-0.0260008723,
-0.0243525226,
0.0178324264,
-0.0092038624,
0.030332379,
0.0161524639,
0.0114535913,
0.0078823958,
-0.0271105096,
0.0261268355,
0.0677803904,
0.0196232405,
-0.0179556385,
-0.0310996883,
-0.033939857,
0.0325707085,
-0.0341638885,
0.0033463356,
0.0510141999,
-0.0670093074,
-0.0895433277,
-0.0365441479,
-0.0797019452,
0.0103436494,
0.0391078442,
0.0205274206,
-0.0066369884,
0.0408230387,
0.0142739117,
-0.0438545458,
-0.0130929928,
-0.0047722873,
0.0073522208,
-0.0731951147,
0.0045519504,
-0.0009321557,
0.0214824267,
-0.0355364643,
0.0337001719,
-0.0961256102,
-0.0748558566,
0.0432539023,
0.0215533208,
0.0187997054,
0.0458849035,
-0.0118037295,
-0.0419611372,
0.014131411,
0.1000671312,
-0.0051613646,
-0.0223487504,
0.0437334999,
-0.0108786048,
-0.0244662035,
0.0026137708,
-0.0475547276,
0.0151948743,
0.0409986712,
0.0074355705,
-0.0546005778,
-0.0121800425,
-0.007888345,
0.0312343389,
0.0562399887,
-0.0124747632,
-0.0494593605,
-0.0354651585,
0.0137132863,
0.0295267496,
0.0085352547,
-0.0029952135,
-0.0315906368,
0.0131992996,
0.0006029318,
-0.0244041011,
0.0642595813,
-0.0048955204,
0.0498501547,
-0.0208972562,
-0.0410173759,
-0.0019689165,
0.0747090802,
0.0062324908,
-0.0381721482,
0.0192168932,
0.0739447922,
0.0740522668,
0.0713956729,
0.020587828,
-0.0403027385,
0.0152396234,
0.0311596394,
0.0134237558,
-0.0300107338,
-0.0269784033,
0.0045054629,
-0.0450402237,
0.0717007145,
0.0379849263,
0.0095899953,
0.0171654969,
-0.0343496539,
-0.0149687296,
0.0056682019,
-0.0205758456,
0.010490736,
0.0036793388,
0.0012626878,
0.0179188997,
-0.0033762658,
-0.0102686053,
0.0589096881,
0.033618398,
0.05553798,
-0.0387725197,
-0.0104711661,
-0.0585820377,
0.0097560994,
-0.0066923955,
-0.0116596408,
-0.0184564069,
0.0088699283,
-0.0434310511,
-0.063442409,
0.0341486,
-0.005740352,
0.0346147269,
0.0099800937,
-0.0129150115,
-0.0041693677,
0.015974747,
0.0234426521,
-0.0180252139,
-0.0100033842,
0.0462005511,
-0.0359226055,
0.0004625442,
-6.116257636e-33,
-0.0282261167,
-0.0488587432,
-0.0121591855,
-0.0590692833,
0.0036804515,
0.0203537364,
-0.0087843407,
0.0085131591,
0.0132901259,
-0.0037902498,
-0.0204761792,
0.0081143463,
0.0255507082,
0.0018082816,
-0.0008507117,
-0.0435440466,
0.0570679754,
-0.0092178704,
-0.0090023009,
-0.0267902892,
0.0165580064,
0.0578602441,
0.0506635793,
-0.1253183335,
0.0766739696,
0.021236686,
-0.0389547758,
0.0030475047,
0.0559505038,
0.0353610851,
0.0024159907,
0.0098971361,
-0.009239668,
-0.0200142488,
-0.0072378977,
-0.043416366,
-0.1550284028,
0.0137119936,
-0.0579492636,
0.0607961006,
-0.0165234096,
-0.011434109,
0.080737032,
-0.0085202884,
-0.0135842478,
0.0065532434,
0.0289801136,
-0.0354031771,
-0.0186688285,
-0.028683966,
-0.0261327345,
0.0577958263,
-0.001312859,
0.0524137244,
0.0563910045,
-0.0276463907,
0.019248819,
0.0172128566,
-0.1161620319,
-0.0102684004,
0.0566640534,
-0.020471666,
-0.005651549,
0.0367065109,
-0.0291006621,
0.042021405,
0.0638715699,
0.0575621538,
-0.0019499338,
-0.0231012795,
0.0226306748,
0.0187969301,
0.0267087705,
0.0753069818,
0.0602062009,
-0.0370139927,
-0.0476680547,
0.0466520488,
-0.0078267902,
-0.0486391075,
-0.0151760802,
-0.0238847788,
-0.0741779283,
0.0058857799,
0.0080027618,
-0.0348916054,
-0.0420052707,
0.0337904058,
0.0112132328,
0.0195710361,
-0.0270106588,
0.0133399544,
-0.0211108625,
-0.0100670028,
-0.0531786159,
-0.0237404313,
0.0561273359,
0.0091706524,
-0.003881739,
-0.022062989,
-0.0221760217,
-0.0503036603,
-0.0007433014,
0.014604941,
0.0291372314,
-0.0250670873,
0.069200784,
-0.0138559695,
-0.0819298625,
0.0148382913,
0.0159032829,
0.0685355067,
0.0336485319,
-0.0069189151,
0.0274612289,
-0.048480358,
0.0100765992,
0.0049326862,
0.0566676073,
0.0301994421,
0.026479125,
0.048472099,
-0.0106643578,
0.0170574896,
0.0152486814,
-0.0229243543,
0.0083130756,
-0.0205166545,
0.022335086,
-0.0401496105,
0.0198163539,
-0.0108229471,
2.636e-7,
-0.0190201588,
0.0502234399,
0.0354234837,
0.0038409594,
-0.0027510074,
0.0425456241,
0.0107945167,
0.0264988989,
-0.0330384895,
-0.0376388803,
0.0046706116,
-0.0477816127,
0.0565059856,
0.0466152094,
-0.0753388479,
-0.0799749494,
-0.0049626348,
0.0347016938,
-0.0168567542,
0.0264511835,
0.0175059494,
0.0588903464,
0.0158785488,
-0.0405856706,
0.003123658,
-0.0199565981,
0.0393732861,
-0.0265100431,
0.0394871049,
0.020729376,
0.0442205109,
0.0388748161,
-0.0063633551,
0.0303747822,
-0.0243943632,
-0.0273651928,
0.0213251431,
0.0192561857,
0.0018211862,
0.0203299876,
-0.0315719359,
-0.0020601435,
0.0406673625,
0.0026755363,
0.0309012998,
0.0040893918,
-0.0116858762,
-0.0120893177,
-0.0526432432,
-0.0238198061,
0.0548559129,
0.0014859686,
-0.0143197794,
-0.0106661245,
0.0001001683,
0.0012022778,
-0.0002080421,
-0.0337542854,
0.0268933829,
-0.0095766075,
0.0189466178,
-0.0128179239,
0.010681048,
-0.0012094199,
0.0265725013,
-0.0485650487,
-0.0061520203,
2.011238003e-34,
0.0362541266,
-0.0172981601,
0.0093773203,
0.0351921096,
-0.0016363132,
-0.000289777,
-0.0177327488,
-0.0269409902,
-0.0101263318,
-0.0015787872,
0.0209431555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07597v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07597v1
|
Using Model-Theoretic Approaches to Uncover Linguistic Organization
| 2024-05-13T09:58:59 | 2024-05-13T09:58:59 |
Olivia Griffin, Jerry Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we consider pluractional markers in Kaqchikel, Karuk, and
Yurok. Like Balinese, each of these languages marks one type of pluractionality
via reduplication, and a different type of pluractionality via
non-reduplicative affixation. This paper serves as a proof-of-concept for
applying model-theoretic approaches to language as a lens that can help us to
recognize linguistic organization that is not apparent on the surface.
|
[
0.0123734642,
0.0223822296,
-0.0620717704,
0.0147736659,
-0.0232876502,
0.0092964014,
-0.0250602048,
0.0215185639,
-0.0408724211,
-0.0188441407,
-0.0205271859,
-0.0331185646,
0.0613685958,
-0.0250135679,
0.0514123291,
-0.0539915636,
0.0367222987,
-0.0210536029,
0.045475401,
0.0538484715,
0.0184993818,
-0.0075941915,
-0.0194342826,
0.0067866831,
-0.0229591615,
-0.0202054437,
-0.0358490869,
-0.0249888431,
0.0161378458,
0.019505322,
-0.0515079498,
-0.002008897,
-0.0456508957,
0.0472982787,
0.0000017243,
-0.0423553623,
-0.0102990465,
-0.0300463848,
-0.0112332534,
0.047157798,
0.0315110907,
-0.0030284708,
-0.0380986929,
-0.0141326189,
0.002121977,
-0.014829223,
0.0750829875,
-0.0014005887,
-0.0258321483,
0.0307225306,
-0.0091723511,
-0.0470618159,
0.0062231305,
-0.0034200209,
-0.0837822407,
0.0472433567,
0.0041495957,
0.0420108885,
0.0256566219,
-0.0374298692,
-0.0215297323,
0.0534612983,
0.0092454916,
-0.0302889645,
-0.0402442329,
-0.0145584336,
0.0161737911,
-0.0477949977,
0.0440334342,
0.0022233161,
-0.0006237496,
-0.0364633203,
-0.0076802312,
0.0111271339,
0.0028714358,
0.0670551434,
-0.0186605938,
0.0386715643,
-0.0043684458,
0.0358059816,
0.0761509389,
-0.0046111015,
0.0236625969,
-0.0165229142,
-0.0440273322,
0.1021566167,
0.0387675613,
0.0020647901,
-0.0256900508,
-0.0229948815,
0.0166786425,
-0.0310673025,
-0.018224014,
0.0300449897,
0.0056297146,
0.0141376015,
0.0495676696,
0.0169552732,
0.0035878858,
-0.0297204908,
0.0768186226,
0.0112361684,
-0.0426104963,
0.0190011505,
-0.0123367319,
0.006501439,
-0.0138053326,
-0.0161989555,
-0.0607338138,
0.0342478901,
-0.0149725294,
-0.049200546,
-0.0528313518,
-0.0022181319,
-0.0024061035,
0.0169019531,
-0.0282206945,
0.0427131765,
0.0437122993,
-0.0239425115,
-0.0755809695,
-0.0929607227,
0.0101575609,
0.0067389482,
0.0164176021,
0.0218625776,
-0.0265315101,
0.0146243358,
-0.0506532192,
-0.0503015928,
0.031701155,
0.0547834672,
-0.0448909663,
0.009551052,
-0.0735006481,
0.0022910305,
0.005488825,
0.0222443342,
-0.0130432211,
-0.014549369,
-0.0276899487,
-0.0441628136,
-0.0059742723,
-0.0099390447,
-0.0045352466,
0.0030312566,
-0.0247862004,
-0.0513646454,
-0.031036498,
-0.0482534133,
0.0116662253,
0.0153978141,
-0.0014743237,
0.0467232466,
0.0166584179,
0.0031633661,
0.0059319907,
0.0221087188,
0.0276544336,
-0.0246034153,
0.0657028258,
-0.0614050329,
0.0537125841,
0.0433225632,
-0.0233488288,
-0.0126358364,
-0.0384668596,
-0.0345810615,
0.0248288307,
-0.0459484942,
-0.0140477018,
0.0538617037,
-0.0101161841,
0.0140716648,
-0.0037015758,
0.059314169,
0.0360896215,
-0.015477322,
0.0015371453,
-0.0256178007,
0.0051509645,
0.0640256032,
0.0321045555,
-0.0246303417,
-0.0591216795,
0.0350762717,
-0.038515009,
-0.0006760937,
0.0012314986,
-0.0385981239,
-0.0559432395,
0.0070578344,
0.0192428902,
-0.0418840051,
0.042810861,
0.039766185,
0.0098523451,
0.0054453234,
0.0323397107,
-0.0301151965,
0.0108041605,
-0.0557846203,
0.0412414484,
-0.0396035872,
-0.0255680494,
-0.0482650995,
0.0496192425,
0.0360874422,
-0.0060916422,
0.0475411713,
-0.0273938794,
-0.0267960448,
-0.009353308,
-0.0249753725,
0.0281572528,
0.0526326187,
0.0472293869,
-0.0109157609,
-0.0866583958,
0.043079216,
-0.0100787003,
-0.0155094713,
0.001616884,
0.0216917899,
-0.0374022759,
0.0295010861,
-0.0420156308,
0.0236392543,
-0.001377117,
0.0281849969,
-0.0059722904,
0.0678589493,
0.0557507835,
-0.0299327653,
0.0431769229,
0.0574575998,
0.0161443539,
0.0258367211,
0.0540268905,
-0.0037934657,
0.0307594631,
-0.0455297157,
0.0587965436,
-0.0315297469,
0.1070854738,
-0.0317691825,
0.0754826814,
-0.0265933629,
0.076039426,
-0.0205753315,
0.0108768027,
-0.0176236946,
0.0563696697,
-0.0091930684,
0.0103053721,
-0.0022039963,
-0.0294621997,
0.027883308,
-0.0278724283,
0.0459727123,
0.0447843373,
-0.0054707006,
-0.0197178964,
0.0134993764,
-0.0503492467,
-0.0104274955,
-0.0420467071,
-0.0418832824,
-0.052718617,
-0.0202344321,
0.0546608642,
0.0075044185,
0.0332449898,
0.0066731982,
-0.0008597348,
0.054260347,
-0.0110931722,
0.037344031,
0.0180439446,
0.0260579754,
-0.0280240905,
-0.0982965678,
-0.0189865865,
-0.0155041628,
0.0001593162,
0.0325119756,
-0.029544197,
-0.1035434455,
-0.0701365322,
-0.0266265273,
-0.0458732061,
-0.0262402333,
-0.0274336245,
-0.0615537874,
0.01041611,
0.0099078752,
0.0177161451,
0.0102601834,
-0.0482831784,
0.050370153,
0.0053790528,
-0.0282760616,
0.0138884848,
-0.0396339186,
0.0004759001,
0.0243078675,
-0.0217200983,
-0.0183416754,
-0.0173676331,
0.0850709304,
0.0110767847,
-0.0024523693,
0.0242606122,
0.0121180182,
-0.0840355158,
0.0196298212,
0.0379340649,
-0.0446239673,
-0.0272557121,
0.0728655681,
-0.0224435199,
-0.0297808573,
-0.0088512767,
-0.0063511366,
-0.0370923243,
0.0032247007,
-0.0150198871,
-0.0388346724,
0.0652374551,
-0.0063112346,
0.006000577,
0.0747825131,
-0.0546275899,
-0.0199811608,
-0.0240951274,
-0.0091653615,
0.0161742382,
0.0529406816,
-0.0695822686,
0.0130037414,
0.0047576232,
-0.0161169171,
-0.0107399737,
0.0065128636,
0.0066027101,
0.0371158235,
-0.0299748369,
0.0187866483,
0.0105205001,
0.0549913459,
-0.0231296569,
-0.0291959345,
0.0243950896,
0.0470042937,
0.0025899701,
0.0642746016,
0.0078597441,
0.0175566226,
0.0224709176,
-0.0095495097,
-0.0079135951,
0.0115432758,
-0.0539005734,
0.0158843827,
0.0097734276,
-0.0101716556,
0.0309679098,
-0.022183001,
-0.0671020225,
-0.0590252057,
-0.0001306692,
-0.0053594867,
0.0264385641,
0.0492039286,
0.0345347524,
0.0373096429,
0.070219405,
-0.0207309257,
0.0204068404,
0.0228450894,
-0.0274015889,
-0.034145005,
0.0490257666,
0.000479467,
-0.0567875393,
-0.0019767156,
0.0123626553,
0.0138567369,
-0.0536890365,
-0.0203107968,
0.0219892543,
-0.0579894483,
-0.0161464456,
-0.0049873427,
0.0084794462,
0.0068542259,
-0.0128781004,
0.0549692214,
-0.0130729638,
-0.0039020823,
0.033505775,
-0.0451161452,
-0.0608593673,
-0.0709493086,
-0.0375853144,
0.0043313568,
0.0202645753,
0.0327697694,
-0.0620267987,
-0.0128291287,
0.0564300977,
0.022221759,
-0.0099599035,
0.0086414916,
-0.0531311445,
0.0713043585,
-0.0138570881,
-0.0437923335,
0.0162112098,
-0.0203293748,
-0.0091440706,
0.0191201996,
0.0467328653,
-0.005751885,
-0.0192828942,
0.0276888255,
-0.0048700147,
-0.0058603375,
0.0060332217,
0.0394719094,
-0.0050248085,
0.019389702,
-0.025442034,
0.0092302132,
0.0995754004,
-0.0448442288,
0.0362658054,
0.0145591898,
-0.053715121,
-0.0844404399,
-0.0431002416,
0.0084172776,
0.0280545689,
0.0308721643,
0.0127148712,
0.0057039978,
-0.0376496576,
-0.0388549939,
-0.0145002939,
-0.0057996754,
-0.0130911237,
-0.0620753616,
-0.0315468907,
-0.0008177527,
-0.0317803323,
0.0102848066,
-0.0332805365,
0.0058568465,
-0.0693702772,
0.0491088405,
-0.0187792741,
0.0317710713,
-0.0463661999,
-0.0139841931,
-0.0536298417,
-0.0268073808,
-0.0441468321,
-0.0170462038,
0.0837250724,
0.01314619,
-0.060955748,
0.0075560561,
0.0659273416,
0.0165994298,
0.048427321,
-0.0061387322,
-0.0188475642,
-0.0828765109,
-0.0157478452,
0.0015289736,
0.0199328456,
0.0255712606,
-0.0346397832,
-0.0246274527,
-0.0225089211,
-0.0380067192,
-0.0443408489,
-0.0006677781,
-0.0294400156,
0.0085156243,
0.0431283154,
0.0233329795,
-0.0333086848,
-0.037970759,
-0.0168501157,
-0.0030516963,
0.0433183759,
0.0395883247,
0.0510622747,
0.0054450929,
0.0065778052,
0.0490253307,
0.0370207503,
0.0841213763,
-0.0866031721,
0.0289929006,
-0.036045853,
-0.0071796426,
0.0163284354,
-0.0035193276,
0.002378375,
0.0426700749,
0.0510337837,
-0.0094274133,
0.0516794994,
-0.04333774,
0.045250088,
-0.0386365205,
0.0714432225,
-0.0213802606,
-0.0067058024,
-0.0354909897,
0.0625237897,
0.0180217754,
-0.0179901198,
-0.0340262838,
0.0375392437,
-0.0307134576,
0.0355040915,
0.0277587064,
0.0009317373,
-0.023382986,
0.0128208967,
0.0066607627,
-0.019358797,
-0.0043250676,
0.0225877222,
-0.0235550366,
0.0048587103,
0.0259813592,
-0.1132407412,
-0.0377515964,
-0.0124955568,
-0.0044934922,
0.0095968116,
0.0032366137,
-0.0147249205,
0.0421891622,
0.0341714248,
0.0105987089,
-0.0568513647,
-0.0206308495,
-0.0164155643,
0.0232280251,
0.0562496856,
-5.492976368e-33,
-0.0461567268,
-0.03775144,
-0.0116373179,
-0.0326443426,
0.0008595983,
0.0200318377,
0.0059025185,
0.0180337988,
-0.0496809445,
0.0264586639,
-0.0041299602,
0.0055878828,
0.0103043737,
-0.0174267888,
0.0508011952,
0.0416311063,
0.0005082768,
-0.0073094522,
-0.0166755281,
-0.0498350337,
0.0452009477,
-0.0448995978,
0.1013335884,
-0.0233047996,
0.0078836959,
-0.0210941397,
-0.0274403356,
0.040474914,
-0.034721572,
0.0579506382,
-0.0323929787,
0.0063286312,
0.0133341327,
0.0135171516,
-0.0108846016,
-0.0536143519,
-0.01757163,
-0.0483112559,
0.0618547872,
0.0322721973,
-0.0312599614,
-0.0215236563,
0.0039517106,
-0.036709588,
-0.0110292798,
0.0021356586,
-0.0152879907,
-0.0113420896,
0.000649943,
0.1229317263,
-0.0777099654,
0.0180485249,
-0.0147452485,
-0.0041533448,
0.107782796,
-0.0541009866,
-0.014860644,
-0.0630664453,
-0.0307358708,
0.0319148488,
0.012621941,
0.072214365,
0.0490955748,
0.0580496341,
-0.026897002,
0.0005485533,
0.040118888,
-0.0065357173,
0.0497261658,
0.026893001,
0.0205704309,
0.0787157938,
0.0056053465,
-0.0019045504,
-0.0265818201,
-0.0090251165,
-0.005739551,
-0.0561622791,
0.0473266952,
-0.0365249738,
-0.0301299077,
0.0301537942,
-0.0649881661,
-0.0503400266,
0.0119042639,
-0.0896193162,
-0.003084647,
0.0013885603,
-0.0152371963,
-0.0160766523,
0.0046249349,
0.0252130758,
0.0146225607,
-0.0174262077,
-0.0457955301,
-0.010824875,
-0.0312544294,
0.0530529395,
0.0040622209,
-0.0028209283,
-0.0019742805,
0.0095130866,
-0.0181376282,
0.0336381234,
0.0249547083,
0.0130143156,
-0.0211354997,
0.0335542485,
-0.0299028903,
-0.0022931728,
0.0120064663,
-0.0507667325,
0.0167126264,
-0.0128736915,
0.0492620766,
0.01475624,
0.02250796,
0.0410969853,
0.0614364669,
-0.0049220896,
0.0065480103,
0.0312906504,
-0.0169291738,
-0.0196780525,
-0.0161303431,
-0.0103463866,
0.0282656662,
0.0681935176,
0.0904578343,
0.0111289928,
-0.0165458079,
-0.0128201554,
2.677e-7,
0.0564219467,
0.043924544,
0.0663175508,
0.006828391,
0.0277442969,
-0.0014443106,
-0.0376649983,
-0.0149916839,
-0.0371120907,
-0.0300079547,
0.0066248714,
-0.0062730787,
0.0171803534,
0.0057308208,
-0.0362513177,
0.0244193915,
-0.0272164531,
0.0011695249,
-0.026753325,
-0.0387196951,
-0.0302298572,
0.0480330326,
0.0171493646,
-0.0231530052,
-0.0580664203,
0.0004266025,
0.0120343687,
0.0073638251,
-0.0172887333,
0.0406496339,
0.0080047008,
-0.0741980299,
0.0147053218,
-0.0005296888,
0.0044679018,
0.0378318615,
0.0563365296,
0.0151413009,
-0.0204688851,
0.0472414494,
0.017516911,
-0.0394105911,
-0.0205002371,
-0.0254210886,
0.0274234656,
0.0529089607,
-0.0264388658,
-0.0074213729,
0.0018005227,
0.0429508612,
0.0289241783,
-0.0069647445,
-0.0030498134,
0.051003024,
0.0031739247,
-0.0307817105,
-0.0202964563,
-0.0119861988,
-0.0640231147,
-0.0324762277,
0.0135846622,
-0.0272254571,
0.0342406407,
-0.0133419018,
0.0020044951,
-0.0567902811,
-0.0442799963,
2.317701549e-34,
0.0099029969,
-0.0059375893,
0.0325493701,
0.0389007926,
0.0047899652,
-0.0397722609,
-0.021327788,
0.0599303767,
0.0304392651,
-0.031359192,
0.0065368214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07586v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07586v1
|
Thai Universal Dependency Treebank
| 2024-05-13T09:48:13 | 2024-05-13T09:48:13 |
Panyut Sriwirote, Wei Qi Leong, Charin Polpanumas, Santhawat Thanyawong, William Chandra Tjhi, Wirote Aroonmanakun, Attapol T. Rutherford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic dependency parsing of Thai sentences has been underexplored, as
evidenced by the lack of large Thai dependency treebanks with complete
dependency structures and the lack of a published systematic evaluation of
state-of-the-art models, especially transformer-based parsers. In this work, we
address these problems by introducing Thai Universal Dependency Treebank (TUD),
a new largest Thai treebank consisting of 3,627 trees annotated in accordance
with the Universal Dependencies (UD) framework. We then benchmark dependency
parsing models that incorporate pretrained transformers as encoders and train
them on Thai-PUD and our TUD. The evaluation results show that most of our
models can outperform other models reported in previous papers and provide
insight into the optimal choices of components to include in Thai dependency
parsers. The new treebank and every model's full prediction generated in our
experiment are made available on a GitHub repository for further study.
|
[
0.0578478836,
0.0572163016,
0.008420107,
0.0597658977,
-0.0105117941,
0.0205374844,
-0.0401870608,
-0.0283333436,
-0.0481679142,
0.0012218877,
-0.0078801084,
-0.0179975256,
-0.0090194484,
0.0132152596,
-0.0435403176,
-0.1024421677,
-0.0052725202,
0.0244457498,
-0.0252817664,
0.0177756399,
0.0303032491,
-0.0105208587,
0.0134398425,
0.0233556554,
-0.066982463,
-0.0348658971,
0.0201610755,
0.0281766951,
0.005819608,
-0.062445689,
0.0360308588,
0.0411506444,
-0.0237714984,
-0.0381045751,
0.0000019531,
-0.0228874683,
-0.018298557,
-0.0408826657,
-0.0258844923,
0.0112204021,
-0.0111674704,
-0.0838057995,
0.004962835,
0.0341645442,
-0.0065178704,
-0.034461204,
0.0553488322,
0.0630869418,
0.0536071695,
0.0735099539,
-0.0401456058,
-0.0802460909,
0.0224498622,
-0.0400401726,
-0.0527024493,
-0.0137453889,
-0.0077855811,
0.0080241757,
-0.0395325907,
-0.0347334146,
-0.0349852927,
0.0067683905,
0.0433187,
0.0191833954,
0.0367350914,
0.0047326111,
-0.0252663679,
-0.0101072378,
0.0067306217,
0.0426617227,
-0.0267634559,
-0.0078946827,
-0.0308196973,
-0.0079404106,
-0.0335946381,
0.0117778117,
-0.0149525506,
0.0354552567,
-0.0059501352,
0.0466486402,
0.0318463072,
0.0516282544,
-0.0093623977,
-0.0266811904,
-0.0188912582,
0.058454264,
-0.0053482689,
-0.0494094454,
-0.0261522755,
0.0200649761,
0.0012522385,
-0.0293593761,
0.0334400125,
-0.0403283946,
0.0219922047,
0.0140123377,
0.00142752,
0.0010490584,
0.0116469776,
-0.0336105004,
-0.0475612134,
0.0558415614,
-0.0907611549,
0.003560381,
0.0070393584,
0.0458610542,
-0.0314736106,
-0.0039879908,
-0.0324273594,
0.0160325952,
-0.0081994385,
0.0063838311,
-0.058524996,
0.0387681536,
-0.0228592902,
-0.0115724532,
-0.041247692,
-0.0166779011,
0.0325066969,
-0.033179,
0.0592897721,
0.02660436,
-0.0599335283,
0.021283064,
0.0072304243,
0.0676315278,
0.0156563055,
-0.0088723572,
-0.037217848,
-0.0445881709,
0.0080804694,
0.0264847018,
0.0311766118,
-0.0475455634,
0.0010213431,
0.0011030182,
0.0028377527,
-0.024535764,
0.0014317365,
0.0421367474,
0.0017112752,
0.0007393332,
-0.0061316947,
-0.0510427319,
0.0270366687,
0.0231280942,
0.0629670396,
-0.0078696301,
0.0319905058,
0.0187023319,
0.0234986041,
0.0634655654,
0.0067963609,
-0.0136155849,
-0.0343856178,
-0.0074799075,
-0.0057907808,
0.0252341367,
-0.0029026701,
0.0118979411,
-0.0014753976,
-0.0012210833,
-0.0034456546,
0.0185659416,
-0.0355482399,
-0.0128449751,
0.0294806287,
0.0005694343,
-0.0320530646,
0.0037997328,
0.003327135,
0.039224118,
-0.0227262285,
0.0139881158,
0.0055157146,
-0.008638164,
-0.0191803053,
0.0085103819,
0.044007998,
0.0159311537,
-0.0045553199,
0.0531821288,
-0.0341998897,
-0.0198415648,
0.0155763328,
0.0124686919,
-0.0755429938,
0.0008708775,
0.0023261334,
-0.0464140289,
-0.0105201891,
-0.0703077018,
-0.0410789922,
-0.0476177745,
0.0567065589,
0.0371746719,
-0.0389155261,
0.0909840763,
0.0351730622,
-0.0553288013,
-0.0328128487,
0.0402420796,
-0.0312830508,
0.0529708341,
0.0444218107,
-0.0056382259,
-0.025610093,
0.007444656,
-0.0251872372,
0.0596757233,
-0.0244326051,
-0.012173729,
0.0089768376,
-0.0428076908,
0.0382012166,
0.0416209996,
0.0103879161,
0.0273805764,
-0.0168923214,
-0.026645435,
0.0142108547,
0.0710875839,
-0.0160212014,
0.0352800004,
0.0182468593,
0.0353827551,
0.0316918492,
0.0200840086,
0.0601116084,
0.015067365,
-0.0308451336,
0.0093646767,
0.0324494243,
-0.0788812563,
-0.0185729023,
0.0498416051,
-0.0890944302,
-0.0454442874,
0.0103248162,
-0.0695012584,
0.0049432237,
0.0683556274,
-0.006578417,
-0.0283413678,
-0.011044655,
0.0020804219,
0.0286673419,
-0.024475202,
0.0354125351,
-0.002415922,
0.0675169528,
-0.0086702257,
0.0801100507,
-0.0186978541,
-0.0054514823,
-0.0173375104,
0.0110736173,
0.0371864811,
-0.0025766795,
-0.038094379,
0.018937761,
0.0028432808,
-0.0353786349,
0.0092518572,
0.0180932675,
-0.0080547137,
-0.017925486,
-0.064149484,
0.0011710528,
-0.0417760424,
0.0632120073,
0.0169592779,
0.0088591464,
-0.0163317062,
-0.0471640229,
0.0186828785,
-0.031076353,
0.0179096255,
-0.0225160364,
-0.0153206084,
0.016700346,
0.017646065,
-0.0407463163,
-0.010226924,
0.0055118473,
0.020312259,
0.003869415,
-0.0811840147,
0.0110870646,
0.0259100832,
0.0287857652,
0.0027286769,
0.0113954647,
-0.0502677374,
0.0153298555,
-0.0086956695,
0.0456631295,
-0.0387547351,
-0.016559789,
-0.0072797025,
-0.0164332166,
-0.0084783174,
-0.0088508986,
0.0039575696,
-0.0085898098,
0.0381642357,
-0.0697175637,
-0.0203086231,
-0.0297545195,
0.0802356675,
0.0061656432,
0.0024144198,
-0.0359627493,
-0.0561993904,
-0.0409860499,
0.0064453641,
0.010715845,
-0.0398216173,
-0.0333035663,
0.0079998588,
-0.0179770719,
-0.0252707731,
0.0303708669,
-0.0178927667,
-0.0318954438,
-0.045596648,
0.0369638614,
-0.0575629361,
0.0801373795,
0.066337876,
-0.0232564006,
0.0302583557,
-0.0739987567,
0.0382107347,
0.0558784306,
0.002445824,
0.0014156644,
0.0342012458,
-0.0309818015,
0.0191262346,
-0.0147434538,
-0.0647779405,
-0.0464124158,
-0.0247101951,
-0.0348766409,
-0.0057111513,
0.0140054347,
-0.0113019096,
0.0368383005,
0.02850434,
-0.0295149479,
0.0059045935,
0.0183211155,
0.0262762383,
-0.0263080113,
0.0613496043,
-0.0064338641,
-0.0042813434,
-0.0057264441,
0.0297425129,
0.0364629105,
0.0149053531,
0.0332977995,
0.0022512905,
-0.0341408513,
-0.0073844218,
0.0048487228,
-0.0067664068,
-0.0282944515,
-0.0302547328,
-0.0325418934,
-0.0233056005,
-0.0098952018,
0.0981175303,
0.0744203627,
-0.0437249541,
0.0284148715,
-0.0123434626,
0.0309252627,
0.0142969321,
0.0023814128,
-0.083570078,
-0.0301145129,
0.0212424286,
-0.0263757035,
0.0012634185,
-0.0155222015,
0.0191284921,
-0.1045904607,
-0.0064118644,
-0.0197283477,
0.03008819,
-0.0241089892,
0.0233869273,
-0.0278968047,
-0.0532285869,
0.0156287961,
0.0220766142,
-0.0118295625,
-0.0197473802,
0.0607668571,
-0.0931466445,
-0.0821372867,
0.0276481546,
-0.0337429419,
-0.0169391669,
0.0447447933,
-0.0018893693,
-0.0379535444,
0.0202080086,
0.0350919515,
-0.0550706498,
-0.0026345516,
0.0036531917,
0.0448603369,
0.006605214,
-0.0379309468,
0.0094916215,
-0.0056426451,
-0.0685040653,
0.0262153726,
0.005408308,
0.055855792,
0.0003447191,
0.0320164189,
0.0524415933,
-0.0547694005,
-0.0073442687,
0.0137011847,
-0.0027909514,
-0.0338584147,
-0.0228793044,
-0.0528942421,
0.0037788951,
-0.0646209568,
-0.0289741028,
0.0294679217,
0.0151057858,
-0.0493758991,
-0.0925861597,
-0.0679678693,
0.0221005026,
-0.0170527175,
-0.0296825822,
-0.0184599031,
0.0438618809,
0.0100897998,
0.0450939648,
0.0369784236,
0.0082272766,
0.005590206,
-0.0391073264,
-0.0138352877,
0.040074531,
0.0157667231,
-0.0064817737,
-0.0019772248,
-0.0074730865,
-0.0110852849,
0.0517832041,
0.0288460404,
0.0069719157,
0.0147777628,
-0.0503056645,
-0.0209174622,
-0.0900264606,
0.0188277978,
-0.0481867976,
-0.0059871827,
0.0418267027,
-0.046986673,
0.0164539348,
0.0283225961,
0.0197575353,
0.0181077104,
-0.0552733727,
0.0454200692,
-0.0213973019,
0.0032876066,
0.0874054581,
0.0044970158,
0.0180358514,
-0.0320543945,
0.0313466936,
-0.0516712628,
0.0609002858,
-0.0658073425,
-0.0234087855,
-0.0322045125,
-0.0046331165,
0.0416864268,
0.0244998522,
-0.0303527415,
-0.0163791738,
-0.0128396554,
-0.0171802957,
0.0275133643,
0.0486420803,
0.0764624923,
0.0246688891,
0.0147857424,
-0.0097984141,
-0.0040114592,
-0.071586974,
0.0153709333,
-0.0087009715,
-0.0062113539,
0.0207480341,
-0.0020078113,
-0.0227433685,
0.0013401208,
-0.0275196489,
0.0360573344,
0.0258287061,
-0.0060665328,
-0.0549920499,
0.0801027119,
-0.0427144952,
0.0681606308,
-0.055134166,
0.0416242778,
0.0105048344,
0.0062529086,
-0.015994031,
-0.0235675015,
0.0210841522,
-0.0304732807,
-0.0160513539,
0.0376211703,
0.0811116472,
-0.0143183898,
0.0522629693,
-0.0013946728,
0.0147429314,
-0.0206681583,
-0.0275174007,
-0.028741857,
0.0047534276,
-0.0244192164,
0.035213396,
-0.0396645293,
-0.0379674882,
-0.0086034462,
0.0103513869,
0.0248383489,
-0.0081146676,
0.0405495539,
0.0185793936,
0.0341386683,
0.0098303379,
-0.0071696877,
-0.0250953846,
-0.0520749316,
0.0305339769,
-0.0262202118,
-5.78590552e-33,
-0.0188062526,
0.0113585051,
-0.0361368917,
0.0258263331,
-0.0128556564,
0.0084048295,
-0.023216268,
0.0261737108,
0.0042935768,
-0.0066919201,
-0.0408660062,
0.0092807459,
0.0279155001,
0.0731013268,
0.0921977609,
-0.015207231,
0.0150552373,
0.006198897,
0.0235129334,
-0.0019838032,
0.0311626699,
0.0476688966,
0.0749065131,
-0.0570432879,
-0.0170207433,
-0.0264011901,
-0.0343567543,
0.0177420583,
-0.0083661675,
0.0541757792,
-0.0291042458,
0.0411335342,
0.0259528905,
-0.029633956,
-0.0272047743,
-0.0196648501,
-0.0856623054,
0.0121976957,
-0.0059298184,
0.059658166,
-0.0455401428,
-0.0142219579,
0.0168741848,
0.0051184716,
0.0317952819,
0.0397250764,
0.0091752717,
-0.053316284,
0.020262368,
0.0045739259,
-0.0499908216,
0.0357625224,
0.0013190953,
0.0189951025,
0.0259696227,
0.077417925,
-0.0141428178,
0.0112429634,
-0.0376477093,
-0.0166950263,
0.001118268,
0.0290880445,
0.0298034027,
-0.0271556377,
-0.0110567063,
0.0161937568,
-0.0042296685,
-0.0857960582,
0.0301997475,
0.0076797931,
-0.0295974296,
0.0438870378,
0.0447456315,
-0.0188835207,
0.0572941229,
-0.0040368033,
-0.0447106473,
-0.0240224339,
0.0344453491,
0.0700125322,
0.0033489396,
0.00892183,
-0.0378691144,
-0.0176182352,
0.023342384,
0.0000399624,
0.0111745857,
-0.0658001974,
0.02020026,
0.0217248369,
-0.0158292707,
0.0377921574,
0.0483347028,
-0.0440934636,
0.0073872604,
0.0358467773,
-0.0185971633,
0.072849527,
-0.0267556999,
-0.0017224429,
-0.053081397,
-0.0164555255,
-0.0125029311,
-0.0179499499,
-0.0003336191,
-0.0229745656,
0.064067252,
0.0313651301,
-0.0509888753,
0.0337041616,
-0.038790971,
0.0187874213,
-0.048955068,
0.1010477394,
0.0055881999,
0.0197356176,
-0.0471308231,
0.0170951299,
0.0036666018,
0.0321459696,
-0.0663071647,
0.0121853016,
0.0148406066,
0.0124311326,
-0.014109008,
0.0056924084,
-0.0309446137,
0.0348124467,
0.0101775359,
-0.0042276415,
-0.0062493742,
0.0588585474,
2.592e-7,
0.0764077902,
0.0115783429,
0.0912671983,
-0.0468355007,
0.0565923937,
-0.0011882378,
-0.014614448,
-0.0058359238,
-0.0200967528,
-0.020201128,
0.0164481867,
-0.0188256223,
0.0455212668,
0.010244146,
-0.1253691167,
-0.0112934271,
-0.0638250783,
-0.0529638678,
-0.029620178,
-0.035489969,
0.050466381,
0.1253727823,
-0.030487664,
-0.0035386579,
-0.017688293,
0.0497925691,
0.0322594531,
0.0166488457,
-0.009641449,
0.0231555942,
0.0093299579,
-0.0025038146,
-0.0022337642,
-0.0039967336,
-0.0132402843,
0.0466767401,
0.0234126989,
0.0329792574,
0.0068480126,
0.0137035372,
0.0248335674,
0.0631697103,
-0.0431036614,
-0.0247588344,
0.0481259152,
-0.0373924933,
0.0105885603,
0.0416066684,
-0.0409794562,
0.0634859204,
-0.0160686765,
0.0245275348,
-0.0329473875,
0.033237502,
0.0323914066,
-0.0381905176,
-0.075989522,
-0.0115992641,
-0.0503565222,
0.034199819,
-0.032158535,
0.0263335686,
-0.0113176843,
-0.0021451004,
-0.0375764072,
-0.0179249421,
-0.0092600984,
2.012396049e-34,
0.0114038698,
0.0121389469,
0.0282385368,
0.0393050238,
0.025397554,
-0.0420434363,
-0.0508712418,
0.042744372,
-0.0513577312,
-0.0628338382,
0.0145334015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13008v1
|
Control Token with Dense Passage Retrieval
| 2024-05-13T09:17:19 | 2024-05-13T09:17:19 |
Juhwan Lee, Jisu Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study addresses the hallucination problem in large language models
(LLMs). We adopted Retrieval-Augmented Generation(RAG) (Lewis et al., 2020), a
technique that involves embedding relevant information in the prompt to obtain
accurate answers. However, RAG also faced inherent issues in retrieving correct
information. To address this, we employed the Dense Passage Retrieval(DPR)
(Karpukhin et al., 2020) model for fetching domain-specific documents related
to user queries. Despite this, the DPR model still lacked accuracy in document
retrieval. We enhanced the DPR model by incorporating control tokens, achieving
significantly superior performance over the standard DPR model, with a 13%
improvement in Top-1 accuracy and a 4% improvement in Top-20 accuracy.
|
[
0.053710822,
0.0291223209,
-0.0152586261,
0.0052463505,
-0.0378999263,
-0.0222870279,
0.0031426044,
0.0255506653,
0.0321870856,
-0.0467309169,
0.0026159966,
-0.0615701228,
-0.0406413488,
0.032253325,
0.0031607375,
-0.048919186,
0.0560697764,
-0.0349250212,
0.0121697355,
-0.0126561793,
-0.0185018759,
0.0027470889,
0.0161020607,
0.0256781373,
-0.004558776,
-0.0123329945,
-0.0050330716,
0.0149008129,
-0.0163467117,
-0.0190599877,
0.0263686404,
0.0470732823,
0.0208158679,
0.0577479526,
0.0000021421,
-0.0539277866,
-0.0615463108,
0.019139057,
-0.0297567565,
-0.0174866728,
0.0579369441,
0.073462449,
0.0274986736,
0.0225230176,
-0.0223437995,
0.005080197,
0.0127143832,
0.0878258124,
0.0386365429,
0.0543681644,
0.0023937791,
-0.0398777798,
0.0249470528,
0.0005470115,
0.0697414279,
-0.0514215156,
0.0232172273,
0.0057310117,
0.0627439469,
0.0159077719,
0.0169904288,
0.0370142497,
0.0021567433,
-0.0142615903,
0.033752162,
0.0200090464,
-0.0696415827,
-0.0096355267,
0.0132071078,
0.04823054,
0.0090617267,
-0.0278690513,
0.0251297932,
0.0178893935,
-0.0052053845,
0.0284659155,
-0.0633133799,
-0.0079958849,
-0.0157836191,
-0.0076697287,
-0.0211029146,
-0.021679569,
0.0314139426,
0.0232947804,
-0.0476318449,
0.0612545274,
0.0320728756,
-0.0332553983,
-0.0011705918,
-0.0070494595,
-0.0070498893,
-0.0138998898,
0.04073954,
0.0347939655,
-0.0655841455,
0.0036969457,
-0.0195168704,
-0.0315343365,
0.0631037131,
-0.0475783683,
-0.0015215707,
0.013618594,
-0.0291702189,
0.0539529584,
-0.0351670273,
0.0483822301,
-0.0108051794,
0.0201151185,
-0.0426552333,
-0.0134610115,
-0.0284769367,
-0.0368059389,
-0.0612028614,
0.0743026733,
-0.0403164402,
-0.0353900641,
-0.0213918667,
0.0145200854,
0.0232663173,
0.0057449751,
-0.0244721361,
0.0245552789,
-0.0270797852,
-0.0237843823,
-0.0139882863,
0.0060019735,
-0.0284389202,
-0.0340271108,
0.0356731191,
-0.0655848309,
-0.0066728238,
-0.0082422569,
0.0205895435,
-0.0157852471,
0.0074077942,
0.019743124,
0.0007006257,
-0.0374869294,
-0.0301806126,
-0.0735819191,
-0.0022745933,
-0.0394610092,
-0.0298998766,
-0.0853132308,
0.0266265888,
0.0303643849,
-0.0099068014,
-0.0225051865,
0.0122567452,
0.0648590177,
-0.0422530398,
0.009876756,
-0.0049257572,
0.0132761179,
0.0582768582,
0.0275161881,
0.0085876752,
0.0453532413,
-0.0256803762,
0.0695584118,
0.0540746227,
0.017475618,
0.0459025763,
0.015753299,
0.0021631944,
-0.0041427165,
-0.0249288827,
0.0009613124,
0.0207023956,
0.0155611616,
0.0036234898,
0.0556714647,
-0.0496658646,
0.026795106,
0.0131720426,
0.0534125939,
0.0300240479,
-0.0107522123,
0.0126826148,
0.0087884879,
0.0018604581,
0.0122025805,
-0.0358647965,
0.0029814315,
-0.0208450295,
0.0072768922,
0.1169548258,
0.0035418263,
-0.0103352675,
-0.0248783361,
-0.0012709097,
0.0222107135,
-0.0337773673,
0.0340148434,
0.033601556,
-0.0048910636,
-0.050357502,
0.0611340441,
0.0171609633,
-0.046236217,
0.01827145,
-0.0488213859,
0.0100696981,
0.0961612388,
0.1005560011,
-0.0384055227,
0.0156537667,
0.0041122609,
0.029736463,
0.0367209055,
0.0471280739,
0.005188277,
-0.0390457436,
-0.0582694151,
-0.0462712049,
0.0158124845,
0.0196795594,
0.0048451419,
0.0209903307,
0.0282739606,
0.0393608734,
-0.0566875152,
-0.0490258783,
0.0185505878,
-0.0149314431,
-0.0229705852,
-0.0198627133,
-0.0206377953,
-0.0134935016,
0.0246360749,
-0.0066616172,
0.0318289623,
0.0236180164,
-0.0229149908,
-0.0544375181,
-0.0331621356,
-0.0574503914,
0.033223547,
0.0300302021,
0.0100678178,
0.0120217009,
-0.0046991636,
0.0012036568,
-0.0430025756,
-0.0216399096,
-0.0516596474,
0.0596987195,
-0.0573039912,
0.0468347482,
-0.0043327692,
-0.0100464346,
-0.064940691,
0.084433049,
0.0092934323,
0.0497607999,
0.0401829183,
0.0250390265,
0.0055059963,
-0.0317742191,
-0.0268188268,
0.0140651288,
-0.0324225761,
0.0171305016,
0.0544389673,
-0.0407638401,
-0.0588282906,
-0.0054888674,
-0.0780409053,
-0.0158145893,
-0.0196344983,
0.0027171415,
-0.0020518077,
0.0406382866,
-0.0163137633,
-0.0092364335,
-0.0257887598,
-0.0353520736,
0.0368266627,
0.0451787077,
-0.0036107234,
0.0180882029,
-0.0181651991,
-0.0330492854,
-0.0111642238,
0.0057172645,
0.0165395215,
-0.0250551347,
-0.0340680815,
-0.0503962114,
0.0516549088,
-0.0164166056,
0.0200244207,
-0.0027925142,
-0.0057959105,
0.0004120095,
-0.0596071295,
0.065458931,
0.0198001433,
0.021580454,
-0.0141437734,
0.0242933761,
-0.0149465287,
-0.0997363105,
0.0181411467,
-0.034219753,
-0.0142661985,
0.013364898,
-0.0240618344,
0.0455370992,
0.0003903903,
0.0102860881,
0.0106498981,
-0.0323485322,
-0.0099254763,
-0.0340516716,
-0.0175352357,
-0.043664027,
-0.0147999693,
-0.0288546383,
0.0378538519,
-0.0226034243,
-0.0441873744,
0.0632867217,
-0.0196098126,
0.0112507045,
-0.0505370386,
0.0273342207,
-0.0143648498,
0.0429875366,
0.0019498937,
0.0320464298,
-0.0502466671,
-0.0590232573,
-0.0124352947,
0.0118196597,
-0.0019177294,
-0.076267086,
0.0191170089,
-0.0049480279,
0.0107871061,
0.0018521714,
-0.0134351095,
-0.0638052449,
-0.0502724797,
0.004801135,
-0.024802411,
-0.0025543065,
-0.0119612794,
-0.0580218956,
0.0033504369,
0.0317967236,
0.0336395316,
-0.044861801,
-0.0232114904,
0.0025406692,
0.0186958294,
0.0862235799,
-0.0090632932,
0.0101843001,
-0.0196270552,
0.0258146711,
0.0804402605,
0.0834705755,
-0.016304139,
0.0455285572,
-0.026941698,
0.0670728534,
-0.0582190901,
-0.0404786654,
0.0236011874,
0.0273855049,
-0.0517656207,
-0.0413657129,
0.1041689143,
0.055831641,
-0.0663817823,
-0.0384045318,
-0.0882881284,
0.036236845,
0.0042850836,
0.0508293398,
-0.0527829938,
-0.0039792666,
0.0340042301,
0.052071251,
0.0007440238,
-0.0104681356,
0.0060043167,
-0.1231280565,
0.0362856686,
-0.0015203339,
0.0135534601,
-0.0403616801,
-0.0554054938,
-0.0066656354,
0.05962855,
0.0130932108,
0.048572164,
-0.0056576384,
-0.0091212867,
0.0189909488,
0.0113659101,
-0.0024829553,
0.0065427246,
-0.0299252924,
-0.0016576918,
0.0938896388,
0.0165187065,
0.0209767185,
-0.050703872,
0.0330530107,
-0.0196540542,
0.0148168951,
-0.0055503501,
0.0379609391,
-0.0006002064,
0.028044356,
-0.0208025035,
0.0116413096,
0.0083282245,
-0.0246540736,
-0.0186579898,
0.0628770217,
-0.0293894783,
-0.006531504,
-0.0516793169,
0.0076693846,
-0.0061116135,
0.0742329583,
0.0076700775,
-0.0086296825,
-0.0569929816,
-0.0201675221,
0.0491738878,
-0.0175453834,
-0.0151689127,
0.0167201739,
0.005854087,
0.0118513256,
-0.0593607947,
-0.0050626434,
0.0089679435,
0.0524146184,
-0.0067463233,
0.0731790438,
-0.0590022653,
-0.0052857623,
-0.0146780731,
0.0217607077,
-0.073454842,
-0.0006595705,
-0.0833048671,
-0.0061922036,
0.0202506036,
-0.0288181249,
-0.0126605732,
0.0269859955,
-0.0355207622,
-0.0698934868,
0.0302571002,
0.0118340133,
0.023666257,
0.0161663722,
-0.0213689394,
-0.0583625622,
0.0771928206,
0.0494521707,
-0.0550055839,
-0.021645166,
-0.0206031762,
0.0040803268,
-0.032604944,
0.0103236958,
-0.0896306783,
-0.0073067676,
-0.0217179693,
0.0537297726,
0.036938522,
-0.0351603292,
0.0201670527,
0.0404077992,
0.0161607023,
0.0038238638,
0.0227722973,
-0.0237986911,
0.0341327488,
-0.0230212342,
-0.0257150419,
0.0027358944,
0.0282994714,
0.0124463001,
-0.0465381369,
0.0101641025,
-0.0107727712,
-0.0033646801,
0.0385393128,
-0.0578721873,
-0.0298253782,
-0.006557269,
-0.003255551,
0.0418561921,
-0.0272008218,
-0.0212847963,
-0.0044056629,
0.0117235826,
0.068622157,
-0.0430732183,
0.0452134348,
-0.0031445795,
-0.0211158656,
-0.0192985311,
0.0220501162,
-0.074269928,
-0.0812980011,
-0.0241025016,
0.0079829618,
0.0384159535,
-0.0084133064,
0.019119706,
-0.0206052028,
-0.0050855246,
-0.0090726595,
-0.039033547,
0.0586979911,
-0.0285009351,
-0.0200078748,
0.0419487804,
-0.0166840777,
0.0192519072,
0.0698161498,
-0.0120332204,
0.0186131354,
-0.0202406086,
-0.0463763438,
-0.008010732,
-0.0256101973,
-0.0007252822,
0.0446907282,
-0.0288553108,
-0.0439803638,
-0.0312296562,
-0.0269488171,
0.0495003499,
-0.010530401,
-0.0073980507,
0.0001995723,
0.0426478386,
0.1049196273,
0.0005760291,
-0.0428296551,
-0.0446788222,
0.0349945612,
0.0136238104,
-0.0134323481,
-0.0009313516,
-6.485308128e-33,
-0.0181678329,
-0.0268133953,
0.017094709,
-0.0410651937,
-0.0364613794,
-0.0374872945,
-0.0196938179,
-0.014880538,
0.0169511531,
-0.0160915349,
-0.0390435718,
0.0150355455,
0.0355027765,
0.0300853942,
-0.0033192041,
-0.021291038,
0.0548998043,
0.0195257831,
-0.0267868116,
0.0583245344,
0.068650648,
0.0561361648,
-0.0198668987,
-0.0247680955,
0.0195812788,
-0.0498212092,
0.0288377143,
0.0016329722,
0.026618911,
0.0282469019,
-0.0189032517,
0.0372358337,
0.0204374585,
-0.0461851731,
-0.0208258238,
0.0147231985,
-0.0579285286,
-0.0150194205,
0.0034688776,
0.0008371881,
0.008008996,
-0.036191158,
0.0332254507,
-0.0355378315,
0.0121401297,
0.0405875668,
0.0294293202,
0.0033532532,
-0.0416076593,
-0.0298879407,
-0.0463822111,
0.0172084719,
0.032435298,
0.0241961796,
0.0066656009,
0.061563313,
0.0188986827,
0.0148579432,
-0.0655853823,
0.0253454652,
-0.0160137843,
0.0765055642,
0.0233266652,
0.0085000936,
-0.0066016787,
0.0708710104,
0.0265751574,
-0.0099543063,
-0.0051962272,
-0.0116574774,
0.0169380512,
0.0077798581,
0.000243272,
0.0113965394,
0.0336441025,
-0.0288678817,
-0.0078047938,
0.05849481,
-0.0332415104,
0.0371251293,
0.0801091716,
0.0054268003,
-0.0520683266,
-0.0194319673,
-0.0090826834,
0.0551233888,
-0.0450051278,
-0.0430550911,
0.0551870689,
0.0224532578,
-0.044422444,
-0.0621435493,
0.0493500046,
-0.0159171,
-0.0260758568,
0.0360566974,
0.0049669491,
-0.0030035665,
-0.0391212292,
0.0207134373,
0.001288206,
-0.0255665705,
0.0140060838,
-0.0250338521,
-0.0300880447,
0.0039101178,
-0.0212977435,
-0.0090695107,
-0.0776856244,
0.0128920609,
-0.0193457361,
0.0123185934,
0.0048858728,
-0.0003818316,
0.0432370156,
0.0076046344,
0.0025471202,
0.0357875302,
0.0214473419,
0.0145856254,
-0.0279377401,
-0.0236578882,
-0.0037454849,
-0.0091364142,
0.0038917505,
0.0312379375,
-0.0537286699,
0.057939671,
0.0032638675,
-0.0391500071,
-0.0097129364,
0.0120605538,
2.906e-7,
-0.0015906193,
0.02534738,
0.0237756837,
0.0290248264,
-0.0208949372,
-0.0176913142,
0.0447856635,
-0.0060172989,
0.0498098172,
-0.0075891349,
-0.0158619545,
0.0109037934,
0.0350729413,
0.0233651884,
-0.1405882388,
-0.0178787038,
-0.0357356928,
-0.0156626888,
-0.0613638535,
-0.0418684445,
0.0332917981,
0.0587611161,
-0.0146675343,
-0.0162651837,
-0.0061762803,
-0.0603522956,
0.0226208139,
0.0185544752,
-0.0332316421,
0.0449665338,
0.0556971133,
0.0380789414,
0.0310437903,
-0.0112180859,
-0.0206778925,
0.0213625841,
0.0322825536,
0.0154093979,
0.0177474525,
-0.056033127,
-0.0220785085,
-0.0229669027,
0.013965751,
-0.0530862696,
0.0755553544,
0.0303279981,
0.0225932375,
0.009024811,
-0.0392710268,
-0.0361587182,
-0.0002359837,
-0.0117938882,
-0.0212596115,
0.0486695729,
-0.0040808553,
0.0092494367,
0.003875291,
-0.0729541183,
-0.0135770682,
-0.0270305853,
-0.0470893048,
-0.035645429,
-0.0480156802,
0.0132262893,
-0.0382712595,
-0.0618766546,
-0.0044691036,
2.907436962e-34,
0.0416229218,
0.0167176556,
0.0187164508,
0.0231483281,
0.0418539159,
0.0074721877,
0.0459250472,
0.0447203964,
0.0226460919,
-0.0900185108,
-0.0314146355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13007v1
|
News Recommendation with Category Description by a Large Language Model
| 2024-05-13T08:53:43 | 2024-05-13T08:53:43 |
Yuki Yada, Hayato Yamana
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Personalized news recommendations are essential for online news platforms to
assist users in discovering news articles that match their interests from a
vast amount of online content. Appropriately encoded content features, such as
text, categories, and images, are essential for recommendations. Among these
features, news categories, such as tv-golden-globe, finance-real-estate, and
news-politics, play an important role in understanding news content, inspiring
us to enhance the categories' descriptions. In this paper, we propose a novel
method that automatically generates informative category descriptions using a
large language model (LLM) without manual effort or domain-specific knowledge
and incorporates them into recommendation models as additional information. In
our comprehensive experimental evaluations using the MIND dataset, our method
successfully achieved 5.8% improvement at most in AUC compared with baseline
approaches without the LLM's generated category descriptions for the
state-of-the-art content-based recommendation models including NAML, NRMS, and
NPA. These results validate the effectiveness of our approach. The code is
available at https://github.com/yamanalab/gpt-augmented-news-recommendation.
|
[
0.0583325364,
0.0433664359,
0.0081135239,
-0.0006913519,
0.0172882769,
0.0278548412,
-0.0082438765,
0.0019068986,
0.0363648459,
-0.0550904535,
-0.0314090773,
-0.0116236629,
-0.0137458816,
0.0306558255,
-0.000741804,
-0.0259282254,
0.0217608418,
-0.0418063141,
0.0277059078,
0.0016104215,
0.0116430223,
0.0501704849,
0.0481429696,
0.0010490402,
0.0212014597,
-0.0152394306,
-0.0230589975,
-0.0003888164,
-0.0139340265,
-0.0346375927,
0.0102434047,
0.0216308348,
0.0136453053,
-0.0190443005,
0.0000018401,
-0.03866712,
-0.0001299754,
-0.0160127878,
0.0588536337,
-0.0184420627,
0.0646625459,
-0.0058733462,
0.0149543062,
0.0121978009,
-0.0104657141,
-0.0064886701,
0.030412918,
0.056896735,
0.0103616435,
0.0774470493,
-0.0288335625,
-0.0203519166,
0.0071505974,
-0.0332914107,
0.0595269129,
-0.0447026715,
0.0251285397,
0.0202010963,
0.0197631475,
0.0397620089,
-0.0008162016,
-0.0263343118,
0.0123100858,
-0.0422129743,
0.0207829662,
0.0397790894,
-0.0133922268,
-0.009628118,
0.0001265155,
0.0733450949,
-0.0280506294,
-0.0102223549,
-0.0020354628,
0.0251078699,
0.0118769696,
0.028011078,
-0.0541826859,
0.034097068,
-0.0039815707,
0.0214201771,
0.0339706466,
-0.0128317401,
0.0329078846,
0.038724184,
0.0319284126,
0.0828300565,
0.0445615388,
-0.0125201801,
0.0059886239,
0.0102050444,
-0.0015895634,
-0.0712388456,
0.0040083341,
0.0180253331,
-0.0232753754,
0.0007678834,
-0.0216657408,
0.0492278226,
0.0153148193,
-0.0704197511,
0.0085315285,
0.011205174,
-0.0111170281,
0.0720491186,
-0.0441794209,
0.0158410035,
-0.0215973184,
-0.0147894202,
-0.047765404,
-0.0291999187,
-0.0499698892,
-0.0003034245,
0.0118888309,
0.0620636418,
-0.0055792816,
-0.0382060595,
-0.0506225377,
0.0703881383,
0.0249200705,
0.040869344,
0.0215831697,
0.0128424028,
-0.0188987479,
-0.0280857272,
-0.0432941504,
-0.0035951859,
-0.0448694229,
0.0068273162,
0.0042265584,
0.0343892798,
0.0242700726,
0.0333794504,
-0.0049059638,
-0.0354351439,
-0.0020051587,
0.045985505,
0.0138286939,
-0.034412872,
-0.0538371503,
-0.022610046,
0.0010333738,
-0.0543366857,
-0.0101744756,
-0.0858062208,
0.0053827041,
0.0099062249,
0.0345497094,
-0.027783677,
0.009448451,
0.0051597161,
-0.028604446,
0.0440487154,
-0.0464681238,
-0.0086064106,
0.0312323309,
0.0233346056,
0.0476263873,
0.0728152245,
-0.0253146458,
0.090652287,
0.0624947622,
-0.0085868947,
0.0270949863,
-0.0031706432,
-0.0246148817,
0.0194716174,
-0.0290511586,
0.0049816617,
-0.0247441307,
0.0204766616,
0.052133929,
0.023378294,
-0.035484653,
0.0056862091,
0.0908815786,
-0.0047538523,
0.0452433601,
0.0945211947,
0.0349877253,
0.0251791738,
0.000456252,
-0.0308705419,
0.0133786174,
0.0745861903,
-0.0736838877,
0.0135723082,
0.0460787416,
0.0603328347,
-0.072837308,
0.0043445374,
0.0173518844,
-0.0674264506,
0.0311669055,
0.0255888924,
0.0301967543,
-0.0096657295,
0.002095005,
0.021620838,
0.073231414,
-0.0106762294,
0.0391945355,
-0.0410915352,
0.0862134248,
0.0701861158,
0.0459724329,
0.0045392346,
-0.004361175,
-0.0246548038,
0.0086417962,
0.013315605,
0.0512211248,
-0.030282665,
-0.0276009291,
-0.0315449685,
-0.0320381224,
-0.0117785782,
0.0120691611,
0.0156208361,
0.0340137482,
0.0624280646,
0.0434093997,
-0.0269443057,
-0.0292321742,
-0.0092451572,
-0.0236633215,
-0.0284767933,
0.0551742576,
-0.0227231085,
-0.0029481554,
0.0272257831,
0.031440448,
-0.0189561173,
0.0121230036,
0.0005863796,
-0.0521183982,
-0.0240804348,
-0.0179828927,
0.0025676712,
0.0451471694,
-0.0233718939,
0.0246170498,
0.0535257123,
-0.0045606829,
-0.0296968948,
-0.0017252407,
-0.0010569942,
0.0140762441,
-0.0441141315,
0.0311978199,
-0.0061115604,
0.0019868505,
-0.0104102846,
0.0841033012,
0.0333304778,
0.0191854481,
-0.0020712484,
-0.028669497,
-0.0208682921,
-0.0042667575,
-0.0411901139,
0.0469468907,
0.0361353308,
0.012065717,
0.0406856313,
0.0059583108,
-0.0305895489,
-0.0148750395,
-0.0778001547,
0.0075627305,
0.0198811516,
-0.0156733058,
0.0221717339,
0.025356058,
-0.0130048282,
0.0204280131,
-0.0767885894,
-0.0166395344,
-0.0307657328,
0.0133725358,
-0.0101718111,
0.0042171623,
-0.0297458675,
0.0103723994,
-0.0050482713,
-0.0127708167,
0.0569556355,
0.00705822,
-0.0020842536,
-0.0719652101,
-0.0122603457,
-0.017254319,
-0.0409838893,
0.0078461533,
0.0113343829,
-0.0559481829,
-0.0114144376,
-0.024773242,
0.0252747815,
0.0234684329,
0.0131125785,
0.0606011823,
0.014452748,
-0.0206224583,
-0.0056675607,
-0.0465659872,
-0.0014338394,
-0.0297781974,
-0.0230286829,
0.0021408305,
0.0362935066,
-0.0320384316,
0.0112771355,
-0.0481171347,
0.0123718837,
-0.0051437127,
0.0541064292,
-0.0673424751,
-0.0246088579,
0.0077898968,
0.0428421199,
0.000959181,
-0.0078179855,
0.0758686066,
-0.0094489092,
0.0122920237,
-0.0484617762,
-0.0409420319,
-0.0875843242,
0.0050829919,
-0.0218574814,
0.0500024594,
-0.038697686,
-0.0384595357,
0.0011159069,
-0.0064823218,
0.0061020874,
-0.0229671374,
0.0486087725,
-0.0038338704,
-0.0136207016,
0.0123044336,
-0.0295345541,
-0.0033731288,
-0.0574025363,
-0.0002887993,
0.022436643,
-0.0058345986,
-0.0308795366,
-0.0327553637,
0.0074839233,
0.0102423867,
0.0227243267,
-0.0595208742,
-0.040601287,
0.016232131,
0.0425879471,
0.1022970304,
-0.0666073337,
-0.0256260056,
0.0104633374,
0.0281137489,
0.0248461086,
-0.0350728296,
0.0379998647,
-0.0452233702,
0.0135549773,
0.0569005348,
-0.0452544205,
-0.0140888914,
0.0254971478,
-0.0053323023,
0.0355879143,
0.0106573896,
0.1222358346,
0.0391638391,
-0.1383606642,
-0.019386543,
0.0075810235,
0.0120449681,
0.039611727,
0.0489063822,
-0.0727313608,
0.0086385133,
0.0004467471,
0.0296726096,
0.0431866236,
0.0029761873,
-0.0182024371,
-0.0863064229,
0.0264340919,
0.0318259113,
0.0016773278,
-0.0271905474,
-0.0692826509,
-0.0075264559,
-0.0247030873,
-0.0119644264,
0.0012948825,
-0.0130739603,
-0.0199843012,
-0.0008187358,
-0.0172254965,
-0.0596314296,
0.0168898385,
-0.0055324892,
0.041601792,
0.0474989936,
0.0357496925,
-0.0165136512,
0.0055858851,
0.0187416803,
0.0092800902,
-0.0453355014,
0.0018803411,
0.0078091323,
-0.0480675474,
0.0199875832,
-0.0199273787,
0.0105784358,
-0.0115788318,
-0.0212017149,
0.021324724,
0.0594543889,
-0.0039231852,
-0.0162034594,
-0.0218886286,
-0.025641676,
0.0281626228,
0.0723429099,
0.0051702703,
-0.0594212413,
0.046794951,
-0.0516193025,
-0.05512226,
0.0300458521,
-0.0347330272,
0.0113274092,
-0.0229730103,
-0.0518960878,
-0.0560179688,
-0.0372280851,
0.0312025342,
-0.0214980543,
0.0292678382,
0.0322542898,
-0.0168014895,
-0.0367349535,
-0.0206230767,
0.0321419984,
-0.0285355859,
-0.0101250522,
-0.0479675755,
-0.0232746638,
0.0411440507,
-0.0954823345,
-0.0050376253,
-0.0094361352,
-0.0414019562,
-0.0252800118,
-0.0489239357,
0.0025492362,
0.0180089213,
0.0480285808,
-0.0470933616,
-0.0738418326,
0.0523518063,
0.0208615176,
-0.0383085683,
-0.0234329384,
-0.0655315667,
0.0413582399,
0.0142294867,
0.0291746426,
-0.0625490472,
0.0134919751,
-0.0430842228,
0.0084519526,
0.0082311928,
-0.0295969378,
0.0406643376,
0.0064664595,
-0.0078663127,
-0.0222544707,
0.0475801267,
-0.0311892554,
-0.0079344157,
-0.022595603,
-0.0495000929,
-0.0135121606,
-0.0055183489,
0.0861580744,
-0.0296064802,
-0.0127090169,
0.0142827081,
-0.0198003557,
0.0278795641,
-0.0213440377,
-0.0189027544,
-0.0355909579,
-0.0008598526,
0.0163667891,
0.0149011174,
-0.0249030255,
-0.0202079471,
0.0071514179,
0.0136117432,
-0.0505036153,
0.0416540913,
-0.0038693233,
-0.0227968059,
-0.015813835,
0.0435472801,
-0.0066572218,
-0.0453489311,
-0.0419702567,
0.040708039,
0.0397027619,
-0.0649590716,
0.0191331767,
-0.0522178188,
-0.0297193583,
-0.0267401114,
0.0049575693,
-0.0193139352,
-0.0494813994,
0.0337146632,
0.0404943787,
-0.0182212945,
0.0018481497,
0.0954395458,
0.019039439,
-0.0171317756,
0.0125024235,
-0.0599194095,
-0.0252388585,
0.0214901902,
0.030451877,
0.0335409269,
-0.0725560337,
0.0111338375,
0.0025852802,
-0.0295419004,
-0.0002899813,
-0.0731519833,
0.0259351265,
0.0070239282,
0.0442809202,
0.0809850991,
-0.0034151855,
0.0124393813,
-0.0914360955,
-0.0412500426,
-0.0479610935,
-0.0373578593,
-0.0272193085,
-6.490495731e-33,
-0.0109047582,
-0.0233694967,
0.0095631965,
-0.007187346,
0.0051227366,
-0.000633559,
-0.0022807794,
0.0123618115,
0.041880101,
-0.0054959073,
0.0203286372,
0.0112841679,
0.0012042953,
0.0225344207,
0.0084419642,
-0.0149783371,
0.0214600246,
0.0406844057,
-0.0220779963,
0.0674560592,
-0.0251947287,
0.0307741594,
0.0193643011,
-0.0728784129,
0.0280508064,
0.0087750964,
-0.0234675538,
-0.0450685807,
0.0615789816,
0.0952433497,
-0.0086168395,
0.0467876531,
0.0273014233,
-0.015277002,
0.0228732303,
0.0162883922,
-0.0591310188,
0.0097763482,
0.0509909801,
-0.0050626844,
-0.0139600597,
-0.0469992198,
-0.0282505751,
-0.0049391515,
0.0119178109,
-0.012395123,
0.0327752456,
-0.0396135375,
-0.0381867364,
-0.0489549562,
-0.0318583399,
0.0162211452,
-0.0092928549,
0.006963159,
0.0185378809,
-0.0046194214,
-0.017713014,
0.0768560991,
-0.0169613529,
0.0579977073,
-0.0033681481,
0.0687685683,
0.0098828478,
-0.0326037146,
-0.0370195843,
0.0377481803,
-0.0150979608,
-0.0109404819,
-0.0051067281,
0.0448596328,
-0.0224952437,
0.0070702122,
-0.000915002,
0.028029751,
-0.0006664793,
-0.0320197307,
-0.0279443432,
0.0595406666,
-0.0066558425,
-0.0010754962,
0.0412743688,
0.0055891941,
-0.0132377269,
-0.0229953155,
-0.0023405703,
0.0097721536,
-0.0795897692,
-0.0633414686,
0.0139304707,
0.0416068584,
-0.0144530293,
0.0037917863,
-0.012210968,
-0.0482844077,
-0.0262488853,
0.0320148058,
-0.0529630221,
0.0252787117,
0.0086116493,
0.0144129647,
-0.0340562649,
-0.0400626399,
-0.012043166,
-0.0598842688,
-0.0397137105,
0.008530857,
0.0471007563,
0.0431323051,
-0.0511533469,
0.018493697,
0.0147886695,
-0.0403405167,
0.0023281942,
0.0049625416,
-0.0057289065,
0.0165992491,
-0.0184214637,
0.0656310171,
0.0417108946,
0.0283772051,
0.0088602463,
-0.0669247583,
0.0121640647,
0.0507255457,
-0.0187502746,
-0.0071567637,
-0.0217837468,
-0.0278324652,
0.0489552505,
-0.0530741289,
-0.0339557752,
-0.021069793,
2.674e-7,
0.000150328,
0.0530216694,
-0.0561984517,
0.0203572828,
0.0264339708,
-0.007768604,
0.0136609841,
0.0430215634,
0.0335298516,
0.0127420481,
0.0151246767,
0.009307595,
0.0243251696,
0.0193154793,
-0.1135643944,
0.0472403057,
-0.0371951312,
-0.0016538708,
-0.103772603,
0.0067998096,
0.0291397255,
0.0878139958,
0.0256246179,
-0.0070705842,
0.0022088075,
-0.045918569,
0.0595151298,
-0.0265779383,
-0.0608865507,
0.0068364642,
0.0592479445,
0.0545531809,
-0.0350676589,
-0.0197881293,
-0.0002599911,
-0.0056304126,
0.0133309672,
0.039215371,
-0.004590461,
-0.009651986,
0.0225084741,
0.0007523203,
0.0195256602,
-0.0602700152,
0.0937984213,
0.0014354936,
-0.0091186957,
-0.0554790869,
-0.0463001542,
0.0017315121,
0.0301790964,
-0.0777319223,
-0.0142973093,
-0.0003828173,
0.0231863204,
0.0152098183,
0.0032714058,
-0.0421086438,
-0.0016091154,
0.0159915444,
-0.0197326001,
-0.0186732225,
-0.0460762419,
0.0211494919,
0.0128444964,
-0.0831228346,
0.0530052297,
2.303843343e-34,
0.030675862,
0.0665534884,
-0.0269641038,
0.0080993446,
0.0288277417,
-0.0214084964,
-0.0489556156,
0.0334384516,
0.0050088223,
-0.0611660741,
-0.0082062576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07551v1
|
MuMath-Code: Combining Tool-Use Large Language Models with Multi-perspective Data Augmentation for Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-05-13T08:32:19 | 2024-05-13T08:32:19 |
Shuo Yin, Weihao You, Zhilong Ji, Guoqiang Zhong, Jinfeng Bai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The tool-use Large Language Models (LLMs) that integrate with external Python
interpreters have significantly enhanced mathematical reasoning capabilities
for open-source LLMs, while tool-free methods chose another track: augmenting
math reasoning data. However, a great method to integrate the above two
research paths and combine their advantages remains to be explored. In this
work, we firstly include new math questions via multi-perspective data
augmenting methods and then synthesize code-nested solutions to them. The open
LLMs (i.e., Llama-2) are finetuned on the augmented dataset to get the
resulting models, MuMath-Code ($\mu$-Math-Code). During the inference phase,
our MuMath-Code generates code and interacts with the external python
interpreter to get the execution results. Therefore, MuMath-Code leverages the
advantages of both the external tool and data augmentation. To fully leverage
the advantages of our augmented data, we propose a two-stage training strategy:
In Stage-1, we finetune Llama-2 on pure CoT data to get an intermediate model,
which then is trained on the code-nested data in Stage-2 to get the resulting
MuMath-Code. Our MuMath-Code-7B achieves 83.8 on GSM8K and 52.4 on MATH, while
MuMath-Code-70B model achieves new state-of-the-art performance among open
methods -- achieving 90.7% on GSM8K and 55.1% on MATH. Extensive experiments
validate the combination of tool use and data augmentation, as well as our
two-stage training strategy. We release the proposed dataset along with the
associated code for public use.
|
[
-0.030473005,
0.1226753592,
-0.0042564357,
0.0866260305,
-0.0124363815,
0.0486895517,
0.0058233021,
-0.0002408783,
-0.0234727319,
-0.0406037457,
-0.0331036374,
0.0254390929,
-0.0159449615,
0.0190485362,
0.0493291356,
-0.0284719653,
-0.0055937972,
-0.0718105808,
-0.0210837666,
-0.0096942224,
-0.0394881554,
0.010875701,
-0.0200725272,
-0.0058191507,
-0.0127712609,
-0.0602419116,
0.0052709002,
-0.0255394857,
0.0190109834,
-0.0359300487,
-0.0223697908,
0.0347485691,
0.0511930175,
0.0590656511,
0.0000023338,
-0.0558062494,
-0.0085398555,
0.010399648,
-0.0498759933,
0.0038347037,
0.004422083,
-0.0369131267,
0.0408789329,
-0.016428344,
-0.0771670863,
-0.0010836595,
0.016545793,
0.0037429023,
0.0975549147,
0.0531233549,
0.0083667468,
-0.0714101866,
0.0509617701,
-0.007657202,
0.0428588651,
-0.0512210466,
0.0231270064,
0.045721814,
0.0133107072,
0.0315245688,
-0.020834934,
0.0370238014,
0.06884747,
-0.012958969,
-0.0071206372,
0.036919333,
-0.0192061756,
0.0342380926,
-0.000534081,
0.0605517924,
-0.0044156029,
-0.0556196831,
-0.0292774197,
-0.0233861543,
-0.012054529,
-0.0180701725,
-0.0831902772,
0.0449719802,
0.0059497193,
0.0194138773,
0.015321305,
-0.0096346624,
0.0309993569,
0.0214353334,
-0.0683095679,
0.0811763257,
0.0148489969,
-0.03143619,
-0.0053612655,
0.0033067982,
-0.0578801595,
-0.0393400602,
0.000305169,
0.0739970058,
0.0393412001,
0.014314143,
-0.0011963665,
-0.0722703561,
-0.0265465938,
-0.0209981203,
0.039234668,
0.0884086788,
-0.0159711465,
0.0303465035,
-0.0398472212,
0.0227684379,
-0.0253856853,
0.0068753073,
-0.0454868488,
0.0093317796,
-0.0338763893,
-0.0077946903,
-0.0069780555,
0.0314864889,
0.0088447975,
0.0347393416,
-0.0205419026,
0.0440487526,
-0.0295163393,
0.028099753,
0.0097270692,
-0.0081943171,
0.005229888,
-0.0273226611,
-0.0176737737,
0.0050525507,
-0.0494032688,
0.0151619725,
0.0069090216,
-0.0553280152,
-0.0373397022,
0.0389860235,
-0.0185799859,
-0.0437692255,
0.0206096396,
0.0591621809,
0.0233639423,
-0.0152154882,
-0.0204022769,
-0.0267032608,
0.0400352105,
-0.0654538944,
0.0117841996,
-0.11328087,
0.0437043458,
0.0154591016,
-0.0205471497,
-0.0473348089,
0.0134069426,
0.0168359727,
0.0064731287,
0.0742026493,
-0.0055924668,
-0.0188781004,
0.0094649736,
0.0074192919,
-0.0217976272,
0.0647037104,
0.0229120106,
-0.0339148752,
0.0149582187,
-0.0173654072,
-0.0124293081,
0.0246381983,
0.0269210916,
0.0120388381,
-0.0176225621,
0.0603019111,
0.026656758,
0.0444091894,
-0.0126791708,
-0.0082748393,
-0.0434013456,
-0.0166360661,
-0.0012605173,
0.0221990831,
-0.0078477832,
-0.002585734,
0.0467840657,
-0.0368984267,
0.0411359929,
-0.0174559131,
-0.0532012172,
0.0271527898,
-0.0351341553,
0.0067746076,
0.0172190163,
0.0246684868,
-0.0233851392,
-0.0828569308,
-0.0018096273,
-0.0110785542,
-0.0320286751,
0.0328903683,
0.0803449675,
-0.0122385835,
0.0253001843,
0.0585620217,
0.0213009883,
-0.0405501537,
-0.0197049845,
-0.0472766198,
0.031343516,
-0.0298351794,
0.0418813452,
-0.0653792769,
-0.0779158473,
-0.0191023126,
-0.0052889609,
0.0144698936,
0.0046946313,
-0.0137731573,
-0.0276571196,
-0.0659513772,
-0.0080075832,
-0.0517915972,
0.0075749713,
-0.01241621,
0.041751612,
-0.0136633124,
0.0407174528,
-0.024572365,
0.0325540975,
0.0308368709,
-0.070050627,
-0.0323935002,
-0.0156844202,
-0.0254025776,
0.0110225994,
-0.008111055,
0.026434157,
0.038019374,
0.0411027074,
-0.0308018904,
0.009384552,
-0.0311691724,
-0.04669163,
-0.0627464503,
0.0732571483,
-0.012828229,
-0.0345494039,
0.0161533244,
-0.0525927953,
-0.0122907702,
0.0293533504,
0.0096852034,
0.0235038605,
-0.0345691592,
0.0119268401,
0.0056858161,
0.001606991,
-0.0058684126,
0.0807071552,
-0.0092733242,
0.0084770499,
0.0268229097,
-0.0139231794,
0.0341401435,
0.0243055522,
0.0200478677,
0.0051214378,
-0.0154290572,
0.0181582905,
-0.0570399314,
0.0127282972,
-0.0492330678,
-0.0203382727,
-0.0615047812,
0.0243982002,
-0.001658189,
0.0358989835,
0.0175524894,
-0.0178109445,
-0.0044013518,
-0.0022351905,
-0.031526044,
-0.0130068846,
-0.0043712519,
-0.0011205744,
0.0228968486,
-0.0016305016,
0.011447615,
0.0085757039,
-0.0205333419,
-0.055846367,
0.066861555,
-0.0012999347,
0.0337833427,
-0.0267654005,
0.0020479229,
-0.061468862,
-0.000638234,
-0.0260060001,
0.0418328084,
0.0272558779,
-0.0487302206,
0.0129923886,
0.0581989214,
-0.0408204198,
0.002694723,
0.0249495078,
-0.0039970642,
-0.0360245965,
0.019871179,
0.0024853076,
-0.0103485975,
-0.0129349688,
0.0148605742,
-0.0291138515,
0.0505792685,
-0.0535499305,
-0.0419247113,
-0.0147129409,
0.0530285425,
-0.0073660719,
-0.0116945105,
-0.016007321,
0.015542008,
-0.0114925988,
0.0707800314,
0.0139743201,
-0.049834244,
0.0579749085,
-0.0178606734,
-0.0293825157,
-0.0525531173,
0.008860847,
-0.1010365635,
0.0312053654,
0.0039773704,
-0.0182572603,
-0.0196164604,
0.0011859986,
-0.0291991308,
-0.0138283949,
0.0142451394,
-0.0246971436,
0.071592696,
-0.0283546057,
-0.0034684399,
-0.0206393152,
-0.0367423072,
-0.0359315351,
0.0267923418,
-0.0429706164,
0.033804439,
-0.0363536589,
-0.0356276743,
0.0193841942,
-0.0380835198,
0.011093786,
0.0059617078,
-0.0237049498,
-0.0203562137,
-0.0270294454,
-0.0067601535,
0.0166010931,
0.0353892669,
0.0486662053,
-0.0527547747,
0.0027253032,
0.0271223709,
0.0241920371,
-0.0064216442,
-0.0287387799,
0.0292901881,
0.0107020838,
0.0023526053,
-0.0108006652,
0.0090760114,
0.0127336346,
-0.0773730725,
0.0051793014,
0.0893679634,
0.0405838527,
-0.0262986831,
-0.0028149814,
-0.0780342072,
0.0177972913,
0.0477015413,
0.0235471167,
-0.0852836818,
-0.0253760517,
0.0034589765,
0.0093969814,
0.0281068254,
-0.030210169,
-0.0073691225,
-0.1258937865,
0.0303912349,
0.0135371685,
-0.0156068178,
-0.0115213459,
-0.0153192803,
0.0168571658,
0.0206458755,
-0.0337332413,
0.0376593918,
0.0031146321,
0.0266520362,
-0.0002685668,
0.0178106315,
-0.0230143238,
0.020107789,
-0.0003839258,
-0.022726642,
-0.0167537034,
0.0089521892,
-0.019755017,
-0.0681147873,
0.0593361184,
0.0159329139,
-0.0317896046,
-0.0227349866,
0.0117825009,
0.0059525212,
-0.0128062582,
0.0040982249,
0.0856346712,
-0.0649703518,
-0.0188124217,
0.019870162,
0.130307883,
-0.0055115204,
0.0035073545,
-0.010248458,
-0.0060799308,
-0.050245557,
0.0366073772,
0.0192082878,
-0.0128077492,
-0.0067491052,
-0.0419914238,
-0.0567988828,
-0.0143262222,
-0.0022856402,
0.0050066472,
0.046582818,
-0.011081961,
-0.0334545188,
-0.0155166443,
0.0534102805,
0.0420771912,
0.0078831827,
0.0061591011,
0.000791026,
-0.0321288034,
-0.0437203012,
0.0383329801,
-0.0556337275,
0.0364431702,
-0.0117902057,
0.0253153816,
-0.0085786264,
-0.0412554331,
-0.0340867937,
0.0215198658,
-0.1273898929,
-0.0474608205,
-0.0458636731,
0.0276634824,
0.023012463,
0.0389405452,
-0.0159324836,
0.0041129445,
0.0126015153,
0.0222596619,
-0.0427429341,
0.0266117174,
0.0471820757,
0.0126447557,
0.0135500617,
0.0196750276,
-0.0016608962,
-0.0200793613,
0.0158730838,
0.0301799718,
-0.0085763773,
-0.0039716596,
0.0273669548,
0.0381948948,
0.0029827787,
0.0360354371,
-0.0123802302,
-0.0195611306,
0.0550672151,
-0.0233899672,
-0.030097587,
-0.0331788845,
0.0229563192,
0.0114173423,
-0.0341617242,
0.0207153521,
-0.0358303078,
0.0307415351,
0.0433558002,
0.0117003443,
0.0721258894,
0.0101755448,
0.0336241387,
0.051015541,
-0.0222957209,
-0.0028970207,
-0.0184486192,
-0.0209745355,
0.051562842,
-0.0368667394,
0.0568385981,
0.0206609685,
0.0126594389,
-0.0298989825,
-0.006028757,
-0.0494300686,
-0.0756952018,
-0.0099706268,
0.0218442362,
0.0291480031,
0.015714068,
-0.0157624856,
-0.0292423386,
-0.005762524,
0.0084190639,
0.0427232124,
0.0230384953,
-0.018716082,
0.0433143526,
0.0198332854,
0.0126437917,
-0.0407613367,
0.0452219099,
-0.0461458154,
0.0333809555,
0.0185000747,
0.0379256792,
-0.0324565805,
-0.0290275831,
0.0310076065,
0.0303509142,
-0.0015057495,
0.021334378,
-0.0363780893,
-0.100649856,
-0.0174957216,
0.016271254,
-0.0467141606,
0.0141527951,
0.0347828008,
0.0659216866,
-0.0018734245,
-0.0156108122,
0.0074384739,
0.0652403235,
-0.0148842968,
-0.054457739,
-0.0016040795,
-6.165481094e-33,
-0.0049647675,
-0.0000126163,
0.0463889502,
0.0320079625,
-0.0151512418,
-0.0191876739,
-0.0298333075,
0.0091393311,
-0.0326968692,
-0.0174971148,
0.017438015,
0.032157056,
-0.0085400892,
0.0149598364,
0.0001525531,
-0.0162816979,
-0.0272098612,
-0.0028408053,
-0.0186598282,
0.0021179128,
0.0166258607,
0.002461741,
0.0791531131,
-0.057649415,
0.0288045481,
-0.02449104,
0.0170809012,
0.0374110751,
-0.0768535808,
0.0713908151,
-0.0305653568,
0.02271441,
0.0263909791,
-0.0175735615,
-0.0106527917,
-0.0205028821,
-0.0448469445,
-0.0457506031,
0.0096657407,
0.0133073423,
-0.0739137158,
-0.048189465,
0.0337260626,
0.0132743558,
0.01067934,
-0.0472430103,
0.0184579343,
-0.0417034179,
0.0024187884,
0.0232539158,
-0.0416093878,
0.0430855043,
-0.0241675675,
-0.0034084478,
0.0250768214,
0.0264342744,
0.0131697301,
0.0408346616,
-0.0067388653,
-0.0009539797,
0.04619601,
0.0124230925,
0.055412136,
-0.0177754238,
0.0109252576,
-0.0023499818,
-0.0129255876,
-0.0537088625,
-0.0403551422,
0.0075154263,
0.0236406364,
0.0717194676,
0.0670175701,
-0.0124645708,
0.0325223133,
0.0293408372,
-0.0558520705,
0.0002017479,
0.0235173572,
0.0490821972,
0.0191305652,
0.0060532903,
-0.0171953738,
-0.000847302,
-0.0531660765,
0.0014269098,
-0.0551285632,
-0.0148160784,
0.0123693328,
-0.0090567786,
-0.0266091824,
0.0494270474,
0.0232846532,
-0.0477976985,
-0.0189494081,
0.0292472858,
0.0046399739,
0.0266683195,
0.0154403821,
0.0539259352,
-0.0133393435,
0.001907889,
0.0154043827,
-0.023768276,
0.0593257584,
0.0063300058,
0.0473744012,
0.0110655054,
-0.0453092828,
-0.022866495,
-0.0694451779,
-0.0269028042,
0.0271918587,
0.0554653369,
0.0279252678,
0.0467481725,
-0.0024596013,
0.0414837524,
0.0080874385,
-0.0066138469,
-0.0605326407,
0.0300384928,
-0.0052865753,
0.0114500439,
-0.0255099833,
-0.0119536389,
-0.0256287158,
-0.0104791969,
0.047216367,
-0.0577462241,
-0.0123687303,
0.0457201302,
2.889e-7,
0.0872666985,
0.0400014967,
-0.0021686133,
0.044009652,
0.0285884887,
0.0323320217,
-0.0644507259,
-0.0124579072,
0.014985742,
-0.0332546532,
-0.0120859453,
0.0515438356,
0.0301912148,
0.0586283952,
-0.0444825627,
0.0247283615,
-0.010432926,
-0.0122146225,
-0.0637353659,
0.0062054903,
0.1036685109,
0.113016963,
0.0259854663,
-0.0176716987,
0.0193808395,
-0.0302222967,
0.0543531328,
-0.0045116856,
0.0045872033,
0.0146337114,
-0.0438433513,
0.0174937397,
0.0178809781,
0.0114564868,
0.0099515673,
0.03110932,
0.0004752245,
0.0583358221,
0.0168962479,
0.0430811234,
-0.0006732842,
-0.035128355,
0.0136714224,
-0.0964279324,
0.0848463327,
-0.0251706429,
-0.0506893545,
-0.019678304,
-0.0097510433,
-0.0104266452,
0.0097499285,
-0.005540865,
0.0255988911,
-0.0033242158,
0.0164176188,
-0.0119083598,
-0.0184532274,
-0.0667266995,
-0.0526251383,
-0.0042732405,
-0.0543774925,
-0.0403630771,
-0.0385034904,
-0.0103742136,
0.0403227471,
-0.0404186137,
0.001269766,
3.281616789e-34,
0.051292628,
-0.0314633921,
0.0151177384,
0.0483895987,
0.046208363,
-0.0285210945,
-0.0210173763,
0.0169120282,
0.0208708532,
-0.0977700129,
-0.009688016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07542v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07542v1
|
EMS-SD: Efficient Multi-sample Speculative Decoding for Accelerating Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T08:24:21 | 2024-05-13T08:24:21 |
Yunsheng Ni, Chuanjian Liu, Yehui Tang, Kai Han, Yunhe Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Speculative decoding emerges as a pivotal technique for enhancing the
inference speed of Large Language Models (LLMs). Despite recent research aiming
to improve prediction efficiency, multi-sample speculative decoding has been
overlooked due to varying numbers of accepted tokens within a batch in the
verification phase. Vanilla method adds padding tokens in order to ensure that
the number of new tokens remains consistent across samples. However, this
increases the computational and memory access overhead, thereby reducing the
speedup ratio. We propose a novel method that can resolve the issue of
inconsistent tokens accepted by different samples without necessitating an
increase in memory or computing overhead. Furthermore, our proposed method can
handle the situation where the prediction tokens of different samples are
inconsistent without the need to add padding tokens. Sufficient experiments
demonstrate the efficacy of our method. Our code is available at
https://github.com/niyunsheng/EMS-SD.
|
[
0.0216591489,
0.0843594,
0.01194451,
0.0226963982,
-0.0054618893,
0.0030748989,
-0.0197203662,
0.0199769214,
-0.0577408597,
0.0073460746,
0.0147344992,
-0.0965046063,
0.019984806,
0.0044229738,
-0.001539215,
0.0115838405,
0.0374660864,
-0.0389807858,
0.0436724089,
-0.0232716519,
-0.0295612942,
0.0296406671,
0.0118049458,
0.0378237441,
0.0124614621,
-0.0099465065,
-0.0281657148,
0.0037570731,
-0.0172104519,
-0.0426101126,
0.0121178944,
0.0559104942,
0.0121781286,
0.0589660928,
0.0000019969,
-0.0016530773,
-0.0236824211,
0.0071085272,
-0.040304739,
0.0749414563,
0.0451298878,
-0.040202599,
-0.0321251974,
0.0191254038,
0.0171506349,
-0.0518330038,
0.0614373349,
-0.0171637684,
-0.0072470359,
0.048535604,
0.0011074612,
0.0058041755,
0.0010334486,
0.013713168,
-0.029996682,
-0.0498351827,
0.0390128493,
-0.041899398,
-0.0297341999,
-0.0080086244,
-0.0336809568,
0.0164661519,
0.0014549332,
0.0161410589,
-0.0427958816,
0.0065931426,
-0.0179483928,
-0.0221923515,
-0.0217888877,
0.0093634287,
-0.0181274451,
-0.0688794553,
-0.0200471487,
0.0086953966,
-0.0507440083,
-0.0206735004,
-0.0350007936,
0.0264323484,
-0.0496442728,
0.0416630469,
0.0684743673,
0.029423438,
0.046223674,
-0.004472469,
-0.0592734031,
0.0925667062,
0.0503565893,
-0.0129886502,
-0.031581603,
0.0114605715,
-0.0058039147,
-0.0397012085,
0.0189175904,
-0.0201163273,
-0.0791857317,
0.0091821225,
-0.0399981253,
-0.0918457657,
0.0143378759,
-0.0121864323,
0.0295239482,
0.0797635093,
0.0228837654,
-0.0119705861,
-0.0176224224,
-0.0090126712,
-0.025766816,
0.0068496931,
-0.0363801457,
-0.0133601697,
0.0352910012,
0.0060773087,
-0.0617662817,
0.0079071447,
-0.0235539153,
-0.0068338597,
-0.0161010884,
0.0173939727,
0.0170441605,
0.0121737616,
0.0404847786,
-0.0334843174,
-0.0402518809,
0.0133005101,
0.0295863133,
0.0337734185,
-0.0170104038,
-0.0098075792,
-0.0289768372,
-0.0534700714,
-0.0346670747,
0.0017289841,
0.0132021569,
-0.0231774133,
-0.0159777328,
0.0458584838,
0.0066855089,
-0.0258563589,
-0.011073716,
-0.0101987803,
0.0155391423,
-0.0409383401,
0.0156138279,
-0.0508505218,
0.0271784142,
0.025358431,
0.0104999198,
-0.003595507,
-0.023905091,
0.0108825974,
-0.0041981917,
0.0472989604,
-0.0274989121,
0.0109083969,
-0.0018101495,
0.0012061686,
-0.0027391869,
0.1178541183,
-0.0118398247,
0.0307693444,
0.0384742282,
-0.005566177,
-0.0245261136,
0.0817030445,
0.033427462,
0.0186934844,
-0.0358072706,
-0.0131045086,
0.0320069864,
-0.0075907982,
0.0502618365,
0.0622875467,
-0.0434921272,
-0.0304848254,
0.0030689123,
0.0650247708,
-0.0397618487,
-0.0055477717,
0.0161067713,
0.0266683623,
0.0263449717,
0.0090799471,
0.004934039,
-0.0086501017,
0.0111136334,
0.0300038215,
0.0692317411,
0.0654281601,
-0.0086710807,
0.0268325843,
-0.03509444,
-0.0186455939,
0.0015290171,
0.0135089681,
0.0734722912,
-0.0375022851,
-0.0606092773,
0.0648423284,
0.0323259905,
-0.0400650091,
-0.0214989074,
-0.0251858942,
0.0531311035,
0.0769387037,
0.0458588451,
0.0401660092,
-0.0121568628,
0.0289426018,
-0.0420324653,
0.0143085876,
0.0055745011,
-0.00822079,
0.0529479347,
-0.0436236039,
-0.0179296117,
0.0693581477,
0.0173075385,
0.0578596853,
0.0647653043,
0.0136683648,
-0.0085360846,
-0.039261736,
-0.0233607646,
0.0122635737,
0.009782902,
0.0097936997,
0.0091081047,
-0.0003746349,
0.0390730463,
0.0062867855,
0.0004098816,
0.0035412528,
0.0393982828,
-0.0258784648,
0.0026623891,
-0.0074159997,
-0.0616060793,
-0.0571252964,
0.0360471085,
0.0040441114,
-0.0325375311,
0.0187967755,
-0.0231457893,
-0.0398244075,
0.0282922871,
-0.0167002119,
0.0591571704,
-0.043125689,
0.0433569327,
-0.0336937532,
0.0391457267,
0.0052850642,
0.0071467427,
-0.0331609286,
0.0339318812,
0.0066725179,
0.0054236958,
-0.004967324,
-0.0199768096,
-0.0098433821,
0.0137583036,
0.0002475641,
0.0081135957,
-0.0126271453,
-0.0208238009,
-0.0064750481,
0.0052506737,
-0.0933072791,
-0.0083361883,
-0.0325814225,
0.0298278239,
-0.0025421751,
0.0210519861,
-0.0113614611,
-0.0089586237,
-0.0045760931,
-0.0398931168,
-0.0101891942,
0.0021068873,
-0.0456168763,
-0.0126323542,
-0.0547230095,
0.0173739027,
-0.0208356157,
0.0048302659,
0.0555987544,
-0.0484180003,
-0.0525582619,
-0.1033905596,
-0.0083816517,
0.0302356835,
0.0176956151,
0.015761489,
-0.032812532,
-0.0041648881,
-0.0502864346,
0.0218031071,
-0.0128621636,
-0.0093445079,
-0.0103376284,
0.0187307447,
-0.0006568148,
-0.0458021834,
-0.0190944895,
0.0109919757,
-0.0049788924,
-0.0393700339,
-0.0591507033,
-0.0142530436,
0.0702146143,
0.0166754015,
-0.0277072955,
-0.064658992,
-0.0297194701,
0.0032247815,
-0.0288615841,
0.0069445879,
-0.0196256749,
-0.0177741945,
0.0438838266,
-0.0099882865,
-0.0537123941,
0.0736849979,
-0.0836877674,
-0.0281584002,
-0.0283320434,
0.003934063,
-0.0202061776,
0.0036758631,
-0.0225067399,
0.029239418,
-0.0079636853,
-0.0406166613,
0.0249256101,
0.0339384638,
-0.0192537811,
-0.0417868793,
0.027030196,
-0.0071836137,
0.0259204935,
-0.0261713974,
-0.0145725934,
-0.0188940056,
-0.0268423501,
-0.0575000718,
-0.0084718177,
0.056524273,
-0.059628699,
0.0117998905,
0.0289569944,
-0.0644830987,
0.0403256305,
-0.0007147433,
0.0247057825,
-0.0022834013,
-0.0109863291,
0.0240474641,
-0.0327500999,
-0.0050200825,
-0.0530268624,
0.0001804894,
0.055009611,
0.0626431704,
0.0437309332,
-0.0604743548,
-0.0048421868,
0.0728720129,
0.0117680114,
0.0235033948,
0.0473264307,
0.0619990565,
-0.0455098227,
-0.0100545576,
0.123433657,
0.0290851668,
-0.0398340821,
0.0164842419,
0.0076011932,
0.0771209672,
0.0030253632,
0.0202932693,
-0.0762660354,
-0.0299945548,
0.0504589267,
0.0263557807,
-0.0166127104,
0.0006882023,
-0.0319326147,
-0.1095132604,
0.0452994406,
0.0368620381,
-0.0614208058,
-0.0035227716,
-0.041574426,
-0.03530287,
0.0372940935,
0.0744409263,
0.0437534079,
0.0398995727,
-0.0058169514,
0.0396858938,
0.0143934535,
-0.0394074358,
0.0292508882,
-0.0227765087,
0.076295808,
0.00649291,
-0.0414644442,
0.0162331555,
-0.0150010008,
-0.0226334669,
0.0053346301,
-0.0471486822,
-0.0268425103,
-0.0031691918,
-0.0240521319,
0.0039149295,
0.0303800367,
0.0061051813,
-0.030937355,
-0.0127719259,
-0.0181054994,
0.0792447552,
0.006537864,
-0.0247607622,
-0.0084417956,
-0.0224240664,
0.0062725642,
0.0622135513,
0.028093271,
-0.0381209701,
0.0079039484,
-0.0613132715,
-0.0458638556,
-0.0653943419,
0.0307678357,
0.0306893513,
-0.01293106,
-0.0421754196,
-0.0115532093,
0.0369985998,
0.0485755242,
0.041149281,
-0.0106558418,
0.0601850785,
0.0078365821,
-0.0315152928,
-0.077048786,
-0.0107101835,
-0.0178383719,
0.0315893628,
-0.0590744093,
0.009394059,
0.0048980373,
0.0176965371,
-0.0073464033,
0.0249335822,
-0.0931995809,
-0.0682943463,
0.007413744,
-0.0011227605,
0.0195080899,
0.0288976599,
-0.0254291128,
-0.0433466285,
0.0502115041,
0.0338869281,
-0.0485078245,
0.0119101061,
0.0236311164,
-0.026386518,
0.0229765717,
0.0150884436,
-0.0063026543,
-0.0119825415,
-0.006279863,
0.0232090317,
0.0198654477,
-0.0069922158,
0.0029215587,
0.0490859896,
0.0333865546,
-0.0486853719,
-0.0036709735,
0.0212866776,
0.0598977096,
-0.0041848482,
-0.0034377328,
-0.0065559824,
0.0176902432,
-0.0051341215,
-0.0493482873,
-0.0363675803,
-0.0146694668,
0.0347096287,
0.0245187953,
0.0386733077,
-0.0297292825,
-0.0451696329,
0.0320106521,
0.0843513459,
-0.0367712006,
-0.0118377097,
-0.0032284143,
0.0153475786,
0.0179158524,
-0.0288974065,
-0.0062715444,
0.018260723,
0.0124724107,
-0.0303938873,
-0.008805057,
-0.0347953588,
-0.0221048612,
-0.0606520958,
0.0288320053,
0.0285433196,
-0.0016196375,
0.0224187057,
-0.0148993563,
0.0030301407,
-0.033620026,
0.0076596327,
-0.026203325,
-0.0045066872,
0.0622832365,
0.0078307241,
-0.0397631228,
0.0244037416,
0.0451916382,
0.0421847701,
0.0266297106,
-0.0161727071,
-0.0276003107,
-0.0152709382,
-0.0264018793,
-0.0261416435,
0.0294444039,
-0.0645094514,
-0.0162199829,
-0.0170410369,
-0.0699433237,
0.0245158561,
0.0264319275,
0.0083674053,
0.0178072006,
-0.0072761485,
0.053559579,
0.0053908904,
0.0018923585,
-0.0062587461,
-0.0174443908,
0.0620904751,
-0.0351254493,
0.0155940987,
-6.540857583e-33,
0.012553297,
-0.011890701,
-0.0197301526,
-0.0679257959,
-0.0039536306,
-0.0290260259,
-0.0320461765,
-0.0281153098,
0.0521744266,
-0.0089802695,
-0.0353785902,
0.0230818205,
0.0450263284,
0.037953943,
0.0041621681,
0.0106665976,
0.065326333,
-0.0108043682,
-0.0231164861,
-0.0050562704,
0.0435445458,
0.0429563709,
0.0508216545,
0.0125126066,
0.0005861341,
-0.0182268173,
0.0084506487,
-0.0096338503,
-0.0133213559,
0.0456852615,
0.001229114,
0.0315340906,
0.0135225113,
-0.0264907591,
-0.0420306697,
0.0044297404,
-0.0812676251,
0.0197483879,
0.033629708,
0.0521846563,
-0.0137082431,
-0.0232762098,
-0.0309855938,
0.0108320769,
-0.0075934916,
0.0105158994,
-0.045324225,
-0.0260536261,
-0.0307579264,
-0.0574273467,
0.0144060403,
0.0335755348,
0.0020733331,
0.0729677528,
0.0764976218,
-0.0219236445,
0.0031477627,
0.0430780351,
-0.0210161954,
0.0090097468,
-0.0174998827,
0.0716856122,
0.0680790097,
0.0149687165,
-0.0219826028,
0.0279454216,
0.0370441712,
-0.0649731234,
-0.0077733938,
0.0104552573,
0.0494654328,
-0.0267532468,
-0.0212823488,
0.0478417054,
0.0913779736,
-0.0452414453,
-0.0488455333,
0.0276350304,
0.0374048389,
-0.0019174737,
0.0544150248,
0.0243640468,
-0.0193321574,
-0.0576841719,
-0.0674332827,
-0.0260372162,
-0.0564349629,
-0.0035273666,
0.0090086097,
0.0134545863,
-0.0488818996,
-0.009000767,
0.0593784712,
-0.0553501844,
-0.0368199423,
-0.0023373037,
-0.015736023,
0.0060268361,
-0.0283357874,
0.0436234809,
0.0052121365,
-0.0498141907,
0.0433370844,
-0.0178904645,
0.0004846203,
-0.0139304847,
0.0101903174,
0.0179062672,
-0.0857113227,
0.0081582665,
-0.0253205523,
0.0263869017,
-0.0000571935,
-0.0018519254,
0.0630993694,
-0.0095729865,
0.0178872459,
0.0029873729,
0.0087781213,
0.0386365205,
-0.0232711937,
-0.0019155464,
0.0288782734,
0.0595784076,
-0.0110812178,
0.0195306037,
-0.0455506667,
-0.0366394371,
0.0533371121,
-0.0431328937,
-0.0122317364,
0.0481275097,
2.641e-7,
0.021936968,
0.0524479486,
0.0542859323,
0.0006018915,
0.0216573607,
0.0009392974,
-0.0280139036,
0.0102887144,
-0.0008835171,
0.0045206537,
-0.008728195,
0.0137868151,
0.0560318716,
0.017763542,
-0.1035506427,
-0.0143394554,
-0.0311465692,
0.0204953458,
-0.0580639578,
-0.0132733071,
-0.0221123863,
0.1315698475,
-0.002226495,
-0.0441760607,
0.0508933477,
-0.0009384175,
-0.0071953437,
0.0077789119,
-0.017852243,
0.0155026875,
-0.015746858,
-0.0081194462,
0.0256392658,
0.0183849949,
-0.0073601995,
-0.0012326202,
-0.0337277651,
0.0658390149,
-0.0004049174,
-0.004915847,
0.0331794955,
-0.0286988728,
-0.0285155531,
-0.0058944356,
0.023443535,
0.0052620023,
-0.0099391807,
-0.047156956,
-0.0005469407,
-0.0161638763,
-0.0551283546,
0.0037681118,
0.019631641,
0.0658728033,
0.0327361561,
-0.0042686895,
0.0078739924,
-0.0566964969,
-0.0420553945,
-0.0327885635,
-0.0502049699,
-0.0819655359,
-0.005621247,
-0.0046135979,
0.0206874367,
-0.0869074315,
0.0202154238,
3.063227157e-34,
0.0871018618,
0.0058603971,
-0.0041539012,
0.0751177073,
0.0226431619,
-0.0702134967,
0.0197741948,
0.0471311584,
-0.01345139,
-0.0597673468,
-0.051051721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07513v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07513v1
|
Fine-tuning the SwissBERT Encoder Model for Embedding Sentences and Documents
| 2024-05-13T07:20:21 | 2024-05-13T07:20:21 |
Juri Grosjean, Jannis Vamvas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Encoder models trained for the embedding of sentences or short documents have
proven useful for tasks such as semantic search and topic modeling. In this
paper, we present a version of the SwissBERT encoder model that we specifically
fine-tuned for this purpose. SwissBERT contains language adapters for the four
national languages of Switzerland -- German, French, Italian, and Romansh --
and has been pre-trained on a large number of news articles in those languages.
Using contrastive learning based on a subset of these articles, we trained a
fine-tuned version, which we call SentenceSwissBERT. Multilingual experiments
on document retrieval and text classification in a Switzerland-specific setting
show that SentenceSwissBERT surpasses the accuracy of the original SwissBERT
model and of a comparable baseline. The model is openly available for research
use.
|
[
0.0102823162,
0.0472739041,
0.0043216501,
0.0738874078,
-0.0622495189,
0.0172934942,
-0.0042838487,
-0.034220349,
-0.0030175217,
-0.0349018276,
0.021818269,
-0.005160301,
-0.0335098431,
0.0256840885,
0.0008172869,
-0.04529595,
0.0296893902,
-0.0227693263,
0.0016874776,
-0.0045701694,
0.0215755887,
-0.002420625,
0.0461045504,
0.009065358,
0.0438982919,
0.0327135436,
-0.0107418597,
0.021052679,
0.0285782572,
-0.0113351569,
0.0222112983,
-0.0017107909,
0.062656343,
0.0018570552,
0.0000016815,
-0.0230878983,
-0.0278846323,
-0.0256599579,
0.0550314113,
-0.0322439633,
0.0368645638,
-0.1103628129,
0.0138320429,
0.0451510996,
-0.0049764211,
0.0010123358,
-0.0101997443,
0.0585661791,
0.0210906286,
0.0968748778,
-0.0440763086,
-0.0534510612,
0.0325379334,
-0.0211486295,
-0.0240530372,
0.0120665906,
0.0075840103,
-0.0180464126,
-0.0079868501,
0.071750015,
-0.0408072136,
0.0465351865,
0.0511915274,
0.0051070936,
0.0164293665,
-0.0101889931,
-0.0085132439,
0.003379199,
0.0192000587,
0.0422760472,
0.0042769196,
-0.017426569,
-0.0297892243,
0.0033682429,
-0.0207840297,
0.0467199907,
-0.0387708992,
-0.0134791546,
0.0041690413,
0.0261401981,
0.0831293315,
0.0258354619,
-0.0232164785,
-0.0064355005,
-0.001298187,
-0.010672641,
0.0309936777,
-0.0625597462,
0.0230658352,
0.0321694501,
0.0127790226,
-0.0031063089,
0.019816611,
0.0146248462,
0.0214526933,
-0.019823527,
-0.0106947832,
-0.0386388153,
0.024838686,
-0.0833576694,
-0.0373158008,
0.0444810912,
-0.0453964137,
0.0853806287,
-0.0285063498,
0.0610880516,
-0.0256444272,
-0.0135305841,
-0.0743436962,
-0.0469986349,
-0.0315526314,
0.0278044082,
-0.0388843827,
0.0304087289,
-0.0690247938,
-0.0599965341,
-0.0121306097,
0.0274188221,
0.0504563041,
0.0148699684,
-0.022541726,
-0.0146084484,
-0.0136773186,
0.0135251898,
-0.0220203791,
0.0763183534,
-0.0464366078,
0.0117040435,
-0.0449309759,
-0.0084753986,
-0.0102907429,
0.0204975586,
0.0126995482,
-0.0365585797,
0.0118560456,
-0.0015291284,
-0.0359359421,
-0.0549074896,
-0.0019339194,
0.0208830517,
0.012155165,
-0.0203310195,
0.0013901532,
-0.0734762177,
0.024616072,
0.017709922,
0.0162015948,
-0.0497180521,
-0.0140188849,
-0.0002362219,
-0.0438508764,
0.0620209277,
-0.008104831,
-0.0426171944,
0.0112582343,
0.0012311555,
0.012207076,
0.0739948079,
-0.0203481466,
0.0172266569,
0.0292578507,
0.0000851843,
0.002035273,
0.0028302062,
0.0015642429,
0.006275055,
-0.0407291465,
0.029402189,
-0.0049601323,
0.0060241758,
0.0487700775,
0.0578710027,
-0.0269966424,
-0.0337027721,
0.0421158373,
0.0426413529,
0.0344845578,
-0.0038223965,
0.018075956,
-0.000020885,
-0.0262830071,
0.0228608213,
0.0328785256,
0.0216550864,
-0.0364582911,
0.0185412522,
0.0131715052,
0.0192239136,
-0.0720623583,
-0.0202935711,
0.0252931658,
-0.0343678445,
0.0607734323,
-0.017211901,
0.0850279257,
0.0157559924,
-0.0513256639,
-0.0003749472,
0.0283812396,
-0.0268478878,
0.0217143148,
-0.0026123668,
0.014247491,
0.0951728672,
0.0438811816,
-0.0015596193,
0.0263165794,
-0.0356822312,
0.0037653644,
0.0349466503,
0.0399827398,
-0.0014407326,
0.0211683493,
-0.0543541238,
-0.04456589,
-0.0564284921,
0.0043072784,
0.0395848118,
-0.0375027321,
0.060739588,
0.019457493,
-0.0179439373,
0.0161830559,
0.0076775826,
-0.0625262335,
-0.0109191975,
-0.0030726946,
0.0076270318,
-0.0148070985,
0.0049837134,
-0.0034652101,
-0.0147527969,
0.0270136818,
-0.0812946558,
-0.0032031275,
0.0132991178,
0.0128441565,
-0.0918019488,
-0.0229631756,
-0.0872363448,
0.0550809763,
0.0535586812,
-0.0353686586,
-0.0509029143,
0.0108446945,
-0.0192456171,
0.0440654196,
-0.0397267491,
-0.019069206,
-0.0233442243,
-0.001673412,
-0.0041041118,
0.0588645674,
-0.0333686471,
0.0595128722,
-0.0051132892,
-0.0267194714,
0.0098433616,
-0.0299630407,
-0.0381498598,
0.0051147984,
0.0165373664,
0.0047940616,
0.0588458441,
0.01319128,
0.0152174225,
-0.0306045599,
-0.076567471,
0.0111918626,
-0.06378185,
0.0101622595,
0.0129439002,
0.0252491608,
0.0187965073,
-0.0290238354,
-0.0324676819,
-0.0112310452,
0.0066442555,
0.0247114748,
0.0214449465,
0.0015974501,
-0.012516493,
-0.0203426797,
-0.0168333706,
0.0193561874,
0.0693993121,
-0.0286588334,
-0.0125718899,
-0.0486321598,
0.0493992455,
-0.0157556366,
-0.0106370188,
-0.0447820798,
-0.046175614,
-0.0315601863,
-0.0007209962,
0.0001112461,
0.0752008259,
0.0118227741,
0.0609564781,
-0.0010319876,
0.0337279364,
-0.0558142997,
-0.0139873372,
-0.0397074781,
0.0281778574,
-0.0598106869,
-0.0283504725,
0.0348636881,
0.0471669212,
-0.0156508181,
0.0394396558,
-0.0373615883,
0.0015504293,
0.0019252984,
0.0159342885,
-0.0334738009,
-0.0187430754,
0.0267344955,
0.0252154097,
-0.0138188628,
0.003071093,
0.0615274943,
0.0034491925,
0.0190368704,
-0.044479847,
-0.0684167445,
-0.0461558178,
0.0117321247,
0.023550421,
0.0303083975,
-0.0190579686,
-0.0004892004,
-0.0252906792,
-0.039681159,
0.0162089318,
-0.0197340474,
0.0112487907,
0.0396327823,
0.0087032886,
0.0004509493,
-0.0894395784,
-0.0011243467,
-0.0650414228,
-0.0149518093,
0.0446124189,
0.026693536,
0.0039460976,
-0.0745109394,
0.0212039165,
0.0264813621,
0.0615100563,
-0.025654126,
-0.0160206575,
-0.0234973487,
0.0788377449,
0.051362142,
-0.054512918,
-0.0094821267,
-0.0491669625,
0.0367221199,
0.034266267,
-0.0213989299,
0.0268225316,
-0.0297237933,
-0.0114109255,
0.0212766714,
-0.0222591516,
-0.0358410887,
-0.0413756631,
0.0385121107,
-0.0180273633,
-0.0432684235,
0.1108761281,
0.030169053,
-0.0553467646,
-0.0351393968,
-0.0162783023,
0.0230074711,
0.0236321278,
0.0267302115,
-0.047022786,
-0.0110934339,
-0.0000980544,
0.0080074007,
0.005713331,
0.0434282571,
0.0271512512,
-0.081857264,
0.0234108418,
0.0181921571,
-0.0576166771,
-0.0456751138,
-0.083757706,
-0.0362653211,
-0.0525969639,
0.0062288381,
-0.0062545557,
-0.00381606,
-0.0175488405,
0.0113815181,
-0.0101712216,
-0.1145969108,
-0.0292283464,
-0.023022458,
0.0065816999,
-0.0104083931,
0.0005160312,
-0.0319796391,
-0.0482952222,
0.0075227381,
-0.0463485382,
-0.0046528853,
-0.0278023407,
0.0520469323,
-0.0300258789,
0.0157047361,
-0.0161260869,
-0.0028812177,
-0.0262047667,
-0.0131937126,
-0.0005104681,
0.0405183658,
-0.0141193829,
0.0271082893,
-0.0254135262,
-0.0116693377,
0.0166566446,
0.0751695335,
0.0280059129,
-0.036309544,
0.0044612018,
-0.053830374,
0.0315595679,
-0.0476092957,
0.0009454773,
-0.023722792,
0.0152252,
0.0235051252,
-0.0452695042,
-0.059698876,
-0.0130158952,
0.0170062874,
-0.0103249643,
-0.0143857989,
-0.0094864098,
-0.043120604,
-0.066829592,
0.0258354191,
0.0128711332,
-0.0210024286,
-0.0154130263,
0.0077703209,
0.0882464647,
-0.0302901734,
-0.0353208333,
-0.0561486818,
-0.015878655,
-0.0357394814,
-0.0617285147,
0.0409110114,
0.0123607963,
0.062962465,
-0.0093943747,
-0.0275478046,
0.0591385923,
0.0022070659,
-0.0453518145,
-0.0328863263,
0.0326320976,
-0.027987482,
-0.0095379483,
0.0024145958,
-0.0307376366,
0.0430926308,
-0.0008027954,
0.0171893593,
-0.0326749831,
-0.020547308,
0.0067908056,
-0.0318310447,
0.0354036093,
0.007377225,
-0.0162634458,
-0.044748079,
0.0230381209,
-0.0216416381,
0.0205301307,
-0.0436478555,
0.0019879101,
0.0474890582,
0.0250293165,
-0.0248559862,
0.0185371488,
-0.0132007161,
0.002395926,
-0.0304299463,
0.0329176746,
0.0691709518,
0.0070974161,
-0.0206937529,
0.0478671268,
-0.0190469231,
0.0440511629,
0.0088043725,
0.0513208732,
-0.0500162579,
0.0520446301,
0.0219413098,
0.0423002206,
0.0011596686,
0.0010881876,
-0.1004935876,
0.0038061626,
-0.0591985583,
0.0075253285,
0.06436795,
-0.0284133311,
0.0451715179,
0.0016638187,
-0.0175517183,
-0.0119563732,
0.0261112098,
-0.0055250232,
-0.0309637561,
0.0114119872,
0.0291145127,
-0.0287237074,
0.0283840559,
0.027722029,
-0.0035715799,
0.0063931788,
0.0198523477,
-0.0246339124,
-0.0331723578,
0.0308409426,
0.0872107148,
0.0373455472,
-0.0278046932,
0.0016425645,
-0.0076188077,
-0.0200316906,
0.0313046202,
0.0119810458,
-0.0286616646,
0.0182046406,
0.0350090601,
0.0578521714,
0.0034375561,
0.0125502534,
-0.0400123447,
-0.0060788002,
-0.0637114272,
-0.0660564005,
-0.0054632681,
-5.834927675e-33,
-0.0126059558,
0.0330758914,
-0.0248661302,
-0.0063840044,
0.0313214026,
0.0143074961,
-0.0278417729,
-0.0497669727,
-0.0359600633,
0.0200664848,
0.0258295983,
0.0094086165,
0.0014092374,
0.050538227,
0.0014029744,
-0.0167100374,
0.0522883125,
0.0410657413,
-0.0180325136,
0.0047261119,
0.0289902724,
0.0386558548,
0.0459052213,
-0.0450971201,
-0.0132921394,
-0.0182316322,
0.0087305373,
0.0113542126,
0.1047491208,
0.0836891159,
-0.0122138914,
0.0355933383,
0.0119667044,
-0.0480467305,
0.0074583432,
0.0352048837,
-0.0705767646,
-0.0332360566,
-0.0215991847,
0.0277896114,
-0.0303328875,
-0.0354256034,
0.030505212,
-0.0075419676,
-0.0063788933,
0.0025855459,
0.05945177,
-0.0106837153,
-0.032058429,
-0.0230970308,
-0.0442211144,
0.0068944627,
-0.0061598462,
0.0259193927,
0.0395241752,
0.0723010227,
0.0222440809,
0.0368791074,
-0.0528710335,
0.0079065971,
-0.0129554952,
0.0153543223,
-0.0044570547,
-0.0351235382,
-0.0258258488,
0.0500865392,
0.0035692216,
-0.0049837818,
0.0472413376,
-0.01592228,
0.0568797514,
-0.0172299258,
0.0483037457,
0.069039315,
0.0273995828,
-0.0182049479,
-0.060190279,
0.0567376353,
0.011616624,
0.0116369668,
0.02728457,
0.0230060145,
-0.0282311011,
-0.0089723626,
-0.0158764683,
-0.0301754866,
-0.0158417914,
-0.0522192121,
0.034522254,
0.0281218886,
0.0294686668,
-0.033957839,
0.0767935887,
-0.0365297869,
0.0138882231,
0.066500552,
-0.0362050608,
0.027668817,
-0.0011596223,
0.0397909656,
-0.0459829345,
-0.0490551256,
-0.0005383874,
0.0219388008,
-0.0136116249,
-0.0032059606,
0.0725203753,
-0.0082370471,
-0.0718377754,
0.0012909569,
-0.0068508708,
-0.0183521491,
-0.0441677049,
0.0301325526,
-0.0056713065,
0.0180850402,
-0.0017235839,
0.0401147902,
0.0085714711,
-0.0120232943,
-0.0199865494,
-0.0871852711,
0.0191026945,
0.0544526875,
-0.0062301224,
0.0205208939,
-0.0174397454,
0.0619492233,
0.001943747,
-0.0401211008,
0.0026351467,
0.008172852,
2.489e-7,
0.0455547087,
0.0247281007,
-0.0475675017,
-0.0031695056,
0.0086169718,
0.0153217604,
-0.0083147362,
0.0650676265,
0.017630022,
-0.0000869453,
0.036445111,
0.0285687502,
0.0364500396,
0.0227262415,
-0.1048063487,
0.0324760675,
-0.0509865917,
-0.0226854607,
-0.0280148368,
0.0200702474,
0.0741891637,
0.1047712788,
0.0087369597,
0.0197939593,
-0.0223652348,
-0.0420057811,
0.0998852178,
-0.0172438081,
-0.0585366264,
-0.0487036407,
-0.0194744151,
0.0738753006,
-0.0152965263,
-0.0070227915,
-0.0024603836,
0.0488852821,
0.0074960026,
0.0332221389,
-0.0031047841,
-0.0361142196,
0.0030383763,
0.0019432275,
-0.0479042567,
-0.0387608819,
0.0423835702,
-0.0384402908,
-0.0120202843,
-0.0029244004,
-0.0624998286,
0.0002909956,
0.088208355,
-0.0114852805,
-0.02046399,
0.0077562816,
0.02522045,
0.0094843889,
0.0125515591,
-0.0429298468,
0.020406777,
0.0560280159,
0.0136377579,
-0.0000567842,
-0.0009386815,
0.0251568165,
0.0041953926,
-0.0193195995,
0.0266032554,
1.88972403e-34,
0.0685316995,
-0.0025773123,
-0.0275383666,
0.0203413963,
0.018956881,
-0.0274407584,
-0.0463425741,
-0.032934621,
0.0155446464,
-0.0498616248,
-0.0026775235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07500v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07500v1
|
PromptLink: Leveraging Large Language Models for Cross-Source Biomedical Concept Linking
| 2024-05-13T06:36:30 | 2024-05-13T06:36:30 |
Yuzhang Xie, Jiaying Lu, Joyce Ho, Fadi Nahab, Xiao Hu, Carl Yang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Linking (aligning) biomedical concepts across diverse data sources enables
various integrative analyses, but it is challenging due to the discrepancies in
concept naming conventions. Various strategies have been developed to overcome
this challenge, such as those based on string-matching rules, manually crafted
thesauri, and machine learning models. However, these methods are constrained
by limited prior biomedical knowledge and can hardly generalize beyond the
limited amounts of rules, thesauri, or training samples. Recently, large
language models (LLMs) have exhibited impressive results in diverse biomedical
NLP tasks due to their unprecedentedly rich prior knowledge and strong
zero-shot prediction abilities. However, LLMs suffer from issues including high
costs, limited context length, and unreliable predictions. In this research, we
propose PromptLink, a novel biomedical concept linking framework that leverages
LLMs. It first employs a biomedical-specialized pre-trained language model to
generate candidate concepts that can fit in the LLM context windows. Then it
utilizes an LLM to link concepts through two-stage prompts, where the
first-stage prompt aims to elicit the biomedical prior knowledge from the LLM
for the concept linking task and the second-stage prompt enforces the LLM to
reflect on its own predictions to further enhance their reliability. Empirical
results on the concept linking task between two EHR datasets and an external
biomedical KG demonstrate the effectiveness of PromptLink. Furthermore,
PromptLink is a generic framework without reliance on additional prior
knowledge, context, or training data, making it well-suited for concept linking
across various types of data sources. The source code is available at
https://github.com/constantjxyz/PromptLink.
|
[
0.0235115159,
0.0601309687,
-0.0040875431,
-0.0505911745,
-0.0194353387,
0.0326578245,
0.0007955551,
0.0121909855,
-0.0137067512,
-0.0138016753,
-0.0293261725,
-0.0129711246,
0.0406186245,
0.0446548089,
0.0373223945,
-0.0210634992,
0.0455147363,
0.0321331136,
0.0050794925,
0.0050727031,
-0.0184153859,
0.0236730129,
0.0054438803,
0.0331574753,
0.0139847659,
-0.0096489601,
0.0303397421,
-0.0142668048,
0.0254762173,
-0.063292332,
-0.0195235405,
0.0545534641,
-0.0018091711,
0.05941654,
0.0000019198,
-0.0663675666,
-0.04597551,
0.0444638804,
-0.0443100631,
-0.0336848125,
0.0244204309,
-0.0503308475,
0.0191291627,
-0.0333384126,
0.0031149955,
-0.0385769568,
0.0733301416,
0.0490667708,
0.0333814695,
0.0372370966,
-0.0023499352,
-0.0248216875,
0.0572123416,
-0.0457988717,
0.0346461646,
-0.0298731998,
0.0741332322,
-0.0236018617,
0.0119484672,
0.0112495981,
-0.0063906298,
0.0516155921,
-0.0086532729,
0.0382390879,
0.0291746613,
0.0450393781,
-0.0230453052,
-0.0318353996,
0.0087213488,
0.1030215546,
-0.0196549371,
-0.043119695,
0.0153571665,
0.0082702897,
-0.0370483622,
0.0375572369,
-0.049765639,
-0.0044964533,
-0.0102232108,
-0.0026946235,
0.0189021863,
-0.017645536,
0.0588110909,
0.0098387832,
-0.0203761309,
0.0367638133,
0.0216776151,
-0.0089944853,
0.0351830013,
-0.0046396852,
-0.0088692186,
-0.0501020104,
-0.0002766771,
0.0225432739,
-0.0316907652,
0.0435993299,
-0.0291626677,
-0.0087982127,
0.0975282937,
-0.0215616897,
-0.0118419519,
0.017770648,
-0.008231936,
0.0371779129,
-0.053706225,
-0.0099149616,
-0.030242011,
0.0158223622,
-0.0163340718,
-0.0422935598,
-0.0701061562,
-0.0107210875,
-0.0080585442,
0.000702501,
-0.018897878,
-0.0233244579,
-0.0770712718,
-0.0005768402,
-0.0155862877,
0.0336697474,
0.0147184432,
-0.0069668004,
-0.0231041797,
0.0082521094,
-0.0416786745,
-0.0010480951,
0.0148998303,
0.0073809586,
-0.0274133757,
-0.0682725534,
-0.0167548507,
-0.0287771933,
-0.0303644352,
-0.0461510196,
0.0115145259,
0.0612386502,
0.0417691879,
0.0014414524,
-0.0154297724,
-0.0569206141,
0.0051845526,
-0.0418790653,
-0.0298112705,
-0.0741129667,
0.0556412451,
0.0139734251,
0.0041845413,
-0.0649665818,
0.0105518242,
0.0174864717,
-0.0795601681,
0.1233961955,
-0.0666470453,
-0.0295623057,
0.0242002551,
0.0178480111,
-0.0085778022,
0.025215663,
-0.0240400806,
-0.0567648523,
0.0086543178,
0.004143205,
-0.0335122719,
-0.0137489121,
0.0496974252,
-0.0517206006,
-0.0046091084,
0.0186058916,
0.0612665676,
0.0802989602,
0.0081968522,
0.045885738,
-0.0061700293,
-0.0356265828,
0.007666063,
0.0667442381,
0.0466956235,
-0.0056377468,
0.0581564866,
-0.031131655,
-0.0164487585,
-0.0530118831,
-0.0300093554,
-0.0124989618,
-0.0270951297,
0.009915472,
0.0132087292,
0.0424868725,
-0.0145867988,
0.0111909853,
-0.0168942139,
-0.0013716827,
-0.0529913381,
0.0041191475,
0.0437009744,
-0.0233808905,
0.0028169996,
0.0659659728,
0.078672953,
0.0260115247,
0.0082443794,
-0.0258217994,
-0.0061817179,
0.0465114415,
0.0395818688,
-0.0063317632,
-0.0507950671,
-0.0206645522,
0.0014174104,
0.0021235833,
0.0149919577,
-0.0351361632,
-0.0141275274,
-0.025658153,
-0.0076833037,
0.0297032241,
-0.0034406669,
-0.012629766,
-0.0002721328,
0.0579825751,
-0.0031503171,
-0.0371590182,
0.0104082134,
0.0568108149,
-0.063458778,
-0.0011213723,
-0.0137694944,
-0.0086911898,
0.0224386305,
0.0043484326,
-0.0150417658,
0.0373009108,
0.0476898886,
-0.0273752697,
-0.0319235437,
-0.016818082,
-0.0179279149,
-0.044589173,
0.0405108109,
-0.0146892834,
-0.0014280415,
-0.0516168773,
-0.0537939295,
-0.0469099097,
-0.0113328202,
0.0263535995,
0.013803062,
-0.0089815082,
0.0273211822,
0.021126397,
0.0085348561,
-0.0547813289,
0.0224247519,
-0.0025276064,
0.0300228167,
0.0307908989,
-0.0067721428,
0.0238815229,
-0.0263937823,
-0.0302006304,
0.016466327,
0.0044789035,
-0.0155948885,
-0.0071942769,
-0.0347840562,
-0.0596422777,
0.0087808995,
-0.0536359251,
0.04285926,
0.0499050431,
0.0047845491,
0.0155888712,
-0.0007658854,
-0.0059806621,
-0.0215789564,
-0.0297879558,
-0.0043213759,
0.0131418062,
0.0244296305,
0.0193496011,
0.0384460688,
-0.0216208808,
-0.0470125191,
-0.0136714661,
-0.0479291715,
0.0777405351,
0.0061458577,
-0.0433603153,
-0.0183766689,
-0.0008116757,
-0.0442234874,
0.0023919041,
-0.0040099653,
0.0313169174,
-0.0201758947,
0.0259369444,
0.0211241376,
-0.0025485775,
-0.0293314382,
-0.0122629926,
0.0764398426,
-0.0010318641,
-0.0458544642,
-0.0048905406,
-0.0262331013,
-0.0191208944,
0.008190643,
-0.0093041481,
0.0223753341,
0.0599150658,
-0.0023134996,
-0.0149716912,
-0.0366810299,
0.0325533077,
0.0001704149,
0.0164295081,
-0.0758494437,
0.0070310617,
-0.0072542736,
0.032373853,
-0.0158656389,
-0.0452163704,
0.0982915312,
-0.0098332623,
0.0546021871,
-0.0195192099,
0.001597171,
-0.029241439,
0.0194371268,
0.0144632068,
0.0253636222,
0.0496910289,
0.0098647457,
0.00077201,
0.0376743302,
-0.0245461501,
-0.0179400519,
0.0611293912,
-0.0352833606,
0.050322637,
0.0361190774,
-0.0054600541,
-0.040891096,
0.0396476723,
-0.0469404347,
0.0335895717,
0.0025293035,
0.0045097121,
-0.0501652136,
0.0368381739,
0.0163587537,
0.0232016314,
0.0342912525,
-0.0312974826,
0.0047417623,
-0.0048760795,
0.0628428385,
-0.0609479994,
0.0173350293,
0.0016769805,
0.0445282497,
0.0415757895,
0.0093649095,
0.0094359275,
0.0232097525,
0.0045492612,
0.0072911275,
-0.0654668659,
-0.0264639948,
0.0120962281,
-0.0104222586,
-0.0410798192,
0.0119855357,
0.1208518073,
0.0552963726,
-0.0940812454,
0.0012565659,
-0.0275046397,
-0.0054867691,
-0.0091909962,
0.0311963484,
-0.0866830572,
-0.0508098304,
-0.0154563021,
-0.0317316502,
-0.0135762617,
-0.0612217039,
-0.0099499216,
-0.0720638558,
-0.0022700627,
-0.0076638232,
-0.0876223296,
-0.0517260097,
-0.0866369084,
0.0323273055,
-0.0410718583,
-0.0006657649,
-0.0051359343,
0.0058622393,
0.0032694878,
-0.0058589,
-0.0360496156,
-0.0805625692,
0.0463322327,
-0.0699380785,
0.0913537219,
0.0436156653,
0.0158257373,
0.0156670455,
-0.0132108219,
-0.0142043196,
-0.0804105401,
-0.020767495,
-0.0194229521,
0.0691980347,
-0.004300456,
0.0098526832,
-0.0238026921,
0.0168722048,
-0.0375783183,
-0.0439682491,
-0.0286689494,
0.1172101647,
-0.000216182,
-0.0086285872,
-0.0423028953,
0.0033621858,
-0.0002002557,
0.083778657,
-0.0102449115,
-0.0020749497,
0.0004657105,
0.0193512049,
0.0197718292,
0.0153654087,
-0.0202170387,
0.033871673,
-0.0752656534,
-0.0198670235,
-0.0521077663,
-0.0073738052,
0.0703521445,
-0.0006860904,
0.0331590697,
0.0748420358,
-0.0131773483,
-0.0201707501,
-0.0599163584,
0.0736023784,
-0.0016738006,
0.0419549569,
-0.0519592762,
-0.0394028537,
0.0668876097,
0.0028179453,
-0.0257930774,
0.0341035984,
-0.0036195638,
-0.0358706191,
-0.029006049,
0.0204317123,
0.0172059275,
0.0164449103,
-0.0122993244,
-0.0277856532,
0.0595502593,
0.0454547741,
-0.0469440073,
-0.0331685729,
-0.0360368751,
0.0221922938,
-0.0035288241,
0.0299330465,
-0.0415254347,
0.0135803064,
0.0105527481,
0.0371816121,
-0.0064285602,
-0.0411147848,
0.0427550189,
0.0372731686,
0.0659393668,
-0.0361211486,
0.0051430431,
-0.0120964255,
-0.0125749251,
0.0160417426,
0.0040296316,
-0.001633177,
0.0068641077,
0.0632556975,
0.0142916059,
-0.0023123096,
-0.0030957377,
-0.0266284551,
-0.012881469,
-0.0344725363,
-0.0004950414,
0.0244625565,
0.0275583509,
0.063120611,
-0.0012867724,
0.0230640061,
-0.0085056853,
-0.0383514911,
0.0083871307,
-0.0668910667,
0.0198145788,
0.026196098,
0.0440470427,
-0.0239141285,
0.0453494936,
-0.0286424961,
-0.029183872,
0.008585182,
-0.0025394952,
0.0488128252,
0.0198675506,
0.0267668683,
0.0057834233,
-0.0312011279,
-0.0264248401,
-0.001913322,
-0.0141544743,
0.0093440656,
0.0806263983,
0.0159119312,
-0.0256336071,
-0.0211026594,
0.0793891996,
-0.0096733216,
0.0990202054,
-0.0042195586,
-0.0538716465,
-0.0053641642,
0.0175318755,
0.0249355156,
-0.0202387422,
-0.065447405,
0.0024573961,
-0.0451591015,
-0.0723938718,
0.0629311278,
-0.0097725699,
-0.0292000677,
0.0386652909,
0.0597893596,
0.0348384939,
0.0506175868,
-0.0119194333,
0.0054531316,
-0.0014466799,
-0.0244324245,
-0.0708585009,
-0.0057931524,
-5.783577306e-33,
-0.0292542838,
-0.0076327026,
0.0135032544,
-0.0122430995,
-0.007821504,
0.0158440061,
-0.0308753736,
-0.0320137739,
-0.0208323821,
0.0464330055,
0.0020340409,
-0.0128644444,
-0.0091489656,
-0.0064433962,
0.0028348286,
-0.031983301,
0.0205229297,
0.0223847441,
0.0112747811,
0.0047714361,
0.0291946847,
0.0562231243,
0.0386585109,
-0.0280468538,
0.0312605463,
0.0478742756,
0.0284993686,
0.0209553614,
0.0224597789,
0.0653976873,
-0.0375985466,
0.0491474718,
0.0233153049,
-0.0312420372,
-0.0159051437,
-0.0049117594,
-0.0879803598,
-0.0153482286,
0.0264127012,
-0.0421240851,
-0.0054681003,
-0.0388189368,
0.0451031327,
-0.0138047561,
0.0052364562,
-0.0198404882,
0.0236834548,
-0.0294887833,
-0.0657968521,
-0.0436412878,
-0.0610055551,
0.0455959924,
0.0051613115,
0.017026104,
0.0260132942,
-0.0177284312,
-0.0145799024,
0.053000886,
-0.0346908383,
-0.0010701531,
0.023593314,
0.0245189983,
0.0269806553,
-0.0037905232,
0.0340759382,
0.0750827938,
0.0011668083,
-0.057171952,
-0.0364574417,
0.0540466122,
-0.0201724991,
0.018298028,
0.024495542,
0.0330105685,
0.0285263248,
-0.0000865639,
-0.1090109125,
0.0322565213,
-0.0270501226,
0.0254209675,
-0.0241278857,
-0.0114191473,
0.0112807686,
-0.009721363,
-0.0729087889,
0.0041342252,
-0.0405808464,
-0.0363994613,
0.0138895428,
-0.03098239,
0.0277311895,
0.0228382964,
-0.0040286435,
-0.0206933506,
0.0006070883,
0.0142655307,
0.0384521112,
-0.0210324489,
0.0073231324,
0.0310236383,
-0.0792198256,
-0.0066526881,
0.0476324707,
-0.0289420877,
0.0440058447,
-0.0012927923,
0.0177220646,
-0.0297449864,
-0.0569944419,
-0.0052016233,
-0.0159700159,
-0.0219917987,
-0.0153769748,
-0.0173545573,
0.026361553,
0.0508318208,
0.0051648649,
0.0372235514,
0.035630051,
-0.0123982858,
-0.0055697351,
0.0122370543,
-0.0113687823,
0.0182244964,
-0.0319433473,
-0.0128562953,
-0.0260099247,
0.0174130369,
0.0248349011,
-0.053543102,
-0.0167892557,
0.0043671364,
2.762e-7,
0.0839518681,
0.0282560345,
-0.0241816528,
0.004423426,
0.0052531217,
-0.0212559011,
-0.0072690248,
0.010081498,
-0.0198619012,
-0.019121673,
0.0146529945,
0.0110053374,
0.0041175517,
0.0085304938,
-0.067892164,
-0.0159990992,
-0.0533217378,
-0.0235104617,
-0.0346975625,
-0.0217324011,
0.0268306714,
0.090891771,
-0.010806106,
-0.0136585217,
0.0180441383,
0.0012290787,
0.0288109146,
-0.0521714464,
-0.0105821146,
0.0513815843,
0.0010484067,
-0.0252481345,
0.0132729337,
0.0785716176,
-0.0065804231,
0.0013544996,
-0.006523584,
0.0452888347,
-0.0313836373,
0.0050429502,
0.016012419,
-0.0147798834,
0.0212135706,
-0.038533546,
0.0539414957,
-0.0680844784,
-0.0471008793,
0.0179971755,
-0.0277700853,
0.0212282557,
0.058466807,
-0.0045487951,
-0.0180108473,
0.0265703779,
0.0290504675,
0.0389008708,
-0.0285092406,
-0.0837412402,
-0.0085784635,
0.0601451769,
-0.0242727455,
-0.0265226439,
0.0130052539,
-0.0451387428,
0.0153997708,
-0.0877346545,
0.0206799358,
2.482633508e-34,
0.0212713629,
-0.0156605076,
-0.0270887464,
0.0138066877,
0.052100189,
-0.0481882617,
0.0038948285,
0.0208701473,
-0.0092313765,
-0.0943944752,
0.0115724113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07495v1
|
MacBehaviour: An R package for behavioural experimentation on large language models
| 2024-05-13T06:31:48 | 2024-05-13T06:31:48 |
Xufeng Duan, Shixuan Li, Zhenguang G. Cai1
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
There has been increasing interest in investigating the behaviours of large
language models (LLMs) and LLM-powered chatbots by treating an LLM as a
participant in a psychological experiment. We therefore developed an R package
called "MacBehaviour" that aims to interact with more than 60 language models
in one package (e.g., OpenAI's GPT family, the Claude family, Gemini, Llama
family, and open-source models) and streamline the experimental process of LLMs
behaviour experiments. The package offers a comprehensive set of functions
designed for LLM experiments, covering experiment design, stimuli presentation,
model behaviour manipulation, logging response and token probability. To
demonstrate the utility and effectiveness of "MacBehaviour," we conducted three
validation experiments on three LLMs (GPT-3.5, Llama-2 7B, and Vicuna-1.5 13B)
to replicate sound-gender association in LLMs. The results consistently showed
that they exhibit human-like tendencies to infer gender from novel personal
names based on their phonology, as previously demonstrated (Cai et al., 2023).
In summary, "MacBehaviour" is an R package for machine behaviour studies which
offers a user-friendly interface and comprehensive features to simplify and
standardize the experimental process.
|
[
0.01920145,
0.058312919,
-0.0525396951,
0.0106482161,
-0.0628442839,
0.0195200536,
0.0265357029,
-0.0007800542,
-0.0018128175,
0.0057006842,
-0.036189273,
-0.0062627625,
0.0344440788,
0.0577941649,
0.0369395651,
-0.0215700343,
0.0496858284,
-0.034766186,
0.007348815,
-0.0088351397,
0.0013076072,
0.0223239083,
-0.0150394617,
0.0700218976,
0.0199666116,
-0.0199417844,
-0.0216553304,
-0.0016733381,
0.0084251743,
-0.0102516012,
-0.0179359,
0.055691909,
0.0086348876,
0.0715067536,
0.0000022291,
-0.0848999098,
0.006231098,
0.023505656,
-0.0270093828,
-0.0050026942,
0.0460098311,
0.0495396741,
-0.0221092235,
0.0208281465,
-0.0050480096,
-0.0171202812,
0.0700851604,
0.0032131237,
0.0000279366,
0.0449052043,
-0.0072551728,
-0.0069578066,
0.0063316221,
-0.0094611244,
0.0308200158,
0.0184214041,
0.0539922193,
-0.0284982696,
0.0283020977,
-0.022627471,
0.0081269024,
-0.0035811306,
-0.0057349284,
-0.0062884931,
-0.0227197036,
0.0466353111,
-0.0345285013,
-0.0673174411,
0.0157647785,
0.0413409844,
0.030358864,
-0.0191423595,
0.0319580287,
0.0339320861,
0.0037654685,
0.015000781,
-0.0192367844,
0.0044811619,
-0.0125841098,
-0.0127751399,
-0.0030179312,
-0.0223766752,
0.0158909708,
0.0140567003,
-0.0116581256,
0.0730194896,
0.0115485545,
-0.0251143929,
0.0181547981,
-0.0197040699,
0.0147857266,
-0.0877447501,
0.0129722524,
0.0096869525,
-0.0238295756,
0.0074347812,
-0.0040852786,
-0.0053037475,
0.0487462692,
-0.0613458045,
0.0162763894,
0.0509540774,
-0.0131541453,
-0.0016830899,
-0.0572083369,
0.0530016683,
-0.017652832,
0.015085225,
0.0087427208,
-0.0183433201,
-0.0388116501,
-0.0356148668,
-0.0029425016,
0.0002358035,
-0.0054875007,
-0.0082810158,
-0.0571149178,
0.0272770375,
-0.0152105847,
-0.018242918,
-0.0025228215,
-0.0258787405,
-0.0273490231,
0.0142161297,
-0.0394857563,
0.0061306208,
-0.0444781817,
0.0385323614,
-0.0198200773,
-0.0773738995,
-0.0049977866,
-0.0023400639,
-0.0036706754,
-0.0199987758,
0.0257940162,
0.0817176998,
0.0099101234,
-0.0183524881,
-0.0096592437,
-0.0042996225,
0.0021192355,
-0.051361721,
-0.0100614419,
-0.0619332269,
0.0025640894,
0.0266580954,
-0.0106153432,
-0.0062278314,
-0.0016405255,
0.0151699437,
-0.0113231493,
0.072775349,
0.018407952,
0.0301107839,
0.0464700386,
0.0028541298,
-0.017406797,
0.0796056911,
0.0431340151,
0.0000493777,
0.0017472473,
-0.0431763269,
0.0254244767,
0.0520665869,
-0.0100477794,
-0.0246515293,
-0.0226910636,
-0.0105163381,
0.0030031276,
0.0378402583,
0.0659304857,
0.031108791,
0.0030779892,
-0.0475903712,
0.0411813185,
0.0809363127,
0.0013921822,
0.0366223417,
0.0329312235,
-0.0088446317,
0.0114250677,
0.0205371883,
-0.0327003971,
0.0197670292,
-0.0609404072,
0.0182115491,
0.0011078309,
0.0352637954,
-0.0039985683,
-0.0178580601,
-0.0171291847,
-0.024951281,
0.0270463433,
0.0047118734,
0.0441439748,
0.014933073,
-0.0018202988,
-0.0044236109,
0.0564533174,
-0.0505744442,
-0.0437468626,
-0.0898824558,
0.0605745725,
0.0415438898,
0.0303254891,
-0.0255267918,
0.0167749561,
-0.0083617801,
-0.0356982164,
0.0581893027,
0.0269218683,
0.0017553233,
0.0003261881,
-0.0250489302,
0.0307032727,
0.0625668913,
0.0055025606,
0.0774562657,
0.0246517453,
0.0406723991,
-0.0335745886,
0.0091135241,
-0.0007608171,
0.0234879311,
-0.0559218265,
-0.0343679823,
-0.006793519,
-0.0240439102,
0.0514412411,
-0.0206152759,
-0.0352781601,
0.0045778169,
0.0172161646,
0.0113373287,
0.0229547117,
0.0566316247,
0.0003192804,
0.0139491037,
0.0299498849,
0.0028561945,
-0.0422108434,
0.0512857921,
0.0172460005,
-0.0088778511,
0.0214077495,
-0.0399548933,
0.0561178289,
-0.0385135077,
0.0239070486,
-0.0409157164,
0.035064619,
-0.0070878696,
0.0211323779,
0.0155169433,
0.0069611636,
0.0265530255,
0.0092982715,
-0.0259944797,
-0.0861168951,
-0.0553165078,
0.0338131823,
-0.0062701171,
-0.0038605127,
0.0036449137,
-0.0123561937,
-0.0505109206,
-0.0406395458,
-0.1027629599,
-0.0067756856,
0.0246341247,
0.0055579678,
-0.0253798738,
-0.0108523304,
-0.0615003146,
-0.0114393197,
-0.0084735136,
-0.0072581302,
0.0067166095,
0.0603669882,
0.0168390237,
-0.0347189903,
-0.071707055,
-0.060677167,
0.0054029361,
-0.0277227852,
0.0315928906,
0.0288917311,
0.0063457508,
-0.0404512659,
0.0173444953,
-0.0623747073,
0.0010174438,
-0.0200967193,
-0.0376316011,
0.0521307029,
0.0037215261,
0.110666357,
0.06960053,
-0.0000252145,
0.0468042158,
0.0485586822,
-0.0027451401,
-0.055293534,
-0.0109480219,
0.0166724864,
-0.0137114311,
-0.0236489121,
-0.1144036204,
-0.0288324524,
0.0732967705,
-0.0200222749,
0.0138944434,
-0.0204260796,
0.0373558104,
0.0075855199,
-0.0630756542,
0.0014381397,
-0.0243743788,
-0.0656455606,
0.0429475456,
0.0076782773,
-0.0782438517,
0.0794523507,
-0.0527627468,
-0.038691476,
-0.0307766683,
-0.0320383199,
-0.0157098137,
0.0935852453,
-0.008107896,
-0.0168873016,
0.0563496947,
-0.0248686578,
-0.024430491,
-0.0123293046,
0.0029404077,
-0.042623587,
0.0029415048,
-0.0293978322,
0.0175551008,
0.0120101422,
0.0039478638,
-0.0492687412,
0.0033806467,
-0.0482671596,
-0.0138897058,
0.0165513121,
-0.0381370559,
-0.0250368845,
0.0345205218,
0.0401325822,
-0.0236621965,
-0.0180175416,
0.0123564415,
-0.0130201103,
-0.006093137,
0.0814459473,
0.0465142913,
0.0016791556,
-0.0003917826,
0.0320313275,
0.0061620455,
-0.0230601113,
0.0157044847,
-0.0392031297,
0.0006922466,
0.007221512,
-0.0023092916,
0.0164429788,
0.0250340831,
0.0393398479,
-0.0396098942,
-0.0050342446,
0.0955901742,
0.0260343291,
-0.0490103327,
-0.0109004946,
-0.0468972847,
0.0885897279,
0.005302574,
0.0420708619,
-0.054965388,
0.0016852925,
0.0460938141,
-0.0142952092,
-0.0315779746,
-0.0163626224,
-0.0045983661,
-0.1256843507,
0.0181343947,
-0.0147024728,
-0.0867978856,
-0.03031753,
-0.0542327426,
0.0327938534,
-0.031954959,
0.034843646,
0.0158024449,
-0.0157070011,
-0.0251128878,
0.0036119884,
-0.053118404,
-0.0417271666,
0.030141551,
-0.0592945106,
0.1172763407,
0.062926054,
0.0266051758,
-0.0466748998,
-0.0414757617,
0.0111877471,
0.0318573862,
0.0171785746,
-0.0145965582,
0.0277261976,
0.0416728817,
-0.0032633692,
-0.0718339384,
0.0080620116,
0.040919479,
0.0015059172,
0.0099435095,
0.0375037752,
-0.0048324428,
-0.0468518324,
-0.0254811384,
0.0184329432,
-0.0227078795,
0.0712496713,
0.0477251671,
-0.0555557646,
-0.0301811062,
-0.0426650457,
-0.0257786773,
0.0307290591,
-0.0719712675,
-0.034641739,
0.0185545683,
-0.0476669669,
-0.0593473464,
-0.0419941545,
0.0486632325,
-0.0255833585,
0.0038000031,
-0.0173084252,
-0.0025144983,
0.0471462607,
-0.031481225,
0.0570554473,
-0.0047614519,
0.0322022364,
-0.0464759544,
-0.0131325023,
0.0517820306,
-0.0447981432,
-0.013571321,
0.0340609699,
-0.0643186569,
-0.092711255,
0.0345741212,
0.035055507,
0.0317723639,
0.0463248938,
0.0042454284,
-0.0488204658,
0.0076494543,
0.0347557552,
-0.0108429277,
0.042499166,
0.0329382382,
0.0298045166,
-0.002575462,
0.0140804676,
-0.0059000216,
0.0420891382,
-0.0307092369,
-0.0000048089,
-0.0268460531,
-0.0416170359,
0.0195446797,
0.0322008058,
0.0100190593,
-0.0087921657,
-0.0146007389,
-0.0272712074,
-0.0017576205,
-0.0438033231,
0.0439488851,
-0.0027489476,
-0.0541462228,
-0.0062384475,
0.0334116817,
0.0045317588,
-0.0713953748,
-0.0537830368,
0.008127057,
0.0141065642,
0.0224568285,
-0.006864544,
0.0730550215,
0.0239125565,
0.0259557273,
-0.007587804,
0.0139397141,
-0.0211728998,
0.0483120196,
0.0191256963,
0.0263922755,
-0.0197598562,
-0.0148211336,
0.0208780766,
0.0210976806,
-0.0247258339,
-0.0264847074,
0.0151144052,
0.0426717252,
0.016488146,
0.01131758,
0.0582630374,
-0.0314644165,
0.0144441016,
-0.0283604134,
0.0078833448,
-0.0400430448,
0.0203086212,
0.0058125253,
0.0211265795,
-0.0374552235,
-0.0450888202,
0.042711623,
0.0111386441,
0.0172437001,
-0.0180302933,
0.0079765432,
-0.0188843012,
-0.015927501,
0.0313275829,
-0.0180959143,
-0.0453945659,
-0.0447009988,
-0.0431217961,
-0.0764887705,
0.0196415558,
-0.0106538059,
0.0217568576,
-0.0275295693,
0.0280802436,
0.0259343404,
-0.0004295544,
-0.0315165445,
-0.0091749243,
0.0087081091,
-0.0083386581,
-0.0453092903,
-0.0049264403,
-6.460402341e-33,
-0.0498428121,
-0.0486160964,
0.007525675,
0.0225180853,
-0.0135766678,
-0.0184057485,
-0.063535206,
0.0283774678,
-0.0098510655,
-0.0016243164,
-0.0069542956,
-0.0111577893,
0.0268526673,
-0.0412465744,
0.02230848,
-0.0021618265,
0.045880951,
-0.0021294707,
0.0200025775,
-0.03609078,
0.010839764,
0.0210490059,
0.0176926609,
-0.0752363428,
0.0407304652,
-0.0148424702,
-0.0365393199,
-0.0182576329,
-0.0761939064,
0.0656510815,
-0.0333122425,
0.0180203505,
0.0011743375,
0.013325992,
-0.0165563449,
0.0707968995,
-0.0528659821,
-0.0368786044,
0.0226156674,
0.0309231002,
-0.0040199906,
-0.0054652737,
0.0418292768,
-0.0184385218,
-0.0507922769,
0.0125983525,
0.0357486233,
-0.0281656161,
0.0239327196,
0.0381736904,
-0.0450553745,
0.0076681469,
0.0174472239,
-0.0339540876,
0.0451108664,
0.028196821,
-0.0183990281,
0.0014388678,
-0.0436144993,
0.0536117963,
-0.0000360642,
-0.0157496668,
0.0582399257,
0.0306188148,
0.0605377331,
0.0307104252,
0.0904583484,
-0.0195487235,
-0.0373637676,
-0.0130909178,
0.0472673811,
0.0097192563,
0.0626203045,
0.0244759433,
0.0153593905,
-0.0121714734,
-0.0149200773,
0.0187448859,
0.0894862339,
-0.0240424052,
0.0277091116,
0.0299017243,
-0.067160517,
-0.0144714732,
-0.0041818982,
-0.0157001931,
-0.0421373993,
-0.047762692,
0.0218950324,
-0.0240990743,
0.0230915733,
-0.0402167588,
0.0383046716,
-0.033612337,
-0.0340063386,
-0.0347514823,
-0.0185169782,
0.0098390672,
0.0168719739,
0.0009424978,
-0.0331246033,
0.0070539759,
0.0427311733,
-0.0049471674,
0.0593442731,
0.0043084458,
-0.0298853386,
0.0085757254,
-0.092293404,
0.0103967404,
-0.0051461677,
0.0011335922,
0.0378668867,
0.00612097,
0.0212463401,
-0.0090923775,
-0.0113820303,
-0.0245227944,
0.03893774,
0.0365909971,
-0.108297646,
-0.0003083316,
-0.0648947507,
0.0304214936,
-0.0160087422,
0.0036921778,
-0.0536626056,
0.0392718203,
0.0409399197,
-0.0283251666,
-0.0113326898,
-0.0267804638,
2.987e-7,
-0.0251512937,
0.0578099526,
0.0231220834,
0.0669398904,
0.0230085421,
0.0107506774,
-0.0350950733,
0.0220780205,
0.0751467645,
-0.0091048609,
-0.0184558798,
0.009201644,
0.0717264488,
0.051829692,
-0.08106976,
-0.0033274014,
-0.0984559357,
0.003549468,
-0.0479371734,
0.0174763408,
-0.0150162922,
0.0816642195,
0.0190518517,
-0.0009542485,
-0.0131544219,
-0.0148466537,
0.0228513572,
-0.0489491336,
0.0019044693,
0.0026333616,
-0.0068881167,
-0.0266158134,
-0.0027409825,
0.0126404176,
0.0205976404,
-0.017265413,
-0.0119851027,
0.0192654971,
-0.0138381254,
-0.0230897926,
0.0244673956,
0.0367362984,
-0.0179559942,
-0.0558946356,
0.0368178189,
-0.0073999804,
-0.026786631,
-0.0256899502,
0.0392786525,
-0.0333692171,
0.0639088303,
-0.0238787532,
0.0064352443,
0.0249860622,
0.0003603912,
0.0008693206,
-0.0123346476,
-0.0254847109,
-0.0128450999,
-0.0190450381,
-0.0923919529,
-0.0641276687,
-0.0238154121,
-0.0140036251,
-0.0014777631,
-0.0401206277,
-0.0006046917,
2.71559858e-34,
0.0064492184,
0.0184846651,
0.0014582097,
0.060528893,
0.0368415974,
0.003309506,
0.0232076142,
0.0491730534,
0.0432898998,
-0.0553417653,
-0.0294350721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07490v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07490v1
|
Strategic Data Ordering: Enhancing Large Language Model Performance through Curriculum Learning
| 2024-05-13T06:09:10 | 2024-05-13T06:09:10 |
Jisu Kim, Juhwan Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has improved text
understanding and generation but poses challenges in computational resources.
This study proposes a curriculum learning-inspired, data-centric training
strategy that begins with simpler tasks and progresses to more complex ones,
using criteria such as prompt length, attention scores, and loss values to
structure the training data. Experiments with Mistral-7B (Jiang et al., 2023)
and Gemma-7B (Team et al., 2024) models demonstrate that curriculum learning
slightly improves performance compared to traditional random data shuffling.
Notably, we observed that sorting data based on our proposed attention criteria
generally led to better performance. This approach offers a sustainable method
to enhance LLM performance without increasing model size or dataset volume,
addressing scalability challenges in LLM training.
|
[
0.0465987772,
0.0375061817,
-0.004230055,
0.0537980609,
-0.0268772896,
0.0199325886,
0.0316986367,
-0.035750702,
-0.0188721605,
-0.0546532683,
-0.0266670156,
-0.0803907886,
0.0132854264,
0.0079052038,
0.0490713343,
-0.0533489473,
0.0362177826,
-0.0864811316,
-0.0036592917,
0.0060916063,
-0.0188966673,
-0.0141822565,
-0.0036778413,
0.0147990445,
0.0254039057,
-0.0157886334,
-0.0113006067,
0.0372246727,
0.021472754,
-0.0404039882,
-0.0026372874,
0.0737008378,
0.0365347676,
0.0658811033,
0.0000022304,
-0.05550275,
-0.0139036579,
0.0064952015,
-0.0267411862,
0.0366055407,
0.0725135058,
0.0192390289,
-0.0053012841,
0.0433120653,
-0.0096699772,
0.035496138,
0.0379263759,
0.0046011573,
0.0758529007,
0.0606056973,
0.0081944549,
-0.0412927791,
0.0143094491,
-0.0519082919,
0.0233483966,
-0.0004166043,
0.0300053842,
0.0407643504,
0.0102601405,
0.0398233905,
-0.0217727926,
0.0359170288,
0.031210551,
0.0024957769,
0.0192908347,
0.0452343076,
-0.0395630822,
-0.0196373984,
-0.026637204,
0.0693319291,
-0.0040466245,
-0.0057855267,
-0.0076491134,
-0.022992786,
0.0017225625,
-0.0327712595,
-0.0584950782,
0.0595849641,
0.0132306423,
0.0089011379,
0.0576486476,
-0.0010129301,
0.0143668447,
-0.0144776767,
-0.0547450595,
0.0142188855,
0.016656775,
-0.0555595271,
-0.0006583049,
-0.0091307145,
-0.0251031369,
-0.0373472497,
-0.0074197105,
0.0489051715,
-0.0033789519,
0.0271962155,
-0.0553087778,
-0.0313530788,
0.0222930852,
-0.0301498752,
0.0750528872,
0.0321893319,
-0.02294234,
0.0288204961,
0.0114043718,
0.0784773976,
0.0150965909,
0.0458192788,
-0.0646880195,
0.0337336995,
-0.0150681837,
-0.020301016,
-0.0284213275,
-0.0013108663,
-0.0606314689,
-0.0074359793,
-0.0455601998,
0.0319154076,
0.0231092982,
-0.0205130316,
0.0791607797,
-0.0007117423,
-0.0396847725,
0.0142822554,
-0.0055297604,
0.014119125,
0.0032349848,
0.0076407474,
0.0236847084,
-0.0438026786,
-0.016665712,
0.0155017348,
-0.0097071901,
-0.0256201997,
0.0058550178,
0.0379280485,
-0.0192951113,
-0.0395454429,
-0.0574382208,
0.0084241359,
-0.0311221164,
-0.0725364313,
0.0220681075,
-0.0721774027,
0.0134715633,
0.0164467506,
-0.0055389949,
0.0025972051,
0.0051394268,
0.012154364,
-0.042010881,
0.0035127152,
0.0227403957,
0.0315394588,
0.0308098868,
-0.0073074531,
0.0257770605,
0.0742445812,
0.0344944671,
0.0190161951,
-0.0093267579,
-0.0076665645,
-0.0178882219,
0.0370718874,
0.009314104,
0.0109147429,
-0.0271892827,
0.0129940286,
0.0208348446,
0.0419903919,
0.0494231731,
0.051773373,
-0.0389209352,
0.0189873651,
0.0859445855,
0.0218875837,
0.0020195041,
-0.0227776039,
0.0373889878,
0.0121853864,
0.0106390947,
0.0085703172,
-0.0474034697,
0.0137721505,
0.0402920581,
0.0178686325,
0.0334278382,
0.0340745114,
-0.0113919768,
-0.0469842702,
-0.0167983528,
0.0042705322,
-0.0064924201,
0.0246318318,
0.0239685252,
-0.0110233817,
-0.0456870943,
0.0032162706,
0.0515784808,
-0.0424808189,
-0.0137658296,
-0.0347434208,
0.0018773677,
0.095591642,
0.0078112255,
-0.0306257885,
-0.0818917826,
0.0158238038,
0.0668484569,
0.0292848982,
0.0272830594,
-0.0036495517,
-0.0045142733,
-0.0599932596,
-0.009108034,
-0.0191173181,
-0.0026932717,
0.0291573051,
0.0142357145,
0.005115136,
0.0134835169,
0.0064803069,
-0.0910037011,
0.0428810716,
-0.0671710148,
-0.054664325,
-0.0082666548,
0.0083919531,
0.0237546992,
-0.0101155089,
0.0025236795,
0.016684141,
0.0385902599,
-0.0419692881,
0.0622681901,
-0.0078130262,
-0.080359064,
-0.0609944202,
0.0335172489,
0.0308635011,
-0.0102793835,
0.0269939974,
-0.0412788279,
-0.0355701521,
0.0093050031,
-0.0220713057,
0.0119506018,
-0.0374950096,
0.0425917208,
0.0013563607,
0.005802006,
-0.0716993511,
0.0553236268,
-0.0274637919,
0.0078498935,
0.0542263649,
0.0328573994,
-0.0177893974,
-0.0586550385,
0.0033343327,
0.0202851277,
-0.0007100343,
0.011817893,
-0.023237247,
0.0285066087,
-0.055066064,
-0.0354528464,
-0.0828483179,
0.0010359873,
-0.0289635826,
0.0064791343,
0.0170007031,
-0.0007751178,
-0.0085567329,
0.0095446361,
-0.0408039093,
-0.0164586958,
0.0292419922,
0.0183687396,
0.014021568,
-0.0092888474,
-0.0412351154,
-0.0302793775,
-0.0298771486,
-0.0005195158,
0.0593067296,
-0.0052836514,
0.0217001271,
-0.0786436349,
0.0301964991,
-0.0160593465,
-0.0045606107,
-0.0163504165,
-0.0143145416,
-0.0036601855,
-0.0112724742,
0.073572658,
0.0783859938,
0.0051763197,
0.0319367163,
0.062774986,
-0.0143829267,
-0.0339576267,
-0.0015004195,
-0.0060805888,
-0.0280771665,
-0.0293466598,
-0.0579807274,
-0.0175431035,
0.0519018508,
0.0073677786,
-0.004498288,
-0.0439516082,
0.0000216561,
-0.0437292829,
-0.0444837213,
-0.0542833209,
-0.017420195,
-0.0505447313,
-0.0008300356,
-0.0401406586,
-0.0287938248,
0.0440958515,
-0.038783744,
0.0053307367,
-0.0887473449,
-0.0008978214,
-0.0432430059,
0.0276438128,
0.0241527036,
0.0299769789,
-0.0262068566,
-0.0135665247,
-0.0883025005,
0.0019285935,
0.0123685859,
-0.0243154448,
0.0348493531,
-0.0413564593,
-0.0087287771,
-0.0194804035,
-0.0298497267,
-0.0664455146,
-0.0182629619,
0.0152389472,
0.0270814095,
0.065643616,
0.0134667084,
-0.0268424377,
0.0154752927,
0.0404175334,
0.0402619429,
-0.042866528,
0.00025516,
-0.0163286831,
0.0505354665,
0.0321987048,
0.016254738,
0.0208724122,
-0.0621417537,
0.0072604804,
0.0256257281,
0.0543438531,
-0.0259859916,
-0.020983072,
0.0151321525,
0.0355257802,
-0.0232052263,
0.0012104969,
0.0370091312,
0.0401870124,
-0.0620597452,
-0.0344756953,
0.1239540204,
0.0170005392,
-0.0413441136,
-0.0013506985,
-0.0096015809,
0.0530638173,
0.026472941,
0.0318759754,
-0.0353871733,
-0.0122690788,
0.0105521102,
0.0560663007,
0.0023218431,
-0.0051200129,
-0.0421475619,
-0.1057098806,
0.0339459144,
0.0290272329,
-0.0496803559,
-0.0100799268,
-0.0665562823,
-0.0278249029,
0.0028551132,
0.0430266075,
0.0470310971,
-0.044041764,
0.0122442599,
0.0618130565,
0.0091775311,
-0.062565878,
-0.0159611888,
-0.0265684724,
0.0508532003,
0.0515791513,
0.0051934742,
-0.0049675093,
0.0016595356,
0.0267806258,
0.0251908954,
0.0074125328,
0.0091388617,
0.0335175693,
-0.0084511247,
0.0154640973,
-0.0107152276,
0.0290684793,
-0.0287660453,
-0.0132815437,
0.0213667322,
0.0800800249,
0.0080018034,
-0.0131673086,
-0.0081037208,
0.0044546458,
0.0236763805,
0.0773348287,
0.0588269569,
-0.0424979106,
0.0008621676,
-0.0126355737,
-0.0026792085,
-0.0185598116,
-0.0108632259,
0.0443284959,
-0.0000681866,
-0.0441255756,
-0.0721255466,
-0.0507478304,
0.0205649287,
0.0609763488,
0.0302579459,
0.0361575857,
0.008162328,
-0.0087984297,
-0.0570184849,
0.0269237105,
-0.0290679745,
-0.0060567297,
-0.1123776585,
-0.0366386659,
-0.0098048132,
-0.0399404801,
-0.0255693235,
0.0256694593,
-0.1400954127,
-0.0821484178,
0.0251999404,
0.051841829,
0.0220916625,
0.057203345,
0.0457411371,
-0.0522075593,
0.0389332213,
0.0121686915,
-0.0235162769,
0.0294485632,
-0.0037167629,
-0.0252224281,
-0.0023527164,
0.0027743168,
-0.0275644828,
0.0311575346,
0.0249305833,
0.0459595844,
0.0111759473,
0.0274849758,
0.011142863,
0.0408659987,
0.0263808202,
-0.0237464346,
-0.0392389968,
-0.0646298006,
0.060186293,
-0.0208022594,
-0.0020354895,
-0.0210285131,
0.0123762507,
0.0162918121,
0.0168637224,
-0.0140239792,
-0.0295711402,
0.0347402282,
-0.0135503067,
-0.0514766686,
0.0216015875,
-0.0428494476,
0.0263260528,
0.0519130155,
0.0093052052,
-0.0371280052,
0.0226321053,
-0.0183268525,
0.0319332071,
-0.0096902661,
0.0475006104,
0.0001568031,
-0.0091137271,
-0.0227606539,
0.0575491227,
-0.0651045814,
-0.051944159,
-0.0290881302,
-0.0073832502,
0.0426721908,
-0.0117004495,
0.0630410463,
-0.0238094777,
0.004675861,
-0.013800134,
0.0031917077,
-0.0010685842,
-0.0256287642,
0.0028883342,
0.0157362092,
-0.0060853274,
-0.0053230138,
0.0875475407,
0.048841998,
-0.0042355657,
0.0018457754,
0.0101036942,
-0.0290390085,
-0.0246930309,
0.0134357139,
0.0040871077,
-0.0335304327,
0.0075816372,
-0.0238915458,
-0.0469638743,
0.0016855394,
0.0013301482,
-0.005784113,
-0.0355421156,
0.0415034816,
0.0512117781,
-0.0306218546,
0.0005025431,
-0.025914548,
0.0027344842,
-0.010294266,
-0.0630258694,
-0.0155293532,
-6.97671399e-33,
-0.0213135369,
0.0150067694,
0.0560848303,
-0.0149363512,
-0.0238977149,
0.0185503606,
-0.0393012315,
-0.0062160385,
0.0151816225,
-0.0220357981,
-0.0240409542,
0.010752474,
0.0199158248,
0.036854241,
0.0043071448,
-0.0008451862,
0.0439634211,
-0.0113465274,
-0.0286982246,
0.0491251126,
0.0242518913,
0.038651377,
0.0584403425,
-0.0163269192,
0.0101613747,
0.0070102564,
0.0430149436,
0.0005943894,
-0.0173477754,
0.0429413952,
-0.0229683723,
0.0344797857,
0.0283119865,
-0.0630735606,
-0.0295113586,
0.0154226562,
-0.0462266877,
-0.019702889,
0.0164287798,
0.0150547531,
-0.0131112281,
-0.0541158728,
0.0270094909,
-0.0052470528,
-0.0194351468,
-0.0145191243,
0.0093759652,
-0.0240436997,
-0.0625085384,
0.0019974872,
-0.0680339932,
0.013561069,
-0.0027749119,
-0.0060409806,
0.0186469909,
0.049402304,
-0.020399332,
0.0258808509,
-0.0437583551,
0.0493836254,
0.0526562929,
0.0619413853,
0.0557850003,
0.0827297717,
0.000075466,
0.0576765798,
0.0308585819,
0.0199998971,
0.0023671873,
-0.0118030356,
0.032918524,
0.0396635383,
0.0082782097,
0.0219769683,
0.0110366428,
-0.0081563825,
-0.097085692,
0.0161445774,
0.0119870519,
-0.0055982084,
0.0639637038,
-0.0318363719,
-0.0353279561,
-0.0485011712,
-0.0203797817,
0.0055011655,
-0.0305655692,
0.0137579795,
0.0552298538,
0.0069077178,
-0.0370103978,
-0.0220975634,
0.0630361289,
-0.0320933349,
-0.0334798098,
0.0571791194,
-0.0033891166,
0.0234175362,
-0.0177281387,
0.0552928559,
-0.1120172516,
-0.0257232711,
0.0361037739,
-0.0098045161,
-0.0010322328,
0.0075782556,
0.0345772505,
0.0044110501,
-0.0367608443,
-0.0136851557,
-0.0418143459,
0.0444347486,
0.0069111614,
0.0197900329,
0.0307716653,
-0.0126294047,
0.0074775522,
0.0560079291,
0.0385340862,
-0.0561724603,
-0.0309684202,
-0.0131157245,
-0.0053755403,
0.0162666813,
-0.0192394741,
0.017577555,
-0.0225907173,
0.0155661236,
0.0313103497,
-0.0518828444,
-0.0194244143,
0.0051169591,
2.864e-7,
0.0335201211,
0.073749885,
-0.0247410331,
0.0122475093,
0.0130031304,
-0.0142032467,
-0.0290477891,
0.0094249956,
0.042002596,
0.023664657,
0.0203081686,
0.0484465137,
0.0360339843,
-0.0021311692,
-0.0694364309,
-0.0341163538,
-0.0708360896,
0.0111383349,
-0.0543544553,
-0.0254818797,
0.016492866,
0.1048018932,
-0.025922399,
-0.0297393911,
-0.0050059212,
0.0066353707,
0.0447771773,
-0.0301588755,
0.0124801174,
0.0111204786,
0.0144050186,
-0.0194556564,
-0.0040918561,
0.0015485847,
-0.0070661134,
-0.0016482484,
-0.0362708382,
0.0439411588,
-0.0008543868,
-0.0149010625,
0.0230983738,
0.0261618048,
-0.0252939425,
-0.0914755315,
0.0585915707,
-0.0745304748,
-0.010008391,
0.0144045353,
-0.010602749,
-0.0087686079,
-0.0181587785,
-0.0323453918,
-0.0150111234,
0.0155502167,
0.0077006719,
-0.0395425037,
0.0155448578,
-0.0451944694,
-0.0033088017,
0.0117713371,
-0.0440145321,
-0.0676802397,
-0.0572424345,
-0.0167921484,
-0.0045230151,
-0.0407232083,
-0.0045540887,
3.109311357e-34,
0.0355317481,
-0.0171166193,
0.0381623097,
-0.0058229296,
0.0106493104,
-0.031406194,
0.0300320908,
0.0219701324,
-0.0042335475,
-0.1031727418,
-0.0445841029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07468v1
|
Evaluating large language models in medical applications: a survey
| 2024-05-13T05:08:33 | 2024-05-13T05:08:33 |
Xiaolan Chen, Jiayang Xiang, Shanfu Lu, Yexin Liu, Mingguang He, Danli Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools with
transformative potential across numerous domains, including healthcare and
medicine. In the medical domain, LLMs hold promise for tasks ranging from
clinical decision support to patient education. However, evaluating the
performance of LLMs in medical contexts presents unique challenges due to the
complex and critical nature of medical information. This paper provides a
comprehensive overview of the landscape of medical LLM evaluation, synthesizing
insights from existing studies and highlighting evaluation data sources, task
scenarios, and evaluation methods. Additionally, it identifies key challenges
and opportunities in medical LLM evaluation, emphasizing the need for continued
research and innovation to ensure the responsible integration of LLMs into
clinical practice.
|
[
0.0321960859,
0.0434156209,
-0.0010816446,
-0.0194734558,
-0.0309379231,
0.0399446599,
0.0068472833,
0.0361172967,
0.0136384396,
-0.0038095755,
-0.0104346927,
-0.084837392,
0.0243852548,
0.0178230312,
-0.0008753024,
-0.007554376,
0.0102644488,
-0.0087231193,
0.0244813692,
-0.0006301078,
-0.0200203788,
0.0016062014,
-0.0146103548,
0.0599940829,
0.0254281498,
0.0006279357,
0.043737255,
-0.0186635442,
-0.0084230183,
-0.0846921504,
-0.0511101335,
0.0269682258,
-0.0152561227,
0.0055506118,
0.0000019061,
-0.0742445737,
-0.0191364549,
0.0399532206,
-0.0560297444,
-0.0117627364,
0.075947538,
-0.0378151573,
-0.0273728017,
0.0044114608,
-0.0146953212,
-0.020309018,
0.0384594128,
-0.0079541672,
0.0251711365,
0.032700479,
-0.0115971519,
0.0034113342,
0.0145216407,
-0.0348010622,
-0.0045687933,
-0.0248281565,
0.0506454371,
0.0296170805,
0.0555631369,
-0.0205935333,
0.0140560307,
0.0493773669,
-0.0182605274,
0.0046336325,
-0.0159376357,
0.0209315754,
-0.0041501787,
-0.017705733,
0.0054407115,
0.0281173158,
0.0066844169,
0.0166873317,
0.0168513861,
0.0021209035,
-0.0201072954,
0.0072200294,
-0.046906732,
0.0069802664,
0.0035377289,
-0.0008727778,
0.0152206076,
-0.0115400227,
0.0472824685,
0.0024074323,
-0.0446632318,
0.0299062952,
0.0225714818,
-0.0145522272,
0.0183085296,
-0.0158769079,
-0.0054598008,
-0.0318135023,
0.030387776,
0.0369394124,
-0.0682363436,
0.0207258184,
0.0089974729,
-0.0241231602,
0.1012288406,
-0.0928667709,
0.0568412095,
-0.0183764193,
0.0176049378,
0.0563223585,
-0.0070789061,
0.0122554563,
-0.023590045,
0.0233650524,
-0.0465856194,
0.0047906158,
-0.0365671553,
0.0088052331,
0.0156667847,
0.0098904166,
-0.0038883418,
0.0058412706,
-0.1030359417,
-0.0017449835,
-0.0192380734,
0.045356784,
0.0178303216,
0.010293493,
0.0040670005,
-0.0187760834,
-0.0301388856,
0.0022732997,
0.0279959906,
0.0238599759,
-0.0344961397,
-0.0335634872,
0.0648736283,
0.0180948749,
-0.0221719742,
-0.0007714637,
0.016080007,
0.0913496539,
0.0384229012,
0.0076433038,
-0.0078005041,
-0.0283296276,
-0.0482721142,
-0.0466793254,
-0.0202920027,
-0.0818216726,
0.0076183132,
0.0312160775,
0.0152677614,
-0.0613027439,
0.0066764145,
-0.0036308269,
-0.0412915722,
0.0667284578,
-0.0453908518,
0.0215297863,
0.0226187482,
0.0334462412,
0.0298017524,
0.0486315712,
0.0395420268,
-0.0356472656,
-0.0049830987,
-0.0310050994,
-0.0060280436,
0.0327949226,
-0.0104471296,
-0.0042662434,
-0.042893704,
0.0321405195,
0.0258080289,
0.0760697424,
-0.0640674382,
0.0741060823,
0.0224931072,
-0.0034552028,
0.035562776,
0.069521457,
0.0547042154,
-0.0098241251,
0.01752837,
-0.0338246077,
-0.001506111,
-0.0405498929,
0.0049171555,
-0.0206430182,
0.0005173761,
-0.0161848478,
-0.0118763801,
0.0198910534,
-0.0229172837,
-0.0346102715,
-0.0662478432,
-0.0425408483,
-0.0068625268,
0.0105786277,
0.0578675568,
-0.0505982414,
-0.0079225209,
0.078194961,
0.0374609455,
-0.0280582681,
-0.0017235319,
-0.0586153828,
-0.0258397534,
0.0914301053,
0.0606661588,
-0.0471261553,
-0.0237055961,
-0.0109359017,
0.0001282692,
0.0067199171,
0.0095519787,
-0.0063202605,
-0.0029613764,
-0.0238922238,
-0.0063565699,
0.0683601424,
0.0098350216,
-0.0342950113,
-0.0035530294,
0.0336552821,
-0.0226300433,
-0.0410219394,
-0.0679906234,
0.0296570286,
-0.0748713687,
0.0022444651,
0.0016019699,
-0.0053488659,
0.0303839985,
0.0353898928,
-0.0085951006,
0.0494143926,
0.0405633114,
-0.0454911664,
-0.0055821664,
-0.0093192635,
0.0084122056,
0.0241203085,
0.029879,
-0.013403004,
0.0126617337,
-0.0419198871,
-0.0108052716,
-0.0184649639,
-0.0156641081,
-0.0529460683,
0.0383141749,
0.0116073377,
0.0404300727,
0.0008758215,
0.0002060817,
-0.0662084296,
0.0013767842,
-0.027546417,
0.0400320068,
0.0249433927,
-0.0410460457,
0.0114541957,
-0.0064670783,
-0.0325666741,
0.0385880545,
-0.0066390657,
0.0230198056,
-0.0158832334,
0.0106572527,
-0.0248383675,
-0.0548736453,
-0.0889557153,
-0.0215551052,
0.0247963332,
0.0430283546,
0.0215281416,
0.0087752361,
0.0015988578,
0.0142957484,
-0.0524633601,
-0.0229737572,
0.0319799632,
0.0139752226,
0.0043801395,
0.0344424285,
-0.0345178954,
-0.0246606655,
-0.0160310548,
-0.0283464473,
0.0416781381,
-0.0078936946,
-0.0128450291,
-0.0155723104,
0.0025118894,
-0.0427191146,
-0.0371176489,
0.0158604831,
-0.01040179,
0.0242797546,
-0.0120137986,
0.0148925083,
0.0083460175,
-0.0160891823,
0.0222461075,
0.052538611,
-0.0120949158,
-0.0116689904,
-0.0358264819,
-0.0113884239,
-0.0374038517,
-0.029858062,
-0.0710176528,
-0.0129072312,
0.0528841354,
-0.0027892105,
0.0262421276,
-0.0132997613,
-0.0229454469,
-0.0901085287,
0.0228710957,
-0.0564987175,
0.0274404697,
-0.034167245,
0.0613455027,
0.0161238853,
-0.0401847288,
0.0825224966,
-0.0402038507,
0.0497003645,
-0.0639166161,
-0.0454694852,
-0.0470901765,
0.0036164122,
-0.0410588123,
0.0236379206,
-0.0060933009,
-0.0113253025,
0.0186950862,
-0.0037843783,
-0.0156621337,
-0.0811169222,
0.1096255183,
-0.0278659593,
0.0268864427,
0.0101333391,
-0.0101274522,
-0.0237277634,
0.0049531478,
-0.0311641749,
0.0107076988,
0.0372720584,
0.0277383141,
-0.0422828048,
0.059812326,
0.0116392346,
0.0449696593,
0.0335222892,
-0.0145818898,
0.0204808991,
-0.0226944946,
-0.0105228713,
0.0159537569,
0.0341359265,
-0.0178028792,
0.0517522469,
0.0437718667,
0.00162872,
0.0257442743,
-0.0120905843,
0.0055576954,
0.0282073505,
-0.0415274426,
0.0065502753,
0.03907343,
0.0202839393,
-0.0421586074,
0.0177860986,
0.1098688394,
0.0415185653,
-0.0621592924,
0.0234599076,
-0.0213618204,
-0.0353724733,
-0.015920246,
-0.0031784712,
-0.0676413924,
-0.0061639464,
-0.0202456508,
0.0302297547,
-0.0167051759,
-0.0179450028,
0.0336848795,
-0.0343009047,
0.0385594778,
0.0186578538,
-0.0269742273,
-0.0220707189,
-0.0435718,
0.0210754182,
-0.0150237978,
0.0114969295,
-0.0125090741,
-0.0277192239,
-0.0391392484,
-0.0009088932,
-0.095673956,
-0.1228767559,
0.0448696539,
-0.0233168602,
0.0659375489,
0.0542100146,
0.0121489856,
-0.0330300443,
-0.0074524251,
0.0000581022,
0.0112376995,
-0.0105572082,
-0.0015496581,
0.0436896309,
0.0478222147,
-0.0095273331,
-0.0426651239,
-0.0219292548,
-0.0466817729,
-0.0023822905,
-0.0159038994,
0.0999246538,
-0.0531374142,
-0.0054666926,
-0.0163761675,
0.022472715,
0.0283263251,
0.0571190454,
0.0196290892,
-0.0278822668,
-0.0074284985,
0.0005759981,
0.0247357432,
0.0230876282,
-0.035772495,
0.0457865521,
-0.0244823266,
-0.0065395739,
-0.0277090799,
0.0077226381,
0.0495082624,
-0.0328274593,
0.0162886791,
0.0643786415,
0.0338214785,
-0.0224089958,
-0.0459459275,
0.0317316502,
0.0308339838,
0.0733102486,
-0.0725848079,
-0.0267772768,
0.0402383283,
0.0104744593,
0.0023068499,
0.0188181307,
-0.0214995332,
-0.0074251434,
0.0136987269,
0.0213034321,
0.0208637957,
-0.0414890274,
-0.0240447298,
-0.039443478,
0.027707858,
0.0251897201,
-0.0349623524,
-0.0204042625,
-0.0169003438,
0.0194763821,
-0.0044691227,
0.012170963,
-0.0123185823,
0.0213931911,
0.0069752093,
0.0146305682,
-0.0052328743,
-0.0291618649,
0.008210062,
0.0574866347,
0.0188633371,
-0.0327209271,
-0.0345228575,
0.0038863651,
0.0057961107,
-0.0508564338,
0.0223797057,
-0.0181617104,
-0.0262494236,
0.0355887823,
-0.0105093867,
-0.0034733114,
0.0127103645,
-0.0590518676,
-0.0560556576,
-0.057323087,
0.0963028371,
-0.0079188645,
0.0004543561,
0.0759687647,
-0.0088703427,
0.0051091914,
0.0150408428,
-0.0361722,
0.0043033916,
-0.0069186855,
0.0582192726,
-0.0213900991,
0.0335137583,
0.0002057117,
0.073016502,
-0.0025403455,
-0.0568735898,
-0.0148579041,
0.0287016556,
0.0589550585,
0.0296533909,
0.0576872788,
-0.0340777859,
0.0090188766,
-0.0618356802,
0.0014243486,
-0.0315379091,
0.0258346777,
0.0367837586,
0.0202696659,
-0.00900371,
-0.01513266,
0.0903894901,
0.013213479,
0.0161525719,
-0.0238078497,
-0.0446353778,
-0.0243819188,
-0.0311094895,
0.0071566547,
-0.0153805781,
-0.1030413955,
0.0067499308,
-0.0955101028,
-0.0605412386,
0.0124612795,
-0.0040866309,
-0.0218967479,
-0.0381516479,
0.0321342982,
0.0452615954,
0.0161072835,
0.0027285214,
-0.046970468,
0.0370777845,
-0.0168751609,
-0.0142074218,
0.0394573063,
-5.513035077e-33,
0.0248555932,
-0.0397550389,
0.027017979,
-0.0335836336,
0.0017281751,
0.032506559,
-0.0223572627,
0.02428459,
0.0045329938,
0.0355005898,
-0.0023575178,
-0.0140620172,
0.0016035023,
0.0277109127,
0.0234115832,
-0.0251997821,
-0.0064653042,
0.0124856876,
-0.0053883344,
0.0142672779,
-0.0188838243,
0.01315175,
0.0409838744,
-0.0893589407,
0.0286377948,
0.01028609,
0.0246599726,
-0.0008550448,
-0.0184789915,
0.0957264751,
-0.0301782489,
0.0397184342,
0.0379754938,
-0.0455098785,
-0.0058864602,
-0.0194676295,
-0.0257324744,
0.0127249854,
0.0222913101,
-0.0246534981,
-0.0149806878,
-0.0211230926,
0.0431076847,
-0.0016352159,
-0.0595421679,
0.00799454,
-0.0161593519,
-0.0581321903,
-0.0319822058,
-0.0086995596,
-0.0283524953,
0.0633260235,
0.0138807287,
0.0118533298,
0.0029726375,
-0.0181139018,
-0.055708535,
0.0357148945,
-0.0198810454,
0.0052940571,
0.0546814911,
0.0260886122,
0.039902892,
-0.0131261954,
-0.0323508903,
0.0451887622,
-0.0099427933,
0.0031873453,
-0.0329302475,
0.0007882736,
-0.0306071844,
0.0463433601,
0.0593705066,
0.0216360185,
-0.030224571,
-0.0233013164,
-0.0960141718,
0.0433531441,
-0.0619533509,
0.0483934246,
0.0349745154,
-0.0234222598,
-0.0444982648,
-0.0303156544,
-0.0471092127,
0.027907243,
-0.0216898844,
-0.0341691822,
0.0302972738,
-0.0240764376,
0.0071566841,
0.0458113104,
0.0182384551,
-0.0385048203,
-0.036320515,
-0.0337134488,
0.0409032926,
0.0318777822,
-0.0246780235,
0.0142719802,
-0.0604046881,
0.0017010516,
-0.0031994558,
-0.0127711883,
0.0302757658,
-0.0055834525,
-0.0102396542,
-0.0355568081,
-0.0488144867,
0.0105160242,
0.0280133728,
-0.0239812471,
-0.0062395814,
0.0180914979,
0.0350741893,
0.0097893123,
0.0213670433,
0.0498623326,
-0.0010953025,
-0.0224573817,
-0.0202844348,
-0.0401947163,
-0.0012328825,
0.0114430273,
-0.0415156148,
0.0087546259,
-0.065146178,
0.045175992,
0.0604198948,
-0.0033353311,
-0.0024010462,
-0.0227240566,
2.61e-7,
0.1140351966,
0.0696243793,
-0.0330862217,
-0.0061712633,
0.0314989239,
-0.0113668004,
-0.0289474931,
-0.0125560826,
-0.00379397,
-0.0153065259,
0.0306373369,
-0.0144441649,
0.0660665631,
0.0459937975,
-0.0333161764,
-0.0211061388,
-0.0779748037,
-0.0093405694,
-0.043909464,
-0.0160282869,
0.0431614593,
0.0648416355,
-0.0463466048,
-0.0329572484,
-0.0006672059,
-0.0189104546,
0.0207688306,
-0.0780191943,
-0.0182372574,
0.0471195728,
0.0307576992,
-0.0149330823,
0.0383780114,
0.0499476865,
-0.0179417729,
-0.0201469883,
-0.0098178433,
0.105644308,
-0.0524706431,
0.0464968756,
0.0353190154,
-0.0288517382,
0.0263522454,
-0.0506904386,
0.0353507921,
-0.0454433486,
-0.0447867997,
-0.0304971915,
0.0077341311,
-0.0271502584,
0.0964601785,
-0.021694677,
-0.0368521512,
0.0335176848,
0.0334830508,
0.0171193667,
-0.0382630229,
-0.0294822268,
-0.0107944636,
0.0331607945,
-0.020830974,
-0.0526397638,
0.0366745219,
-0.0286441073,
-0.0221948307,
-0.0790213421,
0.0404948853,
2.382448788e-34,
0.0376725793,
0.0147673888,
0.0043684477,
0.0186891649,
0.0378444493,
0.0053115054,
-0.008418845,
0.0204748493,
-0.0197966024,
-0.0813247487,
0.0439443439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07467v1
|
MCS-SQL: Leveraging Multiple Prompts and Multiple-Choice Selection For Text-to-SQL Generation
| 2024-05-13T04:59:32 | 2024-05-13T04:59:32 |
Dongjun Lee, Choongwon Park, Jaehyuk Kim, Heesoo Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have enabled in-context
learning (ICL)-based methods that significantly outperform fine-tuning
approaches for text-to-SQL tasks. However, their performance is still
considerably lower than that of human experts on benchmarks that include
complex schemas and queries, such as BIRD. This study considers the sensitivity
of LLMs to the prompts and introduces a novel approach that leverages multiple
prompts to explore a broader search space for possible answers and effectively
aggregate them. Specifically, we robustly refine the database schema through
schema linking using multiple prompts. Thereafter, we generate various
candidate SQL queries based on the refined schema and diverse prompts. Finally,
the candidate queries are filtered based on their confidence scores, and the
optimal query is obtained through a multiple-choice selection that is presented
to the LLM. When evaluated on the BIRD and Spider benchmarks, the proposed
method achieved execution accuracies of 65.5\% and 89.6\%, respectively,
significantly outperforming previous ICL-based methods. Moreover, we
established a new SOTA performance on the BIRD in terms of both the accuracy
and efficiency of the generated queries.
|
[
0.019957386,
0.050075531,
-0.0166059472,
0.0030557339,
-0.0321391113,
0.0127393911,
-0.0161802825,
0.000168385,
0.0226281546,
-0.0552400462,
-0.0028197099,
-0.0300744008,
-0.0304764789,
0.0033378061,
0.0384242348,
-0.0210376661,
0.0296112914,
-0.0337676033,
-0.0334753953,
0.0076910183,
-0.050630942,
0.0320523344,
0.0280402191,
-0.0121446811,
-0.011159393,
0.0008344393,
-0.0339059643,
0.030491285,
-0.0286351591,
-0.0461035483,
-0.0220633466,
0.0636639297,
0.0215793587,
0.023259107,
0.0000022903,
-0.0793043897,
-0.070495531,
0.0159358755,
-0.0609074384,
0.0120574581,
0.0338080078,
0.0094495052,
0.0299767945,
0.0537897609,
-0.0335299633,
0.0159064755,
0.0264034867,
-0.0057770698,
0.0463984348,
0.0626445562,
-0.0004976543,
-0.053905651,
-0.0100735137,
0.0013615731,
0.0396063514,
-0.0716779903,
0.0094848694,
0.0370806381,
0.0600352548,
0.0111989491,
0.005056554,
0.027050253,
0.002862802,
-0.034549851,
-0.0028402174,
0.0018000503,
-0.0157614686,
0.0121758496,
0.001597531,
0.0557187758,
-0.0142427022,
-0.0177907608,
-0.0094204573,
0.0013545435,
-0.0016924796,
0.0091176732,
0.0016496723,
0.0284886714,
-0.0126880314,
0.0094379131,
-0.0216606874,
-0.0221016575,
0.0100987367,
0.0088139111,
-0.0738479346,
0.0248067174,
0.0048685055,
-0.0274004787,
0.0573916622,
-0.0370131321,
-0.0165802184,
-0.0315067358,
0.0282371882,
0.0540686697,
-0.1258479506,
0.0298943613,
-0.0424772277,
-0.0149354786,
0.0281014517,
-0.0366339087,
0.0421386696,
0.035854727,
0.0228935741,
0.0540041775,
-0.0050189253,
0.0134288669,
0.0153835397,
-0.0010359107,
-0.0659031272,
-0.037590012,
-0.0703840926,
0.0088570956,
-0.0439684913,
0.0531205311,
-0.1127951145,
-0.0250090249,
-0.040457122,
0.0483319499,
0.0299965236,
0.0425815433,
0.0118637187,
0.0274460372,
-0.0171241686,
-0.0018154685,
-0.0602611117,
-0.0205091015,
0.0151787596,
-0.0068369564,
0.0060084285,
-0.0616378747,
-0.003559059,
0.0047069085,
0.0120007107,
-0.0332095101,
0.020373363,
0.0658671483,
-0.0397050455,
-0.0056275097,
-0.0755095854,
-0.0696322024,
-0.0291262548,
-0.022806447,
-0.036498297,
-0.0230071321,
0.0594126433,
0.0091479719,
-0.0328571238,
-0.0147897461,
0.0135271819,
0.0602693185,
0.0176568627,
0.0750716403,
-0.0205327608,
0.0233885627,
0.051582627,
-0.0276840087,
0.0091648716,
0.0880680233,
-0.01756135,
0.0502901636,
0.0045683458,
-0.0043895026,
-0.0049925102,
0.0110383704,
0.0157503616,
0.0346292295,
-0.0497926772,
0.0865253583,
0.037672624,
0.0543213375,
-0.0241515394,
0.072149165,
0.0098311054,
0.0137364743,
0.0630138665,
0.0018884902,
0.0341511257,
-0.0099321576,
0.0480745919,
0.0268545598,
0.0110752974,
-0.043336723,
-0.0395516381,
0.0035191502,
-0.0528553799,
0.0383197591,
0.0169282779,
0.0104217408,
0.0013724836,
-0.0413758494,
0.0057374639,
-0.0078165103,
-0.0468497947,
0.0601386204,
0.0136542236,
-0.0185161848,
-0.0509978682,
0.0230008811,
-0.008541109,
-0.0265108217,
0.007481053,
-0.00098463,
0.0056819092,
0.0858126357,
0.011329025,
-0.048031956,
-0.0088681607,
-0.0198399387,
0.0057507269,
0.0314409286,
0.0251697116,
-0.037043523,
-0.0193296447,
-0.0229975451,
-0.0297469851,
0.0435926504,
0.0258375406,
-0.0180496164,
0.0334748887,
0.0043650847,
0.0281263217,
-0.0307589322,
-0.041273538,
0.035177689,
-0.0293885265,
-0.0455668345,
0.0319695175,
-0.0038573679,
0.0159211401,
0.0334903188,
-0.0270932652,
0.0535300486,
0.0263992343,
0.008467556,
-0.047608126,
-0.0549816228,
-0.0092280023,
-0.0114259468,
0.0224419888,
0.0134792123,
-0.0149272857,
-0.0535209365,
-0.0385565422,
-0.0440227166,
-0.0495597273,
-0.0230825916,
0.0052509843,
-0.0441408269,
0.0266478695,
-0.0008688175,
-0.0403165258,
-0.0963715687,
0.0711778998,
0.0242114831,
0.0006440219,
0.0287039112,
-0.016407568,
0.028429823,
-0.0890280902,
0.0160566308,
0.0047665001,
0.0069360649,
0.0428454243,
-0.0182150956,
0.0250367373,
-0.0715458691,
-0.0212562755,
-0.0789551288,
0.0210653171,
-0.0078683775,
0.0149014974,
0.0101474058,
0.0180882011,
-0.0179854054,
-0.0046578106,
-0.0370177664,
-0.0178823788,
-0.0044668382,
0.0128606698,
0.0118908081,
0.0229626577,
-0.0020495872,
-0.0256214608,
-0.0199448708,
-0.0357325599,
0.0663195103,
-0.0160569493,
-0.0073882365,
0.0037586498,
0.0330262296,
-0.0165033061,
-0.0047831461,
0.0197451059,
0.0375587158,
-0.0026389945,
-0.0477640443,
-0.0153110838,
0.0502444878,
0.0400892682,
-0.0383985378,
0.0073885396,
-0.0142836012,
-0.0413605534,
0.0116884494,
-0.0132826772,
-0.0300824307,
-0.0037202265,
-0.0327435844,
0.0503156111,
-0.0208324343,
0.0093709882,
-0.0221966933,
-0.0342624672,
0.0157125406,
0.0355918743,
-0.0039450042,
-0.0860843211,
0.0154541712,
0.0422964692,
0.0420381613,
0.0074975439,
-0.0283682346,
0.0518154874,
-0.02444892,
0.0232985131,
-0.051744733,
0.0081218071,
-0.0551522598,
0.058705017,
-0.0115056382,
0.0337282084,
-0.0057233698,
-0.030246092,
-0.0475442559,
-0.0554099455,
0.0224506352,
-0.0408707336,
0.0846072137,
-0.0505474247,
0.0306632575,
-0.0017169267,
-0.0128991259,
-0.0374741852,
0.0122590438,
-0.0348979123,
0.034838751,
0.0690101013,
0.0081015965,
-0.0022679747,
-0.0070181689,
0.0196653809,
0.0032010821,
-0.0102509838,
-0.0292120185,
0.0031655375,
-0.0148187522,
0.0224711113,
0.0300776195,
0.0043497742,
-0.0107233748,
0.0570267253,
0.0192688033,
0.0390633382,
-0.0490104966,
0.0155720888,
0.0293913614,
-0.0159185492,
-0.0286451355,
-0.0051582726,
0.056111604,
-0.0239346921,
-0.0416218527,
-0.0020036823,
0.0874674469,
0.037069343,
0.0110563943,
-0.0069813519,
0.0339959562,
0.0109215267,
0.0331809036,
0.0703325272,
-0.0899480134,
-0.043422915,
-0.0164741799,
0.0249580368,
0.0296015739,
-0.0581522398,
-0.0255613141,
-0.162465021,
0.0344872475,
-0.0251474697,
-0.0746332482,
-0.0025913808,
-0.0292387623,
-0.033074975,
-0.0268099196,
0.014083256,
0.0722665936,
-0.0258947369,
0.0108544109,
0.0116823083,
0.047302369,
-0.0652365237,
0.0060141971,
-0.0458660312,
-0.0010334613,
0.0317957848,
0.0022246793,
0.0422958471,
-0.0052078115,
0.0268425103,
-0.0484555736,
0.0244270451,
-0.044132635,
0.0636742413,
0.005792398,
0.0161512289,
0.0167925972,
0.0071974341,
-0.0222087987,
0.016121082,
0.0246451199,
0.1077641249,
-0.0322762392,
0.0200074185,
-0.0151349884,
-0.0457831174,
0.0244674161,
0.0503619798,
-0.0131212054,
-0.0322875343,
-0.0492978245,
-0.0153820543,
-0.030419562,
-0.0464803986,
0.0273876656,
0.0586166419,
-0.0391693339,
-0.035634581,
-0.0342628397,
-0.01233806,
0.0686700568,
0.0606417544,
0.0095918458,
0.048302155,
0.0165041089,
0.0088637238,
-0.0281778444,
-0.02313531,
-0.0480554961,
0.0169580001,
-0.0566654839,
0.0135370186,
0.0422699973,
-0.0509559475,
-0.0298331995,
-0.023755271,
-0.0319353975,
-0.0376628712,
-0.0114726098,
0.0157864615,
0.0197695922,
0.0080740452,
0.0137510216,
-0.039793022,
0.0487471111,
0.0556033552,
-0.025828613,
-0.0273291655,
-0.024054043,
0.0173659455,
-0.0326733701,
0.0366197862,
-0.0427941643,
0.011965937,
-0.0026403274,
0.0162443481,
-0.0070578172,
-0.0068612057,
0.0692572668,
0.0699106455,
-0.0305373818,
0.0078594042,
-0.0468039364,
0.012357939,
0.0559152886,
-0.0322150998,
-0.0590325184,
-0.0048009735,
-0.003241994,
0.0013204975,
-0.0256888028,
0.0473621562,
-0.0480611697,
0.0181344021,
0.0331357494,
0.0145062134,
-0.0246658754,
0.0360709876,
-0.0134265954,
0.0492196828,
-0.0175071694,
0.0029034954,
0.0292024836,
0.021391904,
0.0618233047,
0.0009874031,
0.0218575262,
0.0261581764,
0.0013179426,
-0.0416722186,
-0.0033020605,
-0.0235196277,
-0.0449363403,
-0.0169223491,
0.0033752425,
0.0380576625,
-0.0126099559,
-0.005377207,
-0.0028241682,
-0.0236397143,
-0.0406729057,
0.0142691471,
0.0573503301,
-0.0143520543,
0.0454154573,
0.0133528914,
-0.0280026812,
-0.01609198,
0.0630707443,
-0.0031598115,
0.0281718485,
-0.0119713731,
-0.0487903431,
-0.0462264158,
-0.0194434822,
0.0055621816,
0.0194125064,
-0.0139578339,
-0.0211805701,
-0.0500476137,
-0.0287070293,
0.0401962772,
0.0282035377,
-0.0305607859,
-0.0006912622,
0.0640570596,
0.0949962959,
0.0685577542,
-0.0232844353,
-0.0199327897,
0.007703206,
-0.0619050264,
-0.0441397354,
-0.0223377403,
-6.340518815e-33,
-0.0309163686,
-0.0539319329,
0.0383601151,
-0.0295254644,
0.0242644232,
-0.0403534435,
-0.0206030477,
-0.0176589657,
-0.0355053656,
-0.0176628418,
-0.0362820737,
-0.0059766411,
0.0232247524,
0.0600423217,
0.0343398526,
-0.0378082581,
0.0034921723,
0.004535981,
0.0115028676,
0.0034231569,
0.0493040457,
0.0250340048,
0.001697504,
-0.0201256983,
-0.0253610741,
0.0241266079,
-0.0154153854,
0.0368814208,
-0.0303718615,
0.0396651849,
-0.0063614822,
0.0526023582,
0.0090676248,
-0.0218036491,
-0.0054674889,
-0.0200791471,
-0.0214140043,
-0.026149191,
0.0059084874,
-0.0377318859,
0.0304032173,
-0.0342315733,
0.050391715,
-0.0358005278,
-0.0143449754,
-0.0134840431,
0.0149945254,
-0.0464772843,
-0.04602734,
-0.0588607155,
-0.0403757878,
0.0118745323,
0.029849343,
0.0235823523,
-0.0184737183,
0.0474113673,
-0.0075835446,
0.0426090807,
-0.012684525,
0.0558240376,
0.0438695736,
0.0503724702,
0.032559827,
0.04911213,
0.0117899971,
-0.0046644458,
0.018619258,
-0.0033379253,
0.0083670001,
0.0283421353,
-0.0160581358,
0.0634172186,
0.0338419341,
0.0728911683,
-0.0141978515,
-0.0013381508,
-0.0848736316,
0.0392047949,
-0.0273037907,
-0.0085950252,
0.0225374047,
0.0078038354,
-0.0543183126,
-0.0661792234,
-0.074421823,
0.0426236913,
-0.0459930897,
-0.0129827447,
0.0526840463,
-0.0053544058,
-0.0251699761,
-0.0072405413,
0.0281578694,
0.0078524463,
-0.0671454072,
0.0012666106,
-0.031227557,
-0.0299134459,
-0.0058032149,
0.0176237505,
-0.0615516827,
-0.037579529,
0.0187214557,
-0.0019301113,
-0.0103669204,
0.0376727507,
-0.0047283908,
0.0273636803,
-0.0824499279,
0.0198464561,
-0.0154191209,
0.0285645612,
-0.0183020309,
-0.0081393262,
0.0269811749,
-0.0059411563,
0.0268846396,
0.0246194918,
0.0051418883,
-0.0232864469,
-0.0154192466,
-0.031873785,
0.0028582439,
0.0218479317,
0.0415838063,
0.0553201288,
0.0126283318,
-0.0219558328,
0.0262057129,
-0.0210460089,
0.0049907216,
0.0389204882,
2.958e-7,
0.0756548867,
0.038368538,
-0.0028321389,
0.0437253974,
-0.0150602879,
0.0446764678,
0.019008154,
-0.0036997062,
0.0326404646,
-0.0151801938,
0.0282032322,
-0.0091741513,
0.0263513289,
0.0534988381,
-0.0587206744,
-0.0139775211,
-0.0150461998,
0.0165195409,
-0.0747860074,
0.022498155,
0.0585729405,
0.0930277482,
-0.0451550484,
-0.0046821986,
0.0135430954,
-0.0486210361,
0.0126229962,
-0.0442687087,
-0.0222137515,
0.0428458937,
-0.025016712,
-0.0162022579,
-0.0084337369,
0.0852029547,
-0.0269467626,
-0.0086683193,
-0.0116698351,
0.0398725979,
0.0065691164,
0.0124418549,
0.0125422329,
-0.0656436831,
0.010058241,
-0.0497069731,
0.0866944343,
-0.0474069752,
0.0090818089,
0.0608168915,
0.000572919,
-0.0531107895,
0.0110153574,
-0.0165515188,
0.0190551244,
-0.0279959794,
0.000607337,
0.0524209403,
0.024275586,
-0.0318658315,
-0.0059735738,
0.0514436997,
-0.0285319649,
-0.0345465615,
-0.0218099505,
0.0177717283,
-0.0059728781,
-0.0336308926,
-0.0022638268,
3.036500043e-34,
0.0192827843,
0.0293826461,
0.028578978,
-0.0026799266,
0.0418913737,
0.0174367819,
-0.00556278,
0.002955571,
0.0096111912,
-0.0939520523,
-0.0345270708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13006v1
|
Auto FAQ Generation
| 2024-05-13T03:30:27 | 2024-05-13T03:30:27 |
Anjaneya Teja Kalvakolanu, NagaSai Chandra, Michael Fekadu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
FAQ documents are commonly used with text documents and websites to provide
important information in the form of question answer pairs to either aid in
reading comprehension or provide a shortcut to the key ideas. We suppose that
salient sentences from a given document serve as a good proxy fro the answers
to an aggregated set of FAQs from readers. We propose a system for generating
FAQ documents that extract the salient questions and their corresponding
answers from sizeable text documents scraped from the Stanford Encyclopedia of
Philosophy. We use existing text summarization, sentence ranking via the Text
rank algorithm, and question-generation tools to create an initial set of
questions and answers. Finally, we apply some heuristics to filter out invalid
questions. We use human evaluation to rate the generated questions on grammar,
whether the question is meaningful, and whether the question's answerability is
present within a summarized context. On average, participants thought 71
percent of the questions were meaningful.
|
[
0.0761544108,
-0.0302270167,
-0.0090842163,
0.0083249304,
-0.0208663624,
0.0258444697,
-0.0054654405,
-0.0101649463,
0.0192314591,
-0.0634242073,
0.0199846216,
0.0056205899,
0.0116718607,
-0.0221375301,
0.0146018099,
-0.04316907,
0.0062423022,
-0.0069622202,
-0.0049310979,
-0.0102564925,
0.0139259631,
0.0258188602,
-0.0059200693,
0.0100910552,
0.0287459288,
-0.0013992515,
-0.0158514958,
0.0054381886,
0.0268941354,
-0.0165336486,
0.0132749742,
0.0374376178,
-0.0130256601,
-0.0484335199,
0.0000018377,
-0.0982716605,
-0.0370667018,
-0.0094587412,
0.0009147673,
0.004855914,
0.0170562081,
0.055796206,
0.0203487426,
0.0226440672,
-0.0323429964,
0.0395244919,
-0.0324687287,
0.0228503551,
0.0554933958,
0.0425000787,
-0.0086409897,
-0.0749302432,
0.0214449745,
0.0432985052,
0.0398258455,
-0.0370179154,
-0.0048938328,
0.0426448919,
0.0011298164,
0.048016116,
0.0226858109,
-0.00148635,
-0.0005611956,
-0.0397134759,
0.0920195729,
-0.0124603603,
-0.0560399927,
-0.0263402089,
0.0169125479,
0.0616172999,
0.0550331399,
-0.0061366409,
0.0606966354,
0.0162129458,
0.04106085,
0.0444655307,
-0.0425469764,
0.0210305508,
-0.0168185476,
-0.0393364504,
0.0443505496,
-0.0016902655,
-0.0326084048,
-0.0023592606,
-0.0090577612,
0.0144636417,
0.0235226508,
-0.0254670866,
-0.0117008956,
-0.0143621368,
-0.0397030674,
-0.0832866579,
0.0191614758,
0.0809173435,
0.0006828105,
-0.0376750194,
-0.0221900288,
-0.0366485193,
0.0485152081,
-0.0498616807,
-0.0123756481,
0.0058886227,
0.0169384014,
0.0124473656,
0.0085880775,
0.0123356069,
0.0248518605,
-0.028236784,
-0.0519271865,
0.0217756405,
-0.0596712492,
-0.0100785196,
-0.016346788,
0.0841142982,
-0.0079522328,
-0.0177477151,
-0.0228499416,
0.0178363062,
0.066346772,
0.0221413169,
-0.0269642789,
0.0083577586,
-0.0215959121,
-0.0156570766,
-0.0110955192,
-0.0218174215,
-0.0669653416,
0.0090915132,
0.0052714008,
0.0029728105,
0.0392816886,
0.0160780065,
0.0321369395,
0.0157149564,
0.0134985438,
0.0136393867,
-0.0153128346,
-0.0207337439,
-0.0394257307,
-0.0643998459,
0.0085276039,
0.0065482776,
-0.0317439847,
-0.0503761694,
-0.0049115904,
0.0286121871,
-0.0154350037,
0.0356256925,
0.037314564,
0.0576234646,
-0.0107383821,
0.0206558537,
-0.0159642454,
0.0044481223,
0.1317498237,
-0.0201890469,
0.0239441376,
-0.0198445469,
0.0163970068,
0.0333354995,
0.0691208541,
0.0370791182,
0.024636887,
-0.0225462876,
0.0054519773,
0.006608949,
0.0484000295,
0.0591950305,
-0.0343354456,
-0.0133502632,
-0.0668082535,
0.0919423029,
0.0233750287,
0.0375303067,
0.0163829103,
0.0663671792,
-0.0218492448,
0.0493155792,
0.0094201304,
0.0279821176,
0.0336313695,
0.0427660756,
0.0039475732,
0.0463248678,
-0.0466919281,
0.0263784844,
0.0481223501,
0.020127425,
-0.0071079531,
-0.0535700545,
-0.0183572397,
0.029615419,
-0.0442422703,
0.0332890339,
0.0238745827,
0.0273888092,
-0.020346256,
-0.0185428243,
-0.0052969689,
-0.044836618,
0.0090783937,
0.0009205399,
0.0626070648,
0.0376211777,
0.0651063919,
-0.0255327877,
0.0092810532,
-0.0005574232,
0.0392328463,
0.0452553257,
0.0651000068,
-0.0241667349,
-0.0442797132,
-0.0458841883,
-0.0035788375,
-0.0318271033,
-0.0080410168,
-0.0539421774,
-0.0122590866,
0.0035929128,
0.0714489296,
-0.0619422384,
-0.0698330924,
0.0440550484,
-0.0162213761,
-0.0367665589,
0.0063040345,
0.0043617142,
-0.0312107187,
0.0419809781,
-0.0150982905,
0.0374949202,
-0.0008868155,
-0.0288550053,
0.0089634405,
-0.0129013266,
0.0085500227,
0.0162742604,
0.0432001799,
-0.0838379413,
-0.0063811666,
0.0462007523,
-0.0194446407,
-0.0454448275,
-0.0315916277,
-0.0610574335,
-0.0139346207,
-0.0299717989,
0.0171918552,
0.0339792445,
-0.0239472408,
-0.0445916429,
0.0816941485,
0.0248570088,
0.0229470301,
0.0319243185,
-0.0344933309,
0.0445909686,
-0.0520454459,
0.0036445202,
-0.0468570106,
-0.0215967521,
-0.0124800298,
0.0563522652,
0.0232666489,
-0.0544953719,
-0.0076923715,
-0.0820383877,
-0.0050698519,
-0.0303955525,
0.004197869,
0.0375995897,
-0.0120173944,
0.0022843024,
-0.0013414988,
-0.0730289295,
0.004194269,
0.0039175609,
-0.0401523709,
0.0853193998,
0.0188490469,
0.0235640258,
-0.0487283617,
-0.0021390088,
-0.0162428748,
0.0099400878,
0.0972434953,
0.0144143924,
-0.0218809899,
0.0207764897,
-0.0495160818,
-0.0393562242,
0.0334359892,
-0.0038180691,
-0.0151059339,
-0.0153904147,
0.0095510185,
0.0385712758,
0.085909076,
0.0161795802,
-0.0051120864,
0.024795128,
-0.0005910293,
-0.0119575551,
-0.0231977701,
0.0121600199,
0.03454981,
-0.0811678842,
0.0553149506,
-0.0298836362,
0.0039118626,
-0.0035427599,
-0.0221371185,
0.0443025865,
-0.0300168153,
0.0238874592,
-0.0616895631,
-0.0195561405,
0.0010232314,
0.0538190268,
0.0169076491,
0.0078978129,
0.0545946546,
0.0017814324,
0.011871201,
-0.0927799791,
0.0185599197,
-0.056722004,
0.0300887395,
-0.010874561,
0.0363798365,
0.0033845222,
-0.0002308913,
-0.0525622405,
-0.0052251089,
0.0509412736,
-0.0311843753,
0.0040763956,
-0.0324606523,
0.0110670663,
-0.0220091566,
-0.0224478059,
-0.0129416296,
-0.0168606564,
0.0025433355,
-0.0320139304,
0.0448066592,
0.0099628689,
0.0035181236,
-0.0188414715,
0.0472648107,
-0.0033416634,
-0.0301518198,
-0.0470669903,
0.0108650066,
0.0761002228,
0.0893236622,
-0.0173109993,
0.0123638809,
-0.0561855771,
0.0436144397,
0.0450560041,
0.0200869031,
0.0196680408,
0.0472458154,
-0.0328896381,
-0.0055308058,
-0.0591332614,
0.0045729438,
0.0040253852,
-0.0025987518,
-0.0126530966,
-0.0329028256,
0.0986828953,
0.1035025492,
-0.013822617,
-0.015339884,
-0.038816642,
0.0028145423,
0.0007307762,
0.0334936157,
-0.0578123555,
0.0124477064,
0.001851422,
0.0507785529,
-0.0268125664,
0.0026499955,
0.0094700512,
-0.0715423003,
0.0027861516,
-0.01021438,
0.0006190751,
-0.0168857891,
0.0116344523,
-0.0175852198,
0.0175344422,
-0.0606152341,
0.0532358699,
-0.0225796476,
0.0219588019,
0.0285272673,
-0.0191797949,
0.0304121692,
-0.0090785939,
0.0211752485,
-0.0202881787,
0.04467858,
0.0400594026,
-0.0016091447,
-0.0218572449,
0.0583390184,
-0.029584894,
-0.0119415307,
0.0011619768,
0.0604602061,
-0.0117211035,
0.0020728908,
-0.0603009649,
0.0594869629,
-0.0070284256,
-0.0006783442,
0.0891811624,
-0.0213350803,
-0.0293333139,
-0.0165475253,
-0.0569477007,
0.0293081533,
-0.0558201857,
0.0681666732,
0.0049924441,
-0.0254966002,
0.0065756692,
-0.0476393104,
0.0402996838,
-0.0686282218,
-0.0422166772,
-0.0202372391,
-0.0085314568,
-0.0072055706,
-0.1115738675,
-0.0189297013,
-0.0054838234,
0.0102053722,
0.029716596,
-0.0417688116,
-0.0154485675,
0.0410498716,
-0.0304986071,
-0.042224627,
0.0172877498,
-0.030664878,
-0.0587983131,
-0.0297846552,
0.0655046031,
-0.0420863777,
-0.0359856412,
0.0100203222,
0.0143743483,
-0.0358692221,
-0.0031747036,
0.0261648484,
0.0163324662,
-0.0346871205,
-0.002090408,
-0.0000040752,
0.0325840339,
0.0369273201,
-0.0372017138,
0.0042373314,
-0.0254737958,
0.0226485897,
-0.0106570022,
0.0093199788,
-0.0836457312,
0.0355478078,
-0.070728302,
0.0362676047,
-0.0446168333,
-0.0770796537,
0.06147293,
0.0689002126,
-0.0607677251,
0.0074732718,
0.003347402,
-0.0098010786,
0.0411860459,
-0.0230723582,
-0.0353735909,
-0.0175192878,
0.0687498227,
-0.0018917482,
-0.0162048563,
0.0325465426,
0.0108753722,
-0.0159352422,
0.0329233184,
0.0146482931,
-0.0359438583,
0.0099761328,
0.030205721,
-0.0395731591,
-0.0361743346,
-0.0481462702,
-0.0102425506,
-0.0145934122,
0.0587561131,
0.0147188911,
0.036390271,
0.0313641541,
-0.0134544456,
0.0060492516,
-0.008100885,
-0.0791134089,
-0.0570548102,
-0.0427324735,
-0.0079568001,
-0.0201930664,
0.0156251136,
0.0096019357,
-0.0299926084,
-0.0339868367,
0.0006736398,
0.0472429432,
0.0410670638,
-0.0149278007,
-0.0158342719,
0.0330387093,
-0.0056429012,
-0.0198412985,
0.044776734,
-0.0047842339,
-0.0592332855,
0.0376958512,
-0.0523366965,
-0.057320077,
-0.0054267826,
-0.018785568,
0.026018003,
0.0258967821,
0.0118798045,
-0.0716862157,
-0.0354143679,
-0.011189146,
0.0347110741,
0.0394807272,
0.0071355053,
0.0530593581,
0.0369502977,
0.0199818145,
-0.0398573019,
-0.0740931779,
0.0855643153,
-0.0982377529,
-0.0196509082,
0.0117607135,
-5.857848345e-33,
-0.0334844142,
-0.0561449081,
-0.0228973813,
0.0366045386,
0.0271102358,
-0.0244619176,
-0.0515674464,
0.0165391825,
-0.0197317488,
0.0273110569,
0.0066785826,
0.011854142,
-0.0081564439,
0.0236278102,
-0.0333572477,
-0.0259217806,
0.011817866,
-0.0104059437,
-0.0290280133,
0.0355711915,
0.0530658215,
0.007163702,
-0.0208784211,
-0.0074892282,
0.0215215813,
-0.0912965462,
0.008829766,
-0.0077919927,
0.0191990696,
0.0250829365,
0.0037698578,
0.0120280571,
0.0169773549,
0.0021854471,
0.0317985229,
0.0453993641,
-0.0303592384,
-0.0447152555,
0.0088939266,
-0.0608189702,
-0.046427995,
-0.0294489916,
0.0015559947,
-0.012539356,
0.0416298844,
-0.0109259915,
0.0917043984,
-0.0251191705,
0.0028549742,
-0.0891596228,
-0.0303528812,
0.0111122672,
-0.0511676148,
-0.0087248841,
-0.0335948505,
0.0955125615,
0.014261975,
0.0030608603,
0.0268342812,
0.0244310386,
0.0176697075,
0.0278063212,
-0.0027848589,
-0.0248315167,
0.0146741197,
0.0170136094,
-0.0492124557,
0.0155199021,
0.009650209,
0.0084048538,
-0.0534501858,
0.0008779591,
0.0333084464,
0.0547229648,
0.0117313284,
0.0049264058,
-0.0378954858,
0.0818902701,
0.004735474,
-0.0112322951,
0.0074531231,
-0.0567907393,
-0.015085292,
0.0183799621,
-0.0237236898,
0.0522784851,
-0.023471389,
-0.0084989294,
0.0212251097,
-0.0234349091,
-0.0707730278,
-0.0662294701,
-0.0286127795,
0.0162643511,
-0.0154938893,
0.0186075233,
-0.0305861905,
0.0257388745,
-0.0155807585,
-0.0181628056,
-0.0345080085,
0.0498877801,
-0.0092951814,
0.0159706287,
0.0116980169,
0.0120810615,
-0.0265556574,
-0.0345110819,
-0.0129791042,
-0.0104794111,
0.0249721985,
0.0144308498,
-0.0163692124,
-0.0071188007,
-0.0232801791,
0.0415272824,
-0.0108907614,
0.0141765764,
-0.0045018252,
0.0095237428,
-0.0479966179,
-0.0204426162,
0.013668187,
0.0271998607,
-0.0055416082,
0.0114587499,
-0.0121540744,
0.098551169,
0.0169112068,
-0.0383224599,
-0.0099695502,
-0.0118890284,
2.601e-7,
0.0600828268,
-0.0017763503,
0.0362257324,
0.0310125109,
-0.0306851976,
0.0319026522,
0.0456702523,
0.0299936794,
0.0526137911,
-0.0320026092,
0.0218957122,
0.0270595122,
0.0129149398,
0.0198147148,
-0.0852698684,
-0.0448403321,
-0.0254696961,
-0.0433203764,
-0.0337777771,
0.0116942665,
0.0513483956,
-0.0019572428,
-0.008957034,
-0.0029158618,
-0.0185651947,
0.0059920014,
0.0150070386,
0.0132058207,
-0.0079896236,
0.0572217368,
0.0465766378,
-0.0171518195,
-0.0099918777,
0.0176570453,
-0.0203180891,
0.0012046439,
0.0370298252,
-0.0213652421,
0.0174268186,
-0.0689228848,
-0.0308661703,
0.002421617,
0.0518699065,
-0.0748220012,
0.0384078659,
-0.0274634976,
-0.0013491358,
0.0117432317,
-0.070174031,
-0.0075977836,
-0.0257716738,
-0.0018462858,
-0.0450306349,
0.0342594646,
-0.0185200442,
-0.0104669454,
0.0487370268,
-0.0333036296,
-0.0089456597,
0.0253463797,
-0.0043940954,
-0.0397947952,
-0.0302173551,
-0.0041956413,
-0.0389802232,
-0.0015078066,
-0.0185181927,
2.081259355e-34,
0.0429681018,
-0.0070964633,
-0.0134993773,
0.0243512578,
0.0043194001,
-0.0073814453,
-0.0314658806,
0.0134304939,
0.0220505819,
-0.0405209623,
0.004854877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.17440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.17440v1
|
CataLM: Empowering Catalyst Design Through Large Language Models
| 2024-05-13T03:19:47 | 2024-05-13T03:19:47 |
Ludi Wang, Xueqing Chen, Yi Du, Yuanchun Zhou, Yang Gao, Wenjuan Cui
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The field of catalysis holds paramount importance in shaping the trajectory
of sustainable development, prompting intensive research efforts to leverage
artificial intelligence (AI) in catalyst design. Presently, the fine-tuning of
open-source large language models (LLMs) has yielded significant breakthroughs
across various domains such as biology and healthcare. Drawing inspiration from
these advancements, we introduce CataLM Cata}lytic Language Model), a large
language model tailored to the domain of electrocatalytic materials. Our
findings demonstrate that CataLM exhibits remarkable potential for facilitating
human-AI collaboration in catalyst knowledge exploration and design. To the
best of our knowledge, CataLM stands as the pioneering LLM dedicated to the
catalyst domain, offering novel avenues for catalyst discovery and development.
|
[
-0.0145313377,
0.0863894075,
-0.0251473784,
0.0434329808,
-0.0159041584,
0.0094141373,
0.0195959359,
0.0304212701,
0.0415143706,
0.003180929,
-0.0405976996,
0.0264896229,
-0.0213235468,
0.0581734739,
0.0271195788,
-0.0038958574,
0.0541344136,
-0.0560477525,
0.0474374518,
-0.0301380288,
-0.005769108,
-0.0050968286,
-0.0166212954,
0.0427647121,
0.0089271422,
0.0197901428,
-0.0323150009,
0.000417565,
0.024057433,
-0.0317175649,
0.0141713237,
0.0576173551,
0.004806431,
0.0421788059,
0.0000018084,
-0.086307995,
0.0168034714,
0.0296994653,
0.046471823,
-0.0360792503,
0.0335096754,
-0.0403566658,
-0.0230740029,
-0.009039795,
0.0102006132,
-0.0059251962,
0.0315966494,
0.0175762754,
0.0194343347,
-0.0115948161,
-0.0163953137,
-0.0299257357,
0.0784135759,
-0.0107569816,
0.0405367389,
-0.0014118822,
0.0310294628,
-0.0029233729,
0.05012317,
-0.031562008,
-0.0109283011,
0.0394084863,
0.0011110865,
-0.0355733931,
0.0556063354,
-0.0117969085,
-0.014132469,
-0.03826949,
-0.0014613152,
0.0562962852,
-0.0035750477,
-0.0220458787,
-0.0736503452,
0.0023772039,
-0.0569836721,
0.0237015467,
-0.0263819844,
0.0124985063,
-0.0036083751,
0.0261911415,
0.0420804024,
-0.0285465997,
0.0470617563,
0.031317696,
-0.0102757215,
0.0560253896,
-0.001920962,
-0.0245898739,
0.031748116,
0.014434319,
-0.0254782941,
0.0149637032,
-0.0092301928,
0.0075038876,
-0.0459417664,
-0.0120114349,
0.0382932425,
0.0446850285,
0.0045585646,
-0.0527921431,
0.0510717705,
0.0248822086,
0.0167181231,
0.0311505944,
-0.0463964976,
-0.0018770122,
-0.031017758,
-0.0015297631,
-0.061456386,
-0.0413629189,
-0.0354702696,
-0.0205546618,
-0.0518574938,
0.0026858107,
-0.0621323362,
0.0027395189,
-0.015824208,
0.0434021764,
-0.0262227338,
0.0144234458,
-0.0137537438,
-0.001379902,
0.0172874276,
-0.0192707907,
-0.0069092698,
0.0272965226,
-0.0281458776,
0.0215610191,
-0.0121953841,
-0.0338006578,
-0.0140982615,
0.0037014352,
-0.0471592695,
-0.015870735,
-0.0145542119,
0.0965175405,
-0.0035243481,
0.0084752711,
-0.0316062607,
-0.0165697765,
0.0117042447,
0.0150750224,
-0.0003194308,
-0.0400450118,
0.0413960181,
0.04633037,
0.0072565209,
-0.0858026668,
-0.0069180191,
-0.0271120928,
-0.0022817219,
0.0574617088,
-0.0519145504,
-0.0108315526,
0.019541489,
0.0070124259,
-0.0157551635,
0.0245261192,
0.0315580703,
0.0199690368,
-0.0281031206,
0.0106263282,
0.004611169,
0.0195971113,
0.0167970918,
-0.0415759943,
-0.0372313522,
-0.0360939912,
-0.00403815,
0.0529515296,
0.0128899673,
0.0028405997,
0.0013931545,
0.0038612217,
0.0421929657,
0.0456614718,
0.035287369,
0.082520619,
0.0070070825,
0.0284123532,
0.0110315168,
-0.0793409571,
-0.0046632853,
0.0254621599,
-0.0304303821,
-0.0597551949,
0.0342641585,
0.0169622041,
0.0094467476,
-0.0248658396,
-0.027808534,
-0.0185364652,
0.0302861892,
-0.0458264165,
0.0334811546,
-0.0460125059,
-0.0484429821,
0.0331678689,
0.0195951387,
-0.0162858069,
-0.0353499167,
-0.0694526806,
0.0298377629,
0.0922191367,
0.0500176065,
-0.0616407581,
-0.0342559069,
0.0248809401,
-0.0232147723,
0.0007171127,
0.0267089717,
-0.0207182802,
0.0127957361,
0.0264407136,
0.0053511169,
-0.0347640067,
0.0242537707,
-0.014012632,
-0.0303495992,
0.0103834365,
-0.0160747543,
0.0040916107,
-0.0692498237,
0.0295488723,
0.0161870103,
-0.0140119111,
-0.0143763544,
-0.0094701154,
0.033664465,
0.0333734453,
0.0078153294,
0.0195121132,
0.0798802674,
-0.0707049742,
-0.0347428285,
-0.0308942162,
-0.0095497267,
0.0224286355,
0.060591381,
-0.0184312128,
0.0340905115,
0.015800802,
0.0069221444,
0.0088023944,
0.05800635,
0.0400371552,
0.0222927481,
-0.0170609485,
-0.0019483684,
-0.0062447968,
0.0705391541,
-0.0252943877,
0.0605200827,
0.0264871679,
0.0018112907,
0.0200809892,
0.015230489,
0.0187777318,
-0.0061360281,
0.0196905751,
0.0167313255,
0.042332001,
0.0422323793,
0.0366440043,
-0.0217687972,
0.0094705643,
-0.0115162563,
-0.0220512599,
0.0025576053,
-0.0010653555,
0.012782841,
0.002406708,
-0.0277543627,
-0.0084634582,
0.0291361995,
0.0340368971,
-0.029799724,
-0.0182298589,
-0.0495864712,
0.036981672,
0.0049531236,
-0.096545808,
-0.024232829,
-0.0262332074,
-0.0615504123,
0.0700730383,
0.0249726698,
-0.0311122034,
-0.0258753728,
0.0297690891,
0.0572109632,
0.0450435728,
0.0035236203,
-0.0042848,
0.0210703649,
-0.0289264899,
-0.0094440235,
-0.0149818454,
0.0044231089,
0.0455599427,
0.0338680446,
0.0034835772,
-0.0028738563,
0.0072834794,
0.0306059923,
-0.0287970938,
0.0127357496,
-0.0257296134,
0.0078710169,
0.0590052865,
-0.054597415,
0.0291777011,
-0.0069260066,
0.0184385628,
0.0110188676,
-0.0706192702,
-0.0205268245,
-0.0195987895,
0.0457349159,
0.0202795137,
-0.008290953,
-0.0404596329,
0.065669708,
-0.0066593657,
-0.0088620521,
-0.0493262224,
-0.0179640353,
-0.0080298577,
0.0490144752,
-0.0235495009,
0.0346352942,
-0.011665374,
0.0423561446,
-0.0173497815,
-0.0561874136,
-0.0173131954,
0.0321721323,
-0.0018564337,
-0.0302721132,
0.0348059498,
0.0001861383,
-0.0192712937,
-0.0088838357,
-0.0142925652,
-0.0114275152,
0.0612430796,
-0.0020374295,
-0.0191271249,
0.0057589011,
0.0557774939,
0.0664089173,
-0.0173320174,
-0.0165346898,
-0.0195245277,
-0.0400899276,
0.043913357,
-0.0440351516,
0.0007494609,
0.0130179049,
0.0063263848,
0.0694333762,
0.054037448,
0.0047392016,
-0.0012332959,
-0.0849324912,
0.02834576,
0.0281842835,
0.0247351937,
0.0118802264,
-0.0148743512,
-0.0228699762,
-0.0209829453,
0.0050693923,
0.0693005696,
0.0007801973,
-0.060625948,
0.0333422199,
0.0065961494,
-0.0058268411,
-0.0133572146,
0.0658796355,
-0.1112959087,
-0.0183044635,
-0.0110143228,
0.0033860861,
0.0175577942,
0.0074396464,
-0.0100608878,
-0.0296310131,
0.0621630661,
-0.0037063274,
-0.0531767905,
-0.0406006798,
-0.0561932735,
-0.0157324541,
-0.008526451,
-0.0070254235,
0.0456204675,
-0.0028523658,
-0.0204181299,
-0.0130984792,
-0.0191158988,
-0.0862973854,
0.012686844,
0.0029299497,
-0.041258458,
0.0579750128,
0.0270097163,
-0.01492872,
-0.0002904367,
0.0581100024,
-0.0029649148,
0.0296830554,
-0.0913817361,
-0.0431232639,
0.0282770731,
-0.0355260856,
0.0021286902,
0.0719845891,
-0.0369167067,
-0.0843280703,
-0.0151020829,
0.1112031192,
-0.0185318179,
0.0066611362,
-0.0412305817,
-0.0542681776,
0.0184254013,
0.0384635292,
-0.0052302573,
-0.0447350964,
-0.0835786611,
-0.0314843655,
-0.0079368092,
-0.0411850736,
-0.0211038943,
-0.0416993722,
0.0446062014,
-0.0593704171,
0.0032029345,
-0.0127121536,
-0.0052418374,
-0.0217186958,
-0.0375351124,
-0.0280003641,
0.0279470552,
-0.0412543006,
-0.0513723381,
0.0122083761,
-0.0021866735,
0.0144075081,
-0.0238432568,
-0.0977275893,
0.0067603188,
-0.0480725765,
-0.0108278459,
0.050170172,
-0.0001716468,
-0.0283359289,
0.0402256884,
0.0345597155,
0.0228216089,
0.0047074384,
-0.0257324129,
-0.0462925062,
0.0455944687,
0.06635423,
-0.0346748605,
0.0117969457,
-0.0052997321,
0.0178465508,
-0.0271236058,
0.0061530536,
-0.011372501,
0.0346614644,
-0.025140103,
0.0164118372,
-0.0086852973,
-0.0221534315,
0.0132912258,
0.0213749204,
0.0132983364,
0.0107560419,
0.0213823207,
-0.0202250071,
-0.0285392124,
0.0603158623,
0.0267643742,
-0.0547209457,
-0.0319012739,
0.0376137793,
-0.0550521426,
0.0271290708,
-0.0541800335,
0.0186948311,
-0.0529864356,
-0.044422213,
0.1092648581,
0.0238581598,
0.0382930711,
0.042218212,
-0.014711557,
0.0001629913,
0.0143110314,
-0.083367981,
0.0478287451,
-0.0319496877,
-0.0070199892,
0.0026851955,
0.0490976013,
0.0007151708,
0.0763602108,
0.0079690106,
-0.0980444476,
-0.0426377542,
0.0628649741,
0.0704176053,
0.0488515086,
0.0178981945,
-0.0260509346,
-0.0503575467,
-0.0069196811,
0.026525775,
-0.0018619456,
-0.0379165821,
-0.0087236799,
0.0468993224,
-0.022676792,
-0.0644654185,
0.0584588721,
0.0008476459,
-0.009194416,
-0.0409832671,
-0.0383654125,
-0.0245692059,
-0.0447362736,
-0.0178566594,
-0.0522616655,
-0.0267772451,
-0.0232268758,
-0.0619017743,
-0.0237980634,
0.0229511037,
0.0639628991,
-0.0253188815,
0.0004770927,
0.0283486396,
0.0606958978,
0.0001283631,
-0.0620023273,
-0.0012016692,
-0.033974655,
-0.0140487514,
-0.0475525111,
0.0141476635,
-5.338687224e-33,
0.001827467,
0.0249586757,
-0.0069000325,
0.0332315676,
-0.0132721541,
-0.0364343263,
-0.0786737576,
-0.0127948951,
0.0289319847,
0.0563991517,
-0.0004122135,
-0.0302741099,
0.0052838027,
-0.0422679707,
0.0626927242,
0.0254457314,
-0.0012195526,
0.0296655968,
-0.0204383843,
0.0238528047,
-0.0130620291,
0.0433213785,
-0.0007966908,
-0.0246689823,
0.0214327965,
0.0259581804,
-0.0029673099,
0.0060657379,
-0.0173114035,
0.0502104163,
-0.0299235918,
0.0516119078,
-0.0127005503,
-0.044071015,
-0.0072860173,
0.0134037007,
-0.0331655554,
0.0042860131,
-0.0027961207,
0.0038548075,
-0.0374136008,
-0.0120476959,
0.0225701891,
0.0320479125,
-0.0781499594,
0.0355264843,
-0.0035312136,
-0.0740553066,
0.0838525146,
0.0185809061,
-0.0814820156,
-0.0164783262,
0.0025985574,
0.0260189697,
0.0067616641,
-0.0328006856,
-0.0245695133,
0.0181770995,
0.0073073907,
0.052565489,
0.0378983766,
-0.0051750569,
0.059178669,
0.033696115,
-0.0071768714,
0.0114741577,
0.0717860833,
0.0622379631,
0.0109009482,
0.0591687113,
0.0299793985,
0.0796565339,
0.0605225973,
0.0044583688,
-0.0284467041,
0.0253599752,
-0.1304663718,
0.0135203479,
-0.0156451054,
0.0540441312,
0.029597206,
0.0377689935,
0.0267007425,
-0.0583370142,
-0.0298864767,
0.0439238138,
-0.0056247818,
-0.006051302,
-0.0508918762,
-0.0275354255,
-0.0477537289,
0.0080373511,
0.0133459223,
-0.0496239439,
-0.0022439528,
0.0756864846,
-0.0106185535,
0.0416341946,
-0.0208287388,
0.0016588798,
-0.0732817277,
-0.0564850159,
-0.0680847242,
0.0285212398,
0.0328042544,
-0.0226497278,
-0.0407467037,
0.0449786894,
0.0142717352,
-0.0005746622,
-0.0779476613,
-0.0083555216,
0.0278530773,
0.006992626,
0.0059009613,
-0.0193490852,
-0.0016536673,
0.0017621024,
-0.0407748073,
0.0307806823,
0.03020343,
0.0637553781,
-0.0025845249,
0.0308340639,
-0.0265252311,
-0.0336352214,
-0.0559457429,
0.0480340123,
0.0061813109,
-0.0410587825,
-0.020797994,
-0.0208026096,
2.532e-7,
0.0373305641,
0.0276565198,
0.0367729291,
0.0203449968,
-0.0104912147,
0.0192153398,
0.0093764365,
0.0070226993,
-0.0392583199,
0.0015279223,
0.0280840769,
0.064359583,
0.0330292657,
0.005638367,
-0.0195932258,
0.011120677,
-0.0267140586,
0.047287643,
-0.0518299341,
0.0156388767,
-0.0165817011,
0.031024063,
-0.0065989466,
-0.0405977964,
0.021467356,
-0.053513471,
0.0100471973,
-0.0450368039,
0.0129175242,
0.0725971684,
-0.0912462249,
-0.0151873259,
-0.0255281534,
0.0386990681,
0.0033815734,
-0.0041729454,
-0.0185244959,
0.0226708073,
-0.0237385202,
0.0428293794,
0.0461337231,
-0.0027415897,
-0.0008973442,
-0.0133996662,
0.0141737666,
0.0130554698,
-0.0105468985,
-0.0048198197,
0.0031840429,
-0.0410148911,
-0.0034406576,
-0.0187264271,
0.0282694735,
-0.0318940952,
-0.0248921849,
0.0114761107,
0.0098344907,
-0.0078184111,
-0.0384064429,
-0.0010226966,
-0.0206318609,
-0.0190502442,
-0.0450126305,
0.0319444239,
0.0264899451,
0.0227435194,
0.0552710705,
1.950704636e-34,
0.0546039566,
-0.0140363164,
-0.0180604532,
0.0111461505,
0.0609089583,
0.0041994778,
-0.0767753646,
0.0093377121,
0.0006867535,
-0.0542641766,
-0.0185101461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07437v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07437v2
|
Evaluation of Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Survey
| 2024-05-13T02:33:25 | 2024-07-03T04:59:32 |
Hao Yu, Aoran Gan, Kai Zhang, Shiwei Tong, Qi Liu, Zhaofeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has recently gained traction in natural
language processing. Numerous studies and real-world applications are
leveraging its ability to enhance generative models through external
information retrieval. Evaluating these RAG systems, however, poses unique
challenges due to their hybrid structure and reliance on dynamic knowledge
sources. To better understand these challenges, we conduct A Unified Evaluation
Process of RAG (Auepora) and aim to provide a comprehensive overview of the
evaluation and benchmarks of RAG systems. Specifically, we examine and compare
several quantifiable metrics of the Retrieval and Generation components, such
as relevance, accuracy, and faithfulness, within the current RAG benchmarks,
encompassing the possible output and ground truth pairs. We then analyze the
various datasets and metrics, discuss the limitations of current benchmarks,
and suggest potential directions to advance the field of RAG benchmarks.
|
[
0.0614560023,
0.0542922765,
-0.0051031215,
-0.0056412211,
-0.0347069129,
-0.0343211666,
-0.0436356924,
0.0049271467,
-0.032636676,
-0.0476986021,
0.0035688821,
-0.0101292403,
-0.0170247573,
0.0170028768,
0.0337745473,
-0.0084084859,
0.0640291497,
0.0432292335,
-0.0309078228,
0.0265398193,
0.0051884148,
0.0280714314,
-0.0236688554,
0.0532762557,
-0.0450502038,
0.0406367593,
0.013715839,
0.0277181994,
0.0498323888,
-0.0059166686,
-0.0112897018,
0.0018394018,
0.0032831512,
0.0425489545,
0.0000017052,
-0.0648128837,
-0.0375060476,
0.0035119597,
-0.0017127647,
-0.0365969837,
0.0418248326,
0.034584973,
-0.0237708818,
0.0287999026,
-0.0499124452,
-0.0246933065,
0.0515234955,
-0.002919381,
0.0486954935,
0.0889018849,
-0.0045932382,
-0.0124788787,
0.0357747599,
-0.0362097807,
0.0264019649,
-0.0068215597,
-0.0087121148,
0.0037237322,
-0.0126707312,
0.0076362039,
-0.0062035746,
0.0244752504,
0.0147897499,
-0.023442775,
0.0438003056,
0.0188964717,
-0.0769152194,
-0.0035860068,
-0.0185960457,
0.0617498457,
0.0379351303,
-0.0149634695,
-0.0062644985,
0.0083641829,
-0.0089211427,
0.0388431437,
-0.0247069392,
0.0267877877,
-0.0023617756,
0.0303444918,
-0.0129411342,
0.0449582264,
0.0267190859,
0.0101348208,
-0.0051789694,
0.0475527532,
0.0499870963,
-0.0211616978,
-0.0191577375,
0.0010325601,
-0.0068150912,
-0.0257106461,
-0.0187284164,
0.0111610824,
-0.0002149036,
0.0335313194,
-0.0159871317,
-0.040202979,
0.0510153696,
0.0122038871,
0.0442912839,
0.0437540375,
-0.031463474,
0.0229407977,
-0.0371954739,
0.0650742948,
-0.0064060302,
-0.0248343572,
-0.0415629745,
-0.004520528,
-0.0528285205,
-0.0060393959,
-0.0329164788,
0.027707316,
-0.0403593965,
-0.0393113717,
-0.0618624389,
0.012396045,
-0.013540322,
0.0022025425,
0.0148827666,
0.0501047894,
-0.0527256429,
0.0269715935,
-0.0599577613,
0.0041101533,
-0.0334252603,
-0.002367717,
0.0536924042,
-0.06438642,
-0.0083637424,
0.0088934628,
0.0265939217,
-0.0220686551,
-0.0028376633,
0.0532156974,
0.0113710137,
-0.0419095643,
-0.0365842171,
-0.0738585144,
-0.0321330428,
-0.0722076967,
-0.0068617505,
-0.0399101898,
0.0390932336,
-0.024292592,
-0.0195798632,
-0.0279634818,
0.0223967992,
0.0480689071,
0.0067067514,
0.0255695842,
-0.006178984,
-0.0080980528,
0.0039305422,
-0.0006552052,
0.0335471556,
0.0332887061,
0.0265904535,
0.03902141,
0.0310765617,
0.0331817828,
-0.0038360299,
0.0106836008,
0.0308524948,
-0.0104592443,
-0.0292855427,
0.0098619051,
-0.0360835753,
0.0136277694,
0.0093905833,
0.0740852728,
-0.0541531965,
0.006591625,
0.0065141916,
-0.0137395654,
0.0483918451,
0.0180403441,
0.0955321267,
0.0141805531,
0.0036603052,
0.003621154,
0.0020870541,
0.0134561267,
-0.0465248376,
0.0501185097,
0.0697716549,
0.0523576476,
-0.0069723269,
-0.0511991493,
-0.0225335266,
-0.0058242641,
-0.0063319639,
-0.025355367,
0.0515428074,
0.0640935674,
-0.0575597286,
0.0163394492,
0.0174516309,
-0.0793883651,
0.0079530533,
-0.0266435444,
0.0200368259,
0.0843496025,
0.1197406054,
0.0131476345,
-0.0130726537,
0.029099118,
-0.046065744,
0.0479569808,
0.0058007766,
-0.0068214536,
0.0090517011,
-0.0492925085,
-0.0301028546,
-0.0281108078,
0.0123081272,
0.0389770418,
0.0584218204,
0.0072920374,
0.0585412793,
-0.0406920873,
-0.0115167862,
0.0417500697,
-0.0411442518,
-0.0227962621,
0.0203069206,
-0.0017959344,
0.0151334312,
0.0437982306,
-0.0235520657,
0.0305777751,
0.0496702418,
-0.0273675732,
-0.0210064072,
0.0487394556,
-0.046510525,
-0.0496492162,
-0.0054281522,
-0.0382206105,
0.0195432715,
0.0172192771,
-0.0244922657,
-0.0547704138,
0.0315325409,
-0.049895972,
0.0292775892,
-0.1054543778,
-0.0119858738,
0.0595371835,
0.025092138,
-0.0391863845,
0.0824593827,
-0.0202303454,
0.0190478042,
0.0377665013,
0.0334976017,
0.0363666005,
-0.0659944564,
-0.0035721408,
-0.0090372106,
-0.0056438302,
0.0027563395,
0.0506546386,
-0.0095224343,
-0.0572714359,
-0.0066292579,
-0.0422913246,
0.0038700406,
-0.0113875242,
-0.0074514481,
0.0413755961,
0.022615483,
-0.007564282,
-0.0178160649,
-0.0207239538,
-0.0051471586,
0.0545553789,
0.0056342497,
0.0322592594,
0.0323004238,
-0.0145606045,
-0.0464176163,
0.0016106842,
0.016071545,
0.043660596,
0.020521909,
0.0324237272,
-0.0345173664,
0.0150872404,
-0.0801450089,
0.0043253591,
0.0028150396,
-0.007511456,
0.0197131131,
-0.0168477055,
0.059837658,
-0.0343514197,
0.0178159159,
-0.0083954539,
0.0240136161,
-0.0296547282,
-0.0612106062,
0.0113358917,
-0.0614090189,
-0.0248496924,
0.0337746479,
-0.0190367196,
0.0144615462,
0.0300689936,
0.0313295461,
-0.035234604,
-0.0365139805,
0.0291657597,
0.0010677681,
-0.0554032773,
-0.0202149935,
-0.0349131525,
-0.0134641854,
0.0366757959,
-0.0264801364,
-0.067836687,
0.0644714907,
-0.0491936058,
0.0160875842,
-0.0432917327,
0.0260725599,
-0.0341820717,
0.0389582291,
-0.0027617242,
0.0316454843,
-0.0145033291,
-0.0003459576,
0.0013284551,
0.0014451778,
0.0248441733,
-0.0553142726,
0.0230205059,
-0.0222944543,
0.0184401777,
0.0291635562,
0.005739748,
-0.0731515288,
-0.0181420706,
0.0545310415,
0.0097317202,
0.0037774325,
-0.0143371513,
-0.0337886848,
-0.0145938583,
0.034943942,
-0.001351673,
0.0154418675,
-0.0325692222,
-0.0076603913,
0.0457538888,
0.0469308347,
-0.0167458504,
-0.0039960663,
0.0337101482,
-0.0317863598,
0.0305763446,
0.0474855788,
-0.0114138266,
-0.0214780234,
-0.0047687283,
0.013422546,
-0.0120451013,
0.0112082046,
0.0188165754,
0.0087980712,
-0.0316095687,
-0.0529071577,
0.0573966503,
0.0486452654,
0.0185722075,
0.003438829,
0.0088898307,
0.0371509306,
0.0262661893,
0.0307255257,
-0.075371474,
-0.0112806791,
-0.0109761786,
0.0443897806,
-0.0295338985,
-0.0214701034,
-0.0339728631,
-0.146032989,
0.0373321213,
0.0109630832,
0.0029866004,
-0.0061848513,
-0.0333520547,
0.0131315943,
0.0026322771,
-0.0203815103,
0.0241281409,
0.0160751492,
0.0368258394,
-0.0041439966,
-0.0029051765,
-0.0554658286,
-0.0079553509,
-0.0135239195,
-0.0058433507,
0.1174488589,
0.0131218787,
0.035462793,
-0.0419197492,
-0.0207063071,
-0.022192983,
0.0160958916,
0.0015193468,
0.0276843458,
-0.0092984643,
0.0124744223,
-0.021616064,
-0.0045101875,
0.0002314908,
-0.0099835237,
-0.028885005,
0.0369234569,
-0.0162139572,
0.049445048,
-0.0759272426,
-0.0004466668,
0.0268514436,
0.0705799013,
0.021305088,
0.0118793668,
-0.005532281,
-0.001554903,
0.0285892729,
-0.0877273902,
-0.0181803368,
0.0145588974,
-0.003534521,
-0.0323888548,
-0.123288855,
-0.062460538,
-0.0496965051,
0.0299767219,
-0.0201251656,
-0.0178041402,
-0.0477185808,
-0.0117150955,
-0.0625570565,
0.0175780244,
-0.0082486589,
-0.0168620702,
0.0034104914,
-0.0452342555,
0.0374259017,
-0.0485036522,
-0.0088840378,
0.0582878888,
-0.0274665486,
-0.0461737625,
0.0043894169,
0.029880641,
0.0245005134,
0.0368793234,
-0.0350324288,
0.007527269,
0.0367702395,
0.0430980511,
-0.0314913206,
0.0220768061,
-0.0182725322,
0.0092421742,
-0.0086780181,
0.0108572636,
-0.0620892905,
0.0244959109,
-0.019206604,
0.0982559547,
0.036166314,
-0.0272158422,
0.0580394454,
0.0250881296,
0.0309210625,
-0.0579355434,
-0.0192202646,
-0.0284540337,
-0.0188597646,
-0.0410065241,
-0.0238213316,
-0.0440227352,
0.0255368669,
0.0382008292,
-0.0091546755,
-0.0024318288,
0.0232077576,
-0.0468821265,
0.0785999522,
-0.0167458504,
-0.0572243892,
0.0129735013,
0.0002041716,
-0.0185917839,
0.013807497,
-0.0160535797,
0.0195542295,
-0.0338388532,
0.0380256549,
-0.0424482971,
0.0250955429,
-0.0004630577,
-0.0101051768,
0.0098823849,
0.0347093008,
-0.0533288307,
0.0361709297,
-0.0672691688,
0.0249821618,
0.0324942656,
0.0139721921,
0.0749343932,
0.0002289088,
-0.0010885079,
-0.0067413789,
0.01590381,
0.0172026139,
-0.0659355894,
-0.0131113781,
0.0241558943,
-0.0169594605,
0.0206592083,
0.0536824241,
-0.0346143693,
0.0528686903,
-0.0749832243,
-0.0223710705,
-0.0596882142,
-0.0301199276,
-0.0232350547,
0.0112162158,
-0.0062840213,
0.0038389144,
-0.0647763163,
-0.0515998639,
0.0126503129,
0.0199359711,
0.0289627928,
0.0158283822,
0.0683870167,
0.077420719,
0.006175926,
0.0133258421,
-0.0374252722,
-0.0150691019,
-0.0698180124,
0.0104010012,
-0.030302614,
-5.928381312e-33,
-0.0510766916,
-0.011136828,
0.0326139592,
-0.0965703651,
-0.0409943126,
-0.007233981,
-0.0413210839,
-0.0270522088,
-0.0048969002,
-0.0244216993,
0.0117649427,
-0.0086674197,
0.0124189248,
0.0278307833,
-0.0196354948,
0.0329696536,
0.0200964231,
0.0329928361,
-0.0521274842,
0.0299454276,
0.0827777237,
0.0294189379,
0.0416792184,
-0.0401813798,
0.0157300849,
0.0003919701,
-0.0378201306,
-0.0012464934,
0.0017963334,
0.0947985277,
-0.0272848513,
0.0570813492,
0.0013803325,
-0.0115882065,
-0.0090545816,
-0.0212541316,
-0.0663932934,
-0.0170514025,
-0.010783677,
-0.0401060842,
-0.0734390616,
0.0025074445,
0.0286967307,
-0.0545695797,
-0.0200151,
0.0213085972,
0.027357962,
-0.055320248,
-0.0106839389,
-0.0562907681,
-0.0666397288,
0.0183021743,
-0.0027744323,
-0.0137047134,
-0.0404966585,
0.0624762923,
0.0243489891,
0.0171965249,
-0.0514677055,
0.0500379652,
-0.003946851,
0.0627942681,
0.0542928353,
-0.0111398324,
0.0031268005,
0.0506784432,
0.0140113579,
-0.045315221,
-0.0211114231,
-0.0133903297,
0.004875944,
0.0583066717,
0.0102025801,
0.0905677974,
0.0509796888,
0.0056983368,
-0.0372639522,
0.0708160698,
0.0041246605,
0.0490013398,
-0.0043428782,
-0.012933353,
-0.0424251817,
0.0121946586,
-0.0283418428,
0.037221089,
-0.0203361362,
-0.0575732663,
0.0637494996,
0.0590776578,
-0.0324766822,
0.0199902449,
0.0115389526,
-0.0203086976,
0.0453522578,
0.0349000432,
-0.0489989333,
-0.0249266084,
-0.0076639918,
-0.0034597064,
-0.0298270304,
-0.0069250865,
0.0730469972,
0.019917015,
-0.0353037976,
-0.0265498813,
0.0207241513,
0.0480926149,
-0.0398824923,
0.036575038,
-0.0419043526,
0.0551503859,
-0.038198065,
-0.0555011295,
0.0180564467,
0.0190606434,
-0.0409908965,
0.0280905571,
0.0425756164,
0.0347221345,
-0.0015546973,
-0.0218252186,
0.0304803587,
0.0285314005,
-0.0330389701,
0.0548488796,
-0.0026543515,
0.0097274948,
0.0147424238,
-0.0116264308,
-0.0078265499,
0.0299854595,
2.532e-7,
0.030964952,
-0.0177556705,
0.0844778121,
0.0089807166,
-0.0190205108,
-0.0341882706,
-0.0133412182,
0.0224104803,
-0.0044430057,
-0.0070291534,
-0.0206159409,
0.0108727282,
0.024251353,
0.0156439729,
-0.0371207111,
0.0156321637,
-0.0518047139,
-0.0255765002,
-0.0317945257,
-0.0036595,
0.0678054839,
0.0250764769,
-0.0081856316,
-0.0145485522,
-0.007583871,
-0.0506956764,
0.0775729716,
0.0301107485,
-0.0263252184,
0.0075757876,
0.0509977564,
0.0448774807,
0.0056384383,
-0.0494779646,
-0.0215914268,
0.0322103649,
0.0031426712,
-0.0134817455,
0.0071440106,
-0.0790961087,
0.0114499098,
-0.000261779,
0.0049679521,
-0.0162135717,
0.0377617814,
-0.0131892292,
0.0035418018,
-0.0007086168,
-0.0477777682,
0.0325641334,
0.0151873287,
-0.0224601887,
-0.0495939925,
-0.0006173793,
0.0177575964,
0.0422521047,
-0.0222066492,
-0.0780521855,
-0.0130345672,
-0.0200395174,
-0.0488527007,
-0.0410545729,
-0.0208185147,
0.0062745991,
-0.0184002798,
-0.061159499,
-0.0287595652,
2.343605357e-34,
0.0337268226,
0.0270992871,
-0.0109085748,
-0.0159875378,
0.0318980552,
-0.0106627988,
-0.043468751,
0.0008547236,
-0.0157014318,
-0.0569978133,
-0.0411614887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08032v1
|
Exploring the Potential of Conversational AI Support for Agent-Based Social Simulation Model Design
| 2024-05-12T22:11:54 | 2024-05-12T22:11:54 |
Peer-Olaf Siebers
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
ChatGPT, the AI-powered chatbot with a massive user base of hundreds of
millions, has become a global phenomenon. However, the use of Conversational AI
Systems (CAISs) like ChatGPT for research in the field of Social Simulation is
still limited. Specifically, there is no evidence of its usage in Agent-Based
Social Simulation (ABSS) model design. While scepticism towards anything new is
inherent to human nature, we firmly believe it is imperative to initiate the
use of this innovative technology to support ABSS model design. This paper
presents a proof-of-concept that demonstrates how CAISs can facilitate the
development of innovative conceptual ABSS models in a concise timeframe and
with minimal required upfront case-based knowledge. By employing advanced
prompt engineering techniques and adhering to the Engineering ABSS framework,
we have constructed a comprehensive prompt script that enables the design of
ABSS models with or by the CAIS. The effectiveness of the script is
demonstrated through an illustrative case study concerning the use of adaptive
architecture in museums. Despite occasional inaccuracies and divergences in
conversation, the CAIS proved to be a valuable companion for ABSS modellers.
|
[
0.037232466,
0.0108132176,
-0.0486416109,
0.0126069486,
-0.0283789784,
-0.031735532,
0.0423507243,
-0.0347548835,
0.0655312166,
0.0165209547,
-0.0095901666,
-0.0330452956,
0.0030163932,
0.0543491691,
-0.0057310686,
-0.0005822558,
0.0198467448,
-0.0211279951,
-0.0045643831,
-0.0044889948,
0.0106974281,
0.0027761564,
-0.0274746381,
0.0544511788,
-0.0276873168,
0.0000056812,
-0.0903541818,
0.0170809068,
0.0205180421,
-0.0232892595,
-0.0048373789,
0.0451099426,
0.0614569336,
0.0403751396,
0.0000025497,
-0.0494915433,
-0.0211042985,
-0.0004467106,
-0.0464386828,
-0.0121053671,
0.0867703557,
0.1055065617,
-0.0145447636,
-0.0137102939,
-0.0383752584,
0.0306158233,
0.0650817901,
-0.0095142145,
0.0172163881,
0.0103053469,
-0.0150930136,
-0.0098158801,
0.0112427147,
0.0118761742,
-0.0195044726,
-0.0543940887,
0.0169313308,
0.0348644145,
0.1065100953,
-0.0178452525,
0.0105521372,
0.0292045083,
0.0222149231,
-0.0171713047,
0.0180210732,
0.0284826793,
-0.012810722,
-0.0390895307,
-0.0312581956,
0.0616432466,
0.110200651,
0.0043930081,
0.031269718,
0.0099112801,
0.0356559344,
0.0289772376,
-0.0485350788,
0.0030289728,
-0.0068539986,
-0.0203166511,
-0.0281603299,
0.0301682819,
-0.0109974761,
0.0095926467,
0.0201638695,
-0.0078251138,
-0.0019488904,
0.0029648663,
-0.0536998026,
-0.0403434969,
0.0039579626,
-0.0535748899,
-0.0007257545,
0.0602500737,
-0.0898295492,
0.004408055,
0.0396096297,
0.0383635461,
-0.0042822459,
-0.0194839276,
0.0364194475,
0.0319143273,
0.001875531,
0.0100245066,
0.078742899,
0.0385848992,
0.0054897615,
-0.0117423907,
0.0207775328,
0.0524129942,
-0.0706317276,
-0.0029312158,
-0.0466277637,
0.0068155145,
-0.0565728955,
-0.037037883,
0.0234607346,
0.051173199,
-0.0417067595,
0.0136734499,
-0.0228796434,
0.0337918252,
-0.0154230669,
0.0046772263,
-0.0265074037,
-0.0501118042,
-0.039983388,
0.0021713339,
0.0063266782,
-0.082642056,
0.0324302539,
0.0076453439,
0.0192044768,
0.0288732871,
-0.0395237803,
0.0544019639,
-0.0035563414,
-0.0151538076,
0.0091871684,
-0.0413316749,
0.0385004394,
-0.0333371945,
0.0191315636,
-0.0274566095,
0.0476756506,
-0.0112812463,
-0.0154809412,
-0.019601183,
0.0075546112,
-0.015421588,
0.004336297,
0.0458970889,
-0.0327958167,
0.0318470486,
0.030519139,
0.0317918546,
-0.0202629603,
0.0273909215,
0.0234754551,
0.008900471,
0.0273805801,
0.0340795107,
0.0699605942,
0.0395028405,
-0.0027402646,
0.0173338298,
0.0474130325,
0.0132974628,
0.0013071924,
0.017713353,
-0.0551207401,
-0.0075434959,
-0.0201382432,
0.0010042455,
0.0577246957,
0.0017860844,
-0.0498526804,
0.0469521284,
0.0327789038,
0.0480696112,
0.012159111,
-0.0183125455,
-0.0123995626,
0.0268773213,
-0.0137973549,
-0.014413028,
-0.0438178256,
0.0274558589,
-0.0290983543,
-0.0216087569,
0.0611559674,
-0.0302423388,
0.0595331192,
-0.0042531206,
-0.0066841664,
-0.0018545144,
-0.0216017999,
-0.0618218519,
-0.0126817413,
-0.0232685097,
-0.039993491,
-0.0946838707,
0.0277940221,
0.1156611964,
0.0725571662,
-0.0423194766,
0.0087174727,
0.0023911358,
0.0052361675,
0.0528899804,
0.0834990293,
-0.0277531222,
-0.0269857831,
-0.0114533277,
-0.0127967205,
-0.0313701481,
0.0018315429,
0.0417694226,
-0.0183859766,
-0.0149498098,
-0.0207809675,
0.0599029846,
-0.0232089479,
0.0102700451,
-0.0826007351,
0.0052344259,
-0.0691384673,
-0.0092627779,
0.017705828,
0.0628559813,
-0.0346878916,
0.0033116175,
0.0028125814,
0.0359870195,
-0.0232105963,
0.0597152486,
-0.0185287613,
0.0208875425,
0.0130822761,
0.0139384028,
-0.0046248906,
0.0081235291,
0.0031959813,
-0.0043168706,
0.0308180097,
-0.0146564711,
0.0771840438,
0.0107700583,
0.038100224,
-0.0331565849,
-0.0008544733,
-0.0130884349,
-0.003555041,
0.0240605604,
-0.0403973833,
0.0327427164,
0.0110902973,
0.0303550195,
-0.0388606191,
-0.0168001968,
-0.0159139615,
0.0073655606,
0.0170345474,
0.0267529525,
0.0011197253,
-0.0296038631,
0.0468332246,
-0.115600206,
-0.0320378169,
0.0191874634,
-0.0505583286,
-0.0003372617,
0.0002255002,
-0.0253886115,
0.0169703569,
0.0030382259,
0.0523055084,
-0.0203558579,
0.0181726255,
0.0316926651,
-0.0015020114,
-0.1012786478,
-0.0508116968,
0.0299229082,
-0.0119702788,
-0.0017844192,
0.0914125293,
-0.0076607955,
-0.0293225124,
0.0045193308,
-0.0235738046,
0.0034276452,
-0.0054220567,
-0.0568957217,
0.0398118086,
0.0013128062,
0.0181476623,
-0.0172050279,
-0.022642944,
0.0684147403,
0.0131556904,
-0.0641102865,
-0.0457339324,
0.0100980708,
-0.0308535937,
0.0278900303,
-0.0168812443,
-0.0436561294,
0.0010804493,
-0.0146878166,
-0.0065074051,
0.0368997976,
-0.0196463596,
0.0376469493,
0.0280386675,
-0.0450807251,
0.0238991883,
-0.0316641368,
-0.012849411,
0.0581841916,
-0.0054254457,
0.0142795984,
0.0158403534,
-0.0241207797,
-0.0031248515,
0.0103686042,
-0.0151444972,
-0.0088706398,
0.0289014,
-0.0031638078,
0.0082013197,
0.0328873433,
0.0376438126,
-0.0408276841,
-0.0378841981,
-0.03377432,
-0.0218843874,
-0.0605585016,
-0.0319713578,
-0.0237390716,
0.0379889756,
-0.0340228938,
-0.0328346156,
-0.0142618557,
-0.0407159887,
0.0362814851,
0.0060732779,
-0.0305520054,
-0.0363441259,
0.0157264639,
0.0309945103,
0.0069613387,
0.0042358018,
-0.0224515349,
-0.0464147702,
-0.0093372324,
0.0239870455,
0.0668684468,
0.0013157799,
-0.0015097203,
0.0117678912,
-0.0049763252,
-0.0210884511,
-0.0209637471,
-0.0614597872,
-0.0336663537,
-0.0022370077,
0.0289071407,
0.0014643143,
0.0324977636,
0.0265854206,
-0.0124153411,
-0.0127142323,
0.0569049828,
0.0182160493,
-0.000671712,
0.0306681078,
-0.0455753468,
0.0217318386,
-0.0082903896,
0.0139577845,
-0.047380697,
0.0267590843,
0.032061018,
0.0153044378,
-0.0477165468,
-0.0524186492,
0.0270555019,
-0.0671218559,
0.0812774375,
-0.0159435775,
-0.0688249469,
-0.0030143,
-0.0212279782,
0.0419243574,
-0.0021773709,
-0.0272269379,
0.0163892731,
0.0365612656,
-0.0180394277,
-0.0006131958,
-0.0786734894,
-0.0029244761,
0.0184520595,
-0.0299093015,
0.1371788979,
0.0439100601,
0.0611359663,
0.0230180472,
-0.01913145,
-0.0140413549,
0.0743947774,
0.0548682585,
0.005103779,
0.018300727,
0.0235876441,
0.0226279292,
-0.0225608703,
-0.0057559428,
-0.0421547182,
-0.0324178152,
0.0554192588,
0.0341684483,
-0.0388869606,
0.000655117,
-0.0707529038,
0.0258056801,
0.0717690215,
0.0291328225,
0.0259570815,
-0.0249195602,
-0.0350459218,
-0.027151173,
-0.0172573216,
0.0038413666,
-0.0043592481,
-0.0354201943,
-0.0491339415,
-0.0540851168,
-0.0310022663,
-0.0494989753,
-0.0083996663,
0.0092714364,
0.0098879002,
-0.0774368569,
0.0403159596,
0.0242464785,
0.0265438892,
-0.0485056899,
-0.0503690802,
0.0275093261,
0.0287767407,
-0.0177747887,
0.0108682252,
-0.0586725809,
0.0011045495,
-0.0194520038,
0.0503681302,
-0.0429776758,
0.0721389651,
0.0548394881,
0.0343092047,
0.0135997422,
-0.0013074061,
-0.006250666,
-0.0050495379,
0.0054332968,
-0.0298866946,
-0.0042099725,
0.0083071953,
0.0431733578,
-0.0083978875,
-0.0145941069,
0.004966931,
0.0332963504,
-0.0297345147,
0.0380209126,
-0.0384734124,
-0.0329075195,
-0.007153295,
0.0543161854,
-0.0351427831,
0.0114904707,
-0.0467629023,
0.0142458566,
0.0068364157,
-0.0531742759,
0.0118300235,
-0.0076322756,
-0.0266887303,
-0.0590255819,
-0.0003803328,
0.0498837903,
-0.0204925109,
-0.0438141897,
0.0313514732,
0.0179871321,
0.0093097882,
0.0387091301,
0.0212180354,
0.0101250382,
-0.0022748844,
0.0189341381,
0.058022704,
-0.0152622974,
0.0394674577,
0.0254335739,
0.0351407528,
0.0280519091,
-0.044456359,
0.0043287273,
0.0489476025,
-0.0085671721,
-0.0909084827,
-0.01324875,
0.1059927046,
-0.0212677047,
0.0533559099,
-0.0132591557,
-0.0511435866,
0.0302255508,
-0.0184706803,
-0.0030853837,
0.0419069529,
-0.0534571037,
-0.0352561437,
0.0281851385,
-0.0295053814,
-0.0053492151,
-0.002305561,
-0.0460001826,
0.0209068432,
-0.0538576767,
-0.0572428182,
-0.0313750021,
-0.0119035896,
0.0394382216,
0.0164264925,
0.0060227122,
-0.0180989206,
-0.0799047649,
-0.0284189936,
-0.0356731825,
0.0442451909,
-0.0122768786,
-0.0447183624,
0.050883621,
0.0320693105,
-0.0097023416,
-0.0116367191,
0.0020426023,
0.0090525318,
-0.0918546617,
0.0039831479,
-0.0367942788,
-6.490063737e-33,
-0.0190363508,
-0.038098786,
0.0900851041,
0.0386677496,
-0.0265538357,
-0.0559888966,
-0.0501581393,
-0.0017962697,
-0.0115457447,
0.00402309,
-0.0337578021,
-0.0173786879,
0.0071617528,
-0.0340660326,
0.020464126,
-0.0099077458,
0.0503810234,
-0.0110789854,
-0.0407875814,
0.0089019137,
-0.0073151705,
-0.0305526964,
-0.0543420985,
-0.1052408516,
0.007551678,
-0.0506382883,
-0.0103459517,
-0.0053708502,
0.0194254778,
-0.0078786835,
-0.0212692022,
0.0407931246,
0.0186255984,
-0.0002727898,
0.0147011224,
0.0523061976,
-0.0247472748,
-0.0190830417,
0.0217896421,
-0.007335945,
0.0013310196,
-0.0051231161,
-0.0492938645,
-0.0003933042,
-0.0642334521,
0.0499032885,
0.0224096756,
-0.0145774474,
0.0366180576,
0.0536685437,
-0.10057991,
0.0066501666,
-0.0361908078,
-0.0423030704,
0.006272471,
0.0433449894,
0.0085785585,
-0.0208065175,
-0.0248850994,
0.0330789275,
0.0091193281,
-0.0752594694,
0.029682586,
-0.0086983182,
0.0170798935,
-0.0025173847,
0.0502966456,
0.0741175339,
-0.0317253731,
-0.0306124017,
-0.0121502336,
0.0825134143,
0.0054638693,
0.0436831228,
-0.0740542114,
-0.0103252158,
0.004114192,
0.0228315219,
0.0782997534,
0.0062963646,
0.023920618,
0.0410927534,
-0.0700490996,
0.0033437344,
0.0133792935,
0.0056297104,
-0.0132125039,
-0.0459990837,
-0.0081010172,
0.0003254472,
-0.0082138283,
-0.0061018877,
0.0085565709,
-0.0376915336,
-0.0055565261,
-0.0379308723,
0.0020258939,
0.0034348927,
-0.0069934842,
-0.0132881869,
-0.031499289,
-0.0465211757,
0.0180238858,
0.0395329371,
0.0386740789,
0.0450202078,
-0.0500677153,
0.0526829995,
0.0373792648,
-0.0058151591,
0.0008138158,
0.01831403,
0.0362121761,
-0.0870995447,
-0.012980992,
0.0092496416,
-0.0227657668,
-0.0061748656,
0.0160450879,
0.0159580633,
0.0062067448,
0.0142095862,
-0.0437551811,
-0.0234971438,
-0.0210491773,
-0.0213222615,
-0.0426535383,
-0.0158619974,
0.011743105,
-0.0394338928,
-0.0315911658,
-0.0527039655,
3.314e-7,
-0.0451476313,
0.0509774312,
0.0152521171,
0.0323681496,
0.038710665,
0.0410351232,
0.0113762133,
0.0391166806,
-0.004353703,
-0.0325532816,
0.0350150466,
0.0392957814,
0.0131209046,
0.0044050422,
-0.0425780825,
-0.0366050825,
-0.037023697,
-0.0070546954,
-0.0716194138,
0.0077752247,
0.0442813337,
-0.0331426077,
0.0345095918,
0.003920923,
-0.0094678216,
-0.0096702734,
-0.0487471819,
-0.0428998247,
-0.001178352,
0.0439202115,
-0.0064979061,
-0.0230260454,
0.0063883057,
-0.001064292,
0.0203625392,
0.0118087558,
-0.0208908506,
0.0179403722,
-0.0019829376,
-0.0243102703,
0.0542894118,
-0.0484980345,
0.0010988815,
-0.0552649759,
0.0367901549,
-0.0506034642,
-0.0155098122,
-0.0144085782,
-0.0440357924,
-0.0065642749,
-0.0240567178,
-0.0019907455,
-0.0029532788,
-0.0151822474,
-0.0477536246,
-0.005893751,
0.0286762211,
-0.0192243028,
0.0662408844,
-0.0375726335,
-0.0490764566,
-0.0815196857,
-0.0094290003,
-0.02103783,
-0.0086688623,
-0.0281992275,
0.0487379916,
2.681006215e-34,
0.0432753228,
0.0141951563,
-0.0072395648,
0.05763622,
0.0697649196,
0.0199354663,
-0.0038539327,
0.025463948,
0.0611682832,
-0.0303727426,
-0.0308907535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13005v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13005v1
|
Understanding the Rare Inflammatory Disease Using Large Language Models and Social Media Data
| 2024-05-12T20:54:23 | 2024-05-12T20:54:23 |
Nan Miles Xi, Hong-Long Ji, Lin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SI
|
Sarcoidosis is a rare inflammatory disease characterized by the formation of
granulomas in various organs. The disease presents diagnostic and treatment
challenges due to its diverse manifestations and unpredictable nature. In this
study, we employed a Large Language Model (LLM) to analyze sarcoidosis-related
discussions on the social media platform Reddit. Our findings underscore the
efficacy of LLMs in accurately identifying sarcoidosis-related content. We
discovered a wide array of symptoms reported by patients, with fatigue, swollen
lymph nodes, and shortness of breath as the most prevalent. Prednisone was the
most prescribed medication, while infliximab showed the highest effectiveness
in improving prognoses. Notably, our analysis revealed disparities in prognosis
based on age and gender, with women and younger patients experiencing good and
polarized outcomes, respectively. Furthermore, unsupervised clustering
identified three distinct patient subgroups (phenotypes) with unique symptom
profiles, prognostic outcomes, and demographic distributions. Finally,
sentiment analysis revealed a moderate negative impact on patients' mental
health post-diagnosis, particularly among women and younger individuals. Our
study represents the first application of LLMs to understand sarcoidosis
through social media data. It contributes to understanding the disease by
providing data-driven insights into its manifestations, treatments, prognoses,
and impact on patients' lives. Our findings have direct implications for
improving personalized treatment strategies and enhancing the quality of care
for individuals living with sarcoidosis.
|
[
0.0426138304,
0.0848726332,
-0.0011354251,
-0.0036336447,
0.0256739538,
0.0136764124,
-0.0119098425,
0.0208654962,
0.0345554613,
-0.0322365724,
0.0144220358,
-0.0063017169,
0.0016466858,
0.0213303268,
-0.0042084064,
-0.0271871723,
-0.009808708,
0.0389978588,
0.0349768996,
-0.0003045502,
0.0415417701,
0.0123344418,
0.0040516746,
0.0138078304,
0.0268965568,
-0.0196223464,
0.0778197721,
-0.031897001,
0.040694166,
-0.0586357526,
0.0178172179,
0.0215627924,
-0.013254053,
0.020024268,
0.0000019531,
-0.04103994,
-0.0053310543,
-0.0003666434,
0.0336040631,
-0.0097889621,
0.0744075328,
-0.0334685743,
0.0355190895,
0.0173635837,
-0.0456986278,
-0.0361625478,
0.0345308147,
0.0650508031,
0.029487798,
0.0207681675,
-0.0302808173,
-0.0470889248,
-0.0203697905,
-0.0145664727,
0.0085614389,
0.0213698987,
0.0273414496,
-0.0152218742,
0.0424019322,
-0.0407696515,
0.021144757,
0.0624098442,
-0.0615929589,
-0.0204844382,
-0.0041042762,
0.0305841938,
-0.0301354472,
-0.0274971798,
0.0260176621,
0.0552129708,
0.0262595043,
0.0008695954,
0.0373801775,
-0.0056303367,
-0.007282889,
0.0515309945,
-0.0311503001,
-0.0185073167,
0.0177582912,
0.0402558334,
-0.0058326968,
0.0124116642,
0.0348862298,
-0.0066258195,
0.0333078094,
0.0203628205,
-0.0333837867,
0.0111637879,
-0.0215532128,
0.0062170965,
-0.0292057693,
-0.0487765595,
0.0391306169,
0.012321637,
-0.0250546541,
0.0208661333,
0.0265122782,
-0.0375430025,
0.0677489862,
-0.1109204814,
-0.0300992746,
-0.0151584679,
0.0526132621,
0.0333274268,
0.0433518514,
-0.0754667744,
-0.0163543522,
0.0049976944,
-0.0169957448,
0.0079551246,
-0.0591527186,
-0.0037900358,
0.0129178176,
0.0164489448,
0.0225458946,
0.0075034737,
-0.0732740238,
0.0030332364,
-0.023713002,
-0.0286047366,
0.0223712493,
0.0179212932,
0.0445238538,
0.0115008308,
-0.0051535778,
0.013688772,
-0.0300891809,
0.0381433852,
-0.0131912092,
-0.0150290597,
0.0622721426,
-0.010514929,
0.031236019,
-0.0009574714,
0.0213418752,
0.0275050271,
0.0284017175,
-0.0078971544,
0.0101041477,
-0.0087547591,
-0.0457959324,
-0.0477630235,
-0.0218663309,
-0.0982490033,
0.0543208756,
0.0703560933,
0.0072353389,
-0.0255264025,
-0.0262283105,
-0.0142442361,
-0.091558978,
0.0271432474,
-0.0699352846,
0.0274471175,
0.0322770663,
0.0208279714,
0.0395048782,
0.0108368257,
0.0050183311,
-0.0275528636,
0.0360675491,
-0.0149795571,
0.0215767119,
0.022213079,
0.0160508845,
0.0188893899,
-0.0110589061,
0.0456561819,
-0.0254077576,
0.0080783302,
-0.0521921776,
0.0516405478,
0.0020708402,
-0.0114126885,
0.0425341576,
0.105024673,
-0.0092022624,
0.0124910856,
-0.0657143965,
0.0231306236,
-0.0092763435,
-0.061805293,
0.0467554107,
-0.0121824201,
0.0026973232,
-0.0011100278,
0.0536824204,
-0.0056329812,
-0.0221122634,
-0.0389287695,
-0.0797502548,
-0.0187796615,
0.0064781127,
-0.0007082838,
-0.0030631397,
-0.0479234345,
0.0352236517,
0.018671535,
0.0604151823,
-0.0151358489,
-0.0084004318,
-0.0308122374,
-0.017382266,
0.0744362026,
0.0106382119,
-0.0084185647,
-0.0372705087,
-0.0128147416,
0.0146339471,
-0.010747171,
0.0086593796,
0.0008289161,
-0.0501969643,
0.0043560262,
0.0060749264,
0.0500695631,
0.0233495533,
-0.0530795306,
-0.0024006185,
0.0043471986,
-0.0681561977,
-0.0172742344,
-0.0017534285,
0.0148893753,
-0.0114679104,
-0.0313731991,
-0.0109150819,
-0.0259954948,
0.060373459,
0.0175110027,
-0.0004737171,
0.0143457716,
0.0141447652,
-0.0259018671,
-0.0822984651,
0.0362731591,
-0.0067150299,
-0.024655696,
0.0042728479,
-0.0408556797,
-0.0533237197,
-0.0015171706,
-0.0307563264,
0.0076178545,
0.0823965445,
-0.0539778247,
0.0148551026,
0.0478130616,
-0.0309394151,
0.0128638297,
-0.0005385213,
-0.0035712633,
0.0015160446,
-0.0340843834,
0.0158001464,
-0.0188041888,
-0.0737117678,
-0.0122451289,
-0.0385350883,
-0.030079715,
-0.0108458949,
0.0136584695,
0.0299936179,
0.0247556139,
-0.0544585101,
0.0110544711,
0.009516147,
-0.1137168184,
-0.0005290249,
0.0094282664,
0.0108840335,
0.0288151409,
0.0209344812,
-0.0215165261,
-0.0422324762,
-0.0572929904,
-0.0107799275,
0.0440261997,
0.0314834788,
0.0337332934,
0.0132003939,
0.008687485,
-0.0917017907,
-0.024245793,
-0.0562029928,
0.0386935547,
0.0550903305,
-0.0401877835,
0.0525765866,
-0.0163568407,
-0.1083067283,
0.0036884127,
0.0063317055,
-0.0083467932,
-0.0164986383,
-0.0481593087,
-0.0131337289,
0.0162770133,
0.0118664205,
0.0467040762,
0.0307053123,
0.0250577144,
-0.0149529679,
-0.0263756253,
-0.0766405389,
-0.0274228305,
-0.0170584638,
-0.0577518828,
0.0173759144,
0.1022315696,
0.041294653,
0.0345498584,
-0.0194564722,
-0.0113788107,
-0.0627721995,
0.0120415147,
-0.0552856512,
0.0014084069,
-0.0103885746,
0.0350415446,
-0.0130003858,
-0.030590646,
0.0328197591,
0.0242477972,
0.0414989926,
-0.0607862882,
-0.0222288594,
-0.0099691944,
0.0187787004,
0.0263446979,
0.0271568093,
-0.0076806117,
0.0468330421,
0.0555908754,
-0.0480625965,
-0.0024242627,
-0.0564234704,
0.035456907,
-0.0055328952,
0.039740786,
0.0113123283,
-0.0118158739,
0.0230127983,
-0.0233971979,
-0.071285069,
-0.0356390588,
0.0257314872,
-0.0221443381,
-0.0352463759,
0.0140586533,
-0.0153861083,
0.0241897721,
0.0196873769,
-0.0372836813,
0.0358749069,
0.0007699129,
0.0522132069,
-0.0393500365,
0.0137708103,
-0.031267222,
0.0152475433,
0.0710479245,
-0.02743138,
-0.0079677869,
0.0066741342,
-0.0019825054,
0.0039354805,
0.0011910169,
0.010435625,
-0.0129810227,
0.0442818962,
-0.0187931824,
0.0039931731,
0.0809781924,
0.0292128082,
-0.0208401568,
0.0098985285,
-0.025634082,
-0.0316642113,
-0.0161866639,
-0.0033915143,
-0.0176811777,
-0.0268210098,
-0.0466723517,
0.0101126442,
-0.0146182841,
-0.0369920395,
0.0055800509,
0.0027905488,
0.0261455346,
-0.0064002769,
-0.0462514907,
0.0044708294,
-0.0469903126,
0.0030282112,
0.0030878759,
-0.0042691734,
-0.0503462106,
0.0274942555,
0.01421999,
0.0130320927,
-0.0873956755,
-0.0330641046,
0.0434776805,
0.0028031548,
0.0371805653,
0.0090616243,
0.0544338524,
-0.0035002786,
0.0011488098,
0.0098958891,
0.0659810081,
-0.0098175127,
0.0018031963,
0.08591903,
-0.0044560572,
0.0137233296,
-0.1175304428,
0.0179065708,
-0.0854339898,
0.0042415191,
-0.0340328775,
0.0797629729,
0.0030887087,
-0.052652739,
-0.0421787389,
0.0071905642,
0.0210132636,
0.0317655019,
0.0225608423,
0.0178650934,
-0.0214099679,
-0.0103730364,
0.043290399,
0.0133607462,
-0.0444904752,
-0.0123088807,
-0.0073712273,
-0.0517314896,
-0.0392771997,
-0.0181697942,
0.0352016427,
-0.0639012158,
0.0063385647,
0.0315639935,
0.046984259,
-0.0532819703,
-0.094236888,
0.037245173,
0.0452649891,
0.0323647335,
-0.0208452828,
-0.0501530096,
0.0676333681,
0.0534275696,
0.0207589436,
0.015948236,
-0.0429870896,
-0.0303728208,
0.0255486835,
-0.0437291861,
0.0230374672,
-0.0202778,
-0.0156898405,
-0.0377291292,
0.0512430929,
0.0641000196,
-0.0186626501,
-0.0067314571,
-0.0093838116,
0.0339566767,
0.0498733409,
0.0202175174,
-0.0146557866,
0.0309787132,
0.0389246568,
-0.026211923,
-0.0766003057,
-0.009763388,
-0.0083176726,
-0.0066066068,
0.0255511217,
-0.0122598559,
-0.0507308505,
-0.0327212363,
-0.0498380065,
-0.0033203287,
0.0274330713,
-0.007033274,
-0.055034183,
0.0001653274,
0.0194151234,
-0.062504895,
0.0587604046,
-0.0629446581,
0.01327933,
-0.0737769306,
0.0639356151,
0.02428657,
0.0009781513,
0.0501646437,
-0.0202617031,
0.0312709883,
-0.004187502,
-0.0213312376,
-0.0058727399,
0.0150233703,
0.0098063434,
0.0077555873,
0.007231046,
0.0432525463,
0.0296602435,
-0.0104481028,
-0.0411650352,
0.0142759802,
0.0105482852,
-0.0221342035,
-0.0219588354,
0.0749287158,
0.0005810403,
-0.0102475192,
-0.0222098343,
-0.0027205124,
-0.0494855195,
0.0058489349,
0.0408691168,
0.0120954411,
-0.0254412554,
0.0172367953,
0.0553141013,
-0.0376666598,
0.0022940272,
-0.01821745,
-0.057276044,
-0.0100832395,
0.0078458972,
0.014475734,
0.0076065338,
-0.0662782714,
0.016671041,
-0.0550026633,
-0.0607314743,
0.0002850777,
-0.0397620313,
-0.0158354286,
0.0007329651,
0.000629386,
0.0412239693,
0.0276893638,
0.0317953564,
-0.0685563162,
0.06591966,
-0.0567601472,
-0.039705161,
0.0156355314,
-6.19542167e-33,
0.0330769084,
-0.0593606271,
-0.0114260353,
-0.0060508689,
0.0338372588,
0.0416125022,
-0.0414111875,
0.0231056474,
0.0163818914,
0.0415878817,
0.020712778,
0.0170407854,
-0.0044468008,
0.0335496515,
0.0134819858,
-0.0163357332,
0.0314894207,
-0.0004807639,
-0.0131927617,
0.0101492936,
0.0161170755,
0.026127981,
-0.0030076841,
-0.0810359567,
0.0525127761,
-0.0148960156,
0.0528756566,
0.0107812732,
0.0594542399,
0.0566955283,
-0.0167387072,
0.0590473153,
0.0676882267,
0.0161051285,
-0.0044724173,
0.045815412,
-0.0318001434,
-0.0349047817,
-0.016472226,
0.0281936321,
-0.0056062979,
0.0231220108,
0.0348907746,
-0.0032875414,
-0.0109972656,
-0.0106385667,
0.0459656939,
-0.0031582164,
0.0220764205,
-0.0366036482,
-0.0200091507,
0.0405822918,
-0.0115152504,
0.0150145488,
-0.0302433185,
0.0100927865,
-0.0285087656,
0.0770541504,
-0.0355134457,
0.0421666689,
0.0035535463,
0.0051731225,
0.0241837911,
0.0046350271,
-0.0115966424,
0.061290931,
-0.000428556,
-0.0037951625,
-0.0556199737,
0.0356473774,
-0.0524299294,
0.0032332935,
0.0328200385,
0.0226459578,
-0.0090438444,
-0.0243502371,
-0.0598094687,
-0.014503357,
-0.0451843478,
-0.023877304,
0.0600034893,
0.0317597911,
-0.0270924717,
-0.0097458661,
-0.022938868,
0.0274760686,
-0.0102052139,
-0.0138272634,
-0.041867692,
-0.0088278549,
-0.0214038286,
0.0089642256,
0.0026059661,
-0.0139412899,
-0.0623895153,
-0.0352335982,
0.0368565544,
0.0208390169,
-0.0017710953,
0.0249985065,
-0.0311626755,
0.0267860722,
-0.0238842126,
-0.0227881279,
0.0195988379,
-0.0100780642,
0.0118313096,
-0.034680929,
-0.0459630899,
-0.0207278505,
0.0112131732,
0.0009132911,
-0.0203302819,
0.0311709251,
0.0133220078,
0.0381706692,
0.0026054347,
0.0911272392,
0.0411771908,
0.0334187187,
0.0126713514,
-0.021490017,
-0.0535916165,
-0.0422879681,
-0.0322786272,
-0.0227279123,
-0.0465680733,
0.0323770307,
0.0480305813,
-0.06841553,
0.008811105,
-0.032970719,
2.783e-7,
0.1206713095,
0.0814757273,
-0.0631906837,
-0.0359969251,
0.0583026707,
0.0233717747,
0.0078200353,
0.0004402686,
-0.0070182406,
-0.0156330001,
-0.0169184543,
0.0546965562,
-0.0029024028,
0.0585699193,
-0.005245938,
-0.009780651,
-0.0874629766,
-0.0043985033,
-0.017253859,
0.0231588706,
0.0324275121,
0.0959687233,
-0.0155444816,
-0.0264723562,
0.0042502498,
-0.0056040557,
0.0358096212,
-0.063754566,
-0.0337361619,
0.0241710935,
0.0272179339,
-0.034795288,
0.010331138,
0.0150298886,
-0.0224038195,
-0.0437852293,
-0.0257011969,
0.014701087,
0.003953957,
0.0032891834,
0.0233870782,
-0.0559177063,
0.0221931599,
-0.0284942053,
0.0287823956,
-0.0506435931,
-0.0681073964,
-0.0558161661,
0.0277660582,
-0.0053210268,
0.0734887049,
-0.0229812376,
-0.0680950209,
0.011066461,
0.0235770512,
0.0262895226,
-0.0279608592,
-0.0253114104,
0.0085101202,
-0.0132955741,
-0.0708203539,
-0.0435103402,
0.0484659709,
-0.0109130191,
-0.0013013218,
0.0048243692,
0.0631160438,
1.665783861e-34,
0.0244402457,
0.0499786772,
-0.0294248909,
-0.0436604582,
0.0207198523,
-0.0316018984,
-0.0200345051,
0.024682736,
0.0231319312,
-0.0396612473,
-0.008221074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13004v1
|
MathDivide: Improved mathematical reasoning by large language models
| 2024-05-12T20:21:15 | 2024-05-12T20:21:15 |
Saksham Sahai Srivastava, Ashutosh Gandhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have been proven to be capable of handling complex
linguistic and cognitive tasks. Therefore their usage has been extended to
tasks requiring logical reasoning ability such as Mathematics. In this paper,
we propose a prompting technique called MathDivide that breaks down the
mathematical problem into simpler subproblems. Each of the subproblems is
formulated as an algebraic expression whose value is evaluated by the Python
code generated by the LLM for the corresponding algebraic expression. The
values fed to the Python code are the numerical values provided in the problem
statement. The solutions for the subproblems are composed together to obtain
the final answer for the problem statement. Finally, the final answer is
compared to the correct answer. If the final answer matches the correct answer,
it is produced as output else a refinement prompt is fed to the LLM. We
experiment with this prompting technique on both closed-source LLM models and
open-source LLM models using GSM8K dataset. The results obtained demonstrate
that MathDivide was able to significantly outperform the leading prompting
technique called Math-prompter.
|
[
-0.0225405321,
0.0660693049,
-0.0043361583,
0.060226649,
-0.0586169399,
0.0282791648,
0.0471735708,
0.011258183,
-0.005167298,
-0.0446114466,
0.0143835889,
-0.0109610902,
-0.0036797991,
0.0200327132,
0.0044242293,
-0.054886464,
0.0261717867,
-0.067609787,
0.0360641181,
-0.0007981728,
-0.0286994986,
-0.004108523,
-0.017240189,
-0.0159891304,
-0.0151445614,
-0.0650071874,
0.0057281721,
-0.0480393209,
0.0022047325,
-0.0253047347,
-0.0399786793,
0.0338285342,
0.0147916637,
0.0315405503,
0.0000024099,
-0.0508348048,
-0.0112706749,
0.0174850281,
-0.0691976026,
0.0279124007,
0.0067720199,
0.0135408277,
0.0046561812,
0.0240547694,
-0.0822206214,
0.0331803635,
-0.0009174176,
0.0215194263,
0.1015700921,
0.0714929998,
0.0095330579,
-0.0676581636,
0.0175522547,
0.0269535221,
0.0312679261,
-0.0466433801,
0.0378448032,
0.0438685566,
0.0287429653,
-0.0091732498,
-0.0014040743,
0.028772613,
0.068385303,
-0.0216715485,
-0.0214588046,
-0.0149433734,
-0.0424397103,
0.0050326977,
-0.0102084465,
0.0498509072,
-0.0015704731,
-0.0142306844,
-0.0062834881,
-0.0045775054,
0.0032200897,
0.0117759882,
-0.0895855874,
0.0382450633,
-0.0164180119,
-0.0051229573,
0.0089126527,
-0.0249659568,
0.0146888765,
0.0164240655,
-0.0696329176,
0.1137902737,
0.0088468548,
-0.0448681004,
-0.0201466605,
-0.0172617082,
-0.0643638745,
-0.0594234653,
0.0390361845,
0.0979786366,
-0.0304672532,
0.0200913269,
-0.0282944143,
-0.0450891182,
-0.0206429083,
-0.0417219773,
0.0362863168,
0.0573937409,
0.01786834,
0.0360647775,
-0.0453240909,
0.049525585,
-0.0305297133,
0.0072176545,
-0.0343118608,
0.0388024896,
-0.0241896175,
-0.0221496951,
-0.0156545583,
0.049877204,
0.0058279149,
0.0269590039,
-0.0371746868,
0.0392998904,
-0.0325322375,
0.0247060563,
0.0162048023,
-0.0292847287,
0.0506696738,
-0.0282593686,
-0.0373451523,
-0.015049722,
-0.0560370609,
0.0017479761,
-0.0107271951,
-0.0412265286,
0.0083930092,
0.0170623735,
-0.0095865196,
-0.0164876413,
0.0239584912,
0.0644244552,
0.0116836186,
0.0104732541,
-0.0320904925,
-0.0482410118,
0.0451461598,
-0.0835592598,
-0.0130490186,
-0.1069575548,
0.0308252014,
0.0277037602,
-0.0396600142,
-0.0462441407,
0.0024149474,
0.0042547705,
0.044645261,
0.0430214331,
-0.0017657246,
0.0123552708,
0.0688434243,
-0.0106535368,
-0.0250582229,
0.0205496885,
0.0304114297,
-0.0332964733,
0.0128139956,
-0.0089839529,
0.0279913619,
0.0427482203,
0.0040602135,
-0.0098339571,
-0.0460773669,
0.0242603365,
-0.0057908185,
0.0220581871,
-0.0396128856,
0.0423098393,
-0.0364272781,
-0.0043038055,
-0.0082028331,
0.0480747633,
0.0226387456,
-0.0083548408,
0.0335846283,
-0.0001347359,
0.0450124145,
0.0092242751,
-0.0569773205,
0.0184762813,
-0.0432865024,
0.0037839862,
0.0119218556,
0.0282616261,
-0.0110670775,
-0.0790834203,
0.0004124162,
0.0148017611,
-0.0103576276,
0.0447981209,
0.0593204536,
-0.0284026694,
0.0295814052,
0.0805288702,
0.0189287402,
-0.031075459,
-0.0346099697,
-0.0685708448,
0.0634960532,
0.0127985589,
0.0377566703,
-0.0587453656,
-0.0071398919,
-0.0136523871,
0.0068583512,
0.0003014627,
0.0364832021,
-0.0039317566,
-0.0645638108,
-0.0427421816,
0.0064049708,
-0.0118747642,
0.0088435113,
-0.0167254787,
0.0567357838,
-0.0125240516,
0.0308724511,
-0.0155011266,
0.0342799388,
0.026798062,
-0.0234847311,
-0.0376520157,
-0.0137431901,
-0.0015393557,
-0.0113472929,
0.0289817415,
0.0135049438,
0.0540218987,
0.025718892,
-0.0070540369,
0.0038522752,
-0.0488410294,
-0.049514547,
-0.0537820384,
0.070387423,
-0.0050955676,
-0.0444840267,
-0.020678265,
-0.044896666,
-0.0051023602,
0.0363878682,
-0.0289774667,
0.0234667733,
-0.0089603821,
0.0413564444,
-0.013346076,
-0.0487895124,
-0.0152550889,
0.0784004703,
0.022539271,
0.0125937602,
0.0411722139,
0.0066115526,
0.0144703612,
-0.0386144742,
0.0364356637,
-0.0019544296,
-0.0151657425,
0.013954469,
-0.056850493,
0.0214598496,
-0.0188628845,
-0.0136605902,
-0.0063513773,
-0.0095347883,
-0.0088458313,
0.0542008653,
0.0096953968,
-0.018501725,
-0.007335335,
-0.0031886653,
-0.0222373977,
-0.0054711439,
0.0066625462,
-0.0028133283,
0.0117339967,
-0.0096331192,
-0.0197372884,
-0.0125769293,
-0.0308637712,
-0.0349226743,
0.0721099377,
0.0214968175,
0.0349323153,
-0.055223465,
0.0159886405,
-0.041324582,
-0.0107506271,
0.0153897014,
0.0267113913,
0.0185910407,
-0.0400836803,
0.0511593595,
0.0763904974,
-0.0110402321,
0.0137551837,
0.0316553675,
-0.0211304799,
-0.0487187244,
-0.003833734,
-0.0014234675,
0.0137713617,
0.0093900189,
-0.0261430349,
-0.0192317646,
0.0414091498,
-0.0149525944,
-0.0109016262,
-0.001834347,
0.0568552278,
-0.0130896606,
-0.0042107818,
-0.0338061564,
-0.0063500376,
-0.027337607,
0.0741086155,
0.0219429191,
-0.0473508164,
0.0584155954,
-0.0014520981,
-0.014228682,
-0.0580532141,
-0.0274293348,
-0.0815439373,
0.0441008136,
-0.016495306,
-0.0279843491,
-0.0112882424,
-0.0190098099,
-0.0232596807,
-0.0165269803,
0.0247550756,
-0.0274452511,
0.0918724686,
-0.0356027596,
0.0081004985,
-0.004851378,
-0.0138243251,
-0.0447839722,
0.0005377078,
-0.0385513231,
0.0342498198,
-0.0081426268,
-0.009085156,
-0.0007074343,
-0.0015549652,
0.0486202016,
0.0152339814,
-0.0276561901,
-0.0004397115,
-0.0079573784,
0.0047030081,
0.0056256824,
0.0259473026,
0.0363287032,
-0.0458410718,
0.0731981099,
0.0070911208,
0.0323553756,
0.0098166205,
-0.0219499655,
0.0192453768,
-0.0104828672,
-0.0597091503,
-0.031575609,
0.0446672775,
-0.0065008514,
-0.1036972255,
0.0244017933,
0.1039772034,
0.0531326756,
-0.0174864549,
-0.0159851611,
-0.1090857461,
-0.010734668,
0.0326476954,
0.039873261,
-0.0887639523,
-0.0198152419,
0.0077316598,
-0.0222022384,
0.0280365702,
-0.0187691301,
-0.0058294744,
-0.1123078391,
0.0657826513,
0.0125775672,
-0.0026820854,
-0.0056713838,
-0.0448996574,
-0.0083142966,
0.0330470428,
-0.0265541356,
0.0751107112,
-0.014289258,
0.0173624288,
-0.0050535351,
-0.0180121455,
0.0067399614,
0.0126280775,
-0.0082282405,
-0.0290929452,
0.0257002115,
0.0114189805,
-0.0204144847,
-0.0789418444,
0.0366999619,
0.0381345563,
-0.0274490304,
-0.0335356034,
-0.0127650881,
0.0212697778,
0.0080203144,
-0.0268028732,
0.0362352729,
-0.0312919058,
-0.0172693189,
0.066962637,
0.131933555,
-0.025951311,
-0.0036718638,
-0.0044061202,
0.0135460831,
-0.0457615554,
0.0446448401,
0.0280743036,
-0.0010536137,
-0.050519947,
-0.0579153784,
-0.0775991082,
-0.0094802333,
-0.0176533498,
0.0035889091,
0.0227054432,
-0.0010061476,
-0.0198251139,
0.0203410033,
0.0817453116,
0.0401500426,
0.0002130372,
-0.014842255,
0.0276573393,
-0.0033654249,
-0.0383704081,
0.0038408216,
-0.0255917031,
0.0513041019,
-0.0700677037,
0.0212066341,
0.0114797121,
-0.0278037824,
-0.02617478,
0.0003362321,
-0.0656552985,
-0.0526953787,
-0.0258126631,
0.0260415953,
0.0249840487,
-0.0068280776,
0.005491199,
-0.0203922205,
0.0114040049,
0.0257177074,
-0.0489796549,
0.0185335446,
-0.0123859532,
0.0209723525,
0.0082068909,
-0.0016765743,
-0.0070886654,
0.0166461077,
0.0056550717,
0.0289487988,
-0.0489251129,
-0.0255506933,
0.005409589,
0.0761835054,
-0.0249580108,
0.0257660449,
-0.012384071,
-0.0040742056,
0.0290805846,
-0.0376493894,
-0.0314715132,
-0.0213361233,
0.0380197577,
-0.0104164518,
-0.0278090909,
0.0334626511,
-0.0173125416,
-0.0060856501,
0.0012075994,
0.0123490775,
0.0967258364,
-0.0054041157,
0.0287102088,
0.0683095008,
-0.0456311591,
0.0207330529,
-0.0200322866,
-0.0104244845,
0.0363600552,
-0.0028921985,
0.0715068355,
-0.0094631733,
0.0134533234,
-0.0526841618,
-0.0160968006,
-0.0201433003,
-0.1311431676,
0.0327239186,
0.0581037998,
0.011060169,
0.0486398973,
-0.0304307938,
-0.0329003222,
-0.0216930229,
-0.0154866027,
0.032745976,
0.0562674329,
-0.0232154708,
0.0490287133,
0.0281909537,
-0.0094668595,
-0.0654265434,
0.0175417047,
-0.0384096615,
0.0095479209,
0.0150365289,
0.0205466151,
-0.0458667949,
-0.0362453163,
-0.0036943366,
-0.0074243243,
-0.0313497856,
0.0095465994,
-0.0555301085,
-0.0569565669,
-0.0081154555,
0.0131363152,
-0.0156661049,
-0.0082075642,
0.0336969718,
0.0665463209,
-0.0092467964,
-0.023636926,
-0.0007343862,
0.0709840879,
-0.0484506525,
-0.0598731004,
-0.0095482459,
-6.084389249e-33,
-0.021493474,
-0.0476176701,
0.0637295768,
0.031330049,
0.0119329495,
-0.023606563,
-0.0171986986,
0.0326068625,
-0.003842819,
-0.0084870532,
-0.022559762,
0.0165598858,
0.0103836535,
-0.0172783472,
-0.0059408606,
-0.0281531531,
-0.0039158021,
-0.0190718845,
-0.029319508,
-0.0165268816,
-0.0130646611,
0.0057026935,
0.0429163352,
-0.0355271921,
0.0184992682,
-0.0027228333,
0.0147969611,
0.0247756727,
-0.0661230832,
0.0672360137,
-0.0184860863,
0.025724696,
0.0179612376,
-0.0335515067,
-0.0217819214,
0.0538282096,
-0.0084404768,
-0.0191020202,
0.0197186954,
0.0019005968,
-0.0604349375,
-0.0325954296,
0.0330972522,
0.0294590183,
-0.0318063945,
-0.0169520117,
0.0205458738,
-0.0420572944,
0.0009066083,
0.0153478812,
-0.053944651,
0.0561492369,
-0.005568027,
-0.0262073912,
0.0372379124,
0.0224293787,
-0.0414572246,
0.0041549872,
-0.0017876127,
0.0268690009,
0.0849113688,
0.0204583351,
0.0422672033,
-0.0082076788,
-0.0202082396,
0.0057648448,
-0.0047630933,
-0.0588130094,
-0.0304685254,
-0.0132015431,
-0.0032441732,
0.0740927309,
0.060543105,
-0.0081201242,
0.0265642907,
0.0074966904,
-0.0542253368,
0.0133689772,
0.0158430673,
0.0224277973,
0.0185899753,
-0.0040076915,
-0.0034597989,
-0.0126371682,
-0.0288315956,
0.0548140816,
-0.0703730285,
-0.0251546111,
-0.0025604106,
-0.0410762988,
-0.0207181424,
-0.0103090173,
0.0220135022,
-0.0372861363,
-0.0117406808,
0.0216819365,
0.0144214453,
0.0295206495,
-0.0098626297,
0.0267020538,
-0.0222249664,
0.0084681669,
-0.000861061,
-0.021087395,
0.0319049545,
0.0099166995,
-0.0161639862,
-0.0046917964,
-0.0510526821,
-0.0127987545,
-0.0338561423,
-0.0018163666,
0.0335943811,
0.0426314026,
0.0274448898,
0.031339597,
0.018811876,
0.048002962,
-0.0321193412,
-0.0688060522,
-0.0404388122,
0.0234244484,
0.0067585399,
0.0472697653,
-0.0444426239,
-0.0017964054,
-0.0356131084,
0.0147126084,
0.0119185187,
-0.0292890798,
-0.0019104301,
0.0110513754,
3.038e-7,
0.0454132035,
0.0644171834,
0.0075772037,
0.0662379041,
0.0034296734,
0.0177036971,
-0.0194640942,
-0.0442714356,
0.0209315903,
-0.0247404482,
-0.0022600519,
0.0504993908,
0.0299117714,
0.0379486606,
-0.0348765515,
0.0348569006,
-0.0287347268,
-0.0217739642,
-0.0755559579,
0.0236755349,
0.0940750465,
0.0452914722,
0.0329983383,
-0.0015784699,
-0.0008638779,
-0.0239511263,
0.0090892436,
-0.0003394555,
0.0030949551,
0.0155881345,
0.0013150687,
-0.0224390272,
0.0457242988,
0.01967654,
0.015624363,
0.0000957586,
-0.0094660791,
0.0908518881,
0.0250637606,
0.055655472,
-0.0053717075,
-0.0483050793,
0.0084866602,
-0.0506733619,
0.0616480447,
-0.0131672733,
-0.0418369174,
-0.0338359624,
0.007751035,
-0.0657033399,
-0.0067044641,
-0.0349406563,
0.0355837569,
0.0133158062,
0.0157003533,
-0.0306040682,
-0.0030490868,
-0.0364200212,
-0.0426760577,
0.0319860578,
-0.0579929799,
-0.0405795388,
-0.0360265002,
0.0270764772,
0.0374981835,
-0.0072074211,
0.0091848364,
3.010192388e-34,
0.0486621782,
0.0070210374,
0.0233890694,
0.0888720155,
0.053385336,
0.0157388225,
-0.0670023412,
0.0323956907,
0.0278055854,
-0.0713442788,
-0.0030907495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07363v1
|
Multilingual Power and Ideology Identification in the Parliament: a Reference Dataset and Simple Baselines
| 2024-05-12T19:25:15 | 2024-05-12T19:25:15 |
Çağrı Çöltekin, Matyáš Kopp, Katja Meden, Vaidas Morkevicius, Nikola Ljubešić, Tomaž Erjavec
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a dataset on political orientation and power position
identification. The dataset is derived from ParlaMint, a set of comparable
corpora of transcribed parliamentary speeches from 29 national and regional
parliaments. We introduce the dataset, provide the reasoning behind some of the
choices during its creation, present statistics on the dataset, and, using a
simple classifier, some baseline results on predicting political orientation on
the left-to-right axis, and on power position identification, i.e.,
distinguishing between the speeches delivered by governing coalition party
members from those of opposition party members.
|
[
-0.035323374,
0.0701954737,
-0.0203549732,
0.0549250245,
-0.0493540578,
0.0289386064,
-0.0090077389,
-0.0272393487,
-0.0167253446,
0.0125047388,
0.0157860611,
-0.0502938181,
0.0251257997,
-0.0375197418,
0.0435507149,
-0.0701280162,
0.0766529441,
0.0319974869,
0.0550896339,
-0.0321994312,
-0.0104453666,
0.0292753037,
0.0015909284,
0.0408425219,
-0.0153765995,
0.0101789217,
-0.0234643407,
-0.0073033539,
0.0572194532,
0.029802369,
-0.0077397493,
0.0027474489,
-0.0249555409,
0.0005905769,
0.0000015476,
-0.0313287787,
-0.0104577206,
-0.0319578461,
0.0536832996,
-0.0330978446,
0.0752191916,
0.0091640772,
-0.0112645123,
0.0308100693,
-0.0301092397,
-0.0074472814,
0.0408697166,
-0.0092588151,
0.0122693805,
0.0127620213,
0.0083307372,
-0.0076826299,
-0.0759308562,
-0.0220983252,
-0.0253229346,
-0.0089885341,
0.0333662927,
-0.0445268117,
-0.0798184127,
-0.0242465511,
-0.0132038584,
-0.0027909058,
-0.036003124,
0.0013069579,
-0.0616383776,
0.0007008351,
0.0170082822,
-0.0096847052,
0.019639058,
-0.0055735339,
0.042636428,
-0.0127979321,
0.0172320101,
-0.0063952371,
-0.0173412599,
0.0577524714,
0.002695258,
0.0143718841,
-0.0214064289,
-0.0003670283,
0.0664955303,
0.0182847697,
-0.040311493,
0.0044173356,
-0.0583848432,
0.0709349364,
0.0058879559,
0.0040800455,
0.0299206302,
-0.0415546373,
0.0073084971,
-0.0340171792,
-0.015579313,
-0.0221781898,
0.0150237698,
0.0303573254,
0.0411248133,
0.0112376809,
-0.0008219077,
-0.0903950408,
-0.0299204495,
0.0084926132,
-0.0194856413,
0.0712266341,
0.0328461751,
0.0028990889,
0.0135156401,
-0.0065823742,
0.0022920002,
-0.0250776,
0.0181717742,
-0.0040913341,
0.0214049369,
-0.0174337178,
0.0191856753,
0.0173375551,
-0.0558164679,
-0.0027784149,
-0.0130911134,
0.0170900375,
-0.0376842171,
-0.0116632152,
-0.0039975676,
0.0397465117,
-0.0393903591,
0.105419457,
-0.017235728,
0.0379333682,
-0.0815790147,
-0.0058769127,
0.0345328264,
0.0628836378,
-0.0176631324,
-0.0204620659,
0.0176450331,
0.0235868338,
-0.0400573127,
0.0332965031,
0.051257465,
-0.0364428461,
-0.0355291069,
-0.0513517186,
0.0483438559,
-0.0369510353,
0.0614617467,
0.0096318023,
0.009693414,
-0.0551551022,
-0.0044608414,
-0.0215575583,
0.0002688507,
0.0133850425,
0.0397970416,
0.0553553142,
0.0101350769,
0.0044971132,
-0.0096832346,
0.0371310413,
-0.0018347655,
-0.0109717371,
0.0253360085,
-0.052116394,
0.0033266107,
0.0526107997,
-0.0296979751,
0.0261488557,
-0.0377207436,
0.0050393133,
-0.0064440882,
-0.0771939158,
0.0255615227,
0.0140544903,
0.0303392038,
-0.0013541071,
0.0383526757,
0.0232463833,
0.0151317501,
-0.0151968356,
-0.057546135,
0.0190115198,
0.0119808493,
0.0152364271,
0.0279554054,
0.0074680587,
0.057057254,
-0.0134866973,
0.0317051038,
0.0110381106,
0.0018949148,
0.0019829497,
0.00071607,
0.007541412,
-0.0132823354,
0.0129821841,
0.0589824542,
-0.048455514,
-0.0011540798,
0.0065905419,
0.0478225611,
-0.0316959731,
0.0109124267,
-0.0124925934,
0.0216759797,
-0.018547941,
-0.0377503373,
-0.0506618284,
-0.0000602354,
-0.0520526879,
0.0511166602,
0.0387781076,
0.0877383873,
-0.0618324578,
-0.0052902065,
0.0022836365,
0.0262565184,
0.0602869242,
-0.0081217932,
0.0558822751,
-0.0318663456,
0.0275005959,
-0.0240418538,
0.010313822,
0.0184082985,
0.0131391846,
-0.0185966101,
0.0060102581,
0.0210755616,
0.016805103,
0.0479781777,
0.013279072,
-0.0167037379,
-0.0242243391,
0.044417493,
-0.0145518649,
0.0454002395,
0.0212304424,
-0.0250960942,
0.0605270714,
0.0648950338,
0.0020906162,
0.0073536336,
-0.0098091019,
-0.0352409109,
-0.011252935,
0.0934425294,
0.0167719442,
0.0083700018,
-0.0381393358,
0.0181824397,
-0.0343022905,
-0.0286242478,
-0.0171670429,
0.0126732914,
0.0036761153,
0.0238453858,
0.0223073196,
-0.0805019662,
0.073829852,
0.0132672247,
-0.0067598051,
0.0029671805,
0.0101981172,
0.0095327012,
-0.0077527026,
-0.0283791479,
0.0305649191,
-0.042329587,
0.0102634197,
-0.0272797085,
-0.0388652608,
0.0520100221,
0.0064442027,
-0.0202258844,
0.0070916363,
0.0295285601,
-0.0286759343,
-0.0326746888,
-0.0466074273,
-0.0401562415,
0.0249585379,
-0.0079702428,
-0.037079785,
-0.0090128863,
0.0157772787,
-0.0382688493,
0.0000700908,
-0.0240693875,
-0.0726139173,
0.0153728435,
-0.0236341637,
-0.0456045233,
0.0032084754,
-0.0924032256,
-0.0392185636,
0.0016529559,
0.0093700262,
0.0503530055,
0.03214477,
0.0639976487,
-0.0125870649,
0.0217379145,
0.0115451571,
-0.0618050396,
-0.0190112591,
-0.0663026422,
0.0760461465,
-0.0265279394,
-0.0374583565,
0.011813567,
0.0037627537,
-0.0117339855,
0.0154631529,
0.0333821401,
0.0069908365,
0.0010354363,
-0.0163762644,
-0.0097381696,
0.0152612953,
-0.0109424395,
0.0327968299,
0.0546060428,
0.0046264874,
-0.0022128131,
-0.0149937337,
0.0456708074,
0.0007987623,
-0.0141954413,
-0.0235264339,
0.0700533539,
0.001525647,
0.022381464,
-0.0656224787,
0.0078496477,
-0.0224289242,
-0.0741550848,
0.0261799991,
-0.0447812565,
0.0422840752,
-0.0608108491,
-0.0080771763,
-0.0605870113,
-0.0354083776,
-0.0098414887,
-0.0245253611,
0.0117503079,
0.0215083361,
-0.0004456153,
-0.0545202456,
0.0066942447,
0.0625513494,
0.0158164352,
-0.0464709774,
0.0282274336,
0.0531004891,
0.0358999819,
-0.0183575936,
-0.0082908534,
0.0053858608,
0.0166364685,
-0.0283186752,
-0.0625195503,
-0.0002639017,
-0.0254689995,
0.0396941863,
0.0069563184,
-0.0652071089,
0.0399736091,
-0.0326128639,
-0.0083928257,
-0.0045500509,
-0.0209211763,
-0.0158753805,
0.0179530084,
0.0411075428,
0.010702515,
-0.0357048362,
0.0086269416,
-0.0039127879,
-0.030182261,
0.0300773401,
-0.0102585591,
-0.0805241391,
0.0565095134,
0.0405891985,
0.0085176583,
-0.0676515847,
-0.0081989449,
-0.0155533161,
-0.0448039733,
0.0143830134,
0.0138143692,
-0.0206718966,
-0.0581828058,
0.0091169206,
0.0443583652,
-0.0374218225,
-0.0643132627,
0.0326375403,
0.0376687385,
0.0145014711,
0.0432158895,
-0.128177017,
-0.0598363876,
0.0028769593,
-0.0157130323,
0.0097714867,
-0.0163905118,
0.0686009973,
-0.0364613757,
-0.0200537611,
0.0606718138,
-0.0280893221,
-0.0647372454,
0.0364150144,
-0.0082638944,
-0.0234985668,
-0.0022181089,
-0.0115354611,
0.0535138696,
0.082985729,
0.0107582547,
0.0669369251,
0.003272898,
-0.0509439223,
-0.0042920383,
0.0554509573,
0.0315308683,
0.0760486349,
0.0231866334,
0.0237776656,
0.0393134691,
-0.0090278052,
-0.0343852974,
0.0272592716,
-0.0328381769,
-0.0309323017,
-0.002371504,
0.0014329141,
-0.0172219761,
0.0060877814,
-0.0166048314,
0.023862876,
0.0447598025,
0.0367968641,
0.024721548,
-0.0193706416,
-0.014427552,
-0.0340953246,
-0.0792260021,
0.004207179,
0.0400381908,
-0.0106944479,
-0.105905436,
0.014694823,
0.0359857418,
-0.0493530221,
-0.0474016406,
0.0291360039,
-0.0348854996,
0.0419712216,
-0.0263582673,
0.0218124166,
-0.0123879593,
0.0242459197,
-0.0010294442,
0.0470647402,
0.045497518,
-0.0318575352,
0.0206673313,
0.0062456629,
0.0377113037,
-0.0197914802,
0.01835238,
-0.023133928,
0.0179931521,
0.0382091962,
-0.0832788497,
-0.035395205,
0.0068473229,
0.0030696101,
0.0204685293,
0.0054864152,
-0.0248872358,
-0.059620589,
-0.0600278974,
-0.0125385979,
0.0076125683,
-0.0274939332,
0.0268179048,
-0.0472830497,
0.0085827447,
-0.0201506577,
-0.0258537494,
0.0161475167,
-0.0243928134,
0.0292817056,
-0.0170771908,
0.0848640576,
0.0463962071,
0.028940402,
0.02123514,
-0.0284873489,
0.0101058716,
0.0226795115,
-0.0184496958,
0.04920597,
0.0049218778,
0.0024311387,
0.0033670699,
0.0033923995,
0.0493690595,
-0.0074570328,
0.005015268,
-0.028978141,
-0.0221325606,
-0.0198169667,
0.0163013525,
-0.0275455099,
0.0026884624,
-0.0054644942,
0.0048717177,
-0.0393502451,
0.0143094547,
-0.0595571846,
-0.0307180565,
0.0427626669,
-0.0266992655,
-0.0499278009,
0.028094966,
0.0310449041,
0.0067003584,
0.0258362163,
0.0301006865,
-0.0074970368,
-0.0329606906,
-0.0503050201,
0.0446321592,
-0.0254550967,
-0.0330925472,
-0.0629065707,
-0.0873241946,
-0.0036308276,
0.0040540313,
0.0218976866,
0.0153447054,
0.0458651409,
-0.0139004309,
0.0367740057,
0.0035296653,
0.0790876895,
-0.0600294508,
0.00585532,
-0.0760861486,
0.0206411853,
-0.0036451577,
-5.304943557e-33,
-0.0444615111,
0.0108347014,
0.0057347664,
0.0120065203,
0.0272925217,
-0.0254143998,
0.008958376,
0.0027355019,
-0.0317081623,
-0.0009169152,
0.0023840512,
0.004998934,
0.0230804905,
-0.0310856942,
0.008314399,
-0.0150939291,
0.0117010539,
0.0143962745,
-0.0183852334,
-0.0083523933,
0.0903709382,
-0.0254307482,
0.0981961489,
-0.0621826723,
0.0302507933,
0.0581960455,
0.0130433943,
-0.0673600957,
0.0123115145,
-0.0025298197,
-0.0046677333,
-0.0236084592,
-0.0012883403,
-0.0175092164,
0.0163510926,
0.0663961172,
0.0122664794,
-0.0202703793,
-0.0204895958,
0.039503824,
0.0435261726,
-0.0174391735,
0.0062673455,
0.0090903295,
-0.0795668438,
-0.0283959042,
0.0513618253,
0.0295750052,
0.024363663,
-0.0008816649,
-0.0251620989,
0.0214502215,
-0.0185979027,
0.0165103134,
-0.019947432,
0.0638816059,
0.0583602786,
-0.0070980145,
-0.0801362991,
0.0358335823,
-0.0322777964,
0.0145151922,
0.0284030717,
0.0074224565,
0.0135613484,
0.0356949903,
0.0596602336,
0.0272613466,
-0.01115047,
0.0255089346,
0.0325241126,
0.0208051801,
0.0876904503,
0.0351905748,
0.0140374638,
-0.075532943,
-0.082303524,
0.014430997,
0.1056338102,
-0.0069324081,
0.01924528,
-0.0230598245,
0.0204940569,
-0.0351531021,
-0.0180838853,
-0.1026812121,
0.0152876768,
-0.0024754815,
-0.0068757953,
-0.0389480218,
0.0075358045,
0.0306620616,
0.0953852609,
-0.0274653416,
0.0054455651,
0.0018947631,
-0.0538466088,
0.0167413652,
-0.0266184416,
-0.0156281348,
-0.0424314588,
-0.0430305563,
0.0091568893,
0.0472170189,
0.0806299597,
-0.0119442251,
-0.00954716,
-0.0096495599,
-0.0611202493,
-0.0261273608,
-0.0080460552,
-0.0114599951,
0.0008506075,
0.08190348,
0.0348087363,
0.0077017676,
0.0122991959,
-0.0338237099,
-0.0154852932,
-0.007341261,
0.0125771062,
0.0029221105,
-0.0589907765,
-0.0167564321,
-0.0627443716,
-0.0262390953,
-0.0016710601,
-0.0051383451,
0.014840317,
0.0419896692,
0.0020082577,
-0.0387845635,
2.291e-7,
0.0317278877,
0.0501313731,
0.0156850051,
-0.0207018089,
-0.0141152367,
0.0055830576,
-0.0187372845,
0.0548249483,
-0.0757603794,
-0.0393995419,
0.0092635527,
-0.0434650555,
0.0390354022,
0.0521728955,
-0.0896285772,
0.0125819286,
-0.0677767769,
0.0206203256,
-0.0541837178,
0.0373562127,
-0.0550884753,
0.0328926928,
0.0323732495,
0.0096121328,
-0.0109197507,
0.0126517881,
0.0075944751,
-0.0361686498,
-0.0524418429,
0.0341492482,
0.0177512057,
-0.0405012071,
0.0302385483,
0.0302831586,
0.0244703908,
-0.0020680851,
-0.0513451658,
0.063423425,
-0.0035877824,
0.0028845696,
-0.0304629877,
-0.00355496,
0.0028246527,
0.0158547759,
0.0273864754,
0.0056578307,
-0.0287652705,
-0.0425949916,
-0.0382662863,
0.0376981571,
0.078650862,
0.0483147465,
0.0180839393,
0.0332991481,
0.0194086879,
-0.0540829487,
-0.007911263,
-0.0275437292,
-0.0037933181,
-0.0380896218,
-0.0203488898,
-0.0602639541,
0.0420557372,
0.0406116284,
0.0090930592,
0.0227766018,
-0.0296524223,
1.796822209e-34,
-0.011473964,
-0.006424888,
-0.0828770623,
-0.0019554524,
0.0513814948,
-0.0196261853,
-0.005077586,
0.0396631658,
-0.013012643,
-0.0328141674,
0.0271901209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07348v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07348v2
|
MedConceptsQA: Open Source Medical Concepts QA Benchmark
| 2024-05-12T17:54:50 | 2024-05-14T16:44:02 |
Ofir Ben Shoham, Nadav Rappoport
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We present MedConceptsQA, a dedicated open source benchmark for medical
concepts question answering. The benchmark comprises of questions of various
medical concepts across different vocabularies: diagnoses, procedures, and
drugs. The questions are categorized into three levels of difficulty: easy,
medium, and hard. We conducted evaluations of the benchmark using various Large
Language Models. Our findings show that pre-trained clinical Large Language
Models achieved accuracy levels close to random guessing on this benchmark,
despite being pre-trained on medical data. However, GPT-4 achieves an absolute
average improvement of nearly 27%-37% (27% for zero-shot learning and 37% for
few-shot learning) when compared to clinical Large Language Models. Our
benchmark serves as a valuable resource for evaluating the understanding and
reasoning of medical concepts by Large Language Models. Our benchmark is
available at https://huggingface.co/datasets/ofir408/MedConceptsQA
|
[
0.0286674947,
0.0463893414,
0.0159443952,
-0.0071998681,
-0.025637079,
0.0355892889,
-0.0054537253,
0.0254070871,
-0.0055724108,
-0.018189447,
-0.0175373815,
-0.0539043248,
-0.0318666324,
0.0111564295,
0.0080388477,
-0.0424510464,
0.0257099345,
0.0047796355,
0.0106525309,
-0.0193617921,
-0.020408934,
0.0131038902,
-0.0547734462,
0.0327008888,
0.034884993,
-0.0375419445,
0.0299421437,
-0.0170937683,
0.011561621,
-0.0804712698,
0.010410714,
0.0499586798,
-0.0043253424,
0.0188087802,
0.0000018667,
-0.0694232807,
-0.0201454349,
0.0190498605,
-0.0324036852,
-0.0174661446,
-0.0076813018,
-0.0581439696,
0.0151281552,
0.025722323,
-0.0369830951,
-0.0609631911,
0.0273316,
0.0359347425,
0.0411651209,
0.0456091873,
-0.0036051422,
-0.0368220359,
0.0072444775,
-0.0282530729,
0.046489954,
-0.1010039672,
0.0340364128,
0.040089719,
0.0299962237,
-0.0156108597,
0.0043196101,
0.0179314874,
0.012084323,
0.0680890754,
-0.010698678,
0.0586570464,
-0.0542219467,
-0.0030037714,
0.0206038281,
0.1087586433,
0.0016837944,
-0.0121835256,
-0.0071680299,
-0.0009911958,
-0.0312098898,
0.0005394887,
-0.0509045608,
0.0148589211,
-0.0239280257,
-0.0027852943,
0.0012221434,
-0.0004388388,
0.0428681672,
0.017484488,
-0.0020390321,
0.0194398835,
0.0246881209,
-0.0049273912,
0.0378253199,
-0.0179955475,
-0.0538625754,
-0.0129007464,
0.0210595187,
0.0679177567,
-0.0320076756,
0.0220117476,
0.0017398663,
0.0060634506,
0.0812870339,
-0.0455873683,
0.0041883024,
0.0234768093,
-0.0182937253,
0.0761416182,
-0.0359240547,
0.0166462287,
-0.0453720279,
0.0376342125,
-0.0398099236,
-0.0233339369,
-0.0460123383,
-0.0203610621,
-0.0557161644,
0.0243045855,
0.0154944826,
-0.0146922888,
-0.0689841732,
-0.0258578025,
0.0007756709,
0.0054054735,
0.0104881916,
0.0334130488,
-0.0180465709,
-0.016574055,
-0.0212055072,
0.0287801474,
-0.0523571931,
0.0089476472,
-0.0314428881,
-0.0595717616,
-0.0181116257,
-0.0242845528,
0.0039774906,
-0.0301965438,
0.0519343875,
0.0432775021,
-0.002475102,
-0.0252576433,
-0.0017886902,
-0.0489005558,
-0.0073627098,
-0.0371166132,
-0.0033215471,
-0.0732243806,
0.017805526,
0.0294849109,
0.0051964307,
-0.0238075554,
0.0168183707,
0.0247670412,
-0.0443214066,
0.0892491937,
-0.0496050678,
-0.0141355973,
0.0210707318,
0.0572089367,
-0.0106281955,
0.0583255142,
-0.0150223635,
-0.044538755,
0.0169190224,
-0.0321385451,
0.0062137702,
-0.007498764,
0.0350360349,
-0.044210542,
0.0221401416,
0.0425874554,
0.0337208211,
0.1002391428,
-0.0437233411,
0.0725304782,
-0.0096134469,
-0.0217974093,
-0.0159376487,
0.0713662505,
0.0034530144,
0.0022340056,
0.0124190366,
-0.0322329998,
0.0339848399,
-0.031009376,
-0.0000194999,
0.0190549493,
0.0086114937,
0.0161547139,
-0.0284150355,
-0.0115573118,
-0.0366115868,
-0.0094352122,
-0.0522972234,
0.0049017714,
-0.0497483611,
-0.0107864905,
0.0544909015,
-0.0055477768,
-0.0350837708,
0.0658622831,
0.04220796,
0.0067655118,
-0.0216240901,
-0.0297091156,
0.0229818486,
0.0338392518,
0.0427615345,
-0.0451563224,
-0.070414342,
-0.0056409691,
0.0354568511,
0.0001578611,
0.0198522434,
-0.0315723196,
0.025561465,
-0.0517357253,
0.0325059071,
0.0164467357,
0.0140396496,
-0.0351890251,
0.0397928879,
0.0501437634,
-0.015094134,
-0.0536225736,
0.0230118055,
0.0272368379,
-0.0396832302,
-0.057537917,
-0.0108623505,
-0.0221657977,
0.0260763932,
-0.0048601236,
-0.0040443009,
0.0242058765,
0.0251585767,
-0.0202601012,
-0.0132173868,
-0.0072172564,
-0.0486576594,
-0.0329221226,
0.0345673598,
-0.0259877704,
-0.0373076461,
0.0028322034,
-0.0656018704,
-0.0265687313,
-0.0053404188,
-0.0303680524,
0.0179767776,
-0.004504743,
-0.0239253771,
0.0324264579,
0.0036678212,
-0.0491092391,
0.0328606069,
-0.0137773575,
0.0467884429,
0.0146487979,
-0.0020783171,
0.017035868,
-0.0142693846,
-0.0246984605,
0.0168974008,
-0.0028122175,
-0.003891262,
-0.047334481,
-0.0115471752,
-0.0519188643,
-0.0175123885,
-0.0852052644,
0.0194930229,
0.0164480098,
0.0098528601,
0.0480155163,
0.0260911807,
-0.0054522892,
-0.0247578491,
-0.0504891649,
0.0124659566,
0.0184842441,
0.017024368,
0.0472742394,
0.0579382963,
0.0199491382,
-0.0380334593,
0.0000628571,
-0.0460449643,
0.022171665,
-0.0027823173,
0.0280588903,
0.0241066478,
-0.0163377766,
-0.0566559397,
0.0119366376,
-0.001351179,
-0.0253758989,
0.01916942,
-0.0315068401,
-0.0276698042,
0.0627427474,
-0.0035197889,
-0.0116331261,
0.0349185579,
0.0086673358,
-0.0102122473,
0.0351553336,
-0.0249068327,
-0.0588776022,
0.0137159619,
-0.0331195183,
-0.0288274549,
0.0982510597,
0.002949974,
-0.0161517523,
-0.0372511819,
0.0241970364,
-0.0259468276,
0.0392124988,
-0.0684910044,
0.0462565012,
-0.0337407142,
0.0344037153,
-0.0100302044,
-0.0081911404,
0.0907620266,
0.0071120723,
0.0210341047,
-0.0647090226,
0.0251997896,
-0.0408582054,
0.0312073492,
-0.0181230418,
0.0345850587,
-0.0041519948,
-0.0081220157,
-0.0255676229,
-0.0011375602,
0.0089269523,
-0.0681510717,
0.0433330052,
-0.0389193743,
0.0395646989,
-0.0051838546,
-0.0477484725,
-0.0291873794,
0.0021525295,
-0.0589269847,
0.0101558845,
-0.0029184141,
0.0088298349,
-0.0211098548,
0.0094803963,
-0.0109387757,
0.0599241704,
0.0310862828,
-0.0088263256,
-0.0058771474,
0.0364606269,
0.0610688962,
-0.005892769,
0.0048546735,
-0.0083972234,
0.0409348346,
0.0817292854,
0.0124042891,
0.0067424756,
0.0103003001,
-0.0032587722,
-0.0017052881,
-0.0242996607,
0.0059019313,
0.0158439185,
0.0293430965,
-0.051410526,
-0.0226936862,
0.1221940592,
0.0511709414,
-0.0364459269,
0.0121465418,
-0.0229860023,
0.0052477363,
-0.0068327538,
0.0284632258,
-0.0920379311,
-0.064752169,
-0.0131461266,
0.0508770347,
0.0091775125,
-0.030700624,
0.0092619434,
-0.0526192673,
0.0035944893,
-0.0240742974,
-0.0726154521,
-0.0170100424,
-0.0430615954,
-0.0105210589,
-0.0204859991,
-0.0112711219,
0.0023470474,
-0.0095806476,
0.0164247658,
-0.0029138795,
-0.0581671409,
-0.0463952012,
0.0787096545,
-0.010268854,
0.055071786,
0.0342907757,
0.0138734598,
-0.0265881959,
-0.0178765599,
0.018651519,
-0.0552024357,
-0.0047597648,
-0.0044800518,
0.0800246522,
0.014145487,
-0.0185224526,
-0.0583684593,
0.0515804999,
-0.0489495397,
-0.0340254381,
-0.0063863671,
0.0785836279,
-0.0008029438,
-0.038118653,
-0.0222969092,
0.0243194774,
-0.0100661805,
0.0661765784,
-0.0131493174,
0.0227230582,
-0.0528455265,
0.0255684685,
0.0616562553,
0.0067076068,
-0.0250057857,
0.0380577222,
0.0165094826,
0.0007668873,
-0.046768494,
-0.0365984701,
0.0653826147,
0.0111695221,
-0.0171398371,
0.0333508402,
-0.0102326227,
0.0343108624,
-0.0709684491,
0.0647919551,
0.0138551435,
0.0117702857,
-0.0638908148,
-0.0375571288,
0.0840807334,
0.0071488847,
-0.0340477005,
0.0112983929,
-0.0386173762,
0.0170570333,
-0.0009595383,
0.0340104476,
0.015343938,
-0.0227921288,
-0.030297976,
-0.0303644221,
0.0201747026,
-0.0041999365,
-0.0325118154,
-0.0150572201,
0.0101947142,
0.0020343356,
0.0046406924,
0.0305076223,
-0.0381480232,
0.0112674069,
-0.0058786687,
0.045912195,
-0.0144501189,
-0.0088596819,
0.0458470583,
0.0468877368,
0.0115418183,
-0.0059428462,
0.0035209828,
0.0010473423,
0.026443094,
0.0051003047,
0.014012306,
-0.001025912,
0.0038432356,
0.0672614053,
-0.0302517712,
-0.0243374165,
-0.0090297312,
-0.0498786792,
-0.0277936533,
-0.0096333167,
0.0271928962,
0.0455754735,
-0.011737504,
0.074987717,
-0.041392345,
-0.013803618,
0.0009719782,
-0.0148660829,
0.0649732351,
-0.015911771,
0.0669499412,
0.0129098883,
0.0217945129,
0.000761681,
0.0303033665,
-0.0450407341,
-0.064101629,
0.0024972206,
0.0237476137,
0.0453256033,
0.0120291598,
0.0048268265,
-0.0082593355,
-0.0123906136,
-0.0070827082,
-0.0152738579,
-0.0405667126,
0.0051274756,
0.0960397869,
0.0318216905,
0.0154384505,
0.0091699129,
0.1177072302,
-0.005078631,
0.0872729495,
0.0158433411,
-0.0168650914,
-0.0293351542,
-0.0043728566,
-0.0066841897,
0.029138606,
-0.0470690988,
0.0363992453,
-0.0748248473,
-0.0502382219,
0.0092476755,
-0.0087364279,
-0.0402630232,
0.0090389727,
0.0765137747,
0.0532288514,
0.0218007155,
-0.0403226875,
-0.021887999,
0.0664640665,
-0.0493797511,
-0.0059355265,
0.0325221531,
-6.082829148e-33,
0.0131714111,
-0.0106695816,
0.0239584204,
-0.0502416193,
0.0134539669,
0.0307933148,
-0.0392670669,
-0.0126804542,
-0.046371866,
0.0608318783,
-0.0229493883,
0.0159955211,
-0.0035909386,
0.0350658335,
-0.011564252,
-0.0499573313,
-0.0087647382,
0.0071453312,
-0.0162710231,
0.0330060236,
-0.0183126591,
0.0580999851,
0.0366166607,
-0.0207793955,
-0.0254907236,
-0.0077541084,
0.021390399,
0.034502361,
-0.022846302,
0.0644749552,
-0.0471385084,
0.0073506613,
0.0462561846,
-0.0148967654,
0.0213677455,
-0.0235410146,
-0.0788702518,
-0.0251776222,
0.0075701573,
-0.0010712616,
-0.0538966581,
-0.0301069152,
0.0194552746,
-0.0245088153,
-0.0020166002,
-0.0267219692,
-0.0025365232,
-0.0331675485,
-0.0021109332,
-0.0396811999,
-0.013210753,
0.0427396595,
-0.0169395655,
-0.0008595719,
-0.0340973027,
0.0029148951,
-0.0286896359,
0.0684069991,
-0.0088751195,
-0.0175491776,
0.0142412512,
0.0283676535,
0.0173462834,
-0.0227290988,
-0.0046724668,
0.0561652668,
0.0329724029,
-0.0366184376,
-0.0420127735,
0.0205089413,
-0.0545123704,
0.0191861987,
0.0618904568,
0.0499055423,
0.0567222945,
0.013866134,
-0.1162094548,
0.028971713,
-0.0615896918,
0.0806724057,
0.0043857647,
-0.0390745588,
-0.0531958714,
0.000753351,
-0.0546521842,
0.0269906074,
-0.0372534506,
-0.0224829577,
0.0490933731,
-0.0250624996,
-0.0007298027,
0.0086240331,
0.0021215996,
-0.0181651935,
0.025365673,
-0.001250974,
0.0266703926,
0.0100108096,
-0.0299588311,
0.0554979891,
-0.0548660643,
0.0058450261,
0.024643071,
-0.022295611,
0.0346459858,
0.0214628521,
0.0110889776,
-0.0279084593,
-0.056628719,
-0.0062746713,
-0.0167342536,
-0.0045455368,
-0.0271783601,
0.0214957539,
0.0224781744,
0.033774212,
-0.0020519993,
0.0452233404,
0.0050775027,
0.0177423283,
-0.0296106879,
-0.0496535823,
-0.0208053216,
0.0052612927,
-0.0402392447,
0.0003632921,
-0.0248893946,
0.0595982894,
0.011292899,
-0.0613235198,
-0.0110266255,
0.0308565591,
2.669e-7,
0.1165832728,
0.0544666685,
-0.0051966622,
0.0092696985,
0.0261942856,
0.0004796269,
-0.009893436,
-0.0122487908,
-0.0170928035,
-0.0192946214,
0.0096990168,
0.0328365415,
0.0179052465,
0.0536131486,
-0.0717391297,
-0.008422846,
-0.0768479779,
-0.0196941551,
-0.0171254929,
-0.0558267944,
0.0296032224,
0.0964307189,
-0.0525592901,
-0.0368258506,
0.0281939097,
-0.027980864,
0.0441608056,
-0.0060153515,
0.0073331343,
0.0494980589,
0.0061580269,
0.0142619368,
0.0329265408,
0.0297092199,
-0.0099696489,
-0.0372859687,
0.0001234275,
0.0683964118,
-0.041567158,
-0.0208888296,
-0.0115385745,
-0.0309953652,
0.0393808931,
-0.0699733943,
0.0848886743,
-0.0621837042,
-0.0671827793,
0.0034724644,
-0.0329818577,
-0.0341572948,
0.0625163913,
-0.0137480292,
-0.0192664228,
0.023844514,
0.0057013799,
0.0089861862,
-0.0177175719,
-0.0760156885,
-0.0127786817,
0.0304609835,
-0.0041413498,
-0.0357124284,
0.0297571197,
-0.0433223955,
0.0054753139,
-0.0724724531,
0.0074817501,
1.964514169e-34,
0.0333025418,
-0.0041959453,
0.026992077,
0.042818509,
0.009939502,
-0.024048226,
0.0269737691,
-0.0167928245,
0.0297279134,
-0.0540907383,
0.0092553198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07320v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07320v1
|
L(u)PIN: LLM-based Political Ideology Nowcasting
| 2024-05-12T16:14:07 | 2024-05-12T16:14:07 |
Ken Kato, Annabelle Purnomo, Christopher Cochrane, Raeid Saqur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The quantitative analysis of political ideological positions is a difficult
task. In the past, various literature focused on parliamentary voting data of
politicians, party manifestos and parliamentary speech to estimate political
disagreement and polarization in various political systems. However previous
methods of quantitative political analysis suffered from a common challenge
which was the amount of data available for analysis. Also previous methods
frequently focused on a more general analysis of politics such as overall
polarization of the parliament or party-wide political ideological positions.
In this paper, we present a method to analyze ideological positions of
individual parliamentary representatives by leveraging the latent knowledge of
LLMs. The method allows us to evaluate the stance of politicians on an axis of
our choice allowing us to flexibly measure the stance of politicians in regards
to a topic/controversy of our choice. We achieve this by using a fine-tuned
BERT classifier to extract the opinion-based sentences from the speeches of
representatives and projecting the average BERT embeddings for each
representative on a pair of reference seeds. These reference seeds are either
manually chosen representatives known to have opposing views on a particular
topic or they are generated sentences which where created using the GPT-4 model
of OpenAI. We created the sentences by prompting the GPT-4 model to generate a
speech that would come from a politician defending a particular position.
|
[
-0.0201069433,
0.0647586435,
0.0103194481,
0.0573344789,
-0.046596583,
-0.0003249948,
-0.0108373938,
-0.0184204392,
-0.0077175051,
-0.0354771018,
0.0136881648,
-0.0206983797,
-0.0333872326,
-0.0155079411,
0.0055973716,
-0.0604538582,
0.0459159017,
0.0617289841,
0.0641545355,
-0.0422579274,
0.0088029103,
-0.0029675185,
-0.0194856599,
0.0487489216,
-0.0106599126,
-0.0249082316,
-0.0549152642,
-0.0164408572,
0.1096587256,
0.009761448,
0.0026668299,
-0.0142904064,
0.0006252048,
-0.0117714219,
0.0000016615,
-0.0072517893,
-0.0259023681,
-0.0317144655,
0.066882655,
-0.0021464813,
0.0435675345,
0.0624114089,
-0.0290635712,
0.0550837629,
-0.0572343767,
0.05070889,
0.0494462475,
0.0442584939,
0.0700349361,
0.0511977784,
-0.0002457605,
-0.0372607075,
-0.0078568375,
-0.006451461,
0.0089432215,
-0.0001082209,
0.034886986,
-0.0412483141,
-0.0803577453,
0.0159776323,
-0.0172081031,
-0.0188844427,
-0.0045182728,
-0.0060895332,
-0.0363373868,
0.0159780364,
0.0026250682,
-0.031225143,
0.0044971639,
0.0446848869,
0.0373193063,
-0.0007027512,
0.0188920107,
-0.0294434354,
-0.0287305992,
0.041440066,
-0.0285577979,
0.0230148174,
-0.0075625107,
0.0637306497,
0.0673661679,
0.0021210199,
0.0000634935,
0.0283436161,
-0.0551456921,
0.0755819008,
0.005970519,
-0.0341016687,
0.0334354043,
-0.0196899045,
-0.0067598014,
-0.0178981684,
0.0003604263,
0.0141174477,
0.0473213047,
0.0356081016,
0.0094188601,
0.0016833969,
0.0252313707,
-0.0751057342,
0.0074517746,
0.0309298169,
-0.0214441288,
0.0581430905,
0.02583641,
-0.0064721489,
-0.0221561659,
0.0237765443,
0.0074318484,
-0.004019558,
-0.0156188793,
-0.0083401306,
0.0038138155,
0.0363468193,
0.0054102424,
-0.004477676,
-0.0384653062,
0.0180438384,
-0.0493753776,
0.0059863282,
0.0065046027,
0.0208573714,
0.030050071,
0.0349485651,
-0.0582992882,
0.0685876161,
-0.0294997655,
0.0372550152,
-0.0405116342,
-0.0041657826,
0.0138159152,
0.0649391413,
-0.0010133625,
0.0082906801,
0.014449303,
0.0277558174,
0.0191071741,
0.0231660921,
0.0166434143,
0.0028228522,
-0.0545229949,
-0.0470628701,
0.0327203013,
-0.06491445,
0.0110014277,
-0.0202529933,
-0.0041346336,
-0.0393110774,
0.0140190599,
0.0080679888,
-0.0169763248,
0.0535648838,
0.0100181345,
0.0043925219,
0.0277910829,
0.0295547824,
0.0308325868,
0.0377548784,
0.0356254987,
0.0107023744,
0.0143463556,
0.0065609976,
0.0080975452,
0.0344146751,
0.0129572013,
-0.0042264853,
-0.0421168841,
0.0195033923,
-0.0568341687,
-0.0152053572,
0.0129372496,
0.0610712618,
0.019336313,
-0.0178042166,
0.0336103812,
0.0604696684,
-0.0044466001,
0.0322315134,
-0.0229755603,
0.011422134,
0.0476131998,
0.0107581951,
0.0369677432,
0.0532163084,
0.0303089507,
-0.0118492283,
0.0625846907,
0.0137019381,
-0.0012663546,
-0.037379723,
0.0043838043,
-0.0003010583,
-0.01950147,
-0.0320052654,
0.0309229512,
-0.0509101972,
-0.0203108955,
0.0266313534,
0.0332424566,
-0.0786055252,
-0.0081819482,
-0.0539465845,
0.0525525548,
0.0035910336,
-0.0083343564,
-0.0449884012,
-0.0577394962,
-0.0225077551,
-0.0142511874,
0.0669239983,
0.0709622279,
-0.0609224886,
-0.0282810759,
-0.0131162424,
0.0108329309,
-0.0065201041,
0.0175773762,
0.040344689,
-0.0075504179,
0.0289977044,
-0.0202351045,
-0.0071287844,
0.0444047004,
0.029695306,
0.0075212806,
0.012864178,
0.0041933157,
0.0286461562,
0.0839823112,
0.0450298674,
-0.0307418015,
-0.0085491268,
0.0743291527,
-0.012392967,
-0.0035996418,
-0.002509373,
0.0105066244,
0.0224261172,
0.0523494259,
-0.0637646839,
-0.0031189527,
0.0079318667,
-0.0418775901,
0.0035607503,
0.0504228808,
0.0126633514,
0.0055038068,
-0.077349633,
-0.0211901553,
-0.034669213,
-0.0417226814,
-0.0634450242,
0.0680671856,
-0.0158654992,
0.0021135348,
0.0124241831,
-0.060990151,
0.0733848289,
-0.0338969231,
-0.0161109921,
-0.036442183,
0.0552607551,
0.0327548869,
0.0189607944,
-0.0200320892,
0.0023742018,
-0.0778238997,
-0.0497980937,
-0.0132788736,
-0.0212333426,
0.062222328,
0.0122853639,
-0.0428611636,
0.0077195624,
0.0425088592,
-0.0194579493,
-0.0051578232,
-0.0342093296,
-0.0279749203,
0.0646581799,
-0.0036508613,
-0.0210655201,
-0.0315396301,
0.0462772101,
-0.0425845608,
-0.0146924984,
-0.0017015877,
-0.0224517416,
0.0126910536,
-0.0117139872,
-0.0787042379,
0.0047329715,
-0.0397536494,
-0.0650254786,
0.0419561267,
-0.0060044103,
0.0473277606,
0.0222670734,
0.0635557324,
0.0657436997,
0.0257394221,
0.0154988905,
-0.0594478026,
-0.0182101317,
-0.0651777014,
0.0614796132,
-0.015226,
-0.0330154486,
0.0224374477,
0.0281184278,
0.0034526121,
-0.0074609849,
-0.0341985449,
0.0666235536,
0.0254938155,
-0.0094601233,
-0.0052576386,
0.0153530212,
-0.0345697254,
0.0092741027,
0.040703062,
-0.0430212095,
0.0295794774,
-0.0153847123,
0.0682157725,
-0.0205225013,
-0.0187154878,
-0.0330562368,
0.0409420021,
-0.022431463,
0.0001251088,
-0.055301629,
0.0330483653,
-0.0240564998,
-0.0276389122,
-0.0036178627,
-0.0430125408,
0.0482486486,
-0.0325806737,
0.0143839531,
-0.0277390648,
-0.0146747204,
-0.0150828594,
-0.0632278398,
-0.0024571815,
-0.0023250103,
0.004574561,
-0.066064775,
0.0147429574,
0.0184871145,
0.0036372396,
-0.0753232092,
0.0399578437,
0.0317207463,
0.0136689954,
0.0063706753,
0.0116404071,
-0.0157233384,
0.009292,
0.0130996555,
-0.0119856885,
0.0329918861,
-0.0001663327,
0.0346431099,
-0.0653737858,
-0.0677284002,
-0.0006975572,
-0.0276254937,
-0.020870626,
-0.0029657276,
-0.0122886756,
-0.0021072705,
0.0162051003,
0.0675524026,
0.0414188728,
-0.0117430314,
-0.0101704784,
-0.0072732265,
-0.0221323408,
-0.0012667403,
-0.0103206141,
-0.0988679752,
0.0344731584,
-0.0007131862,
-0.0031434749,
-0.0602003634,
-0.0307066031,
-0.0100547392,
-0.0777205974,
0.007604802,
-0.0110091865,
-0.0023998115,
-0.0502053313,
-0.020205617,
0.0320008695,
-0.0042772312,
-0.0324887633,
0.0075079021,
0.0474703833,
0.0444954932,
0.0236059949,
-0.0987033322,
-0.0248728022,
0.0162487831,
-0.0111000352,
0.0396735631,
-0.00092809,
0.1057446525,
-0.0233661141,
-0.0621045753,
0.0314569511,
-0.0377324633,
-0.0334366374,
0.0089382827,
0.0168537293,
-0.0505887233,
-0.026101809,
-0.0362198539,
0.0506856367,
0.0541153215,
-0.0165227745,
-0.0078575527,
0.0487037599,
-0.0911979526,
0.0057624052,
0.0054713665,
0.0465887822,
0.0440419391,
0.0593339317,
0.0177404266,
0.0026242228,
-0.0208557975,
-0.0396460891,
-0.0117784161,
-0.037899252,
-0.0142071173,
-0.0283355005,
-0.0318475775,
0.0249562357,
-0.0359179527,
-0.0151826758,
-0.0058066957,
0.0285608321,
0.0089440839,
0.0059107617,
0.0095920581,
0.0227055587,
-0.023208512,
-0.0318564512,
0.0170568544,
0.0003565656,
0.0110096186,
-0.0689850375,
0.0474583991,
0.0202834662,
-0.0635798946,
-0.0277293194,
0.0028666796,
-0.0742188245,
0.001826369,
0.0215755589,
0.0237090643,
-0.0134752039,
-0.0087684821,
0.0075246166,
0.053362269,
0.0506758504,
0.0356661677,
0.019695675,
0.0264741182,
0.097540006,
0.020703014,
0.0226983167,
-0.0083954278,
0.0078514433,
0.0358280763,
-0.0676396191,
-0.0912453607,
-0.0570574552,
-0.0093616825,
-0.0045679994,
0.0440611243,
0.0048100483,
-0.0579062328,
-0.0572421774,
0.0039865109,
-0.0161046609,
-0.0247147996,
-0.0086670741,
-0.0329225026,
-0.0021023683,
-0.0467226319,
-0.0590069927,
0.0069512539,
-0.0282485448,
0.0539285615,
-0.0065984344,
0.0871553421,
0.031148592,
0.0162184406,
-0.0109931603,
-0.0370759703,
-0.0011359224,
-0.0202294886,
-0.0344422758,
0.0121621378,
0.0105211232,
0.0175162945,
0.0120831365,
0.0243155081,
0.0614428781,
-0.0140080685,
-0.0319976732,
-0.0423732661,
-0.0395165123,
0.0548886433,
0.0030495699,
0.044253502,
0.0052648704,
-0.0249951631,
-0.0167318005,
-0.0126928343,
0.050868243,
-0.0282279644,
-0.0305590462,
0.0686340481,
-0.0284505561,
-0.0478137471,
-0.0286681466,
0.0109675722,
0.0020415534,
0.0379465483,
0.0280226823,
-0.0220926199,
-0.0296309646,
-0.0240392536,
0.0370823778,
-0.0368531197,
-0.0246778224,
-0.0200710818,
-0.0453263149,
0.0047463621,
0.0346968696,
0.0557064898,
0.0062849615,
0.0282221287,
0.0093971547,
0.0478983931,
-0.0062889992,
0.0730608404,
-0.0332136713,
0.0191917624,
-0.0846322775,
-0.0066552903,
0.0162167102,
-5.806760626e-33,
-0.0405755229,
-0.0177812316,
0.0013637074,
0.0289380904,
-0.0124110067,
-0.0137237366,
-0.0188964754,
0.0044180797,
-0.031890437,
0.033544343,
0.0191709045,
0.0449746363,
0.022436155,
-0.00493035,
-0.0100301187,
-0.0390881971,
0.0037557208,
0.0052472418,
-0.0154812504,
-0.0250628162,
0.0595114492,
-0.01897371,
0.0616387725,
-0.0522003397,
0.033089295,
0.0267055389,
-0.0042042769,
-0.0401692241,
-0.0269062221,
0.0005895861,
-0.0195997301,
-0.0049335514,
0.021837825,
0.0096767126,
0.0258798841,
0.0923677608,
-0.0016397631,
-0.0394953974,
-0.0174697097,
-0.0199566968,
-0.0075914599,
-0.0255204681,
0.0139932791,
0.0255070683,
-0.0742176697,
0.0172577426,
0.0471229479,
0.0073979972,
0.0520323105,
-0.0311028436,
-0.0148405833,
0.0159382336,
-0.0221234038,
0.0104764923,
-0.0391305871,
-0.0053810892,
0.0452434123,
0.0300369021,
-0.0860022604,
0.0285158977,
-0.0162159782,
-0.0085461028,
0.0104344776,
-0.0495450273,
0.0326627046,
0.0861739516,
0.0050895498,
-0.0212214962,
-0.0723086521,
-0.0233131554,
0.0105943,
0.0207573939,
0.0644814819,
0.0154048344,
0.0227305628,
-0.0385512635,
-0.1150380224,
0.0293168593,
0.1074491963,
0.0166824386,
0.0118529061,
0.0080891438,
0.0484121665,
0.0074318117,
-0.0229783151,
-0.0908622742,
-0.0171745885,
-0.0097174393,
-0.0139063979,
-0.0272731055,
-0.0024382377,
0.0146833165,
0.0396250784,
-0.0279810764,
0.0310480818,
0.015807515,
-0.0446856655,
0.0190064386,
-0.0272767376,
-0.0163675137,
-0.0694250911,
-0.0244162977,
-0.0211405698,
0.0194899458,
0.0504572205,
-0.0158930589,
-0.001422059,
-0.0055873576,
-0.0855235755,
-0.0293661263,
-0.0135170091,
-0.0357670896,
-0.007044733,
0.0686596408,
0.0279141981,
0.0151283434,
0.0220472813,
-0.01152544,
-0.0259146523,
0.0410108007,
0.0027336918,
-0.0282708872,
-0.0147566609,
-0.014631453,
-0.0212038103,
-0.0184149854,
-0.0047576847,
0.0345492326,
-0.038814649,
-0.0453124084,
-0.0055137016,
-0.0015444736,
2.546e-7,
0.0447997339,
0.048911348,
0.0153740132,
-0.008465887,
0.0053965743,
0.0126610817,
-0.0094315633,
0.0245462898,
-0.0737336278,
-0.0729650185,
0.0074728895,
0.0012019171,
0.0320889987,
0.0234248228,
-0.0668413192,
-0.0033384222,
-0.0567488074,
-0.0085296221,
-0.0376186743,
0.0406307019,
0.0080149611,
0.0529291257,
0.0556143969,
0.0205675513,
0.0030803888,
0.0229688007,
0.0519843251,
-0.001707515,
-0.0380732119,
0.0224424154,
0.0272401478,
-0.0571554415,
0.0161391161,
0.0120509891,
0.0331149101,
0.0038472204,
-0.0301275104,
0.0684453323,
-0.0234224834,
-0.0348328352,
-0.0433991328,
-0.016522849,
0.0102511225,
0.0046755644,
0.0509389751,
-0.0315622389,
-0.0178674664,
-0.0292607285,
-0.0292006936,
0.0237346198,
0.0742467195,
0.010797414,
0.0216314048,
-0.0133073507,
-0.0010424317,
-0.0489959531,
0.0076350775,
-0.0855084509,
-0.0046232012,
-0.0422064103,
-0.0496248305,
-0.0660984814,
0.035249427,
0.0146118598,
0.0613709278,
-0.0409119017,
-0.020878261,
1.899857388e-34,
0.0270581339,
-0.0141978087,
-0.0534646325,
0.0042757061,
0.0475645252,
0.0116300443,
0.0125465794,
0.0111307902,
0.0023276873,
-0.0486888438,
0.0221579913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07282v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07282v1
|
Branching Narratives: Character Decision Points Detection
| 2024-05-12T13:36:07 | 2024-05-12T13:36:07 |
Alexey Tikhonov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
This paper presents the Character Decision Points Detection (CHADPOD) task, a
task of identification of points within narratives where characters make
decisions that may significantly influence the story's direction. We propose a
novel dataset based on CYOA-like games graphs to be used as a benchmark for
such a task. We provide a comparative analysis of different models' performance
on this task, including a couple of LLMs and several MLMs as baselines,
achieving up to 89% accuracy. This underscores the complexity of narrative
analysis, showing the challenges associated with understanding character-driven
story dynamics. Additionally, we show how such a model can be applied to the
existing text to produce linear segments divided by potential branching points,
demonstrating the practical application of our findings in narrative analysis.
|
[
0.0018350591,
-0.0016840486,
-0.0486696325,
0.041096095,
-0.0392478704,
0.0262785666,
-0.0170511696,
0.0098937303,
0.0181061458,
0.0156931896,
0.0261660479,
-0.0229394175,
0.0367437042,
0.0504692271,
-0.0278092176,
-0.0327844918,
0.0087459339,
-0.0140386866,
0.0593398064,
0.028193282,
-0.0207890999,
0.0409794971,
-0.0044178972,
0.0383325741,
0.0000790082,
-0.0430841967,
-0.0198251773,
0.0286751632,
0.0494982786,
-0.074319683,
0.0002826751,
-0.0191412438,
0.0065638036,
-0.0043406263,
0.000001896,
-0.0463636555,
-0.0103545133,
-0.0529496968,
-0.0337855741,
-0.0232493915,
-0.0039351941,
0.0388521999,
0.036539603,
-0.019481374,
0.0011834406,
0.0100085372,
0.0245565455,
0.0311248433,
0.0403833129,
0.063945584,
-0.0155296046,
-0.0492705628,
-0.042855598,
0.0141968271,
-0.0010317183,
0.0105015729,
-0.0133960703,
0.0460523367,
0.0512606911,
-0.0523515269,
-0.034720853,
-0.0051357858,
-0.0149981994,
0.0215631779,
-0.0341651328,
0.0665240213,
0.0469252579,
0.0501086824,
-0.0081160776,
0.0770980269,
-0.0019360076,
-0.0110307718,
0.0090734009,
-0.0438480265,
0.0242862552,
-0.0130527979,
-0.0353980809,
0.0299185608,
-0.0447016135,
0.0108331824,
0.0029685083,
0.0224136114,
0.0176883079,
-0.0308704749,
0.0195457954,
0.059570469,
-0.0066739554,
0.0150851477,
-0.0352229252,
-0.0045972634,
-0.0192367528,
-0.0462232344,
-0.0148055032,
0.0567101203,
0.00205275,
0.025055971,
-0.0529942289,
0.0751161203,
-0.0164634343,
-0.0410440527,
0.0515932217,
-0.0092488648,
0.0357061364,
0.0266284384,
0.0379598513,
0.0089039113,
0.028666459,
-0.0048532384,
0.0056523941,
0.0381238014,
-0.0069855754,
0.0039045643,
-0.0281071067,
0.0221632719,
-0.0224223621,
-0.0329148397,
-0.0205836259,
0.0177972149,
0.0207020715,
0.0233403258,
0.0013911003,
0.0175545178,
0.0244248137,
-0.0009412608,
-0.0409018211,
0.0195476841,
-0.0591054372,
0.0033396059,
-0.0195644386,
0.0405762382,
0.0012846588,
-0.048363328,
0.0617796183,
0.0028791768,
0.0404670276,
0.1020112038,
0.0379407778,
-0.0307509229,
-0.0298801176,
-0.0527674034,
-0.0262636039,
-0.0710935295,
-0.0565980412,
-0.0557608232,
0.0227960441,
-0.0130801899,
0.0453488417,
-0.0001957622,
0.0205824468,
0.00678743,
0.0027284289,
0.0278883446,
0.001961041,
0.0171913281,
0.0163421184,
0.0043625715,
-0.0049980427,
0.0096355369,
0.085576199,
0.0503754131,
0.0570297986,
0.0176554248,
0.0378468595,
0.0250289086,
-0.0543414019,
-0.007704881,
-0.0132366223,
-0.0190740153,
-0.0126074608,
0.0718930885,
-0.0319358855,
0.020650452,
-0.0579835847,
-0.0496577173,
0.0810325965,
0.0870880857,
0.0346075185,
-0.0497880429,
0.0648900717,
-0.0019126433,
0.0334411971,
0.0229756683,
0.0055309949,
0.0058608269,
0.0428537652,
-0.0256427936,
-0.1044170111,
-0.0030637125,
0.0066187526,
-0.0214575585,
0.005578327,
0.0024573423,
-0.0376697034,
-0.0086136758,
-0.00247958,
-0.0434065573,
-0.0434347466,
-0.0206234455,
0.0246267449,
-0.0735085681,
0.0410586111,
-0.0023997817,
0.044900015,
0.0794541538,
0.0735470578,
-0.0680752024,
-0.0880787298,
-0.056893792,
0.0096549345,
-0.0210914742,
-0.0238334537,
-0.0610242821,
0.0755238011,
-0.0294322558,
0.0128301373,
0.0057146759,
0.0234592613,
0.0445556864,
-0.0133778695,
-0.0001122857,
-0.0465308093,
-0.0615732484,
-0.0100172786,
0.0444445089,
-0.0327489637,
0.0110928966,
-0.0094767883,
0.0077779959,
-0.0318344571,
0.006047654,
-0.0104444632,
-0.0449069478,
0.0416731983,
-0.0220344421,
-0.0079887873,
0.0842752159,
-0.0088926107,
-0.0530570634,
0.0429749638,
-0.0579579398,
-0.0353394672,
-0.0280786287,
0.007498763,
-0.0180798434,
0.0193569977,
-0.0573141761,
-0.0053193117,
0.0074102618,
0.0183348488,
-0.0138135571,
-0.0005187061,
-0.0399473011,
0.0849776939,
-0.0079458924,
0.0143377623,
-0.0473134555,
-0.0003466445,
0.0118604098,
-0.0279542226,
0.068718873,
0.0083943084,
0.0285677258,
-0.0299545154,
0.0151494173,
-0.0556646995,
-0.0031649813,
-0.0485847592,
-0.0651572421,
0.019316012,
0.0078913057,
-0.0004210261,
0.0184727479,
-0.0188074112,
-0.0704896674,
0.0245024972,
-0.0242488533,
0.01292649,
0.0170530789,
-0.0406557694,
0.03294608,
0.0436955057,
-0.0011054917,
-0.0074550388,
0.0143850595,
-0.0284303464,
0.0774090365,
0.0437769182,
-0.0321950391,
-0.0507137068,
-0.0232679602,
-0.0042496268,
0.0009962938,
-0.0457972027,
0.0039906371,
0.0207475349,
-0.0151028363,
0.0664893165,
0.0346023999,
-0.0018904775,
0.0358335562,
0.0663229451,
-0.1086220369,
0.0009141908,
0.0194346607,
-0.0177320167,
0.0455679782,
-0.0766757056,
-0.0758215785,
0.0389790125,
0.0555021092,
0.0101655619,
0.0239970908,
-0.036064174,
-0.005151331,
0.026240021,
0.0014866709,
0.0111778518,
-0.0389719494,
-0.0307880659,
0.0363967493,
-0.0111113191,
-0.002835694,
0.0508308485,
-0.0329595916,
0.0325362682,
0.0206373483,
-0.0055019073,
-0.0785003752,
0.1243488044,
0.0274353586,
0.0363188423,
0.0386271998,
-0.0301885977,
-0.0076665217,
-0.0069679031,
0.0625370145,
-0.0150362412,
0.0437990725,
-0.0420281626,
-0.0348948725,
0.0276401266,
0.0090952273,
-0.0197676942,
-0.0054696514,
-0.0432800241,
-0.0428621508,
0.0602905788,
-0.0429256223,
-0.0088212639,
0.0020547516,
-0.0233309176,
0.0017176688,
-0.0132838935,
-0.0043885768,
-0.000673655,
0.0669217706,
0.0551691949,
-0.0119041866,
0.0335901044,
-0.0686210096,
0.0542329587,
0.0301691871,
-0.0411155224,
-0.0221095309,
0.0091931326,
0.0028090565,
0.0170634519,
-0.0558079556,
-0.0193698984,
-0.0026529536,
0.039619755,
-0.0884188637,
-0.0027672513,
0.1059764028,
0.0432397425,
-0.0389190838,
0.0041706227,
0.0160634462,
-0.0127152046,
0.0311250295,
-0.0066209594,
-0.0406452268,
-0.0168292597,
-0.0041261809,
0.0129060578,
-0.0116037764,
-0.0770835876,
-0.0469577871,
-0.0503517836,
0.0482032299,
-0.0128632318,
-0.0229322128,
-0.0177744124,
-0.0031883304,
0.0084392382,
-0.015332805,
-0.0699804947,
-0.0172767173,
-0.041387707,
-0.0185507033,
-0.0267096739,
-0.052672416,
0.0601135567,
0.0157623142,
-0.0491881594,
0.0397763662,
-0.0121855317,
0.0954739302,
-0.0028772466,
0.0480000861,
0.0237539168,
-0.0017474968,
-0.011718289,
0.0073075034,
0.0744218826,
-0.0324035101,
0.0030651407,
-0.0363082364,
0.0271452814,
0.0408628024,
-0.0428444147,
0.0226410236,
0.0453043766,
-0.0120382626,
-0.0554108396,
-0.0117551377,
0.0479696468,
-0.0105855325,
0.0205520317,
0.0047987918,
-0.0375598185,
-0.0537236035,
-0.0093463138,
0.0383885577,
-0.0516725667,
-0.0075372257,
-0.0221100375,
-0.0012988728,
0.0214900356,
-0.0504672788,
-0.0423960462,
0.0037467862,
0.0558980592,
0.023162229,
0.0309134033,
-0.024529634,
0.0194397345,
-0.0388849415,
-0.0080242958,
-0.0320293121,
0.0088236853,
0.0012085898,
0.0467471182,
0.0139681408,
-0.0464632958,
0.0192021914,
0.0379460528,
-0.0581598692,
-0.0473991372,
-0.0289866589,
-0.0065426808,
0.0144313052,
0.017324103,
0.0100742979,
-0.0312053803,
0.0002605776,
0.0122019285,
0.0127671082,
0.0460572727,
-0.0230914857,
0.0622405559,
-0.0309304222,
0.0029651632,
-0.0036286304,
0.0186489541,
-0.0138942385,
0.0019792251,
-0.0844914243,
-0.0158494171,
0.0105279908,
-0.027688548,
0.004127976,
-0.0453055277,
-0.0394087844,
-0.08206705,
-0.0144781973,
-0.0299190506,
-0.0178037528,
-0.0067198882,
-0.0291509684,
0.0193533916,
-0.0081262933,
-0.0592667796,
-0.0013117295,
-0.0257971603,
0.0028406829,
-0.0388146564,
0.0130829876,
0.087531127,
-0.0189631712,
-0.0016596027,
0.0051309625,
-0.0093992604,
0.0085372375,
-0.052880358,
0.0430823565,
0.0192285497,
0.0158198513,
-0.0005687397,
-0.0394556448,
-0.0212962441,
0.0002410847,
-0.0331479199,
0.0037482562,
0.0210857429,
-0.0031760226,
0.06339214,
-0.0200169235,
0.0151339965,
-0.0195796005,
0.0024602362,
-0.0082440162,
0.013344164,
-0.0066234292,
-0.0308577996,
-0.0505819879,
0.0403613374,
-0.0447826684,
0.0477981903,
0.0313214622,
0.0298647564,
0.0735432506,
0.0226919372,
-0.053038124,
-0.0261746105,
-0.0441891626,
0.0104619488,
0.0354959145,
0.0057771448,
0.0008404141,
-0.0952517763,
-0.0085860407,
0.059248656,
0.0223196577,
0.0595827065,
-0.0084922258,
-0.0227240659,
-0.0146677233,
0.0290535092,
0.0165878478,
-0.0583188422,
0.0447003618,
-0.027064411,
-0.003745259,
0.0118858246,
-5.301162506e-33,
-0.0441950634,
-0.0423183441,
0.0044154953,
0.0547487177,
-0.0868021175,
0.0200832076,
-0.0124692442,
-0.0084850444,
0.0063528544,
0.047032617,
0.0232446771,
0.0256683156,
-0.0045868042,
-0.0348191038,
-0.01542689,
-0.0144660249,
0.0268297046,
0.0137579553,
-0.0585800745,
0.0202437025,
0.0492602475,
0.0322571434,
0.0166984871,
-0.0342345163,
-0.0040643527,
-0.0524109825,
-0.0301861018,
0.0046676793,
0.0113810124,
0.0106013846,
0.003422569,
0.0032551161,
0.025900688,
0.0124446684,
0.0068360777,
-0.0068341764,
-0.0751270428,
0.006549729,
-0.0226623286,
-0.0065861973,
0.0245559439,
-0.0401661284,
0.0046964027,
0.030763967,
0.0313784257,
-0.0560285933,
0.0869353339,
-0.0234292205,
0.0036001073,
-0.0175365973,
-0.0632231906,
0.0379899144,
-0.0401307791,
-0.0137417261,
0.0082614832,
0.0590724684,
0.0271724202,
-0.0034302694,
0.0086853402,
0.0491511673,
0.0171236154,
-0.0021551945,
-0.0426303037,
0.031330131,
0.0034190684,
0.1033941656,
0.0179628003,
-0.0128028402,
-0.0443114489,
0.0415232033,
-0.0042585507,
0.0135272779,
0.0464862548,
0.0328519046,
-0.0486361124,
-0.0144394003,
-0.0991621614,
0.0245085731,
0.0567726903,
0.0058466084,
0.0214977786,
-0.000098355,
-0.0460931845,
-0.0141483974,
-0.0105571151,
-0.0776582733,
0.0063247546,
0.0076119578,
-0.0216848105,
-0.0410895273,
-0.03614318,
0.0145665752,
0.0152015863,
-0.029515123,
0.009781573,
0.025539903,
-0.0018530962,
0.0662237927,
0.00589959,
0.0312491041,
0.016458407,
0.0024177029,
0.0089875208,
-0.0184770562,
0.0626227632,
-0.0180107262,
-0.0123831062,
0.0343446545,
-0.0382043757,
-0.001279469,
0.0049894587,
-0.0043882905,
-0.0442118831,
0.0236105733,
0.0314213969,
-0.0320509858,
-0.0093578538,
0.0067101847,
-0.0043506008,
0.0423522815,
-0.0103435237,
-0.0406124219,
-0.0482704192,
0.0074811992,
-0.0030814393,
0.0081619751,
0.0011237575,
0.0626635104,
-0.0094195819,
-0.0427379981,
-0.0157390237,
-0.002862693,
2.637e-7,
0.0124822762,
0.0276969224,
0.0365580432,
-0.0231048837,
0.0128566073,
0.0308937114,
-0.0151630193,
-0.0014577918,
-0.005738148,
-0.0575870834,
0.0642341524,
0.0160837304,
0.0242460798,
0.056811668,
-0.079640165,
0.0087367129,
0.0142423129,
-0.0334103219,
-0.0510412157,
-0.0285712481,
0.0493626185,
0.0197452921,
0.0682819486,
-0.0006202512,
0.0254095923,
-0.0007353402,
0.0243818928,
-0.0459175371,
-0.0113365762,
0.0522038899,
-0.01401137,
-0.0380895361,
-0.0615012497,
-0.0223923922,
0.0066396384,
0.0449537076,
-0.0000893468,
0.0264096316,
-0.0191845465,
0.0124308374,
0.00507798,
-0.0117807379,
-0.0167857185,
-0.0077648582,
0.0517277159,
-0.0040691965,
-0.0354795307,
-0.0491189323,
0.0131497225,
0.0104188928,
0.0274211504,
0.0054270509,
-0.0117104007,
0.0351415053,
-0.0242826808,
-0.0206389483,
0.0117437802,
-0.0997248217,
-0.0002493068,
0.0444978438,
-0.0235666055,
-0.0040116045,
0.012890311,
0.0427642986,
0.0054658526,
-0.0707652122,
0.0343017355,
2.248891278e-34,
-0.0132469414,
-0.0071546156,
-0.0421009101,
0.0192735214,
0.0431543998,
-0.0053064772,
0.0173097923,
0.0104477806,
0.0553330034,
-0.0271709394,
0.0000733187
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07280v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07280v1
|
Humor Mechanics: Advancing Humor Generation with Multistep Reasoning
| 2024-05-12T13:00:14 | 2024-05-12T13:00:14 |
Alexey Tikhonov, Pavel Shtykovskiy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, 68T05, 68T30, 68T50, 91-08, I.2.7; I.2.1; I.2.6; H.5.2
|
In this paper, we explore the generation of one-liner jokes through
multi-step reasoning. Our work involved reconstructing the process behind
creating humorous one-liners and developing a working prototype for humor
generation. We conducted comprehensive experiments with human participants to
evaluate our approach, comparing it with human-created jokes, zero-shot GPT-4
generated humor, and other baselines. The evaluation focused on the quality of
humor produced, using human labeling as a benchmark. Our findings demonstrate
that the multi-step reasoning approach consistently improves the quality of
generated humor. We present the results and share the datasets used in our
experiments, offering insights into enhancing humor generation with artificial
intelligence.
|
[
0.0565473661,
0.0511958189,
-0.0004843074,
0.0094269169,
-0.0236760452,
0.0124872969,
0.0337356403,
0.02100759,
0.047852464,
-0.0331676081,
0.0492301211,
-0.0100809522,
-0.0067629819,
0.0666810572,
0.0309813172,
-0.0848103985,
-0.023388207,
-0.0020459627,
0.0413154438,
-0.019596057,
0.0001400079,
0.0125741614,
-0.0529542267,
0.0378678739,
-0.0351925865,
0.0142269554,
0.0042755567,
0.0625247732,
0.0159075018,
-0.0343063138,
-0.0178481545,
0.0140391653,
0.006247784,
-0.0069841063,
0.0000017003,
-0.0661906898,
0.0137731954,
-0.0262212027,
0.0078716557,
-0.013431455,
-0.0031729252,
-0.013037933,
-0.046611052,
0.0206327923,
-0.0313626751,
0.0468772091,
0.0606597252,
0.0260238443,
0.0825807303,
0.0733972117,
-0.0109377196,
-0.0292830113,
-0.0202133339,
-0.0315487944,
0.0538385026,
-0.045597896,
0.0078701871,
0.0338301882,
0.0315556042,
-0.0360251591,
-0.0325401612,
-0.0058196513,
0.0195758194,
-0.0000373427,
-0.0305567682,
0.0756484792,
-0.0149023114,
-0.0077407896,
-0.0192622636,
0.0309897829,
0.0009617226,
0.0353824235,
0.0132421944,
0.0158795994,
0.0098596336,
-0.0320603363,
-0.0571698174,
0.0380871743,
-0.0189997051,
-0.0215737484,
-0.026864199,
0.0352708772,
-0.0251311213,
0.0313630663,
0.0122957947,
0.045593258,
0.0271658283,
-0.01867879,
-0.0378246829,
-0.007296544,
-0.0290005207,
-0.0598485209,
0.0490319505,
0.0837584436,
0.0285998322,
0.0285319574,
0.000435204,
0.0007357443,
0.0514820963,
-0.0388658084,
0.0043061874,
0.0350476392,
0.0169032626,
0.0726317242,
-0.0401999801,
0.0300183091,
-0.0182189289,
-0.0102785332,
-0.0248358455,
0.0195792411,
-0.0553526431,
-0.0016252234,
-0.0338654183,
0.0353531614,
-0.0016661047,
-0.022862047,
-0.0657988861,
0.0298908371,
0.0250783022,
-0.0213394575,
0.0093259476,
0.0505044349,
-0.0334152021,
-0.0431267023,
-0.0170161389,
0.0288727563,
-0.0855645239,
-0.0092822937,
0.0076331017,
-0.0304968823,
-0.0373890065,
0.0227361396,
0.0556022935,
-0.0324651115,
0.0184748266,
0.0629030988,
-0.0136010321,
-0.0147466687,
-0.0286232661,
-0.0721483603,
-0.0646831542,
-0.0742347389,
0.0228218585,
-0.0529819056,
0.0278657861,
0.0077933245,
-0.0165025648,
-0.0143986568,
0.0103485547,
0.0283375252,
-0.0441938788,
0.0205964558,
-0.050443206,
0.0104013924,
0.0391041748,
0.030509159,
-0.0372899212,
0.0314877629,
0.0301923249,
0.0287990067,
0.0087388847,
-0.0000324478,
0.0322291479,
-0.0277619604,
0.0059050871,
-0.015379156,
-0.0094110416,
-0.0336946845,
-0.0482892282,
0.0443221964,
0.0171856713,
0.0360701345,
-0.0395937823,
0.0679880604,
0.0173418,
0.030738892,
0.0111187706,
0.0477603748,
0.0782443434,
-0.0412204936,
-0.0270647388,
0.0204134881,
0.0146786654,
0.0481785424,
-0.0440055691,
0.013718063,
0.0295613017,
0.0296913926,
-0.0158401225,
-0.0389457792,
-0.0161798857,
-0.0127926115,
0.0583366193,
-0.0605404414,
0.0394362509,
0.0534864962,
-0.0353393331,
0.0256675724,
-0.0093836682,
-0.0773381442,
-0.0276820026,
-0.0046383417,
0.0084768282,
0.0809155628,
0.0414461307,
0.0176634192,
-0.0364920385,
0.0019640154,
0.0506937467,
0.03979991,
-0.0003962733,
0.0247093234,
0.0180991087,
-0.0390789285,
0.0332710333,
-0.0402638167,
0.0037079598,
0.0348566994,
0.0220144279,
0.0311239045,
0.0028848504,
0.0244818646,
0.0892547294,
0.0338882729,
-0.0664481819,
0.0022406818,
0.0072390423,
0.0187343974,
0.0095165586,
-0.0071604545,
-0.0004930071,
-0.0004639747,
-0.0015653895,
-0.0445985906,
-0.0474724397,
0.0567314811,
-0.0303253289,
-0.0422919244,
0.0354779251,
-0.07475245,
-0.0141189294,
-0.0051280614,
-0.0092165694,
-0.0314787738,
0.0418453477,
-0.0472879075,
-0.0121962717,
-0.0592139587,
-0.0332937315,
0.0022394473,
-0.0012922098,
0.007827796,
0.0828627422,
-0.0177992731,
0.0129992897,
0.0032797228,
0.0056007421,
0.0379762687,
0.0001321797,
0.0164261591,
0.0402271375,
-0.0237006843,
0.0232842788,
-0.0008677088,
0.0508186705,
-0.0273011494,
-0.0392052606,
-0.0701261759,
0.0097913463,
0.0109948153,
-0.0321444757,
0.024073422,
-0.0003649547,
-0.0229243636,
-0.0251219608,
-0.0139600579,
-0.0073332977,
0.0031423348,
0.0013194316,
0.0456271432,
-0.0081777116,
-0.0273521226,
0.0144781731,
-0.0024411494,
-0.0497705601,
0.0098495819,
0.0644156262,
0.0671122596,
-0.0530823059,
-0.0075919912,
-0.0949636474,
-0.0436103344,
0.0188525077,
-0.0556510463,
0.0434212014,
-0.026136959,
0.0173090342,
0.0597242638,
0.048684828,
0.0274608955,
0.0199850164,
-0.0229871217,
0.0149199618,
0.0066006263,
-0.0081497524,
0.0612760298,
0.0405303873,
-0.0212497395,
-0.0224233046,
0.0195874609,
0.0287770238,
0.0535047203,
-0.0993468687,
0.1018261462,
0.0351847932,
0.017657131,
0.0096306326,
-0.0272996034,
-0.0281502567,
0.0118019264,
-0.0171294529,
-0.0049920608,
0.1016107574,
-0.0119631654,
-0.0287385006,
-0.0117713474,
0.0311642233,
-0.0012434806,
0.084222801,
-0.028348187,
0.0445997454,
-0.0140369004,
-0.0094436174,
-0.0034773885,
-0.006799466,
0.0226144046,
-0.0139383385,
0.0171318538,
-0.0552989282,
-0.0219457913,
0.006408616,
-0.0567229949,
-0.0153070083,
-0.0163770616,
-0.0340881646,
-0.0025657979,
-0.039829623,
-0.024084691,
-0.0045071105,
-0.0029879105,
0.0096701439,
-0.0111736078,
-0.0422107019,
-0.0268449672,
-0.0131542059,
0.0070396075,
0.0451163501,
-0.0063167242,
-0.0180481896,
-0.0035231209,
-0.0016179241,
0.031028308,
-0.0139365159,
0.0369383842,
0.0027864282,
0.0295045003,
-0.0200882871,
0.00110834,
-0.0011751201,
0.0211563688,
0.0336771607,
-0.0362391435,
-0.0403756425,
0.0571426526,
0.0168914553,
0.0301677156,
0.0212553069,
-0.0016423638,
-0.0079939188,
0.0023380022,
0.015802443,
-0.0373853706,
-0.0364634283,
0.016887933,
0.0028116978,
-0.0207439475,
-0.0237519648,
-0.0488601848,
-0.1042001992,
0.0325858146,
0.0193613209,
-0.0127183404,
-0.0140984775,
0.009807907,
-0.0083280196,
0.0163322464,
-0.0632425919,
0.0091967834,
0.033567246,
0.0282371473,
-0.0019517425,
0.0387652069,
-0.0341421925,
-0.0010396899,
0.0058665783,
0.0628400818,
0.0534733385,
0.0660491139,
0.0087985443,
-0.066001825,
-0.0168534201,
-0.0356399827,
0.0143501554,
-0.0153810931,
0.0426940136,
0.0217755232,
0.0218419563,
-0.0225335155,
0.0460721329,
-0.0319941118,
-0.0307599492,
0.0150665035,
0.0486531481,
-0.0352889448,
-0.041268412,
-0.0426068418,
0.0451316722,
-0.0189478826,
0.0866030902,
0.0458052941,
-0.0475035198,
-0.0483194068,
-0.0607332885,
-0.0086405035,
-0.1043750346,
-0.00024243,
-0.0322535522,
0.0113376072,
-0.0220546238,
-0.0923355892,
-0.011481124,
0.0131983859,
0.07471852,
-0.022717094,
-0.0485981777,
-0.0771052167,
0.0297942627,
0.004210995,
-0.0457844026,
0.002254579,
-0.0180553179,
-0.0115811648,
0.0223446339,
0.0083487192,
-0.0800176933,
-0.0303032044,
0.0317969583,
-0.033341907,
-0.0461134389,
0.0086389147,
0.062876761,
0.0363649577,
-0.0154087497,
-0.0397549607,
-0.0375165753,
-0.0034343246,
0.0706361085,
0.0038023335,
0.0203991383,
0.013216434,
0.0492272861,
0.0258362032,
0.0082306471,
-0.0213225763,
0.0432479642,
0.0198830664,
0.0396416634,
-0.0364940092,
-0.0284831002,
0.005634869,
0.019111257,
0.0277598035,
-0.0395400561,
-0.0629395992,
0.0316605642,
-0.021635944,
-0.0305382721,
-0.0316046029,
-0.0160544533,
0.0209358949,
-0.0013335492,
-0.0115171792,
-0.0348100699,
-0.0452538058,
-0.0276648123,
0.019083837,
0.0077539957,
-0.0446103811,
0.0380283482,
-0.0006237553,
0.0181682538,
-0.0082697328,
-0.0162447616,
-0.0040957425,
-0.0169561133,
0.0192717593,
-0.0187779982,
0.0589437634,
0.0275870673,
-0.0310269166,
0.004056294,
0.0521089733,
-0.0257987455,
-0.0414339267,
0.0161331948,
-0.0170904994,
0.0639516488,
0.0291782636,
0.0579469465,
-0.0281911194,
0.0075507509,
0.0229476169,
0.0378091298,
0.0114598228,
-0.0729642063,
-0.015510479,
0.021191569,
0.0107264668,
-0.0631674528,
0.0701307803,
-0.0864619985,
0.0157728791,
0.0044245361,
-0.0131340483,
-0.0418415889,
-0.0338041559,
-0.0344875157,
0.0344021954,
0.0492863134,
-0.0048580999,
-0.0452727005,
-0.0252970103,
-0.002750709,
0.0113640511,
0.0200693645,
0.0200898759,
0.043265406,
0.0529111251,
-0.0131911607,
-0.0035193604,
-0.0365707353,
0.027647974,
-0.0432314649,
0.0047956412,
-0.0223124661,
-6.033831972e-33,
-0.0192647427,
-0.0462406538,
-0.0076930444,
0.0179182962,
0.0068117953,
-0.0331979021,
-0.0910812989,
0.0189141612,
0.0095225535,
0.0122617874,
0.0030880871,
-0.0082562733,
-0.0168971978,
-0.009349877,
0.0366630666,
-0.0196762737,
0.0139390696,
0.018568296,
-0.0552162379,
0.0265778638,
0.0480183624,
0.0216610525,
0.0035500061,
-0.0430314206,
-0.0116857253,
-0.0066290768,
-0.055315312,
0.0058046258,
0.0221166424,
0.0367915183,
0.0152908172,
0.0278112385,
0.0486429594,
0.0082923267,
0.0104887569,
0.0280827619,
0.0014525137,
-0.0389136709,
-0.0197236966,
-0.054143779,
-0.0459148213,
-0.0472765416,
0.0495208763,
-0.0084183896,
-0.0121733593,
-0.0114786346,
0.0482406132,
-0.0157364905,
0.044274427,
-0.0441723429,
-0.0473142117,
0.0000508506,
-0.0412381627,
-0.0661698356,
-0.0026018987,
0.0468412079,
0.0198987816,
0.000521081,
-0.0202068035,
0.0613302998,
-0.0751264319,
-0.0445095897,
-0.0131414523,
-0.0753748342,
-0.0014019854,
0.0444058366,
-0.0075964532,
0.0348276086,
-0.0267330855,
-0.0084121088,
-0.0093662944,
0.0569331795,
0.0893755928,
0.0339944884,
0.0427745394,
-0.0485822633,
-0.0398428142,
0.0413745344,
0.0043285163,
-0.0156550482,
0.0359023921,
0.0164826829,
-0.0600889698,
0.0095091015,
0.0544455796,
-0.0091026202,
0.0011488521,
-0.105092667,
-0.012324973,
0.0353635997,
-0.0259337183,
-0.0224739686,
0.0031948448,
-0.0096461261,
0.0148166101,
0.0021449712,
-0.0324709937,
0.0264157634,
-0.0031174463,
0.0013509248,
-0.0232678987,
-0.005022448,
0.0423376188,
0.0715482682,
0.0345240086,
0.0309759434,
0.0532356091,
0.0054721632,
-0.0345274173,
0.0037051491,
-0.0607858896,
0.029941434,
0.0051666223,
-0.0551354475,
-0.0079276711,
0.056505695,
-0.0148923127,
-0.0314006247,
0.0482396707,
0.0088082673,
-0.047870867,
0.0220321957,
0.0078600487,
0.0239612069,
-0.0497106612,
-0.0168844853,
-0.0096419174,
-0.0788042918,
-0.0098734116,
-0.0666677877,
-0.0213293396,
0.0078406865,
2.663e-7,
0.0161081366,
0.0657032952,
0.0454443544,
0.0358964354,
0.0467967279,
0.043196056,
-0.0254923813,
0.0031978001,
0.0062944246,
0.008888348,
-0.0053312536,
0.0294856168,
0.0127974879,
0.0090667065,
-0.0739636943,
0.0344853178,
-0.0450481921,
0.01457904,
-0.0339322425,
0.0043445327,
0.0805729553,
-0.0519374162,
0.036851652,
-0.0081001157,
0.0275410283,
-0.0561051928,
0.0204208549,
0.0181614514,
0.0495005548,
-0.0044678356,
0.000156184,
-0.0139451912,
-0.0103371823,
0.0180722978,
0.0058353716,
-0.0804869607,
-0.0004547792,
0.059764415,
-0.0368147492,
-0.0062325825,
0.0230949391,
0.0087636774,
0.019678019,
-0.0552757941,
0.0672956929,
0.0127088903,
-0.018036548,
-0.0032794469,
-0.0098857656,
-0.0169549212,
0.0246927589,
0.0118118543,
-0.0352019332,
-0.0055690436,
0.0299352165,
0.0187769718,
0.0239422135,
-0.0499111339,
-0.0558755547,
0.0287341215,
-0.0637334362,
-0.0064612799,
-0.0071350881,
-0.0181447752,
0.0314600244,
-0.1110062301,
-0.0282231513,
2.110521817e-34,
0.0098148687,
-0.012690003,
0.0353456512,
-0.0223122928,
0.0323105641,
0.0279815365,
-0.007230896,
-0.0133727891,
0.0377226137,
0.0135445902,
-0.0407258794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07278v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07278v1
|
Human-interpretable clustering of short-text using large language models
| 2024-05-12T12:55:40 | 2024-05-12T12:55:40 |
Justin K. Miller, Tristram J. Alexander
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Large language models have seen extraordinary growth in popularity due to
their human-like content generation capabilities. We show that these models can
also be used to successfully cluster human-generated content, with success
defined through the measures of distinctiveness and interpretability. This
success is validated by both human reviewers and ChatGPT, providing an
automated means to close the 'validation gap' that has challenged short-text
clustering. Comparing the machine and human approaches we identify the biases
inherent in each, and question the reliance on human-coding as the 'gold
standard'. We apply our methodology to Twitter bios and find characteristic
ways humans describe themselves, agreeing well with prior specialist work, but
with interesting differences characteristic of the medium used to express
identity.
|
[
0.068022348,
0.0205619745,
-0.021271741,
0.005211317,
-0.0048141754,
0.0186655074,
0.0228414591,
0.0149758924,
0.0507935882,
-0.0089802621,
0.0090767266,
-0.047511559,
0.0196074024,
0.0327961445,
0.0489033312,
-0.0667278916,
0.005823479,
0.0011622475,
0.0242243093,
0.0144440364,
0.028214762,
0.0231611263,
0.0429939777,
0.0545101017,
-0.0010310108,
-0.0081136273,
0.0147261508,
0.0025496208,
0.0183036178,
0.0302473418,
0.0005625575,
0.0969298556,
-0.0186212286,
0.0716088563,
0.000001578,
-0.0358759873,
-0.0481173471,
0.0077576675,
-0.0072732638,
-0.0021845242,
0.0880931541,
0.0047493158,
-0.012952012,
0.0216999073,
-0.0279835258,
-0.0168352183,
0.0342893861,
0.0336802639,
0.0858927146,
0.0699171275,
-0.0267383754,
-0.0133855594,
0.0060690627,
-0.0091047306,
0.0149696749,
-0.0185830798,
0.0253114812,
0.0061425036,
0.0178759191,
0.0373865291,
0.0266742371,
0.0377502963,
-0.0165186822,
-0.003497055,
0.0301460139,
0.0305465143,
-0.0432560444,
-0.0212364122,
0.0448909737,
0.0444763899,
0.0277066436,
-0.0290796068,
0.0635699108,
0.0383800864,
0.0195198879,
0.0149405263,
-0.0360102654,
0.0414740965,
-0.0029650505,
-0.0056498107,
-0.0193698462,
0.0393829644,
0.0182557479,
0.0061123883,
-0.0182110611,
0.0385402404,
0.0053317356,
-0.0066522509,
-0.0221083146,
0.015409614,
0.0069350363,
-0.041808784,
0.0304660872,
0.0107758651,
0.0084875599,
0.0093734525,
-0.0618872233,
0.0001469693,
0.0181157328,
-0.0315671414,
-0.0343828872,
-0.0248894561,
0.0251267925,
0.0406418331,
0.008151127,
0.0110726273,
0.0093225325,
-0.0235527847,
-0.0053756642,
-0.0408234,
-0.1077025309,
-0.0249482915,
-0.0230167322,
0.0093172379,
-0.0073026135,
0.0040527508,
-0.0725544542,
0.0474836119,
-0.0169950798,
-0.0291529372,
-0.0295076538,
-0.0172595587,
-0.0029260688,
-0.0197568778,
0.0021949282,
-0.0331548527,
-0.0227925647,
-0.0128095718,
-0.0112925684,
-0.0343600474,
0.041470889,
0.051738169,
0.0404625088,
-0.0270780213,
-0.0463363305,
0.025210144,
0.0110396836,
-0.0312817805,
-0.0189577378,
-0.0853004381,
-0.027199164,
-0.0136210602,
-0.0389647409,
-0.0831239447,
0.0239403322,
0.0294742584,
-0.005229305,
-0.0441477597,
-0.0294640139,
0.025224695,
-0.0457019098,
0.03427279,
-0.0745367035,
0.0550120883,
0.0330292843,
0.0200999249,
-0.0043410659,
0.0280818231,
0.0338649042,
0.0629242808,
0.0861974582,
-0.0101066511,
0.025184419,
0.0530749112,
-0.0099703372,
0.0166743677,
0.0216659438,
-0.018842971,
-0.010739536,
-0.0003074612,
0.0131537737,
0.0718123615,
-0.0348700248,
0.0101994323,
0.0404868834,
0.1021339968,
0.0229184292,
0.031065464,
0.0301380455,
0.0749741048,
0.0302551426,
-0.0106273554,
-0.028433349,
-0.036149893,
-0.0384138487,
-0.0181665644,
0.0570260845,
0.0326738916,
-0.0287276898,
0.0048113251,
0.0091374638,
-0.0122358734,
0.0392697155,
-0.0376663469,
0.0158104505,
-0.0183335375,
0.0325353183,
0.0522637144,
0.018942479,
-0.0650977343,
0.0379920453,
-0.0544679388,
0.0220138393,
0.06237882,
0.0075117862,
0.0003268459,
0.0316654965,
-0.0029954531,
0.0126888845,
0.0054538888,
-0.0126698827,
-0.0192361567,
-0.0256405231,
-0.0388321653,
0.0027494079,
0.0633373708,
0.0060680844,
-0.0331412517,
0.0289774816,
-0.0089423759,
0.0251933299,
-0.0287960954,
-0.0614362583,
0.0169100333,
-0.0111369835,
-0.0007098853,
0.0046839206,
0.0147041325,
-0.0077501102,
0.0554534532,
0.0260432269,
-0.0188517105,
-0.0018318648,
0.0079426328,
0.0047752177,
0.0221405253,
0.0081078513,
0.0013930821,
0.0012565921,
-0.0278701428,
-0.0660726279,
0.0077185677,
-0.0170561466,
-0.0561355874,
0.0246382672,
-0.0490947366,
0.033206407,
-0.0190356206,
0.0101510417,
-0.0127752842,
-0.0081742471,
-0.0247836411,
0.0672317371,
-0.0000762457,
0.0066777072,
-0.0223600455,
-0.0461534746,
-0.0106927631,
-0.0638820976,
-0.0199832767,
-0.0229670908,
-0.0052282591,
0.0360686779,
0.0361603945,
-0.0266474728,
-0.0656175911,
-0.0415845849,
-0.1117257774,
-0.0227674395,
-0.0202712715,
0.0090933172,
0.0526698716,
0.018628085,
-0.0085264631,
-0.0041495324,
-0.0559940003,
-0.0401901267,
0.0129362419,
0.0078914929,
0.0649218708,
-0.0113488371,
-0.007285621,
-0.0341232494,
-0.0307544284,
-0.0359950662,
0.068010658,
0.042211134,
-0.0352440886,
-0.0449642688,
0.0131515898,
-0.0095514562,
-0.0466014184,
0.0149548752,
-0.0262628291,
-0.0047651269,
-0.0180632714,
0.0345938653,
0.0003179584,
0.0357016288,
0.0595738478,
-0.0449768975,
0.0226070546,
0.0200632215,
-0.048938401,
-0.0270469934,
0.0295517482,
-0.0141200395,
-0.0837645084,
0.0496096425,
0.0102590537,
0.0042340267,
-0.0102551887,
-0.0855298936,
0.0437243022,
-0.0446085595,
-0.0098163644,
-0.0497225188,
-0.0067954622,
0.0016375564,
0.044513043,
-0.0269177034,
-0.0318422429,
0.0366392359,
-0.0396722369,
0.0358843282,
0.0188858248,
-0.0544653349,
-0.0426376462,
0.0521079041,
0.0172783565,
0.03728709,
0.0137868673,
-0.0367589369,
0.0031673119,
0.0124564264,
-0.0133964196,
-0.0138610704,
0.0389142968,
0.0046777297,
0.002656847,
0.038341213,
0.0069284141,
-0.0070907362,
-0.0716294348,
-0.0274259523,
0.0114837205,
0.0727745444,
-0.0714782774,
-0.0399884507,
0.0402289554,
0.034923505,
-0.030758027,
-0.0465448499,
-0.0142023554,
-0.0152518423,
0.0725559294,
0.0238119755,
-0.0022772837,
0.0085972603,
-0.0622617565,
-0.0302083325,
0.0457568094,
0.019106105,
-0.0084313108,
0.0009658251,
-0.0363611914,
-0.0137164015,
-0.0510360263,
-0.0264397841,
-0.004262819,
0.085034661,
-0.0002755215,
0.0007738124,
0.1486078054,
0.0229418948,
-0.0500252694,
0.0168676991,
0.0350329019,
0.0339731351,
-0.0189323667,
0.0142864203,
-0.0140387639,
-0.0109782349,
-0.0061766887,
0.0509590954,
-0.015347736,
-0.0582492687,
0.0016117883,
-0.0431012809,
0.032514926,
0.0154938828,
-0.0781111121,
-0.0228735805,
-0.053450156,
-0.0131006576,
-0.0441905893,
-0.0270261057,
0.0092990445,
-0.0413615666,
0.0258104764,
0.0222516805,
-0.0677805245,
-0.0561450943,
0.0190377831,
-0.0527237989,
0.0481961221,
0.0291440524,
0.0400258787,
0.0100780493,
-0.0023782526,
-0.0240032859,
-0.008090172,
0.0018401961,
0.0204359535,
0.0755958334,
-0.0141037637,
0.0176529158,
-0.097642526,
0.0424006917,
-0.0341434889,
-0.0165469926,
-0.0232506525,
0.0264809001,
0.0151370484,
-0.0199925248,
-0.0124123357,
-0.0039753136,
0.0050107981,
0.0842010453,
0.0433988236,
-0.0407531708,
-0.014493363,
-0.0334534608,
0.0187794659,
-0.0041519655,
-0.0831196532,
-0.0079781031,
-0.0359107703,
-0.0412475392,
-0.0640836358,
-0.0688261688,
0.014120332,
0.0314360745,
-0.0304922611,
-0.0120027289,
0.0509484746,
-0.0205143522,
-0.0562361628,
0.0520349443,
-0.0604252964,
0.0029185112,
-0.0709120408,
-0.0143996794,
0.0260753091,
-0.0336169414,
-0.0141917979,
0.003880641,
-0.0512416065,
-0.0405122153,
-0.0002756698,
-0.0464827418,
0.0302638765,
0.0210485421,
-0.0528094098,
-0.0858527124,
0.0333496407,
0.0432547443,
-0.0478373021,
0.001253904,
-0.0311824884,
0.0262386631,
-0.0197364204,
0.0259241182,
-0.0337148122,
0.0168081168,
-0.0151525605,
-0.0401259959,
-0.0742591172,
-0.0318373442,
-0.0098516857,
0.0536346175,
0.0128219873,
0.0059716306,
-0.0219970085,
-0.0315628573,
-0.0891394913,
-0.0247272309,
0.0039097406,
0.0113951797,
-0.0300401784,
0.0278657805,
0.0040193736,
-0.0207374338,
0.0049313758,
-0.0258883201,
0.0093201622,
-0.061312113,
0.0018909811,
-0.0215545483,
0.0461383685,
-0.010446717,
-0.0185115132,
0.0074747908,
0.0089838477,
-0.0181593783,
0.03124029,
-0.0178251006,
-0.0106666824,
-0.0014975129,
0.0023673642,
-0.0149665019,
0.0829326212,
-0.0772887617,
-0.0364737771,
-0.0139011508,
-0.0175287183,
-0.0031374244,
-0.021401599,
0.0616153926,
-0.0055669239,
-0.0276982728,
-0.0132342605,
0.0386465713,
0.0036996237,
-0.0014717988,
-0.0273252781,
0.0121039329,
-0.0407560132,
0.0061385096,
0.0829912126,
0.032848347,
-0.0074815019,
0.0005324123,
-0.0683483332,
-0.025497267,
0.0064763976,
0.0137301758,
0.0245506447,
-0.0099833421,
-0.0078238416,
-0.0524542741,
-0.057158988,
0.0605562441,
-0.016806338,
0.0312062446,
0.0313351639,
0.0353518873,
0.0562327467,
-0.0028732684,
-0.0012758793,
-0.0857913941,
-0.0221779887,
0.0178213846,
-0.0338020809,
0.0329369083,
-6.44812063e-33,
-0.001656878,
-0.0838795081,
-0.0171973612,
-0.0418722928,
-0.0166133437,
0.0136991385,
-0.0219949838,
0.0150375031,
0.0234713256,
0.0144965714,
0.0016876535,
0.0209631678,
0.012184754,
0.0312209036,
0.0055780085,
0.0534149148,
0.0435918458,
0.0371468067,
0.0012218773,
0.0728228167,
0.0558598191,
0.0057365322,
-0.0252816137,
-0.0607652515,
0.041695714,
-0.0276718587,
-0.0103627667,
0.0170757975,
0.0629303232,
0.0735037774,
-0.0320557728,
0.0241572876,
0.0503501222,
-0.0009553975,
-0.0009556419,
0.0399358869,
-0.0741403848,
-0.0067332764,
-0.0131375724,
-0.0138961496,
-0.0118950699,
-0.0606710762,
0.0625593588,
-0.0434603095,
-0.0113936085,
0.0145269027,
0.0748731717,
0.0296694692,
0.0176393092,
0.0077406587,
-0.0231480971,
0.0746719316,
-0.0198149439,
0.0112007298,
0.0268455315,
0.026668597,
-0.0243980344,
0.0426185839,
-0.0817788243,
0.0506384559,
-0.0010147541,
-0.0028188666,
0.022976229,
0.0271770693,
-0.0116234766,
0.0497528017,
0.0297448412,
0.0278645549,
-0.0557471998,
0.0013277143,
0.003605942,
0.0370787978,
0.0095429067,
0.0585820489,
-0.0456214063,
-0.0405066907,
-0.0401033275,
0.051124718,
0.0014452185,
-0.0151366079,
0.0315735303,
0.0000819348,
-0.0754612535,
-0.0238904729,
0.0127571337,
-0.0480663106,
-0.0253234934,
0.005885412,
-0.0246616751,
-0.0436322689,
-0.0758239478,
0.0059331153,
0.022176642,
-0.032555908,
0.0049391766,
-0.0162829254,
-0.0198704395,
0.0548134446,
0.0037452129,
0.0061517754,
-0.0299009718,
-0.0338531695,
0.019331187,
-0.0023703985,
0.0076523563,
0.0049527315,
0.0268209856,
-0.0202618968,
-0.0360915586,
-0.0096611986,
0.0402496643,
0.0187835246,
-0.023468243,
-0.02182048,
0.0199155193,
0.0062495302,
-0.0087596858,
0.0426290371,
0.0554714017,
0.0377745032,
0.0151584856,
0.0039220182,
-0.0018856544,
-0.0374377295,
-0.0054082968,
0.0081012119,
-0.0269657783,
0.0427058078,
0.0426559113,
-0.0162236821,
-0.0059364759,
-0.0247077066,
2.382e-7,
0.0386560746,
0.0829490125,
0.0299361944,
-0.0238162,
0.0429846756,
0.0478638336,
0.0480136722,
0.0126280505,
-0.0241452083,
0.0067762076,
0.0202525761,
0.0483827554,
0.052302409,
0.0163179897,
-0.0313263685,
0.0198967196,
-0.0403218828,
-0.0133523447,
-0.0443720706,
0.0455008037,
0.0590059459,
0.070554018,
0.0157547537,
0.0062630321,
-0.0059863622,
-0.0442170836,
0.0269285198,
-0.0083836457,
-0.0310718324,
0.0646840781,
0.0363183841,
-0.0204303507,
0.0138143199,
0.0054332223,
-0.0001495771,
-0.0212952308,
0.0294244755,
0.0407677591,
-0.02341903,
0.0347761363,
0.0173714682,
-0.0224734116,
0.021976091,
-0.0437147878,
0.0430986211,
-0.0289120749,
-0.0734911636,
-0.0268655326,
-0.0032074198,
-0.0306552313,
-0.0109523106,
0.0120504862,
-0.0359553061,
0.0483408906,
-0.0010627785,
-0.0202277079,
-0.0123532163,
-0.0507898889,
0.0210007727,
-0.0128080342,
-0.0417611897,
-0.0422244854,
-0.0046092584,
-0.0043303105,
0.0333023183,
-0.0431303829,
0.0691589117,
1.884692707e-34,
0.0194908921,
0.0420639813,
-0.0282667186,
-0.0256452076,
0.0366295762,
0.0209860113,
-0.0208957698,
0.0171621405,
0.0163829233,
-0.0734189674,
0.004312207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07263v1
|
Span-Aggregatable, Contextualized Word Embeddings for Effective Phrase Mining
| 2024-05-12T12:08:05 | 2024-05-12T12:08:05 |
Eyal Orbach, Lev Haikin, Nelly David, Avi Faizakof
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dense vector representations for sentences made significant progress in
recent years as can be seen on sentence similarity tasks. Real-world phrase
retrieval applications, on the other hand, still encounter challenges for
effective use of dense representations. We show that when target phrases reside
inside noisy context, representing the full sentence with a single dense
vector, is not sufficient for effective phrase retrieval. We therefore look
into the notion of representing multiple, sub-sentence, consecutive word spans,
each with its own dense vector. We show that this technique is much more
effective for phrase mining, yet requires considerable compute to obtain useful
span representations. Accordingly, we make an argument for contextualized
word/token embeddings that can be aggregated for arbitrary word spans while
maintaining the span's semantic meaning. We introduce a modification to the
common contrastive loss used for sentence embeddings that encourages word
embeddings to have this property. To demonstrate the effect of this method we
present a dataset based on the STS-B dataset with additional generated text,
that requires finding the best matching paraphrase residing in a larger context
and report the degree of similarity to the origin phrase. We demonstrate on
this dataset, how our proposed method can achieve better results without
significant increase to compute.
|
[
0.0256001037,
0.0507828332,
0.0100599183,
0.0631889254,
-0.0338237882,
-0.013390271,
0.0290576685,
0.0052717011,
-0.0443436019,
-0.0254168976,
-0.0027854696,
-0.0182673205,
-0.0254316665,
0.0096692024,
0.0379582494,
-0.0461154543,
0.046189703,
0.0346071087,
0.0170011539,
0.0087385401,
0.0168880261,
0.0225907303,
0.0094098104,
0.0323380791,
-0.0218596309,
0.0008587299,
0.0484107286,
0.0075194659,
0.0469278581,
-0.0418022759,
0.0583348125,
-0.0046585971,
0.0847496688,
-0.0038699149,
0.0000016842,
-0.0071839518,
-0.0434050709,
-0.0144121246,
0.0043640472,
0.0557567589,
0.0688120872,
-0.0221158322,
0.0352573842,
0.0089526298,
-0.0239568967,
-0.0362746492,
0.000831697,
0.0327234752,
0.0431242995,
0.0376143828,
-0.0318721607,
-0.0238685515,
0.0022698026,
-0.0128396777,
0.0058582891,
-0.0701247528,
0.0115946606,
-0.0465775616,
-0.0036799943,
0.0189350098,
-0.0173155256,
0.0293274652,
-0.0040643923,
0.0081967115,
0.0399365015,
0.0428632572,
-0.074261196,
0.0338533409,
-0.006467565,
0.075186722,
-0.0309554748,
0.0097454237,
0.0296084117,
0.017458437,
-0.0242522079,
-0.0115638888,
-0.0608850978,
0.0195402354,
0.0159461964,
0.0317391753,
-0.0200244039,
0.0525360666,
0.0127920005,
0.0446910597,
-0.0448452123,
-0.0221201722,
0.0254136492,
-0.0390441753,
-0.0199210718,
-0.003411548,
-0.0888219848,
0.0324607082,
0.0271177143,
-0.0249811579,
-0.0346730538,
0.0400991477,
-0.021851318,
-0.0444792211,
0.0353570059,
-0.0363147967,
0.0314964056,
0.0081152683,
-0.022549361,
0.0690237805,
-0.0529984459,
0.03237148,
-0.0318730474,
0.0275127217,
-0.0502885506,
-0.0401743799,
-0.0344648622,
-0.0072088256,
-0.0562684238,
0.0640043095,
-0.0462616012,
-0.0244266242,
-0.0277383365,
0.030954428,
-0.0081905369,
0.0144042736,
-0.0504547991,
0.0626998767,
0.0045847911,
0.0036069269,
0.0205679182,
-0.0128898248,
-0.026396906,
0.025541462,
0.0050888225,
-0.0498078242,
-0.0508763827,
0.025414411,
0.0459190905,
-0.048439391,
-0.0111141196,
0.0301197954,
0.0082836319,
-0.0960604548,
-0.0182784162,
-0.0141728371,
-0.0512993298,
-0.0046051177,
0.0133509813,
-0.0592664257,
0.0590958595,
0.0049166414,
-0.0091360193,
-0.011731985,
-0.0016328784,
0.0490083285,
-0.0410214476,
0.0304713193,
0.0136917187,
-0.0456224456,
-0.0310959369,
0.0295333266,
0.0463872626,
0.0240221918,
0.0267498549,
0.0453236178,
0.064969033,
0.0329935439,
-0.0266043413,
-0.0197157674,
0.0500141643,
0.0156497173,
-0.0567136258,
0.0400072522,
0.0083150407,
0.0049923076,
0.0305508301,
0.0448800251,
-0.066978544,
-0.0188318659,
0.007904755,
0.0998077244,
-0.0078694616,
0.0396472216,
0.0273506511,
0.0306138303,
-0.0268296432,
-0.0116875675,
-0.0185465589,
0.0028126598,
0.0053832247,
0.0100430241,
0.0725898743,
0.0211244952,
-0.0326705687,
-0.0155923357,
-0.0200694762,
-0.0111093111,
-0.0159104671,
-0.0012583641,
0.02647282,
-0.0058329543,
-0.0441905484,
0.0807383433,
0.0252145752,
-0.1055515483,
-0.0373924524,
0.0182380807,
0.0030100525,
0.0564140975,
0.0811402947,
-0.0226033144,
0.0208516531,
0.0035513309,
0.0649724826,
0.0311695579,
0.024862159,
-0.0066067996,
0.0466070659,
-0.0457547195,
-0.0350109413,
-0.0127371848,
0.0054926109,
-0.003694853,
0.0111271823,
-0.0133604398,
0.0208175592,
-0.0355518423,
-0.0395558216,
0.0163802225,
0.0229737759,
-0.0026994285,
0.0371014215,
0.0197477769,
0.0107819904,
0.0313419513,
-0.0091726519,
0.0332050212,
0.0525305457,
-0.0896397382,
-0.0480164513,
0.012963946,
-0.0839852989,
-0.0781815425,
0.0085101668,
-0.0565281697,
-0.0080781709,
-0.0229794085,
-0.0543348454,
-0.0182255656,
0.0194031429,
-0.0864372924,
0.0501523018,
-0.0330834985,
-0.0104382494,
-0.0221928842,
0.0051226914,
-0.0472180434,
0.0908352509,
-0.023416061,
0.0328106731,
-0.007658862,
0.0422570854,
0.0545881987,
-0.0096156914,
-0.038151253,
-0.0119783552,
0.0212147348,
0.0143082328,
0.0251510236,
-0.0077785575,
-0.032047499,
-0.0019157698,
-0.0712671652,
0.0219555832,
-0.0036191472,
-0.02155881,
0.0116421711,
0.0146121997,
-0.0064486736,
-0.0358660966,
0.0019063239,
-0.020774819,
-0.0012066322,
0.0076142033,
0.0576386116,
0.0135540841,
-0.0111153796,
-0.0635028332,
-0.0268543642,
-0.0150765078,
0.0597184561,
-0.0312417205,
0.025529651,
0.0115720499,
0.0478023849,
-0.0265070293,
-0.0067559509,
-0.0111048399,
-0.0157240964,
-0.0193795711,
-0.0577987656,
0.0222094581,
0.0536474474,
0.0518789217,
0.0420204885,
0.0253214892,
0.0059650005,
-0.038679529,
0.0194791891,
-0.0264780466,
0.0177527145,
0.0207235236,
-0.0178639032,
0.0274909791,
0.009309642,
0.0418251269,
0.0067954888,
-0.0403263383,
-0.0184550155,
0.0239547174,
0.0190073531,
-0.037612848,
0.0158128515,
-0.0030167582,
0.0089001684,
-0.0599079095,
-0.0321592465,
0.0486886054,
-0.0111698341,
-0.0019963305,
-0.0475338958,
-0.0321242847,
-0.0465773977,
0.0201029535,
-0.0363667756,
0.0273285676,
-0.0447070785,
-0.0040680529,
-0.0116295228,
-0.013555062,
0.0007635807,
-0.0287972372,
0.0597530343,
-0.0074437568,
0.0018163278,
-0.0217738282,
-0.051358778,
-0.0407180116,
-0.0612127855,
0.0001097811,
0.0070719845,
-0.0227518249,
-0.0083538759,
-0.0353976898,
-0.0498142056,
0.0310259704,
0.0210250784,
-0.007810967,
-0.0152315795,
-0.0211915094,
0.0560482964,
0.0727793872,
0.0099860802,
0.0084574791,
0.0102724759,
0.0129128639,
0.0628898889,
0.0630353615,
0.0046509304,
-0.0371744148,
-0.0028063876,
0.0023250307,
-0.0037558922,
0.0028954116,
-0.0075096786,
0.018534692,
-0.0159361344,
-0.0454847626,
0.1056092605,
0.0370305851,
-0.0288492125,
-0.0166957695,
0.004072356,
0.0266105272,
0.0198113453,
-0.0128127662,
-0.0613226034,
-0.0343869589,
-0.0486338697,
0.0103021795,
0.0417762063,
-0.024051927,
-0.0192461908,
-0.0758203864,
0.0187779535,
0.0027452267,
0.020170629,
-0.0504041463,
-0.0369437635,
-0.0179473795,
0.0115745263,
0.0241085663,
-0.0158814285,
-0.0340996832,
-0.0037165987,
0.0011735086,
-0.0047538453,
-0.0269284267,
0.0266568325,
-0.0638881773,
-0.0219430532,
0.0473178476,
0.0528177992,
-0.0006563149,
-0.0443334393,
-0.0232499745,
-0.0849154964,
-0.0313698724,
0.0177386589,
0.0609020144,
-0.020715626,
-0.0165874176,
-0.0032759025,
-0.0035811318,
-0.0574167594,
-0.0435005203,
0.0312246345,
0.0538009107,
0.0030217711,
0.0227182172,
-0.0480584539,
0.0037518088,
-0.015873991,
0.0941073522,
0.0264576636,
-0.0189030711,
-0.0087409141,
0.0167375263,
0.0159642622,
-0.067475237,
-0.0222381484,
-0.0062490897,
0.0036778448,
0.0543276742,
-0.0482305475,
-0.0405877195,
0.033607997,
0.0550619774,
-0.0421044677,
0.0381919481,
-0.0192262083,
-0.0300249029,
-0.0641170144,
0.0233992543,
-0.0282677449,
0.0311145559,
0.0096707102,
0.0234068967,
0.0207389016,
-0.0053760433,
-0.0375267491,
-0.0165647361,
-0.0470601395,
-0.0303474795,
-0.016242506,
-0.0050050993,
0.0002919634,
0.0133071244,
-0.0157689042,
0.0029644065,
0.0832194835,
0.0358869322,
-0.0530954376,
0.0121105174,
0.0231984463,
0.0372466631,
-0.0024186107,
0.0357356593,
-0.058453612,
0.004905202,
0.0332755148,
0.0406461135,
0.0130016906,
-0.0017101766,
0.008799945,
-0.0399209782,
0.0676712319,
0.0021268076,
-0.0066407174,
-0.0161535386,
-0.0012989021,
-0.0006041641,
-0.0006243585,
-0.018066898,
0.0204530191,
-0.0216642618,
-0.0247266665,
-0.0197527781,
0.049809102,
-0.0127855008,
0.049767714,
-0.0458597578,
0.0228921063,
-0.0262717977,
0.026304245,
-0.0319144018,
0.0308566038,
-0.0289149377,
-0.0432638153,
-0.0597140305,
-0.0141236745,
-0.0322721973,
-0.006930822,
0.0099457297,
-0.0552020185,
-0.0334068723,
0.0680285692,
-0.0889488757,
0.0296445265,
0.0015718018,
0.0043921671,
0.0523720197,
-0.0675552785,
0.0185189825,
0.012085312,
-0.0140805049,
-0.0082595544,
0.017431641,
-0.0199019909,
-0.00978278,
0.0180416759,
0.0460618287,
-0.0290874243,
-0.023797363,
0.0483502448,
0.0263344031,
0.0390433259,
0.0058296332,
-0.0261822995,
-0.0270993449,
-0.0216009598,
0.0356853306,
0.0722043216,
-0.0097118737,
0.011664289,
-0.0287958458,
-0.0346451923,
0.0722136274,
0.0022547524,
-0.011004528,
0.0074613825,
0.0540513285,
0.0365440734,
0.0120321242,
-0.0084382705,
-0.0193607416,
0.041321855,
0.0068890192,
-0.0300822873,
-0.0305291992,
-5.731679965e-33,
0.01015276,
-0.0288333129,
-0.0086510833,
-0.015040596,
-0.0155106038,
0.0262990929,
-0.0471722223,
-0.0468514077,
-0.0429163575,
0.0190146361,
-0.0036705961,
0.0251881368,
0.0080115227,
0.0508657955,
0.0014258053,
-0.0002481993,
0.048373796,
-0.0118320473,
0.0052773808,
0.0239997562,
0.0554519929,
0.0446189605,
0.0476506762,
-0.0544053987,
-0.0156791788,
-0.0344742015,
0.0249657761,
0.0202627443,
0.0656578615,
0.0595512092,
-0.0167820137,
0.0476811603,
0.0301418714,
0.0270197671,
-0.0196944512,
0.0165845994,
-0.0867700651,
-0.0162290242,
-0.005485035,
-0.0393355452,
-0.0760916024,
-0.0311947782,
0.0116828866,
-0.0365505517,
0.020092262,
-0.0048000212,
0.0418065377,
-0.0333187096,
-0.0557534248,
0.0018519639,
-0.0219722241,
0.0111407042,
-0.0079867151,
0.0344730094,
0.0102557745,
0.0289089866,
0.0366137549,
0.0759749264,
-0.044244431,
0.0182865299,
-0.0645356029,
0.0210682657,
-0.0301016774,
-0.0121847559,
0.0050239079,
0.0672372803,
0.0037586896,
-0.080867596,
0.0062189,
-0.0102834515,
-0.0125245154,
0.0274626967,
0.0330320708,
0.0568607748,
0.0396735966,
-0.0306173302,
-0.062697269,
0.0148484958,
0.0018616484,
0.020049708,
0.065560028,
0.0276362412,
-0.0363436528,
-0.0101725543,
0.0065449378,
-0.0130645586,
-0.0395810492,
-0.0145878401,
0.0372806787,
0.0476159975,
-0.0039382344,
0.0004846992,
0.0206085984,
-0.0172592141,
-0.0156265572,
0.0374832936,
0.0101526892,
-0.0205545165,
0.0415933505,
0.0169970095,
-0.0246961992,
-0.0229620803,
-0.0012637518,
0.0227612387,
-0.007130011,
-0.018375827,
0.0826131701,
-0.0136893159,
-0.0540392585,
0.0154078994,
-0.0326003693,
-0.0538678467,
-0.0658635423,
-0.0298500713,
-0.0009285256,
0.0419010557,
0.0035824389,
0.0499691777,
0.0211261827,
-0.0217618179,
-0.0230567008,
-0.0237842947,
0.0075352127,
0.0204225294,
0.0078195799,
-0.0161343701,
-0.0284160152,
0.0448881499,
0.036310792,
-0.0591538362,
0.0109498277,
-0.0402083322,
2.399e-7,
0.0283186864,
0.0143575016,
0.0497898608,
-0.0167767163,
-0.0112300413,
0.013408334,
-0.001648278,
0.0514790639,
-0.0608789958,
0.0150166526,
0.0059027048,
0.0397290923,
0.0268672463,
0.0143692382,
-0.0706279427,
0.0559826307,
-0.0753058866,
-0.0339943171,
-0.0464810245,
-0.0104884934,
0.0993773118,
0.1002443954,
0.0094227614,
-0.0050154766,
-0.0281773545,
-0.0339075327,
0.0581121035,
-0.0194850732,
-0.0063099973,
-0.0310171507,
-0.0361695141,
0.0557175577,
-0.0161153469,
-0.0315950811,
-0.0232520401,
0.0894769058,
0.0622433648,
0.0616336428,
0.0270638019,
-0.0505563579,
-0.0181513857,
-0.0254351031,
0.0078117633,
0.0045030192,
0.0672917515,
-0.0389096662,
0.0213086754,
-0.0172541756,
-0.0095683923,
0.0543022119,
0.0379767492,
0.0264050458,
-0.0396800973,
-0.0102602849,
0.0145569658,
-0.0066527748,
-0.006629358,
-0.1352435797,
-0.0008055487,
0.0210982356,
-0.0400979109,
0.014355802,
-0.0371437222,
0.03627133,
0.0613815673,
-0.0253173988,
0.0266035683,
2.307002254e-34,
0.0194390956,
0.0044896235,
0.0045970408,
-0.0008562276,
0.0247749891,
-0.0336296074,
-0.0368536748,
-0.0227226801,
0.0222069137,
-0.0663284361,
0.0093524074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.10974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.10974v2
|
Bottleneck-Minimal Indexing for Generative Document Retrieval
| 2024-05-12T11:41:26 | 2024-05-21T01:29:13 |
Xin Du, Lixin Xiu, Kumiko Tanaka-Ishii
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We apply an information-theoretic perspective to reconsider generative
document retrieval (GDR), in which a document $x \in X$ is indexed by $t \in
T$, and a neural autoregressive model is trained to map queries $Q$ to $T$. GDR
can be considered to involve information transmission from documents $X$ to
queries $Q$, with the requirement to transmit more bits via the indexes $T$. By
applying Shannon's rate-distortion theory, the optimality of indexing can be
analyzed in terms of the mutual information, and the design of the indexes $T$
can then be regarded as a {\em bottleneck} in GDR. After reformulating GDR from
this perspective, we empirically quantify the bottleneck underlying GDR.
Finally, using the NQ320K and MARCO datasets, we evaluate our proposed
bottleneck-minimal indexing method in comparison with various previous indexing
methods, and we show that it outperforms those methods.
|
[
0.0125589175,
0.053316135,
-0.0222967025,
-0.0054119988,
-0.0493961237,
0.0219461955,
0.0024582779,
0.064660266,
-0.0230748057,
-0.0073253717,
-0.0132854767,
-0.0251231268,
-0.0587734804,
-0.0220333077,
0.0005378846,
-0.0183733962,
0.0358606055,
0.0234831553,
0.0093330499,
-0.0075532631,
-0.0227292739,
-0.0218143892,
0.0329862311,
-0.0090612564,
-0.0113513973,
0.0181496199,
-0.0322707184,
0.0219035912,
-0.0312248394,
-0.0039334409,
-0.0372797512,
0.024324948,
0.0285651125,
0.0568307005,
0.0000020002,
-0.0141702471,
-0.0189252403,
0.0155208567,
-0.0192882735,
0.0122121647,
0.0328994133,
-0.024287235,
0.0078077409,
0.0031864545,
-0.0256789345,
-0.0913075432,
0.0372656286,
0.064183332,
0.0014868389,
0.077208288,
-0.0370398872,
-0.0429953486,
0.037099611,
-0.0552472323,
0.0815266222,
-0.057738889,
0.0161162093,
-0.0120610492,
0.0128967771,
0.0443960987,
-0.0227435417,
0.0317170098,
-0.0025379795,
-0.0127227493,
0.0850360841,
0.0048905048,
0.0182414874,
0.0249910224,
0.0111903576,
0.0153200002,
0.008262584,
-0.025802942,
0.0131195113,
0.0069221845,
-0.029928796,
0.0370808952,
-0.0500113927,
-0.0108287958,
-0.0230399501,
0.0095899664,
-0.0080863349,
0.0519389287,
0.0278076343,
-0.0138306422,
0.015580737,
-0.0306948144,
0.0190050304,
-0.0245340075,
-0.0464558341,
-0.0344087109,
0.0223090928,
0.0254728552,
-0.0237503368,
-0.0099122068,
0.0475899987,
-0.0179383717,
-0.0017805565,
-0.0707169101,
0.0331621468,
-0.0492384508,
0.0038072534,
0.0264122318,
0.0502480753,
0.0698192865,
-0.0088518979,
0.0514074601,
-0.0254068766,
-0.0211097207,
-0.0251942109,
-0.0260093212,
-0.0326227918,
-0.0455555469,
-0.0433715694,
0.0526711121,
0.0037176902,
-0.0483162403,
-0.004253203,
0.0306276157,
0.0305167995,
-0.0578666143,
-0.0356152095,
-0.0083527844,
-0.0501305237,
-0.0028237323,
-0.0421161614,
-0.0119645642,
-0.0427127071,
-0.0089324228,
-0.0248312484,
-0.0277827922,
-0.0119733633,
0.0184376277,
0.0156656299,
-0.0212390963,
0.0004412825,
-0.005800264,
-0.0161742009,
-0.0213049818,
-0.0198907144,
-0.0445440784,
0.0464386716,
0.0025245305,
0.0145730199,
-0.0365632363,
0.0426427424,
0.0106141604,
-0.0100535424,
-0.0397434458,
-0.038841825,
0.0091394205,
-0.010337824,
0.0087810596,
0.0101908036,
0.0100027788,
0.076254271,
0.0140798818,
0.0485030897,
0.0620899796,
0.0034964334,
0.0338701382,
0.0243430603,
0.006236528,
-0.0086758463,
-0.0019030876,
0.031723883,
-0.0113381064,
0.0067812395,
-0.0313444063,
0.0057652271,
0.0321216956,
0.0093128569,
0.0411731191,
-0.0815315768,
-0.0426831543,
-0.0126845213,
0.0616574176,
0.0613281131,
0.0237756614,
-0.0237937625,
0.0022286717,
-0.0420758761,
0.0150300441,
0.0628045946,
0.0586562753,
0.0276794787,
-0.0416382663,
0.0675741732,
-0.0098092444,
-0.0532510094,
-0.0186502542,
0.0145643372,
0.0551190674,
-0.0391848274,
-0.028382767,
0.046246089,
-0.0064930464,
0.0027874976,
-0.0217516012,
-0.0278444309,
-0.0172831062,
-0.010843914,
-0.0149772009,
-0.0054592071,
0.0495476946,
0.0653442144,
-0.0118567171,
0.0416180938,
0.0222785436,
-0.0161214639,
-0.0155105162,
0.0227406491,
-0.0087767458,
-0.0008732592,
-0.0447602235,
-0.0377313085,
0.0224197675,
-0.0106435185,
0.0383389443,
-0.0107682133,
0.0280796718,
0.0429688469,
-0.0210409518,
0.024301203,
-0.0028166876,
-0.0020501642,
-0.0731012598,
0.0587681308,
0.0015456917,
0.0185273923,
-0.0102637718,
-0.028565798,
0.0032185141,
0.046399083,
-0.0305764806,
-0.0235562045,
-0.0203283038,
-0.0140431467,
0.0098357005,
-0.0137252649,
-0.0571293272,
0.0525663644,
-0.0033782779,
0.0137597024,
-0.0766365975,
0.032060843,
-0.0197753869,
0.0322835818,
-0.117181994,
-0.0319595635,
0.0038875497,
0.0102599049,
-0.0373001993,
0.030079538,
0.0209034141,
0.0495777503,
-0.0258053318,
-0.001628668,
0.0735667422,
-0.0492308475,
0.0062993779,
0.0244939718,
-0.0076460014,
0.0162071083,
0.0454272255,
-0.0292233005,
0.0301958248,
-0.0185271855,
-0.046794787,
-0.0121733109,
-0.0286079813,
-0.0207674615,
-0.0321097374,
0.0391764268,
0.0063448148,
-0.0399019867,
-0.0512650944,
-0.0043743988,
0.0168755259,
-0.0009172981,
0.0037996217,
0.0323284939,
-0.005813383,
0.0120226257,
-0.0698992535,
0.0224425364,
0.0224549845,
0.0217438955,
-0.0473426394,
0.0137265977,
0.0089456281,
0.0053973715,
0.0159192793,
-0.0439172834,
0.003106622,
0.007293398,
-0.0705710053,
0.0190521739,
0.0182229597,
0.0120343966,
-0.0412102081,
0.0259164292,
0.0205187667,
-0.1013623402,
0.0414868519,
-0.0397964083,
0.0200052559,
0.0292970054,
-0.0335448422,
0.0386479646,
0.028514713,
0.0006015818,
-0.0111537753,
-0.0514269471,
0.0159014072,
0.0018419657,
-0.0077268207,
-0.0975294858,
0.0120538902,
0.0371868275,
0.0357402526,
-0.0033229114,
-0.0638143867,
0.0058885813,
0.0045249746,
0.0180053432,
-0.010681076,
0.0095380712,
-0.0255623329,
0.0614515543,
0.0138704041,
0.0335696451,
0.0137801254,
-0.0179475043,
0.0100635868,
0.0666358918,
0.0459021553,
-0.0250648241,
-0.022101786,
0.0287973154,
0.0711706355,
-0.0134115946,
-0.0721279308,
0.0013732259,
-0.0358131081,
0.0862529352,
-0.0102889678,
0.0720842332,
-0.0342733189,
-0.012577137,
0.0409619026,
0.0138132852,
0.0267521665,
-0.0308100041,
-0.0417147614,
0.0241227746,
0.0390166789,
0.0383985266,
-0.0319290236,
-0.0208498556,
0.0204833914,
-0.0274709892,
0.0119587183,
0.0501723588,
0.0501240902,
0.0012199687,
0.0098259775,
0.0349338539,
0.0125066461,
-0.0393266641,
-0.0185071118,
-0.0656552166,
0.0257662572,
-0.0342018045,
0.0540441312,
0.0254325587,
-0.0987454355,
-0.049816478,
-0.0090662995,
0.004226556,
0.000992507,
0.0579812452,
-0.048038654,
0.0289354715,
-0.0028683087,
0.0466003641,
-0.038915962,
0.001791125,
-0.0035945508,
-0.0714594573,
0.053602349,
-0.0170330256,
0.0327978916,
-0.0333449543,
-0.068129614,
-0.0405217074,
0.0260068066,
-0.0467078127,
0.0101272976,
-0.0188157186,
-0.0400795601,
0.034199208,
0.0256156884,
-0.0404952429,
-0.0585582815,
-0.0111956866,
0.0171394441,
0.0286939982,
0.0007989375,
0.0141467983,
-0.0259563886,
-0.0165170655,
-0.0061731786,
0.0044186004,
-0.0259524342,
0.0340966433,
-0.0060375161,
-0.0038245465,
-0.0274954904,
-0.0414136611,
0.0301700737,
0.0490488932,
-0.0394994058,
0.0265445746,
-0.0392281003,
0.0284173246,
-0.0472845845,
-0.040762689,
-0.0126080876,
0.0699756891,
-0.0123380274,
0.0365228914,
-0.0097101135,
-0.0004139034,
0.0748558566,
-0.046806816,
0.0054175002,
0.0124225859,
0.0239831302,
-0.0348738618,
-0.0675240979,
-0.003475527,
-0.061262738,
0.0627837703,
-0.0159410499,
0.0502804853,
-0.0438231565,
-0.034073554,
-0.0294768848,
-0.0573378168,
0.0199980605,
-0.0526356623,
-0.0718409717,
-0.0138972523,
0.0371224657,
-0.046715688,
-0.0247846954,
-0.0155410869,
-0.0364959762,
-0.0326665454,
-0.0024712405,
0.0095773358,
0.0164500736,
0.0069028428,
-0.0061056912,
-0.098997049,
0.0418444425,
0.0935905576,
-0.021054972,
-0.002239743,
-0.0245938003,
-0.0657460243,
-0.048334755,
0.0162228048,
-0.043564219,
0.0429479405,
-0.04429093,
0.0029302095,
-0.052450154,
0.0130370138,
-0.0054899226,
0.0299297031,
0.0431911536,
0.0153725445,
0.0149549078,
-0.0484721437,
0.0217496604,
-0.0091151167,
0.0051837903,
-0.0109746447,
-0.042247925,
0.0725520253,
-0.0140493019,
-0.0449261144,
0.0705770925,
0.0393699333,
-0.0096729938,
-0.0275709685,
-0.0371107943,
-0.0299029183,
0.007623319,
-0.0129445652,
0.0076909554,
-0.0277082324,
0.0056833881,
0.0287670828,
0.0324848555,
-0.0424392335,
0.0011645317,
0.0388672315,
0.0152999293,
-0.0166650023,
-0.0050805681,
-0.0671029463,
-0.0521724261,
0.0065281237,
-0.0210635904,
0.0451234207,
0.0014562748,
-0.0147387655,
-0.0287771802,
0.01097639,
-0.0236665718,
-0.0302159749,
0.0530558862,
0.0030861907,
0.0002267246,
0.0401558653,
0.0029741118,
0.0094763003,
0.076391831,
0.0547379106,
0.0162232276,
-0.0418354571,
-0.0216023214,
-0.0029405465,
0.0120647131,
0.0408424214,
0.0092079611,
0.0006184531,
-0.0104673207,
0.0050991774,
0.0260939058,
0.0271549206,
0.0036477651,
0.0134565448,
-0.0109901223,
0.0505012646,
0.0669692904,
-0.002276205,
-0.0328305587,
-0.0262110606,
-0.0263643283,
-0.0662402064,
-0.0079226065,
0.0004146323,
-6.688451919e-33,
0.0067354976,
0.0258702803,
0.001702122,
-0.0008175463,
-0.0034570282,
0.0189140942,
-0.0002711076,
-0.0672424063,
-0.0075870589,
-0.0100720404,
-0.0305373259,
0.0478294976,
0.0077641192,
0.0175994933,
0.0186533649,
0.0277633313,
0.0609225817,
-0.0184431951,
-0.0094872164,
0.0500036478,
0.0552925095,
0.0372274555,
0.000486146,
-0.0082048718,
-0.0342711136,
-0.0095359003,
0.0332879238,
-0.0082167583,
0.0441214219,
0.0639913008,
-0.0370179154,
0.0121143395,
0.012215184,
-0.0672272816,
0.0111201936,
-0.0028321948,
-0.0899005085,
-0.0761884078,
-0.0530360676,
0.0007745412,
0.0309655052,
-0.0255395398,
0.0091080572,
-0.0038699133,
-0.051983811,
0.0153288944,
0.019302072,
0.0491562746,
-0.0789266974,
-0.1003555581,
-0.0072684754,
0.0243825167,
0.0361369848,
0.0374458283,
0.0444256328,
-0.0077688908,
-0.0099484548,
-0.0117428899,
-0.0499280579,
0.023586534,
-0.0081215613,
0.0888774544,
-0.0567317605,
0.0237261709,
0.0614111051,
0.0462935604,
0.0599763542,
-0.0010125039,
0.007697063,
0.0153580438,
0.0429673716,
-0.0271667,
0.0007595202,
0.0416824855,
0.115468815,
-0.0245756023,
-0.0784136131,
0.0892144069,
0.02866528,
0.0379452556,
0.0302889012,
0.0444346182,
-0.0853068233,
-0.0335251093,
-0.0176825132,
0.0079503804,
-0.0044899383,
-0.0129602691,
0.0248897709,
0.0605879575,
0.0180397108,
-0.0511722825,
0.0686798394,
0.0040462948,
-0.0274558384,
0.0462813936,
0.0109004211,
0.0217359662,
-0.0023683507,
-0.0123853898,
-0.0244728439,
-0.0165224876,
0.0560980923,
0.0249680486,
-0.0120060463,
-0.0313672535,
0.0058071488,
0.0227457825,
-0.0685875192,
-0.0375919007,
0.009662481,
0.0146008562,
0.0014709819,
-0.0526650101,
0.0021875256,
-0.004583966,
0.0271019265,
0.0288023949,
0.0212306418,
0.0470432043,
0.0173177179,
-0.0640549809,
0.0059102378,
-0.0196684878,
0.0264944639,
0.0632718801,
-0.0476207957,
0.0160250552,
0.0464367792,
-0.0604331195,
0.0079279756,
0.0878083408,
2.833e-7,
0.0033167792,
0.0119607775,
0.0258029159,
0.0427308418,
0.0276180096,
-0.0163764674,
0.009524256,
0.0353401229,
-0.0091305869,
0.0198075566,
0.0375189558,
0.0134138539,
0.0163813755,
-0.0073583652,
-0.0943227261,
0.0116866017,
-0.0237871893,
0.0157248545,
-0.0322804376,
-0.0444259904,
0.0041558975,
0.0565316901,
-0.0429998673,
0.0096888961,
0.04105689,
-0.0628333762,
0.0635292828,
-0.0262448452,
0.0251093321,
0.0153867621,
0.0894096866,
0.0245332066,
-0.002210798,
-0.0186724812,
-0.0000838616,
0.0223520938,
-0.0256952252,
-0.0006503084,
-0.0416504927,
-0.0452557206,
0.0206087567,
-0.0101632811,
-0.0287038218,
0.0091917375,
0.0713069811,
0.0147475004,
-0.0031238105,
0.0552360639,
-0.0031235123,
0.026573224,
0.0177314058,
0.0035236713,
-0.0474257581,
0.0066491794,
0.0017105609,
-0.0099779181,
0.0316131152,
-0.0360167921,
0.0744155347,
0.0015266723,
-0.0304584485,
0.036467962,
-0.0651522279,
0.038511537,
0.0145918708,
0.0182834584,
0.0013155944,
2.25006241e-34,
0.0217452031,
0.0109080672,
0.001493272,
-0.0056926897,
-0.0076104142,
-0.0067595416,
-0.0458929352,
0.0406161286,
-0.005982344,
-0.0948516354,
-0.0239895284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07248v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07248v1
|
Limited Ability of LLMs to Simulate Human Psychological Behaviours: a Psychometric Analysis
| 2024-05-12T10:52:15 | 2024-05-12T10:52:15 |
Nikolay B Petrov, Gregory Serapio-García, Jason Rentfrow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, 68T50, I.2.7
|
The humanlike responses of large language models (LLMs) have prompted social
scientists to investigate whether LLMs can be used to simulate human
participants in experiments, opinion polls and surveys. Of central interest in
this line of research has been mapping out the psychological profiles of LLMs
by prompting them to respond to standardized questionnaires. The conflicting
findings of this research are unsurprising given that mapping out underlying,
or latent, traits from LLMs' text responses to questionnaires is no easy task.
To address this, we use psychometrics, the science of psychological
measurement. In this study, we prompt OpenAI's flagship models, GPT-3.5 and
GPT-4, to assume different personas and respond to a range of standardized
measures of personality constructs. We used two kinds of persona descriptions:
either generic (four or five random person descriptions) or specific (mostly
demographics of actual humans from a large-scale human dataset). We found that
the responses from GPT-4, but not GPT-3.5, using generic persona descriptions
show promising, albeit not perfect, psychometric properties, similar to human
norms, but the data from both LLMs when using specific demographic profiles,
show poor psychometrics properties. We conclude that, currently, when LLMs are
asked to simulate silicon personas, their responses are poor signals of
potentially underlying latent traits. Thus, our work casts doubt on LLMs'
ability to simulate individual-level human behaviour across multiple-choice
question answering tasks.
|
[
0.0502815843,
0.0512346365,
-0.0576413721,
0.0013470561,
-0.0349600613,
0.0112188077,
0.0170674752,
-0.0092511252,
0.0391126163,
-0.0124136433,
-0.0297395177,
-0.03855085,
0.0130585963,
-0.0143613396,
0.0368261002,
-0.0536056235,
0.0154334353,
-0.0109298471,
0.0188069344,
-0.0251486301,
-0.021532895,
0.0250491407,
0.0255258456,
0.0349101834,
0.0233814567,
-0.0169827528,
0.0077951909,
-0.0421579592,
0.0383818224,
-0.0092060324,
0.0345111527,
0.046126008,
0.0189431906,
-0.0229371302,
0.0000020227,
-0.0355939008,
0.0483138487,
0.0100272121,
0.0241045281,
0.0514090247,
0.0588133968,
0.0640894249,
-0.0017510303,
0.0386553295,
-0.0611566789,
-0.0058551384,
0.0233107693,
0.0305503663,
0.0289435051,
0.0123082865,
-0.0028304667,
-0.0362411663,
0.0215156786,
0.0168488361,
0.007697823,
0.0029429572,
0.0291196592,
-0.0382809937,
0.0002343112,
0.0067129727,
0.0085915029,
-0.0299815554,
0.01391342,
0.0537750088,
-0.0137444017,
0.0134589747,
-0.0242958609,
-0.024413757,
0.018248653,
0.0550900362,
0.0687908456,
-0.0260959323,
-0.0314471051,
-0.0101240296,
0.0135532254,
0.0336644799,
-0.0018821006,
0.0213404633,
-0.009239668,
-0.0155559527,
0.0085256575,
0.0309374705,
0.0030793338,
0.0080545479,
-0.0117651904,
0.0555786528,
0.0163694229,
-0.0328597389,
0.006330438,
-0.0092880875,
-0.0214927923,
-0.0373484902,
-0.0112734893,
0.0199835915,
-0.0221144017,
0.0286850538,
-0.0230011027,
0.0036762548,
0.0566349179,
-0.0481416211,
0.024592299,
0.0458545424,
-0.0168752968,
-0.0031812454,
0.0415897518,
0.0732906982,
0.0059429365,
0.0131002553,
-0.0320192277,
-0.0138769764,
-0.0496760421,
-0.0277497023,
0.0229192749,
0.0202017017,
0.0367621481,
-0.0163039416,
-0.049953267,
0.0093799746,
-0.0233175885,
-0.0382813662,
-0.0190906916,
-0.0015606257,
-0.0122843785,
0.0267641339,
-0.0920332745,
0.0217221137,
-0.0710667893,
0.0261502266,
0.004537432,
-0.0496524163,
0.050117448,
0.0243121013,
-0.0122153861,
-0.0237981733,
0.0338357389,
0.0079410207,
0.0094249556,
-0.0262891371,
-0.0323311985,
-0.0064681047,
-0.0075765625,
-0.0692718923,
0.0126467645,
-0.0572278351,
0.0280625299,
0.0270085335,
-0.022354221,
-0.0410502665,
0.0145814512,
0.0594297908,
-0.0372014344,
0.0469870307,
0.027412314,
0.0406468101,
0.0147830965,
0.0242534839,
0.0275384467,
0.0272750072,
0.0335791036,
-0.0247599166,
0.0401945971,
-0.0390346199,
0.0285247695,
0.0606719479,
-0.0133997835,
0.016975034,
0.0227009673,
0.029023543,
0.0010460385,
0.0064991703,
0.0611420199,
0.0610809028,
-0.0087503269,
-0.0141935972,
0.0922885314,
0.0968239456,
-0.0225063879,
0.0371722206,
0.0324078463,
0.0171196721,
0.0489184707,
0.0315399542,
-0.0243069213,
0.0028028055,
-0.0196194388,
0.0199331027,
0.0079049421,
0.0450212471,
-0.0270290691,
-0.013665528,
-0.0083175106,
-0.0057069007,
0.0236255322,
0.0261755139,
0.0034371156,
-0.0245958194,
0.0038883246,
0.0244308282,
0.0232115779,
-0.0664749369,
-0.0235464629,
-0.0758739337,
0.0286273193,
0.0498489328,
0.0189745445,
0.0091182925,
0.02115467,
0.0098895431,
-0.0191816743,
0.0399735756,
0.074035503,
-0.01471873,
-0.03885879,
-0.0212624837,
0.0321310386,
0.006097795,
-0.0055610724,
0.0158953369,
0.0457685813,
0.0008874049,
0.0010500789,
-0.0410926193,
0.0166347865,
0.0104907174,
-0.0972031802,
-0.02207724,
-0.0296843965,
-0.0005350443,
0.0522159003,
0.0149106244,
-0.0003351351,
0.0214888547,
0.0100485338,
0.017247811,
0.01354127,
-0.0046390709,
0.0056547979,
0.0492999442,
0.0052686981,
0.000011893,
-0.0110246148,
0.0633628368,
0.0257519335,
-0.0107054822,
-0.0073466785,
-0.0264915433,
0.017468499,
-0.0213212073,
-0.0141579546,
-0.0346418992,
0.0530330017,
-0.0191435572,
0.0683501661,
0.0007609456,
0.02418934,
0.0362349339,
0.0068396768,
0.0080979168,
-0.0647035539,
-0.0279320478,
-0.0291933063,
0.0241127778,
0.023454925,
0.0064206203,
-0.0216236636,
-0.061858356,
-0.0402776636,
-0.1044058576,
0.0037939611,
0.0202144571,
0.0157586057,
0.0159736369,
0.0091976738,
-0.0501963608,
0.030753864,
-0.0750708878,
-0.0063766241,
0.0126636755,
0.0464449264,
0.0236299764,
-0.0319338404,
0.0062384428,
-0.0432807989,
0.0099162096,
-0.0509564131,
-0.0021976151,
-0.0331361629,
0.0672565624,
-0.0073769162,
0.0223452374,
-0.0629409775,
0.0052136364,
-0.0094576627,
-0.0482650995,
0.0603155494,
0.0150789302,
0.084507592,
0.0851444975,
0.0418924093,
0.0410006642,
-0.0041974117,
0.0132530406,
-0.0353611037,
-0.0092672342,
-0.0268433336,
-0.024705546,
-0.0304685216,
-0.1127907708,
-0.0053004562,
0.0185265169,
0.0350840837,
0.0084980428,
-0.0600666478,
0.0490809232,
-0.0170862917,
-0.0366833024,
0.0357519947,
0.0234026257,
-0.042609375,
0.0478407741,
-0.0065660668,
-0.0237001441,
0.0487052985,
-0.0007179935,
0.0179790948,
-0.0189660322,
-0.0075206314,
-0.030308662,
0.0619688667,
0.0239467826,
-0.0259158295,
0.0297956653,
0.0354061164,
-0.0663329735,
-0.0228680912,
-0.0146745844,
-0.0514049083,
0.0099140434,
-0.0261739846,
-0.038252309,
0.0190302171,
-0.0109807327,
-0.0231836233,
-0.0470774435,
-0.0318833627,
0.0062138103,
0.0223492701,
-0.031066861,
0.0006325613,
-0.0241053626,
0.0344571508,
-0.039007619,
-0.0328151472,
-0.0083735455,
-0.0015355689,
0.0210477374,
0.0763976872,
0.0326426737,
0.0547783263,
-0.0389742404,
0.0145173064,
0.0235647857,
0.0029564032,
0.0045512882,
-0.0073426422,
-0.0057695452,
0.0118062953,
0.0046627689,
-0.0222442131,
0.0598645471,
0.0470610783,
0.0076395324,
-0.0093067763,
0.1038343087,
0.0322867334,
-0.0233945828,
0.0138010271,
0.0043809805,
0.041997999,
0.018576568,
0.0377642661,
-0.0263382513,
0.0119775524,
-0.0201495439,
0.0241349693,
-0.0634157583,
-0.0241389815,
-0.0076910532,
-0.1206580922,
0.036115855,
-0.0139083285,
-0.0511134751,
0.0134511823,
-0.0541336015,
0.0349413864,
0.0038242226,
0.0224907324,
-0.0200951081,
0.0174491256,
0.0025470357,
-0.0162682571,
-0.0592507198,
-0.0352855213,
0.0933389664,
-0.018236896,
0.0753352866,
0.0291040167,
0.063983798,
-0.0251923315,
-0.0672279,
-0.032552287,
-0.0254245792,
0.011777333,
0.0229874384,
0.0329064764,
-0.00889201,
0.0324023515,
-0.1038724035,
0.0202370062,
-0.049877245,
-0.0195598677,
0.0095032407,
0.061320696,
0.0144413915,
-0.0528451912,
-0.041439537,
0.0048653325,
0.003275638,
0.0567953251,
-0.0001756037,
-0.0862219408,
0.0002762103,
-0.0087388353,
-0.0020297563,
0.0143139912,
-0.0886985138,
0.0004661959,
0.012568038,
-0.0143263461,
-0.0221544169,
-0.1095016524,
0.0071819946,
-0.0221278872,
-0.00081994,
-0.0341860093,
0.0196097773,
0.0011875995,
-0.0145445447,
0.0062415227,
-0.0422371626,
0.0299966726,
-0.0093418937,
-0.0207817182,
0.0698962361,
-0.0388659649,
-0.0029553236,
-0.00925205,
-0.0453526713,
-0.0395573266,
0.0183007196,
0.0361568816,
0.0263414811,
-0.0282300431,
0.022544805,
-0.0454993322,
-0.005140929,
-0.0275992695,
-0.0246343054,
0.0615666993,
-0.0400428362,
0.0511254147,
0.0022542111,
0.002727946,
0.0038143862,
0.0116035147,
0.0107396692,
-0.0256475229,
-0.0219322089,
-0.1097738072,
0.0285616722,
0.0245788954,
0.008287048,
-0.0045779981,
-0.0025403765,
-0.0129156457,
-0.0462184809,
-0.034595862,
0.0034444805,
0.0096590053,
-0.0868411213,
0.0203654096,
0.022524748,
-0.0246963259,
-0.0393746644,
-0.0389263257,
0.0470004007,
-0.0357089043,
-0.0146612488,
0.0317650028,
0.0408099964,
-0.0198637694,
0.0037509883,
-0.0233884566,
-0.0248573795,
-0.0342931822,
0.0650673509,
0.025505539,
0.0794136375,
-0.0229136422,
-0.0017139261,
0.0368052907,
0.0135306763,
-0.0700098798,
-0.0442251004,
0.0067744385,
0.0108375959,
-0.0307651311,
-0.0000224788,
0.0069017778,
-0.0383714847,
0.014103855,
-0.0332608409,
-0.0005278511,
0.0023210172,
-0.0168575868,
0.0421671383,
0.0027421229,
-0.0159587301,
-0.0155711835,
0.0530295558,
0.0252741482,
-0.0030353507,
-0.0195018575,
-0.0427551195,
-0.0259833708,
0.0013466148,
0.0093552433,
0.0338306874,
-0.0234670155,
-0.0389870293,
-0.091791071,
-0.0630953684,
0.010799475,
0.0187742431,
-0.0008887778,
-0.0367140919,
0.0044910377,
0.0564437993,
-0.0364810452,
-0.0392802097,
-0.0331882983,
0.0253777374,
-0.0863744691,
0.0117837284,
-0.0302106962,
-6.237355962e-33,
-0.0440615825,
-0.0258554183,
0.0210978668,
0.0012595417,
-0.0377553143,
-0.0572846755,
-0.0225169677,
0.0263336916,
-0.0556000881,
-0.0115111377,
-0.0417656377,
-0.0042669126,
0.0154235633,
-0.0069009284,
0.0091456017,
-0.0079142135,
0.0206807293,
-0.0393038876,
-0.0252969675,
-0.0115581974,
-0.0179032292,
-0.0508111492,
0.0201799851,
-0.0600266233,
0.0469252244,
-0.0587041155,
0.006658182,
-0.0256342851,
-0.0226364881,
0.0607895367,
-0.0347534381,
0.066926904,
0.0473979935,
0.0037767864,
0.0224522538,
0.0808138177,
-0.0319663472,
-0.0442852527,
0.0402833857,
0.0159324724,
-0.016204603,
-0.0608164668,
0.0081942677,
-0.0116893854,
-0.0509801507,
-0.0233508646,
0.0684931651,
-0.0244706739,
0.035634011,
0.0022102599,
-0.0440031551,
-0.024291588,
0.0207425989,
0.0110672927,
-0.0698886588,
0.0564091019,
-0.0540453792,
0.0151021173,
-0.0775771216,
0.0575780347,
-0.0028915482,
-0.0351458453,
0.0332395919,
0.0192629918,
0.03588368,
0.0289534554,
0.0774812251,
0.0320558473,
-0.0538182221,
-0.0422769524,
0.0546800196,
-0.0010561157,
0.0501642749,
0.0791918635,
-0.012802179,
-0.0572841167,
-0.0044744685,
0.0158634726,
0.0664291829,
-0.0487864353,
0.0502099358,
0.0194553118,
-0.0447872132,
-0.032913398,
-0.0268893242,
-0.0045359163,
-0.0256230533,
-0.0419204943,
0.043353159,
-0.0452373847,
-0.0028616076,
-0.0509118438,
0.0389668085,
-0.0382308699,
-0.0084638055,
-0.0317122824,
-0.0231449101,
0.0564891137,
-0.0036808415,
0.0056657689,
-0.0738438889,
-0.0015062132,
-0.0095697884,
0.0285536628,
0.052322343,
0.0399742536,
-0.0271954853,
0.0095868707,
-0.0508576483,
-0.0272148605,
0.0117804725,
-0.0140789738,
0.0359199531,
0.0029877261,
0.0170099549,
0.0046734745,
0.0206019469,
-0.0225387365,
0.0024658418,
-0.0144451102,
-0.0531982817,
-0.005903543,
-0.0083200382,
-0.0148464367,
-0.0107587464,
0.0141323144,
-0.0492926165,
0.025329899,
0.0159795359,
-0.02051902,
-0.0039112251,
0.0204066578,
2.661e-7,
-0.0090225777,
0.0485488884,
-0.0295825899,
0.0509836189,
0.0349624306,
0.0434766449,
0.0311816726,
0.0030914324,
0.0805167034,
-0.0590623245,
0.0219598766,
0.0198810231,
0.0300905872,
0.0251626354,
-0.0635929182,
0.0097570503,
0.0039332765,
0.0127907796,
-0.0253424197,
0.0182393771,
0.0828906,
0.0360241942,
0.0228145868,
0.0052794674,
-0.0395446122,
0.0140076904,
0.0554951951,
-0.0202481914,
-0.0269479863,
0.0138269719,
-0.0118683139,
0.0049834978,
0.0122730145,
0.0947246179,
0.0107991509,
-0.0040121949,
0.022499159,
0.0473885015,
-0.0099518495,
-0.0506924689,
-0.0057147057,
-0.0289927013,
-0.0154222874,
-0.0726346001,
0.0566712804,
-0.0365994349,
-0.0586227179,
-0.0196550265,
-0.0154287843,
-0.0235845502,
0.0208774209,
-0.0185728092,
-0.0123829329,
-0.0040053078,
0.0244320296,
-0.0017006933,
0.0077966587,
-0.0130286627,
0.0066654538,
-0.0141672576,
-0.0477078743,
-0.1021682322,
-0.0242567975,
0.0238519106,
0.0233492665,
-0.0594053902,
0.0157924145,
2.252255212e-34,
-0.0095357401,
0.0409295745,
0.0158165824,
-0.0122959502,
0.0556265824,
0.0026072359,
0.0193037689,
0.0267946869,
0.0533093922,
-0.0749727115,
-0.0134053109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13003v1
|
A Survey on Recent Advances in Conversational Data Generation
| 2024-05-12T10:11:12 | 2024-05-12T10:11:12 |
Heydar Soudani, Roxana Petcu, Evangelos Kanoulas, Faegheh Hasibi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Recent advancements in conversational systems have significantly enhanced
human-machine interactions across various domains. However, training these
systems is challenging due to the scarcity of specialized dialogue data.
Traditionally, conversational datasets were created through crowdsourcing, but
this method has proven costly, limited in scale, and labor-intensive. As a
solution, the development of synthetic dialogue data has emerged, utilizing
techniques to augment existing datasets or convert textual resources into
conversational formats, providing a more efficient and scalable approach to
dataset creation. In this survey, we offer a systematic and comprehensive
review of multi-turn conversational data generation, focusing on three types of
dialogue systems: open domain, task-oriented, and information-seeking. We
categorize the existing research based on key components like seed data
creation, utterance generation, and quality filtering methods, and introduce a
general framework that outlines the main principles of conversation data
generation systems. Additionally, we examine the evaluation metrics and methods
for assessing synthetic conversational data, address current challenges in the
field, and explore potential directions for future research. Our goal is to
accelerate progress for researchers and practitioners by presenting an overview
of state-of-the-art methods and highlighting opportunities to further research
in this area.
|
[
0.0718795955,
0.0595815554,
-0.0163385365,
0.0213667806,
-0.0085410131,
-0.0167069472,
-0.0015885391,
-0.0081891073,
-0.0020826843,
-0.0397533104,
-0.027161669,
-0.0329783782,
-0.0009137203,
0.0582154877,
0.0156595688,
-0.0553259812,
0.0177447088,
-0.0051452192,
0.0068254466,
0.0300246384,
0.0243055578,
0.0185301378,
-0.0411689505,
0.0538629852,
-0.0503475443,
0.018292794,
-0.0374876559,
0.0220138654,
0.0355597138,
-0.0228758361,
0.0144596919,
0.0357916839,
0.0291977711,
0.0221004989,
0.0000018609,
-0.0258999299,
-0.001072088,
-0.0317443572,
-0.0458442941,
-0.0697531477,
0.0124856969,
0.0165031012,
-0.0000243909,
0.0346976407,
-0.0771339461,
-0.0072302041,
0.0358551815,
0.028930774,
0.0657361969,
0.0918278322,
-0.018904699,
0.0038450549,
-0.0128426403,
0.0133121246,
0.0234084371,
-0.0027154544,
-0.0275892783,
0.0323029645,
0.0179562271,
0.0284225643,
0.0151237138,
-0.0021746201,
0.0153500112,
-0.0425901152,
0.0288831983,
0.0263908301,
-0.0426328331,
-0.028605558,
-0.02586326,
0.1091979593,
0.0365690291,
0.0008122401,
-0.0023846528,
-0.0139864339,
0.0029926198,
-0.0423795506,
-0.0317920707,
0.0225556921,
-0.0137929246,
0.0124872746,
-0.0414738245,
0.0468224846,
-0.0132515822,
0.0025470781,
0.0014912839,
-0.0026220093,
-0.0181396678,
-0.0242723953,
-0.0099763647,
-0.0086637987,
0.0177442636,
-0.0671089366,
-0.017098166,
0.0048302393,
-0.0701225251,
0.0296475347,
-0.0742511749,
-0.0128244581,
0.0061377306,
-0.0086664697,
0.0245412067,
0.0217123535,
-0.0168664195,
0.0052286768,
0.0485915206,
0.0039796322,
-0.0093690045,
-0.0181031283,
-0.0143099325,
-0.0178597663,
-0.0223532673,
0.015545601,
-0.0230578836,
-0.0004135966,
-0.0946909413,
-0.0220701136,
-0.0174093228,
0.0517141111,
0.0027214941,
0.0086700357,
0.0289920215,
0.0398791097,
-0.0354310833,
0.0243424866,
-0.0294732898,
-0.0405006856,
-0.0407186449,
0.029650826,
0.041975569,
-0.0930829197,
-0.0047353599,
0.0490408391,
0.028652342,
0.0016497612,
-0.0058578146,
0.064445883,
-0.0181042328,
-0.0396216214,
-0.0139959408,
-0.0258192737,
-0.0246309713,
-0.0598930605,
-0.003335048,
-0.0056272051,
0.0689575598,
-0.0131976847,
-0.0238622986,
-0.0053121452,
0.0322146714,
0.0401065908,
-0.0001885162,
0.0530875251,
-0.0601522774,
0.0121815884,
0.0189953819,
-0.0013475422,
-0.0121427327,
0.0695690811,
0.076195702,
0.0182541329,
0.0588606037,
-0.0135281589,
0.0180859976,
0.0036847999,
0.0239355341,
-0.0235581845,
0.0383582674,
0.0450921878,
-0.0355252028,
0.0390225835,
-0.002608544,
0.0470668562,
-0.0447178558,
0.0153480517,
0.067199111,
0.0269480832,
0.0100836894,
0.0345479473,
0.0692658797,
0.0562950484,
-0.0065979464,
-0.0209344868,
-0.0014220206,
0.0082269181,
0.0023212922,
-0.0005496636,
0.0518204272,
0.0168550741,
-0.024664823,
-0.0469317026,
0.0105865104,
0.0192655008,
0.0178175922,
0.0004825707,
0.0004318169,
0.0222704504,
-0.0648714527,
0.0161021482,
0.0136235245,
-0.0826743767,
-0.0219564941,
-0.0106834378,
-0.0014112202,
0.0822802261,
0.0590359978,
-0.0151603743,
-0.0156533923,
-0.0140183335,
0.012945395,
0.067821689,
0.0178103875,
-0.0296814963,
0.0427554026,
-0.085736692,
0.004019904,
0.0141545199,
-0.0256286189,
0.0026267751,
0.0180854499,
0.0029638298,
0.0302177984,
-0.0097406693,
-0.0138621135,
0.0221647639,
-0.0240608174,
-0.0051999097,
0.0560230911,
0.0017489736,
0.0236913152,
0.0520857386,
-0.0084721446,
-0.012369548,
0.0371271744,
0.0199599415,
-0.0052531394,
0.0665790588,
-0.0522500537,
-0.0547779724,
-0.0154242143,
-0.0510458536,
-0.0072717802,
0.004218915,
-0.0178009588,
-0.0540422089,
0.0007711587,
-0.0638049915,
0.0055045346,
-0.0504950806,
-0.0029580221,
0.0746221393,
0.0474590547,
0.000499705,
0.035787195,
0.0162032992,
0.0003628672,
0.0426071547,
0.0207287706,
0.0107337078,
-0.0730068088,
0.0343254283,
0.0009106031,
-0.0202566963,
-0.0004808884,
0.0185065251,
0.0220196955,
-0.0790818185,
-0.0311819259,
-0.1144062057,
0.0146234585,
-0.0031952448,
-0.0172985829,
0.0152282398,
0.0125354482,
-0.0167121906,
-0.0251144301,
-0.0732845441,
0.0121018346,
0.0653715655,
-0.0353734642,
0.0505182818,
0.0222382322,
0.001504201,
-0.0345989168,
0.0418153182,
0.0245091524,
0.0300567783,
0.0116444947,
0.0018197022,
-0.0397677831,
0.019937465,
-0.0397705138,
0.0465745367,
-0.0254611429,
-0.0228125863,
0.0527961552,
0.0220971946,
0.0397061184,
0.0149217751,
0.0692683458,
0.0442869477,
-0.0175790917,
-0.056271363,
-0.0470738336,
0.0496488735,
-0.033346381,
0.0368061215,
-0.0238859355,
-0.0372263156,
0.0370509401,
-0.0065351017,
0.0234511048,
0.0461157262,
-0.0566104539,
0.0264133085,
0.0557733588,
-0.0589671284,
-0.0129317353,
0.0105439229,
-0.0507432483,
0.0360638835,
-0.0155249052,
-0.0231949352,
0.0426679999,
-0.0385709405,
-0.0317527093,
-0.0356884338,
-0.0136465402,
-0.0318292081,
0.034529075,
-0.0252124984,
0.0040512914,
0.0119481012,
0.0076528946,
-0.0078656496,
0.0134101706,
0.0110735642,
-0.0361674465,
0.0148313697,
-0.0396082588,
-0.0072989953,
0.0263019446,
-0.0420774184,
-0.0685655326,
-0.039180655,
0.0144242113,
-0.0302519575,
0.0563302152,
-0.0406964682,
-0.0150712682,
-0.0215755831,
-0.0121202311,
0.0370889157,
0.0213343967,
-0.0147144608,
-0.0324338078,
0.0403458811,
0.0470332913,
0.0467934981,
-0.0050342372,
0.0015834273,
0.0636929199,
0.0288074277,
0.0426685363,
-0.0214978699,
-0.0025134056,
-0.028636558,
0.0162137318,
0.0182515308,
0.0194580015,
0.0129592288,
0.0532992519,
0.0089277886,
-0.0332376324,
0.0808574557,
0.0254500378,
-0.0034998124,
0.0077156909,
-0.007336278,
0.0257175025,
-0.0161179695,
0.009149163,
-0.0881354511,
-0.0286232959,
-0.0034133394,
0.0467048511,
-0.0554191731,
-0.0589857101,
-0.036771372,
-0.1039315984,
0.0571171492,
-0.0189202428,
-0.0633412004,
-0.0455876775,
-0.0023348196,
-0.0062078754,
0.0050467798,
-0.0012567922,
-0.0232156049,
0.0232116412,
0.0115755536,
-0.0008028795,
-0.0091933385,
-0.0499974973,
0.0093247816,
0.0037624766,
0.05775268,
0.0416773632,
0.0628807992,
0.0601688884,
-0.019078739,
-0.0061538504,
-0.002833592,
-0.0089407284,
0.0021984356,
0.0772034973,
-0.0372302607,
-0.0239632633,
-0.0297791976,
0.0573999882,
-0.017018795,
-0.0099958871,
0.027073741,
-0.0104032308,
-0.0754338503,
0.0243996959,
-0.0033619711,
0.0495135114,
0.0876628831,
0.0697356239,
0.0425135531,
-0.0548492,
-0.0011443512,
-0.0163575131,
0.0195033345,
-0.0940753445,
0.0058641997,
-0.008281732,
0.028035365,
0.009297506,
-0.0979386643,
-0.0766665787,
0.0262532383,
0.0251739435,
-0.0295227915,
-0.0306280144,
0.0079635233,
0.0057934951,
-0.0186441857,
0.0035579619,
-0.0130350413,
-0.0042630709,
-0.0439586565,
-0.0690099671,
0.0122083938,
-0.0600698926,
-0.0038704444,
0.06427636,
-0.0700383335,
-0.0334250741,
-0.0181420837,
0.0467940606,
0.0191846173,
0.0601223409,
0.0184568781,
0.0037229648,
-0.0124012157,
0.044106368,
-0.0391278043,
-0.020224236,
0.0371523723,
0.0511167832,
0.0000641885,
0.0386922285,
-0.014213888,
0.0189481322,
-0.0228288695,
0.0293836165,
-0.027694881,
-0.0870624259,
0.0144029325,
-0.002895595,
0.0405886732,
-0.0040975786,
-0.0152305374,
-0.0248396751,
0.0255745277,
-0.0672165975,
-0.0384365134,
-0.082691431,
0.0089740176,
-0.0346323587,
-0.0113590956,
0.0137228658,
0.0055805519,
-0.0728862658,
0.0315411575,
-0.0323419236,
-0.0082051223,
0.0217449106,
0.0204880163,
0.014278532,
-0.014905991,
-0.0179611389,
0.0305311531,
-0.0013442577,
0.0378429741,
0.0333525985,
0.0790690184,
0.0174992271,
-0.0513577349,
0.0300981496,
0.0544201471,
-0.0815012306,
-0.0118156839,
-0.0414267257,
0.0476026461,
0.005358886,
0.019652836,
0.0414732695,
-0.0408846214,
0.0337692238,
0.0047380994,
0.0607699789,
0.0013853427,
-0.0475641973,
0.0005749532,
-0.0055377716,
-0.0413650312,
-0.0054321606,
0.0756995976,
-0.0071115699,
0.0221481156,
-0.0363698639,
0.0048028762,
-0.0843201205,
-0.0261798967,
-0.0014609266,
0.0123754172,
0.0151948119,
0.00320978,
-0.0525198132,
-0.0275755003,
-0.0280890334,
0.0213585217,
0.0025397826,
0.0013265924,
0.0624415092,
0.0489657298,
-0.0125440005,
0.020255506,
-0.0432833992,
0.0127898026,
-0.0334620476,
-0.0064259265,
-0.0337548666,
-5.541105882e-33,
-0.0224596094,
-0.039481543,
0.0243489817,
-0.0022095945,
-0.0299216807,
-0.0328923799,
-0.033640027,
-0.0153513346,
-0.0133626703,
-0.016328726,
-0.0280691329,
0.0047453567,
0.0065559084,
0.0636156946,
-0.0264725219,
-0.0202527791,
0.0404580384,
-0.0159157123,
-0.0198403597,
0.049693495,
0.057091184,
-0.0008625929,
0.0064439015,
-0.0758230463,
0.0355055556,
-0.0315859951,
-0.0231243763,
0.0285169408,
0.0358528495,
0.0335548632,
-0.0198486689,
0.0398767479,
0.0076968232,
-0.0366493538,
-0.0341382027,
0.0353463963,
-0.0243621971,
-0.0109138358,
0.00150626,
-0.0137341619,
-0.0367192589,
-0.0021269275,
-0.0047093453,
-0.0244645439,
0.0054950952,
0.0287629552,
0.0010358762,
-0.0422381088,
0.0172918085,
-0.0266046021,
-0.0170347374,
0.0200029947,
-0.03010354,
-0.0854949877,
-0.0212477352,
0.1088222787,
0.0406633019,
-0.0357037373,
-0.036412172,
0.0803558677,
-0.0077190343,
-0.0365590826,
0.0272268448,
0.0331686921,
0.0166116878,
0.0593578033,
0.0308017768,
0.0245750137,
-0.0260475874,
-0.0243025087,
-0.0405379049,
0.0663921237,
0.0059927171,
0.0752514973,
-0.0173026733,
-0.0074681966,
-0.014354392,
0.0481455103,
-0.0119557837,
-0.0194135085,
-0.0297237039,
-0.0242240075,
-0.0364364535,
0.0056602336,
-0.0025082361,
-0.0124115553,
0.0104982136,
-0.0091591887,
0.0347490944,
0.020538535,
-0.0032433888,
-0.0125542544,
0.010035811,
-0.0237044059,
0.044009801,
0.0226672478,
-0.0471773818,
-0.0038216461,
-0.0180705115,
-0.0418393165,
-0.0521189831,
-0.0336369835,
0.1049472317,
0.0388703197,
-0.000987271,
0.0222306959,
-0.0141268428,
0.0050415159,
-0.0203521997,
0.0241110567,
-0.0134553201,
0.095056124,
-0.0542891584,
-0.0089883907,
0.0092940107,
0.0061146053,
-0.0570937172,
0.0629071221,
-0.0104390085,
0.0269401614,
-0.0221229643,
-0.0233236067,
0.0271748658,
0.0218209885,
-0.0232847892,
0.0209224261,
-0.0138815707,
-0.0426670499,
0.034179274,
-0.0170423463,
0.0069872825,
-0.0227528065,
2.522e-7,
-0.0283252858,
0.0100074159,
0.0373903289,
0.0186953582,
0.0040629669,
0.0406975336,
0.01852143,
0.0293212775,
0.0077065779,
-0.0303850733,
0.0259290412,
-0.0034621397,
0.0687493011,
0.0239160676,
-0.101323396,
-0.0610705428,
-0.063969478,
-0.0516472086,
-0.0161384717,
-0.003849332,
0.0840981081,
0.0351900384,
-0.0185628664,
-0.0003801816,
0.0107894791,
0.0144818295,
0.0309766177,
-0.050206013,
-0.026417641,
-0.0008660386,
0.0389040262,
-0.020690456,
-0.0232884344,
-0.0105875311,
-0.026686687,
0.0266768001,
0.0000049535,
0.0262404252,
0.0370613858,
-0.0776609853,
0.00115179,
0.0160378441,
0.0033222097,
-0.0259625223,
0.0248737745,
-0.0371383764,
-0.0189931653,
-0.0025206862,
-0.0101388125,
0.0084076598,
-0.001638404,
-0.0413541906,
-0.0351680629,
0.0161838681,
0.0084048826,
0.0079164952,
0.0400713757,
-0.0565386526,
-0.0014534086,
-0.0407428518,
-0.0749276504,
-0.0579612292,
-0.0163762588,
-0.0364549085,
0.0206569601,
0.0084437802,
0.0037873341,
1.807197898e-34,
0.022527745,
0.0176819246,
0.0174868107,
-0.0005601014,
0.0419416539,
-0.0086626215,
0.0236039404,
-0.0029991914,
0.0358760096,
-0.0555686802,
-0.0209503565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13002v1
|
DuetRAG: Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-05-12T09:48:28 | 2024-05-12T09:48:28 |
Dian Jiao, Li Cai, Jingsheng Huang, Wenqiao Zhang, Siliang Tang, Yueting Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) methods augment the input of Large
Language Models (LLMs) with relevant retrieved passages, reducing factual
errors in knowledge-intensive tasks. However, contemporary RAG approaches
suffer from irrelevant knowledge retrieval issues in complex domain questions
(e.g., HotPot QA) due to the lack of corresponding domain knowledge, leading to
low-quality generations. To address this issue, we propose a novel
Collaborative Retrieval-Augmented Generation framework, DuetRAG. Our
bootstrapping philosophy is to simultaneously integrate the domain fintuning
and RAG models to improve the knowledge retrieval quality, thereby enhancing
generation quality. Finally, we demonstrate DuetRAG' s matches with expert
human researchers on HotPot QA.
|
[
0.0402065292,
0.0158962272,
-0.0162291955,
0.0105408421,
-0.0414844677,
-0.0115773035,
-0.0052909278,
-0.0125157246,
0.0200038683,
-0.0495099574,
-0.0234880149,
-0.0465141498,
-0.0299040265,
0.0183117464,
0.0453335382,
-0.0105213607,
0.0282895621,
-0.0019273473,
-0.0246496778,
-0.023812158,
-0.0024731043,
0.008570916,
-0.0090346672,
0.0442219786,
0.0000454014,
-0.0145938471,
-0.003956323,
-0.009363628,
0.0165428668,
-0.0304579716,
0.0463147797,
0.0340017378,
0.0161021929,
0.0449492186,
0.0000019315,
-0.05386585,
-0.0303093605,
0.0131560536,
-0.0199373588,
0.0003360973,
-0.0016534642,
0.0484164096,
0.0283626933,
0.0348124206,
-0.0668852702,
-0.0031426887,
0.003542688,
0.0448936373,
0.055543486,
0.0498082452,
0.0179884266,
0.0012493698,
0.0126808984,
-0.0536677539,
0.0078210924,
-0.0562936738,
0.011445431,
0.0547925793,
0.0112592969,
0.0354915485,
0.0146035524,
0.0415810831,
0.0181524791,
-0.0266032517,
0.0276413765,
0.0176052917,
-0.0627438053,
-0.0173789002,
0.0285159443,
0.0825851858,
0.0774278343,
-0.0114353346,
0.0131228212,
0.0292607043,
0.0235364027,
0.0990137383,
-0.0528988242,
0.0147805801,
-0.0196508411,
-0.0120755546,
-0.0175019503,
-0.021460453,
0.0220227502,
0.0172478836,
0.0041441955,
0.085893549,
0.0223384537,
-0.0209784694,
-0.0133441901,
0.0155383525,
-0.0392783061,
-0.0230548661,
0.0074196002,
0.0464071184,
-0.0308436789,
0.0051638531,
0.0026955362,
-0.0332724713,
0.0371668115,
0.029723499,
0.0317726135,
0.0117904609,
-0.0066534742,
0.0175002385,
-0.0259262491,
0.0048088208,
0.0075324285,
-0.0386847854,
-0.06941735,
-0.0114270616,
-0.0425359458,
-0.0365883,
-0.047724653,
0.0376372598,
-0.0579744428,
-0.0003473113,
-0.0308543853,
0.0128051117,
-0.0199513063,
0.0104323803,
-0.014969172,
0.0484332182,
-0.0569824129,
-0.0220542327,
-0.0479202494,
0.0470077507,
-0.0331430696,
0.0220819134,
0.0626552776,
-0.0472291037,
-0.0091863293,
0.0114174429,
-0.0164184328,
-0.0074469978,
-0.0115769533,
0.0262271538,
-0.0197332408,
-0.009994843,
-0.0148907928,
-0.0867249891,
-0.0014064095,
-0.0542587973,
0.006167776,
-0.0657513663,
0.0240333881,
0.0213960148,
-0.0230636839,
-0.0553574078,
0.0157596227,
0.0442307517,
-0.0091279261,
0.0341183543,
-0.0163358897,
0.0098389732,
0.0595441349,
0.0384192169,
-0.024183413,
0.0518548414,
-0.0094607603,
0.0340576097,
0.0313367248,
0.0316140801,
0.0063581471,
-0.0067647528,
0.0404162183,
0.0207348224,
-0.0151691251,
0.0465686359,
0.0283653084,
0.0294711795,
0.0172717292,
0.052349478,
-0.0511268079,
0.0492326617,
0.027848281,
0.0227473825,
0.0380807295,
0.0424278602,
0.0628950894,
0.0127060721,
0.0088105462,
0.0314859301,
-0.0134504652,
0.0197698642,
-0.0180926993,
0.0048396746,
0.0416997261,
0.0557892546,
-0.0296518411,
-0.0337906815,
0.0053710761,
0.0284569766,
-0.0483838283,
0.0319354534,
0.0233768225,
0.022147119,
-0.0166461878,
0.0599458031,
-0.0031804556,
-0.0615836047,
0.0304528642,
-0.0238722134,
0.0425086133,
0.0319223665,
0.0889387429,
-0.03100341,
-0.0544662736,
0.02167622,
-0.0198472142,
-0.0144462632,
0.0640130118,
-0.0327324606,
-0.0523097329,
-0.0572792664,
-0.0378638171,
-0.009212194,
0.0167608671,
-0.0109465756,
0.0257820152,
-0.0083249863,
0.0873970985,
-0.0449133962,
-0.0117182164,
0.0191847198,
-0.1125453934,
-0.0073584709,
0.0000830146,
0.0027230224,
-0.010784409,
0.0190943945,
-0.0000594898,
0.0435176119,
0.0306700207,
-0.0318970904,
-0.0390684679,
0.0075133056,
-0.0173099618,
-0.0562808365,
0.0223959852,
-0.022443058,
-0.0063634259,
0.0199798197,
-0.0235041752,
-0.0414053202,
0.0105866147,
-0.0052137407,
-0.0204958115,
-0.0770913884,
-0.0045432411,
0.0301057082,
0.0065665799,
-0.0587090403,
0.070537895,
0.0173692312,
0.0241650771,
0.02781423,
0.0264287908,
0.020776242,
-0.0568801127,
0.0068350793,
-0.0048018559,
-0.0246157832,
0.0339797139,
0.038395606,
-0.0074480865,
-0.0859892592,
-0.0185290743,
-0.0632922873,
0.0206796285,
-0.0203472096,
0.0093474658,
0.0072500138,
0.0110926563,
-0.0011503741,
-0.0029479791,
-0.06953834,
-0.007253468,
0.0186210983,
0.009878628,
0.0186217725,
0.0370639563,
0.0383217596,
-0.0276045315,
0.0199627355,
-0.0116153033,
0.0235956367,
0.0201391485,
0.0392393358,
-0.06521862,
0.0649968758,
-0.0570596494,
-0.0005719126,
-0.0041453731,
0.0093048755,
0.0137341749,
-0.015270466,
0.0886866748,
0.021839045,
0.0057708137,
-0.0107049309,
0.0441685133,
-0.0293800309,
-0.0699183345,
0.0263732374,
-0.0448863879,
-0.0272201411,
0.0298714377,
-0.0117280334,
0.0261937715,
0.0148714902,
-0.0020951657,
-0.0399227142,
-0.0306582563,
0.0441522114,
-0.022595726,
-0.0134512354,
-0.0310609192,
-0.0122788502,
-0.0090182219,
0.0472924672,
-0.0091759767,
-0.0242234226,
0.0793689042,
-0.0286217593,
0.0163955707,
-0.0713232681,
0.0225900598,
-0.0536617339,
0.0384117886,
-0.0311945677,
0.0155757861,
-0.0051092794,
-0.0037893648,
-0.0652779862,
0.0185962971,
0.0252243616,
-0.0700064152,
0.038994953,
-0.0391834378,
0.0243664086,
-0.0057042716,
-0.0361576602,
-0.0643511713,
-0.036262501,
0.0056269425,
0.0137034776,
-0.0027611915,
0.0028280313,
-0.0133532863,
-0.0057476838,
0.039363984,
-0.007283336,
-0.0293562524,
-0.0178549681,
-0.0116966376,
0.074180983,
0.0810970142,
0.0200241487,
0.016209837,
-0.0297149774,
0.0145637393,
0.0433126874,
0.0613798052,
-0.0145396348,
0.0293513313,
-0.038507238,
0.0435762927,
-0.0176819377,
-0.0197431706,
0.0124307331,
0.0538402498,
-0.0512545072,
-0.0364157706,
0.0785312057,
0.0384570733,
-0.0096474104,
-0.0256099254,
-0.050454326,
0.0555519052,
0.0257226154,
0.0766230747,
-0.0729374364,
-0.0100421682,
0.0074845818,
0.0584179685,
0.0100075519,
-0.0440268032,
-0.0197077766,
-0.1561387032,
0.0468548201,
0.0168309901,
0.0107947215,
-0.016085092,
-0.0192010105,
0.0105590448,
0.0289120208,
0.0126206269,
0.0549126528,
-0.010097038,
0.0405512527,
0.0482161678,
0.031712275,
-0.0367355756,
0.0088098943,
-0.0464701541,
0.0392956622,
0.0749201924,
0.0108557325,
0.0321500525,
-0.0155050196,
-0.0272139013,
-0.0281621348,
0.0176569242,
0.004572494,
0.0281914193,
0.0210387949,
-0.0020104251,
-0.0216545518,
0.0329783,
-0.0217936095,
-0.0131886834,
0.0175859667,
0.0601970218,
-0.0360003151,
-0.0031357715,
-0.0353156924,
0.0249455106,
-0.0072474456,
0.0605981313,
0.0494536385,
-0.0008774365,
-0.0008245391,
-0.0013549688,
0.0176223628,
-0.0605826005,
-0.0320152417,
0.0326087363,
-0.009300733,
0.0220241658,
-0.0944610834,
-0.0515089594,
0.044402726,
0.0599132888,
-0.0019554312,
0.0214231182,
-0.0210191868,
-0.0039631776,
-0.030573085,
0.040901009,
-0.07532534,
-0.0049249278,
-0.035834685,
0.0001698727,
0.0476762317,
-0.0550302677,
-0.0107610999,
0.0170045476,
-0.0423517227,
-0.0698756725,
-0.0113827521,
0.0338388868,
0.0235442556,
0.0199938323,
-0.0203793813,
-0.0522486754,
0.0223060716,
0.0780026987,
-0.063063696,
-0.0087989718,
-0.0209503714,
-0.0238321703,
-0.0445456095,
0.040573556,
-0.0527204536,
0.0194325615,
-0.0229411311,
0.0877111703,
0.0091679795,
-0.0756014064,
0.0448222011,
0.0309115294,
0.03917519,
-0.0007476121,
0.0120962551,
-0.0278453585,
-0.0045408825,
-0.0029161079,
-0.0358535051,
-0.0307381377,
0.0310505964,
0.0069608856,
-0.0300057158,
0.0281117,
-0.0051826988,
-0.0019616985,
0.0902374983,
-0.0427339673,
-0.0260059908,
-0.0229204148,
0.0175719336,
0.0345609002,
0.0004088004,
-0.0184778459,
-0.003610003,
-0.0109479045,
0.0542574897,
-0.0149020543,
0.0535796434,
0.0167782772,
0.022076074,
-0.0032518019,
0.0119721889,
-0.0653826818,
-0.0682845339,
-0.0378688797,
-0.0098474631,
0.0228637438,
0.005565329,
0.030102469,
-0.0136449784,
-0.0207129195,
-0.0294862278,
0.0247376934,
-0.0013617794,
-0.0236300435,
0.028553877,
0.034001451,
-0.0238027778,
0.0096780723,
0.0925891027,
-0.0171226915,
0.0222809445,
-0.036182072,
-0.0337123685,
-0.0227690246,
-0.0510851294,
0.0223057717,
-0.0135347713,
-0.0156769734,
0.0152559467,
-0.0885270014,
-0.0841556638,
-0.0171082076,
0.0024458983,
-0.0188994091,
-0.0081733083,
0.0334928446,
0.0866354629,
-0.0156024331,
0.0115540605,
-0.0611954182,
0.071227327,
-0.0567891411,
-0.0166620873,
0.004598042,
-6.60287593e-33,
-0.0417780131,
-0.0647439584,
0.0576113015,
-0.0320604146,
-0.0431949794,
-0.0014525255,
-0.0268655214,
-0.0106972652,
-0.0291930698,
-0.0054311347,
-0.0065836478,
0.0004929167,
0.0026967726,
0.0112214219,
0.010089891,
0.0042603565,
0.0483524799,
0.0221030917,
-0.0432623923,
0.0452929512,
0.0433422141,
0.0520244651,
-0.0041201371,
-0.0579905994,
0.0140137216,
-0.0495460406,
0.0149956709,
0.0263790991,
0.0022606489,
0.0225985814,
-0.0025659199,
0.0365862399,
0.0066908523,
-0.0680712909,
-0.0008126196,
-0.0160494335,
-0.0806329101,
-0.0209217407,
0.0078616934,
-0.0472186692,
-0.0424075462,
-0.0390670635,
0.0238377973,
-0.0162235014,
0.0051762895,
-0.0015516795,
0.0276821479,
-0.0379080586,
-0.0211970173,
-0.0438644588,
-0.0453017503,
0.0129926382,
0.0110692745,
-0.033563409,
-0.0308270659,
0.0790582076,
0.0199850202,
0.0161020104,
-0.0247776732,
0.0292217601,
0.0147709269,
0.0836692899,
0.0611071438,
-0.004169798,
-0.0064399005,
0.0331439488,
-0.0334011093,
-0.0005385465,
-0.0002584928,
-0.0302909929,
-0.007826224,
0.061638806,
0.0028838762,
0.1026553437,
0.0127964122,
-0.0262028128,
-0.0335884057,
0.075708665,
0.0065915706,
0.025051089,
-0.006197521,
-0.0188674256,
-0.016205309,
-0.0202957354,
-0.0487463139,
0.0515083559,
-0.0341773555,
-0.0457096808,
0.0493835807,
0.0267421193,
-0.0433545075,
0.0037590454,
0.0088416077,
-0.0308886711,
0.0328115411,
-0.0153616797,
-0.0454761721,
-0.0229728092,
-0.0278076343,
0.0445204824,
-0.0329767503,
-0.0212401133,
0.0106438426,
0.013407683,
-0.0132838339,
0.0107489051,
0.0153798088,
0.0037148914,
-0.031579487,
0.000699249,
-0.0322536863,
0.0291020442,
-0.0051058657,
-0.0182251856,
-0.00549522,
0.0407253392,
-0.0109616406,
0.0272791013,
0.0237326492,
0.0082358373,
-0.0305045061,
-0.0276260152,
0.0104857115,
-0.0167641472,
-0.0123160295,
0.0327296183,
-0.0203538667,
0.0349667296,
0.0296443347,
-0.0240312461,
-0.0313532166,
-0.005277717,
2.83e-7,
0.0402589478,
0.035659302,
0.0071421522,
-0.0164793581,
-0.0137455659,
0.0469493829,
0.0017009996,
0.014992239,
0.0550180972,
0.0231464654,
0.0008037463,
0.0088185873,
0.0357177816,
0.0388111696,
-0.0815621167,
-0.0320769623,
-0.067837365,
-0.0220627934,
-0.0149639985,
-0.0439153649,
0.0473873168,
0.0393123031,
-0.0123509932,
-0.0327526256,
-0.0183086786,
-0.0579168089,
0.090360336,
0.0291494913,
-0.0545301437,
0.0577412397,
0.0605602749,
0.0059441221,
0.0121759288,
-0.003207196,
-0.0154642584,
0.0186721031,
0.0211434998,
0.0010850236,
0.0512417331,
-0.0275598038,
-0.0004077613,
-0.0144848283,
0.0342386812,
-0.0572081581,
0.0436946936,
-0.0704728961,
-0.0142548494,
0.0083057564,
-0.0381514803,
-0.014581562,
-0.0153235262,
-0.0082391622,
0.0032693283,
0.0225901846,
-0.0222207718,
0.0213173591,
0.0047876979,
-0.0437600911,
-0.0221486427,
-0.0080430089,
-0.056776952,
-0.0666401237,
-0.028367104,
-0.034584906,
-0.0383922756,
-0.0586768314,
0.0378755294,
2.555202147e-34,
0.0267760232,
0.0162993912,
-0.0024423725,
0.0031636809,
0.0364510864,
-0.0060094451,
-0.0414069965,
0.0251279455,
0.014017961,
-0.0611208677,
-0.0163998399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07195v1
|
InsightNet: Structured Insight Mining from Customer Feedback
| 2024-05-12T07:40:12 | 2024-05-12T07:40:12 |
Sandeep Sricharan Mukku, Manan Soni, Jitenkumar Rana, Chetan Aggarwal, Promod Yenigalla, Rashmi Patange, Shyam Mohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose InsightNet, a novel approach for the automated extraction of
structured insights from customer reviews. Our end-to-end machine learning
framework is designed to overcome the limitations of current solutions,
including the absence of structure for identified topics, non-standard aspect
names, and lack of abundant training data. The proposed solution builds a
semi-supervised multi-level taxonomy from raw reviews, a semantic similarity
heuristic approach to generate labelled data and employs a multi-task insight
extraction architecture by fine-tuning an LLM. InsightNet identifies granular
actionable topics with customer sentiments and verbatim for each topic.
Evaluations on real-world customer review data show that InsightNet performs
better than existing solutions in terms of structure, hierarchy and
completeness. We empirically demonstrate that InsightNet outperforms the
current state-of-the-art methods in multi-label topic classification, achieving
an F1 score of 0.85, which is an improvement of 11% F1-score over the previous
best results. Additionally, InsightNet generalises well for unseen aspects and
suggests new topics to be added to the taxonomy.
|
[
0.0448781326,
0.0037077912,
-0.0111007309,
0.0654981658,
-0.0094357478,
0.0143399742,
-0.0158645101,
0.0143692875,
-0.010801388,
-0.0766803101,
-0.070233129,
0.0195182711,
-0.0335307382,
0.0728461742,
-0.0418177657,
-0.0289856214,
0.0084317103,
0.0322645083,
0.0160551667,
0.0640664697,
0.0206535105,
0.0519961379,
-0.0275135003,
0.0286385473,
-0.0020627829,
-0.029981235,
0.0097548719,
-0.003708363,
0.0168391448,
-0.0191124436,
0.0472706258,
-0.0011571681,
-0.0134754339,
0.0138559574,
0.0000022001,
-0.0194913615,
-0.0356726646,
-0.0313636847,
0.0077987947,
-0.0059750048,
0.0534903184,
-0.0013418786,
0.0429761596,
0.0070123412,
-0.0309134014,
0.0185486469,
-0.0275391731,
0.141408667,
0.0643105507,
0.019404551,
-0.0347348936,
-0.0262201447,
-0.0431034751,
0.0115341162,
-0.0034023316,
-0.0359760635,
-0.0137699861,
0.020432936,
-0.0420783758,
0.0706583038,
0.0284704175,
0.0002455902,
-0.0090780444,
-0.0001829931,
0.0402460769,
0.0183293708,
0.0025764725,
0.0131535446,
-0.0356705002,
0.0372388884,
-0.0028571512,
0.0196992699,
-0.000581738,
-0.0510367155,
-0.0092583913,
-0.0371594168,
-0.0043987702,
-0.0220718496,
-0.0081885019,
0.022209296,
-0.0185342487,
0.0208251011,
0.0036578004,
-0.0503100343,
0.0141375363,
0.0791821331,
-0.0440343767,
-0.0178496931,
0.0308567602,
0.0302781444,
0.0130348662,
-0.020688504,
-0.0264356155,
-0.018596543,
-0.0147329783,
0.00147307,
0.0213195905,
0.0010879874,
0.0152529245,
-0.0813032091,
0.0444178022,
-0.0532012247,
-0.0118712503,
0.0407406986,
-0.0271681529,
-0.0445289053,
0.0013222881,
-0.0060077747,
-0.0655883923,
-0.0010043983,
-0.0903307274,
-0.0122431433,
0.012679196,
0.074227266,
0.0027583116,
-0.017652439,
-0.0440569185,
-0.0132618072,
-0.0191012975,
0.017940687,
0.0276867617,
0.0227939524,
0.010793753,
-0.0081628505,
-0.0574763305,
-0.0160449464,
-0.0617702939,
0.0706038922,
-0.0402234867,
0.0339347199,
0.0184718687,
0.0472793654,
0.0235683545,
0.0362734385,
-0.0028133611,
0.0173124094,
-0.0089845723,
-0.0463696606,
-0.0917087793,
-0.0639514029,
-0.0195776708,
-0.0172740985,
-0.0001208151,
-0.0483672917,
0.0190088507,
-0.0195104424,
-0.0410792641,
0.0295762904,
0.0089263637,
0.0110096708,
-0.0074699302,
0.0495161489,
-0.0659754127,
-0.0298540778,
0.0169857144,
0.0142160673,
0.0402518436,
0.0145081384,
-0.0049220305,
0.0628201291,
0.0551939011,
0.0323032439,
-0.0012034525,
-0.0169876236,
0.0041486104,
-0.0357421711,
0.0283101797,
-0.0002160799,
-0.0662814379,
-0.0292698052,
-0.0045061777,
-0.0027515171,
0.0297765229,
0.0464262255,
0.022986725,
0.0170967132,
-0.0080045322,
0.0705219582,
-0.0021547512,
0.0377002805,
-0.0277046487,
-0.0036255701,
0.0531410202,
0.0271988008,
0.0026988401,
-0.0158857573,
0.0061705583,
-0.0495302938,
-0.0288129207,
-0.0708869398,
-0.0083438279,
-0.0156025169,
-0.0274801962,
-0.0191052221,
0.0464856029,
0.0404455699,
-0.0500002578,
0.0311134346,
0.0403848067,
-0.0237748884,
-0.0482249521,
-0.0154806254,
0.0595258959,
0.0513772778,
0.0131616909,
-0.0372497514,
-0.0140838418,
-0.0111830793,
-0.0509691834,
0.0063954592,
0.031732358,
-0.0158492476,
-0.0433290303,
-0.0255850777,
-0.0098824445,
0.0033919567,
0.0173162557,
0.0202548206,
-0.0490076467,
0.0166750234,
0.0130131328,
0.0021994726,
-0.0049704402,
0.0218865555,
0.033318866,
-0.0054700226,
0.0429043658,
-0.0162041821,
0.0555857122,
0.0588335395,
-0.0010849353,
-0.0020278827,
0.0565774851,
-0.0601496063,
-0.0780984983,
0.0069789388,
-0.0039706076,
-0.0253471136,
-0.0160586368,
-0.0136765949,
0.0076093706,
0.0005671839,
-0.0271173157,
-0.0075085736,
-0.0191284865,
0.0403738506,
0.0263371263,
-0.0147711029,
-0.0364453457,
0.0331843123,
0.0070684664,
-0.0051862062,
0.0597759299,
0.010902361,
0.0090584112,
-0.044472307,
-0.1228441671,
-0.0087042321,
0.0626050755,
0.0003327841,
0.0058093797,
0.0050817886,
0.0051748506,
0.0052315313,
0.0437672362,
-0.0069567617,
0.0265530124,
-0.0888873562,
-0.0133402525,
0.0038837686,
0.0160459913,
0.0327919908,
-0.0192644261,
0.0259412918,
0.0198659301,
-0.0369288102,
0.0180138182,
-0.0177689996,
-0.035190586,
0.0635108128,
0.056107536,
0.0099710654,
-0.0403040871,
-0.0051999511,
-0.025893854,
0.0053132745,
0.0199919082,
-0.0483377054,
-0.0231599826,
0.0429731645,
-0.0239853133,
-0.0217690226,
-0.0380463675,
0.0174746327,
-0.0331879929,
-0.0376247987,
-0.0374662951,
-0.0274262242,
0.0276043992,
0.0105604753,
-0.0357997753,
0.0031963997,
-0.033797428,
0.0235477276,
-0.0615399703,
0.0017319353,
0.0048771454,
-0.0185409579,
0.0824480578,
0.0512618497,
0.0340393819,
-0.0109824119,
-0.0416876785,
-0.0036932779,
-0.0433671586,
-0.0037768309,
-0.075678356,
0.0179987531,
0.0234908555,
0.0439005345,
0.0260054283,
0.0028687723,
0.0438099802,
0.0075128525,
0.0260403547,
-0.0600723177,
-0.0286047887,
-0.0600870773,
0.075192824,
-0.0352846347,
0.0355818532,
0.0116054928,
0.0179218948,
0.0289974473,
-0.0587049723,
0.0015545994,
0.0293971449,
0.0719750449,
-0.0177311581,
-0.0008669416,
0.0006882682,
-0.0247294158,
-0.0124078533,
-0.0131009771,
-0.0209340695,
0.002372382,
0.0866992101,
-0.0066666054,
-0.0076511824,
0.0061248816,
-0.040960893,
0.0315541551,
0.0139391785,
-0.0417194776,
0.0167439692,
0.0254602265,
0.0516592711,
-0.0349177383,
0.0097370008,
-0.0244517662,
0.0369011015,
0.077212289,
-0.0291501414,
-0.0202503335,
-0.0111032277,
-0.0320919268,
0.004465119,
-0.0302359238,
0.0354762562,
-0.029667642,
0.0092018014,
-0.0302636903,
0.0059111812,
0.0920975506,
0.0701260045,
-0.0480340123,
-0.0016581804,
0.0023713692,
-0.0107909972,
0.0119098499,
0.0071583763,
-0.0329386108,
-0.0237738248,
-0.0380329825,
0.0327125266,
0.0248625223,
-0.0112657957,
-0.0071325824,
-0.0786890835,
0.0395026244,
-0.0265262481,
0.0121071236,
-0.1050828993,
-0.0092418361,
-0.035851486,
0.0264446437,
-0.0336245671,
-0.0139216082,
-0.0065699029,
-0.023500856,
0.0083919559,
-0.075667128,
-0.019922452,
0.0734202266,
0.0192697868,
-0.003839378,
0.0250678845,
0.0398454294,
-0.0122899553,
0.0133416988,
0.0241288282,
-0.0301104803,
-0.0092469743,
-0.0126553234,
0.0812269002,
-0.0435271151,
0.0049095345,
0.031713713,
0.0213294756,
-0.0917911828,
0.0259245951,
0.0596813411,
0.0073827603,
-0.0319382288,
-0.0296056438,
-0.0171069782,
0.0303502623,
-0.0024349261,
0.0603419915,
-0.023073338,
-0.0508118123,
0.0274862498,
-0.0135952253,
-0.0202472378,
-0.0090917349,
-0.0440612324,
0.0154382093,
-0.0088779163,
-0.0114464853,
-0.069387801,
-0.0096630119,
-0.0080921669,
0.0178053398,
0.0097439345,
-0.00909511,
0.0148212109,
0.0204566643,
-0.0094711268,
0.0042110444,
0.0392997451,
0.0000750923,
-0.0148129519,
-0.0177377444,
0.0881356597,
-0.0216114111,
-0.0496273302,
0.0078660995,
-0.0273397136,
0.0071349782,
-0.0325720794,
0.0260125585,
0.0034168987,
0.0255809724,
0.0089080893,
0.0100371316,
-0.0073678028,
0.0357350968,
-0.0397940129,
-0.0508027822,
0.0338333324,
0.0474946275,
0.0189192519,
0.04792656,
-0.0449097417,
0.034112107,
-0.0221267901,
-0.0109524308,
-0.0599894673,
-0.0333672613,
0.0137054287,
-0.0315653756,
0.0347756445,
0.018632777,
0.0127783082,
-0.0678238422,
0.026396146,
-0.005005307,
-0.024161648,
-0.0628354847,
0.0218668468,
-0.0247677807,
-0.0196407232,
-0.0720286146,
0.0452531911,
-0.0040097032,
0.0338217653,
-0.0195135511,
0.0248627942,
0.0201386642,
-0.0053388067,
-0.0359349437,
-0.0117178168,
-0.0085688671,
-0.0225166045,
0.0038773613,
0.0038888806,
-0.0078909257,
0.0615847744,
0.0287497416,
0.0217628013,
-0.0600625798,
0.0433140248,
-0.0026637702,
-0.0227481145,
-0.0315612257,
0.015421927,
-0.000426169,
-0.0176705252,
0.0139379669,
-0.0832630023,
-0.0071936562,
0.0177660789,
0.0296740141,
-0.0086657982,
0.0184046179,
0.0251025856,
0.0011899509,
-0.0334062167,
-0.0170907881,
0.0788484737,
-0.0693908706,
0.0077553615,
-0.0182942301,
-0.0478898473,
-0.0803135186,
0.0254194234,
0.0535918921,
0.0210394617,
0.0116459532,
-0.0027155601,
-0.0409417078,
-0.022489734,
0.034552101,
0.0058268243,
0.0136716487,
0.001899534,
0.0762395412,
0.0640153289,
0.027273424,
-0.0278508142,
-0.0549863875,
-0.0147442613,
-0.0223892555,
0.0135278841,
-0.0184067618,
-6.667921175e-33,
-0.0359523296,
-0.0294134151,
-0.0434108935,
0.0596556254,
0.0266781263,
0.0147511754,
-0.0235757958,
0.049229186,
0.0426538512,
0.0630841106,
0.0123082269,
0.0106407227,
-0.0076946714,
0.01154014,
0.0334673785,
-0.0127500016,
0.0471945368,
-0.0354662798,
0.0374316759,
0.0604981035,
0.0533481427,
0.023820892,
0.0348305628,
-0.1076579839,
0.0498153418,
-0.0126977479,
-0.0474386401,
0.0053281724,
0.0239962265,
0.0355506055,
0.0026350243,
0.0704754442,
0.0394257233,
-0.055447638,
0.0499646813,
0.021710787,
-0.0516797304,
0.0068693184,
-0.0294543151,
-0.0256828014,
-0.0552150086,
0.0074605993,
-0.0040503033,
0.0120442891,
-0.0019802656,
0.0206288584,
0.0703592449,
-0.0093432888,
0.0196801368,
-0.1329564154,
-0.0386693031,
0.014389853,
-0.0230902433,
-0.0013398284,
0.0110000251,
0.0436324701,
0.0076273424,
0.050942786,
-0.04640048,
0.0045104777,
-0.0079304036,
0.049741134,
0.0136682689,
-0.0122146904,
-0.039090164,
0.0703145191,
-0.0212445091,
0.026824601,
0.0041350387,
0.0524363928,
-0.0037882642,
0.0584722757,
0.0051260847,
-0.0175459757,
-0.0336308032,
-0.0363825113,
-0.0236984529,
0.0282498188,
0.0178703479,
-0.0191691201,
0.031321831,
-0.0175289996,
-0.0363763832,
-0.0007536054,
0.055236496,
-0.0285358652,
-0.0156703107,
-0.0092703188,
0.0021509274,
0.0121019427,
-0.0209649727,
-0.0020824068,
-0.0202408656,
-0.0301514771,
-0.0085204346,
-0.0100328689,
-0.0298823453,
-0.0031127259,
0.00774694,
-0.0111287152,
-0.079729721,
-0.0034659412,
-0.0678979009,
-0.0021245677,
0.0114770224,
-0.0208240692,
0.0623871908,
-0.0016885259,
-0.058881212,
0.0135998614,
0.031206578,
0.0012798898,
-0.0387811512,
0.0966048911,
-0.0046951105,
0.0044804462,
-0.0194597859,
0.091039151,
-0.040744029,
0.0597018674,
-0.0009188907,
0.0286945906,
-0.0131013859,
0.0031351037,
-0.0008400301,
-0.0396471992,
0.0081142206,
-0.0356783085,
0.0433562435,
-0.0382495522,
-0.0100477813,
0.0346443243,
2.892e-7,
0.0347133428,
0.053167522,
-0.0348046832,
-0.0271785464,
0.0605782196,
0.0814068541,
0.05258191,
0.0027154116,
-0.013067795,
-0.0418672003,
0.0495949909,
-0.0135036269,
-0.0054358109,
0.0647022501,
-0.0837018862,
-0.0121592954,
-0.0172399599,
-0.0195040088,
-0.0526168905,
-0.021263184,
0.0910731331,
0.054023698,
0.0015600661,
-0.0126111219,
0.0058493591,
0.0134450961,
-0.0076265079,
-0.0391737558,
-0.0384861417,
0.0385255329,
0.0165259466,
0.0134076513,
-0.0430085547,
-0.0130187171,
-0.054746028,
0.004372471,
0.0328164361,
0.0292034559,
0.031456396,
-0.0698611438,
0.0078765117,
0.0403332412,
0.0197515208,
-0.0013687272,
0.0177783668,
-0.07583417,
-0.0325190313,
-0.0655029193,
0.0442804135,
0.0181175489,
-0.0110578835,
0.0063592643,
-0.0160310492,
0.039060086,
-0.009055947,
-0.0324277766,
-0.0291478485,
-0.0831394047,
0.0589515492,
0.0687885433,
-0.0300130062,
0.0046779192,
0.0077153747,
0.0145030525,
-0.000429943,
-0.0137272105,
0.0053290846,
2.476532187e-34,
0.0492237881,
-0.0156090846,
-0.0081629893,
0.0224744398,
0.0051280702,
0.0202913918,
-0.061309725,
-0.0103921527,
-0.0065935589,
0.011533577,
0.0207586996
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13001v1
|
Large Language Models for Education: A Survey
| 2024-05-12T01:50:01 | 2024-05-12T01:50:01 |
Hanyi Xu, Wensheng Gan, Zhenlian Qi, Jiayang Wu, Philip S. Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Artificial intelligence (AI) has a profound impact on traditional education.
In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly used in
various applications such as natural language processing, computer vision,
speech recognition, and autonomous driving. LLMs have also been applied in many
fields, including recommendation, finance, government, education, legal
affairs, and finance. As powerful auxiliary tools, LLMs incorporate various
technologies such as deep learning, pre-training, fine-tuning, and
reinforcement learning. The use of LLMs for smart education (LLMEdu) has been a
significant strategic direction for countries worldwide. While LLMs have shown
great promise in improving teaching quality, changing education models, and
modifying teacher roles, the technologies are still facing several challenges.
In this paper, we conduct a systematic review of LLMEdu, focusing on current
technologies, challenges, and future developments. We first summarize the
current state of LLMEdu and then introduce the characteristics of LLMs and
education, as well as the benefits of integrating LLMs into education. We also
review the process of integrating LLMs into the education industry, as well as
the introduction of related technologies. Finally, we discuss the challenges
and problems faced by LLMEdu, as well as prospects for future optimization of
LLMEdu.
|
[
0.0657808781,
0.0206142087,
-0.0453161858,
0.0242277589,
-0.0204408113,
0.0167430826,
0.047206752,
-0.0445748046,
0.0064718849,
-0.0693986192,
-0.0174634289,
-0.0051031392,
-0.0249894876,
0.0396908745,
0.0290228277,
-0.0710081309,
0.0165788364,
-0.0548398942,
0.0245849732,
0.0013696952,
-0.0148615101,
0.0051552216,
-0.034251526,
0.0579975247,
-0.0011984484,
-0.0049036806,
-0.0137101458,
-0.0338195227,
0.0029892679,
-0.027058864,
0.0210322738,
0.0426724181,
0.030115841,
0.0427330919,
0.0000024957,
-0.0733776093,
-0.0028292518,
-0.0214951728,
0.0038379929,
0.0254265517,
0.0204632264,
0.0307694077,
-0.0276639815,
0.0326260068,
-0.0730917677,
0.0165241137,
0.0404570997,
0.0016335471,
0.0307019725,
0.028938828,
0.014308813,
-0.0651835129,
0.068605423,
0.004223119,
-0.0383762121,
-0.016672099,
0.0536244102,
0.0004453937,
0.0199291222,
-0.006870864,
-0.0508472845,
0.0320247039,
0.0237586703,
-0.0475328304,
-0.0049002813,
0.0118327113,
-0.0021161023,
-0.0364888422,
-0.0174156372,
0.0530487485,
-0.0129684582,
0.0014858518,
0.0290628448,
-0.0214281995,
-0.0016736963,
0.0086063119,
-0.0566594675,
0.0429029875,
0.0395886824,
0.0373294428,
0.0310293604,
-0.0225870442,
0.0200414136,
0.0604990646,
-0.0245897621,
0.0463033877,
0.0053062607,
-0.0219250023,
-0.0046211258,
0.046614375,
0.0159927942,
-0.0238032676,
0.0303992517,
0.065007776,
-0.0090109454,
0.0194989871,
-0.0187094118,
-0.0503489524,
0.0175300613,
-0.0243866555,
0.0072549875,
0.0140354484,
0.0018755002,
0.0319532417,
-0.0019756316,
0.0657679886,
-0.0047270488,
0.0359697454,
-0.0194064062,
0.0162779596,
-0.0265008025,
-0.0074981092,
-0.0131057566,
0.0634292513,
-0.0164633784,
-0.0103989365,
-0.0536484495,
0.0157790836,
-0.0531010218,
0.0184371453,
-0.0247858632,
-0.0073072854,
-0.0051964624,
-0.0228139162,
-0.0432362594,
0.0626308396,
0.0047583333,
0.0337845087,
-0.0098254252,
-0.0105243791,
0.0533236042,
0.0139780622,
-0.0142222205,
0.0057947496,
0.0225191843,
0.0651594549,
-0.0050877999,
-0.0369927101,
-0.0539031103,
-0.039307043,
-0.0006015649,
-0.0693823546,
0.0228777602,
-0.1087881476,
-0.0235698856,
-0.0277076345,
-0.0054606819,
-0.0351959243,
0.0135804648,
-0.0114719439,
0.0005940729,
0.0259212945,
-0.0201628543,
0.0105837313,
0.0612513982,
-0.0156507138,
0.0494735539,
0.062978439,
0.0416467972,
-0.0126489736,
0.0030452397,
-0.0359944142,
-0.0116600785,
0.0419784859,
-0.002562904,
-0.0036224986,
-0.0125513123,
-0.0228087697,
-0.0162420701,
0.0562583879,
-0.0201874878,
0.0433513746,
0.0102849333,
0.0321699679,
0.0527136102,
0.067685537,
0.0212952532,
0.0203125961,
0.038440831,
0.0399964452,
0.0446730405,
-0.0247908141,
-0.0346188098,
0.0025187423,
-0.0393486172,
-0.0067552188,
0.0030413591,
0.0584203973,
-0.0094068879,
-0.0834067687,
0.0034785448,
-0.0500247888,
0.0139768217,
0.0430807322,
0.0947233513,
-0.0410569385,
-0.0062357304,
-0.0104162646,
0.0633077323,
0.0105796959,
0.0377163365,
-0.0961284339,
0.0571809746,
0.1087289304,
0.0471772179,
-0.0516452491,
-0.0501924939,
-0.0253545344,
0.000669782,
0.072554335,
0.0303217266,
0.0053184833,
-0.0464810915,
-0.0354702398,
-0.0188057348,
0.0090252357,
0.0074125901,
0.004911616,
-0.0203173906,
0.0414405651,
-0.0031683033,
0.0179223288,
-0.0421154462,
0.0233322177,
-0.0570761487,
-0.0371958092,
-0.0254455004,
0.0370391123,
0.0218268093,
0.0524361096,
-0.0034193608,
-0.0105793448,
0.0302779432,
-0.0049246959,
-0.012162514,
-0.0709796995,
-0.071837835,
0.0427482128,
0.0677012056,
-0.0706495643,
0.0091474885,
0.0285687186,
-0.0298661087,
-0.0338779502,
0.0122192567,
-0.0218822863,
0.020058386,
-0.0236140508,
0.0349171571,
-0.0535760708,
-0.0073271808,
-0.0400811099,
0.0153420726,
0.0218639057,
-0.0256575793,
0.0370866805,
0.0382645503,
0.0095976805,
-0.009560734,
-0.0464258343,
0.010406713,
-0.0112017533,
0.0431759804,
0.0274312105,
0.055117745,
-0.0306210686,
-0.0213013142,
-0.0383432582,
-0.0056927269,
0.006489194,
-0.0016784301,
-0.0463342965,
-0.0162034463,
-0.0145214964,
0.0059730015,
-0.0211476013,
0.0132182222,
0.0095831249,
-0.0181526747,
-0.0136477519,
0.0100770211,
-0.023144545,
-0.0489981212,
-0.0367057733,
-0.0275329854,
0.0287546758,
0.0415937863,
0.0025345283,
-0.0337342322,
0.034832947,
-0.029590033,
0.0539690927,
0.03013823,
-0.0395773239,
0.0124038151,
-0.0241409577,
0.0241204668,
0.072058253,
0.0222881734,
0.0322832353,
0.0537323877,
-0.0126824165,
-0.0688077435,
0.0069416799,
-0.0176523309,
-0.0138464794,
-0.0564939193,
0.0040400266,
-0.0526459776,
0.0305577014,
-0.0123859728,
-0.0107987784,
-0.0236471836,
0.0562677458,
-0.0355307758,
-0.0316598266,
-0.0371303968,
-0.0009012086,
-0.020788759,
0.0207880288,
0.021420151,
-0.0233549066,
0.0717417449,
-0.0005695021,
0.0429951698,
-0.0338349156,
-0.0296752751,
-0.0401901379,
0.0074707605,
-0.0095537612,
0.0028125874,
-0.0341497995,
-0.0129314195,
-0.0426924601,
-0.0090929251,
0.0031281696,
-0.0583024286,
0.0464040637,
-0.0445604213,
-0.007651329,
-0.0202376321,
-0.0205400493,
-0.0310595538,
-0.0064454209,
-0.0416603126,
0.0130769871,
-0.0018283592,
-0.0115605984,
-0.0255262777,
0.0055861133,
0.0174907949,
0.0181267913,
-0.0101760942,
0.0205350649,
-0.0289206523,
0.0032424862,
0.0507055335,
-0.0281040501,
0.0028804543,
-0.0127062853,
0.0720685646,
0.012628329,
0.0130269527,
-0.0020375224,
-0.019569885,
0.022029452,
0.0316760987,
-0.0076117795,
-0.0160131827,
0.0365888067,
0.0006034098,
-0.1020449176,
-0.0018904494,
0.1128853336,
0.0122834798,
-0.0491335057,
-0.0142088011,
-0.017308265,
-0.0247441232,
-0.00308958,
0.0151684033,
-0.0890405998,
-0.0230771732,
-0.0114524858,
0.0088434219,
-0.0101453448,
-0.0094307661,
0.020831883,
-0.1190781146,
0.0103702256,
0.0183395837,
-0.0213965289,
-0.0259671193,
-0.0185163394,
-0.0242811795,
0.0216507297,
0.036399927,
-0.0234740078,
-0.0079042539,
-0.00390483,
0.0490085185,
-0.0343007706,
-0.0395939499,
0.0140603883,
-0.0610992536,
0.0495454371,
0.0685448647,
0.0385542326,
-0.0412043408,
-0.013702414,
-0.0410351939,
0.0240246244,
-0.002724614,
-0.0104613584,
-0.0194103494,
-0.0090156291,
-0.0130086737,
-0.034071289,
0.0446134545,
0.0014637165,
0.0187704209,
0.0444758087,
0.1181561872,
-0.036109779,
-0.007706651,
-0.0411893204,
0.0005457654,
-0.0186523292,
0.0603410751,
-0.0038081496,
-0.091911763,
0.0041095032,
-0.015293913,
-0.0419235043,
-0.0024577654,
-0.0426882245,
0.0102830315,
-0.0017365052,
0.011672725,
-0.0223627873,
-0.0458098948,
0.0558619872,
-0.0174181201,
0.0244783796,
0.0103287315,
0.1017141715,
-0.0020239383,
-0.0493224896,
0.0173682347,
-0.043008253,
0.0173848849,
-0.1117249355,
-0.027154997,
0.005491449,
-0.0541006476,
-0.0120784147,
0.0175210107,
-0.0582245998,
-0.0857614428,
0.012382865,
0.0374642611,
0.0102108307,
0.0112765916,
0.014239178,
-0.0574344434,
0.0767871588,
0.0271167178,
-0.0016183435,
0.0057520452,
-0.0002795617,
-0.0048916154,
0.0187118202,
0.0022667979,
-0.0542285107,
0.0224877484,
0.0199221503,
-0.0107990727,
-0.0256805234,
-0.0380845405,
0.0045278659,
0.0265530869,
0.0511557981,
0.0011711254,
-0.0197288226,
-0.061053697,
0.0071937633,
-0.0285521746,
0.0099501144,
-0.0137266591,
-0.0137126772,
0.0345778987,
0.02117824,
0.0153047731,
0.0018139526,
0.0417320579,
-0.0159700885,
-0.0186262969,
0.076401785,
-0.0304107741,
0.0440446436,
0.0217193402,
0.0160216745,
-0.0052635823,
0.0549361557,
-0.0122839976,
0.0209094938,
0.0092498241,
0.0533878282,
0.0083509823,
0.0019686928,
0.0187681839,
-0.0048269909,
0.0099069728,
-0.0987227559,
-0.0227029994,
0.056085594,
0.0517384,
0.0169821233,
0.0100342156,
-0.0450480282,
0.0076136268,
-0.0136102531,
-0.0116593838,
-0.0081007918,
-0.0212674849,
0.0280067436,
-0.0022385858,
0.0131475991,
0.0355808251,
0.0406717509,
0.0265031643,
0.0369928256,
-0.0024815027,
0.0127221188,
-0.0224581063,
-0.0212979112,
0.04207642,
0.0306657162,
-0.0158583988,
0.016116051,
-0.0181255378,
-0.0321942009,
-0.0237781964,
0.0084005389,
-0.0284646284,
-0.0541862994,
0.059386991,
0.020668203,
-0.0320870951,
0.0135370679,
-0.0182445534,
-0.0061443779,
0.0037995486,
-0.0410521775,
0.0084850285,
-6.543929297e-33,
-0.024398515,
-0.0355557688,
0.0606868975,
0.0347710736,
-0.0090985401,
-0.0119633274,
-0.0055854907,
-0.0002610192,
-0.0186016951,
0.0008219819,
0.0316079371,
0.0000046533,
0.0039170603,
0.0479939803,
0.0187442098,
0.0150715262,
0.0405445993,
-0.0121901361,
0.0551598594,
0.0298734177,
-0.0011726188,
0.0239328537,
0.0564939342,
-0.0389806181,
0.0007517153,
0.0149371214,
0.0044851149,
-0.0037200463,
-0.0558580868,
0.0549928285,
-0.0274972562,
0.0536770858,
0.0098137166,
-0.0376914069,
-0.0378220975,
0.052617643,
-0.0602065213,
-0.0386799872,
-0.0107096396,
0.0429577045,
-0.0085608307,
-0.0605101138,
0.0922277048,
-0.0006023248,
-0.0599282011,
0.004923949,
0.0713548586,
-0.0277634002,
-0.0038112141,
-0.0259054694,
-0.0965271816,
0.0071141198,
-0.0468626916,
-0.0094182529,
0.0289527625,
-0.0010584004,
-0.0253739897,
0.0209596548,
-0.0483866334,
0.0662526786,
0.0498801507,
0.0062146126,
0.0721248016,
0.0051075476,
-0.0089352215,
0.0448101982,
0.0317790657,
-0.0214253571,
0.0015475501,
-0.0313570574,
0.0830667913,
0.0544312745,
0.0741839707,
0.04486233,
-0.0149440896,
-0.0161357634,
-0.0742492229,
-0.0154733881,
0.031320978,
0.0132795386,
0.0330845043,
-0.0204230715,
-0.0546750315,
-0.0160166062,
-0.0352648385,
0.0148576777,
0.0020347303,
-0.0119117042,
0.039153263,
-0.0476042293,
-0.0009539522,
0.0121302316,
0.0316859856,
-0.0686296597,
-0.0013787042,
0.0073813261,
-0.000254188,
0.0097220326,
-0.0268597975,
0.0183774531,
-0.0819318295,
-0.0713837668,
-0.000941405,
-0.0234429911,
0.0041713137,
0.0329420343,
0.0029498162,
0.0040706214,
-0.0306656677,
0.0092974165,
-0.0230795313,
-0.0220614728,
0.0674246401,
-0.0241175201,
0.0237715822,
-0.0143948644,
0.0154811786,
0.0573367849,
0.0297890436,
-0.0475399122,
-0.0055961055,
-0.0557839163,
-0.0104244035,
0.0148561327,
-0.0369653031,
-0.004190193,
-0.089873746,
-0.0000972018,
0.0161700454,
-0.0789810419,
0.0040038838,
0.0247436427,
3.119e-7,
-0.0007448801,
0.0928586647,
-0.0085209738,
-0.0275246557,
-0.0062493794,
0.0535149015,
0.0129269306,
-0.0104761785,
0.025311837,
0.0781460479,
0.0276526678,
0.022208361,
0.0435790978,
-0.0036479246,
-0.0704448447,
-0.0002721671,
-0.0408109203,
0.0140358591,
-0.1111789942,
0.0249766242,
0.0093955938,
0.076716058,
0.0479389541,
-0.0253688805,
-0.0103022801,
-0.0413939841,
0.0198439695,
-0.0222174879,
-0.0350801647,
0.0027732567,
0.0037863331,
0.0482602082,
0.0086067775,
0.0164453126,
0.0123845069,
0.0295481179,
-0.026221592,
0.0345991999,
-0.0006540241,
0.0280628651,
0.0131065287,
-0.0246530902,
-0.0318104513,
-0.0389083549,
0.0782602429,
-0.0442056283,
-0.0127745867,
-0.0172207281,
-0.0319258533,
-0.0485664569,
-0.0037859462,
-0.0427429155,
0.0233392995,
-0.0241164714,
0.0033408387,
-0.0454309471,
0.0107097095,
-0.0273468047,
0.0331604294,
0.009490435,
-0.0276016369,
-0.0293695908,
-0.0277324338,
0.0068928939,
0.0231310353,
-0.0459114984,
0.0223852433,
2.618050687e-34,
0.0177051723,
-0.0177589003,
0.0236269403,
-0.0191858578,
0.0175725911,
0.0340343341,
-0.0590121746,
0.0118268486,
0.0051436098,
-0.0807948261,
-0.0173453279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07111v1
|
Designing and Evaluating Dialogue LLMs for Co-Creative Improvised Theatre
| 2024-05-11T23:19:42 | 2024-05-11T23:19:42 |
Boyd Branch, Piotr Mirowski, Kory Mathewson, Sophia Ppali, Alexandra Covaci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social robotics researchers are increasingly interested in multi-party
trained conversational agents. With a growing demand for real-world
evaluations, our study presents Large Language Models (LLMs) deployed in a
month-long live show at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe. This case study
investigates human improvisers co-creating with conversational agents in a
professional theatre setting. We explore the technical capabilities and
constraints of on-the-spot multi-party dialogue, providing comprehensive
insights from both audience and performer experiences with AI on stage. Our
human-in-the-loop methodology underlines the challenges of these LLMs in
generating context-relevant responses, stressing the user interface's crucial
role. Audience feedback indicates an evolving interest for AI-driven live
entertainment, direct human-AI interaction, and a diverse range of expectations
about AI's conversational competence and utility as a creativity support tool.
Human performers express immense enthusiasm, varied satisfaction, and the
evolving public opinion highlights mixed emotions about AI's role in arts.
|
[
0.0423191115,
-0.0324409604,
-0.0420663282,
0.0065343231,
-0.0394990221,
-0.005483178,
0.0180073399,
-0.0153324278,
0.015008728,
-0.0228726212,
-0.0454353094,
-0.0200045221,
-0.0052498989,
0.0901512429,
0.0035740358,
-0.0442208722,
-0.0204280075,
-0.0633201674,
0.0411474593,
0.0143457223,
-0.028623879,
0.0086180186,
-0.0517619736,
0.0593505874,
-0.0297363307,
0.0044327914,
-0.0527415946,
0.0158995502,
0.0154313399,
0.0180709232,
-0.04045837,
0.0245474149,
0.050971128,
0.0532652251,
0.0000016154,
-0.0231124125,
0.0250683893,
-0.0221561249,
0.0425228328,
-0.0310099255,
0.0254201479,
0.0604837388,
-0.0457163639,
0.0257125683,
-0.0339045748,
0.0157420821,
0.0443563089,
0.0185334589,
0.0647248849,
0.0660973489,
0.0062341681,
-0.0109114414,
0.0221184529,
-0.0161631629,
-0.0201450158,
-0.0235214829,
-0.0040839026,
-0.010061821,
0.0972484127,
-0.0416516326,
-0.0192962047,
0.0187214073,
0.0356210805,
-0.0481926464,
0.0027291423,
0.0245095696,
-0.0759107322,
-0.0548040979,
0.0060976529,
0.0623005405,
0.0551262461,
0.0155524341,
0.0024315428,
0.0232576635,
0.0336357281,
0.018941829,
-0.0363017656,
0.037551254,
0.0109057035,
-0.0345644653,
-0.0970904827,
-0.0373658389,
0.002304228,
0.0088642975,
0.0458579212,
0.020416202,
-0.0059374701,
0.0203555357,
-0.0388157666,
-0.0154097602,
-0.028178392,
-0.0806575567,
0.0102480464,
0.0555351414,
-0.0555464439,
0.0161513705,
-0.0326300077,
0.0188645516,
-0.0280335788,
-0.0388041995,
0.0422583781,
0.0380568653,
0.0256187748,
0.0477368198,
0.0355750211,
0.0397606045,
-0.0250884406,
0.0629418641,
0.0334593877,
0.0035118202,
-0.0362731144,
-0.0321337059,
-0.0584144071,
-0.007166293,
-0.0541270114,
-0.0481587425,
0.0226787105,
0.0459882542,
-0.0348574705,
0.0259761121,
-0.0151928682,
0.0011230931,
-0.0119976429,
-0.0285385493,
-0.0215042215,
0.0440505184,
-0.0046884916,
0.0393653288,
0.0454659276,
-0.042505201,
0.0111367898,
0.0285077915,
0.0153600387,
-0.0172669087,
-0.0001181628,
0.045225054,
-0.0199758224,
-0.0660382807,
0.0218305513,
-0.0063517648,
-0.0179560762,
-0.0436090752,
-0.0050347592,
-0.0156171322,
0.046022471,
-0.0321255289,
-0.0287628118,
-0.0291619394,
0.0086362539,
0.0287427735,
0.0157450363,
0.0207791869,
-0.0108845551,
0.0503880642,
0.0246328469,
0.0184359588,
-0.0265456419,
-0.0056324885,
0.1112558618,
0.0558136106,
0.0238187015,
-0.0089474265,
0.0698359013,
0.0241876189,
-0.0496545918,
-0.005070684,
-0.0312465988,
-0.0122419652,
0.0018080961,
0.0519266278,
-0.0184715856,
0.0273343734,
-0.0009306903,
0.0446166508,
0.0629335418,
-0.0057598436,
-0.017774079,
-0.0219443645,
0.0678972676,
0.0142680751,
0.0004723028,
-0.001980589,
0.0165215731,
0.046650406,
0.0505615436,
-0.0108687598,
0.0451280735,
0.0041599656,
-0.013271614,
-0.0107062608,
0.014531265,
-0.0053502764,
0.049987182,
0.0246419124,
-0.0079626301,
0.0205737855,
-0.0472300537,
-0.0632257685,
0.0021464019,
-0.0810476691,
0.0160018094,
-0.0529650524,
0.0192148685,
0.115005441,
0.0384537503,
-0.0354907885,
0.0136267776,
-0.0036042877,
0.0347354971,
0.0741088092,
0.0483812392,
-0.0367891714,
0.0000523968,
0.0226666573,
0.0361227989,
-0.023344731,
-0.0060886121,
0.0149698341,
-0.0483434647,
0.0164087173,
-0.0203684177,
0.0295828804,
-0.03100821,
-0.002627691,
-0.0887046009,
-0.00465811,
-0.0257647131,
-0.0055478062,
0.0400537215,
0.0635294765,
-0.0718075559,
0.0060349018,
0.0445306934,
0.0120094782,
-0.0152914254,
0.0555842854,
-0.0145662613,
0.0113693494,
0.0171836708,
-0.0398417786,
-0.0172886979,
0.0329334997,
0.0149026727,
-0.0274999235,
0.0642369762,
-0.0222521871,
0.038124796,
-0.0122946957,
0.0049370835,
-0.0132720368,
-0.0317233354,
0.0173019376,
-0.0212116539,
0.0166976564,
-0.0079511218,
-0.0198933817,
0.0405800156,
0.0140037984,
-0.0441903211,
-0.0241996814,
0.0757469907,
0.0193402041,
0.061801061,
0.0057635256,
0.0075300704,
-0.0357003734,
-0.0418253243,
-0.131176278,
-0.0264002886,
-0.0248742718,
-0.0638585612,
-0.0148824435,
-0.0111484583,
-0.0338281207,
-0.0005910908,
-0.0170539282,
-0.0398477651,
0.0137901306,
0.0017636837,
-0.0137765249,
0.0380505808,
-0.0590351857,
-0.0091137998,
0.0176543258,
-0.008077492,
0.0010323614,
0.0642579496,
-0.0020376632,
0.0113252634,
-0.0391422175,
-0.0577318408,
0.016302174,
-0.0430262499,
-0.0212764181,
0.0470119342,
-0.0300932396,
0.003641984,
0.036280971,
0.0001550942,
0.0262597073,
0.077356644,
-0.0082926331,
-0.0056931037,
0.0300256256,
0.020552408,
0.0300573315,
-0.0221538767,
0.0113048982,
0.0221630149,
0.0139305918,
0.0399456583,
0.0570554845,
-0.0517698415,
0.0558095016,
0.0124347704,
-0.0646572337,
0.0186074656,
-0.0339076854,
-0.0510678478,
0.0281516183,
-0.0077389143,
0.0276136789,
0.0377331041,
-0.0388190113,
-0.0300253145,
0.0027819178,
-0.0256033074,
-0.0398197696,
0.0665547401,
-0.0521148816,
0.0488722138,
-0.0489891768,
-0.0135209197,
-0.0367217511,
0.03913958,
0.0226643272,
-0.0465717278,
-0.0406530723,
-0.0490709171,
0.0160436742,
0.0037581825,
-0.0168646295,
0.0008213655,
-0.0294459537,
-0.0410794616,
0.0057679694,
-0.0100974767,
-0.0238897186,
-0.0120246988,
0.0226756688,
0.0487917252,
0.0410566777,
0.0309799034,
0.0084841372,
-0.0418400206,
-0.0087028695,
0.016058661,
0.0647754073,
-0.0619964451,
-0.0014784941,
0.0282278843,
-0.018750526,
0.0087872045,
-0.0070066717,
-0.0419883542,
-0.0177306216,
0.0022814341,
0.0274144635,
0.0060132132,
0.0081670312,
0.0642515421,
-0.0392199978,
0.0033671216,
0.0869224072,
0.0135321757,
-0.0308429953,
0.0034076953,
-0.011707643,
-0.0047872206,
-0.0115763545,
-0.0012106366,
-0.0308936927,
0.0078602508,
0.0386703499,
0.046186395,
0.0103182429,
-0.0259734653,
0.005932488,
-0.1035318002,
0.0671770349,
-0.0078634508,
-0.0291928686,
-0.0638685226,
-0.0217324235,
0.0373735577,
0.043115139,
0.0333738066,
0.0454404652,
0.0125961443,
0.0278784391,
0.0219928715,
0.0069962768,
-0.0300908014,
0.006077663,
-0.0440735072,
0.1242929846,
0.0299253296,
0.0612734817,
0.0081851184,
-0.0209931172,
0.0002806848,
0.0174968336,
0.0393709764,
0.0196491573,
0.0088562677,
0.0009651096,
0.0072475816,
0.0233706832,
0.0109819239,
-0.0098133516,
-0.0281782951,
0.0175748803,
0.0244027507,
-0.0564060509,
-0.0137782935,
-0.0093518039,
0.0437430441,
0.0268138424,
0.0397063904,
0.0405455492,
-0.0663251206,
-0.0115416227,
-0.0028140929,
-0.0212537423,
-0.0505710766,
-0.0563728139,
-0.0229509585,
0.0227303766,
-0.033458747,
-0.0367442854,
-0.022920873,
0.018400792,
0.0569768734,
0.0177879166,
-0.0172089376,
-0.0409791842,
0.034683194,
-0.0308046415,
0.012759747,
-0.0084492099,
0.0108339507,
-0.04889144,
-0.0465152711,
-0.0208671317,
-0.0470621809,
-0.0025143237,
0.0059133898,
-0.0208076928,
-0.0723389983,
0.024973169,
0.0506400615,
0.0293691661,
0.0132978,
0.0147967925,
-0.0401500128,
-0.0361091346,
-0.0173884351,
-0.0276793931,
0.0679514036,
-0.0025916996,
0.0489648022,
-0.0267803576,
-0.0000475117,
-0.0369126722,
-0.0007160165,
0.0073036267,
0.0435583591,
-0.0129798828,
-0.0847084522,
0.0025960417,
0.0234311782,
-0.0062444215,
-0.0248105433,
-0.0030417119,
-0.0295634009,
-0.0203483962,
-0.0421448164,
0.0142300008,
-0.0639904514,
-0.0337662287,
-0.0348741971,
-0.0189562701,
0.0082993023,
0.0183863565,
-0.0277361702,
0.0238286033,
-0.0120373825,
0.0097566843,
0.0521209687,
-0.0276614241,
0.0098053692,
0.0037721705,
0.020080274,
0.0617171116,
-0.0199063811,
0.0074967924,
0.0432101414,
0.0185346119,
0.0324250609,
-0.0746093988,
0.0460147262,
0.0781184286,
-0.0404026732,
-0.0995017439,
0.0274152309,
0.0490681045,
0.0224695597,
0.0594431274,
0.0248509012,
-0.0096414052,
0.02394256,
-0.0312174372,
0.05643088,
0.0136536974,
-0.0488639437,
-0.0264414176,
0.0063216714,
-0.010086447,
0.0083361035,
0.0674330071,
-0.0308369938,
-0.0153507469,
-0.0113505004,
0.0029843957,
-0.0193010233,
-0.0360793807,
-0.0213332847,
-0.0182356127,
0.0049451524,
0.046186775,
-0.0601622798,
-0.050847549,
-0.0113253649,
0.0155845741,
-0.0062932493,
-0.0513022728,
0.0102310935,
0.0414228998,
0.025864739,
0.0394470841,
-0.0229408052,
-0.0229279008,
-0.0396203659,
0.0051616044,
-0.0206992831,
-4.984735957e-33,
-0.0587947182,
-0.0459153913,
0.0381528884,
0.0192962494,
-0.0662500337,
-0.0399591997,
-0.0857884958,
0.0303395707,
0.0160996504,
-0.0175431725,
-0.0201033633,
0.0265796334,
-0.0233040005,
-0.0185029339,
0.0264277346,
-0.0647327453,
0.0488554314,
0.0043442831,
-0.0298124012,
0.0398676693,
0.0625356063,
0.0120550143,
-0.0525665097,
-0.1050236523,
0.0041890214,
-0.0304607004,
-0.0388349444,
-0.0110268621,
0.0158536565,
-0.0180985183,
0.0147930896,
0.0261003971,
0.0380503833,
0.004994608,
0.0214446913,
0.049578432,
0.0295594726,
-0.0226952657,
-0.0055507803,
0.027637586,
-0.0405958518,
-0.0179107785,
0.0139519498,
-0.0330743454,
-0.0320518352,
0.052124612,
0.0212088022,
-0.0077280258,
-0.0006094964,
0.0136873191,
-0.0635210127,
-0.0041552605,
-0.0319693685,
-0.0666543096,
-0.0074321739,
0.0441730209,
0.0196134914,
-0.0345724896,
-0.0432491712,
0.05895463,
-0.0680733323,
-0.0351235457,
0.0336761773,
0.000331993,
0.0042654295,
0.0653726757,
0.0116493488,
0.0700881034,
-0.0246351622,
0.0084230807,
-0.0096331388,
0.0887735114,
0.0095818629,
0.0527502075,
-0.0579737648,
-0.0087449653,
0.0369534418,
0.0402033627,
-0.0004742464,
0.0010759399,
-0.0009813019,
0.042392794,
-0.0144057414,
0.0044066971,
-0.0253507253,
-0.0212642793,
0.0079285353,
-0.058147002,
0.0360992737,
0.0105421217,
0.0069756689,
-0.0515991226,
0.0195087623,
-0.0203513987,
0.0052465,
-0.0479980074,
-0.037325073,
0.0608653948,
-0.0294119138,
-0.0154345622,
0.0161322858,
-0.0191643853,
0.0483481847,
0.0257096719,
0.0463287234,
0.0061560501,
-0.035988681,
0.0695722327,
0.0156393219,
-0.017156966,
-0.0043389732,
0.0446997508,
0.0340254232,
-0.0011369325,
0.0107513107,
0.0316022448,
-0.0211178139,
-0.0019768658,
0.0094628194,
0.0341240764,
-0.0000888437,
-0.0183551423,
-0.0517624542,
-0.0165148024,
-0.0405197665,
-0.0134744896,
-0.0341476984,
-0.0141011579,
0.0157224853,
-0.0346547626,
-0.0198066328,
-0.0472199842,
2.656e-7,
-0.0402519815,
0.0253114607,
0.0075957081,
0.0355057716,
0.0477609411,
0.0227696225,
-0.0318541862,
0.0395841599,
-0.0031545758,
-0.0174457002,
0.0360436179,
0.0232145246,
0.0481306463,
0.0218041725,
-0.0868688226,
-0.0349943377,
-0.100686051,
0.0231660027,
-0.0526660532,
0.0067166719,
0.0239114836,
0.001008152,
0.0573045425,
-0.0120415064,
-0.0235668439,
-0.0546967089,
-0.0017311506,
-0.0322374627,
0.0007430497,
0.0004048392,
0.0158431288,
-0.0396376438,
-0.0169641022,
0.0116038276,
-0.0071209571,
0.0225226395,
0.0320196413,
0.0436051711,
-0.0226212237,
-0.0199414622,
0.0175215825,
0.0243253689,
0.0105843693,
-0.0126179876,
0.0471484549,
-0.0034103484,
-0.0325713046,
0.0330082439,
-0.0070927846,
-0.0395554118,
-0.0059325038,
-0.0159112569,
-0.0206463244,
0.0024729676,
-0.0121160364,
-0.0055902377,
0.0555313788,
-0.0205470491,
0.0273763966,
-0.0515019074,
-0.089761734,
-0.0446424596,
-0.0148447799,
-0.0409850962,
-0.0321382359,
-0.0738398284,
0.005085499,
1.904074933e-34,
0.0365090594,
-0.0008146688,
-0.0115133133,
0.0207247902,
0.048286356,
0.0408518054,
0.0067603937,
0.0101811457,
0.0199749935,
-0.0298313443,
-0.0266089104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07101v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07101v1
|
Advanced Natural-based interaction for the ITAlian language: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA
| 2024-05-11T22:02:55 | 2024-05-11T22:02:55 |
Marco Polignano, Pierpaolo Basile, Giovanni Semeraro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the pursuit of advancing natural language processing for the Italian
language, we introduce a state-of-the-art Large Language Model (LLM) based on
the novel Meta LLaMA-3 model: LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA. We fine-tuned
the original 8B parameters instruction tuned model using the Supervised
Fine-tuning (SFT) technique on the English and Italian language datasets in
order to improve the original performance. Consequently, a Dynamic Preference
Optimization (DPO) process has been used to align preferences, avoid dangerous
and inappropriate answers, and limit biases and prejudices. Our model leverages
the efficiency of QLoRA to fine-tune the model on a smaller portion of the
original model weights and then adapt the model specifically for the Italian
linguistic structure, achieving significant improvements in both performance
and computational efficiency. Concurrently, DPO is employed to refine the
model's output, ensuring that generated content aligns with quality answers.
The synergy between SFT, QLoRA's parameter efficiency and DPO's user-centric
optimization results in a robust LLM that excels in a variety of tasks,
including but not limited to text completion, zero-shot classification, and
contextual understanding. The model has been extensively evaluated over
standard benchmarks for the Italian and English languages, showing outstanding
results. The model is freely available over the HuggingFace hub and, examples
of use can be found in our GitHub repository.
https://huggingface.co/swap-uniba/LLaMAntino-3-ANITA-8B-Inst-DPO-ITA
|
[
0.0586557947,
0.0419412367,
-0.0180046298,
0.0529226288,
0.0077178334,
0.0045531527,
-0.0288893338,
0.0030670133,
0.0341536403,
-0.0235672873,
-0.0875342414,
-0.0178309884,
0.0118818171,
0.0358707421,
-0.0211475827,
-0.0523135774,
0.0481821448,
-0.0086402604,
0.0135054998,
-0.0199443251,
0.0346892662,
0.0062672049,
0.0243117958,
0.0166203231,
0.0205115583,
0.0100484416,
0.0117834182,
-0.0271495469,
-0.0050237044,
-0.003986835,
0.0403483063,
0.0750574991,
-0.0032462948,
0.0059785368,
0.0000025191,
-0.0219489522,
0.0283891112,
-0.0432459898,
-0.0065810261,
-0.0048780753,
0.053206265,
0.0445589423,
-0.0033706464,
0.0215768311,
-0.0474422425,
0.0369602405,
0.035824012,
0.0202388614,
0.0198174212,
0.0524048842,
0.0094019771,
-0.0317120031,
0.0190257467,
-0.0393526368,
0.0095576532,
-0.0067549073,
0.030387776,
-0.0337268487,
0.0183575563,
0.0359489657,
-0.0081506036,
0.0193355158,
-0.0025276728,
-0.0244508181,
0.0002160007,
0.0242485683,
-0.0181097724,
-0.0291741453,
0.0015887134,
0.1073156968,
-0.0098560406,
-0.0114595182,
-0.0220919065,
0.0015276747,
0.0113650877,
0.001348921,
-0.049816303,
-0.0285274088,
0.0010433772,
0.0391091444,
0.0453826599,
0.0137260212,
0.0057809199,
0.0278176367,
0.0033996671,
0.0906413198,
0.0084749619,
-0.0158215314,
0.0258423202,
-0.0235671345,
-0.0325965881,
-0.0709878057,
0.0176676195,
0.0402367301,
-0.0258296225,
-0.0023642038,
-0.0275242403,
0.0094992174,
0.0516379066,
-0.0816406235,
0.0023314438,
0.0418652631,
0.0103247985,
0.0345143564,
0.0245842095,
0.0262559094,
-0.028190203,
-0.0393763073,
-0.0511715561,
-0.0029018442,
-0.023814328,
0.0041402928,
-0.0068669668,
0.0585591383,
-0.1010401994,
-0.0064329356,
-0.0224176869,
0.0183957461,
-0.0039221267,
-0.0103033176,
0.0227147788,
0.0088656778,
-0.0259661265,
0.026237309,
-0.0574212745,
0.0692798123,
-0.0789175481,
0.0171507113,
-0.0273395758,
-0.048673477,
0.010088508,
-0.0072043706,
-0.0073737903,
-0.0603023991,
0.0390952416,
0.0507137515,
0.0006801059,
-0.034448795,
0.0023462176,
-0.0188806783,
-0.0416865721,
-0.1033032387,
-0.0388337672,
-0.0701971874,
0.054793898,
-0.0314917825,
-0.0287000909,
-0.0494380742,
-0.0019964727,
0.0482839681,
-0.0457902439,
0.0658868104,
-0.0471224971,
-0.0235730521,
0.0124686463,
0.0025557103,
0.0272556674,
0.052869577,
0.0172142424,
0.0230521541,
0.0391698405,
0.0061733429,
-0.0238933768,
0.0486492477,
0.0309782568,
0.0174336415,
-0.0157760717,
0.0420164689,
-0.0403402038,
0.0200457312,
0.0438509546,
0.0296548046,
-0.0153811704,
-0.0219323859,
0.0592255294,
0.0316570662,
0.0181197245,
0.0247488935,
-0.0156580452,
0.0378276296,
0.0073720259,
0.0056193932,
-0.0343943797,
0.0666719824,
-0.049324587,
-0.0165609848,
0.0120065073,
0.0522672459,
-0.0352243371,
-0.061632961,
0.0233300906,
-0.0354670659,
0.0118730422,
0.0182094704,
0.0368419997,
-0.0249307882,
-0.0229428373,
-0.0471266694,
0.0512035079,
-0.0166220237,
0.0226527695,
-0.0530989282,
0.0898081213,
0.0992402658,
0.0375783518,
-0.0240665469,
-0.0395068862,
-0.0017556401,
-0.0131806973,
0.0515686534,
0.0332057849,
-0.029016275,
-0.0234754086,
-0.0476779602,
-0.0557080805,
-0.0048912619,
-0.0080894539,
0.0249576997,
0.0148833171,
0.0256581921,
-0.0109600173,
0.0289231781,
0.0029519657,
0.015906129,
0.0077236989,
-0.0372246131,
0.0089755338,
-0.0004732989,
0.025053421,
0.0208676662,
0.0023017926,
-0.007955146,
0.0261951834,
-0.0290254653,
-0.0227535702,
-0.0229614619,
-0.0336074121,
-0.0449819975,
0.0324570686,
-0.0164036583,
-0.0023694623,
0.0024399313,
-0.0458430983,
-0.0542886145,
0.0116789909,
0.0083335098,
0.0127936536,
-0.0167118218,
-0.0057401685,
-0.0148424106,
0.0270425342,
-0.0658446401,
0.0936773643,
-0.0255136732,
0.0076559517,
0.044501394,
-0.0010023209,
0.0295250434,
-0.0293685645,
-0.0292562824,
0.0389411859,
0.010473052,
-0.0047572223,
0.058216814,
0.0352070294,
-0.0379698239,
-0.0421008766,
-0.0766888782,
0.0335416868,
-0.0103863124,
0.0408038497,
0.0298077744,
0.0286864769,
-0.0166381821,
-0.0140702529,
-0.0395148434,
-0.0207664222,
-0.011006454,
0.0072470903,
0.0384095907,
0.0285147652,
0.0010896216,
-0.0863070562,
-0.0149009814,
0.0157196,
0.0040009273,
0.008276768,
-0.0188453663,
-0.0042780009,
-0.0107422024,
-0.0452535227,
0.0447576866,
-0.0112653412,
-0.0630493239,
-0.0120919812,
0.0057330593,
0.0147731313,
0.0805146024,
-0.0065846937,
-0.0210047513,
0.038538333,
0.0155787971,
-0.0839820579,
0.0132598188,
-0.0277586728,
-0.0226443224,
-0.0609791428,
-0.0367002711,
0.0162297972,
0.1053649858,
-0.0077456939,
0.0008415019,
-0.0546115525,
0.022147011,
0.0044340533,
-0.0181743633,
0.013957981,
0.0071501695,
-0.016391268,
0.0562921055,
-0.0331548229,
-0.0158463866,
0.0914289504,
-0.0024473218,
0.0232164674,
-0.0668756887,
0.006628986,
-0.0404408649,
0.0050573414,
-0.0036063797,
0.0227339286,
-0.0106160706,
0.011162892,
-0.0576797351,
-0.0674533918,
0.0176472142,
-0.0306595843,
0.0179434307,
-0.0370276198,
0.0111365709,
-0.0026569699,
-0.0550821759,
-0.0005239878,
-0.0224408172,
-0.0323919021,
-0.0057940991,
0.0197067596,
-0.0405580066,
0.015427717,
-0.0176895,
0.0063402336,
0.0425473787,
-0.0438861996,
-0.0035560392,
-0.0220978707,
0.0379842594,
0.079079248,
0.0081791785,
-0.0047863671,
0.0364644043,
0.0357176848,
0.0535007864,
0.0451732762,
0.0127811842,
-0.0020220361,
0.0134169012,
0.0518412739,
-0.0381344445,
-0.0744318143,
0.0181762688,
0.016790159,
-0.0299009215,
0.0047669825,
0.1210941896,
0.0304657687,
-0.075121589,
0.0016876705,
-0.0367592797,
0.0514449775,
0.0363023095,
0.0677833781,
-0.0561489463,
-0.0382011533,
-0.014311715,
0.0268282164,
-0.0118906656,
-0.0207608789,
0.0091854287,
-0.107932508,
0.0217179917,
-0.0294760969,
0.0013573511,
-0.0199811757,
-0.0738387331,
0.0257741567,
-0.0267122779,
0.0217476692,
-0.0070539764,
-0.0073776487,
0.0003843779,
0.0083750915,
0.0216104481,
-0.0541734025,
0.0519148335,
0.0050031412,
0.0614932552,
0.0402069539,
0.0480582379,
-0.0241291374,
0.0009328971,
0.0425860733,
0.0000990103,
-0.0066306158,
-0.0606684722,
0.0380553193,
-0.0039655184,
0.014932584,
-0.0712898821,
0.0492751934,
0.0074998513,
-0.0095640812,
0.0045071403,
0.0749696419,
0.0101890219,
0.0376354009,
-0.0397778042,
-0.0221445076,
0.0119911656,
0.0594067536,
0.0442803539,
-0.0853017569,
-0.0184967183,
-0.0052820588,
-0.0242854115,
-0.0328519121,
-0.0413029715,
0.0160030834,
-0.0208901186,
-0.0080536744,
-0.0651530847,
-0.0474995337,
0.0353932753,
0.0092818774,
0.008515276,
0.0282792244,
-0.0020999676,
-0.0396221504,
-0.0008320942,
0.0583756082,
-0.0265800711,
0.0286484398,
-0.0542081408,
0.0283657704,
0.023629874,
-0.0366561376,
-0.0279412046,
-0.0207260083,
-0.0317384228,
-0.0572275966,
-0.0343288518,
0.0897875652,
0.0215747934,
0.0539168641,
-0.0182414372,
-0.092870988,
0.0233647674,
0.010693877,
0.007881958,
-0.0137960175,
0.0058923569,
0.0069907228,
0.0093006585,
0.0377292037,
-0.0207995567,
0.0117255785,
0.0027105971,
0.0300004799,
-0.0455292724,
-0.041267328,
0.0251148827,
-0.0012954519,
0.0149521763,
-0.0054297163,
0.0009063256,
-0.0431436077,
0.0270317569,
-0.0152254794,
-0.0129215494,
-0.0272417013,
-0.0030053055,
0.0427553467,
-0.0237689,
0.010350991,
-0.0370522998,
-0.0688214228,
0.0271405242,
-0.0260475427,
0.0345727764,
0.0280115958,
0.0083456906,
0.0035088037,
0.0373811908,
-0.0223273765,
0.0465285107,
0.013698522,
0.0685319826,
-0.0444082208,
0.047794953,
0.0114379302,
-0.0342400037,
-0.0129083823,
0.0468040854,
-0.0086965533,
-0.0269546881,
-0.0443364047,
0.0083750617,
0.0385379344,
0.005971991,
0.0470550321,
0.0176324993,
-0.0305038355,
-0.0108362455,
0.0131544117,
-0.0222792067,
-0.0303443428,
0.0596713275,
0.0210004896,
-0.0203214008,
-0.0027287323,
0.0681280717,
0.0006095511,
0.0187473372,
0.0052023032,
0.0114700692,
-0.0135708572,
-0.0219817124,
-0.0184518024,
0.0437717512,
-0.0555846952,
-0.0061251353,
-0.0414122865,
-0.060104344,
-0.0206096917,
-0.0096901311,
-0.0420370549,
-0.0163037498,
0.0663094372,
0.011248149,
0.0095511526,
-0.0137549359,
-0.0487997085,
-0.0000172768,
-0.0153709976,
-0.0192148369,
-0.0348374471,
-7.050261733e-33,
-0.0462011434,
-0.0324009769,
0.0320237577,
0.0256358366,
-0.027505951,
-0.0232376009,
0.0021934747,
-0.0142474696,
-0.0693391487,
-0.0255512483,
-0.0146439672,
-0.0179641433,
0.0020681245,
0.0183411967,
-0.0061185625,
-0.0081123412,
0.0159344003,
-0.0176121797,
-0.0243006088,
0.0119999247,
0.000570048,
-0.0025452173,
0.0470372215,
-0.0456086583,
0.0358951241,
0.0035293356,
-0.0091659911,
0.0369120277,
-0.0209744796,
0.0905916765,
-0.0310577545,
0.0623127408,
0.0120439595,
-0.0091929175,
0.0014627485,
0.0558369607,
-0.0697834566,
-0.0782048255,
0.0485413224,
0.0232557263,
0.0183341298,
-0.0470479093,
0.0250201412,
0.0054580951,
-0.0227405448,
0.01543504,
0.0443930179,
-0.016611943,
-0.0413222015,
0.025913462,
-0.0542808324,
0.0153959151,
0.0074832989,
-0.0244644843,
0.0012756117,
0.0690538138,
0.0205764361,
0.0425174981,
-0.05376276,
0.0011047143,
-0.0114476178,
0.0255801715,
0.0566536225,
0.0189780146,
0.0291766599,
0.0372285582,
0.020285517,
-0.0200858023,
0.0013389428,
-0.0155280149,
0.0159081258,
0.0538212545,
0.0176703818,
0.0844744369,
0.0241796467,
-0.0140068149,
-0.0801819265,
0.030436879,
0.062097054,
0.0475229993,
-0.0144063318,
-0.0104859499,
-0.0497985892,
-0.0232603326,
-0.0650522783,
-0.0248609334,
-0.0440443642,
-0.0321350358,
0.0159038976,
-0.0136219421,
-0.006237973,
-0.0353736877,
0.0167149808,
-0.0366437137,
-0.0264136679,
0.0286628082,
-0.0300079416,
0.0268123392,
0.0253256038,
0.0369807817,
-0.0678658485,
-0.0290903077,
-0.0295752268,
-0.0388552397,
-0.0162117649,
0.0287498888,
0.0197133459,
0.0032942339,
-0.0482271388,
0.0133063169,
-0.0314929411,
0.000124036,
0.0150736142,
0.0479337834,
0.0205111466,
0.0162906405,
-0.0137559697,
0.061081361,
0.0491012484,
0.0417180806,
-0.0312512293,
-0.0666166767,
0.0119653018,
0.0320151709,
-0.0124134002,
0.0133171612,
-0.0068546706,
0.0252257399,
-0.0145275323,
-0.0510661416,
-0.0387003757,
-0.0035899042,
3.097e-7,
0.0452226885,
0.0548340902,
-0.0091306185,
0.030091187,
-0.007784673,
0.0523413979,
0.0085237678,
0.0249140672,
0.0033821329,
0.040294271,
0.0176004842,
0.0166300237,
-0.0044367346,
0.0244211946,
-0.070282869,
0.0194526203,
-0.0486872047,
-0.0043846797,
-0.0626908466,
-0.0471186303,
0.0220040493,
0.0951119438,
0.0352621824,
-0.0214953478,
-0.0339550674,
0.0006550389,
0.068903625,
-0.0186315998,
-0.038076289,
0.0520637184,
0.0121516138,
0.0390711538,
-0.0114059579,
0.0031536645,
-0.0089481706,
0.046729371,
-0.038924709,
0.0850757286,
-0.0196821652,
-0.059738405,
0.037916787,
-0.0576421805,
-0.0179281309,
-0.0538608916,
0.080493398,
-0.0493899472,
-0.0111852866,
-0.0284585729,
-0.0470910855,
-0.0184726156,
0.0368155017,
-0.0542753935,
0.0066280975,
0.0035075624,
0.006236698,
-0.019564718,
-0.0320486836,
-0.0279298332,
-0.0198789742,
-0.0018402594,
-0.0349452533,
-0.0272528641,
-0.0574254021,
-0.0028438321,
0.0008430345,
-0.0090243248,
0.0213551112,
2.859670336e-34,
0.0248728655,
-0.0166706331,
0.0167556424,
0.0272675585,
0.0209167171,
0.0190754477,
-0.0420825779,
0.0223686304,
0.0575516969,
-0.0860343501,
-0.0163157322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07099v1
|
Do Pretrained Contextual Language Models Distinguish between Hebrew Homograph Analyses?
| 2024-05-11T21:50:56 | 2024-05-11T21:50:56 |
Avi Shmidman, Cheyn Shmuel Shmidman, Dan Bareket, Moshe Koppel, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semitic morphologically-rich languages (MRLs) are characterized by extreme
word ambiguity. Because most vowels are omitted in standard texts, many of the
words are homographs with multiple possible analyses, each with a different
pronunciation and different morphosyntactic properties. This ambiguity goes
beyond word-sense disambiguation (WSD), and may include token segmentation into
multiple word units. Previous research on MRLs claimed that standardly trained
pre-trained language models (PLMs) based on word-pieces may not sufficiently
capture the internal structure of such tokens in order to distinguish between
these analyses. Taking Hebrew as a case study, we investigate the extent to
which Hebrew homographs can be disambiguated and analyzed using PLMs. We
evaluate all existing models for contextualized Hebrew embeddings on a novel
Hebrew homograph challenge sets that we deliver. Our empirical results
demonstrate that contemporary Hebrew contextualized embeddings outperform
non-contextualized embeddings; and that they are most effective for
disambiguating segmentation and morphosyntactic features, less so regarding
pure word-sense disambiguation. We show that these embeddings are more
effective when the number of word-piece splits is limited, and they are more
effective for 2-way and 3-way ambiguities than for 4-way ambiguity. We show
that the embeddings are equally effective for homographs of both balanced and
skewed distributions, whether calculated as masked or unmasked tokens. Finally,
we show that these embeddings are as effective for homograph disambiguation
with extensive supervised training as with a few-shot setup.
|
[
-0.0139146997,
0.0161613673,
-0.0146189798,
0.0518726185,
-0.0398595221,
0.0380323529,
0.0396326445,
0.0248138495,
-0.0270575304,
-0.0431672521,
-0.0215933863,
-0.0769582093,
0.0309639368,
-0.0407935567,
0.0396005251,
-0.009640432,
0.0310312118,
-0.0433398709,
-0.0321381465,
0.0147727514,
0.0113077145,
0.0544325635,
0.0150212012,
-0.00435449,
-0.0284669492,
-0.0034830803,
0.0015667431,
0.041777093,
0.0424985923,
0.0366161168,
-0.0735618994,
0.0291078184,
-0.0080644758,
0.0777694657,
0.000001671,
-0.0529722832,
-0.0226739664,
0.0008245601,
-0.045935072,
-0.0005715361,
0.0721214786,
-0.0940652862,
-0.0241547376,
0.0100255962,
-0.0001446052,
-0.0204930734,
0.0434719138,
-0.0299903471,
0.0272914991,
0.0390544161,
-0.0043923724,
-0.0549990162,
0.0189917851,
-0.0166307446,
-0.0250969715,
0.031677492,
0.0037257732,
-0.0580327809,
-0.0783389583,
-0.0052716346,
-0.0501686297,
0.0406211317,
0.0235513244,
0.0589832775,
-0.0329469852,
-0.0124882292,
-0.0473563187,
-0.0154830702,
0.0415681824,
0.0029628656,
-0.0789062604,
-0.0491713397,
0.0205615647,
-0.0323928297,
-0.0506530255,
0.0084386561,
0.01941026,
0.0513081439,
-0.0272327419,
0.0125851668,
0.0367294103,
-0.008405203,
0.0443476811,
0.006840101,
-0.0408012643,
-0.0129407374,
0.0588112846,
-0.0054422133,
0.015947856,
0.0160830878,
-0.0228171274,
-0.0108923567,
0.0093680555,
-0.0100052068,
0.0455540754,
0.0333809778,
-0.0142322388,
-0.0408682898,
0.0025738543,
-0.0429305881,
0.0078943325,
0.0447334684,
-0.0325068012,
-0.0018194983,
-0.0261638425,
0.0127018495,
0.0465897769,
0.0161110479,
-0.0349151082,
-0.0014454836,
0.0149445822,
0.0048490795,
-0.0696831271,
0.0243779719,
-0.0489132814,
0.0397196002,
-0.041823823,
0.0171423946,
0.0371157192,
0.0035536713,
-0.0281585176,
-0.0776043013,
-0.0413292274,
0.0026643134,
0.0293133128,
-0.0238125063,
-0.0500471517,
-0.0281517841,
-0.0560689643,
-0.073088862,
0.0036619361,
0.0440554507,
-0.0195476376,
-0.0266246647,
-0.0025597496,
0.0521068089,
0.0070295786,
-0.057543356,
-0.0107150087,
-0.0126751633,
-0.0527356751,
-0.0141159408,
0.0081822444,
-0.0712959096,
0.0592836104,
-0.0075208484,
-0.0321185924,
-0.0145766763,
-0.0540976934,
-0.009269435,
0.0086347684,
0.0897699967,
0.0310764723,
-0.036965806,
0.0158521794,
0.0083970632,
0.0137668466,
0.0571413897,
-0.009725892,
-0.0100690946,
0.040508613,
-0.0081725866,
-0.0275729187,
0.0345134065,
-0.0112241283,
0.0459778123,
-0.024911087,
-0.0437621884,
-0.0127780149,
0.0219392311,
-0.0151729481,
0.069163613,
-0.0417376198,
-0.0549394563,
0.0182925444,
0.0723121017,
0.0198397748,
-0.0183021035,
0.0335999094,
0.0509344488,
0.0366696939,
0.0303451009,
-0.0193542261,
-0.0499977693,
0.0061239046,
0.0226472374,
-0.0221517161,
0.0346013494,
-0.0123271979,
-0.0491509549,
-0.0191714037,
-0.0335906185,
-0.0158632938,
0.0160395354,
0.0842503756,
0.007441299,
-0.0358147696,
0.0354814604,
0.0290132519,
-0.0455295555,
0.0541943349,
-0.0001456572,
-0.0010164056,
0.0290257987,
0.0349620245,
-0.0019833739,
-0.0295661446,
0.014612346,
0.0015097979,
0.0526088402,
-0.0053535081,
0.0090123974,
0.0452740863,
-0.0556002371,
0.0375517868,
0.0258653369,
0.0265415795,
-0.0006113399,
-0.0144436313,
0.0116416924,
0.048756294,
-0.0458174981,
0.0348300263,
0.0160811488,
-0.0187821537,
0.036278747,
-0.0480463356,
0.0301619377,
-0.0098330881,
0.025797233,
-0.0179369673,
-0.002373673,
0.016337594,
-0.0413922109,
0.0325684361,
0.0099036777,
-0.0627085939,
-0.0534463674,
0.027523201,
-0.0159853958,
-0.0223704334,
-0.019972058,
0.0014923391,
-0.0142215509,
0.0348721966,
-0.0160178617,
0.0717603713,
-0.0357336365,
0.0594828911,
0.0171908457,
0.0199531857,
-0.0505811125,
0.049258925,
0.034796942,
0.0354187898,
0.0030461585,
0.0108274799,
0.0246562213,
0.01244683,
-0.0288320854,
0.0113987308,
-0.005389249,
-0.0143545493,
-0.0341958329,
-0.0587504543,
-0.0035297167,
-0.0349553153,
-0.1044812948,
-0.017718168,
-0.0487576611,
0.0406668745,
-0.0047075977,
0.0141153568,
0.0274894834,
-0.012960379,
0.0137470728,
0.0064285025,
-0.001845347,
0.0099866148,
0.0160552468,
-0.0540979356,
-0.0335425064,
-0.0359859318,
-0.0330883488,
-0.0159116816,
0.0541492365,
0.0265323296,
-0.0040799482,
0.0071009849,
-0.0349547192,
-0.0454110615,
0.0026577208,
-0.0091050547,
-0.0175883695,
0.0141844396,
0.0023712795,
0.0642432347,
-0.0056553623,
-0.0133286836,
0.0292507615,
0.0068949619,
-0.0356508195,
-0.0374852791,
-0.0337737016,
0.0183304716,
0.010083437,
-0.0639009699,
-0.0220489223,
-0.0258157961,
0.0439080484,
0.0217387266,
-0.0110839214,
-0.021286102,
0.037140999,
-0.0589661114,
0.0188938323,
0.0408907868,
0.0033092585,
-0.0260420498,
0.0462422557,
-0.0341027491,
-0.0513433963,
0.0386151634,
-0.047104679,
-0.0040397192,
-0.0276483297,
-0.0214908943,
-0.0516458414,
0.0334858112,
0.0058821025,
0.0253011528,
-0.0237388052,
-0.0373693481,
-0.087817125,
0.0013850543,
0.0186571218,
-0.0369269103,
0.0772834048,
-0.0294326842,
-0.0116925761,
-0.0329608656,
-0.0040229866,
-0.0216075778,
-0.0201360919,
-0.0204111245,
0.0291446354,
0.090064086,
0.0199634917,
0.0327091888,
0.003122865,
-0.0669423342,
0.0173629746,
0.0540584177,
0.0030573143,
-0.0299816299,
0.0187750589,
-0.0047056242,
-0.0364357494,
0.0305747315,
-0.0279534683,
0.0149659077,
-0.0217945743,
-0.0257193837,
-0.0338222235,
-0.0420671776,
-0.0026107272,
0.0300352592,
-0.0539086722,
-0.0685104504,
-0.0369897597,
-0.0057720267,
-0.0144114411,
0.0301928781,
0.1139725149,
0.0492145382,
-0.0382056721,
0.0125288963,
0.0031295067,
-0.0061005563,
-0.0232873466,
-0.0092168273,
-0.1251400858,
-0.0150489332,
0.0325592123,
-0.0088214288,
0.0425421558,
-0.0036242565,
0.0294452794,
-0.0762925819,
-0.0298452657,
0.025394693,
-0.0653659925,
-0.0289042275,
0.0300749782,
-0.0245178007,
-0.0166154094,
-0.001172847,
-0.0102938265,
-0.0318470001,
-0.0018600955,
0.0288331676,
-0.0099538099,
0.0044907723,
-0.0225945134,
-0.0637851283,
0.0163999554,
-0.0099447323,
0.0212711934,
-0.0429669358,
0.0057830061,
0.0430170596,
-0.0449750423,
-0.0358689725,
-0.0205828752,
-0.0041337609,
0.0129726725,
-0.0245820303,
-0.0044859443,
-0.0408184789,
-0.0126791298,
-0.0212782267,
-0.0172421858,
0.0309336688,
-0.0027281342,
0.0104798079,
0.0343017653,
0.0389350988,
-0.0529281311,
0.0677834451,
-0.0087909373,
0.0074974312,
-0.0664894283,
-0.0200018901,
0.0651356354,
0.0106865568,
0.0184769854,
-0.0180359054,
0.0112916911,
0.0281041451,
-0.0836035982,
-0.048380442,
0.0065354914,
0.0511840172,
0.0177537184,
0.0077876435,
-0.0116756102,
-0.0007678889,
-0.0505245887,
-0.0042621964,
0.003174803,
0.0417736433,
-0.0529467314,
-0.0106077734,
0.0110061886,
-0.0481362566,
0.020157367,
0.0242596697,
-0.0593072921,
-0.0422591604,
0.0389402471,
-0.0445098765,
0.0111323018,
0.0525282361,
-0.0562897325,
-0.0261340421,
0.0047662635,
-0.0120932907,
-0.0307864863,
0.048164919,
0.0727942437,
0.0455282331,
-0.0293196701,
0.0334870741,
0.0024720102,
0.0406105146,
0.063198328,
-0.0309809037,
-0.0436958894,
-0.0196603406,
-0.0360668898,
-0.0149943111,
0.0250716973,
-0.0225474052,
0.0222179964,
-0.0333472043,
-0.0001092607,
-0.0130126039,
0.0257074777,
-0.0271148775,
-0.0094019482,
0.027434865,
0.0033069311,
-0.012436009,
0.0623944551,
0.0085901329,
0.0155744553,
0.0216910448,
0.0460597984,
0.0189196523,
-0.0342899151,
-0.0405672863,
0.045244392,
0.0149439033,
0.0136502469,
-0.0278610084,
0.0379226618,
-0.0383379087,
0.0027772528,
-0.0635696799,
-0.0211220682,
-0.0196762569,
0.0046658409,
0.0166055355,
0.0063651023,
-0.0106792897,
0.0504968204,
0.0335816704,
-0.0249065068,
0.0577298515,
0.0057401098,
-0.004360687,
-0.0247968473,
0.0411009081,
-0.0033514353,
0.0160483755,
0.033110451,
0.0159915797,
-0.0283516683,
-0.0155166127,
0.0237542391,
0.0551627763,
0.0024552743,
0.0119060017,
-0.0151753807,
0.0061379359,
-0.0172106996,
0.0093432227,
0.0231864899,
-0.0320000798,
-0.0192205813,
-0.1118200347,
-0.0874476582,
0.0095821321,
0.0074057663,
0.002175668,
0.0204298496,
0.0292067919,
0.0522741377,
-0.000196985,
-0.0224653408,
-0.0220784713,
0.035534773,
0.0340306871,
-0.0303179547,
0.0070752371,
-5.057846563e-33,
-0.0218585189,
0.0078262407,
-0.0218200907,
-0.0648901984,
-0.0243058968,
0.028858671,
-0.0033968445,
-0.0132458024,
-0.0271800458,
-0.0213352013,
-0.0021814483,
0.0328477286,
0.0290747415,
0.009541587,
0.0056225392,
-0.0284544341,
0.0763796493,
0.0326404646,
-0.0251902863,
-0.0132484157,
0.0282909125,
0.028227156,
0.0799854249,
0.0514075048,
-0.001947111,
-0.030398529,
0.0225010347,
0.0296954345,
-0.0042725205,
0.0665795282,
0.01642178,
0.0484208241,
0.0206208099,
0.006231945,
-0.0180348195,
0.0031548315,
-0.0848905146,
-0.0189335253,
0.0578867048,
0.0584553666,
-0.0496885739,
-0.015297927,
0.0104908282,
-0.0307047237,
-0.023239119,
-0.0034720569,
0.025418276,
0.0057680677,
-0.0473570153,
-0.019634299,
-0.0630784184,
0.0828392208,
0.0013469785,
0.0224899203,
0.0850768089,
-0.0137954596,
0.0216029994,
0.0275447648,
-0.0708422959,
-0.0344746299,
0.004142941,
0.0194218047,
0.0120776752,
0.0453753024,
-0.0657853857,
0.002718772,
0.0496421829,
-0.0451001339,
0.0510343127,
0.0208874904,
0.0634718016,
-0.0327801481,
0.0310427323,
0.0212771576,
0.02365488,
-0.0155458581,
-0.0170407817,
-0.0758688673,
0.0497646518,
-0.01502949,
0.0103817582,
-0.0090649426,
-0.0707121119,
-0.0288463961,
-0.0542324409,
-0.0484047011,
-0.0194327906,
-0.0083851628,
0.0280907247,
0.0205167215,
-0.014273488,
0.0835240856,
0.0406477489,
-0.0213504899,
0.0470479205,
0.0226458907,
0.007834251,
0.0290140994,
-0.0184976198,
0.0329757854,
-0.0054426687,
-0.0443111658,
0.0161233023,
0.0054545053,
-0.0123748006,
-0.0206087772,
0.0213103499,
-0.0324456356,
-0.0420419089,
0.0145072155,
-0.0306157134,
-0.0183011182,
-0.0136515545,
0.0160253625,
0.0305510592,
0.0340435095,
0.029266946,
0.024708651,
0.0465163551,
-0.0351744704,
-0.0074388534,
0.0960108042,
-0.045092117,
0.0221128743,
-0.0036623734,
0.0137649532,
0.0497957021,
0.0356532857,
0.0792018995,
-0.0406630114,
0.0053345342,
0.0262202732,
2.421e-7,
0.0673040673,
0.0064182789,
0.011971835,
-0.0217740778,
0.0190614257,
-0.0120107541,
0.0373163074,
-0.0341328755,
-0.0243061502,
0.0450481921,
-0.0228265617,
0.0119134681,
0.0980771258,
0.0199497994,
-0.0308040753,
-0.0157092325,
-0.0274193119,
0.0260796044,
-0.0702523962,
0.0362476744,
0.0447536893,
0.1556446701,
-0.0139265032,
-0.0019956424,
-0.0695344135,
0.0043060258,
0.0293214861,
-0.0265863165,
-0.015679827,
0.0094045661,
-0.0229031034,
-0.0040385188,
0.0312629715,
0.0078193629,
-0.0450120978,
0.005316555,
0.0764904469,
0.0661422536,
0.0279056095,
-0.0032935911,
0.0023734837,
-0.0188540854,
-0.0269247629,
-0.026635224,
0.0734611526,
-0.0214488264,
0.031882409,
0.0190053117,
-0.0196209047,
0.0309716947,
0.0009471626,
0.0371372215,
-0.0606693588,
0.0367717706,
0.0701642632,
-0.0272401012,
-0.0083242673,
-0.0597984269,
0.0399248376,
0.0392201729,
-0.0003976729,
-0.0124595491,
0.0052898536,
-0.0300406106,
0.0166305508,
-0.0005778288,
-0.0210663714,
2.298210612e-34,
0.0393858552,
-0.0105409632,
0.0316759683,
-0.0093132276,
0.0064472216,
-0.0087601868,
0.0341960452,
0.054063417,
0.0036880842,
-0.0115710963,
0.0156510584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16891v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16891v1
|
Survey on Reasoning Capabilities and Accessibility of Large Language Models Using Biology-related Questions
| 2024-05-11T20:25:40 | 2024-05-11T20:25:40 |
Michael Ackerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This research paper discusses the advances made in the past decade in
biomedicine and Large Language Models. To understand how the advances have been
made hand-in-hand with one another, the paper also discusses the integration of
Natural Language Processing techniques and tools into biomedicine. Finally, the
goal of this paper is to expand on a survey conducted last year (2023) by
introducing a new list of questions and prompts for the top two language
models. Through this survey, this paper seeks to quantify the improvement made
in the reasoning abilities in LLMs and to what extent those improvements are
felt by the average user. Additionally, this paper seeks to extend research on
retrieval of biological literature by prompting the LLM to answer open-ended
questions in great depth.
|
[
0.0539969988,
0.0304636732,
0.0024522815,
0.005585751,
-0.0439648926,
0.0222021267,
0.0317630544,
0.0360686965,
0.0440750308,
-0.0296350271,
0.0328612812,
-0.0327917039,
-0.017277455,
0.005042112,
0.0177030321,
-0.0144350752,
0.0074951923,
-0.0164934825,
0.0077449083,
-0.0037958026,
-0.014092423,
0.0162627771,
0.0094900494,
0.0134762824,
0.0829144418,
-0.0205957741,
0.0242704432,
-0.0341903381,
0.0085273366,
-0.0557919219,
-0.0482536219,
0.0163491201,
0.01736743,
-0.005001442,
0.0000020108,
-0.0949930549,
-0.0432034805,
0.0533574894,
-0.0581568703,
-0.0123158172,
0.0463447869,
0.0235591009,
-0.0006799563,
0.0113260271,
-0.0155149372,
0.0223655663,
0.0474623181,
0.0100142006,
0.0067959358,
0.0349559374,
0.0012837817,
-0.0447596461,
0.0796546191,
0.0022745782,
0.0591249242,
-0.0274079032,
0.0365317948,
0.0234407373,
0.1216670498,
0.0226362236,
0.0231473371,
0.0795368627,
0.0019379059,
-0.019636305,
0.0167826246,
0.0194477253,
0.02370915,
-0.0446800441,
0.0346274376,
0.012983121,
0.0541373268,
-0.0109141311,
0.0059681921,
0.0180005711,
0.0000714658,
0.0527454279,
-0.0674732178,
0.0094929226,
-0.0238737576,
-0.0204242487,
0.0366183221,
-0.0356017649,
0.0278250091,
0.0234649032,
-0.0479421765,
0.0712082088,
0.0086078066,
-0.032565549,
0.0236357376,
-0.022111129,
0.0207649972,
-0.0221359637,
0.0442478471,
0.057541959,
-0.0089421635,
0.0133241499,
0.0466478579,
-0.0089217825,
0.0838361233,
-0.0679105893,
0.0087656481,
-0.0103586689,
-0.0179613549,
0.0394788124,
0.0028039191,
-0.0073987958,
-0.0630853549,
0.025397528,
-0.0089702802,
0.0261950511,
-0.0787083656,
-0.0460018255,
-0.0067523699,
0.0254685991,
0.0034944427,
0.035040684,
-0.0580260903,
-0.019955948,
0.027176464,
-0.0161241554,
-0.0135916751,
-0.0179242399,
-0.02454268,
0.0034842025,
-0.0652844235,
0.010954584,
-0.0059225201,
-0.0023724262,
-0.0300769079,
-0.0876952037,
0.009091231,
-0.013797163,
0.0179648194,
-0.0271844212,
0.0226991288,
0.0731135458,
0.0081643742,
-0.0297050476,
-0.0012899322,
-0.0448428914,
-0.0478626639,
-0.0475071557,
-0.0246858001,
-0.0713546127,
0.0046240073,
0.0582521595,
-0.0405649506,
-0.0391643904,
0.0184971653,
0.0191647988,
-0.0508966632,
0.0619626455,
-0.0832972676,
-0.0188205875,
0.0353667885,
0.0080941524,
0.0217177216,
-0.004994492,
-0.0052053425,
-0.0565298833,
0.0148343118,
-0.0128538813,
0.0244970359,
-0.027352063,
-0.0239268225,
-0.048664473,
-0.0160500091,
0.0525922067,
-0.0035370197,
0.0601606891,
-0.0554970615,
0.050895229,
0.0095813917,
0.0027263172,
0.0271520782,
0.1106592417,
0.0376157649,
0.0200370625,
-0.0047385767,
0.0017836323,
0.0240074992,
-0.0069590691,
0.0103734937,
0.011058691,
-0.0129748778,
0.028229421,
0.0019772151,
0.0265198667,
0.0284181051,
-0.0533986799,
-0.0537401214,
0.0306396633,
0.0154813733,
-0.0040012845,
0.0467751212,
-0.039718695,
0.012384302,
0.0458385497,
0.0299761742,
-0.0504487343,
0.0061099823,
-0.0440527909,
0.0080417041,
0.0592227466,
0.0386872254,
-0.0496012829,
-0.0200343058,
-0.0144878346,
-0.0156239672,
0.0601298474,
0.0063630971,
0.0106313955,
-0.0427915044,
-0.0278261043,
0.0188803915,
0.0087469099,
-0.0017935969,
-0.0451462232,
-0.0322272889,
0.0571220443,
-0.0046828547,
-0.0410227366,
-0.0369109847,
0.0149412937,
-0.073492974,
-0.0037300219,
-0.0681811348,
-0.0014227947,
-0.0084557263,
0.0210441276,
-0.0129300794,
0.0623141825,
0.0315486081,
-0.0509434678,
-0.0305595212,
-0.012912008,
0.0215105563,
0.0097319521,
0.037977878,
-0.0058228304,
-0.0259305667,
-0.0165057853,
0.0069366395,
0.0000977291,
-0.0049150093,
-0.0416357182,
0.0391507894,
-0.0170322005,
0.0246188771,
-0.0249135885,
-0.0318901278,
-0.0527215526,
0.0320985429,
0.0200303718,
0.034240786,
0.0470771678,
-0.0666314736,
0.0195158347,
-0.0569992326,
0.0008113137,
0.0464347862,
0.0216797758,
0.0113515761,
0.0138975801,
-0.0090124831,
-0.0553823225,
-0.0036641804,
-0.0251589902,
-0.0141216656,
0.0290524624,
0.0610737763,
-0.0034174654,
-0.0073130098,
0.0016618611,
0.0009731349,
-0.0401768759,
-0.0087732524,
0.0097938692,
0.0165597443,
0.0601972118,
0.020905463,
-0.0288329404,
-0.0513430871,
-0.0067707738,
-0.0457414389,
0.0400264263,
0.0574227534,
-0.0336249396,
0.0133462772,
0.0305432975,
-0.0431896038,
-0.0052575087,
0.0123881493,
-0.0057954183,
0.0373439416,
-0.0374008194,
-0.0092405686,
0.0469091684,
-0.0182015058,
0.0306100138,
0.0633132458,
0.021807218,
-0.0169358682,
0.0056510982,
-0.0179669987,
-0.0238959044,
-0.0191826802,
-0.0287742037,
0.0131903915,
0.0420425609,
-0.020111667,
-0.0323971324,
-0.0059081283,
0.0389216915,
-0.0376511216,
0.0003453459,
-0.0309492704,
-0.0003527761,
-0.0207677074,
0.0702476054,
0.0217705648,
-0.0402656756,
0.0838259161,
-0.0213459972,
0.0227334034,
-0.0834746435,
-0.0183414649,
-0.0212248638,
0.0632663965,
-0.0135843363,
0.0265221186,
0.0192544479,
-0.0220862217,
-0.0070675085,
-0.0101527236,
0.0147172576,
-0.0546321459,
0.0624838397,
-0.0391138308,
0.037432164,
0.0099541582,
-0.0128231915,
-0.0042365999,
0.0237514935,
-0.0553701669,
0.0014643172,
0.0357968435,
-0.0116987694,
-0.0594920181,
0.0421493985,
0.049800694,
-0.006288595,
0.0035762645,
-0.0146722822,
0.0064573931,
0.0105402367,
-0.0090028411,
0.0095705027,
0.0211797077,
-0.0182425193,
0.0617858358,
0.0625308454,
-0.035403315,
0.0064472063,
0.0326399244,
0.0215890706,
0.0404037684,
-0.0596520938,
-0.042641405,
0.031652052,
0.0263502803,
-0.0788817033,
0.0008989936,
0.0996268466,
0.0578061566,
-0.0267299823,
0.0018621918,
-0.0825344175,
-0.07207302,
0.0104303984,
0.0658363923,
-0.077257134,
-0.0056419182,
0.0019394526,
-0.0026377856,
-0.0334157757,
-0.0578071624,
-0.0061746887,
-0.0356351621,
0.0507166572,
0.0027255877,
-0.0360521078,
-0.0194799304,
-0.0604208373,
-0.0060225795,
0.0091451937,
-0.0037279699,
0.0386877432,
-0.0047393469,
0.0235903971,
0.0067998334,
-0.0589247756,
-0.0411826484,
0.0207035691,
-0.0262169857,
0.01406781,
0.0361272283,
0.0470605008,
-0.0158203878,
-0.0344523825,
0.0353670903,
0.0106335226,
0.0215658695,
-0.0323098265,
0.0434150659,
0.0526143014,
0.0098032532,
-0.0874107033,
0.002292237,
-0.0153754149,
-0.0123283817,
-0.0012244619,
0.0954828188,
-0.0232633818,
-0.0312651508,
-0.0494058169,
0.0059820539,
-0.0442706831,
0.0477570817,
0.0405427888,
-0.0038792761,
-0.0259315297,
-0.0425557382,
0.0124550899,
0.0087953266,
-0.0811491758,
0.0292790476,
-0.0348382816,
-0.0139936786,
-0.0372336656,
-0.0044732797,
0.0809382424,
0.0010357336,
0.0146506894,
0.0464380495,
0.0431314819,
-0.0262756683,
-0.0388100818,
0.047476355,
0.0344972648,
0.0351704434,
-0.0662870482,
-0.0094702179,
0.0753285289,
0.0122394515,
-0.0243097246,
0.0145181557,
0.0157719851,
-0.0758279562,
-0.0350664966,
0.0004731557,
0.0317500383,
-0.057700377,
0.0039372835,
-0.0667686239,
-0.0000849647,
0.0339496955,
-0.0121071273,
-0.0245817099,
-0.0436215959,
0.0240778141,
-0.0083777122,
0.0169408899,
-0.0270349514,
-0.0216547083,
-0.0245323442,
0.0507886522,
-0.0027966988,
-0.0331345536,
0.060332559,
0.069650434,
0.0261194408,
0.0067390339,
-0.0328095891,
-0.005469712,
0.009951422,
-0.03368406,
-0.0211147889,
0.0020309002,
-0.0183812678,
0.0092913182,
0.0139798047,
-0.0028810182,
-0.0091373445,
-0.0609830767,
0.0116013,
-0.0338708982,
0.0902487859,
0.0101686362,
-0.015330337,
0.0557282269,
-0.0120895198,
-0.0114698196,
-0.0025939445,
-0.0407677442,
0.0460211597,
0.0023751059,
0.02438014,
-0.0137010552,
0.0111751864,
-0.0329706073,
-0.0184662323,
-0.0407005325,
-0.0770756081,
0.0310810599,
0.0160180219,
0.0087814275,
-0.006324701,
0.0094528589,
0.0006094548,
-0.0224598646,
-0.0193124041,
0.003895815,
0.0046429276,
0.0111974031,
0.0789915845,
0.0268180985,
-0.0389678068,
-0.083570987,
0.0402398147,
0.0323279388,
0.0283592641,
-0.0295615774,
-0.0605884269,
0.0050030062,
-0.0361284986,
-0.0037653963,
-0.0133181643,
-0.0284415819,
-0.0000086359,
-0.0702495351,
-0.0483464524,
0.0299558491,
0.0043608597,
-0.0409455337,
-0.002461626,
-0.0178581011,
0.0368532985,
0.0649605617,
-0.0674244016,
-0.0244566686,
0.0830411911,
-0.0588182695,
-0.0192815065,
0.0150278714,
-6.060832342e-33,
0.0159975681,
-0.0527077205,
0.0282934625,
-0.0192790926,
0.0024568869,
-0.0079130931,
-0.0426889807,
0.010763403,
-0.0208457559,
0.0393986776,
-0.0318895094,
-0.0016324187,
0.0027464759,
-0.0120431473,
0.0008848626,
-0.0303506106,
-0.0007499157,
0.016720064,
0.0164703447,
-0.0327151269,
0.0003775998,
0.0430147573,
0.0343044326,
-0.041323211,
0.0557979643,
-0.0029028815,
0.0610975958,
0.0173125695,
-0.0335734934,
0.040501561,
0.0130426716,
0.0290970802,
0.0163743757,
-0.0447433144,
-0.0149375545,
0.0018827769,
-0.0268562213,
0.0111908754,
0.0455174409,
-0.0321422853,
-0.0385416597,
-0.0424456634,
0.0697650537,
0.0092203738,
-0.0328170173,
0.0032219617,
0.0457200445,
-0.0615526959,
-0.0232302025,
-0.0266201124,
-0.0306912735,
0.0329600945,
-0.0181778856,
0.0541131049,
0.0102718994,
0.0093132621,
-0.0377112255,
0.0357988253,
0.0017565937,
0.024825057,
0.0652868301,
0.0350893065,
0.0494204797,
-0.0256502833,
0.0080608465,
0.0310187265,
-0.0049133925,
-0.0150031494,
-0.0202151015,
-0.0024874327,
-0.0225548483,
0.0468382873,
0.0421625003,
0.0171493106,
0.0111524956,
0.0049535735,
-0.0772438869,
0.0444682576,
-0.0234325323,
0.0631907061,
0.0020184335,
0.0020086111,
-0.0116666108,
-0.0255626626,
-0.0494956411,
0.0318787135,
-0.0354457721,
-0.0349608026,
0.0060642362,
-0.094629094,
0.001163604,
-0.0059563536,
0.0134562571,
-0.0035396616,
-0.0569924675,
-0.0302128494,
0.0200602803,
0.0055756113,
-0.0304044634,
0.0333647057,
-0.0450341329,
0.0239377487,
-0.0184394885,
-0.0145830382,
0.0240322649,
-0.0108161755,
-0.0474122316,
-0.0166302137,
-0.0557223819,
-0.018208297,
-0.0108355926,
-0.0061984202,
0.0283506364,
0.0477971956,
0.0231526233,
0.0267735571,
0.0307418834,
0.0709930584,
0.0151839266,
-0.0159917828,
-0.0235080458,
0.0288287699,
-0.0023381207,
-0.0084543638,
-0.0340923406,
-0.0015663186,
-0.0277669709,
0.0939274877,
0.0202278122,
-0.0365257375,
-0.0084916372,
-0.005492093,
2.846e-7,
0.1178585589,
0.0716719329,
0.0065294332,
0.0113018276,
-0.0009052672,
-0.014597428,
-0.0298682041,
-0.0462018363,
0.0028059918,
-0.0020762808,
0.0222042967,
0.0226677656,
0.0119024254,
0.0155531261,
-0.0426268689,
-0.0238934662,
-0.0619776398,
-0.0119221676,
-0.0442493036,
0.0164620541,
0.063328214,
0.0396000184,
-0.0596693605,
0.0021070368,
-0.0088359499,
-0.0527497232,
0.0096277036,
-0.0517553799,
0.0116273416,
0.0429523736,
0.0439300239,
0.0116917249,
0.0433823541,
0.0452286266,
-0.0082088169,
-0.0269495901,
-0.0116287293,
0.0429287627,
-0.0211105142,
0.0358797163,
0.0449517295,
-0.0216740631,
0.0337595344,
-0.0563740209,
0.0265824497,
-0.0379149169,
-0.06552504,
-0.0068866238,
-0.0122771272,
-0.041403681,
0.0239208341,
-0.0190244131,
-0.009166575,
0.0312454235,
-0.0006569932,
-0.0151362717,
-0.0158651303,
-0.0369516462,
-0.025160471,
0.0158007629,
-0.0239645671,
-0.0693948194,
-0.0277880579,
0.0099936565,
0.025729483,
-0.0447556153,
0.0003820777,
2.398100541e-34,
0.0354271941,
0.0244031623,
0.0185339656,
0.0354734324,
0.042860318,
0.008824734,
-0.0097349714,
0.0178902913,
-0.0122678904,
-0.1049494371,
-0.0019469633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07081v1
|
T-curator: a trust based curation tool for LOD logs
| 2024-05-11T19:32:27 | 2024-05-11T19:32:27 |
Dihia Lanasri
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.CL
|
Nowadays, companies are racing towards Linked Open Data (LOD) to improve
their added value, but they are ignoring their SPARQL query logs. If well
curated, these logs can present an asset for decision makers. A naive and
straightforward use of these logs is too risky because their provenance and
quality are highly questionable. Users of these logs in a trusted way have to
be assisted by providing them with in-depth knowledge of the whole LOD
environment and tools to curate these logs. In this paper, we propose an
interactive and intuitive trust based tool that can be used to curate these LOD
logs before exploiting them. This tool is proposed to support our approach
proposed in our previous work Lanasri et al. [2020].
|
[
0.0412191972,
0.0778389052,
0.0090945028,
0.0186923128,
-0.038387429,
-0.0401842706,
0.033324331,
0.0054453923,
0.0664996505,
-0.006331028,
-0.0335706435,
0.0598519146,
-0.0277457666,
0.0722988918,
-0.043309629,
-0.0278336331,
0.0015616673,
-0.0154164657,
-0.0381866656,
-0.0113579361,
0.0011597596,
0.0335889719,
0.0158431288,
-0.0180571005,
0.0001516549,
-0.0078363959,
0.0046559637,
-0.0068781534,
0.0011292589,
-0.0138431741,
-0.028823521,
0.0347816609,
-0.0321382917,
0.0492452048,
0.0000021016,
-0.0456504822,
-0.0403648131,
0.0305958353,
-0.0630984008,
-0.0008985795,
-0.0097602895,
0.0161480382,
0.0257268697,
0.0231044106,
-0.0184651762,
-0.0305057094,
0.0166478492,
0.0068229265,
0.0269530006,
-0.0238521919,
-0.0009068671,
0.0418410748,
-0.0094912099,
0.0067072073,
0.0591846965,
0.0123486146,
-0.0145259621,
-0.0191658195,
0.0251293369,
0.0040438431,
0.002543025,
0.001587298,
-0.0202000663,
-0.0000164141,
0.0275835115,
0.0113499006,
0.0025027383,
-0.0118578197,
-0.0169395041,
-0.0101206489,
0.0539421216,
0.0197481681,
0.0234323367,
0.0062891524,
-0.0118062291,
0.0445082076,
-0.0386101715,
0.0190842133,
-0.0130617768,
0.0094194347,
-0.0441814326,
0.0089596957,
0.0038721394,
0.0095216017,
-0.0300935395,
0.0548599325,
0.0098069031,
-0.0042106621,
-0.0223543514,
-0.0017904749,
0.0911607742,
-0.0351527557,
0.0204591192,
0.0059288358,
-0.006866842,
-0.0055331481,
0.0029435074,
0.0596044287,
0.0214886945,
0.0607324056,
-0.0636560991,
-0.0230752882,
-0.0187291168,
0.0482861325,
0.0622555092,
-0.0248758588,
0.0036751064,
0.0296624247,
0.0798563287,
-0.0339311101,
-0.0340943485,
-0.0020530354,
0.0204944368,
-0.0288861822,
-0.02002744,
0.0319983102,
0.0137709081,
0.0373452902,
-0.0054700789,
0.065480493,
0.0470103323,
0.0048295935,
0.020613851,
-0.0103707006,
-0.0778757706,
-0.091728285,
0.0296725165,
0.0136498082,
-0.0144322468,
-0.0510610081,
-0.0067552249,
-0.0218931492,
0.0620111115,
-0.0169546641,
-0.0090303132,
-0.0068529169,
0.0578481853,
-0.0112456335,
-0.0580489002,
-0.0994182602,
0.0397978798,
0.025748441,
-0.0597864389,
-0.010292599,
0.0190121066,
-0.0166053958,
-0.012062409,
-0.0417642593,
-0.04276729,
0.0120245516,
-0.0509724841,
0.0005028363,
-0.12336649,
-0.0255560093,
-0.0307036377,
0.0132502206,
0.0059327628,
-0.0158947874,
0.0096994415,
0.0618608855,
0.053055767,
0.0264080819,
0.0117585259,
-0.0125004109,
0.0198105089,
-0.0203541052,
0.0544932,
0.0472640283,
-0.0489683636,
-0.0296129305,
0.0037187596,
0.0092377746,
-0.0142394463,
-0.0235656258,
0.0594709702,
0.0135161635,
0.0559276007,
-0.020909857,
0.0028864546,
0.033909861,
-0.0183788333,
-0.0135555873,
-0.0526481271,
0.0517941788,
0.0474632829,
-0.0407705233,
-0.0009556137,
0.0314507335,
-0.0104529625,
-0.0122273192,
0.0129646976,
-0.0161901265,
-0.015265977,
0.0283200145,
-0.0029047669,
0.0435435995,
0.0413371399,
0.028086232,
-0.0221643206,
0.0045702471,
0.0170589164,
-0.0113302302,
0.0547304451,
0.040119715,
0.0574524589,
-0.0288534351,
-0.002584002,
-0.0411637388,
-0.0046167462,
0.0071703494,
0.0201772824,
0.0047109337,
-0.0251067132,
-0.0180812441,
-0.0809521973,
0.0313902237,
0.0307317358,
-0.0347186066,
-0.0071152924,
0.0473014563,
-0.0092164595,
-0.0758338273,
0.0106723616,
0.0008118097,
0.0862195194,
0.0075698798,
0.0078991372,
0.0205885023,
0.0201288126,
0.0603266135,
0.0504375286,
0.0136608966,
0.0263905227,
0.0543374531,
-0.0452869609,
0.0515128896,
0.0581589006,
0.0857720301,
-0.0265354384,
-0.0513154529,
0.0174007937,
-0.0012622899,
-0.0411097221,
-0.0173874609,
-0.0042978204,
-0.0151342563,
0.0206480045,
-0.0058313105,
-0.0401903279,
0.0058408435,
-0.0108719356,
-0.0205633789,
0.0089070629,
0.0029253988,
0.0052508875,
-0.0466246791,
-0.0102951108,
0.0202910025,
-0.0488275327,
0.0668202639,
-0.0025691981,
-0.0197668187,
0.0147645092,
0.0073948056,
-0.0248572752,
-0.0584708191,
0.0241272785,
-0.0052352669,
-0.0183577873,
-0.0048926538,
0.0188745763,
-0.0092563564,
0.0324453935,
-0.0150323762,
-0.0050820773,
-0.043291837,
0.0223247726,
0.0289409086,
0.0012654356,
0.0379519239,
0.0318266861,
0.0102409897,
0.0141441105,
0.0153739406,
0.0045164088,
0.0131822098,
0.0052377242,
0.0103669455,
-0.0340982676,
-0.032674253,
-0.0749711171,
-0.0507225804,
0.0231674444,
0.0478853323,
-0.0026005066,
0.004429976,
-0.0413166955,
0.0335241221,
0.0035665142,
0.0389264561,
0.010075829,
-0.0241447873,
-0.0360541306,
-0.0488287136,
0.0133943632,
0.0112775825,
0.0071378644,
0.0426596068,
0.0902995095,
-0.0598696284,
0.0267294794,
0.0040824302,
-0.0008580265,
0.0154997027,
0.0245384946,
0.0122258589,
0.0005542684,
-0.0216238946,
0.0071449149,
0.0639770031,
0.028479306,
-0.0652580857,
0.0171186123,
0.0109138321,
0.0429263972,
0.0031320378,
-0.0448404513,
-0.067954503,
0.0526948012,
-0.0206313692,
0.0369366072,
-0.0202001184,
-0.0628828704,
0.0297080372,
-0.0180341788,
0.0408217311,
-0.0343762115,
-0.0559573844,
0.0006722435,
-0.0616214126,
0.0077447081,
-0.0040984522,
-0.0003913436,
0.0022346461,
-0.0637068897,
-0.0405589007,
-0.0036786881,
-0.0378453061,
-0.0308049656,
-0.0149812335,
0.0273853783,
0.0027234256,
0.0299821123,
-0.0316159613,
0.0195703954,
-0.040510755,
-0.0173706133,
0.0003741409,
-0.0059176721,
0.0380078293,
-0.032478109,
0.06842345,
0.0322180651,
-0.0755034089,
0.0113618551,
0.0022945381,
0.0129184304,
-0.019177068,
0.0397948362,
-0.024823796,
-0.0183479376,
-0.0037818882,
0.0187740698,
0.0132192019,
0.0531424321,
-0.0355055369,
0.0114355525,
0.0079130931,
0.0173167996,
-0.0104252761,
0.0080822501,
-0.1209874824,
0.0058260611,
-0.0236023292,
0.0288896449,
-0.0158502795,
-0.1020469666,
-0.0065787453,
-0.0331121273,
0.0622730032,
-0.024541501,
-0.0032265645,
-0.0172977671,
-0.1286975592,
-0.0107869068,
-0.0694415271,
-0.0784421563,
-0.0169526841,
-0.0030631772,
0.0006301867,
0.0045449324,
-0.0109165385,
0.0112002278,
0.0019733361,
-0.0729069188,
0.0219266582,
-0.0237339661,
0.0121426452,
0.0255784858,
-0.0453800596,
-0.0441865213,
0.0547157638,
-0.0269168038,
-0.0478169024,
0.0736572817,
-0.0075172926,
0.0094111189,
-0.0225295052,
0.0639642254,
0.0124983443,
0.023437934,
-0.0140038766,
0.0796296746,
-0.0079655284,
0.0125617152,
0.0028808361,
-0.0440238193,
0.037324857,
0.0446434245,
-0.0026011416,
-0.0136065204,
0.0271746684,
-0.0183898117,
-0.0093251364,
0.065079838,
-0.0178152826,
0.0985771194,
-0.0299691316,
-0.0174253136,
-0.0302007981,
-0.0231735557,
0.0233861692,
0.0469491147,
-0.0062255831,
-0.0321882777,
0.018310912,
-0.0065423115,
0.0022584321,
-0.0015056164,
-0.0848236308,
0.0646522269,
-0.0446649007,
0.0704821721,
0.0007323363,
0.0073934826,
0.0017753093,
0.0196483247,
0.0120266508,
-0.0048529725,
0.0175407119,
0.0255406443,
0.0311397538,
-0.0203980859,
-0.0094360132,
-0.0381062999,
0.0038894359,
0.0298103634,
-0.063679561,
-0.0883239657,
-0.0048916419,
0.0127224959,
-0.0183793567,
0.0204405468,
-0.0734998062,
-0.0479779243,
-0.0199603327,
-0.0821523294,
-0.0020815108,
-0.0267477464,
0.0242361724,
0.0408122726,
0.033567071,
0.0453497693,
0.0460239165,
-0.0160979703,
0.0381698981,
-0.0070204586,
0.0164600257,
0.0086661596,
0.0710915774,
0.0098259747,
-0.0253299139,
0.0183469411,
0.0245669521,
-0.0207938366,
0.0065319361,
-0.0789062455,
-0.0004688614,
0.0168048553,
-0.0063142926,
0.0258941948,
-0.0128018148,
-0.0339834429,
0.0022468141,
-0.0157530829,
0.0510535426,
0.0047162599,
-0.0278961994,
-0.010958177,
-0.0249744877,
0.0069820159,
-0.0107019292,
-0.0991133451,
-0.0406897292,
0.0422643162,
-0.0574061163,
0.006782061,
0.0127022909,
0.0047930987,
-0.0370795578,
0.0028912462,
0.0114238877,
-0.0234710649,
0.0256600063,
-0.0110888705,
0.0102804117,
0.0013443633,
-0.0316332318,
0.0226376895,
0.0388105474,
0.0072053503,
0.0227344129,
-0.075502187,
-0.0601866581,
-0.0524925366,
-0.0263845734,
0.0505123511,
0.063011989,
-0.041510649,
-0.0797461867,
-0.0266799685,
0.0112023754,
0.0528656058,
-0.0020116046,
0.021733921,
0.0176050924,
0.0050374623,
0.0244603362,
0.0154477013,
0.0229413603,
-0.0218225867,
-0.0512104705,
-0.0095454836,
-0.0576887056,
-0.0053892955,
-5.851082641e-33,
0.0368584357,
-0.0548735261,
0.0004738613,
0.0467813835,
0.0314509049,
-0.0127901947,
0.0029113204,
-0.0235518888,
-0.0019040232,
0.0147559922,
0.0003128783,
-0.0028821686,
0.0404522792,
-0.0051779761,
-0.0090094907,
-0.0098963063,
0.0451538675,
0.0017896404,
0.0190042984,
0.0077926824,
0.0830414593,
-0.0107127279,
-0.0336668193,
-0.1008622423,
0.0758683234,
-0.0152226835,
-0.0309110284,
0.0564982519,
0.0252722241,
0.0479350798,
0.0071718995,
-0.005616264,
-0.0144330496,
-0.0027626625,
0.0079254033,
-0.0273172148,
-0.057454031,
-0.0100195007,
0.008376251,
-0.0148154479,
0.0234228075,
0.0240784362,
-0.0035680346,
0.014742882,
0.0080999928,
0.0195160601,
-0.0141422218,
0.0199686289,
-0.0469403043,
-0.0605723187,
0.0226586573,
0.0215015616,
-0.036956545,
0.0421560444,
0.0379245169,
0.014336627,
0.0389302336,
0.0045874324,
-0.0797122493,
0.0443019904,
-0.0796151459,
-0.065196909,
-0.0029718562,
-0.0369531363,
-0.0108852927,
0.0097783804,
-0.0681865811,
-0.0360845067,
0.0338104181,
0.1083518118,
-0.0658038929,
0.0959577933,
0.0029378228,
0.0574719347,
-0.0213595796,
-0.0487211347,
-0.0267654117,
0.0345199592,
0.0094922297,
0.0016132701,
-0.0127899377,
0.0090066213,
-0.0175398793,
0.0218538027,
-0.0049489792,
-0.0277336743,
-0.0517037399,
-0.0071885479,
0.0008437618,
0.0374647789,
-0.0538298376,
0.0020229963,
-0.007732233,
-0.0049734893,
-0.0284216329,
0.0122766551,
0.0442801341,
-0.0196344182,
0.0128286239,
-0.0165227689,
-0.0064604655,
0.0084228143,
0.0224126112,
0.0019460638,
-0.0113722766,
0.0056172339,
0.0597612821,
-0.0199896824,
-0.0408665985,
0.0442084819,
-0.0087707127,
0.0213543884,
-0.0300382804,
-0.0718081743,
0.0458467752,
-0.0106601687,
0.0081387898,
0.0430245586,
0.0291066784,
0.0231064558,
-0.0034779711,
0.0024382977,
-0.0090303365,
-0.0092570269,
0.0513935536,
-0.0405432768,
0.0292081777,
-0.0614680275,
0.0458843261,
-0.0005752051,
0.0052089281,
-0.0550668128,
2.778e-7,
0.0063627972,
-0.0121589005,
-0.0041436125,
0.0096624773,
0.0569493696,
-0.0139970062,
0.0313827395,
0.0769479498,
-0.037124604,
-0.0424719527,
0.006000923,
-0.0207690187,
0.0304872878,
0.0709415972,
-0.0404144004,
-0.0546142459,
-0.0013277797,
-0.0747554675,
-0.0770992413,
-0.0091563389,
0.0287221931,
-0.002289095,
0.0122197056,
0.0004034474,
0.0248906612,
-0.0204123724,
-0.0218993388,
-0.0155877462,
-0.0157873109,
-0.0295128245,
0.1165474802,
-0.0122715561,
-0.0078492062,
-0.0284656174,
-0.0433980785,
-0.001328818,
-0.0622924976,
0.0041840337,
0.0239882022,
0.0146512026,
0.0207581278,
-0.1171183884,
0.0177540835,
-0.0283857211,
0.0436364934,
0.0447571725,
-0.02446457,
0.0498636179,
-0.0054417001,
-0.0422369428,
0.0351960771,
-0.0014158639,
-0.025105698,
0.0029869177,
-0.0053315279,
0.0215332843,
0.0104983011,
-0.0400084406,
-0.0195699017,
-0.0604450516,
0.0068802335,
-0.0311502628,
0.0118770432,
0.0190874711,
0.002655952,
0.0375967845,
0.0152127072,
2.142852504e-34,
0.0027219062,
0.0524358898,
-0.0095908428,
-0.0281032249,
0.0701507032,
0.0035249218,
0.0252107717,
0.0058843913,
0.0456835888,
-0.0350569598,
0.0092787622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07076v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07076v2
|
Integrating Emotional and Linguistic Models for Ethical Compliance in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-11T19:26:00 | 2024-05-14T03:08:12 |
Edward Y. Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
This research develops advanced methodologies for Large Language Models
(LLMs) to better manage linguistic behaviors related to emotions and ethics. We
introduce DIKE, an adversarial framework that enhances the LLMs' ability to
internalize and reflect global human values, adapting to varied cultural
contexts to promote transparency and trust among users. The methodology
involves detailed modeling of emotions, classification of linguistic behaviors,
and implementation of ethical guardrails. Our innovative approaches include
mapping emotions and behaviors using self-supervised learning techniques,
refining these guardrails through adversarial reviews, and systematically
adjusting outputs to ensure ethical alignment. This framework establishes a
robust foundation for AI systems to operate with ethical integrity and cultural
sensitivity, paving the way for more responsible and context-aware AI
interactions.
|
[
0.0688401163,
0.1202246174,
-0.0414645337,
0.0465956852,
-0.0496256985,
-0.0011945133,
0.0374457277,
-0.0197338574,
0.0725842863,
-0.026243154,
-0.0403834395,
-0.0097507173,
-0.0256346334,
0.037029352,
-0.0075225057,
-0.0291584358,
0.0431459807,
0.0384892039,
0.0653515682,
-0.0265227333,
0.0225388277,
0.0510763004,
0.0422481336,
0.0160772856,
-0.0096340617,
-0.0003286047,
0.0033553764,
-0.010756392,
0.0473508947,
0.0030965097,
0.0342239477,
0.0235720668,
0.0066180788,
0.0521836355,
0.0000018885,
-0.0590004586,
-0.0139350547,
0.0067624128,
0.0192847569,
-0.0002247763,
0.1055988595,
-0.0357340761,
-0.0377673693,
-0.0118831741,
-0.0651571378,
0.0240082797,
0.0495280735,
0.0554659255,
0.0859188437,
0.059198536,
-0.0214956384,
0.0203415509,
0.0172834657,
-0.0090567367,
-0.0666521192,
-0.0405106954,
0.0290923193,
0.0059145391,
-0.0582914427,
-0.0057464181,
-0.0180197563,
0.0180296488,
0.0299622267,
-0.02247498,
-0.040196795,
-0.03968326,
-0.0105268275,
-0.0436874814,
0.0012686214,
0.0570910983,
-0.0150789926,
-0.0069286809,
0.0287606753,
0.006044277,
0.0069191544,
-0.0104098162,
0.0046126591,
0.0463829525,
-0.0062682051,
0.0056993077,
0.0137436911,
0.0235184152,
0.0183937252,
0.1112474352,
0.0325478688,
-0.0063361721,
-0.0283424035,
-0.0052937758,
-0.0069954521,
-0.021979278,
0.0006218876,
-0.0239696726,
0.0609902218,
0.025697872,
-0.0279583614,
0.0209858119,
-0.0406438261,
-0.0025342223,
0.0466016196,
-0.0683038235,
0.007729393,
0.0285606161,
-0.0085992515,
0.0146251805,
0.0104626594,
0.0437896289,
-0.0076756435,
0.053152252,
-0.0281170979,
0.0045832493,
0.0165368915,
0.0036663604,
-0.0003793742,
0.0017068166,
-0.0347013772,
0.0327473357,
-0.0738331452,
-0.0029489833,
-0.0781685784,
0.0371173918,
-0.0283977389,
0.014790589,
-0.0165681224,
-0.0140288323,
-0.019137146,
0.0041805413,
-0.0376141705,
0.0221996009,
-0.0128046209,
-0.0029670456,
0.0210633148,
-0.0120389499,
-0.0574956723,
0.0127076227,
0.0163851734,
0.0892170072,
0.0280033089,
0.0280511323,
-0.0341604874,
-0.0082600005,
-0.0161594711,
-0.0569879487,
-0.0167362336,
-0.0305494331,
0.0307310093,
-0.0275994316,
-0.0276679602,
-0.0928732008,
0.0248419549,
0.0099777412,
0.0023282382,
0.0746704489,
0.0273667518,
-0.0199599154,
0.0216188058,
0.0600024462,
0.0193143878,
0.0309013277,
0.0102771269,
0.0762791112,
0.0501081795,
-0.0211027246,
0.0053557795,
0.0102844639,
0.0051843198,
0.0019235136,
-0.0692592636,
-0.0124936886,
-0.007040909,
0.0128210094,
0.0255506728,
0.0722657144,
-0.0116095617,
-0.0572960936,
0.0483769737,
0.0682330355,
-0.0610394441,
0.0315015167,
-0.0067581632,
0.0117227742,
-0.0168269016,
-0.0051743691,
-0.0569315702,
0.03203528,
0.0102323405,
-0.0517644584,
-0.0716585442,
0.0675510168,
-0.0017619793,
-0.0565578304,
0.013147613,
-0.0376462601,
0.0588602647,
0.0293207988,
-0.0102035701,
0.0170711521,
0.0146582844,
-0.0558881126,
0.0311319474,
-0.0817336366,
-0.0056656948,
-0.048667185,
0.0384722017,
0.1047706753,
0.0370135792,
-0.0178860612,
0.0228209589,
-0.0551113114,
-0.0091845049,
0.0377372615,
0.0212976336,
-0.0170755144,
-0.0025932456,
-0.0438950658,
-0.0471164472,
0.0043944046,
-0.0167145338,
0.0191139225,
-0.0069071641,
0.0172476657,
0.0052424478,
-0.0170467235,
-0.0619055927,
0.0322769471,
-0.0392285027,
-0.0218687318,
-0.0265810378,
0.0319975652,
0.028807506,
0.0106839174,
0.0164414085,
-0.0218097195,
0.0083028348,
-0.0047303224,
-0.0209244601,
-0.0184367858,
-0.0245135594,
0.021616511,
0.0419359095,
-0.0405746326,
-0.0272371173,
0.0439104363,
-0.0395113416,
0.0321379788,
-0.0009301013,
0.0246339682,
-0.0056935917,
-0.0696508884,
-0.0219870657,
-0.0438316837,
0.006153712,
-0.0331927612,
0.0250618421,
-0.0442825854,
-0.0297711212,
-0.0288180187,
-0.0065779877,
0.0308022238,
0.016228551,
-0.056516774,
0.0331494175,
-0.0240504853,
0.0459702946,
0.0437613018,
0.0237360224,
-0.0236628484,
-0.0400634557,
-0.0736433342,
-0.027349351,
0.0032468312,
-0.0046568434,
0.003013094,
-0.0163881518,
-0.0010382892,
0.0071731159,
-0.0504141375,
-0.018832894,
0.0036697849,
0.0237435512,
0.0203978978,
-0.0354286842,
-0.0182685107,
-0.0289362632,
-0.0079636853,
-0.0291611515,
0.0042107753,
0.0138090504,
-0.0128830718,
-0.0231613759,
-0.0091535356,
-0.0618984662,
0.0201814808,
-0.009381691,
-0.0956428722,
-0.00758994,
0.0486008041,
-0.011148544,
0.077576153,
0.0388345905,
0.0638673156,
0.0626037046,
0.0471747518,
-0.0518171601,
-0.0087691443,
0.0250713825,
0.0054049813,
-0.0091584204,
-0.0227723401,
-0.0189480186,
0.0285415035,
0.0059517743,
-0.0071982709,
-0.0202922653,
0.0600477234,
-0.052031707,
-0.0807378292,
0.004648908,
-0.0657685995,
-0.0150117157,
0.0243966822,
-0.0127222342,
-0.0562982,
0.0924773067,
0.0460826568,
0.023758186,
-0.0140201412,
-0.0117563857,
-0.0036173158,
0.070943445,
-0.0276187994,
0.0773322359,
0.0169436019,
-0.0060477084,
-0.0394691862,
-0.0199489314,
0.0454027988,
-0.0713262856,
0.0124043291,
-0.0110512059,
-0.0143306097,
0.0243354458,
-0.0456206873,
-0.0693947226,
-0.040184848,
-0.0118855936,
0.005069776,
0.0020255027,
-0.0017985125,
-0.0189694446,
-0.0090312222,
0.0239013769,
-0.0289008021,
0.0077859033,
0.0065520499,
-0.0022216837,
-0.039388895,
0.055125095,
-0.0334484391,
0.0413393676,
0.0093935309,
0.0671636686,
0.0574763082,
0.0080036335,
-0.0082371747,
0.0348901749,
0.0160531923,
0.0255631879,
0.0183064751,
0.035330113,
0.0009876561,
-0.0016614941,
-0.0261086393,
0.0261571463,
0.0831431225,
0.0138735967,
-0.0558631308,
0.0116278166,
-0.0418467224,
-0.0121456282,
0.0135520585,
0.0243600551,
-0.0688904002,
0.0110513419,
-0.0271985121,
0.0238488615,
-0.0470600128,
-0.0349759795,
0.0114648165,
-0.0738130137,
0.0167236794,
0.037778493,
-0.0168878976,
-0.0269125048,
0.0091178641,
-0.0165370181,
-0.0289908983,
0.0566828474,
-0.0421974026,
0.0119534181,
-0.0683594719,
-0.0074816053,
0.0007833336,
-0.0131497476,
0.0392717347,
-0.0554183498,
0.0708752796,
0.083116211,
0.0745624974,
-0.037303336,
-0.0558932871,
-0.0039662519,
0.0206628125,
-0.0191494431,
0.0205122307,
0.0251128394,
-0.0323412232,
-0.0119387265,
-0.0404640809,
0.0239487216,
-0.0067475992,
-0.0355479009,
0.0051940735,
0.0643213615,
0.0020571623,
-0.0318979844,
-0.0208749641,
0.0192712434,
0.0361786671,
0.0630165488,
-0.0176684204,
-0.0711643547,
0.0068722889,
-0.0431050882,
-0.0046189469,
0.0065415949,
-0.0352153778,
0.009506573,
-0.0396614708,
-0.0300603826,
-0.074108392,
-0.0662102848,
-0.0267607924,
0.0044535724,
0.0415060222,
-0.0420294553,
0.0273539927,
-0.0079622688,
-0.0144247375,
0.0042886557,
-0.0153626706,
0.0436790399,
0.0186909288,
0.0154760508,
0.0128566409,
-0.0072431988,
0.0200147089,
0.0309629738,
0.0506709255,
-0.0540768467,
0.0673243701,
0.062939778,
0.0081516281,
0.0220145322,
-0.0138084479,
-0.0193464961,
-0.001563243,
0.0404696204,
-0.0522121564,
-0.0107259965,
0.0708070844,
0.0154659031,
-0.0262820944,
0.0218274351,
-0.0100687239,
0.0280400664,
0.0441919863,
0.0076782661,
-0.074549675,
-0.0452502035,
0.0365365706,
0.0270402823,
-0.0114387777,
-0.0385202281,
-0.0214956328,
-0.0380665176,
-0.0464827381,
-0.0105354199,
-0.0519372262,
-0.0282563977,
0.0119343484,
0.0342016071,
0.0101875886,
0.0062404783,
0.0006175053,
-0.022694638,
-0.0413346663,
-0.001592158,
0.0193186477,
-0.0017448341,
0.088585414,
-0.0348021053,
0.0240041204,
-0.0271273982,
0.0472492874,
0.0251107179,
0.0308070257,
-0.0201587304,
0.0628732964,
0.0394537821,
0.0090964288,
0.0074898074,
0.0442214869,
-0.0127501246,
-0.0027659265,
-0.0074273604,
-0.0090379408,
0.0122545166,
0.0020092218,
0.0228263941,
-0.033809524,
0.0032252246,
-0.0113579938,
-0.000926955,
0.0041420856,
-0.0598257072,
0.003151966,
0.0019115036,
-0.0422327705,
0.0037611979,
0.0028677771,
-0.0401920006,
0.0483479127,
-0.0145251537,
-0.029658867,
-0.0142479064,
-0.0483836308,
0.0946499407,
-0.0408635214,
-0.0217610747,
0.0078323865,
-0.0748527721,
-0.0640248507,
-0.0229884963,
-0.0019738104,
-0.0300579518,
-0.0548625663,
0.0078069018,
0.0637814552,
0.0003154129,
0.0353272855,
-0.0482762195,
0.0114793759,
-0.0323320553,
-0.0345221311,
-0.0134721007,
-5.370866015e-33,
-0.002484774,
-0.053574115,
-0.0288134664,
-0.0150076551,
-0.001012067,
-0.0111262193,
0.0017188664,
0.0011680741,
-0.0396086872,
0.0508074127,
-0.0093931034,
0.0053382115,
-0.0094581181,
-0.0102623412,
0.0033475768,
-0.043929711,
0.0346626379,
0.0191284698,
-0.0106804026,
0.0212273374,
0.0104311621,
0.0073156762,
0.0182341691,
-0.1183133647,
0.0602128804,
0.0394018143,
-0.0684523657,
0.0239343736,
-0.0103223473,
0.0486657545,
-0.0027873856,
0.0715730339,
0.0028481213,
0.018144032,
0.020476656,
0.0383889452,
-0.021104183,
0.0037742543,
0.0255559999,
-0.0083239032,
-0.0185021423,
-0.0472556092,
0.013052606,
-0.0444267765,
-0.0378198028,
0.015534292,
0.0298665818,
-0.0225076396,
-0.002127219,
-0.0385105722,
-0.0630533993,
-0.0162639376,
-0.031057382,
-0.0049555143,
-0.0081131374,
0.0284956582,
-0.0142753394,
-0.0044830325,
-0.0400432013,
0.0116078351,
-0.0174454488,
-0.0400517695,
0.052865278,
-0.0267356187,
0.0024742924,
0.0839966834,
0.000581212,
0.0311044846,
-0.0245931782,
-0.0043956917,
0.0312529206,
0.0455701649,
0.0584831201,
0.0880378932,
-0.0585786328,
-0.0623107776,
-0.0351166241,
0.0204106271,
0.0323037766,
0.0477152877,
0.022535732,
0.0010423773,
-0.0281231068,
-0.0187796764,
-0.0199289639,
-0.0347751081,
-0.021886969,
-0.031612359,
0.0220387429,
-0.0334937423,
-0.0473448895,
-0.0361011699,
-0.0082022352,
-0.0718111992,
0.0111082457,
0.0490933545,
0.039091032,
-0.0300280843,
0.01484113,
0.0557949468,
-0.0139727369,
0.0093634333,
-0.0295597892,
-0.045847673,
0.0384099334,
-0.0027229853,
0.0509830378,
0.0343440995,
-0.0278761368,
0.0105706183,
-0.000638571,
0.0320135355,
0.0067455457,
-0.0116310008,
-0.0014572963,
-0.0050200252,
-0.0098962802,
-0.0018778357,
0.0333665498,
0.0071695056,
-0.0327074006,
-0.0011022058,
-0.0157147348,
0.0383075178,
-0.050772097,
-0.0057585663,
-0.0423883684,
0.0189972408,
0.0421480834,
-0.0473794751,
-0.0099948281,
-0.0035815034,
2.578e-7,
-0.0073385676,
0.0185055193,
-0.0009761275,
-0.0169880707,
-0.0234011747,
0.0642495379,
0.0286944769,
0.067254059,
-0.0010008295,
-0.0356435999,
0.0312559493,
0.0219343118,
0.0733051375,
0.028412208,
-0.0433997847,
0.0083249742,
-0.036299523,
0.0006310137,
-0.0338729322,
0.0542103909,
0.0064558075,
0.0583018512,
0.0292069223,
-0.0222710855,
0.004804241,
-0.0043405984,
0.0347472504,
-0.0539964549,
-0.0060679093,
0.0013923869,
0.0020671466,
-0.0374656953,
0.0257528629,
-0.0004304606,
0.0133872489,
-0.0006857438,
0.0465423763,
0.1090845466,
-0.0136847496,
-0.0174982511,
-0.0153759057,
-0.0187875312,
0.001730838,
-0.052557908,
0.0313434638,
-0.0081639495,
-0.0327892043,
-0.0602942668,
0.0337702222,
-0.0450755544,
0.0452254117,
-0.0293453168,
-0.0476109199,
0.0047697797,
0.0260921698,
0.0047773607,
0.0126010012,
-0.029696513,
0.0032946349,
-0.0304472093,
0.0122389086,
-0.0431668647,
0.0279769134,
0.0382743441,
0.0022613534,
-0.0264039859,
0.0515162796,
1.95529113e-34,
0.0052646375,
-0.0351766497,
0.000560056,
0.0163694061,
0.0502264872,
0.0682212114,
-0.0303789489,
0.0233533103,
0.0298493132,
-0.0008696982,
-0.0017252918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.13000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.13000v1
|
RAGE Against the Machine: Retrieval-Augmented LLM Explanations
| 2024-05-11T19:08:38 | 2024-05-11T19:08:38 |
Joel Rorseth, Parke Godfrey, Lukasz Golab, Divesh Srivastava, Jaroslaw Szlichta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This paper demonstrates RAGE, an interactive tool for explaining Large
Language Models (LLMs) augmented with retrieval capabilities; i.e., able to
query external sources and pull relevant information into their input context.
Our explanations are counterfactual in the sense that they identify parts of
the input context that, when removed, change the answer to the question posed
to the LLM. RAGE includes pruning methods to navigate the vast space of
possible explanations, allowing users to view the provenance of the produced
answers.
|
[
0.0192568544,
0.004243454,
-0.0353422202,
0.0855990127,
-0.0365149714,
-0.0132124852,
-0.01634489,
0.0135519197,
-0.0211426597,
-0.014355991,
0.027085904,
0.0003260919,
0.0027741222,
-0.0049828114,
0.0244118124,
-0.0436844118,
0.0224480387,
-0.0502582304,
0.013631098,
0.0078658694,
0.0036132501,
0.0240631383,
-0.0033809904,
0.0529417582,
0.0144175077,
-0.023840284,
-0.0400568433,
0.0005080769,
-0.0356182829,
-0.0188935865,
-0.0184583366,
-0.000494903,
0.0427459255,
0.0382400602,
0.0000022378,
-0.0385419875,
-0.0044582044,
0.0123630483,
-0.0799197033,
0.0412355661,
-0.0375327431,
0.0364263803,
0.0248389486,
0.019373944,
-0.0089805266,
0.0158858486,
0.044462841,
0.0264985692,
0.0518480539,
0.0519547872,
0.0241042208,
-0.0214671791,
-0.0249776058,
-0.0142721944,
0.0807873756,
-0.0058759665,
0.0010154457,
0.0154765351,
0.0605767556,
0.0141929463,
0.0034096374,
0.0365408845,
0.0281583834,
-0.0506398417,
-0.0296430942,
0.0048343386,
0.0275479052,
-0.0240262523,
0.0125441262,
0.037264619,
0.0270335637,
-0.0369700566,
-0.006592399,
0.0091891149,
0.0069018672,
0.044442445,
-0.1036846936,
0.0236544963,
-0.0103580533,
-0.00190831,
-0.0131312041,
-0.0305224638,
0.0658608526,
0.0129082967,
-0.024254702,
0.0778385848,
-0.0087648155,
-0.004272508,
-0.0615148768,
-0.01041074,
0.0117634935,
-0.0523505285,
0.0180860031,
0.1011092216,
-0.0381846465,
0.026194945,
0.0385583378,
0.003459434,
0.0283780638,
-0.0248594154,
0.0042621568,
0.0161417387,
-0.0389022157,
0.0443444438,
0.0102110337,
0.0505193621,
-0.0282365158,
-0.0203140359,
-0.0255564917,
-0.0040707644,
-0.0360830054,
-0.0514524318,
-0.0089473967,
-0.0034973486,
-0.0562917441,
0.0216653254,
0.0032043846,
0.0310032628,
-0.0167850349,
-0.0068319472,
0.0020349692,
0.0069566593,
-0.0029913893,
-0.0241646003,
-0.0593956038,
0.0171270482,
-0.0518146567,
-0.0138240624,
0.0187327955,
-0.0847844332,
-0.0397430956,
0.0049734791,
-0.0031231793,
-0.0067167119,
-0.007929422,
0.0825954005,
0.0083106523,
0.0130763818,
-0.0340057947,
-0.0584628731,
-0.0198313631,
-0.0411849916,
-0.0243260246,
-0.05547956,
-0.0044792024,
0.0073367567,
-0.0327221639,
-0.042152375,
0.0198108442,
0.0291492678,
-0.0328734666,
0.0414457135,
-0.0595569015,
0.0246784799,
0.0415772945,
0.0082996432,
-0.0164694861,
0.0393557288,
0.0114975553,
0.0113020884,
0.040969234,
-0.023694938,
0.0629004687,
0.0181376766,
0.03965744,
-0.0088383434,
-0.0496605001,
0.0199122634,
-0.037342567,
0.0367368311,
0.0079804407,
0.0235876609,
-0.0352127813,
0.0138566876,
0.0282034259,
0.0595954992,
0.0125396233,
0.0090963794,
0.0273104012,
0.005929932,
0.0019551709,
0.0365248546,
-0.0381555855,
0.0327191874,
-0.0321270414,
0.0061587212,
0.0004509437,
0.012921771,
0.0004353437,
-0.0724702999,
-0.0282552261,
0.0292672385,
-0.0193207487,
0.0315337256,
0.050870169,
0.0042079207,
-0.0002357479,
0.066600509,
0.0367467031,
-0.043807961,
-0.0101950904,
-0.0694535375,
0.0835211426,
0.0724650472,
0.0710026547,
-0.0570661463,
-0.0088176131,
0.0123754321,
0.017635189,
0.0336205401,
0.0208828263,
-0.0029795591,
-0.0138088707,
-0.0086083878,
-0.0182855818,
-0.0464776866,
0.0380730741,
0.0008888786,
0.012512547,
-0.0514315553,
0.0141486656,
-0.0894913077,
-0.0332315266,
0.0152171943,
-0.0254889727,
-0.0518780909,
-0.0217924025,
0.0039145015,
-0.032973215,
0.0345541053,
0.0164240655,
0.0493392237,
0.0387110151,
-0.0107974177,
-0.0104767671,
0.0158571731,
0.0120493798,
0.0045368806,
0.0618891269,
0.0003869532,
-0.0062083849,
0.0026571015,
-0.0137243206,
-0.0258205961,
0.0166453999,
-0.056521412,
0.0679942742,
-0.0163531378,
0.0163570996,
-0.0188723523,
-0.0098120905,
-0.034871988,
0.0536216535,
0.0105297975,
0.0177514162,
0.0558973141,
-0.0346999951,
0.0182189718,
-0.0297750384,
0.0300133303,
0.0323075764,
-0.018577531,
-0.0039861929,
0.0103403358,
-0.0388703719,
-0.0344712846,
0.0036278947,
-0.0084425136,
-0.015624105,
-0.0165406838,
0.0135642989,
0.0100857336,
0.0210282542,
-0.0153947035,
-0.0237210933,
-0.0090251658,
-0.0028032821,
0.0378530547,
0.0288771372,
0.0430940166,
0.0287942849,
-0.0467177927,
-0.0517495312,
-0.0099148275,
-0.0078978026,
0.0652872026,
0.0183162838,
0.0052099312,
-0.0712484121,
-0.022925321,
-0.0413710326,
-0.0008971737,
-0.030132154,
-0.0030163387,
0.0398487002,
-0.0616995394,
-0.0131916078,
0.016758075,
-0.0101426523,
0.0916853324,
0.0780297294,
-0.0240987279,
-0.078612648,
-0.0057946495,
-0.0095524574,
-0.0480307899,
-0.0104842139,
-0.0559218489,
-0.0000966713,
0.0711500347,
-0.0181228016,
0.013241698,
-0.0209236126,
0.0279575381,
0.0253180452,
-0.0009157402,
-0.0543948375,
-0.0664754286,
-0.0298842229,
0.0759018809,
-0.0096591841,
-0.0774755329,
0.0602645688,
-0.0700571984,
0.0171852726,
0.0025579175,
-0.0434166305,
-0.0348871462,
0.0912788659,
-0.0410329998,
0.0157132391,
0.0122514665,
-0.0251925867,
0.0012520618,
-0.0361898504,
0.0487095676,
-0.0500112511,
0.0334301181,
-0.0642025992,
-0.0014751964,
0.0166012943,
0.0159552954,
-0.0181108788,
-0.0377578884,
-0.0413552411,
-0.0157042593,
0.0179383419,
-0.0255009104,
-0.0370217897,
-0.0050811605,
0.0819001868,
-0.001248361,
-0.0150533626,
0.0045965291,
-0.0029737742,
-0.0057093818,
0.0256230589,
0.0623178072,
0.0188723039,
-0.0492985845,
0.0266704317,
0.0354943313,
0.0143968891,
-0.0301565528,
-0.018659275,
-0.0367784128,
0.0139239952,
-0.0231767334,
-0.0235123485,
0.018504126,
0.0380912945,
-0.0786519051,
-0.0068957401,
0.094978407,
0.0326058269,
-0.0515019856,
0.0138662923,
-0.054493688,
0.0258926395,
0.0325854756,
0.0454785973,
-0.0676504523,
-0.0060823811,
0.0066856602,
0.0439889356,
0.0338180996,
0.0028421304,
-0.0197664276,
-0.1082715914,
0.0527802408,
-0.0038262403,
-0.0305833463,
-0.0234191045,
-0.0589056909,
-0.0132531635,
0.0129549103,
0.00089427,
0.0472588167,
-0.0070547764,
0.0289063845,
0.0148610156,
0.001700187,
-0.001391542,
0.0014398284,
-0.006962073,
0.0181194916,
0.032908313,
0.0235244688,
0.0122166472,
-0.0325531587,
0.0507432446,
0.0048296261,
0.052196499,
-0.0424978323,
0.0692156777,
0.0363344811,
-0.008891088,
-0.0481303446,
-0.0140595511,
-0.0017018954,
-0.0352314189,
0.0153155904,
0.1010298058,
-0.0281283427,
0.0186419524,
-0.018808363,
-0.0208817367,
0.0020804808,
0.0824347958,
0.0736355782,
0.0016087982,
-0.0274269003,
-0.0639298037,
-0.0359380804,
-0.0129873762,
-0.0532834083,
-0.0108055351,
0.0246094968,
-0.016181726,
-0.0207237415,
-0.0089479014,
0.0203857571,
0.0439672247,
0.0065334016,
0.0070926985,
-0.0377373509,
0.008650207,
-0.0337335281,
0.0390277915,
-0.0132759763,
0.0105428854,
-0.0141616929,
0.0090624448,
0.0063752383,
-0.0464164168,
0.0146010676,
0.0016984037,
-0.0009850195,
-0.0597942919,
-0.0295466073,
0.0250629373,
0.0371655338,
0.0586005598,
0.0043726251,
-0.0791522935,
0.0174666923,
0.0245551709,
-0.0336835906,
0.0055333925,
-0.0078015816,
0.0043998761,
-0.0130999405,
0.0305035971,
-0.0692172199,
-0.038493365,
-0.0279256701,
0.0399146229,
-0.0565326326,
-0.038886711,
0.0416238308,
0.0286976714,
0.0442210026,
-0.0079436908,
-0.0458039381,
-0.0167620257,
0.0379588343,
-0.0487738475,
-0.0156226968,
-0.0166250933,
0.0430288762,
-0.0122545492,
-0.0630330518,
0.0399078503,
-0.0145143,
-0.0141375978,
0.0290086493,
-0.061465323,
0.0425604917,
0.0117622586,
-0.0125534739,
0.018497508,
0.0244035348,
-0.0028859968,
0.0187519938,
-0.0248778071,
0.0609092005,
-0.0025716436,
0.0422736742,
0.0090038348,
0.004783161,
-0.0125822518,
-0.0118207829,
-0.0819998682,
-0.1075255275,
0.0222935546,
0.0041630128,
0.0394366235,
-0.0136513337,
0.0670599937,
0.0096642617,
-0.0286106579,
-0.0011891542,
0.0399397798,
0.0286281742,
-0.0425326787,
0.0247739609,
0.0411021411,
-0.0298199933,
-0.0101218019,
0.0516357534,
-0.0123395296,
0.0469306633,
0.0076796585,
-0.0224570949,
-0.0049507669,
-0.0382357016,
-0.0147380996,
0.0162154138,
0.0032956642,
-0.0242963005,
-0.056065958,
-0.0737612173,
-0.0211644582,
0.0215068571,
-0.0495235771,
-0.0367560834,
0.0046034772,
0.0910668075,
0.0445558019,
-0.0415164419,
-0.0276120976,
0.0871966705,
-0.0822554976,
-0.0048084641,
-0.0062952186,
-6.457648011e-33,
-0.0431582704,
-0.0766975284,
0.0342913717,
-0.0298934225,
0.00010436,
0.0000138585,
-0.0766257048,
0.0160774738,
-0.0383436531,
0.0157493092,
-0.0077943671,
0.0306285247,
-0.0008591308,
-0.0111911353,
-0.0114080673,
-0.0437808149,
0.0361168198,
0.0311564747,
-0.0164917465,
0.0259975586,
0.0679559559,
0.0169263184,
0.0420461893,
-0.0924449563,
0.0700518861,
-0.0072494475,
-0.0171337649,
0.0585665442,
-0.018276779,
0.0562403128,
-0.0072013475,
0.0468410403,
0.0030450576,
-0.0226811841,
-0.0011811407,
0.0121433437,
-0.0255274046,
-0.0081693223,
0.0573790818,
-0.0014017916,
-0.0291627012,
-0.0583428182,
0.0379880816,
0.0227270368,
0.0085721184,
0.0064799841,
0.0326117054,
-0.0192193985,
-0.0334403887,
0.0349810719,
-0.0178397764,
0.0203671362,
-0.0408529155,
-0.0334200449,
0.018599594,
0.0288140643,
0.0276519135,
0.0183761287,
-0.0100363046,
0.0201913845,
0.0399454944,
0.0453159437,
0.0692639872,
0.021138981,
0.0047061825,
0.0434930362,
-0.0013616697,
-0.0133648356,
-0.0704072863,
0.0133527061,
-0.0122387363,
0.0705555528,
0.0797141641,
0.0336510912,
0.0056002359,
0.0253373589,
-0.0386819281,
0.0395853929,
0.011283759,
0.0431346744,
0.023713911,
0.0218698606,
-0.0103585375,
-0.0154114403,
-0.0413933136,
-0.0158452354,
-0.03919724,
-0.0360381417,
0.022332089,
-0.0301168039,
-0.028967347,
-0.0383191891,
-0.0030356294,
-0.0297869425,
-0.0226994827,
0.0639556497,
-0.0034239499,
-0.0039619277,
0.0043988395,
-0.0187465586,
0.003846409,
0.0331969149,
-0.0176767204,
0.0003481609,
0.0239194594,
0.0483566821,
-0.0290957764,
0.0198368914,
-0.0209170189,
-0.0031672455,
-0.0652479231,
-0.0200211089,
-0.0338906497,
-0.028684929,
0.0263783131,
0.0168073457,
-0.0179117136,
0.0403097048,
0.0103051485,
0.0099104932,
0.0004097172,
0.0019327513,
-0.0278192051,
0.0042047179,
-0.0116449967,
-0.0129593508,
-0.014887955,
0.0474586003,
0.0573435836,
-0.0614407249,
-0.0151417619,
0.0201687366,
2.722e-7,
0.0528022908,
0.0246545188,
0.0481049754,
0.0240864195,
0.007726097,
0.0026631777,
-0.0236137528,
-0.055243481,
0.0331885777,
-0.0522671305,
-0.0150765078,
0.0518280715,
0.0565938763,
0.0404093601,
-0.0393193327,
-0.0350993313,
-0.0630043447,
-0.0410991646,
-0.0485176146,
0.0131307347,
0.04721931,
0.0366833657,
-0.0003102403,
0.0083386628,
-0.0264344141,
-0.0690312237,
0.0236125849,
-0.0498885289,
0.0203539729,
0.0083144084,
0.0370460488,
-0.0038295574,
0.0226598959,
-0.0666743666,
-0.027938826,
-0.0061448859,
-0.0491521172,
0.0364394523,
0.0021474441,
-0.0251336936,
-0.0427087136,
-0.0494656488,
0.0174946412,
-0.0522709973,
0.0490505919,
0.044546403,
0.0001850551,
-0.0206026901,
0.0029463649,
-0.0661258474,
-0.0180560276,
-0.0218835492,
0.0041142032,
0.0235847514,
-0.0219604336,
-0.0187828317,
-0.0038204866,
-0.0621380471,
-0.0732034668,
0.0076318849,
-0.0460135378,
0.0095222751,
-0.0390438288,
-0.0006267328,
0.0128520643,
-0.0180699397,
0.0069923303,
2.52233583e-34,
0.0195511114,
0.0140357409,
0.0117163202,
0.0651766509,
0.0586930104,
0.0317057185,
0.0013377245,
0.0320294127,
0.0433929898,
-0.0931023657,
-0.0201499294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07052v1
|
Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer for Long Document Classification
| 2024-05-11T16:48:06 | 2024-05-11T16:48:06 |
Guangzeng Han, Jack Tsao, Xiaolei Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lengthy documents pose a unique challenge to neural language models due to
substantial memory consumption. While existing state-of-the-art (SOTA) models
segment long texts into equal-length snippets (e.g., 128 tokens per snippet) or
deploy sparse attention networks, these methods have new challenges of context
fragmentation and generalizability due to sentence boundaries and varying text
lengths. For example, our empirical analysis has shown that SOTA models
consistently overfit one set of lengthy documents (e.g., 2000 tokens) while
performing worse on texts with other lengths (e.g., 1000 or 4000). In this
study, we propose a Length-Aware Multi-Kernel Transformer (LAMKIT) to address
the new challenges for the long document classification. LAMKIT encodes lengthy
documents by diverse transformer-based kernels for bridging context boundaries
and vectorizes text length by the kernels to promote model robustness over
varying document lengths. Experiments on five standard benchmarks from health
and law domains show LAMKIT outperforms SOTA models up to an absolute 10.9%
improvement. We conduct extensive ablation analyses to examine model robustness
and effectiveness over varying document lengths.
|
[
0.0329317041,
0.0410529152,
0.0182793867,
0.03056903,
-0.0266402196,
-0.0319581069,
0.0244407225,
0.0221007895,
-0.0276471712,
-0.0565293692,
-0.0193344168,
-0.0167033356,
0.0264327563,
0.0133691877,
0.0259788949,
-0.0411605835,
0.007585498,
-0.0107763615,
-0.001496467,
0.0308468007,
0.0092749652,
0.0072784596,
0.0353172161,
0.031377703,
-0.0456099845,
-0.0057987724,
-0.0080275349,
0.0036533452,
0.0088998079,
-0.0218625087,
0.0601995736,
0.0313731059,
0.005429571,
0.0366874933,
0.0000017796,
-0.0273619127,
-0.0185996816,
0.0250796787,
-0.005678758,
0.030423753,
0.0751246661,
-0.0886433721,
0.0142924646,
-0.0024701618,
0.0122289192,
0.0129873846,
0.0283596795,
0.1021896601,
0.0219159573,
0.0877942145,
-0.0263543539,
-0.0549323708,
0.0575591065,
-0.0569772944,
0.0269309599,
-0.0362010226,
0.0324446745,
-0.0351509675,
0.0306758881,
0.0134641714,
-0.05445344,
0.051695507,
0.0518307239,
-0.0037519904,
0.0216295663,
0.0280614831,
-0.0676858798,
-0.0048612757,
0.0228052717,
0.0763314888,
-0.0485672913,
-0.0009152844,
0.0238570161,
-0.0053674192,
0.0361413099,
-0.032372795,
-0.0193855278,
-0.005666852,
0.0050791628,
0.0092630107,
-0.0086252159,
0.0486637987,
0.0303963106,
-0.0003066273,
-0.056387879,
-0.000975378,
-0.0225565992,
-0.0454465933,
-0.0011843517,
-0.0185208563,
-0.0304252896,
0.0120475907,
0.0104583371,
0.0287659205,
0.036253918,
0.0135475108,
-0.0638979822,
-0.0503331274,
0.0526810214,
-0.0751439929,
-0.0290782042,
0.0031923573,
-0.0351193286,
0.0214884132,
-0.037498951,
-0.0107387062,
-0.0306795593,
0.0321392268,
-0.0305332709,
-0.0135351848,
-0.0485863313,
0.0111741107,
-0.0354666114,
0.010092088,
-0.0119139105,
-0.024168184,
-0.0507210828,
0.0280997641,
0.0177768245,
-0.00488543,
-0.0071574622,
0.0127592757,
0.0067617157,
-0.0009663641,
0.0109490789,
0.0416726358,
-0.0057893717,
0.0015074345,
-0.0052304044,
-0.0068645836,
-0.0252766199,
0.0631321296,
0.0039458284,
-0.048273284,
0.0183689483,
0.0222555902,
-0.0175474603,
-0.0780284777,
-0.0039668707,
-0.0079006497,
-0.0886746198,
-0.0521865524,
-0.0106441667,
-0.0876245052,
0.0233427472,
0.0010826571,
-0.0043671741,
-0.0424277559,
0.0072051217,
0.0137693696,
-0.0545103289,
0.0480432175,
0.0685262978,
-0.0179830436,
0.0599810407,
0.0305625554,
0.0451665856,
0.0458362363,
0.0224991068,
0.0080417022,
0.0304056145,
-0.0120851072,
0.0006347339,
0.0183911752,
0.0367092974,
-0.0282754712,
0.0009963185,
0.0049048788,
0.004112374,
0.0340248719,
0.020890601,
0.06895376,
0.0009040338,
-0.0750683174,
0.0337782204,
0.0746546686,
0.0039022288,
0.0245674085,
0.0047486397,
0.0258672498,
-0.0260473527,
0.0024202876,
-0.0263053793,
-0.0023584773,
0.0241112188,
0.0099729188,
0.0261092596,
0.0155572314,
-0.0319982357,
-0.0423210636,
-0.0258874334,
-0.0335146822,
0.0105808396,
-0.003419301,
0.081231758,
-0.0085137663,
-0.0303935353,
0.101607658,
-0.0134389363,
-0.0411819667,
-0.0114612216,
-0.0204950497,
-0.0141578764,
0.0307925418,
0.0269093513,
-0.0585603192,
-0.0108674048,
-0.0464092195,
0.028516449,
0.0111634992,
0.0392212309,
0.0093330517,
0.017598493,
-0.0671842545,
0.0173389986,
-0.0164270382,
0.0186598748,
-0.0401402079,
0.0301383883,
0.0628888533,
0.0681581274,
-0.0259541478,
-0.0033921069,
0.026140932,
0.0093112811,
-0.0154262418,
-0.0153101487,
0.0036792017,
0.0195614025,
-0.0065166894,
-0.0060551264,
0.0138244815,
0.0252012163,
-0.0582120642,
-0.0107797086,
-0.0330453143,
-0.0510811321,
-0.0217366815,
0.0087857321,
-0.0120073911,
-0.0093695652,
0.0164659228,
-0.0526286662,
-0.0263864007,
-0.0018470725,
-0.0428866111,
0.0021234772,
-0.0030562601,
0.0069751209,
0.0087797781,
0.062911205,
-0.0347113125,
0.005840634,
-0.0045472281,
0.0110285012,
-0.0415500887,
-0.0287946053,
0.0301869325,
-0.0325398222,
-0.0526276454,
0.0171139184,
-0.0350721218,
0.0279171765,
0.0078375097,
-0.0137687288,
-0.0108134728,
-0.0585907772,
-0.0920273587,
-0.0117571373,
-0.0263066236,
0.0076243188,
-0.0340261869,
0.0166251175,
0.0138982665,
-0.0173232183,
-0.0379779264,
-0.0187891982,
0.0085024871,
-0.0044284938,
0.0124066062,
-0.0116050085,
-0.0033125277,
-0.0279071871,
-0.0606199168,
-0.0024791402,
0.0821303129,
-0.0325772427,
-0.050798893,
-0.0305041336,
0.0030568314,
0.0126901576,
0.0015543937,
-0.0286596231,
-0.0242051873,
-0.027755091,
-0.0101019302,
0.0597860403,
0.0766398013,
0.051582519,
0.0435750186,
0.0208411682,
0.0359889716,
-0.0073386165,
0.0263231248,
-0.0209594108,
0.0109025296,
-0.0459032916,
-0.0120211747,
0.0111500192,
0.0730685294,
-0.0134056928,
-0.0065826364,
-0.0464418791,
-0.0458108298,
-0.0059553827,
0.0190476682,
-0.0241184346,
0.0183583107,
-0.0103613771,
-0.010704441,
-0.0055165668,
-0.0392812863,
0.0633811057,
-0.0168297514,
0.0042728605,
-0.0241608508,
-0.0250426531,
-0.0576464087,
0.0653988346,
0.0178429987,
-0.0113086011,
0.0211866237,
0.0122663165,
-0.0269715711,
-0.0138063645,
-0.0491654314,
-0.028284749,
0.0957366452,
0.0137169026,
0.0210327022,
-0.0447236821,
-0.030645689,
-0.0148899676,
-0.066793777,
0.0025980738,
0.0105425585,
-0.0063217939,
-0.0010041128,
-0.0685786158,
0.0327240191,
0.017527109,
0.0922518969,
-0.0045044734,
0.0143042067,
0.0128397858,
0.0622053854,
0.0364288278,
-0.0063661775,
-0.0137404585,
-0.0345233716,
0.0249385368,
0.0517916046,
0.0023340911,
0.0132858735,
-0.0068459879,
-0.0491700582,
-0.0014015922,
-0.0211027022,
-0.0402291715,
-0.0027339621,
0.0396642573,
-0.0873725116,
-0.0064718546,
0.0985610113,
0.0144072073,
-0.0486529656,
0.0191506818,
0.0135028828,
0.0436346829,
-0.0063937828,
0.0192605443,
-0.0531804748,
-0.0281260572,
-0.0258836001,
0.0181641486,
0.0205602609,
0.0004353773,
0.0119504267,
-0.0304391868,
0.0134265721,
0.018651152,
-0.0561383292,
-0.0189425293,
-0.0327127278,
-0.0248061791,
0.0002541183,
-0.0175898895,
-0.0324257277,
-0.0071922946,
-0.0364616998,
0.0141852628,
-0.0473754816,
-0.0383798741,
0.0073350552,
0.0062046405,
0.0276259407,
-0.0033414187,
0.0183247216,
-0.0248151664,
-0.0524630994,
0.0400211029,
-0.0467915945,
-0.0095323212,
0.0279496536,
0.0693819076,
-0.0255526975,
0.0030663465,
0.0219898522,
0.0254567768,
-0.041466061,
-0.0195876844,
-0.0055114911,
0.0850103572,
-0.0060793338,
-0.0315680392,
-0.0468935929,
-0.0256631784,
-0.0193705726,
0.0771590024,
0.0240867641,
-0.0456098616,
-0.0669914186,
0.0091342805,
-0.0352273956,
-0.0419564508,
0.0031788552,
0.0150441919,
-0.0317811519,
-0.0233993456,
-0.0358577371,
-0.0406031944,
-0.002430639,
-0.0019398753,
-0.0349647291,
-0.0004455864,
-0.0034648797,
0.0086986357,
-0.0868066251,
0.0602171235,
0.0073940395,
0.0129648438,
-0.0670870394,
0.0280775316,
0.0399261266,
0.0018613217,
-0.0111627728,
0.0309656188,
-0.0907996893,
-0.0463983752,
0.0012126019,
0.0033671169,
0.0076560751,
0.0311515741,
-0.0006269698,
-0.0224960577,
0.1024197564,
0.0417630263,
-0.0274157692,
0.0167434365,
0.0402127728,
-0.0212963484,
-0.0154450545,
0.0363145769,
-0.0264083538,
0.0472519174,
0.0067214817,
-0.0191057138,
-0.0014067976,
-0.0308607332,
-0.074696742,
-0.027226394,
-0.0123208221,
0.0074998979,
0.0256346185,
-0.0020319344,
0.0375396721,
0.0237910077,
0.0128931915,
-0.0117616849,
0.0053692353,
0.0469723195,
0.0028500098,
-0.0152069898,
0.0500398055,
0.0093135685,
0.0098248497,
-0.0216195453,
0.0307589378,
0.0000367763,
-0.0131881293,
0.0364931971,
0.0091472715,
-0.0237460136,
-0.0348924287,
-0.0106579261,
0.0093485545,
-0.0233866218,
0.0441017151,
-0.0025887252,
0.0335864574,
-0.0384252109,
0.0376809314,
-0.0749470294,
0.027666403,
-0.0294899829,
-0.0035409927,
0.0085997852,
-0.0372941047,
0.0358816683,
-0.0050204666,
-0.0182699561,
-0.0318436809,
0.0509264469,
0.0000929705,
0.0133725246,
0.0110049555,
0.0268215016,
-0.017190814,
0.0066341343,
0.0739634261,
0.0461324751,
0.0136165544,
0.0317501538,
-0.0192878377,
-0.0429883935,
-0.0154318167,
0.0007205985,
0.0233666878,
-0.0160036162,
-0.0043680426,
-0.0151897371,
-0.0496794246,
0.0769222528,
-0.0500727035,
-0.0017233534,
0.0034306454,
0.016997939,
0.0485364534,
0.0257805604,
-0.0072232783,
-0.0222980306,
0.0111193415,
0.0128289359,
-0.0486595668,
0.0010833171,
-5.677129681e-33,
0.0360309258,
-0.0163365826,
-0.0110648712,
0.0258784294,
-0.0405051596,
0.0348913446,
-0.0156166097,
-0.0161061063,
-0.0064793825,
-0.000553596,
-0.0099903867,
0.0214537084,
-0.0012921644,
0.0784789771,
0.007470353,
-0.016498737,
0.0677097663,
0.0043298281,
-0.0186814182,
0.0381444916,
0.0297052134,
0.0310504287,
0.0341451727,
-0.0284358803,
0.0341073051,
0.0217990708,
0.0363831073,
-0.0376503058,
0.0130793368,
0.0780992359,
-0.0317668058,
0.0683111325,
0.0601934195,
-0.0292957798,
-0.0024848727,
0.0737086236,
-0.1042641848,
0.0251095295,
-0.0307433344,
-0.0019612226,
-0.0012859607,
-0.0534694307,
0.0795863047,
-0.0122406613,
0.0234366432,
-0.0521103926,
0.0647692382,
-0.0206225384,
-0.0406747945,
-0.0411371328,
-0.0475921631,
0.0520594679,
-0.0140323201,
-0.0070720203,
0.0354119688,
0.0282428898,
-0.0141180614,
0.0369881317,
-0.0561075658,
-0.0454265103,
-0.0416171327,
0.030839324,
0.0229714345,
0.0138870152,
-0.0322559364,
0.0190241188,
-0.0317163952,
0.0326364003,
-0.0337613747,
-0.0439657755,
0.0302535892,
0.0314724967,
0.0587073527,
0.0267354902,
0.0570535623,
-0.0634111091,
-0.0725049451,
0.0006628317,
-0.030341059,
0.0130580403,
0.0607987829,
0.0062697362,
-0.0205667745,
-0.0199428126,
-0.0029632039,
0.0020844769,
0.0007977332,
-0.000962853,
0.0071070353,
0.041011624,
0.0237129852,
0.0155201126,
0.0444538407,
-0.0297431909,
0.033453092,
0.029037727,
0.0122941742,
0.0367682166,
0.0064075249,
-0.0166863743,
-0.0685641319,
0.0007406463,
0.0239830483,
0.003656998,
0.0086435694,
-0.032614544,
0.1093673036,
0.001309301,
-0.0683972165,
-0.0344392024,
-0.0066165938,
0.0168117788,
-0.0098581109,
0.0769928917,
0.0159092043,
0.0273484811,
-0.0078808963,
0.063766107,
0.0078044613,
-0.0061228746,
-0.0011551991,
-0.0205682348,
0.0177525729,
0.0123617696,
-0.0310508963,
0.0004673195,
-0.012375419,
0.0319898725,
0.0192587487,
-0.0793798044,
0.0211574212,
0.0069579105,
2.501e-7,
0.0643973425,
0.0208592247,
0.0248835068,
-0.0791400671,
0.0420536771,
0.0058954624,
0.0514028817,
0.0641256794,
-0.0751176551,
0.0008019751,
-0.0022586242,
0.0079497751,
0.0706026554,
-0.0005740083,
-0.0902432278,
-0.0253801979,
-0.080895856,
0.0083156181,
-0.0380552039,
0.0081836358,
0.0718033984,
0.1076774895,
0.0001055091,
-0.0223046076,
0.008605089,
-0.0318832025,
0.0588848032,
-0.012573678,
0.0183066763,
0.0081410436,
0.0327816792,
-0.0033704329,
0.0097936485,
-0.0126489094,
-0.0104705412,
0.032781031,
0.0024419681,
0.0955128595,
0.0053186608,
-0.0435721613,
0.0175175276,
0.008957224,
-0.0243311562,
-0.0555924736,
0.0617852733,
-0.0571735315,
-0.0298635717,
-0.029833097,
0.0271760244,
-0.0090754358,
0.0499202907,
0.0082691452,
0.0154738622,
0.0318230875,
0.0290025026,
-0.0525388494,
0.0149021884,
-0.1198003292,
-0.0354455337,
0.0315235443,
-0.046410121,
0.0005979709,
-0.0681895837,
-0.0297773127,
0.0443642475,
-0.0526508801,
-0.0178173892,
2.269133198e-34,
0.0425870642,
-0.0198167805,
-0.0372121148,
0.0017874397,
0.0068751681,
-0.0254294705,
-0.0010217364,
0.0151193524,
0.0114475656,
-0.0849036947,
-0.0123060578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07035v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07035v2
|
A Turkish Educational Crossword Puzzle Generator
| 2024-05-11T15:18:56 | 2024-05-15T12:23:39 |
Kamyar Zeinalipour, Yusuf Gökberk Keptiğ, Marco Maggini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Gori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces the first Turkish crossword puzzle generator designed
to leverage the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) for educational
purposes. In this work, we introduced two specially created datasets: one with
over 180,000 unique answer-clue pairs for generating relevant clues from the
given answer, and another with over 35,000 samples containing text, answer,
category, and clue data, aimed at producing clues for specific texts and
keywords within certain categories. Beyond entertainment, this generator
emerges as an interactive educational tool that enhances memory, vocabulary,
and problem-solving skills. It's a notable step in AI-enhanced education,
merging game-like engagement with learning for Turkish and setting new
standards for interactive, intelligent learning tools in Turkish.
|
[
0.0232404564,
-0.0129111316,
-0.0521737635,
0.0232593417,
-0.0481316,
0.013634827,
0.0391661972,
-0.0039205817,
0.0128015438,
0.0137760621,
-0.0085525038,
0.0158981644,
-0.0053469762,
0.0076573901,
0.0053908215,
-0.0513014868,
0.0320768617,
-0.0653086156,
0.0044953069,
-0.0076619918,
-0.0399337076,
0.0325243883,
-0.0568440259,
0.0247601662,
-0.019651169,
-0.0094186999,
-0.0434502587,
-0.0447133072,
-0.0239274427,
-0.0522421226,
-0.0025273054,
0.0156155042,
-0.0060153888,
0.0440045483,
0.0000019257,
-0.0384667926,
-0.0162079763,
-0.0427322611,
-0.0049819909,
-0.0153969359,
0.0197550226,
0.0280436575,
-0.0295353755,
-0.0108409123,
-0.0553207733,
-0.0079596303,
0.0549360253,
0.0108229183,
0.0547142774,
0.0403897017,
0.0132811703,
-0.0297433268,
0.0548171513,
0.0166614428,
0.100396581,
-0.0633682534,
-0.006724095,
0.0119559309,
0.0228484832,
0.0378538966,
-0.01464961,
0.0507766642,
-0.0109746829,
-0.0120496564,
-0.0401798636,
0.0119372616,
0.0127563374,
-0.0353048593,
0.0083742244,
0.0402768403,
0.0036377967,
-0.0169856735,
0.0213015694,
0.0196050033,
0.0158909652,
0.0856948793,
-0.0834390745,
0.0423970483,
-0.0257745106,
-0.0127528086,
0.082819134,
0.0036076943,
-0.0086108083,
0.0398282632,
0.0031968264,
0.0614659078,
0.0379662737,
-0.0305118095,
-0.043091502,
0.0006780315,
0.0165326931,
-0.0474765822,
0.0083379075,
0.0627828836,
-0.0565528348,
0.0394072533,
-0.047289677,
-0.0522721633,
0.0151702035,
-0.0355598666,
0.05283916,
0.0008107269,
0.0265673138,
0.0511010662,
-0.0002607972,
0.0309281815,
0.0306283701,
-0.0176009685,
-0.0451132953,
-0.0021133434,
-0.0170259811,
-0.0192451142,
-0.0425333902,
0.0496096015,
-0.0390967727,
0.0053157299,
-0.043464452,
0.0175659619,
0.0199134629,
0.056304317,
0.0280863419,
-0.002629699,
-0.0248039085,
-0.0151318843,
-0.0269162636,
-0.0157525577,
-0.0531847253,
-0.0129792113,
-0.0141348811,
-0.0219087601,
0.0326612256,
-0.0245395619,
0.0240972284,
-0.0270576533,
0.0540577099,
0.0359578766,
-0.0189619549,
-0.0375686623,
-0.0209624302,
-0.0124719171,
-0.0081919208,
-0.0526540093,
0.0096565252,
-0.0835236162,
0.0424868241,
-0.0167803206,
0.008121687,
-0.025560379,
0.0266307779,
0.062651366,
0.0150193954,
0.0857117698,
-0.0042946786,
0.0239659753,
0.0614248849,
-0.0105180796,
0.0643144548,
0.0745572448,
0.05792154,
0.0154120512,
0.0671925694,
-0.0373290703,
0.0157334097,
0.0418930426,
0.0167427678,
-0.0307718925,
0.0096824039,
-0.0162538774,
0.0385765769,
0.054947909,
-0.0713366717,
0.0239646491,
0.0249359347,
0.0447365791,
0.0527565479,
0.0763283074,
0.0096093304,
0.0552625172,
0.0243878495,
-0.0105721541,
0.015725974,
0.0061954302,
0.0101375896,
0.0348886773,
-0.0023804163,
0.0209065694,
-0.0053576496,
0.0568562113,
-0.0009797667,
-0.0656236112,
-0.0003211491,
0.0007403931,
0.0383810438,
0.0170138832,
0.1142828614,
-0.024446195,
-0.0299789272,
0.012687942,
0.0322385281,
-0.0617094859,
0.0328803211,
-0.0681123957,
0.0709594786,
0.0743904486,
0.0741858333,
-0.0552437566,
-0.0253541321,
0.0151548581,
0.0510405675,
0.0483378656,
0.0142170032,
-0.035347987,
-0.036160972,
-0.0433377102,
-0.006187751,
0.0063707293,
0.0062941927,
0.002564454,
0.0493224598,
0.051816795,
-0.0062583089,
-0.0179154798,
0.0246322975,
0.0222568866,
-0.067550391,
-0.0501535721,
-0.0258586798,
0.0183467399,
-0.0277424306,
0.0624910332,
0.0046725557,
0.0073886197,
0.0587436855,
-0.0208404176,
0.0254259147,
-0.0384760164,
-0.0331604779,
0.0332666747,
0.0706439912,
-0.0590413809,
0.0160451792,
0.0369389281,
0.0257827751,
-0.0266072135,
0.0563019216,
-0.0132479332,
0.0659569725,
-0.0055841589,
0.0425257161,
0.0009048497,
-0.0133890118,
-0.0394286215,
0.0539062209,
0.0191544052,
0.0338640921,
-0.0475133322,
-0.0263810921,
0.0036260914,
-0.0299236309,
0.0147692394,
0.0665249303,
-0.0246744249,
0.0010367385,
0.0017819011,
0.0089096874,
-0.0576049723,
-0.0345483012,
-0.0709474832,
0.0086755892,
0.0199903492,
0.0100436267,
-0.0025768182,
0.0248008147,
-0.0370759442,
0.0214484818,
-0.0211367421,
-0.0186716169,
0.0598888062,
-0.0169086996,
-0.0014287001,
-0.0020666865,
-0.0004666459,
-0.0075628581,
-0.0288485084,
-0.008550941,
0.0184111781,
0.0268801283,
-0.0258775558,
-0.0205303505,
0.0479791276,
-0.0119942687,
0.0042758635,
-0.0020420526,
-0.0317878425,
0.0321691856,
-0.0280520506,
0.0434860215,
0.0417730175,
0.0133742988,
-0.0001659484,
0.044454217,
-0.1137967035,
-0.0534072444,
0.0156999324,
-0.0122251008,
-0.0439591408,
-0.0146733904,
-0.0569946803,
-0.0174348764,
0.027792871,
0.0044988561,
-0.0044684429,
-0.0478365235,
0.0254107807,
-0.0171304885,
-0.0158184227,
-0.0641758963,
-0.0084457621,
-0.0146165723,
0.0235593971,
-0.0048730732,
0.0123369712,
0.0330677219,
-0.0319848433,
0.0267012957,
-0.0561541729,
0.0085941758,
-0.0314422771,
0.0404560044,
-0.0555968657,
0.0037578344,
-0.0017668958,
0.0113996752,
-0.0524106361,
-0.0029964456,
0.0520105623,
-0.0728560984,
0.0157190971,
-0.0603296906,
-0.0257938225,
-0.0017184115,
0.0088352701,
-0.0330108553,
0.0135414973,
-0.0143320672,
-0.0550499335,
0.0721647665,
-0.0001942513,
-0.0311306827,
-0.0068838201,
0.0454829894,
-0.043181736,
-0.0121151926,
-0.0009934774,
0.0120671177,
0.0393396467,
0.0700008497,
0.0013378307,
-0.0274106711,
-0.0100649614,
0.0304073226,
0.0561011955,
0.0117829172,
-0.036964763,
0.017543219,
0.0284177922,
0.0494042672,
-0.0433501638,
-0.0102939531,
-0.0090522002,
-0.0118654883,
-0.045454625,
-0.0306085721,
0.0788360164,
0.0450463668,
-0.0209055692,
-0.0231207274,
-0.0082087386,
-0.0149410022,
-0.0025205498,
0.0419308692,
-0.0429224372,
0.0125586055,
0.0171883274,
-0.0028990617,
-0.0102090305,
-0.0214975458,
0.0111490358,
-0.1295107305,
0.0009396932,
0.0243595466,
-0.0481508151,
-0.0448735878,
-0.055485066,
-0.0339415185,
0.0011207953,
-0.0634850934,
-0.0097177876,
-0.0194362998,
0.0435396135,
0.0108439373,
0.0098011754,
-0.0311437938,
-0.0196808614,
-0.0293114912,
0.0523320399,
0.0532800294,
0.0389039367,
-0.0305034369,
-0.0635265857,
0.0032837726,
0.0072686747,
-0.0302953217,
-0.0311042164,
0.0120254932,
-0.0206336789,
-0.0288141482,
-0.0492516905,
-0.0064605917,
-0.023754105,
-0.0255993344,
0.059154667,
0.0656922162,
0.0204835124,
0.0360563211,
-0.0082385084,
-0.0062346538,
0.0318158083,
0.0306171924,
-0.025440624,
-0.0340031348,
0.0265390482,
-0.0206454042,
-0.0170496721,
-0.0558276437,
-0.0474476926,
0.0110394452,
-0.0142779145,
0.0177092198,
-0.0559173115,
-0.0300794467,
0.0413705111,
0.0285501555,
-0.0083982283,
0.0433892235,
-0.058140859,
0.0428151265,
-0.0365072489,
-0.0378802828,
-0.0209551528,
0.0104826745,
-0.0512974299,
-0.0685401112,
0.0042472878,
-0.0751693919,
0.0151548851,
0.0481291674,
-0.061414741,
-0.0092635304,
0.0518632755,
0.0415691435,
0.0151885264,
0.0034472721,
0.063673906,
-0.0036806213,
0.0490946993,
-0.0051638358,
-0.0523330197,
0.0093773725,
-0.0613892116,
0.0082942192,
0.0159570184,
-0.014837252,
-0.0206092019,
-0.0168094616,
0.0370623544,
0.0324319936,
-0.0322551988,
-0.0136013608,
0.0189614575,
0.0257807095,
0.006865365,
-0.047598511,
-0.0128016965,
-0.0267759208,
0.0227504335,
-0.0403471552,
-0.0313393697,
0.0011965807,
-0.017606359,
0.0223766528,
-0.0462307259,
0.0252559353,
0.0388059281,
0.0145937968,
-0.0327258147,
-0.0687562078,
0.0386493579,
0.0034914284,
0.0205235723,
-0.0045151585,
0.0205485821,
0.0133043099,
0.0695574656,
-0.0221737549,
0.0509297624,
-0.0079581644,
0.0156622529,
-0.0189356115,
-0.044101432,
0.0127347093,
0.052941449,
-0.0078088981,
-0.0198094156,
-0.019872468,
0.0501349084,
0.0905735642,
-0.0014755561,
-0.0146070365,
-0.021565292,
-0.0038395792,
0.007909026,
-0.0159552544,
0.0266017672,
-0.0310534183,
0.0007040959,
0.0040075663,
0.0292890519,
-0.0291225221,
0.0598378293,
0.011451534,
0.0345280357,
0.0360547379,
-0.0240225755,
-0.0358702354,
-0.0027492221,
0.0255663954,
0.0464945287,
-0.0386556685,
-0.0116665643,
-0.0393617004,
-0.0580400117,
0.0126137864,
0.0719425604,
0.0114304405,
0.0079182945,
0.0384154692,
0.0685185641,
0.0081918333,
0.0228086691,
-0.0379177742,
0.0713500977,
-0.0514350608,
-0.0599337891,
-0.0197998323,
-5.434178508e-33,
-0.0456997044,
-0.035216555,
0.0545536242,
0.0198480785,
0.0029378613,
-0.0343555287,
-0.0029721442,
0.0439305156,
0.0117444973,
-0.0150015261,
-0.0459134504,
0.0015713895,
0.0059536514,
0.0125898374,
0.0143633727,
-0.027971128,
0.005496854,
-0.017152993,
-0.0042710062,
0.0097674523,
0.0467831828,
-0.0009591231,
0.0600571558,
-0.0566825382,
0.0033212821,
-0.0143588334,
-0.0086150188,
-0.0180282444,
-0.0257013366,
0.0613161102,
-0.0185809582,
0.042522423,
0.0023251327,
-0.015595424,
0.007191604,
0.0197559353,
-0.0568550155,
-0.0283681862,
0.007793596,
0.0240987521,
-0.0016787293,
-0.0706969127,
-0.0126232114,
-0.0212931093,
-0.0362924002,
0.0292561185,
0.0490169749,
-0.04654992,
-0.010215302,
0.0016553346,
-0.0375313498,
0.0049785804,
-0.0301593635,
-0.0429426357,
0.0409516431,
-0.0055479277,
0.0364396162,
-0.0453460515,
0.0025912006,
0.1122099757,
0.0487242118,
0.0233775266,
0.1002747789,
-0.0081782294,
-0.0114444168,
0.0335261114,
0.0260852017,
-0.0424323753,
-0.0200570021,
0.0129043665,
0.0365100503,
0.0156955477,
0.0604913421,
0.0781371072,
-0.0025918121,
-0.0421239287,
-0.0541770868,
0.0759908259,
0.0232399479,
0.0328993686,
0.0024812836,
-0.0142410509,
-0.0500954278,
-0.0112777008,
-0.0261664465,
0.0240857676,
-0.0218702573,
-0.0327864438,
0.0234891418,
-0.0235949364,
-0.0320867859,
-0.0461590476,
-0.0110875322,
-0.0006096624,
0.0067884638,
0.0087248096,
0.0667902827,
0.0025588092,
-0.0424774885,
-0.0420728736,
0.0060632224,
-0.0406209677,
-0.0057536946,
-0.0251935348,
0.0055848639,
0.0133601585,
-0.0524118841,
0.0204467867,
-0.0494774468,
0.0182076525,
-0.0231828112,
0.0114638489,
0.05737786,
-0.0373938903,
0.0435498692,
-0.0527954735,
-0.0131472973,
-0.0257756226,
0.0568675473,
-0.0349420346,
-0.0038771476,
-0.0379127041,
-0.0221274719,
-0.0233521368,
0.0045136395,
0.0297639724,
-0.0802563205,
-0.0006656031,
0.0084173884,
-0.0194453951,
0.0188941788,
-0.0128877535,
2.656e-7,
0.0052523827,
0.0642476827,
-0.0025253552,
0.0487160534,
0.0043026968,
-0.0067280759,
-0.0093771424,
-0.0268845949,
-0.0064176652,
0.024052158,
0.019536363,
0.0235421527,
0.0412159152,
0.0518240742,
-0.0831685364,
-0.0227569267,
0.0258667525,
0.0308680721,
-0.070813559,
0.0445615239,
0.0497979745,
0.0277179182,
0.0221356228,
-0.0138863968,
-0.0410962999,
-0.0158517491,
-0.0017877866,
-0.0496678203,
-0.0382287018,
0.0084296856,
-0.0599958226,
0.0184914097,
-0.0128208268,
-0.0010216307,
-0.0340274051,
0.0197852608,
0.0485213697,
0.0195865165,
0.0099366382,
0.0121469488,
0.0027356683,
-0.0202266183,
-0.0159993824,
-0.0659550279,
0.0897957161,
0.0393373743,
0.0169752669,
-0.0285440944,
-0.0128872283,
-0.0425626785,
-0.0112490254,
-0.0454660766,
-0.0332647897,
0.0077310516,
0.0068711075,
0.0193262603,
0.0122892428,
-0.0270768739,
-0.0086740889,
-0.0197328739,
-0.037684381,
-0.0411784314,
-0.0644671917,
-0.0166344214,
-0.0503883101,
0.0128192967,
-0.0036428254,
2.075172728e-34,
-0.0391882882,
0.0031966027,
0.0083739636,
-0.0074332361,
0.0142195104,
-0.0093238261,
0.0097841378,
0.0332973227,
0.0268701892,
-0.0758544803,
-0.0157348234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.08017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.08017v1
|
Translating Expert Intuition into Quantifiable Features: Encode Investigator Domain Knowledge via LLM for Enhanced Predictive Analytics
| 2024-05-11T13:23:43 | 2024-05-11T13:23:43 |
Phoebe Jing, Yijing Gao, Yuanhang Zhang, Xianlong Zeng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the realm of predictive analytics, the nuanced domain knowledge of
investigators often remains underutilized, confined largely to subjective
interpretations and ad hoc decision-making. This paper explores the potential
of Large Language Models (LLMs) to bridge this gap by systematically converting
investigator-derived insights into quantifiable, actionable features that
enhance model performance. We present a framework that leverages LLMs' natural
language understanding capabilities to encode these red flags into a structured
feature set that can be readily integrated into existing predictive models.
Through a series of case studies, we demonstrate how this approach not only
preserves the critical human expertise within the investigative process but
also scales the impact of this knowledge across various prediction tasks. The
results indicate significant improvements in risk assessment and
decision-making accuracy, highlighting the value of blending human experiential
knowledge with advanced machine learning techniques. This study paves the way
for more sophisticated, knowledge-driven analytics in fields where expert
insight is paramount.
|
[
0.0298326612,
0.070593074,
-0.0051180483,
0.0198313277,
-0.0297270995,
-0.0040443786,
-0.0163410623,
-0.0057939999,
0.0234514568,
-0.0163599905,
0.0437100567,
0.0056526312,
-0.0190011561,
0.107230477,
0.0135632716,
-0.0027057468,
0.0089875162,
-0.0378992669,
0.0513180085,
0.042296268,
-0.007852531,
0.0226386972,
0.0029480846,
0.0511703789,
-0.003785053,
0.0199119169,
0.0112331724,
-0.0291022118,
0.0127161341,
-0.0524689294,
0.0148460986,
0.0240594409,
0.0369686112,
0.0258406196,
0.0000020074,
-0.0734682828,
-0.05124446,
0.0226841681,
-0.021352658,
-0.0088192131,
0.0273872558,
-0.0442559347,
0.0404420123,
0.0326428451,
-0.0365513712,
0.0156082651,
0.0170804951,
0.0093808705,
0.0286906213,
0.0100719519,
-0.027506195,
-0.0092179514,
0.0207752734,
0.0100068329,
-0.004535845,
-0.0376731567,
0.0196768362,
0.0259941239,
-0.006407117,
0.0046155229,
0.011785496,
0.0352703445,
0.0200603381,
-0.0010956423,
0.0172395278,
0.0192941185,
0.0052043828,
-0.0119565511,
-0.0115531897,
0.0313355103,
-0.0067437729,
0.0104707275,
-0.004524691,
-0.0254096929,
0.0013461459,
0.0291972626,
-0.0196656343,
-0.003391441,
-0.0257984456,
0.0148807671,
-0.0079011386,
0.0631849095,
0.0245549772,
0.0292527117,
-0.0274621006,
0.0811259896,
-0.0434273258,
-0.0094129751,
0.0359172523,
0.0079092607,
0.0211674906,
0.0009196385,
-0.0067409868,
-0.0008181229,
-0.0316710062,
0.0248351507,
0.0470118299,
0.0156877879,
0.0695945024,
-0.0524175204,
0.026256578,
0.0025149924,
0.0006713785,
0.0389016978,
-0.0202420577,
-0.0117393816,
0.0054672551,
-0.0207051765,
0.0021419686,
-0.0165520404,
-0.0702569485,
-0.0481475517,
0.0341710672,
0.0026078115,
0.0080529079,
0.034563724,
-0.014835001,
0.0033724862,
-0.0148884533,
0.0138587086,
-0.0329420716,
0.0359900296,
-0.00649057,
-0.0065446696,
-0.0679719672,
0.0046328772,
-0.0237206444,
0.068738915,
-0.0207027681,
-0.0294629708,
0.0101584382,
0.0052928203,
-0.0111877937,
0.0115662785,
-0.0006227007,
0.071028851,
0.0276351254,
0.0084360428,
-0.0362379923,
-0.0792528167,
-0.0085104676,
-0.0226411242,
-0.0244286787,
-0.0354597308,
0.0184114538,
0.0336482711,
-0.0087453937,
-0.0763552338,
-0.0021239077,
-0.0277858805,
-0.0191176254,
0.0665627941,
-0.0620950349,
0.0048273504,
0.0004974537,
0.0247964524,
0.0022304743,
0.0515397899,
0.0224230289,
0.0341515392,
0.0068416209,
-0.0045596454,
0.0182159785,
-0.002816458,
0.0145867895,
-0.0267886519,
-0.0245375745,
0.0092937965,
-0.0201353263,
0.0047968822,
0.0087333908,
-0.0128619717,
0.0114396485,
-0.0091891317,
0.0523918308,
0.0483748168,
-0.0242854487,
0.0280247293,
0.0312816799,
0.0229188595,
-0.0204491876,
-0.0692929775,
0.0034685093,
0.0009430303,
-0.0351634584,
-0.0099353595,
-0.0068175341,
0.0279459246,
-0.0025431467,
-0.0522018857,
-0.0210970454,
0.025639683,
0.0096700657,
0.0037936815,
0.0361598954,
-0.0482556336,
-0.0051519573,
0.0222843047,
0.022800643,
-0.0038066572,
-0.0198131558,
-0.0539901853,
0.0078663286,
0.0898927897,
0.040885862,
-0.0581678636,
-0.0105408588,
-0.0314047635,
-0.0143028395,
-0.0573522262,
0.012468705,
0.0138783837,
-0.0023768011,
0.009459815,
-0.0574410595,
-0.0065173111,
0.0066065229,
0.0004391377,
0.0014153026,
0.0014987079,
-0.0158133656,
-0.0175445471,
-0.0754267722,
0.042925328,
-0.0331892557,
-0.0109454496,
0.0043009105,
-0.0086229229,
0.0446826555,
-0.0039629415,
0.0123075005,
0.0330865979,
0.0361990705,
-0.0218126122,
-0.0605882481,
-0.0026676031,
0.0619062707,
0.0297671929,
0.0000260701,
-0.0277306028,
0.0140510984,
-0.0349457785,
-0.0480008163,
0.0324278586,
-0.028878931,
-0.0146962591,
0.0129914004,
-0.0325287841,
-0.0216130819,
-0.0138136297,
0.0039518718,
-0.0159903113,
0.0408153981,
-0.0269984324,
-0.0360079259,
-0.0130864698,
-0.092824854,
0.0209109597,
0.0120144794,
0.0111809261,
-0.0175341349,
0.0017782418,
0.023810219,
0.0329202786,
-0.023909105,
-0.030957954,
0.0198769085,
-0.0605741292,
-0.0159130394,
0.0023300063,
-0.0058069397,
-0.0194505397,
-0.0287906099,
-0.0309134424,
0.0055632396,
0.0087868273,
-0.0432011336,
-0.0042971284,
0.0043598949,
0.049726028,
0.0213232078,
-0.0014089248,
0.0027331549,
-0.0088529214,
-0.0441355892,
0.075497739,
0.0602884591,
-0.0274541304,
-0.0355808549,
0.0342078619,
-0.042191036,
-0.0323689021,
-0.0226411484,
-0.0122615164,
-0.0023767769,
0.0017664396,
-0.0473714508,
0.0286400672,
-0.0207425877,
0.0640754029,
0.0479617566,
-0.0253437348,
-0.0433717109,
-0.0018610412,
-0.0643189326,
-0.0130843529,
-0.0255087707,
-0.0217495281,
0.0129216081,
0.0246740244,
0.0203139968,
-0.0078022536,
-0.0082348799,
0.0414191447,
-0.0206843354,
-0.0426588207,
-0.045203682,
-0.0267179403,
0.0239299182,
0.0999005064,
0.0192784984,
-0.0694193617,
0.0824517012,
0.0157060809,
0.0436410718,
-0.0431397781,
-0.0463103056,
-0.054773014,
0.0696276054,
-0.0243209731,
0.0096925078,
0.0143947825,
0.0409893766,
0.0154911028,
-0.0205592532,
-0.0192079172,
-0.0152356112,
0.00829121,
-0.0738956556,
0.0245222151,
0.0595579892,
-0.0119985072,
-0.0290876813,
-0.0556779578,
-0.0611618422,
0.0350480303,
0.0229611285,
-0.0274400059,
-0.0352615193,
0.0339985192,
0.0118778469,
-0.0245598815,
0.0141850971,
-0.0478519276,
-0.001638956,
-0.0502409488,
0.0161225591,
-0.0139450729,
0.066808857,
-0.0026431959,
0.0360771939,
0.0425793156,
-0.0313247256,
-0.0140021071,
-0.0453200527,
0.0453512371,
-0.0257016774,
-0.0062370943,
0.0072352681,
0.0381369479,
0.0156606976,
-0.0564711466,
0.015762696,
0.0942553058,
0.0242470074,
0.0051523806,
0.0313967131,
-0.0281008855,
0.0266479552,
-0.0203226861,
0.0220292564,
-0.0445662402,
-0.0331472047,
-0.0164690167,
0.0043132338,
-0.0269466247,
-0.0812178627,
-0.0025033867,
-0.0763830468,
0.0752868801,
0.0059642317,
-0.0090667913,
-0.0395800471,
-0.0660042092,
-0.0113618663,
-0.0780591518,
-0.0302634425,
-0.0253168754,
0.0112980483,
-0.0141868591,
0.0245776866,
-0.1025324166,
-0.0741315782,
0.0495461002,
-0.0184064098,
0.0057463408,
0.0439166389,
0.0214034487,
-0.0193508789,
0.0047273519,
-0.0599203855,
0.0300742816,
0.0671248287,
0.0120559437,
0.0783911422,
0.0124169961,
0.0018692148,
-0.0325879194,
0.0479310565,
-0.0523161143,
-0.023529334,
0.0290083662,
0.1310514361,
-0.0590782911,
-0.0244004205,
-0.049702011,
0.0365543142,
0.0161517616,
0.0849118009,
-0.0048370608,
-0.035436172,
-0.0092876367,
-0.0340663455,
0.0093968725,
0.0180922113,
-0.0695052594,
0.0144526623,
-0.0059797489,
-0.0213620309,
-0.0073087481,
-0.0198913272,
0.0482557565,
-0.0232525412,
0.0123539651,
0.0232201684,
0.0059981053,
0.0062526152,
-0.0466574132,
0.0599080361,
0.0182091929,
0.0637176558,
0.0224426724,
0.0174664501,
0.0691867098,
0.0090862401,
-0.0526144281,
0.0352213271,
-0.0214681085,
-0.0515725277,
-0.0148127442,
0.070286274,
0.026992619,
-0.0017702949,
-0.0031081047,
-0.0682941154,
0.0654491186,
0.0294493381,
-0.0611424185,
-0.0634402484,
0.0023446379,
0.0068049314,
0.0019735568,
0.0007682497,
-0.0028354721,
-0.0023717796,
-0.0159057397,
-0.0247762389,
-0.0912340209,
-0.0691132322,
0.0179678444,
-0.0098291244,
0.0548056997,
-0.0189620573,
-0.0061528478,
0.0035608315,
-0.0250202026,
0.0262243431,
0.0110162655,
-0.0368593261,
0.0133029185,
0.0106891599,
-0.0313085504,
-0.0238725431,
0.0067314259,
-0.0226541348,
-0.0538692139,
-0.0139981145,
0.0447972789,
0.0328969881,
0.0025610072,
0.0497501157,
0.0003907744,
0.005306033,
-0.0281770471,
-0.0126119489,
0.0343338661,
0.0471919328,
0.0468321107,
-0.0022871962,
0.045975484,
-0.0289176255,
0.0127671231,
-0.0373248197,
-0.1034215391,
-0.0272794813,
0.0197950788,
-0.0117786564,
0.0152374534,
-0.0169303939,
-0.0605839416,
0.002889497,
-0.0195998885,
0.0310998857,
-0.0265040174,
0.017509453,
0.0650494471,
0.0146558182,
-0.0746980235,
-0.0414706096,
0.0767792761,
0.0496664867,
0.0333553143,
-0.0533913262,
-0.069061324,
-0.0162539091,
-0.0313897729,
0.070679538,
0.0002216015,
0.0015370072,
0.0057968488,
-0.1146878675,
-0.0456617326,
0.0414592028,
-0.0220345538,
-0.0112709515,
-0.0244801976,
-0.0280991793,
0.0494845137,
-0.0114018666,
-0.0151864681,
-0.0204475541,
-0.0245632939,
-0.0310576893,
-0.0051122704,
-0.0456624329,
-6.181937281e-33,
0.0126645304,
-0.0725239962,
-0.0048897578,
-0.0159605183,
0.0168716442,
0.0188553724,
-0.0202501696,
-0.0048130401,
0.0125846341,
0.0295918286,
0.013548499,
-0.0044908365,
-0.0086149918,
-0.0130145373,
0.0673107877,
-0.0226002634,
0.0181483012,
-0.0004651226,
0.0120350188,
-0.002851807,
0.0412878171,
0.0162062105,
0.0081485212,
-0.1122115478,
0.0479925685,
0.0351739377,
-0.0040462497,
0.0322297513,
-0.0126863681,
0.0323296189,
-0.0179037414,
0.0471324027,
0.0266708601,
-0.0782132372,
-0.0306524076,
-0.0127604296,
0.0081812553,
-0.013919685,
0.0204826556,
-0.0555766895,
0.0136979111,
-0.0098118233,
0.0409479961,
0.0339454263,
-0.0126677174,
-0.0044191498,
0.0390145369,
-0.0433376841,
0.0103277192,
-0.0772955716,
-0.0304732565,
0.0507430434,
-0.0703040808,
0.0261017364,
0.0208582003,
0.0419503041,
-0.0169239249,
0.0082665375,
-0.0281137135,
0.019565817,
0.0412707813,
-0.0454869606,
0.0703209117,
-0.0030909383,
-0.0138203064,
0.0974657089,
-0.0026570023,
-0.0189626999,
-0.0410241261,
0.0003120208,
0.0082360813,
0.1006189063,
0.039933838,
0.0341189131,
-0.0241446458,
-0.0010972422,
-0.0891410261,
0.0576698743,
-0.0332672633,
0.0371414497,
0.0397388153,
-0.0023319053,
-0.0459361374,
-0.0542631857,
-0.0172346588,
0.0159346722,
0.0057974104,
-0.0165190846,
0.0179978758,
-0.0314595178,
-0.0447621718,
0.0510695018,
0.0297411289,
-0.0275010541,
0.0120850839,
0.0296241548,
0.0200997125,
0.0008443802,
0.0211842898,
0.0327232406,
-0.0637899041,
0.0246178489,
-0.0368807167,
-0.0314748995,
0.0343973786,
-0.0200746022,
0.0217813682,
0.0180778448,
-0.0099484213,
0.0014421657,
-0.004010139,
-0.0048763189,
0.0058893734,
0.0046999422,
0.0248319432,
0.018345261,
0.0077645145,
0.017896371,
0.0180415008,
0.0089586666,
0.0202329513,
0.0318836272,
-0.0011489796,
-0.0086018424,
-0.01293144,
-0.0386554822,
0.0093902629,
-0.0688366666,
0.020340655,
-0.0125949057,
-0.0161836818,
-0.0120722894,
2.734e-7,
0.0855542868,
0.0414208919,
-0.0287004262,
-0.0051005706,
0.0297248047,
0.0670762137,
0.0132224979,
-0.0109698894,
-0.0021250613,
-0.0360631645,
0.0905207694,
0.021703003,
0.0335609019,
0.0533373617,
-0.0085077295,
-0.031218851,
-0.0159836374,
-0.0380193442,
-0.0948046297,
-0.0079603111,
0.080417648,
0.0683850199,
0.0255249087,
-0.0082236407,
0.0220117997,
-0.0412510447,
0.0135095101,
-0.0893146098,
0.0065759239,
0.0360659882,
0.0448035859,
0.0306446757,
0.0057186796,
0.0661389902,
-0.020357836,
0.0071817283,
-0.0071469704,
0.066230908,
-0.0114181871,
0.0039479444,
0.0062601869,
-0.0421614833,
0.0263590515,
-0.0391879715,
0.0562826097,
-0.0534683913,
-0.0438289233,
-0.0133813564,
0.0327495523,
-0.0324375294,
0.0347097926,
-0.0200096369,
0.0142494561,
0.0143131856,
-0.0390600674,
-0.007577925,
-0.0044985148,
-0.0271396618,
0.0040369825,
0.0608214401,
-0.0463243499,
-0.0375916548,
0.0070854081,
0.0224435851,
0.0491390377,
-0.0561401285,
0.0576096065,
2.683224731e-34,
0.0367170535,
0.0134980036,
-0.0273653287,
0.013390041,
0.0728057399,
0.0261987504,
-0.0347818099,
0.0151163395,
0.0271025598,
-0.0635704696,
0.0212700535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07010v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07010v1
|
Deciphering public attention to geoengineering and climate issues using machine learning and dynamic analysis
| 2024-05-11T13:10:57 | 2024-05-11T13:10:57 |
Ramit Debnath, Pengyu Zhang, Tianzhu Qin, R. Michael Alvarez, Shaun D. Fitzgerald
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, J.4; K.4
|
As the conversation around using geoengineering to combat climate change
intensifies, it is imperative to engage the public and deeply understand their
perspectives on geoengineering research, development, and potential deployment.
Through a comprehensive data-driven investigation, this paper explores the
types of news that captivate public interest in geoengineering. We delved into
30,773 English-language news articles from the BBC and the New York Times,
combined with Google Trends data spanning 2018 to 2022, to explore how public
interest in geoengineering fluctuates in response to news coverage of broader
climate issues. Using BERT-based topic modeling, sentiment analysis, and
time-series regression models, we found that positive sentiment in
energy-related news serves as a good predictor of heightened public interest in
geoengineering, a trend that persists over time. Our findings suggest that
public engagement with geoengineering and climate action is not uniform, with
some topics being more potent in shaping interest over time, such as climate
news related to energy, disasters, and politics. Understanding these patterns
is crucial for scientists, policymakers, and educators aiming to craft
effective strategies for engaging with the public and fostering dialogue around
emerging climate technologies.
|
[
0.0114996247,
0.0911621153,
-0.0022429049,
-0.0006498548,
-0.02318459,
-0.0165533572,
-0.011706912,
-0.0197207741,
0.0200548079,
-0.0520415343,
0.0457402542,
0.0590185486,
-0.0191896018,
0.0568012297,
0.0017408975,
-0.0795109123,
0.0311839487,
0.0089520682,
0.0657869801,
0.0146260886,
0.0038902091,
-0.0330466591,
-0.0065413313,
0.0050010737,
0.0274023339,
0.0091448892,
-0.0046177222,
0.0296077877,
0.0675579235,
-0.064079605,
0.040056847,
0.0148999607,
0.0346337631,
0.0123507325,
0.0000017687,
-0.0161478631,
-0.0304034017,
-0.0169540513,
0.0616136305,
0.0008019786,
0.0486274548,
-0.0303812195,
-0.0040856902,
0.0085778721,
-0.0386388302,
0.0026829662,
0.0522724204,
-0.0214797817,
0.0361341275,
-0.0173536856,
-0.0106236292,
0.0217544697,
-0.0130563201,
-0.0122425463,
-0.0194138829,
0.0701418445,
0.0159863513,
-0.0183991995,
-0.0300477874,
0.0386159681,
-0.0008138545,
0.0516709946,
-0.0263743699,
0.0209273025,
0.0165229067,
0.0449652113,
-0.0468309037,
0.0105852066,
-0.0257743858,
0.0291069206,
0.0684351251,
-0.009685331,
0.0225935839,
-0.0081161987,
-0.0039967345,
0.0185648091,
-0.0296246726,
0.0176690295,
0.0015551145,
0.017463563,
0.0086258641,
-0.0209798031,
-0.0181749016,
0.058502879,
-0.0066515654,
0.0902809948,
-0.0444673263,
-0.0253198855,
-0.0148207033,
0.0362402685,
0.061277736,
-0.0315798074,
-0.0188334957,
-0.0281518791,
0.039303001,
0.0179639719,
0.0175750684,
0.0196654834,
0.0144046163,
-0.0679681897,
-0.0313761793,
0.0232332069,
0.0466140434,
0.0474086888,
0.0711455196,
-0.01919345,
0.0127299521,
0.0142432256,
0.051626619,
0.013605684,
-0.0631191358,
-0.0164426155,
0.0308453999,
-0.0236326903,
0.0305285417,
0.0213464256,
0.0555277281,
-0.0297374651,
-0.025925342,
0.013207214,
-0.0827162862,
0.0076330169,
0.0172690637,
-0.0148515692,
0.0123576727,
0.0736536309,
-0.0326362438,
0.0630129799,
0.0230259765,
0.0284585077,
-0.0140561517,
-0.0316190645,
0.0378445908,
0.0274158847,
-0.0233596154,
0.0378854647,
0.0410502926,
-0.038102638,
-0.0611278377,
-0.0327075273,
0.0347516946,
0.0262152739,
-0.0010341691,
-0.0030146698,
-0.0566290058,
0.0134071503,
0.0067415228,
0.0091056982,
-0.0047557577,
-0.0292161535,
-0.0096137291,
0.0337324701,
-0.0150478305,
-0.0352510735,
0.0518621914,
0.0458463617,
0.0112986369,
0.0679969639,
0.0338440984,
0.0639615208,
0.0221470371,
-0.0060158712,
-0.0148208728,
-0.007838821,
0.0101103652,
0.0157628674,
-0.0442506,
-0.0198190305,
-0.0606050529,
-0.0003232013,
0.0147883408,
-0.0190743785,
-0.0091598267,
0.025881229,
0.030175779,
0.0208120719,
-0.0261368956,
0.0366326459,
-0.0282021593,
0.0705818385,
-0.0257179197,
-0.0624827519,
0.0116827898,
-0.0043224697,
-0.0490911826,
-0.0294698179,
0.0338917002,
0.0233751256,
-0.0275915898,
-0.0211586244,
-0.0222960562,
0.0041582738,
0.0615181848,
-0.0224277005,
0.0110750385,
-0.0383194052,
-0.0015131911,
0.0174860097,
0.019252168,
0.0100503424,
0.0108281262,
0.0211903732,
-0.0004402353,
0.0196795743,
-0.0328688808,
0.0276306085,
-0.0479164794,
-0.0506070107,
-0.0162805598,
-0.0174747705,
0.0199548863,
0.0143950619,
-0.055433739,
0.0102663795,
-0.0475137308,
-0.0408262387,
0.0297463983,
0.0302147083,
-0.0013201868,
0.0596200749,
-0.0299095158,
-0.0096824067,
-0.0071851509,
0.0257440731,
-0.0098522166,
-0.0120735895,
-0.0549466461,
0.0024230669,
0.0336100794,
0.0067124711,
-0.004853609,
0.0049339905,
0.0622860231,
-0.002706602,
-0.0637476593,
0.0350247957,
0.0711039603,
0.0660201088,
-0.0235142782,
-0.0753942952,
-0.0097644171,
0.0004554078,
-0.0185396709,
-0.0032852862,
0.0438984185,
-0.0211325083,
0.0557077527,
0.0078382092,
-0.0416068509,
-0.035951551,
-0.0181977842,
-0.0338450521,
0.0164031461,
-0.02230631,
-0.010992419,
-0.0135383829,
-0.0561974421,
0.0065421518,
-0.0073984535,
0.0083840666,
-0.0277379453,
-0.0214434005,
-0.0161477737,
0.0282356553,
-0.0505474024,
-0.0376100168,
0.0088659963,
-0.0347263999,
-0.0298781451,
-0.0244723912,
0.0329132378,
0.0456658155,
-0.0258961432,
-0.0298140161,
0.0258833505,
0.058338508,
-0.0495731346,
-0.034465909,
0.0097505338,
0.0249934494,
-0.0070141479,
0.0552134402,
-0.042245239,
-0.0100170625,
-0.0404008739,
0.0864207447,
0.0744611248,
-0.0382894017,
-0.0443816148,
0.0124588218,
-0.0133402608,
-0.0203413628,
-0.0330286995,
-0.0259114988,
-0.0280609261,
0.0084622875,
-0.0169125497,
-0.0086676916,
0.0663614944,
0.0568166226,
-0.0028718119,
0.0279134251,
-0.0426389053,
-0.0035101031,
-0.0055527985,
0.0225573983,
0.0360506512,
-0.0130307088,
0.0552940629,
-0.0017976488,
-0.0202290695,
0.0235424414,
0.0522677004,
0.0643373504,
-0.0054836236,
-0.0327237621,
-0.006212384,
-0.0323697217,
0.0315228403,
0.0483845733,
-0.0000970581,
-0.036589507,
0.0515553094,
0.0369525254,
0.0366379507,
-0.0922016352,
-0.0175897107,
-0.0109209688,
0.0171765126,
-0.0232172478,
0.0230569504,
0.0296408944,
0.0128430268,
0.0290345401,
-0.0904014036,
-0.0354164392,
0.0040920167,
0.0057197302,
-0.0344672203,
0.0029450527,
0.0255870447,
0.0079082595,
0.0096468776,
-0.045038566,
-0.0502409749,
0.0045762812,
0.0476140194,
-0.0775890574,
-0.0137675423,
0.0239987448,
0.059238974,
-0.046411708,
0.0153657123,
-0.0266702808,
0.0431667008,
0.0305799861,
0.0146234417,
0.0226707701,
-0.0107873213,
0.0251740664,
-0.0373135582,
-0.0156922136,
0.0306886584,
0.0103937713,
-0.0522319637,
0.0030976378,
0.0147612467,
-0.0098560927,
0.0026655705,
-0.0225357059,
0.0114654088,
-0.0189808849,
0.0116262902,
0.0251316465,
-0.0083433958,
-0.0059781075,
0.0099681001,
0.0024673445,
0.0312465988,
0.0022114883,
0.0033635343,
-0.0384516306,
0.0180988591,
-0.0202697273,
-0.0249771066,
-0.0233410485,
-0.0103606824,
-0.0330703184,
-0.0795956701,
0.0632776693,
-0.0140218744,
0.025756266,
0.0035150081,
-0.1210481599,
0.0134001523,
-0.0329640396,
-0.0785092115,
-0.0470073298,
-0.0105035463,
0.018600123,
0.0348419137,
-0.0791192874,
-0.0455711819,
0.0033959677,
-0.0126273846,
-0.002924416,
0.0834886655,
0.0553417765,
-0.0443165675,
-0.0334027447,
0.0152510703,
0.0572417639,
0.0029407702,
-0.016788736,
0.0231461097,
0.0005801792,
0.0031404956,
-0.005135403,
0.019620603,
0.0032868949,
0.0147859305,
0.009748918,
0.0730915517,
-0.0483331904,
-0.004878541,
-0.0265853424,
0.0172994435,
0.0784264132,
0.013189828,
-0.0278717168,
-0.0148387291,
-0.0509900264,
-0.0577144139,
0.0259744674,
-0.0099997399,
-0.0061487965,
-0.0395568945,
-0.002549655,
-0.0308537222,
0.0025411728,
-0.0198342819,
0.017054962,
0.0081080506,
0.0082136784,
0.0199719481,
0.127032578,
0.0177769624,
-0.0616518892,
0.0619825348,
0.041022297,
0.0098776259,
-0.0322997347,
-0.0921330005,
0.0543129519,
0.0458184853,
-0.0388110988,
0.0074175228,
-0.0394057073,
-0.0400868393,
0.0253067501,
0.001362936,
0.0272452813,
-0.0398992896,
0.0182204358,
0.0319404826,
0.0123049393,
0.0772258416,
-0.0267447103,
-0.0419408455,
0.012617317,
0.0750744119,
-0.0060048723,
-0.0241538044,
0.0422270969,
-0.0062933331,
-0.0027920338,
-0.0491866022,
-0.077917695,
-0.0215140898,
-0.0317444727,
-0.0325286314,
0.0955302492,
0.028822165,
-0.0380858928,
-0.01916367,
-0.0485222042,
0.0390988775,
0.0133280372,
-0.0423054919,
0.013133063,
-0.0082330825,
-0.0120979957,
-0.0725737587,
0.0444744304,
0.0115362583,
0.0016261522,
-0.0969491079,
0.0861757323,
-0.0047610253,
0.0220046099,
-0.0139956335,
0.0062280162,
-0.0011262541,
-0.0316360593,
0.0093477871,
-0.0066867499,
0.0461371578,
-0.0211850516,
0.0187225807,
0.0149551081,
0.0120612271,
0.0226359218,
-0.0481900759,
-0.0644284412,
-0.0250997636,
0.0502957329,
-0.0309112836,
0.0645933449,
0.0061896956,
-0.00270214,
-0.0263691097,
-0.0074992417,
0.0254629962,
-0.011920115,
-0.0206845291,
0.0650535822,
0.0004100326,
-0.0563793816,
-0.0155064333,
-0.0211733673,
0.0295229666,
0.0296949465,
0.0108139338,
-0.0204341393,
-0.0191137213,
-0.029603621,
0.0303705744,
-0.0319624692,
0.0222597457,
0.034240637,
-0.061754588,
0.0408618152,
0.0622509196,
-0.0079972902,
-0.003697945,
-0.0522002801,
0.0166657623,
0.0167564414,
-0.0343328677,
-0.0024746116,
0.0119231101,
-0.001223091,
-0.0928034484,
-0.0410805754,
-0.0135494452,
-5.960138762e-33,
-0.0206555445,
-0.0297552776,
-0.0259996131,
0.0039146929,
-0.048953753,
0.0335928686,
-0.0218311958,
0.0400318019,
-0.0229028706,
0.004687625,
0.0028160496,
0.0098223547,
0.0091326432,
-0.0193347726,
0.0760604888,
0.003083373,
0.0408982597,
0.0009724417,
-0.0098385373,
0.0235453453,
0.0544657484,
0.0348907001,
0.0235364567,
-0.0704566836,
0.032857649,
0.0483806729,
-0.0292343218,
-0.0628505424,
0.0128084878,
-0.0142717697,
0.0013292386,
0.0218166281,
0.0388987809,
-0.0505619422,
-0.0302267093,
0.0661199391,
-0.0569112375,
-0.020801967,
-0.0142162452,
-0.0585574061,
0.015456602,
0.0261333417,
0.0173400305,
0.0335169993,
-0.0376378037,
0.0232390724,
0.0457890891,
0.0053902837,
0.0109850308,
-0.0307385549,
-0.0254107248,
0.0025738231,
-0.03802054,
0.0611890033,
-0.033597555,
0.0382079929,
-0.0048705558,
0.1246357337,
-0.0824436992,
0.060546156,
0.0673758164,
-0.0097026788,
0.0060027856,
0.0014373449,
0.0020722901,
0.0946193039,
-0.0324520208,
0.030258486,
-0.0662167296,
-0.021240918,
0.0251113214,
0.0040764795,
-0.0031995557,
0.0692715794,
0.0324284323,
-0.0471399054,
-0.071405299,
0.0363810025,
0.0311347544,
0.0261332914,
0.0438954048,
-0.0152091486,
0.023007337,
-0.0279457308,
-0.019130934,
-0.0031732204,
-0.0175237786,
0.0214316864,
-0.0135930609,
0.0025908141,
-0.0351046883,
0.0309408363,
0.0183302257,
-0.0273345336,
-0.0296812933,
0.0946807936,
-0.0333389752,
0.0144779533,
0.0087028341,
0.005234784,
-0.0841170773,
-0.0194760952,
-0.0685676411,
0.0756242871,
0.010898714,
-0.0301363915,
-0.043358244,
0.0122910757,
-0.0385350138,
-0.0044976952,
-0.0125095975,
-0.0186529905,
-0.013521716,
-0.0239895191,
0.0015603221,
-0.0235343054,
0.0338209979,
-0.0269081984,
0.0022404389,
0.045974981,
0.0464730114,
0.0070388368,
-0.1033707634,
0.0290584024,
0.0049721384,
-0.0535840541,
-0.0170968752,
-0.0317930803,
-0.0395121127,
-0.0310612619,
0.0120080141,
-0.0277794451,
2.551e-7,
0.0145818787,
0.0551827736,
-0.0117127337,
-0.0140257096,
-0.0031916159,
0.0558265857,
-0.0211671367,
0.0411034301,
0.0104579339,
0.0072543011,
-0.0045368699,
-0.0156907123,
-0.0119326971,
-0.0083565125,
-0.0445160642,
-0.0120646982,
-0.0243390016,
0.0123845115,
-0.06707488,
0.024918519,
0.0610260703,
-0.0224086475,
0.0168799758,
0.0359956734,
-0.0114158913,
-0.0024301033,
0.0532773174,
-0.0886988565,
0.0065276111,
0.0036693807,
-0.0164805241,
0.0153913843,
-0.0072236368,
0.0008311773,
-0.0276797395,
-0.0463594943,
-0.0357485078,
0.0027714767,
0.0446213521,
-0.0544342734,
0.0047880476,
0.0045628292,
0.0063153836,
-0.0379895419,
-0.0257770587,
-0.0579791628,
-0.0281077046,
-0.0488489196,
-0.0151275899,
0.0233947318,
0.0079529053,
-0.0027491061,
-0.0123334331,
-0.0578626059,
-0.0248460323,
-0.0155777894,
-0.0187752601,
-0.0147800259,
0.004304606,
0.013164659,
-0.0349995419,
0.0012425168,
-0.0267210007,
0.0269114189,
0.0429907963,
0.0186382253,
0.0358180888,
1.765770905e-34,
0.0432541929,
-0.0236602612,
-0.0559134707,
-0.0235368572,
0.0022844367,
0.0345979743,
0.0095605338,
-0.0079289423,
0.0242256075,
-0.0407570861,
0.0343757123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07006v1
|
Word-specific tonal realizations in Mandarin
| 2024-05-11T13:00:35 | 2024-05-11T13:00:35 |
Yu-Ying Chuang, Melanie J. Bell, Yu-Hsiang Tseng, R. Harald Baayen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The pitch contours of Mandarin two-character words are generally understood
as being shaped by the underlying tones of the constituent single-character
words, in interaction with articulatory constraints imposed by factors such as
speech rate, co-articulation with adjacent tones, segmental make-up, and
predictability. This study shows that tonal realization is also partially
determined by words' meanings. We first show, on the basis of a Taiwan corpus
of spontaneous conversations, using the generalized additive regression model,
and focusing on the rise-fall tone pattern, that after controlling for effects
of speaker and context, word type is a stronger predictor of pitch realization
than all the previously established word-form related predictors combined.
Importantly, the addition of information about meaning in context improves
prediction accuracy even further. We then proceed to show, using computational
modeling with context-specific word embeddings, that token-specific pitch
contours predict word type with 50% accuracy on held-out data, and that
context-sensitive, token-specific embeddings can predict the shape of pitch
contours with 30% accuracy. These accuracies, which are an order of magnitude
above chance level, suggest that the relation between words' pitch contours and
their meanings are sufficiently strong to be functional for language users. The
theoretical implications of these empirical findings are discussed.
|
[
-0.0233792625,
0.0758955926,
-0.0024050802,
0.0092593152,
-0.0125550181,
-0.0519234724,
-0.0046094921,
-0.0019158447,
-0.0279237349,
0.0294114929,
-0.1043138355,
-0.0785251334,
0.0869372264,
0.0643722937,
0.0299314559,
-0.0694691315,
0.0183729045,
-0.0184299555,
0.0474491641,
0.0032635289,
0.0463917032,
-0.0181112122,
-0.0088462746,
0.0566526093,
-0.0342976972,
-0.0096925842,
-0.030708639,
-0.0000138318,
-0.0068959584,
-0.0099006156,
-0.0244411081,
0.0343628451,
0.0173379723,
0.0129832625,
0.0000017932,
-0.0680099204,
0.0089191319,
-0.0087983301,
-0.0215672702,
-0.0082823075,
0.0636454374,
0.0024824983,
-0.0339327715,
0.0179804396,
-0.01610112,
0.0219601803,
0.052860979,
0.0227835309,
-0.0102724321,
0.0031048758,
-0.0321629681,
-0.0107274503,
-0.0043511372,
0.0019298159,
-0.0218431242,
-0.0023223914,
0.0249007642,
0.013109941,
-0.0435872711,
-0.0656939745,
-0.0506758168,
0.009763916,
-0.014785788,
0.0521538444,
0.0166752748,
0.0379995927,
-0.06252902,
-0.0233192444,
0.0016584927,
0.0278091207,
0.0090016034,
-0.0350979082,
-0.0432719588,
0.0143591752,
0.0002196402,
-0.0173232537,
0.0145006422,
-0.0056518861,
0.0099354144,
0.0020810235,
0.0306585319,
0.0352060273,
-0.0053619947,
-0.0030138884,
-0.0104862833,
-0.0078063621,
0.0273304097,
-0.0728816837,
-0.0028211952,
-0.0271896552,
-0.0136954226,
-0.0241617281,
0.0413715839,
0.0154192364,
0.0116412835,
0.01287279,
0.0107083684,
-0.018040115,
0.0023765166,
-0.0569205545,
0.0003917046,
0.004209708,
-0.0423082188,
-0.0288499184,
0.0087124435,
0.0200399421,
0.0201223139,
-0.075398989,
-0.0556826331,
0.0072886036,
0.0140173119,
-0.0552086979,
-0.0430512242,
0.0060879039,
0.038487304,
-0.0238125809,
-0.0352331065,
0.0006284968,
-0.0430751182,
-0.0210054014,
0.0016163444,
0.0293346532,
-0.0593589433,
-0.0019569215,
-0.0162000936,
0.0217425637,
-0.0410231352,
0.071509093,
-0.0533099249,
-0.0367507972,
0.0165138114,
0.0137061868,
0.0275463574,
0.0467654802,
0.0228221696,
0.0182310995,
0.006041626,
0.0034365335,
0.0587853566,
-0.0603679009,
-0.0845143422,
-0.021379061,
-0.0661027953,
-0.0579701588,
-0.0159607753,
-0.0195908695,
0.0169706997,
-0.019019464,
-0.0342548341,
-0.009400825,
0.0334882438,
0.0245649405,
0.0105129369,
0.0229013711,
0.0016653035,
0.0094305342,
-0.038721934,
0.0253849085,
0.0577684976,
-0.0186324157,
0.0070329197,
-0.0499584042,
0.0031434281,
0.0158115048,
-0.0137161501,
-0.0252130236,
-0.0178898294,
-0.0507503152,
0.0003006536,
0.0592242777,
0.0354043879,
0.0171306562,
0.005142123,
-0.0251246113,
0.0446978323,
0.0949324816,
0.0725681558,
0.0359739847,
0.0066428022,
-0.0048829601,
-0.0065442841,
0.0302686859,
-0.0041954545,
-0.0181414057,
-0.0174896289,
0.0458735414,
0.0223155245,
0.0207081996,
-0.0166471191,
-0.0337262228,
-0.0213779025,
-0.0346527398,
-0.0230787527,
-0.0474549644,
0.0365413465,
0.0154280169,
0.0064356397,
0.0108723398,
0.0151702566,
-0.0470292941,
0.0091463607,
-0.0081922766,
-0.0223554205,
0.0505843535,
-0.0101114856,
-0.0233662687,
0.0271039736,
0.0126427123,
-0.0409556963,
0.0307258107,
0.0131405303,
0.0015826094,
-0.0013816637,
-0.0318355747,
0.0148565024,
0.054238867,
0.0148893436,
0.0221976992,
-0.0459422767,
0.0372606665,
-0.0216355436,
-0.0313898362,
0.0116912993,
-0.0185557138,
-0.0200419147,
-0.0228278134,
-0.0166410636,
0.015965661,
0.0299415216,
0.0349729694,
-0.0345440991,
0.0541467369,
-0.0069958833,
-0.0016074429,
-0.0040218215,
0.054277882,
-0.0814754367,
0.0066709626,
0.0224043485,
-0.0188461337,
0.0360543728,
-0.0420055687,
0.0546355322,
-0.0759794861,
0.0586074963,
0.0128522394,
0.0749783888,
-0.080358468,
0.0244523082,
-0.0483749025,
0.0813310891,
0.0343941599,
0.0057858275,
0.033211533,
-0.0155517459,
-0.019323267,
-0.0032198811,
0.005677639,
-0.0276294686,
-0.0517931357,
0.0321987271,
-0.0011916194,
0.0312778205,
-0.0188836548,
-0.0583787002,
-0.0152405435,
0.0003988602,
-0.0800654367,
-0.013617048,
0.0006903455,
-0.028185226,
0.0075585409,
0.0109717809,
0.0239134021,
0.015486856,
-0.0253632162,
-0.0264798757,
-0.0295791663,
0.0295304172,
-0.0286764335,
-0.0522537641,
-0.0378378518,
-0.0258776248,
0.0030255122,
-0.022175001,
-0.0122513082,
-0.0157753974,
-0.0057216543,
-0.0054299827,
0.0325601511,
-0.0204953346,
-0.0104437405,
0.020309601,
-0.0446992032,
0.0064668213,
-0.0323191993,
0.0741089061,
0.0299799573,
0.0059735747,
0.0205934979,
0.07840956,
-0.0202021338,
-0.0081125638,
-0.0325292908,
0.0171701424,
0.0378916152,
-0.0023548834,
-0.0067110225,
-0.0146217244,
0.0761811286,
0.0707618147,
0.0138304653,
-0.0677811205,
-0.0359219909,
-0.0403194688,
-0.0170044247,
-0.0034863267,
-0.0121918544,
-0.0950396061,
-0.0040089427,
-0.0263214633,
-0.0629942343,
0.08782579,
-0.0221320856,
-0.0455069691,
-0.0142739173,
-0.024551589,
-0.0317253545,
0.0196664631,
-0.0154176252,
-0.0266803447,
0.038969513,
-0.0465620384,
-0.0247573014,
0.0470632613,
0.0186835378,
-0.0712025464,
0.0516506694,
0.0237669609,
-0.0626910031,
-0.0048843618,
-0.0043800129,
-0.0176375303,
-0.0081995437,
-0.0696000829,
0.054556448,
0.0363932773,
-0.015368185,
0.1060965806,
0.0461332388,
-0.0138443308,
-0.0068796617,
-0.0160280652,
0.0332608111,
-0.0013290348,
-0.0403022356,
0.0021428959,
0.084787786,
-0.0037783538,
-0.0040901229,
0.0632046685,
-0.0346779376,
0.0142822908,
0.0387519486,
-0.0071810768,
0.0102159409,
0.0168989096,
0.0274664387,
-0.0368070342,
0.0103911739,
0.0317061245,
-0.0040400079,
0.0232955925,
0.1088073775,
0.0103072617,
-0.0382203907,
0.0121435309,
-0.0110254483,
0.0528499149,
0.0019028091,
-0.0115088951,
-0.0383204371,
-0.0034431985,
0.0508606322,
-0.0278846193,
0.0142674949,
0.0237703472,
-0.0103312824,
-0.0935761705,
0.0352063105,
0.0275678262,
0.013568785,
0.0114760045,
-0.0360268056,
0.0276078284,
0.0199063029,
0.0049970318,
0.0139248259,
-0.0309925806,
-0.0228951946,
0.0189652834,
-0.1192710102,
0.0002618341,
0.0457375273,
-0.0292590875,
-0.0131582636,
0.02237905,
0.0338817649,
-0.0604359172,
-0.0482935645,
-0.0124118719,
0.0364873111,
0.0045835255,
-0.0063350727,
0.0583131388,
0.0478256382,
0.0139802909,
-0.0242657773,
0.0533044636,
-0.033137396,
-0.0162299722,
-0.0201474614,
0.0500444695,
-0.0133075351,
-0.0247914307,
-0.0121761085,
0.0548028275,
-0.0267534871,
0.0782750845,
0.0376478881,
-0.1013548449,
0.0310031399,
0.0264240671,
0.0475913063,
0.0319032259,
-0.0158344619,
0.0214638449,
0.026077345,
-0.0121849533,
-0.0491152517,
-0.0038275358,
-0.0257200804,
0.0285413824,
0.0442103595,
0.0440177061,
-0.0282272063,
-0.0097720511,
-0.0108218193,
-0.0181137566,
0.0586724281,
0.0709844902,
-0.0550926402,
-0.0076220986,
0.0403157212,
-0.0912928581,
-0.0210266802,
-0.0560215414,
-0.0124565763,
-0.0299218073,
0.0823283121,
-0.0666712523,
0.0093417764,
0.0644333065,
-0.0215850584,
-0.0205235109,
0.0352338254,
-0.0281439964,
0.006953151,
0.024451673,
0.0405539833,
0.0022957346,
0.0069843307,
0.0295840651,
-0.0227703098,
0.0327429995,
-0.0512010716,
-0.0268480256,
-0.0009080261,
-0.0406814888,
0.0062404997,
-0.0087431464,
0.0543329269,
-0.0105012478,
0.0160048362,
-0.0424024463,
-0.0080417776,
0.0135865826,
0.003707513,
-0.0090203658,
-0.0443308838,
0.0307206791,
0.0151741672,
-0.0247840155,
-0.00223579,
-0.0297915395,
-0.0214003492,
0.0336321108,
0.0417972393,
0.050055854,
0.0257941857,
0.0136290137,
0.0298037454,
-0.009806741,
0.0323159881,
-0.035504017,
-0.000463288,
0.0042906045,
-0.0206362493,
-0.0321517475,
0.0087121762,
-0.0075353798,
0.000988784,
-0.0133200856,
0.0018387343,
-0.0096578514,
-0.0246160757,
0.0284054894,
-0.0228082929,
-0.0268778149,
-0.0302813724,
0.0357330069,
-0.0318165123,
-0.0107723242,
-0.0310913622,
-0.0239053704,
0.0401919186,
0.0130124427,
-0.0480488092,
-0.0321089961,
0.0311825462,
-0.003775768,
0.0005784521,
-0.042098254,
-0.0035156321,
0.002446933,
0.0281520728,
-0.0096374629,
0.0084669422,
-0.0376560874,
0.0191855226,
-0.0953933895,
-0.0647913888,
0.0760702044,
-0.0050536143,
0.0236172713,
-0.0173254684,
0.0058605457,
0.025949996,
-0.0657249242,
0.0163696278,
0.0206679963,
-0.0359243564,
-0.025931349,
0.0252544619,
0.0355858691,
-5.935041957e-33,
-0.0127134863,
-0.0105734859,
-0.003323369,
0.061162807,
0.0026722879,
0.0504901372,
-0.02349893,
0.0252131168,
-0.0221604165,
0.0143031273,
0.0038151531,
-0.0009575514,
0.0163507778,
-0.0228014179,
0.0457621403,
0.0066670617,
0.0397954211,
-0.0124683734,
0.0129241301,
-0.0506938435,
0.0680466294,
0.012811753,
0.0612885505,
-0.0201353002,
0.0052686064,
0.0135938218,
-0.0027852959,
0.0009255924,
0.0143703213,
0.0442243442,
-0.0218783151,
0.0738339946,
0.0311413929,
0.0470852964,
-0.0447240248,
0.0191292707,
-0.062101271,
-0.060104616,
0.0049145459,
0.0472734682,
0.0067935511,
0.0168866366,
-0.003532246,
-0.0026850086,
-0.0289329346,
-0.0499182977,
0.0278007165,
-0.0200286563,
0.0073708044,
-0.0098062269,
-0.0324750319,
0.0106987031,
0.033882618,
-0.0444487147,
0.0473937206,
0.0288470387,
-0.0408151597,
-0.0139541849,
-0.0169102717,
0.0387119725,
-0.0016973455,
0.0336007625,
0.0078262752,
0.0866990238,
0.0209453683,
0.0343713723,
0.0524816103,
-0.0338182338,
-0.0076219076,
-0.024842361,
0.0860238373,
0.0119651295,
-0.0202481076,
0.017290039,
0.0685999468,
-0.046438437,
0.0505826771,
-0.0337094404,
0.0283771399,
-0.0045049354,
-0.0061450871,
0.0576376282,
-0.06463366,
-0.0370443985,
-0.0276256669,
-0.0345406272,
-0.049141787,
-0.0041639335,
0.0144130029,
-0.0139721343,
0.0473678559,
0.0009017205,
0.0543065332,
-0.0295178033,
0.0070169792,
-0.0165168364,
-0.0291483328,
0.0083397776,
0.0340281352,
0.0262863878,
-0.0368031859,
-0.0115299001,
0.017649876,
0.0806025192,
0.039144773,
-0.0003246048,
-0.0032972181,
0.0173798781,
-0.0285619944,
-0.0084889214,
0.0211869963,
-0.080345571,
0.0357844792,
-0.024778815,
0.046372328,
0.02638207,
-0.024255354,
0.035663411,
0.0020080372,
0.0391406119,
-0.0536318384,
0.0058797817,
-0.0537555031,
0.0531549938,
-0.0376178361,
0.0002093976,
0.0200610217,
-0.0484260246,
0.0702747777,
-0.0493405163,
-0.0276500694,
0.0107339881,
2.68e-7,
0.025333982,
-0.0180145875,
0.0375973545,
0.0077429577,
0.0285924785,
0.0109709706,
-0.0454751588,
0.0089515215,
0.0293026771,
0.0355325751,
0.0323405713,
-0.0303578135,
0.0910455883,
0.0416414514,
-0.0827010572,
0.0237688329,
-0.0774403214,
0.0424151383,
-0.0310115404,
0.02550474,
0.0399776399,
0.0711748675,
-0.0580114499,
-0.0253314357,
0.0115473298,
-0.0206758324,
0.0207175761,
-0.0297047384,
0.0276464149,
-0.0128936209,
-0.0516961664,
-0.0031090821,
0.0002376764,
0.0288052,
-0.0716748759,
0.0729466453,
0.0504809469,
0.0168408491,
-0.0011805,
-0.0194895957,
-0.0183241591,
0.0214547962,
-0.0352277383,
0.0212359596,
0.0548506267,
0.0324820094,
-0.0464312211,
-0.0385251604,
0.0265257433,
0.0083415732,
0.0410006158,
-0.0045131687,
-0.0129080759,
-0.0087401485,
-0.0087754745,
-0.0051764781,
-0.0190285351,
-0.0004888605,
-0.0580916256,
0.0387983657,
-0.0535949916,
-0.0228663869,
0.0151269427,
-0.0674584582,
0.0186638813,
0.0116961086,
0.0034738474,
1.99464838e-34,
0.0224858746,
-0.0330331884,
0.0515494645,
0.004509707,
0.0036558134,
-0.036703933,
0.1105500311,
0.0191833898,
0.0527856275,
-0.0274105705,
-0.0590506196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.07001v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.07001v2
|
Evaluating Task-based Effectiveness of MLLMs on Charts
| 2024-05-11T12:33:46 | 2024-06-17T15:44:33 |
Yifan Wu, Lutao Yan, Yuyu Luo, Yunhai Wang, Nan Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
In this paper, we explore a forward-thinking question: Is GPT-4V effective at
low-level data analysis tasks on charts? To this end, we first curate a
large-scale dataset, named ChartInsights, consisting of 89,388 quartets (chart,
task, question, answer) and covering 10 widely-used low-level data analysis
tasks on 7 chart types. Firstly, we conduct systematic evaluations to
understand the capabilities and limitations of 18 advanced MLLMs, which include
12 open-source models and 6 closed-source models. Starting with a standard
textual prompt approach, the average accuracy rate across the 18 MLLMs is
36.17%. Among all the models, GPT-4V achieves the highest accuracy, reaching
56.13%. To understand the limitations of multimodal large models in low-level
data analysis tasks, we have designed various experiments to conduct an
in-depth test of capabilities of GPT-4V. We further investigate how visual
modifications to charts, such as altering visual elements (e.g. changing color
schemes) and introducing perturbations (e.g. adding image noise), affect
performance of GPT-4V. Secondly, we present 12 experimental findings. These
findings suggest potential of GPT-4V to revolutionize interaction with charts
and uncover the gap between human analytic needs and capabilities of GPT-4V.
Thirdly, we propose a novel textual prompt strategy, named Chain-of-Charts,
tailored for low-level analysis tasks, which boosts model performance by
24.36%, resulting in an accuracy of 80.49%. Furthermore, by incorporating a
visual prompt strategy that directs attention of GPT-4V to question-relevant
visual elements, we further improve accuracy to 83.83%. Our study not only
sheds light on the capabilities and limitations of GPT-4V in low-level data
analysis tasks but also offers valuable insights for future research.
|
[
-0.0161084849,
0.0432310551,
-0.0259086471,
0.0171791036,
-0.0256730728,
-0.0016616248,
0.0544734187,
0.010300152,
0.0464409031,
0.0330322012,
-0.0185524244,
-0.0043925913,
-0.0082173171,
0.0447503366,
0.033533942,
-0.1143143475,
-0.0051314724,
-0.0099054547,
0.0482552983,
0.0084627671,
0.0001111312,
-0.027877057,
-0.0263456665,
0.04298646,
-0.0475244299,
-0.048736766,
-0.0359247178,
0.0374268815,
0.0499404334,
-0.0717213303,
-0.0323208161,
0.058287207,
0.0202636886,
0.0105507486,
0.0000025665,
-0.0313396603,
0.0206652917,
-0.0145026343,
-0.0257961471,
-0.0050083194,
0.0326315798,
-0.0369778164,
0.0357649997,
-0.0225966927,
-0.0297097825,
0.0073414845,
0.0591222532,
0.0146531612,
0.0630475208,
-0.0197055526,
-0.0068158871,
0.030050993,
-0.0124575263,
-0.0147643993,
0.0707669631,
-0.0376665629,
-0.0136324167,
0.0331163406,
0.0472362004,
0.028605435,
-0.0455006026,
0.0610479712,
0.0287759583,
0.0382539891,
0.0209022611,
0.0360779576,
0.0109901745,
-0.0424630605,
-0.0262437463,
0.0909956768,
-0.0099342018,
0.0094677312,
-0.0173041113,
-0.0346198566,
0.0379254967,
0.0630523637,
-0.0940412134,
-0.0381037444,
-0.0425729714,
-0.0404089913,
-0.0686120093,
0.0078840088,
0.0123105599,
-0.0338870622,
-0.0032520022,
-0.0051310472,
-0.010637477,
-0.0280295908,
0.0346894376,
-0.0029673115,
-0.0289352965,
-0.0353103504,
-0.0075807604,
-0.0012780194,
-0.0303490032,
-0.0101191709,
0.0062592048,
-0.0262765903,
0.0025219743,
-0.002322501,
0.0841473937,
0.010370356,
-0.0288004857,
0.0174657255,
0.030815158,
0.0501879603,
-0.0056505813,
-0.05486257,
0.0086769816,
0.0183761958,
-0.0197825041,
-0.0122593641,
-0.0149373449,
-0.0445050858,
-0.0636657402,
-0.0189908352,
-0.0047225947,
0.0220069531,
-0.0056571746,
0.0429970324,
-0.0363473222,
0.0099175433,
-0.011972338,
0.0382560603,
-0.048515182,
0.0257656127,
-0.0648710951,
-0.0139862513,
-0.012951795,
-0.0380053855,
0.0024186426,
0.0126655214,
0.0287927166,
-0.0224683043,
0.0072611053,
0.0630283952,
0.0338069722,
0.0230651032,
-0.0243428368,
-0.0523562506,
-0.0048483657,
-0.0228653904,
0.0102717802,
-0.0050951806,
0.0207813531,
0.0124360239,
0.0186807718,
0.0005492421,
0.011938584,
0.0453284048,
-0.0093141543,
0.0870115459,
-0.0088743409,
-0.0107178017,
-0.0069263722,
-0.0084456578,
-0.063808687,
0.0488005988,
0.0414910354,
0.0310566425,
0.026960237,
-0.0933906138,
0.0530924015,
0.0389146022,
0.0023947433,
-0.0151024247,
-0.0274348427,
0.0267627314,
-0.0710326061,
0.022916371,
0.0135967899,
0.0226834975,
-0.0388790779,
-0.0094853956,
0.115287587,
0.0325502455,
0.059666831,
-0.004677366,
-0.0044176313,
0.004113087,
0.0136388214,
-0.0035480151,
-0.0473264903,
0.0704895407,
0.012895775,
0.0224706214,
-0.0425237939,
0.0011085782,
-0.0069388594,
-0.0497299954,
-0.027816169,
0.0319512412,
-0.0171969011,
0.0075425808,
0.0081736883,
-0.0259755887,
-0.0016218551,
-0.0150156803,
-0.0137521783,
-0.0409388244,
-0.0556251146,
-0.0031537132,
0.0389843062,
0.0563905276,
0.0250881743,
-0.0332540423,
-0.0427188687,
-0.054532595,
0.0089399433,
0.0289911609,
0.049350448,
0.005397514,
-0.0266078617,
-0.0440681577,
-0.0489987321,
-0.0323200747,
0.001879107,
0.0271853618,
-0.0132094016,
-0.0050270497,
-0.0139709236,
-0.0600506924,
0.0051430082,
-0.0165751278,
0.0209296271,
-0.016327044,
0.000660588,
0.0159876551,
0.0246777851,
0.0229006279,
0.0282511003,
0.0166095011,
0.0084190117,
0.0273221936,
0.0324536152,
0.0289333425,
0.0002507264,
-0.0065999692,
0.0165605154,
-0.0426155105,
-0.0185600501,
0.0134606306,
-0.0294482,
-0.0207511261,
0.0061981371,
-0.0502701513,
-0.0268405881,
-0.0121306796,
-0.0542424396,
-0.0061980099,
-0.000612903,
-0.0483031385,
0.0514996126,
-0.009201197,
0.0199947245,
0.0126244193,
0.0641363561,
0.0197880231,
-0.0301483702,
0.0291710887,
0.0203336645,
0.0234145653,
0.0222373996,
-0.0086109731,
-0.019818075,
-0.0725124776,
0.0349741392,
-0.0875087604,
-0.0265522897,
-0.0064122588,
0.0104979472,
0.0249325968,
0.0058632819,
-0.0671002567,
-0.0317791514,
-0.0218997542,
0.0179435592,
-0.0345889628,
0.0214006789,
0.0301368758,
-0.0225119181,
0.02574935,
-0.0157943331,
0.0126610566,
-0.017648885,
0.0131783457,
0.0622396357,
-0.0160960332,
-0.0006524589,
-0.0276650805,
-0.0405659899,
-0.0166572351,
0.0099695344,
0.0402651839,
0.0426937081,
-0.0154953394,
0.1036285385,
0.0282355547,
-0.0391365513,
0.0487214886,
0.007697477,
-0.0563430004,
-0.05006098,
0.051931113,
-0.0050087753,
0.0251733325,
0.0151491538,
-0.0064800782,
-0.0021657459,
0.0255476907,
0.014517393,
0.0143467225,
-0.0120696062,
0.0514152497,
-0.0082770828,
0.0095519722,
-0.0662092716,
0.0239596814,
-0.0237629712,
0.0382003672,
-0.0128967967,
-0.0774853677,
0.0353316851,
-0.0036339266,
-0.0317598172,
-0.0124587072,
-0.007063135,
-0.015250585,
0.079182975,
0.0025607182,
-0.0207472313,
-0.014370339,
-0.0241515003,
-0.0258518141,
0.0223139748,
0.0000857563,
-0.0385065377,
0.0338131972,
-0.0806653202,
-0.0391715281,
-0.0205414984,
-0.0044406457,
-0.0300776307,
-0.0303462595,
-0.0183357783,
-0.0289939232,
-0.0069201663,
-0.0289505906,
0.0016062416,
-0.0032255684,
0.0430415273,
-0.01270572,
-0.0137474993,
-0.0241357833,
0.0025003452,
0.012780006,
0.0147629743,
0.0386452638,
0.0045615453,
-0.0553123802,
0.0398460776,
0.0420719944,
0.0074970461,
-0.024850348,
-0.0373110846,
0.0303704683,
-0.0265325196,
0.0400452614,
-0.0018116729,
0.0348207392,
0.081176132,
-0.0384516455,
0.0397878475,
0.0817745328,
0.0113516543,
-0.0517244041,
-0.0155438632,
-0.0049874359,
0.0553390048,
0.0172922257,
0.0006190122,
-0.0839254707,
-0.0260879043,
0.0249489732,
0.056708809,
0.0058031389,
-0.0438796207,
0.0028238764,
-0.0771346092,
0.0962219387,
0.0016547103,
-0.0257400349,
-0.0003169215,
-0.0285722893,
0.0309991911,
0.007378527,
0.0050735208,
-0.0117752524,
-0.0090960255,
0.0371840037,
0.0076470771,
-0.0592875034,
-0.0263700914,
-0.0302187428,
0.0045030937,
-0.0419786163,
0.026025014,
0.0384525359,
-0.0336016305,
-0.0569556542,
0.0140447812,
0.0447281376,
0.0188182425,
-0.0369603112,
0.0869455114,
0.036288783,
-0.0073899897,
-0.0490347557,
0.0609522015,
0.0183439758,
-0.008235544,
0.0373673029,
0.0650840625,
-0.035995245,
-0.0316833146,
-0.0415670387,
0.009088845,
0.0155714564,
0.0145909591,
0.0957248062,
-0.0403437167,
-0.0256933644,
-0.0645895004,
0.0341592394,
-0.0423095971,
-0.0050896527,
0.0015053175,
0.0379681103,
-0.002077403,
-0.0225279573,
-0.0652291998,
0.0495366007,
0.0176629871,
-0.0018383363,
-0.0144130895,
-0.0256112237,
-0.0240055937,
-0.0290537886,
0.074702546,
-0.0067844889,
0.0443350263,
0.0189787801,
-0.0175608471,
-0.0060222065,
-0.0038717752,
-0.0073152417,
0.0407601073,
-0.0778362826,
-0.0010959409,
-0.0277365949,
0.0477014035,
0.0294794645,
-0.0094304681,
0.0119295437,
-0.0172453597,
0.0253206808,
0.0669798851,
-0.0154137779,
-0.0301431343,
-0.0150171053,
0.038391877,
-0.0058571808,
-0.0263735447,
0.0214772597,
0.0283611231,
0.0086762579,
0.024946386,
-0.0191819239,
-0.0020818312,
-0.0039101131,
0.0180690363,
0.0578530878,
0.0018415252,
-0.0542696826,
0.0037691521,
-0.0303199589,
-0.0109752594,
-0.0186691731,
-0.021463098,
-0.0223315824,
0.0109687513,
-0.0152716599,
-0.0258587226,
-0.0283208843,
-0.0059282375,
-0.0357768275,
-0.1417755634,
0.0248538386,
0.011730927,
-0.0205269791,
0.0265298001,
0.0252481513,
-0.01305658,
-0.0049964571,
0.0050998749,
0.0338506177,
0.0703941956,
0.0630024895,
-0.000762279,
-0.0133479917,
0.0024041103,
0.0414556563,
-0.0724539831,
-0.0767123923,
0.0347163565,
0.003404604,
0.0494464785,
-0.0058380798,
0.0012802689,
-0.0140762897,
-0.0036005827,
-0.014095597,
0.0068695755,
0.030783942,
0.0325112082,
0.0539233051,
0.0047928942,
-0.0248712972,
-0.0800587386,
0.0326081179,
-0.0303602852,
0.022626888,
-0.0468445271,
-0.0300158858,
-0.0643424764,
0.0260990839,
0.0365955383,
0.0167662054,
0.0092807058,
0.0083840303,
-0.1053023115,
-0.0688280836,
0.0243809279,
-0.0075434698,
-0.0083222166,
-0.0233935434,
0.0451167263,
0.0322633497,
-0.0253455825,
-0.0194592215,
0.0111496337,
0.043036025,
-0.0258589461,
-0.040941298,
-0.0380844176,
-6.284541774e-33,
-0.0021768848,
-0.0592999086,
0.0247791521,
0.0153842578,
-0.0120083718,
-0.0062165516,
-0.0294116661,
0.0243287086,
0.0180387907,
0.0126279118,
0.014483328,
-0.0363803394,
-0.0036060279,
-0.0055672615,
0.0281777103,
-0.042530328,
0.0260429308,
0.0165512934,
-0.0202457234,
0.0023173054,
0.0077090031,
0.0219720043,
-0.0113644768,
-0.0900596157,
0.0273123905,
0.019363841,
0.0069073914,
-0.0354322642,
-0.0243939497,
0.0383681208,
-0.0060265469,
0.0489268303,
0.029423587,
-0.0121649196,
-0.0697402731,
0.0693041459,
-0.0327968262,
-0.0581599511,
0.0068628038,
-0.0005338121,
-0.0617767274,
0.0027269521,
0.0431896858,
0.0074244784,
-0.0215256512,
-0.0535510629,
0.0514246859,
-0.0090658488,
-0.0158475321,
0.0167257134,
0.0031321933,
0.0299999565,
-0.0253042746,
-0.0059973341,
0.0296594463,
0.1200845391,
0.0160009917,
0.0465118848,
-0.0628094822,
0.0447411463,
0.0175070409,
-0.0906745195,
0.0456192158,
0.0502880476,
0.0339975245,
0.0309389457,
0.0240323357,
-0.005693682,
-0.0627898201,
0.0336963683,
0.0107431337,
0.0836423263,
0.0716183558,
-0.0081088571,
0.0092040915,
0.0067660073,
-0.0208464209,
0.0435489565,
-0.0475867912,
0.0000262659,
-0.0369227678,
0.0223048106,
-0.0516361296,
-0.0080544595,
-0.0114369486,
0.003810754,
-0.044048693,
-0.0086657023,
0.0503373854,
-0.0452141687,
0.0162633341,
0.0498377606,
0.0113324896,
0.0236155968,
-0.017637603,
-0.0569666997,
0.0163615681,
0.0518896542,
0.0298864041,
-0.0368950665,
-0.0327776074,
0.0348925591,
-0.011480906,
0.0025385167,
0.0463552959,
0.0064504473,
0.0094293337,
0.0099129714,
-0.0644647554,
-0.031352777,
-0.0192709155,
0.00608557,
0.0073845759,
-0.0254911575,
0.0504747629,
-0.0217888188,
-0.0330990814,
0.0252901055,
0.0132374195,
0.0159368254,
-0.0399246477,
-0.0273241401,
-0.0705900192,
-0.0200124085,
0.0344274119,
-0.0293609109,
-0.0061487323,
-0.0368390121,
0.0356220417,
-0.0454979055,
-0.006416813,
-0.0370353647,
3.003e-7,
0.0357008614,
0.0522570573,
0.0235071257,
0.020553695,
0.0417663157,
0.0261391252,
-0.0548878685,
-0.033036992,
0.0130783161,
-0.0348038413,
0.0115751103,
0.0253419839,
0.0646149591,
0.0885236412,
-0.0338098556,
-0.0580118597,
0.0236869045,
-0.0068812184,
-0.069849655,
0.0489768013,
0.0933904424,
-0.0165650211,
0.0320617184,
-0.0138168894,
0.0532925427,
-0.0181746315,
0.0515463986,
-0.0652424023,
0.0028090028,
-0.0407258794,
0.0083075687,
0.0115256971,
0.0112556871,
0.0379490852,
-0.0216069669,
-0.0389349498,
-0.0028929971,
0.017388273,
0.0110107083,
0.0136742359,
0.0056687752,
0.0219326522,
0.0302422978,
-0.0619791225,
0.0469137803,
-0.0184785239,
-0.0365850963,
0.0418926068,
0.0038221765,
-0.0068608718,
0.051073838,
-0.0179378204,
-0.0397673361,
-0.0257308204,
0.0067325723,
0.0131151713,
0.0161156356,
0.0081586605,
-0.0257610269,
0.0258877296,
-0.0570708252,
-0.0553858504,
-0.0500244349,
-0.0052086571,
-0.016145749,
-0.0128120156,
-0.0477328487,
2.832743021e-34,
0.0321476534,
-0.0160284955,
0.0579947978,
-0.0170866977,
0.0512888655,
-0.0144018279,
0.0155519005,
0.0313161537,
0.0499439947,
-0.0606377497,
-0.0152927032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06996v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06996v1
|
Quite Good, but Not Enough: Nationality Bias in Large Language Models -- A Case Study of ChatGPT
| 2024-05-11T12:11:52 | 2024-05-11T12:11:52 |
Shucheng Zhu, Weikang Wang, Ying Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While nationality is a pivotal demographic element that enhances the
performance of language models, it has received far less scrutiny regarding
inherent biases. This study investigates nationality bias in ChatGPT (GPT-3.5),
a large language model (LLM) designed for text generation. The research covers
195 countries, 4 temperature settings, and 3 distinct prompt types, generating
4,680 discourses about nationality descriptions in Chinese and English.
Automated metrics were used to analyze the nationality bias, and expert
annotators alongside ChatGPT itself evaluated the perceived bias. The results
show that ChatGPT's generated discourses are predominantly positive, especially
compared to its predecessor, GPT-2. However, when prompted with negative
inclinations, it occasionally produces negative content. Despite ChatGPT
considering its generated text as neutral, it shows consistent self-awareness
about nationality bias when subjected to the same pair-wise comparison
annotation framework used by human annotators. In conclusion, while ChatGPT's
generated texts seem friendly and positive, they reflect the inherent
nationality biases in the real world. This bias may vary across different
language versions of ChatGPT, indicating diverse cultural perspectives. The
study highlights the subtle and pervasive nature of biases within LLMs,
emphasizing the need for further scrutiny.
|
[
0.0489297174,
0.0222264994,
-0.0246182773,
0.0106656468,
-0.0241955686,
0.0150294332,
0.0551746637,
-0.0380354114,
0.021224644,
-0.0589835942,
-0.0228922497,
-0.0662518218,
0.0039971308,
-0.0116239507,
0.0129499501,
-0.0622607581,
0.0253440291,
0.0283507314,
0.0659672022,
-0.0285845269,
0.039701011,
0.041063711,
0.0239019524,
0.0625998378,
-0.0380511209,
-0.0006435983,
0.0399289094,
0.0153668961,
0.0414170511,
-0.0200760979,
0.0367812365,
0.0706515685,
-0.017579956,
0.0473811366,
0.000002042,
-0.0435480811,
0.0148587069,
-0.0073212683,
0.039966464,
0.0382473841,
0.0755706728,
0.0332026854,
-0.0167344976,
0.0231230669,
-0.0474128835,
-0.0155983334,
0.0491211489,
0.0391058661,
0.0710533261,
0.0449525341,
-0.0086339014,
0.0093541192,
-0.0541813076,
0.0003209378,
-0.0317730196,
0.0201889537,
0.0180725101,
0.0357838571,
-0.0275727082,
0.0098809805,
0.0131792584,
0.0045862519,
-0.0132869128,
-0.0172308236,
0.0019494399,
0.0288983546,
-0.0396989584,
-0.0423314087,
0.0240241885,
0.0391669385,
0.0708972216,
-0.0079303673,
-0.0139680589,
-0.0098585077,
0.0018481284,
-0.0090586627,
-0.0097186258,
0.0621242672,
-0.0224768817,
0.0177631769,
0.0187997073,
-0.005088829,
-0.0057012052,
0.0442436822,
0.0184536371,
0.0511626676,
0.0107673453,
-0.0270958245,
-0.0258043613,
0.0392810106,
0.012496613,
-0.0897589549,
0.0166393556,
0.0008897622,
-0.0305611789,
0.0112436842,
-0.0059328489,
0.0143236183,
0.0273706559,
-0.0769543201,
-0.00795162,
0.0403685309,
-0.0271008089,
-0.0101322392,
0.0171057303,
0.01941365,
0.0068700034,
-0.0256344341,
-0.0371164046,
-0.0063234079,
-0.0099915378,
-0.0199791286,
0.0080290036,
-0.0076997238,
0.0205438174,
0.0358510502,
-0.0774735659,
-0.0195357334,
-0.0439587533,
-0.005815322,
-0.003114769,
-0.0069153714,
-0.0196424481,
0.0092327222,
-0.0393307135,
0.0566610433,
-0.074120827,
-0.0080983927,
-0.0218900554,
-0.0673795417,
0.0407717153,
0.0365495086,
-0.0264629293,
-0.0362755507,
-0.031642694,
0.0122442357,
0.0065569333,
0.0206613448,
-0.0071745832,
-0.0385551639,
-0.012442396,
-0.0603117459,
-0.023827346,
-0.060220696,
0.0034414418,
0.01458616,
-0.006204213,
-0.0444291979,
0.0245870557,
0.0472352616,
-0.0213894323,
-0.0087193977,
-0.029778339,
0.0277445465,
0.0829222053,
0.0116196023,
-0.0166894849,
0.0699341223,
0.0103111966,
0.0016888249,
0.0351973362,
-0.0151787978,
0.0120832305,
0.0231846534,
-0.0262067094,
0.0129369562,
-0.0267360378,
-0.0132872621,
-0.022319166,
-0.0004230474,
0.0430957004,
0.0692169294,
-0.0193881858,
0.0079794796,
0.0483510345,
0.0283073913,
-0.0551903173,
0.0488631502,
0.0509651788,
0.0349240713,
-0.0205039605,
0.0477283671,
-0.0187288802,
0.0176877622,
-0.0362686366,
-0.0133659849,
0.0277717151,
0.0623766072,
-0.0282752104,
-0.0379759967,
-0.0304825716,
0.023386905,
0.0488165058,
-0.0147073809,
0.0014553351,
-0.027666688,
0.0198729187,
0.0377118811,
0.0398723409,
-0.0764977485,
0.0008599455,
-0.0218132138,
0.011423911,
0.0599708036,
-0.0205264445,
0.0328237005,
-0.0283297505,
-0.0237225108,
0.0113230599,
0.0706803501,
0.0843321607,
0.0003488726,
-0.0522224419,
-0.0449360162,
-0.0206984114,
-0.0067237611,
0.0074885446,
0.0436112769,
0.0429664627,
0.0324227549,
0.0437232554,
0.0184960626,
-0.0576161593,
-0.0027873274,
-0.0450401083,
0.0157236457,
-0.0090006497,
-0.0087884609,
0.0182530601,
0.0396854281,
-0.0487472489,
0.0097605092,
-0.0307151154,
-0.0109687662,
-0.0181594808,
0.0861973986,
-0.0643705428,
-0.0088036396,
0.0214883164,
-0.061993286,
-0.0123350359,
-0.0463643819,
-0.0064200172,
-0.0240469575,
0.0301190019,
0.0022873287,
-0.0264246557,
-0.0373934247,
-0.0118352352,
-0.0358370319,
0.0092602046,
-0.0180667546,
0.0416752435,
0.001522147,
0.0050793854,
0.0392208695,
-0.0018060204,
0.044057589,
-0.0490644686,
-0.0433266796,
0.0260717869,
0.0259382185,
0.0038466728,
0.0791101009,
0.0227098763,
-0.0263149217,
-0.0007851206,
-0.1320657134,
-0.0086127296,
-0.0212262776,
0.0029996352,
0.0382737033,
-0.0057890732,
-0.0257371422,
0.0246468894,
-0.0843058825,
-0.0352462716,
0.001217102,
0.0407954305,
0.0273361281,
-0.0235844757,
0.0370383821,
-0.0125746205,
0.0063990392,
-0.0203419514,
0.0015505786,
0.0405394994,
-0.0157526154,
-0.0493337475,
0.0174898338,
-0.0675491467,
-0.0341158025,
-0.003750504,
-0.060712941,
0.0199153256,
0.044254154,
0.0496617295,
0.0130198197,
0.0453719459,
0.0022261715,
0.050291311,
-0.0237033069,
-0.0053149136,
-0.0237846207,
0.0105643533,
0.0438435972,
0.0128906313,
-0.1138044298,
-0.0203449689,
0.0497065,
0.0271618478,
-0.0051234239,
-0.0676480606,
0.056473501,
-0.0893608332,
-0.0239493009,
-0.0098013692,
-0.0328807011,
-0.0084466888,
0.0433019102,
-0.0110524148,
-0.0380230807,
0.0624587275,
-0.0060012555,
0.0154075539,
-0.0225798655,
-0.0052777575,
-0.0539104082,
0.0275923647,
-0.0024704512,
0.0457067341,
0.0269414317,
0.0071722586,
-0.0373064987,
-0.026027428,
0.033302132,
-0.0157671068,
-0.0034116197,
-0.0395615883,
-0.0176241361,
-0.0208042637,
-0.0333946347,
-0.0251331013,
-0.050044477,
-0.0271874256,
0.015734639,
0.0602155738,
-0.0028443474,
0.0385747105,
0.0541099049,
0.03487207,
0.005297896,
-0.0501003489,
0.0376397967,
0.018083835,
0.0026277283,
0.0210298933,
-0.0048477254,
0.044064112,
-0.0254805367,
0.0121705532,
0.0168276895,
-0.0177418031,
0.0116322562,
0.0234069359,
-0.0271527395,
0.0130683342,
-0.0192058086,
-0.0720969737,
-0.0155717926,
0.0816365257,
-0.0425837673,
0.0074962578,
0.101969175,
0.0067651556,
-0.0466409586,
-0.0144480113,
-0.0219396092,
0.0430521443,
0.0254872162,
0.0171784237,
-0.0892551839,
0.0422171801,
0.0029333537,
-0.0043316022,
-0.0767673329,
-0.023383392,
-0.0369440354,
-0.1204082891,
0.0383229256,
0.0305168796,
-0.0317815356,
0.0311356261,
-0.0029687157,
-0.0280640051,
0.0164334793,
0.0356005132,
-0.0144269187,
0.002184567,
0.0243723281,
0.0313549228,
-0.0985373035,
-0.0497505777,
0.0126528507,
-0.0343345664,
0.0740923956,
0.0177204218,
0.0606490187,
-0.0036030367,
-0.0131604774,
0.0308818556,
-0.0083220024,
0.0059153163,
-0.0336484723,
0.0241967477,
-0.0079044029,
-0.0137258675,
-0.0413126685,
-0.0065790042,
0.0256306808,
0.0132464152,
0.0351541862,
0.0120080756,
0.0048714569,
-0.0180885047,
-0.0160718709,
0.0429527387,
0.0114546688,
0.0825285688,
0.0191576965,
-0.0518356636,
-0.0120012006,
-0.0330330804,
0.0199896675,
-0.0275092833,
-0.0475350544,
0.0265030507,
-0.0327725336,
-0.0550801717,
-0.0612237118,
-0.0876533538,
-0.0045359987,
-0.0126100611,
0.0200284831,
-0.0187663883,
0.0004348696,
0.0096492553,
0.0142166987,
0.007692887,
-0.0347967483,
0.0220613033,
-0.0039090179,
-0.0299506932,
0.0178801827,
-0.0458733365,
0.009053627,
0.0043950756,
-0.0178994648,
-0.048755154,
0.0120453034,
0.0328768454,
0.0181468874,
0.0357008055,
0.0174452234,
-0.0469516218,
0.0043489709,
0.0215159506,
0.0007102618,
0.0121044759,
-0.0144992499,
0.0446833335,
0.0079650478,
0.0192566179,
0.0002909031,
0.0459283665,
-0.0102885347,
0.014696572,
-0.0176677722,
-0.0383274555,
0.0135317883,
0.0272004139,
0.0049453652,
-0.0413378552,
0.0158102699,
-0.0700766519,
-0.0311152823,
-0.0626993328,
-0.0382130481,
-0.0234437194,
-0.0329334289,
0.0057557784,
-0.0036054973,
-0.0142891817,
-0.0115468763,
-0.0541651696,
0.0192910172,
-0.0145386718,
0.0430407189,
-0.0100156479,
0.0660097525,
-0.0004595803,
-0.0119259506,
-0.0406122841,
0.0098097436,
-0.0018311597,
0.0262111649,
-0.0155781349,
0.0727560148,
-0.0030604685,
-0.021870248,
0.0508481711,
0.0057347137,
-0.0171104409,
-0.0067280512,
-0.0106115751,
0.0173798315,
0.0711975098,
-0.0151839992,
0.0941523835,
-0.0060765357,
-0.0011396725,
-0.0088774739,
0.0313951373,
0.032356821,
-0.0565051399,
0.0104206754,
-0.0276939683,
-0.0572459102,
-0.0122470837,
0.0651442856,
0.0016308991,
0.0075416556,
0.0253067929,
-0.0635908619,
-0.0106784431,
-0.0189170577,
-0.0095237698,
-0.0342997275,
-0.0115240728,
-0.0073958733,
-0.1047790498,
-0.0247388221,
-0.0275170077,
0.0011076042,
0.0144074764,
-0.0224806666,
0.0026203867,
0.0617138557,
-0.0398640744,
-0.0139830718,
-0.0650890991,
0.0076272418,
-0.0646146983,
0.0123241656,
-0.0099906586,
-6.637211385e-33,
-0.0401145406,
-0.0358354338,
0.0116029205,
0.0013397648,
-0.0438600369,
-0.020119762,
-0.0334939323,
0.0297541972,
-0.0040062438,
0.0358558595,
-0.0100589916,
-0.0218217131,
0.0147697171,
-0.0119563164,
0.0281492379,
-0.0078483149,
0.0570377633,
0.0190094355,
-0.0294198561,
0.0383438766,
0.0304248091,
-0.0083710318,
0.0639092177,
-0.0608779304,
0.0545194,
-0.0398718417,
-0.0161326565,
0.011301511,
0.0220272448,
0.0154359899,
-0.0223054551,
0.0573409833,
0.0407708026,
-0.0050691054,
-0.0182693824,
0.0021881703,
0.0080975527,
-0.0310146976,
0.0260346178,
0.023039259,
0.0325512365,
-0.0642398596,
0.0113457022,
-0.0261972118,
-0.0617795438,
0.0353162214,
0.0514220893,
-0.0110417148,
0.0357590877,
-0.005584172,
-0.0593730062,
0.0473263524,
-0.0063951942,
0.0385832489,
-0.0209382102,
0.0713052079,
-0.0106577938,
-0.0276022237,
-0.0353385471,
0.0225639995,
0.0362505354,
0.0167611688,
0.0536757484,
0.011620787,
0.0144088957,
0.0468733795,
0.0593444631,
0.0811846331,
-0.0374451689,
-0.041618064,
0.0199036542,
-0.0354269743,
0.0078741843,
0.1030788645,
-0.0174135361,
-0.0542856418,
-0.0386708155,
0.0024583475,
0.0676173717,
0.0053824885,
0.0448268689,
-0.0422115736,
-0.0306939632,
-0.0593325421,
-0.0217936616,
-0.0502809882,
-0.0244943425,
-0.0608418658,
0.0340503678,
-0.0163181946,
-0.0033190637,
-0.0291062519,
0.0401539616,
-0.0130764861,
-0.0185219813,
0.0284151863,
-0.0501371585,
-0.0273888037,
-0.0075446507,
0.0344401076,
-0.0514363907,
-0.0246363785,
-0.0209748466,
0.0312257949,
-0.0011478935,
0.02791081,
0.0089495666,
0.0051480583,
-0.0579661578,
-0.0062678489,
-0.0248701014,
0.0200311802,
-0.0189441182,
-0.004203734,
-0.0013523856,
0.004161885,
-0.0179885104,
0.0067881094,
0.060245648,
0.0267192349,
-0.0541132949,
-0.0380251408,
-0.0073621664,
0.0240630955,
-0.0272257496,
0.0360017866,
0.006826546,
0.0396935828,
0.040324904,
-0.0258180015,
-0.0237947349,
-0.0504706725,
2.7e-7,
0.0134606576,
0.0805651993,
-0.0360947996,
0.0014451644,
0.0365769975,
0.0295804925,
0.0001918906,
0.0083431229,
0.057762906,
0.0208849739,
0.0016863792,
-0.0124538168,
0.0439737625,
0.0941914916,
-0.090510644,
0.0320178531,
-0.065583244,
0.0165169407,
-0.0308957044,
0.0244170856,
0.0290870015,
0.0144782616,
0.0050637559,
0.0037394396,
-0.0535139479,
-0.0133983856,
0.07208056,
-0.0642054603,
-0.0264738128,
0.0478112884,
0.0531873666,
-0.003901398,
0.0287604388,
0.0188268293,
0.0148125533,
0.0128464699,
0.0200275891,
0.043229159,
0.0208622105,
0.0125530027,
0.027855562,
0.0219464749,
0.0058951299,
-0.0969946608,
0.0392539948,
-0.0072287512,
-0.0306269154,
-0.0565893427,
-0.0162652954,
-0.0268223472,
0.0563773476,
-0.0333418995,
-0.0381396934,
0.0406474955,
0.0081901085,
-0.0015683017,
0.0007851273,
-0.0101621766,
-0.0468610562,
-0.0317104198,
-0.0187765453,
-0.070526503,
-0.0131426547,
0.0316534303,
-0.0459045507,
0.0056659668,
0.0476816185,
2.229622354e-34,
0.0231692232,
-0.0054456345,
0.0036195952,
-0.0059096129,
0.0543217696,
0.0394177772,
0.0177555196,
-0.0003401471,
0.0066636433,
0.006512797,
-0.0191543177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06981v1
|
AraSpell: A Deep Learning Approach for Arabic Spelling Correction
| 2024-05-11T10:36:28 | 2024-05-11T10:36:28 |
Mahmoud Salhab, Faisal Abu-Khzam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Spelling correction is the task of identifying spelling mistakes, typos, and
grammatical mistakes in a given text and correcting them according to their
context and grammatical structure. This work introduces "AraSpell," a framework
for Arabic spelling correction using different seq2seq model architectures such
as Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) and Transformer with artificial data
generation for error injection, trained on more than 6.9 Million Arabic
sentences. Thorough experimental studies provide empirical evidence of the
effectiveness of the proposed approach, which achieved 4.8% and 1.11% word
error rate (WER) and character error rate (CER), respectively, in comparison
with labeled data of 29.72% WER and 5.03% CER. Our approach achieved 2.9% CER
and 10.65% WER in comparison with labeled data of 10.02% CER and 50.94% WER.
Both of these results are obtained on a test set of 100K sentences.
|
[
0.0398552679,
0.0136240283,
0.0109366933,
0.0191196464,
-0.0305312742,
0.0194711052,
0.0273634866,
-0.0462866351,
-0.019797381,
-0.0620990992,
0.0117895901,
-0.0708160698,
0.0645113438,
0.0045589409,
0.0465476215,
-0.0277470164,
0.0498312414,
-0.0296129081,
-0.0105035473,
0.0087095601,
0.0337802991,
0.0037611532,
-0.0356866457,
0.0212129056,
-0.0222225022,
-0.0215621348,
-0.0100594014,
0.015250179,
0.0134363249,
0.0218681525,
0.03547718,
0.0356632881,
-0.0304451436,
0.0745334625,
0.0000020767,
-0.0515303724,
-0.0313145965,
-0.0346798077,
0.0136849135,
0.0334003977,
0.0228583235,
-0.0352458991,
-0.0886814147,
0.0397275425,
0.0226393454,
0.0021197468,
0.0672728047,
0.06155039,
0.0512538552,
0.0557198487,
-0.0091092223,
-0.04647642,
0.0380127504,
-0.0105197923,
0.0150858536,
-0.0012317013,
0.0232433658,
-0.0449417531,
-0.0414001867,
-0.0081814192,
-0.0638012812,
0.0314743668,
-0.0118489852,
-0.059125714,
-0.0167217851,
-0.0405919701,
0.0289779361,
-0.0270315502,
0.0006815723,
0.0259897616,
-0.0275297929,
-0.0252461694,
-0.0240738802,
0.0218421947,
0.0041433838,
-0.0066087446,
0.0175944138,
0.0347311161,
-0.0282936692,
-0.0007567845,
0.0512037687,
-0.0538637005,
0.0359634459,
0.0225891788,
-0.0322834142,
0.0202969909,
0.0262541268,
-0.0637155771,
-0.0288572442,
0.0081494888,
0.0473889522,
-0.0203444213,
0.050894998,
0.0085115209,
-0.0201351475,
-0.0285217594,
-0.0346415341,
-0.0946733877,
-0.0138688534,
-0.0410924666,
0.0306430534,
0.0120425504,
-0.0126903905,
0.0067836051,
-0.0406867452,
0.0455117449,
0.0501316264,
0.0235859882,
0.0144065507,
0.0009439851,
-0.0359295234,
0.0227926373,
-0.0214234777,
0.0269232523,
-0.0395367481,
0.0135654798,
-0.099235855,
-0.0162139088,
-0.0266002975,
0.0193209853,
0.0220058616,
0.0059171221,
-0.0422518328,
-0.0284536686,
-0.0089613637,
0.0062334985,
0.041558817,
0.0290308632,
-0.0241878293,
-0.0661582351,
0.0233103074,
0.0040073795,
0.0449522212,
0.0145666171,
0.0096506942,
0.0312078986,
-0.0135469502,
-0.0445693322,
-0.0424422324,
0.0230356846,
-0.0158207659,
0.0037480686,
-0.0690378472,
-0.081918247,
-0.010238668,
-0.0515649505,
0.0004936198,
-0.0097746318,
0.0063693943,
0.0356517956,
0.0007056841,
0.1029622406,
-0.0395530351,
0.0121564027,
0.0567497872,
-0.0072223581,
0.0555729121,
-0.0208694711,
0.0448192842,
-0.0159688182,
0.0144382529,
0.0070070345,
0.0652571991,
0.0253082123,
-0.0530386083,
-0.0286997985,
-0.0070974664,
-0.0883866549,
-0.0237235036,
0.0661833063,
0.0188049357,
0.0842864662,
-0.0081814425,
0.0236031469,
0.0634600967,
-0.0101298252,
0.0333598927,
0.0603542291,
0.0039075655,
-0.0316796377,
0.0214777179,
-0.0160694495,
-0.0212985966,
0.0050545195,
0.0064347945,
0.0039295969,
0.0159422942,
0.0299616084,
-0.0244319756,
-0.0572071634,
-0.0127400076,
-0.0187346209,
0.0111149885,
-0.0348550379,
0.0700238571,
0.0136158634,
-0.0775644332,
-0.0107239811,
-0.0249528568,
-0.0315694921,
0.0156592689,
-0.0318819433,
-0.000797577,
0.099661462,
0.0502438247,
0.0035204755,
-0.0342599601,
-0.0324216411,
-0.0467111543,
0.0556000695,
0.0275474489,
-0.0215422343,
0.0033765214,
-0.0620065257,
-0.021630032,
0.0346149318,
-0.0014980887,
-0.0145845506,
0.0113637233,
0.0485982224,
0.0121950004,
-0.0111753633,
-0.0469263457,
0.0275010411,
-0.0163747165,
-0.0199105348,
-0.002146058,
0.0364506282,
-0.0315095745,
0.0256845616,
-0.0212774687,
0.0024550522,
-0.0242156982,
-0.031524539,
-0.0456804037,
-0.0231847744,
-0.0413119346,
-0.0225141887,
0.0509483889,
-0.077420935,
-0.0075297887,
0.0640097484,
-0.0283920672,
-0.0536608361,
0.0178067461,
-0.0525693409,
0.0016906944,
-0.0824803412,
0.0520443134,
0.0121841682,
0.0059757726,
-0.0189183075,
0.0097690644,
-0.0171711296,
-0.0050964793,
-0.0096634431,
0.0096454853,
-0.0082721766,
0.0039100219,
-0.0538147688,
-0.0332480483,
-0.006552272,
0.0318920985,
0.029966576,
0.0174661353,
-0.0154561279,
-0.0369472764,
-0.021857867,
-0.0119440211,
-0.0290265307,
0.0025160715,
0.016719291,
0.034279,
0.0101164235,
-0.0239373744,
-0.0247251466,
-0.0002232163,
0.025541041,
0.0070337267,
0.0993676856,
-0.0426184051,
-0.0151617061,
-0.0596318692,
-0.0220594816,
-0.0183448419,
-0.0183934551,
0.0319499485,
-0.0662769303,
-0.0274040569,
0.0158821009,
0.0086060502,
0.056391079,
0.0419588797,
-0.0595078543,
0.0031317032,
-0.0204103086,
0.0400371067,
0.0334867239,
0.0218054019,
0.0211088862,
-0.0074235983,
0.0006429616,
0.0008867771,
0.002482227,
-0.0036294707,
-0.0169926565,
-0.0054367306,
-0.028023541,
-0.0158792585,
0.0432636775,
-0.0211176071,
-0.0043272139,
-0.0165597145,
-0.0049793315,
-0.0061811567,
0.0250736419,
-0.0039755804,
-0.0148824267,
0.006501406,
0.0364998914,
-0.0259404574,
-0.0254982766,
0.00808693,
0.004393999,
0.0340277962,
-0.0398708992,
0.0028130491,
-0.0123082502,
-0.0709559321,
-0.0350396819,
0.0276315268,
-0.0592529438,
-0.0723769143,
-0.0484069735,
-0.0281860698,
0.0307886861,
-0.0256782658,
0.0484701246,
-0.0547381788,
0.0133216316,
-0.0182383135,
-0.0233791322,
-0.0350852683,
0.0411671624,
-0.0327741355,
-0.0321259722,
0.0353516787,
-0.0303319301,
-0.0361167826,
-0.000777078,
0.0118306065,
0.0838487968,
0.0008933389,
-0.0257020127,
0.0030625712,
-0.0141187077,
0.026442552,
-0.0121177742,
0.0614284985,
-0.0052994243,
0.0559771135,
0.0495660156,
-0.0284047276,
0.0086203376,
-0.0537417866,
-0.0071638683,
0.0215659887,
-0.0461658016,
-0.0274164956,
-0.0254941694,
0.0071040834,
-0.0636117086,
-0.038353797,
0.0985535979,
0.0064539965,
-0.0496635996,
-0.0329887681,
0.0095812771,
-0.0526940897,
-0.0055415435,
-0.0072712321,
-0.0920057893,
-0.0174119715,
0.0660035461,
0.0075470647,
-0.0006577434,
-0.0210476965,
0.0566746518,
-0.1146948189,
0.0279301368,
0.0139854876,
-0.0172371455,
-0.0930634513,
0.0211532079,
-0.0023554892,
0.0045769922,
0.0368869044,
0.0133406343,
-0.0270465557,
-0.0194418598,
0.0474813916,
-0.0476515256,
-0.0764971301,
-0.0196367186,
-0.0562257953,
0.0256000739,
0.0547757931,
0.0118043665,
-0.0205680113,
-0.0473242179,
0.0013009547,
0.0239315983,
-0.0439486206,
0.0086089764,
0.0207548495,
-0.0005667388,
-0.0339098722,
-0.0447590165,
0.0043385993,
-0.0598433502,
0.0226092357,
-0.0396569259,
0.0280137137,
-0.0183448233,
0.0306518953,
0.0099809673,
-0.0032757011,
-0.0001565369,
0.014950159,
-0.0116734942,
-0.0334248431,
-0.0721888095,
-0.0150101911,
-0.0033598111,
-0.0988045707,
-0.0023753592,
0.0358434431,
-0.0043301922,
-0.029367961,
-0.0899822786,
-0.062738575,
0.0131142288,
0.0075823078,
0.0447956957,
0.0161376707,
0.0097937873,
0.0216977801,
-0.0258511379,
-0.079992868,
0.0110500194,
0.0297057386,
-0.0648839027,
0.0153737692,
-0.0338781811,
-0.0199873559,
0.0327856503,
-0.011419096,
-0.0434325859,
-0.0090547409,
0.0712164193,
0.0066478234,
0.0053918497,
0.0017812895,
-0.0222256817,
-0.0537029281,
0.0472925156,
0.0314591452,
0.042844642,
0.0236570835,
0.0174406469,
-0.0255016275,
-0.0151988538,
0.0248798355,
0.0131356409,
0.0045901067,
-0.0124869486,
0.0071668182,
0.0064500691,
-0.0412263051,
0.0065584364,
-0.0266107079,
0.0572247133,
-0.0148733258,
-0.0112428749,
-0.0687599778,
0.0202283096,
0.0202222671,
0.0313014351,
-0.0159615353,
0.0361874662,
0.0300014112,
0.0332204029,
-0.0046756077,
-0.0045204251,
0.0146943647,
-0.0397455133,
0.0198641215,
0.0257052202,
0.0150388302,
0.0479558334,
-0.0000476249,
0.0142258182,
0.0087395087,
-0.0160587952,
0.0380285457,
0.0334291235,
-0.0057499809,
-0.0223352723,
0.0011634594,
0.0530410074,
0.0017933227,
0.0435201041,
0.0133556295,
0.0171540827,
-0.0399515033,
0.0309880581,
0.0922922865,
-0.0150093203,
0.0431488305,
-0.0040817466,
0.0027073252,
-0.0327707976,
0.0340794027,
-0.0087535223,
0.030447213,
0.0047316938,
-0.0119436989,
0.0269529354,
0.0018107255,
0.0202757549,
0.0061811372,
0.0286644101,
0.0107320407,
-0.0310475565,
-0.0045458339,
0.00482766,
-0.0101935156,
-0.0521029942,
-0.059414845,
-0.0380478688,
-0.0100834211,
-0.0883299783,
0.0402506441,
0.0474460162,
0.0244886354,
0.0326689109,
0.0039487747,
0.0417835601,
0.0369335972,
0.0208667126,
-0.0583048798,
0.0003937701,
0.0455076061,
-0.0488498583,
0.0159910377,
-5.994180711e-33,
0.0202016551,
0.0019916459,
0.0090414109,
-0.0134463226,
0.000691533,
0.000783444,
-0.0176608153,
-0.0154459616,
-0.0054710354,
0.0691548735,
-0.0203039758,
0.0307464451,
0.0232517887,
0.0153974248,
0.0638778061,
0.0085411584,
0.0738270804,
0.0134572154,
0.0171281472,
-0.0148561485,
0.0298679154,
0.0854597092,
0.1196028069,
-0.0283741206,
0.0109287268,
0.0043133302,
-0.0299134608,
0.0299289282,
0.0061854008,
0.0507484227,
0.0190281719,
0.043638546,
-0.0042374465,
-0.0065124151,
-0.0073175202,
0.0101988446,
-0.0956695303,
-0.0190549511,
-0.0375200324,
0.0710917413,
-0.0398743451,
-0.0264986381,
0.0423976928,
0.0038231378,
-0.04644721,
0.0150836008,
0.0303607974,
-0.0195661001,
0.0188141484,
-0.0189788062,
-0.0641372055,
0.0119296191,
0.0278366599,
0.001486916,
-0.005499559,
0.0307224113,
-0.0216266233,
-0.0121581163,
-0.1168502346,
0.0035736437,
0.0290057547,
0.0508171096,
0.0225225165,
0.0172846206,
-0.081883207,
0.0071263197,
0.0026702264,
-0.0015866072,
0.0216979515,
0.0284148064,
0.034022402,
-0.0339831598,
0.0744251013,
0.0605243631,
0.0490079932,
-0.060269706,
-0.0632164851,
0.0339414701,
-0.0311604682,
0.0710313767,
-0.0016963661,
-0.0266069565,
-0.042772904,
-0.0004232773,
0.0163193922,
0.0283194706,
-0.01296244,
0.0164517201,
0.0315136984,
0.03596472,
0.0096104164,
0.0450615026,
-0.0473956019,
-0.033329878,
0.0191831421,
-0.0404492803,
0.0131100276,
0.0035537949,
-0.0340030305,
-0.0148174008,
0.0053847111,
-0.028791409,
0.0008354064,
0.0760366842,
-0.0009288225,
0.027671501,
0.0455436595,
0.0684142858,
-0.0909703448,
0.013474483,
-0.0060602678,
0.0488544703,
0.041714821,
0.0346683152,
-0.0293432567,
-0.0467017591,
0.0128695285,
0.0126833878,
-0.0025996394,
0.0234167352,
0.004049948,
-0.0445966981,
-0.0147620272,
-0.0217351615,
-0.0180563554,
-0.0076610893,
-0.0622260235,
-0.000849964,
-0.007361881,
-0.0658991709,
0.0119643854,
-0.0085633611,
2.773e-7,
0.0178467724,
0.0644187033,
0.0565752275,
-0.0321609601,
-0.0059959576,
0.0105893565,
0.0032460964,
0.0493432507,
-0.0127516827,
0.0553886667,
0.0440188088,
-0.0180172697,
0.0480801761,
-0.0229097139,
-0.0767123625,
-0.0341795683,
-0.0506707504,
0.0580882207,
0.0044256612,
-0.0096101221,
0.0110164536,
0.0901338235,
-0.0099209072,
-0.048445709,
-0.0181743596,
-0.0158527251,
0.0208322015,
0.0169503968,
0.0018322399,
0.0058281389,
0.0996162072,
0.0304134712,
0.0560128428,
-0.0107749244,
-0.0465385467,
-0.0196422916,
0.0057947561,
0.0223591533,
-0.0314074829,
0.0338051803,
0.0116247963,
-0.0038388625,
0.0002703033,
-0.0259640552,
0.0183955804,
0.0129147097,
0.051495418,
0.0135338893,
-0.0131529076,
0.0302557889,
0.0514442809,
-0.0435628816,
-0.0057320045,
0.0043135984,
0.0506531298,
0.0292793885,
-0.0258666798,
-0.0348564237,
0.0340030864,
-0.0160993673,
0.0493638925,
0.027338637,
0.0198876914,
-0.031128943,
0.0018420623,
0.0121012982,
-0.0088686934,
2.193390266e-34,
0.0214531627,
-0.0030656143,
0.0288881157,
-0.0007659581,
0.0174221378,
-0.0044569555,
-0.001893767,
0.0190979168,
-0.0021611385,
-0.0180552267,
-0.0320295915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06932v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06932v1
|
Piccolo2: General Text Embedding with Multi-task Hybrid Loss Training
| 2024-05-11T06:32:08 | 2024-05-11T06:32:08 |
Junqin Huang, Zhongjie Hu, Zihao Jing, Mengya Gao, Yichao Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this report, we introduce Piccolo2, an embedding model that surpasses
other models in the comprehensive evaluation over 6 tasks on CMTEB benchmark,
setting a new state-of-the-art. Piccolo2 primarily leverages an efficient
multi-task hybrid loss training approach, effectively harnessing textual data
and labels from diverse downstream tasks. In addition, Piccolo2 scales up the
embedding dimension and uses MRL training to support more flexible vector
dimensions. The latest information of piccolo models can be accessed via:
https://huggingface.co/sensenova/
|
[
-0.0193315204,
-0.0176920649,
0.0239756573,
0.0451560803,
0.0122780697,
0.0192327723,
-0.0009194382,
-0.0132244248,
-0.0024986719,
0.0116882958,
-0.0523181334,
-0.0368879959,
-0.0170916952,
-0.0004662277,
0.0508463942,
-0.0154380258,
0.0043938751,
0.0378806405,
-0.0013882907,
0.0265036803,
0.043689888,
0.0124600148,
0.0220197085,
0.0434091315,
-0.0184937641,
-0.0355739892,
-0.003079955,
0.0431906693,
0.0419327058,
-0.0371633358,
0.0297122356,
0.0121430065,
0.0741289258,
0.0400164351,
0.0000018104,
0.0206300002,
0.0041857166,
0.0183824971,
-0.0366299152,
0.0140221454,
0.0636456311,
-0.002653227,
0.0120316213,
0.0094107063,
-0.0003959135,
-0.0070010438,
0.0397723988,
0.0745247081,
0.0525358617,
0.0828547403,
-0.0101921968,
0.0071133273,
0.0360601917,
-0.0776307359,
0.0354340188,
-0.009614096,
0.0100588324,
0.0011853649,
-0.0217924956,
0.046230454,
-0.0040367614,
0.0394686908,
0.0454352088,
0.012935509,
-0.0009549547,
0.0485857613,
0.0267033912,
0.0080123954,
0.0183295347,
0.0839320347,
-0.0193292908,
0.0011718371,
-0.0120978039,
-0.0123086479,
-0.0046121296,
-0.0554656126,
-0.0473803543,
-0.01192642,
0.0025933585,
0.0216635726,
-0.042014569,
0.0468032435,
0.0413232706,
-0.0157934204,
0.0254992433,
-0.0232793093,
-0.0214756969,
-0.0519802012,
0.0003540266,
-0.0194765888,
0.0077399239,
0.0347504765,
0.016348185,
-0.0181117877,
-0.0058941199,
0.0050543277,
-0.0413745865,
-0.0733670071,
0.0196763892,
-0.0823990479,
0.0594854988,
0.0161576048,
-0.0305400398,
0.0711650252,
-0.0305901952,
0.0302538518,
-0.0400212854,
0.0376866572,
-0.018383747,
-0.0087098135,
-0.0576633178,
-0.0290331449,
-0.0246798526,
0.0178362858,
-0.0360896587,
-0.043237973,
0.0043080989,
0.0200623237,
-0.0211490858,
0.004669528,
0.0471131057,
0.0262304619,
-0.0550652482,
-0.0244130436,
0.0172438696,
0.0325722806,
-0.0333272703,
0.0136705823,
0.0202039797,
0.0232727677,
-0.0384667777,
0.0336004943,
0.0038305758,
-0.0412983447,
0.013234281,
0.0435190946,
-0.0474508703,
-0.0383489132,
-0.0082279257,
-0.0067468262,
-0.0348388888,
-0.0672974065,
-0.0045919931,
-0.0342574604,
0.0586508252,
-0.0582064614,
-0.003885169,
-0.022904709,
0.0072687315,
0.0260459427,
-0.0189426877,
0.0756165534,
0.0464526303,
-0.0578216538,
-0.0051583876,
0.0529474951,
-0.0213701539,
0.0871124864,
-0.0198545549,
0.0513612032,
0.0127231693,
0.0447304323,
-0.0433063619,
-0.0031675862,
0.0228345413,
0.006754789,
0.02493174,
0.0348333381,
0.0386245176,
0.0723647252,
0.0517041273,
0.0211950652,
-0.0471965335,
-0.0311253257,
0.058926791,
0.0036631834,
0.0273745041,
-0.0200213008,
0.0468838885,
0.0385547094,
-0.0191668719,
-0.0255140364,
-0.0265250094,
0.0283855889,
0.041243922,
-0.0112050036,
0.0149003295,
0.0414395407,
-0.0495123751,
-0.01310369,
0.0040743644,
-0.0347949117,
-0.0180881545,
-0.0299550612,
0.0468031429,
-0.0171385668,
-0.0571334437,
0.0200709254,
0.0345723033,
-0.0273995157,
-0.0184644312,
-0.0007527677,
0.0009630942,
0.0479302853,
0.0305240881,
-0.0747680366,
-0.0409333296,
-0.0320534408,
0.0806032866,
0.0302728415,
0.0058249054,
-0.0143391127,
0.0748627856,
-0.0844705701,
-0.0198366642,
-0.0206303615,
0.0332622118,
0.0352034383,
-0.0075661559,
0.0307970829,
0.0247270297,
-0.0442417376,
0.0242860299,
0.0289487448,
-0.0232379194,
-0.0147207426,
0.0030530097,
0.0243514627,
-0.0243693423,
-0.0017035085,
-0.0247442778,
0.0093973437,
0.0495770797,
-0.0507735163,
-0.0500014946,
-0.018697178,
-0.0466874056,
-0.0806625187,
0.032080669,
-0.0448270813,
-0.0077576758,
0.0523575135,
-0.0409281924,
-0.011899611,
-0.0257324502,
-0.0012111763,
-0.0028680833,
-0.0120747359,
-0.031941995,
0.0013890963,
0.0009728922,
-0.0293826088,
0.0487013124,
-0.0287730377,
0.003700699,
-0.0093481475,
-0.0149714518,
0.0096282316,
-0.0387486368,
-0.0309305191,
-0.0047083581,
0.0016731013,
0.0386775769,
-0.0283655878,
-0.0003046267,
-0.0091234716,
-0.0429250896,
-0.0568614192,
0.026308395,
-0.0319837034,
-0.0124692591,
0.0050685839,
-0.0272881854,
0.0207007509,
-0.0220895559,
-0.0320949033,
-0.0228538159,
-0.0460822992,
0.0242146645,
0.0107541317,
-0.0126695232,
0.0452810489,
-0.0042002462,
-0.0089113545,
-0.0034749112,
0.0538847558,
-0.0433854721,
-0.0208668914,
-0.0105741564,
-0.030984981,
0.0246048048,
-0.0203647967,
-0.0520983823,
0.0108762989,
-0.0261432659,
-0.0044433963,
0.0375920646,
0.083812207,
-0.0280499049,
0.040636085,
-0.0062395129,
0.0193816833,
-0.0142474882,
0.0307385139,
0.0065589361,
0.0528296567,
-0.0454670079,
-0.0106954519,
-0.001001234,
0.0381853133,
-0.0295251664,
0.0257725716,
-0.0577365309,
-0.0179142151,
-0.004291032,
-0.0172116663,
-0.0500146225,
0.0275864918,
-0.044405479,
-0.0511468463,
-0.0451838598,
-0.019513566,
0.0123526994,
-0.0279218201,
-0.0363800153,
-0.0416467451,
-0.0441849716,
-0.0210344996,
0.0410153009,
0.001054463,
0.0343812108,
0.0480780527,
-0.0026313828,
-0.0532366857,
0.0376807451,
0.0283206068,
-0.0004565793,
0.0225481484,
0.0346580558,
-0.033094231,
-0.0432437621,
-0.0513469949,
0.0019538437,
-0.0631297976,
0.0300016347,
0.0133136325,
0.0268128533,
-0.011667911,
-0.0752395168,
-0.0276436135,
0.0007743664,
0.0393935852,
-0.0376521498,
-0.0163868815,
-0.0214979779,
0.0737434104,
0.0306435972,
0.0003143632,
-0.0214068796,
-0.0304371566,
0.0168504808,
0.0719782487,
0.0180590823,
-0.0248646084,
-0.010039594,
-0.0161701702,
-0.0123944413,
0.0344950631,
-0.0063717868,
-0.0027607183,
0.0612113327,
-0.046511177,
-0.0128785232,
0.0581267066,
0.014839734,
-0.0514891148,
-0.035077583,
0.0166206006,
0.038138777,
0.0092450306,
-0.0010412371,
-0.0500243455,
-0.0452561341,
0.0012093481,
0.0242199525,
0.0609400645,
0.0122749237,
-0.0063909376,
-0.0312375464,
0.009367438,
0.0019046358,
-0.0328124985,
-0.0350054651,
-0.0121278176,
-0.0233070701,
-0.0218895562,
0.0107554821,
-0.023590818,
-0.0046900236,
-0.0310099404,
0.0389903598,
-0.009877312,
-0.0567524396,
-0.0007159279,
-0.0464308821,
0.0309232678,
0.0018966856,
0.0573971383,
0.0255737565,
0.0091093304,
0.0102607077,
0.0208275877,
-0.0363476947,
0.0209828354,
0.0829368606,
-0.0301399734,
0.012395991,
-0.0272865891,
0.0049161515,
-0.0094882697,
0.0034412085,
0.0136125293,
0.1132201776,
0.0283931773,
0.0067021651,
-0.0319883078,
-0.021967655,
0.0160197187,
0.0739552304,
0.0216866154,
-0.02602138,
-0.0397945791,
-0.0183420908,
0.0166019518,
-0.0490005463,
-0.0353081562,
0.0063229147,
-0.0108840698,
-0.0187113956,
-0.0393215902,
-0.0552822277,
0.0202168617,
0.0592480823,
-0.0298326984,
-0.013162205,
-0.0508413762,
-0.0306088813,
-0.0892112255,
0.0157947801,
-0.0421852246,
0.0456868857,
-0.0245210603,
0.0341904946,
0.0236382186,
-0.0037445426,
-0.0301029775,
0.0042884136,
-0.1280212104,
-0.0466521494,
-0.0628170446,
0.0190097112,
0.0056436849,
0.0339847431,
-0.0181093719,
-0.0136702228,
0.0767201632,
-0.0017410602,
-0.0579224713,
0.0025782546,
0.0807161406,
-0.0301272646,
-0.0116432458,
0.0413724557,
-0.0096108392,
-0.0062975115,
-0.0065733944,
0.0057967189,
0.0178300943,
0.046149008,
0.0080092596,
-0.0991313308,
0.0341839008,
0.0210876744,
-0.0115057454,
-0.0534622893,
0.0230047908,
0.0022469237,
-0.0213122759,
-0.0380276963,
0.020685859,
0.0537059233,
0.0060963137,
-0.0008596987,
0.0246711802,
0.0565430783,
0.0444435813,
-0.0530724376,
0.0179385003,
0.0061886818,
0.0078607965,
0.0326119699,
0.0460643172,
-0.0220625568,
-0.0071796938,
-0.0279060695,
0.0044799354,
-0.0190139897,
0.0326503329,
0.0180673897,
-0.0026321071,
-0.0084267454,
0.0676798522,
-0.0471500605,
-0.0040047741,
-0.0377201252,
-0.007837343,
0.0464098901,
0.0058833603,
0.0359829962,
0.0029593215,
-0.0249288641,
-0.0264179856,
0.0067237588,
-0.0210968833,
0.0053612976,
0.0463666208,
0.0114693595,
-0.0193533879,
-0.0179789457,
0.0878295302,
0.0309087839,
0.0101599293,
0.0205780491,
-0.0036552101,
-0.0446202047,
-0.0239810534,
0.0334049016,
0.0789031163,
0.0028381296,
-0.030014094,
-0.0228876695,
-0.0409018248,
0.0001340687,
-0.0360742398,
-0.0432371497,
0.0177965723,
0.028294079,
0.0102584958,
0.0169956442,
0.011098302,
0.0107428189,
-0.0139752328,
0.0060339351,
-0.0107221073,
-0.0005333006,
-5.717392933e-33,
-0.0170732941,
0.0188218746,
0.0105213681,
-0.04114094,
-0.033854153,
0.0470805466,
-0.029945856,
-0.0135981338,
0.0034936143,
0.0324178226,
0.022072915,
-0.0024984137,
0.0098153949,
0.0475539528,
-0.0250038728,
-0.0145888915,
0.0410382561,
0.0026430569,
0.0049757687,
0.0229146648,
0.021684261,
0.0261818208,
0.0305490531,
-0.0381359681,
0.00144415,
0.018681908,
-0.0109808408,
0.0128720133,
0.0186668113,
0.0605692081,
-0.0320514366,
0.0308588278,
0.0140939206,
-0.0676840395,
-0.0463851541,
0.0483645424,
-0.1056792215,
-0.000577639,
-0.0593476743,
-0.0092015238,
-0.0498422012,
0.0102274707,
-0.0012501527,
0.0007042174,
0.0796009898,
-0.0484582856,
0.0493748039,
0.0032304421,
-0.043985147,
-0.017756965,
-0.0367945172,
0.0366797671,
0.0022079421,
-0.0217800476,
0.0354718901,
0.038071733,
0.0687311739,
0.0358437635,
-0.0741177574,
-0.023241967,
-0.0979797393,
0.0124811511,
-0.025433382,
0.0195931997,
-0.0109451581,
0.0535589568,
0.0345066227,
0.0198997483,
-0.0251258928,
-0.0236588512,
0.0330838822,
0.0494916998,
0.0659534782,
0.0541472472,
0.0124669541,
0.0136537226,
-0.0552647002,
0.0172737241,
0.0695493743,
0.0039206301,
0.0148316883,
0.0596151613,
-0.0468652025,
-0.0246956237,
-0.0012143847,
-0.0036898803,
-0.0204856154,
-0.0188963395,
0.0610663183,
0.0561907366,
0.0162914824,
0.0304239076,
0.0194860175,
-0.0269880351,
0.0050970921,
0.0376086943,
0.008322035,
0.0172382724,
0.0072102407,
0.018747475,
-0.0420666374,
-0.007959703,
0.0368472338,
0.0139999222,
-0.0116935922,
-0.0278185476,
0.0814153776,
0.0046888255,
-0.0845449045,
-0.0135493986,
-0.0548617877,
-0.0259589497,
0.0386345573,
0.0736774132,
0.0277431495,
-0.0241014268,
-0.0268691164,
0.0488732532,
0.03133443,
0.0037489741,
-0.0149803609,
-0.02982256,
0.0010426674,
-0.0040468522,
0.012292468,
0.0057941857,
-0.0500296988,
-0.0171785727,
0.0434232652,
-0.0911427066,
-0.0088341944,
-0.0194278602,
2.334e-7,
0.0124018304,
0.0266868379,
-0.0088639483,
-0.0216441248,
0.0169969089,
0.0609923527,
-0.0354701579,
0.0638922006,
-0.0619235039,
0.0209336709,
0.0118692964,
0.0097224014,
0.0556200035,
0.0140187433,
-0.0964613929,
-0.0060718223,
-0.059400145,
0.0115780765,
-0.0289023854,
-0.0192168169,
0.0207488891,
0.1362897158,
0.0345132686,
0.0128280604,
0.0322638117,
-0.0392361991,
0.0829648748,
-0.0191720221,
0.0416301899,
-0.0175796431,
-0.0308590531,
0.026554266,
-0.0288633108,
-0.0259130914,
-0.0405989848,
0.0182294715,
0.0550267547,
0.0753555819,
0.0022049958,
-0.0586891174,
0.0320563987,
0.0041544796,
-0.0385277234,
-0.0317079984,
0.0606348924,
-0.0428641029,
-0.0224893559,
-0.0103552686,
-0.0182865933,
0.015662482,
0.0336127542,
0.019942455,
-0.0333879702,
0.0034462397,
0.0084061185,
-0.018656699,
-0.0073218495,
-0.1225690767,
-0.0253810398,
0.0010800984,
-0.0711538866,
-0.0156505574,
-0.0601204187,
0.0425108485,
0.0537247509,
-0.0596322827,
0.0061233197,
2.37333664e-34,
0.012858538,
-0.008230078,
0.0141288769,
0.003876263,
0.0035166615,
-0.021780109,
-0.0040285792,
-0.0397771709,
0.0277715474,
-0.0497517474,
-0.0212228708
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06922v1
|
EmoMix-3L: A Code-Mixed Dataset for Bangla-English-Hindi Emotion Detection
| 2024-05-11T05:58:55 | 2024-05-11T05:58:55 |
Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Antara Mahmud, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Code-mixing is a well-studied linguistic phenomenon that occurs when two or
more languages are mixed in text or speech. Several studies have been conducted
on building datasets and performing downstream NLP tasks on code-mixed data.
Although it is not uncommon to observe code-mixing of three or more languages,
most available datasets in this domain contain code-mixed data from only two
languages. In this paper, we introduce EmoMix-3L, a novel multi-label emotion
detection dataset containing code-mixed data from three different languages. We
experiment with several models on EmoMix-3L and we report that MuRIL
outperforms other models on this dataset.
|
[
-0.0029351548,
0.0824348629,
-0.0189550333,
0.0469982363,
0.0052790376,
0.0684162304,
-0.0134416381,
0.0035892006,
0.0305197239,
-0.0220662095,
-0.0725676715,
0.0039062961,
-0.0257724896,
0.0477177426,
-0.014558183,
-0.0191546362,
0.0121354731,
0.0674980804,
0.0483455434,
0.0092956871,
0.0671989471,
0.0519738123,
-0.0026249462,
0.0172747262,
-0.0766168386,
-0.008085357,
-0.0109046316,
0.0365094207,
0.041654557,
-0.021256987,
0.0577814057,
0.0671417862,
0.0041406103,
0.0034436719,
0.0000018378,
-0.0117831035,
-0.0199711788,
-0.0356995165,
-0.005292546,
-0.0325843953,
0.1103608012,
-0.016977258,
-0.0212303363,
0.0220563039,
-0.0279970262,
-0.0477921367,
0.0859361663,
0.037371099,
0.0720380247,
0.0653310642,
-0.0444942601,
-0.0205546301,
-0.0042356621,
0.0012067603,
-0.0148576023,
-0.0028745965,
0.0417179354,
0.0064177644,
0.0166815016,
-0.0475924276,
-0.0343290679,
-0.0185147915,
0.0099673094,
0.0402196757,
-0.0510956496,
-0.0259590019,
-0.0420139544,
-0.0436017811,
0.0030419517,
0.0567682795,
-0.0728786662,
-0.0047385856,
0.0053828117,
-0.0285822973,
-0.0319063962,
-0.0959679037,
0.0290008821,
-0.0088632964,
-0.0424358249,
0.0528601781,
0.0286749713,
0.0186162144,
-0.0043631294,
0.0002326556,
0.0163881369,
0.0403300412,
-0.017487796,
-0.0077765295,
0.0184173118,
0.0030979638,
0.0124184936,
-0.0006880801,
0.009595789,
-0.0286195707,
0.0309235454,
0.0329455696,
-0.0558034778,
-0.0763187557,
-0.0180148426,
-0.0286764577,
-0.0686474368,
0.032758791,
-0.0740767419,
0.0075375121,
-0.0056784027,
0.005435002,
0.0142082982,
0.0025043054,
-0.0304904189,
-0.0505179763,
-0.0145279262,
0.0235819425,
-0.0125945499,
0.0029025106,
-0.0269879121,
0.0195464622,
-0.0983193889,
-0.011855064,
-0.0375634655,
0.0039545936,
-0.0119666224,
-0.0435784869,
0.0208365023,
-0.0055266246,
0.0407137796,
-0.0005103768,
-0.0520353988,
0.0193108041,
0.0052147196,
-0.0928895697,
0.0361769386,
0.0258069355,
-0.0097753424,
-0.0162175559,
0.0306640286,
0.0195830371,
0.0050963876,
-0.0350652225,
-0.0641437545,
0.0003306223,
-0.0311316345,
-0.0387571342,
-0.0021332172,
-0.0498760566,
0.0659552515,
0.0070068198,
0.0419019684,
-0.0704454258,
0.0066227722,
-0.0348498411,
-0.0169849154,
0.0898114666,
-0.0358826183,
-0.0524523295,
-0.0134088267,
0.0081059625,
0.0214814451,
0.0926511288,
-0.0215356909,
0.0165272076,
0.0627482161,
-0.0036620235,
0.0336296968,
0.0399691388,
-0.0093816146,
0.0026281411,
-0.0128151979,
-0.0310759936,
0.0314461142,
-0.0136515098,
0.0181410238,
-0.0108079221,
-0.0336279161,
-0.0081027346,
-0.0556749478,
0.0070178499,
0.0130854137,
0.0014812842,
-0.0216020029,
-0.011324184,
0.0212316643,
-0.0000600259,
0.0163239148,
0.0155638512,
-0.0352017693,
-0.0318867713,
0.0389875509,
0.0379057676,
-0.0393063091,
-0.054951869,
-0.0659734756,
-0.0453590378,
0.0137536628,
0.0105397748,
0.0481167696,
-0.0136120031,
-0.0173290074,
0.0071622636,
0.0685253888,
-0.0515657701,
-0.0043095262,
-0.0197805371,
0.0012220572,
0.0254323501,
-0.0256549343,
-0.0470143706,
0.0151355164,
-0.0045795497,
-0.0041194684,
-0.0047207531,
-0.0014665043,
-0.0155073944,
0.0429783538,
-0.0798153505,
0.0246898346,
0.010842857,
0.0188979693,
0.0364017561,
-0.0138475066,
0.0552337803,
-0.0348626003,
0.0400514305,
0.0041467748,
0.0004135353,
-0.0245391745,
0.0162951015,
0.0015342826,
0.0031652749,
0.0364696383,
0.0040808273,
-0.0295189284,
-0.0234304648,
0.0124356896,
-0.0130180409,
-0.0099828662,
0.0178559404,
0.0172962192,
-0.0949089751,
0.030334834,
-0.0144108618,
-0.0235489719,
0.0114348456,
-0.0392139405,
-0.0245134383,
0.0384879559,
0.0087194499,
0.0441341773,
-0.0283424389,
0.0166964643,
-0.0210258923,
0.0414914675,
-0.003880521,
0.038388662,
0.0098386891,
0.022321105,
-0.0193457212,
0.0051376568,
0.0462047756,
0.0353688002,
-0.0402129516,
0.071066685,
-0.0032476571,
0.0044414308,
-0.0361832157,
0.0079897018,
-0.0594078712,
-0.0578022636,
-0.0684056282,
-0.0191946477,
-0.0259055495,
-0.0120793311,
-0.0067853229,
0.0273273457,
-0.0354036801,
0.0215837564,
-0.0388733149,
0.0162892137,
0.0328136757,
0.009268336,
-0.0073395083,
-0.0154100414,
0.0183769017,
-0.0459131822,
-0.0105190165,
-0.0341798924,
0.0313079655,
-0.022095073,
-0.0281421822,
-0.0260523204,
0.0063175014,
-0.040884044,
0.0235308558,
-0.0277426001,
-0.0503834002,
-0.0064211893,
-0.0343038216,
0.0324973352,
0.0077687944,
-0.0560135841,
0.0653904751,
0.0155101623,
-0.0189474653,
-0.0025077427,
0.041586861,
0.0096567003,
-0.0016950608,
-0.0119203785,
-0.0546495914,
-0.0189852826,
0.0647996515,
-0.0034192693,
-0.0091929808,
-0.0434231721,
-0.0134669114,
-0.0180875827,
-0.0453140698,
-0.0022911092,
-0.0117682889,
-0.0107440539,
0.0618615672,
-0.0006920028,
-0.0496675186,
0.042289231,
0.022827914,
-0.0395513698,
-0.1063884571,
-0.0079450933,
-0.0596083365,
0.0312275179,
-0.0485603362,
0.0136592882,
0.0004738227,
-0.0019897143,
-0.0140506634,
-0.0343002826,
-0.0476625077,
-0.0325265676,
0.0072152154,
-0.0019499668,
-0.024709966,
0.0122547345,
-0.0199273825,
-0.0037430963,
-0.0361295603,
-0.0556521825,
0.0020530075,
0.0437872112,
-0.0032324994,
0.0412723236,
-0.0331904143,
-0.0144073516,
-0.0344823599,
0.0172397979,
-0.0048617134,
0.0345587023,
0.0198469404,
0.024695674,
-0.0454669818,
0.0145078227,
-0.0078163799,
0.00334273,
0.0135171777,
0.0270396806,
0.0405925028,
-0.0043927408,
0.0743332878,
0.0444340631,
0.0688351467,
0.0019919304,
-0.0332641937,
-0.0001281783,
0.0167449433,
0.0519493409,
0.0703961477,
0.0563228093,
-0.054195486,
0.0032107497,
-0.0825995132,
0.030582495,
0.0302523598,
0.0279844347,
-0.0578088127,
-0.0379405506,
-0.0082016513,
-0.0361356661,
0.0022544516,
-0.0157634262,
-0.010875578,
-0.0804622099,
-0.0031790193,
0.0061227423,
-0.0202968661,
-0.0583195165,
0.00528144,
-0.0007720697,
-0.0156330429,
-0.0262265448,
-0.056959562,
0.0206382629,
-0.0396805145,
0.0423435755,
0.0178219974,
-0.0515345,
0.0343018547,
-0.0270971823,
0.0438829176,
0.0073713162,
0.0690795556,
-0.0416715555,
-0.0371606797,
0.0190406665,
0.0183133688,
-0.0415087752,
-0.0250076707,
0.0346107036,
-0.0117834853,
-0.0650457144,
0.0033246374,
0.0103753647,
-0.0529168546,
0.0121112913,
-0.0152609041,
0.0448064283,
0.028155027,
-0.0054870243,
-0.0233462956,
0.0080168433,
0.0265646148,
0.0157260969,
0.0180945918,
-0.0710959136,
0.0205316376,
-0.0227179658,
0.0366876386,
0.0110296411,
-0.0335522853,
0.0423331596,
-0.0346451439,
-0.0536790974,
-0.0309628621,
-0.0839797407,
0.0408347063,
0.041168645,
-0.0262317602,
-0.0046119313,
-0.0285216514,
-0.0035152331,
-0.0260897912,
0.0223941747,
0.034611132,
0.0266610887,
-0.037404675,
-0.005923077,
-0.0019197671,
-0.0138481054,
-0.0021883019,
0.0119236792,
-0.0744086727,
-0.0515447445,
0.0277123656,
-0.0102470899,
0.0133302333,
0.0023800128,
-0.0195695814,
-0.0342443362,
-0.0576036982,
-0.0090850163,
-0.0041736066,
-0.0089817578,
0.0793673992,
0.0027839213,
-0.0087577878,
0.0021372177,
-0.025918575,
0.0377431624,
0.0020891961,
-0.0439199544,
-0.0166239701,
-0.0047348193,
-0.0012150365,
0.008319932,
0.0348365158,
-0.0169000011,
-0.0670228451,
-0.0487345234,
-0.0102241402,
0.0210728329,
-0.0322091691,
-0.0420180894,
-0.0348183513,
0.0199863184,
0.0068643531,
-0.0751669109,
-0.0592648834,
-0.0010796258,
-0.029440878,
0.0379233211,
0.0835597217,
0.0565699413,
0.0506642684,
0.0311191659,
0.037560463,
0.0032380687,
0.0499866419,
-0.0083419774,
0.0005628415,
-0.0202205591,
0.0238267276,
0.0087339934,
-0.0338813961,
0.0678754672,
0.0371516123,
0.062142916,
0.0352513902,
-0.0099949427,
-0.0617153794,
0.0608171262,
-0.0155241163,
0.0554584451,
-0.0176158268,
0.0228521768,
-0.0210792683,
0.0133051062,
-0.0384019613,
-0.0416958034,
0.0328871831,
-0.0080968877,
-0.0385124721,
-0.0144409202,
0.0528417639,
-0.0005688687,
0.0722937137,
-0.0015282843,
0.0213259142,
-0.0112575907,
0.0480477214,
0.110796988,
-0.0090717869,
0.0195027459,
0.0317075625,
-0.0612359568,
-0.0634509176,
0.0423392281,
-0.0607217588,
0.0021518511,
0.0242217891,
0.0240286514,
0.0552167408,
0.0033313637,
0.0458793528,
-0.0316727608,
-0.0017957806,
0.0002359971,
-0.0436306708,
0.0258124322,
-6.005522395e-33,
0.0229807254,
0.0017773779,
-0.0633182377,
-0.0300723948,
0.0089617912,
0.0258982852,
0.0061052125,
0.0144916344,
-0.0310339406,
0.0145454621,
0.0066949166,
0.0521843657,
0.0099766264,
-0.0260799378,
0.0380216837,
-0.0386570692,
0.0047636554,
0.0131883277,
0.0440831855,
0.0025261915,
0.0211571231,
0.0342218466,
0.0722925365,
-0.0573501363,
0.0414187983,
0.010256297,
-0.0458394736,
-0.0122676538,
0.0178385824,
0.077772595,
-0.0219317228,
0.0864763707,
0.0049538123,
0.0075414656,
-0.0062112166,
-0.0197187215,
-0.0075257639,
0.00330755,
-0.0007129829,
0.0622552037,
-0.0210390296,
-0.025546737,
-0.0144840358,
-0.0091116754,
-0.0035714156,
0.0254847147,
0.0239774194,
-0.0134669375,
0.0208603889,
-0.0352517925,
-0.005466341,
0.0485503525,
-0.0039449106,
0.0197067168,
0.065156959,
0.0684216172,
0.0147432284,
0.0450324826,
-0.044174049,
0.0152296657,
-0.0147645203,
0.0120277079,
0.0002639983,
-0.0167342462,
-0.0020835381,
0.0573283173,
0.0518651605,
-0.0143739777,
0.0318143629,
0.0655139461,
0.0281104874,
0.0407024883,
0.0238709282,
0.0571915247,
0.0064757294,
-0.0175696071,
-0.0049862145,
0.0130160693,
0.0470253974,
-0.0129095362,
0.006604129,
0.0310940612,
-0.0601760074,
-0.0330242775,
0.0391679704,
-0.0236708093,
-0.0384006798,
-0.021163458,
0.046096582,
-0.02234664,
0.0193606354,
0.0141969174,
0.0100865606,
-0.0241969824,
-0.0315280594,
0.0379908197,
-0.0328171626,
0.0609305501,
0.0107988091,
0.067440547,
-0.0198206399,
-0.0239507128,
0.0412242226,
0.0175926667,
0.0720174238,
-0.0259238929,
0.0290438253,
0.0069418871,
-0.0839367509,
0.0050749918,
-0.0174102243,
0.0417270251,
-0.0037575935,
0.0288951825,
-0.0382245667,
0.0061011435,
-0.0160805564,
-0.0186157599,
0.0513045304,
0.0179783572,
-0.0328802168,
-0.0408986323,
-0.0284069106,
0.0339891352,
-0.0350256488,
-0.0246972777,
-0.0186065901,
-0.0314520486,
0.0454897061,
-0.0069589484,
-0.0023893181,
-0.0074638552,
2.609e-7,
0.0001015377,
0.0193498023,
-0.0205102768,
-0.0358901173,
-0.0007123164,
0.0312051065,
-0.0644706413,
0.0398651101,
0.0146446126,
-0.0142830657,
-0.0085466327,
-0.0303887781,
0.0685914829,
0.0522396825,
-0.0883836746,
-0.0010075,
0.017627107,
0.0119650941,
-0.0333213024,
0.0232822578,
0.0919280201,
0.1195199639,
0.050693769,
0.0151145058,
0.0011789139,
0.0573462732,
0.0088460529,
-0.0151795661,
0.0191898383,
0.0183776282,
-0.0461265706,
0.0356648415,
0.0014840276,
0.0026059949,
-0.0052101137,
-0.02313748,
0.0611330271,
0.0406598896,
-0.0072335619,
-0.0248086322,
0.058223974,
0.0450982228,
-0.0686797947,
-0.0274336841,
0.0495328605,
0.0292266198,
-0.028849896,
-0.0092920708,
0.0151149668,
0.0174679141,
0.0558846183,
-0.0182629842,
-0.0466305912,
0.0352663957,
0.0050372984,
-0.0623018295,
-0.0257095899,
-0.0730239898,
-0.0215348322,
0.0413200818,
-0.020480454,
-0.0122448308,
-0.0074150362,
0.0553190634,
0.0527935103,
-0.0453762859,
0.0163612198,
2.026536878e-34,
0.0127974059,
-0.0174863115,
0.0092697432,
0.0549733303,
0.0377937965,
-0.0237091929,
-0.0464020558,
0.0013101709,
0.0145095317,
-0.0206746683,
0.0207577776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06919v1
|
Automating Thematic Analysis: How LLMs Analyse Controversial Topics
| 2024-05-11T05:28:25 | 2024-05-11T05:28:25 |
Awais Hameed Khan, Hiruni Kegalle, Rhea D'Silva, Ned Watt, Daniel Whelan-Shamy, Lida Ghahremanlou, Liam Magee
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL, K.4.2
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are promising analytical tools. They can augment
human epistemic, cognitive and reasoning abilities, and support 'sensemaking',
making sense of a complex environment or subject by analysing large volumes of
data with a sensitivity to context and nuance absent in earlier text processing
systems. This paper presents a pilot experiment that explores how LLMs can
support thematic analysis of controversial topics. We compare how human
researchers and two LLMs GPT-4 and Llama 2 categorise excerpts from media
coverage of the controversial Australian Robodebt scandal. Our findings
highlight intriguing overlaps and variances in thematic categorisation between
human and machine agents, and suggest where LLMs can be effective in supporting
forms of discourse and thematic analysis. We argue LLMs should be used to
augment, and not replace human interpretation, and we add further
methodological insights and reflections to existing research on the application
of automation to qualitative research methods. We also introduce a novel
card-based design toolkit, for both researchers and practitioners to further
interrogate LLMs as analytical tools.
|
[
0.0511961766,
0.0564634241,
-0.0414698087,
0.0074384683,
-0.0374472924,
0.0069939587,
0.027147837,
-0.0112888264,
0.000783524,
-0.0515362695,
0.0330636315,
0.0574613176,
-0.0381937735,
0.0597941726,
-0.015556179,
-0.0413378775,
-0.0122431945,
-0.0237910394,
0.053102389,
0.0403922796,
0.0068513029,
0.0351102203,
0.0129438313,
0.0452580079,
0.0171283167,
0.0043031112,
-0.0223115869,
-0.0085174413,
0.0256443545,
-0.0397318862,
-0.0263410378,
0.0503355302,
0.0603907034,
0.0611966401,
0.0000020583,
-0.0174694508,
0.0123482365,
0.011897306,
0.0013980975,
0.0061945012,
0.0631153733,
0.0017839229,
-0.0010930382,
0.00658852,
-0.0464728661,
0.0295338724,
0.0319125503,
-0.0157342572,
0.0342516266,
0.024703823,
-0.0236056708,
-0.0320864804,
-0.0031044923,
0.0111249285,
-0.0602941439,
0.0070195356,
0.0176728666,
-0.0007646606,
0.0573776141,
0.0694602057,
0.0198809113,
0.0604372844,
0.0185701754,
-0.029978523,
-0.0027271013,
-0.0152976597,
-0.0448809899,
-0.0686072558,
0.0290429033,
0.028089663,
0.0420159288,
-0.0080421353,
0.0072666751,
0.0013975523,
0.0008226548,
0.0263262186,
-0.0239202902,
0.0802862048,
-0.0312594846,
-0.0076458752,
0.0109738084,
0.0133955684,
-0.0172392167,
0.0250535831,
-0.0247772913,
0.0296699479,
-0.0308337808,
0.0046630958,
0.0054116207,
-0.0062531703,
0.0307786278,
-0.0352794826,
-0.0072862152,
0.0286659915,
-0.0111688403,
0.030192351,
0.037083935,
0.0023406821,
0.0620100051,
-0.0713158324,
0.0094521809,
0.0132391974,
-0.0228842534,
0.0075481026,
0.0635267571,
-0.0050091692,
-0.0125793694,
0.0123992758,
-0.0263874903,
0.025924772,
-0.0628375635,
-0.0206300747,
-0.021566404,
-0.0032534639,
-0.0611318462,
0.0054155141,
0.0151724806,
0.028405467,
-0.012779993,
-0.0071261209,
-0.0645321682,
0.011943657,
-0.0117460229,
0.0036058163,
-0.023037957,
0.0056305458,
-0.0560355857,
0.0647623762,
-0.0173293408,
-0.0160651561,
0.056687478,
0.024296958,
-0.008345061,
0.0102212233,
-0.0180438031,
0.0714262798,
-0.0015996729,
-0.0103607839,
-0.0695318207,
-0.0502308123,
0.003432031,
-0.0353356078,
0.030197585,
-0.0356428586,
-0.0160860084,
0.0301416777,
-0.0310704093,
-0.0091340449,
0.017669335,
0.010678364,
-0.0280617252,
0.0744013637,
-0.0205710456,
0.0026692287,
0.0527635105,
0.0496582314,
0.0181448758,
0.0497425832,
0.020718975,
0.0577042922,
0.0212771557,
0.0125519279,
0.0355160683,
-0.0021256267,
-0.0646808073,
-0.0031025154,
-0.0608777143,
0.0123418858,
-0.0765768066,
0.0331340097,
0.0398789346,
0.0471487194,
-0.0271929149,
0.0398853868,
0.051051978,
0.0837075785,
-0.0225631036,
0.0430771746,
0.0406755693,
0.0095356358,
-0.0041537741,
0.0053998861,
0.0171460994,
0.0029498292,
0.0076192538,
-0.0360124186,
-0.0065754559,
0.015302361,
-0.022953596,
-0.0389619693,
0.0090558026,
0.0044955206,
0.0667748526,
-0.0108677857,
0.0167118497,
-0.0280626547,
0.0171792917,
-0.0515328906,
0.0149754686,
-0.0196197834,
-0.0237978324,
-0.0797848329,
0.0647313297,
0.0663603693,
0.0281388331,
-0.0265810788,
0.0236622766,
-0.0441585965,
0.0001465765,
0.0523985997,
-0.0086084446,
-0.0178244766,
-0.0947343335,
-0.0024641587,
-0.0254408624,
-0.0276491214,
0.0103907753,
0.0365934558,
-0.028166173,
-0.0076059639,
0.0125145353,
-0.0000236242,
-0.0318333358,
0.0169958882,
-0.0024652861,
-0.0394065641,
-0.0476050042,
0.0097735971,
0.0155398482,
0.0516155958,
-0.0224331636,
0.0183740277,
0.0405007228,
-0.0323371552,
-0.002951917,
0.0189474821,
0.0376380123,
0.0835691169,
-0.0102714906,
-0.0829776078,
-0.0194186438,
0.0325731263,
0.0076237149,
0.0106508601,
0.0217473358,
-0.0017496964,
-0.0090417759,
-0.0494061559,
-0.0167082548,
-0.033545237,
-0.01692947,
-0.0425174534,
0.0407982916,
0.0049926224,
-0.0225999467,
-0.0067996387,
-0.0183409862,
0.0389230922,
0.021843845,
-0.0042482479,
0.0578045212,
0.0316408239,
0.0532867312,
0.0503788926,
-0.044064559,
-0.0302928761,
-0.0428103283,
-0.0824198797,
-0.025786778,
-0.0037346752,
-0.0133785512,
0.0342313424,
-0.0241451338,
-0.0308351927,
-0.0009020769,
0.0303321052,
-0.0596417449,
-0.0232692007,
0.0537045449,
0.0081202863,
0.0199525673,
0.0042500668,
-0.0003717024,
-0.0038096434,
-0.0257158019,
0.0452354513,
0.0796360746,
0.000541621,
-0.0544248633,
-0.006757149,
-0.0233676359,
-0.0294189118,
-0.0132401185,
-0.0391806625,
0.0498993732,
0.0263618845,
-0.0060385079,
0.0488079339,
0.0386632942,
0.0966816396,
0.0575529598,
0.0022264076,
-0.000536113,
-0.0269880984,
0.0126181189,
-0.014606813,
0.0041318359,
-0.0435950011,
0.0162187777,
0.0157713685,
-0.0167488437,
0.0377984941,
-0.0060036061,
0.0683017448,
-0.0426277593,
-0.0218391754,
-0.0600393564,
-0.1011797562,
-0.0307426155,
0.107076399,
0.0145985978,
-0.022265397,
0.0205569901,
0.0090453727,
0.0569056571,
-0.0628096536,
-0.0346665755,
-0.0238081738,
0.1211881116,
-0.0390242562,
0.0255649164,
0.0064642378,
-0.0065165213,
-0.0220479202,
-0.0819319487,
0.0139133818,
-0.0270834249,
0.018253047,
-0.0893113464,
0.0041747922,
-0.0105803991,
-0.0067490041,
-0.024786314,
-0.0359621793,
-0.0721339136,
0.0161539912,
0.0217883922,
-0.0042078258,
-0.018041933,
0.0366823077,
0.0689985082,
0.0070990385,
0.0393030681,
0.008740549,
0.0059586093,
0.0304311216,
0.0054287114,
-0.0341133997,
0.0336092003,
0.0375362933,
0.0295839198,
0.0202473141,
-0.0345961712,
-0.0108355219,
-0.0358289517,
-0.0093715694,
-0.0143429395,
-0.0301973354,
-0.0101210214,
-0.0086573847,
0.0297460463,
-0.0572769865,
0.0105151264,
0.0812241808,
0.0299491715,
-0.0501411892,
0.0035259435,
-0.026141353,
-0.0477801263,
-0.0051885559,
0.037516892,
-0.0645340011,
0.0458801053,
-0.0075176656,
0.0168102849,
-0.0895020142,
-0.0566118546,
0.0120597035,
-0.0624267012,
0.0615864918,
-0.0114022223,
-0.0381375961,
-0.00373258,
-0.047537487,
0.010628744,
0.0096072629,
-0.0030568081,
0.0250631273,
-0.0000582522,
-0.0052995915,
0.0159931369,
-0.0667068809,
0.011802421,
0.0242180042,
-0.005234045,
0.0561897531,
0.0401031487,
0.0488000512,
-0.0226985198,
-0.036898993,
0.0230902825,
-0.0098440088,
-0.0131304618,
0.00959107,
0.0022019113,
0.0031516498,
-0.0105290208,
-0.0326512121,
0.0396997631,
-0.0053950376,
-0.0214819778,
0.032113649,
0.0695554242,
-0.0232935548,
-0.0262162983,
-0.0578708462,
-0.0041686152,
0.0107714599,
0.0088548157,
0.040770188,
-0.03420569,
-0.0139910486,
-0.0374339856,
-0.008910235,
0.0420775078,
-0.0673369244,
0.0029864328,
-0.0098047294,
-0.0213833023,
-0.0129450299,
-0.0915437639,
0.0106213503,
-0.0025711181,
0.0084918421,
-0.0006900132,
0.0360801257,
0.0098482417,
-0.0668913126,
0.0394440964,
-0.0081031434,
0.0067963959,
0.0129941609,
-0.0010171467,
0.0087140519,
0.0108734034,
-0.0016580106,
0.0051555084,
0.0369067304,
-0.0322059169,
0.0579514615,
-0.0139304046,
0.033462543,
-0.0164383948,
0.0071002715,
-0.0496185385,
0.0143813835,
0.0415906012,
-0.0759510398,
0.004942039,
-0.0042770212,
0.0627173707,
-0.0152585078,
0.0032882353,
0.0202982035,
0.0526638925,
-0.0260059405,
-0.0095035266,
-0.0867211595,
-0.0481140725,
0.0156824719,
-0.0234201774,
0.010562297,
-0.0322780162,
-0.0140060904,
-0.0470305458,
-0.0441496558,
-0.0511724353,
-0.0345028006,
-0.0202326346,
0.0110751018,
-0.0070058526,
-0.0072722388,
-0.0424461588,
-0.0440888405,
-0.0944832861,
0.0452658348,
0.0094281081,
0.0752798319,
0.0138554787,
0.0531717911,
-0.013339798,
-0.0214473344,
-0.0160620641,
0.0366319679,
-0.0378566235,
0.0427875072,
0.0095365131,
0.0343919732,
0.0078125698,
-0.0076068491,
0.0190226715,
0.0337367542,
-0.0408296771,
-0.0636450797,
0.0172341354,
-0.0204623062,
-0.0063033467,
-0.003208478,
-0.0336994044,
-0.0125294439,
-0.0238239355,
0.0169276744,
0.0139809698,
0.0020102949,
-0.0071152407,
0.0120336059,
0.0265410617,
-0.0508426726,
-0.0163170472,
0.0099273371,
-0.006105009,
0.0004755307,
0.0470717773,
-0.0405393168,
-0.0207117517,
-0.0550520755,
0.0445290357,
-0.0237421226,
-0.0074528013,
-0.025878448,
-0.1119182631,
-0.0295099076,
0.0128514664,
-0.0023256962,
0.0106637552,
-0.0398307368,
0.0001406483,
0.0575798489,
0.0266898796,
0.0015600385,
-0.0543701276,
0.0268351194,
-0.0581807531,
0.0043025548,
0.0130473534,
-6.358837425e-33,
-0.0211113356,
-0.0693561062,
0.0283113625,
-0.0312778465,
-0.0105292788,
0.0241649449,
-0.0209998395,
0.0233149249,
-0.0231092386,
0.0298996456,
-0.009075081,
-0.0099010477,
0.0064109908,
-0.0380366556,
0.0364600979,
0.0039278558,
0.0475176908,
0.0201503094,
-0.0050909664,
0.0211638007,
0.0258513503,
-0.0102120331,
-0.0275287107,
-0.1162300333,
0.0633373335,
-0.0053129378,
-0.0169389173,
0.0132491495,
0.0460356027,
0.0319617987,
-0.0238174777,
0.0282806288,
0.030288402,
0.0023705289,
0.023962466,
0.101006411,
-0.0208602343,
-0.0144210625,
0.0309799183,
-0.0147861382,
0.0362507477,
-0.0536153428,
0.0267820898,
-0.0238011666,
-0.0240205564,
0.0375721119,
0.043097686,
-0.0470722094,
-0.0053172745,
-0.0567181706,
-0.0667539462,
0.020229077,
-0.0282738209,
0.0202845261,
-0.0291490909,
-0.0277852379,
-0.0061992202,
0.0135930125,
-0.0469399877,
0.0182316136,
0.0381914899,
-0.0284688286,
0.0343779251,
0.0136999823,
-0.0028683178,
0.0521761589,
-0.0257297307,
0.0378488749,
-0.0561797433,
0.0349513479,
0.0101247272,
0.0413866453,
0.0533940531,
0.0511225723,
-0.0229221173,
-0.0280577708,
-0.0602071621,
-0.0055165077,
-0.0107989162,
0.0506617092,
0.0508726835,
0.007722049,
-0.0185549259,
-0.0053007803,
-0.0474831015,
-0.0453880541,
-0.0364641547,
-0.0370314568,
-0.0031896287,
-0.0141614424,
-0.0527821742,
0.0175532214,
0.019281663,
-0.02538082,
0.0453459397,
-0.0296593308,
-0.0017346154,
0.0079365131,
-0.000746102,
0.0328743421,
-0.0313514173,
0.0019344649,
0.017676346,
0.0367877595,
0.0430510901,
-0.0020598876,
-0.0249811374,
-0.0113138147,
-0.0318063535,
-0.0065430752,
-0.018087985,
0.0220839772,
0.0058346693,
-0.0227455702,
0.0063893567,
0.0266812649,
0.0061779083,
-0.020322822,
0.0235244799,
0.0232006498,
-0.005162742,
-0.0012100619,
-0.0715131238,
-0.0028727369,
-0.0153059401,
-0.0128534622,
-0.0211495459,
0.0800561756,
0.0902423859,
-0.0390279517,
-0.0008634618,
-0.0108080357,
2.836e-7,
0.0627810359,
0.0486702695,
-0.0191714782,
-0.0546056852,
0.0142268836,
0.0281345621,
0.0500546843,
0.0206985194,
0.0101833418,
-0.0377525352,
0.0302220173,
0.0340367779,
0.0065420158,
0.0651501939,
-0.0501142032,
-0.0199293941,
-0.0188481286,
0.0036625203,
-0.1104565784,
0.060521774,
0.0853493512,
0.0203869417,
-0.0086480211,
-0.0083128596,
-0.054962337,
-0.0425664075,
0.0009539921,
-0.0374329053,
-0.016456183,
-0.0044763191,
0.0399753638,
0.0375495069,
0.0048858295,
0.010495835,
0.0337310433,
-0.0200224426,
-0.0103725111,
0.0438012443,
0.0098921629,
-0.0283783637,
0.000003433,
-0.0496549644,
0.0263879728,
-0.0584748834,
0.0448517054,
-0.0547336712,
-0.0345898941,
-0.0361529328,
-0.0374651588,
-0.0477565229,
0.0332079455,
-0.0352827087,
-0.0074925646,
0.0367531106,
-0.01620657,
-0.010821959,
0.0318373777,
-0.0621600896,
0.015715437,
-0.0022877392,
-0.0446453057,
-0.0354737639,
-0.0110919178,
-0.0002131747,
0.0291937292,
-0.0558400564,
0.071619533,
2.400485279e-34,
0.0495794453,
0.0177735109,
-0.0496196002,
0.0228575543,
0.0479737967,
0.06731309,
-0.0118016107,
0.003845836,
0.0332120024,
-0.0697278529,
0.0268809721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06907v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06907v2
|
AIOS Compiler: LLM as Interpreter for Natural Language Programming and Flow Programming of AI Agents
| 2024-05-11T04:29:03 | 2024-05-21T20:35:55 |
Shuyuan Xu, Zelong Li, Kai Mei, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
Since their inception, programming languages have trended towards greater
readability and lower barriers for programmers. Following this trend, natural
language can be a promising type of programming language that provides great
flexibility and usability and helps towards the democracy of programming.
However, the inherent vagueness, ambiguity, and verbosity of natural language
pose significant challenges in developing an interpreter that can accurately
understand the programming logic and execute instructions written in natural
language. Fortunately, recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have
demonstrated remarkable proficiency in interpreting complex natural language.
Inspired by this, we develop a novel system for Code Representation and
Execution (CoRE), which employs LLM as interpreter to interpret and execute
natural language instructions. The proposed system unifies natural language
programming, pseudo-code programming, and flow programming under the same
representation for constructing language agents, while LLM serves as the
interpreter to interpret and execute the agent programs. In this paper, we
begin with defining the programming syntax that structures natural language
instructions logically. During the execution, we incorporate external memory to
minimize redundancy. Furthermore, we equip the designed interpreter with the
capability to invoke external tools, compensating for the limitations of LLM in
specialized domains or when accessing real-time information. This work is
open-source at https://github.com/agiresearch/CoRE,
https://github.com/agiresearch/OpenAGI, and
https://github.com/agiresearch/AIOS.
|
[
0.0230245553,
0.0343428329,
-0.0467840284,
0.0508301817,
-0.0166760776,
0.0114973085,
-0.0308575891,
-0.0176698323,
0.0513515659,
-0.0421647578,
-0.0190484934,
0.0502437651,
-0.0144547075,
0.089016594,
0.0249932855,
-0.0368685797,
0.0607362092,
-0.0452362075,
0.0220034774,
0.016360702,
0.0139899533,
0.0267958771,
0.0195988975,
0.0332200266,
0.0552282669,
-0.0105855688,
-0.0397969298,
0.0035869943,
-0.0167585239,
-0.0059682876,
-0.0155737353,
-0.0184585731,
0.0441141948,
-0.0024283342,
0.0000023775,
-0.064523384,
0.0194022153,
0.0365016274,
-0.0388438813,
0.0081173563,
0.0106776832,
0.0101830447,
-0.0093908599,
0.0117762806,
-0.0404644236,
-0.0077046538,
0.0666960701,
-0.0252592321,
0.1011136994,
0.0856158882,
0.0132051259,
-0.0428491347,
0.026044311,
0.0352508575,
0.0222537164,
-0.0353862531,
-0.0008288226,
0.0082830992,
0.0448923297,
0.018334737,
0.004229838,
0.0096829813,
0.0274422579,
-0.0083566997,
-0.0035690928,
0.0132143321,
-0.0223267637,
-0.0336101949,
-0.0390081555,
0.0251764879,
0.0003672481,
0.001517551,
0.035814207,
0.0016298555,
0.0017834349,
-0.058844246,
-0.0321439803,
0.0736279637,
0.0025876961,
0.0077242064,
0.0506211519,
-0.0080409609,
0.0008938402,
0.0189809576,
-0.0504937321,
0.0690758228,
-0.022799328,
0.0007886171,
-0.0143532176,
-0.0354062505,
0.0152732972,
-0.0700234398,
0.0327364206,
0.0757709146,
-0.0289988406,
0.0248234794,
-0.0307523273,
0.0181775447,
0.0155275855,
-0.0893876553,
0.0306067131,
0.0371200331,
0.0118070366,
0.0275700819,
0.0072460594,
0.0915385857,
0.0019827192,
0.0503973812,
-0.0235068705,
0.0193093587,
-0.0445054807,
-0.0175224319,
-0.0530749485,
0.0521950796,
-0.0325638242,
0.0196251106,
0.0024242243,
0.0608903207,
-0.0279452763,
0.0356871672,
-0.0241601262,
-0.0360247046,
-0.027183488,
0.0105188983,
-0.0494491681,
-0.0041966042,
-0.0292123985,
-0.0335351974,
-0.0151537592,
-0.0575582907,
-0.0018536835,
0.0352632888,
-0.0317427106,
0.0011734946,
0.0078546247,
0.1076903194,
0.0374529436,
-0.0033491261,
-0.0479212999,
-0.0189010613,
0.0433410518,
-0.0619167723,
0.001227621,
-0.0829713643,
0.0188386049,
0.0167959388,
-0.0146770375,
-0.0597054623,
0.0151484786,
0.0265114792,
-0.0006180756,
0.0308656655,
-0.0334002525,
-0.0023036527,
-0.0134514878,
-0.0080068195,
0.0157938376,
0.0559115224,
0.0594357029,
-0.0026721584,
-0.0157962274,
-0.0151945604,
0.0111788064,
0.0164817851,
-0.0676023588,
-0.0177503563,
0.0145300319,
0.0404254235,
-0.0337045044,
0.0380470268,
-0.0140671711,
0.0571837239,
0.0227328856,
-0.0124387033,
-0.0192484055,
0.0428760909,
-0.0055931769,
0.032812953,
0.0905849114,
0.066178523,
0.0156969205,
-0.0279122852,
-0.0572815016,
0.0502877012,
-0.0186196584,
0.0008209559,
-0.0499628745,
0.0656648874,
0.0110177631,
-0.0971356705,
-0.0035157194,
-0.0280051939,
0.0426849648,
0.0006956409,
0.0290276855,
0.0087329512,
-0.0296240915,
-0.0088285059,
-0.0078513101,
-0.0434557498,
-0.0238341223,
-0.0722499639,
0.0048460444,
0.0808366612,
0.0048730457,
-0.0390531607,
-0.0227623656,
-0.0145446351,
-0.0264291633,
0.0287891775,
0.0112852594,
0.0039787493,
-0.0223356858,
-0.0383066125,
-0.0111712832,
-0.0154236266,
0.0017310493,
0.0484309793,
-0.0108726658,
-0.0077913716,
-0.0021827566,
0.0358990878,
-0.0656552166,
0.0363433734,
-0.0368116871,
-0.0215201788,
-0.0062178508,
-0.0074931509,
0.0184359215,
-0.0027132956,
-0.018751353,
0.020280866,
0.0536524802,
0.0024578401,
-0.0639505684,
-0.0144293001,
-0.0208704993,
0.0032171321,
0.0333927572,
-0.0149594964,
-0.030301895,
-0.009505908,
-0.0534342788,
-0.0012163885,
0.0638555586,
-0.046402663,
0.0143535873,
0.0188781787,
0.01889107,
-0.0094431015,
-0.0223238822,
-0.0308743883,
0.0439328328,
0.0230448637,
-0.0269789994,
-0.0010988923,
0.0382358804,
-0.0006316399,
-0.0171103012,
0.0169915464,
0.0134494156,
-0.0029174641,
0.0360003002,
0.0521742627,
0.0550798625,
0.0043822816,
-0.012737086,
-0.0447273366,
0.0603456199,
-0.0207604878,
-0.0059863287,
0.0179704465,
0.0202143975,
0.0020188461,
0.0146388002,
0.0038641854,
0.0212739538,
0.0061414135,
-0.0161997732,
0.0109829893,
-0.0071401708,
-0.0805710331,
-0.0046302518,
0.0006820748,
-0.0518101268,
0.0083971303,
0.0256102309,
-0.0343691148,
-0.076645948,
0.06431555,
-0.0094257947,
0.0168813001,
-0.0014459745,
-0.0150556918,
0.000442101,
-0.0414519981,
-0.0103987753,
0.0719590783,
-0.0510560721,
0.0477521047,
0.0640631765,
-0.0113451192,
-0.0465439893,
0.028472608,
0.0350041986,
-0.0195007548,
-0.0392083935,
-0.0456093661,
0.0336548202,
0.0574913993,
0.0305574555,
0.0025055583,
-0.0213924684,
0.0085704224,
0.0142880976,
0.012143244,
0.0377469584,
-0.0243019927,
-0.0332080498,
0.0261508226,
-0.0076328036,
-0.0594288409,
0.0843733847,
-0.0185160637,
-0.0246824622,
-0.0616197772,
-0.0592329577,
-0.0758573264,
0.074151434,
0.0156089794,
0.010648095,
0.0222659726,
-0.0255041849,
0.0155341011,
0.0045102634,
-0.0250434093,
-0.0195276663,
0.0486576892,
-0.0719139427,
-0.0010756095,
0.0130004575,
-0.0100736264,
-0.0278210044,
0.0076581403,
-0.0332128331,
0.005157202,
0.0045696688,
-0.0174959674,
-0.0197447948,
-0.0325868838,
0.0175104868,
0.0196883474,
0.0027960772,
-0.0170412455,
-0.044122614,
-0.0496465452,
-0.0137215331,
-0.0140550062,
-0.0435410067,
0.0440411307,
0.0283904765,
0.03621516,
0.0005183396,
0.010345743,
-0.0811764151,
0.0012085607,
0.0214048047,
-0.0363522209,
-0.0333345085,
0.0637346804,
0.0282917526,
-0.0822446048,
-0.0194770452,
0.1026925221,
0.0270717591,
-0.0171380024,
0.0270035174,
-0.0330701731,
0.0087075196,
0.0820741802,
0.0585548878,
-0.0565087087,
-0.0395716503,
0.0006501632,
0.0101310369,
0.0040991222,
0.0030616601,
-0.0214321688,
-0.0786094964,
0.0369582847,
0.0343249477,
0.0184433423,
-0.0482314602,
-0.0586388633,
-0.0274259802,
-0.0051010149,
-0.0377691165,
0.016151065,
0.0028786112,
-0.0008124805,
-0.0254419222,
-0.0100316033,
0.0082712565,
0.0341295265,
-0.0175548531,
0.0537488759,
0.1261150241,
0.0175957214,
-0.0242223889,
-0.0044587641,
0.0157577731,
0.0339028761,
0.0122127831,
-0.035897173,
0.0036954666,
-0.000419786,
-0.0145776877,
-0.0172934029,
0.0160849299,
-0.0570821501,
0.000240046,
0.0388672687,
0.0766183808,
-0.045590695,
-0.0223959759,
-0.034560822,
-0.0276720058,
0.0116682276,
0.0369013175,
-0.0030349582,
0.0080974679,
-0.0561937355,
-0.0978949592,
-0.0348889157,
-0.0330755748,
-0.0627658367,
0.0243274216,
-0.0166061204,
-0.0227917749,
-0.0115289148,
-0.0189789124,
0.0179059133,
-0.0129043413,
0.0344578475,
-0.0565926135,
0.0663946941,
-0.0086844377,
-0.0240981616,
-0.0032487379,
-0.0506841317,
0.0578741133,
-0.0025058908,
-0.0459314063,
0.0235233568,
0.0072185532,
-0.0231033489,
0.0771903917,
-0.0334326737,
-0.0621863566,
-0.0030255984,
0.0696176738,
0.0176554658,
-0.0069531999,
-0.0070698727,
-0.0027856498,
-0.0459918305,
0.0143729383,
-0.0478638634,
-0.0014847612,
0.014266124,
0.0219590086,
0.0430140421,
0.0101755215,
-0.0546455532,
-0.0085262656,
-0.0352322981,
0.0227835476,
-0.0409511924,
0.0129905045,
0.0457080305,
0.0472976565,
-0.0357319824,
0.0278126765,
-0.0052669705,
0.0316543058,
-0.0247785188,
-0.0367633887,
-0.0212270636,
-0.0540679358,
0.0123309921,
-0.0111812931,
-0.0232346952,
0.0687436238,
-0.0006193189,
-0.0240007322,
-0.0189369172,
0.0306665059,
0.0493784808,
0.0209344607,
0.0258032978,
0.0199529361,
0.0222465862,
-0.0229821317,
0.0546970591,
-0.0072462675,
0.0305118095,
-0.0452514216,
0.0329308324,
0.011040098,
0.0175779499,
-0.0185175873,
-0.0035479555,
-0.0345201306,
-0.0727872476,
0.0423493683,
0.0373444296,
0.0236447733,
0.0347538367,
0.0226697791,
-0.0622564256,
0.0435254835,
-0.0287123863,
0.0310385823,
-0.0091757076,
-0.0661107525,
0.0056782174,
0.0368693545,
-0.0004568907,
-0.0798418522,
0.0687252134,
0.0108411349,
0.0319358073,
-0.010242153,
-0.0427780859,
-0.0580964945,
-0.0321502946,
0.0115407426,
-0.0130079594,
-0.0059673465,
-0.0257321354,
-0.0292768721,
-0.0443110168,
-0.0035559393,
0.0271784496,
0.0338419788,
-0.0458609797,
0.0419208556,
0.0407463796,
0.0156566929,
-0.042521365,
-0.0110083967,
0.0361301601,
-0.029877184,
-0.040367607,
-0.0394304916,
-5.942093454e-33,
-0.055159457,
-0.0118202688,
0.0428341106,
0.0299739055,
-0.0054461295,
-0.0396996662,
-0.0602254234,
-0.019805437,
0.0036978151,
-0.0270067919,
0.0394453406,
0.0027941931,
-0.0016219985,
-0.0156614035,
0.0242916066,
0.0100546097,
0.0213007536,
-0.0073679285,
-0.0008164425,
-0.0018301548,
0.0180714671,
-0.024153389,
0.0268198084,
-0.047275655,
0.0207522511,
0.0078363298,
0.0193220843,
0.0313442238,
-0.0316231102,
0.0289722141,
0.0101862317,
0.0172836315,
-0.0028011224,
-0.0066592423,
-0.0422236808,
0.0228643995,
-0.0383335054,
-0.0325690992,
0.0313530378,
0.0363742188,
-0.0277676824,
-0.0737924129,
0.0805622041,
-0.0192721765,
-0.0408230759,
0.0176325217,
0.0276088864,
-0.0234228354,
0.0306980647,
0.0145706376,
-0.0783990771,
0.0153329605,
-0.0526859537,
-0.0024641547,
0.0082719801,
-0.0062199919,
-0.0099223712,
0.0062774317,
0.0082875323,
0.0148720089,
-0.0112762796,
0.0198388081,
0.0439011529,
-0.0221038107,
0.0300166514,
0.0007826895,
0.0301998705,
-0.0049374439,
-0.0535671376,
0.0625293776,
0.0143929319,
0.0261697639,
-0.0118946666,
0.0038415033,
0.0058610574,
-0.0080824997,
-0.0518424027,
0.0117897028,
0.0051428485,
0.0744455755,
0.0045752316,
0.0286905076,
-0.0527367033,
-0.009638817,
-0.0202130768,
-0.0251123849,
-0.0076403273,
-0.0284593459,
0.0222232267,
-0.0204086248,
-0.0097697191,
-0.0066395937,
-0.0017154351,
-0.0463611521,
0.011985465,
0.0212954395,
-0.0205393527,
0.0034261646,
0.0056434968,
0.0470130295,
0.0015491877,
-0.0271780025,
-0.0176470838,
-0.0283917859,
0.084597446,
0.0280109402,
-0.0170799661,
0.0581606664,
-0.0205762815,
0.0155801624,
-0.0637106076,
-0.0309898537,
0.0077682664,
0.0111087384,
-0.0039239274,
-0.0073848669,
-0.0011069064,
0.0623357035,
-0.0160687491,
-0.0499409102,
-0.0359264165,
0.0087150354,
-0.0012498216,
0.017799139,
-0.0636671633,
-0.0213564821,
-0.0791499838,
0.0522363298,
0.0178375058,
-0.0267964974,
-0.0299458969,
0.016385546,
3.13e-7,
-0.0078749899,
0.0431024097,
0.0263364557,
0.0999785066,
0.0031211227,
0.0459688194,
-0.0125751095,
0.021296557,
-0.0068094195,
-0.022289589,
-0.0570696369,
0.0546867624,
-0.0148242796,
-0.0047188243,
-0.0714152455,
0.0512393937,
0.037107449,
-0.0041913129,
-0.078477554,
0.0369803272,
0.0811359957,
0.0709797591,
0.0399102233,
0.0270651411,
-0.0119164661,
-0.0854739919,
-0.0106581999,
0.0127893602,
0.0162359178,
0.0237590726,
-0.0749706551,
0.0367845446,
-0.020324463,
-0.0165789556,
0.02827923,
0.0111279199,
-0.0296535622,
0.0918697193,
-0.0221260879,
0.0425614491,
0.0361141749,
-0.0331651978,
-0.0107035497,
-0.0087530473,
0.0339386165,
-0.0225646682,
-0.0264575426,
-0.0469731055,
-0.0110515784,
-0.0059274696,
-0.0411292128,
-0.0164425969,
-0.0075202594,
-0.0117493477,
-0.0078703463,
-0.049035918,
-0.0062963259,
-0.0166941453,
-0.009335978,
-0.0368073061,
-0.0343416817,
-0.0093644457,
-0.0575129092,
0.0651009381,
0.0319610089,
-0.0223544613,
0.0094843507,
3.337686721e-34,
0.0184444562,
-0.0207461752,
0.0180421025,
0.0479670614,
0.0826106295,
0.0106414976,
-0.0544515699,
0.0341569334,
0.0212491583,
-0.0346483141,
-0.0430782549
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.